question
stringlengths
37
38.8k
group_id
int64
0
74.5k
sentence_embeddings
sequencelengths
1.02k
1.02k
<p>I ran a data set containing ages through SAS npar1way first, but a reviewer wanted standard errors, so that motivated a smooth bootstrap. Since I could not use survyselect, I had to code a data step. I think it's set up correctly. I ran 10,000, 20,000 and 100,000 replicates. I need some feedback on my findings. The results I got weren't entirely satisfactory, but I don't have a lot of experience bootstrapping, so feedback is appreciated. I have two groups, so first I split them, then drew my samples, combined everything and used by processing to obtain the results.</p> <pre><code>data sasdata.group1 sasdata.group2; set sasdata.have(keep=group ga birthwt); if group=1 then output sasdata.group1; if group=2 then output sasdata.group2; run; sasfile sasdata.group1 load; data sasdata.outboot1(drop=__i); do Replicate = 1 to 100000; do __i = 1 to numrecs; p = int(1 + numrecs*(ranuni(62353006))); set sasdata.group1 point=p nobs=numrecs; a = a + rannor(623530)/sqrt(numrecs); /* 1 */ output; end; end; stop; run; sasfile sasdata.group1 close; ods listing close; sasfile sasdata.group2 load; data sasdata.outboot3(drop=__i); do Replicate = 1 to 100000; do __i = 1 to numrecs; p = int(1 + numrecs*(ranuni(17036255))); set sasdata.group2 point=p nobs=numrecs; a = a + rannor(170362)/sqrt(numrecs); /* 1 */ output; end; end; stop; run; sasfile sasdata.group2 close; ods listing close; data sasdata.a; set sasdata.outboot1 sasdata.outboot3; run; proc sort data=sasdata.a; by replicate group; run; ods listing close; proc univariate data=sasdata.a; var a; by replicate group; output out=sasdata.aresults median=medianx; run; ods listing; proc transpose data=sasdata.aresults (keep=replicate group medianx ) out=sasdata.t_results prefix=grp; by replicate; var medianx; id group; run; proc univariate data=sasdata.t_results; var grp1 grp2; run; data sasdata.median_diff; set sasdata.t_results; median_diff=grp1-grp2; run; proc univariate data=sasdata.median_diff /*noprint */; var median_diff; output out=sasdata.percentiles pctlpre=P_ pctlpts=2.5, 97.5; run; </code></pre> <p>The medians just don't seem to match what I get from npar1way. They're close, but slightly off; thus the difference in medians is slightly larger for the bootstrap case. It doesn't seem right to report the npar1way medians and the bootstrap SEs given that the bootstrap does not converge to the actual medians. Any ideas as to what's going on here?</p>
36,275
[ -0.00045373375178314745, -0.03232424333691597, -0.002027743961662054, -0.007634246721863747, 0.017662322148680687, -0.038860660046339035, 0.0036468300968408585, -0.03280224651098251, 0.01837051659822464, -0.03867805004119873, 0.056533508002758026, 0.030504267662763596, 0.012191897258162498, 0.0342705212533474, -0.03375135734677315, -0.004709480330348015, -0.00429502734914422, -0.006672845222055912, 0.0024571616668254137, 0.0035642627626657486, 0.0025137935299426317, 0.014558415859937668, -0.03565279766917229, -0.08526302129030228, 0.029751913622021675, 0.016822736710309982, -0.029626647010445595, -0.04102553427219391, -0.006840741261839867, 0.015807263553142548, -0.014899881556630135, -0.04398518428206444, 0.030769463628530502, 0.000534100632648915, 0.04123211279511452, 0.019261203706264496, 0.003894779598340392, -0.011613734997808933, 0.002682916820049286, 0.03508157655596733, -0.040938522666692734, 0.011478113010525703, -0.014558181166648865, 0.032256320118904114, 0.009956608526408672, 0.018227940425276756, 0.010253039188683033, 0.023761212825775146, 0.047765616327524185, -0.06714639067649841, 0.02913176827132702, -0.030973348766565323, -0.008020962588489056, 0.028927508741617203, -0.023598622530698776, -0.01428861916065216, 0.05844781920313835, 0.060735370963811874, 0.04252568259835243, -0.014155940152704716, 0.03111397847533226, 0.014378915540874004, -0.0026174394879490137, 0.011110866442322731, -0.02882944978773594, -0.008744604885578156, 0.014947593212127686, -0.036081232130527496, -0.012868976220488548, -0.015666436403989792, 0.058853745460510254, -0.021550694480538368, 0.03325411304831505, -0.028835099190473557, 0.002656195778399706, -0.0021018036641180515, -0.003459298750385642, -0.01318519376218319, 0.06043250486254692, 0.039436835795640945, -0.003189478302374482, 0.048190996050834656, 0.011499403044581413, 0.021830793470144272, 0.008242964744567871, -0.025108497589826584, 0.043526098132133484, -0.044903043657541275, 0.006903693079948425, 0.053955014795064926, 0.025990206748247147, 0.0036064975429326296, 0.054348502308130264, 0.02196410298347473, -0.00667680986225605, 0.05638636276125908, -0.012501823715865612, 0.04390737786889076, -0.05490873008966446, 0.030047042295336723, -0.004664831794798374, -0.025507451966404915, 0.05427414923906326, 0.026543380692601204, -0.02635021135210991, -0.01751646213233471, -0.042134080082178116, 0.0021729611326009035, -0.029188724234700203, -0.032483864575624466, -0.0054063559509813786, 0.0017274064011871815, -0.0007130176527425647, -0.007905608043074608, 0.048009857535362244, 0.015366293489933014, 0.0012967006769031286, 0.03356004133820534, 0.023490428924560547, 0.013877477496862411, 0.022468890994787216, 0.015116480179131031, 0.011726544238626957, -0.008781630545854568, -0.0302467942237854, 0.01406270731240511, -0.0025842313189059496, 0.004318146035075188, -0.058663416653871536, 0.03730904683470726, 0.0043030232191085815, -0.003660007147118449, 0.06779360771179199, -0.03720008209347725, 0.009731706231832504, -0.0212587658315897, -0.08584217727184296, -0.048991650342941284, -0.009267226792871952, -0.00433130469173193, 0.06174418330192566, -0.05137525498867035, 0.02223968133330345, 0.024201851338148117, 0.027355000376701355, -0.011173010803759098, 0.04127528890967369, 0.02268282137811184, 0.03534213453531265, 0.006173694971948862, 0.005393411498516798, 0.003727839794009924, -0.029355429112911224, -0.018922071903944016, -0.00899669248610735, -0.07289385795593262, 0.04036327451467514, 0.017493166029453278, 0.009271707385778427, -0.021176613867282867, -0.013777240179479122, 0.0027013435028493404, 0.03453456610441208, -0.040895912796258926, 0.025098351761698723, -0.014930824749171734, 0.07096154987812042, 0.001786854350939393, -0.027014020830392838, 0.038940299302339554, -0.03869110345840454, 0.04208652675151825, -0.027424192056059837, 0.011657885275781155, 0.06157117709517479, -0.00494596129283309, 0.023211423307657242, -0.011116488836705685, -0.03883419185876846, 0.01461019180715084, -0.0035261157900094986, -0.01031449157744646, -0.023968739435076714, 0.013754008337855339, 0.05381166934967041, 0.0020808943081647158, 0.005652126390486956, -0.00015355336654465646, 0.05416104197502136, -0.035342294722795486, -0.029257329180836678, -0.05750320106744766, -0.0053525082767009735, 0.006315067410469055, -0.07460252195596695, -0.021755056455731392, -0.01358440425246954, -0.00611175037920475, 0.018503746017813683, -0.08520819991827011, -0.04826211556792259, -0.02042149007320404, 0.05512882396578789, -0.0458100289106369, 0.018430549651384354, 0.05606335401535034, 0.019307957962155342, -0.009776419028639793, 0.009709988720715046, -0.02376994863152504, 0.008757166564464569, 0.020251503214240074, -0.0063228122889995575, 0.012515384703874588, -0.019089026376605034, 0.01759140007197857, 0.018508393317461014, 0.003490180242806673, -0.0035455182660371065, 0.03157065808773041, -0.04226776957511902, 0.0076021295972168446, 0.02698153257369995, -0.010606217198073864, -0.006547356024384499, 0.03644236922264099, 0.012665512040257454, 0.005658503621816635, 0.018466245383024216, -0.009446602314710617, -0.030238524079322815, 0.008416404947638512, 0.01343933679163456, 0.01605120673775673, -0.010850876569747925, -0.02171178162097931, 0.07401060312986374, -0.019923530519008636, 0.005283320788294077, 0.03460141643881798, -0.03517971932888031, -0.033421602100133896, 0.030843941494822502, 0.031175637617707253, 0.03394811600446701, -0.0023013469763100147, 0.00590145867317915, 0.020011363551020622, -0.0022818821016699076, 0.05033548176288605, 0.018409021198749542, 0.0177097599953413, 0.004527375567704439, -0.016654564067721367, 0.005357301793992519, -0.007020941935479641, 0.04602672532200813, -0.007309510372579098, 0.0008242005133070052, 0.034146685153245926, 0.02000551111996174, 0.01002766564488411, 0.008378666825592518, -0.025412648916244507, 0.016520949080586433, 0.033932510763406754, -0.021447334438562393, 0.0027626894880086184, 0.017807967960834503, -0.03562675416469574, 0.004437576979398727, -0.001769219059497118, -0.008840851485729218, -0.046628233045339584, 0.025770526379346848, -0.0038937567733228207, -0.004041402135044336, 0.03612421080470085, -0.04481932148337364, 0.0014759288169443607, -0.0230622049421072, 0.002137501258403063, 0.044405244290828705, -0.008374285884201527, -0.0542638897895813, -0.0009174581500701606, -0.025559164583683014, 0.017512282356619835, 0.019543427973985672, 0.006782286800444126, -0.03743762895464897, 0.0555315837264061, -0.02578813210129738, -0.037602756172418594, -0.04408971965312958, -0.05489886924624443, -0.006965231150388718, -0.01307715568691492, -0.014034155756235123, 0.052803847938776016, 0.07070083171129227, -0.03280024603009224, -0.0015898578567430377, -0.020875368267297745, 0.011476507410407066, -0.0019110775319859385, 0.0217429231852293, 0.003585806814953685, 0.002240600064396858, 0.006481723859906197, 0.021432774141430855, -0.008133421652019024, 0.024464862421154976, -0.040824200958013535, -0.0717759057879448, 0.0033354386687278748, 0.023485390469431877, 0.019639089703559875, -0.035988204181194305, 0.017463427037000656, 0.028698869049549103, -0.007322606630623341, -0.042033471167087555, -0.05172249674797058, 0.005133950617164373, -0.048111774027347565, 0.011541834101080894, 0.012359374202787876, 0.0008438559016212821, 0.016961149871349335, 0.01788768172264099, -0.05957283452153206, 0.03914783149957657, 0.090472012758255, 0.025676287710666656, -0.0102884816005826, 0.01877657137811184, -0.019429929554462433, -0.01873176544904709, 0.060108259320259094, 0.03603530302643776, -0.010036296211183071, 0.01351177878677845, -0.022773314267396927, 0.028159422799944878, 0.0086314482614398, -0.052913423627614975, -0.020462846383452415, -0.0018889274215325713, 0.03867410868406296, -0.01109353732317686, -0.026378290727734566, -0.0019160609226673841, -0.03583965077996254, -0.017942234873771667, 0.011604552157223225, 0.02133253589272499, -0.023698490113019943, -0.0035875015892088413, 0.06249615177512169, 0.0406271368265152, 0.03246971592307091, -0.0029020216315984726, 0.0027690338902175426, -0.013472318649291992, 0.0033753360621631145, -0.001972752157598734, -0.018893586471676826, 0.004930840339511633, 0.051147859543561935, -0.012397042475640774, -0.005829604342579842, -0.04220623895525932, 0.030883966013789177, -0.05529751256108284, -0.0006382304127328098, -0.0625668540596962, 0.07322276383638382, 0.01222111377865076, 0.06693993508815765, 0.007616765797138214, -0.01813562400639057, -0.0395226888358593, -0.007881325669586658, -0.0158439502120018, -0.01028085220605135, -0.004205492325127125, -0.036881618201732635, 0.024939998984336853, -0.04215987026691437, -0.011671782471239567, -0.031030962243676186, 0.006712846923619509, 0.01629873365163803, 0.06537790596485138, -0.04526499658823013, -0.024002451449632645, -0.0291576087474823, 0.0414787121117115, -0.037888504564762115, 0.02561836689710617, 0.03983443230390549, -0.009134085848927498, 0.03947906941175461, 0.05466870218515396, 0.017286038026213646, -0.016033019870519638, -0.03620057925581932, -0.023822175338864326, 0.007236558012664318, 0.054654575884342194, 0.02184855379164219, 0.06572897732257843, -0.06886487454175949, 0.01129931304603815, 0.009095256216824055, 0.005800161045044661, 0.038981836289167404, -0.012776937335729599, -0.005384027026593685, 0.020776323974132538, -0.02228563465178013, 0.014385056681931019, 0.0036001610569655895, -0.014577765949070454, -0.010755103081464767, 0.01985711231827736, 0.015413294546306133, -0.018404878675937653, 0.0036929913330823183, 0.05549050495028496, 0.03351428732275963, -0.01307758316397667, -0.044381044805049896, -0.030587784945964813, -0.0054738400503993034, -0.021843839436769485, 0.06105154752731323, 0.03178601711988449, -0.009633682668209076, -0.05926497280597687, 0.06915027648210526, -0.0016868406673893332, -0.026790568605065346, 0.04054565727710724, -0.001357526401989162, 0.02336832880973816, -0.002955897245556116, 0.005104315932840109, 0.009654809720814228, 0.010418238118290901, 0.0023374229203909636, 0.07065138965845108, 0.006893707439303398, -0.0773073360323906, -0.028763586655259132, 0.04679945111274719, 0.027010109275579453, -0.012333751656115055, 0.005349380429834127, -0.0264393649995327, 0.005448603071272373, 0.035491280257701874, -0.06604447960853577, 0.03391919285058975, -0.04415073245763779, 0.03971391171216965, -0.05106433480978012, -0.045270081609487534, 0.0043367911130189896, 0.01242491602897644, -0.021881114691495895, 0.020068565383553505, -0.015172331593930721, -0.02152852527797222, 0.0059804064221680164, -0.01625199243426323, -0.0028722863644361496, 0.06155624985694885, -0.04893966391682625, -0.030972372740507126, 0.03634202852845192, 0.04960468038916588, -0.05715395137667656, -0.023121396079659462, 0.03443370759487152, 0.009185999631881714, -0.019394543021917343, 0.06998103111982346, -0.0053219967521727085, -0.03567367047071457, 0.024801412597298622, -0.0008701589540578425, -0.0034648801665753126, -0.030327918007969856, -0.0255903247743845, 0.062324196100234985, 0.004208108875900507, -0.009780924767255783, 0.05366528034210205, 0.014507772400975227, -0.021774817258119583, 0.02368033677339554, -0.06845277547836304, -0.03279697149991989, -0.033902619034051895, -0.026483308523893356, -0.056827425956726074, 0.014827006496489048, -0.038801711052656174, 0.0014579453272745013, -0.00735953776165843, 0.005919095128774643, -0.02424730733036995, 0.0010996019700542092, 0.08158817887306213, 0.05712265521287918, -0.028859848156571388, 0.0363648422062397, -0.008828348480165005, -0.000559572537895292, -0.02097407914698124, -0.03516964241862297, 0.022078173235058784, -0.02413044311106205, -0.05419500172138214, 0.006978237070143223, -0.03404498100280762, 0.015352229587733746, -0.022988248616456985, -0.03728942573070526, -0.018263284116983414, -0.019184259697794914, 0.025453321635723114, -0.01051101554185152, 0.08298849314451218, 0.005671284161508083, -0.0250225979834795, 0.031007837504148483, 0.028076807036995888, -0.04238622263073921, 0.021223563700914383, -0.03314811363816261, 0.0481603741645813, -0.002436042297631502, 0.015110205858945847, -0.06410554051399231, -0.03408338129520416, 0.03063044883310795, 0.00003596288661356084, -0.028758101165294647, -0.030776912346482277, -0.015935970470309258, -0.003686826676130295, -0.022927075624465942, -0.026418248191475868, 0.060577552765607834, -0.0436534620821476, 0.0096063744276762, 0.023218728601932526, 0.0171847902238369, 0.06202012673020363, -0.025846870616078377, 0.007971365936100483, 0.001965831033885479, 0.009997040964663029, -0.025694608688354492, 0.04984304681420326, -0.017585936933755875, -0.03200992941856384, -0.03269482031464577, -0.04960859566926956, -0.0005868627340532839, 0.012940112501382828, -0.005700325593352318, 0.0023552391212433577, -0.007154424209147692, -0.03053840436041355, 0.027762560173869133, -0.006261877249926329, -0.017310287803411484, -0.042328596115112305, 0.004221552517265081, -0.050017014145851135, 0.00990420114248991, -0.0012951813405379653, -0.005652600433677435, -0.030899574980139732, 0.025424901396036148, 0.009209753945469856, 0.056595202535390854, 0.07757832854986191, -0.002257672371342778, -0.0321258045732975, 0.000147499333252199, -0.03263801708817482, 0.06075273081660271, 0.009975427761673927, -0.0006468970677815378, -0.019269699230790138, 0.00529067637398839, -0.0049841818399727345, 0.01506776362657547, -0.02587456814944744, -0.03566337004303932, 0.0446697473526001, 0.023708729073405266, 0.02380167506635189, 0.011001688428223133, 0.011154369451105595, -0.011149322614073753, -0.040249962359666824, 0.011407263576984406, -0.00838407687842846, -0.01664269156754017, 0.0732671469449997, 0.011718809604644775, -0.016699982807040215, 0.0021525626070797443, 0.01186356134712696, 0.007647838909178972, 0.015007543377578259, 0.005161018576472998, 0.011830958537757397, -0.012846626341342926, -0.014183166436851025, -0.028231948614120483, -0.01575518772006035, -0.0476549006998539, 0.007388383150100708, -0.018108973279595375, -0.010097888298332691, 0.019984854385256767, 0.03499971702694893, 0.018572578206658363, -0.050698231905698776, -0.012963577173650265, -0.06726967543363571, -0.018785804510116577, -0.013731851242482662, -0.04540489614009857, 0.0010247565805912018, 0.024952402338385582, 0.010059773921966553, 0.017282309010624886, 0.03619515150785446, -0.05301036685705185, -0.017028627917170525, -0.03354772925376892, -0.041888561099767685, -0.06441750377416611, 0.03958319127559662, -0.04222429543733597, -0.015078122727572918, 0.017435969784855843, -0.03424331545829773, 0.038490984588861465, -0.0078119239769876, 0.043632231652736664, 0.038319483399391174, 0.050764258950948715, 0.04410894587635994, 0.016208235174417496, -0.009432027116417885, 0.0030275830067694187, 0.1741282194852829, 0.06173591688275337, 0.05107241868972778, -0.05376109108328819, 0.024684909731149673, 0.03268550708889961, 0.027867598459124565, 0.018532171845436096, -0.008195153437554836, 0.015034245327115059, -0.012289605103433132, 0.07179960608482361, 0.020876755937933922, 0.005874500144273043, 0.008180276490747929, 0.004244560841470957, -0.01670057699084282, -0.01652701199054718, 0.04533141851425171, 0.023952985182404518, -0.0006985249347053468, 0.006321738939732313, -0.03108207695186138, 0.007156493607908487, -0.025848375633358955, -0.009864762425422668, -0.029500480741262436, 0.003788944333791733, 0.004845945164561272, 0.0010455267038196325, 0.0038325903005898, 0.02494649402797222, 0.02287651225924492, -0.01274525374174118, 0.02084217220544815, -0.016669712960720062, -0.030723754316568375, -0.046314068138599396, -0.026600521057844162, 0.0361873023211956, -0.010825419798493385, -0.05240228399634361, -0.009145552292466164, 0.030483413487672806, -0.04153967276215553, -0.021310443058609962, -0.004531488288193941, 0.04298227280378342, -0.03421475365757942, -0.018947193399071693, -0.021879423409700394, 0.00235239346511662, 0.019874414429068565, -0.06010907143354416, -0.009060868062078953, 0.009012439288198948, 0.005824599880725145, 0.021959533914923668, -0.045981407165527344, -0.016002755612134933, -0.004329436458647251, -0.005746395327150822, 0.004748125560581684, -0.0004035045567434281, -0.029882099479436874, -0.01680864207446575, -0.03910644352436066, 0.024059899151325226, -0.035478606820106506, 0.004809041973203421, -0.0031460849568247795, 0.006625085137784481, -0.009556019678711891, -0.017975855618715286, -0.01063042413443327, -0.015229801647365093, 0.016070429235696793, -0.0474822074174881, -0.008068211376667023, -0.05835874006152153, -0.03235543891787529, 0.004275571554899216, -0.038725949823856354, -0.023365726694464684, -0.030916735529899597, -0.003823662642389536, 0.007165918592363596, 0.032610442489385605, 0.007966498844325542, 0.0418681874871254, -0.0033878216054290533, 0.060747142881155014, 0.007782793138176203, -0.06245921179652214, 0.009838568046689034, 0.03183552622795105, -0.04204524680972099, 0.006385243497788906, -0.03256892040371895, 0.1010970026254654, -0.0003513131523504853, 0.020968861877918243, -0.017256632447242737, 0.02563340961933136, 0.041981443762779236, -0.024407491087913513, 0.05163431912660599, -0.04152224585413933, 0.014261766336858273, -0.020660866051912308, 0.01609322987496853, -0.013422898016870022, -0.009190785698592663, 0.010100219398736954, -0.05108865723013878, -0.016570087522268295, -0.0404014028608799, -0.00919591635465622, 0.01419772021472454, -0.032360102981328964, 0.011771067045629025, 0.019663361832499504, -0.001687310985289514, -0.002291114302352071, 0.003956425003707409, -0.01143592782318592, 0.02937665581703186, -0.0334332212805748, -0.010253981687128544, 0.014441689476370811, 0.013732421211898327, 0.025308499112725258, 0.041567400097846985, -0.004613880533725023, 0.0009458779240958393, -0.0011564684100449085, 0.01285058818757534, 0.03959473595023155, -0.004453567788004875, 0.023474523797631264, 0.008448457345366478, -0.046217408031225204, -0.03874513879418373, 0.042354926466941833, -0.022420726716518402, 0.03205666318535805, -0.00931371096521616, 0.01530481781810522, -0.004518958739936352, 0.06951616704463959, -0.02094130404293537, -0.03805169835686684, -0.022197024896740913, -0.02350504696369171, 0.05084875971078873, 0.016824940219521523, 0.004723490681499243, 0.012184517458081245, -0.03349800780415535, 0.04400432109832764, 0.0031760651618242264, -0.01563354767858982, -0.016742656007409096, -0.056391045451164246, 0.001218868070282042, 0.008625989779829979, -0.0236933846026659, 0.003914832603186369, 0.030311692506074905, 0.07426445186138153, -0.030407102778553963, 0.014754706993699074, -0.04557410255074501, 0.028197599574923515, -0.029660208150744438, -0.03672559931874275, -0.005386052653193474, 0.004911063704639673, 0.021375875920057297, -0.03904004395008087, 0.003295093309134245, 0.04769233986735344, -0.03465094044804573, 0.011502445675432682, -0.009981720708310604, 0.024714848026633263, -0.0484643317759037, 0.017985552549362183, -0.05040052533149719, -0.014678609557449818, 0.013255175203084946, 0.020050400868058205, -0.00815445464104414, 0.0418485626578331, -0.007855556905269623, -0.05247688665986061, 0.006735716946423054, 0.014735182747244835, -0.005936616100370884, -0.02922637388110161, 0.00686408719047904, -0.05456944927573204, 0.036660052835941315, 0.04005772992968559, -0.04498550295829773, 0.00938649382442236, 0.035470180213451385, 0.014026420190930367, -0.029565200209617615, 0.0015637113247066736, 0.0066169993951916695, -0.011996680870652199, 0.010940027423202991, 0.003259365912526846, 0.022513549774885178, 0.018677223473787308, 0.00520020816475153, 0.03398358076810837, 0.010782863944768906, -0.00965056475251913, 0.01725754328072071, 0.06749702990055084, -0.006683614570647478, -0.025429921224713326, 0.019492633640766144, -0.0012666299007833004, 0.009930339641869068, -0.035895541310310364, 0.0008492490160278976, -0.004650630988180637, 0.06248097121715546, 0.030726788565516472, 0.02486780658364296, -0.007272698450833559, -0.012672774493694305, -0.0284139234572649, -0.041687313467264175, -0.006265067495405674, -0.0023204234894365072, -0.01293165236711502, -0.015230902470648289, -0.017392441630363464, 0.011825098656117916, 0.021020296961069107, -0.006893130950629711, 0.0148148899897933, -0.004866265691816807, 0.0899120345711708, -0.03681858628988266, -0.008746935985982418, -0.005823257379233837, 0.017653491348028183, 0.010461079888045788, -0.09770781546831131, 0.04142012447118759, 0.011382395401597023, 0.009817471727728844, -0.08200769126415253, -0.0064519778825342655, -0.032667797058820724, 0.030351920053362846, 0.04118148982524872, 0.025536980479955673, -0.010298183187842369, -0.023055102676153183, 0.015888605266809464, 0.005377946421504021, -0.029738737270236015, 0.04358981177210808, 0.0016961259534582496, 0.02305719628930092, -0.03973687067627907, -0.007118335459381342, 0.0002778761845547706, -0.005103964824229479, 0.015217471867799759, 0.0031502426136285067, -0.01170641090720892, 0.05281612649559975, -0.011629518121480942, 0.014921102672815323, -0.004669319838285446, -0.024298373609781265, 0.05064092203974724, -0.0037282865960150957, -0.02439500391483307, 0.04488987848162651, 0.01685570552945137, -0.033967748284339905, 0.03846240043640137, 0.00636375742033124, 0.015566922724246979, -0.0019505488453432918, -0.03274603188037872, -0.002362476196140051, -0.04567771032452583, -0.047501735389232635, 0.004888026975095272, -0.011546052061021328, -0.004869005177170038, 0.03123602829873562, 0.03392690047621727, 0.021305490285158157, -0.03602682426571846, 0.047481369227170944, -0.026710910722613335, -0.03027242235839367, 0.04616701602935791, 0.015085908584296703, -0.0166408009827137, 0.027181928977370262, -0.0011765457456931472, 0.07150035351514816, -0.007482969202101231, 0.0020539925899356604, -0.04288126900792122, 0.07189395278692245, 0.0042304908856749535, -0.02072916179895401, 0.012670419178903103, -0.040093835443258286, -0.000759121379815042, 0.0183136984705925, -0.0071344999596476555, 0.06656059622764587, -0.04387379810214043, 0.030259830877184868, -0.02477433532476425, 0.01514668669551611, -0.017735470086336136, 0.012752383947372437, -0.019069848582148552, 0.046607017517089844, -0.03351350128650665, -0.029598254710435867, -0.019394125789403915, 0.0027182421181350946, 0.03680482134222984, 0.0035762011539191008, 0.030283279716968536, -0.01285749115049839, 0.02776283770799637, 0.016153961420059204, -0.007546928711235523, -0.03688172250986099, -0.017659230157732964, 0.02999640628695488, 0.04029837250709534, 0.003540135221555829, 0.0010929105337709188, -0.03471291437745094, 0.0430997796356678, 0.042940907180309296, -0.031275566667318344, -0.06282209604978561, -0.026846667751669884, 0.0202958844602108, -0.014982710592448711, 0.0135884378105402 ]
<p>Currently I am skimming through a couple of papers in well established journals! I became curious when I found papers with linear regression models using the Herfindahl index as the dependent variable. I thought such a continuous but limited variable had to be used in combination with the ln!</p> <p>Could any of you give me an explanation whether one procedure is right or wrong?</p>
36,276
[ -0.0044468422420322895, -0.03985521197319031, 0.009005747735500336, -0.0020064315758645535, 0.037787001579999924, 0.0014804605161771178, -0.016587551683187485, -0.014217217452824116, 0.00885331816971302, -0.04300537332892418, 0.026176562532782555, -0.0047099292278289795, 0.030657637864351273, 0.024055251851677895, 0.02920711040496826, 0.009875216521322727, -0.01174876093864441, 0.04106219857931137, 0.011532728560268879, -0.021265897899866104, -0.012168611399829388, 0.028478646650910378, -0.0190119706094265, -0.012177311815321445, -0.06333670020103455, 0.039477813988924026, 0.019742745906114578, 0.004932231269776821, 0.012727239169180393, 0.02174144797027111, 0.003610484069213271, 0.002082289196550846, 0.024089884012937546, 0.026681799441576004, -0.009011958725750446, 0.005381466820836067, -0.052253950387239456, -0.02683122083544731, -0.02078833058476448, 0.045332036912441254, -0.012789026834070683, -0.03319539874792099, -0.006280091125518084, 0.05962348356842995, -0.021634019911289215, 0.03805194050073624, 0.02875136025249958, -0.0726640522480011, 0.0167083702981472, -0.022456014528870583, 0.08580946922302246, 0.017266592010855675, 0.02723453938961029, 0.02225632406771183, 0.003921617288142443, -0.007515019737184048, 0.055530745536088943, 0.04667254909873009, 0.032590705901384354, -0.05164057016372681, -0.026209695264697075, -0.016195425763726234, 0.008121153339743614, 0.026857612654566765, 0.005321051459759474, 0.015527525916695595, 0.023950854316353798, -0.02503049746155739, 0.05389390513300896, -0.04150419682264328, 0.011830305680632591, -0.0054206582717597485, 0.03838423639535904, -0.028327789157629013, 0.017849992960691452, -0.010748939588665962, 0.0017597121186554432, 0.019214734435081482, 0.027731694281101227, 0.002254965016618371, -0.015792690217494965, 0.0229665357619524, 0.028394900262355804, 0.037121836096048355, 0.01853080280125141, 0.006666260771453381, 0.0407719649374485, -0.03240438923239708, 0.05087171494960785, 0.023107534274458885, -0.04309321939945221, -0.008401882834732533, 0.048661042004823685, 0.021399009972810745, -0.028989285230636597, 0.05108233541250229, -0.00990382395684719, 0.04544352740049362, 0.001088599325157702, 0.0035540196113288403, -0.021886132657527924, -0.03074323758482933, 0.012143836356699467, 0.0475940927863121, -0.007906143553555012, -0.054705917835235596, -0.017094358801841736, 0.008293652907013893, 0.004319360479712486, -0.037275832146406174, -0.04303694888949394, 0.01632075384259224, -0.0013427905505523086, 0.018315982073545456, 0.027907518669962883, -0.026313630864024162, 0.012535338290035725, 0.007084601558744907, 0.058867447078228, 0.09276246279478073, -0.02168167382478714, -0.03798353672027588, 0.06042473390698433, 0.03161847963929176, -0.051915138959884644, 0.0096778878942132, 0.02730250172317028, -0.004681105259805918, -0.029687590897083282, 0.0471278615295887, 0.007409603334963322, -0.005525774322450161, 0.040476974099874496, 0.03326302766799927, 0.05650241672992706, 0.00542085338383913, -0.08683869242668152, -0.05147480592131615, 0.05984623730182648, 0.013732954859733582, 0.019901694729924202, -0.05049547553062439, 0.012489907443523407, 0.02235434204339981, 0.07935167104005814, 0.013604666106402874, 0.04207245260477066, 0.004913560580462217, 0.008672408759593964, 0.006195693742483854, -0.024917451664805412, -0.04181522876024246, 0.01175654772669077, -0.0672273337841034, -0.0163681972771883, -0.09814947098493576, 0.0300458874553442, -0.0017803753726184368, 0.006775134243071079, -0.0053955926559865475, 0.08659994602203369, 0.01911964826285839, 0.007163827307522297, 0.04822099581360817, -0.010602674447000027, -0.03376619517803192, 0.09616883844137192, -0.012061364017426968, 0.07412108033895493, -0.007061406504362822, 0.002312485594302416, 0.03830571472644806, 0.021272940561175346, 0.048155929893255234, -0.005022252909839153, -0.02314247190952301, 0.0024376707151532173, -0.08702996373176575, 0.029616806656122208, 0.02546451985836029, -0.0555594377219677, -0.030439449474215508, -0.008079033344984055, -0.011704451404511929, 0.00790113490074873, 0.0476851761341095, 0.002341822488233447, -0.009832751005887985, 0.0462125688791275, -0.04590214416384697, -0.03138940408825874, -0.030381865799427032, -0.007834088988602161, 0.011417850852012634, -0.016195809468626976, 0.05905923619866371, 0.0018851272761821747, -0.0036257593892514706, 0.00814096536487341, 0.008921616710722446, -0.016605250537395477, -0.01626020483672619, 0.029840609058737755, -0.03336946293711662, 0.03186740726232529, 0.04895089566707611, 0.04167025908827782, 0.025652816519141197, 0.011934175156056881, -0.07795540243387222, -0.06762724369764328, 0.022840922698378563, -0.0061490233056247234, 0.026705622673034668, 0.006721142213791609, -0.04233591631054878, 0.002546852920204401, -0.023856917396187782, -0.038323163986206055, 0.03221060335636139, -0.05194081366062164, 0.043345123529434204, 0.08071385324001312, 0.031214307993650436, -0.013083445839583874, 0.0043078637681901455, 0.015563540160655975, 0.019372539594769478, 0.012954671867191792, -0.014908228069543839, -0.03275579214096069, -0.006092496681958437, 0.002435753820464015, 0.041415341198444366, -0.035617515444755554, 0.002697549993172288, 0.07557059824466705, 0.05301843211054802, 0.03496064245700836, 0.012430443428456783, 0.011815798468887806, -0.055429503321647644, -0.016465360298752785, 0.031917378306388855, 0.01882675476372242, 0.0004118245269637555, -0.006080604158341885, 0.01616799831390381, 0.05901722237467766, -0.02046290598809719, -0.002651356626302004, 0.04196407273411751, -0.01514403149485588, 0.007821501232683659, -0.005931464023888111, -0.0008354561286978424, 0.049269989132881165, -0.03738878667354584, 0.044775426387786865, 0.009013138711452484, -0.015166924335062504, 0.018504543229937553, -0.006116664968430996, -0.003987543284893036, 0.019192423671483994, 0.02921224758028984, -0.07872381806373596, -0.015107761137187481, 0.03466004878282547, -0.06515729427337646, 0.023981930688023567, -0.037988901138305664, -0.017440522089600563, -0.023035448044538498, -0.0005868430598638952, 0.01716252788901329, 0.04775197058916092, 0.02285446599125862, 0.03984583541750908, 0.020849058404564857, 0.00808962807059288, -0.03443808853626251, 0.005609458312392235, -0.01245286874473095, -0.029085583984851837, -0.02720722183585167, -0.013074475340545177, 0.015096605755388737, 0.021516896784305573, -0.034673478454351425, -0.0025877635926008224, 0.023160377517342567, -0.04355516657233238, -0.0598791167140007, -0.04735007882118225, 0.0013656786177307367, -0.0033312616869807243, -0.007506375201046467, -0.028799094259738922, 0.043980613350868225, 0.020587457343935966, -0.010871564038097858, 0.01419064961373806, -0.03630077838897705, -0.04771329089999199, -0.026786481961607933, 0.003529322799295187, -0.021332670003175735, 0.03608189523220062, 0.0018214621813967824, 0.030537856742739677, -0.05097178742289543, -0.03987908363342285, -0.08687480539083481, -0.05927182734012604, 0.04772662743926048, -0.02641078270971775, 0.04911614581942558, -0.015600939281284809, -0.03784698620438576, 0.0760493054986, 0.030600471422076225, -0.00853527057915926, -0.04727090150117874, -0.03929460793733597, -0.04150482639670372, -0.029425062239170074, 0.018097106367349625, 0.016370737925171852, 0.021340925246477127, 0.05384273827075958, -0.03616543486714363, 0.020924344658851624, 0.05947820097208023, 0.018298262730240822, 0.031737882643938065, -0.0049994103610515594, 0.007080524228513241, -0.03862287849187851, 0.013320676051080227, 0.036235928535461426, -0.01573302410542965, 0.020997801795601845, 0.0013522314839065075, 0.051475752145051956, 0.033772341907024384, -0.04910672828555107, 0.00833676103502512, -0.0063828397542238235, -0.0013268935726955533, 0.017597975209355354, -0.02242712490260601, 0.030272770673036575, 0.00875446293503046, -0.008057606406509876, 0.00625867722555995, 0.013868509791791439, -0.03584983944892883, -0.013463122770190239, 0.023287715390324593, 0.019789110869169235, 0.011441626586019993, -0.007001441437751055, -0.003049081191420555, -0.031441036611795425, 0.007163188420236111, -0.044424425810575485, -0.024097084999084473, -0.004819826222956181, 0.05072637274861336, -0.00006650364230154082, -0.023098984733223915, -0.06307324022054672, 0.003936387598514557, -0.059023767709732056, 0.018750036135315895, -0.013008206151425838, 0.04034395515918732, -0.02243819646537304, 0.05051795765757561, -0.01593095250427723, -0.02018037997186184, 0.027532219886779785, -0.004776411689817905, -0.06653192639350891, -0.008865897543728352, -0.03476739302277565, -0.0006919497391209006, 0.013957384042441845, -0.026751292869448662, 0.020938249304890633, 0.006794319022446871, -0.005940185394138098, 0.015403656288981438, -0.006076558493077755, -0.03339392691850662, -0.009852433577179909, -0.04263955354690552, -0.03666555508971214, 0.010699239559471607, -0.015467183664441109, 0.009948808699846268, -0.01542829442769289, 0.0035037791822105646, 0.04587125778198242, -0.000043597228795988485, -0.0256926491856575, -0.0008477838127873838, 0.023993095383048058, 0.039309196174144745, 0.05159686505794525, -0.012709486298263073, -0.01366520207375288, -0.0553235225379467, 0.02330024540424347, -0.011586216278374195, 0.029883841052651405, 0.044453542679548264, -0.011004234664142132, -0.021002333611249924, -0.006504887714982033, -0.03269307315349579, 0.0014251238899305463, 0.003652872983366251, 0.04313760623335838, 0.00938301719725132, 0.07086772471666336, 0.013941355049610138, -0.025445779785513878, -0.01420718152076006, 0.051888879388570786, -0.002545905765146017, -0.0002751466818153858, -0.018536724150180817, -0.005284628830850124, 0.004153027664870024, -0.004607377573847771, 0.019739041104912758, 0.00040653959149494767, -0.003824864747002721, -0.017650887370109558, 0.054522451013326645, -0.0009063331526704133, -0.004660219419747591, 0.0030063262674957514, 0.011709030717611313, 0.0052221184596419334, -0.04799806326627731, -0.06233635172247887, 0.060174502432346344, 0.057180922478437424, 0.04727303236722946, 0.05015568435192108, 0.013586401008069515, -0.08110333234071732, 0.0031912203412503004, 0.010761117562651634, 0.030561424791812897, -0.07372841238975525, -0.022286023944616318, -0.05490187555551529, -0.028976287692785263, 0.026493286713957787, -0.025805938988924026, 0.018803585320711136, -0.024345112964510918, 0.037026092410087585, -0.024524273350834846, -0.04209689423441887, -0.01846865564584732, 0.048753801733255386, 0.02418426051735878, -0.013059694319963455, -0.025135863572359085, -0.017987865954637527, -0.01645495556294918, 0.038141001015901566, -0.014693657867610455, 0.029634982347488403, 0.004394784569740295, -0.020591875538229942, 0.053058505058288574, 0.006245768163353205, -0.045783914625644684, -0.05721336603164673, 0.053080055862665176, 0.00874350219964981, 0.0189518965780735, 0.04521768167614937, -0.011717480607330799, -0.05462340638041496, -0.00607290817424655, 0.014068187214434147, -0.031737104058265686, 0.009659191593527794, -0.0006349780596792698, 0.03956080600619316, 0.037854764610528946, -0.01918012648820877, 0.030049283057451248, 0.05322294682264328, 0.014520390890538692, -0.0030066908802837133, -0.005887896753847599, 0.03211252763867378, -0.015286905691027641, -0.0019169783918187022, -0.012753673829138279, -0.02871461771428585, -0.043862223625183105, 0.006577379535883665, 0.00751675246283412, 0.04047942906618118, -0.019933724775910378, 0.012266324833035469, 0.0003458040300756693, 0.0075793880969285965, 0.005832411348819733, -0.030952073633670807, 0.011828582733869553, -0.002019905485212803, 0.013490880839526653, -0.019516684114933014, 0.0035735126584768295, -0.016818027943372726, 0.010631706565618515, 0.05521237105131149, -0.007839024066925049, 0.009656292386353016, 0.012747217901051044, -0.029921170324087143, 0.016243649646639824, -0.015491646714508533, 0.006671527866274118, -0.017185153439641, -0.01508996170014143, -0.04099049046635628, -0.03668485954403877, 0.0027872747741639614, -0.007255806587636471, -0.017531324177980423, 0.03962714225053787, -0.049261219799518585, 0.020229522138834, -0.008971641771495342, -0.007814356125891209, -0.09251552075147629, -0.03445195406675339, 0.013864783570170403, -0.04117335006594658, -0.0182927418500185, -0.02517588995397091, 0.01621362380683422, -0.020593544468283653, -0.009959599934518337, -0.028276201337575912, 0.07682716846466064, -0.033224109560251236, -0.035889845341444016, -0.03372383117675781, 0.011326096951961517, 0.047690391540527344, -0.005027221515774727, -0.04026661813259125, 0.02251094952225685, -0.023818058893084526, -0.004686116240918636, 0.005418998189270496, -0.018452899530529976, -0.02935204468667507, 0.015255236998200417, -0.029771262779831886, -0.02514374814927578, 0.030649704858660698, 0.008994289673864841, -0.02778334729373455, 0.035734958946704865, 0.004743786528706551, 0.0014567264588549733, -0.004192029125988483, 0.011668187566101551, -0.03655482083559036, 0.0225987546145916, -0.01595391519367695, -0.0007975188200362027, 0.001477772369980812, -0.0024400001857429743, 0.049600910395383835, 0.009755440056324005, 0.009251220151782036, 0.021764880046248436, 0.05104408040642738, 0.005669730715453625, 0.0117696737870574, 0.007045569363981485, -0.007086801342666149, 0.0296469833701849, 0.006182449404150248, 0.00036861657281406224, 0.004625291563570499, 0.0569751113653183, 0.0039623817428946495, -0.04820456728339195, -0.05649574100971222, 0.020423371344804764, 0.031590722501277924, 0.012479517608880997, 0.01599009335041046, 0.04102657735347748, 0.004162423312664032, 0.023936761543154716, 0.00594238331541419, -0.03249644115567207, -0.05958736315369606, -0.007909517735242844, 0.05145217850804329, -0.012898847460746765, 0.0011286608641967177, 0.023667091503739357, 0.015250344760715961, -0.02955506555736065, 0.02850026823580265, 0.026360422372817993, 0.023944376036524773, -0.016657020896673203, 0.007107758894562721, -0.03901487961411476, 0.06345701217651367, -0.037116892635822296, 0.019304772838950157, -0.02315516583621502, -0.02305658906698227, 0.032694246619939804, 0.03822103887796402, 0.020555749535560608, -0.054719578474760056, -0.035985954105854034, -0.02861964702606201, 0.0043493472039699554, 0.027223708108067513, -0.006353157106786966, 0.04552255570888519, -0.014469120651483536, 0.009370154701173306, 0.027766602113842964, 0.022169264033436775, 0.004811842925846577, -0.06130286306142807, -0.012119680643081665, -0.03127512335777283, -0.039342641830444336, -0.01231647189706564, -0.004030132666230202, -0.04023004695773125, 0.040554676204919815, -0.028969760984182358, -0.034389037638902664, 0.013462555594742298, 0.037691857665777206, 0.034788649529218674, 0.06135329231619835, 0.041295114904642105, -0.02375822886824608, 0.01362189557403326, -0.007332845591008663, 0.09167250245809555, 0.09087297320365906, 0.01848742552101612, -0.07746986299753189, 0.04421793669462204, 0.009739488363265991, 0.007500487379729748, -0.01844242587685585, 0.013873588293790817, -0.0231565460562706, -0.02605617046356201, 0.024246379733085632, 0.020528923720121384, 0.0036798533983528614, -0.006731750443577766, 0.036080583930015564, -0.014592892490327358, -0.0182256568223238, -0.0031255101785063744, 0.013082945719361305, -0.004298358224332333, -0.03357493877410889, -0.03625432774424553, 0.0107494555413723, 0.022422829642891884, 0.0001384374627377838, 0.01804254949092865, -0.020099228248000145, 0.0024842717684805393, -0.002116617513820529, -0.008837913163006306, -0.006909949239343405, 