question
stringlengths
37
38.8k
group_id
int64
0
74.5k
sentence_embeddings
sequencelengths
1.02k
1.02k
<p>I am running a linear mixed model and want to check its assumptions. The model I run is comparing if males and females behave differently over time (timeclass=1,2,3,4):</p> <pre><code> x &lt;- lme(response ~ timeclass*sex, random = ~ 1|subject, method="ML", data=dat) </code></pre> <p>The code to create the plots: </p> <pre><code>plot(x) plot(x, response ~ fitted(.) | sex, abline = c(0,1)) qqnorm(x,~resid(.)|timeclass) qqnorm(x,~resid(.)|sex) hist((resid(x) - mean(resid(x), na.rm=T)) / sd(resid(x), na.rm=T), freq=F); curve(dnorm, add = TRUE) </code></pre> <p>This is the output I get:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/4gYnC.png" alt="residual plot"> <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/Pykhd.png" alt="linear relationship males and females"> <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/nm6aJ.png" alt="qqplot for sex"> <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/IyXNj.png" alt="qqplot for timeclass"> <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/66naf.png" alt="histogram"></p> <p>The plots except the residual plot seem to show that there seems to be a linear relationship between the fitted values per sex and the response and that the errors are relatively normally distributed in both sex and across the four time classes. However, the first plot has a very clear diamond shape, almost so clear that it seems values are cut off in the four triangular angles. </p> <p>Can someone help me understand what is going on and what this means? Is the model I run valid based on the plots for assumptions?</p>
30,166
[ -0.014158636331558228, -0.012420013546943665, 0.011495490558445454, -0.015291162766516209, 0.022930214181542397, 0.01479294616729021, -0.0012309697922319174, 0.013583237305283546, 0.005593763664364815, -0.020488133653998375, 0.02392040193080902, 0.05108186602592468, 0.07691233605146408, 0.039910223335027695, 0.02104262262582779, -0.007551131304353476, -0.008198559284210205, -0.02473345398902893, 0.004154484253376722, -0.026226170361042023, -0.01728943921625614, 0.02816537208855152, -0.007693361025303602, -0.04872985929250717, -0.005089628975838423, 0.0344315767288208, 0.04472080618143082, -0.02499503269791603, 0.022915346547961235, 0.05557811260223389, -0.03885403648018837, -0.030445178970694542, -0.0018635017331689596, -0.007009684573858976, 0.02617468126118183, -0.013091392815113068, 0.03164413198828697, -0.01791992411017418, 0.013183473609387875, 0.0450948141515255, 0.023135997354984283, 0.040872737765312195, 0.01258889865130186, 0.0686468854546547, -0.027101946994662285, 0.01714947819709778, 0.03735428303480148, 0.017160901799798012, 0.09067922830581665, -0.03768842667341232, 0.04819486290216446, 0.019698800519108772, 0.011045125313103199, 0.028196554630994797, -0.055378932505846024, -0.027325954288244247, 0.029923945665359497, 0.061631835997104645, 0.01102602668106556, -0.05689980089664459, 0.031180938705801964, -0.04514838382601738, 0.015414491295814514, 0.02352696657180786, -0.027231365442276, -0.014065699651837349, -0.0015169166726991534, -0.05407844856381416, 0.0026941874530166388, -0.02574297785758972, 0.034692682325839996, 0.0354747399687767, 0.04733358696103096, -0.018573405221104622, 0.023069124668836594, -0.009522411972284317, 0.0001707982155494392, 0.009795966558158398, 0.038575608283281326, -0.007521462626755238, -0.02703915908932686, 0.012552468106150627, -0.003964021801948547, 0.008060233667492867, -0.011188685894012451, -0.004335726611316204, 0.05692281201481819, -0.006763927638530731, 0.013721087016165257, 0.03574710711836815, -0.028269993141293526, 0.05953316390514374, 0.041544146835803986, 0.012721468694508076, -0.032755810767412186, 0.010568901896476746, 0.0155253941193223, 0.015343382954597473, 0.04147176444530487, -0.02643929421901703, -0.02702096849679947, -0.05087020993232727, 0.034921228885650635, 0.01642409898340702, -0.010020269080996513, -0.029995903372764587, -0.0035294308327138424, 0.005301253870129585, -0.021816696971654892, -0.007966365665197372, -0.03085407055914402, 0.03795657679438591, 0.008646552450954914, -0.009605083614587784, 0.003322282340377569, -0.03138565272092819, -0.005747526418417692, 0.029256902635097504, 0.0927516520023346, 0.059754807502031326, 0.020437544211745262, -0.02422304078936577, -0.008611462078988552, 0.007275886368006468, -0.04414563626050949, -0.00719304196536541, 0.00033141396124847233, -0.012736148200929165, -0.019162878394126892, 0.06290674954652786, 0.02449386939406395, -0.03806990385055542, 0.03513452410697937, -0.006338503211736679, 0.03964611515402794, -0.037657201290130615, -0.05047473683953285, -0.06546321511268616, -0.007794264238327742, 0.010624587535858154, 0.03376273810863495, -0.05040416494011879, -0.0017913279589265585, 0.05099621042609215, 0.036265239119529724, -0.0012389839394018054, 0.031468465924263, 0.027974318712949753, 0.008164283819496632, 0.005461819004267454, -0.020045578479766846, -0.01343461312353611, -0.02399088442325592, -0.021591441705822945, -0.028219858184456825, -0.08490978926420212, -0.0004823817580472678, -0.018959583714604378, -0.031202757731080055, 0.038816846907138824, 0.03834245726466179, 0.0038141608238220215, 0.008585933595895767, -0.0044168224558234215, -0.005526701454073191, -0.025454236194491386, 0.11183003336191177, -0.017428964376449585, 0.008259743452072144, 0.009153474122285843, -0.026681268587708473, -0.007769660092890263, 0.015955042093992233, 0.05729107931256294, 0.029183359816670418, -0.008220435120165348, 0.0221264585852623, -0.012765754945576191, 0.019743509590625763, 0.013165050186216831, -0.06909696757793427, -0.025700630620121956, -0.05035454034805298, -0.005876624956727028, 0.006688131485134363, 0.015312373638153076, 0.002580495784059167, -0.010545602068305016, 0.057431288063526154, -0.05275502800941467, -0.06083989515900612, -0.05688687041401863, 0.01501778606325388, -0.0286696907132864, -0.02114950492978096, -0.014938455075025558, 0.00534189073368907, 0.03735794126987457, 0.01892804354429245, -0.026338836178183556, -0.024296648800373077, 0.003090181853622198, 0.06325040012598038, -0.032489657402038574, -0.0009568733512423933, 0.010561387985944748, 0.06515894085168839, -0.0005938403191976249, 0.003022497985512018, -0.037301186472177505, -0.004702274687588215, 0.028032727539539337, -0.04295532405376434, -0.003141061868518591, -0.015222739428281784, -0.010687722824513912, -0.004868161398917437, 0.02475053258240223, -0.007632057182490826, 0.03788331151008606, -0.019265659153461456, 0.015426810830831528, 0.07495315372943878, -0.033706337213516235, -0.03290471434593201, 0.006479971576482058, 0.00406557647511363, 0.039553795009851456, -0.06192364916205406, -0.011994471773505211, -0.04913650080561638, 0.021435970440506935, 0.013215751387178898, 0.034396328032016754, -0.011319361627101898, 0.032066959887742996, 0.03267073631286621, 0.002545035444200039, 0.01049690693616867, 0.03364221006631851, 0.006267901975661516, -0.013719869777560234, 0.005606077611446381, 0.042026326060295105, 0.021832304075360298, 0.010305330157279968, 0.011978856287896633, -0.04528062418103218, 0.03087976761162281, -0.01797671429812908, 0.0063530378974974155, 0.03636400029063225, -0.026323886588215828, -0.005223112180829048, -0.009036322124302387, -0.0006446789484471083, 0.03917153179645538, -0.03456558287143707, -0.016436219215393066, 0.03877830505371094, -0.010566038079559803, 0.0013964759418740869, 0.012551003135740757, 0.0038447752594947815, 0.017596906051039696, 0.046064648777246475, -0.013119335286319256, -0.02599535509943962, 0.01700563356280327, 0.006039051339030266, -0.00367318675853312, -0.040097396820783615, -0.04315836727619171, -0.038644567131996155, 0.003063649870455265, 0.009867914952337742, 0.04355546459555626, -0.026989085599780083, -0.04408303275704384, -0.021868271753191948, -0.011830373667180538, -0.005890630651265383, 0.04793378338217735, -0.010300785303115845, -0.045927975326776505, -0.03169570863246918, -0.04136350378394127, -0.037109460681676865, 0.00738091766834259, -0.008187306113541126, -0.0264262892305851, 0.047494590282440186, -0.03210340067744255, -0.019308792427182198, -0.05662122368812561, -0.035388536751270294, -0.0003779988910537213, -0.02726919762790203, -0.03215240314602852, 0.038139600306749344, 0.0021852264180779457, 0.0074128806591033936, 0.03178366273641586, -0.057070475071668625, 0.013927450403571129, -0.0006191217107698321, -0.004651168826967478, 0.020727910101413727, 0.02819003351032734, -0.005323602352291346, 0.020604083314538002, -0.020169710740447044, -0.014200141653418541, -0.07244584709405899, -0.05293013155460358, 0.016672005876898766, 0.000020774041331605986, 0.012212936766445637, 0.016700148582458496, 0.015146694146096706, 0.05510038509964943, 0.07186155766248703, -0.0031778498087078333, -0.04781021922826767, -0.015937360003590584, -0.01900833658874035, -0.020300807431340218, 0.06520294398069382, -0.009252707473933697, 0.05118556320667267, 0.02466304786503315, -0.05226930230855942, 0.008986209519207478, 0.023338325321674347, -0.02314436249434948, -0.007059810217469931, 0.031944964081048965, -0.01737198419868946, -0.023848725482821465, 0.026348266750574112, 0.040727466344833374, -0.006799706257879734, 0.0030159042216837406, -0.005408016033470631, 0.03501350060105324, -0.013707183301448822, -0.08093621581792831, 0.026462389156222343, -0.017484722658991814, -0.005279054865241051, -0.035634223371744156, 0.03835814446210861, -0.0011966705787926912, -0.03161733224987984, -0.025811292231082916, -0.0012346028815954924, 0.04881453514099121, -0.007037952542304993, 0.01096898689866066, 0.04947352409362793, 0.04381720721721649, -0.032772161066532135, 0.006720481440424919, -0.008500676602125168, 0.001719977823086083, 0.037316013127565384, -0.07246998697519302, -0.024443820118904114, 0.04706847667694092, -0.0024864361621439457, 0.002855174709111452, 0.002834505634382367, -0.03277916461229324, -0.014628730714321136, -0.06126857548952103, 0.024896403774619102, -0.037942592054605484, 0.03455980494618416, 0.023343661800026894, 0.037596747279167175, 0.0024528561625629663, 0.017170408740639687, -0.010488299652934074, -0.023226508870720863, -0.04972411319613457, 0.027229629456996918, 0.01094809640198946, -0.01054945308715105, 0.02264673076570034, -0.04406645521521568, 0.023608004674315453, -0.03864036127924919, 0.009927500039339066, 0.002215196378529072, 0.028930330649018288, -0.03923855721950531, 0.0024400376714766026, 0.0031456465367227793, -0.004962502978742123, -0.017345575615763664, 0.03324685990810394, 0.01430384162813425, -0.03718430548906326, -0.00945858471095562, 0.016054725274443626, 0.004930245690047741, -0.05312084034085274, -0.04948212578892708, 0.005406927317380905, 0.034143902361392975, 0.03447507694363594, 0.033445797860622406, -0.015525679104030132, -0.011177030391991138, 0.018352024257183075, 0.015414420515298843, 0.04440709948539734, 0.05887983366847038, 0.0011048291344195604, -0.0044126310385763645, 0.026503631845116615, 0.005977674387395382, 0.0063686068169772625, 0.012164801359176636, -0.018822064623236656, -0.020879145711660385, 0.04395201802253723, 0.053286079317331314, -0.028534119948744774, 0.055901773273944855, 0.03468720614910126, 0.020566636696457863, 0.021544568240642548, -0.026819616556167603, -0.009098655544221401, -0.03138298913836479, 0.021228058263659477, 0.02344328910112381, -0.002388727618381381, 0.002703937003389001, -0.02942611649632454, 0.039347290992736816, -0.02181548811495304, -0.011610090732574463, 0.032377202063798904, 0.00391738023608923, 0.023829525336623192, -0.012365646660327911, 0.0027747834101319313, 0.02367241308093071, 0.008253735490143299, 0.024669287726283073, 0.033860061317682266, -0.0010638948297128081, -0.09317510575056076, -0.03148964047431946, 0.05348978191614151, 0.00047938560601323843, -0.039209119975566864, -0.02575214020907879, -0.029175663366913795, -0.011793973855674267, 0.0005342544754967093, 0.002038403647020459, 0.023988503962755203, -0.008978313766419888, 0.018700631335377693, -0.015466833487153053, -0.04136285185813904, -0.03906097635626793, 0.010891829617321491, -0.01436106488108635, 0.015446364879608154, -0.007947550155222416, -0.04059714823961258, -0.009635002352297306, 0.011310706846415997, 0.02515619434416294, 0.03882021829485893, -0.05926148593425751, -0.026660628616809845, 0.002068944275379181, -0.02782205119729042, -0.03702150285243988, -0.06866728514432907, 0.04858483746647835, -0.02908165752887726, 0.015201732516288757, 0.06425798684358597, -0.018420832231640816, -0.00785438809543848, 0.026587963104248047, 0.04915602505207062, -0.040907297283411026, -0.0011807080591097474, -0.026409467682242393, 0.010496332310140133, 0.056210968643426895, 0.03519446402788162, 0.021462995558977127, 0.029891742393374443, 0.0007499782950617373, -0.030081402510404587, -0.07449165731668472, 0.0377679280936718, -0.0012360065011307597, -0.03570254147052765, -0.05049813911318779, 0.00474119046702981, -0.011830063536763191, 0.023431241512298584, -0.04731503501534462, 0.005858822260051966, -0.03968891128897667, -0.03551022708415985, 0.05501542240381241, 0.025905193760991096, -0.018856268376111984, 0.023820701986551285, 0.02952776663005352, -0.0001002145727397874, -0.023876700550317764, 0.01583399623632431, 0.010081249289214611, -0.012403251603245735, -0.018157366663217545, 0.04670696333050728, -0.0072409361600875854, -0.0069174799136817455, -0.0025309394113719463, -0.010117294266819954, -0.015412013046443462, -0.029136689379811287, -0.031898658722639084, -0.0016958717023953795, 0.06362935155630112, 0.005830447189509869, -0.01735633611679077, 0.01862352155148983, -0.0022964091040194035, -0.010133477859199047, 0.03760583698749542, 0.010681236162781715, 0.045795876532793045, -0.002259682398289442, 0.0011872652685269713, -0.04375918209552765, -0.07302394509315491, 0.02307642437517643, -0.010188539512455463, -0.04816506803035736, -0.021270345896482468, -0.028114916756749153, 0.02705955132842064, 0.019079891964793205, 0.0281562227755785, 0.04993070662021637, -0.020310115069150925, 0.018215248361229897, -0.0149101372808218, 0.031922969967126846, 0.053333502262830734, 0.0010428429814055562, 0.02195661887526512, 0.004136716015636921, -0.009026576764881611, -0.05213082209229469, -0.021818216890096664, 0.017585458233952522, -0.05012821778655052, -0.02423028275370598, -0.05683686211705208, 0.03129386156797409, 0.09361530840396881, -0.015340173617005348, -0.01322654914110899, 0.01558702066540718, -0.002942505292594433, 0.037047129124403, -0.046433862298727036, -0.012889404781162739, -0.03587307408452034, -0.006144148763269186, -0.009497073478996754, -0.0323382131755352, -0.014811995439231396, -0.013665840961039066, 0.008238758891820908, -0.02997015230357647, -0.0432557538151741, 0.037075456231832504, 0.09153109043836594, 0.006356730591505766, -0.006340119522064924, -0.042895134538412094, -0.019083812832832336, 0.02527581714093685, 0.04058573767542839, -0.0043332441709935665, 0.003299761563539505, 0.017276205122470856, -0.009440790861845016, -0.014903738163411617, -0.044721972197294235, 0.004860835615545511, 0.049373775720596313, -0.018184002488851547, 0.043609753251075745, 0.07116523385047913, -0.007934107445180416, 0.010467378422617912, -0.07549000531435013, -0.011101946234703064, -0.026624802500009537, -0.0026368149556219578, 0.06481743603944778, -0.02977217547595501, -0.027736347168684006, 0.013269266113638878, 0.005379273556172848, -0.0060414597392082214, 0.03032020665705204, -0.007120896130800247, -0.0005352016305550933, 0.030362293124198914, 0.031666964292526245, -0.05228042975068092, 0.02744600549340248, 0.008758031763136387, 0.04806922376155853, -0.021881166845560074, -0.0044630360789597034, 0.020831165835261345, 0.08767783641815186, 0.0011694311397150159, -0.0069611938670277596, -0.010730264708399773, -0.08464819192886353, -0.0037415449041873217, 0.037381675094366074, -0.025979241356253624, 0.015928661450743675, 0.016057532280683517, 0.05367176979780197, 0.010367115959525108, 0.022703031077980995, -0.02280019409954548, -0.03673984482884407, -0.03021673858165741, -0.004929960705339909, -0.004894540645182133, 0.031837012618780136, -0.05188925564289093, -0.006270627956837416, -0.008149692788720131, -0.08488240092992783, 0.03604907542467117, 0.0018333045300096273, 0.028661489486694336, 0.01558401994407177, 0.042121317237615585, -0.020755205303430557, -0.025953320786356926, -0.04537533223628998, -0.024154139682650566, 0.14559109508991241, 0.046284448355436325, 0.05558124929666519, -0.08430157601833344, 0.001685063587501645, 0.007384508848190308, 0.010376750491559505, 0.03102634847164154, -0.0013977255439385772, 0.04125117510557175, -0.00897645577788353, 0.03809390589594841, 0.02813108265399933, 0.03123798966407776, -0.007004552986472845, 0.03166845440864563, -0.03588508442044258, 0.017064955085515976, -0.016769006848335266, 0.014175206422805786, -0.008701280690729618, 0.0045588635839521885, -0.06477271765470505, -0.007007306907325983, 0.011910293251276016, 0.006404009647667408, -0.027479158714413643, -0.0013228118186816573, -0.005729658994823694, 0.02734309621155262, -0.04835730418562889, 0.03476697579026222, 0.018301481381058693, 0.003974005579948425, 0.0150985112413764, 0.010867496952414513, -0.00043254479533061385, -0.011699466966092587, 0.019243154674768448, 0.05133945867419243, 0.004652753472328186, 0.012721969746053219, 0.005543086677789688, -0.013115421868860722, -0.014126733876764774, -0.025704197585582733, -0.033658500760793686, 0.07084261626005173, 0.01891956850886345, -0.05260499566793442, -0.0038128576707094908, 0.030076229944825172, 0.005220689810812473, -0.049034133553504944, 0.017380492761731148, 0.01064920611679554, -0.012177372351288795, 0.0126730315387249, 0.03196583688259125, -0.018417369574308395, 0.011447709985077381, -0.02318931557238102, -0.005826739594340324, 0.03688746318221092, -0.021836740896105766, -0.007309863809496164, -0.06408686190843582, 0.022696638479828835, -0.017967194318771362, 0.014206266030669212, 0.021095743402838707, -0.015219531953334808, -0.020870879292488098, 0.002980229677632451, 0.015008500777184963, 0.044597022235393524, 0.04919577017426491, -0.018001556396484375, -0.007670694030821323, -0.025095826014876366, -0.05641646683216095, 0.00732418242841959, 0.002543300623074174, -0.01684335619211197, -0.023210082203149796, -0.01258544996380806, 0.023659994825720787, 0.05534627288579941, 0.013067037798464298, 0.008934537880122662, -0.025277961045503616, 0.061930101364851, 0.0022543282248079777, -0.0454733707010746, -0.028102820739150047, 0.06431809812784195, -0.015672463923692703, -0.0027401770930737257, -0.03212740644812584, 0.016519784927368164, 0.03270542994141579, 0.03889719024300575, -0.03363727778196335, 0.022069871425628662, 0.015831781551241875, -0.007791940122842789, 0.037820104509592056, -0.032416243106126785, 0.00914828758686781, 0.005533474963158369, -0.005606077145785093, 0.0003981802728958428, -0.03419139236211777, -0.049717459827661514, -0.047680046409368515, -0.0029502566903829575, -0.02504129149019718, -0.013206048868596554, 0.006858624052256346, -0.009698115289211273, 0.009772251360118389, -0.03393963351845741, -0.004266635049134493, -0.043380312621593475, -0.043133195489645004, 0.020582290366292, 0.011908179149031639, -0.025139285251498222, 0.010103167034685612, -0.02163090929389, 0.012126848101615906, 0.03027142956852913, 0.0019745242316275835, 0.00992031954228878, -0.006825530435889959, 0.018081532791256905, 0.043084483593702316, 0.05525672063231468, -0.0024028944317251444, -0.010345453396439552, 0.012670649215579033, -0.03588133305311203, -0.02462383732199669, -0.007994255051016808, 0.001521282596513629, -0.01895429939031601, -0.0032617738470435143, 0.030388610437512398, 0.005949425045400858, 0.037009481340646744, -0.03395143151283264, -0.030152516439557076, -0.020384682342410088, -0.014318713918328285, 0.021136872470378876, 0.03608701750636101, 0.0008404215332120657, 0.004682675004005432, 0.0004142340912949294, 0.045305848121643066, 0.0398690365254879, -0.007051663473248482, -0.010934356600046158, -0.007415555417537689, -0.02455783635377884, 0.021756671369075775, -0.003358247457072139, -0.007921567186713219, 0.057314954698085785, 0.03821401298046112, -0.010552838444709778, 0.022691279649734497, -0.02166607230901718, 0.03449428826570511, -0.10090231150388718, -0.02154245413839817, -0.0006230829749256372, 0.0254115778952837, 0.02319835126399994, -0.030257627367973328, 0.00881812535226345, 0.033214546740055084, -0.04985947906970978, 0.002085265936329961, -0.007316699251532555, 0.01370704360306263, -0.059701692312955856, 0.00960780493915081, -0.014163421466946602, 0.016083605587482452, 0.04550471156835556, 0.028211304917931557, 0.031578972935676575, 0.015034494921565056, 0.011034485884010792, 0.008410394191741943, -0.023056326434016228, -0.02128046192228794, 0.03894331678748131, -0.04789985343813896, -0.01310400478541851, -0.06002454087138176, -0.019221670925617218, 0.020881809294223785, -0.018471993505954742, 0.027650674805045128, 0.01679760403931141, 0.005212214309722185, 0.02408508211374283, 0.02603747881948948, 0.02401386760175228, -0.022635603323578835, 0.017134621739387512, -0.02490718849003315, 0.008556191809475422, 0.006862483453005552, -0.0040366207249462605, 0.0009372903150506318, -0.0037097479216754436, -0.02043040469288826, -0.041046738624572754, 0.014853482134640217, -0.013054429553449154, -0.022387303411960602, -0.009283829480409622, -0.01770409755408764, 0.03288508579134941, -0.02714521624147892, 0.007897932082414627, -0.01912629045546055, 0.015492617152631283, 0.06624710559844971, 0.0839921236038208, -0.01753869280219078, 0.007712990511208773, -0.03714827448129654, -0.059484004974365234, -0.018408358097076416, 0.029865365475416183, -0.012458698824048042, -0.014505931176245213, -0.02045716904103756, -0.03290139138698578, 0.022988801822066307, -0.006117601878941059, 0.010819570161402225, -0.021918663755059242, 0.0019831720273941755, -0.0324726477265358, -0.0036158435977995396, -0.023798951879143715, -0.025576937943696976, -0.012326563708484173, -0.11190903186798096, 0.04110216349363327, -0.023554600775241852, -0.016939440742135048, -0.04908772185444832, 0.018553119152784348, -0.07042302936315536, 0.03481021150946617, 0.03663666918873787, 0.038985636085271835, 0.0024094264954328537, -0.011960563249886036, 0.00617347052320838, 0.0015756034990772605, -0.06097785755991936, 0.04911964386701584, 0.01403640303760767, 0.022892745211720467, 0.0064506870694458485, 0.027051255106925964, -0.009836363606154919, 0.026829803362488747, 0.014242171309888363, -0.01470398623496294, 0.019794350489974022, -0.010415527038276196, 0.009369024075567722, -0.000056012831919360906, -0.0018635871820151806, -0.014841064810752869, -0.002333887852728367, -0.0005909170140512288, 0.025228653103113174, 0.055031415075063705, 0.016118673607707024, -0.046527884900569916, 0.028876066207885742, -0.013790911063551903, 0.01448985654860735, 0.008358148857951164, -0.0030190222896635532, -0.012677241116762161, -0.07256829738616943, 0.028026318177580833, -0.02556745707988739, 0.029396072030067444, -0.0342494398355484, 0.011185216717422009, 0.01915164664387703, 0.03821217641234398, -0.002415750175714493, 0.006188361439853907, -0.005924082361161709, -0.03667769581079483, 0.049942146986722946, 0.0049231331795454025, 0.02615867182612419, 0.0068794721737504005, -0.011671802960336208, 0.02413979358971119, -0.01549349632114172, 0.02791784144937992, -0.04296669363975525, 0.053338438272476196, 0.028920503333210945, 0.02601519227027893, 0.033643919974565506, 0.010364577174186707, 0.008772294037044048, 0.01681145466864109, 0.0058310688473284245, 0.02236326038837433, -0.05857858061790466, 0.011870951391756535, -0.04308270290493965, -0.03691995143890381, 0.010490692220628262, 0.027288490906357765, 0.04770248010754585, 0.008043424226343632, 0.020335186272859573, 0.020817913115024567, -0.014794370159506798, -0.017617205157876015, 0.03712743893265724, 0.02619750425219536, -0.0076107727363705635, 0.008246533572673798, -0.01500607468187809, 0.0006459748838096857, -0.044813890010118484, -0.008333913050591946, -0.04389667883515358, 0.030939146876335144, 0.03612162545323372, -0.01677463948726654, -0.05216977372765541, -0.005948306992650032, -0.008772039785981178, 0.021903671324253082, -0.05922488123178482, -0.048469286412000656, -0.0333084836602211, 0.03366580232977867, 0.04241287708282471, -0.02610309049487114 ]
<p>Please help! I have recently been criticized for using pairwise comparisons to explain all three levels of a factor within a negative binomial GLM rather than all levels at once. I was told that it is "long-winded" and "uneccessary". I was under the impression that in GLMs one cannot bulk all levels of a factor together to obtain a test statistic and corresponding p-value.</p> <p>Obviously if a factor is "insignificant" at any level then carrying out a post-hoc analysis is pointless. My levels all have there own p-values therefore I discussed these values from the below global model. I was told to do an ANOVA instead which I don't believe is suitable for overdispersed, zero-inflated data.</p> <p>p-value for all levels of a factor anyone?</p> <p>(Below, lower field layer 0, upper field layer 1 and change1 is in intercept)</p> <pre><code> Deviance Residuals: Min 1Q Median 3Q Max -2.4284 -0.7956 -0.3862 0.4045 2.4233 Coefficients: Estimate Std. Error z value Pr(&gt;|z|) (Intercept) 4.3410884 1.8219786 2.383 0.01719 * Height 0.0373584 0.0119929 3.115 0.00184 ** Width -0.0007891 0.0008246 -0.957 0.33859 MeanMin -0.1731877 0.1404434 -1.233 0.21752 as.factor(Site_Treat)2 -0.4080256 0.2480438 -1.645 0.09998 . as.factor(Change)2 -0.4940398 0.1755487 -2.814 0.00489 ** as.factor(Change)3 -0.1613766 0.1763677 -0.915 0.36019 as.factor(Lower_Field_Layer)1 0.4873488 0.2931585 1.662 0.09643 . as.factor(Lower_Field_Layer)2 -0.3292409 0.3717863 -0.886 0.37585 as.factor(Upper_Field_Layer)2 -0.0081040 0.3257734 -0.025 0.98015 --- Signif. codes: 0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1 (Dispersion parameter for Negative Binomial(4.7795) family taken to be 1) Null deviance: 96.392 on 46 degrees of freedom Residual deviance: 47.968 on 37 degrees of freedom AIC: 403.94 </code></pre> <p>Best wishes, Platypezid</p>
73,737
[ -0.024827884510159492, 0.03144228830933571, -0.03100145235657692, 0.0043319398537278175, 0.06752761453390121, -0.013755346648395061, 0.011369624175131321, -0.0487908311188221, 0.02292080596089363, -0.04861251264810562, 0.014475285075604916, 0.013987014070153236, 0.04879770800471306, 0.013456974178552628, 0.015398441813886166, 0.0186794251203537, 0.003438422456383705, -0.026944521814584732, -0.0023020715452730656, -0.020059742033481598, -0.014832788147032261, 0.043430741876363754, -0.001520137651823461, 0.033013708889484406, -0.043733593076467514, 0.06644705682992935, 0.03859389200806618, -0.046913158148527145, -0.011249582283198833, 0.045576706528663635, -0.04898521676659584, -0.03267053887248039, -0.0016533832531422377, 0.00664739403873682, 0.043667588382959366, 0.02281973883509636, 0.004043667111545801, -0.01900879107415676, -0.01384540181607008, 0.0651213601231575, 0.028972622007131577, 0.0007885245722718537, -0.027698049321770668, 0.015615926124155521, 0.0022878136951476336, 0.013949715532362461, 0.013716966845095158, 0.021149344742298126, 0.06872990727424622, -0.05195875093340874, 0.02604655921459198, -0.001329950406216085, 0.020218105986714363, 0.02406441792845726, -0.02707805670797825, -0.01250712014734745, 0.0468456894159317, 0.04601966589689255, -0.000997462309896946, -0.06453222781419754, -0.008427245542407036, -0.04168076813220978, 0.026969505473971367, -0.023576799780130386, 0.0015204384690150619, 0.03814881294965744, 0.020559042692184448, -0.013423522934317589, 0.053796619176864624, -0.015577873215079308, 0.01698264665901661, 0.00908735953271389, -0.002515806583687663, -0.005104553885757923, 0.009886076673865318, -0.02231624163687229, 0.011815737001597881, 0.0052549648098647594, 0.03697784245014191, 0.032283566892147064, -0.037190698087215424, 0.029060300439596176, 0.007989056408405304, 0.0019687258172780275, 0.008732889778912067, 0.01803920790553093, 0.08009196817874908, -0.036647722125053406, -0.0042831432074308395, 0.03748767822980881, -0.035920388996601105, 0.020309410989284515, 0.027787866070866585, 0.016085434705018997, -0.02144015021622181, 0.02709309570491314, -0.0070555428974330425, 0.0013755010440945625, -0.006121449172496796, 0.030061643570661545, -0.03981434553861618, -0.03166201338171959, 0.011637413874268532, -0.004825897980481386, -0.03125106543302536, 0.02467195875942707, -0.033361926674842834, -0.02234838157892227, -0.015001608058810234, -0.04316740110516548, -0.014150664210319519, 0.01901119202375412, -0.0038061426021158695, -0.03802460804581642, -0.013819907791912556, -0.05918890982866287, 0.005481251049786806, -0.0025842678733170033, 0.05893835052847862, 0.05222459137439728, 0.03191329911351204, -0.05911212041974068, 0.015801822766661644, -0.03861158713698387, -0.07597839832305908, 0.011780274100601673, -0.0026810031849890947, -0.004802313167601824, -0.006805024109780788, 0.07512901723384857, 0.04051249101758003, -0.03233864903450012, 0.04372614249587059, -0.0011716393055394292, 0.012262407690286636, 0.02282036282122135, -0.06347022205591202, -0.057166967540979385, 0.016470879316329956, -0.01780812256038189, 0.02487785555422306, -0.05618634074926376, -0.02560637705028057, 0.01326958741992712, 0.030702846124768257, 0.02201942540705204, 0.04915126785635948, -0.007620768155902624, 0.029411064460873604, 0.01315383706241846, -0.030843080952763557, -0.006404507905244827, -0.04768502712249756, -0.015012187883257866, -0.02277160994708538, -0.07086612284183502, 0.013524412177503109, 0.00039200877654366195, -0.00772042665630579, 0.03567782789468765, 0.044904205948114395, 0.0067934500984847546, 0.0026987134478986263, 0.009385512210428715, -0.017068782821297646, 0.012603764422237873, 0.05796230956912041, -0.022221960127353668, 0.04479779303073883, 0.0541023313999176, -0.033122994005680084, -0.013262804597616196, -0.01349232904613018, 0.03675378859043121, 0.01656106859445572, -0.01427835039794445, 0.016450410708785057, -0.04758730158209801, 0.030533557757735252, 0.019418617710471153, -0.053885336965322495, -0.00615336000919342, -0.038710981607437134, -0.02636374533176422, 0.024237416684627533, 0.058639660477638245, -0.03898414969444275, -0.028531430289149284, 0.1106136292219162, -0.06642854958772659, -0.04212130978703499, -0.02431471087038517, 0.005710312630981207, 0.028955234214663506, -0.010572210885584354, 0.0036715264432132244, -0.01214859914034605, 0.03687717765569687, -0.01278263796120882, 0.026603013277053833, -0.0076678721234202385, 0.00853799469769001, 0.03539135679602623, -0.018131133168935776, 0.031066324561834335, 0.021063104271888733, 0.043427351862192154, -0.030639756470918655, 0.043197400867938995, -0.03084512986242771, -0.028220398351550102, 0.022755896672606468, -0.03445831686258316, 0.036380525678396225, -0.03148248791694641, -0.054349131882190704, 0.023480108007788658, 0.0021990989334881306, -0.008918586187064648, 0.03261519595980644, -0.08339718729257584, 0.06452765315771103, 0.07743283361196518, -0.027667656540870667, -0.008306305855512619, 0.0032133276108652353, 0.004519255831837654, 0.018773147836327553, -0.04733555018901825, 0.025546889752149582, -0.03541091829538345, -0.045319560915231705, 0.07593237608671188, -0.005796810612082481, -0.00959406141191721, -0.0160689614713192, 0.037974145263433456, 0.011169460602104664, 0.0481032095849514, 0.03972884267568588, 0.01710967719554901, -0.03094935044646263, 0.0259240735322237, 0.013445996679365635, 0.040100596845149994, -0.008931433781981468, 0.020997732877731323, -0.0032317840959876776, 0.04894199222326279, 0.004406653810292482, 0.002856435952708125, 0.028055744245648384, -0.011318526230752468, 0.007395043037831783, -0.026810547336935997, -0.005195387173444033, 0.021446270868182182, 0.000521645531989634, 0.018467653542757034, 0.03136303275823593, 0.00880140345543623, 0.0026282574981451035, -0.027448248118162155, -0.012259386479854584, 0.0480777733027935, 0.05844797566533089, -0.038470569998025894, -0.022952059283852577, 0.0037937206216156483, -0.016027230769395828, 0.017338315024971962, -0.05697647109627724, -0.04578838124871254, -0.04782673344016075, -0.003341701813042164, 0.02129410021007061, 0.00766747584566474, 0.028603697195649147, -0.05116815119981766, 0.03935137391090393, -0.018201224505901337, 0.02445802465081215, 0.04901542887091637, 0.029263967648148537, -0.05257968604564667, -0.028524497523903847, -0.02226812019944191, -0.018637340515851974, 0.05672997608780861, -0.019806690514087677, -0.029388556256890297, 0.02275814116001129, -0.003099641529843211, -0.02308334968984127, -0.0197281613945961, -0.026327205821871758, -0.011079219169914722, 0.024341437965631485, -0.02201465703547001, 0.044050246477127075, -0.005175495520234108, -0.04136480391025543, 0.02815817855298519, -0.020809106528759003, -0.009409523569047451, 0.007798093371093273, 0.002488141879439354, -0.0010013969149440527, 0.026290424168109894, -0.01707087643444538, 0.019944265484809875, -0.020190341398119926, -0.0032892238814383745, -0.0368465818464756, -0.06727095693349838, -0.0006814022781327367, 0.007113462779670954, 0.015832416713237762, -0.03468678146600723, -0.012425187043845654, 0.09059205651283264, 0.04656883329153061, -0.018299870193004608, -0.04401698336005211, -0.0152316028252244, -0.036623843014240265, -0.03313523158431053, 0.02750580757856369, -0.012201779522001743, 0.05351290479302406, 0.05651077255606651, -0.0453784242272377, 0.04332418367266655, 0.05179231986403465, 0.04747200757265091, -0.005267820321023464, 0.005000881850719452, 0.007874337956309319, -0.017814140766859055, 0.014439516700804234, -0.00043229316361248493, -0.0021583077032119036, 0.01747305691242218, 0.007435841951519251, 0.014336500316858292, -0.021423621103167534, -0.05929286777973175, 0.017439907416701317, -0.008507424034178257, 0.03200134262442589, -0.03410318121314049, 0.013143541291356087, 0.023701250553131104, -0.050664614886045456, 0.008838515728712082, -0.0086395014077425, 0.045061297714710236, -0.0074563282541930676, 0.006426271982491016, 0.028127042576670647, 0.024962669238448143, -0.015056973323225975, 0.025024905800819397, 0.009492739103734493, 0.004175862763077021, 0.014657452702522278, -0.04406898096203804, -0.0011827817652374506, 0.07865478098392487, 0.04932112246751785, 0.028642112389206886, -0.022741973400115967, -0.02459530532360077, 0.025196118280291557, -0.03698857128620148, 0.03601129725575447, -0.01797201670706272, 0.016007428988814354, -0.012241416610777378, 0.02782217040657997, -0.0020420190412551165, -0.019729364663362503, -0.017667682841420174, -0.004482039716094732, -0.017968082800507545, -0.01594582386314869, -0.010695978067815304, 0.016918279230594635, 0.031238751485943794, -0.010890064761042595, 0.014961177483201027, -0.005417563021183014, 0.017904676496982574, -0.006207268685102463, 0.059710793197155, 0.0017615632386878133, 0.008195888251066208, -0.008383777923882008, 0.002985371043905616, -0.0195434782654047, 0.024834368377923965, 0.03246418014168739, -0.019212644547224045, 0.029431600123643875, 0.023827411234378815, 0.011357216164469719, 0.02646810933947563, -0.017859768122434616, -0.0033850816544145346, 0.03498602285981178, 0.020184127613902092, 0.01562054455280304, 0.02015632577240467, -0.06763560324907303, 0.05282556638121605, 0.003558708820492029, 0.00255789328366518, 0.019491367042064667, 0.010121770203113556, -0.007099027745425701, -0.01126768346875906, -0.04562557116150856, -0.0076306844130158424, 0.015867965295910835, 0.01356262993067503, 0.014402729459106922, 0.040372736752033234, 0.026018278673291206, -0.030179573222994804, 0.05367233231663704, 0.04866758733987808, -0.013086684979498386, -0.0034364277962595224, -0.027362946420907974, -0.037796396762132645, -0.016464855521917343, -0.01014228630810976, 0.04796043410897255, 0.01721913181245327, 0.01000569760799408, -0.03986513987183571, 0.03925101459026337, -0.016367856413125992, -0.03296394273638725, 0.0019367741188034415, 0.035166185349226, 0.02437116578221321, 0.019956622272729874, -0.03346351534128189, -0.011508830823004246, 0.02341187745332718, 0.03774409368634224, 0.03961286321282387, 0.006968388799577951, -0.07448889315128326, -0.012295098043978214, 0.06121932715177536, 0.07025466859340668, -0.011483577080070972, -0.01618465781211853, -0.02816583402454853, -0.043020229786634445, -0.0008914925274439156, -0.025248993188142776, 0.034675244241952896, -0.015065022744238377, 0.038656335324048996, -0.03740284964442253, -0.05460318922996521, -0.08030766993761063, 0.019696129485964775, -0.029573051258921623, 0.018756525591015816, 0.004903669469058514, -0.03325001150369644, -0.03648139163851738, 0.03126393258571625, -0.0009822415886446834, 0.04544304311275482, -0.0392850860953331, -0.004896806553006172, 0.05094260722398758, -0.01949017122387886, -0.00948630552738905, -0.06006131321191788, 0.010018935427069664, -0.006387832574546337, 0.009012761525809765, 0.05112425610423088, -0.002847337629646063, -0.033948078751564026, -0.00722238514572382, 0.039714206010103226, -0.024526456370949745, 0.00032116539659909904, -0.023830147460103035, 0.05102941393852234, 0.019509457051753998, -0.01479249820113182, 0.0723431184887886, 0.017283868044614792, -0.019621748477220535, 0.01662057265639305, -0.07229416072368622, 0.02641853503882885, -0.027986466884613037, -0.03887282684445381, -0.08207320421934128, -0.007649942766875029, 0.0005464939749799669, 0.03899068385362625, -0.00046210596337914467, 0.024291589856147766, -0.04278046265244484, 0.0032952374313026667, 0.026623709127306938, 0.0038252624217420816, -0.034532882273197174, -0.015477219596505165, 0.022120915353298187, -0.008795173838734627, 0.015315189957618713, -0.02149057760834694, 0.008589239791035652, -0.010239602997899055, 0.0005806584958918393, -0.00628498662263155, -0.03977411612868309, -0.007141638081520796, -0.005994241219013929, -0.018520306795835495, -0.03283439204096794, -0.03245401382446289, 0.041979264467954636, -0.0007393957348540425, 0.015103728510439396, -0.02554885856807232, -0.027004621922969818, -0.008582531474530697, 0.015417463146150112, 0.009678900241851807, 0.03271696716547012, -0.0196534413844347, 0.008139769546687603, -0.032121606171131134, 0.009113089181482792, -0.06095467507839203, -0.02526167407631874, 0.022369034588336945, 0.0055425455793738365, 0.005077133420854807, -0.012155294418334961, -0.04245607927441597, 0.003017642069607973, 0.01541364286094904, -0.015457376837730408, 0.042740240693092346, -0.07725447416305542, 0.023741647601127625, 0.008351350203156471, 0.025941047817468643, 0.05708855763077736, -0.00678785378113389, -0.004861137829720974, 0.03401481360197067, 0.004263825248926878, -0.041298817843198776, 0.009626910090446472, -0.02310297079384327, -0.014964712783694267, -0.01742910034954548, -0.012372634373605251, 0.0021237691398710012, 0.018591584637761116, -0.01815054751932621, -0.037790365517139435, -0.013968418352305889, -0.016234179958701134, 0.0016527945408597589, -0.05675144121050835, 0.00011885467392858118, -0.012847105972468853, -0.0004060370847582817, -0.03948025405406952, 0.010817858390510082, -0.02313138172030449, 0.008335360325872898, 0.02529454603791237, -0.04087846353650093, -0.04190351814031601, 0.009652920067310333, 0.061816636472940445, -0.0007147922879084945, 0.007510833907872438, -0.002518102992326021, -0.03369014337658882, 0.02280852384865284, 0.02041076309978962, 0.0040118820033967495, 0.030975807458162308, 0.032292917370796204, -0.02859276346862316, -0.003926844336092472, -0.02300708182156086, 0.00799866858869791, 0.05940353497862816, 0.01202105637639761, -0.00888720341026783, 0.0565512515604496, -0.0043708560988307, -0.002358127385377884, -0.06083015725016594, -0.031032973900437355, 0.0384007953107357, 0.00658164219930768, 0.07511559873819351, -0.023496408015489578, 0.03270702064037323, 0.06083087623119354, 0.01014801301062107, 0.0023247587960213423, 0.047221820801496506, -0.014232587069272995, 0.0006445084582082927, 0.03594813123345375, 0.0008136508404277265, -0.04112429916858673, 0.03139452636241913, -0.053333450108766556, -0.003586601000279188, -0.03099893219769001, -0.017011918127536774, 0.052989207208156586, 0.04792613536119461, 0.02015920914709568, -0.0540977381169796, -0.02694963477551937, -0.055402811616659164, -0.0010493744630366564, 0.019213253632187843, -0.03807509317994118, 0.015165841206908226, -0.008829819969832897, 0.048157282173633575, -0.024209467694163322, 0.02802332490682602, -0.013749424368143082, -0.0678398609161377, -0.01889699324965477, 0.007015233859419823, -0.02732008323073387, 0.015005531720817089, 0.0013388870283961296, -0.04464023560285568, 0.02400415949523449, -0.06267569214105606, 0.005411588121205568, -0.0013569699367508292, 0.0033561433665454388, -0.003368277568370104, 0.0022295035887509584, -0.0016438146121799946, 0.0002960522542707622, -0.00714913010597229, -0.036110080778598785, 0.1376417726278305, 0.04261435940861702, 0.04842128977179527, -0.04976287856698036, 0.012998105026781559, -0.0018322730902582407, 0.0030252281576395035, -0.027778606861829758, -0.020571961998939514, -0.022700442001223564, -0.03054668754339218, 0.06366058439016342, 0.06967400014400482, 0.03693852573633194, -0.018698599189519882, 0.05071225389838219, 0.0013044965453445911, 0.011211046017706394, -0.0062118712812662125, 0.03291399031877518, -0.027434399351477623, -0.038599561899900436, -0.030699657276272774, 0.020002668723464012, 0.03718113154172897, -0.01188830565661192, -0.03779551386833191, 0.021111737936735153, -0.014185264706611633, -0.02001446671783924, -0.046461015939712524, 0.0021868073381483555, -0.005156956147402525, -0.005866804625838995, 0.0004490246355999261, -0.025259017944335938, 0.023201318457722664, -0.02365761250257492, 0.00023281182802747935, 0.06006627902388573, -0.020058298483490944, -0.008183508180081844, 0.033293746411800385, 0.011982611380517483, -0.04737815633416176, -0.05919572710990906, -0.01679433137178421, 0.06654994934797287, -0.00441316980868578, -0.006727423053234816, 0.021709274500608444, -0.023482657968997955, 0.019314805045723915, -0.03862174600362778, -0.0067473906092345715, 0.028959987685084343, 0.03269082307815552, 0.0036016697995364666, 0.0002895524667110294, -0.003667624434456229, 0.027546178549528122, 0.010641121305525303, 0.015194601379334927, 0.026607761159539223, 0.0004937366466037929, -0.025639856234192848, -0.0474863164126873, 0.05943010002374649, 0.021308183670043945, 0.025901934131979942, 0.017604926601052284, 0.002160899341106415, 0.006829488091170788, -0.001507722889073193, 0.004451077897101641, -0.0056751626543700695, 0.018221087753772736, -0.020237235352396965, -0.00899033434689045, -0.03752836957573891, -0.02336016483604908, 0.03141941502690315, -0.043187279254198074, -0.005152030382305384, -0.030593905597925186, -0.030760372057557106, -0.004204528871923685, 0.03467313572764397, 0.029540404677391052, 0.03082660771906376, -0.03951549157500267, 0.05768561735749245, -0.02275269851088524, -0.0728120356798172, -0.014351113699376583, 0.013744741678237915, -0.020951896905899048, -0.030054695904254913, 0.00496515491977334, 0.043029312044382095, 0.028521940112113953, 0.012134676799178123, -0.01971331425011158, 0.04834939166903496, -0.008761445991694927, -0.022717738524079323, 0.03704310581088066, -0.04741741344332695, 0.012342263013124466, 0.017321687191724777, -0.024633347988128662, -0.019257014617323875, -0.03228989988565445, -0.048138007521629333, -0.06341671943664551, 0.01324098277837038, 0.010961931198835373, -0.03776700049638748, -0.011763767339289188, -0.007961715571582317, -0.011294935829937458, -0.03216942399740219, -0.009380445815622807, -0.05296381190419197, -0.009742435067892075, -0.002013933379203081, -0.0414883978664875, 0.000527751340996474, 0.0037772844079881907, -0.020663809031248093, 0.019581666216254234, 0.0432291217148304, -0.024083366617560387, 0.009873333387076855, -0.017927294597029686, 0.026104334741830826, 0.03443635627627373, 0.027275919914245605, 0.033930372446775436, -0.011686715297400951, -0.00835215300321579, -0.028623413294553757, -0.03836458921432495, 0.053969189524650574, 0.0038085707928985357, 0.03934014216065407, 0.0022236909717321396, 0.011520135216414928, -0.03616398945450783, 0.034872252494096756, -0.002873507561162114, -0.018523821607232094, -0.03339153528213501, -0.008636279962956905, 0.005868364591151476, -0.01658686064183712, 0.026682183146476746, 0.0037443507462739944, -0.008169107139110565, 0.025352897122502327, 0.0570250079035759, -0.02133837714791298, -0.00115958193782717, 0.01727457530796528, -0.04353285953402519, -0.01952596753835678, 0.0168010126799345, -0.01616169512271881, -0.006111011374741793, 0.06935422122478485, 0.005107867065817118, 0.040611881762742996, -0.029748806729912758, 0.05475064367055893, -0.1098080649971962, -0.035076603293418884, -0.0006675425684079528, 0.06290536373853683, 0.005222261417657137, -0.07543729990720749, 0.03686368092894554, 0.0016687370371073484, -0.04716530069708824, 0.004927832633256912, 0.006954700220376253, -0.004100504331290722, 0.00589634058997035, -0.012404844164848328, -0.025486312806606293, -0.0042973835952579975, -0.010961594060063362, 0.01253102533519268, 0.014828943647444248, 0.025396766141057014, -0.0012483814498409629, -0.03196823596954346, -0.003475908190011978, 0.023387005552649498, 0.03740696981549263, -0.05767469480633736, 0.014017161913216114, -0.012330899015069008, -0.008023015223443508, 0.0235579926520586, -0.02377183735370636, 0.022713398560881615, 0.03828877583146095, 0.06338366866111755, 0.015208760276436806, 0.043689120560884476, 0.040594104677438736, 0.02200758084654808, -0.014466970227658749, -0.017866449430584908, -0.0026068887673318386, 0.025277353823184967, -0.021884486079216003, 0.053348809480667114, 0.004015050828456879, -0.006264555733650923, 0.001889714621938765, 0.0034918307792395353, -0.03812452405691147, 0.0021726861596107483, -0.03402034565806389, 0.02854384109377861, 0.0024591998662799597, -0.0338236540555954, 0.018334174528717995, -0.0309000127017498, -0.01017849612981081, 0.041039079427719116, 0.012992102652788162, -0.07041119039058685, 0.0318167619407177, 0.009242254309356213, -0.03985321521759033, -0.002386437263339758, -0.0056541599333286285, -0.011795303784310818, -0.06438633799552917, -0.01742287538945675, -0.03147000074386597, -0.01646452583372593, -0.0029975075740367174, 0.004471348598599434, -0.06892355531454086, 0.009566305205225945, -0.03290318697690964, -0.001208212343044579, 0.006815190427005291, -0.013947025872766972, 0.05999324470758438, -0.10639144480228424, 0.05771169811487198, -0.009219782426953316, -0.0123684611171484, -0.06325171887874603, -0.0171003770083189, -0.024888157844543457, 0.024097442626953125, 0.04690089821815491, 0.04407382011413574, 0.0422142818570137, -0.0146157993003726, 0.04046532139182091, 0.0027416974771767855, -0.05909120291471481, 0.052308425307273865, -0.0020725056529045105, -0.007145544979721308, 0.03122061863541603, -0.00006810073682572693, 0.022115277126431465, 0.019306352362036705, 0.014374385587871075, -0.012932771816849709, 0.015025601722300053, -0.006896454840898514, 0.0033756934572011232, 0.04752202332019806, -0.029644524678587914, -0.03395795822143555, 0.019818203523755074, 0.02143329754471779, 0.02476389706134796, 0.05461164563894272, 0.007471932098269463, -0.04614662006497383, 0.036575011909008026, 0.011262498795986176, -0.002386141801252961, 0.011954776011407375, 0.010175546631217003, 0.02382480353116989, -0.05894170701503754, 0.016269270330667496, 0.0019486671080812812, -0.04144785553216934, 0.0038098886143416166, 0.03977063670754433, 0.017306094989180565, 0.007471929304301739, -0.01275185402482748, 0.008053694851696491, -0.0036656707525253296, -0.019007552415132523, 0.016875579953193665, 0.0448780283331871, 0.020449716597795486, -0.006924401503056288, 0.0014603134477511048, 0.02058280259370804, -0.02368752285838127, 0.009661245159804821, 0.02650071308016777, 0.03277358412742615, 0.0001228788896696642, 0.010209118016064167, 0.029255487024784088, 0.008418876677751541, 0.029433708637952805, 0.02293200045824051, -0.00521631445735693, 0.02390667423605919, -0.021893931552767754, -0.018488319590687752, -0.022633686661720276, -0.014174865558743477, -0.027727732434868813, -0.010067267343401909, 0.013691643252968788, 0.04375157877802849, -0.0009057515417225659, -0.021734369918704033, 0.017151959240436554, -0.015588590875267982, -0.023036273196339607, -0.017296072095632553, 0.01805352419614792, -0.00004480359348235652, 0.007435269188135862, -0.0014271228574216366, -0.022364480420947075, -0.00777572114020586, -0.041318103671073914, 0.029478540644049644, 0.010096915997564793, 0.023629289120435715, -0.05858883634209633, 0.007899320684373379, 0.003101461799815297, 0.026357559487223625, -0.05581359565258026, -0.01859360747039318, -0.02419055998325348, 0.025193484500050545, -0.011021613143384457, -0.016018984839320183 ]
<p>I have a time series that follow an MA(1) process , I do non-overlapping aggregation with aggregation level $m=2,3,\dots$, and then I calculate autocorrelation of basic and aggregated series, for negative value of moving average parameter, aggregated autocorrelation becomes close to zero, means that the aggregated series want to be like white noise, I was wondering if anybody can explain the reasons behind this behavior?</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/D0Xun.png" alt="enter image description here"></p>
73,738
[ -0.01841355301439762, 0.006524393800646067, -0.017282754182815552, -0.008615609258413315, 0.0536438450217247, -0.002736744936555624, -0.03076559118926525, -0.01142139919102192, -0.008093261159956455, -0.05347894877195358, 0.014072543941438198, 0.019634883850812912, 0.05227980762720108, 0.021990695968270302, 0.02159462869167328, -0.03467699885368347, -0.028154630213975906, -0.0025037324521690607, 0.015138347633183002, -0.02197255752980709, -0.009663473814725876, 0.06168268620967865, 0.04102182388305664, 0.004155402537435293, -0.019540628418326378, 0.0033892460633069277, 0.0006974814459681511, 0.01904672384262085, 0.000582158041652292, 0.07988803088665009, -0.030830325558781624, -0.0014519470278173685, -0.00821034237742424, 0.03959193453192711, 0.0006700857193209231, 0.022890878841280937, -0.04258313402533531, -0.034071944653987885, -0.03989168256521225, 0.0542391799390316, -0.04613863676786423, -0.036862775683403015, -0.02606646530330181, 0.010504991747438908, -0.04783562198281288, -0.015277599915862083, 0.023113617673516273, 0.015042440965771675, 0.044887933880090714, -0.02714848890900612, 0.07263999432325363, -0.001831547706387937, 0.037488438189029694, 0.03783828020095825, 0.005851224064826965, -0.021326813846826553, 0.06117136776447296, 0.05769545957446098, -0.02932026796042919, -0.04566052928566933, 0.0002572444500401616, -0.035754863172769547, 0.031043706461787224, -0.015442024916410446, 0.00893240887671709, 0.0517553836107254, -0.01732093282043934, -0.03152363747358322, -0.0098883006721735, 0.002782852854579687, 0.012246362864971161, 0.02988099493086338, 0.01959843374788761, -0.03128265589475632, -0.000012309044905123301, -0.03618523105978966, 0.04003271833062172, 0.010159426368772984, 0.07191076874732971, 0.03578368201851845, 0.035816311836242676, 0.018160950392484665, 0.03221423923969269, 0.0017585165333002806, 0.03249811753630638, -0.01770864427089691, 0.08847662806510925, -0.016065534204244614, -0.0036388528533279896, 0.016194485127925873, -0.02190224826335907, 0.02726258523762226, 0.050658050924539566, 0.01653631404042244, -0.05137445777654648, 0.03565380349755287, 0.002506466582417488, 0.036940108984708786, 0.013581614010035992, -0.03871510550379753, -0.023212304338812828, -0.038578104227781296, 0.03318778797984123, 0.028335249051451683, 0.000019976227122242562, 0.007117882836610079, -0.019573161378502846, -0.025878222659230232, -0.03947959467768669, -0.05248728021979332, -0.004838613327592611, -0.017278779298067093, 0.021728549152612686, -0.049349479377269745, 0.0027749582659453154, -0.004379461985081434, -0.012946397066116333, -0.02567771077156067, -0.006138527300208807, 0.083894282579422, 0.040242668241262436, -0.007465697359293699, 0.04300368204712868, -0.035328950732946396, -0.06949930638074875, 0.015147343277931213, -0.018547844141721725, -0.014399223029613495, -0.055833376944065094, 0.08236977458000183, 0.031444668769836426, -0.037582170218229294, 0.07147793471813202, -0.02095308154821396, 0.037405434995889664, -0.00616941973567009, -0.09061142802238464, -0.03451050817966461, 0.06898830085992813, -0.05328349396586418, 0.03247065097093582, -0.05552190914750099, 0.0013549888972193003, 0.016198642551898956, 0.06161043047904968, 0.05085697025060654, 0.0211099311709404, 0.05156421661376953, 0.029187440872192383, 0.0003496796125546098, -0.04662245884537697, -0.056635256856679916, -0.02044001594185829, -0.044366516172885895, 0.0018406282179057598, -0.06082196533679962, 0.024059005081653595, 0.0399143248796463, -0.02237641252577305, 0.0097212428227067, 0.01037127710878849, 0.029158491641283035, -0.002221273025497794, 0.0024645363446325064, 0.0035640026908367872, -0.0466085821390152, 0.0553717315196991, 0.03976259008049965, -0.004679640755057335, -0.018078744411468506, 0.008289681747555733, 0.024227861315011978, 0.0022846413776278496, 0.07067295908927917, 0.040289755910634995, -0.0077777584083378315, -0.017106136307120323, -0.005094253458082676, 0.02676723524928093, 0.0358792245388031, -0.029005909338593483, -0.023885130882263184, -0.025965120643377304, -0.012478386983275414, 0.04310299828648567, 0.00915069505572319, -0.004041253589093685, 0.010136831551790237, -0.002329461043700576, -0.03859039768576622, -0.02267691306769848, -0.058648429811000824, -0.012309505604207516, -0.019940204918384552, -0.021575599908828735, -0.0011954245856031775, -0.027207190170884132, 0.031143341213464737, 0.007425729185342789, 0.004814302548766136, -0.0008619293221272528, -0.009551111608743668, 0.006701004691421986, -0.03826608136296272, 0.041248422116041183, 0.016591887921094894, 0.008996679447591305, -0.006288954056799412, -0.017043160274624825, -0.022820936515927315, -0.019441302865743637, 0.002513873390853405, -0.021669765934348106, 0.02773028425872326, -0.0388578437268734, -0.04012342542409897, 0.03988102078437805, -0.021644866093993187, -0.022494973614811897, 0.03732187673449516, -0.0497233122587204, 0.04169274866580963, 0.04673714190721512, 0.0032733348198235035, 0.016009116545319557, 0.03947841748595238, 0.023645298555493355, -0.011066622100770473, -0.052840813994407654, -0.03076789900660515, -0.04865550622344017, 0.011699714697897434, 0.0454833097755909, 0.052780382335186005, -0.04687395319342613, 0.026858484372496605, 0.040764208883047104, 0.00978486705571413, -0.00810839980840683, 0.0418236218392849, 0.04294406995177269, 0.03636232763528824, 0.024792248383164406, 0.02408050000667572, 0.0034837480634450912, -0.018013007938861847, 0.010401053354144096, -0.017164824530482292, 0.04219008982181549, -0.010123340412974358, -0.05170943960547447, 0.03664078935980797, -0.007981802336871624, 0.040261831134557724, -0.020236385986208916, -0.014326361007988453, 0.02250641956925392, -0.019917171448469162, -0.013295278884470463, 0.022148506715893745, 0.037686869502067566, 0.003357975510880351, 0.013085261918604374, -0.02727072313427925, -0.0003441520093474537, 0.01635134406387806, -0.017559032887220383, -0.04973555728793144, 0.003834191709756851, 0.011324206367135048, 0.01620839349925518, -0.012843277305364609, -0.0033726338297128677, -0.0258474200963974, 0.009593592956662178, 0.07963491231203079, 0.025738555938005447, 0.01822131685912609, -0.0538874976336956, -0.019323091953992844, 0.0001835852162912488, -0.0004669778572861105, 0.038976963609457016, 0.024136321619153023, 0.007600797805935144, 0.01595197431743145, -0.016526388004422188, 0.018649796023964882, 0.039623863995075226, -0.04051743820309639, 0.014501330442726612, 0.017134223133325577, 0.0025750810746103525, -0.08170036971569061, -0.04615996405482292, -0.02388538233935833, -0.041475821286439896, -0.04100428521633148, -0.04142804443836212, 0.03757569566369057, 0.035332221537828445, -0.055205222219228745, 0.032338015735149384, -0.055717647075653076, -0.004948411136865616, -0.04167342931032181, -0.005454274360090494, 0.041703201830387115, -0.061774127185344696, 0.035012148320674896, 0.00355893443338573, -0.020767932757735252, 0.014196235686540604, -0.038029540330171585, -0.024683881551027298, -0.0029937250073999166, -0.0319400280714035, 0.0111123351380229, 0.00017991114873439074, -0.051770493388175964, 0.027698256075382233, 0.02258039452135563, -0.01250861119478941, -0.04500803351402283, -0.02573123387992382, -0.05048922821879387, -0.08223050832748413, 0.011693066917359829, 0.03896002843976021, 0.012353528290987015, 0.023980386555194855, 0.015981612727046013, 0.05264649540185928, 0.03686164319515228, -0.010097477585077286, -0.016046978533267975, 0.0291195809841156, -0.03188787400722504, 0.013508432544767857, 0.012800793163478374, 0.014839048497378826, -0.00016873970162123442, 0.025548264384269714, 0.05012964829802513, 0.00808663759380579, -0.005335255991667509, -0.030080599710345268, 0.05500392988324165, -0.017852436751127243, 0.022961854934692383, -0.07290604710578918, 0.04774288460612297, 0.005752398166805506, 0.02137754112482071, -0.06359868496656418, -0.010335534811019897, 0.008461066521704197, -0.03257725387811661, 0.025414112955331802, 0.0723678320646286, -0.0023495054338127375, -0.025336124002933502, -0.008434772491455078, -0.023131122812628746, 0.009259152226150036, 0.016387322917580605, -0.02125203236937523, 0.009881997480988503, 0.033550672233104706, 0.021954253315925598, 0.016743328422307968, -0.020865801721811295, -0.04905243590474129, -0.0077491095289587975, -0.06810068339109421, 0.0019300602143630385, -0.010283032432198524, 0.06785965710878372, 0.021675776690244675, -0.0032870271243155003, 0.04205496236681938, 0.0064100599847733974, 0.006223154254257679, 0.009890909306704998, -0.03814128413796425, 0.007405683398246765, 0.004470181185752153, -0.009261553175747395, -0.0013590985909104347, -0.030036073178052902, -0.0037788976915180683, -0.02089756168425083, 0.022511832416057587, -0.023081915453076363, 0.025290127843618393, -0.049651190638542175, -0.02357865869998932, 0.009193303063511848, 0.030962040647864342, -0.06483620405197144, -0.0003848263877443969, 0.03540770336985588, -0.013402202166616917, 0.059096064418554306, 0.04247473180294037, -0.018893230706453323, -0.02305782213807106, -0.0354757197201252, 0.0011962774442508817, 0.03402051702141762, 0.012956984341144562, 0.02832205221056938, 0.014104550704360008, -0.06574162095785141, 0.02239256352186203, 0.022997776046395302, 0.030270783230662346, 0.03772667795419693, -0.009851210750639439, -0.014244389720261097, -0.028562868013978004, -0.034801267087459564, 0.04858532175421715, -0.002177418442443013, 0.04342649132013321, 0.015827307477593422, 0.046938613057136536, 0.027483055368065834, -0.01982211507856846, 0.02637404389679432, 0.03814297914505005, 0.011601783335208893, 0.01770184189081192, -0.04594092071056366, -0.02951974980533123, -0.019770940765738487, -0.01112275943160057, 0.06096247583627701, -0.02223515510559082, -0.027661433443427086, -0.02156352624297142, 0.006952621974050999, 0.0036990195512771606, -0.013387349434196949, -0.02707642875611782, 0.03952043876051903, 0.026380451396107674, 0.004574401304125786, -0.031118789687752724, 0.0037160383071750402, 0.04958396777510643, 0.017730575054883957, 0.0017892534378916025, 0.0013933510053902864, -0.07636670023202896, -0.013662968762218952, 0.00905472133308649, 0.015983009710907936, 0.006957433186471462, 0.030837493017315865, -0.053386490792036057, -0.02638844959437847, 0.0034264223650097847, -0.01815478689968586, 0.037961967289447784, -0.027479758486151695, 0.031321726739406586, -0.028202548623085022, -0.00984429381787777, -0.015464665368199348, -0.002439985517412424, 0.012033524923026562, 0.02845660038292408, -0.020057229325175285, -0.00014354067388921976, -0.05293045938014984, -0.013315564021468163, 0.02186221070587635, 0.05293305963277817, -0.008763323538005352, 0.00768240774050355, -0.005067566875368357, 0.020874151960015297, 0.005716630257666111, -0.07398062944412231, 0.001895241322927177, -0.02005237527191639, 0.006038843188434839, 0.06088552996516228, -0.019707025960087776, 0.0033608463127166033, 0.007442292291671038, 0.018104594200849533, 0.022875120863318443, -0.024192258715629578, -0.0421142503619194, 0.042167779058218, 0.014408753253519535, -0.02920246496796608, 0.07010767608880997, 0.030467741191387177, -0.03054182603955269, 0.022735469043254852, -0.01837182603776455, 0.015138523653149605, -0.051655665040016174, 0.008180979639291763, -0.03787030279636383, -0.019834714010357857, -0.02898973971605301, 0.04558829590678215, -0.01367168314754963, 0.029763787984848022, -0.04384010657668114, -0.0008845572010613978, 0.009576093405485153, 0.03398561850190163, -0.014637239277362823, -0.006713682319968939, 0.012084049172699451, 0.013316121883690357, -0.023782970383763313, -0.006217139307409525, 0.02537813037633896, -0.03236555680632591, -0.03854740038514137, 0.02619520016014576, -0.0034780835267156363, -0.008235370740294456, -0.022049499675631523, 0.016505446285009384, -0.005438813008368015, -0.001827125670388341, 0.013409601524472237, 0.01143050380051136, -0.0020700276363641024, 0.019975589588284492, -0.02609848789870739, 0.01333104632794857, -0.03082406520843506, -0.04435044154524803, 0.07185810804367065, -0.02897978201508522, 0.03402966260910034, 0.022523196414113045, -0.009453379549086094, -0.06886720657348633, -0.06288916617631912, 0.012595257721841335, -0.009740911424160004, -0.005811893381178379, -0.009523853659629822, 0.0049184649251401424, -0.02782379277050495, -0.010379644110798836, 0.0017298295861110091, 0.04656456410884857, -0.004974558018147945, -0.02048320509493351, 0.009362750686705112, 0.0353587381541729, 0.057705823332071304, -0.0017274841666221619, 0.001952613703906536, 0.016602925956249237, -0.04151030629873276, -0.0639135092496872, -0.0023582002613693476, 0.04333720728754997, -0.05500498786568642, -0.008189470507204533, -0.010266488417983055, -0.040783435106277466, 0.05685168504714966, -0.038248565047979355, -0.0032736854627728462, -0.005547479726374149, 0.04711579158902168, 0.029035989195108414, -0.0038703058380633593, 0.04212047532200813, -0.0025506513193249702, -0.013490156270563602, 0.017610730603337288, -0.043382540345191956, -0.05167371779680252, -0.03218099847435951, 0.04443616047501564, -0.026704659685492516, -0.03822847828269005, 0.025455614551901817, 0.07424572855234146, 0.016502616927027702, -0.008246282115578651, -0.00011566763714654371, -0.025847529992461205, 0.015667526051402092, 0.001331983250565827, 0.00588369881734252, 0.022486628964543343, 0.017122510820627213, -0.031920913606882095, -0.003996616695076227, -0.03384817764163017, 0.0027276587206870317, 0.052951306104660034, -0.02258751168847084, 0.06037730351090431, -0.013829339295625687, 0.02497340738773346, -0.023708779364824295, -0.03875941410660744, 0.003179258434101939, -0.034642841666936874, -0.017628397792577744, 0.04912395402789116, -0.03711843118071556, 0.024766268208622932, -0.005202613305300474, 0.0355004146695137, 0.027488524094223976, -0.002833940088748932, 0.02923695370554924, 0.01954660937190056, 0.001427204697392881, 0.007515199016779661, -0.03962192311882973, 0.04153946042060852, -0.01629357598721981, 0.013935347087681293, 0.008630071766674519, -0.04033975675702095, 0.022863762453198433, 0.008977435529232025, 0.00635457644239068, -0.05718875303864479, -0.01123136468231678, -0.006698806770145893, 0.026548264548182487, 0.016890201717615128, -0.0074161081574857235, 0.06353776156902313, 0.047473300248384476, 0.02871190756559372, 0.016028286889195442, 0.02003205195069313, 0.018881119787693024, -0.04628147929906845, 0.004877839703112841, -0.004294839221984148, -0.007305123843252659, 0.041385717689991, -0.025635940954089165, -0.03050142340362072, -0.0053936270996928215, -0.012075756676495075, 0.03331642225384712, -0.008975421078503132, -0.02069857157766819, -0.024334605783224106, 0.061549775302410126, 0.02482285164296627, 0.035852622240781784, -0.007306170184165239, 0.013134046457707882, 0.12501804530620575, 0.0359620563685894, 0.009183509275317192, -0.08279997110366821, -0.026825707405805588, 0.005422169808298349, -0.004980368074029684, -0.046542827039957047, 0.027332788333296776, 0.0448526069521904, 0.004145512357354164, 0.019368574023246765, 0.08910036832094193, 0.012597811408340931, -0.006845320109277964, 0.06854304671287537, -0.014808743260800838, -0.027262885123491287, -0.008425558917224407, 0.016464369371533394, 0.01618294045329094, -0.002755708759650588, -0.05048741027712822, 0.05288879945874214, -0.0016988689312711358, -0.00017375742027070373, 0.012744697742164135, -0.039568666368722916, 0.01929520256817341, -0.022604184225201607, -0.00950675830245018, 0.025681691244244576, 0.013380225747823715, 0.020918454974889755, -0.013146501034498215, -0.018682241439819336, -0.005791009869426489, -0.02864951640367508, 0.037237498909235, -0.010671055875718594, 0.0369391031563282, -0.027193106710910797, 0.016315197572112083, -0.003975448664277792, -0.023852577432990074, -0.019516512751579285, -0.017652926966547966, 0.03800918161869049, 0.012740934267640114, -0.010205570608377457, -0.03761976957321167, 0.011630893684923649, -0.01943252794444561, -0.04351463541388512, 0.017470628023147583, -0.02461744099855423, 0.011985418386757374, -0.05573563277721405, -0.028803015127778053, -0.02780848555266857, -0.009728247299790382, 0.02752985619008541, 0.02016304060816765, 0.022324351593852043, -0.0023474660702049732, -0.033330585807561874, -0.0000399890159314964, 0.04833386838436127, -0.022337056696414948, -0.004374345298856497, 0.0012601008638739586, -0.0033349075820297003, -0.02316654473543167, -0.01666826382279396, -0.01720847375690937, -0.03571731224656105, 0.041373904794454575, 0.029748937115073204, 0.015402544289827347, 0.014870434068143368, -0.045952413231134415, -0.0038404802326112986, -0.028452126309275627, 0.001438085688278079, -0.03100019134581089, -0.06860128790140152, -0.008908077143132687, 0.016429245471954346, 0.012168907560408115, -0.0011268430389463902, -0.023212846368551254, 0.05280928313732147, 0.025237010791897774, -0.0185905322432518, 0.009129977785050869, 0.0032541039399802685, -0.0294216126203537, 0.014655443839728832, -0.012219029478728771, 0.028746023774147034, -0.021576225757598877, 0.008327516727149487, -0.007841234095394611, 0.020259009674191475, -0.011483822949230671, -0.027867212891578674, -0.0026500436943024397, -0.017342040315270424, 0.018726535141468048, -0.01792202703654766, 0.010299681685864925, -0.025668108835816383, 0.0071975975297391415, 0.0025996090844273567, 0.00012734481424558908, -0.002286746399477124, 0.0547245517373085, -0.022475892677903175, 0.023718765005469322, 0.005549205467104912, 0.02132684737443924, -0.031016292050480843, -0.0022769144270569086, -0.036562658846378326, 0.013516966253519058, -0.0298120379447937, -0.024779051542282104, -0.013614551164209843, 0.0061884475871920586, -0.005158805754035711, -0.014120473526418209, 0.036188311874866486, 0.02348501794040203, 0.0023371735587716103, -0.0027782274410128593, 0.036423828452825546, -0.03279358148574829, 0.02970214933156967, -0.009263704530894756, -0.07369618117809296, 0.05286514759063721, -0.0468144491314888, -0.04044601321220398, 0.0035198084078729153, 0.005556406918913126, 0.02195635810494423, 0.01335185021162033, -0.02572520077228546, -0.05037064850330353, 0.06261997669935226, 0.001864045625552535, -0.0017149543855339289, 0.006477852817624807, 0.004342232830822468, 0.021069174632430077, 0.04141659662127495, -0.002582018729299307, 0.021976705640554428, -0.007509496062994003, 0.0050863241776824, 0.06011292338371277, -0.0062379115261137486, -0.02363656461238861, 0.019828658550977707, -0.032403990626335144, 0.019881874322891235, 0.004238849505782127, 0.022392792627215385, -0.013565447181463242, 0.032650094479322433, -0.0037263953126966953, -0.004085349850356579, -0.046452075242996216, -0.00980181060731411, -0.053824521601200104, 0.01047846395522356, 0.018481232225894928, -0.010644380934536457, 0.027910271659493446, -0.04122091829776764, -0.02480538748204708, 0.026828961446881294, -0.05419657379388809, -0.0027921649161726236, -0.0206290390342474, -0.02687033824622631, -0.02344859391450882, -0.042929768562316895, -0.018827753141522408, 0.03450867161154747, 0.05815420299768448, 0.03691278398036957, 0.04828307032585144, 0.006959781516343355, -0.0313771553337574, 0.005958328954875469, -0.030349181964993477, 0.020756550133228302, 0.0025508005637675524, -0.02829393744468689, 0.056456346064805984, -0.011731430888175964, -0.050650350749492645, 0.047760218381881714, -0.04664158448576927, -0.038027357310056686, -0.004800414200872183, 0.037481535226106644, 0.0047234478406608105, 0.02398255281150341, 0.010936890728771687, -0.00021905959874857217, 0.0345236212015152, 0.008473934605717659, 0.019541950896382332, 0.03835134580731392, -0.016531677916646004, 0.03379658982157707, 0.027556899935007095, -0.02314021997153759, -0.06447365880012512, -0.014221773482859135, -0.0042317272163927555, -0.021825311705470085, -0.01976906694471836, 0.02436131238937378, 0.01151044387370348, -0.04045481234788895, 0.05623828247189522, 0.04180285707116127, 0.0017488020239397883, 0.046020396053791046, 0.05749686807394028, -0.02489509806036949, -0.016466643661260605, 0.03631136193871498, -0.04006699472665787, 0.022282078862190247, 0.016586795449256897, -0.031758736819028854, -0.015594075433909893, -0.026319101452827454, -0.002460151445120573, 0.013124451972544193, -0.047812625765800476, -0.006315694656223059, -0.034682150930166245, 0.05595571547746658, -0.035596780478954315, 0.014687788672745228, 0.02554214559495449, -0.061695560812950134, -0.009278258308768272, -0.07042814046144485, 0.019577765837311745, -0.027675002813339233, -0.029437722638249397, -0.00823068618774414, -0.019403887912631035, -0.03656898811459541, 0.003313596360385418, 0.036787569522857666, 0.02250863052904606, -0.010195189155638218, 0.022685833275318146, 0.016121067106723785, 0.025339584797620773, 0.01670132204890251, 0.03246259316802025, -0.025567088276147842, 0.004156944341957569, 0.03673575818538666, -0.04247284680604935, 0.019228428602218628, 0.03848377987742424, -0.011602436192333698, -0.01350568700581789, 0.008145143277943134, 0.025602299720048904, -0.018239544704556465, 0.05596143379807472, 0.005670112557709217, -0.0005137817352078855, 0.06750643253326416, -0.0029731690883636475, -0.007215948309749365, 0.002841571345925331, -0.0072873360477387905, -0.06843739748001099, 0.040945135056972504, 0.00876490119844675, -0.030903657898306847, -0.01624223403632641, 0.03528546169400215, 0.037737514823675156, -0.022240767255425453, -0.035346005111932755, 0.014693008735775948, 0.002860859502106905, -0.0034648433793336153, 0.05312597006559372, 0.011766214855015278, 0.022557515650987625, 0.04705103859305382, 0.040849268436431885, -0.016529230400919914, 0.03250233083963394, 0.00692767184227705, 0.04154716432094574, 0.030421826988458633, -0.005203782580792904, -0.006514050532132387, -0.0018745862180367112, -0.020612984895706177, 0.023329295217990875, -0.030508574098348618, 0.038056742399930954, -0.0027212148997932673, -0.03336378186941147, 0.006088526453822851, -0.022348852828145027, 0.008832942694425583, 0.009370149113237858, 0.0188978910446167, 0.09746843576431274, -0.04479584842920303, 0.03202904760837555, 0.016804831102490425, -0.004368345253169537, -0.03146994858980179, 0.012997393496334553, -0.021070212125778198, 0.02132444456219673, -0.012940291315317154, -0.019472429528832436, -0.0023838237393647432, -0.0007378425798378885, 0.028520900756120682, -0.034270964562892914, 0.013367312960326672, 0.004453074187040329, -0.04316936433315277, -0.000979065429419279, -0.024071985855698586, -0.07759938389062881, -0.04406426474452019, 0.020549079403281212, 0.011227278038859367, 0.010370532050728798, -0.005133261438459158, -0.01637735404074192, -0.0292721726000309, 0.04528428241610527, -0.06785773485898972, -0.021035173907876015, -0.011034074239432812, 0.008505821228027344, -0.014723767526447773, -0.022671792656183243 ]
<p>Suppose I have two sets $X$ and $Y$ and a joint probability distribution over these sets $p(x,y)$. Let $p(x)$ and $p(y)$ denote the marginal distributions over $X$ and $Y$ respectively. </p> <p>The mutual information between $X$ and $Y$ is defined to be: $$I(X; Y) = \sum_{x,y}p(x,y)\cdot\log\left(\frac{p(x,y)}{p(x)p(y)}\right)$$</p> <p>i.e. it is the average value of the pointwise mutual information pmi$(x,y) \equiv \log\left(\frac{p(x,y)}{p(x)p(y)}\right)$.</p> <p>Suppose I know upper and lower bounds on pmi$(x,y)$: i.e. I know that for all $x,y$ the following holds: $$-k \leq \log\left(\frac{p(x,y)}{p(x)p(y)}\right) \leq k$$</p> <p>What upper bound does this imply on $I(X; Y)$. Of course it implies $I(X; Y) \leq k$, but I would like a tighter bound if possible. This seems plausible to me because p defines a probability distribution, and pmi$(x,y)$ cannot take its maximum value (or even be non-negative) for every value of $x$ and $y$. </p>
36,199
[ -0.02496308833360672, -0.015511398203670979, 0.009541499428451061, -0.01746264658868313, -0.017222309485077858, 0.03733699768781662, -0.006736357230693102, -0.019528478384017944, 0.030282724648714066, -0.038556989282369614, 0.037202510982751846, 0.06078527495265007, 0.04788767918944359, 0.0527346208691597, 0.013984222896397114, 0.005236679222434759, -0.05591302737593651, 0.018920907750725746, 0.009013894014060497, -0.019869768992066383, -0.0020295169670134783, 0.04639657586812973, 0.06954768300056458, 0.0040982267819345, -0.03273280709981918, 0.041386477649211884, 0.01747613027691841, -0.014666014350950718, 0.016923733055591583, 0.08662393689155579, -0.021275363862514496, -0.02131948620080948, 0.009424746967852116, 0.0730452612042427, 0.030586423352360725, -0.01159008126705885, -0.054505567997694016, -0.011128120124340057, 0.0014904311392456293, 0.003022058168426156, -0.031879521906375885, -0.015706295147538185, 0.031179310753941536, 0.010106596164405346, -0.005350825376808643, 0.008901484310626984, 0.002355039119720459, -0.05343528091907501, -0.01350398175418377, -0.04571257159113884, 0.06746190041303635, -0.0032723157200962305, 0.009970445185899734, 0.035688772797584534, -0.0008129059569910169, -0.004170207306742668, 0.05851444602012634, 0.0874718427658081, 0.013881305232644081, -0.05254266783595085, -0.03955243155360222, -0.04225398227572441, 0.025124013423919678, 0.0038564640562981367, -0.04505295306444168, 0.03552869334816933, -0.015673773363232613, -0.01882467232644558, 0.010736888274550438, -0.0018947850912809372, -0.022487567737698555, 0.05348324775695801, 0.0515735000371933, -0.02349187061190605, 0.01871844194829464, -0.017273442819714546, 0.019186757504940033, 0.04046129062771797, 0.007469849195331335, 0.048616521060466766, 0.014815518632531166, 0.005215037148445845, 0.02718193084001541, 0.06268326938152313, 0.013262697495520115, 0.001381046837195754, 0.10591382533311844, -0.02840944193303585, -0.00258602830581367, -0.0037819459103047848, -0.01746896095573902, -0.00851665623486042, 0.004889478906989098, -0.03879369795322418, -0.040898725390434265, 0.02453978918492794, -0.04079451784491539, 0.017762959003448486, -0.019526474177837372, -0.039303008466959, -0.017265573143959045, -0.04049455001950264, -0.012799132615327835, 0.05784175917506218, 0.008586220443248749, 0.009201524779200554, -0.05144083872437477, 0.007819981314241886, -0.01592627726495266, -0.012804573401808739, -0.0004931105067953467, 0.0011321622878313065, -0.0045655532740056515, 0.009193248115479946, 0.005874473135918379, 0.0031244626734405756, -0.0048372335731983185, -0.0200539268553257, 0.027284672483801842, 0.07118157297372818, 0.06370814144611359, -0.0020093924831598997, 0.013173053972423077, -0.03954450041055679, -0.0683712586760521, 0.03804400563240051, 0.03274426609277725, -0.0161519143730402, -0.062303561717271805, 0.034293338656425476, 0.0001166434958577156, 0.027358096092939377, 0.031084002926945686, -0.010330356657505035, 0.01282681617885828, 0.0076115988194942474, -0.06537766754627228, -0.02544553577899933, 0.06034895405173302, 0.021186115220189095, 0.00007286292384378612, -0.057076431810855865, -0.01306905411183834, 0.043668393045663834, 0.014958713203668594, -0.015910886228084564, 0.037489548325538635, -0.015363294631242752, 0.006654731463640928, 0.039935335516929626, -0.036135315895080566, -0.009672620333731174, -0.032499950379133224, -0.010127853602170944, -0.010273173451423645, -0.06796814501285553, 0.039626482874155045, 0.0609578937292099, -0.030154956504702568, -0.02940908819437027, 0.030732475221157074, -0.009313712827861309, -0.009227666072547436, -0.018813909962773323, 0.0028472726698964834, -0.035629045218229294, 0.05282938852906227, 0.03437021002173424, 0.05573368817567825, 0.012888467870652676, 0.014624329283833504, -0.006198684684932232, -0.006592859048396349, 0.03555603325366974, 0.05672196298837662, -0.05954115092754364, -0.018008260056376457, -0.022521289065480232, 0.0053371768444776535, 0.038946352899074554, -0.013362708501517773, -0.026421643793582916, -0.07099888473749161, 0.00959580484777689, 0.017977479845285416, 0.0036330947186797857, 0.000848701864015311, -0.02388763800263405, 0.03362821042537689, -0.04104776680469513, -0.018993381410837173, -0.07180741429328918, 0.018554970622062683, 0.019704526290297508, -0.039881568402051926, 0.04393835365772247, 0.019134128466248512, 0.009830184280872345, -0.026642179116606712, -0.028044873848557472, -0.02342834137380123, -0.01668444275856018, 0.02720467373728752, -0.03483906760811806, 0.007482724264264107, 0.02937927469611168, 0.03335712105035782, -0.027014389634132385, 0.04697701707482338, -0.025676731020212173, -0.07669384777545929, 0.017706185579299927, 0.0005289960536174476, 0.01005509216338396, 0.022785764187574387, -0.030870379880070686, 0.013638460077345371, 0.0016428908566012979, 0.021870551630854607, -0.020844716578722, -0.057377029210329056, 0.06330519169569016, 0.056771308183670044, 0.032957594841718674, -0.011623810045421124, -0.001667498261667788, 0.01884111575782299, 0.008444908075034618, -0.03972805291414261, -0.02548082545399666, -0.023567983880639076, -0.007286652456969023, 0.017952250316739082, 0.07052150368690491, -0.03952134773135185, 0.03315587341785431, 0.025771787390112877, 0.026927616447210312, 0.03173407167196274, 0.012048417702317238, -0.0010827069636434317, -0.03890388831496239, 0.012743934988975525, 0.03047395683825016, 0.01721486821770668, 0.009927294217050076, 0.0230538472533226, -0.007088897284120321, 0.01722646877169609, -0.02390861324965954, -0.01797158271074295, 0.01702311635017395, -0.008369019255042076, 0.02268395386636257, 0.0012542640324681997, -0.014937708154320717, 0.020521529018878937, -0.01971389725804329, 0.00441855750977993, -0.0336897075176239, 0.014495893381536007, 0.0010334342950955033, -0.010593445971608162, -0.028174955397844315, 0.022162145003676414, 0.016866866499185562, -0.02615494281053543, 0.003260275349020958, 0.014081600122153759, -0.019519515335559845, -0.009468997828662395, 0.009317940101027489, -0.04082790017127991, 0.0021387136075645685, 0.0033722971566021442, 0.012965194880962372, -0.019996847957372665, 0.017546189948916435, -0.025037048384547234, -0.003522812156006694, -0.010981039144098759, -0.0031611586455255747, 0.03450692072510719, -0.011815618723630905, -0.02110445499420166, -0.02257774956524372, -0.00008551902283215895, -0.025897134095430374, 0.001958378590643406, -0.03595110401511192, 0.0013163051335141063, -0.027601182460784912, -0.020632067695260048, -0.07027856260538101, 0.008366993628442287, -0.018952032551169395, 0.038619380444288254, -0.018941804766654968, -0.018976274877786636, 0.01055017951875925, -0.0003117781598120928, -0.04085825756192207, -0.003998474683612585, -0.01430630311369896, -0.04143345728516579, -0.04311702027916908, -0.005938450340181589, 0.018698692321777344, -0.0043391515500843525, -0.02294105477631092, 0.027476293966174126, -0.012279805727303028, -0.05740759149193764, -0.07845281064510345, -0.08749168366193771, 0.0455864779651165, 0.008887702599167824, 0.03598688170313835, -0.0059526227414608, -0.035039838403463364, 0.04867653548717499, 0.023853469640016556, -0.0030898009426891804, -0.024547114968299866, -0.004128867294639349, 0.01955016888678074, 0.034396734088659286, 0.006069360766559839, -0.0018404123838990927, -0.003849850269034505, 0.07303536683320999, 0.06168846786022186, -0.0038046047557145357, 0.01849474385380745, -0.011638716794550419, -0.0005882319528609514, 0.01154835894703865, 0.006980150938034058, -0.023472290486097336, 0.024747567251324654, 0.052600085735321045, -0.022788850590586662, 0.0009169846889562905, 0.012162884697318077, 0.01411654707044363, 0.007059659343212843, -0.013835793361067772, 0.027121182531118393, -0.029692767187952995, 0.017027122899889946, -0.026672307401895523, 0.042239539325237274, 0.008765519596636295, -0.03724084794521332, -0.017390038818120956, 0.028114737942814827, 0.03132358565926552, -0.007303252350538969, 0.015270465984940529, 0.04870475083589554, 0.0019370762165635824, -0.028348905965685844, 0.0017072664340958, -0.034349583089351654, -0.009361090138554573, 0.009586104191839695, -0.028233788907527924, -0.02462831139564514, -0.014030227437615395, 0.015535986050963402, -0.0018868636107072234, -0.02934843860566616, -0.017327910289168358, 0.01120763923972845, -0.05508687347173691, -0.02022448740899563, -0.022206392139196396, 0.02720961906015873, 0.029823649674654007, 0.039887696504592896, 0.016616124659776688, -0.026706287637352943, 0.006957779638469219, -0.004362671170383692, -0.08455383032560349, -0.00465808343142271, -0.03338000550866127, 0.014527438208460808, 0.007824982516467571, -0.02761182375252247, 0.048575058579444885, -0.036483921110630035, 0.020522385835647583, -0.00582844577729702, 0.05509880930185318, -0.05409429594874382, -0.00498870899900794, -0.03371308371424675, -0.02390666864812374, 0.008305503986775875, 0.029466940090060234, 0.014022375456988811, 0.007747675757855177, 0.0718698650598526, 0.009181294590234756, -0.020856445655226707, 0.002953103743493557, -0.010873873718082905, 0.01126774214208126, 0.00606275862082839, 0.00400316109880805, 0.0078507075086236, 0.0125421192497015, 0.0164883341640234, 0.007907641120254993, -0.0011772812576964498, 0.058841414749622345, 0.03870402276515961, -0.06341934949159622, 0.017241220921278, -0.01857421174645424, -0.04419604316353798, -0.01071154698729515, 0.05476485192775726, -0.0010106780100613832, 0.010754447430372238, 0.04468410089612007, 0.02129817195236683, -0.035635389387607574, 0.018816685304045677, 0.08223192393779755, -0.013674566522240639, -0.011154823005199432, 0.005154015962034464, -0.004497724585235119, -0.028123246505856514, 0.01129401195794344, 0.02862333133816719, -0.007687645498663187, 0.006116673815995455, -0.022194746881723404, 0.03282749652862549, -0.01001849677413702, -0.02682899311184883, 0.003739362582564354, -0.004202716983854771, 0.012729472480714321, 0.010031802579760551, -0.002237907610833645, 0.01937265321612358, 0.037276118993759155, 0.019666941836476326, 0.007836704142391682, -0.001927581150084734, -0.024404402822256088, -0.007895849645137787, 0.06671460717916489, 0.04694848135113716, 0.0017436431953683496, 0.026431415230035782, -0.03513212502002716, -0.010972443968057632, 0.03923596814274788, 0.0031208612490445375, 0.020622290670871735, -0.01922827959060669, -0.015264548361301422, -0.020472340285778046, -0.054161325097084045, -0.047731805592775345, -0.011500110849738121, 0.023851878941059113, 0.042667895555496216, -0.0027724336832761765, -0.0036516564432531595, -0.05356737971305847, 0.01525905355811119, 0.021276498213410378, 0.0709652230143547, -0.0015551169635728002, -0.00353742903098464, -0.0024648963008075953, 0.01889803260564804, 0.0027892435900866985, -0.0784166157245636, 0.06394652277231216, -0.016162550076842308, -0.007578909397125244, 0.02476596273481846, -0.02108481340110302, -0.024637514725327492, 0.04977588728070259, 0.02327135019004345, -0.026804475113749504, 0.015865912660956383, -0.01851624995470047, 0.0377681739628315, 0.04789822921156883, 0.004332901909947395, 0.03784791752696037, -0.009789956733584404, -0.023702679201960564, -0.0004407305095810443, -0.0006690376903861761, 0.02982768788933754, -0.03777638077735901, 0.013310759328305721, -0.012464839033782482, 0.01044969167560339, -0.023108264431357384, 0.022283092141151428, -0.01247450988739729, 0.006014769431203604, -0.020984837785363197, 0.0003018279676325619, -0.05617577210068703, -0.0016913851723074913, 0.02137075923383236, 0.010958871804177761, -0.009795348159968853, 0.03850385174155235, 0.0027821031399071217, 0.000280069827567786, 0.015664562582969666, -0.010247090831398964, -0.005485005676746368, 0.007452667225152254, -0.007266605272889137, 0.03265346214175224, -0.06685154885053635, -0.015036609023809433, -0.0056634265929460526, 0.022236481308937073, 0.019205225631594658, 0.01927446946501732, 0.0028488116804510355, 0.04479670897126198, -0.001508018933236599, 0.016119547188282013, 0.045620568096637726, -0.01710457354784012, 0.05744003504514694, -0.03214093670248985, 0.0239543654024601, -0.02841494232416153, -0.006676952354609966, -0.050749536603689194, -0.009831811301410198, 0.021377701312303543, 0.018366334959864616, -0.022081220522522926, -0.03707413375377655, 0.020452512428164482, -0.009372521191835403, -0.017324328422546387, -0.009228039532899857, 0.05731475353240967, 0.0031622007954865694, -0.019978588446974754, -0.028269605711102486, -0.006780599243938923, 0.034136246889829636, -0.038149796426296234, 0.003344789380207658, 0.031087486073374748, -0.013073595240712166, -0.006258228328078985, -0.019376030191779137, 0.00659561762586236, -0.01178998313844204, -0.013279890641570091, 0.005084267817437649, -0.03172707557678223, 0.02176777273416519, -0.01731088012456894, -0.018963662907481194, -0.007195199839770794, 0.004803748801350594, -0.039690203964710236, 0.03592430427670479, -0.019331272691488266, -0.025251487269997597, -0.00013024333748035133, -0.031195783987641335, 0.022914214059710503, 0.004232595209032297, -0.011632569134235382, 0.028098993003368378, -0.002801033901050687, -0.0036999389994889498, -0.015983393415808678, 0.06318236887454987, -0.006622040644288063, 0.00849845353513956, -0.005668354220688343, -0.0069745793007314205, 0.05089998617768288, -0.017074421048164368, -0.009976252913475037, 0.013480829074978828, 0.012791411951184273, -0.033762093633413315, 0.004808512516319752, -0.055564865469932556, -0.0030194208957254887, 0.05778702348470688, -0.02834395319223404, 0.08073928952217102, -0.0003095165593549609, -0.0005168961361050606, -0.022633913904428482, -0.010158193297684193, 0.0004912404110655189, 0.016428006812930107, 0.00803607888519764, 0.03646988049149513, -0.0368121936917305, -0.018689054995775223, 0.028400899842381477, 0.025354864075779915, 0.000533347309101373, -0.012383675202727318, -0.014283761382102966, 0.002385031199082732, 0.026880305260419846, -0.06034477800130844, -0.04164493829011917, 0.025266095995903015, -0.07445953041315079, -0.005212282296270132, -0.024023450911045074, -0.030230870470404625, 0.03115960769355297, 0.032286256551742554, 0.006510572507977486, -0.035667482763528824, -0.03448927029967308, -0.03318814933300018, -0.003311745123937726, 0.0034258821979165077, 0.013884419575333595, 0.034275565296411514, -0.01812809146940708, -0.011500848457217216, -0.015965208411216736, 0.01386310439556837, -0.023365916684269905, -0.05678064748644829, -0.03641793504357338, -0.019436832517385483, -0.03797374665737152, 0.0018843328580260277, 0.05077829211950302, -0.014818540774285793, 0.03605864197015762, -0.022643227130174637, 0.012806758284568787, 0.009798293001949787, 0.010430075228214264, -0.016478078439831734, 0.08293233066797256, 0.01735742762684822, 0.05326730012893677, 0.00915401428937912, -0.02818998321890831, 0.11434480547904968, 0.04779698699712753, 0.02376907877624035, -0.04876353591680527, 0.048748139292001724, 0.0071808877401053905, -0.04040860757231712, -0.05816983804106712, 0.03552248701453209, 0.04644511640071869, -0.002773913089185953, 0.02803783491253853, 0.04668968915939331, 0.011016188189387321, -0.0211104117333889, 0.036500390619039536, -0.06157400831580162, -0.0008568973280489445, 0.03226327523589134, 0.008019985631108284, -0.01193759124726057, -0.019900763407349586, -0.0292179174721241, -0.005218935199081898, -0.026966864243149757, 0.012838714756071568, -0.002945100190117955, -0.030269773676991463, 0.04116763174533844, -0.021595768630504608, -0.006541118025779724, -0.0034104944206774235, 0.01621606945991516, -0.030976591631770134, 0.02663402445614338, 0.002154276240617037, 0.035230450332164764, 0.0008200708543881774, -0.019649304449558258, 0.023425981402397156, -0.020656349137425423, 0.011614568531513214, 0.024749722331762314, 0.0022217342630028725, -0.051795486360788345, -0.04017305001616478, -0.03988946974277496, 0.042144130915403366, -0.032371778041124344, 0.01769537664949894, 0.005495548713952303, -0.040047816932201385, -0.02544592320919037, -0.01754145883023739, -0.01150617003440857, 0.047280024737119675, 0.05158349871635437, -0.03288422152400017, 0.015228981152176857, -0.013551156967878342, 0.039803579449653625, -0.011992150917649269, 0.051276031881570816, -0.02322355844080448, -0.0339830107986927, -0.016966257244348526, 0.009560823440551758, 0.04733492061495781, 0.025716552510857582, 0.012559803202748299, -0.01096186414361, -0.02709650993347168, -0.01836734637618065, -0.05896475166082382, -0.02139716036617756, -0.03073842078447342, 0.02677885629236698, 0.015853485092520714, -0.014265134930610657, -0.019375769421458244, -0.03894933685660362, -0.020787419751286507, -0.019249826669692993, 0.01563502661883831, -0.037256933748722076, 0.01975598931312561, 0.04033667966723442, 0.06667134910821915, 0.011525342240929604, 0.002953228307887912, -0.007718279957771301, 0.06291642785072327, 0.021506991237401962, -0.019536186009645462, -0.001152843818999827, -0.0027780041564255953, -0.06104784831404686, 0.010563988238573074, 0.003253225004300475, 0.049955982714891434, 0.03338681906461716, 0.03477543592453003, 0.04417974501848221, 0.014372862875461578, -0.01615198142826557, -0.005909386090934277, 0.02767728827893734, -0.009533822536468506, -0.02124469168484211, 0.019006580114364624, 0.021358631551265717, -0.004535510204732418, -0.0008867805590853095, 0.005344599485397339, -0.009477159939706326, 0.047664158046245575, -0.023708678781986237, -0.008822029456496239, 0.0043861824087798595, -0.002632042858749628, 0.024751834571361542, -0.0006350980838760734, 0.0061287046410143375, -0.031621865928173065, 0.005446608178317547, -0.013356429524719715, 0.013776925392448902, -0.0066971927881240845, -0.007156009785830975, -0.028382038697600365, -0.025223946198821068, 0.03151152655482292, 0.02784395031630993, 0.0013643968850374222, -0.021638330072164536, 0.02288392372429371, 0.0019844204653054476, 0.0752171128988266, -0.0676906481385231, -0.032811328768730164, 0.07332202047109604, -0.045125920325517654, -0.043027590960264206, 0.008264086209237576, -0.012797756120562553, 0.048445459455251694, 0.018884647637605667, 0.003339483169838786, -0.07638867199420929, 0.03619896620512009, -0.000494833046104759, 0.017165230587124825, 0.02294992469251156, 0.03397390618920326, 0.0023079845122992992, 0.017448386177420616, 0.009554658085107803, -0.02721935510635376, -0.010454853065311909, -0.011061993427574635, 0.0396575853228569, -0.0033279189374297857, -0.007996001280844212, 0.01939801685512066, 0.01766219362616539, 0.04195868968963623, -0.015236052684485912, -0.031882572919130325, 0.06294313818216324, 0.024818986654281616, -0.027970798313617706, 0.030758697539567947, 0.005021136719733477, -0.010088189505040646, -0.08535069972276688, 0.005341303534805775, 0.005408327095210552, 0.02985485829412937, 0.044647544622421265, -0.05627230927348137, 0.011591318063437939, 0.027170170098543167, -0.07152791321277618, 0.03963519632816315, 0.019262533634901047, -0.00787083525210619, -0.035754431039094925, 0.04160069301724434, -0.04618325084447861, 0.036819662898778915, 0.020409144461154938, 0.04220270738005638, 0.03182138130068779, 0.03812791779637337, -0.01673724502325058, -0.03722294792532921, -0.037024758756160736, -0.01095989067107439, -0.026548532769083977, -0.052976444363594055, 0.06668989360332489, -0.027419010177254677, -0.05262237787246704, 0.013923414051532745, 0.0031790705397725105, -0.003178902668878436, -0.012730272486805916, 0.058067530393600464, 0.0322362445294857, 0.029839133843779564, 0.01909797638654709, -0.0029195582028478384, 0.02116554230451584, 0.007019042503088713, -0.009271475486457348, 0.014826701022684574, -0.017523957416415215, -0.00499693350866437, 0.025359515100717545, 0.007304789032787085, -0.02062166854739189, 0.03208322077989578, -0.014428017660975456, -0.050548698753118515, -0.011291006579995155, 0.008482747711241245, 0.004490922670811415, -0.0601651631295681, 0.03688809648156166, -0.01450360007584095, -0.017299015074968338, 0.021975252777338028, 0.028197653591632843, -0.020804502069950104, -0.022347381338477135, -0.009455708786845207, -0.038657836616039276, 0.020501676946878433, 0.009523688815534115, 0.017184657976031303, -0.0821341946721077, -0.0038839855697005987, -0.009052160196006298, -0.0013544814428314567, -0.01576390117406845, -0.02797137014567852, -0.09159396588802338, 0.007100649178028107, -0.025155741721391678, 0.021081412211060524, 0.002340336563065648, 0.01005413569509983, -0.029127072542905807, -0.07851451635360718, 0.021931802853941917, 0.018056612461805344, 0.033233121037483215, -0.03804101049900055, -0.042155198752880096, -0.00671181408688426, -0.027672767639160156, 0.07167286425828934, 0.005269831977784634, -0.04495743289589882, -0.03028065152466297, 0.043141525238752365, 0.03366818651556969, -0.04920375347137451, 0.02200380712747574, -0.05333846062421799, -0.034684691578149796, 0.0075102513656020164, -0.035603784024715424, 0.0098793376237154, 0.016578620299696922, 0.013882027007639408, -0.01517909113317728, 0.00018047814955934882, 0.004643022082746029, 0.009425774216651917, 0.015689468011260033, -0.0035812791902571917, 0.004830353427678347, 0.04349560663104057, 0.05795571580529213, 0.02853287011384964, -0.0044617983512580395, 0.02063688263297081, -0.05744316056370735, 0.027494678273797035, -0.015118279494345188, -0.04389624297618866, -0.005991121754050255, 0.030545681715011597, 0.02435164526104927, -0.03483597934246063, -0.04079032316803932, 0.031006786972284317, -0.05830051004886627, -0.02579457499086857, 0.061133891344070435, 0.039247412234544754, 0.02623671293258667, 0.020892689004540443, 0.04490385204553604, 0.01174218486994505, -0.02957276813685894, 0.017166631296277046, -0.004835549741983414, 0.03326144069433212, -0.042001333087682724, -0.006803291849792004, 0.023740431293845177, -0.023525791242718697, 0.053561653941869736, -0.006551338359713554, 0.045003775507211685, 0.003663096809759736, -0.03263671323657036, 0.011599508114159107, -0.024749036878347397, -0.003652532584965229, 0.0020118511747568846, 0.005715127568691969, 0.059658199548721313, -0.01858762465417385, 0.005655136425048113, -0.05513127148151398, -0.03342820703983307, -0.01591375656425953, -0.014825333841145039, 0.03288586437702179, 0.026590686291456223, 0.007741077803075314, -0.0168903861194849, 0.00036652912967838347, -0.05242869257926941, 0.025034558027982712, -0.05325745791196823, 0.023550940677523613, 0.008414195850491524, 0.015229607000946999, -0.006909126415848732, -0.030079256743192673, -0.025162747129797935, 0.010151274502277374, 0.00716367969289422, 0.049798280000686646, 0.05234573781490326, 0.012912037782371044, -0.056832656264305115, -0.0023022980894893408, 0.07927004992961884, -0.0759456604719162, 0.056134458631277084, -0.08995448052883148, -0.026088396087288857, 0.035774245858192444, -0.03832739591598511 ]
<p>Suppose I have a $95 \%$ confidence interval for $\mu$ with population variance $\sigma^{2}$ known. It will be of the form $$[\bar{X}-1.96 \sigma/\sqrt{n}, \bar{X}+1.96 \sigma/\sqrt{n}]$$ </p> <p>The statistical interpretation of this is that $95\%$ of the confidence intervals will contain the true mean? I know individually, there is a $50\%$ chance for a confidence interval to contain the mean. But collectively, my above sentence is valid?</p>
36,200
[ 0.0053200917318463326, -0.03512880951166153, -0.008210048079490662, -0.00894052255898714, 0.022560909390449524, 0.0421300046145916, -0.000004999752036383143, -0.028880290687084198, 0.011779328808188438, -0.03233495354652405, 0.09459662437438965, 0.03432663902640343, 0.06748233735561371, -0.0018357984954491258, 0.011301661841571331, 0.01810949482023716, -0.03918253630399704, 0.00526340352371335, -0.01319377962499857, -0.011098256334662437, -0.01121202576905489, 0.05046782270073891, 0.0001691177167231217, -0.03350897133350372, -0.03443076089024544, 0.039520591497421265, 0.018739134073257446, 0.0213821679353714, -0.038221295922994614, 0.07273796945810318, -0.03426362946629524, -0.04632623866200447, 0.015000129118561745, 0.03736351430416107, 0.0029180992860347033, -0.005933141335844994, -0.007079635746777058, -0.023024290800094604, 0.022052539512515068, 0.01976189762353897, -0.06286787241697311, -0.003821372054517269, 0.031031252816319466, 0.021096302196383476, -0.017790865153074265, 0.020369982346892357, -0.013689403422176838, -0.035824380815029144, 0.022137541323900223, 0.021269844844937325, 0.0801827535033226, 0.01636810041964054, 0.06107855588197708, 0.015799671411514282, -0.006376165430992842, 0.007816744036972523, 0.02274439111351967, 0.04387873783707619, -0.011217193678021431, -0.0517197921872139, 0.004724977072328329, -0.046598970890045166, 0.004418146330863237, 0.0017080475809052587, -0.010164037346839905, 0.010634244419634342, -0.025054700672626495, 0.008927250280976295, 0.025197045877575874, 0.0164955947548151, 0.005228647030889988, 0.041242815554142, 0.02300003170967102, 0.008193230256438255, 0.013920570723712444, -0.0397675484418869, 0.02654462493956089, -0.00009006437903735787, 0.031653206795454025, 0.026604726910591125, 0.021294008940458298, 0.005014333408325911, 0.032161690294742584, 0.036945417523384094, 0.008482652716338634, -0.021228983998298645, 0.0843968540430069, -0.0063863894902169704, 0.019044291228055954, 0.01806686632335186, 0.03116031363606453, 0.00006356125231832266, 0.02604011259973049, -0.01407573465257883, -0.035892993211746216, 0.04324454814195633, -0.025593925267457962, 0.04466036707162857, -0.005028668791055679, -0.009541240520775318, -0.01021615695208311, -0.013991612941026688, 0.06723169982433319, 0.05501854047179222, -0.0011734629515558481, -0.03090093843638897, -0.039012834429740906, 0.006630066782236099, -0.013164559379220009, -0.02770075388252735, -0.01376375276595354, 0.04971276596188545, -0.005723657086491585, 0.03318105265498161, 0.06530245393514633, 0.030424488708376884, 0.010810849256813526, -0.04875488579273224, 0.025427423417568207, 0.05460046976804733, 0.02662535198032856, -0.001215113210491836, 0.0431843101978302, -0.015601515769958496, -0.06171268969774246, 0.04591990262269974, 0.01824144646525383, -0.00363318994641304, -0.054411064833402634, 0.0274644922465086, 0.0031754367519170046, -0.007487428840249777, 0.01976226270198822, 0.04691970720887184, 0.009609955362975597, -0.04168584197759628, -0.08525653183460236, -0.05267160013318062, 0.011559543199837208, -0.003840638091787696, -0.0015384326688945293, -0.08160517364740372, -0.011002739891409874, 0.048195306211709976, 0.04853907972574234, 0.0007832425180822611, 0.025418413802981377, -0.010642144829034805, 0.040160395205020905, 0.02457270957529545, -0.023210540413856506, -0.013949348591268063, -0.014287962578237057, -0.030292809009552002, -0.0012258695205673575, -0.06550000607967377, 0.031289007514715195, -0.00009459098509978503, -0.00018143032502848655, -0.05771023780107498, -0.009599459357559681, -0.031661830842494965, -0.003402744187042117, -0.03925490751862526, 0.017337540164589882, 0.00861908309161663, 0.07741554826498032, -0.0030124017503112555, 0.012622949667274952, 0.014665580354630947, 0.019146034494042397, 0.017591442912817, 0.03252619877457619, 0.04810214415192604, 0.08150812983512878, -0.05879849195480347, 0.006804991979151964, -0.020484158769249916, 0.007493030745536089, 0.013783280737698078, -0.01680884137749672, 0.0021320926025509834, -0.029547691345214844, 0.027210308238863945, 0.016522854566574097, 0.04645358771085739, 0.01864391379058361, -0.029311828315258026, 0.025108644738793373, -0.05447937548160553, -0.03217685595154762, -0.08669908344745636, 0.008387522771954536, -0.00918414257466793, -0.018358033150434494, 0.005358151625841856, -0.0037747591268271208, -0.002407377352938056, -0.014907360076904297, -0.03406764194369316, 0.00033742195228114724, 0.0013177708024159074, 0.030942823737859726, -0.05982136353850365, 0.02241845801472664, 0.05011259391903877, 0.046872641891241074, -0.01834542490541935, 0.030797207728028297, -0.03743632137775421, -0.053251251578330994, -0.0013318054843693972, -0.023144925013184547, 0.002984318183735013, 0.011508816853165627, -0.02173871360719204, -0.0016016190638765693, -0.03257139399647713, -0.019786136224865913, 0.032318394631147385, -0.04979366809129715, 0.037967950105667114, 0.042707961052656174, 0.022501206025481224, 0.013081351295113564, 0.019306635484099388, 0.01390963327139616, -0.010372745804488659, -0.0184029471129179, -0.04436585307121277, -0.03899408504366875, 0.007723000831902027, 0.031574737280607224, 0.023861311376094818, -0.019801858812570572, 0.025039391592144966, 0.02883884310722351, 0.030126843601465225, 0.005960386712104082, 0.027052802965044975, 0.03541875630617142, 0.0032920208759605885, -0.015559769235551357, 0.014749486930668354, 0.020450985059142113, 0.04772434011101723, -0.016288524493575096, 0.04625310003757477, 0.022142529487609863, 0.028017690405249596, 0.011251249350607395, 0.036451101303100586, -0.006328302901238203, -0.0016881219344213605, 0.0007529951981268823, -0.020139940083026886, 0.03718196973204613, -0.03887199983000755, 0.008764529600739479, 0.029717229306697845, -0.014686131849884987, 0.014615883119404316, 0.0008326463866978884, -0.015037422999739647, 0.0047350418753921986, 0.05866146832704544, -0.045433346182107925, -0.012733034789562225, 0.01821104809641838, -0.04434040188789368, -0.013902544043958187, -0.05091084539890289, -0.027625733986496925, 0.006792758591473103, 0.0011703906347975135, 0.008548966608941555, 0.006608788855373859, 0.04281528666615486, -0.037396129220724106, -0.049799419939517975, -0.017223728820681572, -0.003649981925264001, 0.001571375411003828, 0.0024436432868242264, -0.07672176510095596, -0.009704331867396832, -0.0010000340407714248, -0.03158562257885933, -0.013557622209191322, -0.02172967419028282, -0.016093073412775993, -0.0009498902945779264, -0.06031418219208717, -0.06818320602178574, -0.01896907202899456, -0.020290503278374672, -0.011859090067446232, -0.0017522622365504503, -0.01832016557455063, 0.04174324870109558, 0.006794253829866648, -0.011121101677417755, 0.04778103157877922, 0.004342266358435154, -0.05653518810868263, -0.055218882858753204, 0.006931008771061897, 0.028942745178937912, -0.00947815552353859, 0.023095808923244476, 0.034147344529628754, -0.0036923473235219717, -0.019848350435495377, -0.05094016343355179, -0.071260467171669, -0.010300571098923683, 0.005270233377814293, 0.022932659834623337, 0.026485348120331764, -0.016328217461705208, 0.09590882062911987, 0.020673513412475586, -0.04748930409550667, 0.016256695613265038, 0.004488341975957155, 0.002913634991273284, -0.027232680469751358, -0.012840552255511284, 0.007224330212920904, -0.0037256923969835043, 0.038925331085920334, 0.03215876221656799, 0.01743515394628048, 0.03389054909348488, 0.030706249177455902, -0.0003992491401731968, -0.03367657586932182, -0.016132777556777, -0.02153254859149456, 0.03768507391214371, -0.007739630993455648, -0.012291357852518559, 0.02454698644578457, -0.020167838782072067, 0.035546254366636276, 0.051501210778951645, -0.05557992681860924, 0.05347210168838501, -0.06679422408342361, 0.0012261465890333056, -0.06710989028215408, 0.0689566507935524, 0.02173413150012493, 0.0018367843003943563, 0.009168644435703754, 0.0025236415676772594, 0.017281364649534225, -0.02794777788221836, -0.012210573069751263, 0.011301927268505096, 0.02964414842426777, 0.0013355357805266976, -0.008054696954786777, 0.010631619952619076, -0.019649216905236244, 0.008888215757906437, -0.012473500333726406, -0.014707403257489204, 0.03166380152106285, 0.05961450934410095, 0.020065024495124817, -0.022745123133063316, -0.03680704906582832, 0.0019345785258337855, -0.07189525663852692, -0.0030932878144085407, -0.022472627460956573, -0.010276328772306442, -0.006573730614036322, 0.04402286559343338, 0.03926815092563629, -0.04343661665916443, -0.037988848984241486, -0.004276509862393141, -0.054513271898031235, 0.019151482731103897, -0.030004536733031273, -0.02506827935576439, -0.010897202417254448, -0.04249545931816101, 0.024948203936219215, -0.0013474620645865798, 0.007898909039795399, -0.030929017812013626, 0.023491403087973595, -0.021307753399014473, 0.01844462752342224, -0.03752206638455391, -0.026664147153496742, 0.019671017304062843, 0.013810005970299244, 0.005555100739002228, -0.01266595907509327, 0.05065418407320976, 0.019810890778899193, -0.0047216396778821945, -0.03930673375725746, -0.035840097814798355, 0.011236116290092468, 0.029674110934138298, 0.019063588231801987, 0.06465588510036469, 0.001323595060966909, -0.03323980048298836, 0.03149431198835373, 0.018004680052399635, 0.07301517575979233, 0.04244687780737877, -0.0009286783752031624, -0.00230908440425992, -0.02258298359811306, -0.02528988942503929, -0.0009982917690649629, -0.00574902817606926, -0.008662804961204529, -0.005747792776674032, 0.06901345402002335, 0.017711620777845383, -0.06453485041856766, 0.02465634047985077, 0.07037270069122314, 0.019284414127469063, 0.001673125079832971, -0.06149027496576309, -0.004620528779923916, -0.01719958335161209, -0.0070148734375834465, -0.01689096726477146, -0.02145143784582615, 0.00744646554812789, -0.023712661117315292, 0.06300263851881027, -0.0012290964368730783, -0.03112974762916565, 0.015448523685336113, 0.006691355723887682, 0.058412954211235046, -0.0038569883909076452, 0.00392623245716095, 0.0076669566333293915, 0.016187742352485657, 0.03590159863233566, 0.025255054235458374, 0.006694891955703497, -0.05759990215301514, 0.01383797824382782, 0.008422006852924824, 0.04964340478181839, -0.027342326939105988, 0.005348528269678354, -0.031550776213407516, 0.023616982623934746, 0.026704667136073112, -0.008234926499426365, 0.03721879795193672, -0.032084882259368896, -0.01643451489508152, 0.0027189997490495443, -0.025821583345532417, -0.04609537869691849, -0.012685299851000309, -0.013754213228821754, 0.016839494928717613, -0.05090484023094177, 0.001259414479136467, -0.04370391368865967, -0.017008105292916298, 0.02731095626950264, 0.05135936290025711, -0.005830449052155018, -0.013539697043597698, -0.025437533855438232, 0.04601264372467995, -0.0158986896276474, -0.05323353409767151, 0.016763143241405487, 0.0057816575281322, -0.005731121636927128, 0.04070819169282913, -0.014552542008459568, -0.0561114065349102, 0.039989981800317764, 0.02317005954682827, -0.005459956359118223, -0.029472334310412407, -0.0017102921847254038, 0.029450099915266037, 0.055029258131980896, 0.029758458957076073, 0.06658011674880981, -0.005068323574960232, 0.014760979451239109, 0.017352668568491936, -0.05179733410477638, 0.04376649856567383, -0.03559807687997818, 0.02029205672442913, -0.03597088158130646, -0.004331357777118683, -0.014463421888649464, 0.017793359234929085, 0.017375590279698372, 0.03638982027769089, -0.0071592736057937145, -0.012063984759151936, -0.002659752033650875, 0.017291279509663582, 0.026201777160167694, 0.020259054377675056, -0.01401094626635313, 0.04738335311412811, -0.003790444927290082, -0.001656195381656289, 0.026883956044912338, -0.016184503212571144, 0.01858294941484928, 0.03943704441189766, -0.00529730599373579, 0.038455795496702194, -0.0412210114300251, -0.03212350979447365, 0.007517512887716293, -0.06236172094941139, 0.0076812938787043095, -0.047560639679431915, 0.0031928804237395525, -0.015469953417778015, -0.032375115901231766, -0.0377134270966053, 0.018928343430161476, 0.01581612415611744, 0.019727474078536034, -0.03089556284248829, 0.04453297331929207, 0.01459155511111021, 0.024020856246352196, -0.07552685588598251, -0.046360649168491364, 0.00478696171194315, 0.04175511747598648, -0.0003324341669213027, -0.017921656370162964, -0.006446003448218107, -0.03413575515151024, -0.04452450945973396, -0.03582801669836044, 0.05598254129290581, -0.009968610480427742, -0.04970886930823326, -0.010521912947297096, 0.029530733823776245, 0.09090019017457962, -0.002055200282484293, 0.0018436812097206712, 0.022619234398007393, -0.005646885838359594, -0.012788060121238232, 0.02324725314974785, 0.027309797704219818, -0.030385229736566544, -0.014394444413483143, -0.04326394572854042, 0.0074498592875897884, 0.03760886564850807, -0.012447952292859554, -0.016263866797089577, 0.025801075622439384, 0.020896565169095993, 0.013641759753227234, 0.010862822644412518, -0.012781184166669846, -0.0177944153547287, 0.027599969878792763, 0.010563815012574196, 0.025264708325266838, 0.008155756630003452, 0.023078342899680138, 0.06480980664491653, 0.035691943019628525, -0.006849329918622971, 0.0167570561170578, 0.11186990141868591, -0.05440904200077057, 0.010926952585577965, -0.01898827776312828, -0.011500369757413864, 0.01914660446345806, 0.02436608076095581, -0.0013900803169235587, 0.032673221081495285, 0.004021011292934418, -0.04398857429623604, -0.00274337618611753, -0.027768323197960854, 0.0010595538187772036, 0.051265716552734375, -0.005534801632165909, 0.05407985672354698, 0.010313533246517181, 0.009334842674434185, -0.002726541366428137, -0.03645756468176842, -0.028055094182491302, 0.0024737350177019835, 0.0020034315530210733, 0.003946165554225445, -0.003634148510172963, 0.005663716234266758, 0.028493449091911316, 0.03959697112441063, 0.013479197397828102, 0.020284701138734818, 0.015478339046239853, 0.019096335396170616, 0.017341552302241325, 0.0032381166238337755, -0.035498883575201035, 0.04408486932516098, -0.058838922530412674, -0.012350416742265224, -0.05558720603585243, -0.010432982817292213, 0.009602155536413193, -0.008758359588682652, -0.008473319001495838, 0.005119754001498222, 0.005003529600799084, -0.03443899005651474, 0.016568521037697792, -0.02833268791437149, 0.018506571650505066, 0.021288225427269936, -0.04202037677168846, 0.005848980508744717, -0.00024260010104626417, 0.06396278738975525, -0.027689719572663307, -0.08470774441957474, -0.05056096985936165, -0.008142963983118534, -0.03282198682427406, 0.036297447979450226, -0.015313426032662392, -0.0054505071602761745, 0.027730759233236313, -0.05637390539050102, 0.013717159628868103, 0.010052508674561977, -0.00556893041357398, -0.03285284340381622, 0.08574196696281433, 0.028187669813632965, 0.04748550057411194, 0.01277029886841774, -0.02834855578839779, 0.10906107723712921, 0.056373804807662964, 0.017992759123444557, -0.05313560366630554, 0.014214932918548584, -0.013048222288489342, -0.008167793042957783, 0.005833250470459461, 0.007873637601733208, 0.0049164085648953915, -0.0038868137635290623, 0.011501030065119267, 0.05096949636936188, 0.03226303681731224, -0.007264129817485809, 0.036199044436216354, -0.00630185566842556, -0.015946704894304276, 0.011771160177886486, 0.002303700428456068, -0.03501969948410988, -0.0283206794410944, -0.040512535721063614, 0.027895284816622734, -0.004668983165174723, 0.02525104209780693, -0.0020843155216425657, -0.04380326718091965, -0.02214612066745758, 0.006014775484800339, -0.017451854422688484, -0.007328657899051905, 0.011346104554831982, -0.004798820707947016, -0.033587004989385605, -0.016736803576350212, 0.021694203838706017, -0.0271958876401186, 0.024853862822055817, 0.02430974878370762, -0.006812412291765213, 0.02556680329144001, 0.024684522300958633, 0.038683969527482986, -0.06066049262881279, -0.023936055600643158, -0.03848927468061447, 0.028591692447662354, -0.024159641936421394, -0.01977643556892872, -0.004766083788126707, -0.04335826635360718, 0.00335307396017015, -0.026205318048596382, 0.009763769805431366, 0.011507642455399036, 0.011284289881587029, -0.02975735440850258, 0.0026853294111788273, -0.02811066247522831, 0.042265694588422775, -0.026482220739126205, 0.027958473190665245, 0.033181920647621155, -0.002074791816994548, -0.03281401842832565, -0.016384100541472435, -0.0038141801487654448, -0.019954780116677284, -0.005551102105528116, -0.02081751637160778, -0.02010216936469078, -0.05097011849284172, -0.01700490154325962, 0.020843034610152245, -0.003704012604430318, 0.04255656152963638, -0.017126325517892838, 0.0020817448385059834, 0.01895572617650032, -0.042311932891607285, 0.031255945563316345, -0.02487795054912567, -0.016702258959412575, -0.019178425893187523, -0.006039016880095005, -0.0049893613904714584, 0.028000814840197563, -0.03265753388404846, 0.01672876812517643, 0.008341009728610516, 0.07526904344558716, -0.0023201836738735437, -0.053800780326128006, -0.03223023936152458, -0.003377295099198818, -0.04784302040934563, 0.003913423512130976, 0.015773845836520195, 0.042208462953567505, 0.01026220340281725, 0.04676166921854019, 0.03084626980125904, 0.022757213562726974, 0.007691273931413889, -0.011260002851486206, 0.013635445386171341, -0.040327951312065125, -0.020407166332006454, 0.039157602936029434, 0.0059452299028635025, -0.0213348139077425, -0.018059950321912766, -0.02952142432332039, -0.03110683336853981, 0.02341616339981556, 0.007261812221258879, -0.04962106794118881, 0.012772751972079277, 0.00453560845926404, -0.015266121365129948, 0.0009532614494673908, -0.021529553458094597, -0.05842413380742073, -0.010572451166808605, 0.01402148138731718, -0.019779207184910774, -0.0040812017396092415, -0.003811032511293888, -0.012313404120504856, 0.005051081068813801, 0.037164561450481415, 0.018151406198740005, 0.004147169180214405, -0.0027882703579962254, 0.02288183569908142, -0.010281207971274853, 0.040079515427351, -0.06230941042304039, 0.012057962827384472, 0.08221977204084396, -0.023476142436265945, -0.0050108348950743675, 0.018392831087112427, 0.02226383239030838, 0.04713934659957886, 0.004103866405785084, -0.014580357819795609, -0.03905044123530388, 0.03245813027024269, -0.0699174702167511, -0.012943770736455917, 0.004671997390687466, 0.0013247800525277853, -0.016484105959534645, -0.009457156993448734, -0.0171146709471941, 0.014235729351639748, 0.017564713954925537, 0.00858242530375719, 0.04461197182536125, -0.016742484644055367, -0.008001238107681274, -0.007688661105930805, 0.03023763932287693, 0.03141938894987106, 0.009037247858941555, 0.03627218306064606, -0.016860146075487137, 0.055493224412202835, -0.03921222314238548, 0.048227421939373016, -0.027527859434485435, -0.007941054180264473, -0.0889921486377716, -0.02286580391228199, 0.039160627871751785, 0.010607640258967876, 0.0345916822552681, -0.023431792855262756, 0.005661319475620985, 0.049621373414993286, -0.04456239193677902, -0.016485609114170074, -0.05329933017492294, -0.03853682428598404, -0.02717021107673645, 0.006485915742814541, -0.024920661002397537, 0.011709090322256088, 0.01584736444056034, -0.011851203627884388, 0.03333797678351402, 0.018336206674575806, 0.010914420709013939, -0.05058523640036583, -0.00904314685612917, 0.01424529030919075, 0.009406768716871738, -0.05416398495435715, 0.04309217631816864, -0.01679731346666813, -0.06533246487379074, 0.044727884232997894, 0.0049211131408810616, 0.019267871975898743, 0.030645327642560005, 0.031452108174562454, 0.0024550054222345352, 0.04092380777001381, 0.02104536071419716, -0.0026198960840702057, -0.02456573396921158, -0.014105379581451416, 0.037640511989593506, 0.0434127040207386, -0.011962992139160633, -0.027336876839399338, 0.01584121398627758, -0.018378444015979767, -0.0800233706831932, 0.017317520454525948, -0.029030360281467438, -0.05201291665434837, 0.012596113607287407, -0.017801741138100624, -0.01693340763449669, -0.04851798713207245, 0.06546288728713989, -0.051061391830444336, 0.0016661001136526465, 0.03385719656944275, 0.03812200203537941, -0.019862018525600433, -0.008282443508505821, 0.0034834621474146843, -0.03877941519021988, 0.009292266331613064, 0.01497055683284998, -0.023083413019776344, -0.06960167735815048, -0.020921889692544937, -0.023168645799160004, 0.004996242932975292, 0.003630749648436904, -0.029352864250540733, -0.02442295476794243, 0.04029635339975357, 0.015586869791150093, -0.004409543238580227, -0.0013266344321891665, -0.008700297214090824, -0.02803826704621315, -0.06923200190067291, 0.04170753434300423, 0.003364292439073324, -0.006009580567479134, -0.04827985540032387, 0.016773004084825516, -0.011351977474987507, -0.015570186078548431, 0.033122867345809937, 0.047441232949495316, -0.0022767570335417986, 0.02897343784570694, 0.03606567159295082, 0.03170491382479668, -0.053172722458839417, 0.03904225304722786, -0.04059320315718651, 0.015591033734381199, -0.041265200823545456, -0.02196497656404972, -0.022705508396029472, 0.030682595446705818, 0.012955487705767155, 0.02451152727007866, 0.039944227784872055, 0.015038701705634594, 0.03189411759376526, 0.039922166615724564, 0.035516515374183655, -0.007047425489872694, 0.03919161111116409, -0.002206420758739114, -0.006149342283606529, 0.043730515986680984, -0.005941604729741812, -0.06419599056243896, 0.03059956058859825, 0.0025309165939688683, -0.03352642059326172, 0.001176629215478897, 0.04295989125967026, -0.0064011262729763985, -0.05998819321393967, 0.0055711292661726475, 0.008038855157792568, -0.030559677630662918, -0.004997356794774532, 0.019662637263536453, 0.037881653755903244, 0.041018202900886536, 0.018515918403863907, 0.0023571692872792482, 0.007667674217373133, -0.021616347134113312, -0.004637471400201321, -0.005765103735029697, 0.029207658022642136, -0.018812943249940872, 0.020335322245955467, 0.046530190855264664, -0.0036069275811314583, 0.009599818848073483, 0.0003770228649955243, 0.0288687851279974, -0.026245465502142906, -0.034882884472608566, -0.0035415173042565584, -0.038108088076114655, 0.014445262029767036, -0.01038460060954094, -0.0012571134138852358, 0.07610143721103668, -0.03462015464901924, 0.04966643080115318, -0.0313602015376091, -0.019967971369624138, -0.008386174216866493, -0.012839119881391525, 0.0217742919921875, -0.004507627338171005, 0.018355000764131546, -0.009993460960686207, -0.010795569978654385, 0.018872395157814026, 0.012331497855484486, 0.003376184031367302, 0.010428493842482567, -0.021550992503762245, -0.021759549155831337, -0.05368141084909439, -0.037141766399145126, -0.02685660496354103, -0.004979871213436127, 0.009628712199628353, 0.02047010138630867, 0.03340738266706467, 0.0202224999666214, -0.07404738664627075, -0.033276770263910294, 0.04576379433274269, -0.05013680085539818, -0.001539353164844215, -0.032474324107170105, 0.0018120523309335113, 0.015149288810789585, -0.05221325531601906 ]
<p>Suppose we have two estimators $\alpha_1$ and $\alpha_2$ for some parameter $x$. To determine which estimator is "better" do we look at the MSE (mean squared error)? In other words we look at $$MSE = \beta^2+ \sigma^2$$ where $\beta$ is the bias of the estimator and $\sigma^2$ is the variance of the estimator? Whichever has a greater MSE is a worse estimator? </p>
36,201
[ -0.035527341067790985, -0.0015314155025407672, -0.03296544402837753, 0.0032447685953229666, 0.006134502589702606, 0.06866732239723206, 0.013252202421426773, -0.03466391563415527, 0.033292677253484726, -0.010917367413640022, 0.010983891785144806, 0.03162485733628273, 0.08664659410715103, -0.01608917862176895, 0.02835438959300518, 0.010132350027561188, -0.022506628185510635, 0.029520196840167046, -0.009818599559366703, 0.021283287554979324, -0.008247044868767262, 0.03145624324679375, 0.01548794750124216, -0.0012131119146943092, -0.031563494354486465, 0.04495472460985184, 0.05850382521748543, -0.00032348622335121036, -0.021595273166894913, 0.06005261838436127, -0.025215908885002136, -0.012212816625833511, 0.023483730852603912, 0.05805113539099693, 0.0131588876247406, -0.028417546302080154, -0.010701836086809635, -0.01689170114696026, -0.03321177139878273, 0.05605169013142586, -0.04432389512658119, -0.03237190842628479, -0.00019123994570691139, -0.02475801482796669, -0.015457427129149437, 0.0006748795858584344, -0.025950292125344276, -0.09523309022188187, 0.0002545309835113585, -0.03878406062722206, 0.07684045284986496, -0.009138728491961956, 0.04349580407142639, 0.05175862833857536, -0.017777908593416214, -0.0036205558571964502, 0.028232499957084656, 0.06065359711647034, -0.023201124742627144, -0.03705395758152008, 0.008168200962245464, 0.004634920507669449, 0.02762751467525959, 0.0005714629660360515, -0.03790738061070442, 0.009520204737782478, -0.011428559198975563, -0.0015207052929326892, 0.04341789707541466, 0.006365654524415731, -0.0018723222892731428, 0.01009572483599186, 0.05829845741391182, 0.017857810482382774, 0.013477715663611889, -0.02388838492333889, 0.006047610659152269, 0.03355161473155022, 0.04813102260231972, 0.02647867053747177, 0.025792866945266724, 0.006751612760126591, 0.06326360255479813, 0.045430783182382584, 0.02090710960328579, 0.016562825068831444, 0.08576619625091553, -0.0242459736764431, 0.03864661231637001, 0.02047436498105526, -0.0072767664678394794, -0.007954821921885014, 0.027289293706417084, -0.04420449212193489, -0.020610716193914413, 0.025852635502815247, -0.017716605216264725, 0.017936836928129196, 0.03813203051686287, -0.019057834520936012, -0.006552779581397772, -0.02062974125146866, 0.001944776508025825, 0.06736478954553604, 0.025595106184482574, -0.030313093215227127, -0.03688880428671837, 0.02158934995532036, -0.02191239222884178, -0.03596585988998413, -0.042079728096723557, 0.01362796314060688, 0.0005150846554897726, 0.010496994480490685, 0.034028682857751846, -0.018308479338884354, 0.006373762618750334, 0.0036926462780684233, 0.021255822852253914, 0.059666261076927185, 0.043527647852897644, -0.01847749948501587, 0.013129928149282932, -0.008386246860027313, -0.03885839506983757, 0.045767202973365784, 0.027239952236413956, -0.05179030820727348, -0.04614951089024544, 0.0457589216530323, 0.018872220069169998, -0.0023450488224625587, 0.03206625580787659, 0.016079815104603767, 0.02052212692797184, 0.0018540011951699853, -0.07040620595216751, -0.0655292347073555, 0.04201360046863556, -0.006194042973220348, 0.03130190074443817, -0.07235068827867508, -0.01919608749449253, 0.011549240909516811, 0.06473555415868759, 0.04527892917394638, 0.04909335449337959, 0.032338935881853104, 0.02131776325404644, -0.004443488549441099, -0.024643385782837868, -0.02107997238636017, -0.014130853116512299, -0.019519878551363945, -0.02310875616967678, -0.053309209644794464, -0.0384545624256134, 0.008101767860352993, -0.008680012077093124, -0.025278955698013306, 0.034620825201272964, 0.018200699239969254, -0.02306218445301056, 0.02682955376803875, 0.026313329115509987, -0.02271740697324276, 0.06731065362691879, 0.013924483209848404, 0.042864974588155746, 0.013880440965294838, 0.017692191526293755, 0.04034752398729324, 0.004787245765328407, 0.024801604449748993, 0.05631057173013687, -0.027702758088707924, -0.04422814026474953, -0.01896566152572632, 0.010548373684287071, 0.011404108256101608, -0.04905233532190323, -0.008756982162594795, -0.009517869912087917, -0.0017858661012724042, 0.008900999091565609, 0.07771004736423492, 0.010279114358127117, -0.01862364448606968, 0.04478111118078232, -0.035214055329561234, -0.023436764255166054, -0.09575896710157394, -0.00833796989172697, 0.009395523928105831, -0.027380289509892464, 0.03751078620553017, 0.00001889179111458361, -0.014270864427089691, -0.03655378520488739, 0.003944534808397293, -0.017431018874049187, 0.0163506418466568, 0.02704063057899475, -0.02429988980293274, 0.018903551623225212, 0.048052333295345306, 0.029524778947234154, -0.0027132686227560043, 0.040127843618392944, -0.04543304070830345, -0.05876097083091736, 0.016947224736213684, -0.037168584764003754, 0.027643343433737755, 0.012670351192355156, -0.041669510304927826, 0.03400258719921112, -0.02218097262084484, -0.02023269236087799, 0.024284997954964638, -0.04699099063873291, 0.05453551933169365, 0.04129732772707939, 0.0000717093498678878, -0.0031225515995174646, 0.007576391566544771, 0.03297468274831772, 0.02189347706735134, -0.048251181840896606, -0.006586775649338961, -0.02745339274406433, -0.01262508612126112, 0.03472360223531723, 0.028852857649326324, -0.04473208636045456, 0.017517264932394028, 0.029503924772143364, 0.02591104432940483, 0.01253832783550024, 0.016186194494366646, 0.013283932581543922, 0.006789675913751125, -0.01829908974468708, 0.02107842266559601, -0.01689133234322071, 0.04335556924343109, 0.04309157282114029, 0.024444637820124626, 0.03041187673807144, 0.017445199191570282, 0.032009538263082504, 0.065211221575737, -0.00880621001124382, 0.0009434989187866449, 0.019602948799729347, -0.024157488718628883, 0.017973104491829872, -0.03917616233229637, 0.028486916795372963, 0.02598697692155838, 0.003515092423185706, -0.009671997278928757, 0.0395190604031086, 0.012266548350453377, 0.051936883479356766, 0.0065458486787974834, -0.019346704706549644, 0.014310309663414955, 0.03137480467557907, -0.024296334013342857, 0.016234107315540314, -0.01935657672584057, -0.015819741412997246, -0.00323682464659214, -0.02654927968978882, 0.03623894974589348, -0.02610698528587818, -0.0036545151378959417, -0.0019238932291045785, -0.026172421872615814, -0.04659781605005264, -0.03136618435382843, 0.026825223118066788, 0.01138916052877903, -0.06287039071321487, 0.006841639522463083, -0.04212255775928497, -0.021900564432144165, 0.03527594730257988, -0.009955002926290035, -0.002134672598913312, 0.02442515455186367, -0.007732641417533159, -0.03213358670473099, -0.01768592558801174, -0.032468102872371674, 0.017136069014668465, -0.004967404529452324, -0.03476587310433388, 0.02134805917739868, -0.02724406123161316, -0.026488060131669044, 0.054520271718502045, -0.06896315515041351, -0.06987059116363525, -0.03591414913535118, -0.009225556626915932, 0.01649717427790165, -0.0006991541595198214, 0.01666433922946453, 0.045568034052848816, -0.013304829597473145, -0.030613364651799202, -0.04270797595381737, -0.05543026328086853, 0.02654888667166233, -0.01021848525851965, 0.014477291144430637, -0.012227434664964676, -0.03334757313132286, 0.10147543996572495, 0.055360097438097, 0.002153555629774928, 0.013611487112939358, 0.014470729976892471, -0.03875670209527016, -0.03027660772204399, 0.006611501798033714, 0.010007279925048351, 0.013122542761266232, 0.02539791353046894, -0.018050288781523705, 0.015712400898337364, 0.027487756684422493, 0.011283041909337044, -0.02270696498453617, -0.0026077008806169033, 0.013152243569493294, -0.04186674952507019, 0.057559527456760406, 0.01720239222049713, -0.020075185224413872, 0.034812528640031815, 0.049803413450717926, 0.043788664042949677, -0.001960087800398469, -0.010491244494915009, 0.015934525057673454, -0.03170466795563698, -0.01988094300031662, -0.04562850296497345, 0.03997156396508217, 0.061831191182136536, 0.016355883330106735, -0.019272588193416595, 0.0011699559399858117, -0.019837435334920883, -0.014251780696213245, -0.006852968130260706, 0.02852494828402996, 0.028619511052966118, -0.01670050621032715, -0.02736266516149044, -0.05489586293697357, 0.003406038274988532, 0.017070554196834564, -0.014404280111193657, -0.04732803627848625, 0.023316973820328712, 0.030073536559939384, 0.004880419932305813, -0.015940433368086815, -0.07534971088171005, -0.027401002123951912, -0.1037619560956955, 0.008536944165825844, -0.013153757899999619, 0.04868116229772568, 0.0050754304975271225, 0.036645449697971344, 0.009944564662873745, 0.012146451510488987, 0.010677160695195198, -0.013945940881967545, -0.05141617730259895, 0.050055455416440964, -0.037115924060344696, -0.02165764756500721, 0.005462315399199724, -0.028203129768371582, 0.03803557902574539, -0.05693531781435013, 0.024185599759221077, -0.008826838806271553, -0.004392009694129229, -0.035691626369953156, -0.0011144448071718216, -0.02961665764451027, -0.007041533477604389, 0.013779052533209324, 0.033878590911626816, -0.01562628149986267, -0.039368800818920135, 0.03865087032318115, 0.014021392911672592, -0.032673511654138565, 0.008930993266403675, -0.01863297075033188, 0.0008420257945545018, -0.0016438344027847052, 0.003519349033012986, 0.005064464174211025, 0.010125407949090004, -0.019129643216729164, 0.0271245576441288, 0.018062302842736244, 0.059944070875644684, 0.0226025078445673, -0.003085870761424303, -0.018425079062581062, -0.02599148452281952, -0.029352424666285515, -0.0220347810536623, 0.006458109710365534, -0.008077180944383144, -0.0032834645826369524, 0.06074419617652893, 0.01776721701025963, -0.03449999541044235, 0.024058576673269272, 0.05472573637962341, 0.02112109214067459, -0.0024179003667086363, -0.02229073829948902, -0.010805993340909481, -0.016314320266246796, -0.00910127628594637, 0.021580161526799202, -0.01959245465695858, -0.008793906308710575, -0.022393466904759407, 0.007718970533460379, -0.009842575527727604, -0.031932372599840164, 0.006157737225294113, 0.03426479175686836, 0.0060579814016819, 0.03365248441696167, -0.036955926567316055, 0.0035183087456971407, 0.03125850856304169, 0.026018252596259117, 0.010346242226660252, -0.008001001551747322, -0.0865270271897316, -0.0017295300494879484, 0.006778506562113762, 0.013447590172290802, -0.054194290190935135, -0.0026894432958215475, -0.01007278636097908, -0.010758427903056145, 0.0086497962474823, -0.019054191187024117, 0.029061123728752136, -0.034717388451099396, -0.005582486744970083, -0.04047521576285362, -0.004686076659709215, -0.035170603543519974, 0.013325817883014679, 0.026198536157608032, 0.012611552141606808, 0.010173769667744637, 0.00804881565272808, -0.041185054928064346, -0.015550521202385426, 0.05290120840072632, 0.0713939219713211, 0.0024424628354609013, -0.016238821670413017, 0.022790316492319107, 0.042602453380823135, -0.054565269500017166, -0.06371130794286728, 0.006621005944907665, 0.032679423689842224, -0.04098808392882347, 0.020687483251094818, -0.017412366345524788, -0.020009871572256088, 0.03432928025722504, -0.002515594707801938, -0.03260497376322746, -0.005184217356145382, -0.0019954247400164604, 0.01585528627038002, 0.06519463658332825, 0.04672347381711006, 0.07657045871019363, 0.01510945800691843, -0.014264790341258049, 0.014521128498017788, -0.006608068477362394, 0.0001391165133100003, -0.024297544732689857, -0.028384506702423096, -0.025440853089094162, -0.05819035321474075, -0.012007327750325203, 0.028952505439519882, -0.0025023415219038725, 0.052124179899692535, -0.010774197988212109, -0.015639016404747963, 0.021246924996376038, 0.03750447556376457, 0.006350468844175339, 0.015058155171573162, -0.014697435311973095, 0.02610461227595806, -0.00638512521982193, -0.02693585306406021, 0.041406989097595215, -0.01056999433785677, 0.005057366099208593, 0.027039939537644386, -0.06487926095724106, 0.02884228527545929, -0.03521398827433586, -0.05242475867271423, 0.007534344680607319, -0.003515686374157667, 0.0725998803973198, -0.013847585767507553, -0.012719480320811272, -0.004193007480353117, -0.0288242194801569, -0.026006164029240608, 0.034268055111169815, -0.036386530846357346, 0.015804598107933998, -0.01872056908905506, 0.032125044614076614, 0.021262383088469505, -0.02096383087337017, -0.10279416292905807, -0.009825073182582855, 0.002684421604499221, 0.007559959311038256, -0.0050461553037166595, -0.0008034071652218699, 0.020771916955709457, -0.028293300420045853, -0.02818550355732441, -0.021249813959002495, 0.04766521230340004, -0.011810658499598503, -0.0401814840734005, -0.015616671182215214, 0.02913440577685833, 0.05939922109246254, -0.004318918101489544, 0.0012260789517313242, -0.010577135719358921, -0.028277844190597534, -0.025305569171905518, 0.008847873657941818, 0.06351977586746216, -0.044201068580150604, 0.02730579860508442, -0.013700446113944054, -0.02476276271045208, 0.03333771601319313, -0.014325108379125595, -0.030864356085658073, 0.04550071433186531, 0.022038696333765984, 0.022848470136523247, -0.00018440961139276624, -0.01366439275443554, -0.022720469161868095, 0.019202683120965958, -0.010472500696778297, 0.006459806114435196, -0.008907798677682877, -0.00563956331461668, 0.042297590523958206, 0.0476803332567215, -0.0197112038731575, -0.012426394037902355, 0.0847860649228096, -0.04231763631105423, 0.019699133932590485, 0.011882755905389786, -0.0005542758735828102, 0.046773511916399, 0.007628665771335363, 0.023376744240522385, 0.033163800835609436, 0.05087760463356972, -0.03114463947713375, -0.0034230186138302088, -0.0473259873688221, 0.026580367237329483, 0.08135946094989777, -0.04670886695384979, 0.025803005322813988, 0.05744977667927742, -0.014898574911057949, -0.0227117408066988, -0.06705885380506516, -0.018523192033171654, -0.0026410387363284826, -0.03686095029115677, 0.042122628539800644, -0.021850567311048508, 0.020348669961094856, 0.02507229894399643, -0.012140272185206413, 0.018954677507281303, 0.018449077382683754, -0.017366981133818626, 0.05637458711862564, 0.017438679933547974, -0.026134567335247993, -0.04085386544466019, 0.04603980481624603, -0.0402754507958889, -0.004439708311110735, -0.05314962565898895, -0.03897172957658768, 0.019518114626407623, 0.011784596368670464, -0.005648462567478418, -0.05157560482621193, -0.028154702857136726, -0.03887561708688736, 0.013173502869904041, 0.0011321823112666607, 0.0038881513755768538, 0.04110828787088394, 0.017216229811310768, -0.0027956939302384853, 0.000991074601188302, 0.023840969428420067, -0.0390675887465477, -0.11297649890184402, -0.021888935938477516, 0.012053229846060276, -0.027444541454315186, -0.015779322013258934, -0.014092818833887577, -0.045090388506650925, 0.018946055322885513, -0.03960710018873215, 0.021347172558307648, 0.012024885974824429, 0.005548047833144665, -0.0279733557254076, 0.08376701921224594, -0.007695626933127642, 0.04045423865318298, 0.004516060929745436, 0.0060196612030267715, 0.07940198481082916, 0.07851330935955048, 0.0227599386125803, -0.06626564264297485, 0.024749698117375374, -0.036124229431152344, -0.000806138152256608, -0.013928225263953209, 0.019919976592063904, -0.001540123950690031, 0.02685725875198841, 0.012698318809270859, 0.0656384602189064, 0.034446313977241516, -0.04533462971448898, 0.05454936996102333, -0.035638246685266495, -0.015021835453808308, -0.007711869198828936, 0.014164268970489502, -0.009520087391138077, 0.02010798268020153, -0.01212671585381031, 0.020543279126286507, -0.029660185799002647, 0.00900197308510542, -0.027728518471121788, 0.000499750254675746, -0.009966559708118439, -0.024684596806764603, -0.017038553953170776, 0.010419433005154133, -0.0062467847019433975, -0.007719790562987328, -0.03299156576395035, 0.03465917333960533, 0.021570537239313126, -0.03381529077887535, 0.029631759971380234, 0.007407760247588158, -0.001356567838229239, 0.034580815583467484, 0.024463972076773643, 0.0004204687720630318, -0.04164924472570419, 0.0032224548049271107, -0.026613034307956696, 0.045480694621801376, -0.021340079605579376, -0.00032686759368516505, -0.009889227338135242, -0.002266999101266265, -0.04065825417637825, -0.027972249314188957, -0.018690064549446106, 0.01787366159260273, -0.0009663471137173474, -0.023005448281764984, -0.0037306705489754677, -0.0596478171646595, 0.06152355670928955, -0.017278524115681648, 0.021379314363002777, 0.014873339794576168, -0.07112760096788406, -0.011663608253002167, 0.03299412876367569, 0.05337703600525856, 0.017735227942466736, -0.03659519925713539, -0.021556375548243523, 0.013370013795793056, -0.03798710182309151, -0.03261405602097511, 0.03566398471593857, 0.03174097090959549, 0.04550032690167427, 0.008096952922642231, -0.00606985529884696, -0.014816748909652233, -0.053346749395132065, 0.016104798763990402, -0.038127969950437546, 0.028258852660655975, -0.03907870873808861, -0.018105950206518173, 0.06076260283589363, 0.019098637625575066, 0.018544567748904228, -0.008748708292841911, 0.012333049438893795, 0.01763007789850235, 0.025060143321752548, -0.0665055587887764, -0.02284197323024273, 0.01880728453397751, -0.05534650385379791, 0.012070143595337868, -0.03595547005534172, 0.0386660136282444, 0.01784813031554222, 0.03921794891357422, -0.027140315622091293, 0.024252386763691902, -0.020315119996666908, 0.01265466958284378, 0.0036510666832327843, -0.03678316995501518, -0.03160654008388519, 0.010477330535650253, -0.003758578095585108, -0.0034550928976386786, -0.001356287975795567, -0.046651992946863174, -0.00801455695182085, 0.0042827436700463295, -0.017951032146811485, -0.028893299400806427, 0.028475521132349968, 0.021728303283452988, 0.04914933815598488, -0.037566445767879486, -0.0016669235192239285, -0.03277343139052391, -0.02197365090250969, 0.009417852386832237, -0.02775464579463005, -0.002552905585616827, -0.005478318314999342, -0.006980110425502062, -0.019445287063717842, 0.01597808301448822, 0.014498652890324593, 0.0195282194763422, 0.002578557701781392, 0.030455047264695168, -0.01808399148285389, 0.06196896731853485, -0.05649859458208084, 0.005682900547981262, 0.03247261419892311, -0.050139252096414566, -0.013080084696412086, 0.01634593866765499, -0.0003724498674273491, 0.013554554432630539, 0.00104025739710778, 0.0005469512543641031, -0.04826367273926735, 0.03951770067214966, -0.06517518311738968, -0.023264393210411072, -0.02242414653301239, -0.014969320967793465, 0.02904079295694828, -0.01587628573179245, 0.025851374492049217, -0.0037653285544365644, 0.0013532413868233562, 0.031876090914011, 0.019254028797149658, -0.013432330451905727, -0.026314545422792435, -0.004209741950035095, -0.002816687570884824, 0.03641178831458092, -0.0013862542109563947, 0.005239697173237801, 0.037718284875154495, 0.03216593340039253, -0.037938326597213745, 0.029272057116031647, -0.00032259777071885765, 0.009388705715537071, -0.0845561996102333, -0.01449301466345787, 0.033399466425180435, 0.0029010227881371975, 0.03702041134238243, -0.03600601106882095, 0.049973197281360626, 0.05048713460564613, -0.03483761101961136, 0.018198063597083092, -0.015420708805322647, -0.0022713891230523586, -0.046476028859615326, 0.005671896040439606, -0.02719326689839363, 0.03321106359362602, -0.017599666491150856, 0.002615108387544751, -0.004691186361014843, 0.01542565505951643, 0.01977042481303215, -0.0140827726572752, -0.04976053163409233, 0.0029818241018801928, 0.00645236624404788, -0.06384129077196121, 0.022317059338092804, -0.07133722305297852, -0.0346071831882, 0.05729525163769722, 0.01931304670870304, 0.02517971768975258, -0.006019253749400377, 0.010129084810614586, -0.003142409725114703, 0.021920284256339073, 0.003104378469288349, -0.008923442102968693, -0.0051394253969192505, 0.00814723875373602, 0.0001729604264255613, 0.035682473331689835, -0.008901122957468033, -0.0012674041790887713, 0.01700839214026928, -0.018449749797582626, -0.039706435054540634, -0.022641269490122795, 0.008662690408527851, -0.04379958659410477, 0.0012192473514005542, -0.01628032885491848, 0.037202782928943634, -0.0008321912027895451, 0.038005534559488297, -0.018715983256697655, 0.022689739242196083, 0.04063751921057701, 0.026316767558455467, -0.024017564952373505, 0.012117376551032066, 0.002897932194173336, -0.02468256838619709, 0.002119962591677904, 0.02694355510175228, -0.0004822765477001667, -0.060683880001306534, -0.01680687628686428, 0.009832324460148811, -0.012842858210206032, 0.0005055948859080672, -0.017394138500094414, -0.016155622899532318, 0.03283414989709854, -0.0010195892537012696, 0.028417062014341354, 0.022997301071882248, -0.04453667998313904, -0.0008978235418908298, -0.057578928768634796, 0.06137647107243538, -0.006654044613242149, -0.004808903206139803, -0.01656399480998516, -0.010623997077345848, -0.05470419302582741, -0.019284239038825035, 0.02926076203584671, 0.007397286593914032, 0.002395334653556347, 0.02061956562101841, 0.03518243879079819, 0.015614289790391922, -0.031906407326459885, 0.053145308047533035, -0.004594935569912195, -0.028494326397776604, -0.0236629880964756, -0.01515867654234171, -0.002714513335376978, 0.010364808142185211, -0.007805631961673498, -0.007952744141221046, 0.019390931352972984, 0.009583201259374619, 0.027329249307513237, 0.029851092025637627, 0.012608504854142666, -0.001269501750357449, 0.07330647855997086, 0.006708003580570221, 0.02955719083547592, 0.011209947988390923, -0.0024039552081376314, -0.02358211763203144, 0.02888834848999977, 0.005192709621042013, 0.0015072902897372842, -0.009876109659671783, 0.0031395507976412773, -0.015911027789115906, -0.038521841168403625, -0.0303111020475626, 0.019337281584739685, -0.04787956923246384, -0.012619792483747005, 0.03453009948134422, 0.015112999826669693, 0.0011609813664108515, -0.030743880197405815, 0.03806101158261299, 0.022641660645604134, -0.010162705555558205, -0.009247004054486752, 0.02135711908340454, 0.012227374128997326, 0.021172774955630302, 0.003114094492048025, 0.05927426367998123, 0.009948923252522945, 0.038172438740730286, -0.012224669568240643, 0.050553180277347565, -0.01699395664036274, -0.04489720240235329, -0.01018438208848238, 0.00470687123015523, 0.0018222994403913617, -0.018185550346970558, -0.005037121474742889, 0.04827537015080452, -0.0527699775993824, -0.004188741557300091, -0.030638158321380615, 0.0013833959819748998, -0.03309731185436249, -0.04038846120238304, 0.00047180926776491106, -0.0011501251719892025, 0.02308879978954792, 0.00036841287510469556, -0.009708099998533726, 0.02465355210006237, 0.038273077458143234, -0.03716514632105827, 0.020509401336312294, -0.014399036765098572, -0.005720802117139101, -0.03658820688724518, -0.011691966094076633, -0.04807896539568901, -0.021161969751119614, 0.03511577472090721, 0.062182411551475525, 0.042589444667100906, 0.014678915962576866, -0.057183343917131424, -0.0028976970352232456, 0.05799490213394165, -0.0795581117272377, -0.023044047877192497, -0.031397271901369095, 0.009387397207319736, 0.0037307848688215017, -0.018868647515773773 ]
<p>Curious whether anyone knows a package, or has written an implementation themselves, for conducting instrumental variables regressions using LIML in R. All of the R packages I have seen for IV regressions seem to resort to 2SLS/GMM as opposed to LIML, which may have more desirable finite sample qualities compared to 2SLS <a href="http://press.princeton.edu/titles/6946.html" rel="nofollow">(Hayashi 2000)</a></p> <p>For additional context, stata's ivregress command includes options to use LIML estimation, and hoping someone has already implemented something similar in R so I don't have to write it myself.</p>
40,440
[ -0.031108543276786804, 0.012257232330739498, -0.019861716777086258, 0.03361525759100914, 0.024576960131525993, 0.0258401557803154, -0.029173679649829865, -0.013751317746937275, 0.02163263037800789, -0.024995656684041023, 0.00585870211943984, 0.045091550797224045, 0.05159928649663925, -0.00019969968707300723, 0.018687056377530098, 0.00531625933945179, -0.007718937937170267, 0.042768802493810654, 0.014044268988072872, -0.002895103767514229, -0.02948974259197712, 0.026680024340748787, 0.01924261264503002, 0.014722992666065693, -0.042965952306985855, 0.029989350587129593, 0.017975492402911186, -0.005329579580575228, 0.0012876236578449607, 0.05289789289236069, -0.023951087146997452, -0.002558065578341484, 0.0027143601328134537, 0.014328176155686378, 0.007809748407453299, 0.008542175404727459, -0.06340395659208298, -0.0534389466047287, 0.026613475754857063, 0.029340364038944244, -0.05486169829964638, 0.008444868959486485, -0.009490638971328735, 0.021596688777208328, 0.018965009599924088, 0.013532392680644989, -0.004968056455254555, 0.0026103933341801167, 0.04030008986592293, -0.017865439876914024, 0.058476801961660385, 0.00474580517038703, -0.011872956529259682, 0.01223663054406643, -0.05111221596598625, 0.003734456840902567, 0.07088418304920197, 0.095343217253685, 0.006769280880689621, -0.04139897972345352, -0.0401526503264904, -0.03443467617034912, 0.005593703594058752, 0.015129350125789642, -0.009415567852556705, 0.01909860037267208, 0.01935170404613018, 0.011173965409398079, 0.02467161789536476, -0.015960808843374252, 0.007740586064755917, 0.012363206595182419, 0.02387438900768757, -0.015061813406646252, 0.0016133477911353111, 0.002478770911693573, -0.0009783055866137147, 0.029649507254362106, 0.01924247294664383, 0.025729810819029808, -0.01386190950870514, 0.005023515783250332, 0.03258657827973366, 0.033638861030340195, 0.021588873118162155, -0.023390188813209534, 0.054285429418087006, -0.028678415343165398, 0.029658932238817215, 0.035184700042009354, -0.0549178421497345, 0.0037312782369554043, 0.04925297573208809, 0.013440767303109169, -0.038311272859573364, 0.03731533885002136, -0.029828451573848724, 0.05728985369205475, -0.013176895678043365, 0.02695242501795292, 0.0015600400511175394, -0.01626831851899624, -0.030052443966269493, 0.0670381709933281, -0.028243714943528175, -0.021527258679270744, -0.010218540206551552, -0.03497755154967308, 0.009283705614507198, -0.010571415536105633, -0.03627587854862213, 0.004889842588454485, -0.0016031437553465366, -0.0005791989387944341, -0.017388103529810905, -0.03744599595665932, -0.04443547874689102, -0.0035754770506173372, 0.02051444910466671, 0.09252047538757324, 0.04907947778701782, -0.05265580490231514, -0.0004061040235683322, -0.01355139072984457, -0.04868711903691292, 0.026866639032959938, 0.024965934455394745, -0.03479272127151489, -0.008286976255476475, 0.033410921692848206, 0.017444271594285965, -0.048968713730573654, 0.018373381346464157, -0.008430727757513523, 0.06009317934513092, 0.007323018740862608, -0.045398857444524765, -0.06009269505739212, 0.039173875004053116, 0.007120437454432249, 0.01995708793401718, -0.03376290202140808, 0.0003724184352904558, -0.00559560302644968, 0.08789186924695969, 0.05110405012965202, 0.07659943401813507, 0.02289670705795288, 0.016114860773086548, 0.014418672770261765, -0.03574184700846672, -0.007763874717056751, -0.015715239569544792, -0.00648166798055172, -0.0029587368480861187, -0.07820286601781845, 0.04106282442808151, 0.043786562979221344, -0.03773483261466026, 0.0184602253139019, 0.053254373371601105, 0.01950272172689438, -0.0095487330108881, 0.006889265961945057, 0.0013532674638554454, -0.014937619678676128, 0.057840120047330856, -0.033956557512283325, 0.029418786987662315, 0.0028680989053100348, -0.020248033106327057, 0.040528446435928345, -0.023999042809009552, 0.018368178978562355, 0.03524083271622658, -0.027201158925890923, -0.0022251910995692015, -0.024745462462306023, 0.027421314269304276, 0.03998924046754837, -0.024718087166547775, -0.00021176942391321063, 0.016575943678617477, -0.0866430401802063, 0.004691071808338165, 0.02108258195221424, 0.019204184412956238, -0.020308714359998703, 0.04901192709803581, -0.07863560318946838, -0.024607662111520767, -0.07754486054182053, 0.02618471160531044, -0.01965017057955265, -0.024507997557520866, 0.023961665108799934, 0.0018112724646925926, 0.01879444718360901, -0.011382590048015118, -0.03667586296796799, -0.03308999538421631, -0.0005889689200557768, 0.015429819002747536, -0.021725134924054146, -0.004050569608807564, 0.013628363609313965, 0.052138544619083405, -0.0008940993575379252, 0.03547000139951706, -0.05665044113993645, -0.04819094389677048, 0.03721152991056442, -0.04402873292565346, 0.0384879894554615, -0.021175822243094444, -0.01160834077745676, -0.01134259533137083, -0.005689204670488834, -0.04678015783429146, 0.03781181201338768, -0.036248110234737396, 0.05418355017900467, 0.08797001838684082, 0.052041344344615936, -0.01657586544752121, 0.002972336020320654, 0.00023331209376920015, 0.007618708536028862, -0.024875175207853317, -0.024990705773234367, -0.03994345664978027, -0.058253634721040726, 0.05468228831887245, 0.023437993600964546, -0.026670897379517555, -0.0016585593111813068, 0.0506533719599247, 0.018865622580051422, 0.005058683920651674, 0.022065317258238792, -0.0382821224629879, -0.025988388806581497, 0.015669377520680428, -0.020480694249272346, 0.002326823305338621, 0.02884816750884056, 0.046024177223443985, 0.01413733884692192, 0.06768074631690979, -0.016110161319375038, -0.00851240660995245, 0.029761340469121933, -0.007542429957538843, 0.010644488967955112, -0.018572263419628143, -0.04406736418604851, 0.04715476185083389, -0.024763891473412514, 0.052285172045230865, 0.03039144165813923, 0.021164851263165474, -0.012429467402398586, 0.006282367743551731, -0.008633142337203026, 0.017310116440057755, 0.003970871213823557, -0.05676783621311188, 0.041121046990156174, 0.01676408015191555, -0.007724076043814421, 0.020837558433413506, -0.008706128224730492, -0.020089445635676384, -0.052894845604896545, 0.015194375067949295, -0.018635960295796394, -0.009143076837062836, -0.040848925709724426, -0.015908261761069298, -0.0105209955945611, 0.037642642855644226, -0.00956183485686779, 0.01667896658182144, 0.028406178578734398, -0.019998857751488686, 0.005738592706620693, 0.01583009772002697, -0.008652348071336746, 0.020060719922184944, -0.0007695943349972367, -0.004200856201350689, 0.04196803644299507, -0.0012268769787624478, -0.08227301388978958, -0.01676015928387642, 0.030943522229790688, -0.017356693744659424, 0.0025900036562234163, -0.0023632850497961044, -0.00015088971122168005, 0.026606310158967972, -0.04375492036342621, 0.010212557390332222, -0.06177588552236557, -0.010946639813482761, -0.027579544112086296, 0.0013373197289183736, 0.02818538434803486, -0.0045101456344127655, -0.0055169896222651005, 0.02465120516717434, -0.023889297619462013, -0.041928935796022415, -0.0871160700917244, -0.061039041727781296, 0.019727326929569244, 0.03234368935227394, 0.00801297277212143, 0.005383671727031469, -0.022457759827375412, 0.03608160838484764, 0.0364898256957531, -0.012341205030679703, -0.08378293365240097, -0.040822092443704605, 0.01975659281015396, -0.03474319726228714, 0.026036329567432404, -0.0024862561840564013, 0.01474735140800476, 0.013527663424611092, -0.03103533200919628, -0.007563684601336718, 0.03195803612470627, 0.021528881043195724, 0.04199545830488205, 0.016819195821881294, -0.01480097509920597, -0.018450530245900154, 0.03445121645927429, 0.029185481369495392, 0.008002681657671928, -0.008777156472206116, -0.0046735769137740135, -0.0023944538552314043, -0.015540910884737968, -0.0309427622705698, -0.009076081216335297, 0.002471391810104251, -0.0033581098541617393, -0.030744213610887527, 0.02491695247590542, 0.022164233028888702, 0.002352978801354766, 0.0013146948767825961, 0.006021819077432156, -0.0037989672273397446, -0.021192561835050583, 0.019084813073277473, 0.0032085536513477564, -0.013637726195156574, 0.002533463528379798, -0.0029832893051207066, -0.028415892273187637, -0.03689615800976753, -0.004040205851197243, -0.016428431496024132, -0.009783647954463959, 0.04378733038902283, 0.05493282899260521, -0.019878726452589035, -0.011060971766710281, -0.014205090701580048, 0.02569182775914669, -0.054655008018016815, 0.022542588412761688, -0.03890538588166237, 0.0449163019657135, 0.026186130940914154, 0.06535187363624573, -0.030796412378549576, 0.027659976854920387, 0.03916579484939575, 0.001697135390713811, -0.10623197257518768, 0.03055989369750023, -0.035840172320604324, 0.014745393767952919, -0.015190201811492443, 0.0150548554956913, 0.02702048048377037, -0.012627502903342247, 0.006626669317483902, -0.009578707627952099, 0.0030626787338405848, -0.010610957629978657, 0.0012355149956420064, -0.0020508940797299147, -0.00012502136814873666, -0.015464224852621555, -0.0042702010832726955, 0.01844703033566475, -0.0029447779525071383, 0.004233800806105137, 0.029092296957969666, -0.012208197265863419, -0.03763847053050995, -0.042890191078186035, -0.02540305256843567, 0.0065123531967401505, 0.06603503972291946, 0.049205660820007324, 0.03260515257716179, -0.0490342378616333, 0.006419643294066191, -0.019781548529863358, 0.0012736076023429632, 0.05254562199115753, 0.006067217793315649, -0.02095068246126175, -0.02579309791326523, 0.0006906273192726076, 0.04425900802016258, 0.005449812859296799, -0.0033908544573932886, -0.0015054717659950256, 0.07203777879476547, 0.02363738976418972, -0.005205541383475065, -0.010158159770071507, 0.051076944917440414, 0.011340879835188389, 0.0024025756865739822, -0.02123829536139965, -0.02314937300980091, 0.0026748869568109512, -0.003891834057867527, 0.0302616935223341, -0.021593507379293442, 0.03139585629105568, 0.021733984351158142, 0.0356764979660511, 0.005641722120344639, 0.007385356817394495, -0.002728863386437297, 0.027851875871419907, 0.05049252510070801, 0.013187720440328121, -0.02314373478293419, 0.030925095081329346, 0.0411275252699852, 0.01668454147875309, 0.045250535011291504, 0.013917027972638607, -0.10897365212440491, 0.030958201736211777, 0.02705092541873455, 0.02504749409854412, -0.04894567281007767, -0.045043591409921646, -0.04627810791134834, -0.03663167729973793, 0.025151429697871208, -0.05005422607064247, 0.0024055643007159233, -0.008250473067164421, -0.015362344682216644, -0.029468264430761337, -0.054128244519233704, -0.0168131273239851, -0.0032637398689985275, -0.005725352559238672, 0.004380345344543457, -0.020933132618665695, 0.0015363965649157763, -0.025848785415291786, 0.055348530411720276, 0.004692929331213236, 0.03514616936445236, 0.0020196111872792244, -0.011613214388489723, 0.03607375919818878, 0.02364727109670639, -0.04409638047218323, -0.015221113339066505, 0.011372056789696217, -0.0037067781668156385, 0.013051924295723438, 0.019987892359495163, -0.02106207236647606, -0.031987130641937256, 0.02865694649517536, 0.025762546807527542, -0.014540866017341614, -0.0010692102368921041, -0.01350848563015461, 0.001714652986265719, 0.020704951137304306, 0.009169700555503368, 0.06824184954166412, 0.061373259872198105, 0.012001464143395424, -0.006762795615941286, 0.00015877730038482696, 0.046511661261320114, -0.023157037794589996, -0.05049452930688858, -0.005010005086660385, -0.023109368979930878, -0.022260580211877823, 0.01432479452341795, 0.01884520798921585, 0.032752737402915955, -0.05526932328939438, 0.007527871988713741, 0.009390238672494888, 0.05767803266644478, -0.012958900071680546, -0.015978926792740822, -0.006784146185964346, 0.004462842829525471, 0.005521982442587614, -0.026522232219576836, 0.03522245213389397, -0.015354529954493046, -0.01530145388096571, 0.017033519223332405, -0.03298034518957138, 0.029378892853856087, 0.000842251640278846, -0.054370276629924774, 0.015551893040537834, 0.018884046003222466, 0.02502099610865116, -0.03163627162575722, 0.010341738350689411, -0.01406370010226965, -0.01918930932879448, 0.008228331804275513, 0.019664781168103218, -0.006629600189626217, -0.013057703152298927, -0.0132847148925066, 0.039434775710105896, -0.01126883365213871, -0.008619899861514568, -0.05742216482758522, -0.033351339399814606, -0.009223481640219688, -0.0317036435008049, -0.033878475427627563, -0.03924603387713432, -0.01452447846531868, 0.006662297062575817, -0.032127123326063156, 0.011893932707607746, 0.06825735419988632, -0.02067500539124012, 0.00009646993567002937, -0.05386273190379143, 0.027816928923130035, 0.0565611757338047, 0.01545027270913124, -0.03304603695869446, 0.01937238685786724, -0.04694483429193497, -0.0052009946666657925, 0.016860419884324074, 0.0003456143895164132, -0.015453102067112923, 0.01621818169951439, -0.014767413958907127, 0.003844010876491666, -0.010100415907800198, 0.03162045776844025, -0.04273604974150658, 0.034185562282800674, 0.003965743351727724, 0.002667400985956192, -0.053290702402591705, -0.024647753685712814, -0.017271103337407112, -0.02719048224389553, -0.007447308860719204, -0.0017729487735778093, 0.004034901037812233, 0.01644490659236908, 0.010201601311564445, -0.010304086841642857, -0.00994754210114479, -0.01204589195549488, 0.057488176971673965, 0.019424978643655777, 0.04115563631057739, 0.022012626752257347, -0.027487682178616524, 0.03795985132455826, -0.021625451743602753, 0.006440248340368271, 0.007531740237027407, 0.03624270483851433, -0.059912484139204025, -0.04358399286866188, -0.006566002033650875, 0.029176659882068634, 0.02494443580508232, 0.004009849391877651, 0.03387806564569473, 0.057127904146909714, -0.015809260308742523, -0.01929657533764839, -0.02185828797519207, -0.0033886225428432226, 0.027175210416316986, -0.006374479737132788, 0.04661261662840843, -0.04479990899562836, -0.024144131690263748, 0.02177257463335991, 0.020736180245876312, 0.004266713280230761, 0.03993808105587959, 0.02453528717160225, 0.032893650233745575, 0.019634054973721504, -0.03012377768754959, -0.052459921687841415, 0.04432694613933563, -0.035064321011304855, 0.01915186457335949, -0.03308720514178276, -0.04411650076508522, 0.028481299057602882, 0.01325423363596201, 0.047276128083467484, -0.05702401325106621, -0.004259422887116671, -0.00653861416503787, -0.014132433570921421, 0.06804586946964264, -0.0330769382417202, 0.05172782763838768, 0.021005507558584213, 0.014988325536251068, 0.018039239570498466, 0.029283564537763596, -0.025569666177034378, -0.09087337553501129, 0.012324530631303787, -0.030034303665161133, -0.022525804117321968, 0.00912004429847002, -0.007959585636854172, -0.0005924347206018865, 0.021173721179366112, -0.020852984860539436, -0.024121154099702835, -0.00906260684132576, 0.04786788672208786, 0.010450471192598343, 0.08312888443470001, -0.047734323889017105, 0.02966379188001156, -0.04387280344963074, -0.01159774698317051, 0.12261660397052765, 0.08118359744548798, 0.021467827260494232, -0.11074593663215637, 0.015725282952189445, 0.03366971015930176, -0.00503214867785573, -0.023975910618901253, -0.030391311272978783, -0.020838284865021706, -0.04836556315422058, 0.054084550589323044, 0.07222797721624374, -0.021398086100816727, 0.007707820739597082, 0.06188008934259415, -0.027777941897511482, -0.007315640337765217, 0.01441858522593975, 0.009533463045954704, 0.01838461123406887, -0.01431798655539751, -0.044713325798511505, 0.019802460446953773, 0.009871398098766804, -0.03825805336236954, -0.033027585595846176, -0.00046162743819877505, 0.02256200462579727, 0.02184833027422428, -0.02847316488623619, -0.025678008794784546, 0.029590420424938202, 0.028240658342838287, 0.01922721602022648, -0.031656842678785324, 0.010380434803664684, -0.008690067566931248, 0.01836465485394001, 0.05050187557935715, 0.048904094845056534, 0.014075499027967453, 0.002448237268254161, 0.005527116358280182, -0.04400760307908058, -0.0236296858638525, -0.01210418064147234, 0.027721211314201355, -0.028197994455695152, -0.022697947919368744, -0.024399179965257645, 0.0003143677022308111, 0.03864660859107971, -0.006055151578038931, -0.013141389936208725, 0.030883561819791794, 0.02959502302110195, -0.022896870970726013, 0.033485524356365204, -0.012625446543097496, 0.013442281633615494, -0.004702777601778507, 0.042537178844213486, -0.016770603135228157, -0.06567525863647461, 0.014488335698843002, 0.004078734666109085, 0.014361538924276829, -0.01655515655875206, -0.021031929180026054, 0.035346418619155884, 0.0006457418203353882, -0.026606669649481773, -0.020721856504678726, 0.011834656819701195, 0.0026221119333058596, 0.03817440941929817, -0.04350147396326065, 0.00821063295006752, -0.05275462195277214, -0.053801000118255615, 0.029485849663615227, -0.03098861500620842, 0.004033647943288088, -0.03670250624418259, 0.03381675109267235, 0.042715296149253845, -0.0014904981944710016, -0.009946586564183235, 0.0038890147116035223, -0.017506804317235947, 0.029466554522514343, 0.018417512997984886, -0.047512803226709366, -0.005236010067164898, -0.02619275264441967, -0.024455826729536057, 0.025387393310666084, -0.05516451597213745, 0.04037974402308464, 0.0009962408803403378, 0.019726084545254707, 0.003496777033433318, 0.008084005676209927, -0.029625510796904564, 0.03767053782939911, 0.01640588603913784, -0.04627081751823425, 0.0009089013910852373, 0.008469345048069954, 0.013275288976728916, 0.020161619409918785, 0.018224850296974182, -0.02811911515891552, -0.048797547817230225, 0.008704406209290028, -0.04547452926635742, -0.0734843835234642, 0.06430374085903168, 0.004009850323200226, -0.006301993038505316, -0.02779250591993332, 0.015181012451648712, -0.033830638974905014, -0.04646836221218109, -0.017262190580368042, 0.021559856832027435, 0.005550130736082792, -0.007282523438334465, -0.032221779227256775, -0.008744764141738415, 0.033710043877363205, -0.01278469804674387, -0.004934654105454683, 0.013834498822689056, 0.015534885227680206, -0.005337367299944162, 0.020591367036104202, -0.02263069711625576, -0.02245672047138214, 0.006113607436418533, -0.01984805427491665, -0.026179201900959015, -0.00243542087264359, 0.000579940911848098, 0.020252712070941925, 0.02806401066482067, -0.026849286630749702, -0.055026520043611526, 0.07099084556102753, -0.010824079625308514, 0.004457882139831781, -0.0326881930232048, 0.01894097402691841, 0.03266911208629608, 0.002981617348268628, -0.017090586945414543, -0.0013581657549366355, -0.0012518655275925994, 0.009911543689668179, 0.04143521934747696, 0.009881986305117607, -0.015505285933613777, 0.009672502055764198, -0.0037834898103028536, -0.006109926383942366, 0.005635814741253853, -0.022618645802140236, 0.046274058520793915, 0.015440830960869789, -0.02326205000281334, 0.024860929697752, -0.009468713775277138, 0.022412355989217758, -0.07621239870786667, -0.007788551039993763, -0.0104958051815629, 0.045294634997844696, 0.04365619644522667, -0.0483638159930706, 0.018545038998126984, 0.003171309130266309, -0.029411425814032555, -0.04082734137773514, -0.021860450506210327, -0.01786949299275875, -0.029998932033777237, 0.0025580518413335085, -0.000535710365511477, -0.004523371811956167, 0.02193031646311283, 0.0047573852352797985, 0.01762513630092144, 0.018802830949425697, -0.0006490166997537017, -0.03800321742892265, -0.004424965009093285, -0.016989482566714287, 0.034244127571582794, -0.030612796545028687, 0.04225855693221092, -0.04744357988238335, -0.00458458811044693, 0.04077175259590149, 0.007788557093590498, 0.06393326818943024, 0.014753074385225773, 0.03731467202305794, -0.008902228437364101, 0.1140679121017456, 0.004334353841841221, 0.0366193950176239, 0.007340381387621164, -0.008840681985020638, 0.0033013145439326763, 0.01185362134128809, -0.04178006574511528, 0.0010526455007493496, -0.0030376999638974667, 0.0008313481230288744, 0.0006889811484143138, 0.03582307696342468, 0.023378729820251465, 0.010856417007744312, -0.028257591649889946, -0.05568540841341019, 0.0224069282412529, -0.004105939529836178, 0.0097130062058568, -0.04193420708179474, -0.02055903896689415, 0.047638773918151855, -0.005719562526792288, -0.013679545372724533, -0.008889148011803627, 0.0020400246139615774, -0.011811930686235428, 0.04205071181058884, -0.002244572388008237, 0.003167885122820735, -0.07833408564329147, -0.023222610354423523, -0.005380101501941681, -0.0390288345515728, -0.03709772229194641, 0.03166422247886658, -0.03111419454216957, 0.00005193251126911491, -0.025364404544234276, 0.0027672466821968555, 0.010458908975124359, -0.0005252654082141817, 0.038397036492824554, -0.055538009852170944, 0.07643071562051773, -0.022841332480311394, 0.027674565091729164, 0.0018931074300780892, -0.0029966398142278194, -0.01656789891421795, 0.000830590259283781, 0.0605425126850605, -0.03458704799413681, -0.018020804971456528, -0.013778764754533768, 0.0712345540523529, 0.019884981215000153, -0.026591619476675987, 0.03875381126999855, 0.00539246154949069, -0.024888381361961365, -0.018533267080783844, -0.024288875982165337, 0.007896359078586102, 0.008873604238033295, 0.017527960240840912, -0.014969862066209316, 0.020533407106995583, 0.009819232858717442, -0.015887847170233727, 0.016911061480641365, 0.002268462674692273, -0.019828857854008675, 0.07462677359580994, -0.022495392709970474, 0.00799823459237814, 0.02072181925177574, -0.009341525845229626, -0.06005514785647392, 0.032458070665597916, -0.032620251178741455, -0.02070094272494316, -0.0420670360326767, -0.001954753417521715, -0.044039659202098846, -0.0212454441934824, 0.03265465050935745, -0.017063897103071213, -0.02724958397448063, -0.001635828404687345, 0.0315580777823925, 0.003818848170340061, 0.08174119144678116, 0.018661312758922577, 0.004939813166856766, 0.023001624271273613, 0.0038514025509357452, 0.0027586801443248987, 0.01284328568726778, 0.062015507370233536, 0.003185305744409561, -0.038523271679878235, 0.047138094902038574, -0.007311728782951832, 0.013090971857309341, -0.023572133854031563, 0.02261231280863285, -0.06441859900951385, -0.04769832268357277, 0.025714967399835587, -0.004180003423243761, 0.04798179864883423, -0.02446981891989708, 0.00018968008225783706, 0.038110241293907166, -0.029953695833683014, 0.011824761517345905, -0.053148288279771805, -0.025859201326966286, -0.029190095141530037, 0.019374005496501923, -0.011116374284029007, -0.015057752840220928, 0.023921819403767586, 0.03898102045059204, 0.013491216115653515, -0.023844894021749496, 0.016959747299551964, -0.008350069634616375, 0.01813407987356186, -0.005704572424292564, -0.008923371322453022, -0.03435509651899338, 0.00039843018748797476, -0.02301045134663582, -0.039774712175130844, 0.01213842909783125, 0.028736911714076996, 0.05432473495602608, -0.03127657249569893, -0.012675728648900986, 0.01372784748673439, 0.05338016897439957, -0.07267311960458755, 0.03449428826570511, -0.02304203063249588, -0.011580066755414009, -0.008816050365567207, -0.013598445802927017 ]
<p>Are there any statistical concepts or theories on how to effectively measure recency to where recent events are given more weight than older ones. I'm creating a logistic regression model and would like to apply an adjustment to various factors based on the events recency.</p> <p>...or, is it purely up to me to come up with an arbitrary formula?</p> <p>For example: One of my projects is predicting via logistic regression the performance of pro golfers in upcoming tournaments. Their recent form (how they played last week) is generally more important than how they played six months ago. Are there any specific techniques/approaches that tap into this concept?</p>
73,739
[ -0.027054252102971077, -0.04331568256020546, -0.018598610535264015, -0.01338260155171156, 0.04574311897158623, 0.02646080031991005, 0.016025319695472717, 0.005312417633831501, 0.037177179008722305, 0.005615778733044863, 0.013714113272726536, 0.040334735065698624, 0.018931036815047264, 0.018151303753256798, 0.04235978052020073, -0.006490902043879032, 0.01767612248659134, -0.014888196252286434, -0.0014932109043002129, 0.0052037485875189304, 0.011318101547658443, 0.0056933071464300156, 0.00488134752959013, 0.01315245684236288, -0.02960924059152603, 0.013247930444777012, 0.027392026036977768, 0.010727282613515854, -0.0034514034632593393, 0.05560930445790291, -0.0006630733842030168, -0.0158346239477396, 0.03940267115831375, 0.03002295270562172, 0.004881397821009159, 0.002289521973580122, 0.0022404964547604322, -0.022016432136297226, -0.02937931939959526, 0.031554948538541794, -0.05051499977707863, -0.03155781701207161, -0.028067421168088913, 0.04964812844991684, -0.0070335753262043, 0.027740584686398506, -0.03283650800585747, -0.034804973751306534, 0.05624956265091896, -0.05079865828156471, 0.08393696695566177, -0.034026823937892914, 0.029576892033219337, 0.019163018092513084, -0.032114312052726746, 0.011583121493458748, 0.059763915836811066, 0.07289618998765945, -0.009298857301473618, -0.05349959433078766, -0.021542424336075783, -0.022865863516926765, -0.0036172643303871155, -0.010921462439000607, -0.022342277690768242, 0.014622962102293968, -0.009247568435966969, -0.035195495933294296, 0.08073131740093231, -0.012472693808376789, -0.011555482633411884, 0.020936327055096626, 0.049922093749046326, 0.034339454025030136, 0.011761576868593693, -0.060959361493587494, 0.01698395423591137, -0.016842370852828026, 0.04131074249744415, -0.013032144866883755, -0.02062578871846199, -0.005461222026497126, 0.052428845316171646, 0.027356242761015892, 0.03289363533258438, -0.022938253358006477, 0.07249017804861069, -0.041716113686561584, 0.02062767930328846, 0.021322552114725113, -0.03958016633987427, -0.019086286425590515, 0.010877626948058605, -0.022499054670333862, -0.05932809039950371, 0.01826348342001438, -0.019104456529021263, 0.03575954958796501, 0.0320742130279541, 0.016376473009586334, -0.007940275594592094, -0.06536014378070831, 0.01506978552788496, 0.052763085812330246, -0.03530527651309967, -0.01241590827703476, -0.037916574627161026, -0.018709274008870125, 0.0027943451423197985, -0.03009098581969738, -0.007085922174155712, 0.0004824091156478971, 0.004219996277242899, 0.003544233739376068, 0.019773678854107857, 0.01067278441041708, -0.03500227630138397, 0.005627019330859184, 0.07034996151924133, 0.037978969514369965, 0.018258458003401756, -0.05646766349673271, 0.02282131277024746, -0.02364354021847248, -0.03161201626062393, 0.035882942378520966, 0.02466941438615322, -0.029381457716226578, -0.019894225522875786, 0.04730899631977081, 0.011702506802976131, -0.027690978720784187, 0.017174674198031425, -0.017080655321478844, 0.037417132407426834, 0.02898528426885605, -0.07028567045927048, -0.03469841927289963, 0.03447902202606201, 0.010604801587760448, -0.011300281621515751, -0.06241792067885399, -0.019088473170995712, 0.0225949939340353, 0.03542335703969002, 0.04420292750000954, 0.020421361550688744, 0.03623732179403305, 0.029389813542366028, 0.021073462441563606, -0.022016117349267006, -0.01707882434129715, -0.009108907543122768, -0.010679355822503567, -0.00881926529109478, -0.07956843078136444, -0.0008191383676603436, 0.027221892029047012, -0.021326787769794464, 0.0072658732533454895, 0.044824082404375076, -0.01745731569826603, -0.023174583911895752, -0.007920755073428154, 0.01280494499951601, -0.002409650944173336, 0.07066860795021057, -0.011661623604595661, -0.010089357383549213, 0.007276652380824089, 0.020458264276385307, 0.003995548002421856, 0.05783701315522194, 0.031403034925460815, 0.01271458063274622, -0.022069932892918587, 0.005216103047132492, 0.004757489077746868, -0.02470993623137474, -0.006884247530251741, -0.01804465800523758, -0.02015237882733345, 0.009044388309121132, -0.005593369249254465, 0.021564561873674393, 0.037039708346128464, -0.009624187834560871, -0.020360715687274933, 0.0602397546172142, 0.004406237043440342, -0.029018964618444443, -0.04583831503987312, 0.014028318226337433, -0.007813464850187302, 0.007993129082024097, 0.021955950185656548, -0.01299820002168417, 0.0443146750330925, -0.01967335306107998, 0.006325200200080872, -0.005655280780047178, -0.03621785342693329, 0.006399712525308132, -0.05477925390005112, -0.000851689197588712, 0.005964972078800201, 0.031021922826766968, -0.011282561346888542, 0.06649477034807205, -0.05490514636039734, -0.04465923458337784, 0.011222618632018566, -0.06468252837657928, 0.025496192276477814, -0.05047076940536499, -0.03719186782836914, 0.013734775595366955, -0.037999898195266724, -0.03001292422413826, 0.015440674498677254, -0.0431293286383152, 0.06793567538261414, 0.04043050482869148, 0.0020874813199043274, -0.009657465852797031, 0.019328689202666283, 0.011495753191411495, -0.0062527721747756, -0.004534856881946325, -0.045280106365680695, -0.053551267832517624, -0.005335414316505194, 0.010320036672055721, 0.015282930806279182, -0.0001930481957970187, 0.033370524644851685, 0.0649070218205452, 0.027087397873401642, 0.0013807876966893673, 0.054017551243305206, -0.03384382650256157, -0.00028837897116318345, -0.015925727784633636, 0.02728063240647316, -0.0047484333626925945, 0.006214938126504421, 0.042348090559244156, 0.0032347103115171194, 0.006843841169029474, -0.01509405579417944, -0.010304506868124008, 0.017829235643148422, 0.016420191153883934, 0.0070342146791517735, -0.03624279052019119, -0.059994377195835114, 0.07802868634462357, -0.03845997154712677, 0.027842536568641663, 0.025332069024443626, 0.04005788639187813, 0.00742926262319088, 0.0023268298245966434, -0.009865418076515198, 0.039104413241147995, 0.03222920745611191, -0.05169323459267616, 0.01225760392844677, 0.0178981926292181, 0.0014252654509618878, -0.0030517815612256527, -0.026692360639572144, -0.029106685891747475, -0.020909305661916733, -0.012443128041923046, 0.03340471163392067, 0.029905200004577637, 0.01615738496184349, 0.04184466600418091, -0.034145787358284, -0.028907403349876404, -0.012366285547614098, 0.007570007350295782, 0.012251782231032848, -0.047847945243120193, -0.0008393102907575667, 0.033487435430288315, 0.005315623711794615, 0.019613733515143394, -0.025546425953507423, -0.02105242758989334, 0.03232267498970032, 0.02724851667881012, -0.044298410415649414, -0.019125156104564667, -0.016280604526400566, -0.001894915010780096, -0.013275820761919022, -0.03616735339164734, 0.050549574196338654, 0.01727285049855709, -0.05035978928208351, 0.006197127979248762, -0.04332393407821655, 0.008110690861940384, -0.05357877537608147, -0.0293144341558218, 0.0004367901128716767, -0.0271505918353796, 0.010295625776052475, 0.022753966972231865, -0.01539382804185152, -0.0038662925362586975, -0.06828784942626953, -0.059497322887182236, 0.03523768112063408, -0.043256595730781555, 0.053647611290216446, -0.001520176650956273, -0.007016377057880163, 0.05789601430296898, 0.011875351890921593, -0.014910644851624966, -0.0492333360016346, 0.004332035779953003, -0.015352373942732811, -0.018205000087618828, 0.001382684800773859, 0.01885206066071987, -0.0056928349658846855, 0.03699531778693199, 0.0028160412330180407, -0.002444844227284193, 0.028315460309386253, 0.018752437084913254, 0.006708522792905569, 0.009945605881512165, 0.01737132854759693, -0.0137406587600708, -0.006315185222774744, -0.005517642479389906, -0.050034817308187485, 0.021687375381588936, -0.023769525811076164, 0.02924387715756893, 0.0055894143879413605, -0.04376960173249245, 0.028525911271572113, -0.016403403133153915, -0.006220816168934107, 0.025830719619989395, 0.02038085274398327, -0.013360302895307541, -0.006413998547941446, -0.025768838822841644, 0.012312441132962704, -0.001149111078120768, -0.004080289043486118, 0.03066936507821083, 0.05114578455686569, 0.05975371226668358, -0.029145825654268265, -0.0014515456277877092, -0.031013771891593933, 0.0023319944739341736, 0.04183323681354523, -0.056146442890167236, -0.02367747761309147, 0.021014539524912834, 0.007623108569532633, 0.00836931448429823, -0.01212301291525364, -0.04916619136929512, -0.009310713037848473, -0.08389157056808472, -0.007794766221195459, 0.02231520786881447, 0.07016180455684662, 0.008142964914441109, 0.003012645523995161, 0.032381322234869, -0.015276335179805756, 0.032804861664772034, -0.0018208379624411464, -0.06578996777534485, 0.052882324904203415, -0.024148091673851013, 0.015140357427299023, 0.014963041059672832, 0.011258146725594997, 0.04160623624920845, -0.04053175821900368, -0.03214270994067192, -0.006908763665705919, 0.021728230640292168, -0.029153546318411827, 0.012720349244773388, -0.05769258365035057, -0.009936220943927765, 0.003382864175364375, -0.018676575273275375, -0.008204621262848377, 0.00291652069427073, 0.061119720339775085, 0.03704464063048363, 0.004391164984554052, -0.02344723418354988, -0.02834521047770977, 0.035444702953100204, 0.003345077857375145, 0.043354280292987823, 0.033765148371458054, 0.012009336613118649, -0.05292705446481705, 0.0588507242500782, 0.005593474488705397, 0.011703520081937313, 0.03390318900346756, -0.018885698169469833, -0.027672812342643738, -0.04217845946550369, -0.030081219971179962, 0.01738470047712326, -0.0041362205520272255, 0.03632604703307152, 0.020328843966126442, 0.040781501680612564, 0.019434796646237373, -0.051643140614032745, 0.010099133476614952, 0.04802316799759865, 0.022352108731865883, -0.000044429689296521246, -0.030300447717308998, 0.031306128948926926, 0.019941870123147964, -0.034035902470350266, 0.013161245733499527, 0.029082179069519043, 0.011870750226080418, -0.003557274816557765, 0.029250627383589745, 0.0008001089445315301, -0.05025651305913925, -0.018623806536197662, 0.016645047813653946, 0.012086526490747929, 0.02683662809431553, -0.040974438190460205, 0.04724143072962761, 0.036126405000686646, 0.051033731549978256, 0.03406839445233345, 0.014732449315488338, -0.08623047173023224, 0.005678351502865553, 0.03540150076150894, 0.05245068296790123, -0.06696252524852753, -0.011156806722283363, -0.018492287024855614, 0.020280715078115463, 0.047512296587228775, -0.05511179566383362, 0.012772994115948677, -0.012407497502863407, 0.019996078684926033, -0.017195934429764748, -0.036488018929958344, -0.02500884048640728, 0.04339977726340294, -0.029377439990639687, 0.05117330700159073, -0.013842205516994, -0.024129604920744896, -0.05603707581758499, 0.03087018057703972, 0.020574824884533882, 0.06146230921149254, 0.01881352625787258, -0.011683213524520397, -0.03684922680258751, 0.013487294316291809, -0.02647458389401436, -0.05367010831832886, -0.0017342590726912022, 0.004613518249243498, 0.0029828734695911407, 0.017793728038668633, 0.014212812297046185, -0.016012880951166153, -0.010169471614062786, 0.007338966242969036, -0.045203156769275665, 0.014064310118556023, -0.023828698322176933, 0.04049711301922798, 0.003217958612367511, -0.022695986554026604, 0.04527021944522858, 0.055811807513237, 0.0155333261936903, 0.017590472474694252, 0.02850070595741272, 0.009114893153309822, 0.00151545531116426, -0.0013541282387450337, -0.013896651566028595, -0.016514021903276443, 0.0013820758322253823, 0.029580729082226753, -0.04855846241116524, 0.030652562156319618, 0.032094065099954605, -0.01814265176653862, -0.03185887634754181, 0.0306109469383955, 0.021010026335716248, -0.008562089875340462, 0.008067037910223007, 0.007418063003569841, -0.02312353253364563, -0.0026441558729857206, 0.003617184003815055, 0.017989467829465866, -0.00781932007521391, 0.008096093311905861, -0.016680315136909485, 0.030361395329236984, -0.03346007689833641, -0.0321105420589447, -0.0022119295317679644, -0.02259531244635582, 0.044868603348731995, 0.00441329088062048, -0.02566094696521759, 0.03464866429567337, -0.07266126573085785, 0.019703151658177376, 0.010754852555692196, 0.018522407859563828, 0.030452709645032883, -0.03998544067144394, -0.012374683283269405, 0.018796073272824287, -0.005996375810354948, -0.050435155630111694, -0.04413232579827309, 0.049012187868356705, 0.013743037357926369, -0.02179238200187683, -0.02240278571844101, 0.022228611633181572, -0.01927478238940239, 0.021632669493556023, -0.018906351178884506, 0.0873648151755333, 0.005613126326352358, -0.04822308570146561, 0.01612897962331772, 0.025460822507739067, 0.0693822056055069, -0.009984663687646389, -0.030112970620393753, 0.0035366378724575043, -0.014007802121341228, -0.012119724415242672, -0.003927017096430063, -0.0038523334078490734, -0.03196224570274353, 0.015040606260299683, -0.0013365322956815362, 0.01555539295077324, 0.029330579563975334, -0.026789914816617966, 0.006418132688850164, 0.0008048319723457098, -0.017278172075748444, 0.021919939666986465, -0.02996593900024891, 0.018330391496419907, 0.00759889418259263, 0.003060185583308339, -0.012040013447403908, 0.00688951276242733, 0.019871175289154053, 0.002270932774990797, 0.01702450029551983, 0.015075627714395523, 0.0013665459118783474, 0.0066225603222846985, 0.03225293755531311, 0.009326530620455742, -0.022616039961576462, -0.005947906523942947, -0.014584571123123169, 0.05547764152288437, 0.03571808338165283, 0.004871458746492863, 0.0037266830913722515, 0.015423496253788471, -0.02984176203608513, -0.01909511163830757, -0.022328689694404602, 0.00039021173142828047, 0.053288426250219345, -0.02106226049363613, 0.08294666558504105, 0.04425868019461632, 0.05203716829419136, -0.01147855632007122, -0.008288565091788769, 0.01161277573555708, -0.014964110217988491, -0.05306340754032135, 0.026277504861354828, -0.024830354377627373, 0.008973662741482258, 0.030651835724711418, 0.006278479937463999, 0.004469255916774273, 0.045163169503211975, 0.0035686236806213856, 0.024822399020195007, 0.04983026161789894, -0.018845098093152046, -0.007597313262522221, 0.006821162533015013, -0.052450668066740036, 0.00948615837842226, -0.05543862283229828, -0.015113775618374348, 0.031599581241607666, 0.008637204766273499, 0.0002969526103697717, -0.05113150179386139, -0.05461359769105911, -0.06158112362027168, -0.01534148957580328, 0.006877261679619551, -0.00432951794937253, 0.035627081990242004, 0.01888754591345787, 0.013679111376404762, 0.029876522719860077, 0.006630207411944866, -0.016346294432878494, -0.08065170794725418, -0.019345276057720184, -0.011979198083281517, -0.036244094371795654, -0.01407563965767622, 0.009734787978231907, -0.0140622453764081, 0.010316158644855022, -0.02219865657389164, -0.027363643050193787, 0.02250165119767189, 0.013223396614193916, 0.008743759244680405, 0.12215271592140198, 0.03241289407014847, -0.0020024750847369432, 0.011588577181100845, -0.014247646555304527, 0.09536904096603394, 0.0812443196773529, 0.023131482303142548, -0.05546068027615547, 0.012375200167298317, 0.030561447143554688, 0.026168422773480415, -0.009753543883562088, -0.01927839405834675, -0.004625141620635986, -0.0144265191629529, 0.060885947197675705, 0.04463162645697594, 0.016610482707619667, -0.014362110756337643, 0.042996037751436234, -0.06133049353957176, -0.015630312263965607, -0.00910654291510582, 0.01128956489264965, 0.02196536958217621, -0.0020920063834637403, -0.03972940519452095, 0.02761782519519329, 0.03523039072751999, 0.011957943439483643, 0.024166783317923546, -0.022434689104557037, -0.024225134402513504, -0.02167593128979206, 0.0035623295698314905, 0.00988440029323101, 0.023066600784659386, 0.04705600067973137, -0.025047533214092255, 0.017387118190526962, 0.029516005888581276, -0.01775960624217987, 0.01966518722474575, 0.008586023934185505, -0.0007365524652414024, -0.012637113220989704, -0.014294533990323544, 0.010914054699242115, -0.044253889471292496, -0.06578174233436584, -0.08822448551654816, 0.011762222275137901, -0.025385664775967598, 0.0069939084351062775, 0.002811291953548789, -0.04002203792333603, 0.008346243761479855, -0.030959894880652428, -0.057962510734796524, 0.05441214144229889, 0.012155620381236076, -0.027334008365869522, 0.0019808257929980755, -0.008459782227873802, 0.01752743124961853, 0.014908096753060818, 0.0665694922208786, 0.029910989105701447, -0.011849026195704937, -0.025207387283444405, -0.07747337967157364, 0.01805976778268814, -0.013837064616382122, -0.01174123864620924, -0.0037798199336975813, -0.01363303791731596, -0.04604937136173248, -0.00469285249710083, 0.015520310029387474, -0.022982120513916016, 0.0027659914921969175, -0.01429376844316721, -0.010522576980292797, -0.024859845638275146, -0.00804538931697607, -0.009856771677732468, -0.01953703910112381, -0.005402762442827225, -0.050009988248348236, 0.015472433529794216, 0.0585167370736599, 0.029413405805826187, 0.02949848771095276, 0.01045822724699974, -0.028062961995601654, 0.055698879063129425, 0.03273234888911247, -0.07087840884923935, -0.025747688487172127, 0.0015254407189786434, -0.02558504045009613, -0.012087839655578136, -0.019463669508695602, 0.07741287350654602, 0.02786434255540371, -0.03061477653682232, 0.007165356073528528, 0.027792325243353844, 0.006641279440373182, 0.03186401352286339, 0.014117754995822906, -0.06107194349169731, -0.06423817574977875, -0.04106639698147774, 0.00296298461034894, -0.023223474621772766, -0.051995161920785904, -0.034980908036231995, -0.03167704492807388, -0.0013498581247404218, -0.05418011546134949, -0.027446549385786057, 0.03429975360631943, 0.0033624700736254454, 0.0004507427802309394, -0.005356954410672188, 0.011248345486819744, -0.034735120832920074, -0.013938026502728462, -0.007781544234603643, -0.027845509350299835, -0.006263171788305044, 0.03343920037150383, -0.007705184165388346, -0.009313471615314484, 0.025242773815989494, 0.002511997940018773, 0.027070730924606323, -0.023643922060728073, -0.0005982300499454141, -0.02840670756995678, 0.02510121278464794, -0.03703555837273598, -0.0650293156504631, 0.005569988861680031, -0.052330467849969864, -0.013359494507312775, 0.03482244163751602, 0.010841583833098412, 0.00009625766688259318, -0.007214085664600134, 0.0118974344804883, 0.0022701648995280266, 0.02831898257136345, -0.01136314682662487, -0.03435453772544861, -0.013783738948404789, 0.02890031598508358, 0.0174113642424345, 0.001575243310071528, 0.013716274872422218, 0.01761494390666485, -0.01692083664238453, -0.0028037598822265863, 0.04677162691950798, 0.01451494637876749, -0.0170042272657156, 0.004355667624622583, -0.008878531865775585, -0.0028954322915524244, -0.0024471369106322527, -0.03485463559627533, 0.045892734080553055, 0.07106123119592667, -0.03550543636083603, 0.03197186440229416, 0.015293999575078487, 0.018317505717277527, -0.09493732452392578, -0.00046821037540212274, 0.028609981760382652, -0.014708842150866985, 0.03100253827869892, -0.0640314593911171, 0.024692533537745476, -0.008091402240097523, -0.016376841813325882, 0.016566477715969086, 0.03739781677722931, 0.0037239184603095055, -0.017305875197052956, 0.017556199803948402, 0.017029326409101486, 0.030543643981218338, 0.023819053545594215, 0.01083514466881752, 0.012043982744216919, 0.017757438123226166, 0.04106970503926277, -0.04998425021767616, -0.04657446965575218, 0.0037817966658622026, 0.012063262052834034, -0.04412035271525383, 0.02656037174165249, -0.050433963537216187, -0.0545550137758255, 0.04571773111820221, -0.009633056819438934, 0.010319538414478302, 0.011147593148052692, 0.016732798889279366, 0.013127726502716541, 0.028864197432994843, 0.008088594302535057, -0.04766426607966423, 0.011569942347705364, -0.0034200414083898067, 0.012948621064424515, 0.035387177020311356, -0.02953287400305271, 0.024390101432800293, -0.01088594552129507, -0.035861507058143616, -0.01940128020942211, -0.025167280808091164, -0.017507225275039673, -0.03397679701447487, 0.029662907123565674, -0.002262712921947241, 0.012332119047641754, 0.0053012738935649395, 0.027893347665667534, -0.0397949144244194, -0.006507642101496458, 0.022082297131419182, 0.010276091285049915, -0.021470921114087105, 0.031098760664463043, -0.0018681524088606238, -0.022375252097845078, 0.010754752904176712, 0.00004786741192219779, -0.022973215207457542, -0.05568692088127136, 0.015401271171867847, 0.010406270623207092, -0.018301261588931084, -0.05672241747379303, -0.03813223913311958, -0.03841569274663925, 0.06573930382728577, -0.01928268000483513, -0.0036013643257319927, 0.045752640813589096, 0.0015554075362160802, 0.04328737035393715, -0.09520981460809708, 0.06281532347202301, 0.035950079560279846, -0.014062597416341305, -0.015260239131748676, -0.023580403998494148, -0.006500430405139923, 0.016692612320184708, 0.08632423728704453, -0.04825684428215027, -0.03423472121357918, -0.012250963598489761, 0.013166689313948154, -0.025125665590167046, -0.022005638107657433, 0.019756004214286804, -0.01910020224750042, -0.018541982397437096, -0.016247527673840523, -0.0291098952293396, 0.030328696593642235, 0.005599334370344877, -0.004567557480186224, -0.015096642076969147, -0.0016283047152683139, 0.006999233737587929, 0.015089082531630993, 0.04567214101552963, 0.019134635105729103, 0.0024405415169894695, 0.029674485325813293, 0.028780480846762657, 0.034409672021865845, 0.01001453772187233, -0.010662784799933434, -0.0810723528265953, 0.06956968456506729, -0.042254120111465454, -0.03416949883103371, 0.036717019975185394, 0.005934405606240034, -0.018177742138504982, -0.03430923819541931, -0.019336290657520294, 0.029070807620882988, 0.002002134919166565, 0.04173476994037628, 0.01181335560977459, 0.025942301377654076, 0.04040092974901199, 0.011875650845468044, 0.023540358990430832, 0.011656894348561764, -0.02494075521826744, -0.013272472657263279, 0.020707156509160995, 0.06234695389866829, 0.011087200604379177, 0.019889891147613525, 0.013373948633670807, 0.027284352108836174, 0.008761114440858364, -0.002459263661876321, 0.042827390134334564, -0.018177438527345657, 0.016754785552620888, -0.02288980409502983, -0.01656552404165268, 0.0022965813986957073, 0.03697603568434715, 0.0025291978381574154, 0.0027430623304098845, -0.03143533319234848, 0.004742572084069252, -0.021173102781176567, -0.03037882223725319, -0.023853521794080734, -0.014276077970862389, 0.05764814093708992, -0.00015858608821872622, 0.013759607449173927, 0.015182594768702984, 0.046576619148254395, 0.015053353272378445, 0.01016185712069273, 0.013207346200942993, 0.04474596679210663, -0.012892763130366802, 0.016714833676815033, -0.008803257718682289, -0.04503573849797249, -0.06194542348384857, -0.027966685593128204, 0.014073213562369347, 0.037901464849710464, 0.045066505670547485, 0.02349255420267582, -0.04810591787099838, -0.01238823588937521, 0.05719202756881714, -0.07131499797105789, -0.0070590367540717125, -0.07904163748025894, 0.026796013116836548, -0.04266572371125221, -0.03960852324962616 ]
<p>For my data, I need to run numerous linear regression analyses, separately for each of my two groups of subjects as well as different conditions. Together, I would have to run approximately 40 regression analyses across the 3 conditions for each group. I'm aware that we should correct for multiple comparisons for the regression coefficients within a model. But in my case, should I also do a similar correction for the p-value associated with the regression model itself (ie: the F test)? </p> <p>For example, if in one condition, I have to run 25 regression analyses for each group, would it make sense to divide alpha=.05 by 25?</p> <p>I've been going through different websites and textbooks, but can't seem to find an answer. Any suggestions/help would be appreciated!</p>
36,205
[ -0.03618234395980835, 0.013208026997745037, -0.02388641983270645, 0.02035367861390114, 0.0586526095867157, 0.02004898339509964, -0.0007824729545973241, -0.022197943180799484, 0.030162185430526733, 0.007837856188416481, 0.03708535432815552, 0.015193493105471134, 0.03755540773272514, -0.01689218357205391, -0.0017977230018004775, -0.0022915981244295835, -0.006089572794735432, -0.0033539673313498497, -0.00629029655829072, -0.03227671608328819, -0.007278196979314089, 0.03495785593986511, -0.028747616335749626, -0.002991511719301343, -0.001802347251214087, 0.07202621549367905, 0.047707922756671906, 0.0018947073258459568, 0.01487195398658514, 0.0017227628268301487, -0.02161489613354206, -0.00953382533043623, 0.0355331152677536, 0.07120757550001144, 0.008943572640419006, -0.01446428894996643, 0.006882694084197283, -0.026806849986314774, -0.0463004931807518, 0.04477046802639961, -0.01575430855154991, -0.016425278037786484, 0.021530043333768845, 0.00043289875611662865, 0.013886061497032642, 0.017922766506671906, 0.0026071073953062296, -0.05356345698237419, 0.035986412316560745, -0.020718947052955627, 0.07945539802312851, 0.0015237813349813223, 0.0349544882774353, 0.036309462040662766, -0.0075662871822714806, 0.015603911131620407, 0.07543379813432693, 0.043215472251176834, 0.03942594304680824, -0.0483740009367466, -0.0005202743341214955, -0.01853085495531559, 0.027265114709734917, -0.008786752820014954, -0.03913417086005211, 0.0006043920293450356, -0.01674480177462101, -0.023616168648004532, 0.025874273851513863, 0.007037662900984287, 0.0115927429869771, 0.015413336455821991, 0.0574093721807003, -0.030874744057655334, 0.01667887344956398, -0.02254686877131462, -0.013670054264366627, 0.014224590733647346, 0.06617279350757599, 0.02021823823451996, -0.020801888778805733, 0.020162023603916168, 0.05405266582965851, 0.059996187686920166, 0.012283184565603733, -0.0350383035838604, 0.05989472195506096, -0.026624523103237152, 0.007543792016804218, -0.000762487412430346, -0.03350837156176567, -0.0003473396645858884, 0.04161341115832329, 0.007247010245919228, -0.023785118013620377, 0.020048413425683975, -0.03646467253565788, 0.03268333896994591, -0.009969700127840042, 0.03483192250132561, -0.013212576508522034, -0.044195108115673065, -0.009535443037748337, 0.03150566667318344, -0.029829515144228935, 0.024353742599487305, -0.05067849159240723, -0.0011111992644146085, 0.0346829816699028, -0.041989970952272415, -0.017627568915486336, 0.03133536875247955, -0.03838106989860535, 0.00018206880486104637, 0.024063652381300926, -0.010664822533726692, -0.01850433461368084, -0.009582840837538242, 0.0840272381901741, 0.04714179411530495, 0.03913665935397148, -0.022609025239944458, 0.03106399066746235, 0.012996331788599491, -0.05673816800117493, 0.02912021614611149, -0.01104108989238739, -0.02652863785624504, -0.04965701326727867, 0.07891758531332016, 0.005439897067844868, -0.04374515637755394, -0.0059541817754507065, -0.016895662993192673, 0.025653325021266937, 0.006220817565917969, -0.05867810547351837, -0.06053583696484566, 0.023196501657366753, -0.0010666882153600454, -0.00832519493997097, -0.047135911881923676, -0.01693720743060112, 0.013330026529729366, 0.06356050819158554, 0.017882710322737694, 0.01749809831380844, -0.001570471446029842, 0.031899455934762955, -0.010998750105500221, -0.039904333651065826, -0.011011279188096523, -0.0025244003627449274, -0.015168200246989727, -0.008117655292153358, -0.12088655680418015, 0.025488490238785744, -0.0072883786633610725, 0.02902984619140625, 0.044542569667100906, 0.0348958820104599, 0.008390827104449272, -0.019087957218289375, 0.01976131461560726, -0.0016357385320588946, -0.020004484802484512, 0.0528961718082428, -0.031940262764692307, 0.04626402258872986, -0.0036848036106675863, -0.010546468198299408, 0.018158335238695145, -0.004313756246119738, 0.04374890774488449, 0.04928851127624512, -0.008021039888262749, 0.024239573627710342, -0.034526702016592026, 0.01642787642776966, 0.024231374263763428, -0.045066144317388535, -0.011169522069394588, -0.007052084431052208, -0.00753134535625577, 0.031565211713314056, 0.03881783038377762, 0.0019295074744150043, -0.04630817472934723, 0.04573769122362137, -0.056300245225429535, -0.050470512360334396, -0.07665769755840302, 0.017293894663453102, -0.007004336453974247, -0.02957933582365513, 0.033592503517866135, 0.0023267457727342844, 0.023753318935632706, -0.02686501108109951, -0.04677960276603699, -0.01055978238582611, -0.007569590117782354, 0.06245226413011551, -0.055717647075653076, 0.021267861127853394, 0.06614715605974197, 0.046715423464775085, -0.024784479290246964, 0.05273091048002243, -0.05896047502756119, -0.039626557379961014, 0.023182665929198265, -0.04550180211663246, -0.0005055993096902966, -0.007398615125566721, 0.01113422866910696, -0.001307514263316989, -0.009169860742986202, -0.03036271035671234, 0.028217321261763573, -0.06143312156200409, 0.05581747740507126, 0.062436118721961975, 0.014942843466997147, 0.0003380526613909751, 0.0018711037700995803, 0.013038610108196735, 0.012276509776711464, -0.03838614374399185, -0.020544854924082756, -0.053851738572120667, 0.013804729096591473, 0.018998058512806892, -0.015274681150913239, -0.03768707066774368, 0.0076544019393622875, 0.09873441606760025, 0.024543389678001404, 0.006757793016731739, 0.009323304519057274, 0.012320108711719513, -0.013846628367900848, 0.002603993285447359, 0.03408993035554886, 0.04628903418779373, 0.038023442029953, 0.003505910048261285, -0.00992200244218111, 0.020566942170262337, -0.00019509713456500322, 0.03557276725769043, 0.04353511705994606, -0.016955973580479622, -0.016195174306631088, -0.0017609742935746908, -0.004351015668362379, 0.01454861368983984, -0.035625703632831573, 0.023588888347148895, 0.045520417392253876, -0.014178712852299213, -0.029308274388313293, 0.027556609362363815, -0.007011823356151581, 0.0028642357792705297, 0.05785360932350159, -0.04038991406559944, 0.039566561579704285, 0.02592984214425087, -0.032185353338718414, -0.01337442547082901, -0.06109218671917915, -0.02064199186861515, -0.02788163162767887, -0.0015927775530144572, 0.013593392446637154, 0.001183702377602458, 0.03215761482715607, -0.03554338216781616, 0.005855840165168047, -0.0035550210159271955, -0.006510209757834673, 0.027518996968865395, -0.05209018290042877, -0.06724203377962112, 0.01587045006453991, -0.025029610842466354, -0.03553847223520279, 0.030710870400071144, -0.008813133463263512, 0.009075175039470196, -0.002259564120322466, 0.012785415165126324, -0.031141720712184906, -0.05151442065834999, -0.007912393659353256, -0.002447424689307809, -0.02211667224764824, -0.023454628884792328, 0.026304049417376518, 0.013097467832267284, -0.029365943744778633, 0.00912981852889061, -0.055212292820215225, 0.015092693269252777, -0.02024867571890354, 0.0023960701655596495, 0.0032604604493826628, 0.02137347310781479, -0.009712085127830505, -0.0011488522868603468, -0.051316771656274796, -0.020601369440555573, -0.052433617413043976, -0.05863514542579651, -0.0012628767872229218, 0.024247659370303154, 0.022374460473656654, 0.022233782336115837, -0.014846672303974628, 0.05993253365159035, 0.03847111016511917, -0.017215806990861893, -0.042732227593660355, 0.022225894033908844, -0.04365399107336998, -0.03844625875353813, 0.0019989446736872196, 0.006065064109861851, -0.005311054643243551, 0.027821512892842293, -0.021453289315104485, 0.022596579045057297, 0.045779917389154434, -0.007060389965772629, -0.013048523105680943, 0.0052055069245398045, 0.018062399700284004, -0.013543901965022087, 0.015324154868721962, 0.026530932635068893, -0.0069664339534938335, -0.0007325430051423609, 0.0054311007261276245, 0.033286817371845245, 0.009950822219252586, -0.03435784578323364, 0.008467371575534344, 0.022398879751563072, 0.003924699500203133, -0.027460727840662003, -0.011015074327588081, 0.009870750829577446, 0.0017698111478239298, -0.011788894422352314, 0.018547100946307182, 0.03281600773334503, -0.03225455805659294, 0.023167649284005165, 0.0543084517121315, 0.05232629552483559, -0.035384293645620346, -0.04824428632855415, -0.01939392276108265, -0.011846723966300488, 0.009954295121133327, -0.014911636710166931, -0.01935558207333088, 0.017873652279376984, 0.017394166439771652, 0.049310069531202316, -0.010545208118855953, -0.05997536703944206, 0.03136071190237999, -0.08343992382287979, -0.011679013259708881, -0.02750301919877529, 0.03746261075139046, -0.009524453431367874, 0.019986700266599655, 0.007077287882566452, -0.04125221446156502, 0.03171103820204735, 0.004608896095305681, -0.07206744700670242, 0.059709664434194565, -0.004416613839566708, -0.021144038066267967, 0.02535093203186989, 0.0035335118882358074, 0.010579361580312252, -0.03450809046626091, 0.021869998425245285, -0.015572793781757355, -0.005309153348207474, -0.018412895500659943, 0.0021490873768925667, -0.014427833259105682, -0.014641054905951023, -0.012235675938427448, 0.03499416634440422, 0.01244667824357748, -0.031236058101058006, 0.026268616318702698, -0.01164262741804123, -0.034453894942998886, -0.011623866856098175, 0.00317786424420774, 0.04387804865837097, 0.03752344474196434, 0.033254608511924744, 0.024644726887345314, 0.012546675279736519, -0.024612843990325928, 0.03580818697810173, -0.03259439766407013, 0.0382317416369915, 0.052637889981269836, -0.04993755370378494, -0.02397206239402294, -0.00996887031942606, -0.02567257732152939, 0.0028285880107432604, -0.0024903910234570503, 0.013071493245661259, -0.004962061997503042, 0.01629078947007656, 0.036572717130184174, -0.06567665934562683, 0.03559473901987076, 0.06294406205415726, 0.01112325582653284, -0.04412257671356201, -0.03483546897768974, -0.024166682735085487, -0.0050596799701452255, -0.005525499116629362, 0.0021068830974400043, 0.027918599545955658, 0.015620804391801357, 0.008094181306660175, 0.043855685740709305, -0.046130139380693436, -0.03513443097472191, -0.007175793405622244, 0.052729878574609756, 0.02713966928422451, 0.022092267870903015, -0.05465877056121826, 0.028043534606695175, 0.024055933579802513, -0.003285113023594022, 0.03796050697565079, 0.0035320655442774296, -0.07754591852426529, 0.027455871924757957, 0.015210207551717758, 0.05525534972548485, -0.049537044018507004, 0.009888438507914543, -0.020965920761227608, -0.0013934689341112971, 0.05109826475381851, -0.03659046068787575, 0.027860235422849655, 0.005921239033341408, 0.042487651109695435, -0.010255787521600723, -0.02980608120560646, -0.06679748743772507, 0.016398897394537926, 0.004942930769175291, 0.011824596673250198, -0.027169499546289444, -0.009841924533247948, -0.031127383932471275, 0.04418260231614113, 0.011378965340554714, 0.07073264569044113, -0.0029032339807599783, -0.023764459416270256, -0.0060827299021184444, 0.003377350280061364, -0.011518844403326511, -0.043318308889865875, -0.004446522798389196, -0.03388754650950432, 0.007445975206792355, 0.037121549248695374, 0.007522283121943474, -0.003165198490023613, 0.028000466525554657, 0.02752169407904148, -0.03743420168757439, -0.03916734457015991, -0.026399554684758186, 0.033920902758836746, 0.031821802258491516, 0.015880528837442398, 0.08826826512813568, 0.006542311515659094, -0.029657278209924698, -0.0057824100367724895, -0.028756234794855118, 0.015835007652640343, -0.02410264126956463, -0.015158651396632195, -0.050194691866636276, -0.026580501347780228, 0.01334452535957098, 0.041484009474515915, -0.010603982955217361, 0.012357843108475208, 0.026745231822133064, 0.008785722777247429, 0.010749912820756435, -0.005342691671103239, 0.004028831142932177, 0.002681896323338151, 0.017368877306580544, 0.007063611410558224, -0.023378685116767883, -0.034525688737630844, 0.01908714510500431, -0.007897177711129189, 0.020660866051912308, 0.03761902451515198, -0.030221398919820786, 0.018380995839834213, 0.009119043126702309, -0.036128103733062744, -0.017729612067341805, -0.05308777466416359, 0.033574994653463364, -0.01290492806583643, 0.04403643682599068, -0.021983392536640167, -0.01270237099379301, 0.016273895278573036, 0.03647623583674431, -0.004820440895855427, 0.02802330069243908, -0.05762726441025734, 0.04896888509392738, -0.02946357987821102, -0.014020616188645363, -0.0734611228108406, -0.019930409267544746, 0.04132847487926483, 0.007368232123553753, -0.019624315202236176, -0.03334685042500496, 0.005722572561353445, -0.028539514169096947, -0.009987171739339828, -0.00914726685732603, 0.06080309674143791, -0.035202570259571075, -0.05359480157494545, -0.017564186826348305, 0.009187067858874798, 0.07564032077789307, -0.002931457944214344, -0.025957878679037094, 0.02525792457163334, -0.014865496195852757, -0.038421425968408585, -0.021594984456896782, 0.00879291258752346, -0.037416279315948486, 0.009963790886104107, -0.04588242247700691, 0.01673910766839981, -0.002315109595656395, 0.006642773747444153, -0.01680729351937771, 0.0014762240462005138, 0.0014081289991736412, 0.028643952682614326, -0.0335320308804512, 0.040957748889923096, -0.026773780584335327, 0.004739636089652777, -0.018311062827706337, 0.027481159195303917, 0.005179520696401596, 0.04765674099326134, 0.02170284278690815, -0.0033818271476775408, -0.03392745926976204, 0.034059397876262665, 0.0938887745141983, -0.00876112561672926, 0.027839548885822296, -0.01730654016137123, -0.01632416993379593, 0.027630645781755447, 0.02511752024292946, -0.04136409983038902, -0.025290392339229584, 0.021171430125832558, -0.02982143871486187, -0.028897680342197418, 0.016157403588294983, 0.011465402320027351, 0.05910327658057213, -0.037069905549287796, 0.018616145476698875, 0.0891268327832222, 0.03547157719731331, 0.004435465671122074, -0.03215007856488228, 0.010799451731145382, -0.009380421601235867, 0.0136089026927948, 0.06287800520658493, -0.018128976225852966, -0.010096072219312191, 0.03719482198357582, 0.015894722193479538, 0.0025549514684826136, 0.04036234691739082, 0.0009350310428999364, 0.009562404826283455, 0.018423736095428467, -0.025818686932325363, -0.05692530423402786, 0.039529237896203995, -0.058659959584474564, 0.002137591829523444, -0.0538298524916172, -0.021939966827630997, 0.03605137765407562, 0.06007009372115135, 0.024596286937594414, -0.03172577545046806, -0.022505151107907295, -0.033472590148448944, 0.007250044960528612, -0.01802704855799675, -0.012153852730989456, 0.01301172748208046, -0.028528736904263496, 0.04761066660284996, 0.0020560915581882, 0.029922211542725563, -0.016322113573551178, -0.059087108820676804, -0.05812171474099159, -0.024862580001354218, 0.011616028845310211, 0.043672967702150345, -0.008502942509949207, -0.04387148469686508, 0.020567981526255608, -0.030608437955379486, 0.029439833015203476, -0.0036084724124521017, 0.0433216355741024, 0.015398768708109856, 0.05789521336555481, -0.018867379054427147, 0.010580885224044323, -0.001546709449030459, -0.04253530129790306, 0.09189771115779877, 0.12012665718793869, 0.04616594314575195, -0.04730281978845596, 0.0585491806268692, -0.02899138629436493, -0.006700850557535887, -0.00590258976444602, 0.018810125067830086, -0.013601642102003098, -0.008902336470782757, 0.06821364164352417, 0.08247856795787811, -0.02181515470147133, -0.018827853724360466, 0.06714742630720139, -0.03492269665002823, -0.008368960581719875, 0.005821354687213898, 0.029877789318561554, 0.024438828229904175, -0.01763249933719635, -0.021506451070308685, -0.019577952101826668, -0.020774850621819496, 0.007120122667402029, -0.019611719995737076, -0.002354830503463745, 0.011131862178444862, 0.01765599101781845, -0.039857540279626846, 0.0018414969090372324, 0.010316343978047371, 0.016489319503307343, -0.047190066426992416, 0.008176539093255997, 0.0042523886077106, -0.024612633511424065, -0.01606902852654457, 0.049579109996557236, -0.040519215166568756, 0.025300005450844765, -0.03076164238154888, 0.011198734864592552, -0.026973560452461243, 0.010341544635593891, -0.013610242865979671, 0.031933415681123734, -0.020473403856158257, -0.04570860043168068, -0.011467509903013706, 0.035134799778461456, -0.0013723026495426893, -0.018328575417399406, -0.037584297358989716, 0.033408381044864655, 0.022396504878997803, -0.029926657676696777, -0.00906679593026638, -0.014130045659840107, 0.019539102911949158, 0.018378999084234238, 0.013981164433062077, 0.02632378414273262, -0.021608073264360428, -0.03255690261721611, -0.024427974596619606, 0.0577067956328392, 0.0019041001796722412, 0.014454871416091919, 0.004404401872307062, -0.006588638294488192, -0.024256886914372444, 0.017283780500292778, 0.017708178609609604, 0.027903102338314056, 0.01687719114124775, 0.002032572403550148, -0.01872452348470688, -0.04020039737224579, -0.039579566568136215, 0.017921943217515945, -0.01309959776699543, -0.017158346250653267, -0.050248779356479645, -0.020284324884414673, 0.0315273180603981, 0.02156253345310688, 0.011054331436753273, 0.004117127973586321, -0.022614726796746254, 0.03641630709171295, 0.03312280774116516, -0.05133892968297005, -0.008985377848148346, -0.027285875752568245, -0.026430955156683922, -0.0051364717073738575, -0.041342053562402725, 0.05816815048456192, 0.0032752056140452623, -0.01015324518084526, 0.01958523876965046, 0.05070948973298073, 0.03594699129462242, 0.001955266110599041, -0.0033115807455033064, -0.05047457665205002, 0.012569330632686615, 0.040116533637046814, -0.00033949402859434485, -0.009814615361392498, -0.020111622288823128, -0.03038213402032852, -0.0243866927921772, 0.007108800113201141, -0.05847381055355072, -0.02576356753706932, 0.02941230870783329, -0.016007734462618828, 0.01409076526761055, -0.03745190054178238, 0.018966229632496834, -0.06075181066989899, 0.017746703699231148, 0.014008505269885063, -0.025180257856845856, -0.008539230562746525, -0.00037468975642696023, -0.03888588398694992, 0.012466678395867348, 0.060775864869356155, -0.005716143641620874, 0.038995109498500824, -0.023567356169223785, 0.03019457310438156, 0.01661285199224949, 0.0498080812394619, -0.0024392511695623398, 0.0008282286580651999, 0.05913224071264267, -0.03169972077012062, -0.01319778710603714, 0.00828588381409645, -0.0023077817168086767, 0.023987339809536934, -0.010834467597305775, 0.013138355687260628, -0.05497514829039574, 0.040719784796237946, -0.04295290634036064, -0.03504045307636261, -0.026153184473514557, -0.01628030464053154, -0.0036457490641623735, 0.029506593942642212, 0.02971733547747135, -0.028488021343946457, 0.006199309136718512, 0.02231396548449993, 0.033575236797332764, -0.005416423548012972, -0.009551615454256535, -0.021285563707351685, -0.032404426485300064, 0.02903284691274166, -0.019286008551716805, -0.034792687743902206, 0.039169155061244965, 0.04101327806711197, -0.004482300020754337, 0.016760455444455147, 0.02794748917222023, 0.024638880044221878, -0.07796996086835861, -0.01574024371802807, 0.000808569835498929, 0.02044784277677536, 0.022031202912330627, -0.04874200001358986, 0.01791294664144516, 0.017572132870554924, -0.02284487895667553, 0.010472944006323814, -0.006512975785881281, 0.010363593697547913, -0.03743000701069832, -0.012612685561180115, -0.006981003098189831, 0.03448851779103279, -0.0012866982724517584, 0.023325784131884575, 0.01389163639396429, -0.000050967413699254394, 0.03466902673244476, -0.04200376197695732, 0.0008314352016896009, 0.02172270230948925, 0.009753970429301262, -0.05119502171874046, 0.023747628554701805, -0.005284570157527924, -0.07128020375967026, 0.015911702066659927, -0.0025709867477416992, 0.05128435418009758, 0.030475299805402756, 0.023461004719138145, 0.006288972683250904, 0.0696757435798645, 0.015753205865621567, 0.022720465436577797, -0.005107940640300512, 0.008152173832058907, 0.013053779490292072, 0.021580711007118225, -0.03708977624773979, 0.012956682592630386, -0.007369834464043379, -0.013703787699341774, -0.038706764578819275, 0.0037669865414500237, 0.021843772381544113, -0.005001974292099476, -0.007305815815925598, 0.02192019112408161, 0.0033084386959671974, -0.03887466341257095, -0.003991889767348766, -0.025151563808321953, -0.009557395242154598, 0.030826469883322716, 0.0473538339138031, -0.03978312760591507, 0.007310536224395037, -0.024196557700634003, -0.0320802666246891, -0.01788216270506382, -0.03705322742462158, -0.002990484470501542, -0.044011492282152176, 0.00903353188186884, 0.01423563901335001, -0.03608563542366028, -0.06419918686151505, -0.006968649569898844, -0.032984983175992966, 0.01059524342417717, -0.04673905670642853, 0.006277544889599085, 0.02347841113805771, 0.006376400589942932, 0.015681888908147812, -0.05272705852985382, 0.04944469779729843, 0.013955943286418915, 0.0001518669887445867, -0.0026339746546000242, 0.009835547767579556, -0.028916429728269577, 0.01464814692735672, 0.043195098638534546, 0.0037862726021558046, 0.009049353189766407, 0.0020538039971143007, -0.0005131977377459407, -0.0006952911498956382, -0.06485296785831451, 0.04931940138339996, 0.021436316892504692, -0.02068583481013775, -0.06559166312217712, -0.010076011531054974, 0.01679901033639908, -0.0021140503231436014, -0.0017483836272731423, -0.013345920480787754, 0.018711142241954803, -0.007021790836006403, 0.02212177775800228, 0.020322654396295547, 0.014833771623671055, -0.01838797889649868, 0.02743450738489628, 0.023352904245257378, 0.041554372757673264, 0.03000565618276596, 0.02589053474366665, -0.06418782472610474, 0.032752443104982376, -0.01910662092268467, 0.002317429054528475, -0.007700170855969191, -0.006551275961101055, -0.05509921535849571, -0.05324731394648552, 0.038759324699640274, 0.005956313107162714, -0.05326490104198456, 0.01844288781285286, 0.005645568948239088, 0.004000301007181406, 0.020990978926420212, -0.029809407889842987, 0.038691822439432144, 0.01847252808511257, -0.0461210235953331, -0.02211032249033451, 0.0034490020480006933, 0.04532385617494583, 0.02856309339404106, 0.01563970185816288, 0.05444338545203209, -0.012495305389165878, 0.05647324025630951, 0.0281472597271204, 0.02511310577392578, -0.007662539836019278, -0.0030804441776126623, 0.0020675661507993937, -0.0037071704864501953, 0.017603058367967606, -0.03420959413051605, 0.011974440887570381, 0.00967992190271616, -0.04875931143760681, -0.007198921870440245, -0.020475618541240692, -0.01591120846569538, -0.007348464336246252, -0.023912325501441956, 0.01733887754380703, 0.0543399304151535, -0.0012898101704195142, 0.03034733235836029, -0.03022519126534462, -0.03109317272901535, 0.025818252936005592, -0.01381725538522005, 0.024493785575032234, -0.03867476433515549, -0.01887660287320614, -0.012697793543338776, -0.025028586387634277, -0.03264166787266731, -0.00905623473227024, 0.032532867044210434, 0.03220566362142563, 0.004339973442256451, -0.042444754391908646, -0.03129451349377632, -0.01117537822574377, 0.04610397294163704, -0.03208914399147034, -0.0649619922041893, -0.018792102113366127, 0.0258234441280365, 0.044430509209632874, -0.0057348222471773624 ]
<p>I have a surgical database in which there are approximately 100,000 observations and 200 features. Each observation corresponds to a separate patient while the features correspond to either preoperative, perioperative, or postoperative variables (e.g. preoperative labs, length of operation, and days until death). As such some of the features are factors, while others are continuous data types. The database is not "clean" in that many of the features contain NAs because that data was not collected. Each patient has some feature with NAs in it, so when I try to select only observations without NAs that results in 0 observations.</p> <p>That being all said my end goal is to see whether any of these preoperative variables might be predictive of mortality. Initially I wanted to use L1 regularization (lasso) via glmnet to perform feature selection, however because of the NAs I can't run it. Are there any alternatives or techniques to bypass this problem? I assume that it's more common than not to have a database with NAs, so I wanted to see if you guys could fill me in. Thanks!</p>
43,183
[ -0.018698586151003838, -0.007809017319232225, -0.043704695999622345, -0.0012936097336933017, 0.05677446350455284, -0.021356601268053055, -0.008636043407022953, -0.014480690471827984, 0.03140994533896446, -0.04675735533237457, 0.00011963947326876223, 0.02691059000790119, 0.018106911331415176, -0.008773425593972206, -0.0014444483676925302, -0.008041703142225742, -0.03554472327232361, -0.027815859764814377, 0.020749201998114586, -0.009680712595582008, 0.003651644801720977, 0.02864760532975197, 0.038351766765117645, 0.00859442725777626, -0.015101551078259945, 0.06594949215650558, -0.018719511106610298, -0.030477959662675858, -0.03154531493782997, 0.025806309655308723, -0.03345268964767456, -0.014540326781570911, -0.022064369171857834, 0.05739225819706917, 0.00009335744107374921, 0.006052270997315645, -0.030460629612207413, -0.01688295789062977, -0.013784688897430897, 0.05683634430170059, 0.03718307614326477, -0.03875632956624031, 0.0011133876396343112, 0.043173134326934814, -0.02011779509484768, 0.018416009843349457, 0.0011331996647641063, -0.03060254268348217, 0.025711432099342346, -0.04313303157687187, 0.05731268227100372, -0.011987568810582161, 0.07112672179937363, 0.04651113227009773, -0.030154826119542122, 0.020952438935637474, 0.035136621445417404, 0.07628684490919113, 0.0002176586422137916, -0.03674367070198059, -0.059766825288534164, -0.03914560750126839, 0.00016738660633563995, -0.0340379998087883, 0.0014898621011525393, 0.01963810995221138, -0.016816359013319016, -0.015375979244709015, 0.021142257377505302, -0.0036091732326895, 0.027186846360564232, -0.0001550284359836951, 0.014896128326654434, -0.004797916393727064, 0.0030487000476568937, -0.018752779811620712, -0.009391460567712784, -0.0215042345225811, 0.05046999081969261, 0.0008284901850856841, -0.017127688974142075, -0.016020191833376884, 0.01744254119694233, 0.05250043049454689, 0.024066371843218803, 0.005710220895707607, 0.04326266050338745, -0.022600309923291206, 0.03980116546154022, 0.0079416548833251, -0.036192212253808975, -0.026416385546326637, 0.03191863372921944, 0.03216465190052986, -0.03767218813300133, 0.019349511712789536, -0.0057429843582212925, 0.045643217861652374, 0.021762484684586525, 0.0004947954439558089, -0.008677856996655464, -0.03881324082612991, 0.010319528169929981, 0.028106162324547768, -0.013930541463196278, -0.0037545887753367424, -0.04578535631299019, 0.004445088095963001, -0.019201835617423058, 0.0007247357279993594, -0.013061081990599632, 0.008745868690311909, 0.029085680842399597, -0.033725690096616745, 0.0033466601744294167, -0.03171595558524132, -0.012790464796125889, -0.050092168152332306, 0.010077983140945435, 0.11322158575057983, 0.05843017250299454, -0.017158903181552887, 0.03938436508178711, -0.02307174913585186, -0.03263721242547035, -0.02674471028149128, -0.0007143312250263989, -0.01796819269657135, -0.014334077015519142, 0.05035518854856491, -0.028704315423965454, -0.04211767762899399, 0.04239983484148979, -0.020030103623867035, 0.039561785757541656, -0.002874776953831315, -0.06709103286266327, -0.05367046967148781, 0.028129717335104942, -0.025921253487467766, 0.027107425034046173, -0.02738942950963974, -0.008462424390017986, 0.01965019665658474, 0.06355022639036179, 0.04189448803663254, 0.012285120785236359, 0.027796966955065727, -0.007089205086231232, -0.02510650083422661, -0.006092392839491367, -0.01053596567362547, -0.03995431214570999, -0.004694881848990917, -0.029750864952802658, -0.07271726429462433, 0.03406382352113724, 0.017780626192688942, 0.0006202791701070964, -0.012456263415515423, -0.010940385982394218, -0.004291388671845198, -0.006892432924360037, 0.012972349300980568, 0.011465686373412609, -0.03757912665605545, 0.085842065513134, 0.01910047046840191, 0.03609223663806915, 0.052045729011297226, 0.01103158574551344, 0.016948554664850235, 0.05425780639052391, 0.05022171512246132, 0.029575258493423462, 0.020648658275604248, 0.019065944477915764, -0.013714292086660862, 0.041118841618299484, 0.03677888214588165, 0.017855238169431686, -0.025874337181448936, -0.02615726739168167, -0.009419647045433521, 0.035985227674245834, 0.04624878242611885, 0.013952698558568954, -0.03393989056348801, 0.076191246509552, -0.009046410210430622, -0.005482981912791729, -0.03569789603352547, 0.013645443134009838, 0.028645843267440796, -0.016639873385429382, 0.02615170180797577, 0.017922785133123398, 0.015466330572962761, -0.01124678086489439, -0.008036776445806026, -0.009113000705838203, -0.04097357764840126, 0.05476516857743263, -0.0372026152908802, -0.02432859130203724, -0.003162665758281946, 0.02363346889615059, -0.03366442769765854, 0.06362093240022659, -0.01540964376181364, -0.051281750202178955, 0.009520010091364384, -0.02982431836426258, -0.0000010840028608072316, -0.025806793943047523, -0.03100886195898056, 0.0008655664278194308, 0.0017219956498593092, -0.052935611456632614, 0.04898485913872719, -0.07517629861831665, 0.056727390736341476, 0.04221520200371742, 0.027537379413843155, 0.039108533412218094, 0.0012418933911249042, 0.02502080611884594, -0.019470104947686195, -0.012953454628586769, -0.01324794813990593, -0.0473271906375885, -0.026942316442728043, 0.04384934529662132, 0.01953774504363537, -0.025218157097697258, 0.037367794662714005, 0.06684309989213943, 0.0035199038684368134, 0.05284005403518677, 0.021933885291218758, -0.024834563955664635, -0.018490329384803772, 0.009517593309283257, 0.0027402827981859446, -0.0038185773883014917, -0.009175117127597332, -0.0066278972662985325, 0.014613421633839607, 0.04771481081843376, 0.026122013106942177, 0.002170919207856059, 0.032367363572120667, 0.01779189519584179, -0.016134802252054214, -0.008839018642902374, -0.04635246470570564, 0.03309936821460724, 0.005512294825166464, 0.020782744511961937, 0.0213398989289999, 0.04446987435221672, -0.015509720891714096, 0.031120171770453453, -0.011795696802437305, 0.03649458289146423, 0.012894097715616226, -0.042439185082912445, 0.06124076619744301, 0.012144823558628559, -0.08020008355379105, 0.03616606071591377, -0.005247459746897221, -0.022557547315955162, -0.06583738327026367, 0.0009472247329540551, 0.027094069868326187, 0.0012279358925297856, 0.032555125653743744, -0.0276944562792778, -0.038948141038417816, 0.027284685522317886, -0.05967296287417412, 0.018993346020579338, 0.04767509549856186, -0.027362853288650513, -0.016329623758792877, -0.0048782797530293465, 0.03453133627772331, 0.03676072135567665, -0.018109409138560295, -0.030679406598210335, 0.03494873642921448, -0.02529040165245533, -0.05199700966477394, -0.012185811996459961, -0.043281253427267075, 0.03669671714305878, 0.023200778290629387, -0.03127312287688255, 0.027964424341917038, 0.027994239702820778, -0.07440213859081268, 0.01815621741116047, -0.012848674319684505, -0.013879544101655483, -0.026541676372289658, 0.00932468380779028, 0.031230371445417404, -0.002576330676674843, -0.016117872670292854, 0.045724980533123016, -0.028024209663271904, 0.04656900465488434, -0.06541348248720169, -0.037905529141426086, 0.019825709983706474, -0.006759554147720337, 0.0035470440052449703, 0.016143422573804855, -0.00808960385620594, 0.050549667328596115, 0.03836371749639511, -0.02867916412651539, -0.03036307916045189, -0.029761940240859985, -0.04033618047833443, -0.036519937217235565, 0.028328653424978256, -0.018755724653601646, 0.046465881168842316, 0.037122733891010284, -0.01300885807722807, -0.007882416248321533, 0.08635223656892776, 0.014014261774718761, -0.0008052061893977225, 0.029232129454612732, 0.004507385194301605, 0.009548070840537548, 0.04503488540649414, 0.025902511551976204, -0.018102779984474182, 0.014547247439622879, -0.018607081845402718, 0.024647356942296028, -0.006169338244944811, -0.059554573148489, -0.016214508563280106, -0.017281390726566315, 0.03568034619092941, -0.01570836827158928, -0.01832655631005764, 0.008538426831364632, 0.011150785721838474, -0.008168652653694153, 0.051063422113657, 0.04560104012489319, -0.041916005313396454, 0.01866079680621624, 0.04717516526579857, -0.0011150009231641889, -0.005555285606533289, 0.03431004285812378, 0.004516683053225279, -0.024966083467006683, 0.0036179497838020325, -0.027276717126369476, 0.02324480377137661, 0.030944546684622765, 0.058540668338537216, 0.004315634723752737, -0.016876649111509323, -0.026719726622104645, 0.0466519370675087, -0.024158291518688202, -0.0004742234596051276, 0.038522981107234955, 0.05961222946643829, 0.015454227104783058, 0.01950206607580185, 0.021414978429675102, 0.017634034156799316, 0.008811547420918941, 0.004889200441539288, -0.0542508140206337, 0.030858581885695457, -0.012259431183338165, 0.004455839283764362, 0.03288738429546356, -0.017808837816119194, 0.01715817116200924, -0.02203255146741867, -0.011770635843276978, -0.0056787827052176, 0.03799137473106384, -0.025528088212013245, 0.03091152384877205, -0.05212720111012459, 0.0032080351375043392, -0.0376083068549633, 0.007544373162090778, 0.008881459012627602, 0.0204763226211071, 0.007773811463266611, 0.012368918396532536, 0.0089181549847126, -0.003241109661757946, -0.03182404488325119, 0.0116373086348176, -0.0226005669683218, 0.05928880348801613, 0.003948728553950787, 0.007336948532611132, -0.04998702183365822, 0.02342825010418892, 0.009310656227171421, 0.015117695555090904, 0.011015481315553188, 0.03342621400952339, -0.008352396078407764, -0.057448361068964005, -0.037703149020671844, -0.02603296749293804, 0.017586469650268555, 0.016969887539744377, -0.010797959752380848, 0.04656713083386421, 0.013927171938121319, -0.051792822778224945, -0.014847262762486935, 0.07234594970941544, 0.04894683510065079, -0.009587602689862251, 0.0019625744316726923, -0.0045990608632564545, 0.012336318381130695, -0.0019613339100033045, 0.06381946802139282, 0.008695506490767002, 0.0051804096437990665, -0.00680482666939497, 0.0012030011275783181, -0.012541187927126884, 0.006278322543948889, -0.0208908598870039, 0.04132527858018875, 0.06759364157915115, -0.025161869823932648, -0.03993355482816696, 0.013585707172751427, 0.061046354472637177, 0.03684501722455025, 0.02915150299668312, 0.03175996243953705, -0.11893685907125473, -0.007888742722570896, 0.04017401114106178, 0.0563492625951767, -0.03305407986044884, -0.06919722259044647, -0.029008466750383377, -0.019963541999459267, 0.03286007419228554, 0.005930989980697632, 0.0151854008436203, -0.025501230731606483, -0.010069316253066063, 0.0006961002945899963, -0.05220411345362663, -0.004374833311885595, 0.01702095754444599, -0.03882935270667076, 0.020834866911172867, -0.024590419605374336, -0.03241365775465965, -0.0014137348625808954, -0.02798428013920784, -0.0016218399396166205, 0.05431598797440529, -0.010617182590067387, -0.015430391766130924, 0.01495183352380991, 0.051724012941122055, -0.008559826761484146, -0.05990738794207573, 0.015676727518439293, -0.01715279556810856, -0.040439147502183914, 0.053188785910606384, 0.006537843961268663, -0.030478300526738167, 0.012010861188173294, 0.01792694441974163, -0.0401420034468174, -0.013694536872208118, -0.017009926959872246, 0.032939791679382324, -0.002373390132561326, 0.0012052757665514946, 0.022303374484181404, 0.021149437874555588, 0.00973503477871418, -0.022809475660324097, -0.020388009026646614, 0.013743170537054539, -0.026544520631432533, -0.04614633694291115, -0.03613952174782753, -0.046686623245477676, -0.024578314274549484, -0.009574522264301777, 0.02414357103407383, 0.05258319526910782, 0.030307946726679802, 0.02809615433216095, 0.023853149265050888, 0.04463730379939079, 0.017881667241454124, -0.025930698961019516, -0.0007227867608889937, 0.018714575096964836, 0.008501635864377022, 0.000535222643520683, 0.030224492773413658, -0.01731214113533497, -0.0018456731922924519, 0.024402055889368057, -0.029766930267214775, 0.008983887732028961, -0.01457879226654768, -0.025419259443879128, 0.008444593288004398, -0.007194845471531153, 0.01618128828704357, 0.009013495407998562, 0.05801980942487717, -0.013422215357422829, -0.05122116208076477, -0.00030134612461552024, 0.008949087001383305, 0.013315476477146149, -0.00994162354618311, -0.06477946043014526, 0.04835343360900879, -0.028143614530563354, -0.01090147066861391, -0.07270361483097076, -0.031037693843245506, 0.01518787257373333, 0.04070683568716049, -0.02203024923801422, -0.048705071210861206, 0.03344902768731117, -0.0327117033302784, 0.02349487878382206, 0.01524808444082737, 0.031682681292295456, -0.05763769522309303, 0.018388625234365463, 0.028530437499284744, 0.017156299203634262, 0.06640343368053436, -0.01404654048383236, -0.013749323785305023, 0.015618111938238144, 0.00466052396222949, 0.015504212118685246, 0.016904473304748535, 0.007773612625896931, -0.027637846767902374, 0.0026068356819450855, -0.054586492478847504, 0.010585975833237171, 0.01957849971950054, 0.006461392622441053, 0.006475506350398064, -0.002390919253230095, -0.0224520955234766, 0.027527010068297386, -0.0218841340392828, 0.012454264797270298, 0.0005050762556493282, 0.0036090330686420202, -0.0378655306994915, 0.022818826138973236, 0.0103278374299407, -0.01523530576378107, -0.0038799215108156204, -0.005743334069848061, 0.02934006229043007, 0.010952978394925594, 0.030069416388869286, 0.012783165089786053, 0.012096548452973366, -0.009149361401796341, -0.0083767706528306, 0.08450338244438171, 0.023742355406284332, 0.03692704066634178, -0.011314038187265396, 0.03765016049146652, -0.07262317836284637, -0.020134873688220978, -0.014549687504768372, -0.008973552845418453, 0.04973640665411949, 0.029892444610595703, 0.023134132847189903, 0.023155640810728073, -0.016856873407959938, -0.005276144482195377, -0.02670898474752903, 0.017814606428146362, 0.014310019090771675, -0.003181903623044491, 0.059890083968639374, 0.022344231605529785, 0.002064355416223407, 0.02718130312860012, -0.01712093874812126, 0.014036230742931366, 0.056974273175001144, 0.010995188727974892, 0.02521642856299877, 0.03008287586271763, -0.022143974900245667, -0.03832554072141647, 0.014767594635486603, -0.049310289323329926, 0.0070669762790203094, -0.012980467639863491, -0.0561729371547699, 0.03094653971493244, 0.028165435418486595, 0.03124728985130787, -0.02972797304391861, -0.04890322685241699, -0.02204165793955326, -0.009684833697974682, 0.030872521921992302, -0.043469153344631195, 0.035092927515506744, 0.006728562526404858, -0.0005904679419472814, -0.014313237741589546, 0.031815316528081894, -0.010126061737537384, -0.07282643020153046, -0.04996046423912048, -0.040274884551763535, -0.021476833149790764, 0.031377412378787994, 0.008804026059806347, -0.02692248485982418, -0.010545588098466396, -0.018810255452990532, 0.0031464805360883474, -0.010331353172659874, 0.02813936397433281, -0.012987878173589706, 0.06609480082988739, 0.027422787621617317, 0.0007297997362911701, -0.006159703712910414, 0.02417604997754097, 0.11163263022899628, 0.10599679499864578, 0.05925653874874115, -0.06412223726511002, -0.03303871303796768, -0.007028202060610056, -0.019907070323824883, -0.04616634175181389, 0.020666047930717468, 0.017575278878211975, -0.02305249497294426, 0.038318127393722534, 0.02520068734884262, 0.04463733360171318, -0.007140301167964935, 0.04223859682679176, -0.04167378693819046, 0.00906286109238863, 0.020200911909341812, 0.005287391133606434, 0.009357724338769913, -0.020545413717627525, -0.024875331670045853, 0.05019167810678482, 0.032280974090099335, -0.05486498773097992, -0.02115625888109207, 0.005033939611166716, 0.004104024730622768, -0.02816499024629593, -0.0060197580605745316, -0.0134287029504776, 0.010026657022535801, 0.04561261087656021, -0.0012734450865536928, 0.011059156619012356, 0.02338823489844799, 0.020088233053684235, -0.00327698839828372, -0.012961342930793762, 0.019571421667933464, -0.006790178827941418, -0.03339341655373573, -0.011094557121396065, -0.037979986518621445, 0.0035227760672569275, -0.03984843194484711, 0.056238189339637756, 0.026968255639076233, 0.009236901067197323, -0.03943569213151932, -0.012180681340396404, 0.01836364157497883, -0.011720186099410057, -0.03951534628868103, 0.0016603398835286498, 0.04136313870549202, -0.019018933176994324, -0.04742416739463806, 0.0207503829151392, -0.00153722008690238, 0.0023730560205876827, 0.03774120658636093, 0.03356083109974861, -0.006321670487523079, 0.0004263229784555733, -0.030386563390493393, 0.007864824496209621, 0.004356468096375465, 0.04482593387365341, -0.011625638231635094, -0.017796248197555542, -0.01755535788834095, -0.027311936020851135, 0.04272432625293732, 0.011569181457161903, 0.006511252373456955, -0.034543685615062714, -0.028552455827593803, -0.001876590307801962, -0.04228172078728676, 0.005861067678779364, -0.02900669537484646, -0.02403891272842884, -0.03446413204073906, -0.008996394462883472, -0.000553735182620585, 0.05838826298713684, -0.0011045527644455433, 0.0026361800264567137, 0.0163897555321455, 0.061385128647089005, -0.010559912770986557, -0.04817606881260872, -0.01665905863046646, -0.026345109567046165, -0.045054398477077484, 0.04010511189699173, -0.003477119142189622, 0.08544985204935074, 0.0055623664520680904, 0.03758490830659866, -0.02722768485546112, 0.03543580323457718, -0.026790505275130272, 0.012251952663064003, -0.016313910484313965, -0.060144729912281036, -0.006077307276427746, 0.0018036921974271536, 0.027059394866228104, -0.04402092471718788, -0.06217067316174507, -0.010059433057904243, -0.02943492867052555, 0.0195302851498127, -0.00036732759326696396, -0.02322803996503353, 0.0011423323303461075, 0.0016161263920366764, 0.010039594024419785, -0.02868129126727581, 0.005218071397393942, -0.0571121983230114, -0.0005929791368544102, 0.015536563470959663, -0.05928315594792366, -0.01451504323631525, 0.002439158735796809, 0.0014909523306414485, -0.016192808747291565, -0.003968152683228254, 0.002405888633802533, -0.01921083964407444, 0.0028557605110108852, 0.008591861464083195, 0.017333978787064552, 0.05394251272082329, -0.028240233659744263, -0.011295007541775703, -0.0018391609191894531, -0.0566764660179615, -0.03441903367638588, 0.028004050254821777, -0.00938304141163826, 0.03566158190369606, 0.01554339099675417, -0.020031895488500595, -0.0661589577794075, 0.03522283211350441, -0.036573782563209534, -0.018290190026164055, -0.036648694425821304, 0.049881402403116226, -0.031281229108572006, 0.00721000088378787, 0.0018685688264667988, 0.013588872738182545, -0.036301929503679276, -0.016735205426812172, 0.028516000136733055, 0.03454224020242691, -0.02815840393304825, 0.0121693704277277, 0.0046939728781580925, 0.008700978010892868, 0.02195611037313938, 0.0247784610837698, 0.02817090041935444, 0.04043595865368843, -0.02182074263691902, 0.04043292999267578, 0.015923630446195602, 0.05595487356185913, -0.07422110438346863, -0.03126073256134987, -0.020004717633128166, 0.017224228009581566, 0.05529525503516197, -0.06901749968528748, 0.003928676713258028, 0.025044145062565804, -0.056236039847135544, 0.01445118710398674, 0.0033002840355038643, -0.003410561475902796, -0.06895390897989273, 0.017278971150517464, 0.021319890394806862, -0.017372453585267067, -0.005044529680162668, 0.003028662409633398, 0.012628096155822277, 0.03175697848200798, 0.003220692742615938, -0.0019306704634800553, -0.04558379203081131, 0.014250434003770351, 0.011272304691374302, -0.05115522816777229, 0.003963951021432877, -0.035926200449466705, -0.05990705266594887, 0.004611765965819359, -0.0187540240585804, -0.00906412210315466, 0.05048010125756264, 0.006351241376250982, -0.021969608962535858, 0.01628018729388714, 0.03968880698084831, -0.015055120922625065, 0.014068993739783764, -0.008158035576343536, -0.011824383400380611, 0.03162255138158798, -0.020350519567728043, 0.06589074432849884, 0.0334165133535862, -0.03853929415345192, 0.005746058188378811, -0.009225208312273026, -0.003351103514432907, 0.0018207418033853173, 0.014378412626683712, -0.005743926391005516, 0.018342938274145126, -0.026188595220446587, 0.003756676334887743, -0.060286570340394974, 0.023891082033514977, 0.023753849789500237, 0.012091796845197678, 0.0066500394605100155, 0.008116519078612328, -0.005627702455967665, -0.05530348792672157, 0.0014791928697377443, 0.00960868876427412, -0.01080232672393322, -0.06940631568431854, 0.010760047473013401, -0.04497376084327698, -0.01597960852086544, -0.014445595443248749, -0.0031523979268968105, -0.05420120432972908, 0.05565524846315384, -0.008102850057184696, 0.02679889276623726, 0.024135075509548187, -0.010854317806661129, 0.034299518913030624, -0.07914076000452042, 0.025320710614323616, -0.007976035587489605, 0.014901513233780861, -0.02149718999862671, -0.02042662352323532, -0.053553979843854904, -0.01195015199482441, 0.05117868259549141, -0.004789136350154877, 0.05587772652506828, -0.02165161818265915, 0.0010571051388978958, -0.004036028869450092, -0.01730717159807682, 0.057435374706983566, -0.008166645653545856, -0.031720444560050964, -0.02585754171013832, 0.007011339999735355, 0.013156355358660221, 0.010195504873991013, 0.019201120361685753, 0.008823715150356293, -0.03347199782729149, 0.014242618344724178, 0.006736860144883394, 0.05128529295325279, -0.03400227427482605, 0.011584109626710415, 0.01852448098361492, 0.007578020915389061, -0.0172355268150568, 0.0024195213336497545, 0.020458882674574852, -0.05833594128489494, 0.06665199249982834, -0.05107419937849045, -0.017165495082736015, 0.014377324841916561, 0.0016725193709135056, 0.007708144374191761, -0.04765521362423897, 0.008715382777154446, 0.011020093224942684, -0.04964481666684151, 0.015485215000808239, -0.006804424803704023, 0.004670864436775446, 0.011686216108500957, -0.03081032633781433, 0.024095719680190086, -0.00859192293137312, 0.010117251425981522, -0.017023639753460884, 0.0004594203783199191, 0.00769843440502882, -0.02803436852991581, 0.022790834307670593, 0.04353650286793709, -0.029300540685653687, 0.00548775028437376, -0.016726013273000717, 0.05479732155799866, -0.038992803543806076, -0.0173466969281435, -0.010838075540959835, 0.012069360353052616, 0.005827733315527439, -0.05411845073103905, -0.020535267889499664, 0.06442228704690933, -0.022434590384364128, -0.01754203997552395, -0.051539815962314606, -0.0501272939145565, -0.011186761781573296, -0.008768427185714245, -0.023584920912981033, 0.04337280988693237, -0.03191796690225601, 0.023519184440374374, 0.007894708774983883, -0.012352471239864826, 0.009346609935164452, -0.025260448455810547, 0.018855378031730652, -0.0145873436704278, -0.0035600843839347363, 0.005175918806344271, -0.03325258195400238, 0.011663722805678844, -0.01607383042573929, 0.01059707347303629, 0.05138667672872543, 0.041824277490377426, -0.036685340106487274, -0.022957418113946915, -0.035584427416324615, 0.024257514625787735, -0.041172094643116, -0.0036200599279254675, -0.035758327692747116, 0.03177972882986069, -0.03126201406121254, 0.00911782681941986 ]
<p>We have an events based tracking system for our website, with split testing built-in and we are using <a href="http://www.thumbtack.com/labs/abba/" rel="nofollow">ABBA</a> for the calculations.</p> <p>The problem comes up when we are doing consecutive split tests. For example, we test X and Y, Y wins, so the next test is Y and Z. We are seeing, most of the time, that the conversion rate of Y differs in the two tests... Sometimes by as much as 50%.</p> <p>We have a tool to track conversion rate over time, and I've included two graphs of conversion rate between two different tests of new and baseline. You can see that between the two tests, the previous new and the subsequent baseline differ by a significant amount even though they should theoretically be the same.</p> <p>Both experiments have about 200,000 runs for new and baseline - 400k total - 800k over two experiments, and the P values on both are .0001. I'm just unable to explain why the conversion rate of "new" in test1 was 1.28% but the conversion rate of "baseline" in test2 was .85% - when they are exactly the same content.</p> <p>I can certainly think of some things that would contribute to something like this: only catching part of a user cycle/time of day variations/seasonal variations/holidays, but my gut tells me that it shouldn't really make a 50% difference.</p> <p>We have, however, eliminated the possibility of Googlebot and other bots affecting the results, as we don't even record events for bots.</p> <p>Unfortunately, we don't have anything we can compare with. We do use Google analytics, but we only record our key metrics there, so there's no apples – apples.</p> <p>The experiments were run immediately after each other, and I'm not aware of any special marketing campaigns (We don't do very much marketing, and no CPC). We are seeing some pretty good changes in traffic from certain countries, and I can definitely look into that to see if it could contribute... But, again, 50%?</p> <p>Test 1: "New" wins <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/1WSDF.png" alt="Test 1 conversion"></p> <p>Test2: The old "New" is now "Baseline"...note the mismatch in conversion <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/l1LFv.png" alt="Test 2 conversion"></p>
36,206
[ -0.01954096555709839, -0.011049955151975155, -0.012388063594698906, -0.015294631011784077, 0.03116639144718647, 0.0065609971061348915, -0.013885876163840294, -0.037415627390146255, 0.003991374745965004, 0.0092471269890666, 0.021724138408899307, 0.04476227983832359, 0.0024778887163847685, 0.04886807128787041, -0.0002320546336704865, -0.02551654353737831, 0.0215320885181427, 0.004853235092014074, -0.007336520589888096, 0.024068281054496765, 0.011531960219144821, -0.0067867133766412735, 0.013983156532049179, -0.014369062148034573, -0.022951476275920868, -0.0023538966197520494, 0.011684322729706764, -0.05261240154504776, 0.006305710878223181, 0.049970902502536774, -0.03965769335627556, 0.0013294683303683996, -0.020126234740018845, 0.03127928078174591, 0.025055037811398506, 0.013392344117164612, -0.013652589172124863, -0.019470851868391037, -0.04758366197347641, 0.04970890283584595, -0.024431539699435234, 0.027436647564172745, -0.05838063731789589, 0.0257186908274889, -0.021517828106880188, 0.015277295373380184, -0.012588667683303356, -0.0005724153597839177, 0.0481216236948967, -0.049226269125938416, 0.02724071592092514, -0.04395144060254097, 0.022847887128591537, 0.027577858418226242, -0.015384933911263943, -0.015073082409799099, 0.07709536701440811, 0.014777056872844696, -0.050316695123910904, -0.017104066908359528, -0.01222059316933155, -0.0090866107493639, -0.014225242659449577, -0.009251455776393414, -0.030778303742408752, 0.040517114102840424, 0.02266825921833515, -0.027446167543530464, 0.03893451392650604, -0.02861366979777813, 0.02356415055692196, -0.011911746114492416, 0.034217990934848785, -0.022756382822990417, 0.04075687751173973, -0.04228062555193901, 0.02199392206966877, 0.03559298440814018, 0.03275517746806145, 0.03811892494559288, -0.021497981622815132, -0.032500047236680984, 0.02952369675040245, 0.044115159660577774, 0.053145986050367355, -0.01751200668513775, 0.06602733582258224, -0.055740464478731155, -0.03728571534156799, 0.030716300010681152, -0.008347615599632263, -0.029539048671722412, 0.0488584004342556, 0.007425849791616201, -0.00431748665869236, 0.02657097391784191, 0.004840726498514414, 0.02840614505112171, -0.004558549728244543, 0.025173315778374672, -0.047264937311410904, -0.037820976227521896, 0.029035497456789017, 0.06913229823112488, -0.014489528723061085, -0.0061048041097819805, -0.021224340423941612, -0.05056631937623024, -0.03293215110898018, -0.012424666434526443, -0.060143791139125824, -0.016268786042928696, 0.005634543485939503, -0.00874052383005619, 0.013977598398923874, -0.00879748910665512, 0.006438575219362974, -0.022105105221271515, 0.04723212495446205, 0.0347784198820591, 0.05201392620801926, -0.010632704012095928, -0.0005825312691740692, -0.049135904759168625, -0.02039792388677597, 0.00010421416664030403, 0.0039012697525322437, -0.03365432843565941, -0.057423993945121765, 0.04549122229218483, 0.01348898932337761, -0.002801063470542431, -0.020811717957258224, -0.043048467487096786, 0.015769759193062782, 0.03753732144832611, -0.06933388859033585, -0.02894555777311325, 0.06171838939189911, -0.0029197013936936855, 0.009163057431578636, -0.06585564464330673, -0.038487982004880905, 0.0116850221529603, 0.05497412011027336, 0.010276622138917446, 0.04721718281507492, -0.0012383294524624944, 0.024522390216588974, 0.03214159980416298, -0.03000844083726406, -0.00965771172195673, -0.0058923871256411076, -0.009909030981361866, -0.044876210391521454, -0.07086177170276642, -0.02062082476913929, 0.0309669841080904, -0.003255179151892662, 0.008435951545834541, -0.014065795578062534, 0.04696547985076904, -0.030618244782090187, -0.005823436658829451, 0.052517086267471313, -0.044724300503730774, 0.07604667544364929, 0.015222041867673397, 0.01983366161584854, 0.016860557720065117, -0.01969614066183567, 0.013778883032500744, 0.015563815832138062, -0.008332375437021255, 0.0317494198679924, -0.0175262950360775, 0.005282336380332708, -0.011059088632464409, 0.005675659514963627, 0.016867591068148613, -0.01581893116235733, -0.05176139622926712, -0.047862160950899124, 0.009954918175935745, 0.029484614729881287, 0.0489538349211216, 0.0036601321771740913, 0.00812338013201952, 0.06205179914832115, -0.048033323138952255, -0.03371516615152359, -0.03372190147638321, -0.012316667474806309, -0.0012405068846419454, -0.01143746916204691, -0.0021491539664566517, -0.006302013993263245, 0.014347467571496964, -0.005571197252720594, -0.037627700716257095, 0.006590051110833883, 0.042147282510995865, 0.05122421309351921, -0.036482930183410645, 0.02471059374511242, 0.05134560167789459, -0.022590918466448784, -0.03711419925093651, -0.00239090109243989, -0.026552164927124977, -0.037037093192338943, -0.00927158072590828, -0.022658638656139374, 0.0480341836810112, -0.01809651590883732, -0.015700804069638252, 0.02397037483751774, 0.030093124136328697, -0.03557935357093811, 0.0015043355524539948, -0.06201614812016487, 0.0547124482691288, 0.03653871640563011, -0.03097284585237503, 0.019467031583189964, -0.018578212708234787, 0.025498975068330765, 0.01931803673505783, -0.026502225548028946, -0.002709302818402648, -0.052078038454055786, -0.04540969803929329, 0.07446862757205963, -0.011758813634514809, -0.026096800342202187, 0.03329511359333992, 0.0657053217291832, 0.01270145270973444, -0.025527458637952805, 0.019836552441120148, 0.03510884568095207, -0.03766000270843506, 0.009316209703683853, 0.043431635946035385, 0.0253430362790823, 0.012600960209965706, 0.018396543338894844, -0.03534623980522156, 0.012363100424408913, 0.014376694336533546, 0.014732899144291878, 0.004884046968072653, 0.06331846117973328, 0.0068445270881056786, -0.03863789886236191, 0.015085124410688877, 0.04247407615184784, -0.017722999677062035, -0.002436113078147173, 0.036790892481803894, 0.04745779559016228, -0.0492243766784668, -0.025714967399835587, -0.019914967939257622, 0.0016460190527141094, 0.0344909206032753, 0.004322719294577837, -0.0068397484719753265, 0.03284284844994545, 0.004947182256728411, 0.012461453676223755, -0.013374486938118935, -0.031129958108067513, -0.0055537475273013115, -0.003969893325120211, -0.02399052493274212, 0.015657881274819374, 0.045764390379190445, -0.06722734868526459, 0.006088010035455227, 0.0010354527039453387, 0.02289164625108242, 0.007568443659693003, -0.02272336557507515, 0.0062958733178675175, 0.06228901445865631, 0.008305552415549755, 0.01795944571495056, 0.05285992845892906, 0.005149778909981251, -0.015265698544681072, 0.03877050802111626, 0.023012541234493256, -0.027039721608161926, -0.03007248230278492, -0.052292224019765854, 0.011720594018697739, -0.04613925889134407, -0.03159959241747856, 0.05437607690691948, 0.01960880495607853, -0.062328580766916275, 0.044143714010715485, -0.030874473974108696, 0.016053328290581703, -0.04367729276418686, -0.01071043498814106, -0.046322938054800034, -0.01757526956498623, -0.0013189801247790456, 0.004125904757529497, 0.017893856391310692, -0.013428349047899246, -0.02712026797235012, -0.06786337494850159, 0.02948601543903351, -0.013333768583834171, 0.041626572608947754, -0.0102333202958107, -0.00963466428220272, 0.06225467100739479, 0.027732500806450844, -0.014910830184817314, -0.0792723000049591, -0.011821137741208076, -0.016275323927402496, -0.04404429346323013, 0.00979534164071083, 0.04607824236154556, -0.03488938510417938, 0.0068967933766543865, -0.025371260941028595, 0.017794625833630562, 0.043849267065525055, 0.016669971868395805, -0.029619721695780754, 0.053615957498550415, 0.03668803721666336, -0.003435119055211544, 0.021678343415260315, 0.05698073282837868, -0.03685895726084709, -0.024860601872205734, 0.010649444535374641, 0.03634456545114517, 0.008446304127573967, -0.0782879889011383, 0.03598770871758461, -0.025003671646118164, 0.009421214461326599, 0.012317579239606857, -0.007025855593383312, -0.02055584453046322, -0.02529861219227314, -0.02866068109869957, -0.017738891765475273, 0.019842296838760376, 0.0006961618200875819, 0.0028808440547436476, 0.07636556029319763, 0.037292469292879105, -0.0392136424779892, -0.06339304894208908, -0.017516018822789192, -0.04295143112540245, 0.015796776860952377, -0.016558662056922913, -0.014122644439339638, 0.007356013637036085, 0.015401262789964676, -0.022596972063183784, 0.03082866780459881, -0.026768043637275696, -0.02021106332540512, -0.03643738105893135, 0.017794346436858177, -0.0174616277217865, 0.026707980781793594, -0.027708085253834724, 0.014254020527005196, 0.01221943274140358, -0.0007708408520556986, -0.0199149027466774, 0.0031115480232983828, -0.07477179169654846, -0.004285696428269148, -0.005491454619914293, -0.02785355970263481, 0.04225698485970497, -0.027113763615489006, 0.006608850322663784, 0.017227156087756157, 0.00516863726079464, -0.04542950913310051, -0.0025389452930539846, 0.005091497208923101, 0.014936085790395737, -0.002988950116559863, 0.012129032053053379, 0.01177183911204338, 0.03360205143690109, 0.011342202313244343, 0.014219852164387703, 0.0368322916328907, 0.008587608113884926, 0.009010874666273594, 0.009554979391396046, -0.029488613829016685, 0.012206888757646084, 0.0161424707621336, 0.046523768454790115, -0.015538062900304794, 0.021332044154405594, -0.043681975454092026, 0.004170086234807968, 0.015111689455807209, -0.0100400410592556, 0.00781772006303072, -0.03396374359726906, -0.011773895472288132, -0.046585891395807266, -0.02957930602133274, 0.051159147173166275, 0.00021784630371257663, -0.00487467972561717, -0.008469139225780964, 0.01789204590022564, 0.0256993118673563, 0.008353094570338726, 0.0038950371090322733, 0.06539783626794815, -0.004684684332460165, 0.045012686401605606, 0.006241115275770426, -0.024728359654545784, 0.02664865553379059, -0.006203493569046259, -0.012391908094286919, 0.01572517864406109, 0.006050916854292154, -0.010281145572662354, 0.006903816945850849, 0.006204479839652777, -0.013667930848896503, 0.03130992874503136, -0.021785156801342964, 0.020029190927743912, -0.01715274341404438, -0.0178994070738554, 0.0472077876329422, 0.031200043857097626, 0.03982929512858391, 0.02079508639872074, -0.014087342657148838, -0.08205970376729965, -0.02203037403523922, 0.0287578534334898, 0.060362737625837326, -0.030996980145573616, -0.038112822920084, -0.00898242462426424, -0.013092557899653912, -0.016034597530961037, -0.009486861526966095, 0.037399448454380035, 0.01350252516567707, 0.0296162199229002, -0.03515927121043205, -0.05147714540362358, -0.008753536269068718, 0.020362691953778267, -0.041974350810050964, 0.023546602576971054, -0.008121855556964874, 0.002911854535341263, -0.014329830184578896, 0.0009088711231015623, 0.0074791074730455875, 0.053752560168504715, -0.0339570976793766, -0.020052161067724228, -0.0346444770693779, -0.012189818546175957, -0.03451994061470032, -0.056301090866327286, 0.028767431154847145, 0.0015980747994035482, 0.021682707592844963, 0.05064170062541962, 0.004062801133841276, -0.007759080268442631, 0.024956002831459045, 0.019501276314258575, -0.01123643759638071, 0.03480278328061104, -0.0253284964710474, 0.02671809308230877, 0.04861194267868996, -0.0026053590700030327, 0.022892948240041733, 0.014505681581795216, -0.013070404529571533, 0.011157392524182796, 0.002809221390634775, -0.005046719219535589, -0.041957054287195206, -0.042905427515506744, -0.015658564865589142, -0.0035798114258795977, -0.02731526829302311, 0.03490679711103439, 0.02780936472117901, 0.016708865761756897, -0.0621003694832325, -0.013309529982507229, 0.012571527622640133, 0.02147366665303707, -0.03721696510910988, 0.0036769097205251455, 0.022867901250720024, -0.01068853959441185, -0.013305647298693657, 0.055087845772504807, 0.012260490097105503, -0.056441690772771835, 0.01952715963125229, -0.0030467091128230095, -0.016520047560334206, 0.0039414600469172, -0.05311727151274681, 0.02746747061610222, -0.00509836059063673, -0.014982327818870544, 0.05360535904765129, 0.0028456232976168394, 0.018909666687250137, 0.017541946843266487, -0.014062388800084591, -0.003731615375727415, 0.049386102706193924, 0.011136151850223541, 0.019429409876465797, 0.014400181360542774, 0.009276259690523148, -0.04840997979044914, -0.03761284425854683, -0.041698090732097626, -0.03363776579499245, 0.02577640302479267, -0.0184431504458189, -0.039596255868673325, 0.0005449702148325741, -0.02628413587808609, 0.0077455909922719, -0.03997233510017395, -0.014587588608264923, 0.02864702232182026, -0.04468420147895813, -0.019824974238872528, -0.0017677538562566042, 0.029344774782657623, 0.0809255838394165, -0.01812996156513691, -0.011857150122523308, -0.01503622904419899, 0.057587821036577225, -0.013884584419429302, 0.010820855386555195, 0.003872728906571865, -0.04667274281382561, -0.02731018140912056, -0.047816213220357895, -0.019205987453460693, 0.04320402443408966, -0.05076400190591812, -0.03584607318043709, 0.016386637464165688, -0.016497952863574028, 0.02834005281329155, -0.011116350069642067, 0.03414317965507507, 0.030220309272408485, -0.016604771837592125, -0.024588339030742645, -0.017323393374681473, -0.02872517704963684, -0.025301577523350716, 0.02537405490875244, 0.020861433818936348, -0.027626631781458855, 0.01909622922539711, 0.06813804805278778, -0.004689803346991539, -0.050202708691358566, -0.013304071500897408, -0.024698153138160706, 0.05147132650017738, 0.005492798052728176, -0.004305591806769371, 0.0051571461372077465, -0.015633713454008102, -0.03657199442386627, -0.03326534852385521, -0.017880618572235107, -0.024974636733531952, 0.04525884613394737, 0.03323110193014145, 0.038022495806217194, 0.032670218497514725, 0.017091447487473488, 0.025612549856305122, -0.04633025452494621, 0.04916612058877945, -0.013754906132817268, 0.006943524815142155, 0.011607679538428783, -0.03739534690976143, -0.024972161278128624, 0.02758331596851349, 0.016235051676630974, 0.02863147482275963, 0.02679409272968769, 0.04776417464017868, 0.033046621829271317, 0.044151682406663895, -0.05490972474217415, -0.02935950830578804, 0.0436655655503273, -0.05072278901934624, 0.008121880702674389, -0.024285251274704933, 0.0032208459451794624, 0.08016210794448853, 0.03374752774834633, -0.029678715392947197, -0.02800052985548973, -0.017166458070278168, -0.08129173517227173, -0.005757843144237995, 0.02311008796095848, -0.02364620380103588, 0.03480099141597748, -0.006803568918257952, 0.021155420690774918, 0.0009325564606115222, 0.03504876419901848, 0.010331889614462852, -0.055012740194797516, -0.02564644254744053, 0.006899464875459671, -0.03797450289130211, 0.0124241653829813, -0.049464933574199677, -0.015159140340983868, 0.01582908071577549, -0.04262736067175865, 0.020303577184677124, 0.017986048012971878, 0.025870583951473236, -0.04583020508289337, 0.04514317959547043, -0.010865218937397003, 0.016714846715331078, -0.015072809532284737, -0.01857678033411503, 0.1532253623008728, 0.055614810436964035, 0.03949378430843353, -0.06255629658699036, 0.038945410400629044, 0.05033610388636589, 0.043102364987134933, -0.041423480957746506, -0.017198119312524796, -0.0018173622665926814, -0.013889553025364876, 0.08534533530473709, 0.04564082249999046, 0.015488553792238235, -0.040382202714681625, 0.043958630412817, -0.032894764095544815, 0.006018529646098614, 0.05719549208879471, 0.023831859230995178, -0.027749093249440193, -0.006822135299444199, 0.004667824134230614, 0.0023305420763790607, 0.004274994134902954, 0.006533368024975061, 0.019645528867840767, -0.014352696016430855, -0.01547714788466692, 0.029046140611171722, -0.033189963549375534, 0.04154867306351662, 0.01903640478849411, -0.009521505795419216, 0.018151020631194115, 0.017448291182518005, 0.0016984312096610665, -0.030039582401514053, -0.0009143726783804595, 0.06323046237230301, 0.03677569702267647, -0.03985719382762909, 0.022197827696800232, 0.02060587890446186, -0.0502454899251461, -0.014387519098818302, -0.043489325791597366, 0.03531835973262787, -0.030222315341234207, -0.029096543788909912, -0.008896343410015106, -0.04227781295776367, -0.027444755658507347, -0.010969564318656921, 0.010538473725318909, 0.03267786279320717, -0.017725788056850433, -0.013289795257151127, 0.008602642454206944, 0.006358723156154156, 0.019644562155008316, 0.0058433543890714645, 0.011829303577542305, 0.007508797571063042, 0.006493132561445236, -0.03750947490334511, 0.007762319874018431, 0.03883703052997589, 0.030354414135217667, -0.011208979412913322, 0.03435584530234337, -0.009789671748876572, -0.043035756796598434, 0.0031303814612329006, -0.03239644691348076, -0.019261589273810387, 0.023141516372561455, -0.007971922867000103, -0.0035030159633606672, -0.032298605889081955, 0.021344415843486786, 0.018218986690044403, -0.009467081166803837, -0.0037487938534468412, -0.04895174875855446, -0.019215529784560204, 0.02112956903874874, 0.03152819722890854, 0.02658582292497158, 0.035218194127082825, -0.01338343694806099, 0.09328034520149231, 0.03327532857656479, -0.003840596880763769, -0.05086443945765495, 0.00544734438881278, -0.02487911656498909, -0.04581048712134361, -0.039897602051496506, 0.05419754609465599, 0.00747253093868494, 0.005191395990550518, 0.014709713868796825, -0.03624875843524933, -0.011831178329885006, 0.024425022304058075, 0.003982336260378361, -0.04121217876672745, -0.016647394746541977, 0.015233221463859081, -0.007207134272903204, -0.013611066155135632, -0.005742248613387346, -0.030354522168636322, 0.04823751375079155, 0.02520098350942135, -0.018994195386767387, -0.010986014269292355, -0.0024650171399116516, -0.03990307077765465, 0.04360266402363777, -0.04113638773560524, -0.026831896975636482, -0.03109956532716751, -0.025634407997131348, -0.05799479782581329, 0.0051954081282019615, -0.008175883442163467, 0.027669766917824745, 0.02342205122113228, 0.01872897893190384, 0.058377139270305634, 0.03978097066283226, 0.0028504421934485435, 0.00037711020559072495, 0.05121505632996559, 0.0019424892961978912, -0.020772509276866913, -0.02793242037296295, -0.05887982249259949, 0.05503549054265022, 0.008034774102270603, -0.06358258426189423, -0.00765625387430191, -0.018909486010670662, 0.016507793217897415, -0.004495084751397371, -0.010384121909737587, 0.009328712709248066, 0.061359237879514694, -0.024218523874878883, -0.04409224912524223, 0.02139797806739807, 0.025928182527422905, 0.05524328351020813, 0.026521528139710426, 0.01540379785001278, 0.015999170020222664, -0.020338859409093857, 0.014017724432051182, 0.026571813970804214, -0.02804107405245304, 0.035602208226919174, -0.02653254009783268, -0.030714260414242744, -0.019027920439839363, 0.023103583604097366, -0.00544556463137269, 0.039450500160455704, 0.036347679793834686, -0.0346456803381443, -0.011676431633532047, -0.02877882868051529, 0.008201045915484428, -0.03633483499288559, -0.020152833312749863, 0.0073921107687056065, 0.012767229229211807, 0.03591440990567207, -0.03709862381219864, 0.03946657106280327, 0.04773310199379921, -0.0823979452252388, 0.03447848930954933, 0.024729177355766296, 0.009466374292969704, -0.05552680417895317, -0.025631697848439217, -0.02544262632727623, 0.020183810964226723, 0.020144879817962646, 0.026816420257091522, 0.016759075224399567, 0.04440527781844139, -0.006825016811490059, -0.020190918818116188, -0.05846041440963745, -0.02831493876874447, 0.005513168405741453, 0.010164819657802582, 0.071553535759449, -0.042595796287059784, -0.04550674185156822, 0.055080052465200424, -0.027128959074616432, 0.052671220153570175, -0.005085983779281378, 0.011751941405236721, 0.04333445057272911, 0.0029577133245766163, 0.030850041657686234, 0.030915800482034683, 0.026727575808763504, -0.023867303505539894, -0.009507138282060623, 0.032586030662059784, 0.021735815331339836, 0.0021629396360367537, 0.0488160215318203, -0.0471578948199749, -0.03764615207910538, -0.029328620061278343, -0.020440716296434402, -0.014114844612777233, 0.010752109810709953, 0.007882492616772652, 0.056120485067367554, -0.013005287386476994, -0.019150298088788986, -0.06182011961936951, 0.04510696604847908, 0.05414184555411339, 0.010579222813248634, -0.04577234759926796, -0.008480120450258255, -0.0167591143399477, -0.018434319645166397, 0.029941940680146217, 0.008671569637954235, -0.0024069519713521004, -0.06030852720141411, -0.027665816247463226, -0.014744967222213745, 0.02124498225748539, -0.00027051178039982915, 0.0204481091350317, 0.02821267955005169, 0.046973444521427155, 0.0036166892386972904, -0.0039246566593647, -0.007549881003797054, 0.01829235441982746, 0.007960846647620201, -0.08198365569114685, 0.06363019347190857, -0.0014928053133189678, -0.024236861616373062, -0.05050545558333397, -0.04682266339659691, -0.053565848618745804, -0.0017995379166677594, 0.039218999445438385, 0.006762796547263861, 0.012698039412498474, -0.03185867890715599, -0.012676858343183994, -0.0013809985248371959, -0.03728744760155678, 0.060011621564626694, -0.014523131772875786, -0.004419573582708836, 0.033757004886865616, -0.0026910402812063694, -0.00832028966397047, -0.005513384472578764, 0.014860786497592926, -0.028832048177719116, -0.016182739287614822, -0.017934374511241913, 0.01797924004495144, 0.021223200485110283, 0.01273320708423853, -0.006592991761863232, 0.047310102730989456, 0.009075887501239777, 0.023916954174637794, -0.013423671014606953, -0.012300236150622368, -0.08576539158821106, 0.07594660669565201, -0.031468428671360016, 0.007654923014342785, -0.004974915646016598, 0.025648698210716248, -0.010080596432089806, -0.04168681800365448, -0.014709354378283024, 0.023205064237117767, -0.006795426364988089, 0.0340929739177227, 0.01744072698056698, 0.027133936062455177, -0.010318467393517494, -0.009616943076252937, 0.04844372346997261, -0.009767224080860615, 0.004496329929679632, -0.0017910668393597007, 0.0016689110780134797, 0.013507516123354435, 0.018881281837821007, 0.007446627132594585, 0.031052740290760994, -0.006968892179429531, 0.042027708142995834, 0.022099528461694717, 0.05790415033698082, -0.004321501590311527, 0.012567002326250076, 0.035132668912410736, -0.018743649125099182, -0.00556997861713171, 0.04802428558468819, 0.014109903015196323, 0.02234346605837345, -0.013919704593718052, 0.02828633412718773, -0.05161309987306595, -0.0017219609580934048, 0.00012903290917165577, 0.01945439726114273, 0.009898965246975422, 0.04109009727835655, 0.003485248191282153, -0.018215278163552284, -0.0003788621979765594, -0.01981922797858715, -0.015439559705555439, -0.011587313376367092, 0.003312177723273635, 0.003881515935063362, -0.009976176545023918, 0.01815447211265564, -0.025661079213023186, -0.057358548045158386, 0.012232635170221329, -0.01744133047759533, 0.030941791832447052, -0.0033265370875597, -0.0022700701374560595, -0.04009846970438957, 0.014570126309990883, 0.022252682596445084, -0.023610709235072136, -0.003201108891516924, -0.025209864601492882, 0.004597656428813934, 0.04140033945441246, -0.03176984563469887 ]
<p>I sometimes have difficulty understanding the intuition behind some tests. Is it important to know why some test works in a particular situation, or is it enough to learn things at the level "OK, now I can check homoscedasticity" or "I have no idea why we divide by 12 in Mann–Whitney U-test, but trust me, it works"? Or are there books where the authors have explained the ideas behind every test and provided some reasons to "prove" that the tests work? </p>
73,740
[ -0.016679774969816208, -0.03799937665462494, -0.009237525053322315, -0.00659658620133996, 0.028405271470546722, 0.06248704344034195, 0.004375054966658354, -0.001028798520565033, -0.018160831183195114, 0.009274701587855816, 0.03980272635817528, 0.0032167595345526934, 0.012609501369297504, -0.006738012190908194, 0.009749292396008968, 0.00666322885081172, -0.032027117908000946, -0.008028519339859486, -0.031124340370297432, -0.0027614040300250053, 0.024700045585632324, 0.010319597087800503, -0.01604561321437359, -0.011170737445354462, -0.0008697252487763762, 0.007621929980814457, 0.0132733890786767, -0.04898931458592415, 0.018564820289611816, 0.05252358689904213, -0.015906494110822678, -0.033504899591207504, 0.013330868445336819, 0.02194194681942463, 0.013166279532015324, -0.008596853353083134, 0.04352656751871109, -0.003614411223679781, -0.017128393054008484, 0.0017342587234452367, -0.021582728251814842, -0.008894083090126514, 0.006312384270131588, 0.033586397767066956, -0.022373195737600327, 0.033256422728300095, -0.01288864016532898, -0.03636714816093445, 0.02115735225379467, -0.07273708283901215, 0.03105824626982212, 0.03739412873983383, 0.029317138716578484, 0.0557466596364975, 0.04186922684311867, -0.005980887450277805, 0.014341271482408047, 0.028906535357236862, -0.06157815083861351, -0.06003224477171898, -0.025507334619760513, -0.019792987033724785, -0.010109045542776585, -0.0014103284338489175, -0.03685450553894043, 0.03615148738026619, 0.005554248578846455, -0.00037507081287913024, 0.067470483481884, -0.00025993623421527445, 0.0030489005148410797, 0.03300729766488075, 0.02477310597896576, 0.028220953419804573, -0.02822052873671055, -0.009324967861175537, 0.0041946591809391975, 0.001929329358972609, 0.07623911648988724, 0.05171889066696167, -0.010069547221064568, 0.02293488383293152, 0.03077726624906063, 0.07221143692731857, 0.0002516759268473834, -0.029456213116645813, 0.07089288532733917, -0.023517141118645668, 0.003906713332980871, 0.01855095475912094, -0.008814552798867226, -0.05030800402164459, 0.010195565409958363, -0.019827166572213173, -0.030203623697161674, 0.026854386553168297, -0.02939782105386257, -0.0049414862878620625, 0.016361054033041, -0.0017230997327715158, -0.02848760597407818, -0.01735008880496025, 0.05977779999375343, 0.0615803599357605, -0.025686180219054222, -0.05129808932542801, 0.002047646790742874, 0.028819670900702477, 0.01769833080470562, -0.00825201254338026, -0.014520782977342606, 0.04371590539813042, -0.010488399304449558, 0.04545231908559799, 0.0216473788022995, -0.00016505531675647944, 0.01089518517255783, -0.041470967233181, 0.05812140554189682, 0.03819653019309044, 0.06792456656694412, -0.025684533640742302, 0.0330461785197258, -0.005208659451454878, -0.035116180777549744, 0.019958805292844772, 0.007305794395506382, -0.020592352375388145, -0.007909787818789482, 0.06282787024974823, -0.002016842132434249, -0.028822461143136024, -0.01965462788939476, 0.042338695377111435, 0.05250090733170509, 0.01682666875422001, -0.11750991642475128, -0.05121288076043129, 0.045248713344335556, 0.0011880152160301805, -0.03187432512640953, -0.017311841249465942, 0.010431704111397266, 0.05007994920015335, 0.06061215326189995, -0.0011065141297876835, 0.030408723279833794, -0.03144789859652519, 0.026233108714222908, 0.02837931551039219, -0.024602001532912254, -0.01806139387190342, -0.015531235374510288, -0.029627541080117226, -0.009877441450953484, -0.06815484166145325, -0.003011257154867053, 0.003933072555810213, 0.005222450476139784, -0.04430364817380905, 0.05725695937871933, 0.017406359314918518, -0.0036585344932973385, -0.013623491860926151, -0.027308031916618347, -0.00024271606525871903, 0.08177278190851212, -0.007435060106217861, 0.014798393473029137, 0.029259782284498215, 0.005950713064521551, 0.02053118124604225, 0.03587157279253006, 0.03573843836784363, 0.011506124399602413, -0.024185752496123314, 0.013156210072338581, -0.015031675808131695, 0.016777530312538147, -0.020585862919688225, -0.011170728132128716, -0.019772427156567574, -0.034016069024801254, -0.012109704315662384, 0.0017977908719331026, 0.0198688805103302, -0.0010169637389481068, -0.0030397942755371332, 0.06827312707901001, -0.03422356769442558, -0.03469830006361008, -0.038515605032444, 0.032917048782110214, -0.012095488607883453, -0.04079562798142433, 0.04196416586637497, -0.009057159535586834, 0.03472287580370903, -0.057936087250709534, -0.04725247621536255, -0.04658667743206024, 0.048970263451337814, 0.012616255320608616, -0.06303445994853973, 0.023680979385972023, 0.019644228741526604, 0.021996261551976204, -0.007477973587810993, 0.06058567762374878, -0.06920617818832397, -0.048865076154470444, 0.031128115952014923, -0.025240324437618256, 0.018991943448781967, -0.007876373827457428, -0.009993553161621094, -0.0141879478469491, -0.02090105414390564, -0.015407432802021503, 0.05054132267832756, -0.050785280764102936, 0.05811358615756035, 0.044217437505722046, 0.03964515030384064, 0.02116246335208416, 0.022693391889333725, 0.004057250451296568, 0.012973593547940254, -0.00917693693190813, -0.01609339378774166, -0.030862901359796524, -0.006187358405441046, 0.02637077122926712, 0.039847180247306824, -0.02846759371459484, 0.010640022344887257, 0.03429015353322029, 0.03256841003894806, -0.03698749467730522, 0.04292862117290497, 0.0025867416989058256, -0.028616750612854958, -0.01762440800666809, 0.023847762495279312, 0.0021483469754457474, 0.030914606526494026, 0.036207012832164764, 0.026730792596936226, 0.0008028416195884347, 0.0004784623743034899, -0.02420070953667164, 0.020878871902823448, -0.023262927308678627, 0.012177940458059311, -0.031339436769485474, 0.0272271279245615, 0.02006690204143524, -0.019602708518505096, 0.010614052414894104, -0.008478756062686443, 0.03607882559299469, 0.019763128831982613, -0.03994039446115494, -0.01973983272910118, 0.02360467240214348, 0.010662390850484371, -0.0041033197194337845, -0.02260938659310341, 0.037665192037820816, -0.05900130420923233, -0.002848141361027956, -0.03484484180808067, 0.01355952862650156, 0.0001383765193168074, -0.03188584744930267, 0.013988815248012543, 0.025939710438251495, 0.023204753175377846, -0.022901006042957306, 0.015841510146856308, 0.0001678695116424933, -0.0054868306033313274, 0.03708537667989731, -0.04911894351243973, -0.03695448115468025, 0.020104853436350822, -0.028784915804862976, -0.015340335667133331, 0.07120891660451889, -0.016108805313706398, -0.00610747653990984, 0.01816304214298725, 0.026873627677559853, -0.025717277079820633, -0.012222896330058575, -0.041262369602918625, 0.002847036812454462, -0.04403575509786606, -0.013937553390860558, 0.037294499576091766, -0.05506134778261185, -0.005222057458013296, 0.057823628187179565, 0.0001297349954256788, -0.03779963403940201, -0.012563327327370644, -0.015253462828695774, 0.007317824754863977, -0.008895267732441425, 0.020933179184794426, 0.02107064053416252, -0.055387601256370544, -0.029002206400036812, -0.02502283826470375, -0.040189649909734726, 0.006627170834690332, -0.020557593554258347, 0.04790666699409485, 0.010310049168765545, -0.01254146359860897, 0.06706594675779343, 0.002908079419285059, -0.05035652220249176, -0.02723001316189766, 0.0077994526363909245, -0.021164601668715477, -0.001978442305698991, 0.03824006766080856, 0.02584168314933777, -0.017927095293998718, 0.03528808057308197, 0.0024579791352152824, 0.06512751430273056, 0.02558443509042263, 0.025989321991801262, -0.025196902453899384, 0.04069310054183006, 0.011688084341585636, -0.0016826159553602338, 0.011625456623733044, 0.017855945974588394, -0.03904027119278908, 0.00688321003690362, 0.054745301604270935, 0.03307483345270157, 0.026328587904572487, -0.024556530639529228, 0.05795827880501747, -0.008265180513262749, -0.0023087523877620697, -0.02190399169921875, 0.021819159388542175, -0.027010701596736908, -0.010146220214664936, -0.003552437061443925, 0.009801099076867104, 0.003904190845787525, -0.00147764733992517, 0.04190590977668762, 0.022094890475273132, 0.015384241007268429, -0.059571679681539536, -0.0036065459717065096, -0.013147426769137383, -0.027593232691287994, 0.03791281208395958, -0.024842211976647377, 0.018431920558214188, 0.07882409542798996, 0.057543426752090454, 0.04202176257967949, 0.0038734038826078176, -0.0696553960442543, 0.016698140650987625, -0.05125092715024948, -0.022145910188555717, -0.021042967215180397, 0.03275814652442932, -0.008771512657403946, 0.03528812527656555, 0.04687085002660751, 0.018849652260541916, -0.008617409504950047, -0.03659207373857498, -0.0803305059671402, 0.034685567021369934, -0.029571188613772392, -0.03229206055402756, -0.007711615413427353, -0.0034102164208889008, 0.04266386851668358, -0.021555930376052856, -0.008398505859076977, -0.006427435670047998, 0.007664172910153866, -0.016359401866793633, 0.0287927258759737, -0.01720251329243183, -0.04981023445725441, -0.002034625969827175, -0.003657000605016947, 0.005038074683398008, -0.040268752723932266, -0.011473029851913452, 0.024244455620646477, -0.01505609042942524, -0.0039653480052948, -0.01627783291041851, -0.010188688524067402, 0.026618627831339836, 0.0121609503403306, 0.023593148216605186, 0.017953433096408844, -0.04778824374079704, 0.04470296576619148, -0.0062448265962302685, 0.056870777159929276, -0.03128913417458534, -0.05460542067885399, -0.023280002176761627, -0.0246314387768507, -0.009867377579212189, -0.014793748036026955, 0.03169110044836998, 0.021480673924088478, 0.018718799576163292, 0.06877417117357254, -0.02168405055999756, -0.04991844668984413, 0.032676130533218384, 0.02948511764407158, -0.012757443822920322, -0.004979634191840887, 0.012808341532945633, -0.02786431275308132, -0.04751766100525856, -0.0028753785882145166, 0.021898822858929634, 0.013545428402721882, -0.01384649332612753, -0.021519668400287628, 0.044054288417100906, 0.0022035192232578993, 0.008605943992733955, -0.014431089162826538, 0.019721804186701775, 0.03351422771811485, 0.007520608138293028, -0.03467131033539772, 0.08907809108495712, 0.018579350784420967, 0.06648249179124832, 0.02599683217704296, 0.003584482241421938, -0.030977638438344002, 0.02305537648499012, 0.061060983687639236, 0.025425897911190987, -0.028003636747598648, 0.006262211129069328, -0.03206859901547432, -0.02146749570965767, 0.05330493301153183, -0.042841020971536636, 0.015381289646029472, -0.013070252723991871, -0.009967146441340446, -0.0775340273976326, -0.0012631502468138933, -0.0322931632399559, -0.0033942831214517355, 0.025410547852516174, 0.0550055205821991, -0.03134305402636528, -0.012133083306252956, -0.07407233864068985, 0.021660825237631798, 0.025244930759072304, 0.027424225583672523, -0.026649586856365204, 0.0003040256560780108, 0.02603147178888321, 0.01576782576739788, -0.03504413366317749, -0.08238419145345688, -0.014393203891813755, -0.0017260516760870814, 0.006457156501710415, 0.0238091628998518, 0.01421916764229536, -0.0706244483590126, 0.003208552487194538, -0.008561178110539913, -0.03630855679512024, -0.0036483530420809984, 0.004508312791585922, 0.0030818141531199217, 0.02252071350812912, 0.04919024184346199, 0.033331435173749924, 0.008242908865213394, -0.034672439098358154, 0.01176854595541954, -0.011629370041191578, 0.017331790179014206, -0.015696000307798386, -0.023571567609906197, -0.05765543505549431, -0.03544626757502556, -0.03386493772268295, 0.04650179669260979, -0.002610968891531229, 0.0012806918239220977, -0.018534883856773376, -0.00854515004903078, -0.04809720814228058, 0.021595323458313942, 0.03322095051407814, 0.015883024781942368, 0.010052700527012348, 0.011557037010788918, -0.00025547220138832927, -0.003881101030856371, 0.039789147675037384, 0.013590938411653042, 0.01910478062927723, 0.02360927313566208, -0.0003616971371229738, 0.012597907334566116, -0.0262888353317976, 0.008227636106312275, 0.012750119902193546, -0.01800011657178402, 0.06253067404031754, -0.0007907734252512455, -0.020736850798130035, -0.011537441983819008, 0.006030024494975805, -0.01616332307457924, 0.02683592215180397, 0.00748415244743228, 0.05117225646972656, -0.0030502909794449806, 0.014862763695418835, -0.02070670574903488, -0.012902592308819294, -0.05427245795726776, -0.016624873504042625, 0.012274331413209438, 0.009181942790746689, -0.04469415917992592, -0.02299927920103073, 0.019091326743364334, 0.013427512720227242, -0.016233332455158234, 0.0008433451293967664, 0.07664220035076141, -0.03789587691426277, -0.022530129179358482, -0.00451703742146492, 0.04059619456529617, 0.07684850692749023, -0.02804574929177761, -0.02445259504020214, 0.019733792170882225, -0.009275158867239952, -0.016477251425385475, 0.026393672451376915, -0.007361086085438728, -0.019841430708765984, -0.01496487483382225, -0.03543078154325485, 0.017350971698760986, 0.018325116485357285, -0.04571325704455376, -0.019230956211686134, 0.03518877923488617, -0.02086973376572132, -0.012376474216580391, -0.0199714545160532, -0.0002643139159772545, -0.032543838024139404, 0.03641117736697197, 0.005866938270628452, 0.010819154791533947, 0.009114961139857769, -0.023286374285817146, 0.04406117647886276, -0.001041460083797574, -0.0024693068116903305, 0.014257168397307396, 0.03599543869495392, -0.003617841051891446, -0.006350337527692318, 0.023878417909145355, 0.011933083645999432, 0.00923924520611763, 0.0007277884287759662, 0.008666681125760078, 0.0037570532876998186, 0.02597932517528534, -0.04636024311184883, -0.05431787297129631, -0.03678835555911064, 0.021738503128290176, 0.06290362775325775, -0.0004999380325898528, 0.06903108209371567, 0.0714472085237503, -0.0076857199892401695, 0.01281750574707985, -0.016717106103897095, -0.03333793580532074, -0.03381488844752312, 0.012999190017580986, 0.02778651751577854, -0.019333381205797195, 0.030085407197475433, 0.03390210121870041, -0.0017759163165464997, -0.03732520714402199, -0.024637000635266304, 0.03722469136118889, 0.043063439428806305, 0.03901542350649834, -0.017498690634965897, -0.029550299048423767, 0.04712895676493645, -0.050360988825559616, -0.004234303720295429, -0.013650978915393353, 0.03661276400089264, 0.0251820906996727, 0.04878176748752594, 0.012594200670719147, -0.034474220126867294, -0.01046067290008068, -0.039313361048698425, -0.007636049762368202, 0.02662499062716961, 0.003942871931940317, 0.015947654843330383, 0.027962075546383858, 0.012963586486876011, -0.011777064763009548, 0.005580944009125233, -0.0007178807281889021, -0.07052159309387207, -0.04986026883125305, -0.005736657418310642, -0.02159261144697666, 0.00911187008023262, 0.03575723245739937, -0.026002611964941025, 0.03303642198443413, -0.04264651983976364, 0.039714302867650986, 0.027452172711491585, 0.028941037133336067, -0.03368763625621796, 0.05342554301023483, -0.032729942351579666, -0.00856710597872734, -0.022742124274373055, -0.03557489067316055, 0.11648457497358322, 0.01649130880832672, 0.023226287215948105, -0.09301969408988953, 0.03216048702597618, 0.00047497943160124123, 0.011538536287844181, 0.008108391426503658, 0.02691633626818657, 0.020723426714539528, 0.037618741393089294, 0.014363707974553108, 0.07355989515781403, -0.015575725585222244, -0.019299153238534927, 0.07141909003257751, -0.052687034010887146, -0.030128564685583115, -0.0010820222087204456, 0.020425012335181236, -0.027082663029432297, 0.002416943898424506, -0.0007063382072374225, 0.03014330007135868, 0.005006056744605303, 0.009460256434977055, 0.004206726793199778, -0.03528863191604614, 0.0183259230107069, -0.00040804711170494556, -0.0195209588855505, 0.0029855917673557997, 0.013486355543136597, -0.004733881447464228, -0.006980733014643192, 0.019306575879454613, 0.044060420244932175, -0.03697428107261658, 0.009389511309564114, 0.02098429575562477, -0.01100489404052496, 0.0023861282970756292, 0.010814807377755642, 0.055577993392944336, -0.024587707594037056, -0.026035988703370094, -0.021249137818813324, 0.03784491866827011, -0.041279278695583344, -0.019590912386775017, -0.01699601672589779, -0.005439453292638063, -0.021527322009205818, -0.032200634479522705, -0.039128627628088, 0.010784693993628025, 0.01675306260585785, -0.026101911440491676, -0.01907316967844963, -0.0068931980058550835, 0.05320373922586441, 0.0034956776071339846, 0.03983880579471588, 0.00831957720220089, -0.06264519691467285, 0.01490373071283102, -0.023209335282444954, 0.003697326872497797, -0.007531590759754181, -0.031972046941518784, -0.03853226080536842, 0.0029219205025583506, -0.021908149123191833, -0.001855153008364141, -0.03575501590967178, 0.01834104396402836, 0.015492720529437065, 0.004536671098321676, -0.023557811975479126, 0.025057530030608177, -0.042420193552970886, 0.01416317094117403, -0.028581952676177025, -0.003713765414431691, -0.05221441388130188, -0.04114062339067459, 0.031826961785554886, 0.029849383980035782, 0.05844037979841232, 0.005432089790701866, 0.005574846640229225, -0.0014870791928842664, 0.014957542531192303, -0.039876725524663925, -0.020861996337771416, -0.0225085336714983, -0.013242741115391254, -0.0174461267888546, -0.027127983048558235, 0.020177002996206284, 0.04838123917579651, 0.030111664906144142, -0.017794309183955193, 0.004044307395815849, -0.02774157002568245, 0.023907095193862915, -0.030422816053032875, -0.060083623975515366, -0.005457135848701, 0.027672970667481422, 0.02632860094308853, -0.036048971116542816, -0.060501229017972946, -0.031094737350940704, -0.013162561692297459, 0.018494674935936928, 0.01780376397073269, -0.02135326713323593, 0.020886503159999847, 0.0074922386556863785, 0.03478953614830971, -0.040166500955820084, 0.0015248259296640754, -0.03776202350854874, -0.035489507019519806, 0.007259497884660959, -0.031878333538770676, 0.007694171741604805, -0.011041432619094849, -0.009168571792542934, 0.016349315643310547, 0.017228197306394577, 0.014108291827142239, -0.006382178049534559, -0.0012079350417479873, 0.024610718712210655, -0.02500068210065365, 0.0028272648341953754, -0.010320081375539303, -0.017746824771165848, 0.02419234998524189, -0.03727646917104721, -0.015334033407270908, -0.009723057970404625, 0.004392311908304691, 0.015271873213350773, -0.014716708101332188, -0.01611332781612873, -0.03913596644997597, 0.001194325159303844, 0.003461659187451005, 0.010520259849727154, 0.00816422700881958, 0.0029151435010135174, -0.01150105707347393, 0.007772495504468679, 0.01873541623353958, -0.03570357337594032, -0.026068873703479767, 0.04175332188606262, 0.028015723451972008, 0.028602359816432, -0.0002505789161659777, 0.02968674525618553, -0.013466793112456799, 0.03542826324701309, 0.009898103773593903, -0.018611237406730652, 0.0319555290043354, 0.044031884521245956, 0.016309522092342377, 0.056830741465091705, -0.0010140797821804881, 0.012134818360209465, -0.09593911468982697, -0.01795327663421631, 0.03773289546370506, 0.022441627457737923, 0.03454582393169403, -0.07976951450109482, 0.003250167705118656, 0.009496381506323814, -0.052125200629234314, 0.042026061564683914, -0.042273227125406265, -0.04791741445660591, -0.024873290210962296, -0.049349915236234665, 0.006505077704787254, 0.05070032179355621, 0.028155652806162834, 0.008828630670905113, -0.019771497696638107, 0.002846033778041601, 0.007812597788870335, -0.01173936203122139, -0.004964424297213554, 0.012955748476088047, -0.020688936114311218, -0.0799124613404274, 0.036294110119342804, -0.002533489605411887, -0.05708548054099083, 0.013017204590141773, -0.02246011421084404, 0.012100718915462494, -0.0021064497996121645, 0.022850625216960907, -0.029495835304260254, 0.061291709542274475, 0.06200038641691208, -0.03610428422689438, -0.009216361679136753, 0.005791828036308289, 0.009889199398458004, 0.01957886852324009, 0.006149276625365019, -0.0097831254824996, 0.02565060555934906, -0.03564242646098137, -0.034781064838171005, 0.004327245056629181, -0.005916215013712645, -0.02075369842350483, 0.01953032612800598, -0.015848230570554733, 0.026679113507270813, -0.036324139684438705, 0.05604337528347969, -0.04615413025021553, -0.02078087441623211, 0.024339087307453156, 0.06336967647075653, 0.0221111923456192, 0.008233604021370411, -0.026387110352516174, 0.006683441810309887, 0.026872871443629265, 0.042438067495822906, 0.016491249203681946, -0.05015455186367035, -0.0038027893751859665, -0.0006749894237145782, 0.00837795902043581, -0.015679173171520233, -0.025537438690662384, -0.008236924186348915, 0.013422670774161816, 0.046559564769268036, 0.0026286779902875423, -0.01399880088865757, -0.05413157492876053, 0.016401516273617744, -0.0634678527712822, 0.06425487995147705, -0.006042418070137501, 0.03118976205587387, -0.009037197567522526, -0.0076676118187606335, -0.019269531592726707, -0.006832152605056763, 0.05717454105615616, 0.004804824013262987, -0.001428394578397274, -0.00929857324808836, -0.01528614480048418, -0.0020228521898388863, -0.01763741858303547, 0.04297735542058945, -0.04596846550703049, -0.02042139507830143, -0.02520313672721386, -0.005587050691246986, 0.04116463661193848, -0.0035557644441723824, 0.016205348074436188, 0.006191949360072613, 0.0010467527899891138, -0.025994841009378433, -0.005930684041231871, 0.051165882498025894, 0.04447136074304581, -0.01670435070991516, 0.04444635659456253, -0.0052178590558469296, 0.015734123066067696, -0.027733495458960533, -0.057491373270750046, -0.0441836342215538, 0.052731338888406754, -0.023055896162986755, -0.040411919355392456, 0.004208291880786419, -0.011217929422855377, 0.006307545118033886, -0.03960884362459183, -0.022093819454312325, 0.0381881520152092, -0.03283631056547165, -0.03532738611102104, -0.0067779491655528545, 0.03367600217461586, 0.024406621232628822, -0.018589355051517487, 0.008444939740002155, 0.025892246514558792, -0.028390809893608093, -0.005335283000022173, 0.010565715841948986, 0.06858561187982559, 0.035811349749565125, -0.033937908709049225, 0.03913489729166031, -0.03483808785676956, -0.000172944666701369, -0.019954739138484, 0.05857883393764496, -0.03209339827299118, -0.033395182341337204, 0.017211226746439934, -0.029775863513350487, 0.0245785191655159, 0.004312383476644754, -0.0024281113874167204, 0.09672339260578156, -0.05935459956526756, 0.012444411404430866, -0.044979579746723175, -0.0017533773789182305, -0.020545098930597305, -0.009191697463393211, 0.045048605650663376, 0.008026805706322193, -0.013225024566054344, -0.00087080302182585, -0.03407729044556618, 0.006628658622503281, 0.05280100554227829, -0.003584430320188403, 0.031898196786642075, 0.014046289958059788, -0.03388093784451485, 0.012819952331483364, -0.009308086708188057, -0.0407412126660347, -0.018601112067699432, 0.04615535959601402, 0.0765654444694519, 0.007481459062546492, -0.030154898762702942, -0.018268480896949768, -0.0160232987254858, 0.060847070068120956, -0.0864616185426712, -0.021040258929133415, -0.05007234960794449, -0.005538451485335827, -0.0061190067790448666, -0.02216307632625103 ]
<p>Principal component analysis <em>can use</em> matrix decomposition, but that is just a tool to get there.</p> <p>How would you find the principal components without the use of matrix algebra?</p> <p>What is your objective function (goal), and what are your constraints?</p> <p>Thanks!</p>
73,741
[ -0.027380062267184258, 0.01964993216097355, -0.02710297703742981, -0.016323935240507126, 0.05590219050645828, -0.017760060727596283, -0.03915003314614296, -0.015612329356372356, 0.01203110907226801, -0.03340992331504822, 0.016221515834331512, 0.02307705208659172, 0.04229317978024483, 0.026194194331765175, -0.0065096160396933556, 0.00443204864859581, 0.0004078838974237442, 0.006583144888281822, -0.001582542434334755, 0.011859971098601818, -0.0212294552475214, 0.010062886402010918, 0.02548840455710888, 0.0009102117037400603, -0.0037030703388154507, 0.08403490483760834, 0.024935182183980942, -0.020399803295731544, 0.011134350672364235, 0.036803826689720154, -0.04141184315085411, -0.012503608129918575, 0.014851543121039867, 0.06818842142820358, 0.03454654663801193, -0.012002447620034218, -0.03400227054953575, -0.009632185101509094, -0.01760510355234146, 0.03481298312544823, 0.0010269805788993835, -0.022024810314178467, 0.006105329375714064, 0.00872733909636736, -0.03699609264731407, 0.03631552681326866, -0.003932829946279526, -0.04512869939208031, 0.015207605436444283, -0.046274252235889435, 0.09212162345647812, 0.015892593190073967, 0.03158380091190338, 0.016021380200982094, -0.03904842585325241, -0.004076956305652857, 0.05556068941950798, 0.0623462088406086, -0.008124026469886303, -0.05501642823219299, -0.01434490829706192, 0.013318569399416447, -0.009930470027029514, -0.04518241435289383, -0.04051865637302399, 0.026632312685251236, 0.004861472174525261, 0.008775725960731506, 0.04248564690351486, 0.005193881690502167, 0.003978653810918331, 0.003661811351776123, 0.036853667348623276, -0.016373220831155777, -0.030152292922139168, -0.0516074076294899, 0.0051562185399234295, 0.013130544684827328, 0.03069104440510273, 0.022248677909374237, 0.03030576929450035, 0.00170002575032413, -0.0006887511699460447, 0.01968950219452381, 0.03336285799741745, 0.012089120224118233, 0.07003622502088547, -0.03346463665366173, 0.0028634166810661554, -0.0009828631300479174, -0.002600399311631918, 0.017993180081248283, 0.032023388892412186, 0.027417998760938644, -0.02597866766154766, 0.014486595056951046, -0.0003436171100474894, 0.05399387702345848, 0.03090834990143776, -0.026475615799427032, 0.017734626308083534, 0.0044236574321985245, 0.005482991226017475, 0.0398838073015213, 0.01118843350559473, 0.018874820321798325, -0.03068963810801506, 0.015359281562268734, 0.0023767445236444473, -0.02718442678451538, -0.02938963659107685, -0.007768238428980112, 0.02215220034122467, -0.02075079269707203, 0.04022236168384552, -0.007825558073818684, -0.007516998331993818, -0.022408895194530487, 0.05373261123895645, 0.09881904721260071, 0.018582157790660858, -0.03414924442768097, 0.011862354353070259, -0.016692427918314934, -0.07096629589796066, -0.007717513013631105, -0.012561900541186333, -0.007024018559604883, -0.049386363476514816, 0.044211115688085556, -0.009631438180804253, -0.02551504597067833, 0.048453979194164276, -0.024751201272010803, 0.0027771261520683765, 0.007663473952561617, -0.11213179677724838, -0.03414143994450569, 0.036784280091524124, -0.050347231328487396, 0.009652180597186089, -0.06165749579668045, -0.0069901347160339355, 0.010013770312070847, 0.07271239161491394, -0.00863301195204258, 0.002990070963278413, 0.05208905041217804, 0.012775368057191372, -0.00826088897883892, -0.022125594317913055, -0.022136982530355453, -0.035081058740615845, -0.03483988717198372, -0.04605213925242424, -0.05909586697816849, 0.018433699384331703, 0.04802853241562843, -0.008659480139613152, -0.0006272738100960851, 0.02886623702943325, 0.019927820190787315, -0.027180753648281097, 0.013868974521756172, -0.020859435200691223, -0.010896283201873302, 0.025993896648287773, -0.0010827548103407025, 0.020793145522475243, 0.016680622473359108, -0.006186372600495815, 0.03940713033080101, 0.0353325717151165, 0.05058577284216881, 0.04777159541845322, -0.005288522690534592, -0.015308797359466553, 0.04787110909819603, 0.02699311450123787, -0.008433005772531033, -0.06337662041187286, -0.06898900121450424, 0.024731377139687538, 0.017425835132598877, 0.04309579357504845, 0.05443715304136276, 0.0030943613965064287, -0.05452025309205055, 0.030989229679107666, -0.017862984910607338, -0.027116188779473305, -0.08762151002883911, 0.042032718658447266, 0.005337034352123737, -0.007184362504631281, 0.022029025480151176, 0.01600060984492302, -0.005775215104222298, -0.028449470177292824, -0.04989072307944298, -0.03585449233651161, 0.009738261811435223, 0.0280027873814106, -0.016655348241329193, -0.019158845767378807, 0.03872043266892433, 0.04200732707977295, -0.02301366999745369, 0.024681363254785538, -0.03574192151427269, -0.05337194725871086, -0.004320526495575905, -0.041413865983486176, 0.006916184443980455, 0.002432772424072027, 0.00014161906437948346, 0.021103691309690475, -0.0004894779995083809, -0.06031103804707527, 0.011814788915216923, -0.03681333735585213, 0.09122386574745178, 0.03816596418619156, 0.015731848776340485, 0.028391122817993164, -0.014127776026725769, 0.03127187862992287, -0.0010547322453930974, 0.001889747683890164, 0.009884728118777275, -0.06509768217802048, 0.0019690582994371653, 0.04576876014471054, 0.018573785200715065, -0.08397692441940308, 0.03523540496826172, 0.047801751643419266, 0.05106133967638016, -0.0004177522787358612, 0.03436805307865143, -0.013574008829891682, 0.0064323158003389835, -0.005022908095270395, 0.0025362109299749136, -0.02021356299519539, 0.007689184043556452, -0.0011865103151649237, 0.021944774314761162, 0.039094582200050354, 0.017257288098335266, -0.0023432716261595488, 0.06984701007604599, -0.004960794933140278, -0.012934411875903606, -0.0040276553481817245, -0.04152616858482361, 0.009880687110126019, -0.004352001938968897, 0.03313180059194565, 0.014977912418544292, 0.01437854953110218, -0.011003818362951279, -0.012612882070243359, -0.02810065820813179, -0.0015108584193512797, 0.02651328407227993, -0.048793043941259384, 0.043888576328754425, 0.03532751649618149, -0.036083221435546875, 0.01705111749470234, -0.019006721675395966, -0.008386124856770039, -0.059822216629981995, 0.0015801034169271588, 0.058307964354753494, -0.0033320155926048756, 0.04251715540885925, -0.003279729513451457, -0.03432503342628479, 0.014517439529299736, -0.02594173140823841, -0.005721059162169695, 0.022854134440422058, -0.05937207117676735, -0.008254054933786392, -0.02431674115359783, 0.005872742272913456, 0.027109196409583092, -0.017175013199448586, -0.00039133569225668907, 0.04176286980509758, 0.008040393702685833, -0.05911615863442421, -0.0129650654271245, -0.012035579420626163, 0.027447836473584175, -0.016626590862870216, -0.017537156119942665, 0.018174229189753532, -0.005329741630703211, -0.010998242534697056, -0.008595101535320282, -0.03220542147755623, -0.030764659866690636, -0.017275957390666008, -0.012538603506982327, 0.021248195320367813, -0.01944105699658394, -0.017382197082042694, 0.05228820815682411, -0.0240809116512537, 0.038212839514017105, -0.04973708465695381, -0.0713549256324768, 0.00048589360085316, 0.021897586062550545, 0.03186432272195816, 0.03514173999428749, -0.04023580625653267, 0.07262403517961502, 0.022545674815773964, -0.06709875166416168, -0.03283417224884033, -0.020970681682229042, -0.03516930341720581, -0.053907815366983414, 0.011992696672677994, -0.0050482670776546, 0.021728932857513428, 0.0006180469645187259, -0.01508092600852251, -0.004583550151437521, 0.0666385218501091, 0.025451159104704857, -0.020543936640024185, 0.015454105101525784, -0.007308560889214277, -0.011764074675738811, 0.024155011400580406, 0.00959988497197628, -0.0459895133972168, 0.02918294072151184, 0.04184965789318085, 0.00683344341814518, 0.011797741055488586, -0.038010746240615845, -0.008991663344204426, -0.03525454178452492, 0.017324605956673622, -0.03818923607468605, 0.002570693613961339, -0.0006783005665056407, 0.020114244893193245, 0.02152460440993309, 0.01740986295044422, 0.014521310105919838, -0.007691746577620506, -0.01795770972967148, 0.05146520584821701, 0.02165808714926243, -0.008728482760488987, 0.008887706324458122, 0.010828707367181778, -0.023310933262109756, 0.01211871113628149, 0.0009626187384128571, 0.022053975611925125, 0.062401868402957916, 0.023746347054839134, 0.03995886072516441, 0.026357773691415787, -0.03185102716088295, -0.003147798590362072, -0.0792921707034111, 0.046222295612096786, -0.031113335862755775, 0.055321015417575836, -0.0010945830726996064, 0.07546842098236084, 0.0141957001760602, 0.019716089591383934, 0.012130715884268284, -0.00606918940320611, -0.07887617498636246, -0.0017609321512281895, -0.0388270765542984, 0.012592552229762077, 0.009818959049880505, 0.006425054743885994, 0.03013586811721325, -0.02346622385084629, 0.0052747479639947414, 0.0029076766222715378, 0.022729041054844856, -0.037950560450553894, 0.024075880646705627, -0.016815317794680595, 0.015800131484866142, -0.017823999747633934, -0.010573215782642365, 0.05935768038034439, -0.005734941456466913, 0.054595764726400375, 0.06325887888669968, -0.007338693831115961, -0.012592627666890621, -0.00021013164951000363, -0.0033398843370378017, 0.021459894254803658, 0.048903342336416245, -0.01691201888024807, 0.024277187883853912, -0.021041149273514748, 0.035950612276792526, -0.015480553731322289, 0.07823469489812851, -0.018097655847668648, 0.026719246059656143, -0.015024525113403797, -0.03961652144789696, -0.01974087953567505, -0.007147036958485842, 0.02659301832318306, -0.03370935842394829, -0.03419995307922363, 0.024586696177721024, 0.02454010210931301, -0.048345159739255905, 0.021295784041285515, 0.07535503804683685, 0.04409904405474663, -0.024109670892357826, -0.03030727617442608, -0.015675727277994156, -0.012370406650006771, -0.025151614099740982, 0.02224697358906269, -0.0126803582534194, -0.0003583841898944229, -0.01348116248846054, 0.04601862654089928, -0.016506778076291084, -0.005183147266507149, 0.00989450141787529, 0.01786181889474392, 0.04263821989297867, -0.0009033939568325877, -0.028965763747692108, 0.006949807982891798, 0.056252431124448776, 0.04819060117006302, 0.007779428735375404, -0.021760940551757812, -0.10151753574609756, 0.014592078514397144, 0.03956896811723709, 0.06276348978281021, -0.033855002373456955, -0.012034288607537746, -0.042776450514793396, -0.04154694452881813, 0.038412582129240036, -0.029411539435386658, 0.03563079982995987, -0.014051314443349838, 0.030399836599826813, -0.03993503376841545, -0.021524880081415176, -0.01855151541531086, -0.0006877242703922093, -0.0054241870529949665, 0.02558274008333683, -0.015664581209421158, -0.039103914052248, -0.06220532953739166, 0.02203732542693615, 0.027962783351540565, 0.05668722838163376, 0.0338919423520565, 0.0041464450769126415, 0.015093081630766392, 0.041779808700084686, -0.03229672461748123, -0.09731197357177734, 0.010007702745497227, 0.02506285160779953, -0.034999869763851166, 0.03594222292304039, -0.018232107162475586, -0.05204160884022713, 0.0012206187238916755, -0.004677511285990477, -0.023156113922595978, -0.016033519059419632, 0.0035411748103797436, 0.04688858240842819, 0.017371272668242455, 0.013968304730951786, 0.057030610740184784, -0.005405458156019449, -0.033609192818403244, -0.005576436873525381, -0.05653751268982887, 0.009279564954340458, -0.01856991834938526, -0.020256763324141502, -0.030988924205303192, 0.011750002391636372, 0.00031055285944603384, -0.0027008780743926764, 0.023323794826865196, 0.03361954167485237, -0.008512753993272781, -0.025916391983628273, -0.027744881808757782, 0.03626575693488121, -0.03648955747485161, -0.0015510275261476636, -0.0010949253337457776, 0.01990744099020958, -0.017713146284222603, -0.025886045768857002, 0.02047475427389145, 0.01423455961048603, 0.004609555937349796, -0.0002956486423499882, -0.005530370865017176, -0.01024929154664278, -0.06262855976819992, -0.027637265622615814, 0.015105755999684334, -0.034193579107522964, 0.0717926099896431, -0.011307886801660061, 0.03981297090649605, 0.04498264193534851, -0.07142537832260132, -0.01087899785488844, 0.01776484213769436, -0.030831651762127876, 0.02613130211830139, -0.02148428000509739, 0.03479217365384102, -0.04351689666509628, -0.006517887581139803, -0.06175754964351654, -0.08193813264369965, 0.0021464996971189976, 0.0279560387134552, -0.020704645663499832, -0.04524486884474754, -0.007555009331554174, -0.015470094047486782, -0.006780584342777729, -0.024573873728513718, 0.025480957701802254, -0.047420695424079895, -0.0035424239467829466, 0.02733328938484192, 0.010690812952816486, 0.055913493037223816, -0.006551608443260193, 0.004022661130875349, 0.013174261897802353, -0.038085248321294785, 0.012356520630419254, -0.0402124859392643, 0.021869873628020287, -0.021236425265669823, -0.011019406840205193, -0.06721345335245132, 0.016124719753861427, 0.05754934623837471, -0.015486802905797958, 0.013452455401420593, -0.005086357239633799, 0.03271627798676491, -0.014371893368661404, -0.03348635137081146, -0.0031932189594954252, -0.03627001494169235, 0.0025326109025627375, 0.01989165134727955, 0.0007611535838805139, -0.049929820001125336, -0.011546088382601738, 0.03179352357983589, -0.00017802408547140658, -0.019973138347268105, 0.0200676117092371, 0.052219122648239136, -0.017337616533041, 0.04187958687543869, -0.0014901425456628203, -0.016396328806877136, 0.038703154772520065, 0.013932568952441216, 0.020519305020570755, -0.010202264413237572, 0.010747105814516544, -0.037852246314287186, -0.054524894803762436, -0.022784851491451263, -0.0036361662205308676, 0.05456032603979111, 0.005435338243842125, 0.055155590176582336, 0.07642392069101334, 0.013911751098930836, 0.0008974052616395056, -0.017277473583817482, 0.00788373313844204, 0.03189481422305107, 0.020578136667609215, 0.04138938710093498, 0.013069817796349525, 0.016879497095942497, 0.01738310419023037, 0.012626453302800655, -0.004319971427321434, 0.03341083973646164, 0.016897032037377357, 0.03410344570875168, 0.031389251351356506, -0.05161536484956741, -0.07087771594524384, -0.012007351964712143, -0.0555078387260437, 0.03102887235581875, -0.025193916633725166, -0.02588169276714325, 0.04490657150745392, 0.034914854913949966, -0.03789404034614563, -0.019635919481515884, -0.006991853006184101, -0.03489935025572777, 0.01739412173628807, 0.0226142480969429, 0.01628226414322853, -0.003350985934957862, -0.006728633306920528, 0.026337627321481705, -0.021068792790174484, 0.03631915897130966, 0.003785237204283476, -0.0634935274720192, -0.05480773746967316, -0.0065728300251066685, -0.003918318543583155, 0.028311336413025856, 0.016482453793287277, -0.04139034077525139, 0.024838073179125786, -0.015039169229567051, 0.011137683875858784, 0.002573132747784257, 0.05762074515223503, -0.021988078951835632, 0.027472855523228645, -0.01635265350341797, -0.0022204024717211723, 0.021892322227358818, 0.012834509834647179, 0.10176880657672882, 0.07285511493682861, 0.028362026438117027, -0.054663900285959244, 0.03379498049616814, -0.01656203158199787, -0.011877107433974743, -0.03811267763376236, 0.04131760820746422, -0.0035736234858632088, 0.010794226080179214, 0.01223328709602356, 0.040268197655677795, 0.00598415220156312, 0.005130791570991278, 0.07409416139125824, -0.06040523573756218, -0.04110279306769371, 0.00797644816339016, -0.01160725113004446, -0.026656650006771088, 0.010758703574538231, -0.02270154468715191, 0.015583575703203678, -0.017927657812833786, -0.051464129239320755, -0.031270742416381836, -0.0340278297662735, 0.013075434602797031, -0.028378257527947426, -0.0246242918074131, 0.010502439923584461, 0.031002111732959747, 0.01849977858364582, -0.04276939108967781, 0.014290732331573963, 0.010215668939054012, -0.04091121628880501, 0.0006393425283022225, -0.007739793974906206, 0.024888163432478905, -0.0402187816798687, -0.002081730170175433, -0.005756343249231577, -0.032814301550388336, -0.01654687523841858, -0.03140036389231682, 0.07295582443475723, -0.02698545530438423, 0.009843824431300163, -0.025416603311896324, -0.0023395426105707884, -0.0022477710153907537, -0.04638172313570976, -0.00018039238057099283, 0.016836293041706085, 0.046720463782548904, 0.002815506886690855, -0.014832221902906895, -0.04149670898914337, 0.023076586425304413, -0.026272602379322052, 0.02914843149483204, 0.006133826915174723, 0.016093287616968155, 0.005811172537505627, -0.01316917221993208, 0.06672080606222153, -0.013270224444568157, 0.0017081542173400521, -0.01877218671143055, -0.02431395836174488, -0.018085427582263947, -0.030224254354834557, 0.024370037019252777, 0.029902145266532898, 0.021762721240520477, -0.0003186085377819836, -0.0013527537230402231, 0.01131619792431593, -0.016921700909733772, 0.010051173157989979, -0.023200377821922302, -0.006155867595225573, -0.02415578067302704, 0.008008983917534351, 0.03404438495635986, 0.06782834976911545, 0.008611048571765423, 0.023644644767045975, -0.0066757225431501865, 0.0286305733025074, 0.008421988226473331, -0.01648208312690258, -0.03954615816473961, -0.01090176496654749, -0.014885211363434792, 0.027938388288021088, 0.0028508082032203674, 0.05341362580657005, 0.022816350683569908, -0.023579316213726997, -0.03604621812701225, 0.048647698014974594, -0.04028487950563431, -0.000792506558354944, 0.02358749881386757, -0.02736353687942028, -0.005235318094491959, 0.0017995063681155443, 0.022041553631424904, -0.04291057959198952, 0.0029676828999072313, -0.030157653614878654, 0.020430564880371094, 0.0021246487740427256, 0.02848147228360176, 0.008392267860472202, 0.01002773642539978, -0.021148445084691048, 0.057726263999938965, -0.05749645456671715, -0.005413347855210304, -0.04155419021844864, 0.036580491811037064, -0.0164142157882452, -0.0010708165355026722, -0.017737682908773422, -0.00938537996262312, -0.012275141663849354, 0.009219415485858917, 0.04529786854982376, 0.009343670681118965, 0.008656618185341358, 0.008935759775340557, -0.0005432179314084351, -0.021011225879192352, 0.040487147867679596, -0.030171465128660202, -0.005548646207898855, 0.037210769951343536, -0.06247352808713913, -0.020114513114094734, -0.021138569340109825, -0.020443949848413467, 0.049085937440395355, 0.03255447745323181, -0.016064144670963287, -0.025045283138751984, 0.008917106315493584, -0.017079045996069908, -0.02976032719016075, -0.010849733836948872, 0.021944444626569748, -0.031162919476628304, 0.003408083226531744, 0.02135411836206913, -0.019833171740174294, -0.048899389803409576, 0.042852193117141724, 0.03335097059607506, 0.0067068226635456085, -0.0323694609105587, 0.0646829828619957, 0.006988853216171265, -0.0024398586247116327, 0.030967572703957558, -0.02433890290558338, 0.03684689849615097, 0.03275368735194206, -0.031696438789367676, 0.012971378862857819, -0.009593429043889046, 0.006624104455113411, -0.08507756888866425, -0.004155421629548073, -0.031046221032738686, -0.0020731536205857992, 0.04185394570231438, -0.05916741117835045, 0.012047741562128067, 0.05570903420448303, -0.05311986804008484, 0.03249182179570198, -0.00047045349492691457, -0.0047610136680305, 0.021201713010668755, 0.03533830866217613, -0.01476196013391018, 0.03403058648109436, 0.02215667814016342, 0.01137111708521843, 0.0383874885737896, 0.028892677277326584, 0.027743594720959663, -0.005415615160018206, 0.01640402153134346, -0.008065453730523586, 0.00415845587849617, -0.048678405582904816, 0.02841276489198208, -0.021335626021027565, -0.03737792745232582, -0.002954998752102256, -0.021274929866194725, 0.044929131865501404, 0.03922632709145546, 0.02298302762210369, -0.016911553218960762, 0.031842608004808426, 0.026152702048420906, -0.02371583878993988, -0.01577889360487461, 0.007838663645088673, -0.003845534985885024, 0.04184826835989952, 0.013492874801158905, 0.04587714746594429, 0.020999029278755188, -0.008112328127026558, -0.023467568680644035, -0.03631642833352089, -0.03722028806805611, -0.030287710949778557, -0.003488295478746295, -0.017236579209566116, -0.025930412113666534, -0.000688933243509382, -0.007467077113687992, -0.025332020595669746, -0.0031924366485327482, 0.0003985872317571193, -0.0007120560039766133, -0.026990031823515892, 0.02036997675895691, 0.00900210626423359, -0.04729088395833969, 0.025851476937532425, 0.011566181667149067, -0.001288507948629558, -0.08728761225938797, 0.004310521762818098, 0.039714083075523376, -0.07381995022296906, -0.018382638692855835, -0.028088947758078575, -0.034727394580841064, 0.040750835090875626, 0.008019635453820229, 0.007597093470394611, 0.046505287289619446, -0.030367309227585793, 0.023676207289099693, -0.04576653614640236, 0.06409309804439545, -0.0011834120377898216, -0.03312870115041733, -0.012317226268351078, -0.03445516899228096, -0.028355102986097336, 0.015369415283203125, 0.040102519094944, -0.035449691116809845, 0.002382562728598714, -0.018452057614922523, 0.016324495896697044, -0.004438149277120829, -0.042122527956962585, 0.06530928611755371, -0.007007865235209465, -0.04125857725739479, -0.029219554737210274, -0.030983414500951767, 0.0016734502278268337, -0.004215975292026997, 0.016080342233181, -0.00048447237350046635, -0.0023982480634003878, -0.002193654654547572, -0.012206639163196087, 0.04942919313907623, 0.0011367803672328591, -0.014952296391129494, 0.02995242178440094, 0.0028618525248020887, 0.02694731019437313, 0.02831086330115795, -0.017277168110013008, -0.008759241551160812, 0.03815753012895584, -0.03363974019885063, -0.00500579783692956, 0.020884571596980095, 0.014889855869114399, 0.03646010532975197, -0.06020493805408478, 0.014008846133947372, 0.032168712466955185, -0.05528285726904869, 0.0121628288179636, 0.033188171684741974, -0.0024352401960641146, -0.010802263393998146, 0.007300969213247299, 0.024391986429691315, 0.026728050783276558, -0.0000919976519071497, 0.0006067880312912166, 0.038641806691884995, 0.01440848782658577, -0.0003337397938594222, 0.01332518644630909, 0.040518004447221756, 0.0025539076887071133, 0.01341637410223484, -0.012944349087774754, 0.028729582205414772, -0.02897731028497219, -0.02122858166694641, 0.015816546976566315, -0.007591230794787407, 0.05176999419927597, -0.012544720433652401, -0.021719396114349365, 0.07492411881685257, -0.028057483956217766, -0.023064158856868744, -0.02642744407057762, 0.01903381571173668, -0.04159126058220863, -0.0018040077993646264, -0.01998928189277649, 0.04016721248626709, -0.006676963064819574, 0.004914730321615934, -0.015145103447139263, -0.025195913389325142, 0.016947930678725243, -0.007428677752614021, 0.03493160009384155, 0.0075881751254200935, 0.008473403751850128, -0.022723186761140823, -0.013265153393149376, -0.04218253865838051, -0.014328896068036556, 0.011720260605216026, 0.040416065603494644, 0.010410594753921032, 0.0055823614820837975, -0.015991492196917534, -0.01524607464671135, 0.02204446867108345, -0.04462098702788353, -0.020585089921951294, -0.025636974722146988, -0.0056624142453074455, -0.0030745097901672125, 0.013812374323606491 ]
<p>What is the easiest way / method to compute the correlation between two time series that are exactly the same size? I thought of multiplying $(x[t]-\mu_x)$ and $(y[t] - \mu_y)$, and adding up the multiplication. So if this single number was positive, can we say these two series are correlated? I can think of some examples however where a linearly another exponentially growing time series would have no relation to eachother, but the computation above would report they were correlated. </p> <p>Any thoughts?</p>
42,713
[ -0.008534969761967659, -0.009852239862084389, 0.007889887318015099, -0.00185247918125242, 0.03742966428399086, 0.027017535641789436, 0.004574724938720465, -0.015123248100280762, 0.02267891727387905, -0.02686944045126438, 0.024479106068611145, 0.017960771918296814, 0.05350589007139206, 0.013260283507406712, 0.018791720271110535, 0.0017545002046972513, -0.02879367582499981, 0.025648122653365135, 0.002456269459798932, -0.016474183648824692, -0.008299384266138077, 0.02594071999192238, 0.056538473814725876, -0.022032320499420166, -0.04455476999282837, 0.05358951538801193, 0.03227021172642708, -0.028154965490102768, -0.004939844831824303, 0.071982242166996, -0.0630945935845375, -0.030178170651197433, 0.03722233697772026, 0.06281115859746933, -0.009741909801959991, -0.01971626840531826, -0.026858465746045113, -0.03365900740027428, 0.018390584737062454, 0.02272047847509384, -0.04680885374546051, -0.04445875808596611, -0.015393177978694439, 0.019714323803782463, -0.01613086834549904, 0.025860169902443886, -0.006952085066586733, 0.0019633627962321043, 0.036820776760578156, -0.023395512253046036, 0.10031630098819733, -0.015411346219480038, 0.04916270822286606, 0.02226797677576542, 0.01423516497015953, 0.0024843430146574974, 0.0444827638566494, 0.050332024693489075, -0.002138010924682021, -0.020251303911209106, -0.015343893319368362, 0.023358356207609177, 0.01111193373799324, -0.01945759542286396, -0.018271638080477715, 0.02828509360551834, -0.021810822188854218, -0.02414955385029316, 0.021840980276465416, -0.0027265935204923153, 0.030617479234933853, 0.04555943235754967, 0.051299311220645905, -0.020174497738480568, -0.007084331475198269, -0.0018081783782690763, 0.016430838033556938, 0.020757151767611504, 0.03230389952659607, 0.048009127378463745, -0.00044243488810025156, 0.03227302432060242, 0.054073404520750046, 0.012099724262952805, 0.04327908903360367, -0.0017609595088288188, 0.053764812648296356, -0.010953789576888084, 0.02011239156126976, 0.01881735771894455, -0.013699006289243698, -0.011360409669578075, 0.06583651155233383, -0.018245290964841843, -0.04499829187989235, 0.03502107784152031, -0.019015491008758545, 0.03650004789233208, 0.03726617619395256, 0.005771011579781771, -0.01909755915403366, -0.052376292645931244, 0.004781837109476328, 0.04732191935181618, -0.024923576042056084, -0.008387806825339794, -0.01996585726737976, 0.019174542278051376, -0.0037417428102344275, -0.015158063732087612, -0.025614047423005104, -0.006234356202185154, -0.0023411524016410112, 0.0036993413232266903, 0.022710805758833885, 0.04029626026749611, 0.007227025926113129, -0.0037408536300063133, 0.047812074422836304, 0.0868099257349968, 0.019159112125635147, -0.012461720034480095, 0.021036142483353615, -0.008865260519087315, -0.038556843996047974, 0.021513180807232857, 0.01007407158613205, -0.01833539642393589, -0.06636476516723633, 0.06697181612253189, 0.015062632039189339, -0.037580616772174835, 0.011554093100130558, -0.03355003148317337, 0.051786117255687714, 0.01415687520056963, -0.06613273173570633, -0.03585563972592354, 0.061362069100141525, -0.02597358636558056, -0.01851598359644413, -0.04610823467373848, 0.016728397458791733, 0.034972745925188065, 0.08029410243034363, 0.01145204994827509, 0.03092929907143116, 0.013453844003379345, 0.04113707318902016, 0.021181518211960793, -0.011032018810510635, -0.017761442810297012, -0.022051546722650528, -0.00827686209231615, 0.016818882897496223, -0.06240527704358101, -0.015531064011156559, 0.041992779821157455, -0.013413007371127605, -0.0047857328318059444, 0.06625946611166, 0.021944059059023857, -0.006589963100850582, -0.01526657398790121, 0.010995895601809025, -0.04269223287701607, 0.05305704101920128, -0.014681999571621418, -0.011091168038547039, -0.02652229741215706, -0.013296721503138542, -0.0070088873617351055, 0.05829654633998871, 0.05109100416302681, 0.059045061469078064, -0.01453866995871067, -0.011869668029248714, -0.011395747773349285, 0.025426991283893585, 0.01330056507140398, -0.01649070344865322, -0.047301460057497025, -0.039232153445482254, -0.05389944463968277, 0.04052699729800224, 0.051327284425497055, 0.0210789293050766, -0.02297731675207615, 0.00795966386795044, -0.05370526760816574, -0.034186527132987976, -0.05321938917040825, -0.003213035874068737, -0.026053670793771744, -0.016368668526411057, 0.056362275034189224, 0.0030637220479547977, 0.024960067123174667, -0.021926341578364372, -0.05210702866315842, 0.0016513355076313019, 0.014087987132370472, 0.023625804111361504, -0.030017852783203125, 0.02014533430337906, 0.00955711118876934, 0.04529717192053795, 0.0020059985108673573, 0.014199660159647465, -0.023221438750624657, -0.034651611000299454, 0.022594524547457695, -0.028774013742804527, 0.0020420115906745195, -0.023559536784887314, -0.028025969862937927, -0.0019542439840734005, -0.030688859522342682, -0.039219606667757034, 0.01530037634074688, -0.028410188853740692, 0.041839372366666794, 0.05042222887277603, 0.017466414719820023, 0.013919082470238209, -0.00016991911979857832, 0.04205060750246048, -0.0077191623859107494, -0.033407196402549744, -0.03953402489423752, -0.06226338446140289, -0.012696441262960434, 0.05125657841563225, 0.08965691179037094, -0.025324834510684013, 0.0003701133537106216, 0.06734521687030792, 0.03584340587258339, 0.003899127012118697, 0.05717475712299347, -0.015078166499733925, -0.014628011733293533, -0.01657268777489662, -0.005767997819930315, -0.0010546089615672827, -0.019731538370251656, -0.002189300023019314, 0.02594631165266037, 0.014612085185945034, -0.0015284904511645436, -0.04143664613366127, 0.021895522251725197, 0.014155910350382328, 0.020797288045287132, -0.019352946430444717, -0.019285403192043304, 0.02225215546786785, -0.030431967228651047, 0.013411428779363632, -0.010618997737765312, 0.0065753464587032795, 0.023577135056257248, 0.0006597738247364759, 0.0034805184695869684, -0.008049593307077885, 0.0023626626934856176, -0.02505880407989025, -0.01615702360868454, 0.02625250071287155, -0.02772008441388607, 0.025201577693223953, -0.01676136627793312, -0.05023784935474396, 0.003799509024247527, 0.02052406594157219, 0.042817264795303345, 0.02177571691572666, 0.022302860394120216, -0.027789060026407242, -0.03761010244488716, -0.011338455602526665, -0.002494951942935586, 0.028722062706947327, 0.0008889550226740539, -0.029424145817756653, 0.01534639485180378, -0.01369067095220089, -0.015772216022014618, 0.002866933820769191, -0.02479790523648262, 0.01772441901266575, 0.01628050208091736, -0.01052133645862341, -0.09530622512102127, -0.027930354699492455, -0.0414666086435318, 0.00018947338685393333, -0.012054736725986004, 0.01709415763616562, 0.06266770511865616, -0.004216865636408329, -0.10218495875597, -0.003956689964979887, -0.021057788282632828, 0.0037590647116303444, -0.044765107333660126, -0.024737611413002014, -0.0011367639526724815, -0.04063691198825836, 0.009222818538546562, 0.02304133027791977, -0.05715573951601982, -0.02000880241394043, -0.04100990667939186, -0.03811636567115784, 0.043730635195970535, -0.01895326003432274, 0.04560321569442749, -0.004882624372839928, -0.06498252600431442, 0.033030182123184204, -0.005920008290559053, 0.010515390895307064, -0.03415997326374054, 0.021592184901237488, -0.006824421230703592, -0.0328916572034359, 0.02133224718272686, 0.0332990325987339, 0.020718256011605263, 0.025715317577123642, 0.04231110215187073, -0.012883440591394901, 0.05262831225991249, 0.01805172488093376, 0.03210781142115593, -0.009225012734532356, -0.029309459030628204, 0.022740688174962997, 0.012429814785718918, 0.024802925065159798, -0.020601065829396248, 0.03780598193407059, 0.03423666954040527, -0.006278112530708313, 0.004159053321927786, -0.015800751745700836, 0.010006297379732132, 0.02424567937850952, 0.00081385497469455, -0.07888272404670715, 0.009082887321710587, 0.01559867337346077, 0.004361398052424192, -0.058929573744535446, 0.04683641716837883, 0.019493654370307922, 0.00535881333053112, 0.02726973220705986, 0.01790483109652996, 0.027833187952637672, -0.04481261596083641, -0.03143061324954033, -0.022629523649811745, -0.026000315323472023, 0.027551855891942978, -0.04017056152224541, -0.006943018641322851, 0.06507087498903275, 0.001986578106880188, 0.0007016602903604507, -0.011254752054810524, -0.02249228022992611, -0.023579023778438568, -0.0899534821510315, -0.0200407262891531, -0.0379648320376873, 0.03154405206441879, 0.024073584005236626, 0.03258751332759857, 0.01678372547030449, -0.0037699269596487284, 0.026427168399095535, -0.0059781763702631, -0.06866218149662018, 0.02074597217142582, -0.04787667095661163, -0.03441482409834862, 0.014980902895331383, -0.012046236544847488, 0.037901371717453, -0.03180801495909691, 0.010143080726265907, -0.021375402808189392, 0.019240006804466248, -0.04106748849153519, 0.010137276723980904, -0.01676744595170021, -0.020290931686758995, -0.010411838069558144, 0.005202353931963444, 0.02665170654654503, -0.017729613929986954, 0.057627998292446136, 0.02670673467218876, -0.01495540700852871, -0.04091013967990875, -0.01019934844225645, 0.03447156026959419, 0.017655987292528152, 0.008849461562931538, 0.01977062039077282, 0.006918061524629593, -0.04004369303584099, 0.010503736324608326, 0.02898447774350643, 0.03782910108566284, 0.02025221846997738, -0.024721605703234673, -0.03408484160900116, -0.025640489533543587, -0.02529459446668625, -0.0008249875972978771, 0.03972388431429863, 0.03205579146742821, 0.002656320808455348, 0.041929692029953, 0.04959551990032196, -0.054272040724754333, 0.038195569068193436, 0.054129138588905334, -0.0035027884878218174, 0.020995577797293663, -0.006639789789915085, -0.021639298647642136, 0.009003941901028156, 0.02244465984404087, 0.02772356942296028, -0.007729094009846449, 0.00724139204248786, -0.0557846762239933, 0.024570947512984276, 0.004855609033256769, -0.0008290396654047072, 0.016016649082303047, 0.028094157576560974, 0.061555422842502594, 0.004126338288187981, -0.039644405245780945, 0.02830621413886547, 0.03274910897016525, 0.011265475302934647, 0.034570880234241486, 0.0010297673288732767, -0.0791582465171814, 0.02574928291141987, 0.02140384539961815, 0.012564272619783878, -0.02538682334125042, -0.008688168600201607, -0.03990292549133301, -0.005816204007714987, 0.06792760640382767, -0.007112352643162012, 0.052394378930330276, 0.007095198146998882, 0.011599727906286716, -0.0011500139953568578, -0.017072362825274467, -0.03500843048095703, 0.020558705553412437, -0.01336269173771143, 0.0320415161550045, -0.02408132143318653, -0.03190453350543976, -0.07168377190828323, -0.00933185126632452, 0.02003486454486847, 0.09481523185968399, -0.023060601204633713, -0.005711966194212437, -0.005796057637780905, 0.043007947504520416, 0.0072469087317585945, -0.07676820456981659, 0.034981947392225266, 0.0009053932735696435, -0.040186841040849686, 0.03166021779179573, -0.013014121912419796, -0.02845415659248829, -0.0009291967726312578, -0.019923284649848938, -0.03201352804899216, 0.01500017661601305, -0.004852283280342817, 0.07791942358016968, 0.03881681710481644, 0.039194297045469284, 0.06971661746501923, 0.014337495900690556, 0.01384725235402584, -0.014677046798169613, -0.007309937849640846, -0.0009955463465303183, -0.03033616580069065, 0.004069778136909008, -0.033268511295318604, 0.04161548987030983, -0.051892977207899094, 0.04330064356327057, -0.013475274667143822, 0.029491499066352844, -0.01544124260544777, 0.018364619463682175, -0.016078274697065353, 0.015565577894449234, -0.0059941615909338, -0.03936222195625305, 0.02525426633656025, 0.012573965825140476, -0.005175817757844925, -0.020028065890073776, 0.02518819458782673, -0.02432929538190365, -0.021363675594329834, 0.029346773400902748, -0.026640525087714195, 0.014156509190797806, -0.026651648804545403, 0.006523283198475838, -0.006846608128398657, -0.0052171857096254826, 0.024923410266637802, 0.00785532221198082, -0.0050860983319580555, -0.0002431673347018659, -0.031317852437496185, -0.010843814350664616, 0.04363590106368065, 0.011008764617145061, 0.032073311507701874, -0.05832529440522194, 0.02811998873949051, 0.0041017974726855755, -0.03872372955083847, -0.0735175833106041, -0.04001555219292641, 0.01471905130892992, 0.010752743110060692, 0.021550524979829788, -0.09270886331796646, 0.008669216185808182, -0.025566067546606064, -0.0014545395970344543, -0.02310466207563877, 0.036757275462150574, 0.005378774832934141, -0.005660137627273798, -0.027823064476251602, 0.028076598420739174, 0.08311939239501953, -0.01727919466793537, -0.0036190273240208626, 0.012120758183300495, -0.011110295541584492, -0.029189743101596832, -0.008861749432981014, 0.024115102365612984, -0.04113016650080681, -0.0014809666899964213, -0.018807975575327873, -0.038600146770477295, 0.027049003168940544, -0.056650709360837936, -0.0388345941901207, 0.030004186555743217, 0.025625016540288925, 0.004710739478468895, -0.015107744373381138, 0.0037878069560974836, -0.02622687630355358, 0.0012945563066750765, -0.0020485748536884785, -0.05755143612623215, -0.012146096676588058, -0.020726589486002922, 0.001621149480342865, 0.019261373206973076, -0.04896596446633339, 0.022720150649547577, 0.04083051159977913, -0.0038653144147247076, -0.0279743243008852, 0.004189216531813145, 0.00642454344779253, 0.03001447580754757, -0.016526225954294205, -0.000839795044157654, 0.01448683813214302, 0.015076574869453907, -0.06652985513210297, -0.04714690148830414, -0.016837846487760544, -0.028788678348064423, 0.08284188061952591, -0.004655430559068918, 0.09427325427532196, 0.023703422397375107, -0.0012274719774723053, 0.010593917220830917, 0.005382421426475048, -0.006351755000650883, -0.0007000946789048612, -0.018416287377476692, 0.03617648407816887, -0.026542911306023598, 0.019017985090613365, 0.02056010067462921, 0.008997054770588875, 0.00862103421241045, 0.015470592305064201, 0.01351676881313324, 0.014081709086894989, 0.030930977314710617, -0.022198406979441643, -0.024221282452344894, 0.013226336799561977, -0.017536194995045662, -0.004027372691780329, -0.03095940873026848, 0.010632000863552094, 0.03858383372426033, 0.05195983499288559, -0.03251230716705322, -0.04182777553796768, -0.04275092855095863, -0.0685533732175827, -0.01523074321448803, 0.04640474542975426, -0.0062549361027777195, 0.03643962740898132, 0.028221068903803825, 0.0375591479241848, 0.01920342445373535, 0.020174991339445114, -0.02793220430612564, -0.048688583076000214, -0.010657881386578083, -0.022057771682739258, -0.009597132913768291, 0.05716927349567413, 0.024103919044137, -0.03628242015838623, 0.00874442607164383, -0.0061916084960103035, 0.004437943920493126, -0.01120927557349205, 0.025855159386992455, -0.04260142520070076, 0.0694999024271965, 0.000840605644043535, 0.03630133345723152, -0.0166774969547987, -0.0079285753890872, 0.09172926843166351, 0.05486728996038437, 0.032342247664928436, -0.05953178554773331, 0.025115584954619408, 0.007232492323964834, -0.02174488455057144, -0.05862196534872055, 0.043052736669778824, 0.03206835314631462, -0.02638438530266285, 0.036639951169490814, 0.05555517598986626, 0.041272979229688644, -0.03773023188114166, 0.05095360055565834, 0.006480957847088575, 0.0015741644892841578, 0.0001784092019079253, 0.03388998657464981, 0.02761780098080635, -0.00007489529525628313, -0.07195226103067398, 0.01965584047138691, -0.05587072670459747, -0.004813895095139742, -0.027225393801927567, -0.013107028789818287, 0.0239724088460207, 0.006802051793783903, -0.032549694180488586, 0.0174212958663702, 0.0455559678375721, 0.01865144819021225, -0.0131145054474473, -0.025679996237158775, 0.021102044731378555, -0.012627778574824333, 0.018643660470843315, 0.023640969768166542, 0.0036505800671875477, 0.013529641553759575, -0.014134211465716362, 0.0031206412240862846, -0.04949306324124336, -0.03265182673931122, -0.04459817335009575, 0.040404222905635834, -0.00842521246522665, 0.013720434159040451, 0.02028587833046913, 0.0060564493760466576, -0.018678074702620506, -0.02221505716443062, -0.010405488312244415, 0.00369366561062634, 0.03143315762281418, -0.05454932898283005, 0.03092224709689617, -0.02393021248281002, 0.024473359808325768, -0.005827152635902166, 0.041086964309215546, 0.045878101140260696, -0.010298405773937702, 0.008476377464830875, -0.004961767699569464, 0.04242462292313576, 0.0025509046390652657, -0.03159233182668686, -0.02683967724442482, -0.029168233275413513, -0.012011555023491383, -0.006195846013724804, 0.011460711248219013, -0.009168117307126522, 0.013394102454185486, 0.021837837994098663, -0.002393882954493165, -0.02705635316669941, -0.016621015965938568, 0.025031810626387596, -0.024083368480205536, -0.022287962958216667, -0.02371181547641754, -0.02389928698539734, 0.059257280081510544, 0.02316926047205925, 0.009899776428937912, 0.0054077329114079475, -0.009577878750860691, 0.031567592173814774, 0.05548902601003647, -0.052061527967453, 0.01020458061248064, -0.013273547403514385, -0.007160866167396307, 0.006819756235927343, -0.01240680180490017, 0.02788841538131237, 0.05277762934565544, 0.030194193124771118, -0.0038149915635585785, 0.02555842325091362, -0.01956723816692829, -0.006226639728993177, 0.007031188812106848, -0.020241765305399895, -0.014194987714290619, 0.014476148411631584, -0.0005935842054896057, -0.022702272981405258, -0.015191415324807167, -0.015556760132312775, 0.004249911289662123, -0.0073715136386454105, -0.013906777836382389, -0.03974631801247597, -0.02088700793683529, -0.02429949678480625, 0.01950749009847641, -0.03155164420604706, -0.0195921640843153, -0.0417884923517704, 0.002317083301022649, 0.005985818337649107, -0.03306320682168007, -0.004679499659687281, 0.002886738395318389, -0.02688412368297577, -0.009351550601422787, 0.06269803643226624, 0.01878987066447735, 0.005449777469038963, -0.011300414800643921, 0.01602386310696602, -0.04333264008164406, 0.03803897649049759, -0.015949208289384842, -0.03728046640753746, 0.0526062473654747, -0.029243916273117065, 0.0023684038314968348, 0.032601259648799896, 0.00004833926141145639, 0.015719199553132057, 0.027960248291492462, -0.024731798097491264, -0.0095516974106431, 0.032709669321775436, -0.028236109763383865, 0.0005845155101269484, -0.012538575567305088, 0.01749434508383274, -0.02428773045539856, 0.007604639977216721, 0.02274157479405403, 0.016402091830968857, 0.00850139744579792, -0.0012106774374842644, 0.02892620675265789, -0.008032689802348614, -0.015617278404533863, 0.00343564385548234, 0.006981320679187775, 0.04421467334032059, -0.005409743636846542, -0.039959196001291275, 0.05396329239010811, 0.0760868564248085, -0.01876043528318405, 0.002189925406128168, -0.00023844686802476645, -0.008655770681798458, -0.057068150490522385, 0.014787854626774788, 0.01745874620974064, -0.007530092727392912, 0.05454739183187485, -0.05040084198117256, -0.033860597759485245, 0.03294864296913147, -0.0375463105738163, -0.004278457257896662, -0.011412061750888824, -0.021831199526786804, -0.015536128543317318, -0.010726502165198326, 0.0009863433660939336, 0.022105563431978226, 0.041698046028614044, 0.061740290373563766, 0.00004959884608979337, 0.052102964371442795, -0.005711683072149754, 0.001967519521713257, -0.02540857158601284, 0.0013042065547779202, 0.013309263624250889, -0.054974377155303955, 0.04411214962601662, -0.07238271087408066, -0.03599580004811287, 0.029643582180142403, -0.021467426791787148, 0.00828772783279419, -0.010772684589028358, 0.03733878582715988, -0.0107711898162961, 0.04789770022034645, 0.002303823595866561, -0.04930514469742775, -0.023800987750291824, -0.024609245359897614, 0.026927465572953224, 0.03167504072189331, -0.014256986789405346, 0.0007849085377529263, 0.01268461812287569, 0.0032211237121373415, -0.002189975930377841, 0.026562122628092766, 0.0065719797275960445, -0.024575579911470413, 0.008458997122943401, -0.0333341620862484, 0.005404406227171421, 0.00493167620152235, 0.02346242591738701, -0.015057395212352276, -0.015178907662630081, 0.03727139160037041, 0.035699859261512756, -0.03115239553153515, -0.009598012082278728, 0.008880759589374065, -0.05057051405310631, 0.04613273963332176, -0.011826297268271446, 0.028868284076452255, -0.06477884948253632, -0.016672620549798012, 0.0013702275464311242, -0.012280688621103764, -0.03432727977633476, -0.06936406344175339, -0.05840570479631424, 0.05607080087065697, 0.0008279122412204742, 0.024075860157608986, 0.01721704937517643, -0.011983898468315601, -0.0013348505599424243, -0.04103867709636688, 0.01237904466688633, -0.0031600510701537132, 0.00787435658276081, -0.04012411832809448, -0.01228001993149519, -0.04878221079707146, -0.00003224328247597441, 0.07091277092695236, -0.01388556882739067, 0.010488218627870083, 0.0030805489514023066, 0.02978035993874073, 0.03278961405158043, -0.0576745830476284, 0.012667395174503326, -0.017305955290794373, -0.025167519226670265, 0.0324268564581871, -0.040257491171360016, 0.006862329784780741, -0.012019136920571327, -0.004665686748921871, -0.03115270659327507, -0.02702142857015133, 0.007437221705913544, 0.00907011330127716, 0.06322584301233292, 0.01268341951072216, -0.00864617433398962, 0.045821916311979294, 0.03324611112475395, 0.012491165660321712, 0.01477011851966381, -0.009960608556866646, -0.06498079746961594, 0.008032743819057941, -0.05188349261879921, -0.02933080494403839, 0.0007905674865469337, 0.024746621027588844, 0.0060129351913928986, -0.06619244813919067, -0.03481461852788925, 0.034775570034980774, -0.01749562658369541, -0.026790769770741463, 0.04249227046966553, 0.012904767878353596, 0.022141162306070328, 0.009690470062196255, 0.03316379711031914, 0.019381336867809296, 0.0018708526622503996, -0.001442078733816743, 0.019932731986045837, 0.041965458542108536, -0.027716780081391335, 0.0010404792847111821, 0.021874668076634407, -0.007720110006630421, 0.02370568737387657, -0.04872762784361839, 0.0003411250654608011, -0.03720354661345482, -0.03301167115569115, 0.008222261443734169, -0.022200526669621468, 0.040238864719867706, 0.011147650890052319, -0.021918591111898422, 0.07295119017362595, -0.06809701770544052, 0.004830983933061361, 0.010243428871035576, -0.0017276332946494222, -0.032991595566272736, -0.01753292977809906, -0.009642564691603184, 0.004356619901955128, 0.0002012810728047043, 0.004934730939567089, 0.0168433990329504, -0.02954060398042202, 0.012013168074190617, -0.05366450175642967, -0.004987447988241911, 0.01871984824538231, -0.004858700092881918, -0.020216388627886772, -0.023801563307642937, -0.06407462805509567, -0.04623064771294594, 0.04470580071210861, 0.04408932104706764, 0.0034079281613230705, -0.004620128311216831, -0.016161998733878136, -0.015387005172669888, 0.03389851003885269, -0.09288804978132248, 0.0013704109005630016, -0.06323439627885818, 0.02662608213722706, 0.042900122702121735, -0.009752093814313412 ]
<p>Can someone tell me why this is wrong: </p> <p>I want to estimate the goodness-of-fit for a linear mixed effects model. I regress the fitted values against the raw values and calculate an $R^2$. </p> <p>I suppose an accepted alternative would be to run the model with just the random effect and no fixed effects and compare AIC scores, but I'm specifically interested in the scenario above.</p>
36,209
[ -0.048085618764162064, 0.009442474693059921, -0.052512332797050476, 0.00321598001755774, 0.02465229108929634, 0.022245995700359344, 0.02100440301001072, -0.000042729152482934296, 0.003650460159406066, -0.02278684824705124, 0.03175680711865425, 0.05932101607322693, 0.07855615764856339, 0.023898469284176826, 0.004146129824221134, -0.0068484116345644, -0.026634013280272484, 0.005695099476724863, 0.019569547846913338, -0.017216756939888, -0.01664949394762516, 0.03997603431344032, 0.010974917560815811, -0.030638763681054115, -0.023103253915905952, 0.02848503552377224, 0.030529463663697243, -0.020624658092856407, 0.009699983522295952, 0.06496790051460266, -0.040694233030080795, -0.04006333276629448, 0.03349709138274193, 0.05112900584936142, 0.014828970655798912, 0.008872621692717075, -0.03635692596435547, -0.01499173417687416, -0.011280200444161892, 0.0649024024605751, -0.013767922297120094, -0.035905592143535614, -0.009948975406587124, 0.05300794169306755, -0.016440406441688538, 0.024481121450662613, 0.006444170605391264, -0.044968415051698685, 0.041912637650966644, -0.04207224026322365, 0.0838569775223732, -0.003154516452923417, 0.033907949924468994, 0.03063044510781765, -0.0395229272544384, -0.0032759220339357853, 0.03770655021071434, 0.05635859817266464, -0.02044287510216236, -0.03627369925379753, -0.011112242005765438, -0.03789805248379707, 0.028565097600221634, 0.0304393470287323, -0.04433843865990639, 0.006015266291797161, 0.005966056603938341, -0.020645802840590477, 0.025834931060671806, -0.023370668292045593, 0.025097044184803963, 0.014496169984340668, 0.02237975038588047, -0.011542264372110367, 0.04437985271215439, -0.007959580048918724, 0.0011753906728699803, 0.0016259534750133753, 0.03656036779284477, 0.03771362081170082, -0.00887247547507286, 0.006877827923744917, 0.017528750002384186, 0.036036472767591476, 0.012347646988928318, -0.0453575998544693, 0.04428994655609131, -0.019227445125579834, 0.012606336735188961, 0.031704746186733246, -0.0019062124192714691, -0.008198096416890621, 0.07677992433309555, 0.00744766416028142, -0.05213092640042305, 0.002460420597344637, -0.0055397264659404755, 0.03946934640407562, 0.01371312327682972, -0.010165683925151825, -0.02529059164226055, -0.05493428558111191, 0.022503532469272614, 0.03038625232875347, 0.00575060211122036, -0.011251803487539291, -0.025592202320694923, 0.03359469771385193, 0.016220223158597946, -0.032855745404958725, 0.005534186493605375, 0.029938722029328346, -0.007613277528434992, -0.0023273262195289135, 0.02630160003900528, -0.035966452211141586, -0.01504941750317812, -0.0325302816927433, 0.05981794372200966, 0.031851913779973984, 0.03229587897658348, -0.028989708051085472, 0.029559245333075523, -0.04125077277421951, -0.01436180155724287, 0.034374967217445374, 0.013432876206934452, -0.04559142142534256, -0.061370253562927246, 0.0342244878411293, 0.00030085694743320346, 0.009424339979887009, 0.009509560652077198, -0.009052157402038574, -0.014780300669372082, -0.03560688719153404, -0.04574957862496376, -0.04167346656322479, -0.007465285714715719, 0.004435477312654257, -0.0013520268257707357, -0.05647077038884163, -0.016182590276002884, 0.018926434218883514, 0.05602949857711792, -0.001863313838839531, 0.03969566524028778, 0.004308018833398819, 0.028897983953356743, 0.015733644366264343, -0.024962566792964935, -0.010945252142846584, -0.05868680775165558, -0.0377027802169323, -0.051134657114744186, -0.07971835136413574, 0.016700640320777893, -0.014722022227942944, -0.004998097661882639, 0.004123002290725708, 0.021765053272247314, 0.014215842820703983, -0.00023613791563548148, 0.034518834203481674, 0.020181795582175255, -0.005647704470902681, 0.06626108288764954, -0.0076917060650885105, 0.040428515523672104, 0.022191215306520462, -0.011411729268729687, 0.026986761018633842, 0.021278677508234978, 0.043383751064538956, 0.048267778009176254, -0.022596154361963272, 0.01016022264957428, -0.043192557990550995, 0.04515952989459038, 0.014836553484201431, -0.05102333053946495, 0.013327142223715782, -0.026432489976286888, -0.018715135753154755, 0.01227789930999279, 0.03955275937914848, -0.022435206919908524, -0.013211416080594063, 0.045620229095220566, -0.041812025010585785, -0.017117124050855637, -0.077473483979702, 0.007874732837080956, 0.03855803608894348, -0.012824020348489285, 0.021531149744987488, -0.022051112726330757, 0.02567310817539692, 0.008420825935900211, 0.008492118678987026, -0.028761394321918488, -0.008568117395043373, 0.011403256095945835, -0.03036537766456604, 0.04148534685373306, 0.052288368344306946, 0.06386399269104004, 0.023749761283397675, 0.0634215697646141, -0.013222427107393742, -0.04874962195754051, 0.010804331861436367, -0.0363181047141552, 0.0060181207954883575, -0.002730900188907981, 0.012455590069293976, -0.0007820031605660915, 0.013082454912364483, -0.02057122066617012, 0.027124686166644096, -0.026803335174918175, 0.07750684022903442, 0.04871058464050293, -0.013563129119575024, -0.003596677677705884, 0.013814176432788372, 0.026807447895407677, -0.006157086696475744, -0.02672446146607399, -0.008475834503769875, -0.047095008194446564, -0.013715893030166626, 0.034211765974760056, -0.006534051615744829, -0.04081027954816818, 0.040640003979206085, 0.0826978087425232, 0.028897827491164207, 0.010556133463978767, 0.03244555741548538, 0.003255421994253993, -0.03270488604903221, 0.03625589981675148, 0.030477162450551987, -0.02314409427344799, -0.01672094129025936, 0.012472783215343952, -0.022216862067580223, 0.01889701560139656, 0.00518213352188468, 0.0019202858675271273, 0.032710980623960495, 0.0033937585540115833, 0.011341188102960587, -0.06363577395677567, -0.0194439385086298, 0.031031237915158272, 0.000003967752491007559, 0.00030650023836642504, 0.05559305474162102, 0.03400316834449768, -0.029594985768198967, 0.014005356468260288, -0.0036382190883159637, 0.08035881817340851, -0.004213206935673952, -0.043203894048929214, 0.0018929216312244534, 0.019878247752785683, -0.0009066635393537581, -0.00459858076646924, -0.012494567781686783, -0.017486048862338066, -0.03677723929286003, 0.02323777787387371, 0.01619620807468891, 0.003509275382384658, -0.014311038888990879, -0.010747609660029411, 0.036442890763282776, 0.0010919020278379321, 0.0017628411296755075, 0.008486343547701836, 0.0015350329922512174, -0.03684977442026138, 0.015133089385926723, -0.03131452947854996, -0.004063828382641077, 0.0045526837930083275, 0.017527488991618156, -0.01699146069586277, 0.030805407091975212, -0.027324307709932327, -0.02894127182662487, -0.02746954932808876, -0.03908533975481987, 0.012540270574390888, -0.04599643126130104, -0.019313529133796692, 0.04618469253182411, 0.000994986156001687, -0.014462152495980263, 0.03212229907512665, -0.01696830987930298, 0.0009759762906469405, -0.003070344915613532, -0.003921843133866787, 0.0316573902964592, -0.0331832692027092, 0.0668894574046135, -0.015857940539717674, -0.03116058185696602, 0.0036281002685427666, -0.06879567354917526, -0.05682917311787605, 0.011668962426483631, -0.009038573130965233, -0.0013379589654505253, 0.011213547550141811, -0.04264076426625252, 0.06455187499523163, 0.033496737480163574, -0.0148871885612607, -0.037923820316791534, -0.007096982095390558, -0.04054147005081177, -0.019518740475177765, -0.008429373614490032, 0.0018715797923505306, -0.03432925418019295, 0.05453801900148392, -0.018364354968070984, 0.003562451107427478, 0.03726591542363167, 0.012164361774921417, -0.01029992662370205, 0.025391094386577606, 0.022627048194408417, -0.02901567332446575, 0.017242148518562317, 0.012471942231059074, -0.0022169407457113266, 0.012402866967022419, 0.006647834088653326, 0.0218574870377779, 0.0076755317859351635, -0.05367271602153778, 0.004875978454947472, -0.03540767729282379, 0.013577351346611977, -0.008513894863426685, 0.04249836504459381, 0.00205791974440217, -0.030131354928016663, -0.020836418494582176, 0.003386484691873193, 0.022689593955874443, -0.01789911277592182, 0.0016780048608779907, 0.04513710364699364, 0.03630562871694565, 0.012571198865771294, -0.016713565215468407, -0.01653657853603363, 0.008397113531827927, 0.033333443105220795, -0.029888490214943886, -0.015968717634677887, 0.001426252187229693, 0.005269639194011688, 0.014384699985384941, -0.03993979096412659, -0.057847872376441956, -0.014687929302453995, -0.06014665588736534, 0.010386642068624496, -0.06563594192266464, 0.030578473582863808, -0.018928950652480125, -0.01063305139541626, 0.04382433742284775, -0.03849606215953827, -0.013690630905330181, -0.017152396962046623, -0.05277150124311447, 0.04122324660420418, -0.0462380014359951, -0.02680342085659504, -0.00031707846210338175, -0.02573486790060997, 0.012468073517084122, -0.018087228760123253, 0.00875331275165081, -0.017980100587010384, -0.0063780806958675385, -0.002959100529551506, -0.0004491792351473123, -0.00933458749204874, -0.0211318489164114, 0.007740037981420755, 0.012342866510152817, -0.010077602230012417, -0.027967605739831924, 0.008538887836039066, 0.024487968534231186, -0.012173951603472233, -0.0071278647519648075, -0.008329483680427074, 0.03087732195854187, 0.010664659552276134, 0.024218395352363586, 0.03295838087797165, -0.007383539341390133, -0.04011150076985359, 0.02293865941464901, -0.013442657887935638, 0.049576323479413986, 0.03647306561470032, -0.031940169632434845, -0.02665894106030464, -0.0326952300965786, -0.04422931373119354, 0.01846345141530037, 0.03745649382472038, -0.0025989548303186893, 0.01290814857929945, 0.04938456416130066, 0.01633661426603794, -0.013959147036075592, 0.014561183750629425, 0.07205948978662491, 0.004272982012480497, -0.011363646946847439, -0.016523435711860657, 0.016914229840040207, 0.009219302795827389, -0.010127115994691849, 0.018425295129418373, -0.027328379452228546, 0.0013884895015507936, -0.017142847180366516, 0.06356826424598694, -0.05777371674776077, -0.047349441796541214, -0.021046670153737068, 0.009020200930535793, 0.01671871356666088, 0.015169325284659863, -0.029545551165938377, 0.01574978232383728, 0.03863348066806793, 0.014682421460747719, 0.03589706867933273, -0.0022333690430969, -0.051293034106492996, -0.009364018216729164, 0.022238701581954956, 0.013201792724430561, -0.00535288592800498, -0.019256193190813065, -0.02885698340833187, -0.020714815706014633, 0.005683068186044693, -0.022396927699446678, 0.013479961082339287, -0.008390299044549465, -0.002025509485974908, 0.016772691160440445, -0.013746806420385838, -0.06462445855140686, -0.0026078252121806145, 0.007635863032191992, 0.02588183619081974, -0.021976061165332794, -0.02650405466556549, -0.033878155052661896, 0.0029540618415921926, 0.012435756623744965, 0.03177802637219429, -0.01854768395423889, 0.010514944791793823, 0.04392379894852638, 0.012990606017410755, -0.04048329219222069, -0.04526530206203461, 0.030255045741796494, -0.010340457782149315, 0.01943470723927021, 0.043703120201826096, -0.02429383248090744, -0.016314590349793434, 0.018489258363842964, 0.003737201914191246, -0.009118651039898396, -0.01539553701877594, -0.034877240657806396, 0.05705178529024124, 0.03822843357920647, 0.041765496134757996, 0.08025746792554855, 0.00552794523537159, 0.02210064046084881, -0.00757375406101346, -0.013657874427735806, 0.0341302789747715, -0.03859395906329155, -0.04663592949509621, -0.05847290903329849, -0.018260767683386803, 0.016382938250899315, 0.02070101536810398, -0.01596936583518982, 0.02506636083126068, -0.03192990645766258, -0.055833835154771805, 0.016839193180203438, 0.02178099937736988, 0.006409292109310627, -0.010209745727479458, -0.005819657351821661, 0.02656545676290989, -0.01207735575735569, -0.025313714519143105, 0.0124883484095335, -0.03737019747495651, 0.021584665402770042, 0.0249400082975626, -0.03346218541264534, 0.04476112127304077, -0.005052950698882341, -0.03209719434380531, 0.001362500828690827, -0.024938169866800308, 0.022391842678189278, -0.02021096833050251, 0.012807020917534828, -0.046828269958496094, -0.0031824985053390265, 0.006015110295265913, 0.008284070529043674, -0.00325527461245656, 0.07853024452924728, 0.0011258688755333424, 0.009464395232498646, -0.00380703154951334, -0.01897697150707245, -0.09285980463027954, -0.03396640717983246, 0.01281340979039669, -0.012979132123291492, -0.0038992655463516712, -0.02582760900259018, -0.015713820233941078, -0.005107153207063675, 0.009066824801266193, -0.03603801503777504, 0.07186369597911835, -0.030451461672782898, -0.01671363227069378, -0.015183737501502037, 0.02041650377213955, 0.06220060959458351, -0.015503096394240856, -0.04416898265480995, 0.019902657717466354, -0.03265947848558426, -0.030421648174524307, -0.004413536749780178, 0.04630229249596596, -0.06423243880271912, -0.0012662331573665142, -0.03098757192492485, -0.02004563994705677, 0.060598500072956085, 0.008023791015148163, -0.0033099623396992683, 0.031253259629011154, 0.015689443796873093, 0.005729416850954294, -0.029631171375513077, 0.004908049013465643, -0.0105002261698246, -0.0072769466787576675, -0.011822987347841263, 0.023787256330251694, 0.00687771663069725, -0.0070931860245764256, 0.042192064225673676, -0.02718430757522583, -0.023775476962327957, 0.004463233519345522, 0.1015433594584465, -0.02107488550245762, -0.005803036969155073, -0.035836175084114075, -0.010789924301207066, 0.020503059029579163, 0.02535526268184185, 0.010307385586202145, 0.027944087982177734, 0.027532026171684265, -0.05604277923703194, -0.020040635019540787, -0.03208915516734123, 0.00009448733180761337, 0.09262467920780182, -0.004621214233338833, 0.052387140691280365, 0.04256230220198631, -0.002989366417750716, -0.023704515770077705, -0.02127246931195259, -0.00584725895896554, -0.002142218640074134, 0.0021511295344680548, 0.06328213214874268, -0.028590010479092598, -0.008350463584065437, 0.017276570200920105, -0.011681785807013512, 0.003763978136703372, 0.041191041469573975, 0.042282622307538986, 0.04229506850242615, 0.023032592609524727, 0.0353948138654232, -0.043162792921066284, 0.019449664279818535, -0.04339521750807762, 0.009448925964534283, -0.03582671284675598, -0.021427376195788383, 0.049763668328523636, 0.0438554547727108, 0.008746493607759476, -0.03262362629175186, -0.048878371715545654, -0.03906878083944321, -0.016310695558786392, 0.020600199699401855, -0.006899153348058462, 0.025642871856689453, -0.013043873012065887, 0.03153109550476074, 0.02108258754014969, 0.04052435979247093, -0.02786078117787838, -0.04739892855286598, -0.005455538164824247, -0.005864542443305254, 0.015225742012262344, 0.0010444332147017121, -0.0054520838893949986, -0.01848720572888851, -0.003583258017897606, -0.022665157914161682, -0.00277609727345407, 0.016921905800700188, 0.040699511766433716, -0.015479283407330513, 0.0695205107331276, 0.012037763372063637, 0.002369283465668559, -0.02153521031141281, -0.016512811183929443, 0.10173153132200241, 0.07200305908918381, 0.021036306396126747, -0.08166477084159851, 0.05641293153166771, -0.010936710983514786, -0.013623462058603764, 0.012241534888744354, 0.021283701062202454, -0.007717160042375326, -0.006404606159776449, 0.05903349444270134, 0.05046660080552101, 0.0026108184829354286, 0.0073438300751149654, 0.04764721542596817, -0.025318317115306854, -0.04643207788467407, -0.01169373095035553, 0.012447384186089039, 0.014063453301787376, -0.022192679345607758, -0.006473362911492586, 0.03933340683579445, -0.0035500675439834595, -0.00742867449298501, -0.022049544379115105, -0.004629748873412609, -0.01569211296737194, 0.008698366582393646, -0.04319637268781662, 0.024290762841701508, 0.01673847995698452, 0.0075588407926261425, -0.01209594402462244, -0.020815029740333557, 0.038402803242206573, 0.012329949997365475, 0.03625188022851944, 0.051739297807216644, 0.0038949737790971994, -0.026448551565408707, 0.008739590644836426, -0.02630108967423439, -0.06138108670711517, -0.03316798806190491, -0.032840926200151443, 0.04450278729200363, -0.013999799266457558, -0.045102495700120926, -0.007271988783031702, -0.014237278141081333, -0.029307294636964798, -0.05898020416498184, -0.020418532192707062, 0.03395712375640869, 0.017701758071780205, -0.0047635268419981, -0.021385392174124718, -0.010744928382337093, 0.026596173644065857, -0.01697474531829357, 0.005645467434078455, 0.02900770492851734, -0.03685006871819496, -0.014799254946410656, 0.007052344735711813, 0.06916222721338272, 0.010913140140473843, 0.0072586145251989365, 0.020595461130142212, -0.03144475445151329, -0.05954158678650856, 0.009864330291748047, 0.03114279732108116, 0.029434697702527046, 0.05366766080260277, -0.02797742746770382, -0.02321871928870678, -0.023867011070251465, -0.058386459946632385, 0.0037436047568917274, -0.026151686906814575, 0.012004953809082508, -0.06338494271039963, -0.019339723512530327, 0.01246996782720089, 0.02208065055310726, 0.017801150679588318, -0.004338397644460201, 0.001535795978270471, 0.0788498967885971, -0.0221122857183218, -0.04819512367248535, -0.018540136516094208, 0.013609739020466805, -0.057581789791584015, -0.006528972648084164, 0.037772540003061295, 0.0122145377099514, 0.03859194368124008, 0.044280752539634705, 0.00423487089574337, 0.0397062823176384, -0.026420973241329193, 0.031559981405735016, 0.020611774176359177, -0.049181558191776276, -0.012579004280269146, 0.01704389974474907, 0.012449034489691257, -0.020912792533636093, -0.012889929115772247, -0.03661540895700455, -0.0438549742102623, 0.02021738700568676, -0.0044676270335912704, -0.006840434856712818, -0.004784934688359499, -0.023372408002614975, -0.011438889428973198, -0.054583217948675156, -0.02965030074119568, -0.037602610886096954, -0.007572511211037636, 0.02471623383462429, 0.00020523188868537545, 0.0019414665875956416, 0.025097908452153206, 0.007744388189166784, 0.01073896698653698, 0.05563344061374664, -0.016447409987449646, -0.022354822605848312, -0.007939083501696587, 0.01857180893421173, 0.013112463988363743, 0.05078800022602081, -0.02735157497227192, -0.017454465851187706, 0.035142913460731506, -0.03872900456190109, -0.027832353487610817, 0.015066013671457767, -0.0038753256667405367, 0.013997369445860386, 0.025777503848075867, 0.017998404800891876, -0.034722983837127686, 0.050602998584508896, -0.03419342264533043, -0.015455268323421478, -0.024834269657731056, 0.015931492671370506, 0.026946311816573143, 0.023362886160612106, -0.01250717043876648, -0.0018828243482857943, -0.004336562938988209, 0.06418196111917496, 0.047248292714357376, -0.010033221915364265, 0.02655084803700447, 0.005190439522266388, -0.021875977516174316, 0.04756898060441017, 0.0389823392033577, 0.015369567088782787, 0.010236291214823723, 0.03170632943511009, 0.003474492346867919, 0.023261578753590584, -0.03189331293106079, -0.007583138067275286, -0.07498814910650253, -0.017435859888792038, -0.02226445823907852, 0.013032376766204834, 0.010804669000208378, -0.034428734332323074, -0.000007497714250348508, 0.040672387927770615, -0.04287169501185417, -0.037823863327503204, -0.030831629410386086, -0.03773375600576401, -0.06829150766134262, 0.008440351113677025, -0.040306590497493744, -0.0052800653502345085, -0.0053651402704417706, 0.04262741282582283, 0.02170911803841591, 0.0017040646634995937, -0.027947789058089256, 0.00040700522367842495, 0.014759711921215057, 0.041223425418138504, 0.03929496183991432, -0.02995198406279087, 0.03202812746167183, 0.0001836657611420378, -0.0418534129858017, 0.03278958797454834, 0.016310429200530052, 0.03373109921813011, -0.008965359069406986, 0.046228859573602676, 0.030061200261116028, 0.031494639813899994, 0.03243672475218773, 0.024435898289084435, 0.008774936199188232, -0.03636602684855461, 0.017915207892656326, 0.034150440245866776, -0.03829146549105644, 0.008855080232024193, 0.00849558413028717, -0.008672402240335941, -0.04771970957517624, 0.015080959536135197, -0.01567641831934452, -0.03477245569229126, -0.0016405289061367512, 0.009297847747802734, -0.007000173442065716, -0.05214713141322136, -0.00458769965916872, -0.030373752117156982, 0.05382951721549034, 0.07967787981033325, 0.06397087872028351, -0.025187518447637558, 0.03469567373394966, -0.04123266413807869, -0.03527237847447395, -0.010299766436219215, 0.019385037943720818, -0.016506055369973183, -0.06940750032663345, -0.02985115349292755, 0.009478515945374966, 0.009003293700516224, -0.004339263774454594, 0.007112135645002127, -0.0405954048037529, 0.0013739265268668532, -0.006091047544032335, -0.015979228541254997, 0.01723148301243782, -0.023861374706029892, 0.006573464255779982, -0.10098384320735931, 0.10600960999727249, 0.025146979838609695, -0.03775504603981972, -0.022479606792330742, -0.0021240522619336843, -0.030636247247457504, 0.015977196395397186, 0.04986228793859482, 0.03438061475753784, 0.0024265749379992485, 0.007973971776664257, 0.03625308722257614, -0.008700062520802021, -0.03535058721899986, 0.06615345925092697, -0.031482696533203125, 0.01590176858007908, -0.022317472845315933, -0.02281017415225506, -0.007846870459616184, 0.020005764439702034, 0.008971210569143295, -0.027077583596110344, 0.0306552667170763, -0.017841864377260208, -0.002411669585853815, 0.0573713555932045, 0.007341927383095026, -0.02256293222308159, 0.056040599942207336, -0.011227698996663094, 0.03352756425738335, 0.01110842078924179, 0.009506178088486195, -0.032424528151750565, 0.054833028465509415, -0.024665221571922302, -0.02832036092877388, 0.012410586699843407, 0.020884370431303978, -0.018381265923380852, -0.053414344787597656, 0.019027696922421455, 0.05082561448216438, -0.025148289278149605, -0.009111584164202213, 0.023679250851273537, 0.04525986313819885, 0.05937237665057182, 0.01908406987786293, 0.004478418733924627, 0.028118113055825233, 0.0022119786590337753, 0.011072790250182152, 0.0185250137001276, 0.04331793636083603, 0.006191706750541925, -0.04505552724003792, 0.026034096255898476, -0.0426858514547348, 0.01218727882951498, -0.02152998186647892, 0.057368673384189606, -0.019359994679689407, -0.04242487996816635, 0.011261492036283016, -0.03765987232327461, 0.04822482168674469, -0.02890036813914776, -0.006032566539943218, 0.09394371509552002, -0.04137321561574936, 0.039358995854854584, -0.0662652775645256, -0.04395415633916855, 0.0009317971998825669, 0.007325107231736183, 0.03886298090219498, 0.017868803814053535, 0.0053994618356227875, 0.009634511545300484, -0.03315611183643341, -0.03610217571258545, 0.03652821108698845, -0.030242541804909706, -0.0006940719904378057, -0.012099840678274632, 0.02026136964559555, -0.03732406720519066, -0.0394381619989872, -0.005568184889853001, -0.021000513806939125, 0.014630872756242752, -0.010504858568310738, 0.025848975405097008, -0.030066516250371933, -0.05252791941165924, 0.00741906464099884, 0.06431685388088226, -0.07365091145038605, -0.048271890729665756, -0.03511057794094086, 0.020912224426865578, 0.008350424468517303, 0.009682895615696907 ]
<p>I have just been reading a paper which uses the following method to calculate parameter uncertainties from a likelihood surface of two parameters.</p> <p>Step 1) Calculate the likelihood for finding a given pair of parameters given the data at each point on the grid.</p> <p>Step 2) Normalise the surface to 1. The Likelihood value now give the probability to the parameter given the as L(a|x) is proportional to p(x|a). </p> <p>I'm not totally convinced by this - not least as the extent of the grid is arbitrary. I'm probably going to ticck the 'forward it on to a statician' box as it's a review and I'm not familiar with this method but I was curious to whether this works under any circumstances. I always assumed Wilkes' theorem was about as well as you could do this.</p>
73,742
[ 0.03578083589673042, -0.031689442694187164, 0.022523747757077217, -0.005029866471886635, 0.005958427209407091, 0.010469959117472172, -0.02069888450205326, 0.010878796689212322, 0.01343128364533186, -0.03373732417821884, -0.01297296304255724, 0.05148977041244507, 0.06472048908472061, 0.006961750332266092, 0.022936230525374413, 0.0292355939745903, 0.0034369032364338636, 0.024269279092550278, -0.013715054839849472, -0.05985544994473457, 0.016075825318694115, 0.007792382501065731, 0.014246484264731407, -0.043104734271764755, 0.011175890453159809, -0.002397027797996998, 0.04837164655327797, -0.06249019503593445, -0.0014376136241480708, 0.10371635109186172, -0.06446518748998642, -0.015963541343808174, 0.0039021174889057875, 0.03452906012535095, 0.017939310520887375, 0.007805858738720417, -0.013129521161317825, -0.06429968029260635, 0.0000592583128309343, 0.06692477315664291, -0.027639254927635193, -0.010091062635183334, -0.0042203073389828205, 0.04549992457032204, 0.003987427800893784, 0.042517516762018204, -0.006505731027573347, -0.0367976576089859, 0.007007781881839037, -0.043205443769693375, 0.08637625724077225, -0.014781180769205093, 0.028819311410188675, 0.04078386723995209, -0.009812090545892715, -0.013695280067622662, 0.0745367482304573, 0.06444238871335983, 0.011044486425817013, -0.06914033740758896, -0.027140427380800247, -0.014007855206727982, -0.005739954765886068, -0.026924168691039085, -0.0038390120025724173, 0.0010908746626228094, -0.013817639090120792, -0.05656154826283455, 0.044919971376657486, 0.004666692577302456, -0.036208681762218475, 0.017320990562438965, 0.027626343071460724, -0.02699357643723488, 0.029339730739593506, 0.01294307503849268, 0.016465002670884132, 0.03481394425034523, 0.012743056751787663, 0.005054732784628868, -0.00247790664434433, 0.04532528668642044, 0.0038886028341948986, 0.04998558387160301, -0.005325795616954565, 0.0249035507440567, 0.032538969069719315, -0.04638432711362839, -0.011705268174409866, 0.0009785089641809464, -0.03535061702132225, -0.017048442736268044, 0.055892109870910645, -0.036061760038137436, -0.02465398609638214, 0.050852302461862564, -0.014125370420515537, 0.05078429728746414, -0.01335572823882103, -0.027955735102295876, -0.020898114889860153, -0.049314048141241074, -0.013328769244253635, 0.048804741352796555, -0.009942546486854553, 0.020426122471690178, 0.016014477238059044, 0.01859990693628788, -0.01908162795007229, -0.015611875802278519, -0.01508905179798603, 0.01932140439748764, -0.025213127955794334, -0.006139310076832771, 0.01252397894859314, -0.009510248899459839, -0.02658996917307377, -0.0404822863638401, 0.052330050617456436, 0.05945875868201256, 0.012453250586986542, 0.013606871478259563, -0.006699167191982269, -0.0054053752683103085, -0.08043257147073746, 0.008160973899066448, 0.01437036320567131, 0.003457156242802739, -0.05271812155842781, 0.03256145119667053, -0.0181297454982996, -0.011763842776417732, 0.00840363372117281, 0.023740867152810097, 0.01486801728606224, 0.011033124290406704, -0.057429615408182144, -0.04877997562289238, 0.02288413606584072, 0.0015138555318117142, 0.022375021129846573, -0.061982959508895874, -0.01028253324329853, 0.051618363708257675, 0.04042058065533638, -0.016131866723299026, 0.028289319947361946, -0.014256828464567661, 0.05615320801734924, -0.004204073455184698, -0.047786254435777664, -0.015907907858490944, -0.034504275768995285, -0.061687786132097244, -0.030819933861494064, -0.0675717443227768, 0.01739434152841568, 0.0038326506037265062, -0.012843038886785507, 0.002674400806427002, 0.0581706166267395, -0.021622028201818466, -0.02868611551821232, -0.01777537539601326, -0.0031859800219535828, -0.03229091316461563, 0.07643898576498032, 0.00015465871547348797, -0.001880551571957767, -0.013405172154307365, -0.02999827452003956, 0.03078385815024376, 0.016349274665117264, 0.004184024408459663, 0.08059606701135635, -0.024617623537778854, -0.009438235312700272, -0.0441766083240509, 0.06677258759737015, 0.007735027000308037, -0.005951491184532642, 0.004106041509658098, -0.02110152132809162, 0.021573958918452263, 0.024211741983890533, 0.05729009583592415, 0.004396864213049412, -0.004961841274052858, 0.014539703726768494, -0.05166786164045334, 0.005347696132957935, -0.038860417902469635, -0.0008275902946479619, -0.027645522728562355, 0.00505574606359005, 0.020824730396270752, -0.04307438060641289, -0.010745742358267307, 0.00391542399302125, -0.0160053838044405, -0.022108061239123344, 0.0017930500907823443, 0.017606789246201515, -0.04047012701630592, 0.006639540195465088, 0.05709819495677948, 0.040989235043525696, -0.01640930026769638, 0.04320757836103439, -0.03197621554136276, -0.048024069517850876, -0.013794256374239922, -0.029132084921002388, 0.01713971234858036, 0.04233676940202713, -0.027666697278618813, 0.003543202066794038, 0.01439468190073967, -0.01748402789235115, -0.012685046531260014, -0.0656011700630188, 0.062058720737695694, 0.08232560753822327, 0.0402759350836277, -0.016401348635554314, 0.02371966280043125, 0.016283538192510605, -0.0008233063854277134, 0.012899682857096195, -0.012254893779754639, -0.04964054003357887, 0.02413310296833515, 0.05884416028857231, 0.023296264931559563, -0.01169630791991949, 0.006114009767770767, 0.047866448760032654, 0.014008032158017159, 0.016155336052179337, 0.04734731838107109, 0.0257094856351614, -0.019740678369998932, 0.018602967262268066, -0.019357895478606224, 0.011666984297335148, 0.011127873323857784, 0.02793359011411667, 0.012363896705210209, 0.008799568749964237, -0.012603860348463058, -0.007235400378704071, 0.034401629120111465, -0.007589651737362146, 0.03831865265965462, -0.028605282306671143, 0.025127997621893883, 0.048154380172491074, -0.00888335146009922, 0.014373520389199257, -0.006421972066164017, 0.017546460032463074, -0.007233117241412401, -0.01977197453379631, -0.0017798369517549872, 0.027026761323213577, -0.003037209389731288, -0.03753622993826866, -0.004191256128251553, 0.019196923822164536, -0.013100581243634224, 0.00016093348676804453, -0.002587774535641074, -0.034611668437719345, 0.009263770654797554, -0.04129340872168541, 0.020996393635869026, -0.003997435327619314, 0.05765439569950104, -0.005736962892115116, -0.059155505150556564, -0.003937115427106619, -0.006998909637331963, 0.004439265467226505, 0.03522709384560585, -0.03675869479775429, -0.010103382170200348, -0.03390629589557648, -0.05343906581401825, 0.010895011015236378, -0.026144351810216904, -0.004857220686972141, 0.035626351833343506, -0.024133579805493355, -0.04979024454951286, -0.007579248398542404, -0.03463774546980858, -0.031589608639478683, -0.014466306194663048, -0.002086500870063901, 0.05900457501411438, 0.01948382332921028, -0.01656956970691681, 0.03429173678159714, -0.02904481813311577, -0.011810297146439552, -0.028589025139808655, -0.004535752348601818, -0.03142973408102989, 0.024521565064787865, 0.0310293547809124, 0.028820184990763664, -0.07131153345108032, -0.025913281366229057, -0.04681914299726486, -0.06036098301410675, 0.031132502481341362, -0.003838016651570797, 0.0686061903834343, -0.02865714579820633, -0.047269634902477264, 0.11461099982261658, 0.0142689049243927, -0.03255722299218178, -0.022115178406238556, 0.0037685707211494446, -0.02537536434829235, 0.0039411187171936035, -0.0017641994636505842, 0.02088543213903904, -0.004911570344120264, 0.0679689571261406, -0.014272906817495823, 0.03267597407102585, 0.010222271084785461, 0.014625226147472858, -0.012301021255552769, 0.022994499653577805, 0.018329033628106117, -0.022488819435238838, 0.026124410331249237, 0.041701313108205795, 0.005760752595961094, 0.004814635030925274, -0.03582096844911575, -0.003976363688707352, 0.007293074857443571, -0.05464491248130798, 0.007723051588982344, -0.04803498461842537, -0.013954315334558487, -0.027390936389565468, 0.030607450753450394, 0.050787389278411865, -0.011952484957873821, 0.02719525620341301, 0.023400863632559776, 0.039280615746974945, -0.0016051563434302807, -0.030382534489035606, 0.022973932325839996, 0.05588790774345398, -0.009579384699463844, -0.03242959454655647, -0.007865133695304394, -0.0022699744440615177, 0.003970564343035221, -0.022930795326828957, -0.03704838454723358, 0.040910229086875916, 0.03696673363447189, -0.0037006863858550787, 0.018733732402324677, -0.029738837853074074, 0.008208164013922215, -0.08624504506587982, -0.0013679772382602096, 0.004487779922783375, 0.037690822035074234, 0.003911021165549755, 0.003850599518045783, 0.00963959563523531, -0.01607353426516056, 0.022071022540330887, 0.029716752469539642, -0.06780768930912018, 0.01594735123217106, -0.009442481212317944, -0.03553534671664238, 0.010912494733929634, -0.018208369612693787, 0.043108776211738586, -0.01233105268329382, -0.004110095556825399, -0.024795494973659515, 0.048937924206256866, -0.08527667820453644, 0.010828404687345028, -0.021115344017744064, -0.03412939980626106, -0.043015528470277786, 0.04358791932463646, 0.01917199417948723, 0.00627358490601182, 0.030971286818385124, 0.02907022461295128, -0.008550782687962055, -0.037939369678497314, -0.012899639084935188, -0.0017808715347200632, 0.013291356153786182, 0.033937036991119385, -0.0027556875720620155, 0.026477646082639694, -0.012110717594623566, 0.02354310266673565, -0.014245394617319107, 0.08830404281616211, 0.033498913049697876, 0.0032655159011483192, 0.0027730632573366165, 0.013919728808104992, -0.03494759276509285, -0.027899522334337234, 0.00633639469742775, -0.01441233977675438, -0.0019931485876441, 0.03208865597844124, 0.016901958733797073, -0.016135482117533684, 0.018226582556962967, 0.04820656776428223, -0.01083558239042759, 0.006709986366331577, -0.03675552085042, -0.03031570464372635, -0.00902549084275961, -0.0021837803069502115, 0.025097033008933067, 0.0017768261022865772, -0.01590244099497795, -0.026694491505622864, 0.04693174734711647, 0.026397371664643288, -0.02465745061635971, 0.018304921686649323, 0.002428748644888401, -0.0014182641170918941, 0.013390830717980862, 0.008796241134405136, 0.05486390367150307, 0.01973055861890316, 0.03472559154033661, 0.026717089116573334, 0.0017291040858253837, -0.09181087464094162, 0.022962167859077454, 0.03164736554026604, 0.036673106253147125, -0.011907747946679592, -0.010544221848249435, -0.022632597014307976, 0.004540521185845137, 0.05373499542474747, 0.0033936738036572933, -0.015203225426375866, 0.026557035744190216, -0.020819975063204765, -0.008747393265366554, -0.016516003757715225, -0.028155237436294556, -0.0028431371320039034, -0.015767991542816162, -0.011233274824917316, -0.024572845548391342, -0.013479219749569893, -0.015928862616419792, 0.014833017252385616, 0.01582680642604828, 0.06597428023815155, 0.0031267984304577112, -0.0192140880972147, -0.03198401629924774, 0.023601677268743515, -0.02369869500398636, -0.057083263993263245, 0.054554760456085205, -0.03419835492968559, 0.015035131014883518, 0.047808997333049774, 0.00002673846211109776, -0.026532022282481194, 0.03260417655110359, -0.0015327755827456713, -0.05110367760062218, 0.004159964621067047, 0.02091703750193119, 0.03186240419745445, 0.05464613437652588, 0.01848752796649933, 0.03502649813890457, 0.052248723804950714, -0.046168580651283264, -0.002713169436901808, -0.04703596234321594, 0.019142743200063705, -0.020289534702897072, 0.0308836717158556, -0.031219230964779854, 0.021427258849143982, 0.009980290196835995, -0.013431498780846596, 0.03707420825958252, 0.035781681537628174, -0.027048131451010704, -0.028685100376605988, 0.003348608035594225, 0.04099264740943909, -0.009621412493288517, 0.025692224502563477, 0.01787564717233181, 0.04092760756611824, 0.03282851725816727, -0.0062669916078448296, -0.00974191166460514, -0.050371963530778885, 0.03798840567469597, 0.005029895808547735, -0.017392588779330254, 0.004123079124838114, -0.04262429475784302, -0.017722656950354576, 0.024739917367696762, -0.056402649730443954, 0.04909902438521385, -0.01032539363950491, 0.005210947711020708, 0.00857058446854353, -0.03250466287136078, -0.023608313873410225, 0.030751613900065422, -0.013373342342674732, 0.06645873934030533, -0.05907035619020462, -0.020348135381937027, -0.003850512905046344, 0.014056224375963211, -0.06863832473754883, 0.00680871307849884, 0.008554408326745033, 0.03048432618379593, -0.027847610414028168, -0.045072294771671295, -0.05556044355034828, -0.0195284616202116, -0.036588650196790695, -0.007923298515379429, 0.06486773490905762, 0.013053773902356625, -0.03776033967733383, -0.009419934824109077, 0.017463443800807, 0.053670261055231094, 0.0070313941687345505, 0.014872110448777676, 0.03371007367968559, -0.03437716141343117, 0.02427828498184681, -0.030824754387140274, 0.017142416909337044, -0.047904714941978455, -0.0071931323036551476, -0.0038426110986620188, 0.018459370359778404, 0.033576782792806625, -0.02271794155240059, -0.042116742581129074, -0.006320481654256582, 0.005389706697314978, 0.03444184362888336, 0.008864320814609528, -0.033539067953825, -0.04397233575582504, 0.01664065755903721, -0.008618353866040707, 0.004279104992747307, -0.02611367404460907, 0.021343296393752098, -0.008086428977549076, -0.011252159252762794, 0.004099864978343248, -0.0053136395290493965, 0.09087878465652466, 0.0005419460940174758, -0.02621331810951233, -0.005088200327008963, -0.013148745521903038, 0.03172965347766876, 0.02692689374089241, 0.02158993110060692, 0.015410779044032097, -0.0008527786703780293, 0.006693570874631405, -0.0012515251291915774, -0.04278523102402687, -0.02005298063158989, 0.06932336091995239, -0.014636697247624397, 0.03577401116490364, 0.026505688205361366, 0.0004575932980515063, -0.05140231177210808, -0.023869860917329788, -0.03802131116390228, -0.009094313718378544, -0.024517280980944633, 0.024971019476652145, -0.02967534214258194, -0.03128821402788162, 0.018335362896323204, -0.0038246591575443745, 0.03480130434036255, 0.014266561716794968, 0.014616080559790134, 0.033069200813770294, 0.031053613871335983, 0.01252938061952591, -0.03641342744231224, 0.08117098361253738, -0.06411691755056381, 0.01836293935775757, -0.022368425503373146, -0.00923878327012062, 0.0466376356780529, 0.041577499359846115, -0.04731453210115433, -0.028972776606678963, -0.011166362091898918, -0.02427712269127369, 0.058412857353687286, 0.024610353633761406, 0.007827783934772015, 0.040857944637537, 0.002885383553802967, 0.02500378154218197, -0.005284407176077366, 0.008938279934227467, -0.024540428072214127, -0.05281618610024452, -0.03250963240861893, 0.013081837445497513, -0.026179468259215355, -0.011614310555160046, 0.025283511728048325, 0.019984915852546692, -0.0034661192912608385, -0.016850175336003304, 0.05104986950755119, -0.0027499308343976736, 0.029490981251001358, -0.06670086085796356, 0.08721581101417542, -0.01677127741277218, 0.02557479403913021, -0.05806864798069, -0.028483768925070763, 0.1282021701335907, 0.057096563279628754, 0.05024115368723869, -0.06367519497871399, 0.016598541289567947, -0.016626207157969475, 0.018380243331193924, -0.03213256970047951, -0.0009292862378060818, 0.03405824303627014, -0.03267969191074371, -0.004540946800261736, 0.04626268520951271, -0.004851237405091524, -0.032409172505140305, 0.037936270236968994, -0.021126240491867065, -0.039863333106040955, 0.02035178616642952, -0.01023414172232151, -0.0394897535443306, -0.02339356020092964, -0.03159453347325325, 0.004330186173319817, -0.02202596515417099, -0.0071726590394973755, -0.028735551983118057, -0.01593831554055214, -0.030161578208208084, 0.0061494424007833, -0.0638214498758316, -0.006474400404840708, 0.009708047844469547, 0.004623305518180132, 0.0011307167587801814, -0.01023928727954626, -0.010173210874199867, 0.02593151293694973, 0.0014728442765772343, 0.05984966829419136, 0.00832599401473999, 0.02206922136247158, -0.017781095579266548, 0.02108382247388363, -0.011838492937386036, -0.02707158960402012, -0.029100878164172173, 0.037857092916965485, -0.0037218574434518814, 0.02962050959467888, 0.009763447567820549, 0.0033432627096772194, -0.024011503905057907, 0.008896789513528347, 0.023380277678370476, 0.006838534492999315, 0.04386768490076065, 0.00643245130777359, -0.004974215291440487, -0.010007400996983051, 0.028376534581184387, -0.016316384077072144, 0.003915011882781982, 0.05816863849759102, -0.036773864179849625, -0.007320723962038755, -0.0011685783974826336, 0.07356306910514832, 0.016333000734448433, -0.013805343769490719, -0.03657357767224312, -0.03224507346749306, -0.04284634441137314, -0.035628583282232285, 0.013102450408041477, -0.016344062983989716, 0.04632486030459404, -0.02289089933037758, -0.003040548413991928, 0.013846560381352901, -0.05780750885605812, -0.0012709763832390308, -0.0512816421687603, -0.0074493782594799995, -0.03721801936626434, 0.016228975728154182, 0.04798745736479759, 0.012073339894413948, -0.011060749180614948, 0.011853907257318497, 0.004212548024952412, 0.0639326274394989, -0.0004883810179308057, -0.07443360239267349, -0.01322843786329031, 0.009660428389906883, -0.02850056067109108, 0.004089132882654667, -0.0057458882220089436, 0.02002529427409172, 0.009313295595347881, 0.03703711926937103, 0.0002798430505208671, 0.01655890978872776, 0.01240770984441042, 0.004557001870125532, 0.007311603054404259, -0.04097412899136543, -0.007738613057881594, 0.03455899655818939, 0.01140141487121582, 0.004468887113034725, -0.028922123834490776, 0.007265264634042978, -0.029813507571816444, 0.02061891369521618, -0.02888544276356697, -0.053663067519664764, -0.005338787101209164, 0.011194460093975067, -0.011153267696499825, 0.02471195161342621, 0.028997402638196945, 0.027445927262306213, -0.05350076034665108, -0.02493586391210556, 0.008465575985610485, 0.0016998504288494587, -0.0028185134287923574, -0.007040301337838173, -0.0022784590255469084, 0.020063946023583412, -0.001178514095954597, 0.024578411132097244, -0.013333503156900406, 0.024789299815893173, 0.013183841481804848, 0.039037711918354034, -0.019041934981942177, 0.0027393826749175787, 0.010784517042338848, -0.047795411199331284, -0.06093945726752281, 0.03442561253905296, 0.007267560809850693, 0.007450445089489222, 0.01305043138563633, -0.03129050135612488, -0.04623008519411087, 0.056220389902591705, -0.019619038328528404, -0.01961483806371689, -0.01357316691428423, 0.029918259009718895, 0.009517441503703594, -0.01663760282099247, -0.002887629671022296, 0.015740785747766495, 0.027541501447558403, 0.017366204410791397, 0.021064817905426025, -0.042552098631858826, 0.0036970400251448154, 0.025230959057807922, 0.009217513725161552, 0.007780774030834436, -0.04362541809678078, -0.04986881837248802, 0.039468031376600266, 0.05194487050175667, -0.017806395888328552, 0.020818723365664482, -0.012182418256998062, 0.0321829728782177, -0.06744798272848129, 0.013231996446847916, 0.015054377727210522, 0.023009754717350006, 0.07449280470609665, -0.06699580699205399, 0.009472928009927273, 0.057511184364557266, -0.03383675217628479, -0.05260194465517998, 0.005617412272840738, -0.0013861251063644886, -0.051657535135746, -0.02708139829337597, -0.009812350384891033, 0.04049663990736008, 0.01775510050356388, -0.012142738327383995, 0.00710747204720974, -0.013834369368851185, 0.004447611048817635, -0.03532596305012703, 0.009370910935103893, 0.02897089533507824, 0.005960933398455381, -0.026934348046779633, 0.03511875122785568, -0.038959503173828125, -0.030003195628523827, 0.012971705757081509, 0.002667335094884038, -0.009595990180969238, -0.014677131548523903, 0.05082521215081215, 0.017471764236688614, 0.028080608695745468, 0.04896005988121033, 0.01981559954583645, 0.0008417132776230574, 0.007002435624599457, 0.009207497350871563, 0.021314669400453568, -0.05487630143761635, -0.0052314684726297855, 0.025230826810002327, -0.01899890974164009, -0.013161725364625454, 0.03438837081193924, -0.033941518515348434, 0.00513907615095377, -0.01750635728240013, -0.03418976068496704, 0.006755548063665628, -0.03252337500452995, 0.03390973061323166, -0.020605897530913353, -0.004958661273121834, 0.007242182735353708, 0.015334436669945717, -0.007562681101262569, 0.005171443335711956, -0.03983844444155693, -0.041188839823007584, 0.01755164936184883, -0.020423851907253265, -0.023038223385810852, -0.055762309581041336, -0.030366679653525352, -0.02445821650326252, -0.01050324086099863, -0.01960405521094799, 0.0059262970462441444, -0.006781024392694235, 0.021163098514080048, -0.01727765053510666, 0.01718965545296669, -0.013634171336889267, 0.008548343554139137, 0.012307188473641872, -0.054766058921813965, 0.08490346372127533, 0.009680822491645813, -0.014424913562834263, -0.008941982872784138, 0.002177419140934944, 0.02653156965970993, -0.017273925244808197, 0.015719996765255928, -0.012340720742940903, 0.022125989198684692, -0.020516950637102127, -0.0025890409015119076, 0.024042118340730667, -0.032044731080532074, 0.017338166013360023, -0.02061554789543152, -0.014585446566343307, -0.0005983481532894075, 0.0066445996053516865, 0.04345925524830818, 0.013287880457937717, -0.002344215987250209, -0.033393509685993195, 0.04210406914353371, 0.0010029934346675873, -0.01931278593838215, -0.011552189476788044, 0.004944066517055035, -0.01857992820441723, 0.08438585698604584, 0.0055922577157616615, 0.011728751473128796, -0.014687160961329937, 0.01168353483080864, -0.024120261892676353, 0.0442056730389595, -0.04132763668894768, -0.01707797311246395, 0.005068283062428236, 0.03571181744337082, 0.0006182926008477807, -0.03458259254693985, -0.045742299407720566, 0.0035614040680229664, -0.03389892354607582, -0.014367010444402695, 0.03424351289868355, -0.01899557188153267, 0.04252244159579277, 0.04145141690969467, -0.013370861299335957, 0.021873189136385918, -0.00795021466910839, -0.012578951194882393, -0.00880852434784174, 0.035180725157260895, 0.010804741643369198, 0.0014406959526240826, 0.022298792377114296, -0.03409384936094284, 0.01880491152405739, 0.000040867536881705746, 0.01437748596072197, -0.04315858706831932, -0.009890837594866753, 0.0415782630443573, 0.054706331342458725, 0.036098599433898926, -0.023635029792785645, -0.015846246853470802, 0.046935174614191055, -0.001317361369729042, -0.024861684069037437, -0.10818856209516525, 0.02788977138698101, 0.0018227056134492159, 0.027265748009085655, 0.028569314628839493, 0.022656960412859917, 0.007596771698445082, 0.003549704561010003, -0.0198439322412014, 0.023962773382663727, 0.02047245390713215, -0.06053737923502922, 0.0187723096460104, -0.02866949327290058, 0.02465239353477955, 0.0030685607343912125, 0.027988813817501068, -0.03122987598180771, -0.007807508111000061, -0.022209351882338524, 0.026179473847150803, 0.0433727465569973, 0.002907354850322008, 0.016682252287864685, 0.009479079395532608, 0.06389694660902023, -0.04883880168199539, -0.05807962268590927, -0.04312838986515999, -0.0007930190768092871, 0.0047643049620091915, -0.0007597905932925642 ]
<p>This is an artificial example. I want to compare the Income of the <em>same</em> group of people (i.e. "pairing") while they were working in US, Spain, and Nigeria. In other words, I use the "US" income as a reference and simply conduct 2 Two-sample Paired T-tests:</p> <pre><code>t.test(dat[Country=="US",]$Income, dat[Country=="Spain",]$Income, paired=TRUE) t.test(dat[Country=="US",]$Income, dat[Country=="Nigeria",]$Income, paired=TRUE) </code></pre> <p>But how is this different from the following?</p> <pre><code>pairwise.t.test(dat$Income, dat$Country, paired=TRUE) </code></pre> <p>The help for pairwise.t.test() states, "...with corrections for multiple testing". Is that the only difference?</p>
73,743
[ -0.02186271920800209, -0.00390059407800436, 0.008681979030370712, 0.002227162942290306, -0.019171204417943954, 0.02632111683487892, 0.017850389704108238, -0.006159207317978144, 0.02379784733057022, 0.019218502566218376, 0.03484087064862251, 0.037354327738285065, 0.026554333046078682, -0.0007036686292849481, 0.007666800636798143, 0.023777762427926064, -0.031761422753334045, 0.016520092263817787, 0.009064922109246254, -0.002212108112871647, -0.015591328963637352, 0.01685906946659088, 0.00188858387991786, -0.038261886686086655, 0.028734436258673668, 0.01661660335958004, 0.010862203314900398, -0.018935907632112503, 0.026963243260979652, 0.04489189013838768, -0.03874410316348076, -0.05323942005634308, 0.02216775342822075, -0.0003872988745570183, 0.02679283544421196, 0.017405373975634575, -0.03080761805176735, -0.007003770209848881, 0.004609133116900921, 0.03930513933300972, -0.021771661937236786, -0.011206683702766895, 0.019776372238993645, 0.04531499743461609, 0.02463914081454277, 0.04599753022193909, 0.000604169734288007, -0.0016209246823564172, 0.04458407685160637, -0.015924209728837013, 0.05151541903614998, -0.012689230963587761, 0.032474130392074585, 0.03131699189543724, -0.01321473903954029, 0.03307182341814041, 0.04706514626741409, 0.04302475228905678, 0.0257858969271183, -0.04805506020784378, -0.01749427057802677, -0.05970123037695885, 0.017944008111953735, 0.00041364762000739574, -0.04177873954176903, 0.02514755353331566, -0.022470686584711075, -0.020997967571020126, -0.006453130394220352, -0.007404271513223648, 0.008837448433041573, 0.026221459731459618, 0.011518602259457111, -0.010894627310335636, -0.0025238499511033297, -0.026543734595179558, 0.02790391817688942, 0.012305453419685364, 0.0719643235206604, 0.0513710081577301, -0.005175833590328693, -0.03331355005502701, 0.005627830978482962, 0.05724911764264107, 0.054043885320425034, -0.012804340571165085, 0.0410035066306591, -0.04806734248995781, 0.0033997460268437862, 0.029883401468396187, -0.011897005140781403, 0.035527072846889496, 0.014661201275885105, 0.021199285984039307, -0.02475462295114994, 0.05628655478358269, -0.004793141502887011, -0.01663236878812313, -0.017912691459059715, -0.005908864550292492, -0.0471985824406147, -0.032491814345121384, 0.012036038562655449, 0.010491776280105114, -0.02907409891486168, -0.026763835921883583, -0.05543294548988342, -0.007738132961094379, 0.013876132667064667, 0.016086699441075325, -0.022450441494584084, 0.00744797894731164, -0.030920689925551414, -0.0013160895323380828, 0.02868467941880226, 0.003789049806073308, 0.004017678555101156, 0.024570850655436516, 0.06634578108787537, 0.04699735343456268, 0.048365138471126556, -0.025549734011292458, 0.030873272567987442, -0.013438924215734005, -0.06496839970350266, 0.019835127517580986, 0.020516473799943924, -0.0007208127062767744, -0.008337183855473995, 0.03861125186085701, -0.005712657701224089, -0.028796255588531494, 0.03592939302325249, 0.015110527165234089, 0.02565346099436283, 0.011903766542673111, -0.06835468113422394, -0.06550019979476929, 0.034817684441804886, 0.007890981622040272, -0.0023143854923546314, -0.05537247657775879, 0.0120317954570055, 0.0013188926968723536, 0.05562017858028412, 0.008179082535207272, 0.0480845645070076, 0.026544498279690742, 0.0012838364345952868, 0.04427669942378998, -0.0295090451836586, -0.02112867683172226, -0.0533614307641983, -0.026624765247106552, -0.003830148372799158, -0.06289011985063553, 0.01709875836968422, 0.022341959178447723, -0.011992991901934147, 0.008685652166604996, 0.058865927159786224, 0.008572913706302643, -0.009611550718545914, -0.030309079214930534, -0.009906037710607052, 0.02639375999569893, 0.07367351651191711, -0.005039948038756847, 0.034418992698192596, 0.019588949158787727, -0.03450367599725723, 0.019404569640755653, 0.006460322067141533, 0.03834661468863487, 0.02223527990281582, -0.010164673440158367, -0.024989033117890358, -0.03312179818749428, 0.03578009456396103, 0.022416681051254272, -0.06196243315935135, -0.0035352951381355524, 0.017377806827425957, -0.02314939722418785, 0.01731306128203869, 0.03982821851968765, -0.0069928765296936035, 0.006802204996347427, 0.037870846688747406, -0.0863633006811142, -0.07089002430438995, -0.08027497678995132, -0.01939021423459053, -0.01036064513027668, -0.030772915109992027, 0.016392290592193604, -0.004533804953098297, 0.029405442997813225, -0.01621151529252529, -0.030008645728230476, -0.03570559620857239, 0.011714297346770763, 0.047324422746896744, -0.04339846596121788, 0.016578523442149162, 0.011483531445264816, 0.07404844462871552, 0.00661556888371706, 0.06811471283435822, -0.04985835403203964, -0.012186589650809765, 0.03766929358243942, -0.04123081639409065, 0.027919361367821693, -0.0053293765522539616, -0.037267230451107025, -0.002880680840462446, 0.020482409745454788, -0.04477375000715256, 0.06693274527788162, -0.06555617600679398, 0.0497526191174984, 0.07393531501293182, -0.008378519676625729, 0.004953815136104822, -0.0293156448751688, -0.015508810058236122, 0.007580156903713942, -0.030356550589203835, 0.0042702145874500275, -0.041237954050302505, -0.02390505187213421, 0.011981688439846039, 0.03398759290575981, -0.05506209284067154, 0.030519962310791016, 0.04462851956486702, 0.015695394948124886, -0.01352230180054903, 0.04056350141763687, 0.013046481646597385, -0.02144230529665947, 0.03785848990082741, 0.04056015983223915, 0.035509731620550156, 0.022706976160407066, 0.06669043749570847, -0.02169954404234886, 0.04420751333236694, -0.016359103843569756, 0.002887434558942914, 0.044917985796928406, -0.010251312516629696, 0.03058268502354622, -0.012055371887981892, 0.0019751195795834064, 0.03299938514828682, -0.04715535789728165, 0.005582935642451048, 0.00869262870401144, 0.010691570118069649, -0.036121491342782974, 0.003722298191860318, -0.018938513472676277, -0.004031341057270765, 0.03869972005486488, -0.008481723256409168, -0.005145061295479536, 0.01729845628142357, -0.041726984083652496, 0.015222235582768917, -0.023269129917025566, -0.020489593967795372, -0.032795827835798264, 0.05265481770038605, 0.011352519504725933, 0.008550690487027168, 0.023432936519384384, -0.011055771261453629, -0.0030920940916985273, -0.018858974799513817, -0.0011094865621998906, 0.032389961183071136, -0.01745891384780407, -0.056593019515275955, 0.04164910688996315, -0.03899477422237396, 0.010386750102043152, 0.030394820496439934, 0.030047114938497543, -0.019764207303524017, 0.023226480931043625, 0.006278296932578087, -0.028346765786409378, -0.00986634474247694, -0.025774475187063217, 0.002559650456532836, -0.029536627233028412, -0.014761379919946194, 0.05089563876390457, 0.01276682410389185, -0.012677265331149101, 0.028459349647164345, -0.06127721816301346, -0.024601945653557777, -0.022448135539889336, -0.03376216068863869, 0.017185227945446968, 0.009739113971590996, -0.00252346764318645, 0.02790939435362816, -0.026181770488619804, -0.029289504513144493, -0.06324179470539093, -0.049510568380355835, 0.04920525476336479, 0.024926474317908287, 0.02531941793859005, 0.00011337298928992823, -0.012364296242594719, 0.06493417918682098, 0.020426848903298378, -0.02058066986501217, -0.05036073923110962, -0.019250430166721344, -0.035042691975831985, -0.002936725504696369, 0.022175258025527, 0.027399873360991478, 0.01371675729751587, 0.002407899359241128, 0.004415536765009165, 0.03729083761572838, 0.06793955713510513, -0.018356921151280403, 0.03352420777082443, 0.006670102011412382, 0.010107148438692093, -0.025808531790971756, 0.05174434930086136, 0.016232550144195557, -0.022385217249393463, -0.017756976187229156, 0.03948575258255005, -0.020061001181602478, -0.018598129972815514, -0.018813442438840866, 0.041374027729034424, 0.022182578220963478, 0.01665959320962429, -0.05595735087990761, 0.01513929758220911, -0.0021284939721226692, -0.043062496930360794, -0.02453622967004776, 0.002182177035138011, 0.0088456766679883, -0.049070119857788086, 0.014264993369579315, 0.037847429513931274, 0.039973173290491104, -0.04633067920804024, 0.016274208202958107, 0.021431243047118187, 0.01177771482616663, 0.006698488723486662, -0.048880934715270996, -0.04783911257982254, 0.051614467054605484, 0.013464294373989105, 0.05930957943201065, 0.012492910958826542, -0.028980180621147156, 0.03948564454913139, -0.036056842654943466, 0.021461624652147293, -0.03551338240504265, 0.07052002847194672, -0.005324726924300194, 0.052239250391721725, -0.007370523177087307, 0.01736745424568653, -0.004477108363062143, -0.01903119497001171, -0.042374275624752045, -0.01053777989000082, 0.010146025568246841, -0.0419740304350853, 0.0659472867846489, -0.045609306544065475, 0.010142487473785877, -0.0140383280813694, 0.03300492465496063, -0.03344221040606499, 0.013977386057376862, -0.00604249257594347, 0.05224212631583214, -0.017353301867842674, 0.0004557308566290885, -0.010212864726781845, 0.010914750397205353, 0.037626251578330994, -0.0032626299653202295, 0.0035178756806999445, 0.020359817892313004, -0.02123313397169113, 0.023424342274665833, -0.026798902079463005, -0.0009465896873734891, 0.05714205652475357, 0.011950148269534111, 0.05988787114620209, 0.050916638225317, -0.05791827663779259, 0.012179810553789139, 0.017031192779541016, 0.022267885506153107, 0.038663510233163834, -0.03528366610407829, -0.02251540683209896, 0.004159444477409124, -0.06842401623725891, -0.008839700371026993, 0.03901577368378639, 0.005705300252884626, -0.004505714867264032, 0.037240833044052124, 0.05345182865858078, -0.029799984768033028, 0.0027416434604674578, 0.051662951707839966, 0.01707378588616848, 0.024191373959183693, -0.013375255279242992, -0.018033919855952263, -0.026866130530834198, -0.0133439302444458, 0.05235351249575615, 0.0012481315061450005, -0.016622478142380714, -0.003698080312460661, 0.030343951657414436, -0.018612483516335487, -0.038425058126449585, -0.00007293595263035968, 0.010928502306342125, 0.04010549560189247, 0.0015003569424152374, -0.037784237414598465, 0.004893555771559477, 0.038871295750141144, -0.0030834279023110867, -0.008753820322453976, 0.0063124229200184345, -0.08973708003759384, 0.013755742460489273, 0.05636221915483475, 0.04671452194452286, -0.05075585097074509, -0.022365752607584, -0.04806377366185188, 0.018219860270619392, 0.034400902688503265, -0.04404905438423157, 0.030388325452804565, -0.01884002424776554, 0.03451400250196457, -0.03191808983683586, -0.016107670962810516, -0.06409788876771927, 0.01588372141122818, -0.016098199412226677, 0.014521472156047821, 0.005105975549668074, -0.037855200469493866, -0.010247455909848213, 0.03003774769604206, 0.022139813750982285, 0.05791758745908737, -0.04760916531085968, -0.02039741724729538, 0.03250308334827423, -0.016383083537220955, 0.007281667552888393, -0.031056208536028862, -0.0008118643308989704, -0.016681866720318794, -0.00007657923561055213, 0.009709575213491917, 0.025995315983891487, -0.028986141085624695, 0.00791379064321518, 0.016282442957162857, -0.02997698076069355, -0.002612986834719777, 0.012426340021193027, 0.008036264218389988, 0.050596561282873154, -0.014942902140319347, 0.05369029939174652, -0.015947114676237106, -0.021201523020863533, 0.006634918972849846, -0.055179476737976074, 0.014111205004155636, -0.012930531986057758, 0.0187126025557518, -0.043143514543771744, -0.029199866577982903, -0.01096418872475624, 0.007936588488519192, 0.005021181423217058, 0.025565946474671364, -0.029381603002548218, 0.0025269503239542246, 0.005593393463641405, 0.044609539210796356, -0.021866684779524803, -0.02087797410786152, 0.030529266223311424, 0.011231902986764908, -0.03341572731733322, -0.02771308273077011, 0.02007623389363289, -0.0064140912145376205, -0.0003022441524080932, -0.012741979211568832, -0.007149523124098778, 0.04919951409101486, -0.04176617041230202, -0.025308439508080482, 0.03445614129304886, -0.023068994283676147, 0.014253786765038967, 0.018778039142489433, 0.0315999835729599, 0.006540048401802778, -0.028418872505426407, 0.009796042926609516, 0.003401220543310046, 0.0013164440169930458, -0.005917627830058336, -0.027683807536959648, 0.0679510086774826, 0.021544113755226135, -0.04009396582841873, -0.05010538548231125, -0.0352330207824707, -0.00715794088318944, -0.012448271736502647, -0.0160279031842947, -0.019381225109100342, -0.021484728902578354, 0.018070535734295845, 0.009616521187126637, -0.006804674863815308, 0.06646087765693665, -0.03428105637431145, -0.03654201328754425, -0.03915046527981758, 0.026969004422426224, 0.0466691218316555, 0.013463100418448448, -0.0013340790756046772, -0.01754327490925789, -0.01688939519226551, 0.018122868612408638, -0.00589736457914114, -0.008496110327541828, -0.03071335144340992, -0.01042786706238985, -0.06579620391130447, 0.009981398470699787, 0.060048602521419525, -0.0074121723882853985, -0.011228688061237335, -0.005243424791842699, -0.03622106835246086, 0.007572973147034645, -0.03164329007267952, -0.0036683331709355116, -0.04800242558121681, 0.01636156439781189, -0.039933785796165466, 0.024208547547459602, -0.002794405212625861, -0.03130432963371277, -0.0029042039532214403, -0.0017286776565015316, -0.042238421738147736, 0.006219944451004267, 0.06722132116556168, 0.0077506015077233315, 0.06315448880195618, 0.004524530842900276, -0.06037076562643051, 0.014822937548160553, 0.00032221447327174246, -0.026292646303772926, 0.011258402839303017, 0.0010125950211659074, -0.039586082100868225, 0.0005655692657455802, -0.011702576652169228, -0.02568526566028595, 0.06605761498212814, 0.0021737725473940372, 0.06735926121473312, 0.06256236135959625, 0.006412093061953783, 0.044031351804733276, -0.032922301441431046, -0.01320457924157381, -0.01242396142333746, 0.018427427858114243, 0.04322797805070877, 0.007805545814335346, -0.040184929966926575, 0.07634935528039932, 0.03816189244389534, 0.05246836319565773, 0.02220674231648445, 0.007496751379221678, -0.024923859164118767, 0.021525075659155846, -0.03267519548535347, -0.05042601376771927, 0.03237709403038025, -0.038420066237449646, 0.02713855169713497, -0.030324432998895645, -0.03374800831079483, 0.04780910164117813, 0.010436308570206165, -0.044524069875478745, -0.034590449184179306, -0.034509509801864624, -0.049856655299663544, 0.015147729776799679, 0.0112689770758152, -0.047116730362176895, 0.049920327961444855, -0.011343715712428093, 0.0348380021750927, 0.005446302238851786, 0.030580898746848106, -0.0208527073264122, -0.05091710016131401, -0.05098932608962059, -0.014546673744916916, -0.03194531425833702, 0.048963792622089386, 0.015842244029045105, -0.037265315651893616, 0.021365290507674217, -0.05527859926223755, 0.04121137410402298, 0.014195761643350124, 0.02682442218065262, -0.057380471378564835, 0.06686454266309738, 0.012396886944770813, 0.031311169266700745, 0.0033451428171247244, -0.062422364950180054, 0.1156294047832489, 0.04182279482483864, 0.0408807247877121, -0.06617474555969238, 0.011971384286880493, -0.0080892788246274, -0.02507421374320984, -0.012145139276981354, -0.011800016276538372, -0.000002436797103655408, 0.022510385140776634, 0.060405831784009933, 0.06954208016395569, 0.014471621252596378, 0.02041621506214142, 0.0154412304982543, -0.04359370470046997, -0.027293698862195015, 0.03319226950407028, 0.024613868445158005, 0.006960524711757898, -0.044938649982213974, -0.03172595798969269, -0.020781105384230614, 0.018341001123189926, 0.039769113063812256, -0.010226799175143242, -0.026674490422010422, -0.013138743117451668, 0.05087796971201897, 0.00196920707821846, 0.0021481579169631004, -0.02501452900469303, 0.0050023337826132774, -0.03438764065504074, 0.0009607222164049745, 0.027450481429696083, -0.06236962974071503, 0.017308030277490616, 0.03741883859038353, -0.017265083268284798, 0.0010495362803339958, 0.02665909193456173, 0.017950715497136116, -0.047491926699876785, -0.03298649564385414, -0.01538924127817154, 0.029632193967700005, -0.02203528955578804, -0.01778796873986721, -0.024322865530848503, 0.01121453195810318, 0.024191876873373985, -0.029841991141438484, -0.0258476622402668, 0.02487986348569393, 0.0006405762978829443, -0.015093988738954067, -0.001775585231371224, -0.028027674183249474, 0.01920359395444393, 0.016561469063162804, 0.043265752494335175, 0.03619501367211342, -0.010658026672899723, 0.025363128632307053, -0.03915278613567352, 0.025418493896722794, -0.0042853946797549725, 0.024495387449860573, 0.0337948203086853, -0.02523679845035076, -0.028318917378783226, -0.02118510752916336, -0.004343837033957243, 0.045060016214847565, 0.028294051066040993, -0.02094111405313015, -0.006452529225498438, -0.024596424773335457, -0.014969347044825554, -0.019444435834884644, -0.049128081649541855, -0.0344967246055603, -0.012891275808215141, 0.0053794835694134235, 0.011659391224384308, 0.021398374810814857, 0.05079202353954315, 0.04857832193374634, 0.008120272308588028, 0.04460075497627258, 0.003815894015133381, -0.05395105108618736, -0.0055799405090510845, 0.009774662554264069, -0.022056858986616135, -0.03941286727786064, -0.03871546685695648, 0.061325039714574814, 0.03771769255399704, 0.019053122028708458, -0.05611139163374901, 0.006386394612491131, -0.008958240039646626, -0.0004374199779704213, 0.016564009711146355, -0.03635302931070328, -0.0211662445217371, 0.03718111291527748, 0.000038924099499126896, -0.010651212185621262, 0.006457541137933731, -0.055943116545677185, -0.03938637301325798, 0.02992255426943302, -0.01077005174010992, -0.047764409333467484, -0.0004624454886652529, -0.007896955125033855, 0.01885967329144478, -0.055344611406326294, -0.002537460532039404, -0.05769730731844902, 0.003631027415394783, 0.031055955216288567, 0.026797568425536156, -0.03102470561861992, 0.009603514336049557, -0.04765591397881508, 0.029184741899371147, 0.018692150712013245, -0.0011024593841284513, 0.004408208653330803, -0.005877590738236904, 0.009166323579847813, -0.012291119433939457, 0.03656768798828125, -0.009119062684476376, -0.017357755452394485, 0.04456833377480507, -0.018769754096865654, -0.018591513857245445, 0.015788931399583817, 0.03693155571818352, 0.058257345110177994, 0.0034931807313114405, -0.01166447438299656, -0.04275968670845032, 0.05846404656767845, -0.029425309970974922, -0.03000735491514206, -0.02346125803887844, -0.02897898107767105, 0.017500439658761024, -0.013848952017724514, -0.022248156368732452, -0.006975956726819277, -0.009581043384969234, 0.021229790523648262, 0.04117092862725258, 0.021827934309840202, -0.041524894535541534, -0.03504183515906334, -0.009787529706954956, -0.0010694300290197134, 0.01871306449174881, -0.008356286212801933, -0.020649731159210205, 0.0419217012822628, -0.010581535287201405, 0.02903846651315689, -0.04124049097299576, 0.026505790650844574, -0.06935392320156097, -0.02453591674566269, 0.021181374788284302, -0.01412920281291008, 0.028491629287600517, -0.05231592431664467, 0.019981542602181435, -0.011961371637880802, -0.03322606906294823, 0.04766214266419411, 0.009807072579860687, -0.02282421849668026, -0.03803475201129913, 0.03132157027721405, -0.014804747886955738, 0.06308306753635406, 0.025186223909258842, 0.02899363450706005, 0.03053300827741623, -0.010355102829635143, 0.01260555163025856, -0.014487875625491142, -0.049107689410448074, 0.020961521193385124, 0.009700827300548553, -0.06786418706178665, 0.03470149263739586, -0.020567037165164948, -0.038334861397743225, 0.01617226004600525, -0.01973925158381462, -0.00857671070843935, 0.01802665926516056, 0.0379054918885231, 0.00784682109951973, 0.013551236130297184, 0.05346854031085968, 0.0048649548552930355, -0.003052363870665431, 0.016075139865279198, 0.0011183678871020675, 0.007159041706472635, -0.0013406691141426563, 0.001405530609190464, -0.022863414138555527, 0.024971315637230873, 0.00930600706487894, 0.0328192375600338, 0.002655601827427745, -0.0014024004340171814, 0.02377847582101822, 0.025756753981113434, 0.050511639565229416, -0.019563520327210426, 0.0026126434095203876, -0.05076054483652115, -0.012500499375164509, 0.030341116711497307, 0.028484785929322243, -0.024928422644734383, 0.02538459561765194, 0.02080986648797989, -0.047183115035295486, 0.013720545917749405, 0.011751579120755196, -0.0048457360826432705, -0.032697055488824844, -0.017846448346972466, 0.008168289437890053, -0.016713233664631844, -0.025494050234556198, 0.0030806937720626593, -0.008118522353470325, 0.018849069252610207, 0.006188645958900452, -0.009124658070504665, 0.021766316145658493, -0.0012040617875754833, 0.0013604651903733611, -0.11082158982753754, 0.06138605251908302, -0.006122854072600603, -0.045963186770677567, 0.0006303972913883626, -0.006615742109715939, -0.06171482801437378, 0.04472462460398674, 0.04997973516583443, 0.023855043575167656, 0.003361231880262494, -0.03538094460964203, -0.015778418630361557, -0.006340086925774813, -0.05910580977797508, 0.05982723459601402, -0.004393162205815315, -0.023510800674557686, 0.009242965839803219, -0.010070083662867546, -0.03861799091100693, 0.019492538645863533, -0.00631603691726923, -0.03630191460251808, 0.012408659793436527, 0.018202360719442368, 0.012222708202898502, 0.044507768005132675, -0.011530939489603043, -0.007583667989820242, 0.04168301820755005, 0.005513665731996298, 0.03017578087747097, 0.0263962522149086, -0.002503715455532074, -0.042369991540908813, 0.04222351312637329, -0.013324406929314137, -0.003615195397287607, -0.02301829867064953, -0.011575003154575825, -0.0021312041208148003, -0.019718069583177567, 0.0005448704469017684, 0.020430106669664383, -0.017713265493512154, 0.011279352940618992, 0.01543023344129324, 0.04200255870819092, 0.016959335654973984, -0.015101000666618347, 0.025600463151931763, -0.027333887293934822, -0.0553601011633873, 0.022630972787737846, 0.023629456758499146, 0.013972815126180649, 0.011481636203825474, 0.007673119194805622, 0.02354990877211094, -0.043376050889492035, 0.0016373228281736374, -0.017058633267879486, 0.06524462252855301, -0.02341615781188011, -0.028325984254479408, -0.02401449903845787, -0.008286792784929276, 0.020585643127560616, -0.014103005640208721, -0.011989562772214413, 0.03040851093828678, -0.05437547713518143, -0.0009108833037316799, -0.021056387573480606, 0.007103422190994024, -0.009470059536397457, -0.05733100324869156, 0.005466904491186142, 0.010694511234760284, -0.015095317736268044, 0.009538442827761173, 0.0013447910314425826, -0.04898699373006821, -0.0021780182141810656, 0.0010119042126461864, -0.0009642187505960464, -0.0164932981133461, 0.013860407285392284, -0.041015610098838806, 0.016325129196047783, -0.016961075365543365, -0.03442426025867462, 0.037189219146966934, 0.055268026888370514, 0.03235577419400215, -0.06262274831533432, -0.03549681603908539, 0.017867064103484154, 0.022989805787801743, -0.07895682752132416, -0.022297805175185204, -0.04391869530081749, 0.007392116356641054, 0.00875903107225895, -0.013983229175209999 ]
<p>I'm trying to generate many draws (i.e., realizations) of a Gaussian process $e_i(t)$, $1\leq t \leq T$ with mean 0 and covariance function $\gamma(s,t)=\exp(-|t-s|)$. </p> <p>Is there an efficient way to do this that wouldn't involve computing the square root of a $T \times T$ covariance matrix? Alternatively can anyone recommend an <code>R</code> package to do this?</p>
73,744
[ 0.0021711704321205616, -0.00695342430844903, 0.027777893468737602, -0.010492498986423016, 0.03044203110039234, -0.025972269475460052, -0.0371004082262516, -0.012211661785840988, 0.00239944108761847, -0.036391668021678925, 0.028446447104215622, 0.04271300882101059, 0.013388222083449364, 0.04313721880316734, 0.015355175361037254, 0.006860225927084684, -0.012576027773320675, -0.01237751729786396, -0.033117931336164474, -0.03800761327147484, -0.011692781001329422, 0.015019753016531467, 0.0018998098094016314, -0.041025690734386444, -0.0602182038128376, 0.03166826814413071, 0.027904635295271873, 0.026801753789186478, -0.008490442298352718, 0.07373963296413422, -0.08259890228509903, -0.01761256717145443, 0.012339257635176182, 0.06518810242414474, 0.022827431559562683, 0.0088274497538805, -0.029697593301534653, -0.056862860918045044, 0.02549152448773384, 0.0063832164742052555, -0.024675477296113968, -0.03847150132060051, -0.019792072474956512, 0.023798903450369835, 0.02018430270254612, 0.01388785894960165, -0.004059059079736471, -0.058899980038404465, 0.040531281381845474, -0.025462018325924873, 0.08854156732559204, 0.015866635367274284, 0.022304728627204895, 0.024118583649396896, -0.016368167474865913, 0.013684755191206932, 0.05717641860246658, 0.03331351280212402, 0.035053323954343796, -0.036268047988414764, 0.035733241587877274, -0.03186003118753433, 0.002890051109716296, -0.023737313225865364, -0.002459842711687088, -0.041277624666690826, 0.03264355659484863, -0.004062293563038111, 0.0031808014027774334, -0.06602778285741806, 0.010871357284486294, 0.02455269731581211, 0.021333107724785805, -0.026635056361556053, -0.025923117995262146, 0.0053188977763056755, 0.016094082966446877, 0.005191451869904995, 0.06404057890176773, 0.015980979427695274, 0.003327934304252267, 0.028591256588697433, 0.0015862296568229795, 0.016294259577989578, 0.0014500709949061275, 0.024569757282733917, 0.0644199475646019, -0.023695645853877068, 0.029658270999789238, 0.03756013885140419, -0.026162492111325264, -0.0017758277244865894, 0.08062732219696045, 0.016419105231761932, -0.056632865220308304, 0.027118176221847534, 0.00019736256217584014, 0.036565810441970825, -0.015098227187991142, -0.0034431417006999254, -0.029960228130221367, -0.06557589769363403, 0.026390567421913147, 0.044041264802217484, -0.03319676220417023, 0.01622752659022808, 0.006954345386475325, 0.004463581833988428, -0.016496436670422554, -0.03827129676938057, -0.014372188597917557, -0.00591591140255332, 0.030487388372421265, 0.009921759366989136, 0.05116290971636772, -0.012106572277843952, -0.01900584064424038, -0.0027987314388155937, 0.015965759754180908, 0.08361494541168213, 0.02257610857486725, -0.045942164957523346, 0.04397522285580635, -0.03308635577559471, -0.055647265166044235, 0.029822412878274918, 0.0016106568509712815, -0.011625535786151886, -0.04615207388997078, 0.034245386719703674, -0.009188715368509293, -0.04972941800951958, 0.07035370171070099, -0.004003182984888554, 0.04593105614185333, 0.0024349114391952753, -0.07777173072099686, -0.0629357174038887, 0.034184347838163376, -0.06561045348644257, 0.01151282899081707, -0.07950721681118011, 0.006145407445728779, 0.021272879093885422, 0.03520745411515236, -0.0064020524732768536, 0.03330039232969284, 0.01288589183241129, 0.06406393647193909, -0.004862973000854254, -0.03808886185288429, 0.01981940306723118, -0.03892945498228073, -0.02283671870827675, 0.0007945617544464767, -0.05612443760037422, 0.060986682772636414, 0.017261164262890816, -0.03654045984148979, 0.031751953065395355, 0.03633672371506691, 0.031096184626221657, 0.008694449439644814, 0.0056412131525576115, 0.025483503937721252, -0.0512651652097702, 0.06415260583162308, -0.00724116712808609, 0.033784169703722, -0.016057191416621208, -0.02542073279619217, -0.013116233050823212, 0.010542837902903557, 0.02697318233549595, 0.013690486550331116, -0.04996150732040405, 0.026917502284049988, 0.00543375127017498, -0.0004512181330937892, 0.031519774347543716, 0.011765050701797009, 0.011105794459581375, -0.0023704194463789463, -0.025189725682139397, 0.03358961269259453, 0.016021234914660454, -0.0055078985169529915, -0.004207442980259657, 0.0390704907476902, -0.06325741857290268, -0.012159382924437523, -0.03239060565829277, 0.004765490535646677, 0.021367188543081284, -0.01748763397336006, 0.007415436673909426, 0.02037207782268524, 0.052341826260089874, 0.01397757139056921, -0.046972788870334625, 0.011661653406918049, -0.001576098846271634, 0.025033840909600258, -0.03230316564440727, -0.0008955130469985306, 0.04371116682887077, 0.07753311097621918, -0.0185785461217165, 0.037477556616067886, -0.005233044270426035, -0.04890567809343338, -0.018167445436120033, -0.05641286075115204, 0.04300558939576149, 0.004117029253393412, -0.016454296186566353, -0.01531652919948101, -0.007251191418617964, -0.019657913595438004, 0.01270271185785532, -0.051829803735017776, 0.0027243345975875854, 0.10055071860551834, 0.037035468965768814, 0.005267810076475143, 0.005689009092748165, 0.01893674023449421, 0.0069139571860432625, -0.026271354407072067, -0.0058225058019161224, -0.030002659186720848, -0.013216156512498856, 0.042371802031993866, 0.03712479770183563, -0.028406457975506783, 0.002655679825693369, 0.03255453705787659, 0.010069659911096096, 0.020380431786179543, 0.06708799302577972, -0.030937939882278442, -0.011706187389791012, -0.0016186260618269444, 0.003319568932056427, 0.03177618980407715, -0.0263527724891901, 0.00518495449796319, -0.01609182171523571, 0.01616266556084156, 0.015653904527425766, -0.012886982411146164, 0.0001147300936281681, -0.036887142807245255, -0.003929715137928724, 0.009430747479200363, -0.022738073021173477, 0.03872665390372276, -0.013844705186784267, -0.012977940030395985, 0.016406584531068802, 0.010810654610395432, -0.006846348289400339, 0.02209343947470188, -0.013908195309340954, 0.012997590005397797, 0.028960878029465675, -0.02261345274746418, 0.01149589940905571, 0.03150495886802673, -0.026214968413114548, 0.02556341327726841, -0.010316671803593636, -0.020106680691242218, -0.04351823404431343, 0.029089929535984993, 0.009958579204976559, -0.013967669568955898, 0.011582070961594582, -0.05307857692241669, -0.03225375711917877, -0.008407526649534702, 0.01059639360755682, 0.03765081986784935, 0.02956511452794075, -0.08152112364768982, 0.02871401607990265, -0.03954329714179039, -0.011596648953855038, 0.0031953039579093456, -0.03843202441930771, -0.027594314888119698, 0.011346107348799706, -0.006831575185060501, -0.038096826523542404, -0.01614992693066597, -0.021245421841740608, -0.020120956003665924, -0.016066409647464752, -0.003358678426593542, 0.03534247726202011, 0.03254000470042229, -0.08179450035095215, 0.00839849840849638, -0.048633456230163574, -0.016752412542700768, -0.04212143272161484, -0.005494049750268459, 0.057599712163209915, -0.016743581742048264, 0.03283526375889778, 0.03154698386788368, -0.009416578337550163, 0.030049921944737434, -0.07442289590835571, -0.023540886119008064, -0.021511275321245193, 0.04377096891403198, 0.05740150064229965, 0.022300461307168007, -0.029432907700538635, 0.028271730989217758, 0.02935062162578106, -0.01300597283989191, 0.0037001504097133875, 0.003805852960795164, -0.014803532510995865, -0.03055744431912899, 0.00837453082203865, -0.012905459851026535, -0.024923978373408318, 0.03219768404960632, 0.019423818215727806, -0.01434115320444107, 0.08489328622817993, -0.010902627371251583, -0.01549329049885273, -0.011706865392625332, -0.04230938106775284, 0.00929128285497427, 0.011706942692399025, 0.011946877464652061, -0.035716019570827484, 0.0419563390314579, -0.0051321410574018955, 0.011905557475984097, 0.00854818057268858, -0.02071143314242363, -0.005857486743479967, 0.003412042511627078, 0.02575354091823101, -0.05224083364009857, 0.03087012656033039, 0.020111970603466034, -0.04364507272839546, -0.04200483486056328, 0.06286510825157166, 0.012889712117612362, -0.018945274874567986, 0.025711949914693832, 0.027476336807012558, 0.03206145763397217, -0.025072915479540825, -0.015213974751532078, -0.008854120038449764, -0.04391462728381157, -0.013368436135351658, -0.00022660545073449612, 0.005949906073510647, 0.0539175420999527, 0.013919207267463207, 0.02086247317492962, -0.0025059005711227655, 0.0021978598088026047, -0.016398387029767036, -0.022195206955075264, 0.0019483484793454409, -0.032490745186805725, 0.046652305871248245, 0.012622342444956303, 0.03329791501164436, 0.004019538871943951, -0.009828177280724049, 0.03644934669137001, -0.01689843088388443, -0.031095851212739944, 0.020412210375070572, -0.0479435957968235, 0.006062360014766455, 0.0053164116106927395, 0.015218333341181278, 0.05943601205945015, 0.015622260048985481, 0.04708202928304672, 0.0268340315669775, 0.05164293572306633, -0.04123938828706741, -0.02366526424884796, -0.045052770525217056, -0.014867023564875126, -0.038587793707847595, 0.01986507885158062, 0.013198044151067734, -0.023601585999131203, 0.02420714870095253, 0.02044564113020897, -0.0033295920584350824, 0.0183988269418478, 0.010600532405078411, 0.03470949828624725, 0.022888977080583572, 0.037191491574048996, 0.03902611881494522, 0.023816142231225967, -0.031403470784425735, 0.018102280795574188, -0.014854843728244305, 0.07690587639808655, 0.06162445992231369, -0.015339961275458336, 0.005470483098179102, -0.0639941394329071, -0.040942661464214325, 0.04983881860971451, 0.01217744778841734, -0.017026659101247787, -0.017099738121032715, 0.032903969287872314, 0.032024115324020386, -0.03537359461188316, 0.017627421766519547, 0.060161445289850235, -0.017528723925352097, 0.01782860793173313, -0.013982015661895275, 0.031233951449394226, 0.024775711819529533, 0.003251018701121211, 0.01215376053005457, 0.03233214095234871, -0.022576943039894104, 0.019113799557089806, -0.004972039721906185, -0.018145984038710594, -0.0064988345839083195, -0.02162238210439682, 0.024333259090781212, 0.08322471380233765, 0.014961904846131802, -0.030158957466483116, -0.00033645046642050147, 0.02875610813498497, -0.010804267600178719, 0.032351166009902954, -0.01264925580471754, -0.051798805594444275, 0.03946341946721077, 0.05484524741768837, 0.0078722620382905, 0.016062084585428238, 0.024053020402789116, -0.07503071427345276, -0.034636400640010834, 0.047765396535396576, -0.038711484521627426, -0.0011095391819253564, -0.019018756225705147, -0.0022144971881061792, -0.03379158675670624, -0.034361887723207474, -0.03589973226189613, 0.021024957299232483, -0.04230878874659538, 0.035426679998636246, -0.019392147660255432, -0.0036119730211794376, -0.013946780003607273, 0.004064931068569422, -0.012623940594494343, 0.07958448678255081, -0.01356671191751957, -0.022373253479599953, -0.016055529937148094, 0.054438576102256775, 0.0008177619311027229, -0.028069254010915756, -0.00763318408280611, -0.00680658221244812, -0.01575009524822235, 0.05074949190020561, -0.024885285645723343, -0.027008697390556335, 0.023755012080073357, 0.004060804843902588, -0.0009472798556089401, -0.018214739859104156, -0.041868582367897034, 0.04231422767043114, 0.013262005522847176, 0.00200793263502419, 0.06375879794359207, 0.059636883437633514, -0.007084554526954889, 0.009053126908838749, -0.038842298090457916, 0.004509745631366968, -0.02512286603450775, -0.007504748180508614, -0.06441634148359299, -0.020115844905376434, -0.02236914075911045, -0.018837936222553253, -0.01213801372796297, 0.05561055615544319, 0.0019965150859206915, 0.001355305896140635, 0.006603614892810583, 0.058834318071603775, -0.025085998699069023, 0.010707447305321693, 0.01283748634159565, 0.018547076731920242, -0.04466305300593376, -0.05644674226641655, 0.001206970657221973, 0.005026632454246283, -0.005121196154505014, 0.01980934478342533, -0.02749643474817276, -0.024103419855237007, -0.04599347338080406, -0.004824451170861721, -0.011451938189566135, -0.022488748654723167, 0.0708213597536087, -0.032524410635232925, 0.04607585445046425, 0.024717915803194046, -0.03264665976166725, 0.013188225217163563, 0.020510438829660416, -0.0222532469779253, 0.01929345354437828, -0.045627955347299576, 0.011905724182724953, -0.016390593722462654, -0.010340445674955845, -0.08383830636739731, -0.05919400230050087, 0.016573552042245865, -0.04778754338622093, 0.014407159760594368, -0.06419594585895538, -0.03286612406373024, -0.04642451927065849, 0.008777155540883541, -0.03366834297776222, 0.05176933854818344, 0.01431957446038723, 0.004165269434452057, -0.0053201294504106045, 0.030057745054364204, 0.06484103202819824, -0.03216619789600372, -0.001733880490064621, 0.04234325513243675, -0.02969655580818653, -0.04741501808166504, 0.015324302017688751, 0.03984341770410538, -0.0303916297852993, 0.001206826651468873, 0.01417576428502798, 0.02194410189986229, -0.005975129082798958, -0.003427098970860243, -0.04152088239789009, 0.03385858237743378, -0.02202487923204899, 0.043858833611011505, -0.04404495283961296, -0.01650375872850418, 0.010819858871400356, -0.0042712935246527195, -0.01846497692167759, -0.030707748606801033, -0.0032400640193372965, -0.025806603953242302, 0.007106686942279339, 0.02011602185666561, 0.006101035047322512, 0.06193581223487854, 0.04562269523739815, 0.004540730733424425, 0.015765424817800522, 0.026291770860552788, -0.008440499193966389, 0.037349410355091095, -0.009936001151800156, 0.007111343089491129, -0.007599754724651575, -0.023939579725265503, -0.04829110577702522, -0.017710411921143532, -0.047395795583724976, 0.002934001386165619, 0.038472454994916916, 0.0015772231854498386, 0.06983750313520432, 0.06501615047454834, 0.0070515950210392475, 0.015068239532411098, 0.0060198307037353516, -0.015470471233129501, -0.021756885573267937, -0.016750860959291458, 0.04654600843787193, 0.0002933428040705621, -0.010573268868029118, 0.005807619541883469, 0.007096636574715376, 0.03962448239326477, 0.0645548477768898, -0.022792723029851913, -0.00749176787212491, 0.025278303772211075, -0.027796952053904533, -0.025481916964054108, -0.01481449231505394, -0.0416766032576561, 0.019456418231129646, -0.01752972975373268, -0.016032252460718155, 0.0266894344240427, 0.03625510260462761, 0.0036630036775022745, -0.02229168266057968, -0.022165117785334587, -0.0709841251373291, 0.011399148032069206, 0.05188111215829849, -0.022663813084363937, 0.021320262923836708, 0.010324941016733646, 0.019118107855319977, 0.0013366015627980232, 0.03630514815449715, -0.056807730346918106, -0.061644669622182846, -0.009435197338461876, -0.06803310662508011, -0.016373852267861366, 0.035182926803827286, 0.03994719684123993, -0.012763586826622486, -0.01450581755489111, -0.03309129923582077, 0.03271062672138214, -0.020492980256676674, 0.03503580763936043, -0.008040037006139755, 0.08343026787042618, 0.0002927162277046591, -0.0017559091793373227, -0.0017277218867093325, 0.01403695996850729, 0.12274278700351715, 0.07540509849786758, 0.04609944671392441, -0.03739967569708824, -0.01801883988082409, -0.007603225763887167, -0.020042652264237404, -0.016104068607091904, 0.021583186462521553, 0.01974400505423546, 0.020913342013955116, 0.03919951617717743, 0.06418385356664658, -0.0019574284087866545, 0.007879795506596565, 0.060016222298145294, -0.036027029156684875, -0.010896344669163227, 0.011014332994818687, 0.008543870411813259, 0.00025919030304066837, -0.00394856184720993, -0.08096649497747421, 0.01753142848610878, -0.0282281506806612, -0.026038922369480133, -0.010533689521253109, -0.01617891900241375, 0.002432485343888402, -0.0030349581502377987, -0.0012186066014692187, -0.014298585243523121, 0.02633015811443329, 0.02786761336028576, 0.00690070167183876, 0.00930616445839405, -0.0009403101867064834, -0.012888791039586067, 0.026805825531482697, 0.04511295631527901, 0.019099324941635132, 0.011809712275862694, -0.013839628547430038, -0.017056729644536972, 0.016421625390648842, -0.009642252698540688, -0.043167296797037125, 0.036504391580820084, -0.004024168476462364, 0.0189534779638052, -0.02172323875129223, 0.008730826899409294, 0.025522787123918533, -0.045877907425165176, -0.025020595639944077, -0.024972595274448395, 0.04933931678533554, -0.036887139081954956, -0.01417926512658596, -0.019596971571445465, 0.040080297738313675, -0.01574680581688881, 0.018106602132320404, 0.003205092390999198, -0.03488925099372864, -0.00330151803791523, -0.049971047788858414, 0.03686167299747467, 0.02819680981338024, -0.02419368363916874, 0.004833078011870384, -0.04005042836070061, -0.02346949279308319, -0.041215769946575165, 0.018279774114489555, -0.035053521394729614, -0.0022444992791861296, 0.005207889247685671, 0.014807876199483871, -0.025807728990912437, -0.03148267790675163, 0.010203865356743336, -0.042086366564035416, -0.020096896216273308, -0.00004722437006421387, -0.04678543657064438, 0.040404874831438065, 0.04264114797115326, -0.005795456934720278, 0.005737100727856159, -0.019542686641216278, 0.060228131711483, 0.037479571998119354, -0.0443941168487072, 0.009223202243447304, -0.028836309909820557, -0.03145352378487587, -0.01071283407509327, -0.0032466084230691195, 0.06207212433218956, 0.019612781703472137, 0.0539766401052475, 0.005045055411756039, 0.03993724659085274, -0.00733285304158926, -0.035953339189291, -0.0022762445732951164, -0.03854698687791824, 0.00980448629707098, -0.009776206687092781, -0.000337085104547441, -0.008211206644773483, 0.0126193193718791, -0.008058267645537853, -0.030082138255238533, -0.025927279144525528, -0.032909978181123734, -0.03488729149103165, -0.006258510053157806, -0.02641362138092518, 0.006953119765967131, 0.003038889728486538, 0.03139789029955864, -0.026349123567342758, -0.0014918554807081819, -0.020013215020298958, -0.011731840670108795, -0.0017052325420081615, 0.01681843027472496, 0.015035493299365044, 0.01913846656680107, 0.015232040546834469, 0.02725214883685112, 0.032390374690294266, -0.00014641392044723034, 0.02367836982011795, -0.02007848210632801, 0.007581116631627083, -0.02285420149564743, 0.0024339284282177687, 0.03290338069200516, -0.03839306905865669, -0.0009183374349959195, -0.008849970996379852, -0.000921369472052902, 0.04650100693106651, -0.0021707608830183744, -0.04509443789720535, -0.05309794098138809, 0.012478365562856197, -0.026784105226397514, 0.020705891773104668, 0.004439631011337042, 0.03590312972664833, 0.01036275178194046, -0.02738032117486, 0.0380912683904171, 0.0007708171033300459, -0.003199966624379158, -0.0010594199411571026, 0.018816163763403893, -0.01740076206624508, 0.024930479004979134, -0.001777893048711121, -0.011377111077308655, -0.006597318686544895, 0.03265955299139023, -0.022802913561463356, 0.05188971012830734, 0.045999832451343536, -0.017276905477046967, 0.002374553820118308, -0.02789178676903248, 0.04339831694960594, -0.0729561373591423, -0.008527184836566448, -0.011331428773701191, -0.012945188209414482, 0.06786675751209259, -0.0454668253660202, -0.011709385551512241, 0.049132250249385834, -0.022563179954886436, 0.001995324855670333, 0.026981310918927193, -0.010794024914503098, -0.03872139751911163, 0.0321744903922081, -0.013779375702142715, 0.02809346653521061, 0.05053170025348663, 0.03366523236036301, 0.03967943787574768, 0.03734169527888298, -0.005964287556707859, 0.018104450777173042, -0.01728607714176178, 0.030270004644989967, 0.017926812171936035, -0.03605706989765167, 0.006724401842802763, -0.02308696135878563, 0.002902100095525384, 0.012802939862012863, 0.004833723418414593, -0.016315961256623268, -0.021522898226976395, 0.04108153656125069, -0.014684346504509449, 0.07121609896421432, 0.057961903512477875, -0.01172097958624363, 0.014113850891590118, -0.019490201026201248, 0.021750399842858315, -0.0012365340953692794, -0.012776716612279415, 0.019251815974712372, 0.02549639716744423, -0.005856572650372982, -0.020601971074938774, 0.007491364609450102, 0.007464205846190453, -0.05491512641310692, -0.0129369692876935, -0.008741211146116257, 0.0010234490036964417, -0.01281993743032217, 0.01923799328505993, -0.06425110250711441, 0.0011217979481443763, 0.015615809708833694, -0.018249070271849632, -0.03293546661734581, -0.017241109162569046, -0.014046827331185341, -0.08822241425514221, -0.0003829340566881001, 0.012612268328666687, -0.016719341278076172, -0.06134219095110893, -0.014202767051756382, 0.01889248937368393, -0.01490048412233591, -0.012859178707003593, -0.01846557855606079, -0.060073357075452805, 0.04661233723163605, -0.009141664952039719, 0.026770778000354767, 0.017177799716591835, 0.0034997304901480675, 0.02205994352698326, -0.0662490501999855, 0.051173433661460876, 0.0008302688947878778, -0.010863164439797401, -0.047399185597896576, -0.012146837078034878, 0.005944391246885061, 0.009908574633300304, 0.03244560956954956, -0.007660382892936468, 0.010767709463834763, 0.062244705855846405, 0.05478042736649513, -0.014055521227419376, -0.060813117772340775, 0.01806826703250408, -0.0093140983954072, -0.02996574528515339, -0.03295162320137024, 0.0005995010142214596, 0.030045658349990845, 0.016981367021799088, -0.011442082934081554, -0.009193643927574158, -0.013140651397407055, 0.0011646089842543006, -0.039524439722299576, 0.049459122121334076, 0.014399285428225994, -0.029349369928240776, 0.04933139681816101, -0.017165038734674454, -0.017339495941996574, -0.01063241995871067, -0.013087458908557892, -0.028022145852446556, 0.010501636192202568, -0.028126074001193047, -0.043276097625494, -0.03976958245038986, -0.013924648053944111, -0.01169074047356844, -0.04239659756422043, 0.00014551902131643146, 0.04075644910335541, -0.05733288452029228, 0.023391876369714737, 0.05224364250898361, 0.004252488724887371, 0.027653200551867485, -0.015480569563806057, 0.023160263895988464, 0.004462984390556812, 0.0069339764304459095, 0.026259155943989754, 0.024505535140633583, -0.011152325198054314, -0.031443580985069275, -0.02214849554002285, -0.0009479841683059931, -0.017693892121315002, 0.0475022979080677, -0.007732835598289967, 0.02958082966506481, 0.0010675041703507304, -0.01142484787851572, 0.02909907139837742, -0.014244947582483292, 0.0054275719448924065, -0.02786315232515335, -0.02455948479473591, 0.06428654491901398, -0.02669602446258068, 0.004460460506379604, -0.02157449908554554, 0.02560514584183693, -0.0070672407746315, -0.004435050301253796, 0.004831640515476465, 0.03720618411898613, -0.018704107031226158, 0.002445341320708394, -0.010395235382020473, -0.00812181830406189, 0.030476372689008713, -0.08295338600873947, 0.019115854054689407, 0.028027379885315895, -0.003963358700275421, -0.008339584805071354, -0.013194000348448753, -0.01485645305365324, -0.051399122923612595, 0.008045763708651066, 0.008919132873415947, -0.015423737466335297, -0.013366371393203735, -0.017881890758872032, 0.009128281846642494, 0.04514622688293457, -0.04652981087565422, 0.009690320119261742, 0.006890810560435057, 0.028725620359182358, -0.02362886816263199, 0.045386191457509995 ]
<p>We have the following points:</p> <p>$$ (0,0)(1,51.8)(1.9,101.3)(2.8,148.4)(3.7,201.5)(4.7,251.1)(5.6,302.3)(6.6,350.9)(7.5,397.1)(8.5,452.5)(9.3,496.3)$$</p> <p>How can we find the best fitting line $y=ax$ through the points? My calculator has the option to find the best fitting line $y=ax+b$ through these points, which is:</p> <p>$$y = 53.28x + 0.37$$</p> <p>How can I find the best fitting $y=ax$? It seems to me we can't just remove the $0.37$ without compensating in the $a$?</p>
36,214
[ 0.003943263553082943, 0.027731668204069138, 0.010672223754227161, 0.019895218312740326, 0.009416374377906322, 0.04576801881194115, -0.0012563187628984451, -0.05921626463532448, 0.006085029803216457, 0.014539135619997978, 0.02426012232899666, 0.05022509768605232, 0.06693720817565918, 0.060410041362047195, 0.03538889065384865, 0.0020339195616543293, -0.029625078663229942, -0.008353183977305889, -0.015014861710369587, -0.04805845767259598, 0.00472008902579546, 0.007666928693652153, -0.0033335445914417505, -0.021054422482848167, -0.009661105461418629, 0.007352973334491253, 0.033569131046533585, -0.007022042293101549, 0.0015865694731473923, 0.06860306113958359, 0.006615258287638426, -0.042095791548490524, -0.006264766678214073, 0.04608852416276932, 0.013058776967227459, 0.01850111596286297, 0.00524489488452673, 0.00244048866443336, -0.016726115718483925, 0.043064333498477936, -0.02537453919649124, -0.022228213027119637, 0.005373135209083557, 0.020881788805127144, 0.009171775542199612, 0.031694941222667694, -0.007161951623857021, -0.04025280848145485, 0.028990982100367546, -0.010461103171110153, 0.08683847635984421, 0.008216985501348972, -0.00007119622023310512, 0.030102867633104324, -0.020800041034817696, -0.05097266286611557, 0.056910354644060135, 0.056455306708812714, -0.03964010998606682, -0.03884590417146683, 0.009256360121071339, -0.009002545848488808, 0.007793365977704525, 0.01400220301002264, -0.02929919771850109, 0.03233463317155838, -0.023356959223747253, -0.00517514580860734, 0.020177267491817474, -0.03129712492227554, -0.030550679191946983, 0.013318736106157303, 0.02506592869758606, -0.06515786796808243, -0.0019474918954074383, -0.04047982767224312, 0.030554084107279778, 0.059709928929805756, 0.061062105000019073, 0.03247437626123428, -0.010111745446920395, 0.025090910494327545, 0.052974168211221695, 0.027223514392971992, 0.0032734835986047983, -0.004056557547301054, 0.06666556745767593, -0.012814633548259735, 0.017424985766410828, 0.024941354990005493, 0.0027770481538027525, 0.013130242004990578, 0.03896420821547508, -0.017363227903842926, -0.011642497964203358, 0.04728076234459877, 0.00016839077579788864, 0.03010036237537861, 0.020051956176757812, -0.042291462421417236, -0.000024353686967515387, -0.04204283282160759, -0.034457094967365265, 0.03613467514514923, 0.029458917677402496, 0.015593224205076694, -0.026221150532364845, 0.032043326646089554, 0.033478617668151855, -0.00031702793785370886, -0.013844344764947891, 0.007223043125122786, 0.017354927957057953, 0.012824189849197865, 0.04533923417329788, -0.005095534957945347, -0.0028551325667649508, -0.03750236704945564, 0.026622429490089417, 0.03811324015259743, 0.04241328313946724, -0.036730628460645676, -0.005004300270229578, -0.007948322221636772, -0.04123007133603096, -0.022779377177357674, 0.01001587975770235, 0.012237283401191235, -0.026670537889003754, 0.011425619013607502, 0.0012137750163674355, -0.0018727838760241866, 0.04196295514702797, 0.01584182120859623, 0.02304588444530964, 0.020266389474272728, -0.07713949680328369, -0.06747731566429138, 0.029954450204968452, 0.0014416107442229986, 0.0012574298307299614, -0.04756929352879524, -0.01196733396500349, 0.04166644439101219, 0.06673320382833481, -0.009124834090471268, 0.009804658591747284, 0.010710525326430798, 0.01857607439160347, 0.006640126928687096, -0.013459861278533936, -0.008099487982690334, -0.00998538639396429, -0.06694421917200089, -0.019001802429556847, -0.06712451577186584, 0.01214277371764183, 0.013940886594355106, -0.009130588732659817, -0.05090680718421936, 0.019393576309084892, -0.01544963102787733, -0.06139632314443588, -0.0273112952709198, -0.005913897883147001, 0.011384744197130203, 0.06407427787780762, 0.007358247879892588, -0.03465980663895607, 0.03678896650671959, -0.022636739537119865, 0.05686335638165474, 0.0078821936622262, 0.009976965375244617, 0.029274748638272285, -0.03586998209357262, 0.012618979439139366, -0.027888014912605286, 0.007883751764893532, 0.041551221162080765, -0.029103919863700867, -0.04670010134577751, -0.0030907574109733105, 0.033240556716918945, 0.009259282611310482, 0.09587939828634262, 0.019377924501895905, -0.032219044864177704, 0.03369876742362976, -0.056178152561187744, -0.004747806116938591, -0.08688221126794815, -0.015707867220044136, 0.016905926167964935, -0.02222469076514244, -0.021390313282608986, 0.014492313377559185, -0.025943022221326828, -0.03710922226309776, -0.014125309884548187, 0.014194642193615437, 0.015415246598422527, 0.023657625541090965, -0.046188559383153915, 0.033028729259967804, 0.07733932137489319, 0.06968848407268524, -0.01103671733289957, 0.027009310200810432, -0.037384044378995895, 0.014045942574739456, 0.0025214888155460358, -0.034477800130844116, -0.006979010533541441, -0.019234582781791687, -0.028947584331035614, -0.029755596071481705, 0.011776754632592201, -0.004310603253543377, 0.026050135493278503, -0.04033980518579483, 0.06572854518890381, 0.054859459400177, 0.026124149560928345, 0.005314226262271404, 0.007134968880563974, -0.0038125135470181704, 0.04486243426799774, -0.015010314993560314, -0.0412323996424675, -0.054843977093696594, -0.001493138843216002, 0.010291396640241146, -0.015482665970921516, -0.06639909744262695, -0.0054329996928572655, 0.07630474120378494, -0.010305896401405334, 0.0009914749534800649, 0.032232385128736496, -0.009975205175578594, -0.002151007065549493, -0.00016527956177014858, 0.0008588562486693263, 0.004849250428378582, -0.011816692538559437, 0.0004902038490399718, 0.01064818724989891, 0.0013360026059672236, -0.005614422727376223, 0.02523973025381565, 0.03751368448138237, 0.02111501432955265, 0.010534674860537052, 0.004503603093326092, 0.006504566874355078, 0.029100893065333366, -0.03604670241475105, 0.005807631649076939, 0.04593935236334801, 0.003914887085556984, -0.042807113379240036, 0.02582681179046631, -0.001704811817035079, 0.005000639706850052, 0.025945695117115974, -0.038477830588817596, -0.010793422348797321, 0.03135683387517929, -0.0288045946508646, 0.03419210761785507, -0.06830042600631714, -0.017863191664218903, -0.03466768562793732, -0.012310370802879333, 0.0345827080309391, 0.055841993540525436, 0.0414760485291481, -0.015953058376908302, 0.005286501254886389, -0.01181907020509243, -0.04096490889787674, 0.03025893308222294, -0.0032830573618412018, -0.028164643794298172, -0.02428821660578251, -0.035765472799539566, -0.02179264836013317, 0.006044638343155384, 0.02492108941078186, 0.009714924730360508, -0.01023472473025322, -0.03982730582356453, -0.023885780945420265, -0.022449780255556107, -0.007397528737783432, 0.013602230697870255, -0.0026638503186404705, -0.0139539185911417, 0.04605962708592415, 0.02054036594927311, -0.020746933296322823, 0.004394005984067917, -0.02521403878927231, -0.013731569051742554, -0.017255820333957672, -0.025954950600862503, 0.0244063101708889, 0.030706290155649185, -0.0031091489363461733, -0.0242740698158741, 0.0037488180678337812, 0.035800594836473465, -0.04803723096847534, -0.04308493807911873, 0.016201810911297798, -0.02480332739651203, 0.013173865154385567, 0.013753033243119717, -0.01740485057234764, 0.05779895558953285, 0.039970189332962036, -0.052340079098939896, -0.0382116325199604, 0.05281257629394531, 0.008616385981440544, -0.0024495264515280724, -0.010453909635543823, 0.05437015742063522, -0.0016269010957330465, 0.03801611065864563, 0.0008499448304064572, 0.05762738734483719, 0.06068853661417961, 0.017320867627859116, 0.01963955909013748, -0.006886082235723734, -0.018102090805768967, 0.003311384003609419, -0.013452553190290928, 0.02082771807909012, -0.006054033059626818, 0.01411748118698597, -0.005080807488411665, -0.0010372060351073742, 0.022393397986888885, -0.032582417130470276, 0.003963507246226072, -0.008449321612715721, 0.022470882162451744, -0.01606210507452488, 0.008642131462693214, 0.005437436047941446, -0.01228734478354454, -0.029138457030057907, 0.03499780222773552, 0.03311486914753914, -0.02543058805167675, 0.012410958297550678, 0.057769518345594406, 0.01868562027812004, -0.024748999625444412, -0.0020226503256708384, -0.0030112445820122957, -0.024889826774597168, 0.029415111988782883, 0.006288040895015001, -0.051074620336294174, 0.03801769018173218, 0.05470848083496094, 0.006739082280546427, 0.014468972571194172, -0.013802454806864262, 0.02095343917608261, -0.07518156617879868, -0.031650982797145844, -0.004505890421569347, 0.05733237788081169, -0.022276276722550392, 0.017939889803528786, 0.02224123105406761, 0.0033305766992270947, -0.018085496500134468, 0.027843089774250984, -0.10108710080385208, 0.05602458864450455, 0.005259642843157053, -0.039915699511766434, -0.026363957673311234, -0.03129606321454048, 0.046957988291978836, -0.050011467188596725, 0.01350102387368679, -0.00008797582995612174, 0.016150984913110733, -0.03069748729467392, -0.015199500136077404, -0.021614043042063713, -0.01642041653394699, -0.025354158133268356, 0.032605256885290146, 0.035589318722486496, -0.05951525270938873, 0.03282884135842323, 0.04248339310288429, -0.031998153775930405, -0.006546082906424999, -0.009282618761062622, 0.01987752504646778, 0.01840444654226303, 0.056892238557338715, 0.0194711796939373, 0.03994026407599449, 0.0007846785010769963, 0.006315956357866526, -0.009167368523776531, 0.06407072395086288, 0.022365525364875793, -0.041017334908246994, -0.032578207552433014, -0.03322109952569008, -0.018874339759349823, -0.02715696021914482, 0.06976669281721115, -0.022121887654066086, -0.012393144890666008, 0.04235709086060524, 0.026294119656085968, -0.04388859495520592, 0.029633233323693275, 0.0679691806435585, -0.0013194357743486762, -0.011133809573948383, -0.02413923479616642, -0.04008472338318825, -0.01928415708243847, 0.010065557435154915, -0.0012255500769242644, 0.004345909226685762, 0.0069658877328038216, -0.03992098569869995, 0.0560779832303524, 0.03770710155367851, -0.028384007513523102, 0.03618745505809784, 0.030475463718175888, 0.029352495446801186, 0.003941898234188557, -0.023529406636953354, -0.01817757450044155, 0.03194449841976166, 0.04286709427833557, 0.004043652676045895, 0.006652369629591703, -0.09017808735370636, -0.03614882752299309, 0.024865005165338516, 0.0411999337375164, -0.019937392324209213, -0.011974234133958817, -0.047759875655174255, -0.03088722564280033, 0.06826546043157578, -0.0052282619290053844, 0.028941843658685684, -0.01162324845790863, -0.011282224208116531, -0.04147841036319733, -0.015930524095892906, -0.08979491144418716, 0.00945344939827919, -0.0174780935049057, 0.006134197115898132, -0.044327668845653534, -0.00962038803845644, -0.02522146701812744, 0.003301746677607298, 0.004179037641733885, 0.04922115057706833, 0.021550925448536873, -0.049772340804338455, 0.018521910533308983, 0.009005768224596977, -0.035945262759923935, -0.036572087556123734, -0.012664029374718666, 0.03616786375641823, -0.04002382606267929, 0.02733834832906723, 0.007299274206161499, -0.035434067249298096, 0.06074676662683487, 0.010792583227157593, 0.018515415489673615, 0.013239218853414059, -0.031335730105638504, 0.035484641790390015, 0.040607523173093796, 0.003466000547632575, 0.03522561118006706, 0.017705393955111504, -0.037198688834905624, -0.017253641039133072, -0.0388568677008152, 0.009954999200999737, 0.008542727679014206, -0.038356415927410126, -0.015012167394161224, -0.03014656901359558, -0.015494906343519688, 0.03426692634820938, -0.016337772831320763, 0.008583973161876202, -0.01000164169818163, 0.008186831139028072, 0.029208574444055557, 0.009149904362857342, -0.03108610212802887, 0.042386654764413834, 0.013113430701196194, 0.036950431764125824, 0.021339623257517815, -0.027934042736887932, 0.006777145434170961, 0.0018836926901713014, -0.0014351890422403812, 0.03339696303009987, -0.003397406777366996, 0.027122024446725845, -0.016914665699005127, -0.021619392558932304, -0.015598074533045292, -0.05466005578637123, 0.04102598875761032, -0.02597380429506302, 0.025897962972521782, 0.014583338052034378, -0.04047214612364769, -0.04934454336762428, -0.005753959063440561, -0.010208826512098312, 0.032980430871248245, -0.05637505650520325, 0.04971179738640785, -0.01812153309583664, 0.01373870950192213, -0.03850535675883293, -0.0168310534209013, 0.003876748727634549, 0.00011212547542527318, -0.048924755305051804, -0.010046418756246567, -0.011010688729584217, -0.016248861327767372, -0.00805414468050003, -0.04931662231683731, 0.009353061206638813, -0.034722648561000824, -0.040657758712768555, -0.004782124422490597, 0.04348818212747574, 0.05556763708591461, -0.006674817763268948, 0.018377728760242462, 0.04334346204996109, -0.016956331208348274, -0.012568685226142406, 0.027001697570085526, 0.018953194841742516, -0.035872720181941986, 0.010245466604828835, -0.009622100740671158, -0.0016563677927479148, 0.032718267291784286, 0.01256793923676014, -0.007395544555038214, -0.015358399599790573, 0.031309183686971664, -0.030090684071183205, -0.00480126217007637, 0.00041504716500639915, -0.017016353085637093, 0.004115932155400515, -0.0006037632119841874, 0.003831810550764203, 0.010217420756816864, -0.015084239654242992, 0.02759731002151966, -0.008223363198339939, -0.05050496384501457, -0.016218652948737144, 0.09154907613992691, -0.02638699859380722, -0.006421986036002636, -0.009611918590962887, -0.013723399490118027, 0.067978635430336, 0.02880300208926201, -0.03891231492161751, 0.006038430612534285, 0.03379356861114502, -0.019910087808966637, 0.0003163328510709107, -0.0454665869474411, 0.005347566679120064, 0.04797428101301193, -0.009765131399035454, 0.04047440364956856, 0.04767761006951332, 0.044518277049064636, -0.003254527458921075, -0.037984203547239304, -0.03276858106255531, -0.035077765583992004, 0.015651505440473557, 0.027714569121599197, -0.006783069111406803, -0.02362173981964588, 0.008238472044467926, 0.0032282548490911722, -0.009564772248268127, -0.008173121139407158, -0.030026132240891457, 0.03345758467912674, 0.012005708180367947, -0.013944562524557114, -0.0425899401307106, -0.018059920519590378, -0.004352845251560211, 0.0022067876998335123, -0.007852936163544655, -0.05010465532541275, 0.05099028721451759, 0.003390980651602149, 0.008691956289112568, -0.03851951286196709, -0.021418852731585503, -0.06144178286194801, -0.004682257771492004, -0.033804912120103836, -0.004617796279489994, 0.0447191447019577, 0.02492302656173706, 0.0373944528400898, -0.032682158052921295, 0.03376062586903572, -0.0512087382376194, -0.06016494706273079, -0.04034111648797989, -0.027279945090413094, -0.04408494755625725, 0.03416243940591812, 0.00866552535444498, -0.0568561889231205, 0.04929427057504654, -0.046718448400497437, 0.003808829467743635, -0.01350555568933487, 0.04637431725859642, -0.018071124330163002, 0.07140222191810608, -0.010650872252881527, 0.027677161619067192, -0.004230005666613579, 0.01187078282237053, 0.10185875743627548, 0.05960134044289589, 0.027468077838420868, -0.06205437332391739, 0.021616360172629356, -0.015429817140102386, -0.030343908816576004, -0.0467158704996109, 0.007594010792672634, 0.02899487502872944, 0.03344523906707764, 0.04799060523509979, 0.016988158226013184, -0.0055947802029550076, 0.013148337602615356, 0.044865019619464874, -0.04281925782561302, -0.0404907688498497, 0.03439798206090927, 0.010896244086325169, 0.03168616071343422, 0.016609037294983864, -0.05239330604672432, -0.01796685717999935, -0.01435418426990509, -0.024289416149258614, -0.027065064758062363, -0.012232261709868908, -0.017988117411732674, -0.024289445951581, -0.016353342682123184, 0.05038902908563614, 0.0349479615688324, -0.009215042926371098, -0.05118385702371597, 0.02850762940943241, 0.014963196590542793, -0.03215751051902771, -0.00846363790333271, 0.020616669207811356, -0.019006123766303062, -0.01145385205745697, -0.00865431409329176, 0.028089765459299088, -0.006715748924762011, -0.009430298581719398, -0.04071269929409027, 0.026231007650494576, -0.0009113172418437898, -0.03274374082684517, -0.0008685546345077455, 0.01240779273211956, 0.001674864673987031, -0.06031389907002449, -0.01454839576035738, 0.03242770582437515, 0.02903679944574833, 0.016044141724705696, -0.00012356738443486392, 0.003632518695667386, -0.009219338186085224, -0.02333521470427513, 0.0041595869697630405, 0.04690888151526451, 0.005967393051832914, -0.0011751322308555245, -0.012779302895069122, 0.06410905718803406, 0.03087472729384899, 0.0015047640772536397, 0.030062176287174225, -0.01624971255660057, 0.0010653558420017362, -0.04006246477365494, 0.021622123196721077, -0.0018755537457764149, 0.0188345517963171, 0.012589702382683754, 0.016340145841240883, -0.038258884102106094, -0.03880523890256882, 0.04073318466544151, -0.038000527769327164, 0.0032556531950831413, -0.041456807404756546, -0.020340314134955406, 0.007148359902203083, 0.050682708621025085, 0.040953878313302994, -0.02089984156191349, 0.015765266492962837, 0.05743887647986412, 0.028358925133943558, -0.021626489236950874, -0.03686489537358284, 0.0005416952189989388, -0.013715090230107307, 0.0046301293186843395, 0.01622849330306053, 0.09591097384691238, -0.002554059959948063, 0.01876608468592167, 0.010468988679349422, 0.033719856292009354, -0.0440133772790432, -0.006910082884132862, -0.01971323788166046, -0.03314613178372383, 0.03347272425889969, 0.03773750364780426, -0.0014415604528039694, -0.0491752028465271, 0.02047630213201046, -0.019577834755182266, -0.027734465897083282, 0.027772506698966026, 0.005362707190215588, -0.028451308608055115, 0.05675063654780388, -0.00465009082108736, -0.04532235115766525, -0.02291519194841385, 0.03169054165482521, -0.041748687624931335, -0.02453639730811119, -0.03484174981713295, -0.016233375295996666, -0.009471895173192024, 0.01131698489189148, -0.0013029937399551272, -0.007590757217258215, 0.05698796361684799, 0.033628929406404495, 0.008384901098906994, -0.014876832254230976, 0.029223769903182983, 0.036131445318460464, 0.06673061847686768, -0.029942024499177933, -0.015644198283553123, 0.03280270844697952, -0.041418638080358505, -0.006611492484807968, -0.009831768460571766, -0.024594297632575035, 0.02679370529949665, 0.019662773236632347, -0.02009773999452591, -0.012717990204691887, 0.04372991994023323, -0.014404195360839367, 0.003684061113744974, -0.05759042873978615, -0.0008504766155965626, 0.03281809017062187, 0.017015226185321808, -0.014626489020884037, -0.0270236786454916, -0.005305460654199123, 0.021920720115303993, 0.04750944674015045, -0.032642122358083725, 0.016450956463813782, 0.005951645318418741, 0.003555412869900465, 0.025881322100758553, 0.015311943367123604, 0.001113966223783791, 0.036858752369880676, 0.01409712340682745, -0.020218443125486374, 0.008624994195997715, 0.011428664438426495, 0.018270393833518028, -0.06345650553703308, -0.00567264948040247, -0.028202414512634277, 0.016854792833328247, 0.03231918439269066, -0.03757539391517639, 0.036218851804733276, 0.03584148362278938, -0.017865879461169243, 0.018442368134856224, -0.01902834326028824, 0.01917438954114914, -0.04607698693871498, -0.0026371823623776436, -0.03758596256375313, 0.052272673696279526, 0.07001715898513794, 0.0480705127120018, 0.024952175095677376, -0.004040397237986326, -0.021252775564789772, -0.054674867540597916, 0.04228967800736427, 0.022092631086707115, -0.014632616192102432, -0.06110731139779091, 0.024946721270680428, -0.02794722095131874, -0.0313977487385273, 0.026811467483639717, -0.02107389084994793, 0.038071513175964355, 0.02468939498066902, -0.0025119094643741846, 0.0019956333562731743, 0.03440476581454277, 0.037826042622327805, 0.01181808765977621, -0.015781844034790993, 0.0014159410493448377, 0.0055219982750713825, 0.038833752274513245, 0.011304507963359356, 0.04320762678980827, 0.02035437896847725, 0.008677709847688675, -0.06973323225975037, -0.029830122366547585, 0.0018058953573927283, 0.028515145182609558, 0.013694475404918194, 0.005459097679704428, 0.01804187148809433, -0.054901473224163055, -0.035036951303482056, 0.009083122946321964, 0.044627245515584946, 0.05123656243085861, 0.01547706127166748, -0.01482680905610323, -0.009144093841314316, -0.03213327378034592, -0.03569653257727623, 0.002606328809633851, -0.01438318844884634, 0.02323872223496437, -0.050265055149793625, -0.016994183883070946, 0.0034388150088489056, -0.05917155742645264, -0.026195906102657318, -0.011434909887611866, -0.024135690182447433, 0.03457259759306908, -0.01969306170940399, -0.023211898282170296, 0.01609611324965954, 0.001289921929128468, -0.007886272855103016, -0.10295184701681137, 0.055831026285886765, 0.005639114882797003, -0.03383709490299225, -0.022278357297182083, -0.00488796504214406, -0.0022897517774254084, 0.0010359102161601186, 0.048718634992837906, -0.004927695728838444, 0.023838208988308907, 0.02085641399025917, 0.017675695940852165, 0.042788080871105194, -0.008306759409606457, 0.04244630038738251, 0.002168565057218075, -0.0027319875080138445, -0.001858219038695097, -0.012424968183040619, 0.004730713088065386, -0.0038438423071056604, 0.0076583391055464745, 0.007453493308275938, 0.03856544941663742, 0.016036218032240868, -0.005790041293948889, 0.0033081185538321733, 0.0013569450238719583, -0.001672015176154673, 0.056024376302957535, 0.035781580954790115, -0.0005398537614382803, 0.051200591027736664, -0.028953729197382927, -0.06905362010002136, 0.0005435770144686103, -0.0384976863861084, -0.031950607895851135, -0.030777763575315475, -0.012066897936165333, -0.0075400276109576225, -0.058326784521341324, 0.012364723719656467, 0.03406111150979996, -0.04470319300889969, -0.06288730353116989, 0.011244678869843483, 0.001845829887315631, 0.02951834723353386, -0.010252109728753567, 0.022255489602684975, -0.004569984041154385, -0.0402575246989727, 0.014959112741053104, -0.021007485687732697, 0.026534168049693108, 0.025102848187088966, 0.013589117676019669, 0.014416808262467384, 0.012514669448137283, 0.014706926420331001, -0.017775528132915497, 0.052089132368564606, -0.010007732547819614, -0.006092248950153589, 0.008440718986093998, -0.044388458132743835, 0.005262935068458319, 0.006546645425260067, -0.03128591552376747, 0.0903879851102829, -0.05305888131260872, 0.010821300558745861, -0.03726588562130928, -0.02059270441532135, -0.010727260261774063, -0.0000945969222811982, -0.01570020243525505, -0.02657095529139042, -0.0008956005913205445, -0.016261082142591476, 0.023302409797906876, -0.009112805128097534, 0.028004243969917297, 0.010027211159467697, 0.004724473692476749, -0.02347850240767002, -0.020579248666763306, -0.013904038816690445, -0.014198316261172295, -0.01243937574326992, -0.02609383501112461, 0.028774471953511238, 0.05922245234251022, -0.011133607476949692, -0.018473122268915176, -0.006162535399198532, -0.055480457842350006, 0.06304804980754852, -0.08487076312303543, -0.029547391459345818, -0.033792536705732346, -0.02182791754603386, -0.0011498735984787345, -0.0253708865493536 ]
<p>I am currently running some analyses on a linguistic data set with a mixed effect model. The problem is, I think that one random factor should be excluded while my colleague thinks it should be included. The two options are:</p> <pre><code>lmer(intdiff ~ stress * vowel_group + (1|speaker) + (1|word), data) lmer(intdiff ~ stress * vowel_group + (1|speaker), data) </code></pre> <p>How do we check which model best fits our data set? It was suggested that I use a likelihood ratio test, but as far as I can tell, there isn't a function in R that can be applied to 2 linear mixed effects models. Is there another way to tell which model is more predictive?</p> <p>Thanks</p>
73,745
[ -0.03715730831027031, -0.008417809382081032, -0.02841014415025711, -0.02548036351799965, -0.0018305963603779674, 0.023325206711888313, 0.012576477602124214, 0.0006749090389348567, 0.04680389538407326, -0.006938891019672155, 0.03252563998103142, 0.057650767266750336, 0.1079537570476532, 0.034208256751298904, 0.008820041082799435, -0.0154013866558671, 0.014066135510802269, -0.012252668850123882, -0.018489044159650803, 0.0071220360696315765, -0.04749106615781784, -0.009488552808761597, 0.008604040369391441, -0.013644753955304623, -0.017882399260997772, 0.055411193519830704, 0.044872626662254333, -0.02416369691491127, 0.044385574758052826, 0.02967909350991249, -0.020084407180547714, -0.06417451053857803, 0.012290491722524166, 0.021575648337602615, 0.002209796104580164, -0.011688923463225365, -0.005455799400806427, -0.010299771092832088, -0.03408457338809967, 0.04432763531804085, -0.02637283317744732, 0.00463577127084136, 0.011406458914279938, 0.028147580102086067, -0.011783303692936897, 0.03548852726817131, 0.007072399836033583, -0.006222844123840332, 0.045084383338689804, -0.018157824873924255, 0.06775104254484177, -0.012126138433814049, 0.017913511022925377, 0.02379995584487915, 0.023965999484062195, 0.008050511591136456, 0.06038703769445419, 0.07554230093955994, 0.009185857139527798, -0.04474342614412308, -0.03130020573735237, -0.025021536275744438, -0.013514510355889797, 0.01779787801206112, -0.01741979829967022, 0.008695359341800213, 0.03452649340033531, -0.022756990045309067, 0.05143742263317108, -0.004997636657208204, 0.027919797226786613, -0.043682441115379333, 0.05248573422431946, -0.016262473538517952, 0.023024294525384903, -0.014592964202165604, 0.02795851044356823, 0.02775503136217594, 0.024861082434654236, 0.03675539046525955, -0.0062732272781431675, 0.01993318274617195, -0.006776231806725264, 0.04657074809074402, 0.004314417019486427, -0.03141717240214348, 0.043559055775403976, -0.01742897555232048, -0.017503710463643074, 0.04260138422250748, -0.04386952891945839, -0.005804203916341066, 0.05885109677910805, 0.03222879767417908, -0.07462896406650543, 0.024569861590862274, 0.008611341938376427, 0.04445352405309677, 0.017966976389288902, 0.0026668414939194918, -0.03330254182219505, -0.0476970337331295, 0.024093925952911377, 0.06111351028084755, -0.004043158609420061, 0.035255759954452515, -0.0250877533107996, -0.0026015164330601692, -0.03414478898048401, 0.0023175326641649008, -0.016457227990031242, 0.04048973321914673, -0.010518058203160763, 0.00009154799772659317, 0.011969789862632751, -0.0067909229546785355, -0.013895891606807709, -0.019236458465456963, 0.07845444977283478, 0.07517991214990616, 0.026228992268443108, -0.022029530256986618, 0.02690860442817211, -0.013044248335063457, -0.037763942033052444, -0.004797779023647308, -0.004834089428186417, -0.00027946679620072246, -0.04394011199474335, 0.08510727435350418, 0.00012751387839671224, -0.015631170943379402, 0.028464483097195625, 0.017333658412098885, 0.019546566531062126, -0.009640390053391457, -0.08865701407194138, -0.03838068246841431, 0.014394080266356468, -0.03867795690894127, 0.03804672509431839, -0.062162067741155624, -0.0157137643545866, 0.003825172781944275, 0.07768765836954117, 0.011245684698224068, 0.06745096296072006, 0.0030123102478682995, 0.0028062460478395224, 0.002017279388383031, -0.04832347109913826, -0.03220865875482559, -0.041108760982751846, -0.02154179848730564, -0.040014613419771194, -0.0895312950015068, -0.0004976129275746644, 0.011017438024282455, -0.041809119284152985, 0.012330656871199608, 0.027279920876026154, 0.0015429951017722487, -0.013262568041682243, -0.011292647570371628, 0.04923798143863678, -0.01430978998541832, 0.06789176166057587, -0.016276415437459946, 0.027530452236533165, 0.0035347663797438145, -0.0014310141559690237, 0.01915552467107773, 0.021791353821754456, 0.015186636708676815, 0.06778096407651901, -0.012784122489392757, 0.01834460161626339, 0.0005673489067703485, 0.029836483299732208, 0.02654320001602173, -0.026828916743397713, 0.013363626785576344, -0.0186301339417696, -0.04476815089583397, -0.00192750443238765, 0.054050810635089874, 0.02272694557905197, -0.018012262880802155, 0.06025861203670502, -0.016529753804206848, -0.05270276591181755, -0.05723696947097778, -0.015824085101485252, 0.019132385030388832, -0.021379349753260612, 0.05405990034341812, 0.009172623045742512, 0.059234369546175, -0.01499598566442728, 0.010926080867648125, -0.048301734030246735, -0.036737557500600815, 0.02168538048863411, -0.006276406347751617, 0.003946784418076277, 0.015201618894934654, 0.02849588915705681, -0.018047312274575233, 0.02617800049483776, 0.003257135394960642, -0.07076776027679443, 0.024644263088703156, -0.02082337811589241, -0.001304137404076755, -0.009167389012873173, -0.036112383008003235, 0.014249551109969616, 0.019893113523721695, -0.011832538060843945, 0.018978046253323555, -0.053844988346099854, 0.03244858980178833, 0.028665121644735336, -0.008270775899291039, 0.009402580559253693, 0.01851123571395874, 0.026052337139844894, 0.020173676311969757, -0.013776995241641998, 0.003984848968684673, -0.023377835750579834, -0.027296146377921104, 0.06286488473415375, -0.018768904730677605, -0.032340701669454575, 0.04241126403212547, 0.04462011903524399, -0.024039560928940773, 0.008391739800572395, 0.04609689489006996, -0.003983993083238602, -0.011663161218166351, 0.0037194001488387585, 0.040564507246017456, 0.006024559959769249, 0.008737942203879356, 0.042557038366794586, -0.039024531841278076, 0.02537318877875805, -0.018267346546053886, -0.01638861745595932, 0.07315675914287567, 0.04556151479482651, 0.03547246381640434, -0.031223606318235397, -0.023931922391057014, 0.018457554280757904, -0.013186110183596611, 0.013100937008857727, 0.0349368192255497, -0.0017451869789510965, -0.042495738714933395, 0.024698777124285698, 0.0029907128773629665, 0.0013989782892167568, 0.021707549691200256, -0.027478192001581192, 0.011692334897816181, 0.021901972591876984, -0.04282026365399361, 0.014011288061738014, -0.01604987308382988, -0.020143425092101097, -0.07514901459217072, 0.012210864573717117, 0.04621141403913498, -0.015153094194829464, 0.048215121030807495, -0.011737091466784477, -0.018113350495696068, 0.017331860959529877, -0.04104190692305565, 0.01820099726319313, -0.043537020683288574, -0.02854485809803009, -0.001645834418013692, -0.0347023531794548, -0.00007794854900566861, 0.01852523535490036, 0.01040920615196228, -0.01795990578830242, 0.04242217540740967, -0.01769605465233326, -0.06552118808031082, -0.030779920518398285, -0.021663837134838104, 0.0387263223528862, 0.01729518547654152, -0.05353131145238876, 0.015360645018517971, 0.0293935127556324, -0.04316214099526405, -0.017379816621541977, -0.05444600433111191, -0.003742814529687166, -0.009550660848617554, -0.028863904997706413, 0.004169865045696497, 0.00801040418446064, 0.01722330041229725, -0.0029693315736949444, -0.02440771460533142, -0.032344650477170944, -0.08502635359764099, -0.0576484389603138, 0.034008581191301346, -0.005776238162070513, 0.03034226782619953, 0.005643914453685284, -0.0214135330170393, 0.05690782144665718, 0.03670666739344597, -0.020594768226146698, -0.05423606559634209, -0.023317517712712288, -0.026807865127921104, -0.012252223677933216, 0.016510743647813797, 0.015463965013623238, 0.020295873284339905, 0.05112094432115555, -0.006725751794874668, -0.0027578379958868027, 0.026038875803351402, 0.02336568385362625, -0.01581236906349659, 0.012560326606035233, -0.0049657258205115795, -0.04663539305329323, 0.052018389105796814, 0.02824724279344082, 0.011333850212395191, 0.04316575080156326, -0.04064255952835083, 0.016731545329093933, 0.0010827153455466032, -0.03277655690908432, -0.010790590196847916, -0.033694375306367874, 0.0016165554989129305, -0.024590972810983658, 0.004037997219711542, 0.012989440001547337, -0.041396159678697586, 0.04683961346745491, -0.014076046645641327, 0.045504890382289886, -0.006157372146844864, -0.013313286937773228, 0.03353339433670044, 0.03890450298786163, -0.0019382350146770477, 0.0012754542985931039, -0.0251349825412035, 0.008069031871855259, 0.03459244221448898, -0.03189625218510628, -0.007913172245025635, 0.024866066873073578, 0.013343860395252705, 0.021692220121622086, -0.01699412427842617, -0.05363959074020386, -0.0019130401778966188, -0.07032150030136108, 0.035455070436000824, 0.003002622863277793, 0.05956331640481949, 0.0021878660190850496, 0.02535538747906685, 0.025005370378494263, -0.022094905376434326, 0.020065488293766975, -0.0277915820479393, -0.05247371271252632, 0.05049166828393936, -0.014747999608516693, -0.005503999534994364, -0.002419368363916874, -0.01603592559695244, 0.0012969528324902058, -0.026172654703259468, -0.024285754188895226, -0.008941303938627243, 0.03152022883296013, -0.021490760147571564, 0.01691366918385029, -0.05054071173071861, -0.028752438724040985, -0.005059915129095316, 0.01680334098637104, 0.011730395257472992, -0.003619763068854809, -0.006849085446447134, 0.05106927081942558, -0.004017460625618696, -0.03139745444059372, 0.006767456419765949, -0.0280939731746912, 0.007146134041249752, 0.04803549870848656, 0.02042856253683567, 0.0016679761465638876, -0.030329056084156036, 0.03959367796778679, 0.024029213935136795, 0.045428257435560226, 0.03268435597419739, 0.016151631250977516, -0.010106043890118599, -0.025602862238883972, -0.010514901019632816, -0.029094882309436798, 0.009377210400998592, 0.00489252433180809, -0.0009938377188518643, 0.04081219807267189, 0.030172718688845634, -0.007800889201462269, -0.005429439712315798, 0.04931841418147087, 0.04070566967129707, 0.004100011195987463, -0.030700279399752617, 0.038018785417079926, 0.016002019867300987, -0.02321304753422737, 0.03255068510770798, 0.015420215204358101, 0.01904960721731186, -0.0047674826346337795, 0.02835715189576149, -0.028598347678780556, -0.03409266471862793, 0.00785865169018507, 0.04184447228908539, 0.02286488749086857, 0.011314467526972294, -0.05777721479535103, 0.01475548930466175, 0.03584710508584976, 0.012060018256306648, 0.026242364197969437, -0.00650775944814086, -0.0894794762134552, 0.017630314454436302, 0.062237657606601715, 0.04803192988038063, -0.06170335412025452, -0.013116310350596905, -0.04215281829237938, -0.017116889357566833, -0.005306794308125973, 0.003014128655195236, 0.0008657066500745714, -0.0008544778102077544, 0.028157809749245644, -0.011457460932433605, -0.0218378696590662, -0.04833150655031204, 0.015180783346295357, 0.012387408874928951, 0.008485519327223301, 0.001063467701897025, -0.0513874776661396, -0.013093849644064903, 0.010312969796359539, 0.017983561381697655, 0.04127208888530731, -0.033177852630615234, 0.008341828361153603, 0.0553738996386528, 0.02043825201690197, -0.030110351741313934, -0.04645928740501404, 0.021453801542520523, -0.006521887611597776, 0.004327546805143356, 0.0435371957719326, -0.02405034378170967, -0.028627753257751465, 0.02913467399775982, 0.0050595966167747974, -0.015498253516852856, -0.015295597724616528, 0.003090817015618086, 0.03154582902789116, 0.03349703550338745, 0.025238847360014915, 0.055599503219127655, -0.00407605292275548, 0.035538021475076675, 0.0034612526651471853, -0.03822096064686775, -0.018393106758594513, -0.04829016327857971, -0.029569145292043686, -0.06889064610004425, -0.007446848321706057, -0.04196576029062271, 0.03480799123644829, 0.008483419194817543, 0.0330810546875, -0.028329582884907722, -0.011655849404633045, 0.002043388318270445, 0.022409284487366676, -0.02830786257982254, -0.022135520353913307, 0.01589241810142994, 0.00018932163948193192, -0.024931127205491066, 0.00673290528357029, 0.0375741645693779, -0.028971901163458824, 0.0025441322941333055, 0.011712787672877312, -0.031151335686445236, 0.024479355663061142, 0.022766949608922005, -0.04309254139661789, 0.02336995117366314, -0.010607819072902203, 0.02734343148767948, 0.0030724485404789448, 0.05201573297381401, -0.015602360479533672, -0.018031764775514603, 0.026748981326818466, 0.03892805427312851, -0.02299141138792038, 0.04577377438545227, -0.01755366101861, 0.032802432775497437, -0.03017372079193592, -0.026568422093987465, -0.08361493051052094, -0.041773829609155655, -0.006476451177150011, -0.0008805412799119949, -0.024069203063845634, -0.07030399888753891, -0.006032857578247786, -0.057442691177129745, 0.003461476182565093, -0.013933616690337658, 0.06501340121030807, -0.010773636400699615, 0.009390261024236679, -0.002111981390044093, 0.019216805696487427, 0.07493466138839722, 0.015490341931581497, -0.008520613424479961, 0.04656647890806198, -0.011424102820456028, 0.009920045733451843, -0.0038444455713033676, -0.005979490932077169, -0.046091049909591675, 0.011138733476400375, -0.04413842037320137, 0.004060755483806133, 0.03717060387134552, -0.02279859595000744, 0.008168146014213562, 0.02967824600636959, 0.0038884442765265703, 0.01077239029109478, -0.06456253677606583, -0.006168916821479797, -0.03312486410140991, 0.015388865023851395, -0.029891330748796463, 0.0523616187274456, -0.033234912902116776, -0.014103754423558712, 0.01600809395313263, -0.02328117936849594, -0.02472776547074318, -0.0054924748837947845, 0.07595085352659225, -0.005456582177430391, 0.012112502008676529, 0.00163161417003721, 0.003075571032240987, 0.028244316577911377, -0.008701828308403492, 0.043334342539310455, -0.0016146883135661483, 0.032854434102773666, -0.04097495973110199, -0.02344311960041523, -0.027854079380631447, -0.020565887913107872, 0.07321444153785706, 0.0018838158575817943, 0.038714244961738586, 0.08017007261514664, -0.010782625526189804, -0.006296213250607252, -0.017215561121702194, -0.041805997490882874, -0.0041144597344100475, -0.0006504819612018764, 0.0689174085855484, -0.026390522718429565, 0.016177082434296608, 0.031016957014799118, -0.011521618813276291, 0.05258524417877197, 0.05922187864780426, 0.009464913047850132, 0.04889217019081116, 0.0520813874900341, -0.017863178625702858, -0.029438737779855728, 0.014037013053894043, -0.0580749437212944, 0.02799372561275959, -0.016064850613474846, -0.013660380616784096, 0.048380449414253235, 0.08720482885837555, -0.01073029451072216, -0.07173129916191101, -0.007897735573351383, -0.027072397992014885, 0.01563713140785694, 0.023704780265688896, -0.03074110671877861, 0.04395434260368347, -0.011592205613851547, 0.0452006496489048, 0.02024703659117222, 0.03066088631749153, -0.023205334320664406, -0.10538556426763535, -0.003258657641708851, 0.0001866466336650774, 0.004687193781137466, 0.005575316958129406, -0.004835932515561581, -0.047741733491420746, 0.0053521813824772835, -0.03667326271533966, 0.007940543815493584, -0.02677762135863304, 0.019537555053830147, 0.006901419255882502, 0.02931893616914749, -0.006868291646242142, 0.03184372931718826, 0.00038508293800987303, 0.008833639323711395, 0.12795625627040863, 0.07172287255525589, 0.06078137457370758, -0.07405462116003036, 0.033467113971710205, 0.025910692289471626, -0.004287608899176121, -0.027689434587955475, 0.01327443215996027, 0.025779400020837784, 0.007985981181263924, 0.058672767132520676, 0.02739201858639717, 0.010251347906887531, -0.02534339390695095, 0.025332089513540268, -0.035912737250328064, -0.028759421780705452, 0.0030183903872966766, 0.001485322485677898, 0.0018824652070179582, -0.04589317739009857, -0.038642849773168564, 0.025566723197698593, 0.006119986064732075, 0.003525061532855034, -0.024627255275845528, -0.007577705662697554, 0.017261922359466553, 0.03716091439127922, -0.008560222573578358, 0.020723868161439896, 0.012745111249387264, 0.020652426406741142, 0.0327858030796051, -0.03559369966387749, 0.01695512793958187, -0.01288877334445715, 0.009688814170658588, 0.036613911390304565, -0.013809995725750923, -0.013259604573249817, -0.01129450649023056, 0.012813347391784191, -0.033489394932985306, -0.037430889904499054, -0.029057882726192474, 0.04651927202939987, 0.01739768497645855, -0.006675084587186575, 0.001668530865572393, 0.035818278789520264, 0.005151298362761736, -0.02573103830218315, -0.03267906978726387, 0.013196068815886974, 0.022600572556257248, 0.013035262934863567, -0.02536989003419876, -0.035770148038864136, 0.03117966651916504, 0.0016162486281245947, 0.0008139605633914471, 0.031880348920822144, -0.014969248324632645, -0.010565982200205326, -0.0183132141828537, 0.04124027490615845, 0.016031157225370407, 0.004621540661901236, 0.001987278228625655, -0.02414172887802124, -0.04651996120810509, 0.005359459202736616, 0.04184111952781677, 0.04663272202014923, 0.02669616974890232, -0.03834383562207222, -0.019388657063245773, -0.03497317060828209, -0.0170521829277277, 0.011857730336487293, 0.005417382810264826, -0.0552862212061882, -0.010942797176539898, 0.008627715520560741, 0.018567193299531937, 0.022061044350266457, -0.013034948147833347, -0.04455992951989174, 0.018200712278485298, 0.0110067930072546, -0.010115674696862698, -0.07380480319261551, -0.02849934808909893, -0.008943491615355015, -0.010088843293488026, -0.002734254812821746, -0.021806756034493446, 0.04685232788324356, -0.00027363805565983057, 0.027951234951615334, 0.0014873731415718794, 0.053919389843940735, -0.037297219038009644, 0.003102276474237442, 0.014007083140313625, -0.041555341333150864, -0.03772318735718727, -0.01453496515750885, -0.025373144075274467, -0.03093693032860756, -0.009924443438649178, -0.026542773470282555, -0.025441408157348633, 0.03143558278679848, -0.021059466525912285, -0.0649251788854599, 0.0020743876229971647, 0.024447912350296974, 0.01302003487944603, -0.026723265647888184, 0.012418489903211594, -0.018719356507062912, -0.054982446134090424, 0.018382949754595757, -0.018125733360648155, 0.0015261613298207521, 0.0037354023661464453, -0.007027341518551111, -0.01736406981945038, -0.01110740564763546, 0.001655008178204298, 0.008349367417395115, -0.021506695076823235, 0.03935357928276062, -0.024521922692656517, 0.05194447562098503, -0.0038219643756747246, 0.014629806391894817, -0.005719360429793596, -0.05785376951098442, -0.01390423346310854, -0.003124948823824525, -0.0016391454264521599, 0.00866422988474369, -0.002435765927657485, 0.029736502096056938, 0.004958022385835648, 0.04396020993590355, -0.0194114800542593, -0.044613536447286606, -0.03888902813196182, -0.008056486956775188, 0.014259482733905315, -0.027731886133551598, -0.018360473215579987, 0.033225830644369125, -0.007162346504628658, 0.03829086944460869, 0.0376194603741169, 0.003351096296682954, -0.006536166183650494, 0.0010571802267804742, -0.020964041352272034, 0.06422058492898941, 0.006139970384538174, -0.022855350747704506, 0.003048152197152376, 0.0437360554933548, -0.020013699308037758, 0.030498266220092773, 0.005617957562208176, -0.010297230444848537, -0.07161159068346024, -0.04385573789477348, 0.004624534863978624, 0.013789522461593151, 0.0053360359743237495, -0.02681065909564495, 0.027476735413074493, 0.03846932575106621, -0.012530449777841568, -0.048241741955280304, 0.019546743482351303, 0.017183499410748482, -0.029943568632006645, 0.0005331822903826833, -0.03485375642776489, -0.004911778494715691, -0.008963464759290218, 0.025574328377842903, 0.02811335399746895, 0.03205276280641556, 0.02154667116701603, -0.029028411954641342, -0.008848012425005436, -0.009857205674052238, 0.035480838268995285, -0.03947136923670769, 0.05253058671951294, -0.024635806679725647, -0.04619079455733299, 0.016642196103930473, 0.00979576911777258, 0.05635170638561249, 0.002151981694623828, 0.016203049570322037, 0.021577034145593643, 0.023087909445166588, 0.03618745878338814, -0.037599001079797745, -0.012205210514366627, 0.005930318497121334, -0.003118174383416772, 0.025697434321045876, -0.04151950776576996, -0.019451327621936798, -0.022736862301826477, -0.007564366329461336, -0.01662975177168846, 0.007196497172117233, -0.011998995207250118, -0.031577806919813156, -0.03161173313856125, -0.02660772018134594, -0.03159426525235176, -0.0384383350610733, -0.013755685649812222, -0.030346782878041267, 0.026492180302739143, 0.05372832715511322, 0.049898967146873474, -0.03173426166176796, 0.01609775237739086, -0.024891793727874756, -0.04441124200820923, -0.008505876176059246, -0.00956407655030489, -0.007598043419420719, -0.06281702220439911, -0.009644483216106892, -0.014907793141901493, -0.0002221764880232513, -0.059058431535959244, 0.018976429477334023, -0.03526400029659271, 0.026502367109060287, -0.042369544506073, 0.005593165289610624, -0.0043517048470675945, -0.010626177303493023, 0.019131282344460487, -0.06845193356275558, 0.0699513629078865, 0.0014373287558555603, 0.024490557610988617, -0.03679890185594559, -0.0021760310046374798, -0.034613627940416336, 0.029706597328186035, 0.048487767577171326, 0.03802759572863579, 0.004995828028768301, 0.013950723223388195, 0.03555529564619064, -0.017824238166213036, -0.04612394794821739, 0.03342895582318306, 0.002311691176146269, 0.008800613693892956, -0.020289629697799683, -0.0227331705391407, -0.001965329283848405, -0.010543555952608585, 0.013912458904087543, -0.001923273433931172, 0.006850196048617363, -0.0006028360221534967, -0.00514040095731616, 0.03689846023917198, 0.01877412758767605, 0.013355343602597713, 0.01982870325446129, -0.009411584585905075, 0.006986820604652166, -0.0026331671979278326, -0.0008411729941144586, -0.03068770468235016, 0.08347401022911072, -0.013508778065443039, -0.029495038092136383, 0.007339215837419033, 0.02297418750822544, 0.017591480165719986, -0.03739325329661369, 0.011606033891439438, 0.0195950698107481, -0.051082052290439606, -0.00447493139654398, -0.02014121226966381, -0.005391059909015894, 0.0481860525906086, 0.004335528239607811, 0.012443634681403637, -0.006033352576196194, -0.011902634054422379, 0.0032312350813299417, -0.017676327377557755, 0.035450279712677, 0.0005279164761304855, -0.016357844695448875, 0.012814490124583244, -0.03935718908905983, 0.036479271948337555, -0.014398805797100067, 0.05685150623321533, -0.029261412099003792, -0.025690264999866486, 0.0318397618830204, 0.011271579191088676, 0.011788900010287762, -0.02581418864428997, -0.021790562197566032, 0.05360917001962662, -0.07342778891324997, 0.02008206397294998, -0.07090974599123001, -0.020344741642475128, 0.00655632046982646, 0.0010839515598490834, 0.02223985269665718, 0.00015385837468784302, 0.030233385041356087, 0.013597746379673481, -0.021530264988541603, -0.03197014331817627, 0.039393000304698944, -0.004365067463368177, -0.01619424670934677, -0.02627931535243988, -0.01762481965124607, -0.02070656418800354, -0.014456185512244701, -0.03546855226159096, -0.017307326197624207, 0.0434953048825264, 0.05248844623565674, 0.04154057428240776, -0.06197867915034294, -0.04902133345603943, 0.007920133881270885, 0.0221866425126791, -0.03361009806394577, -0.018001969903707504, -0.04703496769070625, 0.014219721779227257, 0.010473703034222126, -0.00011194509716005996 ]
<p>I have samples from two groups. Samples from each group follow a Dirichlet distribution. The two Dirichlet distributions have the same mean but different precision. How to find the MLE of mean and two precisions?</p>
30,246
[ -0.014872333034873009, 0.016221320256590843, -0.0128064239397645, -0.01271867286413908, 0.03549304977059364, 0.014526983723044395, -0.01185869425535202, -0.01771577075123787, 0.014642750844359398, -0.009035175666213036, 0.04367896914482117, 0.003607963677495718, 0.04794708639383316, 0.008371629752218723, 0.04059158265590668, 0.012263812124729156, -0.022194163873791695, 0.018331827595829964, 0.0000972649286268279, -0.029239187017083168, -0.0068869502283632755, -0.003162866225466132, 0.022247454151511192, -0.03000253438949585, -0.01732616312801838, -0.004480151925235987, 0.0724778026342392, -0.0025542587973177433, -0.019527960568666458, 0.04689474403858185, -0.06515781581401825, -0.024071546271443367, 0.02405986376106739, 0.044227391481399536, -0.005044779274612665, -0.0030051323119550943, -0.04235502704977989, -0.019706381484866142, -0.03386126458644867, 0.04596642032265663, -0.05279975011944771, 0.007688229903578758, 0.0012532019754871726, 0.006107130087912083, -0.02342091128230095, 0.02198472060263157, 0.0004865725932177156, -0.05006294697523117, 0.032949287444353104, -0.02044655755162239, 0.07570410519838333, 0.01893201470375061, 0.05489481985569, -0.005351281724870205, -0.03578217700123787, 0.010637846775352955, 0.013156627304852009, 0.08918234705924988, 0.02416905201971531, -0.04157598316669464, -0.044041022658348083, -0.028947193175554276, 0.05161432921886444, -0.03411661088466644, -0.04964786767959595, 0.027864431962370872, -0.01571078598499298, -0.025211546570062637, -0.01091934647411108, -0.0015852960059419274, 0.04048670455813408, 0.04328078776597977, 0.041348040103912354, -0.02952190488576889, 0.03600995987653732, -0.03158388286828995, 0.013649655506014824, 0.04782203957438469, 0.03854873403906822, 0.012363895773887634, 0.014647702686488628, 0.010847208090126514, 0.03422635793685913, 0.03657747060060501, 0.016532504931092262, -0.01814975030720234, 0.058740634471178055, 0.03473930060863495, -0.0018553960835561156, 0.015517706982791424, -0.05600442737340927, -0.009105321019887924, 0.04478286951780319, -0.01432983111590147, -0.0135884340852499, 0.022697290405631065, -0.041680626571178436, 0.03129557892680168, 0.011761072091758251, -0.02373487688601017, 0.02591034583747387, -0.05889111012220383, 0.02275300770998001, 0.09953165799379349, -0.02209164947271347, 0.001313848770223558, -0.012916669249534607, -0.03322192654013634, -0.03298347815871239, -0.0038986983709037304, 0.02413630485534668, 0.001423622714355588, 0.010280903428792953, -0.011453838087618351, 0.02676788717508316, 0.05420227721333504, -0.029773669317364693, -0.032125331461429596, 0.06818139553070068, 0.039651867002248764, 0.04316060245037079, -0.027793269604444504, 0.014858213253319263, -0.023440495133399963, -0.041606079787015915, 0.039594296365976334, 0.02775278501212597, -0.013403755612671375, -0.056724000722169876, 0.04709136486053467, -0.018915805965662003, -0.03576561436057091, 0.008285715244710445, 0.0019742362201213837, 0.015644323080778122, -0.025557665154337883, -0.05640742927789688, -0.05998675525188446, -0.00170677131973207, 0.015633322298526764, -0.009209769777953625, -0.08252175152301788, 0.002692511770874262, 0.06186417490243912, 0.04247976094484329, 0.046183641999959946, 0.036406900733709335, 0.04221339896321297, 0.04140752553939819, 0.028694914653897285, 0.001621732604689896, 0.0031565348617732525, -0.03757304325699806, 0.023768138140439987, -0.010022861883044243, -0.05341486632823944, -0.02958698943257332, -0.01616092585027218, -0.015527029521763325, 0.002985600149258971, 0.02762957289814949, 0.01121747400611639, -0.018077772110700607, -0.008000032044947147, 0.05786261707544327, -0.02037016488611698, 0.06019587814807892, 0.003907443024218082, 0.002947142580524087, -0.002438121475279331, 0.003465125570073724, 0.038269124925136566, 0.01426957082003355, 0.04228784143924713, 0.031000446528196335, -0.017344364896416664, 0.018652549013495445, -0.01378711685538292, 0.03971696272492409, 0.024486994370818138, -0.03897545114159584, -0.01125806849449873, 0.010224711149930954, -0.020222941413521767, 0.005592964123934507, 0.037184204906225204, 0.010245007462799549, -0.02497599832713604, 0.012497293762862682, -0.04183906316757202, 0.004757164046168327, -0.07476311922073364, -0.011883345432579517, -0.04155271500349045, -0.016192693263292313, 0.0026186269242316484, 0.00787432212382555, -0.01662890613079071, -0.007084949407726526, -0.036988019943237305, -0.03277403488755226, -0.021662354469299316, 0.06069115921854973, -0.03882370889186859, -0.0026159503031522036, 0.039505232125520706, 0.06354872137308121, -0.02073240466415882, 0.05530299246311188, -0.014103458262979984, -0.020160101354122162, 0.006653631571680307, -0.02724362351000309, 0.022716350853443146, 0.01549061480909586, -0.0005487093585543334, 0.0073994966223835945, 0.013669846579432487, -0.0067678214982151985, 0.018397878855466843, -0.045628923922777176, 0.0667349323630333, 0.05465783178806305, 0.024201977998018265, -0.0038176397792994976, -0.011195330880582333, 0.00801113061606884, 0.029213733971118927, -0.030776342377066612, -0.04312283173203468, -0.03339632228016853, -0.011890160851180553, 0.03027677908539772, 0.020713482052087784, -0.02058805525302887, 0.015406222082674503, 0.039119381457567215, 0.0033776492346078157, 0.021610459312796593, 0.028761491179466248, 0.011008750647306442, -0.003487006761133671, 0.007925769314169884, 0.026802467182278633, -0.01803789660334587, 0.02646702155470848, 0.05686614662408829, 0.005841621197760105, 0.0304514579474926, 0.0015153699787333608, 0.008392930030822754, 0.0434284582734108, 0.010980079881846905, -0.0019856421276926994, 0.003270061919465661, -0.005628635175526142, 0.033355019986629486, -0.010156366974115372, -0.001130667282268405, 0.013541708700358868, -0.001215374912135303, -0.050686828792095184, 0.04732136055827141, -0.00394929526373744, 0.047321077436208725, 0.03253919258713722, -0.004768996965140104, -0.01703348010778427, 0.022895872592926025, -0.03431370481848717, 0.008012369275093079, -0.018877683207392693, -0.049623917788267136, -0.012556973844766617, 0.003281734883785248, 0.017863286659121513, -0.0010679889237508178, -0.015069134533405304, -0.02008890174329281, -0.036281272768974304, -0.011777629144489765, -0.015562769025564194, -0.01155212614685297, -0.0032489162404090166, -0.06561336666345596, 0.00456808740273118, 0.005241290666162968, -0.012040521018207073, 0.017492493614554405, 0.05216541141271591, 0.023792030289769173, 0.023524200543761253, -0.003950805403292179, -0.05311334505677223, -0.0037244444247335196, -0.03580391779541969, 0.019684674218297005, -0.018788304179906845, 0.03658199682831764, 0.02171565778553486, 0.006635510362684727, -0.06810172647237778, 0.03759213536977768, -0.010135957971215248, -0.02401893585920334, -0.06681699305772781, -0.004983962047845125, 0.033061683177948, -0.00229336298070848, 0.020078938454389572, 0.025230640545487404, -0.029572634026408195, -0.01381656527519226, -0.053837478160858154, -0.04920357093214989, 0.015745045617222786, -0.016938410699367523, 0.025165090337395668, 0.007304550614207983, -0.026806220412254333, 0.06371286511421204, 0.02234674245119095, -0.0065275318920612335, -0.027858538553118706, 0.008562569506466389, -0.03230765834450722, 0.019833113998174667, 0.03492368012666702, -0.004698455333709717, -0.0023677521385252476, 0.024298911914229393, 0.004016076680272818, -0.00211984827183187, 0.08333148807287216, -0.001260159770026803, 0.003392193466424942, 0.02811274491250515, 0.025785217061638832, -0.01912110298871994, 0.024086296558380127, 0.01800263300538063, -0.029599806293845177, 0.041764188557863235, 0.01835104636847973, 0.0494188591837883, -0.0039842333644628525, -0.020563991740345955, 0.004996947944164276, -0.0024564589839428663, -0.041741374880075455, -0.054230283945798874, 0.0357598215341568, 0.04137677326798439, -0.03068619966506958, -0.00772728631272912, 0.038971733301877975, 0.013177670538425446, -0.025467872619628906, 0.009613101370632648, 0.05319123715162277, 0.04133785516023636, -0.01262346189469099, -0.0410902239382267, -0.02090943232178688, -0.002170981839299202, 0.044119514524936676, -0.003160750260576606, -0.035670023411512375, 0.029144590720534325, 0.0011819544015452266, 0.012099901214241982, 0.004655839875340462, -0.028131771832704544, -0.020263632759451866, -0.06730081886053085, 0.029697662219405174, -0.02499483712017536, 0.0431850366294384, 0.002429988468065858, 0.057252127677202225, 0.0264603104442358, 0.010859218426048756, 0.017892329022288322, -0.026233915239572525, -0.04945974051952362, 0.0642620399594307, -0.0069587682373821735, -0.0090448884293437, -0.00802615750581026, -0.023449718952178955, 0.0336185023188591, -0.045558538287878036, 0.03878888115286827, -0.0022272535134106874, 0.012204932048916817, -0.028638040646910667, 0.01425187848508358, -0.051054880023002625, -0.012690928764641285, 0.003765543457120657, 0.04898541420698166, 0.007236115168780088, 0.001278163050301373, 0.07522669434547424, 0.0011184627655893564, 0.02004004642367363, -0.03496059030294418, -0.04706989973783493, 0.006257383152842522, -0.03463703393936157, 0.022193526849150658, 0.01163596659898758, 0.05722980201244354, -0.02105201780796051, 0.043356530368328094, -0.021579232066869736, 0.08175523579120636, 0.029241789132356644, 0.014161519706249237, -0.022633573040366173, -0.04111230745911598, -0.010028748773038387, -0.006126740947365761, 0.012021172791719437, -0.011451476253569126, -0.005838904995471239, 0.014738164842128754, 0.03621547669172287, -0.07288332283496857, 0.02249857224524021, 0.04157333821058273, 0.002625260502099991, -0.01627378724515438, -0.02713516168296337, 0.021411150693893433, 0.008183499798178673, -0.012971246615052223, 0.01368944812566042, 0.018706398084759712, -0.001701531931757927, -0.02435007132589817, 0.06858303397893906, -0.025320610031485558, -0.0700431764125824, -0.008337179198861122, 0.033252354711294174, -0.0009454925311729312, 0.007184422109276056, -0.041047677397727966, 0.005941851530224085, 0.03855597972869873, 0.03978023678064346, -0.002934844233095646, 0.00977232027798891, -0.07310014963150024, -0.01185382716357708, 0.0056534698233008385, 0.033403925597667694, -0.0424739308655262, 0.009371614083647728, -0.023486025631427765, -0.007808350492268801, 0.016273844987154007, -0.02529648132622242, -0.005197446793317795, -0.006797464098781347, 0.0020357791800051928, -0.020205194130539894, 0.004372777882963419, -0.04799744859337807, 0.032372504472732544, -0.012515228241682053, 0.003938168287277222, -0.026676110923290253, -0.017336349934339523, -0.033332791179418564, 0.00324426987208426, 0.045937929302453995, 0.07955135405063629, 0.008538054302334785, -0.0077980924397706985, 0.003470551921054721, 0.010805890895426273, -0.028965923935174942, -0.05862705782055855, 0.01509486697614193, -0.03718281164765358, 0.016407566145062447, 0.056250475347042084, -0.045801907777786255, -0.04339289665222168, 0.04040633514523506, -0.013381156139075756, -0.02195516973733902, -0.013620411045849323, -0.024686744436621666, 0.015338940545916557, 0.06904736906290054, 0.03321586549282074, 0.054881077259778976, -0.012541120871901512, -0.002865163842216134, -0.004808010067790747, -0.0517696738243103, 0.03095794841647148, -0.036341771483421326, -0.02604358084499836, -0.016709808260202408, -0.017925690859556198, -0.032491326332092285, 0.00030449318001046777, 0.005087893456220627, 0.05876295641064644, -0.015964021906256676, -0.014465907588601112, 0.014293327927589417, -0.0030131216626614332, 0.004532170481979847, 0.03351118043065071, -0.008300406858325005, 0.025142300873994827, -0.03241081163287163, -0.021122178062796593, 0.038463883101940155, -0.009823729284107685, -0.017174948006868362, 0.0010365163907408714, -0.06146760284900665, 0.031505998224020004, -0.021870089694857597, -0.024956710636615753, -0.013048113323748112, -0.011024235747754574, 0.00980938971042633, 0.0029264045879244804, 0.04520682245492935, 0.00608690595254302, -0.004676259588450193, -0.033187124878168106, 0.006302624009549618, 0.01969120092689991, 0.04625330865383148, -0.0336175374686718, 0.03598754107952118, 0.006074709817767143, -0.0339379608631134, -0.08108729124069214, -0.008584846742451191, 0.003785411361604929, -0.0022508427500724792, -0.02120840735733509, -0.0776718258857727, 0.01287234015762806, -0.00737271923571825, -0.01695401780307293, -0.001497661112807691, 0.07811989635229111, 0.010921644046902657, -0.03130973130464554, -0.027417194098234177, 0.02261464297771454, 0.11725443601608276, -0.002546808449551463, 0.0011588366469368339, -0.0000766631928854622, -0.016470525413751602, -0.024561159312725067, 0.008360262960195541, 0.04973259195685387, -0.0345478355884552, 0.01693296618759632, -0.009980162605643272, 0.0053164237178862095, 0.035157449543476105, -0.061277348548173904, 0.01113150268793106, 0.01979474537074566, 0.02298870123922825, 0.0413115955889225, -0.06665956974029541, 0.0022306470200419426, -0.0488564670085907, 0.02495490573346615, -0.056519653648138046, 0.016732564195990562, -0.008221538737416267, 0.009045680984854698, 0.018148062750697136, 0.019389046356081963, -0.0076371245086193085, -0.011596615426242352, 0.07619689404964447, -0.004766014404594898, 0.031541191041469574, 0.008150939829647541, -0.013298199512064457, 0.045320022851228714, -0.025366533547639847, -0.03074618987739086, 0.026710286736488342, 0.031305257230997086, -0.05503345653414726, 0.009133675135672092, -0.05541422590613365, 0.013020934537053108, 0.0717133954167366, 0.009694967418909073, 0.05475110188126564, 0.02403406798839569, 0.008577616885304451, -0.014399800449609756, -0.03145851567387581, -0.0061341505497694016, -0.023162830621004105, -0.019970757886767387, 0.06492897868156433, -0.02826821617782116, -0.00864280667155981, 0.017239192500710487, -0.001658230205066502, 0.037324972450733185, 0.044702015817165375, 0.014279228635132313, 0.013532030396163464, 0.011313245631754398, -0.002623416017740965, 0.008355219848453999, 0.03910014405846596, -0.038689468055963516, -0.007549923844635487, -0.03274866193532944, -0.009724237024784088, 0.024858903139829636, 0.02368338406085968, 0.026102613657712936, 0.0033466301392763853, -0.015151413157582283, -0.06796731054782867, 0.018564676865935326, 0.014475149102509022, 0.005944736767560244, 0.0371880941092968, 0.04813014715909958, 0.008603507652878761, 0.015361581929028034, 0.024554945528507233, -0.01449991762638092, -0.07194799184799194, -0.010290400125086308, -0.0009801527485251427, -0.019296327605843544, -0.010254750959575176, 0.0020228547509759665, -0.04299634322524071, 0.06144443899393082, -0.025067005306482315, 0.012926778756082058, 0.00675549078732729, 0.0011273602722212672, -0.03451506793498993, 0.04953637719154358, 0.03126658871769905, 0.03491779416799545, -0.0007882711943238974, -0.013904646039009094, 0.12547317147254944, 0.04071740433573723, 0.015397853218019009, -0.06708721071481705, 0.028113195672631264, 0.018400246277451515, -0.0037510511465370655, 0.0049159834161400795, 0.03922005742788315, 0.0061727361753582954, 0.006453546695411205, 0.04342282935976982, 0.050598807632923126, -0.004218405112624168, 0.022947601974010468, 0.049237724393606186, 0.00232920260168612, -0.003534049727022648, -0.001378765795379877, 0.005287358071655035, 0.008866927586495876, -0.01843140833079815, -0.009220093488693237, 0.031912483274936676, -0.0370110459625721, -0.020430870354175568, -0.0378522090613842, -0.01917416602373123, 0.004566539544612169, 0.015087775886058807, -0.024394609034061432, -0.0026658454444259405, 0.014577437192201614, 0.006582299247384071, -0.029953986406326294, -0.027698593214154243, 0.019110456109046936, -0.032957907766103745, 0.014492835849523544, 0.03248259425163269, -0.004926858004182577, -0.021014893427491188, -0.010599317029118538, 0.0035520235542207956, -0.026538165286183357, -0.06701351702213287, -0.04139435291290283, 0.025817105546593666, -0.0031190779991447926, 0.0012781701516360044, 0.0012219439959153533, -0.009738198481500149, -0.03260108456015587, -0.03172778710722923, 0.01122627966105938, 0.003731592558324337, 0.000927109969779849, -0.037746407091617584, -0.0004966902197338641, -0.027227511629462242, 0.0696326270699501, -0.01923033967614174, 0.02750318869948387, -0.01886611059308052, -0.024142220616340637, -0.04008706659078598, -0.008903412148356438, 0.04683377593755722, -0.012149114161729813, -0.030659586191177368, 0.006499646231532097, -0.021521221846342087, -0.000117533425509464, 0.009534571319818497, 0.010696136392652988, 0.006886037066578865, 0.03913847729563713, 0.006675390992313623, -0.023587433621287346, -0.006686091423034668, -0.07849685847759247, 0.01799331232905388, -0.013299161568284035, 0.002506566932424903, -0.020973771810531616, -0.023549068719148636, 0.03212616592645645, 0.04703280329704285, -0.0015088183572515845, 0.01597130298614502, 0.0007410103571601212, 0.021039843559265137, 0.04082513228058815, -0.042463891208171844, 0.028140051290392876, -0.0018996146973222494, -0.031492460519075394, 0.0000893818141776137, -0.0775131806731224, 0.07143276184797287, 0.03936474025249481, 0.027083031833171844, 0.0018100274028256536, -0.014940200373530388, -0.01337573304772377, 0.029095817357301712, -0.017258718609809875, -0.0031954580917954445, -0.020148256793618202, 0.020094024017453194, -0.0005914483335800469, 0.006613981910049915, 0.0016664009308442473, -0.04878026619553566, -0.0467229038476944, 0.028142714872956276, -0.03506443649530411, -0.041409678757190704, 0.008892613463103771, -0.00898533221334219, -0.0034672634210437536, -0.021765757352113724, 0.026677997782826424, -0.012516969814896584, -0.002016221871599555, 0.012404600158333778, 0.01516107376664877, -0.022595664486289024, 0.014765815809369087, -0.025501418858766556, -0.027853593230247498, 0.039616964757442474, -0.01041680108755827, 0.06064349412918091, 0.0033533787354826927, 0.016104649752378464, -0.017929187044501305, 0.042997170239686966, -0.015131727792322636, -0.007341414224356413, 0.043343305587768555, -0.051028549671173096, -0.036754630506038666, 0.014009416103363037, 0.022329866886138916, 0.013631865382194519, 0.02745606191456318, -0.016183122992515564, -0.03331311047077179, 0.05996682494878769, -0.04271361231803894, -0.035231251269578934, -0.01822085492312908, -0.0023997982498258352, 0.03813101723790169, 0.022480498999357224, 0.013373790308833122, 0.011822556145489216, -0.008017901331186295, 0.006229640915989876, 0.02893049642443657, -0.0026608228217810392, 0.00305243581533432, 0.011001892387866974, -0.02480839192867279, 0.0467904768884182, -0.0012022391892969608, 0.0033620393369346857, 0.033881209790706635, 0.0358370766043663, -0.01969875954091549, -0.012280721217393875, -0.039808038622140884, -0.01961432956159115, -0.0906161293387413, -0.02077140286564827, 0.01839001476764679, -0.020956899970769882, 0.046108804643154144, -0.03783528879284859, 0.004419946577399969, 0.05716371163725853, -0.025403911247849464, -0.006451697554439306, -0.011837533675134182, -0.009618059732019901, -0.07180360704660416, 0.0128544382750988, -0.04114359989762306, 0.014905947260558605, -0.008154843002557755, 0.030513953417539597, 0.03708965703845024, -0.008533118292689323, -0.027849452570080757, -0.011371098458766937, -0.016818920150399208, -0.018270030617713928, -0.007166463416069746, -0.06227604299783707, -0.01013344619423151, -0.035046979784965515, -0.053103577345609665, 0.0515604130923748, -0.007702338974922895, -0.0025394794065505266, 0.013307236135005951, 0.027330560609698296, 0.014215775765478611, 0.03797774761915207, 0.0354597382247448, 0.003308608429506421, -0.01316773984581232, -0.006075472105294466, -0.01770792156457901, 0.003023152006790042, -0.014071167446672916, -0.010365214198827744, 0.03068537637591362, -0.0020084402058273554, -0.027107171714305878, 0.06130237132310867, 0.010190866887569427, -0.05441926419734955, 0.004542334005236626, 0.0021021361462771893, 0.020143689587712288, -0.04683777689933777, 0.011815049685537815, -0.029753221198916435, -0.027118811383843422, 0.056176189333200455, 0.0053535508923232555, -0.03696107119321823, 0.039672400802373886, -0.027873743325471878, -0.016494430601596832, 0.006587458774447441, 0.03054359368979931, -0.04117590934038162, -0.041595712304115295, -0.010780168697237968, 0.026789778843522072, 0.020970895886421204, -0.01769912801682949, -0.03722083196043968, -0.04572976380586624, 0.018512504175305367, -0.02235696092247963, 0.033546630293130875, -0.023310398682951927, 0.022376807406544685, 0.0038248065393418074, -0.04309098422527313, 0.04033936560153961, -0.022022727876901627, -0.013856397941708565, -0.04114088788628578, -0.023893792182207108, -0.04468395933508873, 0.027688663452863693, 0.07528794556856155, 0.043560124933719635, 0.019963383674621582, -0.006445129401981831, 0.013249541632831097, 0.046969201415777206, -0.05116218328475952, 0.024967363104224205, -0.030076226219534874, -0.023279977962374687, -0.013111881911754608, 0.00886369775980711, -0.0026649218052625656, 0.018650447949767113, -0.019289514049887657, -0.025036968290805817, -0.0038976483047008514, 0.035442810505628586, -0.02032860368490219, 0.013434886001050472, -0.012786537408828735, -0.010237875394523144, 0.025409193709492683, -0.0023303544148802757, -0.005673293024301529, -0.021797360852360725, 0.025342775508761406, -0.06275292485952377, 0.018969787284731865, -0.014924028888344765, -0.009323402307927608, -0.019207129254937172, 0.014235306531190872, -0.02688589133322239, -0.06768930703401566, -0.008660931140184402, 0.012353615835309029, -0.04949330538511276, 0.005246494896709919, 0.039549026638269424, 0.03111855871975422, 0.04874975606799126, -0.008943588472902775, -0.002690524561330676, -0.005569155793637037, -0.04061155021190643, 0.03203863278031349, 0.001463807770051062, 0.030776754021644592, 0.0023638440761715174, -0.00326940487138927, 0.009164364077150822, -0.0315030962228775, 0.003655485576018691, -0.015291603282094002, 0.04224958270788193, 0.006797093898057938, -0.011772393248975277, 0.026116708293557167, -0.049957405775785446, 0.007279770914465189, 0.00993801187723875, 0.0019847836811095476, 0.0799117162823677, -0.01191709190607071, 0.015245359390974045, -0.04333624243736267, -0.00420845951884985, -0.024712899699807167, -0.01589786447584629, -0.003993978723883629, 0.016800079494714737, 0.049113620072603226, 0.016441846266388893, -0.0064702765084803104, -0.027804812416434288, 0.037995703518390656, -0.043735429644584656, 0.012395251542329788, 0.005692341830581427, -0.025813983753323555, -0.042373303323984146, -0.007011816371232271, -0.06113700196146965, -0.04555826261639595, 0.031367380172014236, 0.055277254432439804, 0.05002087727189064, -0.011588552966713905, -0.036328162997961044, 0.0020409668795764446, 0.015579232014715672, -0.08669149875640869, -0.04951859265565872, -0.04673142731189728, -0.007799620274454355, -0.018425529822707176, -0.01235283724963665 ]
<p>Suppose you have 2 distinct features x1 and x2 with discrete values between 1 and 10.</p> <p>When building a neural network, I have 2 options:</p> <ol> <li>Create a new feature x3 = 10*x1 + x2 and use this as the only input.</li> <li>Use both inputs x1 and x2 for the neural network.</li> </ol> <p>How can I decide which is the best option? </p> <p>Here is a practical example inspired from poker: You have 7 cards. The first 2 cards are from player 1. The next 2 cards are from player 2 and the last 3 cards are the flop. You want to determine who has the strongest hand. The two options are:</p> <ol> <li>Treat each card as a number from 1 to 52. </li> <li>Make two inputs: One for the rank (2,3,4,5,6...J,Q,K,A) and one for the suit (club,diamond,heart,spade).</li> </ol> <p>More precisely, I want to understand how choosing each option will affect how much training data is needed, how many neurons in the hidden layer I should use and how much time will be needed for training.</p>
73,746
[ -0.0016108565032482147, -0.03192739561200142, -0.024087032303214073, -0.009797705337405205, 0.00988986250013113, 0.007850787602365017, 0.006804734468460083, -0.037274472415447235, 0.04765821620821953, 0.014181852340698242, 0.015804193913936615, 0.026015954092144966, -0.0015153413405641913, 0.033556174486875534, -0.018834246322512627, 0.04304767772555351, 0.008205858059227467, -0.03925761207938194, 0.0003846215840894729, 0.0037272546906024218, -0.03503435477614403, 0.03617456555366516, 0.0054051619954407215, 0.001838891301304102, -0.042719315737485886, 0.05230352655053139, 0.001263889716938138, -0.003396521555259824, 0.018874233588576317, 0.045236364006996155, -0.020485522225499153, -0.02774577960371971, 0.01633373275399208, 0.029553158208727837, 0.04590083658695221, 0.03629809245467186, 0.009126286022365093, -0.05032132938504219, -0.01920599862933159, -0.012061758898198605, 0.02787190116941929, 0.004941585473716259, -0.011351172812283039, -0.03204263001680374, -0.018616460263729095, 0.048796843737363815, -0.016428308561444283, -0.05691991001367569, 0.007767748553305864, -0.049955930560827255, 0.04667598754167557, 0.006998529192060232, 0.02463737688958645, 0.05593666434288025, -0.0020908808801323175, 0.000459547940408811, 0.04766594246029854, 0.0638541430234909, -0.00930903758853674, -0.05247637629508972, -0.01560081634670496, -0.03818371146917343, -0.01608967036008835, -0.019859356805682182, -0.015846576541662216, 0.019657393917441368, 0.023847335949540138, 0.0029227244667708874, 0.006311019882559776, -0.04361223801970482, 0.015027809888124466, 0.015457525849342346, 0.020568033680319786, -0.01325576938688755, 0.01891075260937214, -0.01642262376844883, 0.007976499386131763, 0.02709442749619484, 0.01438339427113533, -0.012103848159313202, 0.012026501819491386, 0.007623061537742615, 0.014812678098678589, 0.03333287313580513, 0.03982585296034813, 0.01364580076187849, 0.05320730805397034, -0.011681867763400078, 0.023901117965579033, -0.003781569190323353, -0.009179920889437199, 0.0112923514097929, 0.0250236913561821, -0.01722351647913456, -0.021179232746362686, 0.007528943475335836, 0.004681937862187624, -0.007440634071826935, 0.019254954531788826, 0.013730117119848728, -0.007818128913640976, -0.05867588147521019, -0.013998868875205517, 0.04087033495306969, -0.004949978087097406, -0.016443591564893723, 0.005593177862465382, 0.01751982606947422, -0.02752552554011345, 0.011210577562451363, -0.03451259806752205, 0.037474680691957474, -0.014965109527111053, 0.03643523529171944, 0.0015748754376545548, -0.02520768530666828, -0.0029949541203677654, 0.023255513980984688, 0.02648133412003517, 0.04648369550704956, -0.0018500969745218754, -0.04535459354519844, 0.03154652565717697, -0.03538019210100174, -0.07076360285282135, 0.0162868183106184, 0.040703825652599335, -0.018884263932704926, -0.034302178770303726, 0.07251503318548203, -0.02695421874523163, -0.01881551742553711, -0.001666354131884873, 0.009866433218121529, 0.013935809955000877, 0.012200070545077324, -0.09465821087360382, -0.051387298852205276, 0.05002801865339279, -0.04262018948793411, 0.013602323830127716, -0.04811132326722145, 0.03648975118994713, 0.05704783648252487, 0.05537116527557373, 0.008194178342819214, 0.03922191262245178, 0.029714571312069893, -0.019513815641403198, -0.0070521170273423195, -0.007031830959022045, -0.011024323292076588, -0.0226641483604908, 0.023880524560809135, -0.038979385048151016, -0.05038533732295036, 0.0232099462300539, 0.03397836536169052, -0.016188114881515503, -0.007283554878085852, 0.017106717452406883, -0.010634483769536018, 0.005947318859398365, -0.005015870090574026, -0.01017858274281025, -0.044469647109508514, 0.08727414906024933, 0.004125715233385563, 0.06414657831192017, 0.024775993078947067, -0.02602655626833439, -0.00519120879471302, 0.03495737537741661, 0.02352072484791279, 0.03219600394368172, 0.011533207260072231, -0.012393206357955933, -0.021078037098050117, 0.009835751727223396, -0.003952826373279095, -0.011412534862756729, -0.0503765344619751, -0.015162250027060509, 0.0032298362348228693, -0.005764133762568235, 0.027742616832256317, 0.023833030834794044, 0.004853568505495787, 0.0009067477658390999, -0.006006559357047081, -0.048433780670166016, -0.0881444439291954, 0.023775871843099594, -0.01396836806088686, -0.023174650967121124, -0.0027563185431063175, -0.003350077662616968, 0.0057220482267439365, -0.0015455821994692087, -0.03883107379078865, -0.05709114670753479, 0.002377463737502694, 0.03225836530327797, 0.0003643623786047101, 0.007891925983130932, 0.07150673866271973, -0.0075252605602145195, -0.044841594994068146, 0.03723698854446411, -0.04917754977941513, -0.02072344347834587, 0.014427530579268932, -0.02791294828057289, 0.036134835332632065, -0.003279291559010744, -0.015599744394421577, 0.032096922397613525, 0.010994301177561283, -0.019713299348950386, 0.02438347227871418, -0.05916013568639755, 0.07923255860805511, 0.08155369013547897, -0.014364694245159626, 0.04231693595647812, 0.002311178483068943, -0.02028975449502468, -0.00039204105269163847, 0.022881189361214638, -0.005661381874233484, -0.0669478252530098, -0.052801456302404404, 0.024927135556936264, 0.030183203518390656, -0.02105635777115822, 0.04708848148584366, 0.055977486073970795, 0.02427520789206028, 0.019562624394893646, 0.012918575666844845, -0.016324112191796303, 0.022516582161188126, -0.01821894198656082, -0.007244073785841465, 0.018506407737731934, -0.00552073260769248, 0.04851735010743141, 0.003808211302384734, 0.01982821337878704, 0.024829531088471413, -0.02078675851225853, 0.0733267143368721, 0.045930489897727966, 0.017478205263614655, 0.010082196444272995, -0.02346629463136196, 0.024173174053430557, -0.034580379724502563, 0.0027399046812206507, 0.030610330402851105, 0.0032366926316171885, -0.012296214699745178, -0.0039885155856609344, -0.032713569700717926, 0.033420298248529434, 0.035606421530246735, 0.012816773727536201, 0.01864476688206196, 0.03951878100633621, -0.04055982083082199, 0.0024665575474500656, -0.005598579533398151, -0.01769418455660343, -0.03872126340866089, 0.02397238090634346, 0.03440425172448158, -0.03476874157786369, 0.05666360631585121, -0.008321206085383892, -0.03482764586806297, -0.007457961328327656, -0.03173309192061424, 0.02286563813686371, 0.006162039935588837, -0.059760428965091705, 0.004737866576761007, 0.0005244958447292447, -0.022314002737402916, 0.02412617951631546, 0.007342982571572065, -0.025323016569018364, 0.009406198747456074, -0.014185208827257156, -0.024344583973288536, -0.03757656738162041, -0.05883020535111427, 0.05140474811196327, 0.01670975424349308, -0.045664090663194656, 0.052606869488954544, 0.023644067347049713, -0.03979959711432457, 0.0100436145439744, -0.0076295253820717335, -0.01890164613723755, -0.00469551607966423, -0.008458653464913368, 0.005591576918959618, -0.013827411457896233, -0.057957857847213745, 0.039760272949934006, 0.012288392521440983, -0.002876038895919919, -0.07179686427116394, -0.04986118525266647, 0.005051941145211458, -0.017830366268754005, 0.002802184782922268, 0.015073918737471104, 0.009618067182600498, 0.08057668805122375, 0.03295018896460533, -0.024133965373039246, -0.01596749946475029, -0.011608036234974861, -0.01862206496298313, -0.0210293997079134, 0.034097786992788315, 0.03831383213400841, 0.0007458618492819369, 0.007903289049863815, 0.0070828539319336414, 0.03452853858470917, 0.06579291820526123, -0.03657405078411102, -0.012241563759744167, 0.019061200320720673, 0.009889108128845692, -0.0495591014623642, 0.02375904843211174, 0.019877729937434196, -0.04753753915429115, 0.03076760470867157, -0.011726110242307186, 0.009147696197032928, 0.010069114156067371, -0.013891512528061867, 0.023010365664958954, -0.03803222253918648, 0.007561793550848961, -0.016503140330314636, 0.02556118741631508, -0.009266847744584084, -0.031584884971380234, -0.004987612366676331, 0.041996076703071594, 0.0699148178100586, -0.036757808178663254, 0.0019356897100806236, 0.02515420690178871, 0.029742779210209846, -0.028281761333346367, -0.018069814890623093, 0.008502929471433163, 0.011400441639125347, 0.02978421002626419, -0.01497527863830328, 0.0026416087057441473, 0.04343302920460701, -0.008422750048339367, 0.016316281631588936, 0.03401591256260872, -0.04119995981454849, -0.01150814350694418, -0.07749247550964355, 0.027765441685914993, -0.01622316613793373, 0.11027828603982925, 0.019785599783062935, 0.04844473674893379, 0.024426329880952835, -0.031199133023619652, 0.013946172781288624, -0.022101830691099167, -0.10415962338447571, 0.038709599524736404, 0.0033337988425046206, 0.003048267448320985, -0.01173915434628725, -0.039184778928756714, 0.04204026982188225, -0.05490633472800255, -0.023803256452083588, 0.003792473115026951, 0.024959098547697067, -0.030079016461968422, 0.022302431985735893, -0.031095324084162712, 0.0024420451372861862, -0.012173041701316833, 0.009510270319879055, 0.02256082184612751, -0.0022686095908284187, 0.018874898552894592, 0.024555753916502, -0.00026324630016461015, 0.02191939391195774, -0.00503581715747714, 0.013209487311542034, -0.003949589561671019, 0.03346170112490654, -0.025927359238266945, 0.05377762019634247, -0.013031774200499058, 0.015072556212544441, 0.0003152141871396452, 0.04663165658712387, 0.04362373799085617, 0.01594819501042366, -0.010378836654126644, -0.06828367710113525, 0.01790740340948105, 0.01619897410273552, 0.03211383894085884, -0.017521802335977554, -0.015454172156751156, 0.027405422180891037, 0.025772949680685997, -0.05776439234614372, 0.004036141559481621, 0.07040271162986755, 0.012830597348511219, -0.02797340229153633, -0.048782967031002045, 0.016192389652132988, -0.008076997473835945, -0.009012308903038502, 0.04647566378116608, 0.00976611115038395, 0.004082515370100737, -0.001549620646983385, 0.0234001986682415, -0.022817054763436317, -0.0140219796448946, 0.0074380794540047646, 0.045895375311374664, 0.045129235833883286, -0.0180681012570858, -0.01297745294868946, -0.00027861286071129143, 0.03297409415245056, 0.029546858742833138, 0.01051300298422575, -0.01105362456291914, -0.08763179183006287, -0.023064129054546356, 0.06445274502038956, 0.03283913806080818, -0.053998906165361404, -0.0358562134206295, -0.0234273299574852, -0.013640621677041054, 0.000984402373433113, -0.030788881704211235, 0.06867499649524689, -0.020465422421693802, -0.01802709698677063, -0.06330732256174088, 0.0023450334556400776, -0.01981070265173912, 0.05621498450636864, -0.04951723292469978, 0.05276785045862198, 0.011909984983503819, -0.017995016649365425, -0.005383642390370369, 0.019326427951455116, 0.014478773809969425, 0.04951348528265953, -0.05936553701758385, -0.005963062401860952, 0.006475191563367844, -0.022389212623238564, -0.00784112699329853, -0.09074857831001282, 0.014176410622894764, 0.03261963650584221, -0.017005357891321182, 0.036238718777894974, -0.00226407777518034, -0.042397741228342056, 0.026696879416704178, 0.04308606684207916, -0.017060838639736176, -0.010154562070965767, -0.033631276339292526, 0.033177029341459274, 0.058452460914850235, -0.001199560472741723, 0.05902332440018654, 0.006549334619194269, -0.009106844663619995, -0.014898475259542465, 0.022172626107931137, 0.011395665816962719, -0.0050862315110862255, 0.00009527133806841448, -0.03234761208295822, 0.01690700650215149, -0.025916121900081635, 0.04378017410635948, 0.007528161630034447, 0.0655752420425415, -0.021281812340021133, -0.0032740633469074965, -0.051692746579647064, 0.020365359261631966, 0.009857434779405594, -0.03426576778292656, -0.003923376556485891, -0.005279301665723324, -0.023565784096717834, 0.023052485659718513, 0.019230863079428673, -0.020418811589479446, 0.04079916328191757, 0.00846053659915924, -0.030153322964906693, -0.013083262369036674, -0.034833259880542755, -0.022741258144378662, 0.002465009456500411, -0.038194239139556885, 0.06656228005886078, 0.0027704283129423857, -0.002532350830733776, 0.025208989158272743, -0.03521385416388512, -0.013047676533460617, 0.00015128312224987894, 0.01937725767493248, -0.04385918378829956, -0.04084146395325661, 0.05965401977300644, -0.009028352797031403, -0.016259998083114624, -0.02891409583389759, -0.0009322453406639397, -0.014548210427165031, 0.0020767224486917257, -0.008733857423067093, -0.013277408666908741, 0.01437678374350071, 0.01341222319751978, -0.023201631382107735, -0.01226638350635767, 0.03502292558550835, -0.003425432136282325, 0.008085586130619049, 0.020547926425933838, -0.007408150006085634, 0.05982018634676933, 0.013342131860554218, 0.0051979185082018375, -0.011159639805555344, -0.025208743289113045, -0.011179096065461636, -0.007578972727060318, 0.026990629732608795, -0.008618807420134544, -0.0025258727837353945, -0.01725141890347004, 0.02925664186477661, 0.05555872991681099, 0.01520235650241375, -0.0008341289940290153, -0.0012942020548507571, 0.020984023809432983, -0.007656358648091555, -0.028367850929498672, -0.011675739660859108, 0.021220527589321136, 0.0007920256466604769, 0.00034061408950947225, 0.012775084935128689, -0.02228151261806488, -0.025710195302963257, -0.01160467229783535, 0.01982017233967781, -0.03381602466106415, 0.017142096534371376, 0.05363205820322037, 0.0004684202140197158, -0.004950080066919327, -0.02102908119559288, -0.03830492123961449, 0.0759010836482048, -0.0038566647563129663, -0.0009128866950049996, 0.018352705985307693, 0.02349148318171501, -0.03674960881471634, -0.011053449474275112, -0.027819767594337463, 0.010179982520639896, 0.06607843935489655, -0.04678426310420036, 0.046745043247938156, 0.05348438769578934, -0.013225523754954338, 0.03115050308406353, -0.0215188879519701, -0.021586183458566666, -0.07484613358974457, -0.0027504286263138056, 0.03869108110666275, 0.018160652369260788, -0.016936736181378365, 0.05376407876610756, 0.015906985849142075, 0.03732413053512573, 0.050329647958278656, 0.01123877428472042, 0.03795705735683441, 0.0033792229369282722, -0.05665803700685501, -0.02989095449447632, 0.010780653916299343, -0.07179814577102661, 0.0033008111640810966, -0.021173832938075066, -0.01020454429090023, 0.04389834403991699, 0.03541787341237068, -0.009243159554898739, -0.03313737362623215, -0.01092089619487524, -0.05246199667453766, 0.015612905845046043, -0.011112661100924015, -0.00857141986489296, 0.00043360303970985115, 0.011927665211260319, 0.030717823654413223, -0.023943716660141945, 0.011406519450247288, -0.024632776156067848, -0.07559530436992645, -0.039967797696590424, -0.044547099620103836, -0.01738915592432022, 0.0443732813000679, -0.005500804167240858, -0.05272331088781357, 0.05493539944291115, -0.07291519641876221, 0.03220664709806442, 0.003778433660045266, 0.03195533901453018, -0.026581374928355217, 0.07612758874893188, 0.013501695357263088, 0.02523745968937874, -0.0028959366027265787, 0.029919199645519257, 0.12677539885044098, 0.10547685623168945, 0.022590916603803635, -0.07599997520446777, 0.01216645073145628, -0.016029145568609238, -0.011700710281729698, -0.006644431501626968, -0.00879011768847704, 0.03636150062084198, 0.01660267636179924, -0.011552438139915466, -0.0036341678351163864, 0.011320396326482296, 0.0023989102337509394, 0.01505201030522585, -0.045972637832164764, -0.001116801518946886, 0.042083997279405594, 0.026528818532824516, -0.010010633617639542, -0.014718293212354183, -0.0557747557759285, -0.0166238434612751, 0.02999335341155529, -0.04231974482536316, 0.012691453099250793, -0.015220893546938896, 0.03256881982088089, -0.00488275894895196, 0.0016503152437508106, 0.01210811361670494, 0.029283903539180756, 0.014125306159257889, 0.02561224065721035, 0.05192788317799568, -0.008816340938210487, -0.03852011263370514, -0.003165631555020809, 0.0369722917675972, 0.04019786790013313, -0.02277173101902008, -0.00198594992980361, -0.01223153155297041, -0.07733847945928574, -0.04029630124568939, -0.07284704595804214, -0.004313826560974121, -0.02198486402630806, -0.01987229846417904, -0.002261247718706727, 0.030995924025774002, 0.022058911621570587, -0.036995988339185715, -0.04927733913064003, 0.04614832624793053, 0.03137599304318428, -0.017563533037900925, -0.03909007087349892, -0.0246424563229084, 0.016415288671851158, -0.029643885791301727, 0.0064239767380058765, 0.020055726170539856, -0.010079066269099712, -0.022099709138274193, -0.044777411967515945, 0.019473792985081673, 0.004741522949188948, 0.021060744300484657, -0.009197542443871498, -0.028034601360559464, -0.016412772238254547, -0.021838340908288956, -0.0036705806851387024, -0.0007387793157249689, -0.03276548907160759, -0.0034117086324840784, -0.014238353818655014, -0.014152053743600845, 0.003835078561678529, 0.009080753661692142, 0.02705765701830387, 0.00411871075630188, -0.01876237615942955, -0.000604167755227536, 0.006983502302318811, 0.0031534885056316853, 0.03395494446158409, -0.026273608207702637, 0.0392451249063015, -0.0009204348316416144, 0.018671877682209015, -0.06519227474927902, -0.04120543599128723, 0.006336655933409929, -0.03654712438583374, 0.004498961381614208, 0.001312712556682527, 0.05690660700201988, -0.011403143405914307, 0.0337589830160141, 0.0045811086893081665, 0.03455359488725662, -0.014579616487026215, 0.012176956050097942, 0.04263550415635109, -0.03243258222937584, -0.022242853417992592, 0.00019637992954812944, -0.026388995349407196, -0.06688931584358215, -0.04111669957637787, -0.031573280692100525, -0.03396550938487053, 0.002852409379556775, -0.008246722631156445, -0.05003497749567032, 0.003201293759047985, -0.007692199200391769, 0.038081951439380646, -0.007641086354851723, 0.02054082602262497, -0.03280094638466835, 0.005785020068287849, -0.007705594412982464, -0.006126704625785351, -0.021924803033471107, 0.03399622440338135, -0.0022855899296700954, -0.01513116154819727, -0.0065571921877563, 0.02269170619547367, 0.06021726131439209, 0.0000648059940431267, -0.0032941133249551058, -0.017588011920452118, 0.03915649279952049, -0.03938431292772293, -0.02721003070473671, -0.01122446171939373, -0.052836380898952484, 0.017612671479582787, 0.011858188547194004, -0.008539783768355846, 0.061506837606430054, 0.04080227389931679, -0.027807708829641342, 0.012046665884554386, 0.03903375193476677, -0.02642119489610195, -0.04770028963685036, 0.014433087781071663, -0.006587378680706024, 0.009028896689414978, 0.006028176285326481, 0.003062676405534148, -0.015300861559808254, -0.0007712861988693476, 0.004411808215081692, 0.009659036062657833, 0.02310105971992016, -0.026742465794086456, -0.002089141635224223, 0.02420988492667675, 0.020983640104532242, -0.021755553781986237, -0.030184604227542877, 0.020251715555787086, 0.003856057533994317, 0.011406809091567993, 0.05387343466281891, 0.009729024954140186, 0.022018956020474434, -0.08082988858222961, -0.019074492156505585, 0.007504391949623823, -0.011122038587927818, 0.0456051342189312, -0.051997944712638855, 0.03098093532025814, 0.013710197061300278, -0.04158645123243332, 0.03755556792020798, -0.010240025818347931, 0.011656767688691616, -0.020286791026592255, 0.04429470747709274, -0.011646061204373837, 0.018599333241581917, 0.008157153613865376, -0.009568706154823303, 0.054503004997968674, 0.01794564165174961, 0.018274720758199692, -0.0025969247799366713, -0.022005923092365265, 0.04189110919833183, -0.024576181545853615, -0.04301566630601883, 0.04407503455877304, -0.049601923674345016, -0.05115766078233719, 0.053949516266584396, -0.044991105794906616, -0.014540115371346474, 0.04415182024240494, 0.021799026057124138, 0.01606675051152706, 0.011814841069281101, 0.02668807841837406, -0.014929026365280151, 0.009988874197006226, -0.025052305310964584, 0.00825666356831789, -0.01784304529428482, 0.014459479600191116, 0.030098918825387955, 0.019496776163578033, 0.02409757860004902, -0.03154871612787247, -0.020871851593255997, -0.03296491503715515, 0.0034677013754844666, 0.02519216574728489, 0.04214862734079361, 0.030904414132237434, -0.031243285164237022, -0.011639421805739403, -0.0007681818096898496, -0.005869273561984301, -0.004909991752356291, 0.016789816319942474, -0.0020581609569489956, -0.013434382155537605, -0.0047848038375377655, -0.03742893785238266, -0.008479722775518894, 0.037714581936597824, -0.002055057557299733, -0.0380612351000309, 0.0040883212350308895, 0.05325324460864067, -0.009551805444061756, -0.018018174916505814, -0.051262471824884415, -0.02728755585849285, 0.0383712500333786, -0.010713919065892696, 0.06705905497074127, 0.0005513795767910779, -0.053025778383016586, 0.04379291832447052, -0.08294953405857086, 0.03998764604330063, 0.018553560599684715, -0.0008996300166472793, -0.030415356159210205, -0.012432492338120937, -0.021300941705703735, 0.006417102180421352, 0.0417463518679142, -0.0007153009646572173, -0.015648722648620605, -0.034555286169052124, -0.002228804398328066, 0.008719411678612232, -0.01912851817905903, 0.004014910664409399, -0.019222458824515343, -0.010596784763038158, -0.0192378219217062, -0.028193246573209763, 0.018719162791967392, 0.019248371943831444, 0.03750826418399811, 0.01643187366425991, -0.00507153058424592, -0.006315787322819233, 0.013845441862940788, 0.009759495966136456, -0.0032515465281903744, 0.00028947810642421246, 0.033340372145175934, 0.002474837703630328, -0.005920860916376114, -0.031095221638679504, 0.017616290599107742, -0.05494051054120064, 0.044783320277929306, -0.06438685208559036, -0.0024917793925851583, -0.011888398788869381, -0.01069536991417408, 0.06527332961559296, -0.06992833316326141, -0.002656634896993637, 0.021134302020072937, -0.017125509679317474, -0.021331818774342537, 0.026350490748882294, 0.028710084035992622, 0.046460509300231934, -0.009189979173243046, 0.026960529386997223, -0.037155672907829285, -0.03026316501200199, -0.02456780895590782, -0.020288705825805664, 0.020238593220710754, -0.004890315234661102, 0.06354693323373795, 0.0212762001901865, -0.0007247243192978203, 0.041639264672994614, -0.0015344363637268543, 0.0443786084651947, -0.0041440739296376705, -0.029874369502067566, 0.01529143750667572, -0.010886389762163162, 0.0018999682506546378, -0.025706402957439423, 0.008755357004702091, 0.04576556012034416, -0.010079506784677505, -0.006394501309841871, -0.025763150304555893, -0.003023273078724742, -0.04379500076174736, -0.025850141420960426, 0.030600035563111305, 0.028825385496020317, -0.008680080994963646, 0.00887343194335699, -0.019506357610225677, -0.0019127270206809044, 0.02199941873550415, -0.04003190994262695, 0.03709268197417259, -0.015625478699803352, -0.035523392260074615, 0.01957792043685913, 0.009303930215537548, -0.02579178661108017, -0.019751956686377525, 0.06261684745550156, 0.05744951218366623, 0.00708375871181488, -0.004254527390003204, -0.028970669955015182, 0.0041390652768313885, 0.02070913463830948, -0.07078829407691956, -0.009740331210196018, -0.09042517095804214, 0.023357870057225227, -0.015673549845814705, -0.01423921249806881 ]
<p>I'm reading through this paper on <a href="http://uai.sis.pitt.edu/papers/11/p736-wilson.pdf" rel="nofollow">Generalised Wishart Processes</a> (GWP). The paper calculates the covariances between different random variables (following <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaussian_process" rel="nofollow">Gaussian Process</a>) using squared exponential covariance function, i.e., $K(x,x') = \exp\left(-\frac{|(x-x')|^2}{2l^2}\right)$. It then says that this covariance matrix follows GWP.</p> <p>I used to think that a covariance matrix computed from <strong>linear covariance function ($K(x,x') = x^Tx'$)</strong>, follows Wishart Distribution with appropriate parameters. </p> <p>My question is, how can we still assume the covariance to follow a Wishart distribution with squared exponential covariance function? Also, in general, what is the necessary condition for a covariance function to produce a Wishart distributed covariance matrix?</p>
47,211
[ -0.017436819151043892, -0.005202272441238165, 0.03670276328921318, -0.01975024864077568, 0.04386313259601593, -0.009212801232933998, -0.03440170735120773, -0.04017584025859833, 0.010866325348615646, -0.04626164212822914, 0.020400773733854294, 0.0213767122477293, 0.04089842736721039, 0.015160364098846912, 0.020435988903045654, 0.003564155427739024, -0.05394794046878815, -0.015762092545628548, 0.010053133592009544, -0.004469933453947306, -0.011002951301634312, 0.005501421168446541, -0.023297537118196487, -0.014327292330563068, -0.03762104734778404, 0.006831296253949404, -0.007775389589369297, 0.006165258586406708, 0.05248432233929634, 0.07149867713451385, -0.024037839844822884, -0.009946406818926334, 0.01850058324635029, 0.057467371225357056, 0.006947508547455072, 0.006017359904944897, -0.048468057066202164, -0.05227233096957207, 0.008745419792830944, 0.021819332614541054, -0.014972812496125698, -0.034340351819992065, 0.01061792578548193, 0.04207012802362442, -0.002450249856337905, 0.04632133990526199, -0.010106383822858334, -0.07423899322748184, 0.05902985855937004, -0.03592851758003235, 0.06766095012426376, 0.002245067385956645, 0.03132333979010582, 0.03371761739253998, 0.0016417300794273615, -0.009820420295000076, 0.048179809004068375, 0.05179933086037636, 0.00817177165299654, -0.040215957909822464, 0.01588093675673008, -0.01483896654099226, 0.015347867272794247, -0.0031932115089148283, -0.015036921948194504, -0.00032204081071540713, 0.015829887241125107, -0.03170313313603401, -0.005398928187787533, -0.02915235050022602, 0.03086196817457676, 0.01388773787766695, 0.02105543203651905, -0.03427157551050186, -0.012501749210059643, 0.006917674094438553, -0.0072427308186888695, 0.025194291025400162, 0.046048346906900406, 0.0056813303381204605, 0.015051642432808876, 0.018276041373610497, 0.005235310178250074, 0.022145817056298256, -0.005866255611181259, 0.014178377576172352, 0.06233671307563782, -0.0370272733271122, 0.025209520012140274, 0.04564724490046501, -0.02591399848461151, -0.003158122766762972, 0.05996754392981529, -0.035169899463653564, -0.042207419872283936, 0.0315217450261116, -0.0016918833134695888, 0.03820054978132248, 0.0014939273241907358, -0.004903116729110479, -0.01232499722391367, -0.04636329784989357, 0.010109690949320793, 0.034913238137960434, -0.019329305738210678, -0.02787274681031704, 0.001575224450789392, 0.038730110973119736, -0.03343364968895912, -0.035983093082904816, -0.020603524520993233, 0.04577779397368431, 0.016131652519106865, 0.002001209417358041, 0.05181114375591278, -0.008740290999412537, 0.014360606670379639, -0.016239607706665993, 0.04891559109091759, 0.07844299077987671, 0.07262561470270157, -0.015056120231747627, 0.027895953506231308, -0.021026546135544777, -0.046764958649873734, 0.029699008911848068, 0.014748618006706238, 0.00921523105353117, -0.0573137030005455, 0.03801346942782402, 0.025200048461556435, -0.05310089886188507, 0.014621391892433167, 0.05179920420050621, 0.002443896606564522, -0.02434540167450905, -0.13058462738990784, -0.03148548677563667, 0.03583076596260071, -0.023274634033441544, 0.05146513506770134, -0.08468352258205414, -0.006238227244466543, 0.018880419433116913, 0.06726997345685959, -0.02974017709493637, 0.0416797399520874, 0.00009220096399076283, 0.02911977842450142, -0.0023660443257540464, -0.026285191997885704, -0.0072803739458322525, -0.05009152740240097, -0.059126757085323334, 0.00815222691744566, -0.07693209499120712, 0.014588702470064163, 0.01695777103304863, -0.01513286866247654, -0.019003935158252716, 0.06466712057590485, 0.005725228693336248, -0.0353785939514637, -0.005300532095134258, 0.029833395034074783, -0.03709327429533005, 0.07379355281591415, -0.013603721745312214, 0.02101968787610531, 0.018968427553772926, -0.015061788260936737, -0.0013715927489101887, -0.00798998586833477, 0.05681317299604416, 0.021828902885317802, -0.01704971306025982, -0.01115039549767971, -0.015495512634515762, 0.018783872947096825, -0.010227231308817863, -0.06193868815898895, 0.003629823448136449, -0.001132471952587366, 0.011261947453022003, 0.014611543156206608, 0.01876411959528923, 0.004955085925757885, -0.006601918488740921, 0.026308851316571236, -0.06777682155370712, -0.028290044516324997, -0.04472597688436508, 0.03020254708826542, 0.0041857329197227955, -0.034701962023973465, 0.026886362582445145, -0.016981281340122223, 0.0034705675207078457, 0.006501237396150827, -0.04517236724495888, 0.023133981972932816, -0.005567289888858795, 0.019623644649982452, -0.008912473917007446, 0.006507086101919413, 0.024921653792262077, 0.03848756104707718, -0.010780640877783298, 0.06270844489336014, -0.019439786672592163, -0.055923931300640106, 0.00502574210986495, -0.023108381778001785, 0.016380848363041878, -0.017964407801628113, -0.0302414633333683, -0.03601623699069023, 0.00967302918434143, 0.004435666836798191, 0.00910212006419897, -0.06858464330434799, 0.03581726551055908, 0.07980255782604218, 0.0050505525432527065, 0.009434741921722889, 0.05708890035748482, 0.007941405288875103, 0.014390692114830017, -0.016435204073786736, -0.03655398637056351, -0.05599820986390114, -0.0032135923393070698, 0.020219041034579277, 0.017076807096600533, -0.014249741099774837, 0.02988475188612938, 0.021030621603131294, 0.03974497690796852, 0.004490800201892853, 0.03764800727367401, 0.0035730006638914347, -0.02914184145629406, 0.016432588919997215, 0.019923510029911995, 0.012353730387985706, 0.005548964254558086, -0.03505839407444, 0.0036342209205031395, 0.033744584769010544, 0.015057203359901905, -0.0523945614695549, 0.0284750834107399, -0.04784967377781868, -0.0027016059029847383, -0.03800904378294945, -0.010254161432385445, 0.04057611525058746, -0.018524987623095512, 0.020912012085318565, 0.05609744042158127, 0.020411157980561256, 0.006155880633741617, -0.012038432992994785, -0.018641408532857895, 0.0221849512308836, -0.0014281270559877157, -0.06478097289800644, -0.007858114317059517, 0.006141818594187498, -0.004361950326710939, -0.0019434173591434956, -0.009932750836014748, -0.024598533287644386, -0.022143930196762085, 0.03015575185418129, 0.02053469605743885, -0.00788113009184599, 0.024377601221203804, -0.018746595829725266, -0.06626838445663452, -0.012217973358929157, -0.0044253612868487835, 0.0064496928825974464, 0.002613777993246913, -0.05363306403160095, 0.0030936487019062042, -0.049695421010255814, 0.03710618615150452, 0.029063843190670013, -0.04250948131084442, 0.03602491691708565, -0.013880031183362007, -0.004363699816167355, -0.0391366183757782, -0.016369838267564774, -0.003012441098690033, 0.008336212486028671, -0.03274494782090187, -0.010280956514179707, 0.029286954551935196, -0.0035248680505901575, -0.018964819610118866, 0.04411737993359566, -0.06064210087060928, -0.036512717604637146, -0.04807709902524948, 0.0031326496973633766, 0.021710509434342384, -0.01196028757840395, 0.0777740553021431, 0.03697681799530983, -0.04014139249920845, 0.0028220429085195065, -0.058367908000946045, -0.03392244502902031, 0.010045136325061321, -0.0016350267687812448, 0.028199071064591408, -0.010159281082451344, -0.03732352703809738, 0.03515654057264328, 0.02995353937149048, -0.030169324949383736, -0.013885275460779667, -0.01527407392859459, -0.048585619777441025, -0.045277129858732224, -0.011967330239713192, 0.005726831499487162, -0.0020906508434563875, 0.05986640229821205, 0.02063371241092682, -0.02159571461379528, 0.04530894383788109, -0.011669432744383812, -0.010957303456962109, -0.020288607105612755, -0.0008964826702140272, 0.00012898554268758744, 0.02894004061818123, -0.005157230421900749, 0.0006846539326943457, -0.0054885814897716045, 0.005352885462343693, 0.01428177859634161, 0.0018035975517705083, -0.02289002388715744, -0.0005944397998973727, -0.04696139693260193, 0.01041908748447895, -0.04193885624408722, 0.03331439197063446, 0.015394565649330616, -0.03379245474934578, -0.040344275534152985, 0.01733711175620556, 0.026974378153681755, -0.005938359070569277, 0.03455953672528267, 0.036558978259563446, 0.014864698983728886, 0.002568193944171071, 0.01758015714585781, -0.017115171998739243, -0.01989259384572506, 0.030056791380047798, -0.01787603460252285, -0.0005725264200009406, 0.042713362723588943, 0.012723230756819248, -0.019832704216241837, -0.01742006279528141, -0.013769957236945629, -0.009524625726044178, -0.02953551523387432, 0.026569344103336334, -0.018085122108459473, 0.010312455706298351, 0.007036810740828514, 0.04769706353545189, 0.025797301903367043, 0.006586988922208548, 0.03517494350671768, 0.008177991956472397, -0.04484229534864426, 0.009939956478774548, -0.028329554945230484, -0.01749960519373417, 0.02183254063129425, -0.020144473761320114, 0.01123492419719696, 0.005838356446474791, 0.0029680572915822268, 0.006589105818420649, 0.0037672349717468023, -0.04336301237344742, 0.01817835308611393, -0.0418769009411335, -0.028897680342197418, -0.03040703758597374, 0.01239938847720623, 0.02521304227411747, -0.03404684364795685, 0.04194790869951248, 0.064363032579422, -0.051168546080589294, 0.005143006797879934, 0.004699305631220341, 0.03902057185769081, 0.05212397873401642, 0.034215155988931656, 0.00922485813498497, 0.03475701063871384, 0.0007595681236125529, 0.00814008992165327, 0.004153931513428688, 0.08494461327791214, 0.06361768394708633, 0.00462221447378397, 0.003178928280249238, -0.0675327330827713, -0.032758381217718124, 0.027866575866937637, 0.009490731172263622, 0.01628844626247883, -0.03118029609322548, 0.03955882787704468, 0.03293934836983681, -0.012675442732870579, 0.00023385228996630758, 0.06328783929347992, -0.010325429029762745, 0.01629316806793213, -0.0036093334201723337, 0.011007030494511127, 0.020736470818519592, -0.030627891421318054, 0.01992674730718136, -0.02174515277147293, -0.016030384227633476, 0.0011624948820099235, 0.03624146804213524, -0.01980060711503029, -0.012309963814914227, -0.013104773126542568, 0.01832021400332451, 0.029056275263428688, 0.0034368960186839104, -0.04644399508833885, 0.004778409842401743, 0.019183464348316193, 0.032958704978227615, 0.04419256001710892, -0.0024756949860602617, -0.047702986747026443, 0.03683757036924362, 0.04277926683425903, 0.024126766249537468, 0.0005004366976208985, -0.02101787179708481, -0.05369831249117851, -0.04122576117515564, 0.021588142961263657, 0.008826092816889286, 0.023005099967122078, -0.024578839540481567, 0.0016603925032541156, -0.0029184138402342796, 0.005746420007199049, -0.03682941943407059, -0.018219660967588425, 0.011238192208111286, 0.0076934886164963245, -0.023899653926491737, -0.0016748050693422556, -0.04533617943525314, -0.02627207525074482, 0.030446667224168777, 0.07751257717609406, 0.004980920348316431, -0.02732277661561966, -0.027905184775590897, 0.07004185765981674, -0.045381247997283936, -0.05840284749865532, 0.0003096688014920801, 0.002499349880963564, -0.006921499501913786, 0.05232591927051544, -0.0025670486502349377, -0.031620342284440994, 0.013825470581650734, -0.00792224146425724, -0.004717323929071426, 0.029358549043536186, 0.00334451743401587, 0.06266468018293381, 0.02117503620684147, 0.022452153265476227, 0.07815781235694885, 0.029480723664164543, -0.022343048825860023, 0.0010753126116469502, -0.01797197200357914, 0.027455361559987068, -0.04074865207076073, -0.02569892816245556, -0.0673614963889122, 0.0004430954868439585, -0.041804857552051544, 0.023042602464556694, -0.007960813120007515, 0.008991100825369358, -0.037414081394672394, -0.02168187126517296, 0.028529495000839233, 0.04917910322546959, 0.00370198511518538, -0.00829284731298685, -0.03219551965594292, 0.08054148405790329, -0.008738329634070396, -0.032043859362602234, 0.026455556973814964, -0.009880424477159977, -0.006349609233438969, 0.006980920676141977, -0.0032862499356269836, 0.0018730123993009329, -0.025958290323615074, -0.015505936928093433, -0.0015993899432942271, -0.011689524166285992, 0.034814245998859406, -0.007191881537437439, -0.00043968792306259274, 0.027024248614907265, -0.050832174718379974, 0.006707914639264345, 0.019383855164051056, -0.02080494351685047, 0.03708894923329353, -0.030967583879828453, -0.00549455126747489, 0.005075350403785706, -0.03972442448139191, -0.08817092329263687, -0.035427916795015335, 0.01298990286886692, -0.024811815470457077, -0.008500523865222931, -0.02213366888463497, -0.009544143453240395, -0.05480029433965683, -0.024025162681937218, -0.05824925750494003, 0.0864642933011055, 0.013992009684443474, -0.03072926588356495, 0.02175964042544365, 0.03505780175328255, 0.08645255863666534, -0.010262912139296532, -0.011378916911780834, 0.04346272721886635, -0.022345304489135742, -0.020233366638422012, -0.0032468955032527447, 0.0427076555788517, -0.01981160044670105, 0.01034452486783266, -0.02121790498495102, -0.0003879806026816368, 0.039475731551647186, -0.026453597471117973, -0.05224364995956421, 0.022016538307070732, 0.022077316418290138, -0.01221077237278223, -0.04974289610981941, -0.004053222015500069, -0.0017444519326090813, 0.015833059325814247, -0.01268094964325428, -0.05430959537625313, -0.021107081323862076, -0.042005348950624466, 0.028381001204252243, -0.04650005325675011, -0.007777913473546505, 0.028854932636022568, 0.041319046169519424, -0.015785105526447296, 0.013745998032391071, 0.02777489461004734, -0.007297036703675985, 0.02345028705894947, -0.01117390114814043, 0.0007977102068252861, -0.008549479767680168, -0.0006001286674290895, -0.045508649200201035, -0.04588157311081886, -0.05203136429190636, 0.027647579088807106, 0.08499138802289963, -0.01840928941965103, 0.043002236634492874, 0.03148981183767319, 0.010014544241130352, -0.034592900425195694, -0.029712028801441193, -0.00277700275182724, -0.013931714929640293, -0.018618982285261154, 0.035707008093595505, -0.0306310523301363, -0.006631902884691954, -0.00564344460144639, 0.0014469019370153546, 0.034281160682439804, 0.013157221488654613, 0.009386171586811543, 0.021589886397123337, 0.013843518681824207, 0.009665164165198803, -0.04020904749631882, 0.03593243286013603, -0.011028707027435303, 0.0015907211927697062, -0.008159627206623554, -0.027408206835389137, 0.02784341759979725, 0.012919005006551743, -0.019434306770563126, -0.018938753753900528, -0.037816472351551056, -0.03324934095144272, 0.011863591149449348, 0.03341032564640045, 0.001369813340716064, 0.038551438599824905, 0.008649642579257488, 0.018891997635364532, 0.029353134334087372, 0.048696380108594894, -0.01438937708735466, -0.09737121313810349, -0.02805149555206299, -0.030587097629904747, -0.026539543643593788, 0.017457805573940277, 0.015063951723277569, -0.02357037551701069, -0.009100358001887798, -0.0409805066883564, 0.031404148787260056, -0.013120109215378761, 0.05065149813890457, 0.007682273164391518, 0.09056180715560913, 0.015891756862401962, 0.01751568354666233, -0.03353627771139145, 0.01732501946389675, 0.10394205152988434, 0.07226059585809708, 0.019310466945171356, -0.05097213387489319, 0.01123913936316967, -0.027352692559361458, -0.022194599732756615, -0.041208647191524506, 0.009463539347052574, -0.01981973834335804, 0.0007555505726486444, 0.020787624642252922, 0.04685782268643379, 0.005456655751913786, -0.01062638871371746, 0.049949780106544495, -0.03817632049322128, -0.06783757358789444, -0.007857863791286945, -0.01591673493385315, -0.03213745728135109, 0.003463712288066745, -0.023249611258506775, 0.016790181398391724, -0.0180024616420269, 0.021862095221877098, -0.01208388339728117, -0.00000835689661471406, 0.015616217628121376, -0.027533281594514847, -0.04696965590119362, 0.0006848133634775877, 0.05344659462571144, -0.016046274453401566, -0.03147539123892784, -0.01219889335334301, -0.001924383919686079, 0.011743621900677681, 0.019028164446353912, 0.02112436108291149, -0.0031224999111145735, -0.011248832568526268, 0.039705924689769745, 0.032242074608802795, -0.0018597315065562725, -0.026111861690878868, -0.012152610346674919, 0.05140608921647072, -0.011367646977305412, -0.008360002189874649, 0.01991221308708191, -0.03544418513774872, 0.000050032325816573575, -0.05266603082418442, 0.021387489512562752, -0.0055899303406476974, 0.06589828431606293, -0.03795423358678818, -0.04661502689123154, -0.008376523852348328, 0.020761417225003242, 0.015156812965869904, 0.010127727873623371, -0.0022430524695664644, -0.03533850610256195, 0.019233088940382004, -0.044605907052755356, 0.02835630252957344, 0.00010458266478963196, -0.006325559224933386, -0.024520888924598694, -0.010533287189900875, -0.03321646898984909, -0.04165860638022423, 0.034356940537691116, -0.009097817353904247, 0.04366346448659897, -0.02200108952820301, 0.008335229940712452, -0.02431710809469223, -0.07637520134449005, 0.01668448932468891, -0.015108466148376465, -0.02739299274981022, -0.008918778970837593, -0.0020989892072975636, 0.05499621480703354, 0.04637814685702324, 0.02050076425075531, 0.028299104422330856, -0.02422339655458927, 0.03647717833518982, 0.023950845003128052, -0.02294410951435566, -0.010361816734075546, -0.004435516893863678, -0.03420623391866684, -0.03763464465737343, -0.018054788932204247, 0.036397334188222885, 0.029281923547387123, 0.05970870703458786, -0.031766489148139954, 0.02358754724264145, -0.00716768205165863, -0.021024061366915703, 0.021361442282795906, -0.03597216680645943, -0.0020434276666492224, 0.019226817414164543, 0.008028224110603333, -0.022398239001631737, 0.000017850190488388762, -0.03274202346801758, -0.028379138559103012, -0.012761750258505344, -0.018121397122740746, -0.030406968668103218, -0.01779649779200554, -0.03678923100233078, 0.018240422010421753, -0.03300710767507553, -0.010057813487946987, 0.022186826914548874, 0.03572641313076019, -0.01916947402060032, -0.017892949283123016, -0.00897382851690054, 0.0284811370074749, -0.0056784371845424175, -0.027948513627052307, 0.026088323444128036, 0.021036429330706596, 0.00005903686542296782, -0.007929597049951553, -0.010543451644480228, -0.01959424465894699, 0.05251287296414375, -0.025990966707468033, -0.0014356013853102922, 0.05928327143192291, -0.05872596800327301, -0.03299199417233467, 0.025970429182052612, 0.011792891658842564, 0.018095608800649643, 0.00938533153384924, -0.01720716804265976, -0.03194757550954819, 0.047842733561992645, -0.008210543543100357, 0.008684101514518261, 0.002803811803460121, -0.01299668662250042, 0.005859933327883482, -0.010406560264527798, 0.016569415107369423, 0.007954305037856102, 0.01130266860127449, 0.02832861989736557, 0.05521896481513977, 0.00024027061590459198, 0.01900366134941578, 0.030192038044333458, 0.0096366535872221, 0.0230970811098814, 0.013330581597983837, -0.002807777374982834, 0.05763513594865799, 0.04633154720067978, -0.004185412544757128, 0.014393446035683155, -0.018348658457398415, -0.0008519345428794622, -0.06322218477725983, 0.004871844779700041, 0.037749033421278, 0.004599624779075384, 0.07549984753131866, -0.06209421530365944, -0.012711561284959316, 0.05718407779932022, -0.03984883055090904, 0.0045165084302425385, 0.01789873279631138, 0.010028880089521408, -0.018499376252293587, 0.027584007009863853, -0.03246675059199333, 0.052992649376392365, 0.003131659934297204, 0.03882213309407234, 0.0495026521384716, 0.026074498891830444, 0.023596690967679024, 0.0017319027101621032, -0.011364106088876724, 0.03175673261284828, 0.01776403747498989, -0.0480373352766037, 0.031613096594810486, 0.004406362306326628, -0.023363355547189713, 0.046250782907009125, -0.012224317528307438, -0.0036031799390912056, 0.0101554486900568, 0.04373537749052048, 0.023504575714468956, 0.028838980942964554, 0.05583053082227707, -0.02254430577158928, 0.021845050156116486, 0.007990214042365551, 0.020736845210194588, 0.00487945694476366, 0.004576996900141239, 0.025195511057972908, 0.010858647525310516, -0.03896132484078407, 0.02654332108795643, 0.010442758910357952, 0.0013650191249325871, -0.022595135495066643, -0.003089458215981722, 0.0030581620521843433, 0.027244828641414642, -0.026133645325899124, 0.06048944592475891, -0.0633590966463089, -0.012314235791563988, 0.02588813193142414, 0.02340569533407688, -0.013954434543848038, 0.009167355485260487, -0.024978408589959145, -0.08037836849689484, 0.029831504449248314, 0.023615173995494843, 0.009775997139513493, -0.05367061495780945, -0.025620250031352043, -0.012838110327720642, -0.01949794963002205, -0.006547757424414158, -0.02148149162530899, -0.07672073692083359, 0.04833172261714935, -0.002371546346694231, 0.014420961029827595, 0.016117004677653313, 0.0036118554417043924, 0.021403884515166283, -0.07548552751541138, 0.06729089468717575, 0.011471233330667019, -0.027929067611694336, -0.002306724665686488, 0.009353241883218288, 0.025176065042614937, -0.00004496870678849518, 0.03893189877271652, 0.0036139111034572124, -0.01396709680557251, 0.01497899554669857, 0.04062093049287796, -0.032774556428194046, -0.05682213604450226, 0.04841246083378792, 0.005252518691122532, -0.0016396952560171485, -0.021050503477454185, -0.02486916445195675, 0.007057463750243187, 0.037432096898555756, 0.023205591365695, -0.024885231629014015, 0.015410118736326694, 0.021763840690255165, -0.04676800221204758, 0.031085627153515816, 0.030035072937607765, -0.033716630190610886, 0.056249529123306274, -0.0496513694524765, 0.0031057067681103945, 0.00908410083502531, 0.007407842203974724, -0.04427747428417206, 0.013908002525568008, -0.04561285302042961, -0.042031627148389816, -0.00781419686973095, 0.02100575529038906, 0.02393614687025547, -0.07416459918022156, -0.021339500322937965, 0.05615461990237236, -0.039685849100351334, -0.021351123228669167, 0.05942843481898308, 0.025328444316983223, 0.006305644754320383, 0.03551691398024559, 0.0058286674320697784, 0.02231503091752529, 0.013204451650381088, 0.0030591122340410948, 0.0008480012766085565, 0.028535205870866776, -0.01717078872025013, 0.007514361757785082, 0.007089753169566393, -0.021616779267787933, 0.05390563979744911, -0.042627908289432526, 0.04481803998351097, -0.05601413920521736, 0.01304361131042242, 0.007397508714348078, 0.0049470048397779465, 0.00866719987243414, -0.007000099401921034, -0.023367831483483315, 0.07494138926267624, -0.02971416898071766, -0.0024537534918636084, -0.01595171168446541, -0.005282319150865078, -0.023116188123822212, -0.00674709677696228, 0.02096114493906498, -0.003261334029957652, 0.031213385984301567, 0.006938662845641375, -0.007831829600036144, -0.01506932731717825, 0.01260374952107668, -0.04640578106045723, 0.015841174870729446, -0.00034782435977831483, -0.039254117757081985, -0.027252618223428726, -0.02158709429204464, 0.003844969207420945, -0.0015287920832633972, 0.008922530338168144, 0.017189232632517815, 0.04614194482564926, -0.011308691464364529, -0.013412391766905785, -0.02013835310935974, 0.03327985107898712, -0.06869569420814514, 0.022772591561079025, -0.017464622855186462, -0.021846899762749672, 0.01339624635875225, 0.03794349730014801 ]
<p>I'm trying to analyse a dataset to detect fraudulent insurance claims. Unfortunately, other than basic demographics the rest of the claim is a free format OCR scanned text file made from documents submitted by the patient. These documents include lab tests, hospital bills etc., patient summaries. </p> <p>Right now, manual coding is one option but expensive. </p> <p>Is there any chance that applying textual analysis / text-mining might yield some predictive strength? It need not be perfect but even if it can reliably identify high fraud potential claims, that's a plus. </p> <p>Any ideas how I could model this?</p>
73,747
[ -0.02625960484147072, -0.02684776298701763, -0.018442291766405106, -0.02217472344636917, 0.059543218463659286, 0.01294419914484024, 0.007561182137578726, -0.005859513767063618, 0.043104324489831924, -0.03145165368914604, 0.04784040153026581, 0.02702912501990795, 0.04157082736492157, 0.020981643348932266, 0.03020080178976059, -0.003231795970350504, -0.003837338648736477, -0.004428741987794638, 0.0021728642750531435, -0.023680077865719795, 0.014387416653335094, 0.0038185424637049437, 0.01658533699810505, -0.0105779143050313, -0.006728891283273697, 0.024128125980496407, 0.008081209845840931, -0.027602212503552437, 0.010394125245511532, -0.013181337155401707, -0.028378309682011604, 0.01614672690629959, 0.01242250856012106, 0.02927200309932232, 0.03368305787444115, -0.005910804960876703, -0.058434806764125824, -0.026489080861210823, -0.006235653534531593, 0.017863718792796135, -0.02208528481423855, -0.016909824684262276, 0.02399350516498089, 0.04265020787715912, -0.009625318460166454, 0.004791089799255133, -0.03125796467065811, -0.025218777358531952, -0.02530757710337639, -0.05047503486275673, 0.04880787804722786, -0.0326625294983387, 0.03420495241880417, 0.02031933143734932, 0.008875038474798203, -0.02345927059650421, 0.038183532655239105, 0.08504300564527512, 0.008198056370019913, -0.04251953214406967, -0.055007096379995346, 0.04060801491141319, 0.014615578576922417, -0.029850361868739128, -0.047650281339883804, 0.05517932027578354, -0.04561682790517807, -0.05677887052297592, 0.021139953285455704, -0.025021161884069443, 0.008914830163121223, 0.026826240122318268, 0.01949840784072876, -0.0024597765877842903, 0.013114171102643013, -0.01399501133710146, -0.022456133738160133, -0.009600561112165451, 0.0005696311709471047, 0.008644972927868366, 0.017082950100302696, -0.01843196339905262, 0.007484534289687872, 0.015874771401286125, 0.021168170496821404, 0.0076520382426679134, 0.06238458305597305, -0.011109971441328526, 0.035859521478414536, 0.009991432540118694, 0.01409770455211401, 0.027125053107738495, 0.03290112316608429, 0.009546341374516487, -0.011156782507896423, 0.00508610624819994, -0.037893135100603104, 0.0392238050699234, 0.036097824573516846, -0.004098064731806517, -0.004240068141371012, -0.03689086437225342, -0.019555769860744476, 0.06375787407159805, -0.023935329169034958, -0.05531158298254013, -0.01715022511780262, -0.050162483006715775, 0.005394538398832083, -0.0043964684009552, -0.024131763726472855, 0.006409680936485529, 0.03295673802495003, -0.011842241510748863, 0.024324631318449974, -0.002000564942136407, -0.0019248051103204489, -0.048563502728939056, 0.015943801030516624, 0.034567490220069885, 0.018770616501569748, -0.01721329800784588, 0.053099580109119415, -0.02852075733244419, -0.010965349152684212, 0.008699152618646622, 0.007400098256766796, -0.020522771403193474, -0.021638160571455956, 0.08512721210718155, -0.009759972803294659, -0.04158717393875122, 0.030567172914743423, -0.010157495737075806, 0.028530161827802658, 0.01664835773408413, -0.07213399559259415, -0.05831070616841316, -0.00008735914889257401, 0.01319592259824276, 0.044367022812366486, -0.021852616220712662, -0.029863547533750534, 0.021712040528655052, 0.02012636698782444, 0.016238417476415634, 0.045505885034799576, 0.018378181383013725, -0.03398977965116501, -0.002889274386689067, -0.025338850915431976, -0.005751117132604122, 0.0007522500236518681, 0.04051344096660614, -0.029077650979161263, -0.06728395819664001, -0.007686958182603121, 0.011280670762062073, -0.02929997816681862, -0.04458552971482277, 0.0071119568310678005, 0.0008379056816920638, 0.027449315413832664, -0.01569586619734764, -0.017646195366978645, -0.026975741609930992, 0.057467471808195114, 0.024725979194045067, 0.043180912733078, 0.047395024448633194, 0.014088073745369911, 0.05545094609260559, 0.026026243343949318, 0.014243350364267826, 0.03408781439065933, 0.008236945606768131, 0.03115079738199711, -0.006954928394407034, 0.020058268681168556, -0.0036287368275225163, 0.004262283910065889, -0.04658852890133858, -0.04221784323453903, -0.006161055527627468, 0.015366348437964916, 0.017197685316205025, 0.003539163386449218, -0.04427618533372879, 0.0603262297809124, -0.04153967276215553, -0.027416860684752464, -0.061983875930309296, 0.027237677946686745, -0.060281071811914444, -0.0228385329246521, 0.03414994105696678, -0.01043449342250824, 0.03228073567152023, -0.02536817640066147, -0.016782399266958237, -0.0347328782081604, -0.00428657466545701, 0.056733936071395874, -0.03253350779414177, 0.010070087388157845, 0.013876632787287235, -0.012911159545183182, -0.00912460032850504, 0.05063539743423462, -0.030864456668496132, -0.05753061920404434, -0.011361935175955296, -0.03976553678512573, 0.02918298915028572, -0.05029644817113876, -0.0076251705177128315, 0.06598468124866486, -0.015924904495477676, 0.004734240937978029, 0.008658076636493206, -0.06260374188423157, 0.060423754155635834, 0.03241567686200142, 0.035094618797302246, -0.03580120578408241, -0.005610951688140631, 0.02945636212825775, 0.020601343363523483, -0.009894060902297497, -0.041917577385902405, -0.0629468709230423, -0.004954320378601551, 0.041110362857580185, 0.016018379479646683, -0.02971612475812435, -0.005646200384944677, 0.066615030169487, 0.019687309861183167, 0.00850324984639883, -0.020750215277075768, -0.0204435046762228, -0.00837569497525692, 0.00928469281643629, 0.027686459943652153, -0.031047629192471504, 0.007291942369192839, 0.03164881840348244, 0.01629108004271984, 0.042912136763334274, 0.009891060180962086, 0.010640403255820274, 0.0184641033411026, 0.012486318126320839, -0.0028392765671014786, -0.01641950011253357, -0.03795424848794937, 0.05850696936249733, -0.02780572511255741, 0.013637715019285679, 0.020677831023931503, -0.002181927440688014, 0.0132945217192173, 0.011773972772061825, -0.026998862624168396, 0.027234219014644623, 0.04446425661444664, 0.016815975308418274, 0.02273612469434738, 0.021032603457570076, -0.06311111897230148, 0.04669945314526558, -0.012357177212834358, -0.02137569710612297, -0.013168728910386562, 0.058715399354696274, 0.026098771020770073, 0.0035957619547843933, 0.0048443335108459, 0.01141225267201662, -0.03653334453701973, 0.05962130054831505, 0.013925621286034584, 0.02447163127362728, 0.025485007092356682, -0.061337631195783615, -0.045770175755023956, -0.020572321489453316, -0.03213491663336754, 0.06084931641817093, 0.0005553422961384058, -0.014318105764687061, 0.0010064849629998207, -0.030362648889422417, -0.05531942471861839, -0.002207346959039569, -0.015785222873091698, 0.005871477071195841, -0.005533207673579454, -0.001821398618631065, -0.01740981452167034, -0.007066560443490744, 0.0021220557391643524, 0.014396105892956257, 0.00027052685618400574, -0.011619643308222294, -0.04423697665333748, 0.005047466140240431, 0.003669882193207741, 0.0035257439594715834, 0.011278526857495308, 0.010128292255103588, -0.01940980926156044, -0.00695608789101243, -0.06384669244289398, -0.05613579601049423, 0.0377299040555954, -0.04180345684289932, 0.007705244235694408, 0.0047198450192809105, -0.021376216784119606, 0.04390435293316841, 0.01374410092830658, -0.03242058679461479, -0.03319348022341728, -0.042329587042331696, -0.0714954137802124, -0.04240203648805618, -0.008309907279908657, 0.032943543046712875, 0.018324896693229675, 0.012156631797552109, -0.02022702805697918, 0.0059359194710850716, 0.07003919780254364, -0.004290283191949129, -0.005190938711166382, 0.038650814443826675, -0.03040854074060917, 0.0045015751384198666, -0.00492709269747138, 0.056306563317775726, -0.007740442641079426, 0.03669096902012825, 0.03010059893131256, 0.02670489251613617, 0.0449504479765892, -0.0623362772166729, -0.023293422535061836, 0.014702987857162952, 0.019017057493329048, -0.007348521146923304, -0.023090871050953865, -0.010742745362222195, -0.03278622403740883, -0.039567332714796066, 0.019757213070988655, 0.017782006412744522, -0.012203404679894447, -0.0012466327752918005, 0.0642537921667099, 0.038676511496305466, 0.0012548845261335373, 0.009776397608220577, -0.05383394658565521, -0.025829458609223366, 0.00957301165908575, -0.03442082181572914, 0.030213648453354836, 0.03548411652445793, 0.03532852232456207, 0.027101969346404076, 0.031758423894643784, -0.012551982887089252, 0.04509035497903824, -0.05513172596693039, -0.05199335515499115, -0.019156774505972862, 0.06126587465405464, 0.00010792530520120636, 0.011142999865114689, 0.009108384139835835, -0.03139985725283623, -0.0020413061138242483, 0.042468175292015076, -0.0618346631526947, -0.0005050635081715882, -0.009790572337806225, 0.03230338543653488, 0.006737206131219864, -0.0384516678750515, 0.0025548397097736597, -0.011220347136259079, -0.021814024075865746, -0.014197943732142448, 0.03882608935236931, -0.03091530315577984, 0.025880636647343636, 0.0201426949352026, -0.0005794194294139743, 0.005953983869403601, 0.013660147786140442, -0.011664890684187412, 0.030660701915621758, 0.0005473518976941705, 0.04359051212668419, 0.03231705725193024, -0.04978565499186516, -0.047754716128110886, 0.012744783423841, 0.012133898213505745, 0.02271895483136177, 0.025258393958210945, -0.0022465684451162815, -0.06292897462844849, 0.03154689073562622, -0.010889304801821709, 0.03468289598822594, 0.009712288156151772, 0.004138314165174961, -0.009173995815217495, -0.05938122048974037, -0.03672243282198906, 0.03540416061878204, 0.005224177613854408, -0.013280780985951424, -0.005645948927849531, 0.016114985570311546, 0.015583443455398083, -0.08581096678972244, 0.006362121552228928, 0.08562906831502914, 0.04218655079603195, 0.013933776877820492, 0.01086956262588501, -0.0493464358150959, 0.015169388614594936, -0.02071927674114704, 0.043595459312200546, 0.02374490350484848, -0.04573056474328041, -0.014608597382903099, 0.03291790559887886, -0.0657755434513092, -0.047395654022693634, -0.021972347050905228, 0.01762406900525093, 0.004247054923325777, 0.01654226705431938, 0.018899453803896904, 0.05927285552024841, 0.05435957759618759, 0.028598155826330185, 0.03560476750135422, 0.0033644582144916058, -0.11988244205713272, 0.0006306081777438521, 0.04342552274465561, 0.06393446773290634, -0.043875373899936676, -0.04122200980782509, -0.04365336894989014, -0.02068680338561535, 0.034523699432611465, -0.009559676051139832, -0.013157241977751255, 0.02227851003408432, -0.007793636526912451, -0.009662166237831116, 0.006976566277444363, -0.03628279268741608, 0.025354430079460144, 0.010215344838798046, 0.05305151268839836, -0.02872619219124317, -0.017373405396938324, -0.03650423139333725, -0.005444055423140526, 0.009724825620651245, 0.025495590642094612, -0.01578567549586296, -0.011083008721470833, -0.01732584647834301, 0.02122652344405651, -0.03850420564413071, -0.08114052563905716, -0.020601559430360794, -0.023968178778886795, 0.00932964589446783, 0.055219125002622604, 0.0025652037002146244, -0.017418446019291878, -0.008049864321947098, 0.013092968612909317, -0.0372956357896328, -0.04290464147925377, -0.03936760872602463, 0.030738433822989464, 0.03231314942240715, 0.023885227739810944, 0.030747277662158012, 0.030622759833931923, 0.02031012251973152, 0.032668665051460266, -0.03892626240849495, 0.029495105147361755, -0.021250203251838684, -0.012349269352853298, -0.02801000140607357, -0.0221935473382473, -0.004499764181673527, 0.011700938455760479, 0.03855322673916817, 0.04538685455918312, -0.03874584287405014, 0.02508464641869068, -0.0010362614411860704, 0.013625300489366055, -0.009679780341684818, -0.03275323659181595, -0.015351523645222187, 0.022362247109413147, -0.00829220935702324, -0.02537798136472702, 0.03150975704193115, -0.020511476323008537, 0.002684541279450059, 0.02433481626212597, -0.017183734104037285, -0.03380538895726204, -0.023612601682543755, -0.005878238473087549, 0.011375711299479008, 0.02154013328254223, 0.06449471414089203, -0.0012386643793433905, 0.03190845623612404, 0.0029632379300892353, -0.032192859798669815, -0.004340630955994129, 0.034379519522190094, 0.0175985898822546, 0.04337739571928978, 0.013969999738037586, 0.03764842823147774, -0.025173723697662354, -0.027477502822875977, -0.04160445183515549, -0.05770155042409897, 0.05811256915330887, 0.015154908411204815, -0.0581975020468235, -0.03629540279507637, 0.02218296378850937, -0.0026460601948201656, -0.037076663225889206, -0.017096228897571564, 0.07828942686319351, -0.03407471254467964, -0.01422389131039381, 0.013029707595705986, -0.039195116609334946, 0.10735396295785904, 0.0021944495383650064, -0.01130324974656105, 0.05750645324587822, -0.02008751966059208, -0.0007781437016092241, -0.040569644421339035, 0.030007176101207733, -0.025295624509453773, -0.028888868167996407, -0.0744759663939476, 0.022831730544567108, 0.03016827255487442, 0.010507828556001186, 0.03301023691892624, -0.00736531475558877, 0.018314938992261887, 0.0246047992259264, -0.033766474574804306, -0.008978805504739285, 0.030173595994710922, 0.013010542839765549, -0.029504192993044853, 0.01361079327762127, -0.017238769680261612, 0.01026367861777544, 0.012973456643521786, 0.04550487920641899, -0.019516266882419586, 0.050257544964551926, 0.07127098739147186, -0.02523006871342659, 0.0003992323181591928, -0.00523298978805542, -0.030356688424944878, 0.06359187513589859, 0.00581486988812685, 0.007345980033278465, 0.0031950529664754868, 0.03467366844415665, -0.05688267946243286, -0.03759700804948807, -0.016785625368356705, -0.01873086206614971, 0.029597988352179527, 0.02861732617020607, 0.02379111386835575, 0.03030550666153431, -0.009950492531061172, -0.030377790331840515, -0.05235559120774269, -0.043137259781360626, 0.012479516677558422, -0.011826706118881702, 0.00833173468708992, -0.008626057766377926, 0.004433360882103443, 0.02233564294874668, -0.003043984994292259, 0.03081960417330265, 0.029815811663866043, 0.04423096403479576, 0.004324046429246664, 0.03400234505534172, -0.01343145128339529, -0.02980809472501278, 0.009790210984647274, -0.06718132644891739, 0.03879913315176964, -0.018263310194015503, -0.011432315222918987, 0.027566205710172653, 0.04787980392575264, 0.00631011463701725, -0.013192949816584587, -0.022988656535744667, -0.0679776519536972, 0.026906713843345642, 0.022640053182840347, -0.02313145063817501, 0.06363660097122192, 0.006982543505728245, 0.03857928887009621, -0.0023976736702024937, 0.02856363356113434, -0.026737401261925697, -0.08692888170480728, 0.0048515647649765015, -0.03186916559934616, -0.02526659332215786, 0.03350178152322769, 0.03241109475493431, 0.008303120732307434, 0.023603960871696472, -0.04449191689491272, 0.03877433016896248, 0.00447219330817461, 0.02555914968252182, -0.01819806545972824, 0.03585107624530792, -0.02385232411324978, 0.02297591045498848, 0.021947531029582024, -0.036920394748449326, 0.13793842494487762, 0.09271489828824997, 0.024338265880942345, -0.06541381776332855, 0.04598921164870262, 0.007415417581796646, 0.007610101252794266, -0.03276762738823891, 0.017896000295877457, 0.00044956713099963963, -0.0019353872630745173, 0.03689137473702431, 0.046046461910009384, -0.011264187283813953, 0.025842180475592613, 0.055332574993371964, -0.04228619486093521, 0.008205807767808437, 0.010119551792740822, 0.007785043213516474, -0.001423486857675016, 0.008835169486701488, -0.06412958353757858, 0.027658626437187195, -0.004618722014129162, -0.07863122224807739, -0.037094857543706894, 0.009100212715566158, 0.02062777802348137, -0.014940745197236538, -0.010870152153074741, -0.02044103667140007, 0.006678876932710409, 0.031502023339271545, 0.012513051740825176, -0.0119439996778965, 0.0010994873009622097, -0.013506809249520302, 0.0012106959475204349, 0.020739782601594925, 0.016334841027855873, -0.024963414296507835, 0.009110849350690842, 0.025218090042471886, -0.04815155267715454, 0.0016040741465985775, -0.03918835520744324, 0.035576943308115005, -0.010236668400466442, 0.011575577780604362, -0.023387672379612923, -0.004071881528943777, -0.001691316836513579, -0.02268563024699688, -0.02866072952747345, -0.0021306369453668594, 0.00969059020280838, -0.012369537726044655, 0.011877655982971191, -0.010736161842942238, 0.03773190453648567, 0.009456994011998177, 0.02470909059047699, 0.003705241484567523, -0.01606667786836624, -0.012455010786652565, -0.03485124930739403, 0.00797948520630598, 0.0021422537975013256, -0.013121627271175385, 0.011463112197816372, 0.006947680376470089, -0.005032490473240614, 0.012068626470863819, -0.012781229801476002, 0.03201242536306381, -0.030931446701288223, -0.0009461563895456493, 0.006342342123389244, -0.01133593637496233, -0.027123337611556053, 0.054507169872522354, -0.020081238821148872, 0.011727484874427319, -0.060932476073503494, -0.02481437660753727, 0.003457411425188184, 0.030009081587195396, 0.01844460889697075, 0.03359191119670868, 0.031773053109645844, 0.06088380515575409, 0.024259600788354874, -0.03168277442455292, 0.0067400140687823296, -0.047865066677331924, -0.03306058794260025, 0.014193570241332054, -0.006760465446859598, 0.06548965722322464, 0.014294616878032684, 0.015218098647892475, 0.01188479084521532, 0.011374728754162788, -0.001452709431760013, -0.02610168233513832, -0.005302709061652422, -0.032927967607975006, -0.02156931348145008, 0.005616799462586641, -0.01065925695002079, -0.00889483280479908, -0.024777669459581375, -0.015098587609827518, -0.045418526977300644, 0.04746759682893753, 0.009093883447349072, -0.03982850909233093, 0.06951212137937546, -0.015869174152612686, 0.033385589718818665, -0.014302479103207588, 0.019038917496800423, -0.03387663885951042, -0.023987121880054474, -0.010481310077011585, -0.05433010309934616, -0.008192772045731544, 0.01024993322789669, 0.022532179951667786, -0.0038881574291735888, 0.016458597034215927, 0.001711987890303135, -0.027974065393209457, 0.002013441873714328, 0.019870875403285027, -0.023087678477168083, 0.00604954594746232, -0.05117495357990265, 0.006598104257136583, 0.021326879039406776, -0.04566158354282379, -0.00729335704818368, 0.015207082033157349, -0.04124176874756813, 0.0017349229892715812, 0.006291249766945839, 0.0030909727793186903, 0.02617037482559681, 0.05405092239379883, -0.02931394800543785, -0.030940411612391472, -0.0148216113448143, 0.020599612966179848, -0.026104507967829704, 0.0063346559181809425, 0.03476095572113991, -0.001841402263380587, -0.03429301083087921, 0.009007277898490429, 0.04078955575823784, 0.028720172122120857, -0.01862001232802868, 0.030522707849740982, -0.02346828393638134, 0.01226666010916233, 0.027426328510046005, 0.012656621634960175, 0.024591904133558273, 0.005692079197615385, -0.03513890132308006, 0.015061469748616219, -0.005294822156429291, 0.005178671795874834, -0.0727759450674057, -0.02965841442346573, 0.035487283021211624, -0.015833556652069092, 0.032154232263565063, -0.051577139645814896, -0.05398276075720787, 0.000016711719581508078, -0.046928513795137405, 0.030065812170505524, -0.02679261565208435, -0.013917326927185059, -0.036945268511772156, 0.0054639782756567, -0.0492006279528141, -0.015118421986699104, 0.018949268385767937, 0.034886498004198074, 0.03519091010093689, 0.0463021956384182, 0.00009659853822086006, -0.02145807258784771, 0.008257719688117504, 0.01940312422811985, 0.02233014442026615, -0.06713153421878815, 0.018088998273015022, -0.07723180949687958, -0.016424044966697693, 0.009974375367164612, -0.012187096290290356, 0.037003375589847565, 0.04221820458769798, -0.003957527689635754, 0.023772098124027252, 0.010712992399930954, 0.005712411366403103, 0.005803728476166725, 0.006121449172496796, -0.01315975096076727, 0.02762307971715927, 0.039316218346357346, -0.02546262927353382, 0.03356892615556717, 0.002893635770305991, -0.006033003795892, 0.0075736455619335175, 0.036727726459503174, -0.04255957901477814, -0.023715540766716003, -0.03076213411986828, 0.025471067056059837, 0.033983055502176285, -0.02460208721458912, 0.037966907024383545, -0.03865024074912071, 0.015192902646958828, 0.03772637993097305, 0.042031146585941315, -0.0015242475783452392, 0.013389348052442074, -0.03999510034918785, -0.02410457842051983, 0.002672772854566574, 0.014258350245654583, -0.0061022271402180195, -0.03222252056002617, 0.002151650609448552, -0.003638734808191657, 0.01034396793693304, -0.007886992767453194, 0.010532425716519356, 0.029459156095981598, 0.02770179510116577, -0.028135914355516434, -0.002084173960611224, 0.06657809764146805, -0.026236891746520996, 0.0349397212266922, -0.05853841081261635, 0.05731862783432007, 0.0014486188301816583, 0.005361905321478844, -0.029315870255231857, -0.03794489800930023, -0.03261532261967659, -0.020547494292259216, 0.07511364668607712, -0.035279370844364166, 0.002285249065607786, -0.044741541147232056, -0.01214815303683281, 0.009973032400012016, -0.01507923100143671, 0.06311224400997162, -0.05828342214226723, -0.01824161596596241, -0.027668168768286705, 0.010842883959412575, -0.01083434745669365, 0.00212165922857821, 0.017063608393073082, -0.0013457838213071227, -0.00491360342130065, 0.004273265600204468, -0.021905949339270592, -0.005152889993041754, 0.02911095693707466, 0.01142408698797226, 0.061293162405490875, -0.002502769697457552, 0.004656066186726093, 0.019717495888471603, -0.006542259827256203, -0.044600196182727814, 0.015753716230392456, -0.006558166351169348, -0.005192632786929607, 0.015986453741788864, 0.029854528605937958, -0.0271221324801445, -0.06800547242164612, 0.05583303049206734, 0.026414809748530388, 0.010320262052118778, 0.03123132325708866, 0.019552158191800117, 0.015213528648018837, 0.008388921618461609, -0.011108195409178734, -0.0023158411495387554, 0.013282610103487968, -0.04098319262266159, -0.008613522164523602, -0.004565691575407982, 0.02344168908894062, -0.0008534681983292103, 0.0179838165640831, 0.03986288234591484, -0.018473923206329346, 0.040561776608228683, 0.012870924547314644, 0.021608956158161163, -0.058590393513441086, -0.007495983969420195, -0.020603742450475693, 0.04421526566147804, 0.02419114112854004, 0.021996375173330307, -0.017634594812989235, 0.06546788662672043, -0.012616651132702827, 0.027197951450943947, -0.05840553715825081, -0.02983679808676243, -0.02167731150984764, 0.01715179905295372, 0.04193491488695145, 0.019288022071123123, 0.010497433133423328, -0.016707101836800575, -0.010049641132354736, 0.041532400995492935, 0.03208959847688675, -0.006666635163128376, 0.01565439999103546, -0.02773417718708515, -0.016837680712342262, -0.02243773266673088, -0.044674765318632126, 0.0008762743091210723, 0.024478359147906303, -0.011221246793866158, 0.00771684106439352, 0.02583557926118374, -0.003810090711340308, -0.017782391980290413, -0.0012371683260425925, 0.031112737953662872, -0.0720413476228714, 0.023367976769804955, -0.046782419085502625, 0.0023039227817207575, -0.006801628042012453, -0.01998714916408062 ]
<p>I have two matrices with multiple variables. The two matrices come from same sample.I would call them matrix A and Matrix B.Each of them have many correlated variables .</p> <p>I would want to evaluate the relationship between matrix A and matrix B taking matrix B as explanatory and matrix A as dependent . When i looked at the structure of Matrix A .I was able to describe it into 4 factors and matrix B into 3 factors.</p> <p>I fitted a mancova model using factor scores of matrix A and factor scores of matrix B.</p> <p>Is this a valid way to do the analysis.</p>
36,219
[ -0.017524296417832375, 0.010104280896484852, -0.005461394786834717, -0.0068120588548481464, 0.07597086578607559, 0.006102473475039005, -0.019630862399935722, 0.008991403505206108, 0.02892345003783703, -0.031838417053222656, 0.024299506098031998, 0.0012076935963705182, 0.0386202409863472, 0.001086384174413979, 0.011166498064994812, 0.01193823292851448, 0.027236776426434517, 0.005605205427855253, 0.020420527085661888, 0.01242038980126381, -0.007633741945028305, 0.009061682038009167, 0.025739066302776337, -0.0006682772655040026, -0.015795426443219185, 0.05852096155285835, 0.015551821328699589, -0.03761427849531174, 0.008540697395801544, 0.01472969725728035, -0.011676287278532982, -0.022011201828718185, 0.025750158354640007, 0.023545626550912857, 0.011602680198848248, -0.004114041570574045, -0.046201884746551514, -0.007322740741074085, 0.01342520397156477, 0.01611965522170067, -0.010896550491452217, -0.05990685522556305, 0.027281614020466805, 0.05206967517733574, -0.015416222624480724, 0.01893184334039688, 0.0011093508219346404, -0.017296824604272842, 0.0016516029136255383, -0.027209646999835968, 0.11225159466266632, 0.012342472560703754, 0.0432007722556591, 0.032411497086286545, -0.05852503329515457, -0.02751896344125271, 0.05248745530843735, 0.05569618567824364, 0.01739060878753662, -0.03783942013978958, -0.012743925675749779, -0.0016689730109646916, 0.01587294042110443, -0.019376618787646294, -0.04425344616174698, 0.03551188483834267, -0.03887518495321274, -0.01900540105998516, 0.057773444801568985, -0.029118534177541733, 0.008327648974955082, 0.0049744765274226665, 0.05114608630537987, -0.06216609477996826, 0.01194232702255249, -0.0420258566737175, 0.048863958567380905, 0.022091172635555267, 0.04810228571295738, 0.027434948831796646, 0.018336094915866852, 0.05204355716705322, -0.0072907754220068455, 0.02080174721777439, 0.03711247816681862, 0.00898725911974907, 0.07032866775989532, -0.050537679344415665, 0.007172426208853722, 0.015560513362288475, -0.0129828667268157, 0.004633576609194279, 0.059574492275714874, 0.04672429338097572, -0.059077899903059006, 0.014001714996993542, -0.015574641525745392, 0.043400198221206665, 0.03650778532028198, -0.02971840649843216, -0.01933872513473034, -0.001100527006201446, 0.01608162187039852, 0.007460005581378937, 0.01726062409579754, 0.025472037494182587, -0.010548603720963001, 0.02953174151480198, -0.0088375648483634, -0.031300581991672516, -0.02307814359664917, 0.04821809381246567, -0.009381497278809547, 0.0035922559909522533, 0.04054152965545654, -0.030163221061229706, -0.0015446076868101954, -0.0039792172610759735, 0.05303356051445007, 0.06985809653997421, 0.026350948959589005, -0.04027160629630089, -0.0016151682939380407, -0.01740480773150921, -0.05563543736934662, 0.00631713168695569, -0.007359969429671764, -0.006893687881529331, -0.03574628382921219, 0.055049240589141846, 0.012017369270324707, -0.014138046652078629, -0.0058365813456475735, -0.006966801360249519, 0.013057145290076733, -0.009648016653954983, -0.10755854845046997, -0.028926488012075424, 0.04625071585178375, -0.016047129407525063, 0.02811736986041069, -0.0456729419529438, 0.018565339967608452, 0.03469691798090935, 0.09931638091802597, 0.007669189944863319, 0.022934556007385254, 0.0385945625603199, 0.048486556857824326, -0.02548796683549881, -0.024162815883755684, -0.022357124835252762, -0.04226405546069145, -0.04052567481994629, -0.015179164707660675, -0.07756663113832474, 0.016450272873044014, 0.012177052907645702, 0.030950523912906647, 0.01747896894812584, 0.02746460773050785, 0.024749116972088814, -0.041691944003105164, 0.011762321926653385, -0.006148233078420162, -0.012351010926067829, 0.0073173330165445805, -0.04166450351476669, 0.03515550121665001, 0.027076780796051025, -0.021587327122688293, 0.01597631722688675, 0.0003494591510389, 0.05169994384050369, 0.017138129100203514, -0.002224542899057269, -0.0033652931451797485, 0.005751335993409157, 0.037726111710071564, -0.00622370233759284, -0.07927175611257553, -0.0783858373761177, -0.010679168626666069, -0.007713687140494585, 0.037752915173769, 0.04983513802289963, -0.006952410098165274, 0.005310314241796732, 0.0006026976625435054, -0.018129903823137283, -0.044980473816394806, -0.047030024230480194, 0.02230379357933998, -0.017642512917518616, -0.04109117388725281, 0.014147259294986725, -0.03489572927355766, 0.025793738663196564, 0.035025957971811295, -0.011119803413748741, -0.02382725290954113, -0.027015017345547676, 0.010297473520040512, -0.029816048219799995, 0.03712395951151848, 0.029902994632720947, 0.06097930669784546, 0.004404235165566206, 0.0361795574426651, -0.04776569828391075, -0.04100637510418892, 0.028866393491625786, -0.01863333210349083, 0.006068674847483635, 0.004996637813746929, -0.017310524359345436, 0.01274353452026844, -0.0017113512149080634, -0.039384063333272934, 0.03038964606821537, -0.03995843604207039, 0.04044036939740181, 0.04471719637513161, -0.0017148848855867982, -0.0038254756946116686, 0.014920856803655624, 0.030255572870373726, 0.027731677517294884, -0.015244003385305405, -0.013354171998798847, -0.06911420077085495, -0.019584838300943375, 0.0183334369212389, 0.044339410960674286, -0.05973966792225838, 0.018039731308817863, 0.039109449833631516, 0.023341597989201546, -0.013043556362390518, 0.054306261241436005, -0.0045104436576366425, 0.0033429418690502644, 0.0025052702985703945, 0.03776170685887337, -0.00037900489405728877, 0.006263279356062412, -0.022351739928126335, 0.015692586079239845, 0.03859401494264603, -0.02588597685098648, -0.0003165444650221616, 0.060411252081394196, 0.0004737201670650393, -0.008505425415933132, 0.006297391839325428, -0.0017440435476601124, 0.03432809188961983, -0.0017419118667021394, 0.017200449481606483, 0.021687055006623268, -0.006704320199787617, -0.029428591951727867, -0.007255788426846266, -0.028092024847865105, 0.015311784110963345, 0.04888048768043518, -0.04119541496038437, -0.014266155660152435, 0.0036689445842057467, -0.03418427333235741, 0.010406401008367538, -0.01904713548719883, -0.015156676061451435, 0.0048055704683065414, 0.005369868129491806, 0.03706253319978714, 0.022322354838252068, 0.054748523980379105, -0.01120684016495943, -0.01541044469922781, 0.013124671764671803, -0.04651801660656929, -0.00025063843349926174, -0.017738202586770058, -0.03589091822504997, 0.0020717934239655733, -0.027874387800693512, -0.006622907239943743, 0.027053842321038246, -0.007793848402798176, -0.011171390302479267, 0.03972383588552475, 0.005927027203142643, -0.03416528180241585, -0.029159963130950928, 0.009749454446136951, 0.01806795969605446, -0.005133818369358778, -0.02923489920794964, 0.025920122861862183, 0.0003583084908314049, -0.031210172921419144, -0.008129669353365898, -0.043966375291347504, 0.016173196956515312, 0.013192294165492058, -0.0030913986265659332, -0.00392943387851119, 0.0026398126501590014, 0.01684366725385189, 0.029923032969236374, -0.03880702331662178, -0.012189529836177826, -0.058377329260110855, -0.04787864908576012, 0.03657788783311844, 0.012713355012238026, 0.012828665785491467, 0.015780916437506676, -0.030328137800097466, 0.06987519562244415, 0.010783636942505836, -0.022667735815048218, -0.06636785715818405, -0.02683759480714798, -0.057166408747434616, -0.03192226216197014, 0.04573030397295952, -0.00992288812994957, 0.009842591360211372, 0.02531423047184944, 0.006123741623014212, 0.01986873522400856, 0.05136936902999878, 0.008824526332318783, 0.005215137731283903, 0.022764859721064568, 0.015179984271526337, -0.04138568788766861, 0.02176952175796032, -0.007895676419138908, -0.004537468310445547, 0.0157256331294775, 0.014208589680492878, 0.024138744920492172, 0.015966538339853287, -0.020714644342660904, 0.014768524095416069, -0.0233183354139328, 0.01970651000738144, -0.0501173734664917, 0.00790382269769907, 0.022234413772821426, 0.01313034538179636, -0.009525270201265812, -0.0006111804395914078, 0.020595170557498932, -0.014332628808915615, 0.0006496672285720706, 0.06444135308265686, 0.03666960820555687, -0.02767002023756504, -0.032186467200517654, -0.007666145451366901, 0.004436367657035589, 0.028175152838230133, -0.016037091612815857, -0.015669869258999825, 0.041876181960105896, 0.00715623889118433, 0.027535803616046906, -0.007392791099846363, -0.03452462702989578, 0.030021697282791138, -0.07687017321586609, 0.03621037304401398, -0.056459929794073105, 0.01969788409769535, 0.015141475945711136, 0.04664480686187744, 0.0036158680450171232, -0.017749657854437828, 0.04234633967280388, -0.00005929001054028049, -0.0658126249909401, 0.011488347314298153, -0.02123352326452732, 0.01185605302453041, 0.01560765877366066, -0.04650265350937843, 0.020286770537495613, -0.005763308610767126, -0.022991452366113663, 0.015170345082879066, 0.028660228475928307, -0.038141872733831406, 0.01714911311864853, -0.03804890811443329, -0.02276567555963993, -0.0026396422181278467, -0.018115023151040077, 0.032699018716812134, -0.017488937824964523, 0.04149872437119484, 0.07151847332715988, -0.03127669543027878, -0.007328398060053587, -0.017759835347533226, -0.005578724201768637, 0.037027809768915176, 0.04585767537355423, 0.01010522898286581, 0.03872012719511986, -0.01883019134402275, 0.0361761674284935, -0.011664684861898422, 0.005528883542865515, 0.039102595299482346, -0.02047785371541977, -0.030381858348846436, -0.03311645984649658, -0.013451701030135155, 0.005601720884442329, -0.010778323747217655, 0.00013220778782851994, -0.012361039407551289, 0.029429085552692413, 0.040300942957401276, -0.02411174215376377, 0.024192342534661293, 0.05690092220902443, 0.029402857646346092, -0.005725408438593149, -0.020064761862158775, -0.00023329630494117737, -0.02611527591943741, -0.032191913574934006, 0.045277662575244904, 0.008929182775318623, -0.021193673834204674, -0.02044420875608921, 0.056177351623773575, -0.023471912369132042, -0.02374538965523243, 0.03762759268283844, 0.010926691815257072, 0.014498269185423851, -0.012175784446299076, -0.03254469484090805, 0.0060865143314003944, 0.05328547954559326, 0.022668806836009026, 0.022181805223226547, -0.013309674337506294, -0.07899044454097748, 0.023397047072649002, 0.03367442637681961, 0.037703052163124084, -0.05436006188392639, 0.020487146452069283, -0.01546136848628521, -0.021016906946897507, 0.0029743178747594357, -0.0061324359849095345, 0.04483707249164581, 0.004782445263117552, 0.03825869411230087, -0.04881460592150688, 0.0012734814081341028, -0.0436929315328598, 0.002998458221554756, -0.04420899227261543, 0.01238360907882452, -0.008249116130173206, -0.0421801395714283, -0.015698280185461044, 0.0061581493355333805, 0.04922853782773018, 0.03530551865696907, -0.015065480954945087, -0.013092521578073502, 0.009536297991871834, 0.007699542213231325, -0.03170473873615265, -0.04077134281396866, 0.02053925208747387, 0.017368340864777565, -0.036658260971307755, 0.051019977778196335, -0.021676359698176384, -0.01974773406982422, 0.022522730752825737, -0.014694438315927982, 0.012748080305755138, 0.001907813479192555, -0.010660199448466301, 0.029564835131168365, -0.01507155317813158, -0.029785210266709328, 0.06150126829743385, 0.04434972256422043, 0.0030712876468896866, 0.012830308638513088, -0.06206640601158142, 0.024010593071579933, -0.011583940126001835, -0.009163014590740204, -0.04639419913291931, 0.006542853079736233, -0.02187676914036274, 0.015031656250357628, 0.014632857404649258, 0.04612022265791893, -0.03739793598651886, -0.02183845452964306, -0.00075341115007177, 0.015531736426055431, -0.05184191092848778, 0.005552911665290594, -0.005234759766608477, 0.011060787364840508, -0.01855161041021347, -0.05504997447133064, 0.003734647762030363, -0.033861078321933746, 0.012993158772587776, 0.022099271416664124, -0.03747188672423363, -0.02732534147799015, -0.013556146994233131, -0.03533321991562843, -0.021351540461182594, -0.039526741951704025, 0.058459989726543427, -0.02838972583413124, 0.035495106130838394, 0.007171441800892353, -0.03899040445685387, 0.0437740683555603, 0.04477858915925026, 0.02199479751288891, 0.03327721729874611, -0.0406263992190361, 0.013114278204739094, -0.04012923315167427, -0.028914889320731163, -0.049335505813360214, -0.035504139959812164, -0.01316039264202118, 0.005895702168345451, -0.014667507261037827, -0.039089906960725784, 0.016987888142466545, -0.04385475069284439, -0.019528329372406006, -0.01956292800605297, 0.04763929545879364, -0.029317693784832954, -0.02942175790667534, 0.0044575645588338375, -0.0018186491215601563, 0.05372316762804985, 0.005179398227483034, -0.01928144507110119, 0.01700715348124504, 0.0007559849764220417, -0.008601079694926739, -0.008292230777442455, -0.006875999271869659, -0.021944327279925346, -0.020202405750751495, -0.0626126229763031, 0.006188821978867054, 0.06490681320428848, -0.03973223268985748, -0.0028957340400666, 0.01778506673872471, 0.009039127267897129, 0.029737388715147972, -0.012449266389012337, 0.0025880825705826283, -0.018515873700380325, -0.011698211543262005, 0.005185830406844616, 0.006720453966408968, -0.03321231156587601, 0.009700036607682705, 0.04776415601372719, -0.04114771634340286, -0.017804762348532677, 0.01862029917538166, 0.0759090930223465, -0.010502797551453114, 0.02630622684955597, 0.011609500274062157, -0.007204763125628233, 0.016248300671577454, -0.013526182621717453, 0.01618351601064205, 0.01148027740418911, 0.03712965175509453, -0.01355122309178114, -0.04600232094526291, -0.045370157808065414, -0.0021012776996940374, 0.060439225286245346, 0.009586157277226448, -0.008093920536339283, 0.06016293913125992, -0.0021943049505352974, -0.031985096633434296, -0.05076592043042183, -0.009761948138475418, -0.007371965330094099, 0.020274778828024864, 0.07837054133415222, -0.052349336445331573, 0.0022902030032128096, 0.04320870339870453, 0.036409880965948105, -0.00634015304967761, 0.0322636254131794, 0.02580603025853634, -0.004644158761948347, 0.008549044840037823, 0.024564214050769806, -0.07011256366968155, 0.03355273976922035, -0.047026343643665314, -0.006768511142581701, -0.03341681882739067, -0.006949263159185648, 0.035394299775362015, 0.08462381362915039, 0.00025622386601753533, -0.01362578198313713, -0.034698087722063065, -0.026388734579086304, 0.026199785992503166, 0.031187372282147408, 0.006581538822501898, 0.030444495379924774, 0.024718746542930603, 0.0665929839015007, 0.001964854309335351, 0.027485627681016922, -0.007564034312963486, -0.08459606021642685, -0.032188814133405685, -0.028219016268849373, -0.017063377425074577, 0.0451534204185009, -0.020928101614117622, -0.05428626760840416, 0.024639824405312538, -0.03569987416267395, -0.006083078216761351, -0.020559433847665787, 0.04110318794846535, -0.027768786996603012, 0.05564511567354202, -0.016723381355404854, -0.02184157446026802, 0.050226353108882904, 0.018093233928084373, 0.0939902514219284, 0.047725651413202286, 0.01169352326542139, -0.07017146050930023, 0.036600761115550995, 0.0061914375983178616, 0.001491692615672946, -0.055050451308488846, 0.016944363713264465, -0.026486054062843323, -0.011526612564921379, 0.031223250553011894, 0.044992491602897644, 0.006834310479462147, 0.02569621615111828, 0.06043960526585579, -0.005366634111851454, -0.04623457416892052, 0.002093612914904952, 0.0033345138654112816, -0.04586012661457062, -0.009395629167556763, -0.002966505941003561, 0.0006921984604559839, -0.03129313886165619, -0.01726623810827732, -0.025730671361088753, 0.03833426162600517, 0.02153579518198967, -0.0252840518951416, -0.0010344055481255054, 0.012243807315826416, 0.01560265850275755, 0.049746375530958176, -0.016054386273026466, -0.006082682404667139, 0.022257018834352493, -0.015070624649524689, 0.017308803275227547, 0.00878022238612175, -0.02472519688308239, -0.004402454476803541, 0.03309065103530884, -0.012112508527934551, -0.05022471770644188, -0.034991104155778885, -0.0312887504696846, 0.04245402291417122, 0.022188428789377213, -0.018654203042387962, -0.013422505930066109, 0.016185913234949112, 0.002027255715802312, -0.04776071757078171, -0.004214460030198097, 0.030325187370181084, 0.04247916862368584, -0.04524630680680275, -0.03999969735741615, -0.05103261396288872, 0.02508385106921196, -0.006190350279211998, 0.017828097566962242, 0.031070752069354057, -0.004805820994079113, 0.003696905681863427, -0.044076479971408844, 0.047071486711502075, -0.024425553157925606, -0.003969090059399605, -0.0209298525005579, 0.0019939839839935303, -0.01418250147253275, -0.037444137036800385, 0.01580183580517769, 0.033861033618450165, 0.017215903848409653, 0.015541743487119675, 0.005146634299308062, -0.03146394342184067, -0.05079442635178566, -0.015184992924332619, -0.0034670927561819553, -0.03557472676038742, -0.029601529240608215, 0.032588936388492584, 0.024446481838822365, 0.051046621054410934, 0.005937755107879639, -0.019071536138653755, 0.011572645045816898, 0.0018417288083583117, 0.019390029832720757, -0.07070105522871017, -0.0226309671998024, -0.009904496371746063, -0.02610299363732338, -0.019413238391280174, -0.006530566141009331, 0.039666254073381424, 0.016709359362721443, 0.003567575942724943, -0.022477207705378532, 0.03077125921845436, -0.030247420072555542, 0.0038547867443412542, 0.046148285269737244, -0.030551601201295853, 0.013070065528154373, 0.009341932833194733, -0.002294217236340046, -0.010505632497370243, -0.0001440250052837655, -0.029752077534794807, -0.04794929176568985, 0.004190875217318535, -0.012001130729913712, -0.018963465467095375, -0.029638078063726425, -0.02914387732744217, 0.026567185297608376, -0.053338248282670975, -0.0279074814170599, -0.0651855319738388, 0.0021925955079495907, -0.01004229299724102, -0.03301947936415672, -0.011253305710852146, 0.023388085886836052, -0.0428960956633091, 0.022480295971035957, 0.06672642379999161, 0.022859301418066025, 0.00007164955604821444, -0.041761450469493866, -0.022343123331665993, -0.008804784156382084, 0.05731961876153946, -0.004762131255120039, 0.008566927164793015, 0.023591939359903336, -0.06814385950565338, 0.01733633317053318, 0.007753487676382065, 0.023565469309687614, 0.06941540539264679, 0.020726406946778297, -0.004315168131142855, -0.02161986194550991, 0.036321256309747696, -0.014579788781702518, -0.008814720436930656, 0.007987177930772305, -0.016233110800385475, -0.00718073220923543, 0.0069730826653540134, 0.02119799144566059, 0.030008165165781975, 0.0015929627697914839, 0.06062919646501541, 0.05706792697310448, -0.008104024454951286, -0.01645708829164505, 0.024427946656942368, 0.008108030073344707, -0.004661408253014088, -0.0018162300111725926, -0.0260916780680418, 0.02126220241189003, 0.055539343506097794, -0.000357954268110916, 0.008409032598137856, 0.010922853834927082, 0.025032198056578636, -0.06805630773305893, -0.02923854999244213, 0.011445049196481705, 0.008512473665177822, 0.07052942365407944, -0.04701458290219307, 0.022208020091056824, 0.034874409437179565, -0.04006829112768173, 0.0070007191970944405, 0.013735190033912659, -0.01816251501441002, -0.0065550352446734905, -0.006770747248083353, -0.017391616478562355, 0.027206119149923325, 0.014796185307204723, 0.011524081230163574, 0.015209277160465717, 0.03187413141131401, -0.006819024682044983, -0.030072204768657684, -0.03881259635090828, 0.0032850063871592283, -0.0034809361677616835, -0.045925915241241455, 0.014041649177670479, -0.036843299865722656, -0.06686625629663467, 0.05600101128220558, -0.020402317866683006, 0.05610458552837372, 0.0339333713054657, 0.05649731308221817, 0.034624673426151276, 0.023385493084788322, 0.02300504595041275, -0.018363106995821, -0.006085211411118507, -0.025283409282565117, 0.011884558014571667, 0.03416780009865761, -0.015254499390721321, 0.012160815298557281, 0.008714376948773861, -0.019490448758006096, -0.051653292030096054, -0.01613842509686947, -0.03421412780880928, -0.018112225458025932, -0.05159104987978935, -0.023629125207662582, -0.00288193766027689, -0.041360825300216675, 0.029026689007878304, -0.009108142927289009, 0.005976940039545298, 0.043014045804739, 0.032671310007572174, -0.03994857892394066, -0.014958212152123451, 0.011412128806114197, -0.042808208614587784, 0.01698468066751957, -0.018653936684131622, 0.016961831599473953, -0.048531170934438705, -0.026448527351021767, 0.005047776270657778, -0.000182772331754677, -0.053450629115104675, -0.03512052074074745, -0.030850283801555634, 0.042074013501405716, -0.025998128578066826, -0.0007560470839962363, 0.020963307470083237, -0.01916997879743576, 0.00053391233086586, -0.06850773096084595, 0.0571257546544075, 0.015331749804317951, -0.043633636087179184, -0.037138789892196655, 0.0014146610628813505, -0.017090000212192535, -0.003665296360850334, 0.05792982876300812, 0.0062505160458385944, 0.014376985840499401, -0.021081695333123207, 0.05567261204123497, -0.00817401148378849, -0.039320241659879684, 0.05670710653066635, -0.019307591021060944, -0.012325108982622623, -0.008352176286280155, -0.001149476389400661, 0.018599512055516243, 0.002082542283460498, -0.015979187563061714, -0.043853048235177994, 0.02336888201534748, 0.011776233091950417, -0.04226180538535118, 0.04276306554675102, 0.007500330917537212, -0.0439537949860096, 0.05622199922800064, -0.017152655869722366, 0.05293464660644531, 0.05153245851397514, -0.012992770411074162, -0.038790248334407806, 0.01663738489151001, -0.05038908123970032, 0.01892920769751072, 0.011415031738579273, -0.007093471474945545, 0.0007936864858493209, -0.06804966181516647, -0.006237522233277559, 0.02928703837096691, -0.060164108872413635, 0.008373187854886055, 0.0403459370136261, 0.03750967979431152, 0.022607184946537018, -0.00353756221011281, 0.043220121413469315, 0.022942833602428436, -0.035469722002744675, 0.03044663928449154, 0.04008923098444939, 0.04135453701019287, 0.004846307449042797, -0.006687649060040712, 0.04902714863419533, -0.012557702139019966, -0.03430516645312309, -0.0189380906522274, 0.027536842972040176, -0.004308159928768873, -0.005823731888085604, 0.01438327319920063, -0.007086950354278088, 0.022224614396691322, 0.028761902824044228, -0.009571943432092667, 0.07014408707618713, -0.045594148337841034, -0.0011978942202404141, -0.016850164160132408, 0.02635071612894535, -0.04443192854523659, 0.02191731706261635, 0.03680315986275673, 0.012328618206083775, 0.035565122961997986, 0.0022327620536088943, 0.012356767430901527, -0.034589413553476334, 0.03004739247262478, -0.005539423786103725, -0.0018995754653587937, -0.03254958614706993, -0.008878382854163647, -0.004578605759888887, -0.010172142647206783, -0.049176689237356186, -0.022988328710198402, 0.06041992828249931, 0.04547871649265289, 0.0012202055659145117, -0.05154477432370186, 0.0023068625014275312, 0.005846361164003611, 0.046391624957323074, -0.06660981476306915, -0.028887711465358734, -0.05338585004210472, 0.0408332422375679, -0.004709535278379917, 0.014027376659214497 ]
<p>I'm working on a random forest classifier with 10-folds CV to aestimate the hyperparameter 'mtry' (chosen by maximizing AUROC). I decided to pre-split the training set in 8 samples equals in size (about 100 observations each).</p> <p>I iterated the train process 8 times. At each iteration I added one sample to my actual training set. So, the first train model was fitted using a training set of 100 observations, the second had 200...the last one has the entire original training set (about 800 observations).</p> <p>At each iteration I measured the missclassification error (FP + FN) for both training and test set in %.</p> <p>I finally plot this learning curve. On the x axis I have the training set size, on the y axis the missclassification error in % (black for the training set, red for the test set).</p> <p>The gap between train and test performance suggests me I have high variance in the data (overfitting) but I really cannot understand...why does the training error start so high, then suddenly drop, then start to rise again as training set size increases?</p> <p>If I have a overfitting problem, how can I address it (close the gap) if I cannot obtain more training examples?</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/FKsnK.png" alt="enter image description here"></p>
73,748