0.049972500652074814, 0.021359426900744438, 0.021003643050789833, 0.012013658881187439, 0.03218703344464302, -0.001377553679049015, -0.02270229533314705, 0.010965720750391483, 0.007521265652030706, -0.022965574637055397, 0.01528310775756836, 0.0020948355086147785, -0.03544643521308899, -0.012788989581167698, -0.008036819286644459, 0.005094161722809076, 0.02380596101284027, 0.017291227355599403, -0.030854273587465286, 0.011547934263944626, 0.0029731395188719034, -0.03545105457305908, 0.019587304443120956, 0.035738006234169006, 0.03177768737077713, -0.03903878480195999, -0.02681427262723446, -0.013775992207229137, -0.019531069323420525, -0.011495288461446762, 0.015617936849594116, 0.03802090510725975, -0.03965621069073677, 0.03254697844386101, -0.008564640767872334, 0.014839289709925652, -0.01102781854569912, 0.0036861691623926163, -0.00807788036763668, 0.004579633008688688, -0.03345806896686554, 0.015906328335404396, 0.0056113977916538715, 0.02694636955857277, 0.022477876394987106, -0.018929073587059975, 0.018032515421509743, -0.06965897977352142, -0.04586736112833023, 0.020386245101690292, -0.00650235777720809, -0.02749217115342617, -0.06494053453207016, 0.020213861018419266, -0.0005580098950304091, 0.03918187692761421, -0.004015788901597261, 0.038436196744441986, -0.015568065457046032, 0.02318114973604679, 0.004831705708056688, -0.05573422834277153, 0.00972876325249672, 0.0008718648459762335, -0.03168106824159622, 0.001022794283926487, -0.01147704478353262, 0.03220820799469948, 0.021853696554899216, 0.010874594561755657, -0.004937806632369757, 0.05217747762799263, -0.020624730736017227, 0.03757622465491295, 0.042315687984228134, -0.055955804884433746, 0.005887244828045368, 0.016222462058067322, 0.004937174264341593, -0.042495012283325195, -0.024201788008213043, -0.021750090643763542, -0.014579704962670803, -0.015985818579792976, 0.015891501680016518, -0.04578607156872749, -0.0090524572879076, 0.0010190453613176942, 0.044907573610544205, -0.03228484094142914, 0.003343292511999607, -0.05858960375189781, -0.007059423718601465, -0.009329932741820812, -0.012364929541945457, -0.04338517785072327, 0.0061894990503787994, 0.035295967012643814, 0.0262305811047554, 0.0155750447884202, -0.017144490033388138, 0.000733541848603636, -0.022606663405895233, -0.01734451949596405, -0.007998119108378887, 0.01810569129884243, -0.03028879314661026, -0.047557421028614044, -0.0016127213602885604, -0.022944128140807152, -0.02245701104402542, -0.0004364823398645967, 0.01794763281941414, 0.030483460053801537, 0.017579330131411552, 0.0018386050360277295, -0.009784918278455734, 0.03817693144083023, -0.03643713891506195, -0.010152420960366726, -0.006646276451647282, -0.035393696278333664, 0.0016279370756819844, -0.0074521987698972225, -0.017588913440704346, -0.006547566037625074, 0.007587574888020754, 0.020016048103570938, 0.04999633878469467, 0.040654052048921585, -0.020554406568408012, -0.00880833063274622, 0.017649652436375618, 0.024511778727173805, -0.02327212318778038, -0.02237703651189804, 0.033802300691604614, 0.03238173946738243, -0.03140522912144661, 0.010020247660577297, 0.01326733361929655, 0.051325567066669464, -0.07251486927270889, -0.02452465519309044, 0.005769156385213137, 0.017786286771297455, 0.044031769037246704, -0.04281788691878319, 0.02899605594575405, 0.02452136017382145, -0.04531755670905113, -0.02414393611252308, -0.02516225352883339, 0.02671976201236248, -0.05959460139274597, -0.03076067566871643, 0.010517707094550133, 0.025414323434233665, 0.0003383641305845231, 0.030162056908011436, 0.023134296759963036, 0.005802270025014877, -0.02192596159875393, -0.044285111129283905, 0.005814022850245237, 0.003034866414964199, 0.017101718112826347, -0.059052787721157074, 0.03446025773882866, -0.039145853370428085, -0.0592934787273407, 0.059553638100624084, -0.015832262113690376, 0.02211816795170307, 0.03628217428922653, 0.03236157074570656, 0.01346835121512413, 0.031177423894405365, 0.0450110137462616, 0.005698610097169876, -0.022904716432094574, -0.012255475856363773, 0.016626950353384018, 0.01983722485601902, -0.016165349632501602, 0.008504962548613548, 0.022318102419376373, -0.04953090846538544, -0.04159838706254959, -0.007494024001061916, 0.0012217132607474923, 0.012031754478812218, -0.00015523427282460034, -0.02545219287276268, 0.00048586787306703627, -0.03995075821876526, 0.015396070666611195, -0.0469856821000576, -0.05699522793292999, 0.029025113210082054, 0.007944829761981964, -0.01843104511499405, -0.022027168422937393, -0.03568965941667557, -0.06793458014726639, 0.010890339501202106, -0.02498738095164299, -0.0013286449247971177, -0.09473098069429398, 0.02924809418618679, -0.003080649534240365, -0.02483610436320305, -0.0709356814622879, -0.02851836197078228, -0.01867004856467247, 0.03878902271389961, -0.022408777847886086, 0.009527675807476044, 0.01659281738102436, -0.07134027034044266, 0.038199249655008316, -0.10033193975687027, 0.08346151560544968, -0.007782906759530306, 0.004138031508773565, -0.0076036048121750355, 0.018476875498890877, -0.04248613491654396, -0.01484520174562931, 0.06048889830708504, 0.011935334652662277, 0.0000736349102226086, -0.028425084426999092, 0.024447370320558548, 0.014110791496932507, -0.008266335353255272, 0.004114758688956499, -0.0351664163172245, -0.0036875191144645214, -0.01870637573301792, -0.019223792478442192, -0.02213796228170395, -0.005974519532173872, 0.02834845893085003, 0.009216058067977428, 0.05130359157919884, -0.0021873312070965767, -0.01328322384506464, 0.03931690752506256, 0.0034596750047057867, -0.04389718919992447, 0.0541534461081028, -0.023759964853525162, 0.005595583934336901, 0.033777933567762375, -0.006636136677116156, -0.08669228851795197, 0.01333102397620678, -0.015203876420855522, 0.0020533346105366945, -0.016928907483816147, 0.03517865389585495, -0.009535808116197586, -0.014423178508877754, -0.016585318371653557, 0.03413589298725128, -0.028877727687358856, -0.012735903263092041, 0.024885276332497597, 0.04258653149008751, 0.017902188003063202, -0.008601983077824116, 0.022401733323931694, 0.018824592232704163, -0.005226301960647106, -0.04157198965549469, 0.006070561241358519, 0.05058262124657631, 0.012212486006319523, -0.0018877676920965314, 0.020418863743543625, -0.014547945000231266, 0.03905702382326126, 0.005604470614343882, 0.039922021329402924, -0.013018550351262093, -0.005683794151991606, 0.014098221436142921, 0.006171658169478178, -0.01858879067003727, 0.02545742318034172, 0.019843723624944687, 0.037525054067373276, -0.019359005615115166, 0.022779183462262154, -0.02095779962837696, -0.0143837695941329, -0.01294798869639635, 0.016087941825389862, 0.010361230000853539, 0.0030153347179293633, -0.023079777136445045, 0.014517308212816715, -0.008718272671103477, -0.00837207492440939, 0.056524865329265594, -0.00814458541572094, 0.029590988531708717, -0.013163494877517223, 0.022749153897166252, 0.02757183276116848, -0.013634403236210346, -0.0016833614790812135, -0.028272569179534912, 0.03480087220668793, 0.06360193341970444, 0.017623377963900566, -0.012921943329274654, -0.0397057943046093, -0.022135397419333458, 0.07794482260942459, -0.03678416088223457, -0.007601944264024496, -0.020172161981463432, 0.007449494209140539, -0.0037383351009339094, 0.0008215568377636373 ]
<p>I am slightly getting confused at the presentation of regression models.</p> <p>What would be the difference between these two:</p> <p>$y = \beta_0 + \beta_1 x_1 + \beta_2 x_2$</p> <p>$y = \gamma_0 + \gamma_1 x_1 + \gamma_2 x_2$</p> <p>When are the different notations to be used?</p> <p>I'm unable to search this concept well, so it's quite confusing as the literature seems to use the symbols on similar occasions. </p> <p>Is it just a different symbol for the same thing or is there a specific explanation as to when each notation should be used? </p>
73,790
[ -0.020861029624938965, -0.00025404474581591785, -0.023305339738726616, 0.0038800325710326433, 0.015536471270024776, 0.018568122759461403, 0.007696959190070629, -0.019285162910819054, 0.07164352387189865, -0.012807795777916908, 0.03703831881284714, 0.029579870402812958, 0.061531390994787216, -0.03306169435381889, 0.03999066725373268, 0.049886614084243774, 0.00616711238399148, 0.015393939800560474, 0.007093548774719238, 0.028315354138612747, 0.006600935477763414, 0.00985677819699049, 0.025358162820339203, 0.015818679705262184, 0.003930173348635435, 0.07648342847824097, 0.04317116737365723, -0.0048967585898935795, 0.007237331010401249, 0.035163767635822296, -0.00507705844938755, -0.048911236226558685, -0.00872262567281723, 0.045866236090660095, 0.010422158986330032, -0.028980480507016182, 0.008861309848725796, -0.06287829577922821, 0.0004050301213283092, 0.04482395201921463, -0.018058311194181442, -0.04859193414449692, 0.011726432479918003, 0.019558265805244446, -0.029947901144623756, -0.0010411945404484868, 0.0011117574758827686, -0.025446977466344833, 0.0052135600708425045, -0.026903413236141205, 0.06026845425367355, -0.013734803535044193, 0.04341329634189606, 0.06461665034294128, -0.021893996745347977, 0.016837675124406815, 0.0533415712416172, 0.053122442215681076, -0.0014942513080313802, -0.06292173266410828, -0.00507888151332736, -0.021871021017432213, 0.008670169860124588, -0.010875281877815723, -0.029580499976873398, 0.03849013149738312, 0.0044337366707623005, -0.0259255263954401, 0.02012046054005623, -0.009001432918012142, 0.025716396048665047, 0.021311061456799507, 0.04667453467845917, -0.03316473215818405, 0.004515211097896099, -0.016045132651925087, 0.01633988507091999, 0.03331118822097778, 0.040431734174489975, 0.032066673040390015, 0.011596640571951866, 0.011703209020197392, 0.044300008565187454, 0.002632503630593419, -0.015600204467773438, 0.0005238954327069223, 0.07071108371019363, -0.0018446272006258368, 0.01306985504925251, 0.044830817729234695, 0.0062607694417238235, 0.03765160217881203, 0.028463497757911682, -0.01321706734597683, -0.010946119204163551, 0.039673496037721634, -0.00017178429698105901, 0.030019929632544518, 0.007688549347221851, -0.0029841589275747538, 0.011074624955654144, -0.04758122190833092, -0.008252969942986965, 0.06727205216884613, -0.02496367134153843, -0.016991136595606804, -0.0229719839990139, 0.03418649733066559, -0.023105286061763763, -0.05798365920782089, -0.02743557281792164, 0.041762854903936386, -0.022301645949482918, 0.008282066322863102, 0.010789790190756321, -0.015802402049303055, 0.016251495108008385, 0.007063370198011398, 0.06718885898590088, 0.04006475955247879, 0.05816300958395004, -0.059768304228782654, 0.020634934306144714, 0.02423248440027237, -0.047840580344200134, -0.0018739006482064724, 0.02714654803276062, -0.007023837883025408, -0.06680919229984283, 0.027423812076449394, 0.00027751128072850406, -0.04223783686757088, 0.025330791249871254, 0.005818088073283434, 0.0240484569221735, 0.005440821871161461, -0.059440162032842636, -0.04862399771809578, 0.015032478608191013, -0.02265823259949684, 0.027380160987377167, -0.04520373046398163, 0.002243977040052414, 0.04581766948103905, 0.07903473824262619, -0.024622289463877678, 0.029991390183568, 0.03261532634496689, 0.03922780975699425, -0.017132049426436424, -0.01909865066409111, -0.01719873584806919, -0.016819706186652184, -0.03911440819501877, -0.016551794484257698, -0.0644490122795105, 0.02507183700799942, 0.04808266833424568, -0.011556652374565601, -0.008544405922293663, 0.06545621156692505, -0.025131598114967346, 0.00007583310070913285, 0.018180642277002335, 0.013436468318104744, -0.004948900546878576, 0.05419464409351349, 0.023422006517648697, 0.020719628781080246, 0.08206508308649063, 0.0031517120078206062, 0.013079936616122723, -0.007120977155864239, 0.05419457331299782, 0.037976302206516266, 0.015194517560303211, -0.026297058910131454, -0.017791282385587692, -0.009480719454586506, 0.01892775297164917, -0.08483652025461197, -0.03332618996500969, -0.007896123453974724, 0.026470065116882324, 0.0005337558686733246, 0.046281132847070694, 0.0031746095046401024, -0.022147707641124725, 0.02904628962278366, -0.05071333423256874, -0.03598419576883316, -0.07136553525924683, -0.002940449630841613, -0.04509974271059036, 0.004469410516321659, 0.047839101403951645, -0.0033396894577890635, -0.005442515946924686, -0.02940377965569496, -0.010347742587327957, -0.02105703204870224, 0.03849221393465996, 0.03908691555261612, -0.0400644950568676, -0.0042282151989638805, 0.05478593334555626, 0.051434338092803955, 0.004074343014508486, 0.03752962872385979, -0.06476406753063202, -0.018030043691396713, 0.024236908182501793, -0.017477205023169518, 0.019731465727090836, -0.03354528173804283, -0.025087915360927582, -0.018294818699359894, -0.00437643937766552, -0.02388126030564308, 0.03825709968805313, -0.06356453895568848, 0.05707931891083717, 0.08032021671533585, 0.03754279017448425, -0.013779805041849613, 0.000044517117203213274, -0.014576294459402561, 0.013112232089042664, -0.04078863933682442, -0.03461203724145889, -0.03200436756014824, 0.013958102092146873, 0.018894296139478683, -0.009098623879253864, -0.03180466592311859, 0.014319755136966705, 0.04131076857447624, 0.04424106702208519, -0.004664319101721048, 0.01997433602809906, 0.015261645428836346, -0.025804944336414337, -0.010942500084638596, -0.001129667041823268, -0.005152879748493433, 0.01540167536586523, 0.02092081494629383, -0.004183932673186064, 0.055173102766275406, -0.00011195703700650483, -0.005609484855085611, 0.06791014969348907, -0.019642848521471024, -0.012375876307487488, -0.019510440528392792, -0.01977667585015297, 0.05264781042933464, -0.04027165472507477, 0.023408830165863037, 0.02087138406932354, -0.00949803926050663, 0.0018200126942247152, 0.010198934003710747, 0.011652467772364616, 0.0004496588953770697, 0.02350686863064766, -0.03430440276861191, -0.003089096862822771, 0.00884880032390356, -0.039803557097911835, 0.026174498721957207, -0.03946701064705849, -0.05136128142476082, -0.05528963729739189, -0.008922834880650043, 0.0342743918299675, 0.02693871594965458, 0.020117362961173058, -0.012552537955343723, -0.050222184509038925, -0.012682180851697922, -0.02023838460445404, 0.03280291706323624, -0.01036997139453888, -0.02414855547249317, 0.003802569815889001, -0.06481622904539108, 0.005247873719781637, 0.021346677094697952, -0.009821810759603977, -0.023714235052466393, -0.004013351164758205, -0.030338572338223457, -0.06885041296482086, -0.07468446344137192, -0.03666647896170616, 0.049379151314496994, -0.0025470273103564978, -0.05338906869292259, 0.06671944260597229, -0.0367310456931591, -0.0349491648375988, 0.007802032399922609, -0.0371287502348423, -0.028605416417121887, -0.01560274325311184, -0.01711130142211914, 0.015383350662887096, 0.015627553686499596, 0.01883166842162609, 0.0471283495426178, -0.0620570182800293, -0.01909542828798294, -0.0764513909816742, -0.03745618090033531, -0.0026962650008499622, -0.037744686007499695, 0.03236919268965721, -0.004848068580031395, -0.0320446640253067, 0.08594058454036713, 0.03987932950258255, 0.024760443717241287, -0.04285617172718048, 0.036259520798921585, -0.026312505826354027, -0.030894629657268524, -0.004168927203863859, 0.022727366536855698, 0.022050049155950546, 0.03225129842758179, -0.009975425899028778, 0.015110297128558159, 0.05976203829050064, -0.004136670846492052, 0.02943337708711624, -0.011693350970745087, 0.02520162984728813, -0.013146369718015194, 0.04227912425994873, 0.026755981147289276, -0.004290877375751734, 0.003818030236288905, -0.011730614118278027, 0.03912575542926788, 0.005448711104691029, -0.03595759719610214, 0.0220477394759655, 0.007761996239423752, -0.023399028927087784, -0.03888530284166336, 0.03311224654316902, 0.021847719326615334, -0.03180164098739624, -0.005565762985497713, 0.017760874703526497, 0.016819961369037628, -0.05754133313894272, -0.00938183069229126, 0.009107301943004131, 0.03219073638319969, -0.043909549713134766, -0.008650955744087696, -0.000644601765088737, -0.017560012638568878, 0.02476438693702221, -0.017249509692192078, -0.00635794922709465, 0.05383274331688881, 0.02619793266057968, -0.0021514426916837692, -0.008452331647276878, -0.05973750725388527, -0.018732501193881035, -0.10275354981422424, 0.002238778630271554, -0.021285366266965866, 0.041309282183647156, 0.027232304215431213, 0.04794048145413399, -0.007549561560153961, -0.019561167806386948, 0.0437345877289772, -0.0284417811781168, -0.06369046866893768, 0.030396755784749985, -0.017237842082977295, -0.012097245082259178, 0.008996929973363876, 0.0016642786795273423, 0.03308358043432236, -0.025270523503422737, -0.0021202603820711374, -0.004924947861582041, 0.00433789798989892, -0.040341056883335114, 0.017068905755877495, -0.05409780517220497, -0.02316139079630375, -0.008901183493435383, 0.012847968377172947, 0.007654228713363409, -0.023156888782978058, 0.0008901758119463921, 0.05342183634638786, 0.0095573915168643, 0.015067116357386112, -0.036532290279865265, 0.013706929050385952, 0.054801490157842636, 0.00015549348609056324, 0.04138871654868126, 0.021527748554944992, -0.01887933723628521, 0.016541440039873123, 0.023153211921453476, 0.04240609332919121, 0.041261401027441025, -0.004874254576861858, -0.02096802368760109, -0.037226662039756775, 0.010953443124890327, -0.02091899886727333, 0.021146494895219803, 0.030836084857583046, 0.0050017642788589, 0.04869600012898445, 0.02880716696381569, -0.0051744841039180756, 0.012898357585072517, 0.03357996046543121, -0.006631112657487392, 0.012468070723116398, -0.018827300518751144, 0.003551033092662692, -0.013600043021142483, -0.027781356126070023, 0.004516812972724438, -0.006451718043535948, -0.028853563591837883, 0.007655956782400608, 0.030119089409708977, -0.03880976513028145, -0.009284109808504581, 0.0006222501979209483, 0.029159117490053177, 0.03339426591992378, 0.021061934530735016, -0.06703145802021027, 0.022520938888192177, 0.06024017184972763, 0.029248228296637535, 0.03378875181078911, -0.011742876842617989, -0.07215172797441483, -0.024533238261938095, 0.02436174266040325, -0.0014267967781051993, -0.02266336977481842, -0.04566843435168266, -0.02758832275867462, -0.017230447381734848, 0.01995180733501911, -0.014955483376979828, 0.04270419478416443, -0.006219983566552401, -0.013064716942608356, -0.0009552935371175408, -0.014321302063763142, -0.044395811855793, 0.05999279394745827, 0.00670153321698308, 0.03502557426691055, 0.008735877461731434, 0.020335625857114792, -0.01593034528195858, -0.023206941783428192, -0.044936247169971466, 0.05272262915968895, -0.038709934800863266, -0.022626463323831558, 0.03714219108223915, 0.03556249663233757, -0.0060273571871221066, -0.0687975287437439, 0.014018289744853973, 0.03950638696551323, -0.005891276989132166, 0.032790567725896835, -0.0008492805063724518, -0.061639707535505295, 0.005003748927265406, 0.022962359711527824, -0.02464199811220169, 0.0025723325088620186, -0.019262302666902542, 0.05076517537236214, 0.06485188752412796, 0.00649166340008378, 0.07670728862285614, 0.05218329653143883, 0.003946508280932903, -0.019017666578292847, -0.04908493161201477, -0.0030290321446955204, -0.019917836412787437, -0.02258734032511711, -0.06715346872806549, -0.00002720823249546811, -0.010951679199934006, 0.0022255873773247004, -0.006643705535680056, 0.021302370354533195, -0.03156876564025879, -0.046967413276433945, -0.0010915440507233143, 0.0514734648168087, -0.018263502046465874, -0.024481188505887985, 0.0053515685722231865, 0.026563048362731934, -0.015537605620920658, -0.039434127509593964, 0.020978396758437157, -0.04457007721066475, -0.012088535353541374, 0.03246189281344414, -0.018922237679362297, -0.003729911521077156, -0.0054184445179998875, -0.033713094890117645, 0.030949488282203674, -0.017886396497488022, 0.034782856702804565, -0.012695951387286186, 0.03013516589999199, -0.011469901539385319, -0.054936736822128296, -0.058785777539014816, 0.01502318773418665, 0.01990293152630329, 0.017130177468061447, -0.05312228947877884, 0.04113400727510452, -0.014436512254178524, -0.011857970617711544, -0.05246283859014511, -0.07310400158166885, 0.035406988114118576, -0.023656530305743217, -0.021289728581905365, 0.0023766427766531706, 0.020948095247149467, -0.010359362699091434, -0.052251480519771576, -0.010987045243382454, 0.02871885523200035, -0.03596532717347145, -0.01960708387196064, -0.008978722617030144, 0.02649855986237526, 0.0631304532289505, 0.006006650160998106, -0.019986717030405998, 0.013424277305603027, -0.02245919220149517, -0.01988094672560692, 0.024404233321547508, 0.029220493510365486, -0.031219182536005974, -0.00009006184700410813, -0.04047719016671181, 0.008816144429147243, 0.03559131920337677, -0.0005411302554421127, -0.015240523964166641, 0.02029738388955593, 0.011748725548386574, 0.01408570446074009, -0.03686845675110817, -0.0043414137326180935, -0.00445355661213398, 0.018008215352892876, -0.014891349710524082, -0.016962507739663124, 0.005186171270906925, -0.011159379035234451, 0.028398603200912476, 0.021804142743349075, -0.029233822599053383, 0.0279714185744524, 0.06742258369922638, 0.00789704080671072, 0.036250535398721695, -0.017138836905360222, 0.005566143896430731, 0.059423353523015976, 0.019791770726442337, 0.0022619101218879223, 0.018133005127310753, 0.034003544598817825, -0.03950994461774826, -0.012023738585412502, -0.04595852643251419, 0.005119536072015762, 0.06286979466676712, -0.049970049411058426, 0.03228439390659332, 0.037300270050764084, -0.005990303587168455, 0.038747638463974, -0.0477762445807457, -0.040472324937582016, -0.01815366931259632, -0.01119906548410654, 0.06040084734559059, -0.013815612532198429, -0.03964509069919586, 0.03599781543016434, 0.022668004035949707, -0.025170493870973587, 0.016237059608101845, -0.00431798817589879, -0.010548343881964684, -0.017050668597221375, -0.016282008960843086, -0.0416528657078743, 0.051937758922576904, -0.02501584030687809, 0.01759445294737816, -0.04325918108224869, -0.04602798819541931, 0.06710287183523178, 0.01794401742517948, -0.0064206356182694435, -0.09545786678791046, 0.0022971327416598797, -0.057305559515953064, -0.006297085899859667, 0.018453184515237808, -0.012203563936054707, 0.023848719894886017, -0.015208445489406586, 0.035059068351984024, -0.0016945655224844813, 0.028945984318852425, -0.03465452045202255, -0.0674581304192543, -0.016123298555612564, 0.001299696508795023, -0.036589473485946655, 0.042574621737003326, -0.013102993369102478, -0.02817036211490631, 0.004580665845423937, -0.048925526440143585, -0.008445515297353268, 0.007816147990524769, 0.02074137143790722, -0.024879543110728264, 0.04434850066900253, -0.01873684674501419, -0.026934487745165825, 0.006716866046190262, -0.02602514810860157, 0.09427846968173981, 0.07388127595186234, 0.01104509923607111, -0.08049578219652176, 0.03345809131860733, 0.00024048704653978348, 0.006365639623254538, 0.00502775190398097, 0.01895889826118946, 0.003965956158936024, 0.01786831207573414, 0.04300619661808014, 0.05013633891940117, -0.016060324385762215, 0.0021499325521290302, 0.04309992119669914, -0.0364355631172657, -0.028028912842273712, 0.0012136743171140552, 0.007529358379542828, 0.0060983519069850445, 0.013246474787592888, -0.02931160479784012, 0.01324203610420227, 0.0064933947287499905, -0.011214641854166985, 0.00019306543981656432, -0.025547726079821587, 0.019900500774383545, 0.010433674789965153, -0.012249019928276539, -0.00006255038897506893, 0.0051571992225945, 0.016495922580361366, -0.01112703699618578, 0.020023517310619354, 0.02560228854417801, -0.06403812766075134, 0.027796098962426186, 0.02202613651752472, -0.011084898374974728, -0.01347240898758173, 0.009218363091349602, -0.0015223363880068064, -0.04787129908800125, -0.006732112728059292, -0.012983934953808784, 0.052432045340538025, -0.024288548156619072, -0.013448549434542656, -0.017251601442694664, 0.03931020200252533, 0.025809893384575844, -0.03148359805345535, -0.020146293565630913, 0.04675335809588432, 0.021125784143805504, -0.015503669157624245, -0.010788719169795513, -0.0171830877661705, 0.02325679548084736, -0.02831164374947548, 0.06113829463720322, 0.02975395694375038, -0.0648624375462532, 0.014612511731684208, -0.03457438200712204, 0.053638070821762085, -0.009564979933202267, 0.01966041885316372, 0.03889349848031998, -0.021665537729859352, -0.04713677987456322, -0.023635977879166603, 0.03467762842774391, -0.0010214445646852255, 0.015065987594425678, -0.014668869785964489, 0.007998673245310783, -0.007191447075456381, -0.02734905108809471, 0.02312837354838848, 0.003956904634833336, 0.004091269336640835, -0.04955805093050003, 0.007869850844144821, 0.03878163918852806, 0.03273104876279831, 0.013413721695542336, -0.0015074844704940915, -0.006664991844445467, 0.027539735659956932, 0.020419351756572723, -0.04987518489360809, -0.028179999440908432, 0.02997244894504547, -0.017125438898801804, -0.017925091087818146, -0.04916612058877945, 0.04987364262342453, 0.03551898151636124, 0.014719665050506592, -0.02047053724527359, 0.028633030131459236, 0.001937995315529406, -0.001801823265850544, -0.010277561843395233, -0.044851820915937424, 0.015404826030135155, 0.012824720703065395, 0.00912408996373415, -0.028339536860585213, -0.0061538186855614185, -0.013240103609859943, -0.004404122941195965, 0.029395747929811478, -0.014741852879524231, -0.043429646641016006, 0.02084878645837307, -0.017051417380571365, 0.020804153755307198, -0.02567320130765438, -0.026765229180455208, -0.027102911844849586, -0.0021921489387750626, 0.027763409540057182, -0.0342833511531353, 0.006687367334961891, 0.024069126695394516, -0.02642049640417099, -0.01844794675707817, 0.05228199064731598, 0.040367815643548965, 0.007854529656469822, -0.0043213702738285065, 0.009702840819954872, -0.02825130894780159, 0.036725886166095734, -0.04044176638126373, -0.027687184512615204, 0.00033106672344729304, -0.0007315025432035327, -0.016462843865156174, 0.012526758946478367, 0.023471899330615997, 0.04855596646666527, 0.005166958551853895, 0.014523312449455261, -0.051014386117458344, 0.03624112159013748, -0.028081007301807404, -0.0006696316413581371, -0.014847686514258385, 0.004719929303973913, -0.020961351692676544, -0.034010037779808044, 0.012032498605549335, 0.024311423301696777, -0.004803324583917856, -0.010317944921553135, 0.03487338870763779, -0.007126381620764732, -0.021043449640274048, -0.007997168228030205, 0.01251792348921299, 0.027062462642788887, 0.021055757999420166, -0.014891249127686024, 0.0419134646654129, 0.02264774776995182, -0.04430293291807175, 0.02128862589597702, 0.016970954835414886, 0.024421382695436478, -0.08949936181306839, -0.04397857189178467, 0.040594279766082764, 0.01849004067480564, 0.007550818379968405, -0.05792178958654404, 0.02788820117712021, 0.030075054615736008, -0.02690863609313965, -0.00951596163213253, -0.005112838931381702, -0.011811915785074234, -0.010669805109500885, 0.007974819280207157, 0.031101107597351074, 0.06273123621940613, 0.034254252910614014, 0.030195478349924088, 0.009031916037201881, 0.019966132938861847, 0.0012885486939921975, -0.009304160252213478, -0.013561584055423737, -0.00026632778462953866, 0.003048309125006199, -0.054934754967689514, 0.04880329594016075, -0.0397854782640934, -0.013496791012585163, 0.0436209999024868, 0.0035119696985930204, 0.02174300141632557, 0.054969556629657745, 0.030449820682406425, 0.00625159777700901, 0.024233579635620117, 0.03934929147362709, -0.013551844283938408, -0.042877595871686935, -0.0026117207016795874, 0.027879832312464714, 0.010128901340067387, -0.007789489813148975, -0.013338074088096619, 0.022803261876106262, -0.004299934953451157, -0.016110314056277275, 0.012457192875444889, -0.01588011533021927, -0.039198797196149826, -0.014579515904188156, 0.004984091967344284, 0.011350266635417938, -0.016086935997009277, 0.02056770958006382, -0.04638155177235603, -0.023196779191493988, 0.00849500298500061, 0.017564302310347557, -0.00842632632702589, 0.007659273222088814, 0.015418407507240772, -0.03875524923205376, 0.02141193300485611, -0.004950860980898142, 0.018854985013604164, -0.05559077486395836, -0.00046973643475212157, 0.017703991383314133, -0.035108309239149094, -0.0062066419050097466, -0.01292569749057293, -0.05957666039466858, 0.01938260719180107, -0.005712086800485849, -0.0066316635347902775, 0.021211493760347366, -0.03599449247121811, 0.008529954589903355, -0.08128347992897034, 0.06111695244908333, 0.01522811222821474, -0.03726699575781822, -0.032058194279670715, 0.008785763755440712, -0.05564652755856514, -0.011596416123211384, 0.07529369741678238, 0.01868751458823681, 0.013355339877307415, -0.0028973366133868694, 0.056825343519449234, -0.004304697271436453, -0.021669484674930573, 0.028299352154135704, 0.001973329810425639, -0.030295610427856445, -0.01920919120311737, 0.004490770865231752, -0.015131460502743721, 0.042736224830150604, 0.03906131535768509, 0.004975142888724804, 0.03607850894331932, -0.006105894222855568, 0.003597553353756666, 0.028700433671474457, 0.022881338372826576, -0.04575487971305847, 0.07083877176046371, -0.01124841533601284, 0.02363579347729683, 0.02757602371275425, -0.003959950990974903, -0.06839606165885925, -0.005412724334746599, -0.017463047057390213, -0.014455310069024563, -0.0033429330214858055, -0.03581913188099861, -0.004974378272891045, -0.04810705780982971, 0.01205216534435749, 0.01995685324072838, -0.02996038645505905, -0.009205373004078865, 0.032826781272888184, 0.04767083749175072, 0.0689476877450943, -0.025096742436289787, 0.010198765434324741, 0.03063827194273472, -0.019101297482848167, 0.01664222963154316, 0.0029092091135680676, 0.036184925585985184, 0.0498257651925087, 0.021110938861966133, 0.015918072313070297, 0.0043672798201441765, 0.01896020397543907, -0.01887757144868374, 0.03444061800837517, -0.011921041645109653, -0.010088003240525723, 0.01303973887115717, -0.024460794404149055, 0.0006111743277870119, -0.019054118543863297, -0.007664425764232874, 0.035643529146909714, -0.05691138654947281, -0.009724696166813374, 0.002283436944708228, 0.004511709325015545, -0.011457604356110096, -0.02509959414601326, 0.0063879527151584625, 0.03553466498851776, 0.012025637552142143, -0.008003040216863155, -0.009197949431836605, -0.030177541077136993, 0.013537585735321045, -0.019960014149546623, 0.011890488676726818, -0.01629101298749447, -0.0013062445214018226, -0.030445314943790436, -0.017004771158099174, -0.02081332914531231, -0.012469733133912086, 0.06294499337673187, 0.04215070977807045, 0.005546035710722208, -0.023735977709293365, -0.024818455800414085, -0.0027920773718506098, 0.04396292194724083, -0.08179442584514618, -0.028974352404475212, -0.024849889799952507, -0.01692083105444908, 0.007532692048698664, -0.04404633864760399 ]
<p>How would one go about testing an implementation of a Bayes Factor calculation? The analogue in Frequentist hypothesis testing is fairly straightforward: generate data according to the null hypothesis, use the code to generate a p-value, repeat thousands of times with different random seeds, and look for uniformity of the computed p-values. To test an implementation of some Bayes Factor code, however, I am not sure how to proceed. Do I choose from models $M_1$ and $M_2$ with equal probability, generate the data, and test whether the $K$ values are reasonably near 1? Also is there an analogue of Frequentist power testing for Bayes Factors along the same lines (choose from the models with a biased coin flip)?</p>
73,791
[ -0.02335035242140293, 0.012406048364937305, -0.045527324080467224, -0.03574725612998009, 0.06979508697986603, 0.005932987201958895, 0.012538671493530273, -0.049635205417871475, 0.02191123552620411, -0.005152764264494181, 0.03592389076948166, 0.03353874385356903, 0.07601097226142883, 0.011611885391175747, 0.030341660603880882, -0.013508194126188755, -0.0179042536765337, -0.0018021687865257263, -0.004092501476407051, -0.0089085903018713, 0.006052045617252588, 0.027886327356100082, 0.01910451240837574, -0.007488955277949572, -0.02672341838479042, 0.01082566287368536, 0.024569937959313393, -0.02660457417368889, 0.0017436236375942826, 0.028014812618494034, -0.03363261744379997, -0.025191472843289375, 0.03778389096260071, 0.04870177432894707, -0.03006141632795334, 0.007075483910739422, 0.004444479010999203, -0.026074688881635666, -0.025129660964012146, 0.04271809011697769, -0.014184371568262577, -0.03393235430121422, -0.03245110064744949, 0.00044388181413523853, 0.014970118179917336, -0.0013677093666046858, -0.008275657892227173, -0.04121601581573486, 0.028368506580591202, -0.01386282779276371, 0.05809607356786728, 0.05375739559531212, 0.015855243429541588, 0.013351465575397015, -0.024532267823815346, -0.0337473526597023, 0.05257997661828995, 0.06971323490142822, -0.0328669436275959, -0.06540346145629883, -0.05953975021839142, -0.04841173067688942, 0.03017711639404297, -0.01701953448355198, -0.033616118133068085, 0.01251533254981041, -0.00022958040062803775, -0.031956665217876434, 0.03012290969491005, -0.022573677822947502, 0.02347346767783165, 0.029982401058077812, 0.03655363246798515, -0.004556368570774794, -0.019931601360440254, 0.0015594850992783904, 0.022919345647096634, 0.022315843030810356, 0.010946416296064854, 0.04549584537744522, -0.04562349617481232, -0.006918859668076038, -0.01239821407943964, 0.04955683648586273, 0.021347641944885254, -0.026969965547323227, 0.02082139439880848, -0.012844285927712917, -0.00819094106554985, 0.00988147221505642, -0.06467127799987793, -0.017465747892856598, 0.029768921434879303, -0.0031741070561110973, -0.06541310250759125, 0.013698980212211609, -0.03662344068288803, 0.036340389400720596, 0.0024375352077186108, 0.0033442212734371424, -0.0027621211484074593, -0.026726150885224342, 0.006217511836439371, 0.034828998148441315, -0.04128845036029816, 0.004187354817986488, 0.009754380211234093, 0.0050669084303081036, -0.03832382708787918, -0.018140124157071114, -0.030620278790593147, 0.03796963766217232, 0.01406864169985056, -0.005862054415047169, 0.041693758219480515, -0.015311198309063911, -0.013879011385142803, -0.06213118135929108, 0.075921930372715, 0.037563275545835495, 0.07220599800348282, -0.014258308336138725, 0.013665484264492989, -0.029693394899368286, -0.026083027943968773, -0.009282332845032215, -0.013540024869143963, -0.03344288468360901, -0.010581950657069683, 0.046046290546655655, -0.01570666767656803, -0.035012442618608475, 0.0356198213994503, 0.025036411359906197, 0.012394025921821594, -0.00613084202632308, -0.06973893940448761, -0.0331977903842926, 0.04610787332057953, -0.013927008956670761, -0.025741565972566605, -0.08020226657390594, 0.005742816720157862, 0.06444144248962402, 0.03853003308176994, 0.022612690925598145, 0.034806810319423676, -0.0175061896443367, 0.06261204928159714, 0.017324576154351234, -0.040762364864349365, -0.02683495730161667, -0.04347391054034233, 0.016553958877921104, -0.06227162480354309, -0.04689933732151985, -0.00953816156834364, 0.01962900161743164, -0.031030012294650078, -0.014907259494066238, 0.054452747106552124, 0.045755740255117416, -0.03429997339844704, -0.016183679923415184, 0.01285573374480009, 0.012537511065602303, 0.04958013445138931, 0.010979238897562027, 0.013305671513080597, 0.006797530222684145, -0.02771550975739956, 0.006615994963794947, 0.028614401817321777, 0.03097090683877468, 0.06361278146505356, -0.023869555443525314, 0.011305306106805801, -0.032020535320043564, 0.07697757333517075, -0.017832916229963303, 0.006281733512878418, 0.004009139258414507, -0.009167117066681385, -0.03506233170628548, -0.0003940631286241114, 0.022451583296060562, -0.007511910982429981, 0.005901234690099955, 0.05918257683515549, -0.05339996889233589, -0.052485883235931396, -0.0681425929069519, -0.022338921204209328, 0.021967347711324692, -0.022305984050035477, 0.059250358492136, 0.005315346643328667, 0.04211754351854324, -0.00925484113395214, -0.01735135167837143, -0.05138729140162468, -0.022181380540132523, 0.012488758191466331, -0.023192880675196648, -0.007718574721366167, 0.04602173715829849, 0.05107995867729187, 0.010244031436741352, 0.06514827162027359, -0.027882711961865425, -0.05893611162900925, 0.014349131844937801, -0.027956292033195496, -0.03420668840408325, -0.000005438921107270289, 0.0022806732449680567, 0.0037749011535197496, -0.004115058574825525, 0.022371526807546616, -0.0021553041879087687, -0.05993767827749252, 0.04821537435054779, 0.057358771562576294, 0.03568648546934128, 0.0030341860838234425, -0.004534333478659391, 0.0333435945212841, 0.0025815325789153576, -0.01656925119459629, -0.0057938313111662865, -0.043123550713062286, -0.025914084166288376, 0.05210576951503754, -0.0054532615467906, -0.064109206199646, 0.028458086773753166, 0.03401913866400719, 0.022708043456077576, 0.022717034444212914, 0.04522905498743057, -0.0022218984086066484, -0.011360607109963894, 0.009842397645115852, 0.03159607574343681, -0.012119702063500881, 0.033764395862817764, 0.033796194940805435, 0.031078847125172615, -0.018318526446819305, 0.030725786462426186, -0.007271747570484877, 0.005467893555760384, -0.04919036850333214, -0.0008677101577632129, -0.04218214377760887, -0.026343900710344315, 0.00586148165166378, 0.012324539013206959, -0.026575960218906403, 0.036941781640052795, 0.019129835069179535, -0.0040793223306536674, 0.0003600332129281014, -0.01676657795906067, 0.03637149557471275, 0.03492460772395134, -0.029476579278707504, -0.02609212137758732, 0.02834617719054222, -0.03389647603034973, 0.04186118021607399, -0.037698496133089066, -0.02124699018895626, -0.04550521448254585, 0.04651298746466637, 0.019064683467149734, -0.018036233261227608, 0.010430130176246166, -0.02271200716495514, -0.03425493463873863, 0.019632793962955475, -0.014903495088219643, 0.01904463954269886, -0.009592988528311253, -0.06763912737369537, 0.012941150926053524, -0.04706929624080658, 0.013625562191009521, 0.018539074808359146, -0.03923821076750755, -0.03614015877246857, 0.016236597672104836, 0.00547832390293479, -0.01630239747464657, 0.012952588498592377, -0.04062693193554878, -0.013273391872644424, -0.011577433906495571, -0.014360303059220314, 0.008009154349565506, 0.029357049614191055, -0.06897809356451035, 0.010266249999403954, -0.01452476717531681, 0.009303919970989227, -0.017553243786096573, -0.01204704213887453, -0.030231526121497154, -0.027669185772538185, 0.057845596224069595, 0.013446399942040443, -0.06383679062128067, 0.011367950588464737, -0.04930039495229721, -0.029128622263669968, 0.010530914179980755, -0.0019856328144669533, 0.06515238434076309, 0.014163411222398281, -0.006500281393527985, 0.06622786074876785, 0.04199662804603577, -0.013796979561448097, -0.014323815703392029, 0.0011452267644926906, -0.02474425733089447, -0.021290291100740433, -0.02145671285688877, 0.012085872702300549, -0.011136142536997795, 0.025670144706964493, 0.0002908026799559593, -0.004213406704366207, 0.07910249382257462, -0.003971213009208441, 0.010801590979099274, 0.05521385744214058, -0.0043026842176914215, 0.009116867557168007, 0.0213547982275486, 0.00570684252306819, -0.017669936642050743, 0.014344337396323681, 0.031229108572006226, 0.03631220757961273, 0.025461474433541298, -0.0048149870708584785, 0.006544566247612238, -0.0012825173325836658, 0.008227637968957424, -0.06181824579834938, 0.03832992911338806, 0.0017258762381970882, -0.017754798755049706, 0.035425517708063126, 0.0375470295548439, 0.013717321678996086, -0.02122344821691513, 0.005767961964011192, 0.023451002314686775, 0.03994271531701088, -0.004931378178298473, -0.04523283988237381, -0.016418708488345146, -0.006531253457069397, 0.02980266697704792, 0.0018220479832962155, -0.015163163654506207, 0.06226120516657829, -0.006179628428071737, 0.05397188290953636, -0.030096491798758507, -0.02784051187336445, 0.025811925530433655, -0.03947310149669647, -0.017074715346097946, -0.038482606410980225, 0.02390657179057598, -0.007936699315905571, 0.0005774172022938728, 0.017759116366505623, -0.027521345764398575, -0.021273819729685783, 0.0027965500485152006, -0.04683583974838257, 0.02188589982688427, -0.035525843501091, -0.030857807025313377, 0.009395926259458065, 0.0011491944314911962, 0.031196853145956993, -0.036041051149368286, -0.0030448539182543755, 0.016182614490389824, 0.007578027900308371, -0.04391298070549965, 0.0376073457300663, -0.055200159549713135, -0.0253839623183012, 0.008368132635951042, 0.05020049959421158, 0.04115447774529457, -0.016127612441778183, 0.027199234813451767, -0.006556901149451733, -0.03784128651022911, 0.021084511652588844, 0.01609605923295021, 0.018326235935091972, 0.014776038937270641, 0.01745404489338398, 0.055479682981967926, 0.04792093113064766, -0.054386816918849945, 0.03225252404808998, 0.027979303151369095, 0.08285468816757202, 0.05833198130130768, -0.01717195101082325, 0.006223923061043024, -0.01215982623398304, -0.03128763660788536, 0.011119379661977291, 0.03283010795712471, -0.03277156874537468, 0.013565108180046082, 0.06694278120994568, 0.05765528604388237, -0.03726239129900932, 0.044148754328489304, 0.08062699437141418, -0.009171031415462494, -0.006872057914733887, -0.005097610410302877, 0.003470840398222208, -0.024867992848157883, -0.0018162269843742251, 0.007985868491232395, 0.006119368597865105, 0.006809216924011707, 0.012097525410354137, 0.026820246130228043, -0.0461491197347641, -0.025864295661449432, 