[ -0.022424861788749695, -0.002777754794806242, -0.006437454838305712, 0.006324062589555979, 0.04142756760120392, 0.006016447674483061, -0.021770205348730087, -0.040512144565582275, 0.012156288139522076, -0.017961084842681885, 0.028698405250906944, 0.0274944007396698, 0.030286232009530067, 0.015288310125470161, -0.019637955352663994, -0.016556650400161743, -0.017047341912984848, 0.004219924099743366, 0.01487179659307003, -0.022960873320698738, -0.04183752462267876, 0.022346138954162598, 0.02445800043642521, -0.012719010934233665, -0.013910719193518162, 0.036406368017196655, 0.05069001019001007, 0.017562642693519592, 0.02925868332386017, 0.0012013050727546215, -0.04867742210626602, -0.012479654513299465, 0.013320529833436012, 0.030773794278502464, 0.019432611763477325, -0.006044703535735607, -0.017384378239512444, -0.04170221835374832, -0.021293308585882187, 0.030102288350462914, 0.0016325581818819046, -0.015260270796716213, -0.004458083771169186, 0.07410571724176407, 0.017353342846035957, -0.006419410929083824, 0.0022253585048019886, -0.015593123622238636, 0.05739386007189751, -0.05459843948483467, 0.04922429472208023, -0.0055746897123754025, 0.054382096976041794, 0.06830573081970215, 0.019853025674819946, -0.014674576930701733, 0.03961624950170517, 0.10556479543447495, -0.021565768867731094, -0.014018443413078785, -0.024940237402915955, -0.0320267491042614, 0.004263619426637888, 0.015026701614260674, -0.0362996868789196, 0.0555698499083519, -0.0018664244562387466, -0.029881251975893974, 0.009513745084404945, -0.016601035371422768, 0.034931574016809464, 0.009771986864507198, 0.05024412274360657, 0.0010411959374323487, 0.02668929658830166, -0.016991635784506798, -0.016803761944174767, 0.06769244372844696, 0.05030309408903122, 0.03007803112268448, 0.013791698031127453, 0.01286301389336586, 0.020850393921136856, 0.005907346494495869, 0.03217006102204323, -0.015701407566666603, 0.09860313683748245, -0.001613891334272921, 0.012861108407378197, 0.00036452733911573887, -0.01685994677245617, 0.016199246048927307, 0.07154785096645355, -0.004345193039625883, -0.0232339296489954, 0.04015771672129631, -0.012795648537576199, 0.02269223891198635, 0.012816536240279675, 0.0069397930055856705, -0.023399608209729195, -0.02291000261902809, 0.05074585974216461, 0.06073779612779617, -0.044456347823143005, -0.029774965718388557, -0.02572980895638466, -0.03439533710479736, -0.035000886768102646, 0.0015174386790022254, -0.042984411120414734, 0.0380592979490757, 0.021738028153777122, -0.0001875700691016391, 0.024042565375566483, -0.009761606343090534, -0.004807987250387669, 0.0018718776991590858, 0.019341984763741493, 0.054548658430576324, 0.05072055757045746, -0.027576781809329987, 0.033208612352609634, -0.0313880629837513, -0.04204915463924408, 0.01300628762692213, 0.01865341328084469, -0.03264086693525314, 0.001416920917108655, 0.01600595936179161, -0.032088350504636765, -0.01375146396458149, 0.04066413268446922, -0.014754398725926876, 0.04023343324661255, 0.006129991728812456, -0.1024949848651886, -0.07075497508049011, 0.039623841643333435, -0.019918914884328842, 0.019921885803341866, -0.07232171297073364, -0.014030931517481804, 0.01707688346505165, 0.04117835685610771, 0.013811364769935608, 0.0267932191491127, 0.04062303900718689, 0.024214940145611763, 0.006675742566585541, 0.002907701302319765, -0.006259233225136995, -0.022766651585698128, 0.04365108534693718, -0.03199142962694168, -0.08034254610538483, 0.004089642781764269, 0.04066068306565285, -0.03700023517012596, -0.017238076776266098, -0.001303779543377459, 0.006152640096843243, -0.007808920461684465, -0.009297129698097706, 0.013948248699307442, -0.02419981174170971, 0.08559250086545944, 0.03136419132351875, 0.07239357382059097, 0.038700170814991, 0.010982619598507881, -0.00740119768306613, 0.022001635283231735, 0.025734983384609222, 0.045408062636852264, 0.009005171246826649, 0.008229049853980541, -0.020787635818123817, -0.003383674193173647, 0.02869122102856636, -0.010202078148722649, -0.05584273859858513, -0.013957994058728218, -0.009442091919481754, 0.03546435758471489, 0.016684019938111305, 0.0018472790252417326, -0.023845631629228592, 0.035073213279247284, -0.04648851975798607, -0.06751784682273865, -0.04822394624352455, 0.011793631128966808, -0.05363169685006142, -0.0006168463150970638, 0.02208680845797062, -0.015496533364057541, 0.024167777970433235, 0.00012618278560694307, -0.03457494452595711, -0.04895279183983803, 0.010718326084315777, 0.04276639223098755, -0.014066317118704319, 0.008636183105409145, 0.04940245673060417, 0.01915890723466873, -0.005510998424142599, 0.06378032267093658, -0.012057666666805744, -0.07194491475820541, 0.016606368124485016, -0.003161676460877061, -0.005990167148411274, -0.05451396852731705, -0.019240984693169594, 0.007454745937138796, 0.007393286097794771, -0.01209966279566288, 0.058594997972249985, -0.037932440638542175, 0.053799327462911606, 0.07200890779495239, -0.000014146729881758802, -0.016403967514634132, -0.014560204930603504, 0.00024182828201446682, 0.03381967544555664, -0.04685775190591812, 0.00941599253565073, -0.028335969895124435, -0.017344793304800987, 0.0666474923491478, 0.0077481395564973354, -0.021739589050412178, 0.003411913523450494, 0.0655251145362854, 0.005405734293162823, 0.022302504628896713, 0.023845229297876358, 0.0013144605327397585, -0.014422056265175343, 0.030357802286744118, 0.035514891147613525, 0.013126233592629433, -0.022513497620821, 0.0011296850861981511, -0.027499159798026085, 0.013177032582461834, 0.0030743491370230913, -0.0073851412162184715, 0.038262613117694855, 0.018446357920765877, 0.002563245827332139, -0.016887400299310684, -0.020845597609877586, -0.0013399353483691812, 0.03499212488532066, -0.020567359402775764, 0.04140007868409157, 0.018872205168008804, 0.008795926347374916, -0.042188145220279694, -0.0069583021104335785, 0.03769630193710327, 0.03909766674041748, 0.0030709935817867517, -0.01939905621111393, 0.015215428546071053, -0.06851717084646225, 0.00012531639367807657, -0.046009838581085205, -0.0453452430665493, -0.04619323089718819, 0.049678731709718704, 0.022469118237495422, -0.0014976594829931855, 0.03429726883769035, -0.03942433372139931, 0.003396976739168167, 0.0046946280635893345, -0.027843208983540535, 0.04744798690080643, -0.029311634600162506, -0.020335150882601738, 0.02251657098531723, 0.005345926154404879, -0.002463723300024867, 0.022700918838381767, -0.0064395722001791, -0.012335984967648983, -0.018484637141227722, 0.014310339465737343, -0.02775503881275654, -0.035311490297317505, -0.054267194122076035, 0.027006061747670174, 0.004112498369067907, -0.013495249673724174, 0.002592754317447543, -0.007948926649987698, -0.036413874477148056, 0.057365532964468, 0.015474642626941204, 0.011346917599439621, -0.033125974237918854, -0.0169991422444582, 0.011630566790699959, -0.010573847219347954, -0.029869642108678818, 0.0042066085152328014, -0.004749389830976725, -0.010921445675194263, -0.05783824622631073, -0.0689331665635109, -0.01460405346006155, 0.019246142357587814, 0.021494504064321518, 0.005289621185511351, -0.010837373323738575, 0.08144896477460861, 0.023299381136894226, -0.029475810006260872, -0.01742013543844223, 0.012121635489165783, -0.020543713122606277, -0.014487428590655327, 0.009151184931397438, 0.021711423993110657, 0.036181818693876266, 0.020167529582977295, -0.022930361330509186, 0.049268223345279694, 0.0710902139544487, -0.02713288925588131, -0.015261908993124962, 0.007580716162919998, 0.03610613942146301, -0.011853314004838467, 0.016824493184685707, 0.026703717187047005, -0.012038527056574821, 0.02574675902724266, 0.004736809059977531, 0.03884631022810936, 0.032882191240787506, -0.06910225003957748, 0.010041933506727219, -0.019362185150384903, 0.0426170751452446, -0.04449979215860367, 0.015882641077041626, -0.0063508376479148865, -0.042694464325904846, -0.018136709928512573, 0.0163204837590456, 0.07023272663354874, -0.02338194102048874, -0.01917363703250885, 0.052465006709098816, -0.00841174554079771, -0.0023760509211570024, -0.020839018747210503, -0.07507900893688202, -0.03376051038503647, 0.0164552740752697, -0.0069494228810071945, 0.007058785296976566, 0.024657659232616425, 0.05072374641895294, 0.030874457210302353, -0.007018431089818478, -0.0352390855550766, 0.021161414682865143, -0.026235710829496384, -0.010817896574735641, -0.021181952208280563, 0.04722161591053009, 0.0031204058323055506, 0.023036981001496315, -0.026793869212269783, -0.02371733821928501, 0.04534810781478882, 0.02651975490152836, -0.06346486508846283, 0.00691927270963788, 0.01066000759601593, -0.030967053025960922, -0.003662924049422145, -0.02571871317923069, 0.02451583743095398, -0.044752586632966995, 0.012697250582277775, 0.00043467723298817873, 0.021816890686750412, -0.035946305841207504, 0.011180570349097252, -0.0007301452569663525, 0.04227365180850029, -0.018164295703172684, 0.010167957283556461, 0.0034768423065543175, 0.005269049666821957, 0.03321370854973793, 0.03289014846086502, 0.014522976242005825, -0.03094947710633278, -0.021456537768244743, 0.02330438606441021, 0.015340836718678474, 0.04172835871577263, 0.041289832442998886, 0.030637534335255623, -0.07636169344186783, 0.020673245191574097, -0.011811726726591587, 0.03770584985613823, 0.03509145602583885, 0.016823312267661095, -0.02060202695429325, -0.043036844581365585, -0.039176519960165024, 0.0019797165878117085, 0.008463375270366669, 0.007485134061425924, 0.017708899453282356, 0.03024337626993656, 0.04791389778256416, -0.06669356673955917, 0.02430436573922634, 0.039433300495147705, -0.00726390490308404, -0.012997113168239594, -0.02677816152572632, 0.0017813406884670258, -0.019710460677742958, 0.005240361671894789, 0.026603778824210167, 0.005061349831521511, -0.033210549503564835, -0.010901305824518204, 0.0426376610994339, -0.03806845098733902, -0.042671672999858856, -0.005563726183027029, -0.016642820090055466, 0.03232960030436516, 0.0051312996074557304, -0.00899115577340126, 0.009526878595352173, 0.0374237596988678, 0.043525468558073044, 0.0008246119832620025, 0.026205338537693024, -0.06671969592571259, -0.024625500664114952, 0.05930529907345772, 0.038298267871141434, -0.0459153838455677, 0.008520064875483513, -0.03022286668419838, 0.0015369020402431488, 0.005233339499682188, -0.056070733815431595, 0.0027851967606693506, -0.015744736418128014, 0.03314991667866707, -0.046537190675735474, -0.04405655711889267, -0.02820797823369503, -0.0007946162950247526, -0.035774342715740204, 0.05918271467089653, 0.008489802479743958, -0.03176713362336159, -0.014833944849669933, 0.014565272256731987, 0.020210837945342064, 0.07645116746425629, -0.019457221031188965, -0.01213077548891306, 0.026410112157464027, 0.002625690773129463, -0.011537907645106316, -0.06541034579277039, -0.019311225041747093, -0.028315851464867592, -0.025074657052755356, 0.021226825192570686, -0.03125319257378578, -0.06824507564306259, 0.024414734914898872, 0.03254953771829605, -0.04912770166993141, -0.0259062722325325, -0.044720109552145004, 0.04283393174409866, 0.0553504079580307, 0.030369481071829796, 0.056422241032123566, 0.01145313773304224, 0.03189891204237938, 0.03955332934856415, -0.02349673956632614, 0.029583696275949478, -0.032820891588926315, -0.042347852140665054, -0.05192418396472931, -0.01094458345323801, -0.014824990183115005, 0.031292110681533813, -0.01546488981693983, 0.05196458846330643, -0.031717993319034576, -0.010779297910630703, 0.005325653124600649, 0.03224936127662659, -0.013347168453037739, 0.0014873216859996319, -0.0017940786201506853, 0.01666027307510376, -0.02446168288588524, 0.05813443660736084, -0.007282868027687073, -0.0035472214221954346, 0.02911556512117386, 0.0276363343000412, -0.02116941288113594, -0.0031686811707913876, -0.07034169882535934, -0.014171273447573185, -0.0009392545325681567, -0.01994059793651104, 0.029931463301181793, -0.0033303857780992985, 0.027392104268074036, -0.0263559278100729, 0.006753397639840841, -0.01896955631673336, 0.0001076408225344494, -0.008160336874425411, 0.035066816955804825, -0.0492817722260952, 0.013435070402920246, -0.029043154790997505, 0.014292001724243164, -0.0854899138212204, -0.05219488590955734, 0.039147213101387024, 0.00224370788782835, -0.040677525103092194, -0.01922759972512722, -0.015497973188757896, 0.037338241934776306, -0.000999131822027266, -0.03440595790743828, 0.0515039823949337, -0.017876187339425087, -0.01636533997952938, -0.016423802822828293, 0.026187250390648842, 0.03972705453634262, -0.013039708137512207, 0.009495903737843037, 0.009738098829984665, -0.027880292385816574, -0.05970573052763939, 0.0335628017783165, 0.015477830544114113, -0.03680279105901718, -0.029684539884328842, -0.01567740924656391, 0.019572528079152107, 0.07259884476661682, 0.005943202879279852, 0.00601611053571105, -0.005956271663308144, 0.003306793514639139, 0.01601790264248848, -0.025080040097236633, 0.0010901644127443433, 0.006751134060323238, 0.0003205876564607024, -0.00030151763348840177, 0.011577120050787926, 0.013813572935760021, -0.0016458120662719011, 0.004660292062908411, -0.006927733775228262, -0.009702663868665695, 0.01261293888092041, 0.07399816811084747, -0.05495410040020943, 0.02481050044298172, -0.033601950854063034, -0.05603450536727905, 0.03229305148124695, 0.03235117718577385, 0.013200974091887474, -0.008325077593326569, 0.06433963030576706, -0.06319764256477356, -0.01028391346335411, -0.003123464761301875, -0.0012333678314462304, 0.0777740404009819, 0.003512946655973792, 0.022951040416955948, 0.022639665752649307, -0.008424492552876472, 0.02175254002213478, -0.04133247211575508, -0.005324269644916058, -0.006252989172935486, 0.028790410608053207, 0.04267919436097145, 0.029473531991243362, 0.025475189089775085, 0.01867244765162468, 0.025917217135429382, 0.03902849927544594, 0.023311682045459747, 0.00971104297786951, 0.018326658755540848, -0.003328626276925206, -0.046202145516872406, -0.024711688980460167, 0.02450038678944111, -0.022987043485045433, 0.0058830780908465385, -0.009307018481194973, -0.008960243314504623, 0.04048020392656326, 0.03406447544693947, 0.03437899425625801, 0.004463202320039272, -0.009659398347139359, -0.06467967480421066, 0.009211134165525436, -0.016967684030532837, -0.011937204748392105, 0.04690568149089813, -0.015719853341579437, -0.0009026053594425321, -0.003332737134769559, 0.01911606825888157, -0.053043901920318604, -0.05155269801616669, -0.04684830456972122, -0.013283465057611465, -0.018258608877658844, 0.023118620738387108, 0.004735917784273624, -0.05757412686944008, 0.016316978260874748, -0.001351747545413673, 0.03504174202680588, -0.011752314865589142, 0.0304005965590477, -0.02350321225821972, 0.02212595008313656, 0.026821961626410484, 0.046821363270282745, 0.016055598855018616, 0.017479700967669487, 0.11385132372379303, 0.06517693400382996, 0.02436779998242855, -0.012139679864048958, -0.0001738189603202045, -0.01798638142645359, -0.018454691395163536, -0.019895868375897408, 0.04611567407846451, 0.035311952233314514, -0.009788244031369686, 0.01518407091498375, 0.014148342423141003, 0.008692467585206032, -0.0271906815469265, 0.044831372797489166, -0.004335927776992321, 0.008542503230273724, -0.002410018350929022, 0.010566079057753086, 0.02019554190337658, -0.020014557987451553, -0.057075146585702896, -0.00663105770945549, -0.025884922593832016, -0.02025730535387993, -0.03485493361949921, -0.03420913964509964, 0.028604399412870407, 0.016686569899320602, 0.010570785030722618, 0.0025167586281895638, -0.012513549998402596, -0.007925357669591904, -0.005125350784510374, -0.006295359693467617, -0.015297438018023968, -0.01706007868051529, 0.0016561939846724272, 0.018779747188091278, 0.006958804093301296, 0.0020027405116707087, 0.0013237970415502787, 0.006981114856898785, -0.041801027953624725, -0.05817965418100357, -0.033917710185050964, 0.07110565900802612, -0.017297783866524696, 0.0008985856547951698, 0.007259149104356766, 0.008331774733960629, -0.016361530870199203, -0.062227774411439896, -0.002955375239253044, 0.023997334763407707, -0.003881605574861169, -0.019212251529097557, -0.061413154006004333, -0.008818784728646278, 0.012105846777558327, 0.019061965867877007, 0.0053596352227032185, -0.008669216185808182, -0.013862925581634045, -0.0248945951461792, -0.02549252286553383, 0.03320952132344246, 0.02280144952237606, 0.03223617747426033, -0.007675242144614458, -0.006565656512975693, 0.010182540863752365, -0.025691095739603043, 0.023092130199074745, -0.0069709401577711105, 0.020487168803811073, -0.008330236189067364, -0.025502966716885567, -0.03187186270952225, -0.05706433206796646, -0.02104784920811653, -0.025263970717787743, -0.005108451936393976, -0.03914019465446472, -0.026251425966620445, -0.013320477679371834, 0.011659952811896801, 0.033745430409908295, 0.024148553609848022, -0.01471228338778019, 0.061186257749795914, -0.024640066549181938, -0.006622455082833767, -0.032252609729766846, -0.035676583647727966, -0.0321836844086647, 0.04434017464518547, 0.030296090990304947, 0.04930250346660614, 0.021202413365244865, 0.01387832872569561, 0.007496068254113197, 0.04123342037200928, -0.003653933759778738, 0.013041198253631592, 0.012627783231437206, -0.03231484815478325, 0.021006401628255844, -0.00246637174859643, 0.011649005115032196, -0.04518493264913559, -0.027730941772460938, -0.027120929211378098, -0.0451602078974247, 0.036015208810567856, 0.026703879237174988, -0.03810669109225273, 0.031197113916277885, -0.0036224909126758575, 0.04654283449053764, -0.015509158372879028, 0.0021592387929558754, -0.06733083724975586, 0.026974909007549286, -0.040538374334573746, -0.0353860966861248, -0.018314188346266747, 0.007904769852757454, -0.0017396284965798259, -0.031899791210889816, 0.04160042107105255, -0.0019383730832487345, 0.0004136576608289033, 0.00911559909582138, -0.0038871578872203827, 0.016983501613140106, 0.04571489244699478, -0.03009994700551033, -0.000322353356750682, 0.05344618111848831, -0.04508356750011444, -0.0711851418018341, 0.01988099329173565, -0.004065300337970257, 0.06989508122205734, -0.006722784135490656, -0.01944701559841633, -0.014593719504773617, 0.04519214481115341, 0.017864346504211426, -0.03312256932258606, 0.0015772068873047829, 0.014967251569032669, 0.009480963461101055, 0.017959486693143845, 0.015604817308485508, -0.010514309629797935, 0.007791627198457718, 0.0013291597133502364, 0.035239607095718384, 0.024476904422044754, -0.017351696267724037, 0.021661922335624695, -0.025161370635032654, 0.011308856308460236, -0.010837274603545666, 0.01968035101890564, 0.0016673733480274677, 0.013961710967123508, 0.00883476808667183, 0.04028801992535591, -0.04077663645148277, 0.035048916935920715, -0.09676235914230347, -0.03227529302239418, 0.0072103217244148254, 0.05247976630926132, 0.003251601941883564, -0.023875154554843903, -0.025355888530611992, 0.022598622366786003, -0.03756045550107956, -0.0018392798956483603, -0.020571094006299973, -0.009779315441846848, -0.02846597321331501, -0.004856856074184179, -0.05484417453408241, -0.033322617411613464, 0.044370923191308975, 0.026652349159121513, 0.031528305262327194, 0.03148220106959343, 0.0026686047203838825, -0.03549477085471153, -0.01637192629277706, 0.03815450891852379, 0.01296484936028719, -0.05304563790559769, 0.01699117384850979, -0.005404723808169365, -0.026223288848996162, -0.00600967975333333, -0.030751727521419525, 0.0002825265110004693, 0.04059169813990593, 0.017430927604436874, 0.03667431324720383, 0.04797573387622833, 0.023652950301766396, -0.018597522750496864, 0.006160531658679247, -0.022472159937024117, -0.014406914822757244, -0.026037992909550667, -0.011094843968749046, 0.020539553835988045, 0.04464202746748924, -0.013742362149059772, -0.008320443332195282, 0.043777190148830414, -0.02547258511185646, -0.01741918921470642, 0.012817093171179295, 0.023715129122138023, 0.01189144141972065, -0.03791867941617966, -0.02945535257458687, -0.022849321365356445, -0.01585342362523079, 0.03142629936337471, 0.007022771518677473, -0.014275770634412766, 0.007228430360555649, -0.019102221354842186, -0.048910655081272125, -0.007085278630256653, 0.014484847895801067, -0.022419394925236702, -0.05960255488753319, 0.022298268973827362, 0.010938957333564758, -0.046904612332582474, 0.02051987685263157, -0.028880806639790535, -0.028300045058131218, 0.05952177941799164, -0.0037962410133332014, 0.03291013836860657, -0.009345673024654388, -0.03073049522936344, -0.013741743750870228, -0.11928775161504745, 0.06974378973245621, -0.006394882686436176, -0.041773296892642975, -0.01924830675125122, 0.034877482801675797, -0.0234836433082819, 0.017552949488162994, 0.04965442419052124, 0.017424415796995163, 0.009182264097034931, -0.018384188413619995, 0.006347618065774441, 0.034325748682022095, -0.05817580595612526, 0.04523496329784393, -0.003704274306073785, -0.023105904459953308, 0.010890068486332893, -0.031611133366823196, 0.003791138995438814, 0.0007997577777132392, 0.04327336698770523, -0.011378379538655281, 0.01869022287428379, 0.018082331866025925, 0.010942314751446247, 0.035863250494003296, -0.014740188606083393, -0.00008855236956151202, 0.016080409288406372, -0.02824803814291954, 0.0018110782839357853, 0.033923033624887466, 0.009567300789058208, -0.08031344413757324, 0.0017685123020783067, -0.020086592063307762, -0.010445590130984783, -0.001921514980494976, 0.010911023244261742, 0.029114902019500732, -0.08639707416296005, -0.004085935652256012, 0.03439297154545784, -0.05057983100414276, 0.0066533745266497135, 0.04586852341890335, 0.03674529120326042, 0.029131561517715454, -0.022261526435613632, 0.034600358456373215, -0.0004997579380869865, -0.013819897547364235, -0.008076433092355728, -0.001997362356632948, -0.004391335882246494, 0.009813657030463219, 0.03873686119914055, 0.013299554586410522, -0.038568489253520966, 0.011824156157672405, -0.017508096992969513, 0.03339825198054314, -0.05454357713460922, -0.020154299214482307, 0.017890624701976776, -0.012335467152297497, 0.004413618706166744, 0.0021331135649234056, -0.008246746845543385, 0.047557953745126724, -0.030015012249350548, -0.00519163254648447, -0.050340767949819565, -0.05629092827439308, -0.01476440392434597, 0.030931873247027397, 0.00479448027908802, 0.056242942810058594, 0.004582845140248537, 0.011265735141932964, -0.019221987575292587, 0.01978568732738495, 0.042853306978940964, -0.013406270183622837, 0.004953768569976091, -0.025081781670451164, -0.02387637458741665, 0.01346583105623722, -0.004955255426466465, -0.014668925665318966, -0.020841773599386215, 0.019296104088425636, 0.040648821741342545, 0.023471778258681297, -0.023883745074272156, -0.015666427090764046, 0.02482105977833271, 0.029730547219514847, -0.049002643674612045, 0.01558955479413271, -0.05169573798775673, 0.015178659930825233, -0.0101844547316432, -0.04999873414635658 ]
<p>I have two datasets, $D1$ and $D2$, each containing many samples $S_i$ of 100 numbers, each sample from a different (unknown) population. For example:</p> <p>$S_1=\{0.125, 0.122, 0.053, \dots\} \\ S_2=\{0.001, 0.013, 0.034, \dots\} \\ \dots $</p> <p>The are both quite large. $D1$ contains almost 6M samples, and $D2$ contains almost 500K.</p> <p>I randomly split each sample $S_i$ in two disjoint subsamples of size 50 each, let them be $S_i'$ and $S_i''$. For each subsample I run a t-test for the null hypothesis of mean equal zero, so I have two p-values: $p_i'$ and $p_i''$.</p> <p>My question of interest is: how often do I observe significance in $S_i''$ if I observed significance in $S_i'$. So, for different significance levels, I plot this proportion:</p> <p>$\displaystyle\frac {\#\{p_i' \leq \alpha~and~p_i''\leq\alpha\}} {\#\{p_i' \leq \alpha\}}$</p> <p>With dataset $D1$ there is nothing rare: the lower the significance level the smaller the proportion because it is harder to observe significance. But when I plot it with dataset $D2$, I have this weird behavior in the plot: it kind of goes up with alpha, but then at some point it goes down with large alphas.</p> <p>I can't figure out why this is happening. The same happens with other tests such as Wilcoxon and Sign. Any ideas?</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/KPUOV.png" alt="enter image description here"></p>
73,749
[ -0.029080327600240707, 0.013253317214548588, -0.0018551438115537167, -0.007403227500617504, 0.023157550022006035, 0.04589672386646271, 0.0008811491425149143, -0.04705290123820305, -0.02377578429877758, -0.05527662858366966, 0.01860329695045948, 0.020833073183894157, 0.03048078529536724, 0.004660273902118206, 0.021821709349751472, -0.03145477920770645, -0.02092612162232399, 0.012380249798297882, 0.016390332952141762, -0.01296563632786274, -0.0014803990488871932, 0.02520802989602089, 0.022505564615130424, -0.026926841586828232, -0.029822783544659615, 0.03994738683104515, -0.007540955673903227, 0.008927852846682072, 0.0018695072503760457, 0.038053035736083984, -0.04557940736413002, -0.021490778774023056, 0.016932211816310883, 0.026885850355029106, 0.02563774399459362, -0.03191317990422249, 0.007287532556802034, -0.03822486847639084, 0.004408249165862799, 0.017590152099728584, -0.07569532096385956, -0.01608320325613022, -0.001467771246097982, 0.033588655292987823, 0.017956305295228958, 0.02193371392786503, 0.02944878116250038, -0.05413107946515083, 0.02464856207370758, -0.05675532668828964, 0.06284962594509125, 0.03326653316617012, 0.05180133134126663, 0.014329252764582634, -0.03146883472800255, -0.02256663329899311, -0.002292113844305277, 0.05844838544726372, -0.017269184812903404, -0.028239283710718155, -0.012521613389253616, -0.02085636928677559, -0.00969404261559248, 0.010552255436778069, -0.036727238446474075, 0.02083093672990799, -0.021287212148308754, 0.009540542960166931, 0.019887691363692284, -0.005789762828499079, 0.021454181522130966, 0.003404220100492239, 0.026575537398457527, -0.028486846014857292, -0.0055884611792862415, -0.01139773614704609, 0.03154226392507553, 0.009255655109882355, 0.07052648067474365, 0.07222888618707657, 0.021356606855988503, 0.008547812700271606, 0.03620387241244316, -0.010361053980886936, 0.02802211232483387, -0.01175618451088667, 0.0725366473197937, 0.0033749716822057962, 0.004150827880948782, 0.017905419692397118, -0.03525928035378456, 0.021638285368680954, 0.047766733914613724, -0.006375694647431374, -0.03452339768409729, -0.0033923706505447626, -0.013561815954744816, 0.022871077060699463, -0.020491186529397964, -0.02042476087808609, -0.03703581541776657, -0.052941370755434036, 0.042487066239118576, 0.06942766904830933, -0.0016638539964333177, -0.006700873840600252, -0.03750211000442505, 0.001734678982757032, -0.017243102192878723, -0.014507693238556385, 0.012454336509108543, 0.026123756542801857, 0.04294196888804436, 0.0187185388058424, 0.019101127982139587, -0.016115251928567886, 0.004306700546294451, -0.016238903626799583, 0.03762127086520195, 0.04518573358654976, 0.06570423394441605, 0.012375273741781712, 0.006819955538958311, -0.022371331229805946, -0.03682322055101395, 0.04435539245605469, 0.04167666286230087, -0.034807994961738586, -0.023674845695495605, 0.04866132512688637, -0.002672345144674182, -0.026255549862980843, 0.017768094316124916, -0.036151569336652756, 0.03940065577626228, 0.024404387921094894, -0.07109028100967407, -0.06015948951244354, 0.05584828555583954, -0.009238123893737793, 0.01309554185718298, -0.0668962374329567, -0.006181585136801004, 0.058682579547166824, 0.02378695458173752, -0.010392115451395512, -0.0041766781359910965, 0.0031837106216698885, 0.04674992337822914, 0.02679808810353279, -0.007330507505685091, -0.01072057243436575, -0.030901165679097176, 0.02135339379310608, -0.010601844638586044, -0.07205434143543243, 0.028338288888335228, 0.014087456278502941, -0.0006238885107450187, 0.0012610970297828317, 0.031235534697771072, 0.01278635673224926, -0.005510326009243727, -0.0018805550644174218, 0.0438622385263443, -0.026383185759186745, 0.07304075360298157, 0.02716400846838951, 0.05046582221984863, 0.019585084170103073, -0.005104642361402512, 0.027006179094314575, 0.03309902548789978, 0.021929388865828514, 0.016725504770874977, -0.015692580491304398, 0.01848464272916317, -0.028618715703487396, 0.003890773979946971, 0.04444671794772148, -0.040391068905591965, -0.05546474829316139, -0.05694327503442764, -0.0011626769555732608, 0.044206298887729645, 0.013983641751110554, -0.002604018896818161, -0.0218887310475111, 0.03027554415166378, -0.05092255026102066, -0.07476130872964859, -0.048929210752248764, 0.0008267555385828018, -0.02919112890958786, -0.038601621985435486, 0.03502146527171135, 0.0021079517900943756, -0.012941120192408562, 0.005601854994893074, -0.003911424893885851, -0.010288866236805916, -0.03666190430521965, 0.057191357016563416, -0.059608299285173416, 0.009727603755891323, 0.04963161423802376, 0.02388855069875717, 0.009482447057962418, 0.05619937926530838, -0.05700444430112839, -0.02167605422437191, 0.025733353570103645, -0.02049345150589943, -0.007025748956948519, -0.031242486089468002, -0.017768029123544693, -0.012785798870027065, -0.03222694993019104, -0.014839965850114822, 0.049176622182130814, -0.03476303070783615, 0.05524333566427231, 0.05331974849104881, -0.0012028119526803493, -0.024634264409542084, 0.016092339530587196, 0.009458169341087341, -0.011699646711349487, -0.039950523525476456, -0.015182515606284142, -0.08385593444108963, 0.005192667245864868, 0.034630220383405685, 0.009157116524875164, -0.02754702791571617, 0.007664550561457872, 0.013740492053329945, 0.021447982639074326, 0.0017668214859440923, 0.013764819130301476, -0.0045152571983635426, -0.04310978204011917, -0.030080484226346016, 0.04070287570357323, 0.02511751465499401, 0.01751026324927807, 0.012710414826869965, -0.032788220793008804, 0.02654116600751877, -0.00002669055356818717, 0.0029055762570351362, 0.011123471893370152, -0.02257104218006134, 0.003448288654908538, -0.007723573129624128, 0.015104451216757298, 0.030339315533638, -0.013644905760884285, -0.020553482696413994, 0.05759408324956894, -0.0003514619020279497, 0.02364964596927166, 0.01897888071835041, -0.031971827149391174, 0.03184559568762779, 0.009199311956763268, 0.0015592742711305618, -0.010173299349844456, 0.012183381244540215, -0.02442784048616886, -0.01731525920331478, -0.03590111434459686, -0.041303686797618866, -0.019317645579576492, 0.013399424031376839, 0.01933574117720127, 0.0031918121967464685, 0.0012408978072926402, -0.04830414056777954, -0.022229989990592003, 0.012489402666687965, -0.015461253002285957, 0.03867030888795853, -0.0030383002012968063, -0.05023205280303955, 0.029856499284505844, 0.010711511597037315, -0.016242165118455887, 0.019643904641270638, -0.014353044331073761, -0.01593943126499653, -0.00336527731269598, -0.01224440336227417, -0.03387407958507538, -0.05303705111145973, -0.017634620890021324, 0.0021728037390857935, -0.043986208736896515, -0.028629135340452194, 0.05289792641997337, -0.011474551633000374, -0.01772003248333931, 0.019501177594065666, -0.022534186020493507, -0.0052619329653680325, -0.04396390914916992, -0.0029431742150336504, 0.01715729385614395, 0.016461824998259544, -0.003744743764400482, 0.02975446544587612, -0.027392635121941566, -0.033718615770339966, -0.05058152228593826, -0.057420067489147186, 0.020407194271683693, -0.005405888892710209, 0.03792495280504227, -0.014860889874398708, -0.019363362342119217, 0.057636559009552, 0.053179338574409485, 0.03923672065138817, -0.03049902245402336, -0.025776686146855354, -0.03913145512342453, 0.0073187933303415775, 0.019531166180968285, 0.039311524480581284, 0.006401934660971165, 0.0347076915204525, 0.007385133299976587, 0.04184041544795036, -0.0029380638152360916, -0.012639940716326237, -0.03934219107031822, 0.0362091027200222, 0.01347197126597166, 0.007520392537117004, 0.03547896817326546, 0.026621339842677116, -0.037787020206451416, -0.0032015955075621605, 0.02320854365825653, 0.025128131732344627, 0.007370960433036089, -0.029051296412944794, 0.008098911494016647, -0.004937464836984873, 0.017587704584002495, -0.03704260662198067, 0.02085072174668312, 0.042140260338783264, -0.032256994396448135, -0.024338124319911003, 0.009821937419474125, 0.023298079147934914, -0.04955580085515976, 0.014263078570365906, 0.037751298397779465, 0.007933283224701881, -0.012072584591805935, -0.0290076844394207, -0.0278887040913105, -0.012078932486474514, 0.02593320794403553, -0.05445186793804169, -0.04363684356212616, 0.027569418773055077, 0.03806987404823303, 0.021206095814704895, -0.03686537966132164, -0.056117575615644455, 0.016365202143788338, -0.04208890348672867, -0.0010603995760902762, -0.034285712987184525, 0.0433933399617672, -0.007560427300632, 0.028183573856949806, 0.038018304854631424, -0.007928429171442986, -0.029581377282738686, 0.016655167564749718, -0.0637844130396843, 0.060036800801754, -0.010727494023740292, -0.004285271745175123, 0.01715884543955326, 0.01536567136645317, 0.025122785940766335, -0.011894334107637405, 0.030081914737820625, -0.035998694598674774, 0.03411911427974701, -0.02890786901116371, -0.009049822576344013, -0.026774195954203606, -0.004500086884945631, -0.014988454058766365, 0.03536088764667511, -0.0057259825989604, -0.024981146678328514, 0.028376758098602295, 0.0010794742265716195, -0.000380358484108001, -0.012494601309299469, -0.0324605293571949, 0.018574994057416916, 0.005440028849989176, 0.02582085318863392, 0.03440655395388603, 0.02101333625614643, -0.03744626045227051, 0.002212636871263385, -0.002631350187584758, 0.060223277658224106, 0.04554230719804764, -0.010174332186579704, 0.02406700886785984, -0.013692966662347317, -0.020267203450202942, -0.010836933739483356, 0.023691628128290176, -0.009154164232313633, -0.025627342984080315, 0.029352769255638123, 0.02871117740869522, -0.0315539613366127, 0.06746197491884232, 0.029526934027671814, 0.02087443694472313, 0.012078681029379368, -0.0363323837518692, -0.011072141118347645, -0.02512400969862938, 0.008930418640375137, 0.009663736447691917, 0.013816791586577892, -0.0069642518647015095, -0.01094021275639534, 0.03989311680197716, -0.008157996460795403, -0.01096024177968502, -0.010722866281867027, 0.005986211821436882, 0.03939618915319443, 0.007066877093166113, -0.004006634466350079, 0.03330308943986893, -0.019269749522209167, 0.044910937547683716, 0.03826360031962395, 0.028942657634615898, -0.07773351669311523, -0.002635898068547249, 0.04333554953336716, 0.039514075964689255, -0.038773149251937866, 0.043478112667798996, -0.037795037031173706, 0.01809290237724781, 0.03567007929086685, -0.05139128491282463, 0.03846035897731781, 0.010031775571405888, 0.028971653431653976, -0.04559505358338356, -0.009272058494389057, -0.05057195574045181, 0.011901671066880226, -0.019842667505145073, -0.0003379929403308779, -0.043646957725286484, -0.011455765925347805, -0.07067646831274033, 0.002447360660880804, 0.02736191637814045, 0.07233299314975739, -0.016918666660785675, -0.023959994316101074, -0.03267984464764595, -0.012069801799952984, -0.014408322051167488, -0.07453195750713348, 0.048325035721063614, -0.007788288407027721, 0.000858738727401942, 0.0359969362616539, -0.03203921765089035, -0.052801817655563354, 0.02468222938477993, 0.036327093839645386, 0.011594121344387531, -0.03264119103550911, -0.00461238669231534, 0.04920028895139694, 0.05897556245326996, 0.025889204815030098, 0.0540984570980072, 0.019822079688310623, 0.022284813225269318, -0.008271251805126667, 0.010594869963824749, 0.0286061093211174, -0.0170686487108469, -0.0182318277657032, -0.0532567985355854, -0.006900722626596689, -0.016593992710113525, 0.023998891934752464, -0.032877132296562195, 0.04597644880414009, -0.02198042906820774, -0.02457720786333084, 0.0008218228467740119, 0.027409078553318977, 0.04818102344870567, 0.003664684947580099, -0.0078098769299685955, 0.029004663228988647, 0.0010669491020962596, -0.0033111595548689365, 0.030569441616535187, -0.041193604469299316, -0.0023676403798162937, -0.00015329144662246108, -0.06766467541456223, 0.011233351193368435, -0.04669763892889023, 0.007628153078258038, -0.006302275694906712, -0.020204870030283928, 0.00953993946313858, -0.04509012773633003, 0.03527215123176575, 0.006990189664065838, -0.02143261395394802, -0.003340962342917919, 0.032719653099775314, 0.04325620085000992, 0.06391197443008423, -0.04225371405482292, 0.04192754253745079, -0.007737688720226288, 0.02066754922270775, -0.08218831568956375, -0.03961196169257164, 0.024284401908516884, 0.05638185515999794, -0.0014756470918655396, -0.029919631779193878, -0.029755109921097755, 0.016725171357393265, -0.00821692030876875, -0.010558872483670712, 0.04404310882091522, -0.031204096972942352, -0.03080679289996624, -0.019360318779945374, 0.034997254610061646, 0.0991658940911293, -0.06285741925239563, 0.01938166469335556, 0.005446876864880323, 0.002951692556962371, -0.021254941821098328, 0.0016947018448263407, 0.018581505864858627, -0.031052054837346077, -0.02458116039633751, -0.028038015589118004, -0.014338125474750996, 0.01996336318552494, -0.0228029265999794, 0.0015501717571169138, -0.005591097753494978, 0.01330483052879572, 0.08346089720726013, -0.008645356632769108, -0.03707149997353554, 0.026747992262244225, 0.015912136062979698, -0.015525146387517452, 0.0013250000774860382, -0.01615407131612301, -0.03295491263270378, -0.01058625802397728, 0.035425301641225815, -0.010258377529680729, 0.009554327465593815, 0.06022247299551964, -0.012471959926187992, -0.008871868252754211, -0.020987533032894135, -0.01733250916004181, 0.03432228043675423, 0.03818478807806969, -0.023415621370077133, 0.020302727818489075, 0.012753315269947052, -0.01652403362095356, 0.022910568863153458, -0.019821293652057648, -0.017725763842463493, 0.05224060267210007, 0.006397182587534189, 0.0053940340876579285, 0.04942148178815842, -0.014092618599534035, 0.03608698025345802, -0.04801826924085617, -0.018160317093133926, -0.03112906962633133, 0.0009496690472587943, -0.004401359707117081, -0.05099906772375107, -0.029244743287563324, 0.05103803798556328, 0.027958273887634277, 0.02168133482336998, 0.050100862979888916, 0.018705423921346664, 0.020668311044573784, 0.017770085483789444, -0.06449051946401596, -0.047180116176605225, 0.06217417120933533, -0.048486240208148956, 0.01715906709432602, -0.023564638569951057, -0.0466383658349514, 0.053683213889598846, 0.05366172641515732, 0.030876904726028442, -0.019105443730950356, -0.01595604233443737, -0.044119104743003845, 0.008560252375900745, 0.016019387170672417, 0.0022598470095545053, 0.01714336685836315, -0.01544455997645855, -0.005607905797660351, -0.007095365319401026, 0.025440389290452003, -0.025078346952795982, -0.038332607597112656, -0.05473603308200836, -0.016550367698073387, -0.03325127065181732, 0.0480586476624012, -0.024048831313848495, -0.025732845067977905, 0.036758214235305786, -0.05452486500144005, 0.04198799282312393, 0.00007371629908448085, 0.004643834661692381, -0.0013098249910399318, 0.04998059198260307, -0.016381962224841118, 0.05571481212973595, 0.01018912997096777, -0.05352024734020233, 0.13975319266319275, 0.055588822811841965, 0.012238978408277035, -0.03625955060124397, 0.02028280682861805, 0.013179347850382328, 0.03086036443710327, -0.02045007422566414, -0.0018014025408774614, 0.0300578810274601, -0.02963734045624733, 0.04384832829236984, 0.09332718700170517, 0.00993751734495163, -0.009434864856302738, 0.1007726788520813, -0.06065788120031357, -0.0046585374511778355, 0.01551215723156929, 0.022087426856160164, -0.02618490904569626, -0.05260138958692551, -0.040230438113212585, -0.00041492230957373977, -0.008203648030757904, -0.014496838673949242, -0.017730962485074997, -0.011882951483130455, 0.007784533780068159, -0.005589649546891451, -0.026252536103129387, -0.004964086692780256, 0.037325214594602585, -0.007363135926425457, -0.0069477795623242855, 0.0002105172461597249, 0.02667348086833954, -0.04952471703290939, 0.013575137592852116, 0.06028847396373749, -0.011775266379117966, 0.019439367577433586, -0.008935853838920593, 0.03926728293299675, -0.046269312500953674, -0.030958397313952446, -0.012125560082495213, 0.057689178735017776, -0.023929670453071594, -0.030514683574438095, -0.0325511209666729, 0.0008833413594402373, -0.011233936995267868, -0.019617799669504166, -0.03628069534897804, 0.022858263924717903, 0.006160489283502102, -0.02790559083223343, -0.0004540970840025693, -0.003619794500991702, 0.021010978147387505, 0.003469740739092231, 0.025971990078687668, 0.031334780156612396, -0.01645222119987011, -0.06591315567493439, 0.010624940507113934, 0.019995473325252533, -0.003481384599581361, 0.014312615618109703, 0.028240704908967018, 0.0058225831016898155, -0.011326615698635578, -0.006443604826927185, 0.015805469825863838, 0.0059354836121201515, 0.04111297428607941, 0.004003799054771662, -0.02426679991185665, -0.045608386397361755, -0.014030027203261852, 0.00834004208445549, -0.01007548626512289, 0.012835662811994553, -0.03811637684702873, -0.036048874258995056, 0.003556374693289399, 0.03430725261569023, 0.019354157149791718, 0.002699779812246561, 0.026935569941997528, 0.08601152896881104, 0.030365316197276115, -0.032745327800512314, -0.03995039686560631, -0.011995346285402775, -0.0009818760445341468, -0.025868423283100128, -0.016797425225377083, 0.04315606504678726, -0.009290117770433426, -0.000529481447301805, 0.03452746570110321, 0.02593592368066311, 0.000345012842444703, 0.016996920108795166, 0.0052733407355844975, -0.05360051617026329, 0.015100023709237576, 0.019759394228458405, -0.018912333995103836, -0.006224608980119228, -0.0028281603008508682, -0.020638467743992805, 0.014981122687458992, -0.008873770013451576, -0.01538665872067213, -0.016547977924346924, -0.018060486763715744, 0.006088561844080687, 0.01637347973883152, -0.0004142801626585424, -0.020941859111189842, -0.04668862000107765, -0.02810983546078205, -0.00027935230173170567, 0.01922404021024704, -0.03748674690723419, 0.03414548560976982, -0.00894814170897007, -0.0008251008111983538, 0.02334962598979473, 0.024224868044257164, 0.028488652780652046, -0.027032947167754173, 0.023964421823620796, -0.004629124421626329, 0.01473280694335699, -0.05041658505797386, -0.03980598598718643, 0.06493764370679855, -0.05400881916284561, -0.049897268414497375, 0.02778542973101139, -0.014218953438103199, 0.026295341551303864, -0.021067043766379356, -0.0006466858321800828, -0.0022521649952977896, 0.03543370962142944, -0.020147696137428284, -0.03945989906787872, -0.009020362980663776, 0.007712582591921091, 0.016518106684088707, 0.00020695356943178922, -0.02404472976922989, 0.008272397331893444, 0.011849253438413143, 0.03451911360025406, 0.051320746541023254, -0.0197044238448143, 0.014988566748797894, -0.016940249130129814, 0.009825441986322403, 0.039331819862127304, 0.009871987625956535, 0.010150335729122162, 0.05115928128361702, 0.0742177665233612, -0.03675093129277229, 0.028285082429647446, -0.03562886267900467, 0.013535977341234684, -0.07798094302415848, -0.01856018789112568, -0.01117120310664177, -0.0033721246290951967, 0.03639178350567818, -0.04283016547560692, 0.02630065195262432, 0.03486509993672371, -0.051443882286548615, 0.07495257258415222, -0.04993679001927376, 0.006797491572797298, -0.058461789041757584, -0.004417093005031347, 0.0017749867402017117, 0.04632967710494995, 0.008739449083805084, 0.019747616723179817, 0.026962490752339363, 0.0417448952794075, 0.05155480280518532, -0.009251291863620281, -0.038717370480298996, 0.02660292200744152, -0.0182090625166893, -0.08952829241752625, 0.0041184634901583195, -0.03639960289001465, -0.014405308291316032, 0.013259956613183022, -0.003076178254559636, 0.013263002038002014, 0.02442278154194355, 0.02010032720863819, 0.02786152809858322, 0.06877732276916504, 0.021672489121556282, 0.035316020250320435, -0.006426538340747356, -0.0010470893466845155, 0.014072916470468044, 0.005423202645033598, -0.018658295273780823, -0.009275704622268677, 0.057109903544187546, -0.016549397259950638, 0.0008681845501996577, -0.01216814387589693, -0.004429747816175222, -0.010265453718602657, 0.015677794814109802, 0.0015825072769075632, 0.007852589711546898, -0.025062905624508858, 0.018451087176799774, -0.05187397450208664, -0.024586735293269157, 0.020333265885710716, 0.027589065954089165, -0.013805036433041096, 0.02140984870493412, -0.02126232162117958, -0.042102523148059845, -0.044402144849300385, 0.009744028560817242, -0.004414808936417103, -0.031770482659339905, -0.02893652394413948, -0.05539185553789139, 0.01696637272834778, 0.004367939196527004, 0.005435496103018522, -0.044379957020282745, 0.050642021000385284, -0.04193978011608124, 0.01762368716299534, -0.007909859530627728, -0.013889867812395096, -0.0018392580095678568, -0.10186347365379333, 0.04876210168004036, -0.01691395230591297, -0.013382605277001858, -0.03651696816086769, -0.02454410307109356, -0.046454448252916336, 0.027574768289923668, 0.03427227959036827, 0.042347703129053116, 0.007697903085500002, -0.009710969403386116, 0.01056122686713934, 0.05019941180944443, -0.06047239899635315, 0.06038433685898781, -0.009113593026995659, -0.006802410818636417, -0.00846746377646923, -0.003096423577517271, 0.04514152929186821, 0.004353717900812626, 0.00818860623985529, -0.015829011797904968, 0.03591443598270416, 0.006024155765771866, 0.015412739478051662, 0.03480145335197449, -0.023979680612683296, 0.004553540144115686, 0.03877398744225502, -0.01062900573015213, 0.03392606973648071, 0.018703490495681763, -0.023673899471759796, -0.06385256350040436, 0.04142371192574501, -0.006561686750501394, -0.06309283524751663, 0.015387948602437973, 0.0023143303114920855, -0.007241605315357447, -0.03784911707043648, 0.03251007944345474, -0.015972059220075607, -0.023104632273316383, -0.007585374638438225, 0.021759338676929474, 0.02927207760512829, 0.02616002969443798, 0.014542615972459316, 0.056078579276800156, -0.0009212079457938671, 0.006345312111079693, 0.027426782995462418, -0.00732694286853075, 0.0036163092590868473, -0.013212787918746471, 0.032622240483760834, 0.017490072175860405, -0.008068772964179516, 0.0013136641355231404, 0.0012223162921145558, 0.010661059059202671, 0.0073255388997495174, -0.038663558661937714, 0.02312517911195755, -0.02814760059118271, 0.010474229231476784, -0.019138671457767487, 0.014015167951583862, 0.059709250926971436, -0.02196463756263256, 0.038993190973997116, -0.020146621391177177, -0.027218876406550407, -0.008433692157268524, 0.00908772461116314, 0.006293037440627813, 0.01296915765851736, -0.0164580550044775, -0.0032532692421227694, -0.012667081318795681, -0.010739590972661972, 0.03494635596871376, -0.023107795044779778, 0.01956009678542614, -0.0006050200900062919, -0.00934771727770567, -0.02636425755918026, -0.004624597728252411, -0.02653476595878601, -0.05880046635866165, 0.030454793944954872, 0.019533511251211166, 0.010841994546353817, -0.03009773977100849, -0.04990433529019356, 0.013888961635529995, 0.023261545225977898, -0.05084456875920296, -0.04348490759730339, -0.036145687103271484, 0.009273244999349117, 0.015120702795684338, -0.02038484439253807 ]
<p>I have some data that is bounded between 0 and 1. I have used the <code>betareg</code> package in R to fit a regression model with the bounded data as the dependent variable. My question is: how do I interpret the coefficients from the regression?</p>
36,223
[ 0.028857402503490448, -0.026215024292469025, 0.0032639806158840656, 0.015806440263986588, 0.002737542148679495, 0.02484450489282608, -0.008225800469517708, 0.008953489363193512, 0.037351299077272415, -0.06256739050149918, 0.03049665503203869, 0.021860308945178986, 0.03758757933974266, -0.021449346095323563, 0.030093220993876457, 0.006731145549565554, 0.0015367070445790887, -0.0026581601705402136, -0.004988847300410271, 0.006229896564036608, -0.0043942006304860115, 0.02931600995361805, 0.02210250310599804, 0.04675909876823425, -0.04232548177242279, 0.041719790548086166, 0.02850940264761448, -0.021829430013895035, -0.00835705641657114, 0.04020700976252556, -0.011877216398715973, -0.01896096020936966, -0.025202784687280655, -0.003412311663851142, 0.013623158447444439, -0.009370636194944382, -0.024349691346287727, -0.038057662546634674, -0.016309261322021484, 0.04164476692676544, -0.015405462123453617, -0.07248170673847198, 0.009480763226747513, 0.057350654155015945, -0.004721330478787422, -0.012313147075474262, 0.019876837730407715, -0.007265807595103979, 0.05465720593929291, -0.011857476085424423, 0.06650410592556, 0.0021354034543037415, 0.044379822909832, 0.04229152575135231, 0.0015247873961925507, -0.016909576952457428, 0.05771293863654137, 0.0708063542842865, -0.03305612504482269, -0.06349645555019379, -0.028628068044781685, -0.06848751753568649, -0.009465525858104229, 0.01013375073671341, -0.0016480725025758147, 0.009015113115310669, -0.0068166833370924, -0.021736066788434982, 0.035132117569446564, -0.006161590572446585, 0.04052731767296791, 0.04290452599525452, 0.015978218987584114, 0.000231281403102912, 0.00952913798391819, -0.010374479927122593, 0.005319059360772371, 0.037420276552438736, 0.029542041942477226, 0.042856574058532715, 0.0017371488502249122, 0.01630035601556301, 0.03412294760346413, 0.030227409675717354, 0.02969459816813469, -0.018363866955041885, 0.043937310576438904, -0.014152790419757366, 0.03477318212389946, 0.025031354278326035, -0.024758946150541306, 0.03496329486370087, 0.037541355937719345, 0.012987468391656876, -0.025509202852845192, 0.04391974210739136, 0.00805472768843174, 0.05608264356851578, 0.00708579458296299, -0.017769889906048775, 0.0033030472695827484, -0.052927400916814804, 0.002849258715286851, 0.03985360637307167, -0.007013406604528427, -0.007611061446368694, -0.035232171416282654, 0.007795275654643774, 0.000010312526683264878, -0.03344335779547691, -0.03229350224137306, 0.01318129152059555, 0.022560328245162964, -0.02521848864853382, 0.006075796205550432, -0.009892035275697708, -0.0006563105271197855, -0.019208358600735664, 0.08160462230443954, 0.04634702205657959, 0.035913895815610886, -0.015491117723286152, 0.011239135637879372, 0.017072459682822227, -0.052793826907873154, 0.03201334550976753, 0.01596151478588581, -0.03416798636317253, -0.04829388111829758, 0.03650468587875366, -0.021427903324365616, -0.05358530208468437, 0.029427500441670418, 0.0016813493566587567, 0.034512680023908615, 0.013604201376438141, -0.03939247503876686, -0.06822272390127182, 0.026443125680088997, -0.015680590644478798, 0.0018737117061391473, -0.055586572736501694, 0.0039711082354187965, 0.017178073525428772, 0.06812205910682678, 0.0025646300055086613, 0.04334362968802452, 0.018772585317492485, -0.01663362793624401, 0.0005353183951228857, -0.010775189846754074, -0.013166483491659164, -0.03583715856075287, -0.040269479155540466, -0.022005748003721237, -0.05533027648925781, 0.029295872896909714, 0.012293250299990177, -0.04386882111430168, -0.017384754493832588, 0.0728394091129303, -0.020288560539484024, -0.046559613198041916, -0.013590341433882713, -0.018259380012750626, 0.008970183320343494, 0.05928308889269829, 0.01432948000729084, -0.004273093305528164, 0.041686054319143295, 0.010557213798165321, 0.033541809767484665, 0.004278699401766062, 0.0606776662170887, 0.06805974245071411, 0.01999511942267418, 0.011907174251973629, -0.01630939356982708, 0.014820081181824207, 0.010990597307682037, -0.05114171281456947, -0.011483830399811268, -0.01587640307843685, -0.008073379285633564, 0.012610431760549545, 0.02891688421368599, 0.004995905328541994, -0.012824464589357376, 0.014828881248831749, -0.03059271164238453, -0.05239023268222809, -0.07247553765773773, -0.022998996078968048, -0.020712772384285927, 0.0005914272041991353, -0.007233278825879097, 0.008145707659423351, -0.006040302105247974, -0.029505468904972076, 0.005427625961601734, -0.05173156037926674, 0.00040151167195290327, 0.05099474638700485, -0.007971015758812428, -0.0025909123942255974, 0.043842680752277374, 0.0771288126707077, -0.02617599628865719, 0.03268146142363548, -0.03195692598819733, -0.010408484376966953, 0.032363541424274445, -0.03925129771232605, 0.010641875676810741, -0.0150827681645751, 0.027742993086576462, 0.022913191467523575, -0.003970189951360226, -0.004762647207826376, 0.011326415464282036, -0.045459628105163574, 0.03564506769180298, 0.05124308913946152, 0.017955835908651352, -0.027877014130353928, -0.022317098453640938, 0.005063203629106283, -0.032529138028621674, -0.05326632782816887, -0.03253769874572754, -0.04558832570910454, -0.01821468584239483, 0.016393335536122322, 0.03132817521691322, -0.02560923434793949, -0.009924683719873428, 0.029598772525787354, -0.01312351506203413, 0.012165572494268417, -0.00376392831094563, -0.006726568099111319, 0.016684547066688538, 0.0005636991118080914, -0.03065452165901661, 0.025308974087238312, 0.014403530396521091, -0.001031042542308569, 0.04145459458231926, 0.0444968119263649, -0.01436646468937397, 0.011439514346420765, 0.073912613093853, -0.016961587592959404, 0.019887547940015793, -0.030369410291314125, -0.008865426294505596, 0.046443816274404526, -0.03877979516983032, -0.0072184535674750805, 0.030043190345168114, 0.018934646621346474, 0.024288292974233627, 0.008496643975377083, 0.007243369705975056, 0.018400954082608223, 0.028905758634209633, -0.02582261525094509, 0.00039300386561080813, 0.02862778678536415, -0.05114518105983734, 0.035471439361572266, -0.02206180989742279, -0.06792333722114563, -0.02971082553267479, 0.018747994676232338, 0.015629887580871582, 0.03260699659585953, 0.024872340261936188, -0.052914999425411224, -0.05230310931801796, 0.018783975392580032, -0.026729408651590347, 0.03014821745455265, 0.037331659346818924, -0.062138818204402924, -0.004393020179122686, -0.05306139588356018, -0.008855494670569897, 0.03031192533671856, 0.01622146926820278, -0.019911859184503555, 0.0270376019179821, -0.03860246762633324, -0.04510588198900223, -0.055129628628492355, -0.034378331154584885, -0.025080177932977676, -0.009174017235636711, -0.03850620239973068, 0.04558473825454712, 0.0067240996286273, -0.044543638825416565, -0.005685912910848856, -0.06459216773509979, -0.0018108910880982876, -0.019284706562757492, 0.005020761396735907, -0.009205890819430351, -0.0012049872893840075, 0.03185844048857689, 0.02015654742717743, -0.025258788838982582, 0.010790402069687843, -0.04204525426030159, -0.07181522995233536, 0.02123044803738594, -0.0031716872472316027, 0.0014699255116283894, 0.014674996957182884, -0.05137738585472107, 0.09219199419021606, 0.014602139592170715, 0.006890349090099335, -0.07486061006784439, -0.023844538256525993, -0.03077053092420101, -0.0245683491230011, 0.008691331371665001, 0.03523869812488556, 0.052848681807518005, 0.01844058372080326, -0.0032388546969741583, 0.057257264852523804, 0.03575689345598221, -0.026361964643001556, -0.0018438482657074928, 0.027865443378686905, -0.006925660651177168, 0.0024127154611051083, 0.021463433280587196, 0.026327021420001984, 0.013653099536895752, 0.03445139527320862, -0.023806383833289146, 0.028947940096259117, 0.04023155942559242, -0.03861882910132408, 0.0010708189802244306, 0.0240425243973732, 0.0034095938317477703, -0.017966169863939285, 0.0559917651116848, 0.03463523089885712, -0.04069238528609276, 0.009852487593889236, -0.017501793801784515, 0.02959892340004444, -0.03152730315923691, -0.03372429311275482, 0.0019908202812075615, 0.015431837178766727, 0.001714314566925168, -0.042789850383996964, -0.019502051174640656, -0.019622953608632088, 0.008257103152573109, -0.027150552719831467, -0.016393983736634254, 0.040182147175073624, 0.018449651077389717, 0.008766057901084423, -0.0017404353711754084, -0.0827266275882721, -0.004022395703941584, -0.06321757286787033, -0.030651245266199112, -0.013622167520225048, 0.057477474212646484, -0.029429810121655464, 0.028183087706565857, -0.013639084063470364, -0.005196061916649342, 0.049511440098285675, 0.012771902605891228, -0.054767098277807236, 0.04028121381998062, -0.02940267138183117, 0.020665915682911873, -0.009192349389195442, 0.011863921768963337, 0.047735556960105896, -0.01216722559183836, -0.00126828090287745, -0.02845405973494053, -0.013359679840505123, -0.024588732048869133, 0.003170775482431054, -0.014393865130841732, -0.006757384166121483, -0.02663514018058777, 0.013540839776396751, -0.0001551308378111571, 0.0032081538811326027, 0.0024003058206290007, 0.07176197320222855, 0.01995931938290596, 0.006752602756023407, -0.03515481948852539, -0.03979413956403732, 0.02744731865823269, 0.06139971315860748, 0.053116824477910995, -0.005745743867009878, -0.022835468873381615, -0.015163762494921684, -0.009570631198585033, 0.03742191940546036, 0.0628189668059349, 0.01797553151845932, -0.022345874458551407, -0.04344163089990616, 0.006409922149032354, -0.0037861706223338842, -0.008673024363815784, -0.010561651550233364, 0.003338643116876483, 0.10354219377040863, 0.020114805549383163, -0.0348016731441021, 0.01940770260989666, 0.027853496372699738, 0.07027939707040787, -0.013187136501073837, -0.019520236179232597, 0.01363443024456501, 0.005409504286944866, 0.02043634094297886, -0.008252582512795925, -0.023844918236136436, -0.013651272282004356, 0.0132425706833601, 0.04772009328007698, -0.009975411929190159, -0.015742845833301544, 0.002608656417578459, 0.005475522950291634, 0.059005893766880035, 0.01020745374262333, -0.07656525820493698, 0.014723317697644234, 0.0503881499171257, 0.025760142132639885, 0.025010516867041588, -0.02494615875184536, -0.09565684199333191, -0.02530844882130623, 0.009793871082365513, 0.022333258762955666, -0.009223154745995998, -0.015633879229426384, -0.041526298969984055, -0.0071201748214662075, 0.024970505386590958, -0.0473601408302784, -0.0038363151252269745, 0.003263024380430579, 0.012614133767783642, -0.015151755884289742, -0.010096287354826927, -0.038833972066640854, 0.052644841372966766, -0.009202624671161175, 0.056028515100479126, -0.016834681853652, -0.004943178500980139, -0.011043631471693516, 0.036838628351688385, -0.024849677458405495, 0.04463649541139603, -0.008166993968188763, 0.009053693152964115, 0.043392281979322433, 0.012903415597975254, -0.0054037366062402725, -0.03766787797212601, 0.03503483906388283, 0.009475777857005596, 0.014737746678292751, 0.05793796852231026, -0.011632745154201984, -0.04707641899585724, -0.02886657975614071, 0.0030290812719613314, -0.002914654789492488, -0.0023688345681875944, -0.045057691633701324, 0.026842333376407623, 0.023499900475144386, -0.013231403194367886, 0.04930758848786354, 0.05003315582871437, 0.01931682787835598, 0.0012425989843904972, -0.024268537759780884, -0.0018796840449795127, 0.008500579744577408, -0.018072284758090973, -0.03567864000797272, -0.022856708616018295, -0.03399308770895004, 0.029340283945202827, 0.008340230211615562, 0.03374652564525604, -0.009580675512552261, -0.05812720209360123, 0.01661706157028675, 0.042792029678821564, -0.023667726665735245, 0.012008297257125378, 0.011924239806830883, 0.0097489720210433, -0.010270286351442337, -0.055396903306245804, 0.030829070135951042, -0.011768866330385208, 0.024994179606437683, 0.02953474037349224, -0.04600560665130615, 0.03358723595738411, 0.015850860625505447, -0.029250916093587875, 0.032181452959775925, -0.05380112677812576, 0.029730718582868576, -0.004597787745296955, -0.0017888839356601238, -0.02689104713499546, -0.025910191237926483, -0.03851985186338425, -0.0005409563891589642, -0.006948636379092932, 0.01316962018609047, -0.028635298833251, 0.05015523359179497, 0.011464330367743969, 0.0071475873701274395, -0.0593157559633255, -0.060784995555877686, 0.004628097638487816, 0.022079136222600937, -0.016956772655248642, -0.0019119800999760628, 0.0037430727388709784, -0.006814636290073395, -0.02768588997423649, -0.004906804766505957, 0.041175924241542816, -0.04671652987599373, -0.0004523975949268788, -0.010120523162186146, -0.012397044338285923, 0.05259319394826889, 0.017342371866106987, -0.0202267337590456, 0.032546281814575195, -0.01468926016241312, -0.03562445566058159, -0.0012120632454752922, 0.004273031838238239, -0.03809545934200287, -0.0029654051177203655, -0.05309179425239563, 0.033877648413181305, 0.03759765625, -0.018153412267565727, -0.007627373561263084, -0.005057124421000481, 0.010167288593947887, -0.003401809372007847, -0.028391145169734955, -0.02898159623146057, 0.014325875788927078, -0.008959711529314518, -0.014792582020163536, -0.021284818649291992, -0.011186320334672928, -0.026725882664322853, 0.0511922761797905, 0.02562834322452545, -0.017206905409693718, -0.00012189987319288775, 0.09871658682823181, 0.03887142613530159, 0.0119822658598423, -0.017249716445803642, -0.008141320198774338, 0.053258538246154785, 0.039235200732946396, 0.0033066610340029, 0.02802852727472782, 0.07991217076778412, -0.04306399077177048, -0.03519800305366516, -0.07124099880456924, 0.008696826174855232, 0.047152478247880936, -0.035689469426870346, 0.02817707322537899, 0.02347889542579651, -0.06395123153924942, -0.005181171931326389, -0.03259149193763733, -0.022948507219552994, -0.005272451788187027, -0.011935927905142307, 0.015417791903018951, -0.02350180223584175, -0.03120473027229309, -0.0031298527028411627, 0.011295952834188938, -0.03455394506454468, 0.039332471787929535, 0.04173031449317932, 0.011043312028050423, 0.025105269625782967, -0.01973101869225502, -0.04666576907038689, 0.03646943345665932, 0.008802158758044243, 0.01642194762825966, -0.014001492410898209, -0.03205396980047226, 0.058434516191482544, 0.03105703368782997, 0.04454946145415306, -0.07971761375665665, -0.013549137860536575, -0.02920534834265709, 0.008920542895793915, 0.04768851026892662, -0.019835563376545906, 0.04859920218586922, -0.013568675145506859, 0.001966119045391679, 0.0029750552494078875, 0.027601106092333794, -0.02425268106162548, -0.036404799669981, 0.008812754414975643, -0.065907321870327, -0.0452079102396965, 0.026957562193274498, -0.00912476982921362, -0.023167571052908897, 0.031062638387084007, -0.05267249420285225, -0.007329349871724844, 0.028834698721766472, 0.020811455324292183, 0.03282051905989647, 0.07142629474401474, 0.0055778962559998035, -0.016260581091046333, 0.0005765421665273607, 0.0019984629470854998, 0.11740754544734955, 0.1145215705037117, 0.00937300082296133, -0.09936599433422089, -0.020773131400346756, 0.0018054259708151221, 0.010057654231786728, -0.006453797686845064, -0.000869676296133548, -0.008259056136012077, -0.003147692419588566, 0.07070699334144592, 0.04536757245659828, -0.01583460345864296, 0.0745096281170845, 0.05493677034974098, -0.027862481772899628, -0.0008209380321204662, 0.039278171956539154, 0.006276207510381937, 0.009324464946985245, -0.027439432218670845, -0.032821837812662125, 0.0031922522466629744, 0.007743656635284424, -0.04103086143732071, -0.0028869840316474438, -0.00605814578011632, 0.011769916862249374, 0.006813493557274342, -0.022429320961236954, -0.006359504535794258, 0.0010035751620307565, 0.03722105547785759, -0.009241702035069466, 0.01627286523580551, 0.02073512226343155, -0.024749452248215675, -0.03379962220788002, 0.02126680687069893, -0.01697903871536255, -0.010916603729128838, -0.0007317984709516168, -0.012887523509562016, -0.04922566935420036, -0.010826140642166138, -0.009320320561528206, 0.049535468220710754, -0.02964659407734871, -0.006266671232879162, 0.005579225718975067, 0.047001127153635025, -0.016087761148810387, -0.06570763140916824, -0.004905635956674814, 0.042422860860824585, 0.01583591289818287, -0.03800084441900253, -0.04460066556930542, -0.03241010755300522, -0.02217247523367405, -0.0146427471190691, 0.03596843034029007, 0.008332296274602413, -0.05738994851708412, 0.030743762850761414, -0.01434995885938406, 0.057474393397569656, -0.05348920077085495, -0.002784480107948184, 0.016450008377432823, -0.005978787783533335, -0.03088524378836155, 0.004777911119163036, 0.035740263760089874, 0.007317400071769953, -0.0018589068204164505, -0.02284849062561989, -0.0003607803082559258, -0.00956021249294281, -0.04354289174079895, 0.019262241199612617, -0.07301051169633865, 0.000372633890947327, -0.05825614556670189, -0.0035728050861507654, 0.002886080415919423, 0.052383411675691605, 0.01544761098921299, 0.009217222221195698, -0.020190995186567307, 0.04931313917040825, 0.006242368835955858, -0.06766989082098007, -0.02898971363902092, 0.01269041933119297, -0.06801649183034897, 0.011505300179123878, -0.00027234212029725313, 0.06466058641672134, 0.017271172255277634, 0.014562807977199554, -0.016993332654237747, 0.010373581200838089, -0.00418477738276124, 0.02936646156013012, -0.024709369987249374, -0.06570859998464584, 0.02037276141345501, 0.034224532544612885, 0.016587181016802788, -0.019251197576522827, -0.02048848196864128, -0.026863355189561844, -0.027142932638525963, -0.005277268122881651, 0.0009707586141303182, -0.04955805465579033, 0.036531008780002594, -0.0038510269951075315, -0.011936118826270103, 0.0073515563271939754, 0.003122335998341441, -0.020324423909187317, 0.02346605435013771, 0.03163565322756767, -0.0327594093978405, 0.005912178661674261, -0.01054048165678978, -0.029577402397990227, 0.011026006191968918, 0.043065570294857025, 0.012849356047809124, 0.026246927678585052, 0.012715399265289307, -0.0027158630546182394, -0.04644414409995079, 0.026491612195968628, -0.026535069569945335, -0.042611707001924515, -0.02858935296535492, 0.004915828350931406, -0.023173168301582336, 0.004948213696479797, 0.031233398243784904, 0.033896781504154205, 0.006307163741439581, 0.017642997205257416, -0.03360532596707344, 0.042253125458955765, -0.033914316445589066, 0.0007856314769014716, -0.0025423041079193354, 0.016905205324292183, 0.023828458040952682, -0.0003106550720985979, 0.03041924722492695, 0.033796776086091995, -0.011796940118074417, -0.0014613226521760225, 0.027261681854724884, -0.0030863936990499496, -0.027706656605005264, 0.005223574582487345, 0.008608277887105942, -0.009844549931585789, 0.0027483387384563684, 0.008658471517264843, 0.016960829496383667, 0.0517849363386631, -0.025192778557538986, 0.024678658694028854, -0.014851011335849762, 0.015421307645738125, -0.09104601293802261, -0.04390350356698036, 0.011173272505402565, -0.00575620960444212, 0.033121682703495026, -0.0569385290145874, 0.0052148024551570415, 0.029072299599647522, -0.002661803038790822, -0.03809255734086037, -0.004612674470990896, 0.0028844240587204695, -0.012249394319951534, -0.01998472958803177, -0.003103204071521759, 0.025661589577794075, 0.047123175114393234, 0.01196892186999321, 0.025496823713183403, 0.0249592587351799, -0.016284169629216194, -0.03535594791173935, -0.0018222118960693479, 0.004869332071393728, -0.009971298277378082, -0.04443218931555748, 0.04350683093070984, -0.04123762995004654, -0.019765719771385193, 0.055381644517183304, -0.03292781114578247, 0.010289546102285385, 0.04244011640548706, 0.013077829964458942, 0.005108659155666828, 0.05414573848247528, 0.047409817576408386, -0.016512088477611542, -0.028264136984944344, -0.005273124668747187, 0.014117036014795303, -0.004757238551974297, -0.01366790384054184, 0.026451556012034416, -0.013394089415669441, -0.016763661056756973, 0.011930390261113644, 0.037965308874845505, -0.009399134665727615, -0.004422130528837442, -0.025528956204652786, -0.006409103516489267, -0.003414321457967162, -0.02659999206662178, 0.024452317506074905, -0.05255160853266716, -0.008399322628974915, 0.024214552715420723, 0.029282204806804657, -0.030433351173996925, 0.013780811801552773, -0.00816946942359209, -0.02154669351875782, 0.025670912116765976, 0.035110991448163986, -0.03235109522938728, -0.040308624505996704, -0.008892049081623554, 0.007600636221468449, -0.021441688761115074, -0.008242303505539894, 0.0002255499130114913, 0.009358196519315243, 0.017400352284312248, 0.009392808191478252, -0.015624972060322762, 0.0036708470433950424, -0.047655489295721054, 0.037555158138275146, -0.0757320299744606, 0.07202203571796417, -0.023492688313126564, -0.0003507037181407213, -0.009994318708777428, -0.018028438091278076, -0.029968105256557465, -0.01907411217689514, 0.04985829442739487, 0.0077766431495547295, -0.010774127207696438, -0.0030560691375285387, 0.041133154183626175, -0.01048574224114418, -0.01945478841662407, 0.02836054563522339, 0.02864707075059414, -0.012581827118992805, -0.017175739631056786, -0.007094480562955141, -0.014248088002204895, 0.03190559521317482, 0.008298932574689388, 0.03305793181061745, 0.000015053175957291387, -0.00658138794824481, -0.01635027304291725, 0.032923679798841476, 0.014991983771324158, 0.006865857634693384, 0.0885910838842392, 0.018657207489013672, 0.012962700799107552, 0.04567351192235947, -0.008747490122914314, -0.048456743359565735, 0.03904977813363075, -0.012310277670621872, -0.004447081591933966, 0.01410309225320816, -0.003249282017350197, -0.00004258029002812691, -0.052397385239601135, -0.01644245535135269, 0.020114926621317863, 0.013115148060023785, -0.0017922299448400736, 0.014271516352891922, 0.02086939476430416, 0.05148507282137871, -0.025141919031739235, -0.0007058089831843972, 0.03287699073553085, -0.030154528096318245, 0.021359819918870926, 0.0277263093739748, 0.05760350823402405, -0.000245798088144511, 0.02040359377861023, 0.03277619928121567, 0.01580934040248394, -0.003162536770105362, -0.016905082389712334, 0.024081086739897728, -0.03688027709722519, -0.0180968027561903, -0.005165465641766787, 0.0016898004105314612, 0.019875889644026756, -0.028149964287877083, 0.0373431034386158, 0.028356553986668587, -0.02476118877530098, -0.010084786452353, -0.030383272096514702, 0.004146710503846407, -0.02861463651061058, 0.02284897491335869, 0.028365667909383774, 0.019751541316509247, -0.009360883384943008, -0.0038654012605547905, 0.004436608869582415, -0.02724319137632847, 0.027267148718237877, -0.004212915897369385, -0.034229885786771774, -0.019538922235369682, 0.005067893769592047, -0.0041425167582929134, -0.011043141596019268, -0.02554832398891449, -0.007663438096642494, 0.0520765446126461, 0.02412903495132923, 0.01210903748869896, -0.03182161599397659, -0.046080514788627625, 0.005672783125191927, 0.05288415029644966, -0.06567338109016418, -0.018025334924459457, -0.02011801116168499, 0.0056697046384215355, -0.0038573509082198143, -0.04391396790742874 ]
<p>I'm using the <code>igraph</code> package in <code>R</code> to analyze network data. I'm currently trying to calculate some centrality measures for the vertices of my graph and the corresponding centralization scores. My network is both directed and weighted.</p> <pre><code>require(igraph) set.seed(12152) m &lt;- expand.grid(from = 1:4, to = 1:4) m &lt;- m[m$from != m$to, ] m$weight &lt;- sample(1:7, 12, replace = T) g &lt;- graph.data.frame(m) </code></pre> <p>I have no trouble using the <code>closeness</code> function to obtain the closeness centrality for each vertex:</p> <pre><code>closeness(g, mode = "in") closeness(g, mode = "out") closeness(g, mode = "total") </code></pre> <p>However, it appears that the <code>centralization.closeness</code> function from <code>igraph</code> does not work for directed graphs. <code>igraph</code> does include a way to calculate a custom centralization from the individual centrality scores in a graph (the <code>centralize.scores</code> function), but that function requires the user to specify the theoretical maximum of the centrality measure, and it's not obvious to me what that would be in this weighted example (I believe the built-in <code>centralization.closeness.tmax</code> function in <code>igraph</code> assumes an unweighted graph).</p> <p>Does anyone know how to calculate a centralization score in a weighted graph? Is there a good way to accomplish this in R with <code>igraph</code> or some other package?</p>
32,214
[ -0.037060417234897614, 0.005505235865712166, 0.01620849408209324, -0.004056609235703945, 0.024999435991048813, 0.012993291020393372, -0.021969180554151535, -0.01653827168047428, 0.036015089601278305, -0.025228552520275116, 0.026723330840468407, 0.07113660871982574, 0.05980957671999931, 0.03123348020017147, 0.029421694576740265, -0.017570121213793755, -0.025420503690838814, 0.011617748066782951, 0.014037561602890491, -0.028835350647568703, 0.0028319808188825846, 0.041265565901994705, 0.007811843417584896, 0.0003802464052569121, -0.005524938926100731, 0.03601003810763359, -0.0033378410153090954, 0.001437499886378646, -0.0008384644752368331, 0.042742129415273666, -0.02162988670170307, -0.01929750293493271, 0.010070567019283772, -0.0005520424456335604, 0.028657397255301476, 0.0033095062244683504, -0.030022915452718735, -0.016133807599544525, -0.050356049090623856, 0.01160411536693573, 0.007628730498254299, -0.034865014255046844, -0.02870250679552555, 0.03973634913563728, -0.02172263339161873, 0.028275111690163612, -0.03491607680916786, -0.004644536878913641, 0.03595319390296936, -0.05061868205666542, 0.07409690320491791, 0.020209625363349915, 0.03604496642947197, 0.02845221944153309, -0.034793611615896225, -0.018529387190937996, 0.05874486640095711, 0.06405893713235855, 0.012184111401438713, -0.06272007524967194, -0.04540077596902847, -0.05100662633776665, -0.003886484308168292, -0.052051663398742676, -0.052311792969703674, 0.024304747581481934, -0.010508783161640167, 0.0025625608395785093, 0.037948232144117355, -0.05099441483616829, -0.0424627885222435, 0.030336527153849602, 0.03990361839532852, -0.030099472030997276, 0.010356485843658447, -0.034102387726306915, 0.025129100307822227, -0.01377874705940485, 0.03779775649309158, 0.03895150497555733, 0.010860470123589039, 0.039780549705028534, -0.0016156088095158339, 0.036395348608493805, 0.018426664173603058, -0.014808372594416142, 0.09455231577157974, -0.014617200940847397, 0.01866811513900757, 0.00909529346972704, -0.043306875973939896, -0.02284025400876999, 0.02740449458360672, -0.007281442638486624, -0.023323748260736465, 0.024989312514662743, -0.01407290156930685, 0.033957142382860184, -0.014605501666665077, -0.010110796429216862, -0.017570190131664276, -0.04676598682999611, -0.03240739181637764, 0.035783614963293076, -0.0038877236656844616, -0.009643916971981525, -0.06054476276040077, -0.019608113914728165, 0.02333333157002926, -0.014887960627675056, -0.03375256061553955, -0.00022076821187511086, -0.020177163183689117, -0.03874049708247185, 0.01416885107755661, -0.05649157613515854, -0.01572887971997261, 0.0002036336954915896, 0.024474453181028366, 0.04842789098620415, 0.02078152820467949, -0.0025546392425894737, 0.023281851783394814, -0.06803369522094727, -0.0289718359708786, 0.021493103355169296, 0.029099449515342712, -0.026890991255640984, -0.03266407921910286, 0.03627151623368263, 0.02293805405497551, -0.018664982169866562, 0.01994510181248188, -0.007130464073270559, 0.02878911979496479, -0.023943012580275536, -0.09705176204442978, -0.07530622184276581, 0.038617268204689026, -0.02889311872422695, -0.0009890657383948565, -0.05817946419119835, 0.004037915728986263, 0.019022924825549126, 0.04986226186156273, 0.04032724350690842, 0.056920360773801804, 0.010966593399643898, -0.007416439708322287, 0.030008353292942047, -0.03866089507937431, -0.014062698930501938, -0.048848707228899, -0.035778895020484924, -0.020731009542942047, -0.053939856588840485, -0.005198533646762371, -0.005150575656443834, -0.0306266937404871, 0.0032832156866788864, 0.06135677546262741, 0.007852375507354736, -0.010178567841649055, -0.009118426591157913, -0.00003152839053655043, -0.021804586052894592, 0.05993710830807686, 0.026849566027522087, 0.014867452904582024, 0.02302628755569458, -0.018443478271365166, 0.017819950357079506, 0.01661529392004013, 0.04346587881445885, 0.025752803310751915, -0.008393901400268078, -0.0050604925490915775, -0.01588146574795246, -0.0028480766341090202, 0.03262348845601082, -0.014066281728446484, -0.02457340992987156, 0.006590083707123995, -0.0006068411166779697, 0.03118179179728031, 0.03775420039892197, -0.0049171750433743, -0.016205044463276863, 0.034213803708553314, -0.031170830130577087, -0.018955405801534653, -0.052097901701927185, -0.015959151089191437, -0.019792616367340088, -0.029168253764510155, -0.020381607115268707, -0.012719305232167244, 0.060120441019535065, 0.030107799917459488, -0.023086685687303543, -0.009046100080013275, 0.012955037876963615, 0.06172211840748787, -0.019390197470784187, -0.0062819854356348515, 0.03141510859131813, 0.05854512378573418, 0.0003859276184812188, 0.041005559265613556, -0.014364293776452541, -0.0506133995950222, 0.03153470903635025, -0.0476459376513958, 0.0034157864283770323, 0.004983657505363226, -0.025693489238619804, 0.024752330034971237, 0.0026324850041419268, -0.0037664100527763367, 0.0209952499717474, -0.0369204543530941, 0.09937260299921036, 0.06432794779539108, 0.024857239797711372, 0.012435002252459526, 0.0006592878489755094, 0.020367233082652092, 0.010935543105006218, -0.03072013147175312, -0.0013749476056545973, -0.08300873637199402, -0.03684414178133011, 0.033790405839681625, 0.0012499926378950477, -0.04812724143266678, -0.0025794166140258312, 0.03343534097075462, 0.005356683395802975, 0.012854538857936859, 0.008894378319382668, -0.028810881078243256, 0.0018629153491929173, 0.0013501044595614076, 0.026133989915251732, 0.015102185308933258, 0.0018696950282901525, 0.028905780985951424, 0.024856597185134888, 0.0529525987803936, 0.004864566493779421, 0.002516934648156166, 0.06066419929265976, -0.01172185130417347, -0.006552098318934441, -0.021169109269976616, -0.022282537072896957, 0.04353833571076393, -0.021253293380141258, 0.023386899381875992, 0.0701468214392662, -0.021244006231427193, 0.0033725653775036335, 0.006047544535249472, -0.046717338263988495, 0.008944937959313393, 0.04399605840444565, -0.03026164323091507, 0.01555496733635664, -0.016786828637123108, -0.0169694721698761, 0.025427797809243202, -0.018098954111337662, 0.007776838727295399, -0.04994117468595505, 0.030532382428646088, 0.009165770374238491, -0.0011905442224815488, -0.010871034115552902, -0.03768530488014221, -0.04767555743455887, -0.004586874973028898, -0.01806117221713066, -0.0025922951754182577, 0.005742543842643499, -0.035171251744031906, -0.010831829160451889, -0.004524650052189827, -0.041185248643159866, 0.007592721842229366, -0.0024490575306117535, -0.01879058964550495, 0.006296445149928331, 0.03368406742811203, -0.013325461186468601, 0.005728045478463173, -0.016119180247187614, 0.05964457243680954, -0.027745507657527924, 0.007576958741992712, 0.0232634786516428, 0.000350400892784819, -0.03171378746628761, 0.039855923503637314, -0.01773180440068245, -0.031590018421411514, -0.007797985803335905, -0.008848922327160835, 0.01520146057009697, -0.007716498803347349, 0.0019651714246720076, 0.03287293761968613, -0.04712291806936264, -0.015626711770892143, -0.07234512269496918, -0.03817945718765259, 0.027285194024443626, 0.016008285805583, 0.02514270879328251, 0.06428192555904388, -0.02712213806807995, 0.0800284668803215, 0.03208262473344803, -0.04533693194389343, -0.05317483842372894, -0.01236975658684969, -0.02939729019999504, 0.02419980801641941, 0.02517561800777912, 0.007177209947258234, -0.006598960142582655, -0.01632961817085743, 0.01804545521736145, 0.012554476968944073, 0.06439539790153503, -0.032038215547800064, -0.0006956692086532712, 0.042567986994981766, 0.010420626029372215, -0.02492762729525566, 0.0637940838932991, 0.012037796899676323, 0.0000862254310050048, 0.014510187320411205, 0.012587442994117737, -0.012516763992607594, -0.0490998812019825, -0.04426079988479614, -0.009307689033448696, 0.00340086966753006, 0.042735785245895386, -0.0723237544298172, 0.03790856897830963, 0.0022312146611511707, -0.00722033716738224, 0.034658368676900864, 0.026585128158330917, 0.04735966771841049, -0.03164263069629669, 0.009380430914461613, 0.05921758711338043, 0.015402344055473804, -0.01875396817922592, -0.0013083856320008636, -0.0331609770655632, -0.012789638713002205, 0.00988047569990158, -0.019433867186307907, -0.01679166778922081, 0.03966784104704857, 0.028808968141674995, 0.014121729880571365, 0.0334644541144371, -0.03243830054998398, 0.029435794800519943, -0.060693103820085526, 0.03547898307442665, -0.048040684312582016, 0.06258126348257065, 0.002958661876618862, 0.026022780686616898, 0.052411772310733795, 0.011415939778089523, 0.012082536704838276, -0.019090089946985245, -0.07897058874368668, 0.031066253781318665, -0.02600650116801262, -0.001991053344681859, 0.0136139877140522, -0.03452162444591522, 0.020401766523718834, 0.005396497901529074, 0.015919223427772522, -0.002619323553517461, -0.001139785279519856, -0.021441034972667694, 0.027451291680336, 0.0005099383997730911, 0.03473640978336334, -0.008698586374521255, 0.020526854321360588, 0.023750431835651398, -0.025177864357829094, 0.033696845173835754, 0.026406478136777878, -0.003302056808024645, -0.02397097647190094, -0.02879689447581768, -0.02253147028386593, 0.03571318835020065, 0.030583735555410385, 0.05524967983365059, 0.0380965918302536, -0.034090496599674225, -0.0026441658847033978, 0.003277125535532832, 0.05289348214864731, 0.04151922091841698, -0.03820620849728584, -0.0004998011863790452, -0.04429527744650841, -0.019471582025289536, 0.011355072259902954, 0.02029210887849331, -0.017608391121029854, -0.008061493746936321, 0.06684046983718872, 0.03389006108045578, -0.0541127510368824, 0.03358515724539757, 0.0549340546131134, 0.050873588770627975, -0.03142492100596428, -0.030912788584828377, 0.002971337176859379, -0.0098606301471591, -0.02872137911617756, 0.03836534172296524, -0.017473097890615463, 0.014424153603613377, 0.008165662176907063, 0.009457558393478394, -0.043246425688266754, -0.032626792788505554, 0.004352576099336147, 0.002569815143942833, 0.05680890381336212, -0.02048095129430294, -0.015476767905056477, -0.023845845833420753, 0.02034609206020832, 0.047817256301641464, 0.015329882502555847, -0.027842611074447632, -0.08229201287031174, -0.011446893215179443, 0.039169084280729294, 0.05360088124871254, -0.008491368032991886, -0.03154023364186287, 0.002550316508859396, -0.016393344849348068, 0.028773711994290352, -0.031004296615719795, 0.04504130408167839, -0.02169094607234001, 0.014079321175813675, -0.013242817483842373, -0.023170538246631622, -0.009150490164756775, 0.011827557347714901, -0.034098390489816666, 0.023961128666996956, -0.024269070476293564, -0.001676755491644144, -0.07146106660366058, -0.009623058140277863, 0.0020990122575312853, 0.06248379871249199, -0.010462763719260693, -0.019706865772604942, 0.006287748459726572, -0.003803407307714224, -0.026253806427121162, -0.05990205332636833, 0.010405328124761581, 0.008915212005376816, 0.0031701112166047096, 0.05528144910931587, -0.0034760665148496628, 0.013387843035161495, 0.04892652854323387, 0.0572027862071991, -0.001924042240716517, 0.0033789128065109253, 0.0199799295514822, 0.05556052178144455, 0.040143027901649475, -0.03872142732143402, 0.03767642378807068, 0.04567428678274155, -0.015589523129165173, -0.0034560044296085835, -0.050526540726423264, 0.013431431725621223, -0.026317767798900604, -0.02133411541581154, -0.03071417286992073, -0.0011910746106877923, 0.004536910448223352, -0.014964067377150059, 0.00008830862498143688, 0.013355872593820095, -0.04724947363138199, -0.02289515919983387, 0.0003254939219914377, 0.04377155378460884, 0.0007528229034505785, 0.003038096008822322, 0.05711277201771736, 0.028567306697368622, 0.025021512061357498, -0.015514921396970749, 0.0034540093038231134, -0.03161746636033058, 0.016753103584051132, -0.00507896114140749, -0.05768077075481415, -0.000963428639806807, -0.00015875489043537527, -0.014404908753931522, -0.011479339562356472, -0.026097046211361885, 0.03377503529191017, -0.032907016575336456, 0.010274666361510754, -0.02451333776116371, -0.02895570732653141, -0.03568992018699646, 0.008998846635222435, -0.004193959757685661, 0.007270450703799725, 0.003401696914806962, 0.024190327152609825, -0.03912915661931038, -0.012081959284842014, -0.04343385994434357, -0.01976952515542507, 0.019829250872135162, 0.0056352196261286736, -0.056657832115888596, -0.04430760070681572, -0.013931771740317345, -0.010778108611702919, -0.009633165784180164, -0.019084705039858818, 0.023095784708857536, 0.0005189848598092794, -0.010682051070034504, -0.010603193193674088, -0.0049956925213336945, 0.054029885679483414, 0.018442373722791672, 0.0005846270360052586, 0.0007290382054634392, -0.011124002747237682, -0.010471927933394909, 0.0057340157218277454, 0.03283393010497093, -0.04040902853012085, -0.02547273598611355, -0.0045945229940116405, 0.01883777044713497, 0.04985438287258148, 0.016214506700634956, -0.03089352883398533, -0.009153863415122032, -0.00929351057857275, -0.014394586905837059, -0.04052368924021721, -0.03427547216415405, -0.009892974980175495, 0.014301755465567112, -0.03980311006307602, 0.02991648018360138, -0.0034624917898327112, -0.01989097148180008, 0.027462713420391083, -0.007633581757545471, -0.0011671084212139249, 0.007234002463519573, 0.061396848410367966, 0.02969077229499817, 0.040231794118881226, -0.013430286198854446, -0.04957025125622749, 0.034210942685604095, 0.002939449157565832, -0.004058788064867258, 0.01229945570230484, 0.031575530767440796, -0.027094438672065735, 0.002552824094891548, -0.03416520357131958, 0.02285882830619812, 0.03326325863599777, -0.013941035605967045, 0.03928123787045479, 0.04628223925828934, -0.012387356720864773, 0.0036994246765971184, -0.029475390911102295, -0.026927653700113297, -0.008631713688373566, 0.03257247805595398, 0.056194957345724106, -0.023913240060210228, -0.03430337831377983, 0.05524064227938652, 0.029837381094694138, 0.0029596416279673576, 0.017890790477395058, 0.01939609833061695, 0.01121705211699009, 0.014423899352550507, -0.010460610501468182, -0.029656417667865753, 0.023636864498257637, -0.0116109699010849, -0.0017780024791136384, -0.03709176555275917, -0.07586390525102615, 0.006259328685700893, 0.013325309380888939, -0.008082319982349873, -0.023743197321891785, -0.02002032846212387, -0.019879978150129318, 0.021633248776197433, 0.058215923607349396, -0.02012478932738304, -0.01078345812857151, 0.026727458462119102, 0.025955095887184143, -0.015002100728452206, 0.03827427700161934, -0.04314082860946655, -0.06627193093299866, -0.030506445094943047, -0.028343986719846725, -0.045154910534620285, 0.0091117974370718, 0.008829668164253235, -0.019711023196578026, 0.048712436109781265, -0.01701124757528305, 0.012249264866113663, -0.010523192584514618, 0.026477674022316933, -0.01056280080229044, 0.07342912256717682, 0.006800597999244928, -0.006534026004374027, 0.024734925478696823, -0.03621672838926315, 0.13049113750457764, 0.08514711260795593, 0.04470495134592056, -0.057778675109148026, 0.025748111307621002, 0.027063824236392975, -0.012390567921102047, -0.04970719665288925, -0.005878798197954893, -0.0016630101017653942, -0.025665421038866043, 0.07451912760734558, 0.05265435948967934, 0.01127750612795353, 0.0070716082118451595, 0.06851733475923538, -0.029656166210770607, -0.04623176530003548, 0.013950290158390999, 0.019420240074396133, -0.011657190509140491, -0.04825374484062195, -0.08583156019449234, 0.03298315033316612, -0.0098046800121665, -0.0013283351436257362, -0.03505951166152954, 0.001458002720028162, -0.01879824325442314, -0.015244538895785809, 0.02090618945658207, 0.00029121103580109775, 0.007410208694636822, -0.0022120268549770117, -0.013414710760116577, -0.01265038177371025, 0.045400481671094894, -0.004551908001303673, 0.028766373172402382, 0.020850110799074173, -0.020907718688249588, 0.013083075173199177, -0.001017112284898758, 0.04649313911795616, -0.04834210127592087, -0.056921206414699554, -0.015364861115813255, 0.0421263761818409, 0.008715125732123852, 0.013860398903489113, 0.035354290157556534, 0.020353129133582115, -0.003543393686413765, -0.01869962178170681, 0.000029785200240439735, 0.006736032199114561, 0.05858143791556358, -0.015277638100087643, -0.00494765629991889, -0.015175528824329376, 0.023412879556417465, -0.019493546336889267, 0.020553022623062134, -0.0073014493100345135, -0.015380867756903172, -0.02713545225560665, -0.07942044734954834, 0.02774137072265148, 0.00043824539170600474, -0.016848867759108543, -0.013731875456869602, -0.026421494781970978, -0.005981240421533585, -0.012494591064751148, 0.00047047703992575407, -0.013461443595588207, 0.04295184463262558, -0.001323728822171688, 0.04200693964958191, -0.006275402382016182, -0.021076267585158348, -0.00009027650958159938, -0.03325176239013672, -0.019873006269335747, -0.044697780162096024, 0.00948968157172203, 0.078244149684906, 0.051702968776226044, 0.01148813497275114, 0.014031980186700821, -0.025838378816843033, 0.023414861410856247, -0.012340214103460312, -0.020601077005267143, -0.0036744324024766684, -0.013765044510364532, -0.03827327489852905, 0.003462969558313489, -0.006994001101702452, 0.027097532525658607, 0.030236100777983665, -0.022104714065790176, 0.011266752146184444, 0.029918869957327843, 0.0026253564283251762, 0.013027320615947247, 0.018163705244660378, -0.03530251607298851, 0.01989818550646305, -0.023969432339072227, -0.03125086426734924, -0.03677785396575928, -0.0072892508469522, -0.04149022325873375, -0.06125933676958084, 0.040905870497226715, 0.019910642877221107, -0.04794713854789734, 0.007385916542261839, 0.002987871179357171, 0.013414738699793816, -0.01136280782520771, -0.022311709821224213, -0.03170153871178627, -0.03346669673919678, -0.044382717460393906, -0.009238039143383503, -0.005583018064498901, 0.009259087033569813, -0.006684285122901201, -0.01062722783535719, 0.04315049946308136, 0.014145373366773129, -0.001465100678615272, -0.00403687683865428, -0.008441130630671978, 0.013273275457322598, 0.05828109383583069, 0.011078241281211376, -0.01965225674211979, 0.06311700493097305, -0.05967821180820465, -0.04271271824836731, 0.008497556671500206, -0.007044147700071335, 0.02961721271276474, 0.03180800750851631, -0.01804109662771225, -0.010845300741493702, 0.03537760302424431, 0.005131328012794256, -0.0036939657293260098, -0.008907132782042027, 0.007955796085298061, 0.0123215913772583, 0.02609771117568016, -0.0011375994654372334, 0.0025668854359537363, 0.016587110236287117, -0.02707758918404579, 0.03886951506137848, 0.013152621686458588, 0.004575304687023163, -0.014321103692054749, -0.007219540886580944, -0.0056569078005850315, 0.022925961762666702, -0.03295253962278366, 0.051554519683122635, 0.037388015538454056, -0.03764050453901291, -0.0031922466587275267, -0.018351325765252113, 0.022186726331710815, -0.07266712933778763, 0.004629400558769703, -0.01769089885056019, -0.025654342025518417, 0.018499016761779785, -0.05199487507343292, 0.025865811854600906, 0.008828871883451939, -0.03997236117720604, 0.053934067487716675, -0.004799728747457266, -0.013384670950472355, -0.03223802521824837, 0.02253580279648304, -0.024049194529652596, 0.026055974885821342, 0.014711825177073479, 0.04627172276377678, 0.013745030388236046, 0.009958222508430481, 0.012629210948944092, -0.0032230664510279894, -0.01605811156332493, 0.018650922924280167, 0.013479706831276417, -0.08319893479347229, 0.016976000741124153, -0.03156442940235138, -0.054588645696640015, 0.028447099030017853, -0.012650273740291595, -0.02583780698478222, 0.013810067437589169, 0.037128597497940063, 0.04413684457540512, 0.07517984509468079, 0.02245367504656315, -0.018864614889025688, -0.009485225193202496, 0.029704470187425613, 0.029750509187579155, 0.011613328941166401, -0.03744317218661308, 0.035297784954309464, 0.03189914673566818, -0.0038575883954763412, -0.015886228531599045, 0.01809016987681389, -0.045334506779909134, -0.028341960161924362, -0.03668500855565071, -0.011170118115842342, 0.030692385509610176, -0.05563071370124817, 0.02954876609146595, -0.035433296114206314, -0.030654961243271828, 0.05536634102463722, 0.0057092104107141495, -0.012981921434402466, 0.014304948039352894, 0.02048199065029621, -0.034619830548763275, 0.026820354163646698, -0.010193908587098122, 0.0003409783821552992, -0.03053855337202549, 0.0006239514914341271, 0.005500754341483116, -0.0019908982794731855, -0.015423385426402092, -0.017990712076425552, -0.02463599108159542, 0.021227894350886345, -0.015612012706696987, 0.014460061676800251, -0.00413095485419035, 0.01044397708028555, 0.05339694768190384, -0.09745235741138458, 0.01485606748610735, 0.017291637137532234, 0.023386795073747635, -0.027210209518671036, 0.019438374787569046, -0.0019262796267867088, -0.017279213294386864, 0.06171146407723427, -0.0022746718022972345, -0.011002137325704098, 0.005976350512355566, 0.05257324501872063, 0.027256539091467857, -0.04694952443242073, 0.023602107539772987, -0.018772751092910767, -0.019190140068531036, -0.023464644327759743, -0.0431060753762722, 0.007107884623110294, 0.041547395288944244, -0.008267012424767017, -0.01289327722042799, 0.0037269897293299437, -0.011486608535051346, 0.010760920122265816, 0.02792724035680294, -0.007405923213809729, -0.026420341804623604, 0.08385182172060013, 0.0037818464916199446, -0.005102876108139753, 0.05612292140722275, 0.007956092245876789, 0.009481362998485565, 0.042396459728479385, -0.026851976290345192, -0.04910571128129959, 0.03419840335845947, 0.019329829141497612, 0.00980736780911684, -0.06614147126674652, 0.0016040338668972254, 0.009203925728797913, -0.04205378517508507, -0.026806887239217758, 0.025047125294804573, 0.024979257956147194, 0.05515893176198006, 0.017488036304712296, -0.013921525329351425, 0.00929162185639143, -0.03951535373926163, 0.01950852759182453, 0.03376558795571327, 0.0320998951792717, 0.029397908598184586, 0.033720750361680984, -0.009123207069933414, -0.020098840817809105, 0.026782192289829254, -0.02950945869088173, 0.04649798199534416, -0.02579607628285885, -0.0474097914993763, 0.032849401235580444, -0.027912771329283714, 0.06521148979663849, -0.008745122700929642, -0.01260843314230442, 0.03936466574668884, -0.009769836440682411, 0.013660542666912079, -0.005185912363231182, -0.04103779047727585, -0.04407981410622597, 0.03660641610622406, -0.0074067856185138226, 0.05097236856818199, -0.034802526235580444, 0.020865190774202347, -0.004353765398263931, -0.032863955944776535, 0.020093826577067375, -0.005598324351012707, 0.050376035273075104, -0.019930904731154442, 0.02817031741142273, -0.022308802232146263, -0.0012441333383321762, -0.055139657109975815, -0.0029292681720107794, -0.003227140288800001, 0.03608766570687294, 0.03705966845154762, -0.0035046711564064026, -0.01751529797911644, 0.043991900980472565, 0.023785261437296867, -0.06113225221633911, -0.004705445375293493, -0.08552976697683334, -0.004345107823610306, -0.012245215475559235, 0.0020950562320649624 ]
<p>Consider a model with a continuous response variable and a categorical explanatory variable. I appreciate that in R, a summary.lm output of an anova on this data gives you rows that represent the mean value of each factor level. The significance stars represent the significance of the difference between the mean of each level and the "intercept", which represents the mean of the first level of the factor.</p> <p>What I am wondering is what do significance stars on this intercept term represent? Simply that the mean of this particular factor level is different from zero?</p>
36,225
[ -0.05018404871225357, 0.02766837365925312, -0.02947264164686203, 0.017700182273983955, 0.06820554286241531, -0.0063612074591219425, -0.006203147582709789, -0.0018814017530530691, 0.005088001489639282, -0.051649026572704315, 0.031066445633769035, 0.0025342220906168222, 0.022743158042430878, 0.01142381876707077, 0.01925872266292572, 0.02294178307056427, -0.020782470703125, -0.015634018927812576, -0.01022333838045597, 0.011629522778093815, -0.00982891209423542, 0.0005647746147587895, -0.014261744916439056, 0.028595594689249992, -0.02206866443157196, 0.0743766650557518, 0.04705507680773735, -0.02980290912091732, 0.014580057002604008, 0.006212318316102028, -0.004523022100329399, 0.029478538781404495, -0.029369274154305458, -0.003490125760436058, 0.0015214290469884872, 0.022139793261885643, 0.0012350549222901464, -0.026195289567112923, 0.023729732260107994, 0.034239571541547775, 0.0049668652936816216, -0.0078734140843153, 0.007711432408541441, 0.02126409485936165, -0.0005968638579361141, -0.0021399655379354954, -0.0012380320113152266, -0.02483952045440674, 0.029485562816262245, -0.03270531818270683, 0.0668087750673294, -0.017013665288686752, 0.028416650369763374, 0.00961539801210165, -0.050946664065122604, -0.0016746952896937728, 0.04617939889431, 0.013058492913842201, 0.007016198243945837, -0.05794306471943855, -0.01804775558412075, -0.02617950551211834, -0.019652118906378746, -0.008230267092585564, -0.015508512035012245, 0.01315420214086771, 0.015256967395544052, -0.03881116211414337, 0.06358898431062698, 0.017321238294243813, -0.008614280261099339, 0.0004693435621447861, 0.017287828028202057, -0.0031278999522328377, 0.005564011633396149, -0.036194536834955215, 0.019229650497436523, -0.007154126651585102, 0.033793751150369644, 0.053083568811416626, 0.00005507347668753937, 0.024355795234441757, 0.02236987091600895, 0.02355361543595791, -0.018338583409786224, 0.032989419996738434, 0.07727048546075821, 0.010277770459651947, 0.031678006052970886, 0.044051773846149445, -0.016078200191259384, 0.008764335885643959, 0.013074676506221294, -0.004560879897326231, -0.03737844526767731, 0.039986930787563324, 0.015137629583477974, 0.019420359283685684, 0.01239684782922268, 0.018518133088946342, -0.018514754250645638, -0.023614589124917984, 0.021132463589310646, 0.028440963476896286, -0.0025514569133520126, 0.02132023312151432, -0.05040879547595978, 0.014592085033655167, -0.03751632943749428, -0.029339216649532318, -0.010433658957481384, 0.040285855531692505, 0.010642278008162975, -0.0064111086539924145, 0.014292832463979721, -0.023211713880300522, -0.016971826553344727, -0.02038601040840149, 0.06616532802581787, 0.05006975308060646, 0.05311669781804085, -0.03689711540937424, -0.010238779708743095, 0.021332237869501114, -0.034441642463207245, -0.007689741440117359, 0.00405504647642374, -0.0007817340665496886, 0.013334956020116806, 0.07195737212896347, -0.004153648391366005, -0.019383689388632774, 0.029733367264270782, 0.036843396723270416, 0.004598834551870823, -0.02142399176955223, -0.07045084983110428, -0.04735935479402542, 0.014351320452988148, 0.0072292666882276535, -0.028122490271925926, -0.049377329647541046, -0.06564094126224518, 0.026486899703741074, 0.057164423167705536, 0.013702820986509323, -0.01257564127445221, 0.012492830865085125, 0.014837907627224922, 0.02647983841598034, -0.025715632364153862, -0.02412727288901806, -0.040397219359874725, -0.07097968459129333, -0.026896502822637558, -0.06801916658878326, 0.009797362610697746, 0.0062440610490739346, -0.02719351463019848, 0.020975330844521523, 0.01689482480287552, -0.015394649468362331, -0.02210778184235096, 0.04522962123155594, -0.01046101562678814, 0.0010396717116236687, 0.04371658340096474, -0.022811831906437874, 0.04164385423064232, 0.03271690011024475, 0.015927255153656006, 0.011117943562567234, 0.009292352944612503, 0.0742553099989891, 0.022370770573616028, -0.019550498574972153, -0.0016068046679720283, -0.02990756370127201, 0.03807595372200012, -0.01645084284245968, -0.06720977276563644, -0.03059774823486805, -0.023706572130322456, -0.006117712240666151, 0.045019373297691345, 0.041319429874420166, -0.015222330577671528, -0.012371208518743515, 0.054591935127973557, -0.012748394161462784, -0.014145885594189167, -0.06181706115603447, 0.0010133555624634027, -0.020568033680319786, -0.04578915610909462, 0.026995716616511345, 0.021482786163687706, 0.01060156337916851, -0.007586355786770582, 0.020226160064339638, 0.0006950163515284657, -0.03783486783504486, 0.03260678052902222, -0.028698597103357315, 0.021031426265835762, 0.0387745164334774, 0.06996476650238037, -0.007420059759169817, 0.06320268660783768, -0.03650364279747009, -0.03481476008892059, -0.00196359446272254, -0.010399430058896542, 0.012759561650454998, -0.005815225653350353, 0.01995140127837658, 0.020294729620218277, 0.0012235811445862055, -0.018230948597192764, 0.040051478892564774, -0.07417260110378265, 0.04804358631372452, 0.07676252722740173, 0.012889977544546127, 0.02903958596289158, -0.0016830340027809143, 0.012439815327525139, 0.03183812275528908, -0.016119422391057014, -0.022322066128253937, -0.05145510658621788, -0.06721296161413193, 0.0716920867562294, 0.0029251195956021547, -0.01757420040667057, -0.016276773065328598, 0.029961686581373215, 0.01311503816395998, 0.028236208483576775, 0.030508574098348618, -0.008035896345973015, 0.01141351368278265, 0.018175072968006134, 0.01154211163520813, 0.010320142842829227, -0.010325107723474503, 0.06267628818750381, 0.002532201586291194, 0.06471354514360428, 0.0017971647903323174, 0.007038322743028402, 0.046090591698884964, -0.006527330260723829, 0.016008060425519943, -0.016056014224886894, 0.004397995304316282, 0.035534605383872986, -0.029257070273160934, 0.03172552213072777, 0.04949169233441353, 0.009913651272654533, 0.007636945229023695, 0.008045745082199574, 0.02431006170809269, -0.010649388656020164, 0.030085980892181396, -0.030630644410848618, -0.02968722954392433, 0.005821638740599155, -0.020290685817599297, 0.015689129009842873, -0.017113003879785538, -0.05281106382608414, -0.00489381467923522, -0.03416481614112854, 0.0127458730712533, 0.008961761370301247, 0.014044476673007011, -0.027178870514035225, 0.0017002420499920845, 0.0022230008617043495, -0.040566422045230865, 0.05370454490184784, 0.010204174555838108, -0.03339670971035957, -0.007655656896531582, -0.03544002026319504, -0.015216815285384655, 0.028477782383561134, -0.008919797837734222, -0.039891015738248825, 0.028681475669145584, -0.04762565344572067, -0.041328731924295425, -0.007152338046580553, 0.0029812478460371494, 0.02329479530453682, -0.035903431475162506, -0.006866756826639175, 0.0343276783823967, 0.0012692310847342014, 0.0014773720176890492, 0.014396453276276588, -0.060201309621334076, -0.007080086041241884, -0.03220951929688454, -0.023606665432453156, 0.04133082926273346, 0.00725299259647727, 0.021832646802067757, 0.008646804839372635, -0.03455446660518646, 0.009209007024765015, -0.09685977548360825, -0.03801889717578888, -0.019984640181064606, -0.0054953028447926044, 0.012834817171096802, -0.043068088591098785, 0.02375059574842453, 0.09854525327682495, 0.024624846875667572, -0.0010483189253136516, -0.05255021154880524, -0.01654266007244587, -0.027500446885824203, -0.025969959795475006, 0.008270005695521832, 0.01917773112654686, 0.03406521677970886, 0.030074430629611015, -0.030946917831897736, 0.020651530474424362, 0.021025823429226875, 0.020963646471500397, 0.005751756951212883, 0.03800751641392708, -0.00706645380705595, -0.008658980019390583, 0.039017919450998306, 0.03008030541241169, -0.0012734249467030168, 0.020185135304927826, 0.010262771509587765, 0.03811866417527199, 0.0017331757117062807, -0.008734899573028088, -0.0025421883910894394, -0.03043796680867672, -0.004053774755448103, -0.054332803934812546, 0.028177151456475258, 0.014619060792028904, -0.0034808467607945204, -0.037430956959724426, -0.026955828070640564, 0.029402239248156548, -0.03722316399216652, -0.0023126094602048397, 0.016673387959599495, 0.008657504804432392, -0.03645646944642067, 0.017114810645580292, 0.01583324745297432, -0.03620394319295883, 0.024624768644571304, -0.047647010535001755, -0.0005496179801411927, 0.0844687968492508, 0.05384989455342293, -0.0047201793640851974, -0.0055605689994990826, -0.034436892718076706, 0.000597200938500464, -0.03053312748670578, 0.016108768060803413, -0.004074325785040855, 0.036825042217969894, 0.007001422345638275, 0.05382716655731201, 0.02701064758002758, -0.001862244913354516, -0.04748307541012764, -0.021565988659858704, -0.05207636579871178, -0.0045529515482485294, -0.022858023643493652, -0.005875945556908846, 0.015372080728411674, -0.02552250772714615, 0.05560887232422829, -0.02920893207192421, 0.0034859071020036936, 0.0028691990301012993, 0.040665529668331146, -0.0006558339227922261, -0.010825163684785366, 0.00606323080137372, -0.014026925899088383, -0.016797345131635666, -0.006401780992746353, 0.02982105314731598, 0.022536853328347206, 0.03149019181728363, 0.009835293516516685, -0.004125238861888647, 0.008846230804920197, -0.0345696359872818, -0.030346861109137535, 0.05496252328157425, 0.04321674630045891, 0.048630647361278534, -0.004138489719480276, -0.024736005812883377, 0.04495683312416077, 0.01951543614268303, 0.0295636598020792, 0.0038183482829481363, -0.002076702890917659, -0.011203371919691563, -0.05685751140117645, -0.04577893391251564, -0.02396528236567974, 0.014104512520134449, -0.04108314961194992, 0.00981383491307497, 0.04571961984038353, 0.03965124115347862, -0.03635235130786896, 0.04821183532476425, 0.0687425509095192, 0.054361987859010696, 0.002097473479807377, -0.03695306181907654, 0.021541042253375053, -0.05908874794840813, 0.0065140374936163425, 0.003716142848134041, -0.011793632060289383, 0.018577422946691513, 0.006338039413094521, 0.017813729122281075, -0.006390719208866358, -0.04952091723680496, -0.02810601331293583, 0.007266039028763771, 0.02110273577272892, -0.01754433661699295, -0.026418879628181458, 0.014396165497601032, 0.024914849549531937, -0.00443554250523448, 0.0059885592199862, -0.0007639286923222244, -0.05983520299196243, 0.00020789714471902698, 0.019276617094874382, 0.05171208828687668, -0.02792142704129219, -0.03606991842389107, -0.021847989410161972, 0.029482631012797356, 0.02378356084227562, -0.005817833822220564, 0.02818496897816658, -0.022864321246743202, 0.03626507520675659, -0.006632037926465273, 0.004749557003378868, -0.0812084823846817, 0.04246275871992111, -0.031117236241698265, 0.02323206700384617, -0.0009007186163216829, -0.011665903963148594, -0.06693656742572784, -0.014330991543829441, -0.0031828300561755896, -0.0007998143555596471, -0.0381491594016552, -0.01903454400599003, 0.022611668333411217, -0.005169108510017395, 0.02597532980144024, -0.06819179654121399, 0.03993966430425644, 0.01717739924788475, 0.018946954980492592, 0.052960388362407684, -0.010022635571658611, -0.035365991294384, 0.007017404772341251, 0.011190881952643394, -0.01929153874516487, -0.00951674859970808, -0.032119642943143845, 0.04369431734085083, 0.03883788362145424, -0.014698869548738003, 0.07060829550027847, 0.014754722826182842, -0.013790568336844444, 0.00821747537702322, -0.05610290914773941, 0.02106657810509205, 0.004387586377561092, -0.025820452719926834, -0.05248687043786049, 0.0007043422083370388, -0.00020705962378997356, 0.01646464876830578, -0.0167099479585886, 0.04221508651971817, -0.013136928901076317, -0.03168044611811638, 0.03578006476163864, 0.026034070178866386, -0.007884381338953972, -0.04405013844370842, 0.03367103636264801, -0.01128300279378891, -0.0035340185277163982, -0.031169073656201363, 0.01632428914308548, -0.013676295056939125, 0.010303971357643604, 0.013537322171032429, 0.005981738679111004, 0.007241925224661827, -0.009667825885117054, -0.04825395345687866, 0.03327867388725281, -0.034019459038972855, 0.01656823232769966, -0.0292870681732893, 0.021363627165555954, -0.02179405465722084, -0.04930660501122475, -0.03999179229140282, 0.009991372004151344, -0.03123040497303009, 0.02688766084611416, -0.026647428050637245, 0.0233627799898386, -0.027283940464258194, -0.0094841867685318, -0.03536190092563629, -0.05040735751390457, 0.03438038378953934, -0.013056890107691288, -0.001613943255506456, -0.0037532278802245855, -0.015930084511637688, -0.016155609861016273, -0.012458784505724907, 0.021898625418543816, 0.03395133465528488, -0.04376247897744179, -0.039340175688266754, 0.00047236605314537883, 0.04337913915514946, 0.06602736562490463, 0.010880749672651291, -0.012678530998528004, 0.029912859201431274, -0.014841615222394466, -0.03856084123253822, 0.03697570040822029, 0.02382933534681797, -0.020033514127135277, -0.017518216744065285, -0.019654802978038788, 0.01327588688582182, 0.030352050438523293, -0.01131274551153183, -0.031843151897192, 0.003520023776218295, -0.009138572961091995, 0.03521612659096718, -0.009846996515989304, -0.001419507316313684, 0.0016638525994494557, -0.002285013673827052, -0.0038419265765696764, 0.005993352737277746, -0.032997190952301025, 0.029451796784996986, 0.018672704696655273, -0.01524475309997797, -0.036710046231746674, -0.007640417665243149, 0.05327342078089714, 0.00069092569174245, 0.017565464600920677, -0.02793664112687111, -0.020490828901529312, 0.006330257281661034, 0.015928203240036964, -0.021721426397562027, 0.03934226185083389, -0.010675462894141674, -0.03960948809981346, -0.0013675898080691695, -0.06542292982339859, -0.0025823244359344244, 0.015703124925494194, -0.0051573594100773335, 0.032712679356336594, 0.022920358926057816, 0.0021316595375537872, -0.009832553565502167, -0.07437773048877716, -0.04542318731546402, 0.029644275084137917, 0.016211094334721565, 0.03516259416937828, -0.03919047862291336, -0.009594250470399857, 0.05430854484438896, 0.030287107452750206, -0.004855593200773001, 0.033305421471595764, 0.05968440696597099, 0.028925035148859024, 0.020224925130605698, -0.023475460708141327, -0.04828640818595886, 0.054670702666044235, -0.02230539545416832, 0.0033790215384215117, -0.01792277581989765, -0.015373394824564457, 0.04392906278371811, 0.05909140035510063, -0.0048774778842926025, -0.10535676777362823, -0.012859238311648369, -0.049377165734767914, -0.0019478617468848825, 0.02676316536962986, -0.021154368296265602, 0.03291644528508186, -0.028274254873394966, 0.02745327539741993, -0.05163739621639252, 0.04276648908853531, -0.010220813564956188, -0.03698332607746124, -0.05253658816218376, -0.025753289461135864, -0.04108278080821037, 0.022142712026834488, -0.004156897775828838, -0.02580232173204422, 0.025174321606755257, -0.08843854814767838, 0.018872952088713646, 0.009248074144124985, 0.03601393476128578, -0.005698195192962885, 0.06011756509542465, 0.0068646022118628025, -0.005363783333450556, 0.007015789858996868, 0.00348843727260828, 0.13179150223731995, 0.05610189586877823, 0.006252768915146589, -0.07688196748495102, -0.006374804303050041, 0.01609637401998043, 0.046690911054611206, -0.006686507724225521, -0.029104862362146378, -0.03598066419363022, -0.024030663073062897, 0.03658737987279892, 0.0393575057387352, 0.018495719879865646, 0.01134912483394146, 0.02769237756729126, -0.03344013914465904, 0.007990810088813305, 0.018154505640268326, -0.011388402432203293, -0.03023083694279194, 0.0007939335773698986, -0.04025162383913994, 0.020760538056492805, 0.014320430345833302, 0.00762680359184742, -0.011500030755996704, 0.0003250695299357176, -0.016529681161046028, 0.013032857328653336, -0.033682625740766525, 0.04027340188622475, 0.05048323795199394, -0.003959745168685913, -0.022024085745215416, -0.021092550829052925, 0.03717838227748871, -0.020377805456519127, 0.02665652334690094, 0.034588076174259186, -0.03849995136260986, 0.0019902235362678766, -0.004099962767213583, 0.0037822735030204058, -0.0446808747947216, -0.016245057806372643, -0.010172795504331589, 0.05408875271677971, 0.019046416506171227, -0.016310429200530052, -0.050545889884233475, 0.006329691968858242, -0.0184863843023777, -0.015639567747712135, -0.016707297414541245, 0.0012331305770203471, 0.013312931172549725, -0.056775499135255814, -0.031527888029813766, -0.03624682500958443, 0.00009402599971508607, -0.01945853978395462, 0.007692583370953798, 0.03977552428841591, -0.03497970849275589, 0.004991711117327213, -0.06154872104525566, 0.047290097922086716, 0.014247752726078033, -0.03667546808719635, 0.06149463355541229, 0.010454826056957245, -0.03671149164438248, 0.010248377919197083, -0.011802601628005505, 0.0038662264123559, 0.03884073346853256, 0.0048829615116119385, 0.017627133056521416, -0.054541442543268204, -0.05818873643875122, -0.0012965152272954583, -0.009823440574109554, -0.0071760378777980804, -0.02306351624429226, -0.008176789619028568, 0.003478645347058773, 0.037136174738407135, 0.008062186650931835, -0.0008069082978181541, 0.0318722166121006, 0.03724408894777298, 0.016979899257421494, -0.03849450871348381, -0.05702618137001991, 0.054670605808496475, 0.004571773577481508, -0.015278943814337254, -0.017914477735757828, 0.053624872118234634, 0.056297749280929565, 0.017261246219277382, 0.020304612815380096, 0.010857855901122093, -0.04198203980922699, -0.0009177640313282609, -0.01488152053207159, -0.04624580219388008, 0.018245968967676163, 0.013173935934901237, 0.008144271560013294, 0.0000657162454444915, -0.04365973174571991, -0.03151692450046539, -0.05280224233865738, -0.04127030819654465, -0.01493916753679514, 0.0008973866351880133, -0.00477561866864562, -0.024068888276815414, -0.006741035263985395, -0.01489636953920126, -0.015575254335999489, -0.0771062821149826, 0.01454358920454979, 0.03904750943183899, -0.0558803491294384, -0.0027424402069300413, 0.03878803923726082, -0.013577764853835106, 0.02663463167846203, 0.006595022976398468, 0.022715196013450623, 0.0327126644551754, -0.006700634490698576, 0.011666775681078434, -0.002892320044338703, 0.06601816415786743, 0.0003233571769669652, -0.020250478759407997, 0.03347768262028694, -0.015430055558681488, -0.037488650530576706, 0.008485408499836922, 0.017671415582299232, 0.05590596795082092, 0.03186560794711113, -0.0011522602289915085, -0.04874777793884277, 0.03230050206184387, -0.039793118834495544, -0.017581410706043243, -0.039261091500520706, -0.013852543197572231, 0.01056168507784605, 0.00980960950255394, 0.00939401239156723, 0.004018773324787617, 0.010323140770196915, 0.011851932853460312, 0.040749695152044296, -0.023783519864082336, -0.00894343201071024, 0.003147115930914879, -0.006482098251581192, -0.006897900253534317, -0.0029026763513684273, -0.018862251192331314, 0.02367640659213066, 0.04349556565284729, -0.00512961158528924, 0.05617259070277214, -0.03479786962270737, 0.04586850851774216, -0.08683867752552032, -0.05871666967868805, -0.01937900111079216, 0.03320189192891121, 0.04159579053521156, -0.032528799027204514, 0.018540609627962112, 0.03389976546168327, -0.06602855771780014, 0.010313807055354118, 0.015645869076251984, -0.05351544916629791, -0.05158250778913498, -0.016588879749178886, 0.007924270816147327, 0.02241252362728119, 0.042839206755161285, 0.006547953002154827, 0.03183166682720184, 0.027116047218441963, 0.014578635804355145, -0.021276991814374924, 0.021678339689970016, 0.037189144641160965, 0.025644415989518166, -0.0743771567940712, 0.06401225179433823, -0.023841705173254013, -0.013962725177407265, 0.028320830315351486, 0.010403917171061039, 0.0034644254483282566, 0.07163458317518234, 0.024874800816178322, 0.037889983505010605, 0.08969428390264511, 0.01913945935666561, -0.006202386692166328, -0.009930162690579891, 0.0029885435942560434, 0.0015221390640363097, 0.03476627916097641, 0.0012458533747121692, -0.002997202565893531, -0.0007606248836964369, -0.017835702747106552, -0.025029350072145462, -0.01566077396273613, -0.01823912188410759, -0.01773393154144287, 0.0076613822020590305, 0.0065155415795743465, -0.007082577329128981, -0.033202823251485825, 0.023270349949598312, -0.05844396352767944, -0.02383817359805107, 0.011088283732533455, 0.00460186367854476, -0.0423283651471138, -0.017329026013612747, -0.005673523060977459, -0.03139775991439819, 0.010483568534255028, 0.011443356052041054, -0.028359854593873024, -0.029014939442276955, -0.003584877587854862, -0.021035561338067055, -0.004187204875051975, -0.018885524943470955, 0.011538323946297169, -0.010940770618617535, 0.0069360691122710705, -0.029645409435033798, -0.00962840300053358, -0.013813375495374203, -0.07035679370164871, 0.014498207718133926, -0.11116012185811996, 0.07647823542356491, 0.051703840494155884, -0.021180100739002228, -0.04550417140126228, -0.028339248150587082, -0.045502468943595886, 0.027689184993505478, 0.03126152604818344, 0.009830770082771778, -0.01608928106725216, -0.009826328605413437, 0.05417367443442345, 0.007597846910357475, -0.0660785585641861, 0.05554758012294769, 0.011167974211275578, -0.03849786892533302, -0.0055304160341620445, 0.0030665630474686623, 0.03553485870361328, 0.011467446573078632, 0.043247289955616, -0.0010121226077899337, 0.01857585273683071, -0.015757493674755096, -0.025329573079943657, 0.04761423543095589, 0.019934670999646187, -0.023503223434090614, 0.0461060032248497, 0.03079640306532383, -0.017311474308371544, 0.023657212033867836, 0.019362248480319977, -0.03402749449014664, 0.0416596457362175, -0.003987970761954784, 0.011418284848332405, 0.02097664587199688, 0.00895691104233265, -0.009464126080274582, -0.028420602902770042, 0.03342398256063461, 0.035277724266052246, -0.021990660578012466, -0.03158831223845482, 0.03658466041088104, 0.03407499939203262, 0.06051038205623627, 0.02013721503317356, 0.0065998476929962635, 0.004552529193460941, -0.012886312790215015, 0.032481901347637177, 0.028633110225200653, 0.013181769289076328, 0.011197897605597973, 0.006529000587761402, 0.01446816697716713, -0.013493563048541546, 0.013463849201798439, -0.016529984772205353, 0.03479966148734093, 0.010141936130821705, -0.00892411358654499, 0.03608325123786926, -0.011923466809093952, 0.0326697900891304, 0.02255699597299099, 0.0034086399246007204, 0.062304917722940445, -0.01871449127793312, 0.010908186435699463, -0.030136073008179665, 0.05473443865776062, -0.03785596787929535, -0.03891855478286743, 0.033351488411426544, 0.009053118526935577, 0.015170318074524403, 0.010903331451117992, 0.00896570086479187, 0.0008475402719341218, 0.005778676364570856, -0.04974674805998802, 0.016261188313364983, 0.02027011476457119, -0.02703895792365074, -0.002560222987085581, -0.03168855980038643, -0.04602682217955589, -0.05905633419752121, 0.0171030443161726, 0.00919344648718834, 0.014150271192193031, -0.00076634855940938, -0.017797991633415222, -0.014374750666320324, 0.04941411688923836, -0.06788747012615204, -0.010735931806266308, -0.029640810564160347, 0.027243072167038918, 0.013069945387542248, -0.005312186200171709 ]
<p>I recently learned about Fisher's method to combine p-values. This is based on the fact that p-value under the null follows a uniform distribution, and that $$-2\sum_{i=1}^n{\log X_i} \sim \chi^2(2n), \text{ given } X \sim \text{Unif}(0,1)$$ which I think is genius. But my question is why going this convoluted way? and why not (what is wrong with) just using mean of p-values and use central limit theorem? or median? I am trying to understand the genius of RA Fisher behind this grand scheme.</p>
73,750
[ -0.024559641256928444, -0.0260921623557806, 0.0039570992812514305, -0.03589123487472534, 0.011271287687122822, 0.006395512726157904, 0.02262815833091736, -0.019157884642481804, -0.005939668510109186, -0.05327267572283745, 0.03363581374287605, 0.014168255031108856, 0.029199501499533653, -0.0005639786249957979, 0.06802581250667572, 0.012428813613951206, -0.004137788899242878, 0.03484317660331726, -0.006296934559941292, 0.006122445221990347, 0.02372671104967594, 0.04492101073265076, 0.01676846295595169, -0.025090564042329788, -0.027554931119084358, 0.039870817214250565, 0.005403290502727032, -0.04240315780043602, -0.018037157133221626, 0.08651790767908096, -0.035969801247119904, -0.00005472994962474331, 0.03946053981781006, 0.03356505557894707, 0.003576083341613412, -0.010430878959596157, -0.024176867678761482, -0.008859663270413876, 0.009365425445139408, 0.03002670221030712, -0.03421803191304207, -0.004792371764779091, -0.007984156720340252, -0.0026527391746640205, 0.014671647921204567, 0.029189981520175934, -0.011417917907238007, -0.05361129343509674, -0.002059227554127574, -0.040333110839128494, 0.04836614429950714, 0.027921153232455254, 0.023185256868600845, 0.011455077677965164, -0.014290540479123592, 0.0013517451006919146, 0.028963603079319, 0.05069529637694359, -0.014235422015190125, -0.06456425786018372, 0.0220229122787714, 0.0010602761758491397, 0.015847597271203995, -0.017742851749062538, -0.012809041887521744, -0.007256569806486368, 0.003808600129559636, 0.009511047042906284, 0.043825436383485794, -0.02665761113166809, 0.017076045274734497, 0.021217498928308487, 0.0498255118727684, 0.024727310985326767, 0.006666747387498617, -0.017811328172683716, 0.01110370084643364, -0.018761424347758293, 0.02531767264008522, -0.0072722057811915874, 0.0026133174542337656, 0.000336112774675712, 0.052547432482242584, 0.06751114130020142, -0.010257215239107609, 0.01968168281018734, 0.055448293685913086, -0.025370895862579346, 0.00574062205851078, 0.02228645049035549, 0.0014705973444506526, -0.02135627344250679, 0.05070650950074196, -0.018287496641278267, -0.03158625587821007, 0.07228078693151474, -0.008902270346879959, 0.05846166983246803, 0.011088063940405846, -0.004763064440339804, -0.02017025277018547, -0.03534173220396042, 0.023611396551132202, 0.05121241509914398, -0.031205764040350914, -0.012262072414159775, -0.002908253576606512, 0.015267335809767246, 0.011149793863296509, -0.028540588915348053, -0.02749175764620304, 0.016763050109148026, 0.010220179334282875, -0.003876687726005912, 0.0010617886437103152, 0.010129056870937347, -0.0010270933853462338, -0.0037914200220257044, 0.04679938778281212, 0.04651341587305069, 0.028822161257267, -0.005391619633883238, 0.020807011052966118, -0.03371293097734451, -0.027247315272688866, 0.029044006019830704, 0.0052717383950948715, 0.013871344737708569, -0.04554468393325806, 0.046165719628334045, 0.007826312445104122, -0.0022263135761022568, 0.04688079655170441, 0.05659622326493263, 0.027616702020168304, -0.011349532753229141, -0.0959525853395462, -0.042468588799238205, 0.038620758801698685, -0.05007028952240944, 0.023259324952960014, -0.07605345547199249, -0.0008176021510735154, 0.06401117146015167, 0.0336654894053936, 0.0021264830138534307, 0.027129361405968666, -0.005132577382028103, 0.02463683672249317, 0.03134452551603317, -0.023578884080052376, -0.06755970418453217, -0.020457051694393158, -0.010668606497347355, 0.01486190315335989, -0.10229379683732986, 0.020858576521277428, 0.00885849166661501, -0.01400027610361576, -0.025693967938423157, 0.05233396589756012, -0.010471004992723465, 0.006116829812526703, -0.040295593440532684, 0.004750346764922142, -0.007148049771785736, 0.08765827119350433, 0.012646137736737728, 0.01955398917198181, 0.03320362791419029, -0.019890815019607544, 0.012572326697409153, 0.017521793022751808, 0.05288252606987953, -0.0006304493872448802, -0.030013876035809517, 0.0042800018563866615, -0.062418900430202484, 0.03138033300638199, -0.0025203339755535126, -0.030153265222907066, -0.016577651724219322, -0.015532184392213821, 0.004166692029684782, 0.018507950007915497, 0.04730704799294472, -0.008414161391556263, -0.004905810113996267, 0.02403603494167328, -0.03731023520231247, -0.00801528338342905, -0.035783931612968445, -0.04515153914690018, 0.014109868556261063, -0.023439817130565643, 0.055975981056690216, 0.02634969912469387, 0.010048763826489449, 0.020837606862187386, -0.0110859340056777, -0.042666852474212646, -0.006807186175137758, 0.03479016572237015, -0.046301547437906265, 0.021068857982754707, 0.06379356235265732, 0.021474260836839676, 0.00779874250292778, 0.0460687018930912, -0.057776935398578644, -0.04536089673638344, 0.045316748321056366, -0.005702296271920204, -0.005942250601947308, 0.03476308658719063, -0.02457844465970993, 0.014375871047377586, -0.033618293702602386, -0.030194047838449478, 0.02973335050046444, -0.06564215570688248, 0.06690508127212524, 0.04591638967394829, 0.029440581798553467, -0.007013145834207535, 0.03083040378987789, 0.01621037907898426, 0.0023618757259100676, -0.029739053919911385, -0.013823339715600014, -0.03642537444829941, 0.01096551213413477, 0.049849629402160645, 0.05384443700313568, -0.028376752510666847, 0.027696624398231506, 0.01110176369547844, 0.04428323358297348, 0.023084472864866257, 0.05120272934436798, 0.005618277471512556, -0.010710570029914379, 0.02147243358194828, 0.03580576926469803, -0.0228415597230196, -0.012607426382601261, 0.00872871745377779, -0.015106028877198696, 0.03402169421315193, 0.0074388026259839535, -0.037592563778162, 0.0005611492088064551, 0.007971260696649551, 0.02310911752283573, -0.01744946278631687, 0.046246401965618134, 0.011472177691757679, -0.0076667857356369495, 0.014855421148240566, 0.030090129002928734, 0.015312319621443748, -0.0032615051604807377, -0.03222929686307907, -0.029780883342027664, 0.030754631385207176, 0.04324134811758995, -0.06368286162614822, -0.01168234832584858, 0.011197151616215706, -0.05384679511189461, 0.006291469093412161, -0.024319639429450035, -0.033828720450401306, -0.05225309729576111, 0.02693648636341095, -0.0017553420038893819, -0.01959703490138054, 0.0032277293503284454, -0.021915500983595848, -0.04223131388425827, -0.03841149061918259, 0.005116669461131096, -0.006348873488605022, -0.011036824434995651, -0.04376691207289696, -0.02462443709373474, 0.006276944186538458, 0.0017433265456929803, 0.0035605295561254025, -0.023629581555724144, -0.0012599308975040913, -0.02980278991162777, -0.011179552413523197, -0.05585399270057678, -0.06501112878322601, -0.004123495891690254, 0.0032881631050258875, 0.0006805844022892416, -0.050584133714437485, 0.04862236976623535, -0.000516978616360575, -0.04508313164114952, 0.06919849663972855, -0.03976159542798996, -0.052396006882190704, -0.013998926617205143, -0.031645387411117554, 0.013526391237974167, -0.006821227725595236, 0.03162765875458717, 0.0018281781813129783, -0.03649318963289261, -0.004652556963264942, -0.05990889295935631, -0.02893810346722603, 0.024929100647568703, -0.019393526017665863, 0.05528020113706589, 0.020380567759275436, -0.03354913741350174, 0.0818258672952652, 0.012453106231987476, -0.02949398197233677, -0.027747930958867073, 0.06339219212532043, -0.06578824669122696, -0.010401420295238495, 0.03773701563477516, 0.026716027408838272, -0.014035945758223534, 0.06538289785385132, -0.007882985286414623, 0.03696184605360031, 0.06612595915794373, 0.025615384802222252, 0.0002642384497448802, 0.007545420899987221, -0.014060300774872303, 0.006452933885157108, -0.0040341997519135475, 0.01063613686710596, -0.02930082194507122, 0.0109987398609519, 0.011845326982438564, 0.029337288811802864, 0.021893057972192764, -0.01942267082631588, 0.0048013911582529545, -0.02743447758257389, 0.021375861018896103, -0.03559813275933266, 0.03923395648598671, 0.01832442544400692, 0.0005649913800880313, -0.0205836184322834, 0.02226163260638714, 0.020641570910811424, -0.07308216392993927, 0.003091641003265977, 0.03710602968931198, 0.05397132411599159, -0.03148089721798897, -0.0012824517907574773, 0.027882328256964684, 0.013215810991823673, 0.030446363613009453, 0.005541434045881033, -0.008053988218307495, 0.057384125888347626, 0.0667026937007904, 0.007831658236682415, 0.0034061544574797153, -0.004784426186233759, 0.012922842986881733, -0.044933173805475235, 0.022268187254667282, -0.04011149704456329, 0.05929461866617203, -0.004563983529806137, 0.043495163321495056, 0.029840704053640366, -0.039060529321432114, -0.009213138371706009, -0.0038522982504218817, -0.034444522112607956, -0.00470334617421031, 0.01881021447479725, -0.007330110762268305, -0.01977408304810524, -0.04236187785863876, 0.011289829388260841, 0.007018303498625755, 0.035334765911102295, -0.02524738572537899, 0.004692955408245325, -0.026633797213435173, -0.014540783129632473, 0.013709445483982563, 0.011208685114979744, -0.008994548581540585, 0.028962381184101105, 0.01954391784965992, -0.018051644787192345, 0.015411498956382275, 0.03691546618938446, 0.0052422997541725636, -0.013426266610622406, -0.023206181824207306, 0.012519977055490017, -0.003750217380002141, 0.042511824518442154, -0.013452193699777126, 0.037116143852472305, -0.014787554740905762, 0.02254948951303959, -0.006428237073123455, 0.07518446445465088, 0.049034591764211655, -0.01980946771800518, 0.007381117902696133, -0.018991608172655106, -0.019512999802827835, -0.0020225115586072206, 0.028240976855158806, 0.023366788402199745, 0.004815085791051388, 0.046775687485933304, 0.034020185470581055, -0.03787269815802574, -0.0032018995843827724, 0.06944505125284195, -0.03605176508426666, -0.00007772220124024898, -0.03727107122540474, -0.036543749272823334, -0.028711332008242607, -0.019686270505189896, 0.025925619527697563, 0.010155095718801022, -0.023269047960639, -0.013686394318938255, 0.05607431009411812, -0.01159717608243227, -0.013018603436648846, -0.043234001845121384, 0.037430159747600555, 0.023008044809103012, -0.014061173424124718, -0.0491638146340847, 0.004854932427406311, 0.06076192855834961, 0.04019174724817276, 0.03307826444506645, 0.009673184715211391, -0.04805772751569748, 0.022693727165460587, 0.04118122160434723, 0.025428777560591698, -0.030799338594079018, 0.02013169787824154, -0.07198666036128998, -0.01385132223367691, -0.008029191754758358, -0.033356569707393646, -0.00008205399353755638, -0.03694666549563408, 0.008254694752395153, 0.02039291337132454, -0.02306915819644928, -0.04459376260638237, 0.012850342318415642, 0.005444973241537809, 0.06192456930875778, -0.048824243247509, -0.03148561716079712, -0.05985116586089134, 0.0276112612336874, 0.0010028067044913769, 0.02455100603401661, -0.01163774449378252, 0.005782212130725384, 0.02833854779601097, 0.05306278541684151, -0.003376340726390481, -0.03789451718330383, -0.009302886202931404, -0.017666351050138474, 0.021135995164513588, 0.04516351595520973, 0.0033439979888498783, -0.034381650388240814, 0.010600653477013111, 0.011883743107318878, -0.018075039610266685, 0.02074333094060421, -0.015190145932137966, 0.05163959786295891, 0.03955036401748657, -0.00604311004281044, 0.09504036605358124, 0.007893606089055538, -0.04404563084244728, -0.017909007146954536, -0.03806047886610031, 0.02621774561703205, -0.009356953203678131, 0.019891835749149323, -0.05307435244321823, -0.0010400707833468914, -0.007624573539942503, 0.010187316685914993, 0.010429724119603634, 0.037948936223983765, 0.0033865205477923155, 0.00933967437595129, 0.009756483137607574, 0.014594217762351036, 0.02400301955640316, 0.03589639067649841, -0.003973567392677069, 0.023118428885936737, 0.06109626218676567, -0.025043826550245285, 0.04741011932492256, -0.008207659237086773, 0.0007193868514150381, -0.006133182439953089, -0.016203364357352257, 0.017969070002436638, -0.025954658165574074, -0.031660377979278564, 0.001544391387142241, -0.007657063193619251, 0.012420620769262314, -0.02171109989285469, 0.046898290514945984, 0.02700367569923401, -0.06200721114873886, -0.011844513937830925, -0.0166834257543087, 0.00480774138122797, 0.04613777622580528, -0.07813573628664017, 0.041133277118206024, -0.020920947194099426, -0.028561608865857124, -0.06747404485940933, -0.002288652118295431, 0.029866348952054977, -0.026275739073753357, -0.023069102317094803, -0.03044886700809002, -0.01565779186785221, 0.018983954563736916, -0.00024203369684983045, -0.014440884813666344, 0.04779301956295967, 0.001890563522465527, -0.03186479210853577, -0.038561347872018814, 0.043368011713027954, 0.0655142143368721, 0.009494347497820854, -0.009388674050569534, 0.047647517174482346, -0.036136504262685776, -0.030499080196022987, 0.017055977135896683, 0.002613258082419634, -0.030684705823659897, -0.02845858410000801, -0.013272659853100777, -0.0122489333152771, 0.010570409707725048, -0.025017844513058662, -0.012530787847936153, 0.017777523025870323, -0.015788782387971878, 0.015764551237225533, -0.00774809904396534, -0.01917255111038685, -0.024216046556830406, -0.004486661870032549, -0.011530435644090176, 0.014132015407085419, -0.028440294787287712, -0.01508801057934761, 0.047932934015989304, 0.010089118033647537, -0.0065427981317043304, 0.028145376592874527, 0.04386771842837334, -0.007190427277237177, -0.011029339395463467, -0.029610082507133484, 0.0124339759349823, 0.013984509743750095, 0.043038636445999146, -0.021059099584817886, 0.03259763494133949, 0.040729109197854996, -0.022115187719464302, 0.023452330380678177, -0.032335732132196426, -0.00613368907943368, 0.05191781371831894, -0.04428815841674805, 0.057198137044906616, 0.011891930364072323, 0.003907490987330675, -0.04113796353340149, -0.0005681838956661522, 0.0003962573828175664, 0.002384498016908765, -0.006021338980644941, 0.0502217561006546, -0.020232029259204865, 0.0008177144336514175, 0.0173316802829504, 0.018204089254140854, 0.03992072492837906, 0.011903285048902035, 0.035785168409347534, 0.03170068934559822, 0.014272510074079037, -0.03400653228163719, -0.02649998664855957, 0.056616246700286865, -0.012585661374032497, 0.012625479139387608, -0.03481999784708023, -0.014976054430007935, 0.014594711363315582, -0.015724333003163338, -0.02677825093269348, -0.07368730753660202, -0.04845988750457764, -0.012164059095084667, 0.044933516532182693, 0.016290798783302307, -0.02484900690615177, 0.04882624000310898, -0.003670442383736372, 0.043988727033138275, -0.0002685182262212038, 0.002153076697140932, -0.01749943010509014, -0.07860284298658371, -0.04939427971839905, -0.00593023793771863, -0.04233085736632347, -0.006356526166200638, 0.010839235968887806, -0.01910417340695858, 0.018410757184028625, 0.005077503155916929, 0.01620352640748024, -0.016680140048265457, -0.00027485861210152507, -0.044231198728084564, 0.06453339755535126, 0.03388183191418648, 0.044174421578645706, -0.01838734745979309, -0.05094702169299126, 0.11855287849903107, 0.015203552320599556, 0.04097989574074745, -0.0641852617263794, 0.00775533402338624, -0.019690459594130516, 0.040987882763147354, -0.03336157649755478, 0.007103736978024244, 0.0213248822838068, 0.021978460252285004, 0.07802598178386688, 0.05971808731555939, 0.02626260556280613, -0.041223011910915375, 0.017216011881828308, -0.03547314181923866, -0.019255179911851883, -0.02141653001308441, 0.02072650007903576, 0.0041124774143099785, -0.04152461886405945, -0.03879908099770546, -0.002211225451901555, 0.009754174388945103, 0.01455164048820734, -0.04277241230010986, -0.01737605221569538, 0.015982722863554955, -0.02830231934785843, -0.023922035470604897, 0.004503965377807617, 0.02139614336192608, -0.012403921224176884, 0.005953701213002205, -0.047568149864673615, -0.0193313155323267, -0.05310916528105736, 0.0014088531024754047, 0.010957769118249416, 0.005703718867152929, -0.002386856824159622, -0.0035053929314017296, -0.0051439981907606125, -0.022831188514828682, -0.030586296692490578, -0.011597467586398125, 0.05370113253593445, -0.0416804738342762, -0.024659397080540657, -0.00912086945027113, 0.020258354023098946, -0.018696075305342674, 0.005651408806443214, -0.012164008803665638, 0.030159955844283104, 0.032072294503450394, -0.038915593177080154, -0.01386514212936163, -0.04191885516047478, 0.04047190025448799, 0.015012893825769424, 0.06065922975540161, 0.04542645439505577, -0.02326047420501709, -0.04113294184207916, -0.03820667788386345, 0.04866114631295204, 0.0048481374979019165, 0.00040870156954042614, -0.046520598232746124, -0.01158963330090046, -0.0357297882437706, -0.013699770905077457, -0.013032831251621246, -0.030206764116883278, 0.014988773502409458, -0.02858295477926731, -0.017246216535568237, -0.01838752254843712, -0.01715066470205784, 0.03243643790483475, -0.04638855531811714, -0.0020848377607762814, -0.04545654356479645, -0.03382385894656181, 0.02506108395755291, 0.03087032586336136, -0.010991143994033337, 0.01805628463625908, -0.016879303380846977, 0.06566699594259262, 0.022068215534090996, -0.052356161177158356, -0.017572728917002678, -0.01965141110122204, -0.04740314930677414, 0.0038449661806225777, -0.009590360336005688, -0.012916870415210724, 0.015604032203555107, 0.01380942203104496, -0.0034142627846449614, 0.017510592937469482, -0.013286222703754902, -0.014648671261966228, 0.002868212992325425, -0.07020242512226105, 0.006111603230237961, -0.00046857897541485727, 0.007583585102111101, 0.010114037431776524, -0.013069551438093185, 0.003950973507016897, -0.05805650353431702, 0.02225860208272934, -0.003022788092494011, -0.01654290221631527, 0.00016166338173206896, -0.009960927069187164, 0.034398213028907776, -0.02145039476454258, 0.016461869701743126, -0.039130277931690216, 0.009109582751989365, -0.02094552479684353, -0.0263212863355875, -0.025431783869862556, 0.008884649723768234, -0.0023076089564710855, -0.002868531970307231, 0.07732389122247696, 0.008389842696487904, -0.032078150659799576, 0.015756040811538696, 0.004050265531986952, 0.010417679324746132, 0.03482641279697418, 0.0077660600654780865, -0.022031402215361595, 0.06752943247556686, -0.06147712096571922, -0.0621194988489151, 0.01194341853260994, 0.008808615617454052, 0.0008225563797168434, 0.010434078052639961, -0.007963933981955051, -0.06342368572950363, 0.0069287437945604324, -0.061142776161432266, -0.0382586270570755, 0.0021308958530426025, 0.013458166271448135, 0.023704268038272858, -0.0017697951989248395, 0.005317648872733116, -0.026058154180645943, -0.005505535751581192, 0.017515383660793304, 0.05449012666940689, -0.023565247654914856, -0.006308165844529867, 0.013918058946728706, -0.010821097530424595, 0.04610985517501831, 0.0028399804141372442, -0.022754915058612823, 0.012879198417067528, 0.053555287420749664, -0.005325953476130962, 0.01956808567047119, -0.016807781532406807, 0.0011297828750684857, -0.07870341092348099, -0.004455238580703735, 0.0481867641210556, -0.01425016950815916, 0.046444594860076904, -0.05483914166688919, -0.0304532703012228, -0.010212489403784275, -0.035180628299713135, 0.010006049647927284, -0.0396617166697979, -0.06728796660900116, -0.05436240881681442, -0.00266083562746644, -0.037016723304986954, 0.022203119471669197, 0.024881646037101746, 0.004435218870639801, 0.01650047115981579, -0.01275704987347126, 0.022522319108247757, 0.011804602108895779, -0.01184847205877304, 0.016188448294997215, 0.015875505283474922, -0.024469144642353058, 0.05827616527676582, -0.01989489234983921, -0.02162850834429264, 0.01051904633641243, -0.007583810016512871, 0.02821939066052437, -0.0005162102752365172, 0.03802608326077461, -0.007076717913150787, 0.03048834204673767, 0.02322603017091751, 0.00889353547245264, -0.02036491595208645, 0.050733886659145355, 0.06775296479463577, 0.00634791050106287, -0.030557043850421906, -0.009752163663506508, 0.012396878562867641, -0.025545867159962654, -0.04536920785903931, 0.03574088588356972, 0.007567495573312044, 0.001352590275928378, 0.01499930303543806, 0.024464430287480354, 0.016775336116552353, -0.015776462852954865, 0.03274068981409073, -0.018125170841813087, 0.011069098487496376, 0.025739602744579315, 0.05537865310907364, -0.011724627576768398, 0.04491675645112991, 0.0046525984071195126, -0.045384958386421204, 0.03230099380016327, 0.014109929092228413, -0.009253191761672497, -0.049197006970644, -0.02864360623061657, 0.025262905284762383, 0.0035344650968909264, -0.015387244522571564, -0.024442216381430626, -0.04640894755721092, 0.007254422642290592, -0.01733582280576229, 0.03585098683834076, 0.006954010110348463, 0.007451699580997229, 0.01948058418929577, -0.06649255007505417, 0.07672450691461563, -0.01869843527674675, 0.03626153990626335, -0.023153891786932945, -0.020663339644670486, -0.031255703419446945, -0.008209776133298874, 0.07519690692424774, 0.01832817681133747, 0.007606956642121077, -0.020467620342969894, 0.029406223446130753, 0.028044067323207855, -0.031914807856082916, 0.018983889371156693, -0.03229003772139549, -0.01372689288109541, -0.049035992473363876, -0.005941952113062143, 0.04416368901729584, 0.011043153703212738, 0.0017545935697853565, -0.031445711851119995, 0.002421942073851824, -0.01525740697979927, -0.01930626481771469, 0.04318786412477493, -0.027089525014162064, -0.005054287612438202, 0.026161715388298035, -0.01607893593609333, 0.007877852767705917, 0.025995725765824318, 0.000986843486316502, -0.0667804405093193, 0.06813430041074753, -0.0006064982153475285, -0.05173826590180397, 0.007942134514451027, 0.040273021906614304, -0.02991333045065403, -0.028621269389986992, -0.009737693704664707, 0.004456877242773771, -0.05964678153395653, -0.004280737601220608, 0.030507134273648262, -0.010379625484347343, 0.051922306418418884, 0.010630969889461994, 0.015032905153930187, -0.0027699735946953297, 0.003814126830548048, 0.003304061945527792, 0.019538138061761856, 0.010852023027837276, 0.0005580412689596415, -0.006213821470737457, -0.0005023188423365355, -0.010263417847454548, 0.028521772474050522, -0.01488546933978796, 0.0832475796341896, -0.04227098822593689, -0.016791384667158127, 0.01518472284078598, -0.029945213347673416, 0.02544025145471096, -0.0019454166758805513, -0.03418431431055069, 0.08511615544557571, -0.020904898643493652, 0.0011958363465964794, -0.017404714599251747, -0.0641007125377655, -0.025192193686962128, -0.0017677968135103583, -0.007119731977581978, 0.025898998603224754, -0.009143133647739887, 0.00858193077147007, 0.0003879264695569873, 0.022232547402381897, 0.0413750484585762, -0.013985118828713894, 0.03277049958705902, -0.026165923103690147, -0.019268004223704338, 0.004882264416664839, -0.03732077777385712, -0.007398922927677631, -0.04035498574376106, -0.007176478859037161, 0.0306902676820755, 0.019800277426838875, -0.00027375202625989914, -0.013021042570471764, 0.014713604003190994, 0.03733255714178085, -0.04175223782658577, -0.013911515474319458, -0.04454547539353371, 0.028332993388175964, 0.007536250166594982, -0.0156344436109066 ]
<p>What is the best method to determine the minimum number of training samples required for a classifier?</p> <p>I am only comparing one classifier (four class problem), discriminant function analysis (DFA) with different training sample sizes from different data sets. However, I could be considered to be comparing more than one classifier as I am also comparing DFA using the within matrix and separate matrix methods. The data is accelerometer data used to classify animal behaviours. The different data sets are all from the same original data but have had treatments applied, eg smoothed, outlier removed. </p> <p>I have run 100 interations of randomly selected increasing subsample sizes (10 - 2550) from each data set through each classifier. Averaging the classification accuracy or error rate for each subsample size separately for each data set gives me a learning curve for the classifier on each of the four classes.</p> <p>Using the area at which the learning curve levels out, I would like to suggest a possible minimum training sample size for each class required for a future study. Rather than visually looking at the learning curve and making a recommendation, is there an appropriate statistical test. Am I talking about data-driven feature selection? I dont need to extrapolate as it looks like I have enough training samples. I dont think ROC curves are applicable as I only have the classification rates from each run of each sub sample sizes rather than predicted membership probabilities which is what I think i need for ROC curves. </p> <p>I have looked over several posts here which have been useful in advancing my thinking. This post (<a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/51490/how-large-a-training-set-is-needed">How large a training set is needed?</a>) relates to my requirement but I dont see it suggesting an appropriate test.</p> <p>This paper (<a href="http://jmlr.org/papers/volume7/demsar06a/demsar06a.pdf" rel="nofollow">http://jmlr.org/papers/volume7/demsar06a/demsar06a.pdf</a>) suggests the Friedman test with the corresponding post-hoc tests for comparison of more classifiers over multiple data sets. However, it doesn't appear to take into account the increasing sub sample size from the same training data set, rather it uses completely independent data sets.</p>
73,751
[ -0.02723449096083641, -0.0134759321808815, 0.007935396395623684, -0.0015757071087136865, 0.0571114644408226, 0.02000836655497551, -0.03125249594449997, -0.05768120288848877, 0.0113250482827425, -0.014626710675656796, 0.042711999267339706, 0.019210275262594223, 0.03835836797952652, 0.03011918254196644, -0.005575948860496283, -0.0007192232878878713, -0.020381303504109383, -0.008529998362064362, 0.012774157337844372, -0.035213883966207504, -0.025546763092279434, -0.007502390071749687, 0.051882073283195496, -0.01337633840739727, -0.04206034168601036, 0.05524458736181259, 0.023312779143452644, -0.01958439312875271, 0.0030219636391848326, 0.060944147408008575, -0.03974252566695213, -0.01032580342143774, 0.014608711935579777, 0.055221281945705414, 0.02494068816304207, 0.014009928330779076, -0.02576853334903717, -0.02765749767422676, -0.006421440280973911, 0.053012050688266754, -0.013251629658043385, 0.027767829596996307, 0.03243272379040718, 0.032139312475919724, 0.005427422001957893, 0.013431827537715435, 0.013309762813150883, -0.024631906300783157, 0.047235481441020966, -0.04841706529259682, 0.08333349227905273, -0.01730567030608654, 0.01685236394405365, 0.027145640924572945, 0.017098288983106613, -0.04064132273197174, 0.04070185497403145, 0.06658533960580826, -0.016739632934331894, -0.03773709759116173, -0.015687376260757446, -0.04325328394770622, 0.0001631829800317064, -0.00639851950109005, -0.0010412984993308783, 0.030047159641981125, -0.005315039772540331, -0.002867849776521325, 0.015658792108297348, -0.009840281680226326, 0.036215562373399734, -0.03477293252944946, 0.030379055067896843, -0.009736932814121246, 0.015869412571191788, 0.009838893078267574, -0.01742166467010975, 0.07128060609102249, 0.04560549184679985, 0.04309189319610596, -0.001412799465470016, 0.025085777044296265, 0.032448720186948776, -0.0015849167248234153, 0.060523588210344315, -0.016828637570142746, 0.06075213477015495, -0.001809002598747611, -0.0033553254324942827, 0.010382788255810738, -0.0020521171391010284, 0.009642389602959156, 0.0690939724445343, -0.017076240852475166, -0.025137003511190414, 0.017375489696860313, 0.0019320766441524029, 0.025939421728253365, -0.02264202944934368, 0.003774103010073304, -0.03652184456586838, -0.05927786976099014, 0.011372234672307968, 0.054940201342105865, -0.023794321343302727, 0.02243223413825035, -0.03873151168227196, -0.0055466932244598866, -0.019608989357948303, 0.0013811300741508603, -0.021080905571579933, 0.0403258316218853, 0.01158821489661932, 0.014702911488711834, -0.030117876827716827, 0.018025187775492668, -0.012249194085597992, -0.004415145143866539, 0.028311870992183685, 0.05696796253323555, 0.032369501888751984, -0.05069534853100777, -0.009438328444957733, -0.05442074313759804, -0.04964625462889671, 0.01638520136475563, 0.005446568597108126, 0.03359263762831688, -0.014417635276913643, 0.03637133911252022, -0.02013174630701542, -0.020615046843886375, 0.029461046680808067, -0.027163591235876083, 0.0006610865239053965, 0.023125864565372467, -0.06149924919009209, -0.02961130440235138, 0.04251525551080704, -0.028418898582458496, 0.016212189570069313, -0.05260288715362549, -0.02550066076219082, 0.02815190888941288, 0.02665049023926258, 0.016263963654637337, 0.044475115835666656, 0.002544692950323224, 0.022720783948898315, 0.003824484534561634, -0.009088464081287384, 0.03506538271903992, -0.06285583972930908, 0.02029283717274666, -0.05058813467621803, -0.0697464719414711, 0.03647042438387871, -0.009357665665447712, -0.023376518860459328, -0.00037512186099775136, 0.007339504547417164, -0.008518313057720661, -0.001467025838792324, -0.057454828172922134, 0.021022725850343704, -0.0016865202924236655, 0.048600923269987106, 0.0007330075022764504, 0.03235754743218422, 0.002186322584748268, -0.006907670293003321, -0.00828535296022892, 0.015285961329936981, 0.033488549292087555, 0.05476077273488045, -0.017373356968164444, -0.02102549746632576, -0.024726657196879387, 0.007677979301661253, 0.011787361465394497, -0.0201211329549551, -0.061790186911821365, -0.004517445806413889, -0.0070831673219799995, 0.005343527998775244, 0.005682623945176601, 0.02307930402457714, -0.02100832387804985, 0.03281540423631668, -0.04006943851709366, -0.048140525817871094, -0.060877926647663116, 0.014996860176324844, -0.024590931832790375, -0.025190969929099083, 0.023173252120614052, 0.017073391005396843, -0.00010701403516577557, -0.004355844110250473, -0.043109070509672165, -0.044644229114055634, -0.00474586384370923, 0.03238671272993088, -0.03977787494659424, -0.009079355746507645, 0.03459924831986427, 0.005490677896887064, -0.03843670338392258, 0.03339317813515663, -0.03500445559620857, -0.06833747774362564, 0.013819107785820961, -0.02735797129571438, -0.0008873306796886027, -0.03796837851405144, -0.006415703799575567, 0.04490574821829796, 0.020306473597884178, -0.05845208093523979, 0.040546778589487076, -0.03628918528556824, 0.10453371703624725, 0.04431569203734398, 0.004882911220192909, -0.007727961987257004, 0.008487311191856861, -0.00043768505565822124, 0.012291456572711468, -0.06596192717552185, -0.001598961534909904, -0.06883686780929565, -0.013929937966167927, 0.03752719983458519, -0.006079890299588442, -0.013696716167032719, 0.021178925409913063, 0.06468737125396729, 0.0023219012655317783, -0.007612828630954027, 0.024576442316174507, 0.0018998136511072516, -0.04165113344788551, 0.019141636788845062, 0.022167693823575974, -0.0035073033068329096, -0.020233910530805588, -0.004954963456839323, 0.004449188243597746, 0.028962651267647743, 0.005398100707679987, -0.0016253310022875667, 0.03561922907829285, -0.029099062085151672, 0.0055846101604402065, -0.018825028091669083, -0.016404978930950165, 0.03794363886117935, -0.014563685283064842, 0.029634909704327583, 0.05831088125705719, 0.00283228000625968, 0.02594790793955326, 0.0045031714253127575, -0.018092064186930656, 0.029908984899520874, 0.024317331612110138, -0.01916344277560711, -0.03215177729725838, 0.03145994991064072, -0.08102603256702423, 0.0022841808386147022, -0.003893505549058318, -0.05734304338693619, -0.030396929010748863, 0.022803382948040962, 0.028196781873703003, 0.014824938960373402, 0.038608647882938385, -0.013937141746282578, 0.021335575729608536, 0.022553151473402977, 0.013256439007818699, 0.060541801154613495, -0.007810142356902361, -0.04509490728378296, -0.015551685355603695, -0.014894165098667145, -0.04568243771791458, 0.026951313018798828, -0.010168513283133507, -0.05430068075656891, -0.008976472541689873, 0.01743117906153202, -0.07111576944589615, -0.03608997166156769, -0.00015574006829410791, 0.005786897148936987, -0.018287373706698418, -0.022347774356603622, 0.05408823862671852, 0.010403155349195004, -0.039362672716379166, 0.005957641173154116, -0.006640089675784111, -0.0175322238355875, -0.015362805686891079, 0.003968785051256418, 0.010214361362159252, 0.012075393460690975, -0.03513574227690697, 0.031252406537532806, 0.005435246042907238, -0.024769598618149757, -0.04964909702539444, -0.0780106633901596, 0.02180774137377739, 0.0007922850782051682, 0.06129928305745125, 0.0023140322882682085, 0.00376985059119761, 0.055148765444755554, 0.054159004241228104, -0.022748256102204323, -0.01936795748770237, 0.0003462193417362869, -0.03075932338833809, -0.007032092660665512, 0.03395579382777214, 0.019803445786237717, 0.008137905970215797, -0.02038239687681198, -0.019093284383416176, 0.0015092759858816862, 0.043207038193941116, -0.019999396055936813, 0.01572415977716446, 0.01590792089700699, -0.002499830676242709, -0.021072424948215485, 0.015332691371440887, 0.019323552027344704, -0.03370435908436775, 0.0016085575334727764, -0.0025517551694065332, 0.011200429871678352, 0.008405512198805809, -0.055522892624139786, 0.02498629316687584, 0.003910905681550503, 0.01832876354455948, -0.018845031037926674, -0.025162942707538605, 0.0201150830835104, -0.05567493289709091, -0.004281084053218365, 0.01972026936709881, 0.04435860365629196, 0.0020532773341983557, -0.0032589747570455074, 0.0504588820040226, 0.021013125777244568, 0.019975552335381508, 0.038968171924352646, -0.03590049222111702, -0.02892819419503212, 0.009282449260354042, -0.047733355313539505, -0.004574172664433718, 0.025327719748020172, 0.05153932049870491, 0.04665125906467438, 0.011669676750898361, -0.042695675045251846, 0.0183679461479187, -0.03895408287644386, -0.003812091890722513, -0.06265511363744736, 0.08347135037183762, 0.023252904415130615, 0.0015227163676172495, 0.01062678825110197, -0.040698032826185226, 0.008698318153619766, 0.01978459395468235, -0.06907495856285095, 0.04109877720475197, 0.0007310967775993049, -0.01512662973254919, 0.022078372538089752, -0.01983577385544777, 0.04068189859390259, -0.017039725556969643, 0.017849082127213478, -0.03229890018701553, 0.042644839733839035, -0.03917112201452255, 0.009791740216314793, -0.024102643132209778, -0.028472309932112694, -0.017535367980599403, 0.0016621077666059136, 0.019043946638703346, 0.015423018485307693, 0.04170650988817215, 0.008633347228169441, -0.009223726578056812, -0.003854699432849884, -0.008343825116753578, 0.04044456407427788, -0.004107310436666012, 0.029679588973522186, 0.0007417249144054949, 0.019678017124533653, -0.05733523890376091, 0.00793522410094738, -0.016295716166496277, 0.030996359884738922, 0.04619123786687851, -0.030481750145554543, -0.02375321462750435, -0.051984965801239014, -0.012812282890081406, 0.034690264612436295, 0.031231703236699104, -0.001971044111996889, -0.05871422588825226, 0.019774574786424637, 0.0030411146581172943, -0.07050563395023346, 0.004506481345742941, 0.029289698228240013, 0.006328359246253967, 0.007123181130737066, -0.027678539976477623, -0.02602650783956051, -0.007261330261826515, -0.0006406063330359757, 0.012573560699820518, -0.0027080511208623648, -0.02417735382914543, -0.019959524273872375, 0.02203327603638172, -0.006205975543707609, -0.030443012714385986, -0.01158334780484438, 0.006933656521141529, 0.04922524094581604, -0.0026230481453239918, -0.03139360994100571, 0.0032652411609888077, 0.038969267159700394, 0.05605711042881012, 0.03423573449254036, 0.04705386608839035, -0.07578960061073303, -0.01597459986805916, 0.04209928587079048, 0.05181344971060753, -0.03277172893285751, -0.0020692390389740467, -0.022626956924796104, -0.038183826953172684, 0.009686024859547615, -0.021961025893688202, 0.03309620916843414, 0.014770627953112125, 0.051470477133989334, -0.044490329921245575, -0.026288211345672607, -0.056268494576215744, -0.010699118487536907, -0.007428249344229698, 0.023996951058506966, -0.01656346023082733, -0.012601588852703571, -0.02151438035070896, 0.004008856602013111, 0.040780648589134216, 0.07630612701177597, -0.02777099795639515, 0.003432409605011344, 0.02629692852497101, -0.005097670946270227, -0.009808487258851528, -0.06887891888618469, -0.01301213912665844, -0.016477813944220543, -0.004124896600842476, 0.007465172093361616, -0.017233416438102722, -0.03716103732585907, 0.039626963436603546, 0.02076617255806923, -0.04676814377307892, -0.012479468248784542, -0.03845824673771858, 0.0322047658264637, 0.02869529277086258, 0.038420189172029495, 0.05640405789017677, 0.034871578216552734, 0.022838907316327095, 0.017836665734648705, -0.01421927660703659, 0.008842585608363152, -0.04153258726000786, -0.07790414243936539, -0.04553917795419693, 0.020180579274892807, -0.022490637376904488, 0.02349073812365532, -0.04270470142364502, 0.03951706737279892, -0.028879033401608467, -0.023292144760489464, -0.013590957038104534, 0.013697322458028793, -0.025072308257222176, -0.029889721423387527, 0.01020019967108965, 0.058020271360874176, -0.008175058290362358, 0.04542583227157593, 0.03310149163007736, 0.00046179821947589517, 0.004071914590895176, 0.05166883394122124, -0.06625127792358398, -0.016240691766142845, -0.05684816464781761, -0.01662871614098549, -0.012125719338655472, -0.014505818486213684, 0.06484469026327133, 0.005263263825327158, 0.032955389469861984, 0.009183297865092754, -0.010402473621070385, -0.008857743814587593, 0.05095536261796951, -0.004194736946374178, 0.024577951058745384, -0.038954924792051315, 0.015119403600692749, -0.0519501194357872, 0.0037351641803979874, -0.053388483822345734, -0.019703485071659088, 0.02983097732067108, 0.029076995328068733, -0.027096077799797058, -0.026053793728351593, -0.008657241240143776, -0.00967456866055727, -0.015452256426215172, -0.017290432006120682, 0.06183663010597229, -0.016446655616164207, 0.021089142188429832, 0.013232497498393059, 0.01250554621219635, 0.08657736331224442, 0.006459705997258425, -0.0017195717664435506, 0.02114528976380825, -0.01694883406162262, -0.028571147471666336, 0.014550038613379002, 0.004425947088748217, -0.04380474612116814, -0.02166607789695263, -0.023332126438617706, -0.013826015405356884, 0.0398150235414505, -0.006944844499230385, -0.001127138384617865, -0.014230386354029179, 0.007759389001876116, -0.0034621863160282373, -0.04649697616696358, -0.0020799506455659866, -0.008943243883550167, -0.0025602520909160376, 0.006075957790017128, 0.04585425183176994, 0.021230828016996384, -0.003414400387555361, -0.008642757311463356, 0.02867281809449196, -0.013522851280868053, 0.021390514448285103, 0.06088750436902046, -0.04176895692944527, 0.005696098320186138, -0.02032330632209778, -0.05088992044329643, 0.028690047562122345, -0.020602678880095482, 0.053828295320272446, 0.00843209307640791, 0.03483586013317108, -0.007128994446247816, -0.016525743529200554, -0.03810150548815727, -0.029718590900301933, 0.034908439964056015, 0.04752128943800926, 0.049094170331954956, 0.04105575010180473, -0.00829014927148819, -0.00036431808257475495, -0.039618492126464844, -0.021745508536696434, 0.0018484832253307104, 0.03182920813560486, 0.034773267805576324, -0.004043810535222292, -0.0352943018078804, 0.04574891924858093, -0.028066471219062805, 0.031303104013204575, 0.05204686522483826, -0.013196341693401337, 0.03264040872454643, 0.015785839408636093, -0.06767462193965912, -0.03685121610760689, 0.024450648576021194, -0.03345220535993576, 0.026590989902615547, -0.01540131401270628, -0.0074114068411290646, 0.04572320356965065, 0.04203077033162117, 0.038773879408836365, -0.023160859942436218, 0.00915526319295168, -0.06964360177516937, 0.022910574451088905, 0.018574930727481842, -0.023712294176220894, 0.035086531192064285, -0.007347758859395981, 0.0018076503183692694, 0.00321406964212656, 0.04624471813440323, -0.018842434510588646, -0.057298410683870316, -0.026337752118706703, -0.019467594102025032, -0.06600693613290787, 0.03982069343328476, -0.002339665312319994, -0.03861577808856964, 0.01576581783592701, -0.017864903435111046, 0.04755297675728798, 0.012871361337602139, 0.032479170709848404, -0.005030274856835604, 0.04517051950097084, -0.012125151231884956, 0.03833277150988579, 0.017551414668560028, 0.0024747743736952543, 0.14397329092025757, 0.0808369368314743, 0.025506775826215744, -0.0016665664734318852, 0.03465835750102997, 0.01921183429658413, 0.013617792166769505, -0.019844068214297295, 0.014230288565158844, 0.013558642007410526, -0.02931501902639866, 0.01450719777494669, -0.011145076714456081, -0.025062933564186096, -0.04027077183127403, 0.061149612069129944, 0.004492069128900766, 0.0116896266117692, -0.0066092717461287975, 0.0365871824324131, 0.012840284034609795, -0.037766069173812866, -0.01404343731701374, 0.019485652446746826, 0.003754456527531147, -0.029561694711446762, -0.03338628262281418, -0.01093285158276558, -0.0004658022371586412, -0.014808655716478825, -0.011256243102252483, -0.02744300663471222, 0.02197638340294361, -0.01888282038271427, -0.006715510971844196, -0.006736678536981344, -0.019687307998538017, -0.06000082194805145, 0.000607016496360302, 0.08045200258493423, 0.025300005450844765, -0.022744225338101387, -0.00025901757180690765, 0.004000831861048937, -0.005609598476439714, -0.04113972559571266, -0.08331167697906494, 0.05523989349603653, -0.039348047226667404, -0.002535570180043578, 0.018963761627674103, 0.024679863825440407, 0.015579262748360634, -0.0611313134431839, 0.011866338551044464, -0.01229808572679758, 0.025130122900009155, -0.004862648900598288, -0.006273325532674789, -0.026988990604877472, 0.050680458545684814, 0.043689433485269547, 0.017530204728245735, -0.013335171155631542, -0.013330197893083096, -0.05339272692799568, -0.02159779518842697, 0.03582147881388664, 0.020390193909406662, 0.03670134395360947, -0.007395836059004068, -0.021094826981425285, -0.03156355395913124, 0.0018382924608886242, 0.00931624323129654, -0.0054893349297344685, 0.030852004885673523, 0.020557833835482597, -0.0565137080848217, -0.02425435744225979, -0.05637708678841591, -0.005548445973545313, -0.016464654356241226, 0.015065610408782959, -0.02798670344054699, -0.016095342114567757, 0.0023292102850973606, 0.008046282455325127, 0.0483233742415905, 0.044914260506629944, 0.01675661839544773, 0.033731088042259216, 0.004505148157477379, -0.04393281787633896, 0.010069997981190681, 0.0019247974269092083, 0.0022111707367002964, 0.04223500192165375, 0.011338108219206333, 0.08656332641839981, 0.011548168957233429, 0.0068029253743588924, 0.005039689596742392, 0.029243284836411476, 0.01744958944618702, -0.020020635798573494, -0.0013149203732609749, -0.03287704288959503, 0.016293637454509735, 0.0020632443483918905, -0.01673421636223793, -0.06056734919548035, -0.025012638419866562, -0.044064268469810486, -0.044081591069698334, -0.001517611788585782, -0.021774739027023315, -0.022307056933641434, 0.011228098534047604, -0.028287619352340698, 0.0065679349936544895, -0.007169758435338736, -0.0016092583537101746, -0.0204167477786541, 0.0072812591679394245, -0.025229668244719505, 0.0035947661381214857, -0.02117501012980938, -0.00017108191968873143, -0.002940583974123001, -0.02881546877324581, 0.04432591050863266, 0.006830208469182253, -0.006504205986857414, -0.01767265610396862, -0.013604102656245232, -0.005104593001306057, 0.031143371015787125, -0.015086828731000423, 0.01974024809896946, -0.0001583392295287922, -0.04410497099161148, -0.02227385900914669, 0.008800964802503586, -0.006300814915448427, 0.0027499718125909567, 0.022589650005102158, 0.006776686757802963, -0.04375597462058067, 0.027222121134400368, -0.004512016195803881, -0.019535796716809273, -0.019524797797203064, 0.03531051427125931, 0.015562871471047401, 0.030717743560671806, -0.00792524591088295, 0.030556434765458107, -0.004586819559335709, 0.01959288865327835, 0.020433319732546806, -0.001558135962113738, -0.023096241056919098, -0.011096885427832603, -0.021889887750148773, 0.025679370388388634, 0.009041082113981247, 0.003510785289108753, 0.054164282977581024, 0.03334023058414459, 0.0024607102386653423, 0.0368802472949028, -0.012599368579685688, 0.020028969272971153, -0.0900033488869667, -0.019091609865427017, 0.001836921670474112, 0.03107619285583496, 0.03173033148050308, -0.05515872687101364, 0.017771359533071518, 0.05493155121803284, -0.03680969774723053, 0.038856521248817444, -0.033689092844724655, 0.004095657728612423, -0.034607455134391785, -0.025086458772420883, -0.02339906245470047, 0.005353940650820732, 0.023584172129631042, -0.013836430385708809, 0.032679483294487, 0.017754362896084785, -0.024999553337693214, -0.007843243889510632, -0.016953902319073677, 0.050406306982040405, 0.01541135273873806, -0.06591325998306274, 0.03089945577085018, -0.05354200303554535, -0.030859392136335373, 0.050874013453722, -0.011780166998505592, 0.008345105685293674, 0.039725411683321, 0.038967009633779526, 0.0516945943236351, 0.034328196197748184, 0.05603347346186638, -0.018026959151029587, 0.015872033312916756, -0.0037214087788015604, -0.020803354680538177, 0.011191843077540398, -0.018143242225050926, 0.026169592514634132, 0.02082572877407074, 0.0023816267494112253, -0.018933944404125214, 0.03349016234278679, -0.04992261156439781, -0.02110496535897255, -0.028714727610349655, 0.007800873834639788, -0.046146441251039505, -0.02192663960158825, 0.00030584895284846425, -0.013452182523906231, 0.004215421620756388, -0.003460394451394677, 0.023865029215812683, -0.016595348715782166, 0.014522007666528225, -0.020604321733117104, -0.020683418959379196, -0.0035704425536096096, -0.00401927949860692, -0.017353281378746033, -0.04830873757600784, 0.024923771619796753, 0.004708907566964626, -0.037924379110336304, -0.022533202543854713, -0.022161226719617844, -0.034556061029434204, 0.009019598364830017, -0.04859573766589165, 0.02435287833213806, 0.015574470162391663, -0.005771885626018047, 0.03051174432039261, -0.11371088027954102, 0.058143556118011475, 0.0022560516372323036, -0.05300883948802948, -0.024075597524642944, -0.025660259649157524, -0.004092617891728878, 0.011159569025039673, 0.05920296162366867, 0.020945271477103233, 0.03554459661245346, -0.011488063260912895, 0.030951084569096565, 0.011048574931919575, -0.032880999147892, 0.06639393419027328, -0.014542895369231701, 0.0070457905530929565, -0.032275520265102386, -0.00611589290201664, 0.017506003379821777, -0.013180327601730824, 0.035413581877946854, 0.002971446141600609, 0.03650229051709175, 0.03469912335276604, -0.0018261828226968646, 0.06193799525499344, -0.01067147683352232, -0.011623505502939224, 0.010041598230600357, -0.007677935063838959, 0.017685359343886375, 0.02423790469765663, -0.033393848687410355, -0.06610305607318878, -0.03279265761375427, -0.005643283482640982, -0.03346700221300125, -0.015086700208485126, 0.02783709578216076, 0.014546379446983337, -0.05170692875981331, 0.03130751848220825, 0.006106861401349306, 0.00939149409532547, 0.0011477384250611067, 0.03092910535633564, 0.04245506227016449, 0.046241987496614456, -0.032635483890771866, 0.05008197948336601, -0.001839926466345787, -0.01874876208603382, -0.020802216604351997, -0.017911257222294807, 0.0324450358748436, -0.019217118620872498, 0.00905497744679451, 0.034532129764556885, -0.021385252475738525, 0.016968656331300735, -0.016836486756801605, 0.01480573508888483, -0.0174059197306633, 0.0037202981766313314, 0.02187887765467167, -0.017269767820835114, -0.011736777611076832, 0.024804292246699333, -0.023085426539182663, 0.05378846079111099, -0.020804906263947487, -0.03540801629424095, -0.027225563302636147, -0.05883769690990448, -0.03940623998641968, 0.02973206900060177, 0.004934531170874834, 0.04724154993891716, 0.008364682085812092, 0.027141587808728218, 0.015835000202059746, -0.006961929611861706, 0.054243169724941254, -0.01003284752368927, 0.049759771674871445, 0.021302316337823868, 0.01358446478843689, 0.0034948557149618864, -0.0056435903534293175, 0.025180207565426826, -0.01887674257159233, 0.012392126023769379, 0.038245320320129395, 0.03541441261768341, -0.01215226948261261, -0.021545780822634697, 0.014851612970232964, 0.03610394150018692, -0.02379218302667141, -0.016141798347234726, -0.07559961080551147, 0.009418690577149391, 0.008687925525009632, -0.028127186000347137 ]
<p>I would like to know what is the theoretical distribution of the vector of (signed) deviances $d_i$ from a logistic regression. Failing that, is there a way to to transform them unto approximately normally distributed r.v.? </p> <p>My model for the data generating process is the simplest one, e.g.</p> <p>$$y_i\sim\mathcal{B}(p_i)$$</p> <p>where </p> <p>$$p_i=\pmb x_i'\pmb\theta$$</p> <p>and $\mathcal{B}$ is the Bernoulli distribution.</p> <p>so in R code:</p> <pre><code>n&lt;-1000 p&lt;-5 x&lt;-matrix(rnorm(n*(p-1)),nc=p-1); y&lt;-cbind(1,x)%*%rep(1,p) y0&lt;-1/(exp(-y)+1); y0&lt;-rbinom(n,1,y0) fit&lt;-glm(y0~x,family="binomial") y&lt;-residuals(fit,type="deviance") qqnorm(y) qqline(y) </code></pre>
73,752
[ -0.02319852076470852, 0.02507093921303749, -0.01385399792343378, -0.028463568538427353, 0.034745413810014725, 0.006952272262424231, -0.01220825593918562, -0.018648091703653336, 0.05432168394327164, -0.05840066075325012, 0.03042960911989212, 0.04799947515130043, 0.027662035077810287, 0.04162481799721718, 0.03817201405763626, 0.010438377037644386, -0.017605271190404892, 0.00042263834620825946, 0.03108372911810875, -0.03708015754818916, 0.02880782261490822, 0.011370337568223476, 0.029105810448527336, -0.005319525953382254, -0.012622170150279999, 0.05428364500403404, 0.05596042051911354, 0.0034504211507737637, 0.003408374497666955, 0.0589742474257946, -0.023183194920420647, -0.03803998604416847, -0.0019797636196017265, 0.03171086311340332, 0.033354103565216064, 0.03305384889245033, -0.006188771687448025, -0.01389596238732338, 0.00855113472789526, 0.014655811712145805, -0.018030190840363503, -0.023503992706537247, 0.012938753701746464, 0.03469984605908394, 0.029176365584135056, -0.026293134316802025, 0.019103527069091797, -0.04129546880722046, 0.05658538639545441, -0.06396280229091644, 0.0615893192589283, 0.010797486640512943, -0.005830284208059311, 0.04224727302789688, -0.02243323251605034, -0.02021671272814274, 0.04184984415769577, 0.07031551003456116, -0.041102662682533264, -0.0801401138305664, 0.0007635895744897425, -0.06117088347673416, 0.00383268971927464, -0.029618006199598312, -0.04126889631152153, -0.022167565301060677, 0.010174630209803581, -0.06121964007616043, 0.07084912806749344, -0.030155891552567482, 0.019142992794513702, 0.049812767654657364, 0.021737195551395416, -0.018665112555027008, 0.05072849988937378, -0.030297618359327316, -0.0058051347732543945, -0.039178717881441116, 0.007644403725862503, 0.03941911458969116, -0.015297750011086464, 0.016952233389019966, 0.006174088455736637, 0.030478794127702713, -0.015287729911506176, -0.018813753500580788, 0.06456547230482101, -0.02467263676226139, 0.02004202827811241, 0.04525509104132652, -0.01619993895292282, 0.019272807985544205, 0.05149370804429054, 0.02413817308843136, -0.037855952978134155, 0.01938861422240734, -0.003472741227596998, 0.04328392073512077, 0.051415760070085526, -0.027080394327640533, -0.02063801698386669, -0.06671585887670517, 0.01663215272128582, 0.03540012985467911, -0.0419740304350853, -0.005187974777072668, -0.004165856167674065, -0.022004369646310806, 0.0010880217887461185, -0.04344460740685463, -0.005579522345215082, 0.031135817989706993, -0.009569203481078148, 0.013398205861449242, 0.02447720803320408, -0.025080347433686256, -0.013450616970658302, -0.032241739332675934, 0.038903020322322845, 0.05303841456770897, 0.013016744516789913, 0.006295692641288042, 0.025644324719905853, -0.024058468639850616, -0.015789944678544998, 0.00009016501280711964, 0.021878669038414955, -0.0013590971939265728, -0.030141906812787056, 0.035285428166389465, -0.0361541323363781, -0.036159489303827286, 0.021542076021432877, 0.002676789416000247, 0.0250228438526392, 0.01284290011972189, -0.060468655079603195, -0.06237255781888962, -0.004684580024331808, 0.009202034212648869, 0.029736971482634544, -0.03953152894973755, -0.020842617377638817, 0.03338666260242462, 0.014657529070973396, 0.019007494673132896, 0.05050256848335266, -0.0025135716423392296, -0.00243095844052732, 0.009438414126634598, -0.01240521389991045, 0.0078092231415212154, -0.03913188725709915, -0.03991062939167023, -0.01536821760237217, -0.06775008887052536, 0.0450054369866848, 0.0220321137458086, -0.038653310388326645, -0.019007865339517593, 0.02234550379216671, -0.0006170885171741247, -0.004586166702210903, -0.005598766729235649, -0.001008097780868411, -0.008440503850579262, 0.09312982857227325, 0.010969474911689758, 0.02271571382880211, 0.034863539040088654, -0.0147296953946352, -0.010771731846034527, -0.009967776015400887, 0.047430314123630524, 0.04022218659520149, -0.04591565206646919, 0.009820532985031605, -0.04622508957982063, 0.06516125798225403, 0.037770889699459076, -0.05380049720406532, -0.030728710815310478, -0.018405165523290634, -0.03819882497191429, 0.015995558351278305, 0.026508670300245285, -0.023224525153636932, -0.012087858282029629, 0.07276030629873276, -0.023460259661078453, -0.058415696024894714, -0.03490263596177101, 0.015134911052882671, 0.006273234263062477, -0.016170822083950043, 0.006368744187057018, 0.006342959124594927, 0.06009777635335922, 0.005960892420262098, 0.036745380610227585, -0.02722654677927494, -0.040951166301965714, 0.05267903208732605, -0.029502101242542267, -0.025310924276709557, 0.019856944680213928, 0.05087234824895859, -0.026734609156847, 0.04761868342757225, -0.05730748549103737, -0.03512924537062645, -0.006022766698151827, -0.030355680733919144, 0.009932490065693855, -0.016288280487060547, -0.05821773037314415, 0.017694059759378433, 0.0008489797473885119, 0.00013389569357968867, -0.000215463966014795, -0.05557246133685112, 0.04206313565373421, 0.07520030438899994, 0.006162658799439669, -0.012011151760816574, -0.01788308657705784, 0.002232444006949663, 0.002065794076770544, -0.030673228204250336, -0.016925351694226265, -0.04578847438097, -0.02326151728630066, 0.038350194692611694, 0.018380986526608467, -0.02301405556499958, -0.012977207079529762, 0.04187323898077011, -0.007607696577906609, 0.027733610942959785, 0.015602783299982548, -0.0368470698595047, -0.0031231201719492674, 0.0038572975900024176, 0.017983879894018173, 0.0040336656384170055, -0.011817642487585545, 0.004440020304173231, 0.014147836714982986, 0.06015513092279434, -0.015922587364912033, -0.01013677567243576, 0.05783902108669281, 0.0136514101177454, -0.036978304386138916, -0.02149379439651966, -0.008849277161061764, 0.05255119130015373, 0.013307024724781513, -0.012198802083730698, 0.05121808871626854, -0.008135451003909111, -0.006149980239570141, 0.002942955121397972, -0.020312301814556122, 0.04176614060997963, 0.08856160193681717, -0.014350512064993382, -0.018019290640950203, 0.025630207732319832, -0.0017826857510954142, 0.019549475982785225, -0.05018952116370201, -0.042460404336452484, -0.029073871672153473, 0.029164932668209076, 0.018759481608867645, 0.0541311576962471, -0.03056509979069233, -0.05048096552491188, -0.031253326684236526, 0.03770015761256218, -0.004239759407937527, 0.015734635293483734, 0.007854541763663292, -0.07420064508914948, -0.019239814952015877, -0.05407235026359558, -0.015782127156853676, 0.008405793458223343, -0.006495294161140919, -0.012042123824357986, 0.01987316645681858, -0.045920394361019135, -0.046729736030101776, -0.011802404187619686, -0.01783810369670391, -0.02037873864173889, -0.010770108550786972, -0.0701255276799202, 0.026823198422789574, 0.007844991981983185, -0.013855370692908764, 0.03274666517972946, -0.08153221756219864, -0.024014830589294434, -0.017917847260832787, 0.009084015153348446, 0.02586500346660614, 0.021864697337150574, 0.044002290815114975, 0.004278780426830053, -0.021912239491939545, -0.012021880596876144, -0.08994751423597336, -0.05664978548884392, 0.0071936845779418945, 0.011493473313748837, 0.0018702277448028326, -0.002106496598571539, -0.015241920948028564, 0.0909036248922348, 0.0569671206176281, -0.033099256455898285, -0.050661057233810425, -0.016231553629040718, -0.012195653282105923, -0.032671403139829636, 0.02943388931453228, 0.015175613574683666, 0.02329046092927456, 0.05465593934059143, -0.03207196295261383, 0.023198066279292107, 0.008791718631982803, -0.015069917775690556, -0.02465328760445118, 0.05951198562979698, -0.010787767358124256, -0.004244344774633646, 0.03354259580373764, 0.017528651282191277, -0.030915722250938416, 0.030163323506712914, 0.011513606645166874, 0.038027528673410416, 0.017509540542960167, -0.03320297226309776, 0.010030124336481094, -0.007464100141078234, -0.0006871310179121792, -0.006300808861851692, 0.01621575653553009, -0.010946034453809261, -0.04940136522054672, -0.011721373535692692, 0.04229607805609703, 0.02424670197069645, 0.01628255471587181, -0.002008052309975028, 0.012927049770951271, 0.022657273337244987, 0.014339791610836983, 0.002736556576564908, 0.01897355169057846, -0.04015900939702988, 0.013966971077024937, -0.04688911885023117, -0.034186951816082, 0.048251673579216, 0.009178954176604748, 0.007789977826178074, -0.022730812430381775, -0.0068749054335057735, 0.022404126822948456, -0.01072867400944233, -0.005014124326407909, -0.022369056940078735, 0.051015205681324005, 0.02754460647702217, 0.027645884081721306, -0.006017584353685379, -0.017629390582442284, 0.018673283979296684, 0.023661186918616295, -0.0790625661611557, 0.04188911244273186, 0.0005876175127923489, -0.003443627618253231, -0.015601147897541523, 0.0044519356451928616, 0.07899073511362076, -0.032359786331653595, 0.014083378948271275, 0.027836160734295845, 0.024829335510730743, -0.026621656492352486, 0.0022231517359614372, 0.00038169132312759757, -0.019315969198942184, -0.014180055819451809, 0.014752821996808052, -0.02959706448018551, -0.026497356593608856, 0.023309091106057167, 0.037863463163375854, -0.011165540665388107, 0.008996987715363503, -0.029091279953718185, 0.037142932415008545, 0.004489916376769543, 0.038258735090494156, 0.04791482910513878, 0.032003019005060196, -0.035142574459314346, 0.007418942637741566, -0.024241207167506218, 0.03848382458090782, 0.061522871255874634, 0.013576814904808998, -0.004005929920822382, -0.05383941903710365, 0.0030454969964921474, 0.046191662549972534, -0.01936974562704563, 0.0018738240469247103, 0.0027602638583630323, 0.05206660181283951, 0.03550846129655838, -0.03303439915180206, 0.00268450821749866, 0.0785631388425827, -0.0034353737719357014, -0.009797757491469383, -0.001696352963335812, 0.026238275691866875, 0.000550626078620553, 0.036194752901792526, 0.0008320899214595556, 0.029453104361891747, -0.008616222999989986, 0.012047873809933662, 0.05037350952625275, -0.009937643073499203, 0.008560367859899998, -0.016235042363405228, 0.031102865934371948, 0.05580056086182594, -0.0004426613450050354, -0.030142026022076607, 0.020144902169704437, 0.010576295666396618, 0.026939544826745987, 0.011369921267032623, -0.0020562135614454746, -0.0673208236694336, 0.012173143215477467, 0.0710909441113472, 0.04799678921699524, -0.02108968235552311, -0.0212049949914217, -0.0333627387881279, -0.032051537185907364, 0.058723900467157364, -0.023690074682235718, -0.014416307210922241, 0.025682564824819565, 0.022621771320700645, 0.0029031781014055014, -0.020551493391394615, -0.09299971163272858, 0.02219635434448719, -0.029049810022115707, 0.02866487018764019, -0.03986864909529686, -0.049622662365436554, -0.04842580482363701, 0.014456421136856079, -0.009631168097257614, 0.07057355344295502, -0.032527074217796326, -0.026454823091626167, 0.009370877407491207, 0.020319975912570953, 0.033228740096092224, -0.011898485012352467, 0.010316727682948112, 0.027096865698695183, -0.016059374436736107, 0.06676561385393143, 0.007248935289680958, -0.018180610612034798, 0.018053865060210228, 0.007860707119107246, 0.017169883474707603, 0.009207800962030888, -0.044352706521749496, 0.04279794916510582, 0.015184733085334301, -0.002193740801885724, 0.03733791783452034, 0.031693246215581894, 0.008489956147968769, -0.018527166917920113, -0.04986915737390518, 0.009553937241435051, -0.006075349170714617, -0.03760175779461861, -0.044214893132448196, 0.014216940850019455, 0.02524164691567421, 0.01385626383125782, 0.014136913232505322, -0.005793680902570486, -0.015594156458973885, -0.025903768837451935, -0.011827904731035233, 0.050337713211774826, -0.006434262730181217, -0.006637172773480415, 0.032078053802251816, 0.016834301874041557, 0.007687394041568041, 0.008173221722245216, 0.030879907310009003, 0.007878425531089306, 0.00459271389991045, 0.019793400540947914, -0.05090413987636566, -0.021048927679657936, -0.029181038960814476, -0.004948312416672707, -0.024008681997656822, -0.009277607314288616, 0.018862208351492882, 0.014416977763175964, 0.03635358810424805, 0.00001361930844723247, -0.039260029792785645, -0.015235746279358864, -0.004668157547712326, -0.007646727841347456, 0.0028871227987110615, -0.041015055030584335, 0.0012563830241560936, -0.019497424364089966, -0.015089454129338264, -0.05918699502944946, -0.03692319244146347, 0.005070489831268787, -0.015026292763650417, 0.014033827930688858, -0.032695818692445755, -0.025751564651727676, 0.003181545063853264, 0.0027645693626254797, 0.014158734120428562, 0.04750155657529831, -0.032661862671375275, 0.011087074875831604, -0.040367428213357925, 0.030383965000510216, 0.08178781718015671, -0.019022174179553986, 0.006131920497864485, 0.0216505266726017, -0.004120323807001114, -0.010396051220595837, 0.02924465760588646, 0.023104960098862648, -0.03339473903179169, -0.019013097509741783, -0.021476224064826965, 0.0014677084982395172, 0.04314048960804939, -0.028080686926841736, -0.021917646750807762, -0.011297453194856644, 0.010381259955465794, 0.021982276812195778, -0.03156081214547157, 0.014862031675875187, 0.001713102450594306, -0.011300305835902691, -0.04126385599374771, -0.026655523106455803, -0.025147944688796997, 0.01764710433781147, 0.05112864077091217, -0.006666817702353001, 0.01144415233284235, 0.018090177327394485, 0.07528190314769745, 0.009649061597883701, -0.020701758563518524, 0.014584358781576157, -0.02066168002784252, 0.056177109479904175, 0.037344835698604584, -0.014914103783667088, 0.010184325277805328, 0.026727812364697456, -0.001925589982420206, -0.05127105489373207, -0.05896563082933426, -0.024272769689559937, 0.0472925528883934, 0.019946198910474777, 0.02471361681818962, 0.024955233559012413, 0.005788465961813927, -0.013443684205412865, -0.016701970249414444, -0.02069675177335739, 0.018858952447772026, 0.01876937411725521, 0.06499214470386505, -0.03471090644598007, -0.021174054592847824, -0.0027458008844405413, 0.04242033511400223, 0.0023106494918465614, 0.02172488160431385, -0.01404496468603611, 0.023990919813513756, 0.028706958517432213, -0.024317890405654907, -0.03552340716123581, 0.02963179163634777, -0.03148183971643448, 0.030993586406111717, 0.0007689408957958221, -0.0106500294059515, 0.05846630036830902, 0.02516728639602661, 0.018031736835837364, -0.014221630990505219, -0.02154935896396637, -0.02495518885552883, 0.008119857870042324, 0.04307510703802109, -0.03160563111305237, 0.0006128415116108954, 0.006237137597054243, 0.01503690518438816, -0.02483723871409893, 0.027350198477506638, 0.0040132757276296616, -0.07938652485609055, -0.010266945697367191, -0.010686763562262058, -0.017040932551026344, 0.013142036274075508, -0.025079689919948578, -0.009375270456075668, -0.0012642095098271966, -0.06580312550067902, 0.021117640659213066, 0.019932786002755165, 0.030994674190878868, 0.020243383944034576, 0.07353994250297546, -0.03131544589996338, 0.011637743562459946, -0.010528361424803734, -0.03472638130187988, 0.11961709707975388, 0.06786347180604935, 0.035417500883340836, -0.08514467626810074, -0.03596268966794014, -0.008060622960329056, 0.02128445729613304, 0.02401980757713318, -0.022594638168811798, 0.013217128813266754, -0.01284656673669815, 0.06385986506938934, 0.052941784262657166, 0.030887605622410774, 0.02961129881441593, 0.04269297420978546, -0.035214878618717194, -0.01270125713199377, 0.011847035959362984, 0.03980633616447449, -0.02223982661962509, -0.009397739544510841, -0.07071546465158463, 0.010872578248381615, 0.01060320995748043, -0.03491118177771568, -0.05508614704012871, 0.015447771176695824, -0.01477403286844492, -0.012798437848687172, -0.00143445935100317, -0.01581551507115364, 0.009215522557497025, 0.014287990517914295, 0.026094669476151466, -0.005602810066193342, 0.03527599573135376, -0.02003968320786953, 0.01584324985742569, 0.04452476277947426, 0.02991616353392601, 0.0028317891992628574, 0.02821475826203823, -0.010864466428756714, -0.02806277759373188, -0.037476662546396255, -0.03797642141580582, 0.03136270120739937, -0.008686594665050507, -0.018269008025527, -0.004466398153454065, -0.01820417307317257, 0.009993468411266804, -0.051163915544748306, -0.01595350168645382, 0.034699615091085434, -0.007924938574433327, 0.005862124264240265, 0.006824319716542959, 0.00010664450383046642, 0.019202424213290215, 0.008024279028177261, 0.03760361671447754, 0.004423561040312052, -0.03960345312952995, -0.011051168665289879, -0.006587618961930275, 0.0720747858285904, -0.020303543657064438, -0.0034648110158741474, -0.0040090386755764484, -0.015979140996932983, -0.027209414169192314, -0.004210469778627157, -0.008439840748906136, -0.026791498064994812, 0.033301398158073425, -0.007372863125056028, -0.005561319645494223, -0.04082260653376579, -0.05119819566607475, 0.01698710024356842, -0.009310189634561539, 0.0033008717000484467, -0.04053180292248726, -0.03291542828083038, 0.012474896386265755, 0.046432144939899445, 0.018768563866615295, 0.00041172505007125437, -0.002713126363232732, 0.06946808844804764, -0.012799070216715336, -0.036845747381448746, -0.040539566427469254, 0.00296024139970541, -0.05664415284991264, -0.014031223021447659, 0.007058330345898867, 0.03411537781357765, -0.005435480736196041, 0.019010240212082863, -0.021945517510175705, 0.06267180293798447, -0.030050186440348625, 0.02515431120991707, -0.005439148750156164, -0.05366864800453186, 0.017620373517274857, 0.010141951963305473, 0.008018807508051395, -0.01199256256222725, -0.012555252760648727, -0.05127457156777382, -0.0718933716416359, 0.037512216717004776, 0.0017469312297180295, -0.032717444002628326, -0.02062332071363926, 0.00248885340988636, 0.011768555268645287, -0.06402929872274399, 0.007191086653620005, -0.004739982541650534, 0.011972994543612003, -0.018829824402928352, -0.00021520338486880064, -0.016331570222973824, 0.01665332168340683, -0.010883957147598267, 0.012080271728336811, 0.036897845566272736, 0.03137104958295822, 0.03469052165746689, 0.004262910690158606, -0.007219701074063778, 0.015933236107230186, 0.011612629517912865, -0.06320076435804367, -0.017745526507496834, 0.022944223135709763, -0.00783246848732233, -0.020082587376236916, 0.019780030474066734, 0.006027949508279562, 0.015688370913267136, -0.009182623587548733, 0.003525530220940709, -0.06483519822359085, 0.05117963254451752, 0.017030205577611923, 0.0011397345224395394, 0.01086376328021288, 0.007419654168188572, -0.0220218263566494, 0.008121393620967865, 0.017772067338228226, -0.005517665296792984, -0.011366154067218304, 0.024601303040981293, 0.06332488358020782, -0.008607575669884682, -0.0055614374577999115, 0.03079276718199253, 0.009043238125741482, -0.015289387665688992, 0.027215205132961273, -0.024472013115882874, 0.001372436061501503, 0.04103556275367737, -0.021025974303483963, 0.03239408880472183, -0.04309331625699997, 0.0015383745776489377, -0.10136833786964417, -0.04772232845425606, 0.01645779237151146, 0.006583166774362326, 0.03504020348191261, -0.06288818269968033, -0.011361624114215374, 0.009502576664090157, -0.027189841493964195, 0.002827620366588235, 0.006934535223990679, -0.020484497770667076, -0.020419873297214508, 0.027440786361694336, -0.025469088926911354, 0.0495779886841774, 0.02215980738401413, 0.027517734095454216, 0.04705098643898964, 0.003383089555427432, 0.013286357745528221, -0.020993005484342575, -0.008165191859006882, -0.006880228873342276, 0.04192392900586128, -0.057286251336336136, 0.028327204287052155, -0.052262600511312485, -0.01469030138105154, 0.03458891808986664, 0.007693076506257057, 0.050224483013153076, -0.012554201297461987, 0.02445748820900917, 0.006165005266666412, 0.06761585921049118, 0.03669976815581322, 0.0075204940512776375, 0.027649879455566406, -0.011886673048138618, 0.04019860923290253, 0.01500577013939619, -0.022984206676483154, 0.01719093695282936, -0.019816219806671143, -0.00941589754074812, -0.03763489052653313, 0.01928088255226612, -0.014515324495732784, -0.016679754480719566, -0.03369065001606941, 0.014588517136871815, -0.008148291148245335, -0.027621954679489136, 0.020849553868174553, -0.05172654613852501, 0.005553665105253458, 0.034278031438589096, 0.050339654088020325, -0.03840014338493347, 0.008129538968205452, -0.020245686173439026, -0.0604526586830616, -0.02391083724796772, -0.0027548021171242, -0.018189460039138794, -0.06927366554737091, -0.004312604200094938, -0.0036543121095746756, -0.008651796728372574, 0.015416906215250492, -0.029124721884727478, -0.05651004984974861, 0.024777870625257492, -0.04936456307768822, 0.014880404807627201, 0.036184534430503845, -0.0017645147163420916, 0.021157367154955864, -0.0738145112991333, 0.05715203657746315, 0.014772324822843075, -0.01760834828019142, -0.033121075481176376, 0.007636028341948986, -0.037968602031469345, 0.024612873792648315, 0.05043529346585274, 0.011694059707224369, -0.005986177362501621, 0.02718854881823063, 0.007826915010809898, 0.005402079783380032, -0.06525982916355133, 0.02518976852297783, -0.01269722729921341, -0.035946980118751526, 0.010923190973699093, 0.0164197888225317, 0.009318635798990726, 0.026594310998916626, 0.013321791775524616, 0.0032990160398185253, -0.0066149914637207985, -0.006880091968923807, -0.02954516001045704, 0.010242683812975883, -0.018968399614095688, 0.0065428283996880054, 0.04164649173617363, -0.018058806657791138, 0.010550555773079395, 0.048672620207071304, 0.0360557921230793, -0.07279568910598755, 0.016252998262643814, -0.03308054804801941, -0.016148841008543968, 0.01567428931593895, -0.01297273300588131, 0.0018742179963737726, -0.06446919590234756, 0.03480325639247894, 0.0022169845178723335, -0.008728454820811749, 0.016777094453573227, 0.019248193129897118, 0.019324317574501038, 0.0646265372633934, -0.02030666545033455, -0.004626206122338772, 0.008489123545587063, 0.009244012646377087, 0.02926822565495968, -0.008531711995601654, -0.004897360224276781, -0.03699323534965515, 0.010503754019737244, 0.015974873676896095, -0.02567611075937748, 0.041870273649692535, 0.01650911010801792, 0.023080239072442055, -0.011134336702525616, 0.014254328794777393, 0.02640567161142826, -0.022936811670660973, -0.006101432256400585, 0.006581355817615986, -0.0015773060731589794, 0.02558615431189537, -0.03573830425739288, -0.0032577302772551775, -0.010826535522937775, -0.03864145651459694, -0.02532039023935795, -0.0009984426433220506, -0.013297677971422672, 0.03157563507556915, 0.01581496000289917, 0.017348093912005424, 0.0338912308216095, -0.015796029940247536, -0.0029418792109936476, -0.023577626794576645, 0.0018313127802684903, 0.004537926521152258, 0.03286845237016678, 0.012985649518668652, -0.027397073805332184, -0.054403580725193024, -0.020294491201639175, 0.032066550105810165, 0.033408477902412415, 0.014927742071449757, -0.04964501038193703, -0.023827651515603065, 0.012585770338773727, 0.05049175024032593, -0.04811260849237442, -0.01370557677000761, -0.03064548410475254, 0.004805919248610735, -0.003906344063580036, -0.05370532348752022 ]
<p>I have a set of data points $\{x_i\}$. These data points are grouped so that (say) $i\in\{1,2,3\}$ is group $A$, $i\in\{4,5,6,7\}$ is group $B$, etc.</p> <p>I would like to test the null hypothesis of no linear relationship between group means and group variances.</p> <p>A naive approach would be to calculate, for each group, the sample mean $\overline{x}_g$ and sample variance $S^2_g$, then regress $$ \overline{x}_g = \beta S^2_g + \varepsilon_g $$ This doesn't work, since in small samples, $\hat{\beta}$ will be a biased estimate of $\beta$. For example, if $\beta=0$ but the $\{x_i\}$ are very positively skewed, a spuriously high $\hat{\beta}$ will be estimated. This is because</p> <ul> <li>Groups that do not contain positive outliers will have low $S^2_g$ and low $\overline{x}_g$</li> <li>Groups that do contain these outliers will have high $S^2_g$ and high $\overline{x}_g$. </li> </ul> <p>Is there a general technique for solving this problem?</p> <p>(Cross-posted from Math Stack Exchange.)</p>
73,753
[ -0.01686740107834339, 0.013738259673118591, -0.0023250440135598183, -0.017399007454514503, 0.0009481082088313997, 0.03319259732961655, -0.02498435415327549, 0.01079352293163538, 0.010810598731040955, -0.06781185418367386, 0.04868262633681297, 0.01755783148109913, 0.06264031678438187, 0.022439267486333847, 0.007345025893300772, -0.05659285560250282, -0.0588066540658474, 0.003915446810424328, 0.0018954194383695722, -0.004779853392392397, 0.0110991345718503, 0.020893163979053497, 0.018396146595478058, -0.007680520415306091, -0.035713911056518555, -0.004525311756879091, 0.0401671826839447, 0.003188124392181635, -0.03092520870268345, 0.042702849954366684, -0.030276909470558167, -0.004997501149773598, 0.032887160778045654, 0.002300261752679944, -0.0021601596381515265, 0.001926518976688385, 0.03140414133667946, 0.003850525477901101, -0.008660971187055111, 0.022291656583547592, -0.04445343464612961, 0.0005642683827318251, 0.008093292824923992, 0.0473419725894928, -0.002356582786887884, 0.02918640337884426, 0.01315588690340519, -0.04113492742180824, -0.002805477473884821, -0.06048111245036125, 0.0890672355890274, 0.003488391637802124, 0.0010083089582622051, 0.02433060109615326, -0.03648396581411362, -0.012946131639182568, 0.031242894008755684, 0.07098712027072906, -0.0035134924110025167, -0.047886960208415985, -0.008380870334804058, -0.01177364494651556, 0.008810248225927353, 0.0017172286752611399, -0.049696438014507294, 0.020261473953723907, -0.012860511429607868, -0.01549792941659689, 0.028585800901055336, -0.0325452983379364, 0.005944792181253433, 0.015850601717829704, 0.02024923823773861, 0.010788161307573318, -0.015661291778087616, -0.0006464227917604148, 0.015893246978521347, 0.05564749613404274, 0.049828141927719116, 0.03309022635221481, 0.03584245219826698, 0.008907275274395943, 0.02511443942785263, 0.026791833341121674, 0.006828614044934511, -0.009911369532346725, 0.058849506080150604, -0.020908918231725693, 0.032562121748924255, 0.03595871850848198, -0.026202615350484848, -0.024514684453606606, 0.029738251119852066, 0.021296922117471695, -0.060543693602085114, 0.025201542302966118, -0.03210415691137314, 0.020023157820105553, -0.020952977240085602, -0.004783639218658209, -0.012615092098712921, -0.03077690489590168, 0.017688611522316933, 0.10277179628610611, -0.005589381325989962, -0.005989297293126583, -0.03728863224387169, -0.006290110759437084, -0.013316682539880276, -0.018694235011935234, 0.00826223287731409, -0.02423524111509323, 0.010807431302964687, -0.012225660495460033, 0.044768743216991425, 0.03137766197323799, -0.012067058123648167, -0.04726971685886383, 0.022551029920578003, 0.030521659180521965, 0.010995876044034958, 0.00600403593853116, 0.024238934740424156, -0.010056004859507084, -0.026209190487861633, 0.04331205412745476, 0.05524277314543724, 0.002262102672830224, -0.053755514323711395, 0.01934463530778885, 0.048670969903469086, -0.015410808846354485, 0.009082169272005558, -0.006449700333178043, 0.03893934562802315, 0.007461275905370712, -0.07556721568107605, -0.056584957987070084, 0.05388632044196129, -0.00380937778390944, 0.005336708854883909, -0.0497913733124733, -0.041702888906002045, 0.05685755982995033, 0.05530666559934616, -0.0006113570416346192, 0.02672802470624447, 0.023527685552835464, 0.03202382102608681, 0.02873029187321663, -0.00468516256660223, -0.00004860700573772192, -0.050558097660541534, -0.042105499655008316, -0.004580230452120304, -0.08747436851263046, 0.03864089772105217, -0.013114569708704948, -0.013303345069289207, -0.00515409791842103, 0.027691300958395004, -0.007379756309092045, -0.000916539691388607, -0.020525943487882614, 0.04384796693921089, 0.0375547893345356, 0.03253910318017006, 0.023465577512979507, 0.0018735122866928577, 0.004418668337166309, -0.0007632232154719532, 0.04088263958692551, 0.014174769632518291, 0.07899138331413269, 0.06645719707012177, -0.01168119814246893, 0.018703771755099297, 0.011550087481737137, 0.013895660638809204, 0.007413433399051428, -0.05453901365399361, -0.031043466180562973, -0.010581026785075665, -0.0033296733163297176, 0.01160297729074955, 0.044082555919885635, -0.018847385421395302, -0.015474914573132992, 0.052079666405916214, -0.053607210516929626, -0.021088557317852974, -0.08778059482574463, 0.01679687760770321, -0.01321076974272728, -0.046136047691106796, 0.03511812910437584, 0.040763743221759796, -0.0023529657628387213, -0.010139795020222664, -0.03770364075899124, -0.02638380043208599, 0.021224023774266243, 0.06237614527344704, -0.029911082237958908, 0.01884537748992443, 0.024567298591136932, 0.048045139759778976, -0.0117953447625041, 0.034680142998695374, -0.024438204243779182, -0.026615124195814133, 0.011180469766259193, -0.029682587832212448, 0.0035917542409151793, 0.0033974440302699804, 0.004270459525287151, 0.017019884660840034, -0.0071970210410654545, -0.0027684280648827553, 0.04553895816206932, -0.05273577198386192, 0.045752424746751785, 0.05126383528113365, 0.026590237393975258, 0.0024426556192338467, -0.017018500715494156, -0.004000041168183088, -0.0030686226673424244, -0.024533243849873543, 0.004471396561712027, -0.032199788838624954, -0.009932786226272583, 0.0035760255996137857, 0.01464329194277525, -0.03877962380647659, 0.01962103880941868, 0.0540676973760128, 0.030813079327344894, -0.031539756804704666, 0.011289789341390133, -0.0006415696116164327, -0.036325860768556595, -0.02147085964679718, -0.0035088625736534595, 0.03285304456949234, 0.013774669729173183, -0.0015326779102906585, 0.02561594545841217, 0.005953176878392696, 0.010914777405560017, 0.03166129067540169, 0.027246324345469475, 0.03094855695962906, 0.006150397006422281, 0.021467115730047226, -0.0015750600723549724, 0.045319508761167526, 0.008067291229963303, 0.010878623463213444, 0.021599018946290016, 0.011407890357077122, -0.0033829743042588234, 0.013888975605368614, -0.020263157784938812, 0.04516061767935753, 0.029054027050733566, -0.0511404313147068, 0.02859395742416382, 0.009949108585715294, -0.04171169921755791, 0.008707464672625065, -0.010418114252388477, -0.04171150177717209, -0.027973147109150887, 0.04423018544912338, 0.013006912544369698, 0.024851283058524132, 0.0009774171048775315, -0.005185259506106377, -0.0029018213972449303, -0.004286643583327532, -0.016877010464668274, 0.04057956114411354, -0.00031409974326379597, -0.03393706679344177, -0.03937385976314545, -0.04264408349990845, 0.010239423252642155, 0.01909058727324009, 0.012971448712050915, 0.004645954817533493, 0.02021169662475586, 0.02014358527958393, -0.03656443953514099, -0.00198568869382143, -0.07200463861227036, 0.0017328766407445073, -0.024599120020866394, -0.024321524426341057, 0.03759542107582092, 0.005379471927881241, -0.04042783007025719, 0.046606581658124924, -0.0028348006308078766, -0.002975033363327384, -0.02481287531554699, -0.013093515299260616, 0.020142901688814163, -0.030453871935606003, 0.023167302832007408, 0.021552199497818947, -0.016219772398471832, 0.001487707020714879, -0.05108948051929474, -0.06850676238536835, -0.01660643331706524, 0.04004700481891632, 0.020137106999754906, 0.012467923574149609, -0.030853835865855217, 0.06880825012922287, 0.041451141238212585, -0.023067284375429153, -0.0463959239423275, -0.016143910586833954, -0.03203316777944565, -0.03057112544775009, 0.03568334877490997, 0.0008241863688454032, 0.045327480882406235, 0.022883767262101173, 0.008864430710673332, 0.021388132125139236, 0.046019501984119415, 0.010818559676408768, -0.033788397908210754, -0.014550447463989258, -0.015302883461117744, 0.024974899366497993, 0.03673848882317543, 0.010433025658130646, -0.018394801765680313, 0.0011415921617299318, 0.022542528808116913, 0.030034692957997322, 0.026516567915678024, -0.030138451606035233, 0.000025430255846004002, -0.02064739540219307, 0.018073398619890213, -0.02245628647506237, 0.06277879327535629, 0.024059079587459564, -0.00782532524317503, 0.021530333906412125, 0.0160188227891922, 0.02116277627646923, -0.0022383700124919415, 0.006962887477129698, 0.03885938972234726, 0.014465894550085068, -0.016804959625005722, -0.020411305129528046, -0.016206687316298485, -0.030253199860453606, 0.011315474286675453, -0.03717896342277527, -0.003964466042816639, 0.02153998799622059, 0.038756828755140305, -0.0036392598412930965, -0.007077059242874384, -0.04336650297045708, 0.02104809321463108, -0.05849018692970276, 0.0071829017251729965, -0.036296337842941284, 0.034520067274570465, 0.0015015886165201664, 0.013767292723059654, 0.00493257399648428, -0.04842139407992363, 0.0018808291060850024, -0.018593691289424896, -0.059810902923345566, 0.033543188124895096, -0.004031251184642315, -0.001350028207525611, 0.013505532406270504, -0.0023579236585646868, 0.045666083693504333, -0.010874142870306969, 0.03857748210430145, -0.0340542234480381, 0.046270035207271576, -0.003847810672596097, -0.0008339466876350343, -0.04618962109088898, -0.009898817166686058, 0.03492525964975357, 0.03328219801187515, -0.0041974750347435474, -0.06462620943784714, 0.01400910783559084, 0.023972146213054657, 0.003918185830116272, -0.011797121725976467, -0.039603058248758316, -0.001785012660548091, 0.01272311620414257, 0.04453557729721069, 0.006143914069980383, 0.04681111127138138, -0.017970778048038483, -0.019898585975170135, -0.01823856309056282, 0.049689050763845444, 0.035761140286922455, 0.02145376056432724, 0.017504960298538208, -0.02082819491624832, -0.03475198894739151, 0.008289518766105175, 0.011099698022007942, 0.014772956259548664, -0.0428316555917263, 0.045704055577516556, 0.014538384974002838, -0.048572950065135956, 0.011460484005510807, 0.01639239862561226, 0.057714998722076416, -0.003757461905479431, 0.009577691555023193, -0.021887565031647682, 0.016602851450443268, -0.044444236904382706, 0.015199115499854088, -0.02255988121032715, 0.008986285887658596, -0.01042768731713295, 0.035246822983026505, 0.008802727796137333, -0.03683039918541908, 0.018375253304839134, 0.008843902498483658, 0.018131835386157036, -0.001739427214488387, -0.01276067178696394, 0.045832693576812744, 0.03912440687417984, 0.05875220149755478, 0.044347040355205536, -0.020945396274328232, -0.09243764728307724, 0.01428215391933918, 0.023405756801366806, 0.05010988935828209, -0.01296734344214201, -0.0026256158016622066, -0.02245537005364895, 0.03016297146677971, 0.03791731223464012, -0.037447478622198105, 0.024074312299489975, -0.033000510185956955, 0.0179281122982502, -0.03591376915574074, -0.024376485496759415, -0.044579289853572845, 0.024414945393800735, -0.002493268111720681, 0.007718981709331274, -0.020274583250284195, -0.02982129342854023, -0.0228964164853096, -0.014018116518855095, 0.006573158781975508, 0.07347875833511353, 0.023117665201425552, 0.009010697714984417, 0.015084236860275269, 0.07312201708555222, -0.030222022905945778, -0.05973242595791817, 0.03021298535168171, 0.015306362882256508, -0.02744274027645588, 0.09894194453954697, -0.025608249008655548, -0.06383689492940903, 0.0032906041014939547, -0.013070575892925262, 0.0035838442854583263, -0.0030771465972065926, -0.019638197496533394, 0.04697830602526665, 0.054975755512714386, 0.052122581750154495, 0.03347077965736389, 0.05319923162460327, -0.03548711910843849, -0.005142110865563154, -0.03400670364499092, -0.007751153316348791, -0.03461107239127159, -0.04129600152373314, -0.02747984230518341, -0.02885395847260952, -0.010002302937209606, 0.040575720369815826, -0.022074690088629723, 0.039556875824928284, 0.019286707043647766, -0.03532889485359192, 0.023122679442167282, 0.025763023644685745, -0.001969201723113656, 0.0221834946423769, 0.0068307495675981045, 0.025576945394277573, 0.012355441227555275, -0.023649130016565323, 0.04946647956967354, -0.01916736550629139, 0.022824818268418312, 0.009102536365389824, -0.07859349995851517, 0.010409749113023281, -0.058147117495536804, 0.0025588087737560272, -0.03918557986617088, -0.025587595999240875, 0.04135981947183609, -0.009627548046410084, 0.014213993214070797, -0.014729898422956467, -0.006470921915024519, 0.010769483633339405, 0.029796408489346504, 0.0035714309196919203, 0.04612121358513832, -0.014155063778162003, -0.00007757150888210163, 0.027684122323989868, 0.020549006760120392, -0.09149381518363953, -0.042725492268800735, -0.011589188128709793, 0.020615005865693092, -0.009859745390713215, -0.04935242235660553, -0.00759417749941349, -0.023168101906776428, -0.010616110637784004, -0.035301052033901215, 0.06501199305057526, -0.019909387454390526, -0.029279759153723717, -0.01805047132074833, 0.033280204981565475, 0.10222326964139938, -0.03754086047410965, -0.020033225417137146, 0.04016454890370369, -0.001001077122054994, -0.0007086204714141786, 0.0035157164093106985, -0.009462651796638966, -0.04309762641787529, 0.0035876561887562275, -0.03276712819933891, -0.00003995778752141632, 0.013215379789471626, -0.03738507628440857, -0.017139311879873276, -0.0007121706730686128, 0.008743622340261936, 0.031568437814712524, -0.05107877776026726, -0.0119051244109869, -0.009974678978323936, 0.016373034566640854, -0.01896068826317787, -0.007553736679255962, -0.0033597410656511784, 0.006172418128699064, 0.03494768589735031, 0.010930929332971573, -0.05443333461880684, 0.009891360066831112, 0.11158987879753113, 0.015484325587749481, 0.014170635491609573, -0.012334149330854416, -0.03526633605360985, 0.04925895109772682, -0.00022726194583810866, 0.003318271366879344, -0.0131162628531456, 0.060824211686849594, -0.055380888283252716, -0.0019017898011952639, -0.019168395549058914, -0.00714346207678318, 0.0573296844959259, -0.013885078951716423, 0.025711705908179283, 0.04564787074923515, -0.006924015004187822, -0.012927220202982426, -0.04712867736816406, 0.02426159381866455, -0.01672978885471821, -0.003960269503295422, 0.025528283789753914, -0.02134542725980282, 0.029242873191833496, 0.03128914535045624, 0.005550635978579521, -0.0053456025198102, 0.05639894679188728, -0.014643898233771324, 0.044436488300561905, 0.028072698041796684, -0.034978486597537994, -0.07129833847284317, 0.045441411435604095, -0.06933807581663132, 0.01399410143494606, -0.07309534400701523, -0.012443305924534798, 0.00707798358052969, 0.03599229082465172, -0.008918984793126583, -0.01932631805539131, -0.021587105467915535, -0.07120764255523682, 0.014350605197250843, 0.016747260466217995, -0.027023715898394585, 0.01311045978218317, 0.03414873406291008, 0.003789563663303852, -0.017532385885715485, 0.014654294587671757, -0.06627494841814041, -0.09139455854892731, -0.014148510061204433, -0.014792755246162415, -0.01181856170296669, 0.0017475680215284228, 0.005379924084991217, -0.03534434363245964, 0.017140701413154602, -0.05707838013768196, 0.0020563555881381035, -0.023539839312434196, 0.030201293528079987, -0.031000223010778427, 0.06004433333873749, -0.011797809042036533, 0.02285938151180744, 0.007270722649991512, -0.011039390228688717, 0.1045319214463234, 0.05340714380145073, 0.033096589148044586, -0.053957726806402206, 0.044040877372026443, 0.007645478472113609, -0.02389967441558838, -0.04395033419132233, 0.00824284553527832, -0.035578224807977676, 0.012279154732823372, 0.034795962274074554, 0.09173641353845596, 0.004957928322255611, -0.0070954905822873116, 0.06458420306444168, -0.03201103210449219, 0.02418708987534046, -0.004809464327991009, 0.0056673153303563595, -0.013541561551392078, -0.013141565024852753, -0.048398569226264954, 0.024230848997831345, 0.003025427460670471, -0.0025693096686154604, -0.01683257892727852, 0.0029584437143057585, -0.021209726110100746, 0.01620221696794033, -0.026066383346915245, 0.019854005426168442, 0.024416128173470497, -0.011032210662961006, -0.04094115272164345, -0.024687888100743294, -0.004602633882313967, -0.030712081119418144, 0.03949674218893051, 0.004320624750107527, -0.024507593363523483, 0.0035693568643182516, 0.014844201505184174, 0.017282143235206604, -0.030938830226659775, -0.062205519527196884, -0.009543757885694504, 0.06002170965075493, -0.023356696590781212, -0.015648284927010536, -0.024551143869757652, 0.00880364514887333, 0.006077155005186796, -0.03284661844372749, -0.030913224443793297, 0.014690033160150051, 0.02461296133697033, -0.05869607627391815, -0.016037389636039734, 0.0025431911926716566, 0.037916090339422226, -0.0020600506104528904, 0.033633600920438766, 0.0006499887676909566, -0.039643000811338425, -0.01838771067559719, -0.014129318296909332, 0.033258289098739624, 0.022556832060217857, -0.012808697298169136, 0.004395567812025547, -0.045471999794244766, 0.01886739954352379, -0.025650637224316597, 0.02295716293156147, 0.04735763743519783, 0.019981849938631058, 0.012590526603162289, -0.012242061085999012, -0.006397091783583164, -0.04402575641870499, 0.015982765704393387, -0.05284005403518677, -0.005538817495107651, -0.01923249661922455, -0.022006817162036896, 0.029361765831708908, 0.038324739784002304, 0.01585647650063038, -0.009948085062205791, 0.0003175644960720092, 0.06752088665962219, -0.009283091872930527, -0.02364964410662651, -0.026169680058956146, 0.0005975351668894291, -0.009879977442324162, 0.02928122691810131, 0.009424670599400997, 0.046385861933231354, 0.026263073086738586, 0.017573779448866844, 0.004450255539268255, 0.049632418900728226, 0.01999046467244625, -0.027982713654637337, 0.049169041216373444, -0.054053474217653275, 0.02099590003490448, 0.009685499593615532, 0.013152656145393848, -0.0188463032245636, -0.013651429675519466, -0.009311730973422527, -0.02545882947742939, 0.0019138740608468652, -0.03514167293906212, -0.03594909980893135, 0.005101778078824282, -0.022382967174053192, 0.008297068998217583, -0.0313999243080616, -0.00025619857478886843, -0.010727355256676674, -0.02958492934703827, -0.003028729697689414, -0.007392041850835085, 0.0033788622822612524, 0.013127475045621395, -0.003041572170332074, 0.012498113326728344, 0.03515028581023216, 0.031873371452093124, 0.017653686925768852, 0.028528548777103424, -0.02507331781089306, -0.03948262333869934, 0.034443508833646774, 0.004512983839958906, -0.02166217565536499, 0.027327364310622215, -0.014675301499664783, -0.04530593752861023, 0.02957536093890667, 0.002814885461702943, 0.027212101966142654, 0.009950944222509861, 0.013699048198759556, -0.0011854113545268774, 0.0197135079652071, -0.031227538362145424, -0.017089560627937317, -0.036357421427965164, 0.014919256791472435, 0.01268369983881712, -0.012695442885160446, 0.023661846294999123, 0.0038897532504051924, 0.00784259382635355, -0.009506664238870144, 0.028983213007450104, -0.019448893144726753, -0.03486890345811844, -0.0007718243286944926, -0.006366482935845852, 0.027225090190768242, -0.013572878204286098, 0.03423155099153519, 0.02500852569937706, 0.050069503486156464, -0.04728781431913376, 0.010776435025036335, -0.0252163577824831, 0.008361082524061203, -0.11865265667438507, -0.026747331023216248, 0.03514375537633896, -0.00885141734033823, 0.058917466551065445, -0.0654992014169693, 0.03499927371740341, 0.06110578030347824, -0.06281951069831848, 0.03316452354192734, -0.03893632814288139, -0.002812179969623685, -0.044438790529966354, -0.016346750780940056, -0.03285093232989311, 0.0021484242752194405, -0.018317656591534615, 0.04676801338791847, 0.026680361479520798, 0.0415961816906929, -0.019357115030288696, -0.036319550126791, -0.009701043367385864, -0.009789342060685158, 0.050197236239910126, -0.07775389403104782, 0.012758668512105942, -0.00967444758862257, -0.010028584860265255, 0.015443241223692894, -0.006208525970578194, 0.019025316461920738, 0.007537268567830324, 0.022539658471941948, -0.028315652161836624, 0.027889510616660118, 0.04719461873173714, 0.019804852083325386, -0.016584357246756554, -0.03098221868276596, 0.0037057597655802965, 0.018698183819651604, -0.031622011214494705, 0.004590056370943785, 0.000313722703140229, -0.00552070839330554, 0.0005578919081017375, 0.007826830260455608, -0.025130875408649445, -0.029380200430750847, -0.0033413541968911886, 0.002170899882912636, 0.005711029749363661, -0.052217964082956314, -0.0018568133236840367, -0.045442428439855576, -0.0009189856355078518, 0.028275396674871445, 0.0112830251455307, -0.005210806615650654, 0.01067071408033371, -0.011782118119299412, -0.04695358872413635, -0.010458282195031643, 0.003219291102141142, 0.005388997960835695, -0.09560899436473846, -0.028616206720471382, -0.021129673346877098, -0.02104552835226059, -0.03876148536801338, -0.011080780066549778, -0.0024898815900087357, 0.08574660122394562, -0.01780427247285843, 0.026817817240953445, -0.042418353259563446, -0.01682904176414013, 0.019171947613358498, -0.05046887323260307, 0.05788828432559967, 0.0041892267763614655, -0.0014719754690304399, -0.006832831539213657, 0.00666048051789403, -0.04486990347504616, -0.02967223897576332, 0.01907235011458397, 0.030700888484716415, 0.05906396359205246, 0.008771209046244621, 0.02732064574956894, 0.004081134218722582, -0.03119167871773243, 0.051963694393634796, -0.00674345251172781, -0.0034098285250365734, -0.026122551411390305, -0.028192773461341858, -0.000635258387774229, -0.02398029714822769, 0.018565669655799866, -0.0342862606048584, 0.020641982555389404, 0.05247526988387108, -0.005851177964359522, 0.03204513341188431, 0.009297335520386696, -0.0073468685150146484, 0.0348060205578804, -0.001112755504436791, 0.007768288720399141, 0.040267571806907654, -0.016818542033433914, -0.034556664526462555, 0.024306030943989754, -0.008921781554818153, -0.0660138949751854, -0.008091007359325886, 0.03206908330321312, -0.02907574735581875, -0.044887520372867584, 0.0037612912710756063, 0.014716515317559242, -0.011004304513335228, 0.005366606637835503, 0.03188313916325569, 0.003995738923549652, 0.026142053306102753, 0.009051417000591755, -0.015370907261967659, 0.04261019080877304, -0.027185862883925438, 0.047291480004787445, 0.027041759341955185, 0.003218193305656314, 0.019499005749821663, -0.02103986218571663, 0.01775847189128399, 0.0240912027657032, 0.05211789160966873, -0.008880043402314186, 0.04488445445895195, -0.034671615809202194, -0.01692383363842964, 0.003743508132174611, -0.016040688380599022, 0.03710443899035454, -0.023624738678336143, 0.006430408917367458, 0.04044613614678383, -0.02768128551542759, -0.01496302429586649, -0.05902812257409096, 0.0006646874244324863, -0.0006035492406226695, 0.01859952323138714, 0.008216219954192638, 0.04733326658606529, -0.02278650924563408, 0.004557650536298752, -0.0052195885218679905, -0.012770896777510643, 0.0037000339943915606, 0.008410520851612091, 0.04167381301522255, -0.014138984493911266, -0.015633465722203255, -0.0034068208187818527, -0.04764050990343094, -0.026749752461910248, -0.033628199249506, 0.028510132804512978, 0.044013846665620804, 0.010679771192371845, -0.029601020738482475, -0.02694881521165371, -0.003435248974710703, 0.03237447887659073, -0.0705081969499588, -0.014666929841041565, -0.03848594054579735, -0.011357968673110008, -0.025782868266105652, -0.031246183440089226 ]
<p>I have a lot of financial instruments and I need to rank them based on price movement "stability", i.e. instruments with with big outliers should have the lowest ranks and instruments with stable and consistent moves should have the highest ranks. To solve this issue I use the ratio of the <code>Arithmetic Mean</code> to the <code>Standard Deviation</code> for every instrument and then sort them by this ratio. But there is a problem: this method works only roughly and some "bad" instruments have higher ranks than "good" instruments.</p> <p>Are there are different approaches for ranking?</p> <p>For data points I use $\ln(\text{High} / \text{Low})$ and period is 750 data points for every instrument.</p>
36,229
[ 0.0005181343294680119, -0.009668481536209583, -0.018347274512052536, -0.025173431262373924, -0.01195886917412281, 0.023611076176166534, 0.0025472973939031363, -0.03633393347263336, 0.014976286329329014, -0.04117016866803169, 0.024134764447808266, 0.02305363491177559, 0.06212027370929718, 0.06004089489579201, -0.0022063578944653273, -0.020648466423153877, -0.014696383848786354, 0.021810058504343033, 0.0002844972477760166, -0.059460658580064774, 0.029418405145406723, 0.014535270631313324, 0.023488832637667656, -0.018331516534090042, -0.04505108669400215, 0.02584768272936344, 0.015925336629152298, 0.01461189053952694, -0.006643646862357855, 0.03441304340958595, -0.06349169462919235, -0.04560086503624916, 0.0032455569598823786, -0.003067338140681386, 0.020726345479488373, 0.02248566411435604, 0.014405841939151287, -0.015740886330604553, -0.06513702124357224, 0.02877306565642357, -0.033469315618276596, -0.02983156405389309, -0.014357633888721466, 0.013442572206258774, 0.01796770468354225, 0.0210588201880455, 0.03621069714426994, -0.03855227306485176, 0.0328153520822525, -0.05907706916332245, 0.06570320576429367, -0.01388857327401638, -0.0005731109413318336, 0.05120375007390976, -0.03670184686779976, -0.02520694211125374, 0.03226820006966591, 0.05407823622226715, -0.01249992847442627, -0.04160042852163315, -0.013412201777100563, -0.021029161289334297, 0.013112743385136127, 0.011720995418727398, -0.011230209842324257, 0.03492337465286255, -0.005719016771763563, 0.003788101254031062, 0.03929280862212181, 0.004421505145728588, -0.024748152121901512, 0.014933330938220024, 0.009134375490248203, -0.027996709570288658, 0.02821207605302334, -0.015365015715360641, 0.03177405148744583, 0.017214220017194748, 0.06879112869501114, 0.04545299708843231, -0.014256821945309639, 0.027445007115602493, -0.011234988458454609, 0.039475515484809875, 0.031586602330207825, -0.03151072934269905, 0.09058961272239685, -0.053449999541044235, 0.019810868427157402, 0.04783767834305763, -0.005371464882045984, -0.03710377216339111, 0.04233928769826889, 0.0012094085104763508, -0.04146503657102585, -0.010585560463368893, 0.0035532284528017044, 0.017136014997959137, -0.0032752652186900377, -0.00864112563431263, 0.017995918169617653, -0.06617440283298492, 0.0061942883767187595, 0.04793268069624901, 0.02965538203716278, 0.011796553619205952, -0.04041189327836037, -0.018794016912579536, -0.029892990365624428, -0.011129584163427353, 0.007514846511185169, -0.02259697951376438, 0.02025148645043373, 0.01504240557551384, -0.01661188155412674, 0.013622515834867954, -0.028448406606912613, -0.0508880615234375, -0.007160900626331568, 0.037012677639722824, 0.026834387332201004, -0.027300884947180748, 0.020731061697006226, -0.017177777364850044, -0.05184413492679596, -0.01446259394288063, 0.009668500162661076, -0.007286478765308857, -0.09236112982034683, 0.03775115683674812, -0.007485738955438137, -0.0035488265566527843, 0.0829601064324379, -0.02095814049243927, 0.06398805975914001, 0.009237178601324558, -0.08885630965232849, -0.07921085506677628, 0.07542279362678528, 0.01730182208120823, 0.048458389937877655, -0.0682232677936554, -0.00030185465584509075, 0.08572576195001602, 0.02458159811794758, 0.03878016024827957, 0.025358321145176888, 0.06098911538720131, 0.03483278676867485, 0.030236368998885155, -0.027342986315488815, -0.013049333356320858, 0.0036447453312575817, -0.04962468519806862, 0.01610187627375126, -0.03803899884223938, 0.019198285415768623, 0.01691935770213604, -0.044743362814188004, -0.010539659298956394, 0.02538524568080902, 0.0016990990843623877, -0.032695330679416656, -0.013976234942674637, 0.019619937986135483, 0.0028748249169439077, 0.03325384855270386, 0.03922171890735626, 0.04506896063685417, -0.02697783149778843, 0.006514735985547304, 0.006275281775742769, 0.017244458198547363, 0.0154789499938488, 0.05631374195218086, -0.02734946273267269, 0.015498410910367966, -0.04123736172914505, -0.008060703985393047, 0.02244458720088005, -0.03885326534509659, -0.03795664384961128, -0.047391127794981, 0.0093149458989501, 0.01755572482943535, -0.00002344197127968073, -0.01428692601621151, 0.02872367948293686, 0.058097660541534424, -0.08124557882547379, -0.004884653724730015, -0.03050054796040058, -0.025050237774848938, 0.003591278102248907, -0.04465455189347267, 0.02671085298061371, -0.004420931451022625, -0.009063846431672573, -0.011761208064854145, 0.029970388859510422, 0.006863084156066179, -0.049047257751226425, 0.041984666138887405, -0.029481524601578712, 0.009287862107157707, 0.030116090551018715, 0.0010598314693197608, -0.012394110672175884, 0.04310015216469765, -0.007778658997267485, -0.03870037570595741, 0.011033879593014717, -0.01823367178440094, -0.005044204648584127, 0.009911276400089264, -0.031149040907621384, 0.0008192681707441807, -0.048091817647218704, 0.029526447877287865, 0.04881890490651131, -0.028595611453056335, 0.06857457756996155, 0.058148644864559174, -0.014702539891004562, 0.0041482229717075825, 0.010558162815868855, 0.01536731980741024, 0.0459480807185173, -0.026253055781126022, -0.003113968065008521, -0.061215512454509735, -0.032230786979198456, 0.012142271734774113, 0.04419161379337311, -0.06471070647239685, 0.03758833929896355, 0.08882799744606018, 0.020590275526046753, 0.024446269497275352, 0.027534417808055878, 0.010524975135922432, -0.03846496716141701, 0.024512434378266335, 0.023571675643324852, 0.051578838378190994, 0.011268178932368755, 0.00025816791458055377, -0.016323663294315338, 0.024847758933901787, 0.017093708738684654, 0.04358627647161484, 0.02159021608531475, 0.022565554827451706, 0.009655124507844448, -0.002024394227191806, -0.01658696122467518, 0.021934915333986282, -0.04069269821047783, -0.004374752752482891, 0.02374536171555519, -0.00048469993635080755, -0.013334112241864204, 0.03974881023168564, 0.0012079549487680197, 0.028041565790772438, 0.02483467012643814, -0.016783444210886955, 0.030435873195528984, 0.03333606943488121, -0.05854421108961105, 0.020394217222929, -0.03121374547481537, -0.007076622918248177, -0.026184357702732086, 0.036721449345350266, 0.07028543949127197, -0.01061264704912901, -0.004589983262121677, 0.017126861959695816, -0.028960764408111572, -0.013837606646120548, -0.031854815781116486, 0.0023649747017771006, -0.006546045653522015, -0.046876419335603714, -0.00736278248950839, 0.017946457490324974, -0.011800394393503666, 0.034727808088064194, -0.011517415754497051, 0.02974109724164009, 0.04513368010520935, -0.0007410119869746268, -0.02744252234697342, -0.03859807550907135, -0.029962027445435524, -0.005916554015129805, 0.007998342625796795, -0.010361062362790108, 0.0701121836900711, 0.007758588995784521, -0.01754918321967125, 0.008944829925894737, -0.023526979610323906, 0.00880584679543972, -0.02340017445385456, 0.012670383788645267, -0.014254367910325527, 0.021209174767136574, -0.015545937232673168, 0.00930801872164011, 0.014246010221540928, -0.010313279926776886, -0.07961490005254745, -0.022561606019735336, -0.021102095022797585, -0.018511442467570305, 0.034950561821460724, 0.03672563657164574, -0.037696171551942825, 0.07615610957145691, 0.05767045170068741, -0.04957710951566696, -0.040877874940633774, -0.019800888374447823, -0.016761137172579765, -0.029171355068683624, 0.01148370373994112, 0.035248611122369766, 0.008638076484203339, 0.0012340537505224347, 0.030845656991004944, 0.030277475714683533, 0.04618710279464722, -0.01860487461090088, -0.00590907409787178, 0.009352034889161587, -0.014959938824176788, -0.012816785834729671, 0.03183715045452118, 0.028017720207571983, -0.025105541571974754, 0.013655467890202999, 0.03003307618200779, 0.036986399441957474, 0.05823114514350891, -0.05848490819334984, 0.00446745753288269, -0.007970751263201237, -0.00543220853433013, -0.016241315752267838, -0.010209699161350727, 0.05657639726996422, -0.024257592856884003, -0.049655184149742126, 0.0024102400057017803, -0.001861229888163507, 0.008780758827924728, 0.01927986741065979, 0.0740184411406517, 0.033772438764572144, -0.004262452479451895, -0.008218937553465366, 0.005655304063111544, -0.03933902829885483, 0.0007250651833601296, -0.05584060400724411, -0.013829573057591915, 0.001635920605622232, 0.010060150176286697, 0.027242016047239304, -0.025623522698879242, -0.03838856518268585, 0.01751161366701126, -0.08315081894397736, -0.02420686185359955, -0.02063312567770481, 0.054900094866752625, 0.0013392348773777485, 0.029483580961823463, 0.004217993002384901, 0.011097921058535576, 0.018344653770327568, 0.0027128364890813828, -0.043962422758340836, 0.049930915236473083, -0.025704892352223396, -0.0030742024537175894, -0.0012566304067149758, -0.0022218108642846346, -0.018923664465546608, -0.019658444449305534, 0.019481806084513664, -0.028078675270080566, 0.055798087269067764, -0.020321449264883995, 0.006518520414829254, -0.04198276996612549, -0.016813017427921295, 0.00005030183820053935, -0.00572943314909935, 0.0029197479598224163, -0.017246421426534653, 0.07924393564462662, 0.02892967127263546, -0.00675823912024498, 0.0012664839159697294, -0.006832752376794815, 0.033134929835796356, 0.015604618936777115, 0.022340575233101845, -0.004252837039530277, 0.009412611834704876, -0.05174372345209122, 0.04495691508054733, 0.023774906992912292, 0.0566033199429512, 0.03718367964029312, -0.01660052314400673, -0.009783916175365448, -0.0010405646171420813, -0.028756968677043915, 0.0019639218226075172, -0.007233860436826944, 0.021953031420707703, -0.03930459916591644, 0.038215212523937225, 0.018147647380828857, -0.05249062180519104, 0.0301975067704916, 0.06199661269783974, 0.04505566507577896, 0.018364133313298225, -0.017827244475483894, -0.03864460438489914, 0.027226904407143593, -0.013418213464319706, 0.04377879947423935, 0.018016718327999115, -0.009493247605860233, 0.0007796904537826777, 0.04608287662267685, 0.003878433723002672, -0.04194534569978714, 0.004860409535467625, 0.00810836162418127, 0.04651782289147377, -0.012953091412782669, -0.004688580520451069, 0.004931882955133915, 0.014260590076446533, 0.04321584105491638, 0.06631660461425781, 0.0033798476215451956, -0.12316474318504333, 0.027910811826586723, 0.017734527587890625, 0.026467742398381233, -0.033083006739616394, -0.019421139732003212, -0.05101762339472771, -0.043924879282712936, 0.02413777820765972, -0.019205370917916298, 0.044812314212322235, -0.030986374244093895, 0.020099204033613205, -0.01654919795691967, -0.013117934577167034, -0.010515867732465267, 0.014204077422618866, 0.0006312958430498838, 0.017846880480647087, -0.02786368690431118, -0.026659473776817322, -0.05634918063879013, 0.009130979888141155, 0.028229711577296257, 0.03708197921514511, -0.011901946738362312, 0.01283734105527401, 0.020258650183677673, 0.008118324913084507, -0.03124970942735672, -0.061126139014959335, 0.04130122438073158, -0.008678527548909187, 0.01624150760471821, 0.020722201094031334, -0.000057020697568077594, -0.05757005885243416, 0.015533078461885452, 0.016528187319636345, 0.03802777826786041, 0.01463278941810131, 0.006616897881031036, 0.06225937604904175, 0.06529544293880463, 0.03500472009181976, 0.0372786745429039, 0.0643516406416893, 0.00777409365400672, 0.006779476534575224, 0.00083935383008793, 0.005106603726744652, -0.02623182162642479, -0.02048194408416748, -0.024324972182512283, -0.008167403750121593, -0.06272193789482117, 0.02703927457332611, -0.012096834369003773, 0.06226697564125061, -0.009775000624358654, 0.009951598010957241, -0.02196345292031765, 0.010081807151436806, -0.006193523760885, -0.06939984112977982, 0.004679880104959011, 0.03011924959719181, -0.012969359755516052, -0.005564569961279631, 0.03720133751630783, -0.03431585058569908, 0.008310873061418533, 0.04762820526957512, -0.037231139838695526, 0.018621578812599182, -0.04688060283660889, 0.012603537179529667, -0.03937354311347008, 0.02354210801422596, 0.07100290805101395, -0.001300615957006812, -0.024130597710609436, 0.006647101603448391, -0.024558041244745255, -0.03395838290452957, 0.015101983211934566, 0.003590891370549798, 0.04717833921313286, -0.04310070350766182, 0.016949642449617386, 0.010508145205676556, -0.015727948397397995, -0.08086105436086655, -0.06486647576093674, 0.030702397227287292, 0.040468744933605194, -0.015120464377105236, -0.011057295836508274, 0.03603820875287056, 0.0013436625013127923, 0.013467988930642605, -0.03493497893214226, 0.03113456815481186, -0.02490776963531971, -0.0075149210169911385, 0.0014858158538118005, -0.006719010882079601, 0.09293568134307861, -0.02913794293999672, -0.018922219052910805, 0.019341761246323586, 0.022702664136886597, 0.0024303097743541002, -0.01840011402964592, 0.0401117242872715, -0.0425688698887825, -0.005580142606049776, 0.005047359503805637, 0.001034317770972848, 0.019388776272535324, 0.026591606438159943, -0.01672995463013649, 0.03173118084669113, -0.004609233699738979, 0.011488811112940311, 0.014964858070015907, 0.004691226873546839, -0.02334907092154026, 0.007430586963891983, -0.022595858201384544, 0.03440072014927864, -0.015884730964899063, -0.04521310329437256, -0.02246498130261898, -0.005520365666598082, 0.007700458634644747, 0.016998523846268654, 0.058717288076877594, -0.016201233491301537, 0.0019162647658959031, -0.009478305466473103, -0.00464164512231946, 0.028936924412846565, 0.028430696576833725, 0.007468375843018293, -0.02303004078567028, 0.023988302797079086, -0.010290111415088177, -0.0507747046649456, -0.005462399683892727, -0.010298996232450008, 0.049981676042079926, 0.029270732775330544, -0.00009348234016215429, 0.03546745330095291, 0.008796250447630882, 0.04069293662905693, -0.0016957814805209637, -0.06155010685324669, 0.00413663312792778, -0.021424438804388046, 0.04661990702152252, -0.016313187777996063, 0.01765463687479496, 0.02878989838063717, 0.03137148544192314, 0.009058446623384953, 0.048109088093042374, 0.015905171632766724, 0.016633890569210052, -0.015296058729290962, -0.01988149806857109, -0.056149110198020935, 0.06526816636323929, -0.034357693046331406, 0.07563052326440811, -0.052372392266988754, -0.046386417001485825, 0.0014466260327026248, 0.024170147255063057, -0.0030543282628059387, -0.03166114166378975, -0.021307921037077904, -0.07300259172916412, 0.007132841274142265, 0.0130887096747756, -0.023735424503684044, 0.04099425673484802, -0.0004424154758453369, 0.05932148918509483, -0.01933075301349163, 0.003710097400471568, -0.005080946255475283, -0.03077923133969307, -0.01922151818871498, -0.01451585628092289, -0.06725119054317474, 0.008624320849776268, -0.022290853783488274, -0.005624434445053339, 0.016807084903120995, -0.012049959972500801, -0.020388059318065643, -0.03047054447233677, 0.016613120213150978, -0.020629510283470154, 0.07192611694335938, -0.004059859551489353, 0.012822088785469532, -0.00020676260464824736, -0.018117723986506462, 0.14094844460487366, 0.02728244662284851, 0.000985321239568293, -0.053410787135362625, 0.02705717831850052, 0.023355623707175255, 0.04152073711156845, -0.04236158728599548, 0.022498589009046555, 0.013141900300979614, 0.03613533079624176, 0.05108639597892761, 0.03568486124277115, -0.0208358783274889, 0.006576148793101311, 0.05892717465758324, -0.04775528237223625, 0.023577354848384857, 0.0077350689098238945, 0.013637919910252094, 0.010465520434081554, 0.008558643981814384, -0.045012760907411575, 0.050846099853515625, 0.0008447740110568702, -0.00648303609341383, -0.007520134560763836, -0.037612516433000565, 0.025974512100219727, -0.018390150740742683, -0.00025745134917087853, 0.012540875002741814, 0.03706423565745354, 0.019818266853690147, 0.04124526306986809, 0.010609300807118416, 0.009966449812054634, -0.028722280636429787, 0.0046092309057712555, 0.006476431619375944, 0.006012223660945892, 0.009304465726017952, -0.009314385242760181, -0.01203142385929823, -0.04254510626196861, -0.030473733320832253, -0.055345531553030014, -0.02596968412399292, 0.02881147712469101, -0.0034223077818751335, -0.050764478743076324, 0.003205865155905485, -0.030080202966928482, -0.021143607795238495, -0.056951772421598434, 0.0007487013353966177, 0.026055796071887016, -0.040781304240226746, -0.03854158893227577, -0.027215691283345222, 0.015654683113098145, -0.04100213572382927, 0.031041279435157776, -0.002682815073058009, -0.028469914570450783, -0.016538677737116814, -0.045936476439237595, 0.03964032977819443, -0.01809990033507347, 0.019007418304681778, -0.006030849181115627, -0.02761915512382984, -0.02226397767663002, -0.014175966382026672, 0.011200597509741783, 0.03304542601108551, -0.004661634098738432, 0.035457804799079895, 0.0034890363458544016, -0.03186570852994919, -0.0432576946914196, 0.039008818566799164, -0.011101202107965946, -0.015483379364013672, -0.0252323467284441, -0.022286495193839073, 0.009825794957578182, 0.01768353581428528, 0.019603516906499863, 0.006974386516958475, -0.0004979349323548377, 0.0495026595890522, 0.015108003281056881, -0.07579038292169571, -0.005272170063108206, -0.01300983875989914, -0.03364625945687294, 0.002586419228464365, 0.016685282811522484, 0.08420849591493607, 0.02089950442314148, -0.0012043367605656385, 0.030597560107707977, 0.043532952666282654, -0.0057352399453520775, 0.025893300771713257, 0.05639389902353287, -0.02511945366859436, 0.006073497701436281, 0.039165545254945755, 0.008823439478874207, -0.04629216715693474, -0.027629727497696877, -0.010653476230800152, -0.011829671449959278, 0.012147274799644947, 0.01504245214164257, -0.03478961065411568, 0.020252922549843788, 0.004526528995484114, -0.01616642437875271, -0.03962394967675209, 0.022533584386110306, -0.03968183696269989, -0.002694713417440653, 0.004772130865603685, 0.008027632720768452, -0.03269633278250694, 0.013795853592455387, 0.0047088502906262875, 0.007038214709609747, 0.03985041379928589, 0.0036844948772341013, 0.03228229284286499, -0.02012374810874462, 0.005838545970618725, -0.011181715875864029, 0.018550196662545204, -0.041690487414598465, -0.023249372839927673, -0.004691693466156721, -0.05183282867074013, -0.04687013477087021, 0.021666545420885086, 0.0020957733504474163, -0.014269502833485603, 0.0007116679917089641, 0.006261502858251333, 0.013837490230798721, 0.023953670635819435, -0.023617176339030266, -0.03434222564101219, -0.020984046161174774, -0.011382542550563812, 0.02114315889775753, -0.01635262556374073, 0.02741839550435543, -0.007652731612324715, 0.003105924464762211, 0.005451096221804619, 0.06161268427968025, 0.003734119236469269, -0.008994813077151775, -0.017033936455845833, 0.00995951984077692, 0.024333763867616653, -0.01020718738436699, 0.012980766594409943, 0.08341103047132492, 0.005804531741887331, -0.0321694016456604, -0.015110419131815434, -0.03559189289808273, 0.015068825334310532, -0.030462397262454033, -0.018326405435800552, -0.0018380674300715327, -0.0527513325214386, 0.0481763519346714, -0.02793235518038273, -0.002805002499371767, 0.02299525775015354, -0.024185292422771454, 0.00024494188255630434, -0.010238665156066418, 0.004966549575328827, -0.04684590548276901, -0.019423794001340866, -0.04014800488948822, 0.015539987944066525, 0.015396779403090477, 0.01675974577665329, 0.03200411796569824, 0.024721285328269005, 0.00015952083049342036, 0.0021981103345751762, -0.027653412893414497, 0.02750825136899948, 0.011305331252515316, -0.07845643162727356, 0.008224193938076496, -0.05337834730744362, -0.002793712541460991, 0.054087039083242416, -0.007928231731057167, 0.004138411488384008, -0.0036013899371027946, 0.00008382881787838414, -0.01652379520237446, 0.04205281659960747, -0.022325195372104645, 0.00701036537066102, -0.02705633081495762, -0.009535149671137333, 0.03579998388886452, 0.001732116797938943, 0.030793141573667526, 0.010507283732295036, 0.03724462538957596, -0.020368000492453575, -0.01211156602948904, -0.01995961368083954, -0.0399712398648262, -0.002721689874306321, -0.014631276950240135, -0.009316911920905113, 0.014699699357151985, -0.01572565548121929, -0.0019655225332826376, 0.022569190710783005, -0.011730366386473179, 0.03321193903684616, -0.017084430903196335, -0.0031119249761104584, -0.022355379536747932, 0.0024246657267212868, -0.02589213103055954, -0.010712698101997375, 0.05677272006869316, 0.0014856786001473665, -0.030475003644824028, -0.008844975382089615, 0.01991160959005356, -0.022515302523970604, -0.03839443624019623, -0.005583198741078377, 0.010625110007822514, 0.04086035117506981, -0.02033013291656971, 0.029413416981697083, 0.0019736052490770817, -0.020476384088397026, 0.005847931373864412, -0.0843849703669548, 0.025500813499093056, 0.046737346798181534, -0.0022409113589674234, -0.014650184661149979, 0.002631645416840911, -0.03388853743672371, 0.004317421931773424, 0.03874191269278526, 0.022859947755932808, -0.0013598189689218998, -0.0002243944036308676, -0.01196109689772129, 0.0394948348402977, -0.06221224367618561, 0.027988504618406296, -0.039657361805438995, -0.040721241384744644, -0.02098887600004673, -0.017289025709033012, 0.000047416418965440243, -0.005448374431580305, -0.02906353585422039, -0.021326866000890732, -0.003146740607917309, 0.0015044613974168897, 0.020406512543559074, 0.0058194538578391075, -0.016403667628765106, -0.05066811293363571, 0.04985586926341057, 0.006126601714640856, -0.018411559984087944, 0.023226266726851463, -0.007447393145412207, -0.07141517102718353, 0.029783278703689575, -0.04784797877073288, -0.04408801347017288, -0.003577394410967827, 0.02311379835009575, -0.012643027119338512, -0.06034607067704201, 0.009189442731440067, 0.030193820595741272, -0.04411766305565834, -0.010860949754714966, 0.01542982179671526, 0.012605768628418446, 0.023198837414383888, 0.028199002146720886, 0.03601274639368057, 0.04026796668767929, 0.03003634512424469, 0.003966891672462225, -0.010767636820673943, 0.04376234486699104, -0.006383135449141264, -0.0016176465433090925, 0.0024585132487118244, -0.017589719966053963, 0.020830783993005753, 0.008383679203689098, 0.037041034549474716, 0.008150767534971237, -0.003243559505790472, 0.022844506427645683, -0.015975909307599068, -0.006410286296159029, 0.018558017909526825, -0.025530241429805756, 0.03776227682828903, -0.03320089727640152, 0.003664538497105241, -0.04851916804909706, 0.007642763666808605, 0.022113023325800896, 0.0193732101470232, -0.01856095716357231, 0.009956898167729378, -0.036692455410957336, 0.01119791530072689, -0.012758429162204266, 0.020692117512226105, 0.013074052520096302, -0.029574306681752205, 0.024364540353417397, -0.022260766476392746, -0.00012621974747162312, -0.015979530289769173, -0.027709050104022026, -0.05746033042669296, -0.04018687456846237, 0.0022679737303406, -0.022256942465901375, 0.031111134216189384, -0.02556476555764675, -0.027849262580275536, 0.00522912060841918, 0.046131111681461334, -0.044893089681863785, -0.019474199041724205, -0.03428833186626434, -0.004844281822443008, -0.020255310460925102, -0.023819567635655403 ]
<p>A co-worker has asked me to help setup a spreadsheet that is used in the analysis of customer care emails. In particular, we are looking at three categories - the assignment of meta-data, content and communication skills.</p> <p>A typical example question may be:</p> <p>"How well is the email tailored towards the customers questions?" "How well did the employee answer the customers questions?"</p> <p>I'm not a statistician but have conducted a few surveys in the past. After seeing the initial survey, which was basically an ad-hoc collection of questions combined with varying scaling mechanisms for each question. I figured the first step would be to iterate the goals and work back from there; otherwise I'd be basically devising my own methods from scratch, which feels a little flakey. All this led me to re-design the survey using the Likert scale due to it's simplicity in implementation and analysis. </p> <p>However, without a deep statistical background I'm finding it hard to validate why it is better to use a proven methodology than a collection of different scales and measurements aggregated into a single number.</p> <p>How can I convince them of the benefits if using a 'methodology'/scale such as Likert rather than various choice of measurements?</p>
73,754
[ -0.053322236984968185, -0.009228615090250969, 0.00011088956671301275, -0.00270239170640707, 0.040759503841400146, 0.014708355069160461, 0.012134009040892124, 0.005522522144019604, 0.012035149149596691, 0.011299471370875835, 0.036921609193086624, 0.01801128126680851, 0.03807395324110985, 0.010969352908432484, 0.022159645333886147, 0.01875995099544525, -0.018043488264083862, 0.029565395787358284, -0.03496389091014862, -0.012624319642782211, -0.004109397996217012, 0.009730908088386059, -0.00404964666813612, -0.036642078310251236, -0.006691538263112307, 0.007928481325507164, 0.024075932800769806, -0.04829962179064751, -0.006861369125545025, -0.0015133112901821733, -0.0043225535191595554, 0.006188640370965004, 0.01584140956401825, 0.011958724819123745, 0.04853928089141846, 0.013609284535050392, -0.020612802356481552, 0.014961181208491325, 0.006456171162426472, 0.043837159872055054, -0.025320662185549736, -0.00917899701744318, 0.005501612089574337, -0.0172165185213089, -0.021877681836485863, -0.0054022166877985, -0.0656752958893776, -0.017103048041462898, 0.015674151480197906, -0.04513733461499214, 0.07437613606452942, 0.041689373552799225, 0.04118969663977623, 0.05126640200614929, -0.012820218689739704, -0.011081240139901638, 0.04963793233036995, 0.03168840333819389, -0.006490376777946949, -0.03537044674158096, -0.02251456305384636, -0.011949771083891392, 0.018196504563093185, -0.02788999117910862, -0.014336355961859226, 0.0598643533885479, 0.016885748133063316, 0.030128993093967438, 0.05447804927825928, -0.010804468765854836, 0.035749178379774094, 0.0422033853828907, 0.026039734482765198, 0.002126450650393963, 0.019350098446011543, -0.034279026091098785, 0.011856037192046642, -0.013675294816493988, 0.06645011901855469, 0.047269996255636215, -0.006565890274941921, 0.028735749423503876, -0.0033453358337283134, 0.06738998740911484, -0.008839916437864304, -0.032664038240909576, 0.08245846629142761, -0.014148557558655739, 0.004590347874909639, 0.023056138306856155, 0.019957268610596657, 0.008400527760386467, 0.022082503885030746, 0.04160679504275322, 0.00015929574146866798, 0.025362186133861542, -0.04844096675515175, 0.0376834012567997, 0.007468183990567923, -0.017245974391698837, 0.013179657980799675, -0.020389588549733162, 0.0013586495770141482, 0.032256029546260834, -0.010254237800836563, 0.005026484373956919, -0.033321984112262726, 0.007391638588160276, -0.007661939132958651, -0.04255830869078636, 0.021335991099476814, -0.003915803506970406, 0.030421681702136993, 0.0030198448803275824, 0.044449809938669205, 0.006695559248328209, 0.004817829001694918, -0.017008069902658463, 0.08141037076711655, 0.04876624792814255, 0.015496702864766121, -0.05808470398187637, 0.04217403754591942, -0.03246001526713371, -0.017465827986598015, 0.011690260842442513, -0.03361673653125763, -0.00918720755726099, -0.003099376568570733, 0.022225849330425262, -0.008756527677178383, 0.016352491453289986, 0.014690857380628586, 0.005087697878479958, -0.021541418507695198, 0.021002691239118576, -0.10050379484891891, -0.06656281650066376, 0.00439059641212225, 0.018606461584568024, 0.02144039236009121, -0.02575245313346386, -0.02980971708893776, 0.030448757112026215, 0.016236476600170135, -0.00039074174128472805, 0.03221939876675606, 0.0067181093618273735, 0.02069757506251335, -0.002913674572482705, -0.03692549094557762, -0.01875418797135353, -0.03154368698596954, -0.04184608533978462, -0.026806263253092766, -0.05591359734535217, 0.016081295907497406, 0.006742801982909441, -0.004630986135452986, -0.027145732194185257, -0.01499268226325512, 0.025993531569838524, -0.03167831897735596, -0.00024630900588817894, 0.03356997296214104, 0.028239484876394272, 0.05856058746576309, 0.0043478854931890965, -0.008998727425932884, 0.004712886642664671, 0.011878668330609798, 0.0015074425609782338, 0.06177293509244919, -0.01875809207558632, 0.04359691962599754, -0.0015719231450930238, 0.013348621316254139, -0.031494539231061935, 0.01187788788229227, -0.025105193257331848, -0.021941065788269043, -0.05762159451842308, -0.027829762548208237, 0.014365053735673428, 0.021750975400209427, 0.05222443491220474, -0.0026760639157146215, -0.022416191175580025, 0.05749150365591049, -0.03109912760555744, -0.0712445080280304, -0.08740612864494324, 0.04062508046627045, 0.003756376914680004, -0.013079916127026081, 0.0031336285173892975, -0.021444400772452354, 0.00783924013376236, -0.008732741698622704, -0.019256362691521645, 0.016899963840842247, 0.011460753157734871, 0.038800161331892014, -0.02802559733390808, -0.012205604463815689, 0.05784187465906143, 0.0008297339081764221, -0.039943791925907135, 0.019239060580730438, -0.00103771744761616, -0.08591388165950775, -0.0167919360101223, -0.04979422688484192, 0.006590124219655991, 0.003756927093490958, -0.054952554404735565, 0.005783296190202236, 0.031345952302217484, -0.04444670304656029, 0.04657287150621414, -0.025045596063137054, 0.11149799823760986, 0.03031161241233349, -0.022092491388320923, 0.005763564724475145, 0.004569866228848696, 0.030571075156331062, 0.036538269370794296, -0.0033469912596046925, -0.00975868571549654, -0.053281914442777634, -0.011999748647212982, 0.05983841419219971, 0.03824916109442711, -0.011102026328444481, 0.0004217371460981667, 0.03811128810048103, 0.039821792393922806, -0.011387474834918976, -0.008104931563138962, -0.019862422719597816, 0.0015143598429858685, 0.012960040010511875, 0.030490124598145485, 0.006244004238396883, 0.024884428828954697, -0.012378523126244545, 0.020906008780002594, -0.02582331746816635, 0.0564192458987236, 0.0144949397072196, 0.01927630603313446, 0.015675857663154602, 0.0014703450724482536, -0.024689646437764168, 0.016036346554756165, 0.0164780393242836, -0.05238296091556549, 0.002279528882354498, 0.04583831503987312, 0.006957008503377438, -0.019132398068904877, 0.028521357104182243, -0.01357725728303194, 0.013923789374530315, 0.045645080506801605, -0.025886159390211105, -0.007029373198747635, 0.016918526962399483, -0.021887805312871933, 0.028454333543777466, -0.05783470347523689, -0.030084846541285515, -0.039551395922899246, 0.002720141550526023, 0.02356589026749134, -0.0032101122196763754, 0.036065470427274704, -0.008088717237114906, 0.005972180515527725, 0.020002761855721474, 0.0027930140495300293, -0.012314054183661938, 0.0068068476393818855, -0.05368490517139435, -0.05581188201904297, -0.012574614956974983, -0.0020137750543653965, 0.03488953039050102, -0.006528536323457956, -0.00486220046877861, 0.04467175155878067, 0.009383898228406906, -0.05225430056452751, 0.010644217021763325, -0.02342904359102249, 0.02622263692319393, 0.02169533260166645, -0.013295944780111313, 0.047444310039281845, -0.003945614211261272, -0.026886004954576492, 0.03840994834899902, -0.046415284276008606, -0.0548824667930603, -0.011489265598356724, -0.001566303544677794, -0.0009040414006449282, 0.002938918536528945, 0.019927147775888443, -0.01222041342407465, -0.02186421863734722, -0.040556810796260834, -0.03434882313013077, -0.03040056861937046, 0.0024588340893387794, -0.02460836060345173, 0.06212008744478226, 0.015020446851849556, -0.030891310423612595, 0.06804676353931427, 0.041114404797554016, -0.014197464101016521, -0.040033068507909775, -0.026899633929133415, -0.01237949077039957, -0.009825319051742554, 0.06454096734523773, 0.03628921136260033, -0.026076747104525566, -0.01417548581957817, 0.008514022454619408, 0.01858503930270672, 0.04026467353105545, -0.01017781812697649, -0.026617074385285378, -0.023416412994265556, 0.026367073878645897, -0.0040077222511172295, 0.005365805700421333, 0.03040945529937744, -0.07705856114625931, -0.011367050930857658, 0.008155408315360546, 0.018832571804523468, 0.00902659073472023, -0.04726298153400421, 0.011779260821640491, -0.008811467327177525, 0.02136903628706932, 0.00018790106696542352, 0.007181058172136545, 0.01815413497388363, -0.018325651064515114, 0.019513709470629692, 0.006325421389192343, 0.021543391048908234, -0.02230054698884487, -0.018701424822211266, 0.10203060507774353, 0.029279155656695366, 0.009550056420266628, -0.014509880915284157, 0.004842682275921106, -0.023725567385554314, 0.028398511931300163, -0.015420240350067616, -0.023654775694012642, 0.022775039076805115, 0.056784022599458694, 0.0527610220015049, -0.008188683539628983, -0.033280860632658005, -0.0021491663064807653, -0.08132358640432358, 0.000056657772802282125, -0.05286110192537308, 0.08205007761716843, -0.01944015920162201, 0.04310059919953346, 0.04001206159591675, 0.007402956485748291, -0.03493950515985489, 0.02269730344414711, -0.04661962389945984, 0.030876770615577698, -0.03516748547554016, 0.025642134249210358, 0.03199765831232071, 0.00232902355492115, 0.010660703293979168, 0.024014916270971298, -0.019917108118534088, -0.011857853271067142, 0.04044146463274956, -0.001923231640830636, -0.00028813016251660883, -0.024561915546655655, 0.027868350967764854, -0.01158203836530447, 0.017835596576333046, -0.0037373891100287437, -0.00800798088312149, 0.03622495383024216, -0.00929473340511322, 0.012747167609632015, -0.04186473786830902, -0.03416157513856888, -0.011289850808680058, -0.0005161911249160767, 0.041700102388858795, -0.030441440641880035, 0.00207080808468163, -0.024803519248962402, 0.046571001410484314, 0.017987484112381935, 0.014789069071412086, 0.008130284026265144, -0.008660323917865753, -0.02307620830833912, -0.05053737387061119, -0.03172822669148445, 0.027284130454063416, 0.01878751628100872, -0.011390041559934616, -0.02053998038172722, 0.06211547181010246, 0.02555258944630623, -0.04588781297206879, 0.015315957367420197, 0.04084722325205803, 0.03334897384047508, -0.028031665831804276, -0.026730433106422424, -0.027473216876387596, 0.006444379221647978, -0.04345222935080528, 0.04101405665278435, 0.03675226494669914, 0.032762881368398666, -0.0000688635409460403, 0.04406821355223656, -0.0193911325186491, -0.05370818451046944, 0.007176779676228762, 0.009473235346376896, 0.006871901918202639, 0.01690591871738434, -0.033388085663318634, 0.0006750546745024621, 0.06075787916779518, 0.046836335211992264, 0.011735384352505207, -0.0065374430269002914, -0.10951639711856842, 0.024810438975691795, 0.020248357206583023, 0.02625276707112789, -0.0501202829182148, 0.010784586891531944, 0.003956480883061886, -0.01472447905689478, 0.03678403049707413, -0.06337820738554001, 0.02659054845571518, -0.02506684511899948, 0.03566843643784523, -0.06790200620889664, 0.009184908121824265, -0.036350492388010025, 0.035437848418951035, -0.013943870551884174, 0.01577623561024666, -0.005833231844007969, -0.01861441135406494, -0.03669434040784836, 0.014451889321208, 0.01617930456995964, 0.08603227138519287, -0.008749810978770256, -0.011170751415193081, 0.027345236390829086, -0.009844756685197353, -0.012500747106969357, -0.055402304977178574, -0.013485646806657314, 0.017808714881539345, -0.011680345982313156, 0.0317792110145092, -0.013575881719589233, -0.0490318238735199, 0.0022826658096164465, -0.006578706204891205, 0.030705051496624947, 0.007806697394698858, -0.033561598509550095, 0.048556115478277206, 0.05918072164058685, 0.020521342754364014, 0.050597723573446274, 0.008563860319554806, -0.0386095866560936, 0.020031940191984177, -0.038322899490594864, 0.008926387876272202, -0.019607065245509148, -0.016549987718462944, -0.04507473111152649, 0.0022942866198718548, -0.02331528253853321, 0.020715484395623207, 0.03612581267952919, 0.025872012600302696, -0.059150390326976776, -0.051405902951955795, -0.003784073982387781, -0.005132270511239767, 0.02104291506111622, 0.006188431289047003, 0.028031693771481514, 0.017107287421822548, 0.01390509121119976, -0.029752643778920174, 0.003796040080487728, -0.033544354140758514, -0.00309545430354774, 0.012159226462244987, -0.023498358204960823, -0.016175510361790657, -0.05780686065554619, -0.022149188444018364, 0.028912127017974854, -0.03487756848335266, 0.05180013179779053, -0.03249756246805191, 0.011586129665374756, -0.006186226382851601, -0.027189213782548904, 0.0011677825823426247, 0.006393957417458296, 0.012223314493894577, 0.025066353380680084, -0.009635521098971367, 0.013972414657473564, -0.03763105347752571, -0.03280356898903847, -0.06878122687339783, -0.010984672233462334, 0.032483406364917755, 0.020038116723299026, 0.008156456984579563, -0.014911411330103874, -0.0021904222667217255, -0.0018992326222360134, -0.03034416399896145, -0.009129575453698635, 0.05839073657989502, 0.015470034442842007, -0.04239474982023239, -0.02324621006846428, 0.011714588850736618, 0.04807808995246887, -0.020279567688703537, 0.009049848653376102, 0.013894909992814064, 0.011898788623511791, 0.010133219882845879, -0.004200287628918886, -0.0039030162151902914, -0.04447105899453163, -0.0513448566198349, -0.03005380928516388, -0.008359570987522602, 0.03955264762043953, -0.035219911485910416, 0.003573867492377758, -0.005601559765636921, -0.04484303295612335, -0.045385368168354034, -0.026936816051602364, 0.015341382473707199, 0.01651555299758911, -0.009195638820528984, -0.03789685294032097, 0.027360791340470314, -0.039102789014577866, 0.01569700986146927, 0.01968947984278202, 0.01921815052628517, -0.019400080665946007, 0.004955983255058527, 0.030778875574469566, 0.0147874029353261, 0.02101987786591053, -0.02750011347234249, -0.021711328998208046, 0.029410241171717644, 0.011831439100205898, -0.0008142353617586195, 0.010984603315591812, 0.0430230014026165, 0.0029811731074005365, -0.014172506518661976, -0.003821875900030136, -0.00686308927834034, 0.0441938079893589, 0.026897622272372246, 0.05220973491668701, 0.07082073390483856, -0.02062530443072319, -0.011449865065515041, -0.03058840148150921, 0.010011543519794941, -0.0480596087872982, 0.03827524930238724, 0.06484878063201904, 0.006210536230355501, -0.008954886347055435, 0.005597782786935568, 0.021302681416273117, 0.05890960618853569, -0.0001558625663165003, 0.04724809154868126, 0.02460239641368389, 0.012963736429810524, -0.05867379158735275, -0.040064092725515366, 0.014276410453021526, -0.05081590637564659, 0.007063253317028284, -0.018885450437664986, -0.03583596274256706, -0.0004496056935749948, 0.025661107152700424, -0.0390455424785614, -0.004756641574203968, 0.03120114654302597, -0.054177697747945786, 0.0071806227788329124, 0.048780445009469986, -0.008073687553405762, 0.030189210548996925, -0.026291370391845703, 0.01709381677210331, -0.011351313441991806, -0.0015352863119915128, -0.007326077204197645, -0.08587352931499481, -0.01993762142956257, 0.015505927614867687, -0.054955992847681046, 0.005250789225101471, -0.0033564537297934294, -0.02259916625916958, -0.00609508715569973, -0.03047645278275013, 0.003049186896532774, -0.0025111755821853876, 0.006627519614994526, -0.03566547483205795, 0.04055619239807129, 0.006934105418622494, 0.03617842495441437, 0.02790730446577072, -0.0019514355808496475, 0.1159081906080246, 0.09940003603696823, 0.029828127473592758, -0.05462397262454033, 0.06355147063732147, 0.00920720025897026, 0.02152160555124283, -0.03353993222117424, 0.052251603454351425, -0.018058521673083305, 0.021219199523329735, 0.030337365344166756, 0.040124308317899704, 0.007699484936892986, 0.02200928144156933, 0.07096574455499649, -0.03969946876168251, -0.03974909335374832, -0.007984288036823273, -0.004003595095127821, 0.008139231242239475, -0.04271722212433815, -0.053035199642181396, -0.0036031652707606554, 0.00012242604861967266, -0.0059888348914682865, 0.038534145802259445, -0.014988324604928493, -0.012743032537400723, 0.022649159654974937, -0.01961507834494114, 0.012370960786938667, 0.016479380428791046, 0.009324013255536556, -0.02028528042137623, -0.009029691107571125, 0.014684563502669334, -0.03329707309603691, 0.009539487771689892, 0.020198380574584007, -0.03501806780695915, -0.022489706054329872, -0.01443704403936863, 0.029218431562185287, -0.05970581993460655, -0.020889410749077797, -0.0662195086479187, -0.011831691488623619, 0.017074042931199074, -0.0056032417342066765, -0.01610620878636837, -0.019506599754095078, -0.035438939929008484, -0.033458810299634933, 0.006635170895606279, 0.028530532494187355, 0.03496742993593216, -0.031111830845475197, -0.04316762089729309, -0.035123810172080994, 0.007816341705620289, -0.05553821474313736, 0.022382671013474464, 0.049627307802438736, -0.03434382379055023, -0.01840681955218315, -0.017588743939995766, -0.011147045530378819, 0.01791698858141899, 0.0031853828113526106, 0.01217409037053585, 0.01651890203356743, -0.06256324797868729, 0.015406915917992592, 0.0060082790441811085, 0.022314077243208885, 0.0071943472139537334, -0.0024125019554048777, 0.03064696304500103, -0.034937016665935516, -0.024189898744225502, 0.04060915857553482, -0.007065427489578724, 0.008285543881356716, -0.04102255776524544, -0.0006920038140378892, 0.020928701385855675, 0.01861823908984661, 0.026272986084222794, 0.017491301521658897, -0.0008184672333300114, 0.04238378256559372, 0.002743974793702364, -0.03383682295680046, -0.008794378489255905, 0.00955363642424345, -0.09510789066553116, -0.017756812274456024, -0.002926446031779051, 0.055668771266937256, -0.001257235649973154, 0.004915938246995211, -0.007701045833528042, 0.02629251778125763, 0.005021593067795038, 0.023926829919219017, 0.020320406183600426, -0.04219523444771767, -0.004555793479084969, -0.0008614491089247167, 0.01810312829911709, -0.008001542650163174, -0.03420238196849823, -0.07569193840026855, -0.021588150411844254, 0.03765520453453064, 0.010522754862904549, -0.016902150586247444, 0.01871584542095661, -0.0042649488896131516, 0.017864229157567024, -0.014827634207904339, -0.014248862862586975, -0.029511284083127975, -0.03749404102563858, -0.03445200249552727, -0.01608438231050968, -0.011277086101472378, -0.0023926475550979376, -0.012799016200006008, 0.019706960767507553, 0.023922663182020187, 0.022037409245967865, -0.0062282513827085495, -0.04663001373410225, -0.015893474221229553, 0.005928789731115103, 0.05642778426408768, -0.03425659239292145, 0.014282136224210262, 0.028532806783914566, -0.021496469154953957, -0.016399623826146126, -0.0008956810343079269, 0.013690938241779804, -0.002601292682811618, 0.01073089987039566, -0.031235795468091965, 0.023964619264006615, 0.02590908668935299, -0.04042264074087143, -0.05205396190285683, -0.02776147797703743, -0.0022957329638302326, 0.016211779788136482, -0.00002210480124631431, 0.020314207300543785, -0.007778787054121494, -0.00236173695884645, 0.0444054938852787, 0.0515899695456028, -0.009828200563788414, -0.01241903193295002, 0.015997910872101784, -0.017331933602690697, 0.004960008896887302, 0.03698582574725151, 0.011379999108612537, 0.021931322291493416, 0.0288584865629673, -0.04353026673197746, 0.01380322314798832, -0.022535817697644234, 0.013243895024061203, -0.07239042222499847, 0.017488781362771988, -0.019675681367516518, 0.0417889803647995, -0.0008572791703045368, -0.052654508501291275, 0.004675759468227625, 0.011900568380951881, -0.027050361037254333, 0.022875629365444183, -0.02612810954451561, -0.0004729361680801958, -0.01585313491523266, -0.010577639564871788, -0.03950601816177368, 0.004301297944039106, 0.006476789712905884, 0.048405785113573074, -0.004326988942921162, 0.011119714938104153, 0.014965984039008617, -0.002255479572340846, -0.015562951564788818, 0.019312245771288872, -0.008505781181156635, -0.03480859100818634, 0.007103947456926107, -0.006421745754778385, -0.030444514006376266, 0.037088412791490555, -0.015429884195327759, 0.038184843957424164, 0.03505334630608559, 0.04023600369691849, -0.0010242701973766088, 0.020415714010596275, 0.0457640141248703, -0.018839912489056587, -0.025788383558392525, -0.014102996326982975, 0.021924933418631554, 0.04184763878583908, 0.010702740401029587, 0.022648388519883156, 0.08136619627475739, 0.007148724049329758, 0.0052667888812720776, 0.005241835955530405, -0.05423297733068466, -0.031807851046323776, 0.004833015613257885, -0.03798680379986763, 0.04138736054301262, -0.012524920515716076, 0.004815314430743456, -0.07637090235948563, -0.007327200844883919, 0.05220425873994827, 0.013508153147995472, 0.00940503180027008, 0.012763175182044506, -0.02875608578324318, -0.01645631156861782, -0.024099482223391533, 0.015300750732421875, 0.030857333913445473, -0.045510802417993546, -0.02611122466623783, -0.012141709215939045, 0.02037442848086357, -0.001885498990304768, 0.0446879006922245, 0.0332677997648716, 0.07624391466379166, -0.03816014900803566, -0.0029337245505303144, 0.023140106350183487, -0.028752880170941353, 0.016862185671925545, -0.08092695474624634, 0.0755540058016777, 0.02279796078801155, -0.035882558673620224, -0.009786267764866352, -0.035245124250650406, -0.01543541718274355, 0.02811138704419136, 0.09128811210393906, -0.008512771688401699, -0.004729142412543297, -0.03426896035671234, 0.012008567340672016, -0.009170357137918472, -0.04953259229660034, 0.022282065823674202, 0.00365044386126101, -0.005235556047409773, -0.008663346990942955, -0.007078716531395912, 0.019741399213671684, -0.02621852606534958, 0.0250167828053236, -0.024362977594137192, 0.03791158273816109, -0.01066263671964407, -0.025979211553931236, 0.03452339023351669, 0.009551807306706905, -0.02918664738535881, 0.03575313091278076, -0.023535318672657013, -0.021690407767891884, 0.052599601447582245, -0.008086616173386574, -0.027097810059785843, 0.06182072311639786, -0.0432402640581131, 0.028072066605091095, -0.010165803134441376, 0.035315342247486115, 0.0127755431458354, -0.0851437896490097, -0.023468811064958572, 0.018287450075149536, -0.03811236843466759, -0.009824905544519424, 0.07457208633422852, 0.01599607616662979, -0.010825254023075104, -0.017287440598011017, 0.0012597829336300492, 0.012979145161807537, -0.038607217371463776, -0.03211189806461334, 0.017153572291135788, 0.05567006766796112, 0.012354632839560509, 0.008432747796177864, 0.05398096516728401, -0.02823023870587349, 0.024956831708550453, 0.007467946503311396, 0.015593155287206173, -0.005005147773772478, 0.0017725361976772547, 0.02182834967970848, -0.010468094609677792, 0.01840248890221119, 0.027364559471607208, -0.01091750804334879, 0.056082963943481445, -0.039397258311510086, -0.02761542610824108, -0.04709351435303688, -0.04179002717137337, -0.06888305395841599, 0.0006456485134549439, 0.026737725362181664, 0.04837073013186455, 0.0058773718774318695, 0.009371345862746239, 0.0009061861201189458, 0.004724808502942324, 0.03401656821370125, 0.02767244540154934, 0.02261694334447384, -0.03748636692762375, 0.03619404882192612, -0.002229929668828845, -0.05797646939754486, -0.0013691018102690578, -0.005466742441058159, 0.02979925088584423, 0.004481432028114796, 0.018140895292162895, 0.017708752304315567, -0.018393652513623238, 0.002401880919933319, 0.060346245765686035, -0.038799624890089035, -0.0492078997194767, -0.04910438880324364, 0.006271309219300747, 0.00995850469917059, -0.030892515555024147 ]
<p>Suppose I am building a binary logistic regression model with around 400 variables then how weight of evidence(WOE) can be used in here? Also, I have known that WOE is helpful in dimension reduction in a model then why not go for factor analysis rather going for WOE? What should be the size of the number of variables in order to use WOE? Is there any other use of WOE in developing a model? What is the most appropriate scenario where WOE would be best suited to use?</p>
73,755
[ -0.04655919969081879, 0.012415383011102676, -0.014147381298244, -0.012715891934931278, 0.0712723359465599, 0.012559368275105953, 0.015902668237686157, -0.038469620048999786, 0.03696780651807785, -0.02072874829173088, 0.010250027291476727, 0.048492878675460815, 0.05819588899612427, 0.010271942242980003, -0.0013342349557206035, 0.017343606799840927, 0.012075645849108696, -0.002590072574093938, -0.00024092085368465632, -0.0019394340924918652, -0.016336673870682716, 0.015604461543262005, 0.03437148034572601, 0.005431944038718939, -0.010680668987333775, 0.05388256162405014, 0.04209001362323761, -0.022281484678387642, 0.022583816200494766, 0.027930524200201035, -0.016992060467600822, -0.010716716758906841, 0.00812623556703329, 0.05856190621852875, 0.009698092937469482, -0.03477633371949196, -0.016626307740807533, -0.011844802647829056, -0.03116431273519993, 0.0029789491090923548, -0.011074656620621681, -0.027233125641942024, -0.01409133616834879, 0.0063033923506736755, -0.013484960421919823, 0.007557862438261509, -0.018034392967820168, -0.06514950096607208, 0.024899153038859367, -0.03681227192282677, 0.06107467785477638, -0.00268363393843174, 0.02459200657904148, 0.03775671124458313, 0.01440074760466814, 0.014158561825752258, 0.046199820935726166, 0.06331971287727356, -0.025578893721103668, -0.018068108707666397, -0.051507093012332916, -0.046099718660116196, 0.04300084710121155, -0.029422296211123466, -0.00839700736105442, 0.05201583355665207, -0.0006565448129549623, -0.03185998275876045, 0.06061185151338577, 0.02938392385840416, 0.029679207131266594, -0.016441509127616882, 0.03503420203924179, 0.004090475384145975, -0.011808527633547783, -0.04137134179472923, 0.010291596874594688, 0.01874615252017975, 0.02867249958217144, 0.066921167075634, -0.03727898746728897, 0.007202635053545237, 0.0013686398742720485, 0.04427673667669296, 0.03093697689473629, -0.01687360554933548, 0.06309821456670761, -0.006363603286445141, 0.013349617831408978, 0.0021345126442611217, -0.02861754782497883, -0.010196513496339321, 0.03372155502438545, 0.002730107633396983, -0.0007878238684497774, 0.0042667086236178875, -0.03137797489762306, 0.029148606583476067, 0.029742304235696793, -0.003240245394408703, -0.005395909305661917, -0.032833512872457504, 0.005270587280392647, 0.0743853747844696, -0.021948901936411858, -0.013177197426557541, -0.048029035329818726, 0.01152406632900238, -0.007349069230258465, -0.051113951951265335, 0.013840913772583008, 0.0012832253705710173, 0.007078477181494236, 0.011178737506270409, 0.0060708955861628056, 0.00933791697025299, -0.0004981216043233871, -0.01570686511695385, 0.07490423321723938, 0.043766044080257416, 0.03910968080163002, -0.03728771209716797, 0.03088463842868805, -0.029283877462148666, -0.05117525905370712, 0.010094067081809044, 0.02191258780658245, -0.020662013441324234, -0.031479813158512115, 0.049067579209804535, 0.03250999003648758, -0.04904419556260109, 0.027613071724772453, 0.019411975517868996, 0.0016828528605401516, 0.02166772074997425, -0.10523340851068497, -0.06859582662582397, 0.020735368132591248, -0.03974301740527153, 0.03375630080699921, -0.025194242596626282, 0.007644412107765675, 0.02429753728210926, 0.05345367267727852, -0.00214762962423265, 0.039291609078645706, 0.024454619735479355, 0.02781514823436737, 0.0027773831970989704, -0.061238400638103485, -0.022746186703443527, -0.05710675194859505, -0.010668878443539143, -0.008041685447096825, -0.08558660745620728, 0.02677837200462818, 0.03420819714665413, -0.010634868405759335, -0.04524964466691017, -0.01321868970990181, 0.014922169968485832, -0.025138765573501587, 0.0007131851161830127, -0.03509761020541191, -0.021164296194911003, 0.05096264183521271, -0.031657904386520386, 0.02706185169517994, 0.017310941591858864, -0.007011412177234888, 0.004667916335165501, 0.052395954728126526, 0.056374337524175644, 0.01434475276619196, -0.0003045708581339568, -0.01263405941426754, -0.04152016341686249, 0.04037574306130409, 0.001093858852982521, -0.020702823996543884, -0.047588661313056946, 0.007180873770266771, 0.0053818682208657265, 0.013223161920905113, 0.04484688118100166, -0.03269336372613907, -0.01797076314687729, 0.06355058401823044, -0.028644317761063576, -0.05310293287038803, -0.022513406351208687, 0.009197755716741085, -0.005771150812506676, -0.009424432180821896, 0.021970055997371674, -0.0003956318541895598, 0.012517137452960014, -0.04980696365237236, 0.011350582353770733, -0.05978750064969063, 0.007289881352335215, 0.018388815224170685, -0.04423970356583595, 0.02418604865670204, 0.005039784591645002, -0.004319068510085344, -0.0304225143045187, 0.04557221010327339, -0.07820470631122589, -0.07168799638748169, 0.015203287824988365, -0.017670458182692528, -0.04278150945901871, -0.011872945353388786, -0.03519853577017784, 0.017220929265022278, -0.03549356386065483, -0.017745519056916237, 0.027910834178328514, -0.04641108587384224, 0.10899191349744797, 0.07851831614971161, -0.0006573756108991802, 0.015634721145033836, 0.024903960525989532, 0.011299217119812965, -0.003955816850066185, -0.024392753839492798, 0.019960518926382065, -0.04671003296971321, -0.021901370957493782, 0.024710077792406082, -0.0025314788799732924, -0.031831275671720505, 0.019499216228723526, 0.00558900972828269, -0.003156641498208046, 0.04112594947218895, 0.017472073435783386, 0.012882223352789879, -0.04682376980781555, 0.002328600035980344, 0.05354626849293709, -0.024465270340442657, 0.0076045868918299675, -0.0207302775233984, 0.013175911270081997, 0.0038713037502020597, 0.009437477216124535, -0.005015604663640261, 0.056901294738054276, -0.010478317737579346, 0.009468317963182926, -0.02484278380870819, -0.002947539323940873, 0.05796146020293236, -0.05210798233747482, 0.040375325828790665, 0.04674913361668587, 0.034435201436281204, 0.023004252463579178, 0.02327684313058853, -0.028226777911186218, 0.04592433571815491, 0.05102100968360901, -0.05211890861392021, 0.01660134829580784, 0.021167898550629616, -0.06255805492401123, 0.004567374475300312, -0.0004042210930492729, -0.02329973131418228, -0.043153658509254456, 0.027453085407614708, 0.04484626278281212, 0.017282934859395027, 0.017400607466697693, 0.010981908068060875, -0.032975807785987854, -0.010095088742673397, -0.007492853794246912, -0.01738123595714569, -0.012809102423489094, -0.05532248318195343, -0.029946157708764076, 0.0005037810187786818, 0.009535649791359901, 0.06089983507990837, -0.027684565633535385, -0.01919630356132984, -0.00051577651174739, -0.00008064966823440045, -0.00969174038618803, -0.02561582811176777, 0.009634667076170444, 0.0038890154100954533, -0.005132345482707024, -0.029094956815242767, 0.03237170726060867, -0.015769032761454582, -0.04474912956357002, -0.00912604108452797, -0.02101920358836651, -0.02639271318912506, -0.003155927872285247, 0.008454560302197933, 0.010137656703591347, 0.01744139939546585, -0.0037747223395854235, 0.02658860757946968, -0.0288307536393404, 0.008731252513825893, -0.07738527655601501, -0.06020595505833626, 0.024807158857584, -0.013058377429842949, 0.04601233825087547, -0.0054449643939733505, -0.028291767463088036, 0.06555484235286713, 0.052331287413835526, -0.03415985032916069, -0.06759200990200043, -0.012968147173523903, -0.042533647269010544, 0.019153939560055733, -0.0025431911926716566, -0.007815265096724033, 0.025132739916443825, 0.029296932741999626, -0.007166360970586538, -0.0048111602663993835, 0.021392405033111572, 0.0530051663517952, 0.007241889368742704, 0.026158243417739868, -0.02763720043003559, -0.04567461088299751, 0.015026145614683628, 0.02278854511678219, -0.043099869042634964, 0.01033566053956747, 0.00045428561861626804, 0.02790798805654049, 0.021276097744703293, -0.041557829827070236, -0.021738840267062187, 0.0016500832280144095, 0.01796727441251278, -0.021598296239972115, 0.022129761055111885, 0.021864835172891617, -0.006692246999591589, 0.04548332467675209, 0.012626626528799534, 0.03605227172374725, 0.0013606534339487553, -0.010817882604897022, -0.0039587789215147495, 0.02360762469470501, -0.0006187803228385746, -0.003109485376626253, -0.03093593940138817, 0.005865320097655058, 0.00009305464482167736, -0.020922228693962097, -0.001990544144064188, 0.026714034378528595, 0.02970954403281212, 0.007035477552562952, -0.032260868698358536, -0.045874081552028656, -0.008746526204049587, -0.04638684168457985, -0.03707278519868851, -0.026889868080615997, 0.0471920408308506, 0.0018303842516615987, 0.01892153173685074, 0.012747811153531075, -0.0019521702779456973, -0.028716275468468666, 0.0017266265349462628, -0.03237307444214821, 0.018366357311606407, -0.034389324486255646, 0.040707677602767944, 0.026285991072654724, -0.02292572520673275, 0.005181578919291496, -0.05150030180811882, -0.021285856142640114, 0.0008967550820671022, 0.04007726535201073, -0.03250812366604805, 0.018076155334711075, -0.018700947985053062, -0.0029538224916905165, -0.00501868175342679, 0.0028877349104732275, -0.003770512994378805, -0.003346713725477457, 0.021691862493753433, 0.020895594730973244, 0.001902844407595694, -0.01813814416527748, -0.016990412026643753, -0.004795874934643507, -0.02010231651365757, 0.04054095968604088, -0.019475098699331284, -0.011062302626669407, -0.041706450283527374, 0.02672954648733139, 0.010447069071233273, 0.0256107896566391, 0.03349880501627922, -0.02068985253572464, -0.00967868510633707, -0.021933406591415405, -0.022677620872855186, -0.017796000465750694, 0.01922963187098503, 0.005482968408614397, 0.005911875516176224, 0.057233184576034546, 0.012553309090435505, -0.07431571930646896, 0.009495624341070652, 0.07397034764289856, 0.03338709846138954, -0.012420861050486565, -0.025437690317630768, -0.003770791459828615, 0.025136956945061684, 0.011738344095647335, 0.02202903851866722, -0.003342516254633665, -0.011288132518529892, -0.016551652923226357, 0.01627260446548462, -0.032693054527044296, -0.04358823969960213, 0.0017526571173220873, 0.0420721210539341, 0.03349318355321884, 0.015104307793080807, -0.06946142762899399, 0.01040306780487299, 0.04541556537151337, 0.017444264143705368, 0.023795541375875473, -0.026892635971307755, -0.11270055174827576, 0.0019718275871127844, 0.02764122374355793, 0.04555492848157883, -0.03356187790632248, 0.024059247225522995, -0.003186891321092844, -0.013419517315924168, 0.032267458736896515, -0.053100526332855225, 0.0035632140934467316, -0.027025241404771805, 0.04614744335412979, -0.003430113662034273, -0.02477637305855751, -0.031782325357198715, 0.025009289383888245, 0.011451651342213154, 0.02738955058157444, 0.036232639104127884, -0.018591618165373802, -0.011377095244824886, 0.04837372899055481, -0.004000003915280104, 0.04882142320275307, 0.0038129491731524467, 0.00023689845693297684, 0.03748377040028572, 0.02359255962073803, -0.03396286442875862, -0.0472714938223362, -0.010264188051223755, 0.008125191554427147, -0.016081780195236206, 0.02908870205283165, 0.009361408650875092, -0.06344934552907944, -0.02763891965150833, 0.024629443883895874, -0.02782673016190529, -0.020365728065371513, -0.05090012028813362, 0.040968313813209534, -0.012850632891058922, 0.009486106224358082, 0.06941210478544235, 0.010834170505404472, -0.011059045791625977, 0.02946810983121395, -0.05266429856419563, 0.02314762771129608, -0.007947005331516266, -0.007084381300956011, -0.026777874678373337, 0.017760997638106346, -0.010774170979857445, 0.03775475174188614, 0.010276369750499725, 0.03192487359046936, -0.003478694474324584, -0.042027827352285385, -0.06348647177219391, -0.004241721238940954, 0.010283692739903927, -0.028531808406114578, -0.003495084820315242, 0.022305112332105637, 0.0018826286541298032, -0.015592178329825401, 0.052853941917419434, -0.0025792557280510664, 0.009767002426087856, 0.004752700682729483, -0.02520667389035225, 0.001614829758182168, -0.029982827603816986, -0.0047255102545022964, 0.048608291894197464, -0.0068286326713860035, 0.04410872235894203, 0.009953691624104977, -0.004863336216658354, 0.0009672818705439568, -0.07343993335962296, -0.004442841280251741, -0.007318731863051653, 0.02737261913716793, 0.04231278970837593, -0.030318202450871468, 0.008265983313322067, -0.007400984410196543, -0.0075632547959685326, -0.06249199062585831, -0.02732677385210991, 0.017845531925559044, -0.007343399804085493, -0.00004133235415793024, -0.024631643667817116, 0.011222689412534237, -0.022087207064032555, -0.0011324406368657947, -0.05118813365697861, 0.06660296022891998, -0.010408296249806881, 0.028783321380615234, 0.013699319213628769, -0.0016957020852714777, 0.038987185806035995, 0.009256190620362759, -0.021422678604722023, 0.0063917082734405994, -0.035887204110622406, 0.017660217359662056, 0.013121052645146847, -0.009180627763271332, -0.05304192751646042, -0.017982473596930504, -0.025274161249399185, -0.02659810334444046, 0.035123325884342194, -0.02878393419086933, 0.010242733173072338, -0.00665114214643836, -0.004214958753436804, -0.01324236299842596, -0.017123768106102943, -0.00037308779428713024, -0.02250528894364834, 0.04193836450576782, 0.004121541045606136, 0.0235796757042408, -0.01604769192636013, -0.021326187998056412, 0.04707692563533783, -0.0038596210069954395, 0.0025750037748366594, 0.02286859042942524, 0.030029483139514923, -0.012707159854471684, 0.03174639493227005, -0.018335288390517235, -0.04102693870663643, 0.03513086214661598, 0.021386917680501938, -0.03042520582675934, 0.034140270203351974, 0.05120319500565529, -0.01737120747566223, -0.03218872845172882, -0.026244420558214188, 0.03134537115693092, 0.0672730952501297, 0.0073370314203202724, 0.010918316431343555, 0.07452480494976044, -0.02436053194105625, -0.015065829269587994, -0.0008868128643371165, -0.014810754917562008, 0.010112619958817959, 0.0019343231106176972, 0.03702211007475853, 0.002608240582048893, -0.04566086456179619, 0.03685085102915764, -0.004158047027885914, 0.023368805646896362, 0.03223998099565506, -0.021404417231678963, 0.016858521848917007, 0.028602417558431625, -0.030459024012088776, -0.04659371078014374, 0.0193033330142498, -0.03755224123597145, 0.0001064213938661851, -0.010515731759369373, -0.03313182294368744, 0.04696660861372948, 0.005360912997275591, 0.013284014537930489, -0.0719745010137558, -0.055819690227508545, -0.04400181770324707, -0.005406285636126995, 0.023539366200566292, -0.02314320020377636, 0.027260106056928635, 0.003530495800077915, 0.0019112330628558993, 0.039004433900117874, -0.0008217675494961441, -0.0061880191788077354, -0.08750411123037338, -0.035085540264844894, 0.03640298172831535, -0.02611188031733036, 0.006719005759805441, -0.00561901181936264, 0.00015339275705628097, -0.008451743051409721, -0.037987980991601944, -0.008227689191699028, -0.0004407332162372768, 0.022166404873132706, 0.015342775732278824, 0.04523703083395958, -0.006741923745721579, 0.00823255069553852, 0.048839423805475235, 0.03504112362861633, 0.12305058538913727, 0.1069684848189354, 0.0258313175290823, -0.05968877673149109, 0.012895212508738041, 0.04096570238471031, -0.028657881543040276, -0.008398162201046944, 0.01741093397140503, -0.005396558437496424, 0.004625022877007723, 0.026194382458925247, 0.02754519321024418, -0.012209365144371986, -0.02308771014213562, 0.04760269075632095, -0.031106192618608475, -0.028746429830789566, -0.00023416413750965148, 0.0032509227748960257, -0.019474001601338387, -0.035629965364933014, -0.0020342813804745674, 0.007451275363564491, -0.009287547320127487, -0.04316335916519165, 0.01534021832048893, 0.012734243646264076, -0.004957788158208132, -0.052017319947481155, -0.010851734317839146, -0.013623912818729877, 0.0012565003708004951, -0.014855409041047096, -0.0035572675988078117, 0.01293468102812767, 0.010002817958593369, -0.030827343463897705, 0.01349734328687191, 0.009425923228263855, -0.04453064873814583, -0.01977355405688286, -0.014995360746979713, 0.025521334260702133, 0.007221315521746874, -0.05838190019130707, -0.04177003353834152, 0.021460257470607758, 0.02003820240497589, 0.030183803290128708, -0.009156687185168266, -0.02506968565285206, -0.003964135888963938, -0.05255959928035736, -0.008131841197609901, 0.0510680116713047, 0.038104888051748276, -0.005498482845723629, -0.042208727449178696, -0.02057819440960884, 0.03325800970196724, 0.02700677700340748, 0.04839494824409485, 0.060054339468479156, -0.030348394066095352, -0.02001921273767948, -0.015089885331690311, 0.03445783630013466, 0.014147763140499592, -0.02460004761815071, -0.02960999123752117, 0.008114144206047058, -0.03520909324288368, -0.012670462019741535, 0.026863157749176025, 0.019509704783558846, 0.010678908787667751, -0.029839839786291122, -0.030306918546557426, -0.045001380145549774, -0.035751793533563614, -0.024372033774852753, -0.022074244916439056, -0.04859336093068123, -0.042215362191200256, 0.01404732558876276, 0.0015047922497615218, 0.020101448521018028, 0.01678204908967018, 0.0012574706925079226, -0.012186191976070404, 0.020568842068314552, -0.0027270943392068148, -0.033239640295505524, 0.017738627269864082, 0.02269688993692398, -0.03768470138311386, 0.018829308450222015, 0.002764472272247076, 0.046646393835544586, 0.01899620331823826, -0.02412508986890316, 0.014156783930957317, 0.0398937426507473, -0.010153242386877537, 0.026536431163549423, 0.03511698171496391, -0.06003277748823166, -0.015435507521033287, 0.011933164671063423, -0.012373190373182297, -0.030106132850050926, -0.01670445129275322, -0.05186620354652405, -0.06548488140106201, 0.010139957070350647, -0.028676969930529594, -0.03898349404335022, 0.0017711285036057234, 0.013813057914376259, 0.03698459267616272, -0.039195574820041656, 0.021220838651061058, -0.019066592678427696, 0.02606102265417576, 0.013506895862519741, -0.02184084616601467, 0.015843315050005913, 0.015203909017145634, 0.009219124913215637, -0.013380022719502449, -0.011411714367568493, 0.03520570322871208, 0.007595879025757313, -0.019230857491493225, -0.008269966579973698, -0.0038108602166175842, 0.02855314500629902, -0.04141892492771149, -0.0009668650454841554, 0.041284188628196716, -0.049113813787698746, 0.004130878485739231, 0.07798728346824646, -0.041168373078107834, 0.024160999804735184, 0.03406931087374687, 0.024170227348804474, 0.0022566267289221287, 0.024173682555556297, -0.008475149050354958, -0.008825150318443775, 0.02052905783057213, 0.015299491584300995, -0.024340320378541946, 0.027788899838924408, 0.002316561993211508, 0.036459848284721375, -0.029207531362771988, 0.0158634502440691, 0.03765327110886574, 0.013545604422688484, -0.018631231039762497, 0.03317679464817047, -0.004577492829412222, 0.03703419864177704, 0.0008635077974759042, -0.03143152594566345, 0.03677875176072121, 0.056475572288036346, -0.016989586874842644, 0.03593597188591957, -0.00972279068082571, 0.046453122049570084, -0.08935941010713577, -0.04180317372083664, 0.06484078615903854, 0.03407914936542511, 0.03460842743515968, -0.048007331788539886, 0.05460601672530174, 0.04330495744943619, -0.04521118849515915, 0.022356297820806503, -0.018600286915898323, 0.00978798232972622, -0.04270361736416817, -0.007232739590108395, -0.02798447571694851, 0.010468102991580963, 0.008361706510186195, 0.022596867755055428, 0.02666034922003746, -0.022702930495142937, 0.017368094995617867, -0.03315064311027527, 0.00018017261754721403, 0.05030374974012375, -0.03363315761089325, -0.07453025132417679, 0.04668049141764641, -0.0406603179872036, -0.045311786234378815, 0.06467973440885544, 0.039420921355485916, 0.030937692150473595, 0.051608093082904816, 0.05727700889110565, -0.008523726835846901, 0.04448692500591278, 0.016585974022746086, -0.04110589250922203, 0.0017340517370030284, 0.0025094053708016872, 0.01911338046193123, 0.00579807348549366, -0.025272483006119728, 0.03541781008243561, 0.006351734511554241, -0.011075679212808609, 0.010829281993210316, 0.02011541835963726, -0.008126705884933472, -0.012337062507867813, -0.01683340035378933, -0.012684183195233345, -0.04116205871105194, 0.009166701696813107, 0.005664332304149866, -0.044531628489494324, 0.01748366840183735, 0.042038533836603165, 0.024873217567801476, -0.014370136894285679, 0.03554001450538635, 0.0005135656101629138, -0.0558449849486351, -0.01611233502626419, -0.020687993615865707, -0.03591243550181389, -0.02919016405940056, 0.04626781493425369, 0.007857399992644787, 0.010289360769093037, -0.03423003479838371, 0.02755783684551716, -0.052642229944467545, 0.05142459273338318, -0.05524588003754616, 0.019872866570949554, 0.04526212438941002, -0.035032495856285095, 0.02538638934493065, -0.08982329070568085, 0.055005993694067, 0.04141099005937576, -0.019563844427466393, -0.02822897583246231, -0.00013632611080538481, 0.006775280460715294, -0.00286518014036119, 0.04089337959885597, -0.001740556675940752, -0.02249814011156559, -0.035056401044130325, 0.02295355685055256, -0.026624415069818497, -0.025194084271788597, 0.022710347548127174, -0.043019864708185196, -0.0263067577034235, -0.016342943534255028, 0.0023403093218803406, 0.007113059516996145, -0.006031304132193327, 0.019815025851130486, -0.022237805649638176, 0.013326197862625122, -0.009604714810848236, 0.011676818132400513, 0.026272321119904518, -0.005667833145707846, -0.0033816760405898094, 0.05613112449645996, 0.017241310328245163, 0.032867345958948135, 0.03482498228549957, -0.00037401006557047367, -0.03948288410902023, 0.057591989636421204, 0.01213777344673872, 0.005736755207180977, 0.050093647092580795, 0.026265660300850868, 0.027997078374028206, -0.07270742952823639, 0.025103235617280006, 0.0389973409473896, -0.019345687702298164, 0.03598888963460922, 0.04896670579910278, 0.02394860051572323, 0.007798385806381702, 0.025478772819042206, 0.0038619819097220898, 0.026144668459892273, -0.030110513791441917, -0.0035201760474592447, -0.01752833090722561, 0.03956865519285202, 0.004897406790405512, 0.010406292974948883, 0.018657760694622993, 0.0067615630105137825, 0.017154503613710403, 0.012481492012739182, 0.01433792058378458, -0.013683474622666836, 0.008630664087831974, 0.014910132624208927, 0.0014715653378516436, 0.032424163073301315, 0.025552164763212204, -0.03994496166706085, 0.057897716760635376, -0.03287215530872345, -0.006973352283239365, -0.03985608369112015, -0.030558567494153976, -0.05290759354829788, 0.004421732854098082, 0.025093920528888702, 0.06777297705411911, 0.013573524542152882, 0.02003406547009945, 0.023065021261572838, -0.035393502563238144, -0.024492766708135605, -0.009371539577841759, 0.02438335120677948, -0.014597553759813309, 0.02144945226609707, -0.008052760735154152, -0.052652157843112946, -0.039576850831508636, 0.013188031502068043, -0.012101885862648487, 0.025957882404327393, 0.027814900502562523, 0.015589057467877865, -0.023515472188591957, 0.029993722215294838, 0.035031262785196304, -0.038481783121824265, -0.016953052952885628, -0.043137792497873306, 0.014346006326377392, -0.010317418724298477, -0.014511925168335438 ]
<p>Question: Assume the following classical linear normal regression model: \begin{gather*} y_{i} = \beta_1 x_{1i} + \beta_2 x_{2i} + \cdots + \beta_K x_{Ki} + e_i \\ \underbrace{\boldsymbol{y}}_{n \times 1} = \underbrace{\boldsymbol{X}}_{n \times K}\underbrace{\boldsymbol{\beta}}_{K \times 1} + \underbrace{\boldsymbol{e}}_{n \times 1} \end{gather*}</p> <p>where $e_i \sim iid \ N(0, \sigma^2)$ for $i = 1, 2, \cdots, n$ and $x_{1i} = 1$ for $i = 1, 2, \cdots, n$</p> <p>Define $\boldsymbol{\beta} = (\beta_1, \beta_2, \cdots, \beta_K)'$ and assume a noninformative prior of the form $p(\boldsymbol{\beta}, \sigma) \propto \frac{1}{\sigma}$, derive the conditional posterior pdfs for $\boldsymbol{\beta}$ and $\sigma$, that is, $p(\boldsymbol{\beta}|\sigma, \mathbf{y})$ and $p(\sigma|\boldsymbol{\beta}, \mathbf{y})$.</p> <hr> <p>I can derive the conditional posterior pdf for $p(\boldsymbol{\beta}|\sigma, \mathbf{y})$ but I am not sure how to derive it for $p(\sigma|\boldsymbol{\beta}, \mathbf{y})$. The answer to the latter is:</p> <p>$p(\sigma|\boldsymbol{\beta}, \mathbf{y})=\frac{2}{\Gamma\left(\frac{n}{2}\right)}\left(\frac{na}{2}\right)^{\frac{n}{2}} \frac{1}{\sigma^{n+1}}\exp\left[-\frac{na}{2\sigma^2}\right] $ </p> <p>where $a = \frac{1}{n}\left(\boldsymbol{y}-\boldsymbol{X}\boldsymbol{\beta}\right)'\left(\boldsymbol{y}-\boldsymbol{X}\boldsymbol{\beta}\right)$</p> <hr> <p>The following is my working to derive the posterior pdf for $p(\boldsymbol{\beta}|\sigma, \mathbf{y})$</p> <p>We have: \begin{align*} p(\boldsymbol{e}|\sigma) &amp; = \prod_{i=1}^n p(e_i) \\ &amp; = \prod_{i=1}^n (2\pi \sigma^2)^{-\frac{1}{2}}\exp\left[-\frac{1}{2\sigma^2}e_i^2\right] \\ &amp; = (2\pi \sigma^2)^{-\frac{n}{2}}\exp\left[-\frac{1}{2\sigma^2}\sum_{i=1}^n e_i^2\right] \\ &amp; = (2\pi \sigma^2)^{-\frac{n}{2}} \exp\left[-\frac{1}{2\sigma^2} \boldsymbol{e'}\boldsymbol{e}\right] \end{align*} Since $p(\boldsymbol{y}) = p(\boldsymbol{e})\left|\frac{\partial \boldsymbol{e'}}{\partial \boldsymbol{y}} \right|$ and $\boldsymbol{y} = \boldsymbol{X}\boldsymbol{\beta} + \boldsymbol{e} \Longleftrightarrow \boldsymbol{e} = \boldsymbol{y} - \boldsymbol{X}\boldsymbol{\beta}$, then $\frac{\partial \boldsymbol{e'}}{\partial \boldsymbol{y}} = \frac{\partial \boldsymbol{y'}}{\partial \boldsymbol{y}} = \boldsymbol{I}_{n}$. Hence, $\left|\frac{\partial \boldsymbol{e'}}{\partial \boldsymbol{y}} \right| = \left| \boldsymbol{I}_{n}\right| = 1$. So: \begin{align*} p(\boldsymbol{y}|\boldsymbol{\beta}, \sigma) &amp; = p(\boldsymbol{e}) \\ &amp; = (2\pi \sigma^2)^{-\frac{n}{2}} \exp\left[-\frac{1}{2\sigma^2}\left(\boldsymbol{y}-\boldsymbol{X}\boldsymbol{\beta}\right)'\left(\boldsymbol{y}-\boldsymbol{X}\boldsymbol{\beta}\right)\right] \ \ \text{since} \ \ \boldsymbol{e} = \boldsymbol{y} - \boldsymbol{X}\boldsymbol{\beta} \end{align*} Thus we have: $$L(\boldsymbol{\beta}, \sigma|\boldsymbol{y}) \propto (\sigma^2)^{-\frac{n}{2}} \exp\left[-\frac{1}{2\sigma^2}\left(\boldsymbol{y}-\boldsymbol{X}\boldsymbol{\beta}\right)'\left(\boldsymbol{y}-\boldsymbol{X}\boldsymbol{\beta}\right)\right]$$ Given $p(\boldsymbol{\beta}, \sigma) \propto \frac{1}{\sigma}$, we have: \begin{align*} p(\boldsymbol{\beta}, \sigma|\boldsymbol{y}) &amp; \propto L(\boldsymbol{\beta}, \sigma|\boldsymbol{y}) \times p(\boldsymbol{\beta}, \sigma) \\ &amp; \propto \frac{1}{\sigma^n}\exp\left[-\frac{1}{2\sigma^2}\left(\boldsymbol{y}-\boldsymbol{X}\boldsymbol{\beta}\right)'\left(\boldsymbol{y}-\boldsymbol{X}\boldsymbol{\beta}\right)\right] \times \frac{1}{\sigma} \\ &amp; = \frac{1}{\sigma^{n+1}} \exp\left\{-\frac{1}{2\sigma^2}\left[(n-K)\widehat{\sigma}^2 + (\boldsymbol{\beta} - \boldsymbol{b})'\boldsymbol{X}'\boldsymbol{X}(\boldsymbol{\beta}-\boldsymbol{b})\right] \right\} \\ &amp; \text{where} \ \ \widehat{\sigma}^2 = \frac{1}{n-K} (\boldsymbol{y} - \boldsymbol{X}\boldsymbol{b})'(\boldsymbol{y}-\boldsymbol{X}\boldsymbol{b}) \ \ \text{and} \ \ \boldsymbol{b} = (\boldsymbol{X}'\boldsymbol{X})^{-1}\boldsymbol{X}'\boldsymbol{y} \\ &amp; = \underbrace{\frac{1}{\sigma^K} \exp\left[-\frac{1}{2\sigma^2}(\boldsymbol{\beta} - \boldsymbol{b})'\boldsymbol{X}'\boldsymbol{X}(\boldsymbol{\beta}-\boldsymbol{b})\right]}_{f^n(\boldsymbol{\beta}|\sigma, \boldsymbol{y})} \underbrace{\frac{1}{\sigma^{n-K+1}} \exp\left[-\frac{(n-K)\widehat{\sigma}^2}{2\sigma^2}\right]}_{f^n(\sigma|\mathbf{y})} \end{align*} Note that $f^n(\boldsymbol{\beta}|\sigma, \boldsymbol{y})$ is a kernel for $\boldsymbol{\beta}$, where $\boldsymbol{\beta} \sim MVN(\boldsymbol{b}, \sigma^2(\boldsymbol{X}'\boldsymbol{X})^{-1})$ and $f^n(\sigma|\mathbf{y})$ is a kernel for $\sigma$ where $\sigma \sim IG(v, \widehat{\sigma})$ and $v = n-K$, $\widehat{\sigma}^2 = \frac{1}{v} \left(\boldsymbol{y}-\boldsymbol{X}\boldsymbol{\beta}\right)'\left(\boldsymbol{y}-\boldsymbol{X}\boldsymbol{\beta}\right)$. Thus we have: $$p(\boldsymbol{\beta}, \sigma|\mathbf{y}) = p(\boldsymbol{\beta}|\sigma, \boldsymbol{y})p(\sigma|\mathbf{y})$$ where: \begin{gather*} p(\boldsymbol{\beta}|\sigma, \boldsymbol{y}) = (2\pi)^{-\frac{K}{2}}|\sigma^2(\boldsymbol{X}'\boldsymbol{X})^{-1}|^{-\frac{1}{2}}\exp\left[-\frac{1}{2\sigma^2}(\boldsymbol{\beta} - \boldsymbol{b})'\boldsymbol{X}'\boldsymbol{X}(\boldsymbol{\beta}-\boldsymbol{b})\right] \\ p(\sigma|\mathbf{y}) = \frac{2}{\Gamma\left(\frac{v}{2}\right)} \left(\frac{v\widehat{\sigma}^2}{2}\right)^{\frac{v}{2}}\frac{1}{\sigma^{v+1}}\exp\left[-\frac{v\widehat{\sigma}^2}{2\sigma^2}\right] \end{gather*}</p>
73,756
[ -0.015528115443885326, -0.03409915044903755, 0.052888162434101105, -0.03984445706009865, 0.028219571337103844, 0.012497466057538986, 0.0003339187242090702, -0.0010294928215444088, -0.0028315801173448563, -0.05765595659613609, 0.05749007314443588, 0.04084349423646927, 0.08488307148218155, 0.02126561477780342, 0.017021972686052322, 0.014347399584949017, -0.014817336574196815, 0.01618087664246559, -0.030523113906383514, -0.018246827647089958, 0.012877468951046467, 0.019018348306417465, -0.009052515029907227, -0.03375667333602905, -0.04146265611052513, 0.033983565866947174, 0.020232513546943665, -0.022411439567804337, -0.0071393996477127075, 0.07431037724018097, -0.0033325315453112125, -0.015739906579256058, 0.006949233822524548, 0.01796259544789791, -0.019876427948474884, 0.015967072919011116, 0.008877850137650967, -0.031139886006712914, -0.026929792016744614, 0.028177782893180847, -0.008660535328090191, -0.02855083718895912, 0.0025721294805407524, 0.037260934710502625, -0.03756961226463318, 0.02742701955139637, -0.0010340643348172307, -0.014519007876515388, 0.009737184271216393, -0.027533337473869324, 0.09562133252620697, -0.008035880513489246, 0.04015186429023743, 0.044737741351127625, -0.027959579601883888, -0.011160347610712051, 0.037379227578639984, 0.05517486482858658, 0.006559181027114391, -0.06542625278234482, -0.003092124592512846, -0.05566634610295296, 0.026506884023547173, -0.03370979428291321, -0.04445852339267731, 0.0185465719550848, 0.01256414782255888, -0.010872975923120975, 0.009931671433150768, -0.011681301519274712, 0.046653542667627335, -0.011454117484390736, 0.04063508287072182, -0.03353883698582649, -0.004766024183481932, 0.019913528114557266, 0.00637792469933629, 0.030831042677164078, 0.024503836408257484, 0.02454298734664917, 0.006372157949954271, 0.021228129044175148, 0.04153870791196823, 0.03937662020325661, -0.011254568584263325, -0.015221859328448772, 0.08223368972539902, -0.00032790738623589277, 0.0530579648911953, 0.004453684668987989, -0.023948458954691887, 0.002085797255858779, 0.05141546577215195, -0.04381319135427475, -0.0551278330385685, 0.041890863329172134, -0.031064201146364212, 0.02854938805103302, -0.009755627252161503, 0.000525544979609549, -0.004849405959248543, -0.07053891569375992, -0.007557655218988657, 0.039527762681245804, -0.028251314535737038, -0.037157535552978516, 0.0012079250300303102, -0.012397218495607376, -0.043706148862838745, -0.05978211760520935, -0.032366108149290085, 0.062131091952323914, -0.03847455605864525, 0.0060123261064291, 0.027573024854063988, -0.030913863331079483, -0.006670754868537188, -0.026227731257677078, 0.06703490763902664, 0.07491439580917358, 0.01472940668463707, -0.03314164653420448, -0.026085561141371727, -0.008403322659432888, -0.027366435155272484, 0.0022245440632104874, 0.02357601188123226, -0.009730509482324123, -0.024954622611403465, 0.04496769234538078, -0.005491540301591158, -0.005138141103088856, 0.06101794168353081, 0.04798312857747078, 0.011990701779723167, 0.0037989767733961344, -0.057856544852256775, -0.02396596223115921, 0.05197591334581375, -0.03884967043995857, 0.014879267662763596, -0.0592103935778141, 0.014745641499757767, 0.018580500036478043, 0.04960285872220993, -0.006388132460415363, 0.06557159870862961, 0.029790181666612625, -0.0026763719506561756, 0.008286189287900925, -0.029056580737233162, -0.06188823655247688, -0.015957839787006378, -0.01768338866531849, -0.037367869168519974, -0.07600494474172592, 0.03626051917672157, 0.00943650770932436, -0.011290797963738441, -0.021655729040503502, 0.05501566082239151, 0.01778675615787506, -0.012961276806890965, 0.00765236746519804, 0.013418164104223251, -0.05673741176724434, 0.048011016100645065, 0.007695898879319429, 0.036200713366270065, 0.013063710182905197, -0.02938118577003479, -0.003372837556526065, -0.02295321226119995, 0.05576176568865776, 0.04552942141890526, -0.027190042659640312, -0.026914315298199654, -0.023379424586892128, 0.034900013357400894, 0.02157779224216938, -0.03827652707695961, 0.014975943602621555, -0.052077874541282654, -0.025600867345929146, 0.03406878188252449, 0.053960468620061874, 0.035286229103803635, -0.03194145858287811, -0.01985212229192257, -0.051861487329006195, -0.011325370520353317, -0.06619670242071152, -0.014890110120177269, -0.007289061788469553, -0.023578088730573654, 0.04622599110007286, -0.018048979341983795, 0.025468574836850166, 0.034004803746938705, 0.020047128200531006, -0.03524750471115112, -0.020371563732624054, 0.04107321426272392, -0.02508518658578396, 0.016618924215435982, 0.037992462515830994, 0.05879288539290428, 0.0215724129229784, 0.017674151808023453, -0.04388659447431564, -0.04112359508872032, -0.0004210961633361876, -0.05016274005174637, 0.008666004054248333, 0.010944388806819916, -0.00453420402482152, -0.004619237035512924, -0.014342499896883965, -0.019240939989686012, -0.03146010637283325, -0.06715436279773712, 0.03403092920780182, 0.05696365609765053, -0.019216202199459076, -0.01518341712653637, -0.0030480565037578344, -0.007635507266968489, 0.024464616551995277, -0.002397425938397646, 0.0066238208673894405, -0.003924818709492683, -0.0036466701421886683, 0.03813077136874199, 0.027759911492466927, -0.04699500650167465, 0.028783919289708138, 0.023788366466760635, 0.024024199694395065, -0.020013364031910896, 0.021494023501873016, -0.0027934745885431767, -0.03739459440112114, -0.014119293540716171, -0.04280934855341911, 0.009106507524847984, -0.0005426530842669308, -0.0057561383582651615, 0.03137926757335663, 0.05916651710867882, -0.06051218509674072, -0.02091657556593418, 0.049574773758649826, -0.0019159510266035795, -0.0053106313571333885, -0.038097530603408813, -0.011767223477363586, 0.050888996571302414, 0.03931793197989464, -0.001850587548688054, 0.00016708440671209246, -0.010753328911960125, 0.002746816724538803, 0.009432089515030384, -0.013824714347720146, 0.033264607191085815, 0.026938505470752716, -0.04739895462989807, -0.0004933299496769905, 0.014792753383517265, -0.027571143582463264, 0.03309984132647514, 0.0029648225754499435, -0.04927048087120056, 0.0011699869064614177, -0.01368972659111023, -0.005356443580240011, -0.004330703988671303, -0.017383143305778503, -0.04396653175354004, -0.04454497620463371, -0.023739272728562355, 0.030230987817049026, 0.01899811439216137, -0.020782822743058205, -0.06474271416664124, -0.009302244521677494, -0.03757273405790329, 0.028853919357061386, 0.009841682389378548, -0.014475032687187195, -0.04094250127673149, 0.04663306847214699, -0.011601732112467289, -0.04741578921675682, -0.0686030238866806, -0.038576677441596985, 0.010258092544972897, -0.03001493215560913, -0.040112484246492386, 0.02636844292283058, 0.0037101381458342075, -0.021070541813969612, 0.012587806209921837, -0.0035927502904087305, -0.05165857821702957, -0.04434124007821083, -0.01721019111573696, 0.003136963350698352, 0.003188179573044181, 0.07274512946605682, 0.02176528610289097, -0.03201664984226227, 0.006635218858718872, -0.11141809076070786, -0.04902924597263336, 0.029899034649133682, 0.010202988050878048, 0.024884579703211784, 0.029174013063311577, -0.05962546914815903, 0.06353051960468292, -0.012126434594392776, 0.001121644047088921, -0.021475156769156456, 0.03880878537893295, -0.019369928166270256, -0.05152267962694168, 0.023658236488699913, -0.0021915643010288477, -0.017308562994003296, 0.06093716248869896, 0.011651513166725636, 0.003196252277120948, 0.08196348696947098, -0.0021867321338504553, 0.01111006923019886, -0.024004217237234116, -0.013631426729261875, 0.009297320619225502, 0.04368693009018898, 0.017626628279685974, -0.016996489837765694, -0.0029762727208435535, -0.01658535748720169, 0.03199652582406998, 0.031467512249946594, -0.04118810221552849, 0.010887053795158863, -0.0013640281977131963, -0.009492401964962482, -0.06385397911071777, 0.0569220632314682, 0.007340835407376289, -0.059258148074150085, 0.01858706772327423, 0.016783546656370163, 0.01873348467051983, -0.011497066356241703, 0.011415903456509113, 0.02535034529864788, 0.04146011173725128, -0.004429774358868599, -0.025387685745954514, 0.023315520957112312, -0.03578318655490875, 0.019371310248970985, 0.003488389076665044, 0.0019121961668133736, 0.00798124074935913, 0.03902669996023178, -0.0006305787828750908, -0.013278672471642494, -0.00025919690961018205, -0.027304036542773247, 0.0020275157876312733, 0.022392969578504562, 0.005207280162721872, 0.016257617622613907, 0.05119766294956207, 0.050440121442079544, -0.029558075591921806, -0.03134964406490326, 0.0259854756295681, -0.013864926993846893, -0.015365751460194588, -0.008411130867898464, -0.0008863479015417397, -0.022604279220104218, -0.0015902164159342647, -0.017597462981939316, 0.07902469485998154, -0.04268365353345871, 0.038742970675230026, 0.009397469460964203, 0.008070497773587704, -0.02079508826136589, -0.01585235819220543, -0.053384460508823395, -0.03828936070203781, 0.01356439758092165, 0.03178372606635094, 0.005534851923584938, -0.016203904524445534, 0.01217128150165081, 0.025746727362275124, -0.02457476407289505, -0.000656374089885503, -0.020710349082946777, 0.053129106760025024, 0.013415512628853321, 0.02357570454478264, 0.01603132300078869, 0.0049574426375329494, -0.012924428097903728, 0.04161538556218147, 0.023514576256275177, 0.02286338433623314, 0.08063708990812302, 0.009908215142786503, -0.0010281132999807596, -0.014204028062522411, 0.013791684061288834, -0.011705009266734123, 0.02590024098753929, -0.012451007030904293, -0.0025306453462690115, 0.05250344052910805, 0.011494666337966919, -0.019893020391464233, 0.027616441249847412, 0.04108579829335213, 0.0021725718397647142, 0.022727003321051598, -0.024012694135308266, -0.013692278414964676, -0.0072783310897648335, 0.030593998730182648, -0.006521767005324364, -0.009511847048997879, -0.014166689477860928, -0.02296384982764721, 0.0321090929210186, -0.007565121166408062, 0.0296796765178442, -0.005643459036946297, 0.033349957317113876, 0.025403423234820366, 0.009733971208333969, -0.05499795079231262, 0.05489141866564751, 0.03959661349654198, 0.05404649302363396, 0.017709916457533836, -0.0009901474695652723, -0.054220400750637054, -0.024495895951986313, 0.021390391513705254, 0.03886108845472336, -0.03683852776885033, -0.02035701833665371, -0.0440969318151474, -0.02808576077222824, 0.04867955669760704, 0.008054256439208984, -0.005354644265025854, 0.01474121306091547, 0.02017752267420292, 0.014958384446799755, -0.025431198999285698, -0.0586395300924778, 0.0179581418633461, -0.01864723674952984, -0.0008804022800177336, -0.025691263377666473, -0.023844141513109207, -0.040939588099718094, -0.02887684665620327, -0.00023157086980063468, 0.04626553878188133, -0.020761169493198395, -0.00669891806319356, -0.015068499371409416, 0.009318235330283642, -0.009993367828428745, -0.06768157333135605, 0.047988325357437134, -0.0008187433122657239, -0.00489172525703907, 0.05462990701198578, -0.036549195647239685, -0.028758570551872253, 0.04322754591703415, 0.03688887134194374, -0.0026399935595691204, 0.027352266013622284, 0.007716613356024027, 0.0510559044778347, 0.052499234676361084, 0.02551012486219406, 0.04778873920440674, 0.019654029980301857, 0.011671211570501328, -0.014397474005818367, -0.042892687022686005, -0.030751317739486694, -0.03548290953040123, -0.006810052320361137, -0.05382278561592102, 0.013115557841956615, 0.02427618019282818, 0.052321311086416245, -0.0065622045658528805, 0.02015763893723488, -0.013184424489736557, -0.04070962220430374, -0.0004849756951443851, 0.0342973992228508, -0.0011488079326227307, -0.01140511129051447, -0.006349096540361643, 0.03756748512387276, 0.025012681260704994, 0.019751951098442078, 0.00749864149838686, -0.022430332377552986, 0.02951626293361187, -0.00522951316088438, -0.016902578994631767, 0.01844079978764057, -0.008745754137635231, -0.01987769454717636, 0.0010522415395826101, -0.036805927753448486, 0.018985897302627563, 0.022624453529715538, 0.046157483011484146, -0.007408584002405405, -0.017601240426301956, -0.012541933916509151, -0.0036547852214425802, -0.029687467962503433, 0.027043133974075317, -0.032734617590904236, 0.004032498225569725, 0.014936492778360844, 0.0025366051122546196, -0.04695070907473564, -0.013027217239141464, 0.0175340436398983, -0.021279336884617805, -0.024416128173470497, -0.031320758163928986, 0.023259827867150307, -0.018492477014660835, -0.058041274547576904, 0.03282088413834572, 0.022978242486715317, -0.008360255509614944, -0.011799519881606102, -0.014997059479355812, 0.023683715611696243, 0.023985067382454872, 0.006660877726972103, -0.015890320762991905, 0.007368203718215227, -0.01926295831799507, -0.025274191051721573, 0.005509865470230579, 0.0006400126731023192, -0.00714316638186574, 0.02251138910651207, -0.03973991423845291, -0.003916432149708271, 0.036125071346759796, -0.010493614710867405, -0.025650274008512497, 0.01323807705193758, 0.01966790482401848, 0.014415488578379154, 0.0016773680690675974, -0.06025661900639534, -0.002682610647752881, 0.004480903968214989, -0.033907126635313034, -0.03171876072883606, 0.018708486109972, -0.0015794505598023534, 0.06071615591645241, 0.00896198395639658, -0.016376348212361336, -0.022203033789992332, 0.055591318756341934, -0.007531596347689629, 0.024853263050317764, -0.02049383707344532, -0.0004970048321411014, 0.03822232037782669, 0.022616084665060043, -0.02379903942346573, 0.04766078665852547, -0.002814075443893671, -0.04009811952710152, -0.0175614133477211, -0.04595385491847992, 0.024484263733029366, 0.053892310708761215, -0.006637565791606903, 0.030537379905581474, 0.01866184175014496, 0.015402978286147118, -0.01368530374020338, -0.06728822737932205, 0.0016386916395276785, 0.013356814160943031, -0.007612696383148432, 0.05691897124052048, -0.06393951177597046, -0.011281370185315609, 0.06141606345772743, 0.011924265883862972, -0.00301994476467371, 0.010902929119765759, 0.0046419245190918446, 0.03576590120792389, 0.02735995687544346, -0.04584071785211563, -0.0400317907333374, 0.06761782616376877, -0.035319771617650986, 0.009023819118738174, -0.01839001104235649, -0.058845050632953644, 0.04282673820853233, 0.0784568190574646, 0.008582476526498795, -0.04199667274951935, -0.009999535046517849, -0.020857948809862137, 0.02552306093275547, 0.024527156725525856, -0.013071756809949875, 0.015276248566806316, 0.017425501719117165, 0.027442919090390205, -0.03250653296709061, 0.0242789126932621, -0.028489219024777412, -0.0806184858083725, -0.01878357119858265, -0.020343178883194923, 0.005382899194955826, -0.018632272258400917, 0.016218004748225212, -0.020485596731305122, 0.00954975001513958, -0.015747949481010437, 0.024602994322776794, 0.021102841943502426, 0.009109271690249443, 0.00632198341190815, 0.08579804748296738, -0.009090285748243332, 0.020423751324415207, -0.01933402195572853, -0.010039480403065681, 0.1283954232931137, 0.06010590121150017, 0.04801515117287636, -0.06243153288960457, 0.01773913763463497, -0.0035575688816607, 0.002597883576527238, -0.03103410080075264, 0.0051431795582175255, 0.023903248831629753, -0.03487031161785126, 0.024352136999368668, 0.046672023832798004, 0.0008694573771208525, -0.02635849080979824, 0.02803790755569935, -0.04135480895638466, -0.017687741667032242, -0.00759380916133523, -0.010194535367190838, -0.031151847913861275, -0.010396773926913738, -0.009662820026278496, 0.03130277991294861, -0.03177516907453537, -0.01888970658183098, -0.008699247613549232, -0.010700101964175701, -0.034709759056568146, 0.009858342818915844, 0.011489287950098515, -0.0399262011051178, 0.01977640576660633, 0.020692704245448112, 0.03658756986260414, 0.017219267785549164, 0.016515562310814857, -0.0550345741212368, 0.039137985557317734, 0.02939281053841114, 0.001687319716438651, 0.0234826672822237, 0.02334931120276451, -0.016833895817399025, -0.04117107018828392, -0.022971052676439285, -0.0215048436075449, 0.05458157882094383, -0.016089847311377525, -0.018720325082540512, -0.02508544735610485, 0.0003040126175619662, 0.03670978918671608, -0.03608867526054382, -0.0038862167857587337, 0.03978912904858589, 0.026932770386338234, -0.0245226938277483, -0.0018550606910139322, -0.009903138503432274, -0.002175502013415098, 0.02842477522790432, 0.06779666244983673, 0.012630400247871876, -0.06273037940263748, -0.02827499806880951, 0.008847177028656006, 0.031884245574474335, 0.023552995175123215, 0.009934855625033379, -0.005143577232956886, -0.017107684165239334, -0.029322640970349312, -0.054163578897714615, 0.009600114077329636, -0.03534099459648132, 0.026345644146203995, -0.006477337330579758, -0.005122820846736431, -0.007827440276741982, -0.029222635552287102, -0.0016544988611713052, -0.03491852059960365, 0.032560739666223526, -0.03347555547952652, 0.011630884371697903, 0.04338375851511955, 0.06013501435518265, 0.013094003312289715, -0.023853875696659088, 0.03230477496981621, 0.06284721940755844, 0.03467685729265213, -0.05210951343178749, -0.037549085915088654, 0.012983215972781181, -0.021560030058026314, 0.020163455978035927, -0.004154197871685028, 0.0476006381213665, 0.00748602207750082, 0.07444331794977188, 0.0004933113232254982, 0.04364314302802086, -0.03821156173944473, 0.0010174476774409413, -0.02517242543399334, -0.05422200262546539, 0.009377996437251568, 0.026446526870131493, 0.04358292743563652, -0.010990438982844353, 0.011500872671604156, 0.022142469882965088, 0.0022433006670325994, 0.05392256751656532, -0.028952226042747498, -0.028276313096284866, -0.003548634937033057, 0.009389832615852356, -0.0006336939986795187, -0.009746942669153214, 0.004936041310429573, 0.05209837481379509, 0.02571794204413891, -0.014437776990234852, 0.012756452895700932, -0.022743312641978264, 0.021544799208641052, -0.023044586181640625, -0.024800751358270645, 0.023992305621504784, 0.02560218796133995, 0.005779309663921595, -0.024488579481840134, 0.014423326589167118, 0.007140456698834896, 0.05216288939118385, -0.017830679193139076, -0.02280973643064499, 0.009134792722761631, -0.022972535341978073, -0.040986206382513046, 0.009225397370755672, 0.029389554634690285, 0.055300503969192505, 0.040983494371175766, 0.0021624360233545303, -0.05906686559319496, 0.016788356006145477, -0.022567184641957283, 0.01587013341486454, -0.010214882902801037, 0.018504273146390915, 0.00100040715187788, -0.030672231689095497, -0.005292604211717844, 0.01772427372634411, 0.0013435397995635867, 0.04064466059207916, 0.01915057748556137, -0.051326073706150055, -0.02376316301524639, 0.030317045748233795, -0.009588712826371193, -0.020928844809532166, -0.002321175066754222, -0.02572762966156006, 0.012092549353837967, 0.03541219234466553, -0.026829101145267487, 0.03402233496308327, -0.009044289588928223, -0.02154025249183178, -0.12014834582805634, -0.027038853615522385, 0.015225567854940891, 0.03731400892138481, 0.03766170144081116, -0.033689193427562714, 0.0373392179608345, 0.024603836238384247, -0.01389581710100174, -0.0193755105137825, 0.0158998966217041, -0.012486804276704788, -0.011214778758585453, 0.013687352649867535, -0.009060132317245007, 0.03446098789572716, 0.02028859220445156, 0.021814560517668724, 0.025661535561084747, 0.04279978573322296, 0.043641142547130585, -0.033653754740953445, -0.015668567270040512, -0.0032621691934764385, 0.039407696574926376, -0.05777010694146156, 0.04071163386106491, -0.05558009818196297, -0.015049830079078674, 0.006866812240332365, 0.03315907344222069, 0.024326900020241737, 0.0015100964810699224, 0.011086007580161095, 0.016332367435097694, 0.03467857465147972, 0.01254870556294918, 0.02326168864965439, 0.023996852338314056, -0.022867726162075996, 0.030472801998257637, -0.001474116463214159, -0.018671276047825813, -0.004870127886533737, 0.0232852790504694, -0.021052826195955276, -0.048157449811697006, -0.010711264796555042, -0.00949991587549448, -0.02339838072657585, 0.021091513335704803, -0.014138884842395782, -0.0329202339053154, -0.02973659709095955, 0.03367948532104492, -0.06423576921224594, 0.020062124356627464, 0.02881006710231304, 0.03885733336210251, -0.004238228779286146, 0.0071991621516644955, -0.0029210078064352274, -0.06800185143947601, 0.02201276831328869, 0.01146550104022026, -0.0024066362529993057, -0.07007762789726257, 0.004790137056261301, -0.013413420878350735, -0.03265025466680527, -0.0027969738002866507, -0.01623411662876606, -0.044181473553180695, 0.02276899293065071, 0.0019474418368190527, 0.007871552370488644, -0.00708695687353611, 0.017769955098628998, -0.01162599865347147, -0.0404883474111557, 0.05178770795464516, 0.004599956329911947, -0.057947129011154175, -0.005094950087368488, 0.008730556815862656, -0.046977680176496506, -0.02633046545088291, 0.05941032990813255, 0.010995111428201199, 0.010595805943012238, 0.00015843607252463698, 0.034745074808597565, 0.00031592961749993265, -0.07887408137321472, 0.003688632743433118, -0.00875349622219801, -0.03127586841583252, -0.0412130281329155, 0.016011452302336693, 0.035088229924440384, 0.029071873053908348, 0.020611947402358055, -0.0033923164010047913, 0.0005543560837395489, 0.04368377849459648, -0.003813867224380374, 0.005983803886920214, -0.009786113165318966, -0.040354207158088684, 0.046082038432359695, -0.003191716503351927, 0.018013950437307358, 0.018283482640981674, -0.02560783363878727, -0.04860905930399895, -0.01685539446771145, 0.0019838977605104446, -0.02273029088973999, -0.021775785833597183, -0.010007879696786404, -0.015742992982268333, -0.056092824786901474, -0.01919550821185112, 0.025876624509692192, -0.04514963552355766, 0.01920405589044094, 0.07770860195159912, 0.016666825860738754, 0.07571940869092941, -0.004688450135290623, 0.015917260199785233, 0.012113125994801521, -0.005145451053977013, 0.05241654813289642, -0.04151121899485588, 0.03908775746822357, -0.01976807788014412, -0.007347561419010162, -0.0007314299000427127, -0.015982918441295624, 0.035936541855335236, -0.04266289621591568, 0.0185815691947937, -0.03020945005118847, -0.01281034853309393, 0.019138982519507408, -0.030019396916031837, 0.005533101037144661, -0.0192450899630785, 0.0016537735937163234, 0.06737031042575836, -0.053017497062683105, -0.021302247419953346, -0.00424665492027998, -0.0096048628911376, -0.012502164579927921, -0.00623477203771472, 0.008982141502201557, 0.022844666615128517, 0.021530775353312492, 0.005043317098170519, 0.013939397409558296, -0.029378827661275864, 0.023640846833586693, -0.031923599541187286, -0.014976670034229755, 0.0143716586753726, -0.027789916843175888, 0.01335978414863348, -0.01209668442606926, 0.00003205195753253065, -0.005662668030709028, 0.003234431380406022, 0.0017409806605428457, 0.01987389475107193, -0.03428853675723076, -0.030707387253642082, 0.03125191107392311, 0.04356640949845314, -0.024816613644361496, 0.006308016367256641, -0.01913400925695896, 0.021764341741800308, -0.008662359789013863, -0.036525312811136246 ]