0.01517348550260067, 0.019778624176979065, 0.041556864976882935, 0.040294572710990906, -0.020732449367642403, 0.012832722626626492, 0.04277988523244858, 0.009028281085193157, 0.028598077595233917, -0.0009625721140764654, -0.06258340179920197, 0.01552275475114584, 0.07133439928293228, 0.00022200134117156267, -0.02308308146893978, 0.02845846489071846, -0.0679081380367279, 0.011110605672001839, 0.05543661117553711, -0.031846579164266586, -0.001030702143907547, 0.013162576593458652, 0.029558802023530006, -0.02180626057088375, 0.028359394520521164, -0.030933652073144913, 0.02851376123726368, -0.023757776245474815, 0.027259817346930504, -0.026083553209900856, -0.00990917906165123, -0.038850072771310806, 0.007389948703348637, 0.034326136112213135, 0.07319439202547073, -0.052707746624946594, -0.03216753527522087, -0.0008201390155591071, -0.007584696635603905, -0.0022928398102521896, -0.038554735481739044, -0.0018194395815953612, 0.0005430438905023038, -0.02942727506160736, 0.04423272982239723, -0.025724831968545914, -0.05345083400607109, 0.044503238052129745, -0.025313030928373337, -0.021742478013038635, -0.00717539619654417, -0.03590276837348938, 0.04821176826953888, 0.0061312527395784855, -0.0011156323598697782, 0.0710599422454834, -0.0008410414448007941, -0.0003591885033529252, -0.012559388764202595, -0.003399839624762535, 0.004161887336522341, -0.0259503573179245, 0.014469687826931477, -0.06226978078484535, 0.007635625544935465, -0.02354508265852928, 0.04653386026620865, 0.025402357801795006, 0.03912418708205223, -0.02789679542183876, 0.009596792981028557, -0.0312819629907608, 0.04190747067332268, -0.010899201035499573, -0.006796742789447308, -0.0038937050849199295, 0.022100429981946945, -0.0249329824000597, 0.002182411029934883, 0.03016078658401966, -0.03571157902479172, 0.051005054265260696, -0.05139106139540672, -0.046234380453825, 0.02812592312693596, -0.051302384585142136, 0.003060745308175683, -0.0019496413879096508, -0.027344774454832077, 0.047004491090774536, -0.016597310081124306, 0.017283551394939423, -0.0010939636267721653, -0.03134426847100258, -0.018882060423493385, -0.004350681323558092, 0.03251608461141586, 0.062476225197315216, -0.02231513150036335, 0.00590513925999403, -0.026072466745972633, -0.02389686554670334, -0.07476039230823517, 0.006632504053413868, 0.030760537832975388, -0.005042181815952063, 0.0038566305302083492, -0.05164139345288277, 0.013238084502518177, -0.020599087700247765, 0.012112735770642757, -0.02069270983338356, 0.05797819420695305, -0.027285024523735046, 0.0005177227430976927, -0.008498994633555412, 0.011235264129936695, 0.05828539654612541, 0.012597081251442432, 0.003807361936196685, 0.024832814931869507, 0.000004091441951459274, -0.02916429191827774, 0.005402879789471626, -0.04053736478090286, -0.027307599782943726, -0.014994713477790356, -0.028671303763985634, 0.035634417086839676, 0.03901785984635353, -0.05154626816511154, -0.019048413261771202, 0.020192524418234825, -0.00730654364451766, 0.0270763598382473, -0.025028500705957413, -0.02868211828172207, -0.001076124724932015, 0.028891731053590775, -0.046346183866262436, -0.02391938492655754, 0.012101981788873672, 0.007901611737906933, 0.030193334445357323, -0.00418446259573102, 0.0001829765096772462, 0.022389961406588554, 0.060731906443834305, -0.003176253754645586, 0.02365022897720337, -0.014531153254210949, -0.00757277337834239, 0.010040134191513062, 0.04747331142425537, 0.013246002607047558, 0.005729466211050749, 0.008155548945069313, -0.014933777041733265, -0.025405587628483772, -0.05311935395002365, -0.016819680109620094, 0.08327291905879974, 0.0106715252622962, 0.043536651879549026, 0.06066582724452019, 0.01915379986166954, -0.000167558784596622, 0.0016715032979846, -0.021582182496786118, 0.004047308582812548, 0.011465354822576046, 0.026208268478512764, -0.028695346787571907, 0.019935796037316322, 0.0662880390882492, 0.015522157773375511, 0.02605859935283661, 0.04474310204386711, 0.025370338931679726, 0.05701781436800957, 0.042239926755428314, -0.036772213876247406, -0.031008344143629074, 0.03330860286951065, -0.06323394924402237, -0.005646222271025181, -0.04134533181786537, -0.02461988851428032, 0.037829428911209106, 0.04408125951886177, -0.02268095500767231, -0.05991872027516365, -0.05324101075530052, -0.030443215742707253, 0.007848888635635376, 0.028388500213623047, 0.03157179057598114, 0.04532429203391075, 0.010358148254454136, 0.007693496998399496, 0.01565355248749256, 0.004571979399770498, 0.0019808353390544653, -0.0751461312174797, -0.061304785311222076, 0.019026484340429306, -0.021847449243068695, 0.02660500817000866, 0.02222580462694168, -0.015461872331798077, -0.008107989095151424, -0.041150130331516266, 0.03152872994542122, 0.01929016411304474, 0.012925487942993641, -0.029977092519402504, 0.06292525678873062, -0.04092433676123619, 0.026011770591139793, 0.0015233827289193869, -0.028881900012493134, 0.10710293054580688, 0.06726288050413132, 0.0423421785235405, -0.0973471850156784, 0.011449540965259075, -0.024053243920207024, 0.00789183471351862, -0.03035423904657364, 0.035377927124500275, 0.03072204254567623, -0.005641358904540539, 0.020054221153259277, 0.06681882590055466, 0.016254663467407227, 0.0012588477693498135, 0.07149507850408554, -0.031906306743621826, -0.009757338091731071, 0.019045118242502213, 0.02049083076417446, 0.004417015239596367, -0.04074179381132126, -0.006214880850166082, 0.012173306196928024, 0.000896650250069797, -0.0441880002617836, -0.0022703777067363262, 0.007160802837461233, -0.015120716765522957, 0.014471041969954967, -0.018682971596717834, 0.014655953273177147, 0.0052246227860450745, -0.00031937932362779975, 0.012626763433218002, -0.02601041831076145, 0.008580063469707966, 0.012602441944181919, 0.018834898248314857, 0.04411756619811058, 0.00455453572794795, -0.013002735562622547, 0.019446805119514465, 0.004740869160741568, -0.02554059587419033, -0.03723025694489479, -0.037649527192115784, 0.027392534539103508, -0.02566017396748066, -0.021049857139587402, -0.004449053201824427, 0.004042538348585367, -0.009838555008172989, -0.045703958719968796, -0.011775241233408451, 0.013658896088600159, 0.02825905755162239, -0.04248037189245224, -0.0018985428614541888, 0.022434918209910393, 0.06145184487104416, -0.029040474444627762, 0.028043139725923538, 0.008902527391910553, -0.04535962641239166, -0.01059427484869957, -0.015037773177027702, 0.026842018589377403, 0.05533070117235184, -0.05292076990008354, -0.004924190230667591, -0.005848972126841545, -0.041052769869565964, 0.008732260204851627, -0.01217578910291195, 0.008370555005967617, 0.002289165509864688, 0.019263502210378647, -0.035119879990816116, -0.012150653637945652, -0.01402952242642641, -0.03889373317360878, -0.06151719391345978, -0.018675541505217552, -0.037431322038173676, -0.03630606830120087, 0.04716228321194649, 0.029563048854470253, 0.04016541689634323, 0.010664998553693295, -0.01558978483080864, 0.033448949456214905, 0.0326610803604126, -0.08408590406179428, -0.0021364097483456135, -0.019134456291794777, -0.04799953103065491, -0.013621564023196697, -0.029001876711845398, 0.03182011842727661, 0.04099187254905701, 0.01041259616613388, 0.0006904021720401943, 0.0068723582662642, -0.01429139543324709, 0.017864877358078957, -0.024089328944683075, -0.037946827709674835, -0.006636585108935833, 0.008244064636528492, 0.0021022926084697247, -0.04895612597465515, -0.049240842461586, -0.028105556964874268, -0.028070976957678795, -0.0019825389608740807, 0.015113359317183495, -0.03333383798599243, -0.01192468125373125, 0.024616995826363564, 0.0011786187533289194, -0.026795120909810066, 0.014385485090315342, 0.04070764780044556, -0.0015389783075079322, 0.0019546961411833763, -0.004030437674373388, -0.00964265875518322, 0.0278401430696249, -0.020903168246150017, 0.022548675537109375, 0.03841729462146759, 0.021897796541452408, 0.013926693238317966, 0.034026358276605606, 0.0067558325827121735, 0.012202015146613121, 0.04514377564191818, -0.026950890198349953, -0.038374003022909164, 0.0316954031586647, -0.05298401042819023, -0.025580834597349167, 0.02930879406630993, 0.0012922931928187609, 0.022802578285336494, 0.015669560059905052, 0.00955668743699789, -0.020101353526115417, 0.024618394672870636, -0.014075923711061478, -0.012929701246321201, 0.016230840235948563, 0.020435478538274765, -0.016362590715289116, 0.009690027683973312, 0.02141283079981804, 0.005451494362205267, -0.01022962387651205, 0.04082215949892998, 0.04563193768262863, -0.000883178086951375, -0.0014574372908100486, 0.018818777054548264, -0.01617060974240303, 0.004988952074199915, 0.013514936901628971, -0.023111457005143166, 0.032687775790691376, 0.07619032263755798, 0.0027338683139532804, 0.036250222474336624, -0.027913374826312065, -0.007288504391908646, -0.10274524986743927, -0.04755338281393051, 0.02661725878715515, 0.022195909172296524, 0.043832339346408844, -0.04860920459032059, 0.0241834856569767, 0.017352106049656868, -0.05360248312354088, -0.0010275106178596616, 0.019738703966140747, -0.011249597184360027, -0.053380582481622696, -0.009528227150440216, -0.0024789797607809305, -0.00029316189466044307, 0.007839813828468323, -0.006440272554755211, 0.034004371613264084, 0.016272328794002533, 0.006176990456879139, 0.012719009071588516, 0.023997629061341286, 0.008599048480391502, -0.0023581685964018106, -0.04654860496520996, 0.029125545173883438, -0.013860533945262432, -0.04297598451375961, 0.01508917473256588, 0.02722669206559658, 0.016863955184817314, -0.013725653290748596, 0.038398079574108124, 0.007619217503815889, 0.058070164173841476, 0.034975599497556686, -0.005261075682938099, -0.004776626359671354, -0.0017629204085096717, -0.025967156514525414, 0.03225671872496605, -0.02360701374709606, 0.03336482495069504, 0.03651190176606178, -0.019624870270490646, -0.03141453117132187, 0.007096010260283947, 0.0020354718435555696, -0.03975621610879898, -0.007798417005687952, -0.00840115174651146, 0.008025631308555603, 0.004762052558362484, 0.006644995883107185, -0.0842672735452652, 0.014739037491381168, 0.041467055678367615, 0.00665669422596693, -0.049385081976652145, 0.0015762472758069634, -0.05064503476023674, -0.019593371078372, 0.02081669308245182, 0.024045657366514206, -0.028517216444015503, -0.062238071113824844, -0.02452385611832142, 0.007454006467014551, -0.0035201660357415676, -0.005006386898458004, -0.0576065331697464, -0.031220396980643272, 0.00818738341331482, -0.049352627247571945, 0.011065629310905933, -0.026744099333882332, -0.00045056059025228024, 0.017516938969492912, -0.04212414100766182, 0.046834949404001236, -0.014846890233457088, -0.007951071485877037, -0.0083870654925704, 0.019473213702440262, -0.036691389977931976, 0.009186332114040852, 0.02562449686229229, -0.002189763356000185, -0.01552070677280426, -0.006746653933078051, 0.019809307530522346, 0.02630842849612236, -0.07910817861557007, 0.037218429148197174, 0.0015970872482284904, -0.016772469505667686, -0.03880540654063225, -0.029759908095002174, 0.01611682027578354, 0.03294964134693146, -0.0016394770937040448, -0.01077098399400711, -0.022742390632629395, -0.009856282733380795, 0.006478790659457445, 0.050989266484975815, -0.010356204584240913, 0.026195334270596504, 0.018603071570396423, 0.00967998243868351, 0.018359504640102386, 0.01253708265721798, 0.003669372061267495, -0.05483265966176987, 0.033587951213121414, -0.020985940471291542, -0.015870722010731697, 0.019940944388508797, 0.031239069998264313, -0.00525450985878706, -0.043777111917734146, -0.017462948337197304, 0.027628697454929352, -0.02864803373813629, 0.012904392555356026, 0.024426335468888283, 0.005354500375688076, 0.0022499102633446455, -0.006922452244907618, 0.025913197547197342, 0.011240314692258835, 0.01405504159629345, 0.007858168333768845, 0.01330880168825388, 0.05482054874300957, -0.012063667178153992, 0.048906199634075165, 0.036632657051086426, -0.042738884687423706, 0.004158456809818745, -0.008025461807847023, 0.03813798725605011, -0.029573140665888786, -0.032816093415021896, 0.05141228437423706, -0.019731592386960983, 0.004644487053155899, -0.02930407039821148, -0.009745948947966099, 0.07218431681394577, -0.024089915677905083, 0.00017302918422501534, -0.054880935698747635, -0.014212059788405895, 0.008325435221195221, 0.003000405617058277, 0.00918881967663765, 0.009787937626242638, -0.0204812940210104, 0.006859252694994211, 0.0140541922301054, -0.007853465154767036, 0.021102434024214745, -0.04934387654066086, 0.0023031337186694145, 0.007824852131307125, 0.012561478652060032, -0.054567303508520126, -0.008578254841268063, -0.04648461565375328, -0.03535749390721321, 0.00926157459616661, 0.03794991597533226, 0.02007255144417286, -0.027386536821722984, -0.02682683616876602, 0.01210354920476675, 0.021446803584694862, -0.007749256677925587, 0.004104654770344496, -0.03175841644406319, 0.023014746606349945, 0.011738504283130169, 0.009017247706651688 ]
<p>I have data that includes the number of students in a class and the percentage of that group who achieved a preset pass level in a standard test. I have this data for a number if different schools in two population samples, about 30 schools in each. The class sizes differ considerably, so it seems take sense to use the percentage already given when calculating the t-test.</p> <p>But I also know that percentages shouldn't be averaged. I could calculate the number of students from the data given, but this does not reflect class size, which seems important. The percentage "automatically" reflects the weighting of class size. Any advice or thoughts about this problem appreciated.</p> <p>Example data to illustrate problem</p> <pre><code>No students percent passed calculated no passed 28 7% 2 79 7% 6 28 51% 14 58 50% 29 </code></pre> <p>Thanks Tim</p>
36,278
[ -0.033531248569488525, -0.009077422320842743, -0.0041397204622626305, -0.030116982758045197, 0.026871202513575554, 0.03702634945511818, -0.028403855860233307, -0.04067856818437576, 0.012507244013249874, 0.02301398478448391, 0.04263627529144287, 0.031854595988988876, 0.04770620912313461, 0.02921149879693985, 0.017939524725079536, 0.00789638701826334, -0.05535128340125084, 0.0054654814302921295, -0.0022098643239587545, -0.009703436866402626, 0.0034616191405802965, 0.024044591933488846, -0.0018054760294035077, -0.05325506627559662, -0.018332432955503464, 0.03028477355837822, 0.04804719239473343, -0.03523630648851395, 0.015920160338282585, 0.025962425395846367, -0.007373442407697439, -0.036957211792469025, 0.026951143518090248, 0.03003060258924961, 0.008836652152240276, 0.016113633289933205, -0.021044963970780373, -0.008608571253716946, 0.007247076835483313, 0.03565788269042969, -0.04393300041556358, -0.0066216387785971165, 0.00618857704102993, 0.007148023694753647, -0.013640997000038624, 0.04250005632638931, 0.0050009554252028465, -0.008666159585118294, 0.02574693039059639, -0.03651317209005356, 0.05100712925195694, 0.016266679391264915, 0.05317070707678795, 0.01263230200856924, -0.008679145015776157, -0.014804949052631855, 0.022019265219569206, 0.07626756280660629, -0.012319640256464481, -0.020534809678792953, 0.00011953170178458095, -0.0553087517619133, -0.012805513106286526, -0.024809038266539574, -0.037395257502794266, -0.013569283299148083, -0.01011580042541027, -0.007032277062535286, 0.03552984446287155, -0.02847159467637539, 0.04566001892089844, 0.038624513894319534, 0.037315674126148224, -0.014439745806157589, 0.012761018238961697, -0.031641099601984024, 0.03511111065745354, 0.06082544103264809, 0.04882382974028587, 0.05445653200149536, 0.011571411043405533, -0.000481653114547953, 0.06136548891663551, 0.03037962131202221, 0.025914812460541725, -0.04189556464552879, 0.05658930540084839, 0.003948585130274296, -0.021431583911180496, 0.013266243040561676, -0.0011765790404751897, -0.019863391295075417, 0.05514027178287506, 0.018278956413269043, -0.03176272660493851, 0.048037007451057434, -0.029022853821516037, 0.03277946263551712, 0.024470049887895584, 0.020596403628587723, -0.003986783791333437, -0.033090122044086456, 0.02764364331960678, 0.038527511060237885, -0.038379620760679245, -0.024738581851124763, -0.026180127635598183, -0.04131396487355232, -0.014008559286594391, -0.03385705128312111, 0.011608677916228771, 0.0160839706659317, 0.014771110378205776, -0.00207686610519886, 0.009491289034485817, -0.00041030789725482464, 0.004908429458737373, 0.011269536800682545, 0.06296603381633759, 0.04432656988501549, 0.05734315887093544, -0.01947351172566414, 0.02129751816391945, -0.015253863297402859, -0.006147732958197594, 0.04518662765622139, 0.010988394729793072, -0.018767286092042923, -0.05945026874542236, 0.04374248534440994, -0.047565918415784836, -0.015325143001973629, 0.048697758466005325, -0.028572387993335724, 0.04278033599257469, -0.007376035675406456, -0.04604767635464668, -0.03646130487322807, 0.030563190579414368, -0.03364940732717514, -0.018030187115073204, -0.05161168426275253, 0.00675773061811924, 0.03689726069569588, 0.0608832910656929, 0.00563001586124301, 0.05283382534980774, 0.02426234446465969, 0.022764364257454872, 0.026949111372232437, -0.024191398173570633, -0.0017666800413280725, 0.004491621628403664, -0.028394361957907677, -0.020210472866892815, -0.06261441856622696, 0.014140221290290356, 0.03749166801571846, -0.01153050921857357, 0.011814781464636326, 0.023719623684883118, -0.025380242615938187, -0.011893803253769875, 0.002070826245471835, 0.04539361596107483, -0.0473218597471714, 0.0613376721739769, 0.01750829443335533, 0.019980745390057564, 0.002843009540811181, -0.000014429867405851837, -0.0011168188648298383, 0.03615932539105415, 0.02257477305829525, 0.034443989396095276, 0.0026223594322800636, -0.00774167338386178, -0.028045643121004105, -0.011568511836230755, -0.014828779734671116, -0.047066304832696915, -0.02291395142674446, 0.002641039900481701, 0.0442444309592247, 0.02893035300076008, 0.0067879799753427505, 0.02540145255625248, -0.04086996242403984, 0.014543893747031689, -0.0021154272835701704, -0.048154402524232864, -0.1062292531132698, 0.00036656358861364424, -0.02689533680677414, -0.012315263040363789, -0.029387228190898895, -0.004747635219246149, 0.028764944523572922, 0.017865637317299843, -0.011012974195182323, -0.01553830225020647, -0.023793423548340797, 0.013387877494096756, -0.05919336900115013, 0.008706425316631794, 0.022046402096748352, 0.06336387246847153, -0.0084403520449996, 0.04009019955992699, -0.01797005534172058, -0.0359172560274601, -0.011197900399565697, -0.02284691296517849, 0.020545199513435364, -0.015976250171661377, -0.013544471934437752, -0.031817879527807236, -0.0015749386511743069, -0.0418303981423378, 0.03613061085343361, -0.06354901939630508, 0.06869973987340927, 0.05761779472231865, -0.002004684880375862, 0.004640684928745031, -0.020340505987405777, -0.010208137333393097, 0.005662935320287943, 0.0025961892679333687, -0.009242076426744461, -0.04970790818333626, -0.0008603370515629649, 0.01663205772638321, -0.026076290756464005, -0.03172658756375313, -0.004957145545631647, 0.06977230310440063, -0.007850363850593567, 0.004125435370951891, 0.042273279279470444, -0.0004957050550729036, -0.015843268483877182, -0.00201645796187222, 0.020182764157652855, 0.00929863192141056, 0.003478521015495062, 0.008668441325426102, 0.04263807460665703, 0.01697384938597679, 0.04266421124339104, -0.013497143983840942, 0.03361501172184944, -0.00019624691049102694, 0.015088704414665699, -0.0227983295917511, -0.018927624449133873, 0.02820424735546112, -0.03213934972882271, -0.007486789487302303, 0.021295012906193733, 0.005444452166557312, -0.00944768637418747, 0.0022922137286514044, -0.030947064980864525, 0.00251232972368598, 0.02935183048248291, -0.03133796527981758, 0.031643543392419815, 0.009613154456019402, -0.05021815747022629, -0.004388612695038319, -0.015927527099847794, -0.027861014008522034, -0.04752833768725395, 0.04321252554655075, 0.01955815590918064, 0.0007983415271155536, 0.050039615482091904, -0.03733032941818237, -0.019952991977334023, -0.03300311416387558, 0.014561559073626995, 0.001484778942540288, 0.018254006281495094, -0.06998743116855621, -0.00008571585203753784, -0.024292394518852234, -0.035552557557821274, 0.02538137696683407, -0.018624916672706604, -0.01977391168475151, 0.02688177488744259, 0.015267566777765751, -0.04659083113074303, -0.013556045480072498, -0.038788557052612305, -0.006063436158001423, -0.024780254811048508, 0.02122563309967518, 0.00849138479679823, -0.006860476918518543, -0.03812352940440178, 0.04783948138356209, -0.0219214279204607, -0.03519067540764809, -0.04028378799557686, 0.005822768900543451, 0.0002581207372713834, -0.027361970394849777, -0.006311336066573858, 0.015981361269950867, -0.00893511064350605, -0.025909477844834328, -0.03547981008887291, -0.04457942396402359, 0.014834577217698097, 0.010865677148103714, 0.04661637917160988, 0.004770130850374699, -0.03932822868227959, 0.07830110937356949, 0.012332115322351456, -0.05738861486315727, -0.027081945911049843, -0.0035466195549815893, 0.00701435562223196, -0.01748763956129551, 0.02850331924855709, 0.03897639736533165, -0.029171863570809364, -0.041621774435043335, -0.00624024448916316, -0.010924647562205791, 0.0897272601723671, 0.01823347806930542, 0.011267977766692638, -0.014322045259177685, 0.004744063597172499, -0.02387884072959423, 0.060935311019420624, 0.010151075199246407, -0.05141338333487511, 0.005356171168386936, -0.010272427462041378, 0.04546060413122177, -0.012067770585417747, -0.059110015630722046, 0.01280126627534628, 0.0007250974304042757, 0.018542204052209854, -0.03814304247498512, 0.03176698088645935, 0.01349392719566822, -0.012415977194905281, 0.012452195398509502, 0.04049967974424362, 0.0033369821030646563, -0.0387263223528862, 0.015278512611985207, 0.05229460820555687, 0.06650780886411667, -0.014031891711056232, -0.004646588116884232, 0.011655192822217941, -0.01060671079903841, 0.008102779276669025, -0.03824302926659584, -0.01880088448524475, 0.03648419678211212, 0.09181210398674011, 0.026727430522441864, 0.004010551609098911, -0.04927638918161392, 0.007871204987168312, -0.08136171102523804, -0.006191628985106945, -0.05376961827278137, 0.0626193955540657, 0.0008044022833928466, 0.04515208676457405, -0.005380944814532995, 0.012709147296845913, 0.04023972898721695, 0.0032358544413000345, -0.024808524176478386, 0.020629199221730232, 0.004327833186835051, -0.03945871815085411, 0.022905681282281876, -0.029249554499983788, 0.006832406390458345, 0.0009240508661605418, 0.002443864243105054, -0.013398713432252407, -0.004594747442752123, 0.0032633671071380377, 0.020502625033259392, -0.0029696200508624315, 0.040016692131757736, 0.008564540185034275, 0.03484056144952774, 0.003657094668596983, -0.004475337453186512, 0.01620565354824066, 0.054699189960956573, 0.00413499167189002, -0.019551284611225128, -0.04707552120089531, 0.007353000342845917, 0.01199845876544714, 0.05401523411273956, 0.05649133399128914, 0.04915966838598251, -0.07850870490074158, 0.0030044023878872395, 0.003368605161085725, 0.04388917237520218, 0.04840165749192238, -0.0007765604532323778, -0.0027207755483686924, -0.0266574714332819, -0.02172900177538395, 0.029204726219177246, 0.004741309210658073, -0.01949526183307171, -0.019702015444636345, 0.05009746924042702, 0.029448483139276505, -0.0709591805934906, 0.02372848056256771, 0.033446796238422394, 0.03246661275625229, 0.025756025686860085, -0.047571662813425064, 0.009584415704011917, -0.01749267242848873, -0.029828263446688652, 0.017386218532919884, 0.0218163151293993, 0.021258151158690453, 0.016762912273406982, 0.0374935008585453, 0.006071289535611868, -0.04225008562207222, 0.024795617908239365, -0.013926141895353794, 0.04193565994501114, 0.025290505960583687, -0.0485532246530056, 0.016633495688438416, 0.05045822635293007, 0.023393327370285988, 0.005897988099604845, 0.017110604792833328, -0.0777473896741867, -0.04208366945385933, 0.008331643417477608, 0.06466283649206161, -0.05059081315994263, -0.039304617792367935, 0.0008264384232461452, 0.008667169138789177, 0.02702888660132885, -0.04484192654490471, 0.015217042528092861, -0.002889894647523761, 0.01550918910652399, -0.0561082661151886, -0.023339109495282173, -0.04723329097032547, 0.019727006554603577, -0.036702658981084824, 0.00449962355196476, -0.0263323076069355, -0.03130727261304855, -0.03828400373458862, -0.0005566392792388797, 0.0070810625329613686, 0.050723232328891754, -0.056694112718105316, -0.05716776102781296, -0.012215116992592812, 0.02667519450187683, -0.021551277488470078, -0.054166294634342194, -0.0161853339523077, -0.029398445039987564, 0.012978609651327133, 0.021282372996211052, 0.0006163152866065502, -0.02433173358440399, 0.03872179612517357, 0.001746668480336666, -0.05268734320998192, -0.00546275544911623, -0.044158101081848145, 0.05433470010757446, 0.04118887335062027, -0.0023508118465542793, 0.05607852339744568, 0.010802601464092731, 0.03037375584244728, -0.007774308789521456, -0.0612710639834404, -0.032411325722932816, -0.03647250309586525, -0.016582995653152466, -0.048395704478025436, -0.016975464299321175, 0.0009497855207882822, 0.028806349262595177, -0.01135548297315836, 0.026783959940075874, -0.06048957630991936, -0.0218316949903965, 0.013930107466876507, 0.002229417907074094, 0.010683747008442879, 0.012195456773042679, 0.028076296672225, -0.00042353817843832076, -0.01119889598339796, -0.008527075871825218, 0.0219119805842638, -0.031196512281894684, -0.004681846126914024, -0.0039971149526536465, -0.02840176410973072, 0.022135330364108086, -0.03219372034072876, -0.0470665879547596, 0.02994462661445141, -0.03968910127878189, -0.013722253032028675, -0.034262944012880325, 0.024126674979925156, -0.016001354902982712, 0.01935364305973053, -0.04876986891031265, 0.020375097170472145, 0.020788179710507393, 0.024968119338154793, -0.026857350021600723, 0.05839508771896362, 0.009915674105286598, 0.01184424664825201, -0.045726850628852844, -0.03308386355638504, 0.014015675522387028, -0.027871020138263702, -0.012533977627754211, -0.02867835946381092, -0.010534554719924927, -0.02016484923660755, -0.025924017652869225, 0.02289736643433571, 0.06787526607513428, -0.006767320912331343, -0.021118363365530968, -0.016433048993349075, 0.010629460215568542, 0.07038816809654236, -0.0015710340812802315, -0.020313799381256104, 0.015526581555604935, -0.022553179413080215, -0.035872604697942734, 0.022274361923336983, 0.018568875268101692, -0.05163826048374176, -0.024464111775159836, -0.012197567149996758, 0.001235133153386414, 0.058203328400850296, -0.01579517312347889, 0.00015099075972102582, -0.0012603718787431717, -0.01659189723432064, 0.023900751024484634, -0.0223932396620512, 0.019395669922232628, 0.004143113736063242, -0.011868977919220924, -0.031020862981677055, 0.00009064791083801538, -0.04034653306007385, 0.012116490863263607, 0.01837819442152977, 0.03640471398830414, -0.06167305260896683, -0.021752553060650826, 0.09146083146333694, 0.0018138892482966185, 0.017039751634001732, -0.025400998070836067, -0.060523759573698044, 0.047772690653800964, 0.038496650755405426, -0.007887053303420544, 0.018936503678560257, 0.009862528182566166, -0.003823620965704322, 0.0017248434014618397, -0.017085889354348183, -0.022607484832406044, 0.04601811617612839, -0.01006223727017641, 0.03877970576286316, 0.03278797119855881, 0.022996176034212112, 0.03384903445839882, 0.013564209453761578, 0.0066067068837583065, -0.0028786598704755306, 0.02662590518593788, 0.040318720042705536, 0.01118320319801569, -0.028653942048549652, 0.0021937221754342318, -0.023177864030003548, 0.02292487397789955, 0.0504581518471241, 0.033465925604104996, -0.019119713455438614, -0.004374288953840733, -0.009957109577953815, -0.027357297018170357, 0.0038299914449453354, -0.02301895245909691, 0.00474122678861022, -0.052769843488931656, -0.038726817816495895, 0.030896225944161415, -0.012995077297091484, -0.010013801045715809, -0.03387195244431496, 0.0013832530239596963, -0.015175622887909412, 0.0049573942087590694, -0.002097137039527297, -0.014322199858725071, 0.027123313397169113, -0.00864570401608944, 0.03397034481167793, -0.012366426177322865, 0.05292064696550369, -0.05729071795940399, -0.0816764384508133, -0.030175838619470596, -0.05348711088299751, -0.05618148297071457, 0.0016170088201761246, -0.008207989856600761, -0.00033878267277032137, 0.018039830029010773, -0.02170982025563717, 0.055381547659635544, -0.016630249097943306, 0.034971702843904495, -0.04495298117399216, 0.038594260811805725, 0.02309938333928585, 0.042141444981098175, 0.019686270505189896, -0.031115615740418434, 0.13220012187957764, 0.07019912451505661, 0.050488751381635666, -0.03706880658864975, 0.01997125893831253, 0.011502258479595184, -0.01025204174220562, 0.004822249989956617, -0.04618547856807709, 0.022874804213643074, -0.016643377020955086, 0.04593260586261749, 0.03599926084280014, 0.01143683772534132, -0.03594779968261719, 0.04652760922908783, -0.04110522195696831, -0.02626827172935009, 0.049506597220897675, 0.00870228186249733, 0.016291892156004906, -0.026868555694818497, -0.05590461567044258, 0.0077156065963208675, 0.026315923780202866, -0.005642238538712263, -0.014368911273777485, -0.017738856375217438, -0.0360935777425766, -0.03202955424785614, -0.046929534524679184, 0.012713450007140636, 0.006767926272004843, 0.013617009855806828, -0.03617255017161369, -0.0318942628800869, 0.0025380714796483517, -0.038507167249917984, -0.02080703154206276, 0.04641271010041237, -0.030609870329499245, 0.00567981693893671, -0.015805339440703392, 0.0553576797246933, -0.05608918517827988, 0.0023147016763687134, -0.036207061260938644, 0.03452692925930023, -0.03152717649936676, -0.0054106879979372025, -0.002430576831102371, -0.0011698330054059625, -0.0034312463831156492, -0.043355923146009445, -0.029696673154830933, 0.003542061196640134, 0.02140520140528679, -0.005830796901136637, -0.02248077467083931, 0.01043727621436119, -0.014341642148792744, -0.004307915922254324, -0.0036936025135219097, 0.04246967285871506, 0.002589668147265911, -0.03314397484064102, -0.038879282772541046, 0.05537077412009239, 0.022348172962665558, 0.028993040323257446, 0.04070834815502167, -0.003671959275379777, -0.0408095046877861, 0.023733559995889664, 0.0340193472802639, 0.010455682873725891, 0.015613659285008907, 0.017840981483459473, 0.027353813871741295, -0.011081376112997532, -0.00040711945621296763, 0.02591346949338913, -0.008800079114735126, 0.006369510665535927, -0.03482500836253166, 0.004473554901778698, -0.0012429654598236084, 0.029138969257473946, 0.034306809306144714, 0.04169612005352974, 0.0232978705316782, 0.02902134507894516, 0.010285996831953526, -0.05312848463654518, -0.008535033091902733, -0.00814263615757227, -0.0423850417137146, 0.0040681613609194756, 0.0021861675195395947, 0.09046302735805511, 0.01547944825142622, 0.0017755083972588181, -0.01780516840517521, 0.027944985777139664, 0.017140796408057213, -0.0015589697286486626, -0.042944181710481644, -0.06685349345207214, -0.024624919518828392, 0.02364804781973362, 0.014030500315129757, -0.046422772109508514, 0.044515013694763184, -0.05271080508828163, -0.025783196091651917, 0.015672458335757256, -0.029919099062681198, -0.040191031992435455, 0.01766209676861763, -0.009860091842710972, -0.0017445508856326342, -0.011116758920252323, 0.007678968366235495, 0.0018098100554198027, -0.054765067994594574, -0.041523464024066925, 0.0013425179058685899, -0.043547265231609344, 0.01726032979786396, -0.036180611699819565, 0.03127827122807503, 0.07973575592041016, 0.01338163297623396, 0.032490480691194534, -0.006384138483554125, 0.014583198353648186, 0.0020360234193503857, 0.041410043835639954, -0.024269206449389458, -0.010604599490761757, 0.06668677181005478, -0.053463563323020935, -0.02079760655760765, 0.026540493592619896, -0.019529419019818306, 0.05198979005217552, -0.014068776741623878, -0.03291434794664383, -0.02318282052874565, 0.05320163443684578, -0.06330931931734085, -0.038060203194618225, -0.024309342727065086, 0.01069319061934948, 0.050994060933589935, -0.013346805237233639, -0.02541227824985981, 0.034649915993213654, -0.0015852439682930708, 0.0010744343744590878, 0.03613146021962166, -0.023112749680876732, -0.010203810408711433, 0.01036650501191616, 0.008383002132177353, 0.01263855118304491, 0.0157752875238657, 0.018452366814017296, 0.003571243491023779, 0.010651458986103535, -0.03234177082777023, -0.0008286206866614521, -0.01522979699075222, 0.009837979450821877, -0.0836968719959259, -0.02970181778073311, 0.003168681636452675, 0.037067778408527374, 0.02180386334657669, -0.022532112896442413, -0.007571748457849026, 0.018625466153025627, -0.04711870849132538, 0.06538809090852737, -0.011573145166039467, -0.003914543427526951, -0.014567581936717033, 0.028505168855190277, 0.0019120600773021579, 0.01165827363729477, 0.007895219139754772, 0.04891229793429375, 0.03523635119199753, 0.025201309472322464, 0.030203843489289284, -0.028213657438755035, -0.03882504254579544, 0.005336456000804901, 0.016617415472865105, -0.027881409972906113, 0.011914960108697414, -0.013868591748178005, -0.025634244084358215, 0.032774992287158966, 0.01074014138430357, 0.044079575687646866, -0.00459775235503912, 0.017078647390007973, 0.009108061902225018, 0.03602614253759384, 0.06126971170306206, -0.0011939762625843287, -0.02539043501019478, 0.03246462717652321, 0.0226022619754076, 0.021577240899205208, -0.011253601871430874, -0.0016907156677916646, 0.0657893642783165, 0.0017832625890150666, -0.0073833405040204525, 0.02247558906674385, 0.0001660907146288082, -0.0015288259601220489, -0.01388019323348999, -0.0010519917123019695, 0.002045496366918087, -0.04967441409826279, -0.014646518044173717, -0.042748790234327316, 0.0009038790594786406, 0.039533939212560654, 0.007704644463956356, -0.021716147661209106, 0.024314220994710922, 0.01284573134034872, -0.023629268631339073, -0.010960048995912075, 0.008345924317836761, 0.0013966559199616313, -0.014579573646187782, 0.037323541939258575, 0.026682324707508087, -0.011906474828720093, -0.0005798027850687504, -0.03364907205104828, -0.01526330690830946, 0.03120342828333378, -0.012081575579941273, 0.021948272362351418, 0.017014501616358757, 0.015293627977371216, 0.028065090999007225, -0.07267852127552032, 0.0526343509554863, -0.008326112292706966, -0.011359736323356628, -0.013096642680466175, -0.0023744788486510515, -0.03509052097797394, 0.040616102516651154, 0.06965456902980804, 0.05462176352739334, 0.024495361372828484, -0.011651615612208843, 0.02699877880513668, 0.0031612825114279985, -0.04748579487204552, 0.035394929349422455, -0.0025539519265294075, -0.0179230198264122, -0.050382062792778015, -0.011655515991151333, 0.014450577087700367, 0.03230161592364311, 0.026936888694763184, -0.01737053506076336, 0.008396025747060776, -0.02572716400027275, -0.0037139104679226875, 0.05380852147936821, 0.014019583351910114, -0.03388401120901108, 0.014788473956286907, -0.007751102093607187, 0.003695532213896513, 0.04130534455180168, -0.00970522128045559, -0.06943824887275696, 0.01141253113746643, -0.03701825067400932, -0.048865996301174164, 0.0064752665348351, 0.040106307715177536, -0.008537900634109974, -0.050449006259441376, 0.01861662045121193, 0.014464540407061577, -0.04803785681724548, -0.006455800961703062, 0.04192380607128143, 0.021603485569357872, 0.05550185590982437, -0.05088622868061066, 0.06026953458786011, 0.0004600097599904984, -0.056805673986673355, 0.01126816961914301, 0.0272015780210495, 0.01306017767637968, 0.02165459468960762, 0.022057516500353813, 0.0375397615134716, 0.00811883993446827, -0.019956061616539955, 0.000008408599569520447, 0.014906670898199081, -0.03359965607523918, -0.0362088605761528, 0.018327469006180763, -0.014848248101770878, 0.0488605797290802, 0.021083783358335495, 0.0019021575571969151, 0.04779544472694397, -0.01557760126888752, 0.01528044231235981, -0.04792190343141556, -0.019994279369711876, -0.014787602238357067, 0.0005087271565571427, -0.001483127474784851, 0.06455987691879272, -0.010440567508339882, -0.0003243330284021795, -0.011115821078419685, -0.026616979390382767, 0.011060845106840134, -0.006884770002216101, 0.024297483265399933, -0.017796695232391357, -0.024250740185379982, -0.013818266801536083, 0.020032601431012154, -0.04812130704522133, -0.010450941510498524, 0.01606614515185356, 0.0416923426091671, 0.016206853091716766, -0.029342029243707657, -0.035165004432201385, 0.016283195465803146, 0.025448227301239967, -0.017832191661000252, -0.02147170715034008, -0.04234624281525612, 0.020282432436943054, 0.014183803461492062, -0.05177738890051842 ]
<p>I am modelling eyetracking data where people can look at one of two objects on the screen. Our experimental manipulation is meant to increase the likelihood that they look at object A over object B. However, the effect isn't likely to be linear and what we actually hypothesize is that our control participants will have a greater fit to a quadratic or cubic curve (indicating more alternation between the two objects) than our experimental condition. It's a between-subjects manipulation.</p> <p>So, I am using orthogonal polynomial codes to model with <code>lmer()</code>, with a model like:</p> <p><code>elog(proportion-A) ~ ot1 + ot2 + ot3 + Condition + ot1:Condition + ot2:Condition + ot3:Condition + (1 | Subject) + (0 + ot1 | Subject) + (0 + ot2 | Subject) + (0 + ot3 |Subject)</code></p> <p>Am I right in entering the random slopes as non-correlated (i.e., as distinct error terms) because orthogonal polynomial codes should not correlate with each other and should have unique effects on the predicted variable (looking proportion)? This has an added benefit of being able to use Markov Chain Monte Carlo sampling with <code>languageR</code>'s <code>pvals.fnc()</code>, but we do get different results than if I enter the random terms like <code>(1 + ot1 + ot2 + ot3 | Subject)</code> and so I want to make sure this is OK.</p>
47,846
[ -0.027264682576060295, -0.035567380487918854, -0.025515463203191757, -0.017266428098082542, 0.004092416726052761, 0.04345898702740669, -0.028810009360313416, -0.002411127323284745, 0.04288431257009506, 0.014844723045825958, 0.054409708827733994, 0.03690345957875252, 0.06379510462284088, 0.005320485215634108, 0.001661255257204175, -0.029228748753666878, 0.00034509014221839607, 0.002092990791425109, 0.008697199635207653, -0.004719079472124577, -0.03463272750377655, 0.004206781275570393, -0.00742869358509779, -0.001298086135648191, -0.005617890506982803, 0.053910110145807266, 0.017420275136828423, -0.06331054866313934, 0.03189530596137047, -0.00235751667059958, -0.029044395312666893, -0.04309306666254997, 0.01888960599899292, 0.008150318637490273, 0.01705571822822094, 0.03226780891418457, -0.03269629552960396, -0.008646367117762566, 0.007473204750567675, 0.02896420657634735, -0.028204714879393578, -0.02739715948700905, -0.0030412590131163597, 0.03856921195983887, 0.029976796358823776, -0.002012884244322777, -0.018688105046749115, -0.006878220476210117, 0.0573573037981987, 0.009572012349963188, 0.06195379048585892, -0.004898278973996639, 0.013099124655127525, 0.04063575714826584, -0.01415636483579874, -0.0020059875678271055, 0.05790947377681732, 0.0824156403541565, 0.021390391513705254, -0.026619188487529755, -0.027720773592591286, -0.004426321014761925, 0.012566404417157173, 0.030890658497810364, -0.006218021735548973, -0.01245814748108387, 0.022822733968496323, -0.018540166318416595, 0.04623865708708763, -0.034994907677173615, 0.017729464918375015, 0.032931551337242126, 0.04965326189994812, -0.016220469027757645, 0.022373737767338753, 0.018125304952263832, 0.03287900611758232, 0.03225843980908394, 0.0368485301733017, 0.0026383993681520224, -0.017026500776410103, -0.014144787564873695, -0.019915787503123283, 0.05763224884867668, 0.01028597354888916, 0.007464217953383923, 0.045438118278980255, -0.042122624814510345, -0.001150569412857294, 0.037361759692430496, -0.02113823965191841, 0.0041755628772079945, 0.051491621881723404, 0.028888409957289696, -0.06012135371565819, -0.007467276882380247, 0.004564180038869381, 0.006488175597041845, 0.004997521638870239, 0.024737941101193428, -0.055417969822883606, -0.05160481110215187, -0.0344516895711422, 0.02616209164261818, -0.050084758549928665, -0.017471997067332268, -0.0009534551063552499, 0.009135589003562927, -0.01644803397357464, -0.03707338124513626, -0.011056548915803432, 0.012216256000101566, 0.003484982531517744, 0.028325945138931274, 0.029062172397971153, -0.04377127066254616, 0.002133579459041357, -0.007044334430247545, 0.08081327378749847, 0.06875059753656387, 0.028360215947031975, 0.007558932062238455, 0.04155416041612625, -0.034453243017196655, -0.04061916097998619, -0.003489480121061206, 0.0024378399830311537, -0.01874152012169361, -0.014472742564976215, 0.04190770909190178, 0.007258270401507616, -0.014627254568040371, 0.06251760572195053, 0.008106168359518051, 0.030142366886138916, -0.007295504212379456, -0.09965179860591888, -0.02333359606564045, 0.03348793461918831, -0.008098205551505089, 0.023147128522396088, -0.054623402655124664, -0.0581122525036335, 0.05015893653035164, 0.06295521557331085, -0.005955755710601807, 0.024957193061709404, -0.02574048936367035, -0.0011178944259881973, 0.0002784613170661032, -0.051162801682949066, 0.00782125722616911, -0.03022785671055317, -0.0007069488056004047, -0.033151816576719284, -0.08328631520271301, 0.04678304120898247, 0.047323454171419144, 0.00556909991428256, -0.0038781482726335526, 0.04534836858510971, -0.019170565530657768, 0.019816000014543533, -0.02534819208085537, -0.022732678800821304, -0.03292738273739815, 0.054724786430597305, -0.009975608438253403, 0.06915450096130371, 0.008915932849049568, -0.003043148899450898, 0.03931504860520363, -0.01597585342824459, 0.02860630303621292, 0.061754871159791946, -0.044011279940605164, 0.04308249056339264, -0.0040938048623502254, 0.005395340733230114, 0.04403849318623543, -0.05513575300574303, -0.021997669711709023, -0.0225625429302454, -0.0017333986470475793, 0.01263074204325676, 0.014047910459339619, 0.0204531978815794, 0.0069259097799658775, 0.053654853254556656, -0.02726368047297001, -0.04550669714808464, -0.05358840525150299, 0.011555958539247513, -0.015816472470760345, -0.05211441591382027, 0.027347147464752197, -0.03630565479397774, 0.04200049117207527, 0.005614419002085924, -0.02741185575723648, -0.03383917734026909, 0.014941098168492317, 0.048038482666015625, -0.050344280898571014, 0.0005994304665364325, 0.028337644413113594, 0.026282526552677155, -0.025506718084216118, 0.030287211760878563, -0.02298157662153244, -0.035378407686948776, -0.010888864286243916, -0.029221121221780777, 0.0011067993473261595, -0.014256095513701439, -0.015267517417669296, -0.018662575632333755, 0.06489396095275879, 0.003473758464679122, 0.035664476454257965, -0.022425031289458275, 0.061212699860334396, 0.0687670037150383, 0.019026488065719604, -0.008210412226617336, 0.027854667976498604, 0.0007558169309049845, 0.01604403369128704, -0.031745780259370804, -0.02535943314433098, -0.044167883694171906, -0.006361476611346006, 0.03180408477783203, 0.0037210434675216675, -0.0775626003742218, 0.005814331118017435, 0.04395898059010506, 0.03210419788956642, -0.0014816659968346357, 0.029892344027757645, -0.010351253673434258, -0.01838851533830166, -0.0031198502983897924, 0.030269162729382515, 0.06110519543290138, 0.019185418263077736, 0.0077753751538693905, -0.024657415226101875, 0.014835965819656849, -0.0227754395455122, 0.012895947322249413, 0.01123405434191227, -0.0003081454196944833, 0.017498550936579704, -0.03792032226920128, -0.011106305755674839, 0.025992734357714653, -0.0076257395558059216, -0.0006511250976473093, 0.06776630133390427, -0.000983204459771514, -0.054209738969802856, 0.007563210558146238, -0.0327351950109005, -0.018238170072436333, 0.03579184412956238, -0.0279498603194952, 0.007574714720249176, 0.023177335038781166, -0.031756531447172165, 0.012478811666369438, -0.027150586247444153, 0.012772968970239162, -0.052921876311302185, 0.033140093088150024, 0.011369853280484676, -0.01146854367107153, 0.036035820841789246, -0.04779743403196335, -0.029420986771583557, 0.0028908157255500555, -0.015350506640970707, 0.017147116363048553, -0.006786854472011328, -0.10148164629936218, 0.004880898632109165, -0.03088684380054474, -0.012107624672353268, 0.021598808467388153, 0.017278574407100677, -0.02381485514342785, 0.0016623222036287189, -0.002057806123048067, -0.02447507530450821, -0.050239697098731995, -0.01653216779232025, 0.0009369291365146637, 0.013103866949677467, -0.027770647779107094, 0.00411420501768589, 0.017419563606381416, -0.05114128813147545, 0.021064307540655136, -0.021977204829454422, -0.006156885996460915, 0.003961896989494562, -0.0035973726771771908, -0.03196272626519203, -0.002198954578489065, 0.012047146447002888, 0.02420535683631897, 0.007449192460626364, -0.016511892899870872, -0.08187266439199448, -0.0492817647755146, 0.011449144221842289, 0.03603597730398178, 0.03096143715083599, 0.016937868669629097, -0.006193193141371012, 0.08893876522779465, 0.018273303285241127, -0.006065720226615667, -0.06581500172615051, -0.006147748325020075, -0.04043116047978401, -0.037901174277067184, 0.016630467027425766, 0.0054852962493896484, 0.016176968812942505, 0.024369655176997185, -0.015514060854911804, 0.0041050720028579235, 0.03667373210191727, 0.013728050515055656, 0.024157078936696053, 0.016975218430161476, -0.0036474172957241535, -0.0616186261177063, 0.025149287655949593, 0.031513478606939316, -0.0163981094956398, 0.03108801692724228, 0.031172577291727066, -0.017514584586024284, 0.009322340600192547, -0.02101043052971363, 0.013900858350098133, -0.017482399940490723, 0.009075772017240524, 0.014277702197432518, 0.030107667669653893, 0.014463203959167004, -0.0415770448744297, -0.007138690445572138, 0.01820143312215805, 0.028486276045441628, -0.007060304284095764, 0.003286166815087199, 0.019348373636603355, 0.07011297345161438, -0.0010171704925596714, -0.004495033994317055, -0.04159991070628166, 0.02259727381169796, 0.026286395266652107, -0.03433133661746979, 0.019796788692474365, 0.052707429975271225, 0.010749666951596737, -0.0010507366387173533, -0.0018768188310787082, -0.020811043679714203, 0.0014961822889745235, -0.052467912435531616, 0.024437811225652695, -0.04517798870801926, 0.026530589908361435, 0.016164502128958702, 0.038892559707164764, 0.02896220050752163, -0.011050044558942318, -0.011333276517689228, 0.02469870261847973, -0.05808452516794205, 0.03505166992545128, -0.008593830280005932, -0.02866556867957115, 0.01346453744918108, -0.020432105287909508, 0.000015723597243777476, -0.04031691700220108, -0.005269201472401619, 0.039412908256053925, 0.015174019150435925, -0.006991150788962841, -0.0013965037651360035, -0.03406958281993866, -0.015273494645953178, -0.028496509417891502, 0.028944427147507668, -0.04173867776989937, -0.0035915367770940065, 0.00033801066456362605, 0.053315989673137665, 0.0028189655859023333, -0.007028750143945217, -0.038123637437820435, 0.019693955779075623, 0.034944575279951096, 0.05266180261969566, 0.019526105374097824, 0.013510582968592644, -0.08406659960746765, 0.0324414037168026, 0.0391286164522171, 0.029622018337249756, 0.04354714974761009, 0.01245004590600729, 0.01636997051537037, -0.020556030794978142, -0.04001389071345329, 0.0034350494388490915, -0.0014207573840394616, 0.006788489408791065, -0.013299505226314068, 0.05098020285367966, 0.05953922122716904, -0.019211798906326294, -0.027417171746492386, 0.06825406104326248, -0.002059939783066511, 0.012143533676862717, -0.04064163565635681, 0.02655504085123539, 0.016894886270165443, 0.010654092766344547, 0.00446414016187191, 0.03349591791629791, 0.02040157839655876, -0.019780240952968597, 0.04227188229560852, 0.01272878423333168, -0.02666085958480835, 0.01896139420568943, 0.00706440769135952, -0.0024667121469974518, -0.019135238602757454, -0.0015596816083416343, -0.001997663639485836, 0.016459444537758827, 0.012614778243005276, 0.011072772555053234, -0.020067784935235977, -0.11230296641588211, 0.0067783682607114315, 0.025035038590431213, 0.052863702178001404, -0.039976511150598526, -0.008718919940292835, -0.0075720869936048985, -0.0002635725250001997, 0.002395146293565631, -0.006790323182940483, 0.01858837530016899, 0.02340831235051155, 0.015022780746221542, -0.023892639204859734, -0.041143372654914856, -0.06538230180740356, 0.03533126413822174, -0.028549902141094208, 0.019032327458262444, -0.020782025530934334, -0.042449019849300385, -0.026880094781517982, 0.03559476509690285, 0.009962840937077999, 0.06360010802745819, -0.08245513588190079, -0.031329281628131866, 0.0023801573552191257, 0.002760998671874404, -0.0398564338684082, -0.07283172756433487, 0.03983055055141449, -0.013962587341666222, -0.012714101932942867, 0.05552612990140915, 0.010617714375257492, -0.007594892289489508, 0.001844075508415699, 0.037605538964271545, 0.0042990464717149734, -0.0199180506169796, 0.013448691926896572, 0.04048820212483406, 0.039600126445293427, 0.03269543871283531, 0.09533724933862686, 0.027070390060544014, 0.01699054054915905, -0.015359844081103802, -0.05174480751156807, 0.015984149649739265, -0.014716203324496746, 0.010682801716029644, -0.060442809015512466, -0.022785820066928864, -0.04789287969470024, 0.03324710950255394, 0.009609171189367771, 0.01100745890289545, -0.02922287955880165, -0.0134233133867383, -0.018442388623952866, 0.05663242191076279, 0.005593163426965475, -0.01302249077707529, 0.027913784608244896, -0.007568920962512493, -0.019077997654676437, 0.011624772101640701, -0.00872088223695755, -0.07612020522356033, -0.0017721542390063405, -0.005951445084065199, -0.007838565856218338, -0.05870009586215019, -0.014331716112792492, 0.014896350912749767, -0.0011613003443926573, -0.04371494799852371, 0.026404649019241333, 0.03133741766214371, 0.015690185129642487, 0.003570642787963152, -0.03555798530578613, 0.02512548305094242, 0.02755194902420044, -0.017050202935934067, 0.0448063388466835, -0.023914476856589317, 0.019394824281334877, -0.05144394561648369, 0.006388822570443153, -0.030685871839523315, -0.07282137125730515, 0.0056991358287632465, -0.0025046481750905514, -0.005529569461941719, 0.016841115429997444, -0.038887448608875275, -0.036457937210798264, -0.025171451270580292, -0.02091531828045845, 0.053795766085386276, -0.028926849365234375, 0.015891380608081818, -0.0020073610357940197, 0.010461444035172462, 0.03347112983465195, -0.002528538927435875, -0.03568486124277115, 0.041166823357343674, -0.006184759549796581, 0.026153281331062317, -0.005446428898721933, -0.02337968908250332, -0.06482783704996109, -0.03288516774773598, -0.06305374205112457, 0.01295104343444109, 0.08334332704544067, 0.006975017953664064, -0.022858338430523872, 0.021200543269515038, 0.010958974249660969, 0.030273959040641785, -0.019423842430114746, -0.050992053002119064, -0.024151097983121872, 0.02102884091436863, -0.03102906420826912, 0.044860925525426865, -0.005951708182692528, 0.037974826991558075, 0.029179280623793602, 0.020504940301179886, -0.033249955624341965, 0.018459418788552284, 0.07827217876911163, -0.00989853497594595, 0.015937240794301033, -0.0009807146852836013, 0.02228672429919243, 0.046320002526044846, 0.019549809396266937, 0.01937096379697323, -0.004896126221865416, 0.010762668214738369, -0.003124427981674671, -0.03792798891663551, -0.01617623306810856, -0.006657790392637253, 0.0828220322728157, 0.014745881780982018, 0.04610920324921608, 0.052228476852178574, -0.03085838444530964, -0.008705547079443932, -0.02519836276769638, -0.04829452186822891, -0.006138707511126995, 0.0016177771613001823, 0.0551636777818203, -0.033773813396692276, -0.02582765743136406, 0.04536689817905426, 0.00440810015425086, 0.062398627400398254, 0.042980145663022995, 0.025028999894857407, 0.03145069256424904, 0.03987230733036995, -0.025409189984202385, -0.04523969441652298, 0.0409342385828495, -0.07649226486682892, 0.04764663055539131, -0.012936956249177456, -0.046801988035440445, 0.03718290477991104, 0.05480969697237015, 0.0037658114451915026, -0.06469666957855225, -0.03290057182312012, -0.045336101204156876, 0.009019758552312851, 0.008380907587707043, -0.03033769316971302, 0.0024617137387394905, -0.026627929881215096, 0.06366801261901855, 0.0022281811106950045, 0.012433751486241817, -0.02896469458937645, -0.10257294028997421, -0.022909164428710938, -0.006711091846227646, -0.005978819914162159, 0.029268847778439522, 0.0024988865479826927, -0.014320848509669304, 0.04147552698850632, -0.016828911378979683, 0.015310265123844147, 0.002578717889264226, 0.03011569194495678, -0.01243236567825079, 0.002293060999363661, -0.04522931948304176, 0.017249371856451035, -0.027548080310225487, -0.035919319838285446, 0.11044315993785858, 0.06836217641830444, 0.015257730148732662, -0.04621574282646179, 0.03915153816342354, 0.014287922531366348, -0.013194473460316658, -0.01594015769660473, -0.014439398422837257, 0.04968627542257309, -0.012818612158298492, 0.007917210459709167, 0.036562711000442505, 0.013286426663398743, -0.0227580014616251, 0.0637916550040245, -0.03655138984322548, -0.025110652670264244, 0.02324807085096836, -0.003796919248998165, 0.025270909070968628, 0.003497830592095852, -0.04749932512640953, -0.0030968165956437588, -0.004404713865369558, -0.028157398104667664, -0.0007364498451352119, -0.015562634915113449, -0.004372324328869581, 0.009672327898442745, -0.011380805633962154, 0.00816709641367197, 0.004634731449186802, -0.0089684147387743, 0.04326098412275314, 0.0023544824216514826, 0.011901508085429668, -0.01837211102247238, 0.025379948318004608, 0.036225076764822006, 0.01836344785988331, -0.004167592152953148, -0.012554321438074112, 0.024653740227222443, -0.022156067192554474, -0.035198234021663666, -0.04386242851614952, 0.0344412736594677, -0.030627483502030373, -0.02205323614180088, 0.010187672451138496, -0.005738896317780018, 0.027691999450325966, -0.055268917232751846, -0.04823901131749153, 0.030706578865647316, 0.009453446604311466, 0.010331823490560055, -0.00672183558344841, -0.01192108727991581, -0.015839600935578346, 0.012511596083641052, -0.01861937716603279, 0.022410966455936432, 0.0038682506419718266, 0.009954245761036873, -0.04634919390082359, 0.0717807486653328, 0.013607834465801716, 0.013203948736190796, 0.0027492758817970753, -0.0017150340136140585, -0.04158857837319374, -0.029848488047719002, -0.022266561165452003, 0.039461493492126465, 0.035892702639102936, -0.00738114258274436, -0.006019728723913431, -0.036416422575712204, -0.024040035903453827, 0.005648781545460224, 0.016012541949748993, -0.022351069375872612, -0.0316431038081646, -0.007402744609862566, 0.03883010894060135, 0.0038198025431483984, -0.018192538991570473, 0.0037642812822014093, 0.002617178251966834, 0.0758790373802185, -0.006136598065495491, -0.04953666403889656, -0.05172186344861984, -0.0012041006702929735, 0.011537221260368824, -0.0246635340154171, -0.012255251407623291, 0.05796502158045769, 0.01013597846031189, 0.014798721298575401, -0.018385212868452072, 0.02683194726705551, 0.02183305285871029, -0.00847147312015295, 0.052437491714954376, -0.051329176872968674, -0.0016857204027473927, 0.01900833658874035, -0.023611828684806824, -0.0369323305785656, -0.01346172671765089, -0.03916064649820328, -0.04384255036711693, -0.00562648568302393, -0.0408436544239521, -0.04194684326648712, -0.02548762410879135, 0.000012109201634302735, 0.012375684455037117, 0.01560962200164795, -0.003674897598102689, -0.0007077103364281356, -0.007541293278336525, -0.009100093506276608, -0.019950220361351967, -0.009653294458985329, 0.023887215182185173, -0.014606171287596226, 0.02280181460082531, -0.006595505401492119, 0.034919898957014084, 0.037276897579431534, -0.012638804502785206, -0.0015162397176027298, 0.0015727672725915909, 0.0424264520406723, -0.018127011135220528, -0.0292684193700552, 0.001231432193890214, -0.021752789616584778, -0.031831227242946625, 0.03260549157857895, 0.006107504479587078, 0.02263186126947403, 0.016627231612801552, 0.011202344670891762, 0.015239634551107883, 0.023053182289004326, -0.010781446471810341, -0.018100664019584656, -0.004585557617247105, -0.0025903808418661356, -0.0011709234677255154, -0.02991556003689766, 0.033601921051740646, 0.014911569654941559, 0.004173459019511938, 0.049704886972904205, 0.07222685217857361, -0.004618593957275152, 0.01507764495909214, 0.02066262997686863, -0.021932952105998993, 0.01733504794538021, 0.0073429192416369915, 0.016121333464980125, -0.003339663613587618, 0.02561168186366558, -0.009723708033561707, 0.03249894082546234, -0.009248458780348301, 0.0046479348093271255, -0.06402941793203354, -0.04538556560873985, 0.018200373277068138, -0.01130420621484518, 0.06558594107627869, -0.058774761855602264, -0.02574055641889572, 0.004115396644920111, -0.03006109781563282, -0.030454492196440697, 0.021512165665626526, -0.005972748622298241, -0.06179366260766983, 0.006880464032292366, -0.04550706595182419, 0.006951791699975729, 0.00029950946918688715, 0.006814459804445505, 0.032571762800216675, -0.0004366544308140874, 0.0071501461789011955, -0.020075814798474312, -0.007960176095366478, -0.022137705236673355, 0.035933662205934525, -0.04600999876856804, 0.032578591257333755, -0.025877783074975014, -0.023272261023521423, 0.007808889728039503, -0.028799645602703094, 0.0055741132237017155, 0.019911855459213257, 0.01275965478271246, 0.012716343626379967, 0.040861308574676514, -0.0075964732095599174, -0.004550558049231768, -0.009096560068428516, -0.020067362114787102, 0.026695212349295616, 0.042196378111839294, -0.04900138080120087, 0.01912630908191204, 0.01243525743484497, 0.01392607856541872, -0.03534586355090141, 0.020694008097052574, -0.02783241495490074, -0.011107808910310268, -0.018597835674881935, 0.009877239353954792, -0.009208847768604755, -0.022351643070578575, 0.019371885806322098, -0.036457695066928864, 0.029024189338088036, -0.007109656929969788, 0.023160535842180252, -0.0011771108256652951, -0.007801169063895941, -0.0626634731888771, -0.02387714944779873, -0.021567145362496376, 0.013025302439928055, -0.02621370740234852, -0.010829254053533077, 0.011028151959180832, 0.012131795287132263, 0.01030920259654522, 0.029566027224063873, -0.002348220208659768, 0.0036776585038751364, 0.04069353640079498, -0.015417277812957764, -0.024405134841799736, 0.04261627793312073, -0.011515242047607899, 0.048821210861206055, -0.06488043069839478, 0.06889571249485016, 0.017703687772154808, 0.014259302988648415, -0.03859926387667656, 0.009503372944891453, -0.023549657315015793, 0.04517395794391632, 0.02661053277552128, 0.01241719163954258, 0.019355926662683487, 0.02591809630393982, 0.03672336786985397, -0.01983032375574112, -0.008516849018633366, 0.042980682104825974, -0.017889829352498055, 0.04910145327448845, -0.015824245288968086, 0.0069183954037725925, -0.003976076375693083, -0.03407759219408035, 0.0012934246333315969, -0.013497145846486092, -0.0063199857249855995, 0.002360460814088583, -0.03935225307941437, 0.010351333767175674, -0.01769072376191616, -0.0341235026717186, 0.0013358414871618152, -0.012928643263876438, 0.0036657711025327444, 0.0026272812392562628, -0.00788807775825262, -0.04501059278845787, 0.03275090456008911, -0.03063591755926609, -0.023973021656274796, -0.011853347532451153, -0.009394305758178234, 0.014111310243606567, -0.05317215248942375, 0.03270935267210007, 0.0066983927972614765, -0.0323369987308979, -0.025080814957618713, 0.02409818023443222, 0.015068423002958298, 0.002454858971759677, -0.008612135425209999, 0.026961464434862137, 0.01877628266811371, -0.040470197796821594, 0.0019713807851076126, 0.0015896849799901247, 0.02098957635462284, -0.005855156108736992, 0.010635850951075554, 0.03554503619670868, 0.002129683271050453, 0.04953065887093544, -0.01691821590065956, 0.05556322634220123, -0.014613962732255459, -0.0017324666259810328, 0.045799918472766876, 0.044893186539411545, 0.005192303564399481, -0.009053043089807034, 0.003737896215170622, 0.04349767416715622, -0.04827409237623215, -0.027585938572883606, -0.03972494229674339, 0.024537865072488785, 0.0050108726136386395, -0.008444874547421932, 0.03932136669754982, 0.007649296894669533, 0.03236767649650574, -0.013141767121851444, -0.009821383282542229, -0.055753160268068314, 0.034834492951631546, -0.03818471357226372, -0.018350912258028984, 0.0017119215335696936, -0.017289379611611366, -0.008631727658212185, -0.030636191368103027, -0.025502802804112434, -0.030805224552750587, 0.08455824851989746, 0.0007817396544851363, 0.05171418935060501, -0.05164904519915581, -0.053576622158288956, -0.002396787516772747, 0.04022882133722305, -0.03567786514759064, -0.035851720720529556, -0.013017380610108376, 0.05169592797756195, 0.04254651069641113, -0.0009938327129930258 ]
<p>I would like to regress the influence of income, education, marital status etc. on life satisfaction. The data I use is from the SHARE survey – life satisfaction can take values of 1–10, most values are around 6–8.</p> <p>OLS regression seems to be a poor choice to me, as it might produce predicted values outside the 1–10 interval.</p> <p>My colleagues have suggested that I might take a look at truncated/censored analysis, such as tobit regression. However, I do not believe that I have data which is censored in the way tobit regression would assume, which would be the case if only part of the real spectrum of values can be observed. </p> <p>Most researchers use ordered logistic regression. This seems valid to me, but 10 might be quite high number of possible outcomes for ologit (I have usually done it with fewer outcomes, though I am not sure if this is an issue at all), and I believe ologit does not assume the intervals between the categories to be of equal size (<a href="http://www.ats.ucla.edu/stat/stata/dae/ologit.htm" rel="nofollow">stated here</a>), which I however believe is the case in my scenario (why would the difference between 3 and 4 be any different than between 7 and 8?)</p> <p>I wonder if <a href="http://www.ats.ucla.edu/stat/stata/dae/intreg.htm" rel="nofollow">interval regression</a> is what I need. I think it is, but I need proof :)</p> <p>So, which statistic analysis would you recommend?</p>
36,279
[ -0.03840247169137001, -0.04341130703687668, 0.016100013628602028, 0.012795503251254559, 0.01807490736246109, -0.004224705975502729, -0.0509687103331089, 0.01753688044846058, 0.05749814212322235, -0.04244517534971237, -0.018143167719244957, 0.023887284100055695, 0.03139196336269379, 0.022382693365216255, 0.018600696697831154, 0.018033456057310104, -0.002825779840350151, 0.01126940455287695, -0.02833368629217148, -0.0030840265098959208, -0.02725408226251602, 0.048708200454711914, -0.020023826509714127, -0.009088627062737942, -0.039470281451940536, 0.032122693955898285, 0.03486979380249977, -0.020821718499064445, -0.006849267985671759, 0.03447195515036583, 0.0018956831190735102, -0.02084294892847538, -0.007977004162967205, 0.018153315410017967, 0.01897398568689823, 0.004407115746289492, -0.011133491061627865, -0.023576995357871056, 0.025078389793634415, 0.03294815868139267, -0.04318855330348015, -0.011786777526140213, -0.03320130333304405, 0.021064113825559616, -0.007434043567627668, 0.00481332978233695, -0.0017222183523699641, -0.02677313983440399, 0.043014045804739, -0.03131815418601036, 0.07962767034769058, -0.01890016719698906, 0.014836292713880539, 0.01512360479682684, -0.012701042927801609, -0.03431122004985809, 0.038563262671232224, 0.056340884417295456, -0.01802070252597332, -0.026233527809381485, -0.031068049371242523, -0.006021036300808191, -0.01860491745173931, -0.0009675645851530135, -0.017682010307908058, -0.002105140592902899, -0.005727277137339115, -0.00015977198199834675, 0.05650106817483902, -0.011779519729316235, 0.009142384864389896, 0.032842814922332764, 0.023530378937721252, 0.04275364428758621, 0.05030025169253349, -0.013527106493711472, 0.004489396698772907, 0.023030132055282593, 0.03454158082604408, 0.033217623829841614, -0.01899070292711258, -0.006055852863937616, 0.02084519900381565, 0.0769181102514267, -0.002299859654158354, -0.007164857350289822, 0.044893037527799606, -0.04188470542430878, 0.03625742718577385, 0.03976435959339142, -0.0022178879007697105, -0.0059893568977713585, 0.053481508046388626, 0.061558227986097336, -0.024309294298291206, 0.05888475477695465, -0.036110930144786835, 0.04162472113966942, 0.01522993203252554, 0.01735447533428669, -0.0014364179223775864, -0.053155988454818726, 0.009170989505946636, 0.029023589566349983, -0.011805574409663677, -0.0125361243262887, -0.002672147238627076, -0.019186267629265785, 0.022258339449763298, -0.03350645303726196, 0.040439486503601074, 0.03250250592827797, 0.012590179219841957, -0.004272640682756901, 0.02855975180864334, -0.014376659877598286, 0.017662392929196358, -0.031645823270082474, 0.06374482810497284, 0.07669514417648315, 0.012633087113499641, -0.034725867211818695, 0.0029904500115662813, -0.015826089307665825, -0.041541390120983124, 0.010513941757380962, 0.027047690004110336, -0.010967939160764217, -0.028642572462558746, 0.05560717359185219, -0.02190939150750637, -0.03498132899403572, 0.05454271286725998, 0.0015242010122165084, 0.0006579215405508876, 0.004763311706483364, -0.10776329040527344, -0.059761278331279755, 0.007837573997676373, 0.016160307452082634, -0.016952725127339363, -0.07470382750034332, -0.011687446385622025, -0.01505224872380495, 0.025775130838155746, -0.009380445815622807, 0.0346112884581089, 0.013032188639044762, 0.019424540922045708, 0.02788527123630047, -0.000606765563134104, -0.006670806091278791, -0.015904145315289497, -0.012179040350019932, -0.008063992485404015, -0.08082079142332077, 0.00404658867046237, 0.013480822555720806, -0.005885241087526083, 0.007898712530732155, 0.04743519052863121, 0.045388363301754, -0.0571470782160759, -0.012602219358086586, 0.04012586548924446, 0.0061510587111115456, 0.05203944444656372, -0.024721449241042137, 0.028462139889597893, 0.017203936353325844, 0.0033729446586221457, 0.006892372854053974, 0.02114439755678177, 0.048450060188770294, 0.04360824078321457, 0.013767754659056664, 0.0018821579869836569, -0.04685622453689575, -0.01767844520509243, -0.012077443301677704, -0.024107299745082855, -0.04505138471722603, -0.04237719997763634, -0.03768564388155937, 0.008984404616057873, 0.02159668132662773, -0.011645370163023472, 0.00517308060079813, 0.018452264368534088, -0.033611055463552475, -0.08313865214586258, -0.05948468670248985, 0.01749696210026741, 0.020629074424505234, -0.03964940458536148, 0.0014993728836998343, -0.00893778819590807, 0.0453416146337986, -0.01836790144443512, -0.030976440757513046, -0.009269515052437782, 0.006362278945744038, 0.04617875814437866, -0.05392622947692871, 0.025493936613202095, 0.037721242755651474, 0.05344589427113533, -0.03432336449623108, 0.0013286345638334751, -0.02509523555636406, -0.051947176456451416, 0.003321059513837099, -0.009250063449144363, 0.028820445761084557, 0.012347137555480003, -0.008518364280462265, 0.002782513853162527, 0.019427821040153503, -0.03560341149568558, 0.05919294059276581, -0.042004406452178955, 0.08434824645519257, 0.054840706288814545, 0.00012577119923662394, 0.01691070757806301, -0.010658304207026958, 0.008123067207634449, 0.0016583577962592244, -0.029322044923901558, -0.0104639558121562, -0.0157249066978693, 0.0031024974305182695, 0.0073593356646597385, 0.005608971230685711, -0.018150053918361664, 0.007153712213039398, 0.08394020050764084, 0.0018573029665276408, -0.0013311146758496761, -0.0021749387960880995, 0.015004095621407032, -0.01734480820596218, 0.011096709407866001, -0.011012258939445019, -0.007513061631470919, 0.04784446209669113, 0.016153037548065186, -0.01483142003417015, 0.028906159102916718, -0.018457941710948944, 0.022136610001325607, 0.061302654445171356, 0.003711463650688529, 0.017885543406009674, -0.018209485337138176, -0.02069730870425701, 0.050120025873184204, -0.047735925763845444, -0.018120363354682922, 0.05506839230656624, 0.0005305659142322838, -0.004874884616583586, 0.05811823904514313, -0.02872627042233944, -0.02124745026230812, 0.038083627820014954, -0.0570562519133091, -0.00326730078086257, 0.0016877257730811834, -0.012991552241146564, -0.008155060932040215, -0.031100338324904442, -0.01425597257912159, -0.05882887914776802, -0.007726047188043594, 0.04294885694980621, 0.00858373288065195, 0.018793776631355286, -0.0006223870441317558, -0.002341347048059106, 0.015279256738722324, -0.00976375862956047, 0.03283137455582619, 0.002912913914769888, -0.0565534345805645, -0.03921601548790932, -0.045919135212898254, -0.024156050756573677, 0.002892850898206234, -0.0037432676181197166, -0.002965867519378662, 0.03537984564900398, 0.015498252585530281, -0.059989333152770996, -0.023716960102319717, -0.028956349939107895, 0.00036742622614838183, -0.02597963996231556, -0.04913978651165962, 0.027442069724202156, -0.004422816447913647, -0.049432799220085144, -0.0016326202312484384, -0.05042346566915512, -0.018001098185777664, -0.013250636868178844, -0.0002840128436218947, 0.014204568229615688, 0.0008928725146688521, 0.017323331907391548, 0.016032451763749123, 0.014036200940608978, -0.03281604126095772, -0.09352406114339828, -0.07508312910795212, 0.0506831556558609, -0.0006301668472588062, 0.04020873084664345, 0.018513912335038185, -0.04016006737947464, 0.0698382705450058, 0.03634212538599968, -0.012448465451598167, -0.043601300567388535, 0.012680340558290482, 0.012628091499209404, 0.00585356168448925, 0.0195753313601017, 0.02948601357638836, 0.05475040525197983, -0.010480507276952267, 0.035551246255636215, 0.04918045923113823, 0.020805222913622856, -0.018983444198966026, -0.0008188966894522309, -0.0014117058599367738, -0.019840605556964874, -0.04104457423090935, 0.05407024174928665, 0.03386750817298889, -0.020661961287260056, -0.0025835426058620214, 0.0017190283397212625, 0.002988769905641675, 0.017939666286110878, -0.06575000286102295, 0.01914871484041214, 0.003154490375891328, -0.0004528679419308901, -0.03305855020880699, 0.011087318882346153, 0.0051198373548686504, -0.04674340784549713, 0.0031578263733536005, 0.022642511874437332, 0.034230150282382965, -0.022654762491583824, 0.006469174288213253, 0.051404669880867004, 0.030198778957128525, -0.0006801550625823438, 0.007135198917239904, -0.04470760375261307, -0.0009923827601596713, 0.03319145739078522, -0.00794172566384077, -0.03309818357229233, 0.038900505751371384, 0.03565584495663643, 0.038747482001781464, -0.0567903071641922, -0.07936522364616394, 0.028959831222891808, -0.06734499335289001, -0.0006216118345037103, -0.024564916267991066, 0.0719921812415123, 0.008576964028179646, 0.010397177189588547, -0.0009470785735175014, -0.025408325716853142, -0.007747402414679527, 0.02394757606089115, -0.039685919880867004, 0.02694113738834858, -0.026961233466863632, 0.02616286650300026, 0.0127780856564641, -0.022854749113321304, 0.01737133599817753, 0.0047577000223100185, 0.01351974532008171, -0.010771331377327442, 0.04372550547122955, -0.01668664813041687, -0.033945534378290176, -0.026337362825870514, 0.002255952451378107, -0.004370394628494978, -0.028637927025556564, -0.008331796154379845, -0.018994931131601334, 0.009101036936044693, 0.03722766414284706, 0.006151075009256601, -0.011302796192467213, -0.025263536721467972, 0.024148134514689445, 0.028807111084461212, 0.056780844926834106, 0.04709278792142868, -0.003034785622730851, -0.009482616558670998, 0.04989885911345482, -0.01865997351706028, 0.01567825861275196, 0.04126959294080734, 0.018343117088079453, -0.018328174948692322, 0.015759868547320366, 0.014318438246846199, 0.011167261749505997, 0.02926359325647354, 0.01974472589790821, -0.015614991076290607, 0.05066429823637009, 0.018894752487540245, -0.07065851241350174, -0.002561525907367468, 0.03920793905854225, 0.014163656160235405, -0.014931433834135532, -0.025376703590154648, -0.02688143029808998, -0.010341065935790539, -0.0034650899469852448, 0.009913008660078049, 0.03886019065976143, -0.01095238234847784, -0.025157375261187553, 0.045265838503837585, -0.017032088711857796, -0.05852504074573517, 0.008318670094013214, 0.005379427224397659, 0.06184779852628708, -0.016980597749352455, -0.0728335976600647, 0.0011059991084039211, 0.02501794323325157, 0.04098707437515259, 0.05930323898792267, 0.061243243515491486, -0.09942174702882767, 0.02033817023038864, 0.04472977668046951, 0.04965167120099068, -0.03173130378127098, 0.005151418037712574, -0.029613502323627472, -0.012777943164110184, 0.0051249912939965725, -0.04105992987751961, 0.03505709022283554, -0.008605480194091797, 0.019403522834181786, -0.04231968894600868, -0.0534183569252491, -0.04797516390681267, 0.037759799510240555, -0.013057236559689045, 0.003395644947886467, 0.0018540823366492987, -0.05207538604736328, -0.011950569227337837, 0.04220746457576752, 0.02935102954506874, 0.038460176438093185, -0.027586137875914574, -0.01674938015639782, 0.012323698028922081, 0.0233625415712595, -0.05165424197912216, -0.029942074790596962, -0.004589686635881662, -0.005202913656830788, 0.0030942722223699093, 0.04967309907078743, 0.0034179172944277525, -0.022637102752923965, -0.034262996166944504, 0.011733637191355228, -0.04390242323279381, 0.007010582368820906, -0.03873470798134804, 0.06326965987682343, -0.008570347912609577, 0.0042598070576786995, 0.02010674960911274, 0.03506667912006378, 0.0017783750081434846, 0.02825528383255005, -0.045576754957437515, -0.005950130056589842, -0.024370206519961357, -0.04246543347835541, 0.0051722899079322815, -0.025768188759684563, -0.030436333268880844, 0.019490782171487808, -0.014211898669600487, 0.021769938990473747, -0.012531383894383907, -0.005134709645062685, 0.013059275224804878, -0.006624863017350435, -0.0020006345584988594, 0.011056212708353996, -0.00963631272315979, 0.034762024879455566, 0.01576896756887436, -0.013684501871466637, 0.004273852799087763, 0.025906534865498543, -0.01175137422978878, 0.03624510020017624, -0.04691329598426819, 0.02573435939848423, -0.03078886866569519, -0.0346897654235363, 0.0119235934689641, -0.02516341023147106, 0.016834933310747147, -0.0014219548320397735, 0.015052308328449726, -0.012090351432561874, -0.027214450761675835, -0.018718047067523003, 0.006851448677480221, -0.008548573590815067, 0.04153183102607727, -0.009926756843924522, 0.05539307743310928, 0.0018636641325429082, -0.005557534284889698, -0.0859723836183548, -0.05469252169132233, 0.02369317039847374, 0.012568328529596329, -0.030244389548897743, 0.0025044954381883144, -0.01918072998523712, -0.01204407587647438, -0.04335730895400047, -0.005657757632434368, 0.06089555844664574, -0.008751519955694675, 0.0002933188807219267, -0.06816604733467102, 0.017961153760552406, 0.06572749465703964, 0.006677545607089996, -0.02019801177084446, 0.007149758283048868, -0.020640714094042778, -0.0017008789582177997, -0.023263221606612206, 0.014735265634953976, -0.03124338574707508, -0.009414460510015488, -0.02758067660033703, 0.047679487615823746, 0.06035846099257469, 0.0012131347320973873, -0.03658883273601532, -0.027266066521406174, -0.010575325228273869, 0.05238625034689903, 0.008019592612981796, 0.007894388400018215, -0.026617655530571938, 0.003821437945589423, -0.005134013015776873, 0.0022221973631531, -0.003344221506267786, 0.011103499680757523, -0.012141253799200058, -0.010979266837239265, -0.04043610021471977, 0.01961103267967701, 0.067510224878788, 0.03523367643356323, 0.013933378271758556, 0.0026092627085745335, -0.01705355942249298, 0.024341044947504997, -0.012118722312152386, -0.05632975697517395, 0.014487840235233307, 0.06834918260574341, -0.040326058864593506, -0.06206918880343437, -0.022333303466439247, 0.017086392268538475, 0.0517730750143528, -0.026823293417692184, 0.0380425862967968, 0.0641157329082489, -0.01805790327489376, -0.005170930176973343, -0.028522314503788948, -0.04132748022675514, -0.03043905273079872, 0.022687438875436783, 0.054760199040174484, -0.002210297854617238, -0.004339694511145353, 0.03700076416134834, 0.009572281502187252, -0.013880541548132896, 0.036952000111341476, 0.04408403858542442, 0.017467986792325974, 0.020821746438741684, -0.030086703598499298, -0.0780395120382309, 0.03958575055003166, -0.06090435013175011, 0.007745315320789814, -0.01942618191242218, -0.026286374777555466, 0.034888748079538345, 0.04205746948719025, 0.03873724490404129, -0.016432346776127815, -0.006266346666961908, -0.046561311930418015, 0.019222913309931755, -0.0025865943171083927, -0.008718361146748066, 0.04254341125488281, -0.04323003813624382, 0.038246750831604004, -0.012035460211336613, 0.021150847896933556, -0.02709117904305458, -0.06575622409582138, -0.002816162072122097, -0.03284287452697754, -0.04158378764986992, 0.010074721649289131, -0.011118846945464611, -0.017624666914343834, 0.02835911698639393, -0.06457991153001785, -0.05361974984407425, -0.01466816384345293, 0.033081334084272385, 0.018848489969968796, 0.05918678268790245, 0.01020613219588995, 0.010717169381678104, -0.007709167432039976, 0.0012088181683793664, 0.14544548094272614, 0.08596773445606232, 0.023835958912968636, -0.03864997252821922, 0.038337141275405884, 0.014244583435356617, 0.007591754198074341, 0.004274907987564802, -0.005374699365347624, 0.010925531387329102, -0.02038607932627201, 0.029880208894610405, 0.05339614674448967, 0.030357154086232185, 0.02269568294286728, 0.07584333419799805, -0.020716220140457153, -0.015431013889610767, 0.002551108133047819, 0.00027398651582188904, 0.009951416403055191, -0.03938452526926994, -0.03232559934258461, 0.02215508744120598, 0.021268485113978386, -0.043160345405340195, -0.002791875507682562, -0.025262411683797836, -0.027503425255417824, -0.022765010595321655, -0.03142940625548363, -0.017330391332507133, 0.027920514345169067, 0.01689440757036209, -0.026609506458044052, -0.015434587374329567, 0.0031338934786617756, -0.06565412133932114, -0.01108916662633419, 0.023460526019334793, -0.06259722262620926, -0.008546866476535797, 0.014774076640605927, 0.016665754839777946, -0.0634632557630539, -0.02659653127193451, -0.05812378227710724, -0.009441377595067024, 0.01928781159222126, -0.0366484597325325, -0.03205262869596481, 0.005233693867921829, -0.01154382899403572, -0.05139140412211418, -0.054438188672065735, 0.02721988782286644, 0.03238353133201599, -0.01863035187125206, -0.03546283394098282, -0.005378228146582842, -0.010995611548423767, 0.004286994691938162, 0.04210609942674637, 0.05261116847395897, -0.022525204345583916, -0.024072622880339622, -0.014852591790258884, 0.021777121350169182, 0.024750998243689537, 0.029319172725081444, 0.019581107422709465, -0.027525201439857483, -0.03696611523628235, -0.0018275644397363067, 0.008348342962563038, 0.037369951605796814, 0.03265335410833359, -0.01980373077094555, -0.02139444649219513, -0.015021855011582375, 0.027912158519029617, -0.019702360033988953, -0.031110994517803192, -0.023482928052544594, -0.03442062437534332, 0.002491649007424712, -0.01020351517945528, -0.010721445083618164, -0.0008860822999849916, 0.012389720417559147, 0.0005529640475288033, 0.05547202751040459, 0.0036221786867827177, -0.027535293251276016, 0.0032751071266829967, 0.002775541739538312, -0.03514636680483818, 0.004268622025847435, 0.012048028409481049, 0.07337041199207306, -0.01111334003508091, 0.0031486472580581903, -0.005020458716899157, 0.014388487674295902, -0.0059092543087899685, 0.03663112223148346, 0.03944190964102745, -0.04899725690484047, 0.000535186321940273, 0.03549230471253395, 0.026917332783341408, -0.00915239006280899, -0.01739729568362236, -0.016506223008036613, -0.016770698130130768, 0.029352545738220215, -0.0333329401910305, -0.022020772099494934, 0.049476079642772675, -0.008961262181401253, 0.0031842957250773907, -0.015722768381237984, -0.010128689929842949, -0.03469936177134514, -0.007867851294577122, -0.01118258386850357, -0.0032394989393651485, 0.03393623232841492, 0.02500648982822895, -0.008335153572261333, -0.0023149929475039244, 0.04585397616028786, 0.02456628531217575, -0.015499763190746307, -0.004426982253789902, 0.00941390823572874, 0.006691912654787302, 0.0645236074924469, -0.00462293392047286, -0.031127437949180603, 0.014096660539507866, -0.012544081546366215, -0.038571249693632126, 0.0357307530939579, -0.020025528967380524, 0.030420929193496704, 0.03403742238879204, 0.008501937612891197, -0.0049092150293290615, 0.04294080287218094, -0.01320501510053873, 0.022999856621026993, -0.022445684298872948, 0.015697337687015533, 0.016065364703536034, 0.002279032953083515, -0.03405508026480675, 0.010137086734175682, -0.010742218233644962, 0.007135951891541481, 0.03924066945910454, -0.005076534580439329, -0.017867667600512505, -0.017133237794041634, -0.011116541922092438, -0.008942930027842522, -0.01673918589949608, 0.004618154838681221, 0.027509599924087524, 0.04677118733525276, -0.039788007736206055, 0.06483962386846542, 0.02390458434820175, -0.017980027943849564, -0.06907203793525696, -0.03290414810180664, -0.016788560897111893, 0.03862758353352547, 0.04661715030670166, -0.04472924396395683, 0.017119968309998512, 0.0031425715424120426, -0.03257586807012558, 0.015616529621183872, -0.004237316083163023, 0.030985046178102493, -0.003339793300256133, 0.004820909351110458, -0.020848844200372696, 0.0012434386881068349, 0.001890765386633575, 0.02794690430164337, 0.016613559797406197, 0.049630530178546906, -0.00006238598143681884, -0.014097069390118122, 0.012014119885861874, 0.029987715184688568, 0.018018050119280815, -0.04094237834215164, 0.049185529351234436, -0.0553690530359745, -0.02864067070186138, 0.07359863817691803, -0.013700122013688087, 0.03886262699961662, 0.02538072131574154, 0.03163331001996994, 0.0024635992012917995, 0.0551404170691967, 0.039593152701854706, -0.004706940613687038, -0.03489857539534569, -0.0026654002722352743, 0.02774556167423725, 0.018894454464316368, 0.002032736549153924, 0.0037917422596365213, 0.069198839366436, -0.022928548976778984, -0.008415165357291698, 0.00896408874541521, 0.0029513270128518343, 0.007555459160357714, 0.010854714550077915, -0.04443097114562988, 0.021227266639471054, -0.04521274194121361, 0.02746947854757309, -0.016786275431513786, -0.002603453816846013, 0.034022483974695206, 0.0047411611303687096, 0.0010970535222440958, -0.00805707834661007, -0.03422416374087334, -0.03020375408232212, 0.00426652655005455, 0.00820742454379797, 0.012928446754813194, -0.01957407407462597, -0.018778346478939056, -0.00950275082141161, -0.024528218433260918, -0.046202175319194794, -0.01194631028920412, -0.03461907058954239, 0.027163274586200714, -0.04213593900203705, -0.026739520952105522, 0.04298833757638931, 0.000774531508795917, 0.0034207566641271114, -0.07395577430725098, 0.0628034919500351, 0.02388755790889263, 0.006994433235377073, -0.004725772887468338, 0.023116815835237503, -0.013540663756430149, -0.008118094876408577, 0.07571157068014145, -0.013972210697829723, -0.011343469843268394, -0.00036236995947547257, 0.015241596847772598, -0.012461944483220577, -0.005158499348908663, 0.04430241510272026, 0.016521170735359192, -0.0013535196194425225, -0.01614249497652054, 0.007232389412820339, -0.023424319922924042, -0.02744513377547264, 0.011053860187530518, -0.016612209379673004, 0.01820712350308895, 0.03487075865268707, -0.021662691608071327, 0.028889143839478493, 0.02621784247457981, -0.02611798606812954, 0.035128407180309296, -0.021747440099716187, 0.026115205138921738, 0.02465258538722992, 0.00248407619073987, -0.04635397344827652, 0.02317044883966446, -0.008505742996931076, -0.019260834902524948, -0.024729454889893532, 0.005079901777207851, 0.001680916640907526, -0.058472830802202225, 0.02008354850113392, 0.016357246786355972, -0.01937142387032509, -0.0012591932900249958, 0.030076714232563972, 0.022239865735173225, 0.04656555876135826, -0.016419172286987305, 0.007174481172114611, -0.03394011780619621, -0.07023730874061584, 0.023418597877025604, -0.002213884610682726, 0.029563987627625465, 0.027857061475515366, -0.0046224649995565414, 0.045150186866521835, -0.0003091979306191206, 0.054424919188022614, 0.008508036844432354, 0.03263767063617706, -0.013041437603533268, -0.04125507175922394, 0.01919431798160076, 0.02495056390762329, 0.011551644653081894, 0.00857910793274641, -0.01785920560359955, 0.026161223649978638, -0.020281577482819557, -0.0028967116959393024, -0.053134191781282425, -0.037969544529914856, -0.08062521368265152, -0.014248467050492764, 0.021500173956155777, 0.027284229174256325, 0.007658469025045633, -0.0005735890590585768, -0.0013905373634770513, -0.027110900729894638, 0.02465088479220867, 0.0025130806025117636, 0.008703520521521568, 0.008457716554403305, -0.02676968090236187, -0.018695903941988945, -0.01614995300769806, -0.007598890457302332, -0.018941303715109825, 0.03318021446466446, 0.02275526523590088, 0.012304991483688354, 0.010327733121812344, -0.019344346597790718, 0.028684120625257492, 0.06593313813209534, -0.036590877920389175, -0.026559077203273773, -0.05707470327615738, -0.012192905880510807, 0.010109457187354565, -0.0391140952706337 ]