<p>I'm running the a ridge regression broadly analogous to the one at <a href="http://www.mathworks.com.au/help/stats/ridge.html" rel="nofollow">http://www.mathworks.com.au/help/stats/ridge.html</a>. </p> <p>However, I have a lot more predictors (12) than the example (which only has 3). Thus when I include the interactions the number of parameters blows out. </p> <p>What should I do? I don't have any particular reason for thinking there would/would not be interactions.</p>
36,233
[ -0.010529810562729836, 0.019365664571523666, -0.017860226333141327, 0.018411291763186455, 0.047452569007873535, 0.017725670710206032, -0.042684756219387054, -0.03627840429544449, 0.0455503985285759, -0.024045685306191444, 0.030961232259869576, 0.006759677082300186, 0.019168445840477943, -0.0062470645643770695, 0.0013522565132007003, 0.012527484446763992, -0.025281155481934547, -0.012036895379424095, 0.04844745993614197, -0.0038917206693440676, -0.011952923610806465, 0.0401289276778698, -0.018424497917294502, 0.00849792268127203, -0.0018226078245788813, 0.06482189893722534, 0.041231539100408554, -0.035100266337394714, 0.01687544211745262, 0.010497023351490498, -0.01690606400370598, -0.03443972393870354, 0.021731209009885788, 0.05002091825008392, -0.006504742428660393, -0.0034045239444822073, -0.004361589904874563, -0.03094520978629589, 0.0031977100297808647, 0.06240631639957428, -0.006460672244429588, -0.012460003606975079, -0.006811668165028095, 0.042930103838443756, -0.025467045605182648, 0.005897144787013531, -0.018291473388671875, -0.016185840591788292, 0.0348384715616703, -0.0272000040858984, 0.047013573348522186, 0.025661954656243324, 0.044057104736566544, 0.04177536815404892, -0.03449849784374237, -0.002079418394714594, 0.04559614509344101, 0.0782366544008255, 0.007873820140957832, -0.058211710304021835, 0.009407980367541313, -0.020269397646188736, -0.0015299193328246474, -0.013290858827531338, -0.03402548283338547, 0.011050828732550144, -0.003866925835609436, -0.02012680284678936, 0.01535637117922306, -0.006717730313539505, 0.02807443030178547, -0.00599513528868556, 0.036540817469358444, -0.006914152763783932, -0.009757195599377155, -0.002243656199425459, 0.0043843514285981655, 0.05303844064474106, 0.06215757131576538, 0.011257132515311241, 0.032115668058395386, 0.03714386373758316, 0.02632802166044712, 0.007640914525836706, 0.03813427686691284, 0.023249903693795204, 0.03179508447647095, 0.0043220422230660915, 0.02262718789279461, 0.02474026009440422, -0.04745618999004364, 0.00675805052742362, 0.06536781787872314, -0.004609437193721533, -0.04619043320417404, 0.03501392528414726, -0.016565823927521706, 0.028608908876776695, -0.001692799269221723, 0.018996288999915123, -0.011437810957431793, -0.02044171281158924, -0.02635006606578827, 0.03873082250356674, 0.0031255928333848715, -0.029612498357892036, -0.046265989542007446, -0.028822513297200203, -0.013231017626821995, -0.0648360624909401, -0.011377655901014805, 0.013929033651947975, -0.014321863651275635, -0.0503121092915535, -0.00957515649497509, -0.005072264466434717, -0.003092274535447359, -0.018782028928399086, 0.040617939084768295, 0.06431517004966736, 0.02342790737748146, -0.04541587084531784, 0.032816559076309204, -0.009276974014937878, -0.04691972956061363, -0.0026797542814165354, -0.0016831174725666642, -0.023100310936570168, -0.04811800643801689, 0.08291521668434143, 0.024798015132546425, -0.009009073488414288, 0.026864320039749146, -0.002304279012605548, 0.0196633730083704, 0.006681943777948618, -0.05535970628261566, -0.07597731053829193, 0.024409042671322823, -0.05274292454123497, 0.008017990738153458, -0.05162463337182999, -0.006510951090604067, 0.038158003240823746, 0.09502619504928589, 0.015286868438124657, 0.0224600862711668, 0.02786741405725479, 0.037548698484897614, 0.007927678525447845, -0.02497170865535736, -0.017258530482649803, -0.01847243867814541, -0.03507915884256363, -0.024541232734918594, -0.06451927870512009, 0.0023930182214826345, 0.02353637106716633, 0.0018821351695805788, 0.022670604288578033, 0.04054967314004898, 0.028299914672970772, 0.0003503466141410172, 0.0009068150538951159, 0.019195958971977234, -0.032881077378988266, 0.06021012365818024, 0.00045821999083273113, 0.04631759598851204, 0.022570697590708733, -0.010143428109586239, 0.029253076761960983, -0.022264327853918076, 0.05390169471502304, 0.03913429006934166, 0.016149384900927544, -0.010089541785418987, -0.03675053268671036, -0.018969977274537086, 0.02232232689857483, -0.02311629243195057, -0.07648056745529175, -0.02576269768178463, 0.035214364528656006, 0.04233584925532341, 0.057310353964567184, -0.021704670041799545, -0.015234507620334625, 0.0038260100409388542, -0.027998145669698715, -0.06949504464864731, -0.047441884875297546, 0.019605668261647224, -0.008181980811059475, -0.03443952277302742, 0.030642546713352203, 0.012257939204573631, 0.0032833016011863947, -0.008374269120395184, -0.020708607509732246, -0.004278395790606737, -0.026357052847743034, 0.025772446766495705, -0.0034300803672522306, 0.018094047904014587, 0.061924874782562256, 0.05421930178999901, -0.0249884482473135, 0.0545579195022583, -0.029521210119128227, -0.040290169417858124, 0.007015356793999672, -0.04259762540459633, -0.004810902290046215, -0.026636308059096336, -0.028891712427139282, -0.0005386149859987199, -0.02539307251572609, 0.002949112793430686, 0.043787531554698944, -0.08427761495113373, 0.042895033955574036, 0.049392472952604294, -0.005957814399152994, -0.001066852710209787, 0.010358109138906002, 0.026041235774755478, 0.014362088404595852, -0.052043426781892776, 0.026570888236165047, -0.05577472969889641, -0.038803212344646454, 0.04843750596046448, 0.031495895236730576, -0.04917953163385391, 0.01779894158244133, 0.08132465928792953, -0.002554505132138729, 0.01038399338722229, 0.04386346787214279, -0.0024945519398897886, -0.006442590616643429, 0.02662612497806549, 0.018932770937681198, 0.023189660161733627, -0.019246814772486687, 0.004530426114797592, -0.0023360438644886017, 0.008069281466305256, -0.016286710277199745, -0.0033719558268785477, 0.026822436600923538, -0.001330546336248517, 0.021825874224305153, -0.008875304833054543, 0.017411353066563606, 0.021175255998969078, -0.039245568215847015, 0.025949673727154732, 0.023196609690785408, 0.03028896637260914, -0.022661954164505005, 0.006945371627807617, -0.041649531573057175, 0.002068756613880396, 0.025323428213596344, -0.02793119288980961, -0.03397781029343605, 0.004167132079601288, -0.05429687350988388, 0.00835099071264267, -0.03795616328716278, -0.010005843825638294, -0.0340474471449852, 0.004343277774751186, 0.022233786061406136, 0.010019487701356411, 0.05373988673090935, -0.026121532544493675, -0.03384159505367279, 0.0327039510011673, -0.017405185848474503, 0.002195709152147174, -0.0019754779059439898, -0.05915061756968498, -0.02660653367638588, -0.010849559679627419, 0.0010851911501958966, 0.03377790376543999, -0.008723962120711803, 0.006239133421331644, 0.034024521708488464, -0.028878970071673393, -0.06120814383029938, -0.05323091149330139, -0.019017891958355904, -0.0002550342178437859, -0.011373661458492279, -0.0426495224237442, 0.023367587476968765, 0.021520836278796196, -0.03754551336169243, 0.019243789836764336, -0.041245583444833755, 0.02063007839024067, -0.037327151745557785, -0.017838483676314354, 0.022869272157549858, -0.0017541588749736547, 0.0011822712840512395, 0.018720179796218872, -0.02315589413046837, 0.031017117202281952, -0.07398314028978348, -0.06996490061283112, 0.009593319147825241, 0.017737461254000664, 0.04667334258556366, -0.04533515125513077, -0.01847623847424984, 0.055773455649614334, -0.010426651686429977, -0.03231601417064667, -0.038715340197086334, -0.04230276867747307, -0.026739126071333885, -0.03251250460743904, 0.03772512450814247, 0.023548610508441925, 0.004221492446959019, 0.03130263835191727, -0.026405055075883865, 0.03911373391747475, 0.06283874064683914, 0.0015456833643838763, 0.00378188444301486, 0.00682086730375886, 0.010286477394402027, 0.011692071333527565, 0.0417378768324852, 0.01925673894584179, 0.011932195164263248, 0.008496640250086784, -0.03259970620274544, 0.00857876893132925, 0.002668415429070592, -0.03317204862833023, 0.018975229933857918, -0.019886326044797897, 0.042945556342601776, -0.03170602768659592, -0.009364258497953415, 0.016638273373246193, -0.01719767041504383, -0.025716939941048622, 0.02468719705939293, 0.07336856424808502, -0.034685224294662476, -0.00499349320307374, 0.05113501101732254, 0.008602794259786606, 0.0021061592269688845, -0.0008254945278167725, 0.0193046722561121, -0.01678718812763691, -0.03527431935071945, 0.022553376853466034, -0.027086811140179634, 0.05304250866174698, -0.007262211758643389, -0.011638786643743515, -0.0174940787255764, -0.0883273184299469, 0.03017774410545826, -0.06277976930141449, -0.0002568682830315083, -0.04530146345496178, 0.04096697270870209, -0.023372631520032883, 0.03178388252854347, -0.0057772439904510975, -0.012087613344192505, 0.019175615161657333, 0.0010802862234413624, -0.05742581561207771, 0.02112475596368313, -0.002603641478344798, -0.025637531653046608, 0.018701480701565742, -0.018734190613031387, -0.00783554743975401, -0.039795830845832825, 0.02179114706814289, 0.024897471070289612, 0.0008034060592763126, -0.03158921003341675, -0.00548635795712471, -0.053402822464704514, -0.022226808592677116, -0.014121281914412975, 0.00983512308448553, 0.027145585045218468, 0.0009867610642686486, 0.018565652891993523, 0.05926540121436119, -0.044940028339624405, -0.047474946826696396, -0.005379778333008289, 0.0029315706342458725, 0.0032575635705143213, 0.030742978677153587, 0.04058491811156273, 0.029060693457722664, -0.026270249858498573, 0.01811433769762516, -0.00996734295040369, 0.046949535608291626, 0.039999473839998245, 0.016358740627765656, -0.00998731143772602, -0.017542459070682526, -0.03655523434281349, 0.016703417524695396, 0.003908722661435604, -0.03468216210603714, -0.006202786695212126, 0.06298774480819702, 0.014689100906252861, -0.036757100373506546, 0.032691165804862976, 0.038129132241010666, 0.05493483319878578, -0.0030538924038410187, -0.013249095529317856, -0.004821005277335644, 0.02453848533332348, -0.012838686816394329, 0.02827395685017109, -0.005845143459737301, 0.014053236693143845, 0.016854319721460342, 0.012873723171651363, -0.04232252389192581, -0.012076372280716896, 0.01228359341621399, 0.02351200021803379, 0.04634696617722511, 0.02030518278479576, -0.06322036683559418, 0.004329507239162922, 0.02418179251253605, 0.008018041960895061, 0.03395198658108711, 0.04091468080878258, -0.09953887015581131, 0.004951915703713894, 0.06559307128190994, 0.06572508066892624, -0.0486890971660614, -0.017736190930008888, -0.026652615517377853, -0.02295891009271145, 0.04121030494570732, -0.024088162928819656, 0.021652013063430786, -0.024989880621433258, 0.01456523034721613, -0.014338899403810501, -0.05728808790445328, -0.0683419480919838, -0.011660308577120304, -0.004253594670444727, 0.028024254366755486, -0.026321440935134888, -0.02614152990281582, -0.02527873031795025, 0.028086606413125992, 0.019192425534129143, 0.06785767525434494, -0.01391488779336214, -0.011364033445715904, 0.01861516945064068, 0.01730712503194809, 0.0036951235961169004, -0.06391165405511856, 0.015627557411789894, 0.006375036668032408, -0.019044574350118637, 0.059247925877571106, -0.0030050126370042562, -0.011728591285645962, 0.013421210460364819, 0.021275445818901062, -0.004678608383983374, -0.024123415350914, -0.0423286147415638, 0.0257735438644886, 0.017720902338624, -0.04221946373581886, 0.07558394223451614, 0.010739960707724094, -0.01597142033278942, 0.018192196264863014, -0.02364487573504448, 0.006426369305700064, -0.0441342368721962, -0.033287230879068375, -0.01768663339316845, -0.01720709353685379, -0.0018699021311476827, 0.02063056454062462, 0.017791081219911575, 0.012159014120697975, -0.05070793256163597, -0.013589131645858288, 0.019842570647597313, 0.014628516510128975, -0.013283916749060154, 0.017949385568499565, 0.002187669277191162, 0.025002531707286835, 0.004930094815790653, -0.011116121895611286, 0.01814698986709118, -0.03222277760505676, -0.010165971703827381, 0.01603347435593605, -0.036075983196496964, -0.009350062347948551, 0.0016291884239763021, -0.012211231514811516, -0.018170572817325592, -0.03437107428908348, 0.031609151512384415, -0.020222235471010208, 0.031476255506277084, -0.015588127076625824, -0.039469413459300995, 0.006936636287719011, 0.00011089587496826425, 0.011746786534786224, 0.04580245912075043, -0.026206644251942635, 0.06415511667728424, -0.05750342085957527, -0.0010909033007919788, -0.05784551054239273, -0.03697647899389267, 0.006862664595246315, -0.010182727128267288, -0.015671052038669586, -0.029244305565953255, -0.007101394236087799, -0.030825410038232803, -0.025953201577067375, -0.017561174929142, 0.03401532396674156, -0.03882277384400368, 0.005746062379330397, 0.03177501633763313, 0.038733817636966705, 0.052780937403440475, 0.02956857532262802, 0.01338792685419321, 0.05726248770952225, -0.025747936218976974, -0.03044329583644867, -0.03542337194085121, 0.001960697816684842, -0.004083128180354834, 0.003663700306788087, 0.005196679849177599, -0.020188167691230774, 0.06326695531606674, 0.002027926966547966, 0.003768780268728733, -0.020416278392076492, -0.00306013529188931, 0.02319180592894554, -0.026086488738656044, 0.015737425535917282, -0.006053442135453224, 0.006822001188993454, -0.017047323286533356, 0.02000991813838482, -0.031874075531959534, -0.02109241671860218, 0.020935626700520515, -0.017139364033937454, -0.0294246356934309, 0.002891885582357645, 0.07469639927148819, 0.013173148036003113, 0.0016081285430118442, 0.009527250193059444, -0.021969102323055267, 0.05379787087440491, -0.019199099391698837, 0.016657311469316483, 0.010764099657535553, 0.010096377693116665, -0.0500616692006588, -0.05332481861114502, -0.03586815670132637, 0.015687623992562294, 0.05432378500699997, -0.029992161318659782, 0.03663160651922226, 0.04690057039260864, -0.0011701304465532303, 0.0039335861802101135, -0.04251030832529068, -0.015494312159717083, 0.005621065851300955, 0.00850767083466053, 0.06340048462152481, 0.014943590387701988, 0.002103170147165656, 0.03753509745001793, 0.009927120991051197, 0.047521620988845825, 0.04562321677803993, -0.0019321609288454056, 0.04493377357721329, 0.002130109816789627, -0.0010480622295290232, -0.04494617134332657, 0.010146183893084526, -0.04940499737858772, 0.008520247414708138, -0.025953596457839012, 0.014127981849014759, 0.05599179118871689, 0.07955803722143173, 0.049089204519987106, -0.03118119016289711, -0.05596987530589104, -0.01215736661106348, 0.020002909004688263, -0.0023814879823476076, -0.030265673995018005, 0.03854406997561455, 0.019158214330673218, 0.02660880796611309, -0.02219056710600853, 0.031509559601545334, -0.054345715790987015, -0.09588860720396042, -0.017601607367396355, 0.003773866221308708, -0.006716263480484486, 0.06478763371706009, -0.007454903796315193, -0.036295320838689804, 0.007306349463760853, -0.04092312231659889, -0.0035970930475741625, 0.026129862293601036, 0.026492301374673843, -0.004084901884198189, 0.08574255555868149, 0.011970717459917068, 0.02268880233168602, 0.014117090962827206, -0.0009578150347806513, 0.10531126707792282, 0.08312814682722092, 0.00847040768712759, -0.06784062832593918, 0.003761009545996785, -0.004787259269505739, -0.01043294183909893, -0.0434139259159565, -0.006147743668407202, 0.013868382200598717, -0.03598422929644585, 0.051996733993291855, 0.038767118006944656, -0.017291782423853874, -0.010474005714058876, 0.05101492255926132, -0.028108352795243263, -0.018977180123329163, -0.02700420841574669, -0.011677350848913193, 0.02162340097129345, -0.0023795480374246836, -0.041049860417842865, -0.006270663347095251, -0.021004216745495796, -0.00917380303144455, -0.03059512749314308, -0.0025786699261516333, -0.001389653654769063, -0.0032584259752184153, -0.046701330691576004, 0.005629174876958132, 0.026088817045092583, 0.02584778144955635, 0.012173861265182495, 0.034055210649967194, 0.027471357956528664, -0.015276971273124218, -0.011299533769488335, 0.021354107186198235, -0.043464355170726776, -0.016212351620197296, 0.011938339099287987, -0.009740875102579594, -0.02545524761080742, -0.01443349290639162, 0.014721079729497433, 0.06391283124685287, 0.014512792229652405, -0.012846250087022781, -0.003144799266010523, 0.02367199957370758, 0.005910236854106188, -0.05268941447138786, -0.036338455975055695, -0.01031440682709217, 0.002705404069274664, -0.053083132952451706, -0.025416851043701172, -0.0019303151639178395, -0.013310084119439125, 0.00029264530166983604, 0.033414874225854874, 0.06974473595619202, -0.03913860395550728, -0.0023002757225185633, -0.09125058352947235, 0.0009484966867603362, 0.007062694523483515, 0.023097874596714973, -0.008010261692106724, -0.006549222860485315, -0.03272367641329765, -0.029509874060750008, 0.015101621858775616, 0.0250910185277462, 0.03404681384563446, 0.011556420475244522, -0.005695308558642864, -0.042216669768095016, -0.024345090612769127, 0.011732659302651882, -0.023644452914595604, 0.0023373467847704887, -0.025333236902952194, 0.0006880157743580639, 0.04172131419181824, 0.032623182982206345, 0.008758148178458214, 0.016263466328382492, -0.042037978768348694, 0.040139928460121155, 0.029817447066307068, -0.033847320824861526, -0.038914795964956284, 0.013413661159574986, -0.04203575477004051, -0.02485860325396061, -0.007687201723456383, 0.07053966820240021, -0.032349057495594025, 0.020591843873262405, 0.010359523817896843, 0.058558691293001175, -0.02255619689822197, 0.011329524219036102, 0.0006675467011518776, -0.025687148794531822, 0.012616995722055435, 0.03557918220758438, 0.0021047277841717005, -0.019730744883418083, -0.011003450490534306, -0.011854021809995174, -0.05361154302954674, 0.027346041053533554, -0.015048898756504059, -0.07031452655792236, 0.0029612903017550707, -0.017250007018446922, 0.03020164556801319, -0.03349248319864273, -0.005666360724717379, -0.06255711615085602, -0.011667417362332344, 0.015439056791365147, -0.004889603704214096, 0.0018860682612285018, 0.006203930359333754, -0.020847773179411888, -0.002679876983165741, 0.05128217488527298, 0.041353460401296616, 0.029717430472373962, -0.03642180562019348, 0.02173956111073494, -0.0009075980051420629, 0.07058482617139816, -0.040407802909612656, -0.0466756597161293, 0.03397690877318382, -0.04330313205718994, 0.008170870132744312, -0.004422063007950783, -0.007230582647025585, 0.03366905078291893, 0.023366142064332962, -0.0026312856934964657, -0.05635613203048706, 0.04934918135404587, 0.013529324904084206, 0.01841479167342186, 0.003709809621796012, -0.002227154327556491, -0.0030565971974283457, -0.03948165103793144, 0.019092939794063568, 0.0035637947730720043, -0.028620149940252304, -0.005526306573301554, 0.044190943241119385, -0.01276240311563015, -0.005960589740425348, -0.013202259317040443, 0.014182698912918568, 0.04996785148978233, -0.034397728741168976, -0.02566617727279663, 0.03816638141870499, 0.026137156412005424, -0.059765640646219254, 0.026946719735860825, 0.02549559623003006, 0.029084814712405205, -0.07390925288200378, -0.025918034836649895, -0.0309168491512537, -0.002088791923597455, 0.027767537161707878, -0.031915031373500824, -0.02209918387234211, 0.0132297957316041, -0.05978948622941971, 0.011187870055437088, 0.03794257342815399, 0.03907394781708717, -0.058346234261989594, -0.014152750372886658, -0.023535320535302162, 0.02090429700911045, 0.03134150803089142, 0.05353366583585739, 0.03268464654684067, 0.027905547991394997, -0.013766421936452389, -0.04841683432459831, -0.0029498368967324495, 0.013650399632751942, -0.00021053322416264564, -0.024950789287686348, 0.006212043110281229, -0.01502537913620472, -0.0414750836789608, 0.015711667016148567, -0.011560661718249321, 0.021843349561095238, 0.045630551874637604, -0.0030047460459172726, 0.03903120383620262, 0.06309891492128372, 0.007000681012868881, -0.0033309648279100657, 0.01836087554693222, -0.007274757605046034, -0.025887491181492805, 0.017672354355454445, -0.0033954258542507887, 0.03682952746748924, 0.007197749335318804, -0.01386114303022623, -0.034459710121154785, -0.01120686437934637, 0.0022910097613930702, 0.007668395526707172, -0.010243428871035576, -0.012097524479031563, 0.018183503299951553, -0.01250793319195509, -0.01440910343080759, -0.018194882199168205, -0.007132903207093477, 0.02331099659204483, 0.050325196236371994, -0.030241835862398148, 0.009775721468031406, -0.02166190929710865, -0.00688560213893652, 0.018663831055164337, -0.014911654405295849, 0.0036284399684518576, -0.03728742152452469, 0.015511668287217617, 0.01361231692135334, -0.020005617290735245, -0.033101338893175125, 0.0279508326202631, -0.040554434061050415, 0.018401192501187325, -0.027725422754883766, 0.010528690181672573, 0.02060781791806221, -0.022131459787487984, 0.03530316427350044, -0.07915686070919037, 0.035773199051618576, -0.009196708910167217, -0.020635027438402176, -0.02088385820388794, -0.0015208855038508773, -0.009814233519136906, -0.0019015405559912324, 0.04416469857096672, -0.017772503197193146, 0.02838871255517006, -0.014605709351599216, 0.06233159080147743, -0.006562898866832256, -0.020519917830824852, 0.07989504188299179, 0.03453061357140541, 0.014129223302006721, -0.004365500528365374, -0.02164340391755104, 0.017069494351744652, 0.033646538853645325, 0.005115368869155645, -0.009554319083690643, 0.0014447488356381655, 0.03000183403491974, -0.04172711446881294, 0.03612915799021721, 0.011189814656972885, 0.024237120524048805, 0.057811398059129715, 0.008399644866585732, 0.03776375204324722, 0.027316207066178322, 0.004677961114794016, -0.04796433448791504, 0.022502446547150612, -0.021189171820878983, 0.0059972177259624004, 0.007772711105644703, 0.020305098965764046, 0.010756433010101318, -0.020972535014152527, 0.01780817098915577, -0.006860001944005489, -0.055553652346134186, 0.004732925444841385, 0.023440375924110413, 0.012945041991770267, 0.045053333044052124, -0.0008640156011097133, 0.04683184251189232, -0.006283082999289036, -0.011580096557736397, 0.002417422831058502, 0.0010199487442150712, 0.030569734051823616, 0.008476631715893745, 0.02078220061957836, 0.07008445262908936, -0.03082084283232689, 0.02247401885688305, -0.0073066153563559055, -0.012997306883335114, -0.04069225490093231, -0.02642880380153656, 0.000024870225388440304, -0.027941981330513954, 0.035634253174066544, 0.00344478921033442, 0.0035483017563819885, 0.0580022931098938, -0.048143401741981506, -0.010402095504105091, -0.023842889815568924, -0.0010626008734107018, -0.006880170200020075, 0.010574624873697758, 0.010041091591119766, 0.018435344099998474, -0.00668334448710084, -0.00938612874597311, -0.008840583264827728, -0.00840689241886139, 0.019314993172883987, -0.01892620511353016, 0.026909755542874336, -0.02278733439743519, -0.025827765464782715, -0.014498040080070496, -0.008325129747390747, -0.009972784668207169, -0.0433439165353775, 0.061728108674287796, 0.07559628784656525, -0.015979526564478874, -0.04852381348609924, -0.017398005351424217, -0.028691506013274193, 0.039358753710985184, -0.048327796161174774, -0.01386538241058588, -0.00234861858189106, 0.025026895105838776, -0.031099459156394005, -0.017525088042020798 ]
<p>Consider an i.i.d. sample $(X_{1},\ldots, X_{n})$ where the $X_{i}$ have density $f(x) = k \cdot \exp(−(x − θ)^4)$ with $x$ and $\theta$ real, obtain the sufficient statistic and its dimension. What does this example show? Is the statistic that you have found also complete?</p>
36,235
[ -0.024106239899992943, -0.005977851338684559, 0.03426346927881241, 0.02806205302476883, 0.01493607833981514, 0.04527200013399124, -0.027203217148780823, 0.011471271514892578, 0.008239046670496464, -0.03553881123661995, 0.03333783149719238, 0.01721915230154991, 0.031124234199523926, 0.03724997863173485, -0.009035875089466572, 0.01487888116389513, -0.03238143026828766, 0.03039638325572014, 0.014541905373334885, -0.01800980605185032, -0.00948308501392603, 0.007835419848561287, 0.008870248682796955, -0.040546026080846786, -0.05122512951493263, 0.030278274789452553, 0.003847174346446991, -0.0046847485937178135, -0.00572665361687541, 0.05375583469867706, -0.0437428243458271, 0.007313931826502085, -0.006899760104715824, 0.06096246838569641, 0.011358173564076424, 0.004606534726917744, -0.011847039684653282, -0.006206802558153868, 0.06799070537090302, 0.03799864277243614, -0.0365707166492939, -0.04058649763464928, 0.02993788942694664, 0.0037487451918423176, -0.018740734085440636, 0.026931041851639748, 0.007343853823840618, -0.07007398456335068, 0.03209628164768219, -0.014829041436314583, 0.08764948695898056, 0.003510619280859828, 0.04026230424642563, -0.022488337010145187, 0.00835481472313404, -0.01956580951809883, 0.025622470304369926, 0.04942457377910614, 0.013971642591059208, -0.021209577098488808, -0.0355900414288044, -0.0080221276730299, -0.0003731691977009177, -0.016391949728131294, -0.03373652696609497, 0.01901836320757866, -0.017122766003012657, -0.03060769848525524, 0.019203076139092445, -0.023814093321561813, 0.007017161697149277, -0.0024880932178348303, 0.013844918459653854, -0.00826636515557766, -0.009803940542042255, 0.02217268757522106, 0.0034588135313242674, 0.03772560879588127, 0.011104869656264782, -0.011320412158966064, 0.0023522276896983385, 0.0037658754736185074, 0.04752083867788315, 0.04324769973754883, 0.013761603273451328, 0.03698199987411499, 0.0775054395198822, -0.00831777323037386, 0.009130402468144894, 0.04010828956961632, 0.023850740864872932, -0.016891518607735634, 0.05076824873685837, -0.019934484735131264, -0.040187347680330276, 0.017885060980916023, -0.028032515197992325, 0.053865108639001846, -0.008903967216610909, -0.005610913038253784, 0.02020065300166607, -0.03933094069361687, 0.005129625089466572, 0.02047395519912243, -0.03966596722602844, 0.018663447350263596, -0.02069791406393051, -0.016265591606497765, -0.006087399087846279, 0.006240862421691418, -0.014116650447249413, 0.03710612654685974, 0.0419960543513298, 0.009537533856928349, 0.0365702323615551, -0.0004755487898364663, -0.020892225205898285, -0.006782254669815302, 0.00754203274846077, 0.05995547026395798, 0.03329913690686226, 0.006404519081115723, -0.005069011822342873, -0.04312731325626373, -0.054520703852176666, 0.03586520627140999, 0.02786281891167164, -0.020637689158320427, -0.01526562962681055, 0.061116207391023636, -0.01712532341480255, 0.03243838623166084, 0.038434263318777084, 0.0644441545009613, 0.03828096017241478, 0.008874714374542236, -0.04879971221089363, -0.009306520223617554, 0.06010410934686661, -0.031173449009656906, 0.011848187074065208, -0.07275395095348358, 0.015743164345622063, 0.027827609330415726, 0.0177915021777153, -0.026467323303222656, 0.06881870329380035, -0.009311906062066555, -0.0012581554474309087, 0.02843399904668331, -0.023798370733857155, -0.004086151719093323, 0.004222371615469456, -0.010988106019794941, -0.013975623063743114, -0.07080823928117752, 0.036152198910713196, 0.012446267530322075, -0.009911986067891121, -0.042304545640945435, 0.029292507097125053, 0.013024535961449146, -0.044968754053115845, -0.0023921772371977568, 0.0002683103666640818, -0.01609722711145878, 0.06287489086389542, -0.0136885866522789, 0.02797236479818821, -0.01219018455594778, -0.005734588485211134, 0.013664045371115208, 0.0341045968234539, 0.035747725516557693, 0.021831652149558067, -0.0185738205909729, -0.022429022938013077, -0.029218066483736038, 0.04543421044945717, 0.01349804736673832, -0.026783570647239685, -0.03917408734560013, -0.004228358622640371, 0.0229187048971653, 0.028869207948446274, 0.043088704347610474, 0.029081277549266815, -0.04313518851995468, 0.04208234325051308, -0.05224931985139847, -0.0062576341442763805, -0.030311590060591698, 0.03832093998789787, 0.0245314110070467, -0.10017267614603043, 0.02906200662255287, 0.009711177088320255, 0.03058771975338459, -0.0006420158315449953, 0.0019486170494928956, -0.06453974545001984, -0.0264792051166296, 0.015199518762528896, -0.052629634737968445, -0.0012641485081985593, 0.03317068889737129, 0.045996300876140594, 0.014134164899587631, 0.04878273233771324, -0.00808156467974186, -0.07847663760185242, -0.016287533566355705, -0.004911272320896387, 0.031176581978797913, -0.00782499834895134, -0.023915814235806465, -0.0011002736864611506, 0.027564866468310356, -0.008867659606039524, 0.05113128945231438, -0.04921574890613556, 0.060946203768253326, 0.03813556209206581, 0.025545375421643257, 0.008950293064117432, -0.007039212621748447, 0.02246471680700779, 0.008801682852208614, 0.010619692504405975, -0.023240357637405396, -0.001190224546007812, 0.002253761515021324, 0.04037202149629593, 0.05875084176659584, -0.06511352211236954, 0.03763313591480255, 0.0506482757627964, 0.013380003161728382, 0.03638187050819397, 0.019784878939390182, -0.02014845609664917, -0.018039410933852196, -0.008740759454667568, 0.010693276301026344, 0.0008487533777952194, -0.003004230558872223, -0.0021296886261552572, 0.005497922655194998, 0.031157083809375763, -0.013281639665365219, 0.009956777095794678, 0.05034386366605759, -0.02150462567806244, -0.013820597901940346, -0.012365654110908508, -0.017571434378623962, 0.053813427686691284, -0.02539817802608013, -0.030105898156762123, 0.012984169647097588, 0.013639607466757298, 0.04271678254008293, 0.0010917437030002475, -0.013589035719633102, 0.06428765505552292, 0.02120029181241989, -0.010056762956082821, -0.046674855053424835, 0.03140324726700783, -0.048434000462293625, 0.012469702400267124, -0.032782524824142456, -0.06260697543621063, -0.0021953650284558535, 0.04490438848733902, 0.08414778858423233, -0.011176031082868576, -0.017662102356553078, 0.030120717361569405, -0.026498010382056236, -0.01335467305034399, -0.01686612330377102, 0.01037951372563839, 0.010631046257913113, -0.022441579028964043, 0.005329389125108719, -0.028175299987196922, 0.010294748470187187, 0.00553791131824255, -0.00949462503194809, -0.0012964034685865045, 0.02375143952667713, -0.02453974448144436, -0.0025934104342013597, 0.009073806926608086, -0.016675345599651337, 0.0072145480662584305, -0.06163763999938965, -0.02042319066822529, 0.04617274925112724, -0.02265934646129608, -0.01831192709505558, -0.02106429822742939, -0.034462932497262955, -0.025798970833420753, -0.04529700055718422, -0.011155623942613602, 0.04512449726462364, -0.0017581972060725093, 0.020499614998698235, 0.024931631982326508, -0.013759001158177853, 0.03663738816976547, -0.077542744576931, -0.08930522948503494, -0.011474846862256527, 0.0033704701345413923, 0.029777584597468376, -0.008777149952948093, -0.03300836309790611, 0.038524873554706573, 0.024507122114300728, -0.04108080267906189, -0.018135447055101395, -0.013769036158919334, -0.024177057668566704, 0.011183923110365868, 0.004935925826430321, -0.018821440637111664, 0.009858840145170689, 0.008830546401441097, 0.053844623267650604, 0.028665004298090935, 0.003376785898581147, -0.003375258995220065, 0.014677692204713821, 0.07788202166557312, 0.029958611354231834, -0.01757042482495308, 0.017621498554944992, 0.028889236971735954, -0.05474821850657463, -0.0007431239355355501, -0.005301829893141985, 0.03840358927845955, 0.03386234492063522, -0.04157647490501404, -0.013709994032979012, -0.022044619545340538, 0.07329168170690536, -0.0072916303761303425, 0.02702767215669155, 0.03734062984585762, -0.058118924498558044, -0.029621701687574387, 0.04482319951057434, 0.006773143541067839, -0.015073022805154324, -0.022268783301115036, 0.0534055158495903, -0.028840292245149612, -0.04124189168214798, 0.028254900127649307, -0.011971427127718925, -0.00638118851929903, 0.036205049604177475, -0.008004977367818356, -0.038412611931562424, 0.0036272003781050444, 0.043911390006542206, 0.01452038437128067, -0.037877801805734634, -0.007214663550257683, -0.003432643599808216, -0.0683012455701828, 0.00807278323918581, -0.0141542237251997, 0.06290415674448013, -0.0009583219070918858, 0.02848643623292446, 0.02440594509243965, -0.01799621246755123, -0.010989736765623093, 0.02523256093263626, -0.0473443977534771, -0.03218330442905426, -0.003126137889921665, 0.028793685138225555, 0.016164319589734077, -0.04394607990980148, 0.05767256021499634, -0.0465744324028492, 0.017642449587583542, 0.04565038904547691, -0.00012157648598076776, -0.05997348576784134, -0.004553229548037052, 0.004277147352695465, -0.021262850612401962, -0.01287923939526081, 0.028504066169261932, 0.04162370786070824, 0.029396727681159973, 0.021289104595780373, 0.04421798139810562, 0.028131825849413872, -0.0056657749228179455, -0.00031661189859732985, 0.0036068889312446117, -0.015320350416004658, 0.053037822246551514, 0.014517391100525856, 0.005126412026584148, -0.031125880777835846, 0.013312413357198238, -0.023488469421863556, 0.0756487101316452, 0.02071276493370533, 0.033004388213157654, 0.0037295715883374214, -0.03234989941120148, -0.020206380635499954, 0.010325656272470951, 0.019072789698839188, 0.02844885364174843, -0.004415987990796566, 0.036904703825712204, 0.03684839606285095, -0.04682718589901924, 0.020751163363456726, 0.06679971516132355, 0.02065012790262699, 0.0005905167781747878, -0.02619568444788456, -0.00640094606205821, -0.012298512272536755, 0.039530158042907715, 0.023263033479452133, -0.002876961138099432, 0.003665023250505328, 0.007036145310848951, 0.03637303039431572, -0.003607813734561205, -0.05171063169836998, -0.0030210628174245358, 0.009734502993524075, 0.03132617473602295, -0.03320227563381195, -0.008968566544353962, 0.026464421302080154, 0.009340377524495125, 0.04698868840932846, 0.01904020830988884, -0.0020558133255690336, -0.0555703267455101, 0.02481924556195736, 0.06312558054924011, 0.024341296404600143, -0.028935400769114494, 0.00015180089394561946, -0.08450455218553543, -0.005945520009845495, 0.03284286707639694, -0.015771251171827316, 0.03891436383128166, -0.03574999421834946, 0.012243930250406265, -0.02752106823027134, -0.04555506631731987, -0.018020810559391975, -0.007729269564151764, 0.007449612487107515, 0.023565875366330147, -0.014663681387901306, -0.0026824360247701406, -0.049365025013685226, 0.009041298180818558, 0.03427693620324135, 0.05464548245072365, 0.04508183151483536, -0.02771269902586937, -0.019778020679950714, 0.02094626985490322, -0.01435678917914629, -0.05190931260585785, 0.036293886601924896, -0.020505543798208237, -0.029216144233942032, 0.027238288894295692, -0.04095788672566414, -0.03572545945644379, 0.02150508388876915, 0.004292507655918598, -0.027110328897833824, 0.017566237598657608, -0.01845601201057434, 0.03811364620923996, 0.02126927860081196, -0.010716584511101246, 0.049380626529455185, 0.01508257444947958, 0.06285401433706284, 0.02083258517086506, -0.05127594992518425, 0.02379550039768219, -0.027893180027604103, -0.0030356012284755707, -0.050020117312669754, 0.010047245770692825, -0.03767435997724533, 0.0023444106336683035, -0.017354385927319527, 0.019406748935580254, -0.0031546205282211304, 0.020440490916371346, 0.01574927754700184, 0.017190031707286835, 0.01049770973622799, -0.03272527828812599, -0.03038233518600464, 0.031468890607357025, -0.0185865368694067, 0.008372421376407146, 0.012455561198294163, -0.02375899814069271, 0.0016557085327804089, 0.016515588387846947, -0.0003676336782518774, 0.008979074656963348, -0.04127425700426102, -0.006336793769150972, 0.004564554430544376, -0.012178905308246613, 0.025906270369887352, -0.052883900701999664, 0.03690316900610924, -0.016825351864099503, -0.057845890522003174, 0.009722046554088593, -0.00015240196080412716, 0.026550432667136192, 0.05750683322548866, -0.041128821671009064, -0.020131466910243034, -0.020795542746782303, -0.020894832909107208, -0.12209554761648178, -0.008608326315879822, 0.012298742309212685, 0.016923939809203148, -0.024600600823760033, -0.043514952063560486, -0.024083053693175316, -0.018420888110995293, -0.05971579998731613, -0.0022282886784523726, 0.032655976712703705, 0.0058349184691905975, -0.0367957279086113, -0.02055206336081028, 0.03496252000331879, 0.05626305565237999, -0.03020411729812622, -0.008138716220855713, 0.03440902382135391, -0.0007507081609219313, -0.017436433583498, -0.010505838319659233, -0.006379556842148304, -0.021353308111429214, 0.022546103224158287, -0.013342156074941158, -0.020798370242118835, -0.007412678562104702, -0.004524416755884886, -0.06531255692243576, -0.024490585550665855, -0.006988155655562878, 0.01318921335041523, -0.05150667950510979, -0.04166681319475174, 0.004527200013399124, 0.013288465328514576, -0.01106148213148117, -0.0030910493806004524, -0.003161115339025855, -0.050529979169368744, 0.012775057926774025, -0.017559628933668137, 0.017239896580576897, 0.03685517981648445, 0.05195506662130356, 0.002649161498993635, 0.005945100449025631, 0.0020795210730284452, 0.02832488715648651, -0.0007272232323884964, -0.007133963983505964, 0.018189193680882454, -0.014008445665240288, 0.04115068539977074, -0.05724892392754555, -0.021701505407691002, -0.04246162623167038, 0.022064264863729477, 0.020055344328284264, 0.017899885773658752, 0.02557557076215744, 0.05038311704993248, -0.020381314679980278, 0.0023726129438728094, -0.0031496589072048664, -0.008640349842607975, -0.010196258313953876, 0.007669153623282909, 0.048729896545410156, 0.013990133069455624, -0.029619239270687103, 0.02387712150812149, 0.016485625877976418, -0.012557530775666237, 0.01152246817946434, 0.003704614471644163, -0.00047033390728756785, -0.023017408326268196, -0.03576761111617088, -0.04742790386080742, 0.03371986746788025, -0.03200799971818924, 0.01848706044256687, -0.012294662185013294, -0.009053004905581474, -0.006747093982994556, 0.02660123072564602, 0.03353394567966461, -0.04380371794104576, -0.02936084195971489, -0.035975437611341476, -0.008388921618461609, 0.010170233435928822, 0.03344712406396866, -0.00972281489521265, -0.013301237486302853, -0.0015946266939863563, -0.012750528752803802, 0.04873579740524292, -0.010748867876827717, -0.04144302383065224, -0.06599859893321991, -0.029509946703910828, -0.04387694597244263, 0.046229470521211624, -0.00653478829190135, -0.023945456370711327, 0.0027385223656892776, -0.05889009311795235, 0.044095128774642944, 0.009660552255809307, 0.0353969968855381, 0.01841559447348118, 0.03625153377652168, 0.018968267366290092, 0.0433245413005352, -0.015710657462477684, 0.012945295311510563, 0.12689144909381866, 0.07576274126768112, 0.04254278540611267, -0.05718616023659706, 0.023994551971554756, -0.006319426465779543, 0.02485402300953865, -0.036644503474235535, -0.0024175161961466074, -0.012085623107850552, -0.012484261766076088, 0.008810251019895077, 0.03616193309426308, -0.0032703306060284376, 0.03039005771279335, 0.02055245079100132, -0.01174000184983015, -0.05306347832083702, 0.00723614078015089, 0.018638892099261284, -0.024434585124254227, -0.01227075420320034, -0.08170979470014572, 0.0043222056701779366, 0.0025964309461414814, -0.06709250062704086, -0.016543403267860413, 0.009908966720104218, -0.017675286158919334, -0.013602717779576778, -0.03263351321220398, -0.031745895743370056, 0.05476139858365059, 0.004278385080397129, -0.02471149154007435, -0.030948137864470482, -0.036564070731401443, -0.020005222409963608, -0.012463521212339401, 0.08200397342443466, -0.00786986481398344, -0.023271609097719193, 0.014207107946276665, 0.0046633570455014706, -0.01874879188835621, -0.009534846059978008, -0.03557046502828598, 0.027291415259242058, -0.007550025824457407, 0.03276120126247406, -0.008118011057376862, 0.0052378554828464985, -0.039119914174079895, -0.020263491198420525, -0.040212564170360565, 0.0062686181627213955, 0.05707840994000435, -0.0458814911544323, -0.017039339989423752, -0.005505580920726061, 0.004448945168405771, -0.01715795509517193, 0.013566181063652039, 0.005314072594046593, -0.04798326641321182, 0.013682682067155838, -0.022084668278694153, 0.03623029962182045, 0.018140895292162895, -0.011634362861514091, -0.029077913612127304, 0.00525270402431488, -0.011797799728810787, -0.006990963127464056, -0.017433272674679756, -0.001030539395287633, 0.00812244787812233, -0.0060921949334442616, -0.05184721574187279, -0.003925727214664221, -0.030522704124450684, -0.007465265225619078, -0.01753119006752968, -0.041759565472602844, -0.035073019564151764, -0.016829481348395348, -0.012998418882489204, 0.043265584856271744, 0.00925939530134201, -0.005628215614706278, 0.01692804880440235, 0.06621076911687851, 0.024216940626502037, -0.06714172661304474, 0.005103499162942171, -0.0036252152640372515, -0.02670089341700077, 0.025535153225064278, -0.010561222210526466, 0.022483129054307938, 0.040446147322654724, 0.021092113107442856, 0.037933140993118286, 0.031139610335230827, -0.04359040409326553, 0.026397433131933212, 0.02028612419962883, -0.03931993991136551, -0.02855002135038376, 0.02128606289625168, 0.0015603202627971768, -0.04138216748833656, -0.03404355049133301, -0.04913444444537163, -0.011295558884739876, 0.008679413236677647, -0.02872636541724205, -0.027251435443758965, -0.021359136328101158, 0.012091613374650478, 0.026948213577270508, -0.006143024191260338, -0.013485891744494438, -0.027967272326350212, -0.007150899153202772, 0.010541441850364208, 0.0063759880140423775, -0.0058483243919909, 0.0029887387063354254, -0.01941877044737339, -0.019551783800125122, 0.027433397248387337, 0.028301147744059563, 0.0005429675802588463, -0.007072134874761105, -0.01990097016096115, 0.018955200910568237, 0.03794996067881584, -0.018490983173251152, 0.011259332299232483, 0.014974657446146011, -0.08189491927623749, -0.02132241055369377, 0.043407000601291656, -0.035987675189971924, 0.0033428259193897247, 0.0025847069919109344, 0.026140473783016205, -0.04034476354718208, 0.01047412771731615, -0.02684107981622219, -0.02063526213169098, 0.011872428469359875, 0.03490292280912399, -0.004939924459904432, 0.008526070043444633, 0.004018625244498253, 0.0033950041979551315, 0.014626063406467438, 0.015830425545573235, 0.06404342502355576, 0.04160844162106514, -0.02096509002149105, 0.06564035266637802, 0.0018753820331767201, -0.010089742951095104, 0.02598685398697853, -0.009717214852571487, 0.03692357987165451, 0.05846194550395012, -0.0004895254969596863, 0.008178960531949997, -0.019789688289165497, 0.013597952201962471, -0.09534487873315811, -0.05727940797805786, 0.022210340946912766, 0.038105204701423645, 0.03178409859538078, -0.07929170876741409, 0.001640776521526277, 0.021662715822458267, -0.08735983073711395, 0.014348607510328293, 0.00248146615922451, 0.005813146475702524, -0.0666603371500969, 0.00020432916062418371, -0.024976855143904686, 0.012917821295559406, 0.055999502539634705, 0.04888542741537094, 0.007651698309928179, 0.03990262374281883, -0.016518065705895424, -0.019740818068385124, 0.016777964308857918, 0.016134057193994522, -0.0018177442252635956, -0.07362841814756393, 0.060269251465797424, -0.0007083688979037106, -0.025881337001919746, 0.04302569478750229, 0.0009911118540912867, 0.022240497171878815, 0.03288554400205612, 0.029025867581367493, -0.008531375788152218, 0.04116442799568176, 0.05149184912443161, -0.017019256949424744, 0.0074298931285738945, 0.00084091437747702, 0.0046248058788478374, 0.013627937063574791, -0.023074794560670853, -0.01443895697593689, 0.06835354119539261, -0.012437715195119381, -0.0035529090091586113, 0.015663128346204758, 0.004194395616650581, -0.03525345027446747, 0.015154706314206123, -0.00808457937091589, 0.005823483224958181, -0.04678073897957802, 0.04021284356713295, -0.028805069625377655, -0.026011386886239052, -0.01294433232396841, 0.01086549274623394, 0.003439543303102255, -0.003888751845806837, 0.0014422526583075523, -0.06431209295988083, -0.0009449908975511789, 0.003408407559618354, -0.016883226111531258, -0.044127147644758224, 0.01824028789997101, -0.00898634921759367, 0.0028673612978309393, 0.00388924079015851, 0.0009437784319743514, -0.06130818650126457, 0.024141676723957062, 0.001694570411927998, 0.005123563576489687, 0.005339023191481829, -0.0461512990295887, -0.02091047540307045, -0.07146012037992477, 0.06994994729757309, 0.014539459720253944, -0.008718888275325298, 0.011368347331881523, 0.00843514408916235, -0.00701482268050313, 0.010816751979291439, 0.06863393634557724, 0.005986751057207584, -0.007218995131552219, 0.03425539284944534, 0.034225497394800186, 0.012485673651099205, -0.053911395370960236, 0.009597470983862877, -0.03699874132871628, -0.018877485767006874, -0.03525298833847046, -0.007425050251185894, 0.02944956161081791, -0.017373180016875267, -0.021606627851724625, 0.02121719904243946, 0.0070276567712426186, 0.01591649278998375, -0.023485397920012474, 0.048423804342746735, -0.006260725203901529, -0.006588813383132219, 0.052762601524591446, -0.00997029896825552, 0.028213342651724815, -0.01152524258941412, -0.016614487394690514, -0.042704422026872635, 0.015888676047325134, -0.026150256395339966, -0.03648652136325836, -0.02869502827525139, -0.005348356906324625, 0.008171483874320984, -0.03517341613769531, -0.02463470585644245, 0.022564679384231567, -0.027843348681926727, 0.00016684339789208025, 0.02942732535302639, 0.06333357840776443, 0.055040229111909866, -0.02594771794974804, -0.0031027542427182198, -0.0011263471096754074, 0.017568551003932953, 0.01974658854305744, 0.04391276091337204, 0.011348315514624119, 0.0023924021515995264, -0.024100759997963905, 0.0018293929751962423, -0.026689529418945312, 0.015146549791097641, -0.016344362869858742, 0.058730173856019974, -0.007992246188223362, -0.051370441913604736, 0.007462925277650356, -0.03495624288916588, 0.03408104553818703, -0.013723672367632389, -0.00794355571269989, 0.08161284774541855, -0.03253564611077309, -0.005327554885298014, -0.025397345423698425, -0.02475898712873459, -0.04439486190676689, 0.005291258450597525, 0.04249502718448639, 0.004714159294962883, -0.04002910852432251, 0.010070845484733582, -0.0025421653408557177, -0.014396012760698795, 0.032040875405073166, -0.03206181153655052, 0.013712876476347446, 0.028592191636562347, -0.010487893596291542, 0.003903477219864726, 0.0073467399924993515, -0.0027311325538903475, -0.03758147358894348, -0.003693012520670891, 0.048434071242809296, 0.023996451869606972, -0.008786054328083992, -0.03404144570231438, -0.015538387931883335, 0.08163926750421524, -0.04882592335343361, 0.013870341703295708, -0.03387754037976265, 0.02471073344349861, 0.0398220531642437, 0.0038818898610770702 ]
<p>I am looking for a toy similarity matrix of any kind of entity class to test my random walk code. Is there any set like this or how can I create my own set? I need to interpret the results of the random walk that I run to find the dominant instances of the data.</p>
36,237
[ -0.0071310312487185, -0.0035110425669699907, -0.007376907858997583, 0.030282318592071533, 0.014801000244915485, -0.0005898871459066868, -0.019931592047214508, -0.017771417275071144, 0.02963634394109249, -0.014049017801880836, 0.04822792485356331, 0.024845952168107033, 0.03137245401740074, 0.03716154396533966, 0.021026229485869408, 0.012590882368385792, -0.05087374895811081, 0.001696084626019001, -0.01513666845858097, -0.008568799123167992, 0.015225858427584171, -0.02315574698150158, 0.02987266331911087, -0.018539605662226677, -0.0022908332757651806, 0.015158410184085369, -0.020193835720419884, -0.010546100325882435, 0.010188356973230839, 0.037413258105516434, -0.08572659641504288, -0.03236982226371765, 0.003791321301832795, 0.02569759637117386, 0.021253423765301704, 0.0010677846148610115, -0.03480100259184837, -0.01656464673578739, -0.021585647016763687, -0.018819959834218025, -0.006221340037882328, -0.029411865398287773, -0.01962839812040329, 0.0846778154373169, 0.004551294259727001, 0.022358041256666183, -0.01775635965168476, -0.007695694454014301, 0.053754184395074844, -0.04043979570269585, 0.10500892251729965, -0.002394016832113266, 0.04561905190348625, 0.056238312274217606, 0.0031609591096639633, -0.011121120303869247, 0.009456244297325611, 0.03337647393345833, -0.03276615962386131, -0.03230386972427368, -0.03027358464896679, -0.007130604237318039, -0.006025313399732113, -0.05694134533405304, -0.019107595086097717, 0.03851163759827614, 0.02672554738819599, -0.032881587743759155, 0.03137411177158356, -0.03454011678695679, 0.005427734926342964, 0.018337175250053406, 0.05596982315182686, 0.01491420716047287, 0.012849384918808937, 0.01903717592358589, -0.030853133648633957, 0.03837023675441742, 0.07061447948217392, 0.006328644696623087, 0.006475083064287901, 0.030305875465273857, 0.007494713645428419, -0.014279049821197987, -0.008877678774297237, -0.03570331260561943, -0.003258367069065571, -0.06160850450396538, -0.021490110084414482, 0.06856267899274826, -0.01606564037501812, -0.029440896585583687, 0.012033890001475811, 0.024493571370840073, -0.04767521470785141, -0.0029371962882578373, 0.01646914891898632, 0.008155789226293564, 0.006960961036384106, 0.031490836292505264, -0.041047416627407074, -0.050807349383831024, -0.027377251535654068, 0.0500335693359375, -0.008006403222680092, 0.006442939396947622, -0.029364846646785736, -0.0033235368318855762, -0.03328980505466461, -0.009277976118028164, -0.0022008358500897884, 0.013089204207062721, 0.030781609937548637, 0.03336741775274277, -0.002232025610283017, -0.009583837352693081, -0.018146442249417305, -0.060586169362068176, 0.037305258214473724, 0.054498665034770966, 0.02597697637975216, 0.014607193879783154, 0.014482570812106133, -0.07502268999814987, -0.06794946640729904, 0.045163389295339584, 0.012940555810928345, -0.028357572853565216, -0.030380047857761383, 0.047699809074401855, -0.012459867633879185, -0.0035975303035229445, 0.025470038875937462, -0.02200164832174778, 0.06708270311355591, -0.050718508660793304, -0.08661100268363953, -0.05894141271710396, 0.007059590891003609, -0.038981348276138306, 0.005232665687799454, -0.05389513447880745, 0.02023962326347828, 0.018869351595640182, 0.02264038473367691, 0.015716589987277985, 0.015181605704128742, -0.004190351348370314, 0.04167287424206734, 0.04874693974852562, 0.006207707803696394, -0.02542884647846222, -0.03130052611231804, -0.007820573635399342, -0.013503250665962696, -0.0859360545873642, 0.03840826079249382, 0.012594517320394516, -0.04004582762718201, 0.013301307335495949, 0.021894069388508797, 0.021970991045236588, 0.026582201942801476, -0.027721695601940155, -0.004550359211862087, -0.048584457486867905, 0.0848693698644638, -0.010975217446684837, 0.014088660478591919, 0.005949093494564295, -0.02426796779036522, 0.037378303706645966, 0.026224980130791664, 0.0391446128487587, 0.06098136678338051, 0.013016103766858578, 0.007013201247900724, 0.03740660101175308, 0.006343387998640537, -0.016975557431578636, -0.012882123701274395, -0.044884152710437775, -0.0012040738947689533, -0.021997535601258278, -0.03913004696369171, 0.01636374555528164, 0.002912999363616109, -0.022807251662015915, 0.052468329668045044, -0.05987001210451126, -0.04878846928477287, -0.039432648569345474, 0.011512070894241333, -0.0057159005664289, -0.022631408646702766, 0.02286914736032486, 0.026276351884007454, 0.016312459483742714, 0.013780776411294937, -0.04916858300566673, -0.037905458360910416, -0.005185806658118963, 0.027482332661747932, -0.008679278194904327, -0.0003715894417837262, 0.025045841932296753, -0.001576523995026946, -0.05232163518667221, 0.010834815911948681, -0.00477967644110322, -0.059494275599718094, -0.01085867639631033, -0.016352511942386627, 0.024514630436897278, 0.018270494416356087, 0.030307497829198837, 0.02516598254442215, 0.04247013106942177, 0.005422699265182018, 0.027813376858830452, -0.02326999232172966, 0.017128784209489822, 0.04921014606952667, 0.003942916635423899, -0.019142840057611465, -0.0037991253193467855, -0.00031702726846560836, 0.02150772698223591, 0.018875183537602425, 0.012037057429552078, -0.017880048602819443, -0.004068654030561447, 0.01608680561184883, 0.01589641533792019, -0.06099192798137665, 0.011616543866693974, 0.08261891454458237, 0.0237751342356205, 0.02782616950571537, 0.004367244895547628, -0.0011476437794044614, -0.020826565101742744, 0.019521836191415787, 0.024206435307860374, 0.03468010947108269, -0.015863439068198204, 0.006672480143606663, 0.001935515203513205, 0.015201683156192303, 0.004802534356713295, -0.027116553857922554, -0.018519453704357147, 0.03235865756869316, -0.010064201429486275, -0.022023780271410942, -0.05974558740854263, 0.017501937225461006, -0.004195295739918947, 0.019726479426026344, 0.025987917557358742, -0.018645908683538437, -0.024726858362555504, -0.043956443667411804, -0.02517344057559967, 0.029423752799630165, 0.05128539353609085, -0.00671711191534996, -0.008920983411371708, 0.03639917075634003, -0.025427330285310745, 0.07040325552225113, -0.0076540312729775906, -0.001102490583434701, -0.04732104390859604, 0.02470720186829567, 0.0646246150135994, -0.013938923366367817, 0.02622455358505249, -0.014861304312944412, 0.00833158940076828, 0.032915856689214706, 0.011491839773952961, 0.004760248586535454, -0.004808508325368166, -0.05941768363118172, 0.00634357612580061, -0.03070896677672863, -0.022602204233407974, 0.014062120579183102, 0.004016564693301916, -0.014226362109184265, 0.035242438316345215, -0.012487257830798626, 0.0076101901941001415, -0.029584892094135284, -0.02594063989818096, 0.00917662400752306, -0.0492301806807518, 0.02243478037416935, 0.019383683800697327, 0.021311167627573013, -0.08005049079656601, 0.00978661235421896, -0.008234468288719654, -0.0005855951458215714, -0.008979711681604385, -0.034716952592134476, 0.01800081692636013, -0.02076566219329834, -0.01834365725517273, 0.03138112276792526, -0.002155524445697665, 0.0189806018024683, -0.08333474397659302, -0.05996638536453247, -0.01927998661994934, 0.01742534525692463, 0.02698444575071335, 0.03471365571022034, 0.03818994760513306, 0.0710219219326973, 0.0271354541182518, -0.07332859933376312, -0.0487833209335804, 0.01312491949647665, -0.036839790642261505, -0.06891427934169769, 0.043142303824424744, 0.021236451342701912, -0.0368054173886776, -0.013083070516586304, 0.014770004898309708, 0.046118661761283875, 0.04254966601729393, -0.010830960236489773, -0.010321410372853279, 0.05758644640445709, 0.0020836491603404284, -0.02046911232173443, 0.06460876017808914, -0.00900441873818636, -0.028477100655436516, -0.0026899196673184633, 0.01882370375096798, 0.021216923370957375, 0.012988947331905365, -0.05153960734605789, 0.03804357722401619, -0.01889776438474655, 0.005167385563254356, 0.007358180359005928, -0.0017487924778833985, -0.015613504685461521, -0.029350820928812027, -0.002089646179229021, 0.05249297618865967, 0.012944700196385384, 0.016271071508526802, 0.01937016099691391, 0.05914447456598282, 0.01811443828046322, -0.031779877841472626, 0.013964003883302212, -0.05278540402650833, -0.007332420442253351, -0.006587141193449497, -0.0023466916754841805, -0.013480056077241898, 0.02072071097791195, -0.006987458094954491, 0.03942552208900452, -0.0019067312823608518, -0.03824169188737869, -0.03931388258934021, -0.04861640930175781, 0.01690627448260784, -0.06078963726758957, 0.06010377034544945, -0.01698252186179161, 0.07210418581962585, -0.008786761201918125, -0.03258708119392395, 0.023778898641467094, 0.019390461966395378, -0.07329923659563065, 0.007327075581997633, -0.0444239005446434, -0.012610401026904583, 0.022960269823670387, -0.006538053974509239, -0.02019461803138256, 0.0037496541626751423, 0.02377757802605629, 0.062388572841882706, -0.0002845769049599767, -0.039640381932258606, 0.01639101654291153, -0.0039580343291163445, -0.024783991277217865, 0.03288768604397774, 0.03888373821973801, -0.006819852627813816, 0.010161830112338066, 0.016183800995349884, 0.0030377600342035294, 0.001019126852042973, -0.005891847424209118, 0.02495899610221386, 0.018800387158989906, 0.017310701310634613, 0.007170921191573143, 0.05453212559223175, 0.0053393784910440445, -0.06333155930042267, 0.0036545770708471537, 0.003805257147178054, 0.03937627375125885, 0.039480146020650864, 0.021161457523703575, -0.017154362052679062, -0.03275401517748833, -0.015350629575550556, 0.03060857579112053, 0.025786753743886948, 0.013327240012586117, -0.01131882332265377, 0.021371623501181602, 0.0619155652821064, -0.03706945851445198, 0.022975830361247063, 0.09974835813045502, 0.021030133590102196, -0.040268223732709885, -0.003492542775347829, 0.007397170178592205, 0.047868937253952026, -0.011196646839380264, -0.018596380949020386, 0.02037271484732628, -0.005679612513631582, 0.004766245372593403, -0.0017087562009692192, -0.008040599524974823, -0.01922556199133396, -0.0050920057110488415, -0.027054255828261375, 0.01642734371125698, -0.06510253995656967, 0.011632747948169708, -0.00642408337444067, -0.015896474942564964, 0.004600191488862038, 0.054838091135025024, -0.0019474845612421632, -0.07052764296531677, 0.019686998799443245, 0.04845411330461502, 0.040547557175159454, -0.021110424771904945, -0.015961501747369766, -0.040440961718559265, -0.036506105214357376, 0.0576685294508934, -0.029787933453917503, 0.03443187102675438, -0.021795736625790596, -0.010442202910780907, -0.031508080661296844, 0.004133278504014015, 0.014901849441230297, 0.04993009939789772, -0.013851610012352467, 0.02375437133014202, -0.0233441349118948, 0.007182527333498001, -0.008360598236322403, 0.056616976857185364, -0.003176833037286997, 0.06237746775150299, -0.041329000145196915, 0.0006519780145026743, 0.027549291029572487, 0.0074303350411355495, -0.03577949479222298, -0.06811732053756714, 0.02087447978556156, 0.006192061118781567, -0.019717177376151085, -0.0004960732767358422, -0.0170801542699337, -0.029623206704854965, 0.013699449598789215, -0.005688447970896959, -0.00798617210239172, 0.014074098318815231, -0.03595244511961937, 0.03855980187654495, 0.015802673995494843, 0.003891135100275278, 0.026955438777804375, 0.014710268005728722, 0.04886843264102936, 0.0025207828730344772, -0.0071432096883654594, 0.01803184300661087, -0.010641909204423428, -0.00443390104919672, -0.023919956758618355, 0.003254272975027561, -0.07194138318300247, 0.02937585860490799, -0.008307543583214283, 0.05708906799554825, -0.03296644240617752, -0.01373741589486599, -0.02729814499616623, 0.036979179829359055, -0.006464898586273193, -0.02285279892385006, 0.012507990933954716, -0.002339126542210579, -0.011395804584026337, 0.00007696679676882923, 0.031242063269019127, -0.030263666063547134, -0.013468066230416298, 0.0063478657975792885, -0.010900388471782207, 0.0244174525141716, -0.039042938500642776, -0.013105121441185474, 0.018621321767568588, -0.04690670594573021, 0.04746553301811218, -0.012137322686612606, 0.018146421760320663, -0.012272569350898266, -0.022099608555436134, -0.02204267866909504, 0.056897781789302826, 0.010078671388328075, -0.010654591023921967, -0.020606759935617447, -0.014895321801304817, -0.012008587829768658, -0.010610288009047508, -0.07500865310430527, -0.03872762992978096, 0.0012355485232546926, 0.0192872267216444, -0.012490976601839066, -0.04633798822760582, -0.012527231127023697, -0.022489620372653008, -0.009804734960198402, -0.04082382842898369, 0.06599269807338715, -0.008126500993967056, -0.014799438416957855, -0.010525538586080074, 0.02088882215321064, 0.07067444920539856, 0.05695664882659912, -0.003011406632140279, 0.02974862791597843, 0.0072359065525233746, -0.000671201734803617, 0.012193662114441395, 0.027649113908410072, -0.02117198519408703, -0.012516645714640617, -0.025747286155819893, 0.0068289353512227535, 0.06550656259059906, -0.04940802976489067, 0.028607329353690147, 0.0156983844935894, -0.01831251010298729, -0.010697846300899982, -0.033795662224292755, -0.005489023867994547, -0.005623239558190107, -0.002607278060168028, -0.019133707508444786, 0.006799532566219568, -0.004462343640625477, 0.004168172832578421, 0.006545200478285551, -0.011641073040664196, 0.010924683883786201, 0.010385561734437943, 0.05911410599946976, -0.01787380687892437, -0.04204881936311722, 0.014719943515956402, -0.022676095366477966, 0.019835662096738815, -0.00145590933971107, 0.0050089918076992035, 0.038449306041002274, 0.046801112592220306, -0.024024125188589096, -0.022804206237196922, -0.03315088897943497, 0.006305876653641462, 0.06376848369836807, 0.005265469662845135, 0.03731435164809227, 0.06343404203653336, -0.014546912163496017, -0.02532501146197319, 0.027319684624671936, -0.011455345898866653, 0.049493107944726944, 0.026440102607011795, 0.04491887614130974, -0.007203204557299614, 0.027150459587574005, 0.010344897396862507, 0.036118004471063614, -0.01794770173728466, 0.04211197793483734, 0.0074484399519860744, 0.035954974591732025, 0.010271357372403145, 0.010354205034673214, -0.004033256322145462, 0.007410408463329077, -0.04154936224222183, 0.046961650252342224, -0.046169452369213104, -0.007806320209056139, 0.04739324375987053, 0.051366936415433884, 0.01353998389095068, 0.01522794459015131, -0.019038161262869835, -0.06384441256523132, 0.036444440484046936, 0.048809729516506195, 0.017083000391721725, 0.021243976429104805, 0.023911818861961365, 0.021236656233668327, -0.03357819840312004, 0.04155127704143524, -0.03752008453011513, -0.06197187304496765, 0.01892743445932865, 0.008652330376207829, -0.04880892485380173, 0.014787280932068825, 0.0476180799305439, -0.013949453830718994, -0.013253982178866863, -0.04150327295064926, -0.006016167812049389, 0.01949547789990902, -0.0032949750311672688, 0.00993727333843708, 0.05477607250213623, -0.00432859780266881, 0.02117806300520897, 0.005160536151379347, -0.001426644274033606, 0.135490283370018, 0.07268823683261871, 0.04276362061500549, -0.05099303647875786, -0.02149246074259281, -0.008692719973623753, -0.018056094646453857, -0.05125618353486061, 0.008027718402445316, 0.033665455877780914, 0.017826851457357407, 0.0432952418923378, 0.04107211157679558, 0.002228204859420657, -0.004895188380032778, 0.01590152271091938, -0.024132702499628067, -0.019470099359750748, 0.026816539466381073, -0.002159617841243744, -0.034596286714076996, 0.02644260786473751, -0.06108858436346054, 0.011929573491215706, 0.05302787199616432, 0.015257486142218113, -0.005008077248930931, -0.00901264138519764, 0.013465122319757938, 0.00042766734259203076, 0.02758127637207508, 0.003071201266720891, 0.006895292550325394, 0.013441743329167366, 0.016452481970191002, -0.024850353598594666, -0.01610957458615303, 0.027052059769630432, 0.029746683314442635, 0.05027630180120468, 0.05859461426734924, -0.001958665670827031, -0.010578446090221405, 0.04233920946717262, -0.01563866250216961, -0.021645821630954742, -0.03626130521297455, 0.05427141860127449, -0.030414670705795288, -0.0211268849670887, 0.006809900514781475, -0.00411040335893631, -0.03829113021492958, -0.05179557204246521, -0.012697364203631878, 0.021943096071481705, 0.05261574313044548, -0.016293726861476898, -0.01059011835604906, -0.048072658479213715, 0.01605975069105625, -0.05806351080536842, 0.008703283034265041, 0.002252192236483097, -0.004044875968247652, -0.00008630321826785803, -0.1003599613904953, 0.07418664544820786, 0.017917325720191002, -0.013783163391053677, -0.013097986578941345, -0.06348980963230133, -0.007562770042568445, 0.010868876241147518, -0.029287707060575485, 0.010676282458007336, -0.005815793294459581, 0.013633093796670437, 0.0007800019811838865, 0.009085291065275669, 0.018322069197893143, 0.0039963689632713795, -0.044153861701488495, -0.037798333913087845, -0.026510950177907944, -0.013117673806846142, 0.04220731183886528, 0.04419408738613129, 0.015502551570534706, 0.0027307793498039246, 0.004631886258721352, 0.02702461928129196, 0.003424731083214283, -0.03520330786705017, -0.02068486623466015, -0.014375914819538593, -0.06010241433978081, 0.020450681447982788, -0.020889662206172943, 0.008222062140703201, 0.00867021270096302, -0.042164918035268784, -0.016485275700688362, 0.006357927806675434, -0.010081958957016468, 0.02408062480390072, 0.03228619322180748, -0.04959867522120476, -0.013113616965711117, 0.02064032107591629, -0.060340553522109985, -0.04665108025074005, -0.03753204271197319, -0.05949007347226143, -0.01012873649597168, -0.028836995363235474, 0.02421182207763195, -0.033729664981365204, -0.018353715538978577, -0.018657512962818146, 0.04706637188792229, -0.03693952411413193, -0.009912222623825073, -0.054258111864328384, -0.02452266588807106, -0.019709903746843338, -0.005966180004179478, -0.004431859124451876, 0.027701513841748238, 0.0093991095200181, 0.025187067687511444, 0.02533603645861149, 0.001997600309550762, -0.03331427276134491, -0.002923677209764719, -0.023841043934226036, 0.0023303453344851732, 0.043966829776763916, -0.01878317818045616, -0.03197358921170235, 0.06327834725379944, -0.010055714286863804, -0.017017120495438576, 0.01954137347638607, -0.03018195927143097, 0.023329108953475952, 0.006713621784001589, 0.00424290681257844, 0.02259424328804016, 0.03965706378221512, -0.01860782876610756, -0.04163964092731476, 0.011742607690393925, -0.0023070683237165213, 0.010945274494588375, 0.001926259370520711, 0.043330118060112, 0.004234754014760256, -0.01817072555422783, 0.015662766993045807, 0.03633282333612442, 0.03278734162449837, -0.020262934267520905, -0.023183919489383698, 0.017565831542015076, 0.03939412906765938, 0.003058932488784194, -0.01678428053855896, 0.06160317733883858, 0.02782261371612549, -0.03694416955113411, 0.05375111475586891, 0.012983542867004871, 0.024764062836766243, -0.010095343925058842, -0.0007769552175886929, -0.005994634702801704, 0.0022765006870031357, 0.04915960133075714, -0.06236400455236435, 0.012764839455485344, 0.02324129454791546, -0.08492108434438705, 0.03440222144126892, 0.023251840844750404, -0.009903413243591785, -0.02151479199528694, 0.0035085740964859724, -0.017862847074866295, 0.0182067658752203, 0.018970703706145287, 0.03425786644220352, 0.027048606425523758, 0.03177804499864578, -0.017777208238840103, -0.03811460733413696, -0.03637261316180229, 0.033912137150764465, 0.007209903094917536, -0.0014647863572463393, -0.008244873024523258, -0.01631230302155018, -0.05548945069313049, 0.042900923639535904, -0.00704710278660059, 0.011833129450678825, 0.01303562056273222, 0.018101800233125687, 0.017491741105914116, 0.051147907972335815, 0.09440628439188004, -0.0109050702303648, -0.030213378369808197, -0.029543643817305565, -0.018387826159596443, 0.020356571301817894, 0.02227170579135418, -0.000602823740337044, 0.035113319754600525, 0.008854233659803867, -0.004622066859155893, 0.024045430123806, -0.039202943444252014, -0.029051905497908592, -0.05334716662764549, -0.0342065691947937, 0.006664691027253866, -0.011909880675375462, -0.019281743094325066, -0.035995930433273315, 0.023361291736364365, 0.02845071814954281, 0.011546443216502666, 0.012581948190927505, 0.05594417080283165, -0.025582116097211838, -0.03970220312476158, 0.020507855340838432, 0.029444562271237373, -0.024458834901452065, -0.06520078331232071, -0.01488453894853592, -0.004166874568909407, -0.015905151143670082, -0.02343180403113365, -0.01996316760778427, 0.0031723584979772568, 0.028108054772019386, -0.020461300387978554, 0.013140288181602955, 0.025745423510670662, 0.0031683261040598154, 0.014014136046171188, -0.05451357364654541, 0.02396269328892231, -0.011272966861724854, -0.024235134944319725, -0.030983464792370796, 0.03773093223571777, 0.00226337811909616, 0.0017552428180351853, 0.009173108264803886, -0.04423785209655762, 0.0347217321395874, -0.02939029596745968, 0.017195366322994232, -0.002793391002342105, -0.03837524354457855, 0.03442053496837616, -0.048225756734609604, -0.012660942040383816, 0.008337263949215412, 0.0033325888216495514, 0.020587002858519554, -0.018469229340553284, 0.018563320860266685, 0.0017858477076515555, -0.06724084168672562, -0.013438627123832703, -0.03285776451230049, -0.018513478338718414, 0.02073315531015396, -0.017197400331497192, -0.004694119095802307, -0.03551831468939781, -0.004998727235943079, 0.03640522062778473, -0.026634585112333298, 0.0036476626992225647, 0.05907703563570976, -0.04517687112092972, -0.05152363330125809, 0.02774575911462307, 0.027078384533524513, -0.0009370120824314654, -0.06893135607242584, -0.007459885440766811, -0.011120854876935482, -0.011859627440571785, 0.009870922192931175, 0.04932607710361481, 0.020330840721726418, 0.01984047144651413, 0.0223599411547184, 0.03802306577563286, -0.029372651129961014, -0.011143211275339127, 0.021493427455425262, 0.010435974225401878, -0.018006304278969765, -0.018421461805701256, 0.01048379484564066, 0.016650212928652763, -0.04005327448248863, 0.06168985739350319, 0.005258999764919281, -0.007645184639841318, -0.013036009855568409, 0.007643117103725672, 0.06197246536612511, -0.03935413435101509, 0.019986554980278015, 0.027613921090960503, -0.00643977290019393, 0.042798880487680435, -0.05052657797932625, 0.012555873952805996, -0.06486048549413681, 0.01454873476177454, -0.004972235299646854, 0.01971382461488247, 0.010952094569802284, -0.007792900316417217, 0.006686743348836899, 0.01653306744992733, -0.014706015586853027, 0.0008401203085668385, 0.0011735480511561036, -0.027217667549848557, -0.028824452310800552, -0.00625230697914958, 0.007540887221693993, -0.00856751948595047, -0.005570031702518463, -0.03627564385533333, 0.015155747532844543, -0.0037706925068050623, 0.007606910075992346, -0.01583954133093357, -0.009041870012879372, -0.02029765024781227, 0.010159417986869812, 0.01929592154920101, -0.03945054113864899, -0.009459175169467926, -0.04717959836125374, 0.03860855475068092, -0.000030524115572916344, 0.016664916649460793 ]
<p><strong>1. The problem</strong></p> <p>I have some measurements of a variable $y_t$, where $t=1,2,..,n$, for which I have a distribution $f_{y_t}(y_t)$ obtained via MCMC, which for simplicity I'll assume is a gaussian of mean $\mu_t$ and variance $\sigma_t^2$. </p> <p>I have a physical model for those observations, say $g(t)$, but the residuals $r_t = \mu_t-g(t)$ appear to be correlated; in particular, I have physical reasons to think that an $AR(1)$ process will suffice to take into account the correlation, and I plan on obtaining the coefficients of the fit via MCMC, for which I need <strong>the likelihood</strong>. I think the solution is rather simple, but I'm not pretty sure (it seems so simple, that I think I'm missing something).</p> <p><strong>2. Deriving the likelihood</strong></p> <p>A zero-mean $AR(1)$ process can be written as: $$X_t = \phi X_{t-1}+\varepsilon_t,\ \ \ (1)$$ where I'll assume $\varepsilon_t\sim N(0,\sigma_w^2)$. The parameters to be estimated are, therefore, $\theta = \{\phi,\sigma_w^2\}$ (in my case, I also have to add the parameters of the model $g(t)$, but that's not the problem). What I observe, however, is the variable $$R_t = X_t+\eta_t,\ \ \ (2)$$ where I'm assuming $\eta_t\sim N(0,\sigma_t^2)$, and the $\sigma_t^2$ are known (the measurement errors). Because $X_t$ is a gaussian process, $R_t$ is also. In particular, I know that $$X_1 \sim N(0,\sigma_w^2/[1-\phi^2]),$$ therefore, $$R_1 \sim N(0,\sigma_w^2/[1-\phi^2]+\sigma_t^2).$$ The next challenge is to obtain $R_t|R_{t-1}$ for $t\neq 1$. To derive the distribution of this random variable, note that, using eq. $(2)$ I can write $$X_{t-1} = R_{t-1}-\eta_{t-1}.\ \ \ (3)$$ Using eq. $(2)$, and using the definition of eq. $(1)$, I can write, $$R_{t} = X_t+\eta_t = \phi X_{t-1}+\varepsilon_{t}+\eta_t.$$ Using eq. $(3)$ in this last expression, then, I obtain, $$R_{t} = \phi (R_{t-1}-\eta_{t-1})+\varepsilon_{t}+\eta_t,$$ thus, $$R_t|R_{t-1} = \phi (r_{t-1}-\eta_{t-1})+\varepsilon_{t}+\eta_t,$$ and, therefore, $$R_t|R_{t-1} \sim N(\phi r_{t-1},\sigma_w^2+\sigma_t^2-\phi^2\sigma^2_{t-1}).$$ Finally, I can write the likelihood function as $$L(\theta) = f_{R_1}(R_1=r_1) \prod_{t=2}^{n} f_{R_{t}|R_{t-1}}(R_t=r_t|R_{t-1}=r_{t-1}),$$ where the $f(\cdot)$ are the distributions of the variables that I just defined, .i.e., defining $\sigma'^2 = \sigma_w^2/[1-\phi^2]+\sigma_t^2,$ $$f_{R_1}(R_1=r_1) = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2\pi \sigma'^2}}\text{exp}\left(-\frac{r_1^2}{2\sigma'^2}\right),$$ and defining $\sigma^2(t) = \sigma_w^2+\sigma_t^2-\phi^2\sigma^2_{t-1}$, $$f_{R_{t}|R_{t-1}}(R_t=r_t|R_{t-1}=r_{t-1})=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2\pi \sigma^2(t)}}\text{exp}\left(-\frac{(r_t-\phi r_{t-1})^2}{2\sigma^2(t)}\right)$$</p> <p><strong>3. Questions</strong></p> <ol> <li><strong>Is my derivation ok?</strong> I don't have any resources to compare other than simulations (which seem to agree), and I'm not a statistician!</li> <li><strong>Are there any derivation of this kind of things in the literature for $MA(1)$ proccesses or $ARMA(1,1)$ proccesses?</strong> A study for $ARMA(p,q)$ proccesses in general that could be particularized to this case would be nice.</li> </ol>
73,757
[ -0.004629186354577541, -0.010975266806781292, 0.00553539814427495, -0.01990022510290146, -0.006553302053362131, 0.019243022426962852, -0.01774795912206173, -0.020439069718122482, 0.030625231564044952, -0.033248625695705414, 0.02777673304080963, 0.04410959407687187, 0.07577590644359589, 0.0021904136519879103, 0.030950171872973442, -0.0028336148243397474, -0.0217119250446558, 0.011053336784243584, 0.021083299070596695, -0.014169049449265003, 0.0006405506865121424, 0.04403364285826683, -0.01894734799861908, -0.0008521885611116886, -0.04631548002362251, 0.025766920298337936, 0.042587313801050186, 0.0009837420657277107, -0.04928315803408623, 0.051877111196517944, -0.05302202329039574, -0.004509707447141409, -0.008467435836791992, 0.052972882986068726, 0.004522299859672785, -0.009925400838255882, -0.025618229061365128, -0.015596429817378521, 0.009567859582602978, 0.03338257595896721, -0.029265711084008217, -0.01404280960559845, -0.0018434816738590598, 0.0009219484636560082, 0.009745347313582897, 0.0048463414423167706, -0.02098027989268303, -0.013731779530644417, 0.05140300467610359, -0.01943870447576046, 0.044758059084415436, -0.00047354010166600347, 0.024326257407665253, 0.024707473814487457, -0.002453445689752698, -0.019355645403265953, 0.03544572368264198, 0.030092688277363777, -0.03368215635418892, -0.05604584515094757, -0.031494077295064926, -0.01403981912881136, 0.0003713178157340735, 0.0061264862306416035, -0.0061152600683271885, 0.013223472982645035, -0.012838603928685188, -0.049851395189762115, 0.02043130062520504, 0.004099342506378889, 0.03413398936390877, -0.0017599858110770583, 0.006910266820341349, 0.019350171089172363, 0.024330228567123413, 0.012179870158433914, -0.039090659469366074, 0.019445952028036118, 0.03499618172645569, 0.015497570857405663, -0.017867283895611763, -0.003711262485012412, 0.02323482744395733, 0.04898858442902565, -0.009500620886683464, 0.00680380966514349, 0.07268881797790527, -0.02397186867892742, 0.014886016957461834, 0.03537173941731453, -0.03336828574538231, 0.030037231743335724, 0.04160701110959053, -0.023204000666737556, -0.03771918639540672, 0.052596163004636765, -0.02482481114566326, 0.03595986217260361, -0.004347784444689751, -0.003254448063671589, -0.0335082970559597, -0.05424585938453674, -0.0015168547397479415, 0.08977877348661423, -0.0374380387365818, -0.024725640192627907, 0.0597102977335453, -0.012238530442118645, -0.012956355698406696, -0.03507118672132492, -0.03623579815030098, 0.006399260833859444, -0.014891069382429123, -0.011725375428795815, 0.04288497939705849, 0.022802384570240974, -0.03885403275489807, -0.036198921501636505, 0.06469330936670303, 0.09107091277837753, 0.047811757773160934, -0.027185803279280663, 0.013849368318915367, 0.00466585997492075, -0.0669589638710022, -0.0067271701991558075, 0.009265375323593616, -0.04245217517018318, -0.033138178288936615, 0.05192472040653229, 0.0013332994421944022, 0.0020579008851200342, 0.048430055379867554, 0.005111944396048784, 0.024032114073634148, 0.013954085297882557, -0.08508152514696121, -0.04254116490483284, 0.03601367399096489, -0.03603554889559746, 0.023508474230766296, -0.05214104428887367, 0.001492781681008637, 0.021786361932754517, 0.08532434701919556, 0.002232752973213792, 0.02996898628771305, 0.012916812673211098, 0.04518307000398636, -0.012607872486114502, -0.043784331530332565, -0.02349807508289814, -0.006056220270693302, -0.023622170090675354, -0.025517556816339493, -0.06645046174526215, 0.02889220416545868, 0.038111329078674316, -0.032729554921388626, 0.029062435030937195, 0.04644501581788063, 0.028110217303037643, -0.039685141295194626, -0.013320795260369778, 0.00956552941352129, -0.04354756698012352, 0.05047110095620155, 0.013656942173838615, 0.004886366426944733, 0.024316973984241486, -0.037554532289505005, -0.02030155621469021, 0.0076378206722438335, 0.023236984387040138, 0.04126863554120064, -0.03296121954917908, -0.009676855988800526, -0.009163571521639824, -0.023196518421173096, 0.04280219227075577, -0.015942852944135666, -0.019005214795470238, -0.02856081910431385, -0.027799945324659348, 0.022386718541383743, 0.031162545084953308, 0.007083036936819553, 0.019593005999922752, 0.008690196089446545, -0.046184249222278595, -0.019863657653331757, -0.0550713911652565, -0.012182370759546757, 0.0020141087006777525, 0.014689145609736443, 0.07146676629781723, -0.015492799691855907, 0.0008666279609315097, 0.027232447639107704, -0.02430007793009281, -0.023889046162366867, 0.013182863593101501, 0.022790374234318733, -0.03838512301445007, 0.013664006255567074, 0.05843793600797653, 0.06514710932970047, 0.025680065155029297, 0.055111728608608246, 0.0015406368765980005, -0.039086535573005676, -0.008967755362391472, -0.047070734202861786, 0.019170790910720825, -0.012281589210033417, -0.02594677358865738, 0.019698292016983032, -0.01844368316233158, -0.018863791599869728, -0.011594613082706928, -0.04083379730582237, 0.028308121487498283, 0.05444827675819397, -0.0262125376611948, -0.011119873262941837, 0.015124049969017506, -0.015623210929334164, 0.005911852698773146, -0.03904649615287781, 0.012020682916045189, -0.02949654497206211, -0.0308782160282135, 0.009188481606543064, 0.06368735432624817, -0.0183298010379076, -0.000311580573907122, 0.027973929420113564, 0.03947955369949341, 0.019103597849607468, 0.01938984915614128, -0.008203432895243168, -0.03320666030049324, 0.05601552128791809, -0.016517525538802147, -0.010630526579916477, 0.02117699384689331, 0.0060881758108735085, -0.006971553433686495, 0.025432167574763298, -0.01001045573502779, -0.011666770093142986, 0.02067306637763977, 0.027229521423578262, -0.01897827349603176, -0.028034541755914688, -0.007381749805063009, 0.048913076519966125, -0.007516289595514536, 0.03345653414726257, 0.03967255726456642, -0.00512660201638937, 0.0018291367450729012, -0.03539348021149635, 0.003939198795706034, 0.028784403577446938, 0.017453381791710854, -0.006806897930800915, 0.00201124744489789, 0.019788747653365135, -0.04972217604517937, 0.007802061270922422, -0.027194051072001457, -0.02663872018456459, -0.003142512869089842, 0.0051520518027246, 0.0113694928586483, 0.035323262214660645, -0.013575305230915546, -0.05191344395279884, -0.01738298311829567, 0.02177520841360092, 0.015579278580844402, 0.02537037432193756, 0.045703936368227005, -0.06396950781345367, -0.011626414023339748, -0.008791233412921429, 0.023186439648270607, 0.012887767516076565, -0.005974595434963703, 0.015572532080113888, 0.03271478787064552, -0.016335755586624146, -0.08093379437923431, -0.029921606183052063, 0.0028832382522523403, -0.019841250032186508, -0.037418726831674576, -0.043852537870407104, 0.023923413828015327, 0.01629362627863884, -0.044570278376340866, 0.028894875198602676, -0.05830083787441254, 0.004741523414850235, -0.04886540770530701, -0.008568101562559605, -0.003225129097700119, -0.01316649466753006, 0.043430160731077194, 0.04321771487593651, -0.01035978738218546, 0.0004154146881774068, -0.07329431921243668, -0.04010491445660591, 0.05571910738945007, -0.0014558027032762766, 0.04361587390303612, -0.0033357429783791304, -0.015280515886843204, 0.05233661085367203, 0.013923212885856628, -0.018916158005595207, -0.02415366657078266, 0.036198798567056656, -0.0006686942069791257, -0.023393891751766205, -0.02482159249484539, 0.012302006594836712, 0.022898754104971886, 0.029426759108901024, -0.01660744473338127, 0.00267945509403944, 0.015767434611916542, 0.03740367293357849, -0.004638753365725279, 0.03617419674992561, -0.018132584169507027, -0.001253383932635188, 0.026762397959828377, 0.014480244368314743, 0.009188004769384861, 0.01717887818813324, 0.00844420026987791, 0.016842303797602654, 0.01264936849474907, -0.033917929977178574, 0.018459618091583252, -0.008796618320047855, -0.03164118900895119, -0.044080328196287155, 0.04497711732983589, 0.0010030375560745597, -0.05877561867237091, -0.025079920887947083, 0.011277145706117153, 0.023097706958651543, -0.01069505512714386, 0.002537971129640937, 0.048779845237731934, -0.006473264191299677, -0.009940657764673233, -0.021774297580122948, -0.01698906160891056, -0.026781566441059113, 0.02001938223838806, -0.037239912897348404, 0.004227560944855213, 0.004833956249058247, 0.027147764340043068, 0.005185429938137531, -0.03249743953347206, 0.016048435121774673, -0.02386021986603737, -0.05306583270430565, 0.03128718212246895, -0.005709192715585232, 0.051156312227249146, 0.001976586412638426, 0.0442250519990921, 0.012768663465976715, -0.027032261714339256, 0.008969036862254143, -0.00753577146679163, -0.071258544921875, 0.03043445013463497, 0.003628996666520834, -0.026883382350206375, 0.007746751885861158, -0.018785422667860985, 0.039438847452402115, -0.0604490227997303, 0.018531478941440582, -0.019847769290208817, 0.029422661289572716, 0.0021407201420515776, 0.02731829695403576, -0.048624057322740555, -0.014139833860099316, 0.0017878718208521605, 0.06314685195684433, 0.03296612575650215, -0.0024387720040977, 0.0053068045526742935, 0.052927594631910324, -0.004790003877133131, -0.0018715434707701206, -0.04816453158855438, 0.011101478710770607, 0.009944040328264236, 0.07618631422519684, 0.05967053398489952, 0.01462856587022543, 0.0018704993417486548, 0.02707216516137123, 0.01717633381485939, 0.02104358561336994, 0.05042874068021774, 0.012722121551632881, -0.019696848466992378, -0.011349069885909557, -0.028724662959575653, -0.00239549414254725, 0.0406346321105957, 0.036355551332235336, -0.011385771445930004, 0.051974259316921234, -0.01211146917194128, -0.012916949577629566, -0.021566541865468025, 0.039224110543727875, -0.008525719866156578, 0.005176606122404337, -0.007471915800124407, -0.026126885786652565, 0.02781253680586815, 0.059544701129198074, 0.05507265776395798, 0.00042399950325489044, -0.017320606857538223, -0.027576500549912453, 0.013701491057872772, -0.0017543459543958306, -0.028269225731492043, 0.0012035800609737635, 0.05269027128815651, 0.027901537716388702, 0.05500669777393341, -0.0603603720664978, 0.01028429251164198, 0.08064908534288406, 0.0022724526934325695, 0.018253138288855553, -0.0008305502124130726, -0.07486839592456818, -0.0033732394222170115, -0.011003180406987667, 0.030732015147805214, -0.025604454800486565, 0.017822271212935448, -0.044270019978284836, -0.006524240132421255, 0.01088910736143589, -0.005201336462050676, 0.0229205209761858, 0.0036081611178815365, -0.014903981238603592, 0.02437516115605831, -0.055419839918613434, -0.06650783121585846, 0.015611411072313786, -0.01729845255613327, 0.014191177673637867, -0.05119948461651802, -0.028480257838964462, -0.0059221964329481125, -0.012566144578158855, -0.011914554052054882, 0.04783668369054794, -0.013073813170194626, -0.00925946794450283, 0.015402344986796379, 0.046397216618061066, 0.012588288635015488, -0.061462655663490295, 0.03379809483885765, 0.0033910551574081182, -0.00021193806605879217, 0.0399804525077343, -0.013305244967341423, -0.02851209044456482, 0.03587102144956589, -0.003667742246761918, -0.00638170400634408, 0.004157260991632938, -0.015977831557393074, 0.05420902371406555, -0.002265311311930418, 0.018590480089187622, 0.0486433282494545, 0.036414433270692825, -0.008892848156392574, -0.005379009060561657, -0.01892738975584507, -0.013492710888385773, -0.0009574264986440539, 0.0024041887372732162, -0.041587673127651215, 0.0011754200095310807, 0.001201798440888524, 0.049421727657318115, -0.0022026177030056715, 0.05348837748169899, 0.01929342932999134, -0.012843089178204536, 0.01662275940179825, 0.033568400889635086, -0.03327192738652229, 0.013827421702444553, -0.008973684161901474, 0.023500986397266388, 0.0009376889211125672, -0.03032771125435829, -0.01289403811097145, -0.01925666444003582, -0.03063298761844635, 0.010934041813015938, -0.0560421422123909, -0.002085882704705, -0.036371443420648575, -0.006848722230643034, 0.004741649143397808, -0.009967190213501453, 0.02466261386871338, -0.006704308092594147, 0.047305334359407425, 0.005967688746750355, -0.03540748357772827, -0.027545476332306862, -0.0049120294861495495, 0.003087299410253763, 0.05251382663846016, 0.012629201635718346, -0.03316487744450569, 0.01052420400083065, 0.005660906434059143, -0.06708730757236481, -0.011416705325245857, -0.008736899122595787, -0.009415024891495705, -0.0062041752971708775, -0.038446228951215744, 0.027383998036384583, -0.036242760717868805, -0.03571498021483421, -0.02215604856610298, 0.07148925215005875, 0.014662797562777996, -0.02721421606838703, -0.008948590606451035, 0.05420762673020363, 0.07572697848081589, -0.02471969835460186, -0.008750509470701218, 0.06755422055721283, -0.0332876592874527, -0.022262651473283768, 0.028007246553897858, -0.006720464210957289, -0.037485312670469284, -0.006510612554848194, -0.0071329171769320965, -0.03505498543381691, 0.0005146614857949317, -0.026201141998171806, -0.03465689718723297, 0.013619047589600086, -0.013448416255414486, -0.009028163738548756, -0.04111510515213013, -0.024910779669880867, -0.022964783012866974, 0.03579822555184364, 0.007234082091599703, -0.037885796278715134, 0.002402790356427431, 0.009961850941181183, 0.0424693338572979, -0.020141752436757088, -0.03823969140648842, 0.03502606600522995, 0.05093548819422722, 0.002686660038307309, -0.02353254333138466, 0.023417947813868523, 0.009859269484877586, 0.025024933740496635, -0.0010029323166236281, 0.029742764309048653, 0.026115376502275467, 0.00030640765908174217, -0.08584262430667877, -0.011816301383078098, -0.035952869802713394, -0.017794348299503326, 0.09424731135368347, 0.016763703897595406, 0.06395531445741653, -0.016649039462208748, -0.037820830941200256, -0.0038149631582200527, -0.034894026815891266, 0.0012887300690636039, 0.029576970264315605, -0.015878643840551376, 0.01641259714961052, -0.02459780126810074, -0.02870248444378376, 0.006835962180048227, -0.02784224972128868, 0.02274313196539879, 0.010109075345098972, -0.00968859065324068, 0.010467943735420704, 0.018970787525177002, -0.03975346311926842, -0.04560953006148338, 0.0504932627081871, -0.04364553838968277, 0.0030568549409508705, -0.003749572904780507, -0.01376325637102127, 0.0316874235868454, 0.02979760803282261, 0.013016840443015099, -0.005075166933238506, -0.012462989427149296, -0.07847651839256287, -0.011734920553863049, 0.016666701063513756, -0.025049051269888878, 0.029521377757191658, -0.018449658527970314, 0.028540801256895065, 0.008375421166419983, 0.06369201838970184, -0.00292069255374372, -0.11177965998649597, 0.016808561980724335, 0.019230645149946213, -0.006537475157529116, 0.07941751927137375, -0.0018435959937050939, -0.025126969441771507, 0.05163117125630379, -0.03196065127849579, 0.04431788623332977, 0.032562918961048126, 0.024679748341441154, -0.0500158853828907, 0.060676418244838715, -0.035272687673568726, 0.0024894014932215214, -0.057197410613298416, -0.01682802475988865, 0.12667912244796753, 0.06673924624919891, 0.06108817458152771, -0.019208084791898727, -0.015356066636741161, -0.019525673240423203, -0.017028916627168655, -0.0148751400411129, 0.01138350460678339, 0.012868351303040981, -0.02856837399303913, 0.014761933125555515, 0.026809627190232277, 0.02672841213643551, 0.016468625515699387, 0.03845349699258804, -0.03065076470375061, -0.0019409548258408904, -0.03351440280675888, -0.0033773714676499367, 0.0037720329128205776, 0.0027668538969010115, -0.023408928886055946, 0.034949056804180145, -0.045446526259183884, -0.039206959307193756, -0.008161566220223904, 0.015512797981500626, -0.019890613853931427, -0.010118493810296059, -0.062014754861593246, -0.004951790906488895, -0.004754037130624056, 0.006185518577694893, -0.001317915739491582, 0.003702617948874831, -0.007170592434704304, -0.016941826790571213, 0.028296733275055885, 0.00861029326915741, -0.021677523851394653, 0.020406333729624748, 0.02700147219002247, -0.0009424076415598392, -0.016497740522027016, -0.0516253300011158, -0.01635611243546009, 0.07708372920751572, -0.010169233195483685, -0.020443527027964592, -0.013345874845981598, -0.012799524702131748, 0.010335169732570648, -0.007779709063470364, 0.0015728778671473265, 0.007214998826384544, 0.043546535074710846, -0.048162516206502914, -0.002564355731010437, -0.04583359137177467, 0.03458613157272339, -0.01694800704717636, 0.041243426501750946, 0.02747838757932186, -0.026503313332796097, -0.015815583989024162, -0.01620248146355152, 0.0519428551197052, 0.006112395320087671, -0.012138031423091888, -0.0024124570190906525, -0.01695711351931095, -0.029421215876936913, -0.0186386089771986, 0.044390253722667694, -0.01866006851196289, 0.042532358318567276, 0.0036026625894010067, -0.010213840752840042, -0.01715599000453949, -0.05332609638571739, 0.01262333057820797, -0.05436054617166519, 0.0025067657697945833, -0.019484350457787514, -0.05051393806934357, 0.03435438871383667, 0.01555080059915781, 0.011641623452305794, -0.021766705438494682, -0.016511766240000725, 0.0687202513217926, 0.04514774680137634, -0.038281504064798355, -0.055468108505010605, 0.0022753297816962004, -0.006318234372884035, -0.0007784050540067255, -0.010872173123061657, 0.030740628018975258, 0.031038833782076836, 0.06486745923757553, -0.003751810174435377, 0.011833933182060719, -0.014592960476875305, -0.0175155196338892, 0.007362796925008297, -0.0378585010766983, -0.018941683694720268, 0.02344045229256153, 0.014485428109765053, -0.0005548760527744889, -0.0035750693641602993, -0.01729544997215271, -0.0007306471234187484, -0.035189565271139145, -0.02261502854526043, -0.045973218977451324, 0.007521175313740969, -0.023312294855713844, 0.008648174814879894, 0.005743622779846191, 0.0102977454662323, 0.008229676634073257, -0.010393576696515083, -0.0316743478178978, -0.01490319985896349, 0.005728782620280981, 0.019509615376591682, -0.004365168046206236, -0.019269393756985664, 0.039975933730602264, -0.01808866485953331, 0.041280947625637054, -0.005915201269090176, 0.0041949013248085976, 0.008530952036380768, 0.029176751151680946, -0.0005842810496687889, -0.05516435205936432, 0.0035198174882680178, -0.05508533865213394, -0.030123677104711533, 0.047346893697977066, 0.011536694131791592, 0.04059652239084244, 0.004705033730715513, -0.02759980969130993, -0.035182442516088486, 0.024113422259688377, -0.04407396912574768, 0.011605185456573963, -0.013536561280488968, 0.027322562411427498, -0.009562339633703232, -0.013268094509840012, 0.048327524214982986, 0.012776684947311878, 0.030109792947769165, 0.022527581080794334, 0.03003109246492386, 0.036475762724876404, 0.007577554322779179, 0.030257053673267365, -0.04147827997803688, -0.008405938744544983, 0.011284584179520607, -0.005535035394132137, -0.007106248755007982, 0.052044112235307693, -0.018958507105708122, 0.014037164859473705, 0.01049851719290018, 0.015002249740064144, -0.07857372611761093, -0.007438864558935165, 0.03796634078025818, 0.023269252851605415, 0.05979162082076073, -0.04668595269322395, -0.0027465287130326033, 0.05176985263824463, -0.041672978550195694, -0.008668926544487476, 0.03071645088493824, -0.022811202332377434, -0.0114523870870471, -0.02359066717326641, -0.04430393502116203, 0.015090557746589184, 0.030245840549468994, 0.03166285529732704, 0.025816958397626877, 0.0238343458622694, 0.005438525229692459, -0.05283837020397186, -0.01601986214518547, 0.004156762734055519, 0.06342461705207825, -0.05071572586894035, 0.03721708059310913, -0.04371745139360428, -0.0015034234384074807, 0.012076308950781822, 0.021963724866509438, 0.02771691232919693, -0.022857820615172386, 0.019085314124822617, -0.004215463995933533, 0.034482888877391815, 0.025174003094434738, 0.005840721074491739, 0.014375017024576664, 0.0031239266972988844, 0.05124364793300629, 0.009919540956616402, -0.0399455651640892, -0.008055901154875755, -0.007626208011060953, -0.011878126300871372, -0.025126831606030464, 0.030988844111561775, 0.018664397299289703, -0.02200818434357643, 0.041991718113422394, -0.02006017230451107, -0.02664504200220108, -0.02095070853829384, 0.0046800728887319565, -0.0436469130218029, 0.018006781116127968, 0.05895790085196495, 0.05563833937048912, -0.05018998309969902, 0.013214854523539543, -0.023413658142089844, -0.01692083477973938, 0.008717674762010574, -0.010584819130599499, -0.021250398829579353, -0.026810359209775925, -0.03235553577542305, -0.0162874273955822, -0.018991023302078247, -0.025556012988090515, 0.01791580766439438, -0.018970806151628494, 0.05913173034787178, -0.02393760159611702, -0.006193482782691717, -0.0025590918958187103, -0.015363186597824097, 0.0033672465942800045, -0.06727316975593567, 0.03795555606484413, 0.03248217701911926, -0.025966322049498558, 0.01981206052005291, -0.012928741052746773, -0.023744435980916023, 0.015961430966854095, 0.06975000351667404, 0.013642438687384129, 0.004228820092976093, 0.04684729874134064, 0.021534692496061325, 0.028357945382595062, -0.05663694068789482, 0.040296148508787155, -0.009669509716331959, -0.01323638390749693, -0.015249217860400677, -0.013145607896149158, 0.009408286772668362, 0.024037854745984077, 0.034243859350681305, -0.014781701378524303, -0.011858571320772171, -0.004187160171568394, -0.003969649784266949, 0.04863951727747917, -0.020580001175403595, 0.006476667243987322, 0.054283227771520615, -0.030883461236953735, 0.02917582169175148, 0.060938965529203415, -0.008770948275923729, -0.07525583356618881, 0.014928869903087616, -0.011570509523153305, -0.012354902923107147, 0.0007292602094821632, 0.02325594425201416, 0.01594201661646366, -0.051526665687561035, -0.0046845246106386185, 0.023870334029197693, -0.016467619687318802, 0.004153417889028788, 0.047016628086566925, -0.019595958292484283, 0.03071843832731247, 0.04626355320215225, 0.020566143095493317, 0.022413603961467743, 0.015879562124609947, 0.01638580858707428, 0.04538010433316231, 0.06453168392181396, -0.001476094126701355, 0.014238744042813778, 0.03691106662154198, -0.012481528334319592, -0.020063094794750214, -0.04202766716480255, 0.021739134564995766, -0.025750212371349335, -0.053267356008291245, 0.00491665443405509, -0.01105273887515068, -0.0035996227525174618, -0.009030187502503395, -0.013209808617830276, 0.0667305737733841, -0.065085269510746, -0.04370008781552315, -0.005798053462058306, 0.027095498517155647, -0.003137059509754181, 0.0402320921421051, -0.04128863289952278, 0.006934044416993856, 0.002219641814008355, 0.03290807455778122, -0.00021248339908197522, -0.014295205473899841, -0.047208018600940704, -0.05058109387755394, -0.03266715258359909, 0.05329114571213722, -0.003415242535993457, -0.03145860135555267, -0.052924513816833496, -0.046905845403671265, -0.044123537838459015, 0.024299336597323418, 0.014148891903460026, 0.007239803671836853, -0.06424032896757126, -0.01167998556047678, -0.03465157747268677, 0.06610672175884247, -0.03253193199634552, -0.002089009853079915, 0.01863831840455532, -0.03553856536746025, -0.025365088135004044, -0.03288152813911438 ]
<p>(1) I preprocessed data with a matching method (CEM)</p> <p>(2) On this data (binary dependent variable, explanatory variables) , I ran a logit model and estimate predicted probabilities or odds ratios.</p> <p>I would like to integrate my estimates of the logit model into the potential outcome framework (I would like get an average treatment effect for the treated (ATT) of my explanatory variable)</p> <p>I know it's possible for OLS (I found it in Gelman &amp; Hill 2007, Chapter 9), but I did not find anything on logit.</p>
73,758
[ -0.042353663593530655, 0.01647573709487915, -0.05472848191857338, 0.01870150864124298, 0.006492834538221359, 0.011643150821328163, -0.020421404391527176, -0.011906841769814491, 0.047874778509140015, -0.0002513375075068325, 0.04827156290411949, 0.02959561161696911, 0.05914076790213585, 0.012029994279146194, 0.05397320166230202, -0.006158741191029549, 0.00458714971318841, 0.012903181836009026, 0.020758841186761856, -0.002565962029621005, 0.006439221557229757, 0.019736692309379578, 0.036072034388780594, -0.02793082594871521, 0.015225782990455627, 0.06844478100538254, 0.046627163887023926, -0.04149514436721802, -0.02076570689678192, 0.06991519033908844, 0.021230068057775497, -0.04311376065015793, 0.014706389047205448, 0.04834778979420662, -0.021512608975172043, 0.023123787716031075, -0.012827739119529724, -0.039381906390190125, 0.008301304653286934, 0.005605095531791449, -0.027728483080863953, -0.023520339280366898, 0.00657826941460371, 0.024309556931257248, -0.005143573973327875, -0.003828311339020729, -0.033941421657800674, -0.001827126368880272, 0.019709229469299316, -0.001961168833076954, 0.0655558630824089, -0.018234768882393837, 0.017781667411327362, 0.011398723348975182, -0.04337750002741814, -0.0077042956836521626, 0.049329061061143875, 0.08035936951637268, 0.017866740003228188, -0.019298160448670387, -0.03203387185931206, -0.017090579494833946, -0.019746236503124237, -0.02920975722372532, -0.029742524027824402, 0.01149400882422924, -0.027662552893161774, -0.02097475342452526, 0.050596050918102264, -0.01771167665719986, -0.007761850021779537, 0.019585050642490387, 0.029886644333600998, 0.018053971230983734, 0.051131721585989, -0.035703472793102264, 0.012795581482350826, -0.030058106407523155, 0.002840933855623007, 0.009669283404946327, -0.011163637973368168, 0.02131832018494606, 0.014677637256681919, 0.060321446508169174, -0.0168923269957304, -0.006236838176846504, 0.030718263238668442, -0.020007357001304626, 0.018572742119431496, 0.03780229017138481, -0.023092808201909065, 0.022589242085814476, 0.05390242859721184, 0.01663278043270111, -0.019042326137423515, 0.036083173006772995, 0.006891691591590643, 0.04931618273258209, 0.02309502847492695, 0.008827530778944492, -0.00031925764051266015, -0.04114627093076706, -0.011015312746167183, 0.06826741248369217, 0.010672302916646004, -0.0054275575093925, -0.01826479099690914, 0.015563818626105785, 0.016850648447871208, -0.04813431575894356, 0.002829978009685874, 0.026159074157476425, 0.0024950045626610518, -0.014303481206297874, 0.0058454424142837524, -0.028656184673309326, -0.037210214883089066, -0.05827191472053528, 0.0777670219540596, 0.021505290642380714, 0.05381346121430397, -0.06119133532047272, 0.023826373741030693, -0.01569271832704544, -0.04669690504670143, -0.021334750577807426, -0.009073752909898758, -0.020029839128255844, -0.04011118412017822, 0.031991828233003616, 0.012018384411931038, -0.05768578499555588, 0.021614544093608856, 0.004297878127545118, 0.0165089201182127, -0.0018807777669280767, -0.04036569595336914, -0.052097856998443604, -0.008602305315434933, 0.003252074820920825, 0.02232356183230877, -0.06472373008728027, 0.006042157765477896, 0.027328763157129288, 0.06124105304479599, 0.01423660945147276, 0.02437717095017433, 0.018498161807656288, 0.024285685271024704, 0.044278986752033234, -0.01312737725675106, -0.011555597186088562, -0.0535840205848217, -0.042841002345085144, -0.01654086448252201, -0.06538333743810654, 0.01931285858154297, 0.018976792693138123, -0.019717881456017494, -0.007998275570571423, 0.06754922866821289, 0.026302434504032135, -0.03406825289130211, -0.018556084483861923, 0.017919888719916344, -0.0009000313002616167, 0.046216078102588654, -0.005087769124656916, 0.014749648980796337, 0.026312507688999176, -0.007606223225593567, -0.01675385795533657, 0.025904105976223946, 0.04426087439060211, 0.017426060512661934, -0.037231430411338806, 0.007028388790786266, -0.05224218964576721, 0.010917553678154945, -0.005347912665456533, 0.00003342556010466069, -0.030467944219708443, -0.02464749850332737, -0.013143581338226795, 0.012172025628387928, 0.049787167459726334, 0.000008865470590535551, -0.017368147149682045, 0.02992207556962967, -0.02836517058312893, -0.06775947660207748, -0.06249102205038071, 0.0261106975376606, 0.022843360900878906, -0.002450087573379278, -0.0029678079299628735, 0.010209035128355026, 0.049008809030056, -0.018190840259194374, 0.0027004925068467855, 0.008587993681430817, -0.04491234943270683, 0.022185536101460457, -0.03207068145275116, -0.021844739094376564, 0.07617978006601334, 0.07238159328699112, -0.01372138038277626, 0.029976602643728256, -0.06187077984213829, -0.013214866630733013, 0.004479303024709225, -0.013988767750561237, -0.008635547012090683, -0.0012637133477255702, -0.007572374306619167, -0.00902819074690342, -0.015799641609191895, 0.01621626876294613, 0.039033081382513046, -0.059332553297281265, 0.060119688510894775, 0.07065936923027039, 0.005356925074011087, 0.004880711901932955, 0.006946716457605362, -0.00008977251127362251, 0.03452036529779434, 0.007696410175412893, -0.040487539023160934, -0.03356774523854256, -0.033658482134342194, 0.032660111784935, -0.0026019189972430468, -0.0488729402422905, 0.026747796684503555, 0.06224023923277855, -0.0019382222089916468, 0.006551146507263184, 0.04615442827343941, 0.02564055472612381, -0.0068054525181651115, 0.03475738316774368, 0.006302905734628439, 0.028397968038916588, -0.03247186914086342, -0.004456734284758568, 0.003907926846295595, 0.029277056455612183, 0.03637522831559181, -0.00912379752844572, 0.026109084486961365, 0.013989065773785114, -0.009208623319864273, -0.052510228008031845, 0.0039353459142148495, 0.06586337089538574, -0.01508492324501276, 0.0017021062085404992, 0.029540855437517166, -0.00569342402741313, -0.015807263553142548, 0.019439591094851494, -0.026667514815926552, 0.030109278857707977, 0.05104612559080124, -0.011979903094470501, -0.02176777645945549, 0.021164193749427795, -0.04041153937578201, 0.016957877203822136, 0.0007417381857521832, -0.0055505335330963135, -0.04411603510379791, 0.019664885476231575, 0.028762968257069588, -0.01124504953622818, 0.049231186509132385, -0.03603542968630791, -0.04204591363668442, 0.007155047729611397, -0.026743507012724876, 0.05109298601746559, 0.026751570403575897, -0.053340844810009, -0.03258606046438217, -0.0512060709297657, -0.020347310230135918, 0.010185472667217255, -0.02502732165157795, -0.02539967931807041, 0.05519779026508331, -0.02040562778711319, -0.02000247687101364, -0.019263843074440956, 0.0019713204819709063, -0.0038492968305945396, -0.04242587089538574, -0.02550997957587242, 0.041004478931427, 0.01872805319726467, -0.009376494213938713, -0.011005439795553684, -0.046595703810453415, -0.009635776281356812, 0.004173490684479475, 0.01242613885551691, 0.010704828426241875, 0.004759870935231447, 0.054593898355960846, 0.0037941401824355125, 0.008981486782431602, -0.010838866233825684, -0.11007385700941086, -0.05420438200235367, 0.023433569818735123, 0.014522901736199856, -0.006550287362188101, 0.0008740159100852907, -0.0028367640916258097, 0.0639897957444191, 0.024376127868890762, -0.04008134827017784, -0.06572827696800232, 0.013341650366783142, 0.021160045638680458, 0.01040893979370594, 0.007740299683064222, -0.004701676778495312, 0.00494314543902874, 0.04750123247504234, 0.0012064813636243343, 0.02420462854206562, 0.04854181408882141, 0.013910789974033833, 0.023307690396904945, 0.019168850034475327, 0.013411971740424633, -0.008100578561425209, 0.020740311592817307, 0.03801247477531433, -0.042633119970560074, 0.038145117461681366, 0.0025370800867676735, 0.010483532212674618, 0.010178669355809689, -0.05301918461918831, 0.03519103676080704, 0.0010145199485123158, -0.02869519591331482, -0.012644428759813309, 0.013831773772835732, 0.040334053337574005, -0.054902732372283936, -0.023810243234038353, 0.030476894229650497, 0.008498851209878922, -0.02253149449825287, 0.025891661643981934, 0.02943328209221363, 0.02963193692266941, 0.016144253313541412, -0.008524158038198948, 0.020976316183805466, -0.006604848429560661, 0.034019265323877335, -0.012234717607498169, -0.017448365688323975, 0.02578955888748169, 0.039960093796253204, 0.010255635716021061, -0.006701853591948748, 0.0032934139017015696, 0.008989072404801846, -0.04549126699566841, -0.02004084177315235, -0.047555144876241684, 0.04902464523911476, 0.025799782946705818, 0.011005953885614872, -0.015331486240029335, 0.00012016794789815322, 0.022310735657811165, 0.0324101597070694, -0.08366566896438599, 0.013271628879010677, -0.01047783438116312, -0.008265305310487747, 0.010697281919419765, -0.024871349334716797, 0.04836057499051094, -0.015895098447799683, -0.010995465330779552, 0.001670464756898582, 0.024833666160702705, -0.0024671924766153097, -0.016205349937081337, -0.012847819365561008, -0.020801104605197906, -0.0038467980921268463, -0.032481882721185684, -0.009156033396720886, -0.025446660816669464, -0.001704030903056264, 0.028983931988477707, -0.007603632751852274, -0.023965518921613693, -0.03926389291882515, 0.016484448686242104, 0.015322857536375523, 0.055340491235256195, 0.03798416629433632, 0.02651607245206833, -0.0421154610812664, 0.037820104509592056, -0.010014280676841736, 0.0608849860727787, 0.040213145315647125, -0.016260646283626556, -0.04704510048031807, -0.024187596514821053, -0.01603873260319233, 0.0008356188773177564, 0.028728894889354706, -0.014011701568961143, -0.0064536212012171745, 0.04988951236009598, 0.06461827456951141, -0.06354819983243942, -0.012654737569391727, 0.03731633722782135, -0.002966080792248249, 0.021974055096507072, -0.029768487438559532, -0.016585620120167732, -0.0031151522416621447, 0.007536823861300945, 0.03356225788593292, 0.013986504636704922, -0.01544104889035225, -0.01845795102417469, 0.03955311328172684, 0.007509555201977491, -0.024946153163909912, -0.02338113822042942, 0.009537152014672756, 0.028167610988020897, 0.024965355172753334, -0.05667369067668915, 0.01346634142100811, 0.06218418851494789, 0.013065760023891926, -0.020605823025107384, 0.035774193704128265, -0.08144836872816086, 0.0363340862095356, 0.041804760694503784, 0.03500623628497124, -0.033876821398735046, -0.010379145853221416, -0.028673049062490463, 0.0006020517321303487, 0.017310792580246925, -0.009688125923275948, 0.009592658840119839, -0.0076460461132228374, 0.014197837561368942, 0.009343079291284084, -0.012957978062331676, -0.10150153934955597, -0.00559702655300498, -0.009130618534982204, -0.020932059735059738, -0.0058466000482439995, -0.04599934071302414, -0.025677653029561043, 0.02795310690999031, 0.0246115829795599, 0.003491051262244582, -0.0017952154157683253, -0.01631658896803856, 0.029588140547275543, 0.04572153463959694, -0.02233712188899517, -0.037838563323020935, -0.012897327542304993, 0.019548574462532997, -0.01726786606013775, 0.06180119886994362, -0.006916719488799572, 0.010088246315717697, 0.0346822589635849, -0.015661008656024933, -0.02170277200639248, -0.027317052707076073, -0.038050368428230286, 0.05287269875407219, 0.0076967827044427395, -0.0063485875725746155, 0.07717200368642807, 0.0224507674574852, -0.008103061467409134, -0.004096916876733303, -0.03523440286517143, 0.003918135538697243, -0.027350235730409622, -0.01762111857533455, -0.02920214645564556, -0.012141796760261059, -0.010011684149503708, 0.02358597330749035, -0.003659600857645273, 0.0266017597168684, -0.034330036491155624, -0.006389683578163385, -0.03748850151896477, 0.006011743098497391, -0.019614970311522484, -0.014682084321975708, -0.008206929080188274, 0.034124407917261124, -0.010300913825631142, -0.05459142476320267, 0.000034478747693356127, -0.024950368329882622, -0.0023360245395451784, -0.003914671950042248, -0.05768674239516258, 0.008394001051783562, -0.009018348529934883, -0.03584086149930954, 0.025707637891173363, -0.024855321273207664, 0.0018332573818042874, -0.02536485157907009, 0.06625600904226303, -0.02477114275097847, -0.018335135653614998, -0.01599780097603798, 0.005892646033316851, 0.03417056053876877, 0.01237105205655098, -0.04347886145114899, 0.02462516725063324, 0.004307047929614782, -0.021439598873257637, -0.05744209885597229, -0.04407934471964836, 0.04328693076968193, 0.00024979293812066317, -0.002791748847812414, -0.0325106605887413, -0.013093044050037861, -0.028154535219073296, -0.04152800887823105, -0.00983794778585434, 0.082962766289711, -0.02032526023685932, -0.013447238132357597, -0.02948308177292347, 0.029335567727684975, 0.013484392315149307, 0.022167282178997993, -0.02003747597336769, 0.03074924275279045, -0.017779015004634857, -0.027959883213043213, 0.006489345338195562, 0.03870090842247009, -0.03294211998581886, 0.002555273240432143, -0.038513172417879105, -0.0009264708496630192, 0.02131180465221405, -0.023664435371756554, -0.016597885638475418, 0.02905854769051075, -0.03563865274190903, -0.008530113846063614, -0.007605628576129675, -0.004469048697501421, -0.0045728120021522045, 0.003638720838353038, -0.02969312109053135, 0.013066694140434265, -0.010631188750267029, 0.02019360661506653, 0.05463551729917526, -0.021365048363804817, 0.015384531579911709, 0.0006691875169053674, 0.07626520097255707, 0.004147590138018131, 0.029219696298241615, 0.0018866255413740873, -0.02430598996579647, 0.04130733385682106, -0.033980853855609894, -0.028959907591342926, 0.02182280272245407, 0.00868644192814827, -0.06508396565914154, -0.06428331881761551, -0.027406617999076843, 0.0035895691253244877, 0.04817879572510719, -0.03545525297522545, 0.04159873351454735, 0.039916954934597015, -0.012612440623342991, -0.02281911112368107, -0.00998595915734768, -0.003322416916489601, 0.029750710353255272, -0.002945786574855447, 0.08100982755422592, 0.015896117314696312, -0.018228918313980103, 0.03261091187596321, 0.030096400529146194, -0.005095722619444132, 0.022863570600748062, 0.019024888053536415, 0.007719944231212139, 0.03081326186656952, -0.016034653410315514, -0.015584523789584637, 0.03607482463121414, -0.05110865458846092, -0.001437466824427247, -0.03629129007458687, -0.049801990389823914, 0.05913133546710014, 0.05477511137723923, -0.0025835128035396338, -0.05675491690635681, -0.0593717098236084, -0.050216034054756165, 0.032271407544612885, 0.02043200470507145, -0.0015168999088928103, 0.0738653689622879, -0.013554573059082031, 0.028595302253961563, -0.01721987873315811, -0.011086325161159039, -0.019124671816825867, -0.07233668863773346, 0.0009389464394189417, -0.03758807107806206, -0.027766037732362747, 0.0407429039478302, 0.027846364304423332, 0.011461707763373852, 0.013424227014183998, -0.04073245823383331, 0.015108616091310978, -0.009630201384425163, 0.05254249647259712, 0.010100403800606728, 0.09429320693016052, 0.00706374179571867, -0.0024991673417389393, -0.02560672163963318, -0.021643951535224915, 0.12372329086065292, 0.08989529311656952, 0.042966265231370926, -0.06514787673950195, 0.03665383905172348, 0.03199320286512375, -0.006323548965156078, -0.015037116594612598, -0.04775139316916466, -0.02393454685807228, -0.0009782114066183567, 0.03950819745659828, 0.04795914515852928, 0.008499043993651867, -0.028285996988415718, 0.04488394036889076, -0.02503347024321556, -0.004728642292320728, 0.04520200565457344, -0.008714169263839722, -0.015608535148203373, -0.050135690718889236, -0.009903894737362862, 0.0016107360133901238, 0.016239067539572716, -0.053444214165210724, -0.020296547561883926, -0.030987748876214027, 0.018497787415981293, -0.021733423694968224, -0.00611313758417964, 0.0045971954241395, 0.028725963085889816, 0.03461693227291107, 0.002179941162467003, -0.010975315235555172, 0.02045152708888054, -0.024633849039673805, -0.0005921116098761559, 0.010162290185689926, 0.007843132130801678, 0.03594985604286194, -0.000510462443344295, -0.005047510378062725, -0.03810391575098038, 0.0010422152699902654, -0.019744087010622025, 0.056953247636556625, -0.026679182425141335, -0.02518025040626526, -0.009623526595532894, -0.001695326529443264, 0.0352640375494957, -0.0008098449325188994, -0.009223022498190403, 0.030707363039255142, -0.008743279613554478, -0.01109488494694233, 0.0017329046968370676, -0.011446956545114517, 0.0076446677558124065, -0.013655447401106358, 0.03339039161801338, 0.04786811023950577, -0.016108211129903793, -0.017678549513220787, -0.03623315319418907, 0.028786512091755867, -0.017684902995824814, -0.05776617303490639, 0.004181311931461096, -0.012119727209210396, -0.009867076762020588, -0.049328677356243134, -0.0120294950902462, -0.0011728864628821611, 0.024311963468790054, 0.0014267907245084643, -0.02342635579407215, -0.07081539183855057, -0.0361064113676548, -0.00834836158901453, -0.03375852480530739, -0.012758273631334305, -0.048253193497657776, 0.03607390820980072, 0.046262048184871674, 0.029857691377401352, -0.0024130302481353283, -0.018459830433130264, -0.003508748486638069, 0.027043092995882034, -0.0054522003047168255, -0.015130413696169853, -0.02531989850103855, -0.01688263565301895, -0.03815704584121704, -0.016844697296619415, 0.019941309466958046, 0.07220800966024399, -0.022917116060853004, 0.03805273398756981, 0.01144852489233017, 0.026049336418509483, -0.017898153513669968, 0.040775515139102936, 0.011608496308326721, -0.01820037141442299, -0.019490042701363564, 0.0008210914093069732, 0.038314588367938995, 0.017422102391719818, 0.0024313172325491905, -0.0480661503970623, -0.06263948231935501, 0.021618137136101723, -0.03253253921866417, -0.04274660721421242, 0.024039536714553833, -0.016610221937298775, 0.02204086259007454, -0.02904537320137024, -0.011398489587008953, -0.03559907153248787, -0.025822103023529053, 0.0026661348529160023, -0.046427711844444275, 0.00962663721293211, 0.03144274279475212, 0.006877064239233732, -0.006836291868239641, 0.03087531588971615, 0.047734569758176804, -0.014351698569953442, -0.024939103052020073, 0.032435670495033264, 0.026616564020514488, 0.04143739119172096, -0.027114735916256905, -0.008815240114927292, 0.05723267048597336, -0.040103133767843246, -0.014925749972462654, 0.032443974167108536, -0.016355201601982117, 0.05255027487874031, 0.03271259739995003, 0.014545956626534462, -0.03670097142457962, 0.03625175729393959, 0.0009111901745200157, -0.020515544340014458, -0.008271392434835434, -0.024416936561465263, 0.0032661810982972383, -0.0051319655030965805, 0.022239048033952713, 0.018978141248226166, -0.01976316049695015, 0.0337078757584095, 0.0330105721950531, 0.006556537002325058, -0.008261332288384438, -0.009504751302301884, 0.0323416143655777, 0.008122503757476807, 0.018040556460618973, -0.045354973524808884, -0.004685690626502037, 0.007185210008174181, -0.014333189465105534, 0.030296562239527702, 0.00469599012285471, 0.025487329810857773, -0.04960809648036957, -0.02676280587911606, 0.013332975097000599, 0.024156102910637856, 0.045983001589775085, -0.03679090365767479, 0.030765678733587265, -0.012250207364559174, 0.004513729829341173, 0.011967351660132408, 0.024126563221216202, -0.016120214015245438, -0.037575699388980865, 0.03790341317653656, -0.027270959690213203, -0.022309865802526474, 0.05482722818851471, 0.02344910055398941, 0.02701367624104023, 0.0009903986938297749, -0.0016787447966635227, -0.020569832995533943, -0.025536464527249336, 0.00016390551172662526, 0.029106732457876205, -0.05357763171195984, 0.04811019450426102, -0.06609094142913818, -0.022211628034710884, 0.050667136907577515, 0.002264519687741995, 0.015338670462369919, 0.025431502610445023, 0.020363785326480865, 0.022172413766384125, 0.04915548115968704, 0.041172634810209274, 0.03593739867210388, -0.004297728184610605, 0.015746191143989563, 0.0294801015406847, 0.01125050988048315, -0.06841416656970978, -0.005323722492903471, -0.005689594428986311, 0.008341589011251926, -0.054131779819726944, 0.01704225316643715, -0.0049935607239604, -0.028573550283908844, -0.05200847238302231, -0.04476512596011162, 0.00832332856953144, -0.033976126462221146, 0.030341705307364464, -0.049528818577528, 0.015710532665252686, 0.052956562489271164, 0.007849236950278282, -0.03228167071938515, 0.012852844782173634, -0.00769824581220746, -0.02101653441786766, 0.009091687388718128, 0.02263648249208927, 0.027879083529114723, -0.03313927724957466, -0.016786007210612297, 0.00041836666059680283, -0.026297474279999733, -0.031723883002996445, 0.007666746620088816, -0.0397334061563015, 0.02818121202290058, -0.10268534719944, 0.01870313473045826, 0.07789792120456696, 0.01959490217268467, 0.03449025750160217, -0.08875471353530884, 0.07535073161125183, 0.030516773462295532, -0.002563208807259798, -0.028291381895542145, 0.013823232613503933, -0.013810728676617146, -0.02765391208231449, 0.05809535086154938, -0.007857543416321278, -0.040032196789979935, 0.014745744876563549, 0.005522674880921841, -0.0190232302993536, -0.022589094936847687, 0.02567039616405964, -0.030805950984358788, -0.020780500024557114, -0.0034848549403250217, -0.0019076222088187933, 0.002169202081859112, 0.019008411094546318, 0.011996560730040073, -0.0423012375831604, -0.01687604747712612, -0.03289536014199257, -0.025477275252342224, 0.014287571422755718, -0.004813679959625006, -0.006795576307922602, 0.020484700798988342, 0.018754489719867706, 0.015183446928858757, 0.0398639477789402, -0.018063344061374664, -0.0363568551838398, 0.05222749337553978, -0.07783445715904236, -0.00973354373127222, -0.022125447168946266, 0.02387731894850731, -0.003290661610662937, -0.04198091849684715, 0.031501054763793945, 0.015834204852581024, -0.016895294189453125, 0.014424102380871773, 0.05153876543045044, -0.005437142215669155, 0.01560265850275755, 0.006800505332648754, 0.060825053602457047, -0.04860776290297508, -0.020528540015220642, 0.012431323528289795, -0.003466334193944931, 0.03827085345983505, -0.001237464020960033, -0.021957308053970337, 0.02895846590399742, 0.02519100345671177, 0.005041742231696844, -0.00024402528651989996, 0.028675617650151253, -0.04390496760606766, -0.0007437761523760855, 0.028132816776633263, 0.0027457980904728174, 0.04119756072759628, -0.012348349206149578, -0.0007375830900855362, 0.030534042045474052, -0.017951615154743195, 0.024607209488749504, -0.032811861485242844, 0.015385217033326626, -0.00342412106692791, 0.019481463357806206, 0.0214847382158041, 0.02460920810699463, 0.02371063642203808, 0.014323298819363117, 0.04350131005048752, -0.016758110374212265, -0.017332013696432114, -0.004589431919157505, 0.006603536661714315, -0.013094352558255196, -0.03508848324418068, -0.007524625863879919, -0.05626852810382843, -0.021411027759313583, -0.02316933311522007, 0.007987640798091888, 0.004335545003414154, 0.006575313862413168, -0.003769678995013237, -0.008633244782686234, 0.028152145445346832, 0.052504152059555054, -0.07515619695186615, -0.0065293097868561745, -0.03544865548610687, -0.013348766602575779, 0.018691057339310646, -0.032618023455142975 ]
<p>Is it possible to calculate the correlation between two proportions, while accounting for the individual sample size that is used to calculate the proportion per individual?</p> <p>For example: How do I calculate the correlation between the proportion of heads from one coin, and the proportion of heads from another coin, when tossed by the same individual. Not every individual tosses every coin as often (some individuals even toss one of the two coins once). </p> <p>Is this even possible?</p>
34,909
[ -0.04455850273370743, -0.02151753567159176, 0.03670977056026459, 0.0019821813330054283, 0.019972871989011765, 0.01688867248594761, -0.03569591045379639, -0.031975965946912766, 0.014086127281188965, -0.008181094191968441, 0.03549018129706383, 0.04110603779554367, 0.0684078112244606, 0.042608462274074554, 0.02063848078250885, 0.016917653381824493, -0.027444826439023018, 0.06226290762424469, 0.014949275180697441, -0.015003742650151253, 0.0027923583984375, 0.008053673431277275, 0.040300726890563965, -0.027040550485253334, -0.000021342060790630057, 0.05682206153869629, 0.051931243389844894, -0.041094355285167694, 0.00828116200864315, 0.0705857202410698, -0.04142376407980919, -0.03558054566383362, 0.040309611707925797, 0.08074847608804703, 0.037591949105262756, -0.03291943669319153, -0.027634702622890472, -0.02917218767106533, 0.026899846270680428, 0.012748563662171364, -0.05807259678840637, -0.03503736853599548, 0.014204219914972782, 0.025447359308600426, 0.0019673723727464676, 0.023208051919937134, -0.020929792895913124, -0.06273406744003296, -0.00017322757048532367, -0.04529310762882233, 0.07564574480056763, 0.012543948367238045, 0.06070172041654587, 0.036856602877378464, 0.014042026363313198, 0.01024188194423914, 0.058114465326070786, 0.04948531463742256, -0.002113815862685442, -0.017726702615618706, 0.0014795871684327722, -0.003580647986382246, -0.001341568655334413, -0.02687310241162777, -0.044044379144907, 0.004623108077794313, -0.02864038199186325, -0.03079262003302574, 0.014075368642807007, 0.0019002495100721717, 0.05743603780865669, 0.021924443542957306, 0.06174027547240257, -0.02756454236805439, 0.0030667500104755163, -0.018227124586701393, 0.02326861210167408, 0.006113169714808464, 0.053211748600006104, 0.05559457838535309, -0.008011835627257824, 0.01495660562068224, 0.05534503608942032, 0.002062777988612652, 0.047333311289548874, -0.0432974174618721, 0.05684133246541023, -0.04008711501955986, 0.011303388513624668, 0.010379343293607235, -0.04265362024307251, -0.013258450664579868, 0.053524795919656754, 0.002884915331378579, -0.032221660017967224, 0.03818005323410034, -0.013295569457113743, 0.048564426600933075, -0.021219313144683838, 0.0011192061938345432, 0.01266075111925602, -0.02614712342619896, 0.01184557843953371, 0.05444171652197838, -0.02368166483938694, -0.029351091012358665, -0.021078364923596382, 0.014661219902336597, -0.003879998344928026, -0.013151129707694054, -0.006724677048623562, -0.002981540746986866, 0.010991211980581284, 0.024650389328598976, 0.03780263662338257, -0.0013457905733957887, -0.021433506160974503, -0.03800361603498459, 0.06562945991754532, 0.06767573207616806, 0.022771406918764114, -0.013411813415586948, -0.006391463801264763, -0.01549623068422079, -0.03255176544189453, 0.03222674876451492, -0.005356427747756243, -0.0019119466887786984, -0.03358990326523781, 0.06855881214141846, 0.004694516770541668, -0.016093948855996132, 0.044829778373241425, 0.013737913221120834, 0.009441525675356388, 0.004721061792224646, -0.08667196333408356, -0.0063569191843271255, 0.046143464744091034, -0.03652419522404671, -0.009556747041642666, -0.059041887521743774, 0.03239980712532997, 0.038948092609643936, 0.03539091348648071, 0.026639189571142197, 0.05447026342153549, -0.023884931579232216, 0.03650045022368431, 0.05193442478775978, -0.017931189388036728, 0.008244967088103294, -0.011781413108110428, 0.007133443374186754, 0.012446845881640911, -0.07518487423658371, 0.03105444647371769, 0.01908467337489128, 0.009595981799066067, -0.012133876793086529, 0.023147493600845337, 0.025459015741944313, -0.02311476320028305, 0.0019517671316862106, 0.03982913866639137, -0.012240239419043064, 0.06010705977678299, -0.008372754789888859, 0.028165139257907867, -0.015494965948164463, -0.0031342972069978714, -0.00801609456539154, 0.03399244323372841, 0.032126545906066895, 0.056071363389492035, -0.022700361907482147, -0.02449345774948597, -0.011181184090673923, 0.006822904106229544, 0.03492597118020058, -0.030193736776709557, -0.0033822632394731045, -0.02939937263727188, -0.0007705743191763759, 0.04829655960202217, 0.036075904965400696, 0.015442436560988426, -0.018330633640289307, -0.01077215000987053, -0.04282176122069359, -0.03783696889877319, -0.08064950257539749, -0.013719700276851654, -0.013421518728137016, -0.02776199020445347, 0.03241749107837677, 0.022299621254205704, 0.020992327481508255, -0.013844078406691551, -0.05578967183828354, -0.03836318850517273, -0.010563766583800316, 0.03425896540284157, -0.03567647188901901, 0.01120664831250906, 0.05224680155515671, 0.03562251850962639, -0.013981127180159092, 0.03497865051031113, -0.003707894589751959, -0.03129807487130165, 0.016349896788597107, -0.032203078269958496, 0.012790909968316555, -0.016755178570747375, -0.013882376253604889, -0.0033413772471249104, 0.02413918450474739, -0.024558041244745255, 0.03677239641547203, -0.01049835979938507, 0.08876872062683105, 0.06678888946771622, -0.0017357292817905545, -0.014594747684895992, 0.01564418524503708, 0.028251593932509422, -0.03305792808532715, -0.021809538826346397, -0.02798757143318653, -0.060911182314157486, 0.022559626027941704, 0.0272993016988039, 0.0481179803609848, -0.038817811757326126, -0.004763335455209017, 0.04722758010029793, 0.03777087479829788, 0.0036806471180170774, 0.03454875573515892, -0.0037946703378111124, -0.023325756192207336, -0.025515899062156677, 0.011721208691596985, 0.019182346761226654, -0.007555149029940367, -0.006734981667250395, -0.01039719209074974, 0.04147408902645111, 0.008374943397939205, -0.043821584433317184, 0.025889387354254723, 0.011879486963152885, -0.014084710739552975, -0.011852404102683067, -0.02210853062570095, 0.026076296344399452, -0.03067460097372532, 0.0026071488391608, 0.026947839185595512, -0.002572249621152878, -0.015108127146959305, 0.007115646731108427, -0.02775673009455204, 0.020837554708123207, 0.06140375882387161, -0.030578695237636566, 0.007381189148873091, -0.0021222811192274094, -0.030884478241205215, -0.015808919444680214, -0.019633926451206207, -0.004193548578768969, -0.04029364138841629, 0.015304955653846264, 0.029001852497458458, -0.011582582257688046, 0.041748274117708206, -0.011472539976239204, -0.041220128536224365, 0.010087928734719753, -0.0019006181973963976, -0.03179974853992462, -0.032715585082769394, -0.08600132167339325, 0.007375669665634632, 0.019077254459261894, -0.01913546770811081, -0.005348873324692249, -0.017244601622223854, -0.01183303538709879, 0.01312373485416174, -0.00007439784531015903, -0.09715777635574341, -0.0035088760778307915, -0.020743098109960556, 0.015950502827763557, -0.03244974464178085, 0.006807503290474415, 0.020390745252370834, 0.018693706020712852, -0.053129371255636215, -0.0051001147367060184, 0.0023774791043251753, -0.014882830902934074, -0.02971554361283779, -0.011278548277914524, 0.0100115817040205, -0.012679310515522957, -0.035689692944288254, 0.031949590891599655, -0.02278825268149376, -0.022366870194673538, -0.06024555116891861, -0.07699304819107056, 0.03714906424283981, 0.013766464777290821, 0.04329664632678032, 0.018546245992183685, -0.024737292900681496, 0.047059882432222366, 0.007618912495672703, -0.0364501029253006, -0.008925392292439938, -0.01603984460234642, 0.006690932437777519, 0.015815379098057747, 0.03652317449450493, 0.02737029828131199, 0.0017416808987036347, 0.013346107676625252, 0.02043008804321289, -0.0036839477252215147, 0.046430498361587524, 0.02270635962486267, 0.01812160387635231, 0.02222762629389763, 0.011732898652553558, -0.011793459765613079, 0.012728544883430004, 0.023874841630458832, -0.08924030512571335, 0.00884290225803852, 0.003896253416314721, 0.02255839668214321, -0.000712111359462142, -0.02716170623898506, -0.001346166362054646, 0.009363069199025631, 0.004853460937738419, -0.06702295690774918, 0.003738830564543605, 0.01393816526979208, -0.004462606273591518, -0.012128297239542007, 0.03710377216339111, 0.03272836655378342, -0.002053337637335062, 0.02504185028374195, 0.06370656192302704, 0.01163338404148817, -0.026771079748868942, -0.034516822546720505, -0.002620783867314458, 0.002253203419968486, 0.03504292294383049, -0.00873012375086546, -0.01431762333959341, 0.0288804043084383, 0.047324288636446, 0.049547478556632996, -0.0191013403236866, -0.00945238396525383, 0.016613001003861427, -0.07394669950008392, 0.0026504620909690857, -0.034247249364852905, 0.0167091004550457, -0.01145357545465231, 0.07415260374546051, 0.03243187814950943, -0.006156171206384897, 0.007427532225847244, -0.013487099669873714, -0.05258620157837868, 0.037074919790029526, -0.020917074754834175, -0.03140302747488022, 0.007560207974165678, -0.038975104689598083, 0.03068840503692627, -0.05519058182835579, -0.0016017621383070946, -0.010733596980571747, 0.029986049979925156, 0.01318957470357418, 0.017071906477212906, 0.0020621870644390583, -0.002664404921233654, 0.031282052397727966, 0.03542940318584442, -0.011586242355406284, -0.02483835630118847, 0.03488703444600105, 0.033373910933732986, 0.008370591327548027, -0.019655240699648857, -0.038107261061668396, 0.042251601815223694, 0.0006891376688145101, 0.050492264330387115, 0.03484010696411133, 0.03161866217851639, -0.07312819361686707, 0.0161999873816967, -0.02225598320364952, 0.05123663321137428, 0.034000884741544724, -0.025971759110689163, -0.023488488048315048, -0.02490907348692417, -0.015652894973754883, 0.004288170021027327, 0.01046711578965187, 0.009441200643777847, -0.006089762784540653, 0.05318282172083855, 0.01930869184434414, -0.05527356266975403, 0.01532016322016716, 0.0640253871679306, 0.019853651523590088, 0.008685316890478134, -0.05500968545675278, 0.006847435142844915, 0.0030210581608116627, 0.016928493976593018, 0.03224778175354004, 0.03464014083147049, -0.008981638588011265, -0.005372733809053898, 0.036508165299892426, 0.004861969966441393, -0.034027617424726486, 0.016049973666667938, -0.014091002754867077, 0.06118881702423096, 0.0020446907728910446, -0.010936548002064228, 0.016118071973323822, 0.029938260093331337, 0.025166887789964676, 0.027917809784412384, -0.005212748423218727, -0.07095763087272644, 0.008617027662694454, 0.020211828872561455, 0.025570319965481758, -0.07663959264755249, 0.04128628224134445, -0.0201139934360981, -0.014506309293210506, 0.06607193499803543, -0.0295630544424057, 0.004867097362875938, -0.005754145793616772, 0.008746744133532047, -0.007851578295230865, -0.03806186467409134, -0.05303327739238739, 0.03122427873313427, -0.02236035093665123, -0.032945916056632996, -0.018072815611958504, -0.02466668002307415, -0.05126542970538139, 0.014864441007375717, 0.0574854239821434, 0.07508304715156555, -0.04344648867845535, -0.012579104863107204, -0.012793627567589283, 0.02203683741390705, 0.003055397653952241, -0.07357873022556305, 0.03772182762622833, -0.0037215801421552896, -0.0004257196851540357, 0.015086228959262371, -0.0130305802449584, -0.03911944106221199, 0.016650380566716194, 0.0039575835689902306, -0.02741917036473751, -0.005224964115768671, -0.019115973263978958, 0.06279097497463226, 0.026436133310198784, 0.008556141518056393, 0.060108453035354614, 0.040074534714221954, 0.014725315384566784, -0.03234926238656044, -0.03527071699500084, 0.013847993686795235, -0.02008286491036415, -0.018595244735479355, -0.035294096916913986, 0.019548974931240082, -0.01227866392582655, 0.02214096486568451, 0.013277340680360794, 0.03380400687456131, -0.024024799466133118, -0.004695727489888668, -0.012068263255059719, 0.0025137115735560656, 0.018880199640989304, 0.013996823690831661, -0.015613622963428497, 0.04305904358625412, 0.005805292632430792, -0.03839600086212158, 0.018247514963150024, -0.019181786105036736, -0.024774720892310143, -0.0035489783622324467, -0.04773929342627525, -0.00782240740954876, -0.049719806760549545, -0.028117364272475243, 0.012083002366125584, -0.0205269493162632, 0.06002483889460564, -0.03657972067594528, 0.045457322150468826, -0.0192338265478611, -0.03672647103667259, -0.01224838849157095, 0.05218791589140892, 0.035206545144319534, 0.046534523367881775, -0.03852568939328194, 0.0210989061743021, -0.02670944854617119, -0.02221660688519478, -0.07830621302127838, -0.01774713769555092, 0.007798295933753252, 0.038848020136356354, 0.014528270810842514, -0.07026658952236176, 0.0034213713370263577, 0.0036725003737956285, -0.009912656620144844, -0.01077836100012064, 0.023997165262699127, 0.014120214618742466, -0.02829050086438656, -0.030542688444256783, 0.005581364501267672, 0.08547252416610718, -0.01799982227385044, -0.00865415669977665, 0.014047534205019474, -0.04182704538106918, -0.0014649973018094897, -0.003486911067739129, 0.015604269690811634, -0.04296279326081276, -0.026805099099874496, -0.026423370465636253, -0.029413387179374695, 0.04947448521852493, -0.032617777585983276, -0.05503982678055763, -0.002879544161260128, -0.0037174008321017027, 0.014883547089993954, -0.015094438567757607, -0.0072645945474505424, 0.002783713163807988, 0.03286002203822136, -0.019857991486787796, 0.005780077539384365, -0.03295379877090454, -0.00582592049613595, 0.03661350905895233, 0.03721816465258598, -0.045548174530267715, 0.04123463109135628, 0.05780671909451485, -0.030051495879888535, 0.008177262730896473, -0.0009119145688600838, -0.014547392725944519, 0.005984194111078978, -0.0031351055949926376, -0.01662033423781395, 0.025768795982003212, 0.02155439741909504, -0.03413565084338188, -0.04284854233264923, -0.021254878491163254, -0.01642378605902195, 0.048447612673044205, -0.03178442269563675, 0.02357751689851284, 0.05493288114666939, -0.0009080778690986335, -0.005234645679593086, -0.01517154648900032, -0.010422119870781898, -0.0028824906330555677, 0.0020294152200222015, 0.049126412719488144, -0.023604385554790497, -0.02416238933801651, 0.03642553463578224, 0.0284408126026392, 0.0023698247969150543, 0.061340779066085815, 0.011185738258063793, 0.0115956487134099, -0.010457048192620277, -0.006822856608778238, -0.024564580991864204, 0.02197401039302349, -0.04320767894387245, -0.0038366822991520166, -0.06453225761651993, -0.02825561724603176, 0.05721844360232353, 0.040090978145599365, -0.01282848883420229, -0.022781897336244583, -0.03355756774544716, -0.013380520977079868, 0.019861724227666855, 0.01177377998828888, 0.0008529434562660754, 0.030690662562847137, -0.010122048668563366, 0.013051762245595455, -0.018882928416132927, 0.02284051664173603, -0.030110793188214302, -0.07159806787967682, -0.03816244751214981, -0.02716728486120701, -0.031951479613780975, 0.050835441797971725, 0.004858190193772316, -0.040987323969602585, 0.03846728801727295, -0.016803530976176262, 0.03555642440915108, -0.013292970135807991, 0.03590817004442215, -0.03711434081196785, 0.06348975747823715, 0.03176959231495857, 0.018703017383813858, -0.00807902216911316, -0.0029954349156469107, 0.10245581716299057, 0.04563949629664421, 0.029972026124596596, -0.044370029121637344, 0.01488113310188055, -0.014633656479418278, -0.011135467328131199, -0.013914819806814194, 0.015814708545804024, -0.004547279793769121, -0.0068750581704080105, 0.02599206194281578, 0.07968844473361969, 0.05298902094364166, -0.022785060107707977, 0.07652824372053146, 0.0036346986889839172, -0.023687245324254036, 0.011952035129070282, 0.008123000152409077, -0.01579463668167591, -0.022531621158123016, -0.03151095658540726, 0.0018337598303332925, -0.01793396659195423, -0.022464729845523834, -0.03854934871196747, -0.005319396965205669, -0.0273139625787735, -0.009342577308416367, -0.048506323248147964, -0.00954057089984417, 0.03753017261624336, 0.001060404465533793, -0.0158659927546978, -0.060750771313905716, 0.044879671186208725, -0.05408238619565964, 0.004142363555729389, 0.024139201268553734, -0.022705473005771637, 0.01931086555123329, -0.014930417761206627, 0.034846480935811996, -0.044046346098184586, -0.021912826225161552, -0.006107359658926725, 0.0216887928545475, 0.0010448091197758913, 0.014275949448347092, -0.021396581083536148, -0.014713394455611706, -0.012291211634874344, -0.023616807535290718, -0.0022889371030032635, 0.024800386279821396, 0.020192664116621017, -0.024737125262618065, -0.019307706505060196, -0.03698419779539108, 0.00742533802986145, -0.02798203006386757, 0.01640419103205204, 0.03711095452308655, -0.003641960211098194, -0.027404725551605225, -0.00759546784684062, 0.02094968408346176, 0.0261834766715765, -0.025318212807178497, -0.02602265775203705, -0.0004015351296402514, -0.017867522314190865, -0.006124404724687338, 0.017298351973295212, 0.01064330991357565, 0.04259606823325157, -0.002896352671086788, -0.011860587634146214, -0.009819461032748222, -0.026676025241613388, 0.029893649742007256, 0.007292673923075199, -0.010531686246395111, -0.026769079267978668, 0.0012850037310272455, 0.04166397079825401, 0.04703560844063759, -0.03255306929349899, -0.017535734921693802, -0.0033255924936383963, 0.015443473123013973, 0.0247966255992651, -0.036796968430280685, -0.007664133794605732, 0.0013105683028697968, -0.026418808847665787, 0.0022354654502123594, -0.0028068702667951584, 0.046776480972766876, 0.011799894273281097, 0.029505625367164612, -0.0008219179580919445, 0.02190738543868065, -0.011109700426459312, 0.026392990723252296, -0.0048024095594882965, -0.022112980484962463, -0.015608693473041058, 0.028244325891137123, -0.01037011668086052, -0.019232332706451416, -0.024761121720075607, -0.03837583586573601, 0.00272188987582922, 0.016226688399910927, -0.014185572974383831, -0.029746772721409798, -0.031617678701877594, -0.00449212733656168, -0.004465762060135603, 0.00931701622903347, 0.0010916641913354397, -0.055389367043972015, -0.04713661968708038, 0.01739964820444584, 0.00033281545620411634, 0.020066412165760994, 0.0370519645512104, -0.0012465021573007107, 0.015196704305708408, 0.0698484554886818, 0.0030427598394453526, 0.02108035795390606, 0.0012523799668997526, 0.002661362988874316, 0.007269912865012884, 0.04610928148031235, -0.031552109867334366, -0.03884761780500412, 0.07622743397951126, -0.062082692980766296, -0.01192424725741148, 0.01747780852019787, -0.030018910765647888, 0.04863746091723442, 0.02986908331513405, 0.004033940378576517, -0.028670374304056168, 0.041007570922374725, -0.03462764993309975, -0.0163143128156662, -0.03566499426960945, 0.02551559917628765, -0.00046948110684752464, -0.02182578854262829, -0.001439432380720973, 0.019059913232922554, -0.02845079079270363, 0.06301495432853699, 0.05494515597820282, 0.014874971471726894, -0.005190293304622173, -0.01195633877068758, 0.03145965188741684, 0.01869582198560238, 0.007533668074756861, -0.01225769892334938, 0.032263483852148056, 0.06294206529855728, -0.02795795165002346, 0.01449669525027275, 0.00528594758361578, 0.01139600109308958, -0.11428001523017883, -0.02738052047789097, 0.01133858785033226, 0.03241296112537384, 0.011944611556828022, -0.02516968920826912, -0.012334940023720264, -0.0024324841797351837, -0.05197324976325035, 0.007944921031594276, 0.005773372482508421, -0.03576929122209549, -0.027468979358673096, 0.028208520263433456, -0.02123689465224743, 0.012267961166799068, 0.02817869372665882, 0.03349840268492699, 0.020423799753189087, 0.01409568078815937, 0.011642497032880783, -0.003910607658326626, -0.04041621461510658, -0.001720244181342423, -0.00843807402998209, -0.07218781113624573, 0.01711931824684143, -0.07110859453678131, -0.03398914635181427, 0.031842660158872604, -0.01241952832788229, 0.03100528195500374, 0.0230258759111166, 0.036256879568099976, -0.008132757619023323, 0.0030170632526278496, 0.034398917108774185, -0.018155770376324654, -0.01531008817255497, 0.015128391794860363, 0.004798879846930504, 0.04187615215778351, -0.030306387692689896, -0.0030829687602818012, 0.04362984746694565, -0.002855443162843585, -0.0031690611504018307, 0.015062257647514343, -0.02680152840912342, -0.027005331590771675, 0.0036689850967377424, -0.004830411169677973, 0.006041452754288912, -0.007352709770202637, 0.041255973279476166, -0.05134853720664978, -0.009133879095315933, 0.04941517859697342, 0.005084753502160311, -0.011495396494865417, -0.0030110080260783434, -0.00509507255628705, -0.017903750762343407, 0.012431398965418339, 0.004858724307268858, -0.016235239803791046, -0.04858054220676422, 0.0013896443415433168, 0.018996724858880043, 0.021831203252077103, 0.024556230753660202, -0.020407378673553467, -0.030453477054834366, 0.022038325667381287, -0.04039936512708664, 0.04459962248802185, 0.021151989698410034, 0.010949886403977871, -0.0029650493524968624, -0.066566102206707, 0.04824478551745415, -0.014791230671107769, -0.024054961279034615, -0.05041608214378357, -0.021810488775372505, -0.038918983191251755, 0.012992420233786106, 0.06699077785015106, -0.005877086892724037, 0.015058830380439758, 0.006853058002889156, 0.05087195709347725, 0.0283052921295166, -0.051985401660203934, 0.01942918822169304, -0.0293695367872715, -0.019847190007567406, 0.0013290704227983952, -0.013123593293130398, -0.011267977766692638, -0.017336327582597733, -0.008519099093973637, -0.016097931191325188, 0.02190835028886795, 0.004449629224836826, -0.015363681130111217, 0.04974285140633583, 0.008005416952073574, 0.006105179898440838, 0.0379013866186142, -0.008359702304005623, 0.001897722133435309, 0.027362143620848656, 0.016671694815158844, -0.054189372807741165, 0.016881683841347694, -0.060124464333057404, -0.045810502022504807, -0.010345586575567722, 0.019982146099209785, 0.007213072385638952, -0.049958236515522, 0.020103739574551582, -0.001143302652053535, -0.059549763798713684, 0.006271077785640955, 0.00875651091337204, 0.019659696146845818, 0.022199133411049843, -0.013343068771064281, -0.015736840665340424, 0.013852418400347233, -0.030823957175016403, 0.0007075448520481586, 0.02650715783238411, 0.012592962943017483, -0.011818583123385906, 0.0010135149350389838, 0.030167819932103157, 0.03016875497996807, -0.0021796217188239098, -0.018920505419373512, -0.004824450239539146, -0.026311621069908142, -0.04936647415161133, 0.022765329107642174, -0.03798253834247589, 0.053756438195705414, 0.01098655629903078, 0.0016828225925564766, 0.07679034024477005, -0.02023659273982048, 0.01421747263520956, -0.020306801423430443, -0.004555525723844767, -0.031824640929698944, 0.003877540584653616, 0.03470660373568535, 0.017575649544596672, 0.0028460295870900154, -0.013563700951635838, 0.010844314470887184, -0.0267926175147295, 0.029967207461595535, -0.025746338069438934, 0.03321216627955437, 0.006503303535282612, -0.01799212209880352, -0.0288140457123518, -0.008709074929356575, -0.049432892352342606, -0.05029233917593956, 0.027905918657779694, 0.015828173607587814, 0.02833789587020874, -0.00860836822539568, -0.03831171616911888, -0.015456224791705608, 0.07662028074264526, -0.07266652584075928, -0.03408544883131981, -0.07844364643096924, 0.0340876542031765, -0.013413290493190289, -0.026774819940328598 ]
<p>I have two factors: <strong>Brainregion (4 levels)</strong> and <strong>Group (5 levels)</strong>. Glutamate is my dependent variable.</p> <p>I am running General Linear Models in SPSS (two factor ANOVA).</p> <p>Can I get the output in such a way that: I can compare means (post-hoc test) of control with other levels such as alcohol, EW etc. (Group) across CC, CB etc. (Brainregion)?</p>
73,759
[ -0.059404123574495316, 0.038353223353624344, -0.017434753477573395, 0.023265954107046127, 0.04314843937754631, 0.022073835134506226, -0.023272037506103516, -0.06648140400648117, 0.024884339421987534, -0.009405403397977352, 0.0490533746778965, 0.031636130064725876, 0.041401565074920654, 0.043510131537914276, -0.0022236329969018698, 0.016342151910066605, 0.017584405839443207, -0.002365819411352277, -0.045780301094055176, 0.027164405211806297, 0.005665530450642109, 0.02682061679661274, -0.021389009431004524, 0.007970250211656094, -0.019520822912454605, 0.09070707112550735, 0.03670800104737282, -0.055811312049627304, -0.014595399610698223, 0.03445759788155556, -0.022297386080026627, -0.06431354582309723, 0.02945566177368164, 0.007901410572230816, 0.0344914048910141, -0.025367485359311104, -0.005147733259946108, -0.016940489411354065, -0.017305094748735428, 0.02365422062575817, -0.03666751831769943, 0.0037145696114748716, -0.03920745477080345, 0.05659809708595276, -0.022500738501548767, 0.029572485014796257, -0.01242891326546669, -0.0033870579209178686, -0.012553565204143524, -0.045571453869342804, 0.02555266208946705, -0.009922494180500507, 0.040845196694135666, 0.046236518770456314, -0.02242126874625683, 0.019455550238490105, 0.05049265921115875, 0.04267062246799469, 0.04181808605790138, -0.05374244228005409, -0.010913725942373276, 0.0009219457861036062, 0.030193425714969635, -0.007349060382694006, -0.060319364070892334, -0.01361682079732418, -0.0017752830171957612, -0.018497681245207787, 0.026492662727832794, -0.01747855544090271, 0.028065508231520653, 0.002902151783928275, 0.014197535812854767, -0.013505754061043262, 0.0022568432614207268, -0.04077301546931267, 0.0300991702824831, 0.009214307181537151, 0.03806177154183388, 0.04738844558596611, 0.011550726369023323, -0.003094025421887636, -0.01818356104195118, 0.029242446646094322, 0.0395449623465538, 0.006102364044636488, 0.05956052243709564, -0.02040049247443676, 0.025631830096244812, 0.06317578256130219, -0.01726427860558033, 0.01461001392453909, 0.024815166369080544, 0.043180979788303375, -0.030345898121595383, -0.021088194102048874, -0.03892090544104576, 0.01350552961230278, 0.008651134558022022, 0.018767409026622772, -0.012396372854709625, -0.053801655769348145, 0.013637932017445564, 0.05567498505115509, -0.025581970810890198, 0.014492525719106197, -0.04079858586192131, -0.0430951826274395, -0.023262392729520798, -0.0026887243147939444, 0.028369996696710587, 0.008497262373566628, 0.01828666403889656, -0.02702704258263111, 0.01702803187072277, -0.03534058853983879, -0.013453922234475613, -0.017706597223877907, 0.02558048814535141, 0.032342586666345596, 0.06675032526254654, -0.04562810808420181, -0.012256196700036526, 0.015296358615159988, -0.01210812572389841, 0.025262722745537758, 0.010385631583631039, -0.010437164455652237, -0.015163863077759743, 0.05920931696891785, 0.014988996088504791, -0.01278605405241251, 0.018300369381904602, -0.007842919789254665, 0.01518706139177084, 0.009510799311101437, -0.06249876692891121, -0.0727182924747467, 0.04819454997777939, -0.047159358859062195, 0.019073273986577988, -0.054548896849155426, -0.024259861558675766, 0.025013219565153122, 0.0500011146068573, -0.011159010231494904, 0.04266649857163429, 0.0020221718586981297, -0.008005592972040176, 0.0201726034283638, -0.01954176276922226, -0.011146840639412403, -0.05157073214650154, -0.029069148004055023, -0.0009507356444373727, -0.09377886354923248, 0.002646339125931263, -0.02539796382188797, 0.0027912782970815897, 0.058444224298000336, 0.02855919860303402, -0.004598408937454224, -0.0193555299192667, 0.0001818365417420864, 0.014557292684912682, 0.007368449587374926, 0.05497274175286293, -0.03829362615942955, 0.0583404004573822, 0.017505865544080734, -0.0171568114310503, 0.012397550977766514, -0.02676370181143284, 0.024532480165362358, 0.0430595837533474, -0.0020389086566865444, -0.03704216703772545, 0.005334649235010147, -0.006045677233487368, 0.0037744613364338875, -0.04880945757031441, -0.006960044149309397, -0.0629795491695404, 0.013286326080560684, 0.04984060302376747, 0.005216418765485287, -0.010005590505897999, -0.01860990561544895, 0.02291109226644039, 0.012341075576841831, -0.023526236414909363, -0.03310913220047951, 0.02166190929710865, 0.036624178290367126, -0.06439638882875443, 0.029261158779263496, -0.016627073287963867, 0.023534830659627914, -0.0030656810849905014, -0.018980447202920914, -0.029977232217788696, -0.007771387230604887, 0.03387151286005974, -0.02140287682414055, 0.008126785047352314, 0.04018969088792801, 0.03830164298415184, -0.01769579015672207, 0.05758294835686684, -0.026731902733445168, -0.02073703147470951, 0.027162494137883186, 0.0013506505638360977, 0.020572632551193237, -0.014595074579119682, -0.019149236381053925, -0.04025522992014885, 0.02984508126974106, -0.025019211694598198, 0.03784763440489769, -0.07579026371240616, 0.07533954083919525, 0.097540482878685, -0.04996999725699425, 0.017973430454730988, -0.016391927376389503, -0.008433892391622066, 0.03180857002735138, -0.04874029755592346, 0.002058467362076044, -0.04342513903975487, -0.02389337122440338, -0.018962541595101357, 0.002749738749116659, -0.03669395670294762, 0.012712405063211918, 0.03730431944131851, 0.00013326512998901308, 0.03913652151823044, 0.010268130339682102, 0.006817845162004232, -0.024922683835029602, -0.011521099135279655, 0.027290087193250656, 0.03896412253379822, 0.0271834097802639, -0.0035184305161237717, 0.013390416279435158, 0.04470627009868622, 0.005149285774677992, 0.027495333924889565, 0.028953660279512405, 0.016534093767404556, -0.011141931638121605, -0.0028212619945406914, -0.01004183478653431, 0.06680554151535034, -0.012843099422752857, 0.026811014860868454, 0.05753630772233009, 0.014688764698803425, -0.041432902216911316, 0.010098329745233059, -0.005549401510506868, 0.021100791171193123, 0.05449218675494194, -0.022849442437291145, -0.00964592956006527, 0.006596521474421024, -0.01817997545003891, 0.02534135803580284, -0.0058039408177137375, 0.0023325616493821144, -0.026798035949468613, 0.013039560057222843, 0.0709083303809166, -0.006051596254110336, 0.01756007969379425, -0.006082110106945038, 0.015905961394309998, -0.0212501622736454, 0.013949671760201454, 0.030110180377960205, -0.00513004045933485, -0.0438481867313385, -0.008788011968135834, -0.039667196571826935, 0.028212789446115494, 0.021919306367635727, -0.011044413782656193, -0.04552100598812103, 0.0417335070669651, 0.018555067479610443, -0.07441070675849915, -0.014650147408246994, -0.039650678634643555, 0.010053848847746849, -0.012199810706079006, -0.008096402511000633, 0.022568009793758392, 0.03458552807569504, -0.03982175886631012, -0.00393551355227828, -0.02406827174127102, 0.026107460260391235, 0.027191413566470146, 0.009012861177325249, 0.0004156037175562233, 0.0286929439753294, 0.013630663976073265, 0.022524680942296982, -0.03148088976740837, 0.006859446410089731, -0.05372350662946701, -0.02357199601829052, 0.04326016455888748, 0.023714588955044746, 0.04590785130858421, -0.03735712915658951, 0.01665676198899746, 0.07100587338209152, 0.026552977040410042, -0.02761819399893284, -0.05266508832573891, -0.040543802082538605, -0.04158763214945793, -0.04252564162015915, 0.016916370019316673, 0.012268157675862312, 0.0014939107932150364, -0.008215108886361122, -0.0018586538499221206, 0.00971877109259367, 0.0788806900382042, 0.016682367771863937, -0.003050681669265032, 0.04200616478919983, 0.0060928394086658955, -0.008911564014852047, 0.04888379946351051, 0.02733028680086136, -0.03354332223534584, 0.004691330716013908, -0.011689429171383381, 0.03248349577188492, -0.013516023755073547, -0.03526905179023743, 0.015230637975037098, -0.02132527343928814, 0.012217182666063309, -0.04337631165981293, 0.04473339021205902, 0.03957995027303696, -0.009090856648981571, 0.0068543148227036, 0.0071459501050412655, 0.022962486371397972, 0.003191915573552251, 0.008060966618359089, 0.043430671095848083, 0.018546314910054207, -0.000468154699774459, -0.015614603646099567, 0.006208142731338739, 0.00875273160636425, 0.0018829095643013716, -0.0357515774667263, -0.038071565330028534, 0.022693097591400146, 0.07598564028739929, 0.0036355338525027037, 0.008142556995153427, -0.022260887548327446, 0.0069698551669716835, -0.08043859153985977, 0.029006123542785645, -0.015580768696963787, 0.02362079545855522, 0.021579323336482048, 0.06603280454874039, 0.012505420483648777, -0.034074071794748306, -0.014928774908185005, -0.014363555237650871, -0.032200101763010025, 0.019616028293967247, 0.006860589142888784, 0.013256678357720375, 0.056724246591329575, -0.05501746013760567, 0.03173353150486946, -0.016703346744179726, 0.017278041690587997, -0.005482851527631283, 0.0316937193274498, -0.007383145857602358, -0.0008232936961576343, 0.001033731852658093, 0.00380206061527133, -0.03714663162827492, -0.015498755499720573, 0.011660882271826267, -0.0001293953973799944, 0.030973166227340698, -0.027965327724814415, 0.000053840180044062436, 0.013429748825728893, -0.01929830014705658, -0.001960292225703597, 0.04469253122806549, 0.05914665758609772, 0.02529992163181305, 0.006745572667568922, -0.03668201342225075, 0.009826312772929668, -0.012043717317283154, 0.056479014456272125, 0.05649082735180855, 0.017297150567173958, -0.0075898063369095325, -0.01163992565125227, -0.01650380529463291, -0.015260618180036545, 0.01610753871500492, -0.00213724747300148, -0.011358213610947132, 0.004709573462605476, 0.028043847531080246, -0.06188931316137314, 0.03134316951036453, 0.020716484636068344, 0.017513848841190338, -0.011504897847771645, -0.020266152918338776, -0.025233836844563484, -0.0186441782861948, -0.027259131893515587, 0.030254820361733437, 0.0016759177669882774, 0.007967722602188587, 0.013336577452719212, 0.0414876714348793, 0.002653607167303562, -0.039530206471681595, -0.0227363258600235, -0.024456439539790154, 0.025861406698822975, 0.005018637515604496, -0.025125863030552864, -0.0012263929238542914, 0.06283113360404968, 0.023110363632440567, -0.004951577167958021, -0.015377086587250233, -0.055943675339221954, 0.0013082276564091444, 0.015163754113018513, 0.059823282063007355, -0.034313369542360306, -0.00873870775103569, -0.00030271499417722225, -0.035035230219364166, 0.016636669635772705, -0.03720369189977646, 0.07497671991586685, -0.02742164209485054, 0.03164162486791611, -0.023822873830795288, -0.03790292888879776, -0.040326617658138275, 0.022943144664168358, -0.0271313413977623, 0.018409516662359238, 0.0007204323774203658, -0.004048523027449846, -0.04110180586576462, -0.028320247307419777, 0.03651928901672363, 0.022077472880482674, -0.018644137308001518, -0.02421562187373638, 0.010251038707792759, 0.049200862646102905, -0.01351950317621231, -0.053744975477457047, 0.02226569503545761, 0.0114593505859375, 0.030064526945352554, 0.07699359953403473, -0.01565154641866684, -0.030598370358347893, 0.0074961804784834385, -0.009707397781312466, 0.004324773326516151, -0.00025035315775312483, 0.00830482505261898, 0.08446953445672989, -0.001228315639309585, -0.011342526413500309, 0.07494596391916275, -0.018525255843997, 0.004440756514668465, -0.014719663187861443, -0.03915317729115486, 0.012586110271513462, -0.018169885501265526, -0.05144527554512024, -0.04515460506081581, -0.029897240921854973, -0.015202374197542667, 0.017069919034838676, -0.04140879213809967, 0.032744284719228745, -0.017287980765104294, -0.008754135109484196, 0.027466384693980217, 0.010836576111614704, -0.01083261426538229, -0.005373470950871706, -0.02051323466002941, -0.0017654809635132551, -0.0066502997651696205, -0.047704633325338364, 0.014401662163436413, -0.03064657188951969, 0.0024493683595210314, 0.014546196907758713, -0.06945968419313431, 0.014136106707155704, -0.020701635628938675, -0.021156663075089455, -0.02408207394182682, -0.05897161737084389, 0.010779015719890594, -0.010510588064789772, 0.03788432851433754, 0.0002057062811218202, -0.0334700345993042, -0.021296894177794456, 0.09115277975797653, 0.004352771211415529, -0.025498904287815094, -0.011061646044254303, 0.06109581142663956, 0.002450762316584587, 0.010338605381548405, -0.06926620006561279, -0.014628161676228046, 0.01827719621360302, 0.011770705692470074, 0.005972179584205151, -0.03032595105469227, -0.022836977615952492, -0.02086358517408371, 0.005571591667830944, -0.01149945892393589, 0.045120153576135635, -0.013220561668276787, 0.02410638891160488, 0.015105955302715302, -0.028312312439084053, 0.07933413237333298, 0.009175734594464302, 0.005009364802390337, -0.005162594839930534, -0.013537352904677391, -0.010716857388615608, -0.04625699669122696, -0.04245376959443092, -0.022414766252040863, -0.02452285960316658, -0.03405135124921799, 0.028827015310525894, 0.03962170332670212, -0.016923071816563606, -0.044750723987817764, 0.005098221357911825, -0.010236729867756367, -0.007692320272326469, -0.04970307648181915, -0.02220352552831173, -0.04496440663933754, -0.013861650601029396, -0.008666547946631908, 0.004330031108111143, -0.03419368714094162, -0.006606754381209612, 0.017519697546958923, -0.0011127861216664314, -0.02409282699227333, -0.001239847857505083, 0.0620717778801918, 0.025169532746076584, 0.029498692601919174, -0.006054013501852751, -0.00486487103626132, 0.022625841200351715, 0.008943786844611168, 0.015145111829042435, 0.0034544956870377064, 0.04811873659491539, -0.026341944932937622, -0.02107142098248005, -0.017626099288463593, -0.007299948483705521, 0.04866912215948105, 0.034970514476299286, 0.030064912512898445, 0.060907650738954544, -0.02982403337955475, -0.0303002018481493, -0.048263344913721085, -0.008395968936383724, 0.019027993083000183, 0.011818086728453636, 0.0758870393037796, -0.005488004069775343, 0.016057493165135384, 0.04428212344646454, 0.018845435231924057, 0.0006183464429341257, 0.056467268615961075, 0.03827116638422012, 0.011577604338526726, 0.021787814795970917, -0.0146515853703022, -0.04102654755115509, 0.01937258429825306, -0.04342053458094597, -0.024182582274079323, -0.04278897866606712, -0.017136873677372932, 0.009437115862965584, 0.04718049243092537, -0.022489745169878006, -0.05381174758076668, -0.02707807719707489, -0.07353321462869644, 0.004558933433145285, 0.011741886846721172, 0.004304187372326851, -0.0000028874051167804282, 0.017337026074528694, 0.04091523960232735, -0.031545061618089676, -0.007283931598067284, -0.0566391721367836, -0.06561238318681717, 0.008593090809881687, -0.02012908086180687, -0.014827555045485497, 0.0498998649418354, -0.02271697297692299, -0.009826325811445713, 0.02428213693201542, -0.04457796737551689, 0.014016746543347836, -0.011064920574426651, 0.02062574215233326, 0.03830364719033241, 0.02844473533332348, 0.01918182708323002, -0.017957506701350212, 0.03912622854113579, 0.014246566221117973, 0.12418187409639359, 0.04163160175085068, 0.003062683390453458, -0.06254836916923523, 0.005518808960914612, 0.014637204818427563, -0.00633039977401495, 0.01160082221031189, -0.025414200499653816, -0.008337273262441158, -0.029825912788510323, 0.028542444109916687, 0.058882471174001694, 0.03703603520989418, -0.021001150831580162, 0.06072064861655235, -0.007183499168604612, 0.030061811208724976, 0.019121861085295677, 0.009863847866654396, -0.014440447092056274, 0.0017909201560541987, 0.0011329979170113802, 0.021019212901592255, 0.01939019188284874, 0.006190670654177666, -0.05153251066803932, 0.009834676049649715, -0.019218340516090393, -0.01308116503059864, -0.0411079078912735, 0.00020034862973261625, -0.0043211751617491245, 0.048388317227363586, -0.023754334077239037, -0.022498667240142822, 0.04300493001937866, -0.05525696650147438, -0.0010987755376845598, 0.028178054839372635, -0.031440794467926025, 0.023971784859895706, -0.003082560608163476, -0.008481983095407486, -0.028277896344661713, -0.02384893037378788, -0.017929336056113243, 0.02373206987977028, -0.006752270273864269, -0.06982798129320145, -0.010583173483610153, -0.0033050747588276863, -0.015478083863854408, -0.02704213559627533, -0.03444380313158035, -0.016247937455773354, 0.02583705633878708, -0.005315802991390228, -0.033357441425323486, -0.06563252210617065, -0.031449053436517715, 0.008135923184454441, -0.007403706666082144, 0.04036435857415199, 0.0038132336921989918, 0.0035128272138535976, -0.05740350857377052, 0.013853233307600021, 0.029430871829390526, -0.011892677284777164, 0.0022184515837579966, 0.009123005904257298, -0.03386311233043671, -0.0031737808603793383, 0.034155163913965225, 0.04142162948846817, 0.008723147213459015, 0.029307112097740173, -0.030144810676574707, -0.020507588982582092, -0.03745986148715019, -0.01637023501098156, -0.053959786891937256, 0.016831664368510246, -0.008878322318196297, 0.030363192781805992, 0.010376041755080223, 0.06393764913082123, 0.009157448075711727, 0.009796684607863426, -0.001203468069434166, 0.019351938739418983, 0.03932506591081619, -0.048488978296518326, -0.035371456295251846, -0.003055328968912363, -0.05295749008655548, 0.00360850733704865, -0.018818216398358345, 0.08629626035690308, 0.022768555209040642, 0.012409616261720657, -0.028652379289269447, 0.02836163341999054, 0.0018136693397536874, -0.0032285128254443407, 0.024240830913186073, -0.05495940148830414, -0.02126087248325348, -0.0011876688804477453, 0.01632959395647049, 0.0019390317611396313, 0.03361661359667778, -0.07107198983430862, -0.046213239431381226, 0.021838119253516197, -0.023172611370682716, -0.017956556752324104, 0.00012590766709763557, -0.004446118138730526, 0.01199969183653593, -0.05958879366517067, 0.013747815042734146, -0.04342474788427353, 0.008895345032215118, 0.008356534875929356, -0.034660179167985916, -0.01107577234506607, 0.007134103216230869, -0.009021573700010777, 0.0040209656581282616, 0.05871231481432915, 0.0008240616880357265, 0.041712455451488495, -0.006006111390888691, 0.03510931879281998, 0.008649957366287708, 0.07452410459518433, 0.052393339574337006, 0.0060883150435984135, -0.008468810468912125, -0.06050915643572807, 0.006065061781555414, -0.004712858237326145, -0.02130739577114582, 0.050539780408144, 0.031782303005456924, 0.016158664599061012, -0.017727423459291458, 0.04147438332438469, 0.013878167606890202, -0.035564303398132324, -0.025428881868720055, 0.006596586667001247, 0.023790249601006508, -0.019406503066420555, 0.007176384795457125, 0.027244364842772484, 0.001955256797373295, 0.013535677455365658, 0.014477815479040146, 0.01809599995613098, -0.01851513423025608, -0.01602625474333763, -0.046849336475133896, 0.03332749381661415, -0.0013272444484755397, -0.033745985478162766, 0.041416630148887634, 0.020839828997850418, -0.009930523112416267, -0.008040794171392918, 0.008931491523981094, 0.00787531491369009, -0.09479543566703796, -0.037163179367780685, -0.01405018474906683, -0.005668330937623978, 0.028628887608647346, -0.027921730652451515, 0.03143661841750145, 0.010692982003092766, -0.07647529244422913, -0.00705306138843298, -0.004978901240974665, -0.014536418952047825, -0.02944091334939003, 0.020999513566493988, -0.051152829080820084, 0.0174166951328516, -0.03728163614869118, 0.03089500404894352, 0.018752535805106163, 0.03419504687190056, 0.021170536056160927, -0.0436738021671772, 0.0022744815796613693, 0.00024078933347482234, 0.052157241851091385, -0.06223447993397713, 0.032415520399808884, -0.03248731419444084, -0.005111801438033581, 0.007905540987849236, -0.03918618708848953, 0.0063065518625080585, 0.032635509967803955, 0.025060303509235382, 0.012950995936989784, 0.06108805909752846, 0.0072129457257688046, 0.006248863879591227, 0.011004844680428505, -0.014859653078019619, -0.02107985131442547, -0.0018804284045472741, -0.03399838134646416, 0.031969405710697174, 0.021254537627100945, -0.005886899773031473, -0.035179514437913895, 0.013447750359773636, -0.002845566254109144, -0.022046424448490143, 0.025579148903489113, -0.0002589814830571413, 0.030689163133502007, -0.018827037885785103, -0.017486847937107086, -0.026760375127196312, 0.002014034427702427, 0.033099375665187836, -0.005772580858319998, -0.03671632334589958, -0.011861216276884079, 0.009020852856338024, -0.036700740456581116, -0.0030996382702142, 0.0020934180356562138, 0.0035845572128891945, -0.07207420468330383, 0.0019098010379821062, -0.03390916436910629, -0.0061813537031412125, -0.02836502157151699, -0.019724922254681587, -0.031637705862522125, 0.05207260698080063, -0.023807963356375694, 0.004207518417388201, 0.0003738208906725049, 0.010461904108524323, 0.04844485595822334, -0.0765000507235527, 0.026805073022842407, 0.0041349115781486034, -0.04163321480154991, -0.03922731801867485, -0.011124838143587112, -0.03780719265341759, 0.04126501455903053, 0.06692689657211304, 0.02633412554860115, 0.018063900992274284, -0.010356356389820576, 0.06707751750946045, -0.009989846497774124, -0.06273958086967468, 0.06011468172073364, -0.004005275666713715, -0.029399307444691658, -0.012785717844963074, 0.030094411224126816, -0.03870156779885292, 0.022931942716240883, 0.038520462810993195, 0.002813141094520688, -0.0033137514255940914, -0.015889709815382957, 0.029640715569257736, 0.058718256652355194, 0.005702266935259104, -0.017698755487799644, 0.03642617538571358, -0.01126096397638321, -0.005762027110904455, 0.03913775458931923, 0.03332282230257988, -0.023708287626504898, 0.021162724122405052, -0.02852327935397625, -0.00735357403755188, -0.010651265271008015, 0.03266999125480652, -0.0279553085565567, -0.042255256325006485, -0.030256740748882294, 0.023915916681289673, -0.03820256143808365, 0.02507300116121769, 0.040341801941394806, 0.017900090664625168, 0.044921763241291046, -0.009193715639412403, 0.02866380475461483, -0.0267737228423357, -0.016323696821928024, 0.021672211587429047, 0.01394727360457182, 0.04146352410316467, 0.018497079610824585, 0.0134495310485363, 0.029362626373767853, -0.020923519507050514, 0.039384983479976654, 0.004529100377112627, 0.02566702291369438, -0.027108483016490936, 0.020348748192191124, 0.01876678131520748, -0.0018024485325440764, 0.05532503500580788, 0.004617670550942421, -0.01684984751045704, 0.044953037053346634, -0.07095182687044144, -0.01623946987092495, -0.034661900252103806, 0.0012361116241663694, -0.03648039326071739, 0.018740961328148842, 0.02030293084681034, 0.04046546295285225, 0.021786155179142952, 0.020397981628775597, 0.0030858663376420736, -0.03185787796974182, 0.014369993470609188, 0.0079093212261796, 0.04726770892739296, 0.0033523410093039274, -0.02322438359260559, -0.007638341281563044, -0.023450134322047234, -0.03857394680380821, -0.04068191349506378, 0.03944821655750275, 0.007490126881748438, 0.010067058727145195, -0.05576270446181297, -0.025358909741044044, 0.017387913540005684, 0.01985820196568966, -0.038871727883815765, -0.03031737543642521, -0.008417951874434948, 0.009554838761687279, -0.036487337201833725, -0.027870554476976395 ]
<p>I am looking for papers, preferably in economics, where simple OLS is used. The reason is that to convey the workings of linear regression, I want to have real data from real papers. Most research uses simultaneous models or other bells and whistles. Also few researchers release their data. I could generate my own data, but as I said, I want to have the whole story of the data and research behind it. Wooldridge (Introductory Econometrics) does a lot of simple analyses from past papers, but as far as I know, these are just simplified version of the real models.</p>
73,760
[ -0.030620481818914413, -0.001627576071768999, -0.011073857545852661, -0.00406126631423831, 0.03754640370607376, 0.03887521103024483, -0.014588989317417145, 0.004745611920952797, 0.00429641455411911, -0.058855991810560226, 0.013995305635035038, 0.038185134530067444, 0.026350371539592743, 0.004501465708017349, 0.006956072058528662, 0.011186868883669376, -0.030919503420591354, 0.026179654523730278, -0.02008628472685814, 0.03555842489004135, 0.010329537093639374, 0.009663159027695656, 0.02574770711362362, 0.00023487427097279578, 0.0010757872369140387, 0.021973464637994766, 0.010268166661262512, 0.006639949046075344, -0.0032838406041264534, 0.047412607818841934, -0.024979032576084137, 0.012029178440570831, -0.022716643288731575, 0.03138333931565285, 0.007032629568129778, -0.005335506051778793, -0.010342184454202652, -0.040962353348731995, 0.030126698315143585, 0.009073514491319656, -0.02971760928630829, -0.006704331841319799, 0.0007493369048461318, 0.021885788068175316, -0.003238369943574071, 0.05419454351067543, 0.02761315368115902, -0.058779072016477585, 0.0088174007833004, -0.04717245325446129, 0.0784512460231781, -0.02488504722714424, 0.00016548417625017464, 0.07140934467315674, -0.002561903791502118, 0.027777643874287605, 0.028503114357590675, 0.021263856440782547, 0.014211161993443966, -0.02463356778025627, -0.009068717248737812, 0.021112928166985512, 0.0007757284911349416, -0.03618356212973595, -0.03325921669602394, 0.023160472512245178, 0.01140197180211544, -0.014419952407479286, 0.05146019160747528, -0.02621079608798027, 0.004042522516101599, 0.026126574724912643, 0.025449655950069427, 0.02846858650445938, -0.03842204436659813, -0.0035512461327016354, -0.008868198841810226, 0.017746681347489357, 0.053815826773643494, 0.019524792209267616, 0.005761940032243729, 0.014253576286137104, 0.033219728618860245, 0.052269432693719864, -0.017617175355553627, -0.010023172944784164, 0.0625329315662384, -0.014618501998484135, 0.026315193623304367, 0.03551766276359558, 0.016433607786893845, -0.008366021327674389, 0.03317766636610031, 0.011263974010944366, -0.026269594207406044, -0.015670346096158028, 0.024930214509367943, 0.04950595274567604, 0.0038916042540222406, -0.012556207366287708, 0.009444238618016243, -0.04740939289331436, -0.010092935524880886, 0.0477050244808197, 0.018235234543681145, -0.05552763119339943, 0.008639814332127571, 0.0015604050131514668, 0.014806634746491909, -0.056691400706768036, 0.019632738083600998, 0.026196332648396492, 0.01682295836508274, -0.026955774053931236, -0.01428903266787529, -0.04860807955265045, 0.006146681495010853, -0.0007533500320278108, 0.07403719425201416, 0.06457848846912384, 0.04130256175994873, -0.040760114789009094, 0.007591980509459972, -0.023381784558296204, -0.016320563852787018, -0.006484149023890495, 0.008795862086117268, -0.02594575099647045, -0.04334726557135582, 0.06259705871343613, 0.006318219471722841, -0.06285372376441956, 0.00669666426256299, -0.030982358381152153, 0.0630621388554573, 0.0028985689859837294, -0.0572577603161335, -0.05079920217394829, 0.017784733325242996, -0.014052540063858032, 0.020856419578194618, -0.014877749606966972, -0.011992011219263077, -0.005035579204559326, 0.042765598744153976, 0.014107637107372284, 0.04432832449674606, 0.018375279381871223, 0.02033885009586811, 0.011624020524322987, -0.025634480640292168, -0.0049832905642688274, 0.023335296660661697, 0.004366341046988964, 0.014822951517999172, -0.07743261009454727, 0.031918808817863464, 0.017780199646949768, 0.020723365247249603, -0.009518899954855442, 0.0737830102443695, 0.0194400567561388, -0.00982775166630745, 0.015254258178174496, -0.028198881074786186, -0.04733835905790329, 0.04956794157624245, -0.03613332659006119, -0.008161446079611778, -0.006112636532634497, 0.003824947401881218, 0.015426253899931908, 0.017027705907821655, 0.032377682626247406, 0.0004975495394319296, -0.016957953572273254, 0.004198427312076092, 0.0171938668936491, -0.012527331709861755, 0.03224050626158714, -0.08138376474380493, -0.010345736518502235, 0.00635688379406929, -0.010983677580952644, -0.005126838572323322, 0.05490307882428169, -0.003929463680833578, -0.0075853061862289906, 0.027965327724814415, -0.06556940078735352, -0.046817127615213394, -0.044947944581508636, 0.06638062000274658, -0.027011994272470474, -0.010862762108445168, 0.053747452795505524, 0.019329315051436424, 0.0036476561799645424, -0.003988290671259165, -0.055792324244976044, 0.041097741574048996, 0.017240315675735474, 0.042711954563856125, -0.04619869217276573, 0.017526524141430855, 0.03259185329079628, 0.029230322688817978, -0.02909013070166111, 0.02783399261534214, -0.03557562828063965, -0.04093106836080551, 0.02051122486591339, -0.012524936348199844, 0.03455764800310135, -0.010233001783490181, 0.004329420160502195, -0.008631663396954536, -0.02025827020406723, 0.0015796413645148277, 0.075526662170887, -0.07072459161281586, 0.024868976324796677, 0.04868372902274132, 0.03505520150065422, -0.0020144854206591845, 0.03607087954878807, -0.0004202979034744203, 0.005101923830807209, 0.009720327332615852, -0.00912362802773714, -0.015725642442703247, -0.003645779099315405, 0.06005207076668739, 0.01731390506029129, -0.04413720220327377, 0.009648323059082031, 0.046942442655563354, 0.02150649204850197, -0.0036567547358572483, 0.04083319380879402, -0.022680368274450302, -0.059491001069545746, -0.002064506756141782, -0.013019155710935593, 0.024366136640310287, 0.04762144759297371, -0.00532176811248064, 0.02248525805771351, 0.014181327074766159, 0.027632202953100204, -0.018013861030340195, 0.04263513907790184, 0.005323582794517279, -0.03859312832355499, -0.00008647915092296898, -0.020403236150741577, 0.07521262019872665, -0.049703553318977356, 0.012524975463747978, 0.007529826834797859, 0.00858550425618887, 0.02018645778298378, 0.02021985501050949, -0.02367427945137024, -0.006029705982655287, -0.003768656635656953, -0.028262170031666756, 0.026915060356259346, 0.03169102966785431, -0.03031676448881626, 0.036495622247457504, -0.030843166634440422, 0.0016785049811005592, -0.06378605961799622, 0.01532397884875536, 0.019203128293156624, 0.01539659220725298, 0.0027643281500786543, -0.012279529124498367, -0.04124541953206062, 0.019338032230734825, -0.02113119512796402, 0.05867058038711548, 0.009044977836310863, -0.023621859028935432, 0.04984382167458534, -0.03436073660850525, -0.026286575943231583, 0.04600927233695984, 0.011690732091665268, 0.02281879261136055, 0.048679836094379425, -0.0026598097756505013, -0.06211656332015991, -0.0620870441198349, -0.01663563959300518, -0.01769784465432167, -0.03219883143901825, 0.013621238991618156, 0.015622276812791824, -0.0038075121119618416, -0.015288645401597023, -0.017355578020215034, -0.00655837869271636, -0.0262303426861763, 0.0042223683558404446, -0.02062247321009636, -0.0020842391531914473, -0.008740666322410107, 0.02220034971833229, 0.03195308893918991, -0.05211148411035538, -0.03561503067612648, -0.09862979501485825, -0.05827584117650986, 0.007018510717898607, -0.010260498151183128, 0.010886692441999912, 0.0023558796383440495, -0.02100086770951748, 0.07019712030887604, -0.0021888529881834984, -0.008689183741807938, -0.05281803011894226, 0.029432442039251328, -0.012530547566711903, -0.024176327511668205, 0.035373128950595856, -0.02269916795194149, -0.0012957402504980564, 0.03379158675670624, -0.008784373290836811, 0.023767558857798576, 0.03754883632063866, 0.02631540410220623, 0.05202239751815796, 0.013808827847242355, -0.052515316754579544, -0.015183400362730026, 0.0031781713478267193, 0.017021387815475464, -0.05164657533168793, 0.03994520381093025, 0.018873300403356552, 0.02483665570616722, 0.009633631445467472, -0.0651724711060524, 0.024839824065566063, -0.006889598444104195, -0.030295854434370995, -0.007266491185873747, -0.01409999281167984, -0.007810747250914574, -0.03483421355485916, -0.01482747495174408, 0.028219174593687057, -0.030665211379528046, 0.01201967429369688, 0.01842687278985977, 0.01586315594613552, 0.0033197756856679916, -0.007488506846129894, -0.00011895863281097263, -0.03619511052966118, 0.02555842138826847, 0.01922382041811943, -0.0001514585455879569, 0.008882928639650345, 0.046013396233320236, 0.05178028717637062, 0.002943597733974457, -0.03148515895009041, -0.03685943782329559, 0.005358345806598663, -0.08849606662988663, -0.007019323762506247, -0.041510988026857376, 0.027264291420578957, 0.012691502459347248, 0.03164205700159073, -0.053439680486917496, 0.0165875144302845, 0.024556782096624374, 0.013152537867426872, -0.09254266321659088, 0.035694412887096405, -0.03524473309516907, 0.01612897403538227, 0.029095986858010292, 0.031636759638786316, 0.016130894422531128, -0.017384931445121765, -0.024830978363752365, -0.021708734333515167, 0.017559392377734184, -0.00812492985278368, -0.02843336947262287, 0.0031224198173731565, -0.034798163920640945, 0.02052571065723896, -0.02184436097741127, -0.0036490827333182096, -0.034977760165929794, -0.016160696744918823, 0.03870129957795143, -0.017103519290685654, -0.042355749756097794, -0.03686509653925896, 0.030585190281271935, 0.03152437135577202, 0.027966640889644623, 0.01679850183427334, 0.006931419018656015, -0.014189554378390312, 0.06670031696557999, -0.005902392324060202, 0.043584927916526794, 0.028411930426955223, 0.033208876848220825, -0.004805128555744886, -0.04266752675175667, -0.0027406245935708284, 0.022274784743785858, -0.005814239848405123, 0.020287180319428444, -0.04507504776120186, 0.027477458119392395, 0.015608841553330421, -0.01819535903632641, -0.008492670953273773, 0.047886669635772705, -0.00669855484738946, 0.022506823763251305, -0.016715386882424355, -0.021150127053260803, -0.008779825642704964, 0.010927273891866207, 0.026109175756573677, 0.005658193025738001, 0.012295159511268139, -0.029263686388731003, 0.059046242386102676, -0.0019144682446494699, -0.018851542845368385, 0.00020808436966035515, 0.01885964907705784, 0.054903674870729446, -0.004523518029600382, -0.031203024089336395, 0.06383321434259415, 0.09694768488407135, 0.04848708584904671, 0.0345928817987442, 0.022799262776970863, -0.06264478713274002, 0.02306489087641239, 0.0321279875934124, 0.04831736534833908, -0.03196288272738457, 0.02078361064195633, -0.042673926800489426, -0.02368052490055561, 0.042326126247644424, -0.006828991696238518, 0.015989739447832108, -0.019455431029200554, -0.0017202554736286402, -0.01967446506023407, 0.020228449255228043, -0.03883006423711777, -0.027108371257781982, 0.021923402324318886, 0.018928267061710358, -0.02874564565718174, -0.03139203414320946, -0.06190019100904465, 0.02199413627386093, 0.04606373608112335, -0.003420470282435417, 0.0062743560411036015, -0.018617143854498863, 0.04823130741715431, 0.05617351830005646, -0.04469480738043785, -0.06504051387310028, 0.0132423872128129, -0.014825448393821716, -0.005227753426879644, 0.02993432618677616, 0.03217208385467529, -0.028841497376561165, -0.023458117619156837, -0.014752741903066635, -0.0464804582297802, -0.015166226774454117, -0.00754769891500473, 0.01595417968928814, 0.035914842039346695, 0.010120450519025326, 0.056893110275268555, 0.04380820319056511, 0.008159366436302662, -0.009921413846313953, -0.03224506974220276, 0.01667170599102974, -0.025793317705392838, -0.04115646332502365, -0.048654865473508835, -0.004698806442320347, -0.011751841753721237, 0.003150391858071089, -0.013892622664570808, 0.015154365450143814, -0.025645868852734566, -0.033475689589977264, 0.002680620877072215, 0.01751350797712803, -0.029918938875198364, -0.031985677778720856, 0.013003344647586346, 0.035837940871715546, -0.008923293091356754, -0.019836122170090675, -0.013966375030577183, 0.003743233857676387, 0.009816375561058521, 0.014755461364984512, -0.03849940001964569, 0.015611994080245495, -0.046780623495578766, -0.02897380106151104, 0.00007555097545264289, -0.03858356550335884, 0.03100048005580902, -0.004986629821360111, 0.011774583719670773, 0.02643304318189621, -0.06316445767879486, -0.023172613233327866, 0.009378721006214619, 0.021997949108481407, 0.01545941736549139, -0.05986684560775757, 0.008530311286449432, -0.01030340138822794, -0.0518665574491024, -0.05124189704656601, -0.0524243600666523, 0.034894537180662155, -0.022557606920599937, -0.04886166378855705, -0.0354195162653923, 0.025018027052283287, 0.0044724722392857075, -0.030782535672187805, -0.03613938018679619, 0.049966052174568176, -0.04473709315061569, 0.02966459095478058, -0.016051651909947395, 0.0009196135797537863, 0.036533012986183167, -0.02970077656209469, -0.02429000847041607, -0.019658483564853668, -0.01515389047563076, 0.0017652385868132114, 0.005956896580755711, 0.013852057978510857, -0.015561804175376892, 0.004238736350089312, -0.0344281867146492, -0.014156733639538288, -0.007754199206829071, -0.05095762014389038, -0.003893865505233407, 0.05231964960694313, 0.012216693721711636, 0.0041375067085027695, -0.006408788729459047, 0.016113804653286934, -0.015206151641905308, 0.0032340555917471647, -0.04142240807414055, 0.005114874802529812, 0.005558899603784084, -0.02651985175907612, 0.02803220972418785, -0.029009457677602768, -0.014819321222603321, 0.027827443554997444, 0.09531465917825699, 0.018152084201574326, -0.028719870373606682, 0.027749547734856606, -0.02455504797399044, 0.020451605319976807, -0.004065029323101044, -0.008201378397643566, 0.004304307978600264, 0.017793113365769386, -0.03868686035275459, -0.08235678821802139, -0.0041770185343921185, 0.008545436896383762, 0.03774798661470413, 0.045035894960165024, 0.05710182711482048, 0.07914097607135773, -0.011431591585278511, -0.03788874298334122, -0.0053632534109056, -0.01320058386772871, -0.006984974257647991, 0.016312502324581146, 0.05343615636229515, -0.023417871445417404, -0.0007546437554992735, 0.013658287934958935, 0.045954588800668716, -0.00008588874334236607, 0.03670797869563103, -0.013001727871596813, 0.019252611324191093, 0.04637979716062546, -0.038229163736104965, -0.06549894064664841, 0.02678043209016323, 0.0026145828887820244, 0.023467140272259712, -0.028990238904953003, -0.036446597427129745, 0.044218748807907104, 0.035280097275972366, 0.04525688290596008, -0.05141953006386757, -0.02817360684275627, -0.05117091163992882, 0.054877035319805145, 0.004188633989542723, -0.05020799860358238, 0.0021319868974387646, 0.036259688436985016, 0.013456198386847973, -0.007749558426439762, 0.022465815767645836, -0.01719902828335762, -0.053652312606573105, -0.03544345125555992, -0.001702292705886066, -0.010502210818231106, 0.016271330416202545, 0.03049599938094616, -0.008816907182335854, 0.03335651755332947, -0.05975905433297157, 0.0104946568608284, 0.028127405792474747, 0.028530843555927277, 0.012768186628818512, 0.051590919494628906, -0.03488951176404953, -0.03413543850183487, -0.016490768641233444, -0.049349505454301834, 0.12694771587848663, 0.08804871886968613, 0.017597470432519913, -0.10083285719156265, 0.05732205882668495, 0.010323556140065193, -0.011583737097680569, -0.002750250045210123, -0.01370810717344284, -0.021083591505885124, -0.008990531787276268, 0.03194978088140488, 0.06688681244850159, 0.01387727539986372, -0.028948450461030006, 0.047679558396339417, -0.015546503476798534, -0.026235431432724, -0.0187089666724205, -0.01385771855711937, 0.02602909505367279, -0.003674441482871771, -0.045601826161146164, 0.03687259182333946, 0.0031753391958773136, -0.0599726103246212, -0.04992388188838959, -0.06489168852567673, 0.028332127258181572, -0.014414319768548012, -0.03963138535618782, -0.017403652891516685, 0.049514271318912506, 0.05710282176733017, -0.010829229839146137, 0.043776266276836395, -0.013510887511074543, -0.029512465000152588, 0.023464767262339592, 0.010027704760432243, 0.006352073512971401, -0.02070683240890503, 0.014382376335561275, -0.0007745312177576125, -0.03291111811995506, -0.014520975761115551, -0.03688668832182884, 0.01822979561984539, -0.01917777955532074, -0.010579507797956467, -0.022221343591809273, -0.00014769587141927332, 0.011066464707255363, -0.007457534782588482, -0.047557368874549866, 0.03585221618413925, 0.031879112124443054, -0.03868020325899124, -0.0007992587052285671, -0.009961878880858421, 0.0035126712173223495, -0.00595605606213212, 0.027894029393792152, 0.019957151263952255, -0.032566845417022705, -0.03379814326763153, -0.018719680607318878, 0.02804921381175518, 0.004736332222819328, -0.025436537340283394, 0.002301635453477502, 0.0016435839934274554, -0.021257946267724037, -0.01037494745105505, 0.02427041530609131, 0.017558081075549126, 0.02708115242421627, -0.008513919077813625, -0.02414725534617901, -0.008512210100889206, -0.016718126833438873, 0.0015933325048536062, 0.011974556371569633, -0.032767973840236664, -0.06311431527137756, 0.007481086533516645, 0.031231582164764404, 0.024657264351844788, 0.007335266564041376, -0.023359976708889008, -0.004295565653592348, 0.0057221525348722935, 0.01037933211773634, -0.04705946519970894, 0.018002517521381378, -0.003435212653130293, -0.05164458230137825, -0.016776954755187035, -0.00873170979321003, 0.0516219325363636, 0.01779569312930107, 0.008767418563365936, -0.013524273410439491, 0.009924890473484993, -0.02099727652966976, 0.014501862227916718, 0.027712382376194, -0.06469270586967468, 0.043143436312675476, 0.022072724997997284, 0.021510936319828033, -0.027352696284651756, -0.02450300008058548, -0.022576535120606422, 0.012024079449474812, -0.024883456528186798, 0.0034757123794406652, -0.04549085348844528, 0.06767807900905609, -0.007788137067109346, 0.020443452522158623, -0.025308391079306602, -0.016216296702623367, -0.03449082002043724, -0.017860373482108116, 0.0132257966324687, -0.004985783249139786, -0.009377042762935162, 0.004946606699377298, 0.03324451297521591, -0.006639525294303894, 0.047778815031051636, 0.03386765718460083, -0.01347975991666317, 0.010028203949332237, 0.012138988822698593, 0.0099893007427454, 0.006715029012411833, -0.025659723207354546, -0.048363205045461655, 0.02421414665877819, -0.01740499772131443, -0.008681478910148144, -0.006439574528485537, -0.01539562363177538, 0.014815270900726318, 0.01563740335404873, -0.01694279909133911, -0.039946675300598145, 0.049776893109083176, -0.00009365733421873301, 0.020033536478877068, 0.005876131821423769, 0.018043644726276398, 0.02685713768005371, 0.03580522909760475, 0.019637227058410645, -0.0023475815542042255, -0.006304196082055569, 0.002057167934253812, 0.029934534803032875, -0.004554445389658213, 0.009867671877145767, -0.0059240711852908134, 0.0037318856921046972, -0.02461991086602211, 0.012374212965369225, -0.0020394183229655027, 0.018266312777996063, 0.06677422672510147, -0.07689572125673294, 0.0316290557384491, 0.034979525953531265, 0.016105221584439278, -0.07591002434492111, 0.03640775382518768, 0.031472206115722656, 0.033316344022750854, 0.048774730414152145, -0.06352246552705765, 0.0013775021070614457, 0.013996330089867115, -0.04033719003200531, -0.04330126568675041, -0.013108388520777225, -0.012619832530617714, -0.007979863323271275, -0.06302117556333542, -0.025110330432653427, 0.02728506736457348, -0.012229403480887413, 0.0371428020298481, 0.01930108107626438, 0.026357829570770264, 0.025308208540081978, 0.0025314907543361187, -0.00027002321439795196, 0.020007573068141937, 0.009602930396795273, -0.04227212071418762, 0.03656955808401108, -0.02586100623011589, -0.014920203015208244, 0.043989554047584534, -0.013786982744932175, 0.009182244539260864, -0.0026659194845706224, 0.041467420756816864, -0.014328574761748314, 0.06724970787763596, 0.03271584212779999, 0.023262187838554382, -0.0064481403678655624, -0.019936585798859596, 0.02464558742940426, -0.003653506515547633, 0.016230633482336998, 0.04949461296200752, 0.030972423031926155, -0.020093146711587906, 0.0017400210490450263, 0.009866263717412949, 0.0004908760893158615, -0.0033509409986436367, 0.0010312702506780624, -0.0369841493666172, 0.01904265582561493, -0.01347859762609005, 0.0362168550491333, -0.03913692757487297, -0.017123013734817505, 0.01705540344119072, 0.008532793261110783, -0.04569145292043686, 0.060142144560813904, -0.04015708714723587, -0.02988170087337494, 0.02975529618561268, -0.010508132167160511, 0.037192847579717636, -0.07300223410129547, -0.009776493534445763, 0.029179329052567482, -0.02070065587759018, -0.034154560416936874, -0.01601283624768257, -0.04264817386865616, 0.017247971147298813, -0.03003617189824581, -0.003232675138860941, 0.01598936691880226, -0.014689057134091854, 0.035778291523456573, -0.05540494620800018, 0.06812632828950882, 0.010763626545667648, 0.007266483269631863, 0.01721837744116783, 0.0008181867888197303, -0.03712330386042595, -0.01795821078121662, 0.030925747007131577, -0.04254714772105217, 0.005758274346590042, -0.025307588279247284, 0.006287055090069771, 0.006305045913904905, -0.028595181182026863, 0.053665321320295334, 0.00034788541961461306, -0.025397447869181633, -0.0207375418394804, -0.015909725800156593, 0.017158621922135353, -0.0040685757994651794, 0.008747169747948647, 0.00001660531052039005, -0.02994036115705967, -0.014792886562645435, -0.02648489736020565, 0.03493845462799072, 0.04204670339822769, -0.016994142904877663, 0.024160025641322136, 0.00832519680261612, 0.014978465624153614, 0.017844611778855324, -0.0005756770842708647, -0.04275568202137947, 0.02147143892943859, -0.027330245822668076, -0.005305045284330845, -0.006976826582103968, -0.012491150759160519, -0.004601673688739538, -0.02702074684202671, -0.0015849362825974822, -0.017641548067331314, -0.008691394701600075, -0.003658850910142064, 0.03320048376917839, 0.0032382619101554155, 0.03516068309545517, 0.01694151572883129, 0.0228259339928627, 0.03272455185651779, 0.01061728224158287, 0.024316323921084404, 0.0014854073524475098, 0.0526740625500679, 0.0455271378159523, 0.008524260483682156, 0.061928290873765945, -0.030200611799955368, 0.05745308846235275, -0.037800468504428864, 0.03378819674253464, -0.05767185613512993, -0.032504480332136154, 0.030042361468076706, -0.02842138335108757, 0.0417485348880291, -0.011074711568653584, 0.004591708537191153, 0.05132544785737991, -0.049977775663137436, 0.023645011708140373, -0.026089614257216454, 0.004216155037283897, -0.0253200251609087, -0.032389748841524124, -0.006239135283976793, 0.0028747005853801966, 0.006096584256738424, 0.029978953301906586, -0.04608941078186035, -0.0002677965094335377, 0.021410005167126656, -0.004255610518157482, 0.010063230991363525, 0.0020703093614429235, -0.0512518472969532, -0.004549269564449787, -0.018181923776865005, 0.004786381963640451, -0.01839987188577652, 0.04416721686720848, 0.023434661328792572, 0.004922545049339533, -0.025775369256734848, 0.01718754507601261, -0.024440638720989227, 0.050055261701345444, -0.09307963401079178, 0.03744661062955856, -0.03478260710835457, 0.011272609233856201, -0.036243267357349396, 0.0006190109997987747 ]
<p>Let $X_1$, $X_2$, ..., $X_n$ be iid RV's with range $[0,1]$ but unknown distribution. (I'm OK with assuming that the distribution is continuous, etc., if necessary.)</p> <p>Define $S_n = X_1 + \cdots + X_n$.</p> <p>I am given $S_k$, and ask: What can I infer, in a Bayesian manner, about $S_n$?</p> <p>That is, I am given the sum of a sample of size $k$ of the RV's, and I would like to know what I can infer about the distribution of the sum of all the RV's, using a Bayesian approach (and assuming reasonable priors about the distribution).</p> <p>If the support were $\{0,1\}$ instead of $[0,1]$, then this problem is well-studied, and (with uniform priors) you get beta-binomial compound distributions for the inferred distribution on $S_n$. But I'm not sure how to approach it with $[0,1]$ as the range...</p> <p><strong>Full disclosure</strong>: I already <a href="http://mathoverflow.net/questions/90580/bayesian-inference-on-sum-of-random-variables" rel="nofollow">posted this on MathOverflow</a>, but was told it would be better posted here, so this is a re-post.</p>
47,785
[ -0.019196409732103348, -0.03304425626993179, 0.019545795395970345, 0.00475838640704751, 0.016603777185082436, 0.011879929341375828, 0.003912203945219517, 0.0009111952385865152, 0.04373755306005478, -0.08068742603063583, 0.03662148863077164, 0.034890566021203995, 0.0390041209757328, -0.006430927664041519, 0.006231751758605242, 0.021141456440091133, -0.025361189618706703, -0.0143438084051013, -0.010032523423433304, -0.031831253319978714, 0.017078405246138573, 0.029801666736602783, 0.03806832432746887, -0.004547578282654285, -0.05233174189925194, 0.008705598302185535, 0.0226149745285511, -0.011619684286415577, 0.001109444536268711, 0.06578835844993591, -0.010200443677604198, -0.0020933260675519705, 0.007650725077837706, 0.04962747544050217, -0.013889532536268234, -0.003504972904920578, -0.01588805764913559, -0.001056172652170062, 0.015150661580264568, 0.029178239405155182, -0.029573723673820496, -0.027149394154548645, -0.0005791214061900973, 0.006629529874771833, -0.030396144837141037, 0.002242325572296977, 0.025111252442002296, -0.06328381597995758, 0.012253900058567524, -0.04742277041077614, 0.044319260865449905, 0.01949557103216648, 0.03725097328424454, 0.05769900605082512, -0.02676358073949814, -0.035754818469285965, 0.01080286968499422, 0.052729807794094086, 0.03201054036617279, -0.035182032734155655, 0.0027316531632095575, -0.03856784477829933, -0.0045934757217764854, -0.03353223577141762, -0.05909866467118263, 0.021408962085843086, -0.019402531906962395, -0.01849331706762314, -0.0064810155890882015, -0.01905483938753605, 0.03434096276760101, 0.04812910035252571, -0.0006375785451382399, 0.018016455695033073, -0.000883570231962949, 0.010243533179163933, 0.03893788158893585, 0.028072567656636238, 0.07005500793457031, 0.01789311319589615, 0.01160679291933775, -0.00396549329161644, 0.05705126002430916, 0.0471024289727211, 0.009770478121936321, -0.032228562980890274, 0.06199188530445099, 0.00383971119299531, 0.01381840743124485, -0.005697388201951981, -0.022255538031458855, 0.002559095621109009, 0.03477846831083298, -0.003950624726712704, -0.056576866656541824, 0.05627945438027382, -0.03960195183753967, 0.053935252130031586, -0.00811330322176218, -0.055248454213142395, 0.004859986715018749, -0.04006224870681763, 0.0008735720766708255, 0.07918933779001236, -0.03175719827413559, -0.028622159734368324, -0.010986916720867157, 0.02424977347254753, -0.026503410190343857, -0.033526401966810226, -0.03750704601407051, 0.04101482406258583, 0.006899975705891848, -0.010695875622332096, 0.0031645840499550104, 0.005520195234566927, -0.006369743961840868, -0.04665890708565712, 0.04716230183839798, 0.07925334572792053, 0.028249017894268036, 0.0016678868560120463, 0.022040706127882004, -0.019864413887262344, -0.060341257601976395, 0.01022112462669611, -0.003806240623816848, -0.03529426082968712, -0.02667171135544777, 0.06800827383995056, 0.007973791100084782, -0.013196892105042934, 0.04425904154777527, 0.01621220074594021, 0.007281587924808264, -0.006257099099457264, -0.03619857132434845, -0.013168377801775932, 0.03611164167523384, -0.011978129856288433, -0.019005684182047844, -0.05070077255368233, 0.005293188616633415, 0.044932201504707336, 0.002985754981637001, -0.025483064353466034, 0.07091682404279709, 0.012610168196260929, 0.035224538296461105, 0.03250917047262192, -0.03666922450065613, -0.05538741499185562, -0.028655176982283592, -0.0154308145865798, -0.02185976877808571, -0.0683618038892746, 0.04053984582424164, -0.009009575471282005, -0.008521023206412792, -0.019548390060663223, 0.032445162534713745, 0.001970515353605151, -0.012232835404574871, -0.023801589384675026, 0.034141380339860916, -0.01906297542154789, 0.06563833355903625, 0.02156497724354267, 0.02301677316427231, 0.027984317392110825, -0.017880059778690338, -0.0012212299043312669, 0.029036344960331917, 0.040751516819000244, 0.057717788964509964, -0.031219039112329483, -0.012990504503250122, 0.007809984032064676, 0.012220155447721481, 0.011026092804968357, -0.00042243642383255064, -0.009408882819116116, -0.031187381595373154, -0.01907319203019142, 0.01668136566877365, 0.07578856498003006, 0.027494989335536957, -0.037269096821546555, -0.010873755440115929, -0.04153863713145256, -0.002710252068936825, -0.054703518748283386, -0.041906073689460754, 0.0006102147744968534, -0.0468689501285553, 0.021238118410110474, -0.00020794238662347198, 0.02906259149312973, 0.0014809095300734043, 0.004628801252692938, -0.04607365280389786, -0.015203049406409264, 0.03176770359277725, -0.021958371624350548, 0.023120038211345673, 0.03283613547682762, 0.04899591952562332, -0.0050634341314435005, 0.05200501158833504, -0.0226946659386158, -0.06518734246492386, -0.014689882285892963, -0.02536206692457199, 0.015109909698367119, 0.0029248828068375587, 0.016329994425177574, -0.008504902943968773, -0.0306460689753294, 0.015614764764904976, 0.016026200726628304, -0.02032148279249668, 0.06113804131746292, 0.06634101271629333, 0.03705213963985443, -0.008977526798844337, 0.027349546551704407, 0.018681177869439125, -0.012750211171805859, -0.003086747834458947, -0.014071322046220303, -0.047569189220666885, -0.0010196364019066095, 0.040582701563835144, 0.038182150572538376, -0.024578597396612167, 0.017157254740595818, 0.02829378843307495, 0.02075081691145897, 0.01203922275453806, 0.024162882938981056, 0.003789179492741823, 0.007825677283108234, 0.020388923585414886, 0.027357960119843483, 0.013479374349117279, -0.022059768438339233, -0.006498156581073999, 0.0012194325681775808, 0.051812343299388885, -0.005238494370132685, -0.022307930514216423, 0.003840566612780094, -0.011862292885780334, 0.004810198210179806, -0.04602561891078949, 0.0023562766145914793, 0.011546256951987743, -0.01026175171136856, -0.002481253817677498, 0.007463532499969006, 0.02794080227613449, -0.00994808692485094, 0.005965354386717081, -0.015333820134401321, 0.05247605964541435, 0.03224610537290573, -0.0454738512635231, -0.017154086381196976, 0.02648381143808365, -0.054043982177972794, 0.03680223599076271, -0.02326813153922558, -0.0637226328253746, 0.0020109456963837147, 0.04336629435420036, -0.0016210275935009122, -0.010709208436310291, -0.027535518631339073, -0.025861969217658043, -0.024465365335345268, -0.01841435208916664, 0.007990662008523941, 0.032162103801965714, -0.011344007216393948, -0.07032676041126251, 0.0032993953209370375, -0.0412357933819294, 0.002842881251126528, 0.03952258080244064, -0.011872198432683945, -0.040279362350702286, 0.010268748737871647, -0.027131518349051476, -0.052859582006931305, -0.014748197048902512, -0.026313621550798416, 0.03158982843160629, -0.052109185606241226, -0.014129776507616043, 0.03314588591456413, 0.022512825205922127, -0.03835279494524002, 0.05278808996081352, 0.0007443605572916567, -0.011527576483786106, -0.03638239949941635, -0.007926973514258862, -0.001870843581855297, 0.0012962962500751019, 0.03146172687411308, 0.00487497728317976, -0.014476006850600243, 0.021455924957990646, -0.06157694011926651, -0.07058627903461456, 0.007966122590005398, 0.016821924597024918, 0.034268058836460114, 0.022147150710225105, -0.04038723558187485, 0.055610641837120056, -0.0038606482557952404, -0.017433030530810356, 0.005674687214195728, 0.016809627413749695, 0.004572124220430851, 0.012172888033092022, 0.01905669830739498, -0.003059783484786749, 0.020678289234638214, 0.04429687187075615, 0.04075068607926369, 0.013511478900909424, 0.022085828706622124, -0.0009357393137179315, 0.01218937337398529, 0.026724230498075485, -0.006246992852538824, 0.020744692534208298, 0.01715255156159401, 0.02416660450398922, -0.004487388301640749, -0.018128324300050735, -0.025455141440033913, 0.010380185209214687, 0.018716784194111824, -0.014711493626236916, -0.007558990735560656, 0.017137963324785233, 0.008834043517708778, -0.01782950945198536, 0.0643187016248703, 0.010396325960755348, -0.038449373096227646, 0.003600419033318758, 0.005744118709117174, 0.016436053439974785, -0.042168501764535904, 0.04390600323677063, 0.04743937775492668, 0.05638173967599869, -0.04420790821313858, -0.035818517208099365, -0.011747115291655064, -0.027861272916197777, -0.027033131569623947, 0.02070922590792179, -0.010846313089132309, 0.00923839583992958, 0.034418392926454544, 0.0025061240885406733, -0.012868130579590797, -0.026225799694657326, 0.013070531189441681, -0.07585324347019196, -0.03278792276978493, -0.026818927377462387, 0.028439847752451897, -0.009339350275695324, 0.055513788014650345, 0.004813630599528551, -0.012649651616811752, -0.018707524985074997, -0.0021558518055826426, -0.03049941547214985, -0.017860157415270805, 0.003232064424082637, -0.010329890064895153, -0.022147540003061295, 0.011596515774726868, 0.05889490991830826, -0.003956243861466646, 0.0212094709277153, -0.012828224338591099, -0.01198088563978672, -0.028493940830230713, -0.008909722790122032, -0.035956524312496185, -0.033063847571611404, 0.01058038230985403, 0.01649513468146324, 0.014345026575028896, -0.026660267263650894, 0.032890062779188156, 0.02299729734659195, 0.004054002929478884, 0.009282871149480343, -0.037039678543806076, 0.04338398575782776, -0.01839284412562847, 0.015388574451208115, 0.055719044059515, 0.03244428336620331, -0.008484164252877235, 0.030755378305912018, -0.015561312437057495, 0.07418861985206604, 0.05647619068622589, -0.01524625439196825, 0.025402355939149857, -0.059963732957839966, -0.020855994895100594, 0.014450361020863056, -0.0009613008587621152, 0.005244313273578882, -0.003736702958121896, 0.0759216845035553, 0.029955759644508362, -0.06554475426673889, 0.037448298186063766, 0.05727009475231171, 0.007316240109503269, 0.01897214725613594, -0.022382058203220367, 0.009744998998939991, -0.03670000657439232, 0.0007081706426106393, 0.018630897626280785, -0.006084055174142122, -0.003818988101556897, 0.011801399290561676, 0.032289404422044754, -0.03396553173661232, -0.03401581943035126, 0.010691549628973007, 0.003983506467193365, 0.05049949884414673, 0.027220670133829117, -0.06232127174735069, 0.02453971840441227, 0.02497299388051033, 0.03675329312682152, 0.02264387533068657, 0.017697885632514954, -0.05819839611649513, -0.0017802295042201877, 0.033354341983795166, 0.01187488529831171, -0.03288242965936661, 0.01460124459117651, -0.04216468706727028, -0.0029825042001903057, 0.05869714170694351, -0.020911771804094315, 0.001871179323643446, -0.02790541760623455, 0.013829383999109268, 0.005561002995818853, -0.049154579639434814, -0.0637751966714859, 0.0002234096173197031, -0.03685004264116287, 0.06469429284334183, -0.00755916116759181, -0.0037671371828764677, -0.023359043523669243, 0.01240942906588316, 0.03347299247980118, 0.05995278060436249, 0.015955358743667603, -0.018800541758537292, -0.009068133309483528, 0.030848387628793716, 0.011367562226951122, -0.08889003843069077, 0.04312741011381149, -0.011174280196428299, -0.03087892197072506, 0.06613333523273468, -0.06430548429489136, -0.054262299090623856, 0.053008031100034714, -0.017745671793818474, -0.015126580372452736, 0.027750568464398384, -0.041980959475040436, 0.041120607405900955, 0.050278011709451675, 0.02209780551493168, 0.04617661237716675, 0.011365393176674843, -0.002631631214171648, 0.02042902633547783, 0.008296379819512367, -0.008617562241852283, -0.024557730183005333, -0.019855191931128502, -0.02027047798037529, -0.021633705124258995, -0.01429685577750206, 0.02757790870964527, 0.0015943730250000954, 0.03422372043132782, 0.023223498836159706, -0.027914395555853844, 0.0028139762580394745, 0.05376822501420975, 0.021759651601314545, 0.00010319444845663384, 0.004534309264272451, 0.050476375967264175, 0.006901856977492571, -0.020024817436933517, 0.03210625424981117, 0.0027879802510142326, 0.02184535749256611, -0.013513746671378613, -0.023911215364933014, 0.016578588634729385, -0.05240895226597786, 0.008663788437843323, 0.007240920327603817, -0.041518136858940125, 0.07724671065807343, 0.009481453336775303, 0.03406938165426254, -0.025579459965229034, -0.03358958661556244, -0.017800748348236084, -0.007476367522031069, 0.011258910410106182, 0.044670332223176956, -0.041159484535455704, 0.01413548830896616, -0.004075411707162857, -0.012263797223567963, -0.0594480074942112, -0.059601932764053345, 0.020534178242087364, 0.04458226263523102, 0.005142479669302702, -0.05596034228801727, 0.02653633989393711, -0.014216877520084381, -0.008308145217597485, -0.027681507170200348, 0.011493469588458538, -0.045796990394592285, -0.02216409705579281, -0.0017584129236638546, 0.01418142206966877, 0.07568556815385818, 0.0183078832924366, 0.00999778788536787, 0.05245671421289444, -0.02059994824230671, -0.006497856695204973, -0.0080497357994318, -0.029136791825294495, -0.03722475469112396, 0.015181845985352993, -0.028628423810005188, -0.0013297672849148512, 0.029862504452466965, -0.07334974408149719, -0.028070781379938126, 0.013495963998138905, 0.00274587026797235, 0.01774042844772339, -0.04088989272713661, -0.027529478073120117, -0.004305400885641575, -0.013844487257301807, -0.03557560220360756, -0.022341271862387657, 0.02604137361049652, 0.005745464004576206, 0.029628032818436623, -0.007052299100905657, -0.0459132082760334, 0.017929112538695335, 0.045680075883865356, 0.009196053259074688, 0.007192535325884819, 0.009126105345785618, 0.041666824370622635, 0.03325698897242546, 0.011975015513598919, -0.02612430229783058, 0.029702264815568924, 0.02119654044508934, -0.019323699176311493, -0.020327972248196602, -0.07418103516101837, 0.008982133120298386, 0.062023475766181946, -0.012320367619395256, 0.0224339347332716, 0.013974694535136223, 0.0013218226376920938, -0.0052548055537045, -0.026703380048274994, -0.019222799688577652, -0.029510950669646263, 0.007664126344025135, 0.0061675854958593845, -0.04784268140792847, 0.01334231998771429, 0.026551416143774986, -0.00566548015922308, 0.010129709728062153, 0.001467120717279613, 0.010030345991253853, -0.004961777478456497, 0.06108164042234421, -0.03505726531147957, -0.05425330623984337, 0.03368089348077774, -0.027541425079107285, -0.0182346161454916, -0.021224409341812134, -0.027241721749305725, 0.04742159694433212, 0.011917641386389732, 0.03257432579994202, -0.04360117390751839, -0.04554819315671921, -0.027258586138486862, 0.012655745260417461, 0.022810690104961395, 0.03903020918369293, 0.027402617037296295, -0.04511946439743042, 0.013291834853589535, -0.03393818810582161, 0.016926446929574013, -0.038168374449014664, -0.08951500058174133, -0.05926520377397537, -0.004439583979547024, -0.013131994754076004, -0.010188158601522446, 0.01975857838988304, -0.007723083719611168, 0.020637936890125275, -0.035979580134153366, 0.0137779014185071, 0.016606997698545456, 0.027974238619208336, -0.007512235548347235, 0.09293245524168015, -0.0022308938205242157, 0.034568868577480316, -0.0012248867424204946, -0.017534349113702774, 0.1088126003742218, 0.060264308005571365, 0.06273863464593887, -0.04343751445412636, -0.017954256385564804, 0.016356468200683594, -0.0075506591238081455, -0.0438050776720047, 0.021115418523550034, 0.03636501729488373, -0.002175508998334408, 0.013352488167583942, 0.04934115707874298, -0.00040696325595490634, 0.007374564651399851, 0.03476720675826073, -0.0580228716135025, 0.0032915379852056503, 0.008734787814319134, 0.016440561041235924, 0.0030430490151047707, -0.024001017212867737, -0.070065438747406, 0.022592682391405106, -0.018567804247140884, -0.03794539347290993, -0.028845807537436485, 0.014062671922147274, -0.021928934380412102, 0.024529311805963516, 0.029136575758457184, -0.0208156518638134, 0.03304610773921013, -0.026760920882225037, 0.014384564012289047, -0.013112036511301994, 0.02534407377243042, -0.03951376676559448, 0.009382453747093678, 0.029249271377921104, -0.02544398605823517, -0.012378765270113945, 0.002624012529850006, 0.04000628739595413, -0.03908783569931984, -0.0434911735355854, -0.039766471832990646, 0.033412281423807144, -0.028275541961193085, -0.0029891026206314564, -0.009700794704258442, -0.05566123500466347, -0.016214603558182716, -0.0667199194431305, -0.008616611361503601, 0.03360326960682869, 0.03935793414711952, -0.017569441348314285, -0.01408386044204235, -0.0030823657289147377, 0.02679462358355522, -0.0007096847402863204, 0.0307773444801569, 0.04777965694665909, -0.03830244019627571, -0.017345132306218147, -0.012245064601302147, 0.042022332549095154, 0.04071769863367081, -0.015583427622914314, -0.007766838185489178, -0.03475939854979515, -0.014428325928747654, -0.006477427668869495, -0.0076371761970222, -0.02581125870347023, 0.029000969603657722, -0.005338268354535103, 0.011553758755326271, 0.016726281493902206, -0.032248012721538544, -0.027639752253890038, -0.05687258765101433, -0.010421453975141048, -0.024401474744081497, -0.0031102148350328207, 0.009829421527683735, 0.049585580825805664, 0.012341748923063278, 0.01530566904693842, -0.009014330804347992, 0.08665060251951218, 0.01270633190870285, -0.050810735672712326, -0.004206863697618246, -0.006629909388720989, -0.042184941470623016, 0.015699906274676323, -0.022320745512843132, 0.044701188802719116, 0.030927667394280434, 0.03203431889414787, 0.019866056740283966, 0.008078455924987793, -0.00902304332703352, 0.011670522391796112, -0.013032212853431702, -0.06710021942853928, 0.029867565259337425, 0.00690236734226346, 0.0210269745439291, -0.028544172644615173, 0.006873859092593193, 0.006159164477139711, -0.017289113253355026, 0.046869322657585144, -0.029440704733133316, -0.05496513843536377, 0.013071591034531593, -0.007142285816371441, -0.009938640519976616, 0.011608610861003399, 0.03752822428941727, 0.0485508069396019, -0.010263039730489254, -0.0290637519210577, -0.00499146431684494, -0.005870371591299772, 0.028543692082166672, -0.05018934980034828, -0.04045453295111656, 0.03889438509941101, 0.0006495656562037766, 0.01741667278110981, -0.03106488659977913, -0.002367527922615409, 0.0008683883934281766, 0.030710896477103233, -0.03322790190577507, -0.022428901866078377, 0.04881681129336357, -0.04422545060515404, -0.008720449171960354, 0.024542488157749176, 0.012199362739920616, 0.04452560096979141, 0.015576529316604137, -0.006392932962626219, -0.04437998682260513, 0.012558525428175926, -0.043742720037698746, 0.005785377696156502, 0.016088126227259636, 0.024637827649712563, -0.006882008630782366, 0.007273528724908829, 0.03050389513373375, 0.017278358340263367, 0.010097906924784184, 0.008199004456400871, 0.02156134881079197, -0.011022521182894707, -0.0071653034538030624, 0.03810517489910126, 0.004102851264178753, -0.003242992330342531, -0.01453121192753315, -0.010097276419401169, 0.02205085940659046, 0.04623734578490257, -0.01950458064675331, 0.04691772162914276, -0.0484064519405365, -0.01232234388589859, -0.12121996283531189, -0.03614409267902374, 0.025346336886286736, 0.000303609122056514, 0.04581966623663902, -0.020500387996435165, 0.02321481704711914, 0.019411534070968628, -0.05975352227687836, 0.020675351843237877, -0.007827356457710266, -0.004904822446405888, -0.052397146821022034, 0.02031044103205204, -0.0329439751803875, -0.0002870340831577778, 0.0115096066147089, 0.07032807171344757, 0.043557897210121155, 0.03952576965093613, 0.0028798829298466444, -0.03189347684383392, -0.02078646793961525, 0.006266354117542505, 0.013696364127099514, -0.048296838998794556, 0.03441400080919266, -0.02547852322459221, -0.02043653465807438, 0.006933208554983139, 0.03866426274180412, 0.03173163905739784, 0.003519403515383601, 0.03653808310627937, -0.0023578410036861897, 0.06448420137166977, 0.0036159027367830276, -0.0017971255583688617, 0.02626613713800907, -0.006993325427174568, 0.041977301239967346, -0.0022146268747746944, -0.01978440210223198, -0.0032655522227287292, 0.029232801869511604, -0.020212139934301376, -0.005128176882863045, 0.01967841200530529, -0.003441477194428444, -0.036952484399080276, 0.011294701136648655, -0.006972163915634155, 0.027070198208093643, -0.030571281909942627, 0.02342618629336357, -0.06708439439535141, -0.0015910901129245758, 0.025466004386544228, 0.01775694265961647, -0.006576017942279577, -0.004985122941434383, -0.012598109431564808, -0.05493171513080597, -0.01643843576312065, -0.004047549329698086, -0.006196309346705675, -0.06591156870126724, 0.006164770107716322, 0.02115490473806858, 0.0210393238812685, -0.02277515083551407, -0.03252159431576729, -0.038064684718847275, 0.03458462283015251, 0.008077051490545273, 0.029501918703317642, 0.013404764235019684, -0.0006543855415657163, 0.007822914980351925, -0.05951237678527832, 0.0690736249089241, 0.039154909551143646, -0.0221417136490345, -0.023472828790545464, -0.0019222451373934746, -0.01327374018728733, -0.03443184867501259, 0.0648360550403595, 0.013555118814110756, -0.0096253277733922, 0.012770556844770908, 0.01682264357805252, 0.01809745840728283, -0.023174649104475975, 0.007337050046771765, -0.011293838731944561, -0.033897221088409424, -0.054936718195676804, -0.01976999267935753, 0.034593891352415085, 0.011819538660347462, 0.025615466758608818, 0.005647389218211174, -0.014025973156094551, -0.018152644857764244, -0.018619293347001076, 0.031856101006269455, -0.013486413285136223, 0.01598764955997467, 0.03616301342844963, 0.00479410495609045, 0.02757260762155056, 0.0007443281938321888, -0.003473052056506276, -0.05897427722811699, 0.02650558017194271, -0.02947159856557846, -0.056043338030576706, 0.027152791619300842, -0.014659406617283821, -0.020421350374817848, -0.06768748909235, -0.010111193172633648, 0.0508563406765461, -0.03634532913565636, -0.005918616428971291, 0.059852223843336105, 0.008109129965305328, 0.0716102197766304, 0.017778664827346802, 0.0026169761549681425, 0.028873689472675323, -0.024122480303049088, 0.028099549934267998, 0.02987818978726864, 0.021843086928129196, -0.032284464687108994, -0.00032608312903903425, 0.047306012362241745, -0.02018541470170021, 0.027932720258831978, -0.012205524370074272, 0.04163307696580887, -0.04657364636659622, -0.007532067131251097, -0.02139350399374962, -0.05643213912844658, -0.009218869730830193, -0.007215437013655901, -0.026548724621534348, 0.081393763422966, -0.009275133721530437, 0.008151554502546787, -0.03668645769357681, 0.007709751836955547, -0.006275685504078865, -0.013146381825208664, -0.02140515297651291, 0.017496861517429352, 0.016427064314484596, -0.011316112242639065, 0.01629962958395481, -0.03629312664270401, 0.012449661269783974, -0.009815782308578491, 0.017132997512817383, -0.011234653182327747, 0.018495839089155197, -0.006589581724256277, -0.040162425488233566, -0.010840767063200474, 0.010139684192836285, -0.0008246823563240469, 0.03752579167485237, 0.010218922048807144, -0.026290955021977425, -0.01446440163999796, -0.014949832111597061, 0.05917246267199516, -0.05863895267248154, 0.009219800122082233, -0.06041182577610016, 0.012769683264195919, 0.015146072022616863, -0.038657594472169876 ]
<p>I am performing multiple t-tests to compare conditions of data. I have had to resort to permutation based t-tests (based on difference of means) due to high variance between samples.</p> <p>My question is if I am using permutation based t-tests is FWE correction still required? </p> <p>My understanding is that because is it non-parametric the probability of a false negative is not contingent on the number of tests applied to the same set of data. So FWE correction should not be required?</p> <hr> <p>I will expand on my specific issue. </p> <p>I am comparing scan-path data for subjects looking at two different types of faces (inverted and upright). I need to compare a number of measures for different face areas (eyes, nose , mouth, ears and 'other') between the areas. For this I have set up a t-test for each area, for each measure, and then correct for multiple comparisons. For example, I am testing the number of fixations, and fixation duration for each face area. I am constrained these tests in order to be able to compare to previous work. I have not been able to rely on any omnibus test thus far because of the non normality of my data greatly reduced the power of any omnibus test I have tried.</p>
73,761
[ -0.036967311054468155, 0.024407781660556793, -0.0128246508538723, -0.020065346732735634, 0.03856630250811577, 0.022824283689260483, 0.0009507113136351109, -0.001587280654348433, 0.021794835105538368, -0.004262047354131937, 0.041580572724342346, -0.0004955269978381693, 0.017183948308229446, -0.00468094227835536, -0.011956298723816872, -0.028893403708934784, -0.026147013530135155, 0.0008719692705199122, -0.01230081357061863, -0.02547428570687771, 0.0015158634632825851, 0.021850567311048508, 0.01336384192109108, -0.017374824732542038, -0.02806379459798336, 0.028923852369189262, -0.014202714897692204, -0.06489143520593643, 0.02858700044453144, 0.022135114297270775, -0.0443962924182415, -0.027083437889814377, 0.016311289742588997, 0.03421452268958092, 0.00006431400834117085, -0.003242040751501918, -0.007182685192674398, -0.027489695698022842, 0.006853190250694752, 0.048375580459833145, -0.027004893869161606, 0.0020630350336432457, -0.03220420703291893, 0.06540782004594803, 0.0020029162988066673, 0.022600114345550537, -0.024237625300884247, -0.04053085669875145, -0.00843854434788227, -0.06192449480295181, 0.05553502216935158, -0.008809231221675873, 0.06825987249612808, 0.0288807675242424, -0.01333136111497879, -0.03778653219342232, 0.06930437684059143, 0.05744452029466629, 0.009556463919579983, -0.05539359152317047, -0.007675564847886562, -0.05449442192912102, 0.014235960319638252, -0.014522504061460495, -0.028930719941854477, 0.04579677805304527, 0.0021885717287659645, -0.010872003622353077, 0.0435773991048336, -0.027499446645379066, 0.011622482910752296, -0.01114452350884676, 0.05610865727066994, -0.01993551477789879, 0.01825215108692646, -0.026417719200253487, 0.054596196860075, 0.01854509860277176, 0.04710602015256882, 0.042139530181884766, 0.015208473429083824, -0.016309326514601707, 0.007631382904946804, 0.08228565752506256, 0.0074964286759495735, -0.0031713657081127167, 0.05997825786471367, -0.02707742154598236, -0.008364597335457802, 0.03390505909919739, -0.01287800632417202, 0.007910328917205334, 0.05629725381731987, -0.00041423324728384614, -0.0481131412088871, 0.02872518077492714, -0.008779165334999561, 0.00667144451290369, -0.029009578749537468, 0.001954040490090847, -0.03800316900014877, -0.05455552414059639, -0.01667197421193123, 0.030633995309472084, -0.024274148046970367, 0.030842745676636696, -0.03245421499013901, 0.030419502407312393, -0.012298023328185081, 0.017878156155347824, -0.01778595894575119, 0.02381906844675541, -0.02996404469013214, 0.015395570546388626, 0.032924555242061615, -0.030687255784869194, -0.04542238637804985, -0.027265597134828568, 0.06399863958358765, 0.07082948088645935, 0.07236303389072418, -0.023142637684941292, 0.015166876837611198, -0.0036367042921483517, -0.054775845259428024, 0.020640779286623, 0.020753461867570877, -0.007407962344586849, -0.03643030300736427, 0.05165243148803711, 0.028218569234013557, -0.017919525504112244, 0.07624805718660355, -0.0029345452785491943, 0.025971168652176857, 0.023663034662604332, -0.06763042509555817, -0.0575987808406353, 0.04236161708831787, -0.02609184756875038, -0.012129203416407108, -0.0577787421643734, -0.02018556371331215, 0.023422062397003174, 0.04610298573970795, -0.0299769788980484, 0.062483008950948715, 0.020857902243733406, -0.004438036121428013, 0.0012671154690906405, -0.041830115020275116, 0.035464394837617874, -0.011981268413364887, -0.016597267240285873, -0.020701777189970016, -0.07048802077770233, 0.04307776317000389, 0.035928115248680115, 0.02253629080951214, 0.0288325697183609, 0.02957029826939106, 0.003118059365078807, -0.017487213015556335, 0.007702959235757589, 0.019342834129929543, -0.024396607652306557, 0.05401984602212906, -0.02314632013440132, 0.05152978003025055, -0.0008109792252071202, -0.025914890691637993, 0.007243153639137745, 0.0071081980131566525, 0.016477268189191818, 0.01806553639471531, -0.0444716215133667, 0.02027611806988716, 0.009915409609675407, 0.02792205661535263, 0.013134125620126724, -0.01550451759248972, 0.00981105212122202, -0.014230232685804367, 0.0030972356908023357, 0.047047052532434464, 0.04645274952054024, -0.018271254375576973, -0.0037715479265898466, 0.07347440719604492, -0.06384585052728653, -0.024803852662444115, -0.06526052206754684, -0.007177341263741255, -0.005115087144076824, -0.058869607746601105, 0.030843667685985565, -0.03731421381235123, 0.02603759616613388, 0.0274488665163517, -0.03758034482598305, -0.012652400881052017, -0.015431088395416737, 0.051576968282461166, -0.05389482155442238, -0.011353272013366222, 0.06450037658214569, 0.03228284791111946, -0.016781199723482132, 0.0416090227663517, -0.031091611832380295, -0.033487964421510696, 0.004273904953151941, -0.06822808086872101, 0.04353002831339836, 0.02416798286139965, -0.030512018129229546, -0.006194660905748606, 0.019944198429584503, -0.030599672347307205, 0.04474636912345886, -0.02350582927465439, 0.06485580652952194, 0.04674782231450081, -0.014557291753590107, 0.03399493917822838, 0.002638610079884529, 0.02305576391518116, -0.004063613712787628, 0.0015673364978283644, 0.002403704449534416, -0.04940818250179291, -0.025169774889945984, 0.03144856169819832, -0.03374085947871208, -0.03602606803178787, 0.010472781024873257, 0.040382154285907745, 0.0011245792265981436, 0.02240896224975586, 0.031227268278598785, -0.0050576175563037395, -0.0762149840593338, -0.0016628693556413054, 0.03882517293095589, 0.041051335632801056, 0.009365428239107132, 0.01394567172974348, -0.02044939063489437, 0.054593149572610855, 0.024715276435017586, 0.014249295927584171, 0.038726065307855606, 0.004504164215177298, 0.017085162922739983, -0.017886582762002945, -0.004224927630275488, 0.0040236543864011765, -0.022190678864717484, 0.02379000373184681, 0.053671590983867645, 0.005861335899680853, -0.023072540760040283, -0.020325616002082825, -0.026735994964838028, 0.04183657839894295, 0.017584608867764473, -0.014165828004479408, 0.007291079964488745, 0.016195768490433693, -0.03518083691596985, -0.0051151057705283165, -0.034179866313934326, -0.023539632558822632, -0.031883493065834045, 0.011973243206739426, 0.03403013199567795, 0.012772584334015846, 0.028534790500998497, -0.0459933876991272, 0.008899306878447533, -0.002297413069754839, 0.013073918409645557, -0.021154021844267845, -0.003344846423715353, -0.07718163728713989, 0.002489045262336731, -0.035476479679346085, -0.008302414789795876, 0.010114140808582306, 0.01247370894998312, -0.004047591704875231, 0.01754063367843628, 0.0045936196111142635, -0.014966842718422413, -0.01103628147393465, -0.027690790593624115, 0.035953667014837265, -0.031149856746196747, -0.01784162037074566, 0.0502222515642643, 0.01958552934229374, -0.04637584835290909, 0.03386879712343216, -0.02449866756796837, -0.03800828754901886, 0.005644613411277533, -0.016194863244891167, -0.017271626740694046, -0.012218751944601536, -0.015002064406871796, 0.02377336472272873, -0.027337968349456787, 0.003621320240199566, -0.0734667181968689, -0.06843552738428116, 0.016360079869627953, 0.02578510344028473, 0.03885575383901596, -0.0033300244249403477, -0.05919758975505829, 0.04346815124154091, 0.02253608964383602, -0.04158993810415268, -0.05980713292956352, -0.0008322525536641479, -0.062090784311294556, -0.016322791576385498, -0.00647605350241065, 0.011947152204811573, 0.01774599589407444, 0.006414753384888172, 0.00031423845211975276, 0.029081162065267563, 0.04986376315355301, 0.02981407754123211, -0.059667982161045074, 0.0007072989246807992, 0.019227687269449234, -0.03629683330655098, 0.034561339765787125, 0.014545434154570103, -0.014191989786922932, -0.023091254755854607, 0.010975122451782227, -0.021907154470682144, 0.03903026133775711, -0.04655246436595917, 0.032968100160360336, -0.04642900452017784, 0.01448824442923069, -0.03573856130242348, 0.010935869999229908, 0.03323112428188324, -0.016686974093317986, -0.04095417633652687, 0.026126082986593246, 0.047421082854270935, -0.02244711108505726, 0.05522191524505615, 0.0466146357357502, 0.04243559017777443, -0.0009731456520967185, -0.0018943548202514648, -0.02067156322300434, -0.013671744614839554, 0.015963224694132805, -0.0024773709010332823, -0.0004688242916017771, 0.031452152878046036, 0.06568793952465057, 0.04541582614183426, 0.008741602301597595, -0.029474899172782898, 0.0025719294790178537, -0.02196301333606243, 0.015315583907067776, -0.018797973170876503, 0.025099022313952446, 0.009858254343271255, 0.008270799182355404, 0.03418025001883507, -0.006536704022437334, -0.01613851636648178, 0.004679189063608646, -0.033781517297029495, -0.004575296305119991, -0.01038696151226759, -0.024559473618865013, 0.013867240399122238, -0.024709606543183327, -0.0014774741139262915, -0.021181326359510422, 0.02614773064851761, -0.0038231974467635155, 0.05116620287299156, -0.029688112437725067, -0.000839566404465586, -0.028054403141140938, 0.007467495743185282, -0.015897801145911217, 0.04779256135225296, -0.017592115327715874, -0.02131027542054653, 0.020666349679231644, 0.009345687925815582, 0.0034561813808977604, -0.014448202215135098, -0.03166114538908005, 0.017586925998330116, 0.010642838664352894, 0.03558611124753952, -0.013264166191220284, 0.044994454830884933, -0.06024730205535889, 0.030440418049693108, 0.021414104849100113, 0.026089537888765335, 0.028026821091771126, 0.0009751101606525481, -0.01462879404425621, -0.031000614166259766, -0.07089722901582718, -0.021606506779789925, 0.031390368938446045, 0.03005579113960266, -0.04198167473077774, 0.021522490307688713, 0.03009253367781639, -0.044686783105134964, -0.007428708020597696, 0.07440514117479324, -0.009010466746985912, -0.01994357444345951, -0.06598153710365295, -0.04407140985131264, -0.007465085946023464, -0.010737796314060688, 0.04213244095444679, 0.04278823360800743, 0.008362692780792713, 0.0052244653925299644, 0.034474994987249374, -0.009729511104524136, -0.017670445144176483, -0.0036704151425510645, 0.042996399104595184, 0.04072833061218262, 0.024787653237581253, 0.0022918141912668943, 0.0615546777844429, 0.014491938054561615, 0.023516397923231125, 0.024419037625193596, -0.0037592246662825346, -0.08234240859746933, 0.035184118896722794, 0.04307900741696358, 0.052193086594343185, -0.019423987716436386, -0.009119212627410889, 0.00009618989861337468, 0.01329498179256916, -0.0030194823630154133, -0.02005552500486374, 0.015277874656021595, 0.004507942590862513, 0.01774308830499649, -0.03989272564649582, -0.04000043869018555, -0.017906390130519867, 0.02211158722639084, 0.010066275484859943, 0.0024721361696720123, -0.030113693326711655, -0.003855526214465499, -0.014684585854411125, -0.02149270661175251, -0.025608528405427933, 0.03802119567990303, 0.00518241198733449, -0.017493169754743576, 0.04466448724269867, 0.012861436232924461, -0.04358423501253128, -0.09234144538640976, 0.022605424746870995, 0.017543647438287735, -0.015850653871893883, 0.06795886158943176, -0.0022627972066402435, 0.014921017922461033, 0.02820354513823986, -0.02075262740254402, -0.03839148208498955, -0.012705757282674313, -0.004226651042699814, 0.05706142261624336, 0.05152463540434837, 0.055289238691329956, 0.06768690794706345, -0.01924009621143341, 0.04482584074139595, 0.001221895799972117, 0.013481751084327698, 0.007289086002856493, -0.04613199830055237, 0.004519568290561438, -0.024969836696982384, -0.025934770703315735, -0.012453143484890461, 0.04272158443927765, -0.022897912189364433, 0.016060275956988335, 0.00015732660540379584, 0.030994025990366936, 0.0035353878047317266, 0.02873743511736393, 0.020270762965083122, 0.021477872505784035, 0.0012211614521220326, 0.024616342037916183, -0.03256726264953613, 0.005179188679903746, 0.023343758657574654, -0.05723284184932709, 0.009594307281076908, 0.024933887645602226, -0.018140187487006187, -0.009189967066049576, -0.05476043000817299, -0.02281867153942585, -0.0031197608914226294, -0.0006009205244481564, 0.01720050908625126, -0.010618227533996105, 0.01744326390326023, 0.009840273298323154, -0.031061919406056404, 0.01621556654572487, 0.028219640254974365, -0.029681626707315445, 0.04343051090836525, -0.0247350987046957, 0.060992948710918427, 0.004355940502136946, -0.00024627120001241565, -0.0573270283639431, -0.023937774822115898, -0.020859993994235992, 0.008541914634406567, -0.012450886890292168, -0.03662772476673126, 0.012692313641309738, -0.03651031479239464, -0.03305806219577789, 0.004774790722876787, 0.02975524589419365, -0.029907943680882454, -0.012133372947573662, -0.003557877615094185, 0.017583057284355164, 0.07225187867879868, -0.02154105342924595, 0.006697528529912233, 0.02759750932455063, -0.0012985445791855454, -0.012690717354416847, 0.006697962526232004, 0.01012211013585329, -0.026431141421198845, -0.013062256388366222, -0.020844995975494385, 0.0005885016289539635, 0.03503180295228958, 0.01549428142607212, -0.04525379836559296, -0.016679955646395683, -0.023113062605261803, 0.004934413358569145, -0.044230878353118896, 0.006121888756752014, -0.03900483623147011, 0.012040217407047749, -0.038231320679187775, 0.06648927181959152, -0.006674919743090868, 0.0014922601403668523, 0.026310713961720467, -0.03166213631629944, -0.03585639223456383, 0.020184511318802834, 0.05511688068509102, -0.0009101836476475, 0.028111159801483154, -0.03126434236764908, -0.04078991338610649, 0.04276144877076149, -0.00016937340842559934, 0.01603495143353939, -0.02655232511460781, 0.009161737747490406, -0.020397361367940903, 0.003080853493884206, 0.01814822480082512, 0.01082734577357769, 0.05165602266788483, -0.006249681580811739, 0.02634512260556221, 0.0712355449795723, -0.020126262679696083, 0.01662473753094673, -0.0558837428689003, 0.038175541907548904, 0.01738961599767208, 0.014931020326912403, 0.04588157683610916, -0.008646526373922825, 0.006232913117855787, 0.048094313591718674, 0.02829126827418804, 0.007353351451456547, 0.03321169689297676, 0.007205186411738396, 0.009884987957775593, -0.0058885617181658745, 0.003727638628333807, -0.03878160938620567, 0.04595477506518364, -0.053771354258060455, 0.052423056215047836, -0.010842477902770042, -0.014729006215929985, 0.050878506153821945, 0.022348420694470406, 0.016744768247008324, -0.029239462688565254, -0.04208218306303024, -0.04977511242032051, 0.038809698075056076, 0.009582196362316608, -0.02735518105328083, -0.02584519237279892, -0.05350979045033455, 0.07674866169691086, -0.02283543162047863, 0.034911029040813446, -0.017984552308917046, -0.05496952682733536, -0.04908916354179382, -0.0379842147231102, -0.014350906945765018, 0.045615557581186295, -0.05390691012144089, -0.023016009479761124, -0.008508323691785336, -0.04560091346502304, 0.016685867682099342, -0.002159825759008527, 0.05490115284919739, -0.03412388265132904, 0.0348847396671772, -0.0027986878994852304, 0.044099047780036926, 0.006240538787096739, -0.02305227890610695, 0.12145645171403885, 0.07744589447975159, 0.022604988887906075, -0.02752324752509594, 0.016622046008706093, -0.029275914654135704, -0.01604633778333664, -0.02493947185575962, 0.04496586695313454, 0.012179993093013763, -0.013222797773778439, 0.0330006405711174, 0.05814637988805771, -0.00295948120765388, -0.04548923671245575, 0.05261692777276039, -0.03711530193686485, -0.04074760153889656, 0.03065415844321251, -0.01702347956597805, 0.03945162147283554, -0.019501622766256332, -0.04057847335934639, -0.039300285279750824, -0.009102601557970047, -0.013229777105152607, -0.011549927294254303, 0.01776880957186222, -0.0025901764165610075, 0.021330326795578003, -0.025298045948147774, 0.006919035688042641, -0.010900460183620453, -0.017416372895240784, -0.03612145408987999, -0.03524347394704819, 0.019796030595898628, -0.0426107682287693, 0.037765782326459885, 0.08290813118219376, -0.014374212361872196, -0.021142099052667618, 0.014267228543758392, 0.02389637753367424, -0.022093357518315315, -0.002982933074235916, -0.0005972306244075298, 0.038999054580926895, -0.018843932077288628, 0.006888461299240589, 0.0029091639444231987, -0.01832917332649231, -0.007387095130980015, -0.06062750518321991, -0.019809605553746223, 0.012310261838138103, 0.008584054186940193, 0.010886404663324356, -0.028357524424791336, -0.04490179196000099, 0.02629002556204796, 0.02172064408659935, 0.003741443157196045, 0.002563019748777151, 0.02870289608836174, -0.033923547714948654, -0.029522033408284187, 0.07376262545585632, 0.026363618671894073, 0.018839022144675255, -0.03149890527129173, -0.03386274725198746, -0.02051568403840065, 0.026257071644067764, 0.0036376062780618668, -0.007275978568941355, 0.022868482396006584, 0.003221888793632388, -0.0005190343945287168, -0.029657689854502678, -0.045649316161870956, -0.009557756595313549, -0.025746475905179977, 0.013500720262527466, -0.04610868915915489, -0.004617729689925909, 0.05932621657848358, -0.01574358530342579, -0.0016398333245888352, 0.03143522888422012, 0.008128059096634388, 0.06324926763772964, 0.007056433707475662, -0.0393313467502594, -0.03429373353719711, -0.026582442224025726, 0.03431416302919388, 0.0018301407108083367, -0.041351184248924255, 0.039078958332538605, 0.02911064773797989, 0.03928240388631821, 0.010530995205044746, 0.022870657965540886, 0.031023968011140823, -0.0082547040656209, -0.0018584855133667588, -0.05783656984567642, 0.0015056923730298877, 0.036786939948797226, 0.024871844798326492, -0.01978055201470852, -0.006208754610270262, -0.025795185938477516, -0.007587679196149111, 0.027577709406614304, -0.0325644351541996, -0.015523898415267467, -0.022991565987467766, 0.00009208791016135365, 0.02569393441081047, -0.05086732283234596, -0.01857336238026619, -0.027187805622816086, 0.033340997993946075, -0.01246547233313322, 0.013134453445672989, 0.0029681811574846506, -0.021901240572333336, 0.009219986386597157, -0.040785543620586395, 0.08331219851970673, 0.009243401698768139, 0.012275727465748787, 0.0016771700466051698, 0.011329486034810543, 0.01623574085533619, 0.04220288246870041, 0.02671186253428459, -0.011303815059363842, 0.030953478068113327, -0.04576732590794563, -0.011864738538861275, 0.05334192141890526, 0.03263004124164581, 0.011731237173080444, -0.004662360996007919, -0.00339972460642457, -0.015591572038829327, 0.029326140880584717, -0.02409776858985424, -0.0307859368622303, 0.0031987151596695185, 0.02603827975690365, 0.009375695139169693, -0.010437574237585068, 0.026549482718110085, 0.0018894022796303034, -0.015608103014528751, 0.027392486110329628, 0.05313727632164955, 0.018485717475414276, 0.013456396758556366, 0.01116532925516367, -0.041926223784685135, 0.0002737145696301013, -0.029123393818736076, -0.012284509837627411, 0.040700823068618774, 0.03002593107521534, 0.0018528345972299576, 0.0398552268743515, -0.04648258537054062, 0.00736922025680542, -0.05750507116317749, -0.00438452884554863, 0.03804316744208336, 0.024120165035128593, 0.049114130437374115, -0.039752617478370667, 0.010829939506947994, 0.04370949789881706, -0.04113457724452019, 0.03289094567298889, 0.003826828906312585, -0.030288847163319588, -0.06275778263807297, -0.003198015270754695, -0.02355727180838585, 0.016455838456749916, -0.029420282691717148, -0.004139200318604708, 0.03553614020347595, 0.01440077368170023, -0.012632523663341999, -0.024541065096855164, 0.0036341382656246424, 0.019818220287561417, 0.01070203073322773, -0.07552368193864822, 0.000660322664771229, -0.003809501649811864, -0.05925993248820305, 0.009623410180211067, 0.013133225031197071, 0.007937658578157425, 0.006494847126305103, 0.04979738965630531, 0.0012612962163984776, 0.003777067642658949, 0.03480108082294464, 0.030253607779741287, 0.015061349608004093, 0.01861284300684929, -0.01594475470483303, 0.029866980388760567, -0.04850257933139801, -0.006409972440451384, 0.01892191916704178, -0.026772700250148773, -0.02307715453207493, 0.015331311151385307, -0.0330788791179657, -0.007977710105478764, 0.004984443541616201, -0.008697046898305416, 0.00820891186594963, -0.007628836203366518, -0.0065826610662043095, -0.027356082573533058, 0.03206184506416321, 0.021852577105164528, 0.013685484416782856, -0.01759086176753044, 0.013656159862875938, -0.016699355095624924, -0.034564197063446045, 0.015076419338583946, -0.001481171464547515, 0.018378211185336113, -0.049965258687734604, 0.002826471347361803, 0.000010795962225529365, -0.011084631085395813, -0.01884460635483265, -0.01179502997547388, -0.03867661580443382, 0.01761697418987751, -0.050124261528253555, 0.00038803581264801323, 0.02509954199194908, -0.003347381018102169, -0.009539259597659111, -0.07424462586641312, 0.027426637709140778, -0.01825757697224617, -0.006069819442927837, -0.017380638048052788, 0.036072082817554474, -0.043365221470594406, 0.025253724306821823, 0.04523417353630066, 0.012558636255562305, 0.04104059934616089, -0.003416523803025484, 0.010464510880410671, 0.009053603745996952, -0.07966621220111847, 0.04309430718421936, -0.027666524052619934, -0.027451056987047195, -0.010562714189291, -0.033473070710897446, 0.019825058057904243, 0.0074954405426979065, 0.02185843139886856, -0.027355169877409935, 0.038692645728588104, 0.0056686559692025185, -0.021601062268018723, 0.01364943664520979, 0.0008211284875869751, -0.03910936787724495, 0.013695272617042065, 0.027626363560557365, 0.03905186802148819, 0.00698361499235034, -0.01986946165561676, -0.052809860557317734, 0.03712226077914238, -0.016852660104632378, -0.011758766137063503, -0.010109074413776398, 0.0019036440644413233, -0.016451895236968994, -0.07009492814540863, -0.005573376547545195, -0.0012160412734374404, -0.02920006401836872, -0.0004152477195020765, 0.025656888261437416, 0.03162270784378052, 0.007779110688716173, -0.017340434715151787, 0.053353503346443176, 0.03618307039141655, -0.04001181572675705, 0.007900652475655079, 0.02439405769109726, -0.008869237266480923, 0.010043117217719555, -0.008757979609072208, 0.017944851890206337, -0.026585081592202187, 0.05932474136352539, -0.0121182044968009, 0.028508732095360756, -0.019467050209641457, -0.0259687639772892, 0.010394129902124405, 0.05382390320301056, 0.020471116527915, -0.010650016367435455, 0.007456718012690544, 0.038214653730392456, -0.03374279662966728, -0.010378940962255001, -0.0162311103194952, 0.0031358839478343725, -0.05066297948360443, -0.011867058463394642, 0.022039785981178284, 0.038031164556741714, 0.0014119899133220315, 0.005068598780781031, -0.02914218232035637, -0.0010462247300893068, 0.048608869314193726, -0.03797018900513649, 0.02841874212026596, -0.034899838268756866, -0.01937628909945488, -0.01918335258960724, -0.005995482672005892, -0.0674298033118248, -0.015943210572004318, -0.013767296448349953, 0.029808565974235535, 0.023453785106539726, -0.04262201488018036, -0.033257968723773956, -0.00785732176154852, 0.0356437973678112, -0.054364163428545, -0.05270100384950638, -0.059350837022066116, -0.006025100592523813, -0.018770739436149597, 0.0014377953484654427 ]
<p>Gelman &amp; Hill (2006) explain how a multilevel regression model can compensate for data sparsity by pooling parameter estimates. But what happens if the data are not sparse at random?</p> <p>For example, suppose we are evaluating a new blood pressure medication. On every visit we measure a patient's blood pressure, administer the treatment, and measure blood pressure again. We may have fewer opportunities to observe the effect of a treatment in some patients than in others, so we may want to use pooling. But the number of observations per patient could be related to the fact that the treatment is ineffective for some patients (so they do not want to come in), or causes side effects two hours later (so they do not want to come in), or the medication puts patients in a coma and they drop out of the study.</p> <p>Is pooling no longer appropriate in such a study?</p>
73,762
[ -0.043649327009916306, -0.011636162176728249, 0.015147065743803978, -0.032921984791755676, 0.007116954308003187, -0.0025798913557082415, -0.04012754559516907, -0.028760699555277824, 0.058118630200624466, -0.0011944634607061744, 0.017259951680898666, 0.004980240948498249, 0.04576098546385765, -0.016682272776961327, 0.03324873372912407, 0.03296178951859474, 0.0018986096838489175, 0.02739511802792549, 0.026294434443116188, -0.02588961087167263, -0.03328043222427368, 0.02112725004553795, 0.01980908215045929, -0.01891765184700489, -0.024305500090122223, 0.03162568435072899, 0.007738342043012381, -0.04594762623310089, 0.015328590758144855, 0.05554977059364319, -0.03623200207948685, -0.012851654551923275, -0.014530342072248459, 0.03270150348544121, 0.024398740381002426, -0.006605658680200577, -0.014139766804873943, -0.01820506900548935, 0.014966584742069244, 0.00903463177382946, 0.007093730848282576, -0.018674911931157112, -0.033388156443834305, 0.015460874885320663, -0.0510835275053978, 0.01625620573759079, 0.014067326672375202, -0.02530827559530735, 0.04115656763315201, -0.031538303941488266, 0.0023693195544183254, 0.007310087326914072, 0.026357071474194527, 0.06890153139829636, -0.050468411296606064, 0.010057544335722923, 0.06196697801351547, 0.06676262617111206, 0.013115258887410164, -0.023007558658719063, -0.03471013158559799, -0.0250098779797554, 0.03967074677348137, 0.01030001137405634, -0.038191813975572586, 0.008617222309112549, 0.011296368204057217, -0.022723931819200516, -0.00226815533824265, -0.031229300424456596, 0.015400726348161697, 0.022993680089712143, 0.03888685256242752, -0.00825726892799139, 0.0343230664730072, -0.011227228678762913, 0.01697741262614727, 0.0476476214826107, 0.05652021989226341, 0.015434754081070423, 0.017045939341187477, -0.014949849806725979, 0.040492601692676544, -0.013656649738550186, 0.009563395753502846, 0.013261009939014912, 0.03609751537442207, -0.013315713033080101, 0.0568699836730957, -0.026992803439497948, -0.02107008546590805, 0.008507982827723026, 0.041084542870521545, 0.015404324047267437, -0.05818158760666847, -0.007128444965928793, -0.009088026359677315, 0.03522280976176262, 0.026477951556444168, -0.014617621898651123, -0.010470952838659286, -0.017745880410075188, -0.02327246591448784, 0.06450673937797546, -0.01842888444662094, -0.018425269052386284, -0.03936805576086044, 0.0020104646682739258, -0.013177679851651192, -0.029120290651917458, -0.04768593609333038, 0.01751263625919819, -0.008537285961210728, -0.01216072402894497, 0.07698029279708862, -0.0017448891885578632, -0.025950711220502853, 0.010975833050906658, 0.06823746114969254, 0.06946404278278351, 0.04668501392006874, -0.013903644867241383, 0.011131820268929005, -0.03925594687461853, -0.036835577338933945, 0.021929766982793808, 0.0034239741507917643, -0.046203069388866425, -0.0645240768790245, 0.03829510509967804, 0.03488704934716225, -0.014933441765606403, 0.05806763470172882, -0.0023198751732707024, 0.016945358365774155, -0.003823481732979417, -0.08650767803192139, -0.04957692325115204, 0.03822135552763939, 0.018814923241734505, 0.009678177535533905, -0.0424514040350914, -0.02084391750395298, 0.0153837064281106, 0.08106856793165207, 0.014916849322617054, 0.03204458951950073, 0.020820843055844307, 0.03127392753958702, 0.013796641491353512, -0.001421795692294836, -0.006218806840479374, 0.016394788399338722, -0.01563606783747673, -0.005569161847233772, -0.11212152242660522, -0.004396331962198019, 0.02246851474046707, -0.0025907501112669706, 0.020715070888400078, 0.018439315259456635, 0.013952895067632198, -0.01558146346360445, -0.00958866998553276, 0.008388033136725426, 0.010617127642035484, 0.018458832055330276, -0.028600160032510757, 0.036340467631816864, 0.02783905901014805, 0.06382272392511368, 0.038375742733478546, 0.004748856648802757, 0.07297293096780777, 0.015105387195944786, -0.003651514882221818, 0.029522862285375595, -0.01038646325469017, 0.004411537665873766, 0.011186867021024227, -0.048566557466983795, -0.03829518333077431, 0.012916026636958122, 0.016879180446267128, 0.018371304497122765, 0.03557107225060463, 0.02357097901403904, 0.027068685740232468, 0.018949726596474648, -0.0314456969499588, -0.043418038636446, -0.07550826668739319, 0.0010332410456612706, 0.013470232486724854, -0.026591872796416283, 0.05001970753073692, -0.016921652480959892, 0.02858094312250614, 0.013311570510268211, -0.02716713212430477, 0.011743578128516674, -0.0213134977966547, 0.04934777319431305, -0.026644516736268997, -0.013697569258511066, 0.03508893772959709, 0.019865931943058968, -0.02174294926226139, 0.012124824337661266, -0.05991686135530472, -0.06697411835193634, -0.013908255845308304, -0.013827492482960224, 0.011742140166461468, -0.029154494404792786, -0.041861698031425476, 0.0016112133162096143, -0.032654888927936554, -0.017178218811750412, 0.054739080369472504, -0.05718928575515747, 0.06476245820522308, 0.05994907766580582, 0.01692982390522957, -0.018158957362174988, 0.04801803454756737, -0.0024786635767668486, -0.04784649237990379, -0.015991441905498505, -0.05663655698299408, -0.026060184463858604, -0.0056878915056586266, -0.019375480711460114, 0.013463027775287628, 0.0038185068406164646, 0.0448763482272625, 0.06914195418357849, 0.04091156646609306, 0.034640755504369736, 0.014537236653268337, 0.0052775121293962, 0.015288091264665127, 0.051228754222393036, 0.023745030164718628, 0.021878590807318687, 0.03613648936152458, -0.007048128638416529, 0.007738649379462004, 0.006457415409386158, 0.00008609245560364798, 0.001848419546149671, 0.03552667051553726, 0.045359931886196136, 0.00998608022928238, -0.02961087040603161, -0.02745342254638672, 0.0018023218726739287, -0.033784836530685425, 0.014296317473053932, 0.02054576762020588, 0.030764542520046234, 0.03324068337678909, -0.0307000819593668, -0.05630386620759964, 0.03772202134132385, 0.01778019405901432, -0.02336297370493412, -0.014310724101960659, 0.023802829906344414, -0.0488809198141098, -0.01141436118632555, -0.027334243059158325, -0.025013046339154243, -0.05336038023233414, 0.00074852752732113, 0.03535008803009987, -0.01910884864628315, 0.02173246443271637, -0.036501962691545486, -0.03321680426597595, 0.006586980074644089, -0.02469920553267002, 0.022640515118837357, -0.00248165987432003, -0.022842466831207275, -0.02750331349670887, -0.021924437955021858, -0.012274787761271, 0.013645719736814499, -0.003594090696424246, -0.0069239321164786816, 0.00894850306212902, 0.004775766748934984, -0.05966803804039955, -0.015468878671526909, -0.002394517883658409, 0.007384817115962505, -0.013916882686316967, -0.0637873038649559, 0.026333652436733246, -0.009844968095421791, -0.01856178231537342, -0.010710828006267548, 0.014306638389825821, -0.041943058371543884, -0.017089087516069412, -0.004961232654750347, 0.020621486008167267, -0.0026013655588030815, -0.0127141447737813, 0.04245195910334587, -0.03161564841866493, -0.027233997359871864, -0.0749029889702797, -0.08212689310312271, 0.002704148180782795, -0.019921883940696716, 0.00833252351731062, -0.016504665836691856, -0.027481799945235252, 0.07271386682987213, -0.002088174456730485, 0.0211070217192173, -0.0013374893460422754, 0.00034206692362204194, 0.01809825748205185, -0.010786519385874271, 0.007159717381000519, 0.027029385790228844, 0.029771504923701286, 0.006544006057083607, -0.023605812340974808, 0.057666338980197906, 0.034224733710289, -0.00919320061802864, 0.01727791130542755, 0.00042789930012077093, 0.005761962849646807, -0.008940898813307285, -0.009683129377663136, -0.0031721859704703093, -0.0008993234951049089, 0.004724145866930485, -0.00618647038936615, 0.006539999973028898, -0.029991386458277702, -0.04369927570223808, 0.0030864912550896406, -0.03368086740374565, 0.016793478280305862, -0.024145958945155144, 0.004550872836261988, 0.03395567089319229, -0.05854668840765953, -0.008589601144194603, 0.04790002107620239, 0.0428665466606617, -0.043119266629219055, 0.007212533615529537, 0.03971988707780838, 0.03715520352125168, -0.008073250763118267, 0.00625630235299468, 0.010677679441869259, -0.007720035966485739, 0.03743887320160866, -0.022339383140206337, 0.00021022779401391745, 0.00782112404704094, -0.007731313351541758, -0.03155608847737312, -0.017178410664200783, -0.0723191648721695, -0.004465773236006498, -0.08636971563100815, 0.01334317959845066, -0.0011772186262533069, 0.01382328849285841, -0.016879497095942497, -0.0054337624460458755, 0.013190943747758865, -0.025198660790920258, -0.001412929268553853, 0.02519172430038452, -0.03703330084681511, -0.020886730402708054, -0.0306758563965559, 0.028355812653899193, 0.013490916229784489, -0.028304891660809517, 0.04023366421461105, -0.01538916490972042, -0.002904633991420269, -0.0038635956589132547, 0.04304593801498413, -0.010375846177339554, 0.006287775002419949, 0.0009972307598218322, -0.027782490476965904, -0.02198180928826332, -0.04160193353891373, 0.016961006447672844, 0.016211707144975662, 0.004305010661482811, 0.06685708463191986, 0.0031600715592503548, -0.028405848890542984, -0.05237460508942604, -0.0012515048729255795, 0.025087011978030205, 0.014903008937835693, 0.018283380195498466, 0.017154384404420853, -0.03621426597237587, 0.008202631957828999, -0.00791254173964262, 0.05905848369002342, 0.022706666961312294, 0.004240439739078283, -0.009191105142235756, 0.008906497620046139, -0.026237551122903824, 0.038919851183891296, -0.02598564699292183, 0.024984296411275864, 0.018097704276442528, 0.05232462286949158, 0.007775420323014259, -0.013180477544665337, 0.022390171885490417, 0.06307170540094376, 0.0027887120377272367, 0.002808792283758521, -0.05603210628032684, -0.0009098752052523196, 0.007246000692248344, 0.00937825720757246, 0.05942303687334061, -0.0180958341807127, -0.0018859016709029675, -0.02117350697517395, 0.0502835176885128, -0.017743118107318878, -0.022416232153773308, -0.007340642157942057, 0.03964832425117493, 0.020637603476643562, -0.007248625624924898, 0.0017367175314575434, 0.023312009871006012, 0.04089969024062157, 0.009275592863559723, 0.022479316219687462, -0.012821712531149387, -0.08238271623849869, -0.034987956285476685, 0.005856547504663467, 0.0012346755247563124, -0.011966213583946228, 0.013472363352775574, -0.04253174364566803, 0.005350220482796431, 0.040007226169109344, -0.004902046173810959, -0.014927394688129425, 0.0068537769839167595, -0.01032742764800787, -0.020232301205396652, -0.06324361264705658, -0.014546295627951622, 0.010443105362355709, -0.02111046575009823, 0.0023005157709121704, 0.010870630852878094, -0.008573387749493122, -0.03534216433763504, 0.012651761062443256, -0.004849941004067659, 0.044927824288606644, -0.009188161231577396, -0.03514746576547623, 0.0012395329540595412, -0.0018370423931628466, 0.0003527896187733859, -0.08129357546567917, 0.02051664888858795, -0.02209579013288021, -0.022723348811268806, 0.03187433257699013, -0.010699964128434658, -0.04139482229948044, 0.018733534961938858, 0.042591340839862823, -0.042478449642658234, -0.002660253783687949, -0.03585543483495712, 0.006764132995158434, 0.010988167487084866, 0.044396352022886276, 0.04693734273314476, 0.024502500891685486, 0.04148590564727783, 0.008082980290055275, -0.014312938787043095, 0.02257683500647545, -0.03402800112962723, -0.02044326439499855, -0.03195786476135254, -0.03315061330795288, -0.006327469367533922, 0.0545034185051918, 0.008205392397940159, 0.03685938939452171, -0.0083850072696805, -0.03734980896115303, -0.01262522954493761, 0.04043439030647278, 0.008532596752047539, 0.013644758611917496, 0.03152957558631897, 0.019869770854711533, 0.010827491991221905, 0.004528385121375322, -0.006807638797909021, -0.04490245133638382, 0.038958657532930374, 0.030458983033895493, -0.0635392889380455, -0.018373088911175728, -0.013144238851964474, 0.0030796376522630453, 0.03410891070961952, -0.017910361289978027, 0.014123758301138878, 0.002563236281275749, 0.05428878590464592, -0.019677553325891495, -0.02657349407672882, -0.008459296077489853, -0.0025216706562787294, -0.026453081518411636, 0.0070567987859249115, -0.04793825373053551, 0.010301378555595875, -0.017207438126206398, 0.004022516310214996, -0.0713193416595459, -0.013238373212516308, 0.037183716893196106, 0.0008234751294367015, -0.002710046712309122, -0.017073778435587883, 0.0190157238394022, -0.03488921746611595, -0.010735874064266682, -0.009617808274924755, 0.07961004972457886, -0.003636309178546071, -0.0004678744589909911, -0.022403109818696976, 0.01588066853582859, 0.05813395604491234, -0.020940186455845833, 0.013381571508944035, 0.031194422394037247, -0.05354704335331917, -0.02546088583767414, -0.025546319782733917, 0.024425946176052094, -0.03479141741991043, 0.024117833003401756, -0.028597397729754448, -0.0021321529056876898, 0.014539175666868687, 0.015042318031191826, 0.014708861708641052, 0.04271349310874939, -0.03303787484765053, 0.03795010969042778, -0.0033150219824165106, 0.0031909605022519827, -0.025286322459578514, 0.047206830233335495, 0.022772708907723427, 0.01894286461174488, 0.005651048384606838, 0.011715924367308617, 0.02735063061118126, -0.0016510700806975365, -0.03305194154381752, 0.0276927687227726, 0.07444597780704498, 0.01672789640724659, 0.04500202834606171, -0.022391686215996742, -0.005508494097739458, 0.08601415902376175, 0.006400686223059893, -0.018547138199210167, -0.016276467591524124, 0.06109173223376274, -0.03856098651885986, -0.03973593935370445, -0.0007121380185708404, 0.04905228689312935, 0.07858069986104965, -0.024695493280887604, 0.03293474018573761, 0.044982749968767166, -0.02777513861656189, 0.015727544203400612, -0.037370845675468445, 0.01813742145895958, -0.008568013086915016, -0.025978723540902138, 0.03045360930263996, -0.003709013806656003, 0.004527096636593342, 0.03748159483075142, -0.0015565098728984594, 0.002911353250965476, 0.027131956070661545, 0.01401417888700962, 0.042972631752491, -0.001955518964678049, -0.05857459828257561, -0.033798523247241974, 0.043467383831739426, -0.04902339726686478, -0.029092926532030106, -0.01062242966145277, -0.03938151150941849, 0.06188887730240822, 0.00620673643425107, 0.012089407071471214, -0.03444766625761986, -0.004949066787958145, -0.0677596926689148, 0.016112228855490685, 0.005364023149013519, -0.006925657391548157, 0.02205785922706127, 0.0073335058987140656, 0.017542950809001923, 0.020093610510230064, 0.027438925579190254, -0.03963268920779228, -0.09158021956682205, -0.03746457397937775, -0.010802182368934155, 0.010549723170697689, 0.04996512457728386, 0.03626208379864693, -0.037305206060409546, -0.017160987481474876, -0.016144292429089546, 0.011531117372214794, -0.013420850969851017, 0.021150823682546616, -0.020932350307703018, 0.03534678742289543, 0.02450534515082836, 0.0050951410084962845, -0.008972343988716602, -0.004845466464757919, 0.1264219731092453, 0.07719289511442184, 0.05433015897870064, -0.04345162957906723, 0.008511672727763653, 0.015632690861821175, -0.024613413959741592, 0.026169080287218094, -0.03439616411924362, 0.0031616955529898405, 0.02552599273622036, 0.030167218297719955, 0.01376679539680481, 0.049999453127384186, -0.017553653568029404, 0.043903231620788574, -0.031349554657936096, -0.03750893101096153, -0.0012130056275054812, 0.002747460501268506, 0.019870273768901825, -0.029637441039085388, -0.04220852628350258, 0.012158825993537903, 0.04032783955335617, -0.03338506445288658, -0.02802634984254837, 0.020906241610646248, 0.0030759016517549753, 0.00945301540195942, 0.0028121459763497114, 0.0005068761529400945, 0.027270501479506493, 0.02950219437479973, -0.0042478046379983425, 0.046894002705812454, 0.02771003544330597, -0.040487781167030334, -0.00438686553388834, 0.016667375341057777, 0.0027812200132757425, -0.007149046752601862, -0.006215947214514017, 0.002229240955784917, -0.034395646303892136, 0.008728287182748318, 0.0029708961956202984, 0.06189780309796333, -0.03139631822705269, -0.01496119424700737, -0.02114308811724186, -0.016055116429924965, -0.012358208186924458, -0.03637683391571045, -0.009242256172001362, 0.018237709999084473, 0.05217026174068451, -0.03883635252714157, 0.0004557737847790122, 0.01247397344559431, -0.007065275218337774, -0.018913475796580315, 0.016816629096865654, 0.028925392776727676, -0.02777651883661747, -0.05255751684308052, -0.021190639585256577, 0.02699379064142704, 0.02431991696357727, -0.021767493337392807, -0.018802780658006668, -0.011932307854294777, -0.013426044024527073, -0.03429216518998146, 0.00453598378226161, -0.0015253446763381362, 0.033968258649110794, -0.021921267732977867, 0.00402216799557209, -0.05265511944890022, -0.036786530166864395, 0.0009152247221209109, -0.03501187264919281, 0.016958385705947876, -0.037213560193777084, 0.01193110179156065, -0.013592422008514404, 0.024053866043686867, -0.011007947847247124, -0.006898143328726292, 0.00982764270156622, 0.05469852313399315, -0.020434914156794548, -0.045831840485334396, 0.02638113498687744, -0.04671623557806015, -0.037317510694265366, 0.013745940290391445, 0.003054648404940963, 0.06814460456371307, -0.023666897788643837, 0.05382710322737694, -0.03270157799124718, 0.023608071729540825, -0.017447223886847496, -0.010121281258761883, 0.049680426716804504, -0.06279254704713821, 0.031197218224406242, 0.016026485711336136, 0.011565600521862507, -0.040910255163908005, 0.009508802555501461, -0.017720550298690796, -0.014790928922593594, 0.0012462297454476357, -0.02970288135111332, -0.04572325572371483, -0.005737417843192816, 0.001978579442948103, 0.0700843408703804, 0.003984988667070866, -0.0013051546411588788, -0.049892812967300415, -0.009825228713452816, 0.023259682580828667, -0.023698929697275162, 0.006402348168194294, -0.009206399321556091, -0.03740838170051575, 0.0231200959533453, 0.0005306748207658529, 0.025118134915828705, 0.019459489732980728, 0.016790488734841347, 0.014472662471234798, -0.0007742332527413964, 0.029149195179343224, -0.023463036864995956, -0.057009439915418625, 0.060125112533569336, -0.012924447655677795, -0.00811153557151556, 0.03367101028561592, -0.013807435519993305, 0.03393522650003433, 0.05880100652575493, 0.010785585269331932, -0.03149152919650078, 0.023914678022265434, -0.04860007390379906, -0.023082558065652847, 0.014343510381877422, 0.01717957854270935, -0.011855537071824074, -0.03036501072347164, -0.006443353369832039, -0.005087060388177633, -0.016885364428162575, 0.02163534052670002, 0.048039279878139496, 0.014657104387879372, -0.01868104748427868, 0.016031796112656593, 0.0002268296229885891, 0.05140765383839607, -0.02595546841621399, 0.007147714029997587, 0.03551888093352318, 0.04917222261428833, -0.04557983577251434, 0.03886955976486206, 0.012090041302144527, 0.03043668530881405, -0.11917367577552795, -0.05405133217573166, 0.02862381376326084, 0.036069855093955994, -0.007546777371317148, -0.00396527536213398, -0.04415997862815857, 0.01235064584761858, -0.07563569396734238, 0.004129891283810139, -0.007064008619636297, -0.029007215052843094, -0.01671963557600975, 0.05645916610956192, -0.036600563675165176, 0.017984526231884956, 0.025724342092871666, 0.008942579850554466, 0.01106774527579546, 0.0046478030271828175, 0.03900213539600372, -0.008292957209050655, -0.020699528977274895, 0.00958627462387085, 0.009860750287771225, -0.05340104550123215, 0.014177448116242886, -0.05169370025396347, -0.03444620966911316, 0.012107759714126587, -0.026530003175139427, 0.018090510740876198, 0.005447777453809977, 0.011412271298468113, 0.015109281986951828, 0.04741638898849487, -0.005615990608930588, 0.008967097848653793, 0.007862044498324394, -0.016302069649100304, 0.030248010531067848, 0.04832795262336731, -0.011002941057085991, 0.048662666231393814, 0.0244910828769207, 0.00023032368335407227, 0.004213604610413313, 0.007758945692330599, -0.012672428973019123, -0.03999656066298485, 0.037861719727516174, -0.015285259112715721, 0.00748183811083436, 0.017262114211916924, 0.017997199669480324, -0.033280763775110245, 0.029089054092764854, 0.0693957582116127, 0.04863772168755531, -0.04326130077242851, 0.019711684435606003, -0.03104635328054428, -0.009090274572372437, -0.02886734902858734, -0.019185276702046394, -0.015402499586343765, -0.069778673350811, -0.0027702939696609974, -0.003922271076589823, -0.0021332688629627228, -0.02402501180768013, 0.0036323198582977057, -0.005550957750529051, 0.0495133139193058, -0.023694604635238647, -0.01621042564511299, 0.005245639011263847, -0.05104400962591171, 0.005645772907882929, -0.10062257200479507, 0.05951307713985443, 0.018127283081412315, -0.011716644279658794, -0.03516620397567749, -0.0008560657151974738, -0.02021663263440132, 0.0056947749108076096, 0.05628664419054985, 0.05456399545073509, 0.047401122748851776, 0.004038337618112564, 0.02351021021604538, -0.0025953147560358047, -0.011417056433856487, 0.050162266939878464, 0.008286595344543457, 0.0012368778698146343, -0.033077046275138855, 0.009991707280278206, -0.001793025410734117, -0.03237723559141159, 0.028105514124035835, 0.0042434437200427055, 0.012402281165122986, 0.002160344272851944, 0.015193795785307884, 0.029453031718730927, 0.01759248413145542, -0.03821902722120285, 0.01595354452729225, -0.005364369135349989, 0.029380111023783684, 0.005551248788833618, 0.01318736094981432, -0.05116773769259453, 0.007710556499660015, -0.03245598450303078, -0.00674289558082819, 0.019937848672270775, 0.04610808193683624, -0.041573792695999146, -0.04535788670182228, 0.025965383276343346, 0.00787223968654871, -0.05887497216463089, -0.021471906453371048, 0.05446050688624382, 0.02967868000268936, 0.021935679018497467, 0.040973398834466934, -0.008813721127808094, 0.023273395374417305, -0.008639564737677574, -0.01864752545952797, 0.03700723126530647, 0.027435552328824997, -0.006524419877678156, -0.009587910957634449, -0.0036551300436258316, -0.011945456266403198, 0.03797057271003723, 0.031284209340810776, 0.040030017495155334, -0.02874060347676277, -0.048085667192935944, -0.016973601654171944, 0.0090091023594141, -0.016465719789266586, -0.023254109546542168, 0.03274424374103546, 0.06069587171077728, -0.021487846970558167, -0.03152010589838028, -0.06291167438030243, -0.011051913723349571, 0.0192556194961071, 0.032024357467889786, 0.0009202251676470041, 0.03663148358464241, 0.0068133496679365635, -0.02278890088200569, -0.04199304059147835, -0.01287150103598833, 0.030402999371290207, -0.01477868016809225, 0.043525330722332, -0.06550445407629013, -0.02890634350478649, -0.015093408524990082, -0.011583364568650723, -0.019420744851231575, -0.029189590364694595, 0.020604711025953293, 0.021908937022089958, 0.03536893054842949, -0.005946817342191935, -0.03360896557569504, -0.032045941799879074, 0.05976344272494316, -0.08627571910619736, -0.03072066232562065, -0.04044201970100403, 0.004330790601670742, -0.030032355338335037, 0.014292704872786999 ]
<p>I know the value for the 16% quartile, so I know the additive deviation for the given distribution. How do I find the deviation of the log of the given distribution on a multiplicative scale?</p>
73,763
[ -0.010476173833012581, -0.004908167291432619, -0.0007657000096514821, 0.0032220487482845783, 0.05168536677956581, 0.007001698482781649, 0.004772133659571409, -0.015621311031281948, -0.008586596697568893, -0.032130613923072815, 0.06494215875864029, 0.015479098074138165, 0.07448995113372803, 0.0045700594782829285, 0.021356528624892235, 0.012301270850002766, -0.04793865233659744, 0.021427029743790627, 0.004106879234313965, -0.0011514418292790651, -0.0000714425987098366, -0.006774445995688438, 0.00039046810707077384, -0.006511295679956675, -0.018553152680397034, 0.05632883682847023, 0.06638212502002716, 0.012726053595542908, 0.03842315822839737, 0.08412668853998184, -0.029087970033288002, -0.03468446433544159, 0.04617223143577576, 0.04658995196223259, 0.037565927952528, 0.01324760727584362, -0.051048628985881805, 0.006283008959144354, -0.039590153843164444, 0.023679474368691444, -0.05033189058303833, -0.011748719960451126, 0.0513976588845253, 0.014608383178710938, 0.010045578703284264, 0.038285043090581894, -0.010563945397734642, -0.03991860896348953, 0.02690972574055195, -0.027859192341566086, 0.07027933746576309, -0.00503767654299736, 0.016723135486245155, 0.04152632877230644, -0.014809953048825264, 0.001903383294120431, 0.07246086746454239, 0.09913806617259979, -0.007815050892531872, -0.06747868657112122, -0.012068226933479309, -0.00011200286826351658, -0.001834224327467382, -0.03151705488562584, -0.02304564043879509, -0.02027830481529236, -0.027579760178923607, -0.030076224356889725, 0.04677163437008858, -0.02654738537967205, -0.012112383730709553, 0.04832383990287781, 0.03385940194129944, -0.018032703548669815, -0.009033819660544395, -0.028081871569156647, 0.009098068810999393, 0.03322422504425049, 0.03388403356075287, 0.012265756726264954, 0.033577244728803635, 0.02022608369588852, 0.02788170613348484, -0.006338056642562151, 0.0010824552737176418, -0.05493514984846115, 0.08413281291723251, 0.012988042086362839, 0.005887959152460098, 0.010596539825201035, -0.0006779753020964563, 0.008091328665614128, 0.01882573962211609, -0.01834844797849655, -0.02414698339998722, 0.033810269087553024, -0.029441295191645622, -0.005180725362151861, 0.01657991297543049, -0.0031158910132944584, -0.008119117468595505, -0.016703881323337555, 0.029520265758037567, 0.052947983145713806, -0.02567436173558235, 0.010024111717939377, -0.007963522337377071, 0.0009040030417963862, 0.01991105079650879, -0.006731308065354824, 0.025689033791422844, 0.031702715903520584, 0.031469207257032394, -0.02061951346695423, 0.031160390004515648, 0.02782757394015789, -0.05597037822008133, -0.02842612750828266, 0.053366344422101974, 0.003816836979240179, 0.005905286408960819, 0.003859925549477339, 0.02959587238729, -0.013537673279643059, -0.01805669255554676, 0.023111147806048393, 0.020588716492056847, -0.00837128609418869, -0.042124442756175995, 0.033427804708480835, -0.006350314244627953, -0.03071431815624237, 0.026645760983228683, 0.02599193900823593, -0.00213515292853117, -0.00024558970471844077, -0.0631641075015068, -0.05694816634058952, 0.027613259851932526, -0.0031948303803801537, -0.014392311684787273, -0.017232153564691544, -0.03851524740457535, 0.044112928211688995, 0.006564607843756676, 0.022951895371079445, 0.03571894019842148, 0.0012131067924201488, -0.00150635268073529, 0.03247230127453804, 0.011081785894930363, -0.03579330071806908, -0.0422881618142128, -0.02230723761022091, 0.01548463013023138, -0.0628790408372879, -0.002516246633604169, 0.02646302990615368, -0.03711755946278572, -0.04629470035433769, 0.03989280015230179, -0.004560532979667187, -0.037582915276288986, 0.007078854367136955, -0.006552733015269041, -0.041475895792245865, 0.08655326813459396, -0.0013788554351776838, -0.014892681501805782, -0.003972639329731464, -0.013838285580277443, -0.01768779195845127, -0.023735640570521355, 0.01909816265106201, 0.06441566348075867, 0.02011832781136036, -0.012649700045585632, -0.05129407346248627, -0.004657322075217962, 0.036812715232372284, -0.03967028111219406, -0.049975574016571045, -0.03651340678334236, 0.0035251625813543797, 0.009485771879553795, 0.02331472560763359, 0.015870023518800735, 0.0027206551749259233, 0.037478867918252945, -0.021131284534931183, -0.004781320225447416, -0.07284306734800339, 0.008275839500129223, 0.03474024683237076, -0.015749575570225716, 0.013888814486563206, 0.015310046263039112, 0.031117919832468033, -0.00959829892963171, -0.00021857948740944266, 0.04089450463652611, -0.02624663896858692, 0.015337086282670498, -0.020491892471909523, 0.03505677357316017, 0.05163799971342087, 0.04422811418771744, -0.004533157218247652, 0.059341590851545334, -0.0280083529651165, 0.006810636725276709, 0.021113913506269455, -0.014772128313779831, 0.028475409373641014, -0.04764989763498306, -0.004708454012870789, -0.009564659558236599, -0.0014563467120751739, 0.00683855963870883, 0.030468888580799103, -0.029661308974027634, 0.04110703244805336, 0.08243563026189804, 0.048173073679208755, -0.027979837730526924, 0.0015675295144319534, -0.0005154930404387414, 0.04518836364150047, -0.02373627945780754, -0.060238879173994064, -0.06935290992259979, -0.025808358564972878, 0.002608121605589986, 0.023166144266724586, -0.026968006044626236, -0.009905725717544556, 0.04399304464459419, 0.040192294865846634, 0.010561168193817139, 0.0133738424628973, -0.027485085651278496, 0.006381625775247812, 0.026114899665117264, -0.008036750368773937, 0.019364621490240097, 0.012904149480164051, 0.0001753672695485875, 0.029065340757369995, 0.05952368304133415, -0.0013233080971986055, -0.004791613202542067, 0.02235899306833744, -0.022032879292964935, 0.019559094682335854, 0.003017654176801443, -0.020517710596323013, 0.046034738421440125, -0.028612298890948296, -0.0023276163265109062, 0.060985174030065536, 0.023389361798763275, 0.009982172399759293, 0.04533042013645172, -0.028547396883368492, 0.0378350168466568, 0.05958898738026619, -0.04383822903037071, -0.04205288365483284, 0.04048106446862221, -0.02051514759659767, -0.02963867411017418, -0.015728089958429337, -0.017111338675022125, -0.011048630811274052, 0.007103608921170235, 0.03758551552891731, 0.006107978522777557, -0.03209072723984718, -0.010481354780495167, -0.0330367349088192, 0.009466464631259441, -0.03157618269324303, -0.001308710197918117, -0.03175530210137367, -0.033948320895433426, -0.005867978557944298, -0.01221096608787775, 0.011214668862521648, 0.0013672685017809272, -0.02025652676820755, 0.0150902746245265, 0.02009228616952896, 0.004865213297307491, -0.07182111591100693, 0.0011102032149210572, -0.0038960028905421495, 0.004755405709147453, -0.0327816940844059, 0.007013603579252958, 0.04325275123119354, -0.012553978711366653, -0.041623957455158234, 0.04137411341071129, -0.05496593937277794, -0.009400489740073681, -0.05532466247677803, 0.013533033430576324, 0.0009041597950272262, 0.02233271859586239, 0.01606968231499195, -0.021862724795937538, -0.010199926793575287, -0.005090686958283186, -0.08245193958282471, -0.031698137521743774, 0.006285267416387796, 0.032860469073057175, 0.04070482775568962, -0.040088169276714325, -0.01317979209125042, 0.03217153251171112, 0.02957463264465332, -0.0360354408621788, -0.04752465337514877, 0.033914972096681595, -0.003838308621197939, -0.04580216482281685, 0.0224287211894989, 0.004732589703053236, -0.006838669069111347, 0.021892676129937172, -0.010544994845986366, 0.031420912593603134, 0.05446800962090492, -0.006562644615769386, -0.007845770567655563, -0.002829707460477948, -0.04530074819922447, -0.005848330445587635, 0.026099691167473793, 0.016670184209942818, 0.015838662162423134, 0.013965083286166191, 0.013497307896614075, 0.03746161609888077, 0.012082217261195183, -0.04685685783624649, 0.04442097991704941, 0.013353475369513035, -0.04549427703022957, -0.02478875406086445, 0.04156901687383652, 0.031349390745162964, -0.00040454507688991725, 0.01677044853568077, -0.01548864133656025, 0.018786635249853134, -0.029116036370396614, 0.017839526757597923, 0.06908413767814636, 0.05011385679244995, -0.009845172055065632, -0.06009642779827118, 0.007741358131170273, 0.0006113960989750922, 0.0016466238303110003, -0.024409953504800797, 0.004848936572670937, 0.04138791188597679, 0.05384261533617973, 0.009889116510748863, -0.01193354930728674, -0.03486254811286926, 0.01784936524927616, -0.0630556046962738, -0.0223282091319561, 0.003413003869354725, 0.033240269869565964, 0.0029850746504962444, 0.04566621035337448, 0.0019715307280421257, -0.006760476157069206, 0.008326810784637928, 0.002311387564986944, -0.05066605657339096, 0.038117703050374985, -0.0253461804240942, -0.0025416119024157524, 0.00819857232272625, -0.004191509913653135, 0.006209537386894226, -0.01534955482929945, -0.016893010586500168, 0.003493357915431261, 0.009827707894146442, 0.001260707969777286, 0.007912862114608288, -0.008776145055890083, -0.015942182391881943, 0.00009603407670510933, 0.019285762682557106, 0.009852643124759197, -0.03498787432909012, 0.03193298727273941, 0.01554335281252861, 0.0335531085729599, 0.0016930114943534136, -0.017958002164959908, 0.018675118684768677, 0.021761499345302582, 0.05391265079379082, -0.02187662199139595, 0.015134981833398342, -0.029982155188918114, 0.023379771038889885, -0.020944172516465187, 0.025959106162190437, 0.02314506471157074, -0.018886202946305275, -0.017593784257769585, -0.015481499023735523, -0.016688236966729164, -0.0077357725240290165, 0.012871203012764454, -0.027387510985136032, 0.027641544118523598, 0.02474396489560604, 0.02970714308321476, -0.10258933901786804, 0.04064106196165085, 0.08347883075475693, -0.013102255761623383, -0.03769729658961296, -0.007402545306831598, -0.007637585047632456, -0.03194420784711838, -0.02178538404405117, 0.024365095421671867, -0.00718021672219038, -0.016780300065875053, -0.01848836988210678, 0.07730969041585922, -0.007249944843351841, -0.011770197190344334, -0.012456652708351612, 0.021709829568862915, 0.014880658127367496, 0.0036498275585472584, -0.027637463063001633, 0.0266030915081501, 0.05518428236246109, 0.016686053946614265, -0.0003414255625102669, 0.02931138686835766, -0.07742755860090256, 0.022074367851018906, 0.012059526517987251, 0.052559744566679, -0.02151770144701004, -0.008951880037784576, -0.05143633112311363, -0.0029304216150194407, 0.05127962306141853, -0.022834524512290955, 0.02241436019539833, -0.0060786777175962925, 0.054155487567186356, 0.019426779821515083, -0.02666298672556877, -0.05139855295419693, 0.019233644008636475, -0.017239082604646683, 0.012739421799778938, -0.03733254596590996, -0.00493996124714613, -0.0422237254679203, 0.024546759203076363, 0.04143325611948967, 0.0811145082116127, -0.011456326581537724, -0.02561129257082939, -0.0014712531119585037, -0.004850310273468494, -0.022108396515250206, -0.062180906534194946, 0.01478584948927164, -0.022806789726018906, -0.03312883898615837, 0.03596000745892525, -0.0018492485396564007, -0.019432520493865013, 0.008101006969809532, 0.021402254700660706, 0.0015255644684657454, 0.0296548530459404, -0.01806945540010929, 0.0463431254029274, 0.044495582580566406, 0.035714954137802124, 0.07644792646169662, 0.04271897301077843, -0.011241772212088108, 0.010778030380606651, -0.006672348827123642, 0.020898880437016487, -0.02321179211139679, -0.030263395980000496, -0.028567766770720482, 0.015330619178712368, 0.01342715509235859, 0.011561703868210316, -0.022428469732403755, 0.04632686823606491, 0.00014945759903639555, -0.0038425191305577755, -0.005532843992114067, 0.002283524489030242, 0.022785713896155357, 0.0037735644727945328, 0.03386595472693443, 0.03652580454945564, 0.006122112274169922, -0.026121899485588074, 0.054821863770484924, 0.0219570379704237, 0.02683078683912754, -0.006574735511094332, -0.021588081493973732, -0.010797390714287758, -0.061767641454935074, -0.051641013473272324, -0.009800437837839127, -0.0033524350728839636, 0.024619966745376587, -0.014794010668992996, -0.012163914740085602, 0.029668865725398064, -0.04083986207842827, -0.021015571430325508, -0.008613123558461666, 0.022028347477316856, 0.07131105661392212, -0.04896615073084831, 0.03011014685034752, -0.007727427873760462, -0.009739838540554047, -0.09480276703834534, -0.04074883833527565, 0.029712330549955368, 0.033555373549461365, -0.020787445828318596, -0.019462568685412407, -0.008283610455691814, 0.0018048797501251101, -0.012014084495604038, -0.046467047184705734, 0.042261846363544464, 0.0007809957605786622, -0.021459434181451797, -0.021893465891480446, 0.054676786065101624, 0.08033515512943268, -0.009289655834436417, 0.009583860635757446, 0.03499488905072212, 0.00003977668166044168, -0.04546920955181122, 0.015259085223078728, 0.018090076744556427, -0.029069755226373672, -0.01646856591105461, 0.005221618805080652, -0.012225206941366196, -0.00443061301484704, -0.0016435005236417055, -0.011197068728506565, -0.031165165826678276, 0.019297046586871147, -0.006498763337731361, -0.0034732534550130367, -0.007282179780304432, -0.0008719828329049051, 0.020415237173438072, -0.03587538003921509, -0.029542837291955948, -0.015284953638911247, 0.004758595023304224, 0.022852005437016487, 0.057287320494651794, -0.012195788323879242, 0.02846340648829937, 0.08034501224756241, -0.019274618476629257, 0.009002961218357086, 0.03200796619057655, -0.010355591773986816, 0.01246908213943243, -0.023238444700837135, 0.005015713628381491, 0.04105186089873314, 0.008355680853128433, -0.047644488513469696, -0.001935975975356996, -0.02458743192255497, -0.04170365259051323, 0.06673608720302582, -0.0028426405042409897, 0.05179605260491371, 0.01849236898124218, 0.005813145078718662, 0.007812063675373793, -0.002478414447978139, -0.052370067685842514, -0.017970433458685875, 0.03504302725195885, 0.03405831754207611, -0.005623990204185247, 0.014252818189561367, 0.0012392549542710185, 0.00043292558984830976, 0.013330411165952682, 0.03821087256073952, 0.019000044092535973, -0.005686967168003321, 0.01818390190601349, -0.012743496336042881, -0.032440777868032455, 0.01828690804541111, -0.04072098433971405, 0.027758106589317322, -0.04369378834962845, -0.04383917897939682, 0.043924883008003235, -0.02814711630344391, -0.012035135179758072, -0.028401456773281097, -0.004275922663509846, -0.008830374106764793, -0.035608623176813126, 0.008445365354418755, -0.013716175220906734, 0.05309370905160904, 0.013994170352816582, 0.017322294414043427, -0.014783705584704876, -0.009706850163638592, -0.01945735327899456, -0.06713635474443436, -0.032028477638959885, -0.006273347418755293, -0.06265691667795181, 0.023408744484186172, 0.010277044959366322, -0.026136159896850586, 0.012154078111052513, 0.006316599901765585, 0.023807989433407784, 0.011799591593444347, 0.013546465896070004, -0.026177026331424713, 0.05854897201061249, -0.012098073959350586, -0.020299086347222328, 0.014918939210474491, -0.009399626404047012, 0.11111234873533249, 0.06312180310487747, 0.01736532710492611, -0.09449616074562073, -0.0033841782715171576, -0.045317549258470535, -0.010846499353647232, -0.04356894642114639, 0.005681958980858326, -0.0027397482190281153, -0.004166730213910341, 0.07271569222211838, 0.06808026134967804, 0.018902547657489777, -0.019258759915828705, 0.025440597906708717, -0.024212069809436798, -0.04204162582755089, 0.009067247621715069, -0.0011961142299696803, 0.005807653069496155, -0.002886169357225299, -0.05962255969643593, 0.01587209291756153, 0.005812648218125105, 0.01781555451452732, -0.059096403419971466, -0.05451595410704613, -0.014489611610770226, 0.031343478709459305, -0.05466823652386665, 0.004328838083893061, 0.06775209307670593, -0.00019471647101454437, -0.01102958433330059, -0.025819474831223488, 0.006709429435431957, -0.021512839943170547, 0.014966628514230251, 0.028024161234498024, 0.0061261411756277084, 0.027322622016072273, 0.011104452423751354, -0.012452946044504642, -0.04401479288935661, -0.05292320251464844, -0.04623047634959221, 0.0004141909012105316, -0.006272012833505869, 0.018761467188596725, -0.008004124276340008, -0.012510615400969982, -0.06271576881408691, -0.02521391585469246, 0.005054071079939604, 0.0002159412979381159, -0.0029229053761810064, -0.030271213501691818, -0.05373488366603851, 0.013143454678356647, 0.03720379248261452, 0.01725972443819046, 0.023257244378328323, 0.015116343274712563, 0.01143590360879898, -0.008671030402183533, -0.0014375810278579593, 0.025483589619398117, 0.0014143305597826838, -0.022417867556214333, -0.002824479481205344, -0.008411805145442486, -0.010253984481096268, 0.0029046935960650444, -0.009442556649446487, -0.030143724754452705, 0.032048918306827545, 0.01611117273569107, -0.010966367088258266, -0.03497740626335144, -0.05448879674077034, 0.016663499176502228, -0.01520779263228178, 0.021664991974830627, -0.04754772409796715, 0.013214330188930035, 0.012742839753627777, 0.02084171772003174, 0.02560380846261978, 0.017081480473279953, -0.0015244921669363976, 0.04359680414199829, 0.028247887268662453, -0.045042142271995544, 0.026517130434513092, 0.03322365880012512, -0.03980540111660957, -0.01225985586643219, -0.014126211404800415, 0.07830912619829178, 0.02806100808084011, 0.01386936753988266, -0.021292801946401596, 0.008860327303409576, -0.016295278444886208, 0.010975869372487068, 0.012005654163658619, -0.03217526897788048, -0.011730404570698738, 0.05372225493192673, 0.011663950979709625, -0.048014506697654724, -0.008022322319447994, -0.06605201959609985, -0.06193031743168831, 0.03874880447983742, -0.020213594660162926, -0.03215299919247627, -0.017783332616090775, -0.01949821040034294, 0.008937901817262173, -0.027457060292363167, -0.005876387469470501, 0.021940993145108223, -0.007229899056255817, 0.017069634050130844, -0.0015001306310296059, 0.0007285877945832908, -0.0007042229408398271, -0.03397286310791969, 0.004810890182852745, 0.037219077348709106, 0.0403592512011528, 0.05886484310030937, -0.021542813628911972, -0.003288502339273691, -0.031817637383937836, 0.06183134391903877, -0.03325168788433075, 0.003525146981701255, 0.0687788650393486, -0.027845535427331924, -0.002658113371580839, 0.021119344979524612, 0.022849826142191887, 0.017500000074505806, 0.022875027731060982, 0.017383405938744545, -0.014174449257552624, 0.032760683447122574, -0.017333490774035454, -0.016349295154213905, -0.050515200942754745, -0.009850943461060524, 0.025441687554121017, 0.013366976752877235, -0.018692385405302048, -0.011533715762197971, -0.003657320514321327, 0.011810174211859703, 0.0359174907207489, -0.00829632394015789, 0.010832052677869797, -0.004547480959445238, 0.005688801873475313, 0.024480169638991356, 0.021516477689146996, -0.011580429971218109, 0.011223675683140755, 0.037836868315935135, -0.011349394917488098, 0.01415855623781681, -0.015010069124400616, -0.010174269787967205, -0.07716686278581619, -0.04090737923979759, 0.03282258287072182, 0.02640724740922451, 0.056357093155384064, -0.0759148895740509, -0.03902382776141167, 0.04797443747520447, -0.053639139980077744, 0.02881631627678871, -0.029795384034514427, -0.02273276075720787, -0.02095990628004074, -0.005216941703110933, -0.006922021508216858, 0.05784102529287338, 0.03048516809940338, 0.05186005309224129, 0.04149870201945305, 0.0099937217310071, -0.019126707687973976, -0.027291441336274147, 0.005382448900490999, 0.013718502596020699, 0.053220950067043304, -0.06922675669193268, 0.017524054273962975, -0.03244087100028992, -0.02230537310242653, 0.013731404207646847, -0.04891401529312134, 0.03833239525556564, -0.00012113565026083961, 0.01701217144727707, -0.0033838655799627304, 0.07625754922628403, -0.0005453028716146946, -0.009644748643040657, -0.008109552785754204, 0.030773578211665154, 0.016902249306440353, 0.02398284524679184, -0.027295954525470734, -0.01494377851486206, 0.042209986597299576, 0.0011534026125445962, -0.049247730523347855, 0.02130858041346073, 0.017794033512473106, -0.023883605375885963, 0.002692165784537792, -0.001363464747555554, 0.0024710586294531822, -0.05777640640735626, 0.007697926834225655, -0.051375143229961395, -0.009971417486667633, 0.06371912360191345, 0.020864753052592278, -0.02692083828151226, -0.012744852341711521, -0.010042086243629456, -0.05102670565247536, 0.0034780895803123713, -0.015218181535601616, -0.031004758551716805, -0.030561665073037148, 0.0037534248549491167, -0.028144320473074913, -0.01624229922890663, 0.02167997695505619, -0.018359681591391563, 0.013016431592404842, 0.017056932672858238, -0.0394863560795784, 0.012228772975504398, -0.0013035722076892853, -0.023432152345776558, 0.01113555021584034, -0.0574975311756134, 0.07293302565813065, 0.01739605888724327, -0.009130979888141155, -0.030820686370134354, -0.021242355927824974, -0.03887046128511429, -0.0006330629112198949, 0.049155477434396744, 0.03336884826421738, -0.01408762764185667, -0.025161322206258774, -0.006808618549257517, 0.035325851291418076, -0.0271152351051569, 0.00041364654316566885, -0.02748284302651882, 0.010843809694051743, -0.02611982449889183, 0.025447087362408638, -0.044867631047964096, -0.011900517158210278, 0.02425132691860199, -0.007054812740534544, -0.0041952915489673615, 0.0010588847799226642, -0.0272191371768713, 0.007756258361041546, 0.00853500235825777, -0.039681483060121536, 0.09452620148658752, 0.00445677200332284, -0.01372870896011591, 0.03831265866756439, 0.01946439780294895, -0.06311381608247757, 0.03456190973520279, -0.030764201655983925, 0.006769679021090269, -0.012510930188000202, 0.018201880156993866, 0.01643596962094307, -0.026747360825538635, -0.021753517910838127, 0.059444185346364975, -0.060910701751708984, 0.008833445608615875, -0.008665084838867188, 0.030201172456145287, 0.041940052062273026, 0.025537820532917976, -0.007718590088188648, 0.016072096303105354, -0.02075512893497944, 0.016606319695711136, -0.012636742554605007, 0.015140878967940807, -0.024755598977208138, -0.006236362271010876, 0.037187475711107254, -0.03133101761341095, 0.023602532222867012, -0.0005172800156287849, 0.029130324721336365, -0.03625069558620453, -0.01759393699467182, 0.007460226304829121, -0.019626162946224213, 0.01987365446984768, -0.014460318721830845, -0.05745478719472885, 0.0646776482462883, -0.03729655221104622, 0.015318888239562511, -0.04872540757060051, -0.051149483770132065, -0.03885604441165924, -0.030379831790924072, 0.010456804186105728, 0.0008810885483399034, 0.01360925380140543, 0.003685374977067113, 0.02616490051150322, 0.011447908356785774, 0.016934050247073174, -0.02860225923359394, 0.03407970443367958, -0.01981520839035511, -0.016588889062404633, -0.0024344685953110456, -0.03533277288079262, -0.06433330476284027, -0.017823731526732445, -0.005398115608841181, 0.04812515899538994, 0.017971253022551537, 0.03439350798726082, -0.028918124735355377, -0.026885945349931717, 0.043795857578516006, -0.05780445411801338, -0.002485131612047553, -0.05476445332169533, -0.03151395544409752, 0.00991983711719513, -0.01040647178888321 ]
<p>I am trying to figure out good model to analyze social dynamics using a model. I have commenting data from a website. Such as 500 articles, 10000 users, and their 75000 comments. Every user does not comment on every article. </p> <p>The opinions posed by each user is linked to the opinion of the previous users, as well as the opinion of the article itself. The opinions of previous users are also linked to the previous users and the article. </p> <p>I want to estimate the impact of opinion of previous user, average user opinion, article opinion and variation of opinions on the current opinion. Can you suggest a methodology for such a problem? Everything is correlated. </p> <p>I also would like to ask, what software and code would you use to model a problem like this? Codes are very very appreciated. </p>
47,786
[ -0.056508950889110565, -0.040929850190877914, 0.01765294559299946, -0.02062489464879036, 0.047495801001787186, -0.002346343593671918, -0.012221187353134155, -0.014398453757166862, 0.015788475051522255, -0.0461307130753994, 0.022644072771072388, 0.044702399522066116, 0.04837443679571152, 0.03785828873515129, 0.024940207600593567, 0.005067698657512665, 0.007542544510215521, 0.007496354635804892, -0.009808795526623726, 0.014596497640013695, -0.03010893054306507, -0.00037339775008149445, -0.0025572616141289473, -0.024946872144937515, -0.044347841292619705, 0.02006278932094574, 0.021957602351903915, -0.016336023807525635, 0.029437296092510223, 0.039623018354177475, -0.0520542673766613, -0.04598623514175415, 0.004140978213399649, 0.04603087529540062, 0.0026260996237397194, 0.020164692774415016, -0.03296497464179993, -0.05635387450456619, -0.038663350045681, 0.001531120971776545, -0.014253007248044014, -0.025301078334450722, 0.0035967384465038776, 0.01665326952934265, -0.026232296600937843, -0.023692084476351738, 0.006462764460593462, -0.007154297549277544, 0.03247230872511864, -0.047505948692560196, 0.11134262382984161, -0.00101079058367759, 0.049354810267686844, 0.027764596045017242, 0.00022499525221064687, 0.016652418300509453, 0.05049026757478714, 0.06341715157032013, 0.01055035088211298, -0.03851937875151634, -0.02812274917960167, -0.019230136647820473, 0.009346562437713146, -0.008935987949371338, -0.02316196635365486, 0.0675380676984787, -0.01872454583644867, -0.029572054743766785, 0.06778300553560257, 0.013757443986833096, -0.00029841120704077184, 0.012625067494809628, 0.061079539358615875, -0.004300005733966827, 0.016035577282309532, -0.0363224521279335, 0.024838194251060486, 0.01585848070681095, 0.04094752296805382, 0.03999052941799164, -0.0149459233507514, 0.005326807964593172, 0.008461346849799156, 0.04769190773367882, 0.029981601983308792, -0.031078098341822624, 0.06646357476711273, -0.024164238944649696, 0.014679924584925175, 0.03286905959248543, -0.049270402640104294, 0.009920652955770493, 0.022418851032853127, 0.024258213117718697, -0.04119230434298515, 0.020682087168097496, 0.024980895221233368, 0.03282708302140236, 0.013805720955133438, -0.00251430063508451, 0.011864128522574902, -0.0580110177397728, -0.020418008789420128, 0.03750408813357353, -0.019556354731321335, -0.018477262929081917, -0.04168464615941048, -0.0421144925057888, -0.018007075414061546, -0.02499791607260704, -0.0227800440043211, -0.022008171305060387, 0.007369129918515682, -0.007843682542443275, 0.03884681314229965, -0.009063716046512127, -0.0018452078802511096, -0.03900422900915146, 0.059041861444711685, 0.06919889897108078, 0.0024106274358928204, -0.007009921129792929, 0.02339736744761467, -0.020671647042036057, -0.0530741922557354, 0.007156487554311752, 0.035247862339019775, -0.037370167672634125, -0.031961049884557724, 0.05675211548805237, -0.030937958508729935, -0.02176593244075775, 0.04011841490864754, -0.007674220949411392, 0.06354103982448578, -0.0012521761236712337, -0.08255632221698761, -0.05922636762261391, 0.034583140164613724, -0.030305730178952217, 0.05222547426819801, -0.04705580323934555, 0.013878838159143925, 0.04963516443967819, 0.04001535102725029, 0.03023633547127247, 0.035379569977521896, 0.05680917203426361, 0.05673224851489067, 0.009109700098633766, -0.02227773144841194, 0.007753788027912378, -0.009560597129166126, 0.015939118340611458, -0.021251043304800987, -0.046679407358169556, 0.020214185118675232, 0.039780642837285995, -0.027893587946891785, 0.016333578154444695, 0.04016885906457901, 0.038207799196243286, -0.04556660354137421, 0.007503515109419823, 0.02618926763534546, -0.02307155728340149, 0.05792993679642677, -0.012704442255198956, 0.004760030657052994, 0.018805699422955513, 0.011255287565290928, 0.00014263231423683465, -0.016774235293269157, 0.022390522062778473, 0.04214567691087723, -0.00948354508727789, 0.013818520121276379, -0.005688545759767294, -0.01664719544351101, 0.0032383515499532223, -0.04682442173361778, -0.050008900463581085, 0.012782743200659752, 0.00791048165410757, 0.024683095514774323, 0.04505639523267746, 0.005268443841487169, 0.011437592096626759, 0.031095992773771286, -0.037676550447940826, -0.04446526989340782, -0.07128977030515671, 0.017405254766345024, -0.04223279282450676, 0.01229941938072443, -0.0003837882832158357, -0.020579682663083076, 0.008937034755945206, -0.005723105743527412, -0.015190539881587029, -0.02916763350367546, -0.011782963760197163, 0.0556759238243103, -0.010797038674354553, 0.004061849322170019, 0.028537029400467873, 0.0028397038113325834, -0.03899047523736954, 0.015083721838891506, -0.03327979892492294, -0.04384142532944679, -0.014302871190011501, -0.03258365020155907, 0.041569262742996216, -0.027930818498134613, -0.02508963830769062, 0.027718864381313324, -0.009952745400369167, 0.0011652318062260747, 0.014238852076232433, -0.03349125012755394, 0.06269219517707825, 0.05604542791843414, 0.012700905092060566, -0.009969687089323997, 0.013815639540553093, 0.009480566717684269, 0.027063529938459396, -0.020064648240804672, -0.02109086886048317, -0.09686330705881119, 0.03584175556898117, 0.021328262984752655, -0.002162962919101119, -0.054076097905635834, -0.028745291754603386, 0.053923897445201874, 0.022054068744182587, 0.012165834195911884, 0.00552526256069541, -0.026134401559829712, 0.002008568262681365, 0.020006941631436348, 0.027748137712478638, 0.04092836752533913, -0.0006997412419877946, -0.008988880552351475, 0.007156079635024071, 0.02166757918894291, -0.0006804307922720909, 0.00199111457914114, 0.060228582471609116, 0.028409186750650406, 0.016037801280617714, -0.030178016051650047, -0.020337725058197975, 0.047822557389736176, -0.001241290825419128, 0.0004437696188688278, 0.0167899951338768, 0.0025427336804568768, 0.005002671852707863, 0.0066879321821033955, -0.017494430765509605, 0.011388896964490414, 0.02863350138068199, -0.023829083889722824, -0.025043988600373268, 0.017506185919046402, -0.015328180976212025, 0.034426286816596985, 0.00013921699428465217, -0.021739114075899124, -0.0476534478366375, 0.013300283811986446, 0.04358750581741333, 0.0038673935923725367, -0.001012269756756723, 0.008438057266175747, -0.05838564783334732, 0.01785155199468136, 0.002978172153234482, -0.01827755570411682, 0.020688606426119804, -0.08543672412633896, -0.014555716887116432, 0.005913481116294861, -0.01919206976890564, 0.02123318798840046, 0.01771407574415207, -0.0002901637926697731, 0.05528157204389572, 0.005075447261333466, -0.06213444098830223, -0.022228078916668892, -0.013651448301970959, 0.019096987321972847, -0.01841648295521736, -0.03687083721160889, 0.03908281400799751, -0.02816522866487503, -0.03132679685950279, 0.04049775376915932, -0.061065252870321274, -0.02533266879618168, -0.006491152569651604, -0.008060344494879246, 0.01676832139492035, -0.0058731683529913425, 0.014775518327951431, 0.023970622569322586, 0.004410967696458101, -0.024471743032336235, -0.09412578493356705, -0.05749325826764107, 0.06786312162876129, -0.017334874719381332, 0.04357191175222397, -0.003452535020187497, -0.019337326288223267, 0.06806355714797974, 0.0159456729888916, -0.060558732599020004, -0.04715314507484436, -0.016163775697350502, -0.030759762972593307, -0.021589960902929306, 0.019784770905971527, 0.029852572828531265, 0.02279144525527954, -0.004050040617585182, 0.027168957516551018, 0.009744582697749138, 0.002504331059753895, 0.013341098092496395, 0.019180580973625183, 0.005231648217886686, 0.0028609037399291992, 0.02103067748248577, 0.01637604460120201, 0.012407760135829449, -0.012178290635347366, 0.009618406184017658, 0.0034046145156025887, 0.01757516711950302, -0.0009496728889644146, -0.04227425158023834, 0.0006618743645958602, 0.008651777170598507, -0.03533950075507164, -0.031037865206599236, 0.02611871063709259, -0.008003554306924343, -0.03264382481575012, 0.013080975040793419, 0.0021979324519634247, 0.024460066109895706, 0.005681788548827171, 0.019371578469872475, 0.05659112334251404, 0.015388342551887035, -0.036215655505657196, -0.03217398747801781, -0.025902925059199333, 0.00029707467183470726, -0.039726365357637405, -0.04344792664051056, 0.017147930338978767, 0.03406381234526634, 0.02228119783103466, 0.010519502684473991, 0.00217424426227808, -0.05785280838608742, 0.016980120912194252, -0.07331793755292892, 0.028802232816815376, -0.03053862228989601, 0.07693246752023697, -0.011636677198112011, 0.041362468153238297, 0.0008853389881551266, -0.012168495915830135, 0.05705839395523071, -0.009151080623269081, -0.031732071191072464, 0.0396568663418293, -0.03333643823862076, 0.009439283050596714, 0.008633098565042019, -0.0026216479018330574, 0.017572684213519096, -0.0006970841204747558, -0.01928015425801277, -0.015872806310653687, 0.008710102178156376, -0.03943640738725662, -0.01869330182671547, -0.04146411642432213, 0.010465464554727077, 0.010092767886817455, 0.0024263891391456127, 0.009086225181818008, -0.034685760736465454, 0.04624186456203461, 0.047507163137197495, -0.006613311357796192, -0.02028767392039299, -0.058590807020664215, 0.006578931584954262, 0.019813545048236847, 0.03237925097346306, 0.02915029413998127, 0.01339037250727415, -0.047701939940452576, 0.03897299990057945, -0.02083560824394226, 0.02454548142850399, 0.0699034184217453, 0.0006578731699846685, -0.008958667516708374, -0.045741286128759384, 0.0254022479057312, 0.02701694145798683, 0.02402484603226185, -0.00783628225326538, 0.010354245081543922, 0.03142140060663223, 0.02069091983139515, -0.052635375410318375, 0.01966291107237339, 0.028907451778650284, 0.025609560310840607, -0.005746292416006327, 0.0033490308560431004, 0.014267221093177795, 0.010274534113705158, 0.010934931226074696, 0.020447345450520515, 0.002750858897343278, -0.006739114411175251, 0.0046007162891328335, 0.004571632947772741, 0.008958036080002785, -0.03955427557229996, 0.010747650638222694, 0.012457380071282387, 0.07649648934602737, -0.009147925302386284, -0.055021047592163086, 0.001825704937800765, 0.05831082537770271, 0.060288939625024796, 0.01642860472202301, -0.007251577917486429, -0.12014355510473251, 0.007968761026859283, 0.053653158247470856, 0.009389769285917282, -0.03121832199394703, -0.01648620329797268, -0.030599284917116165, -0.03325178846716881, 0.06697101145982742, -0.014797852374613285, 0.004606358241289854, 0.0212024487555027, 0.021540530025959015, -0.010286492295563221, -0.03087354451417923, -0.009481854736804962, 0.021411169320344925, -0.05544175207614899, 0.025022106245160103, -0.0344083197414875, -0.0063131037168204784, -0.05019458383321762, 0.01617114618420601, 0.04173295944929123, 0.04954361543059349, -0.01759241707623005, 0.021709224209189415, 0.013615376316010952, 0.04829423874616623, -0.05313306674361229, -0.07377374172210693, 0.05070324242115021, 0.015443982556462288, -0.015082702971994877, 0.03041343204677105, -0.018589144572615623, -0.011385689489543438, -0.01591695286333561, 0.012321004644036293, -0.004663750063627958, -0.021231938153505325, -0.03723831847310066, 0.027628816664218903, 0.022485338151454926, -0.020769868046045303, 0.05162275210022926, 0.06373978406190872, -0.00844650063663721, 0.00893285870552063, 0.012235973961651325, -0.01237527560442686, -0.006614271085709333, -0.004196769092231989, -0.03101692721247673, -0.006138326600193977, -0.03757888078689575, 0.0393911674618721, -0.0021468857303261757, 0.008522567339241505, -0.02089790627360344, 0.02303779497742653, -0.02026626095175743, 0.03151681274175644, 0.0005687940283678472, -0.014051887206733227, -0.010075502097606659, -0.012438531965017319, 0.019078681245446205, -0.01586119830608368, 0.036663781851530075, -0.05798247829079628, -0.01669926568865776, -0.01889543980360031, -0.04423125460743904, -0.011492385528981686, -0.03803938254714012, -0.04480057209730148, 0.00298546371050179, -0.02523808553814888, 0.04836547374725342, 0.0005485829897224903, 0.028375010937452316, 0.05060941353440285, -0.043698716908693314, -0.018884751945734024, 0.04856378957629204, 0.006652989890426397, 0.03563348948955536, -0.012078769505023956, 0.0328877791762352, -0.02498818188905716, -0.023209288716316223, -0.05782958120107651, -0.05749974772334099, 0.0643254742026329, -0.046806372702121735, -0.010695815086364746, -0.048028599470853806, 0.01525061670690775, -0.026513492688536644, -0.006692160852253437, -0.006728929467499256, 0.007679137866944075, -0.004870369099080563, 0.005548060871660709, 0.023796994239091873, -0.0190914124250412, 0.05370606482028961, -0.006412513554096222, -0.01861170120537281, 0.031538840383291245, -0.010698450729250908, -0.030894985422492027, -0.02304849401116371, 0.03893505781888962, -0.03231854736804962, 0.01627117395401001, -0.041999656707048416, 0.004827991593629122, 0.05313622206449509, -0.03604227304458618, 0.039890214800834656, -0.010260425508022308, 0.028650976717472076, 0.0007173217018134892, -0.01986186020076275, -0.00381473614834249, 0.007623758167028427, -0.006904843728989363, -0.021620091050863266, 0.001861927448771894, -0.023124221712350845, 0.005998275708407164, 0.04354002699255943, 0.0005206422065384686, -0.029522063210606575, 0.0051893810741603374, 0.0441356785595417, 0.024736778810620308, -0.006910047493875027, 0.010316186584532261, -0.042419347912073135, 0.05136646330356598, -0.0396248921751976, -0.017889924347400665, -0.002605311805382371, 0.007937259040772915, -0.014626999385654926, -0.03375784680247307, -0.003121625166386366, -0.030142096802592278, 0.07757698744535446, -0.03624170273542404, 0.033637143671512604, 0.06448530405759811, 0.012173885479569435, -0.0012496388517320156, 0.015530383214354515, -0.013170760124921799, -0.0059750378131866455, 0.005483166314661503, 0.00846012867987156, -0.03857777640223503, -0.002083317143842578, 0.009827276691794395, 0.008923696354031563, 0.016537752002477646, 0.062200043350458145, -0.006810463033616543, 0.01958427205681801, 0.013116545043885708, -0.005293301772326231, -0.012257032096385956, 0.041655782610177994, -0.048595212399959564, 0.0032851751893758774, -0.058017127215862274, -0.03859348222613335, 0.06483084708452225, 0.025113549083471298, 0.016331784427165985, -0.00493341451510787, -0.010229647159576416, -0.024312622845172882, -0.01705778017640114, 0.0055447788909077644, 0.007243161555379629, 0.015251560136675835, 0.057187579572200775, 0.0288139246404171, -0.006311703473329544, 0.06279876828193665, -0.029175657778978348, -0.08928003907203674, -0.018406488001346588, -0.014887156896293163, -0.05224737524986267, 0.022584276273846626, 0.021584277972579002, -0.04466122016310692, 0.01376415230333805, -0.04300771653652191, -0.02748274616897106, 0.00849144160747528, 0.02425105683505535, -0.009632879868149757, 0.08660057187080383, -0.021080102771520615, 0.03436623141169548, -0.013303444720804691, -0.005665724165737629, 0.0920652449131012, 0.07937861979007721, 0.02811346761882305, -0.08264757692813873, 0.00991105381399393, 0.017101144418120384, -0.003977136220782995, -0.03809167072176933, 0.03502847999334335, 0.013799666427075863, 0.0016923341900110245, 0.03708730265498161, 0.029126634821295738, 0.014551741071045399, 0.005686445161700249, 0.05316026881337166, -0.038884397596120834, -0.052343010902404785, 0.008068986237049103, -0.042361970990896225, 0.003946603741496801, -0.031193112954497337, -0.0507427453994751, 0.018994200974702835, 0.005967426113784313, -0.03645472601056099, 0.0015617101453244686, -0.009333900175988674, 0.004239724017679691, -0.010501423850655556, -0.025596367195248604, 0.039273228496313095, 0.0008114338852465153, 0.005805067718029022, -0.0047819423489272594, -0.0034348296467214823, 0.007007664069533348, -0.0030932759400457144, 0.04178287461400032, 0.03319717198610306, 0.010478585958480835, 0.0017904257401823997, 0.005135443527251482, 0.027916427701711655, -0.02025315910577774, -0.04565069079399109, -0.04616932570934296, 0.03781578317284584, 0.00816583912819624, -0.008958091028034687, 0.004741200245916843, 0.035836078226566315, -0.013945507816970348, -0.006751706823706627, -0.06401686370372772, 0.04717453941702843, 0.030681753531098366, -0.005279840901494026, -0.012331373989582062, -0.021797634661197662, 0.013741799630224705, -0.047661617398262024, 0.007775557227432728, 0.018499936908483505, -0.03555039316415787, -0.060868941247463226, -0.03486495465040207, 0.051717545837163925, -0.0026213901583105326, -0.018093662336468697, -0.0353412963449955, -0.03761781007051468, -0.023391490802168846, 0.017923997715115547, -0.013359549455344677, 0.003616723697632551, 0.03471457213163376, -0.019654424861073494, 0.03319776803255081, -0.04739530757069588, -0.0010482422076165676, 0.032509226351976395, 0.019377676770091057, -0.013969063758850098, -0.01169560756534338, 0.001313339569605887, 0.02548893168568611, 0.030602144077420235, 0.017922939732670784, -0.008485031314194202, -0.005864896811544895, -0.016283392906188965, 0.007309063337743282, -0.05357244983315468, -0.0061880131252110004, -0.01944141276180744, -0.04257938265800476, -0.0029218881390988827, -0.02325625717639923, 0.050805266946554184, -0.017466727644205093, -0.04113586246967316, 0.02305036038160324, 0.0345022939145565, -0.0036893209908157587, 0.027809903025627136, 0.02999720722436905, -0.04270565137267113, 0.009243051521480083, -0.015941912308335304, -0.0008779377676546574, -0.04253694415092468, -0.010353943333029747, -0.020908724516630173, 0.0035735941492021084, 0.02520972304046154, -0.007727884221822023, -0.032307449728250504, 0.01992904208600521, -0.0138327581807971, 0.031178010627627373, -0.01605410687625408, 0.0046182903461158276, -0.03211585804820061, -0.001892776694148779, -0.02947331592440605, 0.006566023454070091, -0.01206686906516552, 0.013034365139901638, 0.04336113855242729, 0.01802728697657585, 0.024633387103676796, -0.017055226489901543, 0.0015261914813891053, -0.03656453266739845, 0.008644012734293938, -0.0013985044788569212, 0.044452864676713943, -0.04071008041501045, -0.07209154963493347, 0.02754965052008629, -0.04756186529994011, -0.021500708535313606, -0.004313381854444742, 0.0006220637005753815, 0.039291344583034515, 0.009162127040326595, -0.04091900587081909, 0.03121391125023365, 0.04486866295337677, -0.0024761527311056852, -0.028975823894143105, -0.00623379647731781, 0.003569759428501129, -0.01168045960366726, 0.0029718398582190275, 0.008208251558244228, 0.03073236159980297, -0.018743686378002167, 0.03137902915477753, 0.06478425860404968, -0.0016728894552215934, -0.020585445687174797, -0.002241583075374365, 0.013057183474302292, 0.025101661682128906, 0.016193203628063202, 0.016661202535033226, 0.04483971372246742, 0.0635390356183052, -0.04667056351900101, -0.004372225143015385, 0.01776130497455597, 0.007495570462197065, -0.05097288265824318, 0.013518278487026691, 0.015006172470748425, -0.019006866961717606, 0.040873851627111435, -0.051593054085969925, 0.019139902666211128, 0.04964887723326683, -0.02455921284854412, 0.03290402144193649, 0.036348551511764526, 0.03444065526127815, -0.012077386491000652, -0.002390041947364807, -0.03898276761174202, 0.06740638613700867, 0.029493793845176697, 0.04912067577242851, 0.03334329277276993, 0.014477469958364964, 0.023386843502521515, -0.03323761001229286, -0.03187888488173485, 0.004034825135022402, -0.00013048223627265543, -0.0195721834897995, 0.034523725509643555, -0.05527987703680992, -0.04114798828959465, 0.05928238481283188, -0.01160399429500103, 0.024774953722953796, 0.013527330942451954, 0.04713570699095726, 0.005990046076476574, 0.03064453788101673, 0.012445961125195026, -0.013972251676023006, -0.012275469489395618, 0.020486941561102867, 0.015407855622470379, 0.018093910068273544, 0.006095195189118385, 0.02945961058139801, 0.013897139579057693, -0.028935441747307777, -0.0032201369758695364, 0.031317513436079025, -0.023825090378522873, -0.03111167810857296, -0.02459702268242836, -0.028898652642965317, -0.00680472981184721, -0.02290872484445572, -0.013474289327859879, -0.02408778667449951, 0.020187146961688995, 0.030092889443039894, -0.006722464691847563, -0.007500257808715105, -0.014942239969968796, -0.017892569303512573, -0.03841521590948105, 0.020478691905736923, -0.020919950678944588, -0.01622435450553894, -0.07633242756128311, 0.002426914405077696, -0.006782400421798229, -0.023417895659804344, -0.03956448659300804, -0.016557076945900917, -0.03782648220658302, 0.05123433843255043, -0.030939936637878418, -0.013620216399431229, 0.03527970239520073, -0.04087657481431961, 0.006375198718160391, -0.05593498423695564, 0.06618733704090118, 0.03178918734192848, 0.0004821232578251511, -0.01736929453909397, 0.005659741815179586, -0.012887380085885525, -0.01926605775952339, 0.05360075458884239, -0.021757442504167557, 0.00033847405575215816, -0.00756080960854888, 0.01734694465994835, 0.009559480473399162, -0.04053265601396561, 0.015306688845157623, -0.0382174476981163, 0.006466559134423733, -0.021546993404626846, -0.02531399019062519, 0.0008225415367633104, -0.010082123801112175, 0.010658908635377884, -0.04222061485052109, -0.0047774421982467175, 0.006470471154898405, -0.03730757534503937, 0.028882890939712524, 0.03642953559756279, -0.0003014119283761829, 0.033477380871772766, 0.02269837260246277, 0.019203072413802147, 0.04780988022685051, 0.024212872609496117, -0.022771108895540237, 0.031073428690433502, -0.05482965707778931, -0.02426828071475029, -0.012220440432429314, -0.012152068316936493, -0.01166011206805706, -0.06581562757492065, 0.000692385365255177, 0.03438926860690117, -0.06887322664260864, 0.010824760422110558, 0.005021392833441496, 0.004749646410346031, 0.021187439560890198, 0.0009329263702966273, 0.03712094575166702, 0.024436861276626587, 0.0314500629901886, -0.017994863912463188, -0.011220427230000496, 0.038573406636714935, 0.010105685330927372, 0.042177196592092514, 0.018574994057416916, -0.015776848420500755, 0.06368276476860046, -0.023607371374964714, 0.007861316204071045, -0.044290151447057724, -0.010697595775127411, 0.020162736997008324, 0.018526028841733932, 0.01330313179641962, 0.048650480806827545, -0.02754725143313408, 0.046607114374637604, -0.04861848056316376, 0.025212116539478302, -0.0035242463927716017, -0.023597490042448044, -0.03155367821455002, 0.03142113983631134, -0.006433658301830292, 0.012266845442354679, -0.0016870989929884672, 0.003994894213974476, 0.037521760910749435, 0.010896430350840092, 0.024656932801008224, -0.00849904678761959, 0.03628610819578171, -0.005503842607140541, -0.023234019055962563, -0.015680061653256416, -0.012640406377613544, -0.01807265169918537, -0.003990027587860823, 0.06565577536821365, 0.030283773317933083, 0.03411417454481125, -0.013922305777668953, 0.028073962777853012, -0.04171454906463623, 0.05008894205093384, -0.05253622680902481, -0.024419091641902924, -0.05038880184292793, 0.007467267569154501, -0.024340176954865456, -0.02463270165026188 ]