<p>I have two time-series:</p> <ol> <li>A proxy for the market risk premium (ERP; red line)</li> <li>The risk-free rate, proxied by a government bond (blue line)</li> </ol> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/evTDC.png" alt="Risk premium proxy and risk-free rate over time"></p> <p>I want to test if the risk-free rate can explain the ERP. Hereby, I basically followed the advice of Tsay (2010, 3rd edition, p. 96): Financial Time Series:</p> <ol> <li>Fit the linear regression model and check serial correlations of the residuals.</li> <li>If the residual series is unit-root nonstationarity, take the first difference of both the dependent and explanatory variables.</li> </ol> <p>Doing the first step, I get the following results:</p> <pre><code>Coefficients: Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(&gt;|t|) (Intercept) 6.77019 0.25103 26.97 &lt;2e-16 *** Risk_Free_Rate -0.65320 0.04123 -15.84 &lt;2e-16 *** --- Signif. codes: 0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1 </code></pre> <p>As expected from the figure, the relation is negative and significant. However, the residuals are serially correlated:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/GfdWn.png" alt="ACF function of the residuals of the regression of risk-free rate on ERP"></p> <p>Therefore, I first difference both the dependent and explanatory variable. Here is what I get:</p> <pre><code>Coefficients: Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(&gt;|t|) (Intercept) -0.002077 0.016497 -0.126 0.9 Risk_Free_Rate -0.958267 0.053731 -17.834 &lt;2e-16 *** --- Signif. codes: 0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1 </code></pre> <p>And the ACF of the residuals looks like:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/J25Gn.png" alt="ACF function of the residuals of the regression of risk-free rate on ERP (differenced)"></p> <p>This result looks great: First, the residuals are now uncorrelated. Second, the relation seems to be more negative now. </p> <p>Here are my questions (you probably wondered by now ;-) The first regression, I would have interpreted as (econometric problems aside) "if the riskfree rate rises by one percentage point, the ERP falls by 0.65 percentage points." Actually, after pondering about this for a while, I would interpret the second regression just the same (now resulting in a 0.96 percentage points fall though). Is this interpretation correct? It just feels weird that I transform my variables, but don't have to change my interpretation. If this, however, is correct, why do the results change? Is this just the result of econometric problems? If so, does anyone have an idea why my second regression seems to be even "better"? Normally, I always read that you can have spurious correlations that vanish after you do it correctly. Here, it seems the other way round.</p>
47,851
[ 0.009560310281813145, 0.012159419246017933, 0.01067260466516018, 0.01561563741415739, 0.029322752729058266, -0.01457265391945839, -0.013377141207456589, -0.015369000844657421, 0.028379444032907486, -0.054964762181043625, 0.03888469189405441, 0.01489243470132351, 0.03642098233103752, 0.02849050611257553, 0.011347342282533646, -0.011356847360730171, -0.000052653540478786454, 0.025069894269108772, 0.03455956652760506, -0.023709578439593315, -0.0005175502155907452, 0.03297228738665581, 0.013767226599156857, 0.021758902817964554, 0.005807944107800722, 0.0341513454914093, 0.012723470106720924, -0.01882661134004593, -0.012437035329639912, 0.08087284862995148, -0.0013928466942161322, -0.019754840061068535, -0.03079739585518837, 0.013805236667394638, -0.013977044261991978, 0.034987304359674454, -0.013540921732783318, -0.0017550750635564327, 0.01575276255607605, 0.02231571450829506, 0.019254134967923164, -0.005627528298646212, 0.015637565404176712, 0.03387408331036568, 0.011732161045074463, -0.0015743945259600878, 0.009722467511892319, -0.010052761062979698, 0.023853031918406487, 0.006685917265713215, 0.026565132662653923, -0.0234941728413105, 0.021177988499403, 0.02879180572926998, -0.04467723146080971, -0.05689715966582298, 0.026676969602704048, 0.07707054167985916, -0.01911582425236702, -0.04726419225335121, -0.018000392243266106, -0.00453835679218173, 0.007004963234066963, -0.034881334751844406, -0.03438849002122879, 0.0078616077080369, -0.007074921857565641, -0.021863073110580444, 0.02075488492846489, -0.03753471374511719, 0.015995066612958908, 0.001906599965877831, 0.017525438219308853, 0.006692832335829735, -0.017212186008691788, -0.01977851241827011, -0.003254442708566785, 0.029493842273950577, 0.02327553741633892, 0.0432889461517334, 0.005009419284760952, 0.009360217489302158, 0.029759252443909645, 0.008339710533618927, 0.039802469313144684, 0.010776983574032784, 0.06191005930304527, -0.013920418918132782, 0.031489886343479156, 0.03459915891289711, -0.02503911405801773, -0.003429910633713007, 0.048095207661390305, 0.02963438257575035, -0.0516161248087883, 0.007866844534873962, -0.023737866431474686, 0.03290196880698204, 0.0002622968459036201, -0.004316924139857292, -0.03279890865087509, -0.042778514325618744, -0.027692744508385658, 0.020542504265904427, -0.006304518785327673, 0.0010947525734081864, 0.01643492840230465, -0.01849137619137764, -0.01373064424842596, -0.0522993840277195, -0.04421329125761986, 0.0025671864859759808, -0.013220585882663727, -0.04522944986820221, 0.011749932542443275, -0.02002108469605446, -0.004352669697254896, -0.018311958760023117, 0.065754733979702, 0.03573029115796089, 0.028750400990247726, -0.00679816585034132, -0.0010305691976100206, -0.009657120332121849, -0.029457533732056618, 0.009921420365571976, 0.02133205719292164, -0.02541983872652054, -0.027226563543081284, 0.04195895045995712, 0.013509293086826801, -0.061870377510786057, -0.0010430078255012631, 0.031465452164411545, 0.048254210501909256, 0.02229117974638939, -0.06992458552122116, -0.027691252529621124, 0.05668328329920769, -0.002994457958266139, 0.009040097706019878, -0.05940663442015648, -0.04022093489766121, 0.03358938917517662, 0.07320476323366165, -0.012624950148165226, 0.05890098959207535, 0.0277264304459095, 0.023673444986343384, 0.036616742610931396, -0.050962671637535095, 0.014995953068137169, -0.020038455724716187, -0.0037246597930788994, -0.028766905888915062, -0.05477523058652878, -0.012261020950973034, 0.01946655474603176, -0.06248646229505539, 0.019246434792876244, 0.04329093545675278, 0.031246982514858246, -0.024876508861780167, 0.0051210722886025906, -0.036727175116539, -0.06273974478244781, 0.05167229846119881, 0.010394164361059666, -0.034851688891649246, 0.014119967818260193, -0.015442481264472008, 0.024158548563718796, -0.0022976738400757313, 0.05069638416171074, -0.008486573584377766, -0.05151866003870964, 0.02690095454454422, -0.008289646357297897, -0.02304561249911785, -0.02515590749680996, -0.05934043973684311, -0.008448794484138489, -0.04633350670337677, -0.052795812487602234, 0.03181656822562218, 0.07234854251146317, -0.022598708048462868, -0.023254765197634697, 0.04604046046733856, -0.0710504949092865, -0.05153823643922806, -0.026166783645749092, 0.013979090377688408, -0.010034945793449879, -0.05531571805477142, 0.007438448257744312, -0.03718085587024689, 0.060774415731430054, 0.02124754898250103, 0.02211838774383068, -0.016850486397743225, 0.006222294177860022, 0.021754926070570946, -0.03381450101733208, 0.03458051383495331, 0.007066613528877497, 0.062495335936546326, 0.052689794450998306, 0.007983841001987457, -0.03773288428783417, -0.03182313218712807, 0.058302491903305054, -0.04438408091664314, 0.0076629179529845715, -0.010499756783246994, -0.026914993301033974, 0.010932836681604385, -0.014866495504975319, 0.01757517270743847, 0.015570473857223988, -0.05020032823085785, 0.002263808622956276, 0.05419296771287918, 0.009661412797868252, -0.019892122596502304, -0.024761131033301353, 0.016980979591608047, 0.034060318022966385, -0.07519220560789108, 0.020224517211318016, -0.0439634844660759, -0.04303640127182007, 0.05971715599298477, 0.08725161105394363, -0.017785316333174706, -0.0024866226594895124, 0.07628782838582993, -0.012954018078744411, -0.02198365330696106, 0.05842003598809242, 0.002160279545933008, -0.046295493841171265, 0.019757358357310295, 0.007070550695061684, 0.000573894300032407, 0.026262817904353142, 0.04094099625945091, -0.006201193202286959, 0.05425228178501129, -0.023731078952550888, -0.016638517379760742, 0.052503347396850586, -0.011154863983392715, 0.018314894288778305, 0.02323378250002861, -0.02194182202219963, 0.04287181794643402, -0.006107420660555363, -0.018687086179852486, -0.0022586663253605366, 0.0021580024622380733, 0.01903458684682846, 0.021183764562010765, -0.031142540276050568, 0.011355898343026638, -0.00032542209373787045, -0.026854105293750763, -0.016134247183799744, 0.009912308305501938, -0.029406744986772537, -0.01644008420407772, -0.023903850466012955, -0.0026695874985307455, 0.00767221674323082, -0.01999957114458084, 0.03148617222905159, 0.020932605490088463, 0.005726960487663746, -0.029652608558535576, -0.0015790876932442188, 0.03203122317790985, -0.027835886925458908, 0.021718746051192284, -0.019651547074317932, -0.04116944596171379, 0.0018405530136078596, -0.001138016115874052, -0.001301391632296145, 0.020226318389177322, -0.010290496982634068, 0.00901957880705595, 0.020364342257380486, -0.009468997828662395, -0.0341588631272316, -0.02879168465733528, -0.06114877387881279, -0.02523111179471016, -0.05425650253891945, -0.023391753435134888, 0.05797002464532852, -0.018348703160881996, -0.029431700706481934, 0.002727038227021694, -0.0572630949318409, -0.004595556296408176, 0.002345217624679208, -0.025738613680005074, 0.002617723774164915, -0.027897050604224205, -0.019987909123301506, 0.010746247135102749, -0.014370092190802097, -0.007408230099827051, -0.06499610096216202, -0.029636595398187637, 0.018747476860880852, 0.035267461091279984, 0.003678872948512435, -0.049741439521312714, -0.048015695065259933, 0.03019857592880726, 0.030348321422934532, 0.0013519530184566975, -0.052985094487667084, -0.014630569145083427, -0.031398896127939224, -0.054508570581674576, 0.034542493522167206, 0.0378161296248436, -0.005633751396089792, 0.029742389917373657, -0.016641251742839813, 0.05230157822370529, 0.04597615450620651, 0.014443280175328255, 0.02060663141310215, 0.01894536241889, -0.01629338227212429, 0.0051276502199471, 0.06635770201683044, 0.019246617332100868, -0.004611514508724213, -0.009828826412558556, 0.02118983305990696, 0.0437479093670845, -0.0026317699812352657, -0.03511524945497513, 0.02572239190340042, -0.006279042921960354, 0.0037642011884599924, -0.04007677733898163, 0.023445188999176025, 0.003995636012405157, 0.008648849092423916, -0.048690538853406906, -0.04529377818107605, 0.00907591637223959, 0.0058017815463244915, 0.034846846014261246, 0.030257055535912514, 0.00866139680147171, 0.04074372351169586, -0.018688783049583435, -0.054975416511297226, -0.028615089133381844, 0.03710515424609184, -0.03170408308506012, -0.0034258230589330196, 0.032192252576351166, 0.024041779339313507, 0.019881194457411766, -0.05956627428531647, -0.04171207174658775, 0.017743241041898727, -0.03276972845196724, 0.02573537454009056, -0.012994027696549892, 0.04243406653404236, 0.015284685418009758, 0.031240710988640785, -0.03126091882586479, -0.01908910647034645, 0.0023733272682875395, 0.012570173479616642, -0.05246150121092796, 0.03573690354824066, 0.004808926023542881, -0.007060425356030464, 0.031403981149196625, -0.031155990436673164, 0.05151645094156265, -0.0713835060596466, 0.012084468267858028, 0.012333107180893421, 0.019897498190402985, -0.030656179413199425, 0.006419265177100897, -0.02486175112426281, -0.0033995809499174356, -0.02590075321495533, -0.016711918637156487, 0.012168968096375465, -0.019340571016073227, 0.01845197007060051, 0.0670480877161026, 0.029651720076799393, 0.0012525576166808605, -0.029843712225556374, -0.012708303518593311, 0.061948392540216446, 0.057807084172964096, 0.0532267801463604, -0.02372008189558983, -0.044231876730918884, 0.016020042821764946, 0.018998950719833374, 0.0027245308738201857, 0.032761819660663605, -0.0004904919769614935, -0.03855830430984497, -0.020964233204722404, -0.01955086551606655, -0.00007180519605753943, 0.01755557209253311, -0.0006260719383135438, -0.002524367766454816, 0.06537969410419464, 0.044991638511419296, 0.0017015987541526556, 0.01359223760664463, 0.06348332017660141, 0.020204361528158188, 0.029584018513560295, -0.022439615800976753, -0.06665053218603134, -0.017821744084358215, 0.01010556798428297, 0.03563346341252327, 0.008477671071887016, -0.0248552318662405, -0.0069334860891103745, 0.042251039296388626, -0.019102446734905243, -0.01232307218015194, -0.029669925570487976, 0.025141334161162376, 0.027039889246225357, 0.021674800664186478, -0.041943956166505814, 0.05591586232185364, -0.008342226035892963, 0.011736809276044369, 0.019944099709391594, 0.021124836057424545, -0.11568190902471542, 0.005498664453625679, 0.025363432243466377, 0.010320896282792091, -0.02887854352593422, -0.05437337979674339, -0.03220053389668465, -0.017373383045196533, 0.016884617507457733, -0.009292465634644032, 0.030520599335432053, 0.020329754799604416, 0.053655922412872314, -0.016239825636148453, -0.06513052433729172, -0.04545892775058746, 0.04289409890770912, -0.005804883316159248, 0.018315861001610756, -0.04389984905719757, -0.04835335910320282, -0.02257378213107586, -0.015502339228987694, -0.002574039390310645, 0.06757943332195282, -0.03352505713701248, 0.0015995224239304662, -0.0017026853747665882, 0.01828492246568203, -0.000026712035833043046, -0.06994756311178207, 0.019491076469421387, -0.016393860802054405, -0.014191771857440472, 0.027192743495106697, -0.011838894337415695, -0.05204136669635773, 0.0005364730022847652, 0.0027439226396381855, -0.02134283073246479, 0.009235956706106663, -0.025397462770342827, 0.03023993968963623, 0.00805019773542881, -0.01670892909169197, 0.06901568919420242, 0.03551590070128441, 0.013284681364893913, 0.01188653614372015, -0.03957800939679146, 0.006416656076908112, -0.014303833246231079, 0.009775049984455109, -0.0381796769797802, -0.006473887246102095, 0.008590697310864925, 0.023171529173851013, 0.011685109697282314, 0.009134196676313877, -0.06605014950037003, 0.021461471915245056, 0.003953972831368446, 0.03421417251229286, -0.035748619586229324, -0.0109729478135705, 0.02620338276028633, -0.00860451441258192, -0.05282505601644516, -0.008421087637543678, -0.022086864337325096, -0.019282987341284752, -0.019044222310185432, 0.0038218095432966948, -0.021951667964458466, -0.001194355427287519, 0.014746101573109627, -0.006400006823241711, -0.008824165910482407, -0.019138237461447716, 0.00014361088688019663, 0.0326087661087513, 0.031017260625958443, -0.04763178899884224, -0.020647656172513962, 0.00006333236524369568, 0.04737192019820213, 0.03815577179193497, 0.04192657768726349, -0.0009260695660486817, 0.006896651815623045, 0.021463492885231972, -0.05138405039906502, -0.05231888219714165, -0.04068295285105705, 0.02765723690390587, 0.021596262231469154, -0.05458842217922211, -0.01868448406457901, -0.015033937059342861, 0.00684451824054122, -0.013068605214357376, -0.003962347283959389, 0.04976680129766464, -0.02208097279071808, -0.04528673365712166, 0.00875431764870882, 0.015258466824889183, 0.060214102268218994, -0.0570184588432312, 0.004504501819610596, 0.00925118662416935, -0.039204295724630356, -0.03592538833618164, -0.034688208252191544, 0.019637782126665115, -0.025220729410648346, -0.019673332571983337, -0.03734678402543068, -0.00935632735490799, 0.04369733855128288, -0.01815536431968212, -0.02353762276470661, 0.019149355590343475, -0.007928996346890926, 0.022038089111447334, -0.015042508020997047, 0.01494502555578947, 0.018077919259667397, 0.04361097514629364, 0.02803502231836319, -0.02275061421096325, -0.025415511801838875, -0.02637302502989769, 0.020172767341136932, 0.002886549336835742, -0.03341259807348251, 0.02075546607375145, 0.04628225415945053, -0.0034514095168560743, -0.02833033725619316, -0.02484976314008236, 0.014800134114921093, 0.05780457332730293, -0.017124837264418602, 0.03349433094263077, 0.0015633654547855258, 0.008556075394153595, -0.07221896946430206, -0.03298327699303627, -0.021196730434894562, 0.006456680595874786, 0.06945117563009262, -0.001867006765678525, 0.02510540373623371, 0.011303599923849106, 0.0007077671471051872, 0.015023996122181416, -0.06531814485788345, -0.013038801029324532, 0.02421312779188156, 0.013378492556512356, 0.03368186578154564, -0.06435397267341614, -0.0037106741219758987, 0.03421211987733841, 0.018709493800997734, 0.011545399203896523, 0.033130161464214325, 0.017454104498028755, -0.028922688215970993, 0.00467393035069108, -0.028317822143435478, -0.006106786895543337, 0.016659360378980637, -0.020624782890081406, 0.04411780834197998, -0.044449176639318466, 0.004553721286356449, 0.01935318298637867, 0.06825899332761765, -0.0038657363038510084, -0.04552222415804863, -0.04092651978135109, -0.0769919902086258, -0.00039992001256905496, 0.01231005135923624, 0.0009947576327249408, 0.05881287157535553, 0.030332393944263458, 0.0306877288967371, -0.00411751726642251, 0.06330139935016632, -0.04428402706980705, -0.07795783877372742, 0.014244983904063702, -0.019660567864775658, 0.00797670055180788, 0.090532086789608, 0.007697771769016981, -0.05205734074115753, 0.039414599537849426, -0.05785689875483513, 0.020163899287581444, 0.02228081226348877, 0.024564189836382866, 0.010388344526290894, 0.08644892275333405, -0.01328845415264368, 0.016665304079651833, -0.016275838017463684, -0.014033772051334381, 0.16083893179893494, 0.06249377131462097, 0.01035977527499199, -0.040272314101457596, 0.015098544768989086, -0.007003666367381811, 0.024657726287841797, -0.01754371076822281, 0.003332496387884021, 0.009180857799947262, -0.030712030827999115, 0.03695463016629219, 0.0502193309366703, 0.0014001643285155296, -0.05821341648697853, 0.022941602393984795, -0.02369368076324463, 0.02670194022357464, -0.020320093259215355, 0.045521967113018036, 0.03204192966222763, -0.010340328328311443, -0.019902920350432396, -0.025199919939041138, -0.01661759614944458, 0.005798263940960169, -0.040549978613853455, -0.013432948850095272, -0.024541135877370834, -0.022582922130823135, -0.016878295689821243, -0.024875391274690628, 0.023909345269203186, 0.030622871592640877, -0.01141340471804142, -0.010652252472937107, 0.02651592344045639, -0.029166771098971367, 0.039969395846128464, 0.01723323203623295, -0.028323490172624588, -0.03344874829053879, 0.04237429052591324, -0.0065625994466245174, -0.05929096043109894, -0.014478569850325584, -0.02882121503353119, 0.05248042568564415, -0.012231521308422089, -0.04990522563457489, -0.03860275819897652, -0.016916770488023758, 0.005484095774590969, -0.019407792016863823, -0.029826872050762177, 0.028951693326234818, -0.020450416952371597, -0.039628203958272934, 0.015965383499860764, -0.029973868280649185, -0.012392785400152206, 0.0015662513906136155, 0.03270621970295906, 0.026990734040737152, -0.016186708584427834, -0.011162102222442627, -0.03507937863469124, 0.028546830639243126, -0.03010431118309498, 0.004529816098511219, 0.033684514462947845, -0.002162687946110964, -0.016802622005343437, -0.012284508906304836, 0.028372474014759064, 0.0150181008502841, 0.018092531710863113, 0.02799662947654724, -0.005087010562419891, -0.010181708261370659, -0.03079308196902275, 0.07632506638765335, -0.021146493032574654, -0.003431819612160325, -0.05763886123895645, 0.012953643687069416, 0.022951528429985046, -0.0002720481716096401, 0.027269387617707253, 0.022818610072135925, -0.01056381594389677, 0.08486812561750412, 0.028645778074860573, -0.067379429936409, -0.026182405650615692, -0.02831723727285862, 0.009969381615519524, -0.02558504045009613, -0.03168193995952606, 0.024279098957777023, 0.04150744900107384, 0.05292099714279175, -0.03444698452949524, 0.005892277229577303, -0.03401714190840721, 0.0015841997228562832, 0.04142943397164345, -0.01661091111600399, 0.0007938719354569912, 0.037989020347595215, 0.006607023533433676, -0.0051866862922906876, 0.045192819088697433, 0.004091754090040922, -0.013412165455520153, -0.00775851821526885, 0.016513032838702202, -0.03716332092881203, 0.01673322543501854, -0.008543089032173157, 0.04046960175037384, -0.03444850817322731, -0.01109110377728939, -0.02800428308546543, 0.014425828121602535, 0.003967850003391504, -0.030207615345716476, -0.05575314536690712, 0.039621029049158096, -0.011708320118486881, -0.023675400763750076, 0.026187704876065254, 0.02314596436917782, 0.031361229717731476, -0.013110523112118244, 0.04954452067613602, -0.012913130223751068, 0.03328237310051918, -0.01771678775548935, -0.04084888473153114, -0.008127626962959766, -0.008129843510687351, -0.010089489631354809, 0.01591743901371956, 0.030405202880501747, 0.04521491378545761, -0.010587966069579124, 0.015355152077972889, -0.01010829582810402, 0.05219699442386627, -0.0492667630314827, -0.00600849324837327, -0.0003514435957185924, 0.005640598479658365, 0.03317710757255554, -0.029414266347885132, 0.024274203926324844, 0.00936568807810545, 0.014389609917998314, -0.00518729817122221, 0.026804812252521515, -0.0346064567565918, 0.004713551606982946, 0.05653982236981392, -0.03183113411068916, -0.007006630301475525, 0.014884525910019875, 0.013659980148077011, 0.012205688282847404, 0.04086526855826378, 0.01581704616546631, 0.017864054068922997, -0.020667433738708496, 0.03523600473999977, -0.04642419517040253, 0.008486205711960793, 0.0007449874537996948, 0.02319641038775444, 0.04841616749763489, -0.0015161007177084684, -0.011569817550480366, 0.010293002240359783, -0.015573274344205856, 0.00274087255820632, 0.005617527291178703, -0.012913625687360764, -0.03113603964447975, -0.020794473588466644, -0.026417838409543037, 0.03415874391794205, 0.050950150936841965, 0.021690916270017624, 0.033411066979169846, 0.05806704983115196, 0.010770455934107304, -0.00883450172841549, -0.035910800099372864, -0.019226431846618652, 0.035962752997875214, -0.045699018985033035, 0.028837714344263077, -0.018286067992448807, 0.016820434480905533, 0.044640108942985535, -0.024221565574407578, 0.026898643001914024, -0.00270401150919497, 0.01670723222196102, -0.013917364180088043, 0.020123016089200974, 0.011431775987148285, 0.001572976354509592, -0.010573922656476498, -0.035717304795980453, 0.02545539103448391, 0.004967616405338049, -0.022859085351228714, 0.026924481615424156, 0.00036347770947031677, -0.0048782965168356895, -0.009043731726706028, 0.016885995864868164, -0.01265361625701189, 0.013335048221051693, 0.011606686748564243, -0.009229084476828575, 0.01704411208629608, -0.00838031992316246, 0.023862890899181366, -0.00656194519251585, -0.014653709717094898, 0.06383170187473297, 0.04862118884921074, -0.04642355814576149, -0.034887801855802536, -0.021130703389644623, -0.06962171941995621, 0.01947942189872265, -0.0045435079373419285, -0.00651810597628355, -0.023087384179234505, -0.0428520068526268, -0.019585736095905304, -0.011924201622605324, -0.033092401921749115, 0.012720038183033466, 0.00754588982090354, 0.03943493589758873, -0.015781326219439507, 0.016995485872030258, 0.014021226204931736, -0.013727761805057526, 0.020697804167866707, -0.08069346100091934, 0.032794076949357986, -0.017763469368219376, -0.0347771979868412, -0.008924748748540878, -0.03657424449920654, -0.06708300858736038, 0.019634826108813286, 0.06485243886709213, -0.028588373214006424, 0.028418345376849174, -0.012561860494315624, 0.038178909569978714, 0.009630534797906876, -0.025856172665953636, 0.03340204805135727, -0.006077927071601152, -0.005836402997374535, 0.026582680642604828, 0.003760576480999589, 0.015324835665524006, 0.053519077599048615, 0.033101726323366165, -0.006507201585918665, -0.0038092657923698425, 0.013875079341232777, -0.015339676290750504, 0.03708941489458084, -0.0065803551115095615, -0.043774038553237915, 0.03723268583416939, 0.008449338376522064, -0.007050775457173586, 0.017871025949716568, -0.010162340477108955, -0.06253959983587265, 0.020932812243700027, -0.004380058962851763, -0.013514047488570213, 0.02766341343522072, 0.014045944437384605, -0.00837282557040453, -0.04534095898270607, 0.023760810494422913, 0.02781705930829048, -0.022931000217795372, -0.02242560312151909, 0.0135604003444314, 0.017287543043494225, -0.007297804579138756, 0.003355585038661957, 0.027206161990761757, 0.02454231306910515, 0.0026657627895474434, 0.03810945525765419, -0.0024288787972182035, 0.03189883753657341, -0.010171894915401936, 0.00836257915943861, 0.03393511101603508, 0.004268310964107513, 0.002401411999017, -0.031949903815984726, -0.0004987918073311448, -0.02110213041305542, -0.02838624268770218, 0.04926444590091705, 0.03876146674156189, 0.0030295976903289557, 0.0010744464816525578, -0.011499304324388504, 0.04802362248301506, -0.035812098532915115, 0.014794832095503807, 0.03485278785228729, 0.04553399607539177, -0.018522925674915314, 0.019660349935293198, 0.026984531432390213, -0.017100553959608078, 0.002131924033164978, -0.02271036058664322, 0.030435997992753983, -0.020800406113266945, -0.02583622746169567, -0.033671144396066666, -0.009898006916046143, 0.02065904252231121, -0.027370432391762733, -0.007880566641688347, -0.034192848950624466, -0.03168616071343422, -0.03921442851424217, 0.04256650060415268, 0.04219944775104523, -0.0033727181144058704, -0.03240808844566345, -0.029764825478196144, 0.027713662013411522, 0.06911413371562958, -0.056463658809661865, -0.0018905046163126826, -0.004542367532849312, 0.008110621944069862, 0.013749999925494194, 0.034095097333192825 ]
<p>I did a one-way ANOVA followed by a Tukey's test to compare the means of different treatments.</p> <p>Let's say the treatments are A, B and C.</p> <p>The table of multiple comparisons tells me there is a significant difference between B and C. However, these two are not significantly different from A, and therefore there are in the same subset when we order the results. </p> <p>Can I say there is a significant difference between B and C, or is that not possible?</p>
3,017
[ -0.03945089504122734, 0.03958645090460777, -0.03933139145374298, -0.008985086344182491, 0.05580035224556923, 0.03623240068554878, 0.0068757496774196625, 0.0014334942679852247, -0.005788838490843773, -0.019613593816757202, 0.05051892623305321, 0.015638230368494987, 0.042672812938690186, 0.014474499970674515, -0.004134016577154398, -0.02901039645075798, 0.014791062101721764, 0.007197512313723564, 0.021732188761234283, 0.02746591717004776, -0.03566795587539673, 0.014730449765920639, -0.0069522918201982975, -0.005497200880199671, -0.02346615679562092, 0.0362243726849556, 0.02951410971581936, -0.006734172347933054, 0.014265885576605797, 0.048577677458524704, -0.05210847407579422, -0.03341652452945709, -0.010343194007873535, 0.0028773131780326366, 0.04390838369727135, -0.009511939249932766, -0.033471789211034775, 0.007685376331210136, 0.02194376103579998, 0.006679836194962263, -0.019166892394423485, -0.036654576659202576, -0.016365665942430496, 0.033157020807266235, -0.0006766248843632638, 0.02649056352674961, -0.010240726172924042, -0.030555548146367073, 0.03468124568462372, -0.03442365303635597, 0.030561013147234917, -0.02334768697619438, 0.03261374309659004, 0.026475410908460617, -0.02088305354118347, -0.0037169994320720434, 0.035931892693042755, 0.04400598630309105, 0.013456396758556366, -0.0671602189540863, 0.01566329225897789, -0.008519953116774559, 0.03304619714617729, 0.014577903784811497, -0.03615609556436539, 0.014529915526509285, -0.020738190039992332, -0.01764105260372162, 0.031605519354343414, -0.003909678664058447, 0.005111812148243189, -0.02117953449487686, 0.02007172629237175, -0.01726522296667099, -0.017638616263866425, -0.024138515815138817, 0.00963039044290781, -0.0002844418922904879, 0.05310507491230965, 0.026273787021636963, -0.0021637664176523685, 0.028134457767009735, 0.0036521474830806255, 0.027792299166321754, 0.04070774465799332, -0.018265873193740845, 0.044481489807367325, -0.045141953974962234, -0.016134824603796005, 0.024208417162299156, -0.006626402959227562, -0.015324709005653858, 0.06738868355751038, 0.017396895214915276, -0.0015669440617784858, -0.014420933090150356, -0.033389803022146225, 0.009381105192005634, -0.015179995447397232, -0.0043847039341926575, -0.020783284679055214, -0.047517407685518265, 0.05573683977127075, 0.04612689092755318, -0.019000301137566566, 0.018859615549445152, -0.0394010990858078, 0.022894835099577904, -0.011835434474050999, 0.007738430518656969, -0.020515194162726402, 0.02167355641722679, 0.013316490687429905, 0.02640637569129467, 0.0119789382442832, -0.012060916982591152, -0.019215472042560577, -0.007996659725904465, 0.07264005392789841, 0.04896581918001175, 0.07338209450244904, -0.03475959971547127, 0.004171243868768215, -0.014794550836086273, -0.03198423236608505, 0.008242998272180557, 0.011533648706972599, -0.012785715982317924, -0.057363759726285934, 0.06674742698669434, -0.015658516436815262, 0.029031893238425255, 0.018790654838085175, -0.011664957739412785, 0.028516456484794617, 0.006367579568177462, -0.11649865657091141, -0.07819551974534988, 0.04119987413287163, -0.0062254006043076515, -0.03450038284063339, -0.05287381634116173, 0.004270370118319988, 0.033975329250097275, 0.03852736949920654, 0.01503080129623413, 0.004855913110077381, 0.008709331043064594, 0.013208184391260147, 0.030578473582863808, 0.01952015608549118, 0.008443539962172508, -0.010410982184112072, -0.039228372275829315, 0.00424688495695591, -0.0977507084608078, 0.03587669879198074, 0.017583565786480904, 0.04224023595452309, -0.0005344520322978497, 0.009392723441123962, -0.010693657211959362, -0.023944884538650513, 0.0019811498932540417, 0.01738874614238739, 0.03233974426984787, 0.06415484100580215, -0.01859334483742714, 0.03536384180188179, 0.0058779302053153515, -0.015864280983805656, 0.010968752205371857, -0.02826865389943123, 0.03464927896857262, 0.025776196271181107, -0.001072918763384223, -0.020874330773949623, -0.014719915576279163, 0.026372725144028664, -0.003233501920476556, -0.04838496446609497, -0.007432712707668543, -0.045861516147851944, 0.019099075347185135, 0.03135025128722191, 0.031153107061982155, -0.0055573866702616215, -0.0066338493488729, 0.022737935185432434, -0.028970306739211082, -0.0379992350935936, -0.06580492854118347, -0.02906111814081669, 0.010514702647924423, -0.040097568184137344, 0.023578353226184845, 0.020150387659668922, 0.009484831243753433, -0.01907077617943287, 0.011216931976377964, 0.0034872766118496656, -0.015704896301031113, 0.03492659330368042, -0.02352115884423256, 0.015479868277907372, 0.040102265775203705, 0.07544752210378647, -0.027238091453909874, 0.05126770958304405, -0.030272647738456726, -0.018944352865219116, 0.023016780614852905, -0.023646589368581772, -0.009962259791791439, 0.0034261897671967745, -0.011752798222005367, 0.017367038875818253, 0.032506030052900314, -0.02857421338558197, 0.0586874857544899, -0.053329143673181534, 0.08739301562309265, 0.025852100923657417, -0.028243642300367355, 0.0030873045325279236, 0.0009907016064971685, 0.013974146917462349, 0.002445544581860304, -0.03411091864109039, -0.026055876165628433, -0.05373707413673401, -0.03929879143834114, 0.043072059750556946, -0.019455986097455025, -0.02919606678187847, 0.03788917884230614, 0.027573563158512115, 0.0253568384796381, 0.017302557826042175, 0.011570362374186516, 0.008125759661197662, -0.033091019839048386, 0.02736317552626133, 0.017140349373221397, 0.0526127889752388, 0.015988096594810486, 0.0044591184705495834, -0.028768010437488556, 0.05624879151582718, 0.01813783496618271, 0.040628012269735336, 0.03244897350668907, 0.024996589869260788, 0.006789537612348795, 0.012616594322025776, -0.01474735513329506, 0.026745779439806938, -0.019704438745975494, -0.001709289033897221, 0.014349933713674545, -0.0013231070479378104, -0.013087398372590542, 0.011345380917191505, -0.021782182157039642, 0.016753803938627243, 0.04831850528717041, -0.027832720428705215, 0.018140317872166634, 0.03030558116734028, -0.0184341873973608, -0.0014860526425763965, -0.042809974402189255, -0.04149310663342476, -0.013603338040411472, -0.01626289263367653, 0.023420589044690132, 0.00006628255505347624, 0.02771175093948841, -0.0489056296646595, 0.01054774597287178, -0.030867746099829674, -0.032296497374773026, 0.0022975606843829155, -0.03736541420221329, -0.05636030435562134, 0.02123279683291912, -0.017758602276444435, -0.0005785528919659555, 0.024116413667798042, -0.02647021785378456, -0.03161199018359184, 0.04359189420938492, 0.02151705138385296, -0.06136602535843849, -0.014044183306396008, -0.023408187553286552, 0.027789251878857613, -0.05661463364958763, -0.026922883465886116, 0.029947850853204727, 0.020511265844106674, -0.02949455939233303, 0.029724808409810066, -0.012820135802030563, -0.007165245711803436, 0.024880986660718918, -0.001598019851371646, 0.009584023617208004, -0.001377555658109486, 0.0016799333970993757, 0.013065237551927567, -0.012128585018217564, -0.01973644271492958, -0.056384313851594925, -0.04127047210931778, 0.032607320696115494, -0.013401062227785587, 0.05804773420095444, -0.026239484548568726, -0.03189193829894066, 0.08915732800960541, 0.024936117231845856, -0.03096151351928711, -0.013215848244726658, -0.01985153555870056, -0.018996288999915123, -0.013873981311917305, 0.05507756397128105, 0.017473330721259117, -0.0203650314360857, -0.0026567268650978804, 0.005570825655013323, 0.04434608295559883, 0.03434020280838013, 0.03394749015569687, -0.03138183429837227, 0.038934092968702316, 0.008711091242730618, -0.0036548017524182796, 0.035197462886571884, 0.025735415518283844, -0.034901212900877, 0.0033104820176959038, 0.016761934384703636, 0.020951436832547188, 0.017100265249609947, -0.028779732063412666, 0.07193925976753235, 0.0136140501126647, 0.004281865898519754, -0.05356299877166748, 0.01306534931063652, 0.03740732744336128, -0.014021550305187702, -0.015664516016840935, -0.027950584888458252, 0.008235570974647999, 0.004450613632798195, 0.006343222223222256, 0.046243928372859955, 0.053031936287879944, -0.041095759719610214, -0.0038168185856193304, -0.030914325267076492, -0.020368186756968498, -0.00980578176677227, -0.028952928259968758, -0.03550267219543457, 0.007075096946209669, 0.053686678409576416, -0.019798459485173225, -0.004722996614873409, -0.04234810918569565, -0.028895745053887367, -0.03899407014250755, 0.02457229606807232, -0.03514302149415016, 0.04591156169772148, 0.0036269831471145153, 0.045570868998765945, -0.003911109641194344, -0.01425488293170929, -0.025578778237104416, -0.006583173293620348, -0.041523631662130356, 0.019512822851538658, 0.0029387865215539932, -0.02576560713350773, -0.004011277575045824, -0.07264705747365952, 0.00565359415486455, -0.011405140161514282, 0.01828913949429989, -0.017334265634417534, 0.017580226063728333, -0.0005406411364674568, -0.005408535711467266, -0.012595822103321552, -0.009350369684398174, -0.006956270895898342, 0.033467188477516174, 0.006168431602418423, -0.011828083544969559, 0.049553077667951584, -0.0012221788056194782, -0.016123240813612938, -0.010729827918112278, 0.013695003464818, 0.03253025561571121, 0.027855204418301582, 0.036852605640888214, 0.009287916123867035, 0.03160848841071129, -0.060867637395858765, 0.025763671845197678, 0.02828889526426792, 0.052427925169467926, 0.026658235117793083, -0.011486485600471497, -0.04105481877923012, -0.02753789909183979, -0.02531259134411812, 0.00217263400554657, 0.042598824948072433, -0.008450274355709553, -0.012940590269863605, 0.018641168251633644, 0.03676118701696396, -0.056041520088911057, 0.025681884959340096, 0.03378129005432129, 0.020465271547436714, -0.006008094176650047, -0.01923779956996441, -0.002392888767644763, -0.01701158843934536, -0.025778107345104218, 0.0003049727529287338, 0.02260523848235607, 0.007555724587291479, 0.021728942170739174, 0.00978118646889925, 0.016208766028285027, -0.0654090940952301, -0.02171926386654377, -0.041217267513275146, 0.018620964139699936, -0.002527401549741626, -0.005740692373365164, 0.04088175296783447, 0.04300258681178093, 0.01768476888537407, 0.01501047145575285, 0.01804581843316555, -0.07264260947704315, -0.02018384262919426, 0.06060697138309479, 0.06616722792387009, -0.03911565989255905, 0.008058828301727772, -0.0186564102768898, 0.0028888785745948553, 0.05363253131508827, -0.020814094692468643, 0.05034155398607254, -0.034965500235557556, 0.01716974563896656, -0.018971068784594536, -0.04915258660912514, -0.05260453373193741, -0.002908339025452733, -0.01425652951002121, 0.018540682271122932, 0.03653155639767647, -0.00968325138092041, -0.04709697142243385, -0.021487003192305565, 0.052962128072977066, 0.015833303332328796, -0.05157695710659027, 0.0016192215261980891, 0.023375144228339195, -0.003123242175206542, 0.014186980202794075, -0.05733523517847061, 0.07446349412202835, -0.01126959826797247, -0.012921219691634178, 0.029753539711236954, -0.021352579817175865, -0.023712104186415672, 0.04618094861507416, 0.014954475685954094, 0.0007509259739890695, 0.001877377973869443, -0.008745561353862286, 0.04575180262327194, 0.02156972326338291, -0.026331569999456406, 0.07415040582418442, 0.00005063930439064279, -0.025600502267479897, 0.003466925350949168, -0.05156565457582474, 0.02335147000849247, -0.025146467611193657, 0.002906372770667076, -0.03408600017428398, -0.028433118015527725, -0.039383918046951294, 0.014211023226380348, 0.02319074422121048, 0.042764630168676376, -0.022913996130228043, -0.014510013163089752, 0.02284022979438305, 0.020142024382948875, 0.048548635095357895, -0.009343074634671211, -0.02182156778872013, 0.0005605029873549938, -0.02277974970638752, -0.01334285270422697, 0.03607797622680664, -0.022922169417142868, 0.0010184899438172579, -0.01668871007859707, -0.03873331844806671, -0.00839998573064804, -0.049887433648109436, -0.04724507033824921, -0.017909778282046318, -0.03714894875884056, 0.028039053082466125, -0.030561719089746475, 0.03265492245554924, 0.009475947357714176, -0.022652439773082733, -0.029634978622198105, 0.057105857878923416, -0.009003322571516037, 0.027393775060772896, -0.03157594054937363, 0.06021784991025925, -0.009476711973547935, -0.027448467910289764, -0.053397368639707565, -0.0238800011575222, 0.02217702940106392, 0.03618009760975838, 0.0008044451242312789, -0.003489783266559243, -0.039312176406383514, 0.007660120725631714, -0.012922239489853382, -0.02650279551744461, 0.013401263393461704, 0.0023904189001768827, -0.03937442600727081, 0.026917200535535812, 0.013073037378489971, 0.09236428141593933, -0.009245453402400017, -0.04144829511642456, -0.015726061537861824, -0.035169173032045364, -0.03558778390288353, 0.001453155535273254, 0.015391862951219082, -0.03249279409646988, -0.009404037147760391, -0.022894248366355896, 0.009507210925221443, 0.037056248635053635, -0.005831587128341198, -0.026716090738773346, 0.044178251177072525, -0.028806909918785095, 0.001987849362194538, -0.04714649170637131, 0.007732601370662451, 0.007252273615449667, 0.04199666902422905, -0.03554137051105499, 0.019685346633195877, -0.005410485900938511, -0.039927154779434204, 0.03326500207185745, -0.0062750051729381084, -0.023848963901400566, -0.0023907918948680162, 0.05711115524172783, -0.03486337512731552, 0.02976032719016075, -0.015126684680581093, -0.028573080897331238, 0.025439878925681114, -0.006085207220166922, -0.0018922953167930245, -0.013631073758006096, 0.027198465541005135, -0.04734129458665848, 0.029826637357473373, 0.002827663207426667, -0.0314314104616642, 0.028389018028974533, 0.03553815931081772, 0.0311297457665205, 0.07162382453680038, -0.0024420295376330614, -0.014316418208181858, -0.03270726278424263, -0.0218646340072155, 0.0004311336961109191, 0.044285956770181656, 0.03504692763090134, -0.01972588710486889, -0.0012123725609853864, 0.06872672587633133, 0.02343294396996498, -0.022558115422725677, 0.025551170110702515, 0.05404955893754959, -0.02799244597554207, 0.018663296476006508, 0.0014204267645254731, -0.029933921992778778, 0.013324907049536705, -0.06333482265472412, 0.03531823307275772, -0.04393959417939186, -0.0032730051316320896, 0.0480843260884285, 0.03893087059259415, -0.009581933729350567, -0.06150059774518013, -0.04793159291148186, -0.10015007108449936, 0.010840192437171936, -0.006149014458060265, -0.013866562396287918, 0.03981693834066391, 0.00020853642490692437, 0.037424229085445404, -0.03300204128026962, -0.003970749210566282, -0.02547936514019966, -0.040311768651008606, -0.04271779954433441, -0.018046768382191658, -0.03274640440940857, 0.043613456189632416, -0.041386086493730545, -0.04863259568810463, -0.027382399886846542, -0.02225239761173725, 0.013386858627200127, 0.019814075902104378, 0.024546843022108078, -0.027755511924624443, 0.027634473517537117, -0.003562304889783263, 0.014923609793186188, 0.030813179910182953, -0.04026055708527565, 0.10506909340620041, 0.034967608749866486, -0.010238668881356716, -0.026445914059877396, 0.05266313999891281, 0.008838067762553692, -0.002411144319921732, 0.009509360417723656, 0.003379212925210595, 0.0010816609719768167, -0.003610341576859355, 0.028291434049606323, 0.06695866584777832, -0.01956121437251568, -0.009813806042075157, 0.039564140141010284, -0.024764133617281914, -0.04418523982167244, 0.01704859547317028, 0.03757951036095619, 0.006735106930136681, -0.01514600869268179, -0.03621186688542366, 0.0028741469141095877, 0.028510570526123047, -0.015554086305201054, -0.044514380395412445, -0.027652259916067123, 0.02151903137564659, -0.014510821551084518, -0.01036014873534441, 0.017453746870160103, 0.031274423003196716, -0.00019013797282241285, -0.04196152091026306, -0.004488696809858084, 0.03894122689962387, -0.07532850652933121, 0.027677016332745552, 0.04981611296534538, 0.010020681656897068, -0.0129063306376338, 0.00028958695475012064, -0.004078626167029142, -0.048979904502630234, -0.0006047841161489487, -0.021861860528588295, 0.03398146107792854, 0.011073592118918896, -0.024799395352602005, -0.016195569187402725, -0.009076879359781742, -0.009085095487535, -0.06489993631839752, -0.025753328576683998, 0.042771317064762115, 0.010614953935146332, -0.042368896305561066, -0.030730491504073143, -0.0362464040517807, -0.014145857654511929, -0.00796334259212017, -0.008718033321201801, 0.013253008015453815, -0.022503098472952843, -0.0021999645978212357, -0.02997717261314392, 0.025176163762807846, 0.01714257337152958, 0.007099091541022062, -0.006525821052491665, -0.020111463963985443, 0.012189026921987534, 0.040777914226055145, -0.02812175452709198, 0.011976323090493679, 0.04993267357349396, 0.02077168971300125, -0.03120381198823452, -0.0364137701690197, -0.055312104523181915, 0.028987593948841095, -0.019801994785666466, 0.00664046173915267, -0.03404536843299866, -0.018017636612057686, 0.045147236436605453, 0.06645947694778442, 0.03856152668595314, 0.01781083643436432, 0.013355971314013004, 0.028632143512368202, 0.03794960677623749, -0.049734655767679214, -0.020253337919712067, 0.027774900197982788, -0.028696846216917038, -0.003554921830072999, -0.026696715503931046, 0.061946168541908264, 0.06098482012748718, 0.0004951552837155759, -0.000403331418056041, 0.0029925452545285225, -0.0073103043250739574, 0.01802980527281761, 0.032193634659051895, -0.0717339813709259, -0.019466759636998177, 0.04638547822833061, 0.004072823096066713, -0.00718644680455327, -0.04907526820898056, -0.057780466973781586, -0.005803469568490982, 0.026721717789769173, -0.020955566316843033, 0.037228722125291824, -0.015469510108232498, 0.019179025664925575, 0.021787529811263084, -0.04779231920838356, -0.01698410138487816, -0.05531389266252518, 0.007034806534647942, 0.03178410977125168, 0.02310231328010559, -0.01421201229095459, 0.011120450682938099, -0.013767067342996597, 0.039613042026758194, 0.04949131980538368, -0.016502289101481438, 0.02348168194293976, -0.008043349720537663, -0.014188363216817379, 0.020716046914458275, 0.040592487901449203, 0.022335859015583992, -0.018239103257656097, 0.058071382343769073, -0.012274724431335926, -0.028484079986810684, 0.03215564787387848, 0.02248847484588623, 0.02788415737450123, 0.034997664391994476, -0.00432187644764781, -0.0259503535926342, 0.041311632841825485, -0.020428383722901344, -0.032448165118694305, -0.02489672601222992, -0.00459697749465704, 0.03039252944290638, 0.0011608093045651913, 0.00887663010507822, 0.0015040159923955798, -0.05538081377744675, 0.06571120023727417, 0.046583034098148346, 0.05308148264884949, -0.03569909930229187, -0.030916737392544746, 0.026641154661774635, 0.032907649874687195, 0.00006489219231298193, -0.0007985834963619709, 0.018396815285086632, 0.04710305854678154, -0.03722929581999779, 0.04768085107207298, -0.020875100046396255, 0.027094760909676552, -0.05867369845509529, -0.04059423878788948, -0.012927891686558723, 0.018591517582535744, 0.03493136912584305, -0.018666720017790794, 0.022213127464056015, 0.030319467186927795, -0.04703029617667198, 0.016113270074129105, -0.018641434609889984, -0.02314184047281742, -0.051200445741415024, 0.010139414109289646, -0.031232422217726707, 0.05894796922802925, -0.007741020061075687, 0.01138811931014061, 0.0253828763961792, 0.01909676194190979, -0.02130301669239998, -0.029791152104735374, 0.010114037431776524, 0.04861216992139816, 0.015259516425430775, -0.06884578615427017, 0.0354095958173275, -0.023526044562458992, -0.011333693750202656, 0.020873121917247772, -0.046246226876974106, 0.0018341027898713946, 0.023444348946213722, 0.022877080366015434, 0.0378006249666214, 0.07635888457298279, 0.005448725074529648, 0.009807471185922623, -0.026769043877720833, 0.006875248160213232, 0.0027082774322479963, 0.025644071400165558, -0.0118617694824934, -0.018058300018310547, 0.03046265058219433, -0.03372139856219292, -0.017713604494929314, -0.009298312477767467, -0.04032063111662865, -0.019643941894173622, -0.007086385972797871, -0.005579077173024416, 0.014844379387795925, 0.008701472543179989, 0.0017336857272312045, -0.03459428250789642, 0.000041916893678717315, 0.02459592930972576, 0.016555851325392723, -0.059951264411211014, -0.0018959108274430037, 0.01645170897245407, -0.01214365754276514, 0.012402418069541454, -0.0016508391126990318, -0.006715951953083277, -0.0725027322769165, -0.022743919864296913, -0.029274020344018936, 0.007221580483019352, -0.028962047770619392, -0.01862851344048977, -0.021886615082621574, -0.014396553859114647, -0.002186555415391922, -0.019365740939974785, -0.0005850395536981523, -0.010126779787242413, -0.03208213299512863, -0.09280967712402344, 0.06014339253306389, 0.0318077988922596, -0.024958260357379913, -0.058243583887815475, -0.027317872270941734, -0.0675087720155716, 0.04345864802598953, 0.07076256722211838, 0.04253222048282623, -0.0020012827590107918, 0.02195761352777481, -0.023483360186219215, 0.03616856783628464, -0.07864651083946228, 0.03974572569131851, -0.008847614750266075, 0.0026722378097474575, 0.007186354137957096, -0.016140373423695564, -0.0019296169048175216, 0.007214766461402178, 0.014579424634575844, -0.03499132767319679, 0.013065791688859463, -0.022883301600813866, 0.024181272834539413, 0.05365489050745964, 0.00881187990307808, -0.03116774372756481, 0.019075870513916016, 0.008732435293495655, 0.033636126667261124, 0.04225866496562958, 0.018169593065977097, -0.04515641927719116, 0.028974460437893867, -0.03645053133368492, 0.012505734339356422, 0.004715459421277046, -0.004333820194005966, -0.019665129482746124, -0.05330538749694824, 0.00694306893274188, 0.004633474163711071, 0.024869155138731003, 0.028658214956521988, 0.038826245814561844, 0.029514312744140625, 0.017011230811476707, 0.0011836965568363667, 0.03308276832103729, -0.04168425872921944, -0.030194923281669617, 0.03756854683160782, 0.02175593376159668, 0.0020885798148810863, 0.01960635744035244, 0.001748951617628336, 0.0409180112183094, -0.020123424008488655, 0.012853430584073067, 0.011997574009001255, 0.007206637412309647, -0.024684809148311615, -0.004132531583309174, -0.00824978668242693, 0.004728347063064575, 0.022366512566804886, 0.01429049763828516, -0.023609476163983345, 0.06158323213458061, -0.04288983717560768, 0.018317976966500282, -0.03084036149084568, 0.05575505644083023, -0.005139481276273727, -0.007972024381160736, 0.0528390035033226, 0.01499702874571085, -0.012315427884459496, -0.009177669882774353, 0.01794799044728279, 0.013238922692835331, 0.01341121457517147, -0.031216870993375778, 0.04886042699217796, -0.0014572326326742768, 0.011416325345635414, -0.02540847472846508, -0.009418506175279617, -0.06978337466716766, -0.010138594545423985, 0.05617183819413185, 0.01737682893872261, 0.022768614813685417, -0.005283151287585497, -0.05610183626413345, 0.005159896332770586, 0.05451839789748192, -0.01697961986064911, -0.03451303020119667, -0.045286379754543304, 0.048936884850263596, -0.006855580024421215, -0.007491773460060358 ]
<p>I'm trying to use the ridge.cv() function in R. The <a href="http://www.inside-r.org/packages/cran/parcor/docs/ridge.cv" rel="nofollow">documentation</a> says that the input y is the "vector of responses".</p> <p>What exactly does that mean?</p>
36,284
[ -0.02913583442568779, -0.02317945472896099, 0.014094959013164043, -0.016537347808480263, -0.001499456469900906, 0.02942470833659172, -0.02441239356994629, -0.0066214436665177345, 0.03180352598428726, -0.016583068296313286, 0.02441302128136158, 0.03714752197265625, 0.051721278578042984, 0.016963409259915352, 0.0031221320386976004, 0.027512390166521072, -0.016166647896170616, 0.011645161546766758, -0.004658298566937447, -0.0027401645202189684, -0.008760865777730942, 0.022566640749573708, 0.002664806554093957, 0.011542859487235546, 0.025638045743107796, 0.05916755273938179, 0.017114702612161636, 0.02310401014983654, 0.024475574493408203, 0.03849863260984421, -0.07083424925804138, -0.030272115021944046, -0.004563184920698404, 0.023526841774582863, 0.012811189517378807, -0.0024870235938578844, -0.013711471110582352, -0.0147808026522398, 0.005537723191082478, 0.05160421133041382, 0.00009716926433611661, -0.02423468418419361, 0.01526439655572176, 0.07666486501693726, -0.02724430151283741, 0.014889164827764034, -0.002788613550364971, -0.012772919610142708, 0.022327223792672157, -0.008339662104845047, 0.0797930508852005, 0.02104877308011055, 0.004989982582628727, 0.052099332213401794, 0.01649020053446293, 0.043000709265470505, 0.043049897998571396, 0.03016950562596321, -0.0391557440161705, -0.034934911876916885, -0.02020794339478016, -0.03363877907395363, -0.027943098917603493, -0.009006197564303875, -0.0206100195646286, -0.007884343154728413, 0.015020380727946758, -0.036486245691776276, 0.023212555795907974, -0.015581639483571053, 0.02615085244178772, 0.027912547811865807, 0.014787779189646244, -0.032290469855070114, -0.005249055102467537, -0.03251431882381439, 0.007419549860060215, 0.013927558436989784, 0.016028661280870438, 0.003606559243053198, 0.04082941636443138, 0.026714401319622993, -0.01997404359281063, -0.00045088486513122916, 0.023030336946249008, -0.001534753362648189, 0.051553674042224884, -0.017218224704265594, 0.04703258350491524, 0.014170625247061253, -0.027854589745402336, 0.012403169646859169, 0.028718478977680206, 0.036584723740816116, -0.07079082727432251, 0.02677627094089985, -0.0032739166636019945, 0.061036352068185806, 0.01191064901649952, -0.0016542836092412472, 0.017910320311784744, -0.024195244535803795, -0.0036741364747285843, 0.047915395349264145, -0.03302976116538048, -0.007876015268266201, -0.02374916337430477, -0.007790947798639536, -0.020217901095747948, -0.04438522830605507, -0.056285884231328964, 0.024497196078300476, 0.0009565973887220025, 0.007382845506072044, 0.03670142963528633, -0.015356519259512424, -0.03082817792892456, 0.035725634545087814, 0.05465830862522125, 0.05788068845868111, 0.04444047436118126, -0.032090164721012115, 0.045017946511507034, -0.0373794287443161, -0.0822213739156723, 0.012617705389857292, 0.041321586817502975, -0.007062268443405628, -0.010794871486723423, 0.06494273245334625, 0.004603894893079996, -0.00958594586700201, 0.0131116583943367, -0.025724001228809357, 0.007035036571323872, -0.013841879554092884, -0.08648194372653961, -0.07260732352733612, 0.0006558949244208634, 0.013920938596129417, -0.021706730127334595, -0.0550197996199131, 0.03417768329381943, 0.028534919023513794, 0.026950204744935036, 0.01205559354275465, 0.031898658722639084, 0.04805119335651398, 0.007881192490458488, -0.011077092960476875, -0.03906289115548134, -0.03708585724234581, -0.00808229111135006, -0.03284608945250511, -0.004789518192410469, -0.053992051631212234, 0.016601625829935074, -0.011738249100744724, 0.007384678348898888, 0.0009988992242142558, 0.02224602922797203, -0.021343572065234184, -0.02586054988205433, 0.0018972530961036682, -0.021263204514980316, -0.04203715920448303, 0.07101050019264221, 0.010485499165952206, 0.03872949630022049, 0.03111891821026802, -0.032383568584918976, 0.024251068010926247, 0.00319103617221117, 0.07077987492084503, 0.016384992748498917, 0.0018455645767971873, -0.023461947217583656, -0.0302067082375288, 0.027864443138241768, 0.027149975299835205, -0.026239613071084023, -0.039067935198545456, 0.006251662503927946, 0.021698856726288795, 0.0019460282055661082, 0.04888353869318962, -0.015239610336720943, -0.019925203174352646, 0.00196088501252234, 0.005368238314986229, -0.06908080726861954, -0.007271916139870882, 0.023354671895503998, -0.004283112473785877, -0.0017760265618562698, 0.00342377508059144, 0.016484584659337997, 0.0027463131118565798, 0.01563895307481289, -0.005789467599242926, -0.02433883398771286, -0.006627415306866169, 0.024324903264641762, 0.01838313788175583, -0.01788111962378025, 0.03516518324613571, 0.020027488470077515, 0.003450351534411311, 0.04056563600897789, -0.029244236648082733, -0.012428300455212593, -0.010881367139518261, -0.00019657918892335147, 0.028158944100141525, -0.021848153322935104, -0.011874041520059109, 0.006612470373511314, 0.029776133596897125, -0.004575940780341625, 0.05319590121507645, -0.09593893587589264, 0.06318990886211395, 0.07082460820674896, 0.02783985063433647, -0.0007569274166598916, 0.0068124039098620415, -0.019342029467225075, 0.015006531029939651, -0.06457796692848206, 0.04151656851172447, -0.041691966354846954, -0.006061401683837175, 0.047200851142406464, 0.01946004293859005, -0.04020784795284271, -0.0007942687952890992, 0.05649249255657196, 0.032408442348241806, 0.03132312372326851, 0.017066676169633865, 0.01001005806028843, 0.003783478867262602, 0.00630786269903183, -0.024928905069828033, 0.019389940425753593, -0.010634737089276314, -0.033299125730991364, -0.01334948930889368, 0.046023327857255936, 0.004352059215307236, -0.0038930452428758144, 0.07445275038480759, 0.003470861818641424, 0.01625833474099636, 0.004777142312377691, 0.025455623865127563, 0.017865924164652824, -0.03207193687558174, 0.025777118280529976, 0.05460108071565628, 0.021597806364297867, -0.005278215743601322, 0.005584205500781536, 0.007416637148708105, 0.03554357960820198, 0.04662903770804405, -0.036221493035554886, -0.020560352131724358, 0.01612747646868229, -0.025946728885173798, 0.024673715233802795, -0.019229525700211525, -0.05681515485048294, -0.04415731877088547, 0.033942583948373795, 0.040549810975790024, 0.016286717727780342, 0.04818598926067352, -0.05497489124536514, -0.040265265852212906, 0.03829900920391083, -0.05377243831753731, 0.04043104872107506, -0.005113383289426565, -0.0642610713839531, 0.012871830724179745, -0.03820318356156349, -0.01930575631558895, 0.015877945348620415, 0.010670492425560951, -0.043235134333372116, 0.019337378442287445, -0.012046697549521923, -0.04841754585504532, -0.002963203238323331, -0.02342800982296467, 0.03395692631602287, 0.0051221465691924095, -0.007926554419100285, 0.025737175717949867, 0.009755123406648636, -0.05156993865966797, 0.023002589121460915, -0.06951586157083511, 0.010283993557095528, -0.050904083997011185, -0.06353689730167389, 0.0128847761079669, -0.0005752883153036237, 0.028882812708616257, 0.05815982073545456, -0.042013444006443024, 0.016853192821145058, -0.050914566963911057, -0.05178533494472504, 0.010739060118794441, 0.017688030377030373, 0.006939599756151438, 0.0034381640143692493, 0.01670745573937893, 0.039441369473934174, -0.010408775880932808, -0.05133099481463432, -0.023469319567084312, 0.00011448793520685285, -0.023402689024806023, -0.014849971048533916, 0.041985467076301575, 0.01801006682217121, 0.03527221083641052, 0.007135647814720869, -0.0402347669005394, 0.026612667366862297, 0.0799630731344223, -0.03661622107028961, 0.0006374213844537735, 0.005711767822504044, -0.011742896400392056, -0.008610280230641365, 0.0361008457839489, 0.03069336712360382, -0.017489509657025337, 0.043151743710041046, -0.015065490268170834, 0.003954129759222269, -0.00234367698431015, 0.001520625432021916, 0.002618529135361314, 0.0027281444054096937, 0.0164299588650465, -0.03997103497385979, 0.03226550668478012, -0.019940141588449478, 0.002442881464958191, 0.01757725700736046, 0.00602306192740798, 0.08053050190210342, -0.03424639254808426, -0.018436918035149574, 0.02495424635708332, 0.03601277619600296, -0.011371308006346226, 0.011271479539573193, -0.015436884947121143, -0.00743091432377696, -0.028516238555312157, 0.008932992815971375, -0.02547135390341282, 0.05757914111018181, 0.00511948624625802, -0.001746038906276226, -0.0032922206446528435, -0.04901011288166046, 0.03355107456445694, -0.016202112659811974, 0.008087706752121449, -0.00459578400477767, 0.02537935972213745, -0.0242325272411108, 0.06330674886703491, 0.06271635740995407, 0.015716955065727234, 0.03966464474797249, -0.010562022216618061, -0.05120624601840973, -0.011444819159805775, -0.006237105466425419, -0.009547669440507889, -0.024683484807610512, 0.005068149883300066, 0.044418368488550186, 0.014905858784914017, 0.007374918088316917, 0.03658778965473175, -0.015374841168522835, -0.036287467926740646, -0.006617563311010599, 0.02102857641875744, 0.007308024913072586, -0.020856663584709167, 0.00638157082721591, 0.049253255128860474, -0.007022775709629059, 0.020471077412366867, 0.05115187540650368, -0.010944560170173645, -0.014160566963255405, 0.012128296308219433, -0.016751283779740334, 0.038256462663412094, 0.027842795476317406, 0.0191433597356081, 0.029514456167817116, -0.036543820053339005, 0.0345703586935997, -0.005429890472441912, 0.049335185438394547, 0.0578288696706295, -0.03525540977716446, -0.030142752453684807, -0.04607689008116722, -0.018423208966851234, -0.02396887168288231, -0.010775777511298656, -0.01614236645400524, 0.0034223701804876328, 0.041481949388980865, 0.02873227372765541, -0.022320054471492767, 0.0393400639295578, 0.022025708109140396, 0.032126035541296005, -0.030026903375983238, -0.010440673679113388, 0.02683873660862446, -0.0056854537688195705, -0.011450928635895252, 0.03685745224356651, 0.009012446738779545, -0.006463610101491213, 0.031099330633878708, 0.023876572027802467, -0.03663730248808861, -0.017197830602526665, -0.018869824707508087, -0.0008620168664492667, 0.037000976502895355, -0.02892247401177883, -0.04307040944695473, 0.006384166888892651, 0.04240529239177704, 0.037669021636247635, 0.011522503569722176, -0.0007707445183768868, -0.08845947682857513, -0.027527976781129837, 0.022593136876821518, 0.04005802050232887, -0.07648231834173203, -0.022383397445082664, -0.0553833544254303, -0.028788749128580093, 0.0728447213768959, -0.03426897153258324, 0.009104710072278976, -0.04794028401374817, -0.009965155273675919, -0.009097830392420292, 0.006543669383972883, -0.0496647022664547, -0.03736729547381401, -0.03663037344813347, 0.020561788231134415, 0.006414006929844618, -0.05110807716846466, -0.04749767854809761, -0.0008688432280905545, -0.04323504865169525, 0.0411280058324337, -0.027829408645629883, 0.0042520142160356045, 0.01729852706193924, 0.05020979046821594, 0.002091735601425171, -0.023675432428717613, 0.004332050681114197, 0.024997519329190254, 0.0026666573248803616, 0.047070782631635666, 0.001967292046174407, -0.013113385066390038, 0.053710006177425385, 0.026112617924809456, 0.017234593629837036, -0.014431416988372803, -0.05355197563767433, -0.000053626852604793385, 0.022848187014460564, -0.014666027389466763, 0.07461468130350113, -0.0061827292665839195, -0.012591056525707245, 0.005502477753907442, -0.04396127536892891, 0.02685706503689289, -0.04349168390035629, -0.031684741377830505, -0.046698350459337234, -0.012699824757874012, -0.014061445370316505, 0.041049860417842865, 0.014546757563948631, 0.009561738930642605, -0.0836685374379158, -0.026155781000852585, 0.0178313497453928, 0.01291176863014698, -0.03573627769947052, 0.0004435745649971068, -0.009851089678704739, 0.01869051530957222, 0.005032544024288654, -0.02088467963039875, 0.008456193841993809, -0.027178660035133362, -0.013041410595178604, 0.014141122810542583, -0.01983007788658142, -0.03937724232673645, 0.007182376459240913, 0.010361270979046822, 0.043634213507175446, -0.03812961280345917, 0.014051740057766438, -0.019967099651694298, 0.03596760705113411, -0.006804949138313532, -0.052602652460336685, -0.022420354187488556, 0.017648043110966682, -0.025780891999602318, -0.0007886064704507589, -0.05417487397789955, 0.055066708475351334, -0.02482752501964569, 0.023751771077513695, -0.059408705681562424, -0.047927938401699066, -0.001603087061084807, -0.016046127304434776, -0.04390460625290871, -0.05852007865905762, -0.01681375876069069, 0.007798395119607449, -0.019006215035915375, 0.012536817230284214, 0.022051621228456497, -0.03263367339968681, 0.03917446359992027, -0.0227391105145216, -0.004390880931168795, 0.0327494852244854, 0.003559625241905451, 0.02427751012146473, 0.04729719087481499, -0.012659579515457153, -0.020340465009212494, -0.017008474096655846, 0.009388730861246586, -0.021376969292759895, 0.02134357951581478, 0.0013986771227791905, -0.016174281015992165, 0.0365234836935997, -0.0016621134709566832, -0.0006478713476099074, 0.017113687470555305, -0.005561233963817358, -0.01213059015572071, -0.06056329980492592, 0.01378103531897068, -0.006362019572407007, -0.013867679983377457, -0.03281715512275696, -0.03402756527066231, -0.03815096244215965, -0.0035286264028400183, 0.04377816990017891, -0.0027652541175484657, 0.007835290394723415, 0.03866695985198021, 0.07258881628513336, -0.025640560314059258, 0.03327750042080879, -0.024130824953317642, -0.018835434690117836, 0.03413676470518112, 0.014702948741614819, 0.013738622888922691, -0.007190853822976351, 0.019583314657211304, -0.0555594377219677, -0.008339673280715942, -0.03688851371407509, 0.013137058354914188, 0.08058224618434906, -0.006916265934705734, 0.04337945953011513, 0.03575551137328148, -0.02766595408320427, 0.020292887464165688, -0.02010803483426571, 0.004994550719857216, -0.03475749120116234, 0.007416712120175362, 0.06926629692316055, 0.0027217480819672346, -0.015056667849421501, 0.042214713990688324, 0.0020264091435819864, 0.02608473412692547, 0.026130281388759613, -0.003285751212388277, 0.06471899151802063, 0.01931936666369438, 0.0010321327717974782, -0.037467725574970245, 0.00403554318472743, -0.017043527215719223, 0.010037236846983433, -0.009167530573904514, -0.020806020125746727, 0.05797230079770088, 0.04409201815724373, 0.04016624018549919, -0.04603494703769684, -0.02838781289756298, -0.03418107330799103, 0.030607428401708603, 0.017372073605656624, -0.01828482747077942, -0.0009014101815409958, 0.030517304316163063, 0.027544984593987465, 0.0030554805416613817, 0.0409400574862957, -0.023635530844330788, -0.11520382761955261, -0.04002927243709564, -0.03334860876202583, -0.008653963916003704, 0.05018676817417145, 0.010223040357232094, -0.018616707995533943, -0.008656870573759079, -0.06911048293113708, -0.0026951173786073923, 0.03274545818567276, 0.05199899524450302, -0.0243693795055151, 0.04905563220381737, -0.017074597999453545, 0.0494241788983345, -0.03441331535577774, -0.034800007939338684, 0.11732015013694763, 0.07472065836191177, 0.003568473970517516, -0.07182834297418594, -0.02920842356979847, -0.012444226071238518, -0.0028891221154481173, 0.008753206580877304, -0.017930403351783752, 0.03987368568778038, -0.0052385092712938786, 0.04969285428524017, 0.00853047613054514, 0.018235789611935616, 0.019767941907048225, 0.027884025126695633, -0.015392283909022808, -0.04651883244514465, 0.0015242492081597447, -0.03298463299870491, -0.008369303308427334, 0.014972825534641743, -0.07182454317808151, -0.004667985253036022, 0.00666849547997117, -0.02561691589653492, -0.029134340584278107, -0.019327078014612198, 0.012393727898597717, 0.03400576487183571, -0.015401075594127178, 0.0036569125950336456, 0.012436768040060997, 0.003134465776383877, 0.01639498770236969, 0.03300921246409416, 0.023474492132663727, -0.0017320503247901797, 0.012728310190141201, 0.02878156490623951, 0.000140231495606713, -0.005893724970519543, -0.009364053606987, -0.01102557871490717, -0.03265509009361267, -0.025007380172610283, -0.010355720296502113, 0.046172142028808594, 0.02742045186460018, 0.006008792202919722, -0.015740273520350456, 0.03494047001004219, 0.00021440544514916837, -0.0699511393904686, 0.01191668026149273, 0.019248563796281815, 0.017205839976668358, -0.015385959297418594, -0.04601268470287323, -0.026418333873152733, -0.0070641543716192245, -0.03719228133559227, 0.04146779328584671, 0.07275675982236862, -0.023686176165938377, -0.008892581798136234, -0.06909744441509247, 0.026352543383836746, -0.032656360417604446, 0.0040613519959151745, -0.016929958015680313, -0.015048773027956486, -0.01903943158686161, -0.010924311354756355, 0.018634002655744553, -0.003872104687616229, 0.019633222371339798, -0.01684591919183731, -0.022454528138041496, -0.020376073196530342, -0.03381221368908882, 0.006761131342500448, -0.017607102170586586, -0.010556373745203018, -0.016736548393964767, 0.005608236882835627, 0.04511586204171181, 0.032116252928972244, 0.0009782759007066488, -0.013196238316595554, -0.019925806671380997, 0.003986010327935219, -0.0003866583574563265, -0.03990757837891579, -0.05410601571202278, 0.05867990478873253, -0.008940204046666622, -0.03668486699461937, -0.009640894830226898, 0.07241478562355042, 0.025413909927010536, 0.041018057614564896, -0.026988711208105087, 0.04125632345676422, -0.04533504694700241, -0.0010418948950245976, 0.01696370355784893, -0.02445644699037075, 0.01597735658288002, -0.023332200944423676, -0.006938149221241474, -0.06385578215122223, -0.007398196030408144, -0.026059048250317574, -0.047945450991392136, 0.027245886623859406, -0.012100239284336567, -0.04212665185332298, -0.021266112104058266, -0.030797211453318596, 0.045910101383924484, -0.013957159593701363, -0.009214658290147781, -0.03273538127541542, 0.03373829275369644, 0.01312548853456974, -0.005794559605419636, -0.0026113607455044985, -0.017364829778671265, -0.025137074291706085, 0.0015674899332225323, 0.006168041378259659, 0.02785973995923996, 0.0342070646584034, 0.011851305142045021, 0.01396142691373825, -0.004865432158112526, 0.06915271282196045, -0.01585560292005539, -0.002613834338262677, 0.05538255348801613, -0.05506244674324989, -0.019015468657016754, 0.009561817161738873, 0.029619382694363594, 0.034500084817409515, 0.00892292708158493, 0.02412291057407856, -0.019272195175290108, 0.0621606670320034, 0.006705662235617638, 0.026923462748527527, 0.001843317411839962, -0.028755804523825645, -0.028814254328608513, -0.0005301942001096904, 0.004836617968976498, -0.0029110924806445837, -0.00014787224063184112, 0.0033732736483216286, 0.006926233414560556, -0.027923671528697014, -0.012855828739702702, -0.013702909462153912, 0.0011088668834418058, 0.014536937698721886, -0.0033425227738916874, -0.026692010462284088, 0.04889201745390892, 0.039611317217350006, -0.0318572111427784, 0.0333586111664772, 0.01046337652951479, 0.01319162454456091, -0.08003194630146027, 0.008195998147130013, -0.014707461930811405, -0.03985342010855675, 0.009956808760762215, -0.05750430375337601, -0.029582524672150612, 0.015878573060035706, -0.047887708991765976, 0.01736067794263363, 0.007532463409006596, -0.001264776918105781, -0.015223179943859577, 0.0630018413066864, 0.005703811068087816, 0.063558429479599, 0.048607680946588516, 0.02378786914050579, 0.06009967252612114, -0.00019383076869416982, 0.00800449587404728, -0.013971828855574131, -0.0039838203229010105, 0.025123044848442078, -0.035354677587747574, -0.04537300765514374, 0.01948482356965542, -0.0005781007930636406, -0.023508567363023758, 0.0007630290929228067, -0.017653904855251312, 0.03164350986480713, 0.06311988085508347, 0.044254373759031296, 0.029508985579013824, 0.029776956886053085, 0.0033343734685331583, -0.032045017927885056, -0.009547841735184193, 0.001124594477005303, 0.005261347629129887, 0.013763521797955036, -0.015507685020565987, -0.016526272520422935, -0.011278155259788036, -0.013125283643603325, -0.007682273164391518, 0.018834440037608147, -0.01413004007190466, -0.028042659163475037, -0.0012659935746341944, -0.02425812929868698, 0.02821425534784794, -0.05387250706553459, 0.018949594348669052, -0.042667992413043976, -0.003222215920686722, 0.021508216857910156, 0.021665338426828384, -0.021374396979808807, 0.003396984888240695, -0.030419116839766502, -0.045447055250406265, -0.013332398608326912, -0.024247843772172928, 0.0030916917603462934, -0.0682736486196518, 0.0290378425270319, 0.03035579062998295, -0.044066041707992554, -0.001384716248139739, 0.026507968083024025, -0.03449700400233269, 0.03455542400479317, 0.01611490733921528, 0.003802905324846506, 0.03144405037164688, -0.010047689080238342, 0.006018621381372213, -0.06563682109117508, 0.050584618002176285, 0.026399454101920128, -0.04482191056013107, -0.00811427179723978, -0.0011217097053304315, -0.005228884983807802, 0.030223289504647255, 0.04164411127567291, -0.014325947500765324, 0.017710963264107704, -0.01618766225874424, 0.026204990223050117, 0.008954623714089394, -0.03656385838985443, 0.04697759449481964, 0.002485277596861124, -0.018608780577778816, -0.00922216847538948, 0.0025967175606638193, -0.0025064346846193075, 0.00014243507757782936, 0.011406623758375645, 0.013839027844369411, -0.010878784582018852, -0.042781516909599304, -0.03477801755070686, 0.022622177377343178, 0.044936999678611755, 0.02079801820218563, 0.048123229295015335, -0.019549120217561722, 0.011557302437722683, 0.04019938036799431, 0.021816659718751907, -0.059916820377111435, -0.00186724413651973, -0.02668934501707554, -0.00728078605607152, 0.025726929306983948, 0.012574763968586922, 0.033807191997766495, -0.04943164810538292, -0.04065408557653427, 0.005131689831614494, -0.0631837323307991, -0.010060794651508331, 0.04571887105703354, 0.017652608454227448, 0.05217500030994415, 0.01333426870405674, 0.01202340703457594, -0.023520343005657196, -0.03711193427443504, 0.0072839823551476, 0.02171613648533821, 0.04988027736544609, -0.007086263503879309, 0.004470460116863251, 0.050506871193647385, -0.02916531451046467, 0.046217262744903564, 0.0026620258577167988, 0.04350651800632477, -0.041229743510484695, 0.018483854830265045, -0.055998530238866806, -0.057322438806295395, 0.004211790394037962, 0.010259578004479408, 0.0011228484800085425, 0.05597073584794998, -0.051154725253582, -0.01939837634563446, 0.007756151258945465, -0.020634785294532776, -0.025125723332166672, 0.00015235126193147153, 0.029352562502026558, 0.0011667216895148158, -0.012876595370471478, -0.009645992890000343, 0.007961689494550228, -0.02366003207862377, 0.03574060648679733, -0.019857121631503105, 0.012144118547439575, -0.025352874770760536, -0.012686061672866344, 0.01980789192020893, -0.003806818975135684, -0.0327179953455925, -0.004080973565578461, 0.0172822717577219, 0.05110377445816994, -0.009010205045342445, -0.027280112728476524, -0.0008723517530597746, -0.01756826974451542, 0.014559293165802956, -0.07924530655145645, 0.0046745529398322105, -0.030242854729294777, 0.049883823841810226, 0.008170024491846561, -0.008227257989346981 ]
<p>What do I need to measure interaction between variables in a particular equation?</p> <p>For e.g. Me just taking 50 grams of protein everyday will help me health wise. Me just doing exercise for 1 hour everyday will help me health wise. Me just stretching 1 hour everyday will help me health wise. Etc.</p> <p>But Combing two of the above things will help me more health wise than just doing one. And combining all three will help me even more than just doing two of the above things.</p> <p>For e.g. Taking 50 gm protein and doing 1 hour exercise everyday is beneficial than just doing one or the other. How does taking 50 grams of protein complement exercising 1 hour every day, by how much?</p> <p>What I want to find out is, a way to measuring interaction between these things. How can I quantify a relationship between each above?</p> <p>What type of data-set will I need to quantify how they compliment each other?</p> <p>Note: I don't know what tags to use for my question. Please suggest.</p> <p>Any suggestions are much appreciated.</p>
73,792
[ -0.029343338683247566, 0.011354963295161724, -0.0416780449450016, 0.01928350143134594, 0.02535799890756607, 0.034284256398677826, 0.009497113525867462, -0.040643636137247086, 0.05270484834909439, 0.019489126279950142, 0.07866626977920532, 0.014407726936042309, 0.06080422177910805, 0.0211293064057827, 0.003412977559491992, 0.01103035919368267, -0.008766037411987782, -0.001746973255649209, -0.013248953968286514, -0.008232067339122295, 0.00671802181750536, -0.0013058853801339865, 0.014296084642410278, 0.02143738605082035, -0.021395953372120857, 0.06562452018260956, 0.026829704642295837, -0.039086852222681046, -0.030435724183917046, 0.04422984644770622, -0.012437786906957626, -0.05418736860156059, 0.045927926898002625, 0.0482461117208004, 0.03155812248587608, 0.01416668202728033, -0.029949355870485306, -0.012074511498212814, 0.005457323510199785, 0.05790793523192406, -0.02834189310669899, -0.018676672130823135, 0.005159925669431686, 0.0033221871126443148, -0.051857348531484604, 0.029055055230855942, -0.024110209196805954, 0.0009559534373693168, 0.03641811013221741, -0.0529433973133564, 0.07820171862840652, -0.0033610351383686066, 0.03366442769765854, 0.021229831501841545, -0.006148508284240961, -0.01186760701239109, 0.06300528347492218, 0.060858238488435745, 0.017765885218977928, -0.05596480891108513, -0.033940598368644714, 0.015015654265880585, 0.001480252598412335, -0.010159097611904144, -0.0403117872774601, 0.03904192894697189, 0.0063131521455943584, -0.0034577224869281054, 0.05692029744386673, 0.00436806445941329, -0.017051510512828827, 0.021748730912804604, 0.057973749935626984, 0.004679379519075155, 0.015598416328430176, -0.03010638803243637, 0.007320493459701538, 0.019982079043984413, 0.05131232365965843, 0.06370272487401962, -0.03911801427602768, -0.011104153469204903, 0.011448130011558533, 0.04270493611693382, 0.03739188238978386, -0.03201376646757126, 0.06793469190597534, -0.016313858330249786, -0.0040326486341655254, 0.015169976279139519, -0.005322716198861599, 0.02446996048092842, 0.03350053355097771, 0.013898296281695366, -0.017647529020905495, 0.029270483180880547, -0.009854847565293312, -0.002053509233519435, 0.015116935595870018, 0.012518662959337234, -0.003426890354603529, -0.06789477169513702, -0.011930258944630623, 0.05677976459264755, 0.0009416899411007762, -0.0041441298089921474, -0.013747112825512886, -0.013423852622509003, -0.018097953870892525, -0.007664194796234369, 0.010387955233454704, -0.01702119968831539, 0.014825071208178997, -0.0008609672077000141, 0.012487992644309998, -0.02888544090092182, 0.005222133360803127, -0.000335436750901863, 0.0662369653582573, 0.0862862840294838, 0.01835385151207447, -0.0419144481420517, 0.03236229717731476, -0.004253971390426159, -0.05716118589043617, -0.0027428946923464537, 0.002491029677912593, -0.016663072630763054, -0.02851863205432892, 0.06185385584831238, 0.011041154153645039, -0.027457457035779953, -0.0009511956595815718, -0.023058559745550156, 0.004314058925956488, -0.001342201605439186, -0.1010739728808403, -0.02735348604619503, 0.039922911673784256, -0.013366371393203735, -0.033994875848293304, -0.04866783320903778, 0.023365121334791183, 0.019734321162104607, 0.05603314936161041, 0.025073066353797913, -0.004457845352590084, 0.008074158802628517, 0.03309091925621033, 0.00421720277518034, -0.016382597386837006, -0.03269811347126961, 0.013365249149501324, -0.01295455265790224, -0.015232718549668789, -0.060785938054323196, 0.010395189747214317, 0.031503330916166306, 0.0016137502389028668, 0.019119523465633392, 0.04133331775665283, 0.0070040118880569935, -0.00803520530462265, 0.008431581780314445, 0.0065203565172851086, 0.0030780623201280832, 0.026016848161816597, -0.009367014281451702, 0.024605484679341316, 0.02924925833940506, -0.001096536754630506, 0.0016582728130742908, 0.03293687105178833, 0.017956791445612907, 0.04640987887978554, 0.007926156744360924, -0.018593033775687218, -0.01712672784924507, -0.020729562267661095, -0.004928081762045622, -0.0284134428948164, -0.06506748497486115, -0.03219044953584671, 0.023755399510264397, 0.035968679934740067, 0.04599916562438011, 0.018442440778017044, -0.013428985141217709, 0.028490761294960976, 0.004691408481448889, -0.038547415286302567, -0.08363211899995804, 0.0020409359131008387, -0.03932741656899452, -0.055762920528650284, 0.012399300932884216, 0.0006424118764698505, -0.017419476062059402, -0.01840652897953987, -0.053492333739995956, 0.010460383258759975, 0.014068151824176311, 0.03131561726331711, 0.0008169065113179386, -0.022518033161759377, 0.05317005142569542, 0.04018362611532211, -0.04191087186336517, 0.0023762332275509834, -0.03746907413005829, -0.03817882016301155, 0.008696501143276691, -0.040688589215278625, 0.012038937769830227, 0.005547558888792992, -0.01423532422631979, 0.013898376375436783, -0.004387022461742163, -0.028616726398468018, 0.02880801074206829, -0.03967677056789398, 0.09112311154603958, 0.04968986660242081, -0.0024549856316298246, 0.027066368609666824, 0.011576434597373009, 0.0276276096701622, 0.05120183899998665, 0.010326624847948551, -0.017496196553111076, -0.042612578719854355, -0.009463928639888763, 0.02581300400197506, 0.023395609110593796, -0.007774371188133955, -0.007827370427548885, 0.07036108523607254, 0.004141541663557291, -0.007345134392380714, 0.025980975478887558, -0.013750387355685234, -0.008301441557705402, 0.05113167315721512, 0.02266737073659897, 0.030332354828715324, -0.0028746388852596283, 0.0017109066247940063, 0.027120541781187057, 0.01983335241675377, 0.02020202949643135, 0.011993561871349812, 0.029539193958044052, 0.021794598549604416, 0.018682224676012993, -0.022590063512325287, -0.019139762967824936, 0.03941626846790314, -0.010188029147684574, 0.018392471596598625, 0.03822111710906029, 0.005822575185447931, -0.008004341274499893, 0.013064846396446228, -0.031867045909166336, 0.007274598348885775, 0.040999431163072586, -0.045766714960336685, -0.02452920563519001, 0.01565299928188324, -0.044131793081760406, 0.018308227881789207, -0.0023887755814939737, -0.01678757555782795, -0.039183761924505234, -0.011191021651029587, 0.022629154846072197, -0.010299532674252987, 0.08621026575565338, -0.05130468308925629, -0.03422018885612488, 0.008804735727608204, -0.025110412389039993, -0.018316185101866722, -0.022203514352440834, -0.02418437972664833, -0.017355913296341896, -0.03288329392671585, -0.03150777518749237, 0.038946688175201416, -0.024504393339157104, -0.02885613963007927, 0.018434589728713036, 0.029759971424937248, -0.039859920740127563, -0.04418875277042389, -0.04101504385471344, 0.04211118444800377, -0.00034736908855848014, -0.02867247723042965, 0.030066322535276413, -0.004479332827031612, -0.05682056397199631, 0.010813920758664608, -0.024967895820736885, -0.008964033797383308, 0.009807161055505276, -0.03532068431377411, 0.02967022731900215, -0.014589358121156693, -0.011572755873203278, 