<p>I previously asked this question: <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/24194/winning-percentage-logistic-regression-or-linear-regression">link</a></p> <p>I've generated the two logistic regression models described in the link using all available data (8 seasons for all 30 teams), and now I want to decide which is a better predictor of win percentage in the coming season, winning percentage in the previous season or Pythagorean expectation from the previous season. </p> <p>I know that if you want to evaluate the predictive abilities of a model, it's often good to evaluate on data different from that which generated the model. I wonder how important that is here, given that the models are of the same type, created from the same data. It seems as though we could say that the model which was a better fit with respect to the data which created both models is better in this case. </p> <p>So, the question is: 1) do I need to see how the models compare on a different data set, and 2) what's the standard measure for model comparison in a situation like that I've described. </p> <p>Basically, how do I know which is better? </p>
73,764
[ -0.06476544588804245, 0.009711799211800098, -0.04553724080324173, 0.0001686637697275728, 0.0009260824299417436, 0.014098391868174076, 0.01332581602036953, -0.03480774164199829, 0.0445808544754982, 0.01664838008582592, 0.026736203581094742, 0.02891557104885578, -0.0002847861032932997, 0.02613094076514244, 0.012350084260106087, 0.005138294771313667, -0.010403304360806942, 0.00547424890100956, -0.003525323700159788, 0.0271003395318985, -0.011807235889136791, -0.004497912246733904, 0.01932227611541748, -0.007436985615640879, -0.020346419885754585, 0.07475174218416214, 0.06110244616866112, 0.007386405020952225, 0.023340104147791862, 0.02963479980826378, 0.010053087957203388, 0.003522062674164772, -0.004664984531700611, 0.08494433760643005, 0.01766773872077465, -0.008267106488347054, -0.0034990108106285334, -0.045397743582725525, -0.012013077735900879, 0.025190437212586403, -0.016769230365753174, -0.03929844871163368, 0.0033150201197713614, 0.03221296891570091, 0.006502077449113131, 0.04469012841582298, -0.04269437491893768, -0.026455245912075043, 0.02683842182159424, -0.022279582917690277, 0.03870181739330292, 0.005557292606681585, 0.017360609024763107, 0.04326842725276947, -0.0070863584987819195, 0.0037750164046883583, 0.03215046226978302, 0.0998399555683136, -0.009782494977116585, -0.05097401142120361, -0.018846383318305016, -0.009070971049368382, -0.004652911797165871, -0.011164010502398014, -0.054914843291044235, 0.05562352389097214, 0.018846731632947922, -0.03356480598449707, 0.05447130277752876, -0.010081040672957897, 0.011644323356449604, 0.01495038066059351, 0.05591728165745735, -0.009925467893481255, 0.006362109445035458, -0.02805241011083126, 0.006494706030935049, 0.024636348709464073, 0.04930518567562103, 0.020363112911581993, -0.003711434779688716, 0.030293352901935577, 0.03956691175699234, 0.06423623859882355, 0.04694998636841774, 0.0008338597835972905, 0.057815954089164734, -0.039102308452129364, 0.020802637562155724, 0.009501761756837368, -0.024567129090428352, -0.004452730529010296, 0.018455015495419502, 0.007291409652680159, -0.04338083043694496, 0.013628436252474785, -0.04455631971359253, 0.03636104613542557, 0.04296285659074783, 0.0005460896645672619, 0.012023849412798882, -0.06151178106665611, 0.0020596918184310198, 0.01762443780899048, 0.022465238347649574, -0.025314532220363617, -0.05201165750622749, -0.0024295602925121784, -0.015879018232226372, -0.058181069791316986, -0.013284975662827492, 0.04277271032333374, -0.00009703058458399028, 0.030371706932783127, -0.006460798438638449, -0.03156070038676262, -0.01325943786650896, -0.03154134377837181, 0.0754818469285965, 0.04475940018892288, 0.04233499988913536, -0.02181245945394039, 0.03788089379668236, -0.035715606063604355, -0.012173579074442387, -0.004859468899667263, -0.004363342188298702, -0.012013360857963562, -0.03819431737065315, 0.04437996819615364, -0.011973860673606396, -0.02232067659497261, 0.02053038403391838, 0.01847834885120392, 0.03992299735546112, 0.02627517469227314, -0.09503718465566635, -0.0392942875623703, 0.029378443956375122, -0.0006111169350333512, 0.026153089478611946, -0.05378425493836403, -0.02551664412021637, 0.02840035781264305, 0.06652816385030746, 0.023893073201179504, 0.03565356880426407, 0.008600289933383465, 0.04667400196194649, -0.012238369323313236, -0.004085037391632795, -0.020847665145993233, -0.05389931797981262, -0.022798050194978714, -0.012966335751116276, -0.08568491041660309, -0.00805400125682354, 0.025585589930415154, -0.01207492034882307, 0.009928260929882526, 0.026496522128582, 0.022602710872888565, 0.002267996082082391, -0.00986634660512209, 0.02601637877523899, -0.0012956330319866538, 0.054500509053468704, -0.009298812597990036, 0.028769217431545258, -0.02543358877301216, -0.010464410297572613, -0.009986033663153648, 0.04810520261526108, 0.024879634380340576, 0.05647817999124527, 0.017321601510047913, 0.011676852591335773, -0.01954926922917366, -0.00008416621858486906, -0.011711617931723595, -0.0498698428273201, 0.009124496951699257, -0.029121603816747665, -0.016818787902593613, 0.01713649183511734, 0.05745823308825493, 0.004681815858930349, -0.0047281901352107525, 0.054044295102357864, -0.04306836426258087, -0.07918344438076019, -0.07710782438516617, -0.0007183016277849674, 0.006803305819630623, -0.007594176568090916, 0.037969134747982025, 0.019350437447428703, 0.034307967871427536, -0.021835997700691223, 0.0221241544932127, 0.004016960505396128, 0.025642652064561844, 0.05884115397930145, -0.03242611140012741, -0.004630370065569878, 0.05883259326219559, 0.026045426726341248, -0.024329062551259995, 0.02407090924680233, -0.06994317471981049, -0.058392006903886795, 0.04124284163117409, -0.005111610051244497, -0.00707011204212904, -0.013137754052877426, 0.009628360159695148, 0.014056598767638206, -0.012260576710104942, -0.04340256750583649, 0.031182684004306793, -0.07331469655036926, 0.05101252719759941, 0.054685790091753006, 0.002059356775134802, 0.00780680775642395, 0.026488546282052994, -0.031224282458424568, 0.025657348334789276, -0.010119014419615269, 0.007972444407641888, -0.0407254733145237, 0.0003383454750292003, 0.05505272373557091, 0.0293028112500906, -0.02566990628838539, 0.02982456050813198, 0.06716325134038925, -0.017342396080493927, -0.02542450651526451, 0.027018310502171516, -0.041170984506607056, -0.02377878688275814, -0.010858941823244095, 0.027396967634558678, 0.02534469962120056, -0.02557169646024704, 0.021154027432203293, 0.015967464074492455, 0.041209034621715546, 0.022298626601696014, -0.02407551184296608, 0.0666268989443779, 0.00467277504503727, -0.03226344287395477, 0.005744173191487789, -0.0038125880528241396, 0.05009462684392929, -0.0073274290189146996, -0.03873931244015694, 0.020855437964200974, 0.008807497099041939, -0.008114852011203766, 0.01163752842694521, 0.030512554571032524, 0.03020787239074707, 0.06004306674003601, -0.02976168505847454, 0.021522827446460724, 0.02556140162050724, -0.018872829154133797, 0.020876605063676834, -0.01570197381079197, -0.03232605755329132, -0.03411667421460152, 0.0262202937155962, 0.016488997265696526, -0.024499868974089622, 0.02543686144053936, 0.00532594695687294, -0.02357056550681591, 0.003347356105223298, -0.020340953022241592, 0.009369543753564358, 0.008505964651703835, -0.06244002655148506, -0.012226782739162445, -0.04609079658985138, 0.006541863549500704, 0.012549727223813534, -0.02744024060666561, 0.0035611020866781473, 0.018917925655841827, -0.007804597727954388, -0.07716258615255356, -0.047796256840229034, -0.041382260620594025, 0.0392935536801815, -0.00400687288492918, -0.0440773144364357, 0.01902339607477188, 0.017703434452414513, -0.04876454174518585, 0.007622986100614071, -0.027810631319880486, 0.024379633367061615, -0.005625654477626085, 0.02822963148355484, 0.020323559641838074, 0.010143917053937912, 0.004558858927339315, 0.025361334905028343, -0.04313379526138306, -0.031270988285541534, -0.08983686566352844, -0.03848787769675255, 0.009122764691710472, -0.01619655080139637, 0.010957609862089157, -0.004163023550063372, -0.037259284406900406, 0.0780404657125473, 0.06067522242665291, -0.011384791694581509, -0.05874951183795929, 0.025263361632823944, -0.04586203396320343, -0.028460999950766563, -0.013203143142163754, 0.010098886676132679, -0.004322837572544813, 0.042185455560684204, -0.025077763944864273, 0.0014465758576989174, 0.01533527858555317, -0.011761792004108429, 0.015012179501354694, 0.0175858736038208, 0.01727459952235222, -0.013341470621526241, 0.02899017743766308, -0.0023412532173097134, -0.006773157045245171, 0.03665334731340408, 0.014685774222016335, 0.013132559135556221, 0.018387608230113983, -0.0581112802028656, 0.029926421120762825, -0.008724750019609928, -0.021772049367427826, -0.010179206728935242, 0.021372618153691292, -0.014630810357630253, -0.02694535069167614, 0.008927201852202415, 0.02913792058825493, 0.024216486141085625, 0.012641030363738537, -0.014398209750652313, 0.042843058705329895, 0.014702585525810719, -0.017361240461468697, 0.002874907338991761, -0.03499612957239151, -0.015009515918791294, 0.020885910838842392, -0.024309881031513214, -0.029989490285515785, 0.03189776465296745, 0.01072877086699009, -0.008270659483969212, -0.018064318224787712, -0.04079540818929672, -0.02015150897204876, -0.06017271429300308, 0.02264440432190895, -0.027642400935292244, 0.03745760768651962, 0.024397481232881546, 0.020107991993427277, -0.024812469258904457, -0.025613846257328987, 0.023130830377340317, -0.005460340995341539, -0.06707821786403656, 0.034525979310274124, -0.0017370384884998202, -0.0092445258051157, -0.011988015845417976, -0.041872721165418625, 0.0219274889677763, -0.027156783267855644, -0.013224156573414803, 0.014980634674429893, 0.009200779721140862, -0.019322779029607773, 0.01073925755918026, -0.03551063314080238, -0.034337304532527924, -0.007124339230358601, 0.017110345885157585, 0.0010617178631946445, -0.013598459772765636, 0.012541153468191624, 0.02645391784608364, 0.00822196714580059, -0.029957717284560204, 0.0015887939371168613, 0.04609351605176926, 0.022457081824541092, 0.007850033231079578, 0.023171141743659973, 0.014691357500851154, -0.04631999135017395, 0.033745843917131424, 0.013044022023677826, 0.013249152339994907, 0.020160457119345665, -0.025945408269762993, -0.024522926658391953, -0.06294940412044525, -0.015109280124306679, 0.006879252847284079, 0.030880792066454887, -0.004917540121823549, -0.01649077981710434, 0.05919281020760536, 0.06161382421851158, -0.024806441739201546, 0.028468143194913864, 0.029044270515441895, -0.011826331727206707, 0.0008203914039768279, -0.03801608830690384, 0.020154397934675217, -0.0014800586504861712, -0.001410807715728879, 0.030468784272670746, 0.018037522211670876, 0.03934485837817192, -0.02666381001472473, 0.03249606117606163, -0.03806709870696068, -0.05599696561694145, 0.010407431051135063, 0.04587883502244949, 0.03821076825261116, 0.003962344489991665, -0.04947800189256668, 0.023298408836126328, 0.07829998433589935, 0.021257173269987106, 0.03271075338125229, 0.021045027300715446, -0.05636809393763542, -0.004523496609181166, 0.044688209891319275, 0.029474899172782898, -0.05612083524465561, -0.047321878373622894, -0.02633572369813919, 0.010034327395260334, 0.04863698035478592, -0.0017976927338168025, 0.05269389599561691, 0.02749555930495262, 0.020122753456234932, -0.06171325221657753, -0.013275875709950924, -0.053377989679574966, 0.03138458728790283, 0.003080980619415641, 0.029060354456305504, -0.02218298800289631, -0.008377649821341038, -0.029982753098011017, 0.01534613873809576, 0.012176857329905033, 0.06038220226764679, -0.032070789486169815, -0.024219412356615067, 0.005322431679815054, 0.01407956425100565, 0.002061589388176799, -0.032981786876916885, 0.0020691175013780594, 0.01840382069349289, -0.033931296318769455, 0.02103823982179165, -0.023901956155896187, -0.02302038110792637, -0.0029403259977698326, 0.0005334822344593704, -0.022593818604946136, 0.015162778086960316, -0.011241860687732697, 0.046121083199977875, 0.023329736664891243, -0.007428060285747051, 0.05139758437871933, 0.015478460118174553, -0.0013432825217023492, -0.008736812509596348, -0.041696496307849884, -0.017225686460733414, -0.001137371058575809, -0.05028154328465462, -0.029378095641732216, -0.03918334096670151, -0.03959670290350914, 0.030320651829242706, -0.013552566058933735, 0.057201869785785675, -0.020376145839691162, -0.025264734402298927, -0.006705874111503363, 0.025315923616290092, 0.002707891399040818, -0.022502068430185318, 0.02920084446668625, 0.013531409204006195, -0.026989301666617393, -0.00030226228409446776, 0.0022895890288054943, -0.008566221222281456, 0.005913113243877888, 0.02516110986471176, -0.04278646782040596, 0.04061700403690338, -0.015220662578940392, -0.00833659153431654, -0.022625699639320374, -0.010101410560309887, 0.0061187744140625, 0.010764152742922306, 0.025830067694187164, -0.010528403334319592, -0.0549294650554657, -0.01459177304059267, -0.002602816093713045, 0.026366746053099632, 0.0491139218211174, -0.019553355872631073, 0.024308498948812485, -0.028316864743828773, -0.03939799219369888, -0.05593062564730644, -0.039854180067777634, 0.017064683139324188, 0.007182929199188948, -0.05162904039025307, -0.03257063031196594, 0.016826044768095016, -0.010893418453633785, -0.020304394885897636, 0.005929806735366583, 0.07821875065565109, -0.013292886316776276, -0.02500571310520172, -0.0018627527169883251, 0.015285229310393333, 0.076544389128685, 0.001900003175251186, -0.009593439288437366, 0.005157965701073408, -0.02462424524128437, 0.004196615424007177, 0.010628894902765751, 0.05126424506306648, -0.03031803108751774, -0.019848229363560677, 0.0038010133430361748, 0.014201711863279343, 0.07256481051445007, -0.005430459976196289, -0.017013873904943466, 0.025260472670197487, -0.008469777181744576, 0.030724938958883286, -0.0030733158346265554, 0.005548352841287851, -0.026347465813159943, 0.005426761228591204, -0.027751542627811432, 0.0016594947082921863, 0.019733114168047905, -0.027603350579738617, 0.027666639536619186, 0.02315661683678627, 0.029010361060500145, -0.011756068095564842, 0.06033044680953026, -0.004926242399960756, 0.0005929523031227291, -0.010036014020442963, -0.044908344745635986, 0.0607663132250309, 0.00280617899261415, 0.011916758492588997, -0.005332959815859795, 0.04477398097515106, -0.015476279892027378, -0.037431664764881134, -0.032073285430669785, 0.014004874043166637, 0.035828378051519394, -0.007174356374889612, 0.03474895656108856, 0.05120159685611725, 0.035050828009843826, 0.00613799225538969, -0.06458486616611481, -0.006051668431609869, -0.031162967905402184, 0.007717018015682697, 0.05827988684177399, -0.017530465498566628, -0.013947400264441967, 0.049384668469429016, -0.020868834108114243, 0.025906646624207497, 0.020519955083727837, 0.038775667548179626, 0.025471001863479614, 0.03423373028635979, -0.01730840839445591, -0.023465333506464958, 0.03612816333770752, -0.04926588758826256, 0.0031100919004529715, -0.04990724101662636, 0.013549384661018848, 0.06875292211771011, 0.07202360779047012, 0.003484300570562482, -0.052039843052625656, -0.010735899209976196, -0.07353153079748154, -0.011685920879244804, 0.010733811184763908, 0.018803875893354416, 0.019301041960716248, 0.015394497662782669, 0.025291914120316505, 0.0013991284649819136, 0.026134654879570007, -0.009481769055128098, -0.09112998843193054, -0.015406828373670578, 0.009300212375819683, -0.0326179638504982, -0.006059219595044851, 0.030842792242765427, -0.01612897589802742, 0.013586899265646935, -0.03395659476518631, -0.01354304514825344, -0.033494338393211365, 0.025843121111392975, -0.018546784296631813, 0.07022392004728317, -0.025364838540554047, 0.011595102027058601, 0.0019080762285739183, -0.012085053138434887, 0.12046661227941513, 0.07404488325119019, 0.039805348962545395, -0.03882141038775444, 0.03237978368997574, 0.01658383198082447, -0.016231073066592216, -0.014799567870795727, -0.006764678750187159, 0.01617312617599964, -0.025190332904458046, 0.05380513519048691, 0.027304749935865402, 0.00034587012487463653, -0.031158143654465675, 0.05504447594285011, -0.03143427148461342, 0.03186333552002907, 0.01810622401535511, 0.0096869096159935, 0.0011917364317923784, -0.029388178139925003, -0.004571973811835051, 0.014380051754415035, -0.0016363962786272168, 0.02508402056992054, 0.010051324963569641, -0.027882061898708344, -0.01562797650694847, -0.02094150148332119, -0.015122927725315094, -0.0036327613051980734, 0.028581256046891212, 0.045644424855709076, -0.025884367525577545, 0.021211277693510056, 0.012610089965164661, -0.062185924500226974, 0.015755318105220795, 0.0248403362929821, 0.006821253336966038, 0.010594496503472328, -0.011053906753659248, 0.02742268517613411, -0.045204706490039825, -0.020200714468955994, -0.09196748584508896, 0.012892377562820911, 0.019292619079351425, -0.0056252977810800076, -0.007946302182972431, -0.014090473763644695, -0.04163603484630585, -0.022817520424723625, -0.018633663654327393, 0.03342723473906517, 0.026971876621246338, -0.021816113963723183, -0.04594440385699272, -0.037564072757959366, 0.02817530743777752, 0.0071811494417488575, 0.027649832889437675, 0.0182856023311615, -0.0148259112611413, -0.030089357867836952, -0.0003849357017315924, 0.05299815908074379, 0.008474864065647125, 0.0172639898955822, 0.010149143636226654, -0.005049817729741335, -0.04247591271996498, -0.0076056597754359245, 0.007252752780914307, 0.0046730367466807365, 0.018322572112083435, 0.00891134049743414, -0.019837534055113792, -0.008817327208817005, -0.039496876299381256, -0.016603803262114525, -0.011898582801222801, 0.02069898135960102, -0.05887626111507416, 0.0048592654056847095, 0.030546782538294792, 0.025080811232328415, -0.0006690747104585171, 0.030474018305540085, 0.011074719950556755, 0.013787376694381237, -0.0068736146204173565, -0.05535668134689331, -0.0017358044860884547, -0.005022503901273012, -0.06550653278827667, 0.0012355473591014743, -0.02639056369662285, 0.061217471957206726, 0.025263790041208267, 0.010338537395000458, -0.014864637516438961, 0.01982985995709896, 0.01716509461402893, 0.05207301676273346, -0.008294466882944107, -0.06380204856395721, -0.024755146354436874, 0.011351560242474079, -0.005497632548213005, -0.014708849601447582, -0.012858168222010136, -0.05410895496606827, -0.04717293754220009, 0.02329559437930584, -0.06014866754412651, -0.04263585805892944, 0.008615778759121895, -0.009701667353510857, 0.021215908229351044, -0.003961833659559488, -0.027979660779237747, -0.03127981349825859, 0.01257716678082943, 0.015241549350321293, -0.037710074335336685, 0.026080360636115074, 0.008364969864487648, -0.011345411650836468, -0.0037726254668086767, 0.045007701963186264, -0.012689778581261635, 0.017302092164754868, -0.048271939158439636, 0.022092917934060097, -0.021414054557681084, 0.047757621854543686, -0.03493574261665344, -0.01646885648369789, 0.052424028515815735, 0.021650714799761772, -0.04227277263998985, 0.030924376100301743, -0.0070456163957715034, 0.043690115213394165, 0.00646986672654748, -0.0032713240943849087, -0.0068906815722584724, 0.02457868680357933, -0.006843003910034895, 0.001367884804494679, -0.01365495752543211, -0.007541121449321508, -0.0062965042889118195, -0.006307493429630995, 0.011405927129089832, 0.005373863037675619, -0.011699325405061245, -0.012563614174723625, 0.028999296948313713, -0.01216848473995924, -0.009427627548575401, -0.035467538982629776, -0.019996851682662964, 0.010709470137953758, -0.008946345187723637, -0.01930488459765911, 0.03876940906047821, 0.014775251969695091, 0.0007569122244603932, 0.011885703541338444, 0.027627313509583473, -0.0008785515674389899, -0.09283491969108582, -0.05050954595208168, 0.011403157375752926, 0.026305101811885834, -0.0026980997063219547, -0.08173517882823944, 0.018308188766241074, 0.0434214286506176, -0.01682714931666851, 0.028652647510170937, 0.033320263028144836, 0.008457210846245289, -0.048212118446826935, -0.02110898867249489, -0.0185327660292387, 0.03116375207901001, 0.003701640758663416, 0.0032342865597456694, 0.012072989717125893, 0.025725113227963448, -0.002055539283901453, -0.01357932947576046, -0.05329608917236328, 0.031215816736221313, -0.002106540836393833, -0.04591606929898262, 0.03336785361170769, -0.03879919648170471, -0.057833608239889145, 0.03061557374894619, 0.006772362161427736, 0.027412788942456245, 0.021220333874225616, 0.0011380036594346166, 0.017918406054377556, 0.018448151648044586, 0.04277001693844795, -0.02241167426109314, -0.035568974912166595, 0.0004809370147995651, 0.02965705282986164, 0.015719454735517502, -0.040685154497623444, 0.00566341495141387, 0.010999700985848904, 0.0012168021639809012, -0.02401980198919773, -0.023120321333408356, -0.012862429022789001, -0.01119257789105177, -0.011740108951926231, -0.0029296851716935635, 0.006133790593594313, -0.028321463614702225, 0.012963791377842426, -0.04733012616634369, 0.01105597335845232, 0.05118047073483467, 0.04237000644207001, -0.060755252838134766, 0.03231833130121231, -0.008931961841881275, -0.038612328469753265, -0.010666076093912125, -0.016183750703930855, 0.015350328758358955, -0.03907749056816101, 0.0017087648157030344, 0.0048669930547475815, -0.01813659444451332, -0.02747313864529133, -0.009508212096989155, -0.09551449120044708, 0.043782975524663925, -0.018519418314099312, 0.01458026934415102, 0.042607348412275314, -0.0015207126270979643, 0.015456557273864746, -0.0751747190952301, 0.05361485853791237, 0.02419283241033554, -0.05280812084674835, -0.014347442425787449, 0.0016341782175004482, -0.03562705218791962, -0.026264594867825508, 0.07138241082429886, 0.006079688668251038, -0.0046703689731657505, -0.004762599244713783, 0.021963434293866158, -0.010437749326229095, -0.024477064609527588, 0.012155383825302124, -0.024978971108794212, -0.008928036317229271, -0.025437038391828537, -0.025339599698781967, 0.00847212877124548, 0.00427449494600296, 0.043282490223646164, -0.016411853954195976, 0.008749252185225487, 0.0072674984112381935, -0.007499219849705696, 0.03768979758024216, -0.0066431183367967606, -0.01454294752329588, 0.05007113888859749, 0.03457037732005119, -0.004537147935479879, 0.009947656653821468, -0.0034600377548485994, -0.025053594261407852, 0.07619629800319672, -0.04462327063083649, -0.022042518481612206, -0.00755776884034276, 0.010470980778336525, -0.013278715312480927, -0.04020987078547478, 0.0016262017888948321, 0.043430596590042114, -0.012776064686477184, 0.018451858311891556, 0.006071214098483324, -0.005802069325000048, 0.0180509053170681, -0.009837676770985126, 0.02938426472246647, -0.0013247150927782059, -0.02517644129693508, -0.01873895712196827, -0.03385186567902565, 0.044659651815891266, 0.0511542372405529, 0.002602081745862961, 0.037464965134859085, -0.007176443003118038, 0.04775048419833183, 0.006414478644728661, 0.045657362788915634, -0.0378875769674778, 0.009206215851008892, 0.01701386645436287, -0.006247436162084341, 0.020421531051397324, 0.016147060319781303, -0.007156542968004942, 0.05400839075446129, -0.061257876455783844, 0.012384572066366673, -0.045388177037239075, 0.004794083070009947, -0.013900191523134708, -0.02496703341603279, 0.023871732875704765, 0.01744825206696987, 0.03859665244817734, 0.02824990637600422, 0.027478208765387535, 0.006074400153011084, 0.029446575790643692, 0.02836567722260952, 0.011821422725915909, -0.02190345525741577, 0.014323369599878788, -0.046480901539325714, -0.02521016076207161, -0.02773287147283554, -0.004254366271197796, 0.009231689386069775, 0.04362024739384651, 0.00587485870346427, -0.022464411333203316, -0.06317365169525146, -0.0043147592805325985, 0.04522251710295677, -0.061474382877349854, -0.03232454136013985, -0.07462983578443527, 0.034254319965839386, 0.039543602615594864, -0.0433918721973896 ]
<p>I'm the author of the <a href="http://cran.r-project.org/package=ez" rel="nofollow">ez package</a> for R, and I'm working on an update to include automatic computation of likelihood ratios (LRs) in the output of ANOVAs. The idea is to provide a LR for each effect that is analogous to the test of that effect that the ANOVA achieves. For example, the LR for main effect represents the comparison of a null model to a model that includes the main effect, the LR for an interaction represents the comparison of a model that includes both component main effects versus a model that includes both main effects <em>and</em> their interaction, etc.</p> <p>Now, my understanding of LR computation comes from <a href="http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15732688" rel="nofollow">Glover &amp; Dixon</a> (<a href="http://www.thinkingaboutthinking.org/wp-content/uploads/2010/09/Glover-Dixon-2004-Likelihood-ratios-a-simple-and-flexible-statistic-for-empirical-psychologists.pdf" rel="nofollow">PDF</a>), which covers basic computations as well as corrections for complexity, and the appendix to <a href="http://rads.stackoverflow.com/amzn/click/0521009138" rel="nofollow">Bortolussi &amp; Dixon</a> (<a href="http://www.thinkingaboutthinking.org/wp-content/uploads/2010/09/Dixon-Unknown-Evaluating-Evidence-Appendix-to-Psychonarratology.pdf" rel="nofollow">appendix PDF</a>), which covers computations involving repeated-measures variables. To test my understanding, I developed <a href="https://spreadsheets.google.com/ccc?key=0Ap2N_aeyRMGHdHJxUnVNeEl5VGtvY1RVLVc5UjU4Vmc&amp;hl=en" rel="nofollow">this spreadsheet</a>, which takes the dfs &amp; SSs from an example ANOVA (generated from a 2*2*3*4 design using fake data) and steps through the computation of the LR for each effect.</p> <p>I would really appreciate it if someone with a little more confidence with such computation could take a look and make sure I did everything correctly. For those that prefer abstract code, <a href="http://gist.github.com/590789" rel="nofollow">here is the R code</a> implementing the update to ezANOVA() (see esp. lines 15-95).</p>
73,765
[ -0.04250365495681763, 0.013364522717893124, 0.018110353499650955, -0.0021293610334396362, 0.035899803042411804, 0.02850545383989811, -0.011873573996126652, -0.015617094933986664, 0.010469421744346619, -0.00040779553819447756, 0.02092624083161354, 0.02102714590728283, 0.04597439989447594, 0.05327147617936134, 0.02017892897129059, 0.009173697791993618, 0.008506441488862038, 0.017885709181427956, 0.012544503435492516, -0.015133801847696304, -0.028735734522342682, 0.013313556089997292, 0.02122790738940239, -0.015493406914174557, -0.02722644992172718, 0.029130922630429268, 0.032660774886608124, -0.05469648540019989, 0.009689762257039547, 0.035979099571704865, -0.0453982949256897, -0.03020857833325863, 0.026886358857154846, 0.016599399968981743, -0.0000072746174737403635, 0.016092810779809952, -0.010563764721155167, 0.02003796398639679, 0.0400405153632164, 0.04840433970093727, -0.040177930146455765, 0.0014764589723199606, -0.024219557642936707, 0.034249283373355865, -0.03206593543291092, -0.001040910603478551, -0.02912743389606476, -0.00553547078743577, 0.016732782125473022, -0.020308086648583412, 0.0583392009139061, 0.02216131053864956, 0.007366677280515432, 0.05172593891620636, 0.007481639739125967, 0.0025839165318757296, 0.028793197125196457, 0.060277972370386124, 0.03154517337679863, -0.09390062838792801, -0.0369851179420948, -0.029198024421930313, -0.02874499186873436, 0.020501641556620598, -0.011768996715545654, -0.0036198757588863373, 0.018415672704577446, -0.024782566353678703, 0.03988166153430939, -0.03155119717121124, 0.02113172598183155, 0.011518040671944618, 0.018215199932456017, -0.0019169265870004892, 0.006457676645368338, -0.018504302948713303, 0.002898448845371604, -0.006165524013340473, 0.041039831936359406, 0.0442693755030632, -0.011586577631533146, 0.03021249547600746, 0.0023945767898112535, 0.02792212925851345, -0.00012759007222484797, 0.024928797036409378, 0.07167349755764008, -0.04297259822487831, -0.011973626911640167, 0.009443618357181549, -0.07189954072237015, -0.0009274801122955978, 0.03155824542045593, -0.011188376694917679, -0.06240523234009743, 0.025351490825414658, -0.012647348456084728, 0.021651726216077805, -0.0066947340965271, 0.015031978487968445, -0.05418134853243828, -0.025379478931427002, 0.02007845789194107, 0.06288538128137589, -0.013562669046223164, -0.023189907893538475, 0.00966016948223114, 0.03375215083360672, 0.0041200206615030766, -0.042880211025476456, -0.00793179776519537, 0.031053246930241585, -0.0005668399971909821, 0.014656035229563713, -0.014619286172091961, -0.022174440324306488, -0.008889938704669476, -0.002291920827701688, 0.06747078895568848, 0.026011426001787186, 0.03628876432776451, -0.037894781678915024, 0.039076365530490875, -0.04147297143936157, -0.06014686077833176, 0.035689979791641235, 0.036017004400491714, -0.021769527345895767, -0.07414435595273972, 0.08219466358423233, -0.0038467436097562313, -0.04357185214757919, 0.008368713781237602, 0.023734940215945244, 0.00744148064404726, 0.04641897976398468, -0.09584420919418335, -0.0660097748041153, 0.06342296302318573, -0.0011543149594217539, 0.0005974279483780265, -0.03719276562333107, -0.019475318491458893, 0.05618185177445412, 0.06181768700480461, -0.0008960884879343212, 0.039765141904354095, 0.021202506497502327, 0.006213489454239607, 0.03391671180725098, -0.03260083496570587, -0.000048162266466533765, -0.057341318577528, 0.0011593411909416318, -0.044353265315294266, -0.10588835924863815, 0.018051069229841232, 0.0007374425185844302, -0.013666562736034393, 0.010060450062155724, 0.04642358049750328, 0.01253135409206152, -0.029300104826688766, -0.02312939055263996, 0.019518105313181877, -0.041741613298654556, 0.04514843970537186, -0.033303726464509964, 0.012328936718404293, 0.02124772034585476, -0.049506235867738724, 0.008969258517026901, -0.017178751528263092, 0.027244340628385544, 0.03316836804151535, -0.027983922511339188, -0.023053206503391266, -0.04582374542951584, -0.008250677958130836, 0.04701598361134529, -0.02397676184773445, -0.015588806010782719, -0.045251574367284775, -0.06912466138601303, 0.05491156876087189, 0.040330179035663605, -0.007293063215911388, -0.02876107394695282, 0.035075630992650986, -0.034455060958862305, -0.04962334781885147, -0.07282961159944534, 0.0019804800394922495, 0.01194136030972004, -0.026150301098823547, 0.039502423256635666, -0.01488928310573101, 0.02498674765229225, 0.022212162613868713, -0.010151580907404423, -0.04192596673965454, -0.0025357939302921295, 0.004379997495561838, -0.03181815519928932, 0.0186347346752882, 0.005510093178600073, 0.062354426831007004, -0.05994023010134697, 0.03964018076658249, -0.05874102562665939, -0.033500559628009796, 0.0154575752094388, -0.02319595403969288, 0.014749816618859768, 0.0015945008490234613, -0.020540397614240646, -0.012372695840895176, 0.00720540015026927, -0.00362262106500566, 0.047844428569078445, -0.045480601489543915, 0.05309181660413742, 0.04991895705461502, 0.008577982895076275, 0.009029887616634369, 0.047901351004838943, 0.05125683546066284, -0.015264572575688362, 0.016259690746665, 0.020532360300421715, -0.07752914726734161, -0.002398665063083172, 0.05242122709751129, -0.014272169210016727, -0.020405810326337814, 0.02219320274889469, 0.010215412825345993, 0.011651156470179558, 0.00573066296055913, 0.058986127376556396, -0.0069410172291100025, -0.04307744279503822, -0.009167950600385666, 0.015355471521615982, 0.02094523049890995, 0.01330751646310091, 0.011544380336999893, -0.005482150707393885, 0.07294629514217377, 0.02824629843235016, -0.0053395600989460945, 0.029656704515218735, 0.04207077622413635, 0.0008446280844509602, -0.02265808917582035, 0.0017517898231744766, 0.04738272726535797, -0.03171925246715546, 0.01438997220247984, 0.02424870803952217, -0.006898434367030859, -0.016293535009026527, 0.020593145862221718, -0.010985763743519783, 0.036847569048404694, -0.006621245760470629, -0.006932027637958527, 0.010985166765749454, 0.01475509349256754, -0.02422693558037281, 0.021173536777496338, -0.033678337931632996, -0.016713252291083336, -0.008069713599979877, -0.007907209917902946, -0.01368238590657711, -0.010212601162493229, 0.02504020184278488, -0.0054981904104352, 0.008752602152526379, 0.005889704450964928, -0.04104183241724968, 0.0482599101960659, 0.024118874222040176, -0.034305475652217865, -0.013009767979383469, -0.01958651654422283, -0.0014597404515370727, 0.033922381699085236, 0.0031284394208341837, -0.027077123522758484, 0.020737865939736366, -0.0035632257349789143, -0.0544293075799942, 0.00011624268518062308, 0.02506561577320099, 0.0045943837612867355, -0.045213039964437485, -0.012108530849218369, 0.035791948437690735, 0.0239365566521883, -0.02858278900384903, 0.010953596793115139, -0.0021430207416415215, 0.007752011995762587, 0.017122779041528702, -0.024183541536331177, -0.012777279131114483, 0.005503542721271515, 0.022667085751891136, 0.003166025271639228, -0.02235698141157627, -0.03663065657019615, -0.09437806904315948, -0.025323964655399323, -0.02839742787182331, 0.008643877692520618, 0.03977423533797264, -0.0013884567888453603, -0.015967752784490585, 0.05816510319709778, 0.02418711967766285, -0.000424296100391075, -0.06265034526586533, -0.005695438012480736, 0.006800818722695112, -0.012297490611672401, 0.017163047567009926, 0.05200423672795296, -0.010410887189209461, 0.03331267088651657, -0.008015609346330166, 0.006201006937772036, 0.05086088925600052, 0.03944693133234978, 0.03033100999891758, 0.03958190977573395, -0.011070587672293186, -0.036961015313863754, 0.0174260251224041, 0.01698579080402851, 0.01020719576627016, 0.029859058558940887, 0.018486903980374336, 0.04611274600028992, -0.00689272303134203, -0.05156148597598076, 0.020867858082056046, -0.020676838234066963, 0.0023119894322007895, -0.02951723523437977, 0.025974376127123833, 0.023089421913027763, -0.031608086079359055, -0.014518754556775093, 0.01081789843738079, 0.03560513257980347, -0.004321897402405739, -0.02078472450375557, 0.006509358063340187, 0.03551186993718147, -0.02305162325501442, -0.023750169202685356, -0.037534743547439575, -0.011170079000294209, 0.022219492122530937, -0.044216662645339966, -0.005262266378849745, 0.0342329740524292, 0.022244768217206, -0.03855356574058533, -0.013474801555275917, -0.04575198516249657, -0.012311607599258423, -0.04496036842465401, 0.005242958199232817, -0.06823796033859253, 0.03444288671016693, 0.02243279106914997, 0.03520849347114563, -0.014103821478784084, -0.04461595416069031, -0.0031147205736488104, -0.03227486088871956, -0.06412265449762344, 0.01192808710038662, -0.013573111966252327, -0.02049613930284977, 0.018707644194364548, -0.04302697256207466, 0.04595448076725006, 0.006433030590415001, -0.0024024678859859705, -0.03199651092290878, 0.03355291113257408, -0.008994586765766144, -0.0027741556987166405, -0.0034097563475370407, -0.03187142312526703, 0.0016728081973269582, 0.009402119554579258, 0.004925786983221769, -0.005598657764494419, -0.0038251946680247784, 0.041746124625205994, -0.003421899862587452, -0.023833682760596275, -0.014840040355920792, 0.009499553591012955, 0.03160286322236061, 0.015491404570639133, 0.018597714602947235, 0.030175939202308655, -0.0430893748998642, 0.011814058758318424, 0.0039009060710668564, 0.025728801265358925, 0.04193749278783798, -0.022101635113358498, -0.03720558062195778, 0.0009679277427494526, -0.02737303264439106, -0.00699268002063036, 0.016979549080133438, -0.02202557772397995, 0.020876582711935043, 0.0653686597943306, 0.0606982558965683, -0.013225873932242393, 0.0165755245834589, 0.030242128297686577, 0.0008000863599590957, -0.014235383830964565, -0.049980927258729935, 0.00878677237778902, -0.010152177885174751, -0.004319137893617153, 0.015141041949391365, 0.011647597886621952, 0.008550494909286499, -0.014174016192555428, 0.026618456467986107, 0.01058050524443388, -0.016306644305586815, -0.0006567694363184273, 0.01906527206301689, 0.023308847099542618, 0.009416403248906136, -0.010914511047303677, 0.003298883093520999, 0.03659790754318237, 0.04488106444478035, 0.005903203506022692, 0.023256899788975716, -0.08188897371292114, 0.02713746950030327, 0.06359784305095673, 0.0575832761824131, -0.037166547030210495, 0.011556992307305336, 0.013687945902347565, -0.009499664418399334, 0.03848077729344368, -0.02291785180568695, 0.009634101763367653, -0.008022695779800415, 0.020508455112576485, -0.06216401979327202, -0.05010741949081421, 0.0017546041635796428, 0.016372479498386383, -0.01656115986406803, 0.00940000917762518, 0.010267402045428753, -0.02178560383617878, -0.061206914484500885, -0.01629606820642948, 0.0014638748252764344, 0.015903370454907417, -0.03446545451879501, 0.008209829218685627, 0.03248747065663338, -0.018193485215306282, -0.03317256644368172, -0.08029641956090927, 0.026331428438425064, -0.01454124040901661, -0.033142078667879105, 0.03708365559577942, -0.0024748535361140966, -0.003623747965320945, 0.006586235016584396, 0.035103004425764084, -0.03649156540632248, 0.009325895458459854, -0.006510117091238499, 0.04343286529183388, 0.01418354082852602, 0.02403300441801548, 0.06795704364776611, 0.001812595408409834, -0.04209859296679497, 0.00006839961861260235, -0.060399822890758514, -0.0209032129496336, -0.029549842700362206, -0.02123972959816456, -0.05261616036295891, -0.026542903855443, -0.010133017785847187, 0.03427617624402046, 0.02091429941356182, 0.028077131137251854, -0.023315908387303352, 0.0016260044649243355, -0.016145288944244385, -0.0013183006085455418, -0.0005416802014224231, -0.00856596790254116, 0.015268499031662941, -0.014309566468000412, 0.006220536306500435, -0.0014552912907674909, 0.014416363090276718, -0.03437770903110504, -0.0003640090872067958, 0.02091391570866108, -0.049171146005392075, -0.003496393794193864, -0.02117444947361946, -0.053054362535476685, 0.014331416226923466, -0.02547335997223854, 0.06780441105365753, 0.0006462568999268115, -0.023837970569729805, -0.018009640276432037, -0.012639541178941727, -0.04121042788028717, 0.05245812237262726, -0.024870414286851883, 0.019667435437440872, 0.005934419110417366, -0.009882637299597263, -0.014306730590760708, -0.009461147710680962, -0.03622058779001236, 0.033495403826236725, 0.01557871699333191, -0.010230481624603271, -0.024853676557540894, -0.0211773868650198, -0.03343496099114418, 0.013425561599433422, -0.013004571199417114, -0.02753155305981636, 0.07109569013118744, -0.013370247557759285, 0.005675161723047495, -0.033918578177690506, 0.02526283636689186, 0.03560930863022804, 0.012226085178554058, -0.002577822655439377, -0.0017915036296471953, -0.026768434792757034, 0.02018909901380539, 0.022781817242503166, -0.009585405699908733, -0.031087011098861694, -0.025483524426817894, -0.03164732828736305, 0.00619607325643301, 0.05076572299003601, 0.006350767333060503, -0.020524445921182632, 0.011966164223849773, -0.0002073599025607109, 0.020237300544977188, -0.03510310873389244, -0.01462499238550663, -0.014544126577675343, 0.009381580166518688, -0.006032848265022039, 0.011805382557213306, 0.0023507343139499426, 0.011495181359350681, 0.014820965006947517, -0.011304826475679874, -0.02262357622385025, 0.00598387373611331, 0.07254090160131454, -0.007887853309512138, 0.018761523067951202, -0.0028041282203048468, -0.0006947892252355814, 0.08144931495189667, 0.0031244459096342325, 0.033860135823488235, 0.008938164450228214, -0.013357650488615036, -0.004387550987303257, -0.0212541613727808, -0.04062241315841675, -0.03893798589706421, 0.059953365474939346, 0.0063812811858952045, 0.01790359802544117, 0.07996100187301636, -0.026684090495109558, -0.012942585162818432, -0.024525873363018036, 0.0109567167237401, -0.031641095876693726, 0.03652622923254967, 0.04670441895723343, -0.028424464166164398, -0.029017584398388863, 0.05260889604687691, -0.011290226131677628, 0.006576520390808582, -0.0024710565339773893, 0.0017707055667415261, 0.03129572421312332, 0.00303261517547071, -0.030351251363754272, -0.034349340945482254, 0.06605786830186844, -0.05900091677904129, 0.021840982139110565, -0.03600369021296501, 0.005858549848198891, 0.029784968122839928, 0.04336077719926834, -0.01706421747803688, -0.06689517945051193, -0.03882313519716263, -0.0905240923166275, 0.013304163701832294, 0.009923391975462437, -0.010156565345823765, 0.01849427819252014, -0.009494290687143803, 0.029418185353279114, -0.012843405827879906, 0.020270081236958504, -0.04391276463866234, -0.027652710676193237, 0.013599290512502193, 0.0017634698888286948, 0.018933426588773727, 0.04122694581747055, 0.0040755621157586575, 0.0023799159098416567, -0.004528754390776157, -0.007103682961314917, 0.014336098916828632, 0.00417432002723217, 0.0039029528852552176, -0.037147149443626404, 0.08239709585905075, -0.034872330725193024, 0.03454378992319107, -0.010087217204272747, -0.011895143426954746, 0.14477717876434326, 0.06947659701108932, 0.022591328248381615, -0.04886393994092941, 0.05038435012102127, 0.026636596769094467, 0.026812493801116943, 0.013627134263515472, -0.025866298004984856, -0.001304119941778481, -0.04505039379000664, 0.02882250025868416, 0.048518482595682144, 0.0012433708179742098, -0.04518052935600281, 0.06046478822827339, -0.009547571651637554, -0.03303702175617218, 0.0154725331813097, -0.030558008700609207, -0.011585501953959465, -0.05239041522145271, -0.01969667337834835, -0.015755997970700264, -0.029808711260557175, -0.0023250561207532883, -0.04022146761417389, -0.05383482202887535, 0.011393378488719463, 0.0016334695974364877, -0.007864023558795452, 0.03676560893654823, 0.01885303296148777, 0.00657226424664259, 0.05734076723456383, -0.0013702944852411747, 0.07151708006858826, -0.0370752289891243, 0.030887257307767868, 0.05367476865649223, -0.00013673338980879635, 0.036450956016778946, -0.030334485694766045, 0.021157281473279, -0.037130821496248245, -0.03738139942288399, -0.024173803627490997, 0.03404378145933151, -0.005750605836510658, 0.00047458737390115857, -0.030795959755778313, 0.012651482596993446, -0.0010790404630824924, -0.017308084294199944, -0.005840703845024109, 0.05497318133711815, 0.005890295375138521, -0.029391728341579437, -0.006913214921951294, -0.02515377290546894, -0.011969060637056828, 0.005506537389010191, 0.05757027491927147, 0.037720806896686554, -0.012003164738416672, -0.02733980119228363, -0.05037928372621536, 0.05249648168683052, -0.015298699028789997, 0.013742048293352127, -0.0383695587515831, 0.013077450916171074, -0.005666190758347511, -0.043060749769210815, -0.008335830643773079, 0.05435570701956749, 0.03187871724367142, -0.013097194023430347, 0.01894528977572918, -0.053994107991456985, -0.05822671577334404, -0.009620034135878086, -0.010853462852537632, -0.006326448637992144, -0.04852819815278053, -0.024560099467635155, 0.04946090281009674, 0.012823065742850304, 0.010521387681365013, -0.0025528306141495705, 0.00027225137455388904, 0.047409120947122574, 0.008407996036112309, -0.03753335401415825, -0.014248967170715332, 0.003961792215704918, -0.0034227296710014343, -0.020844625309109688, -0.026717331260442734, 0.0282462015748024, -0.008452914655208588, 0.01236645132303238, 0.029062382876873016, 0.041565392166376114, -0.032126739621162415, -0.013247262686491013, 0.012096177786588669, -0.052495669573545456, -0.01339283213019371, 0.022926511242985725, 0.022898821160197258, 0.013753918930888176, -0.0015276647172868252, -0.04817984625697136, -0.024940848350524902, 0.03235334903001785, -0.0653335303068161, -0.002624653512611985, -0.037879958748817444, -0.00868123210966587, 0.021872200071811676, -0.022579850628972054, 0.0005605306942015886, -0.0464608371257782, -0.023463677614927292, -0.03589770197868347, 0.008921622298657894, -0.03511081635951996, 0.02301696315407753, 0.02103998325765133, 0.004749414045363665, 0.030282465741038322, 0.007039722055196762, 0.019711477681994438, -0.009467431344091892, -0.004230523016303778, -0.0025707746390253305, 0.01970367319881916, 0.020469341427087784, -0.037226125597953796, 0.018372973427176476, -0.026980072259902954, -0.03400230407714844, 0.01709546148777008, -0.002647912595421076, 0.0075529045425355434, 0.023786960169672966, -0.011732997372746468, 0.015050508081912994, 0.02763228490948677, 0.028497042134404182, -0.028523344546556473, -0.042619552463293076, -0.007785129360854626, 0.029751509428024292, -0.021191641688346863, 0.01057598926126957, 0.029062997549772263, -0.004401038400828838, 0.03681008517742157, 0.05539482831954956, 0.007577309384942055, 0.009442214854061604, -0.005372163839638233, -0.023576214909553528, 0.03127003833651543, -0.016409216448664665, -0.020761149004101753, 0.02098502404987812, 0.06651502847671509, -0.005816464312374592, 0.06058282405138016, -0.012850303202867508, 0.05071497708559036, -0.09278225898742676, -0.003285533981397748, -0.009814090095460415, 0.04417639225721359, 0.049078263342380524, -0.05062279850244522, 0.046022482216358185, 0.029092391952872276, -0.027586672455072403, 0.002830362878739834, 0.008521665818989277, -0.002461823169142008, -0.0027066075708717108, 0.003742978675290942, -0.03653236851096153, -0.0017224580515176058, 0.001448342576622963, 0.01463151816278696, 0.02803502045571804, 0.006796284578740597, 0.02065345272421837, -0.05790283903479576, -0.00331946462392807, 0.014168014749884605, 0.03872279077768326, -0.05627235397696495, 0.027256131172180176, -0.0341324508190155, -0.015797415748238564, 0.01896410435438156, 0.0401930995285511, 0.05209094285964966, 0.002627291949465871, 0.06480851024389267, 0.016515998169779778, 0.07782859355211258, 0.015535447746515274, 0.015017933212220669, -0.015312034636735916, 0.010367251001298428, 0.008026636205613613, 0.037112459540367126, -0.0327787920832634, -0.0005245753563940525, 0.012251060456037521, 0.004646402783691883, -0.02653774805366993, -0.011299761943519115, -0.013127473182976246, -0.009591332636773586, -0.02224862575531006, 0.0007136541535146534, 0.004444385413080454, -0.008975966833531857, -0.01647280901670456, -0.03732334449887276, 0.024181952700018883, 0.05517887696623802, 0.03898419812321663, -0.03552894666790962, 0.06763947010040283, -0.024254262447357178, -0.0004958949866704643, 0.0008990488131530583, -0.019473044201731682, -0.01598190888762474, -0.06902854889631271, 0.004613116383552551, -0.009896956384181976, 0.0009903883328661323, -0.028040915727615356, 0.036915525794029236, -0.03868165239691734, 0.01916753128170967, -0.052639514207839966, 0.028677139431238174, -0.002831291174516082, -0.028558116406202316, 0.01991782709956169, -0.07041566073894501, 0.11214350163936615, 0.015366801992058754, -0.03476150333881378, -0.06653991341590881, -0.02476074919104576, 0.00865000020712614, 0.02294008433818817, 0.052609577775001526, -0.0033971830271184444, -0.016688577830791473, -0.01446465589106083, 0.026141710579395294, -0.009079261682927608, -0.044101085513830185, 0.02890915796160698, -0.01805683970451355, 0.0004689448105636984, 0.0074873133562505245, 0.020256655290722847, -0.01659216545522213, -0.0013382621109485626, 0.022480838000774384, -0.01711679995059967, -0.0033689457923173904, -0.0005039199022576213, 0.00959358736872673, 0.042767830193042755, 0.007634575013071299, -0.030610810965299606, 0.02414456568658352, -0.025220049545168877, 0.03352413326501846, 0.02322719804942608, -0.04663153737783432, -0.05093522369861603, 0.054725464433431625, -0.025268325582146645, -0.006661200895905495, 0.013725054450333118, 0.01219585444778204, 0.03148329630494118, -0.011322327889502048, -0.018128545954823494, 0.03321629762649536, -0.02440735697746277, 0.0033532113302499056, 0.05109722167253494, 0.022768642753362656, 0.06534523516893387, 0.01627599447965622, 0.018005071207880974, -0.0021546490024775267, -0.022712333127856255, 0.0031182451639324427, -0.016619209200143814, 0.03148242458701134, 0.021434685215353966, -0.029664216563105583, 0.046285249292850494, -0.023184604942798615, 0.05250180512666702, -0.030574876815080643, 0.010995405726134777, -0.03457833081483841, -0.004027245100587606, 0.026104748249053955, -0.044292304664850235, -0.0008565360913053155, -0.014350250363349915, 0.011030521243810654, 0.06700889766216278, -0.024558624252676964, -0.006458830088376999, -0.005536688957363367, -0.004462974611669779, -0.018709789961576462, 0.031986456364393234, 0.01192588359117508, 0.007232197094708681, 0.027527831494808197, 0.0005316896713338792, 0.014664435759186745, -0.02689063549041748, 0.022801917046308517, 0.005441497545689344, 0.005837537813931704, 0.003066128818318248, -0.003361328737810254, -0.0009601594065316021, 0.011136402375996113, -0.06361798942089081, -0.05177314206957817, 0.04979836940765381, -0.020158329978585243, 0.008212091401219368, -0.016883989796042442, -0.0371241569519043, 0.018157927319407463, 0.020952237769961357, -0.040217287838459015, -0.020936697721481323, -0.02468441240489483, 0.02286972478032112, 0.010538220405578613, -0.0297178253531456 ]
<p>The Gauss-Markov theorem tells us that the OLS estimator is the best linear unbiased estimator for the linear regression model. </p> <p>But suppose I don't care about linearity and unbiasedness. Then is there some other (possible nonlinear/biased) estimator for the linear regression model which is the most efficient under the Gauss-Markov assumptions or some other general set of assumptions?</p> <p>There is of course one standard result: OLS itself is the best unbiased estimator if in addition to the Gauss-Markov assumptions we also assume that the errors are normally distributed. For some other particular distribution of errors I could compute the corresponding maximum-likelihood estimator.</p> <p>But I was wondering if there is some estimator which is better-than-OLS in some relatively general set of circumstances?</p>
73,766
[ -0.05473516508936882, 0.017682267352938652, -0.010620676912367344, -0.02775651589035988, 0.027832793071866035, 0.06435292959213257, -0.00843107234686613, -0.03875211998820305, 0.011442793533205986, -0.03651437163352966, 0.03287104144692421, 0.04757308214902878, 0.06448695063591003, 0.01336071826517582, 0.035409390926361084, -0.02060176059603691, -0.028471264988183975, 0.010886963456869125, -0.012965736910700798, -0.009867813438177109, 0.006195342633873224, 0.03740426525473595, -0.0017821815563365817, 0.0006555132567882538, -0.03198707848787308, 0.026303477585315704, 0.028134508058428764, 0.006369271781295538, 0.034074943512678146, 0.07809975743293762, -0.01461914461106062, -0.01442032027989626, -0.0011379076167941093, 0.06598687171936035, 0.021882247179746628, -0.0011687573278322816, -0.017127402126789093, -0.03981312736868858, -0.03161883354187012, 0.05692516267299652, -0.04538186267018318, -0.033098481595516205, -0.004403937142342329, 0.027454575523734093, 0.014279885217547417, 0.05371605232357979, 0.012052754871547222, -0.04567062482237816, 0.026774633675813675, -0.041338928043842316, 0.062298376113176346, -0.03457392007112503, 0.00662435544654727, 0.014940495602786541, 0.004919320344924927, 0.0021845409646630287, 0.04751383140683174, 0.07651092112064362, 0.0007678866968490183, -0.05170055851340294, -0.00808087456971407, -0.00538850761950016, 0.04190514609217644, -0.0311688594520092, -0.013016567565500736, 0.026825716719031334, -0.006161781493574381, -0.026243053376674652, 0.05380398407578468, -0.009253930300474167, -0.0348769836127758, 0.015594297088682652, 0.026583924889564514, 0.012512927874922752, -0.006365431472659111, -0.019860699772834778, -0.0038602317217737436, 0.0388718880712986, 0.021538013592362404, 0.005313224159181118, 0.03629228472709656, 0.009169526398181915, 0.02800271473824978, 0.05923142656683922, -0.0023814858868718147, 0.017795072868466377, 0.07859431952238083, -0.02152082324028015, 0.04820176586508751, 0.02902901917695999, -0.006882321089506149, -0.023079613223671913, 0.047361962497234344, -0.0125315235927701, -0.06148438900709152, 0.016596578061580658, 0.01115548238158226, 0.04241248965263367, 0.010259660892188549, -0.00020951520127709955, 0.0035239008720964193, -0.04483663663268089, -0.0253004003316164, 0.0568300224840641, -0.006540738977491856, -0.026573866605758667, -0.00627107685431838, 0.011016085743904114, 0.008036287501454353, -0.03643114119768143, -0.013520723208785057, 0.018295053392648697, 0.004089908208698034, 0.025695471093058586, 0.01644316501915455, -0.01045931875705719, -0.0035932958126068115, -0.034085460007190704, 0.01976937986910343, 0.06989268213510513, 0.01825781911611557, -0.036616500467061996, 0.012830397114157677, -0.008366385474801064, -0.005976737942546606, 0.054883815348148346, 0.001321651041507721, -0.015494134277105331, -0.05535309389233589, 0.0273924358189106, 0.022890478372573853, -0.03449315205216408, 0.04194171354174614, 0.02498195879161358, 0.04624094441533089, -0.032554615288972855, -0.08421007543802261, -0.07191205769777298, 0.05256844684481621, -0.02205241657793522, 0.020615871995687485, -0.07345204800367355, -0.011977685615420341, 0.026128247380256653, 0.048362020403146744, -0.01097165048122406, 0.06666363775730133, 0.010289883241057396, 0.020797036588191986, -0.024453608319163322, -0.030965344980359077, -0.02796780876815319, -0.004371799062937498, -0.024099787697196007, 0.010386113077402115, -0.11086146533489227, 0.0047772894613444805, -0.005260762758553028, -0.014297178946435452, -0.019018903374671936, 0.05362919718027115, 0.027222858741879463, -0.036107081919908524, -0.030921699479222298, 0.03277856111526489, -0.0505463108420372, 0.07217481732368469, -0.01444107573479414, 0.06258837133646011, 0.01719052717089653, 0.002110994653776288, 0.03328179940581322, 0.014970099553465843, 0.045316506177186966, 0.050803396850824356, -0.06326774507761002, -0.008360734209418297, -0.018499217927455902, 0.004547370132058859, 0.0182803887873888, -0.045163050293922424, 0.004076386336237192, 0.010724550113081932, -0.025073278695344925, -0.023303646594285965, 0.05439620837569237, 0.01748260110616684, 0.029213642701506615, 0.04669806361198425, -0.05117104947566986, -0.009067777544260025, -0.0437651127576828, 0.035418856889009476, 0.011549858376383781, -0.013268738985061646, 0.0250707995146513, 0.011625461280345917, 0.0020824610255658627, -0.034977857023477554, -0.025999024510383606, 0.003316708607599139, -0.00008169146894942969, 0.02129119075834751, -0.055932532995939255, 0.03716735169291496, 0.056759145110845566, 0.03711939975619316, -0.022724127396941185, 0.0269057285040617, -0.01710297353565693, -0.028238089755177498, 0.02186686173081398, -0.02878107689321041, 0.04069792479276657, 0.00568977277725935, -0.03616679459810257, -0.014759840443730354, -0.031315065920352936, -0.021827485412359238, 0.019829632714390755, -0.05158155411481857, 0.022417426109313965, 0.06371927261352539, 0.008654712699353695, -0.013528712093830109, 0.019223997369408607, 0.006308064796030521, 0.0032629319466650486, -0.019851598888635635, 0.012989228591322899, -0.0465642474591732, -0.0055761015973985195, 0.04355520382523537, 0.04816756024956703, -0.06756018102169037, 0.04458818957209587, 0.0491924062371254, 0.010341532528400421, -0.009474447928369045, 0.028586065396666527, -0.02336951531469822, -0.04096481576561928, 0.00022103071387391537, -0.011178378015756607, 0.015747664496302605, 0.028955522924661636, 0.035012222826480865, 0.022098349407315254, 0.029807081446051598, 0.0025615531485527754, 0.0017418317729607224, 0.05311906337738037, -0.003157110186293721, -0.002199473325163126, -0.012399040162563324, -0.04131662845611572, 0.010450606234371662, -0.03826316073536873, 0.024257078766822815, 0.009873838163912296, -0.028641343116760254, -0.006242129486054182, 0.0037833245005458593, -0.029493069276213646, 0.017586929723620415, -0.023553047329187393, -0.06253805756568909, 0.025432825088500977, 0.042536474764347076, -0.04202793538570404, -0.004826909862458706, -0.017864495515823364, 0.008571847341954708, -0.03464329242706299, 0.0014544700970873237, 0.02022370882332325, -0.009101435542106628, -0.01118068303912878, 0.0031092462595552206, -0.014087039977312088, -0.006785873789340258, -0.024851428344845772, 0.01630859635770321, 0.006712637841701508, -0.029867328703403473, -0.010175463743507862, -0.012888490222394466, -0.03989959508180618, 0.03016427718102932, -0.008782834745943546, 0.017842892557382584, 0.03790222853422165, 0.0006575820734724402, -0.027784185484051704, -0.038315486162900925, -0.020190903916954994, 0.0005055250367149711, -0.039323266595602036, -0.03583170473575592, 0.018873710185289383, -0.026469945907592773, -0.03253873437643051, 0.03285674378275871, -0.08001108467578888, -0.029591409489512444, -0.027790745720267296, -0.0026448355056345463, 0.002912345575168729, 0.004774189088493586, 0.051802858710289, 0.005980722140520811, -0.034057945013046265, -0.015962325036525726, -0.053802572190761566, -0.05943405255675316, 0.018995242193341255, 0.0068650925531983376, 0.042202532291412354, 0.023446062579751015, -0.056166958063840866, 0.04097758233547211, 0.046271443367004395, -0.036091651767492294, -0.028609462082386017, 0.019339023157954216, -0.030318396165966988, -0.019092805683612823, 0.004903757479041815, -0.02001454308629036, 0.01664435863494873, 0.035424068570137024, -0.018086779862642288, -0.011370484717190266, 0.018913989886641502, 0.010920838452875614, 0.058441441506147385, -0.03636834770441055, -0.022316422313451767, 0.005643113981932402, 0.0202968530356884, 0.0377960130572319, 0.02268233336508274, 0.02854127436876297, 0.03804526850581169, 0.005655534099787474, 0.004876045044511557, -0.03761855885386467, 0.02656780183315277, -0.018640337511897087, -0.0019898447208106518, -0.01810302771627903, 0.03076351247727871, 0.013452170416712761, -0.0022559252101927996, 0.015880998224020004, 0.012490306980907917, -0.03247196227312088, -0.001448310911655426, 0.03334157168865204, -0.006609427276998758, 0.02416803129017353, 0.010299970395863056, -0.021150406450033188, -0.04141460359096527, -0.021446578204631805, 0.020580241456627846, 0.003239935962483287, -0.05052987113595009, 0.05215451866388321, 0.03961852565407753, -0.0158957839012146, 0.001704858965240419, -0.04622678458690643, 0.02222413383424282, -0.08703519403934479, -0.0032086516730487347, -0.0027866598684340715, 0.02902909740805626, 0.015917330980300903, 0.001744783134199679, 0.015478692017495632, -0.013726520352065563, 0.039681948721408844, -0.006566388998180628, -0.09716977179050446, 0.06227296218276024, -0.019906023517251015, -0.02600499615073204, 0.01973309926688671, -0.032611310482025146, 0.03618156909942627, -0.05199505016207695, 0.011047066189348698, -0.0008092606440186501, 0.027708372101187706, -0.04261317849159241, -0.0031600671354681253, -0.008643061853945255, -0.04905173182487488, -0.011153955943882465, -0.006818479858338833, -0.03343665599822998, -0.021802328526973724, 0.010092406533658504, 0.043627336621284485, -0.036825936287641525, -0.029618380591273308, -0.01956195756793022, 0.04145081713795662, 0.008609561249613762, 0.058511052280664444, 0.025384031236171722, 0.014025152660906315, -0.03334299847483635, 0.02973286621272564, 0.008154165931046009, 0.04702898859977722, 0.021819839254021645, -0.012647639960050583, -0.013190512545406818, -0.02694227360188961, 0.004416055511683226, 0.00010887818643823266, 0.0014522442361339927, 0.026226460933685303, -0.017463240772485733, 0.06627435982227325, 0.025345392525196075, -0.02399599179625511, 0.02041216380894184, 0.07198747992515564, -0.007999674417078495, 0.01316264271736145, -0.009226089343428612, -0.01798800379037857, 0.005646024364978075, 0.012527700513601303, 0.04092918336391449, -0.012378671206533909, 0.03183518350124359, -0.009105931967496872, 0.03311511129140854, -0.0030595390126109123, -0.026468586176633835, -0.010565368458628654, 0.03453414887189865, 0.04685995727777481, 0.02453775331377983, -0.020463211461901665, 0.025932973250746727, 0.03315667808055878, 0.053197722882032394, 0.05837607383728027, -0.00901067815721035, -0.06035485118627548, 0.03398633375763893, 0.018676334992051125, 0.04269997775554657, -0.030075998976826668, 0.007699224632233381, -0.002554962644353509, -0.013561392202973366, 0.019472096115350723, 0.01301483903080225, 0.016872698441147804, -0.009328828193247318, 0.003098716028034687, -0.05492496117949486, -0.03527871519327164, -0.05096850171685219, -0.021007291972637177, 0.020390329882502556, 0.02353525534272194, -0.02371910773217678, -0.03426339477300644, -0.06343353539705276, 0.0003189071430824697, 0.02176872454583645, 0.07076746970415115, -0.0001037502515828237, -0.01130491029471159, 0.008618205785751343, 0.07920888066291809, -0.039607252925634384, -0.03645426779985428, 0.017207186669111252, 0.009261371567845345, -0.04738109931349754, 0.02050706371665001, 0.01683669351041317, -0.03798375651240349, 0.01492954883724451, -0.010667279362678528, -0.05600888282060623, 0.003003345802426338, 0.005724744405597448, 0.005740310065448284, 0.023132963106036186, 0.058915261179208755, 0.061597615480422974, 0.013306627050042152, 0.011053505353629589, -0.02775247022509575, -0.01155681349337101, 0.0006288020522333682, -0.05078912898898125, -0.033561572432518005, -0.013396117836236954, -0.008408518508076668, 0.0018041095463559031, 0.005620067473500967, -0.021666118875145912, 0.02600752003490925, 0.002662594197317958, -0.0280475877225399, -0.010869362391531467, 0.055831149220466614, -0.012263311073184013, -0.023187244310975075, -0.005784945096820593, 0.03384796157479286, -0.022848688066005707, -0.007418034132570028, 0.01113990880548954, -0.004934102296829224, 0.01566116139292717, 0.01734769344329834, -0.02813577838242054, 0.026731889694929123, -0.03302335366606712, -0.02153308503329754, -0.01678524911403656, -0.02803489938378334, 0.03641555830836296, 0.015423476696014404, 0.03159501403570175, 0.007939866743981838, -0.04712803289294243, -0.023472703993320465, 0.021862639114260674, 0.0005257446900941432, 0.04103071615099907, -0.03688732162117958, 0.023158090189099312, -0.03963904455304146, -0.006631503347307444, -0.06917216628789902, -0.059744372963905334, 0.02477663941681385, 0.017104070633649826, -0.011680962517857552, -0.006828031037002802, 0.0036266082897782326, -0.036398064345121384, -0.017890682443976402, -0.021174170076847076, 0.053964368999004364, -0.0014034939231351018, -0.012257447466254234, 0.00891195610165596, 0.04174886271357536, 0.04822077229619026, -0.03649953752756119, -0.02859348990023136, 0.03515433520078659, -0.01814432442188263, 0.007413922343403101, -0.009660938754677773, 0.0416317842900753, -0.01235816441476345, 0.034391097724437714, -0.010472375899553299, 0.0006220765644684434, 0.055710408836603165, -0.01006502564996481, -0.024529673159122467, 0.05553993955254555, 0.029662063345313072, -0.016490915790200233, 0.0025363389868289232, -0.014604740776121616, -0.0323772169649601, -0.006564641837030649, 0.01625048741698265, -0.0002560665598139167, 0.030435608699917793, -0.021891674026846886, 0.046027772128582, -0.003476493526250124, -0.046651288866996765, 0.008241444826126099, 0.0609913133084774, 0.007582214195281267, -0.010155001655220985, 0.01912086270749569, -0.029315676540136337, 0.047685086727142334, -0.00040088457171805203, 0.029545104131102562, 0.024653201922774315, 0.013568404130637646, -0.027363071218132973, -0.05092769116163254, -0.045145221054553986, 0.04368949681520462, 0.07723946869373322, -0.025464024394750595, 0.054209981113672256, 0.03938315063714981, 0.020881153643131256, -0.02747068554162979, -0.04338891804218292, -0.01673847809433937, -0.00034450434031896293, -0.027935225516557693, 0.06291276216506958, -0.014008637517690659, 0.025686578825116158, 0.013224520720541477, 0.0027376359794288874, 0.007209453731775284, 0.025777431204915047, 0.005320451222360134, 0.03932349011301994, 0.04506613686680794, -0.02407211810350418, -0.04365704208612442, 0.06065237149596214, -0.030222734436392784, -0.0038386001251637936, -0.022793756797909737, -0.04444216564297676, 0.028762245550751686, 0.007762846536934376, 0.05773181468248367, -0.03426415100693703, -0.0033916684333235025, -0.04623684287071228, 0.032958582043647766, 0.001527284737676382, -0.011605300009250641, 0.04078144580125809, 0.0024449427146464586, 0.03199613466858864, 0.017398500815033913, 0.05116874352097511, -0.03930675610899925, -0.10172506421804428, -0.01740293763577938, 0.006643423344939947, -0.03499528393149376, 0.006925818510353565, 0.03210345655679703, -0.04032478481531143, 0.009888028725981712, -0.03941602259874344, 0.011844058521091938, 0.01964038796722889, 0.04699293151497841, 0.007340384181588888, 0.0625397115945816, -0.003711935831233859, 0.012891152873635292, -0.02256970852613449, -0.021597828716039658, 0.10545776784420013, 0.07647539675235748, 0.045868612825870514, -0.07627372443675995, 0.021226398646831512, -0.03355526551604271, -0.016552772372961044, -0.026720497757196426, -0.005099085625261068, -0.0012611247366294265, 0.018663616850972176, 0.029938342049717903, 0.06245472654700279, -0.003307937877252698, -0.03186469152569771, 0.04578845202922821, -0.03460683673620224, 0.0017603400629013777, 0.022999519482254982, 0.013759301044046879, 0.01634085923433304, -0.0008384220418520272, -0.04003957286477089, 0.01675194501876831, -0.01030727569013834, -0.022365635260939598, 0.004492721986025572, -0.016127517446875572, 0.00599729735404253, -0.007069696206599474, -0.04079163447022438, 0.005471250042319298, 0.007944328710436821, 0.004243373870849609, -0.039015140384435654, 0.007438499480485916, 0.009580991230905056, -0.02058560587465763, 0.018819084390997887, 0.007665869314223528, 0.009921769611537457, 0.029983241111040115, 0.012386645190417767, -0.01830952614545822, -0.02060798741877079, 0.0010696452809497714, -0.03682142123579979, 0.03215765953063965, -0.04666541889309883, 0.014092477969825268, 0.00639462610706687, 0.007789942901581526, 0.024346446618437767, -0.05211704969406128, -0.025688309222459793, -0.005759267136454582, 0.04786986857652664, -0.01672428287565708, -0.04577483981847763, -0.011300009675323963, 0.02115105651319027, -0.016464024782180786, 0.0016664884751662612, 0.008271768689155579, -0.03798820078372955, -0.02182215079665184, 0.009555851109325886, 0.05955858528614044, 0.001381529145874083, -0.01229999028146267, 0.008013937622308731, -0.02292405627667904, -0.03602200746536255, -0.010932037606835365, 0.03613808751106262, -0.030714591965079308, 0.041389379650354385, 0.019334053620696068, 0.004157862160354853, -0.01575871743261814, -0.02901141531765461, 0.017062881961464882, -0.03311760351061821, 0.0023496916983276606, -0.05345715209841728, 0.0022860881872475147, 0.05587441846728325, 0.017584050074219704, 0.031331636011600494, 0.015063511207699776, -0.0011517100501805544, 0.00790189579129219, -0.0070307618007063866, -0.04889936372637749, 0.0109688900411129, -0.02056128904223442, -0.006254630163311958, -0.0019964128732681274, -0.010355852544307709, 0.03786429017782211, 0.019988320767879486, 0.033924199640750885, -0.027027221396565437, 0.045368846505880356, -0.008829754777252674, 0.014557329006493092, -0.010056638158857822, -0.0443074107170105, -0.03325195237994194, 0.033331532031297684, 0.01658717915415764, -0.012359055690467358, -0.0048490967601537704, -0.030694281682372093, -0.011466171592473984, 0.015541990287601948, -0.004146587569266558, -0.02389662340283394, 0.04415319859981537, 0.007881201803684235, 0.003638432826846838, -0.01813558302819729, 0.0007162675610743463, 0.015472332015633583, 0.002466655569151044, 0.0012534705456346273, -0.00965545978397131, -0.0005029512103646994, -0.01765015535056591, 0.017839524894952774, -0.03714698553085327, 0.03424258530139923, 0.012198494747281075, 0.007869333028793335, 0.015172760933637619, 0.026218703016638756, -0.012442456558346748, 0.05510636791586876, -0.043414000421762466, -0.0017258079024031758, 0.023395653814077377, -0.043132949620485306, -0.023471930995583534, 0.003530225483700633, -0.024895643815398216, -0.008782526478171349, 0.003977582324296236, 0.026062041521072388, -0.06344164907932281, 0.04135695472359657, -0.0210564024746418, 0.04826229065656662, -0.03698207065463066, -0.024494968354701996, -0.0009310445748269558, -0.006996683776378632, -0.0016517066396772861, -0.0010874334257096052, -0.013451669365167618, 0.01852417178452015, 0.03974203020334244, 0.010587469674646854, 0.012343388982117176, 0.028415517881512642, -0.014017379842698574, -0.007178724277764559, 0.039803482592105865, -0.008489156141877174, -0.004055738914757967, 0.037167806178331375, -0.052618835121393204, 0.021728357300162315, 0.0017834339523687959, 0.007746830116957426, -0.067951999604702, -0.01653107814490795, 0.026533093303442, 0.020670205354690552, 0.047038909047842026, -0.0640338584780693, -0.020656567066907883, 0.04320479556918144, -0.0363798551261425, -0.018146900460124016, 0.0059613436460494995, 0.013499167747795582, -0.05306528881192207, -0.026396768167614937, -0.0309126116335392, 0.02789323963224888, -0.0007557430653832853, 0.002028105314821005, 0.014758050441741943, 0.052110422402620316, 0.014513560570776463, -0.01518580038100481, -0.0009738266817294061, -0.00799667276442051, 0.03437843173742294, -0.06528260558843613, 0.05091017112135887, -0.057360630482435226, -0.025456134229898453, 0.07253360748291016, -0.013194093480706215, 0.04045966640114784, -0.015797024592757225, 0.02138451859354973, -0.02316526509821415, 0.038133714348077774, 0.015275212936103344, -0.013690871186554432, 0.00865644495934248, 0.006831087172031403, 0.01549658365547657, 0.03840219974517822, -0.03011486306786537, -0.00014139780250843614, -0.00332360016182065, 0.004102318547666073, -0.03684975579380989, 0.0012902390444651246, 0.02792138047516346, -0.031200231984257698, -0.0038177245296537876, 0.010827453806996346, -0.002897552913054824, -0.00834872480481863, 0.013885095715522766, -0.038905102759599686, 0.02975447289645672, 0.03704455867409706, 0.032611213624477386, -0.042242202907800674, 0.02744727022945881, -0.02008146047592163, -0.03274952992796898, 0.009000182151794434, -0.015830811113119125, 0.018082592636346817, -0.08024612814188004, 0.020276637747883797, -0.0024851469788700342, -0.04575847461819649, 0.0015457526315003633, -0.02574055641889572, -0.017967630177736282, 0.03310064598917961, -0.0004925933899357915, -0.004811673890799284, 0.025545040145516396, -0.024890590459108353, 0.006977236829698086, -0.06465598940849304, 0.09123382717370987, -0.00315575092099607, 0.006480145268142223, -0.016837256029248238, -0.014568251557648182, -0.018780624493956566, -0.009995406493544579, 0.06081406772136688, -0.005710918456315994, -0.0003321506083011627, 0.023025548085570335, 0.029668133705854416, 0.0010103555396199226, -0.010331472381949425, 0.030327508226037025, -0.02996852807700634, -0.04438894987106323, -0.02851114235818386, -0.03435887023806572, -0.008259189315140247, 0.0025830569211393595, -0.011852112598717213, -0.015225800685584545, 0.005969746503978968, 0.022148340940475464, 0.029707791283726692, 0.036659836769104004, 0.039960864931344986, -0.009519930928945541, 0.047522302716970444, -0.014957813546061516, 0.01226623635739088, -0.008993089199066162, -0.020316336303949356, -0.04855138808488846, 0.012167184613645077, -0.025649119168519974, -0.012313490733504295, -0.034132007509469986, -0.004023248329758644, -0.01715438812971115, -0.031704504042863846, 0.021114161238074303, 0.018341612070798874, -0.04415598139166832, -0.01612059213221073, 0.021106654778122902, -0.018343063071370125, 0.054060474038124084, -0.014733651652932167, 0.027323387563228607, 0.028055686503648758, 0.011260775849223137, 0.0052247559651732445, 0.014840819872915745, 0.03766291216015816, 0.01392879243940115, 0.0027131654787808657, 0.02952919714152813, -0.03248904272913933, 0.06305500864982605, -0.005645381286740303, 0.027668176218867302, -0.06502728909254074, -0.025740211829543114, 0.004654066637158394, -0.003758295439183712, -0.016859062016010284, -0.03427690640091896, -0.027937376871705055, 0.042745333164930344, -0.050803251564502716, -0.013845005072653294, -0.04400606080889702, -0.004596964456140995, -0.02131204679608345, -0.04721533879637718, -0.04263589158654213, -0.014541417360305786, -0.00863704364746809, 0.04562685638666153, 0.029438979923725128, 0.02128431759774685, 0.07400092482566833, -0.000956701987888664, 0.00974774919450283, -0.010464310646057129, -0.044155802577733994, -0.02877243235707283, -0.016380315646529198, -0.0460977628827095, 0.003968153148889542, -0.0009365567821078002, 0.05017561465501785, 0.028388408944010735, -0.02374120242893696, -0.033591270446777344, -0.025347214192152023, 0.02894258126616478, -0.08246411383152008, 0.005892911925911903, -0.026214225217700005, -0.000550889119040221, -0.004875135142356157, -0.02993392013013363 ]
<p>I want to conduct a statistical test that will allow me to say that two populations are similar rather than different. As statisticians know, I can't do this with tests like the T test because the null hypothesis of the test is that the populations' means are equal. Hence my question.</p>
73,767
[ -0.06210837513208389, -0.014931373298168182, -0.039581216871738434, -0.004515068139880896, 0.016395999118685722, 0.012024102732539177, 0.02053654193878174, -0.012031869031488895, 0.0224963016808033, 0.0014047924196347594, 0.047599803656339645, 0.031531646847724915, 0.039985671639442444, -0.0014196354895830154, 0.03375979885458946, 0.026134565472602844, -0.05989246815443039, 0.03115968033671379, 0.0021145192440599203, -0.00262009771540761, 0.016997741535305977, 0.021691685542464256, 0.045252155512571335, -0.009442443028092384, -0.022685615345835686, 0.031677793711423874, 0.02663130685687065, -0.02732132375240326, -0.0012204275699332356, 0.05774360150098801, -0.05872740596532822, -0.03154655545949936, 0.012291613966226578, 0.07533368468284607, 0.023592300713062286, 0.005171043798327446, -0.02536574937403202, -0.012134363874793053, -0.01545626949518919, 0.029994668439030647, -0.05290514975786209, -0.032539546489715576, 0.00956031959503889, 0.02839740552008152, -0.038231559097766876, 0.011211639270186424, -0.0005827571148984134, -0.04417683556675911, -0.002925802953541279, -0.05216425284743309, 0.08115915209054947, 0.005588080734014511, 0.05262240022420883, 0.031127402558922768, -0.008401590399444103, 0.0038142448756843805, 0.05172242596745491, 0.05181990563869476, -0.028952470049262047, -0.049056194722652435, -0.025141017511487007, -0.030655797570943832, 0.014814107678830624, -0.015608771704137325, -0.058345433324575424, 0.024567736312747, -0.018658455461263657, -0.01936042681336403, 0.033052958548069, -0.023476669564843178, 0.012800216674804688, 0.03860047832131386, 0.04053422808647156, -0.004196017514914274, -0.01601874642074108, -0.04347396269440651, 0.026439659297466278, 0.0018578717717900872, 0.048793017864227295, 0.04230547696352005, 0.005835763644427061, -0.00008461115066893399, 0.0245791245251894, 0.050116218626499176, 0.033454086631536484, -0.037156932055950165, 0.05129728093743324, -0.029453950002789497, -0.013888292014598846, 0.05397803336381912, -0.0077497148886322975, -0.024995766580104828, 0.05668232962489128, 0.013859494589269161, -0.03415296971797943, 0.02152658812701702, -0.02082086354494095, 0.05869163200259209, -0.005030875094234943, -0.013207991607487202, 0.02190118469297886, -0.007034451700747013, 0.06218033283948898, 0.022567786276340485, -0.008744818158447742, -0.03152947127819061, -0.04330981522798538, -0.010611225850880146, 0.003494111355394125, 0.034663427621126175, 0.0017363576916977763, 0.009579222649335861, 0.0071159410290420055, -0.013276790268719196, 0.04478827491402626, 0.017411798238754272, 0.00985984317958355, -0.055114589631557465, 0.06267758458852768, 0.037120573222637177, 0.06192547827959061, -0.016137707978487015, 0.03880954906344414, -0.017972249537706375, -0.022515688091516495, 0.01877562515437603, 0.0028987035620957613, -0.011552185751497746, -0.016767971217632294, 0.0524112731218338, -0.019974326714873314, -0.012672889046370983, 0.02261117659509182, -0.014873368665575981, 0.040075819939374924, -0.014573121443390846, -0.07238660752773285, -0.054969314485788345, 0.003079773858189583, -0.02462013065814972, -0.01087757758796215, -0.0640040710568428, 0.008827846497297287, -0.00014345621457323432, 0.019789164885878563, 0.019546393305063248, 0.041200652718544006, -0.007399125024676323, 0.01609227806329727, 0.03052688017487526, -0.01780110038816929, -0.04382237792015076, -0.011170042678713799, -0.0192140843719244, -0.003244895488023758, -0.07157028466463089, -0.018618818372488022, -0.019453244283795357, -0.032288048416376114, -0.015553872101008892, 0.011736934073269367, -0.01034066453576088, 0.012419129721820354, -0.01946464367210865, 0.04248092323541641, 0.0049465070478618145, 0.0759815126657486, -0.0050994763150811195, -0.009873632341623306, 0.01956307888031006, -0.01751490868628025, 0.021850325167179108, 0.028633078560233116, 0.04940827935934067, 0.030124753713607788, -0.04448872432112694, -0.006943888962268829, -0.0011947521707043052, 0.04261208325624466, 0.0027775405906140804, -0.02098710648715496, -0.006651426199823618, 0.0019827806390821934, -0.00391614343971014, 0.01108225155621767, 0.05240819603204727, -0.0006865741452202201, -0.018228372558951378, 0.05707763507962227, -0.05399302765727043, -0.03780488669872284, -0.07986476272344589, -0.014084241352975368, 0.004103102721273899, -0.0231651458889246, 0.028236795216798782, 0.03884761035442352, 0.04032813385128975, -0.06655775010585785, -0.029557107016444206, -0.024907171726226807, -0.0046700346283614635, 0.02659527212381363, -0.03806039318442345, -0.0012029651552438736, 0.048259031027555466, 0.06175847351551056, -0.02449740283191204, 0.06240202859044075, -0.01721773110330105, -0.04944003373384476, 0.006027931347489357, -0.042203646153211594, 0.00471142353489995, 0.02673942595720291, 0.005375620909035206, 0.010778108611702919, 0.0223750751465559, -0.014915365725755692, 0.06110000237822533, -0.035172972828149796, 0.07286150008440018, 0.008072840981185436, 0.002349421614781022, -0.010224072262644768, -0.02834598906338215, 0.01201819907873869, -0.0024721252266317606, -0.0077855694107711315, -0.013737410306930542, -0.06376700848340988, -0.013688965700566769, 0.03885882720351219, 0.010543465614318848, -0.061301980167627335, 0.008332161232829094, 0.041167888790369034, 0.05213269963860512, 0.010031393729150295, 0.032558146864175797, 0.002861475106328726, -0.029624545946717262, -0.0023852242156863213, 0.014152482151985168, -0.007211389951407909, 0.016296498477458954, 0.03207964077591896, 0.02391171269118786, 0.03932188078761101, 0.0019382406026124954, -0.005493862088769674, 0.04278784617781639, -0.0025198773946613073, -0.0074201105162501335, -0.0026050761807709932, -0.03361835330724716, 0.015614326111972332, -0.03209405764937401, 0.008528214879333973, 0.028908032923936844, -0.0014719259925186634, -0.019146999344229698, 0.009589958004653454, -0.019396735355257988, 0.026276912540197372, 0.060675978660583496, -0.019740765914320946, 0.02632218226790428, 0.034630436450242996, -0.05820833891630173, 0.008911960758268833, -0.011806165799498558, -0.0315270870923996, -0.02981032058596611, 0.020841237157583237, 0.035309430211782455, -0.0027426807209849358, 0.03707369044423103, -0.017423108220100403, -0.0362551286816597, -0.0027036508545279503, -0.03822287544608116, 0.001473518437705934, -0.0004816442960873246, -0.06433243304491043, 0.00189801340457052, -0.009299639612436295, -0.024844737723469734, 0.02271919511258602, -0.013823078945279121, 0.010072510689496994, 0.03138774633407593, -0.002757814945653081, -0.05379437655210495, 0.0029747544322162867, -0.05126302316784859, 0.0033868523314595222, 0.003137836931273341, 0.005046835634857416, 0.030993768945336342, -0.0019943227525800467, -0.031928300857543945, 0.03808943182229996, -0.053632114082574844, -0.04048815369606018, -0.03632843494415283, -0.0016743475571274757, 0.02140122279524803, -0.016712946817278862, 0.011731709353625774, 0.05965703725814819, -0.05222487822175026, -0.016726886853575706, -0.04364130273461342, -0.07243384420871735, 0.05385416001081467, 0.025895219296216965, 0.043947212398052216, 0.004745131824165583, -0.022600021213293076, 0.071659155189991, 0.02099425159394741, -0.04184744879603386, -0.055753253400325775, 0.005535308737307787, -0.030327346175909042, -0.007963734678924084, 0.04022219777107239, 0.008521629497408867, -0.01431899145245552, 0.006702511105686426, 0.04205436632037163, 0.015012824907898903, 0.054557714611291885, 0.013565887697041035, -0.015636729076504707, 0.010005229152739048, 0.02291162870824337, 0.01251133345067501, 0.03599739447236061, 0.007454847916960716, -0.07337538152933121, 0.025923006236553192, 0.029171383008360863, 0.023067569360136986, -0.0017360181082040071, -0.01729082502424717, 0.030525652691721916, 0.019863048568367958, -0.002720431424677372, -0.04629598930478096, 0.0361102819442749, 0.0012978398008272052, 0.017100615426898003, 0.00004557050851872191, 0.03231687471270561, 0.015477295964956284, -0.012305674143135548, -0.00575093412771821, 0.06129051744937897, 0.023888416588306427, -0.03260484337806702, 0.006440434604883194, -0.015193144790828228, -0.04170028865337372, 0.013629021123051643, -0.01642506942152977, -0.00842095073312521, 0.07687485963106155, 0.03220609575510025, 0.03153116628527641, 0.015446214936673641, -0.035447925329208374, 0.016042688861489296, -0.04890032112598419, 0.007711187936365604, 0.006503848358988762, 0.03159714490175247, -0.023772578686475754, 0.06550886482000351, 0.045932836830616, 0.01645626686513424, 0.004725208040326834, -0.02025366574525833, -0.05049103870987892, 0.03214901685714722, -0.03994213044643402, -0.010709011927247047, 0.0165594182908535, -0.028776338323950768, 0.008133312687277794, 0.010997566394507885, 0.02142682857811451, -0.005130338948220015, 0.0008595972904004157, -0.0362982451915741, 0.014298523776233196, -0.011529403738677502, -0.03326928988099098, 0.02389030158519745, 0.04332641512155533, -0.018743593245744705, -0.027425313368439674, 0.010787528939545155, 0.024787260219454765, 0.011906600557267666, -0.01649620570242405, -0.024202115833759308, 0.02143050916492939, 0.021026378497481346, 0.05992451310157776, 0.03857455402612686, 0.04278339445590973, -0.05420748144388199, 0.03435035049915314, -0.0012478355783969164, 0.04370357468724251, 0.022625446319580078, 0.018256494775414467, -0.024040335789322853, -0.0425945445895195, -0.03766367956995964, -0.004276278894394636, 0.025417545810341835, -0.01386080402880907, -0.02622375264763832, 0.021660249680280685, 0.04372212663292885, -0.04464254528284073, 0.023079847916960716, 0.04853448271751404, 0.031060295179486275, -0.0009464582544751465, -0.008250739425420761, -0.028952714055776596, -0.030249187722802162, -0.012648376636207104, 0.019033318385481834, 0.023413103073835373, -0.015252247452735901, 0.00025765973259694874, 0.04800831153988838, -0.006562361028045416, -0.036478448659181595, -0.008705927059054375, -0.0018223733641207218, 0.04269789531826973, 0.001074369647540152, -0.03191683441400528, 0.02125457488000393, 0.03783063963055611, 0.0059212991036474705, 0.02911067008972168, 0.0026669567450881004, -0.09354405105113983, 0.012066245079040527, 0.03376474604010582, 0.02020394802093506, -0.03496268764138222, -0.01805742457509041, -0.013002927415072918, 0.008003471419215202, 0.056655239313840866, -0.024660645052790642, 0.018980693072080612, -0.007592138834297657, 0.0017443648539483547, -0.013446449302136898, 0.023129234090447426, -0.030093081295490265, 0.030376728624105453, 0.01284053921699524, -0.003348513040691614, -0.009859771467745304, -0.02080823853611946, -0.06891939043998718, 0.004530020523816347, 0.021274587139487267, 0.0748264268040657, -0.03637389838695526, -0.022604910656809807, 0.030916351824998856, 0.02200428396463394, -0.0336444117128849, -0.03672125190496445, 0.014540166594088078, 0.02006111480295658, -0.0006531559047289193, 0.060909684747457504, -0.014349741861224174, -0.026164568960666656, 0.02143366076052189, -0.0198209285736084, -0.022604739293456078, 0.006980397738516331, -0.0053567346185445786, 0.010555962100625038, 0.03223205357789993, 0.03750720992684364, 0.06397392600774765, 0.0032044490799307823, 0.004790018778294325, 0.0030484856106340885, -0.03959016501903534, 0.023788614198565483, -0.05396612361073494, -0.03435732051730156, -0.04996197298169136, -0.016103453934192657, -0.00760608958080411, 0.013812065124511719, -0.015748627483844757, 0.004129977896809578, -0.025017473846673965, -0.011737148277461529, 0.005052144639194012, 0.0042861164547502995, 0.02333684079349041, 0.0032824513036757708, 0.011087940074503422, 0.014039356261491776, -0.0192364901304245, -0.04169066250324249, 0.028917713090777397, -0.0200248584151268, -0.007491684518754482, -0.01680017076432705, -0.055311016738414764, 0.022695492953062057, -0.051358070224523544, -0.030043531209230423, 0.017606096342206, -0.018878156319260597, 0.026032254099845886, -0.02888137474656105, 0.0393364354968071, 0.01704668626189232, -0.0658784955739975, -0.01661592535674572, 0.06137304753065109, 0.018001455813646317, 0.028630435466766357, -0.041112929582595825, 0.05650032311677933, 0.004213585518300533, -0.010444903746247292, -0.0901077538728714, -0.03341544419527054, 0.009157923981547356, 0.01570504903793335, 0.020387448370456696, -0.0633072480559349, 0.004999123048037291, 0.003925858531147242, -0.00458499975502491, -0.03490326926112175, 0.07289149612188339, 0.005393291357904673, -0.034184928983449936, -0.02992241270840168, -0.0035484235268086195, 0.09202151745557785, 0.0034387698397040367, -0.021891655400395393, -0.01006432343274355, -0.003785030683502555, 0.016893502324819565, -0.00025524519151076674, 0.022807983681559563, -0.03572644665837288, 0.013819737359881401, -0.043388042598962784, 0.0019295046804472804, 0.024000383913517, -0.04954640194773674, -0.002125656232237816, 0.0074122389778494835, -0.0175765473395586, 0.007038407027721405, -0.06342141330242157, 0.008400099352002144, -0.04148884862661362, 0.0021622052881866693, -0.05499972775578499, 0.0014509650645777583, -0.0047273188829422, -0.008287017233669758, 0.04064233601093292, 0.01889747381210327, -0.010510060004889965, -0.008447796106338501, 0.06208229437470436, -0.0008081354899331927, 0.02387235499918461, -0.0020581306889653206, -0.007822223007678986, 0.02572193369269371, 0.0018976565916091204, -0.02716090902686119, -0.00397445959970355, 0.03902854397892952, -0.04189139977097511, -0.006873138248920441, -0.00709485961124301, -0.02976960502564907, 0.04816092923283577, 0.007876052521169186, 0.07353610545396805, 0.08906423300504684, 0.009201088920235634, 0.02299557439982891, -0.012110299430787563, -0.00650619063526392, 0.004450015723705292, 0.00676869647577405, 0.04327124357223511, 0.02917615696787834, 0.02784763276576996, 0.050178203731775284, 0.04994107782840729, 0.02860087901353836, 0.05598835647106171, 0.01873907633125782, 0.026577487587928772, 0.05042371526360512, -0.022638022899627686, -0.04887847229838371, 0.03631981089711189, -0.07292712479829788, 0.019610196352005005, -0.041596364229917526, -0.017820902168750763, 0.03429283946752548, 0.012694560922682285, -0.0000017742221416483517, -0.019120408222079277, -0.03363168239593506, -0.03233299404382706, 0.03458409011363983, 0.030366554856300354, 0.02062118798494339, 0.020908646285533905, 0.017858020961284637, 0.02692694403231144, -0.01726989634335041, 0.007115812972187996, -0.04064609855413437, -0.07488243281841278, -0.0313909687101841, -0.0433526448905468, -0.04172280803322792, 0.03352557495236397, 0.008582665584981441, -0.03425220400094986, 0.01459134928882122, -0.020323017612099648, -0.018938548862934113, -0.014877129346132278, 0.013559247367084026, -0.026655005291104317, 0.05382663384079933, 0.027299227192997932, 0.046313002705574036, 0.00008286064257845283, -0.014529398642480373, 0.09107304364442825, 0.04346543923020363, 0.04601749777793884, -0.079233817756176, 0.04378852993249893, -0.015584330074489117, -0.0005328209372237325, -0.005371791776269674, 0.019941644743084908, 0.006819703616201878, 0.0066564385779201984, 0.040200524032115936, 0.07288490235805511, 0.01869138889014721, -0.023672865703701973, 0.08832041919231415, -0.013350595720112324, -0.025504084303975105, 0.018813256174325943, 0.016767119988799095, -0.0015571212861686945, -0.04027608409523964, -0.01893964223563671, 0.029522083699703217, 0.0016376622952520847, -0.011926689185202122, -0.008410911075770855, -0.010371864773333073, 0.000902526022400707, 0.016098514199256897, -0.0277964249253273, 0.012665420770645142, 0.028701212257146835, -0.002770474646240473, -0.0614561066031456, -0.0423940047621727, 0.027853496372699738, -0.03998515009880066, 0.023322461172938347, 0.016286753118038177, 0.017238205298781395, -0.008762719109654427, -0.00034865393536165357, 0.00037724091089330614, -0.03376273810863495, 0.009234302677214146, -0.01703173667192459, 0.028453953564167023, -0.00860271044075489, -0.017639875411987305, -0.01694992184638977, 0.01179442834109068, -0.009258751757442951, -0.03948930278420448, -0.032784756273031235, -0.00026651809457689524, 0.0062249465845525265, -0.02850273810327053, -0.0037706932052969933, -0.050907671451568604, 0.04372994601726532, -0.025223003700375557, 0.03282896429300308, 0.013475781306624413, -0.01682007685303688, 0.00000781111066316953, -0.021275732666254044, 0.02452915906906128, -0.025830833241343498, -0.04453802853822708, 0.0038850209675729275, -0.020273305475711823, -0.01906229741871357, -0.005586284212768078, 0.005110480356961489, 0.0290148314088583, 0.019320333376526833, 0.011013492941856384, -0.017212580889463425, 0.01764172501862049, -0.04750439524650574, 0.03432496264576912, -0.016432376578450203, -0.0038342387415468693, -0.01822643168270588, -0.019591793417930603, 0.060858841985464096, 0.03789230436086655, 0.02418149635195732, 0.039324741810560226, -0.004429153632372618, 0.04425503686070442, 0.011516333557665348, -0.07226874679327011, -0.030036278069019318, 0.0029405844397842884, -0.04287099093198776, 0.00139003642834723, -0.035145845264196396, 0.02495744824409485, 0.05429914593696594, 0.022113272920250893, -0.0001408870448358357, 0.010940325446426868, -0.028590798377990723, 0.024190129712224007, -0.02163008786737919, -0.061036884784698486, -0.03448520973324776, 0.014649828895926476, 0.002897127065807581, -0.0015152060659602284, -0.03167571499943733, -0.05624353140592575, -0.013073991052806377, 0.013544654473662376, -0.037357792258262634, -0.02056409977376461, 0.011057737283408642, -0.007572363596409559, -0.00248153368011117, -0.048504170030355453, -0.009125208482146263, -0.03064333088696003, -0.02753441408276558, 0.016360774636268616, -0.0023378885816782713, -0.008108885027468204, 0.005061502568423748, -0.0031092229764908552, 0.004042126704007387, 0.062126245349645615, 0.009821862913668156, 0.009019198827445507, 0.059422463178634644, 0.00969246868044138, 0.013647438026964664, 0.04471990838646889, -0.03102201782166958, -0.007066541351377964, 0.06061101332306862, -0.055040061473846436, -0.02150285802781582, 0.032113634049892426, 0.005762734450399876, 0.02709922194480896, 0.01943013072013855, -0.02532469667494297, 0.0000013794804090139223, 0.0457698218524456, -0.021555591374635696, -0.026513103395700455, -0.023512158542871475, 0.006441449746489525, 0.0025541880168020725, 0.010030264034867287, 0.009976577945053577, 0.0012813395587727427, -0.032319650053977966, 0.03229155391454697, 0.04242868721485138, -0.010350530967116356, -0.019697465002536774, -0.009647073224186897, 0.02440057322382927, 0.002681952202692628, 0.022715745493769646, -0.012632250785827637, 0.05459536612033844, 0.06039759889245033, -0.03473811596632004, 0.005215717479586601, -0.04324330389499664, 0.014036184176802635, -0.10001633316278458, 0.000402003584895283, 0.008937741629779339, -0.011517739854753017, 0.02866259217262268, -0.056219957768917084, 0.011746679432690144, 0.02057650126516819, -0.0593646764755249, 0.0027217199094593525, -0.024551209062337875, -0.04938926175236702, -0.03578636795282364, 0.016331633552908897, 0.008071784861385822, 0.032995253801345825, -0.004111976828426123, 0.03792949020862579, 0.005789388902485371, 0.02785705029964447, 0.0038669961504638195, 0.0006122945924289525, -0.010458189994096756, -0.0030612668488174677, 0.01824408583343029, -0.06694178283214569, -0.0016151947202160954, -0.026528414338827133, -0.047980379313230515, 0.031942691653966904, -0.019309453666210175, 0.04651719331741333, 0.033119481056928635, 0.022262712940573692, -0.00331864389590919, 0.009779270738363266, 0.02132052555680275, 0.01161528192460537, -0.04435315728187561, 0.007110925391316414, -0.005029378924518824, 0.04942987859249115, -0.007056029047816992, -0.014950121752917767, 0.045390233397483826, -0.024785280227661133, -0.018104011192917824, 0.011758108623325825, -0.02207149565219879, -0.025960953906178474, -0.002975146286189556, -0.006589538883417845, 0.02690148539841175, -0.010141033679246902, -0.006939721759408712, -0.05575983226299286, 0.007916285656392574, 0.04298600181937218, 0.006829152349382639, -0.0223341416567564, 0.003963060211390257, -0.035167280584573746, -0.04103751853108406, 0.004255759995430708, 0.012147615663707256, 0.008683313615620136, -0.04329272359609604, -0.0038275178521871567, -0.015851981937885284, -0.0027489163912832737, -0.03032688796520233, -0.02937825582921505, 0.003103763796389103, 0.038246557116508484, -0.005181442014873028, 0.0054731108248233795, 0.013146264478564262, -0.010819141753017902, 0.00378500297665596, -0.033712923526763916, 0.06188342720270157, -0.004808153957128525, 0.009521467611193657, -0.048507288098335266, -0.015722952783107758, -0.06956404447555542, 0.009915615431964397, 0.0409424789249897, 0.008965462446212769, 0.02838362380862236, 0.002980810822919011, -0.006466650404036045, 0.00011352683941368014, -0.06112762540578842, 0.03496910259127617, -0.04186344891786575, -0.05370977148413658, 0.00827808491885662, -0.02242129109799862, 0.006203199736773968, -0.0113063370808959, -0.001912113861180842, -0.021800223737955093, -0.0041009592823684216, -0.006227088626474142, 0.002000851556658745, 0.05282319709658623, 0.008173773065209389, -0.01910901442170143, 0.0281631201505661, -0.035884346812963486, -0.010135884396731853, 0.03586503118276596, 0.0048804194666445255, -0.05580036714673042, 0.0652441680431366, -0.039525289088487625, -0.020618971437215805, 0.003998421132564545, 0.026904098689556122, -0.03337739780545235, -0.024737033993005753, 0.007502098102122545, 0.01584407314658165, -0.006545436568558216, 0.01973937451839447, 0.014111525379121304, 0.04932884871959686, 0.003588167717680335, -0.04851419851183891, -0.0031337642576545477, 0.0012335269711911678, -0.004394779447466135, 0.004502591677010059, 0.013816652819514275, 0.021012773737311363, 0.01593007706105709, 0.025403190404176712, 0.023269906640052795, -0.011981903575360775, 0.0341205857694149, -0.001249865279532969, 0.0316372811794281, 0.006565118674188852, -0.022090429440140724, -0.0023208209313452244, -0.005828201305121183, 0.05454520508646965, 0.005966675002127886, 0.00009910802327794954, 0.07287106662988663, -0.035902637988328934, 0.0075797284953296185, -0.03578802943229675, -0.002374592237174511, -0.04428279772400856, -0.01252994779497385, 0.04032089561223984, -0.013423050753772259, -0.021732039749622345, 0.009385066106915474, 0.0022006696090102196, -0.0038873101584613323, 0.02001885138452053, -0.02493792399764061, 0.02461652085185051, -0.033315349370241165, -0.01218199823051691, -0.021908026188611984, 0.003712891135364771, -0.057876523584127426, 0.0004518674104474485, 0.03514772281050682, 0.03155718371272087, 0.038445327430963516, -0.005324740428477526, -0.023125948384404182, -0.003981064539402723, 0.03157618269324303, -0.0958736464381218, -0.05066026747226715, -0.04049214720726013, -0.0016091617289930582, 0.019126618281006813, -0.010434066876769066 ]
<p>E.g. from the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Netflix_Prize" rel="nofollow">Netflix prize</a> I know that the best RMSE = 0.8563 where the test dataset has a size of n=1,408,789.</p> <p>Can I calculate a boundary for the MAE. If not, why can't I calculate a boundary?</p> <p>I started like that:</p> <p>RMSE = $\sqrt{\frac{\sum_{i=1}^{n}(y_{i}-\hat y_{i})^2}{n}}=0.8563$</p> <p>Now I want to calculate the MAE or a boundary for the MSE:</p> <p>MAE = $\frac{1}{n}\sum_{i=1}^{n}{|y_{i}-\hat y_{i}|}$</p> <p>I know that:</p> <p>$\sum_{i=1}^{n}(y_{i}-\hat y_{i})^2=RMSE^2*n$</p> <p>from the first formula.</p> <p>Is it possible to determine a boundary for the MAE e.g. MAE &lt; 1?</p>
73,768
[ -0.043963413685560226, -0.000014874129192321561, 0.012337758205831051, -0.015683304518461227, 0.020005885511636734, 0.01580895483493805, -0.029348047450184822, -0.03380897268652916, 0.02471025101840496, 0.0017840545624494553, 0.06320986896753311, 0.055466365069150925, 0.07196012884378433, 0.026777418330311775, 0.023106323555111885, 0.021429162472486496, -0.01586383953690529, 0.026776934042572975, -0.01934877596795559, -0.01518893800675869, 0.02138398587703705, 0.03310232609510422, 0.019058162346482277, -0.01912153884768486, -0.020575527101755142, 0.00324592599645257, 0.027587175369262695, -0.01013713888823986, -0.020612044259905815, 0.07569324970245361, -0.01699722558259964, -0.007569973822683096, 0.04109301045536995, 0.014770209789276123, 0.025373298674821854, 0.009075069800019264, -0.03785014525055885, 0.018933769315481186, -0.02061936818063259, 0.02117474563419819, -0.0010274066589772701, -0.024655302986502647, 0.02769073098897934, 0.04069789499044418, -0.03294645994901657, -0.012534423731267452, -0.014443758875131607, -0.024094779044389725, 0.008154025301337242, -0.03623080998659134, 0.07780226320028305, -0.0346970409154892, 0.05503436177968979, 0.03622976318001747, -0.011164432391524315, -0.00286271539516747, 0.02216816507279873, 0.07307524234056473, -0.013556428253650665, -0.037148941308259964, 0.018820583820343018, 0.006402946077287197, 0.04292580857872963, 0.011581278406083584, -0.020598387345671654, 0.0679597482085228, 0.014543700031936169, -0.0258168987929821, 0.009414351545274258, -0.016051126644015312, 0.009253045544028282, 0.021872054785490036, 0.03589817136526108, -0.013638617470860481, 0.05356289818882942, -0.01790758967399597, 0.049357857555150986, 0.0053438362665474415, 0.03880512714385986, 0.0387439988553524, 0.013429621234536171, 0.03135091811418533, 0.02284947596490383, 0.03709062933921814, 0.04369735345244408, -0.0014255560236051679, 0.08016662299633026, 0.015246995724737644, 0.030189724639058113, 0.02832142449915409, 0.01778090000152588, 0.008010721765458584, 0.04565709829330444, -0.04037581384181976, -0.02924080565571785, 0.046172842383384705, -0.017805973067879677, 0.022153837606310844, 0.021167676895856857, -0.02482185885310173, -0.02196943201124668, -0.035177286714315414, 0.003747528651729226, 0.059885624796152115, 0.001616771100088954, -0.03869589790701866, -0.02535739541053772, 0.004102307837456465, -0.0061396220698952675, -0.04272748529911041, -0.03682643175125122, 0.012252194806933403, 0.0034317427780479193, -0.00044575356878340244, 0.014518745243549347, -0.022444291040301323, -0.003764220280572772, 0.026355072855949402, 0.008628841489553452, 0.07662869244813919, 0.05809863656759262, -0.0037723109126091003, 0.004349199123680592, -0.02510225586593151, -0.07548118382692337, 0.027670281007885933, 0.006839549168944359, -0.020867282524704933, -0.036698050796985626, 0.06147819384932518, 0.00048289282131008804, -0.0072363512590527534, 0.03893429785966873, -0.02440446801483631, 0.032471127808094025, 0.010250908322632313, -0.08407147973775864, -0.061064496636390686, 0.03591379523277283, -0.017631446942687035, -0.02074677310883999, -0.03625744953751564, 0.005653364583849907, 0.031943924725055695, 0.06021982431411743, 0.015923865139484406, 0.016443071886897087, 0.034377649426460266, 0.05549037456512451, -0.02162010222673416, -0.02480519749224186, -0.019755352288484573, -0.013256247155368328, -0.009431032463908195, -0.02549797296524048, -0.09821159392595291, -0.004913775250315666, 0.001622165902517736, -0.008532733656466007, 0.002962645376101136, 0.049614500254392624, 0.025273365899920464, 0.007145541720092297, -0.028627462685108185, -0.009522316046059132, -0.027854088693857193, 0.08996229618787766, 0.028920277953147888, -0.0008215087000280619, 0.021662158891558647, -0.028098689392209053, 0.03226454183459282, -0.027360714972019196, 0.005436330568045378, 0.03515937924385071, -0.07080966979265213, -0.010722482576966286, -0.04621991515159607, 0.03550657257437706, 0.03764120116829872, -0.04528863728046417, -0.005526743363589048, -0.042041607201099396, -0.007241945248097181, 0.06125302240252495, 0.04061690345406532, -0.00209344201721251, -0.011950446292757988, 0.013023745268583298, -0.04449106380343437, -0.016567440703511238, -0.02810235507786274, -0.008137021213769913, -0.030604563653469086, -0.03583225980401039, 0.01911243237555027, -0.0477653369307518, -0.0015061527956277132, -0.020643865689635277, -0.007597083225846291, 0.00045119039714336395, 0.010009991005063057, 0.038448747247457504, 0.012102452106773853, 0.021348508074879646, 0.047243695706129074, 0.0284306388348341, -0.0041245995089411736, -0.010790253058075905, -0.057079046964645386, -0.04625002667307854, 0.011620475910604, -0.05471447482705116, 0.06262856721878052, 0.025047162547707558, -0.022096892818808556, 0.016665993258357048, 0.009787023067474365, -0.0026660989969968796, 0.025775184854865074, -0.049537185579538345, 0.03527345135807991, 0.07787761092185974, 0.021221274510025978, 0.03510117903351784, -0.0051543922163546085, 0.013088112697005272, 0.003751422744244337, -0.01392158679664135, 0.01792287826538086, -0.03798895701766014, -0.04674704745411873, 0.03926093876361847, -0.012894054874777794, -0.017812272533774376, 0.023519331589341164, 0.08979445695877075, -0.02855660393834114, 0.03183424472808838, 0.012283877469599247, -0.003988632932305336, -0.00655247550457716, 0.03202010318636894, 0.05749724060297012, -0.0266911331564188, 0.03137589618563652, -0.00484164385125041, -0.003266680985689163, 0.018173273652791977, 0.006003436166793108, -0.012243099510669708, 0.03235475346446037, -0.0165609959512949, -0.04929996281862259, -0.027853354811668396, -0.015704888850450516, 0.06802408397197723, -0.025170138105750084, 0.007009434979408979, 0.03754718601703644, -0.006254053208976984, -0.015296874567866325, -0.02058696560561657, -0.015869686380028725, 0.029393967241048813, 0.004529051017016172, -0.009008876979351044, -0.016153963282704353, 0.029177114367485046, -0.021679919213056564, 0.024834290146827698, -0.007648426108062267, -0.01059183944016695, -0.03868400678038597, 0.009082049131393433, 0.029653815552592278, 0.008312426507472992, 0.011280766688287258, -0.03898392617702484, 0.008054956793785095, -0.00791488029062748, -0.01682140678167343, 0.0039071012288331985, -0.017041848972439766, -0.030356014147400856, 0.02659730426967144, -0.02991403266787529, -0.005846386309713125, 0.0592820979654789, -0.003358058864250779, -0.012060864828526974, 0.012285228818655014, 0.02544970065355301, -0.02167709358036518, -0.022092396393418312, -0.059459928423166275, 0.004928496200591326, -0.0456961914896965, -0.01921192742884159, 0.017084695398807526, 0.011774239130318165, -0.06104367971420288, 0.036617178469896317, -0.007774929516017437, -0.035220980644226074, -0.0435524582862854, -0.03388559818267822, 0.04730993136763573, -0.016679348424077034, 0.03986341878771782, 0.017820211127400398, 0.00922309048473835, 0.014804146252572536, -0.07616239786148071, -0.05567076429724693, 0.018659096211194992, -0.038002099841833115, -0.0017637750133872032, 0.021343113854527473, -0.03404971584677696, 0.04794318974018097, 0.03357940912246704, -0.01059548556804657, -0.03901643678545952, 0.015217241831123829, -0.018191847950220108, -0.06987308710813522, 0.002579969586804509, 0.034730490297079086, -0.025957506150007248, 0.024349171668291092, -0.009083740413188934, 0.026864323765039444, 0.05005495622754097, -0.009437535889446735, 0.003365911543369293, 0.00745396176353097, -0.03755030408501625, -0.026160825043916702, 0.08575687557458878, 0.03300948441028595, -0.015082250349223614, 0.022199075669050217, 0.011062064208090305, 0.016027906909585, 0.008120725862681866, -0.054019469767808914, 0.006098141428083181, -0.0539734847843647, -0.025528045371174812, -0.06706874817609787, 0.048955757170915604, 0.0166946928948164, 0.001642660005018115, -0.0027125144843012094, 0.024057753384113312, 0.02307967096567154, 0.012998435646295547, -0.0049701896496117115, 0.06239056587219238, 0.03324202448129654, 0.007486284244805574, -0.01584993302822113, -0.051444947719573975, 0.011959311552345753, 0.002900267019867897, -0.015958592295646667, -0.014004926197230816, 0.003410340053960681, 0.033700328320264816, 0.005016248673200607, -0.002678670920431614, -0.01882796362042427, -0.04638051614165306, -0.05745348334312439, -0.027690576389431953, -0.055471498519182205, 0.06178462877869606, 0.00997102539986372, 0.02377932332456112, 0.011770155280828476, 0.016770919784903526, -0.0026979686226695776, 0.023158296942710876, -0.06648623943328857, -0.0048847496509552, -0.0019358714343979955, -0.04705856740474701, -0.012617036700248718, -0.0210114773362875, 0.015298566780984402, -0.02130231074988842, 0.03944771736860275, 0.024300402030348778, 0.018500061705708504, -0.049300674349069595, -0.007335682865232229, -0.02468666061758995, 0.0026892281603068113, 0.0070728641003370285, 0.010516739450395107, 0.028039461001753807, -0.008852488361299038, 0.041812457144260406, 0.03687120974063873, -0.035024628043174744, -0.009870617650449276, -0.025757286697626114, -0.01677715592086315, -0.010526678524911404, 0.010545222088694572, 0.033908404409885406, 0.029560480266809464, -0.04268243908882141, 0.014352464117109776, -0.006484604440629482, 0.032711461186409, 0.03286624699831009, -0.0259040966629982, -0.03443377837538719, -0.03340592235326767, -0.0313221737742424, 0.015923084691166878, 0.009250284172594547, 0.0011527242604643106, 0.015688052400946617, 0.020105615258216858, -0.008494183421134949, -0.037833672016859055, 0.0005581997102126479, 0.05114421620965004, -0.01819731295108795, 0.007447221782058477, -0.04633549973368645, -0.007990033365786076, -0.021139487624168396, -0.011661820113658905, 0.026033969596028328, 0.00022577929485123605, -0.004487294238060713, -0.01663597673177719, 0.04098713397979736, -0.038430675864219666, -0.02338888682425022, -0.013435707427561283, 0.014072502963244915, 0.023379864171147346, -0.0031153878662735224, -0.03431561216711998, -0.006212495733052492, 0.026194320991635323, 0.033884093165397644, -0.03009147383272648, -0.015019167214632034, -0.06353740394115448, -0.035957079380750656, 0.028126567602157593, 0.051451556384563446, 0.005251319147646427, -0.01477357279509306, -0.04134993627667427, -0.00926134455949068, 0.00705796480178833, -0.001993616344407201, 0.07328160852193832, -0.031073087826371193, 0.04873476177453995, -0.01694461517035961, -0.02603759616613388, -0.04182964935898781, -0.00533224456012249, -0.008860640227794647, 0.011420220136642456, -0.039470743387937546, -0.03816019743680954, -0.031072106212377548, 0.02175263501703739, 0.01597573794424534, 0.0474429689347744, -0.014502139762043953, -0.02101304940879345, 0.036500174552202225, -0.0002696464362088591, -0.03633273392915726, -0.06533733755350113, -0.024584924802184105, 0.002062728861346841, 0.00659045297652483, 0.035360537469387054, -0.02614767849445343, -0.036452069878578186, 0.036207232624292374, 0.045767322182655334, -0.02893977053463459, -0.003274261951446533, -0.010577249340713024, 0.05215991288423538, 0.06603845953941345, -0.0060869972221553326, 0.06352309137582779, 0.029151393100619316, 0.03212014585733414, 0.010126837529242039, -0.04942603036761284, -0.0161685049533844, -0.008664547465741634, -0.010256543755531311, -0.01177843939512968, -0.02803950384259224, -0.027621926739811897, 0.022904176265001297, -0.002476745517924428, 0.026018574833869934, -0.046395234763622284, -0.030145879834890366, 0.015145132318139076, 0.02897002547979355, -0.010114438831806183, -0.014196890406310558, 0.01737036742269993, 0.025456838309764862, 0.00876692682504654, 0.004082468803972006, 0.02152203395962715, 0.018821075558662415, 0.04497149959206581, 0.025180017575621605, -0.004972011316567659, 0.023642538115382195, -0.011747564189136028, -0.027814647182822227, -0.008493492379784584, -0.01633278653025627, 0.0566239207983017, -0.01672685332596302, 0.016753103584051132, 0.044506803154945374, -0.021557824686169624, -0.023246701806783676, 0.002375416923314333, -0.02124270796775818, 0.011633115820586681, -0.012800917029380798, -0.01934667117893696, 0.02655950002372265, 0.015087820589542389, -0.05073631927371025, 0.002908275695517659, 0.003729064716026187, 0.02097696252167225, -0.014091902412474155, -0.01640837825834751, -0.005253118462860584, -0.03710655868053436, -0.012606794014573097, 0.00589977391064167, 0.013101905584335327, -0.04141539707779884, -0.005170272663235664, -0.015112918801605701, -0.001975678140297532, 0.07130488753318787, 0.04376571625471115, -0.012211623601615429, 0.008754703216254711, -0.0003055421111639589, 0.005636472254991531, 0.01231714803725481, 0.05617056041955948, -0.030811123549938202, -0.030017534270882607, -0.026034265756607056, -0.009281358681619167, 0.07141489535570145, 0.014717210084199905, -0.012399056926369667, -0.0036525509785860777, 0.004675593692809343, 0.0013542115921154618, -0.04304959252476692, -0.014165465719997883, -0.02731619030237198, 0.029411068186163902, -0.010768791660666466, 0.017478901892900467, -0.02954203449189663, -0.0032184815499931574, 0.03887501731514931, 0.0065580629743635654, 0.012469401583075523, -0.016572482883930206, 0.08710995316505432, -0.03547259047627449, 0.018152544274926186, 0.010442378930747509, 0.0020763955544680357, 0.0200556181371212, -0.0007544052205048501, -0.0053215897642076015, -0.00712455902248621, 0.01670300029218197, -0.05374299734830856, -0.01662592962384224, -0.08447148650884628, 0.03826969116926193, 0.05683387443423271, -0.03192160278558731, 0.02938908524811268, 0.017527544870972633, 0.007575457915663719, -0.04149011895060539, -0.07112334668636322, 0.007523666601628065, -0.007535644341260195, -0.022441621869802475, 0.07763183116912842, -0.0023884442634880543, -0.0021805146243423223, 0.032439202070236206, -0.0038128411397337914, 0.04266459867358208, -0.012502566911280155, 0.0049626464024186134, 0.03929518163204193, 0.059700772166252136, -0.035305336117744446, 0.01658739522099495, 0.039907313883304596, -0.01945035718381405, -0.014739730395376682, -0.019375281408429146, -0.027581052854657173, 0.027328670024871826, 0.027147646993398666, 0.01987052708864212, -0.046340521425008774, -0.058600395917892456, -0.0530623197555542, 0.024391908198595047, 0.04512061923742294, -0.031851720064878464, 0.01988881267607212, 0.03432953357696533, -0.0077182091772556305, -0.012579962611198425, 0.009783165529370308, -0.00481310673058033, -0.062299422919750214, -0.0011786605464294553, -0.03078520856797695, -0.06867142766714096, 0.01108021754771471, 0.005656986963003874, -0.01478666439652443, 0.03299518674612045, -0.05145098641514778, 0.011256743222475052, 0.0512644425034523, 0.0000030243284072639653, -0.015357539989054203, 0.07050061970949173, -0.000670339388307184, 0.04573150351643562, -0.010602985508739948, -0.0010835712309926748, 0.13911353051662445, 0.04074395075440407, 0.02881850115954876, -0.05524256080389023, -0.011709704995155334, 0.010330291464924812, -0.011068378575146198, -0.050019968301057816, 0.01640370488166809, 0.002741156844422221, 0.005049252416938543, 0.05102914199233055, 0.05501598119735718, -0.007021998520940542, -0.008169945329427719, 0.03652898594737053, -0.05195675417780876, 0.0072306073270738125, 0.04889089986681938, -0.016231680288910866, 0.006892675533890724, 0.028732581064105034, -0.04975685477256775, 0.04380233585834503, -0.02676612138748169, 0.03318120166659355, -0.03617657348513603, -0.035741839557886124, 0.05874968320131302, 0.01965644396841526, 0.005827905144542456, 0.009344183839857578, 0.0111373420804739, 0.004319892730563879, 0.040656670928001404, 0.016731711104512215, 0.032849255949258804, -0.029310256242752075, 0.021594224497675896, 0.04732465371489525, 0.00918932817876339, -0.027471374720335007, 0.023151488974690437, -0.001335694920271635, -0.026364220306277275, -0.06064484640955925, -0.03610497713088989, 0.05339713767170906, -0.0001427488896297291, -0.02253939025104046, 0.02349785715341568, -0.02151556871831417, -0.020219532772898674, -0.050323713570833206, -0.007180657237768173, 0.0042414418421685696, -0.016343122348189354, -0.011652817949652672, 0.004919363185763359, 0.007768920622766018, 0.030151544138789177, 0.027529561892151833, 0.019911298528313637, 0.013846665620803833, -0.029829543083906174, -0.04263196885585785, 0.00006126869993750006, 0.0177969578653574, 0.020552946254611015, -0.05539338290691376, -0.008764373138546944, -0.021778654307127, -0.034391652792692184, -0.028526771813631058, 0.004549168981611729, -0.01722172647714615, 0.004114235285669565, 0.03058646246790886, -0.009834015741944313, -0.0071654547937214375, -0.017535410821437836, -0.0045968093909323215, -0.050728585571050644, -0.013728435151278973, -0.03042878396809101, -0.0533759742975235, 0.027364768087863922, 0.03047206625342369, -0.003047678153961897, -0.008587728254497051, 0.055468518286943436, 0.04956648871302605, 0.0015903206076472998, -0.015259855426847935, -0.07680589705705643, 0.024058843031525612, -0.021870482712984085, 0.043358076363801956, -0.003017983864992857, 0.07438727468252182, 0.023211631923913956, -0.02493962086737156, -0.0028291603084653616, -0.011033033952116966, -0.04713798314332962, -0.010593644343316555, 0.03319322690367699, -0.041139617562294006, -0.00127680622972548, -0.0100975651293993, -0.035774219781160355, -0.02439919486641884, 0.015070408582687378, -0.03101867437362671, -0.00912370253354311, 0.023927055299282074, 0.01578426919877529, -0.030486218631267548, 0.04912835359573364, -0.007343535777181387, 0.02005927450954914, -0.033827442675828934, -0.007253825198858976, -0.025155236944556236, -0.010289479978382587, -0.0406743586063385, -0.025440720841288567, -0.009388583712279797, -0.01033592876046896, -0.034654416143894196, -0.01618104986846447, 0.01552672404795885, 0.09568025171756744, -0.013307087123394012, -0.006869685836136341, -0.02192910574376583, 0.008121851831674576, 0.03688061237335205, -0.014325869269669056, -0.00009716261411085725, 0.049974698573350906, -0.04925910010933876, 0.0015250429278239608, 0.009836840443313122, -0.018073713406920433, 0.03867052495479584, 0.022332677617669106, 0.012536644004285336, -0.0013321455335244536, 0.04745984822511673, -0.005218532867729664, 0.0014506374718621373, 0.005856169853359461, -0.04443468526005745, 0.015448316931724548, 0.014331870712339878, 0.04719378426671028, -0.026257969439029694, -0.010003588162362576, 0.007896499708294868, 0.004487268626689911, -0.006465209648013115, -0.0497891865670681, -0.00918158795684576, -0.022572001442313194, 0.022567767649888992, 0.024622144177556038, 0.025516768917441368, 0.00450909323990345, -0.008915171027183533, -0.03673698008060455, 0.023295246064662933, -0.026476366445422173, -0.006490380968898535, -0.09548411518335342, -0.02274400182068348, -0.00034241945832036436, -0.00046031971578486264, 0.029379112645983696, -0.004642237443476915, 0.01713532954454422, 0.030088182538747787, -0.06803186237812042, 0.042209234088659286, 0.021159814670681953, 0.004994293674826622, -0.03588346019387245, 0.05872400104999542, -0.02718731202185154, 0.015538956969976425, 0.02520090341567993, 0.03935084119439125, 0.033617015928030014, 0.01024763472378254, -0.005014895927160978, -0.024537183344364166, 0.010796821676194668, 0.028450101613998413, -0.021953698247671127, -0.07957720011472702, 0.04432661458849907, -0.03270335495471954, -0.009833252988755703, 0.029557697474956512, -0.03562190383672714, 0.02388910949230194, 0.0007041743956506252, -0.009851358830928802, -0.000549724732991308, 0.009505332447588444, 0.03643288090825081, 0.013251385651528835, 0.035102035850286484, -0.0072853039018809795, -0.0010338578140363097, 0.0060158162377774715, -0.01322968490421772, -0.00020196412515360862, 0.046716656535863876, 0.017855053767561913, -0.056086502969264984, 0.02765406295657158, 0.023591971024870872, -0.03036687523126602, 0.0004624828288797289, 0.013408309780061245, 0.0010487971594557166, -0.04167923703789711, 0.017380405217409134, -0.032833848148584366, 0.0033981353044509888, -0.009170585311949253, 0.042441945523023605, -0.011672337539494038, 0.019971193745732307, 0.011149249039590359, -0.05483816936612129, 0.03293571248650551, 0.02338598109781742, -0.012276782654225826, -0.06903170049190521, 0.027126315981149673, 0.014181648381054401, -0.03756127506494522, 0.004561608657240868, 0.01499886903911829, -0.04706090688705444, 0.01217541191726923, 0.0002617232094053179, -0.014722730033099651, 0.010073782876133919, 0.00940677709877491, 0.005899496842175722, -0.10236915200948715, -0.007683373987674713, 0.010365555062890053, -0.028143541887402534, -0.02384374476969242, -0.0026056761853396893, -0.0038014675956219435, 0.005014882422983646, 0.03266372159123421, 0.010124793276190758, -0.019484177231788635, -0.0457117035984993, -0.030036915093660355, 0.011128438636660576, -0.03377896919846535, 0.03294788673520088, -0.021833110600709915, -0.013903849758207798, -0.005019709002226591, -0.012929360382258892, 0.01007375679910183, -0.002364873653277755, 0.019697656854987144, 0.0202864408493042, 0.004056685604155064, -0.014042651280760765, 0.01898595690727234, -0.0016173376934602857, 0.012174049392342567, -0.009353646077215672, 0.05866704136133194, -0.003187776543200016, 0.00221444689668715, -0.0008281465852633119, -0.0265763308852911, -0.04144160449504852, 0.02553432434797287, -0.01801854372024536, -0.03376000002026558, -0.027536410838365555, 0.0012761345133185387, 0.010038820095360279, -0.03764049708843231, -0.05909441411495209, 0.06430555880069733, 0.0032043801620602608, -0.03937816619873047, 0.045750509947538376, 0.03014701046049595, 0.014984351582825184, -0.0012859645066782832, 0.016864577308297157, 0.006420010235160589, -0.046261850744485855, -0.003329969011247158, 0.008797154761850834, 0.06682434678077698, 0.017389854416251183, 0.007924308069050312, 0.050918031483888626, -0.021776461973786354, 0.0030555177945643663, 0.017478080466389656, 0.027093837037682533, 0.010452973656356335, -0.028427354991436005, 0.0019345006439834833, -0.00643971748650074, -0.013782870024442673, -0.013498811051249504, 0.0006344564608298242, 0.054731786251068115, 0.004385158885270357, 0.043223582208156586, 0.016613932326436043, 0.014090584591031075, -0.0501922070980072, 0.006723149213939905, 0.009595857001841068, 0.018273187801241875, 0.017657732591032982, -0.03698287531733513, -0.023590682074427605, 0.0012298037763684988, 0.01633063144981861, -0.002706557512283325, 0.009172465652227402, -0.00022608990548178554, 0.014242932200431824, -0.016744565218687057, -0.011900404468178749, -0.018033206462860107, -0.027745792642235756, 0.01748463697731495, 0.05323538929224014, 0.004493186250329018, 0.018962902948260307, -0.03750360384583473, -0.006867195945233107, 0.05245727300643921, -0.08827473223209381, -0.018337320536375046, -0.02029559016227722, -0.007302296347916126, -0.01709107495844364, -0.0349532775580883 ]
<p>To apply Bayes inference for data analysis or machine learning, we have to construct <em>prior</em> and <em>likelihood</em>, right? But if I fail to come up with a reasonable <em>prior</em> and <em>likelihood</em>, then the Bayes model will not be meaningful, right?</p> <p>I wonder is there any technique could be utilized to construct reasonable Bayes models? </p> <p>Let me make it concrete by an example, given a dataest with features $X$ and target $y$, where $y=\{0,1\}$ and $X$ is composed of $p$ variables. This is an ordinary binary classification problem, to do Bayes inference, what and how should I specify for the prior and likelihood?</p> <p>One more question, if we could not specify a reasonable prior, then what's the point of using Bayes modelling?</p>
73,769
[ -0.039768293499946594, 0.012757649645209312, 0.0019137051422148943, -0.04030939191579819, 0.04484204575419426, 0.01558954268693924, -0.029786866158246994, -0.016937999054789543, 0.018932584673166275, -0.022078929468989372, 0.029200738295912743, 0.036267396062612534, 0.06613789498806, 0.010323614813387394, 0.041652385145425797, 0.014811765402555466, -0.010274547152221203, -0.026511836796998978, -0.019983477890491486, 0.01359509862959385, 0.018444903194904327, 0.02463185042142868, 0.05519326403737068, 0.0007696755928918719, -0.020307235419750214, 0.02265203185379505, 0.030150478705763817, -0.009413747116923332, 0.009900248609483242, 0.0569978728890419, -0.011178298853337765, -0.009835448116064072, 0.01275569200515747, 0.04903468117117882, -0.012328005395829678, -0.028090666979551315, -0.011236830614507198, -0.016291966661810875, 0.00045576225966215134, 0.04399304464459419, -0.02217499166727066, -0.039371948689222336, 0.014666509814560413, 0.03190162777900696, -0.041425157338380814, -0.01733747124671936, 0.012500815093517303, -0.05054784566164017, 0.0003364180156495422, -0.05765848234295845, 0.04895109310746193, -0.001974794315174222, 0.03547434136271477, 0.03784884884953499, -0.020646871998906136, -0.03650161623954773, 0.06404276192188263, 0.07924076914787292, -0.03151124343276024, -0.05355381965637207, -0.019974248483777046, -0.022655822336673737, 0.011041803285479546, -0.01615067571401596, -0.02844991162419319, 0.04169471934437752, -0.014213252812623978, -0.013120321556925774, 0.03716724365949631, -0.019730640575289726, 0.021161168813705444, 0.01577628217637539, 0.0135685158893466, 0.007284458726644516, 0.02868768386542797, -0.013810520060360432, 0.021199095994234085, 0.04257914796471596, 0.04004504904150963, 0.04664101451635361, 0.008830108679831028, -0.011590669862926006, 0.01646900735795498, 0.055072154849767685, 0.009443196468055248, -0.01890757493674755, 0.0681668221950531, -0.02387489564716816, 0.028153065592050552, -0.04261000081896782, -0.01794377714395523, 0.003927961923182011, 0.014745333231985569, -0.04110606014728546, -0.010415696538984776, 0.05559081956744194, -0.026781102642416954, 0.04747796058654785, 0.01553152222186327, -0.03795391693711281, 0.020222343504428864, -0.010184445418417454, 0.0014416818739846349, 0.057166311889886856, -0.03999091684818268, -0.020238926634192467, -0.032489728182554245, 0.02453562617301941, -0.013178405351936817, -0.039595723152160645, -0.03581367805600166, 0.07415895164012909, 0.018284544348716736, 0.01159572508186102, 0.0022367124911397696, -0.0025984521489590406, 0.017166607081890106, -0.056777648627758026, 0.05748862400650978, 0.047343429177999496, 0.050596561282873154, -0.0426083505153656, 0.02774403616786003, -0.027346987277269363, -0.049049653112888336, -0.010805298574268818, 0.013803726993501186, -0.022642195224761963, -0.010723997838795185, 0.024784592911601067, -0.00986719224601984, 0.00002557822699600365, 0.044206757098436356, 0.025428391993045807, 0.020951392129063606, 0.0021820683032274246, -0.08400817215442657, -0.03363567218184471, 0.026603680104017258, -0.00805821642279625, -0.010169553570449352, -0.06058773770928383, -0.0063956500962376595, 0.05073236674070358, 0.04264161363244057, -0.011076935566961765, 0.033715005964040756, 0.03865744546055794, 0.027234412729740143, -0.030300242826342583, -0.03282059356570244, -0.009853544645011425, -0.01041483599692583, 0.0043767220340669155, -0.04197932407259941, -0.056795839220285416, 0.024733612313866615, 0.002685204613953829, -0.0039742994122207165, -0.040843766182661057, 0.04115583375096321, -0.009336991235613823, -0.023329682648181915, -0.006857838481664658, -0.009555165655910969, -0.003186478279531002, 0.0692056193947792, 0.01226803008466959, 0.05318525806069374, 0.056629423052072525, -0.006587198004126549, 0.022871864959597588, 0.03198763728141785, 0.043297696858644485, 0.05066128820180893, -0.01775970123708248, -0.05342002585530281, -0.012068432755768299, 0.03919054940342903, 0.00668348278850317, -0.003808664157986641, -0.005230175796896219, 0.0011173796374350786, 0.004126375541090965, 0.0075550866313278675, 0.02786172181367874, 0.04180314764380455, -0.019387539476156235, 0.04404772073030472, -0.04198484867811203, -0.019817914813756943, -0.09419594705104828, 0.00946512445807457, -0.04226095974445343, -0.004016640596091747, 0.029674341902136803, -0.0033348561264574528, -0.0010910896817222238, -0.027705570682883263, -0.015568130649626255, -0.03300682082772255, 0.0032658283598721027, 0.02348528429865837, -0.04334314540028572, 0.028284981846809387, 0.0678524300456047, 0.011808160692453384, 0.0022768357302993536, 0.02129165641963482, -0.022144583985209465, -0.05806835740804672, 0.0048658233135938644, -0.007847249507904053, -0.0066645173355937, -0.013098442927002907, -0.024855412542819977, 0.020211268216371536, -0.0427858904004097, -0.01684570498764515, 0.022204069420695305, -0.05326485633850098, 0.07714104652404785, 0.05940718948841095, -0.00008268560486612841, -0.013010296039283276, 0.02366672083735466, 0.023757588118314743, 0.01281551644206047, -0.0013888009125366807, 0.015034021809697151, -0.05397874489426613, -0.008986998349428177, 0.06116550415754318, 0.024865923449397087, -0.04662217199802399, 0.04584764316678047, -0.00402683112770319, 0.04948140308260918, 0.03604353219270706, 0.017548436298966408, -0.009285369887948036, -0.02274932898581028, 0.03701169043779373, 0.010574878193438053, -0.026584066450595856, 0.01933446153998375, 0.018015529960393906, 0.0037940226029604673, 0.02827482856810093, 0.009844085201621056, -0.017987258732318878, 0.07708396017551422, -0.04018161818385124, 0.012064589187502861, -0.009395997039973736, -0.004138872493058443, 0.017724378034472466, -0.029362956061959267, 0.00704189483076334, 0.022119615226984024, 0.012238670140504837, 0.013102865777909756, -0.0006314415368251503, -0.008767050690948963, 0.02473456785082817, 0.04663853719830513, -0.03561592102050781, 0.006043815519660711, 0.009233396500349045, -0.04466278851032257, 0.023431120440363884, 0.00816498976200819, -0.06653544306755066, -0.043356798589229584, 0.027183692902326584, 0.025335969403386116, -0.0154467998072505, 0.026895029470324516, -0.03353555500507355, -0.046985168009996414, 0.022100849077105522, -0.021752767264842987, 0.012601940892636776, -0.00024589337408542633, -0.0460338369011879, -0.00809748936444521, -0.04892975091934204, -0.01934869773685932, 0.028510667383670807, -0.0273929201066494, -0.03175417706370354, -0.030758241191506386, -0.02195175364613533, -0.022864192724227905, -0.023533599451184273, -0.025979872792959213, 0.0200054869055748, -0.004431094974279404, -0.03097139298915863, 0.011915852315723896, -0.0012045946205034852, -0.01491196546703577, 0.023858439177274704, -0.030260153114795685, -0.04159229248762131, -0.007939186878502369, -0.00570225715637207, 0.0008224189514294267, 0.0007688365294598043, 0.03397953882813454, 0.0343097560107708, -0.05696488171815872, 0.00779982004314661, -0.07465164363384247, -0.0544513538479805, 0.03127611055970192, -0.015797704458236694, 0.02067338302731514, 0.01922725886106491, 0.004245591349899769, 0.049211788922548294, 0.03588591888546944, -0.01259022206068039, -0.006055306643247604, 0.013659791089594364, -0.027929333969950676, -0.008615314029157162, -0.029308786615729332, 0.023328794166445732, 0.008418696001172066, 0.00641250517219305, 0.0033366477582603693, 0.01037368830293417, 0.04124397039413452, 0.006250906269997358, -0.02435208484530449, 0.04697882756590843, 0.016463816165924072, -0.01116251666098833, 0.011578825302422047, 0.016491994261741638, -0.016091272234916687, 0.020621877163648605, -0.0005623919423669577, 0.037156302481889725, 0.030166305601596832, -0.027725255116820335, 0.02046941965818405, -0.026074513792991638, 0.006897699553519487, -0.042754318565130234, 0.04093873128294945, 0.02649248018860817, -0.03471701592206955, 0.019850360229611397, -0.0035062977112829685, 0.02218472771346569, -0.041297364979982376, 0.012470568530261517, 0.026710670441389084, 0.009792760014533997, -0.04911680519580841, -0.02624383009970188, 0.0003595588495954871, -0.02678007259964943, 0.02560972422361374, 0.008370286785066128, 0.019947562366724014, 0.02627350203692913, 0.042981963604688644, 0.027095835655927658, -0.015143672935664654, -0.04497739300131798, -0.020917683839797974, -0.06983640044927597, -0.012125887908041477, -0.01557297632098198, 0.04481925070285797, 0.015692321583628654, 0.028568830341100693, 0.03150252252817154, -0.017273899167776108, -0.0032394349109381437, 0.00781269557774067, -0.0584990531206131, 0.004061207640916109, -0.02612275630235672, 0.007747904397547245, -0.02526269108057022, -0.030592437833547592, 0.03461488336324692, -0.0690506249666214, -0.012563977390527725, -0.035730477422475815, 0.00672519626095891, -0.038455136120319366, 0.026677962392568588, -0.05121931806206703, -0.036932557821273804, 0.02492665685713291, 0.022703124210238457, 0.01748095080256462, 0.005495757795870304, 0.019886082038283348, 0.04814600944519043, -0.008555291220545769, -0.025074992328882217, 0.0010811457177624106, -0.013684066012501717, -0.005005938000977039, 0.00894630141556263, 0.023579066619277, 0.04553360119462013, -0.027164626866579056, 0.030255690217018127, 0.0230319332331419, 0.08069063723087311, 0.05395006015896797, -0.019259609282016754, -0.012476460076868534, -0.03988780081272125, -0.033895112574100494, 0.008276397362351418, 0.033242110162973404, 0.0009335053036920726, -0.008720489218831062, 0.060706425458192825, -0.0021227148827165365, -0.05908523499965668, 0.025354908779263496, 0.08272210508584976, 0.011407232843339443, -0.038618896156549454, -0.024248139932751656, -0.018354784697294235, -0.04996602237224579, -0.00020379787019919604, 0.015817346051335335, -0.004415510222315788, -0.015334058552980423, -0.004961356986314058, 0.015284528955817223, -0.03005458414554596, -0.024579834192991257, -0.012064666487276554, 0.04722901061177254, 0.03257396072149277, 0.03332237899303436, -0.027887415140867233, 0.040525611490011215, 0.04150742292404175, 0.021654630079865456, -0.01200046669691801, 0.011711767874658108, -0.12222383916378021, 0.02268204465508461, 0.013190720230340958, 0.03565378859639168, -0.04505006968975067, 0.024388935416936874, -0.05155738443136215, -0.013189755380153656, 0.027012452483177185, -0.024470115080475807, 0.018580060452222824, -0.03264541178941727, 0.004435199312865734, -0.0046206871047616005, 0.0011442105751484632, -0.03827076777815819, 0.00834709219634533, -0.010989543050527573, 0.0240830909460783, -0.010718151926994324, 0.01723206415772438, -0.038247741758823395, 0.008374180644750595, 0.022433631122112274, 0.06091214343905449, -0.013970865868031979, -0.045185450464487076, 0.008142845705151558, -0.0004561794048640877, 0.010524093173444271, -0.05607251450419426, 0.0023391188587993383, 0.01603701524436474, -0.019396157935261726, 0.02318163588643074, -0.015036425553262234, -0.05469537898898125, 0.024142799898982048, 0.020939752459526062, -0.041043613106012344, 0.017339251935482025, -0.02232160046696663, 0.030216585844755173, 0.006266855169087648, 0.038987915962934494, 0.04312153160572052, -0.0029671373777091503, -0.01136330422013998, -0.028912654146552086, -0.06492646783590317, 0.019955452531576157, -0.04425134137272835, 0.005715458188205957, -0.04330867528915405, 0.015656309202313423, -0.0023632929660379887, 0.052765388041734695, 0.01361454464495182, 0.003566781524568796, -0.023090366274118423, -0.0430774986743927, -0.014268777333199978, 0.036150477826595306, 0.0016341176815330982, -0.007184759713709354, -0.027088453993201256, 0.016228407621383667, -0.024004831910133362, 0.02504374086856842, 0.01613006740808487, -0.00909239612519741, 0.02745017036795616, 0.006442323327064514, -0.033377762883901596, 0.03306829184293747, -0.04316410794854164, -0.0076462822034955025, 0.04024440050125122, -0.03173181042075157, 0.060501232743263245, 0.04790417477488518, 0.025394707918167114, 0.0036942935548722744, -0.04241613671183586, -0.02430260181427002, -0.010599826462566853, 0.015222621150314808, 0.039944522082805634, -0.01976856030523777, 0.00818676594644785, -0.02245275117456913, 0.008951188065111637, -0.05927024409174919, -0.00918428972363472, -0.003364472882822156, -0.0037174620665609837, -0.027139335870742798, -0.03995228558778763, 0.0620032362639904, -0.02415904588997364, -0.01694243773818016, -0.018653152510523796, 0.05890180915594101, -0.026456119492650032, -0.021467437967658043, -0.017191320657730103, 0.028933310881257057, 0.0756850615143776, 0.01183259580284357, 0.007581144571304321, 0.0377446711063385, -0.014276293106377125, 0.0031642934773117304, 0.017376525327563286, 0.004215913359075785, -0.04512367025017738, -0.012532140128314495, -0.04088272526860237, 0.014465715736150742, 0.04549176245927811, -0.028520574793219566, -0.02210066467523575, 0.01568671502172947, 0.014552886597812176, -0.013938214629888535, -0.020777558907866478, -0.00758527684956789, -0.008262261748313904, -0.005294944625347853, -0.0326097197830677, 0.00175604154355824, -0.006572396494448185, -0.012073159217834473, 0.07427863776683807, -0.03047809563577175, -0.005531130824238062, 0.008183261379599571, 0.026115328073501587, -0.017155887559056282, 0.02987457439303398, -0.0016961927758529782, 0.008613578043878078, 0.05047384276986122, 0.024319125339388847, -0.014054262079298496, 0.04359954595565796, 0.0017755476292222738, -0.022494180127978325, 0.007222382351756096, -0.07518289238214493, -0.01360186468809843, 0.08451111614704132, -0.007626687176525593, 0.05130840837955475, 0.036481279879808426, 0.006994673050940037, -0.011584632098674774, -0.026948334649205208, -0.012304667383432388, -0.028361711651086807, 0.009278710000216961, 0.025977343320846558, -0.0219423808157444, 0.005687780678272247, 0.051919758319854736, -0.01969434693455696, 0.012920468114316463, 0.04824521765112877, 0.011930340901017189, 0.016941815614700317, 0.02441592887043953, -0.04967951029539108, -0.0486464723944664, 0.06275785714387894, -0.03828708827495575, -0.01840435341000557, -0.017747201025485992, -0.06458866596221924, 0.05822809785604477, 0.03667176887392998, -0.008266190066933632, -0.06003624200820923, -0.002923533320426941, -0.04791640117764473, 0.020125862210989, 0.0160154290497303, 0.025133611634373665, 0.033745747059583664, -0.022104814648628235, 0.00733152125030756, -0.016297070309519768, 0.02010693959891796, 0.007815917022526264, -0.08911332488059998, -0.06453286856412888, -0.005086468067020178, -0.03887743502855301, 0.007262505125254393, 0.004445978906005621, -0.019601430743932724, -0.0068856109865009785, -0.039427537471055984, 0.036262985318899155, 0.004082066472619772, 0.02279832772910595, -0.051093846559524536, 0.04136277362704277, -0.024921603500843048, 0.03916709125041962, 0.011975569650530815, 0.008201058022677898, 0.11511263996362686, 0.09761729836463928, 0.046685781329870224, -0.05489503964781761, 0.021921643987298012, -0.008852469734847546, -0.02734287828207016, -0.02860826812684536, 0.033174917101860046, -0.0025601345114409924, -0.01780809834599495, -0.015870409086346626, 0.021927759051322937, -0.0016256183153018355, -0.008538547903299332, 0.07403834909200668, -0.06402909755706787, -0.04906941205263138, 0.005599498748779297, -0.00011569385242182761, -0.011818266473710537, -0.0044772932305932045, -0.017236091196537018, -0.020336002111434937, 0.0011690377723425627, -0.046114835888147354, -0.014631905592978, 0.006093861535191536, -0.01603860780596733, 0.012953167781233788, -0.003378717927262187, -0.029566312208771706, 0.014617063105106354, -0.013749910518527031, 0.0020242712926119566, -0.029839348047971725, -0.018350891768932343, -0.03756917268037796, 0.004009658936411142, 0.034833043813705444, -0.01691284589469433, -0.0041020638309419155, -0.00046697049401700497, 0.0165468230843544, -0.04291025176644325, -0.030357036739587784, -0.04163162037730217, 0.06445784866809845, -0.020213359966874123, 0.017926227301359177, -0.025853894650936127, 0.008201911114156246, -0.01597536727786064, -0.03763400390744209, -0.01094953902065754, 0.03128240257501602, 0.04441987723112106, -0.0051002223044633865, -0.005642303265631199, -0.022540364414453506, 0.03243429958820343, -0.0044834064319729805, 0.05287653207778931, 0.02656843326985836, -0.029574789106845856, -0.0072510018944740295, -0.007359514944255352, 0.044906504452228546, 0.007845759391784668, 0.02121604233980179, -0.026162654161453247, -0.01781606674194336, -0.03046741522848606, -0.016832029446959496, 0.033141832798719406, 0.0045816837809979916, -0.002218573121353984, 0.007475980557501316, -0.01614939421415329, -0.003984237555414438, -0.03917298465967178, 0.007662027608603239, -0.04557430371642113, -0.01135005708783865, -0.05092018470168114, 0.024433216080069542, 0.0390627346932888, 0.03577305004000664, 0.037069112062454224, 0.023264393210411072, -0.013328082859516144, 0.02659936062991619, 0.019808454439044, -0.02211378887295723, -0.02041749469935894, 0.005486616399139166, -0.016761446371674538, 0.03718924894928932, 0.013275308534502983, 0.029608527198433876, 0.05770302936434746, 0.03458510711789131, -0.008903112262487411, 0.024044958874583244, -0.004863686393946409, 0.03395845368504524, -0.025244345888495445, -0.024095628410577774, 0.016783125698566437, -0.00005867679283255711, 0.04204559698700905, -0.0337815135717392, -0.06605472415685654, -0.02258288860321045, -0.008694789372384548, 0.024652153253555298, -0.033940646797418594, -0.031250953674316406, 0.017434941604733467, 0.028134454041719437, 0.010283607058227062, -0.033037975430488586, 0.004679827950894833, -0.007457039784640074, 0.002736980328336358, -0.01810574345290661, -0.02875864878296852, -0.005333503242582083, 0.008446968160569668, -0.021008092910051346, -0.016197029501199722, 0.01785215362906456, 0.007922949269413948, 0.005576088558882475, 0.006113144569098949, 0.013033556751906872, -0.015062609687447548, 0.04170256480574608, -0.03118159994482994, -0.02397298626601696, 0.023902975022792816, -0.04969028756022453, -0.012989159673452377, 0.039484623819589615, 0.008884676732122898, 0.036479610949754715, 0.022506868466734886, 0.03499627858400345, 0.0018258985364809632, -0.005304157268255949, -0.01246571820229292, -0.004695451818406582, 0.02763441577553749, 0.040028732270002365, -0.0351378358900547, 0.012758677825331688, 0.026593709364533424, 0.015113039873540401, -0.009090433828532696, 0.0055841305293142796, 0.02320018783211708, 0.03911812976002693, -0.017672881484031677, 0.04010685160756111, 0.0013976551126688719, 0.0162382572889328, 0.0004525695985648781, 0.0030669623520225286, 0.029124708846211433, 0.0350010059773922, -0.027453819289803505, 0.06232215091586113, 0.014499603770673275, 0.0022052726708352566, -0.10730540752410889, -0.02655932307243347, 0.05573830008506775, 0.026476789265871048, 0.021398872137069702, -0.06171136721968651, 0.03155577927827835, 0.018335087224841118, -0.0463985837996006, 0.023104863241314888, 0.0033502124715596437, -0.0001690130593487993, -0.01881108433008194, 0.026261139661073685, -0.03371252864599228, 0.030410105362534523, -0.003538093762472272, 0.03958038613200188, 0.04054008051753044, -0.009660436771810055, 0.010517561808228493, -0.00598301412537694, -0.01465402077883482, 0.02787288837134838, -0.024930525571107864, -0.05474993959069252, 0.06962676346302032, -0.061334870755672455, -0.0321381650865078, 0.03686005249619484, 0.06927318871021271, 0.03921878710389137, 0.03328366577625275, 0.006052700337022543, 0.023414477705955505, 0.02990429289638996, 0.06569673120975494, -0.007369234226644039, -0.00956209097057581, 0.0221815574914217, 0.001483578234910965, 0.04765061289072037, -0.00900581106543541, 0.0011819512583315372, 0.00538729690015316, -0.04234502092003822, -0.02368682622909546, -0.007110405247658491, -0.03728112578392029, -0.03910961374640465, 0.013647099956870079, -0.0006205386016517878, -0.027095112949609756, -0.00577702047303319, 0.016303861513733864, -0.04595191404223442, -0.0043611894361674786, 0.03214450553059578, 0.018850622698664665, -0.0049048191867768764, 0.018663087859749794, -0.027510136365890503, -0.03594909980893135, 0.004386435262858868, 0.003913838416337967, -0.009765599854290485, -0.05242418125271797, 0.011765754781663418, 0.013666455633938313, -0.02097218483686447, -0.019592883065342903, 0.0029228178318589926, -0.048665717244148254, 0.04034385457634926, -0.06362107396125793, 0.039675500243902206, 0.003212464042007923, -0.008638465777039528, -0.02279425598680973, -0.06724565476179123, 0.06086019426584244, -0.0037378405686467886, -0.03377308323979378, -0.030760619789361954, -0.004979800898581743, -0.038823388516902924, -0.017949193716049194, 0.05255426466464996, 0.006743781268596649, -0.003998033702373505, -0.004038296639919281, 0.027727633714675903, 0.02667311765253544, -0.025224018841981888, 0.014224626123905182, -0.014693355187773705, -0.03271658718585968, -0.032007649540901184, -0.02199266105890274, 0.020283197984099388, 0.029495690017938614, 0.030743809416890144, -0.01520027220249176, -0.00013333765673451126, -0.007504140492528677, 0.005795648787170649, 0.040455952286720276, 0.006429956294596195, -0.015525558032095432, 0.02790055423974991, 0.016880931332707405, 0.02156042493879795, 0.028035325929522514, -0.009701096452772617, -0.05721970647573471, 0.030400661751627922, -0.036362599581480026, -0.05082298815250397, 0.0049507394433021545, 0.011528639122843742, 0.011217580176889896, -0.05529889836907387, 0.0020889712031930685, 0.0526130311191082, -0.04920237511396408, 0.03141346946358681, 0.032637789845466614, -0.006378225050866604, 0.030308036133646965, 0.000017646380001679063, 0.0064062876626849174, 0.007088718935847282, -0.028536135330796242, 0.007972970604896545, -0.00014658260624855757, 0.05303453281521797, -0.03184965252876282, 0.04027538001537323, 0.03792247921228409, 0.008274842984974384, 0.007816036231815815, 0.00490697892382741, 0.03969622030854225, -0.019592268392443657, -0.008526439778506756, 0.019882943481206894, 0.0021719986107200384, 0.0064464351162314415, 0.021352555602788925, -0.02277575060725212, 0.0758281797170639, -0.00588575191795826, -0.010482726618647575, -0.03494579344987869, -0.01232299767434597, -0.05331110954284668, 0.015905432403087616, -0.01269388385117054, 0.020419960841536522, 0.037105005234479904, 0.01616325043141842, -0.01127233263105154, -0.005400107242166996, 0.04502102732658386, -0.027901887893676758, -0.02465054579079151, -0.02186044119298458, -0.020249227061867714, -0.006736596580594778, -0.017872754484415054, -0.02533840201795101, -0.00665021687746048, 0.021387659013271332, 0.049618419259786606, 0.05968335643410683, -0.0036898276302963495, -0.027958666905760765, -0.027680380269885063, 0.018200835213065147, -0.07614974677562714, 0.00020819528435822576, -0.04435671865940094, -0.012828454375267029, 0.0015111827524378896, -0.034571219235658646 ]
<p>This should be a fairly straight forward, but I can't seem to figure out the answer. I'm doing some A/B(C/D/E...) testing on a website and measuring impressions and clicks. What method should I be using to determine the statistically significant winner?</p> <p>This is sample data that I would have. There could be any number of tests, all being displayed in relatively-equal distribution and measuring clicks as a successful result. Such as:</p> <pre><code>Test # | Impressions | Clicks 1 | 50 | 12 2 | 55 | 15 3 | 53 | 30 4 | 49 | 22 </code></pre> <p>What algorithm should I be using to determine the winner in a statistically significant way?</p>
39,353
[ -0.05738771706819534, -0.05210716649889946, -0.028294922783970833, -0.009524239227175713, 0.020277950912714005, 0.03798867017030716, 0.016780633479356766, 0.008146231062710285, 0.015977634117007256, 0.026126980781555176, 0.041791319847106934, 0.014475764706730843, 0.02993359975516796, 0.023040540516376495, 0.027341492474079132, -0.011195669881999493, -0.014018772169947624, 0.00899628084152937, 0.00567379966378212, 0.01634795404970646, 0.0034961586352437735, -0.010477825067937374, 0.00641526747494936, -0.03117193654179573, -0.05060657858848572, 0.0310954749584198, 0.037620022892951965, 0.006773056462407112, 0.008220037445425987, 0.03348860517144203, -0.0566876195371151, -0.036276645958423615, 0.022601161152124405, 0.046814288944005966, 0.03886980190873146, 0.0006237425841391087, -0.010002286173403263, 0.005282883532345295, -0.03507881984114647, -0.022379474714398384, 0.001781514729373157, 0.0011967865284532309, -0.01919470727443695, 0.026605036109685898, -0.012141549959778786, 0.013574497774243355, -0.06118031218647957, -0.04984968155622482, 0.03753137215971947, -0.06606379896402359, 0.10730499774217606, 0.00806080736219883, 0.06884239614009857, -0.02677847072482109, -0.0015798589447513223, -0.010954600758850574, 0.029333919286727905, 0.0647563561797142, -0.026750026270747185, -0.051679566502571106, -0.016372550278902054, -0.02935406006872654, -0.015747198835015297, -0.02402678318321705, -0.024631531909108162, 0.01615728624165058, -0.011696872301399708, -0.0009050118387676775, 0.09796400368213654, 0.003565529128536582, 0.0015797748928889632, 0.045168936252593994, 0.035449039191007614, 0.025024812668561935, 0.013882824219763279, -0.031118009239435196, 0.03615947067737579, -0.0002768148260656744, 0.04247352480888367, 0.030871959403157234, -0.023712540045380592, -0.015379323624074459, 0.004011970944702625, 0.05832783877849579, 0.048242293298244476, -0.029331237077713013, 0.031205996870994568, -0.04140065610408783, 0.01081619132310152, 0.02002309449017048, -0.029504001140594482, -0.05848715826869011, 0.047392163425683975, -0.008733993396162987, -0.05831976234912872, 0.016388576477766037, -0.010016661137342453, 0.041733257472515106, 0.0398077629506588, -0.006523577030748129, -0.009196098893880844, -0.02932402677834034, 0.040574558079242706, 0.05342082679271698, -0.030295243486762047, 0.032750051468610764, -0.04656810685992241, -0.001295706257224083, 0.014019072987139225, 0.01516374945640564, 0.0018219047924503684, 0.012191548943519592, 0.007904705591499805, 0.04113773629069328, 0.05118093267083168, -0.02795899659395218, -0.013410820625722408, 0.010149608366191387, 0.07738158106803894, 0.03619334101676941, 0.022741051390767097, -0.01760074682533741, 0.028365667909383774, -0.02876201644539833, 0.003825432388111949, -0.01001546997576952, 0.01006079651415348, 0.003003408433869481, -0.006814855616539717, 0.07259360700845718, -0.05014116317033768, -0.013989096507430077, 0.018656723201274872, -0.008251411840319633, 0.007200970780104399, 0.0060355099849402905, -0.08029882609844208, -0.007177491206675768, 0.048519331961870193, -0.05484256520867348, -0.02401828207075596, -0.04096640646457672, -0.02769814059138298, 0.04020874202251434, -0.00513227004557848, 0.036273594945669174, 0.03581464663147926, -0.0071441736072301865, 0.027913574129343033, 0.01773246005177498, -0.023407505825161934, -0.0038387158419936895, -0.015379702672362328, -0.021532908082008362, -0.04089526832103729, -0.054966382682323456, -0.03222261741757393, -0.010657965205609798, 0.001973530510440469, -0.021892201155424118, -0.0021634360309690237, 0.012165437452495098, -0.019909033551812172, -0.011246972717344761, 0.030413292348384857, 0.006790712010115385, 0.08860963582992554, 0.018810531124472618, 0.025991525501012802, 0.012255669571459293, -0.04231353476643562, 0.005871608853340149, 0.03504884988069534, 0.00407871650531888, 0.051932983100414276, -0.006236580666154623, -0.006563897244632244, -0.03495650738477707, 0.019646551460027695, -0.0015319919912144542, -0.01869887486100197, -0.06441066414117813, -0.03803456947207451, 0.029356103390455246, 0.040745604783296585, 0.04028964787721634, -0.016212906688451767, -0.008193465881049633, 0.06400749832391739, -0.032170869410037994, -0.048338815569877625, -0.0754920244216919, 0.003472525393590331, 0.01938852109014988, -0.04384357109665871, 0.021763596683740616, 0.022012466564774513, 0.0224105603992939, 0.005349155981093645, -0.005543653387576342, -0.042192693799734116, -0.01622597873210907, 0.027214832603931427, -0.02440878376364708, -0.018481621518731117, 0.05376969650387764, 0.028603361919522285, -0.032233841717243195, 0.024773461744189262, -0.0042666601948440075, -0.0106877526268363, -0.015441293828189373, -0.004521104507148266, 0.0144892493262887, -0.0027646704111248255, -0.021325068548321724, 0.02633553370833397, 0.019817033782601357, -0.00843380019068718, 0.012476173229515553, -0.052173011004924774, 0.07118222117424011, 0.05487137660384178, -0.0008345390087924898, 0.009394912980496883, -0.03245905041694641, -0.0031512307468801737, 0.01441445667296648, 0.017939474433660507, 0.000579131708946079, -0.057054903358221054, 0.002416693838313222, 0.025953656062483788, 0.0011401482624933124, -0.01778477244079113, 0.003501373576000333, 0.0780087560415268, -0.0006455570110119879, 0.02087896503508091, 0.06732873618602753, -0.029368862509727478, 0.025077207013964653, -0.0008105450542643666, 0.017854657024145126, 0.02417251281440258, 0.025437677279114723, 0.0192213486880064, 0.028066756203770638, -0.00218144990503788, -0.0035379754845052958, 0.017162444069981575, 0.019571634009480476, -0.022334733977913857, 0.0005648008082062006, -0.050876911729574203, -0.009349421598017216, 0.035826120525598526, -0.010351911187171936, -0.017660537734627724, 0.06785701215267181, -0.0019559788051992655, -0.02395467832684517, 0.01619230955839157, -0.0342288613319397, 0.0111642275005579, 0.04447799548506737, -0.029286175966262817, -0.012187527492642403, 0.030921611934900284, -0.02018577978014946, 0.02299000322818756, -0.011378497816622257, -0.00949037354439497, -0.02803882025182247, 0.024838360026478767, 0.046260155737400055, -0.019061380997300148, 0.022726206108927727, -0.018825100734829903, -0.02047126740217209, -0.03192717209458351, -0.06109050288796425, 0.028642453253269196, -0.01941555179655552, -0.04124566540122032, -0.025064954534173012, -0.019579121842980385, -0.048233482986688614, 0.03770405426621437, -0.03969982638955116, -0.044339679181575775, 0.02177978679537773, 0.025293223559856415, -0.04624702036380768, 0.000011089797226304654, -0.052118510007858276, 0.05555100366473198, -0.041574567556381226, -0.014959187246859074, 0.06243939697742462, 0.03872731328010559, -0.03805350512266159, 0.06779494136571884, -0.008671480230987072, -0.02548900619149208, -0.019806912168860435, -0.022679176181554794, -0.00595867121592164, -0.012679842300713062, 0.021108871325850487, 0.013658476062119007, 0.010440814308822155, 0.0018046227050945163, -0.054092977195978165, -0.06971962749958038, 0.04359334334731102, -0.0046892170794308186, 0.05276307463645935, 0.005709231831133366, -0.018725786358118057, 0.061796847730875015, 0.025485793128609657, -0.04244304448366165, -0.042036741971969604, -0.01827346347272396, 0.003020412987098098, -0.011615108698606491, 0.016116496175527573, 0.026063740253448486, -0.018983427435159683, 0.015074736438691616, 0.0076349880546331406, -0.0051272474229335785, 0.02538631483912468, -0.0010528909042477608, -0.04199119284749031, 0.03069249726831913, 0.0017325392691418529, 0.006392975337803364, 0.010620946995913982, 0.049666255712509155, -0.06111984699964523, 0.013394221663475037, 0.0059175086207687855, 0.008565694093704224, 0.012752857990562916, -0.010432048700749874, 0.007103939540684223, -0.0110224774107337, -0.016072724014520645, -0.0017717828741297126, 0.007774757221341133, -0.018562505021691322, -0.007278671022504568, -0.003920760937035084, -0.023226702585816383, 0.02440132200717926, -0.03653580695390701, -0.012629463337361813, 0.054609254002571106, 0.053848996758461, -0.031083781272172928, -0.010404023341834545, -0.018275102600455284, -0.01231002900749445, 0.005598049610853195, -0.026929954066872597, -0.03711679205298424, 0.014251166954636574, 0.0202028788626194, 0.011825742200016975, 0.03496413305401802, -0.060241565108299255, -0.012364039197564125, -0.0671125054359436, 0.0015507562784478068, -0.027837194502353668, 0.06058953329920769, -0.028488902375102043, 0.04744711518287659, 0.05174622684717178, -0.01969803124666214, 0.0026016980409622192, 0.002002617111429572, -0.07937705516815186, 0.06060953065752983, 0.001656535197980702, -0.000316220975946635, 0.009886021725833416, -0.04287507012486458, 0.021914541721343994, -0.013164476491510868, 0.008386554196476936, 0.012057065032422543, 0.03202785924077034, 0.007376869674772024, 0.020184345543384552, 0.00022229239402804524, 0.02687658555805683, 0.0014519807882606983, 0.037259992212057114, 0.005824452731758356, 0.001850518980063498, 0.04971722513437271, 0.017319073900580406, -0.02609384059906006, -0.012403630651533604, -0.003825071267783642, 0.004159005358815193, 0.004649728070944548, 0.044036488980054855, 0.02072487585246563, 0.03155286982655525, -0.034626469016075134, 0.0022695790976285934, -0.010314739309251308, 0.04277661815285683, 0.012143280357122421, -0.03045584261417389, -0.02695588581264019, -0.05212075635790825, -0.0024866664316505194, 0.0032573763746768236, 0.015984531491994858, 0.03642694279551506, 0.014818576164543629, 0.036704111844301224, 0.020745931193232536, -0.05991780757904053, 0.029401151463389397, 0.07309850305318832, 0.02197553962469101, -0.009561124257743359, -0.009548526257276535, 0.01975816674530506, -0.004961252678185701, -0.02728768065571785, 0.01840480975806713, 0.048053842037916183, 0.026785464957356453, -0.005765616428107023, 0.030023451894521713, -0.01229336578398943, -0.03057146444916725, 0.0267445407807827, -0.00867534801363945, 0.042785391211509705, -0.005196148529648781, -0.043524160981178284, -0.000006761489657947095, 0.03852764889597893, 0.026230361312627792, 0.03550102934241295, -0.00489079300314188, -0.0800982415676117, 0.016892243176698685, 0.02840295061469078, 0.03011133335530758, -0.055894672870635986, -0.014361456036567688, -0.02424837276339531, 0.02256968803703785, 0.05071719363331795, -0.06635770201683044, 0.0441458597779274, -0.004868899937719107, 0.02399233542382717, -0.01747421734035015, 0.03293217346072197, -0.061041105538606644, 0.017374103888869286, -0.034433480352163315, 0.015926091000437737, -0.016495095565915108, -0.04630585387349129, -0.06266868859529495, 0.003840548684820533, 0.03386928513646126, 0.06092606484889984, -0.06449421495199203, -0.02049156464636326, 0.0011950720800086856, 0.006113759707659483, -0.04270092025399208, -0.0654800608754158, 0.022816134616732597, 0.011217782273888588, -0.00012702499225270003, 0.025514181703329086, -0.0032082300167530775, -0.04560749605298042, 0.013273895718157291, 0.010994254611432552, -0.04303508624434471, 0.005485024768859148, 0.008999770507216454, 0.04189992696046829, 0.03032979927957058, 0.0015004478627815843, 0.016338558867573738, -0.024222511798143387, 0.007978319190442562, -0.0015706256963312626, 0.029974160715937614, -0.006331027951091528, -0.017762016505002975, -0.0027729368302971125, -0.048941899091005325, 0.014196600764989853, -0.05197342857718468, 0.003465070389211178, 0.01903248019516468, 0.01755048707127571, -0.041001975536346436, -0.0015234316233545542, -0.01666252501308918, 0.016566088423132896, -0.0016836605500429869, -0.020991681143641472, 0.011268571019172668, 0.006623596418648958, -0.002235142281278968, -0.0007232229690998793, 0.042719095945358276, 0.0006732835317961872, -0.013617130927741528, -0.022924164310097694, -0.053257204592227936, 0.02199436165392399, -0.029618218541145325, -0.01451865304261446, 0.010602453723549843, -0.0402207188308239, 0.04986221715807915, -0.007237953133881092, 0.037258654832839966, 0.028033312410116196, -0.040769096463918686, -0.04635903611779213, 0.027279524132609367, 0.029234357178211212, 0.039419203996658325, -0.05031397566199303, 0.050234243273735046, -0.020713716745376587, -0.03637655824422836, -0.06475813686847687, -0.018338963389396667, 0.03522960841655731, 0.05089983344078064, -0.023050058633089066, -0.014805672690272331, 0.0021535493433475494, -0.0018551868852227926, -0.014361613430082798, -0.03389713913202286, 0.013562886044383049, 0.0024532615207135677, -0.0216823723167181, 0.020832695066928864, 0.0154478894546628, 0.08378835022449493, 0.04290864244103432, -0.008794770576059818, 0.01875721476972103, 0.015612554736435413, -0.03045547753572464, 0.016831979155540466, 0.02347988449037075, -0.037661150097846985, -0.015665534883737564, -0.025346141308546066, 0.031139232218265533, 0.012093865312635899, -0.021387876942753792, 0.015582055784761906, -0.04084254428744316, 0.014731277711689472, 0.004915251396596432, -0.012732465751469135, 0.01722561940550804, -0.015245338901877403, 0.027213716879487038, -0.001271008513867855, -0.01712699607014656, -0.0354708731174469, 0.0004786954668816179, 0.021726375445723534, 0.02243783324956894, -0.016597464680671692, -0.010966695845127106, 0.04504229873418808, -0.03526394069194794, -0.03303442895412445, 0.0035016601905226707, -0.019603000953793526, 0.04378660395741463, 0.019549742341041565, 0.024677228182554245, -0.013570109382271767, 0.02999046817421913, -0.0333721823990345, 0.00952962413430214, -0.030603501945734024, 0.011504524387419224, 0.043081752955913544, -0.012681091204285622, 0.03883974626660347, 0.07812246680259705, 0.03905170410871506, 0.006130280904471874, 0.0036907028406858444, -0.0267728753387928, -0.031176580116152763, 0.03676798939704895, 0.023391317576169968, -0.008901912719011307, 0.0034150381106883287, 0.02857293374836445, -0.016999462619423866, 0.05978376045823097, 0.04776856303215027, 0.044350966811180115, 0.01782720722258091, 0.05469806492328644, -0.05328623205423355, -0.008288917131721973, 0.016315709799528122, -0.0448790080845356, 0.029974250122904778, -0.022974466904997826, -0.0033962507732212543, 0.033072590827941895, 0.01847163401544094, -0.024130171164870262, -0.02302023209631443, -0.04477319493889809, -0.06091487035155296, 0.010704734362661839, -0.00335694313980639, -0.0363035574555397, 0.029104525223374367, -0.006451587192714214, 0.01291822548955679, 0.013173055835068226, 0.04815579950809479, -0.03941214457154274, -0.04985763505101204, -0.01845129020512104, -0.04047757759690285, -0.056051839143037796, 0.014004385098814964, 0.016133705154061317, -0.034717220813035965, 0.011293385177850723, -0.035886406898498535, 0.009758930653333664, 0.03603602945804596, 0.011406639590859413, -0.02287003956735134, 0.05266100913286209, 0.010263108648359776, 0.046398311853408813, 0.019598189741373062, -0.02419058047235012, 0.09285379946231842, 0.04788556694984436, 0.0141985435038805, -0.07444164901971817, 0.02528580091893673, 0.00951753556728363, 0.014295984990894794, -0.020146548748016357, -0.00041856110328808427, 0.04804089665412903, 0.009856020100414753, 0.08188866078853607, 0.0011507513700053096, 0.025510361418128014, 0.004611395299434662, 0.04123330116271973, -0.015091592445969582, -0.05593663826584816, 0.04313848912715912, 0.007298009470105171, -0.03189295902848244, -0.022313836961984634, -0.06777086108922958, -0.006068713963031769, 0.05119527131319046, -0.01676567830145359, 0.025020115077495575, -0.03537018597126007, -0.039132628589868546, 0.01043857540935278, -0.015276928432285786, 0.018292203545570374, 0.011800210922956467, 0.014377947896718979, -0.028699489310383797, -0.011226985603570938, 0.013751990161836147, -0.009085886180400848, 0.009211122058331966, 0.016743674874305725, 0.04217962920665741, -0.023865966126322746, -0.015429720282554626, 0.047731250524520874, -0.02853630855679512, -0.03784594684839249, -0.03674863651394844, 0.0058162640780210495, -0.015517959371209145, -0.005152407102286816, -0.03531894460320473, 0.00659332238137722, -0.02503964863717556, -0.05829201266169548, -0.02760888636112213, 0.035770729184150696, 0.007290604058653116, -0.06313849240541458, -0.04952773451805115, -0.014113234356045723, 0.024740980938076973, -0.015838107094168663, 0.003994540311396122, 0.017560265958309174, 0.0035218149423599243, -0.030494339764118195, -0.034782540053129196, 0.04359375685453415, 0.022018833085894585, -0.03480512276291847, 0.022264162078499794, -0.04247342795133591, -0.040904149413108826, 0.039699118584394455, -0.016388919204473495, -0.02072128839790821, -0.025894982740283012, 0.011841394007205963, 0.004612224642187357, -0.00795256532728672, 0.03902668505907059, 0.03880501911044121, -0.011379995383322239, -0.024066712707281113, -0.06177319213747978, -0.0013987231068313122, 0.004431605339050293, 0.028140323236584663, 0.04367578402161598, 0.019893981516361237, 0.013905777595937252, 0.02663324400782585, 0.017460523173213005, -0.047723401337862015, -0.04000970721244812, 0.0011829782743006945, -0.012059959582984447, -0.023380719125270844, -0.009820453822612762, 0.07502245157957077, 0.035798367112874985, -0.028803300112485886, -0.007795622572302818, -0.017595769837498665, -0.042654767632484436, 0.023903755471110344, -0.02546602487564087, -0.060413796454668045, -0.0367167703807354, 0.005832793191075325, -0.02602786011993885, -0.036607928574085236, -0.009555232711136341, -0.03637196496129036, -0.006944750435650349, -0.014416401274502277, 0.009429858066141605, 0.017454097047448158, 0.008569180965423584, -0.020565979182720184, 0.021339286118745804, -0.04248711094260216, -0.012816088274121284, -0.030308600515127182, -0.01912749744951725, -0.0114017678424716, 0.020691122859716415, 0.007210990414023399, 0.028390495106577873, 0.017445452511310577, 0.012370369397103786, -0.017057020217180252, 0.020826058462262154, 0.02346361242234707, -0.019069213420152664, 0.002493400825187564, -0.023616570979356766, 0.048762157559394836, -0.0030387425795197487, -0.013276007026433945, 0.0588579960167408, -0.04143627732992172, -0.031205609440803528, 0.004103121813386679, -0.017613984644412994, 0.03961176797747612, 0.005207234527915716, -0.018298882991075516, 0.017688173800706863, 0.023978006094694138, 0.0008260892936959863, -0.02295808494091034, -0.01324885617941618, -0.0010521281510591507, 0.03822240233421326, 0.044798605144023895, -0.029525496065616608, -0.0024844766594469547, -0.03125166520476341, 0.017490558326244354, 0.020994601771235466, -0.010151052847504616, 0.0007530025904998183, 0.01597350649535656, 0.030744332820177078, 0.04703570529818535, 0.029555438086390495, -0.026366429403424263, 0.02712384983897209, 0.041666265577077866, -0.047959595918655396, 0.0027908796910196543, -0.005181543063372374, -0.0069792489521205425, -0.03233454003930092, -0.030927417799830437, 0.007872470654547215, -0.03349578380584717, 0.07878866791725159, -0.06974238902330399, 0.014070237055420876, 0.062302958220243454, -0.06657423079013824, 0.03761833533644676, -0.014977624639868736, -0.0011932682245969772, -0.0542801208794117, 0.011403181590139866, -0.031741853803396225, 0.031561315059661865, 0.020370259881019592, 0.01679946854710579, 0.044536489993333817, 0.01570853218436241, 0.0005941824638284743, -0.014235256239771843, -0.016980353742837906, 0.014609277248382568, 0.008780570700764656, -0.0738033652305603, 0.028294315561652184, -0.0331929549574852, -0.045244455337524414, 0.051208604127168655, -0.03350726142525673, 0.05023908242583275, 0.02819693461060524, -0.011598962359130383, 0.026607103645801544, 0.05291849374771118, 0.03683941438794136, -0.036181554198265076, -0.013422329910099506, 0.030571695417165756, 0.007713488768786192, 0.032785505056381226, 0.01055881753563881, 0.02210570126771927, 0.01928306184709072, -0.001557883690111339, -0.033457718789577484, 0.03023783676326275, 0.010240507312119007, -0.020002145320177078, -0.007434849627315998, -0.022086389362812042, 0.025180991739034653, -0.029708318412303925, -0.020992044359445572, -0.06727605313062668, 0.015451807528734207, 0.04059360921382904, 0.026004591956734657, -0.007055723108351231, -0.001920298091135919, -0.025573406368494034, -0.019793327897787094, -0.03435969725251198, -0.012105134315788746, -0.012139234691858292, -0.029824653640389442, 0.003515193471685052, -0.009531121701002121, 0.02780933491885662, -0.0043446882627904415, -0.05162031576037407, -0.02130189910531044, 0.053559914231300354, 0.02180706337094307, 0.0033233053982257843, 0.012066689319908619, -0.01995016634464264, 0.012892271392047405, -0.09084349125623703, 0.06346731632947922, 0.023547282442450523, -0.01415103580802679, -0.013436325825750828, -0.020303722470998764, -0.028753116726875305, 0.02833874151110649, 0.02638927847146988, 0.004389025270938873, -0.003586753271520138, -0.01878170110285282, -0.022791579365730286, -0.009460288099944592, -0.04975554347038269, 0.025047119706869125, -0.030300991609692574, -0.0283832848072052, -0.045664429664611816, 0.009371371008455753, 0.012857417576014996, -0.01676994189620018, -0.002062872750684619, -0.004528677556663752, -0.016093803569674492, -0.05260996147990227, -0.037258394062519073, 0.05858999863266945, 0.019113732501864433, 0.03328137472271919, 0.025981031358242035, 0.013910695910453796, 0.02246374823153019, 0.006163560785353184, 0.0014632382662966847, -0.03161785379052162, 0.05855611711740494, -0.04694657027721405, -0.0153921814635396, 0.00585579127073288, 0.015789218246936798, -0.014286660589277744, -0.05272841081023216, -0.002183307660743594, 0.007562398444861174, 0.01150463242083788, -0.002094896510243416, -0.002428539330139756, 0.004641230683773756, 0.02467585913836956, -0.0033185805659741163, 0.01281000766903162, -0.02229381911456585, 0.016295695677399635, -0.02465379610657692, 0.01056002639234066, 0.0188106931746006, 0.017422758042812347, 0.032230302691459656, 0.022022774443030357, -0.008546747267246246, 0.05935927852988243, -0.0015735909109935164, 0.013561055064201355, 0.00496713537722826, 0.00200835894793272, 0.0226689875125885, -0.02465253509581089, 0.0034230404999107122, 0.0019973809830844402, -0.014691182412207127, 0.04236415773630142, -0.05342608690261841, 0.037273697555065155, -0.04599034786224365, -0.012086857110261917, -0.036092739552259445, -0.021005047485232353, 0.018586279824376106, 0.012488125823438168, -0.023126598447561264, 0.02520844340324402, 0.040938325226306915, 0.03773728758096695, 0.005820550490170717, 0.005967938806861639, 0.04403980076313019, -0.004548242781311274, -0.032006826251745224, -0.0026689625810831785, 0.010078790597617626, -0.04494927451014519, 0.020957738161087036, 0.01854574866592884, 0.062151260673999786, 0.01396164670586586, 0.00443870248273015, -0.003925119061022997, -0.009445439092814922, 0.04721050336956978, -0.006387632340192795, -0.04433053359389305, -0.044680532068014145, 0.03719129413366318, -0.010422776453197002, 0.007148484233766794 ]
<p>I am working on Markov transition matrices. I would like to find a statistical test to compare them.</p> <p>The first matrix is considered the population transition matrix and the second one is obtained by estimation from data (counting the transitions).</p> <p>My first idea was to use a Chi square test on each line of the two matrices. But I have an issue: some of the transitions might be null. When this happens the Chi square test does not work any more.</p> <p>If someone has an idea, it would be great. In addition, if you have some academic paper on the subject I would like to have the references.</p>
73,770
[ -0.055933065712451935, -0.009168867953121662, -0.03847215324640274, 0.0013829558156430721, 0.03916054964065552, 0.0018697200575843453, -0.0007282372680492699, -0.03357502818107605, 0.017144016921520233, -0.01588624157011509, 0.06141382455825806, 0.047704193741083145, 0.02202681079506874, 0.046380165964365005, 0.03204193338751793, 0.041102346032857895, -0.05614382028579712, -0.01946162059903145, -0.030997179448604584, -0.000033752752642612904, -0.00463871518149972, 0.010015509091317654, 0.06221901997923851, -0.01009066216647625, -0.04449642449617386, 0.03932838886976242, 0.02230047807097435, -0.027851376682519913, -0.005022827535867691, 0.04923883453011513, -0.08685677498579025, -0.041927583515644073, -0.0038952508475631475, 0.02187298983335495, 0.017208188772201538, -0.002774320775642991, -0.030200766399502754, -0.03965359553694725, -0.02480999194085598, 0.05020177364349365, -0.04150087386369705, -0.00010988912254106253, -0.006403899751603603, 0.021545374765992165, -0.0159655399620533, 0.01973717100918293, 0.0023554819636046886, -0.0026259836740791798, 0.012881766073405743, -0.04177189990878105, 0.09952602535486221, -0.00726366089656949, 0.02539658360183239, 0.021885400637984276, 0.011039786972105503, -0.015355493873357773, 0.016769906505942345, 0.058559171855449677, -0.006746499799191952, -0.07338909059762955, 0.000407571584219113, -0.05632790923118591, -0.0025388330686837435, -0.025049351155757904, -0.03548000380396843, 0.03372139856219292, 0.020229166373610497, -0.04088602960109711, 0.029159104451537132, -0.019610311836004257, -0.015108483843505383, 0.007999311201274395, 0.070452980697155, -0.018405145034193993, 0.029161125421524048, -0.04147616773843765, 0.023971624672412872, 0.06391577422618866, 0.030550606548786163, 0.037299785763025284, 0.013702376745641232, 0.030940158292651176, 0.017714228481054306, 0.03242551535367966, -0.0025661776307970285, -0.03435852751135826, 0.058299463242292404, -0.020910775288939476, 0.0025902702473104, 0.028286317363381386, -0.0014945784350857139, -0.018917445093393326, 0.06457758694887161, 0.048694510012865067, -0.06414564698934555, 0.023175397887825966, -0.01262626238167286, 0.07089465111494064, 0.0016695872182026505, -0.024334141984581947, -0.010186993516981602, -0.020117895677685738, 0.046783119440078735, 0.047966815531253815, 0.0032931342720985413, 0.0352158322930336, -0.02978232130408287, -0.0020635705441236496, -0.030573727563023567, -0.005206757690757513, -0.04541764035820961, 0.02549329400062561, 0.0030407041776925325, 0.05747832730412483, -0.02110237441956997, -0.007865015417337418, -0.03013519011437893, -0.04593552276492119, 0.06557653099298477, 0.07479244470596313, 0.02977164089679718, -0.00811693537980318, 0.007796118501573801, -0.0382201261818409, -0.04494490101933479, 0.027039971202611923, -0.024306556209921837, -0.010315784253180027, -0.06020190566778183, 0.06554191559553146, -0.03311249613761902, -0.01303710788488388, 0.031117567792534828, -0.04130745306611061, 0.04545475170016289, -0.008849355392158031, -0.10204125940799713, -0.026751581579446793, 0.014876699075102806, -0.012945763766765594, 0.009806293062865734, -0.06261902302503586, 0.01926596090197563, 0.033942487090826035, 0.06750491261482239, -0.007802597247064114, 0.023844406008720398, -0.021835515275597572, 0.013670253567397594, 0.008382879197597504, -0.02314293570816517, -0.0040056537836790085, -0.015682028606534004, -0.009476293809711933, 0.012970237992703915, -0.03481651097536087, 0.026279469951987267, 0.026325291022658348, -0.018425948917865753, 0.004283982329070568, 0.01398485153913498, 0.03701670467853546, 0.002971203066408634, 0.008090810850262642, 0.042983606457710266, -0.027087518945336342, 0.06840571016073227, 0.01142823975533247, 0.004156210925430059, -0.006430222187191248, 0.003566468134522438, 0.03971274569630623, -0.0009684101096354425, 0.04694197326898575, 0.05444318428635597, -0.04158670827746391, -0.019287437200546265, 0.026624003425240517, 0.01809185929596424, 0.005247923545539379, -0.050306536257267, -0.04052288457751274, -0.015281685627996922, -0.0029208736959844828, 0.0036859672982245684, 0.04241526499390602, -0.01985866203904152, 0.01749403215944767, 0.0700429156422615, -0.06704950332641602, -0.02211933769285679, -0.056012146174907684, 0.00679290946573019, 0.00987066887319088, -0.0290166474878788, 0.02004953660070896, 0.02597479335963726, 0.0038753689732402563, -0.016755666583776474, -0.042341604828834534, -0.038512006402015686, -0.02857900597155094, 0.00867071095854044, -0.020527394488453865, 0.004264598712325096, 0.050217777490615845, 0.020851822569966316, -0.051584623754024506, 0.047151461243629456, -0.04449208453297615, -0.021258454769849777, -0.0030405132565647364, -0.018951671198010445, 0.02550150267779827, 0.020729606971144676, -0.007204447872936726, 0.012854455970227718, 0.0037154925521463156, -0.0217352956533432, 0.03796248137950897, -0.03975389525294304, 0.043963488191366196, 0.020561840385198593, 0.010485466569662094, 0.014196525327861309, 0.0018592767883092165, 0.0035204708110541105, 0.0344105139374733, -0.01121109165251255, 0.006843841169029474, -0.04496102035045624, 0.009556961245834827, 0.02522932179272175, 0.009274872951209545, -0.043520573526620865, 0.012894582003355026, 0.022642984986305237, 0.0004116942873224616, -0.020494215190410614, 0.010138827376067638, -0.013461201451718807, -0.03529049828648567, 0.009687825106084347, 0.02615843527019024, -0.01916787028312683, 0.011741564609110355, 0.047769851982593536, -0.021510358899831772, 0.027759019285440445, -0.0033150422386825085, -0.03696233034133911, 0.02993033081293106, -0.03990306332707405, -0.007443911861628294, -0.0419563353061676, -0.05944201350212097, 0.03399655967950821, 0.0014632859965786338, 0.007056891452521086, 0.033185914158821106, -0.025668196380138397, -0.002893595490604639, -0.01276737917214632, -0.021502209827303886, 0.04124957695603371, -0.0005191921954974532, -0.033651914447546005, 0.0053161317482590675, 0.035507190972566605, -0.021914346143603325, 0.03705165535211563, -0.0022578465286642313, -0.02642568200826645, -0.03410816192626953, 0.008430471643805504, 0.03013686090707779, -0.019388297572731972, 0.04002517834305763, -0.025184012949466705, -0.04548797383904457, 0.021071290597319603, -0.029519634321331978, 0.023039240390062332, 0.02650114893913269, -0.022261179983615875, 0.0011103219585493207, -0.022060342133045197, -0.028430581092834473, 0.021386589854955673, -0.013851760886609554, 0.008614962920546532, 0.045369863510131836, -0.010654652491211891, -0.03373057022690773, -0.03326503559947014, -0.005833923351019621, -0.015139492228627205, 0.005560792982578278, 0.020659472793340683, 0.036151353269815445, 0.0010829090606421232, -0.06320086121559143, 0.044896211475133896, -0.061505138874053955, -0.028176680207252502, -0.034867823123931885, -0.0059365276247262955, 0.02858540043234825, -0.014910665340721607, 0.03874814137816429, 0.03155306354165077, -0.0075778476893901825, 0.015016843564808369, -0.06625808775424957, -0.03846735134720802, 0.030555598437786102, -0.02677484042942524, 0.05119207501411438, 0.01462287362664938, -0.01731971465051174, 0.05711833015084267, 0.032472509890794754, -0.007718108594417572, -0.053575292229652405, 0.012286525219678879, -0.053244903683662415, -0.02263142354786396, 0.030079973861575127, 0.029043400660157204, -0.01606842130422592, 0.030444646254181862, 0.02612338773906231, 0.03909560292959213, 0.05034862086176872, -0.01911177672445774, -0.016139743849635124, 0.004221520386636257, 0.006924845278263092, -0.02599451318383217, 0.02678452804684639, -0.04722411930561066, -0.01855657435953617, -0.006555155850946903, 0.008135538548231125, 0.016035743057727814, -0.0027219094336032867, -0.06324373930692673, 0.0001060706126736477, -0.03281797096133232, 0.007301341276615858, -0.028756745159626007, 0.03508990630507469, 0.028562743216753006, -0.014538461342453957, 0.011341598816215992, 0.07438015192747116, 0.032627128064632416, -0.008197040297091007, 0.0010929021518677473, 0.06374789774417877, 0.0017515061190351844, -0.00636897049844265, 0.029194539412856102, -0.0016106953844428062, -0.01489614974707365, 0.021811479702591896, -0.022694557905197144, -0.05239756405353546, 0.05267694592475891, 0.026290616020560265, 0.024319780990481377, -0.0017901489045470953, -0.0288857314735651, 0.000811606936622411, -0.0320892296731472, 0.013203541748225689, -0.020431790500879288, 0.053408876061439514, 0.01906786672770977, 0.023701442405581474, 0.025324610993266106, -0.0023074625059962273, 0.018758095800876617, -0.025592586025595665, -0.06651090085506439, 0.0023766434751451015, 0.009313056245446205, -0.033472027629613876, 0.028404397889971733, -0.0017267608782276511, 0.029404563829302788, -0.03769286721944809, 0.002364632673561573, 0.012148390524089336, 0.027830282226204872, -0.0732632726430893, 0.029944604262709618, -0.049451954662799835, -0.01989634893834591, 0.01352351251989603, -0.0036866459995508194, 0.020392458885908127, -0.004409389104694128, 0.029274333268404007, 0.021642860025167465, -0.018836630508303642, 0.0022186096757650375, -0.008860117755830288, 0.028481433168053627, 0.028511174023151398, 0.047005731612443924, 0.028902629390358925, 0.03478461503982544, -0.05159537121653557, 0.023279951885342598, 0.00659016240388155, 0.022497771307826042, 0.003237719414755702, 0.011570812202990055, 0.01724100112915039, -0.02489573135972023, 0.0025755681563168764, 0.008488946594297886, 0.015146216377615929, 0.03292226791381836, -0.016902266070246696, 0.022518057376146317, 0.047415781766176224, -0.0019135638140141964, 0.02700299397110939, 0.060043614357709885, 0.02416090853512287, 0.03675029054284096, -0.0014151239302009344, 0.0024140409659594297, -0.024171683937311172, -0.006662428379058838, -0.012020126916468143, 0.024425406008958817, 0.018523307517170906, 0.009203066118061543, 0.04040644317865372, -0.005626026075333357, -0.040567439049482346, -0.008617260493338108, 0.019246086478233337, 0.034355200827121735, -0.006230374798178673, -0.0351669117808342, 0.029950661584734917, 0.0294698104262352, 0.02004227414727211, 0.03492707386612892, 0.03128957003355026, -0.08708079904317856, 0.012122508138418198, 0.05719539523124695, -0.008518689312040806, -0.012648340314626694, -0.03485596925020218, -0.04739651456475258, -0.0234523992985487, 0.02026461437344551, 0.010117498226463795, 0.05744791775941849, 0.01164676807820797, 0.012079719454050064, -0.03581550344824791, 0.012783590704202652, 0.0074645839631557465, 0.042195845395326614, -0.0038104276172816753, 0.029779775068163872, -0.05034695193171501, -0.02934255450963974, -0.020055126398801804, -0.006079744081944227, 0.017948966473340988, 0.0772075355052948, -0.0019171576714143157, -0.0007036817260086536, 0.041003987193107605, 0.05542976036667824, -0.04685381054878235, -0.018497398123145103, 0.03574744239449501, 0.010363818146288395, -0.004916110076010227, 0.05719549581408501, -0.034191638231277466, -0.032286860048770905, -0.007716814987361431, -0.03422921523451805, -0.04973442479968071, -0.0049224356189370155, 0.007557784207165241, 0.007412445265799761, 0.013292619958519936, 0.017374521121382713, 0.04989128187298775, 0.048470932990312576, -0.005326072685420513, -0.0028786943294107914, -0.003109040204435587, 0.011979724280536175, -0.046693045645952225, -0.013274534605443478, -0.05642857402563095, 0.011429383419454098, -0.02412477508187294, 0.02816023863852024, -0.013437881134450436, 0.028239978477358818, -0.009782236069440842, 0.0345182865858078, 0.002851467812433839, 0.0194479301571846, -0.05626138299703598, -0.006699402816593647, 0.02602783404290676, 0.014745415188372135, -0.024011334404349327, -0.02170930989086628, 0.07282526046037674, -0.002587374299764633, -0.008803668431937695, -0.0071968017145991325, -0.046333517879247665, 0.02561076357960701, -0.050330135971307755, -0.029262445867061615, 0.011793977580964565, -0.016624143347144127, 0.031123854219913483, -0.022154420614242554, 0.03869388997554779, -0.010587052442133427, -0.026101958006620407, -0.015068435110151768, 0.03188397362828255, -0.036261409521102905, 0.02130274660885334, -0.037233393639326096, 0.03852083534002304, -0.02783232182264328, 0.021403800696134567, -0.05873328447341919, -0.033392660319805145, -0.00673667062073946, 0.008426093496382236, -0.021012114360928535, -0.050760574638843536, -0.0026767977979034185, 0.008309364318847656, -0.010327792726457119, -0.022757897153496742, 0.029983961954712868, -0.003085762495175004, 0.001844256417825818, 0.012988517060875893, -0.007049363572150469, 0.09863456338644028, 0.020518574863672256, -0.015376729890704155, 0.016291627660393715, -0.03193676844239235, 0.0014994513476267457, -0.00981222465634346, 0.010088810697197914, -0.0185267124325037, -0.0043536704033613205, -0.008337132632732391, 0.017183929681777954, 0.032866496592760086, -0.03699333220720291, -0.005447600968182087, 0.039495982229709625, 0.007388417609035969, 0.034874219447374344, -0.05010978877544403, -0.0049212477169930935, -0.042066700756549835, -0.024743547663092613, 0.009599911980330944, 0.004117957316339016, 0.0014299253234639764, -0.02683093026280403, 0.0281342975795269, -0.016604430973529816, -0.061340779066085815, -0.004421649035066366, 0.0854421928524971, 0.020079314708709717, -0.009792616590857506, 0.02514420635998249, 0.011331033892929554, 0.04144304618239403, -0.00020819151541218162, -0.006019057240337133, 0.015168114565312862, 0.024744335561990738, -0.03665925934910774, -0.02802019752562046, -0.024737920612096786, -0.0062730624340474606, 0.02789655141532421, -0.0018246284453198314, 0.01808062195777893, 0.026731157675385475, 0.022653663530945778, 0.006676868069916964, -0.002212815685197711, 0.000013684122677659616, 0.0068689691834151745, 0.0078994520008564, 0.024763362482190132, -0.02127690427005291, 0.010675719939172268, 0.0586337074637413, 0.033944323658943176, 0.0032116291113197803, 0.060232508927583694, 0.004008295014500618, 0.050254639238119125, 0.054538238793611526, -0.014070402830839157, -0.01306567620486021, 0.04278352111577988, -0.05402630567550659, 0.017853757366538048, -0.06993556767702103, 0.029684659093618393, 0.06137195602059364, 0.07040353864431381, 0.0021609640680253506, -0.0056739007122814655, -0.001099895453080535, -0.04582033306360245, 0.04997631162405014, 0.013553177937865257, -0.0074974107556045055, 0.010940762236714363, 0.03530985489487648, 0.05399599298834801, -0.006157146766781807, 0.008628230541944504, -0.030609585344791412, -0.05740402266383171, -0.0020673375111073256, -0.02410700172185898, -0.04647579789161682, 0.02322065271437168, 0.0025720095727592707, -0.023936811834573746, -0.009433973580598831, -0.01884513720870018, -0.01794666238129139, -0.04033412039279938, 0.031646087765693665, -0.028397448360919952, 0.008258831687271595, 0.006102427840232849, 0.008914759382605553, 0.0373021624982357, 0.01737879402935505, 0.08214781433343887, 0.052975937724113464, 0.04634644463658333, -0.065047986805439, 0.04355965927243233, -0.015340223908424377, 0.04135841503739357, -0.029740426689386368, 0.005585928913205862, 0.025444289669394493, -0.014227139763534069, 0.04223008453845978, 0.045514050871133804, 0.021802661940455437, -0.01771252416074276, 0.050324276089668274, -0.026156479492783546, -0.0201106034219265, 0.026706039905548096, 0.008133256807923317, -0.03442651405930519, -0.03272775560617447, -0.01754011958837509, 0.03807961940765381, 0.02493695728480816, -0.02094147726893425, -0.023368436843156815, 0.015092873945832253, 0.03733178973197937, -0.012610065750777721, -0.0010819315211847425, 0.010851661674678326, 0.023505954071879387, 0.029383527114987373, -0.021966949105262756, -0.018296489492058754, -0.035041894763708115, -0.007325677201151848, 0.026782415807247162, 0.06006675586104393, 0.0021175702568143606, -0.020612098276615143, 0.029200758785009384, 0.014155428856611252, -0.03644011542201042, -0.015558674931526184, -0.06096453592181206, 0.05526655912399292, -0.024213220924139023, -0.02079244703054428, -0.02238808013498783, 0.0013683746801689267, -0.004337094258517027, -0.038920529186725616, -0.025339802727103233, -0.016862578690052032, 0.024557234719395638, -0.010400798171758652, -0.0009157211752608418, -0.06899373978376389, 0.038925256580114365, -0.006981395650655031, 0.006217761430889368, 0.03659948706626892, -0.0589604489505291, -0.036562368273735046, 0.005562617909163237, 0.04851650074124336, -0.05680908262729645, -0.019708499312400818, 0.02300570346415043, -0.03210972994565964, -0.032946180552244186, -0.02702360413968563, 0.022645877674221992, 0.002214389154687524, 0.026173226535320282, 0.014681166037917137, -0.035819556564092636, 0.026393957436084747, -0.08035241812467575, 0.011441635899245739, 0.0031143014784902334, -0.01533425785601139, -0.0408831350505352, -0.027661437168717384, 0.07851499319076538, 0.015171194449067116, -0.017967885360121727, 0.04486175626516342, 0.00885405670851469, 0.024636253714561462, 0.0124239232391119, -0.0561768040060997, -0.0371578224003315, -0.0189985241740942, -0.028512731194496155, 0.008536322042346, -0.084502212703228, 0.02942218817770481, 0.005857204552739859, 0.0018282196251675487, -0.01569133624434471, 0.030929170548915863, -0.0037895217537879944, -0.00251687690615654, 0.02417929098010063, -0.027138415724039078, -0.024304572492837906, 0.01381039060652256, 0.023042364045977592, 0.003236282616853714, -0.021208172664046288, -0.05504028871655464, -0.009915634989738464, -0.0029617331456393003, -0.025974946096539497, -0.01936226338148117, -0.01663253642618656, -0.04242353141307831, -0.008464770391583443, -0.027724221348762512, 0.00930815190076828, -0.05683238431811333, 0.0028919302858412266, 0.02630782313644886, -0.03409514203667641, -0.048788659274578094, 0.0006083900225348771, -0.01832161471247673, 0.003630678867921233, 0.035377759486436844, 0.013437953777611256, -0.023769047111272812, 0.020031709223985672, -0.0016159855294972658, 0.028449485078454018, 0.052344247698783875, -0.015574540942907333, -0.0015694969333708286, 0.027887718752026558, -0.04698692634701729, -0.0058594089932739735, 0.014638234861195087, -0.026584269478917122, 0.03958859667181969, -0.01582244783639908, -0.027287401258945465, 0.010253516025841236, 0.05763845145702362, -0.014860655181109905, 0.0056723495945334435, -0.02880517952144146, -0.01974891498684883, -0.01818905584514141, 0.03715626150369644, -0.015412171371281147, -0.021478703245520592, -0.022157462313771248, 0.007990210317075253, 0.0713643878698349, -0.011923960410058498, -0.01822996884584427, -0.03135313466191292, -0.0002878391242120415, 0.02569447085261345, 0.026557769626379013, -0.027353016659617424, 0.03910258784890175, 0.06506315618753433, -0.0040327706374228, -0.030062232166528702, -0.0185772106051445, 0.019204959273338318, -0.07880299538373947, 0.021401626989245415, 0.020998528227210045, 0.008767640218138695, 0.007220980245620012, -0.049896277487277985, 0.042338840663433075, 0.04193452000617981, -0.035719335079193115, 0.004880491644144058, 0.024914393201470375, 0.00040947957313619554, -0.053181253373622894, -0.022193212062120438, -0.0035689454525709152, 0.028866132721304893, -0.01156680379062891, 0.00171872868668288, 0.022919096052646637, 0.036526333540678024, -0.04303008317947388, -0.033043909817934036, -0.01374991238117218, 0.016180966049432755, 0.003195963567122817, -0.042634621262550354, 0.02787186950445175, -0.038150664418935776, -0.04685576260089874, 0.03909958526492119, -0.019165365025401115, 0.07328983396291733, 0.02399824745953083, 0.030265850946307182, 0.0008078418904915452, 0.02659708820283413, 0.029176976531744003, -0.006626977119594812, -0.003492992836982012, -0.020420387387275696, -0.02759185992181301, 0.03293526545166969, -0.033725760877132416, 0.03199157118797302, 0.033578209578990936, -0.02610066905617714, -0.009941759519279003, -0.0019343458116054535, -0.02409060113132, -0.008976571261882782, -0.016279181465506554, -0.013287544250488281, 0.017049256712198257, 0.004245296586304903, 0.01944897323846817, -0.04420538246631622, 0.00858355313539505, 0.004023178480565548, 0.03887907415628433, -0.007943554781377316, 0.008218681439757347, -0.02466166764497757, -0.0310610830783844, 0.05196291208267212, -0.00060081243282184, -0.009255102835595608, -0.04360131919384003, -0.0473954975605011, -0.030352411791682243, 0.021485166624188423, -0.029198113828897476, -0.04124755039811134, -0.02768159657716751, 0.05497074872255325, -0.014876186847686768, -0.005838081706315279, 0.0069933426566421986, 0.008953159675002098, 0.029433351010084152, -0.05779452621936798, 0.03881729021668434, -0.004925685469061136, -0.005699814762920141, -0.014889142476022243, 0.02123991586267948, -0.06053316965699196, -0.015034557320177555, 0.04866374284029007, -0.01667672209441662, 0.024337487295269966, 0.0018763946136459708, 0.012501221150159836, 0.020931998267769814, -0.04663253575563431, 0.034060873091220856, -0.05976175516843796, -0.04189346730709076, -0.02722829394042492, -0.01908857934176922, 0.03159505873918533, 0.0050107743591070175, 0.00413188710808754, -0.008106919005513191, -0.01737363077700138, 0.03094349056482315, -0.036085162311792374, 0.023761766031384468, 0.025658316910266876, -0.01431288942694664, 0.02375594526529312, -0.03666794300079346, 0.031145408749580383, 0.008180190809071064, -0.0055251107551157475, -0.03598959743976593, 0.06707408279180527, -0.044991008937358856, -0.022960498929023743, -0.008038115687668324, -0.008223794400691986, -0.046082232147455215, -0.04425908997654915, 0.02765691839158535, 0.0039050427731126547, -0.0275197084993124, -0.007499999832361937, 0.012327569536864758, 0.05721430853009224, 0.02902895398437977, -0.024377141147851944, 0.043726298958063126, 0.01728132925927639, -0.004984152037650347, 0.026286054402589798, 0.01645420864224434, -0.014454285614192486, 0.010959298349916935, 0.016761906445026398, 0.020329229533672333, -0.03734839707612991, 0.013439290225505829, -0.01193881593644619, -0.014617168344557285, 0.011361665092408657, 0.0073127951472997665, 0.014892684295773506, -0.018658587709069252, -0.01078316755592823, 0.005680610425770283, -0.02944779582321644, 0.06384747475385666, -0.02486639842391014, 0.020670253783464432, -0.03591030836105347, -0.0023897800128906965, -0.035190001130104065, -0.01971084251999855, 0.005820603109896183, 0.005467922426760197, -0.003877167357131839, 0.056433070451021194, -0.0033276064787060022, -0.008631255477666855, 0.007915722206234932, -0.04290008544921875, 0.0011874533956870437, -0.02883068658411503, 0.0013992588501423597, -0.01234476175159216, 0.0032725264318287373, 0.0008701758342795074, -0.007615226320922375, 0.06941583007574081, 0.054125625640153885, 0.026916464790701866, -0.0343768373131752, -0.03990468010306358, 0.011128339916467667, 0.01864876225590706, -0.0382019504904747, -0.027344411239027977, -0.0514313168823719, 0.03199618309736252, -0.004086576867848635, 0.01245790347456932 ]
<p>EDIT 2: I originally thought I needed to run a two-factor ANOVA with repeated measures on one factor, but I now think a linear mixed-effect model will work better for my data. I think I nearly know what needs to happen, but am still confused by few points.</p> <p>The experiments I need to analyze look like this: </p> <ul> <li>Subjects were assigned to one of several treatment groups</li> <li>Measurements of each subject were taken on multiple days</li> <li>So: <ul> <li>Subject is nested within treatment</li> <li>Treatment is crossed with day</li> </ul></li> </ul> <p>(each subject is assigned to only one treatment, and measurements are taken on each subject on each day)</p> <p>My dataset contains the following information:</p> <ul> <li>Subject = blocking factor (random factor)</li> <li>Day = within subject or repeated measures factor (fixed factor)</li> <li>Treatment = between subject factor (fixed factor)</li> <li>Obs = measured (dependent) variable</li> </ul> <p><strong>UPDATE</strong> OK, so I went and talked to a statistician, but he's an SAS user. He thinks that the model should be:</p> <p><strong>Treatment + Day + Subject(Treatment) + Day*Subject(Treatment)</strong></p> <p>Obviously his notation is different from the R syntax, but this model is supposed to account for:</p> <ul> <li>Treatment (fixed)</li> <li>Day (fixed)</li> <li>the Treatment*Day interaction</li> <li>Subject nested within Treatment (random)</li> <li>Day crossed with "Subject within Treatment" (random)</li> </ul> <p>So, is this the correct syntax to use? </p> <pre><code>m4 &lt;- lmer(Obs~Treatment*Day + (1+Treatment/Subject) + (1+Day*Treatment/Subject), mydata) </code></pre> <p>I'm particularly concerned about whether the Day crossed with "Subject within Treatment" part is right. Is anyone familiar with SAS, or confident that they understand what's going on in his model, able to comment on whether my sad attempt at R syntax matches?</p> <p>Here are my previous attempts at building a model and writing syntax (discussed in answers &amp; comments):</p> <pre><code>m1 &lt;- lmer(Obs ~ Treatment * Day + (1 | Subject), mydata) </code></pre> <p>How do I deal with the fact that subject is nested within treatment? How does <code>m1</code> differ from: </p> <pre><code>m2 &lt;- lmer(Obs ~ Treatment * Day + (Treatment|Subject), mydata) m3 &lt;- lmer(Obs ~ Treatment * Day + (Treatment:Subject), mydata) </code></pre> <p>and are <code>m2</code> and <code>m3</code> equivalent (and if not, why)?</p> <p>Also, do I need to be using nlme instead of lme4 if I want to specify the correlation structure (like <code>correlation = corAR1</code>)? According to <a href="http://circ.ahajournals.org/content/117/9/1238.full" rel="nofollow">Repeated Measures</a>, for a repeated-measures analysis with repeated measures on one factor, the covariance structure (the nature of the correlations between measurements of the same subject) is important. </p> <p>When I was trying to do a repeated-measures ANOVA, I'd decided to use a Type II SS; is this still relevant, and if so, how do I go about specifying that?</p> <p>Here's an example of what the data look like:</p> <pre><code>mydata &lt;- data.frame( Subject = c(13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 62, 63, 64, 65, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 62, 63, 64, 65, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 62, 63, 64, 65), Day = c(rep(c("Day1", "Day3", "Day6"), each=28)), Treatment = c(rep(c("B", "A", "C", "B", "C", "A", "A", "B", "A", "C", "B", "C", "A", "A", "B", "A", "C", "B", "C", "A", "A"), each = 4)), Obs = c(6.472687, 7.017110, 6.200715, 6.613928, 6.829968, 7.387583, 7.367293, 8.018853, 7.527408, 6.746739, 7.296910, 6.983360, 6.816621, 6.571689, 5.911261, 6.954988, 7.624122, 7.669865, 7.676225, 7.263593, 7.704737, 7.328716, 7.295610, 5.964180, 6.880814, 6.926342, 6.926342, 7.562293, 6.677607, 7.023526, 6.441864, 7.020875, 7.478931, 7.495336, 7.427709, 7.633020, 7.382091, 7.359731, 7.285889, 7.496863, 6.632403, 6.171196, 6.306012, 7.253833, 7.594852, 6.915225, 7.220147, 7.298227, 7.573612, 7.366550, 7.560513, 7.289078, 7.287802, 7.155336, 7.394452, 7.465383, 6.976048, 7.222966, 6.584153, 7.013223, 7.569905, 7.459185, 7.504068, 7.801867, 7.598728, 7.475841, 7.511873, 7.518384, 6.618589, 5.854754, 6.125749, 6.962720, 7.540600, 7.379861, 7.344189, 7.362815, 7.805802, 7.764172, 7.789844, 7.616437, NA, NA, NA, NA)) </code></pre>
47,796
[ -0.04900908097624779, -0.020443148910999298, -0.025619428604841232, -0.006102755665779114, 0.063314288854599, 0.01918073371052742, 0.020470380783081055, -0.010293381288647652, 0.047080863267183304, -0.015510061755776405, 0.05710377171635628, 0.05004044622182846, 0.07896501570940018, -0.024371609091758728, 0.0006606925162486732, 0.010414231568574905, 0.012830073945224285, 0.0007798405713401735, -0.018303940072655678, 0.010871676728129387, -0.012305652722716331, 0.001977297943085432, -0.014661571942269802, -0.01216045767068863, -0.027309592813253403, 0.054887596517801285, 0.012278683483600616, -0.07506363093852997, 0.000256563100265339, 0.03517105057835579, -0.010282998904585838, -0.055975716561079025, 0.01780993863940239, -0.0183394905179739, 0.006564231123775244, 0.00017391152505297214, -0.0466560535132885, -0.014581847004592419, -0.0010955556062981486, 0.029429031535983086, -0.00402439758181572, 0.002030089031904936, -0.018279582262039185, 0.044580113142728806, -0.012081091292202473, 0.002680463483557105, 0.0026282116305083036, 0.03513254225254059, 0.0742010772228241, -0.03605218976736069, 0.05194955691695213, -0.04938368499279022, 0.036161068826913834, -0.003645619610324502, -0.04617740958929062, 0.003357531037181616, 0.07279516756534576, 0.035137150436639786, 0.05584489926695824, -0.05776367709040642, -0.04301214590668678, 0.00008929584146244451, 0.0008882481488399208, -0.006237592548131943, -0.00895216315984726, -0.03298647329211235, 0.007946999743580818, -0.026590285822749138, 0.02603047899901867, -0.006785077974200249, 0.025692811235785484, -0.005886663217097521, 0.05693046376109123, -0.0036141949240118265, 0.01638246513903141, -0.017287686467170715, 0.03895086795091629, -0.02515786699950695, 0.027070382609963417, -0.0111008919775486, -0.00671022105962038, 0.029749352484941483, -0.008519927971065044, 0.044634271413087845, 0.005888261832296848, -0.03615417331457138, 0.0503416508436203, 0.020717931911349297, 0.020379966124892235, 0.024116378277540207, -0.027488287538290024, 0.03267081454396248, 0.0570848174393177, 0.03867548704147339, -0.025179406628012657, 0.036798954010009766, 0.004158556926995516, 0.02428794838488102, -0.016025956720113754, 0.03401702642440796, -0.03151470422744751, -0.06373785436153412, -0.003480177838355303, 0.054980188608169556, -0.004190247505903244, -0.014423249289393425, 0.001832393230870366, -0.006360506173223257, 0.012732425704598427, -0.01693308725953102, -0.02453434094786644, 0.04160919412970543, 0.00809413567185402, -0.038344886153936386, 0.0007763387984596193, -0.0769074559211731, -0.02160237729549408, 0.008684285916388035, 0.06401675939559937, 0.05162975937128067, 0.041171517223119736, -0.033642400056123734, 0.026209477335214615, -0.03515496477484703, -0.025672361254692078, -0.023953285068273544, -0.003970655146986246, 0.015823887661099434, -0.05112622305750847, 0.08618022501468658, 0.041892241686582565, -0.0019387039355933666, 0.04924435913562775, -0.007225800771266222, 0.002215897897258401, -0.020559431985020638, -0.059826355427503586, -0.05973746255040169, 0.012429476715624332, -0.022146552801132202, 0.017278335988521576, -0.05661392584443092, -0.03081531450152397, -0.013753590174019337, 0.07905462384223938, 0.003511043731123209, 0.015118963085114956, 0.03392249345779419, 0.024453092366456985, 0.015311970375478268, -0.01328391581773758, 0.013311016373336315, -0.04655132070183754, -0.04666701331734657, -0.03459342569112778, -0.07575511187314987, 0.0343514047563076, -0.003729207906872034, -0.023019134998321533, 0.01726396568119526, 0.02793598361313343, 0.009821588173508644, 0.030361706390976906, 0.01544205378741026, 0.00010579114314168692, -0.007820713333785534, 0.041238266974687576, -0.019830847159028053, 0.057868678122758865, 0.04776136577129364, -0.01869339868426323, -0.0045350342988967896, -0.014719707891345024, 0.05554362013936043, 0.015605541877448559, -0.0389384925365448, -0.007114879786968231, -0.00023126322776079178, -0.016894998028874397, 0.05336233973503113, -0.04195113480091095, -0.024623101577162743, -0.08065350353717804, -0.024783913046121597, 0.026920363306999207, 0.05416199564933777, 0.006992155220359564, 0.021371031180024147, 0.02254815399646759, -0.028552750125527382, -0.029545877128839493, -0.05973558500409126, 0.009190100245177746, -0.006454613991081715, -0.03692184388637543, -0.017332112416625023, -0.026937583461403847, 0.024433836340904236, 0.02442699298262596, -0.023873180150985718, -0.04370281100273132, -0.01913297548890114, 0.055427245795726776, -0.006581571418792009, 0.013706183061003685, 0.005686725955456495, 0.04909462854266167, -0.024524040520191193, 0.018283575773239136, -0.03356916084885597, 0.009748397395014763, -0.0007125490810722113, -0.024181047454476357, -0.0024390271864831448, 0.016377605497837067, -0.0071456413716077805, 0.0034761542920023203, -0.0011947613675147295, -0.02299330197274685, 0.03388269990682602, -0.05508900806307793, 0.03263790160417557, 0.07725149393081665, 0.006677723024040461, 0.01947072520852089, 0.037867121398448944, 0.024413172155618668, 0.012861758470535278, -0.022699391469359398, -0.02231382578611374, -0.024195311591029167, -0.006338487844914198, 0.038995321840047836, -0.026033179834485054, -0.022323565557599068, 0.03010578453540802, 0.04330629110336304, 0.002795410342514515, 0.006270845886319876, 0.053432200103998184, 0.010977867990732193, -0.013979652896523476, 0.02010354958474636, 0.025712285190820694, 0.012912348844110966, 0.030567212030291557, 0.0024029375053942204, -0.03345206752419472, 0.03750154376029968, -0.0026014188770204782, 0.007113962899893522, 0.033245742321014404, 0.008703681640326977, 0.027562135830521584, -0.03295863792300224, -0.022949816659092903, 0.06495098769664764, -0.014222103171050549, 0.010218744166195393, 0.05989633500576019, 0.012230278924107552, -0.01052731741219759, -0.020501431077718735, -0.024682192131876945, 0.006387223489582539, 0.02647128701210022, -0.022719772532582283, -0.02242162823677063, 0.00646005105227232, -0.03473525494337082, 0.029205597937107086, -0.014479372650384903, 0.007841993123292923, -0.026309968903660774, 0.02415820211172104, -0.014931945130228996, 0.012775531969964504, -0.0043275863863527775, -0.03316891938447952, 0.009143207222223282, 0.012883265502750874, -0.01944229193031788, 0.04202481731772423, -0.023521045222878456, -0.05664714425802231, -0.008693164214491844, -0.02862674929201603, 0.004775386769324541, 0.04731975868344307, 0.003840627381578088, -0.0792851373553276, 0.042558539658784866, 0.010382228530943394, -0.04549313336610794, -0.04557231068611145, -0.017937354743480682, 0.018015936017036438, -0.030066147446632385, -0.012967073358595371, 0.05025015398859978, 0.05022857338190079, -0.02048109844326973, -0.022088780999183655, -0.03049166314303875, 0.024140983819961548, 0.011053561232984066, -0.017139293253421783, 0.013089430518448353, 0.025705818086862564, -0.0016431116964668036, 0.03362419828772545, 0.02860848605632782, -0.033825065940618515, -0.07674979418516159, -0.05137920379638672, -0.00007743209425825626, 0.025446699932217598, 0.00973934680223465, 0.00012956697901245207, 0.012079296633601189, 0.09380071610212326, 0.01941760815680027, -0.01997803896665573, -0.06030125543475151, -0.0004007978714071214, -0.028699427843093872, -0.025971533730626106, 0.03585084527730942, -0.006997954566031694, -0.007574852090328932, 0.02901296690106392, -0.006743337027728558, -0.009275577031075954, 0.03561759367585182, 0.06009283661842346, -0.0054550073109567165, 0.019588161259889603, 0.0077773816883563995, -0.030238598585128784, 0.044468458741903305, 0.02528952807188034, -0.010387742891907692, 0.007382477633655071, -0.010908073745667934, -0.009250503964722157, -0.0019102046499028802, -0.03481825813651085, 0.013675025664269924, -0.032959599047899246, 0.007114286534488201, -0.012817992828786373, -0.0010976074263453484, 0.020404616370797157, -0.03977392241358757, -0.018298620358109474, 0.02548203431069851, 0.0346570760011673, 0.004073835909366608, 0.011050446890294552, 0.053843915462493896, 0.05577091500163078, -0.008885793387889862, -0.006779613438993692, -0.02853303775191307, -0.009301763027906418, 0.004829820245504379, -0.038796380162239075, 0.011924742721021175, 0.004808461293578148, 0.03689267113804817, 0.009202837944030762, 0.001629662117920816, -0.04653071612119675, -0.005513304844498634, -0.05510503053665161, 0.017693083733320236, -0.03720450773835182, 0.04964115098118782, 0.003026481717824936, 0.03345785290002823, 0.01488201692700386, -0.0534021332859993, -0.002763911383226514, -0.025616219267249107, -0.029036885127425194, 0.01247148122638464, 0.04728425666689873, -0.01550629734992981, 0.02715562842786312, -0.029554687440395355, -0.011445402167737484, 0.007076028268784285, -0.0009152156999334693, 0.009285989217460155, 0.025650130584836006, 0.0064548831433057785, -0.03791610151529312, 0.0006995684234425426, -0.02064414508640766, -0.03722963109612465, -0.0018151071853935719, 0.03586387261748314, -0.013185780495405197, -0.015654515475034714, 0.04770034924149513, 0.014489199966192245, 0.00012095709098502994, -0.04876256734132767, -0.03518429398536682, 0.03173203021287918, 0.06021110713481903, -0.02626560628414154, 0.03250006586313248, -0.0171489454805851, 0.04479345679283142, 0.011810590513050556, 0.019298138096928596, 0.02810203656554222, 0.018769992515444756, -0.00846383348107338, -0.013265085406601429, -0.01344370935112238, 0.037524305284023285, -0.0036048481706529856, -0.009260794147849083, 0.003825357649475336, 0.047749731689691544, 0.03011494316160679, -0.04355071112513542, -0.013609222136437893, 0.07548201084136963, 0.00960457045584917, 0.007101797964423895, -0.022415772080421448, 0.008977115154266357, -0.002915367018431425, 0.012038839980959892, 0.03488926589488983, -0.0036332672461867332, 0.02189544029533863, 0.003703706432133913, 0.02317054010927677, 0.006087580695748329, -0.007026200648397207, 0.04701249673962593, -0.0153213981539011, 0.007305126637220383, 0.025819802656769753, -0.024934101849794388, -0.016116170212626457, 0.05897532403469086, 0.04590557515621185, 0.014716842211782932, 0.010596762411296368, -0.10711509734392166, -0.006192035507410765, 0.031673941761255264, 0.05621436983346939, -0.015052988193929195, 0.011254526674747467, 0.008359170518815517, -0.01062430813908577, -0.012912648729979992, -0.02307705767452717, 0.054599225521087646, -0.029282236471772194, 0.015566492453217506, -0.01179246325045824, -0.0522344671189785, -0.055699314922094345, 0.006879312451928854, -0.022900573909282684, 0.014341895468533039, 0.03925450146198273, -0.01898333802819252, -0.030285779386758804, -0.005458304192870855, 0.006885038688778877, 0.02141094021499157, -0.039768971502780914, -0.03270969167351723, 0.04880343750119209, 0.032386064529418945, -0.0405278205871582, -0.017430255189538002, 0.02749229595065117, 0.014554393477737904, -0.027517208829522133, 0.057966988533735275, -0.013713452033698559, -0.0005062033305875957, -0.014855783432722092, 0.03226471692323685, 0.007204718887805939, -0.0037771672941744328, -0.012673847377300262, 0.028561735525727272, -0.002050373936071992, -0.02965899184346199, 0.06991460919380188, 0.03418327495455742, 0.01584942825138569, 0.012339313514530659, -0.02973850630223751, 0.03496570512652397, -0.00021813716739416122, -0.03535068780183792, -0.060858383774757385, -0.003005098784342408, -0.017877548933029175, 0.013658947311341763, -0.00983833521604538, 0.03474392741918564, -0.047835905104875565, -0.03557940945029259, 0.027907008305191994, -0.00423898920416832, -0.01318386197090149, -0.012372612953186035, -0.0023685696069151163, -0.022469691932201385, -0.0005017018411308527, -0.03056516870856285, 0.006117498502135277, -0.05984732136130333, -0.007699633948504925, -0.0008652518154121935, -0.009592638351023197, -0.02425719052553177, -0.012018087320029736, -0.04505454748868942, 0.00012159479229012504, -0.020117104053497314, -0.002222551731392741, -0.01164153404533863, 0.006652302108705044, -0.03044353798031807, -0.04102444648742676, 0.00420129531994462, 0.06129505857825279, -0.003010891145095229, -0.011324865743517876, 0.0030841052066534758, 0.02122657746076584, -0.04256895184516907, -0.007870624773204327, -0.059664536267519, -0.06669707596302032, 0.04605862870812416, 0.0021062635350972414, 0.007311453111469746, -0.01683668978512287, -0.03065147064626217, -0.0266104843467474, -0.008991803042590618, -0.032529693096876144, 0.024934472516179085, -0.05374680459499359, 0.024303976446390152, 0.0011882815742865205, 0.03982565924525261, 0.04548513889312744, 0.023984286934137344, -0.0019386844942346215, -0.0014325098600238562, 0.007644317112863064, -0.0438673309981823, -0.006296960636973381, -0.043570250272750854, -0.037533003836870193, -0.008666015230119228, -0.052536290138959885, 0.04100928083062172, 0.06439639627933502, 0.006129217799752951, -0.001971632707864046, 0.03248061239719391, -0.013720568269491196, 0.003859797026962042, -0.04912895709276199, -0.018956156447529793, -0.020080002024769783, 0.012108263559639454, -0.014630249701440334, 0.02974862791597843, -0.028349095955491066, -0.00569087453186512, 0.0016764329047873616, -0.041900813579559326, -0.004359023179858923, 0.01626013033092022, 0.06386671215295792, 0.007668673526495695, 0.013673877343535423, 0.0010836768196895719, 0.007281630765646696, 0.02276494726538658, 0.0005541231366805732, 0.004209853243082762, 0.012272704392671585, 0.024473490193486214, -0.021919196471571922, -0.007640252821147442, -0.031147776171565056, 0.0099269924685359, 0.050169866532087326, 0.006127366330474615, 0.017214404419064522, 0.06398839503526688, -0.03519413247704506, 0.011453939601778984, -0.03519307076931, 0.010456535965204239, 0.0024458018597215414, 0.009591568261384964, 0.09601451456546783, 0.007170879747718573, -0.02258916199207306, 0.01718810386955738, 0.037367794662714005, 0.013328147120773792, 0.04418998211622238, 0.023557720705866814, -0.006809668615460396, 0.00412558251991868, -0.005885199178010225, -0.057515766471624374, 0.019378527998924255, -0.053865980356931686, 0.012786169536411762, -0.03985525667667389, -0.026448260992765427, 0.01460735872387886, 0.06300963461399078, -0.008034334518015385, -0.05412837862968445, -0.009896657429635525, -0.05229731276631355, 0.012831681407988071, 0.03577438369393349, -0.04561857134103775, 0.01140754483640194, 0.002362930215895176, 0.06338303536176682, -0.005610853899270296, 0.021724451333284378, -0.0474296510219574, -0.07698411494493484, -0.040995705872774124, -0.013825762085616589, -0.029401803389191628, 0.04741450771689415, -0.01774740032851696, -0.006646020337939262, 0.004269517492502928, -0.05949363484978676, -0.005979626905173063, 0.014025699347257614, 0.061374127864837646, 0.015252556651830673, 0.04726026579737663, -0.003963167313486338, 0.002444242825731635, -0.02631593868136406, 0.015122740529477596, 0.15209569036960602, 0.0813593938946724, 0.02756475657224655, -0.07114586979150772, 0.04339830204844475, 0.01459343358874321, 0.022244777530431747, -0.019904611632227898, 0.0036340178921818733, -0.0010509525891393423, -0.015516962856054306, 0.04697426036000252, 0.06072882190346718, 0.030294453725218773, 0.004431850276887417, 0.03324848785996437, -0.023834379389882088, -0.03261241316795349, 0.023253673687577248, -0.013355170376598835, -0.005050260107964277, -0.0217181034386158, -0.027804819867014885, 0.0119882021099329, 0.0015638824552297592, -0.02911468781530857, -0.009491834789514542, 0.007874681614339352, -0.00144676782656461, 0.02455674670636654, -0.018691306933760643, 0.016860075294971466, -0.003282712073996663, -0.008431796915829182, 0.025685356929898262, -0.020803693681955338, 0.04222099855542183, -0.015505573712289333, 0.01299137994647026, 0.05079996958374977, 0.0014383295783773065, -0.011872551403939724, 0.010068449191749096, 0.023696037009358406, -0.02853863127529621, -0.05280052870512009, -0.01599535532295704, 0.051886361092329025, -0.024757705628871918, -0.029281258583068848, 0.014560696668922901, 0.012913104146718979, 0.03125961869955063, -0.034883975982666016, -0.004548397846519947, 0.02526143752038479, 0.02742142789065838, -0.004722428973764181, 0.0035873656161129475, -0.031977493315935135, 0.01656290329992771, -0.011091841384768486, -0.0010542456293478608, 0.02109762653708458, -0.02301088720560074, -0.0021189723629504442, -0.05397745594382286, 0.026903687044978142, -0.004964980762451887, 0.022320576012134552, -0.0023515012580901384, -0.00775065878406167, -0.010134401731193066, -0.021678533405065536, 0.015811579301953316, 0.015502351336181164, 0.025947732850909233, -0.019213296473026276, 0.006246588192880154, -0.03691689670085907, -0.028477806597948074, -0.0007959468639455736, -0.006210201419889927, -0.018634676933288574, -0.024619191884994507, 0.007000672165304422, 0.00877766590565443, 0.03722558170557022, -0.007637660484761, -0.014430639334022999, -0.020503606647253036, 0.04982505738735199, 0.00967599917203188, -0.0729614719748497, -0.01691311039030552, 0.01837163046002388, 0.02276744693517685, -0.011735387146472931, -0.022212043404579163, 0.03093886375427246, 0.034356627613306046, 0.016411876305937767, -0.03369806334376335, 0.04513758793473244, -0.01795940473675728, -0.018293514847755432, 0.05423149839043617, -0.07772085815668106, 0.0015002420404925942, -0.01632111333310604, -0.004740365780889988, -0.0026463307440280914, -0.0446501299738884, -0.03252972289919853, -0.03688826039433479, -0.022335289046168327, -0.01761464588344097, -0.021278413012623787, -0.009379316121339798, -0.03394750505685806, 0.0052029103972017765, -0.01217980682849884, 0.009348250925540924, -0.03195444121956825, -0.016359416767954826, 0.017300443723797798, -0.0045579057186841965, 0.009411859326064587, 0.015671638771891594, 0.008076095022261143, 0.02237984724342823, 0.026414312422275543, 0.0122518390417099, 0.014492451213300228, 0.0020891183521598577, -0.0032571363262832165, 0.011026892811059952, 0.04563608020544052, 0.02784164808690548, -0.012001082301139832, 0.015090161003172398, -0.05687645077705383, 0.0000014339044582811766, -0.012346196919679642, 0.01506824977695942, 0.021998461335897446, 0.01573597826063633, -0.004821871407330036, -0.02235722541809082, 0.042046934366226196, -0.03916963189840317, -0.06370154768228531, -0.01656980812549591, -0.017229605466127396, 0.019390273839235306, 0.001861481461673975, 0.023236390203237534, 0.04324903339147568, -0.03792070597410202, 0.04033590108156204, 0.01722967065870762, 0.01994490437209606, -0.003509208559989929, -0.007763077970594168, -0.035309262573719025, 0.0321032851934433, 0.006158818956464529, -0.0016104457899928093, 0.03287286311388016, 0.04712972417473793, -0.017856130376458168, 0.026976168155670166, -0.018135618418455124, 0.011707933619618416, -0.08256117254495621, -0.03324056789278984, 0.0011224026093259454, 0.006374089978635311, 0.021352751180529594, -0.03143179416656494, 0.00023458083160221577, 0.0053063491359353065, -0.03339030221104622, -0.03052693046629429, -0.0014018035726621747, 0.006555456668138504, -0.005130518693476915, 0.006031577475368977, -0.05219497159123421, 0.008715027943253517, 0.009548923932015896, -0.008567159064114094, 0.04115745797753334, 0.05356743186712265, 0.034506656229496, -0.03233891725540161, 0.03493985906243324, 0.027116423472762108, 0.07173295319080353, -0.05288548767566681, 0.006161730736494064, -0.004360098857432604, -0.011511065997183323, 0.009004950523376465, -0.03506457805633545, 0.027125347405672073, 0.02352132834494114, 0.028958071023225784, 0.013460207730531693, 0.05788097530603409, -0.0070696501061320305, 0.014206153340637684, 0.0222617220133543, 0.007986498065292835, 0.012435561046004295, 0.015760991722345352, -0.01000903733074665, -0.0062904660589993, 0.06474810093641281, -0.029307780787348747, -0.0442538820207119, 0.028642235323786736, -0.022354811429977417, -0.01560827437788248, -0.035936467349529266, -0.03782635182142258, 0.020134413614869118, -0.05982170253992081, -0.01827431470155716, -0.01000193040817976, 0.03691665828227997, 0.060096170753240585, 0.007537603843957186, -0.03381248190999031, 0.009088031016290188, 0.0004343627952039242, -0.014475592412054539, 0.02828512154519558, 0.004864543676376343, -0.025293469429016113, -0.07636383920907974, -0.04263442009687424, -0.014867059886455536, -0.03871063515543938, -0.023203615099191666, 0.03689556568861008, -0.036568447947502136, 0.014487302862107754, -0.04162374138832092, -0.004708997905254364, -0.010049553588032722, -0.01786048710346222, 0.02685231901705265, -0.10962717235088348, 0.06497272104024887, 0.010802051052451134, -0.0008637825376354158, -0.09358273446559906, -0.00695547740906477, -0.008477272465825081, 0.019998637959361076, 0.043634433299303055, 0.025087878108024597, -0.010311688296496868, -0.0037715525832027197, 0.054209351539611816, -0.018480604514479637, -0.03743293508887291, 0.050734732300043106, 0.01934981159865856, 0.0371827632188797, -0.03828830644488335, -0.01755478046834469, -0.027063116431236267, 0.005156899336725473, -0.009643924422562122, -0.02272694557905197, 0.03009238839149475, -0.01767857000231743, -0.027146555483341217, -0.002642190782353282, 0.0033008551690727472, -0.05969536304473877, 0.03969813510775566, 0.03073565661907196, -0.012615028768777847, 0.058319345116615295, -0.026176627725362778, -0.026522696018218994, 0.013684779405593872, -0.052186187356710434, 0.004697349853813648, 0.017813345417380333, 0.011911546811461449, -0.013495982624590397, -0.04329195246100426, 0.01803486794233322, 0.007910039275884628, -0.03039535880088806, -0.018575727939605713, 0.03041950799524784, 0.04433368518948555, 0.045822832733392715, -0.015349763445556164, 0.030494041740894318, -0.0034303918946534395, -0.002134398790076375, 0.01130527351051569, 0.02985481172800064, 0.022181954234838486, -0.022375719621777534, -0.02306930534541607, 0.03771514073014259, -0.00857621617615223, 0.02122274599969387, -0.030336549505591393, 0.04504077881574631, 0.016057603061199188, 0.0070916758850216866, 0.0014648643555119634, -0.005095928907394409, 0.02696842886507511, 0.001724632689729333, 0.004737501963973045, 0.037455592304468155, -0.06099594384431839, 0.014392537996172905, -0.016394976526498795, -0.0038108460139483213, 0.009250708855688572, 0.022716226056218147, 0.05997143313288689, 0.0513293594121933, -0.00030598894227296114, -0.004317621234804392, -0.0234622023999691, -0.034465521574020386, 0.011417253874242306, 0.00029134497162885964, -0.0007469091797247529, -0.014961512759327888, 0.003535526106134057, -0.01906650885939598, -0.04186297953128815, -0.02005808614194393, -0.04273417219519615, 0.03905806690454483, 0.01345295924693346, 0.0004318031424190849, -0.03830607607960701, -0.013033339753746986, 0.0365387462079525, 0.05709204822778702, -0.07888583093881607, 0.008547944016754627, -0.04113654047250748, 0.01748059317469597, -0.0018715850310400128, 0.03148900344967842 ]
<p>I am looking to generate 450 data points in R. There are three distinct sets 150 of each distributed in a circular band with different radii (at 1, 2.8 and 5).</p> <p>In particular, I'm looking to reproduce the first graph on p546 of The Elements of Statistical Learning. <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/rMILV.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>I would be very grateful for some assistance in the R code that could generate this data.</p> <p>Thanks!</p>
73,771
[ -0.04552014172077179, -0.05249511078000069, 0.00990795437246561, -0.004894424695521593, 0.014879045076668262, -0.024631036445498466, -0.022708263248205185, -0.04165860638022423, 0.03373551368713379, -0.04207686334848404, 0.038217030465602875, 0.025877680629491806, 0.04135856777429581, 0.07486927509307861, -0.016645213589072227, 0.01694360002875328, -0.012755317613482475, 0.02859259583055973, -0.019004128873348236, -0.05309339612722397, -0.0003423384914640337, -0.00041341764153912663, -0.014526869170367718, -0.035088952630758286, -0.045979056507349014, 0.03529244288802147, 0.03676968067884445, -0.008038779720664024, -0.009981007315218449, 0.08940840512514114, -0.08191274106502533, -0.03393060714006424, 0.031836915761232376, 0.02208976075053215, 0.05203265696763992, 0.0061844633892178535, -0.043780405074357986, -0.02256135269999504, -0.016604358330368996, 0.007391942664980888, -0.02354859560728073, 0.04819253832101822, 0.01769447885453701, 0.04504576325416565, -0.006629300769418478, 0.014871520921587944, -0.0308390986174345, -0.026236310601234436, 0.026253698393702507, -0.017677579075098038, 0.10438665747642517, -0.013048969209194183, 0.03292609751224518, -0.008006342686712742, -0.01201720628887415, -0.005913435481488705, 0.03400617092847824, 0.03373256325721741, -0.0028811621014028788, -0.04134414717555046, 0.027034660801291466, -0.021241847425699234, 0.003018417861312628, 0.037115104496479034, -0.054702047258615494, 0.010231208987534046, 0.0011572869261726737, 0.0007370281382463872, 0.03713420033454895, -0.004286555107682943, 0.04212715104222298, 0.05905355140566826, 0.05461552366614342, -0.03304344788193703, 0.013021876104176044, 0.014735152944922447, 0.02204219251871109, -0.03449481353163719, 0.05155264586210251, 0.01548864133656025, 0.006030792370438576, 0.007438181899487972, 0.0014984995359554887, 0.00704572070389986, 0.02718692272901535, -0.0072000655345618725, 0.054997518658638, -0.021301452070474625, 0.010861664079129696, 0.027938416227698326, -0.005966855213046074, 0.00021298445062711835, 0.06550225615501404, -0.002196423476561904, -0.027648506686091423, 0.035274405032396317, -0.010516460053622723, 0.02982534095644951, -0.010261564515531063, 0.020334886386990547, 0.024839254096150398, -0.04690256342291832, 0.006441560573875904, 0.06289352476596832, -0.017872562631964684, -0.027423888444900513, -0.013572636060416698, 0.0018999900203198195, -0.023567114025354385, -0.00007295329123735428, -0.00716834980994463, 0.037936750799417496, 0.02172670140862465, 0.010602264665067196, 0.026775380596518517, -0.003379235742613673, -0.04284122586250305, 0.01011362299323082, 0.031956542283296585, 0.02204093523323536, 0.027943698689341545, -0.035674143582582474, 0.04103924706578255, -0.043335188180208206, -0.017246989533305168, 0.024299418553709984, -0.00857353676110506, -0.015348739922046661, -0.034628111869096756, 0.051589127629995346, -0.042876794934272766, -0.059988781809806824, 0.04849644750356674, -0.021336765959858894, 0.0027350489981472492, -0.01568537764251232, -0.10739055275917053, -0.04836694151163101, 0.03525949642062187, -0.04543646425008774, 0.009771850891411304, -0.02350807748734951, 0.034134577959775925, 0.041692860424518585, 0.008344614878296852, -0.004085201770067215, 0.04141341522336006, 0.006276528816670179, 0.05083593726158142, 0.020774442702531815, -0.04055444523692131, 0.00580716785043478, -0.04504479840397835, -0.023295847699046135, -0.05228696018457413, -0.06774317473173141, 0.017970191314816475, 0.032972779124975204, -0.012780276127159595, -0.035701293498277664, 0.009138723835349083, -0.020404769107699394, 0.009628601372241974, -0.010249235667288303, -0.0009831837378442287, 0.006402036175131798, 0.06258006393909454, 0.02605360746383667, -0.008509616367518902, 0.02781379409134388, -0.05429644137620926, 0.009401165880262852, 0.002665589563548565, 0.029080616310238838, 0.043290212750434875, -0.015492690727114677, 0.03387736901640892, 0.004103372804820538, 0.021105390042066574, 0.04768609255552292, -0.0420018695294857, -0.012396249920129776, 0.012161911465227604, -0.018076235428452492, 0.025804031640291214, 0.06407319009304047, -0.005323827266693115, -0.04609297215938568, 0.04487333446741104, -0.04834034666419029, 0.01399126835167408, -0.03764532133936882, -0.033524613827466965, -0.005725123919546604, -0.03394288942217827, -0.003282108809798956, 0.05133235827088356, 0.050528984516859055, 0.0105777308344841, -0.02495112083852291, -0.019442779943346977, -0.00804341584444046, 0.06312213838100433, 0.006955401040613651, -0.013458211906254292, 0.05702665448188782, 0.04327768087387085, -0.013621295802295208, 0.00043918154551647604, -0.018877573311328888, -0.029926009476184845, -0.0017706837970763445, -0.04620653763413429, 0.012851133942604065, -0.024275651201605797, 0.009237375110387802, -0.03381387144327164, 0.0253143273293972, -0.00428001768887043, 0.025268718600273132, -0.04088686406612396, 0.057313963770866394, 0.04931963235139847, 0.005243795458227396, -0.018554333597421646, -0.01319792028516531, 0.020391132682561874, 0.038314156234264374, -0.036664679646492004, -0.029762117192149162, -0.07661090046167374, -0.025398962199687958, 0.0334901325404644, 0.015042060054838657, -0.021548928692936897, -0.002173095475882292, 0.058112576603889465, 0.0042367130517959595, 0.024528997018933296, 0.05932271480560303, -0.0034729656763374805, 0.016214612871408463, 0.04247162863612175, 0.022053735330700874, 0.06593625247478485, -0.034785665571689606, 0.00027081527514383197, 0.02607565186917782, 0.038859836757183075, 0.01121891662478447, -0.0031111438293009996, 0.021565992385149002, 0.0028557763434946537, -0.009406317956745625, -0.023676631972193718, 0.0025102507788687944, 0.048105571419000626, -0.011400957591831684, -0.07600271701812744, 0.05719750002026558, -0.005411655176430941, -0.025056546553969383, -0.01759166270494461, 0.004245164804160595, 0.027658481150865555, 0.07288434356451035, 0.0006218099151737988, -0.011618735268712044, 0.01270157191902399, -0.03529881685972214, 0.004411378875374794, -0.014652788639068604, -0.005022096913307905, -0.03035878762602806, 0.044165950268507004, -0.0023301246110349894, -0.007143296767026186, 0.012866944074630737, -0.04570925980806351, -0.02355687879025936, 0.014524303376674652, 0.001837700023315847, 0.024418428540229797, 0.024526041001081467, -0.033009663224220276, -0.010868214070796967, -0.0022913345601409674, 0.014171183109283447, 0.011730552650988102, -0.01698118820786476, -0.0698084756731987, 0.022097894921898842, -0.031100772321224213, -0.04544980823993683, -0.0359501913189888, -0.02722444385290146, 0.02953275665640831, -0.014874431304633617, 0.014641856774687767, 0.04714691638946533, 0.025427527725696564, -0.015447837300598621, 0.041223715990781784, -0.053807247430086136, 0.015964530408382416, -0.009790698997676373, 0.023593207821249962, 0.012872148305177689, -0.012091660872101784, -0.022044887766242027, 0.026748737320303917, 0.026342494413256645, 0.006077253725379705, -0.061200179159641266, -0.027655161917209625, 0.0007934886962175369, 0.01042081881314516, 0.031038867309689522, 0.01810326613485813, 0.003222007304430008, 0.08854404091835022, 0.04167719930410385, -0.053925175219774246, -0.022641854360699654, -0.028309175744652748, -0.0019594235345721245, -0.02715076319873333, 0.06172042712569237, -0.019392430782318115, -0.011892505921423435, -0.011047051288187504, -0.0077591282315552235, 0.008628531359136105, 0.08652415871620178, -0.029346343129873276, -0.00981622189283371, 0.05209508538246155, -0.022929096594452858, -0.0197109617292881, 0.039249539375305176, 0.03429454192519188, -0.03469406068325043, 0.015573582611978054, 0.009704336524009705, 0.017106181010603905, 0.008247919380664825, -0.09107209742069244, -0.011460057459771633, -0.015831761062145233, 0.021517522633075714, -0.005352053325623274, 0.022525489330291748, 0.034341346472501755, -0.027398593723773956, 0.017433717846870422, 0.03682028129696846, 0.061283472925424576, -0.004665060434490442, -0.038613516837358475, 0.015809543430805206, 0.04906683787703514, 0.018053879961371422, 0.014743507839739323, -0.00487429229542613, 0.009002435952425003, 0.021225566044449806, -0.024522826075553894, -0.01025635190308094, 0.008958986960351467, 0.02751942351460457, 0.011742726899683475, 0.028647733852267265, -0.01754515804350376, 0.04491504281759262, -0.03016597032546997, 0.025311725214123726, -0.05103957653045654, 0.044618453830480576, 0.011232804507017136, 0.0374239981174469, -0.011728744022548199, -0.015157032757997513, 0.0070897601544857025, -0.016340332105755806, -0.04694441333413124, 0.022583741694688797, 0.030676869675517082, 0.0341145358979702, 0.02512034773826599, -0.003191978670656681, 0.033635467290878296, -0.016958070918917656, 0.028197921812534332, 0.025702204555273056, 0.00995640829205513, -0.026037998497486115, -0.016438031569123268, -0.021857071667909622, 0.009867052547633648, -0.0238941702991724, 0.033640578389167786, 0.017630968242883682, -0.025837259367108345, 0.06620614975690842, 0.020296331495046616, -0.00979533139616251, 0.01095488015562296, -0.010454860515892506, 0.008732082322239876, -0.01807773858308792, 0.03404626622796059, 0.04235446825623512, -0.003216538345441222, -0.02490825019776821, -0.009697605855762959, -0.04390428960323334, 0.012075374834239483, 0.06216701865196228, 0.01503761950880289, -0.0055571869015693665, -0.03894485905766487, 0.012226794846355915, 0.017037196084856987, 0.03157863765954971, -0.019924713298678398, 0.0054412647150456905, 0.04818490520119667, 0.005192712880671024, -0.05062982439994812, 0.024352973327040672, 0.04214183986186981, -0.013990282081067562, 0.008235463872551918, -0.03828004002571106, -0.022967223078012466, -0.0037987136747688055, -0.025811199098825455, 0.06356155872344971, 0.025010162964463234, -0.005590919870883226, 0.015350035391747952, 0.031137945130467415, 0.026414839550852776, -0.03303353860974312, 0.03444279357790947, -0.0026168362237513065, 0.04535135254263878, -0.05104265362024307, -0.03207962214946747, 0.009073140099644661, 0.013586451299488544, 0.04251972585916519, 0.00233344710431993, -0.03219705820083618, -0.06764017045497894, 0.015343477949500084, 0.0495125837624073, 0.004852666053920984, -0.018185537308454514, -0.00282084196805954, -0.07909448444843292, -0.022031521424651146, 0.03533655032515526, -0.02281000092625618, -0.002159101888537407, -0.029726874083280563, 0.012492220848798752, -0.015957122668623924, -0.05933535844087601, -0.020364532247185707, -0.005035978741943836, -0.04928877204656601, 0.024525387212634087, -0.027671748772263527, -0.032048922032117844, 0.002207901095971465, 0.01739385724067688, 0.013209681957960129, 0.061130374670028687, -0.0031542947981506586, -0.007357608061283827, 0.04092127084732056, 0.029981261119246483, -0.004153973422944546, -0.014088248834013939, 0.009051121771335602, 0.008847082033753395, 0.02222590148448944, 0.04646430164575577, -0.020643938332796097, -0.003950546029955149, 0.03517923131585121, 0.03466549143195152, 0.00833863765001297, -0.014400622807443142, -0.03745574876666069, 0.035525307059288025, 0.02534552291035652, 0.011851698160171509, 0.05268285796046257, 0.04525436460971832, 0.028636090457439423, -0.023691173642873764, -0.05517317354679108, 0.06201525777578354, 0.0161394402384758, -0.0330023318529129, -0.0685289278626442, -0.004292565397918224, -0.02028261125087738, -0.012269065715372562, 0.019073013216257095, -0.008051029406487942, -0.03959823027253151, -0.03438912704586983, 0.009570918045938015, 0.006926789414137602, -0.027972262352705002, 0.016074107959866524, -0.011372693814337254, 0.025972651317715645, 0.002023876877501607, -0.025486120954155922, 0.00853713508695364, -0.02499237470328808, 0.023370681330561638, 0.02116379328072071, -0.053210169076919556, -0.017910074442625046, -0.0681292936205864, -0.020635372027754784, -0.006929631810635328, -0.03482610732316971, 0.055940426886081696, -0.02267700992524624, 0.08097919821739197, 0.04011064022779465, -0.037413015961647034, -0.012859469279646873, 0.0011117079993709922, -0.021237604320049286, 0.002814163686707616, -0.038817256689071655, 0.04390925541520119, -0.032180365175008774, -0.016167934983968735, -0.046072568744421005, -0.0706290528178215, 0.006669331807643175, 0.028164567425847054, -0.021884864196181297, -0.030249280855059624, -0.0008397091296501458, 0.007259860634803772, 0.017413385212421417, -0.022925440222024918, 0.04285025596618652, -0.033457156270742416, 0.029887154698371887, -0.03745417669415474, -0.004359728191047907, 0.08213362842798233, 0.0047941687516868114, 0.018765626475214958, 0.038885697722435, 0.02238307148218155, -0.037687037140131, -0.029439551755785942, 0.006600344553589821, -0.026962624862790108, -0.02614476904273033, -0.006520161870867014, 0.019837116822600365, 0.04572257772088051, -0.045013461261987686, 0.0044184583239257336, -0.01035697665065527, -0.008089090697467327, 0.002139800926670432, -0.050480395555496216, -0.0031913716811686754, -0.03202715516090393, -0.009473633021116257, -0.046846602112054825, 0.02049851603806019, -0.0025799667928367853, 0.04710076376795769, 0.036070775240659714, -0.0023727556690573692, 0.019880201667547226, 0.03255554288625717, 0.07857047021389008, -0.02317509800195694, 0.01858912594616413, -0.017962398007512093, -0.03191123902797699, -0.001035859459079802, 0.006427010986953974, -0.0015682402299717069, 0.015262218192219734, -0.008840947411954403, -0.06321144104003906, -0.015315850265324116, -0.05577084422111511, -0.0220201313495636, 0.03712267801165581, 0.041525062173604965, 0.047988008707761765, 0.06196972355246544, -0.0028124635573476553, 0.028531759977340698, -0.010220217518508434, 0.011044086888432503, -0.017634635791182518, 0.019185030832886696, 0.06441422551870346, -0.007249021902680397, -0.017016896978020668, -0.007888935506343842, 0.03721196949481964, 0.026955433189868927, 0.06371895223855972, -0.001321187592111528, -0.02810722403228283, 0.03343081474304199, -0.029766499996185303, -0.03995725139975548, 0.0017767517128959298, 0.021166712045669556, 0.042687516659498215, 0.01016018446534872, -0.01290815882384777, 0.04082702472805977, 0.0083084087818861, 0.009326387196779251, -0.043963976204395294, -0.03293413668870926, -0.02944391407072544, -0.008480992168188095, 0.04803727567195892, -0.01980799250304699, 0.007831821218132973, -0.0024617838207632303, -0.005118119530379772, -0.0313536673784256, 0.01482765655964613, -0.04616078734397888, -0.07460230588912964, 0.005966369993984699, -0.022872423753142357, -0.04950213059782982, 0.037957705557346344, -0.01920253224670887, -0.053985293954610825, 0.032985035330057144, -0.021616782993078232, 0.03409429267048836, -0.004254264757037163, 0.03410820662975311, 0.016386238858103752, 0.053614795207977295, 0.007894019596278667, 0.0005590398795902729, -0.010996131226420403, -0.012619005516171455, 0.14459723234176636, 0.02661922201514244, 0.03590008616447449, -0.03369510546326637, 0.03020383045077324, -0.005501147359609604, -0.02317950129508972, -0.0038203808944672346, -0.00012806765153072774, -0.011154134757816792, 0.015430562198162079, 0.0300936046987772, 0.034683696925640106, 0.015040160156786442, 0.056176405400037766, -0.006533447187393904, -0.019644152373075485, 0.026390960440039635, 0.028472570702433586, -0.04420623555779457, 0.019822152331471443, 0.024088945239782333, -0.0654718279838562, -0.001638800953514874, -0.011114358901977539, -0.006420555058866739, -0.03515207767486572, -0.049407023936510086, 0.06397183984518051, 0.023034069687128067, 0.01751759648323059, 0.008291042409837246, 0.0018669181736186147, 0.001985409064218402, 0.0022830634843558073, 0.011903781443834305, -0.016729893162846565, -0.03367453068494797, 0.0190423596650362, 0.008248426020145416, 0.010316337458789349, -0.0039963675662875175, -0.01014701183885336, 0.00956867728382349, -0.011015325784683228, -0.04791813716292381, -0.039060287177562714, 0.05353066325187683, -0.035115547478199005, -0.030428525060415268, -0.004461646545678377, 0.01639896258711815, 0.012899341061711311, -0.03406382352113724, -0.007299275137484074, -0.028367307037115097, -0.014099041931331158, -0.005749241914600134, -0.002598138991743326, -0.024790942668914795, 0.025690050795674324, -0.004441275727003813, 0.049287982285022736, -0.015938706696033478, -0.02312615141272545, -0.004117978736758232, 0.009019847959280014, 0.05487135797739029, -0.012469100765883923, -0.003697282401844859, -0.013504981063306332, -0.03898175060749054, -0.021756617352366447, -0.0077919503673911095, 0.020269576460123062, 0.011486466974020004, -0.010469026863574982, 0.004113472532480955, -0.021530697122216225, -0.012265228666365147, -0.0064181974157691, 0.01027941145002842, -0.024529166519641876, -0.024068934842944145, -0.020634165033698082, -0.018012113869190216, 0.016320450231432915, 0.08254577219486237, -0.00014324963558465242, -0.018290601670742035, -0.006640168838202953, 0.008089721202850342, 0.023945411667227745, -0.041983772069215775, -0.008154136128723621, 0.012836080975830555, -0.025779874995350838, -0.00028666164143942297, -0.017586328089237213, 0.0685456246137619, 0.009440282359719276, 0.01646670699119568, 0.015977907925844193, 0.049767717719078064, -0.012267384678125381, 0.001980468863621354, 0.004434796515852213, -0.08302172273397446, 0.04894820228219032, -0.01219172589480877, -0.02365635149180889, -0.04938778653740883, 0.00145715253893286, 0.0012393771903589368, -0.03796224668622017, -0.018069053068757057, -0.02288351207971573, -0.03240528330206871, 0.017603393644094467, -0.03045780025422573, 0.004241144750267267, -0.03215435892343521, -0.000012303075891395565, -0.034308746457099915, -0.008068125694990158, -0.024170847609639168, 0.020423196256160736, -0.033040858805179596, 0.021397097036242485, 0.010837506502866745, 0.03647760674357414, 0.028218576684594154, -0.010620814748108387, 0.01971435546875, 0.01628531701862812, 0.000049982954806182534, 0.012630599550902843, 0.03657669946551323, -0.013560093939304352, -0.01240223366767168, 0.015297669917345047, -0.06343439966440201, -0.03425009921193123, -0.011293929070234299, -0.01010693609714508, 0.03539222478866577, -0.009863454848527908, -0.01568477414548397, -0.0066310507245361805, 0.039788998663425446, -0.0076843868009746075, -0.01606634445488453, -0.018181217834353447, 0.014704607427120209, 0.03783546760678291, 0.005343736615031958, 0.045143965631723404, -0.0027241739444434643, -0.011012256145477295, 0.03532475233078003, 0.001232528011314571, -0.005845354869961739, -0.031265031546354294, 0.011122666299343109, -0.04500558227300644, -0.00175750523339957, -0.014914107508957386, 0.02842560224235058, 0.048695094883441925, -0.0014263043412938714, -0.046988941729068756, 0.005166049115359783, -0.011955267749726772, 0.033931665122509, -0.0836208239197731, -0.02576611191034317, 0.003581234021112323, -0.031152382493019104, 0.01676756888628006, -0.06953940540552139, 0.013435762375593185, 0.06823091208934784, -0.076690673828125, 0.024591511115431786, -0.004606728442013264, -0.03123030997812748, -0.028636377304792404, 0.02161131426692009, -0.0444939024746418, -0.010175050236284733, 0.01977434940636158, 0.04169529676437378, 0.04464029148221016, 0.013633361086249352, -0.008233615197241306, -0.02934570237994194, -0.02158743143081665, -0.01051152590662241, 0.018321353942155838, -0.040564119815826416, 0.022495891898870468, 0.003941065166145563, -0.0113340700045228, 0.02256927639245987, -0.024032581597566605, 0.010557063855230808, 0.00443354481831193, -0.021504869684576988, -0.007556452415883541, 0.06527343392372131, 0.004794977605342865, -0.019885240122675896, 0.014914844185113907, -0.05492798984050751, 0.0063974917866289616, -0.008131502196192741, -0.026249438524246216, 0.0069823735393583775, 0.04577646031975746, 0.018511513248085976, -0.028111552819609642, 0.007802811451256275, -0.012642127461731434, -0.025578467175364494, -0.03517482802271843, 0.01271460298448801, -0.011290679685771465, -0.03978145867586136, -0.006566740106791258, -0.02181456796824932, 0.04658817872405052, 0.014836788177490234, -0.012509175576269627, -0.04499819129705429, 0.03286640718579292, -0.015201762318611145, -0.04180727154016495, -0.04825594648718834, -0.017856953665614128, -0.03321726620197296, -0.034018728882074356, 0.004299690946936607, 0.018020862713456154, -0.02669992297887802, -0.000028412485335138626, 0.0007431012345477939, -0.0332629531621933, 0.053662121295928955, 0.010006889700889587, 0.011015157215297222, 0.0005350254359655082, 0.003897684859111905, 0.004256544169038534, -0.06970949470996857, 0.044625893235206604, 0.0149844354018569, -0.02386433444917202, -0.04590652510523796, -0.0024267369881272316, -0.0125099066644907, 0.040778595954179764, 0.025449471548199654, 0.03232119232416153, 0.016173621639609337, -0.03495633229613304, 0.0015469897771254182, 0.028389442712068558, -0.05122935026884079, 0.0403713695704937, 0.011602257378399372, -0.03185819461941719, -0.028049124404788017, -0.017863454297184944, 0.015588775277137756, 0.030871739611029625, -0.012946326285600662, 0.012094413861632347, 0.024756764993071556, -0.030073579400777817, -0.018713442608714104, 0.006180691998451948, -0.020018888637423515, -0.024309661239385605, 0.08133894205093384, -0.004501201678067446, -0.019724765792489052, 0.02419322170317173, 0.016692325472831726, -0.025512440130114555, 0.025212781503796577, -0.00866524875164032, -0.016036126762628555, -0.003281589364632964, -0.0016324715688824654, 0.03074423223733902, -0.062229640781879425, 0.007666071876883507, 0.0018610776169225574, -0.03179411590099335, -0.015263264998793602, 0.049292754381895065, -0.011871135793626308, 0.02814493514597416, -0.026896890252828598, 0.001563472324050963, -0.02392711490392685, -0.018419262021780014, 0.012832754291594028, -0.018871260806918144, -0.01664089597761631, 0.005917355418205261, 0.01016391720622778, 0.027883075177669525, -0.03857344761490822, 0.03036835975944996, 0.00690141087397933, 0.05250838026404381, 0.012104779481887817, -0.018088584765791893, 0.01095154881477356, -0.048578597605228424, 0.0026521983090788126, 0.031058063730597496, -0.019879888743162155, 0.06653907150030136, -0.02016141451895237, 0.00404242193326354, -0.0348387286067009, -0.048644788563251495, -0.037649005651474, 0.026735205203294754, -0.012111356481909752, 0.009621592238545418, 0.0015415963716804981, -0.0019246184965595603, 0.01952974684536457, -0.007862121798098087, 0.02448628470301628, -0.014205729588866234, 0.01625989004969597, 0.0009113152045756578, 0.006752007640898228, -0.004227892961353064, 0.020502200350165367, 0.00410220492631197, 0.0052194902673363686, 0.008777070790529251, 0.05356782302260399, 0.0027690688148140907, -0.04530112072825432, 0.012064976617693901, 0.019900862127542496, 0.0646410658955574, -0.055350616574287415, -0.028438858687877655, -0.0341765359044075, 0.02619321085512638, -0.009515770711004734, -0.017012249678373337 ]
<p>I would like to build a message classification system which classifies a given message into either of 2 class - Relevant/Not.</p> <p>I don't have any labelled dataset. I only have certain keywords which defines relevance. I can include more keywords (synonyms, nearly same words, etc).</p> <p>For example: If I want to define relevance for Automobile the relevant keywords I'll be having are - Cars, bikes, automobiles, gas, tires, engine, oil, ... Now, the classifier should check a new message (email/SMS) and classify them whether the message belongs to this category or not.</p> <pre><code>Message1: Always use abc car oil. Message2: My dish had too much of oil. </code></pre> <p>In this case, <em>Message1</em> is relevant to automobile domain rather <em>Message2</em>.</p> <p>Please, advice me how to build a training dataset and how do I generalize this model for any domain?</p>
36,243
[ -0.02157537080347538, -0.0339539460837841, 0.0014462328981608152, 0.03428606316447258, 0.012805375270545483, 0.0012031812220811844, -0.023001737892627716, -0.005619274452328682, 0.04290089011192322, -0.01331956684589386, 0.023228604346513748, 0.030334683135151863, 0.03185739368200302, 0.021927131339907646, 0.03254636749625206, -0.013432027772068977, 0.02929847687482834, -0.022787289693951607, 0.017520586028695107, -0.005674681626260281, 0.011000275611877441, -0.04405505210161209, 0.02588484436273575, -0.005481304135173559, -0.00458788126707077, 0.04353993758559227, 0.007167920470237732, -0.005560593213886023, 0.019713658839464188, -0.009970910847187042, -0.011551701463758945, -0.017554624006152153, -0.01543382741510868, 0.016412019729614258, 0.015234038233757019, 0.03571663796901703, -0.03474336862564087, -0.004658459220081568, -0.024757683277130127, 0.008111423812806606, -0.024151328951120377, 0.0028786524198949337, 0.024377433583140373, 0.06479132175445557, -0.023897996172308922, 0.009432835504412651, -0.023086614906787872, -0.0025264534633606672, -0.0030911469366401434, -0.056751396507024765, 0.05522678792476654, -0.02429317869246006, 0.043145861476659775, 0.06695692986249924, -0.003590070176869631, -0.033184584230184555, 0.05905121564865112, 0.09277822822332382, -0.004988453816622496, -0.040833115577697754, -0.037032440304756165, 0.008440624922513962, -0.00529611948877573, -0.03843001648783684, -0.05976293608546257, 0.0036514399107545614, 0.00029235900728963315, -0.01701543480157852, 0.06866692006587982, 0.0340920053422451, 0.012052949517965317, -0.0034705831203609705, 0.03351069986820221, -0.007141279987990856, 0.0313662551343441, -0.028375830501317978, 0.0011307046515867114, 0.0422108992934227, 0.028530480340123177, 0.033971257507801056, 0.012801610864698887, -0.007837059907615185, -0.0214706901460886, 0.02639973908662796, 0.029409315437078476, -0.03745849058032036, 0.026628853753209114, -0.0103986244648695, 0.019997943192720413, 0.015939412638545036, -0.029053717851638794, 0.02071845717728138, 0.030152209103107452, 0.011871512979269028, 0.014816231094300747, 0.04484230652451515, 0.022089798003435135, 0.02372233010828495, 0.03133164346218109, -0.007305810693651438, -0.0005035295034758747, -0.031299713999032974, 0.0036590592935681343, 0.05440451204776764, -0.017096249386668205, -0.010016427375376225, -0.05171586573123932, -0.01803603023290634, -0.02500249445438385, -0.008409273810684681, 0.0037792951334267855, 0.015960155054926872, 0.014352764934301376, 0.01596268266439438, -0.0026978047098964453, -0.05617327243089676, -0.005942010786384344, -0.04267628863453865, 0.022020213305950165, 0.06982328742742538, 0.050184231251478195, -0.00013731734361499548, -0.0133688198402524, -0.060448769479990005, -0.033030129969120026, -0.01582498848438263, 0.0008895172504708171, -0.01130071934312582, 0.033491864800453186, 0.03047708421945572, -0.04906991496682167, -0.01754467561841011, -0.014665678143501282, -0.009301353245973587, 0.014675942249596119, -0.014048478566110134, -0.07442528754472733, -0.049390777945518494, -0.013562661595642567, 0.009347519837319851, 0.000948312459513545, -0.025699706748127937, 0.014307580888271332, 0.050275687128305435, 0.047764021903276443, 0.016165146604180336, 0.027944203466176987, 0.05814826488494873, 0.025266272947192192, 0.021101953461766243, -0.02627282217144966, -0.0388716422021389, -0.03571893274784088, 0.03307781741023064, -0.017095321789383888, -0.07280251383781433, -0.0011947136372327805, -0.019523506984114647, -0.01945563592016697, -0.008681119419634342, 0.021319182589650154, -0.021092591807246208, 0.012316315434873104, -0.011492456309497356, 0.03608056157827377, -0.01832457259297371, 0.086158886551857, 0.028427166864275932, 0.039367713034152985, 0.011706055141985416, 0.015358186326920986, 0.0174859669059515, 0.04458174481987953, 0.026949917897582054, 0.06481636315584183, 0.016685843467712402, -0.009777728468179703, -0.01987529546022415, 0.051739756017923355, 0.009681228548288345, -0.02041560970246792, -0.04678450897336006, -0.03603554889559746, 0.009828738868236542, -0.01902013085782528, -0.01444779708981514, 0.02047971449792385, -0.02711213380098343, 0.07938866317272186, -0.025531619787216187, -0.019372930750250816, -0.025478817522525787, 0.02958470955491066, -0.055836986750364304, -0.03585996478796005, 0.0021577775478363037, 0.007072675507515669, -0.015860872343182564, -0.009232594631612301, -0.008665528148412704, -0.03168601170182228, -0.021799860522150993, 0.02894759178161621, -0.01929575204849243, -0.022955862805247307, 0.04736696928739548, -0.01417434960603714, -0.045444440096616745, 0.02640843763947487, -0.025535935536026955, -0.06589829176664352, 0.024491963908076286, 0.0034864803310483694, -0.011759147979319096, -0.03436601907014847, -0.0143073545768857, 0.0381925068795681, -0.01356886513531208, -0.006338691338896751, 0.009599189274013042, -0.0664525255560875, 0.07579503208398819, 0.05795939266681671, -0.008416950702667236, 0.007624474354088306, -0.0063088517636060715, 0.005029675550758839, 0.040500979870557785, 0.013522544875741005, -0.009433015249669552, -0.051921118050813675, -0.05087772011756897, 0.07854018360376358, -0.0047162603586912155, -0.03286762908101082, 0.0026163733564317226, 0.04991079866886139, 0.006878347136080265, 0.03216703236103058, 0.008319769985973835, 0.003959630616009235, 0.012163161300122738, 0.0240160059183836, 0.07713349908590317, 0.019076867029070854, -0.007300904486328363, 0.03329848870635033, -0.0004784756456501782, 0.07313111424446106, -0.011961022391915321, 0.006546941585838795, 0.06739772856235504, 0.044741179794073105, 0.00138000026345253, 0.004670571535825729, 0.002840496599674225, 0.021256720647215843, -0.016399843618273735, -0.008930599316954613, 0.0372648611664772, -0.0015014717355370522, -0.004818460438400507, 0.03854755312204361, -0.004549712873995304, 0.015673277899622917, 0.03769000247120857, -0.00047016466851346195, -0.004161457065492868, 0.03218415752053261, -0.08288344740867615, 0.00119122548494488, 0.03007175214588642, -0.0467233806848526, -0.033456332981586456, 0.04521157220005989, 0.07764807343482971, -0.020088721066713333, 0.012140688486397266, -0.011441051959991455, -0.02679324708878994, 0.005229420494288206, -0.030847841873764992, -0.011315316893160343, -0.017378069460392, -0.03130536153912544, 0.022194044664502144, -0.016561971977353096, -0.018837841227650642, 0.020327864214777946, -0.004995865747332573, -0.05870814248919487, -0.0027911770157516003, -0.006581275258213282, -0.034217823296785355, -0.03410360962152481, -0.04373409226536751, 0.04282214492559433, -0.030130082741379738, -0.027059758082032204, 0.03789660707116127, 0.04171369969844818, -0.05257865786552429, -0.02644135244190693, -0.06043054535984993, -0.04463789984583855, -0.03880815580487251, -0.017435435205698013, 0.01852876879274845, -0.03548172488808632, 0.020237606018781662, 0.0243691299110651, -0.024587592110037804, -0.012519066222012043, -0.047686345875263214, -0.06597916036844254, 0.028181657195091248, 0.007219931576400995, 0.02191755548119545, -0.0009719999507069588, 0.0011377400951460004, 0.06265591830015182, 0.05092218145728111, -0.005677249748259783, -0.008358970284461975, -0.009198073297739029, -0.020931724458932877, -0.04178597033023834, -0.019773725420236588, 0.027125004678964615, -0.016621338203549385, -0.03018665686249733, 0.04068008437752724, 0.04514813795685768, 0.021191054955124855, -0.011688388884067535, -0.015190662816166878, 0.024817729368805885, 0.0054718186147511005, 0.0035886152181774378, 0.04835117235779762, 0.045998215675354004, -0.04402114823460579, 0.019556283950805664, -0.024240009486675262, 0.01812700554728508, 0.014898496679961681, -0.050782375037670135, -0.001374200452119112, -0.01817883551120758, 0.027811549603939056, -0.005287484265863895, 0.016657153144478798, 0.01846214570105076, -0.04966436326503754, 0.0013293820666149259, -0.003663015319034457, 0.015442832373082638, -0.015462002716958523, -0.0010259350528940558, 0.05425950512290001, 0.02658671699464321, -0.025096656754612923, -0.021036777645349503, -0.032910462468862534, -0.01798420213162899, 0.011114691384136677, -0.0201207734644413, 0.010486497543752193, 0.037834107875823975, 0.00023688621877226979, 0.022181950509548187, 0.01959969848394394, -0.030263807624578476, -0.014106245711445808, -0.07436639815568924, 0.00042556191328912973, -0.024010011926293373, 0.05775173008441925, 0.004269873723387718, 0.029867105185985565, 0.015202950686216354, -0.025343284010887146, -0.005011086352169514, 0.011655556969344616, -0.05469004064798355, 0.04111459478735924, 0.001575208967551589, -0.017593564465641975, 0.03463786095380783, -0.017073968425393105, -0.019123706966638565, -0.06324204802513123, -0.008108456619083881, -0.010873365215957165, 0.011239467188715935, -0.0492287203669548, 0.03712804242968559, -0.01402482483536005, -0.05357062444090843, -0.018619081005454063, 0.0013503035297617316, 0.020826417952775955, 0.009325286373496056, 0.021792905405163765, 0.031598661094903946, -0.015217720530927181, -0.016525691375136375, -0.0020830908324569464, -0.00019280517881270498, 0.011649541556835175, 0.031490255147218704, 0.023709164932370186, 0.06268750876188278, -0.04502668231725693, 0.010332677513360977, 0.013658285140991211, 0.015933942049741745, 0.03514600545167923, 0.019869189709424973, -0.02896900288760662, -0.07595489174127579, -0.03417283669114113, 0.0156401377171278, 0.05514569580554962, -0.014223258942365646, -0.028695305809378624, 0.005025413352996111, -0.012322247959673405, -0.052619148045778275, -0.00994871649891138, 0.05776134878396988, 0.03729424625635147, -0.028612276539206505, -0.029140740633010864, 0.0034108213149011135, 0.005682678893208504, -0.016378145664930344, 0.024583445861935616, 0.035330478101968765, -0.005376081448048353, -0.04194553568959236, 0.0075681270100176334, -0.02820477820932865, -0.051893215626478195, -0.00555391376838088, -0.002773294458165765, -0.0029605019371956587, -0.00015229442215058953, -0.02893996238708496, 0.010407964698970318, -0.007258452009409666, 0.061754848808050156, -0.00989655964076519, 0.033824194222688675, -0.13565516471862793, 0.029672877863049507, 0.029061641544103622, 0.05260178819298744, -0.025034576654434204, -0.02689475379884243, -0.02230798453092575, -0.03612028807401657, 0.030768709257245064, -0.07954978942871094, 0.03776124119758606, -0.015486320480704308, 0.014993887394666672, -0.002132711699232459, 0.014341481029987335, -0.03424245864152908, 0.008659275248646736, -0.035108838230371475, 0.007355904672294855, 0.01509534940123558, -0.024714002385735512, -0.07031602412462234, 0.006430693902075291, 0.03705420345067978, 0.03652988374233246, -0.01742570847272873, -0.02692246064543724, -0.012843411415815353, -0.008980000391602516, 0.004456290043890476, -0.0386844240128994, -0.020220663398504257, 0.006562182679772377, -0.016340171918272972, 0.05639919638633728, -0.011886720545589924, -0.028834449127316475, -0.002516594249755144, -0.010279818437993526, -0.0674101933836937, -0.03204165771603584, -0.029960770159959793, 0.012605871073901653, 0.02849249541759491, -0.002771195722743869, 0.011683979071676731, 0.005329570733010769, 0.016462700441479683, 0.003817753167822957, -0.030066508799791336, 0.01767965406179428, -0.013872201554477215, -0.013878250494599342, -0.037141427397727966, 0.022416073828935623, -0.035254091024398804, 0.0051473514176905155, -0.006256927270442247, 0.01845617964863777, -0.03747284784913063, -0.058056607842445374, -0.030344173312187195, 0.04629615694284439, -0.013229959644377232, -0.03594660013914108, -0.010387003421783447, 0.045229073613882065, -0.010931345634162426, 0.0240571741014719, 0.01702377013862133, -0.050051406025886536, -0.0006202543736435473, -0.015456030145287514, -0.021956630051136017, 0.028402207419276237, -0.03729702904820442, -0.013454758562147617, 0.0007397274603135884, -0.03256358206272125, 0.03849933668971062, 0.008379262872040272, 0.027422994375228882, 0.012619188986718655, -0.05056024715304375, -0.009996874257922173, 0.04026377201080322, 0.03186367079615593, 0.0402880534529686, -0.0061655594035983086, 0.04544631019234657, -0.013091561384499073, -0.038865044713020325, -0.046933237463235855, -0.03272893652319908, -0.013167928904294968, 0.019126009196043015, -0.015541473403573036, -0.020192399621009827, 0.01785476878285408, -0.008685153909027576, -0.02968013286590576, -0.007121396716684103, 0.07483593374490738, -0.03052147664129734, -0.015995359048247337, 0.02860851213335991, 0.013255355879664421, 0.06125501170754433, 0.013816813938319683, 0.04826199635863304, 0.00010467328684171662, -0.01969882845878601, -0.013019104488193989, -0.0161448884755373, 0.003522254293784499, -0.026617668569087982, -0.04698647931218147, -0.07186660915613174, 0.057397451251745224, 0.045122530311346054, 0.005336741916835308, 0.019969550892710686, -0.011473982594907284, -0.00021528433717321604, -0.023920392617583275, -0.024988457560539246, -0.014393205754458904, 0.02289605513215065, -0.0395142063498497, -0.02033079043030739, 0.02696889080107212, -0.01924181543290615, -0.012277358211576939, 0.008529032580554485, -0.010887267999351025, 0.024650098755955696, 0.020801430568099022, 0.0737556666135788, 0.00045325333485379815, 0.014533903449773788, 0.009606505744159222, -0.04030083492398262, 0.05061866715550423, 0.0007750988588668406, -0.026608483865857124, -0.005967310629785061, 0.015154469758272171, 0.007149529177695513, 0.019469426944851875, -0.03445093333721161, -0.04350865259766579, 0.05840669944882393, 0.006765304133296013, 0.037790969014167786, 0.05777738243341446, -0.006500594783574343, 0.019600234925746918, -0.040113937109708786, -0.015069328248500824, -0.018522104248404503, 0.015132628381252289, 0.04192712903022766, -0.038573089987039566, -0.027370385825634003, 0.055215343832969666, -0.006449527107179165, 0.060142889618873596, -0.016717854887247086, 0.02924302965402603, 0.04162346199154854, 0.02098240703344345, -0.05463840439915657, -0.049619823694229126, 0.0006323896814137697, -0.01634972169995308, 0.015789156779646873, 0.01266846526414156, -0.0393294021487236, 0.04373154789209366, 0.01640629582107067, -0.012520725838840008, -0.035779256373643875, 0.01305369846522808, -0.07948093861341476, 0.05745041370391846, 0.008724289014935493, 0.007421224843710661, 0.0034259159583598375, 0.025704171508550644, 0.028514426201581955, -0.005285671446472406, 0.01864192821085453, 0.004561468493193388, -0.08685079962015152, -0.021671026945114136, -0.011945359408855438, -0.047250185161828995, 0.03870593383908272, 0.015441611409187317, -0.046611037105321884, 0.027897894382476807, -0.034195754677057266, 0.03503847122192383, 0.009483607485890388, 0.052663981914520264, 0.0004622006381396204, 0.019070666283369064, -0.03723841533064842, 0.05990677699446678, 0.04226464405655861, -0.03249214589595795, 0.11265841126441956, 0.08292705565690994, 0.06837011873722076, -0.03313454985618591, 0.01565801165997982, -0.022546065971255302, -0.03237611800432205, -0.030622394755482674, 0.019426146522164345, 0.008487546816468239, 0.02585257962346077, 0.024936364963650703, 0.017127923667430878, 0.017585495486855507, -0.01074975449591875, 0.04704151675105095, -0.0190376378595829, -0.016681019216775894, 0.0076365480199456215, 0.03429986163973808, -0.021542023867368698, -0.014093300327658653, -0.049580153077840805, 0.024092473089694977, 0.019008111208677292, -0.0005418839864432812, -0.027123993262648582, -0.03059622459113598, 0.021308785304427147, -0.046326637268066406, 0.0255261417478323, -0.011169170960783958, -0.004327808972448111, 0.03149003908038139, 0.021622173488140106, 0.014051316305994987, -0.0019966550171375275, -0.008630400523543358, 0.0009075307752937078, 0.020205652341246605, 0.04571022093296051, -0.04971703886985779, 0.008977429941296577, 0.002132947323843837, -0.07482334226369858, -0.02617073431611061, -0.05276548117399216, 0.0607108473777771, -0.008987264707684517, -0.015023074112832546, 0.006152221001684666, 0.029273614287376404, 0.005185137037187815, -0.03317756578326225, -0.04174170270562172, 0.03921186551451683, 0.001993397017940879, -0.019765730947256088, 0.021710757166147232, -0.03726084157824516, 0.043033551424741745, 0.02117946185171604, 0.024477101862430573, 0.01771857962012291, 0.0009196295286528766, -0.025275008752942085, -0.022858573123812675, 0.02888493426144123, 0.013265639543533325, -0.0066031659953296185, 0.013124344870448112, -0.0008290226687677205, -0.004517048597335815, 0.0012256844202056527, 0.015870800241827965, 0.03636976704001427, 0.007814942859113216, -0.026733523234725, -0.005095369182527065, -0.03494064509868622, -0.0050579095259308815, 0.004036769270896912, -0.032944779843091965, -0.0011136651737615466, -0.036463912576436996, 0.017290247604250908, 0.015560973435640335, 0.006773108616471291, -0.0015585729852318764, 0.023815752938389778, 0.02635823003947735, 0.037032440304756165, 0.003695143386721611, -0.03805866464972496, -0.03694722801446915, 0.0011569713242352009, -0.040882378816604614, -0.013403838500380516, 0.008399797603487968, 0.08110851049423218, 0.01893761195242405, -0.013037508353590965, 0.018100256100296974, 0.03553125262260437, -0.017560003325343132, 0.026844147592782974, 0.03273255005478859, 0.0017888454021885991, -0.02861172892153263, 0.0026115584187209606, 0.017330950126051903, -0.02842887118458748, -0.011404821649193764, -0.0028512715362012386, -0.04001227766275406, 0.024804065003991127, 0.007444201502948999, -0.0197146013379097, 0.009570433758199215, -0.013475128449499607, 0.05831199139356613, -0.027237774804234505, 0.016679219901561737, -0.05552809685468674, -0.0006311884499154985, -0.036294884979724884, -0.02571161836385727, -0.05811826139688492, 0.026373468339443207, -0.03416389226913452, 0.002555408515036106, -0.0011784406378865242, 0.009863197803497314, -0.001382180256769061, 0.007392051164060831, 0.014187266118824482, -0.05930744856595993, 0.0415438748896122, -0.03917320445179939, -0.016046203672885895, 0.028612200170755386, -0.04381446912884712, 0.004311713855713606, 0.010313278995454311, -0.026730773970484734, 0.04645409807562828, 0.02782508172094822, 0.02706104889512062, 0.028341207653284073, 0.0657990500330925, -0.026539424434304237, -0.039493996649980545, 0.017141079530119896, 0.02980724722146988, 0.008399197831749916, 0.004027372691780329, 0.025297101587057114, 0.019024280831217766, -0.022552108392119408, 0.01574643701314926, 0.043539486825466156, 0.05257856473326683, -0.03501264378428459, 0.012486918829381466, -0.006474906112998724, 0.018469655886292458, 0.0024919824209064245, -0.0035297516733407974, 0.020281614735722542, 0.024355754256248474, -0.049999747425317764, 0.018384667113423347, 0.001151559641584754, 0.01994483545422554, -0.05565040186047554, -0.024494420737028122, 0.01485754456371069, 0.0021540471352636814, 0.05972108617424965, -0.030563797801733017, 0.029492350295186043, -0.015976622700691223, -0.017326626926660538, 0.027222538366913795, 0.00445874547585845, 0.011635469272732735, -0.02576179802417755, 0.034961797297000885, 0.0013403851771727204, 0.041377369314432144, 0.012221521697938442, 0.017041239887475967, 0.042491864413022995, 0.021868856623768806, -0.011190994642674923, -0.011800863780081272, -0.032773032784461975, 0.025447731837630272, -0.00010846511577256024, -0.009733232669532299, 0.04989752173423767, -0.030058639124035835, -0.04800271615386009, 0.027413612231612206, -0.018091754987835884, 0.033581193536520004, 0.043001268059015274, -0.002105293795466423, 0.04721994325518608, 0.03032686561346054, 0.044022560119628906, -0.02231653220951557, 0.013579812832176685, 0.007087536156177521, 0.009908726438879967, -0.014176751486957073, -0.017190847545862198, 0.004500222392380238, 0.028447069227695465, -0.020136667415499687, 0.010450877249240875, -0.000641447666566819, -0.02262130007147789, -0.03702986240386963, 0.003156582824885845, 0.0012104471679776907, -0.02351551316678524, -0.021778453141450882, -0.03444657847285271, -0.0347331278026104, 0.0009703084942884743, 0.03587663173675537, 0.034135960042476654, -0.003959484864026308, 0.04091430827975273, -0.02398889884352684, -0.05081842839717865, -0.017771905288100243, 0.0017507878364995122, -0.04507884755730629, -0.0005125480238348246, -0.011902572587132454, -0.010520252399146557, 0.02804979868233204, -0.04247205704450607, -0.01691030152142048, 0.006536142434924841, 0.04631698131561279, -0.03770776465535164, 0.05336688086390495, 0.04243920370936394, -0.015077803283929825, 0.006833148654550314, -0.07184037566184998, 0.0337899886071682, 0.022997358813881874, -0.01869368553161621, -0.028150632977485657, -0.01654229685664177, -0.05348324403166771, 0.009852117858827114, 0.07529222965240479, -0.005377637222409248, 0.02957157976925373, -0.05882162228226662, -0.01678699627518654, 0.0029517204966396093, -0.01710243709385395, 0.05128913372755051, -0.026526622474193573, -0.04247933626174927, -0.019113102927803993, 0.0010134256444871426, 0.0110179977491498, -0.010937881655991077, 0.04039440676569939, -0.015190156176686287, -0.015966441482305527, 0.022424697875976562, -0.029814422130584717, 0.010731128044426441, -0.0035278641153126955, 0.03736162930727005, 0.03036506474018097, -0.008362642489373684, 0.002889215713366866, 0.035076968371868134, 0.004825325682759285, -0.03747095540165901, 0.03347865492105484, -0.03261876106262207, 0.007556540425866842, 0.008218730799853802, 0.011989864520728588, 0.026459841057658195, -0.0719628632068634, 0.009286623448133469, 0.0027015681844204664, 0.022109754383563995, 0.011119640432298183, 0.025353211909532547, 0.03323516249656677, 0.05051716789603233, 0.024764791131019592, 0.02284224145114422, -0.023473378270864487, -0.020523566752672195, 0.009320714510977268, 0.01896275021135807, -0.0009060986922122538, -0.005608794745057821, 0.03525009751319885, 0.0312928706407547, 0.00016275265079457313, 0.028169961646199226, -0.031097738072276115, 0.04729917272925377, -0.017643189057707787, -0.00047268252819776535, 0.0017631228547543287, -0.0035942147951573133, 0.016354989260435104, 0.0250548105686903, 0.011848707683384418, 0.02213232032954693, -0.04715154320001602, -0.024345453828573227, -0.037043116986751556, 0.006502113770693541, -0.04833326116204262, 0.034287866204977036, -0.005428359378129244, -0.004466761369258165, 0.028469489887356758, 0.008693769574165344, 0.03275488317012787, -0.01981618069112301, 0.012344487942755222, 0.011595748364925385, -0.0001004869191092439, 0.013356867246329784, -0.026425408199429512, 0.009494371712207794, -0.013857332989573479, -0.007086871657520533, 0.01748114824295044, 0.004357541911303997, 0.10045426338911057, 0.003158390522003174, -0.04808707535266876, 0.002738852286711335, 0.02395441196858883, -0.006269256118685007, -0.08052421361207962, 0.01431538350880146, -0.05683276057243347, -0.027104824781417847, 0.007552874740213156, -0.05235273763537407 ]
<p>I am working with different transition diagrams and want to calculate the likelihood ratio statistic for testing time-homogeneous. I saw that there are already some comparable questions, but I still don't understand the method. For example, if I have the following transition diagram (probabilities) for 1 year:</p> <pre><code>From state 1 to state 1,2,3: 0,3 0,4 0,3 &lt;- (Based on 80 companies) From state 2 to state 1,2,3: 0,2 0,7 0,1 &lt;-(Based on 500 companies) From state 3 to state 1,2,3: 0,5 0,2 0,3 &lt;- (Based on 300 companies). </code></pre> <p>And the following diagram for 2 years:</p> <pre><code>From state 1 to state 1,2,3: 0,2 0,5 0,3 &lt;-(Based on 100 companies) From state 2 to state 1,2,3: 0,1 0,2 0,7 &lt;-(Based on 1000 companies) From state 3 to state 1,2,3: 0,6 0,2 0,2 &lt;-(Based on 500 companies) </code></pre> <p>How can I calculate the likelihood ratio statistic with the same method as done in the article Testing simple Markov structures for Credit Rating transitions (<a href="http://www.occ.gov/publications/publications-by-type/occ-working-papers/2008-2000/wp2004-3.pdf" rel="nofollow">http://www.occ.gov/publications/publications-by-type/occ-working-papers/2008-2000/wp2004-3.pdf</a>). I hope that someone can help me with this question based on this example!</p>
73,772
[ -0.01930377259850502, -0.02008628658950329, -0.00006084674168960191, -0.009646669961512089, 0.010396058671176434, 0.002116087358444929, -0.026332076638936996, -0.03303280100226402, 0.01783762313425541, -0.01044551283121109, 0.03160262480378151, 0.04236608371138573, 0.046531811356544495, 0.036293402314186096, 0.031232992187142372, 0.017263295128941536, -0.006034397520124912, 0.008102395571768284, -0.03250400722026825, 0.002531395759433508, 0.013435738161206245, -0.011140147224068642, 0.03280835226178169, -0.016881808638572693, 0.011721867136657238, -0.0049259779043495655, 0.0027666399255394936, -0.025993086397647858, 0.03414352238178253, 0.029529348015785217, -0.030053427442908287, -0.04112951457500458, 0.028040606528520584, 0.0044702524319291115, -0.005201350897550583, 0.008405284024775028, -0.008549694903194904, -0.06259800493717194, -0.021173924207687378, 0.03230738639831543, -0.03762159124016762, 0.008997088298201561, -0.03137046843767166, 0.04495346546173096, 0.035823624581098557, -0.003465054091066122, 0.012250188738107681, -0.012251101434230804, 0.02140355110168457, -0.023443950340151787, 0.07433131337165833, -0.018775302916765213, 0.005825423169881105, 0.002884684596210718, -0.00906660407781601, -0.020353764295578003, 0.02437564544379711, 0.07815954089164734, -0.0017010824522003531, -0.028807928785681725, -0.04926050081849098, -0.05282425135374069, 0.014753504656255245, -0.03870502486824989, -0.009260537102818489, 0.025399962440133095, -0.014720025472342968, -0.0292135551571846, 0.05869040638208389, -0.03930871933698654, -0.02533475123345852, 0.019926540553569794, 0.057162825018167496, -0.020720001310110092, 0.01769210211932659, -0.043577536940574646, 0.03828864544630051, 0.0034587043337523937, 0.046131934970617294, 0.0632626935839653, -0.0376540869474411, 0.018873708322644234, 0.02477029711008072, 0.03742654621601105, 0.0016000056639313698, -0.017752718180418015, 0.09479644894599915, -0.046438027173280716, 0.042078591883182526, -0.003199824830517173, -0.014544660225510597, 0.019404899328947067, 0.030962668359279633, 0.03413969278335571, -0.05431785061955452, 0.03919064998626709, -0.025413183495402336, 0.040484681725502014, -0.02629988268017769, 0.01660662516951561, -0.01071074791252613, -0.07130826264619827, -0.01255691796541214, 0.028249910101294518, 0.036187686026096344, 0.010622133500874043, -0.006325779482722282, -0.00700430478900671, -0.034590546041727066, -0.01904548704624176, -0.03937292844057083, 0.03024766966700554, 0.023295897990465164, 0.01127577107399702, -0.04524274542927742, -0.03213713318109512, -0.016647791489958763, -0.010046220384538174, 0.04422972723841667, 0.019480571150779724, 0.0300421305000782, -0.004390618298202753, 0.021083323284983635, -0.017293309792876244, -0.07334607094526291, 0.013035984709858894, 0.016893504187464714, -0.01168274600058794, -0.008851299062371254, 0.045823629945516586, -0.027934247627854347, -0.03817537799477577, 0.062009770423173904, 0.025832979008555412, 0.03431621938943863, 0.011799436993896961, -0.09361033886671066, -0.017377236858010292, 0.025329535827040672, 0.007953275926411152, 0.044220440089702606, -0.07933070510625839, 0.020089801400899887, 0.05373510345816612, 0.036366283893585205, -0.014476812444627285, 0.05206404998898506, -0.0004791168321389705, 0.008638058789074421, 0.026046492159366608, -0.03301317244768143, -0.014478842727839947, -0.04101315885782242, -0.0038813441060483456, 0.005409028381109238, -0.05300678685307503, 0.004803850781172514, 0.0027855951339006424, 0.009895144030451775, -0.03055708482861519, 0.013149524107575417, -0.008938931860029697, -0.05116206780076027, -0.024796752259135246, -0.005151274148374796, 0.0035510531160980463, 0.058239296078681946, -0.013398285955190659, -0.003093588398769498, -0.007957696914672852, -0.0032278597354888916, 0.011366684921085835, -0.008262488059699535, 0.030165867879986763, 0.04862774536013603, -0.0347437784075737, 0.020729757845401764, -0.015160078182816505, -0.004845691844820976, -0.006353855598717928, -0.020641980692744255, 0.0015286854468286037, -0.02243414707481861, -0.04443451762199402, 0.04186957702040672, -0.021153448149561882, 0.004407607484608889, 0.02218734472990036, 0.028519343584775925, -0.0432901605963707, -0.04758298024535179, -0.06685905903577805, 0.012101104483008385, -0.04259413108229637, -0.027709243819117546, 0.03649144619703293, -0.000721722433809191, 0.040839482098817825, 0.0037369101773947477, -0.036797504872083664, -0.025702036917209625, -0.031825508922338486, -0.0058655026368796825, -0.040730759501457214, 0.031016964465379715, 0.04885562136769295, 0.0643797293305397, -0.012121476233005524, 0.048572901636362076, -0.06015971675515175, -0.022231828421354294, 0.02419450506567955, 0.0024676392786204815, 0.01688849925994873, -0.000544256588909775, -0.02797439880669117, -0.013142721727490425, 0.02130878157913685, -0.007137828040868044, 0.030687695369124413, -0.06147531047463417, 0.03442059084773064, 0.1070890948176384, 0.05006953328847885, 0.0025691790506243706, -0.018519194796681404, 0.00376674416474998, 0.04516046121716499, -0.02036447823047638, -0.000630183145403862, -0.05452369898557663, -0.02679525315761566, 0.0159621499478817, 0.0023014810867607594, -0.01608698070049286, -0.010176090523600578, 0.04237363487482071, -0.0008049957687035203, -0.026194481179118156, 0.030557772144675255, 0.00813104398548603, -0.010393841192126274, 0.020502854138612747, 0.009347761981189251, 0.020950812846422195, -0.003449908923357725, 0.021812977269291878, 0.025360848754644394, 0.05057433247566223, -0.01299027819186449, -0.010560410097241402, 0.04631694406270981, -0.007155843544751406, 0.020286375656723976, -0.04764294996857643, -0.011231053620576859, 0.06476475298404694, 0.0008817139896564186, -0.0071552167646586895, 0.04919084534049034, 0.03629210591316223, 0.027379537001252174, 0.007704455871134996, -0.020956244319677353, -0.00408966327086091, 0.04718608409166336, -0.02673681080341339, -0.004559528082609177, 0.0016407811781391501, -0.003137802705168724, 0.06534522026777267, -0.0041596125811338425, -0.005782767664641142, -0.035800203680992126, 0.024703212082386017, 0.0003922632022295147, -0.01917300373315811, 0.026612453162670135, -0.05420159921050072, -0.040154632180929184, 0.026720454916357994, 0.01963970623910427, 0.047252438962459564, 0.003602967131882906, -0.03534579649567604, 0.031713955104351044, 0.011457500047981739, -0.023809202015399933, 0.02947150729596615, -0.004714778624475002, -0.06797702610492706, 0.004711765330284834, 0.012243010103702545, -0.02431950718164444, -0.039020344614982605, 0.0076931859366595745, -0.021297361701726913, -0.028430728241801262, 0.005255105439573526, 0.05823271721601486, -0.012735966593027115, -0.03054679185152054, 0.007512453943490982, -0.05017315223813057, -0.005787800066173077, 0.004397984594106674, -0.002913643140345812, -0.003650475526228547, 0.009949848055839539, 0.033075764775276184, 0.03462160751223564, -0.01576511561870575, -0.005180218257009983, -0.04771466180682182, -0.05705888569355011, 0.0025669855531305075, -0.01398707740008831, 0.017122121527791023, 0.0028634597547352314, -0.03203406557440758, 0.046004340052604675, 0.02936980500817299, -0.024046871811151505, -0.043791353702545166, 0.003533625276759267, -0.043103113770484924, -0.006787826772779226, -0.008874567225575447, 0.06265287101268768, 0.007457026746124029, -0.005023529287427664, 0.012115917168557644, 0.017460130155086517, 0.04022093117237091, -0.03574444726109505, 0.05255874991416931, 0.030390987172722816, 0.0020015116315335035, -0.0010120189981535077, 0.0549623966217041, -0.0009985902579501271, -0.00519597576931119, 0.008067331276834011, 0.006167444866150618, 0.0392926000058651, 0.025681329891085625, -0.0523066446185112, -0.005484219174832106, -0.006402390543371439, 0.001931649399921298, -0.038162410259246826, 0.039350476115942, 0.009281647391617298, -0.029875794425606728, 0.021419452503323555, 0.006586954928934574, 0.04095495864748955, -0.014865832403302193, 0.0033497600816190243, 0.028537210077047348, 0.0013549292925745249, -0.006832502316683531, 0.0032736475113779306, -0.025717878714203835, -0.02957775630056858, 0.00679063843563199, -0.06774946302175522, -0.0444120429456234, 0.0326668806374073, 0.019671129062771797, 0.02638362906873226, -0.0073681543581187725, -0.028777262195944786, 0.020505914464592934, -0.036528490483760834, 0.007777644321322441, -0.05057985708117485, 0.047071170061826706, 0.03728686645627022, 0.042053211480379105, -0.011745098978281021, -0.040933795273303986, 0.029336972162127495, -0.024297133088111877, -0.06204039230942726, 0.01880154199898243, -0.023377547040581703, 0.004385226871818304, 0.006078590173274279, 0.0004508591373451054, 0.06648976355791092, -0.02495265193283558, -0.015559329651296139, 0.0020215269178152084, 0.009744434617459774, -0.03171061351895332, 0.011040066368877888, 0.002245055977255106, -0.004857724066823721, 0.005456577055156231, 0.013083422556519508, 0.009067035280168056, 0.01287577860057354, 0.04782439395785332, 0.06824415922164917, -0.011627583764493465, -0.0019516658503562212, -0.00492075877264142, 0.006896514445543289, 0.019855044782161713, 0.044653721153736115, 0.05407918244600296, 0.02335176430642605, -0.053231097757816315, 0.01675347238779068, 0.016854649409651756, 0.031527839601039886, 0.027933351695537567, -0.028086243197321892, -0.030384264886379242, -0.024088434875011444, -0.007183364126831293, 0.030458087101578712, -0.009244789369404316, 0.014441984705626965, 0.009806550107896328, 0.038670726120471954, 0.05090280994772911, -0.021614642813801765, 0.03201109915971756, 0.09020949900150299, 0.028346888720989227, 0.01032376941293478, -0.006656227167695761, -0.015626562759280205, -0.0005014839116483927, -0.015177246183156967, 0.018314596265554428, 0.018500743433833122, -0.017382007092237473, 0.022940618917346, 0.036795951426029205, -0.020300231873989105, 0.00470481812953949, 0.0013754259562119842, 0.0038259674329310656, 0.023724067956209183, 0.0392187274992466, -0.022220568731427193, 0.039867911487817764, -0.0032255700789391994, 0.03828766942024231, 0.008099590428173542, 0.007355664856731892, -0.10540693253278732, 0.0024600219912827015, 0.03268368914723396, 0.02166256122291088, -0.022654155269265175, -0.0455777645111084, -0.0526980496942997, 0.013603508472442627, 0.019148213788866997, -0.004500484559684992, 0.009288504719734192, 0.020154301077127457, 0.011185013689100742, -0.04178940877318382, -0.04635416343808174, 0.004847881384193897, 0.05875105410814285, -0.0032378723844885826, 0.003063802607357502, -0.03175576403737068, -0.006379648111760616, -0.0388307087123394, -0.007116889581084251, 0.03112487681210041, 0.06811492145061493, -0.05678144842386246, -0.005952748935669661, 0.014263308607041836, 0.008317124098539352, -0.049464982002973557, -0.025559425354003906, 0.042476631700992584, -0.01900395378470421, -0.005609683692455292, 0.06479687988758087, -0.022163456305861473, -0.028249401599168777, 0.027814246714115143, 0.03726363927125931, -0.022618498653173447, 0.009072626009583473, -0.0001012452703434974, 0.05574314668774605, 0.03955161198973656, 0.019046498462557793, 0.06072952598333359, 0.021341748535633087, -0.00046600360656157136, 0.04026829078793526, -0.024482084438204765, 0.02839931659400463, -0.027285851538181305, 0.019327228888869286, -0.05828327685594559, 0.022704320028424263, -0.018794020637869835, 0.034730736166238785, -0.020198561251163483, 0.0015971909742802382, -0.032366469502449036, 0.033958666026592255, 0.0031188896391540766, 0.01813308522105217, -0.040176115930080414, -0.02818336896598339, 0.020014354959130287, 0.0025778531562536955, 0.02409578301012516, -0.009437370114028454, 0.011133695021271706, -0.0649009570479393, 0.02644854411482811, -0.020876184105873108, -0.042489442974328995, 0.014686448499560356, -0.040003325790166855, 0.013224657624959946, 0.004783574491739273, -0.03048224002122879, 0.025955118238925934, 0.011452770791947842, -0.007599169388413429, 0.005780372768640518, 0.0005764140514656901, -0.015180472284555435, 0.028407976031303406, -0.008182380348443985, 0.027240421622991562, -0.01477973535656929, 0.016556018963456154, 0.002413144102320075, -0.023064501583576202, -0.06432092934846878, -0.038205426186323166, 0.033270277082920074, 0.021836386993527412, -0.06240057945251465, -0.047242894768714905, -0.009062920697033405, 0.029404466971755028, -0.023907871916890144, -0.03457537665963173, 0.00723651610314846, -0.019260577857494354, -0.01634160242974758, -0.017030294984579086, 0.01789332740008831, 0.07873594015836716, 0.007421055808663368, 0.0030625772196799517, 0.006830041762441397, -0.011416052468121052, 0.0017866611015051603, -0.043580714613199234, -0.007055568043142557, -0.035595230758190155, -0.019479090347886086, -0.011983053758740425, 0.023232456296682358, 0.07832153886556625, -0.03783489763736725, -0.03505311906337738, -0.008488427847623825, 0.028612691909074783, 0.003450720338150859, -0.03346295282244682, -0.03185853362083435, -0.001393769052810967, -0.010195250622928143, -0.015710970386862755, 0.002526643220335245, -0.03478211909532547, -0.014363192021846771, 0.02091071382164955, -0.02269747108221054, -0.0244650449603796, 0.007714070379734039, 0.10618207603693008, 0.0006739479722455144, -0.0038026345428079367, 0.006249245256185532, -0.018578706309199333, 0.03346526250243187, 0.023855021223425865, -0.02906382642686367, 0.030025657266378403, -0.014335517771542072, -0.0264898668974638, -0.027676697820425034, -0.06671606004238129, 0.014287680387496948, 0.02920716628432274, -0.01131726335734129, 0.011283164843916893, 0.04633784666657448, 0.010103543289005756, 0.020801426842808723, -0.054005034267902374, -0.031420040875673294, -0.013845565728843212, 0.0050952560268342495, 0.015844471752643585, -0.04714493826031685, -0.015058229677379131, 0.04833275079727173, -0.0018392495112493634, -0.01571464352309704, 0.02918771281838417, 0.019110070541501045, 0.009895069524645805, 0.051229219883680344, -0.030738618224859238, 0.031017780303955078, 0.08115900307893753, -0.032105717808008194, 0.03546907752752304, -0.06000008434057236, -0.01791072078049183, 0.04498111829161644, 0.036309149116277695, -0.012430069968104362, -0.05440570414066315, -0.022233890369534492, -0.06543608009815216, 0.07114920020103455, 0.01835557445883751, 0.0037226707208901644, 0.07163231074810028, 0.05542151257395744, 0.041944947093725204, -0.010275044478476048, 0.03390255942940712, 0.0057899076491594315, -0.0753805860877037, -0.039248276501894, -0.011628057807683945, -0.040270037949085236, -0.007833961397409439, 0.006807749159634113, 0.008871913887560368, 0.0019521868089213967, -0.045361824333667755, 0.02606651559472084, -0.030947262421250343, 0.03402024880051613, -0.03314054757356644, 0.06737064570188522, -0.015471178106963634, 0.05061454698443413, -0.013281076215207577, -0.03195952996611595, 0.11612608283758163, 0.07323829084634781, 0.019831571727991104, -0.056526586413383484, 0.016032865270972252, 0.038203880190849304, 0.036740027368068695, -0.049054984003305435, 0.0024563269689679146, 0.005310909356921911, -0.015983864665031433, -0.000532531354110688, 0.06081676855683327, -0.0008676488068886101, -0.00600437680259347, 0.05406102538108826, -0.04920644313097, -0.015503519214689732, 0.004829064477235079, 0.017721567302942276, -0.03687819838523865, -0.02951713278889656, -0.043640993535518646, 0.022539276629686356, 0.013311512768268585, -0.012200539000332355, -0.03886686637997627, -0.009882226586341858, 0.002059154212474823, -0.015300698578357697, 0.027679791674017906, -0.002251263242214918, 0.0190329197794199, 0.02795715443789959, 0.012109218165278435, -0.018631722778081894, 0.008974513038992882, -0.03795807808637619, 0.02039474993944168, 0.07833932340145111, 0.01349773071706295, -0.021963469684123993, -0.01074827928096056, -0.01277897134423256, -0.025538109242916107, -0.02716493047773838, -0.05915708839893341, 0.030769117176532745, -0.02066919207572937, -0.003150789299979806, -0.011283253319561481, 0.011572656221687794, 0.005015150643885136, -0.014057548716664314, -0.01792520098388195, 0.03420114144682884, 0.01961950957775116, -0.020980745553970337, 0.005981443915516138, -0.03595826402306557, -0.009094775654375553, -0.012531409971415997, 0.04083161801099777, 0.033249109983444214, -0.025327078998088837, -0.022628968581557274, -0.06428106874227524, 0.061234187334775925, -0.018862521275877953, 0.02770882658660412, -0.010488249361515045, 0.02526572160422802, -0.037754692137241364, -0.04106682538986206, 0.006614070385694504, 0.004689149558544159, 0.017507512122392654, 0.005207905080169439, -0.012361026369035244, 0.007377490866929293, -0.02080778032541275, -0.002490261336788535, 0.008118271827697754, -0.03116592764854431, -0.03214961662888527, 0.00249481201171875, 0.060804761946201324, 0.023771628737449646, -0.0000037305867408576887, 0.045560747385025024, 0.02460896596312523, 0.06081515550613403, 0.017631908878684044, -0.06575978547334671, 0.010989661328494549, -0.011711742728948593, -0.028744366019964218, 0.004912970121949911, -0.055985670536756516, 0.05660567432641983, 0.024700786918401718, 0.0038793853018432856, 0.014579575508832932, 0.01148067507892847, -0.018703775480389595, 0.0017260534223169088, 0.017676228657364845, -0.04188738763332367, 0.02444271743297577, 0.001538239186629653, -0.006769296247512102, 0.010618478991091251, 0.001949034514836967, -0.02006508968770504, -0.008184617385268211, 0.04306972771883011, -0.02640276402235031, -0.039035823196172714, 0.002454559551551938, -0.011957693845033646, 0.006135872099548578, 0.004715322516858578, 0.0047010076232254505, 0.0263384822756052, 0.014700953848659992, -0.0003498340956866741, -0.0044968100264668465, -0.010831874795258045, 0.010669032111763954, -0.025129543617367744, 0.01222349051386118, 0.02527836710214615, -0.009441988542675972, 0.005327271763235331, 0.005987065378576517, 0.0017226629424840212, 0.009961215779185295, 0.006414750590920448, -0.007471789605915546, -0.01492977049201727, 0.013697290793061256, -0.048586998134851456, -0.028643343597650528, -0.002315754070878029, 0.053320057690143585, 0.059308603405952454, -0.011963652446866035, -0.0028273556381464005, -0.036051709204912186, 0.06879749894142151, -0.023145923390984535, 0.0008160511497408152, -0.025914287194609642, 0.016917342320084572, 0.016423899680376053, 0.026965539902448654, -0.015193100087344646, 0.014745306223630905, 0.017777102068066597, 0.015171799808740616, 0.07165882736444473, -0.004272804129868746, -0.0107151223346591, -0.026163341477513313, -0.023755468428134918, 0.017354028299450874, 0.022928442806005478, 0.014885672368109226, 0.052480533719062805, 0.07874834537506104, 0.019347552210092545, 0.002641933737322688, -0.028144221752882004, -0.0057969773188233376, -0.07905466854572296, -0.015345395542681217, 0.01270880177617073, 0.004197940230369568, 0.03803060203790665, -0.05937737599015236, 0.02102743275463581, 0.022905003279447556, -0.032466910779476166, 0.004825099837034941, -0.005510863848030567, 0.01645299233496189, -0.03211088106036186, -0.03686868026852608, -0.021743301302194595, 0.022336861118674278, 0.029979679733514786, -0.004330693278461695, 0.05690273270010948, 0.028541147708892822, -0.016523975878953934, -0.028525888919830322, -0.020867936313152313, -0.0010030845878645778, 0.02361939661204815, -0.08037108927965164, 0.05894266441464424, -0.035121090710163116, -0.023745840415358543, 0.020664149895310402, 0.011586234904825687, 0.024701548740267754, 0.03096461109817028, 0.009706535376608372, -0.005708533804863691, 0.033168725669384, 0.07446350902318954, 0.0140893729403615, -0.016768718138337135, -0.005594000220298767, 0.029074247926473618, -0.014893744140863419, -0.032577645033597946, 0.03260413929820061, 0.030606091022491455, -0.022389067336916924, -0.026661427691578865, -0.007421780843287706, -0.046507351100444794, 0.014634846709668636, -0.021763170138001442, -0.05122862756252289, 0.022368134930729866, -0.0065419673919677734, 0.01341251004487276, -0.02573607861995697, -0.013114526867866516, 0.05682161822915077, 0.04722186550498009, 0.01710633561015129, -0.0031826579943299294, -0.052207332104444504, -0.04107603058218956, -0.007962755858898163, -0.010414037853479385, -0.012843134813010693, -0.05389672890305519, 0.00751128513365984, -0.007286763750016689, -0.01638707146048546, -0.058765850961208344, 0.004184765741229057, -0.02848046086728573, 0.009257358498871326, -0.014444185420870781, -0.00914681889116764, 0.02516242302954197, -0.00798420887440443, 0.026916706934571266, -0.06175672635436058, 0.0640113577246666, 0.011843490414321423, -0.05381530523300171, -0.027687419205904007, -0.02000783383846283, -0.030558297410607338, 0.024747638031840324, 0.04439736157655716, -0.009953242726624012, -0.0036315396428108215, -0.05406962335109711, 0.003150645177811384, 0.03595130890607834, -0.043848179280757904, 0.04284744709730148, -0.03433584049344063, -0.00963680911809206, -0.014231824316084385, 0.014660710468888283, 0.038189489394426346, -0.01532437652349472, 0.01191665232181549, -0.008176686242222786, -0.009400984272360802, 0.009346033446490765, -0.023879310116171837, -0.035677243024110794, -0.02216327004134655, -0.042568378150463104, 0.047885216772556305, 0.0003739256353583187, 0.005947640165686607, -0.004792574793100357, 0.004145047627389431, -0.07510014623403549, 0.026578301563858986, -0.04144122079014778, -0.030010294169187546, 0.008558804169297218, -0.015705792233347893, -0.0007753540412522852, -0.07420959323644638, 0.015123539604246616, 0.020180677995085716, -0.054712116718292236, -0.0012308225268498063, 0.019259734079241753, 0.026374787092208862, 0.014964165166020393, -0.029729606583714485, -0.00326217501424253, 0.008184410631656647, -0.0033834867645055056, 0.019361479207873344, -0.005444889888167381, 0.020330969244241714, -0.0065218606032431126, 0.0015560489846393466, 0.02370937168598175, -0.024510174989700317, 0.008020629175007343, 0.014957457780838013, 0.02693234570324421, -0.025827161967754364, 0.005604109261184931, 0.041633542627096176, 0.0021563228219747543, -0.0009847385808825493, 0.00876160990446806, -0.015072987414896488, 0.05994029343128204, -0.004536080174148083, 0.00810677744448185, -0.028755484148859978, -0.002458310453221202, -0.049320511519908905, 0.031547971069812775, -0.0014066093135625124, 0.014244762249290943, -0.014247984625399113, 0.04471871256828308, -0.005160217639058828, -0.026807107031345367, 0.00531935365870595, -0.01242207083851099, 0.015215868130326271, -0.03989177942276001, -0.0006282266112975776, 0.0038708257488906384, 0.03116256557404995, -0.027906853705644608, -0.011621461249887943, 0.004294995218515396, -0.027314331382513046, 0.03433452919125557, -0.0243800338357687, -0.024684717878699303, 0.01721888594329357, 0.031837910413742065, 0.00026534145581535995, -0.01854117587208748, -0.0646979883313179, -0.013529074378311634, 0.00500100664794445, -0.027120402082800865 ]
<p>Here are my data:</p> <pre><code> Substrate Species Human.Impact Count 1 rubbles E. quadricolor 0 0 2 corals and rubbles E. quadricolor 0 0 3 corals E. quadricolor 0 4 4 corals and sand E. quadricolor 0 0 5 sand E. quadricolor 0 0 6 rubbles S. mertensii 0 0 7 corals and rubbles S. mertensii 0 2 8 corals S. mertensii 0 10 9 corals and sand S. mertensii 0 9 10 sand S. mertensii 0 0 11 rubbles H. crispa 0 0 12 corals and rubbles H. crispa 0 6 13 corals H. crispa 0 6 14 corals and sand H. crispa 0 5 15 sand H. crispa 0 0 16 rubbles M. doreensis 0 0 17 corals and rubbles M. doreensis 0 0 18 corals M. doreensis 0 0 19 corals and sand M. doreensis 0 0 20 sand M. doreensis 0 0 21 rubbles H. magnifica 0 0 22 corals and rubbles H. magnifica 0 0 23 corals H. magnifica 0 1 24 corals and sand H. magnifica 0 0 25 sand H. magnifica 0 0 26 rubbles S. gigantea 0 0 27 corals and rubbles S. gigantea 0 0 28 corals S. gigantea 0 0 29 corals and sand S. gigantea 0 0 30 sand S. gigantea 0 0 31 rubbles H. aurora 0 0 32 corals and rubbles H. aurora 0 0 33 corals H. aurora 0 2 34 corals and sand H. aurora 0 4 35 sand H. aurora 0 0 36 rubbles E. quadricolor 1 0 37 corals and rubbles E. quadricolor 1 0 38 corals E. quadricolor 1 8 39 corals and sand E. quadricolor 1 0 40 sand E. quadricolor 1 0 41 rubbles S. mertensii 1 0 42 corals and rubbles S. mertensii 1 0 43 corals S. mertensii 1 0 44 corals and sand S. mertensii 1 0 45 sand S. mertensii 1 0 46 rubbles H. crispa 1 0 47 corals and rubbles H. crispa 1 0 48 corals H. crispa 1 18 49 corals and sand H. crispa 1 0 50 sand H. crispa 1 0 51 rubbles M. doreensis 1 0 52 corals and rubbles M. doreensis 1 0 53 corals M. doreensis 1 0 54 corals and sand M. doreensis 1 0 55 sand M. doreensis 1 0 56 rubbles H. magnifica 1 0 57 corals and rubbles H. magnifica 1 0 58 corals H. magnifica 1 3 59 corals and sand H. magnifica 1 0 60 sand H. magnifica 1 0 61 rubbles S. gigantea 1 0 62 corals and rubbles S. gigantea 1 0 63 corals S. gigantea 1 1 64 corals and sand S. gigantea 1 0 65 sand S. gigantea 1 0 66 rubbles H. aurora 1 0 67 corals and rubbles H. aurora 1 0 68 corals H. aurora 1 1 69 corals and sand H. aurora 1 0 70 sand H. aurora 1 0 71 rubbles E. quadricolor 2 0 72 corals and rubbles E. quadricolor 2 0 73 corals E. quadricolor 2 0 74 corals and sand E. quadricolor 2 1 75 sand E. quadricolor 2 0 76 rubbles S. mertensii 2 0 77 corals and rubbles S. mertensii 2 0 78 corals S. mertensii 2 2 79 corals and sand S. mertensii 2 1 80 sand S. mertensii 2 0 81 rubbles H. crispa 2 0 82 corals and rubbles H. crispa 2 0 83 corals H. crispa 2 0 84 corals and sand H. crispa 2 3 85 sand H. crispa 2 0 86 rubbles M. doreensis 2 0 87 corals and rubbles M. doreensis 2 0 88 corals M. doreensis 2 0 89 corals and sand M. doreensis 2 0 90 sand M. doreensis 2 0 91 rubbles H. magnifica 2 0 92 corals and rubbles H. magnifica 2 0 93 corals H. magnifica 2 0 94 corals and sand H. magnifica 2 0 95 sand H. magnifica 2 0 96 rubbles S. gigantea 2 0 97 corals and rubbles S. gigantea 2 0 98 corals S. gigantea 2 0 99 corals and sand S. gigantea 2 0 100 sand S. gigantea 2 0 101 rubbles H. aurora 2 0 102 corals and rubbles H. aurora 2 0 103 corals H. aurora 2 4 104 corals and sand H. aurora 2 5 105 sand H. aurora 2 0 106 rubbles E. quadricolor 3 0 107 corals and rubbles E. quadricolor 3 0 108 corals E. quadricolor 3 0 109 corals and sand E. quadricolor 3 0 110 sand E. quadricolor 3 0 111 rubbles S. mertensii 3 2 112 corals and rubbles S. mertensii 3 0 113 corals S. mertensii 3 1 114 corals and sand S. mertensii 3 0 115 sand S. mertensii 3 0 116 rubbles H. crispa 3 1 117 corals and rubbles H. crispa 3 0 118 corals H. crispa 3 6 119 corals and sand H. crispa 3 3 120 sand H. crispa 3 0 121 rubbles M. doreensis 3 0 122 corals and rubbles M. doreensis 3 0 123 corals M. doreensis 3 3 124 corals and sand M. doreensis 3 0 125 sand M. doreensis 3 0 126 rubbles H. magnifica 3 0 127 corals and rubbles H. magnifica 3 0 128 corals H. magnifica 3 0 129 corals and sand H. magnifica 3 0 130 sand H. magnifica 3 0 131 rubbles S. gigantea 3 1 132 corals and rubbles S. gigantea 3 0 133 corals S. gigantea 3 5 134 corals and sand S. gigantea 3 0 135 sand S. gigantea 3 2 136 rubbles H. aurora 3 0 137 corals and rubbles H. aurora 3 0 138 corals H. aurora 3 8 139 corals and sand H. aurora 3 3 140 sand H. aurora 3 0 </code></pre> <p>I'd like to know if the species are found in random substrate or if each species seem to have its own personal substrate.</p> <p>Here is I think might be good (coded in R):</p> <pre><code>summary(glm(Count ~ substrate * species + Human.impact, data=myData, family='Poisson')) </code></pre> <p>Does it seem good to you? All p.values are extremely close to 1 (except for <code>Human.impact</code>). Am I missing something or is there really no difference in habitat choice per species?</p> <p>Note: <code>Human.impact</code> is added in order to remove some unwilling variance of the model.</p>
36,245
[ -0.04880087077617645, -0.03214755281805992, -0.0021792161278426647, 0.010921023786067963, 0.01125653088092804, -0.005927611142396927, -0.02332957275211811, -0.010263537056744099, -0.0017847857670858502, -0.07487784326076508, 0.042388591915369034, 0.0171807873994112, 0.03829175606369972, 0.06901756674051285, 0.044013313949108124, -0.03324609994888306, -0.027798473834991455, -0.02364678680896759, -0.004616834223270416, -0.00023658970894757658, -0.02493840456008911, -0.031686700880527496, 0.03789708390831947, -0.024187983945012093, -0.021553166210651398, 0.023929402232170105, 0.04823346063494682, 0.010444107465445995, 0.007009916473180056, -0.014318433590233326, -0.006193955894559622, -0.03799808770418167, -0.013423092663288116, 0.004535982385277748, 0.03744374215602875, 0.03846697881817818, -0.07101655751466751, -0.0022908367682248354, 0.01380884274840355, 0.029297664761543274, 0.013570334762334824, 0.0031819259747862816, 0.015622612088918686, 0.02940516360104084, -0.02101070247590542, 0.020490361377596855, 0.010136538185179234, 0.03816293179988861, 0.034993890672922134, -0.012672550976276398, 0.06783366203308105, -0.01649654656648636, 0.0532243512570858, -0.030699988827109337, -0.015409514307975769, 0.016740411520004272, 0.026721689850091934, 0.08174551278352737, 0.0033403458073735237, -0.049437329173088074, 0.011747464537620544, -0.03748169541358948, -0.018268143758177757, -0.03884746506810188, -0.0001863636716734618, 0.04605071246623993, -0.019296716898679733, -0.040844935923814774, 0.059294186532497406, -0.01119375042617321, -0.009385512210428715, -0.02738252654671669, 0.004386512096971273, -0.038335759192705154, 0.007883028127253056, -0.019090954214334488, 0.047034721821546555, 0.02056216262280941, -0.007140389643609524, 0.006958537269383669, 0.019967397674918175, 0.019755100831389427, 0.01663215644657612, -0.009496013633906841, 0.08121602237224579, -0.012513176538050175, 0.010313356295228004, -0.0019056908786296844, -0.0014311844715848565, 0.011133724823594093, 0.06297476589679718, -0.02806256338953972, 0.07408802211284637, 0.04071604833006859, 0.0076241400092840195, -0.0014428283320739865, 0.011254868470132351, 0.020530857145786285, -0.027612177655100822, 0.015356197953224182, -0.015019644983112812, -0.046515341848134995, 0.04659123718738556, 0.025110362097620964, -0.01430897880345583, -0.0038764835335314274, -0.08346129208803177, -0.033214520663022995, -0.0409473218023777, 0.017663268372416496, 0.006879592780023813, 0.002665309002622962, 0.018399260938167572, -0.024520745500922203, -0.0082784965634346, -0.054477278143167496, 0.0014565234305337071, 0.003624177072197199, 0.04125650227069855, 0.05367105454206467, 0.059856683015823364, -0.015344465151429176, 0.024019472301006317, -0.0406973659992218, -0.06951583921909332, 0.01581638678908348, 0.020826058462262154, -0.01600976474583149, 0.0016207501757889986, 0.05290622636675835, -0.03532036766409874, 0.000028101829229854047, 0.04535703733563423, -0.044213078916072845, 0.02461608313024044, -0.005905440077185631, -0.06879708170890808, -0.047986675053834915, 0.031209809705615044, 0.01716000586748123, 0.04252682626247406, -0.06359923630952835, 0.022739510983228683, -0.0029527777805924416, 0.0025751006323844194, 0.026374777778983116, 0.005184222012758255, 0.03136787936091423, 0.028332985937595367, 0.011594447307288647, -0.022258389741182327, 0.021914731711149216, -0.008839210495352745, -0.016951661556959152, -0.027199285104870796, -0.038116589188575745, 0.0018564136698842049, -0.04843578860163689, 0.012636513449251652, 0.0016203615814447403, 0.06594779342412949, -0.010324542410671711, 0.019520781934261322, -0.010501045733690262, -0.062306083738803864, -0.04168953374028206, 0.059271201491355896, 0.004454408306628466, -0.003396113170310855, 0.03634076565504074, 0.02269706502556801, -0.0056589702144265175, -0.018997633829712868, 0.005874041002243757, 0.030547436326742172, -0.036774251610040665, 0.02189583145081997, -0.02852649986743927, -0.004464142024517059, 0.016049211844801903, -0.036879535764455795, -0.04816577211022377, -0.0012075367849320173, -0.01897626742720604, 0.06467612087726593, 0.0305152740329504, 0.029428653419017792, -0.06383733451366425, 0.030507976189255714, -0.0681794136762619, -0.03019084595143795, -0.07311419397592545, 0.007238204125314951, -0.032540276646614075, -0.007791534531861544, -0.013921027071774006, 0.008232943713665009, 0.005701277870684862, 0.024087021127343178, 0.043157514184713364, -0.0003200677747372538, -0.0013695380184799433, 0.05560382455587387, -0.05255815014243126, -0.03561006858944893, 0.014880619943141937, 0.011768888682126999, -0.012786196544766426, 0.013925548642873764, -0.03657267987728119, 0.014484007842838764, 0.034176286309957504, -0.0101557532325387, 0.0019281255081295967, 0.020047426223754883, -0.004702602978795767, -0.01055175717920065, 0.033728841692209244, -0.017565174028277397, 0.0159878209233284, -0.04785725474357605, 0.043718013912439346, 0.07482120394706726, 0.015081368386745453, 0.04681858420372009, -0.04433618113398552, -0.008729275315999985, 0.020011307671666145, -0.03282160684466362, -0.022497916594147682, -0.05783325433731079, 0.029292041435837746, 0.03286994248628616, -0.0039571854285895824, 0.008035792969167233, -0.011256728321313858, 0.03226608783006668, 0.005724800750613213, 0.01633846014738083, 0.017333317548036575, -0.02819250524044037, -0.012537824921309948, 0.05806341767311096, 0.02319609932601452, 0.019900590181350708, -0.029953308403491974, -0.004984861705452204, 0.027560152113437653, 0.04217527061700821, -0.0045630005188286304, 0.029984407126903534, 0.012187047861516476, 0.0207094457000494, -0.000571666460018605, -0.0053181881085038185, -0.029114166274666786, 0.05472716689109802, -0.013402128592133522, -0.012209801934659481, 0.08433052897453308, 0.011154293082654476, -0.045531339943408966, -0.033118393272161484, 0.0024995477870106697, -0.008849512785673141, 0.006207602098584175, 0.008189106360077858, 0.021217050030827522, 0.019141610711812973, -0.04461079463362694, 0.04138452559709549, 0.02476065419614315, -0.042048271745443344, -0.03811406344175339, 0.013062839396297932, 0.04427865147590637, 0.03398403525352478, 0.07776342332363129, -0.055133845657110214, 0.02440226823091507, -0.0011487252777442336, -0.038915131241083145, 0.024464646354317665, -0.0024217308964580297, -0.05865582078695297, -0.006136792246252298, -0.005642708856612444, 0.00967627763748169, 0.03339376300573349, -0.008025330491364002, -0.06808087974786758, 0.02515505999326706, -0.0008555083768442273, -0.003790672169998288, 0.00341894687153399, -0.014892271719872952, 0.012795725837349892, -0.01142466627061367, -0.03294552490115166, 0.06972864270210266, 0.03254563733935356, -0.04875429719686508, 0.004986917600035667, -0.04776942729949951, -0.012570589780807495, 0.014712793752551079, -0.025362497195601463, -0.04879912734031677, -0.000250743527431041, -0.025670338422060013, -0.009000466205179691, -0.0040447525680065155, -0.0010986034758388996, -0.018246322870254517, -0.08954744786024094, -0.012767020612955093, -0.024200694635510445, 0.0327010303735733, -0.01782584749162197, -0.012862201780080795, 0.04352010414004326, 0.040223754942417145, -0.013351953588426113, -0.03502357006072998, 0.005791300907731056, -0.020988408476114273, -0.005483550019562244, 0.017615899443626404, -0.007980662398040295, 0.006214645225554705, -0.007228359580039978, -0.02387385442852974, 0.0522911474108696, 0.02422274649143219, -0.019110968336462975, 0.023023908957839012, -0.011731481179594994, 0.032777007669210434, -0.01464787032455206, 0.020484747365117073, 0.04383464157581329, -0.014188669621944427, 0.034083615988492966, -0.01800304837524891, -0.008059623651206493, -0.027368735522031784, -0.02259150706231594, -0.04804491624236107, 0.011700477451086044, 0.031257789582014084, -0.04091589152812958, -0.02819807268679142, 0.008285521529614925, 0.0032171932980418205, -0.02220824360847473, 0.003009121399372816, 0.06185101345181465, -0.033101990818977356, 0.0059355441480875015, 0.04933583736419678, 0.024043509736657143, 0.02860081009566784, 0.040869928896427155, -0.03274429589509964, 0.018182743340730667, -0.0015042895684018731, -0.04547550529241562, 0.0008680193568579853, 0.014427931979298592, 0.03462490066885948, 0.00018581218319013715, 0.028458738699555397, -0.04966402426362038, -0.01622243970632553, -0.019490806385874748, -0.015825655311346054, -0.017685571685433388, 0.04233890026807785, 0.0020848477724939585, 0.011236966587603092, -0.004298207350075245, -0.040498021990060806, -0.03410810977220535, 0.02639223448932171, -0.005534667056053877, 0.013483247719705105, 0.02084488235414028, 0.02786041423678398, 0.046950604766607285, -0.030741466209292412, -0.003643908305093646, 0.0270647332072258, -0.0017858295468613505, 0.010893288068473339, -0.02895602025091648, -0.030703870579600334, -0.00012016380787827075, 0.01744740642607212, -0.01579376868903637, -0.0072629996575415134, 0.02526024915277958, 0.004022523760795593, -0.02191794291138649, 0.02463485300540924, 0.050930049270391464, -0.036810681223869324, 0.018480747938156128, -0.014300582930445671, -0.010772932320833206, 0.0055409446358680725, 0.016411811113357544, -0.010495799593627453, 0.029303906485438347, -0.027552155777812004, -0.023623045533895493, -0.02430219016969204, 0.018347594887018204, 0.037340112030506134, 0.01262064091861248, 0.01676865667104721, 0.02134017087519169, -0.012496661394834518, 0.014529943466186523, 0.00645010732114315, 0.012960229068994522, -0.018638938665390015, 0.03840388357639313, 0.047086384147405624, -0.02036471664905548, 0.028298672288656235, 0.05997217074036598, 0.005276473239064217, -0.016846802085638046, -0.04264175891876221, -0.0225191842764616, -0.030382437631487846, -0.002938435412943363, 0.013071688823401928, 0.03994135186076164, 0.0042441547848284245, 0.022466883063316345, 0.005907369777560234, -0.025452440604567528, -0.051094941794872284, 0.011763432063162327, -0.007333326153457165, 0.030399736016988754, -0.051043760031461716, -0.0001756170386215672, 0.023463333025574684, 0.03862396255135536, 0.03209773078560829, -0.01646360754966736, -0.0013472496066242456, -0.06695721298456192, -0.019139938056468964, 0.02048199251294136, 0.035453274846076965, -0.004741170909255743, -0.04333381727337837, -0.048712436109781265, -0.002225820440798998, 0.02160540036857128, -0.06756512075662613, -0.0014555298257619143, -0.008054031990468502, 0.039611127227544785, -0.02022480219602585, -0.04090451821684837, -0.03826836124062538, -0.014292867854237556, 0.012017782777547836, 0.036851439625024796, -0.016498010605573654, -0.04872528091073036, -0.018142111599445343, 0.03045632503926754, -0.010083734057843685, 0.03852338343858719, -0.04160630330443382, 0.008122158236801624, 0.011261975392699242, -0.028723163530230522, -0.04285930097103119, 0.007117934990674257, 0.028024058789014816, -0.030306462198495865, 0.014834887348115444, 0.06858277320861816, -0.012811209075152874, 0.012164445593953133, -0.0022611834574490786, 0.04077617824077606, -0.013294659554958344, -0.04878707975149155, -0.0055510676465928555, 0.0324803963303566, 0.02784671075642109, -0.001270017120987177, 0.07689334452152252, 0.0330369807779789, -0.044478029012680054, -0.010213560424745083, -0.06827955693006516, -0.01651035062968731, -0.01742042973637581, 0.0010054227896034718, -0.048178549855947495, 0.0027928885538131, -0.029844660311937332, 0.012345045804977417, 0.02287665754556656, 0.004485615994781256, -0.012158210389316082, 0.02142150141298771, 0.02442319318652153, 0.020882096141576767, -0.023054128512740135, -0.011570747941732407, -0.017389491200447083, -0.014698735438287258, 0.01995675638318062, -0.02886885777115822, 0.04265633597970009, -0.04103024676442146, -0.010697031393647194, -0.02768591418862343, -0.007109392900019884, 0.014912071637809277, -0.0407215915620327, -0.008874931372702122, 0.023141680285334587, -0.049573153257369995, -0.022731618955731392, 0.013497178442776203, 0.03589444234967232, 0.02147221378982067, -0.04405582696199417, -0.01396226231008768, 0.00039279984775930643, -0.014623868279159069, -0.019817141816020012, -0.01535813044756651, 0.05016805976629257, 0.06466618180274963, 0.026171470060944557, -0.032421886920928955, -0.014349189586937428, 0.017530987039208412, 0.016752205789089203, -0.024555977433919907, -0.042579617351293564, -0.033308032900094986, -0.010301867499947548, 0.007427144795656204, 0.006062794476747513, 0.04430273175239563, -0.06217852979898453, -0.016138490289449692, -0.00410672789439559, -0.0033771852031350136, 0.062272168695926666, -0.0036909794434905052, 0.022189946845173836, 0.014157342724502087, -0.007429943419992924, -0.027303388342261314, -0.001765018911100924, -0.005407813936471939, -0.02643868327140808, -0.01925107277929783, -0.02069481462240219, 0.00900229811668396, 0.01886364445090294, -0.007420853246003389, 0.00478367879986763, -0.03569857403635979, -0.001538574113510549, 0.008661285974085331, -0.0016792556270956993, -0.0036380786914378405, 0.008317278698086739, -0.027393214404582977, -0.03806094080209732, 0.050307370722293854, -0.009102455340325832, -0.02121114730834961, 0.01625032350420952, -0.0038512262981384993, -0.03104241192340851, 0.040851008147001266, 0.06470522284507751, -0.019479086622595787, -0.00707125011831522, 0.008327456191182137, -0.04628468677401543, 0.0439421720802784, 0.012285337783396244, -0.022342141717672348, -0.02415221370756626, 0.033365990966558456, -0.01938583329319954, 0.0015864446759223938, -0.02553192898631096, 0.016340482980012894, 0.02723045088350773, -0.01020706444978714, 0.008427087217569351, 0.029093937948346138, 0.00766229210421443, 0.02634233795106411, -0.0294661782681942, -0.001742496038787067, 0.044988613575696945, 0.01680273376405239, 0.06891962885856628, -0.009452289901673794, -0.0013363808393478394, 0.050681065768003464, 0.010697723366320133, 0.029366979375481606, 0.048414476215839386, 0.021715868264436722, -0.003465528367087245, -0.03919898718595505, -0.03847397118806839, -0.012196660973131657, 0.016916217282414436, -0.05776004120707512, 0.026811059564352036, -0.00746636837720871, -0.013815420679748058, 0.04652576893568039, 0.06834936887025833, -0.02980109676718712, -0.07939998060464859, -0.01196279190480709, -0.04636494442820549, 0.03795608878135681, 0.02355973981320858, -0.009435552172362804, 0.03735332190990448, 0.0351281575858593, 0.06254024803638458, -0.04771547392010689, 0.039814967662096024, -0.027197863906621933, -0.05491071566939354, -0.02771577797830105, -0.015703625977039337, -0.04363042861223221, 0.04223254323005676, 0.034956179559230804, -0.019124547019600868, 0.03235013410449028, -0.013756664469838142, 0.009032411500811577, 0.019593633711338043, 0.03063800558447838, 0.0018395931692793965, 0.041986070573329926, -0.0100522106513381, -0.013760603964328766, -0.007143775466829538, -0.039013829082250595, 0.1651093065738678, 0.09457380324602127, 0.048654355108737946, -0.004343744367361069, -0.019920451566576958, 0.04290681704878807, -0.011391975916922092, 0.01225548516958952, -0.04192304611206055, 0.0398118831217289, -0.02539992332458496, 0.0458931103348732, 0.01948579028248787, 0.04935987666249275, 0.011109943501651287, 0.026191892102360725, -0.02610095404088497, -0.00827886164188385, 0.0256595928221941, -0.02416764572262764, -0.013173921965062618, -0.01083293929696083, -0.058182038366794586, -0.016078580170869827, 0.015009569004178047, -0.025494568049907684, -0.05219774320721626, -0.003441982204094529, 0.008273635990917683, 0.009364272467792034, -0.023315655067563057, 0.025259068235754967, -0.007686480414122343, 0.014709783717989922, 0.021886631846427917, -0.021027283743023872, 0.022170376032590866, -0.02150776796042919, -0.011537856422364712, 0.021703775972127914, -0.01467809733003378, 0.006100875791162252, -0.014818225987255573, 0.040704067796468735, -0.03813296556472778, 0.017795804888010025, -0.05753638595342636, 0.03336618095636368, -0.020649434998631477, -0.00962522067129612, 0.009350103326141834, 0.010988468304276466, 0.0006194185698404908, -0.00507920840755105, 0.014561737887561321, 0.04339879751205444, 0.02975132130086422, 0.008737653493881226, -0.011707362718880177, 0.000393271999200806, -0.006005802657455206, -0.022749075666069984, 0.00013952446170151234, 0.027430688962340355, 0.027295837178826332, -0.058890849351882935, -0.025875451043248177, 0.033482931554317474, -0.01620246097445488, 0.010067688301205635, -0.01971270702779293, -0.04229895770549774, -0.024398338049650192, -0.0005454186466522515, 0.024995679035782814, 0.04451978951692581, 0.02051190473139286, 0.014575790613889694, -0.09433199465274811, -0.08911625295877457, -0.01038004457950592, 0.02434220351278782, -0.0413653701543808, -0.05615059286355972, -0.04855143651366234, -0.029751481488347054, 0.009365019388496876, 0.028681308031082153, 0.03606152534484863, 0.05051520839333534, 0.0036248122341930866, 0.03204362094402313, -0.016288885846734047, -0.02906976453959942, -0.04742377996444702, 0.03463008999824524, -0.025969505310058594, -0.0030532870441675186, -0.02609686739742756, 0.03809502720832825, 0.04499946907162666, -0.013375651091337204, 0.0486859567463398, 0.05919475853443146, 0.0038141796831041574, 0.0027062471490353346, 0.032118868082761765, -0.01784875988960266, 0.0005618254072032869, 0.03384336456656456, 0.02033895254135132, -0.020905740559101105, 0.003169892355799675, -0.00482893968001008, -0.029426177963614464, -0.02619720809161663, -0.006709431763738394, -0.03127441182732582, 0.018898669630289078, -0.034622788429260254, 0.0033466247841715813, -0.01407652162015438, -0.00882314145565033, -0.06697803735733032, -0.026276573538780212, 0.031766992062330246, -0.005779210478067398, -0.02962203323841095, 0.0012421561405062675, -0.03232550248503685, 0.014689614996314049, 0.00526238651946187, -0.03165401890873909, -0.008402152918279171, 0.013455107808113098, 0.009500744752585888, 0.01995517872273922, 0.01991330087184906, 0.005173415876924992, 0.01914253644645214, 0.0007472708821296692, -0.04257940500974655, -0.055692512542009354, 0.00712877232581377, 0.009846978820860386, 0.048213403671979904, 0.014017368666827679, 0.023760316893458366, 0.014444295316934586, 0.08160177618265152, -0.0004910343559458852, -0.03349122405052185, -0.032967593520879745, -0.026762859895825386, -0.0017199874855577946, 0.021575406193733215, 0.008713257499039173, 0.03163500130176544, -0.057942118495702744, 0.02421264722943306, 0.05170159041881561, 0.02946080081164837, -0.020741816610097885, -0.04518352076411247, -0.06486301124095917, -0.008711302652955055, 0.02607725001871586, 0.007024264428764582, 0.0186440609395504, 0.05055942013859749, 0.0024021067656576633, 0.029636166989803314, -0.0002643104235175997, -0.01701797917485237, -0.0040922705084085464, -0.009717890992760658, -0.003056127345189452, 0.0010934065794572234, 0.0872771218419075, -0.06975468248128891, 0.01208201702684164, 0.030789820477366447, -0.018007928505539894, -0.012116125784814358, 0.003925767261534929, 0.01481692399829626, -0.022219887003302574, 0.03191475570201874, -0.052022386342287064, -0.01997922733426094, 0.02145984023809433, 0.04269780218601227, 0.08094348758459091, 0.013895468786358833, -0.020214714109897614, -0.024332096800208092, -0.02100088633596897, 0.03961202874779701, 0.01675335504114628, -0.0013657583622261882, 0.0021793951746076345, -0.031310051679611206, 0.025435933843255043, 0.012335257604718208, -0.03581392765045166, 0.01668301224708557, -0.010371784679591656, 0.033969730138778687, 0.037216976284980774, 0.03661312907934189, 0.006146602798253298, 0.01218654029071331, -0.03656370937824249, 0.002018802799284458, -0.018734322860836983, 0.014510007575154305, 0.013498605228960514, 0.02697649411857128, 0.024103112518787384, -0.017835235223174095, 0.0033017508685588837, 0.020858336240053177, 0.026161354035139084, 0.005704894196242094, -0.04460352659225464, -0.004099669400602579, 0.04664017632603645, -0.009294244460761547, -0.019449763000011444, -0.027127401903271675, 0.056473612785339355, 0.024299416691064835, -0.03244129195809364, -0.003980078734457493, 0.007517457474023104, 0.031158121302723885, -0.019832393154501915, -0.04524238407611847, 0.008062707260251045, -0.02756117843091488, -0.018897179514169693, -0.020210228860378265, -0.015987960621714592, -0.008464772254228592, -0.015916641801595688, 0.04951123520731926, -0.04620565474033356, 0.05697356164455414, -0.020534105598926544, -0.006130596622824669, 0.03883372247219086, -0.028013138100504875, 0.03475417569279671, -0.036780357360839844, 0.033753011375665665, 0.014560016803443432, -0.026930460706353188, -0.0530274398624897, 0.007819185964763165, -0.016135936602950096, 0.03714067116379738, 0.029884660616517067, -0.03790726885199547, 0.011272864416241646, -0.03546542301774025, -0.022846268489956856, 0.009806017391383648, -0.033332567662000656, 0.06931938976049423, -0.0008824792457744479, 0.00920865312218666, -0.018638458102941513, 0.026045482605695724, 0.013629290275275707, 0.01490815356373787, 0.0150718679651618, -0.012724372558295727, 0.005102348048239946, 0.004787664860486984, -0.04600829631090164, 0.0024776572827249765, -0.03478451445698738, -0.017536964267492294, 0.026035035029053688, 0.020506948232650757, 0.0043524750508368015, 0.05068594589829445, -0.03849304839968681, -0.03813006356358528, 0.04126714915037155, -0.022090904414653778, -0.00464254105463624, 0.03603646531701088, 0.00022857490694150329, 0.011132496409118176, -0.04054320231080055, 0.0248586293309927, 0.02204059436917305, -0.004748310428112745, -0.010855083353817463, 0.024560630321502686, 0.007010395638644695, 0.05482150986790657, -0.07336558401584625, 0.04144791141152382, -0.02648092433810234, -0.06156187504529953, 0.03663276880979538, 0.040716469287872314, -0.03665183112025261, -0.00419420562684536, 0.00795791670680046, 0.004149741493165493, 0.00911518931388855, 0.01268710009753704, -0.004312851000577211, 0.05149711295962334, 0.024086181074380875, -0.00008763840742176399, -0.013146770186722279, -0.0009689086582511663, -0.018640225753188133, 0.041242871433496475, -0.012695787474513054, 0.02921694703400135, -0.02850157953798771, -0.009743277914822102, -0.027237478643655777, -0.028909927234053612, -0.038879863917827606, 0.02547859214246273, -0.04149225354194641, 0.01598130166530609, -0.0031949190888553858, -0.0016112582525238395, 0.02340819127857685, -0.0038618443068116903, 0.0657745897769928, -0.013610996305942535, 0.029295163229107857, -0.006563341710716486, 0.02256508730351925, 0.015047327615320683, 0.03068118542432785, -0.007707786280661821, -0.026349227875471115, 0.06437278538942337, 0.011156497523188591, -0.04146287962794304, -0.03604811057448387, -0.052112944424152374, -0.027987239882349968, 0.04603218659758568, -0.0264879260212183, -0.02296842820942402, -0.04014837369322777, 0.005431935656815767, 0.0052461628802120686, -0.02526831440627575 ]
<p>I would like to show that $\sum \frac{X^m}{a_n k^2}$ from $k=1$ to $k=n$ converges in distribution to the degenerate random variable 0. We have that some constant $m &gt; 0$, $X$ ~ $Cauchy$, or the ratio of two independent standard Normal random variables, and that $a_n$ goes to $\infty$ as $n$ goes to $\infty$. I am not sure how to show this - it seems intuitive if the denominator itself goes to infinity, but the Cauchy term itself could take on values of infinity too, and would be much larger than the denominator with a power $m &gt; 0$. Given this, how would this possibly converge to the degenerate case?</p>
36,247
[ -0.020409205928444862, -0.007766764145344496, 0.013253808952867985, -0.01842578686773777, 0.036547303199768066, -0.003965563140809536, 0.018190987408161163, -0.06532056629657745, -0.026623615995049477, -0.0764610767364502, 0.04661622643470764, 0.01064226869493723, 0.046219293028116226, 0.0299183651804924, 0.03066808544099331, -0.03792893886566162, -0.06623382866382599, -0.04537832364439964, 0.038478460162878036, -0.021058836951851845, -0.008130589500069618, 0.030897632241249084, 0.020092567428946495, -0.04340341314673424, -0.02320726029574871, -0.006318185944110155, -0.002971544163301587, 0.004191352985799313, -0.00040453244582749903, 0.059902776032686234, -0.0430581159889698, 0.01099725067615509, 0.03283163905143738, 0.045438095927238464, 0.024967068806290627, 0.035857245326042175, -0.013655669055879116, -0.022784961387515068, 0.005726272240281105, 0.010561205446720123, -0.025149140506982803, -0.05436588078737259, 0.0031950718257576227, 0.0280081145465374, -0.018288809806108475, 0.005753163248300552, 0.023411225527524948, -0.08411805331707001, 0.02042885683476925, -0.029847828671336174, 0.09863625466823578, 0.034572016447782516, 0.035871513187885284, 0.05256827175617218, 0.04491380602121353, -0.019444113597273827, 0.01387856062501669, 0.059301283210515976, 0.017437800765037537, -0.017394855618476868, -0.002449924824759364, -0.02391529455780983, -0.018566401675343513, -0.0210932157933712, 0.0007010374683886766, -0.002720736898481846, 0.0026295785792171955, -0.003900707932189107, 0.0036414458882063627, -0.04785773903131485, -0.011022684164345264, 0.07148510962724686, 0.047571852803230286, 0.0014063304988667369, -0.02085995301604271, 0.03632201999425888, 0.008347757160663605, -0.004010964184999466, 0.048269953578710556, 0.033078957349061966, 0.0117078498005867, -0.021180618554353714, 0.006610824726521969, 0.03414321690797806, 0.008906467817723751, 0.006388342939317226, 0.050909943878650665, 0.0003364206349942833, 0.016477195546030998, 0.04517178237438202, -0.031324394047260284, -0.023617083206772804, 0.035587944090366364, -0.027871035039424896, -0.044625088572502136, 0.06354238092899323, -0.022752951830625534, 0.006156532559543848, -0.009441336616873741, -0.029418237507343292, -0.03348910063505173, -0.016342733055353165, 0.013167550787329674, 0.06690387427806854, 0.011363389901816845, -0.02322896011173725, -0.03248515725135803, 0.02926313504576683, -0.038581352680921555, -0.03595083951950073, -0.027446288615465164, 0.027647580951452255, -0.004913959186524153, 0.002071371302008629, 0.012955243699252605, -0.003997377585619688, -0.030576391145586967, -0.0377737358212471, 0.015247929841279984, 0.07795359939336777, 0.03503347933292389, 0.025828557088971138, 0.04472667723894119, -0.023310968652367592, -0.03456233814358711, -0.0008244903874583542, 0.006068282760679722, -0.024345412850379944, -0.027984535321593285, 0.0550658144056797, -0.0017863607499748468, 0.0014269299572333694, -0.009439392015337944, 0.006431049667298794, 0.03965362161397934, 0.0007937136688269675, -0.04475998878479004, -0.0474526472389698, 0.04887593910098076, -0.025584837421774864, 0.04231305792927742, -0.06732425093650818, 0.04415617510676384, 0.071494922041893, 0.06455371528863907, 0.021970432251691818, 0.03898393735289574, -0.026467006653547287, 0.037754081189632416, 0.02264242060482502, -0.023791970685124397, -0.031082341447472572, -0.008269469253718853, -0.0314004011452198, 0.022832728922367096, -0.0654531940817833, 0.036575525999069214, 0.043348733335733414, 0.027427153661847115, -0.02747679129242897, 0.0336332730948925, -0.010992481373250484, -0.00991438515484333, -0.01853744313120842, 0.014491444453597069, 0.0025193693581968546, 0.09341949969530106, 0.03587230294942856, 0.050582896918058395, -0.00013364138430915773, 0.008536769077181816, 0.024010056629776955, 0.016357380896806717, 0.0680287629365921, 0.029462717473506927, -0.016351794824004173, 0.031965047121047974, 0.0024939686991274357, 0.02973579615354538, 0.04344544559717178, -0.049059417098760605, 0.022123955190181732, 0.007377126254141331, 0.01815851591527462, 0.017025405541062355, 0.02385198324918747, -0.017023757100105286, 0.003545032348483801, 0.00926249846816063, -0.03961961343884468, 0.0005943672149442136, -0.05065752938389778, 0.02469717524945736, -0.010929591953754425, 0.004986356478184462, 0.03924169763922691, -0.01670554094016552, 0.03217940032482147, -0.015253672376275063, 0.0052018011920154095, -0.00686787161976099, 0.0119552593678236, 0.031324900686740875, -0.029473666101694107, 0.06118370220065117, 0.03701803460717201, 0.034312400966882706, 0.007184464018791914, 0.06000334024429321, -0.02146364003419876, -0.010321580804884434, -0.005002133548259735, -0.01709362305700779, -0.014999756589531898, -0.043311405926942825, 0.026714317500591278, 0.009014058858156204, -0.008682355284690857, 0.017085811123251915, 0.040577758103609085, -0.016570961102843285, 0.02702782116830349, 0.020547468215227127, 0.06288192421197891, -0.01799209788441658, 0.0047658029943704605, 0.035664789378643036, -0.015107600949704647, -0.007033551577478647, -0.025492150336503983, -0.02256985940039158, 0.021404270082712173, 0.0504208505153656, 0.05617639422416687, -0.048611659556627274, 0.0147162564098835, 0.06080587953329086, 0.022290460765361786, 0.03553481772542, 0.041294656693935394, -0.007168312557041645, 0.008996406570076942, -0.019301816821098328, 0.013390685431659222, 0.0015531708486378193, -0.00607434893026948, -0.012533014640212059, -0.003451667260378599, 0.02441570721566677, 0.009025143459439278, 0.001927706296555698, 0.00315362261608243, -0.02206624113023281, 0.031565532088279724, -0.036207813769578934, -0.03558577224612236, -0.009407427161931992, -0.000335305550834164, -0.006792924832552671, 0.0030782620888203382, 0.03471079841256142, 0.0032483681570738554, -0.036197371780872345, -0.05169074609875679, 0.0723654255270958, -0.022680943831801414, -0.04707057401537895, -0.03933064639568329, 0.025723768398165703, -0.0026782765053212643, 0.030888907611370087, -0.02151678502559662, -0.026317356154322624, -0.025982381775975227, 0.018877524882555008, 0.005043678916990757, -0.009651574306190014, -0.017656102776527405, -0.009650486521422863, -0.043279170989990234, 0.010689733549952507, -0.009522685781121254, 0.01370568573474884, -0.031547751277685165, -0.025951450690627098, 0.006168898195028305, 0.0047849141992628574, 0.016329776495695114, 0.0500761941075325, 0.023563535884022713, 0.01572057232260704, 0.03189228102564812, 0.0017534606158733368, -0.04951683431863785, 0.012837927788496017, -0.02217947505414486, -0.01007018331438303, -0.06009445711970329, -0.002645910019055009, 0.05071710795164108, -0.0070421029813587666, -0.02870117500424385, 0.04818647354841232, -0.047562457621097565, -0.05515480414032936, -0.04964257776737213, 0.01702001318335533, 0.04930280148983002, -0.0790746808052063, 0.05279456079006195, -0.01167455967515707, -0.034976132214069366, 0.011614964343607426, -0.07561764121055603, -0.052086085081100464, -0.01692027412354946, 0.003937783185392618, 0.042670413851737976, 0.02468309924006462, -0.056352369487285614, 0.06683461368083954, 0.029039686545729637, -0.020371604710817337, 0.00859247799962759, -0.013255498372018337, 0.035938557237386703, -0.03478080779314041, 0.0013461190974339843, 0.040854427963495255, -0.024832099676132202, 0.031142493709921837, 0.038779426366090775, 0.015869850292801857, 0.03179531171917915, -0.04529878869652748, 0.004165817517787218, 0.03641142323613167, 0.0021611449774354696, 0.012275658547878265, 0.022378653287887573, 0.010090296156704426, -0.011475875973701477, -0.004538686014711857, 0.0005960332928225398, 0.026582809165120125, -0.019071562215685844, -0.022595630958676338, 0.004338151775300503, -0.043528106063604355, 0.005064187105745077, -0.024654226377606392, 0.03732717037200928, 0.006464280188083649, -0.04786090925335884, 0.006852791178971529, -0.010838848538696766, 0.004544479306787252, -0.027504604309797287, 0.02692103572189808, 0.04728401452302933, 0.034286338835954666, -0.004252483602613211, -0.057163018733263016, -0.011669240891933441, -0.007590277120471001, 0.03311234340071678, -0.006588899064809084, -0.006082502193748951, 0.006903423927724361, -0.008665932342410088, -0.01074044406414032, -0.03248867392539978, 0.010501718148589134, 0.029080485925078392, -0.03519206866621971, -0.02493095025420189, -0.0005112442886456847, 0.023944899439811707, -0.007891732268035412, 0.045438069850206375, -0.004297380801290274, -0.007031681947410107, 0.02047370746731758, 0.030612710863351822, -0.06760358065366745, -0.01605423167347908, -0.03947233781218529, -0.009559016674757004, -0.005221792496740818, -0.014926133677363396, 0.010957025922834873, 0.012641716748476028, -0.005688279401510954, -0.03246202692389488, -0.014169681817293167, -0.04786680266261101, 0.006471479311585426, -0.05306989327073097, -0.028330229222774506, -0.018076863139867783, 0.031213443726301193, -0.01937122270464897, -0.02391679212450981, 0.025413254275918007, 0.027458690106868744, -0.034672487527132034, -0.008490612730383873, -0.009912649169564247, 0.033231474459171295, -0.007703692652285099, 0.008833198808133602, 0.0453326441347599, 0.03477955609560013, -0.04405822232365608, -0.03425975888967514, 0.017753638327121735, 0.055367372930049896, 0.007958943955600262, -0.02780655212700367, 0.023256748914718628, -0.044574253261089325, -0.05667534098029137, 0.011383097618818283, 0.01305459812283516, 0.021048733964562416, -0.017128683626651764, 0.033397529274225235, -0.010416592471301556, -0.009541590698063374, 0.047764018177986145, 0.041864063590765, -0.013494458980858326, -0.011448021978139877, -0.021579837426543236, -0.022299472242593765, -0.019594920799136162, 0.0019108382984995842, 0.0012721795355901122, -0.01149417832493782, -0.009182768873870373, -0.020277025178074837, 0.01862940564751625, 0.013544799759984016, -0.0019656613003462553, -0.018638646230101585, 0.03541477769613266, 0.00908634439110756, 0.02726593241095543, -0.026495622470974922, 0.0407387912273407, 0.020697038620710373, 0.0014427793212234974, 0.03035592846572399, -0.028391893953084946, -0.037620652467012405, -0.00712230009958148, 0.034013889729976654, 0.01988743618130684, -0.005196144338697195, -0.008621209301054478, -0.04751976206898689, -0.010691008530557156, 0.04341874271631241, -0.033728692680597305, 0.041850682348012924, 0.01495011430233717, -0.002470237435773015, 0.019713018089532852, -0.010539954528212547, -0.04349265247583389, -0.0001679265988059342, 0.011389192193746567, -0.011430095881223679, -0.06103399395942688, -0.018681297078728676, -0.07335298508405685, 0.007916973903775215, 0.037476327270269394, 0.06494081765413284, 0.01518965233117342, 0.00435377424582839, -0.020994199439883232, 0.03360525518655777, 0.009693688713014126, -0.07318754494190216, 0.049561142921447754, 0.0025781854055821896, -0.030024897307157516, 0.03186384588479996, -0.02824360318481922, -0.06326736509799957, 0.029180295765399933, 0.010978376492857933, -0.024892570450901985, 0.07090356945991516, -0.03419208526611328, 0.023063942790031433, 0.03358914703130722, 0.018651491031050682, 0.0522724986076355, 0.033367276191711426, -0.022977862507104874, 0.006256787572056055, 0.018677089363336563, 0.03532661497592926, -0.00012671705917455256, -0.0007169426535256207, -0.04201340675354004, -0.021073073148727417, -0.02660009264945984, 0.002687909174710512, -0.03409859538078308, 0.03769818693399429, -0.01594695635139942, 0.004480510950088501, 0.028733137995004654, 0.027547083795070648, 0.048136286437511444, -0.0056019192561507225, 0.0068028648383915424, 0.029177356511354446, -0.0028199502266943455, 0.004490521736443043, 0.038225285708904266, -0.039084769785404205, 0.033522602170705795, 0.022163623943924904, -0.014885127544403076, 0.01997354067862034, 0.004280945751816034, -0.03228587657213211, -0.011819452047348022, -0.008802383206784725, 0.034034036099910736, -0.014526483602821827, 0.018920576199889183, -0.017501091584563255, -0.02929888293147087, -0.018430540338158607, 0.011941072531044483, -0.003960296045988798, 0.067478708922863, -0.04094873368740082, -0.002702481346204877, 0.014154458418488503, -0.018391719087958336, -0.06797678768634796, -0.04596049338579178, -0.021066436544060707, 0.04719211161136627, -0.025610439479351044, -0.031919438391923904, 0.015785599127411842, -0.027312777936458588, -0.02164962701499462, -0.02229227125644684, 0.06009019538760185, -0.021662868559360504, -0.031409990042448044, 0.0016666015144437551, 0.024099430069327354, 0.029298890382051468, -0.010718811303377151, -0.015708133578300476, 0.03879829868674278, -0.01900463178753853, -0.04348134249448776, -0.016870098188519478, 0.051144372671842575, -0.015090511180460453, 0.018490688875317574, -0.02010166458785534, -0.044922586530447006, 0.05731532350182533, -0.039659284055233, -0.06076856702566147, 0.013496408239006996, 0.011483365669846535, 0.036562204360961914, -0.03848519176244736, -0.023151425644755363, 0.01301506906747818, 0.046971045434474945, -0.01386767067015171, -0.06486652791500092, 0.010492966510355473, -0.033319778740406036, 0.029520604759454727, 0.006756542716175318, 0.006585706491023302, -0.004153967369347811, 0.08014784753322601, -0.036456149071455, -0.037060994654893875, -0.028177781030535698, 0.012623697519302368, -0.002546661766245961, 0.0352073572576046, -0.004645261447876692, 0.007689156103879213, 0.030024340376257896, 0.003335079411044717, 0.005899025127291679, -0.04778601974248886, -0.0047937314957380295, 0.05742329731583595, -0.015474379993975163, 0.012038913555443287, 0.012177086435258389, 0.02062179148197174, 0.014843295328319073, -0.00013204719289205968, -0.03885949030518532, -0.03799513354897499, 0.003851013956591487, 0.015664076432585716, -0.055292218923568726, 0.0028903235215693712, 0.039331771433353424, 0.005813556257635355, -0.008477114140987396, 0.03536272421479225, 0.002173192799091339, 0.007427491247653961, 0.03975672274827957, 0.01793905347585678, -0.02400786615908146, 0.028922202065587044, -0.03627225011587143, 0.01388274785131216, -0.021271605044603348, -0.012814648449420929, 0.040837086737155914, 0.010325002484023571, -0.0296905767172575, -0.04220278933644295, -0.017850568518042564, -0.005395387765020132, 0.010041057132184505, 0.026839900761842728, 0.02262234129011631, 0.034701697528362274, 0.008425905369222164, -0.0209531020373106, -0.023729365319013596, 0.015535232611000538, 0.0011308618122711778, -0.04117470979690552, -0.021344244480133057, -0.041446905583143234, -0.044516511261463165, 0.022097792476415634, 0.03426171466708183, -0.0528298020362854, -0.030316196382045746, -0.029971163719892502, 0.030149782076478004, -0.007345330435782671, -0.012926934286952019, -0.01293367799371481, 0.08179157227277756, 0.04222338646650314, 0.04858123138546944, 0.0021428782492876053, -0.004682340659201145, 0.08338648080825806, 0.057281073182821274, 0.022193485870957375, -0.07027220726013184, -0.010665896348655224, -0.003818877274170518, 0.0110645592212677, -0.06659775227308273, -0.008726545609533787, -0.002338069025427103, -0.022095825523138046, 0.039619460701942444, 0.054989539086818695, -0.01105478499084711, 0.0021770913153886795, 0.039636120200157166, -0.016169873997569084, -0.036088284105062485, -0.001553429407067597, 0.0008876050706021488, -0.0033663990907371044, 0.04368545487523079, -0.025305133312940598, 0.035317376255989075, -0.007602456957101822, -0.01381696667522192, -0.05248119309544563, 0.004172265529632568, 0.009189821779727936, 0.02363819070160389, -0.03803776949644089, 0.0010852745035663247, 0.0466868132352829, 0.0024236447643488646, -0.014949411153793335, -0.02848537638783455, 0.02582039311528206, -0.007023419253528118, 0.004256606101989746, 0.04023381695151329, 0.03701627999544144, 0.012304762378334999, 0.037513867020606995, 0.009567898698151112, -0.02271530218422413, -0.053642891347408295, -0.002755636116489768, 0.03263181820511818, -0.000688778527546674, 0.009992338716983795, -0.01576930843293667, -0.0026330233085900545, -0.03411129489541054, -0.028407691046595573, 0.007495300378650427, 0.03733213618397713, 0.03153592348098755, -0.03834463283419609, 0.0075560882687568665, 0.01330471970140934, 0.049127161502838135, 0.04389139264822006, 0.02752617374062538, 0.0008324292721226811, -0.06339800357818604, -0.02308100461959839, -0.01670672744512558, 0.0218662116676569, -0.04645581170916557, -0.053863152861595154, -0.025281308218836784, 0.008239861577749252, -0.027695249766111374, 0.0004557656648103148, -0.008893967606127262, -0.03084140457212925, 0.03884126618504524, 0.011103956028819084, -0.011863750405609608, -0.010152721777558327, -0.03231434524059296, 0.014932270161807537, -0.02901754155755043, 0.018307965248823166, -0.023980293422937393, -0.04023754224181175, -0.019578590989112854, 0.017395293340086937, -0.03998922184109688, -0.030275648459792137, 0.02523699589073658, 0.06272732466459274, 0.018897950649261475, 0.00791932176798582, 0.014276902191340923, -0.02199275605380535, -0.05448654294013977, 0.022674772888422012, -0.01889372617006302, 0.02222207747399807, 0.027682079002261162, 0.04261263832449913, -0.0015465946635231376, 0.003600516589358449, -0.05563405901193619, 0.022288110107183456, -0.020252656191587448, -0.041091471910476685, 0.008688719011843204, 0.05211127549409866, 0.00415410939604044, -0.00493646739050746, -0.02407447062432766, 0.01389122661203146, -0.014652722515165806, -0.007921208627521992, -0.007588301319628954, -0.025688588619232178, -0.019671227782964706, -0.003345076460391283, -0.002484259195625782, 0.023272521793842316, -0.0290321446955204, -0.016551759093999863, -0.003631435101851821, 0.027848822996020317, -0.019307848066091537, 0.01753661036491394, 0.04001220315694809, -0.00935943890362978, -0.017314469441771507, 0.05022738501429558, 0.05412141978740692, -0.0022697043605148792, -0.0038473361637443304, 0.0052169631235301495, 0.0023946911096572876, 0.04002917557954788, -0.023486370220780373, -0.02612544782459736, 0.043014708906412125, -0.032349053770303726, -0.030496537685394287, 0.017434367910027504, 0.013155510649085045, 0.023568708449602127, 0.013686304911971092, -0.010570035316050053, -0.043701883405447006, 0.053629737347364426, -0.026307683438062668, -0.006949645932763815, -0.033082395792007446, -0.036842141300439835, 0.02389882318675518, 0.012313159182667732, 0.017253760248422623, -0.010563897900283337, 0.015525182709097862, -0.00004773723048856482, 0.06133122742176056, -0.007860755547881126, -0.01964813657104969, 0.02118712104856968, 0.020299628376960754, 0.010996622033417225, -0.0024711149744689465, 0.027645837515592575, 0.054676733911037445, 0.02915971353650093, -0.011951418593525887, 0.0294337198138237, -0.0725291445851326, -0.015643198043107986, -0.07615117728710175, -0.00016761718143243343, 0.010739029385149479, 0.015647195279598236, 0.07266653329133987, -0.025612426921725273, -0.02195783145725727, 0.04081963002681732, -0.040562402456998825, 0.004570113029330969, -0.012195270508527756, -0.012100405991077423, -0.0541808046400547, -0.01127566583454609, -0.03498828411102295, 0.03329424560070038, 0.026601366698741913, 0.05819522961974144, 0.0617465041577816, 0.002180791459977627, -0.013553120195865631, -0.010640636086463928, -0.006389545276761055, -0.002315330086275935, -0.022016257047653198, -0.028369614854454994, 0.009211263619363308, 0.007517033722251654, 0.0013789483346045017, 0.03659709915518761, -0.04706732556223869, -0.0037399446591734886, 0.007746580522507429, 0.03478871285915375, 0.016707997769117355, 0.028174784034490585, -0.0025020823813974857, 0.006633737590163946, 0.019177164882421494, 0.008308845572173595, 0.030353661626577377, -0.003174999263137579, -0.1069500669836998, -0.006560217123478651, 0.07473152130842209, -0.017810391262173653, -0.06258252263069153, 0.03766292706131935, -0.008760697208344936, -0.012329903431236744, -0.0004793357802554965, 0.0022073565050959587, 0.038677044212818146, -0.030224209651350975, 0.02987581491470337, -0.03614100441336632, -0.0255502387881279, 0.004601254127919674, 0.05175131931900978, -0.0009324279380962253, 0.03006155416369438, 0.0019821892492473125, -0.04434701055288315, 0.02025684528052807, 0.02821238525211811, -0.013498632237315178, -0.01289930660277605, -0.009125940501689911, -0.02110937051475048, 0.009482973255217075, -0.004699230194091797, -0.025767305865883827, -0.003550546709448099, 0.01683531142771244, 0.013330991379916668, 0.062162432819604874, -0.025145405903458595, -0.027828294783830643, -0.009955666027963161, -0.11080832034349442, 0.04814640432596207, -0.026987310498952866, -0.023385049775242805, -0.02741903066635132, 0.023952096700668335, 0.01124897412955761, -0.00990702398121357, 0.030657071620225906, 0.020090918987989426, 0.03656861558556557, -0.018586674705147743, 0.04277326911687851, 0.07114749401807785, -0.03338053449988365, 0.02219846285879612, -0.025557097047567368, -0.014403225854039192, -0.0018112348625436425, 0.0013996672350913286, 0.009881681762635708, 0.004164912272244692, 0.009335977956652641, -0.020227406173944473, -0.013791436329483986, 0.0004281209548935294, -0.02530810236930847, 0.015494280494749546, 0.007030547596514225, -0.011439313180744648, 0.04476948454976082, -0.05649425461888313, -0.01664046384394169, 0.0056525892578065395, -0.0063153463415801525, -0.05820851027965546, 0.03204922378063202, -0.05267423018813133, -0.014387309551239014, -0.04965751990675926, -0.000807026051916182, -0.017184719443321228, -0.03809231519699097, -0.009883355349302292, 0.042931798845529556, -0.05491779372096062, -0.04004094377160072, 0.0203438438475132, -0.0009590807603672147, 0.03225730359554291, 0.045620545744895935, -0.023488465696573257, -0.00997097510844469, 0.04121793061494827, 0.015370662324130535, 0.0012186042731627822, 0.04009156674146652, -0.007813031785190105, -0.024009253829717636, -0.025905948132276535, -0.018367109820246696, 0.030214762315154076, -0.05542680248618126, -0.0023593001533299685, -0.06556622684001923, -0.04833269491791725, -0.003632797859609127, -0.06396746635437012, 0.024290386587381363, -0.008124479092657566, -0.026343373581767082, 0.056419387459754944, 0.02188734896481037, 0.014074119739234447, -0.04073713347315788, -0.008071589283645153, 0.01261099148541689, -0.004657179582864046, 0.030502861365675926, 0.02788611501455307, -0.04122796282172203, 0.023326151072978973, 0.038743920624256134, -0.010888728313148022, 0.047484856098890305, -0.023337366059422493, 0.0009830188937485218, -0.0038060592487454414, -0.03250911086797714, 0.007491018157452345, -0.0373883917927742, -0.027128687128424644, -0.015126585029065609, 0.022662894800305367, 0.02845124900341034, 0.05302853509783745, 0.019751381129026413, -0.013336571864783764, -0.004677324090152979, 0.04967828094959259, -0.06299418210983276, 0.02182481624186039, -0.03420781344175339, -0.01512917410582304, 0.030878884717822075, -0.006693804170936346 ]
<p>Does anybody have an idea about why conditional correlation between 2 variables is called "partial" correlation and the simple correlation between them (so, when not conditioned on any other variable) is called "marginal" correlation? What is the intuition behind words "partial" and "marginal"? What do they do with "parts" or "margins"?</p> <p>It would be good to learn the answer in order to understand those concepts better.</p>
36,248
[ 0.008158370852470398, 0.016650505363941193, 0.005011466331779957, -0.015658944845199585, 0.0416191890835762, 0.054474059492349625, -0.0015861442079767585, 0.01339173037558794, 0.011595520190894604, -0.033393047749996185, 0.003967219963669777, 0.015942392870783806, 0.050317421555519104, 0.03244167938828468, -0.0008118550176732242, 0.025303736329078674, 0.018617289140820503, 0.024744080379605293, -0.016312530264258385, -0.008688966743648052, 0.004581735003739595, -0.0023102175910025835, 0.0311038289219141, 0.015289019793272018, 0.0019923970103263855, 0.03493577614426613, 0.010276095941662788, -0.03648209944367409, 0.055258188396692276, 0.06260263174772263, -0.03443246707320213, -0.027624092996120453, -0.010436705313622952, 0.021361570805311203, 0.01071618776768446, -0.03236846253275871, -0.03607947379350662, -0.022330427542328835, 0.017251694574952126, 0.04538796469569206, -0.09638236463069916, -0.022287696599960327, 0.0089943278580904, 0.0007013443391770124, -0.05160031467676163, 0.012925395742058754, 0.005293673370033503, -0.0026979034300893545, 0.03883861377835274, -0.05211939662694931, 0.04989570751786232, 0.0035338157322257757, 0.03289226442575455, 0.04569651558995247, 0.00908834021538496, 0.044358447194099426, 0.06216488406062126, 0.07147045433521271, -0.022249193862080574, -0.05857958272099495, -0.007721248548477888, -0.020016612485051155, 0.0058914474211633205, 0.000583869987167418, -0.028033921495079994, 0.03397810086607933, 0.016656232997775078, -0.014091910794377327, 0.03534939885139465, 0.025513911619782448, 0.0026139600668102503, 0.005462333094328642, 0.04623537138104439, -0.037766024470329285, -0.013040222227573395, -0.008012424223124981, 0.030817970633506775, 0.04099712148308754, 0.010442165657877922, 0.040472470223903656, 0.015147225931286812, 0.0009703327668830752, 0.0282073263078928, 0.037953559309244156, 0.015713827684521675, 0.0019124919781461358, 0.07862746715545654, -0.030771972611546516, 0.027746090665459633, 0.013475275598466396, -0.002799366135150194, 0.011240293271839619, 0.01578984037041664, -0.0017350943526253104, -0.04943476617336273, 0.05485896021127701, -0.008400357328355312, 0.020690852776169777, 0.013774720951914787, 0.02196209877729416, -0.018135573714971542, -0.0017218954162672162, -0.0061770835891366005, 0.05937374383211136, -0.038958851248025894, -0.0006659693317487836, -0.03550444543361664, 0.014794375747442245, 0.04031343013048172, 0.0015364080900326371, -0.012209895998239517, 0.008332090452313423, 0.023996610194444656, 0.017174504697322845, 0.038420479744672775, -0.012328796088695526, -0.007476890459656715, -0.018480325117707253, 0.04455098137259483, 0.05978327617049217, 0.020074140280485153, -0.05163327604532242, 0.013219629414379597, -0.010003451257944107, -0.07156775891780853, 0.03038034215569496, 0.020999958738684654, 0.005409542936831713, -0.006378562655299902, 0.05873227119445801, 0.02035810612142086, -0.03471219167113304, 0.02202540822327137, 0.020516810938715935, 0.03890056535601616, 0.021200112998485565, -0.07566866278648376, 0.0023795717861503363, 0.07215669006109238, 0.011702402494847775, -0.00519639952108264, -0.012567196972668171, 0.021070711314678192, 0.050360120832920074, 0.06943691521883011, -0.000776945031248033, 0.022480875253677368, -0.006735214497894049, 0.027193089947104454, 0.027519896626472473, -0.030371589586138725, -0.04825414717197418, -0.039055705070495605, -0.0001306590565945953, -0.014458553865551949, -0.059995442628860474, -0.0036048730835318565, 0.04393918439745903, -0.028323505073785782, -0.03921787813305855, 0.047496747225522995, 0.004102116450667381, -0.0440349280834198, 0.001941368798725307, -0.010535416193306446, -0.036706726998090744, 0.03657661750912666, -0.019422480836510658, 0.012826967053115368, 0.039803940802812576, -0.023590069264173508, -0.016161862760782242, 0.01429885346442461, 0.05169617384672165, 0.05117813125252724, -0.03717128187417984, -0.04216933250427246, -0.005585558712482452, 0.003225265769287944, -0.01844863034784794, -0.06298236548900604, 0.020582495257258415, -0.06146722286939621, 0.006266091484576464, 0.03496025502681732, 0.04706965386867523, 0.011206078343093395, -0.05258963257074356, 0.006475367583334446, -0.039649348706007004, -0.07144850492477417, -0.07892914861440659, 0.01710301637649536, -0.05328184738755226, -0.06374458968639374, 0.04823435842990875, 0.030803848057985306, 0.0017714817076921463, 0.0006257078493945301, -0.03227248787879944, -0.027219578623771667, 0.026729369536042213, 0.006188265513628721, -0.011029860004782677, 0.05892282724380493, 0.04427385702729225, 0.030355624854564667, 0.017533285543322563, 0.008825770579278469, -0.057554226368665695, -0.0624491423368454, 0.046258531510829926, 0.003222363069653511, 0.036366984248161316, -0.029176032170653343, -0.04928189143538475, 0.00041432425496168435, -0.012236641719937325, -0.00519210658967495, 0.04888875409960747, -0.048579923808574677, 0.04879562929272652, 0.06356200575828552, -0.019705340266227722, 0.00013342929014470428, 0.03179635852575302, 0.027427328750491142, 0.027550578117370605, -0.00949612446129322, 0.006424177438020706, -0.039981693029403687, 0.010013598017394543, 0.036826424300670624, 0.027373120188713074, -0.03149089589715004, -0.0001580913958605379, 0.03570157289505005, 0.002431171480566263, 0.00869086291640997, 0.04236550256609917, 0.02024880424141884, -0.026999350637197495, -0.02480182982981205, 0.014508961699903011, 0.03233110159635544, -0.014418307691812515, -0.00685084518045187, 0.008209091611206532, 0.07658486068248749, 0.0008920413674786687, -0.0470377579331398, 0.05169215798377991, 0.02061644196510315, 0.024149147793650627, -0.016108574345707893, -0.00978757068514824, 0.06169293075799942, -0.03144228085875511, 0.01473045814782381, 0.008938144892454147, 0.01600043661892414, 0.01216085348278284, -0.001263593090698123, -0.03495457023382187, -0.017448903992772102, 0.026605097576975822, -0.04708344489336014, -0.009762038476765156, 0.0028003216721117496, 0.0012369797332212329, 0.019567672163248062, -0.01968509517610073, -0.042440012097358704, -0.018268350511789322, -0.027832986786961555, 0.047190211713314056, 0.0024827495217323303, 0.04989949241280556, -0.012416529469192028, -0.05495961382985115, -0.005672863218933344, -0.017740534618496895, -0.004609294701367617, -0.00890666339546442, -0.0552445612847805, 0.01670714095234871, 0.0036082954611629248, -0.01886017620563507, 0.02725536935031414, -0.0034503370989114046, 0.011038958095014095, -0.009500293992459774, -0.0028809059876948595, -0.08129872381687164, -0.04110421612858772, -0.02842671424150467, 0.01347785722464323, -0.04313419386744499, -0.010573791339993477, 0.052643485367298126, -0.003147902199998498, -0.03800410032272339, 0.00003094402200076729, -0.01744866371154785, -0.018437553197145462, -0.018934059888124466, -0.047396041452884674, 0.005449332762509584, -0.011409875005483627, 0.015349676832556725, 0.04964689910411835, -0.05558393523097038, -0.024073783308267593, -0.041503340005874634, -0.056513458490371704, 0.043875742703676224, -0.00779001647606492, 0.02198321931064129, -0.019892478361725807, -0.019268089905381203, 0.05715098977088928, 0.011592925526201725, -0.04537418484687805, -0.030911287292838097, 0.009016579948365688, -0.01786467619240284, -0.02759583108127117, 0.012499489821493626, 0.014892660081386566, 0.019336216151714325, 0.06183597072958946, 0.017415154725313187, 0.060718607157468796, 0.02974167838692665, 0.04868452623486519, 0.019430119544267654, 0.007824462838470936, -0.00936344638466835, -0.04494638368487358, 0.03343525528907776, 0.017656952142715454, -0.04700571298599243, -0.007990018464624882, -0.023608408868312836, 0.06004752963781357, 0.02954646572470665, -0.04153569042682648, 0.03883184492588043, 0.022368518635630608, -0.005368412472307682, -0.054830729961395264, 0.032419025897979736, 0.02985674887895584, -0.025914454832673073, 0.0023815426975488663, 0.00779383722692728, 0.013885156251490116, -0.03362821415066719, -0.008794547989964485, 0.033848509192466736, 0.038353901356458664, -0.06103065237402916, 0.0031297686509788036, -0.006440202705562115, 0.026145517826080322, 0.025704266503453255, -0.005713261663913727, -0.021568801254034042, 0.07690760493278503, 0.03194883465766907, -0.0036815886851400137, 0.004204326309263706, -0.019841475412249565, 0.008605989627540112, -0.05571405589580536, 0.021958189085125923, -0.00177483179140836, 0.01175561361014843, -0.008933181874454021, 0.08810846507549286, -0.011881954967975616, 0.00750163197517395, 0.017459476366639137, 0.04747598245739937, -0.08679158985614777, -0.004842383787035942, -0.007309284992516041, -0.007470124401152134, -0.015552799217402935, -0.010576330125331879, 0.029486771672964096, -0.03970690071582794, -0.035681989043951035, -0.03273246809840202, 0.009640205651521683, -0.03547944128513336, 0.008106637746095657, -0.017261188477277756, -0.012225362472236156, 0.0012699394719675183, 0.02312135137617588, 0.018120471388101578, 0.010574555955827236, 0.03315442427992821, 0.07342645525932312, 0.015874754637479782, -0.023471828550100327, 0.0031212924513965845, 0.015148201026022434, 0.0582561157643795, 0.045700352638959885, 0.0004279456625226885, 0.0011792391305789351, -0.02245454490184784, 0.04364215210080147, 0.01543307676911354, 0.04953640326857567, 0.03129632771015167, -0.04468259587883949, -0.007175949402153492, 0.017650334164500237, -0.012454429641366005, -0.02034539356827736, 0.009980948641896248, 0.024025218561291695, 0.019134435802698135, 0.027206970378756523, 0.015108632855117321, -0.04518114775419235, 0.03329622000455856, 0.0616903230547905, 0.022289393469691277, -0.01732505112886429, -0.05077895522117615, 0.013018564321100712, -0.03421950340270996, -0.01281768549233675, 0.026573436334729195, 0.0000747728263377212, -0.035177361220121384, -0.0006450656801462173, 0.008911306038498878, -0.029386423528194427, 0.017676927149295807, 0.017141159623861313, -0.02253572642803192, 0.014826315455138683, 0.009052255190908909, -0.0477881096303463, 0.030375024303793907, 0.05835164710879326, 0.0185684934258461, 0.0379583016037941, -0.0004035324091091752, -0.06303494423627853, 0.00139101583044976, 0.03776782751083374, 0.02476627752184868, -0.028467552736401558, -0.022479848936200142, -0.040600720793008804, -0.03354649990797043, 0.036306750029325485, -0.016753850504755974, -0.0054755257442593575, -0.03571590781211853, 0.0045103225857019424, -0.018919939175248146, -0.020319553092122078, -0.02053001895546913, 0.005189463030546904, -0.029882114380598068, 0.017046252265572548, 0.0012993391137570143, -0.04071018472313881, -0.07434254884719849, -0.0034238409716635942, 0.023400958627462387, 0.05230693146586418, -0.004073735326528549, -0.005226283799856901, -0.02004130743443966, 0.034697044640779495, 0.0217661801725626, -0.07803746312856674, 0.04311515763401985, 0.00489082233980298, -0.017246637493371964, 0.013154244050383568, -0.005073057021945715, -0.029042955487966537, 0.017670823261141777, -0.004055491182953119, -0.008029253222048283, 0.01735801249742508, 0.012906301766633987, 0.05762305483222008, 0.033309970051050186, -0.02677564136683941, 0.04880313202738762, 0.023215757682919502, -0.022651925683021545, -0.036834314465522766, -0.006236028857529163, 0.04514363780617714, -0.040500760078430176, 0.007187691982835531, -0.046530794352293015, -0.020402422174811363, -0.024657852947711945, 0.03799872100353241, -0.004660806618630886, 0.04345861077308655, -0.05888700485229492, -0.020674923434853554, -0.023144274950027466, 0.010100648738443851, -0.003276616334915161, -0.01769336871802807, -0.010958214290440083, 0.003672037273645401, 0.001731550320982933, -0.0029779619071632624, 0.03999638929963112, -0.019072670489549637, -0.03223163262009621, 0.007460432592779398, -0.020321020856499672, -0.005865742452442646, -0.03790383040904999, -0.022038321942090988, 0.02960958145558834, -0.021488558501005173, 0.013399633578956127, -0.01455212663859129, 0.0239690113812685, 0.0058136084116995335, -0.04923919215798378, -0.028604689985513687, 0.043298058211803436, -0.009531508199870586, 0.04693834111094475, -0.05883915722370148, 0.031115682795643806, -0.013616321608424187, 0.005822389852255583, -0.053389739245176315, -0.0474049411714077, -0.0040258849039673805, -0.008240179158747196, -0.03292832151055336, -0.0026386240497231483, 0.015849318355321884, -0.0273684523999691, -0.027220895513892174, -0.008146189153194427, 0.036632239818573, -0.016138426959514618, -0.011837104335427284, -0.002413275884464383, 0.0056663621217012405, 0.03478051722049713, 0.000018427117538521998, -0.04353047162294388, 0.025106776505708694, 0.005042334087193012, 0.000049199265049537644, 0.01521135400980711, 0.015980519354343414, -0.013970759697258472, -0.016931161284446716, -0.015248950570821762, -0.011302662082016468, 0.0021345829591155052, -0.011321713216602802, 0.03183668479323387, -0.030075879767537117, 0.021861784160137177, 0.0001748305221553892, -0.008823457174003124, 0.008482418954372406, -0.00023390619026031345, 0.009826946072280407, 0.004961519502103329, -0.01820231042802334, -0.02093621715903282, -0.03195306286215782, 0.038760922849178314, 0.02442619390785694, -0.016073551028966904, 0.0222671777009964, 0.05740378797054291, -0.007548984605818987, 0.0019424447091296315, 0.022640282288193703, -0.002303808694705367, 0.043516673147678375, 0.016570869833230972, 0.015378992073237896, 0.040857695043087006, 0.008950435556471348, -0.019155705347657204, 0.009592997841536999, -0.02591327764093876, -0.01575636677443981, 0.07206931710243225, -0.040755487978458405, 0.045136213302612305, 0.027964213863015175, -0.02757127955555916, -0.028245307505130768, -0.06561020016670227, -0.001477435347624123, -0.012728163041174412, -0.01107262447476387, 0.04266957566142082, -0.05366737022995949, -0.025073258206248283, 0.019899772480130196, -0.0022687017917633057, -0.031123854219913483, 0.02700633741915226, -0.003309781663119793, 0.0411643423140049, 0.010936308652162552, 0.0022633024491369724, -0.04223901778459549, 0.022717462852597237, -0.01963178627192974, 0.00434137461706996, -0.024586554616689682, -0.017094871029257774, 0.054625023156404495, 0.025521891191601753, -0.005273483693599701, -0.08828878402709961, -0.01751347817480564, -0.024912189692258835, 0.01715679280459881, -0.004979215562343597, -0.03008398227393627, 0.03211077302694321, 0.00823721382766962, 0.01620492897927761, -0.04203018918633461, 0.016679953783750534, 0.0076566822826862335, -0.03251872584223747, -0.05229296162724495, -0.033329226076602936, -0.0244915634393692, 0.01410205103456974, 0.011370228603482246, -0.018743271008133888, -0.007156353909522295, -0.014069727621972561, -0.01131691224873066, 0.0023951854091137648, 0.017010793089866638, -0.042735762894153595, 0.07205449789762497, 0.01600438915193081, 0.03153838962316513, -0.015078525058925152, -0.047214075922966, 0.12168261408805847, 0.012713832780718803, -0.0049107614904642105, -0.08777324110269547, 0.06179557368159294, -0.005738443229347467, 0.01996549405157566, -0.030304383486509323, 0.004083370324224234, 0.011121772229671478, -0.02530798129737377, 0.047802574932575226, 0.06048484519124031, 0.03661014139652252, 0.0019754383247345686, 0.03675825148820877, -0.04952062666416168, -0.03408277779817581, -0.029065536335110664, -0.0037457135040313005, -0.026995593681931496, 0.01782381907105446, -0.04252670705318451, -0.03687761351466179, -0.002517015440389514, 0.0005508438916876912, -0.02702728472650051, -0.03177814930677414, 0.011043260805308819, 0.002312312601134181, -0.00939694419503212, -0.01651875674724579, 0.033807337284088135, 0.009385289624333382, 0.00033682340290397406, -0.01846427656710148, 0.04917033761739731, -0.04344126209616661, 0.00543201295658946, -0.03034462220966816, -0.03261624649167061, 0.002689569955691695, 0.004873774480074644, 0.002244086703285575, -0.054871127009391785, -0.020538249984383583, -0.01743563450872898, 0.03458890691399574, 0.008014517836272717, -0.02409536950290203, -0.02619493566453457, -0.0033794082701206207, -0.0094467643648386, -0.018538955599069595, -0.03862927481532097, 0.015834935009479523, 0.030932750552892685, -0.026389699429273605, -0.01916923001408577, -0.006271734368056059, 0.005910159088671207, -0.004099822603166103, 0.0591343455016613, -0.01755528897047043, -0.03001445159316063, 0.0061655594035983086, -0.019129909574985504, 0.04968832805752754, -0.0014062285190448165, 0.010701722465455532, 0.03486892953515053, -0.0051307776011526585, -0.04696330428123474, -0.00420791283249855, -0.007467683870345354, -0.005898603703826666, -0.0015504276379942894, -0.018353046849370003, 0.03121313266456127, -0.012431788258254528, -0.0032166605815291405, 0.009880591183900833, -0.006941842380911112, -0.008044916205108166, -0.04374111816287041, 0.007439220789819956, 0.007120962720364332, 0.0559576153755188, 0.005920484196394682, -0.01642836071550846, -0.02363065630197525, 0.026840874925255775, 0.008079327642917633, -0.03171180933713913, -0.027563398703932762, 0.022232085466384888, 0.011765772476792336, -0.01772971823811531, 0.009057734161615372, 0.024919716641306877, 0.014985237270593643, 0.02276054583489895, -0.03633367642760277, 0.020859401673078537, -0.004846460651606321, 0.008618605323135853, 0.04126938059926033, -0.0368867963552475, 0.027294762432575226, 0.019567351788282394, -0.018301403149962425, -0.05743654817342758, -0.015720311552286148, 0.004413255024701357, 0.0038769133388996124, 0.003472263691946864, -0.012915330938994884, -0.007757128681987524, -0.00065118313068524, -0.0002940217382274568, 0.023549571633338928, -0.023101286962628365, -0.01710035279393196, -0.057674821466207504, 0.028948452323675156, 0.03037094697356224, -0.007921717129647732, 0.018620112910866737, 0.005270759575068951, -0.03792896866798401, -0.00934625044465065, 0.0876622125506401, 0.04152718558907509, -0.020314762368798256, -0.016616616398096085, 0.01837380975484848, 0.022144710645079613, 0.05472564697265625, -0.028413407504558563, -0.02300567738711834, 0.011406376957893372, -0.04212520271539688, -0.06127506494522095, 0.028764497488737106, 0.023234181106090546, 0.04078690707683563, 0.02049674093723297, 0.02552826516330242, -0.004157870076596737, 0.029746271669864655, 0.007554777432233095, -0.011654437519609928, -0.023882463574409485, 0.011903326027095318, -0.017493359744548798, -0.05240826681256294, 0.00649652723222971, -0.01304682344198227, -0.011964648962020874, 0.023772044107317924, 0.02583845891058445, -0.012819718569517136, -0.012555588968098164, 0.03396216779947281, 0.011743102222681046, 0.028112847357988358, -0.024942804127931595, -0.005371331237256527, 0.019772622734308243, 0.04632857069373131, -0.05598534643650055, 0.035275522619485855, 0.034893948584795, 0.04904015362262726, -0.05878196284174919, -0.01836376078426838, 0.022011304274201393, -0.012320240028202534, 0.014909973368048668, -0.045823659747838974, -0.0012673798482865095, 0.024260062724351883, -0.06584341078996658, 0.024108316749334335, 0.03835104778409004, -0.015611061826348305, -0.02078389748930931, 0.017880089581012726, -0.0032229286152869463, 0.08871527016162872, 0.016792841255664825, 0.012266661040484905, 0.03219587355852127, 0.015064490959048271, -0.023775450885295868, -0.03168238326907158, -0.04979010671377182, 0.007574899587780237, -0.011198784224689007, -0.032033443450927734, 0.07868316769599915, -0.05285327509045601, -0.05334854498505592, 0.043540067970752716, 0.002852829173207283, -0.009508246555924416, -0.0021676295436918736, 0.0010363145265728235, -0.014620376750826836, 0.014975755475461483, 0.02495025098323822, -0.016023652628064156, 0.004298637621104717, 0.00392655236646533, 0.029683666303753853, 0.03416690602898598, 0.011435452848672867, -0.002176888519898057, 0.03786563500761986, -0.008707506582140923, -0.037837907671928406, 0.03674311190843582, 0.0073224445804953575, -0.027177944779396057, -0.008622745983302593, -0.007718874141573906, 0.02846665494143963, -0.03776245191693306, 0.04625167325139046, -0.07619284838438034, -0.056841280311346054, 0.05420282855629921, 0.028088508173823357, -0.007400629110634327, 0.01766486093401909, 0.008774235844612122, -0.023724189028143883, 0.03494996577501297, 0.003276615869253874, -0.002296095248311758, -0.04952887073159218, 0.012736737728118896, 0.0189824141561985, -0.022837607190012932, -0.037313394248485565, 0.008698755875229836, -0.020390549674630165, 0.014771991409361362, -0.00473373755812645, 0.05329088494181633, -0.021047763526439667, -0.02988443709909916, 0.0020602967124432325, -0.08665039390325546, 0.04008351266384125, 0.006259349174797535, -0.02582617849111557, -0.04762936383485794, -0.03402793034911156, -0.07169508188962936, -0.025832312181591988, 0.048516903072595596, 0.003643965581431985, 0.025160085409879684, -0.05291367694735527, 0.034592155367136, 0.038114387542009354, -0.03085440769791603, 0.002136263996362686, -0.015016939491033554, -0.013782519847154617, 0.02309301123023033, -0.011553538031876087, -0.01420291792601347, 0.010126117616891861, -0.01790182664990425, -0.01440055388957262, 0.03030557371675968, -0.03578764572739601, -0.00620527658611536, 0.04959656298160553, -0.0034492278937250376, -0.011170090176165104, 0.04624904319643974, -0.019824080169200897, 0.040744416415691376, 0.019481712952256203, -0.017350157722830772, -0.07204738259315491, -0.0031914592254906893, -0.020772207528352737, -0.021367011591792107, -0.014123762026429176, 0.02569565922021866, 0.000028867256332887337, -0.04256214201450348, -0.024722494184970856, 0.03521835803985596, -0.029370469972491264, 0.032538335770368576, 0.053968291729688644, 0.03906891867518425, 0.033793844282627106, -0.019769396632909775, -0.000325161061482504, 0.019572744145989418, -0.01080472394824028, 0.02837812900543213, 0.020847447216510773, 0.0442083515226841, -0.000203662522835657, -0.0020176179241389036, 0.00953791942447424, -0.02381238527595997, 0.03186551481485367, -0.03422655165195465, 0.01939505897462368, -0.07531300187110901, -0.0030060731805860996, 0.03350174427032471, -0.0125023378059268, 0.029129622504115105, 0.013809199444949627, -0.0004963122773915529, 0.04552260413765907, -0.025856342166662216, -0.018840119242668152, -0.03722807765007019, 0.03194436430931091, -0.019573895260691643, -0.0027744469698518515, 0.020504582673311234, 0.012139083817601204, 0.0009589609690010548, 0.002200966002419591, 0.012122663669288158, -0.042700234800577164, 0.02235916070640087, 0.006983212195336819, 0.036583349108695984, -0.023684844374656677, 0.0007768035284243524, 0.006632124539464712, 0.025672750547528267, -0.02037782594561577, -0.026068780571222305, 0.03397601097822189, 0.03915666416287422, 0.02215256355702877, 0.03797721117734909, -0.004141261335462332, -0.026281891390681267, 0.038513798266649246, -0.07499679177999496, -0.00557092996314168, -0.03866560012102127, 0.048314448446035385, 0.022404219955205917, -0.017077697440981865 ]
<p>I have a population of interest ($N = 5000$) for which I know some demographic information. I have a sample 1500 members of that population. </p> <p>So I have a good sized sample, and I know exactly how it is biased (at least based on the demographic information I have). </p> <p>Is it possible for me to make generalizations about the entire population based on the responses of my sample? </p> <p>Can someone point me to a good resource on where to read about how to handle drawing inferences and calculating stats in this situation? Do I treat this as a stratified sample, but not all strata are equal (or equally representative of the whole). </p>
73,773
[ -0.059050362557172775, -0.051768649369478226, -0.006102082785218954, 0.01846861094236374, 0.05863596871495247, 0.008047635667026043, -0.007310927379876375, -0.024220895022153854, 0.030036186799407005, -0.052883073687553406, 0.055068157613277435, 0.037280045449733734, 0.04940322786569595, 0.03254951536655426, 0.025787319988012314, 0.017487579956650734, -0.0363067090511322, 0.020210418850183487, 0.03075738251209259, -0.005668106954544783, 0.007077729795128107, 0.027401583269238472, -0.00020312730339355767, -0.036773622035980225, -0.06216522306203842, 0.03900599479675293, 0.03378205746412277, -0.0020615444518625736, 0.039645951241254807, 0.04480380192399025, -0.011924593709409237, -0.011864491738379002, 0.018238721415400505, 0.037913672626018524, 0.035216398537158966, 0.019961345940828323, -0.04124821722507477, -0.03628738224506378, -0.00415544118732214, 0.03397031128406525, -0.05012429505586624, 0.0019438120070844889, 0.039914973080158234, 0.02466760389506817, -0.025151468813419342, 0.000854296435136348, 0.00022289136541076005, -0.03225068375468254, 0.005360535811632872, -0.059771351516246796, 0.05584021285176277, 0.014722349122166634, 0.058735158294439316, 0.021426862105727196, -0.014422252774238586, -0.0037703069392591715, 0.05174306407570839, 0.06902585178613663, -0.00833899062126875, -0.04919810593128204, 0.017078330740332603, -0.043765563517808914, 0.0022663818672299385, -0.012688081711530685, -0.03908347710967064, 0.014418712817132473, -0.02089124359190464, -0.03525334596633911, 0.05059140548110008, -0.03429039567708969, 0.01752774976193905, 0.023618610575795174, 0.010629584081470966, 0.01791611686348915, -0.01642482727766037, -0.02969449758529663, 0.02418573945760727, -0.010502129793167114, 0.02389455772936344, 0.014776338823139668, 0.011499038897454739, 0.018230555579066277, 0.007159593515098095, 0.05105630308389664, 0.01901983469724655, -0.02904491312801838, 0.06404463946819305, -0.023161225020885468, 0.038749560713768005, 0.014267726801335812, -0.03494277223944664, -0.018342070281505585, 0.043350256979465485, -0.034543514251708984, -0.05502036213874817, 0.03490271791815758, -0.036454446613788605, 0.03368170186877251, 0.006564019713550806, 0.011597851291298866, -0.019153345376253128, -0.02013436332345009, 0.012477113865315914, 0.0474863238632679, -0.034119609743356705, -0.009871035814285278, -0.042336829006671906, 0.003727368079125881, 0.0024074858520179987, -0.021495996043086052, 0.021516533568501472, 0.007110694423317909, 0.0026838183403015137, -0.030010541900992393, 0.025233738124370575, 0.028826646506786346, -0.016850752755999565, -0.030754249542951584, 0.045216526836156845, 0.02454294078052044, 0.03470734506845474, -0.02737675979733467, 0.05403342843055725, -0.04387694597244263, -0.056089531630277634, 0.012497001327574253, 0.039909183979034424, -0.03209822624921799, -0.050496552139520645, 0.03582688793540001, 0.018392173573374748, -0.026866920292377472, 0.045828815549612045, 0.009381331503391266, 0.03278699517250061, -0.009984135627746582, -0.08691201359033585, -0.06951552629470825, 0.009199551306664944, -0.013387489132583141, -0.012485397979617119, -0.05459490045905113, -0.0003136158629786223, 0.026506096124649048, 0.01262642815709114, 0.004503423813730478, 0.054844535887241364, -0.00022462510969489813, 0.038257308304309845, 0.047578804194927216, -0.015299704857170582, 0.005958876572549343, -0.03483263775706291, -0.0240322258323431, 0.003002370474860072, -0.09813961386680603, 0.040019743144512177, -0.0027553015388548374, -0.007706471253186464, -0.024223392829298973, 0.04591591656208038, 0.018050000071525574, -0.009076673537492752, -0.0043864138424396515, 0.02047807164490223, 0.007689591962844133, 0.12086247652769089, -0.017595428973436356, 0.00871961284428835, 0.01879432238638401, 0.007520210929214954, 0.031338706612586975, 0.020675629377365112, 0.05071532353758812, 0.015044547617435455, -0.020870380103588104, 0.031660597771406174, 0.0002920637489296496, 0.010732888244092464, -0.0009577066521160305, -0.047222837805747986, -0.0356292761862278, -0.002293430035933852, -0.0066334097646176815, 0.011427707970142365, 0.044274646788835526, 0.015532998368144035, -0.02399679459631443, 0.03142370283603668, -0.07401517033576965, -0.042095474898815155, -0.0738266259431839, -0.0049024540930986404, -0.0019973376765847206, -0.023260388523340225, 0.01532212644815445, -0.008951568976044655, 0.04009415581822395, -0.03425336256623268, -0.036390647292137146, -0.016613468527793884, -0.012152438051998615, 0.06843028217554092, -0.045428063720464706, 0.00824173353612423, 0.028178736567497253, 0.03282482549548149, -0.02778487466275692, 0.06589139252901077, -0.03411637991666794, -0.05288055166602135, 0.006319632288068533, -0.0215580016374588, 0.040902648121118546, -0.006664081942290068, 0.021339481696486473, -0.0061536794528365135, -0.003049213672056794, 0.0015742589021101594, 0.06508798152208328, -0.032617680728435516, 0.08986003696918488, 0.057298287749290466, 0.0018311548046767712, -0.010900983586907387, 0.014995545148849487, 0.035189274698495865, -0.021643327549099922, 0.0004654760705307126, -0.025469867512583733, -0.08218364417552948, 0.008565427735447884, 0.05262640863656998, -0.02876230515539646, -0.0295797660946846, -0.011815635487437248, 0.027786865830421448, 0.03280911222100258, 0.021036695688962936, 0.005578198935836554, -0.018953535705804825, -0.002782593248412013, 0.014156397432088852, 0.027348646894097328, 0.010500647127628326, 0.014935134910047054, 0.03316943347454071, 0.0015329421730712056, 0.027431970462203026, 0.01340662594884634, 0.02735200524330139, 0.07207997143268585, 0.001143581815995276, 0.015587897039949894, -0.008148458786308765, -0.014976637437939644, 0.030341889709234238, -0.019232608377933502, 0.0006576463347300887, 0.023892339318990707, -0.000582478882279247, -0.012880915775895119, -0.025128213688731194, -0.03153077885508537, 0.022689320147037506, 0.04542219266295433, -0.049373336136341095, 0.012615240179002285, 0.02284238114953041, -0.015144379809498787, 0.014600574970245361, -0.0040638260543346405, -0.027794286608695984, -0.03577500954270363, -0.00758301792666316, 0.037398677319288254, 0.0027272317092865705, 0.010103476233780384, -0.028158633038401604, -0.05310450866818428, -0.0033960004802793264, 0.015625400468707085, -0.006253773346543312, 0.004986786749213934, -0.10123030096292496, -0.00594536354765296, -0.016070416197180748, -0.04596148058772087, 0.02140934392809868, 0.005846857558935881, -0.03195682540535927, 0.03216682747006416, -0.01819276623427868, -0.02733727917075157, -0.029867883771657944, -0.02101944386959076, 0.010718921199440956, -0.0391736663877964, -0.011599594727158546, 0.054568108171224594, 0.011229528114199638, -0.00019650570175144821, 0.03530579060316086, -0.033450618386268616, -0.04441380128264427, -0.027488207444548607, -0.00916773360222578, 0.009302747435867786, -0.007485260255634785, -0.019449202343821526, 0.028914527967572212, -0.012765380553901196, -0.020212257280945778, -0.04952024295926094, -0.05318114161491394, 0.0461294911801815, 0.02033446915447712, 0.04048717021942139, 0.033096835017204285, 0.0008171951631084085, 0.049708202481269836, 0.039696723222732544, -0.02814454585313797, -0.024295486509799957, -0.008912370540201664, -0.006774659268558025, -0.023916121572256088, 0.021552955731749535, 0.04745063558220863, -0.009074940346181393, -0.010005700401961803, 0.01610967330634594, 0.030167490243911743, 0.010444425977766514, 0.012188635766506195, -0.012998724356293678, 0.023877333849668503, -0.009989138692617416, 0.022817987948656082, 0.006061743479222059, 0.045366354286670685, -0.03302641957998276, 0.028210781514644623, -0.006305181421339512, 0.03580906614661217, 0.020445892587304115, -0.03746163472533226, 0.02149931900203228, -0.018098684027791023, -0.00793750211596489, -0.0622464157640934, 0.06516141444444656, -0.01942649483680725, -0.024889159947633743, 0.007388817146420479, -0.0008792816079221666, 0.0026372093707323074, -0.025269269943237305, 0.005763726774603128, 0.07691171020269394, 0.018025392666459084, -0.019263267517089844, -0.016706276684999466, -0.00039001350523903966, -0.021377068012952805, 0.009013630449771881, -0.00909212976694107, -0.0033762799575924873, 0.03526807948946953, 0.06526680290699005, 0.005117734894156456, -0.049908220767974854, -0.056683339178562164, 0.05533832684159279, -0.05778002738952637, 0.008734079077839851, -0.03505507484078407, 0.05704999342560768, -0.026716170832514763, 0.0487041212618351, 0.005396374501287937, -0.008886804804205894, 0.021001964807510376, 0.014947500079870224, -0.018876058980822563, 0.0512499175965786, -0.012253539636731148, -0.033125367015600204, -0.003914153669029474, -0.019823815673589706, 0.06524894386529922, -0.007060948293656111, -0.013455929234623909, -0.013294666074216366, 0.025665977969765663, -0.01990305259823799, 0.0028395983390510082, -0.003001393284648657, -0.02136227861046791, -0.006007562857121229, 0.040288377553224564, -0.028702490031719208, -0.016418714076280594, 0.025393454357981682, 0.03345891460776329, -0.0020390464924275875, -0.050317324697971344, -0.04845481365919113, 0.030627798289060593, 0.0172552652657032, 0.02303299866616726, 0.03576015308499336, 0.015918148681521416, -0.06721481680870056, 0.02766730822622776, -0.040121953934431076, 0.06251491606235504, 0.050134483724832535, -0.0017894436605274677, -0.011809855699539185, -0.04888841509819031, -0.0018251382280141115, -0.009545378386974335, 0.014774223789572716, 0.008782867342233658, -0.020187824964523315, 0.05492304638028145, 0.01837991364300251, -0.07267522066831589, 0.009922612458467484, 0.017715075984597206, -0.00778668187558651, 0.002876008627936244, -0.032666951417922974, 0.014217803254723549, -0.018004529178142548, 0.010689720511436462, 0.004654414020478725, 0.009595731273293495, 0.005165343172848225, 0.01605396345257759, 0.048293545842170715, -0.021070871502161026, -0.04123548045754433, -0.003799179568886757, -0.009586033411324024, 0.06424425542354584, 0.006040024571120739, -0.044714830815792084, 0.04863623157143593, 0.009569520130753517, 0.034639883786439896, 0.007134397979825735, -0.008899969048798084, -0.10705501586198807, 0.02575383521616459, 0.012977201491594315, 0.04543821141123772, -0.04362078756093979, 0.02262580581009388, -0.03828413411974907, -0.003388017416000366, 0.06186788156628609, 0.004900116939097643, 0.018776847049593925, -0.007018403150141239, 0.010384513065218925, -0.0011575103271752596, 0.013044871389865875, -0.0429019033908844, 0.003159501124173403, -0.039356619119644165, 0.04222702234983444, -0.028404120355844498, 0.0025385254994034767, -0.05600401386618614, 0.026434021070599556, 0.03573332354426384, 0.06368042528629303, -0.03165283426642418, -0.019135918468236923, 0.025483185425400734, 0.04022125154733658, -0.01583069935441017, -0.07339747250080109, -0.012542428448796272, 0.00929933413863182, -0.011782070621848106, 0.04150255024433136, -0.006532647181302309, -0.056521158665418625, 0.011749951168894768, 0.0029093686025589705, -0.006221012212336063, -0.007707083132117987, -0.012874257750809193, 0.033762045204639435, -0.020317094400525093, 0.02098245546221733, 0.06604011356830597, 0.0434051975607872, 0.0099596893414855, 0.016847817227244377, -0.03637177124619484, 0.017026262357831, -0.017540352419018745, -0.04075315594673157, -0.03570671007037163, -0.017202768474817276, 0.029749391600489616, 0.003923715092241764, 0.014729647897183895, 0.02444756217300892, 0.00660155713558197, -0.05231067165732384, -0.013591163791716099, 0.015843216329813004, 0.020310191437602043, 0.0011051672045141459, -0.011424515396356583, 0.002921679290011525, 0.0033527447376400232, -0.03541196510195732, 0.018389342352747917, 0.007339168339967728, 0.03035023622214794, -0.013225088827311993, -0.046676356345415115, -0.013920905999839306, -0.054448071867227554, -0.03654459863901138, 0.007944486103951931, -0.029045769944787025, 0.06271236389875412, 0.013976831920444965, 0.05710740014910698, 0.016035297885537148, -0.029953334480524063, -0.01590367592871189, 0.04275849461555481, 0.01609698124229908, 0.05159199610352516, -0.02035430632531643, 0.04126111418008804, -0.025193244218826294, -0.001506916480138898, -0.061359405517578125, -0.03191649168729782, 0.01911764219403267, 0.025186633691191673, 0.007585407234728336, -0.050445277243852615, 0.009329752996563911, -0.011371025815606117, -0.031795185059309006, 0.009389509446918964, 0.06875427067279816, -0.011674046516418457, -0.00897981133311987, -0.028774674981832504, 0.014749840833246708, 0.11699406057596207, -0.04449458420276642, -0.03478796035051346, 0.009858834557235241, -0.029692914336919785, 0.003082306357100606, -0.027295606210827827, 0.008828971534967422, -0.021641841158270836, -0.006707451771944761, -0.023539423942565918, 0.03683868423104286, 0.037106238305568695, -0.03253747522830963, -0.029371723532676697, -0.018793610855937004, -0.03262421116232872, 0.026566103100776672, -0.02828070893883705, -0.013075736351311207, -0.025140371173620224, 0.019700106233358383, -0.04556066915392876, 0.0156907569617033, -0.0007716087275184691, -0.01641533337533474, 0.0482582151889801, 0.03124198131263256, -0.015013406053185463, 0.048009030520915985, 0.05832618102431297, -0.022590523585677147, 0.028567157685756683, 0.00007653086504433304, -0.016945065930485725, 0.05671248212456703, 0.015302917920053005, -0.03790988400578499, 0.008478446863591671, 0.026419175788760185, -0.017739638686180115, -0.020215122029185295, -0.04059772938489914, -0.009300570003688335, 0.06628396362066269, -0.0041238912381231785, 0.038655199110507965, 0.06960026919841766, 0.015018305741250515, -0.001754612778313458, -0.02478729374706745, -0.007326450198888779, -0.00312790647149086, -0.015722159296274185, 0.03676370158791542, 0.008157570846378803, 0.012154367752373219, 0.03729880228638649, 0.04349483177065849, 0.00726607721298933, 0.026694349944591522, -0.00023823643277864903, 0.010771505534648895, 0.02134763076901436, -0.03743569180369377, -0.020253803580999374, 0.033378928899765015, -0.06496924161911011, -0.005958455614745617, -0.044084396213293076, -0.0315440371632576, 0.05025436356663704, 0.00544445076957345, 0.04440867900848389, -0.03392545506358147, -0.009008442983031273, -0.016751714050769806, -0.008702808991074562, 0.05286937579512596, 0.04386946186423302, 0.035186950117349625, -0.014575921930372715, 0.04915302246809006, -0.03820335865020752, -0.011643729172647, -0.025740649551153183, -0.05840113386511803, -0.03911835327744484, -0.03356057405471802, -0.05602443590760231, -0.005449100863188505, 0.02108665741980076, -0.01862306147813797, 0.02663339115679264, -0.047225359827280045, 0.02637922205030918, -0.012233400717377663, 0.04629584401845932, -0.00020322698401287198, 0.05719934031367302, 0.01046997681260109, 0.008346391841769218, 0.03386402502655983, -0.01862386241555214, 0.1126108318567276, 0.05898871272802353, 0.028239963576197624, -0.04628276079893112, 0.0133040901273489, -0.028215162456035614, -0.00341137801297009, -0.011376803740859032, 0.0026749863754957914, -0.01560320146381855, -0.024193495512008667, 0.008895598351955414, 0.07166911661624908, 0.004277849569916725, 0.0028772547375410795, 0.07033541798591614, -0.005371336359530687, -0.023577485233545303, 0.008698432706296444, -0.0014130340423434973, 0.012216226197779179, -0.031822580844163895, -0.010417970828711987, -0.0009021343430504203, 0.01375629473477602, -0.015962768346071243, -0.04822224751114845, 0.010078340768814087, -0.005063442979007959, 0.0073138088919222355, -0.02256450429558754, 0.007174912374466658, 0.017049139365553856, -0.006449612323194742, -0.024108704179525375, -0.030268870294094086, 0.008388939313590527, -0.05796456336975098, 0.017173057422041893, 0.048505425453186035, -0.02786114253103733, 0.03590197116136551, 0.005751746706664562, 0.03569798544049263, -0.0035291118547320366, -0.017452586442232132, -0.012157361954450607, 0.02863522432744503, -0.025632653385400772, 0.013041790574789047, -0.019804904237389565, 0.01921777054667473, -0.0224310215562582, -0.03218671679496765, -0.01136897224932909, 0.03340328112244606, 0.02111905999481678, -0.015848172828555107, -0.008738483302295208, -0.0065915887244045734, 0.0180222038179636, -0.021000543609261513, 0.019624022766947746, -0.0002062102867057547, -0.04900757968425751, -0.010417532175779343, -0.018005333840847015, -0.006642157211899757, -0.00449747871607542, -0.023487916216254234, -0.029873067513108253, -0.01953679509460926, -0.025643281638622284, 0.0045336270704865456, 0.02133677713572979, 0.015049384906888008, 0.05745435133576393, -0.0034011288080364466, 0.0053886594250798225, -0.020280273631215096, -0.056067172437906265, 0.02136014588177204, -0.015002508647739887, -0.010036546736955643, -0.023942355066537857, -0.0010985881090164185, -0.004465533886104822, 0.04201750457286835, 0.012918459251523018, 0.029438333585858345, 0.00261798407882452, 0.04756281152367592, 0.008932207711040974, -0.04920361936092377, -0.00962818693369627, -0.016240211203694344, -0.017455797642469406, 0.01771652325987816, 0.0024930876679718494, 0.05705413222312927, 0.026066120713949203, -0.0014211804373189807, 0.021878721192479134, 0.015825295820832253, 0.015447715297341347, 0.028826171532273293, 0.01736099272966385, -0.07321452349424362, 0.02859748899936676, 0.017910581082105637, -0.009720789268612862, -0.059156011790037155, -0.0512130968272686, -0.01243663765490055, -0.04389123618602753, 0.026023808866739273, -0.03388143703341484, 0.00014357006875798106, 0.035381436347961426, -0.044261686503887177, -0.014742505736649036, -0.032266851514577866, -0.011494195088744164, -0.04982254281640053, -0.03333009034395218, -0.014657221734523773, -0.030953414738178253, 0.019852809607982635, -0.02120979130268097, -0.008631688542664051, -0.0050621647387743, 0.014604929834604263, -0.0029237200506031513, -0.008403077721595764, 0.0011019011726602912, 0.005062104668468237, -0.026209697127342224, 0.04239239916205406, -0.0446983203291893, 0.013232477940618992, 0.06851617991924286, -0.037892282009124756, -0.03001561015844345, 0.01116735115647316, 0.00904424861073494, 0.06486617028713226, 0.03844756633043289, -0.011804207228124142, 0.013003104366362095, 0.04221544414758682, -0.018302885815501213, -0.03463759273290634, -0.037107471376657486, 0.028801295906305313, -0.000007852216185710859, 0.004616095218807459, -0.0004838543536607176, 0.008942695334553719, -0.010768122039735317, 0.04963241517543793, 0.023013485595583916, -0.0019255783408880234, -0.027981474995613098, -0.009679451584815979, 0.0010583472903817892, -0.00013472735008690506, 0.01249570120126009, -0.007472330238670111, 0.03723935782909393, 0.04221697896718979, -0.03138778731226921, 0.03795632719993591, -0.016554420813918114, 0.008507495746016502, -0.07801884412765503, -0.03394641354680061, 0.023401111364364624, -0.016943061724305153, 0.03040209785103798, -0.055396292358636856, -0.012390563264489174, -0.007117200177162886, -0.043212465941905975, 0.037229061126708984, -0.007105293218046427, 0.013379840180277824, -0.03333704173564911, 0.02229400910437107, -0.004079362843185663, 0.008514201268553734, 0.004639806225895882, 0.02556808851659298, 0.0017235601553693414, -0.002060879021883011, 0.01828729920089245, -0.031618986278772354, 0.014509351924061775, 0.0005626162164844573, 0.0075650764629244804, -0.07963917404413223, 0.0011820726795122027, -0.007990894839167595, -0.03119589015841484, 0.022453375160694122, -0.030411476269364357, 0.03488187491893768, 0.05907417833805084, 0.008866680786013603, -0.006205359939485788, 0.03182077780365944, 0.007945572026073933, -0.005681206937879324, 0.011280588805675507, 0.05107971280813217, 0.026942597702145576, 0.010709111578762531, -0.02042548730969429, 0.0020592070650309324, 0.045644138008356094, -0.03362672030925751, -0.003379394533112645, 0.02215203084051609, -0.04004105553030968, -0.03916388750076294, 0.009219535626471043, -0.019910110160708427, -0.005745106376707554, -0.005531908478587866, 0.06339338421821594, -0.027295798063278198, 0.0038522726390510798, 0.02728678099811077, 0.00875694677233696, 0.003829473629593849, -0.01376599445939064, 0.0017835295293480158, -0.016359861940145493, 0.006187183316797018, 0.008707399480044842, 0.008991386741399765, -0.039761949330568314, -0.010399134829640388, -0.015911001712083817, -0.016099052503705025, -0.032431770116090775, -0.009996834211051464, -0.0321759358048439, 0.04193651303648949, -0.004736634436994791, 0.0019233936909586191, 0.022128526121377945, -0.002937811193987727, 0.002005535876378417, -0.05467446148395538, 0.06685913354158401, 0.028362613171339035, 0.026136614382267, -0.05250424146652222, 0.016476545482873917, -0.038786228746175766, 0.013295197859406471, 0.024342432618141174, -0.009968314319849014, 0.01184720080345869, -0.007569727022200823, 0.004751695320010185, 0.004179056733846664, -0.043957535177469254, 0.039414700120687485, -0.013303978368639946, -0.044680025428533554, -0.027763938531279564, 0.004955973010510206, -0.0161509420722723, 0.0023382948711514473, 0.0043425485491752625, 0.02190404385328293, 0.026975063607096672, 0.00011975086090387776, -0.016733592376112938, 0.03984004631638527, 0.0370609313249588, -0.00030036518000997603, 0.01474104542285204, 0.006515223067253828, 0.010006988421082497, 0.03395266830921173, 0.006453972775489092, -0.0608331523835659, 0.01384073868393898, -0.040556468069553375, -0.03405144065618515, -0.01067562960088253, -0.004741576500236988, 0.013034832663834095, -0.026555437594652176, 0.03318791463971138, 0.01738051325082779, -0.05557671934366226, 0.007046787533909082, 0.018749145790934563, 0.04586675763130188, 0.001495383563451469, -0.059043802320957184, 0.0036065021995455027, 0.010205456055700779, -0.024845454841852188, 0.0026103323325514793, 0.003534622024744749, 0.016962246969342232, -0.016310488805174828, 0.04992130771279335, 0.057465363293886185, 0.017910173162817955, 0.029675520956516266, 0.0015209995908662677, 0.02407781034708023, -0.036573003977537155, -0.0007754995604045689, -0.014076100662350655, -0.0010398848680779338, -0.004119939170777798, 0.018664134666323662, -0.017363177612423897, 0.02477806620299816, -0.019360972568392754, -0.017969898879528046, -0.03250334411859512, -0.032196126878261566, 0.006499357987195253, -0.012943116948008537, 0.003442411543801427, 0.037490300834178925, 0.00666829152032733, -0.0026509109884500504, -0.005315711721777916, -0.0007638188544660807, 0.0414794497191906, -0.02354639768600464, 0.03321048989892006, 0.014101944863796234, -0.007192027289420366, -0.019565192982554436, -0.021252207458019257, -0.013578081503510475, -0.021111059933900833, 0.052274081856012344, 0.046700369566679, 0.020130164921283722, -0.02428155578672886, -0.00804195087403059, -0.023475641384720802, 0.014956618659198284, -0.07402778416872025, -0.039767369627952576, -0.051124218851327896, -0.005714103113859892, -0.011035936884582043, -0.021474536508321762 ]
<p>Looking at the <a href="http://www.mrc-bsu.cam.ac.uk/bugs/winbugs/geobugs12manual.pdf" rel="nofollow">GeoBUGS manual version 12</a>, there is a confusion how exactly the <code>car.normal</code> model is specified:</p> <p>1) at page 12, I read</p> <blockquote> <h3>car.normal and car.l1 [top]</h3> <p>The intrinsic Gaussian CAR prior distribution is specified using the distribution car.normal for the vector of random varables ....</p> </blockquote> <p>2) looking into Appendix 1, how exactly is this <strong>intrinsic</strong> CAR model specified, I read (page 41):</p> <blockquote> <h3>Intrinsic CAR model [top]</h3> <p>Besag, York and Mollie (1991) propose an intrinsic version of this CAR model in which [...] Their model corresponds to choosing C<sub>ij</sub> = 1/n<sub>i</sub> if areas i and j are adjacent and C<sub>ij</sub> = 0 otherwise (with C<sub>ii</sub> also set to 0) [...] Note that an equivalent specification is take unnormalised weights W<sub>ij</sub> = 1 if areas i and j are adjacent and W<sub>ij</sub> = 0 otherwise, and set C<sub>ij</sub> = W<sub>ij</sub> / W<sub>i+</sub> where W<sub>i+</sub> = &sum;<sub>j</sub> W<sub>ij</sub>. The car.normal and (car.l1) distributions in GeoBUGS requires the user to specify unnormalised weights.</p> </blockquote> <p>Let alone that they use Both C<sub>ij</sub> and W<sub>ij</sub> for weights, which is confusing, and that setting C<sub>ij</sub> = W<sub>ij</sub> / W<sub>i+</sub> with W<sub>ij</sub> = 1 for neighbours is trivially the same as setting C<sub>ij</sub> = 1/n<sub>i</sub>, so why they say it's equivalent - they probably wanted to say that an equivalent specification is to set C<sub>ij</sub> = 1 for neighbours and 0 otherwise... There seems to be a lot confusion in the manual (e.g. what is v in the model at pg. 41, what is &Phi; in the Conditional specification at pg. 41 and how is it connected to tau parameter at pg. 12?) but anyway... </p> <p>The major confusion is that <code>car.normal</code> allows specification of <em>arbitrary (?) weights</em>, yet they say that weights are restricted to 1 and 0 and in the model specification at the end of page 41 (and beginning of page 42) there are no weights in the expression. So it is not clear what the actual model of <code>car.normal</code> actually does. The description of <code>weights</code> parameter at pg 12 doesn't make it clearer:</p> <blockquote> <p><strong>weights[]</strong> : A vector the same length as adj[] giving unnormalised weights associated with each pair of areas. For the CAR model described above, taking Cij = 1 (equivalently Wij = 1/ ni ) if areas i and j are neighbours and 0 otherwise, gives a vector of 1's for weights[].</p> </blockquote> <p>I don't know what they mean by "CAR model described above", there is only a general call to <code>car.normal</code> - so this is kind of circular definition. So is it necessary to have such weights or not? This comment adds a lot of confusion. (and btw they keep using both C and W for weights, here at pg 12 they use them in the opposite context than at pg 41 - sometimes W is normalized, sometimes C is normalized..)</p> <p>I would like to see the real expression behind this model. I can only speculate if the model is like:</p> <p>$$ S_i|S_j \sim \mbox{Normal}(\frac{1}{n_i}\sum_{j}{S_j}, \frac{1}{\tau \space n_i}) $$</p> <p>as suggested (unclearly) by the documentation in the Appendix 1, or if it is like ($w_{i+} = \sum_{k}{w_{ik}}$) </p> <p>$$ S_i|S_j \sim \mbox{Normal}(\frac{1}{w_{i+}}\sum_{j}{w_{ij} \space S_j}, \frac{1}{\tau \space n_i}) $$ </p> <p>as you would expect from the function <code>car.normal</code> having weights as an argument (why would it be there if it must be all 1s?)</p> <p>Is there any other authoritative/trustworthy source to answer that question?</p>
73,774
[ -0.018890613690018654, -0.0447794646024704, 0.0015458835987374187, -0.03627121075987816, 0.05131971836090088, 0.005874510854482651, -0.008618781343102455, -0.039488062262535095, -0.0010517515474930406, -0.0438244454562664, 0.007560429163277149, 0.05583922192454338, 0.043088655918836594, 0.04110058769583702, 0.012326951138675213, 0.00642296951264143, 0.004800592549145222, 0.005568491294980049, -0.018073532730340958, -0.025847991928458214, 0.012980993837118149, 0.0036249731201678514, -0.007846495136618614, -0.012326723895967007, 0.02344042807817459, 0.006275296676903963, -0.050434015691280365, -0.07010069489479065, 0.005067017860710621, 0.0357796810567379, -0.025345901027321815, 0.003561920253559947, -0.030031654983758926, 0.003926401492208242, -0.02874816581606865, 0.005298689939081669, 0.02024449221789837, -0.002550759119912982, -0.006164996884763241, 0.026958683505654335, -0.034511350095272064, -0.012447298504412174, -0.04261964559555054, 0.029767723754048347, -0.05097062513232231, 0.05446706339716911, -0.00402826676145196, -0.030863195657730103, 0.042651597410440445, -0.0264128427952528, 0.05627628415822983, -0.016242582350969315, 0.026962311938405037, 0.03470947965979576, -0.013860389590263367, -0.03878920525312424, 0.048986200243234634, 0.046578601002693176, 0.021053684875369072, -0.057885222136974335, -0.01419763546437025, -0.012663441710174084, 0.0027436399832367897, -0.036749064922332764, 0.006310185883194208, 0.01778978295624256, 0.008992386050522327, -0.0683080181479454, 0.05683695524930954, 0.00024380382092203945, 0.0231794323772192, 0.0010131066665053368, 0.005506573710590601, -0.03454633802175522, 0.012713420204818249, 0.006532507948577404, -0.011883776634931564, 0.034674011170864105, 0.011344380676746368, -0.002369099762290716, 0.01573043130338192, -0.009660529904067516, 0.004889854229986668, 0.023148437961935997, 0.01069566048681736, 0.0017439692746847868, 0.07470444589853287, -0.012760509736835957, 0.024848368018865585, 0.01716572232544422, -0.025548502802848816, 0.003618787042796612, 0.051857318729162216, -0.023206926882267, -0.0001671381323831156, 0.0712614506483078, 0.016625378280878067, -0.0187717005610466, -0.03516259789466858, 0.02332947961986065, -0.044917941093444824, -0.05233500897884369, -0.004719647578895092, 0.041558168828487396, -0.025239523500204086, -0.027955319732427597, -0.023596854880452156, 0.019768444821238518, 0.006793088745325804, -0.03078489936888218, -0.049108732491731644, 0.032100118696689606, -0.026110785081982613, -0.03080032579600811, 0.02246127463877201, -0.005221543367952108, 0.0224860031157732, 0.020310858264565468, 0.04866695776581764, 0.02512884885072708, 0.06434854120016098, -0.0185261070728302, -0.026585694402456284, -0.04664868116378784, -0.04579227790236473, -0.02683933638036251, 0.005983863957226276, -0.018756011500954628, -0.05917816609144211, 0.046668630093336105, -0.0016617057844996452, -0.01378563977777958, 0.02599838562309742, 0.005290713161230087, -0.027089621871709824, 0.00379746500402689, -0.06095777079463005, -0.0793461725115776, 0.022407090291380882, -0.047527048736810684, 0.05276256054639816, -0.055756766349077225, -0.012576285749673843, 0.00585166085511446, 0.05673830956220627, 0.006217973306775093, 0.06170017644762993, 0.019757846370339394, 0.015138252638280392, -0.0070959110744297504, 0.0029692677780985832, -0.013399318791925907, -0.029284503310918808, -0.019844595342874527, -0.056395746767520905, -0.10971678793430328, 0.04765060544013977, 0.020322466269135475, -0.04104280099272728, -0.009564820677042007, 0.034854717552661896, 0.01706128567457199, 0.023155011236667633, -0.009768455289304256, -0.02250034175813198, -0.03723949193954468, 0.05702557414770126, 0.021440090611577034, 0.029478084295988083, 0.04503729194402695, -0.017016148194670677, 0.029388751834630966, -0.005301926285028458, 0.010440555401146412, 0.025015661492943764, -0.042697980999946594, 0.014346188865602016, -0.017956264317035675, 0.0005186808994039893, 0.031370118260383606, -0.034468092024326324, -0.005418041255325079, -0.03443742170929909, -0.0024162831250578165, 0.028471311554312706, 0.031886979937553406, -0.00433809170499444, -0.009354733861982822, 0.049213945865631104, -0.03609596565365791, -0.0006343124550767243, -0.021577032282948494, 0.012899012304842472, 0.009395115077495575, -0.0017822245135903358, 0.038092512637376785, -0.0386296845972538, 0.03591780737042427, 0.029679153114557266, -0.0076515632681548595, 0.011476263403892517, 0.004131443332880735, 0.04423400014638901, -0.05114436149597168, 0.009995213709771633, 0.06271790713071823, 0.02467949129641056, -0.012945490889251232, 0.01731380634009838, 0.010121595114469528, -0.040098462253808975, 0.019498314708471298, -0.021296674385666847, 0.022228330373764038, -0.010722501203417778, -0.019568007439374924, -0.0016074456507340074, 0.05234166979789734, -0.020684681832790375, 0.0009224214009009302, -0.07063771039247513, 0.024788785725831985, 0.07839513570070267, 0.011024817824363708, -0.027632664889097214, 0.06487274914979935, -0.02225528657436371, 0.04206927493214607, 0.001894647255539894, -0.0322391502559185, -0.06688836961984634, -0.0007251101196743548, 0.056847721338272095, 0.014810584485530853, -0.061722759157419205, -0.0027244556695222855, 0.041068900376558304, 0.036911364644765854, 0.022853778675198555, 0.02041064389050007, 0.0015384542057290673, -0.06168093532323837, 0.04250246286392212, 0.01986667886376381, 0.01618574745953083, 0.00906298216432333, -0.027985338121652603, -0.0009788102470338345, 0.04188298434019089, -0.034743908792734146, -0.005302039906382561, 0.045520246028900146, -0.020592691376805305, 0.012990144081413746, -0.04663865268230438, 0.017269717529416084, 0.06848806887865067, -0.038417402654886246, -0.0031091610435396433, 0.05282457545399666, -0.033019427210092545, -0.027185669168829918, -0.01628454588353634, -0.04355446249246597, -0.010170241817831993, 0.008818883448839188, -0.02381412498652935, -0.0031118146143853664, 0.007867529056966305, -0.010738077573478222, 0.028092240914702415, -0.03447667509317398, -0.011052332818508148, -0.04397139698266983, 0.021556833758950233, 0.0416305772960186, 0.05227195471525192, -0.027657797560095787, -0.02500060573220253, 0.007477879524230957, -0.03064727410674095, 0.031960900872945786, 0.007033783942461014, 0.015253154560923576, -0.015529184602200985, 0.027168776839971542, -0.05022817105054855, -0.007715000305324793, 0.031124820932745934, -0.03166869282722473, -0.060299403965473175, 0.03292413428425789, 0.017133396118879318, -0.027319662272930145, -0.007166394032537937, -0.026158688589930534, 0.0168173648416996, -0.04027288407087326, -0.0579349584877491, 0.04392767325043678, 0.05043104663491249, -0.02753237448632717, 0.026943977922201157, 0.00043593996088020504, -0.026663463562726974, 0.014069419354200363, -0.026575110852718353, -0.02057259902358055, -0.0005258466699160635, 0.036814406514167786, 0.03267131373286247, -0.029297946020960808, 0.010921795852482319, -0.07798592001199722, -0.0541498102247715, 0.015620533376932144, -0.011668801307678223, 0.03168879821896553, 0.017747823148965836, 0.03701284900307655, 0.07997811585664749, 0.026908334344625473, -0.010937397368252277, -0.010136697441339493, -0.00040315790101885796, -0.021314634010195732, -0.03408427536487579, -0.029270537197589874, -0.00026618593255989254, 0.02165328897535801, 0.00033122708555310965, -0.005116325803101063, 0.04318610578775406, 0.0533030666410923, -0.028262939304113388, 0.0049702757969498634, 0.0353534035384655, -0.0466448999941349, -0.032759010791778564, 0.04337156191468239, 0.026737380772829056, 0.04225533828139305, -0.022432727739214897, -0.021373560652136803, 0.019956834614276886, 0.02645834907889366, -0.028300918638706207, 0.011243618093430996, 0.01082826778292656, 0.04747197777032852, -0.05425267666578293, 0.040480341762304306, -0.02422783523797989, -0.027322236448526382, 0.0016771676018834114, -0.014098457992076874, 0.048879507929086685, -0.0040874299593269825, -0.005474233068525791, 0.04961389675736427, 0.05893227085471153, -0.01118903886526823, -0.02147608995437622, -0.0023818116169422865, 0.026749245822429657, 0.037393856793642044, 0.001451707910746336, 0.009009665809571743, 0.017687378451228142, 0.05445880815386772, -0.011119889095425606, 0.0014691733522340655, -0.04770736023783684, 0.005591547582298517, -0.049725040793418884, 0.010036301799118519, -0.04411902278661728, 0.0015440876595675945, -0.014304393902420998, 0.0034408820793032646, 0.016300814226269722, -0.0285706277936697, -0.007769426796585321, -0.008481714874505997, -0.059496473520994186, -0.014241020195186138, 0.04330069199204445, -0.013007638975977898, 0.00919484905898571, -0.0737031027674675, 0.024516966193914413, -0.02162412367761135, 0.04238389432430267, -0.003741935361176729, 0.0064160567708313465, -0.03254448622465134, 0.013902216218411922, -0.008535812608897686, -0.023333612829446793, -0.013464530929923058, 0.014790497720241547, 0.03981781005859375, -0.025277329608798027, 0.012762353755533695, 0.02004728838801384, 0.0018516938434913754, -0.017143897712230682, -0.0013396083377301693, 0.006760162767022848, 0.03265732154250145, 0.022403862327337265, 0.025791587308049202, 0.019779544323682785, -0.008334062062203884, -0.010791151784360409, 0.042322710156440735, 0.04881233721971512, 0.03375965356826782, -0.014873000793159008, -0.011494997888803482, -0.056221481412649155, -0.02920396439731121, 0.028793197125196457, 0.021145157516002655, -0.014945214614272118, 0.021205594763159752, 0.04786783084273338, 0.013932137750089169, -0.02754717506468296, 0.02035169117152691, 0.01992306299507618, 0.032009243965148926, -0.0012596953893080354, -0.021863073110580444, -0.021364526823163033, 0.007106920704245567, -0.04062763601541519, 0.056864071637392044, 0.015165167860686779, -0.0382191501557827, -0.016554072499275208, 0.04140026867389679, 0.007856360636651516, -0.027208441868424416, -0.0014824371319264174, -0.025290662422776222, 0.022579262033104897, 0.006095838267356157, 0.0052561829797923565, 0.026245808228850365, 0.004162422381341457, 0.04597507044672966, 0.034707412123680115, -0.029341621324419975, -0.08696979284286499, -0.03533680737018585, 0.028032759204506874, 0.015050079673528671, 0.0016813701950013638, -0.0027088900096714497, -0.0491788387298584, -0.014666197821497917, 0.0005297369789332151, -0.010929967276751995, 0.05923875421285629, -0.008153802715241909, 0.022134827449917793, -0.0046304333955049515, -0.038681548088788986, -0.020751643925905228, 0.012673272751271725, -0.008902158588171005, 0.030769994482398033, -0.020045578479766846, 0.0054872045293450356, -0.034414827823638916, 0.03002704493701458, -0.03628818690776825, 0.0053838337771594524, -0.04834238067269325, -0.015209730714559555, -0.007482259999960661, 0.019814981147646904, 0.0039058050606399775, -0.04574829339981079, 0.02217361517250538, -0.0044603366404771805, 0.0019401672761887312, 0.07191530615091324, -0.024033518508076668, 0.0007100985385477543, 0.02981100231409073, 0.02537940815091133, -0.008773247711360455, 0.011048839427530766, -0.01555386558175087, 0.04494551569223404, 0.013160321861505508, -0.03550708666443825, 0.04779291898012161, -0.0033237941097468138, -0.02804587595164776, -0.011437470093369484, -0.029908617958426476, 0.01962244138121605, -0.038204412907361984, -0.036288343369960785, -0.04954071715474129, 0.020845144987106323, 0.0030313318129628897, 0.0026797596365213394, 0.011325228959321976, 0.014007003977894783, -0.04422586411237717, -0.04100685194134712, 0.008804121054708958, -0.011257007718086243, -0.024174127727746964, 0.030368074774742126, -0.027024779468774796, 0.051984403282403946, -0.012958274222910404, -0.020656714215874672, 0.009706525132060051, -0.05329744517803192, 0.013079989701509476, 0.014398684725165367, -0.011362488381564617, -0.017557451501488686, -0.03318561986088753, 0.014604194089770317, 0.017850464209914207, -0.03604857251048088, 0.03278924897313118, 0.021257849410176277, 0.05997820943593979, -0.001815894152969122, -0.004898431245237589, -0.022504372522234917, 0.01664181798696518, 0.009558552876114845, 0.043829984962940216, 0.004863061476498842, 0.047135744243860245, 0.000059839068853762, -0.010998337529599667, -0.0424918606877327, -0.02137439325451851, 0.02304741181433201, 0.030296852812170982, -0.04526001214981079, -0.02287404052913189, 0.004563968162983656, -0.006238206289708614, -0.021768080070614815, -0.03937869891524315, 0.06869295239448547, -0.031898949295282364, 0.0014032921753823757, 0.024129893630743027, 0.031680814921855927, 0.05664072185754776, 0.001981097972020507, -0.012589705176651478, 0.06671541929244995, -0.008232977241277695, -0.004728952422738075, -0.019984988495707512, -0.005002109333872795, -0.04006065055727959, 0.034729067236185074, -0.026672737672924995, 0.01341088768094778, 0.07499589025974274, -0.0012775425566360354, -0.04386391490697861, 0.015625769272446632, 0.007128907833248377, -0.008375262841582298, -0.022768141701817513, -0.0034790944773703814, -0.007982655428349972, 0.0031863925978541374, -0.0810309424996376, 0.0164822805672884, -0.0007640770054422319, 0.00422714464366436, 0.02895532362163067, -0.02117396518588066, 0.008554061874747276, 0.03537657484412193, 0.046186476945877075, 0.007059626746922731, 0.025844084098935127, -0.025962235406041145, 0.0008788115810602903, 0.03105936013162136, 0.01008648332208395, 0.009575072675943375, 0.053856801241636276, -0.0026174348313361406, -0.006530630402266979, 0.0017544875154271722, -0.0639318898320198, 0.0537758506834507, 0.05208868160843849, -0.004108345601707697, 0.04070306196808815, 0.05584616959095001, -0.045800354331731796, -0.025983776897192, -0.05652344599366188, -0.012916340492665768, 0.003723548259586096, -0.00960247591137886, 0.06090398132801056, -0.014623605646193027, -0.03250020742416382, 0.04287201166152954, 0.014552884735167027, 0.0063970331102609634, -0.0036538285203278065, -0.00984109751880169, 0.008770451880991459, 0.000038414360460592434, -0.010911968536674976, -0.029614418745040894, 0.04994026944041252, -0.0005197859136387706, 0.01594359427690506, 0.03908061608672142, -0.017304174602031708, 0.04638098552823067, 0.02651618979871273, -0.003985508810728788, -0.05443746596574783, -0.023626798763871193, -0.04917830228805542, 0.02563142031431198, 0.02985563315451145, -0.04527640342712402, -0.03333301842212677, 0.007589793764054775, 0.019770337268710136, -0.019990868866443634, 0.022964337840676308, -0.02370738983154297, -0.07874469459056854, -0.04235101863741875, -0.02810649201273918, -0.014324728399515152, 0.04303640127182007, 0.023129962384700775, -0.034221913665533066, 0.04653842747211456, -0.0610591359436512, 0.045611362904310226, 0.03314710035920143, 0.020093129947781563, 0.03444956988096237, 0.07184717804193497, 0.00020677679276559502, 0.003669401630759239, -0.0410131998360157, -0.045397982001304626, 0.15425753593444824, 0.0551876500248909, 0.02860197424888611, -0.044920194894075394, 0.044949859380722046, -0.013481996022164822, -0.006582939997315407, 0.009389611892402172, -0.03864738717675209, 0.020907793194055557, -0.01996937394142151, 0.03258848190307617, 0.006857459899038076, -0.0009945044293999672, -0.018330929800868034, 0.016917400062084198, -0.04638335481286049, -0.04092198237776756, 0.005089952144771814, 0.05908357352018356, 0.02191510796546936, -0.012193607166409492, -0.026600457727909088, -0.005055881571024656, 0.04687022790312767, -0.02276471257209778, -0.0050519127398729324, 0.009246502071619034, -0.027800772339105606, 0.03909248113632202, -0.0300341434776783, 0.005187068600207567, 0.019708646461367607, 0.018898097798228264, 0.02482093870639801, 0.010743842460215092, 0.021075742319226265, -0.03258741647005081, -0.01220488827675581, 0.03000427596271038, 0.01036012638360262, 0.014464320614933968, 0.014761192724108696, 0.016677865758538246, -0.04795166850090027, -0.022910894826054573, -0.04500701650977135, 0.018846921622753143, -0.06217975914478302, -0.012723824009299278, 0.010208919644355774, 0.022520896047353745, 0.047164592891931534, -0.04099087044596672, 0.00400332547724247, -0.009089954197406769, 0.023570114746689796, 0.02181362174451351, -0.007788916118443012, 0.01063805352896452, 0.00641531590372324, -0.0012327258009463549, 0.026746664196252823, 0.024676362052559853, -0.03022116981446743, -0.045108944177627563, -0.050179850310087204, 0.06553357094526291, -0.007218600250780582, 0.03798800706863403, -0.005879226606339216, -0.04454851895570755, -0.039408743381500244, -0.015406250953674316, -0.009052924811840057, 0.003232328686863184, 0.06458466500043869, 0.010706666857004166, 0.0047030942514538765, -0.010940885171294212, -0.02743573673069477, -0.009563161060214043, -0.0266233142465353, 0.015492611564695835, -0.05348537489771843, 0.020020578056573868, -0.001732105971314013, 0.01888461224734783, 0.030004093423485756, 0.017905505374073982, -0.026065723970532417, 0.06311602145433426, -0.025985904037952423, 0.016721542924642563, -0.031859107315540314, -0.0006373375072143972, -0.030047886073589325, -0.00993314478546381, 0.036111265420913696, 0.012625027447938919, 0.03466484323143959, 0.032338112592697144, -0.01713605970144272, 0.06142876297235489, 0.009988338686525822, -0.003777229692786932, 0.01007112767547369, -0.06954748183488846, 0.006146361585706472, 0.02912476472556591, -0.03364568203687668, -0.04665075242519379, 0.02976791374385357, 0.01076381467282772, -0.015946678817272186, 0.037030771374702454, 0.018598319962620735, -0.047618571668863297, -0.03895379602909088, -0.03705381974577904, -0.00011513352365000173, 0.005658749025315046, -0.025384020060300827, 0.013754148036241531, 0.0013438926544040442, -0.018157245591282845, -0.005555727984756231, -0.025695011019706726, 0.007342478260397911, -0.0172102190554142, 0.0056210290640592575, 0.024226216599345207, -0.021372826769948006, 0.018971944227814674, -0.03901784494519234, -0.02088906615972519, 0.004437615163624287, 0.04538608342409134, 0.005319588351994753, -0.029049864038825035, 0.008351672440767288, -0.005224030464887619, -0.029649503529071808, -0.019480599090456963, -0.001964746043086052, 0.005596311297267675, -0.0038459792267531157, -0.005223903805017471, -0.03343157470226288, 0.06537596136331558, -0.027356615290045738, -0.014538641087710857, -0.017770223319530487, 0.007742706686258316, -0.004996582865715027, -0.0376986488699913, 0.011234489269554615, 0.02302093617618084, -0.028226088732481003, 0.014717165380716324, -0.004393387585878372, -0.04586571827530861, 0.0019944545347243547, 0.0013577296631410718, -0.042259279638528824, -0.007025926373898983, -0.031784072518348694, 0.027629496529698372, 0.03512139990925789, 0.007077554240822792, 0.0083011444658041, 0.008142612874507904, -0.03635616973042488, -0.0004897852777503431, -0.0729917585849762, -0.021349292248487473, 0.04102592170238495, -0.008887236006557941, 0.049653176218271255, -0.04402081295847893, 0.03093506209552288, 0.028732093051075935, -0.06896346807479858, -0.011355911381542683, 0.005247491877526045, 0.032428596168756485, -0.06695054471492767, 0.03183674067258835, -0.027356911450624466, 0.009367483668029308, -0.027353646233677864, -0.009566495195031166, 0.031988613307476044, 0.04268314689397812, -0.019291061908006668, -0.022772997617721558, -0.00424611009657383, -0.009020683355629444, 0.04947482421994209, -0.004574276506900787, 0.03617601469159126, -0.0033834793139249086, 0.01838701218366623, 0.007619591895490885, -0.04211680591106415, 0.009308885782957077, 0.011330416426062584, 0.034294698387384415, 0.04579699784517288, 0.03361941874027252, 0.03843142092227936, 0.0481853224337101, 0.021411599591374397, -0.03428902477025986, 0.003599891671910882, 0.01208589132875204, -0.007821019738912582, 0.0022786834742873907, 0.018116144463419914, -0.032495614141225815, -0.04315507784485817, 0.022364500910043716, -0.03341912850737572, -0.017247801646590233, 0.03250011056661606, 0.004346860107034445, 0.005993830505758524, -0.041299961507320404, 0.0037889524828642607, -0.04723988473415375, 0.00008448951120954007, 0.05551029369235039, 0.014664395712316036, -0.03478502854704857, 0.0014122843276709318, -0.048023659735918045, -0.02413148060441017, -0.0072289686650037766, 0.0024290659930557013, 0.007232398726046085, -0.028520595282316208, 0.017491646111011505, 0.02367442660033703, 0.007164896000176668, -0.03952103480696678, -0.004634948913007975, -0.06567972153425217, 0.01670166291296482, 0.009064780548214912, -0.013761438429355621, -0.014459065161645412, 0.007043504621833563, 0.023562585934996605, -0.09680185467004776, 0.05644461140036583, 0.00966496579349041, -0.04069066047668457, -0.03897994011640549, -0.0139094777405262, -0.000752240710426122, 0.016694404184818268, 0.056589219719171524, -0.0069883763790130615, -0.025243179872632027, 0.0019395991694182158, 0.04056720435619354, -0.007278573699295521, 0.02338617667555809, 0.03301995247602463, -0.0016858229646459222, -0.02820936031639576, 0.030690180137753487, 0.022357705980539322, -0.0005224939668551087, 0.018616465851664543, -0.0008446660358458757, 0.004587761592119932, 0.0012949325609952211, -0.017279895022511482, 0.005949257407337427, 0.00964797381311655, -0.002165509620681405, -0.035169050097465515, 0.046505846083164215, 0.025392252951860428, 0.027802549302577972, 0.041804756969213486, 0.02556469850242138, -0.038092419505119324, 0.02167641744017601, -0.04587772116065025, -0.03977683559060097, 0.012003069743514061, -0.0011603479506447911, 0.05293460562825203, -0.027356600388884544, -0.00024319576914422214, 0.034630849957466125, -0.02597772888839245, -0.0031013754196465015, 0.023764288052916527, 0.03992556780576706, 0.06062022224068642, 0.0469355508685112, 0.01899396814405918, 0.015278175473213196, -0.016826247796416283, 0.017830567434430122, 0.01943141594529152, 0.0429890900850296, -0.0037291080225259066, -0.021687908098101616, 0.03193960711359978, -0.019342005252838135, 0.060892362147569656, -0.01662309095263481, 0.05470231920480728, -0.0155939981341362, -0.011062145233154297, 0.021357301622629166, 0.013391047716140747, 0.05501071363687515, 0.014980653300881386, -0.028313113376498222, 0.046239934861660004, -0.0008029777673073113, 0.0022667981684207916, -0.00031848790240474045, -0.0050069899298250675, -0.041886381804943085, 0.024248763918876648, -0.004816509783267975, 0.021501554176211357, 0.03014053776860237, -0.017249664291739464, -0.0032403443474322557, -0.0548371858894825, -0.00047229093615897, -0.03957637399435043, 0.0318908728659153, 0.006847696844488382, 0.01613709330558777, 0.028156157582998276, 0.0020488433074206114, -0.022021351382136345, 0.03453877195715904, -0.01972793973982334, 0.03832799568772316, 0.007836182601749897, -0.05346234142780304, -0.017175639048218727, -0.01706266775727272, 0.040627170354127884, -0.05658538267016411, 0.006347706541419029, -0.04151475057005882, 0.006656351499259472, -0.015737244859337807, -0.032948125153779984 ]
<p>I'd like to match the outputs of lmer (really glmer) with a toy binomial example. I've read the vignettes and believe I understand what's going on.</p> <p>But apparently I do not. After getting stuck, I fixed the "truth" in terms of the random effects and went after estimation of the fixed effects alone. I'm including this code below. To see that it's legit, you can comment out <code>+ Z %*% b.k</code> and it will match the results of a regular glm. I'm hoping to borrow some brainpower to figure out why I'm not able to match lmer's output when the random effects are included.</p> <pre><code># Setup - hard coding simple data set df &lt;- data.frame(x1 = rep(c(1:5), 3), subject = sort(rep(c(1:3), 5))) df$subject &lt;- factor(df$subject) # True coefficient values beta &lt;- matrix(c(-3.3, 1), ncol = 1) # Intercept and slope, respectively u &lt;- matrix(c(-.5, .6, .9), ncol = 1) # random effects for the 3 subjects # Design matrices Z (random effects) and X (fixed effects) Z &lt;- model.matrix(~ 0 + factor(subject), data = df) X &lt;- model.matrix(~ 1 + x1, data = df) # Response df$y &lt;- c(1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0, 0, 0, 1, 1, 0, 1, 0, 1, 1) y &lt;- df$y ### Goal: match estimates from the following lmer output! library(lme4) my.lmer &lt;- lmer( y ~ x1 + (1 | subject), data = df, family = binomial) summary(my.lmer) ranef(my.lmer) ### Matching effort STARTS HERE beta.k &lt;- matrix(c(-3, 1.5), ncol = 1) # Initial values (close to truth) b.k &lt;- matrix(c(1.82478, -1.53618, -.5139356), ncol = 1) # lmer's random effects # Iterative Gauss-Newton algorithm for (iter in 1:6) { lin.pred &lt;- as.numeric(X %*% beta.k + Z %*% b.k) mu.k &lt;- plogis(lin.pred) variances &lt;- mu.k * (1 - mu.k) W.k &lt;- diag(1/variances) y.star &lt;- W.k^(.5) %*% (y - mu.k) X.star &lt;- W.k^(.5) %*% (variances * X) delta.k &lt;- solve(t(X.star) %*% X.star) %*% t(X.star) %*% y.star # Gauss-Newton Update beta.k &lt;- beta.k + delta.k cat(iter, "Fixed Effects: ", beta.k, "\n") } </code></pre>
30,414
[ -0.0508895069360733, 0.0026617725379765034, 0.016565494239330292, 0.012901153415441513, 0.00763236777856946, 0.014876892790198326, -0.010999266989529133, 0.005031762644648552, 0.034664254635572433, -0.02743631787598133, 0.032911572605371475, 0.06225263699889183, 0.07144597917795181, 0.004556949716061354, 0.0387011282145977, -0.0005521969287656248, -0.0005618862342089415, -0.00031323375878855586, -0.005311938002705574, -0.005852255038917065, 0.01459868997335434, -0.009180043824017048, -0.0019472935236990452, 0.026453739032149315, -0.013416307047009468, 0.06653417646884918, 0.024442313238978386, -0.03664301335811615, -0.005136668682098389, 0.03644826263189316, -0.03439170867204666, -0.03046063520014286, -0.00579310767352581, -0.042720306664705276, -0.004440402612090111, 0.004022970329970121, 0.0010337900603190064, 0.006584216840565205, -0.0021052025258541107, 0.01997661031782627, -0.005177704151719809, -0.014804943464696407, -0.03647628054022789, 0.018100453540682793, -0.012802074663341045, -0.023613527417182922, -0.0076753729954361916, 0.005134898703545332, 0.06753459572792053, -0.007101539056748152, 0.06647838652133942, 0.011701402254402637, 0.013901946134865284, 0.017537634819746017, -0.04896259680390358, 0.0001332205138169229, 0.05538599565625191, 0.07661297172307968, 0.02032308094203472, -0.04138252139091492, -0.0030552067328244448, -0.054115913808345795, -0.02287181466817856, -0.01890992373228073, -0.01463393960148096, -0.02806614339351654, 0.03028249740600586, 0.012143322266638279, 0.028561118990182877, -0.03146794065833092, 0.06214459240436554, 0.015636155381798744, 0.045742545276880264, -0.024540985003113747, 0.022759566083550453, -0.0300791934132576, -0.01739390194416046, -0.012064570561051369, 0.02201533503830433, -0.013463282957673073, -0.019679371267557144, 0.00801839679479599, 0.008536775596439838, 0.051873400807380676, -0.010063298046588898, -0.0353713184595108, 0.040732260793447495, -0.0170811265707016, 0.023149708285927773, 0.0335967093706131, -0.0077093662694096565, 0.03418227657675743, 0.03819083049893379, 0.048082564026117325, -0.029470572248101234, 0.039679355919361115, 0.0045247464440763, 0.051958125084638596, 0.03761117532849312, -0.0018429498886689544, -0.03581058606505394, -0.05404096096754074, -0.021396679803729057, 0.05108299478888512, 0.00011679024464683607, 0.003977842628955841, -0.007093637716025114, 0.002723030047491193, -0.012715842574834824, -0.04624330252408981, 0.00458162697032094, 0.08387914299964905, 0.0049508134834468365, 0.004492000676691532, -0.0007194180507212877, -0.08083076775074005, 0.006822090595960617, -0.019584715366363525, 0.09849276393651962, 0.04844590276479721, 0.022593485191464424, -0.013940825127065182, -0.01693924516439438, -0.01940246671438217, -0.024856597185134888, -0.015941597521305084, 0.02022605575621128, -0.024939415976405144, -0.04153041914105415, 0.027457458898425102, 0.049704719334840775, -0.0013822237960994244, 0.04986238479614258, 0.007437365595251322, 0.00755678303539753, -0.004073534160852432, -0.07113387435674667, -0.03960500657558441, -0.006580181419849396, 0.015777455642819405, 0.03195302560925484, -0.07082441449165344, -0.029547058045864105, 0.013162967748939991, 0.04738947004079819, 0.013023467734456062, 0.04397403821349144, 0.03765727952122688, 0.011809725314378738, -0.000048936610255623236, -0.05543006211519241, 0.007634584791958332, -0.0338742770254612, -0.03200448676943779, -0.048807140439748764, -0.05294836685061455, 0.03691878914833069, 0.008643570356070995, -0.02304808795452118, 0.004069587681442499, 0.012496239505708218, 0.033196378499269485, 0.005113010294735432, -0.017247648909687996, -0.008259429596364498, 0.020830374211072922, 0.036355119198560715, -0.010265558026731014, 0.03863539174199104, 0.0361381433904171, -0.043240610510110855, 0.027241427451372147, 0.01242158841341734, 0.04840325936675072, 0.03642910718917847, -0.03498930111527443, 0.014713476411998272, -0.019232062622904778, 0.0277857668697834, 0.03174251317977905, -0.041410330682992935, -0.007508446462452412, -0.023565324023365974, -0.02334463596343994, -0.011804885230958462, 0.03595992922782898, -0.011549018323421478, -0.004977429285645485, 0.05142808333039284, -0.030048146843910217, -0.062097810208797455, -0.04429753124713898, 0.006127197295427322, 0.00979585200548172, -0.030195189639925957, -0.0008334075100719929, 0.021092243492603302, 0.049939412623643875, 0.0032740789465606213, 0.0161561481654644, -0.02857672981917858, -0.019528532400727272, 0.029538627713918686, 0.011996325105428696, -0.03360237181186676, 0.013072293251752853, 0.06507329642772675, -0.019463306292891502, 0.052865564823150635, -0.014609373174607754, 0.004768616985529661, 0.01609448716044426, -0.005386981647461653, -0.016351183876395226, 0.0033339979127049446, -0.01589875854551792, 0.011023027822375298, 0.00840244721621275, -0.022158849984407425, 0.04150832071900368, -0.0634479969739914, 0.02597765065729618, 0.04223990440368652, 0.005469301249831915, -0.012156426906585693, 0.00830273237079382, -0.010524149052798748, 0.01086223591119051, -0.04048207774758339, -0.015872493386268616, -0.03471001610159874, -0.050832390785217285, 0.06752188503742218, 0.022644134238362312, -0.026656774803996086, 0.013041093945503235, 0.015862062573432922, -0.029987912625074387, 0.008881103247404099, 0.009226121008396149, 0.004077495075762272, -0.02190358191728592, 0.04240715131163597, 0.022583983838558197, 0.006519562564790249, 0.005857471842318773, 0.015436697751283646, -0.05807881057262421, 0.0365719348192215, -0.04873599112033844, -0.020066935569047928, 0.04190967604517937, 0.007652395870536566, -0.008661133237183094, -0.04567968472838402, -0.01078247930854559, 0.05366650968790054, 0.024116763845086098, 0.008235764689743519, 0.04048319160938263, -0.008469694294035435, 0.02374354563653469, -0.008513863198459148, -0.018404386937618256, 0.024856211617588997, 0.053830455988645554, -0.039946042001247406, -0.017736447975039482, 0.02066626399755478, -0.023064814507961273, 0.03867163509130478, -0.02631116844713688, -0.041684310883283615, -0.03660468012094498, 0.018245412036776543, -0.04034434258937836, 0.004525064956396818, 0.0007625002763234079, -0.057681724429130554, -0.009474163874983788, 0.026185670867562294, -0.007087968289852142, 0.06234687566757202, -0.011460207402706146, -0.07092908769845963, -0.027051428332924843, -0.034795016050338745, 0.007103203795850277, 0.023231251165270805, 0.028879396617412567, -0.030377168208360672, 0.027376053854823112, -0.01676851511001587, -0.04493764042854309, -0.019853387027978897, -0.019376976415514946, 0.009749576449394226, -0.016309181228280067, -0.007228081114590168, 0.024318495765328407, 0.024150894954800606, -0.05442444980144501, 0.03136724233627319, -0.025588158518075943, 0.008010311983525753, -0.013324919156730175, -0.01980087161064148, 0.034756600856781006, 0.00423590699210763, 0.04625833407044411, 0.010249802842736244, -0.01469174399971962, -0.00006150599801912904, -0.06103253737092018, -0.049128543585538864, 0.005859532859176397, 0.042788226157426834, 0.011266807094216347, 0.04765224829316139, 0.010354837402701378, 0.1130833700299263, 0.045776017010211945, -0.013746839947998524, -0.07011952996253967, -0.008531859144568443, -0.03135163336992264, -0.048542123287916183, 0.03710372745990753, -0.0004999652155674994, 0.03464645519852638, 0.03228524327278137, -0.03526368364691734, 0.010065864771604538, 0.028767915442585945, -0.004150656517595053, -0.00026346370577812195, 0.009254551492631435, 0.026200616732239723, -0.03694019466638565, 0.026150550693273544, -0.009300991892814636, 0.007594462018460035, 0.01551892515271902, 0.03536706045269966, 0.011886106804013252, -0.024528304114937782, -0.03875250741839409, 0.009763145819306374, -0.05999913066625595, 0.020030653104186058, -0.03435840457677841, 0.01945669576525688, 0.020151332020759583, -0.06183411180973053, 0.007535276934504509, -0.015362918376922607, 0.05028289929032326, -0.012144098989665508, 0.023391956463456154, 0.06774688512086868, 0.007401300594210625, -0.030129237100481987, 0.040147844702005386, -0.012518199160695076, -0.036217719316482544, 0.009240028448402882, -0.04576312378048897, -0.01884343847632408, 0.03085380233824253, 0.022367196157574654, -0.011372352950274944, -0.011427413672208786, -0.02243264764547348, -0.010253960266709328, -0.0355810672044754, 0.015528426505625248, -0.05051499605178833, 0.02563478797674179, -0.011290488764643669, 0.045522917062044144, 0.026356326416134834, -0.01369217224419117, -0.005858813878148794, -0.01186427939683199, -0.04676007106900215, 0.02303331531584263, -0.029799679294228554, -0.008854463696479797, 0.007550924550741911, -0.03195865824818611, 0.010332750156521797, -0.005235789343714714, -0.0014428532449528575, 0.020162831991910934, 0.025539319962263107, -0.00891089253127575, 0.007815685123205185, -0.007902691140770912, -0.04647824913263321, 0.009447668679058552, -0.0031096208840608597, -0.00019625165441539139, -0.01263462658971548, -0.0005370285362005234, 0.061794716864824295, 0.018929140642285347, 0.007687774952501059, -0.05383151397109032, 0.009228542447090149, 0.022666320204734802, 0.05441756546497345, 0.011175031773746014, 0.001447938266210258, -0.03724512830376625, 0.04859188571572304, 0.01601247861981392, 0.024087460711598396, 0.07000651955604553, 0.02189112827181816, -0.0198748130351305, -0.027524834498763084, -0.03683888167142868, 0.01637982204556465, -0.006233494728803635, -0.0053526172414422035, 0.005096228327602148, 0.08179129660129547, 0.0437224879860878, -0.0005594724207185209, -0.02138025127351284, 0.04573453962802887, 0.022643517702817917, 0.022055121138691902, -0.026233123615384102, 0.017918376252055168, -0.018857430666685104, 0.005939426366239786, 0.01690046675503254, 0.006284784059971571, 0.015284407883882523, -0.0075666471384465694, 0.04466654360294342, -0.026404017582535744, -0.01623978093266487, 0.030025700107216835, 0.02763029746711254, 0.0027761380188167095, -0.002669102046638727, -0.05677836388349533, -0.014818642288446426, 0.04677354916930199, 0.043708331882953644, -0.019997846335172653, -0.0004920372739434242, -0.04835100844502449, 0.02122589386999607, 0.04098163917660713, 0.04441925510764122, -0.03099876269698143, -0.016387350857257843, -0.06229449808597565, 0.00034780625719577074, -0.013030349276959896, -0.025891227647662163, 0.04535457119345665, -0.0511464849114418, 0.03433651477098465, -0.009162251837551594, -0.00020497919467743486, -0.08088146150112152, 0.020512303337454796, -0.019234012812376022, 0.011828966438770294, 0.010966477915644646, -0.054208263754844666, -0.015793485566973686, 0.025920052081346512, 0.022486453875899315, 0.03702247887849808, -0.01831580512225628, -0.009776969440281391, 0.049484461545944214, 0.008360210806131363, -0.03116292506456375, -0.04841763153672218, 0.028575392439961433, -0.015147355385124683, 0.01157811377197504, 0.03438737615942955, -0.0059557752683758736, -0.022419942542910576, 0.007365948986262083, 0.026455797255039215, 0.016218282282352448, 0.002922884188592434, -0.012858577072620392, 0.027208389714360237, 0.0602906234562397, -0.0031416050624102354, 0.08152797818183899, 0.006037896033376455, -0.029913989827036858, 0.024432120844721794, -0.058692362159490585, -0.02062269300222397, -0.052242107689380646, -0.031849589198827744, -0.05326028913259506, 0.012558970600366592, -0.025438548997044563, 0.018381159752607346, -0.020204925909638405, 0.0286073237657547, -0.07976006716489792, -0.018660904839634895, 0.008770358748733997, -0.011167220771312714, -0.013853359036147594, -0.01666463166475296, -0.024321535602211952, -0.005620887037366629, -0.015446324832737446, -0.013233897276222706, 0.038751691579818726, -0.01363344956189394, -0.01721792481839657, -0.025232231244444847, -0.033531226217746735, 0.010646864771842957, 0.03049500100314617, -0.0034488141536712646, 0.013431508094072342, -0.009555564261972904, 0.0012021881993860006, -0.0009605105733498931, 0.037793535739183426, -0.00890212319791317, -0.0376000851392746, -0.012626147828996181, 0.029231764376163483, -0.03783022239804268, 0.003110564546659589, 0.00881600845605135, -0.013621159829199314, 0.000520978239364922, -0.004110846668481827, -0.05897432938218117, -0.03759658709168434, 0.0030902510043233633, -0.03268628939986229, 0.0018014225643128157, -0.04966195300221443, -0.04172838106751442, -0.012269280850887299, -0.009507096372544765, 0.016989653930068016, 0.02880147658288479, -0.03898910805583, 0.030092570930719376, -0.018353326246142387, 0.01981549896299839, 0.03953651711344719, -0.001236333278939128, -0.010105018503963947, 0.028879784047603607, -0.03318854048848152, -0.020233407616615295, 0.016554323956370354, -0.0332835391163826, -0.022150883451104164, 0.00560465594753623, -0.034692831337451935, 0.030638523399829865, 0.06897009909152985, -0.01140606589615345, -0.027458257973194122, 0.027996787801384926, -0.029502028599381447, 0.02803831920027733, -0.056595318019390106, 0.003952360711991787, -0.01740957424044609, 0.008958268910646439, -0.03003459982573986, -0.008071713149547577, -0.01475859247148037, 0.011888701468706131, 0.05339684709906578, -0.04837479814887047, -0.014735089614987373, -0.01659085415303707, 0.10775528848171234, -0.01431993581354618, 0.0043117450550198555, -0.016496339812874794, -0.00009128917736234143, 0.029541214928030968, -0.002315276302397251, 0.010615047067403793, 0.017819415777921677, 0.037140142172575, -0.003908604383468628, -0.022077223286032677, -0.046909138560295105, 0.012280046008527279, 0.04252958297729492, 0.034008853137493134, 0.030242761597037315, 0.055335551500320435, -0.04213499650359154, 0.02472059428691864, -0.03368741646409035, -0.01874316670000553, 0.017716677859425545, 0.009280901402235031, 0.052121423184871674, -0.02472231350839138, -0.00442079734057188, 0.0189330093562603, -0.000872021249961108, 0.036336127668619156, -0.0007110037258826196, 0.00007727256888756528, 0.015355261042714119, 0.0265679769217968, 0.02145877294242382, -0.026912864297628403, 0.025791116058826447, -0.03295877203345299, 0.036699581891298294, -0.03449564799666405, -0.05933835729956627, 0.026626737788319588, 0.06396738439798355, -0.014385038055479527, -0.05282513424754143, -0.020017847418785095, -0.029251661151647568, 0.017544079571962357, 0.024019768461585045, -0.01948588341474533, 0.04938096925616264, 0.00013464891526382416, 0.03518189117312431, 0.03140346333384514, 0.04992247745394707, -0.021647224202752113, -0.07041307538747787, -0.005855779629200697, -0.021557312458753586, -0.016247153282165527, 0.032404251396656036, 0.0014744248474016786, -0.019908007234334946, 0.03685106709599495, -0.04465099051594734, 0.007266125176101923, 0.02611384354531765, 0.022442078217864037, 0.025924982503056526, 0.00459686666727066, -0.010968947783112526, 0.022553423419594765, -0.011731697246432304, -0.026318136602640152, 0.14930060505867004, 0.04951528087258339, 0.021664375439286232, -0.08243177831172943, 0.02682315930724144, 0.01769058220088482, -0.002943335333839059, -0.002042531967163086, -0.006947683170437813, 0.024921348318457603, -0.022486794739961624, 0.04759281873703003, 0.03658255934715271, 0.019996481016278267, 0.0003057293070014566, 0.03769289329648018, -0.04465031996369362, -0.003932082559913397, 0.010378820821642876, 0.027156241238117218, -0.006705647800117731, -0.014872731640934944, -0.04534013941884041, 0.006909218151122332, 0.007729870267212391, -0.001768279355019331, -0.04538406431674957, 0.0023502372205257416, 0.011282356455922127, 0.008165028877556324, -0.010348600335419178, 0.034831441938877106, -0.010459437035024166, -0.008817311376333237, 0.042321667075157166, -0.0032212832011282444, 0.03474709391593933, -0.016332214698195457, 0.019740436226129532, 0.020885275676846504, -0.010461299680173397, 0.02242991141974926, 0.02222490683197975, -0.004575101658701897, -0.026168575510382652, -0.0356922373175621, -0.027559982612729073, 0.04896542429924011, -0.0042665149085223675, -0.011617100797593594, 0.009906260296702385, -0.002207869431003928, 0.003549584187567234, -0.04206889867782593, -0.017015760764479637, 0.040577225387096405, 0.03194894641637802, -0.029882512986660004, -0.011286837048828602, -0.020996607840061188, 0.016230665147304535, 0.00713350297883153, 0.03889042139053345, 0.03199499845504761, -0.024024344980716705, 0.001536948373541236, -0.039829522371292114, 0.05870336294174194, -0.019180819392204285, 0.008426501415669918, 0.005540652200579643, -0.007247033528983593, -0.02468128316104412, -0.05078957974910736, 0.003702208399772644, 0.021345769986510277, 0.028259169310331345, -0.008675691671669483, 0.018649136647582054, -0.03733597695827484, -0.04081496223807335, -0.010223464109003544, -0.004064059816300869, -0.03805895149707794, -0.025599252432584763, -0.002593024168163538, 0.04790892452001572, 0.04042362421751022, -0.0016156969359144568, 0.008258743211627007, 0.004059260245412588, 0.04811879247426987, -0.02143331803381443, -0.05446695536375046, -0.006517833564430475, 0.0465296134352684, -0.01770915277302265, -0.007392148021608591, -0.0027890256606042385, 0.04548262432217598, 0.07268564403057098, 0.04058058559894562, -0.005845686886459589, 0.04676568880677223, -0.04211729019880295, 0.0003119072935078293, 0.03428548946976662, -0.024091390892863274, 0.021706601604819298, -0.007922083139419556, 0.0057144477032125, -0.006201278883963823, -0.009565089829266071, -0.07526027411222458, -0.037570592015981674, 0.00887744128704071, -0.013193233869969845, -0.01732531748712063, -0.03294941782951355, 0.005540670361369848, 0.012455770745873451, -0.0008249267120845616, -0.044253211468458176, -0.024163860827684402, -0.03624960035085678, 0.0016298440750688314, -0.008475543931126595, -0.0177383404225111, 0.017816394567489624, 0.013041440397500992, 0.011383606120944023, 0.011225640773773193, 0.02922670915722847, 0.007039302494376898, -0.02716979570686817, 0.01746870018541813, 0.017855055630207062, 0.04323361814022064, 0.0008580057765357196, -0.0010426329681649804, 0.0039739785715937614, -0.02940955013036728, -0.03343416005373001, 0.016939286142587662, -0.005225708242505789, 0.0009736939682625234, 0.009889580309391022, 0.005069026257842779, -0.05212072655558586, 0.03892097622156143, -0.05487464368343353, -0.005044746212661266, -0.04872633144259453, 0.00287616322748363, -0.005083892494440079, -0.006748518906533718, 0.018429623916745186, 0.01715279184281826, -0.038306087255477905, 0.043866876512765884, 0.036732740700244904, -0.015404296107590199, 0.0021622604690492153, 0.0014314282452687621, -0.03270207718014717, 0.011516444385051727, 0.00280968239530921, 0.005932241678237915, 0.024050429463386536, 0.04213746637105942, -0.03355610370635986, 0.06449805200099945, -0.0239121001213789, 0.025236520916223526, -0.08906974643468857, -0.03564197197556496, -0.005674745421856642, -0.003805330256000161, 0.021790310740470886, -0.037168797105550766, 0.01733437553048134, 0.010979998856782913, -0.03191591426730156, -0.008419248275458813, 0.006343594752252102, -0.015667328611016273, -0.05116157606244087, 0.03468780964612961, -0.013957638293504715, -0.02012293040752411, 0.033039651811122894, -0.023253699764609337, 0.026613282039761543, 0.0333077609539032, 0.01501087099313736, -0.01706298626959324, -0.0436771959066391, 0.01429726928472519, 0.03405313938856125, -0.052914559841156006, 0.035831939429044724, -0.04404857009649277, -0.022197673097252846, -0.013512459583580494, 0.015067960135638714, 0.032410964369773865, 0.011647986248135567, 0.07062415033578873, 0.06069936975836754, 0.048434145748615265, -0.007328530307859182, 0.029721679165959358, 0.0027497797273099422, -0.02231253683567047, 0.04460414871573448, 0.032797329127788544, -0.06188304349780083, 0.010962075553834438, 0.0035258124116808176, 0.00673148175701499, -0.04691828042268753, -0.015015553683042526, -0.019133878871798515, -0.026781708002090454, -0.053241852670907974, 0.0004929660935886204, -0.0161974485963583, -0.0605294294655323, 0.0162095557898283, -0.05097724124789238, 0.000802277063485235, 0.05636724457144737, 0.05529899522662163, -0.00878811627626419, 0.01756218820810318, -0.015875352546572685, -0.0023356922902166843, 0.01870805025100708, -0.01152241975069046, -0.014431457966566086, -0.04263163357973099, -0.0259077250957489, 0.013635422103106976, -0.004037961829453707, 0.005649822298437357, 0.02682543359696865, -0.045261211693286896, 0.016587497666478157, -0.024920601397752762, -0.02940327115356922, -0.02093336544930935, 0.008668333292007446, 0.01610550843179226, -0.09143713861703873, 0.059479549527168274, -0.01897309720516205, -0.03342616185545921, -0.07033834606409073, 0.010092650540173054, -0.024057818576693535, 0.03570971637964249, 0.005448478274047375, -0.0018556410213932395, 0.025900473818182945, 0.030899958685040474, 0.054975222796201706, 0.01654624380171299, -0.049322228878736496, 0.049860477447509766, 0.01787392981350422, -0.028039755299687386, -0.01074550673365593, -0.018415750935673714, -0.007533026859164238, 0.029355397447943687, 0.024637389928102493, -0.011922025121748447, -0.000038747199141653255, -0.02025313302874565, -0.027990402653813362, 0.024504799395799637, 0.003841844853013754, -0.01216419693082571, 0.008799929171800613, -0.011791069991886616, 0.04260142520070076, 0.05672897398471832, 0.013202949427068233, -0.046723734587430954, 0.0333724282681942, -0.04397893697023392, 0.010149739682674408, 0.025338739156723022, -0.024136124178767204, 0.017183993011713028, -0.07284444570541382, 0.01879981718957424, -0.005172164179384708, -0.013791617937386036, -0.008411291986703873, 0.03586965426802635, -0.015940440818667412, 0.03276294469833374, -0.026407863944768906, 0.06361927092075348, -0.015261211432516575, -0.04100221395492554, 0.017855817452073097, 0.005490359850227833, 0.029995141550898552, -0.051805708557367325, -0.0007403136696666479, 0.024904057383537292, -0.005801514256745577, 0.02275324985384941, -0.010749229229986668, 0.061248213052749634, 0.01855546422302723, -0.004916128236800432, 0.013338460586965084, 0.00546999741345644, 0.014495044946670532, 0.0024685494136065245, 0.021798064932227135, 0.04933397099375725, -0.08003820478916168, 0.017256703227758408, -0.014307541772723198, -0.017277199774980545, 0.005390095990151167, 0.019199181348085403, -0.008622325025498867, 0.01967727392911911, 0.016300253570079803, 0.039373718202114105, -0.013129409402608871, -0.04778366535902023, 0.00847573857754469, -0.0006719701923429966, -0.04471692070364952, -0.0027030736673623323, 0.010758208110928535, 0.011759539134800434, -0.024740196764469147, -0.011239422485232353, -0.025151237845420837, 0.048908669501543045, 0.037251994013786316, -0.03552795574069023, -0.07621791958808899, -0.030231298878788948, 0.02373134344816208, 0.05424923449754715, -0.03925827518105507, -0.014093432575464249, -0.0037629331927746534, 0.025479454547166824, 0.015388496220111847, -0.014692501164972782 ]
<p>I am using a Neural Networks based classifier to run a classification for my data in n-dimensional.</p> <p>Then I thought it may be a good idea to run dimension reduction like PCA for my data at first, and then put the PCA results into the classifier (I keep 3 PCs). However, the classification on the dimension reduced features are not as good as using the original high-dimensional features directly.</p> <p>Then I came across this post <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/31462/how-exactly-do-neural-network-and-support-vector-machine-methods-reduce-dimensio">NN as a DR1</a> that discussed Neural Networks as a dimension reduction method. Also some information can be found in this paper <a href="http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/stamp/stamp.jsp?tp=&amp;arnumber=897072" rel="nofollow">NN as a DR2</a> I am confusing now:</p> <ol> <li>If I use Neural Networks based classification (in Matlab), does it automatically do the dimension reduction for me?</li> <li>Should I run dimension reduction like PCA before running Neural Networks classification?</li> <li>Are there any other reasons the classification on PCA results is not as good as using the original high dimensional features?</li> </ol> <p>Thanks very much. A.</p>
1,022
[ -0.01271645538508892, 0.008836097083985806, -0.018276643007993698, -0.027092035859823227, 0.04500988870859146, -0.022393863648176193, -0.04582573473453522, -0.023117510601878166, 0.03534429147839546, -0.055001918226480484, -0.0018045976758003235, 0.007944740355014801, 0.034783076494932175, 0.053276002407073975, 0.016268102452158928, -0.018179967999458313, -0.016018785536289215, -0.008215805515646935, 0.015833210200071335, -0.008193472400307655, -0.006252751685678959, 0.019843587651848793, 0.011278627440333366, -0.016943760216236115, -0.04340551048517227, 0.06918493658304214, 0.0046287961304187775, 0.00024512759409844875, 0.01568850502371788, 0.026553623378276825, -0.018112551420927048, -0.003830031957477331, 0.00013995758490636945, 0.054824139922857285, -0.013574907556176186, -0.012400622479617596, 0.0024675235617905855, -0.03152909502387047, 0.02005915530025959, 0.045153215527534485, 0.01814921200275421, -0.0005011535831727087, 0.016008174046874046, 0.049107782542705536, -0.0048662894405424595, 0.029678160324692726, -0.012635125778615475, -0.013907388783991337, -0.010136947967112064, -0.05955880135297775, 0.08473549783229828, 0.018555866554379463, 0.0390743613243103, 0.025021204724907875, -0.018754979595541954, 0.005417340435087681, 0.05414631962776184, 0.05042669549584389, 0.004510069265961647, -0.037204574793577194, 0.00235470081679523, -0.019394978880882263, -0.005031612701714039, -0.040129952132701874, -0.030064987018704414, 0.06241520121693611, -0.015216502360999584, -0.013684765435755253, 0.04658389464020729, -0.010043158195912838, 0.007099105976521969, -0.026173068210482597, -0.008854883722960949, -0.03518103435635567, 0.007564729545265436, -0.025788437575101852, -0.011965791694819927, -0.0017528495518490672, 0.03097955510020256, 0.022153152152895927, 0.01008738111704588, 0.04046902433037758, -0.0005269100656732917, 0.04741895571351051, 0.02926570735871792, -0.007810767740011215, 0.0700819119811058, -0.009428098797798157, 0.03215271607041359, 0.00998679269105196, 0.001196487806737423, 0.013139406219124794, 0.03974831849336624, -0.0061050341464579105, -0.009566707536578178, 0.0017991294153034687, 0.005521021783351898, 0.05464234948158264, 0.031766410917043686, -0.0433107353746891, -0.013964567333459854, -0.02850877307355404, -0.004440444987267256, 0.012825075536966324, -0.018456166610121727, -0.020313316956162453, -0.03966177999973297, 0.009402338415384293, -0.0316709503531456, -0.015599298290908337, -0.027138130739331245, 0.011832992546260357, -0.01206713542342186, -0.006438443902879953, 0.027142586186528206, -0.007132089231163263, 0.004376140423119068, -0.01892017386853695, 0.015321975573897362, 0.08516979217529297, 0.021318472921848297, -0.03101985715329647, 0.00836655218154192, -0.029338791966438293, -0.06773032248020172, 0.004060717765241861, 0.01351116318255663, -0.0005949285696260631, -0.005232671741396189, 0.027437375858426094, -0.03775809332728386, -0.026292376220226288, 0.02907031774520874, -0.012720800936222076, 0.008605682291090488, 0.012976721860468388, -0.07941111922264099, -0.04762520268559456, 0.04465653747320175, -0.033598292618989944, 0.023848941549658775, -0.07719995081424713, 0.008419541642069817, 0.021827245131134987, 0.061708249151706696, 0.013149750418961048, 0.04876866191625595, 0.027365725487470627, -0.0014706803485751152, -0.01978355459868908, -0.034090306609869, -0.019380085170269012, -0.028772225603461266, -0.007682259660214186, -0.02761385776102543, -0.058254871517419815, 0.03768506273627281, 0.02443842403590679, 0.004960926715284586, -0.003102113725617528, 0.02072896808385849, 0.011790686286985874, -0.014139529317617416, 0.012242726981639862, -0.021444465965032578, -0.018171265721321106, 0.07576776295900345, -0.024218399077653885, 0.07418281584978104, 0.0008980066631920636, -0.027533896267414093, 0.01994398795068264, 0.019836680963635445, 0.0674033984541893, 0.04047848656773567, 0.036345742642879486, -0.030789000913500786, -0.014434249140322208, 0.024475475773215294, 0.02014613151550293, -0.02230508252978325, -0.04444362223148346, -0.01848750375211239, 0.000008522512871422805, -0.0007960404618643224, 0.05777185037732124, 0.0045236870646476746, -0.06607365608215332, 0.019573582336306572, -0.01570451632142067, -0.04642331972718239, -0.0698375478386879, 0.03400452807545662, -0.0212357547134161, -0.018536338582634926, 0.020361093804240227, 0.01966690644621849, 0.03042374551296234, 0.009569146670401096, -0.028794463723897934, -0.05516885221004486, 0.002265162533149123, 0.017111286520957947, -0.045971162617206573, -0.02584942989051342, 0.02881074696779251, 0.032961439341306686, -0.04094044119119644, 0.04355353116989136, -0.027367668226361275, -0.06655635684728622, -0.002620892133563757, 0.00018160614126827568, 0.005917474161833525, -0.01901107281446457, -0.03491390496492386, 0.008565101772546768, -0.023173358291387558, -0.03935248404741287, 0.036645062267780304, -0.056630026549100876, 0.08635515719652176, 0.05674552917480469, -0.02306511066854, 0.020027250051498413, 0.016503581777215004, 0.006374821998178959, 0.010440247133374214, -0.008541428484022617, 0.02817494049668312, -0.04582371562719345, -0.01143045537173748, 0.06297321617603302, 0.04753526672720909, -0.07160980254411697, 0.03431493788957596, 0.023741476237773895, 0.0315794013440609, 0.02131672576069832, 0.014037399552762508, 0.0053625102154910564, -0.05927256494760513, -0.012712445110082626, 0.03658242151141167, -0.010537892580032349, -0.01846279576420784, 0.024433650076389313, -0.014651214703917503, 0.04394666478037834, 0.0014388534473255277, -0.03836601972579956, 0.06584074348211288, -0.010027446784079075, 0.001436396618373692, 0.026227105408906937, -0.020724844187498093, 0.03289533779025078, -0.002493950305506587, -0.010086390189826488, 0.017770303413271904, 0.02158617228269577, 0.006918156053870916, 0.00033945852192118764, 0.0035276589915156364, 0.029397718608379364, 0.024866625666618347, -0.00993838720023632, -0.0038615644443780184, 0.01841740496456623, -0.0552394799888134, 0.01731264963746071, -0.02779879979789257, -0.029177485033869743, -0.05701536685228348, 0.06418552249670029, 0.04354528337717056, -0.014480700716376305, 0.043383967131376266, -0.005957754794508219, -0.004746497143059969, 0.018992923200130463, -0.053881995379924774, 0.012144540436565876, 0.014887056313455105, -0.05146820843219757, 0.023487187922000885, -0.0404379703104496, -0.0026547047309577465, 0.01757134310901165, -0.011089780367910862, 0.009698641486465931, 0.0189786646515131, -0.014320937916636467, -0.07415005564689636, -0.042803846299648285, -0.028506722301244736, 0.03653498739004135, 0.007004895713180304, -0.04263357073068619, 0.022453583776950836, -0.020740609616041183, -0.025750337168574333, 0.01895790919661522, -0.024729827418923378, -0.04279359430074692, -0.013968298211693764, 0.0099154869094491, -0.012995063327252865, -0.017186641693115234, -0.04272365942597389, 0.045609984546899796, -0.014627330005168915, 0.005557098891586065, -0.04790337011218071, -0.05494420602917671, 0.04585811123251915, 0.000479183770949021, 0.015650030225515366, 0.02010479010641575, -0.008740234188735485, 0.0637776181101799, 0.048073939979076385, -0.015172475017607212, -0.03826219588518143, -0.007556921802461147, -0.03890877589583397, -0.026050806045532227, 0.006008562166243792, 0.007130898535251617, -0.0014600957510992885, 0.03241058811545372, -0.00793228205293417, -0.008453953079879284, 0.06604672968387604, -0.005207302514463663, -0.01516888476908207, 0.029004110023379326, -0.010517248883843422, 0.005296660121530294, 0.01877574250102043, 0.003958985209465027, -0.015045884996652603, 0.025174230337142944, -0.0028289714828133583, 0.016807781532406807, 0.005984846502542496, -0.031200943514704704, 0.015203961171209812, -0.03534884750843048, 0.031405191868543625, -0.010445179417729378, -0.018413783982396126, 0.017251506447792053, -0.0022080426570028067, 0.015083125792443752, 0.016466068103909492, 0.05276606231927872, -0.01138368807733059, 0.010481874458491802, 0.033150386065244675, 0.01417322177439928, 0.008954424411058426, 0.004329611547291279, 0.008194562047719955, -0.00861111655831337, 0.02744174376130104, -0.0079277278855443, 0.023777170106768608, 0.046090610325336456, 0.042193617671728134, 0.045717835426330566, 0.01803763397037983, -0.05449304357171059, 0.015202851966023445, -0.09222299605607986, 0.017964810132980347, -0.046837855130434036, 0.047554370015859604, -0.0036695741582661867, 0.025948956608772278, 0.0096364077180624, -0.019541196525096893, 0.02947710081934929, -0.014813970774412155, -0.06328541040420532, 0.004828796721994877, -0.02655155211687088, -0.0058944979682564735, 0.019046923145651817, -0.021788103505969048, 0.03335459902882576, -0.02266843616962433, 0.021456541493535042, 0.0062882378697395325, 0.017382003366947174, -0.0644543245434761, 0.015558505430817604, -0.01311246957629919, 0.004550756886601448, -0.022593874484300613, 0.001925268559716642, 0.02033301442861557, -0.015897516161203384, 0.014918653294444084, 0.05115457624197006, -0.025211725383996964, 0.02137143164873123, 0.00350848282687366, 0.009568355977535248, 0.008380729705095291, 0.024588491767644882, 0.013084329664707184, 0.022978831082582474, -0.052820995450019836, 0.013191832229495049, 0.02647542580962181, 0.0659029558300972, 0.010230070911347866, 0.0080293919891119, -0.02249385416507721, -0.054203182458877563, -0.03708457574248314, -0.011172953993082047, 0.06335397809743881, 0.0028067403472959995, -0.020996127277612686, 0.010452100075781345, 0.016795430332422256, -0.04201335832476616, 0.0008076263475231826, 0.08142878115177155, 0.007784683723002672, -0.016078012064099312, -0.02994116209447384, -0.007594495080411434, -0.022437037900090218, -0.008957388810813427, 0.06604832410812378, 0.008604587987065315, -0.04225118085741997, -0.009834462776780128, 0.05740191414952278, -0.04096270725131035, -0.022514870390295982, 0.006249893456697464, 0.051794275641441345, 0.05316122621297836, 0.00697685731574893, 0.003212372772395611, -0.0047312332317233086, 0.05223419517278671, 0.06104810908436775, 0.00444238493219018, 0.0018604579381644726, -0.08815672248601913, -0.023055048659443855, 0.034995581954717636, 0.047293782234191895, -0.0547252781689167, -0.02555517479777336, -0.026541775092482567, -0.01504373736679554, 0.02490576170384884, -0.03362210839986801, 0.03364873304963112, 0.012033217586576939, -0.01589656062424183, -0.03812776133418083, -0.00005735448939958587, -0.0316409096121788, 0.006777409929782152, -0.005975842941552401, 0.059454016387462616, -0.0023886223789304495, -0.035131342709064484, -0.07236417382955551, 0.014367148280143738, 0.011862115003168583, 0.03134942054748535, -0.014074430800974369, -0.017175711691379547, -0.025656240060925484, 0.025743629783391953, -0.017288079485297203, -0.06461324542760849, 0.009680830873548985, 0.05241391435265541, -0.01795659027993679, 0.06104113161563873, 0.005661251489073038, -0.0319194458425045, 0.03789689391851425, 0.021936949342489243, -0.004777590744197369, -0.035216882824897766, -0.033917542546987534, 0.04513675346970558, 0.04364382103085518, -0.019116418436169624, 0.05595369637012482, -0.010883168317377567, 0.015431014820933342, 0.007496366742998362, -0.03928452730178833, 0.022612592205405235, -0.041482292115688324, -0.019747504964470863, -0.015860212966799736, -0.016366995871067047, -0.021205997094511986, 0.04319676384329796, 0.019436892122030258, 0.04844967648386955, -0.011727908626198769, 0.006390940863639116, -0.0027960380539298058, 0.015091991052031517, 0.011090231128036976, -0.016947463154792786, -0.039104413241147995, 0.03307735174894333, -0.0007111195591278374, -0.010588889010250568, -0.012648428790271282, 0.007365060038864613, -0.02084146812558174, 0.05002405866980553, -0.027198979631066322, -0.018576515838503838, -0.02647647075355053, -0.009428142569959164, 0.025524262338876724, -0.02578343264758587, 0.04229298606514931, 0.0021679133642464876, 0.00879666581749916, 0.03428635746240616, -0.033369019627571106, -0.007053434383124113, -0.0009506113710813224, 0.008215733803808689, 0.03485265374183655, -0.04675557464361191, 0.04021095484495163, 0.013293462805449963, 0.004658117890357971, -0.05858045071363449, -0.03622917830944061, -0.01518468651920557, -0.0018219536868855357, -0.019887996837496758, -0.04346132650971413, 0.008143511600792408, -0.018925387412309647, -0.018591273576021194, 0.01387019082903862, 0.05408355966210365, -0.029665593057870865, -0.014078945852816105, 0.04725222289562225, 0.021327167749404907, 0.0700976550579071, -0.035071149468421936, 0.0007241249550133944, -0.025482725352048874, -0.009258780628442764, -0.004688025452196598, -0.015516964718699455, 0.050245027989149094, -0.013163521885871887, 0.008703607134521008, -0.034099090844392776, 0.0034683202393352985, 0.06084883213043213, -0.0005066831945441663, -0.00882582925260067, 0.026382889598608017, -0.022654186934232712, -0.015144838020205498, -0.031187517568469048, -0.007191574200987816, -0.008069533854722977, 0.006929541938006878, 0.012196527794003487, -0.00001480506489315303, -0.01133805699646473, -0.00723268324509263, 0.011166408658027649, -0.009152697399258614, 0.030522383749485016, 0.023544134572148323, 0.030522052198648453, -0.034360550343990326, 0.01581691764295101, -0.042934663593769073, -0.029188159853219986, 0.042475637048482895, -0.012994076125323772, 0.007921322248876095, -0.013406249694526196, 0.008465616032481194, -0.02274191379547119, -0.032548144459724426, -0.0487021803855896, 0.027860140427947044, 0.05898362770676613, 0.011302049271762371, 0.029035840183496475, 0.015922637656331062, 0.0058597903698682785, 0.010430603288114071, -0.04998937249183655, 0.014935916289687157, -0.007028201129287481, -0.006712304428219795, 0.07821198552846909, 0.025151502341032028, -0.023646311834454536, 0.04509392008185387, -0.005670355632901192, 0.008705485612154007, 0.05016852170228958, 0.03231680020689964, 0.009896542876958847, 0.004824092611670494, -0.025633879005908966, -0.03889119252562523, 0.015043212100863457, -0.04048391804099083, 0.004825064912438393, -0.01822010986506939, -0.018369613215327263, 0.0444582998752594, 0.031560301780700684, 0.008367556147277355, -0.07232387363910675, -0.017445774748921394, -0.030286841094493866, -0.02006514184176922, 0.02222149632871151, 0.003084565745666623, 0.034511346369981766, -0.030471768230199814, 0.03995061665773392, 0.009160543791949749, 0.014813916757702827, 0.01091901957988739, -0.052336473017930984, -0.04835208132863045, -0.033393844962120056, -0.02920210175216198, 0.030168164521455765, 0.010778650641441345, -0.05376482382416725, 0.022585993632674217, -0.04017286002635956, 0.050211235880851746, 0.020248975604772568, 0.0326605923473835, 0.022216003388166428, 0.04440566897392273, 0.007973981089890003, 0.03456135094165802, 0.0348077118396759, -0.002476175781339407, 0.11505525559186935, 0.07772165536880493, 0.025260884314775467, -0.05918231979012489, 0.01833651214838028, 0.0011134640080854297, -0.012055210769176483, -0.03222890943288803, 0.008873715996742249, -0.007792001124471426, -0.007491199765354395, 0.02008018270134926, 0.03813927620649338, 0.012753293849527836, -0.018580403178930283, 0.03159654140472412, -0.044468577951192856, -0.02465716004371643, 0.0035734318662434816, -0.0004717499832622707, 0.0012109380913898349, -0.013922794722020626, -0.03317203000187874, 0.02104138769209385, -0.00003239422585465945, -0.02659265510737896, -0.028347870334982872, 0.020386530086398125, 0.028610309585928917, -0.029186617583036423, -0.028821617364883423, -0.015520845539867878, 0.014709231443703175, 0.0036661315243691206, -0.012104001827538013, 0.03853797912597656, 0.015493202954530716, -0.03478962928056717, 0.014267044141888618, 0.02837839536368847, 0.011955609545111656, -0.024109145626425743, -0.0062265763990581036, -0.013144810684025288, -0.0905388817191124, -0.02122516930103302, -0.049255482852458954, 0.057715702801942825, 0.00173876469489187, 0.0016497713513672352, 0.01798415556550026, -0.022857019677758217, 0.002932086354121566, -0.05060170963406563, -0.0352884903550148, 0.014883640222251415, 0.04195347800850868, 0.0011990426573902369, -0.03460048511624336, -0.05032564327120781, 0.01651008427143097, -0.021354755386710167, 0.06073771417140961, 0.029297104105353355, 0.010052112862467766, -0.0051875305362045765, -0.02643074281513691, 0.035759106278419495, -0.017229381948709488, 0.021179968491196632, -0.03075585886836052, 0.03716195747256279, -0.010596760548651218, -0.05886557325720787, 0.012208227999508381, 0.01178780011832714, -0.003757813945412636, -0.03165894374251366, -0.042588040232658386, 0.0015625085216015577, -0.05977388843894005, 0.006213642191141844, -0.03965146467089653, 0.02221580781042576, -0.03204069286584854, 0.010568681173026562, 0.021002227440476418, 0.024264490231871605, 0.03562093898653984, 0.03533134609460831, -0.004478838760405779, 0.023210782557725906, 0.03473925590515137, -0.04075116664171219, -0.03698095679283142, 0.0024426006712019444, -0.057561784982681274, 0.041137151420116425, 0.01576163060963154, 0.01964542455971241, 0.048042744398117065, 0.012187091633677483, -0.019992221146821976, 0.05267898738384247, -0.024776248261332512, -0.005561920814216137, -0.007978328503668308, -0.041227445006370544, 0.01888582482933998, -0.013274697586894035, 0.016604458913207054, -0.027516983449459076, -0.03598174825310707, -0.02703963778913021, -0.00586421275511384, -0.004379629623144865, 0.012992013245821, -0.036515675485134125, 0.0018601800547912717, -0.02651824802160263, 0.034896690398454666, -0.026310620829463005, -0.017665989696979523, -0.03587954118847847, 0.03452325239777565, 0.0016613194020465016, -0.034681063145399094, -0.026552565395832062, 0.02001427672803402, -0.01865277998149395, 0.001695782644674182, 0.0235137939453125, 0.0063964249566197395, 0.025319412350654602, -0.036298248916864395, -0.004949315916746855, -0.025440484285354614, 0.053278494626283646, -0.029921531677246094, 0.0032959908712655306, 0.033075619488954544, -0.07120253145694733, -0.03344859555363655, 0.00033474614610895514, -0.03401964157819748, 0.03308676555752754, 0.034942638128995895, 0.009922614321112633, -0.012217707000672817, 0.023275483399629593, -0.01278681680560112, -0.027620406821370125, -0.014201505109667778, -0.002706684870645404, -0.026069285348057747, 0.008688321337103844, 0.04474540054798126, 0.0001772044925019145, -0.0284645464271307, 0.029042402282357216, 0.047504786401987076, 0.02481556124985218, -0.03326447308063507, 0.029378974810242653, -0.022350894287228584, 0.035870376974344254, 0.02827143855392933, -0.0060152290388941765, 0.03638477250933647, 0.04236985743045807, -0.020350994542241096, 0.056104108691215515, -0.0002916822850238532, 0.012969071976840496, -0.09132601320743561, -0.013629288412630558, -0.0204984899610281, 0.013914836570620537, 0.02636861801147461, -0.08232985436916351, 0.033106643706560135, 0.010459782555699348, -0.06267441809177399, 0.020001770928502083, -0.0004891611752100289, 0.008720657788217068, -0.003925599157810211, 0.017203807830810547, -0.008130508475005627, -0.004363284911960363, 0.02877378650009632, 0.009093721397221088, 0.027288049459457397, 0.012106658890843391, -0.023811843246221542, -0.001368215074762702, -0.028409676626324654, 0.017372887581586838, -0.013143857009708881, -0.060679640620946884, 0.026805652305483818, -0.036966025829315186, -0.04358234629034996, 0.03251710534095764, -0.03672061860561371, 0.012399576604366302, 0.06473346054553986, 0.007955295965075493, 0.021472427994012833, -0.0220290906727314, 0.06703165173530579, -0.022231245413422585, -0.00904669426381588, 0.02101460099220276, 0.027268145233392715, -0.005614491645246744, 0.01907062716782093, 0.0280012097209692, 0.027302537113428116, -0.01874762400984764, 0.011301273480057716, -0.02739465795457363, -0.021245550364255905, -0.009341230615973473, -0.013269521296024323, -0.02387172169983387, 0.007405595388263464, -0.016017811372876167, 0.015921732410788536, -0.0254279263317585, -0.029580257833003998, 0.010902835987508297, 0.022937022149562836, -0.013955443166196346, 0.026538126170635223, -0.007535399403423071, -0.06358230859041214, -0.01105002872645855, 0.007437888532876968, -0.008730275556445122, -0.05092313885688782, 0.008117659017443657, 0.03828658536076546, -0.016811946406960487, -0.02378286048769951, -0.029883457347750664, -0.030858108773827553, 0.06842079758644104, -0.01391630619764328, 0.05201256275177002, 0.021449580788612366, -0.043108999729156494, 0.01139155589044094, -0.09764056652784348, 0.051416292786598206, 0.002243336057290435, -0.05279691889882088, -0.026852184906601906, 0.005383937619626522, -0.057521671056747437, -0.007953988388180733, 0.06681647896766663, 0.02082297019660473, 0.02698490396142006, -0.018524320796132088, 0.010710557922720909, 0.007456387393176556, -0.058054015040397644, 0.043422263115644455, -0.0021631524432450533, -0.040978118777275085, -0.029033441096544266, -0.020455094054341316, 0.000328618916682899, 0.02470594458281994, 0.04054315760731697, 0.004209987819194794, -0.012300246395170689, 0.023753803223371506, 0.010764384642243385, 0.02352609671652317, -0.02502318285405636, 0.01091804075986147, 0.06455539166927338, -0.015104400925338268, 0.005427720490843058, 0.029098769649863243, -0.0008552881772629917, -0.01452944427728653, 0.01649748906493187, -0.03537207469344139, -0.005509764421731234, 0.005011946428567171, 0.030845141038298607, 0.02817770279943943, -0.06827309727668762, -0.01323862187564373, 0.028862155973911285, -0.023590968921780586, -0.011696894653141499, 0.04337100684642792, 0.012133877724409103, -0.016075527295470238, 0.0062790787778794765, 0.03608876094222069, 0.015094299800693989, 0.019917413592338562, -0.0038446884136646986, 0.03300277143716812, 0.020536888390779495, -0.027955958619713783, 0.030133910477161407, 0.04182680696249008, -0.008814830332994461, 0.031524114310741425, -0.025066973641514778, 0.07897448539733887, -0.03921636566519737, -0.042092423886060715, 0.034273598343133926, 0.0013615748612210155, 0.012355254963040352, -0.001227175584062934, -0.026494227349758148, 0.08636018633842468, -0.03819314017891884, 0.006881583482027054, -0.022573862224817276, -0.04472053796052933, -0.013999820686876774, -0.012578750029206276, 0.0032182170543819666, 0.041566550731658936, -0.00928836315870285, 0.041248999536037445, -0.010363882407546043, -0.0129031827673316, 0.04425251856446266, -0.0048656826838850975, 0.041392408311367035, 0.0018058501882478595, 0.011118791066110134, 0.016361115500330925, -0.0021984411869198084, 0.005320511758327484, -0.022615645080804825, 0.015003077685832977, 0.041595786809921265, 0.034488245844841, -0.0003489817027002573, -0.02618943341076374, 0.02062593400478363, 0.01965712197124958, -0.056358423084020615, -0.03337360545992851, -0.04793548956513405, -0.01855596713721752, 0.010404122993350029, -0.01679089479148388 ]
<p>I'm trying to train a classifier on 10 classes, using 249 samples and a (currently) 16-dimensional feature vector. I'm using an SVM with RBF kernel, through Python's scikit-learn module. The distribution of classes in those 249 samples is as follows:</p> <p>[6, 45, 51, 38, 34, 23, 12, 15, 19, 6]</p> <p>When building my 200-sample training set, I'm careful to maintain this same relationship. I'm not currently applying any class weighting when training. I've used grid search to optimize my C and gamma values, and the feature vectors are normalized.</p> <p>My problem is this: When I randomly create different test/training sets from the samples (again, always maintaining the class frequency relationship above), the learned SVMs, when cross-validated against the test set, give values for precision/recall/f-score that will be anywhere from ~0.20 to ~0.50. This is making it hard for me to evaluate relative performance changes when trying different feature vectors. </p> <p>I should mention that the data is somewhat subjective; it consists of what I'll call 'squiggly lines' (to avoid the wrath of my employer) that have been graded by an expert we call the 'Golden Eyeball', who allegedly knows how and why some squiggles are better than others. So, we're all quite happy to be within +/- 1 grade of his 'true' grade.</p> <p>My question: I have some learning curve data suggesting that more training examples will help, but can I glean anything else from these differing performances? Or does this just tell me my model is flawed?</p> <p>And a side question: Am I fooling myself in thinking I can choose the SVM with the best performance and say 'Done!'?</p> <p>For the visual: I like making animations to quickly scan through the different SVMs. The one below shows the confusion matrix for 20 different SVMs taught per above. Probably not overly helpful, but I think I can sometimes see 'flashes of brilliance' in some of them that keeps me plugging away.</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/S3NWu.gif" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>(The size of the blocks above is relative to the proportion of samples in that class; predicted class is on the horizontal axis)</p>
73,775
[ -0.058701787143945694, 0.0012214250164106488, 0.005305146798491478, -0.01207281555980444, 0.040408626198768616, -0.021898459643125534, -0.0044282847084105015, 0.004030391573905945, -0.001620052964426577, -0.010025668889284134, 0.019361209124326706, 0.0488930307328701, 0.03752977401018143, 0.011324615217745304, -0.01025759894400835, -0.03296062722802162, 0.02047884650528431, -0.02685079164803028, -0.0140368128195405, 0.006205973215401173, -0.0027975530829280615, 0.024830210953950882, 0.005683711264282465, -0.004825020674616098, -0.04043380916118622, 0.06055251881480217, 0.013624115847051144, -0.026641683652997017, -0.005357327871024609, 0.022621095180511475, -0.06019008532166481, -0.004576222971081734, -0.010440031066536903, 0.02721572108566761, 0.016262993216514587, 0.02384071983397007, 0.025344986468553543, -0.0039617326110601425, -0.0169513076543808, 0.027580123394727707, 0.010103934444487095, 0.007057614158838987, -0.004981180187314749, 0.09079591184854507, 0.016250483691692352, 0.04853145778179169, -0.0029908770229667425, -0.02043355256319046, 0.03424929827451706, -0.040033891797065735, 0.07545282691717148, 0.011436015367507935, 0.018755502998828888, 0.07101821154356003, -0.009560770355165005, -0.013186669908463955, 0.04277719557285309, 0.08119626343250275, -0.02088627777993679, -0.03083435632288456, 0.024349872022867203, -0.05203152075409889, -0.011684371158480644, -0.02571127377450466, 0.02075261063873768, 0.06264254450798035, 0.015538353472948074, 0.00891643762588501, 0.05665728077292442, -0.02511964552104473, 0.0007664120057597756, 0.0013345777988433838, 0.030562013387680054, -0.01690901629626751, 0.02001408115029335, -0.02342667058110237, 0.019080806523561478, 0.04921294003725052, 0.034505318850278854, 0.026147861033678055, 0.019658785313367844, 0.0314846895635128, -0.009537363424897194, 0.0258552934974432, 0.024824444204568863, 0.013638485223054886, 0.07071495801210403, -0.012846536003053188, 0.030553530901670456, 0.03751708194613457, -0.011463440023362637, 0.014119630679488182, 0.0452672578394413, 0.016103185713291168, -0.028050342574715614, 0.038213517516851425, -0.02563522197306156, -0.019348524510860443, 0.019296245649456978, -0.0171244777739048, -0.0327029787003994, -0.028250904753804207, -0.005424811039119959, 0.06166645511984825, -0.0652407631278038, -0.01300550065934658, -0.026698432862758636, -0.013862475752830505, -0.020102187991142273, -0.02937731333076954, -0.01472398079931736, 0.008617439307272434, 0.007925349287688732, 0.007129890378564596, 0.008244427852332592, -0.022174477577209473, -0.014800644479691982, -0.011142337694764137, 0.04542890191078186, 0.04280310124158859, 0.027499990537762642, -0.05320344120264053, 0.017381099984049797, -0.030765054747462273, -0.044326163828372955, 0.012656908482313156, 0.05515150725841522, -0.027539188042283058, -0.054859958589076996, 0.034685168415308, 0.016843562945723534, -0.02195831760764122, 0.04194462299346924, -0.04633612185716629, 0.019083058461546898, 0.00028745713643729687, -0.068699911236763, -0.08327598869800568, 0.05028633773326874, -0.04117147624492645, 0.0031417591962963343, -0.07335174083709717, -0.00014650791126769036, 0.027785852551460266, 0.04994902014732361, -0.024716302752494812, 0.03148043528199196, 0.020605802536010742, 0.04213017597794533, -0.03022496961057186, -0.02234864979982376, -0.007657990790903568, -0.02509208209812641, -0.004865516442805529, -0.02952617220580578, -0.07815171778202057, -0.003482476342469454, 0.002448531100526452, 0.009436924941837788, 0.008965075947344303, -0.01850658655166626, -0.01276049017906189, 0.01273528765887022, -0.01717056706547737, 0.013641675002872944, -0.01942470856010914, 0.035688988864421844, 0.0323808528482914, 0.05018775910139084, 0.004227392375469208, -0.04449605941772461, -0.02482105977833271, 0.02805156446993351, 0.01600055769085884, 0.028232069686055183, 0.0116448774933815, 0.03998076543211937, -0.040793225169181824, 0.0034636310301721096, 0.004581148270517588, -0.03801615163683891, -0.07248944789171219, -0.037169262766838074, 0.03235388919711113, 0.006830180529505014, 0.05232806131243706, -0.010355744510889053, -0.012777329422533512, 0.04047442227602005, -0.037800949066877365, -0.04002508148550987, -0.03317151591181755, 0.007786430884152651, -0.03926731273531914, 0.001996580744162202, 0.019329898059368134, -0.022454190999269485, -0.01111467182636261, -0.004554756451398134, -0.014918562956154346, -0.010576175525784492, -0.001278908341191709, 0.019238850101828575, -0.05614607781171799, -0.01756838895380497, 0.02972068265080452, 0.007055859547108412, -0.045549020171165466, 0.04266130179166794, -0.04207151383161545, -0.07553241401910782, 0.010277580469846725, -0.034902069717645645, 0.012807035818696022, -0.030181385576725006, -0.008552703075110912, 0.012733696028590202, 0.026080993935465813, -0.04724443331360817, -0.007555476855486631, -0.04337559640407562, 0.07873795181512833, 0.03892786428332329, -0.004196841735392809, -0.028552930802106857, 0.0009242266532965004, 0.013929851353168488, 0.02084200270473957, -0.031237121671438217, 0.035333555191755295, -0.041486699134111404, -0.0013072211295366287, 0.08512959629297256, 0.02087225206196308, -0.01929883286356926, 0.011056053452193737, 0.054357465356588364, 0.039240751415491104, 0.017383327707648277, 0.004455638118088245, 0.004323939792811871, -0.03690703958272934, 0.009515237994492054, 0.03310639038681984, 0.005919237155467272, -0.004839887376874685, 0.01731163077056408, -0.009422315284609795, 0.020390549674630165, 0.01469361037015915, 0.0032474794425070286, 0.02600683644413948, -0.026087360456585884, -0.00905275996774435, 0.003431522287428379, -0.010508636012673378, 0.030394285917282104, -0.012489518150687218, -0.0367639996111393, 0.050492119044065475, -0.007235654629766941, -0.0011442300165072083, -0.002737773582339287, -0.011755558662116528, 0.043889667838811874, 0.033486273139715195, -0.02655220776796341, 0.012953576631844044, 0.02445411868393421, -0.07347913086414337, 0.020295418798923492, -0.007382864132523537, -0.02321910858154297, -0.04573320597410202, 0.03211237117648125, 0.018324749544262886, 0.018405884504318237, 0.04591771587729454, -0.04043801501393318, 0.0020587840117514133, 0.000019207185687264428, 0.0006635838653892279, 0.05180282145738602, -0.019593121483922005, -0.054771944880485535, 0.006937514059245586, -0.006736460607498884, -0.0318656750023365, 0.06395894289016724, -0.0006503135082311928, -0.02783522568643093, 0.018333839252591133, 0.0009314147755503654, -0.025577832013368607, -0.019358452409505844, -0.06334716826677322, 0.016672121360898018, -0.01163022592663765, -0.034038521349430084, 0.027315136045217514, -0.017316197976469994, -0.0803229957818985, 0.044877856969833374, 0.015770545229315758, -0.06387238204479218, -0.018216455355286598, 0.023783724755048752, 0.027790259569883347, -0.014487593434751034, -0.03268211707472801, 0.04712146520614624, 0.012780550867319107, 0.008391255512833595, -0.024456018581986427, -0.03942303732037544, -0.01871849223971367, -0.005411059129983187, 0.022641513496637344, 0.024879783391952515, 0.02078412100672722, 0.10060062259435654, 0.036476537585258484, -0.03898729756474495, -0.05569944903254509, 0.010324468836188316, -0.08086889982223511, -0.013043991290032864, 0.029139170423150063, 0.0175680723041296, -0.008213978260755539, -0.007215875666588545, -0.014645066112279892, 0.024811087176203728, 0.0782204270362854, -0.028398944064974785, -0.0331401489675045, 0.052703093737363815, -0.020860180258750916, -0.01510501280426979, 0.017649777233600616, 0.014942734502255917, -0.03995490074157715, -0.01461886428296566, 0.01852406933903694, 0.005103287752717733, 0.014470141381025314, -0.039023082703351974, 0.05742121487855911, -0.045128725469112396, 0.03068884275853634, -0.01683417148888111, -0.0005597510607913136, 0.02675841562449932, -0.043459054082632065, -0.017718305811285973, 0.007244441192597151, 0.03667611628770828, -0.02706976793706417, 0.028301823884248734, 0.06449278444051743, 0.04449072107672691, 0.011978269554674625, -0.023151913657784462, -0.026549382135272026, -0.012793395668268204, -0.003611126681789756, -0.022836141288280487, -0.02034124918282032, 0.04221903905272484, 0.0201460849493742, 0.01621992699801922, 0.01958117075264454, -0.050478383898735046, 0.026000982150435448, -0.060972295701503754, -0.013696416281163692, -0.04653647169470787, 0.025573741644620895, 0.033129263669252396, 0.02616782858967781, 0.00959872268140316, -0.027269070968031883, 0.0066591184586286545, 0.03911365568637848, -0.017600780352950096, 0.0015014118980616331, 0.018487337976694107, 0.006021374370902777, 0.016195029020309448, -0.03336399048566818, 0.0008612954989075661, -0.02414148673415184, 0.0020957496017217636, -0.009173276834189892, 0.03777584061026573, -0.03732828050851822, -0.013803627341985703, -0.025113258510828018, -0.01017877645790577, -0.023405887186527252, -0.00015216883912216872, -0.004577165469527245, -0.012089855037629604, 0.04545915126800537, 0.00935445912182331, -0.03221673518419266, 0.011622394435107708, -0.021394573152065277, 0.03412238880991936, -0.0022201454266905785, 0.01680922880768776, -0.013880399987101555, 0.04240807518362999, -0.07927463203668594, 0.032813526690006256, 0.0035006722901016474, 0.029179159551858902, 0.049306221306324005, -0.002657021628692746, -0.013241009786725044, -0.0530293732881546, -0.05555984750390053, 0.02055913209915161, 0.037080612033605576, -0.004534092266112566, 0.0039787013083696365, 0.04640348255634308, 0.012346428819000721, -0.06744793057441711, -0.021265968680381775, 0.04629804193973541, -0.0006495430134236813, -0.012681405059993267, -0.05198930203914642, -0.049574270844459534, 0.0018826284212991595, -0.00527796009555459, 0.0279703252017498, 0.011549383401870728, -0.029218576848506927, -0.01892043836414814, 0.03927617892622948, -0.04836490377783775, -0.04441794753074646, 0.0017993077635765076, 0.01600634679198265, -0.007852614857256413, -0.032458506524562836, 0.002322685904800892, -0.010566159151494503, 0.025661472231149673, 0.05379846319556236, 0.0306476429104805, 0.016588842496275902, -0.08412421494722366, -0.02496904321014881, 0.07982852309942245, 0.03775305673480034, -0.04017418250441551, -0.0332782082259655, -0.04547306150197983, -0.029324572533369064, 0.030249711126089096, -0.05384797602891922, 0.02974427118897438, 0.014665828086435795, 0.012982194311916828, -0.06274301558732986, -0.03801453113555908, -0.02051585726439953, 0.045623693615198135, -0.0065000769682228565, 0.06184941157698631, -0.019067537039518356, -0.02291266806423664, -0.02964320220053196, 0.023690925911068916, -0.006351864896714687, 0.0415475107729435, -0.025944260880351067, -0.015869420021772385, 0.0012725346023216844, -0.0019311150535941124, -0.0014061806723475456, -0.07230900228023529, -0.007690833881497383, -0.019167106598615646, -0.015048342756927013, 0.051109619438648224, 0.012219607830047607, -0.050087589770555496, 0.004125990439206362, 0.011686021462082863, -0.019539397209882736, -0.015089239925146103, -0.024706829339265823, 0.04892894625663757, 0.03200589120388031, 0.029360035434365273, 0.0260317325592041, -0.00028021441539749503, -0.0017074214993044734, 0.016384927555918694, -0.014581785537302494, 0.010636947117745876, -0.02199767902493477, -0.04629427567124367, -0.004724562168121338, -0.010066387243568897, -0.009028912521898746, 0.028600413352251053, 0.019641969352960587, 0.08108582347631454, -0.011457417160272598, -0.027323691174387932, 0.0036865214351564646, 0.02475673332810402, 0.0001644616131670773, -0.014982717111706734, 0.0006321603432297707, 0.006334918085485697, -0.046338047832250595, 0.029871754348278046, -0.003088561352342367, 0.006416992750018835, 0.009830704890191555, 0.023095356300473213, -0.029137292876839638, -0.014917037449777126, -0.03668500483036041, 0.010693788528442383, -0.017535671591758728, -0.026643948629498482, 0.06098667532205582, -0.004061290994286537, 0.03896148130297661, 0.01833133026957512, -0.022091588005423546, 0.0036484217271208763, 0.00271051493473351, 0.024766843765974045, 0.04546552151441574, -0.0038265842013061047, 0.00753344502300024, 0.006830570288002491, 0.004654020071029663, -0.04916679859161377, -0.03325226157903671, 0.02463170513510704, 0.023621579632163048, -0.04136892780661583, -0.044655151665210724, 0.0021561398170888424, 0.03328720107674599, -0.03537927195429802, 0.018921485170722008, 0.04738805443048477, -0.00023255379346664995, -0.009444345720112324, 0.003958652727305889, -0.00489800376817584, 0.08013612776994705, -0.010778888128697872, 0.010913525708019733, 0.006847884505987167, 0.0033504082821309566, -0.033578190952539444, 0.024765456095337868, 0.03109525889158249, -0.015428205952048302, -0.015164477750658989, -0.039986513555049896, 0.03438965231180191, 0.036272697150707245, -0.003980641253292561, 0.020055852830410004, 0.006488817278295755, -0.026425085961818695, 0.035009369254112244, -0.014627184718847275, 0.04051601141691208, -0.012044425122439861, -0.039582230150699615, -0.004431695677340031, 0.0028880166355520487, 0.00896507315337658, -0.04753529652953148, 0.019444232806563377, 0.009417989291250706, -0.01350666955113411, 0.02473742887377739, 0.07888398319482803, -0.023615263402462006, 0.014127146452665329, -0.02707311138510704, -0.04938391223549843, 0.011173447594046593, -0.003614754183217883, 0.011155557818710804, -0.02768375165760517, 0.017035208642482758, -0.029346488416194916, 0.019274087622761726, -0.035350315272808075, -0.003820240730419755, 0.06837637722492218, 0.03170228749513626, 0.030666520819067955, 0.01980520784854889, -0.0009592644055373967, 0.0163225419819355, -0.043628305196762085, -0.019179118797183037, -0.026566961780190468, -0.018132472410798073, 0.0526643805205822, 0.014234191738069057, 0.00612708181142807, 0.04711730778217316, 0.018631985411047935, 0.04112841188907623, 0.013428602367639542, 0.009601669386029243, 0.02160795032978058, 0.035767026245594025, -0.042635444551706314, -0.054531410336494446, 0.04470027983188629, -0.026320720091462135, 0.037353675812482834, 0.00833742506802082, 0.02340300939977169, 0.04706745594739914, 0.02875615656375885, -0.00009984417556552216, 0.014565592631697655, -0.032500818371772766, -0.04688499867916107, 0.0025297522079199553, 0.03127669543027878, -0.042072296142578125, -0.017059102654457092, 0.025878772139549255, 0.01625136099755764, 0.016046373173594475, 0.034018829464912415, -0.058281075209379196, -0.07499673217535019, -0.047444164752960205, -0.02740776725113392, -0.029084598645567894, 0.057261671870946884, 0.021272657439112663, -0.029100170359015465, -0.007599209435284138, -0.010572423227131367, 0.0061611151322722435, -0.008991194888949394, 0.02420067973434925, -0.01721235364675522, -0.00859084166586399, -0.018305310979485512, 0.014070235192775726, -0.003991379402577877, -0.005206796806305647, 0.1527063101530075, 0.061063043773174286, 0.016682714223861694, -0.01620291732251644, -0.015332161448895931, 0.018047042191028595, -0.017659910023212433, -0.022230032831430435, 0.03108915127813816, 0.016545847058296204, -0.01667965203523636, 0.017854789271950722, 0.014500296674668789, 0.039132289588451385, -0.019958099350333214, 0.045469798147678375, 0.0046411133371293545, 0.030942918732762337, -0.011358986608684063, 0.018512558192014694, 0.02424600161612034, 0.006076251622289419, -0.04446011781692505, 0.01644287444651127, -0.016314605250954628, -0.017800679430365562, -0.019445031881332397, -0.00045423556002788246, 0.007749058771878481, -0.006757241208106279, -0.004827325697988272, -0.02497326023876667, 0.011672338470816612, 0.0011165295727550983, 0.009689033962786198, 0.0121857775375247, -0.0019530737772583961, -0.004023099318146706, 0.03666398674249649, 0.043077632784843445, 0.016988622024655342, 0.01674393191933632, -0.023262962698936462, 0.013821226544678211, -0.022626418620347977, -0.035601865500211716, -0.06007184088230133, 0.04803779348731041, -0.0075887711718678474, -0.03358357399702072, 0.02103758230805397, 0.019253358244895935, -0.0022046505473554134, -0.09224968403577805, -0.012269425205886364, -0.002517007989808917, 0.030427230522036552, 0.01068741362541914, -0.047856174409389496, -0.020249877125024796, 0.028629325330257416, 0.002251665573567152, 0.027146123349666595, 0.010141740553081036, -0.04302512854337692, -0.061009205877780914, -0.024000069126486778, 0.03963065147399902, 0.014571147039532661, 0.014601786620914936, 0.0025681350380182266, -0.01728445664048195, -0.0009742687689140439, -0.027763446792960167, 0.024309253320097923, 0.027394067496061325, -0.002494317479431629, -0.006062865722924471, -0.04826672002673149, -0.025706658139824867, -0.03204667568206787, 0.010282477363944054, -0.01090970914810896, -0.001775372656993568, -0.017927827313542366, 0.016878405585885048, 0.026778247207403183, 0.00762982340529561, 0.05778323858976364, 0.04043249040842056, 0.01581757701933384, 0.042966328561306, 0.014775991439819336, -0.038616843521595, -0.016633151099085808, 0.011183569207787514, -0.033865176141262054, -0.005731451790779829, 0.03039986453950405, 0.06074606254696846, 0.03405362740159035, 0.014504726976156235, -0.0010033814469352365, 0.01840764656662941, 0.026805106550455093, -0.006765181198716164, 0.008158078417181969, -0.05567168816924095, -0.02129991352558136, 0.010893967002630234, -0.03341519087553024, -0.03154364228248596, -0.025565428659319878, -0.03995174914598465, -0.02406763657927513, 0.0008263750933110714, 0.019624261185526848, -0.011187382973730564, -0.028180966153740883, -0.003224755870178342, 0.016237935051321983, -0.020627852529287338, -0.008009140379726887, -0.007086973637342453, 0.020101575180888176, -0.03968482092022896, -0.022753771394491196, -0.017840899527072906, -0.003721921006217599, 0.014268363825976849, -0.01110147126019001, 0.0381087101995945, 0.020836861804127693, 0.014786637388169765, -0.03862207755446434, 0.009636610746383667, -0.007398783694952726, 0.024513106793165207, -0.022715777158737183, -0.01347307302057743, 0.012920984998345375, -0.01064540259540081, -0.04801596701145172, 0.01707632467150688, -0.008028729818761349, 0.027085375040769577, 0.02857985533773899, -0.02953651361167431, -0.016735296696424484, 0.06288953870534897, -0.020649757236242294, -0.026149963960051537, 0.005145195405930281, 0.044208552688360214, 0.010010446421802044, 0.039553143084049225, 0.0377190075814724, -0.019825546070933342, -0.002611978678032756, 0.04110337421298027, -0.010094184428453445, -0.023376943543553352, -0.02748953551054001, 0.01286067720502615, -0.06769514828920364, 0.015627166256308556, -0.0047009894624352455, -0.0006693463656120002, 0.05570435896515846, -0.005564131308346987, -0.0251686442643404, 0.042848557233810425, -0.01234914269298315, 0.029803570359945297, -0.09430672228336334, -0.022395381703972816, 0.013952773995697498, 0.035757433623075485, 0.02179049886763096, -0.060496795922517776, 0.025877323001623154, 0.0340101532638073, -0.06417721509933472, 0.02811582013964653, 0.004935001488775015, 0.0006327154114842415, -0.0597519613802433, 0.015191148966550827, -0.0031951030250638723, 0.0011185604380443692, 0.012077025137841702, -0.000914654228836298, 0.03939725458621979, 0.02175874263048172, -0.028677308931946754, -0.00619828887283802, -0.022750377655029297, 0.05100629851222038, -0.02528557740151882, -0.024379169568419456, 0.007111644372344017, -0.0280735045671463, -0.00986415147781372, -0.013976548798382282, 0.0032778114546090364, 0.014412845484912395, 0.04839795082807541, 0.04122351482510567, 0.023447677493095398, 0.052585307508707047, 0.028177399188280106, -0.013615349307656288, 0.0034931665286421776, -0.01079649943858385, 0.039935074746608734, 0.014801887795329094, -0.014392494224011898, -0.001099743414670229, 0.04555555433034897, -0.018972650170326233, -0.023271208629012108, 0.008094982244074345, -0.026254044845700264, -0.021060096099972725, 0.019364308565855026, 0.019177041947841644, 0.01799575239419937, 0.00033241018536500633, 0.011431751772761345, -0.06274959444999695, 0.007495607249438763, -0.009365937672555447, 0.010869020596146584, -0.019477687776088715, 0.026493201032280922, -0.03175272420048714, -0.025395242497324944, -0.026341721415519714, 0.012221325188875198, 0.0062628695741295815, -0.0175150278955698, -0.01037490926682949, 0.024331841617822647, -0.032018113881349564, -0.006573121063411236, -0.0008859828230924904, -0.025906488299369812, 0.06087903678417206, 0.011607130989432335, 0.022465741261839867, 0.03684251010417938, -0.009740854613482952, -0.021781254559755325, -0.11152670532464981, 0.04045262187719345, -0.019698739051818848, -0.043007586151361465, -0.02493041753768921, 0.016480999067425728, -0.0008887748699635267, 0.028499778360128403, 0.06975767761468887, -0.0455736443400383, 0.024898577481508255, -0.03909085690975189, 0.01642872579395771, 0.02735106460750103, -0.04696642979979515, 0.015109090134501457, -0.039686743170022964, -0.013653673231601715, -0.028055310249328613, 0.0030996939167380333, 0.0037006023339927197, 0.008809889666736126, 0.039280105382204056, -0.010182546451687813, -0.0017555435188114643, 0.013599839061498642, -0.0017690187087282538, 0.03665134683251381, -0.005434606224298477, -0.010908117517828941, 0.06245167553424835, 0.019571827724575996, -0.009882908314466476, 0.04909203574061394, -0.01406086329370737, -0.08035033196210861, 0.016295118257403374, 0.0035567432641983032, -0.009129117242991924, -0.010102563537657261, 0.030147939920425415, 0.04185684397816658, -0.06320099532604218, 0.0040440489538013935, 0.028333598747849464, -0.025912422686815262, 0.007633032277226448, 0.03285141661763191, 0.019217250868678093, -0.005560835357755423, -0.017050163820385933, 0.03899063915014267, -0.026480520144104958, -0.02563619799911976, 0.007848742417991161, 0.002623575506731868, 0.012111767195165157, 0.02769598737359047, 0.013386058621108532, 0.02612968347966671, -0.0024123138282448053, 0.02079869993031025, -0.021157385781407356, 0.0433521494269371, -0.026099609211087227, 0.019878191873431206, 0.016691625118255615, 0.013170534744858742, -0.013372550718486309, 0.012785919941961765, -0.0369308739900589, 0.07028963416814804, -0.0462544821202755, -0.026824135333299637, -0.053826991468667984, -0.0487278588116169, -0.010495389811694622, -0.008968877606093884, 0.03931618481874466, 0.03607940673828125, 0.02952410653233528, -0.00039547885535284877, -0.039933785796165466, 0.023497771471738815, 0.06162705272436142, -0.009200229309499264, 0.005914382636547089, 0.008790555410087109, 0.008523629046976566, 0.031802382320165634, 0.009773571975529194, -0.015521273016929626, 0.023218849673867226, 0.021441318094730377, 0.014501319266855717, -0.02007523737847805, -0.02331577055156231, -0.021799813956022263, -0.019225718453526497, 0.04323485493659973, -0.05539355054497719, -0.031886883080005646, -0.02748403511941433, 0.034076884388923645, 0.009954607114195824, -0.01914013922214508 ]
<p>This is nearly the same headline as my previous <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/67762/interpretation-of-logistic-regression-intercept-with-one-dummy-coded-categorical">question</a>, but it turned out I was asking about multiple issues. I still have not understood the more basic issues, which have to do with the interpretation of the intercept and the role of the reference category.</p> <p>Let's say I do a regression (in this case, a logistic regression) with a single predictor, "color", a dummy coded categorical variable having three categories ("red", "blue", and "green"). The regression and results have two predictor variables, let's say "red" and "blue" with "green" as the omitted reference category.</p> <p>In the results, the intercept is the log odds when "red" and "blue" are zero. But in that case, it's also the log odds when "green"=1. </p> <p>The results have an intercept and a test of its significance. If the intercept is significant but the coefficients for "red" and "blue" are not, what does this say about:</p> <ul> <li><p>the value "green" as a predictor of the outcome?</p></li> <li><p>the categorical variable "color" as a predictor of the outcome?</p></li> </ul> <p>(I have an inkling that the answers may depend on how perfectly "color" predicts the outcome, but I don't know how to talk about this.)</p> <p>Thanks for your help with these elementary questions.</p>
73,776
[ -0.06875178962945938, -0.003303737845271826, -0.02060678042471409, 0.018793921917676926, 0.03595062345266342, 0.022300368174910545, 0.009695717133581638, 0.007351442240178585, 0.03086739219725132, -0.0408107191324234, 0.044942233711481094, 0.034734368324279785, 0.040273718535900116, 0.0014898189110681415, 0.006603640969842672, 0.002952044131234288, 0.017270974814891815, 0.020982129499316216, 0.014760931953787804, 0.01941005513072014, 0.0034385479521006346, 0.024769140407443047, 0.030261045321822166, 0.04734659940004349, 0.00007024551450740546, 0.08614657074213028, 0.026583662256598473, -0.013728393241763115, 0.017027495428919792, 0.013694372959434986, -0.02431570179760456, -0.013240988366305828, -0.019714247435331345, 0.011492217890918255, -0.00921258982270956, -0.0032971121836453676, 0.005360839422792196, -0.02061154879629612, 0.012611801736056805, 0.00548480125144124, 0.014435485005378723, -0.03084551729261875, 0.001328153652139008, 0.03314799442887306, -0.008871892467141151, 0.007365493569523096, -0.037498313933610916, -0.024531858041882515, 0.052685048431158066, -0.03187175095081329, 0.045886535197496414, -0.011477034538984299, 0.033770591020584106, 0.028872856870293617, -0.019970279186964035, 0.006587033625692129, 0.04162416607141495, 0.06818155944347382, -0.028795232996344566, -0.03593611717224121, -0.018880467861890793, -0.003301990684121847, 0.013953928835690022, 0.0026517848018556833, -0.01736094243824482, 0.04060899093747139, 0.005611605942249298, -0.009833213873207569, 0.057197462767362595, -0.010632410645484924, 0.009396597743034363, 0.0019661111291497946, 0.03431303799152374, 0.02528230845928192, 0.03678864985704422, -0.05399595573544502, -0.0060601313598454, 0.021339019760489464, 0.003928957041352987, 0.05842766538262367, -0.022816963493824005, 0.006782947573810816, -0.014123689383268356, 0.050147101283073425, 0.018131952732801437, 0.010236399248242378, 0.06577111035585403, -0.022232336923480034, 0.026189733296632767, 0.012617689557373524, 0.0041178083047270775, -0.010445304214954376, 0.02910539135336876, 0.008621571585536003, -0.028040381148457527, 0.04086238518357277, -0.03624733164906502, 0.04535466432571411, 0.017393024638295174, 0.024318130686879158, -0.03212340176105499, -0.029545223340392113, 0.023871755227446556, 0.04033584147691727, -0.043348703533411026, -0.01570851542055607, -0.041393034160137177, 0.018107213079929352, 0.02275649458169937, -0.04258941486477852, 0.0009795015212148428, 0.020708266645669937, 0.029596593230962753, -0.03569488972425461, -0.006331826094537973, -0.039478227496147156, -0.004487084224820137, -0.008486976847052574, 0.02602851763367653, 0.0285041481256485, 0.024382777512073517, -0.040478698909282684, -0.002840502420440316, -0.0164212416857481, 0.00026932821492664516, -0.011690034531056881, 0.03207176923751831, 0.009660904295742512, -0.013583959080278873, 0.058736834675073624, -0.029953427612781525, -0.037444837391376495, 0.012789757922291756, 0.03442469611763954, 0.003049005987122655, -0.0014346137177199125, -0.0765443742275238, -0.06255029141902924, 0.0032203909941017628, 0.025059588253498077, -0.021250586956739426, -0.08051399886608124, -0.05875043943524361, 0.021234838292002678, 0.0411314032971859, -0.00026865844847634435, 0.013267922215163708, 0.01241929829120636, 0.009163226000964642, 0.04459988698363304, -0.040212035179138184, -0.0071417237631976604, -0.059550587087869644, -0.02609838731586933, -0.017299100756645203, -0.06624926626682281, 0.019308988004922867, 0.004788896068930626, -0.01106931921094656, 0.0019138808129355311, 0.05208821967244148, 0.004087675828486681, -0.024412840604782104, 0.012401333078742027, -0.01996293105185032, 0.008797144517302513, 0.0715075209736824, -0.037918709218502045, 0.02078900672495365, 0.024792799726128578, 0.033486947417259216, 0.017407307401299477, 0.0071051958948373795, 0.06972521543502808, 0.02255498617887497, -0.007651626598089933, -0.008671648800373077, -0.03462393954396248, 0.021031798794865608, -0.03727583587169647, -0.06612806022167206, -0.0474160835146904, -0.020378248766064644, -0.034785911440849304, 0.03437741473317146, 0.03859962150454521, -0.012519504874944687, -0.025651725009083748, 0.08600884675979614, -0.01523515023291111, -0.04524800181388855, -0.039559926837682724, 0.027237145230174065, 0.005500511731952429, -0.022109869867563248, 0.04303453490138054, 0.01892555132508278, 0.031706493347883224, -0.022487612441182137, 0.02071816846728325, -0.018505491316318512, -0.004253897815942764, 0.03843845799565315, -0.03489429131150246, -0.0017366721294820309, 0.046582214534282684, 0.035352036356925964, -0.03534344583749771, 0.02533685229718685, -0.06466422230005264, -0.07344235479831696, 0.03296726569533348, 0.008629091084003448, 0.035649146884679794, -0.02354169823229313, -0.013364084996283054, 0.0230848528444767, -0.014963110908865929, -0.028429463505744934, 0.04155473783612251, -0.06022965535521507, 0.07775997370481491, -0.004436051473021507, -0.0194794200360775, 0.004217717796564102, 0.036494795233011246, 0.015445172786712646, 0.02324296347796917, -0.01588650792837143, 0.0011662887409329414, -0.03685930371284485, -0.03408617526292801, 0.044531047344207764, 0.006810619030147791, -0.0242309533059597, 0.010797152295708656, 0.0008922945708036423, 0.0367281436920166, 0.003224398707970977, 0.020938104018568993, 0.014630839228630066, -0.012752408161759377, -0.016561657190322876, 0.017828993499279022, -0.006747263949364424, -0.007965155877172947, 0.0366826131939888, 0.011573992669582367, 0.04483843594789505, 0.008374606259167194, 0.006369527895003557, 0.08836638182401657, -0.013256852515041828, -0.009274274110794067, -0.019951416179537773, -0.021776266396045685, 0.05949211120605469, -0.059774208813905716, 0.01534251682460308, 0.05815935879945755, 0.04645250365138054, -0.014567488804459572, 0.006271728780120611, 0.012087670154869556, -0.010110720060765743, 0.04635296016931534, -0.04320523515343666, -0.003464511362835765, 0.0012240009382367134, -0.0491875484585762, 0.021662602201104164, 0.00833917036652565, -0.04206154868006706, -0.01949629932641983, 0.0047010392881929874, -0.004166217055171728, -0.005088945385068655, -0.008943058550357819, -0.045138295739889145, -0.027737585827708244, 0.016801245510578156, -0.010180452838540077, 0.036307066679000854, -0.0051873899064958096, -0.04686657711863518, -0.04044970124959946, -0.061034299433231354, 0.0016336374683305621, 0.01336588617414236, 0.0002979309647344053, -0.060200419276952744, 0.0167130958288908, -0.03816359117627144, -0.07219979912042618, -0.02048441395163536, -0.013167286291718483, 0.02919749543070793, -0.04388810321688652, -0.05189386010169983, 0.05575564503669739, -0.01999288983643055, -0.01726832240819931, 0.018376575782895088, -0.031573690474033356, -0.017323769629001617, 0.003643305506557226, 0.0009323793929070234, 0.0065980697982013226, 0.007999084889888763, 0.017635364085435867, 0.010516009293496609, -0.03181063011288643, -0.0037289869505912066, -0.08884923160076141, -0.06925077736377716, -0.006465989165008068, 0.034323692321777344, 0.040863752365112305, -0.014501910656690598, 0.003121383488178253, 0.05691187456250191, 0.020291410386562347, 0.005892458837479353, -0.08309848606586456, -0.009529849514365196, -0.04967624694108963, -0.02941887639462948, 0.02750753052532673, 0.019616063684225082, 0.02815401181578636, 0.03956103324890137, -0.01732870563864708, 0.03740408644080162, 0.01222487073391676, 0.04754453897476196, 0.0041821361519396305, 0.03512176498770714, -0.0004922779626213014, -0.0021427131723612547, 0.006961888633668423, 0.03993605449795723, 0.012699968181550503, 0.01939230225980282, -0.027207979932427406, 0.05400979146361351, 0.005057616624981165, -0.03315915912389755, 0.01692652888596058, -0.010099680162966251, 0.014746686443686485, 0.0005498025566339493, 0.02181735634803772, 0.023216772824525833, -0.03694435954093933, -0.030655281618237495, -0.003969143610447645, 0.007324098143726587, -0.0014823381789028645, 0.006342116743326187, 0.04245481640100479, 0.04323095083236694, -0.0009451829828321934, -0.0191193800419569, -0.009615528397262096, -0.008202394470572472, 0.039708178490400314, -0.0372563935816288, 0.021848415955901146, 0.06673627346754074, 0.03301990032196045, -0.008772273547947407, -0.03177696093916893, -0.04461071640253067, 0.01698620617389679, -0.04448848217725754, -0.0196339413523674, 0.0037380270659923553, 0.018742935732007027, -0.0024367051664739847, 0.04916194826364517, 0.011481857858598232, -0.0134630361571908, 0.00548511603847146, 0.030198032036423683, -0.057335928082466125, -0.007661193143576384, -0.011469379998743534, 0.01629403978586197, 0.02300422266125679, -0.020492153242230415, 0.06521337479352951, -0.023973744362592697, -0.011098255403339863, 0.023097550496459007, 0.012945331633090973, 0.01595805212855339, 0.015296577475965023, -0.009829740971326828, -0.059349700808525085, 0.01753832958638668, -0.0018424263689666986, -0.012415213510394096, 0.019199814647436142, 0.019185947254300117, 0.05875805765390396, -0.009204110130667686, 0.0016417810693383217, -0.027795055881142616, -0.006226749625056982, 0.03572705760598183, 0.05508958175778389, 0.02510828897356987, -0.017304422333836555, -0.02665746957063675, 0.04668396711349487, -0.012154273688793182, 0.021298907697200775, -0.0022303606383502483, -0.008133748546242714, -0.004160144366323948, -0.04570217803120613, -0.013716195710003376, -0.02855544164776802, 0.001258665113709867, -0.020163198933005333, 0.007212372031062841, 0.08548029512166977, 0.044145453721284866, -0.04516514018177986, 0.027811503037810326, 0.05082669481635094, 0.032577671110630035, -0.016017435118556023, -0.02765372395515442, 0.03236713260412216, -0.01521307323127985, 0.02197961136698723, 0.041244152933359146, -0.013349579647183418, 0.0023796597961336374, -0.013631650246679783, 0.04455731064081192, -0.012637886218726635, -0.02860540896654129, -0.0351693294942379, 0.006674592383205891, 0.013953532092273235, 0.000995268695987761, -0.05459462106227875, -0.002523666713386774, 0.0680292472243309, 0.008604013361036777, 0.01631956361234188, 0.002732550725340843, -0.09382788836956024, 0.02046850323677063, 0.021795615553855896, 0.06520722806453705, -0.039029475301504135, -0.022432148456573486, -0.02300688438117504, 0.036729004234075546, 0.00827191211283207, -0.028310617431998253, -0.004227025900036097, -0.03307168558239937, 0.011750884354114532, -0.00708575826138258, -0.0310522373765707, -0.06548812985420227, 0.017626982182264328, -0.005200866609811783, 0.023466603830456734, -0.006421720143407583, -0.025826964527368546, -0.038364995270967484, 0.029222726821899414, 0.020863331854343414, 0.05218271166086197, -0.03708573058247566, 0.006464699283242226, 0.012814209796488285, 0.012343570590019226, -0.010460386984050274, -0.07287947833538055, 0.018845178186893463, 0.0014895388158038259, -0.00737643800675869, 0.06468350440263748, -0.014642775058746338, -0.0314556285738945, -0.00037853344110772014, 0.03873174637556076, -0.049477718770504, 0.01224016584455967, -0.056921083480119705, 0.04150988161563873, 0.005293247755616903, -0.00825459137558937, 0.03543230518698692, 0.01933712512254715, 0.009046029299497604, 0.027264781296253204, -0.032715022563934326, 0.007986116223037243, 0.01045631617307663, -0.03903613239526749, -0.006404170300811529, -0.005395402666181326, -0.011476139537990093, 0.025391731411218643, -0.00023624856839887798, 0.0015095305861905217, -0.025981508195400238, -0.04717329889535904, 0.001473857555538416, -0.008641852997243404, -0.005756968166679144, 0.014634137973189354, 0.027622859925031662, 0.0008494695066474378, 0.018492691218852997, -0.044580407440662384, 0.027443958446383476, -0.011443974450230598, 0.012428369373083115, 0.02936212345957756, -0.01004491001367569, 0.026770370081067085, -0.01449689082801342, -0.01539239939302206, 0.002306463662534952, -0.02835887111723423, 0.010698010213673115, -0.020111365243792534, 0.019414320588111877, -0.007998360320925713, -0.05025406926870346, -0.03902505710721016, -0.0029948207084089518, -0.025459008291363716, 0.034962136298418045, -0.025118065997958183, 0.028421049937605858, 0.004965479485690594, -0.012237759307026863, -0.06733520328998566, -0.031093090772628784, 0.01835837960243225, 0.021237773820757866, -0.0503564216196537, -0.02387780137360096, 0.005126384552568197, -0.03331136703491211, -0.020441872999072075, 0.00975099392235279, 0.022734126076102257, -0.035792674869298935, -0.0196255911141634, -0.002229329664260149, 0.023890061303973198, 0.05686548352241516, 0.01235159020870924, -0.024980265647172928, -0.005565971601754427, -0.0318421795964241, -0.014740357175469398, 0.023006292060017586, -0.008983044885098934, -0.02418510615825653, -0.03988847881555557, -0.01867666095495224, -0.0007496486650779843, -0.0007790150702930987, 0.005604993551969528, -0.016238005831837654, 0.02987802028656006, -0.017090903595089912, 0.004819607827812433, -0.03281962499022484, 0.007710776291787624, 0.009621623903512955, 0.0008968450711108744, -0.00930427759885788, 0.022956253960728645, -0.009623081423342228, 0.019274262711405754, 0.02566969208419323, -0.009827898815274239, -0.035210177302360535, 0.022388027980923653, 0.09337139874696732, 0.03377027064561844, 0.04087894409894943, -0.01899592950940132, -0.02076420560479164, 0.06688842922449112, 0.004856287967413664, -0.030215458944439888, 0.014511258341372013, 0.019250590354204178, -0.01859828270971775, -0.013771845027804375, -0.04861878231167793, 0.00151633913628757, 0.03520306944847107, -0.01895958185195923, 0.04299493134021759, 0.018022147938609123, -0.032652173191308975, 0.030877234414219856, -0.04016196355223656, 0.01777712255716324, -0.025477662682533264, 0.020437998697161674, 0.04177989438176155, -0.006130943074822426, 0.008596877567470074, 0.04773354530334473, -0.0021362819243222475, -0.010725099593400955, -0.006736518815159798, 0.037045836448669434, -0.006863709539175034, 0.04943056032061577, -0.044117897748947144, -0.043672673404216766, 0.035871539264917374, -0.04605790227651596, -0.0178847573697567, -0.018748151138424873, -0.0250321626663208, 0.055983901023864746, 0.019157670438289642, -0.00021405301231425256, -0.06735542416572571, -0.03743758425116539, -0.03091937117278576, 0.004165816120803356, 0.019222883507609367, 0.016029374673962593, 0.026012655347585678, -0.04648919403553009, 0.01585029810667038, -0.010842383839190006, 0.013425971381366253, -0.03577274829149246, -0.08577849715948105, -0.05109664797782898, -0.010833801701664925, -0.01720413938164711, 0.022907759994268417, 0.005998153239488602, -0.008591897785663605, 0.015291525982320309, -0.0822533667087555, -0.0027546724304556847, 0.010714652948081493, 0.035172998905181885, 0.006936073303222656, 0.05259518697857857, 0.0183870829641819, -0.006345468573272228, 0.003492914140224457, -0.022844068706035614, 0.10334952920675278, 0.11240951716899872, 0.024280546233057976, -0.09606233984231949, 0.029997913166880608, 0.03523993864655495, 0.010946689173579216, 0.0071404846385121346, -0.022427447140216827, -0.02804741822183132, -0.010323954746127129, 0.04934978857636452, 0.05349602550268173, 0.04136333987116814, 0.0027184810023754835, 0.04974484443664551, -0.04062550514936447, -0.014169316738843918, 0.011562701314687729, -0.022096432745456696, -0.00029765587532892823, -0.012876270338892937, -0.020581316202878952, 0.01225204300135374, 0.013863079249858856, -0.007543155923485756, -0.02908661961555481, -0.0290732029825449, -0.01736719161272049, -0.0111831771209836, -0.00717789214104414, -0.0010287537006661296, 0.016798261553049088, 0.008069648407399654, -0.01405792124569416, -0.018655290827155113, 0.056824736297130585, -0.018969783559441566, -0.004272220190614462, 0.02895178273320198, -0.027319910004734993, -0.0034564826637506485, 0.032052475959062576, 0.017534658312797546, -0.05180210992693901, -0.03211822360754013, -0.03698110580444336, 0.05170593783259392, -0.01805749349296093, 0.008635743521153927, -0.033721186220645905, 0.009756182320415974, -0.004246954340487719, -0.019517511129379272, -0.035086315125226974, 0.036024946719408035, 0.009129616431891918, -0.039442311972379684, -0.015900762751698494, -0.016787266358733177, 0.02500498853623867, 0.014722391031682491, 0.048860322684049606, 0.0301106795668602, -0.02452489174902439, -0.000979375559836626, -0.0325159952044487, 0.06431100517511368, 0.04661514610052109, 0.0031860806047916412, 0.03283781558275223, -0.011791039258241653, -0.03329484164714813, -0.03424513712525368, 0.007002629805356264, 0.0315297394990921, 0.012865514494478703, -0.01576860062777996, -0.0014366275863721967, -0.032124053686857224, -0.0684397891163826, 0.007171865552663803, -0.015658382326364517, -0.0009683795506134629, -0.08205761760473251, -0.006760533899068832, 0.014225893653929234, 0.032325584441423416, 0.007026314735412598, 0.013240881264209747, 0.021063825115561485, 0.06282170861959457, -0.02070123888552189, -0.038362108170986176, -0.014904842711985111, 0.036493632942438126, -0.04332670196890831, -0.005615872330963612, -0.009401380084455013, 0.08831782639026642, -0.008693485520780087, 0.033164847642183304, 0.00439542206004262, 0.0151326609775424, -0.0022016679868102074, -0.0009409909253008664, 0.0059244707226753235, -0.03531324490904808, -0.0010753922397270799, 0.021128952503204346, 0.015493006445467472, -0.00197158707305789, -0.04446204751729965, -0.041614171117544174, -0.05366138741374016, 0.020003924146294594, -0.035931386053562164, -0.056845661252737045, 0.015492577105760574, 0.00224884576164186, 0.018912261351943016, -0.015391607768833637, -0.04762139916419983, -0.06708270311355591, 0.0048822443932294846, 0.01086529903113842, -0.050714362412691116, 0.010256593115627766, 0.04475243017077446, -0.037438664585351944, 0.019736170768737793, 0.023700660094618797, 0.01249030139297247, 0.014595559798181057, 0.00039242295315489173, 0.00969053152948618, 0.003049283754080534, 0.04177315533161163, -0.010120250284671783, -0.02898968756198883, 0.026457345113158226, -0.0046096970327198505, 0.0019521544454619288, 0.03960370272397995, -0.024391356855630875, 0.04633520916104317, 0.03100159578025341, 0.02567312866449356, -0.01142263412475586, 0.03615301474928856, 0.0009792561177164316, 0.0035038006026297808, -0.023545127362012863, -0.03959474712610245, 0.005779607687145472, -0.01537742093205452, -0.005097986664623022, 0.030568819493055344, -0.03450355678796768, 0.005357631016522646, 0.04046580567955971, 0.006555072497576475, 0.00713352719321847, 0.0151090482249856, 0.0006484059849753976, 0.012471180409193039, -0.0011027122382074594, -0.01197619829326868, -0.0016092617297545075, 0.03524225950241089, -0.01880025491118431, 0.08158155530691147, -0.00013091476284898818, 0.021618466824293137, -0.10993514955043793, -0.05752972140908241, 0.03498227149248123, 0.02969440259039402, 0.03520283102989197, -0.07157071679830551, -0.02010868303477764, 0.030941925942897797, -0.05513623356819153, 0.014401833526790142, 0.01259224209934473, -0.0337444432079792, -0.025590866804122925, 0.0023683523759245872, 0.00598249351605773, 0.0021623861975967884, 0.03748021647334099, -0.0008669464732520282, 0.00976733211427927, 0.04050334170460701, -0.020862404257059097, -0.05340966954827309, -0.009298818185925484, 0.022664891555905342, 0.03011474944651127, -0.04378959909081459, 0.0543818473815918, -0.028529496863484383, -0.008375790901482105, 0.027447687461972237, 0.012682451866567135, 0.039968568831682205, 0.07302362471818924, -0.018377309665083885, -0.010106891393661499, 0.04445548355579376, 0.03607283532619476, 0.030591415241360664, -0.016705680638551712, -0.0005507824243977666, 0.014781808480620384, 0.03769833967089653, 0.0035247833002358675, -0.011973615735769272, -0.004551928956061602, -0.012539857998490334, -0.021144593134522438, 0.008524729870259762, -0.026178082451224327, 0.010674401186406612, 0.028346320614218712, 0.006024010479450226, -0.015443720854818821, -0.011558232828974724, 0.01792016252875328, -0.0656622126698494, -0.005109042394906282, 0.020940039306879044, 0.009351338259875774, -0.02353454940021038, 0.005297147203236818, -0.037654582411050797, 0.010278429836034775, 0.012865078635513783, 0.0033080028370022774, -0.007140098139643669, -0.030368180945515633, 0.048867255449295044, 0.000841786153614521, -0.0029934535268694162, -0.018848547711968422, 0.0012433252995833755, -0.03760135918855667, 0.025193316861987114, -0.0303222443908453, -0.00634690560400486, 0.024098007008433342, -0.039524372667074203, 0.027281027287244797, -0.08276344835758209, 0.056743111461400986, 0.032576870173215866, -0.023884424939751625, -0.04732758179306984, -0.01198881957679987, -0.03818443790078163, 0.02906773053109646, 0.045524753630161285, -0.009940270334482193, -0.02532043121755123, -0.0013557311613112688, 0.043913114815950394, -0.003450188785791397, -0.021503634750843048, 0.023939117789268494, 0.013912969268858433, -0.012218629010021687, -0.041851598769426346, -0.003503007348626852, -0.0003383682924322784, 0.010255943052470684, 0.03149362653493881, -0.012204458937048912, -0.010575469583272934, -0.006915364880114794, -0.027333443984389305, 0.03476885333657265, 0.004714779555797577, -0.010014042258262634, 0.07619524747133255, 0.022358454763889313, 0.008771248161792755, 0.0023729479871690273, -0.013545197434723377, -0.07266365736722946, 0.03150218725204468, 0.005911937914788723, -0.027404531836509705, 0.027371611446142197, -0.004186792764812708, 0.011953696608543396, -0.055336739867925644, 0.0431891568005085, 0.016480842605233192, 0.010034470818936825, 0.0006693030591122806, 0.03594588488340378, 0.0448138564825058, 0.03248907998204231, -0.012275132350623608, -0.007356863934546709, 0.005154479295015335, -0.040671318769454956, 0.009535074234008789, 0.002690177410840988, 0.02274356409907341, 0.0077156745828688145, 0.023396847769618034, 0.03591366484761238, 0.016241325065493584, 0.022918423637747765, 0.021795762702822685, 0.048309434205293655, -0.018669845536351204, 0.004983327817171812, 0.008160227909684181, 0.013244986534118652, 0.047622207552194595, 0.00699929054826498, 0.008082510903477669, 0.04101227596402168, -0.024284273386001587, -0.01662677712738514, -0.03408979997038841, 0.022435098886489868, -0.048926644027233124, -0.041214264929294586, 0.036130212247371674, 0.01520712673664093, 0.011833485215902328, 0.003527129301801324, 0.009902391582727432, -0.027484126389026642, -0.014826704747974873, -0.0024008839391171932, -0.004109545145183802, 0.0060315425507724285, -0.03489184007048607, -0.022586019709706306, -0.03547079488635063, 0.00959836132824421, -0.033898815512657166, 0.01290091872215271, 0.04577963426709175, -0.003604365512728691, -0.02160538360476494, -0.013922924175858498, -0.02295447140932083, 0.06417862325906754, -0.0549548901617527, -0.013875273987650871, -0.04713839292526245, 0.04215932637453079, 0.02541443705558777, -0.03838780149817467 ]
<p>I am rather new to Matlab and never had a lot to do with statistics, so I apologize already for possibly being ignorant of quite a bit of important knowledge. It also would be nice if you could answer as simple as possible. Thanks ☺</p> <p>My question is about finding the parameters of a univariate distribution. I get two sets of data, which I want to analyze automatically. The first set is bimodal, with the two distributions generally being separated completely. The second set has at least three modes. My data is about the fiber directions in a carbon composite. So if I have 2 general directions I get the bimodal distribution, but if I have 3, I get two high peaks and usually one or two smaller ones (the peak at 0° is wrong data I'm working on eliminating).</p> <p>I already played around a bit with mle, and got it to work for the bimodal case, but it takes ages, even when given good starting values. Right now I am splitting the bimodal in two and fit two separate normal distributions, but I would like to find a more elegant way. As for the 3-fiber case, I’m still without any working idea. </p> <p>I really appreciate any help with this :)</p> <p>The distributions</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/zBdVG.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/PHoJP.png" alt="enter image description here"></p>
73,777
[ -0.015959670767188072, 0.010307683609426022, 0.01766820065677166, -0.030305461958050728, 0.016532063484191895, 0.01278302725404501, 0.011952894739806652, -0.015217102132737637, 0.04920263588428497, -0.05287851765751839, 0.04167113080620766, 0.044071219861507416, 0.02895340695977211, 0.035264596343040466, 0.053864654153585434, -0.010149015113711357, -0.03043362870812416, -0.020002217963337898, -0.06239950284361839, -0.030606228858232498, 0.012473398819565773, 0.00029592576902359724, -0.03197775036096573, -0.0011745622614398599, -0.027366438880562782, 0.0661507174372673, 0.0006279629888013005, -0.007042623125016689, 0.02688302844762802, 0.03232770785689354, -0.04619986191391945, -0.049314405769109726, -0.009868293069303036, 0.006812393665313721, -0.009485149756073952, -0.01762533374130726, 0.01293948758393526, 0.002865247195586562, -0.0037856893613934517, 0.025577085092663765, -0.04234163463115692, -0.01058676652610302, -0.03594754636287689, -0.0022067795507609844, -0.004367742221802473, -0.006030366290360689, 0.02917681634426117, -0.05183843523263931, 0.03171501308679581, -0.03626859933137894, 0.10838048160076141, 0.018683068454265594, 0.026371952146291733, -0.003656771732494235, -0.011442909948527813, -0.027301514521241188, 0.039701204746961594, 0.08731372654438019, 0.04184180498123169, -0.05857681483030319, -0.007002289406955242, -0.0057067652232944965, 0.012434008531272411, 0.01105875801295042, -0.044262539595365524, 0.019828030839562416, -0.0055114696733653545, -0.04786151647567749, 0.03503955900669098, -0.019229793921113014, 0.026666130870580673, 0.013175390660762787, 0.06947536766529083, -0.017607275396585464, -0.0006263153627514839, 0.004297013860195875, 0.012886431068181992, 0.012432548217475414, 0.058505259454250336, -0.01214135903865099, -0.012533318251371384, 0.03142251446843147, 0.006148210726678371, 0.028444236144423485, -0.016705531626939774, -0.001978288870304823, 0.11345408111810684, -0.028041431680321693, 0.0034304813016206026, 0.010667168535292149, -0.028217842802405357, -0.0056241159327328205, 0.06657665222883224, 0.018528059124946594, -0.006728366948664188, 0.019503237679600716, -0.022327281534671783, 0.04592845216393471, 0.010862079448997974, 0.03143324330449104, 0.00776704354211688, -0.06788177788257599, -0.007378106005489826, 0.04218420758843422, -0.015800073742866516, 0.030609356239438057, -0.018302511423826218, 0.001625546021386981, -0.029457855969667435, -0.037758100777864456, -0.014735287986695766, 0.03407963737845421, 0.008513061329722404, -0.022494908422231674, 0.025537658482789993, 0.015407220460474491, -0.006260502617806196, -0.04518904909491539, 0.03807226940989494, 0.05223822593688965, 0.025761162862181664, -0.02160974219441414, 0.012507232837378979, -0.017006264999508858, -0.05837979540228844, -0.02049485594034195, 0.017541324719786644, 0.034501638263463974, -0.05454276129603386, 0.063188336789608, -0.01152895763516426, -0.005677560344338417, 0.05922960117459297, -0.02522655390202999, 0.00883796438574791, -0.013038165867328644, -0.0651504322886467, -0.046060480177402496, -0.00034203563700430095, -0.01816084235906601, 0.00526632834225893, -0.04885803163051605, -0.025812223553657532, 0.05756891518831253, 0.046604134142398834, 0.024938154965639114, 0.06820683181285858, 0.0033293815795332193, 0.010130430571734905, -0.01252078078687191, 0.01052968017756939, -0.0032631997019052505, -0.06476188451051712, 0.01564146764576435, -0.028370903804898262, -0.06340143084526062, 0.01761479303240776, -0.003427303396165371, -0.0031868754886090755, 0.0019777158740907907, 0.015091080218553543, 0.05395521596074104, -0.0227230004966259, 0.0186940785497427, 0.006270749028772116, -0.012008916586637497, 0.07424546778202057, -0.012904143892228603, 0.02332422509789467, 0.009490772150456905, 0.0056493766605854034, 0.010064542293548584, -0.009937070310115814, 0.04786001518368721, 0.042714398354291916, -0.0101057980209589, -0.016090180724859238, -0.005570374429225922, 0.022204723209142685, 0.0638948604464531, -0.004673914518207312, -0.03484718129038811, 0.003984617069363594, 0.0022197335492819548, 0.02636353112757206, 0.04344522953033447, 0.00543582160025835, -0.03317650035023689, 0.05935678631067276, -0.03494718298316002, -0.01202957984060049, -0.05859997496008873, 0.017522964626550674, -0.018107838928699493, -0.0532008521258831, 0.036113444715738297, 0.00008231661922764033, 0.007226429879665375, 0.010486350394785404, -0.0052679297514259815, -0.007983393967151642, -0.015884120017290115, 0.04992811009287834, -0.04213748127222061, 0.00762571208178997, 0.03383542224764824, 0.052281640470027924, -0.03640570491552353, 0.059734124690294266, 0.015171959064900875, -0.01235277485102415, 0.02870374172925949, -0.047851379960775375, 0.010223389603197575, -0.0008437618380412459, -0.03235738351941109, -0.029354101046919823, -0.0006680666701868176, -0.015379930846393108, 0.0002822118694894016, -0.033698517829179764, 0.05107886344194412, 0.06390747427940369, -0.03216943517327309, -0.011455543339252472, 0.012772039510309696, -0.005570041947066784, 0.03212154284119606, -0.03161982074379921, -0.032028451561927795, -0.05139092728495598, -0.017820920795202255, 0.05334705114364624, 0.011977476999163628, -0.0407513752579689, 0.035011131316423416, 0.049261149019002914, -0.012679730542004108, 0.026101326569914818, 0.047548163682222366, 0.033899057656526566, 0.01193301659077406, 0.03461579233407974, 0.014598427340388298, 0.013398854993283749, -0.014700555242598057, 0.007095915265381336, -0.004101286176592112, 0.04153949394822121, -0.0348958745598793, -0.025005098432302475, 0.05276333540678024, 0.0004386490036267787, 0.003726187627762556, -0.008649486117064953, 0.03157464414834976, 0.0427158921957016, 0.0012370593613013625, -0.012606591917574406, 0.05032186582684517, 0.027214420959353447, -0.034438926726579666, 0.03161504864692688, 0.004591892473399639, 0.021787207573652267, 0.02585524506866932, -0.008146393112838268, -0.022113041952252388, -0.005580261815339327, -0.03628423064947128, 0.020387442782521248, -0.023758381605148315, -0.013163918629288673, -0.027203764766454697, 0.015386921353638172, 0.002956018317490816, 0.045454494655132294, 0.031218670308589935, -0.022359130904078484, -0.047261469066143036, 0.020143209025263786, 0.016468802466988564, 0.0418395921587944, 0.010860980488359928, -0.030439725145697594, 0.013534510508179665, -0.02199927344918251, -0.012514608912169933, 0.010755532421171665, 0.014464511536061764, 0.003959835972636938, 0.011899078264832497, -0.02885696478188038, -0.07612031698226929, -0.02095392718911171, -0.022831426933407784, 0.020655453205108643, -0.026293553411960602, 0.014975717291235924, 0.03784625977277756, 0.0049654822796583176, -0.024629369378089905, 0.022732742130756378, -0.05012388527393341, -0.02833809331059456, -0.009170378558337688, -0.004569029901176691, 0.02690546214580536, 0.03264157474040985, 0.014727332629263401, 0.024707423523068428, 0.0018014978850260377, 0.015262866392731667, -0.09856732189655304, -0.010065954178571701, 0.009562795981764793, 0.017174219712615013, 0.02244294062256813, -0.003573922673240304, -0.012209923937916756, 0.04163387417793274, 0.018986457958817482, -0.07175745815038681, 0.01234979834407568, 0.004609803669154644, -0.029665935784578323, -0.02144206501543522, 0.04594384506344795, -0.005691002123057842, 0.021931307390332222, 0.03974384441971779, -0.008852765895426273, -0.002536857035011053, 0.0847172811627388, 0.022367170080542564, -0.011352979578077793, 0.01955512724816799, 0.002673393813893199, -0.03441967815160751, 0.05933256074786186, 0.04718033969402313, 0.03496865555644035, 0.04300303757190704, -0.01073544006794691, 0.0016477182507514954, -0.012331950478255749, -0.05371294543147087, 0.004330335184931755, -0.03432420268654823, 0.014363722875714302, -0.02527099847793579, 0.005248027853667736, 0.014255045913159847, -0.05143684893846512, -0.005829019006341696, 0.043218303471803665, 0.04445420578122139, -0.006844241172075272, 0.004841551650315523, 0.04088138788938522, 0.01563284546136856, -0.00425499165430665, -0.022587021812796593, -0.037904947996139526, 0.005267569795250893, -0.00110835419036448, -0.013306038454174995, -0.026380302384495735, 0.03932333365082741, 0.03596281260251999, 0.058943916112184525, 0.02046448364853859, -0.024065248668193817, 0.021858664229512215, -0.06704001873731613, -0.0024600308388471603, -0.03218638524413109, 0.05119764804840088, 0.01209212839603424, 0.05064872279763222, 0.060308899730443954, 0.0030843315180391073, 0.010299374349415302, -0.009601701982319355, -0.07961787283420563, 0.0241664107888937, 0.005417675245553255, 0.010751268826425076, -0.01882260851562023, -0.02500544674694538, 0.003488287329673767, -0.03780461475253105, 0.028889087960124016, 0.04156184569001198, 0.040975939482450485, -0.06561092287302017, -0.026749005541205406, -0.058399803936481476, -0.004205387085676193, -0.018473803997039795, 0.005179232452064753, 0.010401079431176186, -0.015943558886647224, 0.007183114532381296, 0.013446478173136711, 0.0008242978365160525, 0.005844630766659975, -0.042591243982315063, 0.012122627347707748, -0.002503936644643545, 0.061452850699424744, -0.001863595680333674, 0.04397423937916756, -0.005155317485332489, -0.00007653565990040079, 0.03446543961763382, 0.0736946314573288, 0.03729436919093132, -0.00510498508810997, -0.005103989038616419, -0.0404612198472023, -0.014355437830090523, -0.01611422933638096, 0.024995705112814903, -0.013502735644578934, -0.009632067754864693, 0.0182966161519289, 0.025883447378873825, -0.06300000101327896, 0.015923911705613136, 0.046940095722675323, 0.011374657973647118, -0.011466708965599537, -0.0665108859539032, -0.00617710966616869, 0.005885025952011347, -0.01828083023428917, 0.02544926106929779, 0.03774157911539078, -0.014192257076501846, -0.024299481883645058, 0.07342144846916199, -0.014766559936106205, -0.003310520201921463, 0.02088376134634018, 0.031857218593358994, 0.034968096762895584, 0.00037789877387695014, -0.023938601836562157, -0.011318358592689037, 0.035090286284685135, 0.049479931592941284, 0.010270174592733383, 0.004573233425617218, -0.07367046922445297, 0.018554236739873886, 0.06025563180446625, 0.03701474517583847, -0.051209185272455215, -0.014547531493008137, -0.017236890271306038, -0.010809763334691525, -0.0016532629961147904, -0.024152709171175957, -0.026084640994668007, -0.007211634889245033, 0.0251569002866745, -0.009882267564535141, -0.00043037161231040955, -0.04964953288435936, 0.0206528939306736, -0.024145347997546196, 0.004297011997550726, -0.029333041980862617, -0.04511294513940811, -0.049628064036369324, 0.050315286964178085, 0.04062940925359726, 0.03688240051269531, -0.01075503509491682, -0.0310924481600523, 0.04396799951791763, 0.01175993774086237, -0.008062366396188736, -0.05710901319980621, 0.0023300216998904943, -0.007794673088937998, 0.0010637011146172881, 0.04967884346842766, -0.018645113334059715, -0.050093017518520355, 0.03578466922044754, 0.01661674864590168, -0.0057005370035767555, 0.03639528527855873, -0.018118208274245262, 0.03468336910009384, 0.011495368555188179, 0.021153470501303673, 0.0565374456346035, 0.015083271078765392, -0.011410679668188095, -0.02890137955546379, -0.04113587364554405, 0.017226705327630043, -0.0023570097982883453, -0.03423134610056877, -0.059933796525001526, -0.005322576034814119, -0.007676656823605299, 0.01689683273434639, 0.0035401710774749517, 0.03336241468787193, -0.03793083131313324, -0.0026908565778285265, 0.027745120227336884, 0.006490756757557392, 0.008127936162054539, 0.01242588646709919, -0.0032056686468422413, 0.020114857703447342, -0.020059632137417793, -0.02643493562936783, 0.014026078395545483, -0.045576732605695724, 0.01287756022065878, 0.015764128416776657, -0.026359504088759422, 0.010555124841630459, -0.04180152341723442, -0.020734693855047226, -0.04643618315458298, -0.017194632440805435, 0.018432235345244408, 0.0025606437120586634, 0.050078317523002625, 0.019000278785824776, -0.00832042284309864, -0.03127265349030495, 0.0014354995219036937, -0.0034003618638962507, 0.06040557846426964, -0.05459907278418541, 0.028750691562891006, -0.02233165316283703, 0.005670769140124321, -0.057084277272224426, -0.040444374084472656, 0.0016753196250647306, 0.027297165244817734, -0.014796372503042221, -0.03457185998558998, -0.012159102596342564, -0.007123929914087057, -0.005846682470291853, 0.0028612359892576933, 0.07013817131519318, -0.0017738216556608677, -0.012039782479405403, 0.014073108322918415, 0.038877274841070175, 0.06287772208452225, -0.028465544804930687, 0.005126631818711758, 0.01973075047135353, -0.010274797677993774, -0.04407038167119026, 0.002396955853328109, -0.0007573800976388156, -0.0057655880227684975, 0.029941381886601448, -0.005201177205890417, 0.021709062159061432, 0.05922210216522217, -0.043558984994888306, -0.014588940888643265, 0.01041825208812952, -0.000580194522626698, -0.035918790847063065, -0.01227614376693964, -0.0065912650898098946, -0.0019359108991920948, -0.015673505142331123, -0.025187551975250244, -0.02496933378279209, -0.02630920149385929, -0.006361845415085554, 0.037532247602939606, -0.010313590057194233, -0.021036231890320778, 0.02458636462688446, 0.054680950939655304, -0.015158260241150856, 0.005969515535980463, -0.02589896135032177, 0.03247730806469917, 0.03261268511414528, -0.01285482943058014, -0.016071617603302002, 0.04259304329752922, 0.04716477170586586, -0.012359916232526302, 0.026610059663653374, -0.03759446740150452, 0.01599036157131195, 0.06158506125211716, -0.010809333063662052, 0.04619442671537399, 0.024120807647705078, 0.024039888754487038, -0.003506480948999524, -0.041393060237169266, -0.029271041974425316, 0.008773733861744404, -0.004443205893039703, 0.04534745216369629, -0.013315057381987572, -0.0013234121724963188, 0.02985014021396637, 0.001262608915567398, -0.013591298833489418, 0.059888143092393875, -0.020588679239153862, 0.039042145013809204, 0.022713935002684593, -0.019481664523482323, 0.0007772416574880481, 0.011376387439668179, -0.031174803152680397, 0.03568580001592636, -0.017187288030982018, -0.009466628544032574, 0.02063761278986931, 0.06723324954509735, -0.01984410732984543, -0.07198438793420792, -0.0028083249926567078, -0.052307501435279846, 0.00047585697029717267, 0.037592023611068726, -0.004742128308862448, 0.03400710970163345, 0.03524307906627655, 0.06111999601125717, 0.044880595058202744, 0.036151256412267685, -0.015106388367712498, -0.04255295917391777, -0.0010232808999717236, -0.031332828104496, -0.03695353493094444, 0.05755239352583885, -0.032141562551259995, -0.01313974428921938, 0.03757098317146301, -0.03405173495411873, 0.039086490869522095, 0.01739678718149662, 0.052026547491550446, -0.0032543358393013477, 0.0622042641043663, 0.010625806637108326, -0.006562492344528437, 0.014463336206972599, 0.000042222163756377995, 0.11174338310956955, 0.06699245423078537, 0.0291283056139946, -0.06864865869283676, 0.0009494207333773375, 0.0331692211329937, -0.03862060606479645, -0.012132617644965649, 0.018477823585271835, 0.03162659704685211, 0.03043374791741371, 0.03468030318617821, 0.0361587293446064, -0.02605932205915451, -0.015863515436649323, 0.035045791417360306, -0.0017572389915585518, -0.028171837329864502, 0.004948990419507027, 0.041863229125738144, 0.014650499448180199, -0.02516266144812107, -0.040630921721458435, 0.05209298059344292, -0.02935694344341755, -0.021147338673472404, -0.032749809324741364, -0.03219221904873848, 0.04378670081496239, -0.0038704141043126583, -0.015774833038449287, 0.007571002002805471, 0.02608652040362358, 0.005777253303676844, 0.0022343071177601814, 0.04321889579296112, 0.0006563529605045915, -0.035335443913936615, 0.027994409203529358, -0.013843039982020855, -0.007936115376651287, 0.0033745337277650833, 0.02374153584241867, -0.0017561246640980244, -0.04283751919865608, -0.06725429743528366, -0.03974924609065056, 0.045836012810468674, 0.007595050148665905, -0.05594151094555855, -0.0014571950305253267, -0.014123881235718727, 0.03198336437344551, -0.07154182344675064, 0.012085768394172192, -0.042253412306308746, 0.004076812881976366, -0.04053454101085663, 0.010069574229419231, -0.03370146453380585, 0.007247304543852806, 0.02920379303395748, 0.02010580524802208, 0.009695845656096935, -0.029954519122838974, -0.007511422503739595, -0.046874791383743286, 0.07391108572483063, 0.02029946632683277, -0.06046582758426666, -0.0002768466074485332, -0.049527980387210846, 0.009772561490535736, -0.008169654756784439, 0.01734856702387333, 0.0014186722692102194, 0.03661978989839554, 0.006394615396857262, -0.04206378757953644, -0.023669855669140816, -0.04915156587958336, -0.019245384261012077, -0.025773512199521065, 0.007343390490859747, -0.021317975595593452, -0.018051641061902046, 0.00891918409615755, 0.03687569499015808, 0.013298574835062027, 0.016473477706313133, 0.003280940465629101, 0.01769597828388214, 0.022408664226531982, -0.06329395622015, -0.032482340931892395, 0.015761176124215126, -0.02161056362092495, 0.034080248326063156, -0.00821631122380495, 0.06156324967741966, -0.006099436432123184, 0.028967086225748062, -0.02664988674223423, 0.03968092054128647, -0.03192480280995369, -0.014522366225719452, -0.02471901848912239, -0.0514189749956131, 0.0040780920535326, 0.03012831322848797, -0.014702477492392063, -0.03855303302407265, -0.023380132392048836, -0.025688813999295235, -0.030243361368775368, 0.018498273566365242, -0.0036590564996004105, -0.020268723368644714, -0.00948534905910492, -0.02577168494462967, 0.01727813482284546, -0.02890554629266262, 0.03287453576922417, 0.004669178742915392, 0.0033692270517349243, -0.027889210730791092, -0.007915462367236614, -0.03574424237012863, 0.028667094185948372, -0.020796960219740868, -0.01935368776321411, 0.01633867435157299, 0.057262640446424484, 0.038673460483551025, -0.02744465321302414, 0.008869204670190811, -0.015790093690156937, 0.06048845872282982, 0.01884128712117672, 0.0003001599106937647, 0.016732102259993553, -0.05075555294752121, -0.01784432679414749, -0.006555889267474413, -0.022117216140031815, 0.013158172369003296, -0.008835856802761555, -0.015154569409787655, -0.020186148583889008, 0.03188953921198845, -0.006194521673023701, -0.010782969184219837, -0.01614335924386978, 0.011830445379018784, 0.030271288007497787, -0.0062012337148189545, 0.019376179203391075, -0.014229434542357922, -0.036102257668972015, 0.031494323164224625, 0.011878885328769684, 0.029056832194328308, 0.005362774711102247, 0.030628841370344162, -0.03498521447181702, 0.030432265251874924, -0.008849643170833588, 0.013263318687677383, 0.03993507847189903, 0.06036954000592232, -0.031122315675020218, -0.0011893209302797914, -0.013995674438774586, 0.019514964893460274, -0.07984640449285507, -0.0035371994599699974, 0.027832001447677612, -0.03242620825767517, 0.03787999227643013, -0.0606379471719265, -0.0007484469097107649, 0.03031596913933754, -0.004878244362771511, 0.02343875728547573, -0.04265352338552475, -0.0018589223036542535, -0.043173953890800476, -0.02711227908730507, -0.05865958705544472, 0.007929348386824131, 0.03598656877875328, 0.004695673938840628, 0.04861869663000107, 0.021898964419960976, -0.06367819011211395, -0.024348057806491852, -0.005505172070115805, 0.01939183473587036, 0.027600040659308434, -0.08291260898113251, 0.01119814720004797, -0.02927354909479618, -0.013960440643131733, 0.014828724786639214, -0.054043304175138474, -0.01695438101887703, 0.02041276916861534, 0.0010474842274561524, 0.016817856580018997, 0.018178965896368027, 0.018927915021777153, -0.0054576946422457695, 0.03950441628694534, -0.014909997582435608, 0.02724040299654007, -0.01226083468645811, -0.0573197677731514, 0.04322483018040657, 0.030651062726974487, -0.020953979343175888, -0.016997966915369034, 0.0015765042044222355, -0.004583484493196011, -0.00865840632468462, -0.03644460067152977, -0.012843350879848003, 0.0009001954458653927, -0.05849450081586838, 0.024389168247580528, -0.05684330314397812, -0.011038661934435368, -0.001993117155507207, 0.02252814918756485, -0.011004388332366943, 0.0062923370860517025, -0.021938633173704147, -0.04764945060014725, 0.015082651749253273, -0.0032382113859057426, -0.02774297259747982, -0.039511729031801224, -0.013937482610344887, -0.020569929853081703, 0.01734801009297371, -0.022584525868296623, -0.028788866475224495, -0.006871816702187061, 0.04889807105064392, -0.025307461619377136, -0.006576853338629007, 0.004066454712301493, -0.005861723329871893, 0.00922247115522623, -0.10981687903404236, 0.014577546156942844, 0.021841591224074364, -0.03159814327955246, -0.04869460314512253, 0.006489323452115059, -0.02554614655673504, 0.047610875219106674, 0.019017543643712997, 0.010499117895960808, 0.031231829896569252, -0.0206332728266716, 0.01921611838042736, 0.01715785823762417, -0.05780687928199768, 0.040907226502895355, -0.0211896151304245, -0.026967186480760574, -0.03297719731926918, 0.009761873632669449, 0.020153257995843887, 0.007063540164381266, 0.010709374211728573, -0.005979589652270079, 0.01700587570667267, 0.02936611697077751, -0.0021948679350316525, -0.02247798815369606, -0.024133028462529182, -0.028453543782234192, 0.024227559566497803, -0.016208326444029808, 0.011419753544032574, -0.0015613577561452985, 0.015608545392751694, -0.06378315389156342, 0.01430007815361023, -0.021991655230522156, -0.041432078927755356, -0.010372190736234188, 0.020583178848028183, 0.03468801826238632, -0.04711524024605751, -0.0032233952078968287, -0.0073005687445402145, -0.06901849806308746, -0.01942768692970276, 0.006792884320020676, -0.016989750787615776, 0.05269331857562065, -0.02846963331103325, 0.02431521564722061, 0.008284286595880985, -0.039703723043203354, 0.02542833983898163, -0.0010642262641340494, 0.004193988628685474, 0.0003535740543156862, -0.0002501595299690962, 0.0014387646224349737, -0.06052982062101364, 0.019705362617969513, -0.031803783029317856, 0.03741138428449631, 0.016725996509194374, -0.015614147298038006, 0.03205592557787895, 0.016057712957262993, 0.004241995047777891, -0.014175173826515675, -0.022163091227412224, 0.04107075557112694, -0.0029588022734969854, -0.006506399251520634, -0.01944538950920105, -0.0013937443727627397, 0.01508297212421894, 0.026009365916252136, 0.014275822788476944, 0.01556947361677885, 0.006594147998839617, 0.031504444777965546, 0.004440874792635441, -0.013773228041827679, 0.052798718214035034, -0.014929763972759247, 0.01803814433515072, -0.0164012610912323, -0.01846347562968731, 0.024392643943428993, -0.05597376823425293, -0.034041378647089005, -0.04465840756893158, 0.02242117188870907, 0.010602886788547039, 0.01590374857187271, -0.029035786166787148, -0.014356669969856739, -0.014335013926029205, 0.04848780855536461, -0.04900812730193138, -0.027317669242620468, -0.002066602697595954, 0.005365478806197643, -0.005610351916402578, 0.012880991213023663 ]
<p>I try to model quasi-poisson family in bugs language, to handle overdispersion. According to <a href="http://www.mbr-pwrc.usgs.gov/software/kerybook/" rel="nofollow">Introduction to WinBUGS for ecologists</a>, this is done by:</p> <p>$log(\lambda_i) = f(x_i) + \epsilon_i$</p> <p>$N_i \sim Poiss(\lambda_i)$</p> <p>where $\epsilon_i$ does the overdispersion. This is equivalent to scenario 8 in <a href="http://www.esajournals.org/doi/abs/10.1890/10-1831.1" rel="nofollow">Lindén &amp; Mäntyniemi 2011</a>:</p> <p>$log(\lambda_i) = f(x_i)$</p> <p>$N_i \sim Poiss(\lambda_i \theta_i)$</p> <p>However, <strong>how do I get the "dispersion parameter for quasipoisson family"</strong>, as reported by GLM when using quasipoisson family?</p> <pre><code>&gt; summary(glm.fit.with.OD) Call: glm(formula = C.OD ~ x, family = quasipoisson) [...] (Dispersion parameter for quasipoisson family taken to be 1.470301) </code></pre> <p>Here I include full reproducible code, taken from <a href="http://www.mbr-pwrc.usgs.gov/software/kerybook/R_WB_code.txt" rel="nofollow">Introduction to WinBUGS for ecologists, see chapter 14.1</a> (slightly modified):</p> <pre><code>set.seed(123) ### 14.1. Overdispersion ### 14.1.2. Data generation n.site &lt;- 10 x &lt;- gl(n = 2, k = n.site, labels = c("grassland", "arable")) eps &lt;- rnorm(2*n.site, mean = 0, sd = 0.5)# Normal random effect lambda.OD &lt;- exp(0.69 +(0.92*(as.numeric(x)-1) + eps) ) lambda.Poisson &lt;- exp(0.69 +(0.92*(as.numeric(x)-1)) ) # For comparison C.OD &lt;- rpois(n = 2*n.site, lambda = lambda.OD) C.Poisson &lt;- rpois(n = 2*n.site, lambda = lambda.Poisson) par(mfrow = c(1,2)) boxplot(C.OD ~ x, col = "grey", xlab = "Land-use", main = "With OD", ylab = "Hare count", las = 1, ylim = c(0, max(C.OD))) boxplot(C.Poisson ~ x, col = "grey", xlab = "Land-use", main = "Without OD", ylab = "Hare count", las = 1, ylim = c(0, max(C.OD)) ) ### 14.1.3. Analysis using R glm.fit.no.OD &lt;- glm(C.OD ~ x, family = poisson) glm.fit.with.OD &lt;- glm(C.OD ~ x, family = quasipoisson) summary(glm.fit.no.OD) summary(glm.fit.with.OD) anova(glm.fit.no.OD, test = "Chisq") anova(glm.fit.with.OD, test = "F") ### 14.1.4. Analysis using WinBUGS # Define model sink("Poisson.OD.t.test.txt") cat(" model { # Priors alpha ~ dnorm(0,0.001) beta ~ dnorm(0,0.001) sigma ~ dunif(0, 10) tau &lt;- 1 / (sigma * sigma) maybe_overdisp &lt;- mean(exp_eps[]) # Likelihood for (i in 1:n) { C.OD[i] ~ dpois(lambda[i]) log(lambda[i]) &lt;- alpha + beta *x[i] + eps[i] eps[i] ~ dnorm(0, tau) exp_eps[i] &lt;- exp(eps[i]) } } ",fill=TRUE) sink() # Bundle data win.data &lt;- list(C.OD = C.OD, x = as.numeric(x)-1, n = length(x)) # Inits function inits &lt;- function(){ list(alpha=rlnorm(1), beta=rlnorm(1), sigma = rlnorm(1))} # Parameters to estimate params &lt;- c("lambda","alpha", "beta", "sigma", "maybe_overdisp") # MCMC settings nc &lt;- 3 # Number of chains ni &lt;- 30000 # Number of draws from posterior per chain nb &lt;- 10000 # Number of draws to discard as burn-in nt &lt;- 5 # Thinning rate # Start Gibbs sampling out &lt;- bugs(data=win.data, inits=inits, parameters.to.save=params, model.file="Poisson.OD.t.test.txt", n.thin=nt, n.chains=nc, n.burnin=nb, n.iter=ni, debug = TRUE) print(out, dig = 3) </code></pre> <p>Here is the output of the <code>glm()</code> in R:</p> <pre><code>&gt; summary(glm.fit.with.OD) Call: glm(formula = C.OD ~ x, family = quasipoisson) Deviance Residuals: Min 1Q Median 3Q Max -2.2945 -0.5905 -0.4348 1.0798 1.8159 Coefficients: Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(&gt;|t|) (Intercept) 0.4055 0.3131 1.295 0.21166 xarable 1.2622 0.3546 3.559 0.00224 ** --- Signif. codes: 0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1 (Dispersion parameter for quasipoisson family taken to be 1.470301) Null deviance: 51.032 on 19 degrees of freedom Residual deviance: 28.524 on 18 degrees of freedom AIC: NA Number of Fisher Scoring iterations: 5 </code></pre> <p>And here is the output of the jags model (using more iterations than in the above code):</p> <pre><code>&gt; print(out, dig = 3) Inference for Bugs model at "Poisson.OD.t.test.txt", fit using jags, 3 chains, each with 300000 iterations (first 100000 discarded), n.thin = 5 n.sims = 120000 iterations saved mu.vect sd.vect 2.5% 25% 50% 75% 97.5% Rhat n.eff alpha 0.275 0.324 -0.415 0.073 0.291 0.498 0.861 1.001 23000 beta 1.289 0.385 0.547 1.035 1.281 1.534 2.071 1.001 41000 lambda[1] 1.163 0.586 0.263 0.740 1.092 1.496 2.512 1.001 24000 lambda[2] 1.368 0.654 0.398 0.914 1.273 1.700 2.934 1.001 27000 lambda[3] 2.173 1.081 0.818 1.429 1.919 2.638 4.976 1.001 120000 lambda[4] 1.367 0.654 0.397 0.912 1.273 1.701 2.927 1.001 26000 lambda[5] 1.370 0.655 0.401 0.914 1.275 1.702 2.929 1.001 20000 lambda[6] 1.602 0.759 0.545 1.086 1.464 1.954 3.503 1.001 24000 lambda[7] 1.365 0.656 0.399 0.909 1.268 1.697 2.941 1.001 34000 lambda[8] 1.366 0.653 0.394 0.912 1.272 1.701 2.919 1.001 43000 lambda[9] 1.368 0.654 0.400 0.916 1.270 1.700 2.934 1.001 16000 lambda[10] 1.872 0.904 0.690 1.260 1.679 2.261 4.198 1.001 84000 lambda[11] 4.608 1.548 1.978 3.525 4.494 5.521 8.032 1.001 54000 lambda[12] 5.058 1.628 2.340 3.937 4.903 5.969 8.818 1.001 52000 lambda[13] 6.544 2.064 3.426 5.091 6.189 7.649 11.521 1.001 120000 lambda[14] 4.170 1.492 1.610 3.095 4.078 5.116 7.355 1.001 67000 lambda[15] 4.613 1.554 1.974 3.524 4.499 5.528 8.073 1.001 120000 lambda[16] 7.066 2.258 3.759 5.439 6.675 8.293 12.477 1.001 49000 lambda[17] 7.615 2.462 4.054 5.802 7.190 9.003 13.472 1.001 42000 lambda[18] 3.385 1.458 0.956 2.281 3.264 4.385 6.403 1.001 61000 lambda[19] 6.538 2.066 3.431 5.089 6.185 7.643 11.505 1.001 120000 lambda[20] 3.385 1.459 0.957 2.279 3.260 4.384 6.399 1.001 95000 maybe_overdisp 1.121 0.179 0.898 1.006 1.076 1.189 1.577 1.001 120000 sigma 0.465 0.236 0.051 0.301 0.449 0.606 0.983 1.001 27000 deviance 74.767 5.985 64.292 70.311 74.343 79.042 86.528 1.001 120000 For each parameter, n.eff is a crude measure of effective sample size, and Rhat is the potential scale reduction factor (at convergence, Rhat=1). DIC info (using the rule, pD = var(deviance)/2) pD = 17.9 and DIC = 92.7 DIC is an estimate of expected predictive error (lower deviance is better). </code></pre> <h3>Edit 2</h3> <p>Modified model:</p> <pre><code>model { # Priors alpha ~ dnorm(0,0.001) beta ~ dnorm(0,0.001) sigma ~ dunif(0, 10) tau &lt;- 1 / (sigma * sigma) maybe_overdisp &lt;- mean(exp_eps[]) # co mi poradili na stats.SE sigma2 &lt;- sigma*sigma kappa &lt;- exp(alpha + beta); mean.x &lt;- exp(alpha + 0.5*sigma2); vari &lt;- kappa*exp(sigma2/2)+kappa*kappa*exp(2*sigma2) - kappa*kappa*exp(sigma2) DI &lt;- vari/mean.x # Likelihood for (i in 1:n) { C.OD[i] ~ dpois(lambda[i]) log(lambda[i]) &lt;- alpha + beta *x[i] + eps[i] eps[i] ~ dnorm(0, tau) exp_eps[i] &lt;- exp(eps[i]) } } </code></pre> <p>output:</p> <pre><code>&gt; print(out, dig = 6) Inference for Bugs model at "Poisson.OD.t.test.txt", fit using jags, 3 chains, each with 30000 iterations (first 10000 discarded), n.thin = 5 n.sims = 12000 iterations saved mu.vect sd.vect 2.5% 25% 50% 75% 97.5% Rhat n.eff DI 20.691012 574.969428 2.748532 4.908448 7.479553 13.014255 64.410436 1.001834 2100 alpha 0.276339 0.319067 -0.410506 0.081158 0.293487 0.491261 0.859875 1.001180 6500 beta 1.285987 0.378753 0.556607 1.042379 1.276188 1.523705 2.054021 1.001084 9500 lambda[1] 1.173864 0.584403 0.268459 0.749624 1.106648 1.508932 2.499185 1.001344 4300 lambda[2] 1.364399 0.653852 0.395182 0.913774 1.272952 1.693450 2.944849 1.001782 2200 lambda[3] 2.148461 1.056564 0.814731 1.422458 1.892689 2.620223 4.912488 1.001393 3900 lambda[4] 1.373973 0.651289 0.404761 0.922161 1.283126 1.707821 2.930640 1.001074 10000 lambda[5] 1.364438 0.646131 0.397013 0.915541 1.271812 1.700321 2.908050 1.000922 12000 lambda[6] 1.596684 0.737480 0.562846 1.098588 1.463223 1.931152 3.472518 1.001139 7500 lambda[7] 1.372055 0.667968 0.394750 0.912321 1.270109 1.702314 3.030247 1.001004 12000 lambda[8] 1.368805 0.641905 0.393292 0.926187 1.281149 1.694738 2.933341 1.001159 7000 lambda[9] 1.367516 0.644055 0.410916 0.914202 1.279055 1.693786 2.892084 1.001237 5500 lambda[10] 1.874077 0.903156 0.706316 1.261625 1.683053 2.256230 4.224203 1.001380 4000 lambda[11] 4.604620 1.551257 1.983965 3.515142 4.484644 5.530132 8.040010 1.000890 12000 lambda[12] 5.052838 1.631220 2.325490 3.949769 4.904707 5.942355 8.784829 1.000883 12000 lambda[13] 6.506786 2.050675 3.424231 5.043272 6.159473 7.621714 11.341993 1.000896 12000 lambda[14] 4.168782 1.468719 1.617240 3.104178 4.099795 5.114893 7.324785 1.002270 1400 lambda[15] 4.588128 1.529048 1.986595 3.537436 4.479550 5.476045 7.997842 1.000895 12000 lambda[16] 7.035670 2.235785 3.776619 5.428774 6.617842 8.235651 12.389102 1.001082 9600 lambda[17] 7.586794 2.444835 4.078003 5.780102 7.145878 8.986080 13.364148 1.000973 12000 lambda[18] 3.413945 1.459583 0.955955 2.306502 3.321237 4.407808 6.427175 1.002377 1300 lambda[19] 6.559620 2.077231 3.418885 5.098825 6.196538 7.664223 11.574183 1.001324 4400 lambda[20] 3.391437 1.459840 0.949251 2.262276 3.281995 4.407545 6.371617 1.001482 3300 maybe_overdisp 1.119677 0.178304 0.900895 1.006214 1.073253 1.185895 1.565368 1.002841 1000 sigma 0.458185 0.235224 0.048157 0.294464 0.441186 0.597933 0.972298 1.009139 960 deviance 74.818941 5.985537 64.100886 70.435067 74.417487 79.115472 86.443865 1.001312 4600 For each parameter, n.eff is a crude measure of effective sample size, and Rhat is the potential scale reduction factor (at convergence, Rhat=1). DIC info (using the rule, pD = var(deviance)/2) pD = 17.9 and DIC = 92.7 DIC is an estimate of expected predictive error (lower deviance is better). </code></pre>
36,254
[ 0.020125919952988625, -0.011031013913452625, 0.0496356375515461, -0.03227045014500618, -0.008865189738571644, 0.0008137910044752061, -0.032139550894498825, 0.018819594755768776, 0.006185226608067751, -0.04816799610853195, 0.02280448190867901, 0.053490329533815384, 0.08265987038612366, -0.001194832264445722, 0.03404325991868973, -0.002904396504163742, -0.022098969668149948, 0.01620488613843918, -0.005324661266058683, -0.008575478568673134, 0.008047324605286121, 0.0007009915425442159, -0.024185121059417725, -0.011454206891357899, 0.014792555011808872, 0.016436459496617317, 0.028230858966708183, -0.010782669298350811, 0.01948809064924717, 0.04181292653083801, -0.053755417466163635, -0.00836488138884306, 0.014941368252038956, 0.014358822256326675, 0.041202835738658905, 0.025081638246774673, -0.011094402521848679, -0.003830814501270652, -0.015360238961875439, 0.03711516037583351, -0.03208468481898308, -0.015934789553284645, 0.020123692229390144, 0.03482907637953758, -0.026531532406806946, 0.020832516252994537, -0.006066073197871447, -0.00027723319362848997, 0.07357022166252136, -0.029808152467012405, 0.024368833750486374, -0.027491744607686996, 0.03261122852563858, 0.07037495821714401, 0.017113439738750458, 0.008484497666358948, 0.09995992481708527, 0.04326954856514931, -0.015237626619637012, -0.05877358838915825, -0.020238514989614487, -0.015806935727596283, 0.006381727755069733, -0.035799991339445114, -0.007367623504251242, 0.003572572721168399, -0.013040883466601372, -0.0389973446726799, 0.029333289712667465, 0.015211157500743866, 0.056383419781923294, -0.012577948160469532, 0.04062999039888382, 0.022660503163933754, 0.020659035071730614, 0.003854273119941354, -0.012693333439528942, -0.0030782565008848906, 0.021874025464057922, 0.04590447247028351, -0.021459538489580154, 0.02785087749361992, -0.020362738519906998, 0.011320056393742561, 0.010051514953374863, -0.03920358791947365, 0.07409965991973877, -0.019755277782678604, -0.005692117847502232, 0.05673043057322502, -0.028795555233955383, 0.02871634066104889, 0.03411715105175972, -0.014301197603344917, -0.01680525206029415, 0.043226417154073715, 0.002797838067635894, -0.023685283958911896, -0.021325021982192993, -0.0016349407378584146, -0.03624984622001648, -0.06136441230773926, 0.006399259902536869, 0.04844871163368225, -0.02646535634994507, -0.030672157183289528, -0.0198605265468359, -0.02615751512348652, -0.0521073080599308, -0.056657824665308, 0.0022635916247963905, 0.046344492584466934, 0.009815748780965805, -0.011166198179125786, 0.0020248990040272474, -0.034511320292949677, 0.017926814034581184, -0.010833954438567162, 0.042014699429273605, 0.0546257346868515, 0.033968329429626465, -0.01921386457979679, 0.01074498426169157, -0.020036958158016205, -0.014790949411690235, -0.009601680561900139, 0.004853745456784964, 0.006566428579390049, -0.023895619437098503, 0.03904334828257561, -0.025350993499159813, 0.009225894697010517, 0.06437259167432785, 0.025226328521966934, 0.010174503549933434, -0.004447475541383028, -0.07790534943342209, -0.05393174663186073, 0.057014744728803635, 0.006277186330407858, 0.05032920092344284, -0.06591855734586716, -0.0161348395049572, 0.014814400114119053, -0.003971532918512821, 0.017098309472203255, 0.03777259960770607, 0.02838231809437275, 0.028335800394415855, 0.001990589080378413, -0.021417507901787758, -0.013026165775954723, -0.016633400693535805, -0.020080847665667534, -0.02145318128168583, -0.1045791283249855, 0.012181003578007221, 0.015876224264502525, -0.02782239019870758, 0.018100880086421967, 0.01764228567481041, 0.0032596683595329523, -0.013367033563554287, -0.061574727296829224, -0.0094760712236166, -0.038163866847753525, 0.03716672211885452, -0.00949142687022686, 0.003629471408203244, 0.002916037105023861, -0.034620217978954315, -0.00939933955669403, -0.017744343727827072, 0.03866905719041824, 0.036280557513237, -0.02239023894071579, 0.03799312189221382, -0.05542946979403496, -0.004859852604568005, 0.00544565636664629, -0.033283915370702744, -0.015914583578705788, 0.0023628470953553915, -0.016252988949418068, 0.03498543053865433, 0.016444599255919456, -0.002029474824666977, 0.014219719916582108, 0.039298053830862045, -0.04735944792628288, -0.059384558349847794, 0.00882649328559637, -0.02769976481795311, 0.036707330495119095, 0.0014335877494886518, 0.03496579825878143, -0.01873643696308136, 0.013375204056501389, 0.027648992836475372, -0.001479662605561316, -0.03521840646862984, -0.00332326116040349, 0.030506806448101997, -0.031305670738220215, -0.006818679161369801, 0.05515827611088753, 0.0520353801548481, -0.03470383957028389, 0.05126144737005234, -0.010380638763308525, -0.019502118229866028, 0.0013678409159183502, -0.026985080912709236, 0.009391486644744873, -0.028339937329292297, -0.03167462721467018, 0.03885216638445854, 0.03903696686029434, 0.018040506169199944, 0.024557100608944893, -0.031594108790159225, 0.027075864374637604, 0.09253381937742233, -0.007602490484714508, -0.024203721433877945, -0.009409275837242603, -0.03343074396252632, 0.011003008112311363, -0.03017914481461048, -0.009465290233492851, -0.040863290429115295, 0.0018632598221302032, 0.041356153786182404, 0.002304636174812913, -0.03196939826011658, -0.02710314281284809, 0.06700386852025986, 0.02072310447692871, 0.020989224314689636, 0.03619313985109329, -0.018619805574417114, -0.022812221199274063, 0.03785431757569313, 0.020970242097973824, 0.017106635496020317, -0.01602235808968544, 0.030207796022295952, -0.02325577661395073, 0.023496832698583603, -0.046876173466444016, -0.005022862460464239, 0.031568825244903564, 0.047428444027900696, -0.03425171598792076, -0.05033215507864952, 0.0069514974020421505, 0.05162333324551582, -0.002926023444160819, 0.03745827451348305, 0.03401946648955345, 0.03104245848953724, 0.0065178293734788895, -0.015037650242447853, -0.014854846522212029, 0.013028159737586975, 0.014657039195299149, -0.021206246688961983, -0.00888786930590868, -0.001282022101804614, -0.03596988320350647, 0.021709376946091652, -0.053204528987407684, -0.020963381975889206, -0.025177892297506332, 0.019663354381918907, 0.03752891346812248, 0.04223743453621864, -0.02333236299455166, -0.033406153321266174, -0.029016058892011642, -0.04270986467599869, -0.011496063321828842, 0.03540973737835884, 0.023642675951123238, -0.05569615960121155, 0.014500965364277363, -0.035581376403570175, 0.010538384318351746, 0.027514418587088585, -0.015899404883384705, -0.04938327521085739, 0.024981379508972168, 0.006749200634658337, -0.0018203731160610914, -0.016450246796011925, -0.05460388585925102, -0.032642852514982224, 0.0005677303415723145, -0.04144229739904404, 0.05246004834771156, -0.04157140851020813, -0.05032484605908394, 0.005256203003227711, -0.06753355264663696, -0.02295197732746601, -0.013327134773135185, 0.00471516652032733, -0.012387746013700962, 0.019453395158052444, 0.01211385615170002, 0.03453124314546585, -0.007578371558338404, -0.013769601471722126, -0.0538531057536602, -0.07438060641288757, 0.008647635579109192, 0.01836359314620495, 0.05336429551243782, -0.020456794649362564, -0.020813144743442535, 0.0886467918753624, 0.0243610218167305, 0.017438512295484543, -0.04662065953016281, 0.025310443714261055, -0.0026843524537980556, -0.03662785142660141, 0.049307841807603836, -0.003182443557307124, 0.019440753385424614, 0.06353774666786194, -0.03054622933268547, 0.034034933894872665, 0.027859775349497795, -0.02420857548713684, 0.009218117222189903, 0.016166262328624725, -0.015602396801114082, 0.0006454021204262972, 0.04113130643963814, 0.02146882750093937, 0.028437267988920212, 0.02069966308772564, -0.018513988703489304, 0.02475845441222191, 0.0054135313257575035, -0.05320771411061287, -0.00637437216937542, 0.03370623663067818, 0.0049187554977834225, -0.061418913304805756, -0.002975085051730275, -0.0019482200732454658, -0.08379244059324265, -0.010491842404007912, 0.010932354256510735, 0.05888150632381439, -0.0021145641803741455, -0.02216339111328125, 0.03471015393733978, 0.037128373980522156, -0.01570049673318863, 0.007485716138035059, -0.036179978400468826, -0.009427935816347599, 0.01696711778640747, -0.000780319853220135, 0.012288539670407772, 0.026750268414616585, 0.049574147909879684, -0.014384722337126732, -0.031466953456401825, -0.011165517382323742, 0.002017023740336299, 0.001771237119100988, 0.00516406400129199, -0.012367064133286476, 0.0026749714743345976, 0.011189915239810944, 0.04075280576944351, -0.03529402241110802, -0.0298591461032629, 0.0028253125492483377, 0.01270222570747137, -0.0186064001172781, 0.023168053478002548, -0.014176543802022934, -0.022111903876066208, 0.013416355475783348, -0.059606608003377914, 0.03964966908097267, 0.014005119912326336, 0.03888276219367981, 0.0055601573549211025, 0.0090022636577487, -0.02257698029279709, 0.04450394585728645, -0.013141746632754803, -0.016092490404844284, -0.02828211523592472, 0.03300001099705696, 0.005255090072751045, -0.02785142883658409, 0.02346741408109665, 0.040526919066905975, -0.0024305442348122597, -0.008120113983750343, -0.010727121494710445, 0.015942798927426338, 0.0011301726335659623, 0.010461983270943165, 0.007103690877556801, 0.03541778400540352, -0.06414059549570084, 0.009146824479103088, 0.025612210854887962, 0.02545079030096531, 0.07795614004135132, 0.006063925568014383, -0.004960646852850914, -0.022672466933727264, -0.0071707190945744514, -0.003943924326449633, 0.029926296323537827, 0.003861777251586318, 0.02250595949590206, 0.07431595772504807, 0.01442199107259512, -0.026690877974033356, 0.019690293818712234, 0.03374391049146652, -0.0028790368232876062, 0.02168499492108822, 0.03083008900284767, -0.016885478049516678, 0.0036246273666620255, 0.02210613712668419, 0.012929783202707767, 0.020245522260665894, -0.045111432671546936, 0.006669255439192057, 0.06230045109987259, -0.01279290672391653, -0.037763141095638275, -0.020851943641901016, -0.018615903332829475, 0.020003579556941986, -0.018912233412265778, -0.02489836886525154, -0.012227289378643036, 0.013067485764622688, 0.004640416707843542, 0.035777393728494644, -0.02197663113474846, -0.03360680490732193, -0.07316027581691742, 0.03717070445418358, 0.022450750693678856, 0.0012383685680106282, 0.0016722346190363169, -0.046175554394721985, -0.01968192309141159, 0.008362287655472755, -0.029084699228405952, 0.006938993465155363, -0.009554795920848846, 0.04179326817393303, -0.0097648398950696, -0.04305728152394295, -0.07288943976163864, 0.022032521665096283, -0.0012583116767928004, 0.022689107805490494, -0.014829378575086594, -0.006159635726362467, -0.01742253266274929, 0.015499086119234562, 0.0014103122521191835, 0.05891713872551918, -0.03570645675063133, -0.05161071568727493, 0.028260471299290657, -0.012416250072419643, -0.014432177878916264, -0.04134555160999298, 0.0180197861045599, -0.008310407400131226, 0.04646870493888855, 0.04901563376188278, -0.019528264179825783, -0.05084548518061638, 0.00028579297941178083, 0.04682835936546326, -0.008428060449659824, -0.028021348640322685, -0.026355141773819923, 0.03889298811554909, 0.03175783157348633, -0.035950347781181335, 0.05704045668244362, 0.030696680769324303, -0.011066201142966747, 0.0238505769520998, -0.08981908857822418, -0.021085664629936218, -0.04900350794196129, -0.044289350509643555, -0.03846309706568718, 0.033596016466617584, -0.028434043750166893, 0.038638874888420105, -0.007480100728571415, -0.0024353857152163982, -0.048866644501686096, -0.022153742611408234, 0.005587378982454538, 0.011986475437879562, -0.019470874220132828, 0.034686971455812454, -0.007352591957896948, 0.015532383695244789, -0.009702644310891628, 0.005094412248581648, 0.012240373529493809, -0.04048292711377144, -0.029783815145492554, 0.037104636430740356, -0.051227521151304245, 0.0070472960360348225, -0.02887401357293129, 0.0044168406166136265, 0.0015127190854400396, -0.003758280072361231, 0.012883862480521202, 0.023071985691785812, 0.036409471184015274, 0.004217018373310566, -0.04093925282359123, -0.017755310982465744, 0.010219420306384563, 0.0073030367493629456, 0.028212927281856537, 0.00029826676473021507, -0.01731456071138382, 0.013433592393994331, 0.01453028991818428, -0.06750406324863434, 0.003360884264111519, 0.015751603990793228, -0.021623831242322922, -0.04057818651199341, -0.042304035276174545, -0.033521104604005814, -0.008984765969216824, -0.029665548354387283, -0.00537340110167861, 0.06891018897294998, -0.04497567564249039, -0.0028711932245641947, -0.02658187411725521, 0.015273984521627426, 0.06187683716416359, -0.024862464517354965, 0.001504099927842617, 0.05408809706568718, -0.007890160195529461, -0.018522799015045166, 0.033116456121206284, 0.004146866966038942, -0.017606817185878754, -0.03272038698196411, -0.01251057256013155, -0.005449242889881134, 0.010653939098119736, 0.009102468378841877, -0.045484546571969986, -0.024691343307495117, -0.0032715206034481525, 0.023957645520567894, -0.007331866305321455, -0.023843824863433838, -0.00575431389734149, 0.012879690155386925, -0.0691426694393158, 0.008196936920285225, -0.029063045978546143, -0.012083150446414948, 0.024270886555314064, -0.028187260031700134, 0.025546090677380562, 0.034513283520936966, 0.1054428368806839, 0.0018338338704779744, -0.033224597573280334, 0.030167097225785255, -0.020706364884972572, 0.02788189798593521, 0.008268524892628193, 0.015973912551999092, 0.0068186610005795956, 0.03057010844349861, -0.019905010238289833, -0.02460995689034462, -0.0714954286813736, 0.014595510438084602, 0.019537407904863358, 0.008378916420042515, 0.014239695854485035, 0.012866748496890068, -0.03398262336850166, -0.0126572260633111, -0.0572764053940773, 0.003074915613979101, 0.02188856527209282, -0.002742299810051918, 0.0401754193007946, -0.02462775446474552, 0.002439105184748769, 0.04746119678020477, 0.02232043445110321, 0.015365980565547943, 0.031434591859579086, -0.023099999874830246, 0.009560071863234043, -0.03928598389029503, -0.03218242526054382, -0.015567273832857609, 0.048237401992082596, -0.0339505672454834, 0.006056488491594791, -0.014543416909873486, -0.027965301647782326, 0.023112483322620392, 0.03299662470817566, 0.006644519045948982, -0.031102392822504044, -0.02434930019080639, -0.03821523115038872, 0.039085857570171356, 0.031999390572309494, -0.004050008952617645, 0.030111921951174736, 0.003027331316843629, 0.0037087600212544203, -0.011886954307556152, 0.024957753717899323, -0.03818676620721817, -0.06732314825057983, 0.007127223536372185, -0.02152284048497677, -0.03644115850329399, 0.05241409316658974, -0.003031314117833972, -0.023644719272851944, 0.014403830282390118, -0.01691647432744503, 0.04166203364729881, 0.015206542797386646, 0.032854534685611725, 0.0005953689105808735, 0.10837925225496292, -0.0009144436335191131, -0.0012729590525850654, -0.02829987369477749, -0.05393064767122269, 0.16884203255176544, 0.03563593327999115, 0.031680893152952194, -0.02433791570365429, -0.012695224024355412, 0.02364841103553772, -0.006442181766033173, -0.02743401937186718, -0.05030810832977295, 0.034968625754117966, -0.019642621278762817, 0.034302160143852234, 0.04896686598658562, 0.00046393871889449656, -0.01894211955368519, 0.048289909958839417, -0.03537977486848831, -0.02765442058444023, 0.018519259989261627, -0.0005229325033724308, 0.013938849791884422, -0.011252325028181076, -0.018593057990074158, -0.00037004664773121476, 0.01425895094871521, 0.03553299978375435, -0.037456680089235306, -0.012055846862494946, -0.04135170951485634, -0.027045056223869324, -0.033298905938863754, -0.040480419993400574, 0.021429458633065224, -0.021146269515156746, 0.02506296895444393, -0.017579281702637672, 0.02146913670003414, -0.04491642490029335, 0.018110526725649834, 0.03608238697052002, -0.006194546818733215, 0.03355299308896065, 0.029513906687498093, 0.014047767035663128, -0.0463811419904232, -0.04384962096810341, -0.01248109620064497, 0.03392810374498367, -0.024003611877560616, 0.02528190053999424, 0.021851513534784317, -0.009188992902636528, -0.007612629793584347, -0.010736262425780296, 0.028725584968924522, -0.004039669409394264, 0.03641495108604431, -0.00942227616906166, -0.053237851709127426, -0.003242016304284334, -0.0049336194060742855, 0.0042916336096823215, 0.0513102225959301, 0.010649572126567364, -0.028162002563476562, -0.026290040463209152, -0.03672860190272331, 0.03868086263537407, 0.0072045535780489445, 0.017532873898744583, -0.010944420471787453, -0.01944277249276638, 0.006115416996181011, -0.015582778491079807, 0.007953254505991936, -0.02288740873336792, 0.034162525087594986, -0.006534361746162176, -0.012084059417247772, -0.026019060984253883, -0.04059452563524246, 0.010279995389282703, -0.04352091997861862, -0.0015305831329897046, -0.045273393392562866, -0.04537687078118324, 0.0053751105442643166, 0.06230362504720688, 0.03169907629489899, 0.026617929339408875, -0.014317134395241737, 0.05551335588097572, 0.013552356511354446, -0.043784163892269135, -0.033102571964263916, -0.0037218972574919462, -0.013435635715723038, -0.0242338627576828, 0.0038552498444914818, 0.039324771612882614, 0.02140951156616211, 0.05308390036225319, -0.007613218855112791, 0.013591050170361996, 0.0018498459830880165, 0.022936856374144554, 0.010029727593064308, -0.04477907344698906, 0.006605417933315039, -0.007644182536751032, -0.032970018684864044, -0.03193679451942444, 0.009749868884682655, -0.009419061243534088, -0.01683172956109047, 0.020689433440566063, -0.016185978427529335, -0.08926407992839813, 0.0023736166767776012, -0.05392732471227646, 0.003757537342607975, 0.026091424748301506, -0.01530191209167242, 0.0011569857597351074, -0.018139712512493134, -0.025058235973119736, -0.00690924096852541, -0.028881726786494255, -0.001616014982573688, -0.02362838014960289, 0.004685448948293924, 0.021499723196029663, 0.00732327438890934, 0.03472214192152023, 0.03841813653707504, 0.022277509793639183, 0.02570836991071701, 0.02998272515833378, -0.007456426043063402, 0.004089938942342997, 0.011251200921833515, -0.04603410139679909, -0.025969740003347397, 0.04176441580057144, -0.004419778008013964, 0.0519198402762413, -0.005083343014121056, 0.013031499460339546, -0.08388517051935196, 0.010513854213058949, -0.0028685147408396006, 0.005124829709529877, 0.016910403966903687, -0.0035153774078935385, -0.012036299332976341, -0.022626666352152824, -0.0027797273360192776, 0.03306732326745987, -0.006792649161070585, 0.02236202172935009, 0.03406990319490433, -0.016941111534833908, -0.029208337888121605, 0.02802686206996441, -0.06232098862528801, 0.015550516545772552, -0.02676350437104702, 0.021504081785678864, 0.013638950884342194, 0.06802058964967728, -0.01873164251446724, 0.03309830650687218, -0.04945843666791916, 0.006685667671263218, -0.08925257623195648, -0.05040033906698227, 0.014790344052016735, 0.026769595220685005, 0.02854308672249317, -0.04481271654367447, -0.019517282024025917, 0.04975209757685661, -0.01931624300777912, 0.010353774763643742, 0.02836913801729679, 0.02749793976545334, -0.05102313309907913, 0.0007895578746683896, -0.04369394853711128, 0.003928139340132475, 0.05434703081846237, 0.03437461331486702, 0.04192600026726723, 0.027937596663832664, 0.0008343866211362183, -0.05389648303389549, -0.023460783064365387, -0.031374167650938034, 0.025838105008006096, -0.02940312586724758, 0.01994558796286583, -0.024275243282318115, 0.022856151685118675, 0.006434307433664799, -0.0029841430950909853, -0.01273086853325367, -0.0029668963979929686, 0.05331408604979515, 0.02043962851166725, 0.048674728721380234, 0.05206400901079178, -0.006934299133718014, 0.029240475967526436, 0.010625229217112064, -0.005695813801139593, 0.029484739527106285, -0.026270991191267967, 0.003924262709915638, 0.01949443854391575, -0.02436646819114685, -0.030616864562034607, 0.06795281916856766, 0.0017963508144021034, 0.004917473532259464, 0.026158710941672325, 0.03191692754626274, -0.009485823102295399, -0.018370961770415306, 0.006368797272443771, -0.027084151282906532, 0.03593834489583969, 0.04836437478661537, 0.031288355588912964, -0.020415591076016426, -0.00606924993917346, -0.045184265822172165, -0.021453984081745148, -0.04945477843284607, -0.003362403716892004, -0.011486576870083809, -0.04022113233804703, 0.01794162392616272, -0.022512344643473625, 0.02399742230772972, -0.008133728988468647, 0.011165708303451538, -0.04198826476931572, 0.049083322286605835, -0.02495141513645649, -0.007857641205191612, -0.00887968111783266, 0.005128571297973394, 0.053751375526189804, -0.039718419313430786, 0.04957795888185501, 0.0153137082234025, -0.02862779051065445, -0.026577293872833252, -0.020342281088232994, 0.009664231911301613, 0.031025327742099762, 0.015406664460897446, -0.013111765496432781, -0.046127453446388245, 0.011649315245449543, 0.05645699054002762, 0.020526142790913582, -0.04819469526410103, 0.04033983498811722, -0.0005949354381300509, -0.027647126466035843, -0.009826244786381721, 0.01707664504647255, -0.008014436811208725, 0.0014246463542804122, 0.03088974393904209, 0.02429312840104103, -0.01334192231297493, 0.01774931326508522, -0.044970784336328506, 0.016736291348934174, -0.003418043488636613, -0.023581570014357567, 0.0569022037088871, -0.015097054652869701, -0.02127314731478691, 0.02945290319621563, -0.00044821453047916293, -0.03563106805086136, 0.046563103795051575, -0.04263227432966232, -0.006441150326281786, 0.031273189932107925, 0.006852379068732262, 0.024095214903354645, -0.0768878161907196, -0.0007957148482091725, 0.015759345144033432, -0.006138653960078955, -0.031619057059288025, 0.019268754869699478, 0.029948722571134567, 0.05945446714758873, 0.004416980314999819, 0.028480833396315575, 0.008768736384809017, -0.013200782239437103, 0.021729424595832825, 0.0345303937792778, 0.0027922147419303656, -0.000871061987709254, 0.028435613960027695, 0.011771241202950478, 0.03621367737650871, 0.03953876346349716, -0.0005870344466529787, 0.06570279598236084, -0.006685387343168259, -0.018833912909030914, 0.05370640382170677, -0.006487769540399313, 0.022019442170858383, 0.05174042657017708, -0.010181885212659836, 0.05417978763580322, -0.014969756826758385, -0.0019413407426327467, 0.0029727129731327295, -0.00992424413561821, -0.018994025886058807, 0.024959160014986992, -0.027255509048700333, 0.03249765560030937, 0.005114791914820671, 0.0025857838336378336, 0.019531290978193283, 0.004536251537501812, 0.005525624845176935, -0.025136545300483704, 0.03302881866693497, 0.044443193823099136, 0.02022474817931652, -0.010105876252055168, 0.014751880429685116, -0.018813440576195717, -0.00966752041131258, 0.03197778761386871, -0.0002541148569434881, 0.006463023833930492, -0.07485087215900421, -0.037414517253637314, 0.020812850445508957, 0.040454402565956116, -0.032673608511686325, 0.01872328482568264, -0.03670420125126839, -0.004178589675575495, -0.009916660375893116, -0.06550642102956772 ]
<p>I've tried to create three models (using R): an intercept only linear regression, a simple mixed effects regression and a by-subject effects mixed effects regression.</p> <p>An intercept only regression models the grand mean of a response variable plus error. In <code>mtcars</code>, the variable <code>drat</code> may be considered a response variable. In the model below, have I correctly modelled the grand mean of <code>drat</code>, plus error?</p> <pre><code>interceptOnly &lt;- lm(drat ~ 1, data=mtcars) </code></pre> <p>A simple mixed effects regression models the grand mean of a response variable, plus subject deviation, plus error. In <code>mtcars</code>, <code>drat</code> may be considered a response variable and <code>cyl</code> a subject deviation. In the model below, have I correctly modelled the grand mean of <code>drat</code>, plus the deviation of <code>cyl</code> from <code>drat</code>, plus error?</p> <pre><code>library(lme4) simpleMixedEffects &lt;- lmer(drat ~ (1|cyl), data=mtcars) </code></pre> <p>A by-subject effects mixed effects regression models the grand mean of a response variable, plus subject deviation, plus condition effect, plus error. In <code>mtcars</code>, <code>drat</code> may be considered a response variable, <code>cyl</code> a subject deviation and <code>wt</code> a condition effect. In the model below, have I correctly modelled the grand mean of <code>drat</code>, plus the deviation of <code>cyl</code> from <code>drat</code>, plus the effect of <code>wt</code>, plus error?</p> <pre><code>bySubjectMixedEffects &lt;- lmer(drat ~ (1|cyl) + wt, data=mtcars) </code></pre> <p>I have one further question: </p> <p>How can I model a by-subject varying condition effect model. This is a mixed effects model which models the grand mean of a response variable, plus group deviation from grand mean (random effect), plus condition effect (fixed effect), plus group deviation from condition effect (random effect), plus error. Could someone provide R code that outputs a "by-subject varying condition effect model"?</p>
36,255
[ -0.04817330464720726, 0.028539875522255898, 0.012492282316088676, -0.007750948425382376, 0.019311659038066864, 0.03909529745578766, -0.014739981852471828, 0.0018808546010404825, 0.04910127446055412, 0.019010530784726143, 0.07653307169675827, 0.018030330538749695, 0.0825573205947876, -0.008815188892185688, 0.030491027981042862, 0.023675205186009407, 0.0020095023792237043, -0.0022550683934241533, 0.015914909541606903, 0.00041659927228465676, 0.024273745715618134, -0.01001711469143629, -0.0011678464943543077, 0.002233924577012658, -0.01743696816265583, 0.02223183773458004, 0.03813382610678673, -0.033747538924217224, -0.004177370574325323, -0.003218321828171611, -0.038777295500040054, -0.010998076759278774, 0.01644442044198513, 0.02004603110253811, 0.0016187533037737012, 0.03542323410511017, -0.009694033302366734, 0.00016086484538391232, -0.0027984068728983402, 0.028046831488609314, 0.006620813626796007, -0.02092963084578514, -0.006112564355134964, 0.021201400086283684, -0.01653141714632511, -0.00977540947496891, -0.00328801479190588, 0.004529038444161415, 0.08230278640985489, -0.015428796410560608, 0.06918520480394363, -0.011267113499343395, 0.007296716794371605, -0.002453066874295473, -0.046881452202796936, 0.01666678860783577, 0.07695478200912476, 0.09007083624601364, 0.009402411058545113, -0.07337520271539688, -0.03292892500758171, -0.03853144496679306, 0.02052021212875843, -0.0014033042825758457, -0.05916299670934677, -0.02273792028427124, 0.04642266780138016, -0.0043183318339288235, 0.058203279972076416, -0.013531379401683807, 0.03270459547638893, -0.013793746009469032, -0.0012393547222018242, -0.006638028658926487, 0.03813475742936134, -0.007085252087563276, -0.007643462158739567, 0.0009430397767573595, 0.022753238677978516, 0.03232383728027344, -0.03905577212572098, 0.010384038090705872, 0.010494931600987911, 0.011271280236542225, 0.0016974881291389465, -0.022001191973686218, 0.0515635684132576, 0.03813676908612251, 0.03830213472247124, 0.020265158265829086, -0.03252857178449631, 0.014255859889090061, 0.048709768801927567, 0.00852137804031372, -0.011660116724669933, 0.06450293213129044, -0.015987206250429153, 0.017609450966119766, 0.02997192181646824, -0.019658206030726433, -0.04718698933720589, -0.03719187155365944, 0.002006458817049861, 0.052160777151584625, -0.04381078481674194, -0.03015163354575634, -0.018538139760494232, -0.015056039206683636, -0.013087082654237747, -0.02882302924990654, 0.0018642200157046318, 0.05661281943321228, -0.020965417847037315, -0.001668591983616352, 0.0106095802038908, -0.04467009752988815, -0.007789298426359892, -0.020260589197278023, 0.06179825961589813, 0.06415065377950668, 0.07833107560873032, -0.05341820418834686, 0.005834909621626139, -0.02448141947388649, -0.00583933899179101, -0.012735999189317226, -0.003228595480322838, 0.02028682269155979, -0.024338576942682266, 0.014463773928582668, 0.03716612234711647, -0.04793950915336609, 0.05966084450483322, 0.042915232479572296, -0.01002164650708437, -0.020307661965489388, -0.05195329710841179, -0.04913380742073059, 0.014252294786274433, -0.02351578138768673, 0.004834267310798168, -0.048605505377054214, -0.03379926458001137, 0.005686461925506592, 0.05568838492035866, 0.01806667260825634, 0.021042868494987488, 0.06250474601984024, -0.008310191333293915, -0.007414971012622118, -0.054684437811374664, 0.024582304060459137, -0.021984634920954704, 0.004472109489142895, -0.021091237664222717, -0.05999884009361267, 0.004480245057493448, 0.028820160776376724, -0.04649565368890762, 0.06564026325941086, 0.05054935812950134, -0.006856158375740051, 0.007375174202024937, 0.02457333542406559, 0.016813749447464943, 0.01753987744450569, 0.05973140522837639, -0.01302775926887989, 0.044834524393081665, 0.031628675758838654, -0.007099849637597799, 0.010771348141133785, -0.02437092550098896, 0.05199060216546059, 0.015018866397440434, -0.036000870168209076, 0.030189480632543564, -0.032551273703575134, -0.006141601596027613, 0.040099918842315674, -0.08441003412008286, -0.012556667439639568, -0.027431132271885872, -0.0650985985994339, 0.029200119897723198, 0.013093668036162853, 0.015067142434418201, -0.03328656777739525, 0.05408593639731407, -0.04472903162240982, -0.03364228457212448, -0.05612229183316231, -0.022802073508501053, -0.022860659286379814, -0.03971121460199356, -0.0006241629016585648, -0.03905458748340607, 0.00953679159283638, 0.02821127511560917, 0.011721806600689888, -0.02540270797908306, 0.012324153445661068, 0.050306759774684906, -0.006128765642642975, -0.01004317868500948, 0.042911823838949203, 0.06497833877801895, -0.02575225569307804, 0.014389356598258018, -0.03674893453717232, -0.02138463594019413, 0.01442872267216444, -0.03694913536310196, 0.019343622028827667, 0.0024529146030545235, -0.02739700861275196, -0.010309919714927673, -0.026279976591467857, -0.043539710342884064, 0.02696375735104084, -0.04420528933405876, 0.058603547513484955, 0.07452744990587234, -0.011755438521504402, 0.0024490286596119404, -0.018027039244771004, 0.0006137049058452249, 0.02935650572180748, -0.05693081393837929, 0.014529299922287464, -0.053329601883888245, -0.015211893245577812, 0.03510081022977829, -0.001884120050817728, -0.03709610551595688, 0.03042234666645527, 0.008639968931674957, -0.004750527441501617, 0.024610653519630432, 0.028304874897003174, -0.021478548645973206, -0.052136488258838654, 0.04534940794110298, 0.004481092561036348, 0.027142904698848724, 0.030706804245710373, 0.006782623007893562, -0.015988025814294815, -0.01556322630494833, -0.022274890914559364, 0.0035812442656606436, 0.04824092239141464, -0.017868543043732643, -0.03440657630562782, -0.04182818531990051, -0.03159594535827637, 0.019206324592232704, 0.007520874030888081, -0.0025661238469183445, 0.07033617049455643, -0.004253162071108818, -0.01758112758398056, 0.011056475341320038, 0.014013472013175488, -0.024184931069612503, 0.031012916937470436, -0.0190828088670969, -0.006221484858542681, 0.024566538631916046, -0.028343316167593002, 0.02439429983496666, -0.019621288403868675, -0.04004431143403053, -0.0449250265955925, -0.0036685538943856955, 0.0015831947093829513, 0.010750140994787216, 0.03985345736145973, -0.04318747669458389, 0.0013614814961329103, 0.0031073447316884995, -0.019637780264019966, 0.027068693190813065, -0.031518351286649704, -0.06397736817598343, -0.003672051941975951, -0.04728209599852562, -0.015934642404317856, 0.03123781457543373, 0.019541339948773384, -0.023418210446834564, 0.022349148988723755, 0.0003522840270306915, -0.04500297084450722, -0.07219245284795761, -0.019340967759490013, -0.004616354126483202, 0.0018103445181623101, -0.031102310866117477, 0.028264835476875305, -0.0161555428057909, -0.019083233550190926, 0.0321638323366642, -0.04116927087306976, -0.021832209080457687, -0.02504677325487137, -0.023279229179024696, 0.0005334996967576444, 0.04007147252559662, 0.03577994927763939, 0.03463191166520119, -0.02230588160455227, -0.011796698905527592, -0.08895444869995117, -0.030497219413518906, 0.0280851311981678, 0.006600361317396164, 0.004658711142838001, 0.023759430274367332, -0.0046377284452319145, 0.06795533001422882, 0.02219553291797638, -0.008697506971657276, -0.058422431349754333, 0.00874532014131546, -0.014965394511818886, -0.02567802369594574, 0.012044359929859638, 0.010107867419719696, 0.03520948439836502, 0.020788248628377914, -0.03909566253423691, -0.014601301401853561, 0.007083036005496979, 0.015959173440933228, -0.01443062350153923, -0.0033340665977448225, -0.0057799918577075005, -0.02089897356927395, 0.023104656487703323, 0.025426113978028297, 0.021036891266703606, 0.008476047776639462, 0.002909389091655612, 0.028743654489517212, -0.032972902059555054, -0.054495904594659805, -0.008502504788339138, 0.005746303126215935, -0.014959198422729969, -0.03711720183491707, 0.0555432066321373, -0.025124216452240944, -0.06999143958091736, -0.036787305027246475, 0.018540656194090843, 0.03568042814731598, -0.0196014866232872, -0.0008474526111967862, 0.049490395933389664, -0.00775867747142911, -0.02429754100739956, 0.027855202555656433, -0.01152869313955307, -0.03086976148188114, 0.027608973905444145, -0.008313862606883049, 0.033499907702207565, 0.06517631560564041, 0.049923837184906006, -0.015582184307277203, 0.00621752766892314, -0.022190937772393227, 0.005603268276900053, -0.0410260446369648, -0.007339200936257839, -0.026357311755418777, 0.02628515474498272, 0.019903572276234627, 0.04156707599759102, 0.008350841701030731, -0.03439632058143616, 0.005743568763136864, -0.006045798771083355, -0.015395448543131351, 0.01428863126784563, 0.02844466082751751, -0.028800347819924355, 0.00753247132524848, -0.011652699671685696, 0.02155373990535736, -0.07040903717279434, -0.021449653431773186, -0.020737960934638977, 0.015350278466939926, 0.027966689318418503, 0.01825881190598011, 0.020968429744243622, -0.024628669023513794, 0.0063275680877268314, 0.0358097068965435, 0.04743896797299385, 0.034207046031951904, -0.019021928310394287, 0.03565330058336258, 0.012447794899344444, -0.034317754209041595, -0.05285077542066574, 0.01719685271382332, 0.009000763297080994, 0.05169156566262245, 0.04434698075056076, 0.024029962718486786, -0.03444104641675949, 0.06168942525982857, 0.01707063615322113, 0.009803061373531818, 0.06289082765579224, -0.0029585394077003, -0.028487814590334892, -0.04321591183543205, -0.027136242017149925, 0.011415452696383, 0.0056972987949848175, 0.020840216428041458, 0.0206416305154562, 0.03816425800323486, 0.022062106058001518, 0.0024755068589001894, 0.00691539142280817, 0.05530385300517082, -0.008222537115216255, 0.001051324768923223, -0.043793778866529465, -0.0009153435821644962, 0.008668504655361176, 0.018728885799646378, 0.04606997221708298, 0.00024281666264869273, 0.014157409779727459, 0.0052934810519218445, 0.008373849093914032, 0.02228684537112713, -0.039092838764190674, 0.027718404307961464, 0.026214273646473885, 0.02443164587020874, 0.010894576087594032, -0.025589030236005783, 0.008319646120071411, 0.03518177196383476, 0.03635652735829353, 0.002283521695062518, -0.004372844006866217, -0.10331198573112488, 0.002510388847440481, 0.01291993074119091, 0.03570258617401123, -0.024791879579424858, -0.014454786665737629, -0.025683782994747162, -0.0023998075630515814, -0.031760845333337784, 0.0007844429928809404, 0.045773256570100784, 0.0034104562364518642, 0.032423440366983414, -0.0031638655345886946, -0.029169199988245964, -0.07695427536964417, 0.03482139855623245, -0.02114815078675747, -0.012446432374417782, -0.03292079642415047, -0.03768511861562729, -0.014190643094480038, 0.0014242210891097784, 0.007839738391339779, 0.030435526743531227, -0.06500018388032913, -0.015634415671229362, 0.018007991835474968, 0.013677428476512432, -0.043169159442186356, -0.01759653352200985, 0.029331481084227562, 0.008108068257570267, 0.012032942846417427, 0.05848054587841034, 0.0014418686041608453, 0.0013183169066905975, -0.00720942672342062, 0.03490431606769562, -0.01595725677907467, -0.015981577336788177, -0.004122133832424879, 0.028073115274310112, 0.020908068865537643, 0.01134776882827282, 0.08849014341831207, 0.024800386279821396, 0.004521948751062155, 0.01640116423368454, -0.04650067165493965, -0.00036008647293783724, -0.03932831436395645, -0.045764029026031494, -0.053219351917505264, -0.010758670046925545, 0.017985504120588303, 0.02107827179133892, -0.0073648011311888695, 0.022012749686837196, -0.05028632655739784, -0.02528299205005169, 0.049638502299785614, 0.016141317784786224, -0.021381614729762077, -0.014668414369225502, 0.0007906110840849578, -0.012772748246788979, -0.021833239123225212, -0.006649944931268692, 0.01314259972423315, -0.006392225157469511, -0.025055179372429848, 0.005995258688926697, -0.04294826090335846, 0.004846547264605761, 0.013795068487524986, -0.029457641765475273, -0.014006003737449646, -0.014146026223897934, -0.006382979452610016, 0.0341641865670681, 0.01807541586458683, 0.007334270514547825, -0.03127428889274597, -0.02139822021126747, 0.0233467984944582, -0.015059084631502628, -0.02590142749249935, 0.015509082935750484, 0.01623789593577385, -0.020377010107040405, -0.029403766617178917, -0.06124069541692734, -0.044771935790777206, 0.0072526405565440655, -0.04317391663789749, -0.009544186294078827, -0.01756681501865387, -0.03562973812222481, -0.020569197833538055, -0.023995831608772278, -0.006421892438083887, 0.05039004981517792, -0.08305438607931137, 0.03115946613252163, -0.02774062193930149, 0.011032400652766228, 0.02203979715704918, 0.009921140968799591, 0.008342863060534, 0.01262254174798727, -0.03370005264878273, -0.018371056765317917, 0.023795556277036667, -0.021805400028824806, -0.033909667283296585, 0.011518244631588459, -0.04991817846894264, 0.00737232668325305, 0.08343712240457535, 0.0005555371171794832, -0.04198234900832176, -0.012401307933032513, 0.015806308016180992, 0.007446944713592529, -0.04919595271348953, -0.004110390320420265, -0.023916900157928467, 0.00931574683636427, -0.016528325155377388, 0.03117654100060463, 0.0005984785966575146, 0.028460146859288216, 0.03985793888568878, -0.02510535717010498, -0.014684157446026802, 0.013678021728992462, 0.07558701187372208, 0.01838161051273346, 0.049779053777456284, -0.0143172862008214, -0.004420447628945112, 0.061716798692941666, -0.02602250687777996, -0.003767322516068816, 0.005963863804936409, 0.027396082878112793, -0.049620527774095535, -0.04512646794319153, -0.022391246631741524, 0.018656104803085327, 0.04637455195188522, -0.005471946205943823, 0.0373825766146183, 0.05290719121694565, -0.032124437391757965, -0.0066754319705069065, -0.07003196328878403, -0.0017992876237258315, 0.034622497856616974, 0.013750134035944939, 0.09438184648752213, -0.025348616763949394, 0.0016601295210421085, 0.024770142510533333, 0.004492892883718014, 0.01743105612695217, -0.004709137137979269, 0.028391560539603233, -0.03274715691804886, -0.02945643849670887, -0.03364569693803787, -0.04247969016432762, 0.03635804355144501, -0.04848429560661316, 0.008834251202642918, -0.03696361556649208, -0.031269606202840805, 0.007699543610215187, 0.0390084907412529, -0.009190507233142853, -0.058910977095365524, -0.019847651943564415, -0.032353464514017105, 0.02258165180683136, 0.027783073484897614, -0.0229336004704237, 0.01197642832994461, -0.014240010641515255, 0.04267822951078415, -0.03130127117037773, 0.06898060441017151, -0.023409679532051086, -0.10572702437639236, -0.003702649613842368, 0.023879868909716606, 0.013685035519301891, 0.049486834555864334, 0.010371934622526169, -0.00835329107940197, 0.029133198782801628, -0.02863628976047039, 0.04346240684390068, 0.03175916150212288, 0.03919549286365509, -0.008338134735822678, 0.009081684984266758, -0.029586460441350937, -0.020283879712224007, -0.026685161516070366, -0.014651763252913952, 0.17507591843605042, 0.08440413326025009, 0.018738092854619026, -0.0606604740023613, 0.021292923018336296, 0.028805632144212723, 0.004056565463542938, 0.02322584204375744, -0.004212281666696072, 0.0194283127784729, -0.04026868939399719, 0.01638059690594673, 0.012771526351571083, 0.027823781594634056, -0.004211061634123325, 0.012600223533809185, -0.011926954612135887, -0.015931911766529083, -0.016664696857333183, -0.01384690124541521, 0.0171098243445158, 0.0037832767702639103, -0.047489047050476074, -0.02269679680466652, 0.02013091929256916, 0.0069091832265257835, -0.03304549306631088, 0.011831612326204777, 0.0023312245029956102, 0.03790953755378723, -0.038124412298202515, 0.023320700973272324, -0.014241144061088562, -0.00024596924777142704, 0.01061184611171484, -0.006515965331345797, 0.037293583154678345, -0.04575183615088463, 0.01406351663172245, 0.022541066631674767, -0.016797436401247978, 0.0015591102419421077, 0.00044853685540147126, 0.052178218960762024, -0.035291124135255814, -0.0106512987986207, -0.007827321998775005, 0.02746380865573883, -0.01100471243262291, 0.008478730916976929, -0.01681503839790821, 0.004449628759175539, -0.0064903260208666325, -0.03015482984483242, -0.041154272854328156, 0.022542672231793404, 0.04062472656369209, -0.006806539371609688, -0.01619751751422882, -0.014979799278080463, 0.03533018007874489, -0.019535992294549942, 0.036423467099666595, 0.00016903417417779565, -0.011476158164441586, -0.029983749613165855, -0.030350912362337112, 0.05387112870812416, 0.0029093148186802864, 0.0362572968006134, 0.004318336956202984, -0.005313935223966837, -0.0036180175375193357, -0.017513291910290718, 0.04977775737643242, 0.03956883028149605, 0.015206586569547653, -0.0018620808841660619, 0.010492435656487942, -0.05788291618227959, -0.038006894290447235, -0.010918688029050827, -0.0006345988367684186, -0.00767003558576107, -0.03531935438513756, -0.018372632563114166, 0.013501130044460297, 0.02804047055542469, -0.007980510592460632, -0.006584403105080128, -0.025383174419403076, 0.05617859959602356, -0.009068702347576618, -0.027244603261351585, -0.024846257641911507, 0.07250204682350159, -0.002603353699669242, -0.028038665652275085, -0.010637210682034492, 0.06549738347530365, 0.035451605916023254, 0.030310560017824173, -0.04261695593595505, 0.024387134239077568, -0.008473756723105907, -0.007505382876843214, 0.04632796347141266, 0.0014986086171120405, -0.0022473083809018135, -0.0016367911593988538, 0.028510937467217445, -0.012530157342553139, 0.021607348695397377, -0.028923235833644867, -0.05816644802689552, 0.0013151351595297456, -0.03275561332702637, -0.02421465516090393, 0.012076310813426971, 0.010161626152694225, -0.018089158460497856, 0.00005908103412366472, -0.021750589832663536, -0.04216039553284645, 0.00121878064237535, 0.014449342153966427, -0.03349019214510918, -0.020763594657182693, -0.0015327222645282745, -0.02639811672270298, 0.0014537149108946323, 0.01418232824653387, 0.02415253035724163, 0.01104297861456871, -0.03561640903353691, 0.009455020539462566, 0.0031307083554565907, 0.05549818277359009, 0.015425707213580608, -0.008855306543409824, 0.033677730709314346, -0.02944924682378769, -0.023644112050533295, -0.01612524874508381, 0.017506850883364677, 0.023540880531072617, 0.0013465638039633632, 0.012662668712437153, -0.017892641946673393, 0.05319564417004585, -0.02459167130291462, -0.015149962157011032, -0.014478747732937336, -0.0037227177526801825, 0.009906675666570663, -0.029104148969054222, 0.03041907586157322, 0.023831017315387726, 0.0038026906549930573, 0.014802650548517704, 0.021990297362208366, 0.01418272778391838, -0.006115961819887161, 0.0034164777025580406, -0.055791206657886505, 0.0067194621078670025, 0.012361087836325169, -0.0019419938325881958, 0.006085338070988655, 0.029428819194436073, -0.012607338838279247, 0.054438911378383636, -0.007066547870635986, 0.047046955674886703, -0.09165994077920914, -0.04684114083647728, 0.010930493474006653, 0.04380812868475914, 0.013524186797440052, -0.028953270986676216, 0.005665123928338289, 0.060369111597537994, -0.017202865332365036, -0.029243752360343933, -0.00008127635373966768, 0.004167794715613127, -0.004263042006641626, 0.019017107784748077, -0.03351845592260361, -0.0203368179500103, -0.021539192646741867, -0.005015335511416197, 0.02506752498447895, 0.023159896954894066, 0.03248412907123566, -0.01238042302429676, -0.009728215634822845, -0.009710988961160183, 0.051771871745586395, -0.054443325847387314, 0.04476103186607361, -0.02020559459924698, -0.025431940332055092, -0.0021134410053491592, 0.01879197731614113, 0.050081029534339905, 0.007636067923158407, 0.03240311145782471, 0.0749618262052536, 0.048986490815877914, 0.0030931802466511726, -0.0011235906276851892, 0.000517395616043359, 0.0002787000557873398, 0.03431852161884308, 0.014313815161585808, -0.035115230828523636, -0.004860036075115204, 0.017091339454054832, 0.0009878469863906503, -0.022588644176721573, 0.03334953263401985, -0.010188654996454716, -0.05311712250113487, -0.043497372418642044, 0.022296849638223648, 0.003304628888145089, -0.05933895334601402, -0.0053870100528001785, -0.01402080338448286, 0.023720411583781242, 0.03706220164895058, 0.03984268754720688, -0.029856868088245392, 0.01997988298535347, -0.008686404675245285, 0.012908355332911015, 0.0010344748152419925, 0.0006073114345781505, -0.0009879354620352387, -0.024188201874494553, 0.011238578706979752, -0.002727632177993655, -0.026068851351737976, -0.029867073521018028, 0.013357202522456646, -0.07806895673274994, 0.02866974286735058, -0.033031266182661057, -0.010962369851768017, -0.0000244792227022117, -0.023208631202578545, 0.03488435223698616, -0.08491157740354538, 0.047176193445920944, 0.003911890089511871, 0.00946854054927826, -0.046846531331539154, -0.006514033302664757, -0.044717397540807724, 0.036099113523960114, 0.04768320545554161, 0.01715758815407753, -0.00345306727103889, 0.013021107763051987, 0.032171230763196945, 0.004545011557638645, -0.042908940464258194, 0.03485012799501419, 0.04857563227415085, 0.01093502901494503, -0.008958305232226849, 0.0031768318731337786, 0.0166922640055418, -0.009236177429556847, 0.016228191554546356, 0.007513947784900665, -0.002488256897777319, -0.0028501604683697224, -0.012313921935856342, 0.03475235402584076, 0.014463169500231743, -0.01341249980032444, 0.048804931342601776, -0.02237067185342312, 0.05158061161637306, 0.05786347761750221, 0.0027456204406917095, -0.029543036594986916, 0.013612590730190277, -0.0156965721398592, 0.009291955269873142, -0.018892263993620872, 0.003350035287439823, 0.0074132950976490974, -0.030264804139733315, 0.002586709801107645, 0.03633992001414299, -0.025046302005648613, -0.017775272950530052, 0.043399274349212646, -0.012555844150483608, 0.06198844686150551, -0.015081096440553665, 0.014499171636998653, -0.001488394453190267, -0.030496342107653618, 0.019139844924211502, -0.0052179298363626, 0.0008800398209132254, -0.002107414649799466, -0.023042596876621246, 0.0493943952023983, -0.038525037467479706, 0.02117292210459709, -0.01778004691004753, 0.03547416999936104, 0.030328867956995964, -0.008017514832317829, 0.02114894427359104, -0.010831671766936779, -0.007783570326864719, 0.027939964085817337, 0.0030409384053200483, 0.02877737209200859, -0.07370132952928543, -0.0014888053992763162, -0.0399387963116169, -0.0028158975765109062, 0.0029683676548302174, 0.012858712114393711, -0.037562720477581024, 0.01271558366715908, 0.022105803713202477, 0.005469050724059343, -0.013667779043316841, -0.038574233651161194, -0.005000303965061903, -0.030361806973814964, -0.023046448826789856, 0.01875322125852108, 0.010138606652617455, 0.008268446661531925, -0.019890332594513893, -0.023674746975302696, -0.014197169803082943, 0.015088194981217384, 0.010959547944366932, 0.02602972276508808, -0.09097430855035782, 0.01149024534970522, 0.0033162932377308607, 0.04440366104245186, -0.052483972162008286, -0.05138377100229263, 0.011654645204544067, 0.016690708696842194, 0.007135970517992973, -0.00952144805341959 ]