0.022431615740060806, -0.04484868422150612, -0.021332744508981705, -0.10181371867656708, -0.07305717468261719, 0.032115012407302856, 0.004833097103983164, 0.021467676386237144, 0.015319599770009518, -0.02268241159617901, 0.05208057910203934, 0.0007011195411905646, -0.0492749847471714, -0.04469471797347069, -0.02413482964038849, -0.015464955940842628, -0.023905044421553612, 0.023210592567920685, 0.006372017785906792, 0.013821326196193695, 0.02799934893846512, 0.038345422595739365, 0.02098424918949604, 0.0333026759326458, 0.03191536292433739, -0.005623952951282263, 0.002376631833612919, 0.006346011999994516, 0.006185960490256548, 0.03570348396897316, 0.05763503909111023, -0.03368236497044563, -0.00827041082084179, -0.004060485400259495, -0.005497331265360117, 0.03135954588651657, -0.057016149163246155, 0.021822543814778328, 0.040368348360061646, 0.024981776252388954, -0.033678580075502396, 0.030072709545493126, 0.025608938187360764, 0.00714304530993104, 0.006270290352404118, 0.0470210425555706, 0.04994941130280495, -0.03325306251645088, 0.001532298163510859, 0.07014776021242142, 0.062245722860097885, -0.008670787326991558, -0.02861684560775757, -0.013791738077998161, 0.024374989792704582, -0.014737235382199287, -0.02531551942229271, -0.037827346473932266, 0.033321037888526917, 0.03712332248687744, 0.012898581102490425, -0.025662565603852272, -0.06461604684591293, 0.009578201919794083, -0.09542310982942581, -0.03885035589337349, -0.03282751515507698, 0.06858545541763306, -0.0019428359810262918, 0.05995529145002365, 0.003190506948158145, -0.01949859969317913, -0.0009581499616615474, 0.004194085951894522, -0.07855663448572159, 0.057938363403081894, 0.0027434471994638443, -0.033594198524951935, 0.04555025324225426, -0.010324770584702492, 0.01647189073264599, -0.04941796511411667, -0.025982314720749855, 0.006565773393958807, 0.042503636330366135, -0.01768990233540535, -0.00876053050160408, -0.019660046324133873, -0.022405406460165977, 0.0015973232220858335, -0.0048274872824549675, 0.03728143125772476, -0.0011190143413841724, 0.0038039512000977993, 0.043332066386938095, -0.005857591517269611, -0.04081622511148453, -0.01824347861111164, 0.016137000173330307, -0.002554632257670164, 0.04684475064277649, 0.0020449471194297075, 0.04244633764028549, 0.01563653163611889, 0.05390501767396927, -0.009583652019500732, 0.033694274723529816, 0.028020573779940605, -0.02496124617755413, -0.006089784670621157, -0.010812188498675823, -0.002615946112200618, -0.00036595703568309546, 0.007923511788249016, 0.004420027136802673, 0.007620640564709902, 0.03222087025642395, 0.010941551066935062, -0.04249914735555649, 0.02830146625638008, 0.069320447742939, 0.011019068770110607, -0.053689613938331604, -0.061799801886081696, -0.05154554918408394, 0.011983987875282764, -0.006646406836807728, 0.006655390374362469, 0.03494103625416756, 0.026065995916724205, -0.013334741815924644, 0.011863716877996922, -0.0009929246734827757, -0.023076120764017105, -0.00778451282531023, 0.004433122929185629, 0.02060430683195591, -0.02078341133892536, -0.040182292461395264, 0.003945250529795885, 0.05179287865757942, 0.053789228200912476, -0.007423511706292629, 0.0038356813602149487, -0.10923286527395248, 0.03247988224029541, 0.051795653998851776, 0.030347216874361038, -0.06212877109646797, -0.013445643708109856, -0.007022170349955559, -0.02797263115644455, 0.019982317462563515, -0.04391603171825409, 0.05660729855298996, -0.029332781210541725, 0.001952741527929902, -0.029618551954627037, -0.02094358764588833, -0.044811028987169266, 0.036557603627443314, -0.016344012692570686, -0.011317234486341476, -0.01090136170387268, -0.013484952971339226, -0.02866869419813156, 0.031255997717380524, 0.03283042460680008, 0.041165079921483994, -0.06126970052719116, -0.02860228717327118, -0.0009873841190710664, 0.026026442646980286, -0.03884981572628021, -0.09606171399354935, 0.014344966970384121, 0.05069797858595848, -0.009270244278013706, 0.056669868528842926, -0.012205845676362514, -0.021854525431990623, 0.011449542827904224, 0.009434659034013748, -0.027338502928614616, -0.015817752107977867, -0.028945961967110634, 0.05895186588168144, 0.05052896589040756, 0.02411792241036892, 0.06302854418754578, 0.03842438384890556, -0.02315169759094715, -0.022209718823432922, 0.009012999944388866, 0.03911532089114189, -0.00823118444532156, -0.03870004788041115, -0.02920699678361416, 0.009082349017262459, -0.05110792815685272, 0.013518361374735832, -0.03117009438574314, 0.0039053980726748705, -0.05336802452802658, -0.009299071505665779, -0.00864194892346859, 0.0042964075691998005, 0.016660010442137718, -0.034999363124370575, 0.025489909574389458, 0.014911569654941559, 0.05495971813797951, -0.015377089381217957, 0.0113436384126544, -0.00023553580103907734, -0.03770438954234123, 0.011919773183763027, -0.011652830056846142, -0.004664454143494368, -0.016200682148337364, -0.013995779678225517, 0.008043412119150162, 0.011091169901192188, 0.017885686829686165, -0.016805745661258698, 0.03511231765151024, 0.010476803407073021, -0.026344437152147293, -0.028418319299817085, 0.035188570618629456, 0.03949693590402603, 0.02305663377046585, -0.021834563463926315, 0.04216998815536499, -0.043799180537462234, -0.006162552163004875, -0.05092724412679672, -0.025081846863031387, 0.060041557997465134, 0.0039354972541332245, 0.017000658437609673, -0.03607606142759323, 0.01866152137517929, -0.03049258515238762, -0.041435644030570984, -0.020011812448501587, 0.008482654578983784, -0.039668742567300797, -0.00800403580069542, 0.006145525723695755, 0.005011419765651226, 0.027707142755389214, 0.03380494937300682, 0.05486756190657616, 0.025027716532349586, -0.008024264127016068, -0.0017419210635125637, 0.011833587661385536, -0.010605600662529469, -0.020501291379332542, -0.03252311423420906, -0.03306145966053009, -0.004992560017853975, 0.01655879244208336, -0.016980750486254692, -0.0012990784598514438, -0.018486443907022476, -0.028854157775640488, -0.001446615089662373, -0.038572415709495544, 0.03525114804506302, 0.02079625427722931, 0.020496482029557228, -0.0048199906013906, 0.03187186270952225, -0.03486746549606323, -0.007991019636392593, 0.006947873160243034, -0.027929626405239105, -0.08303184807300568, -0.004369058180600405, 0.06764532625675201, 0.0028249642346054316, 0.021835429593920708, 0.024318533018231392, 0.010787657462060452, 0.0340619720518589, -0.039157524704933167, -0.013505391776561737, 0.0426829531788826, 0.014277578331530094, -0.03443063795566559, -0.007124692667275667, -0.012709659524261951, -0.035314369946718216, 0.07234545797109604, -0.044633880257606506, 0.0584174320101738, 0.05820566043257713, -0.018699513748288155, -0.010593499056994915, 0.013260171748697758, 0.007016491610556841, 0.008126715198159218, 0.03540128096938133, 0.041112255305051804, -0.02363315038383007, -0.01122438907623291, 0.06385936588048935, 0.006665111985057592, 0.0022590244188904762, -0.017955973744392395, 0.015766175463795662, 0.03155136480927467, 0.014813256449997425, -0.028101366013288498, -0.03928909823298454, 0.05198464170098305, -0.0554778166115284, -0.002165367128327489, -0.026725418865680695, -0.027638660743832588, 0.04872790351510048, 0.043548066169023514, -0.030887145549058914, -0.038071680814027786, -0.0023230770602822304, -0.01024833507835865, 0.0016261005075648427, 0.02537539415061474, -0.03801721706986427, 0.0301187876611948, -0.01369335688650608, 0.040982238948345184, -0.014790364541113377, 0.006894331891089678, -0.009743292815983295, -0.08173708617687225, 0.02852613851428032, -0.012616482563316822, -0.04833346605300903, 0.04245331883430481, 0.0193222276866436, -0.030237294733524323, 0.015152759850025177, -0.01868617907166481, 0.03310413286089897, 0.01274037268012762, 0.009786820970475674, -0.021794024854898453, 0.06047878414392471, -0.010613222606480122, 0.017993606626987457, 0.015494425781071186, 0.006157903932034969, 0.09367990493774414, 0.04162784293293953, 0.021920757368206978, -0.04782095178961754, 0.015010735020041466, 0.02416910044848919, 0.015121565200388432, -0.011728116311132908, 0.013758423738181591, 0.010922313667833805, 0.01879785768687725, 0.033810585737228394, 0.032958030700683594, 0.03378644213080406, -0.006477775052189827, 0.04777054116129875, -0.02660478465259075, -0.0012429757043719292, 0.027303805574774742, -0.009191928431391716, 0.003841773374006152, -0.022191865369677544, -0.019205791875720024, 0.024475088343024254, -0.013910653069615364, -0.0019382582977414131, -0.003361658426001668, -0.03392033651471138, 0.020108990371227264, 0.030396971851587296, -0.02203279919922352, -0.0046614487655460835, 0.002716809045523405, 0.037898026406764984, -0.035109132528305054, -0.003034748136997223, 0.052800241857767105, -0.007888490334153175, -0.029567139223217964, 0.03133353590965271, 0.0006146027590148151, -0.016084866598248482, -0.014033390209078789, 0.019068650901317596, -0.08290684968233109, -0.024122275412082672, -0.024407802149653435, 0.030123395845294, -0.013960822485387325, -0.016850296407938004, -0.04382351413369179, 0.010314342565834522, 0.020869893953204155, -0.03256727755069733, -0.045969415456056595, 0.004103854298591614, 0.042399585247039795, -0.061054300516843796, 0.010596749372780323, -0.04463997483253479, 0.00889673177152872, -0.028351739048957825, 0.017408570274710655, 0.026942476630210876, -0.021345054730772972, -0.032873183488845825, -0.03472337871789932, 0.017674989998340607, -0.0061851502396166325, -0.006285661365836859, -0.016951212659478188, -0.02913740649819374, -0.04499009996652603, 0.012293637730181217, 0.021127307787537575, 0.0426630862057209, -0.010598930530250072, 0.00005121344293002039, -0.005735828075557947, -0.04076791927218437, -0.018778620287775993, 0.050863560289144516, 0.00009462673915550113, 0.009145868942141533, -0.0542667880654335, -0.03862834349274635, 0.019601060077548027, 0.01688951812684536, 0.014485706575214863, 0.004336133599281311, -0.005086938384920359, 0.029186861589550972, 0.025062302127480507, -0.009587103500962257, -0.03683893010020256, 0.02253025770187378, -0.024733450263738632, 0.005464483052492142, 0.002681666286662221, 0.06470250338315964, -0.0074938503094017506, -0.009902450256049633, -0.0007652194472029805, 0.0322219543159008, -0.04499349743127823, 0.01474019419401884, 0.015695059671998024, -0.02444647066295147, 0.006330940872430801, 0.00564090209081769, 0.02411057986319065, 0.013103100471198559, 0.016978036612272263, 0.002846228890120983, -0.056817419826984406, 0.0045966217294335365, -0.002618276048451662, -0.017416488379240036, 0.021541381254792213, -0.009441476315259933, 0.032592080533504486, -0.035421110689640045, 0.009047122672200203, -0.10686571151018143, -0.023212168365716934, 0.021926669403910637, -0.024081170558929443, 0.004693834111094475, 0.004340574610978365, -0.012763740494847298, 0.005036268383264542, 0.055443037301301956, 0.021446356549859047, 0.008078228682279587, -0.03577827662229538, 0.02507684752345085, -0.00468161515891552, 0.058790963143110275, -0.008240991272032261, -0.03883390128612518, 0.03960854187607765, -0.05010602995753288, 0.029371263459324837, 0.026443438604474068, -0.04058745503425598, 0.03918977081775665, 0.03868257254362106, -0.028030484914779663, -0.015347863547503948, 0.0426483117043972, -0.005874622147530317, -0.00915436539798975, -0.009871058166027069, -0.027292218059301376, -0.01920512318611145, 0.004056261386722326, -0.01606553979218006, -0.020843539386987686, -0.036931611597537994, 0.01736145094037056, 0.024828340858221054, 0.026722725480794907, -0.011334281414747238, -0.002251085825264454, -0.0016624134732410312, -0.004708660766482353, -0.011587763205170631, -0.0490141436457634, 0.017459770664572716, 0.049246467649936676, -0.03294128552079201, 0.021782539784908295, -0.00814574584364891, 0.019504820927977562, -0.05617699772119522, 0.01376478560268879, -0.0391080342233181, 0.021048706024885178, 0.021885449066758156, -0.061924081295728683, 0.025988744571805, -0.00926973856985569, -0.03220411762595177, 0.052359312772750854, -0.02650921232998371, 0.024271922186017036, -0.02041400596499443, 0.039767876267433167, -0.006973894778639078, 0.009865235537290573, 0.0032550266478210688, 0.041200749576091766, 0.004256487358361483, 0.018779905512928963, 0.009627592749893665, -0.0010307361371815205, 0.0011847704881802201, -0.0007785665802657604, 0.0025010404642671347, -0.04333043843507767, 0.0382801815867424, -0.027672510594129562, -0.04182257503271103, 0.021585209295153618, -0.027429962530732155, 0.06371939182281494, 0.00651705265045166, 0.004534231033176184, 0.002617676742374897, 0.05640741437673569, 0.007734626065939665, -0.04102315008640289, -0.055411167442798615, -0.02081124112010002, -0.00895440112799406, 0.04009187966585159, 0.0035739161539822817, 0.03338256850838661, 0.05006755515933037, -0.002517381450161338, -0.0384037047624588, 0.018104393035173416, -0.0025931810960173607, -0.018634706735610962, 0.008086374960839748, -0.032730795443058014, 0.02282796800136566, -0.02187703736126423, -0.031111380085349083, -0.03598691523075104, 0.02886214852333069, 0.012684693560004234, 0.009197530336678028, -0.04423408955335617, -0.004230686463415623, -0.029968740418553352, -0.016260424628853798, -0.004108234774321318, 0.011723369359970093, 0.006662638392299414, -0.024872129783034325, -0.013102171942591667, -0.014512994326651096, 0.0017006987472996116, -0.022170986980199814, -0.00378078012727201, -0.04201963543891907, 0.04570932686328888, -0.0138988783583045, 0.0017575054662302136, 0.010592910461127758, -0.031128454953432083, 0.005161779932677746, -0.05952474847435951, 0.02638247422873974, 0.06437983363866806, -0.0028144975658506155, -0.03298827260732651, -0.0010308451019227505, -0.0224438589066267, 0.017411459237337112, 0.04497119039297104, -0.018910840153694153, -0.01617361605167389, -0.047272492200136185, 0.026052400469779968, -0.0001385640207445249, -0.021069539710879326, 0.06498370319604874, -0.029067331925034523, -0.021366441622376442, -0.006362455431371927, -0.0043406300246715546, 0.011745847761631012, 0.000848611758556217, 0.031974852085113525, -0.02663891389966011, 0.0070244199596345425, -0.016474802047014236, -0.019575748592615128, 0.029818519949913025, 0.006877541542053223, 0.002651705639436841, 0.015183099545538425, 0.019297270104289055, 0.04325581341981888, 0.03783351927995682, -0.024094587191939354, -0.020502358675003052, 0.06467870622873306, -0.01951129548251629, 0.0005656436551362276, -0.00006004681563354097, -0.004477325826883316, -0.011575314216315746, -0.0730229988694191, -0.005331157706677914, 0.026431811973452568, -0.03395713493227959, -0.016442982479929924, 0.03413325920701027, 0.04988538846373558, 0.0460403673350811, -0.012138817459344864, 0.04819482937455177, -0.006701524369418621, -0.022597651928663254, -0.005811121314764023, 0.028475960716605186, 0.036940522491931915, 0.016370020806789398, -0.008027895353734493, 0.035472359508275986, 0.012025122530758381, 0.0031835988629609346, -0.007857670076191425, 0.009018278680741787, -0.03462843596935272, -0.026243561878800392, 0.01221480779349804, -0.027104591950774193, 0.013088545762002468, 0.053841330111026764, 0.004917594138532877, 0.04681597277522087, -0.06479416787624359, -0.014734502881765366, -0.02292488142848015, -0.006780785042792559, -0.03183064982295036, -0.02243872918188572, 0.0230178814381361, 0.026321955025196075, 0.018801581114530563, 0.017583083361387253, -0.035910800099372864, -0.03709622845053673, 0.0023018561769276857, 0.0009568276000209153, 0.03933562710881233, -0.015600073151290417, -0.019313279539346695, 0.0143771693110466, -0.03872349113225937, -0.04171765595674515, -0.0345001220703125, 0.04995280131697655, 0.029312100261449814, 0.013781367801129818, -0.02543744258582592, -0.006653021089732647, 0.00028290037880651653, 0.0541565828025341, -0.051115937530994415, -0.05084161087870598, -0.055114053189754486, 0.008905566297471523, -0.013409006409347057, -0.00032437744084745646 ]
<p>I sometimes have the situation where I have from several dozen to over 100 linear models to perform hypothesis tests on. They have the same predictor variables, but different response variables. </p> <p>Let's say I have 100 models and each model has four p-values-- one for the intercept, one each for two main effects, and one for the interaction effect. If I want to calculate false discovery rates, should I calculate one set of FDRs based on the 400 p-values, or should I calculate a separate set of FDRs for each term in the model, based on the 100 p-values for that one term? I've been told by a more experienced colleague that it is the latter, but I don't understand why.</p> <p>In case it matters, usually one of the main effects and its interactions with the other effects is of primary interest, and the other terms are included because they might influence the response and therefore must be taken into account.</p>
30,600
[ -0.06302691996097565, 0.04258628934621811, -0.01978706568479538, 0.019269602373242378, 0.049533963203430176, 0.02990073896944523, 0.03194833919405937, -0.02903834916651249, 0.056256189942359924, 0.004401063080877066, 0.051097262650728226, -0.007435694336891174, 0.06560371071100235, -0.03897061571478844, 0.02515004388988018, -0.008737176656723022, -0.011539789848029613, 0.026574168354272842, -0.009895539842545986, -0.012462559156119823, -0.027803540229797363, 0.010313238948583603, 0.008612588047981262, -0.01228044182062149, -0.01769399456679821, 0.07469911128282547, 0.030997812747955322, -0.00001302114105783403, 0.025220319628715515, 0.0027177578303962946, -0.003544645383954048, -0.03128300979733467, 0.019971555098891258, 0.05671051889657974, 0.0203132051974535, -0.031783878803253174, -0.023455779999494553, -0.003625547979027033, 0.00759681174531579, 0.05163940414786339, -0.03496628999710083, -0.03183644264936447, 0.010550041683018208, 0.018450826406478882, -0.007607324048876762, 0.01947927661240101, 0.006195736583322287, -0.030387353152036667, 0.04179868847131729, -0.025595664978027344, 0.06226203218102455, -0.004271714482456446, 0.047276027500629425, 0.05539394170045853, -0.01818263903260231, -0.004600983113050461, 0.04514779523015022, 0.06764991581439972, -0.0003452987293712795, -0.040694333612918854, -0.023783495649695396, -0.008791215717792511, 0.021382160484790802, -0.012280841358006, -0.03768417611718178, 0.041967011988162994, 0.00724867545068264, -0.02466621622443199, 0.03444711118936539, -0.002980477875098586, 0.005729458760470152, -0.026266315951943398, 0.04498801752924919, -0.0160997174680233, 0.0002827353891916573, -0.01544489897787571, 0.03466867282986641, 0.014219931326806545, 0.05508085712790489, 0.01826762966811657, -0.015935951843857765, 0.007527122739702463, 0.015397137962281704, 0.0487312488257885, 0.026514921337366104, 0.0052612461149692535, 0.05664839968085289, -0.022318236529827118, 0.016836851835250854, 0.008355164900422096, -0.027810271829366684, -0.01760927028954029, 0.08412858843803406, -0.01375320740044117, -0.043553464114665985, 0.03948012739419937, -0.025366371497511864, 0.020451854914426804, 0.018343403935432434, 0.044366504997015, -0.03181860223412514, -0.044546209275722504, -0.009760902263224125, 0.043557412922382355, -0.024494577199220657, -0.03726119175553322, -0.03610207885503769, 0.019782647490501404, -0.003948913421481848, -0.04037971422076225, 0.010211657732725143, 0.046763673424720764, -0.03159946948289871, 0.02854754589498043, 0.028622345998883247, -0.0065019926987588406, 0.012400930747389793, -0.017760535702109337, 0.05335741117596626, 0.03973890841007233, 0.03316885977983475, -0.05971686542034149, 0.03298618271946907, 0.0008557517430745065, -0.02504492923617363, -0.01600322127342224, 0.015127027407288551, -0.000383282225811854, -0.03621816262602806, 0.057276517152786255, 0.033789295703172684, -0.023020410910248756, 0.03681127727031708, -0.0017239425797015429, 0.0009766152361407876, 0.008817662484943867, -0.06961945444345474, -0.041948478668928146, 0.03167076036334038, -0.028182102367281914, -0.016004130244255066, -0.07462573796510696, -0.017038634046912193, 0.009889299981296062, 0.06353921443223953, -0.021823253482580185, 0.028694860637187958, 0.02237163484096527, 0.03342825174331665, 0.02620088867843151, -0.02784835919737816, -0.05406840518116951, -0.02547517418861389, -0.032672714442014694, -0.04079654440283775, -0.08737469464540482, -0.000884587352629751, 0.009706000797450542, 0.00871284306049347, 0.03643692284822464, 0.009091758169233799, 0.007478147745132446, 0.007781269960105419, 0.021227244287729263, 0.03534899279475212, -0.001596656977199018, 0.056114017963409424, -0.010885117575526237, 0.048120468854904175, 0.0256342813372612, 0.012092076241970062, -0.0018487231573089957, -0.006220940034836531, 0.06510430574417114, 0.026397978886961937, -0.02245759218931198, 0.008304048329591751, -0.02402639202773571, 0.018185218796133995, 0.006860664580017328, -0.028586437925696373, -0.01797487586736679, -0.019710643216967583, -0.004964430816471577, 0.032525546848773956, 0.02080429159104824, -0.001358195673674345, -0.039924804121255875, 0.025714829564094543, -0.03747386857867241, -0.07024311274290085, -0.07499440759420395, -0.016416722908616066, -0.011138387024402618, -0.033338889479637146, 0.05286066606640816, 0.010430378839373589, 0.013696219772100449, 0.0014235503040254116, -0.028675848618149757, -0.03925400227308273, 0.012529035098850727, 0.04699838533997536, -0.04820777848362923, 0.014238324016332626, 0.06109779700636864, 0.044902972877025604, -0.03191433846950531, 0.037203140556812286, -0.04379216209053993, -0.06390788406133652, 0.03028573840856552, -0.043031711131334305, -0.012123704887926579, -0.005879972595721483, -0.03611800819635391, -0.03422747179865837, -0.03969740495085716, -0.012151064351201057, 0.03885195776820183, -0.09132060408592224, 0.06929197162389755, 0.08912492543458939, -0.0062562343664467335, -0.009457867592573166, 0.023783553391695023, 0.020000599324703217, -0.002486184937879443, -0.02019152231514454, 0.013746486976742744, -0.07146904617547989, -0.02195781283080578, 0.03652878478169441, 0.011797865852713585, -0.039440128952264786, 0.03746756538748741, 0.04996027424931526, 0.01328986044973135, 0.014034131541848183, 0.047967974096536636, 0.017440365627408028, -0.015709523111581802, 0.02282503806054592, 0.03773123770952225, 0.013034163974225521, 0.004344235174357891, 0.029863614588975906, -0.020241031423211098, 0.021217791363596916, -0.009908313862979412, -0.009141994640231133, 0.04468963295221329, -0.009190535172820091, -0.00783008523285389, -0.027192244306206703, 0.002366599626839161, 0.0030250190757215023, -0.03549869731068611, 0.03972823917865753, 0.016555212438106537, -0.0022473735734820366, 0.0038867504335939884, 0.01575615629553795, -0.016475452110171318, 0.0088032903149724, 0.011187421157956123, -0.0548119843006134, -0.004167177248746157, 0.02209317870438099, -0.05717157572507858, 0.004727889318019152, -0.03639782965183258, -0.027425164356827736, -0.038401417434215546, 0.032451506704092026, 0.00038187220343388617, -0.003140141721814871, 0.07503696531057358, -0.03324073180556297, -0.027978990226984024, 0.004770506173372269, -0.04184294119477272, 0.017304861918091774, -0.011096867732703686, -0.053190361708402634, -0.0034355390816926956, -0.04165385663509369, -0.031065991148352623, 0.022587407380342484, -0.010536775924265385, -0.020356958732008934, 0.004215504974126816, 0.003842263715341687, -0.06654031574726105, -0.05167550966143608, -0.0013430588878691196, 0.010362683795392513, -0.02223922498524189, -0.042401041835546494, 0.015054339542984962, 0.009084860794246197, -0.023710722103714943, 0.014217818155884743, -0.008770565502345562, 0.0027494800742715597, 0.002802155679091811, -0.014483876526355743, 0.010903851129114628, 0.02554660104215145, -0.020003192126750946, 0.018791332840919495, -0.03897268697619438, -0.029075488448143005, -0.07111261785030365, -0.036383457481861115, -0.00906272791326046, -0.005580729339271784, 0.03842901065945625, -0.00933091714978218, 0.012232799082994461, 0.061905622482299805, 0.041192810982465744, -0.006520342081785202, -0.029949190095067024, 0.0029759258031845093, -0.0374668687582016, -0.028550388291478157, 0.031783055514097214, -0.010645948350429535, -0.0102281728759408, 0.029755862429738045, -0.009921595454216003, 0.019515277817845345, 0.024191124364733696, 0.014355206862092018, -0.0008769329288043082, 0.006006848532706499, 0.02649700827896595, -0.025530211627483368, 0.02461658976972103, 0.034280646592378616, 0.03909088671207428, 0.027504438534379005, 0.008394382894039154, 0.021518979221582413, 0.011197631247341633, -0.03710968792438507, 0.039989810436964035, -0.029308754950761795, 0.008229122497141361, -0.02207753248512745, 0.00014393249875865877, 0.01749822124838829, -0.009875422343611717, -0.03524241968989372, 0.027042115107178688, 0.02783818542957306, -0.04577808827161789, -0.000334897602442652, 0.05039861425757408, 0.03024485521018505, -0.02497532032430172, -0.004810098558664322, -0.005789011251181364, -0.011995037086308002, 0.014618052169680595, -0.016158221289515495, -0.007584200706332922, 0.03997515141963959, 0.023769790306687355, 0.0036891622003167868, -0.026358027011156082, -0.041772786527872086, 0.007995604537427425, -0.08544059097766876, 0.01281462050974369, -0.02298552356660366, 0.026113906875252724, -0.006765101104974747, 0.02263382263481617, 0.013946032151579857, -0.03655565530061722, -0.015213259495794773, 0.018316827714443207, -0.03724752739071846, 0.017940176650881767, -0.0030872891657054424, -0.03392837569117546, -0.01711232401430607, -0.021463513374328613, 0.0418323278427124, -0.022962365299463272, -0.002215583110228181, -0.013768574222922325, 0.004554876126348972, -0.0020342564675956964, -0.005740916356444359, -0.036113619804382324, -0.03953256458044052, -0.03932877257466316, 0.04438486322760582, 0.03713341802358627, 0.005246060434728861, 0.017916936427354813, 0.04798178747296333, -0.0017757682362571359, -0.0317203663289547, -0.022772355005145073, -0.010037505999207497, -0.0008513396605849266, 0.03659399226307869, 0.007391287013888359, 0.0030069672502577305, -0.07155519723892212, 0.04384796693921089, 0.017902247607707977, 0.028844935819506645, 0.0328189954161644, 0.00010668338654795662, -0.025332989171147346, -0.030801234766840935, -0.005391635932028294, -0.014105606824159622, 0.004290225449949503, -0.0020332476124167442, -0.027241617441177368, 0.08829367160797119, 0.04904690757393837, -0.045085106045007706, 0.07113377004861832, 0.04546182230114937, 0.01923654042184353, 0.008646431379020214, -0.03543915972113609, 0.003413801547139883, -0.016233548521995544, 0.02027994953095913, 0.022351855412125587, 0.013341357931494713, 0.0033648547250777483, -0.011551235802471638, 0.03502770885825157, -0.033162884414196014, -0.03616673871874809, -0.008889151737093925, 0.04025691747665405, 0.028642471879720688, 0.00046232377644628286, -0.0314331091940403, 0.03159094229340553, 0.0607791393995285, 0.010038678534328938, 0.00022966587857808918, 0.01501998957246542, -0.08814475685358047, 0.01961878128349781, 0.02730831503868103, 0.033380165696144104, -0.041392989456653595, -0.01604987122118473, -0.006223473697900772, -0.000713955785613507, -0.0006916897254996002, -0.03519606590270996, 0.02508147433400154, 0.00036348606226965785, 0.028937410563230515, -0.027934091165661812, -0.04455289989709854, -0.053618427366018295, 0.025234900414943695, 0.003759316634386778, 0.036968424916267395, -0.01580824889242649, -0.019081778824329376, -0.02366970293223858, 0.03708018362522125, 0.011440659873187542, 0.04199003055691719, -0.024823755025863647, -0.00013979793584439903, 0.03555607795715332, 0.012384950183331966, -0.0036448424216359854, -0.05704408138990402, 0.016603942960500717, -0.002233074279502034, -0.02176007069647312, 0.05655710771679878, -0.002013315912336111, -0.013041485100984573, 0.017555490136146545, 0.02347225323319435, -0.02757946401834488, -0.025742527097463608, 0.013547965325415134, 0.027462709695100784, 0.046090152114629745, 0.027218228206038475, 0.10279320180416107, -0.02230956219136715, -0.017653409391641617, -0.03270549327135086, -0.02384735271334648, 0.025957157835364342, -0.06479564309120178, -0.012553174048662186, -0.03009243682026863, 0.014146465808153152, -0.016690824180841446, 0.024513402953743935, -0.01843396946787834, 0.012308121658861637, -0.03150787577033043, 0.006950953975319862, -0.01924275979399681, 0.010938757099211216, -0.0027301942463964224, -0.04134529083967209, 0.028881818056106567, 0.02330297976732254, -0.028545573353767395, -0.004166977480053902, 0.014140831306576729, -0.034819308668375015, 0.0034695109352469444, 0.017952265217900276, 0.006301837041974068, 0.025742923840880394, -0.023248983547091484, -0.05051521956920624, 0.018760165199637413, -0.009455276653170586, 0.010462647303938866, 0.005702242720872164, 0.033905331045389175, -0.005586160346865654, -0.06325245648622513, -0.016267064958810806, 0.01563413254916668, 0.00981387123465538, 0.03781531751155853, -0.022923650220036507, 0.06822791695594788, -0.06840522587299347, 0.013311358168721199, -0.07221958786249161, -0.031138477846980095, 0.05317237228155136, 0.025695091113448143, 0.00876982044428587, -0.030219782143831253, 0.027504555881023407, -0.03999153524637222, 0.0003395467938389629, -0.018570318818092346, 0.06047853082418442, -0.03704717382788658, -0.03058326244354248, 0.005331776104867458, 0.03632894903421402, 0.03849662467837334, -0.021978486329317093, 0.00908820703625679, 0.03597242757678032, -0.0173332542181015, 0.00021804228890687227, 0.004142326302826405, -0.01595686934888363, -0.039539534598588943, 0.007862349972128868, -0.023692747578024864, -0.03369416296482086, 0.03985295444726944, -0.018985338509082794, 0.00077442527981475, 0.04183978959918022, 0.0018502173479646444, 0.009620394557714462, -0.023712361231446266, -0.013750988058745861, -0.03388514369726181, -0.00010351781384088099, 0.008946347050368786, 0.0395711287856102, -0.005251390393823385, -0.012341772206127644, 0.02105633169412613, -0.032892029732465744, -0.02279435656964779, 0.04975966364145279, 0.062194306403398514, -0.012480237521231174, 0.025411345064640045, -0.02666701003909111, -0.01273435726761818, 0.0417611263692379, 0.023932481184601784, 0.005015796050429344, -0.019464604556560516, -0.002944604028016329, -0.012117207050323486, -0.03720322623848915, 0.009919301606714725, -0.00730758486315608, 0.07389897853136063, -0.02822943590581417, 0.024146420881152153, 0.05899123102426529, -0.0040350500494241714, 0.013942448422312737, -0.03455082327127457, 0.027392102405428886, -0.00460911076515913, 0.00705973245203495, 0.06250621378421783, -0.01807791367173195, -0.010406941175460815, 0.056075844913721085, 0.007741102948784828, 0.02805030159652233, 0.019122205674648285, -0.00008570504724048078, 0.01370395440608263, 0.016030816361308098, -0.04172002896666527, -0.023720186203718185, 0.05176704376935959, -0.05885915458202362, -0.006022623274475336, -0.0308233555406332, -0.006029447540640831, 0.03571634739637375, 0.03684447705745697, 0.023097677156329155, -0.05569275841116905, -0.0024605642538517714, -0.011761597357690334, 0.0019330483628436923, 0.03758460655808449, -0.007536235731095076, 0.02682102657854557, -0.002353254472836852, 0.050167590379714966, 0.025320010259747505, 0.04165755957365036, 0.005948441568762064, -0.05371307581663132, -0.07103557884693146, -0.0003745360882021487, 0.0065095131285488605, 0.03587254881858826, -0.0365867018699646, -0.02199181728065014, 0.0033442657440900803, -0.04179314523935318, 0.008126545697450638, 0.0011352741857990623, 0.06003009155392647, -0.03234970197081566, 0.010148461908102036, 0.03094441257417202, -0.012352066114544868, 0.0313413068652153, -0.04830170050263405, 0.12397065758705139, 0.09021861106157303, 0.04796360060572624, -0.062249962240457535, 0.015501611866056919, 0.0026697064749896526, 0.00781562365591526, -0.008462140336632729, 0.001028803177177906, 0.020082859322428703, -0.005103062838315964, 0.037162862718105316, 0.04689161106944084, -0.0030228234827518463, -0.02039768546819687, 0.05185559019446373, -0.017091087996959686, 0.012669786810874939, 0.004880289081484079, 0.018472086638212204, 0.011270920746028423, -0.020810740068554878, -0.0156394075602293, -0.010648987255990505, -0.03139713779091835, 0.007934554480016232, 0.005186412017792463, -0.026614509522914886, 0.001362127368338406, 0.008948326110839844, -0.020124128088355064, 0.03519041836261749, 0.0003070945094805211, 0.012216772884130478, -0.016386527568101883, 0.006679009646177292, 0.0075111170299351215, -0.016101760789752007, 0.00655757263302803, 0.037042636424303055, -0.03442825749516487, 0.010427569970488548, -0.002306876704096794, 0.04016570374369621, -0.04063430428504944, -0.026660926640033722, -0.005846125539392233, 0.0603296272456646, 0.028987634927034378, 0.00007264475425472483, 0.006166092120110989, -0.021345527842640877, 0.007483839523047209, -0.011042694561183453, -0.02934407815337181, 0.027434470131993294, 0.009531236253678799, -0.048820070922374725, 0.0253155380487442, -0.01804777979850769, 0.017677124589681625, -0.010930212214589119, 0.01061819214373827, 0.03951727971434593, -0.028443528339266777, 0.0046884529292583466, -0.021571464836597443, 0.0487193688750267, 0.025740331038832664, 0.006865059956908226, -0.007765715941786766, -0.013673229143023491, -0.05421176925301552, -0.009702427312731743, 0.01401037909090519, 0.023660212755203247, 0.026150405406951904, -0.025025997310876846, -0.006673931609839201, -0.04782547801733017, -0.03539203479886055, 0.0051497844979166985, 0.011706423945724964, -0.006100133527070284, -0.06660101562738419, -0.005036595743149519, 0.04777104780077934, 0.04052095115184784, 0.008190333843231201, -0.009767954237759113, 0.013033824972808361, 0.028894290328025818, 0.009435667656362057, -0.0480073019862175, -0.009638438932597637, 0.01424340344965458, -0.015689488500356674, 0.0038977484218776226, -0.013231479562819004, 0.06425183266401291, 0.014351477846503258, 0.00607568072155118, 0.014305289834737778, 0.044966548681259155, -0.026581306010484695, 0.02849860116839409, 0.015002703294157982, -0.07225394994020462, -0.0029886045958846807, 0.015378785319626331, 0.003951017279177904, -0.014936022460460663, -0.039303019642829895, -0.06054266542196274, -0.03153068944811821, 0.028432339429855347, -0.006367185618728399, -0.019498310983181, 0.005071636755019426, -0.004113522358238697, 0.01900334283709526, -0.033549387007951736, -0.0076619707979261875, -0.07397586852312088, 0.02445901185274124, 0.01718161068856716, -0.035670943558216095, -0.016745390370488167, -0.015564273111522198, -0.022592483088374138, 0.001995823811739683, 0.022207334637641907, 0.023905089125037193, -0.019422097131609917, -0.05378147214651108, 0.02334938943386078, 0.027279213070869446, 0.057071976363658905, 0.01759183593094349, -0.010410775430500507, 0.04083121195435524, -0.06028322875499725, -0.04373909533023834, 0.024155791848897934, -0.001338970148935914, 0.025298889726400375, 0.020561091601848602, 0.013526318594813347, -0.038670409470796585, 0.019687490537762642, -0.034024279564619064, -0.017711007967591286, -0.007446561940014362, -0.007935689762234688, 0.007179010193794966, 0.0028808307833969593, 0.04933718219399452, 0.019507599994540215, 0.011302364990115166, 0.017711475491523743, 0.018400387838482857, 0.02594408392906189, 0.021052196621894836, -0.02819792740046978, 0.004739147145301104, 0.048784539103507996, -0.006390188820660114, -0.015936627984046936, -0.010205578058958054, 0.034010834991931915, -0.014947994612157345, 0.027162333950400352, 0.018400590866804123, 0.0536189042031765, -0.09206892549991608, -0.03743111342191696, -0.005015294533222914, 0.015010528266429901, 0.006590696517378092, -0.04480432718992233, 0.023959707468748093, 0.007439114153385162, -0.05097208544611931, 0.028640741482377052, -0.04263674095273018, 0.015135505236685276, -0.045412175357341766, -0.034179043024778366, -0.022154157981276512, 0.03499055281281471, 0.05158068612217903, 0.01124393567442894, 0.016441112384200096, -0.007152447942644358, 0.04472921043634415, -0.014416208490729332, 0.0014820151263847947, 0.015971243381500244, -0.017131010070443153, -0.06505146622657776, 0.012758206576108932, -0.035803817212581635, -0.06913390010595322, 0.010567598044872284, -0.005031852517277002, 0.019321028143167496, 0.008280888199806213, 0.02320205233991146, 0.013252475298941135, 0.06978153437376022, 0.027433404698967934, -0.027997542172670364, -0.005956884939223528, 0.01990457996726036, 0.014299380593001842, 0.02791639231145382, -0.00946247112005949, -0.017070289701223373, -0.0005138549022376537, -0.019672278314828873, -0.04550788924098015, -0.016052370890975, 0.011701180599629879, -0.03840310871601105, -0.013350019231438637, 0.007493802811950445, -0.0024461383000016212, -0.014870419166982174, -0.000603891268838197, -0.05623072385787964, -0.009708953090012074, 0.04226146265864372, 0.025071846321225166, -0.03574893996119499, 0.045149438083171844, -0.037803731858730316, -0.027238445356488228, 0.01639718934893608, -0.00016738346312195063, 0.023554442450404167, -0.07065894454717636, 0.0019842705223709345, 0.017399299889802933, -0.018065081909298897, -0.05644187331199646, 0.023911932483315468, -0.04277394711971283, 0.01460353098809719, -0.034732893109321594, 0.009069643914699554, -0.01694662682712078, -0.05632425472140312, 0.038023144006729126, -0.0673941820859909, 0.05056309700012207, 0.005503242369741201, -0.008715980686247349, -0.028240125626325607, 0.012845908291637897, -0.0463763065636158, 0.009845695458352566, 0.025355521589517593, 0.018423454836010933, -0.015216495841741562, -0.027828942984342575, 0.029958169907331467, -0.0007202940178103745, -0.06510547548532486, 0.03906127065420151, -0.0054548648186028, -0.004080930259078741, -0.044634267687797546, -0.006866494659334421, 0.011971067637205124, 0.017583666369318962, 0.02136673592031002, -0.003864097874611616, 0.03479991480708122, 0.017872681841254234, 0.021418215706944466, 0.04723439738154411, 0.031241370365023613, 0.009201842360198498, 0.0201368797570467, 0.029462359845638275, 0.02552894502878189, 0.055083390325307846, -0.0001710271608317271, -0.05034003034234047, 0.023932136595249176, -0.007735951337963343, -0.03254975005984306, 0.02277618646621704, 0.041416216641664505, -0.005798832047730684, -0.031230473890900612, 0.021096672862768173, -0.00037716340739279985, -0.031772758811712265, -0.00756302522495389, 0.0458822026848793, 0.005945931654423475, 0.019903765991330147, -0.00048704256187193096, 0.032936032861471176, -0.013987341895699501, -0.053822822868824005, -0.026744015514850616, -0.0073334635235369205, 0.013375937938690186, 0.033793721348047256, 0.029250936582684517, 0.04183170199394226, -0.03579041361808777, -0.008544649928808212, -0.007480545900762081, 0.039662811905145645, -0.022163547575473785, 0.004328248556703329, 0.010582677088677883, -0.026998654007911682, 0.02405192330479622, -0.005372387357056141, -0.007818968035280704, 0.045636389404535294, -0.05582490563392639, -0.01884007640182972, -0.031134892255067825, -0.02471543662250042, 0.00535848643630743, 0.0213655736297369, -0.015289214439690113, 0.02937970496714115, -0.007656480185687542, 0.01271549891680479, -0.02391084097325802, -0.011383777484297752, 0.03059879131615162, -0.03248592093586922, 0.025920281186699867, -0.01597488485276699, -0.006645599380135536, -0.037238672375679016, -0.01853335276246071, -0.026758350431919098, -0.04294775426387787, 0.047724124044179916, 0.048509348183870316, 0.0002415767521597445, -0.049204230308532715, -0.04716162011027336, -0.054383017122745514, 0.031272657215595245, -0.018793417140841484, -0.010759529657661915, -0.04966620355844498, 0.025294257327914238, 0.03723898530006409, 0.014292038045823574 ]
<p>Suppose $U_{(1)} , \dots , U_{(n)}$ is order statistics a random sample from $U(0,1)$.how can find joint Probability density function limit distribution of statistics $T_n=(nU_{(1)},nU_{(2)}).$</p>
36,288