<p>I have a database of time series data generated by giroscope sensor. A small part of the data is already labeled and used to fit the model. My strong assumption is that most of the samples left in this database are of the same class of movement. Can I use this data to replenish the model without manual labeling? What are the steps required?</p>
36,256
[ -0.006604181602597237, -0.007466595154255629, 0.013947905972599983, 0.02140083909034729, 0.012084283865988255, 0.003916459623724222, -0.051510028541088104, -0.020351190119981766, -0.00242726132273674, -0.022871173918247223, 0.004634313751012087, -0.0048147207126021385, 0.02557103894650936, 0.03099999390542507, -0.0024620983749628067, 0.0017850137082859874, -0.007410453632473946, -0.011128979735076427, -0.018329543992877007, -0.03938319534063339, -0.03139287978410721, -0.011448046192526817, 0.009920215234160423, -0.013002431951463223, -0.02985573746263981, 0.03135276958346367, 0.03606783598661423, -0.03949587419629097, -0.014685973525047302, 0.010448329150676727, -0.05682353675365448, 0.0013602296821773052, -0.03441891446709633, 0.03244074806571007, 0.0345006138086319, 0.005535104312002659, -0.05818025767803192, -0.0521804541349411, 0.033126749098300934, 0.02433081902563572, -0.05939337611198425, 0.03808917850255966, 0.0294081699103117, 0.07048927247524261, 0.009970768354833126, -0.00506485253572464, -0.012320581823587418, -0.003240062855184078, 0.04042848199605942, -0.024804340675473213, 0.0430106520652771, -0.03453025594353676, 0.028388958424329758, 0.02879607304930687, -0.0232000183314085, 0.015050544403493404, 0.055762019008398056, 0.0519544817507267, 0.022298108786344528, 0.006455762777477503, 0.013083311729133129, 0.0005403271643444896, -0.017206627875566483, -0.039871569722890854, -0.00958657544106245, 0.007290292531251907, 0.016932835802435875, -0.024062320590019226, 0.05169215798377991, -0.02573671191930771, 0.03509552776813507, 0.004817482084035873, 0.05207515135407448, 0.0014432972529903054, 0.060505013912916183, 0.009020800702273846, 0.0292657483369112, 0.03710073605179787, 0.02178206481039524, 0.009910010732710361, -0.00025640593958087265, -0.026250043883919716, 0.009467183612287045, 0.042558640241622925, 0.01552542857825756, -0.015187453478574753, 0.03282095864415169, -0.03922724351286888, 0.018453581258654594, -0.011112307198345661, 0.017200561240315437, 0.000992989051155746, 0.02797197550535202, 0.02337527461349964, -0.03906486555933952, 0.04279473051428795, 0.023123884573578835, 0.03322890028357506, -0.015547819435596466, 0.013669516891241074, 0.005111425183713436, -0.046004656702280045, -0.037680961191654205, 0.017859818413853645, -0.04839345067739487, 0.027353210374712944, 0.013541731983423233, -0.05165481194853783, 0.0031126225367188454, -0.0024087245110422373, -0.03169271722435951, -0.034992896020412445, 0.034639872610569, 0.010747854597866535, 0.025419151410460472, 0.0023540693800896406, -0.06941474974155426, -0.011448950506746769, 0.052210137248039246, 0.051511500030756, 0.06070845201611519, -0.035242605954408646, 0.02113122120499611, -0.03997387737035751, -0.04751155152916908, -0.011001335456967354, -0.004470141138881445, -0.02323811873793602, -0.04473642259836197, 0.04695655405521393, -0.008525791577994823, -0.016897153109312057, 0.04847005382180214, -0.04200965166091919, 0.046513546258211136, 0.0012513167457655072, -0.0662202313542366, -0.01512899063527584, 0.027694081887602806, 0.010195141658186913, 0.029900724068284035, -0.0677352324128151, 0.01193411648273468, 0.04888627305626869, 0.023241732269525528, 0.015400384552776814, 0.02839740365743637, 0.021627863869071007, -0.010000362060964108, -0.014493580907583237, -0.003790271235629916, -0.04633457586169243, -0.03311099112033844, -0.006833428516983986, -0.04228053614497185, -0.07728613168001175, 0.0024274250026792288, 0.014488798566162586, -0.03487982973456383, -0.01597837544977665, 0.008254735730588436, 0.0069089955650269985, 0.0038124092388898134, 0.017165325582027435, 0.014729137532413006, -0.02748425118625164, 0.05807645246386528, -0.03152763098478317, 0.03128752112388611, -0.010631476528942585, 0.0017380263889208436, 0.023933278396725655, 0.040672361850738525, 0.027727589011192322, 0.0569920614361763, 0.014278166927397251, -0.014083250425755978, 0.03833560273051262, 0.028598926961421967, 0.020030399784445763, -0.019928082823753357, -0.03244122862815857, -0.017403915524482727, -0.004775332752615213, 0.022249825298786163, -0.006749271415174007, 0.039622027426958084, -0.005168665666133165, 0.018294531852006912, -0.0798049047589302, -0.026908908039331436, -0.03134814649820328, -0.005379603244364262, -0.05757623538374901, 0.029119519516825676, 0.01985814794898033, -0.004476724658161402, 0.008826402947306633, 0.015147541649639606, -0.0642000213265419, -0.043378639966249466, -0.04935448244214058, 0.00932303722947836, -0.04545152932405472, -0.024081075564026833, 0.03484348952770233, 0.04198339581489563, -0.00494521576911211, 0.05506232753396034, -0.009563800878822803, -0.03215603530406952, 0.001129265408962965, -0.04409727454185486, 0.008040054701268673, -0.00034228150616399944, 0.026576489210128784, 0.012383980676531792, 0.042151276022195816, -0.0217888243496418, 0.028469057753682137, -0.009470531716942787, 0.037288013845682144, 0.08500928431749344, -0.00006511517858598381, 0.016165094450116158, 0.029979927465319633, 0.02064773626625538, 0.046544719487428665, -0.0007289400091394782, -0.037025418132543564, -0.06084563210606575, -0.02992623671889305, 0.029262728989124298, -0.004030534997582436, -0.023263223469257355, 0.0045114425010979176, 0.08338328450918198, 0.00040098928730003536, -0.006792221684008837, 0.019192751497030258, -0.009039039723575115, 0.00469139963388443, 0.029793063178658485, 0.02170155756175518, 0.04472167789936066, -0.022076601162552834, 0.015135261230170727, -0.005754583049565554, 0.03177506476640701, 0.029189538210630417, 0.05420038104057312, -0.0014135075034573674, 0.03132004663348198, -0.023336535319685936, 0.0030224346555769444, -0.016811911016702652, 0.03226412460207939, -0.022186242043972015, 0.05685722455382347, 0.030706271529197693, -0.006961675360798836, -0.03318040817975998, 0.03717910125851631, -0.014303477481007576, 0.006209964398294687, 0.039373211562633514, 0.011357706971466541, -0.01637055166065693, 0.037406135350465775, -0.08673971891403198, 0.02791963331401348, -0.009864816442131996, -0.05013367161154747, -0.04390358924865723, 0.017997723072767258, 0.03433884307742119, 0.021099599078297615, 0.03575040400028229, -0.046779002994298935, -0.01080473605543375, -0.022468334063887596, 0.005609668791294098, 0.0019916382152587175, 0.05876517668366432, -0.05335446447134018, 0.001715480349957943, 0.02556401677429676, -0.023542288690805435, 0.0032977641094475985, 0.0004997925134375691, -0.0020229839719831944, 0.032900720834732056, -0.017239689826965332, -0.043512750416994095, -0.01038870494812727, -0.019754761829972267, 0.004382479470223188, -0.018909987062215805, -0.02089020051062107, 0.007095051929354668, 0.04388478398323059, -0.08312324434518814, 0.0006685969419777393, -0.05496538430452347, -0.024079162627458572, -0.007453469093888998, 0.025074612349271774, 0.034117456525564194, -0.028031066060066223, 0.04006630554795265, 0.01857711561024189, 0.010437725111842155, 0.002293998608365655, -0.05483529344201088, -0.060095787048339844, 0.022067828103899956, -0.0013041227357462049, 0.0034850866068154573, 0.025782661512494087, 0.0032940141391009092, 0.06124911457300186, 0.018853966146707535, -0.0426749549806118, -0.015876103192567825, -0.010496407747268677, 0.00323926261626184, -0.038857001811265945, -0.019298000261187553, -0.02047007530927658, -0.011178849264979362, 0.0046046278439462185, -0.012399278581142426, 0.03327837213873863, 0.06834083795547485, -0.017077572643756866, -0.018731439486145973, 0.014241714030504227, 0.013704180717468262, 0.01413757260888815, 0.02551485225558281, 0.009606895968317986, -0.04670019447803497, 0.02058384008705616, -0.04795295000076294, 0.04390298202633858, 0.06594578176736832, -0.05061514303088188, 0.03544197604060173, -0.0191260427236557, -0.003092474304139614, -0.000519245455507189, -0.00430975342169404, 0.018567515537142754, -0.021161967888474464, -0.034259408712387085, 0.060915786772966385, 0.054626353085041046, 0.012810125015676022, 0.01658628135919571, 0.030958043411374092, 0.013465638272464275, 0.005385209806263447, -0.0021213453728705645, -0.023308612406253815, -0.0062686000019311905, 0.034238893538713455, -0.018509408459067345, 0.007040928117930889, -0.0020569521002471447, 0.02565046027302742, 0.008499891497194767, -0.0024192279670387506, -0.04256585240364075, 0.007741203065961599, -0.05353616550564766, -0.015637405216693878, -0.025653911754488945, 0.02396305464208126, 0.008450429886579514, 0.013486744835972786, -0.004475960973650217, -0.005811135750263929, 0.03338336572051048, 0.010731036774814129, -0.02905328944325447, 0.028163284063339233, 0.02381235919892788, -0.002743947086855769, 0.018119744956493378, -0.03043472394347191, 0.052893731743097305, -0.0036211127880960703, 0.0065473890863358974, -0.006758768577128649, -0.011492415331304073, -0.05561261996626854, 0.0022836688440293074, -0.028104903176426888, -0.03310481831431389, -0.030286941677331924, 0.01083463802933693, 0.04951195791363716, 0.004293599631637335, 0.01968246139585972, 0.014904291369020939, 0.03894847258925438, -0.018580345436930656, -0.05374735966324806, 0.018644003197550774, -0.008927387185394764, 0.043226420879364014, 0.006625541020184755, 0.02747059427201748, -0.08045729994773865, 0.008587988093495369, -0.0007796012796461582, 0.027491413056850433, 0.01031899731606245, 0.04247114062309265, -0.02893807366490364, -0.04281635209918022, -0.04640182852745056, 0.0219783503562212, 0.063486248254776, 0.01378864049911499, -0.021826596930623055, 0.03464948385953903, 0.0175042562186718, -0.06633247435092926, 0.026820261031389236, 0.09041539579629898, -0.005697205662727356, 0.016040382906794548, -0.04259033501148224, -0.0014633903047069907, -0.0017743861535564065, -0.00646767346188426, 0.03774576634168625, 0.01853426732122898, -0.002740479540079832, 0.004138992168009281, 0.04084562137722969, 0.06285595893859863, -0.025249388068914413, -0.011763863265514374, 0.0254852045327425, 0.07592261582612991, -0.02543092705309391, -0.008247902616858482, 0.009348531253635883, 0.01658637635409832, 0.06114451214671135, 0.02457437850534916, 0.0046792407520115376, -0.10093007236719131, -0.012349775061011314, 0.025148384273052216, 0.0022608183789998293, 0.0069062612019479275, 0.009663150645792484, -0.03367696329951286, -0.0435371994972229, 0.01539791002869606, 0.00028968730475753546, 0.024872642010450363, -0.01151328906416893, 0.004040585830807686, -0.015218277461826801, -0.03867534548044205, -0.020065395161509514, -0.003887701081112027, -0.045060355216264725, 0.007526738103479147, -0.0007624575519002974, -0.020135890692472458, -0.01285052951425314, 0.02089376002550125, -0.028085757046937943, 0.057312291115522385, -0.031818684190511703, -0.007284610532224178, 0.03550746291875839, -0.011922508478164673, -0.059868596494197845, -0.05275946855545044, 0.015538796782493591, -0.021281061694025993, 0.011652011424303055, 0.02560221031308174, -0.00686014536768198, -0.023943433538079262, -0.0025010828394442797, -0.016899792477488518, -0.012694093398749828, -0.02333775721490383, -0.021757803857326508, 0.015748515725135803, 0.008301977068185806, -0.012842303141951561, 0.06396359950304031, 0.05533388629555702, 0.05547546595335007, -0.0014129538321867585, -0.01148929912596941, 0.014382578432559967, -0.07291652262210846, -0.012186317704617977, 0.007195735815912485, 0.01830848678946495, -0.047157540917396545, 0.03894514963030815, 0.011753605678677559, 0.06337887048721313, -0.012310816906392574, -0.029158752411603928, 0.017292436212301254, 0.04282307252287865, 0.00033421392436139286, -0.029200837016105652, -0.015415308997035027, 0.03719901293516159, -0.048205506056547165, -0.008083898574113846, -0.03296884521842003, -0.049131568521261215, -0.02490556426346302, 0.010072391480207443, -0.008455123752355576, 0.004498252645134926, -0.060257237404584885, 0.013672931119799614, -0.0075544449500739574, -0.02499706670641899, 0.001718690269626677, 0.013546615839004517, 0.062083493918180466, 0.022669179365038872, -0.06518489867448807, -0.017565682530403137, 0.008517353795468807, -0.008418936282396317, 0.014703692868351936, -0.05078741908073425, 0.023249546065926552, -0.01749919168651104, 0.045369699597358704, -0.06314664334058762, -0.03711118549108505, 0.01938367262482643, -0.004779813811182976, -0.0338236428797245, -0.038060422986745834, -0.0012370970798656344, 0.0012169622350484133, -0.01067378744482994, -0.008194929920136929, 0.05630379915237427, 0.009378612041473389, -0.007720024324953556, 0.002061867620795965, 0.018492594361305237, 0.08262008428573608, 0.009873741306364536, -0.005789176095277071, 0.054527271538972855, 0.002231864957138896, -0.015269830822944641, -0.0014882117975503206, 0.001160976942628622, -0.020002789795398712, -0.015885980799794197, -0.04582841694355011, 0.035834405571222305, 0.061795953661203384, -0.021025141701102257, 0.008181963115930557, 0.021650684997439384, -0.00783719215542078, 0.02925555594265461, -0.06056180223822594, 0.0009683671523816884, -0.0242669228464365, -0.030806537717580795, -0.03079925663769245, 0.03667275607585907, 0.015220727771520615, 0.00033081459696404636, 0.026566263288259506, -0.023358983919024467, -0.008753524161875248, 0.007027393206954002, 0.05615592747926712, -0.019594525918364525, -0.03972383588552475, 0.06211579963564873, -0.020024236291646957, 0.013421140611171722, 0.0182897187769413, 0.028455698862671852, -0.02307691052556038, 0.034177716821432114, -0.041018255054950714, -0.008121083490550518, -0.018451442942023277, -0.036282531917095184, 0.08155768364667892, 0.015134929679334164, 0.04066045954823494, 0.011146772652864456, 0.0017556503880769014, -0.009068175218999386, -0.00040135806193575263, 0.027277374640107155, -0.0071273427456617355, -0.016228046268224716, 0.035183586180210114, 0.013536762446165085, -0.03318936377763748, -0.018490688875317574, 0.0224470105022192, 0.021122250705957413, 0.04431578889489174, 0.025342194363474846, 0.02556191384792328, 0.0035344897769391537, -0.029867270961403847, -0.045188531279563904, 0.004476975183933973, -0.01768157258629799, 0.039632316678762436, 0.011402113363146782, -0.006152541842311621, 0.03536490723490715, 0.06342580169439316, 0.017108989879488945, -0.036631543189287186, -0.0306948721408844, -0.06692691147327423, 0.005897932685911655, -0.006541674491018057, 0.004031362943351269, 0.016595564782619476, 0.00578638119623065, 0.02104736492037773, 0.006506070960313082, -0.009779619053006172, -0.03079622983932495, -0.07087196409702301, -0.025390852242708206, -0.02293875254690647, -0.02705470286309719, 0.07474832236766815, -0.005715955514460802, -0.00006888549978611991, 0.002077518729493022, 0.01838727295398712, -0.000379699602490291, 0.0013518733903765678, 0.06407082825899124, 0.004579075612127781, 0.05379030480980873, 0.012925198301672935, 0.010408547706902027, -0.04729282110929489, 0.0282900407910347, 0.15317732095718384, 0.054899267852306366, 0.05288858711719513, -0.02414543367922306, -0.004990085028111935, 0.030223065987229347, -0.012584243901073933, -0.014746191911399364, -0.004573667421936989, 0.019295379519462585, -0.012391550466418266, -0.018055489286780357, 0.01391912717372179, -0.014766615815460682, 0.0012021178845316172, 0.06449295580387115, -0.011220360174775124, -0.012889932841062546, 0.03456520661711693, 0.0015246698167175055, 0.0026423311792314053, 0.013471541926264763, -0.05407062917947769, 0.022274352610111237, 0.012699145823717117, -0.028050504624843597, 0.009264673106372356, -0.03478768840432167, 0.0055394298397004604, 0.008297516964375973, 0.009950034320354462, 0.03270568698644638, -0.004815598484128714, 0.06447280943393707, 0.0005829049623571336, 0.0006756699294783175, -0.015825500711798668, 0.00699462927877903, -0.004380110185593367, 0.02898813784122467, 0.01756691001355648, 0.01948021538555622, -0.02097562700510025, -0.03001382015645504, 0.006104559637606144, -0.012137596495449543, -0.044919662177562714, 0.02490047924220562, -0.02274889312684536, -0.012904813513159752, 0.006269145291298628, 0.000884546316228807, -0.0035816628951579332, -0.06264879554510117, -0.038035549223423004, 0.005012159701436758, 0.029087524861097336, -0.006871870718896389, -0.04022866487503052, -0.03129350766539574, -0.007566025946289301, -0.005740019958466291, 0.00907476618885994, -0.027170075103640556, -0.03534725680947304, -0.011979852803051472, -0.03110153041779995, 0.047932859510183334, -0.01976500079035759, 0.005078108049929142, -0.02838115207850933, -0.02105133607983589, -0.02543141134083271, -0.030921729281544685, 0.0073258099146187305, 0.03282587602734566, -0.0035423082299530506, 0.0009581047925166786, -0.027809638530015945, -0.019146019592881203, -0.038016367703676224, -0.01144124660640955, 0.0056587993167340755, -0.0073630716651678085, -0.0134236766025424, -0.02201690338551998, 0.0341191366314888, 0.07802015542984009, 0.003670362289994955, 0.01613311655819416, 0.0006690824520774186, 0.058974385261535645, -0.005169322248548269, -0.03831538185477257, -0.029853863641619682, 0.007135892752557993, -0.06013605743646622, 0.04957886040210724, -0.010939979925751686, 0.05507196485996246, 0.03745771571993828, 0.021464765071868896, 0.0002608014037832618, 0.018607255071401596, 0.003840353339910507, 0.05041759833693504, -0.00538289500400424, -0.05758276954293251, 0.008012088015675545, 0.0010960220824927092, -0.012003240175545216, -0.046961188316345215, -0.07978187501430511, -0.007205350790172815, -0.04095127806067467, 0.009798129089176655, -0.02851225435733795, -0.02938101626932621, 0.01949893869459629, -0.06679028272628784, 0.009860815480351448, -0.015276992693543434, 0.009850065223872662, -0.07080972194671631, -0.01209337543696165, -0.022365568205714226, -0.030194854363799095, -0.028634648770093918, -0.012130587361752987, 0.008170791901648045, 0.021857397630810738, 0.04665778577327728, 0.005563594866544008, -0.011084229685366154, -0.008121605962514877, -0.020354945212602615, -0.01896556466817856, 0.034206099808216095, -0.009417708963155746, 0.0031502051278948784, 0.050963904708623886, -0.024140741676092148, 0.0040750643238425255, 0.025549210608005524, -0.013832994736731052, 0.04727097973227501, 0.05207935720682144, -0.01963752880692482, 0.014372517354786396, 0.025695405900478363, -0.023817164823412895, -0.008679225109517574, 0.008404147811233997, 0.006358750630170107, 0.010672499425709248, 0.0019420082680881023, 0.055516354739665985, 0.04239332675933838, -0.025345034897327423, 0.041227784007787704, 0.028508828952908516, 0.04437374696135521, -0.05405618995428085, 0.035424284636974335, 0.012409827671945095, -0.0050681945867836475, 0.012105668894946575, 0.008179242722690105, 0.047253239899873734, 0.014662470668554306, -0.021718712523579597, -0.004363717045634985, -0.03398928791284561, -0.014865328557789326, -0.048456527292728424, -0.051663096994161606, -0.008689985610544682, -0.01752866804599762, 0.025177137926220894, -0.01966852881014347, -0.01590573601424694, 0.009613321162760258, -0.07365453988313675, 0.002348109381273389, 0.012015648186206818, -0.03905700892210007, -0.0036458438262343407, 0.013460787013173103, -0.016310907900333405, -0.016985682770609856, 0.06297671049833298, 0.015398092567920685, 0.018765944987535477, 0.00037691579200327396, -0.0031243397388607264, -0.0040280804969370365, -0.008283920586109161, 0.023844696581363678, 0.02634870447218418, -0.0111863873898983, 0.02208486571907997, -0.0651421770453453, -0.03343036398291588, 0.015505523420870304, -0.028613466769456863, 0.000688369560521096, 0.017189551144838333, -0.01999732293188572, -0.030117379501461983, 0.0511954240500927, 0.04149962216615677, -0.015102016739547253, 0.016089892014861107, 0.008447165600955486, 0.005016733426600695, 0.0479409359395504, -0.02531798556447029, 0.0180584155023098, 0.009317624382674694, -0.030379505828022957, -0.01957162283360958, 0.017473844811320305, -0.01565990038216114, 0.01429886557161808, 0.03197931870818138, -0.005540455225855112, 0.012360203079879284, -0.018165474757552147, -0.003337813075631857, -0.028858589008450508, 0.05885375291109085, -0.014824090525507927, -0.020731646567583084, -0.01786211133003235, 0.00475254887714982, -0.04282722622156143, -0.04364381358027458, 0.03358854353427887, 0.02655934914946556, -0.05492351949214935, -0.03224450349807739, 0.0028258387465029955, 0.008907752111554146, -0.017747022211551666, -0.008482299745082855, -0.004078309517353773, -0.03953520208597183, 0.060253262519836426, -0.00450102286413312, 0.04462536424398422, 0.007200276013463736, 0.005318197887390852, -0.016225356608629227, -0.0747784972190857, 0.04833332821726799, 0.05308348312973976, -0.03508327528834343, -0.020165950059890747, -0.008928854949772358, -0.0123974047601223, 0.028021512553095818, 0.05314210429787636, -0.029437314718961716, -0.008906056173145771, -0.014636393636465073, -0.013259949162602425, -0.011436451226472855, -0.027316244319081306, 0.04716135933995247, -0.0016224682331085205, -0.010095040313899517, 0.016389312222599983, -0.008687755092978477, -0.02597428485751152, 0.010065863840281963, -0.0027349628508090973, 0.014092247001826763, 0.037771835923194885, 0.022729700431227684, -0.014054995961487293, 0.0032286879140883684, 0.00016483046056237072, 0.009403906762599945, 0.011569908820092678, 0.00022540046484209597, -0.010823114775121212, 0.020367896184325218, -0.027581144124269485, -0.07274273782968521, 0.05145707726478577, -0.11832854151725769, -0.005682788789272308, -0.0006256181513890624, 0.007634760811924934, 0.006904044654220343, -0.03079613298177719, -0.0030318626668304205, -0.00873290654271841, 0.0029341098852455616, 0.046646907925605774, 0.010493235662579536, 0.035816192626953125, 0.050780899822711945, -0.04589751735329628, 0.01632819138467312, -0.026547031477093697, -0.00011983899457845837, 0.03317132219672203, 0.023334644734859467, -0.008321030996739864, -0.01758241280913353, -0.0014020561939105392, 0.018887648358941078, 0.014690885320305824, 0.017021479085087776, 0.015367466025054455, 0.013128567487001419, -0.003557146294042468, 0.006328611169010401, -0.012337171472609043, -0.002769308863207698, 0.016844492405653, 0.051307693123817444, -0.025988776236772537, 0.0682772845029831, -0.007669169455766678, -0.015290270559489727, -0.07589633017778397, 0.022507010027766228, 0.016438309103250504, 0.034321438521146774, -0.016004551202058792, 0.004560950677841902, 0.025737939402461052, 0.0029470256995409727, -0.041385386139154434, 0.021527541801333427, 0.003568212501704693, -0.02568158693611622, 0.028600938618183136, 0.03675175830721855, 0.021849805489182472, -0.003717130981385708, 0.018294956535100937, -0.057012028992176056, -0.038568027317523956, 0.016488775610923767, 0.05966167896986008, 0.00923216249793768, -0.011903347447514534, -0.03172297030687332, -0.03901190310716629, 0.008081174455583096, -0.050819531083106995, -0.007556155323982239, -0.060827817767858505, 0.004215309862047434, 0.0027995449490845203, -0.00014473438204731792 ]
<p>Also, are the standardized regression weights equivalent to the correlation between a factor and a manifest variable?</p> <p>I write this question with reference to an example on p138-142 of the following document: <a href="ftp://ftp.software.ibm.com/software/analytics/spss/documentation/amos/20.0/en/Manuals/IBM_SPSS_Amos_User_Guide.pdf" rel="nofollow">ftp://ftp.software.ibm.com/software/analytics/spss/documentation/amos/20.0/en/Manuals/IBM_SPSS_Amos_User_Guide.pdf</a>. </p> <p>Here are illustrative figures and a table: <img src="http://i.imgur.com/Rmayocw.png" alt="CFA example"></p>
36,257
[ -0.03733765333890915, -0.00254269503057003, -0.015795959159731865, 0.02702639065682888, 0.06017393618822098, 0.004944630898535252, -0.017897954210639, -0.027875510975718498, 0.02883308194577694, -0.008675763383507729, -0.014443686231970787, 0.02119278535246849, 0.052605096250772476, -0.0005492371274158359, 0.005479360930621624, 0.03002973087131977, -0.0047455839812755585, 0.0600992888212204, 0.011027982458472252, 0.021315298974514008, 0.023771032691001892, 0.02046637050807476, 0.021652210503816605, -0.0059760864824056625, -0.03312439098954201, 0.05321032553911209, 0.010502965189516544, -0.04322801157832146, 0.03803093731403351, 0.029511338099837303, -0.027741793543100357, -0.013534316793084145, 0.01907145418226719, 0.057798150926828384, 0.013224158436059952, -0.005529096815735102, -0.01998981088399887, -0.012616320513188839, 0.005576895549893379, 0.0444587767124176, -0.044175826013088226, -0.023014577105641365, 0.012001565657556057, 0.005194554105401039, -0.012014798820018768, -0.008153731003403664, 0.00028268349706195295, 0.027351373806595802, 0.033197540789842606, -0.04115193709731102, 0.08603887259960175, 0.005313632544130087, 0.011406081728637218, 0.010730573907494545, -0.04136943444609642, -0.010199548676609993, 0.07082341611385345, 0.008142314851284027, -0.013216708786785603, -0.08220043778419495, -0.017031343653798103, -0.0195004940032959, -0.013460872694849968, -0.025440989062190056, -0.026759015396237373, 0.03477869927883148, 0.026388544589281082, -0.0018683429807424545, 0.05654262378811836, 0.011423635296523571, 0.030776318162679672, 0.020094744861125946, 0.023489244282245636, -0.0019868386443704367, 0.02547495812177658, -0.03278636932373047, 0.017363669350743294, 0.02536783181130886, 0.011358496733009815, 0.06220836937427521, 0.0532756969332695, 0.013964490033686161, 0.01967402547597885, 0.032669562846422195, 0.05387409031391144, 0.016500066965818405, 0.07370283454656601, -0.014822219498455524, 0.004999211989343166, 0.04871194437146187, 0.009665586985647678, 0.025035718455910683, 0.030782785266637802, -0.034518320113420486, 0.0016770806396380067, 0.021565893664956093, -0.03876999020576477, 0.013759614899754524, 0.019430825486779213, 0.0015035896794870496, -0.004141559824347496, -0.0412038192152977, 0.011299057863652706, 0.015745053067803383, -0.007288360968232155, -0.001386784017086029, -0.00671917200088501, 0.02051808312535286, -0.004691702779382467, -0.03971182182431221, -0.030994759872555733, -0.024646133184432983, 0.003864689962938428, -0.003993449732661247, 0.004884983878582716, -0.013009601272642612, -0.008624591864645481, 0.014010037295520306, 0.058283161371946335, 0.07473861426115036, 0.030513478443026543, -0.03783644363284111, 0.0011427259305492043, -0.02687958814203739, -0.026485946029424667, 0.04405801370739937, -0.009834939613938332, -0.02082526870071888, -0.04082685708999634, 0.025192005559802055, 0.029176177456974983, -0.035797812044620514, 0.018203631043434143, 0.023001618683338165, -0.011482632718980312, 0.004983614198863506, -0.08539534360170364, -0.048941757529973984, 0.035583872348070145, -0.011219683103263378, 0.012488464824855328, -0.04177619889378548, -0.012807916849851608, 0.03532031551003456, 0.06337920576334, 0.013793005608022213, 0.06051486358046532, 0.022901825606822968, 0.039535559713840485, 0.016468139365315437, -0.0028644283302128315, -0.020580526441335678, -0.015782896429300308, -0.06273236125707626, -0.020665490999817848, -0.0889832004904747, -0.014124453067779541, 0.02976900152862072, -0.001159030944108963, 0.013205005787312984, 0.058909010142087936, -0.00863646250218153, -0.01589343324303627, -0.007326581981033087, 0.02333597093820572, -0.03798852115869522, 0.03670208156108856, -0.021432848647236824, -0.009202845394611359, 0.03522777557373047, 0.001123654656112194, -0.007353652734309435, -0.012567926198244095, 0.06803064048290253, 0.016404546797275543, -0.007656775880604982, -0.011792652308940887, -0.044730231165885925, -0.010143383406102657, -0.02121300995349884, -0.06260295957326889, -0.036498717963695526, -0.041159458458423615, -0.017229432240128517, 0.05372195318341255, 0.07752170413732529, -0.015133907087147236, -0.01152105163782835, 0.02621300332248211, -0.04904394969344139, -0.03334440663456917, -0.03821668028831482, 0.039349719882011414, -0.006330567412078381, -0.02219485677778721, 0.03269904851913452, -0.006775415502488613, 0.027228327468037605, 0.013381587341427803, -0.023991381749510765, -0.01880686730146408, 0.022980093955993652, 0.014125700108706951, -0.019356554374098778, -0.007895005866885185, 0.028899522498250008, 0.05535430461168289, -0.04866032674908638, -0.0014909410383552313, -0.052764974534511566, -0.05925381928682327, 0.019236676394939423, -0.056353773921728134, 0.03706258535385132, -0.009667904116213322, -0.025946609675884247, 0.019224081188440323, 0.03091687336564064, -0.02453633025288582, 0.05224981904029846, -0.0395146980881691, 0.05309894308447838, 0.06231880187988281, 0.0003824449086096138, 0.008610174059867859, -0.001924219075590372, 0.04119810834527016, 0.009485268034040928, -0.038282785564661026, -0.0034064871724694967, -0.02181289717555046, -0.03970034047961235, 0.009183540940284729, 0.01783132553100586, -0.041283514350652695, 0.0048921904526650906, 0.04137727990746498, 0.046063557267189026, 0.004076635930687189, 0.0013100621290504932, -0.01858351193368435, -0.011676594614982605, 0.01421069260686636, 0.014802182093262672, 0.033454641699790955, 0.027808697894215584, -0.015815239399671555, 0.02756810002028942, 0.061003729701042175, 0.030897628515958786, -0.019321594387292862, 0.06595897674560547, -0.021067524328827858, 0.0018013915978372097, -0.01713467203080654, -0.0015612486749887466, 0.06064360588788986, -0.0405845120549202, 0.019947506487369537, 0.06100262328982353, 0.0081044165417552, -0.016752304509282112, 0.029597550630569458, -0.02881457842886448, 0.02232416346669197, 0.01762174628674984, -0.00861996877938509, -0.010095449164509773, -0.02515268884599209, -0.013780858367681503, 0.013141797855496407, -0.011317059397697449, -0.01956896483898163, -0.00960827898234129, 0.014722628518939018, 0.062309470027685165, -0.0012712390162050724, 0.025948354974389076, -0.019214754924178123, -0.019731996580958366, -0.00577921699732542, -0.003354274667799473, -0.03282162547111511, 0.0019426689250394702, -0.0672428160905838, -0.04774043336510658, -0.02554582804441452, -0.0012189798289909959, 0.03812522441148758, -0.04036331549286842, -0.01116461493074894, 0.026336219161748886, -0.006996016018092632, -0.015698719769716263, -0.04906269907951355, -0.03529608994722366, -0.002534011611714959, -0.030491584911942482, -0.042898427695035934, 0.047625184059143066, -0.008934334851801395, -0.050289351493120193, 0.0026317001320421696, -0.04553249850869179, -0.014012932777404785, 0.01043110154569149, -0.01306635607033968, -0.016119934618473053, -0.02245122380554676, 0.0067227501422166824, -0.008693673647940159, -0.03366808220744133, 0.0007239914266392589, -0.06227010115981102, -0.04800266772508621, 0.029368899762630463, -0.01046841312199831, 0.05580827221274376, 0.03304751589894295, -0.017600618302822113, 0.07994628697633743, 0.044916894286870956, -0.02261764369904995, -0.06632325053215027, -0.004732919856905937, 0.0007858120952732861, -0.028119077906012535, 0.013609160669147968, 0.015942493453621864, 0.01767589896917343, 0.008584383875131607, -0.039133429527282715, 0.02215070091187954, 0.030738454312086105, 0.022777734324336052, 0.01244138740003109, 0.0335509292781353, -0.014246887527406216, 0.000600273662712425, 0.04565799608826637, 0.017568321898579597, -0.014669126830995083, -0.009020371362566948, 0.00849421788007021, 0.03410585969686508, -0.002612397773191333, -0.04001457989215851, 0.011141226626932621, 0.00487141590565443, 0.025142157450318336, -0.04195527732372284, 0.03769402205944061, 0.03197437524795532, 0.00744619918987155, -0.02353065274655819, -0.019185250625014305, 0.01893012225627899, -0.02270074188709259, -0.0018350784666836262, 0.03802208974957466, 0.034779805690050125, 0.009824253618717194, 0.009108264930546284, -0.03940119594335556, -0.006368225906044245, 0.06264136731624603, -0.05571582168340683, -0.042271196842193604, 0.03801094740629196, 0.05349811166524887, -0.005034008529037237, -0.0019905760418623686, -0.06584779173135757, 0.018297074362635612, -0.08141767978668213, 0.006450247019529343, -0.017911849543452263, 0.04841333627700806, -0.0100396778434515, 0.052218880504369736, 0.031378671526908875, -0.009068897925317287, 0.029142435640096664, 0.019077250733971596, -0.07988234609365463, 0.021417127922177315, -0.033826280385255814, 0.010331204161047935, 0.04042574763298035, -0.03656342625617981, 0.011671770364046097, -0.030563313513994217, 0.018650652840733528, 0.013662030920386314, 0.014099749736487865, -0.035344988107681274, -0.00015055053518153727, -0.029096050187945366, -0.024178314954042435, -0.01131316926330328, 0.010859986767172813, 0.013698142021894455, -0.0030480180867016315, 0.005990194622427225, 0.04404747113585472, -0.026356998831033707, 0.003308400511741638, -0.013799128122627735, -0.006062354426831007, -0.00467442162334919, 0.06023629382252693, 0.033217642456293106, 0.032199010252952576, -0.03682929277420044, 0.026267552748322487, 0.02980789728462696, -0.018826594576239586, 0.04321342706680298, -0.012172410264611244, -0.04228959605097771, -0.031145671382546425, 0.012363984249532223, 0.028728598728775978, 0.0024100574664771557, -0.0018954378319904208, -0.012590880505740643, 0.06458037346601486, -0.0024836843367666006, -0.012223729863762856, 0.03387537971138954, 0.036136604845523834, 0.0500459223985672, -0.007074923254549503, -0.005778963211923838, 0.008425257168710232, -0.009698937647044659, -0.024409333243966103, 0.03237295150756836, 0.003588284133002162, 0.012916765175759792, 0.004386013839393854, -0.011377548798918724, -0.00571122020483017, -0.027022959664463997, 0.02208675444126129, -0.008992546238005161, 0.03187270835042, 0.0073889316990971565, -0.06455618143081665, 0.03559023514389992, 0.06390950828790665, 0.018413588404655457, 0.03652774170041084, -0.008522639982402325, -0.07061037421226501, 0.01903056539595127, 0.024531766772270203, 0.023439517244696617, -0.00733445817604661, -0.00009259359649149701, 0.013057377189397812, -0.027370739728212357, 0.029845822602510452, -0.022839631885290146, 0.032200392335653305, 0.006890233606100082, 0.04070257395505905, -0.022802777588367462, -0.06438501924276352, -0.04416525736451149, 0.04222875460982323, -0.013422529213130474, 0.009126147255301476, -0.006814036052674055, -0.03602185100317001, -0.04369845613837242, 0.010163377039134502, 0.007939757779240608, 0.018219809979200363, -0.027629515156149864, 0.012818588875234127, 0.02252502739429474, 0.0338277630507946, -0.007793033495545387, -0.07120149582624435, -0.021309077739715576, 0.03019591048359871, -0.010305169969797134, 0.04792575538158417, -0.009712256491184235, -0.03736734762787819, 0.028742805123329163, 0.01681618019938469, 0.011259548366069794, 0.0058786701411008835, -0.03722236305475235, 0.07399074733257294, 0.025248579680919647, -0.005623113363981247, 0.04118717461824417, 0.0027782972902059555, -0.009160816669464111, 0.01936749555170536, -0.0382600873708725, 0.02328384667634964, -0.018722841516137123, -0.0770675390958786, -0.025395702570676804, 0.030100341886281967, -0.009074916131794453, 0.046512048691511154, 0.02348095364868641, 0.01661069318652153, -0.04030729457736015, -0.01964464969933033, 0.0015580940525978804, 0.026005912572145462, -0.012308702804148197, 0.011615597642958164, 0.013153820298612118, -0.0018175188452005386, 0.017899755388498306, -0.021574493497610092, -0.01114676520228386, -0.03361690789461136, 0.018485073000192642, -0.00744079053401947, -0.0434599444270134, 0.011800827458500862, -0.005076039582490921, 0.0036076109390705824, 0.03766677528619766, -0.040798310190439224, 0.023178357630968094, 0.017907969653606415, 0.030136846005916595, -0.009383785538375378, -0.049110297113657, 0.00466611934825778, 0.02878853864967823, 0.006981760263442993, 0.03841479867696762, 0.0016171681927517056, 0.01655679941177368, 0.01543724350631237, -0.011732176877558231, -0.04844503477215767, -0.04480108618736267, -0.024132493883371353, 0.014598334208130836, 0.0026608321350067854, 0.011214296333491802, 0.013857885263860226, -0.035201702266931534, -0.0393083319067955, -0.03975548595190048, 0.044927336275577545, -0.04953061416745186, -0.0011283119674772024, 0.005156143102794886, 0.009327460080385208, 0.08080613613128662, -0.031018096953630447, -0.032203055918216705, -0.01722928136587143, 0.0011714192805811763, 0.009096414782106876, -0.020222319290041924, 0.02800031565129757, -0.037615202367305756, -0.07961836457252502, -0.03888577222824097, -0.055101364850997925, 0.050063006579875946, 0.0006987374508753419, -0.03103576973080635, -0.03167698532342911, -0.015399160794913769, -0.005120949819684029, -0.019602617248892784, -0.002934330375865102, 0.01225216407328844, 0.008414406329393387, -0.04788903519511223, -0.0003420396242290735, -0.00381669239141047, -0.008693810552358627, 0.008025710470974445, 0.002541173016652465, -0.011998044326901436, 0.01780964434146881, 0.04718941077589989, -0.011889331974089146, 0.03323780372738838, -0.025851549580693245, -0.007580253761261702, 0.05199248343706131, 0.01495598629117012, 0.04332670569419861, 0.01247425377368927, 0.014617355540394783, 0.010062303394079208, -0.03328317031264305, -0.05340943485498428, 0.00009499362204223871, 0.06562250107526779, 0.005919537041336298, 0.028728019446134567, 0.07179820537567139, -0.02826596610248089, -0.020939141511917114, -0.06693270057439804, 0.010425996035337448, 0.012959484942257404, 0.007945962250232697, 0.05655822902917862, -0.012673799879848957, -0.002914764452725649, 0.0228334479033947, -0.0139333950355649, 0.00939760822802782, 0.018251171335577965, -0.026709264144301414, 0.02394568733870983, 0.017606046050786972, -0.01622164621949196, -0.05287577584385872, 0.02267507277429104, -0.031164299696683884, 0.005107104778289795, -0.01706608198583126, -0.04289136826992035, 0.018496351316571236, 0.021306369453668594, 0.013196625746786594, -0.08175840973854065, -0.04428932070732117, -0.005436476320028305, -0.008573970757424831, 0.004134531132876873, -0.015541765838861465, 0.008827152661979198, -0.005419085267931223, 0.0021131488028913736, 0.003285675775259733, 0.03870895877480507, -0.02226961962878704, -0.0853433683514595, -0.0077309454791247845, -0.006188883446156979, -0.02514205127954483, 0.02520628646016121, -0.0639914944767952, -0.024713607504963875, -0.0020815145689994097, -0.0643489807844162, -0.01196997705847025, 0.013152576051652431, 0.03519086167216301, 0.004593468736857176, 0.0934627503156662, -0.012123842723667622, 0.014306172728538513, -0.01013694703578949, 0.00580747751519084, 0.10714231431484222, 0.06160236522555351, 0.04888617992401123, -0.07048669457435608, 0.025489918887615204, -0.016710635274648666, 0.013002831488847733, -0.03316674381494522, 0.007214343175292015, -0.03415295109152794, -0.0448257178068161, 0.03798964247107506, 0.08261986821889877, 0.0001541524543426931, -0.021675722673535347, 0.03604647517204285, -0.007144554052501917, -0.004562785383313894, -0.008819036185741425, 0.006190043408423662, -0.03594034165143967, 0.015267581678926945, -0.021965214982628822, 0.0018323209369555116, 0.01783657819032669, -0.03646919131278992, -0.005350328050553799, 0.025227712467312813, -0.01293928548693657, -0.023802906274795532, -0.036255184561014175, -0.011502415873110294, 0.00768785597756505, 0.008488797582685947, -0.018725570291280746, 0.009618236683309078, 0.00905038695782423, -0.0685892403125763, 0.038002245128154755, 0.020443325862288475, -0.027648279443383217, 0.0014713642885908484, 0.009508280083537102, -0.026810551062226295, -0.052011068910360336, 0.005629366729408503, -0.03920057415962219, 0.03437124565243721, -0.011945548467338085, -0.02308211289346218, 0.007216391619294882, -0.005073802080005407, 0.006234128028154373, -0.0326884426176548, -0.01957220584154129, 0.017374789342284203, 0.014212684705853462, -0.047873277217149734, -0.034259114414453506, -0.0468992181122303, -0.005236058961600065, 0.010730504989624023, 0.05407506972551346, 0.010898526757955551, -0.053005609661340714, 0.005689192097634077, -0.019830437377095222, 0.03473333641886711, 0.03831086307764053, 0.02134150080382824, -0.0026652731467038393, -0.0017918504308909178, -0.027552351355552673, -0.02161247283220291, 0.04181940108537674, 0.018498143181204796, 0.016001269221305847, 0.024067405611276627, 0.0017414148896932602, -0.06064295768737793, -0.04411192610859871, 0.03087865561246872, -0.019602183252573013, -0.030021393671631813, -0.0288524329662323, -0.016821688041090965, 0.036506250500679016, 0.039290133863687515, 0.003306799568235874, -0.016150373965501785, 0.002986303297802806, 0.05838235467672348, 0.01826903596520424, -0.07394938170909882, -0.022109216079115868, -0.0072954874485731125, -0.04292408749461174, -0.006143441889435053, -0.007052083034068346, 0.013876068405807018, 0.030226411297917366, 0.016182102262973785, -0.022909272462129593, 0.03228921443223953, 0.019215846434235573, 0.01419186219573021, -0.01251847855746746, -0.04466516524553299, 0.021351421251893044, 0.029518989846110344, -0.01221545785665512, -0.01854802668094635, 0.0032798328902572393, -0.06425604969263077, 0.011046239174902439, 0.014578009955585003, -0.02994031272828579, -0.04045445844531059, 0.03218052536249161, 0.017452599480748177, 0.047845326364040375, -0.05202401056885719, -0.013467380777001381, -0.04033702611923218, -0.013837519101798534, 0.032494109123945236, -0.02894391119480133, 0.004814100917428732, 0.011523566208779812, -0.027008866891264915, 0.03709930554032326, 0.042690496891736984, 0.011775938794016838, 0.0020067894365638494, -0.013214954175055027, -0.01950792223215103, 0.009999490343034267, 0.0402366928756237, -0.010487311519682407, -0.009750088676810265, 0.019302090629935265, 0.00417720852419734, -0.0015116508584469557, 0.04444422572851181, -0.02377290278673172, 0.033683616667985916, 0.02458881586790085, 0.023456832394003868, -0.019190145656466484, 0.04862353578209877, -0.007798878476023674, 0.028055723756551743, -0.028365639969706535, 0.006426975131034851, 0.0198653694242239, 0.01972082443535328, 0.01463546883314848, 0.03549441322684288, -0.015890326350927353, 0.011507527902722359, 0.03655508905649185, -0.025596439838409424, 0.021821636706590652, 0.012698614969849586, -0.02776915766298771, -0.005005617626011372, -0.0027408385649323463, -0.016906660050153732, -0.009303564205765724, 0.008634224534034729, -0.02938971109688282, -0.00365196680650115, -0.02299751155078411, 0.03632180765271187, -0.08175055682659149, -0.016357997432351112, 0.02090843766927719, 0.014229926280677319, 0.003295471891760826, -0.027415018528699875, 0.004124326631426811, 0.04723966866731644, -0.07256658375263214, 0.0016724191373214126, 0.0206803809851408, 0.00011153726518386975, -0.02628342993557453, 0.0021757229696959257, 0.005591881461441517, 0.0164510328322649, 0.023249493911862373, 0.026465294882655144, -0.020363599061965942, 0.04778888076543808, 0.025733331218361855, -0.011214107275009155, -0.003161299042403698, -0.024219047278165817, 0.020651476457715034, -0.04928132891654968, 0.036514658480882645, -0.046710941940546036, -0.0345723032951355, 0.06290428340435028, -0.020035525783896446, 0.028418507426977158, 0.017516400665044785, 0.020598841831088066, -0.006890191230922937, 0.013655658811330795, 0.016803091391921043, 0.005489685572683811, -0.000985309132374823, -0.02164241299033165, -0.009562397375702858, 0.020664380863308907, -0.027205469086766243, 0.01671915128827095, -0.009827936068177223, -0.00808291882276535, -0.033785246312618256, -0.0079059898853302, -0.038667548447847366, -0.039963603019714355, 0.004299026448279619, -0.024081094190478325, 0.024107014760375023, 0.02210499718785286, 0.009955110028386116, -0.08512428402900696, -0.02178318239748478, 0.01556962076574564, 0.019896510988473892, -0.053818244487047195, 0.009248561225831509, 0.016966747120022774, -0.04134749621152878, 0.016232207417488098, 0.028448915109038353, -0.02791878767311573, -0.04177740588784218, -0.01621181145310402, 0.022797174751758575, -0.019816115498542786, -0.01554169412702322, 0.02643948420882225, -0.030463699251413345, 0.038319963961839676, -0.03369280695915222, -0.02216852828860283, 0.013683292083442211, -0.029443781822919846, 0.026026804000139236, -0.062424514442682266, 0.06715458631515503, 0.034550148993730545, -0.022535940632224083, -0.03683456778526306, -0.031266648322343826, -0.0469035841524601, 0.024361325427889824, 0.03885193169116974, -0.02322174608707428, 0.017712557688355446, -0.005505391862243414, 0.012848823331296444, 0.0017103623831644654, -0.025833778083324432, 0.04422920569777489, 0.028155602514743805, -0.010558666661381721, 0.013768038712441921, -0.005130762699991465, 0.04514507204294205, -0.007940130308270454, -0.00692356564104557, -0.031292874366045, -0.01351223886013031, 0.026028694584965706, -0.03251098468899727, 0.02830757386982441, -0.003319130279123783, -0.01492349337786436, 0.07142975181341171, 0.008772628381848335, -0.00989606324583292, 0.055846165865659714, -0.010215225629508495, -0.0474088117480278, 0.037132665514945984, 0.018945276737213135, 0.026776297017931938, 0.007631554268300533, 0.047034475952386856, 0.006793531123548746, -0.066260926425457, -0.008647204376757145, 0.02194424532353878, 0.017605768516659737, -0.026416800916194916, 0.03019290417432785, 0.012977544218301773, 0.005376082845032215, 0.04582836106419563, 0.020080020651221275, -0.008637111634016037, -0.0261240154504776, 0.026026098057627678, 0.018327534198760986, 0.061748191714286804, 0.02019396610558033, 0.01259747426956892, 0.033567748963832855, -0.010977443307638168, 0.0506824254989624, -0.00842803344130516, -0.0006709114531986415, -0.04517558962106705, -0.026377558708190918, 0.03840529918670654, 0.024418963119387627, 0.07219862937927246, 0.029617641121149063, -0.007044109515845776, 0.043044526129961014, -0.06161380186676979, 0.006072507705539465, -0.033391498029232025, 0.013787615112960339, -0.0682620108127594, -0.007057987153530121, 0.007106760982424021, 0.012611334212124348, 0.006209698040038347, -0.025143856182694435, 0.012195834890007973, -0.028174415230751038, 0.009823264554142952, 0.011184519156813622, 0.009475808590650558, -0.029096556827425957, -0.017892925068736076, -0.02311154082417488, -0.026865584775805473, -0.029589828103780746, 0.020182248204946518, 0.037710968405008316, 0.039233796298503876, 0.018320482224225998, -0.002107050037011504, 0.012293892912566662, 0.06445809453725815, 0.04886259138584137, -0.09192050248384476, -0.025145290419459343, -0.01309687178581953, 0.023497596383094788, 0.00016185107233468443, -0.05150637775659561 ]
<p>Please consider the following panel dataset:</p> <pre><code>comp obs industry weekDay ind10 ind15 day3 day4 day5 marketRet tweets stockRet ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 1 15 3 0 1 1 0 0 0.10 5321 -0.90 1 2 15 4 0 1 0 1 0 1.30 4244 -0.30 1 3 15 5 0 1 0 0 1 0.90 5543 1.32 2 1 10 3 1 0 1 0 0 0.10 789 0.10 2 2 10 4 1 0 0 1 0 1.30 842 0.16 2 3 10 5 1 0 0 0 1 0.90 734 0.00 </code></pre> <ul> <li>For a list of companies (<code>comp</code>) it describes the number of <code>tweets</code> and the stockreturn (<code>stockRet</code>) for a series of days (<code>obs</code>)</li> <li><code>weekDay</code> gives the day of the week (<code>1</code> = monday, <code>2</code> = tuesday, ...); this has been extracted in dummies <code>day3</code> to <code>day5</code></li> <li><code>industry</code> gives the company industry (<code>15</code> = IT, <code>10</code> = banking, ...); this has been extracted in dummies <code>ind10</code> and <code>ind15</code></li> <li>The final variable (<code>marketRet</code>) gives the average return of the stockmarket that day. Notice that for each day (<code>obs</code>), the market return is the same.</li> </ul> <p><strong>Question 1:</strong> Say I am running an OLS regression with <code>tweets</code> as independent variable and <code>stockRet</code> as dependent. I'm also adding the dummies <code>day3</code> to <code>day5</code> and <code>ind10</code> &amp; <code>ind15</code> to the model as independent variables. Does the model now include, as they say, "fixed effects for industry and day of week"?</p> <p><strong>Question 2:</strong> I have read articles with similar research to mine, and they say they have "added the market return as a control". In SPSS preferably, how do I enter the variable <code>marketRet</code> as a control to the model? Just by adding it as an independent variable?</p> <p><strong>Question 3:</strong> What is the difference between fixed effects and control variables?</p> <p>These questions are probably very basic, but I have not been able to find a clear answer to them. For instance, articles mention they "control for market return" but make no mention of <em>how</em> and <em>why</em> they do so. Thus, any help is greatly appreciated :-)</p>
36,258
[ -0.04830300435423851, -0.009124626405537128, 0.0193027276545763, 0.032002631574869156, 0.04354504123330116, -0.007193064317107201, -0.04237654060125351, -0.021426711231470108, 0.01379809807986021, 0.012773193418979645, 0.04840868338942528, 0.049510493874549866, 0.06881409883499146, 0.05059640854597092, -0.00835565384477377, 0.014619696885347366, -0.0416250042617321, -0.005231170449405909, -0.005733841098845005, 0.0004327080096118152, -0.03480851650238037, 0.012524787336587906, -0.020232388749718666, -0.007534362375736237, -0.02714262530207634, 0.02064630575478077, 0.02763434872031212, 0.020471587777137756, -0.031320422887802124, 0.02826714515686035, -0.03257516026496887, -0.04836873337626457, 0.04289739206433296, 0.007470366079360247, -0.001527048647403717, 0.059129200875759125, 0.030326494947075844, -0.04027951881289482, -0.023308366537094116, -0.02492271549999714, -0.016692621633410454, 0.03370476886630058, -0.008664451539516449, 0.03385251760482788, 0.007620608899742365, 0.027822045609354973, 0.018480423837900162, 0.02633390761911869, -0.010546533390879631, -0.01272063609212637, 0.062303729355335236, -0.03101488947868347, 0.03572065383195877, -0.020598260685801506, -0.05664490908384323, -0.0075010997243225574, 0.018704520538449287, 0.05138622596859932, 0.00242880848236382, -0.06078726425766945, -0.010011410340666771, 0.022304639220237732, -0.005923900753259659, -0.008457467891275883, -0.02139875665307045, 0.04098034277558327, 0.008619865402579308, -0.007257396355271339, 0.050852347165346146, -0.05189962312579155, -0.006918321363627911, -0.00033394037745893, 0.02305537648499012, 0.021501071751117706, 0.046425119042396545, -0.007697252091020346, 0.01174102071672678, 0.001297878916375339, 0.011602486483752728, 0.03662831336259842, 0.00033988512586802244, 0.045822955667972565, 0.029392167925834656, 0.01603272370994091, 0.07529830187559128, 0.001113592996262014, 0.0546964667737484, -0.041415952146053314, 0.04363647848367691, 0.019332818686962128, 0.01394908968359232, 0.00892997533082962, 0.049088556319475174, 0.050367582589387894, -0.03772847726941109, 0.06833494454622269, 0.02814331278204918, -0.012873527593910694, -0.010899142362177372, -0.023092221468687057, -0.03212070092558861, -0.03899424523115158, 0.013953722082078457, 0.008599134162068367, 0.013418500311672688, -0.0011600498110055923, -0.02723812311887741, -0.03015662357211113, -0.03538278490304947, -0.023527871817350388, -0.0014720304170623422, 0.03142435848712921, -0.020073052495718002, -0.027721986174583435, 0.012171979993581772, -0.06306908279657364, 0.027684936299920082, 0.04454122483730316, 0.04896002635359764, 0.03545777499675751, 0.021677695214748383, -0.0039175646379590034, 0.02428271248936653, -0.03215014562010765, -0.06810487061738968, 0.018187029287219048, 0.004206058569252491, -0.009772284887731075, -0.04900447651743889, 0.062324415892362595, -0.009610995650291443, 0.0006845869356766343, 0.018746426329016685, -0.0282940361648798, 0.018216589465737343, 0.027862831950187683, -0.05898679792881012, -0.06291477382183075, 0.03999742120504379, 0.006884571630507708, 0.009705562144517899, -0.03994307294487953, 0.0005180333973839879, 0.018708238378167152, 0.02035394310951233, 0.018677547574043274, 0.033642932772636414, 0.006618599407374859, -0.00820566900074482, 0.012340259738266468, 0.002995547140017152, 0.014754671603441238, -0.0378805547952652, -0.03591649979352951, 0.012103821150958538, -0.042106665670871735, 0.01246988121420145, 0.021253932267427444, -0.006261828355491161, 0.022901277989149094, -0.002189736347645521, 0.00967023428529501, -0.01260985154658556, -0.01730448193848133, -0.040050141513347626, -0.06641387939453125, 0.015132702887058258, 0.01632995903491974, 0.00851668231189251, 0.03489105775952339, -0.02391366846859455, -0.004529363941401243, -0.0064946734346449375, 0.03137284517288208, 0.02816586196422577, -0.029748443514108658, -0.019764704629778862, -0.03293348476290703, 0.007429786957800388, 0.00584547920152545, -0.03685399517416954, -0.043159328401088715, -0.07818181067705154, 0.006264237221330404, 0.0444299653172493, 0.002613110700622201, 0.008915087208151817, -0.03227359801530838, 0.019199131056666374, -0.06911485642194748, -0.03778461739420891, -0.03398410230875015, 0.028356244787573814, -0.03373272344470024, -0.054231300950050354, -0.04167791083455086, 0.019144248217344284, 0.01971552148461342, 0.012475208379328251, -0.012438099831342697, 0.005963713396340609, -0.007919625379145145, 0.07358404248952866, -0.023708343505859375, -0.015622688457369804, 0.012499017640948296, 0.05279889702796936, -0.011108210310339928, 0.0027986420318484306, 0.0025062670465558767, -0.04532059282064438, -0.00054665602510795, -0.06039438769221306, 0.008844248950481415, -0.00433366047218442, -0.011274348944425583, 0.044335223734378815, 0.006266712211072445, -0.033425748348236084, 0.017273686826229095, -0.03672543913125992, 0.05677828565239906, 0.06493566930294037, -0.010377343744039536, 0.019492071121931076, -0.0435999296605587, -0.0057532768696546555, 0.07254399359226227, 0.0017011266900226474, 0.028466641902923584, -0.0583561472594738, 0.013731682673096657, 0.0111472113057971, -0.005964715965092182, -0.003512537106871605, 0.017310205847024918, 0.07614712417125702, -0.011245259083807468, -0.02085644192993641, 0.05105356127023697, -0.008430561050772667, 0.007376271765679121, 0.022121205925941467, -0.009623895399272442, 0.015155341476202011, -0.025183875113725662, 0.03645176813006401, -0.024253616109490395, 0.002104405080899596, 0.00828397274017334, 0.011799479834735394, 0.026022354140877724, -0.024678153917193413, 0.00002616149686218705, -0.04207850992679596, -0.04385088384151459, 0.046381354331970215, -0.004900822881609201, -0.05393162742257118, 0.022040214389562607, -0.007869194261729717, -0.01646995171904564, 0.012923614121973515, -0.020232144743204117, -0.021676015108823776, 0.0038487943820655346, -0.03780630975961685, -0.01943131722509861, 0.035696715116500854, -0.04716798663139343, -0.004991802386939526, -0.004541190341114998, 0.010566001757979393, -0.04574687406420708, -0.0003633822489064187, 0.028897499665617943, -0.021595681086182594, 0.01994425430893898, -0.028271952643990517, 0.012326660566031933, -0.009175515733659267, -0.025343172252178192, 0.03110668435692787, -0.0020455345511436462, -0.04225144535303116, 0.022895153611898422, -0.016007570549845695, -0.035422053188085556, 0.02002343349158764, 0.03341099992394447, -0.04411611706018448, 0.03401903435587883, 0.019069518893957138, -0.018435148522257805, -0.019458124414086342, -0.044510576874017715, 0.03658119589090347, -0.05976305902004242, -0.03110283613204956, 0.04393996670842171, -0.029780879616737366, -0.05192117765545845, -0.003770038252696395, -0.04710569605231285, -0.030969327315688133, 0.0026857436168938875, -0.023061098530888557, 0.014096059836447239, 0.0035748151130974293, -0.024083895608782768, 0.023549748584628105, 0.0027386995498090982, -0.0159364715218544, -0.07663226872682571, -0.05901695042848587, -0.0064646899700164795, -0.012306666933000088, -0.025733575224876404, -0.0006084182532504201, -0.03195984661579132, 0.061389319598674774, 0.017401527613401413, -0.0548824779689312, -0.05173241347074509, 0.001098523149266839, -0.022659318521618843, -0.02314164489507675, 0.027690734714269638, 0.03736597299575806, 0.04274331405758858, -0.027049392461776733, -0.015873469412326813, 0.056625112891197205, 0.07644297927618027, -0.010486076585948467, 0.024030160158872604, -0.0007938501657918096, -0.029505612328648567, -0.026621563360095024, 0.016693534329533577, 0.011778832413256168, -0.016395170241594315, 0.005385539494454861, 0.0328739732503891, 0.03609437122941017, -0.014513682574033737, -0.028643300756812096, 0.015149079263210297, -0.015330263413488865, 0.00923463050276041, -0.017231838777661324, 0.051671501249074936, 0.002930557122454047, -0.044558800756931305, -0.02887442149221897, 0.023213190957903862, 0.05437855049967766, -0.02940652333199978, 0.006518468260765076, 0.06089628487825394, 0.015405518002808094, -0.023833615705370903, 0.002251572208479047, -0.039652712643146515, -0.022289134562015533, 0.00578331807628274, -0.07173149287700653, -0.008167092688381672, 0.04767879471182823, 0.04424312338232994, 0.02167716808617115, -0.0020207574125379324, -0.060817569494247437, 0.00012976674770470709, -0.0664636492729187, 0.008134111762046814, -0.019185692071914673, 0.07644117623567581, 0.04043932259082794, 0.04795040935277939, 0.018219338729977608, 0.03268147259950638, -0.016506850719451904, -0.0329212062060833, -0.048136502504348755, 0.015810541808605194, 0.02020173706114292, 0.004973165225237608, -0.010459025390446186, -0.031241517513990402, 0.03515338897705078, -0.011445101350545883, 0.00866928230971098, 0.021650414913892746, 0.02274940349161625, -0.038502831012010574, 0.033844955265522, 0.0044855414889752865, -0.01576409488916397, 0.010361630469560623, -0.008750650100409985, 0.05464154854416847, 0.028018426150083542, 0.04184624180197716, 0.028988154605031013, 0.0012694409815594554, -0.005752554628998041, -0.01334313116967678, -0.010863219387829304, 0.002351411385461688, 0.023805327713489532, 0.043991975486278534, 0.017225870862603188, -0.02243528701364994, 0.03790507838129997, -0.008820703253149986, 0.02072249725461006, 0.04275725409388542, 0.0026545280124992132, 0.02178865857422352, -0.01712079904973507, 0.003735733451321721, 0.018764372915029526, 0.012243332341313362, -0.026019155979156494, -0.010522947646677494, 0.04903065040707588, 0.05130491778254509, -0.014625470153987408, 0.014779608696699142, 0.1054910197854042, 0.012605422176420689, -0.014181958511471748, -0.030540604144334793, -0.00457413075491786, 0.0033680787310004234, 0.00861586257815361, 0.04678834602236748, 0.05223128944635391, 0.003527451539412141, 0.03303889185190201, 0.006295184604823589, -0.02318236604332924, -0.042770564556121826, 0.046452924609184265, 0.0013257800601422787, 0.02918250858783722, -0.017062468454241753, -0.01403516624122858, 0.00492279464378953, 0.05239003151655197, 0.03708105906844139, 0.029076313599944115, 0.00033118569990620017, -0.10652878135442734, 0.012495961040258408, 0.05242689326405525, 0.07174515724182129, -0.018242202699184418, -0.00449539115652442, -0.0394592247903347, 0.034685391932725906, -0.0008546636672690511, 0.005038688890635967, 0.042459845542907715, -0.010105800814926624, 0.007268882822245359, -0.006705822888761759, -0.005230904556810856, -0.03626884147524834, -0.008736307732760906, -0.06196674332022667, 0.0416027270257473, 0.01850922405719757, -0.051778893917798996, -0.06702535599470139, 0.030689489096403122, -0.003111644648015499, 0.002150358632206917, -0.0756404772400856, -0.004703890066593885, -0.011791110038757324, -0.00716474000364542, -0.04514386132359505, -0.0584806427359581, -0.014684700407087803, -0.0045383586548268795, -0.028241895139217377, 0.06125437468290329, 0.02030562423169613, -0.05102170258760452, -0.018017981201410294, 0.05124858766794205, 0.02263534814119339, -0.02995527721941471, -0.05226366966962814, 0.016592485830187798, 0.006179188843816519, 0.0033596246503293514, 0.02907874993979931, 0.03289656713604927, -0.005807447712868452, 0.04554931819438934, -0.050964660942554474, -0.018278611823916435, -0.00541596719995141, -0.013437513262033463, -0.02167319506406784, -0.013880808837711811, 0.006813751067966223, -0.004716092720627785, -0.022534510120749474, 0.017141547054052353, -0.04360729455947876, -0.007694878149777651, -0.008501474745571613, 0.014029249548912048, -0.04149880260229111, -0.057662468403577805, -0.03686096891760826, 0.009050421416759491, -0.020438717678189278, 0.004144355654716492, 0.006201992277055979, -0.04942595213651657, 0.040856748819351196, -0.002610130002722144, -0.009999020956456661, -0.004996202886104584, -0.004515193868428469, 0.005958638619631529, 0.00577292637899518, -0.003021937096491456, 0.009433289058506489, -0.013981985859572887, 0.04675229638814926, -0.008858108893036842, 0.010300656780600548, -0.009265320375561714, -0.007529974449425936, -0.01093896385282278, -0.014765842817723751, -0.01539864856749773, 0.036475688219070435, 0.022188197821378708, -0.06319581717252731, -0.04792335629463196, -0.0405820868909359, 0.016771823167800903, 0.03711479902267456, -0.051709599792957306, -0.02670910395681858, -0.04183349385857582, -0.009978367015719414, 0.007760325446724892, 0.005909498780965805, 0.012645856477320194, -0.026215363293886185, 0.00024160565226338804, -0.025194628164172173, -0.024179330095648766, 0.09311462193727493, -0.00623658811673522, -0.0024795003701001406, 0.026600325480103493, 0.004720472730696201, 0.004711272194981575, -0.012787869200110435, 0.007446678820997477, -0.03355945274233818, -0.034535884857177734, -0.0239876676350832, -0.021512115374207497, 0.055217623710632324, -0.00286109559237957, -0.005313769448548555, 0.005397250410169363, -0.00559120811522007, -0.032472509890794754, -0.019985150545835495, 0.001233526854775846, 0.01552166324108839, 0.018231047317385674, -0.0494547002017498, 0.03170202299952507, -0.016885073855519295, -0.015282467938959599, -0.012769510969519615, -0.00969521701335907, -0.012698511593043804, 0.031001664698123932, 0.07420038431882858, -0.011306686326861382, 0.003689172677695751, -0.00021978117001708597, -0.012035606428980827, 0.05873536318540573, -0.02956615574657917, 0.02907191403210163, -0.008609042502939701, 0.04925619810819626, -0.04111584275960922, -0.03530057519674301, -0.04219352826476097, 0.043419379740953445, 0.031578730791807175, -0.006238156463950872, 0.031683631241321564, 0.06653342396020889, 0.01111619733273983, 0.006852178834378719, -0.03496774286031723, -0.015810664743185043, -0.0038121440447866917, -0.015561153180897236, 0.05847422778606415, 0.044915586709976196, -0.037095144391059875, 0.06265337020158768, -0.014418305829167366, 0.03677336499094963, 0.01822449080646038, 0.01861054077744484, -0.0011412014719098806, -0.01311942096799612, -0.019802674651145935, -0.03465908393263817, 0.0009920442244037986, -0.034613218158483505, 0.044213905930519104, -0.04211602360010147, -0.0035513273905962706, 0.025703663006424904, 0.035577744245529175, -0.028911970555782318, -0.051667023450136185, -0.006684889551252127, -0.05856911838054657, 0.02994443289935589, 0.033812034875154495, -0.01030746940523386, 0.004379265010356903, 0.012054989114403725, 0.06563347578048706, -0.013256214559078217, 0.04173941910266876, -0.014952936209738255, -0.05920782685279846, -0.002202168107032776, -0.015316364355385303, -0.03141574189066887, 0.05445064231753349, -0.015973109751939774, 0.02492734231054783, 0.03015071339905262, -0.057365939021110535, -0.003455418860539794, 0.012049220502376556, 0.02374299056828022, 0.012611540965735912, 0.0901380181312561, 0.007284891791641712, -0.01958194188773632, -0.00844095554202795, -0.010107436217367649, 0.16477401554584503, 0.08853476494550705, 0.0060031237080693245, -0.027094367891550064, 0.010789536871016026, 0.04234488680958748, -0.0019023241475224495, -0.02666352316737175, 0.00946023315191269, -0.005065355449914932, 0.01228355709463358, 0.04430116340517998, 0.046528078615665436, 0.02715439163148403, 0.003479030216112733, -0.014286029152572155, -0.06496904790401459, 0.009852666407823563, 0.006535973399877548, 0.02250293456017971, 0.015494267456233501, -0.009041828103363514, -0.096774160861969, -0.020119236782193184, 0.0358671173453331, 0.00807227473706007, 0.012371471151709557, -0.006442277692258358, -0.03218906745314598, -0.01641259528696537, -0.04702608659863472, 0.01753784716129303, 0.023992272093892097, 0.018290746957063675, 0.0167874526232481, -0.001525915926322341, 0.0433247908949852, -0.03273112699389458, -0.0026335131842643023, 0.02427842654287815, -0.017565658316016197, 0.005556269083172083, -0.02693176083266735, 0.03800204396247864, -0.0347289964556694, -0.0030796134378761053, -0.0476168617606163, 0.010557778179645538, -0.007415343541651964, -0.03838571906089783, -0.01371215283870697, 0.01716003194451332, 0.0014656777493655682, -0.014713133685290813, -0.002046319656074047, 0.04369108006358147, 0.011965112760663033, 0.007120639085769653, -0.003849338972941041, -0.007413364946842194, 0.027348970994353294, 0.00762378191575408, 0.03776892274618149, 0.024237053468823433, -0.0026502760592848063, -0.016620861366391182, -0.010050579905509949, 0.06351839751005173, -0.012581557035446167, 0.021692117676138878, -0.0015212009893730283, -0.017214423045516014, -0.0232332032173872, -0.0008117040270008147, 0.015553371980786324, 0.021705083549022675, -0.03753555193543434, 0.03653867915272713, -0.002571035409346223, -0.026843398809432983, -0.010591288097202778, 0.031249964609742165, 0.015131051652133465, -0.04514162987470627, -0.05628643184900284, 0.016352517530322075, 0.016996903344988823, 0.03893093392252922, 0.008540946990251541, 0.013582407496869564, -0.016624392941594124, 0.07883123308420181, 0.008132180199027061, -0.037893690168857574, -0.022572247311472893, -0.0012765853898599744, -0.004013068042695522, -0.015581075102090836, 0.014333621598780155, 0.06825276464223862, 0.04803586006164551, -0.0002478709793649614, -0.011278605088591576, 0.028582226485013962, -0.01927866041660309, 0.010836267843842506, 0.022523917257785797, -0.05507699027657509, 0.0075720432214438915, 0.044813986867666245, -0.01390920765697956, -0.04026217386126518, 0.0031614413019269705, -0.009576736018061638, -0.040300533175468445, 0.010737083852291107, 0.004288962576538324, -0.049966149032115936, -0.007349015679210424, -0.0038835632149130106, 0.050012778490781784, -0.03198520094156265, 0.0016925008967518806, -0.040994297713041306, -0.02600022219121456, -0.0015574448043480515, -0.05006994307041168, -0.0037971995770931244, 0.03984777629375458, -0.013696364127099514, 0.02246146649122238, 0.02372334711253643, 0.04703253135085106, 0.004034981597214937, -0.0028216498903930187, 0.010720188729465008, -0.02503199316561222, 0.0005412929458543658, 0.00004466359314392321, -0.019185664132237434, 0.018321391195058823, -0.013131115585565567, -0.012425358407199383, 0.004205009900033474, -0.013849174603819847, 0.07851346582174301, -0.012292662635445595, 0.02339114435017109, -0.006011747755110264, 0.0348440520465374, -0.020841579884290695, 0.005376701708883047, -0.019792066887021065, -0.00523596303537488, 0.0645894855260849, -0.015625521540641785, -0.02331109717488289, 0.05107574164867401, -0.0185293760150671, 0.005152029916644096, 0.035383325070142746, 0.017009882256388664, -0.005999580025672913, 0.01076962985098362, 0.00346210110001266, -0.01736862026154995, 0.049799028784036636, -0.03068392537534237, 0.028223862871527672, 0.028974860906600952, -0.01866810768842697, 0.02183021605014801, -0.017953213304281235, 0.00010734449460869655, -0.06659422814846039, -0.007291870191693306, 0.01635148748755455, -0.023327108472585678, 0.033886272460222244, -0.02801995538175106, 0.01626286283135414, 0.0059514823369681835, -0.018991298973560333, 0.04086294770240784, 0.02033616043627262, -0.025558048859238625, -0.022237179800868034, 0.046781182289123535, -0.03171314299106598, 0.037477944046258926, 0.01899496465921402, -0.004368718713521957, 0.049327608197927475, 0.005392844323068857, 0.03304329887032509, -0.01984386332333088, -0.005572174210101366, -0.01010861899703741, 0.002867023693397641, -0.04193045198917389, 0.02859981544315815, -0.06327121704816818, 0.026136238127946854, -0.014061735942959785, -0.013709556311368942, -0.006128306500613689, 0.0061799753457307816, 0.009975609369575977, 0.012737458571791649, 0.045271001756191254, 0.005362815223634243, 0.02152182348072529, -0.01106635108590126, 0.01600750908255577, 0.007697919383645058, 0.009402994997799397, 0.025095559656620026, 0.027928581461310387, 0.042323656380176544, 0.0031590498983860016, 0.0009251896408386528, -0.01632297784090042, -0.004291737452149391, -0.017044510692358017, -0.03525232896208763, -0.006857687141746283, -0.003842027857899666, -0.011989202350378036, -0.004232423380017281, -0.0335688441991806, 0.020021971315145493, -0.0018755816854536533, 0.035723887383937836, -0.03065609559416771, 0.001166009926237166, -0.005376833491027355, -0.021039515733718872, 0.005471633281558752, 0.024197708815336227, 0.00002815630432451144, 0.0034396967384964228, -0.037384167313575745, 0.043265145272016525, -0.0038053132593631744, -0.0379331074655056, 0.04388449341058731, 0.016837801784276962, 0.011509514413774014, -0.0011746095260605216, 0.009738118387758732, 0.019683606922626495, -0.015877071768045425, 0.020199451595544815, -0.11755535006523132, 0.05084189027547836, 0.015707094222307205, -0.017890140414237976, -0.03970886394381523, -0.03079069033265114, -0.04712340235710144, 0.015690216794610023, 0.03621801733970642, 0.011179019697010517, 0.008924810215830803, -0.03328202664852142, -0.003287628758698702, -0.008017567917704582, -0.044337496161460876, 0.06430979073047638, -0.002665153704583645, -0.03158619627356529, -0.003761827014386654, -0.005599418189376593, -0.009363995864987373, 0.03766808286309242, 0.011666522361338139, -0.007368871942162514, -0.03774821013212204, 0.008907550945878029, -0.022912705317139626, -0.004406968597322702, -0.0235208198428154, -0.030206674709916115, 0.04516718164086342, 0.03715803474187851, -0.020922774448990822, 0.040041543543338776, -0.013075241819024086, -0.05975791811943054, 0.04633954539895058, -0.05080509930849075, -0.010751231573522091, -0.010609019547700882, 0.019397171214222908, 0.020559798926115036, -0.05724163353443146, 0.021336469799280167, -0.009899253956973553, -0.007112301420420408, 0.036571912467479706, 0.025567399337887764, -0.014613648876547813, 0.03024420514702797, 0.0021574459969997406, 0.015275678597390652, 0.00872719381004572, -0.021674929186701775, -0.015278611332178116, -0.006220848299562931, 0.05202391743659973, -0.00421260017901659, 0.008738942444324493, 0.027854295447468758, -0.0013872503768652678, 0.03217339515686035, -0.042567938566207886, 0.00861776527017355, -0.025288423523306847, -0.04152558743953705, 0.004593979567289352, -0.005836604628711939, -0.008882534690201283, 0.042928215116262436, 0.004991104360669851, 0.02439889870584011, -0.053826555609703064, 0.04974057897925377, -0.02929115481674671, 0.0053707873448729515, -0.002612941199913621, 0.03896302729845047, 0.025192903354763985, 0.028692912310361862, -0.012262607924640179, -0.00943092443048954, 0.0011457009240984917, 0.01747444085776806, -0.000929996429476887, -0.013983814977109432, 0.023318396881222725, 0.01396179385483265, 0.003786977846175432, 0.01014371681958437, -0.0076707834377884865, -0.05104740709066391, -0.06831526011228561, 0.022239360958337784, 0.017156237736344337, -0.04785595089197159, -0.0125522930175066, -0.017156662419438362, 0.007481392938643694, 0.036569226533174515, -0.057825978845357895, 0.007172105833888054, -0.04939426854252815, 0.025495760142803192, -0.006351596675813198, -0.00317412824369967 ]
<p>Given min and max values, how can I estimate shape parameter (tail index) of data generated by truncated pareto distribution ? I see a package tpareto but find no information on how to estimate tail index from given data.</p> <p>kindly help.</p>
36,260
[ -0.019179098308086395, -0.0034742066636681557, 0.033204928040504456, 0.0030563920736312866, 0.040147218853235245, 0.04911104589700699, -0.009333297610282898, -0.010905441828072071, 0.01115968357771635, -0.04909992218017578, 0.030331768095493317, 0.04309261962771416, -0.0042200093157589436, 0.020043203607201576, 0.03808228299021721, -0.005861692130565643, -0.059565018862485886, 0.021707015112042427, -0.0009131748811341822, -0.04479742795228958, -0.01324403751641512, 0.01833619363605976, 0.017737437039613724, -0.013139067217707634, -0.01788223721086979, 0.02434631437063217, 0.026032887399196625, -0.015529902651906013, -0.003716870676726103, 0.0835430771112442, -0.04702066257596016, -0.05889924615621567, 0.026061011478304863, 0.03778253123164177, -0.007645747158676386, -0.006439561489969492, -0.05833394452929497, -0.025991220027208328, -0.024648401886224747, 0.01658698171377182, -0.010364492423832417, -0.0115188704803586, -0.00016347570635844022, 0.007411041297018528, 0.011656238697469234, 0.02130904793739319, -0.01990952529013157, -0.049066029489040375, 0.026729093864560127, -0.0462387353181839, 0.08150258660316467, 0.017210043966770172, 0.02434532716870308, -0.006493482738733292, -0.005680536385625601, 0.002324588829651475, 0.05717262625694275, 0.08497685939073563, -0.012074677273631096, -0.0742856040596962, -0.011445236392319202, -0.04917741194367409, 0.005105908028781414, -0.023469870910048485, -0.023410143330693245, 0.013153829611837864, -0.026303492486476898, -0.015560310333967209, 0.018336815759539604, 0.0024746584240347147, -0.012513245455920696, -0.0004512237792368978, 0.025275880470871925, 0.021029118448495865, 0.03649667650461197, -0.03560179844498634, 0.023382000625133514, -0.011726496741175652, 0.0749872475862503, 0.04598201811313629, 0.021869556978344917, 0.03345843777060509, -0.006857233587652445, 0.028353290632367134, -0.013316786848008633, 0.013045981526374817, 0.05781667307019234, -0.029799360781908035, 0.019238363951444626, 0.021342318505048752, -0.034352391958236694, -0.02584698051214218, 0.04191191866993904, -0.027745554223656654, -0.022454634308815002, 0.028332239016890526, 0.022776447236537933, 0.022085821256041527, -0.0250849649310112, -0.026644393801689148, 0.006800246424973011, -0.05335794389247894, -0.04194248467683792, 0.04100155830383301, -0.0010505004320293665, 0.015557617880403996, -0.014811467379331589, -0.008384129963815212, -0.03727809712290764, 0.0072365375235676765, -0.0022256276570260525, 0.0005632467218674719, -0.00828841608017683, 0.002037912141531706, 0.026006005704402924, -0.0003179992490913719, 0.004559161141514778, -0.03175194561481476, 0.0449911430478096, 0.03479940816760063, 0.0282138604670763, -0.011779471300542355, -0.003430716460570693, -0.03105642832815647, -0.049419086426496506, 0.006252829451113939, 0.05763743072748184, -0.018289413303136826, -0.052611373364925385, 0.023633461445569992, 0.004171593114733696, -0.03374210000038147, 0.08112779259681702, -0.0014828294515609741, 0.030261078849434853, 0.021491117775440216, -0.06857956945896149, -0.04003806784749031, 0.0002064329310087487, -0.016407614573836327, -0.0022429279051721096, -0.0659981220960617, -0.004260054789483547, 0.028415514156222343, 0.04457443580031395, -0.003981899935752153, 0.042276058346033096, 0.0543634258210659, -0.002224887255579233, -0.01954643428325653, -0.02226591482758522, 0.0008673404809087515, -0.010914587415754795, -0.006336406338959932, 0.010737290605902672, -0.07068318873643875, 0.006987735163420439, -0.0021709471475332975, -0.026900285854935646, -0.013229022733867168, 0.055666469037532806, -0.006318274419754744, -0.02252659946680069, -0.010049255564808846, 0.014075630344450474, -0.026865698397159576, 0.08760517090559006, 0.009142094291746616, 0.016331952065229416, 0.005126796662807465, -0.021419746801257133, -0.0028769448399543762, 0.03174624964594841, 0.03734077140688896, 0.04550855606794357, -0.03395251929759979, -0.02407296933233738, -0.033734772354364395, -0.007411811035126448, 0.031445227563381195, -0.03314020112156868, -0.029007678851485252, 0.022421272471547127, 0.012679598294198513, 0.04747174307703972, 0.0071091721765697, -0.00764436786994338, -0.03714095428586006, 0.054271310567855835, -0.05812789499759674, -0.02510490082204342, -0.03775162622332573, -0.05956018716096878, 0.023552613332867622, -0.00778061430901289, 0.004996198695152998, 0.002276348415762186, -0.00017969506734516472, -0.029539750888943672, 0.019629180431365967, -0.015154389664530754, 0.015122590586543083, 0.044778719544410706, -0.015103979967534542, -0.009106372483074665, 0.05970770865678787, 0.05826019495725632, -0.015361307188868523, 0.025154313072562218, -0.016739806160330772, -0.0394916832447052, 0.012649400159716606, -0.052513487637043, 0.01808878406882286, -0.0199844129383564, -0.019214779138565063, 0.002520479029044509, 0.007489678915590048, -0.0024072080850601196, 0.0016501485370099545, -0.020994242280721664, 0.05748351663351059, 0.10076431930065155, 0.036644965410232544, 0.016514871269464493, -0.03979450464248657, 0.0269188079982996, 0.019065244123339653, -0.04233437776565552, -0.0017250524833798409, -0.03596862033009529, -0.03305027633905411, 0.04244865104556084, 0.0035952969919890165, -0.06183943152427673, 0.018950048834085464, 0.05640539526939392, -0.028519246727228165, 0.05709688365459442, 0.04082275554537773, -0.019043568521738052, -0.007972239516675472, 0.01012872252613306, 0.015641357749700546, 0.014246373437345028, 0.010111394338309765, 0.018366798758506775, 0.025914514437317848, 0.04078672453761101, -0.02929532341659069, 0.001363507006317377, 0.01392399426549673, 0.004472288768738508, -0.026312796398997307, -0.016698798164725304, -0.03628996014595032, 0.024512838572263718, -0.04544913396239281, 0.004113537259399891, 0.030734602361917496, -0.0018409318290650845, 0.01851366087794304, 0.020244726911187172, -0.004384794272482395, 0.016695838421583176, 0.04124859720468521, -0.02294609323143959, -0.010506732389330864, 0.019900327548384666, -0.02116711065173149, 0.016721397638320923, 0.004435631446540356, -0.025138739496469498, -0.02332594059407711, 0.052606791257858276, 0.08191853761672974, 0.003111792029812932, -0.019565168768167496, 0.023661786690354347, -0.04249722510576248, 0.022912468761205673, 0.001782535226084292, 0.026361076161265373, 0.015473616309463978, -0.05398497357964516, -0.00237010745331645, -0.03975071385502815, -0.03188367560505867, 0.01655171811580658, 0.018407590687274933, 0.02978675253689289, 0.0071650599129498005, 0.0004535806947387755, -0.03357333689928055, -0.008092989213764668, -0.0150830103084445, 0.030164603143930435, -0.020492911338806152, 0.006087953224778175, 0.01808338239789009, 0.020475508645176888, -0.011834381148219109, 0.02926746942102909, -0.042435646057128906, -0.03787796199321747, -0.05019043758511543, 0.027302473783493042, 0.005097375251352787, 0.03757064789533615, 0.04339759051799774, 0.04206850007176399, 0.026865581050515175, -0.0001960909430636093, -0.06634565442800522, -0.04950638487935066, 0.020649459213018417, 0.0021091050002723932, 0.018956303596496582, -0.003487352514639497, -0.051902998238801956, 0.0752161294221878, 0.005361787974834442, -0.013018052093684673, -0.03397975116968155, -0.01432389672845602, 0.004462722688913345, -0.004360271152108908, -0.0018966341158375144, -0.008266578428447247, 0.025143751874566078, -0.00898970477283001, 0.005008908919990063, 0.01738898642361164, 0.047070249915122986, 0.02063068374991417, -0.02479402907192707, 0.005404151510447264, -0.00358106498606503, -0.0294853076338768, 0.031076066195964813, 0.020803481340408325, -0.0013053647708147764, 0.027394436299800873, -0.009859233163297176, 0.024235868826508522, -0.009228562004864216, -0.035078514367341995, 0.01117508765310049, -0.023645224049687386, -0.0050565623678267, -0.021710066124796867, 0.021211501210927963, 0.029722265899181366, -0.003777408506721258, -0.002805511001497507, 0.012015745975077152, 0.04779578745365143, -0.03518231213092804, 0.01919572986662388, 0.02645176276564598, 0.0125798424705863, -0.02768225409090519, -0.022164370864629745, -0.01123770046979189, -0.04367296025156975, 0.0005196519778110087, -0.018344873562455177, -0.02018607035279274, 0.0018802628619596362, 0.05200144648551941, 0.0364655964076519, 0.014858967624604702, -0.007231004536151886, 0.031114140525460243, -0.05597745627164841, 0.003856500145047903, -0.026153739541769028, 0.06823458522558212, 0.005047142039984465, 0.03333694860339165, 0.028202587738633156, 0.030655810609459877, 0.0026515063364058733, 0.004000469110906124, -0.06865168362855911, 0.012184853665530682, -0.034634705632925034, -0.01037091389298439, -0.019125280901789665, -0.02516748569905758, 0.029937084764242172, 0.006004496477544308, 0.024440819397568703, -0.012275885790586472, 0.016703542321920395, -0.03463616594672203, 0.01099421363323927, -0.026260770857334137, 0.005284836981445551, 0.01819027028977871, 0.03053301014006138, 0.011639535427093506, -0.025979015976190567, 0.03565368056297302, 0.04648056998848915, -0.015512769110500813, 0.00045714524458162487, -0.020207036286592484, 0.017266105860471725, 0.0014830303844064474, 0.02912895567715168, -0.0015817176317796111, 0.020946305245161057, -0.0620553120970726, 0.030186008661985397, -0.02326769195497036, 0.09991893917322159, 0.0456872433423996, 0.01333646196871996, -0.013439672999083996, -0.050850749015808105, 0.013377772644162178, 0.001633048290386796, -0.000792213249951601, -0.026553887873888016, 0.004098231438547373, 0.054333578795194626, 0.004845834337174892, -0.08570004999637604, 0.009168819524347782, 0.050796348601579666, 0.05009935423731804, -0.0015750611200928688, -0.04160855710506439, -0.010922836139798164, -0.03519158437848091, -0.05387822538614273, 0.009704258292913437, 0.006186813581734896, -0.0352446623146534, 0.020516354590654373, 0.023337967693805695, -0.010607416741549969, -0.027399342507123947, -0.03221207484602928, 0.046357713639736176, 0.058313291519880295, -0.02998606488108635, -0.019475363194942474, 0.014234138652682304, 0.01215517520904541, 0.007865970954298973, 0.009159553796052933, -0.005275222938507795, -0.07181932032108307, 0.008722452446818352, 0.08078958839178085, 0.03982421010732651, -0.01720329001545906, -0.0006107045337557793, -0.07106975466012955, -0.009698343463242054, 0.03146734833717346, -0.05283614620566368, 0.02102004364132881, -0.005958850961178541, -0.007539981510490179, 0.0010915278689935803, 0.014792690053582191, -0.029981378465890884, 0.02355075068771839, -0.02355165407061577, -0.008837372995913029, -0.0684208944439888, 0.0010637077502906322, -0.032871849834918976, 0.00018087259377352893, 0.00401612464338541, 0.04525917395949364, 0.027948029339313507, -0.012159048579633236, 0.03309861570596695, 0.019498713314533234, -0.03786483407020569, -0.05933130159974098, 0.007933786138892174, -0.019320441409945488, 0.02006741426885128, 0.05317787081003189, 0.017222179099917412, -0.015578906051814556, 0.06475547701120377, 0.002074532676488161, -0.008718536235392094, -0.009636628441512585, -0.02385236695408821, 0.042118292301893234, 0.0257533248513937, -0.012855062261223793, 0.045917823910713196, 0.026608439162373543, 0.015021983534097672, -0.014925018884241581, -0.01793244108557701, 0.01771114021539688, -0.0321473553776741, -0.02861989475786686, -0.06315493583679199, 0.0028835872653871775, -0.024724489077925682, 0.006899449974298477, -0.015020783990621567, 0.04140089452266693, -0.012153134681284428, -0.0054821837693452835, -0.01090044155716896, 0.02752583660185337, 0.04781400039792061, -0.025555869564414024, 0.02018081769347191, 0.021342510357499123, 0.029514532536268234, -0.02894444763660431, 0.0032853183802217245, -0.015013091266155243, 0.004480349365621805, -0.0031764761079102755, -0.056085631251335144, 0.04080955311655998, -0.030128613114356995, -0.032582830637693405, 0.01643666997551918, 0.007569658104330301, 0.028482727706432343, -0.0583660826086998, -0.011655382812023163, 0.050734229385852814, -0.05101636424660683, 0.011907842941582203, 0.013539890758693218, 0.03355209901928902, 0.03332727402448654, -0.05269930139183998, 0.07678435742855072, 0.00016329131904058158, -0.0035256030969321728, -0.07005592435598373, -0.006672298535704613, 0.05240840092301369, 0.011507965624332428, -0.025917962193489075, -0.04295407608151436, 0.04001964256167412, -0.02376139722764492, -0.016744064167141914, -0.005803229287266731, 0.03760344535112381, -0.008289352059364319, -0.0297163724899292, -0.052807170897722244, 0.015321562066674232, 0.05018332228064537, 0.018755163997411728, -0.009129333309829235, 0.043935809284448624, 0.00960903987288475, -0.025603415444493294, 0.0012131041148677468, 0.005862085148692131, -0.017836911603808403, -0.003032514126971364, 0.0018381726695224643, -0.021994659677147865, 0.01777290739119053, 0.024524668231606483, 0.004952313378453255, 0.024746393784880638, 0.018202729523181915, -0.01049297209829092, -0.03183966502547264, -0.0451330803334713, -0.017574362456798553, 0.008223067969083786, -0.036293599754571915, -0.003274566261097789, -0.02303388901054859, 0.00428673205897212, 0.038428861647844315, -0.02087845839560032, -0.017530569806694984, 0.0017762418137863278, 0.06602402776479721, 0.017640279605984688, 0.00606940733268857, -0.04193764925003052, -0.01926305703818798, -0.006725220941007137, 0.03314867243170738, -0.031560469418764114, 0.020184937864542007, 0.04971162602305412, -0.03379460796713829, 0.01666107401251793, -0.059844423085451126, -0.006308478303253651, 0.05211227759718895, -0.014425648376345634, 0.03216931223869324, 0.0327092744410038, 0.014372450299561024, -0.02022988721728325, -0.01978185772895813, 0.0017037454526871443, -0.0038280657026916742, 0.011560197919607162, 0.07622700184583664, 0.011876745149493217, -0.021311577409505844, 0.048668693751096725, -0.010674678720533848, -0.028700582683086395, 0.07212767004966736, -0.02528243325650692, 0.009579483419656754, -0.0008767670369707048, -0.02972155436873436, -0.027904881164431572, 0.016886848956346512, -0.01159727107733488, 0.04721777141094208, -0.04436087980866432, -0.03810623288154602, 0.022580813616514206, 0.01932547055184841, 0.0015651845606043935, -0.02678050473332405, -0.01985900290310383, -0.03976958617568016, 0.011642002500593662, 0.05625215917825699, -0.05203165486454964, 0.030251627787947655, 0.029455505311489105, 0.015162537805736065, -0.018887104466557503, 0.008504458703100681, -0.057501792907714844, -0.035602740943431854, 0.00312447315081954, 0.010159189812839031, -0.08428191393613815, 0.021864237263798714, -0.0029723322950303555, 0.0024161578621715307, 0.021239979192614555, -0.031798843294382095, -0.0034188968129456043, -0.01019398681819439, 0.04934919998049736, 0.004674958530813456, 0.09460274875164032, 0.0100833335891366, 0.010497452691197395, -0.003236272605136037, 0.016128821298480034, 0.13847604393959045, 0.09844743460416794, 0.029604915529489517, -0.07940347492694855, 0.027990976348519325, -0.005908237304538488, 0.00018622538482304662, -0.04341848939657211, 0.028067825362086296, 0.047045741230249405, -0.016383880749344826, 0.062354762107133865, 0.02457408979535103, -0.023397579789161682, 0.00800684466958046, 0.05686686560511589, -0.04803008586168289, -0.04134433716535568, 0.005469170864671469, 0.02032596245408058, -0.017241133376955986, -0.04789625480771065, -0.07276197522878647, 0.039244383573532104, -0.004351104609668255, 0.016391120851039886, -0.03249180316925049, -0.025927115231752396, 0.0001284604222746566, 0.0025393683463335037, -0.028635364025831223, -0.027267741039395332, 0.03190469741821289, 0.03131919726729393, 0.01939133182168007, 0.006524937693029642, -0.004103838000446558, 0.027918534353375435, 0.008287271484732628, 0.03744145855307579, 0.03729504719376564, 0.013986103236675262, 0.016006680205464363, 0.02610022947192192, -0.019328126683831215, -0.021878620609641075, -0.021984921768307686, 0.01960384100675583, -0.021487537771463394, 0.015882357954978943, -0.003473547287285328, 0.012965601868927479, -0.01022061612457037, -0.03998792916536331, -0.010015989653766155, -0.005006616469472647, 0.032212529331445694, -0.02314426377415657, -0.015349977649748325, 0.005227799527347088, -0.004407456610351801, -0.01113117951899767, 0.041433751583099365, 0.0065051494166255, -0.03350395709276199, -0.01705455593764782, -0.0016645396826788783, 0.04818114638328552, -0.009350829757750034, -0.033908188343048096, -0.010283087380230427, -0.038821566849946976, -0.002143298042938113, -0.00263707316480577, 0.027211032807826996, -0.005670750048011541, 0.007298081181943417, 0.01868266426026821, 0.0025767802726477385, 0.00014347957039717585, -0.010775779373943806, 0.041704703122377396, -0.024603411555290222, -0.029110856354236603, -0.043820854276418686, 0.021978186443448067, 0.04826309159398079, 0.04421368986368179, -0.014843933284282684, 0.013652806170284748, -0.03638310357928276, 0.04845200851559639, 0.010952552780508995, -0.060438577085733414, -0.002413220703601837, 0.011166839860379696, -0.03720903769135475, 0.022011779248714447, -0.011062638834118843, 0.0643000677227974, 0.027616966515779495, 0.02647525817155838, -0.011943576857447624, 0.00123627542052418, -0.024583736434578896, -0.012434370815753937, 0.002085127867758274, -0.037480343133211136, 0.04206248000264168, -0.02392726019024849, -0.0037699700333178043, -0.044950589537620544, -0.003325200406834483, -0.005515494849532843, -0.03913910314440727, 0.026862384751439095, 0.015625324100255966, -0.024873707443475723, 0.00948967132717371, -0.023886417970061302, -0.015961425378918648, -0.00570660037919879, -0.0008451195317320526, -0.01039870735257864, -0.012374501675367355, -0.03482328727841377, -0.005255206022411585, -0.01995852403342724, -0.006354959215968847, -0.01969551481306553, -0.025424618273973465, 0.0034533971920609474, 0.016350071877241135, 0.023591557517647743, 0.014126403257250786, 0.002761529292911291, -0.007317251991480589, 0.0543396919965744, 0.014551475644111633, -0.03788559511303902, 0.04530344903469086, -0.05596223473548889, -0.02708398550748825, -0.009379374794661999, -0.0019656666554510593, 0.07856607437133789, -0.0014786128886044025, -0.010810202918946743, -0.021825537085533142, 0.042096853256225586, -0.018190575763583183, -0.014004448428750038, 0.008906309492886066, 0.02147676981985569, -0.015053976327180862, -0.007135232910513878, -0.001488627982325852, -0.002032126998528838, -0.04614241421222687, 0.0035941486712545156, 0.007436018902808428, -0.028939947485923767, 0.003706720657646656, 0.06118658930063248, -0.0031185848638415337, 0.004891302902251482, 0.003539941506460309, 0.01015512179583311, 0.041324637830257416, 0.05328969284892082, 0.015616160817444324, 0.016374586150050163, -0.07183710485696793, -0.007916219532489777, -0.08731973171234131, -0.026354877278208733, 0.03609775751829147, -0.00612366059795022, -0.0005393843166530132, -0.0251786932349205, 0.009908364154398441, 0.03175969049334526, 0.002266894094645977, 0.029009656980633736, 0.009147830307483673, 0.008102538995444775, -0.024089716374874115, -0.011276395060122013, -0.0172855444252491, 0.018783042207360268, 0.05671476200222969, 0.02246459387242794, 0.07358089089393616, 0.001396632520481944, -0.018126891925930977, -0.02182801626622677, -0.010813010856509209, 0.049104172736406326, 0.021949779242277145, -0.07724566012620926, 0.0173933282494545, -0.02925705723464489, -0.020065709948539734, 0.05392925813794136, 0.0008105270098894835, 0.0075877211056649685, -0.003129022428765893, 0.022168327122926712, -0.011145244352519512, 0.09077697992324829, 0.049424007534980774, 0.03295265883207321, -0.0002747637336142361, 0.001506184577010572, 0.021055487915873528, 0.004145490471273661, -0.052524227648973465, 0.03579099476337433, 0.01815771497786045, 0.0034507629461586475, -0.028755981475114822, 0.008552237413823605, -0.028481926769018173, -0.04158136248588562, -0.0395081453025341, -0.01801026053726673, 0.0032551726326346397, -0.04287300258874893, 0.03016563318669796, -0.03343862295150757, -0.006175667978823185, 0.022154878824949265, -0.004773836582899094, -0.017658766359090805, 0.03181561082601547, -0.02106492780148983, -0.059032078832387924, 0.035331156104803085, 0.022718019783496857, -0.04485207796096802, -0.04502265527844429, 0.03355848044157028, -0.014251102693378925, -0.015161313116550446, -0.027868084609508514, -0.031099459156394005, -0.026844779029488564, 0.02586282789707184, 0.0005112603539600968, -0.014898204244673252, -0.00475333072245121, 0.018704041838645935, 0.02481602504849434, -0.11294844001531601, 0.04745393618941307, -0.03115689940750599, 0.0020622480660676956, -0.0038396958261728287, -0.0114629240706563, -0.003643044736236334, -0.0051640709862113, 0.02766420692205429, 0.02038876712322235, -0.037401195615530014, 0.008587922900915146, 0.04281526431441307, 0.016952604055404663, -0.03573593869805336, -0.0029886995907872915, -0.0035041591618210077, -0.03501497581601143, -0.011693008244037628, -0.023406585678458214, 0.017259223386645317, 0.01042680162936449, 0.0034391176886856556, -0.004059375263750553, 0.00973573513329029, 0.03131863847374916, 0.0010378791484981775, 0.03728445991873741, -0.017657943069934845, -0.017022565007209778, 0.0740804448723793, 0.002453755121678114, 0.002035964746028185, 0.026355693116784096, 0.017389418557286263, -0.026878364384174347, -0.009810945950448513, -0.02234753407537937, -0.03471662104129791, -0.010429631918668747, 0.023496277630329132, 0.004834021907299757, -0.03982068598270416, 0.0074000731110572815, 0.04924581199884415, -0.03663089871406555, -0.03994035720825195, 0.01226923055946827, -0.0028019302990287542, 0.004925742745399475, -0.01757778599858284, 0.008640780113637447, 0.009972193278372288, -0.008078699931502342, 0.010232117958366871, 0.02154778502881527, 0.006661530584096909, -0.02019600197672844, 0.01200972218066454, -0.015257211402058601, -0.020761139690876007, 0.01113310270011425, -0.04889802262187004, 0.038497377187013626, -0.0214003287255764, -0.07330024987459183, 0.017517628148198128, -0.016802748665213585, 0.022150082513689995, -0.0265665240585804, -0.003929250407963991, 0.03415404632687569, 0.028152618557214737, 0.018564647063612938, -0.01928134448826313, -0.0373312346637249, -0.06962449848651886, 0.014373932965099812, 0.022865014150738716, -0.020453309640288353, -0.0023872642777860165, 0.017034688964486122, 0.02343112789094448, 0.026770226657390594, 0.025562044233083725, -0.02107231877744198, 0.00004672974318964407, -0.021418919786810875, -0.002233515726402402, -0.01838964968919754, -0.01631631888449192, -0.03767259418964386, -0.008720231242477894, 0.01768895611166954, 0.03872423991560936, 0.023673368617892265, 0.016680056229233742, 0.0008662245236337185, 0.020846838131546974, 0.05224395915865898, -0.08543641120195389, -0.009574583731591702, -0.022092046216130257, -0.021519871428608894, -0.03217224031686783, -0.012201214209198952 ]
<p>Suppose I have a dataset $x_i$ (with $x_i &gt;= 0$) of N samples. I would like to determine the average of the data when the data is limited to some theshold c: </p> <p>$limitedaverage(x,c) = \frac{1}{N} \sum_{i=1}^N max(x_i,c)$</p> <p>Problem is I don't have access to the actual samples, I only know some aggregate statistics of the data: the sum, sum of squares, etc, up to a certain order k:</p> <p>$\sum x$, $\sum x^2$, $\sum x^3$ ... $\sum x^k$</p> <p>I'm looking for a way to estimate the above limited average for a given c and given said aggregates.</p> <p>Intuitively I've been able to get a rough idea for k=2: given $\sum x$ and $\sum x^2$ one can calculate the average and the standard deviation and this tells me whether there are any samples that are significantly below c and would become clipped. But also given $\sum x^3$ and $\sum x^4$ I'm sure it's possible to get a more accurate estimate.</p> <p>My idea is that it should be possible to exploit $max(x,c) = \lim_{k \to \infty} (x^k+c^k)^\frac{1}{k}$ but from here I'm stuck.</p> <p>Any hints?</p>
73,778
[ -0.036998309195041656, -0.017261041328310966, 0.006472337059676647, 0.003459656611084938, 0.02021649293601513, 0.0281890407204628, 0.0038523569237440825, -0.037080466747283936, 0.006948207970708609, -0.06848400086164474, 0.052282121032476425, 0.04360741749405861, 0.06738699227571487, 0.03543675318360329, 0.02039165049791336, -0.018466759473085403, -0.06387520581483841, 0.03130314499139786, 0.03162505850195885, -0.04393826052546501, 0.009270966984331608, 0.06019195541739464, -0.0010188244050368667, -0.011937552131712437, -0.03417615965008736, -0.009788545779883862, 0.021898159757256508, -0.016328860074281693, -0.02383643016219139, 0.08092760294675827, -0.02602689154446125, -0.022484339773654938, 0.022827403619885445, 0.05621860921382904, 0.041736405342817307, 0.0046502514742314816, -0.026850875467061996, -0.008876774460077286, 0.03359639272093773, 0.021652597934007645, -0.04708948731422424, -0.034534092992544174, 0.02562108263373375, -0.03426128253340721, 0.01188397966325283, 0.021813541650772095, -0.004120043013244867, -0.06466936320066452, 0.00024407725140918046, -0.05915835127234459, 0.06611370295286179, 0.009352700784802437, 0.019768236204981804, 0.01454959623515606, 0.007632527034729719, -0.0001040868810378015, 0.04117836058139801, 0.08135146647691727, 0.020237501710653305, -0.0541924349963665, -0.00898413173854351, -0.0044168406166136265, 0.014632197096943855, 0.0069065275602042675, -0.0408201664686203, 0.018244409933686256, -0.01889052428305149, -0.03190081939101219, -0.000796252628788352, -0.05984564870595932, 0.0051160696893930435, 0.05703624337911606, 0.020726051181554794, 0.02214403636753559, 0.011008956469595432, 0.016680115833878517, -0.014245543628931046, 0.015396290458738804, 0.06969523429870605, 0.031016798689961433, 0.02527656778693199, 0.00357726844958961, 0.028690198436379433, 0.037333894520998, 0.020581981167197227, 0.010938804596662521, 0.0935201495885849, -0.016273772343993187, 0.010102192871272564, 0.01243356242775917, -0.0050313640385866165, -0.03992069140076637, 0.038064420223236084, -0.04004234820604324, -0.03380421921610832, -0.0005681662587448955, -0.04121675342321396, 0.039274513721466064, -0.02902904525399208, -0.02664025127887726, 0.004913731478154659, -0.02996225841343403, -0.027635615319013596, 0.06526394933462143, 0.010857225395739079, 0.014025305397808552, -0.029359785839915276, 0.024082720279693604, 0.002950135385617614, -0.016621924936771393, -0.008848514407873154, -0.011531668715178967, 0.0294490996748209, -0.006598338950425386, -0.0079428656026721, 0.02075672335922718, -0.024068403989076614, -0.03286372125148773, 0.02364451065659523, 0.06558556109666824, 0.05333878844976425, -0.013671061024069786, 0.022053362801671028, -0.02395952120423317, -0.035066016018390656, 0.020592333748936653, 0.01608683168888092, -0.0538453534245491, -0.04227394610643387, 0.03782949969172478, 0.042358800768852234, -0.011138039641082287, 0.03215724602341652, -0.010064332745969296, 0.024251852184534073, -0.00932474248111248, -0.0934208407998085, -0.016166837885975838, 0.04609048739075661, -0.004292166326195002, -0.01667868159711361, -0.07018718868494034, 0.0024113846011459827, 0.04174799844622612, 0.04725656285881996, 0.03107304684817791, 0.05868913605809212, 0.020192058756947517, 0.0075379954650998116, 0.03443771228194237, -0.03395712375640869, -0.005754594225436449, -0.026745619252324104, -0.002964164363220334, -0.0033250413835048676, -0.04885674640536308, 0.018116915598511696, 0.026527121663093567, 0.004865885712206364, -0.005519689992070198, 0.07345905900001526, 0.03658716753125191, -0.0164935365319252, 0.004207833204418421, 0.021110793575644493, 0.006490678526461124, 0.08562318235635757, 0.02180480770766735, 0.05831873044371605, -0.022364748641848564, 0.002329933224245906, 0.018942849710583687, 0.007772766053676605, 0.023895125836133957, 0.07051657885313034, -0.016726011410355568, 0.012547411024570465, 0.0019507738761603832, 0.01590864360332489, 0.03951309248805046, -0.030978834256529808, -0.006981296930462122, 0.03690694272518158, -0.010426396504044533, 0.0398339182138443, 0.048222288489341736, 0.004104847088456154, -0.04947361722588539, -0.015629872679710388, -0.040905606001615524, -0.01169661432504654, -0.07850189507007599, -0.01870424672961235, 0.032824765890836716, -0.020930005237460136, 0.0418449267745018, 0.0009322625119239092, 0.013256515376269817, -0.015088651329278946, -0.02560717798769474, -0.009381188079714775, 0.00007891807763371617, 0.059350449591875076, -0.03549450635910034, 0.007879085838794708, 0.0200764462351799, 0.046409595757722855, -0.029058143496513367, 0.023119255900382996, -0.011489318683743477, -0.06649667024612427, 0.0034957106690853834, -0.05167679861187935, -0.007413633167743683, -0.012037630192935467, 0.004455213900655508, 0.005105629097670317, -0.027293071150779724, 0.010076366364955902, 0.03702953830361366, -0.02388441003859043, 0.06046772003173828, 0.019274255260825157, 0.025910716503858566, -0.010201849974691868, -0.0041464706882834435, 0.0031749603804200888, 0.0032841614447534084, -0.018976209685206413, -0.016676995903253555, -0.03215525671839714, 0.017826175317168236, 0.015426301397383213, 0.04911023750901222, -0.06863845884799957, -0.011919437907636166, 0.0612032413482666, -0.014488263055682182, 0.027946272864937782, -0.006646348629146814, -0.0072675952687859535, 0.023775598034262657, -0.0012236880138516426, -0.00398634048178792, 0.013293396681547165, -0.002819263841956854, -0.015755120664834976, 0.003220711136236787, 0.02368282712996006, 0.01815778762102127, 0.006763142999261618, 0.00005902101474930532, 0.006969816517084837, 0.00878020841628313, -0.01894226111471653, -0.011268514208495617, 0.010777509771287441, -0.009372157044708729, -0.0034885527566075325, 0.000047064389946172014, 0.018268978223204613, 0.014926906675100327, 0.0052657825872302055, -0.027585523203015327, 0.07484614849090576, 0.008504648692905903, -0.06704138219356537, -0.030087608844041824, 0.0179679524153471, -0.02906828559935093, 0.012380311265587807, -0.02066974900662899, -0.038667209446430206, -0.02338544838130474, 0.03963211178779602, 0.027839845046401024, -0.011650821194052696, 0.00828454177826643, -0.0034548023249953985, -0.02715594694018364, -0.00011860570521093905, -0.02165799029171467, 0.01673137955367565, 0.03141062706708908, -0.030351152643561363, -0.005063808523118496, 0.008793912827968597, -0.005275430157780647, 0.031373992562294006, -0.001949072116985917, 0.014166031032800674, 0.06519996374845505, 0.023202717304229736, -0.04763657599687576, -0.008004735223948956, -0.005330420099198818, 0.018831562250852585, -0.04044007509946823, -0.03334181755781174, 0.024211931973695755, -0.0022438224405050278, -0.030037637799978256, 0.05528419837355614, -0.028526509180665016, -0.025663508102297783, -0.05167512968182564, 0.018733959645032883, 0.004475092981010675, -0.02227018214762211, 0.008329886011779308, 0.013150853104889393, 0.015020179562270641, -0.020131906494498253, -0.053324971348047256, -0.06069326773285866, 0.025287548080086708, -0.010079317726194859, 0.02149454690515995, 0.03679054230451584, -0.03419194743037224, 0.06794759631156921, 0.034956417977809906, -0.00472591957077384, -0.04214223474264145, -0.027850396931171417, 0.009242217987775803, -0.0012688848655670881, 0.016525067389011383, -0.00954464916139841, -0.015792343765497208, 0.007363459095358849, 0.012118929997086525, 0.00958317518234253, 0.02668805979192257, 0.01115382369607687, -0.000430910789873451, 0.010924704372882843, -0.048131175339221954, -0.0021868546027690172, 0.02554267644882202, 0.04526146873831749, -0.02331416867673397, 0.015858536586165428, 0.02323848009109497, 0.01810147985816002, 0.026747919619083405, -0.04529566690325737, -0.018180062994360924, -0.01730751246213913, 0.005846227984875441, -0.01709531433880329, 0.02941979467868805, 0.04125363379716873, -0.036754149943590164, 0.0004011667042504996, 0.025378307327628136, -0.028487805277109146, -0.02611195109784603, 0.0391954630613327, 0.020061509683728218, 0.038888610899448395, -0.028308331966400146, -0.012259380891919136, -0.009431972168385983, -0.02241140604019165, 0.0321742445230484, -0.009004856459796429, 0.0019189344020560384, 0.02826589345932007, 0.06112203747034073, -0.010728158056735992, -0.011619159020483494, -0.010018783621490002, 0.022593721747398376, -0.06291425228118896, 0.012764290906488895, -0.04582400247454643, 0.06142169609665871, 0.023008223623037338, 0.03400776907801628, 0.045530322939157486, -0.0008087657042779028, 0.01784655451774597, 0.022770117968320847, -0.09029778838157654, 0.016956569626927376, -0.011738392524421215, 0.0016482803039252758, -0.04247824475169182, -0.030327672138810158, 0.029322747141122818, 0.01926596462726593, 0.018905652686953545, -0.021615417674183846, 0.013791503384709358, -0.03226508945226669, 0.010158892720937729, -0.004486410412937403, 0.017865337431430817, -0.005275169387459755, 0.019902747124433517, 0.027398565784096718, -0.03079030103981495, 0.02779846452176571, 0.04001262038946152, -0.03138387203216553, -0.029665037989616394, -0.04489469900727272, 0.02753833308815956, -0.009132025763392448, 0.03889623284339905, -0.0013395292917266488, 0.023808101192116737, -0.03983193263411522, 0.014509488828480244, -0.028658341616392136, 0.055098678916692734, 0.047388747334480286, 0.008640526793897152, 0.024148685857653618, -0.031036270782351494, -0.0016670763725414872, 0.0285832267254591, -0.0007615556241944432, 0.023216040804982185, -0.0046311477199196815, 0.04483553022146225, 0.020603148266673088, -0.06247654929757118, 0.017833929508924484, 0.042913902550935745, -0.011502423323690891, 0.003987483214586973, -0.07123211026191711, -0.014982324093580246, -0.02300710789859295, 0.009074010886251926, 0.03230582922697067, -0.002883335342630744, 0.014115355908870697, -0.003521603299304843, 0.049140337854623795, 0.00425740797072649, -0.05186612531542778, 0.005500001832842827, 0.03186411038041115, 0.05223766714334488, -0.0175052210688591, -0.03526869788765907, 0.024465806782245636, 0.04748314246535301, 0.04900215566158295, -0.016523614525794983, -0.011656614951789379, -0.09774467349052429, -0.008527414873242378, 0.02499733306467533, 0.038227375596761703, -0.010857973247766495, -0.005400428548455238, -0.027466416358947754, 0.016398603096604347, 0.04481067508459091, -0.025680365040898323, 0.024779800325632095, -0.013095565140247345, -0.002219179878011346, -0.019930081441998482, -0.029526326805353165, -0.05224655941128731, -0.015279487706720829, -0.008663238026201725, -0.006703912280499935, -0.017647605389356613, 0.009788962081074715, -0.03693526238203049, 0.023804843425750732, 0.011642259545624256, 0.0662597045302391, 0.006586642004549503, -0.025562914088368416, 0.011241507716476917, 0.031366847455501556, -0.017868850380182266, -0.07346101105213165, 0.03335001692175865, -0.015748199075460434, -0.018321169540286064, 0.041124314069747925, -0.031578510999679565, -0.041847001761198044, 0.04001026600599289, -0.013357491232454777, -0.024961698800325394, 0.006978919263929129, -0.01301043014973402, 0.03770978003740311, 0.03819124028086662, 0.017806153744459152, 0.0816003754734993, 0.02881322242319584, 0.012928635813295841, -0.0035965663846582174, -0.006001570262014866, -0.005380137823522091, -0.018829548731446266, -0.015171048231422901, -0.03696608170866966, -0.016926774755120277, -0.01582450419664383, 0.009894386865198612, -0.02756531350314617, 0.06619517505168915, -0.031701188534498215, 0.0005995584651827812, 0.011228158138692379, -0.004574510734528303, 0.05043439939618111, 0.0028262920677661896, -0.00785476341843605, 0.011803665198385715, 0.01568656601011753, -0.022741107270121574, 0.024758264422416687, 0.010909519158303738, 0.007922966033220291, 0.0003656355547718704, -0.03533582761883736, -0.00027603580383583903, -0.03126920759677887, 0.00004059146158397198, -0.01109460648149252, 0.010313916020095348, 0.0755588486790657, -0.01380134653300047, 0.0434226468205452, -0.0015457087429240346, 0.007305879611521959, 0.003777574747800827, -0.002880084328353405, 0.00045144648174755275, 0.05811470001935959, -0.06065668538212776, 0.059017207473516464, -0.01997043378651142, 0.01589815691113472, -0.06322436779737473, -0.009094160050153732, 0.030680084601044655, 0.036377761512994766, -0.008608430624008179, -0.028494665399193764, -0.009435677900910378, -0.02155221439898014, -0.023221323266625404, -0.03149500489234924, 0.07267486304044724, -0.01090160384774208, -0.04298197105526924, -0.016562161967158318, 0.044021353125572205, 0.08066866546869278, -0.026537807658314705, -0.013347381725907326, 0.04263219237327576, -0.04091425612568855, -0.012144808657467365, -0.016747238114476204, 0.014748911373317242, -0.03950812667608261, 0.01616816408932209, -0.04221745580434799, -0.017120935022830963, 0.0223606675863266, -0.03645627573132515, -0.020513296127319336, 0.028966328129172325, 0.036684874445199966, -0.005803938023746014, -0.04264726862311363, -0.04539800435304642, -0.003798777237534523, 0.009675647132098675, -0.006778998766094446, -0.022047225385904312, 0.004088773392140865, -0.020957212895154953, 0.0422360822558403, 0.05136209353804588, -0.03200102597475052, 0.0000069570719460898545, 0.053553737699985504, 0.0036079762503504753, -0.014922315254807472, -0.021023139357566833, -0.0026557769160717726, 0.042272765189409256, 0.013121352531015873, -0.0011485376162454486, 0.02896548993885517, 0.023437824100255966, -0.027422171086072922, -0.0034165247343480587, -0.06058473140001297, 0.028862740844488144, 0.03130830079317093, -0.012626067735254765, 0.04540831968188286, 0.04309207946062088, 0.01611456274986267, -0.01243718434125185, -0.009252064861357212, -0.015821456909179688, -0.005508389789611101, 0.010271595790982246, 0.05777674913406372, -0.01466397475451231, -0.011455456726253033, 0.017585093155503273, -0.010121400468051434, -0.012562813237309456, 0.01407927181571722, -0.01981334201991558, 0.003179417224600911, 0.0016496183816343546, -0.04816185683012009, -0.021428463980555534, 0.04244622960686684, -0.05889225751161575, -0.01601320691406727, -0.007089228369295597, -0.033867623656988144, 0.02952348068356514, 0.000867532507982105, 0.0025111243594437838, -0.053778938949108124, -0.03328964486718178, -0.007365881931036711, -0.013407018966972828, 0.020761355757713318, -0.05048559233546257, 0.06607677042484283, -0.015732016414403915, -0.007886764593422413, -0.018574928864836693, 0.03265054151415825, -0.03359822556376457, -0.06611624360084534, -0.033451780676841736, -0.02435685321688652, -0.03158166632056236, -0.005510533694177866, 0.04994215816259384, -0.03427453339099884, 0.03333703801035881, -0.02896735817193985, 0.060337189584970474, 0.001590617117471993, 0.04146741330623627, -0.0021344649139791727, 0.02076784148812294, 0.025815190747380257, 0.005890817381441593, -0.00784631073474884, -0.011562020517885685, 0.1137603148818016, 0.07015743851661682, 0.009326154366135597, -0.054209742695093155, 0.027000298723578453, 0.016256527975201607, -0.01116439700126648, -0.07414893060922623, 0.007109769154340029, 0.004238415975123644, -0.0152635732665658, 0.012129789218306541, 0.08359291404485703, -0.00017366996326018125, 0.02021757885813713, 0.05611233040690422, -0.033337969332933426, 0.018447281792759895, 0.018100466579198837, 0.018603123724460602, 0.003661099122837186, -0.045129094272851944, -0.05441773310303688, 0.03846375271677971, 0.012522434815764427, -0.024525754153728485, -0.049114953726530075, 0.0108179384842515, -0.005992263555526733, -0.02308952808380127, -0.024389326572418213, 0.007083703298121691, 0.039734531193971634, -0.013034234754741192, -0.0037421707529574633, -0.016007158905267715, 0.0010156725766137242, -0.0351356640458107, 0.006916489917784929, 0.0473153330385685, 0.029778465628623962, 0.00030414797947742045, 0.027880633249878883, 0.02798783779144287, -0.0008105324814096093, -0.04326983168721199, -0.0523112453520298, 0.02972901612520218, -0.0027611535042524338, -0.003065108321607113, -0.028889380395412445, 0.006987610831856728, -0.024457251653075218, -0.041543446481227875, -0.013003276661038399, -0.008823614567518234, 0.054709482938051224, -0.057591672986745834, -0.0002658294979482889, -0.0008275689324364066, 0.0021389953326433897, 0.010324761271476746, 0.011425718665122986, -0.004106756299734116, -0.05333305150270462, -0.021490871906280518, -0.008349116891622543, 0.015895845368504524, -0.010260692797601223, -0.02187410742044449, 0.012432875111699104, -0.023885251954197884, -0.0065421755425632, -0.01669469103217125, 0.025319799780845642, -0.021685736253857613, 0.056512247771024704, -0.008112709037959576, 0.0012994902208447456, 0.008604650385677814, -0.03299640491604805, -0.00889919139444828, -0.05207236111164093, 0.03313865140080452, -0.03378557786345482, -0.012784128077328205, 0.008738002739846706, 0.030216513201594353, 0.0017815992468968034, 0.0024621072225272655, 0.029670903459191322, 0.08183010667562485, 0.040886085480451584, 0.002404486760497093, 0.013809248805046082, -0.014935820363461971, -0.03132171183824539, 0.05332276597619057, 0.00400017574429512, 0.09913571178913116, 0.02389264851808548, 0.006309655494987965, 0.008003486320376396, 0.015620986931025982, -0.04002436622977257, 0.014685739763081074, 0.03905288130044937, -0.05119900777935982, 0.0328790545463562, -0.0008635317790322006, 0.0043052490800619125, -0.003882849356159568, -0.02140529826283455, -0.017265837639570236, -0.0497753843665123, 0.01641165465116501, -0.03265761956572533, -0.02844291180372238, 0.025796523317694664, -0.007795616053044796, -0.012552659958600998, 0.004233467858284712, -0.01721356064081192, -0.0352272130548954, -0.0008616329287178814, -0.012752285227179527, -0.009767369367182255, -0.00506491307169199, 0.009426732547581196, -0.026962116360664368, -0.015127735212445259, 0.0388522706925869, 0.009876451455056667, 0.00304093724116683, -0.012475145980715752, -0.059687163680791855, 0.0018137191655114293, -0.003397551132366061, -0.006219971459358931, -0.037586331367492676, 0.05727909877896309, -0.08244241774082184, -0.022336089983582497, 0.019524790346622467, 0.006956880912184715, 0.048234328627586365, 0.03440975397825241, 0.008055715821683407, -0.06878268718719482, 0.03420383483171463, -0.027901800349354744, 0.002611413598060608, 0.008860914036631584, 0.037188027054071426, -0.027409344911575317, 0.01986861787736416, 0.04278961196541786, 0.004578346852213144, -0.014279886148869991, -0.01848660036921501, 0.03638525679707527, 0.004451028071343899, 0.000491867249365896, 0.020413532853126526, 0.005402872338891029, -0.0018101867754012346, -0.0206893477588892, 0.025829648599028587, 0.03877715393900871, 0.040668945759534836, -0.04907875135540962, 0.0057593598030507565, -0.04806986823678017, 0.014935296960175037, -0.09698307514190674, -0.02925899438560009, 0.006473088171333075, -0.0032436628825962543, -0.004469096194952726, -0.02686327137053013, 0.028545424342155457, 0.04924887791275978, -0.02990405634045601, 0.04220286384224892, -0.0036268734838813543, -0.014235765673220158, -0.022505732253193855, 0.03708183020353317, -0.01379248034209013, -0.0014467566506937146, 0.016004914417862892, 0.013094362802803516, 0.010365230962634087, 0.02483697235584259, -0.014858371578156948, -0.015225614421069622, -0.02527155913412571, 0.008864383213222027, 0.0234563909471035, -0.0618046410381794, 0.01089748740196228, -0.03794686868786812, -0.04147423431277275, 0.04021674767136574, -0.005610654130578041, 0.006708070635795593, -0.004169592168182135, 0.0028066837694495916, -0.007932746782898903, 0.054618269205093384, 0.015306521207094193, 0.0007049313862808049, 0.023939982056617737, 0.009607961401343346, 0.022262239828705788, 0.025395959615707397, -0.04877181351184845, 0.015458082780241966, 0.06560526043176651, 0.006108957342803478, -0.05211213231086731, -0.006331729236990213, 0.004736815579235554, -0.04556367173790932, -0.026452455669641495, -0.013372010551393032, 0.008240102790296078, -0.041069380939006805, 0.02751927822828293, -0.027111614122986794, -0.008118872530758381, 0.00609960500150919, 0.04101182892918587, -0.01668783649802208, 0.015865227207541466, -0.04492909088730812, -0.004280738532543182, 0.006016069557517767, 0.034447189420461655, -0.01020843256264925, -0.04669823870062828, -0.02725508250296116, 0.013062038458883762, 0.008897898718714714, -0.026105355471372604, -0.021633248776197433, -0.02540101483464241, 0.013566438108682632, 0.006927149370312691, 0.026944125071167946, -0.006204790435731411, 0.020477229729294777, 0.009600777179002762, -0.12032074481248856, 0.048335034400224686, 0.00688302144408226, 0.011652195826172829, 0.00039082247531041503, -0.006827299017459154, -0.0037138396874070168, -0.015296828001737595, 0.06542915850877762, -0.00824735127389431, 0.0013648520689457655, -0.024140959605574608, 0.0489012636244297, 0.009615867398679256, -0.02787669561803341, -0.01472423691302538, -0.03475036844611168, -0.008128331042826176, -0.02532610297203064, -0.015565396286547184, 0.005161252338439226, -0.023814231157302856, -0.019176125526428223, 0.011611919850111008, 0.01773548685014248, 0.0075744204223155975, -0.0019027701346203685, 0.05220872163772583, 0.018197165802121162, -0.029742907732725143, 0.02790733240544796, -0.02042846567928791, 0.008434714749455452, 0.008005321025848389, -0.01555946096777916, -0.026457685977220535, 0.029010148718953133, -0.06678549945354462, -0.038809459656476974, -0.0645703673362732, 0.0010290829231962562, -0.016557686030864716, -0.02557815983891487, 0.007998527027666569, 0.03688257560133934, -0.04543163999915123, -0.005809927359223366, 0.08592245727777481, 0.011785237118601799, 0.024334311485290527, 0.011293000541627407, 0.00039011871558614075, 0.0036040195263922215, -0.013670523650944233, -0.0014926812145859003, 0.007541348226368427, 0.0384957417845726, -0.012842626310884953, -0.00839260220527649, 0.019067155197262764, 0.006246630102396011, 0.0077186631970107555, -0.03825272619724274, 0.01779138669371605, -0.034030377864837646, -0.06341258436441422, -0.012893457897007465, -0.05092955008149147, 0.01385792251676321, -0.022679446265101433, 0.004974800627678633, 0.07141236215829849, 0.005317959003150463, -0.01047297939658165, -0.02717599645256996, -0.037223413586616516, -0.026909667998552322, -0.010719511657953262, -0.04642292484641075, 0.027689311653375626, -0.04561251774430275, 0.013209396973252296, -0.00813028123229742, 0.002954730996862054, 0.04305421933531761, 0.006855248007923365, 0.02471613883972168, -0.00008157488628057763, 0.005121762398630381, 0.0007556326454505324, -0.03645164519548416, -0.0059144929982721806, 0.007615021429955959, 0.025886960327625275, 0.028951497748494148, 0.028779923915863037, 0.007638275623321533, -0.01622549258172512, 0.0006817443645559251, 0.04433520883321762, -0.0659724622964859, 0.001406623050570488, -0.030237818136811256, 0.0018680159701034427, -0.00971888191998005, -0.036035049706697464 ]
<p>How can a stationary, invertible ARMA(1,1) process be represented as either an infinite order AR or infinite order MA process?</p>
73,779
[ -0.007329914718866348, -0.02956261672079563, -0.006152810528874397, -0.004875849932432175, 0.04772022366523743, 0.013190122321248055, -0.016089651733636856, -0.004270343109965324, -0.014156742952764034, -0.02848496474325657, 0.005919907242059708, 0.001026382204145193, 0.03496560826897621, 0.023695217445492744, 0.01824873872101307, 0.010313384234905243, -0.013058812357485294, 0.03369954228401184, 0.008612921461462975, -0.004798044450581074, 0.0020561066921800375, 0.031728751957416534, 0.01472608745098114, -0.014405801892280579, -0.024694200605154037, 0.02484741248190403, 0.030020689591765404, 0.013061433099210262, 0.02635018900036812, 0.06723485887050629, -0.032881397753953934, -0.016174182295799255, -0.0013181898975744843, 0.09481262415647507, 0.01427834015339613, 0.004822119604796171, -0.024744147434830666, -0.03333913907408714, 0.03269656375050545, 0.0450015664100647, -0.038674164563417435, -0.035724982619285583, -0.00948136392980814, 0.02740294672548771, -0.03001980297267437, -0.0009019232238642871, -0.008600256405770779, -0.01970710977911949, 0.05482680723071098, -0.020377229899168015, 0.09450114518404007, -0.04461125284433365, 0.004664506763219833, 0.0387122742831707, -0.0030132820829749107, -0.001614913227967918, 0.05439291149377823, 0.03399694710969925, 0.0013483185321092606, -0.05845421180129051, -0.006844616960734129, 0.024613918736577034, -0.011123361997306347, -0.0005500511033460498, 0.009430047124624252, -0.005488538648933172, 0.0035369452089071274, -0.015808062627911568, 0.012302113696932793, 0.014525393024086952, 0.045473307371139526, 0.0013415793655440211, 0.009084627032279968, -0.04487912729382515, -0.0011279699392616749, 0.00167077814694494, -0.008425237610936165, -0.0029556434601545334, 0.06164662167429924, 0.004339955281466246, 0.020730802789330482, 0.020997868850827217, 0.05158211663365364, 0.026252441108226776, 0.00041847096872515976, -0.006360831670463085, 0.05848730355501175, -0.0027698613703250885, 0.013045361265540123, 0.022416405379772186, -0.03437602147459984, 0.0011972293723374605, 0.02277068980038166, -0.019012952223420143, -0.045513443648815155, 0.006425417494028807, -0.005603858735412359, 0.03534260019659996, 0.01454821228981018, -0.015872806310653687, 0.024958480149507523, -0.05371261388063431, -0.0127762071788311, 0.036613643169403076, 0.011497659608721733, 0.00389456981793046, 0.014332391321659088, 0.011764545924961567, -0.06301833689212799, -0.015297089703381062, -0.058040887117385864, 0.018377458676695824, 0.01903577707707882, 0.042725760489702225, 0.041933152824640274, 0.012014036066830158, 0.0031809876672923565, -0.027859220281243324, 0.025404145941138268, 0.07631708681583405, 0.04614681005477905, -0.015477778390049934, 0.005280808079987764, -0.024978579953312874, -0.08061178773641586, -0.02861025370657444, -0.04040651395916939, -0.02284085564315319, -0.05847429856657982, 0.025351524353027344, 0.004280546680092812, -0.042223576456308365, 0.022965075448155403, -0.011818690225481987, 0.050456635653972626, -0.012689080089330673, -0.10847876220941544, -0.036497943103313446, 0.018129577860236168, -0.02617880143225193, 0.035479139536619186, -0.10141978412866592, 0.05286293476819992, 0.0673234611749649, 0.04972362518310547, -0.0024630026891827583, 0.042708802968263626, 0.04208773002028465, 0.040148697793483734, -0.02382083609700203, -0.029737666249275208, -0.004040087107568979, -0.016062498092651367, -0.019202759489417076, 0.012665826827287674, -0.06514071673154831, 0.025314580649137497, 0.03195030242204666, -0.03544941917061806, -0.015054607763886452, 0.05770900100469589, -0.0022810918744653463, -0.026223724707961082, -0.026245681568980217, -0.0037362598814070225, -0.03246153146028519, 0.04880078136920929, -0.005355347413569689, 0.029489710927009583, 0.010339697822928429, -0.0014523918507620692, 0.02338070049881935, -0.004360463470220566, 0.05378396436572075, 0.052250612527132034, -0.023527173325419426, -0.02300586737692356, -0.007642698939889669, -0.025546232238411903, 0.07333212345838547, -0.021575603634119034, -0.013320138677954674, 0.00938425213098526, 0.0045206379145383835, 0.027162719517946243, 0.024899180978536606, -0.03166886791586876, 0.002808833960443735, 0.004339203238487244, -0.059115003794431686, -0.03355991840362549, -0.06291168928146362, 0.018810223788022995, -0.011191432364284992, 0.015233637765049934, 0.03377685323357582, 0.010883253999054432, 0.015610724687576294, -0.012997040525078773, -0.01001210417598486, -0.01768038421869278, -0.02129892073571682, 0.05218678340315819, -0.03200635686516762, 0.01856025494635105, 0.029217397794127464, 0.037980783730745316, 0.011861148290336132, 0.013066565617918968, -0.01575949601829052, -0.036711737513542175, 0.011011906899511814, -0.019246617332100868, 0.03125780448317528, -0.029847079887986183, -0.018740588799118996, -0.005350273102521896, -0.03044828586280346, -0.01907878927886486, 0.04960601031780243, -0.04734736308455467, 0.03032097965478897, 0.06428169459104538, -0.010864472016692162, -0.012817704118788242, 0.03664779290556908, 0.024483468383550644, -0.007050418294966221, -0.03423188999295235, -0.019108394160866737, -0.04590323567390442, -0.04485921189188957, 0.043464258313179016, 0.0641106516122818, -0.04652288556098938, 0.04079832509160042, 0.03982822969555855, 0.064803846180439, 0.025720637291669846, 0.031300585716962814, 0.004730092361569405, -0.010563002899289131, 0.04036632925271988, -0.017487796023488045, 0.015770351514220238, -0.006179449148476124, -0.005554798524826765, -0.04211193695664406, 0.01411752961575985, 0.014630841091275215, -0.027039552107453346, 0.04802115634083748, -0.024094805121421814, 0.017205137759447098, 0.013172526843845844, -0.03700672835111618, 0.021391427144408226, -0.02739487588405609, 0.008103007450699806, 0.015597048215568066, 0.009657138027250767, -0.01073082722723484, 0.041249435395002365, 0.023493967950344086, -0.011938095092773438, 0.0011105538578704, -0.01653948985040188, -0.05619091913104057, 0.046350106596946716, -0.00550520746037364, 0.03430015966296196, -0.051148708909749985, -0.03969353809952736, -0.05240370333194733, -0.02430262789130211, 0.03653203323483467, 0.02431301772594452, 0.004847899079322815, -0.02631828933954239, -0.021394195035099983, 0.036509059369564056, -0.028021523728966713, 0.032623834908008575, 0.020768646150827408, -0.0010715717216953635, 0.04564335569739342, -0.0029771490953862667, -0.0021576606668531895, 0.03262336924672127, 0.010540257208049297, 0.011817562393844128, 0.01422946061939001, -0.02911320887506008, -0.07757693529129028, -0.03638322651386261, -0.055820416659116745, 0.03409803286194801, -0.007924065925180912, -0.042190518230199814, 0.047914594411849976, 0.020928386598825455, -0.039418093860149384, -0.005673600360751152, -0.03852831944823265, 0.022892626002430916, -0.0411224402487278, 0.009352125227451324, 0.020503921434283257, -0.03952360525727272, 0.03211593255400658, 0.004763901233673096, -0.050561267882585526, 0.00135005300398916, -0.03785933554172516, -0.03840523585677147, -0.006724730134010315, -0.0009900415316224098, 0.015762725844979286, 0.0430767685174942, -0.03623947128653526, 0.03146536275744438, 0.05009462684392929, 0.008981240913271904, -0.0203196220099926, -0.034560464322566986, -0.020233795046806335, -0.06375549733638763, 0.019932333379983902, 0.013077173382043839, -0.031302209943532944, 0.037117063999176025, 0.014504849910736084, 0.012982402928173542, 0.05723779648542404, -0.0017291075782850385, -0.020418141037225723, 0.011398659087717533, -0.03619752079248428, 0.02764423005282879, 0.003471595700830221, -0.005748413968831301, 0.021686969324946404, 0.020284444093704224, 0.020252354443073273, 0.001974948449060321, 0.02224741317331791, 0.006260300055146217, 0.02496505156159401, -0.0063525172881782055, -0.007514734286814928, -0.09318703413009644, 0.03729870170354843, -0.013411378487944603, -0.00932927057147026, -0.05038829147815704, -0.0061851972714066505, 0.029410159215331078, -0.015074864029884338, 0.02699870802462101, 0.035320132970809937, 0.0323367677628994, -0.015320013277232647, -0.04401698708534241, -0.002872595563530922, -0.01927880384027958, 0.021861717104911804, -0.010101424530148506, -0.03501095995306969, 0.04872377961874008, 0.0030109158251434565, -0.02659738063812256, -0.01219907309859991, -0.015306241810321808, -0.012152506969869137, -0.061917323619127274, 0.029909519478678703, -0.037941571325063705, 0.02175586111843586, 0.005938029382377863, 0.06299208849668503, 0.010705778375267982, 0.004259625915437937, 0.008239155635237694, 0.02487047389149666, -0.05310717225074768, 0.033542003482580185, -0.026270927861332893, 0.013812797144055367, -0.01957448571920395, -0.0008102423162199557, 0.018329115584492683, -0.05123380199074745, -0.00624949112534523, 0.010121598839759827, -0.05042869225144386, -0.03429458662867546, -0.008349140174686909, -0.06289580464363098, -0.03549439087510109, -0.022169260308146477, -0.0014961124397814274, 0.053312335163354874, -0.04139285162091255, 0.03273441642522812, 0.04207177460193634, -0.005813960451632738, -0.009735229425132275, -0.014411789365112782, 0.015455713495612144, 0.007172341924160719, 0.028159385547041893, 0.028203682973980904, 0.012933008372783661, -0.026283469051122665, 0.039697472006082535, 0.055743131786584854, 0.029010705649852753, 0.02149003930389881, 0.009312301874160767, -0.028030304238200188, -0.06590189784765244, -0.009565233252942562, 0.020853955298662186, 0.013214034028351307, 0.015381610952317715, -0.006585862021893263, 0.01735883578658104, 0.016599703580141068, -0.029677635058760643, 0.006911201402544975, 0.014814584515988827, 0.037535373121500015, 0.012611271813511848, -0.0353114977478981, 0.0031703936401754618, 0.0009784265421330929, 0.01205307338386774, 0.04823419451713562, -0.008722442202270031, -0.02346392534673214, 0.016922568902373314, -0.0016523353988304734, -0.028407441452145576, 0.010816684924066067, -0.0034890223760157824, 0.004134422168135643, 0.03979498893022537, 0.02209010161459446, -0.02998385578393936, 0.01914011500775814, 0.03545042499899864, 0.05120640993118286, 0.04424440115690231, 0.0105924466624856, -0.11187252402305603, 0.01612531766295433, 0.024279585108160973, -0.012297776527702808, 0.0038940536323934793, 0.011469505727291107, -0.07327254861593246, -0.033096861094236374, 0.022294411435723305, -0.0190985519438982, 0.07464393228292465, -0.010908416472375393, 0.01357018481940031, 0.018047913908958435, -0.02044643834233284, -0.03716471046209335, 0.03454629331827164, 0.030997829511761665, 0.0030919131822884083, 0.0017371650319546461, 0.0027580310124903917, -0.04628872871398926, 0.0016914323205128312, 0.022744396701455116, 0.04632753133773804, 0.013089408166706562, 0.03684888407588005, -0.01416302565485239, 0.035808272659778595, -0.0011772438883781433, -0.06130317226052284, 0.020691154524683952, 0.017747629433870316, -0.01516418531537056, 0.03572947904467583, -0.012366268783807755, -0.040433865040540695, 0.016592763364315033, 0.011016339994966984, 0.01301620714366436, 0.007062756456434727, -0.021740669384598732, 0.05844119191169739, 0.012673350982367992, 0.005413114093244076, 0.06718859821557999, 0.013324519619345665, -0.0011297889286652207, -0.007785961031913757, 0.0010935238096863031, 0.011887365952134132, -0.02937108464539051, -0.000863199180457741, -0.03725661337375641, 0.009064367040991783, -0.04238862171769142, 0.03324665501713753, 0.034094762057065964, 0.026089390739798546, 0.015595824457705021, 0.01638978160917759, -0.014349786564707756, 0.07110925763845444, -0.01590828038752079, -0.045815568417310715, -0.04960684850811958, 0.029448416084051132, -0.02433919347822666, -0.01201547123491764, 0.019997600466012955, -0.02372974343597889, -0.004455432295799255, 0.02170146256685257, -0.0029575894586741924, 0.05132128670811653, -0.0257220808416605, -0.017695026472210884, 0.010367190465331078, -0.0125244976952672, 0.04492884874343872, -0.025257647037506104, 0.03318566828966141, 0.022843075916171074, -0.06265426427125931, -0.00245399447157979, -0.01235724426805973, -0.017346316948533058, 0.026029130443930626, -0.03744447976350784, 0.026008054614067078, 0.0120546268299222, -0.029747573658823967, -0.07680241763591766, -0.06022447347640991, 0.0048634568229317665, 0.012057303451001644, -0.025072986260056496, -0.03414742276072502, 0.03825952485203743, -0.008556541055440903, -0.011996990069746971, -0.030963942408561707, 0.04431675747036934, -0.028154250234365463, -0.005905600264668465, 0.022633345797657967, 0.037259671837091446, 0.06608603894710541, -0.0016343186143785715, -0.004214133135974407, 0.05282413586974144, -0.06534210592508316, -0.04879770427942276, -0.007449392694979906, 0.04283829405903816, -0.02306513302028179, 0.013067583553493023, -0.023654885590076447, -0.04073040932416916, 0.021858174353837967, -0.0011399617651477456, -0.01267548743635416, 0.03312996029853821, 0.010124360211193562, 0.028484178707003593, -0.0074784723110497, -0.019332000985741615, -0.0013975490583106875, 0.040540117770433426, 0.02493414282798767, -0.05417829006910324, -0.013573943637311459, -0.02595178782939911, 0.05781455710530281, -0.01059968862682581, -0.020815839990973473, 0.055114489048719406, 0.06037397310137749, -0.03845376893877983, -0.004865988623350859, 0.014978324994444847, -0.003202376887202263, 0.03477975353598595, -0.023014763370156288, 0.024588070809841156, 0.012076195329427719, -0.00586464861407876, -0.052512481808662415, -0.04596686363220215, -0.01736319437623024, 0.02022249810397625, 0.03537653014063835, 0.03406672924757004, 0.028099425137043, -0.0054510412737727165, 0.011323248967528343, -0.017709903419017792, -0.0037110832054167986, -0.012552982196211815, -0.002015069592744112, -0.038186341524124146, 0.034359466284513474, -0.03376070410013199, 0.018397152423858643, 0.003788752481341362, -0.002632846822962165, 0.03202824294567108, 0.01328651700168848, 0.02106088027358055, 0.0158081017434597, -0.00235170079395175, 0.013171314261853695, -0.02891409955918789, 0.04742018133401871, -0.017499186098575592, 0.013446386903524399, -0.00009920950833475217, -0.017808610573410988, 0.04734897240996361, 0.03230828791856766, 0.004500693175941706, -0.06272713094949722, -0.004392470698803663, -0.060924988240003586, 0.02201807126402855, 0.009265708737075329, 0.00600338913500309, 0.06117812916636467, 0.025871669873595238, 0.020144866779446602, -0.014316241256892681, 0.0073105706833302975, 0.015497851185500622, -0.04928461089730263, -0.014934338629245758, -0.031153474003076553, -0.05619829520583153, 0.05276124179363251, -0.010124835185706615, -0.028887508437037468, 0.0017685390776023269, -0.037650492042303085, 0.014335975982248783, 0.012808568775653839, 0.029397107660770416, -0.03017551079392433, 0.08112373948097229, 0.022537510842084885, 0.048739682883024216, -0.018812797963619232, 0.023526117205619812, 0.1134660467505455, 0.06944827735424042, 0.012133639305830002, -0.09542021155357361, 0.03013749048113823, -0.03481201082468033, 0.029714029282331467, -0.02375013567507267, 0.006032264791429043, 0.03425736352801323, -0.010389023460447788, 0.011409568600356579, 0.027358774095773697, -0.0059404815547168255, 0.005875255446881056, 0.07861904054880142, -0.04264935106039047, -0.005572321359068155, -0.014136699959635735, 0.02069995552301407, 0.00426594028249383, 0.011568417772650719, -0.053405702114105225, 0.007710521575063467, -0.025540795177221298, -0.024799099192023277, -0.0032595053780823946, -0.05064186453819275, 0.006853554397821426, -0.015113972127437592, -0.03356678783893585, -0.01448348443955183, 0.050916530191898346, 0.0021244625095278025, 0.012061080895364285, 0.01833484135568142, -0.007651220541447401, -0.0074927303940057755, 0.028143102303147316, 0.019440917298197746, 0.04074671491980553, -0.021173974499106407, 0.005532548297196627, -0.02313643880188465, -0.021616298705339432, -0.023470500484108925, -0.03316270560026169, -0.0010038528125733137, -0.012506980448961258, 0.0011570791248232126, -0.040062692016363144, -0.011610696092247963, -0.01718869060277939, -0.04693303629755974, -0.021577754989266396, 0.009570085443556309, 0.02746095135807991, -0.037091366946697235, -0.02602146938443184, -0.04709862172603607, -0.004961170721799135, 0.0023690545931458473, 0.05484059453010559, 0.004768843296915293, -0.04573244974017143, 0.008862342685461044, -0.032382383942604065, 0.045425646007061005, -0.016073785722255707, -0.028622616082429886, -0.015043157152831554, -0.0007764603942632675, -0.04106198251247406, 0.006150632165372372, 0.0238405242562294, -0.027144065126776695, 0.030501367524266243, 0.019899636507034302, 0.009654003195464611, -0.002068352187052369, -0.049356117844581604, 0.00460051978006959, -0.025983475148677826, 0.008391137234866619, 0.0027781552635133266, -0.022604020312428474, 0.01969185471534729, 0.03110653907060623, -0.0019039533799514174, 0.0049887765198946, -0.026373783126473427, 0.005725302267819643, 0.028716454282402992, -0.05493918061256409, -0.02286677621304989, 0.012571608647704124, -0.03415763005614281, -0.005806716158986092, -0.00901112612336874, 0.05224623158574104, 0.05223836749792099, 0.009272429160773754, -0.019026929512619972, 0.03271908685564995, -0.03838072344660759, -0.024511875584721565, 0.008504155091941357, 0.011074363254010677, 0.010915632359683514, 0.034818559885025024, 0.032572295516729355, -0.03902506083250046, -0.026208896189928055, -0.027435217052698135, 0.043934114277362823, -0.039009422063827515, 0.016382593661546707, 0.0032246538903564215, 0.0027675784658640623, -0.0031687519513070583, 0.02088119462132454, -0.03927965834736824, 0.006862191949039698, 0.013721486553549767, -0.014123421162366867, -0.005895075388252735, -0.009305710904300213, -0.019706858322024345, 0.007402488961815834, -0.004067557398229837, -0.03670993819832802, -0.0021675387397408485, 0.010447831824421883, 0.000315837562084198, -0.003407791256904602, -0.005512540694326162, -0.0073659080080688, 0.027076203376054764, -0.03289514407515526, -0.06775441765785217, 0.015556296333670616, -0.029750507324934006, -0.016095058992505074, 0.020465606823563576, 0.006094896700233221, 0.042029086500406265, 0.019313374534249306, -0.030424412339925766, -0.03604161739349365, 0.03330143168568611, -0.037942126393318176, 0.0005030284519307315, -0.008467338047921658, 0.020403778180480003, 0.013625778257846832, 0.007066473364830017, 0.01585974730551243, 0.00500002596527338, -0.012125908397138119, -0.008224563673138618, 0.04247291013598442, 0.006027494091540575, -0.04475310444831848, 0.02773747220635414, 0.005346689838916063, 0.018132589757442474, 0.01030736230313778, 0.021969307214021683, 0.052853960543870926, 0.04452180862426758, -0.023137347772717476, 0.020664816722273827, -0.015791811048984528, -0.017130253836512566, -0.049606889486312866, 0.003764521097764373, 0.008295667357742786, -0.00325163290835917, 0.06806925684213638, -0.026590315625071526, -0.01472253818064928, 0.02226349525153637, -0.04094235971570015, 0.0023364524822682142, 0.010148017667233944, -0.017882902175188065, -0.02834266424179077, -0.001760047976858914, -0.05706677958369255, 0.061792220920324326, 0.05027777701616287, 0.005393387749791145, 0.04096613824367523, -0.0008267561788670719, 0.005801441613584757, 0.00942607969045639, 0.005421426612883806, 0.022809462621808052, -0.0011637465795502067, 0.005741037428379059, 0.06833431124687195, -0.03278281167149544, -0.03480299934744835, 0.04760519415140152, -0.010835297405719757, 0.024885030463337898, 0.029764648526906967, 0.0409688763320446, -0.009504963643848896, 0.029533125460147858, -0.014719118364155293, -0.030913494527339935, -0.013896840624511242, -0.018249211832880974, 0.05958639457821846, -0.0009744793642312288, -0.02596454881131649, 0.012860214337706566, 0.0012235906906425953, -0.02668502926826477, -0.013967955484986305, -0.01312259491533041, -0.008256400004029274, -0.027147825807332993, -0.009933361783623695, -0.013730894774198532, -0.025527330115437508, -0.002554291160777211, 0.03571712598204613, -0.0027062289882451296, -0.024437250569462776, 0.05249273404479027, 0.009157892316579819, -0.0354691706597805, -0.018538692966103554, -0.004559004213660955, -0.04073548689484596, 0.0521346852183342, 0.03418850526213646, -0.02506798319518566, -0.04122196137905121, -0.02564440295100212, 0.02157071977853775, 0.000013594530173577368, -0.04151373729109764, -0.0363883413374424, -0.06858552247285843, 0.014955955557525158, 0.005971516016870737, 0.0033953855745494366, -0.02410993166267872, -0.050944942981004715, -0.0018900878494605422, -0.06927161663770676, 0.07492479681968689, 0.0151362931355834, -0.026940224692225456, -0.023935144767165184, -0.044071730226278305, -0.022664405405521393, -0.01794649101793766, 0.05545142665505409, 0.018760818988084793, -0.03764466196298599, 0.03251473605632782, 0.02907438948750496, -0.0061805760487914085, -0.013115841895341873, 0.03426642715930939, -0.018733249977231026, 0.0017817731713876128, -0.006062248721718788, -0.04258689656853676, 0.00588695053011179, 0.02488068677484989, -0.003910025581717491, -0.010709207504987717, -0.01817619800567627, 0.024002833291888237, -0.027527667582035065, 0.03299000859260559, -0.00552168395370245, -0.005423113238066435, 0.053762953728437424, -0.01728733256459236, 0.001575950300320983, 0.007901402190327644, -0.026682665571570396, -0.04352237284183502, 0.008036460727453232, -0.014096535742282867, 0.013622299768030643, -0.042217958718538284, 0.028446005657315254, 0.018471021205186844, -0.043189384043216705, -0.039176516234874725, 0.05539178475737572, -0.01590190827846527, -0.021495571359992027, 0.038718994706869125, 0.01719062775373459, 0.049410201609134674, 0.015285328961908817, 0.015554972924292088, 0.016901906579732895, 0.07645951956510544, 0.02435556799173355, 0.019215133041143417, 0.028788628056645393, -0.002821400063112378, 0.010756906121969223, 0.018268221989274025, -0.04073742777109146, -0.008372930809855461, -0.04052473604679108, 0.039911460131406784, -0.057192035019397736, -0.02916586771607399, 0.010527572594583035, -0.03487764298915863, 0.017296001315116882, 0.009314811788499355, -0.00010060913336928934, 0.07954786717891693, -0.00923385564237833, 0.018037838861346245, 0.027039697393774986, 0.016807744279503822, -0.0305309034883976, -0.043434999883174896, 0.0027670145500451326, -0.006431203801184893, -0.028077078983187675, 0.016239020973443985, -0.0003947947989217937, -0.005196151323616505, 0.03027448058128357, -0.05572201684117317, -0.030684620141983032, 0.015194810926914215, -0.027367398142814636, -0.01308145746588707, -0.025738567113876343, -0.05595279484987259, -0.00849077943712473, 0.047087233513593674, 0.055277805775403976, 0.05092328041791916, 0.008303464390337467, -0.021093832328915596, -0.03903838247060776, 0.055548638105392456, -0.07173077017068863, -0.020987089723348618, -0.012626489624381065, 0.006832635495811701, -0.0022352358791977167, 0.009970922023057938 ]
<p>I am investigating the achieved mark in a math test in grade 8 in two different cities. The plot shows the two <em>Empirical Cumulative Distribution Functions</em> (<em>ECDF</em>).</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/6vLlw.png" alt="Plot of two ECDFs"></p> <p>How can I evaluate whether these two <em>ECDFs</em> follow the same distribution or not?</p>
73,780
[ -0.029117317870259285, -0.02582818642258644, -0.02568592131137848, -0.005322839133441448, 0.02857680805027485, 0.009333504363894463, -0.010009466670453548, -0.00816606916487217, 0.026197100058197975, 0.009989738464355469, 0.07440299540758133, 0.025787143036723137, 0.0427449531853199, 0.02475222758948803, 0.020067768171429634, 0.002802121452987194, -0.013821778818964958, 0.041619110852479935, 0.027396244928240776, -0.039428066462278366, -0.023879030719399452, -0.010868452489376068, 0.030024098232388496, -0.03643971309065819, -0.042170993983745575, 0.02047915942966938, 0.06358686089515686, -0.06266100704669952, 0.021578190848231316, 0.06436621397733688, -0.01029000524431467, -0.04063167795538902, 0.06386308372020721, 0.028717374429106712, 0.013415226712822914, -0.018611537292599678, -0.05610843002796173, -0.02497246488928795, -0.019637402147054672, 0.03973337262868881, -0.032383233308792114, -0.050888072699308395, -0.00611161720007658, 0.03221699595451355, -0.008198072202503681, 0.024474820122122765, -0.008927659131586552, -0.022588608786463737, 0.04228871688246727, -0.03676663711667061, 0.05509093403816223, -0.011439794674515724, 0.052839245647192, 0.026723716408014297, 0.001808654167689383, -0.02669771946966648, 0.02546657994389534, 0.04260857030749321, 0.025395380333065987, -0.04835129901766777, -0.020157307386398315, -0.03092145547270775, -0.028669031336903572, -0.0050902897492051125, -0.027541084215044975, 0.04130278155207634, -0.017224350944161415, -0.022148476913571358, 0.004367940593510866, 0.013349759392440319, 0.034157879650592804, 0.06165459752082825, 0.031630344688892365, -0.025350406765937805, 0.03188130259513855, -0.034894999116659164, 0.026281580328941345, 0.02164282090961933, 0.059386201202869415, 0.02565019391477108, -0.019453825429081917, 0.02873879484832287, 0.03523266315460205, 0.03767198696732521, 0.04296795651316643, -0.019958220422267914, 0.05604181066155434, 0.005073386710137129, 0.00232448591850698, 0.027306659147143364, 0.000174964516190812, -0.04061909019947052, 0.0742088258266449, -0.012993701733648777, -0.028593068942427635, 0.011467965319752693, -0.020720848813652992, 0.005971361882984638, -0.010526895523071289, 0.0003334788198117167, -0.031388964504003525, -0.03976059332489967, 0.07002457976341248, 0.05691397190093994, -0.028767054900527, 0.0020209718495607376, -0.031692586839199066, -0.0012770630419254303, -0.03041449375450611, 0.007332955487072468, -0.013733391650021076, 0.05522209033370018, 0.017680730670690536, 0.03357602283358574, 0.023215869441628456, 0.03290954604744911, -0.00934573169797659, -0.026993971318006516, 0.0709308385848999, 0.03618940711021423, 0.022983526811003685, -0.02475164458155632, -0.005481821019202471, -0.04065796360373497, -0.028238506987690926, -0.024171631783246994, 0.025305600836873055, 0.043721217662096024, -0.008446979336440563, 0.06831958144903183, -0.039372239261865616, -0.02349746786057949, -0.0016713709337636828, 0.00992301944643259, -0.004909644369035959, 0.013751459307968616, -0.0861927717924118, -0.01912238448858261, 0.013515257276594639, 0.0020035456400364637, -0.015316752716898918, -0.056467607617378235, -0.0368589386343956, 0.022905733436346054, 0.023804644122719765, 0.03733266144990921, 0.03154289722442627, -0.022577544674277306, 0.04760720953345299, 0.02975689433515072, 0.010931032709777355, -0.012616843916475773, -0.02534112147986889, -0.031521864235401154, -0.02775029093027115, -0.060664400458335876, 0.008459070697426796, 0.03218795731663704, -0.02410249598324299, -0.03420868143439293, 0.07116153091192245, 0.023070184513926506, 0.007164875511080027, -0.008404284715652466, 0.042458172887563705, -0.024919569492340088, 0.07729753106832504, 0.030235327780246735, 0.01884453184902668, 0.02425927296280861, -0.028212759643793106, 0.0343749113380909, -0.005677982699126005, -0.006912951823323965, 0.017612159252166748, 0.010659921914339066, 0.019656939432024956, -0.04142313450574875, 0.04039640724658966, -0.014546869322657585, -0.023531096056103706, -0.0076236301101744175, -0.05403529852628708, -0.015333221293985844, 0.018228674307465553, 0.04819885641336441, 0.0021176354493945837, -0.04466567561030388, 0.015861520543694496, -0.049428414553403854, -0.053247593343257904, -0.06528438627719879, 0.037321094423532486, -0.003156757913529873, -0.035229314118623734, 0.029373817145824432, -0.01038579922169447, 0.026916570961475372, -0.04468318074941635, -0.003708497853949666, -0.03941541537642479, -0.013449333608150482, 0.011154219508171082, -0.013698328286409378, -0.00463838130235672, 0.0453789159655571, 0.06830130517482758, -0.004665547516196966, 0.027383921667933464, -0.04355539008975029, -0.045066848397254944, -0.0012523524928838015, -0.0528775192797184, 0.006622853688895702, -0.01494748517870903, 0.010032616555690765, -0.002040252787992358, 0.025435205549001694, 0.01897924207150936, 0.016139540821313858, -0.043565258383750916, 0.09062394499778748, 0.042804889380931854, 0.012317475862801075, 0.001757135963998735, 0.001059174188412726, 0.019983427599072456, 0.012112589552998543, -0.00408959062770009, -0.03665823116898537, -0.04238951951265335, -0.01626376435160637, 0.052107974886894226, 0.012761582620441914, -0.026258323341608047, 0.03572206571698189, 0.06075777858495712, 0.017800673842430115, -0.015392525121569633, 0.028240835294127464, 0.01998940296471119, -0.00872491579502821, 0.025308426469564438, 0.025827882811427116, 0.027677511796355247, 0.01257689855992794, 0.0355503223836422, 0.02006179839372635, 0.03414051607251167, -0.04864994436502457, -0.010164115577936172, 0.063265360891819, -0.048130061477422714, 0.014852289110422134, -0.019622405990958214, 0.040447529405355453, 0.03708196058869362, -0.012416983023285866, -0.00889081135392189, 0.02220342494547367, -0.05064869672060013, 0.01598013937473297, 0.006881668232381344, -0.039970241487026215, 0.0315232090651989, 0.02814912423491478, -0.019216172397136688, -0.051690105348825455, 0.020780248567461967, -0.03936712071299553, 0.010635270737111568, -0.025816313922405243, -0.0477188378572464, 0.00012469491048250347, 0.01133607979863882, 0.05597085505723953, 0.013844868168234825, -0.0019408747320994735, -0.0206870399415493, -0.03130625560879707, 0.015268894843757153, -0.032009609043598175, 0.013357714749872684, -0.015899650752544403, -0.041906923055648804, 0.01030952949076891, -0.00608194200322032, 0.006684530526399612, 0.05717910826206207, 0.027428239583969116, -0.033331915736198425, 0.019635282456874847, 0.005894755013287067, -0.004667932167649269, 0.010115064680576324, -0.01794244535267353, 0.012544672004878521, -0.02996903471648693, -0.0017813241574913263, 0.06033175066113472, -0.021827979013323784, -0.011622590944170952, 0.035572636872529984, -0.03577061742544174, -0.025615021586418152, -0.0211025457829237, 0.009174950420856476, 0.008449336513876915, -0.018534773960709572, 0.020481590181589127, 0.010702656581997871, 0.006275585386902094, -0.05546452850103378, -0.08284398168325424, -0.03556529060006142, 0.009149298071861267, -0.018187666311860085, 0.048675257712602615, -0.022341599687933922, -0.021349787712097168, 0.03545926883816719, 0.044873468577861786, -0.020365605130791664, -0.03855297341942787, -0.009886411018669605, -0.020797040313482285, 0.003749698167666793, -0.011754460632801056, 0.03464308753609657, -0.023993996903300285, 0.019072065129876137, 0.006394473370164633, 0.012728437781333923, 0.05735767260193825, -0.04539097845554352, 0.0008692904957570136, 0.0035699910949915648, 0.02665582112967968, -0.01921936310827732, 0.053048696368932724, 0.013955963775515556, -0.012461028061807156, -0.016844339668750763, 0.029843492433428764, 0.03116912767291069, 0.004424442537128925, -0.03142550587654114, 0.02699904330074787, -0.023179085925221443, -0.002667313674464822, -0.04847518354654312, 0.02088289149105549, 0.04294377565383911, -0.02457464672625065, 0.008234001696109772, -0.02135678194463253, 0.03182845190167427, -0.013991067185997963, 0.006133750081062317, 0.0634332001209259, 0.04859508201479912, 0.0069136363454163074, 0.003918807487934828, -0.059789251536130905, 0.027663737535476685, 0.04118833318352699, -0.04079454764723778, -0.04090040922164917, 0.03505268692970276, 0.0247738566249609, 0.02971324883401394, -0.013873509131371975, -0.04883318394422531, -0.010484100319445133, -0.07046127319335938, -0.00181123660877347, 0.01249152421951294, 0.023031191900372505, 0.055106084793806076, 0.03581151366233826, 0.0015345438150689006, -0.022193577140569687, -0.00867503322660923, 0.00876576080918312, -0.08807358890771866, 0.009751005098223686, 0.021974340081214905, -0.011854134500026703, -0.02395208366215229, -0.014295632019639015, 0.014092748053371906, -0.03360186144709587, 0.0039668302051723, 0.025910232216119766, 0.0013756798580288887, -0.012702284380793571, -0.026247577741742134, -0.05345679074525833, -0.021099496632814407, -0.023691190406680107, 0.010058347135782242, 0.028727121651172638, -0.025453360751271248, 0.02838219702243805, 0.022876713424921036, -0.007071655243635178, -0.02381817251443863, -0.03299842029809952, 0.01266143936663866, 0.019958822056651115, 0.023815810680389404, -0.00362889445386827, 0.04059301316738129, -0.03427315503358841, 0.0434405617415905, 0.027138100937008858, 0.05517895147204399, 0.07515353709459305, -0.041411977261304855, -0.04027137905359268, -0.03488384559750557, -0.02717689797282219, -0.004346612840890884, 0.032131046056747437, -0.011101665906608105, 0.017703406512737274, 0.035362664610147476, 0.030219383537769318, 0.0018025535391643643, 0.018866313621401787, 0.032269448041915894, -0.003978894557803869, 0.048597175627946854, -0.011187002062797546, -0.021949516609311104, -0.05448746681213379, -0.032011061906814575, 0.02395857311785221, 0.0076867626048624516, 0.02217496745288372, -0.02221267856657505, 0.04414840042591095, 0.008273941464722157, -0.05263897776603699, -0.03343002870678902, -0.02867228351533413, 0.015697192400693893, -0.005862654652446508, -0.04991859942674637, 0.04438537731766701, 0.03372283652424812, 0.04311523959040642, 0.0002667917578946799, 0.026320338249206543, -0.07286140322685242, -0.0030687127728015184, 0.05645691230893135, 0.007513065356761217, -0.030203670263290405, -0.020149128511548042, -0.06586315482854843, -0.013041718862950802, 0.04084757715463638, -0.03932968154549599, 0.014816361479461193, 0.018306246027350426, 0.018689677119255066, -0.041860174387693405, -0.019010769203305244, -0.022887935861945152, 0.04970059543848038, -0.0018004855373874307, 0.024850860238075256, -0.02057795040309429, 0.014086787588894367, 0.0024222484789788723, 0.019999638199806213, 0.052842721343040466, 0.02869739569723606, -0.005089677404612303, -0.014262810349464417, 0.0097584780305624, -0.006064076907932758, -0.0020182065200060606, -0.03481987491250038, 0.011516530998051167, -0.023438461124897003, 0.036682989448308945, 0.046392567455768585, -0.018258392810821533, -0.031148551031947136, 0.020557377487421036, -0.02077179029583931, -0.017181871458888054, 0.020640170201659203, -0.013365501537919044, 0.06639798730611801, 0.0325959287583828, -0.004641700070351362, 0.03450774773955345, 0.01860634796321392, -0.002856831531971693, 0.006467008031904697, -0.05618900805711746, -0.004151246510446072, -0.044457390904426575, -0.011165288276970387, -0.032277509570121765, -0.014020726084709167, -0.02045302279293537, -0.0049331337213516235, -0.009637817740440369, 0.04140646383166313, -0.04909147694706917, -0.003815868403762579, 0.006197912152856588, -0.008842557668685913, -0.017605267465114594, 0.009612562134861946, -0.022526279091835022, -0.00396248884499073, -0.0033422838896512985, -0.008309289813041687, 0.009669404476881027, 0.007890276610851288, 0.008914920501410961, -0.047622278332710266, -0.03482045978307724, 0.03443905711174011, -0.06156688556075096, -0.019147096201777458, 0.009844299405813217, -0.0527748204767704, 0.028996093198657036, -0.01186890248209238, 0.026223842054605484, 0.023683497682213783, 0.0008437535725533962, -0.03198861703276634, 0.03557679057121277, 0.019979681819677353, 0.05718236044049263, -0.02494804747402668, 0.04540546238422394, 0.01401140633970499, -0.02008700929582119, -0.053726356476545334, -0.03710348159074783, 0.04553379490971565, 0.03035995177924633, -0.022898439317941666, -0.031776461750268936, -0.010940915904939175, 0.015412694774568081, -0.007547296583652496, -0.013817992061376572, 0.0664462223649025, 0.0032768838573247194, -0.0105888145044446, 0.017738191410899162, -0.0010106000117957592, 0.1155562773346901, -0.0041708205826580524, 0.003442102577537298, 0.020032735541462898, 0.006409156136214733, -0.03727033734321594, -0.005514971911907196, 0.010890825651586056, -0.042138900607824326, -0.029732530936598778, -0.02347797527909279, 0.03889823332428932, 0.025234539061784744, -0.05552591010928154, -0.016808660700917244, 0.005674438085407019, 0.0020089461468160152, 0.016233626753091812, -0.010398783721029758, -0.007160934153944254, -0.02525996044278145, -0.0027471736539155245, -0.024180786684155464, 0.0034200348891317844, 0.02549576945602894, -0.052308689802885056, 0.018442753702402115, 0.0003903178730979562, -0.018954850733280182, -0.009699790738523006, 0.07799690961837769, -0.02771509438753128, -0.03372754529118538, 0.0023680098820477724, -0.007993756793439388, 0.0018876893445849419, -0.01620016060769558, -0.009520871564745903, 0.016057293862104416, 0.008216663263738155, -0.04386346787214279, 0.0005248815868981183, -0.05434112623333931, -0.04659338667988777, 0.0396278016269207, 0.030850430950522423, 0.05766432359814644, 0.04412708431482315, 0.026733744889497757, 0.00676575256511569, -0.022681131958961487, -0.0009315162897109985, -0.015380935743451118, 0.002491585910320282, 0.024157198145985603, -0.01111125573515892, -0.00429864227771759, 0.032871197909116745, 0.032017115503549576, 0.014676498249173164, 0.01525395829230547, 0.01141460333019495, -0.020626099780201912, 0.03301785886287689, -0.03200005367398262, -0.0083824023604393, 0.029427921399474144, -0.03920118138194084, 0.040609586983919144, -0.030004212632775307, -0.0058140829205513, 0.05420374870300293, 0.03378307446837425, -0.03784069046378136, -0.03147142007946968, -0.010730626061558723, -0.07503890991210938, 0.00843555387109518, 0.015675408765673637, -0.03882264718413353, 0.04693946614861488, 0.023275133222341537, 0.02179500088095665, 0.004668043460696936, 0.03099287673830986, -0.037885621190071106, -0.05130142346024513, 0.01547564659267664, -0.025833534076809883, -0.032126788049936295, 0.01820983923971653, 0.0034033709671348333, -0.023882612586021423, -0.001871363609097898, -0.0007336935959756374, 0.03250729665160179, 0.018253527581691742, 0.028340525925159454, -0.0008230233797803521, 0.05919085443019867, -0.00673032458871603, 0.037321414798498154, -0.017100447788834572, -0.02696562185883522, 0.11812055110931396, 0.03478063642978668, 0.03249145671725273, -0.040255650877952576, 0.0015660361386835575, 0.0003826121101155877, 0.03947019577026367, -0.007791068870574236, -0.009951556101441383, 0.012636210769414902, -0.015964236110448837, 0.04944344237446785, 0.03378202021121979, 0.021853134036064148, -0.05228457599878311, 0.03408774361014366, 0.005317940842360258, -0.02289511449635029, -0.032330937683582306, 0.04805539920926094, 0.005957120563834906, -0.01188824512064457, -0.061320409178733826, 0.023755867034196854, -0.009185592643916607, 0.004041824024170637, -0.059964850544929504, -0.06375584751367569, 0.022688651457428932, -0.0019820828456431627, 0.0012976978905498981, -0.012331344187259674, 0.027793148532509804, -0.01792513206601143, -0.007541286759078503, -0.015865691006183624, -0.012689074501395226, -0.04292667284607887, 0.03377508744597435, 0.042436324059963226, 0.012081404216587543, -0.04033108428120613, 0.023921191692352295, 0.020902778953313828, -0.04580586031079292, -0.020433364436030388, -0.0360560417175293, 0.026803169399499893, -0.011335007846355438, -0.01870296150445938, -0.02449917234480381, -0.001764307264238596, 0.00006514314736705273, -0.054464440792798996, -0.04605241119861603, -0.02199459634721279, -0.0009373410721309483, -0.03738739714026451, -0.023613912984728813, -0.029880572110414505, 0.004067272879183292, 0.00028323629521764815, 0.026076430454850197, 0.009349376894533634, -0.035607047379016876, -0.0016775451367720962, -0.0005882724653929472, 0.04496639594435692, 0.024832794442772865, -0.04435761272907257, 0.005920084659010172, -0.02439977414906025, -0.021584399044513702, -0.008689239621162415, 0.00504318019375205, 0.02635357901453972, 0.021681055426597595, 0.029367700219154358, 0.009690187871456146, 0.0011951248161494732, -0.013296418823301792, 0.04708612337708473, -0.011751728132367134, -0.006066998466849327, -0.03614729270339012, 0.009096657857298851, 0.03310401365160942, 0.026017989963293076, 0.040743473917245865, 0.060769300907850266, 0.015634343028068542, 0.05788964033126831, 0.036370329558849335, -0.034164026379585266, 0.0007768961368128657, -0.013875733129680157, -0.012723316438496113, -0.020057737827301025, -0.02347574569284916, 0.08219616860151291, 0.012491331435739994, -0.0012579020112752914, -0.0061407070606946945, 0.0329158715903759, -0.005372061859816313, 0.014626908116042614, -0.03704804554581642, -0.04757954925298691, -0.02917277254164219, 0.007448890712112188, -0.0032297878060489893, -0.034528229385614395, -0.0176677443087101, -0.04067259281873703, -0.022123821079730988, 0.018034981563687325, -0.008018139749765396, -0.03029211238026619, -0.00795868132263422, -0.027527300640940666, 0.01831885054707527, -0.015587667934596539, -0.011857631616294384, -0.03215407580137253, -0.035971105098724365, -0.011700027622282505, -0.04174647107720375, -0.01992071606218815, 0.01310125645250082, 0.022388922050595284, 0.01037872675806284, 0.03284461051225662, 0.03267396613955498, 0.0052301581017673016, -0.03382754325866699, 0.010337545536458492, -0.019835740327835083, 0.030062656849622726, -0.004637190140783787, -0.008378067053854465, 0.06458937376737595, -0.017087077721953392, -0.037934012711048126, 0.00020363663497846574, 0.0144138652831316, 0.017903553321957588, 0.00847191084176302, -0.009841613471508026, 0.031456343829631805, 0.06104830652475357, -0.018713438883423805, -0.01372299250215292, -0.024796748533844948, -0.0327439159154892, 0.03818667680025101, 0.02703079767525196, -0.008367776870727539, -0.009367559105157852, -0.0286544281989336, 0.050767675042152405, 0.010166228748857975, 0.02262554131448269, -0.001618541544303298, 0.008320447988808155, -0.02187972143292427, 0.010173501446843147, 0.018316777423024178, 0.015386524610221386, 0.019383223727345467, 0.04304473102092743, 0.0053263441659510136, -0.012681630440056324, -0.02897128090262413, 0.018671303987503052, -0.06882408261299133, -0.012665024027228355, 0.04994228854775429, -0.012976417317986488, 0.010716312564909458, 0.0049448162317276, -0.0033416778314858675, 0.031115997582674026, -0.02494383230805397, 0.030357051640748978, -0.028764350339770317, -0.01360401976853609, -0.05762966349720955, -0.021109409630298615, 0.015675770118832588, 0.04856795072555542, 0.0294374767690897, 0.0545012392103672, 0.012850395403802395, 0.03154655545949936, 0.008699643425643444, -0.0014988796319812536, -0.01581140235066414, -0.0036918148398399353, 0.016727104783058167, -0.032410845160484314, 0.02539302222430706, -0.017244163900613785, -0.0052233063615858555, 0.0048011853359639645, -0.04448175057768822, 0.022892097011208534, 0.00018643519433680922, -0.014017530716955662, 0.04453734681010246, 0.011323196813464165, 0.015531745739281178, -0.0076505569741129875, -0.03669622540473938, -0.030971352010965347, 0.018098322674632072, 0.013009097427129745, -0.03422637656331062, -0.00022178109793458134, 0.02122398652136326, -0.0019105523824691772, -0.04780326411128044, 0.034738656133413315, 0.02854328043758869, -0.040922969579696655, -0.017837027087807655, -0.00234217569231987, 0.05399933457374573, -0.008737306110560894, 0.005973143503069878, -0.05039187893271446, -0.035094067454338074, 0.017584966495633125, 0.002613500924780965, -0.025835979729890823, 0.02264380268752575, -0.014646404422819614, -0.0460914745926857, -0.0012558357557281852, 0.02366987243294716, -0.002892901189625263, -0.020946793258190155, 0.011069045402109623, -0.02811254933476448, 0.02615649253129959, 0.004978670738637447, -0.07140158861875534, -0.0005581891164183617, 0.03049594536423683, -0.0021707480773329735, -0.006966992747038603, 0.017879702150821686, -0.017423409968614578, -0.024104593321681023, -0.07359921187162399, 0.0426948219537735, 0.006667994894087315, -0.059951070696115494, -0.03775757923722267, 0.028589360415935516, -0.031928546726703644, 0.028802433982491493, 0.06183608993887901, 0.030285676941275597, 0.012568129226565361, -0.02150948904454708, 0.020627396181225777, 0.009913818910717964, -0.1030508279800415, 0.016858095303177834, -0.01525902934372425, -0.011106337420642376, 0.0021979822777211666, 0.03298087790608406, -0.010591370053589344, 0.0411212183535099, -0.012064277194440365, -0.018055729568004608, 0.03794490545988083, -0.015396966598927975, 0.003972420934587717, 0.051566313952207565, 0.005350323859602213, -0.03624414652585983, 0.0637626200914383, -0.023560605943202972, 0.01865835301578045, -0.03778652846813202, 0.0047990563325583935, -0.05206489935517311, 0.059978485107421875, -0.009343534708023071, -0.03138047456741333, 0.0020121997222304344, -0.010202344506978989, 0.018049638718366623, -0.06276282668113708, -0.06239873915910721, -0.0072929649613797665, -0.0276093278080225, -0.01984742470085621, 0.0209632720798254, 0.024254167452454567, 0.027062751352787018, -0.017430929467082024, 0.0010153151815757155, -0.0322091244161129, -0.008045264519751072, 0.00639514671638608, -0.01702387072145939, 0.05320637673139572, -0.012370244599878788, 0.009110644459724426, 0.04510587081313133, -0.04523229971528053, 0.018305007368326187, -0.01704188995063305, 0.05783998966217041, -0.0032454682514071465, -0.020075850188732147, 0.017269864678382874, 0.007924460805952549, 0.007793651893734932, 0.013560627587139606, -0.029350481927394867, 0.0687919408082962, -0.03474996238946915, -0.0007560058729723096, -0.01908976212143898, -0.030232181772589684, -0.0378572903573513, 0.005712673533707857, 0.06706221401691437, -0.008361236192286015, 0.018902644515037537, -0.02743603102862835, -0.012320077046751976, 0.005753958597779274, 0.016265977174043655, -0.0031224393751472235, 0.04043984413146973, -0.004712347872555256, -0.004905395209789276, 0.02759733237326145, 0.022648176178336143, -0.011212889105081558, -0.02147410623729229, 0.034335341304540634, 0.041853249073028564, 0.04203015938401222, 0.001398405758664012, -0.04420594871044159, 0.02467215806245804, 0.06708390265703201, -0.07214082777500153, -0.03477829322218895, -0.024533016607165337, 0.020221630111336708, 0.010320615023374557, -0.043114177882671356 ]
<p>I'd be really grateful for recommendations of a robust package for fitting discrete choice models to a large amount ($n$ in the millions and $p$ in 2000 range) of data. I want a smoothed model that can deal with multi-colinear dependent variables and matrix inversion issues sensibly - like <a href="http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/glmnet/index.html" rel="nofollow">glmnet</a>. I'm happy to bootstrap samples, which may be the only way to deal with big data in R.</p> <p>I've tried using the <a href="http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/mlogit/index.html" rel="nofollow">mlogit</a> package and it falls apart with more than a few hundred predictors, producing errors to do with matrix inversion.</p> <p>My alternative is to use the <a href="http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/glmnet/index.html" rel="nofollow">glmnet</a> package for binary regression and then use transforms to approximate the discrete choice model using something called Begg and Gray's approximation. </p> <p>This data is not multinomial, in the traditional sense. It is discrete-choice, that is the classes themselves change from observation to observation -- possibly also the number of classes. Each of the classes has a set of predictors which are measured on the same scale and are class specific -- cf. <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discrete_choice" rel="nofollow">Discrete Choice Models</a>. I wrote to the maintainer of <code>glmnet</code>, Trevor Hastie, who says there is no mapping to discrete choice models in their package.</p> <p>Another name for discrete-choice is conditional logit, with the correct parameterization. I found the package <a href="http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/pglm/index.html" rel="nofollow">pglm</a>, but it is also lacking in robustness. There's reference, <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/10141/">Discrete choice panel models in R</a> to <a href="http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/lme4/index.html" rel="nofollow">lme4</a> also, but I have found no examples of the conditional logit with it.</p>
73,781
[ -0.04200875014066696, -0.0029760298784822226, 0.02779405005276203, -0.001581203076057136, 0.022659393027424812, 0.010373062454164028, -0.0420721173286438, -0.010438097640872002, 0.01922326348721981, -0.03913850709795952, 0.014715559780597687, 0.03865586966276169, 0.03585752844810486, 0.03630763664841652, 0.0023990077897906303, 0.0211611557751894, -0.014773066155612469, -0.0026612926740199327, -0.00739802373573184, 0.00401913421228528, 0.013943152502179146, 0.051655113697052, -0.002775401808321476, -0.039290547370910645, -0.021395619958639145, 0.012207160703837872, -0.008893029764294624, -0.028554271906614304, 0.005045528523623943, 0.041184477508068085, -0.05764627829194069, -0.01932031661272049, -0.009153146296739578, 0.03516257554292679, -0.00415260624140501, 0.03518360108137131, -0.025230854749679565, -0.03505093976855278, 0.015332862734794617, 0.003563895355910063, -0.04403167590498924, -0.02950860559940338, 0.001251236186362803, 0.026685187593102455, 0.020345697179436684, 0.016775330528616905, 0.03992052376270294, -0.020950399339199066, 0.0936051458120346, -0.019925996661186218, 0.06464607268571854, -0.021498320624232292, -0.00161459029186517, 0.043165575712919235, -0.04730648547410965, -0.030038416385650635, 0.05231698974967003, 0.06217232719063759, -0.02167186141014099, -0.050787776708602905, 0.0029289196245372295, -0.04564640671014786, 0.016939125955104828, -0.060717396438121796, -0.01933283545076847, 0.002742562210187316, 0.014051735401153564, -0.03156284987926483, 0.023956933990120888, -0.04440135136246681, 0.02849944680929184, 0.002872331067919731, 0.014112906530499458, 0.01799936592578888, 0.030215688049793243, 0.013631719164550304, 0.03841184824705124, 0.04545914754271507, 0.05245472118258476, 0.02291528321802616, -0.035494495183229446, 0.012482354417443275, 0.010837110690772533, 0.006152140907943249, 0.016451645642518997, -0.04662666842341423, 0.026647286489605904, -0.008377944119274616, 0.04928618669509888, 0.01575958915054798, -0.048302020877599716, -0.02699306420981884, 0.04093046858906746, 0.020848235115408897, -0.024251123890280724, 0.034482117742300034, 0.0058214738965034485, 0.001493718707934022, 0.004860338289290667, -0.024643028154969215, -0.02540041320025921, -0.0322578027844429, -0.030520478263497353, 0.06540406495332718, -0.013992981985211372, 0.029052751138806343, -0.034770652651786804, -0.07106595486402512, -0.0027126555796712637, -0.019380591809749603, -0.015963559970259666, 0.02013225294649601, -0.007576791103929281, -0.004842623136937618, -0.0005770639982074499, -0.02120330184698105, -0.030229900032281876, -0.014815384522080421, 0.02616855688393116, 0.09059978276491165, 0.04279065504670143, -0.034428469836711884, 0.01966927945613861, -0.060669634491205215, -0.06492944061756134, 0.013717619702219963, 0.02941039390861988, -0.011744203977286816, -0.03932442516088486, 0.05422205850481987, -0.012179003097116947, -0.04168085381388664, 0.03816860541701317, -0.015525471419095993, 0.013644346967339516, -0.02322535589337349, -0.06133756786584854, -0.06773003190755844, 0.011601374484598637, -0.009618735872209072, 0.03366550803184509, -0.03413473442196846, -0.0037942216731607914, -0.007448926568031311, 0.04344925656914711, -0.002072117757052183, 0.07219421863555908, 0.04753732681274414, 0.013039394281804562, 0.007847837172448635, -0.010014118626713753, 0.04522572457790375, -0.010168930515646935, 0.0222781952470541, 0.007548544090241194, -0.06240696832537651, 0.035192955285310745, 0.021748797968029976, -0.0324026457965374, 0.027892692014575005, 0.044142309576272964, 0.05835052579641342, -0.06844501942396164, -0.0022281683050096035, 0.006185742560774088, -0.004172413144260645, 0.013182912953197956, -0.01636062189936638, 0.06403965502977371, -0.008266288787126541, -0.019973143935203552, 0.013566956855356693, 0.007874745875597, 0.08171777427196503, 0.007004160899668932, -0.009695625863969326, -0.004371494986116886, -0.021933363750576973, 0.005432656034827232, 0.008746885694563389, -0.0202599186450243, -0.020260892808437347, -0.014993827790021896, -0.04453593119978905, -0.021219154819846153, 0.03161749243736267, -0.005178753286600113, -0.031938325613737106, 0.03694130480289459, -0.02720952033996582, -0.05655856058001518, -0.03194710612297058, -0.008693649433553219, -0.015767496079206467, 0.021265262737870216, 0.04112040251493454, -0.00267903134226799, 0.0029029331635683775, 0.044216498732566833, -0.02450162172317505, -0.020576706156134605, 0.0036079389974474907, 0.046773385256528854, -0.011666884645819664, -0.02089965157210827, 0.035151366144418716, 0.06969183683395386, -0.055194318294525146, 0.023013245314359665, -0.04225168749690056, -0.004197989124804735, 0.01132428552955389, -0.02973460964858532, 0.03599468991160393, -0.04275321215391159, -0.038444314152002335, 0.026756977662444115, 0.004579004365950823, -0.015311295166611671, 0.0395793654024601, -0.07465824484825134, 0.02022627554833889, 0.074013851583004, -0.013077708892524242, 0.009364921599626541, 0.0263131782412529, -0.05175752192735672, 0.009547209367156029, -0.053467798978090286, -0.007855167612433434, -0.032143495976924896, -0.003406656440347433, 0.0448659248650074, 0.02435513585805893, -0.012574687600135803, 0.015364383347332478, 0.03624074533581734, 0.05568256601691246, 0.014208377338945866, 0.010898709297180176, -0.03945218771696091, -0.04977736249566078, 0.03035857528448105, -0.022478947415947914, 0.012564093805849552, 0.016160372644662857, -0.011825216934084892, -0.02900524251163006, 0.045687709003686905, -0.030350329354405403, -0.001362189301289618, 0.034966129809617996, 0.025762872770428658, -0.03710324689745903, -0.019888028502464294, -0.030489761382341385, 0.05104125663638115, -0.026814071461558342, 0.0008005564450286329, 0.03970874100923538, 0.011281504295766354, -0.0006512334221042693, 0.0014222775353118777, -0.03498116508126259, 0.03673949092626572, 0.06693311780691147, -0.03617829829454422, -0.005712553393095732, 0.017347708344459534, -0.05629989132285118, 0.04384663328528404, -0.0384700708091259, -0.04321780800819397, -0.021751025691628456, 0.018618814647197723, -0.012198982760310173, 0.021439624950289726, -0.01904590055346489, -0.03669193387031555, 0.0008855070336721838, 0.01695210486650467, 0.0009891465306282043, 0.03539208322763443, 0.0261082760989666, -0.04975375905632973, -0.01950070820748806, -0.02759423665702343, -0.034603141248226166, 0.03628908842802048, -0.014808887615799904, -0.02869744412600994, 0.032422080636024475, -0.003197956830263138, -0.05490584298968315, -0.0019442031625658274, -0.002654055831953883, -0.017121950164437294, -0.026966668665409088, -0.026466866955161095, 0.02162698283791542, 0.02122085727751255, -0.05178200080990791, 0.007480265107005835, -0.04943621903657913, -0.02188422717154026, -0.00894390232861042, -0.00010488877887837589, -0.02237633243203163, -0.012126193381845951, 0.008725093677639961, -0.01037740707397461, 0.016795970499515533, -0.012536110356450081, -0.08776073902845383, -0.04288432374596596, 0.01532957423478365, -0.022981826215982437, 0.03441762924194336, 0.02269800752401352, 0.007432308979332447, 0.057919587939977646, 0.049276676028966904, -0.0428481325507164, -0.025253966450691223, -0.015304991975426674, 0.001265762490220368, 0.011816351674497128, 0.03161891922354698, 0.017837485298514366, 0.010600167326629162, 0.021051019430160522, -0.019207926467061043, -0.0057919686660170555, 0.02429424598813057, -0.00420749606564641, 0.016462793573737144, 0.05834303796291351, -0.027530906721949577, -0.015437791123986244, -0.01766529306769371, 0.01979433000087738, -0.031928058713674545, -0.005687433760613203, -0.030232040211558342, -0.034596797078847885, -0.004517941735684872, -0.04559556767344475, 0.0076309130527079105, 0.00891784019768238, -0.005572102498263121, -0.043511345982551575, 0.026737770065665245, -0.004070010036230087, -0.06430676579475403, 0.014528795145452023, 0.010102241300046444, 0.04946020245552063, -0.024779904633760452, 0.014129476621747017, 0.01857917383313179, 0.045257385820150375, -0.03176295757293701, 0.024626919999718666, 0.0011144496966153383, 0.012173469178378582, 0.01852845400571823, -0.04775277152657509, 0.039839766919612885, 0.003917730879038572, 0.03971988335251808, 0.033122509717941284, -0.005508553236722946, -0.03282861411571503, 0.03413444757461548, -0.04970284551382065, 0.014829845167696476, -0.0398869626224041, 0.041390854865312576, 0.004083205014467239, 0.03246339038014412, -0.012866458855569363, 0.000021931306037004106, 0.016300665214657784, 0.021953536197543144, -0.05592530593276024, 0.027260741218924522, 0.018979458138346672, 0.022712409496307373, 0.020482009276747704, -0.016677197068929672, 0.033863987773656845, 0.004833529703319073, 0.012084469199180603, -0.04543925076723099, 0.04329570755362511, -0.025427786633372307, -0.0016029534162953496, 0.009185455739498138, -0.02370472438633442, 0.004613852594047785, -0.005420867819339037, 0.027102800086140633, -0.026608973741531372, 0.00301984790712595, 0.013827015645802021, -0.010395336896181107, -0.014555529691278934, -0.031091269105672836, 0.03430996462702751, 0.0000402457189920824, 0.04645371437072754, -0.015359173528850079, 0.03052382543683052, -0.018978886306285858, 0.01307647954672575, 0.021834978833794594, 0.03037804365158081, 0.01858861930668354, -0.008558386005461216, -0.014476715587079525, -0.05792783200740814, -0.042929504066705704, 0.01256575994193554, 0.018237877637147903, 0.01670011505484581, -0.038587529212236404, 0.09005902707576752, 0.015269284136593342, -0.03919064626097679, -0.0032302415929734707, 0.023538285866379738, 0.008082451298832893, -0.010760040953755379, 0.0017468772130087018, 0.003587197745218873, -0.0039551821537315845, 0.04487944394350052, 0.016226759180426598, -0.0013140345690771937, 0.012900207191705704, -0.00894090998917818, 0.020499713718891144, -0.002074179006740451, -0.013206436298787594, 0.0011292722774669528, 0.04651227593421936, 0.05370195209980011, -0.017110826447606087, -0.027038363739848137, -0.008816929534077644, 0.05899392068386078, 0.030185356736183167, 0.019556205719709396, 0.025675170123577118, -0.10515538603067398, -0.00794216338545084, 0.019212353974580765, 0.05983452498912811, -0.05117978900671005, 0.004311015363782644, -0.0506928451359272, -0.025523213669657707, 0.015749439597129822, -0.011864671483635902, 0.031871505081653595, -0.012385189533233643, 0.019565992057323456, -0.023231295868754387, -0.04849334433674812, -0.05175546184182167, -0.010134575888514519, -0.051371194422245026, 0.030835583806037903, -0.019593991339206696, -0.04154444485902786, -0.006827112287282944, 0.04723760485649109, 0.01297521311789751, 0.04583821818232536, -0.008608866482973099, -0.014852035790681839, 0.06179925054311752, -0.009597094729542732, -0.022184686735272408, -0.04774346947669983, 0.010896244086325169, -0.00005319648698787205, 0.008518019691109657, 0.041476037353277206, -0.004611660726368427, -0.021735593676567078, -0.014756896533071995, -0.001026825630106032, -0.015364078804850578, 0.005302585195749998, -0.0547003373503685, 0.006295355036854744, -0.008891761302947998, -0.022675741463899612, 0.03166466951370239, 0.02084738202393055, -0.030587326735258102, 0.045390136539936066, -0.047714922577142715, -0.0022635175846517086, -0.0037862672470510006, -0.06871943920850754, -0.002178739756345749, -0.03941476717591286, -0.02379370853304863, 0.029516953974962234, 0.02162044309079647, 0.03062933310866356, 0.0007116589113138616, -0.005431069526821375, -0.02307809703052044, 0.024334801360964775, -0.025968782603740692, 0.029113279655575752, 0.010006329976022243, 0.0059372135438025, 0.023092146962881088, 0.003817820455878973, 0.052082620561122894, 0.004939077887684107, 0.015342285856604576, 0.02762703411281109, -0.06081877648830414, -0.007767781615257263, -0.04248848184943199, -0.05197083204984665, -0.008809562772512436, -0.03962067514657974, 0.05274936184287071, 0.01513552013784647, 0.04974120482802391, -0.008324012160301208, -0.07662373036146164, -0.010429058223962784, 0.010071340017020702, 0.00787363015115261, 0.0034608456771820784, -0.008009363897144794, -0.013616121374070644, -0.013252015225589275, 0.024890685454010963, -0.04174134135246277, -0.02929375134408474, 0.028422219678759575, -0.03937581181526184, -0.037045739591121674, -0.019544538110494614, 0.017007604241371155, -0.006593975238502026, 0.001992208417505026, -0.0012581807095557451, 0.048970695585012436, -0.04115315526723862, 0.03096892684698105, -0.04611332714557648, 0.044827770441770554, 0.06098232790827751, 0.024630598723888397, 0.004206940531730652, -0.0009449548670090735, -0.01180719118565321, -0.03330085426568985, 0.02225472591817379, 0.015285464003682137, -0.02795976586639881, -0.014843032695353031, -0.019844401627779007, 0.0013129664584994316, 0.04756779596209526, -0.0007445189403370023, -0.021360918879508972, 0.0445127859711647, -0.049732331186532974, -0.01185742300003767, -0.00957157276570797, 0.01753663644194603, -0.0007740454748272896, -0.0004145835991948843, -0.05485435575246811, -0.012781066820025444, -0.005992946680635214, 0.015454052947461605, 0.005580062046647072, -0.02966342866420746, -0.037045855075120926, 0.017228344455361366, 0.035770315676927567, 0.018043797463178635, -0.003627366852015257, 0.016934771090745926, -0.035944875329732895, 0.06304792314767838, -0.003957143984735012, -0.023280957713723183, 0.03279704600572586, 0.005549504421651363, -0.038638580590486526, -0.019269771873950958, -0.03143654391169548, -0.012467577122151852, 0.025360237807035446, 0.03209485858678818, 0.026044780388474464, 0.038538429886102676, -0.027485165745019913, 0.009629270061850548, -0.023015858605504036, 0.014254646375775337, 0.05287088826298714, 0.02684779278934002, 0.052660901099443436, 0.014421815983951092, -0.023719878867268562, 0.028505483642220497, -0.031959328800439835, 0.01584240235388279, 0.0395619198679924, -0.020375046879053116, -0.0004931421135552227, 0.03389642387628555, -0.04047224298119545, -0.038859523832798004, 0.026500144973397255, -0.05342792347073555, 0.008115828037261963, -0.024152357131242752, -0.029985399916768074, 0.046910855919122696, 0.033187855035066605, 0.05041760578751564, -0.008668376132845879, -0.03270816430449486, -0.06268949806690216, -0.0012253924505785108, 0.003249046392738819, -0.013655967079102993, 0.01814800687134266, 0.011072839610278606, 0.0233419481664896, -0.012123956345021725, 0.03437881916761398, -0.010728727094829082, -0.07845289260149002, -0.006853692699223757, -0.02561216428875923, -0.03647555038332939, 0.032498497515916824, -0.002722193719819188, -0.009774669073522091, 0.012564992532134056, -0.05761032924056053, -0.00936525035649538, 0.00005672998304362409, -0.006366241257637739, 0.02510101906955242, 0.049022603780031204, -0.04386572912335396, -0.014384632930159569, -0.02316395193338394, -0.057630594819784164, 0.15379302203655243, 0.07290265709161758, 0.045148562639951706, -0.056189555674791336, 0.03223443403840065, -0.013761905953288078, 0.0018361867405474186, -0.02348325587809086, -0.053125739097595215, 0.02845601923763752, -0.02809075638651848, 0.05301717296242714, 0.02874450758099556, 0.02552594244480133, -0.007669716142117977, 0.04963706061244011, 0.01177594717592001, 0.011256457306444645, 0.018342625349760056, 0.006769433617591858, 0.01842639036476612, -0.016489554196596146, -0.02291991002857685, -0.0015510226367041469, -0.0032892327290028334, -0.034009627997875214, -0.027034029364585876, -0.006995667703449726, 0.021147923544049263, 0.023122960701584816, -0.014288503676652908, -0.017803005874156952, 0.01374494656920433, 0.021370848640799522, 0.017880486324429512, 0.020137440413236618, -0.010664108209311962, -0.007746847812086344, 0.006830499041825533, 0.06661862134933472, 0.01467478834092617, 0.013847976922988892, 0.005928784143179655, 0.017516929656267166, -0.055469661951065063, -0.02231139875948429, -0.05227842181921005, 0.02207367680966854, -0.006955407094210386, -0.028899013996124268, -0.0042852796614170074, 0.017922410741448402, 0.02413785830140114, -0.04167284816503525, -0.011497057974338531, 0.049156978726387024, 0.015071527101099491, 0.014571243897080421, -0.05027232691645622, 0.014210729859769344, 0.0010349582880735397, 0.004834942054003477, 0.020434174686670303, -0.0032269374933093786, -0.056471552699804306, -0.06351660937070847, 0.005991281475871801, 0.04899021238088608, 0.024335471913218498, 0.016078393906354904, -0.008816614747047424, 0.0057177459821105, -0.0022428410593420267, -0.018480774015188217, 0.024069756269454956, 0.0017390962457284331, 0.0013411873951554298, 0.009071976877748966, 0.005623287055641413, -0.0261074285954237, -0.01908058300614357, -0.013113005086779594, -0.037156060338020325, 0.028745774179697037, -0.053843121975660324, -0.00242331949993968, -0.017028730362653732, 0.00814619567245245, 0.04267672449350357, 0.034488480538129807, -0.012073286809027195, 0.023768696933984756, 0.01899273321032524, -0.04120325669646263, -0.003496768418699503, -0.05097736790776253, -0.05719076097011566, 0.010256019420921803, 0.011649493128061295, 0.08054249733686447, -0.006543236784636974, 0.010740721598267555, -0.001681722467765212, 0.020760321989655495, 0.004669106099754572, 0.033331673592329025, 0.011222520843148232, -0.05059594288468361, 0.0167942363768816, 0.013481760397553444, -0.005398754961788654, -0.02179790288209915, -0.00750182056799531, -0.04502909630537033, -0.022726530209183693, -0.025595705956220627, -0.053433384746313095, -0.028346462175250053, 0.016794458031654358, -0.03716731816530228, 0.01294337585568428, -0.03342670947313309, -0.037669382989406586, -0.038067568093538284, 0.009757615625858307, -0.04108579456806183, 0.004339142702519894, -0.021674348041415215, -0.0031917020678520203, -0.02445710264146328, -0.001422171131707728, 0.06878331303596497, -0.007276721764355898, -0.008997499942779541, -0.002669429173693061, 0.03005124069750309, 0.023755088448524475, 0.0537806935608387, -0.00895980466157198, -0.013810339383780956, 0.032582011073827744, -0.010291618295013905, -0.017621289938688278, -0.00800599530339241, -0.024272222071886063, 0.06428101658821106, -0.01188932079821825, -0.027284273877739906, -0.007809735368937254, 0.04333433136343956, -0.05597063899040222, 0.003525546519085765, -0.009635211899876595, 0.04858936741948128, 0.03972122445702553, -0.027963481843471527, -0.006231986451894045, 0.021842898800969124, -0.006602806970477104, 0.04026100039482117, 0.02123604714870453, 0.017895936965942383, 0.0005268206004984677, -0.0068703265860676765, -0.04295698553323746, 0.020465966314077377, 0.006738283671438694, 0.026138385757803917, -0.01634947396814823, 0.03224886953830719, -0.024429870769381523, 0.03479006886482239, 0.015105906873941422, 0.016499051824212074, -0.08056866377592087, -0.032223984599113464, 0.009175410494208336, 0.031230807304382324, 0.08301790803670883, -0.05668936297297478, 0.031147673726081848, 0.02061326801776886, -0.04385930299758911, 0.027481138706207275, 0.015823012217879295, 0.01082179881632328, -0.0025079722981899977, -0.02431032992899418, -0.03977208212018013, 0.007153231650590897, 0.025660187005996704, 0.03160405531525612, 0.03133183345198631, 0.004031635355204344, -0.008638792671263218, -0.0005363678210414946, 0.007082369644194841, 0.010089654475450516, 0.033779073506593704, -0.05185750871896744, 0.02176465466618538, -0.04054110497236252, -0.01891605742275715, 0.045503173023462296, 0.011936450377106667, 0.0761328637599945, 0.02652871049940586, 0.028413863852620125, 0.0385812483727932, 0.06688657402992249, 0.045495424419641495, 0.009689193218946457, 0.022350072860717773, -0.02678729221224785, 0.005813957192003727, 0.015278259292244911, 0.006306362804025412, 0.014647293835878372, 0.008317082189023495, 0.0071249897591769695, -0.018266791477799416, 0.013537924736738205, 0.0020886885467916727, 0.02040250413119793, -0.027483101934194565, -0.011294269002974033, -0.004562463145703077, -0.0018493735697120428, -0.00627477839589119, -0.0746845081448555, -0.03110809437930584, 0.019362125545740128, 0.020182644948363304, 0.02707717940211296, 0.024950142949819565, -0.011856443248689175, -0.0339789092540741, 0.028386270627379417, 0.002093521412461996, -0.023916784673929214, -0.05003950744867325, -0.0013044639490544796, 0.01750210113823414, 0.010427296161651611, -0.010059069842100143, 0.025970863178372383, -0.03562787175178528, 0.01826835423707962, -0.04701164364814758, -0.0028767732437700033, 0.03498043492436409, -0.005940884351730347, 0.02765747718513012, -0.08320847153663635, 0.0707501545548439, 0.019774094223976135, 0.009661844000220299, -0.022622812539339066, -0.012212992645800114, -0.0006586937815882266, -0.005946884397417307, 0.07546266168355942, 0.007806627079844475, 0.00507328612729907, -0.004167730454355478, 0.029689442366361618, 0.034118980169296265, -0.028212398290634155, 0.02475622296333313, 0.003488971618935466, 0.000026517160222283565, -0.002957763383165002, -0.005321214906871319, 0.006009523756802082, 0.009508438408374786, 0.021216491237282753, 0.004184021148830652, -0.0020749326795339584, 0.027063945308327675, -0.028207696974277496, 0.02273702621459961, -0.008581481873989105, -0.00878917332738638, 0.029544178396463394, -0.033961519598960876, 0.002832763595506549, 0.04365762695670128, -0.012753640301525593, -0.06217579171061516, -0.008036461658775806, -0.029015887528657913, -0.03475073352456093, -0.0024160747416317463, 0.023407401517033577, -0.012391377240419388, -0.054291021078825, 0.051297627389431, 0.00936904177069664, 0.009520553052425385, 0.017555471509695053, 0.046264126896858215, 0.04346778243780136, 0.06279730051755905, -0.012391284108161926, 0.04214382544159889, -0.014039801433682442, -0.025900891050696373, 0.03267926722764969, 0.000651063397526741, 0.03455693647265434, -0.015717441216111183, 0.021049439907073975, 0.021417468786239624, -0.004947488661855459, 0.024240149185061455, 0.037881411612033844, 0.039118412882089615, -0.009422722272574902, -0.01623212918639183, 0.057838018983602524, 0.03001651167869568, 0.004471587482839823, 0.022393444553017616, -0.022565383464097977, 0.056278783828020096, -0.011028953827917576, -0.018298817798495293, -0.01788019947707653, -0.015408002771437168, -0.02033613808453083, 0.0250264722853899, -0.02771049737930298, 0.02817021682858467, 0.007339706644415855, 0.038099270313978195, 0.02849925495684147, -0.009933830238878727, -0.011326262727379799, -0.004737135488539934, -0.0067892782390117645, -0.021574784070253372, 0.0034642189275473356, -0.0053182365372776985, -0.02933780662715435, 0.01465535443276167, -0.026544485241174698, 0.029614893719553947, 0.031541064381599426, 0.019352424889802933, -0.019453855231404305, -0.011531294323503971, 0.01008362416177988, 0.0641186535358429, -0.07540960609912872, 0.023291856050491333, -0.0675162747502327, -0.011675496585667133, 0.004544084891676903, -0.036090075969696045 ]
<p>I am trying to use <code>randomForest</code> in R to find interaction terms to add to a model. My plan was to fit trees with <code>maxnodes=4</code> (two deep stubs), then compute how often <code>var A</code> is a child of <code>var B</code> and its improved accuracy to measure the importance of the <code>A*B</code> interaction. Essentially this is leveraging <code>randomForest</code> for the sampling.</p> <p>To make this work I also wanted <code>mtry=#</code> variables, so all variables would have a chance at being the child of the root variable.</p> <p>This strategy failed in my data because all trees after the first few were identical. I did decrease <code>cp</code>, but that did not help. I removed <code>mtry=#vars</code>, and still got all 95% of trees the same (the last 95%, the first few are different).</p> <p>When <code>maxnodes=32</code>, I got a good set of trees, but that's not what I needed for determining interactions. I need to do this because I can't deploy a <code>randomForest</code> in production.</p> <p>Any ideas why this wouldn't work? I am coding this myself now using <code>rpart</code> on 2 variable models iterating over the potential good pairs.</p>
36,265
[ -0.00876837782561779, 0.027597123757004738, -0.005540268961340189, 0.029842570424079895, 0.022516202181577682, -0.005376175511628389, 0.003258700715377927, -0.036988336592912674, 0.058233246207237244, -0.03526439890265465, 0.016955573111772537, 0.018121130764484406, 0.0539650097489357, 0.002688891254365444, 0.005018942523747683, 0.016451233997941017, 0.0036275472957640886, -0.001970647368580103, 0.009535767138004303, -0.0021742607932537794, -0.03572314232587814, 0.027637619525194168, 0.018611112609505653, -0.0117970434948802, -0.005446672905236483, 0.07682260125875473, 0.005181458313018084, -0.0435805544257164, -0.03982904553413391, 0.01577296480536461, -0.02789916843175888, -0.022299686446785927, -0.0002672424307093024, 0.03696195036172867, 0.044013116508722305, -0.007973702624440193, -0.032626744359731674, -0.02553282305598259, -0.006134238559752703, 0.017069607973098755, -0.02548675239086151, -0.0005918224342167377, -0.04636275768280029, 0.024673806503415108, -0.00069046625867486, -0.00016846874495968223, -0.03578471764922142, 0.015385297127068043, 0.09812603890895844, -0.020392797887325287, 0.04200129956007004, -0.007245727814733982, 0.03481798246502876, 0.03555407375097275, -0.05134051293134689, -0.03772981837391853, 0.045613985508680344, 0.08201630413532257, -0.003508170833811164, -0.014203377068042755, -0.043444421142339706, -0.022977981716394424, -0.007465031463652849, 0.025920730084180832, -0.06976329535245895, 0.013767522759735584, 0.015133331529796124, 0.014847244136035442, 0.04409201443195343, -0.009723628871142864, -0.0017669060034677386, -0.00011756277672247961, 0.022135121747851372, 0.05440524220466614, 0.012779400683939457, -0.011495940387248993, 0.03767378255724907, 0.007459643296897411, 0.03113633394241333, 0.03962721303105354, -0.04934793338179588, 0.026703760027885437, -0.008867401629686356, -0.013805104419589043, 0.04285610094666481, -0.020092057064175606, 0.045971084386110306, -0.02518649958074093, 0.003976684994995594, 0.03098314069211483, -0.0023908070288598537, 0.00008107276516966522, 0.08016717433929443, 0.016316091641783714, -0.05875145643949509, 0.04607190936803818, -0.022502224892377853, 0.0295186135917902, 0.00019499439804349095, 0.00826217234134674, -0.04223480448126793, -0.065050408244133, 0.006473085377365351, 0.05058840662240982, -0.03668764978647232, -0.005047901067882776, -0.051172561943531036, -0.023910345509648323, 0.006002785637974739, -0.018175743520259857, -0.021945923566818237, 0.003627064172178507, -0.020458435639739037, -0.02468723990023136, 0.026676632463932037, -0.052351225167512894, -0.012836264446377754, 0.010573424398899078, 0.09892518818378448, 0.032447606325149536, 0.05831614509224892, -0.03804292902350426, 0.04557764530181885, -0.03432243689894676, -0.03311016410589218, -0.030623575672507286, 0.019167335703969002, -0.0033425474539399147, -0.045043207705020905, 0.04264064133167267, 0.0231569092720747, -0.01475615706294775, 0.010906210169196129, -0.0014078270178288221, 0.01883978582918644, -0.01881604641675949, -0.09470784664154053, -0.062235277146101, 0.03342418745160103, -0.030004438012838364, 0.02386080101132393, -0.036189720034599304, -0.0044606029987335205, 0.02164352871477604, 0.06557126343250275, -0.01427987590432167, 0.02164214849472046, 0.010998583398759365, 0.018394526094198227, 0.041913025081157684, -0.022676078602671623, -0.022767575457692146, -0.030937684699892998, -0.004092555958777666, -0.037307728081941605, -0.056704480201005936, 0.026531236246228218, 0.03189994767308235, -0.052930962294340134, 0.02424958348274231, 0.018608255311846733, -0.015192699618637562, 0.0003818754048552364, 0.008104188367724419, 0.004778075497597456, -0.06958752870559692, 0.044278521090745926, -0.004090829752385616, 0.020170236006379128, 0.00025383534375578165, -0.01657281443476677, -0.009228629060089588, 0.028368690982460976, 0.037367407232522964, 0.015979481860995293, -0.00673023471608758, 0.014999615959823132, 0.002144903875887394, 0.022400205954909325, 0.004945256747305393, -0.030878674238920212, -0.036508698016405106, -0.07489209622144699, 0.003962385468184948, 0.029470331966876984, 0.015357512049376965, -0.024377254769206047, 0.002524383133277297, 0.03406783938407898, -0.045572638511657715, -0.0410955585539341, -0.06344441324472427, -0.0009264919790439308, -0.0008732991991564631, -0.03644426539540291, -0.010081537999212742, 0.02425508201122284, 0.029042067006230354, 0.010451721958816051, -0.0010788090294227004, -0.038349494338035583, -0.0011647121282294393, 0.05713769793510437, -0.0003738137020263821, -0.01439325325191021, 0.024349229410290718, 0.01736302673816681, -0.0148299066349864, 0.029403042048215866, -0.0360025130212307, -0.07193935662508011, 0.009197949431836605, -0.023377923294901848, -0.01636514440178871, -0.025184689089655876, -0.020409436896443367, 0.02352050319314003, 0.007227109745144844, 0.0015529596712440252, 0.016758613288402557, -0.03792440891265869, 0.04011833295226097, 0.08937575668096542, 0.057213567197322845, -0.005820221267640591, 0.013380322605371475, -0.011363563127815723, 0.01903626136481762, -0.03171289712190628, 0.022193243727087975, -0.05384634807705879, -0.04088739678263664, 0.04125358909368515, -0.00672408752143383, -0.03714021295309067, -0.01880834810435772, 0.06498977541923523, -0.007699145469814539, -0.008765940554440022, 0.039716240018606186, -0.006112522911280394, -0.00942174531519413, 0.04600469768047333, 0.01815837062895298, 0.05094986408948898, 0.015831319615244865, 0.033841557800769806, -0.002020407933741808, 0.02667233720421791, 0.015186059288680553, -0.003363202093169093, 0.010484753176569939, 0.009957578033208847, -0.0019239303655922413, -0.034487392753362656, -0.029009804129600525, 0.011889524757862091, -0.0065749394707381725, -0.0030996580608189106, 0.0560479611158371, 0.03124498389661312, -0.02924191951751709, 0.032550059258937836, -0.04219019040465355, 0.04684656113386154, -0.008386453613638878, -0.01483150664716959, -0.004694024100899696, 0.00851708184927702, -0.015133685432374477, 0.036735717207193375, -0.0037656326312571764, -0.019008882343769073, -0.036847811192274094, 0.028855321928858757, 0.029268406331539154, 0.0024665724486112595, 0.04254110902547836, -0.009952831082046032, 0.002407447202131152, 0.014708527363836765, -0.020763080567121506, 0.006487163249403238, -0.01232854276895523, -0.06375192850828171, -0.02232818305492401, -0.009236506186425686, -0.0274366345256567, -0.004539535380899906, -0.00009690924343885854, -0.049352407455444336, 0.019878271967172623, -0.0029805193189531565, -0.046898696571588516, 0.004405977204442024, 0.005514702759683132, 0.03829155117273331, -0.01233628299087286, -0.009099392220377922, -0.009037917479872704, 0.032259322702884674, -0.02813650108873844, 0.01285131648182869, -0.008905751630663872, 0.008034669794142246, -0.017342956736683846, -0.021122023463249207, 0.011158092878758907, 0.0261140875518322, 0.02131921797990799, 0.04637643322348595, -0.011133386753499508, -0.000985123566351831, -0.06589963287115097, -0.026056567206978798, 0.008221025578677654, 0.018903294578194618, 0.037081316113471985, 0.00039242435013875365, -0.006279631983488798, 0.06171301007270813, 0.02309703454375267, -0.020665189251303673, -0.030592499300837517, -0.013157542794942856, -0.03189091011881828, -0.015468507073819637, -0.005969590041786432, -0.0016074244631454349, 0.0102790966629982, 0.02737792581319809, 0.007446036674082279, 0.03885738551616669, 0.02186383679509163, -0.0065275211818516254, -0.009089840576052666, 0.023479890078306198, -0.01662393845617771, -0.023371975868940353, 0.050334203988313675, 0.0108433086425066, 0.008626699447631836, 0.0032250091899186373, -0.011683654971420765, -0.005988263059407473, 0.004615668673068285, -0.031458210200071335, -0.0010099895298480988, -0.021754292771220207, -0.006808961275964975, -0.0028830780647695065, 0.01542048342525959, -0.009057133458554745, -0.052575431764125824, -0.02873312495648861, -0.0010224954457953572, 0.08059459179639816, 0.005968817044049501, -0.025721637532114983, 0.05709519237279892, 0.01978413574397564, -0.007987214252352715, 0.012900855392217636, -0.01882043480873108, -0.0302890557795763, -0.009580807760357857, -0.015757860615849495, 0.012391959317028522, 0.03992192819714546, 0.03787432238459587, 0.019559495151042938, -0.0167696550488472, -0.05346094071865082, 0.000927443674299866, -0.029802966862916946, 0.031018072739243507, -0.108318991959095, 0.03617863357067108, -0.003300277516245842, 0.05328631028532982, -0.00856694858521223, -0.005327547434717417, 0.012056744657456875, -0.009288678877055645, -0.06136932224035263, 0.008310654200613499, 0.011039317585527897, -0.028894374147057533, 0.0036965308245271444, -0.024178558960556984, 0.0036690672859549522, 0.0086750453338027, 0.030225740745663643, 0.002538474276661873, -0.014734957367181778, 0.015383493155241013, -0.031469766050577164, -0.0052896225824952126, -0.019571010023355484, -0.0234473068267107, 0.00893621239811182, 0.029651446267962456, -0.009203880093991756, 0.027529845014214516, 0.04554370045661926, 0.0019239052198827267, -0.03176208585500717, -0.058280523866415024, -0.024430835619568825, 0.015475100837647915, 0.046714939177036285, 0.07619598507881165, -0.012665688060224056, -0.042040202766656876, -0.00469399057328701, 0.009669202379882336, 0.035068329423666, 0.04613613337278366, 0.019129261374473572, 0.016878804191946983, -0.04015642777085304, -0.02779265306890011, 0.028464525938034058, 0.031598035246133804, -0.022888168692588806, 0.018413381651043892, 0.05518331006169319, 0.043289151042699814, -0.04268629848957062, 0.009536364115774632, 0.0780976414680481, -0.0029897151980549097, -0.02452901192009449, -0.00033223460195586085, 0.010675129480659962, 0.0036896232049912214, -0.018494613468647003, 0.05808189883828163, 0.018249057233333588, -0.015545923262834549, -0.03155524656176567, 0.0261158999055624, -0.007123351562768221, -0.030209355056285858, 0.05021780729293823, -0.003840789897367358, 0.020979316905140877, -0.019486229866743088, -0.020585233345627785, -0.02199619449675083, 0.013703855685889721, -0.004128164146095514, 0.028696157038211823, -0.019793683663010597, -0.07647465914487839, 0.007128087803721428, 0.05025339499115944, 0.033661119639873505, -0.04318353161215782, -0.04356128349900246, -0.010071753524243832, -0.029923930764198303, 0.02098148502409458, -0.042460884898900986, 0.015816612169146538, -0.009091848507523537, 0.020549951121211052, -0.01787884160876274, -0.03164513781666756, -0.022945856675505638, 0.01002240739762783, -0.049545444548130035, 0.013489625416696072, -0.029712773859500885, -0.057356275618076324, -0.030442362651228905, 0.022801952436566353, 0.026943568140268326, 0.036223117262125015, -0.05360422655940056, -0.038998089730739594, -0.008685272186994553, -0.009170250035822392, 0.01176536176353693, -0.04244043678045273, 0.04395733028650284, -0.005784531589597464, -0.02178753726184368, 0.0532875619828701, -0.01698577217757702, -0.05635903775691986, 0.024735933169722557, 0.018909817561507225, 0.01564580202102661, -0.03222638741135597, 0.006892284378409386, 0.04301152005791664, 0.03634633868932724, -0.01614251919090748, 0.05304933339357376, 0.046581901609897614, -0.008412309922277927, 0.009906459599733353, -0.003430492477491498, 0.004989562090486288, -0.046735379844903946, -0.0005174049874767661, -0.027349263429641724, -0.030877774581313133, -0.024484749883413315, -0.01883649080991745, 0.007201947271823883, 0.032457537949085236, -0.08843651413917542, 0.017972981557250023, -0.020846394822001457, 0.03887565806508064, -0.011695223860442638, 0.0041238656267523766, 0.035614337772130966, 0.005232701543718576, -0.002461120253428817, -0.005872308276593685, 0.03996428847312927, -0.020356131717562675, -0.02998272329568863, 0.0024670041166245937, -0.009564175270497799, -0.0038592813070863485, -0.019670825451612473, -0.007888119667768478, 0.011370121501386166, 0.010407286696135998, 0.038356032222509384, 0.014762249775230885, 0.05228151008486748, -0.028263546526432037, -0.01841815374791622, -0.0204329714179039, 0.03435287997126579, -0.01676824316382408, 0.02168354205787182, -0.03130461275577545, 0.061057861894369125, -0.06706428527832031, 0.018976014107465744, -0.022858910262584686, -0.03875276446342468, -0.0012234102468937635, 0.019884349778294563, 0.037396013736724854, -0.04129539802670479, -0.016675768420100212, 0.011220693588256836, 0.01058940775692463, -0.02942487597465515, 0.06258171796798706, -0.0360877551138401, -0.010319679044187069, -0.020745595917105675, 0.017763514071702957, 0.0654524639248848, 0.022238682955503464, -0.010312923230230808, 0.04889099672436714, 0.002281687455251813, 0.002393213799223304, 0.02728184126317501, -0.027988813817501068, -0.04350762069225311, 0.006664539687335491, -0.010141666978597641, 0.03504632040858269, 0.05008239671587944, 0.027384504675865173, -0.0008099659462459385, -0.012873501516878605, -0.013721984811127186, 0.0190619844943285, -0.054918184876441956, -0.024678565561771393, 0.01565701887011528, 0.005052174441516399, -0.047393959015607834, 0.02578756771981716, -0.028453819453716278, 0.01685093715786934, 0.018717097118496895, -0.02958625927567482, -0.03179921954870224, 0.01694878190755844, 0.09149999916553497, -0.0024954956024885178, 0.022689437493681908, -0.0010868834797292948, -0.014734284020960331, 0.06379096955060959, -0.0010722451843321323, -0.0061265695840120316, 0.009881176985800266, 0.025724982842803, -0.029487691819667816, -0.01915549300611019, -0.022252215072512627, -0.015022216364741325, 0.046208519488573074, -0.05171181261539459, 0.0835544764995575, 0.045094627887010574, -0.05813973397016525, 0.0027583979535847902, -0.0073952628299593925, -0.011641932651400566, -0.005659370217472315, 0.023424187675118446, 0.050589755177497864, 0.011596499010920525, 0.00001919426904350985, 0.05987641587853432, 0.015839608386158943, 0.019724546000361443, 0.04050355404615402, -0.0002633083495311439, 0.02555147372186184, 0.027834126725792885, -0.04219033941626549, -0.019177818670868874, 0.031821414828300476, -0.06701582670211792, 0.015196508727967739, -0.02218877151608467, -0.02432560920715332, 0.07074693590402603, 0.0393882691860199, -0.020691419020295143, -0.0065088579431176186, -0.04234914854168892, -0.0421544574201107, -0.021041052415966988, 0.021491961553692818, -0.04570544511079788, 0.032370731234550476, 0.01807151921093464, 0.012341280467808247, -0.01716165617108345, 0.02607736550271511, -0.02871517650783062, -0.10380978882312775, -0.019481852650642395, -0.006695641670376062, -0.03144019842147827, 0.04167978838086128, 0.010311081074178219, -0.01533430628478527, 0.028078489005565643, -0.007607999257743359, -0.015354636125266552, 0.014234315603971481, 0.009310215711593628, -0.013265739195048809, 0.04974894970655441, 0.00699253287166357, 0.02001282386481762, -0.012785504572093487, -0.025890348479151726, 0.12839114665985107, 0.03996598720550537, 0.023745166137814522, -0.052611831575632095, 0.041598934680223465, 0.0031496405135840178, -0.005351112689822912, -0.0412873849272728, -0.016414398327469826, 0.00962107628583908, -0.028966868296265602, 0.03626319020986557, 0.008371771313250065, 0.027373716235160828, -0.026229629293084145, 0.030461963266134262, -0.03328485041856766, -0.05068213865160942, 0.0003347244346514344, 0.023030828684568405, 0.0065297516994178295, -0.03403935953974724, -0.04105646535754204, -0.015055370517075062, 0.008287545293569565, 0.009819760918617249, -0.007353643886744976, -0.0017498061060905457, -0.003200978972017765, -0.0014944187132641673, 0.016587164252996445, 0.03532799333333969, 0.014276623725891113, 0.024431966245174408, 0.03158963844180107, -0.006198802497237921, 0.03948918357491493, -0.014331831596791744, 0.005170744378119707, 0.01677965372800827, -0.019288694486021996, -0.012171300128102303, 0.006465478800237179, 0.061505258083343506, -0.05151992663741112, -0.0508667454123497, -0.01795903593301773, 0.03202525153756142, 0.015126079320907593, -0.041968196630477905, -0.02066667191684246, -0.012813554145395756, 0.01022362057119608, -0.01637130044400692, -0.019290797412395477, 0.011561968363821507, 0.06362997740507126, -0.04254893958568573, -0.012285563163459301, 0.015845973044633865, 0.015834230929613113, -0.012189359404146671, 0.030506107956171036, 0.017981283366680145, -0.006178034469485283, -0.0012360699474811554, -0.07986153662204742, 0.05133344978094101, -0.014793561771512032, -0.0056999423541128635, -0.0025499227922409773, -0.02400616556406021, -0.017880896106362343, 0.019244972616434097, 0.005860501434653997, 0.0314565971493721, 0.058798640966415405, -0.03462456911802292, 0.0040283179841935635, -0.02400320954620838, -0.006558339577168226, 0.007276366930454969, -0.042468078434467316, -0.020486483350396156, -0.08029668033123016, 0.02038062922656536, 0.012797359377145767, 0.02297932654619217, 0.03421062231063843, 0.015278100967407227, -0.031370118260383606, 0.07263250648975372, 0.0163878146559, -0.05345381796360016, -0.035299163311719894, 0.0043499888852238655, -0.023624951019883156, -0.04133706912398338, 0.03370188549160957, 0.03397395834326744, 0.015525826252996922, 0.0006722885882481933, -0.011953131295740604, 0.01678338646888733, -0.016474958509206772, 0.023034371435642242, 0.024273479357361794, -0.044229816645383835, -0.006341623142361641, 0.007299874909222126, -0.014793905429542065, -0.03710970655083656, 0.0012808041647076607, -0.013185450807213783, -0.025937380269169807, 0.028571635484695435, -0.008166712708771229, -0.07580594718456268, -0.02450135163962841, -0.04438832402229309, 0.03711753711104393, -0.009846864268183708, -0.026675771921873093, -0.030544575303792953, -0.04513105750083923, 0.01726013794541359, -0.042354028671979904, -0.01399038266390562, 0.008443168364465237, -0.010309259407222271, -0.01629357784986496, 0.03105805814266205, 0.01662871427834034, 0.012460214085876942, -0.007796347141265869, -0.016782963648438454, 0.02033214457333088, 0.04549424350261688, -0.006969883572310209, -0.0208816509693861, 0.048884447664022446, -0.057043492794036865, -0.020160146057605743, 0.007478038314729929, 0.0050910646095871925, 0.04721754416823387, 0.007301720790565014, -0.008719420991837978, -0.02879246138036251, 0.045468639582395554, -0.00827050767838955, -0.004173642955720425, 0.02307943068444729, 0.027724694460630417, 0.01377350278198719, -0.028940819203853607, -0.0038918335922062397, 0.006944986991584301, -0.0173100046813488, 0.007121626753360033, 0.039787907153367996, 0.03738892450928688, -0.0315946489572525, 0.01737877167761326, -0.0011849667644128203, 0.021029485389590263, -0.013344510458409786, -0.01266978308558464, 0.03452354669570923, 0.048988837748765945, -0.01773451827466488, 0.02571147307753563, -0.0018393187783658504, 0.011504330672323704, -0.07617291808128357, -0.029565276578068733, -0.01875157468020916, 0.0021228885743767023, 0.018328608945012093, -0.0214823167771101, -0.002692256588488817, 0.011370866559445858, -0.05270852521061897, 0.03139329329133034, -0.010924095287919044, 0.03422057256102562, -0.06342069059610367, 0.009761055931448936, -0.06623570621013641, -0.016467910259962082, 0.018095145002007484, 0.05091158300638199, 0.031673580408096313, 0.016375545412302017, 0.023963816463947296, -0.03478303179144859, -0.02684674598276615, 0.0034196556080132723, -0.00417906092479825, -0.04171792417764664, -0.00023454197798855603, -0.025015324354171753, -0.022126957774162292, 0.007800865452736616, -0.038849424570798874, 0.006700835190713406, 0.025523275136947632, 0.029007816687226295, 0.04372701793909073, 0.08518405258655548, 0.05764729529619217, -0.018970172852277756, 0.01577545329928398, -0.02308749593794346, 0.00290566380135715, 0.01263331063091755, -0.017719462513923645, 0.02869412675499916, 0.032981134951114655, 0.008653842844069004, -0.006920615676790476, 0.016363797709345818, -0.031657874584198, -0.02226535975933075, -0.023749694228172302, -0.015183640643954277, 0.021401524543762207, -0.005785773973912001, -0.03626727685332298, -0.047696445137262344, 0.024526309221982956, 0.07024459540843964, 0.022103523835539818, 0.02735719084739685, 0.015145950019359589, -0.04113422706723213, 0.00029189715860411525, 0.0015896958066150546, 0.035059887915849686, -0.03169550001621246, -0.021321268752217293, -0.014277774840593338, 0.008617226034402847, -0.0027946443296968937, -0.008070704527199268, 0.009865887463092804, -0.01183315645903349, 0.0429006963968277, -0.055021021515131, -0.0039642066694796085, 0.038744233548641205, -0.010634241625666618, 0.06916151195764542, -0.06339643150568008, 0.08132240921258926, 0.03561652451753616, 0.0035234601236879826, -0.06416875123977661, 0.004596252925693989, -0.0263878982514143, 0.00637686625123024, 0.03443486616015434, -0.02302817814052105, 0.009911800734698772, 0.004173590335994959, 0.07299641519784927, 0.03357354551553726, -0.02730853483080864, 0.049873221665620804, -0.010391470044851303, 0.007312119007110596, 0.00569796422496438, -0.03725915402173996, 0.04652976617217064, -0.008121524006128311, -0.01237174216657877, -0.041549019515514374, 0.009187661111354828, 0.010675585828721523, -0.022886307910084724, 0.04838181287050247, -0.020280394703149796, -0.0010749665088951588, 0.022455716505646706, 0.021450603380799294, 0.0007744285394437611, 0.04345659911632538, 0.011843389831483364, -0.010572420433163643, 0.04115426167845726, -0.021586723625659943, -0.03521136939525604, 0.0026277436409145594, 0.015336884185671806, -0.00821772776544094, -0.04005412757396698, 0.00517730787396431, 0.04011968523263931, -0.043542440980672836, -0.021341810002923012, 0.07032175362110138, -0.007295527495443821, 0.08042963594198227, 0.02553216926753521, 0.023813001811504364, -0.006259990390390158, -0.019164856523275375, -0.0005949925980530679, 0.006414620205760002, 0.006628639996051788, -0.040598995983600616, -0.016568727791309357, 0.022930188104510307, -0.028400618582963943, 0.020095232874155045, -0.02576514333486557, 0.026515191420912743, 0.01315334066748619, -0.041643328964710236, 0.02029058337211609, -0.02934568002820015, 0.023378878831863403, 0.011310858651995659, -0.018184930086135864, 0.04875914379954338, -0.04175300523638725, 0.00482232915237546, -0.026749370619654655, 0.008643009699881077, 0.0003856400726363063, 0.026536986231803894, -0.01318987738341093, 0.00322959222830832, 0.011407876387238503, 0.023037200793623924, 0.02020958811044693, -0.014817954041063786, 0.024888034909963608, -0.02429584041237831, 0.03271002694964409, -0.026982158422470093, 0.003223377512767911, -0.0239252932369709, 0.017140677198767662, -0.02130924165248871, -0.04685971513390541, 0.04032323509454727, 0.04082895815372467, 0.03318578749895096, -0.029589783400297165, -0.006110204849392176, 0.015869854018092155, 0.02292102389037609, -0.037762027233839035, -0.007119994144886732, -0.025426197797060013, -0.014013941399753094, 0.0003305522259324789, 0.011693536303937435 ]
<p>I have a general question about interpreting interaction effects in a non-linear model. I understand the reasons Ai and Norton (2004) suggest using the stata inteff command to help interpret interaction effects in a non-linear model.</p> <p><a href="http://www.unc.edu/~enorton/NortonWangAi.pdf" rel="nofollow">http://www.unc.edu/~enorton/NortonWangAi.pdf</a></p> <p>However, Buis (2010) seems to suggest that interpreting a logit model through odds ratios overcomes the problem in a much simpler way. </p> <p><a href="http://www.stata-journal.com/sjpdf.html?articlenum=st0194" rel="nofollow">http://www.stata-journal.com/sjpdf.html?articlenum=st0194</a></p> <p>It is not clear to me how Buis's suggestion helps with the issues of Ai and Norton (2004) namely that the sign and significance of interaction effects in non-linear models vary across observations. Any help in understanding this would be much appreciated?</p>
73,782
[ -0.028031598776578903, -0.01201150007545948, -0.00040547357639297843, 0.021747257560491562, 0.06374704837799072, 0.04149729758501053, 0.007844059728085995, -0.0005486618028953671, 0.0436885729432106, -0.01308892946690321, 0.01545082125812769, 0.004048576578497887, 0.05400370806455612, 0.0216918233782053, 0.02403712272644043, 0.006867786403745413, -0.008896593004465103, 0.04257737472653389, 0.015086322091519833, 0.00006188180122990161, -0.007661815732717514, 0.012166962958872318, -0.010694600641727448, -0.005951142869889736, -0.033069271594285965, 0.06243227422237396, 0.017504733055830002, -0.01370885781943798, 0.01794513501226902, 0.048461057245731354, -0.0018552426481619477, -0.00718848779797554, -0.0004616724618244916, 0.018466860055923462, -0.0026997842360287905, 0.014116458594799042, -0.000489400583319366, -0.02410423755645752, 0.007535207085311413, 0.03776942193508148, -0.019595911726355553, 0.0025256797671318054, 0.015892760828137398, 0.024328364059329033, -0.05552516505122185, 0.015160822309553623, -0.019232677295804024, -0.017019979655742645, 0.035707056522369385, -0.041405729949474335, 0.040338676422834396, -0.028398551046848297, 0.031114226207137108, 0.015735533088445663, -0.03653208911418915, -0.002470974577590823, 0.02906760759651661, 0.06599442660808563, -0.004700441379100084, -0.03894325718283653, -0.01810428686439991, -0.025745917111635208, -0.02546021156013012, -0.043905336409807205, -0.01995110884308815, 0.027046969160437584, -0.02532467432320118, -0.016080843284726143, 0.06622450798749924, -0.02435261383652687, 0.015762168914079666, 0.014881419017910957, 0.041515275835990906, -0.002832554979249835, -0.014049150981009007, -0.021901598200201988, 0.03442101925611496, -0.013568452559411526, 0.022463159635663033, 0.04392063617706299, -0.0332317128777504, 0.006845972500741482, 0.03087075799703598, 0.03589895740151405, 0.032261934131383896, -0.026608772575855255, 0.03716422989964485, -0.038544513285160065, 0.05930163338780403, 0.022710829973220825, -0.04577803984284401, -0.013348623178899288, 0.016141271218657494, -0.0042369975708425045, -0.04552589729428291, 0.017781950533390045, -0.015684230253100395, 0.04486674815416336, 0.02692587673664093, 0.006650503259152174, -0.02419179119169712, -0.03574250638484955, 0.004268532618880272, 0.03855444863438606, 0.008197693154215813, -0.036433570086956024, -0.04806031659245491, 0.03285001963376999, 0.0027615986764431, -0.05555400252342224, -0.017346903681755066, 0.005419241730123758, -0.007712963968515396, 0.000752007239498198, 0.007150003220885992, -0.02763202413916588, -0.01720782183110714, -0.003758444217965007, 0.08757296204566956, 0.046253181993961334, 0.03506701812148094, -0.05026205629110336, 0.032235823571681976, 0.017566172406077385, -0.00423859478905797, 0.02104080282151699, 0.01239993516355753, -0.01861049421131611, -0.03546823188662529, 0.05169416218996048, -0.0029432345181703568, -0.024808144196867943, 0.015063729137182236, 0.02840072102844715, 0.016654489561915398, -0.010101433843374252, -0.05714643374085426, -0.06737364083528519, 0.046242158859968185, -0.0010599222732707858, -0.00241445517167449, -0.08563003689050674, -0.011950149200856686, 0.041967444121837616, 0.09421344101428986, 0.0008799090865068138, 0.020892510190606117, 0.030650561675429344, 0.0322866253554821, 0.05667337402701378, -0.026597166433930397, -0.01134166494011879, -0.024321215227246284, -0.02319071628153324, 0.01691393181681633, -0.11012730747461319, 0.03949786722660065, 0.028095990419387817, -0.0021752931643277407, 0.0014797633048146963, 0.07298792898654938, 0.039049796760082245, -0.03192136064171791, -0.009215259924530983, -0.01460263878107071, -0.023526834324002266, 0.058727335184812546, -0.02804705873131752, 0.015500358305871487, 0.055048711597919464, -0.00677708862349391, 0.028909599408507347, 0.011899405159056187, 0.07542494684457779, 0.052077390253543854, -0.012903280556201935, 0.010539665818214417, -0.05524371564388275, -0.030420977622270584, 0.0047008078545331955, -0.03465699777007103, -0.036141812801361084, -0.03455077484250069, -0.008391592651605606, 0.03258210048079491, 0.05093301832675934, -0.015062367543578148, -0.023413298651576042, 0.04552504047751427, -0.04938225448131561, -0.06482343375682831, -0.10060890763998032, 0.00013099804345984012, -0.01133566815406084, -0.02318330854177475, 0.05151989310979843, -0.007454198785126209, 0.05408860370516777, 0.005920630879700184, 0.010507266968488693, 0.007831031456589699, -0.02696327120065689, 0.039850763976573944, -0.06780336052179337, 0.015836982056498528, 0.012219912372529507, 0.059593554586172104, -0.020609065890312195, 0.045958612114191055, -0.0744524672627449, -0.04263262078166008, 0.053549569100141525, -0.03112786076962948, 0.007170330733060837, 0.007132621947675943, -0.0007997213979251683, -0.0021237104665488005, -0.007340782787650824, -0.03288025036454201, 0.015574016608297825, -0.07213788479566574, 0.055599670857191086, 0.05871708691120148, -0.028671754524111748, -0.005357616115361452, 0.04839327186346054, 0.04046832397580147, 0.02535429410636425, -0.03983047604560852, 0.00017989467596635222, -0.05982111021876335, -0.013854690827429295, 0.008432644419372082, 0.021869346499443054, -0.0015864374581724405, 0.043814729899168015, 0.04672471806406975, 0.005787532310932875, -0.016175484284758568, 0.04794352129101753, -0.0012836153618991375, -0.017595909535884857, 0.005150399636477232, 0.01213674433529377, -0.00472764577716589, 0.025591740384697914, 0.01507012639194727, -0.010907599702477455, 0.04179245978593826, -0.010116113349795341, -0.02797575853765011, 0.04956868290901184, 0.006436688359826803, 0.026067262515425682, -0.032328929752111435, 0.009741547517478466, 0.06880118697881699, -0.021065915003418922, 0.010518087074160576, 0.034731458872556686, 0.009425206109881401, 0.002383553422987461, 0.05978933349251747, -0.00910024531185627, 0.009716575033962727, 0.0029353953432291746, -0.038961198180913925, 0.016378158703446388, -0.010755347087979317, -0.056283243000507355, 0.02215513214468956, -0.0023820619098842144, 0.016500001773238182, -0.011083513498306274, -0.01758379116654396, -0.005701317451894283, 0.005428776610642672, 0.010509345680475235, -0.03197918459773064, -0.01845303364098072, -0.0008928179158829153, -0.036210257560014725, -0.0008609314681962132, -0.011662422679364681, -0.036749448627233505, -0.01926567032933235, -0.001416295999661088, 0.0019184204284101725, 0.023034291341900826, -0.009223506785929203, -0.0040985774248838425, 0.012486119754612446, -0.028669016435742378, -0.03804884850978851, -0.03656613454222679, -0.017823420464992523, -0.007169086951762438, -0.00129505165386945, -0.03047499991953373, 0.047624289989471436, 0.025922518223524094, -0.028390472754836082, 0.0199531689286232, -0.033462200313806534, -0.04667161405086517, -0.02065371349453926, 0.022508656606078148, 0.023486893624067307, -0.028467226773500443, 0.013812033459544182, 0.010219824500381947, -0.022729434072971344, -0.030834248289465904, -0.08503343909978867, -0.0658627301454544, -0.011153013445436954, 0.03240542486310005, 0.005197269842028618, -0.024725766852498055, -0.058106422424316406, 0.04079514369368553, -0.003808202687650919, -0.007113060913980007, -0.04201449081301689, -0.010285831987857819, -0.009971162304282188, 0.0028054616414010525, 0.024846062064170837, 0.039898257702589035, 0.020032605156302452, 0.040341757237911224, -0.018112866207957268, 0.06401327252388, 0.030144214630126953, 0.01468433067202568, -0.0020502819679677486, -0.00067277648486197, 0.0040600597858428955, -0.014002438634634018, 0.03211458772420883, 0.03762885555624962, -0.00017081815167330205, 0.00968359038233757, -0.013299736194312572, 0.015758704394102097, -0.009286697953939438, -0.042002204805612564, 0.04302476719021797, -0.005718521308153868, 0.002302891109138727, -0.04858602210879326, 0.017720840871334076, 0.02334166318178177, -0.010099230334162712, 0.0077714137732982635, -0.0188345555216074, 0.055704277008771896, -0.035256557166576385, 0.02244284376502037, 0.018309731036424637, 0.03987245634198189, 0.012504084035754204, -0.016080036759376526, -0.008739158511161804, -0.008755773305892944, -0.006081299390643835, 0.010503844358026981, 0.015175278298556805, 0.02569054625928402, 0.05177019536495209, -0.020456701517105103, -0.031573858112096786, -0.034441012889146805, 0.014164578169584274, -0.04595625773072243, -0.015412744134664536, -0.020956747233867645, 0.04189761355519295, 0.026930619031190872, 0.004749673418700695, -0.005084359552711248, -0.02718299999833107, 0.011428354308009148, -0.0014845447149127722, -0.07717873156070709, 0.02593487873673439, 0.005018658470362425, -0.014334834180772305, -0.010179605334997177, -0.02641383931040764, 0.006928172428160906, -0.039567731320858, -0.03082830272614956, -0.016450483351945877, 0.03033372201025486, -0.026803558692336082, -0.01136783231049776, -0.028722627088427544, -0.05203636363148689, -0.017901809886097908, -0.010418862104415894, -0.014074776321649551, -0.032637521624565125, -0.018739793449640274, 0.04436187818646431, -0.02487163618206978, -0.05352555587887764, -0.010589021258056164, -0.00031246463186107576, 0.029463116079568863, 0.023389291018247604, 0.011844441294670105, -0.0017538220854476094, -0.0375334769487381, 0.02551237680017948, 0.016000207513570786, 0.038918107748031616, 0.04113750532269478, 0.008599129505455494, -0.006278023589402437, 0.005684319417923689, -0.016209719702601433, -0.01635248214006424, 0.02790355682373047, 0.007015107665210962, 0.009063593111932278, 0.05766816437244415, 0.055932894349098206, -0.03686000406742096, 0.03663403168320656, 0.04529682546854019, 0.04163292422890663, 0.0004881075001321733, -0.04908772557973862, -0.03494853153824806, 0.0032193537335842848, 0.0013129595899954438, 0.023103881627321243, 0.006534702144563198, 0.007417422719299793, -0.0016713811783120036, 0.06900729238986969, -0.01367647759616375, -0.02498631924390793, -0.008367137052118778, 0.0022533731535077095, 0.05126936733722687, 0.02248040959239006, -0.05059328302741051, 0.011411734856665134, 0.04289489611983299, 0.05478686839342117, 0.036673590540885925, 0.013426775112748146, -0.08735716342926025, -0.016403432935476303, 0.03549937903881073, 0.004597625695168972, -0.06327943503856659, -0.031114017590880394, 0.005983591079711914, -0.023880554363131523, 0.01354022417217493, -0.039007265120744705, 0.013316442258656025, -0.005947889760136604, 0.02187643013894558, -0.02424597553908825, -0.06232738122344017, -0.04218289628624916, -0.0017607209738343954, 0.027140788733959198, 0.015580592676997185, -0.0015310879098251462, 0.001609284314326942, -0.013319414108991623, -0.006517595145851374, 0.0009906393242999911, 0.039495326578617096, -0.02628542110323906, -0.009005592204630375, 0.028907410800457, 0.029820270836353302, -0.03925298899412155, -0.07153388857841492, 0.05645853281021118, -0.011728730984032154, 0.010184623301029205, 0.044688232243061066, -0.0016668237512931228, -0.00930601917207241, -0.041489481925964355, 0.03895032778382301, 0.0011252565309405327, -0.013551034964621067, -0.02842981368303299, 0.03370329365134239, -0.01026887446641922, 0.005251580849289894, 0.06758763641119003, 0.021628698334097862, -0.029951170086860657, -0.008455054834485054, -0.03900834172964096, 0.026361914351582527, -0.0064435177482664585, -0.018876060843467712, -0.030322901904582977, 0.015469282865524292, 0.0015824076253920794, 0.03973902389407158, 0.014785006642341614, 0.04629431292414665, -0.0015803915448486805, -0.0331566296517849, 0.00029904552502557635, -0.008603334426879883, -0.013450129888951778, -0.004240165464580059, -0.020009325817227364, 0.01623351313173771, 0.014087568037211895, -0.013570928946137428, 0.04296021908521652, -0.008313319645822048, -0.020284684374928474, 0.03552469611167908, -0.023135537281632423, -0.001156267011538148, -0.00589826749637723, -0.04808656871318817, -0.005752720404416323, -0.03212817758321762, 0.02232728898525238, -0.023742692545056343, -0.02628514915704727, -0.02831546775996685, -0.01141024474054575, -0.012541988864541054, 0.01219420786947012, -0.010029079392552376, 0.03470977023243904, -0.011458616703748703, 0.04158862680196762, 0.01636137068271637, -0.03758782148361206, -0.05559170991182327, -0.0754704549908638, 0.01100008375942707, -0.018904276192188263, -0.02056899294257164, -0.02373431622982025, -0.01654823310673237, -0.02122526802122593, -0.035318028181791306, 0.005130566190928221, 0.0770123302936554, -0.04361483082175255, -0.004612952936440706, 0.016985846683382988, 0.025330157950520515, 0.05237479507923126, -0.0036418233066797256, -0.033562492579221725, 0.018738755956292152, -0.021492697298526764, 0.0313311405479908, -0.019295454025268555, 0.026792526245117188, -0.0172349214553833, -0.02540249191224575, -0.016182607039809227, 0.002130852546542883, 0.041639428585767746, 0.013675329275429249, -0.03868740797042847, 0.012165011838078499, -0.014042750000953674, 0.023350993171334267, 0.01015397533774376, -0.0034989959094673395, 0.005537652876228094, 0.0109384935349226, -0.02089953050017357, 0.003979493398219347, 0.021132061257958412, 0.010482002049684525, 0.06409942358732224, -0.024127013981342316, -0.007440296933054924, 0.014181270264089108, 0.04641402140259743, 0.007728658150881529, 0.030596639961004257, -0.02468162588775158, -0.02392124943435192, 0.07421551644802094, 0.003299079369753599, 0.0027733738534152508, 0.01353646069765091, 0.006556925363838673, -0.033842604607343674, -0.026116834953427315, -0.04332348704338074, 0.04834134504199028, 0.05509510263800621, -0.026986515149474144, 0.016139661893248558, 0.04970395565032959, 0.014510978944599628, 0.02869763784110546, -0.02934696525335312, 0.048556484282016754, -0.00971341785043478, 0.008831098675727844, 0.05085315182805061, -0.023091351613402367, -0.014952033758163452, 0.06786157190799713, 0.029935508966445923, 0.014985756017267704, 0.022006629034876823, 0.03330798074603081, 0.015198186971247196, 0.006208751350641251, -0.018716970458626747, -0.06051097437739372, 0.042691025882959366, -0.0341530442237854, 0.020118555054068565, -0.011203019879758358, -0.03341611847281456, 0.0668412297964096, 0.011573748663067818, 0.026983555406332016, -0.07379366457462311, -0.0255099106580019, -0.02388821914792061, -0.028757480904459953, 0.002476812805980444, -0.016835682094097137, 0.06280168145895004, 0.0027658026665449142, 0.03224557265639305, -0.012774452567100525, -0.017391979694366455, -0.02404838241636753, -0.09268894046545029, 0.006455166265368462, -0.02213069051504135, 0.005297913681715727, -0.012028482742607594, -0.02751661278307438, -0.025094008073210716, 0.0390225350856781, -0.03582726791501045, -0.036224719136953354, 0.024858508259058, -0.006845079828053713, -0.01920352689921856, 0.08819255232810974, -0.008150113746523857, 0.026829129084944725, -0.0016018112655729055, -0.006779724266380072, 0.13451844453811646, 0.07187434285879135, 0.01993345469236374, -0.07621444016695023, 0.03878764063119888, 0.03420070558786392, 0.0221864040941, -0.018482383340597153, -0.025336163118481636, 0.018003525212407112, -0.054911185055971146, 0.04431850463151932, 0.0759667456150055, 0.03141004592180252, -0.011483145877718925, 0.05276394635438919, -0.036102764308452606, -0.013360703364014626, 0.04448235034942627, -0.007781708147376776, 0.004323921632021666, -0.046728286892175674, -0.02611800655722618, -0.007313214708119631, -0.010160289704799652, -0.01305539533495903, 0.006256224121898413, -0.014548112638294697, -0.004013051278889179, 0.020233266055583954, -0.01728600449860096, 0.016916785389184952, 0.026401054114103317, 0.008646381087601185, 0.003509895410388708, -0.016430208459496498, 0.016698528081178665, -0.02689017914235592, 0.015652909874916077, 0.009285559877753258, -0.032847676426172256, 0.007722892798483372, 0.002205202355980873, 0.014884348958730698, -0.03302227705717087, -0.019164670258760452, -0.03412776440382004, 0.038493312895298004, -0.021863281726837158, 0.010314476676285267, -0.03488236665725708, 0.00241079437546432, -0.020212456583976746, -0.023722652345895767, -0.031140794977545738, 0.03629399463534355, 0.03301708400249481, -0.02420678548514843, -0.03769036382436752, -0.034826308488845825, -0.009269041940569878, -0.022165503352880478, 0.044369351118803024, 0.026273127645254135, -0.051121581345796585, -0.007093226071447134, -0.022627444937825203, 0.038159918040037155, 0.003605268197134137, -0.0014453037874773145, 0.008231576532125473, 0.01367999892681837, -0.014403006061911583, -0.01351124607026577, -0.006063018459826708, 0.016745075583457947, 0.04772476479411125, -0.0037380459252744913, -0.01495285239070654, -0.015861080959439278, -0.05064352974295616, 0.018657376989722252, -0.027419287711381912, -0.0018574376590549946, -0.0580611489713192, 0.03191651031374931, 0.0511401928961277, 0.024950100108981133, -0.019211649894714355, 0.03302482143044472, -0.03802328184247017, 0.019493792206048965, -0.010582110844552517, -0.05658944323658943, -0.02395554818212986, 0.018082741647958755, -0.0013469080440700054, -0.041841015219688416, -0.021878719329833984, 0.024790918454527855, 0.026678908616304398, 0.016166532412171364, -0.0031768307089805603, 0.04514608904719353, 0.0030209433753043413, 0.012879318557679653, 0.030848683789372444, -0.03871992602944374, -0.013923032209277153, 0.048334646970033646, 0.016754547134041786, 0.012574929744005203, -0.020463833585381508, -0.007015860639512539, -0.05549347400665283, 0.017579812556505203, -0.042453888803720474, -0.04245411232113838, -0.00403484795242548, -0.011849991045892239, 0.03211437910795212, -0.014466507360339165, -0.046384360641241074, -0.06175146996974945, -0.024201707914471626, 0.02294539101421833, -0.018922248855233192, 0.0031199860386550426, 0.003566096303984523, -0.013142800889909267, 0.0010215203510597348, 0.029099613428115845, 0.011034348979592323, -0.015493066981434822, -0.023875834420323372, 0.0016232396010309458, -0.002241457812488079, 0.035015445202589035, -0.05177393928170204, -0.04043596237897873, 0.05436747148633003, -0.023566819727420807, -0.031258005648851395, 0.0030303271487355232, -0.0011996743269264698, 0.009929483756422997, 0.012507036328315735, 0.0236053429543972, -0.009369445033371449, 0.041389431804418564, -0.03997272625565529, 0.027018683031201363, -0.028766224160790443, -0.018596235662698746, 0.006888798903673887, -0.047384291887283325, -0.03725143522024155, 0.05505131185054779, -0.03925547003746033, 0.03158528357744217, 0.07056688517332077, -0.013378306291997433, 0.013679486699402332, 0.021332362666726112, -0.004395350813865662, 0.032272934913635254, -0.0018995438003912568, -0.01471930555999279, 0.033243514597415924, 0.03954781964421272, -0.02389831840991974, 0.02972518466413021, -0.0031930988188833, 0.02374187856912613, -0.057532839477062225, -0.019332949072122574, -0.011577215977013111, 0.024656441062688828, 0.038896821439266205, -0.0431133396923542, 0.0072305696085095406, -0.022471001371741295, -0.02917250245809555, -0.01867176964879036, 0.00019179776427336037, -0.009635845199227333, -0.03822430595755577, -0.003616280620917678, -0.009960992261767387, 0.031424980610609055, 0.042065538465976715, -0.01886131428182125, 0.009112912230193615, 0.022461313754320145, -0.007686615455895662, 0.00585684971883893, -0.002652860479429364, -0.001923218253068626, 0.01712546870112419, -0.047158949077129364, 0.040547143667936325, -0.02790563739836216, -0.03017571195960045, 0.06489675492048264, -0.0032555917277932167, 0.026566186919808388, 0.0189619492739439, -0.0005103474832139909, 0.012978359125554562, 0.04162667691707611, 0.002858476247638464, -0.009347859770059586, -0.009001524187624454, 0.0004912489675916731, 0.025306453928351402, 0.03724318742752075, 0.002028180519118905, -0.018025053665041924, 0.020184369757771492, -0.0012238705530762672, -0.026471257209777832, 0.014646578580141068, -0.018786296248435974, -0.013183859176933765, -0.022927844896912575, -0.0296900924295187, 0.015849990770220757, -0.008421044796705246, 0.034172963351011276, -0.020870503038167953, -0.013079996220767498, 0.051031120121479034, 0.0495777502655983, -0.043529510498046875, 0.0167241133749485, -0.000584073131904006, -0.02502346970140934, 0.004006706643849611, 0.010770728811621666, 0.03162436932325363, -0.06371026486158371, 0.031018633395433426, -0.009761211462318897, -0.003163192654028535, -0.04989118501543999, 0.03565844148397446, -0.04729704186320305, 0.033167582005262375, -0.0394640676677227, 0.02201460674405098, 0.006243573501706123, -0.05499085783958435, 0.04699643328785896, -0.08032933622598648, 0.0756586343050003, 0.01671714335680008, -0.029079752042889595, -0.038640156388282776, -0.019070761278271675, -0.05292493477463722, -0.011736863292753696, 0.04606247693300247, 0.000502679671626538, -0.021463241428136826, 0.02374582551419735, 0.03717292845249176, 0.015519832260906696, 0.012633899226784706, 0.028119120746850967, -0.02463061548769474, -0.017178907990455627, -0.0005035937647335231, -0.003887414000928402, -0.013205407187342644, 0.033472299575805664, 0.013137412257492542, -0.045465148985385895, 0.0067006004974246025, 0.004365977365523577, -0.004844984970986843, 0.0074996137991547585, 0.02240692637860775, -0.007534009404480457, 0.00630890903994441, 0.0024660304188728333, 0.03558703511953354, 0.04273822158575058, 0.01978040114045143, -0.054856203496456146, 0.027655841782689095, 0.0012523988261818886, -0.013243480585515499, -0.017875634133815765, -0.0221150703728199, -0.011848358437418938, -0.023771019652485847, 0.04220157489180565, 0.014000766910612583, -0.011993630789220333, -0.016514375805854797, 0.007437339052557945, 0.029529301449656487, 0.03144017234444618, 0.013815607875585556, 0.031074732542037964, -0.002200361108407378, 0.016529768705368042, -0.008633112534880638, 0.001974426442757249, 0.04881526157259941, 0.013811534270644188, -0.03746818006038666, 0.038353707641363144, 0.002517495770007372, 0.048270825296640396, -0.049447380006313324, 0.04322528466582298, -0.0076261404901742935, -0.026411687955260277, 0.0008679597522132099, -0.02117188833653927, 0.03343426063656807, 0.05715853348374367, 0.0022324714809656143, 0.05667417496442795, -0.030738968402147293, 0.03796035423874855, 0.0070728762075304985, 0.008781933225691319, -0.02412450686097145, -0.018534470349550247, 0.03434883803129196, 0.012559376657009125, 0.0007459489279426634, -0.0075601921416819096, 0.014016295783221722, -0.044266119599342346, 0.03205856680870056, -0.03410852327942848, -0.017295146360993385, 0.021978167816996574, -0.024931257590651512, -0.04048360139131546, -0.05209796130657196, -0.014986208640038967, -0.017241019755601883, 0.043118201196193695, 0.0260512363165617, 0.014174776151776314, -0.03901631385087967, -0.03906885161995888, 0.017129987478256226, 0.04645594581961632, -0.04706477001309395, -0.005408305209130049, -0.025446817278862, -0.016898954287171364, 0.02846689149737358, -0.0279384758323431 ]
<p>This is bordering on a philosophical question, but I am interested in how others with more experience think about distribution selection. In some cases it seems clear that theory might work best (mice tail lengths are probably normally distributed). In a lot of cases there is probably no theory to describe a set of data, so you just use something that fits what you have fairly well regardless of what it was originally developed to describe? I can imagine some of the pitfalls of going with one or the other of these, and then of course there seems to be the problem that maybe you should just use an empirical distribution if you really have no idea. </p> <p>So I guess what I'm really asking: does someone have a coherent way of approaching/thinking about this problem? And are there any resources you can suggest that give a good treatment of this? </p>
73,783
[ -0.02961403876543045, -0.022556789219379425, 0.017475057393312454, -0.04607842490077019, 0.0008012001635506749, 0.037724390625953674, -0.005991083569824696, 0.01556399092078209, 0.012343441136181355, -0.007385066710412502, 0.0045256721787154675, 0.05265749618411064, 0.028684381395578384, -0.006885517854243517, 0.04245207831263542, -0.016251906752586365, 0.007999593392014503, -0.0025491793639957905, -0.032802484929561615, -0.019561056047677994, -0.00016736397810745984, 0.02347465790808201, -0.006902155000716448, -0.029886435717344284, -0.028927359730005264, 0.04728810861706734, -0.0001167225418612361, -0.008807674050331116, 0.01532952394336462, 0.038625359535217285, 0.002987317042425275, -0.003963185474276543, -0.003558090189471841, 0.05473405867815018, 0.01970335841178894, -0.0012132299598306417, -0.006533842533826828, -0.026841549202799797, -0.007871094159781933, 0.035416118800640106, -0.029508396983146667, -0.01551011111587286, 0.007217729464173317, -0.014125450514256954, -0.013427588157355785, 0.036776598542928696, -0.018776657059788704, -0.07333018630743027, 0.027199149131774902, -0.06055087968707085, 0.07205314934253693, 0.040755096822977066, 0.018763551488518715, 0.05990000069141388, 0.003034780966117978, -0.012338094413280487, 0.05188687518239021, 0.03551375865936279, -0.023082097992300987, -0.059520650655031204, -0.041932396590709686, -0.0303817056119442, -0.005514113698154688, -0.009909497573971748, 0.015321379527449608, 0.0081323878839612, 0.0077017489820718765, -0.02373647876083851, 0.0612051822245121, 0.01001750584691763, 0.010815666988492012, 0.041449036449193954, 0.06469430774450302, 0.04554346948862076, 0.049825187772512436, -0.008541608229279518, 0.05502527207136154, 0.0015248145209625363, 0.04968956857919693, 0.01991940289735794, -0.00827331468462944, 0.018812404945492744, 0.026588283479213715, 0.05300804600119591, 0.020988427102565765, -0.025141214951872826, 0.054770804941654205, -0.04490714147686958, -0.008091043680906296, 0.051686231046915054, -0.03463543578982353, -0.02942570671439171, 0.07729563117027283, -0.03442078083753586, -0.048684172332286835, 0.05420437082648277, 0.02025366947054863, 0.03100348450243473, -0.009252681396901608, -0.03217126056551933, -0.016491753980517387, -0.046824388206005096, 0.02491733245551586, 0.04133617877960205, -0.04284272715449333, -0.025940390303730965, -0.05336762219667435, 0.01908048614859581, -0.018871763721108437, -0.017216254025697708, -0.011259214952588081, 0.04794958233833313, 0.02297689951956272, 0.032156407833099365, 0.05275717005133629, 0.023966126143932343, 0.02626206912100315, -0.03145226091146469, 0.09487050026655197, 0.0656418576836586, 0.008578776381909847, -0.022658860310912132, 0.05043783411383629, -0.002912704600021243, -0.022598259150981903, 0.007859740406274796, 0.009005273692309856, 0.011843553744256496, -0.03147118538618088, 0.049736522138118744, -0.017326252534985542, -0.013902361504733562, 0.02489404007792473, -0.01034421194344759, 0.024983389303088188, -0.005533255636692047, -0.051348745822906494, -0.029118523001670837, 0.04905305057764053, -0.042466629296541214, -0.026490593329072, -0.05014953762292862, -0.02453901618719101, 0.0008584051975049078, 0.039271920919418335, -0.009482964873313904, 0.021390633657574654, -0.01935429498553276, 0.03202492371201515, -0.014465543441474438, 0.006473754998296499, -0.01785779930651188, -0.01925765909254551, -0.03452987223863602, 0.0014970279298722744, -0.06584877520799637, 0.0408395417034626, 0.012224694713950157, -0.0014677430735900998, -0.03590041771531105, 0.0509079284965992, 0.00797867402434349, -0.005240703001618385, 0.015814155340194702, 0.03536485880613327, -0.02780485898256302, 0.0771307572722435, -0.014394454658031464, 0.028044871985912323, 0.02690163254737854, 0.013628561049699783, 0.003759911749511957, 0.020966697484254837, 0.03802599757909775, 0.0365217886865139, -0.021144289523363113, 0.020227551460266113, -0.019280539825558662, 0.004800861701369286, -0.007828503847122192, 0.00698771420866251, -0.009072058834135532, -0.011312023736536503, -0.016435133293271065, 0.028600173071026802, 0.03362995758652687, 0.01247707474976778, -0.03061806596815586, 0.0669703558087349, -0.05294742062687874, -0.04621582478284836, -0.0686604231595993, -0.017796888947486877, -0.028540221974253654, -0.02481941692531109, 0.05243014171719551, -0.010462208651006222, -0.010205266997218132, -0.022517656907439232, -0.04247010871767998, -0.03106265887618065, -0.0027959258295595646, 0.02477290667593479, -0.0389009453356266, -0.00630396930500865, 0.0781785249710083, 0.007750214077532291, -0.040470920503139496, 0.050796933472156525, -0.025478122755885124, -0.0698406845331192, -0.03723827376961708, -0.03473299741744995, 0.024499397724866867, 0.012162898667156696, 0.013639252632856369, -0.015341294929385185, -0.01379227451980114, -0.04610680788755417, 0.02150290459394455, -0.0350445918738842, 0.06864698976278305, 0.047591764479875565, 0.0026945634745061398, -0.005971382837742567, 0.02888234704732895, -0.021714285016059875, -0.004181644879281521, -0.004161181394010782, -0.020529014989733696, -0.07024582475423813, -0.0075248354114592075, 0.059907279908657074, 0.009029563516378403, -0.03882863000035286, 0.03291201591491699, 0.020449567586183548, 0.04938580468297005, 0.025049537420272827, 0.04128788784146309, -0.02373090386390686, -0.014647924341261387, -0.0070957918651402, -0.009367064572870731, 0.010274549014866352, 0.0020024459809064865, 0.01999576762318611, 0.00791189819574356, 0.00612605968490243, -0.019854644313454628, -0.010298540815711021, 0.036101777106523514, 0.004770964849740267, 0.0023119868710637093, -0.0071393889375030994, -0.00315156695432961, 0.03855932876467705, -0.029872123152017593, 0.023353097960352898, 0.051393479108810425, 0.004066525027155876, -0.003150677541270852, 0.006640600040555, -0.019471006467938423, 0.0388588048517704, 0.039997879415750504, -0.023335138335824013, 0.014805375598371029, 0.01801913045346737, 0.009550361894071102, -0.018332678824663162, -0.02111620269715786, -0.040730830281972885, -0.0035442498046904802, 0.015422840602695942, 0.016499344259500504, 0.0035719266161322594, 0.029411129653453827, 0.01906006410717964, -0.04296112433075905, -0.011277742683887482, -0.020914064720273018, 0.025981048122048378, 0.03263495862483978, -0.048477642238140106, 0.0025039827451109886, -0.06349507719278336, -0.03564947098493576, 0.04752602055668831, -0.0053254179656505585, -0.009870072826743126, -0.033047862350940704, 0.01875557377934456, -0.04006601870059967, -0.02304653264582157, -0.007364511955529451, 0.02012336254119873, -0.0172756128013134, -0.021302076056599617, 0.03588853031396866, -0.0021741697564721107, -0.025517268106341362, 0.0593956783413887, -0.05504322797060013, -0.08168929070234299, -0.00670971255749464, 0.011801440268754959, 0.004220864735543728, 0.00896699633449316, 0.01318508479744196, 0.02059272862970829, -0.02444145455956459, -0.02086852677166462, -0.08416624367237091, -0.03627745434641838, 0.013285831548273563, -0.030976224690675735, 0.060597047209739685, 0.02384425699710846, -0.005205902270972729, 0.06950284540653229, 0.04290153458714485, -0.028184369206428528, 0.019277526065707207, 0.016664518043398857, -0.03601523116230965, -0.00822730828076601, 0.024813557043671608, 0.02814665623009205, -0.0032655978575348854, 0.010777229443192482, 0.044399481266736984, 0.024093667045235634, 0.03121725469827652, -0.00900181196630001, -0.019855186343193054, 0.05779097229242325, 0.021835248917341232, -0.01952093094587326, 0.00018022555741481483, 0.013893675059080124, -0.00020982460409868509, 0.021418489515781403, -0.027939539402723312, -0.006155913230031729, 0.0061639901250600815, -0.0552077554166317, 0.026600787416100502, -0.011109663173556328, 0.03544025868177414, -0.009823668748140335, 0.020137624815106392, 0.02055191993713379, -0.029903758317232132, 0.013876707293093204, 0.006433624308556318, 0.034297093749046326, -0.011639243923127651, -0.0008866788703016937, 0.057015061378479004, 0.03214423730969429, -0.04458118602633476, -0.0050142426043748856, -0.018142400309443474, 0.004058131016790867, -0.021627306938171387, -0.01284088846296072, -0.01729343831539154, 0.034443072974681854, 0.026297595351934433, 0.053901556879282, -0.0250520221889019, -0.05107759311795235, 0.0023020224180072546, -0.06670910865068436, 0.013855686411261559, -0.011889779008924961, 0.05243570730090141, 0.007648958824574947, 0.013802982866764069, 0.04234999418258667, 0.011937838979065418, -0.004190091043710709, 0.022658878937363625, -0.05682792142033577, 0.043223798274993896, -0.03416724503040314, -0.008321557193994522, -0.05176309868693352, -0.04360973462462425, 0.04630228504538536, -0.027410652488470078, 0.005214243661612272, 0.004532492253929377, 0.03505821153521538, -0.01839573308825493, -0.023064393550157547, -0.04110875725746155, -0.035081956535577774, -0.04579665884375572, 0.01362577360123396, -0.012518837116658688, -0.011340075172483921, 0.03004097193479538, 0.029922930523753166, 0.0003893541288562119, -0.015388616360723972, -0.04618405923247337, 0.033384088426828384, 0.03838687762618065, 0.012425054796040058, 0.004193735774606466, -0.0028738300316035748, -0.058139994740486145, 0.030162926763296127, -0.019703242927789688, 0.07744698226451874, 0.03362414985895157, -0.05426139384508133, -0.0041056121699512005, -0.07042660564184189, -0.027934595942497253, 0.002844186034053564, 0.00970444269478321, 0.0018604763317853212, -0.006506805308163166, 0.059666018933057785, -0.0022163735702633858, -0.03432312235236168, 0.022083576768636703, 0.039208974689245224, 0.002269067568704486, 0.00222605443559587, -0.02345125563442707, 0.012314814142882824, -0.00385424611158669, 0.0143647575750947, 0.01439396757632494, 0.012929833494126797, -0.00009503931505605578, -0.0015948484651744366, 0.011084605939686298, 0.00860302709043026, -0.0131021523848176, -0.01668540947139263, -0.0039900122210383415, 0.05031270533800125, -0.004797222558408976, -0.03810655325651169, 0.01716262474656105, 0.03815377876162529, 0.03055766224861145, 0.05071766674518585, 0.007137789390981197, -0.06227082014083862, 0.0032995406072586775, 0.047958917915821075, 0.00353260594420135, -0.03644121438264847, 0.007796785794198513, -0.04812825098633766, -0.03279322385787964, 0.03348124772310257, -0.003951310645788908, 0.012619334273040295, -0.027295364066958427, -0.0019310642965137959, -0.03723777085542679, -0.02582230232656002, -0.027541328221559525, -0.00011225406342418864, -0.019861694425344467, 0.07088300585746765, -0.025313641875982285, -0.013536804355680943, -0.04614759236574173, 0.02417377196252346, 0.012652439996600151, 0.03990786522626877, 0.0012511142995208502, -0.041343189775943756, 0.02312980592250824, 0.018525728955864906, 0.001144527574069798, -0.060585565865039825, -0.011385616846382618, 0.003532151225954294, 0.016742488369345665, 0.01656832918524742, 0.008380263112485409, -0.0443265438079834, 0.007163787726312876, -0.01228602509945631, -0.02534700185060501, 0.007952490821480751, -0.0024182163178920746, 0.026315221562981606, 0.004880631808191538, 0.024469265714287758, 0.031011013314127922, 0.032461073249578476, -0.008852628991007805, 0.0008211944368667901, -0.039759136736392975, 0.02594735473394394, -0.02583211287856102, -0.02166854590177536, -0.0823328047990799, -0.001984687289223075, -0.037906464189291, 0.013985535129904747, 0.028816549107432365, 0.05548457056283951, -0.024371815845370293, -0.05694106966257095, -0.006005993112921715, 0.0013051885180175304, -0.0030170187819749117, -0.025827011093497276, 0.029587822034955025, 0.03242601826786995, -0.019571270793676376, 0.0096518499776721, 0.00546231959015131, 0.02154521644115448, 0.015715163201093674, 0.0071501233614981174, -0.04977581650018692, 0.012796404771506786, -0.04220081493258476, -0.061855901032686234, 0.04109323397278786, -0.05507228896021843, 0.043836962431669235, -0.001033911481499672, 0.013746697455644608, 0.014837081544101238, -0.05389171466231346, -0.024717625230550766, 0.009966530837118626, 0.0013791808160021901, 0.057025354355573654, -0.04305741935968399, 0.019375234842300415, -0.0519385039806366, 0.02043849416077137, -0.07282071560621262, -0.017170829698443413, -0.008018418215215206, 0.03740096837282181, -0.01679767109453678, -0.024370063096284866, 0.060315705835819244, -0.007450214587152004, -0.032784875482320786, 0.008133301511406898, 0.039566244930028915, 0.00324585591442883, -0.01693146303296089, 0.0014493148773908615, 0.04418870061635971, 0.10229000449180603, -0.018763042986392975, -0.009037654846906662, 0.04542888328433037, -0.020383624359965324, 0.008572179824113846, 0.006377766840159893, 0.020763017237186432, -0.0399884469807148, -0.004770566243678331, -0.013217289000749588, 0.03398461267352104, 0.044533826410770416, -0.026414990425109863, -0.012258651666343212, 0.039668887853622437, -0.02523035556077957, 0.0003700106171891093, -0.009466693736612797, 0.013662558980286121, -0.0037949122488498688, -0.011739552021026611, -0.03216177597641945, 0.008447283878922462, 0.014978569932281971, 0.00029050122248008847, 0.0501793697476387, -0.006499176379293203, 0.021086590364575386, 0.0473221093416214, 0.01503933034837246, -0.015953032299876213, 0.01552837435156107, 0.0009127387893386185, -0.024602500721812248, 0.007454880978912115, -0.008470333181321621, 0.008490649983286858, 0.0037808811757713556, 0.036044877022504807, -0.028705056756734848, -0.02592679113149643, -0.04308202490210533, -0.010051248595118523, 0.05202123522758484, -0.01533307135105133, 0.039774417877197266, 0.052709802985191345, -0.0017319456674158573, -0.036622874438762665, -0.05046277493238449, -0.011331800371408463, -0.04167534038424492, 0.0048333569429814816, 0.05927566438913345, -0.010155468247830868, -0.005758056417107582, 0.0439913384616375, -0.0002422011602902785, 0.017362022772431374, 0.05240962654352188, 0.0198809914290905, 0.0066252946853637695, 0.060753244906663895, -0.017623914405703545, -0.040602315217256546, 0.02344363182783127, -0.04654042422771454, 0.020053841173648834, -0.045838598161935806, 0.012384156696498394, 0.04234791547060013, 0.04473956674337387, -0.021707169711589813, -0.030503936111927032, -0.01949426345527172, -0.00797087512910366, -0.009763825684785843, 0.0337626077234745, -0.030712861567735672, 0.04730328544974327, -0.01881091482937336, 0.028286796063184738, -0.0481637641787529, 0.026277072727680206, 0.011822777800261974, -0.07498972117900848, -0.00808421615511179, -0.032372891902923584, -0.046696968376636505, 0.01101680751889944, 0.011033125221729279, -0.0015990573447197676, -0.005143637768924236, -0.029034985229372978, -0.012441969476640224, 0.023944763466715813, 0.007200943306088448, -0.023301230743527412, 0.10586046427488327, -0.010606988333165646, -0.010006633587181568, -0.010385707020759583, -0.02112717740237713, 0.11058492213487625, 0.07503661513328552, 0.03557347133755684, -0.07422685623168945, 0.0312020406126976, -0.014117494225502014, 0.022524340078234673, -0.017838211730122566, 0.026768682524561882, -0.0037089940160512924, 0.06334238499403, 0.039673738181591034, 0.04518626630306244, 0.0250379778444767, -0.007852117531001568, 0.06646012514829636, -0.04410403221845627, -0.04701162129640579, 0.02587403915822506, 0.024853438138961792, -0.0034959721378982067, -0.0090026268735528, -0.04170151427388191, -0.005668663885444403, 0.025158848613500595, 0.019976196810603142, 0.01394737884402275, -0.02239242009818554, 0.00186893658246845, 0.0039208754897117615, -0.00554741732776165, -0.011247440241277218, 0.014857137575745583, -0.0046770223416388035, -0.02152630314230919, -0.021009836345911026, -0.007519784849137068, -0.03715182840824127, 0.0043967412784695625, 0.022824671119451523, 0.012904562056064606, -0.004758472554385662, -0.00887750182300806, 0.019586345180869102, -0.035698890686035156, -0.04340037703514099, -0.030696718022227287, 0.028124434873461723, -0.02024618536233902, -0.011037813499569893, 0.006837412249296904, -0.008141663856804371, 0.0180791225284338, -0.04369800537824631, -0.014174587093293667, -0.0069327158853411674, 0.043882105499506, -0.0004418675962369889, -0.015013718977570534, 0.0008848907891660929, 0.045984331518411636, -0.007143724709749222, 0.032142579555511475, 0.02055404894053936, -0.025694914162158966, -0.029642978683114052, 0.0028801634907722473, 0.03312456235289574, 0.05532427504658699, -0.032554302364587784, -0.037075530737638474, -0.008221495896577835, -0.05442235618829727, -0.004851509816944599, -0.017603743821382523, -0.005066170822829008, 0.031504418700933456, -0.029107876121997833, -0.0008431393653154373, -0.020630283281207085, -0.03658268228173256, 0.02432718127965927, -0.019920745864510536, 0.00382734346203506, -0.06840471178293228, 0.022041624411940575, -0.0006074699340388179, 0.059179529547691345, 0.027929609641432762, 0.012267444282770157, -0.025753963738679886, 0.02931426465511322, 0.003341518109664321, -0.04712490737438202, 0.0030897120013833046, -0.007894767448306084, -0.0418362095952034, -0.0041803293861448765, -0.005842018872499466, 0.050538383424282074, 0.004623004235327244, 0.012977974489331245, -0.005317031405866146, 0.008920647203922272, 0.037874508649110794, 0.030674556270241737, -0.02022462897002697, -0.07374978810548782, -0.024455608800053596, -0.006874321959912777, -0.036495476961135864, -0.061569251120090485, -0.047709159553050995, -0.027059748768806458, -0.04113001376390457, -0.002725383499637246, 0.025085559114813805, -0.027477744966745377, -0.004845529794692993, -0.049060575664043427, 0.020057260990142822, -0.004165180027484894, 0.01550211850553751, -0.012786969542503357, -0.015288923867046833, -0.057405341416597366, -0.004092074930667877, -0.01882416382431984, 0.00992410909384489, -0.016656946390867233, -0.004878286272287369, -0.0016943180235102773, 0.008189767599105835, 0.024303609505295753, 0.006858254782855511, -0.01999041438102722, -0.004166139289736748, 0.057469259947538376, -0.001794762210920453, 0.02085448056459427, 0.013657089322805405, -0.019003678113222122, -0.029306596145033836, -0.014481613412499428, -0.009694325737655163, 0.04774346202611923, -0.013888582587242126, -0.004603173583745956, -0.03607884421944618, 0.04907655715942383, -0.03247756510972977, -0.0310591459274292, -0.02825462631881237, -0.0018615720327943563, -0.0028883919585496187, -0.0008395528420805931, 0.025782771408557892, -0.01137650478631258, -0.014312502928078175, 0.04253395274281502, 0.00900568813085556, 0.02418217808008194, -0.0033108657225966454, 0.03138042986392975, -0.0074216644279658794, 0.025071654468774796, 0.02822931855916977, -0.012707602232694626, 0.02007119543850422, 0.07246473431587219, -0.012092847377061844, 0.031126441434025764, 0.013011464849114418, -0.018763521686196327, -0.05732500180602074, -0.007177835796028376, 0.0401807501912117, -0.024515721946954727, 0.03694577515125275, -0.05440038442611694, -0.02827206440269947, 0.03176107630133629, -0.054023467004299164, 0.00895572081208229, -0.018756816163659096, -0.026007527485489845, -0.04389357566833496, -0.004934718832373619, -0.016098808497190475, 0.04197627305984497, 0.036850135773420334, 0.012617353349924088, 0.008558354340493679, -0.007660642731934786, 0.003602095413953066, -0.003390207886695862, -0.0076417475938797, 0.024561412632465363, 0.005018388852477074, -0.04826943203806877, 0.030669715255498886, -0.03305961936712265, -0.018042296171188354, 0.07217057049274445, -0.01457995269447565, 0.02885214425623417, 0.02789217047393322, 0.012660438194870949, 0.006521052680909634, 0.044776998460292816, 0.04098844900727272, -0.02094731666147709, -0.0016399259911850095, 0.01916893944144249, 0.03994497284293175, 0.02147059701383114, -0.030282679945230484, 0.017669029533863068, -0.0041260323487222195, -0.04308051988482475, -0.022773558273911476, 0.007852960377931595, -0.008110133931040764, -0.02807650901377201, 0.011502150446176529, 0.0007981400704011321, 0.02350868657231331, -0.00021149143867660314, 0.038348935544490814, -0.05162195488810539, -0.004383350722491741, 0.021445639431476593, 0.030871199443936348, -0.01049884781241417, 0.030786989256739616, -0.023782499134540558, -0.05162553861737251, -0.024160677567124367, 0.020908702164888382, 0.024099677801132202, -0.033463407307863235, 0.0015077022835612297, -0.0168482456356287, 0.013800251297652721, -0.0002782012161333114, -0.03241203352808952, -0.037260837852954865, 0.02366563305258751, -0.007607002276927233, 0.026815973222255707, 0.034769561141729355, -0.05210501328110695, 0.015040320344269276, -0.07267904281616211, 0.07656525820493698, -0.00811220332980156, -0.01729663275182247, -0.01859932951629162, -0.022230803966522217, -0.005116784945130348, 0.024565789848566055, 0.04052125662565231, 0.009042143821716309, 0.020558761432766914, -0.034411974251270294, 0.03150356560945511, 0.012127003632485867, -0.04667915403842926, 0.01984638348221779, 0.000009580518053553533, -0.0416809618473053, -0.003579122247174382, 0.01485750824213028, 0.0035740635357797146, 0.0013355303090065718, 0.026988811790943146, 0.016202254220843315, 0.02027917467057705, 0.02095029316842556, -0.01815509796142578, 0.0642707571387291, 0.011809829622507095, -0.0031970611307770014, 0.03544224053621292, -0.0325930118560791, 0.007632486056536436, -0.015628036111593246, 0.004945114254951477, -0.046998556703329086, 0.02465030550956726, -0.0716170221567154, -0.018459077924489975, -0.01979866437613964, 0.015796426683664322, 0.02113492228090763, -0.04454226791858673, 0.0016342434100806713, -0.005236464086920023, -0.006909893825650215, -0.03507893905043602, -0.035808347165584564, 0.012192445807158947, 0.04075946286320686, -0.002937116427347064, -0.006364417262375355, 0.009735324420034885, 0.008409935981035233, -0.021001197397708893, 0.01778429001569748, 0.041080228984355927, -0.018512973561882973, -0.010503334924578667, 0.0270075760781765, -0.028012249618768692, 0.03150855004787445, -0.038274940103292465, 0.0715726986527443, -0.03682075813412666, -0.007837453857064247, 0.03012080118060112, -0.009225727058947086, 0.01013299822807312, 0.0018074525287374854, -0.033938854932785034, 0.08010750263929367, 0.009567035362124443, -0.00018612320127431303, -0.021875515580177307, -0.04486192390322685, -0.013781392015516758, -0.005601693410426378, -0.012186514213681221, 0.02103712037205696, 0.00000671062389301369, 0.03310729190707207, 0.0024871043860912323, 0.01377806719392538, 0.07011141628026962, -0.007496112957596779, 0.04545179754495621, -0.016135310754179955, -0.01662742719054222, -0.013242236338555813, -0.01083849836140871, -0.005154794082045555, 0.008017315529286861, 0.01772468537092209, 0.050475336611270905, 0.03880887106060982, -0.02634488046169281, -0.01784595288336277, -0.008691336028277874, 0.056681010872125626, -0.07667461782693863, -0.02255207858979702, -0.050765011459589005, 0.010241832584142685, 0.0055084931664168835, -0.014725456945598125 ]
<p>I want to compare the distributions of $K$ contingency tables, where each table is $N \times M$. To make things clearer, let's work on $K=M=N=2$. Suppose I have a classical cases and controls test, where I have $2$ variables, treated or not, and cured or not. Suppose that besides testing whether the treatment is effective or not, I want to test whether the effect is different among groups, say males and females. Then I would have $2$ $2 \times 2$ tables, one for males, one for females. I want to test whether the distribution of the tables is independent of sex.</p> <p>Is there a standard test for this?</p>
40,857
[ -0.05074106529355049, -0.011646555736660957, -0.025372637435793877, 0.002761485055088997, 0.02471367083489895, -0.01717296987771988, -0.01564597897231579, 0.006711798720061779, 0.02216697856783867, -0.0034628789871931076, 0.06994199752807617, 0.026108596473932266, 0.08967534452676773, 0.009181646630167961, 0.02290460281074047, 0.01340161357074976, -0.03636157140135765, -0.0006992296548560262, -0.0013567352434620261, 0.008952791802585125, 0.017089838162064552, 0.023484474048018456, 0.011595438234508038, -0.011760055087506771, 0.007624564692378044, 0.0345337949693203, -0.0058251130394637585, -0.04320715740323067, 0.0027787419967353344, 0.04389232024550438, -0.054013606160879135, -0.01765359751880169, -0.008721022866666317, 0.057460322976112366, -0.027689097449183464, 0.014902436174452305, 0.0017983050784096122, -0.015480656176805496, -0.0157366581261158, 0.019986001774668694, -0.013711112551391125, -0.044222183525562286, -0.0009399366099387407, 0.033492326736450195, -0.0190514475107193, 0.01909097470343113, 0.0013942425139248371, -0.04122982546687126, 0.0031657847575843334, -0.0548076406121254, 0.07234277576208115, 0.022900834679603577, 0.03743593394756317, 0.023936308920383453, -0.028094401583075523, -0.00686873821541667, 0.040299512445926666, 0.0520615428686142, -0.0007608882733620703, -0.037729956209659576, -0.0257373359054327, -0.05493451654911041, 0.030579451471567154, -0.013997609727084637, -0.05759250372648239, 0.022679919376969337, -0.02141077071428299, -0.02351108007133007, -0.0014809069689363241, -0.02857435867190361, -0.014475107192993164, 0.042536187916994095, 0.06654863804578781, -0.01275672484189272, -0.024053622037172318, -0.008502510376274586, 0.03757542371749878, 0.0004007635870948434, 0.019000405445694923, 0.011640693061053753, -0.0164357777684927, 0.03135780990123749, 0.010671911761164665, 0.038312554359436035, 0.0025912795681506395, -0.03692029044032097, 0.053434066474437714, 0.007233644835650921, -0.005014279391616583, 0.03712272271513939, -0.043789882212877274, -0.039657529443502426, 0.040750887244939804, -0.0017761141061782837, -0.06377945840358734, -0.0007574849878437817, -0.013395538553595543, 0.04111804813146591, -0.013542328029870987, -0.00815727561712265, -0.0030085325706750154, -0.005258555524051189, 0.029835093766450882, 0.04781646281480789, -0.041493985801935196, 0.00006665306136710569, -0.030473055317997932, 0.0064978948794305325, -0.035537708550691605, 0.0023260382004082203, -0.022175991907715797, 0.025290479883551598, 0.022671416401863098, -0.010172462090849876, 0.0404144749045372, 0.003691365709528327, -0.05093821510672569, -0.030734222382307053, 0.05515499413013458, 0.07559934258460999, 0.06339901685714722, -0.018826225772500038, 0.022201433777809143, -0.016417639330029488, -0.033349066972732544, 0.011145995929837227, -0.0026540302205830812, -0.011261825449764729, -0.029583729803562164, 0.033794600516557693, -0.02032284438610077, -0.02934914082288742, 0.01988135650753975, 0.00464223837479949, 0.022778386250138283, -0.02914128452539444, -0.06072721630334854, -0.06696347892284393, 0.013667366467416286, -0.021580586209893227, -0.0057230484671890736, -0.03029663860797882, 0.02557106502354145, 0.04012588784098625, 0.04404867812991142, -0.00320990732870996, 0.020426085218787193, -0.023947184905409813, 0.03088417649269104, 0.03734508529305458, -0.03647482395172119, -0.02360544539988041, -0.016023144125938416, -0.011827891692519188, 0.003546913620084524, -0.10375414788722992, 0.034136321395635605, 0.0013534313766285777, 0.01614324003458023, -0.003403025446459651, 0.07170581072568893, 0.017450638115406036, -0.011315150186419487, -0.00651075504720211, 0.03317130357027054, -0.010761271230876446, 0.06684165447950363, -0.009009452536702156, 0.031434737145900726, 0.0269919503480196, -0.00865881983190775, 0.04203706234693527, 0.025929976254701614, 0.06738439202308655, 0.01546055544167757, -0.014211038127541542, -0.012055647559463978, -0.016769234091043472, 0.049628328531980515, -0.0005849995068274438, -0.05673711374402046, -0.005852504167705774, -0.019015537574887276, -0.03161837160587311, 0.010741684585809708, 0.05368177965283394, -0.0032304623164236546, -0.012675775215029716, 0.03692234307527542, -0.029789458960294724, -0.04556940868496895, -0.07680787891149521, 0.028226513415575027, -0.006147394422441721, -0.05527893826365471, 0.04854939132928848, 0.035958677530288696, 0.048740558326244354, -0.02437269315123558, -0.023377813398838043, -0.0311259925365448, -0.015447380021214485, -0.005564713850617409, -0.06581874191761017, 0.00428678747266531, 0.05517219007015228, 0.04847274720668793, 0.002381228609010577, 0.04697699472308159, -0.04015609994530678, -0.09106960892677307, 0.014376954175531864, -0.05919768661260605, -0.0189235620200634, 0.022237172350287437, 0.0068228524178266525, 0.013744753785431385, 0.013405457139015198, 0.0072773657739162445, 0.060861505568027496, -0.059217099100351334, 0.06806660443544388, 0.06467752903699875, 0.0074027604423463345, 0.002012221608310938, -0.03916676342487335, 0.01657610572874546, -0.004654284100979567, -0.0058205993846058846, -0.006187194958329201, -0.05986937880516052, 0.007898691110312939, 0.012499994598329067, -0.021417081356048584, -0.049392495304346085, 0.042889583855867386, 0.06136462464928627, 0.012299918569624424, 0.003584137884899974, 0.015620367601513863, -0.002143160905689001, -0.012273428030312061, -0.009234640747308731, 0.010520031675696373, -0.009325215592980385, 0.03400900959968567, 0.03115665353834629, 0.022204698994755745, 0.036430295556783676, 0.016520237550139427, -0.011716781184077263, 0.0495433434844017, -0.01977895200252533, -0.014879092574119568, -0.006472986191511154, -0.04622950404882431, 0.0333760604262352, -0.010337215848267078, -0.0011253668926656246, 0.0392402745783329, 0.01524401642382145, 0.016458721831440926, 0.0014956427039578557, -0.013004316948354244, 0.02490125223994255, -0.008429396897554398, -0.04081876203417778, -0.0033747802954167128, 0.01926504820585251, -0.034334007650613785, 0.021675381809473038, -0.010155592113733292, -0.02881842479109764, -0.013195588253438473, 0.015502753667533398, 0.04096444323658943, -0.019164372235536575, 0.017477383837103844, 0.015396016649901867, -0.0027507953345775604, 0.009978746064007282, -0.04637591540813446, 0.017019037157297134, -0.0032549265306442976, -0.04967150464653969, -0.022555744275450706, -0.047919172793626785, -0.035557862371206284, 0.05048432573676109, -0.017701735720038414, -0.007936371490359306, 0.022861193865537643, -0.013345777057111263, -0.031470175832509995, -0.011753826402127743, -0.021230114623904228, 0.02530917339026928, -0.05597525089979172, -0.038198743015527725, 0.020534949377179146, 0.0034718120004981756, 0.0016927060205489397, 0.014316306449472904, -0.022289777174592018, -0.01211734488606453, -0.004169628489762545, -0.005119234323501587, 0.03263109549880028, -0.028558531776070595, -0.027365798130631447, 0.032965946942567825, -0.04503284767270088, -0.017531277611851692, -0.0763469859957695, -0.0343608595430851, 0.012087098322808743, -0.0007953146123327315, 0.04914669319987297, 0.021242259070277214, -0.03631383180618286, 0.04928276315331459, 0.048727959394454956, -0.014402797445654869, -0.026859773322939873, -0.014506720006465912, -0.0641319751739502, -0.04692770540714264, 0.03406601771712303, -0.0016028189565986395, -0.00015332785551436245, 0.026841428130865097, 0.020023463293910027, 0.008987035602331161, 0.03836331143975258, -0.025971751660108566, -0.006255729123950005, 0.03495502471923828, 0.02532648667693138, -0.019314294680953026, 0.025500794872641563, 0.002463528187945485, -0.032179899513721466, -0.013958183117210865, 0.02470378205180168, 0.013725404627621174, 0.010661034844815731, -0.03541622310876846, 0.042824603617191315, -0.030944332480430603, 0.004756246227771044, -0.016222599893808365, 0.04391732066869736, 0.017895296216011047, -0.01593594066798687, 0.00013075972674414515, 0.04682426527142525, 0.014632562175393105, -0.05438888818025589, 0.03454181179404259, 0.0604209303855896, 0.05476067215204239, -0.009734511375427246, -0.012879038229584694, -0.028066065162420273, 0.010053001344203949, 0.012481043115258217, -0.011989264748990536, -0.030519872903823853, 0.017723623663187027, 0.027780966833233833, 0.02035614661872387, -0.019080061465501785, -0.031520891934633255, 0.019305668771266937, -0.06346592307090759, 0.020544541999697685, -0.022694410756230354, 0.02846168912947178, 0.01125250943005085, 0.05653994902968407, 0.026168210431933403, 0.0028706537559628487, -0.03500242158770561, 0.0006198271876201034, -0.043224088847637177, 0.02662612870335579, -0.017170893028378487, -0.013611020520329475, 0.020944563671946526, -0.015776734799146652, 0.011506273411214352, 0.01242558192461729, -0.002961687743663788, 0.026668401435017586, 0.02840607427060604, -0.025267118588089943, 0.013429060578346252, -0.011883476749062538, -0.040685176849365234, 0.04023168608546257, 0.031898051500320435, 0.003177306614816189, -0.005088869947940111, 0.010840936563909054, 0.024335667490959167, -0.007635791786015034, -0.027042681351304054, -0.021367916837334633, 0.042807865887880325, -0.021525850519537926, 0.017578616738319397, 0.042074598371982574, 0.027421027421951294, -0.038875602185726166, 0.025346284732222557, -0.010439732111990452, 0.053096238523721695, 0.024235880002379417, -0.006137982476502657, -0.018500229343771935, -0.020405953750014305, -0.0028857060242444277, -0.01271962933242321, 0.03154585883021355, 0.016519593074917793, -0.015938211232423782, 0.08405111730098724, 0.04932580888271332, -0.05748802050948143, -0.0006459853611886501, 0.05028868839144707, 0.0012482460588216782, -0.017933547496795654, -0.030654875561594963, -0.024782484397292137, -0.008578922599554062, 0.002966216066852212, 0.012077650055289268, -0.002167367609217763, 0.0020417890045791864, -0.0127173513174057, 0.033135779201984406, -0.021759314462542534, -0.04096287116408348, -0.013105981983244419, 0.007713426370173693, 0.05949047580361366, 0.004035459365695715, -0.015031611546874046, 0.015176428481936455, 0.025500623509287834, -0.008968508802354336, 0.022069741040468216, -0.012190627865493298, -0.06142452359199524, 0.03351945802569389, 0.056217730045318604, 0.016025397926568985, -0.043503861874341965, -0.02392970770597458, -0.019743820652365685, -0.008790349587798119, 0.045026201754808426, -0.0007405804353766143, -0.003662256756797433, 0.0017435476183891296, 0.004847625736147165, -0.027248859405517578, 0.013720482587814331, -0.01207344513386488, -0.0018990657990798354, 0.006100245751440525, 0.01038455031812191, -0.00709332013502717, -0.020229164510965347, -0.045918647199869156, -0.032754022628068924, 0.039364878088235855, 0.049334220588207245, -0.009418711997568607, -0.005808447953313589, 0.013055842369794846, 0.01809377409517765, -0.020357733592391014, -0.036492325365543365, 0.0065297214314341545, 0.010856587439775467, -0.015544483438134193, 0.05350475013256073, -0.028499003499746323, -0.013935858383774757, 0.012121232226490974, -0.010075382888317108, -0.017782418057322502, 0.04571334272623062, 0.01818198896944523, 0.014470801688730717, 0.0069580161944031715, 0.02726762928068638, 0.04008498415350914, 0.011067216284573078, -0.013271494768559933, -0.012750073336064816, -0.016472909599542618, 0.04002512991428375, -0.025309082120656967, -0.012165626510977745, -0.0378686748445034, 0.008164433762431145, -0.017784636467695236, 0.0324077233672142, 0.005919024348258972, 0.029077017679810524, -0.005044338759034872, 0.00443135853856802, 0.004409996792674065, 0.037496741861104965, 0.023150326684117317, 0.009803452529013157, 0.021936528384685516, 0.01892237737774849, -0.012105418369174004, -0.031593188643455505, 0.049956660717725754, -0.008456327952444553, 0.0050856806337833405, -0.028339147567749023, -0.019685247913002968, 0.011976995505392551, -0.06468522548675537, -0.022472556680440903, 0.019891316071152687, 0.010130886919796467, 0.03458566591143608, 0.006856826134026051, 0.05552195385098457, -0.017159536480903625, -0.058765556663274765, -0.015075246803462505, 0.02437097765505314, 0.00492087984457612, 0.04847069829702377, -0.014341473579406738, 0.032473769038915634, 0.005913885775953531, 0.00037665729178115726, -0.09798426181077957, -0.033237945288419724, 0.01792500540614128, -0.0043564909137785435, -0.017175037413835526, -0.02661179006099701, 0.002365007298067212, -0.022571124136447906, -0.01651131361722946, -0.018622461706399918, 0.07483820617198944, 0.02611144259572029, -0.024163631722331047, -0.004774603992700577, -0.000775612541474402, 0.07663670182228088, 0.02542690932750702, -0.018747728317975998, -0.018330760300159454, -0.030696766451001167, -0.0238041989505291, -0.01606574095785618, 0.0025977641344070435, -0.024586573243141174, 0.012648445554077625, -0.033808037638664246, -0.0014967697206884623, 0.05130259692668915, -0.03455740213394165, -0.029603976756334305, 0.03868412598967552, -0.00190464046318084, -0.0017174610402435064, -0.037082429975271225, 0.00809382926672697, -0.033852361142635345, 0.042067740112543106, -0.04260626062750816, -0.0284867063164711, 0.0020377938635647297, -0.011554330587387085, 0.014552371576428413, 0.00965621042996645, -0.04746124893426895, 0.023258330300450325, 0.07135427743196487, -0.004372903145849705, 0.007248483598232269, -0.02997513674199581, 0.019856823608279228, 0.023762298747897148, 0.010930207557976246, -0.022003190591931343, -0.0011375785106793046, 0.02919743023812771, -0.023278623819351196, -0.019413702189922333, -0.025476902723312378, 0.041016075760126114, 0.052165787667036057, -0.014890053309500217, 0.055082522332668304, 0.06188633292913437, 0.02637375332415104, 0.02055094577372074, -0.032502882182598114, 0.015915334224700928, -0.0047794911079108715, 0.01795223169028759, 0.022908102720975876, -0.012113921344280243, 0.023424185812473297, 0.04962417483329773, 0.009999213740229607, -0.0004820530884899199, 0.05908268690109253, 0.014957651495933533, 0.010250799357891083, 0.0507756844162941, -0.013487267307937145, -0.019114602357149124, 0.0474536269903183, -0.10158391296863556, 0.01120876707136631, -0.06933560967445374, -0.018764717504382133, 0.029915826395154, 0.05374935641884804, -0.007404005620628595, -0.023478245362639427, -0.05924113094806671, -0.04527706652879715, 0.018723146989941597, 0.01879909262061119, 0.014030328020453453, 0.030006062239408493, -0.0035133378114551306, 0.04532598331570625, -0.011532261036336422, 0.025054655969142914, -0.03372588008642197, -0.10026292502880096, -0.0341152623295784, -0.015572094358503819, -0.021153545007109642, 0.026059716939926147, 0.01372815202921629, -0.03136899694800377, 0.0107189966365695, -0.04213937371969223, 0.021393125876784325, 0.029331054538488388, 0.04838474467396736, -0.002211604965850711, 0.06709108501672745, -0.003483240259811282, -0.00045958845294080675, 0.010740806348621845, -0.01776854693889618, 0.10616721957921982, 0.06015973165631294, 0.05082734674215317, -0.09258493781089783, 0.014172259718179703, -0.012047220021486282, -0.013537502847611904, -0.0059264712035655975, 0.019214840605854988, -0.004830458667129278, -0.007864742539823055, 0.04607025533914566, 0.07479582726955414, 0.020450986921787262, -0.0009713519248180091, 0.07198241353034973, -0.015201989561319351, -0.02948329970240593, 0.018363546580076218, -0.00056891527492553, -0.011897715739905834, -0.017951946705579758, -0.01922357641160488, 0.0006193952285684645, 0.022531233727931976, -0.017936883494257927, -0.02241039276123047, 0.009851079434156418, 0.016130393370985985, -0.0014714797725901008, -0.00282564340159297, 0.010244010016322136, 0.04162231832742691, 0.009159557521343231, -0.03406482934951782, -0.0274336040019989, 0.009229735471308231, -0.030640628188848495, 0.01911974512040615, 0.049260057508945465, -0.011572999879717827, -0.00031611439771950245, 0.028395460918545723, -0.002183945383876562, -0.04897917062044144, -0.0289449505507946, -0.03665832057595253, 0.024459315463900566, -0.007439009379595518, -0.00934509839862585, -0.01869944855570793, 0.011310690082609653, -0.021809324622154236, -0.0356757827103138, 0.005752129014581442, 0.03359916806221008, 0.03762580826878548, -0.049022573977708817, 0.023633047938346863, -0.05538269132375717, 0.01949155516922474, -0.0053183711133897305, 0.02203918993473053, 0.021726559847593307, -0.014970632269978523, -0.021442249417304993, 0.00591502757743001, 0.03055676259100437, 0.013662981800734997, -0.01618473418056965, 0.007055853959172964, -0.028803644701838493, -0.009003380313515663, -0.0031450665555894375, -0.015012362040579319, 0.03806981444358826, 0.050475314259529114, 0.010208760388195515, -0.02971438318490982, 0.00495430501177907, -0.034981466829776764, 0.0074700163677334785, -0.029213955625891685, 0.003372961888089776, -0.039310336112976074, 0.012436781078577042, 0.030381396412849426, 0.003943414893001318, 0.014214952476322651, 0.00035018028574995697, -0.007634317968040705, 0.04218040779232979, 0.022856982424855232, -0.05991879850625992, -0.02990475296974182, -0.044712577015161514, -0.030359510332345963, -0.004287059418857098, -0.05295781046152115, 0.034689705818891525, -0.00260813906788826, 0.02379852533340454, -0.00034597647027112544, -0.006183064077049494, -0.0076218764297664165, 0.02182641252875328, 0.01816084235906601, -0.06301089376211166, 0.00957522913813591, 0.027888942509889603, -0.009793883189558983, -0.02038528025150299, -0.03434911370277405, -0.03698527067899704, -0.024168139323592186, 0.018683962523937225, -0.034996870905160904, -0.011004647240042686, -0.006323198787868023, -0.013139250688254833, 0.011501990258693695, -0.02106623724102974, -0.021448353305459023, -0.029860466718673706, -0.014937285333871841, 0.042809583246707916, 0.005320112220942974, 0.012953855097293854, 0.010088881477713585, -0.015270205214619637, 0.0212184377014637, 0.023261141031980515, 0.034276947379112244, 0.006948026362806559, 0.030906379222869873, -0.003960494417697191, 0.012260193936526775, 0.06535588949918747, -0.01642570272088051, -0.03277396038174629, 0.04770401120185852, -0.039303313940763474, -0.020673982799053192, 0.01222415640950203, -0.018878253176808357, 0.04782850295305252, 0.011904986575245857, 0.0020708367228507996, -0.007602493278682232, 0.0367199182510376, -0.05311857908964157, -0.017535824328660965, 0.008660353720188141, -0.004935739561915398, 0.013322180137038231, -0.0050177257508039474, -0.005102495197206736, -0.006047461181879044, -0.02441789209842682, 0.027692556381225586, 0.05070913955569267, 0.024442322552204132, 0.014025231823325157, 0.0196662787348032, 0.039435867220163345, 0.027022799476981163, 0.00952908769249916, -0.008728459477424622, 0.0586562380194664, 0.07377650588750839, -0.024687251076102257, 0.023889902979135513, -0.010877853259444237, 0.021135013550519943, -0.12256121635437012, -0.023964151740074158, 0.020397549495100975, 0.016595877707004547, 0.043916005641222, -0.07092144340276718, -0.0031962331850081682, 0.003943941090255976, -0.03909347578883171, 0.01767144165933132, -0.007130002602934837, -0.007564901374280453, -0.07925350964069366, 0.01876974292099476, 0.0027625085785984993, 0.030759604647755623, 0.03803827613592148, 0.006741751916706562, 0.030536850914359093, 0.02050921320915222, 0.007062593474984169, -0.002458795439451933, 0.002135208807885647, -0.026198528707027435, 0.0200587660074234, -0.06329431384801865, 0.00010330725490348414, -0.0020875870250165462, -0.051629334688186646, 0.01615464687347412, 0.005020544398576021, 0.00886648241430521, 0.0014245269121602178, 0.008373142220079899, -0.0017720384057611227, 0.037870101630687714, 0.016753684729337692, -0.01526735071092844, -0.02159188687801361, 0.007620610762387514, -0.007539491169154644, 0.0345531702041626, -0.04711262509226799, 0.026937570422887802, 0.046419184654951096, -0.05442100018262863, -0.020165646448731422, 0.023821096867322922, 0.010720835067331791, -0.048929132521152496, -0.013186376541852951, -0.05357014015316963, 0.04576563835144043, -0.002059151418507099, 0.04495171830058098, -0.055937714874744415, 0.01341210212558508, 0.013927959837019444, 0.030146388337016106, -0.0010872043203562498, 0.03061777725815773, -0.0045090485364198685, -0.03139200806617737, -0.019476188346743584, 0.024590367451310158, 0.010158859193325043, -0.07944675534963608, 0.0035197229590266943, -0.041164759546518326, 0.012483524158596992, -0.03047531470656395, -0.04385708272457123, -0.012493825517594814, 0.012861894443631172, -0.03215377405285835, -0.004598837811499834, 0.04061968997120857, -0.0043815686367452145, 0.011585170403122902, -0.05357297882437706, 0.0339241661131382, 0.006891968194395304, -0.04369135573506355, -0.016279049217700958, 0.012854211032390594, -0.047968123108148575, -0.0030505782924592495, 0.05734866484999657, 0.03748379647731781, 0.003944686613976955, -0.01994440145790577, 0.028618738055229187, -0.025051942095160484, -0.07093046605587006, 0.04149710014462471, -0.029240630567073822, -0.038651540875434875, -0.03642671927809715, 0.006492109037935734, 0.0325494185090065, 0.006985155399888754, 0.02127923257648945, -0.027883417904376984, 0.006331815384328365, 0.011096310801804066, -0.008751548826694489, 0.03171004727482796, 0.01443385798484087, 0.0012480936711654067, 0.03710104897618294, 0.0031334543600678444, 0.01231143344193697, 0.004667862318456173, 0.017719639465212822, -0.05615704506635666, 0.07284918427467346, -0.04143733158707619, -0.03820371255278587, 0.004518786445260048, 0.03643941134214401, -0.03986310586333275, -0.040313947945833206, 0.006276291329413652, 0.013740352354943752, -0.0334753654897213, 0.009329310618340969, -0.02256057970225811, 0.040064435452222824, 0.03228286653757095, -0.002469225088134408, -0.009115693159401417, -0.006697819102555513, -0.015963498502969742, 0.03830214589834213, 0.022021057084202766, 0.01864864118397236, 0.014915179461240768, -0.01381720695644617, -0.0033970915246754885, -0.05284035578370094, 0.031153986230492592, 0.007009986322373152, 0.02444254606962204, 0.026200734078884125, -0.002553939586505294, 0.0030297269113361835, -0.011736211366951466, 0.015791404992341995, -0.009292583912611008, -0.03484034538269043, 0.05247530713677406, -0.005413725506514311, -0.002624091226607561, -0.04177713766694069, -0.023930324241518974, -0.00007211024058051407, -0.0007795701385475695, 0.045808855444192886, 0.0019503245130181313, -0.03973379358649254, 0.0027151345275342464, 0.011519434861838818, -0.02919112518429756, 0.02392849326133728, -0.00920098926872015, 0.06609304994344711, -0.03609158471226692, -0.03227325156331062, -0.028023751452565193, -0.04088437184691429, -0.03445889428257942, -0.03761550039052963, 0.04365292191505432, 0.033493511378765106, 0.02594812773168087, -0.04561375826597214, -0.028887435793876648, 0.0015559784369543195, 0.06634242832660675, -0.0642981082201004, -0.04626050963997841, -0.04066525027155876, 0.016462845727801323, 0.030683722347021103, 0.013424032367765903 ]
<p>I am just learning R. I have developed a regression model with six predictor variables. While developing it, I found the relationships are not very linear. So, maybe because of this the predictions of my model are not exact.</p> <p>Here is Headers of my data set:</p> <pre><code>1.bouncerate(To be predicted) 2.avgServerResponseTime 3.avgServerConnectionTime 4.avgRedirectionTime 5.avgPageDownloadTime 6.avgDomainLookupTime 7.avgPageLoadTime </code></pre> <p>Sample datasets:</p> <pre><code>28.57142857,4.132,0.234,0,0.505,0,14.168 42.85714286,3.356777778,0.090777778,0.077333333,0.459,0.105444444,14.78644444 0,3.372,0.1105,0.0015,0.425,0.1305,34.3425 33.33333333,3.583,0.218,0,0.385,0.649,11.816 66.66666667,2.438,0.234,0,0.3405,0,8.645 100,2.805,0.179666667,3.203666667,0.000333333,0.11,13.47066667 66.66666667,0.977,0,0.003,0,0,12.847 0,2.776,0,7.888,0,0,14.393 100,2.59,0.261,0,0.517,0,6.216 </code></pre> <p>Here is the summary of my model:</p> <pre><code>Call: lm(formula = y ~ x_1 + x_2 + x_3 + x_4 + x_5 + x_6) Residuals: Min 1Q Median 3Q Max -125.302 -26.210 0.702 26.261 111.511 Coefficients: Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(&gt;|t|) (Intercept) 48.62944 0.27999 173.684 &lt; 2e-16 *** x_1 -0.67831 0.08053 -8.423 &lt; 2e-16 *** x_2 0.07476 0.49578 0.151 0.880143 x_3 -0.22981 0.06489 -3.541 0.000399 *** x_4 0.01845 0.09070 0.203 0.838814 x_5 3.76952 0.67006 5.626 1.87e-08 *** x_6 0.07698 0.01565 4.919 8.75e-07 *** --- Signif. codes: 0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1 Residual standard error: 33.76 on 19710 degrees of freedom Multiple R-squared: 0.006298, Adjusted R-squared: 0.005995 F-statistic: 20.82 on 6 and 19710 DF, p-value: &lt; 2.2e-16 </code></pre> <p>plot with all single variable are below: <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/jsW0j.png" alt="bouncerate vs avgServerConnectionTime"> <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/uhrya.png" alt="bouncerate vs ServerResponseTime"> <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/iuROe.png" alt="bouncerate vs avgRedirectionTime"> <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/wbfsP.png" alt="bouncerate vs avgDomainLookupTime"> <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/arTC6.png" alt="bouncerate vs avgPageLoadTime"></p> <p>I have certain questions about this model: </p> <ol> <li>Is there any way to improve the accuracy of this model? </li> <li>Which of the values is most useful: residual standard error, degrees of freedom, multiple R-squared, adjusted R-squared, F-statistics, or p-values for choosing best model? </li> <li>Is it appropriate to use polynomial transformations with these data? </li> <li>In case I do use polynomial terms in my model, which degree is most appropriate? </li> </ol>
49,923
[ -0.033388182520866394, 0.02661162242293358, 0.005934620276093483, -0.005024371203035116, 0.054278694093227386, -0.02125365100800991, 0.00037042584153823555, -0.02124461904168129, 0.0345485582947731, -0.02016925998032093, 0.044518377631902695, 0.0504259318113327, 0.01930023916065693, 0.03522517904639244, 0.04599861428141594, -0.01424574013799429, -0.005874817259609699, 0.015855571255087852, 0.01582704856991768, -0.004911632742732763, 0.007330003194510937, 0.019567646086215973, 0.004351886920630932, -0.02134133130311966, -0.02023441158235073, 0.06255103647708893, 0.050696682184934616, -0.021813003346323967, 0.0016594722401350737, 0.01201119739562273, -0.03063565120100975, 0.008881878107786179, 0.01629391871392727, 0.0028405587654560804, 0.027666591107845306, 0.0380452498793602, -0.012081251479685307, -0.02825986221432686, 0.007717890199273825, 0.03647473081946373, -0.013803970068693161, 0.03205116465687752, 0.006158520467579365, 0.050771016627550125, -0.005630561150610447, 0.009006218053400517, 0.022985519841313362, 0.017385710030794144, 0.0734904408454895, 0.0022878379095345736, 0.08655539900064468, -0.02175319753587246, 0.037191785871982574, 0.03130697086453438, -0.03692527487874031, -0.012020711787045002, 0.061340540647506714, 0.0940011739730835, -0.003654886968433857, -0.05894412100315094, 0.01565251685678959, -0.029058875516057014, -0.007028982508927584, -0.038222137838602066, -0.02078542672097683, 0.03309974446892738, 0.002159755676984787, -0.005123551934957504, 0.02027033269405365, -0.013833865523338318, 0.021096855401992798, -0.003984831273555756, 0.027914980426430702, -0.00018552137771621346, 0.011989795602858067, -0.016260342672467232, 0.012636120431125164, 0.011304385028779507, 0.01420538779348135, 0.030220218002796173, -0.00319473585113883, 0.013627884909510612, 0.0025066544767469168, 0.025841940194368362, 0.027264516800642014, 0.0002690146502573043, 0.04402459040284157, -0.016177037730813026, 0.028626345098018646, 0.01944955252110958, -0.012921595014631748, 0.023170718923211098, 0.05066528916358948, 0.034974776208400726, -0.04916359856724739, 0.042991794645786285, 0.008585385046899319, 0.030830034986138344, 0.018927689641714096, -0.04787074401974678, -0.003430197946727276, -0.04515928030014038, -0.009216082282364368, 0.006436437368392944, -0.024355843663215637, -0.05597412586212158, -0.0487261526286602, -0.050525736063718796, -0.027314554899930954, -0.04130234569311142, 0.011845298111438751, 0.01657842844724655, -0.01501450501382351, -0.01097174547612667, -0.009073787368834019, -0.05968094617128372, -0.0241028293967247, -0.013448248617351055, 0.025210388004779816, 0.04576195031404495, 0.017471298575401306, -0.03170270845293999, 0.02363075315952301, -0.0062889414839446545, -0.020633190870285034, 0.013432549312710762, 0.011903132311999798, -0.03311493992805481, -0.01477966457605362, 0.050049785524606705, 0.017302287742495537, -0.03752531856298447, 0.04164496809244156, 0.008216594345867634, 0.05965190380811691, -0.011902333237230778, -0.08691640198230743, -0.0497954860329628, 0.04921954125165939, -0.02354997768998146, 0.02251475304365158, -0.05774907022714615, 0.000052359839173732325, 0.044009726494550705, 0.059640999883413315, 0.016784779727458954, 0.020794637501239777, 0.0410110279917717, -0.0014510806649923325, 0.011406244710087776, -0.026621514931321144, -0.02736813947558403, -0.04049055650830269, -0.051060933619737625, 0.004383941181004047, -0.06505517661571503, -0.004639049060642719, -0.002469154540449381, -0.015435220673680305, 0.03619183227419853, 0.010243702679872513, -0.028622742742300034, -0.0077636949717998505, -0.022505085915327072, -0.02944113500416279, -0.033475112169981, 0.04788270965218544, 0.0064170267432928085, 0.028020620346069336, 0.029661385342478752, -0.046980809420347214, -0.009592080488801003, 0.004740836098790169, 0.05325064808130264, 0.05266118422150612, 0.016785332933068275, 0.009259117767214775, -0.028799811378121376, 0.00981852039694786, 0.000529950950294733, -0.07174345850944519, -0.032911889255046844, -0.01679052785038948, 0.0022286404855549335, 0.03167358413338661, 0.032336290925741196, 0.0025637506041675806, -0.01807199791073799, 0.031465478241443634, -0.022057609632611275, -0.044856056571006775, -0.026548927649855614, 0.03191542252898216, -0.00527616124600172, -0.017894046381115913, -0.017960093915462494, 0.011970695108175278, 0.02158871851861477, 0.022074751555919647, 0.015087197534739971, 0.007285051513463259, -0.0012982136104255915, 0.0552191324532032, -0.008297107182443142, 0.00048246298683807254, 0.04808466136455536, 0.04927726089954376, -0.01861642487347126, 0.03392484039068222, -0.03234482929110527, 0.008363916538655758, 0.015988456085324287, -0.0028119641356170177, -0.0008748231339268386, -0.038819752633571625, 0.006459243595600128, 0.040836501866579056, 0.0004915236495435238, -0.004415001720190048, 0.028417520225048065, -0.05971335247159004, 0.021264007315039635, 0.07738475501537323, 0.010252220556139946, -0.010913504287600517, -0.009755315259099007, -0.03798491135239601, 0.055801909416913986, -0.03750229999423027, 0.024168692529201508, -0.04524071514606476, -0.016398221254348755, 0.028915315866470337, 0.009423564188182354, -0.013174767605960369, -0.006314776372164488, 0.0719098299741745, -0.0001831891859183088, 0.01969955861568451, 0.03149809315800667, -0.007354425266385078, -0.03928101062774658, 0.02206689678132534, -0.00448628980666399, 0.04157925769686699, -0.0011784648522734642, 0.008013960905373096, 0.032377663999795914, 0.04220195859670639, -0.04459334909915924, 0.0033529940992593765, 0.02980966679751873, 0.006425522267818451, -0.01448740717023611, -0.022724822163581848, -0.03194044157862663, 0.03906574100255966, 0.007615214213728905, -0.009049015119671822, 0.03612957522273064, 0.0034769519697874784, -0.014064973220229149, -0.008865865878760815, -0.02606373094022274, -0.001940287766046822, 0.03817330300807953, -0.04899143800139427, -0.050528425723314285, 0.003992143087089062, -0.04455375671386719, 0.007142915390431881, -0.031292468309402466, -0.02873438410460949, -0.042304523289203644, 0.027778232470154762, 0.03768186271190643, 0.009479311294853687, 0.02982010878622532, -0.004487034399062395, -0.0204042699187994, 0.016089538112282753, -0.028870079666376114, 0.044633716344833374, -0.029417812824249268, -0.02338097058236599, -0.03862341120839119, 0.011060575023293495, -0.015484793111681938, 0.03027152270078659, 0.018348969519138336, -0.01814047433435917, 0.040065959095954895, -0.012020309455692768, -0.06926722079515457, -0.023396654054522514, -0.04859020560979843, 0.02946208231151104, -0.009440426714718342, -0.04227486625313759, 0.026664039120078087, -0.00169616867788136, -0.058335669338703156, 0.006821219809353352, -0.03701208531856537, 0.021758917719125748, -0.025818726047873497, -0.007343115750700235, -0.007356381509453058, 0.004830616060644388, 0.014855260029435158, 0.009453417733311653, 0.0020726134534925222, -0.008543077856302261, -0.07993315160274506, -0.07745067030191422, -0.014810374937951565, 0.002118788193911314, 0.00927139911800623, 0.00912367645651102, -0.0020347286481410265, 0.08070588856935501, 0.01890760287642479, -0.02643527276813984, -0.048684343695640564, -0.015009075403213501, -0.0013218774693086743, -0.03731967881321907, 0.04652150347828865, 0.040779344737529755, 0.03035270981490612, 0.024803072214126587, -0.045538973063230515, 0.0169493667781353, 0.047690149396657944, -0.01403521653264761, 0.041820596903562546, 0.007113005965948105, -0.013184676878154278, -0.01870945282280445, 0.039157282561063766, 0.036689214408397675, -0.030330244451761246, 0.0448521189391613, 0.009746549651026726, 0.01686962880194187, -0.004009622149169445, -0.07883448898792267, 0.0020105966832488775, 0.0014920798130333424, 0.011837131343781948, -0.02309458702802658, -0.0029708982910960913, 0.008548291400074959, -0.0699273869395256, -0.0007445149240083992, 0.014907562173902988, 0.03209615871310234, -0.009989671409130096, 0.02307398058474064, 0.06549693644046783, -0.0012843562290072441, 0.000581577536650002, 0.024109110236167908, -0.007230938877910376, -0.03198135644197464, 0.009892608970403671, -0.029747270047664642, 0.0031393382232636213, 0.05917763337492943, -0.001243392820470035, -0.0048031192272901535, 0.015620491467416286, -0.01500746514648199, 0.018747754395008087, -0.05313397943973541, 0.01816243678331375, -0.029819494113326073, 0.053458936512470245, 0.02484721876680851, 0.03959408402442932, 0.005334603134542704, -0.043985866010189056, 0.013843338005244732, 0.02586819976568222, -0.050963904708623886, 0.026313500478863716, 0.019881024956703186, -0.03226185590028763, 0.0005524572334252298, -0.048291731625795364, -0.004742101300507784, -0.05111921578645706, 0.013452442362904549, 0.00998202245682478, 0.0038403889629989862, -0.008817542344331741, -0.007329139858484268, 0.007953941822052002, 0.016649793833494186, -0.04146583005785942, -0.020265188068151474, 0.025196105241775513, 0.008610900491476059, 0.02879103645682335, 0.053027618676424026, 0.009624466300010681, -0.015802329406142235, -0.005056171678006649, -0.02090545929968357, 0.05490834638476372, 0.04383692517876625, 0.038921065628528595, 0.004946541972458363, -0.012203419581055641, 0.011377954855561256, -0.0021494049578905106, -0.015095734968781471, 0.055524926632642746, 0.009351357817649841, -0.012775574810802937, -0.038559529930353165, -0.0028958290349692106, 0.019656455144286156, -0.007867312990128994, 0.02151048369705677, -0.013218746520578861, 0.050234414637088776, 0.01626923680305481, 0.002555561251938343, 0.01605963706970215, 0.04396265745162964, 0.01841687224805355, 0.008931600488722324, -0.03157993033528328, -0.04286720231175423, 0.004442078527063131, 0.011959973722696304, 0.06423523277044296, -0.005943047348409891, 0.015602280385792255, -0.007669346407055855, 0.030652116984128952, 0.009109770879149437, -0.03305359184741974, -0.011421124450862408, 0.02617631107568741, 0.03681827336549759, -0.019664686173200607, -0.043525997549295425, -0.02531077340245247, 0.05066782236099243, 0.04410139471292496, -0.004983521532267332, -0.008764480240643024, -0.10348375886678696, 0.01284581795334816, 0.018154000863432884, 0.050063520669937134, -0.04037202522158623, -0.03540583327412605, -0.02809174172580242, -0.013296792283654213, 0.030042031779885292, -0.03812630474567413, 0.02403280697762966, 0.030717186629772186, 0.04228607937693596, -0.008869806304574013, -0.056876882910728455, -0.073028065264225, -0.001557382638566196, -0.024327343329787254, 0.019992835819721222, -0.054271068423986435, -0.04751497879624367, -0.043332599103450775, -0.002235116669908166, 0.023377181962132454, 0.04852825030684471, -0.010165360756218433, -0.027251172810792923, -0.008883963339030743, 0.0065903733484447, 0.0005745585658587515, -0.058729302138090134, 0.04378613457083702, -0.010241487063467503, -0.003291955217719078, 0.04930456355214119, -0.007906727492809296, 0.0009943109471350908, 0.025575701147317886, 0.051823411136865616, 0.005690880585461855, -0.025449581444263458, -0.061908796429634094, 0.00811881385743618, 0.00519894901663065, -0.011232299730181694, 0.06738174706697464, 0.01214585267007351, -0.031555697321891785, 0.006823054514825344, -0.042770322412252426, -0.0010617850348353386, -0.0019398849690333009, -0.03329582139849663, -0.029218822717666626, -0.025534415617585182, -0.010799997486174107, 0.021890034899115562, -0.02440357580780983, 0.040645889937877655, -0.0321950763463974, 0.02269938588142395, 0.03674916550517082, 0.024048523977398872, -0.021540123969316483, -0.00020805456733796746, 0.005138884764164686, -0.000512459606397897, -0.025760849937796593, 0.014933944679796696, -0.012025226838886738, -0.0014896750217303634, 0.0188555009663105, 0.055092062801122665, -0.029224514961242676, -0.0010193649213761091, 0.010400948114693165, 0.010742473416030407, -0.019473673775792122, -0.014898042194545269, -0.0047258175909519196, 0.019180312752723694, 0.026816776022315025, 0.0040735770016908646, -0.0095556965097785, -0.025528164580464363, 0.028490697965025902, -0.012229069136083126, 0.03001636080443859, -0.013903897255659103, 0.004630493465811014, -0.034875303506851196, -0.0008074072538875043, -0.05763809755444527, -0.061043400317430496, 0.025024158880114555, -0.005657981149852276, -0.0562334768474102, -0.03556600585579872, -0.02644173987209797, -0.04434762895107269, -0.0036526687908917665, -0.001810686313547194, 0.0017787819961085916, -0.019915059208869934, -0.008335563354194164, 0.006584327667951584, -0.01638515293598175, 0.06565108895301819, -0.0013430546969175339, 0.02414463646709919, 0.03227746859192848, 0.00005103071089251898, -0.020808950066566467, -0.00904304813593626, -0.00764445448294282, -0.03386292606592178, -0.008521337993443012, -0.0400128997862339, -0.013772754929959774, 0.07145771384239197, -0.02895934320986271, -0.019898120313882828, -0.03826817125082016, 0.001178670092485845, 0.020570961758494377, -0.028739850968122482, 0.025401147082448006, 0.0025116605684161186, -0.03263109177350998, 0.009807690978050232, -0.00212930329144001, -0.023268448188900948, 0.00697269756346941, 0.018713150173425674, -0.01062364038079977, -0.006777292117476463, 0.0390874445438385, 0.09501815587282181, 0.015808535739779472, -0.00011027527216356248, -0.006196694914251566, -0.008917166851460934, 0.021415414288640022, -0.005309785716235638, -0.00009369976760353893, -0.025892095640301704, 0.04641253128647804, -0.023944973945617676, -0.043757203966379166, -0.02999088540673256, -0.021275144070386887, 0.05563532933592796, -0.03302400931715965, 0.030683912336826324, 0.012300937436521053, 0.01992233656346798, -0.02103961817920208, -0.024987254291772842, -0.01549791730940342, 0.011060748249292374, 0.04138071462512016, 0.0787462443113327, -0.013874243013560772, -0.0462292805314064, 0.04064345732331276, -0.026934733614325523, 0.0431818850338459, 0.03955749049782753, -0.02196671813726425, -0.01433583814650774, -0.0025594516191631556, -0.003682035254314542, -0.029814695939421654, 0.012399079278111458, -0.019319117069244385, 0.015974344685673714, -0.021990617737174034, 0.008887500502169132, 0.03232640400528908, 0.04743794724345207, 0.003433492500334978, -0.04778272658586502, -0.015517203137278557, -0.045149218291044235, -0.02776077762246132, 0.026980873197317123, -0.014370058663189411, 0.033316489309072495, 0.0354376956820488, 0.022454217076301575, 0.004533194471150637, 0.08216650038957596, -0.024764517322182655, -0.10201825946569443, -0.03040246106684208, -0.01551052089780569, -0.02578222192823887, 0.07765870541334152, 0.006872621830552816, -0.02597648650407791, 0.020958278328180313, -0.04487517103552818, 0.029675275087356567, -0.019830934703350067, 0.026572300121188164, 0.013661310076713562, 0.04674181714653969, -0.005524784792214632, -0.02041146159172058, -0.003704974427819252, -0.019157608970999718, 0.14521759748458862, 0.05693800374865532, 0.029404908418655396, -0.043150465935468674, 0.01333525963127613, 0.03678854927420616, -0.026855308562517166, -0.0348043367266655, -0.03045506216585636, 0.00784409511834383, -0.026018423959612846, 0.07345220446586609, -0.007505892775952816, 0.02224278450012207, -0.002286989241838455, 0.01789613626897335, -0.04286329820752144, 0.02188647910952568, 0.001244685729034245, -0.002009695628657937, 0.013131015002727509, -0.024787254631519318, -0.06318827718496323, 0.025593219324946404, -0.008730503730475903, -0.016109362244606018, -0.0398954302072525, -0.013333424925804138, -0.0005472475313581526, 0.0046550314873456955, -0.021328071132302284, 0.029166260734200478, -0.001777474768459797, 0.013409193605184555, 0.02884216047823429, 0.013576841913163662, 0.03719243034720421, -0.028462858870625496, 0.012081347405910492, 0.029676219448447227, 0.006880562752485275, 0.0076787155121564865, -0.0006820193957537413, 0.0065898532047867775, -0.043074414134025574, -0.0398782417178154, -0.045203883200883865, 0.054873038083314896, 0.027752401307225227, -0.001198409590870142, 0.02256721258163452, 0.02341391146183014, -0.001256659161299467, -0.043507907539606094, -0.0064508020877838135, 0.03672553226351738, 0.012656796723604202, -0.032651737332344055, -0.006199170835316181, -0.006341501139104366, 0.000752806372474879, 0.00004035075835417956, 0.01730901375412941, 0.012118788436055183, -0.03778204694390297, -0.004714380484074354, -0.034787386655807495, 0.07121627032756805, -0.02424050308763981, 0.03927561268210411, 0.023952428251504898, -0.015966610983014107, 0.005371201783418655, -0.010910315439105034, 0.05523363873362541, 0.008655249141156673, 0.003369363024830818, -0.010642356239259243, -0.014331966638565063, -0.036047980189323425, -0.037323325872421265, 0.007986674085259438, -0.014491020701825619, 0.009801390580832958, -0.04500507935881615, -0.010738520883023739, 0.022684352472424507, 0.05357930436730385, 0.009346495382487774, -0.011569034308195114, -0.030383117496967316, 0.03581855446100235, -0.005523867439478636, -0.02340589463710785, -0.03311321511864662, 0.006981044076383114, -0.021390030160546303, 0.01709652878344059, -0.007150705903768539, 0.09818941354751587, 0.02270616590976715, 0.005004317965358496, -0.008422628976404667, 0.02046746015548706, -0.008086740970611572, -0.012740567326545715, 0.015534400939941406, -0.006407158449292183, -0.006181691307574511, 0.01056896522641182, 0.020079178735613823, -0.011147052980959415, 0.004240765236318111, -0.02098650299012661, -0.06427538394927979, -0.01817432790994644, -0.018665779381990433, -0.03540904074907303, 0.015861112624406815, 0.0002000692766159773, -0.007617106195539236, -0.03459357097744942, -0.01667751744389534, -0.01748843304812908, -0.01921217143535614, -0.040281400084495544, -0.05407290160655975, -0.017693523317575455, 0.007478880230337381, -0.035090938210487366, -0.018199291080236435, 0.04388026148080826, 0.003108485834673047, 0.052302148193120956, -0.03771151974797249, 0.033823613077402115, -0.01138457003980875, 0.05034468695521355, -0.02985498122870922, -0.041324637830257416, 0.030933275818824768, -0.029525501653552055, -0.07414893060922623, 0.01696763187646866, -0.0011743631912395358, 0.037159036844968796, -0.0026615464594215155, 0.023229332640767097, -0.004902927204966545, 0.0900188684463501, 0.0031836675480008125, 0.04762396588921547, -0.023773420602083206, 0.006166671868413687, 0.03509002923965454, 0.01666204445064068, 0.013286348432302475, 0.0025470273103564978, 0.006334357429295778, -0.016277235001325607, 0.060891043394804, -0.009266124106943607, -0.010244657285511494, 0.017257869243621826, -0.012084639631211758, 0.007563419174402952, -0.0010111243464052677, 0.008399732410907745, 0.02010420896112919, -0.0016491616843268275, -0.03324931114912033, 0.04392465949058533, -0.0020965305157005787, 0.01418179739266634, -0.07468874752521515, -0.012291100807487965, -0.01881897822022438, 0.0096965990960598, 0.029022129252552986, -0.052176930010318756, -0.016431676223874092, 0.038531746715307236, -0.041394591331481934, -0.007783418986946344, -0.007565789390355349, 0.0034864116460084915, -0.008008226752281189, 0.014050981029868126, -0.031632985919713974, -0.016099579632282257, 0.04483784735202789, 0.04306354746222496, 0.03739531710743904, 0.01513721700757742, 0.014793583191931248, -0.013808534480631351, -0.004506601952016354, 0.04052182286977768, 0.0025844809133559465, -0.030320104211568832, 0.028356565162539482, -0.0635949969291687, -0.0018083020113408566, 0.013990900479257107, -0.02942727506160736, -0.004740687552839518, 0.016528960317373276, 0.011062553152441978, 0.01803531125187874, 0.06368312239646912, 0.038256652653217316, -0.01679062284529209, -0.00801119115203619, -0.013961481861770153, -0.000022888618332217447, 0.011831812560558319, -0.006555186118930578, 0.018234336748719215, -0.026376206427812576, 0.02225520648062229, -0.05145520716905594, 0.019257672131061554, -0.011746280826628208, 0.008767404593527317, -0.019674357026815414, 0.056458793580532074, -0.01162075437605381, -0.07562367618083954, 0.017467567697167397, -0.0475856214761734, -0.030013184994459152, 0.04866202175617218, 0.03664333000779152, -0.05592558905482292, 0.007091728504747152, -0.027765510603785515, -0.018322020769119263, -0.006132551468908787, -0.002115659648552537, 0.01513300184160471, -0.060908254235982895, -0.016516532748937607, 0.006388534791767597, -0.05697387456893921, -0.040404871106147766, -0.012532161548733711, -0.027198048308491707, 0.04360444098711014, -0.01171068288385868, 0.004496338311582804, 0.03575511276721954, -0.016637220978736877, 0.02205173671245575, -0.11224883049726486, 0.05335155129432678, -0.006727658212184906, -0.02262810245156288, -0.046121980994939804, -0.012976479716598988, -0.0428982749581337, 0.038519199937582016, 0.065069779753685, 0.008462567813694477, -0.008885523304343224, 0.007257829420268536, 0.009422470815479755, 0.019057568162679672, -0.01318490132689476, 0.029597120359539986, -0.013028174638748169, -0.017297884449362755, 0.006215327885001898, 0.0010815594578161836, 0.011218315921723843, 0.007600467652082443, 0.018422599881887436, -0.025775570422410965, -0.01708546280860901, 0.022221241146326065, -0.0371464304625988, 0.022900830954313278, -0.004017050843685865, -0.021114950999617577, 0.059015072882175446, -0.010679207742214203, -0.010913543403148651, 0.08041767030954361, -0.007807672023773193, -0.06409643590450287, 0.010607881471514702, 0.014207253232598305, 0.027553623542189598, -0.024897756054997444, -0.008944228291511536, -0.015478599816560745, -0.05348047614097595, 0.008046183735132217, 0.0334952175617218, -0.002864309586584568, 0.016434196382761, 0.01628064177930355, 0.0021796957589685917, 0.039062924683094025, 0.0006639530183747411, 0.015537991188466549, -0.021299390122294426, -0.01709708943963051, 0.0020660727750509977, 0.007418408058583736, 0.033093005418777466, -0.0006902192835696042, 0.020213164389133453, 0.056438639760017395, -0.02670825459063053, 0.05800008028745651, -0.05285654589533806, 0.06649540364742279, -0.04021932929754257, 0.021306240931153297, -0.020822696387767792, -0.008782235905528069, 0.0032030721195042133, 0.01012110523879528, -0.0034717305097728968, 0.019608426839113235, -0.06691370159387589, 0.00283115659840405, -0.013616430573165417, 0.007551125250756741, -0.009474515914916992, 0.0470602847635746, -0.027737034484744072, 0.027426613494753838, -0.012338108383119106, 0.009523939341306686, 0.01071477122604847, -0.004110609646886587, 0.03355485200881958, 0.012445660308003426, -0.014791089110076427, -0.014392627403140068, 0.003889617742970586, -0.003300759242847562, -0.01318454835563898, -0.009259115904569626, -0.028207214549183846, 0.04546551778912544, 0.05206362158060074, -0.005782436579465866, -0.06428325921297073, 0.011466845870018005, -0.008200014010071754, 0.04776674509048462, -0.07806549221277237, -0.009154707193374634, -0.004484986886382103, 0.012866759672760963, 0.04467006027698517, -0.014195320196449757 ]
<p>I'm doing statistical analysis on a psychology study I ran a short while ago, and I'm starting to think that I've designed myself into a corner.</p> <p>In the study, we measured participants' pointing responses after traveling in a virtual environment. There were three factors, each nested within another:</p> <p>Physical rotation: 2 levels Visuals: 3 levels Turning angle: 10 levels</p> <p>Each participant was subjected to all variations of these treatments, so they ran 60 trials each. However, due to this large number of factors, we restricted the randomization of the order of treatments for each participant. In picture form, our design looks like this:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/zEITj.png" alt="Split-split-split plot design"></p> <p>M represents the physical rotation condition, V is the visual condition, and A is the turning angle condition. Each table represents one full session of 60 trials for a participant assigned to that group. The numbers in the cells represent the order in which participants assigned to that group perform trials. We ran 36 participants in total, and assigned each randomly to a group so that each of the four groups had 9 participants.</p> <p>This is a bit complex, so please let me know if I can explain something better. The groups represent the four different permutations of the 60 conditions we decided on, to make the best out of our limited number of participants.</p> <p>Group 1:</p> <ol> <li>M1|V1</li> <li>M2|V1</li> <li>M1|V2</li> <li>M2|V2</li> <li>M1|V3</li> <li>M2|V3</li> </ol> <p>Group 2:</p> <ol> <li>M1|V3</li> <li>M2|V3</li> <li>M1|V2</li> <li>M2|V2</li> <li>M1|V1</li> <li>M2|V1</li> </ol> <p>Group 3:</p> <ol> <li>M2|V1</li> <li>M1|V1</li> <li>M2|V2</li> <li>M1|V2</li> <li>M2|V3</li> <li>M1|V3</li> </ol> <p>Group 4:</p> <ol> <li>M2|V3</li> <li>M1|V3</li> <li>M2|V2</li> <li>M1|V2</li> <li>M2|V1</li> <li>M1|V1</li> </ol> <p>Within each of the six blocks, participants completed all ten turning angle conditions, in random order.</p> <p>So, we have one factor that is randomized (turning angle), one that is alternated (movement condition) and one that is ordered (visual condition). Each of these is nested within another, making for a split-split-split plot design.</p> <p>Now, what we are analyzing is how the pointing responses differ between conditions, and between participants. I have read everything I could find on split-plots, and even found some references to split-split-split plots, but I am still very unsure of how to actually crunch the numbers in R or SPSS.</p> <p>I would be very grateful for any advice, hints or references to useful reading material that could help me in this. Please ask if you have any questions, or if I can explain something more clearly.</p>
73,784
[ -0.045287154614925385, -0.007632732857018709, -0.001443024375475943, -0.04300418868660927, 0.04869116470217705, 0.021518990397453308, -0.021873056888580322, -0.016060402616858482, 0.010903826914727688, -0.007332849781960249, 0.023220481351017952, 0.027268148958683014, 0.013989219442009926, 0.03676668182015419, -0.011154339648783207, -0.00844687782227993, 0.024090735241770744, 0.015447903424501419, -0.024179335683584213, 0.012371583841741085, -0.00222141039557755, 0.009184060618281364, -0.01175696775317192, 0.0052042133174836636, -0.04827495664358139, 0.06124762445688248, 0.029475774616003036, -0.040583882480859756, -0.03061911091208458, 0.05539210885763168, -0.03941792622208595, -0.010367459617555141, -0.0039887623861432076, -0.0006527170189656317, 0.013561738654971123, -0.0033199077006429434, 0.011768481694161892, 0.010112700052559376, 0.008414155803620815, 0.004118234384804964, 0.004031091928482056, 0.069652259349823, -0.06020227074623108, 0.0420895554125309, -0.023940011858940125, 0.047466304153203964, -0.029851604253053665, 0.004932481795549393, 0.043323639780282974, -0.02451857551932335, 0.08324933797121048, -0.0063966019079089165, -0.007350130006670952, 0.011788844130933285, 0.024571584537625313, 0.0011376065667718649, 0.03216442093253136, 0.061105113476514816, 0.024787189438939095, -0.02366502955555916, -0.015362021513283253, -0.05780929699540138, 0.000777403125539422, -0.005255336407572031, 0.007166101597249508, -0.020366623997688293, 0.01754574663937092, 0.033031776547431946, 0.03574692830443382, -0.01696496270596981, 0.05268283933401108, 0.0018711038865149021, 0.04949521645903587, -0.026566211134195328, 0.01241334993392229, -0.01219965610653162, 0.013116779737174511, 0.019687043502926826, 0.018742846325039864, 0.008523577824234962, -0.001542922225780785, -0.0063258023001253605, 0.025952478870749474, 0.03051172010600567, -0.012590951286256313, -0.034796301275491714, 0.05673252418637276, -0.04600946977734566, 0.020269015803933144, 0.03402028977870941, 0.004381408449262381, -0.010562367737293243, 0.055453430861234665, 0.025609510019421577, -0.05776095390319824, 0.009348280727863312, 0.0019073212752118707, 0.030160406604409218, 0.0028798067942261696, 0.027181534096598625, -0.02601490542292595, -0.011485081166028976, -0.03399408236145973, 0.05933346226811409, -0.012817568145692348, 0.0048999241553246975, -0.006761241238564253, 0.026249978691339493, 0.007101586554199457, 0.014326389878988266, -0.011661417782306671, 0.015311192721128464, 0.01343278307467699, 0.026825932785868645, 0.010247733443975449, -0.014957519248127937, -0.03757338598370552, 0.018804995343089104, 0.06654499471187592, 0.0489376001060009, 0.058425914496183395, -0.058933235704898834, 0.013698931783437729, -0.053803373128175735, -0.03989168629050255, -0.006407728418707848, 0.024562157690525055, 0.011194112710654736, -0.04430532455444336, 0.015606128610670567, 0.03890964388847351, -0.0024877709802240133, 0.04786112904548645, -0.02509772777557373, 0.013762034475803375, 0.009349931962788105, -0.09762268513441086, -0.05251589044928551, 0.05170340836048126, 0.006042905151844025, -0.03244473785161972, -0.03530002757906914, -0.015954822301864624, 0.021608546376228333, 0.05291743949055672, -0.018986713141202927, 0.04118350148200989, -0.002247620141133666, 0.03737637773156166, 0.011202899739146233, -0.03392890468239784, 0.06183934956789017, -0.04504597187042236, -0.0027647924143821, 0.0001951352460309863, -0.09727250784635544, 0.031606338918209076, 0.003446810645982623, 0.03446304053068161, -0.015967387706041336, 0.02899850346148014, -0.04593733325600624, 0.022293858230113983, -0.014188055880367756, 0.012903178110718727, 0.0015802577836439013, 0.04243195429444313, -0.017993485555052757, 0.03474336862564087, 0.03824011981487274, 0.004891089163720608, 0.02145320549607277, -0.0005073915235698223, 0.01996161974966526, 0.028922591358423233, -0.027205921709537506, 0.029548199847340584, 0.005817028693854809, -0.011189737357199192, -0.0008307503303512931, -0.04116680845618248, -0.03497708588838577, -0.023662235587835312, 0.012237785384058952, 0.042180657386779785, 0.042868658900260925, -0.021289527416229248, 0.0120048513635993, 0.040234196931123734, -0.0330953374505043, -0.052432700991630554, -0.06986476480960846, 0.017617573961615562, 0.003787488443776965, -0.05616175755858421, -0.01234916877001524, -0.005984342657029629, -0.00021757540525868535, 0.015256335027515888, -0.05028318241238594, -0.05182093381881714, 0.012598046101629734, 0.04943908751010895, -0.011908731423318386, 0.0029363594949245453, 0.04559469223022461, 0.02564450353384018, -0.029904980212450027, 0.01217722799628973, -0.030649147927761078, -0.030678022652864456, -0.015361668542027473, -0.021510779857635498, 0.0500757098197937, 0.018408626317977905, 0.0030548658687621355, -0.002384987659752369, 0.06742223352193832, -0.03396083042025566, 0.03770799934864044, -0.02810559794306755, 0.0635002925992012, 0.026329344138503075, -0.03683263435959816, 0.034720052033662796, 0.044195275753736496, -0.010341543704271317, 0.02108340710401535, 0.022869905456900597, 0.004988322500139475, -0.03759022429585457, -0.03592037782073021, 0.043486759066581726, -0.015054102055728436, -0.011734455823898315, 0.025179224088788033, 0.042821962386369705, 0.006448542233556509, -0.021359849721193314, 0.019782960414886475, 0.003849244676530361, -0.022844092920422554, -0.018178142607212067, 0.060779113322496414, 0.07057036459445953, 0.020130503922700882, -0.01459001936018467, -0.005186893045902252, -0.004121196921914816, 0.024596070870757103, 0.0011483780108392239, 0.018816128373146057, 0.02295633964240551, 0.018781764432787895, -0.024920862168073654, 0.01121207233518362, 0.03580136597156525, -0.03241060674190521, -0.02552058733999729, 0.028122615069150925, 0.015655826777219772, -0.010503617115318775, -0.02205343171954155, -0.02481553889811039, 0.006168924737721682, 0.030716823413968086, -0.0023864193353801966, 0.008433843031525612, 0.03620770946145058, -0.0156992357224226, -0.0027136090211570263, 0.0033958288840949535, -0.03989348188042641, -0.0027418681420385838, 0.016686642542481422, 0.03150937706232071, 0.006435811053961515, 0.023583650588989258, -0.01332956925034523, 0.0028904315549880266, -0.00687063205987215, 0.04172157123684883, 0.0301626306027174, 0.02186405099928379, -0.05450332164764404, 0.007337962277233601, -0.02544049359858036, -0.03744460269808769, 0.03535449504852295, 0.015442537143826485, -0.04262012988328934, 0.02993367426097393, 0.010070910677313805, -0.0703144446015358, -0.06474776566028595, -0.05105412378907204, 0.034066230058670044, -0.028336061164736748, -0.033602602779865265, 0.0516694076359272, 0.055946771055459976, -0.03028278797864914, 0.014262986369431019, -0.021066924557089806, -0.02750893495976925, 0.021115880459547043, 0.004931565839797258, 0.010413337498903275, 0.017241220921278, -0.02644169330596924, 0.007443439215421677, 0.0084309633821249, -0.026566259562969208, -0.08632741868495941, -0.08343725651502609, -0.016566919162869453, -0.008505506440997124, 0.07466495782136917, -0.009027286432683468, -0.005860310047864914, 0.11421919614076614, 0.030585896223783493, -0.018734654411673546, -0.07070156186819077, -0.022373437881469727, -0.03034689463675022, -0.043701011687517166, 0.05933159217238426, 0.03324440121650696, -0.017544422298669815, 0.011995366774499416, -0.025610795244574547, 0.03090045414865017, 0.027831587940454483, -0.0054903579875826836, 0.0143031170591712, 0.029688408598303795, 0.04417634382843971, -0.03407973423600197, 0.013250825926661491, 0.024191422387957573, -0.025478223338723183, 0.020863154903054237, -0.00289825233630836, 0.0012594813015311956, -0.01404984574764967, -0.09347745031118393, 0.017174657434225082, -0.011847414076328278, 0.035942528396844864, -0.012827667407691479, 0.027135314419865608, 0.01892770268023014, -0.02007211372256279, -0.017619017511606216, 0.04284122213721275, 0.020277705043554306, -0.013614236377179623, 0.01408198568969965, 0.0647752583026886, 0.028548458591103554, -0.01201239600777626, -0.00972456019371748, -0.021383048966526985, 0.014068594202399254, 0.016760000959038734, -0.017129071056842804, -0.011802030727267265, -0.012416848912835121, 0.03693763166666031, 0.0092404093593359, 0.0018804400460794568, -0.04067343845963478, 0.00988853070884943, -0.04259730502963066, 0.01511231530457735, -0.056089166551828384, 0.027523614466190338, -0.017189236357808113, 0.033755362033843994, -0.01057413686066866, 0.016565872356295586, -0.05548626556992531, 0.02230735681951046, -0.07358912378549576, 0.007547753397375345, 0.01982733979821205, 0.018492354080080986, -0.0016311226645484567, -0.014989719726145267, 0.02748473733663559, -0.017623258754611015, -0.006492042914032936, 0.019941596314311028, 0.01827302575111389, -0.006613776087760925, -0.024388348683714867, -0.014339752495288849, 0.0006168276886455715, -0.016125481575727463, 0.023152943700551987, 0.007620708085596561, -0.00020425648835953325, 0.05400291457772255, 0.02526850625872612, -0.020912380889058113, 0.01642628386616707, -0.0029056405182927847, -0.030031021684408188, 0.026073170825839043, 0.03280549496412277, -0.01671438105404377, -0.0033472764771431684, -0.01781289465725422, 0.0030705565586686134, -0.03373987600207329, 0.024322113022208214, 0.04879120737314224, 0.007286485284566879, 0.010564420372247696, -0.009348348714411259, -0.004053809214383364, 0.03449122607707977, 0.017862021923065186, -0.004570668563246727, -0.027039898559451103, 0.026526521891355515, 0.024737557396292686, -0.05344272032380104, -0.012894024141132832, 0.03525691106915474, 0.013343438506126404, -0.024640105664730072, -0.060912471264600754, -0.019171157851815224, 0.03231088072061539, -0.0037650447338819504, 0.027573658153414726, -0.0025408349465578794, 0.01745857112109661, -0.027920790016651154, 0.05498231574892998, 0.013521535322070122, -0.058685123920440674, 0.07881368696689606, -0.04340982437133789, 0.03833586350083351, 0.04000923037528992, -0.0035787089727818966, 0.003358070272952318, 0.03447870537638664, 0.03847147524356842, 0.0042538633570075035, -0.02084273099899292, -0.06690186262130737, -0.024637781083583832, 0.060104839503765106, 0.06656841933727264, -0.0038753810804337263, 0.03207622468471527, -0.023600811138749123, -0.038289859890937805, -0.008888475596904755, -0.02841893769800663, 0.02864976041018963, -0.00772895198315382, 0.02172401361167431, -0.06318654865026474, -0.08010537177324295, -0.06377580016851425, -0.0010779757285490632, -0.010745418258011341, 0.011400358751416206, -0.004949143622070551, -0.01753501407802105, -0.03485787659883499, 0.006602464243769646, 0.019019715487957, 0.02136574313044548, -0.03750522807240486, -0.005486613139510155, 0.0010551908053457737, 0.003420749446377158, -0.05294252187013626, -0.07770372927188873, 0.042404964566230774, 0.015416651964187622, 0.02609579637646675, 0.05884933099150658, -0.0056937215849757195, 0.0008494638022966683, 0.0006300177192315459, -0.006135433446615934, 0.02830427885055542, 0.0053969188593328, 0.0008916344959288836, 0.055063843727111816, 0.03433844819664955, 0.011407528072595596, 0.03847900405526161, 0.00018376653315499425, -0.0014070363249629736, 0.006038611754775047, -0.0048075346276164055, 0.00945953093469143, 0.020065851509571075, -0.010662535205483437, -0.04579753056168556, -0.03444916754961014, -0.019607478752732277, 0.007626763079315424, -0.02811058610677719, 0.026060007512569427, -0.023060636594891548, -0.043346915394067764, -0.015310780145227909, -0.0027799969539046288, 0.01749693602323532, -0.013955112546682358, 0.020526861771941185, -0.02129444293677807, 0.027171209454536438, -0.003696420695632696, 0.03647617623209953, -0.04005975276231766, 0.02520679496228695, 0.05654917657375336, -0.05342136323451996, -0.03345560282468796, -0.03662912920117378, 0.005215858109295368, 0.005228027235716581, -0.05185488611459732, 0.04399790242314339, -0.029067818075418472, 0.017314894124865532, 0.030726894736289978, -0.009804247878491879, -0.031071651726961136, 0.044322606176137924, -0.06572931259870529, 0.02164413221180439, 0.00992561224848032, 0.004033868666738272, -0.01877932995557785, 0.020692408084869385, -0.04316631704568863, -0.008163543418049812, -0.02637280896306038, 0.005899771582335234, -0.03921274095773697, -0.02684909850358963, -0.04547200724482536, 0.006847678683698177, -0.06079185754060745, 0.007785863243043423, 0.0352405421435833, -0.023437120020389557, 0.049035776406526566, -0.005139568820595741, 0.0016576150665059686, 0.08961864560842514, 0.010659444145858288, -0.033441465348005295, 0.008556407876312733, -0.021821074187755585, 0.012005492113530636, -0.005983124487102032, 0.0018881261348724365, -0.03231361508369446, -0.007676370907574892, -0.029986055567860603, 0.054827310144901276, 0.016706785187125206, -0.008381212130188942, 0.0019136352930217981, 0.006443419493734837, -0.009561348706483841, -0.0013889591209590435, -0.054806094616651535, 0.0150114381685853, -0.02078779973089695, -0.0025534892920404673, -0.0025220359675586224, 0.056492071598768234, -0.006685324944555759, -0.023185385391116142, 0.009520970284938812, 0.015579150058329105, -0.02620609663426876, -0.0038556987419724464, 0.06510550528764725, 0.009726407006382942, -0.0009818912949413061, -0.006661493796855211, 0.0021410442423075438, 0.05200096219778061, 0.013065462931990623, -0.01474690716713667, 0.00866642501205206, -0.000708268373273313, -0.024315867573022842, 0.00925061758607626, -0.03430662676692009, 0.010003643110394478, 0.05092791095376015, 0.03594716265797615, 0.05401476100087166, 0.0700240507721901, -0.02141428366303444, -0.0009907825151458383, -0.025699662044644356, 0.03800225257873535, -0.02501736953854561, 0.004956784192472696, 0.07774239778518677, 0.0020268650259822607, -0.01567104086279869, 0.03160931169986725, 0.0171404667198658, -0.008791869506239891, 0.03006397932767868, 0.05123293772339821, -0.01921178586781025, 0.017950542271137238, -0.046591341495513916, -0.053132932633161545, 0.009951435960829258, -0.07256226241588593, 0.033636920154094696, -0.04639838635921478, -0.01694047823548317, 0.011786581948399544, 0.07181456685066223, 0.007289535365998745, -0.04170559346675873, -0.026286045089364052, -0.06607460975646973, 0.027745697647333145, 0.00967536773532629, -0.02361195534467697, -0.014656361192464828, -0.0024804293643683195, 0.04770142212510109, -0.030918706208467484, -0.007343756966292858, -0.04466267302632332, -0.05573943629860878, -0.024673186242580414, -0.012540635652840137, -0.042279668152332306, 0.03805208206176758, -0.016471534967422485, -0.03339122235774994, 0.021638812497258186, -0.04768512025475502, -0.00493641896173358, 0.016134073957800865, 0.027756452560424805, -0.01517742034047842, 0.03287384659051895, 0.011485854163765907, 0.03230056166648865, -0.028066212311387062, -0.024690544232726097, 0.15160489082336426, 0.024193784222006798, -0.0005737525643780828, -0.04379299655556679, 0.053515754640102386, 0.019732970744371414, 0.0035019705537706614, 0.006139914505183697, 0.0365539975464344, -0.0014412195887416601, -0.007279128301888704, 0.011239511892199516, 0.03397992625832558, 0.015890013426542282, 0.001827411586418748, 0.04350629448890686, -0.020067142322659492, -0.0421612486243248, -0.004909595940262079, -0.030077418312430382, 0.014900445006787777, 0.00040088561945594847, -0.05516394227743149, 0.0012331963516771793, 0.009890291839838028, 0.02088063955307007, 0.005266175139695406, -0.039964284747838974, 0.03088168054819107, -0.006682346574962139, -0.010556625202298164, 0.043119240552186966, 0.01691620610654354, -0.01407333929091692, -0.03039122000336647, -0.008112596347928047, 0.030724598094820976, -0.06765265762805939, 0.02702309750020504, 0.05059000104665756, -0.019966108724474907, -0.020913200452923775, -0.02869926579296589, -0.025750750675797462, -0.01212624367326498, -0.03564002737402916, -0.03451366350054741, 0.03545977547764778, -0.015906939283013344, -0.043486256152391434, 0.005388180259615183, 0.004270491655915976, -0.016559747979044914, -0.052846379578113556, -0.00299306632950902, 0.01404519472271204, 0.04093829542398453, -0.017369844019412994, -0.024759238585829735, -0.01084392610937357, -0.006301153916865587, 0.01352660357952118, -0.019137125462293625, 0.01011382881551981, 0.015451743267476559, -0.043211326003074646, -0.04363638162612915, 0.030141863971948624, 0.01567741483449936, 0.0027648042887449265, 0.019266795367002487, -0.011608908884227276, -0.013924437575042248, -0.020698517560958862, 0.009773398749530315, 0.022107034921646118, 0.010804339312016964, 0.0012304544216021895, -0.02615947090089321, -0.006219492293894291, -0.004569429904222488, -0.037167228758335114, -0.030135590583086014, -0.040283143520355225, -0.01808241754770279, 0.002660664962604642, 0.0038241688162088394, 0.04966124892234802, -0.00840192660689354, -0.010978379286825657, 0.001959976041689515, 0.0640401840209961, -0.009071719832718372, -0.03509249910712242, -0.055133190006017685, 0.013982774689793587, 0.003318434813991189, -0.009037304669618607, -0.026767916977405548, 0.08488503098487854, -0.007615980226546526, -0.027487827464938164, 0.022491488605737686, 0.022443410009145737, 0.022565703839063644, -0.020719733089208603, 0.050739262253046036, -0.055553779006004333, 0.01760086975991726, 0.010417435318231583, -0.022124001756310463, -0.029801929369568825, 0.008389797993004322, -0.014507812447845936, 0.013085531070828438, -0.014287483878433704, -0.03222997114062309, 0.02529264986515045, -0.012548020109534264, 0.0038268808275461197, 0.03630940243601799, 0.0008787370170466602, 0.01665082760155201, -0.020818928256630898, -0.017038457095623016, -0.03459959849715233, 0.02760479599237442, -0.0224361103028059, 0.021149909123778343, 0.02044130675494671, 0.026095939800143242, 0.005674922838807106, 0.00502207363024354, 0.025512821972370148, -0.01320839487016201, -0.014140431769192219, 0.0013930096756666899, 0.025469336658716202, 0.017865637317299843, -0.028972212225198746, 0.014573675580322742, -0.03188908472657204, -0.031756021082401276, 0.009617368690669537, -0.029355626553297043, 0.025152340531349182, 0.019208373501896858, 0.010023187845945358, 0.002235551830381155, 0.05438370630145073, -0.025643665343523026, -0.040577180683612823, -0.018422270193696022, 0.01498782355338335, 0.028362048789858818, -0.0242904182523489, 0.028885969892144203, -0.0031416406854987144, -0.0072027454152703285, -0.0064916228875517845, 0.026902716606855392, -0.022561494261026382, -0.030414629727602005, -0.02987052872776985, -0.022975992411375046, 0.006837916560471058, -0.029935341328382492, 0.0014929273165762424, 0.027840379625558853, 0.02882971800863743, -0.029651621356606483, 0.03365210443735123, 0.013066928833723068, 0.035038311034440994, -0.06393231451511383, -0.024790890514850616, 0.021980537101626396, 0.017324209213256836, 0.05096586421132088, -0.06657086312770844, -0.00674884719774127, 0.041284896433353424, -0.06811779737472534, 0.021006368100643158, 0.024260876700282097, -0.0014674455160275102, -0.05493030324578285, 0.009555657394230366, -0.012830251827836037, 0.028777746483683586, -0.00575793394818902, 0.0013608487788587809, 0.03669369965791702, 0.02576647698879242, -0.021822122856974602, -0.023957017809152603, 0.02404194325208664, 0.04422678425908089, 0.002474709879606962, -0.015818772837519646, 0.040798526257276535, -0.03337507322430611, -0.039704155176877975, 0.011959432624280453, -0.01631730981171131, 0.02316324971616268, 0.012052114121615887, 0.03650504723191261, -0.003540097502991557, 0.059820517897605896, -0.002927349181845784, 0.011006581597030163, -0.013756711035966873, -0.01981961354613304, 0.006686069071292877, 0.01996634341776371, 0.013600483536720276, 0.026545438915491104, 0.03487974777817726, 0.004142961464822292, -0.024170538410544395, 0.004223128780722618, -0.0055629778653383255, -0.028185350820422173, 0.018284577876329422, -0.008188451640307903, 0.0027059786953032017, -0.03845539689064026, 0.00607667863368988, -0.030681703239679337, 0.01195468008518219, 0.02452111802995205, -0.021119890734553337, -0.013751975260674953, 0.01992889493703842, -0.02813921496272087, -0.02059703879058361, -0.026941297575831413, -0.011546814814209938, -0.041362449526786804, -0.06512247771024704, 0.014691798947751522, 0.0016143657267093658, -0.016159575432538986, -0.019121762365102768, 0.000017357971955789253, 0.005102940835058689, 0.014979098923504353, 0.002912206342443824, 0.038236103951931, 0.004332015756517649, -0.01835040934383869, -0.02436879090964794, -0.08707355707883835, 0.09255878627300262, -0.00416767131537199, -0.011618182063102722, -0.04999905452132225, -0.04822339862585068, -0.027634764090180397, 0.027940064668655396, 0.032712146639823914, 0.032927338033914566, 0.01467195712029934, -0.0059821391478180885, 0.014266148209571838, 0.004797771573066711, -0.04026838392019272, 0.05301999673247337, -0.019365135580301285, 0.019815783947706223, -0.010673699900507927, 0.009308584034442902, 0.005055056419223547, -0.032312918454408646, 0.0242058876901865, -0.03564973920583725, -0.008140899240970612, -0.008223784156143665, 0.011141017079353333, 0.009878017008304596, -0.01934569887816906, -0.013486986979842186, 0.003731959033757448, 0.011733352206647396, -0.012240338139235973, 0.016100341454148293, -0.015732500702142715, -0.04394352436065674, 0.013622225262224674, -0.008841083385050297, -0.036817725747823715, -0.011605769395828247, 0.009264693595468998, 0.02502056211233139, -0.04577401652932167, 0.021487347781658173, -0.005046579521149397, -0.01734219305217266, -0.010138226673007011, 0.04885515570640564, 0.061882928013801575, 0.008950050920248032, -0.03838834911584854, 0.02310236170887947, -0.021251894533634186, -0.06096009537577629, 0.016795942559838295, 0.028169676661491394, 0.01623319275677204, 0.024291738867759705, -0.02910955809056759, 0.025826478376984596, 0.015058737248182297, 0.06334161013364792, 0.015633950009942055, 0.029577789828181267, 0.013091402128338814, 0.055457524955272675, 0.03878029063344002, -0.0429619662463665, -0.022303637117147446, -0.03076375648379326, 0.04360753670334816, 0.04592124745249748, -0.03859769552946091, -0.007545868866145611, -0.033395916223526, -0.016939815133810043, -0.05648002028465271, 0.02999740093946457, 0.04520275816321373, 0.029468320310115814, -0.030046191066503525, 0.005625303369015455, -0.04867399483919144, -0.02910350263118744, 0.03833256661891937, 0.0007123656687326729, 0.05503572151064873, 0.023375438526272774, -0.031838931143283844, 0.028558073565363884, -0.018717395141720772, -0.015624195337295532, -0.048558034002780914, 0.01512435544282198, 0.011853748932480812, 0.013120501302182674, -0.022286202758550644, -0.029640426859259605, 0.01250733993947506, 0.03484596684575081, -0.024176273494958878, -0.033292632550001144, -0.03722437098622322, 0.0523420125246048, 0.012506679631769657, 0.020231302827596664 ]
<p>Yesterday i read this blog post <a href="http://www.petrkeil.com/?p=393" rel="nofollow">Predictors, responses and residuals: What really needs to be normally distributed? </a> and I wonder what do you think about it. Personally I totally agree with the author about the fact that sometimes people even discard to build or evaluate models without log-transformations or things like that, just because of they have variables not normal distributed (incomes or other measures that are usually not gaussian), sometimes getting wrong about the predictor or outcome hypothesis for the models.. </p> <p>I think this is an relevant point nowadays when the "machine-learning trend" seems to be way less restrictive than "classic statistics" and therefore leaves classic models a little bit aside while many times they produce equal or even better results..</p>
47,833
[ -0.025828681886196136, 0.0070078130811452866, -0.0008362411172129214, -0.03253183141350746, 0.043871209025382996, -0.01718909479677677, -0.01710098795592785, -0.008767069317400455, 0.035325340926647186, -0.034039661288261414, -0.005659589543938637, -0.007536708377301693, 0.04026849940419197, 0.015775006264448166, 0.02876286767423153, 0.003325934987515211, -0.016236063092947006, 0.003600005991756916, -0.006791300605982542, -0.01842307858169079, -0.018392672762274742, 0.04622029885649681, 0.008688917383551598, -0.008982125669717789, -0.02296837605535984, 0.052508071064949036, 0.017528261989355087, -0.005345860030502081, 0.00786405149847269, 0.041758742183446884, -0.0219533983618021, -0.001341088442131877, -0.0036932816728949547, 0.06322797387838364, -0.008503671735525131, 0.018289826810359955, -0.020428411662578583, -0.025176439434289932, 0.024546939879655838, 0.05309414491057396, 0.0018005291931331158, -0.03306099772453308, 0.025284355506300926, -0.00202996120788157, -0.01856052875518799, 0.024757783859968185, -0.02855776995420456, -0.042334116995334625, 0.035289403051137924, -0.06356821954250336, 0.06843961030244827, 0.010173331014811993, 0.023121025413274765, 0.02002374455332756, -0.01698147878050804, -0.02911718189716339, 0.06717263907194138, 0.04776555672287941, -0.006688293535262346, -0.08318258076906204, -0.006269221194088459, -0.002794295782223344, -0.003923223819583654, 0.013194646686315536, -0.009473305195569992, 0.0023162479046732187, 0.003839004086330533, -0.026351409032940865, 0.07427705824375153, -0.025308504700660706, 0.022753704339265823, 0.04047320783138275, 0.033246200531721115, 0.030178438872098923, 0.019509300589561462, 0.00931698177009821, 0.013922459445893764, -0.007862147875130177, 0.014311126433312893, 0.03777040168642998, 0.029744628816843033, -0.006976810283958912, -0.005298107862472534, 0.0679301917552948, 0.005839276127517223, -0.0012438480043783784, 0.0497572235763073, -0.04578786715865135, 0.02846265770494938, 0.041868891566991806, 0.01621662825345993, 0.01278508361428976, 0.03909982368350029, -0.024430466815829277, -0.062240730971097946, 0.04007944092154503, -0.0011598356068134308, 0.02154654823243618, 0.019743021577596664, 0.006916445214301348, -0.026597831398248672, -0.029434243217110634, 0.0013687009923160076, 0.03462362289428711, -0.04184586554765701, -0.012121366336941719, -0.008197003044188023, 0.005033372435718775, -0.004226210992783308, -0.05175109580159187, -0.0521477647125721, 0.0076059503480792046, 0.013563171029090881, 0.011164102703332901, 0.03329990431666374, -0.000822458416223526, -0.027105748653411865, -0.017696252092719078, 0.057812515646219254, 0.0754552111029625, -0.00892853457480669, -0.008317944593727589, 0.02436203509569168, -0.010632879100739956, -0.0346389003098011, 0.013308849185705185, 0.07104949653148651, -0.014521093107759953, -0.0445810928940773, 0.042432766407728195, -0.0031203872058540583, -0.024223778396844864, 0.016774116083979607, 0.025277338922023773, 0.03331758826971054, -0.00844504777342081, -0.07346557080745697, -0.04589755833148956, 0.007244716864079237, 0.0024297735653817654, -0.011141746304929256, -0.058150745928287506, -0.03914029896259308, -0.0025567645207047462, 0.016215156763792038, 0.016445502638816833, 0.05810069292783737, 0.001689997734501958, 0.03604065254330635, -0.009611214511096478, -0.03229404240846634, -0.007212847471237183, 0.00663414504379034, -0.04106907919049263, -0.03871448338031769, -0.06142434477806091, 0.012874387204647064, 0.016554856672883034, -0.01257788110524416, 0.017524942755699158, 0.002316933125257492, -0.010370000265538692, -0.038375165313482285, -0.009388338774442673, 0.00025802452000789344, -0.04194488748908043, 0.0644414871931076, 0.0023755556903779507, 0.07221166789531708, 0.028500860556960106, -0.0009290787857025862, 0.004592910408973694, 0.011692114174365997, 0.05860697478055954, 0.02120976150035858, -0.0041158078238368034, 0.005289110355079174, -0.03346383944153786, 0.0429779514670372, 0.0011333912843838334, -0.028088049963116646, 0.005393293220549822, -0.002358450321480632, -0.012868461199104786, -0.006220477633178234, 0.04460814595222473, 0.002508552046492696, -0.02100026048719883, 0.06009393930435181, -0.05360683426260948, -0.039072901010513306, -0.04324236884713173, 0.007210070732980967, -0.013924445025622845, 0.027755007147789, 0.025451958179473877, -0.00421508913859725, 0.021271446719765663, 0.003126176306977868, -0.006893528159707785, 0.0045769610442221165, -0.002670563291758299, 0.02479228936135769, -0.04441440477967262, 0.024269044399261475, 0.022282201796770096, 0.0015888301422819495, -0.04008815437555313, 0.011741588823497295, -0.04214164987206459, -0.07489632815122604, 0.030658304691314697, -0.03370681032538414, 0.021284285932779312, 0.00456256465986371, -0.0348227396607399, 0.043515048921108246, -0.030767496675252914, -0.05504165589809418, 0.016760921105742455, -0.07327039539813995, 0.05530557781457901, 0.028672324493527412, -0.014853672124445438, -0.048055313527584076, 0.012979622930288315, 0.010608052834868431, 0.007810419891029596, -0.02755581960082054, 0.004623252898454666, -0.043465908616781235, -0.02977898344397545, 0.04385232552886009, 0.047624483704566956, -0.03479747101664543, 0.021163465455174446, 0.046030472964048386, 0.0422338992357254, 0.024687130004167557, 0.008214188739657402, -0.010958835482597351, -0.021847933530807495, 0.006443996448069811, 0.006444113794714212, -0.005320040509104729, 0.004903153050690889, 0.013475976884365082, 0.0039142342284321785, 0.028062928467988968, -0.008326931856572628, -0.017898010089993477, 0.04269702360033989, 0.015907390043139458, -0.00652289018034935, -0.023074114695191383, -0.003899454837664962, 0.03582509607076645, -0.03157234564423561, 0.015506195835769176, 0.030689850449562073, 0.021691609174013138, -0.003142547095194459, -0.029040973633527756, -0.011583462357521057, 0.01863936334848404, 0.011348679661750793, -0.03565565496683121, 0.006968688685446978, 0.03448907285928726, -0.03079792484641075, -0.002182312309741974, -0.035644758492708206, -0.04025569558143616, -0.043873101472854614, 0.02231396548449993, 0.00002750514067884069, -0.009260707534849644, 0.0057443189434707165, 0.014457833021879196, -0.03473902493715286, 0.027968183159828186, 0.017727680504322052, -0.007889592088758945, 0.0272894948720932, -0.039956945925951004, 0.0011670972453430295, -0.05241504684090614, -0.018322715535759926, 0.041311126202344894, -0.010377421975135803, 0.016728626564145088, -0.018508313223719597, -0.020236827433109283, -0.07079432904720306, -0.030896563082933426, -0.0138351209461689, -0.0006795660592615604, -0.0195267703384161, -0.054289329797029495, 0.04101148992776871, -0.028254175558686256, -0.04274042323231697, 0.0011404817923903465, -0.03169633448123932, -0.06681153923273087, -0.03761812672019005, -0.018402021378278732, 0.009173186495900154, -0.010270114988088608, 0.03789989650249481, 0.03541028872132301, -0.0517859049141407, -0.0021800482645630836, -0.0726415142416954, -0.05230190232396126, 0.004978316370397806, -0.026446353644132614, 0.06478236615657806, 0.014792973175644875, -0.005885515362024307, 0.0734395757317543, 0.03288673609495163, -0.01809069700539112, -0.006274456158280373, -0.0179034024477005, -0.0018708360148593783, -0.03579872474074364, 0.018231552094221115, 0.033261433243751526, -0.0013668776955455542, 0.02802455611526966, -0.050237588584423065, 0.028379466384649277, 0.01167986448854208, 0.020855087786912918, -0.02237413451075554, 0.020794251933693886, 0.016752831637859344, -0.009027907624840736, 0.010206843726336956, 0.025733688846230507, -0.011511581018567085, 0.003060300135985017, 0.027949539944529533, 0.03452661260962486, 0.012476779520511627, -0.05284063518047333, 0.046794552356004715, -0.030935300514101982, 0.03595719113945961, -0.00180184340570122, -0.028788845986127853, 0.016528617590665817, -0.04657301679253578, -0.008519730530679226, 0.02989073283970356, -0.0010844424832612276, -0.016549093648791313, 0.014978614635765553, 0.03595348075032234, 0.04793784022331238, 0.018055053427815437, -0.006927941460162401, -0.0028351806104183197, -0.022429339587688446, 0.03755127638578415, 0.0029799395706504583, 0.022554805502295494, 0.0572202131152153, 0.014099879190325737, -0.007326464634388685, -0.032473016530275345, -0.05971694365143776, 0.00524175027385354, -0.06369774043560028, 0.032858170568943024, 0.00801136065274477, 0.0647534430027008, 0.009489885531365871, -0.015985459089279175, 0.004596584476530552, -0.02628364972770214, 0.004636991769075394, 0.0013010215479880571, -0.06161411106586456, 0.006366126239299774, -0.01653304696083069, -0.0075315916910767555, 0.007766209077090025, -0.03605029359459877, 0.03333120420575142, 0.007776414509862661, -0.011318929493427277, -0.03527955338358879, 0.015013433992862701, -0.051344554871320724, -0.010707263834774494, -0.024780279025435448, -0.08256717026233673, 0.004766420461237431, -0.04342623054981232, 0.017801975831389427, 0.00859013944864273, -0.00783078745007515, 0.04858895763754845, -0.004688631277531385, -0.03766598179936409, -0.016144687309861183, 0.029706666246056557, 0.01160388346761465, 0.05413869023323059, 0.019345136359333992, 0.005056108348071575, -0.06758593767881393, 0.047253888100385666, -0.001999456435441971, 0.044996168464422226, 0.0022698736283928156, -0.015390787273645401, 0.004086881875991821, -0.04052281007170677, -0.04911182448267937, 0.04009998217225075, 0.016101378947496414, 0.02618180215358734, 0.002696562558412552, 0.06718575209379196, 0.013695460744202137, -0.035758864134550095, 0.006407515611499548, 0.05985432118177414, -0.017305554822087288, -0.008566799573600292, -0.026957398280501366, -0.028575481846928596, 0.0007854727446101606, -0.019634835422039032, 0.049428973346948624, -0.00890821497887373, -0.0021886243484914303, -0.024669857695698738, 0.03400161862373352, -0.026879403740167618, 0.009246024303138256, -0.03894632309675217, 0.048268113285303116, 0.03655991703271866, 0.023214610293507576, -0.020011480897665024, 0.02254004403948784, 0.05126720294356346, 0.052672818303108215, 0.04394600912928581, -0.0031216877978295088, -0.08335322141647339, 0.03919204697012901, 0.04890833795070648, 0.008458966389298439, -0.021481750532984734, -0.02556481398642063, -0.021218299865722656, 0.013159622438251972, 0.024634938687086105, -0.025292180478572845, 0.020809443667531013, 0.010622575879096985, 0.01569278910756111, -0.026338310912251472, -0.01159697212278843, -0.049615271389484406, 0.004952339455485344, 0.01166433934122324, 0.040627457201480865, 0.02126806601881981, -0.040679436177015305, -0.07014808058738708, 0.011879241093993187, -0.03097362443804741, 0.054015520960092545, -0.001247542561031878, -0.03638383001089096, 0.03155433014035225, 0.041462674736976624, -0.007000441662967205, -0.07770111411809921, 0.009565846063196659, -0.014271464198827744, -0.013444384559988976, 0.05351748317480087, 0.004701841156929731, -0.06575348973274231, -0.0014851975720375776, 0.03677752614021301, -0.02969164215028286, -0.003444142872467637, -0.02961374633014202, 0.0065841530449688435, 0.0033928898628801107, 0.019074315205216408, 0.05299507826566696, 0.029056694358587265, 0.0024750474840402603, -0.02118479646742344, -0.035275768488645554, 0.005352361127734184, -0.04677753522992134, -0.012334008701145649, -0.04183149337768555, -0.030049551278352737, 0.0007374142878688872, 0.014777186326682568, 0.019710000604391098, 0.029274631291627884, -0.024652941152453423, -0.04745107144117355, 0.00424980791285634, 0.0013991885352879763, -0.017042269930243492, -0.004461520817130804, 0.004090490285307169, 0.024876506999135017, -0.03362857922911644, 0.006049254443496466, 0.01578165777027607, 0.008556269109249115, 0.005314772482961416, 0.01421886682510376, -0.008458469063043594, -0.01748838648200035, -0.014830273576080799, -0.007537271361798048, 0.018277859315276146, -0.004321595188230276, 0.02818555012345314, 0.041110847145318985, 0.06422194093465805, -0.0017450569430366158, -0.0356234610080719, 0.03083280846476555, 0.000678079726640135, 0.02581607550382614, 0.027240509167313576, -0.028942234814167023, 0.030186055228114128, -0.043485015630722046, 0.0028619091026484966, -0.06147576496005058, -0.013368762098252773, 0.007507459260523319, -0.03772969916462898, -0.029805732890963554, -0.036217812448740005, 0.015818631276488304, -0.04103316739201546, -0.03846362978219986, 0.03057551197707653, 0.06012176722288132, -0.013486492447555065, -0.0017930201720446348, 0.018637023866176605, 0.035947639495134354, 0.07772401720285416, -0.018468230962753296, -0.00906289555132389, 0.04053834453225136, -0.025401605293154716, 0.012448037974536419, 0.0003826284664683044, 0.0390973836183548, -0.04087376967072487, 0.01858147233724594, -0.03164186328649521, -0.034066181629896164, 0.03880210220813751, -0.009490245021879673, -0.009053213521838188, 0.037509314715862274, -0.029834730550646782, 0.0035622476134449244, -0.0006729013985022902, 0.02851165272295475, -0.0028342793229967356, 0.0018343054689466953, -0.01704282872378826, 0.007372550666332245, 0.0022666556760668755, 0.0029502571560442448, 0.061559323221445084, 0.007971168495714664, 0.008916896767914295, 0.05263647064566612, 0.024180065840482712, 0.0069582113064825535, -0.004453759640455246, -0.013804936781525612, -0.04256894439458847, 0.06164166331291199, 0.02826656401157379, 0.021590188145637512, 0.004698744043707848, -0.0035280475858598948, -0.03640230372548103, -0.07072671502828598, -0.025785451754927635, -0.02117721550166607, 0.03170901909470558, -0.019585764035582542, 0.06042172387242317, 0.01035481970757246, -0.008807129226624966, -0.03311493992805481, -0.06991082429885864, -0.007352944929152727, -0.03332684934139252, -0.023515276610851288, 0.03558693826198578, -0.018431799486279488, 0.02093948796391487, 0.014384717680513859, 0.009537731297314167, 0.036973170936107635, 0.020897943526506424, -0.007597091142088175, 0.007802402134984732, 0.027571341022849083, -0.001079242560081184, -0.030778395012021065, 0.06121499836444855, -0.05015898868441582, -0.010006980039179325, 0.014661379158496857, 0.021673962473869324, 0.0399005226790905, 0.018149927258491516, 0.015455720014870167, -0.037014368921518326, -0.01751994714140892, -0.024217164143919945, 0.010521844029426575, 0.02393409237265587, -0.031099215149879456, -0.0005417342763394117, -0.034480780363082886, 0.010724385268986225, 0.0008130021742545068, 0.0448206402361393, -0.0069178249686956406, -0.09738604724407196, -0.03032786399126053, -0.021037772297859192, 0.013987119309604168, 0.036951806396245956, 0.000025747356630745344, -0.01821310631930828, 0.022064341232180595, -0.06275350600481033, 0.010449717752635479, 0.026112373918294907, 0.0001393821876263246, -0.015840549021959305, 0.06551357358694077, -0.0054890732280910015, -0.015297530218958855, -0.014749117195606232, -0.010019348002970219, 0.13454777002334595, 0.06104492023587227, 0.04368919879198074, -0.053324420005083084, 0.03022812306880951, -0.02629948779940605, 0.010565346106886864, 0.030806289985775948, -0.020434347912669182, -0.010990753769874573, 0.009129288606345654, 0.03530208021402359, 0.005665943026542664, 0.01716785319149494, 0.004323042929172516, 0.051790330559015274, -0.028542164713144302, -0.03498929738998413, 0.016235660761594772, 0.01363561861217022, 0.02468438632786274, -0.013631326146423817, -0.012294895015656948, 0.02461056597530842, -0.015504774637520313, -0.007894800044596195, 0.04457389935851097, 0.0011748973047360778, -0.015804672613739967, -0.013552851974964142, -0.021166697144508362, -0.001209449372254312, 0.044527072459459305, 0.028420595452189445, -0.011720417998731136, -0.0009311576141044497, 0.013120943680405617, -0.014773204922676086, 0.0026103425770998, 0.01815185695886612, -0.01133564580231905, -0.02432580105960369, 0.05152951180934906, -0.02049524150788784, -0.05402129516005516, -0.01207041833549738, -0.04063183814287186, 0.0452517494559288, -0.03418736532330513, 0.015464616008102894, 0.0014847194543108344, -0.01768544875085354, 0.013036028482019901, -0.02472721040248871, -0.014592042192816734, 0.03723302111029625, 0.02429276704788208, -0.010024476796388626, -0.009623924270272255, 0.01338481530547142, 0.024178309366106987, 0.011459617875516415, 0.06312250345945358, -0.014946060255169868, -0.03652733191847801, -0.022480813786387444, -0.01072254590690136, 0.0680985078215599, 0.0009122668416239321, 0.005460909567773342, -0.014824219979345798, -0.012106649577617645, -0.049503058195114136, 0.0021755180787295103, -0.005020590033382177, -0.0023648447822779417, 0.01566304825246334, -0.015313223004341125, 0.013948250561952591, -0.06125633046030998, -0.04080890864133835, 0.028152834624052048, -0.03182876855134964, 0.06420500576496124, -0.06675264239311218, -0.010513607412576675, 0.005777022801339626, 0.062415897846221924, 0.02632332593202591, -0.0027392429765313864, 0.019372988492250443, 0.03428569808602333, 0.017355160787701607, -0.05120446905493736, 0.011177655309438705, 0.011522018350660801, -0.03770560398697853, -0.01543433591723442, -0.027371063828468323, 0.056605540215969086, 0.005258014425635338, 0.030717849731445312, -0.048705022782087326, 0.05079459026455879, 0.0048849438317120075, 0.02433118410408497, -0.017650797963142395, -0.04351253807544708, 0.012539605610072613, 0.016660545021295547, 0.01951449364423752, -0.005658847279846668, -0.025121401995420456, -0.025135044008493423, -0.031848397105932236, 0.008919782936573029, -0.017355429008603096, -0.0037751777563244104, -0.01059191208332777, 0.01269884966313839, 0.05014527961611748, -0.03471498191356659, -0.025232158601284027, -0.027401525527238846, -0.011098679155111313, 0.007351893000304699, -0.03953781723976135, -0.01307058148086071, -0.01644180528819561, 0.004571470431983471, 0.030780812725424767, 0.02943485975265503, 0.034337714314460754, 0.014277088455855846, -0.03400028496980667, -0.012419987469911575, -0.009124824777245522, 0.026967188343405724, -0.06412510573863983, -0.03241555392742157, 0.028288012370467186, 0.014271104708313942, -0.033036354929208755, 0.012380365282297134, -0.011569325812160969, 0.009361542761325836, -0.02202019654214382, 0.013134622015058994, -0.04017873480916023, 0.040836554020643234, -0.03825138136744499, 0.022732092067599297, -0.0169279295951128, -0.005907341372221708, 0.00275101768784225, 0.008354122750461102, 0.022127529606223106, -0.009917418472468853, -0.015693454071879387, 0.02832217328250408, 0.04608742892742157, 0.0327894389629364, 0.02891465835273266, 0.026548033580183983, 0.004093866795301437, 0.022161921486258507, -0.010478021577000618, 0.017366847023367882, 0.015587205067276955, 0.0302871260792017, -0.016364380717277527, 0.014043168164789677, -0.0013729390921071172, 0.019335392862558365, -0.09243965893983841, -0.022847091779112816, 0.021370859816670418, 0.00876444112509489, 0.035627178847789764, -0.0661659687757492, -0.020218810066580772, 0.007245357614010572, -0.07932732999324799, 0.006548267789185047, -0.009581893682479858, -0.039260368794202805, 0.0010806353529915214, 0.010252129286527634, -0.008533736690878868, 0.0546414740383625, 0.01981252059340477, 0.024455824866890907, 0.0063223885372281075, 0.004207137506455183, 0.023790545761585236, 0.010112278163433075, 0.004471109714359045, -0.0057427603751420975, -0.0163797028362751, -0.018695179373025894, 0.009080321528017521, -0.029490362852811813, -0.04095140099525452, 0.03690169006586075, 0.0320853590965271, 0.03167203441262245, 0.014437534846365452, 0.001601965050213039, 0.018261121585965157, 0.058639854192733765, 0.044895607978105545, -0.004521165508776903, -0.017899954691529274, 0.007120292168110609, 0.027044888585805893, 0.07082322239875793, -0.017522091045975685, 0.006301523186266422, -0.014859473332762718, -0.03612995520234108, -0.03420278802514076, 0.002252731006592512, -0.03378168120980263, -0.02096640318632126, -0.001158996601589024, 0.025679588317871094, -0.01665933057665825, -0.020255865529179573, 0.04887671396136284, -0.06481462717056274, 0.003931933548301458, 0.03998909145593643, 0.03944437950849533, -0.018699713051319122, 0.015462887473404408, -0.037607476115226746, -0.031084265559911728, 0.026423627510666847, -0.003934621345251799, 0.024992944672703743, -0.05780106410384178, -0.011653762310743332, 0.019698696210980415, -0.01929030381143093, -0.027791528031229973, 0.0066367932595312595, -0.0521395280957222, 0.0278785340487957, 0.000439537747297436, 0.0607343353331089, 0.033034779131412506, -0.04746575653553009, 0.011798365041613579, -0.07180587202310562, 0.085933156311512, 0.0046298569068312645, -0.022886116057634354, -0.00816346611827612, 0.008021526969969273, -0.021234063431620598, -0.021569594740867615, 0.07449620217084885, -0.0012000595452263951, 0.02130742371082306, -0.011855191551148891, -0.00818253867328167, -0.03806385025382042, -0.029354164376854897, 0.04109429195523262, -0.00858297385275364, -0.009763154201209545, -0.025019865483045578, -0.007149780169129372, -0.012146568857133389, 0.03490179404616356, 0.02665671892464161, -0.013475432060658932, 0.007421860005706549, 0.024187428876757622, 0.00943281315267086, 0.045446623116731644, 0.04046446457505226, -0.01478496938943863, 0.03446296229958534, -0.030815113335847855, 0.01992795802652836, -0.009569370187819004, 0.0038722979370504618, -0.03992222622036934, 0.028706787154078484, -0.0141676627099514, -0.04424956813454628, -0.028723230585455894, 0.03945966809988022, 0.02884494513273239, -0.027529407292604446, 0.0007824490894563496, 0.05736541002988815, -0.013555830344557762, 0.012294791638851166, 0.014854720793664455, 0.020422175526618958, 0.05143827572464943, -0.014470592141151428, 0.013920019380748272, 0.018214181065559387, -0.030543526634573936, -0.02223105914890766, 0.006381562910974026, 0.030734168365597725, 0.024902483448386192, -0.008266828022897243, 0.03411589562892914, -0.03854520618915558, 0.06702671945095062, -0.008084932342171669, 0.07681763172149658, -0.037297070026397705, 0.00809174682945013, -0.010659707710146904, 0.003081180853769183, 0.03564128652215004, -0.0010793085675686598, 0.02486852928996086, 0.05734080821275711, -0.0008261734619736671, -0.05016869306564331, -0.03555847331881523, -0.05810539051890373, -0.04459063708782196, -0.03072681650519371, -0.0005104251322336495, 0.013688168488442898, 0.005369008518755436, 0.0005762388464063406, -0.007218125741928816, 0.01645469479262829, 0.039529986679553986, -0.0007855136645957828, 0.03301461413502693, -0.004278949927538633, 0.0019429693929851055, -0.01157098263502121, -0.03632884472608566, -0.034031156450510025, -0.014596998691558838, 0.02084622159600258, 0.06672879308462143, 0.022060148417949677, -0.047345295548439026, -0.004657956771552563, -0.046285681426525116, 0.06508845835924149, -0.07283096760511398, 0.026248708367347717, -0.0502803772687912, -0.0016549573047086596, 0.020814500749111176, -0.056800827383995056 ]
<blockquote> <p><strong>Possible Duplicate:</strong><br> <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/35719/improvement-of-regression-model">Improvement of regression model</a> </p> </blockquote> <p>I have recently started learning regression. I have a dataset containing a response and a predictor variable. When I plot the response and predictor variables there is no linear or curvilinear relationship between them. I used polynomial regression with degree 6 to fit the data, but the prediction does not seem good (the difference between the actual and predicted values is large). So I want to know that how can I improve my regression model? </p>
49,923
[ -0.023351483047008514, 0.010115435346961021, -0.006307042203843594, 0.011933393776416779, 0.03222554549574852, 0.00037556211464107037, -0.0012336738873273134, -0.02896123193204403, 0.051048941910266876, -0.027421973645687103, 0.04067413881421089, 0.018621128052473068, 0.027895774692296982, 0.005199066828936338, 0.015849808230996132, -0.02377702295780182, -0.005965408403426409, 0.00028716790257021785, 0.010333554819226265, 0.019072797149419785, -0.015720166265964508, 0.017544275149703026, 0.000929918373003602, 0.014673056080937386, -0.018790319561958313, 0.059892438352108, 0.051280632615089417, -0.016012510284781456, 0.015110677108168602, 0.019258584827184677, -0.024027278646826744, -0.008043072186410427, 0.03381825610995293, 0.0656643733382225, 0.03109593503177166, -0.02256939560174942, 0.007264107000082731, -0.04316829890012741, 0.014766319654881954, 0.03399328514933586, -0.0003475112607702613, -0.034180015325546265, -0.004828299395740032, 0.022937368601560593, -0.010747362859547138, 0.00407463638111949, 0.012299965135753155, -0.03327295556664467, 0.0434759147465229, -0.03298399597406387, 0.07565716654062271, -0.009209745563566685, 0.019802208989858627, 0.04996128007769585, -0.021394217386841774, -0.027434298768639565, 0.04959918558597565, 0.09767894446849823, -0.039060547947883606, -0.01460503414273262, 0.0019483461510390043, -0.02169131673872471, 0.015422448515892029, 0.008852321654558182, -0.03896478936076164, 0.025421617552638054, -0.010778830386698246, -0.0035495683550834656, 0.019680311903357506, 0.0038874971214681864, 0.006146835628896952, 0.025707276538014412, 0.027653122320771217, 0.0008745181257836521, -0.01761467382311821, -0.03992265835404396, -0.01722586527466774, 0.0515047088265419, 0.05821993201971054, 0.006308494135737419, -0.02543090283870697, 0.010969169437885284, 0.01937941089272499, 0.03394414111971855, 0.011846398934721947, 0.009597535245120525, 0.047928180545568466, 0.004667558241635561, 0.013180128298699856, 0.029426209628582, -0.012525921687483788, 0.008571496233344078, 0.062418460845947266, -0.008569968864321709, -0.04030781611800194, 0.016127310693264008, -0.01629934459924698, 0.0410766638815403, 0.046997349709272385, -0.0024300115182995796, -0.0063654282130301, -0.041678208857774734, -0.013655880466103554, 0.04403034597635269, -0.03822912648320198, -0.012534933164715767, -0.031079154461622238, -0.007738346233963966, -0.012274418026208878, -0.03974533453583717, -0.02973739057779312, 0.04416273906826973, 0.0000936781070777215, -0.02295231632888317, 0.011614604853093624, -0.04384481906890869, -0.006388182286173105, -0.04756747931241989, 0.060489483177661896, 0.05642708018422127, 0.016691988334059715, -0.057486020028591156, 0.03895455226302147, -0.018795328214764595, -0.020007546991109848, -0.019061220809817314, -0.003855352057144046, -0.02974303439259529, -0.015011739917099476, 0.03803492337465286, 0.009941481053829193, -0.021772434934973717, 0.015746066346764565, 0.01756555400788784, 0.02782963588833809, 0.032703299075365067, -0.09677066653966904, -0.03723951429128647, 0.04963793233036995, -0.005816433113068342, 0.007491766940802336, -0.05449198931455612, 0.00018422429275233299, 0.038372114300727844, 0.08388937264680862, 0.029605736956000328, 0.01668691635131836, 0.03863033652305603, 0.02817777544260025, 0.0034659351222217083, 0.013160397298634052, -0.027335725724697113, -0.022024644538760185, -0.04235749691724777, -0.007622790988534689, -0.08081305772066116, 0.0015772264450788498, 0.007909931242465973, -0.016417689621448517, 0.010088320821523666, 0.057510387152433395, -0.029120447114109993, -0.002806571079418063, -0.017790913581848145, 0.016393592581152916, 0.0010958827333524823, 0.056328434497117996, -0.00667261378839612, 0.04736531153321266, 0.0024230252020061016, -0.015625596046447754, -0.009762860834598541, 0.0035460705403238535, 0.030541660264134407, 0.011246920563280582, -0.014335345476865768, -0.003712587058544159, -0.00502577843144536, 0.01888175681233406, 0.0037441530730575323, -0.05040416866540909, -0.04527027904987335, -0.013162386603653431, 0.018542611971497536, 0.0017721381736919284, 0.06663277745246887, -0.015298712067306042, -0.018304796889424324, 0.03142658248543739, -0.028738923370838165, -0.03964552655816078, -0.0615665465593338, 0.02301524206995964, -0.011859321966767311, -0.00862024910748005, 0.0120744863525033, -0.0030141337774693966, 0.028254017233848572, -0.014704857021570206, 0.020419256761670113, -0.040556401014328, 0.011059311218559742, 0.04888983443379402, -0.03036772646009922, 0.001543781254440546, 0.04224314168095589, 0.061779651790857315, -0.01232500933110714, 0.04495060071349144, -0.06513573974370956, -0.030426383018493652, 0.011557109653949738, -0.029563533142209053, -0.0116819953545928, -0.053250785917043686, 0.003435000078752637, 0.011621704325079918, -0.03216081112623215, -0.0340920127928257, 0.009858725592494011, -0.04191850498318672, 0.07803181558847427, 0.04899592697620392, 0.015336835756897926, 0.018717261031270027, 0.02323075942695141, -0.010265800170600414, 0.031160032376646996, -0.03520846366882324, -0.02513977140188217, -0.050667423754930496, 0.01616748236119747, 0.05736100301146507, -0.0022952572908252478, -0.080851249396801, 0.026718106120824814, 0.0340200774371624, 0.027041034772992134, 0.006127136293798685, 0.013558265753090382, -0.028151942417025566, -0.017589325085282326, 0.01927896961569786, -0.015567119233310223, 0.01623234711587429, -0.0015588626265525818, 0.008140374906361103, 0.02682802826166153, 0.03439398854970932, -0.013297032564878464, 0.024101298302412033, 0.05851265788078308, 0.0016553194727748632, -0.012297159992158413, -0.011043388396501541, 0.010537765920162201, 0.013966838829219341, -0.02856852114200592, -0.029391983523964882, 0.030707169324159622, -0.006363488733768463, 0.03682500869035721, -0.004154559224843979, 0.007269483990967274, 0.011815618723630905, 0.04781222343444824, -0.020463084802031517, 0.006849982310086489, 0.02199552021920681, -0.055248845368623734, 0.008657282218337059, -0.046658169478178024, -0.012652500532567501, -0.0441724993288517, 0.018706338480114937, 0.013436376117169857, 0.0037904230412095785, 0.026534145697951317, -0.013234078884124756, -0.00847181398421526, 0.011945869773626328, 0.002300238935276866, 0.01119314692914486, -0.009210692718625069, -0.06369712203741074, -0.021077590063214302, -0.019114850088953972, 0.0061745126731693745, 0.019754968583583832, -0.0028857882134616375, 0.0045853666961193085, -0.001557669835165143, -0.023711370304226875, -0.067484550178051, -0.04344264417886734, -0.046170756220817566, 0.018561283126473427, -0.0051690274849534035, -0.06980189681053162, 0.026002109050750732, -0.021121153607964516, -0.03741874545812607, 0.02133898064494133, -0.03699711710214615, 0.020157530903816223, -0.030207376927137375, 0.0062902397476136684, 0.04259876534342766, 0.002328690141439438, 0.02916111797094345, 0.017575912177562714, -0.0007398886955343187, 0.01572498306632042, -0.08895952999591827, -0.06303003430366516, 0.014524165540933609, -0.005734438542276621, 0.03154745697975159, 0.011270572431385517, -0.019174546003341675, 0.05496012046933174, 0.027842827141284943, -0.03134406730532646, -0.04920292645692825, 0.0061530363745987415, -0.029347222298383713, -0.03197319433093071, 0.002045121043920517, 0.01268721092492342, 0.011295405216515064, -0.002690529450774193, -0.020047882571816444, 0.029713744297623634, 0.040167436003685, 0.01343731489032507, -0.028692347928881645, 0.009114347398281097, 0.0006599624757654965, -0.00742208119481802, 0.009718099609017372, 0.011044110171496868, -0.03656453266739845, 0.03125310689210892, 0.0020950469188392162, -0.005131611600518227, 0.00560825876891613, -0.052968986332416534, 0.007270654663443565, 0.0064660352654755116, -0.0029166163876652718, -0.007974080741405487, 0.01672774739563465, 0.009607325308024883, -0.026483934372663498, -0.0235576368868351, 0.023474352434277534, 0.023942027240991592, 0.01111358217895031, 0.01929544471204281, 0.03310554102063179, 0.014142824336886406, -0.011063933372497559, 0.020581619814038277, -0.01621296815574169, -0.028334086760878563, 0.01462275255471468, -0.0022534308955073357, 0.009490660391747952, 0.06731191277503967, 0.02196645922958851, 0.0008592728991061449, 0.011133454740047455, -0.05398763343691826, 0.017042845487594604, -0.0622226744890213, 0.010443867184221745, -0.039011865854263306, 0.055438946932554245, 0.019868813455104828, 0.005142379552125931, 0.0052411663345992565, -0.029037190601229668, 0.03896757960319519, 0.016433892771601677, -0.07769634574651718, 0.05483061820268631, -0.025913968682289124, -0.012223427183926105, 0.0017674785340204835, -0.010268001817166805, 0.004115529824048281, -0.038034845143556595, 0.005835109855979681, 0.000536159670446068, 0.011351645924150944, -0.039277464151382446, 0.011643734760582447, -0.030901946127414703, -0.012185275554656982, -0.016467077657580376, 0.016335250809788704, 0.015376657247543335, -0.035001132637262344, 0.0036195756401866674, 0.04192741960287094, -0.008649993687868118, -0.0218453761190176, -0.03774801641702652, -0.005667447578161955, 0.031592778861522675, 0.05732870474457741, 0.016951516270637512, 0.010254434309899807, -0.022365810349583626, 0.05465460941195488, 0.004670879803597927, 0.01223814208060503, 0.03777369484305382, -0.008333662524819374, -0.006060004234313965, -0.045445043593645096, -0.0069246478378772736, -0.011555440723896027, 0.03106633946299553, 0.0015455858083441854, -0.016502974554896355, 0.059118062257766724, -0.009773602709174156, -0.053053222596645355, 0.0014578077243641019, 0.03795637935400009, 0.013055381365120411, 0.026217956095933914, -0.01180266123265028, -0.01008542813360691, 0.004976784810423851, -0.0025934719014912844, 0.0335591621696949, -0.024100231006741524, -0.003830711590126157, -0.006079850718379021, 0.05747362971305847, -0.011681651696562767, -0.015118828043341637, -0.01728544756770134, 0.01811884716153145, 0.05914025753736496, 0.0029024737887084484, -0.0468488484621048, -0.010188293643295765, 0.04939449205994606, 0.04639807716012001, 0.012334403581917286, 0.02280319109559059, -0.11268506944179535, -0.02980891428887844, 0.010528119280934334, 0.06315255165100098, -0.06747472286224365, -0.013317948207259178, -0.025768518447875977, -0.009760424494743347, 0.034528698772192, -0.039898261427879333, 0.040120381861925125, 0.01363582443445921, 0.010004911571741104, -0.024370668455958366, -0.040308013558387756, -0.07644721865653992, 0.02593451924622059, -0.007749099284410477, 0.029435167089104652, -0.02422642894089222, -0.016813134774565697, -0.05447018891572952, 0.013625073246657848, 0.02178649976849556, 0.04445776715874672, -0.0002234760468127206, -0.005610933527350426, 0.015330232679843903, 0.013409970328211784, -0.024717651307582855, -0.057809311896562576, 0.01717047020792961, 0.005151834804564714, -0.03102963976562023, -0.002544335788115859, -0.013184232637286186, -0.038069386035203934, 0.009118262678384781, 0.030514424666762352, -0.048984214663505554, -0.011787159368395805, -0.04189131408929825, 0.026498818770051003, 0.006300799082964659, 0.0013172049075365067, 0.06769384443759918, 0.042258765548467636, -0.0018457000842317939, -0.006769601721316576, -0.005567937158048153, 0.010649862699210644, -0.015552298165857792, -0.06826013326644897, -0.028419628739356995, -0.015842469409108162, -0.028605090454220772, 0.04639887809753418, -0.007831074297428131, 0.029244573786854744, -0.05097074806690216, -0.009989188984036446, 0.007185737136751413, 0.04793853685259819, 0.0014953524805605412, 0.015722183510661125, 0.008206872269511223, 0.024540558457374573, -0.005248976871371269, -0.040559232234954834, 0.009132174775004387, -0.0037317760288715363, -0.0053030140697956085, 0.031559381633996964, -0.03929951786994934, 0.02406236156821251, -0.007673367857933044, -0.0168540608137846, -0.013795050792396069, -0.01587730459868908, 0.056470125913619995, 0.012085624039173126, -0.00208169873803854, 0.0084148608148098, -0.06966866552829742, -0.012740821577608585, 0.012037886306643486, 0.006261172238737345, 0.026128394529223442, -0.03236503154039383, 0.01788591779768467, -0.01572078838944435, 0.007312391418963671, -0.058744266629219055, -0.07505464553833008, 0.018189558759331703, -0.005886813160032034, -0.02295353077352047, -0.015666203573346138, 0.0005059177638031542, -0.025455474853515625, -0.010313664563000202, -0.032408807426691055, 0.024592610076069832, -0.013167220167815685, -0.024162564426660538, 0.007313581649214029, 0.0003643239033408463, 0.03813133388757706, -0.015098253265023232, -0.012907629832625389, 0.010597228072583675, -0.01909118890762329, -0.03284390643239021, -0.006974076386541128, 0.026086222380399704, -0.05276111140847206, -0.028665123507380486, -0.03697236627340317, 0.008008580654859543, 0.08775265514850616, -0.0009233848541043699, -0.026489028707146645, -0.011220292188227177, -0.0011830257717519999, -0.0014245593920350075, -0.009703502058982849, -0.007890606299042702, 0.0028816740959882736, -0.0041542863473296165, 0.004177949391305447, 0.007459662389010191, 0.005936022847890854, -0.034009624272584915, 0.018105439841747284, -0.009457563981413841, -0.018403062596917152, -0.0136217987164855, 0.08083351701498032, -0.007985787466168404, 0.008471825160086155, -0.00448227534070611, -0.02550564333796501, 0.008678529411554337, 0.04181818664073944, 0.012536291964352131, -0.007193409837782383, 0.05706296116113663, -0.0453481487929821, -0.054903093725442886, -0.0033036635722965, -0.015114833600819111, 0.07087302953004837, -0.03567977994680405, 0.05286955460906029, 0.04709552600979805, 0.03172892704606056, -0.0015390429180115461, -0.008734194561839104, -0.018022974953055382, -0.02204233780503273, 0.02027333527803421, 0.06296008825302124, 0.001143631525337696, 0.028230074793100357, 0.04982062801718712, 0.01574501022696495, 0.01898948661983013, 0.05937875062227249, 0.007392996922135353, 0.03169917315244675, 0.03073439560830593, -0.03099968656897545, -0.06605260819196701, 0.03461822122335434, -0.03168675675988197, 0.042128290981054306, -0.013111221604049206, 0.006003436166793108, 0.037165991961956024, 0.03379163146018982, 0.02008395455777645, -0.059752997010946274, -0.010996289551258087, -0.05890870466828346, -0.007658152375370264, 0.0212381724268198, -0.011533962562680244, 0.03839582949876785, -0.0016493997536599636, 0.024684634059667587, 0.008622325956821442, 0.045182064175605774, -0.05245411396026611, -0.09233550727367401, -0.012709679082036018, -0.029024189338088036, -0.026680152863264084, 0.04176950827240944, 0.024498702958226204, -0.05998023971915245, 0.03904615342617035, -0.026892490684986115, 0.015065012499690056, 0.013894819654524326, 0.02563249133527279, 0.00636948412284255, 0.0505860261619091, -0.03815493732690811, -0.03261897712945938, 0.025843847543001175, -0.00017119893163908273, 0.09002713114023209, 0.08912953734397888, 0.010626865550875664, -0.06253471970558167, 0.034583114087581635, 0.03527512773871422, -0.01933923363685608, -0.018461937084794044, 0.006726969964802265, -0.006448631174862385, -0.02050565928220749, 0.039486657828092575, 0.04894113168120384, 0.009684622287750244, 0.006148613058030605, 0.0624835230410099, -0.03314635902643204, -0.026008272543549538, -0.003119502915069461, -0.00970784667879343, 0.016631722450256348, 0.007727659773081541, -0.01140859629958868, 0.002317348262295127, -0.021677426993846893, -0.022675545886158943, -0.0383780375123024, 0.0005893083871342242, -0.009011371061205864, -0.006919063162058592, -0.02336689829826355, 0.008653641678392887, 0.003927231766283512, 0.027947137132287025, -0.035004064440727234, 0.015280375257134438, 0.0160593930631876, -0.029210561886429787, -0.0008315563900396228, 0.03195911645889282, 0.0006066448986530304, 0.005492588970810175, 0.018159396946430206, -0.01150410994887352, -0.05482882633805275, -0.02262292429804802, -0.03882405161857605, 0.03230344504117966, 0.018379902467131615, -0.023506147786974907, -0.014758053235709667, 0.013821466825902462, -0.009563727304339409, -0.031125344336032867, -0.04895515367388725, 0.04114849492907524, 0.03927916660904884, -0.03858914598822594, -0.06381306797266006, -0.015329603105783463, 0.029718713834881783, -0.0033256281167268753, 0.025828231126070023, 0.02935354970395565, -0.05143822729587555, -0.0230963546782732, -0.021857809275388718, 0.051415227353572845, 0.009603461250662804, 0.027616875246167183, 0.004818038083612919, 0.015266296453773975, -0.007740653585642576, -0.018030796200037003, 0.04201928898692131, 0.01113433763384819, 0.005369291640818119, -0.001460411585867405, -0.010079546831548214, -0.02730092778801918, -0.04834135249257088, 0.006679531652480364, -0.005539912264794111, 0.05431351810693741, -0.0735287144780159, 0.003123550908640027, 0.03506472334265709, 0.01040673814713955, 0.03795452415943146, 0.005290147848427296, -0.019495315849781036, 0.042067285627126694, 0.027021806687116623, -0.03684943541884422, -0.022563206031918526, -0.004621103871613741, -0.044041093438863754, 0.013129453174769878, 0.0005466520087793469, 0.08569645881652832, 0.044265057891607285, 0.020787427201867104, -0.018230071291327477, 0.036005470901727676, -0.034690938889980316, 0.022359928116202354, 0.007786997593939304, -0.05247626453638077, -0.024896230548620224, -0.0016034377040341496, 0.007842134684324265, -0.022175071761012077, -0.03711982071399689, -0.010266127996146679, -0.06295379251241684, 0.04820651561021805, -0.012180862948298454, -0.022801462560892105, 0.0381782092154026, -0.03377901017665863, 0.029061393812298775, -0.055474381893873215, -0.018297111615538597, -0.06275417655706406, -0.006877468898892403, 0.005438582506030798, -0.06908915191888809, -0.00161575130186975, 0.0013284372398629785, -0.01339904684573412, -0.0000955506693571806, 0.05160218104720116, 0.022215187549591064, 0.03717244043946266, -0.00981516670435667, 0.018427595496177673, -0.0016897359164431691, 0.07108856737613678, -0.034355804324150085, -0.028357623144984245, 0.04425785690546036, -0.04037681967020035, 0.0008441592799499631, 0.024483583867549896, -0.01754538156092167, 0.04011630266904831, 0.00957296323031187, -0.0008932267082855105, -0.000028262908017495647, 0.03936892747879028, 0.007552721071988344, 0.0038037432823330164, -0.034778159111738205, 0.006460611242800951, 0.0023553092032670975, -0.015822362154722214, 0.011175496503710747, -0.017522448673844337, 0.0028850319795310497, 0.010192755609750748, 0.06056778132915497, 0.03145761042833328, -0.003723376663401723, 0.033528126776218414, 0.0032765453215688467, 0.021135475486516953, 0.009036005474627018, 0.005622561555355787, 0.038757115602493286, 0.027836384251713753, -0.039709705859422684, 0.04051632806658745, -0.0008832041639834642, 0.03849180042743683, -0.09026216715574265, -0.01782062277197838, 0.013539238832890987, 0.00904009398072958, 0.04222448170185089, -0.056112777441740036, -0.009110944345593452, 0.05523555725812912, -0.05199241265654564, 0.002623435342684388, -0.013480923138558865, 0.011104284785687923, -0.00679061422124505, -0.027054741978645325, -0.024062292650341988, 0.022874396294355392, 0.051467008888721466, 0.042242906987667084, 0.015064426697790623, 0.04213831201195717, 0.034852683544158936, -0.006520875729620457, 0.02120499312877655, 0.0228541512042284, 0.004901297390460968, -0.04145355522632599, 0.021337909623980522, -0.045256420969963074, 0.0017438220093026757, 0.009102271869778633, -0.02609170600771904, 0.034219127148389816, 0.05211299657821655, -0.00844314694404602, -0.01702096313238144, 0.03341606259346008, 0.020695140585303307, -0.01282827090471983, -0.030485231429338455, -0.005049318075180054, -0.010969395749270916, 0.027782537043094635, -0.01121475175023079, 0.00878081563860178, 0.023486340418457985, 0.021753007546067238, -0.021031998097896576, 0.01111186109483242, -0.00961444154381752, -0.00973573513329029, 0.007344497367739677, 0.006636159494519234, -0.01503606978803873, -0.046074848622083664, -0.006462705787271261, -0.01723327301442623, -0.030033711344003677, 0.030194856226444244, 0.03756921365857124, -0.03727041184902191, -0.00043391462531872094, -0.009556279517710209, -0.04372018203139305, 0.0023478702642023563, 0.005293272435665131, 0.018426932394504547, -0.04544127359986305, -0.006842632312327623, 0.022453943267464638, -0.02584671601653099, -0.020422406494617462, -0.011129733175039291, -0.04389476776123047, 0.06406480073928833, -0.023022398352622986, 0.004695425275713205, 0.026455845683813095, -0.031904060393571854, -0.030475527048110962, -0.05972355231642723, 0.08671684563159943, 0.012679495848715305, -0.022924741730093956, -0.027893027290701866, -0.0013862763298675418, -0.02851416915655136, 0.014169960282742977, 0.07240217179059982, 0.01072603091597557, 0.01633838750422001, -0.0014649252407252789, 0.047752004116773605, 0.01163847278803587, -0.0227051991969347, 0.01765148900449276, 0.008363583125174046, -0.0063382345251739025, -0.03085366263985634, -0.020545363426208496, 0.021711500361561775, 0.021987764164805412, 0.0030650985427200794, -0.017735015600919724, 0.023052770644426346, 0.022958379238843918, -0.0023772139102220535, 0.034321121871471405, 0.007154820021241903, -0.003684399649500847, 0.05683780461549759, -0.014929791912436485, 0.02064402773976326, 0.04771961644291878, -0.0030166739597916603, -0.044130440801382065, 0.015141605399549007, -0.048728831112384796, -0.0010868794051930308, -0.007575878873467445, -0.0003606148238759488, -0.029388390481472015, -0.06249130889773369, 0.0022345478646457195, 0.04056858643889427, -0.0374067984521389, 0.02699948661029339, 0.01518632285296917, -0.023967193439602852, 0.035558074712753296, -0.014948934316635132, 0.02578379213809967, 0.012233376502990723, 0.0047367410734295845, -0.005051909945905209, 0.0007870871922932565, 0.05333908647298813, 0.013983119279146194, 0.02515525370836258, 0.046519242227077484, 0.00536829000338912, 0.06290662288665771, -0.018278639763593674, 0.024546103551983833, -0.034735701978206635, -0.017291387543082237, 0.0036572818644344807, -0.008825164288282394, -0.0024424749426543713, 0.012325441464781761, 0.0012431152863427997, 0.059554651379585266, -0.03859148547053337, -0.029095353558659554, -0.020260486751794815, -0.034481316804885864, -0.04619257524609566, -0.014532904140651226, 0.029105696827173233, 0.04456993192434311, 0.030551563948392868, 0.013920734636485577, 0.02703344263136387, -0.021739596500992775, 0.02426205761730671, 0.025617580860853195, 0.010263682343065739, -0.010270419530570507, -0.028281381353735924, -0.03443172574043274, -0.031127575784921646, -0.02309463731944561, -0.01914905570447445, 0.06090202182531357, 0.0546184703707695, 0.05202497914433479, -0.022630691528320312, -0.02489936351776123, -0.014687106013298035, 0.06535729020833969, -0.10151048004627228, -0.025134190917015076, -0.018806882202625275, -0.007614258676767349, 0.0053335209377110004, -0.055408719927072525 ]
<p>Is there a Box-Cox like transformation for independent variables? That is, a transformation that optimizes the $x$ variable so that the <code>y~f(x)</code> will make a more reasonable fit for a linear model?</p> <p>If so, is there a function to perform this with <code>R</code>?</p>
49,507
[ -0.04432100057601929, 0.04323942959308624, 0.0025454929564148188, 0.004363904241472483, 0.011595004238188267, -0.01319663692265749, -0.029032403603196144, -0.01679595373570919, 0.06599093228578568, -0.020567109808325768, 0.03617403283715248, 0.05135442689061165, 0.06799378246068954, -0.009677118621766567, 0.025215763598680496, 0.00017581164138391614, -0.0030139952432364225, 0.02469654008746147, -0.030682891607284546, -0.014421386644244194, -0.01972001977264881, 0.01962432824075222, 0.013655376620590687, 0.00006560475594596937, -0.004030183423310518, 0.061631590127944946, 0.015581880696117878, -0.0238701943308115, 0.009325999766588211, 0.07649046927690506, 0.0029230467043817043, -0.029483763501048088, 0.0017267224611714482, 0.03520670905709267, -0.001881113275885582, -0.0041749440133571625, 0.01601283811032772, -0.046573277562856674, 0.027506180107593536, 0.06685250252485275, -0.020321210846304893, -0.030188346281647682, 0.0007858340977691114, 0.05606309697031975, 0.04577082395553589, 0.06133342534303665, 0.00014514423673972487, -0.03389357030391693, 0.010593677870929241, -0.04941670969128609, 0.1087702065706253, -0.021164532750844955, 0.021251637488603592, 0.017749033868312836, -0.03958917036652565, -0.046473536640405655, 0.06361304223537445, 0.08038341999053955, -0.006295353174209595, -0.03707137331366539, -0.01593104936182499, -0.01982424594461918, 0.0010186007712036371, -0.01879825070500374, -0.03464328870177269, 0.023459261283278465, -0.02359674498438835, 0.01467134803533554, 0.010586978867650032, -0.048450786620378494, 0.009425903670489788, 0.022902773693203926, 0.038905758410692215, -0.03082912415266037, -0.011928567662835121, -0.02806142531335354, 0.0328323096036911, 0.0007289952482096851, 0.02793663926422596, 0.024625176563858986, 0.025808118283748627, 0.009214774705469608, 0.02409345470368862, 0.007036296185106039, -0.0017608669586479664, 0.004385230131447315, 0.06482511758804321, -0.027658527716994286, 0.0059721628203988075, 0.01501347403973341, -0.012705115601420403, -0.013346454128623009, 0.08569285273551941, 0.009840168058872223, -0.021845871582627296, 0.052239131182432175, 0.003200446953997016, 0.031866829842329025, 0.022824104875326157, -0.03504670783877373, -0.0003196110774297267, -0.05487968027591705, -0.015328742563724518, 0.03080466203391552, 0.011478020809590816, -0.002113093389198184, -0.0008531336789019406, 0.012992111966013908, -0.004370989743620157, -0.009749003686010838, -0.01405178103595972, 0.025090819224715233, -0.019665084779262543, 0.003278915537521243, 0.06939761340618134, -0.029431499540805817, -0.009417123161256313, -0.01713551953434944, 0.03921937569975853, 0.051274221390485764, 0.04486940801143646, -0.05323867127299309, 0.029743511229753494, -0.004580453969538212, -0.025454789400100708, 0.022181449458003044, -0.014124917797744274, 0.01116485707461834, -0.042247872799634933, 0.04050726071000099, 0.008010518737137318, -0.04460914805531502, 0.04330524802207947, 0.01470703724771738, -0.017988892272114754, -0.017637304961681366, -0.061843883246183395, -0.06834575533866882, 0.015434473752975464, -0.013297834433615208, -0.01818346045911312, -0.06907627731561661, -0.00530606135725975, 0.02371528185904026, 0.03238599747419357, 0.011444026604294777, 0.0328541100025177, 0.02695654146373272, 0.03176692873239517, -0.018437819555401802, -0.001822342281229794, -0.01463563833385706, -0.02493738941848278, -0.03687917813658714, 0.0029056540224701166, -0.06964217871427536, 0.0062858471646904945, 0.015658559277653694, -0.014830152504146099, 0.013879294507205486, 0.07468070089817047, -0.0034012424293905497, -0.04528278112411499, -0.010394609533250332, 0.008651982061564922, -0.03447843715548515, 0.04128239303827286, 0.005079383030533791, 0.035097990185022354, 0.0013144226977601647, -0.010612712241709232, 0.05654127523303032, 0.029250936582684517, 0.042666491121053696, 0.026011258363723755, -0.039639417082071304, -0.024560967460274696, -0.02445627935230732, 0.02747236005961895, 0.027036331593990326, -0.017845604568719864, -0.0037422054447233677, -0.03717915341258049, -0.021546246483922005, -0.00807869154959917, 0.06098530441522598, -0.02368614636361599, -0.0164355356246233, 0.06059687212109566, -0.08152879029512405, -0.05333707109093666, -0.058634426444768906, 0.011690502986311913, 0.01633194088935852, 0.0143700260668993, 0.014866839163005352, 0.02121635526418686, 0.03475301340222359, 0.01313392911106348, -0.010823010466992855, 0.00551126804202795, -0.008959556929767132, 0.037077758461236954, -0.005180141422897577, -0.004139157943427563, 0.036815088242292404, 0.07428207248449326, -0.019090477377176285, 0.023257816210389137, -0.04122401773929596, -0.012636318802833557, 0.012423302978277206, -0.061195578426122665, 0.031012583523988724, -0.0649227425456047, 0.021144332364201546, 0.02080066315829754, -0.027218589559197426, 0.005729311611503363, -0.008675293996930122, -0.04746025800704956, 0.026979845017194748, 0.06705459207296371, 0.004698173142969608, 0.000827718642540276, 0.026050696149468422, 0.02309311367571354, 0.028405800461769104, -0.021386053413152695, -0.037264157086610794, -0.04690670594573021, 0.0007589877350255847, 0.034605879336595535, 0.014293828047811985, -0.037792086601257324, 0.027378607541322708, 0.04231424629688263, 0.016936663538217545, 0.009580857120454311, 0.04095466807484627, -0.00024692885926924646, -0.01090293750166893, -0.005242036189883947, -0.008996165357530117, 0.023064127191901207, -0.003715518396347761, -0.004605609457939863, 0.013642522506415844, 0.032346803694963455, -0.010298574343323708, -0.03258445858955383, 0.03040691651403904, -0.002186718862503767, 0.0029332521371543407, -0.021310841664671898, -0.020760690793395042, 0.025981830433011055, -0.05750260129570961, -0.003562947502359748, 0.02549229934811592, -0.008606472052633762, 0.024478061124682426, 0.029953885823488235, 0.006249490659683943, 0.01000977959483862, 0.021210700273513794, -0.003675408661365509, 0.015502341091632843, 0.020345013588666916, -0.03624963387846947, 0.03577328100800514, -0.02437692880630493, -0.013835916295647621, -0.029445050284266472, -0.01522732712328434, 0.011147125624120235, 0.038956813514232635, 0.016780925914645195, -0.0037835794501006603, -0.0037624139804393053, 0.026558680459856987, -0.03942801430821419, 0.023288795724511147, -0.014088932424783707, -0.02477957122027874, -0.00821825210005045, -0.06178708001971245, -0.02302909456193447, 0.013154351152479649, -0.0201558955013752, -0.009892282076179981, 0.023416470736265182, -0.01670030876994133, -0.0456802174448967, -0.015375260263681412, -0.03054535761475563, 0.0036470305640250444, -0.0072820549830794334, -0.0028530138079077005, 0.03581592068076134, 0.0033286584075540304, -0.022610841318964958, -0.00986210722476244, -0.044410429894924164, -0.014195763505995274, -0.02792142517864704, 0.003610739717260003, 0.027753552421927452, 0.024204833433032036, 0.019518399611115456, 0.022960130125284195, -0.028964007273316383, 0.016808317974209785, -0.0439787395298481, -0.04448593780398369, 0.027033256366848946, 0.025037964805960655, 0.034205738455057144, 0.0344545803964138, -0.04066207632422447, 0.07017537206411362, 0.05604706332087517, -0.02280259318649769, -0.06154325604438782, -0.008316071704030037, -0.014006544835865498, -0.035542454570531845, 0.0036988079082220793, 0.02184583805501461, 0.02102547697722912, 0.038162488490343094, 0.0007420043693855405, 0.00583906564861536, 0.05268774926662445, 0.0006322935805656016, 0.013050766661763191, 0.04011939465999603, 0.0034095493610948324, -0.017015822231769562, 0.0024790975730866194, -0.00026626134058460593, -0.016208872199058533, 0.03922388702630997, 0.0003000190481543541, -0.03570838272571564, 0.00076208112295717, -0.025428781285881996, 0.028558755293488503, -0.006441126111894846, -0.00826707947999239, -0.016970498487353325, 0.02037147246301174, 0.00044589382014237344, -0.013500149361789227, -0.008740659803152084, 0.04547601565718651, 0.036098357290029526, 0.004246867727488279, 0.027836216613650322, 0.01740804873406887, 0.026405733078718185, 0.006356790196150541, 0.028896955773234367, -0.016251778230071068, -0.013202010653913021, 0.027839796617627144, -0.02068657986819744, -0.024704769253730774, 0.050877418369054794, 0.017622871324419975, 0.047223176807165146, 0.0024657160975039005, -0.027067307382822037, 0.060971084982156754, -0.04285341501235962, -0.0077651916071772575, -0.012954686768352985, 0.030779724940657616, 0.03113323263823986, 0.020246470347046852, 0.04124218970537186, 0.003336411900818348, 0.012844575569033623, -0.01395703200250864, -0.0670238733291626, 0.03918130323290825, -0.01912483386695385, 0.012335403822362423, -0.021941134706139565, 0.008332643657922745, 0.045468319207429886, -0.025241484865546227, 0.008378852158784866, 0.003263764549046755, 0.026630818843841553, -0.007581755518913269, -0.0008021772955544293, 0.004771336447447538, -0.05046918988227844, -0.002487788675352931, 0.02895328216254711, 0.03389051929116249, -0.05506501719355583, -0.013881281018257141, 0.03688667342066765, -0.02519039250910282, -0.011568690650165081, 0.0004530134319793433, 0.00930037721991539, 0.0127925556153059, 0.0423164889216423, -0.0015633522998541594, 0.020614327862858772, -0.03327999636530876, 0.03305201977491379, 0.004906175192445517, -0.003950970247387886, 0.04819410666823387, -0.03539783135056496, -0.026443686336278915, -0.05931646376848221, -0.012496226467192173, 0.0017406343249604106, -0.002587348921224475, 0.015550519339740276, -0.00466569559648633, 0.07820389419794083, 0.03784620761871338, -0.025491919368505478, 0.009992178529500961, 0.07331418991088867, 0.035767678171396255, -0.01778760738670826, -0.034383296966552734, 0.013379855081439018, 0.010331262834370136, 0.012831108644604683, 0.0160208772867918, -0.011525359004735947, 0.013464855030179024, -0.0074183326214551926, 0.04408537596464157, -0.009463541209697723, -0.011579618789255619, -0.022526798769831657, 0.012980535626411438, 0.04512588307261467, 0.017226362600922585, -0.017946334555745125, -0.0077070496045053005, 0.0533033050596714, 0.03226602077484131, 0.020312942564487457, 0.007855728268623352, -0.0806453749537468, 0.022235462442040443, 0.015603985637426376, 0.05055800825357437, -0.03957533836364746, 0.008291690610349178, -0.02710144780576229, -0.028767598792910576, 0.053796857595443726, -0.008658742532134056, 0.010162931866943836, -0.0057759410701692104, 0.019450698047876358, -0.000767611141782254, -0.03196941688656807, -0.08504267781972885, 0.016720926389098167, -0.023451104760169983, -0.022949911653995514, -0.03954846411943436, -0.03420952707529068, -0.023529762402176857, 0.02149996906518936, -0.00938834436237812, 0.04105271026492119, -0.04004644230008125, -0.006295113358646631, -0.00009452935046283528, 0.010557557456195354, -0.025105243548750877, -0.026115765795111656, -0.00008286424417747185, 0.030470052734017372, -0.02996215783059597, 0.003259979886934161, 0.02086825482547283, -0.05264647305011749, 0.016127148643136024, 0.0012241549557074904, -0.008397496305406094, 0.027471302077174187, -0.01181973610073328, 0.035514358431100845, 0.015881383791565895, 0.021427201107144356, 0.059103477746248245, 0.04587457701563835, -0.044358473271131516, -0.03047468699514866, -0.051395632326602936, 0.020019149407744408, -0.022213540971279144, -0.03392202407121658, -0.03652792423963547, -0.006296785548329353, 0.00335172307677567, 0.033694375306367874, -0.023727579042315483, 0.04378936067223549, -0.0661671906709671, 0.012068419717252254, 0.0018879517447203398, 0.024109086021780968, -0.015306885354220867, -0.029614901170134544, 0.00748048909008503, 0.025991331785917282, 0.008484423160552979, -0.024406330659985542, -0.008119664154946804, -0.0009985844371840358, 0.023368345573544502, 0.01890665479004383, -0.04965825006365776, 0.011915513314306736, -0.04340924322605133, -0.041189756244421005, 0.009187465533614159, -0.04452783986926079, 0.05897904187440872, -0.03872767090797424, -0.008774121291935444, -0.0070097134448587894, -0.043091725558042526, -0.006619217339903116, 0.020701095461845398, 0.015356197953224182, 0.02606271393597126, -0.053456056863069534, 0.016614170745015144, -0.033184099942445755, -0.005720684304833412, -0.0704505443572998, -0.06553879380226135, 0.02789546363055706, -0.02774202823638916, -0.005448393523693085, -0.07021663337945938, 0.01625400222837925, -0.027871444821357727, -0.00831313244998455, -0.021784184500575066, 0.049543190747499466, -0.02704682946205139, 0.011691528372466564, -0.029467662796378136, 0.008441826328635216, 0.006672725081443787, 0.00031912082340568304, -0.0021298504434525967, 0.020417246967554092, 0.007689873222261667, -0.0017511938931420445, 0.015538228675723076, 0.03486080467700958, -0.039037853479385376, 0.008734548464417458, -0.021367041394114494, -0.020340999588370323, 0.03607839345932007, -0.013257461600005627, -0.009639399126172066, 0.04336054250597954, 0.019024215638637543, -0.026481779292225838, 0.005247374996542931, -0.002094285562634468, 0.017058640718460083, -0.022994820028543472, 0.0007329789223149419, -0.00009943515760824084, -0.007546504493802786, -0.026865767315030098, 0.024981576949357986, -0.024941448122262955, 0.006201866548508406, 0.004762687720358372, 0.07032860815525055, -0.012233561836183071, -0.003298673080280423, -0.02879192866384983, -0.01264982484281063, 0.02210967428982258, 0.017318276688456535, 0.002071378054097295, 0.0004919971688650548, 0.021349620074033737, -0.02731708623468876, -0.04725291579961777, -0.03680184483528137, -0.02212907187640667, 0.07357370853424072, -0.03090621717274189, 0.053908444941043854, 0.07633808255195618, 0.013648992404341698, -0.00456272205337882, -0.027798455208539963, 0.002175504807382822, -0.00673956423997879, -0.0022155705373734236, 0.06956639140844345, 0.0190131776034832, 0.0006721302634105086, 0.042714133858680725, 0.04095211252570152, 0.0036894381046295166, 0.04962548613548279, -0.002719967160373926, 0.0159206073731184, 0.040550414472818375, -0.050657182931900024, -0.07692712545394897, 0.019444160163402557, -0.0235594492405653, 0.020208321511745453, -0.019282007589936256, -0.01770881377160549, 0.056716933846473694, 0.04061078280210495, -0.011332866735756397, -0.03654712438583374, -0.016392629593610764, -0.07727215439081192, -0.006593725644052029, 0.03260308876633644, 0.004800453316420317, 0.037974752485752106, 0.01753358356654644, 0.06321152299642563, -0.006688324268907309, 0.02111453376710415, -0.03423716872930527, -0.06879403442144394, -0.006679547019302845, -0.027040252462029457, -0.024500448256731033, 0.012713431380689144, -0.0034622005186975002, -0.00852416455745697, 0.0030956673435866833, -0.015323825180530548, 0.012853951193392277, 0.018715662881731987, 0.04664906859397888, -0.006035506259649992, 0.07558897137641907, -0.01348493155092001, -0.0066099390387535095, -0.03609718382358551, -0.001985908253118396, 0.11544176936149597, 0.08050034940242767, 0.04489763453602791, -0.06928789615631104, 0.0037931010592728853, -0.053497057408094406, -0.022210149094462395, -0.010825041681528091, -0.020924139767885208, 0.018742132931947708, -0.0024594783317297697, 0.034505296498537064, 0.08357284218072891, 0.03498523309826851, -0.025415359064936638, 0.0416717454791069, -0.014619993977248669, -0.023890763521194458, 0.009388880804181099, 0.012655345723032951, -0.014541436918079853, -0.014550833962857723, -0.0657598078250885, -0.006710211280733347, -0.014304759912192822, -0.03244444727897644, -0.016087308526039124, -0.03129800036549568, -0.009739713743329048, -0.014918738044798374, -0.0368025116622448, 0.003017465118318796, 0.012796584516763687, 0.007332870736718178, -0.008202975615859032, 0.04951183870434761, 0.02477581799030304, -0.010028994642198086, -0.01048492081463337, 0.0428064689040184, 0.006882051005959511, 0.03174121305346489, 0.012774371542036533, -0.024576639756560326, -0.026098400354385376, -0.009904411621391773, -0.059441469609737396, -0.004137772135436535, -0.0062500229105353355, -0.002841636072844267, -0.028653886169195175, 0.008632144890725613, -0.016801392659544945, -0.06648401916027069, 0.013490299694240093, 0.06374169141054153, 0.03039330430328846, 0.002281615510582924, 0.007617237977683544, -0.0074413493275642395, 0.013484491035342216, -0.012111971154808998, 0.00967054907232523, 0.052032846957445145, -0.02544168382883072, 0.001229567569680512, 0.012295235879719257, 0.07993093132972717, -0.006435818038880825, -0.003751733573153615, 0.028555329889059067, -0.02934734709560871, 0.0010673762299120426, -0.02721077762544155, 0.0537552610039711, 0.013171734288334846, 0.038369070738554, -0.0231364406645298, 0.01521250419318676, -0.035432372242212296, -0.07122195512056351, 0.020921478047966957, -0.029796579852700233, 0.03155034780502319, -0.0628524124622345, 0.016299009323120117, 0.03646911308169365, 0.04487074911594391, 0.02847173623740673, -0.0039002434350550175, -0.03510134294629097, 0.030766980722546577, 0.006806450895965099, -0.06599900126457214, -0.05421028658747673, -0.012518671341240406, 0.015082750469446182, -0.022497830912470818, 0.006437789183109999, 0.07836639136075974, 0.03562444448471069, 0.01630401238799095, -0.03276730701327324, 0.04446689411997795, -0.012022124603390694, 0.027068311348557472, -0.003241701051592827, -0.04918147251009941, 0.013423620723187923, -0.01305478997528553, 0.01659468188881874, -0.02807893417775631, -0.0021575218997895718, -0.04209836572408676, -0.043421804904937744, 0.033239953219890594, -0.007695614360272884, -0.013190137222409248, 0.006767414044588804, -0.024564892053604126, 0.033931031823158264, -0.03860625997185707, 0.004303428810089827, -0.003260795259848237, -0.010428119450807571, -0.0023057337384670973, -0.06532203406095505, 0.008880415931344032, 0.016580909490585327, -0.01342280674725771, 0.010296521708369255, 0.03742257133126259, -0.007501248735934496, 0.023073816671967506, 0.0091706532984972, -0.0048517328687012196, 0.02371499501168728, 0.05149386450648308, -0.041412774473428726, -0.007273889146745205, -0.004679064266383648, -0.060837142169475555, -0.021158192306756973, 0.03939028084278107, -0.03740563243627548, 0.020437750965356827, 0.022405842319130898, 0.006444274913519621, -0.02950417622923851, 0.02187204733490944, -0.018074126914143562, 0.0061788661405444145, -0.007031946908682585, 0.009406592696905136, 0.04102993756532669, -0.008862514048814774, 0.00888210628181696, -0.02453007362782955, -0.04651233181357384, 0.04689648002386093, 0.04608037695288658, 0.005694031715393066, -0.007882118225097656, 0.007654531393200159, -0.0016445759683847427, 0.01252878550440073, -0.010651483200490475, 0.021228289231657982, 0.049965742975473404, 0.029138267040252686, -0.022501422092318535, 0.037204891443252563, 0.003872557310387492, 0.0072919889353215694, -0.11931964010000229, -0.023403847590088844, -0.012099185958504677, 0.01927352510392666, 0.05471128970384598, -0.07227712124586105, 0.00384174520149827, -0.02640240266919136, -0.05510474368929863, 0.018897952511906624, 0.0051063965074718, -0.0009840975981205702, 0.0022565603721886873, 0.00005764663001173176, -0.020006729289889336, 0.02534649521112442, 0.037965163588523865, 0.014978690072894096, 0.040445417165756226, 0.02436409518122673, -0.0020332555286586285, 0.0003349133476149291, -0.0012334296479821205, -0.004340733867138624, 0.028179317712783813, -0.062256183475255966, 0.015612410381436348, -0.03264237567782402, -0.029365457594394684, 0.012127748690545559, 0.0003081198956351727, 0.05808108299970627, 0.008388384245336056, 0.008130873553454876, 0.023311374709010124, 0.03154253959655762, 0.035740386694669724, -0.028583725914359093, -0.028517350554466248, 0.001780869672074914, 0.008523538708686829, 0.035074472427368164, -0.03659774363040924, 0.014022679068148136, -0.0035187744069844484, -0.01953957974910736, -0.048312194645404816, -0.01612008735537529, -0.02726753242313862, -0.017462285235524178, 0.0020807019900530577, -0.022787367925047874, -0.007852445356547832, -0.01674731820821762, 0.013330754823982716, -0.03318836912512779, -0.0021765970159322023, 0.04348527267575264, 0.01051325909793377, -0.017604384571313858, 0.008992313407361507, -0.0020981663838028908, -0.03859119489789009, -0.001929239952005446, 0.015879852697253227, 0.008711890317499638, -0.08441458642482758, -0.012015956453979015, -0.004569107200950384, -0.03711238503456116, -0.02532917447388172, -0.02347869612276554, -0.03627759590744972, 0.03861573711037636, -0.033960506319999695, -0.0035135503858327866, 0.03312266245484352, 0.005975133739411831, 0.0031513662543147802, -0.06927190721035004, 0.06417592614889145, 0.00794614665210247, -0.021662114188075066, -0.008864171802997589, -0.015196743421256542, -0.023608682677149773, -0.052198972553014755, 0.07025802135467529, 0.004137571435421705, 0.02873832918703556, -0.012927868403494358, 0.04201314225792885, -0.01929434947669506, -0.03168906271457672, 0.0355587862432003, -0.013398661278188229, 0.005569036118686199, -0.021495936438441277, 0.012140539474785328, 0.013051467947661877, 0.027694107964634895, -0.011207005940377712, -0.032192081212997437, 0.005265627522021532, -0.000017276601283811033, 0.00474547129124403, 0.005944356322288513, 0.011525468900799751, -0.014697928912937641, 0.0366823673248291, 0.03886612504720688, 0.014050534926354885, 0.019073227420449257, 0.0028837828431278467, -0.05880341678857803, 0.0028211406897753477, -0.06695713102817535, -0.03036549687385559, -0.01025223359465599, 0.00168695452157408, -0.013416982255876064, -0.03402188792824745, 0.027215149253606796, 0.007788761984556913, -0.02687663957476616, -0.025232696905732155, 0.055852603167295456, 0.005857408046722412, 0.032563671469688416, 0.017193075269460678, -0.007724073715507984, 0.011591543443500996, -0.003147789742797613, 0.007981125265359879, -0.02510172128677368, 0.024843063205480576, -0.010384908877313137, 0.030781099572777748, 0.0557311475276947, -0.014276957139372826, 0.035221584141254425, 0.015546703711152077, 0.030267158523201942, -0.007490507327020168, -0.025883084163069725, 0.020294517278671265, -0.03263328969478607, 0.0265035517513752, -0.01708941161632538, -0.04596585035324097, 0.04815992712974548, -0.03084617294371128, 0.0065640611574053764, -0.043155208230018616, 0.0036837910301983356, -0.02612764947116375, 0.010884438641369343, -0.027210526168346405, 0.0330318920314312, -0.03685947135090828, 0.00251195696182549, 0.016413401812314987, -0.02377856709063053, 0.0346657857298851, -0.016512926667928696, -0.015544243156909943, -0.03179623559117317, 0.009282508864998817, 0.014268031343817711, -0.01406695693731308, -0.03487295284867287, -0.03833192214369774, -0.017130399122834206, 0.05243927612900734, 0.03790033981204033, -0.020619437098503113, -0.010011482052505016, -0.020843882113695145, 0.08519919961690903, -0.09131161123514175, -0.022146642208099365, -0.03007025644183159, -0.009650706313550472, -0.0024119673762470484, -0.0059851789847016335 ]
<p>I am not entirely sure if I should ask this question here, but does EViews has a function of converting <em>J</em> statistics to <em>p</em>-value of Jstats, or other way around. I am running several GMM estimations and I would like show both of them in my paper. Or is their a way to convert the <em>J</em> statistics to <em>p</em>-value of <em>J</em> statistics.</p>
12,399
[ -0.02241593785583973, 0.00856721680611372, 0.010652286931872368, -0.045702893286943436, 0.051777467131614685, 0.047601114958524704, -0.04260114207863808, -0.03728623688220978, 0.06303427368402481, -0.029152020812034607, 0.07295046746730804, 0.04478843882679939, 0.08042638748884201, 0.03385339304804802, 0.00893850065767765, -0.0010945704998448491, -0.03173644840717316, 0.02015904150903225, -0.01599922776222229, -0.046752799302339554, 0.00264569791033864, 0.016026390716433525, -0.005355939269065857, -0.03628440201282501, -0.015170243568718433, 0.030719278380274773, 0.023635484278202057, -0.009638912044465542, 0.023064175620675087, 0.058342043310403824, -0.029137007892131805, 0.007981888018548489, 0.006334585137665272, 0.05725995451211929, 0.012013610452413559, 0.007185284048318863, -0.016392936930060387, -0.05385901778936386, 0.02833862043917179, 0.05400236323475838, -0.03249363228678703, 0.04597879946231842, -0.0032177160028368235, -0.012356891296803951, -0.011163761839270592, 0.03807612881064415, -0.014756239019334316, -0.012126156128942966, 0.04213810712099075, -0.029525382444262505, 0.04536498710513115, 0.001064363052137196, -0.018305549398064613, -0.0037880379240959883, -0.012661794200539589, 0.001065821503289044, 0.06930170208215714, 0.0418563112616539, 0.018916413187980652, -0.04100973531603813, 0.013986542820930481, 0.020766163244843483, -0.009699824266135693, -0.03796885535120964, 0.004354266449809074, 0.029585152864456177, 0.007960805669426918, -0.058877043426036835, 0.05264533683657646, 0.01212894357740879, -0.013889269903302193, 0.011610818095505238, 0.026710396632552147, -0.018543198704719543, 0.06810801476240158, -0.0494147427380085, 0.05222107470035553, 0.023560626432299614, -0.004831134341657162, 0.010857916437089443, 0.029783567413687706, 0.009052068926393986, 0.03156856819987297, 0.054671868681907654, 0.018997982144355774, 0.008893239311873913, 0.05061524733901024, -0.05299327149987221, 0.05864319950342178, 0.047571923583745956, -0.013816694729030132, -0.03248650208115578, 0.06748408824205399, -0.005900573451071978, -0.02432849630713463, 0.017352290451526642, -0.002343566622585058, 0.08025941997766495, 0.017280196771025658, 0.017361970618367195, -0.02389049157500267, -0.015404130332171917, 0.020070619881153107, 0.05021558701992035, -0.03234314173460007, -0.0186301339417696, 0.020622890442609787, -0.06222578138113022, -0.007552040740847588, -0.01620553620159626, -0.045483414083719254, 0.021876323968172073, 0.012523253448307514, -0.02669619955122471, 0.032469674944877625, 0.004881357774138451, -0.006686870474368334, -0.030158033594489098, 0.016837460920214653, 0.06992661207914352, 0.07410988211631775, -0.014727461151778698, -0.03494098782539368, -0.05400116741657257, -0.09063385426998138, -0.008654377423226833, 0.013258935883641243, 0.007671571336686611, -0.022714804857969284, 0.012662997469305992, -0.009218400344252586, -0.01930178888142109, 0.015471181832253933, -0.0018079589353874326, 0.03160393238067627, 0.01691984198987484, -0.06359443068504333, -0.04349434748291969, 0.06104842945933342, 0.007573622278869152, 0.004795391578227282, -0.03881193697452545, 0.024544913321733475, 0.015709523111581802, -0.012841442599892616, 0.02677767165005207, 0.035758715122938156, -0.032307565212249756, 0.04955006763339043, 0.0179096981883049, -0.02926761470735073, -0.011339455842971802, -0.028927531093358994, -0.0208213459700346, 0.019621971994638443, -0.05132820084691048, 0.026447150856256485, -0.0020224202889949083, -0.01136865559965372, 0.008604093454778194, 0.046987134963274, -0.0026341069024056196, -0.007189684081822634, -0.02941095642745495, 0.002703718841075897, -0.03833113983273506, 0.07785236090421677, -0.002708323299884796, 0.012146355584263802, -0.02554336003959179, 0.013017049059271812, 0.01704438030719757, 0.02743975631892681, 0.022521082311868668, 0.03747701644897461, -0.038638193160295486, -0.022536972537636757, -0.006956541910767555, 0.0031938417814671993, -0.008245883509516716, -0.014842700213193893, 0.005286534316837788, -0.01729506254196167, 0.01912994310259819, 0.018663527444005013, 0.020647181198000908, 0.010424097068607807, 0.014188178814947605, 0.012851648963987827, -0.05628369003534317, -0.012382516637444496, -0.04570766165852547, 0.004807162564247847, -0.03126872703433037, 0.006198547314852476, 0.01526019535958767, -0.01943790540099144, 0.017127390950918198, -0.0071205273270606995, -0.03692271560430527, 0.01759270206093788, 0.008288266137242317, 0.0605279915034771, -0.028075866401195526, -0.05586642771959305, 0.022568169981241226, 0.05158756673336029, -0.007949207909405231, 0.028757890686392784, -0.04775412380695343, -0.05216727778315544, -0.016031965613365173, -0.010197297669947147, 0.019078321754932404, 0.02853972464799881, -0.025546511635184288, -0.01930803433060646, 0.008947663940489292, 0.0016914544394239783, -0.008827594108879566, -0.030478226020932198, 0.04430937394499779, 0.09252607077360153, -0.008039473555982113, -0.0157887265086174, 0.0021426519379019737, 0.00930694304406643, 0.050825972110033035, 0.001985729206353426, 0.014600838534533978, -0.023467352613806725, 0.008549248799681664, 0.014886589720845222, 0.010816618800163269, -0.04894198104739189, 0.025396348908543587, 0.07514725625514984, 0.027830248698592186, -0.014536397531628609, 0.008089703507721424, -0.0160636305809021, -0.01615510880947113, 0.021507399156689644, 0.00843719206750393, 0.0383155457675457, -0.016921965405344963, 0.010296843014657497, 0.011261321604251862, 0.01860375888645649, -0.025401979684829712, -0.03559598699212074, 0.05699891969561577, -0.00908264797180891, -0.03929198160767555, -0.040786273777484894, -0.035513199865818024, 0.0715157762169838, -0.03875173255801201, 0.01583678647875786, 0.056501783430576324, 0.008876730687916279, 0.0007121817325241864, 0.011585930362343788, -0.0472072958946228, 0.0026580363046377897, 0.003668475430458784, -0.017759161069989204, -0.02235238254070282, 0.011701634153723717, -0.013026366010308266, 0.006953718140721321, -0.017762565985322, 0.01899806410074234, -0.0253145694732666, 0.03517672047019005, -0.0011038568336516619, -0.00858335755765438, 0.03334523364901543, -0.008466498926281929, -0.03451971337199211, -0.008438479155302048, 0.002059900900349021, -0.0011270293034613132, 0.018499257043004036, -0.05319928005337715, 0.0021881728898733854, -0.04876391217112541, -0.015665674582123756, 0.010683821514248848, -0.009177060797810555, -0.040520913898944855, -0.011598466895520687, -0.010377161204814911, -0.03943541273474693, -0.02147367037832737, 0.009394075721502304, -0.001494336174800992, -0.01843942143023014, -0.03061973862349987, 0.024228688329458237, 0.0327879972755909, 0.01759069599211216, 0.013404259458184242, -0.04951140284538269, -0.036043357104063034, -0.03735114261507988, -0.010853364132344723, -0.014376893639564514, -0.009476509876549244, 0.030284419655799866, 0.020051393657922745, 0.0023654126562178135, 0.00702480087056756, -0.06514178216457367, -0.06546033918857574, 0.022675730288028717, 0.008855492807924747, -0.003797023557126522, 0.001559809548780322, -0.010883045382797718, 0.08532056212425232, 0.02968495897948742, -0.05361050367355347, -0.053522974252700806, 0.022643817588686943, -0.014802555553615093, -0.014660532586276531, -0.0153972078114748, 0.014872529543936253, 0.020693784579634666, 0.017286155372858047, -0.01538814790546894, 0.006838152185082436, 0.04684204235672951, -0.015581837855279446, -0.01462928019464016, 0.005226728972047567, 0.005144639406353235, 0.011934436857700348, 0.05365869775414467, 0.027536500245332718, -0.015510168857872486, 0.022409949451684952, -0.011453879997134209, 0.026483885943889618, -0.018092703074216843, -0.06274029612541199, 0.03560851141810417, 0.03329206630587578, 0.004129035398364067, -0.05158664286136627, 0.013544815592467785, 0.05798737332224846, -0.02360345982015133, 0.0021466081961989403, 0.009604480117559433, 0.01613629423081875, -0.021625341847538948, -0.018337344750761986, 0.049101173877716064, -0.005854048766195774, 0.01637476496398449, -0.035104162991046906, -0.00023380224592983723, 0.004698600620031357, 0.04257843643426895, -0.009032109752297401, -0.021841607987880707, 0.02588804066181183, 0.02508816309273243, -0.007327656727284193, 0.02247944101691246, -0.06242065131664276, 0.01906598173081875, -0.0624300092458725, -0.022762374952435493, -0.021661903709173203, 0.03794204071164131, 0.014576171524822712, 0.07287909835577011, -0.007810327690094709, 0.014558400958776474, 0.0013066033134236932, 0.002694184659048915, -0.06863345205783844, 0.04992572218179703, -0.03295089676976204, -0.002243389142677188, 0.0019082039361819625, -0.03489378094673157, 0.016416925936937332, -0.006796439178287983, -0.003612253814935684, -0.010991089977324009, 0.016097702085971832, -0.0405636765062809, 0.0019027591915801167, -0.014522405341267586, -0.022740133106708527, -0.016151851043105125, 0.04091113433241844, 0.03394465148448944, -0.021485306322574615, -0.014572834596037865, 0.05898966267704964, -0.014551084488630295, -0.010725324042141438, -0.018957987427711487, 0.03898117318749428, 0.023144660517573357, 0.011164897121489048, 0.04705541580915451, 0.040895044803619385, -0.08418776839971542, 0.03871483728289604, 0.018908578902482986, -0.01916499435901642, 0.05629666894674301, -0.05965607985854149, -0.019827336072921753, 0.0029912430327385664, -0.004916952922940254, 0.028609350323677063, 0.024807406589388847, 0.012389558367431164, 0.01437084749341011, 0.03890682011842728, 0.017751544713974, -0.019649391993880272, 0.02615373022854328, 0.081306092441082, 0.01791563257575035, 0.01829371228814125, -0.04843178763985634, -0.008437207899987698, 0.018283933401107788, -0.004323137924075127, -0.0026999390684068203, 0.04621778428554535, -0.003470838302746415, -0.015412243083119392, -0.00977633148431778, -0.0034820404835045338, -0.04265667870640755, -0.02247428521513939, 0.02287321723997593, -0.0051512462086975574, -0.008993204683065414, 0.008714323863387108, 0.06560549139976501, 0.039766088128089905, 0.015057379379868507, -0.0183042474091053, -0.03633315488696098, -0.06945554167032242, 0.014658121392130852, 0.04870850220322609, 0.009268637746572495, -0.04400549829006195, 0.03128747269511223, -0.013632292859256268, -0.002090904163196683, 0.0033649811521172523, -0.02752239815890789, -0.004370964597910643, 0.006086311303079128, 0.0017901323735713959, 0.02984427660703659, -0.021809274330735207, -0.0463036485016346, -0.014317726716399193, -0.04811429977416992, 0.024904673919081688, -0.06022704392671585, -0.012913515791296959, -0.05905068293213844, 0.03063260205090046, 0.016926869750022888, -0.006358195561915636, -0.04217885807156563, -0.006540818139910698, -0.011991293169558048, 0.005914111156016588, -0.04789314419031143, -0.061739347875118256, -0.016024645417928696, 0.04446452483534813, -0.013790461234748363, 0.05159388482570648, 0.0007263071602210402, -0.03439174219965935, 0.04785314202308655, -0.03485407680273056, -0.034771718084812164, -0.027173787355422974, -0.014183910563588142, 0.05262444168329239, 0.016481876373291016, -0.01057352963835001, 0.04817073419690132, 0.002318592742085457, -0.008695476688444614, -0.006317645311355591, -0.05851682648062706, 0.054460108280181885, -0.05502113699913025, -0.017415402457118034, -0.021350130438804626, 0.031201686710119247, 0.01320229284465313, -0.0014807343250140548, 0.029154084622859955, -0.002112847985699773, -0.03813453018665314, 0.007396335247904062, 0.048630133271217346, 0.015998901799321175, -0.000307629321468994, -0.014080749824643135, 0.016255801543593407, 0.04231683909893036, 0.011554306373000145, -0.04281274601817131, 0.014012960717082024, -0.06075526401400566, -0.0235835500061512, 0.01937667466700077, -0.05340564250946045, 0.011773690581321716, -0.010072611272335052, 0.011637475341558456, 0.057801004499197006, -0.024456925690174103, 0.0016269482439383864, -0.03635363653302193, 0.032667454332113266, 0.05400453135371208, -0.0282722320407629, -0.029889190569519997, 0.0001896887260954827, 0.008293627761304379, 0.006402518134564161, -0.03644512966275215, 0.01892784796655178, -0.0028457087464630604, 0.005028721876442432, -0.05393017455935478, -0.023427678272128105, 0.03537774085998535, 0.008251253515481949, -0.05119673162698746, -0.018103649839758873, -0.026981450617313385, 0.0015925482148304582, -0.00593049731105566, -0.0128767229616642, 0.04199664294719696, -0.012263506650924683, -0.04307521879673004, 0.016789333894848824, 0.040487244725227356, 0.0838371142745018, 0.009585839696228504, -0.010628560557961464, 0.04131186008453369, 0.006541523151099682, 0.0017048000590875745, 0.013117584399878979, -0.0022510825656354427, -0.014105605892837048, -0.018662968650460243, 0.0008164974860846996, -0.01862759329378605, -0.016584863886237144, -0.001710976823233068, 0.0002416036877548322, 0.057586152106523514, 0.009947629645466805, -0.01133075263351202, -0.003918409813195467, 0.02458183467388153, -0.050108134746551514, -0.03712853044271469, -0.01812828704714775, 0.021749092265963554, 0.0299160648137331, 0.021468011662364006, 0.01251787506043911, -0.023716460913419724, -0.009233586490154266, 0.008396313525736332, 0.04319117218255997, -0.012266200967133045, 0.003790660761296749, 0.04970403015613556, -0.0075718411244452, 0.011723024770617485, 0.019160063937306404, 0.004083368927240372, -0.01422414556145668, 0.007212489377707243, 0.00035174432559870183, -0.021186551079154015, -0.057284411042928696, -0.01718960888683796, 0.08490687608718872, -0.02106565795838833, 0.05651018023490906, 0.01701669953763485, 0.02874419465661049, -0.005531282629817724, -0.06667286157608032, 0.002275281585752964, 0.027857528999447823, 0.007966773584485054, 0.03418166935443878, -0.02424984611570835, 0.007531925104558468, 0.032435957342386246, 0.03926493600010872, -0.032248422503471375, 0.0631992444396019, 0.010192148387432098, 0.045304760336875916, 0.014521526172757149, -0.018770944327116013, 0.0007570478483103216, 0.045335061848163605, -0.017093239352107048, 0.040601447224617004, -0.05205126479268074, -0.026055416092276573, 0.023390306159853935, 0.05095807462930679, 0.009550193324685097, -0.053552526980638504, -0.02558382973074913, -0.01475050300359726, 0.03396374359726906, 0.057946283370256424, -0.037052400410175323, 0.0020559628028422594, 0.008081750944256783, 0.039426758885383606, -0.06381847709417343, 0.04645739495754242, -0.013213527388870716, -0.06792864203453064, -0.030000509694218636, -0.02972641959786415, -0.05169781669974327, 0.01568836346268654, -0.009019526652991772, -0.0019184501143172383, 0.01208783220499754, -0.0011137822875753045, 0.04017475247383118, -0.020188618451356888, 0.07026823610067368, 0.019524214789271355, 0.07674238085746765, 0.014132884331047535, -0.02389581874012947, -0.010951128788292408, -0.01471779402345419, 0.1290314644575119, 0.036601096391677856, 0.06223632022738457, -0.043856047093868256, -0.00940737035125494, 0.025785483419895172, -0.0017326787346974015, 0.010241705924272537, -0.01343908254057169, -0.009680764749646187, -0.018822617828845978, 0.02163202501833439, 0.05287972465157509, 0.032109424471855164, -0.009556327015161514, 0.02312619425356388, -0.01531614363193512, -0.0037752522621303797, 0.0028979082126170397, 0.05332570523023605, -0.023744825273752213, -0.02301858365535736, -0.03155596926808357, 0.010400469414889812, 0.038402408361434937, -0.029318755492568016, -0.026011306792497635, -0.03710944205522537, -0.028966154903173447, 0.0253915898501873, -0.02485954388976097, -0.010397443547844887, 0.04409027472138405, 0.058526962995529175, 0.009029923938214779, -0.011033712886273861, 0.007231205701828003, 0.002005957765504718, -0.0026159961707890034, 0.06877291202545166, 0.01283474825322628, -0.008427769877016544, 0.026144981384277344, 0.012821784242987633, -0.05892280861735344, 0.0019186690915375948, 0.0022762359585613012, 0.020694788545370102, -0.0026983125135302544, 0.007023754995316267, -0.021728012710809708, -0.04027635604143143, -0.02148730307817459, -0.0002088021719828248, -0.040200669318437576, 0.018568523228168488, 0.0029012300074100494, 0.002119263866916299, -0.01059078611433506, -0.02341851033270359, 0.007236892357468605, -0.025880523025989532, 0.03035641647875309, 0.020744966343045235, -0.03191974014043808, -0.03058849833905697, 0.018939685076475143, 0.012067542411386967, -0.021454844623804092, -0.03091919980943203, -0.017959462478756905, -0.05041477084159851, -0.033569008111953735, -0.03606428578495979, -0.02493089810013771, 0.0029311152175068855, -0.006489654071629047, 0.02001059800386429, -0.007736280094832182, -0.03804130479693413, -0.04133778437972069, 0.03098004311323166, -0.02250790037214756, 0.009834853932261467, -0.027323387563228607, 0.003463975852355361, 0.04396951571106911, 0.030556296929717064, -0.0053399233147501945, 0.002070206915959716, -0.02393363043665886, 0.06490277498960495, 0.0010978605132550001, -0.07225523144006729, -0.03601745143532753, 0.02629079855978489, -0.034961435943841934, 0.008223691955208778, 0.01341936644166708, 0.04993869736790657, 0.03543596342206001, 0.0065447562374174595, -0.004055495373904705, 0.00369411613792181, 0.00851851049810648, -0.00985676795244217, -0.00038716872222721577, -0.048421747982501984, -0.013608992099761963, 0.0020555644296109676, -0.018536562100052834, 0.0059047238901257515, 0.008817304857075214, -0.03313707560300827, -0.013334764167666435, 0.012257321737706661, -0.026827272027730942, -0.05286349728703499, 0.03026960976421833, -0.03148100525140762, 0.025713855400681496, -0.00737352017313242, 0.013004430569708347, 0.0009178792824968696, -0.01681208238005638, -0.00818177405744791, 0.004447344224900007, 0.010603148490190506, 0.006118937395513058, -0.04088209941983223, 0.008425235748291016, 0.04547343775629997, 0.026605360209941864, 0.020947908982634544, -0.01044823694974184, 0.0280362069606781, 0.012238690629601479, 0.05572183430194855, 0.00048211272223852575, 0.0033143393229693174, 0.0072198291309177876, -0.04708056524395943, -0.00872773863375187, 0.038860421627759933, -0.018566830083727837, -0.0004489024868234992, -0.003859128337353468, -0.003211998613551259, -0.016565386205911636, 0.052630744874477386, -0.06423995643854141, 0.010185346938669682, -0.020356399938464165, -0.026662589982151985, 0.011052924208343029, 0.02120739035308361, -0.017460862174630165, 0.037292830646038055, 0.0025917189195752144, 0.01726592890918255, 0.03277404233813286, 0.012782711535692215, 0.01094889733940363, -0.03151978924870491, 0.017209358513355255, -0.012614685110747814, 0.006428951863199472, -0.020601561293005943, 0.012827950529754162, 0.03139199689030647, -0.03015046939253807, -0.0052872831001877785, -0.02197665348649025, 0.030846185982227325, -0.032985080033540726, -0.018421797081828117, -0.02395743504166603, -0.03150936961174011, 0.05691736936569214, -0.05452863126993179, 0.044483233243227005, 0.0036732566077262163, -0.0846797451376915, 0.014827215112745762, -0.0006970809772610664, -0.0747106671333313, -0.03987801820039749, -0.016185259446501732, -0.01982663944363594, 0.04387228563427925, 0.0025768319610506296, -0.014827607199549675, 0.01825934275984764, 0.003547640284523368, 0.01620866172015667, -0.027050219476222992, -0.025151021778583527, 0.02916073240339756, 0.034256793558597565, -0.02205376699566841, 0.07509933412075043, -0.06733633577823639, -0.07095102220773697, 0.06454198062419891, -0.04877867177128792, 0.04355593025684357, -0.017675837501883507, -0.00013597530778497458, 0.017916901037096977, 0.047897569835186005, 0.04104337468743324, 0.04045955464243889, -0.001291742199100554, -0.01251264102756977, -0.04791748896241188, 0.007786217145621777, -0.009241315536201, 0.018906330689787865, 0.022741785272955894, 0.00679209316149354, -0.028270265087485313, 0.00097716657910496, -0.008498863317072392, -0.012485876679420471, 0.004802994430065155, -0.01183953508734703, 0.023437313735485077, 0.0016258674440905452, 0.05858049541711807, -0.05836617574095726, 0.03288364037871361, 0.05170285701751709, 0.016239440068602562, -0.03477057069540024, 0.0053695146925747395, -0.024221090599894524, -0.03720751777291298, 0.007089822553098202, 0.011346177197992802, -0.05760457366704941, -0.03419993072748184, -0.017302099615335464, 0.037739306688308716, 0.011363694444298744, -0.02388438582420349, -0.027669789269566536, -0.064052514731884, 0.015145421028137207, -0.012256879359483719, 0.0025710626505315304, 0.0024535823613405228, -0.0026406035758554935, 0.05300484970211983, -0.07405595481395721, 0.043077196925878525, 0.03598352149128914, -0.026538722217082977, 0.0008954957593232393, -0.019932057708501816, 0.007971391081809998, 0.005101904273033142, 0.057066842913627625, -0.011315939016640186, -0.01878524012863636, -0.015043867751955986, -0.009802953340113163, -0.02297237515449524, -0.03935299441218376, 0.025012770667672157, -0.03474433347582817, -0.03349421173334122, 0.006757153198122978, 0.0021526638884097338, 0.02067996747791767, 0.017217520624399185, 0.0391777902841568, -0.03430348262190819, 0.007247759494930506, -0.0011495365761220455, -0.023402785882353783, -0.011004839092493057, -0.014212213456630707, 0.009275385178625584, 0.03474695235490799, -0.0014068682212382555, 0.003753046039491892, 0.014391202479600906, 0.020254388451576233, -0.045954156666994095, 0.025086533278226852, -0.012053463608026505, -0.021802831441164017, -0.005289291962981224, -0.01076477486640215, -0.004023236688226461, -0.03926197066903114, -0.018546871840953827, 0.05658182129263878, -0.011192073114216328, -0.0049310969188809395, 0.03705218434333801, 0.04277612268924713, -0.0067117172293365, -0.0012603129725903273, -0.005216190125793219, -0.002366267377510667, -0.04900946095585823, -0.002842199755832553, 0.01000741496682167, 0.02828008495271206, 0.006806935649365187, 0.03581405431032181, 0.02344416081905365, -0.009833874180912971, 0.045965664088726044, 0.04087919741868973, 0.003776904195547104, -0.002384138060733676, -0.017667625099420547, 0.05512015148997307, 0.016065895557403564, 0.02526019886136055, 0.02068224735558033, -0.005692870356142521, 0.043164175003767014, -0.016933251172304153, -0.010094373486936092, -0.05263204872608185, -0.04713169112801552, -0.05857759341597557, -0.02822975255548954, -0.004023578483611345, -0.011314405128359795, 0.0029492322355508804, 0.02756568416953087, 0.04208356514573097, -0.013977969996631145, 0.017238076776266098, -0.027907555922865868, 0.033176884055137634, -0.01971122995018959, -0.007943028584122658, 0.025444896891713142, -0.014309553429484367, -0.027179082855582237, 0.026287132874131203, 0.010002978146076202, -0.030133357271552086, 0.029820866882801056, -0.02373635396361351, -0.03229022026062012, 0.0011939769610762596, 0.04276540130376816, -0.050229884684085846, -0.027337264269590378, -0.031033921986818314, 0.002883479930460453, 0.00046079253661446273, -0.02154478058218956 ]
<p>I have a sample design that can be resumed in:</p> <ol> <li>Split the city in X areas and, for each area, sample 5% of the residences and get some informations about it;</li> <li>For each residence, interview ALL residents;</li> <li>In the end, weights to homes and residents are calculated.</li> </ol> <p>So, actually, I have 2 samples: one for residences and another for residents. My question is: what are the sampling designs and how declare it on survey()?</p> <p>Each dataset has this variables: CD_APONDE - A code to identify the splited areas V0300 - A code to identify the residences V0010 - The weight</p> <p>The first one (for the residences), I believe that is a stratified sampling and should declare like <code>svydesign(strata = ~ CD_APONDE, weights = ~ V0010, data = dados)</code>.</p> <p>The second (for residents, and my true question) I guess that is a stratified 1 - level Cluster Sampling design, but have not sure, and should use <code>svydesign(ids = ~ V0300, strata = ~ CD_APONDE, weights = ~ V0010, data = dados)</code>.</p> <p>Am I right? Wrong? 50/50?</p>
73,785
[ -0.03109741024672985, -0.009400402195751667, 0.01905927248299122, 0.033176861703395844, 0.030882198363542557, -0.0006650637951679528, 0.005437841638922691, -0.0413028709590435, 0.028018290176987648, -0.025666946545243263, 0.05426528677344322, 0.06083500012755394, 0.025080395862460136, 0.02072902023792267, 0.040945474058389664, -0.007914811372756958, -0.020815106108784676, -0.010968091897666454, 0.0005413861945271492, -0.018455591052770615, -0.017462221905589104, -0.008036595769226551, -0.021995747461915016, -0.026630574837327003, -0.062156837433576584, 0.01921149156987667, 0.0016041803173720837, -0.04945778846740723, 0.014801830984652042, 0.04413466528058052, -0.0360342301428318, -0.013254793360829353, -0.02861139364540577, -0.01648821495473385, 0.03779983893036842, -0.015472776256501675, -0.05400913953781128, -0.04673483967781067, -0.008248385973274708, 0.036207493394613266, -0.03826812654733658, -0.0040071094408631325, -0.02274424210190773, 0.003594327950850129, 0.029206831008195877, -0.026801520958542824, 0.023516826331615448, 0.0008017857326194644, 0.02743714489042759, -0.0353928841650486, 0.0382995530962944, 0.022576820105314255, 0.01313825137913227, 0.04556409269571304, -0.014422536827623844, 0.014562957920134068, 0.010125981643795967, 0.03689747303724289, 0.02191038429737091, -0.025953764095902443, 0.0002969690249301493, -0.002831344958394766, 0.005080124828964472, 0.0003640929935500026, -0.054775338619947433, -0.01951994001865387, -0.005477287340909243, -0.02184308134019375, 0.06757595390081406, -0.01890445314347744, 0.03154024854302406, -0.015027755871415138, -0.006948445457965136, -0.05119001492857933, 0.01257216464728117, -0.004174733534455299, -0.016653690487146378, 0.025277765467762947, 0.04556231200695038, -0.0031832242384552956, 0.008136419579386711, 0.015582644380629063, 0.012383983470499516, 0.015841346234083176, 0.020793458446860313, -0.014757385477423668, 0.06219007447361946, -0.02582147717475891, 0.005003013648092747, -0.01056970190256834, 0.004680741112679243, -0.004574265796691179, 0.06378020346164703, 0.002876500366255641, -0.006426592357456684, 0.028814654797315598, -0.010328997857868671, 0.058864839375019073, -0.03248230367898941, 0.019759051501750946, -0.01014302670955658, -0.02494058385491371, 0.003497435012832284, 0.013980015181005001, -0.05515957996249199, -0.012539409101009369, 0.005802921950817108, 0.0011697662994265556, -0.013121774420142174, -0.027938582003116608, 0.010621101595461369, 0.009286235086619854, 0.005106834229081869, -0.0019711009226739407, 0.028304465115070343, -0.0018923039315268397, 0.03927712142467499, 0.05249005928635597, 0.016575170680880547, 0.046204425394535065, 0.04757341742515564, -0.031111368909478188, 0.014079060405492783, -0.054764531552791595, -0.08318517357110977, 0.03556763753294945, 0.00398630416020751, -0.004392907954752445, -0.0428476557135582, 0.03570706397294998, 0.00962450634688139, -0.020387809723615646, 0.03946402668952942, -0.01745663210749626, 0.018840521574020386, -0.015146314166486263, -0.08662573993206024, -0.050462059676647186, -0.006105409003794193, 0.015468494966626167, 0.004633644130080938, -0.02541515603661537, -0.004416489042341709, -0.008092536590993404, 0.04987156018614769, -0.006798842456191778, 0.04767320305109024, 0.0036528920754790306, 0.03200516849756241, -0.01346417423337698, -0.024178218096494675, -0.01705210469663143, -0.016972491517663002, -0.004063373897224665, -0.03763759136199951, -0.05460280552506447, 0.013594726100564003, 0.04453146830201149, -0.017590656876564026, 0.001437585218809545, 0.010945622809231281, 0.02053617127239704, -0.006601855158805847, -0.0006750305183231831, 0.03724142909049988, -0.0299995020031929, 0.07542870938777924, -0.002491174964234233, 0.03596208989620209, 0.04672999307513237, -0.02659580670297146, 0.015333213843405247, 0.0018013741355389357, 0.014816889539361, 0.0485294908285141, -0.006458974909037352, 0.0026432317681610584, -0.03818671032786369, 0.0319201834499836, 0.026046430692076683, -0.012496975250542164, -0.02808520942926407, 0.017494304105639458, -0.011372087523341179, 0.03879283368587494, 0.009017672389745712, 0.000020320958356023766, 0.005800530314445496, 0.021671103313565254, -0.04154140129685402, -0.056524939835071564, -0.06593602150678635, -0.012909646145999432, -0.014995348639786243, -0.021588124334812164, -0.012739811092615128, -0.0356474444270134, 0.00015736681234557182, 0.02526087313890457, -0.04076578468084335, -0.06635693460702896, -0.013219335116446018, 0.026882432401180267, -0.025811346247792244, -0.007123193703591824, 0.03944438323378563, 0.04329313710331917, -0.033816251903772354, 0.0384344756603241, -0.004418741911649704, -0.02383057400584221, 0.01506061851978302, 0.007242786698043346, 0.009232564829289913, -0.02272568643093109, 0.007154291495680809, 0.005166312213987112, 0.05600682646036148, 0.0038400094490498304, 0.025769874453544617, -0.04838309437036514, 0.07414320111274719, 0.1344050019979477, -0.01527444925159216, -0.017325730994343758, 0.04255272448062897, 0.004002776462584734, 0.03699016198515892, -0.01890454813838005, 0.013304540887475014, -0.03312334418296814, 0.023006396368145943, 0.03790413215756416, -0.0011051654582843184, -0.02689417079091072, -0.011859160847961903, 0.061519503593444824, 0.033589255064725876, 0.023576803505420685, 0.028431301936507225, 0.007811045739799738, 0.002133149653673172, 0.028277071192860603, 0.005659088958054781, 0.049171749502420425, 0.02998580038547516, 0.021251996979117393, 0.005376076325774193, 0.019815007224678993, -0.03258786350488663, 0.04617909714579582, 0.08579343557357788, -0.025072062388062477, 0.04904448240995407, -0.011636309325695038, 0.021563097834587097, 0.030760779976844788, -0.030561616644263268, 0.00027769801090471447, 0.040569622069597244, 0.01807333715260029, -0.009097016416490078, 0.017293132841587067, -0.023145664483308792, -0.007464047987014055, 0.05447900667786598, -0.029466964304447174, 0.01253443118184805, 0.01163223572075367, -0.025978941470384598, 0.008200207725167274, -0.012424666434526443, -0.03948920592665672, -0.04506601393222809, 0.01134535577148199, 0.07970980554819107, -0.023322883993387222, -0.005528924986720085, -0.015973789617419243, -0.025687996298074722, -0.007696449290961027, -0.01664586365222931, 0.00466938829049468, 0.008481420576572418, -0.08234398812055588, 0.01221831887960434, -0.021484851837158203, -0.020617330446839333, 0.02504264935851097, 0.015635821968317032, -0.03957130014896393, 0.05538284033536911, -0.008165773935616016, -0.01500498503446579, -0.022199368104338646, -0.01997072622179985, 0.013585381209850311, 0.003126362105831504, -0.004506073426455259, 0.05022760108113289, 0.035687752068042755, -0.016365811228752136, 0.015760388225317, -0.04421933740377426, -0.02516241930425167, -0.03359587863087654, -0.02435716800391674, -0.02632029354572296, -0.010418307967483997, 0.008823389187455177, 0.051966696977615356, 0.0020861623343080282, -0.024866759777069092, -0.04290665686130524, -0.08110564947128296, 0.0014740412589162588, 0.013131842948496342, 0.017210161313414574, 0.022837329655885696, 0.01015674602240324, 0.0775119811296463, 0.022377029061317444, -0.02076827920973301, -0.005147333722561598, -0.013361557386815548, -0.037505365908145905, -0.004957741592079401, 0.026565145701169968, 0.00679759168997407, -0.015014009550213814, -0.005877193063497543, 0.015393533743917942, 0.02455357275903225, 0.06903423368930817, -0.026129312813282013, 0.03347492218017578, 0.02066183276474476, -0.000758844253141433, -0.009324961341917515, 0.0807943046092987, -0.01979617029428482, -0.03310982510447502, -0.02059905417263508, -0.010341936722397804, -0.011029904708266258, 0.03026987798511982, -0.03231499344110489, -0.01951049268245697, -0.03553524985909462, -0.00456613302230835, -0.044379327446222305, 0.035830218344926834, 0.016285628080368042, -0.03677335008978844, 0.017429862171411514, 0.03792490065097809, 0.04486830532550812, -0.02140582539141178, -0.06076280027627945, 0.04995023459196091, 0.025969229638576508, -0.0027951758820563555, -0.005732307210564613, 0.026508878916502, -0.0024438640102744102, 0.021145937964320183, -0.04275349900126457, -0.028823768720030785, 0.0006381334969773889, 0.04931485652923584, 0.00256579858250916, -0.0298687145113945, -0.05019960179924965, 0.05875426530838013, -0.08784450590610504, 0.006813253276050091, -0.00976815540343523, 0.07631740719079971, -0.039869360625743866, 0.020326292142271996, 0.03102019615471363, 0.003277164651080966, -0.011058097705245018, -0.014513666741549969, -0.047618117183446884, 0.01921219192445278, 0.0613870732486248, -0.023230399936437607, -0.010542252101004124, -0.017305033281445503, 0.024233601987361908, -0.014424667693674564, 0.01905634067952633, -0.0035461997613310814, 0.013864808715879917, -0.03503742441534996, 0.015439632348716259, 0.0009339821408502758, 0.005564036779105663, 0.00491245137527585, 0.027370909228920937, 0.0061056530103087425, 0.002342885360121727, 0.018955018371343613, 0.02217416651546955, 0.0032044914551079273, 0.00686917407438159, -0.05451047047972679, 0.013497104868292809, 0.013193115592002869, 0.04693332314491272, 0.026412885636091232, 0.03562261536717415, -0.058783236891031265, -0.026535023003816605, 0.014668804593384266, 0.04254675284028053, 0.019794845953583717, -0.02019583061337471, 0.0003845181199721992, 0.0021372693590819836, 0.010282808914780617, 0.010663843713700771, 0.013244505040347576, -0.015310022048652172, 0.013788892887532711, 0.050876252353191376, 0.02730672061443329, -0.07771076261997223, 0.032730814069509506, 0.06966899335384369, 0.00865145307034254, 0.0001963300019269809, -0.027683911845088005, 0.011318319477140903, -0.011643300764262676, 0.012018146924674511, 0.056375861167907715, 0.014851088635623455, 0.0067579918541014194, 0.018757285550236702, 0.03825986757874489, -0.017538370564579964, -0.033815931528806686, 0.04067513346672058, -0.004592570010572672, 0.02458765357732773, 0.00014182693848852068, -0.027119383215904236, 0.028253329917788506, 0.0002403593243798241, 0.04896469786763191, 0.028496911749243736, -0.009679918177425861, -0.09678676724433899, -0.03501582518219948, 0.01240555476397276, 0.00526059977710247, -0.03595102205872536, 0.0036658835597336292, -0.021549291908740997, -0.0344696044921875, 0.022356215864419937, -0.044505953788757324, 0.006730854511260986, -0.032131604850292206, 0.0024310918524861336, -0.015088074840605259, 0.0070549240335822105, -0.04500566050410271, -0.009168601594865322, -0.030477426946163177, 0.050318531692028046, -0.006455009337514639, -0.011175515130162239, -0.02094506286084652, 0.051012635231018066, 0.01792917028069496, 0.045833658427000046, -0.0745660588145256, -0.03865864872932434, -0.021842757239937782, 0.03790226951241493, -0.02227460965514183, -0.048598166555166245, -0.011121964082121849, 0.02644653245806694, 0.008670315146446228, 0.06276043504476547, 0.004978295415639877, -0.05030979961156845, 0.03399466350674629, 0.0628945603966713, -0.010073758661746979, -0.0017075733048841357, -0.011540163308382034, 0.05494960397481918, 0.014841039665043354, 0.014021619223058224, 0.025295883417129517, 0.02104697749018669, 0.00325579522177577, 0.003130629425868392, -0.04553157463669777, -0.034791842103004456, -0.06557165831327438, -0.005648404825478792, -0.03447466343641281, -0.0036235882434993982, -0.03891490772366524, -0.002469703322276473, -0.005396661814302206, 0.02476075291633606, -0.030996887013316154, -0.0446648970246315, 0.03855026513338089, 0.04091326519846916, -0.003617718117311597, -0.008446812629699707, -0.021975060924887657, 0.03017464280128479, 0.0008531971252523363, -0.0026657076086848974, 0.0052525317296385765, -0.04601987078785896, 0.015193440020084381, -0.012506670318543911, -0.036418650299310684, -0.01621406152844429, -0.04644354432821274, -0.004300182219594717, 0.02530595473945141, -0.042428117245435715, 0.019193418323993683, 0.018908021971583366, 0.07079929113388062, -0.012267930433154106, -0.008757812902331352, 0.003243199549615383, 0.013938604854047298, -0.0047177504748106, 0.007071370724588633, -0.009404183365404606, 0.09528812766075134, 0.010885928757488728, -0.010012838058173656, -0.0859307125210762, -0.025374777615070343, 0.02969670109450817, 0.018230723217129707, -0.02475559338927269, -0.06138242408633232, -0.008854749612510204, -0.0007976387278176844, -0.057508520781993866, -0.012781118974089622, 0.03343765810132027, -0.02876298315823078, -0.007164476905018091, -0.021579334512352943, 0.04318845644593239, 0.08334869146347046, -0.038786549121141434, 0.026537228375673294, 0.00617989432066679, -0.006703948602080345, 0.021618802100419998, -0.009264498949050903, -0.03392835706472397, -0.02529802732169628, -0.00806992594152689, -0.05052876099944115, 0.025036759674549103, 0.04473921284079552, 0.0004931498551741242, 0.002973679220303893, 0.0009694270556792617, -0.022729529067873955, 0.025697000324726105, 0.0037524420768022537, 0.006418029777705669, -0.03517886996269226, -0.02024020254611969, -0.05214851722121239, 0.03860072046518326, -0.033479269593954086, 0.006298307795077562, 0.05488335341215134, -0.009170536883175373, -0.022744864225387573, 0.02767302468419075, 0.07793065905570984, -0.000981140066869557, 0.013398285955190659, 0.015107633545994759, 0.006772907450795174, 0.03617703914642334, 0.009983588941395283, -0.03228428214788437, 0.007424637209624052, 0.023622510954737663, 0.01526479423046112, -0.005079903639853001, -0.04173407703638077, 0.016180317848920822, 0.07024624198675156, 0.0020376292522996664, 0.07887785881757736, 0.06716949492692947, -0.01621655561029911, 0.029294712468981743, -0.01859176903963089, -0.023067275062203407, -0.013280501589179039, 0.0022073518484830856, 0.0657731145620346, -0.01518144179135561, -0.023878298699855804, 0.03428009897470474, 0.017431335523724556, 0.05184628814458847, 0.03038266859948635, 0.03248579055070877, 0.010898384265601635, -0.007716324180364609, -0.057079561054706573, -0.0312897227704525, 0.0248744897544384, -0.012861534021794796, 0.024163024500012398, -0.010816040448844433, -0.03968409076333046, 0.04823030158877373, 0.04040537774562836, 0.022411076352000237, -0.03727328032255173, 0.011615468189120293, -0.0715121179819107, 0.011771353892982006, 0.023552531376481056, -0.007386388722807169, -0.007691504433751106, 0.017672453075647354, 0.0342281349003315, -0.014509855769574642, -0.012403207831084728, -0.04192725569009781, -0.021871645003557205, -0.04431743547320366, -0.03596903011202812, -0.05525427684187889, 0.010049376636743546, 0.00293540908023715, -0.00439026253297925, 0.016799354925751686, -0.030510930344462395, 0.0173786710947752, -0.003132279496639967, 0.01935482583940029, 0.024759551510214806, 0.055444151163101196, -0.014950011856853962, 0.05212299898266792, -0.011700141243636608, -0.007539111655205488, 0.1544550359249115, 0.06241138279438019, 0.026854338124394417, -0.055134519934654236, 0.03408863767981529, 0.048556555062532425, 0.010353898629546165, 0.025590768083930016, 0.001209831447340548, 0.025725796818733215, -0.007126692682504654, 0.029662463814020157, 0.040212199091911316, 0.011504479683935642, 0.017428794875741005, 0.043256841599941254, -0.0017341984203085303, -0.030925292521715164, 0.023463070392608643, -0.02278706803917885, -0.023831071332097054, -0.041982877999544144, -0.057098593562841415, 0.019588274881243706, 0.040761154145002365, 0.005190802738070488, -0.004286949522793293, -0.019165324047207832, -0.005486664827913046, 0.028812818229198456, 0.017562419176101685, -0.013602820225059986, 0.018856234848499298, -0.014694311656057835, -0.015659067779779434, -0.054163746535778046, 0.010821529664099216, -0.05502106249332428, -0.012949842028319836, 0.05246367305517197, -0.021115070208907127, -0.007054775953292847, -0.03324783593416214, 0.029948454350233078, -0.031658072024583817, 0.0021814554929733276, -0.0297944825142622, 0.03689543530344963, -0.008594333194196224, -0.005589651875197887, 0.01905391924083233, 0.027441514655947685, 0.011834623292088509, -0.05114857479929924, 0.0017846645787358284, 0.00519675062969327, 0.015105053782463074, -0.03905745968222618, -0.02466355450451374, -0.02123236656188965, -0.011911420151591301, -0.025854038074612617, 0.005465441849082708, 0.015298028476536274, -0.017631875351071358, 0.016563909128308296, -0.03377070650458336, 0.056919023394584656, -0.05190274864435196, 0.028541117906570435, 0.02203180454671383, -0.02522340603172779, -0.00713694840669632, -0.011631413362920284, -0.024031149223446846, 0.017604000866413116, 0.015659332275390625, -0.017427830025553703, -0.008264790289103985, -0.03033646009862423, -0.019518468528985977, 0.02052856981754303, -0.029948145151138306, -0.03942786157131195, -0.04516606777906418, 0.045649003237485886, 0.010511370375752449, 0.035369787365198135, 0.025106213986873627, 0.026523364707827568, 0.01788502186536789, 0.056250493973493576, -0.016934910789132118, -0.0531776137650013, 0.0011865674750879407, -0.008404044434428215, -0.006888053845614195, 0.007234875578433275, -0.022444268688559532, 0.05262279510498047, 0.019010134041309357, 0.00048715577577240765, -0.019617831334471703, 0.036284852772951126, 0.009112621657550335, 0.004966331645846367, -0.02873990871012211, -0.05955331027507782, 0.014395021833479404, -0.021418584510684013, 0.021622078493237495, -0.03191603720188141, -0.007277924567461014, -0.033546462655067444, -0.050743281841278076, -0.011506156995892525, -0.011524911969900131, -0.0570833720266819, 0.0011761125642806292, -0.01449599303305149, 0.012037874199450016, -0.0013602928956970572, -0.017044615000486374, -0.028240296989679337, -0.014976982027292252, -0.04553631320595741, -0.04096095636487007, -0.030086839571595192, -0.005416980478912592, 0.009753726422786713, 0.03211294114589691, -0.007780080661177635, -0.011775495484471321, 0.010845842771232128, 0.03240790218114853, -0.01676943339407444, -0.0188150554895401, 0.037279244512319565, 0.00250991084612906, 0.007427493575960398, 0.004073861055076122, -0.0248936265707016, -0.06427621096372604, 0.015131967142224312, -0.036837611347436905, 0.0379258468747139, 0.011538305319845676, 0.0006841500289738178, 0.0009860415011644363, 0.07245256751775742, -0.014233047142624855, -0.03685726597905159, -0.0020404369570314884, -0.010601927526295185, 0.03519914299249649, 0.0009291385649703443, 0.00638458551838994, 0.03432842716574669, -0.029084205627441406, 0.030642973259091377, 0.008718983270227909, -0.013495884835720062, -0.030070224776864052, -0.01602545939385891, -0.01208775769919157, 0.041209496557712555, -0.003607768565416336, -0.028683800250291824, 0.022907638922333717, 0.050494659692049026, -0.058856185525655746, 0.01470157690346241, -0.052211906760931015, -0.0041710794903337955, -0.019054478034377098, -0.05002381280064583, 0.0030519156716763973, -0.018662214279174805, -0.006260815542191267, -0.06135718896985054, 0.01670394279062748, 0.035609930753707886, -0.022367354482412338, 0.01774112693965435, 0.01413897704333067, 0.014703805558383465, -0.04275862127542496, 0.05325714498758316, -0.03757546842098236, 0.012359767220914364, 0.0006518978043459356, -0.03169761598110199, 0.011254617013037205, 0.01520530879497528, 0.0330638587474823, 0.024927835911512375, -0.009274688549339771, -0.03060428984463215, 0.004479055758565664, -0.05419318005442619, 0.02158747799694538, -0.0451459139585495, 0.0035396101884543896, 0.012484526261687279, -0.01445412915199995, 0.016475234180688858, 0.08717399090528488, 0.009403867647051811, -0.021024515852332115, 0.038091182708740234, 0.024795837700366974, 0.031412530690431595, -0.004410570953041315, -0.016816459596157074, 0.027676695957779884, 0.020735135301947594, 0.013988870196044445, -0.00363210984505713, 0.02089151181280613, 0.010973779484629631, -0.0016519763739779592, 0.031224822625517845, -0.04173417016863823, -0.00467826658859849, -0.029542379081249237, -0.01251455582678318, 0.0015710374573245645, -0.01865302585065365, 0.030580755323171616, -0.030582189559936523, -0.0009535671561025083, 0.022950954735279083, -0.03400760516524315, 0.005318009294569492, 0.018940072506666183, 0.005116615444421768, -0.045631054788827896, -0.01487746648490429, -0.01148828212171793, -0.05516071245074272, -0.041493676602840424, -0.02940678596496582, 0.00017629594367463142, -0.013671629130840302, -0.017803257331252098, 0.0313834585249424, 0.010512149892747402, 0.04831719025969505, -0.026618430390954018, -0.010197027586400509, 0.004433993715792894, -0.018914058804512024, 0.03938093036413193, -0.07423114031553268, 0.07242047041654587, 0.011913240887224674, -0.018143683671951294, -0.04604293778538704, -0.05109603330492973, -0.043773774057626724, 0.016283409669995308, 0.03352772817015648, 0.025516966357827187, -0.002250980120152235, 0.011396926827728748, 0.017940690740942955, 0.025127282366156578, 0.000836377264931798, 0.03575907647609711, 0.010029740631580353, -0.03380735218524933, 0.029729023575782776, -0.02267242968082428, 0.0160505510866642, -0.006930413190275431, 0.0005610911175608635, -0.004836782347410917, -0.0010235306108370423, 0.007435125298798084, 0.01877022534608841, -0.027295321226119995, 0.012506915256381035, 0.007694109808653593, 0.03359624743461609, -0.0022682014387100935, -0.015645205974578857, 0.05530567094683647, 0.0020702474284917116, -0.015763288363814354, 0.025505563244223595, -0.014697208069264889, -0.03147868812084198, 0.03910135477781296, -0.039933446794748306, 0.022086260840296745, -0.06068697199225426, -0.04541483148932457, -0.01678309217095375, -0.05669752508401871, -0.02000034786760807, 0.05089833214879036, 0.022557009011507034, 0.0027909178752452135, -0.001067419070750475, 0.010769293643534184, -0.014404015615582466, -0.021518100053071976, 0.007375708781182766, 0.017582615837454796, 0.027048775926232338, -0.015191702172160149, -0.02225613407790661, 0.03431696072220802, 0.035211049020290375, 0.02806965634226799, -0.00950826145708561, 0.04430314898490906, 0.006350253708660603, -0.01472369022667408, 0.0008039060630835593, 0.007203956134617329, -0.021798502653837204, 0.0198491420596838, -0.03207302838563919, 0.032206811010837555, -0.03626960515975952, 0.009486845694482327, -0.027828937396407127, -0.037184420973062515, -0.01836608350276947, -0.0011210941011086106, 0.03220468759536743, 0.054930295795202255, 0.004864371847361326, -0.003708138596266508, -0.010494939051568508, -0.04647226259112358, 0.04246700182557106, -0.054065629839897156, 0.0435568131506443, -0.0017805774696171284, 0.03316546231508255, 0.0021154158748686314, 0.014323800802230835, -0.004964594263583422, -0.018597835674881935, 0.008667072281241417, 0.058821965008974075, 0.03765958547592163, -0.02477693371474743, -0.03780099004507065, 0.010628334246575832, 0.00579602736979723, -0.03823898360133171, -0.0381239652633667, -0.026804227381944656, -0.0017874089535325766, 0.0010900829220190644, -0.011522104032337666 ]
<p>I am thinking about how best to construct a data set containing one record for every individual in the entire United States population starting from something like the <a href="http://www.asdfree.com/search/label/american%20community%20survey%20%28acs%29" rel="nofollow">American community survey</a> or the <a href="http://www.asdfree.com/search/label/united%20states%20decennial%20census%20public%20use%20microdata%20sample%20%28pums%29" rel="nofollow">United States decennial census public use microdata files</a>.</p> <p>Both of these "starting points" would be very large, they have between 1 and 5% of the entire United States population already.</p> <p>So long as this concept is not majorly flawed from the start, having this synthetic but complete data set would make it much easier to merge on (cold-deck impute) information from other, smaller data sets.</p> <p>One could obviously take a simplistic approach and - for every record - make the same number of records as that record's weights. This wouldn't be much different than just analyzing the data set with <a href="http://www.stata.com/help.cgi?weights" rel="nofollow">Stata's frequency weights</a> but that will obviously create problems in smaller geographic areas.</p> <p>Say you've got a small county that you know for a fact has 10,000 residents, but in your sample only ten records. Obviously you cannot simply expand those ten records to the 10,000 residents on their own. Since you'll have a very lumpy (and wrong) age, race, income distribution within the county. However, if you took a bit of information from nearby areas and projected the probabilities of age, race, income, etc. of each of those 10,000 records you're creating from scratch, you could semi-randomly create 10,000 records that would look more reasonable for that specific county.</p> <p>I am unsure whether this sort of thing has not been done because it's a terrible idea for some reason or if statisticians and demographers simply haven't had the computing power to quickly deal with 300 million records of data <a href="http://www.asdfree.com/2013/03/column-store-r-or-how-i-learned-to-stop.html" rel="nofollow">until very recently</a>.</p>
73,786
[ -0.034925203770399094, 0.003241556463763118, 0.03398161008954048, -0.024959038943052292, 0.058183327317237854, -0.03800142928957939, -0.00545891746878624, -0.021394597366452217, -0.020750023424625397, -0.010619602166116238, 0.009075752459466457, 0.0021796664223074913, 0.02858544886112213, 0.015484183095395565, -0.00019609081209637225, 0.030169278383255005, 0.008550874888896942, 0.036338839679956436, -0.044896479696035385, -0.023266488686203957, 0.02505761757493019, -0.0019438938470557332, -0.012175504118204117, -0.029142048209905624, -0.02191227115690708, 0.012332656420767307, 0.014049884863197803, -0.061667345464229584, -0.002772877225652337, 0.0714036077260971, -0.045834243297576904, -0.011526870541274548, -0.007635971996933222, 0.033129364252090454, 0.05555396154522896, 0.02072330377995968, -0.025044424459338188, -0.017405269667506218, 0.024283889681100845, 0.06188658997416496, -0.08893222361803055, 0.003548927139490843, -0.025777624920010567, -0.01563473977148533, 0.0018396144732832909, 0.016679193824529648, 0.01677662320435047, -0.004026360344141722, 0.022630851715803146, -0.019746318459510803, 0.05169476568698883, -0.03208117559552193, 0.016785966232419014, 0.05045522376894951, -0.02193361148238182, -0.015306660905480385, 0.039891019463539124, 0.018660496920347214, -0.006220095790922642, -0.011744891293346882, 0.019831303507089615, 0.008324132300913334, -0.028395116329193115, -0.06425405293703079, -0.007243644446134567, -0.004200759343802929, 0.010189656168222427, 0.00369558809325099, 0.03808965906500816, -0.04026533663272858, 0.03877323120832443, 0.0066281650215387344, 0.01279132068157196, 0.009304298087954521, 0.003008656669408083, -0.005996455904096365, 0.006692687980830669, 0.0007434153812937438, 0.046910610049963, -0.010374737903475761, -0.013725221157073975, 0.017509685829281807, 0.04526899755001068, 0.03916313499212265, 0.026794975623488426, -0.008326372131705284, 0.037245143204927444, -0.031967226415872574, 0.0234967228025198, 0.012873672880232334, -0.006934810895472765, -0.033585283905267715, 0.04441134259104729, -0.013566162437200546, -0.014140456914901733, 0.06161222234368324, -0.0457967147231102, 0.026564816012978554, -0.021870853379368782, -0.019854219630360603, -0.04849826171994209, -0.01224646158516407, 0.011460216715931892, 0.03037378191947937, -0.0336579866707325, -0.01484003383666277, -0.019031628966331482, -0.021756870672106743, 0.0038000524509698153, -0.016910698264837265, -0.015558943152427673, 0.002272874116897583, 0.016393614932894707, -0.010886070318520069, 0.021143339574337006, 0.015208647586405277, 0.052468061447143555, 0.014517662115395069, 0.03242674097418785, 0.05499309301376343, 0.04169955477118492, -0.06239829212427139, 0.009193413890898228, -0.06424695253372192, -0.03260279446840286, 0.014987148344516754, -0.0008601311128586531, -0.013570521958172321, -0.026899471879005432, 0.04353857412934303, 0.013791680335998535, -0.048175156116485596, 0.06894785910844803, -0.013236350379884243, 0.015480319038033485, -0.02437932789325714, -0.10258525609970093, -0.054566070437431335, -0.00963850412517786, -0.03452785685658455, 0.0073837474919855595, -0.04283808544278145, 0.022524060681462288, -0.014243938960134983, 0.01588580571115017, 0.010157741606235504, 0.060040611773729324, 0.01852983795106411, 0.07795489579439163, 0.019018180668354034, 0.016431747004389763, -0.014291574247181416, -0.00036928028566762805, 0.016276124864816666, -0.053135138005018234, -0.05735580250620842, 0.051700159907341, 0.036106206476688385, -0.03480928763747215, -0.011276635341346264, 0.012420016340911388, 0.03133070096373558, -0.02025960013270378, -0.013928543776273727, 0.02828679233789444, -0.025870224460959435, 0.04800315946340561, 0.015790553763508797, 0.002365073887631297, 0.023477064445614815, -0.032001033425331116, 0.01796872168779373, 0.04812910780310631, 0.033204566687345505, 0.03393925726413727, -0.012988956645131111, 0.024477217346429825, -0.038523536175489426, -0.011065568774938583, -0.00817396491765976, 0.009502338245511055, -0.014158308506011963, -0.003515823045745492, -0.02519894763827324, 0.06775210797786713, 0.017873182892799377, 0.02023182436823845, -0.0035614711232483387, 0.058101754635572433, -0.06937552988529205, -0.053352195769548416, -0.03682353347539902, -0.00690951943397522, -0.014764934778213501, -0.0005081965355202556, 0.022449316456913948, -0.019494231790304184, -0.00041489858995191753, 0.006164273712784052, -0.03158710151910782, -0.02405860647559166, -0.002576638711616397, 0.04821810871362686, -0.04779122397303581, -0.015281997621059418, 0.04246686026453972, 0.030993562191724777, -0.019396357238292694, 0.04380069300532341, -0.055417828261852264, -0.058590881526470184, 0.010302971117198467, -0.03298308327794075, 0.05894394591450691, 0.0002765075187198818, 0.04056951031088829, -0.01250743493437767, -0.005572968162596226, -0.008136697113513947, 0.026635048910975456, -0.0601499080657959, 0.06077257916331291, 0.08894763886928558, -0.02165408246219158, -0.012568877078592777, 0.03904202952980995, 0.018034260720014572, 0.024706130847334862, -0.02016581781208515, -0.009332559071481228, -0.0616808645427227, 0.01231225486844778, 0.04536815360188484, -0.0005456699873320758, -0.0269574336707592, -0.002674724906682968, 0.05137120559811592, 0.05283448100090027, 0.005127661861479282, 0.012301689945161343, -0.0019566514529287815, -0.008574849925935268, 0.016718506813049316, -0.009834031574428082, 0.007340859156101942, 0.0246443971991539, 0.01377034094184637, 0.004746052902191877, 0.0005995190003886819, -0.0010448502143844962, 0.03986331820487976, 0.052341215312480927, 0.024502089247107506, 0.02127893641591072, -0.009374831803143024, 0.00007795417332090437, 0.04639260098338127, -0.0436369851231575, 0.028038281947374344, 0.030331533402204514, -0.03159790113568306, -0.002091487869620323, -0.0035446856636554003, -0.020787909626960754, -0.01627488061785698, 0.014826656319200993, -0.009537882171571255, -0.004215632099658251, 0.010015911422669888, -0.026126200333237648, 0.013730831444263458, -0.012462193146348, -0.04068703576922417, -0.025557447224855423, 0.0010741854785010219, 0.04268258437514305, 0.011545165441930294, 0.01848822832107544, -0.03452232480049133, -0.02301250956952572, 0.004281059373170137, -0.0019858344458043575, 0.009984936565160751, 0.022342773154377937, -0.06649487465620041, -0.013046760112047195, -0.018685847520828247, -0.0349673368036747, 0.0510367751121521, 0.025653328746557236, -0.02923966757953167, 0.018459483981132507, 0.027575939893722534, -0.015381773933768272, -0.010802539065480232, 0.010052508674561977, -0.03820975124835968, -0.018945766612887383, -0.02683285064995289, 0.037822283804416656, 0.06701212376356125, -0.0885559618473053, 0.014905881136655807, -0.035529546439647675, -0.043002899736166, -0.040397994220256805, -0.005871359724551439, 0.007955512963235378, -0.01616314984858036, 0.01602727733552456, 0.015812082216143608, -0.0226907916367054, 0.0108163021504879, -0.042430244386196136, -0.0781978964805603, 0.04077623412013054, 0.0037710925098508596, 0.047791484743356705, 0.029002239927649498, 0.0000019892179352609674, 0.06879419088363647, 0.00976947695016861, -0.014504773542284966, -0.031898315995931625, 0.0012527074432000518, 0.0007288592169061303, 0.004292069468647242, 0.016562554985284805, 0.023407280445098877, -0.03536193445324898, -0.035135649144649506, -0.0035548631567507982, 0.021293599158525467, 0.042021363973617554, 0.017183760181069374, 0.01089493278414011, 0.025897186249494553, -0.045109789818525314, -0.0038605746813118458, 0.05296090245246887, 0.010520738549530506, -0.031998470425605774, 0.009104048833251, -0.04572341591119766, 0.026072537526488304, 0.018280446529388428, -0.05580439046025276, -0.019832495599985123, 0.013282977975904942, 0.023202456533908844, -0.08596216142177582, 0.01157216913998127, -0.01189852599054575, -0.0456867441534996, 0.0033855747897177935, -0.0029425581451505423, 0.030025290325284004, -0.011795911937952042, -0.029450828209519386, 0.021951554343104362, 0.055155735462903976, 0.04445640370249748, 0.02970762737095356, -0.017888950183987617, 0.00018344396085012704, 0.01590709015727043, 0.010645282454788685, 0.011705812998116016, 0.02501307986676693, 0.09282910823822021, 0.0028328602202236652, -0.037836622446775436, -0.038336314260959625, 0.03549344465136528, -0.046835195273160934, -0.015459004789590836, -0.021098613739013672, 0.06022520363330841, -0.017885887995362282, 0.04365384951233864, 0.009494845755398273, -0.0071966745890676975, -0.04411618411540985, 0.01402073074132204, -0.06407064944505692, -0.03996838256716728, 0.01936311088502407, -0.01068390067666769, -0.002232515951618552, -0.06514724344015121, 0.046055473387241364, 0.03447560966014862, -0.01873433217406273, -0.03106091171503067, 0.02012931928038597, -0.036348868161439896, 0.018090443685650826, 0.010852605104446411, -0.011858693324029446, 0.000199167596292682, 0.022062838077545166, 0.029315195977687836, 0.004882348235696554, 0.02149757742881775, -0.006417672149837017, 0.02642708271741867, -0.04082423448562622, -0.03936212882399559, 0.02194100245833397, 0.03186932951211929, 0.04518049955368042, -0.0013353109825402498, 0.032681774348020554, -0.06378860026597977, -0.0018283067038282752, -0.011242438107728958, 0.032572563737630844, 0.018530748784542084, -0.009547203779220581, -0.01539610791951418, -0.02802598662674427, -0.029884306713938713, -0.008763094432651997, -0.012774037197232246, -0.0007650461047887802, 0.02116432972252369, 0.0547248013317585, -0.00978761725127697, -0.034595128148794174, 0.02184406667947769, 0.03776466101408005, -0.012345044873654842, 0.029241129755973816, -0.01622159220278263, -0.008799929171800613, -0.006561148911714554, -0.021634547039866447, 0.026213208213448524, 0.01961752213537693, 0.008658490143716335, 0.0020183492451906204, 0.05549214780330658, -0.010376746766269207, -0.07353013008832932, 0.04928864166140556, 0.011732753366231918, 0.06230330839753151, -0.016793297603726387, -0.036152392625808716, 0.044500261545181274, 0.014615564607083797, 0.0344199500977993, 0.041553448885679245, 0.013851528987288475, -0.11703287065029144, -0.04183493182063103, 0.03429313749074936, 0.028929568827152252, -0.011532031930983067, 0.008780133910477161, -0.04098360985517502, -0.03935466334223747, 0.006875155959278345, -0.029503243044018745, 0.011754211038351059, -0.016592176631093025, 0.011793388053774834, -0.021632149815559387, -0.04804787039756775, 0.0007698081899434328, -0.011070532724261284, -0.03510259464383125, 0.02301814593374729, -0.015456262975931168, -0.003582469653338194, -0.03774363920092583, 0.04819454625248909, 0.0018479392165318131, 0.025034254416823387, -0.04158909618854523, -0.03735039383172989, 0.035123180598020554, 0.007593823131173849, -0.023306505754590034, -0.05276699364185333, 0.007345256861299276, -0.022672969847917557, 0.030890969559550285, 0.02234555594623089, 0.021561918780207634, -0.05350922420620918, 0.011265836656093597, 0.0031038408633321524, -0.01900896616280079, 0.017543744295835495, -0.02403891272842884, 0.0295590627938509, -0.00627667224034667, 0.017318718135356903, 0.044112008064985275, 0.04779457300901413, -0.016686661168932915, 0.03750681132078171, -0.011312095448374748, -0.02012888342142105, -0.040332019329071045, -0.012071346864104271, -0.027324410155415535, -0.0016483872896060348, -0.021632112562656403, -0.014469217509031296, -0.01147906482219696, 0.023516997694969177, -0.01644156500697136, -0.029156601056456566, 0.013156736269593239, 0.00009931640670401976, -0.01244176272302866, 0.0212418120354414, -0.034143295139074326, 0.04210176318883896, 0.009077549912035465, -0.00223405659198761, 0.046584464609622955, 0.030294526368379593, 0.026844533160328865, -0.029911799356341362, -0.03364633396267891, 0.009243729524314404, -0.06024312227964401, -0.02448868751525879, 0.03832293301820755, -0.029789019376039505, 0.06389130651950836, -0.007145465351641178, 0.07488857954740524, 0.0060096257366240025, -0.06838202476501465, -0.012013646773993969, 0.01570490002632141, -0.004089473281055689, 0.03196686878800392, -0.016441278159618378, 0.006512723863124847, -0.010156327858567238, -0.005497876554727554, -0.05736980214715004, -0.012278285808861256, 0.02010350488126278, 0.000347976922057569, -0.0013000327162444592, -0.010091939941048622, 0.008488504216074944, 0.026135006919503212, -0.013562584295868874, 0.0015275143086910248, 0.06069664657115936, -0.012041008099913597, -0.015090047381818295, -0.0026304449420422316, 0.03238226845860481, 0.08314291387796402, -0.01216710451990366, 0.010969754308462143, 0.017812756821513176, -0.035284753888845444, 0.018783777952194214, 0.013030117377638817, -0.01601499877870083, -0.038763388991355896, 0.01209232397377491, -0.02073385752737522, -0.023876851424574852, 0.015255150385200977, -0.01291563082486391, 0.005760169122368097, -0.022381575778126717, -0.0066439248621463776, 0.03672371804714203, -0.04065798595547676, 0.009097227826714516, -0.036679770797491074, -0.024889538064599037, -0.060369376093149185, 0.02750256285071373, 0.008094117045402527, 0.014891409315168858, 0.050780680030584335, 0.013297129422426224, -0.030503427609801292, 0.029405580833554268, 0.04084025323390961, -0.031039811670780182, -0.02775295451283455, -0.00738533167168498, -0.03073148988187313, 0.027508141472935677, 0.014436410740017891, -0.0266701802611351, 0.018573632463812828, 0.023428020998835564, -0.009372306987643242, 0.00011705260840244591, -0.051418159157037735, 0.0073149073868989944, 0.0369538739323616, 0.02195667289197445, 0.059702448546886444, 0.0434153713285923, -0.012181893922388554, 0.004214216955006123, -0.03741852566599846, 0.020568691194057465, -0.00008512812928529456, -0.009465423412621021, 0.04853769391775131, 0.01100399810820818, -0.02423541434109211, 0.012062370777130127, 0.015862179920077324, 0.05463148653507233, 0.02020600251853466, 0.023533469066023827, 0.005224721971899271, 0.020626699551939964, -0.07255091518163681, -0.013774466700851917, -0.009872077964246273, -0.01846740022301674, -0.009057766757905483, 0.025795828551054, -0.026610292494297028, 0.025331273674964905, 0.025711461901664734, 0.017642682418227196, -0.04003137722611427, -0.03000924177467823, -0.05973891541361809, 0.023593993857502937, -0.006783743388950825, -0.009733361192047596, 0.056420303881168365, -0.005909015890210867, 0.03352082520723343, 0.007974224165081978, 0.013865958899259567, -0.017618725076317787, -0.06705896556377411, -0.041776712983846664, -0.03773471340537071, -0.07463949173688889, 0.016284186393022537, -0.004067877307534218, -0.02987525425851345, 0.038789212703704834, -0.03590000420808792, 0.0064118062146008015, 0.023308970034122467, 0.012841609306633472, -0.02896958403289318, 0.05885689705610275, 0.03007502108812332, 0.03362009674310684, -0.0022874316200613976, -0.013026991859078407, 0.17438119649887085, 0.057622529566287994, 0.05870439484715462, -0.024821097031235695, 0.02480020932853222, 0.04011918231844902, -0.00130518211517483, 0.00832361076027155, -0.0183695200830698, 0.00869826227426529, -0.027214379981160164, 0.049764227122068405, 0.03386843204498291, -0.015846217051148415, 0.019309023395180702, 0.03825077414512634, -0.029000891372561455, -0.0028357189148664474, 0.0027606585063040257, 0.0056888568215072155, -0.025021756067872047, -0.016550689935684204, -0.02245025523006916, 0.013591432012617588, 0.01630830019712448, -0.020425517112016678, -0.016294069588184357, 0.005872137378901243, -0.008357347920536995, 0.031085677444934845, -0.02837829850614071, 0.014859005808830261, 0.0261580478399992, -0.010936420410871506, -0.015388553030788898, -0.033364105969667435, 0.0024764412082731724, -0.050432004034519196, -0.015003649517893791, 0.035099953413009644, -0.050080347806215286, -0.006896097678691149, -0.015456178225576878, -0.0007481356151401997, -0.04198530316352844, -0.028182873502373695, -0.06251483410596848, 0.030804425477981567, -0.04301358386874199, -0.01032909657806158, 0.0066863661631941795, -0.013572094962000847, 0.017079627141356468, -0.021007416769862175, -0.00949783343821764, 0.01594225876033306, 0.03990214318037033, 0.013453193940222263, -0.016651038080453873, 0.0018539723241701722, 0.01374210137873888, -0.00588360708206892, 0.015702692791819572, 0.046854861080646515, -0.020551713183522224, -0.055947788059711456, -0.019279487431049347, 0.04220146685838699, 0.025242643430829048, -0.00041780094034038484, 0.010848276317119598, -0.004914641845971346, -0.028906283900141716, -0.004150181543081999, -0.029379626736044884, 0.007554590702056885, 0.03596774488687515, -0.030348442494869232, 0.038596075028181076, -0.018456779420375824, 0.012649571523070335, -0.014322156086564064, -0.012469606474041939, -0.013230112381279469, -0.049322545528411865, -0.0010563867399469018, -0.02227918617427349, 0.03852501139044762, 0.0005828865105286241, 0.029379038140177727, 0.03096228651702404, 0.05117897689342499, -0.001024022581987083, -0.027460888028144836, 0.016068827360868454, -0.009650595486164093, -0.022521568462252617, 0.02763613872230053, -0.003498455509543419, 0.04843655228614807, 0.03426263481378555, 0.016484685242176056, 0.009593005292117596, 0.0708334669470787, 0.010959652252495289, 0.027952203527092934, 0.0003597950271796435, -0.07409120351076126, 0.0061114197596907616, -0.02255224622786045, -0.009782504290342331, -0.05055392161011696, -0.012937565334141254, -0.011107709258794785, -0.04804226756095886, -0.001036300789564848, -0.03538866341114044, -0.020086849108338356, 0.03171227127313614, -0.02279576286673546, 0.02295386791229248, -0.015902653336524963, -0.032814305275678635, -0.04336105287075043, -0.02730708010494709, -0.043211568146944046, -0.02266647107899189, 0.014058125205338001, -0.0002550310455262661, 0.007539285346865654, 0.00680842949077487, 0.057401224970817566, -0.007680368144065142, -0.029492482542991638, 0.005895680282264948, 0.04813558980822563, 0.016146471723914146, 0.009948019869625568, -0.01852724887430668, 0.002208214718848467, 0.034027259796857834, -0.055923040956258774, -0.019669057801365852, 0.0021714295726269484, -0.037348344922065735, 0.041538286954164505, -0.016665063798427582, -0.031966209411621094, 0.0068818372674286366, 0.052318353205919266, -0.03543095290660858, -0.02096656896173954, -0.05034511163830757, 0.030833804979920387, 0.058742184191942215, 0.011226882226765156, -0.0003338387468829751, 0.02481308951973915, -0.01703542470932007, 0.025024764239788055, 0.019334157928824425, -0.023309357464313507, -0.0614049956202507, -0.0009180863271467388, 0.008620236068964005, -0.007614943664520979, -0.02957463450729847, 0.0029839163180440664, 0.004673543851822615, 0.008212273940443993, -0.062270134687423706, 0.025580424815416336, -0.008012669160962105, -0.0027537739370018244, -0.05375048890709877, -0.06759771704673767, 0.03971998021006584, 0.019671592861413956, 0.03650755062699318, -0.011435894295573235, 0.020183585584163666, 0.002081124810501933, -0.03412202000617981, 0.02950901910662651, 0.003048788057640195, 0.020481066778302193, -0.03975822776556015, 0.02294486202299595, -0.06384982913732529, 0.016477080062031746, 0.022466354072093964, 0.023961862549185753, 0.019094200804829597, 0.03607746213674545, -0.013735811226069927, -0.035987552255392075, -0.0298051368445158, -0.018950166180729866, 0.031493887305259705, -0.023065373301506042, 0.0592716783285141, -0.04959751293063164, -0.018328210338950157, 0.06027615815401077, -0.008348489180207253, 0.06243259459733963, -0.021703265607357025, 0.019839951768517494, 0.001618815353140235, 0.015453052707016468, 0.027019664645195007, 0.022463152185082436, 0.02454999089241028, 0.025427335873246193, 0.028097955510020256, 0.0331852100789547, -0.011021461337804794, 0.03080616146326065, 0.04000217467546463, -0.01651482656598091, -0.005426743067800999, 0.015936894342303276, 0.009344432502985, 0.00514176907017827, 0.0046984790824353695, -0.013364910148084164, -0.013845929875969887, 0.004359656013548374, 0.04216974601149559, 0.019275957718491554, 0.004821293521672487, 0.05275814235210419, 0.03875758871436119, -0.018128369003534317, 0.046765007078647614, -0.022153396159410477, -0.03363041952252388, 0.03023044392466545, -0.0018512216629460454, -0.029568547382950783, -0.057341307401657104, -0.01605178602039814, 0.016306674107909203, -0.00320085184648633, -0.031722746789455414, 0.024397006258368492, -0.03177814185619354, 0.03661995008587837, 0.007525700144469738, -0.0015887065092101693, 0.012911959551274776, -0.028817618265748024, 0.029829787090420723, -0.09370464831590652, 0.05969640240073204, 0.0046335989609360695, 0.01642751507461071, -0.057173050940036774, -0.02798999287188053, 0.00024445183225907385, 0.0044370307587087154, 0.019385837018489838, -0.008069035597145557, 0.019022149965167046, -0.040998682379722595, -0.010098026134073734, 0.00561435567215085, 0.013497309759259224, 0.039884407073259354, 0.011248758994042873, -0.0097912373021245, 0.0008009207667782903, -0.019072270020842552, 0.01724313385784626, -0.01496052648872137, -0.029415257275104523, -0.014238824136555195, -0.04088360816240311, 0.05567266047000885, 0.023961501196026802, 0.040314871817827225, 0.013769342564046383, -0.017132272943854332, -0.007105804048478603, 0.00349118048325181, 0.008978378027677536, 0.049200624227523804, -0.013761639595031738, -0.030588753521442413, 0.029671525582671165, -0.034035224467515945, -0.019968504086136818, 0.0038458018098026514, 0.009072701446712017, 0.0003269280132371932, 0.00032524418202228844, 0.008856919594109058, 0.006250080186873674, 0.001448091585189104, 0.021067814901471138, 0.03099985420703888, -0.009830888360738754, 0.046771563589572906, 0.0170541163533926, 0.01721229963004589, -0.050239063799381256, -0.06115373224020004, 0.006748611107468605, -0.006376510486006737, 0.0112788500264287, -0.025912348181009293, 0.0010030572302639484, 0.06252817064523697, 0.016193732619285583, -0.009339135140180588, -0.015288629569113255, 0.030894488096237183, -0.04667048156261444, -0.01262718066573143, 0.004622299689799547, -0.0026998950634151697, -0.015125791542232037, 0.04436055198311806, -0.03149961680173874, 0.0828230082988739, 0.015358161181211472, 0.022996656596660614, -0.028806408867239952, -0.004918476101011038, 0.006881485693156719, -0.00158224836923182, -0.018105344846844673, 0.03517733886837959, -0.0010042267385870218, -0.007733715698122978, -0.016472749412059784, -0.01309988833963871, 0.049945954233407974, -0.03360360115766525, 0.036905281245708466, -0.023718662559986115, 0.01351955533027649, 0.003708891337737441, -0.005494614597409964, -0.013208003714680672, -0.0066459039226174355, 0.03717728704214096, 0.062485575675964355, 0.016190527006983757, -0.004695454612374306, -0.03949154540896416, 0.003424383932724595, 0.001400877838023007, -0.038315121084451675, -0.02951328456401825, -0.05892667546868324, 0.005541294347494841, -0.0068111903965473175, -0.024120701476931572 ]
<p>The regret in a multi-arm bandit model is given by </p> <p>$$\underset{j}{\max}\sum_{t=1}^{T}x_j(t) -G_{A}$$</p> <p>where $$G_A=\sum_{t=1}^{T}x_{it}(t)$$ is the total reward achieved by the learner, based on an action $i$, taken at each time interval $t$, i.e $i_{t}\in {1,2,...,K}$ and $x_j(t)$ is the reward assosciated with action $j$, at time $t$ with $K$, being the total number of actions available.</p> <p>In a stochastic multi-arm bandit setting where each arm is modeled by a population distribution: </p> <p>a) What is the connection between the sequential decisions taken by a chosen learner that guarantees a minimization of the expectation of the above regret?</p> <p>I ask this, as I do not see the expectation of the best arm being accounted for- directly in the given form of the regret. Instead, is there a bound that connects this regret to the population mean parameters?</p> <p>I looked at the expected regret being $$\mathbb{E}\left[\underset{j}{\max}\sum_{t=1}^{T}x_j(t)\right]-\mathbb{E}G_A $$ and want to have a connection between the steps in any chosen multi-arm-bandit algorithm and the minimization of the expected regret. Is it done directly- or is it based on the minimization of say, an indirect upper bound? </p>
36,273
[ -0.012324412353336811, -0.07301227748394012, -0.004858349449932575, -0.012525921687483788, -0.002448122249916196, 0.013567646034061909, -0.03273644298315048, -0.020822910591959953, 0.03231383487582207, -0.02600978873670101, 0.013775617815554142, 0.04070279747247696, 0.06311982125043869, 0.029255155473947525, -0.016739636659622192, -0.004439574666321278, -0.023624174296855927, -0.0054948655888438225, 0.007643714081496, -0.0005291420966386795, 0.014403468929231167, 0.0350576676428318, 0.03592703118920326, -0.01824922487139702, -0.014487726613879204, 0.028225870802998543, 0.024990838021039963, -0.028864750638604164, 0.0024657859466969967, 0.07275712490081787, -0.03419504687190056, -0.007873453199863434, -0.04007083177566528, 0.05112283676862717, 0.014373201876878738, -0.008078841492533684, -0.05044514685869217, -0.04766888543963432, -0.00948916096240282, 0.02828066237270832, -0.034644559025764465, -0.018000442534685135, 0.016502616927027702, 0.01658257097005844, 0.015473979525268078, 0.025766149163246155, -0.04164399951696396, -0.021853219717741013, 0.018611758947372437, -0.025975080206990242, 0.02646014280617237, 0.003944166470319033, -0.024360770359635353, -0.010581969283521175, -0.00495541375130415, 0.004105782136321068, 0.052792519330978394, 0.0672328919172287, 0.0014643898466601968, -0.01930643804371357, -0.015795551240444183, -0.024509212002158165, 0.057204678654670715, -0.04449370130896568, -0.045024771243333817, 0.04023972526192665, -0.012882699258625507, -0.03845158964395523, 0.005351112689822912, -0.018189894035458565, 0.0011398991337046027, 0.039901625365018845, 0.026118604466319084, 0.001080272370018065, 0.02438882552087307, 0.01808394305408001, 0.019546419382095337, 0.06595513224601746, 0.04033920541405678, 0.04859359562397003, 0.0007022821228019893, -0.025998691096901894, 0.05021721124649048, 0.07156293839216232, 0.008501207455992699, 0.016864916309714317, 0.059602659195661545, -0.021098919212818146, 0.0364595465362072, -0.0032551258336752653, -0.0010589496232569218, 0.007437054067850113, 0.01684492826461792, -0.036351658403873444, -0.058660004287958145, 0.025579849258065224, -0.011050106026232243, 0.03316695988178253, 0.01688462309539318, -0.04542363062500954, 0.0014934230130165815, -0.04362448304891586, 0.010043543763458729, 0.06201621890068054, -0.010516266338527203, -0.006778422277420759, -0.03109227493405342, -0.0014741903869435191, -0.014589278027415276, -0.021746113896369934, -0.030832869932055473, 0.030692631378769875, -0.006084722001105547, -0.003187403781339526, 0.002227948047220707, 0.0065999021753668785, 0.0003023231402039528, 0.0017466791905462742, 0.05337342992424965, 0.059673506766557693, 0.07172183692455292, -0.02080075442790985, 0.007041411940008402, -0.06281354278326035, -0.0653015673160553, -0.021006403490900993, 0.03256160393357277, -0.04496340826153755, -0.047236666083335876, 0.014811438508331776, -0.006450633052736521, -0.006636598613113165, 0.04275882616639137, 0.007735503371804953, 0.0150686576962471, -0.06323221325874329, -0.06764846295118332, -0.04299462214112282, 0.032641272991895676, -0.03425983339548111, -0.016069738194346428, -0.048403654247522354, -0.04016289860010147, 0.04325493052601814, 0.02577536553144455, 0.015706181526184082, 0.02969985455274582, 0.04186522215604782, 0.03736885264515877, 0.01571464352309704, -0.025262560695409775, 0.015798654407262802, -0.00024226453388109803, 0.017371412366628647, -0.02710268646478653, -0.04105479270219803, 0.04494967311620712, 0.03553123399615288, -0.010627725161612034, 0.00009632900037104264, 0.07193984091281891, -0.008100785315036774, -0.01659686304628849, -0.02745966799557209, 0.019862424582242966, -0.00506178941577673, 0.0837554782629013, 0.031701259315013885, 0.02449898235499859, 0.008391058072447777, 0.038036927580833435, -0.01423792913556099, 0.011449519544839859, 0.02324369177222252, 0.06064184755086899, -0.05385761335492134, -0.03693518787622452, -0.007085736840963364, -0.017303787171840668, 0.02166367694735527, -0.007140845991671085, -0.05206058919429779, -0.011197918094694614, 0.007920585572719574, 0.019232280552387238, 0.039800964295864105, 0.02008499950170517, 0.0054444847628474236, 0.0042199380695819855, -0.02433299645781517, -0.04989452287554741, -0.09706542640924454, -0.013477887026965618, 0.011596386320888996, -0.014962385408580303, 0.04130374640226364, -0.007755463942885399, 0.014918381348252296, -0.020497901365160942, -0.04482758417725563, 0.010235278867185116, 0.002938060788437724, 0.049606356769800186, -0.03387156128883362, -0.02278834767639637, 0.05000445246696472, 0.023748943582177162, -0.03457609936594963, 0.05152297765016556, -0.034275636076927185, -0.08587615936994553, 0.01280855294317007, -0.02557767741382122, 0.03404713794589043, 0.035262640565633774, 0.011957612819969654, 0.002283956855535507, -0.014266320504248142, -0.0069138710387051105, 0.0020468190778046846, -0.043820448219776154, 0.044985331594944, 0.06812889128923416, 0.044560711830854416, 0.02137932740151882, 0.04470625892281532, 0.00017106308951042593, 0.022675827145576477, -0.06255896389484406, -0.024254340678453445, -0.0221510361880064, -0.03025619499385357, 0.05631028860807419, 0.04335246980190277, -0.05179718881845474, 0.038828786462545395, 0.06316841393709183, 0.03322126716375351, 0.028774268925189972, 0.007895523682236671, -0.001323932083323598, 0.03530697897076607, 0.034621696919202805, 0.06794773787260056, -0.02157718688249588, 0.030040189623832703, -0.006743752863258123, -0.003141229972243309, 0.0009024157770909369, 0.019072487950325012, -0.025385836139321327, 0.019952621310949326, 0.0016583106480538845, -0.0020104756113141775, -0.0023379544727504253, -0.031384412199258804, 0.0439227819442749, -0.054207343608140945, 0.043671004474163055, 0.057406701147556305, -0.005219500511884689, 0.004831901751458645, -0.016127953305840492, -0.022022023797035217, -0.008630525320768356, 0.010731913149356842, -0.016422023996710777, -0.01124744862318039, 0.010717667639255524, -0.03159428760409355, -0.00022488248941954225, -0.02111908048391342, -0.008986135944724083, -0.018013469874858856, 0.026433110237121582, 0.009524022229015827, -0.03711816295981407, -0.0008288570097647607, -0.024445628747344017, -0.025081180036067963, 0.006534627638757229, -0.0023438178468495607, 0.03986506164073944, -0.009223430417478085, -0.05456354841589928, 0.011173172853887081, -0.019846199080348015, -0.002872949233278632, 0.04511472210288048, 0.00578739307820797, 0.015968771651387215, -0.00013934318849351257, -0.02138345129787922, -0.03379946947097778, -0.022860033437609673, -0.013253058306872845, 0.010456589981913567, 0.0017130543710663915, -0.014412924647331238, 0.05516448989510536, -0.006802779622375965, -0.01954597793519497, 0.008461047895252705, -0.009070394560694695, -0.01295520830899477, -0.03261992707848549, 0.003518099198117852, 0.0015982184559106827, -0.0037732396740466356, -0.004087203647941351, 0.06529903411865234, 0.008411801420152187, -0.014959027990698814, -0.07804408669471741, -0.051473405212163925, 0.036277785897254944, 0.026082059368491173, 0.02493281103670597, 0.017028173431754112, 0.012289025820791721, 0.06868772208690643, 0.027230560779571533, -0.006086057052016258, -0.016222745180130005, 0.00529452646151185, 0.01572314277291298, 0.010070694610476494, -0.013951290398836136, 0.03076937608420849, -0.023467186838388443, 0.041943736374378204, 0.002557076746597886, 0.022326139733195305, 0.06305587291717529, -0.022153569385409355, -0.008606815710663795, -0.00040190762956626713, 0.019909562543034554, 0.0013193947961553931, 0.021819405257701874, 0.02152816765010357, 0.012128346599638462, -0.0028622301761060953, -0.0013844402274116874, 0.03125762194395065, -0.015325626358389854, -0.01892399787902832, 0.004980860743671656, -0.03359290212392807, -0.019057290628552437, -0.05100245773792267, 0.02162959799170494, -0.003106025280430913, 0.000016925767340580933, -0.008173851296305656, 0.04107561707496643, 0.05836255103349686, -0.05368094518780708, 0.028892099857330322, 0.007308690343052149, 0.01984429359436035, -0.008647880516946316, -0.03684409335255623, -0.001141113811172545, -0.04986240342259407, -0.007090279832482338, 0.0017785424133762717, -0.012260328978300095, 0.000870974559802562, 0.01445335615426302, -0.009740631096065044, -0.004902711603790522, -0.03926662728190422, 0.01998690329492092, -0.09696149080991745, -0.01957741379737854, -0.023088553920388222, 0.056093502789735794, -0.0031547676771879196, 0.005316408351063728, -0.004860120825469494, 0.002782800467684865, -0.03116155043244362, 0.032712433487176895, -0.06763751804828644, 0.03748133033514023, -0.004916285164654255, -0.006467046216130257, 0.0067590950056910515, -0.00033540005097165704, 0.06333034485578537, -0.010027816519141197, 0.012942396104335785, -0.018491989001631737, 0.02525383047759533, -0.0213927049189806, 0.03214804455637932, -0.02273491583764553, -0.005556178744882345, -0.01900860294699669, 0.008563293144106865, 0.03851848468184471, -0.01808912493288517, 0.016390502452850342, 0.024198172613978386, -0.005242930259555578, -0.018335292115807533, -0.031714435666799545, 0.011307832784950733, 0.01959124393761158, 0.020107856020331383, 0.05170630291104317, 0.005849462002515793, 0.0036178831942379475, 0.028540365397930145, 0.0057227397337555885, 0.042401351034641266, 0.02596377208828926, -0.04870123788714409, 0.009302227757871151, -0.05649717152118683, -0.04184668883681297, 0.006464096717536449, -0.015576141886413097, 0.001968563999980688, 0.012835722416639328, 0.06300108134746552, 0.03249221295118332, -0.036217283457517624, 0.022009458392858505, 0.0745358020067215, -0.003453978570178151, -0.012331858277320862, -0.05098225548863411, -0.008118189871311188, -0.004827180411666632, 0.02680867724120617, 0.01917438581585884, -0.039172857999801636, 0.009115157648921013, 0.008355298079550266, 0.030584702268242836, -0.010934008285403252, -0.019773414358496666, 0.005192354787141085, 0.013874604366719723, 0.058486297726631165, 0.034872401505708694, 0.012199926190078259, -0.0010780879529193044, 0.02016117051243782, 0.018346454948186874, 0.0005313614383339882, 0.005758593790233135, -0.08778709918260574, -0.04760124534368515, 0.011264235712587833, 0.06524252146482468, -0.04192272946238518, 0.029120437800884247, -0.04202476143836975, 0.02710394375026226, 0.027938712388277054, -0.0190003402531147, 0.029270442202687263, -0.02225242741405964, -0.02193804271519184, -0.01825704611837864, -0.04064670950174332, -0.008831520564854145, 0.015389936044812202, 0.019144535064697266, 0.01568555273115635, -0.02367003634572029, 0.032185766845941544, -0.048707056790590286, -0.03115825727581978, 0.016695545986294746, 0.06737345457077026, 0.01887097768485546, -0.019880345091223717, 0.005669496022164822, 0.02570832148194313, 0.0008853470208123326, -0.08121572434902191, 0.014486393891274929, -0.04035127907991409, -0.037348657846450806, 0.01896793022751808, -0.03600417077541351, -0.01689121499657631, 0.05298306420445442, 0.04033700376749039, -0.03483530133962631, -0.0016982534434646368, -0.03338134288787842, 0.021607965230941772, 0.03182940185070038, -0.018200384452939034, 0.055518995970487595, 0.017077771946787834, 0.01050937082618475, 0.006971396971493959, 0.00506354495882988, 0.03289236128330231, -0.01852290891110897, -0.02702184021472931, -0.03673291206359863, -0.022480223327875137, 0.006841478869318962, 0.04233125224709511, -0.0021911300718784332, 0.016130492091178894, -0.017983293160796165, -0.026825642213225365, -0.015312439762055874, 0.03448472172021866, 0.011494617909193039, -0.018775934353470802, 0.017268076539039612, 0.04776596277952194, -0.01043720543384552, 0.00041623954894021153, 0.014274446293711662, -0.02211129292845726, 0.06104616820812225, 0.03188697621226311, -0.03148581087589264, 0.028681591153144836, -0.05052195116877556, -0.022247930988669395, 0.02393198385834694, 0.004443792626261711, 0.04296431690454483, -0.0026108967140316963, 0.02143826335668564, -0.012401900254189968, 0.0002382148668402806, -0.025214271619915962, -0.02362125925719738, -0.03259394317865372, -0.013429253362119198, -0.03766413405537605, 0.003735841019079089, -0.02005927637219429, 0.022975105792284012, -0.06780779361724854, 0.0009782416746020317, 0.020900126546621323, 0.011803834699094296, -0.02390391007065773, 0.02329310029745102, -0.0018388490425422788, -0.02866419591009617, -0.038663025945425034, -0.011372835375368595, 0.040166087448596954, -0.01733401231467724, -0.017667656764388084, -0.013606439344584942, 0.03294386714696884, 0.08709663152694702, 0.024503512308001518, -0.0011650390224531293, 0.01602601818740368, -0.0432061031460762, -0.019731253385543823, -0.034304723143577576, 0.04959134757518768, -0.025771161541342735, 0.007623438257724047, -0.014859200455248356, 0.01411251351237297, 0.036330994218587875, -0.009647981263697147, -0.03315465524792671, 0.0030365593265742064, -0.01550664845854044, 0.019815439358353615, -0.034372664988040924, -0.011122489348053932, -0.008229128085076809, 0.0229240283370018, 0.007343702483922243, 0.0085110729560256, 0.016379553824663162, -0.032896023243665695, 0.05464273318648338, 0.017237599939107895, -0.017191926017403603, -0.011447620578110218, 0.04194260761141777, -0.026126952841877937, 0.011037454009056091, 0.022663945332169533, -0.01611977443099022, 0.054128360003232956, -0.03368845209479332, 0.009046261198818684, 0.037013642489910126, -0.0010038085747510195, -0.04185190796852112, -0.031214607879519463, -0.04162218049168587, 0.04005521163344383, 0.027984825894236565, -0.018348895013332367, 0.028016243129968643, 0.004090835340321064, -0.016096046194434166, -0.0005612082895822823, -0.04756265878677368, -0.004176572896540165, 0.004461396485567093, 0.00010132395982509479, 0.042712483555078506, 0.001108431606553495, -0.0070005254819989204, 0.05749543011188507, -0.009552801959216595, 0.03643575683236122, 0.01051349751651287, -0.0031260945834219456, 0.012743229046463966, -0.010379042476415634, -0.06870187819004059, -0.03835263475775719, 0.019171427935361862, -0.037977688014507294, -0.018583377823233604, -0.02282468043267727, -0.04171540588140488, 0.042450543493032455, 0.030259322375059128, 0.016617655754089355, -0.015181733295321465, 0.012693142518401146, -0.057389773428440094, 0.013038860633969307, 0.030802123248577118, 0.017107201740145683, 0.05104618892073631, -0.009515075944364071, 0.035077210515737534, -0.022796474397182465, 0.05584236606955528, 0.008472133427858353, -0.06589875370264053, -0.06949608772993088, -0.030363628640770912, -0.05395107716321945, -0.006014438811689615, 0.012264479883015156, -0.005714178550988436, 0.03824828565120697, -0.0031703906133770943, 0.03068070486187935, 0.005144387949258089, 0.032732948660850525, 0.014439201913774014, 0.07009049504995346, 0.03604782745242119, 0.057467300444841385, -0.02318609319627285, -0.004831363912671804, 0.12653756141662598, 0.09609346836805344, 0.052833013236522675, -0.08154113590717316, 0.000017063106497516856, -0.01468920148909092, 0.003386500058695674, -0.013188077136874199, -0.002425419632345438, 0.03703361377120018, -0.04303004965186119, 0.006655867211520672, -0.01895146630704403, 0.0025028306990861893, -0.04315527155995369, 0.042233970016241074, -0.05784735083580017, -0.02035229466855526, 0.024405404925346375, -0.017389841377735138, 0.02126915380358696, -0.01612108014523983, -0.039487507194280624, 0.012074681930243969, 0.006747792474925518, -0.013757026754319668, 0.03551236167550087, -0.00277268816716969, -0.01825869455933571, -0.0008126944885589182, 0.014186971820890903, -0.007071260828524828, 0.007175910752266645, -0.005793294403702021, 0.020990394055843353, 0.024403182789683342, -0.038631871342659, -0.01893259771168232, 0.01540270633995533, 0.024238595739006996, -0.017188483849167824, 0.0110408253967762, 0.022559422999620438, 0.02759227715432644, -0.01629825122654438, -0.028293883427977562, -0.0023573730140924454, 0.02595549263060093, -0.045019228011369705, 0.022395502775907516, -0.01748189516365528, -0.03560030460357666, -0.013010247610509396, -0.027127794921398163, -0.02902197279036045, 0.006523891817778349, 0.0499848797917366, -0.03171783313155174, -0.022631779313087463, -0.03556511551141739, 0.027093859389424324, -0.034041877835989, 0.026485027745366096, -0.0007099394570104778, -0.04415641725063324, -0.023636551573872566, -0.03439395874738693, -0.017356978729367256, 0.04665351286530495, 0.013588109984993935, -0.016025451943278313, -0.029127763584256172, -0.026661468669772148, -0.031708013266325, -0.009562562219798565, -0.013103125616908073, 0.04221956059336662, -0.014484708197414875, -0.03341713920235634, 0.014941701665520668, -0.06357721984386444, -0.010199259035289288, -0.07082289457321167, 0.011961781419813633, -0.035780586302280426, -0.001390393590554595, 0.030906910076737404, -0.0002884316782001406, 0.016896188259124756, 0.023874690756201744, -0.01330062560737133, 0.051624372601509094, -0.016449131071567535, -0.0258657056838274, -0.0015048617497086525, -0.02348531223833561, -0.02927199937403202, 0.03504046052694321, -0.02108038030564785, 0.07723476737737656, 0.016207894310355186, 0.01638326421380043, -0.026869075372815132, 0.00045397126814350486, 0.013328347355127335, 0.008095880970358849, 0.017431989312171936, -0.058153875172138214, 0.029562070965766907, 0.008109879679977894, 0.022268328815698624, -0.06757532805204391, -0.02506711333990097, -0.033759888261556625, 0.029421545565128326, 0.024715520441532135, -0.030435042455792427, -0.029969198629260063, 0.0027335751801729202, -0.02965454012155533, 0.03501411899924278, -0.021211858838796616, 0.006301981396973133, -0.017268406227231026, 0.01721072383224964, -0.023870227858424187, -0.03625482693314552, -0.002929933601990342, -0.014043889008462429, -0.0013406419893726707, -0.007576414849609137, 0.0010361900785937905, 0.03171396628022194, 0.01679074950516224, -0.0017202494200319052, 0.02702663093805313, 0.008623722940683365, 0.05474225431680679, -0.015579799190163612, -0.04388207197189331, 0.05111890286207199, -0.049913566559553146, -0.0016268560430034995, 0.012038489803671837, 0.010466527193784714, 0.029749123379588127, 0.019639424979686737, -0.04067159444093704, -0.015323339961469173, 0.03221563994884491, -0.032131634652614594, -0.012462020851671696, 0.04176562279462814, 0.01477988064289093, -0.005341856274753809, -0.024099070578813553, -0.0025991518050432205, -0.00750001659616828, -0.01468835212290287, -0.0016576142515987158, 0.0366273857653141, 0.007829075679183006, 0.0032412512227892876, 0.031729236245155334, 0.005160207394510508, 0.023554718121886253, -0.01357622817158699, 0.008772668428719044, 0.015207018703222275, 0.030644264072179794, 0.004428870510309935, 0.04194898530840874, -0.014030416496098042, 0.007148274220526218, -0.06233781576156616, 0.000846940791234374, -0.02108072303235531, 0.041211292147636414, 0.01296487357467413, -0.04564565047621727, 0.033082008361816406, 0.034943222999572754, -0.01819794438779354, 0.011254406534135342, 0.010309136472642422, -0.029692091047763824, -0.031159522011876106, 0.007146846503019333, -0.023462237790226936, 0.000531505502294749, -0.00346396048553288, -0.0038811301346868277, 0.05381840094923973, 0.009592096321284771, 0.023121505975723267, -0.03926653787493706, -0.0434592179954052, 0.03926635906100273, -0.01817372627556324, -0.0509757325053215, 0.07726255059242249, -0.01854604296386242, -0.03848083317279816, 0.009327257052063942, 0.028027182444930077, 0.01741143688559532, 0.014986368827521801, 0.02634521760046482, -0.01016845740377903, 0.04800690710544586, 0.0007320611621253192, -0.017001640051603317, 0.009549598209559917, 0.010181202553212643, 0.01060785073786974, 0.013166612945497036, -0.023376617580652237, 0.02093026041984558, 0.04103928804397583, -0.0061987885273993015, -0.022032031789422035, 0.008240368217229843, -0.02181612141430378, -0.06429584324359894, 0.0032464060932397842, -0.004009569995105267, 0.02135409228503704, -0.040768373757600784, 0.024990806356072426, 0.0066385455429553986, -0.02241862379014492, 0.03175953030586243, -0.0034315374214202166, -0.009309673681855202, -0.029920853674411774, -0.0008254506392404437, -0.040430497378110886, 0.020878233015537262, 0.034221164882183075, -0.03324902430176735, -0.04770590364933014, 0.023234480991959572, -0.02308552712202072, -0.01744341291487217, -0.04177142679691315, -0.029857339337468147, -0.00666232081130147, 0.02451414428651333, -0.026590637862682343, 0.020070545375347137, 0.0020523604471236467, 0.02391287125647068, -0.009942570701241493, -0.09383486211299896, 0.03902183845639229, -0.0058233547024428844, -0.0323808416724205, -0.021440444514155388, -0.02994016371667385, -0.01697913371026516, -0.03892333805561066, 0.07280995696783066, -0.017372019588947296, -0.038710303604602814, 0.008521012961864471, 0.027284996584057808, 0.015677811577916145, -0.008246990852057934, 0.04491635039448738, -0.04393192008137703, -0.0009347145678475499, -0.03769409656524658, -0.036930497735738754, -0.002443525241687894, -0.0032888860441744328, 0.021751733496785164, 0.017351126298308372, -0.006168877240270376, 0.002811538754031062, 0.044910624623298645, 0.04154978692531586, 0.026186129078269005, 0.029009247198700905, 0.04721454530954361, 0.02592696249485016, 0.026429129764437675, -0.0007444261573255062, -0.013370172120630741, -0.07398632913827896, 0.007515433710068464, -0.04956679418683052, -0.051816657185554504, -0.003587537445127964, 0.027604106813669205, -0.014036738313734531, -0.032780349254608154, 0.0058073136024177074, 0.051643405109643936, -0.012317999266088009, -0.030649662017822266, 0.0468711256980896, 0.0017343913204967976, 0.03771787881851196, 0.002895150799304247, 0.02688455581665039, 0.04236464947462082, 0.021149786189198494, -0.005084901116788387, 0.01761646382510662, 0.04018797725439072, 0.01565716788172722, 0.05495470389723778, 0.016797475516796112, -0.024685734882950783, 0.04271853715181351, -0.013560554012656212, 0.029715949669480324, -0.021667199209332466, -0.03536062315106392, 0.016840582713484764, 0.010387016460299492, -0.03213926777243614, -0.022357584908604622, -0.029758431017398834, 0.049408555030822754, -0.00805752445012331, 0.009681452065706253, -0.026598410680890083, -0.008150518871843815, -0.009707530029118061, -0.02089916542172432, -0.021944649517536163, 0.03831511363387108, 0.008427523076534271, 0.003077099798247218, -0.009682197123765945, 0.0046794721856713295, 0.06439251452684402, -0.045446399599313736, 0.041221704334020615, 0.013499454595148563, -0.03162212669849396, -0.030625514686107635, -0.05295060947537422, -0.000985778053291142, -0.02865850180387497, -0.00258248089812696, 0.03102198988199234, 0.04754074662923813, 0.006177292205393314, -0.03892458602786064, -0.009892593137919903, 0.0714450478553772, -0.09554487466812134, 0.00355556164868176, -0.05993170291185379, -0.004890995100140572, 0.03449892997741699, -0.012086823582649231 ]
<p>How many lags should one use a Ljung-Box test for the returns on 1320 daily price quotes? Is there a rule of thumb? What is exactly the impact in the end result of misuse of lag number?</p>
36,274
[ 0.0017910405294969678, -0.03888225927948952, -0.005913831759244204, -0.00847817026078701, 0.062081411480903625, 0.022729147225618362, -0.013563953340053558, 0.005783308297395706, -0.012621724046766758, -0.0023836137261241674, 0.03245076537132263, 0.011846518144011497, -0.024971604347229004, -0.012389463372528553, -0.0036157281138002872, 0.026293598115444183, -0.017712470144033432, -0.010883059352636337, 0.020099816843867302, -0.014064988121390343, 0.015400100499391556, -0.014032987877726555, -0.009330294094979763, -0.027117880061268806, -0.02139193005859852, -0.012013107538223267, -0.007662570104002953, 0.009282414801418781, 0.04304499179124832, 0.012228268198668957, -0.017777174711227417, -0.0029079820960760117, -0.000050302671297686175, 0.016687043011188507, -0.039627447724342346, 0.022608937695622444, 0.007202713284641504, -0.05294635519385338, -0.03315258026123047, 0.03738697990775108, -0.029879255220294, 0.002788309706375003, -0.006410782691091299, 0.02741842530667782, -0.02331218123435974, -0.004210910759866238, 0.02757820300757885, -0.05042732506990433, 0.022910000756382942, -0.02871621400117874, 0.06680566817522049, -0.031215457245707512, 0.00686607463285327, -0.003269321983680129, -0.019441399723291397, -0.014065259136259556, 0.08434389531612396, 0.01853601634502411, 0.0029786513186991215, -0.04065681993961334, 0.025642607361078262, 0.006192220374941826, 0.046168502420186996, -0.037790216505527496, -0.028934026136994362, 0.047748416662216187, 0.023133588954806328, -0.02600138448178768, 0.019472742453217506, -0.002322656335309148, 0.023207198828458786, 0.013009725138545036, 0.009698918089270592, 0.019031064584851265, 0.06589219719171524, -0.0151628777384758, -0.005312593188136816, 0.06062914803624153, 0.03782469779253006, 0.06301465630531311, 0.009481488727033138, 0.02571954019367695, 0.055246204137802124, 0.041984256356954575, 0.05978638306260109, -0.002506145741790533, 0.034686021506786346, -0.03963841125369072, 0.012714666314423084, 0.03799475356936455, -0.0109595051035285, 0.002539775101467967, 0.047508735209703445, 0.017075298354029655, -0.03375740349292755, 0.010611230507493019, -0.029832273721694946, 0.02831246890127659, -0.018389733508229256, -0.05090001970529556, -0.022317830473184586, -0.03278639167547226, 0.02800050377845764, 0.031637948006391525, -0.015077022835612297, 0.023226184770464897, -0.0035520701203495264, -0.027855513617396355, -0.015960603952407837, -0.044675834476947784, -0.00987755972892046, -0.007922339253127575, -0.04167884960770607, -0.004892448429018259, 0.047667670994997025, -0.009797386825084686, -0.020543614402413368, 0.02213607355952263, 0.05463065952062607, 0.0239849966019392, 0.040602002292871475, 0.011467302218079567, 0.027462895959615707, 0.004642523359507322, -0.07071168720722198, 0.024634122848510742, 0.02321731485426426, -0.03467550128698349, -0.07580649107694626, 0.03977955877780914, 0.0204083900898695, -0.03141264244914055, 0.0334303081035614, 0.001376042957417667, 0.04737810418009758, 0.005791541654616594, -0.07458855956792831, -0.065834641456604, 0.05373384431004524, -0.014909422025084496, 0.013182844035327435, -0.06700223684310913, -0.00487106665968895, 0.009768418036401272, 0.03964579105377197, 0.0006478526047430933, 0.04159829393029213, 0.009146825410425663, 0.03149973228573799, -0.008183605968952179, -0.04525623098015785, -0.020412517711520195, -0.006233915686607361, -0.027967695146799088, 0.010578218847513199, -0.08055998384952545, -0.0039663780480623245, 0.042296357452869415, -0.01574937254190445, -0.05686306580901146, 0.020953407511115074, 0.03832438960671425, -0.003996357321739197, 0.005321086384356022, -0.018899211660027504, -0.04030833765864372, 0.04808003082871437, -0.006254006642848253, 0.02699616178870201, -0.007319743279367685, -0.0026136820670217276, 0.0178128182888031, 0.018897701054811478, 0.0006972666014917195, 0.018227191641926765, -0.0025091140996664762, 0.03589516133069992, -0.018982969224452972, 0.019792892038822174, 0.02065664902329445, -0.056569233536720276, -0.0011032918700948358, -0.020186133682727814, 0.027081429958343506, 0.015441056340932846, 0.030833788216114044, -0.030845295637845993, 0.007280740886926651, 0.01859387569129467, -0.06989911943674088, -0.05935623124241829, -0.04682694375514984, 0.012195081450045109, -0.025988414883613586, -0.02257172018289566, 0.025156093761324883, -0.009938298724591732, 0.013266663067042828, -0.0017223812174052, -0.02864709310233593, 0.0024126062635332346, 0.031611368060112, 0.05935071036219597, -0.048573173582553864, 0.008820719085633755, 0.06290046125650406, 0.01892220787703991, -0.03994680941104889, -0.002486300654709339, -0.010723459534347057, -0.05644391477108002, 0.018469884991645813, 0.005818343721330166, 0.041830673813819885, 0.010195951908826828, -0.03555146977305412, 0.02121150866150856, -0.007962536998093128, -0.02699938975274563, 0.04390175640583038, -0.049325279891490936, 0.0439581535756588, 0.07343597710132599, 0.022606203332543373, -0.0019608312286436558, 0.01938275806605816, 0.01552035566419363, 0.0006925775087438524, 0.021113820374011993, -0.0057424381375312805, -0.031114486977458, -0.01083567924797535, 0.014868519268929958, 0.006033538840711117, -0.023334957659244537, 0.011093901470303535, 0.05815662443637848, 0.0018004229059442878, -0.01049985270947218, 0.024638047441840172, -0.01766265369951725, -0.04393314570188522, 0.004550653044134378, 0.013668075203895569, 0.02843855880200863, 0.014496286399662495, -0.0100189708173275, 0.014420730993151665, 0.013992251828312874, -0.00814548134803772, 0.0037064100615680218, 0.04152843728661537, -0.011961107142269611, -0.03427272289991379, -0.019214916974306107, -0.03880247846245766, 0.03713173791766167, -0.05168019235134125, -0.007463078014552593, 0.004666775930672884, 0.026800336316227913, 0.04454128444194794, -0.008001800626516342, -0.0394991897046566, 0.03049764782190323, 0.010779453441500664, -0.041866693645715714, -0.012414627708494663, 0.03655427321791649, -0.040351226925849915, 0.028326671570539474, -0.08768782019615173, 0.0015796859515830874, -0.02134559489786625, 0.017698919400572777, -0.002160261385142803, 0.019986890256404877, 0.03108832985162735, -0.0007514488534070551, -0.018551278859376907, 0.012357913888990879, -0.016821106895804405, -0.010911484248936176, -0.012909303419291973, -0.026998557150363922, -0.0081758638843894, 0.005011986941099167, -0.005120602902024984, 0.01750032790005207, -0.015856951475143433, 0.005787272471934557, 0.04562950134277344, 0.005476089660078287, -0.034360505640506744, -0.07330430299043655, -0.03889990970492363, -0.00026549756876192987, -0.05135694146156311, -0.015672236680984497, 0.03309282660484314, 0.000527656520716846, -0.04207570105791092, 0.009463234804570675, -0.014672402292490005, 0.006064680404961109, -0.007824202999472618, -0.022812796756625175, 0.0067804898135364056, -0.03286604583263397, -0.06149786710739136, 0.003521210979670286, -0.041096031665802, -0.001063067582435906, -0.020509155467152596, -0.05395587533712387, 0.029992764815688133, -0.027777811512351036, 0.0069777099415659904, -0.00846300832927227, -0.05189109966158867, 0.09171730279922485, 0.012249900959432125, 0.028897900134325027, -0.021283330395817757, -0.026409747079014778, -0.02534068003296852, -0.03526977822184563, -0.027400894090533257, 0.021828103810548782, 0.03871322423219681, 0.04793154448270798, -0.010773780755698681, 0.046256180852651596, 0.058088477700948715, 0.01529244426637888, 0.033290088176727295, -0.007024464197456837, -0.01992039941251278, 0.02063443697988987, 0.022175930440425873, 0.05115894600749016, 0.008353350684046745, -0.010741331614553928, 0.0035168577451258898, 0.036733582615852356, 0.008299197070300579, -0.05392787978053093, 0.05687872692942619, -0.001689106342382729, -0.005787799134850502, -0.0002281185006722808, 0.002274076920002699, -0.01866626925766468, 0.011064879596233368, -0.03554918244481087, -0.01730005070567131, 0.00429345341399312, 0.022307347506284714, -0.0028084879741072655, 0.06420516222715378, 0.05032076686620712, -0.03602054342627525, -0.0327904187142849, -0.00020748535462189466, -0.016923023387789726, 0.043133825063705444, -0.038148049265146255, -0.03649701923131943, -0.00028923293575644493, 0.015617541037499905, 0.03155357390642166, 0.010533407330513, -0.029019929468631744, 0.011959859170019627, -0.065176822245121, -0.02129315957427025, -0.01668436825275421, 0.042316630482673645, -0.012785104103386402, 0.046469796448946, 0.0010842813644558191, -0.05222542956471443, 0.002205169526860118, -0.005738406907767057, -0.020406395196914673, 0.001954854466021061, -0.012853136286139488, 0.014581338502466679, -0.01176106370985508, -0.00032271811505779624, 0.012274066917598248, -0.03265483304858208, 0.03073199838399887, -0.00723233912140131, 0.05606309697031975, -0.01873004622757435, 0.021822752431035042, -0.003815822536125779, -0.0010883361101150513, -0.036326419562101364, 0.013983719982206821, -0.0008445479325018823, 0.02376573346555233, 0.009978282265365124, 0.06064573675394058, 0.0044443001970648766, -0.017410701140761375, 0.023707306012511253, 0.04238478094339371, -0.01261385902762413, 0.021328169852495193, 0.031909868121147156, 0.008834087289869785, -0.029102729633450508, 0.03235749900341034, 0.008332003839313984, 0.015513435006141663, 0.02912108600139618, -0.004282808396965265, -0.006348007824271917, -0.05679820850491524, -0.02724878489971161, 0.02253745310008526, -0.001686064526438713, 0.023470820859074593, -0.00445792730897665, 0.06916883587837219, 0.026882119476795197, -0.023810800164937973, 0.003106816438958049, 0.0674995705485344, 0.029642466455698013, -0.01789485663175583, -0.030252749100327492, -0.008790316060185432, 0.03735737130045891, -0.012301504611968994, 0.006199485622346401, 0.0418706089258194, -0.01960083656013012, 0.004168406594544649, 0.0036731469444930553, -0.009089617989957333, -0.015562918037176132, 0.0025052614510059357, 0.010713431984186172, 0.006947836373001337, -0.0048327152617275715, 0.010391108691692352, 0.04559263959527016, 0.04885997995734215, 0.011928643099963665, 0.015403560362756252, -0.021396180614829063, -0.11532629281282425, 0.027851426973938942, 0.048926640301942825, 0.07612588256597519, -0.05337867885828018, -0.010111826471984386, -0.03514191508293152, 0.022053677588701248, -0.003963290713727474, -0.05047815665602684, 0.034688543528318405, -0.03212396055459976, 0.023179957643151283, -0.0404113307595253, -0.02015991136431694, 0.017619801685214043, 0.05566410347819328, 0.004474807530641556, 0.011554231867194176, -0.03972884640097618, 0.009322366677224636, 0.004394617397338152, 0.013972653076052666, 0.02464427798986435, 0.041875168681144714, -0.023014217615127563, 0.024018054828047752, -0.035162992775440216, 0.024430368095636368, -0.04176665470004082, -0.07543206959962845, -0.012049269862473011, -0.018202275037765503, -0.007640774827450514, 0.07891318202018738, -0.0002323811932001263, -0.04676942154765129, 0.015836844220757484, 0.011048100888729095, -0.009147131815552711, 0.005057227332144976, -0.06338684260845184, -0.026235336437821388, 0.01846485771238804, 0.030858881771564484, 0.027053378522396088, 0.00975807849317789, 0.023013781756162643, 0.048032451421022415, 0.01861860603094101, 0.04161727800965309, -0.030376151204109192, -0.02500648982822895, 0.011948548257350922, 0.008178431540727615, -0.07259631156921387, 0.010029883123934269, 0.013577195815742016, 0.03723786026239395, -0.01929411105811596, 0.005766395479440689, -0.018089430406689644, 0.01916557364165783, 0.04305315017700195, 0.006753804627805948, 0.016263680532574654, 0.016574615612626076, -0.02099008858203888, 0.0054326714016497135, -0.0005554898525588214, -0.05190718546509743, 0.025454100221395493, 0.030990827828645706, -0.019241521134972572, 0.012171353213489056, -0.010982226580381393, 0.037688277661800385, -0.016318244859576225, 0.001635657623410225, 0.014882782474160194, 0.07315569370985031, 0.0016465724911540747, -0.00025539161288179457, -0.00887619610875845, 0.010983004234731197, 0.010277611203491688, -0.01619567535817623, 0.04042798653244972, -0.06164000928401947, 0.024684196338057518, -0.011830491945147514, 0.010249292477965355, -0.09806691110134125, -0.027382509782910347, 0.042318496853113174, 0.021693017333745956, -0.03091983124613762, 0.0021444023586809635, 0.0022202585823833942, -0.0006258665816858411, 0.008014270104467869, -0.04545135051012039, 0.043570104986429214, 0.011926449835300446, -0.0269535593688488, -0.03753092512488365, 0.001593692577444017, 0.103414386510849, -0.008720393292605877, -0.013103816658258438, -0.003310518804937601, -0.006401718128472567, -0.014037746004760265, -0.014381688088178635, 0.029434029012918472, -0.03694215416908264, -0.004213716369122267, -0.02229253575205803, -0.022941814735531807, 0.05330229550600052, -0.011212138459086418, -0.045713216066360474, 0.010051070712506771, -0.0035596119705587626, -0.008321478962898254, -0.0011386540718376637, 0.03606364503502846, -0.03009304776787758, 0.030874183401465416, -0.01937735266983509, -0.029093116521835327, -0.009123343974351883, 0.0070627047680318356, -0.013447796925902367, 0.04606390371918678, -0.04471246898174286, 0.022093670442700386, 0.0691218227148056, -0.02786731719970703, -0.024609118700027466, -0.013974151574075222, -0.04514698311686516, 0.020664988085627556, -0.002026558853685856, 0.003563942387700081, -0.010041095316410065, -0.022327162325382233, -0.012035119347274303, -0.048594553023576736, -0.039325155317783356, 0.005906166974455118, 0.06701213121414185, 0.02200787514448166, 0.008053001947700977, -0.016843050718307495, 0.0034465258941054344, 0.0188151802867651, 0.00009730803139973432, 0.022927477955818176, -0.01610361412167549, -0.03129308670759201, 0.07589484751224518, 0.012782217003405094, -0.0035430702846497297, -0.0006801203126087785, -0.026337679475545883, 0.03527999296784401, 0.001773111056536436, -0.0016163241816684604, 0.006212875712662935, -0.014079956337809563, -0.02266952581703663, -0.026222137734293938, 0.030761288478970528, -0.04988063871860504, 0.03997323289513588, -0.05277523025870323, 0.007603870704770088, 0.05173201486468315, -0.007180649321526289, -0.00203215004876256, -0.008048280142247677, -0.025512920692563057, -0.06931409239768982, -0.012005594559013844, 0.026637841016054153, -0.014558177441358566, 0.03694362938404083, 0.01960925944149494, 0.05221595615148544, -0.010921217501163483, 0.05650382488965988, 0.007601922377943993, -0.07195470482110977, -0.004010400269180536, -0.001824740320444107, -0.0692729502916336, 0.03733799234032631, -0.027446458116173744, 0.012008637189865112, -0.04148094728589058, -0.019759468734264374, 0.020973481237888336, -0.04911619797348976, 0.024791212752461433, -0.0438486784696579, 0.08593080937862396, 0.016135182231664658, 0.01336781494319439, 0.0012337982188910246, -0.016580121591687202, 0.1410871297121048, 0.07684671878814697, 0.008095922879874706, -0.07306677103042603, 0.03449707850813866, -0.004351718816906214, 0.00028716918313875794, -0.03393249586224556, -0.0011334199225530028, -0.00471239211037755, -0.0022874062415212393, 0.056505635380744934, 0.028781848028302193, -0.014021915383636951, -0.01782071590423584, 0.02999197691679001, -0.028737928718328476, 0.017478283494710922, 0.04411973059177399, 0.03266638517379761, 0.0047703213058412075, 0.00957093108445406, -0.03482580557465553, -0.007637578062713146, -0.004038267303258181, -0.0004376631695777178, 0.014495309442281723, -0.028607776388525963, 0.02723909541964531, 0.019674232229590416, -0.04142535850405693, -0.0053145126439630985, 0.034242212772369385, 0.023556558415293694, -0.05322141945362091, -0.03829796984791756, 0.013272538781166077, -0.024501772597432137, 0.020813124254345894, 0.04920803755521774, 0.029601996764540672, -0.010750913061201572, -0.03774084895849228, -0.004482054151594639, -0.02131686545908451, -0.016500890254974365, 0.0346764475107193, -0.043915264308452606, 0.026778489351272583, 0.005630181171000004, -0.042206838726997375, 0.023536385968327522, -0.025391114875674248, -0.056024450808763504, 0.006409674417227507, 0.03443492203950882, 0.0364510752260685, -0.04710603877902031, -0.05439349263906479, -0.024486318230628967, -0.0033189652021974325, -0.024880142882466316, 0.05531616881489754, 0.022718366235494614, -0.035349659621715546, 0.021148409694433212, -0.02954285964369774, 0.04020876809954643, 0.018759334459900856, 0.031641021370887756, -0.04260890930891037, 0.011121849529445171, -0.022434288635849953, 0.0030022268183529377, 0.013116039335727692, 0.027263883501291275, 0.004474926739931107, -0.005374109838157892, -0.016605403274297714, -0.022331293672323227, -0.05250807851552963, 0.02564619854092598, -0.04756423085927963, -0.03505930304527283, -0.07197103649377823, 0.015625322237610817, 0.028778381645679474, 0.01956602931022644, 0.00015605738735757768, 0.005528996232897043, -0.03587197884917259, 0.050576236099004745, 0.023094123229384422, -0.04017840698361397, 0.01647755317389965, -0.03717091679573059, -0.05679730325937271, -0.040395624935626984, -0.05092380940914154, 0.0658847913146019, 0.02278834581375122, -0.004857824649661779, -0.01671513170003891, -0.040543533861637115, 0.016847332939505577, 0.005426997784525156, 0.026034913957118988, -0.054672662168741226, -0.0009702257229946554, 0.04015030339360237, -0.015150540508329868, -0.010682140477001667, -0.03126237913966179, -0.0019355765543878078, -0.016156554222106934, 0.042078301310539246, 0.038321949541568756, -0.05616580322384834, 0.012576443143188953, -0.012768898159265518, 0.005024132318794727, -0.01283965166658163, 0.005232568364590406, -0.02785399928689003, -0.0023452441673725843, -0.017723331227898598, -0.01571057178080082, -0.010732777416706085, -0.004476496949791908, -0.01038937084376812, 0.007082698866724968, 0.028137531131505966, 0.0089533980935812, 0.02455119602382183, -0.0034693721681833267, 0.01799776405096054, -0.022206375375390053, 0.03700009733438492, -0.028018780052661896, -0.06389503180980682, 0.014995907433331013, -0.023816552013158798, -0.0416470468044281, 0.007466584909707308, -0.01951509341597557, 0.027828143909573555, 0.026660671457648277, 0.02131073921918869, -0.018145602196455002, 0.03683732822537422, -0.01678377576172352, 0.0071405814960598946, 0.0353362001478672, 0.0007674010703340173, 0.026686547324061394, 0.0059090061113238335, 0.006649260874837637, 0.003352693747729063, 0.0005424889968708158, 0.0172138512134552, 0.031605806201696396, 0.02614654041826725, 0.06460823118686676, 0.009518992155790329, -0.009151959791779518, 0.02421157993376255, -0.035009872168302536, -0.03153177723288536, 0.012325732968747616, 0.021986428648233414, 0.015511343255639076, -0.01600731536746025, -0.03031999245285988, 0.038553379476070404, -0.0705162063241005, 0.006339628249406815, 0.009506132453680038, 0.006658107973635197, 0.055658288300037384, -0.01564769260585308, 0.037563201040029526, 0.02475043572485447, -0.02554158866405487, 0.008351578377187252, -0.024660687893629074, 0.013356724753975868, -0.06276503205299377, -0.06261113286018372, -0.02335575595498085, 0.005584376398473978, 0.06470471620559692, 0.005109003745019436, -0.012990258634090424, 0.035618916153907776, 0.0161210335791111, -0.005467386916279793, 0.04726601392030716, 0.0204258244484663, 0.0016699583502486348, -0.035439252853393555, 0.0476636067032814, -0.026054833084344864, -0.04266449064016342, 0.03575863689184189, 0.00013849926472175866, 0.03043070249259472, 0.04456045478582382, 0.00445184763520956, 0.0003935140557587147, 0.030780073255300522, 0.04010193049907684, -0.007806811947375536, -0.02736949548125267, -0.009783491492271423, 0.03374970704317093, 0.010311612859368324, -0.000887797970790416, 0.012520023621618748, 0.02534787543118, -0.03937988728284836, -0.007881324738264084, 0.009381505660712719, -0.0168889369815588, -0.017400572076439857, 0.010721537284553051, -0.005548209883272648, 0.03244763985276222, -0.008034071885049343, 0.011472112499177456, -0.01163608767092228, -0.03462141752243042, 0.0892057791352272, 0.016489330679178238, -0.023871244862675667, -0.014792063273489475, -0.050399597734212875, -0.02171412482857704, 0.04163948446512222, 0.021774904802441597, 0.021539408713579178, -0.09719390422105789, -0.0022458694875240326, 0.004089527763426304, -0.018684115260839462, -0.035364408046007156, -0.011753910221159458, 0.011460819281637669, 0.021359717473387718, -0.03200730308890343, 0.003358997404575348, 0.013256947509944439, -0.008757107891142368, 0.01087117101997137, -0.09818419814109802, 0.0710638090968132, -0.014011595398187637, -0.007966218516230583, -0.031913936138153076, -0.038742970675230026, -0.029949359595775604, -0.0014445021515712142, 0.05942847207188606, -0.01646091230213642, -0.014145856723189354, -0.034573692828416824, -0.0014602086739614606, 0.009989463724195957, -0.010511726140975952, 0.009425943717360497, -0.014385383576154709, 0.005606533493846655, 0.0005194336990825832, -0.008177860639989376, 0.010172090493142605, -0.015655847266316414, 0.015094042755663395, -0.0027595965657383204, -0.02952544391155243, 0.026565391570329666, -0.0070314048789441586, 0.053342487663030624, 0.023067070171236992, -0.016614805907011032, 0.05009917914867401, 0.036772582679986954, -0.019865497946739197, 0.031185492873191833, -0.0027520451694726944, -0.07422662526369095, 0.02335273288190365, -0.0017429227009415627, 0.009655316360294819, -0.010483852587640285, 0.029836434870958328, 0.008627688512206078, -0.040554825216531754, -0.017813028767704964, 0.01991601102054119, 0.0019764325115829706, 0.002734973095357418, 0.04836060106754303, -0.005178175400942564, 0.007417420856654644, 0.013939904980361462, 0.03628069534897804, 0.054567672312259674, 0.03695467486977577, 0.01060723140835762, 0.008598696440458298, 0.03003547340631485, -0.0029384123627096415, 0.029437417164444923, 0.004381487611681223, -0.019075103104114532, 0.0690232366323471, 0.007706005591899157, 0.03983673080801964, -0.003077720059081912, -0.03784741461277008, 0.01654117740690708, 0.015673568472266197, 0.003287669736891985, 0.01428531389683485, -0.009064271114766598, 0.02440311200916767, -0.019548557698726654, 0.008167367428541183, -0.023987209424376488, -0.02241337113082409, 0.0036164449993520975, -0.013090887106955051, 0.01836559921503067, 0.009796084836125374, -0.0013108337298035622, 0.03631100431084633, -0.013566683046519756, 0.030623028054833412, 0.0197151992470026, -0.0638141855597496, 0.007385815493762493, -0.04970826953649521, -0.0021278338972479105, 0.0048864237032830715, -0.03954797610640526, -0.06342707574367523, 0.00636749854311347, 0.0005395488697104156, 0.016531195491552353, -0.007242701482027769, -0.019597128033638, 0.009052361361682415, -0.0019982997328042984, 0.038589395582675934, -0.05469048395752907, -0.026330864056944847, -0.027302855625748634, 0.005129562225192785, -0.0011668408988043666, -0.03384751081466675 ]
<p>I have four sets of data grouped by stages (Stage 1-4) with each having their own correlation coefficient. The 4 sets of data has the same dependent and independent variables with 1st n=106, 2nd n=23, 3rd n=89, 4th n=132. My hypothesis is that at stage 4 the correlation would get weaker.</p> <p>From the numbers alone it supports the idea since the correlation is smaller on the 4th stage than on the 1st, 2nd and 3rd but is there a way to prove it statistically? Or is it just okay to say that there is a weakening in the correlation without having to resort to statistical significance testing? I have read about the Fisher z transform but can it be used to test 4 coefficients? And since I am only comparing the 4th stage to the rest can I just test 1-4 2-4 and 3-4 using Fisher z? Oh and is there a way to do the test using SPSS?</p>
73,787
[ -0.02421732060611248, -0.01313137449324131, -0.008653336204588413, 0.0069204168394207954, 0.03450968861579895, 0.02249881997704506, 0.00727043254300952, -0.050580769777297974, 0.005949696991592646, -0.019762007519602776, 0.00511188805103302, 0.022526713088154793, 0.017806297168135643, -0.01217066403478384, 0.029452649876475334, 0.016129517927765846, -0.010137184523046017, 0.013467713259160519, -0.026581965386867523, 0.022905830293893814, -0.030577439814805984, 0.009321946650743484, 0.012598144821822643, -0.017378440126776695, -0.018813369795680046, 0.0410180501639843, 0.026141639798879623, -0.023762252181768417, 0.013199430890381336, 0.046567510813474655, -0.006048457231372595, -0.01709895394742489, -0.01089673675596714, 0.051884476095438004, 0.011327053420245647, -0.028725840151309967, -0.029039952903985977, -0.02783505991101265, -0.00007016460585873574, 0.022377094253897667, -0.028285590931773186, -0.008394544012844563, -0.041657302528619766, 0.05522250756621361, -0.008391974493861198, 0.004998984280973673, 0.007722013164311647, 0.008365290239453316, 0.05869511142373085, -0.012616968713700771, 0.09165098518133163, 0.00892930943518877, 0.023784251883625984, 0.03066127561032772, -0.019221754744648933, -0.007547776214778423, 0.04226607456803322, 0.06009220331907272, -0.03925400599837303, -0.03444621339440346, -0.03993408381938934, -0.0495629645884037, 0.003806743770837784, -0.03255457803606987, -0.020893052220344543, -0.0025942442007362843, -0.014484204351902008, -0.015159289352595806, 0.037828899919986725, -0.0006038626306690276, 0.008837981149554253, 0.037059541791677475, 0.06531038135290146, -0.016277575865387917, -0.022481553256511688, -0.022043868899345398, 0.041600994765758514, 0.0020630552899092436, 0.041005492210388184, 0.05222839117050171, -0.002452262444421649, 0.008670477196574211, 0.015172775834798813, 0.04052082076668739, 0.03844056278467178, -0.013822481967508793, 0.06595846265554428, -0.03215566650032997, 0.01603819988667965, 0.040215227752923965, -0.032203786075115204, -0.026499275118112564, 0.03983462601900101, 0.020067034289240837, -0.03438560292124748, 0.020175471901893616, -0.04010600596666336, 0.03948556259274483, 0.018669715151190758, -0.0027289295103400946, 0.003547696629539132, -0.01769682951271534, 0.017187902703881264, 0.035933107137680054, -0.031760092824697495, 0.02626868709921837, -0.07008908689022064, -0.015308148227632046, -0.01645008847117424, -0.02430897392332554, 0.015413213521242142, -0.00789287406951189, 0.023968655616044998, 0.00976676493883133, 0.058721866458654404, -0.014122980646789074, -0.05693284794688225, -0.009056687355041504, 0.0338742733001709, 0.05195487290620804, 0.05597715079784393, -0.04164883866906166, 0.024519730359315872, 0.004235281143337488, -0.018774358555674553, 0.0295413751155138, -0.00018098978034686297, -0.04406624659895897, -0.016369082033634186, 0.05465348809957504, 0.01316127274185419, 0.0007266798056662083, 0.003916231915354729, -0.01592876948416233, 0.051185980439186096, 0.04179544746875763, -0.051953915506601334, -0.046171072870492935, 0.04629822447896004, -0.0413300059735775, 0.025506941601634026, -0.057966671884059906, 0.009314616210758686, 0.0029045850969851017, 0.09559964388608932, -0.02471855655312538, 0.02014334686100483, -0.03980548307299614, 0.03634671866893768, 0.04319210723042488, 0.0023540505208075047, -0.01695016585290432, -0.017273517325520515, -0.040512457489967346, 0.004954793956130743, -0.08165048807859421, 0.024232957512140274, -0.005454551428556442, 0.017493752762675285, -0.02591158263385296, 0.022199023514986038, 0.021115262061357498, -0.015859030187129974, -0.008734773844480515, 0.052659157663583755, 0.023265698924660683, 0.05503527447581291, -0.030497834086418152, 0.014678677543997765, 0.007520899176597595, 0.005147184710949659, -0.0042332992888987064, 0.004001901485025883, 0.07199741899967194, 0.06355844438076019, -0.0451122485101223, -0.03847642242908478, -0.02668413519859314, 0.0043755192309618, -0.0378277450799942, -0.03271639719605446, -0.02322242222726345, -0.05269221216440201, -0.005164314992725849, 0.01492029894143343, 0.03953895345330238, -0.004932868294417858, -0.00020535940711852163, 0.012158190831542015, -0.027267687022686005, -0.04900036379694939, -0.04492989182472229, 0.010944366455078125, 0.00979544222354889, -0.042948365211486816, 0.03145735710859299, 0.032931916415691376, 0.04743717983365059, 0.0015747471479699016, -0.042655862867832184, -0.027026040479540825, -0.008216225542128086, 0.013442201539874077, -0.04716556891798973, 0.02542855590581894, 0.033640459179878235, 0.0289654228836298, -0.03432859107851982, 0.05714956670999527, -0.049512602388858795, -0.015089171938598156, 0.056790709495544434, 0.00004331808304414153, -0.011261919513344765, 0.028347592800855637, -0.04184693470597267, 0.016655154526233673, -0.008637016639113426, -0.024720821529626846, 0.032744210213422775, -0.047542884945869446, 0.07574055343866348, 0.0651482492685318, 0.009213989600539207, -0.008570760488510132, 0.0016088633565232158, 0.020260481163859367, 0.054333094507455826, -0.02916766330599785, -0.015368512831628323, -0.02283480577170849, -0.036288291215896606, 0.0010711047798395157, 0.007756326347589493, -0.05790376663208008, 0.03204270824790001, 0.07500186562538147, 0.007651837542653084, 0.010766576044261456, 0.03583543747663498, 0.027305901050567627, -0.008703146129846573, -0.0007770742522552609, 0.05188289284706116, 0.016068842262029648, 0.022215383127331734, 0.011325392872095108, 0.027303002774715424, 0.05753163620829582, 0.006027672439813614, -0.040547799319028854, -0.023601412773132324, 0.04190830886363983, -0.005330471787601709, -0.029346855357289314, -0.021254152059555054, 0.048802219331264496, -0.02968609891831875, 0.01897817850112915, 0.03676265478134155, 0.017020130529999733, 0.015994684770703316, 0.007173218298703432, -0.03969442471861839, 0.05146784335374832, 0.05881860479712486, -0.018472028896212578, 0.006366802379488945, -0.0061705647967755795, -0.013225050643086433, 0.007914078421890736, -0.021181782707571983, -0.0027488041669130325, -0.04840334132313728, 0.021229049190878868, 0.038667865097522736, -0.02508736588060856, 0.02947981469333172, -0.019920961931347847, -0.0072874873876571655, -0.020441140979528427, 0.019946349784731865, 0.022597914561629295, -0.002785199088975787, -0.04755312576889992, -0.04182614013552666, 0.02465657703578472, -0.028947632759809494, 0.008656404912471771, -0.026954101398587227, -0.017374521121382713, 0.048362620174884796, -0.006714936811476946, -0.03143728896975517, -0.028606589883565903, 0.006390490103513002, 0.0036949883215129375, -0.04228627309203148, -0.03258651867508888, 0.059364937245845795, -0.004987388849258423, -0.0389375314116478, 0.024826733395457268, -0.02341657131910324, -0.015546089969575405, -0.008681802079081535, 0.03295496851205826, -0.0009163581999018788, 0.0073592085391283035, -0.005772060714662075, -0.0009033893584273756, -0.01921691559255123, -0.017296254634857178, -0.045672252774238586, -0.07690662890672684, 0.029618773609399796, -0.015983175486326218, 0.04385358840227127, 0.013705044984817505, -0.040720466524362564, 0.07709253579378128, 0.011294715106487274, 0.003324921941384673, -0.03818027675151825, -0.0018400127300992608, -0.054767053574323654, -0.02083955705165863, 0.054108764976263046, 0.0260782390832901, 0.014629118144512177, 0.023953713476657867, 0.011233045719563961, 0.03855578973889351, 0.05160743370652199, 0.018050827085971832, 0.016740867868065834, 0.03940793499350548, 0.0309365913271904, -0.03307291865348816, 0.014598624780774117, -0.004080809652805328, -0.08829957991838455, 0.0067596896551549435, -0.005170377902686596, 0.03075249120593071, 0.035419121384620667, -0.02539505437016487, 0.014508960768580437, 0.008870531804859638, -0.0009919634321704507, -0.027870971709489822, -0.000690896762534976, 0.037345368415117264, 0.0020343242213129997, -0.008143079467117786, 0.029283912852406502, 0.035310182720422745, 0.005974623374640942, -0.004493610933423042, 0.03195200860500336, -0.0018340109381824732, -0.038387078791856766, 0.026207929477095604, -0.010858062654733658, -0.0464128814637661, 0.05588126182556152, -0.004047879483550787, -0.021814482286572456, 0.033352937549352646, 0.01957152970135212, 0.020688025280833244, -0.019313110038638115, -0.02544546127319336, 0.02713293768465519, -0.051761023700237274, -0.009016131050884724, -0.025240560993552208, 0.03218609839677811, 0.0002686992520466447, 0.052444323897361755, 0.041313886642456055, -0.0005270728142932057, 0.024982277303934097, 0.02134379744529724, -0.08377169817686081, 0.0201918575912714, 0.01860217936336994, 0.026751387864351273, 0.014500350691378117, -0.030997227877378464, -0.03448761999607086, -0.02439301460981369, 0.024796616286039352, -0.008030200377106667, 0.05807707458734512, -0.014296390116214752, -0.004736240487545729, -0.030951330438256264, 0.010769072920084, -0.0008851266466081142, 0.030865198001265526, 0.014032091945409775, -0.03899722918868065, 0.04312387853860855, 0.032455459237098694, 0.0033997378777712584, 0.013322641141712666, -0.03617387264966965, 0.01084325835108757, 0.024652952328324318, 0.03049047850072384, 0.03310074657201767, -0.0018636537715792656, -0.03535003587603569, 0.013776274397969246, -0.012096961960196495, 0.027422767132520676, 0.027030086144804955, 0.008953701704740524, 0.007053524721413851, 0.006147482432425022, -0.0027554354164749384, 0.000770175305660814, 0.028159691020846367, 0.05656581372022629, -0.0038236144464462996, 0.01017951499670744, 0.005687525495886803, -0.06495807319879532, 0.012129888869822025, 0.08260845392942429, 0.006955921184271574, -0.03477032110095024, -0.02451215125620365, -0.004276173189282417, 0.002222621813416481, -0.015112554654479027, 0.012275204993784428, 0.045306362211704254, -0.007534484378993511, 0.017334572970867157, 0.01707294024527073, -0.0031106232199817896, -0.034437526017427444, 0.015386496670544147, -0.018187813460826874, 0.03468833118677139, 0.019325416535139084, -0.009569395333528519, 0.008079512044787407, 0.04043060913681984, 0.013196755200624466, 0.025839297100901604, -0.013008617796003819, -0.07379583269357681, 0.011842114850878716, 0.04650256782770157, 0.04542206600308418, -0.05819004029035568, 0.03526385873556137, -0.016496147960424423, -0.033427804708480835, 0.041004281491041183, -0.042598068714141846, 0.021288899704813957, 0.0019337928388267756, -0.013361972756683826, -0.053822312504053116, -0.032568108290433884, -0.029041530564427376, 0.004301699344068766, -0.005809287074953318, 0.0129395117983222, -0.029079224914312363, -0.004502879921346903, -0.024805525317788124, -0.012357862666249275, 0.021159783005714417, 0.05482679605484009, 0.0014838514616712928, -0.02057110145688057, -0.014324250631034374, 0.02831498719751835, -0.017106248065829277, -0.04886222258210182, 0.022693388164043427, -0.005116599146276712, 0.006280516739934683, 0.08215229958295822, -0.0277696680277586, -0.0027647996321320534, -0.007940330542623997, -0.010328740812838078, -0.015966499224305153, -0.000986375380307436, -0.018688153475522995, 0.06854075938463211, 0.01602780818939209, 0.007345151621848345, 0.030863428488373756, 0.03487280011177063, 0.010163845494389534, 0.012725465930998325, -0.013852312229573727, 0.019762400537729263, -0.03225107491016388, 0.01098085381090641, -0.0041589271277189255, 0.004332432057708502, -0.022210026159882545, 0.04756709933280945, -0.036669548600912094, 0.00834401324391365, -0.05022014304995537, 0.020058559253811836, 0.03088340535759926, -0.003272282425314188, -0.012214923277497292, 0.015166918747127056, -0.0011954030487686396, -0.00755205238237977, -0.012492950074374676, -0.02591113932430744, -0.016884641721844673, -0.03294159471988678, -0.019471153616905212, -0.0014117778046056628, -0.019556935876607895, 0.02421961911022663, -0.03722010552883148, -0.0026994445361196995, 0.03522095829248428, -0.026110870763659477, 0.00818677805364132, -0.02230871468782425, 0.020461175590753555, 0.004692512098699808, -0.013372674584388733, -0.0008949752082116902, 0.042000625282526016, -0.026470553129911423, 0.055469661951065063, -0.012503898702561855, 0.021175522357225418, -0.0037974659353494644, -0.0024470442440360785, -0.08963164687156677, -0.039014771580696106, 0.013848108239471912, 0.012291256338357925, -0.020172355696558952, 0.0007257410325109959, 0.00005216227873461321, -0.028935786336660385, -0.0034194334875792265, -0.01725500263273716, 0.046665873378515244, -0.002266407012939453, -0.028351619839668274, 0.019458914175629616, -0.008356449194252491, 0.06621124595403671, -0.011897752992808819, 0.00525188772007823, -0.025574179366230965, -0.027440931648015976, -0.02104509249329567, -0.00026823265943676233, -0.012452438473701477, -0.012283316813409328, -0.044262588024139404, 0.008961099199950695, -0.01990327052772045, 0.04035745561122894, -0.042594242841005325, -0.018563928082585335, -0.013444808311760426, -0.022073794156312943, 0.025071151554584503, -0.02912730537354946, 0.001981970854103565, -0.04537473991513252, 0.016677377745509148, -0.0077146808616817, 0.02230897732079029, -0.02558187209069729, -0.018352514132857323, 0.02708159200847149, 0.0151808001101017, -0.020888617262244225, 0.006192746572196484, 0.07267387211322784, -0.008662194013595581, -0.0010572101455181837, -0.008305578492581844, -0.027389468625187874, 0.013590159825980663, 0.04449577257037163, 0.007281975820660591, -0.018319521099328995, 0.03507538512349129, -0.02350032888352871, -0.023418888449668884, -0.019782597199082375, -0.0033088389318436384, 0.04756952077150345, -0.018126774579286575, 0.035380009561777115, 0.06754191219806671, -0.01519483420997858, 0.010434267111122608, -0.020556244999170303, 0.0209549218416214, 0.015370503067970276, -0.03683651611208916, 0.043150074779987335, -0.0019307626644149423, 0.006447178777307272, 0.011210708878934383, -0.002434329129755497, 0.011050991714000702, 0.06290312111377716, 0.014714760705828667, 0.007802540436387062, 0.03880797699093819, -0.040350016206502914, -0.02666216529905796, 0.03344376012682915, -0.03425632789731026, 0.012543750926852226, -0.05819130688905716, 0.02115204930305481, 0.009312565438449383, 0.07401333004236221, 0.013318760320544243, -0.04879457503557205, -0.020243946462869644, -0.049022797495126724, 0.017926611006259918, 0.009886815212666988, -0.034809064120054245, 0.02939809300005436, 0.0288100503385067, 0.010162032209336758, 0.006536569911986589, 0.05869536101818085, -0.023857058957219124, -0.060592979192733765, -0.02193051017820835, -0.008465033024549484, -0.026861701160669327, 0.025869332253932953, -0.009651966392993927, -0.02584739401936531, -0.008408399298787117, -0.046978943049907684, 0.0019938452169299126, 0.01160971075296402, 0.018082676455378532, -0.02919674664735794, 0.049225594848394394, 0.0006270367302931845, 0.0241742804646492, 0.03183077275753021, 0.0024244156666100025, 0.1191336140036583, 0.07751583307981491, -0.0018789650639519095, -0.05224527791142464, 0.02864779904484749, 0.004427980165928602, 0.005728043150156736, -0.05219179019331932, 0.022297808900475502, 0.023212995380163193, 0.000902737898286432, 0.029231419786810875, 0.1062697172164917, 0.01913495734333992, 0.01728581264615059, 0.057974107563495636, -0.01914626732468605, 0.007900654338300228, -0.019643809646368027, 0.016531838104128838, -0.009814620018005371, -0.01858329027891159, -0.06867669522762299, 0.0074657560326159, 0.0027088341303169727, -0.02479918859899044, -0.029509656131267548, 0.006192557513713837, 0.020124662667512894, -0.026598671451210976, -0.05472755804657936, 0.002817177912220359, 0.027950724586844444, 0.0044251405633986, -0.04843150079250336, -0.0028357072733342648, 0.011497550643980503, -0.05076367408037186, 0.05233818292617798, 0.03724835067987442, -0.0105653190985322, -0.0003081400354858488, -0.018353020772337914, 0.025197191163897514, -0.025356100872159004, -0.014557426795363426, -0.020906204357743263, 0.04537978395819664, 0.024115052074193954, -0.04369447007775307, -0.014809234999120235, 0.00684182858094573, 0.0024017959367483854, -0.045324601233005524, -0.03513718768954277, 0.011832725256681442, 0.020624365657567978, -0.03510597348213196, -0.02046600542962551, -0.03784925863146782, -0.016837362200021744, 0.000870397430844605, 0.014377091079950333, 0.0050386693328619, -0.01856977492570877, 0.0019211173057556152, -0.06033928692340851, 0.03639087453484535, -0.006509931292384863, -0.030380772426724434, -0.005249651614576578, 0.03207234665751457, -0.017002439126372337, 0.003800909733399749, -0.0033511039800941944, 0.0009061800083145499, 0.006649221759289503, -0.00290309963747859, -0.008098923601210117, -0.011943772435188293, -0.013236227445304394, -0.009958256036043167, -0.012560487724840641, -0.0011992418440058827, -0.053096335381269455, -0.017463309690356255, 0.05354791507124901, 0.04060376062989235, -0.025986716151237488, -0.00008472715853713453, -0.02719440497457981, 0.039680734276771545, 0.04251619428396225, -0.07285026460886002, -0.030768342316150665, -0.010639830492436886, -0.018394846469163895, -0.012942534871399403, -0.06568418443202972, 0.06978925317525864, 0.005102707538753748, -0.029279403388500214, -0.008954438380897045, 0.014136875979602337, -0.01996462047100067, 0.007279221434146166, 0.009610615670681, -0.06424820423126221, -0.021468348801136017, 0.0026816960889846087, -0.019436843693256378, -0.031552866101264954, -0.011765345931053162, -0.044617850333452225, 0.006728676147758961, 0.005722095258533955, -0.035160042345523834, -0.011461082845926285, 0.00967895146459341, -0.007696565706282854, -0.0048128776252269745, -0.015141377225518227, -0.0053716725669801235, -0.0548706129193306, -0.012404396198689938, 0.010454965755343437, 0.02688785269856453, 0.0011403620010241866, 0.026873402297496796, -0.03438194841146469, 0.016292421147227287, 0.06325841695070267, -0.012293891049921513, 0.0038592980708926916, -0.036442067474126816, -0.009185743518173695, 0.03620827943086624, 0.03169231489300728, -0.006129689048975706, -0.032402221113443375, 0.041524823755025864, -0.04958884045481682, -0.03699597343802452, 0.016146600246429443, -0.018216850236058235, 0.02296624891459942, 0.0004278025880921632, 0.01588478870689869, -0.025657063350081444, 0.02901744470000267, -0.01852746121585369, 0.00599780073389411, -0.017953794449567795, 0.007826241664588451, -0.03307679295539856, 0.037860769778490067, 0.00566414650529623, 0.01580102927982807, -0.029828259721398354, 0.016445841640233994, 0.07362474501132965, -0.008604777976870537, 0.007025125436484814, -0.011099946685135365, -0.010645108297467232, 0.02722863480448723, -0.00508411368355155, -0.04187290742993355, 0.06070289760828018, 0.06045747548341751, -0.010925409384071827, 0.021168412640690804, 0.014591779559850693, -0.01179065927863121, -0.09531445801258087, 0.0011566085740923882, -0.01345977745950222, 0.017243655398488045, 0.03656786307692528, -0.05464264377951622, 0.05797279253602028, 0.010305283591151237, -0.07041749358177185, 0.04419394209980965, -0.014698030427098274, -0.02791481278836727, -0.0671101063489914, -0.010775948874652386, 0.004603730980306864, 0.01892370730638504, 0.04899505153298378, 0.047729961574077606, 0.022393841296434402, 0.009349904954433441, 0.015396644361317158, 0.022402258589863777, 0.014670955017209053, 0.0004371057730168104, 0.015387623570859432, -0.06932269036769867, 0.025364026427268982, -0.05076904967427254, -0.05778764188289642, 0.04177446290850639, -0.01211839634925127, 0.018443439155817032, 0.019463859498500824, 0.02048344351351261, -0.003192292992025614, 0.062256284058094025, 0.019131524488329887, -0.02747379057109356, -0.015523997135460377, 0.0002477507514413446, -0.0020417794585227966, 0.013779517263174057, -0.016552496701478958, 0.01103328075259924, 0.008972304873168468, -0.017163194715976715, -0.05559679865837097, -0.0052200620993971825, -0.033966220915317535, 0.020288454368710518, -0.004886431619524956, -0.04044650122523308, -0.004717942792922258, -0.006369168870151043, 0.013006704859435558, -0.021830465644598007, -0.012713808566331863, 0.03514964506030083, 0.05043238028883934, -0.02168617583811283, -0.028236081823706627, -0.02474142238497734, -0.005021929740905762, 0.010780379176139832, 0.000910238828510046, 0.010969121940433979, -0.05749295651912689, 0.008036932907998562, -0.025324877351522446, -0.009225504472851753, -0.03724829480051994, -0.02213347516953945, -0.010126139037311077, 0.058962076902389526, -0.024128282442688942, -0.03434605523943901, 0.026727870106697083, -0.03844126686453819, 0.0008089515031315386, -0.10997097939252853, 0.021160470321774483, 0.00016663616406731308, -0.04004387930035591, -0.0411597341299057, 0.015399281866848469, -0.045382749289274216, -0.005351097323000431, 0.07925105839967728, 0.004827969707548618, 0.021462852135300636, -0.008349878713488579, 0.030259601771831512, 0.010900522582232952, -0.055722612887620926, 0.0844796672463417, 0.011485643684864044, -0.003272640984505415, -0.02780574932694435, -0.0033035906963050365, 0.007732233963906765, -0.02013886347413063, -0.005121416412293911, -0.012484351173043251, 0.021420417353510857, -0.035125311464071274, -0.007800310850143433, 0.032287053763866425, -0.027958251535892487, -0.003416835330426693, 0.05016067624092102, -0.04972495511174202, -0.013675060123205185, 0.05206028372049332, 0.007729952223598957, -0.04029490053653717, 0.027954641729593277, -0.0076800864189863205, -0.00040177410119213164, -0.022856416180729866, 0.03511433303356171, -0.025369668379426003, -0.036896150559186935, -0.0000019384228835406248, -0.002365601249039173, -0.04694643244147301, 0.008416990749537945, 0.05004151165485382, 0.04397065192461014, -0.00047093949979171157, -0.021078938618302345, 0.004381719045341015, -0.026177188381552696, -0.011331496760249138, 0.037493009120225906, 0.037538688629865646, 0.0160840954631567, 0.010694442316889763, -0.005089172627776861, 0.006872416008263826, -0.00001202105704578571, 0.01117048691958189, -0.0230606347322464, 0.02001672424376011, -0.004409031011164188, -0.013694338500499725, 0.0314469039440155, -0.005657683592289686, 0.026539383456110954, 0.03026971034705639, 0.044733040034770966, 0.031198175624012947, -0.048799898475408554, -0.00989831704646349, -0.031645454466342926, -0.03025946021080017, -0.05838678032159805, 0.03860802948474884, 0.04331722855567932, -0.010612564161419868, -0.02586512081325054, 0.01506495475769043, 0.008421072736382484, -0.02706868015229702, 0.030512120574712753, 0.007976114749908447, 0.019785568118095398, -0.057275205850601196, -0.016034472733736038, -0.0020735834259539843, 0.013890177011489868, -0.052929047495126724, -0.03727103769779205, 0.01823859103024006, 0.05624629557132721, 0.025499388575553894, -0.0056799352169036865, -0.013840069994330406, -0.0015515952836722136, 0.06588762253522873, -0.029554840177297592, -0.03616422042250633, -0.02995329350233078, 0.037121932953596115, 0.001945621334016323, -0.01112627424299717 ]
<p>I would like to try to make some sense of a neural network. The neural network has a single hidden layer and is used on 30-40 attributes, which are used to classify the probability that the observation belongs to 1 of 3 different classes. My goal is to the find 5-10 main interactions in order to understand the model better.</p> <p>To do this I've been recommended by my adviser to look into the 'Optimal Brain Damage'-algorithm (<a href="http://yann.lecun.com/exdb/publis/pdf/lecun-90b.pdf" rel="nofollow">http://yann.lecun.com/exdb/publis/pdf/lecun-90b.pdf</a>), which removes connections between nodes one by one. However, I cannot seem to find any R packages that supports this algorithm.</p> <p>I would therefore like to know what other algorithms exist to simplify neural networks and make them more easily interpreted. My efforts searching has so far been pretty useless, which is likely due to the fact that I don't have any clue of which key words to use.</p> <p>Thanks!</p>
73,788
[ -0.0264755729585886, 0.008678878657519817, 0.0025859877932816744, -0.008322305977344513, 0.040981002151966095, -0.0362931452691555, -0.0010893706930801272, -0.012504194863140583, 0.03287346288561821, -0.04467880353331566, 0.021110383793711662, 0.056305140256881714, 0.026446277275681496, 0.05792300030589104, -0.010710274800658226, -0.010768662206828594, -0.02516111731529236, -0.029548652470111847, -0.016342060640454292, -0.034883663058280945, -0.036842986941337585, -0.000073958195571322, 0.011635531671345234, -0.005692541599273682, -0.01720360480248928, 0.052308954298496246, 0.0035634543746709824, 0.004595691803842783, -0.009090008214116096, 0.0435161218047142, -0.021122010424733162, -0.04935864359140396, -0.012800400145351887, 0.029734091833233833, -0.004466439131647348, -0.008929946459829807, 0.01309365127235651, -0.034215155988931656, -0.014718311838805676, -0.005671316757798195, -0.004037738777697086, -0.02418910153210163, -0.009056522510945797, 0.024033628404140472, -0.03877774626016617, 0.029202349483966827, 0.001595837646164, -0.009918003343045712, 0.03297136351466179, -0.024698542430996895, 0.0704643726348877, 0.008019035682082176, 0.021346356719732285, 0.04462503269314766, -0.013584425672888756, -0.001052636536769569, 0.04159292206168175, 0.08471713215112686, -0.02184975892305374, -0.07392948120832443, -0.009510571137070656, -0.032018523663282394, -0.011939261108636856, -0.0029950460884720087, -0.02912040241062641, 0.05909235402941704, -0.0005769297713413835, -0.004021623637527227, 0.029534894973039627, -0.012404331006109715, 0.0028121252544224262, -0.01976444385945797, 0.020406609401106834, 0.0003905717749148607, -0.027139127254486084, 0.013554476201534271, 0.01748785376548767, -0.003949203994125128, 0.028703797608613968, 0.042045485228300095, -0.00014706265938002616, 0.007024677935987711, 0.0023358899634331465, 0.010783380828797817, 0.024894051253795624, -0.014117450453341007, 0.11045318096876144, -0.03431747108697891, 0.01996639557182789, 0.0059098126366734505, -0.044362809509038925, 0.010446219705045223, 0.05740935727953911, 0.027531499043107033, -0.04278258979320526, 0.015007459558546543, 0.0020971919875591993, 0.018102867528796196, 0.035100486129522324, 0.0007953358581289649, -0.014417086727917194, -0.0370764397084713, -0.03664473444223404, 0.03474080562591553, -0.01962568238377571, -0.01467543188482523, -0.03874816745519638, -0.01069636456668377, 0.006054242607206106, 0.007133635692298412, -0.010090159252285957, 0.04320767521858215, 0.005450658034533262, 0.014944317750632763, 0.007113112602382898, -0.032622698694467545, -0.012616394087672234, -0.010537846013903618, -0.015218311920762062, 0.04893089458346367, 0.022958824411034584, -0.03929370641708374, 0.03793734312057495, -0.02527749165892601, -0.03938578814268112, -0.017283368855714798, 0.044358402490615845, -0.021405404433608055, -0.023409919813275337, 0.06287489086389542, 0.02219763584434986, -0.040354274213314056, 0.03481534495949745, -0.0007525095716118813, 0.029365992173552513, -0.015734700486063957, -0.07064395397901535, -0.05268484726548195, 0.058227669447660446, -0.05605306103825569, 0.007632093038409948, -0.04694466292858124, 0.003795328550040722, 0.0033354400657117367, 0.05681559070944786, 0.019321462139487267, 0.016645636409521103, 0.020602039992809296, -0.002532049547880888, 0.010737310163676739, -0.02212659828364849, -0.003582151373848319, -0.013921656645834446, 0.026998765766620636, -0.05670151114463806, -0.06910067051649094, 0.041763484477996826, 0.040311429649591446, -0.007164262235164642, 0.005701059941202402, 0.041583478450775146, -0.0037447584327310324, -0.0037406301125884056, -0.003130989847704768, -0.011273045092821121, -0.010965503752231598, 0.07421085983514786, -0.01389381568878889, 0.05517476424574852, 0.013019033707678318, -0.039489589631557465, 0.03148145601153374, 0.008254184387624264, 0.05372840538620949, 0.02872156910598278, 0.007190476171672344, -0.010012781247496605, -0.029756594449281693, 0.019556552171707153, 0.03402242437005043, 0.0033252215944230556, -0.03170282766222954, -0.025861451402306557, -0.022526375949382782, -0.005879280157387257, 0.048539891839027405, 0.013436872512102127, -0.03532705083489418, 0.028922129422426224, -0.017590753734111786, -0.06814289093017578, -0.05088680610060692, 0.021694915369153023, -0.06907583028078079, 0.006579139735549688, -0.00013446758384816349, 0.016423078253865242, 0.03310013562440872, -0.00037362813600338995, -0.012550923973321915, -0.04550325497984886, 0.009561089798808098, 0.01072692684829235, 0.003124307608231902, -0.010908969677984715, 0.01760600507259369, 0.029340632259845734, -0.028683317825198174, 0.049151986837387085, -0.04825059697031975, -0.044784869998693466, 0.014732875861227512, -0.013423656113445759, 0.01831701770424843, -0.005107675679028034, -0.045041702687740326, 0.021672561764717102, 0.02119513228535652, -0.024820582941174507, 0.02233944460749626, -0.07735507190227509, 0.06606990844011307, 0.047553565353155136, 0.02006528526544571, 0.033170927315950394, 0.011673878878355026, -0.008303127251565456, 0.03750638663768768, -0.0012321193935349584, 0.017277158796787262, -0.08341757953166962, -0.009227479808032513, 0.051140815019607544, 0.000010896297681028955, -0.03366707265377045, 0.0198897123336792, 0.040072280913591385, 0.01639779843389988, 0.024804847314953804, 0.015461455099284649, -0.01586327701807022, -0.008453140035271645, -0.00283904280513525, 0.01812872663140297, -0.01907956413924694, -0.00387430377304554, 0.042559653520584106, 0.0030822670087218285, 0.06788919866085052, 0.004212810192257166, -0.02356460690498352, 0.06191755458712578, 0.00411289231851697, 0.003540088189765811, 0.009634551592171192, -0.021746240556240082, 0.03880380466580391, -0.024932587519288063, 0.002193462336435914, 0.015679238364100456, 0.00968154240399599, -0.024501025676727295, 0.0020609619095921516, 0.01687133125960827, 0.015635106712579727, 0.015210537239909172, -0.008136836811900139, 0.006549085956066847, 0.016580799594521523, -0.036757998168468475, 0.004859936889261007, -0.01441236399114132, -0.0037106124218553305, -0.037532173097133636, 0.06266128271818161, 0.047700896859169006, 0.008446496911346912, 0.03952557221055031, -0.01304622646421194, 0.003730726893991232, 0.033102381974458694, -0.0420328788459301, 0.05103252828121185, 0.020890502259135246, -0.04282477870583534, -0.006463560275733471, -0.031189948320388794, -0.01341956201940775, 0.027163516730070114, -0.004267403390258551, -0.03503531590104103, -0.0044652135111391544, -0.01695282571017742, -0.05169083550572395, -0.01290757767856121, -0.031162358820438385, 0.00660298066213727, -0.023191148415207863, -0.02130591869354248, 0.002268992131575942, 0.024953115731477737, -0.03628766909241676, 0.011839049868285656, -0.03470079228281975, -0.025995487347245216, -0.01085712667554617, -0.014745738357305527, 0.018648775294423103, 0.024515580385923386, -0.07945343852043152, 0.053874239325523376, -0.020106153562664986, -0.002535230712965131, -0.06951850652694702, -0.06403134763240814, 0.0208829827606678, 0.0021153902634978294, 0.005838815122842789, 0.03185427188873291, 0.0237038005143404, 0.050206687301397324, -0.001246815430931747, -0.062296006828546524, -0.02634192816913128, 0.02109275385737419, 0.0010846079094335437, -0.013149278238415718, 0.058659788221120834, 0.038607239723205566, 0.05409624055027962, 0.005879410542547703, -0.013918984681367874, 0.00032170291524380445, 0.051676541566848755, -0.010700386017560959, 0.026177814230322838, 0.03699303790926933, -0.03282124921679497, -0.04518118500709534, 0.00445966562256217, 0.0494600310921669, -0.036901313811540604, 0.0483151413500309, -0.011240600608289242, 0.009373731911182404, 0.03648856282234192, -0.021058641374111176, 0.03086126782000065, -0.013602995313704014, 0.00548352999612689, -0.022444527596235275, -0.025191567838191986, -0.030803047120571136, -0.019533652812242508, 0.008916202932596207, 0.04697836562991142, 0.06987239420413971, -0.03041689284145832, -0.00952982623130083, 0.0398193821310997, 0.02066734805703163, -0.01556727197021246, 0.0032982828561216593, -0.005962572526186705, -0.02165837027132511, -0.0023500979878008366, -0.00920647382736206, 0.013481326401233673, 0.040098488330841064, 0.023424040526151657, 0.00993108656257391, 0.04393206164240837, -0.01327179279178381, 0.039574962109327316, -0.0635470598936081, -0.0009411765495315194, -0.054513730108737946, 0.04278113692998886, 0.02726582996547222, 0.0007215615478344262, -0.009003687649965286, -0.009632433764636517, 0.032959870994091034, 0.002451507607474923, -0.08689197897911072, 0.04209379851818085, 0.003377474844455719, -0.024715716019272804, 0.023777814581990242, -0.012766961939632893, 0.035924218595027924, -0.015640972182154655, -0.0022862330079078674, -0.04083745926618576, 0.0275547094643116, -0.06449413299560547, 0.014801295474171638, -0.0009508748771622777, 0.01551938895136118, -0.02627462148666382, 0.016274429857730865, 0.06207529455423355, 0.0002151337539544329, -0.01864778995513916, 0.024013420566916466, 0.02637311816215515, -0.02184808999300003, 0.013449001125991344, -0.0072435857728123665, 0.030209193006157875, 0.039293039590120316, 0.00003897482019965537, 0.027997028082609177, -0.024711044505238533, 0.020604945719242096, -0.0029450873844325542, 0.03615044429898262, 0.013262070715427399, 0.012713906355202198, -0.03361615911126137, -0.057984333485364914, 0.015337646938860416, -0.0036533824168145657, 0.04603517800569534, -0.00864534080028534, 0.010645669884979725, 0.07023617625236511, 0.02791483886539936, -0.06702042371034622, -0.021680137142539024, 0.06265489757061005, 0.013745095580816269, -0.022101420909166336, -0.010813961736857891, -0.008212416432797909, -0.0194417592138052, 0.02373277209699154, 0.039778370410203934, 0.016830483451485634, -0.020368965342640877, 0.01464135479182005, 0.058910466730594635, -0.032581787556409836, -0.023615434765815735, -0.03716554865241051, -0.023506879806518555, 0.04255346953868866, -0.01857323758304119, -0.009107253514230251, -0.01085283886641264, 0.02596319653093815, 0.04916560649871826, -0.003408238757401705, -0.0012962899636477232, -0.0656154602766037, 0.030527746304869652, 0.058267321437597275, 0.04197867959737778, -0.026354430243372917, -0.016538696363568306, -0.0642550066113472, -0.04467063397169113, 0.062479063868522644, -0.050538137555122375, 0.013435694389045238, -0.019322490319609642, 0.012763270176947117, -0.03271138295531273, -0.022317472845315933, 0.011043447069823742, -0.0016803876496851444, -0.031031696125864983, 0.05325254052877426, -0.0038648496847599745, -0.011411883868277073, -0.04836083576083183, 0.008798722177743912, -0.006812031846493483, 0.04278873652219772, 0.00034036883153021336, -0.007098151836544275, 0.03649032115936279, -0.012282252311706543, 0.009583065286278725, -0.07924845814704895, 0.007937544025480747, -0.0019971029832959175, -0.02671288140118122, 0.04282258823513985, 0.0020809227135032415, -0.040098920464515686, 0.026855485513806343, 0.019199954345822334, -0.04545385017991066, -0.01638711243867874, -0.02891290746629238, 0.055787596851587296, 0.03060080297291279, 0.003043500240892172, 0.055792659521102905, -0.012012685649096966, -0.01940685510635376, 0.021503688767552376, -0.04523796960711479, 0.009908457286655903, -0.01490585133433342, -0.005615565925836563, -0.029681501910090446, -0.017069591209292412, -0.0003938211302738637, 0.04010039195418358, -0.010318468324840069, 0.04996718093752861, -0.031160961836576462, 0.024249009788036346, -0.018229762092232704, 0.01088610477745533, -0.022989138960838318, -0.013768007047474384, 0.015901006758213043, 0.02928163670003414, 0.023323718458414078, -0.0017713112756609917, 0.027493756264448166, -0.009637901559472084, -0.0022610605228692293, 0.024463264271616936, -0.024593841284513474, -0.021485749632120132, -0.046544961631298065, -0.03730874881148338, 0.04462109133601189, -0.0458156056702137, 0.0708313137292862, -0.0067178611643612385, 0.03710750490427017, 0.01926870085299015, 0.0015084899496287107, -0.05564218387007713, 0.00251420633867383, -0.009389616549015045, -0.01672198995947838, -0.02559373714029789, 0.021728534251451492, -0.03918193653225899, -0.006274285260587931, -0.02052018977701664, -0.052377454936504364, 0.01542787067592144, -0.03235664591193199, -0.03565039113163948, -0.061425693333148956, 0.02474149875342846, 0.020579954609274864, -0.017659593373537064, -0.018473133444786072, 0.04259978234767914, -0.04283372312784195, 0.009412253275513649, -0.0011671606916934252, -0.03280617669224739, 0.04953780770301819, 0.038123633712530136, 0.012244349345564842, 0.0014472634065896273, -0.027865100651979446, -0.011992386542260647, -0.010791968554258347, 0.01965446211397648, -0.0019020561594516039, -0.00219989032484591, -0.05360929295420647, 0.005224461667239666, 0.05831807479262352, -0.0035848310217261314, 0.005691698286682367, -0.007731329184025526, 0.004201417323201895, -0.03270446136593819, -0.04754917696118355, -0.002058599144220352, -0.021307189017534256, 0.016679562628269196, -0.0006706292042508721, 0.010275347158312798, -0.009686165489256382, -0.05522768944501877, 0.02487754449248314, -0.004546056501567364, -0.009254833683371544, 0.03610978648066521, 0.053407520055770874, 0.01621874049305916, -0.002655608579516411, -0.010818712413311005, -0.04991031438112259, 0.051710646599531174, -0.027082333341240883, 0.005528793670237064, -0.047656867653131485, 0.036192748695611954, -0.04325703904032707, -0.05644004046916962, -0.036616239696741104, 0.027783958241343498, 0.04960786923766136, -0.006474113091826439, 0.042414382100105286, 0.038111478090286255, -0.021214989945292473, -0.005146061070263386, -0.017012067139148712, 0.007105271797627211, 0.024307379499077797, 0.02967619150876999, 0.07337263226509094, -0.02407096140086651, -0.007569583598524332, 0.01921030320227146, 0.05428425967693329, 0.0037163207307457924, 0.06296322494745255, -0.013636717572808266, -0.007435590028762817, 0.013558736070990562, -0.04487403482198715, -0.05547618120908737, 0.0028116290923208, -0.03462421894073486, 0.035258714109659195, -0.019008008763194084, -0.006304166279733181, 0.04304919391870499, 0.025583283975720406, 0.0003085180651396513, -0.023164847865700722, -0.036049146205186844, -0.04813450947403908, -0.009889621287584305, 0.03644029051065445, -0.021279610693454742, 0.003281565150246024, -0.004676998592913151, 0.018491927534341812, 0.0028735892847180367, 0.011158659122884274, -0.03898685798048973, -0.06557463109493256, -0.03506758436560631, -0.006443466059863567, -0.036032285541296005, 0.05310345068573952, 0.00788156408816576, -0.061898160725831985, 0.02216401696205139, -0.019085753709077835, 0.030025390908122063, 0.004597591236233711, 0.049990639090538025, 0.02045537531375885, 0.05125841125845909, 0.001760605489835143, -0.016613267362117767, 0.023227153345942497, 0.001506737433373928, 0.13993877172470093, 0.08668803423643112, 0.026521751657128334, -0.07440688461065292, 0.0019233747152611613, 0.022147778421640396, -0.025490188971161842, -0.015237054787576199, 0.03548191115260124, 0.015986111015081406, 0.003202988998964429, 0.021871350705623627, 0.027114642783999443, 0.034538041800260544, -0.013061131350696087, 0.05075734108686447, -0.03594735264778137, -0.045103829354047775, 0.019556161016225815, 0.008328535594046116, -0.00307297776453197, -0.03287845849990845, -0.06208282336592674, 0.0035467620473355055, -0.013356415554881096, -0.017681382596492767, -0.02570846490561962, 0.0003159951011184603, 0.05766654759645462, 0.01038757711648941, -0.018250903114676476, 0.014938393607735634, -0.009861095808446407, 0.013808872550725937, 0.04048383980989456, 0.041009657084941864, 0.027019891887903214, -0.04119330272078514, 0.036970674991607666, 0.01255921833217144, 0.02342294715344906, -0.0029309524688869715, 0.013862352818250656, 0.0044820187613368034, -0.026976056396961212, -0.04347327724099159, -0.03071397729218006, 0.05753989890217781, -0.009118222631514072, -0.008447768166661263, 0.0010626154253259301, -0.00006298197695286945, 0.030638044700026512, -0.04850376024842262, -0.005046857055276632, 0.02709738165140152, 0.04662374407052994, -0.003262325655668974, 0.014884578995406628, -0.036097630858421326, -0.0028818997088819742, -0.0176030732691288, 0.02175917476415634, 0.051708295941352844, 0.020756863057613373, -0.01766415499150753, -0.03774392232298851, 0.021239634603261948, 0.022942978888750076, 0.016927411779761314, 0.0037378796841949224, -0.04325477406382561, 0.009380146861076355, -0.00463266484439373, 0.020428398624062538, 0.025484472513198853, 0.006215021479874849, -0.020316749811172485, -0.018812598660588264, -0.007651798892766237, -0.0013596114004030824, 0.0040712179616093636, -0.004572519566863775, -0.012076914310455322, 0.009138788096606731, -0.02317703329026699, 0.027822870761156082, 0.04021956026554108, 0.04050678759813309, 0.005415078718215227, -0.0027607025112956762, -0.02081953175365925, 0.02208484150469303, -0.045521657913923264, -0.03807630017399788, 0.018444519490003586, -0.022861896082758904, 0.010712135583162308, 0.004399108234792948, 0.05738196149468422, -0.004201624076813459, -0.015418739058077335, 0.004936687182635069, 0.05872959643602371, -0.004404010716825724, -0.010073312558233738, -0.003379607107490301, -0.060093145817518234, 0.018900852650403976, -0.014569837599992752, 0.037259291857481, -0.04522383213043213, -0.013975311070680618, -0.018800947815179825, -0.022217297926545143, 0.0003217204939574003, 0.01604943536221981, -0.018380707129836082, 0.011606688611209393, 0.011806664057075977, 0.0232470091432333, -0.03345460444688797, 0.04381965473294258, -0.07244087755680084, -0.002014339901506901, -0.006733623333275318, -0.04014212638139725, -0.023356657475233078, 0.013150312006473541, 0.018309125676751137, -0.006763809826225042, 0.06112022325396538, -0.019173530861735344, 0.006838840898126364, -0.009842082858085632, 0.002219853224232793, -0.0026729642413556576, 0.0755712017416954, -0.003396842395886779, -0.007550153415650129, 0.012512735091149807, -0.039651401340961456, -0.020480068400502205, -0.01595844142138958, -0.020800698548555374, 0.03992662578821182, 0.027000028640031815, -0.03347209095954895, -0.012890670448541641, 0.05430644378066063, -0.0175153985619545, -0.0011373416054993868, -0.012173841707408428, -0.010360426269471645, -0.0223053228110075, 0.00154975859913975, -0.0172888096421957, 0.0016598606016486883, -0.019878234714269638, -0.005884194280952215, 0.020081670954823494, 0.028635649010539055, -0.02839818224310875, 0.016380801796913147, -0.031386349350214005, 0.017980093136429787, -0.01969117671251297, 0.00232698954641819, 0.0009208093397319317, 0.04103507101535797, -0.043251920491456985, 0.08544521778821945, 0.004854352679103613, 0.03216191381216049, -0.10315654426813126, -0.010832020081579685, -0.031710028648376465, 0.022662702947854996, 0.055714961141347885, -0.07921786606311798, 0.04126593843102455, -0.035223186016082764, -0.04973391443490982, 0.02090711146593094, -0.014591876417398453, 0.016566287726163864, 0.0058386423625051975, 0.00822847243398428, -0.04187032952904701, 0.006702509243041277, 0.01598767563700676, 0.029615821316838264, 0.03162061423063278, -0.005956368986517191, -0.032197512686252594, -0.026717418804764748, -0.025727681815624237, 0.01808030903339386, 0.020713545382022858, -0.03265251964330673, 0.05528257414698601, -0.048553191125392914, -0.03497491031885147, 0.0331779308617115, -0.02234220691025257, 0.016557909548282623, 0.04555289074778557, 0.01887512020766735, 0.015500105917453766, 0.06753534078598022, 0.02308618277311325, -0.029550833627581596, 0.018136335536837578, -0.016442490741610527, 0.00477573974058032, 0.011697263456881046, -0.0012857168912887573, -0.0016369125805795193, 0.021212387830018997, -0.006976841948926449, -0.05773046985268593, -0.021167879924178123, 0.0025275119114667177, -0.00354071450419724, -0.05503670871257782, -0.04547256603837013, 0.026065070182085037, -0.020408393815159798, 0.005626938305795193, -0.010751280933618546, 0.010844903066754341, 0.025517147034406662, 0.04391805827617645, -0.0060660215094685555, 0.024798521772027016, -0.001411649864166975, -0.030224597081542015, -0.02590806782245636, 0.008794503286480904, 0.015376275405287743, -0.05062617361545563, 0.01712772808969021, 0.020270289853215218, -0.029778171330690384, -0.03236464038491249, -0.015206110663712025, -0.019861748442053795, 0.04729211702942848, -0.006055733188986778, 0.010113888420164585, 0.026017064228653908, -0.041671380400657654, 0.05296226590871811, -0.07329116016626358, 0.016787780448794365, 0.015111876651644707, 0.0343514159321785, -0.022077756002545357, 0.008918079547584057, -0.020124690607190132, -0.0047697345726192, 0.06073393672704697, -0.04668677598237991, 0.02927219308912754, -0.027273625135421753, 0.020854853093624115, 0.02561183273792267, -0.04577380046248436, 0.03809832036495209, -0.025102123618125916, -0.020381180569529533, -0.02564120851457119, -0.04252741485834122, 0.01487095095217228, 0.022165320813655853, 0.017223147675395012, 0.014721806161105633, -0.028345681726932526, -0.006533736363053322, 0.01834777370095253, 0.03342662379145622, -0.008654939010739326, 0.003747867653146386, 0.01788727380335331, -0.0047107175923883915, -0.0013580200029537082, 0.04096929728984833, -0.0015843939036130905, -0.033086441457271576, 0.029642874374985695, -0.027740946039557457, -0.007044412661343813, -0.012270370498299599, -0.0023116078227758408, 0.018850546330213547, -0.0681220218539238, -0.0010489127598702908, 0.012748262844979763, 0.00416986970230937, -0.014168947003781796, 0.0657803937792778, 0.004999267868697643, 0.034136444330215454, 0.013616183772683144, 0.008255776949226856, -0.03749314695596695, -0.007180353160947561, 0.023691294714808464, -0.0008287067175842822, -0.016439685598015785, -0.010306060314178467, 0.003997575957328081, 0.022135665640234947, -0.036983393132686615, 0.049569692462682724, -0.02715124934911728, 0.0222809836268425, -0.0336456336081028, -0.045562565326690674, 0.005270897876471281, -0.028040340170264244, 0.012113070115447044, -0.027263253927230835, 0.0007662457064725459, 0.04567072167992592, -0.030701158568263054, 0.008637988939881325, -0.005728464107960463, -0.021321196109056473, -0.02017637901008129, 0.018776092678308487, -0.007488693576306105, 0.04495977610349655, -0.001614027889445424, 0.02075350098311901, 0.029937785118818283, 0.01366988942027092, 0.0314117856323719, -0.03266225755214691, 0.02937360852956772, -0.009045405313372612, -0.027357349172234535, 0.030817624181509018, 0.014024335891008377, -0.03431759402155876, -0.03676926717162132, 0.029796777293086052, 0.07670851796865463, -0.027263524010777473, -0.0011452882317826152, 0.002759136026725173, -0.026003196835517883, 0.03192241117358208, -0.06734973192214966, -0.004740681499242783, -0.05354873463511467, 0.001014321343973279, -0.021371126174926758, -0.019304633140563965 ]
<p>I'm creating Poisson GLMs in R. To check for overdispersion I'm looking at the ratio of residual deviance to degrees of freedom provided by <code>summary(model.name)</code>. </p> <p>Is there a cutoff value or test for this ratio to be considered "significant?" I know that if it's >1 then the data are overdispersed, but if I have ratios relatively close to 1 [for example, one ratio of 1.7 (residual deviance = 25.48, df=15) and another of 1.3 (rd = 324, df = 253)], should I still switch to quasipoisson/negative binomial? I found <a href="http://data.princeton.edu/R/glms.html">here</a> this test for significance: 1-pchisq(residual deviance,df), but I've only seen that once, which makes me nervous. I also read (I can't find the source) that a ratio &lt; 1.5 is generally safe. Opinions?</p> <p>Thanks!</p>
73,789
[ 0.01216883398592472, 0.023158641532063484, 0.00884946621954441, -0.024133512750267982, 0.023454517126083374, 0.010270816273987293, -0.005280863493680954, -0.00525708869099617, 0.049272164702415466, -0.03998410329222679, 0.02944803610444069, 0.04781973734498024, 0.0330212339758873, 0.007615897338837385, 0.03872651234269142, 0.0006734656635671854, -0.011447407305240631, -0.004966922104358673, 0.006986294407397509, -0.01942390576004982, -0.012415512464940548, -0.006173818372189999, 0.0313909612596035, -0.02007109485566616, -0.024801384657621384, 0.03718539699912071, 0.04929465800523758, 0.017264991998672485, 0.027301102876663208, 0.03288134187459946, -0.04546166583895683, -0.0075334603898227215, 0.019508419558405876, 0.036954861134290695, 0.05260491371154785, 0.012359559535980225, -0.0059624360874295235, -0.039716605097055435, 0.014516862109303474, 0.024584325030446053, -0.01061942894011736, -0.022650096565485, -0.026134634390473366, 0.016960326582193375, 0.012950368225574493, -0.003060348331928253, -0.015322820283472538, -0.05914883688092232, 0.08431121706962585, -0.0385856069624424, 0.02361305244266987, -0.008443859405815601, 0.016816087067127228, 0.04620777815580368, 0.010108216665685177, 0.007057282142341137, 0.05207933858036995, 0.06517481058835983, -0.005307432264089584, -0.03485914692282677, -0.027552597224712372, -0.05303061008453369, 0.012926098890602589, -0.01903783716261387, 0.00020758621394634247, 0.023439371958374977, -0.017790857702493668, -0.05017133802175522, 0.06363720446825027, -0.01138550229370594, 0.011714310385286808, 0.004013364668935537, 0.0188203863799572, -0.0017728391103446484, 0.0036776571068912745, 0.006454776972532272, -0.003034271765500307, -0.005405006464570761, 0.020063376054167747, 0.08054529875516891, -0.01503430213779211, -0.00514491880312562, -0.01290691364556551, 0.036654047667980194, 0.010585999116301537, -0.0270330011844635, 0.0705983117222786, -0.0309844259172678, 0.011521199718117714, 0.05373385548591614, -0.03500792756676674, -0.016940360888838768, 0.0400007925927639, 0.023933086544275284, -0.04932748153805733, 0.03335783630609512, 0.0055704545229673386, -0.010269134305417538, 0.00857616402208805, -0.016273396089673042, -0.058669667690992355, -0.055388495326042175, 0.030744677409529686, 0.037997473031282425, -0.038035158067941666, -0.004761841148138046, -0.0495302714407444, -0.024281546473503113, -0.008964370004832745, -0.07335971295833588, 0.0004571351164486259, 0.0017916541546583176, 0.016211874783039093, -0.02291128970682621, 0.0147304842248559, -0.02575349248945713, 0.008464192040264606, -0.006291909608989954, 0.06709814816713333, 0.06167076900601387, 0.051331453025341034, 0.013767224736511707, 0.022716468200087547, -0.024058012291789055, -0.03439097851514816, 0.009286169894039631, 0.035844605416059494, 0.006211532279849052, -0.03427322581410408, 0.06639084964990616, -0.0105725834146142, -0.019925490021705627, 0.0330662876367569, -0.007256334647536278, 0.04204290732741356, 0.008140196092426777, -0.07336858659982681, -0.04565926641225815, 0.044025011360645294, 0.017980456352233887, 0.01122971996665001, -0.06519608199596405, -0.023372536525130272, 0.011511120945215225, 0.01666279323399067, 0.012470848858356476, 0.034533869475126266, -0.050882190465927124, -0.0032049547880887985, -0.01841098442673683, -0.04426770657300949, -0.017346080392599106, -0.011868919245898724, -0.03840469941496849, -0.016569949686527252, -0.08704795688390732, 0.007048507686704397, 0.006513858214020729, 0.01729857549071312, 0.014561970718204975, -0.0000012309251360420603, 0.010400449857115746, 0.017965925857424736, -0.00224937847815454, -0.01330823265016079, -0.001418699393980205, 0.07357877492904663, -0.0191760566085577, 0.013016019947826862, 0.018770992755889893, -0.02573155052959919, -0.015268631279468536, 0.029332302510738373, 0.059866972267627716, 0.0385780967772007, -0.00407369202002883, 0.02513066679239273, -0.0628909319639206, 0.019955558702349663, 0.010665258392691612, -0.038723334670066833, 0.022119279950857162, -0.01826048083603382, -0.02954019047319889, 0.036117807030677795, 0.008569738827645779, -0.010631456971168518, -0.013073347508907318, 0.07726787775754929, -0.04309794306755066, -0.07564777880907059, -0.0038643439766019583, -0.04596228897571564, 0.0011961840791627765, -0.020011624321341515, 0.02922498807311058, 0.04339325428009033, 0.043768659234046936, -0.03192388638854027, 0.020969955250620842, -0.02112615294754505, -0.029196934774518013, 0.027621077373623848, -0.04783819988369942, -0.015539855696260929, 0.021632008254528046, 0.0299694687128067, -0.03697211295366287, 0.04615158215165138, -0.011785264126956463, -0.040991704910993576, -0.0170174241065979, -0.034464120864868164, 0.0009209353011101484, -0.008098560385406017, -0.013155806809663773, 0.0335603803396225, -0.008500314317643642, -0.030945109203457832, 0.00419028103351593, -0.04370544105768204, 0.06745008379220963, 0.04761878028512001, 0.0066657885909080505, 0.013323160819709301, -0.015059167519211769, 0.039090946316719055, -0.018692806363105774, -0.03967660292983055, 0.007945975288748741, -0.04454169049859047, 0.011644916608929634, 0.06479696929454803, 0.0007182614644989371, -0.02481413632631302, 0.01359962485730648, 0.08434189110994339, -0.008161833509802818, 0.04707665368914604, 0.03428145498037338, -0.008797606453299522, -0.014436136931180954, 0.017310576513409615, 0.024292727932333946, 0.03003011830151081, -0.00299787032417953, 0.05448165163397789, -0.0023930068127810955, 0.017815835773944855, -0.005309806205332279, -0.0008291628328152001, 0.02938746102154255, 0.021727371960878372, -0.025097358971834183, 0.0033154499251395464, 0.01849883608520031, 0.029511939734220505, 0.010861700400710106, 0.03344045951962471, 0.060832150280475616, 0.012579084374010563, -0.011205463670194149, 0.02225842885673046, -0.021179815754294395, 0.003747924230992794, 0.036827635020017624, -0.0591464526951313, -0.009833201766014099, 0.011076034046709538, -0.028996532782912254, -0.0013816223945468664, -0.04032943770289421, -0.03827492520213127, -0.04421969875693321, 0.021808262914419174, 0.036378536373376846, 0.018811538815498352, 0.026199761778116226, -0.02899548038840294, -0.007367700804024935, -0.020853588357567787, -0.011020272970199585, 0.023547083139419556, 0.006618778221309185, -0.07145549356937408, -0.014262738637626171, -0.011688191443681717, -0.02317076548933983, 0.034150365740060806, -0.025549935176968575, -0.021035246551036835, -0.006115712691098452, 0.010670009069144726, -0.03722500428557396, -0.029988348484039307, -0.016996003687381744, -0.014781300909817219, -0.018750209361314774, -0.05963889881968498, 0.02248230017721653, -0.033241257071495056, -0.0385102741420269, 0.005030022002756596, -0.040127065032720566, -0.022067628800868988, -0.0012821450363844633, 0.037522803992033005, 0.01885521598160267, 0.020551178604364395, -0.012942511588335037, 0.0004901268403045833, -0.017358755692839622, -0.02574050985276699, -0.06281019002199173, -0.08558685332536697, -0.006626991089433432, 0.008853443898260593, 0.05579026788473129, 0.013871661387383938, -0.015704339370131493, 0.08427247405052185, 0.03776966407895088, 0.006624861154705286, -0.013025037944316864, 0.012978031300008297, -0.03297114372253418, -0.025497371330857277, 0.03134544566273689, 0.03246469795703888, 0.05559477582573891, 0.04760469123721123, -0.002856013597920537, 0.052150171250104904, 0.0018028217600658536, -0.004373325500637293, -0.025017768144607544, 0.02909129671752453, -0.001387081341817975, -0.0013475293526425958, 0.004593998659402132, 0.03354547545313835, -0.03159422427415848, 0.0014596179826185107, 0.0061471061781048775, 0.0515303872525692, 0.006072679068893194, -0.020701775327324867, 0.005032863933593035, 0.0026541671250015497, 0.008247093297541142, 0.010850760154426098, 0.00659007765352726, -0.0062111420556902885, -0.037897344678640366, 0.008630788885056973, 0.016626032069325447, 0.029994450509548187, -0.02592494711279869, 0.008130425587296486, 0.03205312415957451, 0.011925242841243744, 0.010679221712052822, 0.022936390712857246, -0.009673292748630047, -0.006221834570169449, 0.0061360434629023075, -0.00922304391860962, -0.02538418397307396, 0.02770094946026802, 0.026838697493076324, 0.029224107041954994, -0.03912649303674698, -0.03613124042749405, 0.03163149580359459, -0.04381761699914932, 0.008788084611296654, -0.003154801670461893, 0.00795873161405325, -0.011997521854937077, 0.03486064448952675, 0.008795458823442459, -0.013031006790697575, -0.023313792422413826, -0.007966447621583939, -0.02322353795170784, 0.03955383598804474, -0.028868861496448517, 0.003794719697907567, -0.0034502726048231125, -0.006459253374487162, 0.014745060354471207, -0.029321204870939255, 0.008016971871256828, 0.00270649790763855, 0.027487048879265785, -0.02350139059126377, 0.023591643199324608, -0.02793864533305168, 0.0005117668770253658, -0.017075663432478905, 0.020482363179326057, -0.024439675733447075, -0.0027626652736216784, 0.03202270343899727, 0.042844053357839584, 0.00019198704103473574, -0.015860669314861298, -0.021375276148319244, 0.01985606737434864, 0.01821819320321083, 0.05178609490394592, 0.04301172122359276, 0.024336976930499077, -0.05182472988963127, 0.036588821560144424, 0.008200855925679207, 0.01715277135372162, 0.009924090467393398, -0.012026339769363403, -0.004473177716135979, -0.031222008168697357, -0.021744679659605026, -0.042322490364313126, 0.016575509682297707, 0.017948735505342484, 0.0003807002794928849, 0.06297900527715683, 0.04821178689599037, -0.050168465822935104, 0.019600022584199905, 0.06477485597133636, -0.004180346615612507, 0.009714238345623016, -0.039079636335372925, 0.006791264284402132, 0.022741716355085373, 0.017443684861063957, -0.00644419901072979, 0.028573645278811455, -0.006630419287830591, 0.011951004154980183, 0.03564316779375076, -0.026649782434105873, -0.02914697676897049, -0.006098554469645023, 0.011407042853534222, 0.06779831647872925, -0.005301219876855612, -0.0010012362617999315, -0.005797704681754112, -0.019649570807814598, 0.031266238540410995, 0.05470717325806618, -0.004583184141665697, -0.06977496296167374, -0.020533641800284386, 0.0692535787820816, 0.04486236721277237, -0.031048914417624474, 0.007293262984603643, -0.009503643959760666, -0.012423751875758171, 0.06441829353570938, -0.02750248834490776, 0.0010914021404460073, -0.008907875046133995, 0.031302716583013535, -0.011950923129916191, -0.03759867697954178, -0.09867855161428452, 0.027846239507198334, 0.005351553205400705, 0.012539983727037907, -0.023555438965559006, -0.04263976961374283, -0.0675472617149353, 0.04824614152312279, -0.017687732353806496, 0.047895289957523346, -0.026406120508909225, -0.033136941492557526, 0.011211064644157887, 0.008474067784845829, -0.0038323220796883106, -0.0714273750782013, 0.027153251692652702, -0.017143983393907547, 0.01786329783499241, 0.0681295096874237, -0.03353263437747955, -0.03622983768582344, -0.008598503656685352, 0.02772747166454792, -0.04621739313006401, 0.007383990567177534, -0.006519128102809191, 0.035764724016189575, 0.002187063219025731, -0.012979594990611076, 0.019616952165961266, -0.005586694460362196, -0.02163153700530529, 0.021960526704788208, -0.07871635258197784, -0.007032298017293215, -0.03599855676293373, -0.025632206350564957, -0.03643811494112015, -0.0010810059029608965, -0.03612465783953667, 0.024515260010957718, -0.010469739325344563, 0.014408379793167114, -0.01891462691128254, 0.007977301254868507, 0.023111039772629738, 0.032671160995960236, 0.027088863775134087, -0.016121912747621536, 0.037782855331897736, -0.009998501278460026, -0.025360234081745148, -0.012438698671758175, 0.008578935638070107, -0.04271407425403595, -0.007910787127912045, 0.03904985263943672, -0.07770860195159912, -0.010449721477925777, -0.029533684253692627, -0.020520301535725594, -0.01557737123221159, -0.035816390067338943, 0.03265230730175972, 0.014088987372815609, 0.028612328693270683, 0.0007298801210708916, -0.034081365913152695, -0.0030381798278540373, 0.029951058328151703, -0.005386193282902241, 0.047020409256219864, -0.0075767929665744305, 0.007049961946904659, -0.049730267375707626, 0.010286662727594376, -0.07239764928817749, -0.04071066156029701, 0.005661367438733578, 0.0071341497823596, 0.0055806273594498634, -0.049697551876306534, -0.020791346207261086, -0.016738491132855415, -0.002229026984423399, -0.01558798085898161, 0.03975386917591095, -0.06122055649757385, -0.01558808796107769, -0.028442300856113434, -0.008304410614073277, 0.06634793430566788, -0.026194794103503227, 0.007783557754009962, 0.04468739777803421, -0.006644456647336483, -0.016177168115973473, 0.01895887590944767, 0.0301460400223732, -0.005807604640722275, -0.04840272292494774, -0.03080444224178791, -0.03302546963095665, 0.01677004061639309, -0.052058104425668716, -0.052529893815517426, -0.013247906230390072, -0.014708337374031544, 0.06449588388204575, -0.02298920974135399, -0.006185996811836958, -0.013466929085552692, 0.011766631156206131, -0.050538770854473114, 0.021035656332969666, -0.006360104773193598, 0.00019491364946588874, 0.0644865557551384, -0.0020832077134400606, 0.012278104200959206, 0.04180625453591347, 0.05878416448831558, -0.007823256775736809, -0.02314871922135353, 0.02473009191453457, -0.031274713575839996, 0.041659701615571976, 0.027999013662338257, -0.0017315231962129474, 0.0018323884578421712, 0.06338679790496826, -0.03810011222958565, -0.02852722443640232, -0.023977821692824364, -0.027274182066321373, 0.02209029346704483, 0.0010284760501235723, 0.012240268290042877, 0.039850521832704544, 0.0028318448457866907, 0.03290911763906479, 0.011148194782435894, -0.010774263180792332, 0.0011761088389903307, 0.0004107505374122411, 0.031092392280697823, -0.07052087038755417, 0.007446896750479937, 0.020612619817256927, 0.014023357070982456, -0.0019559997599571943, 0.05036604404449463, -0.01603950932621956, 0.012433045543730259, 0.027537133544683456, -0.013531085103750229, -0.049342185258865356, 0.05624615401029587, -0.0367947556078434, 0.033330779522657394, -0.04095309227705002, -0.023525990545749664, 0.03236966207623482, 0.04038427397608757, -0.0062338681891560555, -0.03536014258861542, -0.03990380838513374, -0.03316061571240425, 0.024911608546972275, 0.026551343500614166, -0.0069633591920137405, -0.0030963015742599964, -0.027333447709679604, 0.04940084367990494, -0.005936851259320974, 0.033892713487148285, -0.025786343961954117, -0.07945994287729263, -0.024775288999080658, 0.012592737562954426, -0.027210421860218048, 0.016317302361130714, -0.010474594309926033, -0.028563741594552994, 0.02506127581000328, -0.05230266973376274, -0.018273742869496346, -0.005677154287695885, 0.03062564507126808, -0.016467392444610596, 0.05662291496992111, -0.009517720900475979, -0.0039953142404556274, 0.002444419078528881, -0.020955203101038933, 0.12694032490253448, 0.052980195730924606, 0.03164907172322273, -0.027432451024651527, 0.007046754006296396, 0.0038263031747192144, -0.01877620443701744, -0.021906517446041107, -0.00437289709225297, 0.011533338576555252, 0.009468535892665386, 0.07988427579402924, 0.06306667625904083, 0.0330425389111042, -0.022965043783187866, 0.06348999589681625, 0.005764282774180174, -0.018391801044344902, -0.0004996193456463516, 0.03268758952617645, -0.008279681205749512, -0.029184259474277496, -0.050607338547706604, 0.017548689618706703, 0.0199850145727396, 0.015011084266006947, -0.030019793659448624, -0.002067842287942767, -0.03404882550239563, 0.02602372318506241, -0.0274030938744545, -0.03435128554701805, 0.021735917776823044, 0.0034482814371585846, 0.007982693612575531, -0.03519843518733978, 0.013465951196849346, -0.015113170258700848, -0.00991589855402708, 0.036027342081069946, -0.026011325418949127, 0.030374137684702873, 0.016773413866758347, 0.017807748168706894, -0.03925212845206261, -0.022067679092288017, -0.0172028299421072, 0.018350474536418915, 0.019925029948353767, 0.032992877066135406, 0.013100409880280495, -0.007968796417117119, -0.0009922193130478263, -0.026859654113650322, -0.017819974571466446, 0.02656986564397812, 0.032123126089572906, -0.019585231319069862, -0.01919800229370594, -0.024716004729270935, 0.025738339871168137, 0.004265452269464731, 0.015487308613955975, 0.016395851969718933, 0.0033746804110705853, -0.04177726432681084, -0.017242901027202606, 0.0834779441356659, 0.0006071388488635421, 0.0003645016986411065, -0.014045805670320988, -0.02066837251186371, -0.009576259180903435, 0.04258076846599579, -0.014993080869317055, -0.032843511551618576, 0.01587936282157898, -0.011411534622311592, -0.0057813371531665325, -0.01070075761526823, -0.034756582230329514, 0.023750225082039833, -0.018355384469032288, -0.0031631572637706995, -0.0278963390737772, -0.0703926607966423, 0.03435481712222099, 0.016858169808983803, 0.0006415834068320692, 0.008392742834985256, -0.012269658036530018, 0.07700525224208832, -0.01977873407304287, -0.0459749735891819, 0.008434416726231575, -0.028533529490232468, -0.0370037741959095, -0.00024107799981720746, -0.03877773880958557, 0.03427276387810707, 0.012248788960278034, 0.019705839455127716, 0.011524125002324581, 0.010028532706201077, -0.023488126695156097, 0.04099048674106598, 0.023716764524579048, -0.04999757558107376, -0.030154773965477943, -0.007897177711129189, -0.03071877360343933, 0.010849055834114552, -0.029370054602622986, -0.030328713357448578, -0.042362917214632034, -0.013424517586827278, 0.006359410006552935, -0.022740676999092102, -0.021736562252044678, 0.017108889296650887, 0.011925389058887959, -0.015674030408263206, -0.040301162749528885, -0.03973756730556488, 0.007602553814649582, 0.012562659569084644, -0.023689623922109604, 0.024608489125967026, -0.009954712353646755, 0.0137731172144413, 0.042169105261564255, 0.03838221728801727, 0.013908454217016697, 0.030517488718032837, -0.00757205206900835, 0.03140502795577049, 0.029991477727890015, 0.039304595440626144, -0.02186492085456848, 0.011240823194384575, 0.06741256266832352, -0.01645917445421219, -0.01849452592432499, 0.04900432750582695, -0.004883092828094959, 0.05230695754289627, -0.01303093135356903, -0.000943722203373909, -0.02974400296807289, 0.044218510389328, -0.011938742361962795, -0.010033708065748215, 0.002592266071587801, -0.009971153922379017, -0.011646609753370285, -0.020688101649284363, 0.0014691912801936269, -0.01641392521560192, -0.039269786328077316, 0.027543362230062485, 0.06557417660951614, -0.006200452335178852, 0.008154341951012611, 0.017377352342009544, -0.03848852217197418, -0.008080776780843735, 0.004762412514537573, -0.009174135513603687, 0.029558105394244194, 0.061759527772665024, -0.04898316040635109, 0.02198861539363861, -0.055108122527599335, 0.047532856464385986, -0.0873711034655571, -0.05694950744509697, -0.010720264166593552, 0.014006983488798141, 0.01737033948302269, -0.06567192077636719, 0.0198709387332201, 0.015300897881388664, -0.0068182689137756824, -0.018627848476171494, -0.043197643011808395, -0.04962514340877533, -0.04985116049647331, -0.00394246494397521, -0.02838750183582306, 0.02328414097428322, 0.016917208209633827, -0.003255085088312626, 0.04267621785402298, 0.0493856780230999, -0.018513843417167664, -0.035207316279411316, 0.007383230607956648, 0.0011214939877390862, -0.014084653928875923, -0.08634832501411438, 0.019430318847298622, -0.01065774168819189, 0.0016643075505271554, 0.020657280460000038, -0.010955363512039185, 0.010410735383629799, 0.05400656536221504, 0.030324798077344894, 0.01034696213901043, 0.0685996562242508, 0.05447985231876373, 0.0016391028184443712, -0.028757328167557716, -0.03025442361831665, 0.02150431089103222, 0.04019477218389511, -0.041632942855358124, -0.0048091779462993145, -0.004683741834014654, -0.016889233142137527, -0.026304829865694046, 0.03878505155444145, -0.016372136771678925, -0.007192626129835844, -0.02091444469988346, 0.05880517512559891, -0.009767013601958752, -0.025286134332418442, 0.07451379299163818, -0.044913727790117264, 0.01606905274093151, 0.05159769579768181, 0.0649762749671936, -0.03625940531492233, 0.02216547355055809, -0.01091539766639471, -0.02479672245681286, -0.016440708190202713, 0.002063027350232005, -0.016152266412973404, -0.026485946029424667, 0.007638814393430948, -0.03277106583118439, 0.055676620453596115, -0.01447216048836708, 0.007679889444261789, -0.02490956149995327, 0.041702281683683395, 0.0005523375002667308, 0.025524763390421867, 0.0463605597615242, -0.011147307232022285, 0.020555494353175163, -0.07925351709127426, 0.042169906198978424, 0.04729394242167473, -0.00731418002396822, -0.04556765407323837, -0.029246916994452477, -0.048040956258773804, 0.01106653269380331, 0.05130581557750702, 0.035877957940101624, 0.015220681205391884, 0.006247892510145903, 0.03184662386775017, 0.0007451795390807092, -0.05533001571893692, 0.013356063514947891, -0.0069266632199287415, -0.04379608482122421, -0.02335679903626442, 0.011238430626690388, 0.03398929536342621, -0.006901849526911974, 0.007260781712830067, 0.016076475381851196, 0.008086099289357662, 0.00027004224830307066, -0.05268433690071106, 0.05385732650756836, 0.024932969361543655, 0.0074388254433870316, 0.03714409098029137, -0.01336633786559105, 0.017590003088116646, 0.03398311138153076, -0.0010314121609553695, -0.026572279632091522, 0.08464406430721283, -0.016509898006916046, -0.02449413202702999, 0.005784287117421627, 0.01415930688381195, -0.015256819315254688, -0.04287674278020859, 0.014432147145271301, -0.004231436178088188, -0.04845159873366356, 0.017305459827184677, -0.017784908413887024, 0.006070484407246113, 0.018868668004870415, -0.017443304881453514, -0.004504690412431955, 0.023387597873806953, -0.009841430932283401, 0.01775568537414074, 0.026626648381352425, -0.005615580826997757, 0.009207814931869507, 0.007001261226832867, 0.019636405631899834, -0.007211390417069197, 0.01510077528655529, 0.02536385878920555, 0.039282605051994324, -0.012704959139227867, 0.01894124411046505, 0.03263600915670395, -0.015042386017739773, 0.039819467812776566, 0.043702878057956696, 0.001516589312814176, 0.016454653814435005, 0.005525293760001659, -0.0066367946565151215, -0.0027816088404506445, -0.021340783685445786, 0.011909712105989456, -0.0071957772597670555, -0.013148754835128784, 0.034135568886995316, -0.0076879533007740974, 0.01024729572236538, 0.004538793116807938, -0.008582830429077148, 0.007830077782273293, -0.050567932426929474, 0.058604445308446884, -0.0004891068674623966, 0.031069215387105942, -0.01370636373758316, 0.00275047542527318, -0.040268439799547195, -0.02563473768532276, 0.031732309609651566, 0.028814224526286125, 0.017383335158228874, -0.062303803861141205, -0.03458833321928978, 0.04382209852337837, 0.012602603062987328, -0.03503050282597542, -0.04185687378048897, -0.03555780649185181, -0.0025032414123415947, -0.018526850268244743, 0.004034338518977165 ]