[ -0.007144670467823744, -0.03726653754711151, 0.005954058840870857, -0.005197558086365461, 0.014834882691502571, 0.043212078511714935, 0.00496215233579278, 0.00972836185246706, 0.021533355116844177, -0.04491312801837921, 0.057071465998888016, 0.028238017112016678, 0.054430801421403885, 0.045646484941244125, 0.02837221324443817, 0.02748565562069416, -0.04949905350804329, 0.04169141873717308, -0.03591809421777725, -0.05043269321322441, -0.003960674162954092, 0.014783842489123344, 0.035339657217264175, -0.012409896589815617, -0.04735890030860901, 0.006152189802378416, 0.0050034592859447, -0.011060330085456371, 0.014071332290768623, 0.05009487643837929, -0.03879857808351517, -0.049598515033721924, 0.0031982064247131348, 0.018318654969334602, -0.0089417127892375, 0.0005034225177951157, -0.022788498550653458, -0.046874888241291046, 0.014174764044582844, -0.009206859394907951, -0.07261806726455688, -0.06817791610956192, -0.00992890726774931, -0.012102951295673847, 0.017754623666405678, 0.011225643567740917, -0.0025316188111901283, -0.040746770799160004, 0.028045151382684708, -0.0311244186013937, 0.08007174730300903, 0.0007666395395062864, 0.025102321058511734, 0.007939227856695652, -0.006491913925856352, -0.0008408566354773939, 0.02192692644894123, 0.06175217032432556, 0.013476614840328693, -0.016792574897408485, 0.024700528010725975, -0.023971332237124443, 0.01050595659762621, -0.043899040669202805, -0.019253648817539215, 0.03408730775117874, -0.055800821632146835, 0.009522018022835255, -0.05484309419989586, -0.0071541862562298775, 0.010951798409223557, 0.024451367557048798, 0.05469142273068428, -0.026712121441960335, 0.011018062010407448, 0.006290118210017681, 0.01685013808310032, -0.012068373151123524, 0.0518309511244297, 0.03305621072649956, 0.020918700844049454, 0.05208016186952591, 0.02256353385746479, 0.020512240007519722, -0.01256584096699953, -0.01693384163081646, 0.08088088780641556, 0.007431035861372948, 0.018345871940255165, 0.021896757185459137, 0.008341857232153416, -0.022984186187386513, 0.011759904213249683, 0.0036897154059261084, -0.03536191210150719, -0.015132038854062557, -0.014045195654034615, 0.0030225066002458334, -0.047168344259262085, -0.03260912001132965, 0.012525002472102642, -0.05589547008275986, 0.002123337471857667, 0.04712490364909172, -0.03465757146477699, -0.008797687478363514, -0.02218456380069256, -0.005314494948834181, -0.028790775686502457, 0.004614092409610748, -0.03510688990354538, 0.027916938066482544, -0.019766943529248238, 0.0025515789166092873, 0.008868538774549961, 0.03909151256084442, 0.012839219532907009, -0.026129160076379776, 0.044684454798698425, 0.06816067546606064, 0.07891577482223511, 0.009071643464267254, 0.017763083800673485, -0.011546454392373562, -0.06042797490954399, 0.023834936320781708, 0.03174446523189545, 0.006374687422066927, -0.02434786781668663, 0.05149540677666664, -0.04987889155745506, -0.0030581329483538866, 0.022114239633083344, 0.006318885367363691, 0.0012219176860526204, 0.009268798865377903, -0.0902065858244896, -0.0099862702190876, 0.0017999408300966024, -0.026275092735886574, 0.01169141661375761, -0.05251232534646988, 0.052712369710206985, 0.037159696221351624, -0.02634165808558464, 0.008797341957688332, 0.05763941630721092, -0.025086702778935432, 0.02435349114239216, 0.007294769864529371, 0.0006736590876244009, -0.021046841517090797, -0.03743987902998924, -0.019008619710803032, 0.033988770097494125, -0.061573393642902374, 0.02672632224857807, -0.000019185099517926574, -0.022168966010212898, -0.05857608839869499, 0.05301054194569588, -0.0009271411108784378, 0.025306575000286102, -0.03122887574136257, 0.005624269600957632, -0.03331577032804489, 0.07056048512458801, 0.002669053850695491, 0.0337069146335125, 0.027206426486372948, -0.024424517527222633, 0.022841788828372955, 0.03481848165392876, 0.05497344955801964, 0.008260552771389484, -0.03795928508043289, -0.02795557677745819, -0.010171658359467983, 0.022135358303785324, 0.026512810960412025, -0.009688098914921284, 0.026181159541010857, -0.006904745940119028, -0.003090354846790433, -0.013094648718833923, -0.02891499176621437, 0.02138294279575348, -0.01744350790977478, -0.013184714131057262, -0.08162720501422882, 0.007122926879674196, -0.059818170964717865, -0.01619640178978443, 0.013496369123458862, -0.017064698040485382, 0.03202145919203758, -0.01105143316090107, 0.03569285199046135, -0.010435706004500389, -0.011838013306260109, -0.05471577122807503, -0.016387300565838814, 0.000351051363395527, -0.029818596318364143, 0.028057286515831947, 0.03170960396528244, 0.04401356726884842, 0.002203454962000251, 0.06132661551237106, -0.049362972378730774, -0.02396455407142639, 0.03287946432828903, -0.03846568986773491, 0.0071071358397603035, 0.0010735372779890895, -0.0033549393992871046, 0.018602246418595314, -0.007584833074361086, 0.004206575453281403, 0.006079136393964291, -0.02625664882361889, 0.034962672740221024, 0.09429291635751724, -0.0012798879761248827, -0.008167321793735027, -0.008554304949939251, 0.009936791844666004, 0.017854830250144005, -0.017362497746944427, -0.010635112412273884, -0.038450513035058975, 0.01103958673775196, 0.04849293455481529, 0.06893268972635269, -0.037275876849889755, 0.020332740619778633, 0.03980611264705658, -0.019731024280190468, 0.011003520339727402, -0.0029047001153230667, -0.0245959535241127, -0.01900208182632923, 0.01180408988147974, 0.032856136560440063, 0.02173374406993389, -0.001555920927785337, -0.033501699566841125, 0.011075596325099468, 0.016802532598376274, -0.0189895648509264, -0.050305116921663284, 0.06065163388848305, -0.022598257288336754, -0.0030975874979048967, 0.014665346592664719, -0.03503967821598053, 0.015992403030395508, -0.009977543726563454, -0.0225435309112072, -0.017799584195017815, 0.00959788914769888, 0.018854398280382156, 0.05132734030485153, -0.018730534240603447, 0.061348527669906616, 0.024754591286182404, -0.03958570212125778, -0.05527815595269203, 0.033820174634456635, -0.02861473523080349, -0.02511502616107464, -0.014088435098528862, -0.06261790543794632, -0.03789471462368965, -0.010933325625956059, 0.04504537954926491, 0.01196445245295763, -0.015833882614970207, -0.0293385349214077, -0.018741508945822716, 0.01166629046201706, 0.006096049211919308, -0.0025869866367429495, -0.004103681538254023, -0.05744335055351257, 0.0099155493080616, 0.020624050870537758, -0.03533310443162918, -0.011540684849023819, 0.009519779123365879, 0.015555718913674355, 0.025450048968195915, -0.01169668696820736, -0.05521554872393608, -0.0514504499733448, -0.013903389684855938, 0.006622754968702793, -0.019981058314442635, -0.015221170149743557, 0.04031002148985863, 0.004024778958410025, -0.03417418524622917, 0.02500411681830883, -0.04094332084059715, -0.052941787987947464, -0.041868750005960464, 0.049128517508506775, 0.04678740352392197, -0.005584891885519028, 0.06456103175878525, -0.01536069717258215, 0.011776333674788475, -0.03238360211253166, -0.05876028910279274, -0.02399016171693802, 0.024629052728414536, 0.003467333037406206, 0.060606591403484344, 0.01509147323668003, -0.05058445408940315, 0.04861491918563843, 0.03063386119902134, -0.029445180669426918, -0.013117481023073196, -0.004382675979286432, -0.009648486040532589, 0.03685333952307701, 0.026976939290761948, 0.014200830832123756, 0.0034272412303835154, 0.016903867945075035, 0.0370035283267498, 0.030306925997138023, 0.06802335381507874, -0.014615632593631744, 0.019986571744084358, 0.016264040023088455, 0.008257897570729256, 0.0027394869830459356, -0.0011733616702258587, -0.011798130348324776, -0.011420970782637596, 0.028605464845895767, 0.0036893533542752266, 0.024460354819893837, 0.017451688647270203, -0.02670413628220558, 0.027935726568102837, -0.02621382102370262, -0.006380499340593815, -0.04515595734119415, 0.06512945145368576, 0.059162165969610214, -0.014002891257405281, -0.00563696026802063, 0.036823663860559464, 0.019761789590120316, -0.014604423195123672, 0.030409744009375572, 0.02783716656267643, 0.04959309101104736, -0.02288181707262993, -0.04308215156197548, -0.02396383509039879, 0.008995887823402882, 0.04839606583118439, -0.016589026898145676, -0.0128173204138875, -0.0016651335172355175, 0.038647424429655075, 0.007150192745029926, -0.018132001161575317, -0.005325618665665388, 0.008851760067045689, -0.025790628045797348, 0.002754661487415433, -0.024564068764448166, 0.06660819798707962, 0.015518316067755222, 0.07178112864494324, 0.01512448862195015, -0.0007197157246991992, 0.013400927186012268, 0.005555074196308851, -0.052744194865226746, -0.003479855367913842, -0.012284785509109497, 0.010781320743262768, -0.026582904160022736, 0.0008634289260953665, 0.026113126426935196, 0.006665070075541735, 0.039363473653793335, 0.008759933523833752, 0.005701933056116104, -0.053104218095541, -0.007572348229587078, -0.039332315325737, -0.022409707307815552, 0.02566242404282093, 0.03154031187295914, 0.014535007067024708, -0.017424201592803, 0.034299105405807495, 0.00966380164027214, -0.003798289690166712, -0.0057298713363707066, -0.014456847682595253, 0.03411727026104927, 0.0004958328790962696, 0.031337086111307144, 0.004278563428670168, 0.03440612554550171, -0.04703743755817413, 0.012024752795696259, -0.02765030600130558, 0.08139923214912415, 0.04332907497882843, 0.0066850692965090275, -0.017251938581466675, -0.0122145414352417, -0.001048063742928207, 0.001374987419694662, 0.020015178248286247, 0.0016185796121135354, -0.02916463278234005, 0.04830199107527733, 0.003083158051595092, -0.05577130988240242, 0.03658682107925415, 0.030322108417749405, 0.035432007163763046, 0.03608494624495506, -0.032478269189596176, -0.005991775076836348, -0.025116100907325745, -0.011519087478518486, 0.03224421292543411, -0.004128698259592056, -0.018830623477697372, 0.010799122042953968, 0.06011415645480156, 0.025106778368353844, -0.03564393147826195, -0.034680482000112534, 0.04434378445148468, 0.06570756435394287, 0.007202595937997103, -0.044419120997190475, 0.00527875404804945, 0.026103084906935692, 0.0345771387219429, 0.03183289244771004, 0.008113013580441475, -0.026006678119301796, 0.018714014440774918, 0.034014903008937836, -0.04332415387034416, -0.019758306443691254, 0.030541913583874702, -0.043501485139131546, 0.01504613272845745, 0.03501642122864723, -0.01770727150142193, 0.020091714337468147, 0.018048394471406937, 0.004215269349515438, 0.009382715448737144, -0.00918126106262207, -0.049063123762607574, 0.024022560566663742, -0.011488111689686775, -0.00953963864594698, -0.006574945989996195, 0.011859742924571037, -0.04573674872517586, 0.021838661283254623, 0.0100033488124609, 0.0569908507168293, -0.029565071687102318, -0.008736342191696167, 0.006328285671770573, 0.0011093048378825188, 0.016048355028033257, -0.07657288014888763, 0.059148311614990234, -0.01372817624360323, 0.015430479310452938, 0.03692755103111267, -0.04086577147245407, -0.02679784782230854, 0.013700775802135468, -0.024019572883844376, -0.005710997153073549, 0.03373459726572037, 0.006899811793118715, 0.05887475982308388, 0.008158210664987564, -0.013038041070103645, 0.0370323471724987, -0.02595437876880169, 0.05584895983338356, -0.00806555338203907, -0.020937522873282433, 0.047647520899772644, -0.06117802858352661, 0.015509859658777714, -0.012762398459017277, 0.014127380214631557, -0.02971697598695755, 0.03788161277770996, -0.013165674172341824, 0.015831293538212776, -0.02784700319170952, -0.01205976027995348, 0.005534169729799032, 0.013819093815982342, 0.028546126559376717, 0.01692318171262741, -0.04940711706876755, 0.017483992502093315, 0.005772216245532036, 0.0034744380973279476, 0.03452379256486893, -0.017743941396474838, -0.00151829665992409, 0.008909831754863262, -0.006191690918058157, 0.01694803684949875, -0.04259204491972923, -0.022732563316822052, -0.006688334979116917, -0.05224636569619179, 0.027839776128530502, -0.01984282210469246, 0.007603084668517113, 0.016195978969335556, -0.008141343481838703, 0.004270012956112623, 0.006948692724108696, 0.017512604594230652, 0.04753628373146057, -0.04136710986495018, 0.03827594965696335, 0.01891646347939968, -0.023426245898008347, -0.10368078202009201, -0.027542486786842346, 0.03009585663676262, 0.010258551687002182, -0.0029906935524195433, -0.0660824403166771, 0.01925811916589737, -0.01252703182399273, -0.01569250039756298, -0.014479008503258228, 0.03506485000252724, 0.026495080441236496, -0.05153919756412506, -0.01546124555170536, 0.012709561735391617, 0.06579843163490295, 0.00616057263687253, -0.0029921301174908876, 0.034614771604537964, -0.005839560180902481, -0.026968758553266525, -0.004547289106994867, 0.006915438920259476, -0.011434081010520458, 0.005243250634521246, -0.03199348226189613, -0.03655286133289337, 0.0335644893348217, -0.04612015560269356, -0.014195389114320278, 0.0350094810128212, 0.05176142603158951, 0.0017278579762205482, -0.025475839152932167, -0.026931196451187134, -0.009591910988092422, -0.0367061048746109, -0.017576968297362328, -0.02956835739314556, -0.01714547537267208, -0.015161823481321335, 0.022845575585961342, -0.023010365664958954, -0.015323265455663204, 0.04254138097167015, 0.0633513405919075, -0.00008904303831513971, -0.03803294897079468, -0.008606444112956524, -0.010167148895561695, -0.01134400349110365, 0.0047687022015452385, -0.01405404694378376, 0.04940955713391304, -0.000035527129512047395, -0.015415324829518795, -0.013745727948844433, -0.0516991950571537, -0.006406900007277727, 0.06253490597009659, -0.020867355167865753, 0.061441272497177124, 0.04421553760766983, 0.008152863010764122, -0.004755489062517881, 0.024324165657162666, -0.005506879184395075, -0.02324318327009678, 0.012212336994707584, 0.03250318765640259, -0.013390163891017437, -0.0037580293137580156, 0.0463670939207077, -0.009534550830721855, 0.0331236757338047, 0.0656759962439537, -0.023754891008138657, 0.0069967168383300304, 0.023757528513669968, -0.020644184201955795, -0.020341558381915092, 0.0079105319455266, -0.04396796226501465, -0.00011826988338725641, -0.0035792868584394455, -0.016812220215797424, 0.042705003172159195, 0.023240724578499794, 0.00382427079603076, -0.014889813028275967, -0.04369601607322693, -0.0316106416285038, 0.013105886057019234, 0.0038832486607134342, 0.019821494817733765, 0.025960033759474754, 0.03786518797278404, 0.019907508045434952, -0.022316252812743187, 0.050527047365903854, 0.013625704683363438, -0.04943925142288208, -0.03232958912849426, 0.0012729112058877945, -0.06531374901533127, 0.03554462641477585, -0.006991454400122166, -0.01090425904840231, 0.03894113376736641, -0.015834905207157135, -0.005861910060048103, 0.03174951672554016, 0.024967219680547714, -0.022418826818466187, 0.09248218685388565, 0.05756479129195213, 0.062113527208566666, 0.01368772890418768, -0.006917539518326521, 0.12448917329311371, 0.05275474861264229, 0.0198411513119936, -0.0582205168902874, -0.004549490753561258, -0.0033391008619219065, -0.011954877525568008, -0.05421010032296181, 0.011617055162787437, 0.03249066323041916, 0.012283767573535442, 0.04381938278675079, 0.0607667900621891, 0.005480004940181971, 0.00497848866507411, 0.04440324008464813, -0.012931155040860176, -0.029911357909440994, 0.014189394190907478, 0.03441326692700386, -0.01448483020067215, -0.004803297109901905, -0.059173669666051865, -0.006756613031029701, 0.005738911684602499, -0.007215574383735657, -0.04461221396923065, -0.04546738788485527, 0.008122206665575504, -0.01685180515050888, -0.002171924337744713, -0.012819877825677395, 0.03429097309708595, -0.010831734165549278, -0.03587959706783295, -0.029623255133628845, -0.039301540702581406, -0.04941205307841301, 0.010569700039923191, 0.04498066380620003, 0.010625327937304974, 0.0007042323122732341, 0.010511613450944424, -0.004204180557280779, -0.02244630828499794, 0.00253125443123281, -0.04025372862815857, 0.00422723637893796, -0.0344528891146183, 0.0386703722178936, -0.01647351309657097, 0.008451506495475769, -0.01455773413181305, -0.03393673151731491, -0.009593360126018524, 0.032758910208940506, 0.04638773575425148, -0.022607164457440376, -0.01727643795311451, -0.047240860760211945, 0.012079795822501183, 0.000454280583653599, 0.04101454094052315, 0.037280332297086716, -0.06000717356801033, -0.012210851535201073, -0.006649504881352186, 0.047442734241485596, -0.012082903645932674, -0.002728785388171673, -0.010983161628246307, 0.00930503848940134, -0.010800940915942192, 0.00550687313079834, 0.004274317529052496, -0.030086921527981758, 0.022715555503964424, 0.044952139258384705, -0.012733886949717999, -0.01422522496432066, -0.046993087977170944, -0.024519992992281914, -0.02857551909983158, -0.01721346192061901, -0.0045281462371349335, 0.0013894462026655674, 0.026753783226013184, 0.05359223857522011, 0.028320588171482086, -0.011376800946891308, 0.009309420362114906, 0.045256439596414566, 0.045480258762836456, -0.04045884683728218, 0.0021589105017483234, 0.0022930719424039125, 0.009433376602828503, 0.025701310485601425, -0.015478232875466347, 0.036189496517181396, 0.0595930740237236, 0.010689404793083668, 0.019042201340198517, 0.007498296443372965, -0.03593457490205765, 0.015366352163255215, -0.028698118403553963, -0.04133293032646179, 0.011514795012772083, 0.04817258566617966, -0.026099596172571182, -0.004095199517905712, -0.06589160114526749, -0.022119181230664253, -0.028463860973715782, 0.02312263660132885, -0.0008755542221479118, -0.012194758281111717, -0.05043193697929382, 0.0027928841300308704, 0.03468310832977295, -0.0002578812709543854, -0.01361753884702921, -0.009453397244215012, -0.016901247203350067, -0.01164420135319233, 0.027463274076581, -0.03781028464436531, 0.01779354177415371, 0.0034365353640168905, 0.0014974181540310383, 0.012220164760947227, 0.0004280837019905448, 0.017142657190561295, -0.024708814918994904, -0.02272905223071575, -0.005784472916275263, 0.033398814499378204, 0.017549239099025726, 0.000046367826143978164, 0.04052453488111496, -0.05979035422205925, -0.034496892243623734, 0.006384680513292551, 0.021511675789952278, 0.06207427382469177, -0.005876860581338406, 0.012216352857649326, -0.025986842811107635, 0.0176747627556324, -0.05991790443658829, 0.005942481569945812, -0.013473223894834518, 0.019629620015621185, 0.019976869225502014, -0.007897532545030117, -0.01342209056019783, 0.007665958255529404, 0.0011779250344261527, -0.006140373181551695, 0.04306523874402046, 0.00811826717108488, -0.007456815801560879, 0.04497786611318588, 0.0005707273376174271, 0.02356230467557907, -0.024402113631367683, -0.0061265816912055016, 0.037040479481220245, 0.04663332551717758, -0.027019262313842773, 0.0005962211289443076, -0.041830699890851974, 0.005033774301409721, -0.08849811553955078, -0.051353342831134796, 0.01862195134162903, -0.004216549918055534, 0.055628444999456406, 0.007152163423597813, -0.009924945421516895, 0.03611033037304878, -0.001472577336244285, 0.03950624540448189, -0.000947779044508934, -0.012715090997517109, -0.02518189139664173, -0.0016246625455096364, -0.04909113049507141, 0.04410107806324959, 0.024891994893550873, 0.032287124544382095, 0.042007677257061005, 0.038885314017534256, -0.0026208965573459864, 0.013322514481842518, -0.016410551965236664, -0.0060173990204930305, 0.010219831019639969, -0.030482610687613487, 0.07554765045642853, -0.0591856986284256, -0.0181602630764246, 0.04104702174663544, 0.03352440148591995, -0.018438946455717087, 0.009751536883413792, 0.014732743613421917, -0.025992901995778084, 0.01795775443315506, 0.016781724989414215, -0.011232654564082623, 0.00021005615417379886, -0.002472329419106245, 0.022623777389526367, -0.014504117891192436, -0.06760738790035248, -0.02043420635163784, 0.05847020447254181, -0.008649451658129692, -0.06415089219808578, 0.03610140457749367, 0.009540303610265255, -0.058632224798202515, -0.015387569554150105, -0.01480214111506939, -0.017914636060595512, -0.03744381293654442, 0.04302477091550827, -0.02391054295003414, -0.032281119376420975, -0.00010633513011271134, 0.02062954194843769, -0.02191946841776371, 0.026800859719514847, -0.003088616766035557, -0.03937646746635437, 0.018127894029021263, -0.013728211633861065, -0.015954768285155296, -0.03796205297112465, 0.031006889417767525, -0.014669905416667461, 0.009428353048861027, -0.023369237780570984, -0.05211932212114334, -0.03659567981958389, 0.010796737857162952, 0.005438711494207382, -0.011124313808977604, 0.025106308981776237, 0.008108081296086311, -0.020856497809290886, -0.05791477859020233, 0.03417649120092392, 0.015214142389595509, -0.049104202538728714, -0.004575290251523256, 0.0006480176816694438, 0.004096643067896366, 0.0235544852912426, 0.05546977370977402, 0.059359606355428696, -0.010660344734787941, 0.008104718290269375, 0.03494173288345337, 0.026468073949217796, -0.04844691604375839, 0.00716791395097971, -0.04141935333609581, -0.016427241265773773, -0.011567985638976097, -0.00662829726934433, 0.03238348662853241, 0.029147623106837273, -0.03408721089363098, -0.004276381339877844, -0.025879062712192535, 0.007987073622643948, -0.014126941561698914, 0.01706315577030182, -0.023943696171045303, 0.009683738462626934, 0.0538429319858551, -0.06383117288351059, 0.009592208079993725, -0.019007401540875435, -0.015940077602863312, -0.06931307166814804, 0.01875997707247734, -0.024710271507501602, -0.034205809235572815, -0.053161296993494034, 0.020361213013529778, 0.024250492453575134, -0.05466824024915695, -0.04895475134253502, 0.005493770353496075, -0.057834427803754807, 0.044869519770145416, -0.0028765120077878237, 0.03343638777732849, 0.04575986787676811, -0.012967344373464584, -0.001544960425235331, 0.0048108478076756, -0.03345032408833504, 0.051770515739917755, 0.02599557861685753, -0.006374564953148365, -0.020522605627775192, 0.0012750455643981695, 0.013479727320373058, -0.0400293692946434, 0.01925457827746868, -0.0023978499229997396, 0.014932394027709961, -0.008860421366989613, -0.01086525060236454, 0.037178006023168564, -0.03579074516892433, -0.0005059493123553693, 0.027237102389335632, -0.021122800186276436, 0.060468655079603195, -0.039954718202352524, 0.025058459490537643, -0.032923661172389984, -0.028277546167373657, -0.06227443367242813, 0.0016896214801818132, 0.022358637303113937, 0.011442895047366619, -0.050312649458646774, 0.01827104762196541, 0.008213530294597149, -0.03732835501432419, 0.030752258375287056, -0.01621389202773571, -0.01935664936900139, 0.006633316166698933, 0.011763821355998516, 0.013059751130640507, -0.07073938846588135, -0.03689589351415634, -0.045873336493968964, 0.05110856890678406, 0.014482512138783932, 0.044179510325193405, 0.004147008527070284, -0.008140761405229568, 0.0031531492713838816, 0.05944636091589928, -0.06301061809062958, -0.02788202464580536, -0.04143346846103668, -0.014577783644199371, 0.019610563293099403, -0.041020479053258896 ]
<p>My question is exactly the title : to whom can we report a problem with SAS ?</p> <p>Below is an example. This problem is not really severe but somewhat dangerous (in fact I have just updated my example below after Aniko's comment; there was a confusion in the first version of this post). </p> <p>Consider such a dataset:</p> <pre><code>&gt; dat tube position y 1 1 top 0.25602779 2 1 top 2.99327392 3 1 top 0.03673459 4 1 top -0.94515391 5 1 bottom 9.12947343 6 1 bottom 5.96666893 7 1 bottom 6.65291454 8 2 top -2.32616858 9 2 top -1.61491564 10 2 top -2.88930533 11 2 top -1.48685691 12 2 bottom 0.03474644 13 2 bottom 4.23073725 14 2 bottom 1.43776713 15 3 top 3.04525229 16 3 top -1.06611380 17 3 top 0.64097731 18 3 bottom 5.63571519 19 3 bottom 5.96779074 20 3 bottom 2.14091389 21 3 bottom 5.46937089 22 4 top 7.00724734 23 4 top 4.33632991 24 4 top 1.90765886 25 4 top 1.91688415 26 4 bottom 9.54251973 27 4 bottom 6.88220097 28 4 bottom 3.62175779 29 5 top 6.38900310 30 5 top 7.19216388 31 5 top 8.29793550 32 5 bottom 9.46722783 33 5 bottom 9.11261143 34 5 bottom 11.08097843 35 6 top -1.05244281 36 6 top -0.86450352 37 6 top -0.66251724 38 6 top -1.29278055 39 6 bottom 4.99175539 40 6 bottom 3.92459045 41 6 bottom 6.90398638 </code></pre> <p>This SAS model</p> <pre><code>PROC MIXED DATA=dat ; CLASS POSITION TUBE ; MODEL y = POSITION / cl ; RANDOM POSITION / type=CS subject=TUBE ; RUN; QUIT; </code></pre> <p>is theoretically equivalent to this other SAS model (the marginal models are the same):</p> <pre><code>PROC MIXED DATA=dat ; CLASS POSITION TUBE ; MODEL y = POSITION / cl ; RANDOM TUBE TUBE*POSITION; RUN; QUIT; </code></pre> <p>However the two models yield the same estimates and standard errors but they yield completely different degrees of freedom for the estimates (with the default option). </p>
73,793
[ -0.013902729377150536, -0.02524695359170437, -0.005138430278748274, -0.04366157576441765, -0.0005850627203471959, 0.02507275715470314, -0.0009777873056009412, -0.007332480512559414, -0.0005157948471605778, -0.05916853994131088, 0.04767240211367607, 0.04280281066894531, 0.027835160493850708, 0.043235115706920624, 0.03022623434662819, 0.03201519697904587, -0.016147654503583908, 0.028395606204867363, -0.008586672134697437, -0.020246382802724838, 0.03218564763665199, -0.0022571897134184837, 0.004920218139886856, -0.04297760874032974, -0.0014282244956120849, 0.005548728629946709, 0.04109501466155052, -0.0054115476086735725, -0.008024001494050026, 0.03319386765360832, -0.01450977474451065, 0.0000784404473961331, 0.04336639866232872, -0.038663990795612335, 0.013525434769690037, 0.005315976217389107, -0.016183966770768166, 0.009637860581278801, -0.06739594787359238, 0.019392231479287148, -0.015921590849757195, 0.013005856424570084, 0.035656049847602844, 0.046755220741033554, -0.013683146797120571, 0.027534732595086098, -0.021649489179253578, 0.04830240085721016, 0.03874444216489792, -0.018475381657481194, 0.04425531253218651, -0.004442228004336357, 0.030442768707871437, 0.009328640066087246, -0.03262009471654892, 0.012059581466019154, 0.04445471614599228, 0.02937985211610794, -0.011155844666063786, -0.05891899764537811, -0.031902458518743515, 0.007073563523590565, -0.039008837193250656, 0.014748708344995975, -0.0038067526184022427, 0.0162392295897007, -0.026734018698334694, -0.01123170368373394, -0.03677473962306976, -0.04233676940202713, -0.01593915745615959, -0.0011844425462186337, 0.023961782455444336, -0.03379764035344124, 0.050603996962308884, -0.014289109967648983, 0.028923586010932922, 0.018433580175042152, 0.030043313279747963, 0.012648489326238632, -0.007282508537173271, -0.013019662350416183, 0.00847094226628542, 0.05423727259039879, 0.02954254485666752, -0.02291887067258358, 0.05510351434350014, -0.04420395568013191, 0.061999838799238205, 0.0309306550770998, 0.01098437700420618, 0.01908770389854908, 0.040918827056884766, 0.01740925759077072, -0.012856475077569485, 0.0033717898186296225, 0.0283625740557909, 0.039980463683605194, -0.005742666777223349, -0.007198163773864508, 0.01916039176285267, -0.06013742834329605, 0.03499620780348778, 0.05831930786371231, -0.01074647344648838, -0.05438842251896858, -0.015625322237610817, -0.014945206232368946, -0.013262173160910606, -0.036900654435157776, -0.040521040558815, 0.009930119849741459, -0.012409170158207417, -0.016011307016015053, -0.004740354139357805, -0.06129420921206474, -0.011412681080400944, 0.01965230703353882, 0.02000557817518711, 0.0036676900926977396, 0.07225260883569717, -0.016491087153553963, 0.00006481449963757768, -0.043219927698373795, -0.07412362843751907, -0.02045036107301712, -0.011149954050779343, -0.03386718034744263, -0.046523384749889374, 0.027276411652565002, 0.02387133426964283, -0.009494620375335217, 0.07951954007148743, -0.04054385796189308, 0.02751191332936287, 0.026369938626885414, -0.06769770383834839, -0.07336380332708359, 0.02860921248793602, 0.02375030890107155, -0.00670058187097311, -0.06359141319990158, -0.004642450250685215, -0.00626211054623127, 0.029702218249440193, -0.0031902864575386047, 0.0010225671576336026, 0.0487847775220871, 0.04057636484503746, -0.0011147352633997798, 0.01948384754359722, 0.009529664181172848, -0.03195659816265106, -0.06226120516657829, -0.03896532207727432, -0.03246496617794037, -0.014531350694596767, -0.0060281651094555855, -0.021665116772055626, -0.02626318484544754, 0.005082777701318264, -0.003991010598838329, 0.01788870245218277, -0.0514594204723835, -0.059633899480104446, -0.029185647144913673, 0.0461697056889534, 0.01037694327533245, 0.015261756256222725, 0.01538653764873743, -0.040158711373806, 0.017417501658201218, -0.046273134648799896, 0.01971207745373249, 0.049834538251161575, -0.037733111530542374, 0.012587222270667553, -0.03821135312318802, 0.00154935906175524, 0.0464334562420845, -0.00827360711991787, -0.015523931942880154, -0.03793269768357277, -0.033816590905189514, 0.05479521304368973, 0.03681345656514168, 0.014329527504742146, 0.013014549389481544, 0.08399669826030731, -0.08107487857341766, -0.012580517679452896, -0.03352716937661171, -0.01550372689962387, -0.029562540352344513, -0.06028486415743828, -0.032029520720243454, 0.010844784788787365, -0.00692804716527462, -0.01740422286093235, -0.01365746557712555, -0.007563639897853136, 0.00010196922812610865, 0.09085887670516968, -0.013009414076805115, -0.00858232844620943, 0.0179935023188591, 0.04189658910036087, -0.01843683421611786, 0.02891319990158081, -0.018396573141217232, 0.02044345811009407, 0.03298792988061905, 0.013542113825678825, 0.0017781190108507872, -0.0018463454907760024, -0.02623167261481285, 0.030844131484627724, -0.034852270036935806, -0.048278968781232834, 0.040771111845970154, -0.054744891822338104, 0.04261143505573273, 0.05508645623922348, 0.013576535508036613, 0.01963433437049389, -0.030510181561112404, -0.004145903047174215, 0.01609083265066147, 0.01213009376078844, -0.006188292987644672, -0.04370605945587158, 0.007066726218909025, 0.015820110216736794, 0.033186715096235275, -0.02324860729277134, -0.015126103535294533, 0.06517908722162247, -0.011861909180879593, 0.004370313603430986, 0.04148945212364197, 0.005612032487988472, -0.025151195004582405, 0.023163581266999245, 0.013304339721798897, 0.05849204957485199, 0.005422302521765232, 0.01968298852443695, 0.03283127397298813, 0.056556232273578644, 0.028158197179436684, -0.02384384348988533, -0.003531624097377062, 0.029201390221714973, -0.012469370849430561, 0.013624010607600212, 0.005715798120945692, 0.08559392392635345, -0.01758216693997383, -0.01637328416109085, 0.06490575522184372, -0.003017808310687542, -0.00312604196369648, 0.010529142804443836, 0.010119794867932796, -0.002462100936099887, 0.0918731689453125, -0.02860311046242714, 0.0042252009734511375, 0.010395216755568981, -0.0036135902628302574, 0.006532602943480015, 0.0009363236022181809, -0.009986205957829952, -0.0008327492978423834, 0.06121154502034187, 0.03180558606982231, -0.006562388502061367, 0.013324355706572533, -0.03368014469742775, 0.0025137700140476227, -0.005325338803231716, 0.0338294580578804, 0.03723330795764923, 0.036039263010025024, -0.02953536994755268, 0.01498014759272337, 0.0017908740555867553, -0.013712512329220772, 0.03319529443979263, 0.029076900333166122, -0.04926185682415962, 0.047821104526519775, -0.007973161526024342, -0.04797767847776413, -0.021471776068210602, -0.049711525440216064, 0.02692878060042858, -0.03098311275243759, 0.0026217522099614143, 0.06826955080032349, 0.01209473330527544, -0.04513800889253616, 0.013787198811769485, -0.03418729826807976, -0.009716433472931385, -0.018587538972496986, 0.000026841797080123797, 0.024221979081630707, 0.026235932484269142, -0.0349210686981678, -0.003785636043176055, 0.009883998893201351, -0.028406206518411636, -0.03132222965359688, -0.06475134193897247, -0.010455257259309292, 0.04201699048280716, -0.0043362947180867195, 0.014139343053102493, -0.01548112090677023, 0.07798099517822266, 0.0006223116652108729, -0.02868492528796196, -0.019108785316348076, -0.025963177904486656, -0.04375312104821205, -0.029480181634426117, 0.00754573242738843, 0.04464776813983917, 0.02781681902706623, 0.014364331029355526, -0.013218455947935581, 0.07590417563915253, 0.06068633124232292, 0.002801035065203905, 0.024957366287708282, 0.012765792198479176, 0.011751544661819935, -0.024507051333785057, 0.016433823853731155, 0.027983684092760086, 0.01370997354388237, 0.010808873921632767, 0.0025600010994821787, 0.013041704893112183, -0.016197921708226204, -0.005171772558242083, 0.00834557507187128, -0.021014701575040817, 0.013662964105606079, -0.007084079552441835, -0.024847518652677536, 0.04343397170305252, -0.0518689900636673, -0.002511671744287014, 0.03243999555706978, 0.037026286125183105, 0.010561221279203892, -0.02314077690243721, 0.0704105868935585, 0.029455887153744698, -0.0027354692574590445, 0.003082514042034745, 0.0012571325059980154, -0.025495553389191628, 0.020884821191430092, -0.010799399577081203, -0.020057784393429756, 0.017569655552506447, 0.04821522906422615, -0.010524313896894455, 0.017157502472400665, -0.02187616564333439, 0.023675911128520966, -0.036946870386600494, -0.024069834500551224, -0.036324527114629745, 0.04342026263475418, -0.000014063639355299529, 0.010104001499712467, -0.0037573662120848894, 0.012378567829728127, -0.01525247935205698, 0.0027018312830477953, -0.04178382456302643, -0.036095552146434784, 0.03815364092588425, 0.02038894221186638, -0.0017336495220661163, -0.02119700238108635, 0.005263424012809992, -0.014350002631545067, 0.04374236240983009, -0.007601567078381777, 0.05659184604883194, -0.017521437257528305, 0.021947871893644333, -0.00138627621345222, 0.014168674126267433, -0.010314407758414745, 0.04447629675269127, 0.07954703271389008, -0.017872478812932968, 0.033571816980838776, 0.027892161160707474, -0.029271544888615608, -0.03045721910893917, -0.052264269441366196, -0.0009696734487079084, 0.045832015573978424, 0.02751530148088932, -0.03311978280544281, 0.014315971173346043, -0.06865223497152328, -0.00010078967898152769, 0.01330653578042984, -0.0056981053203344345, 0.019182421267032623, -0.03409743681550026, -0.0109254727140069, 0.010423647239804268, -0.014093463309109211, -0.000500448455568403, 0.04391975700855255, -0.04726288467645645, 0.03392348811030388, 0.0113628339022398, 0.0029338852036744356, -0.022735539823770523, 0.04714157432317734, 0.0813547670841217, 0.04224644601345062, 0.00486103305593133, -0.021009525284171104, -0.03669935092329979, -0.001486003864556551, 0.028445059433579445, 0.012577368877828121, 0.04959391430020332, 0.02598514035344124, 0.00036811770405620337, -0.007247450295835733, 0.008306492120027542, -0.03831412270665169, 0.01504567451775074, 0.005449150688946247, 0.0070562055334448814, -0.006019321735948324, 0.015743806958198547, 0.01025137584656477, 0.006448147818446159, 0.03374055400490761, 0.01943117566406727, -0.008907889015972614, -0.07722979784011841, -0.017677385360002518, 0.05512233451008797, 0.05876205861568451, -0.011845527216792107, -0.021445835009217262, -0.05321703851222992, 0.03353216126561165, 0.025880716741085052, -0.026525350287556648, 0.03654034808278084, -0.027696028351783752, 0.012018817476928234, -0.014160247519612312, -0.05166887491941452, -0.009730791673064232, -0.015798419713974, -0.018683375790715218, 0.0032775215804576874, -0.004987616091966629, -0.03261817246675491, -0.04127185791730881, 0.008926295675337315, 0.030250275507569313, -0.004791856277734041, -0.008446330204606056, -0.03512195870280266, 0.0008903663256205618, 0.027745982632040977, -0.03207118809223175, -0.017713604494929314, 0.023506032302975655, -0.023366427049040794, -0.002275026636198163, 0.0651339441537857, -0.02246646024286747, -0.021783282980322838, 0.032340165227651596, 0.04263703152537346, 0.016789957880973816, 0.014545971527695656, -0.0006650947034358978, 0.05883654206991196, 0.06567725539207458, 0.014526600018143654, -0.014400547370314598, 0.028152721002697945, 0.015536319464445114, -0.01940728910267353, -0.06018053740262985, -0.01233589556068182, 0.0108205396682024, -0.03314046934247017, -0.07072202861309052, 0.009138933382928371, 0.0023522176779806614, 0.04862804338335991, -0.004839679691940546, 0.006713416893035173, -0.0132871950045228, -0.01974744349718094, 0.06802411377429962, 0.02632695622742176, -0.04954797774553299, -0.035165172070264816, -0.03081848844885826, 0.0036602579057216644, -0.021895308047533035, 0.001626778393983841, 0.03632458299398422, -0.032083190977573395, -0.01327040046453476, 0.03647857531905174, -0.053961846977472305, 0.009344647638499737, -0.012720084749162197, 0.01776992529630661, -0.02659635990858078, -0.02105650119483471, 0.01827877201139927, -0.01261099148541689, 0.019788231700658798, -0.0030541978776454926, -0.003890533233061433, -0.005309619475156069, 0.054274722933769226, -0.014974896796047688, 0.00522839929908514, -0.02948620356619358, 0.00036813318729400635, -0.00364762544631958, 0.015482154674828053, -0.04681584611535072, -0.0358143150806427, 0.021109413355588913, -0.003076533554121852, -0.03767303377389908, -0.003953743726015091, -0.04439377412199974, 0.025236954912543297, -0.015481536276638508, -0.03668811544775963, 0.02132948860526085, -0.06129150092601776, 0.005420702509582043, -0.01203769538551569, -0.039867959916591644, 0.09733323007822037, -0.012127644382417202, 0.005880181211978197, 0.026998983696103096, -0.01898329146206379, -0.019219914451241493, 0.02083706483244896, 0.0017250959062948823, -0.023641932755708694, -0.04897775501012802, -0.027125606313347816, -0.0056061712093651295, 0.042892832309007645, 0.004656416364014149, -0.0007804378983564675, -0.027317272499203682, -0.030122222378849983, 0.0008735036244615912, 0.007364140823483467, 0.004597481340169907, -0.07020188122987747, 0.0227385014295578, -0.04679447039961815, 0.014064179733395576, -0.0014121534768491983, 0.01656454987823963, -0.006761929485946894, 0.005443960428237915, -0.0095616290345788, 0.020298218354582787, 0.07613611966371536, -0.007171027362346649, -0.017239777371287346, -0.002069678623229265, -0.011847819201648235, 0.04819345101714134, 0.016773909330368042, 0.018733488395810127, -0.021012993529438972, 0.026702726259827614, -0.03301176428794861, -0.04049203172326088, -0.0360507108271122, 0.020730530843138695, 0.06363113224506378, 0.032060690224170685, 0.011600136756896973, -0.006781848147511482, -0.032399535179138184, 0.028101522475481033, -0.04191014543175697, 0.001754916738718748, 0.005250941030681133, -0.01215845625847578, 0.04809533432126045, 0.013324202969670296, -0.03697710111737251, 0.027196289971470833, 0.016680274158716202, 0.022867264226078987, 0.04158017039299011, 0.011423420161008835, -0.01735253632068634, -0.011722248047590256, -0.03092212788760662, -0.05029011890292168, 0.05185069888830185, -0.06311089545488358, 0.013265185058116913, -0.0398140586912632, -0.015118924900889397, 0.01842198520898819, 0.0464642308652401, 0.012921973131597042, -0.054040826857089996, -0.024538151919841766, -0.07575704902410507, 0.003801793558523059, 0.009502542205154896, -0.03025456890463829, 0.023540299385786057, 0.010354164987802505, 0.029194528236985207, -0.028783131390810013, 0.017552101984620094, -0.06388264149427414, -0.03529481217265129, -0.04040658101439476, -0.01742660067975521, -0.01480465941131115, 0.05792420357465744, -0.010589361190795898, -0.018555739894509315, 0.007744528818875551, -0.08030050992965698, 0.014410779811441898, -0.014338875189423561, 0.05209582298994064, -0.011054608970880508, 0.052154310047626495, -0.025369765236973763, 0.030735941603779793, -0.02041560970246792, -0.011713767424225807, 0.16651560366153717, 0.031032230705022812, 0.0486927404999733, -0.03279556334018707, 0.005203844979405403, 0.0474308580160141, 0.005613456480205059, -0.04323500767350197, -0.014926232397556305, 0.021735453978180885, -0.030458979308605194, 0.029859144240617752, 0.04678907245397568, 0.06359325349330902, 0.027451051399111748, 0.014548390172421932, -0.07089065760374069, 0.029069911688566208, 0.026617305353283882, 0.006305919494479895, -0.025354860350489616, -0.004314611200243235, -0.062439728528261185, -0.0007144918781705201, 0.005599713884294033, 0.0033343355171382427, -0.030964236706495285, -0.0019497196190059185, -0.003983920440077782, 0.013618296943604946, -0.042190276086330414, 0.01335623674094677, -0.0147485276684165, 0.004532922524958849, 0.025807516649365425, 0.010720950551331043, 0.00858269538730383, -0.058931924402713776, 0.022121716290712357, 0.03147660195827484, 0.002850825898349285, 0.020966755226254463, -0.028513265773653984, 0.044196777045726776, -0.01800837740302086, -0.019581932574510574, -0.01238294504582882, 0.034187719225883484, 0.005838209763169289, -0.03575536608695984, 0.017710410058498383, -0.01566152460873127, 0.002406962914392352, -0.018011802807450294, -0.017954617738723755, 0.022439870983362198, 0.023935621604323387, 0.04251088947057724, 0.021502310410141945, 0.005034780129790306, 0.04947849363088608, -0.022372819483280182, 0.006788086146116257, 0.014396036975085735, 0.014773853123188019, -0.02253459207713604, -0.013138129375874996, 0.059508539736270905, 0.0043968139216303825, 0.048579275608062744, -0.033273808658123016, -0.0223647803068161, -0.004238732159137726, -0.03298671171069145, 0.004054884891957045, -0.0021410472691059113, 0.013428903184831142, 0.017728928476572037, 0.00930421706289053, -0.019426826387643814, -0.02845490723848343, 0.007846447639167309, -0.02147367037832737, -0.01135099958628416, -0.03915700688958168, -0.029308483004570007, 0.027288386598229408, 0.03679506853222847, -0.011813526041805744, -0.01701534353196621, -0.022864732891321182, 0.11853111535310745, -0.02241479605436325, -0.04995201155543327, -0.026911748573184013, 0.03636953979730606, 0.013600201345980167, 0.024038169533014297, -0.015683263540267944, 0.03578447178006172, 0.013491603545844555, 0.019085055217146873, -0.023208029568195343, 0.0032124104909598827, -0.01221340149641037, -0.011968003585934639, 0.013368699699640274, -0.026871370151638985, -0.010614261031150818, 0.028279168531298637, -0.005064584780484438, -0.014915643259882927, -0.042958058416843414, -0.01415088027715683, -0.02880001626908779, -0.0054007829166948795, 0.008745475672185421, -0.02485400065779686, 0.029560577124357224, -0.022718029096722603, -0.07601524889469147, -0.015077367424964905, -0.0035945300478488207, -0.03556200489401817, -0.01090999785810709, -0.02286454848945141, -0.009538826532661915, 0.0014971974305808544, 0.015020345337688923, -0.03261028975248337, 0.028457066044211388, 0.00170534523203969, 0.014789813198149204, 0.0024204214569181204, -0.0033778382930904627, -0.0023195012472569942, 0.011039027944207191, 0.034416429698467255, -0.007308877073228359, 0.0020004473626613617, 0.004592090845108032, -0.014402065426111221, -0.055586084723472595, 0.009481148794293404, -0.015240868553519249, 0.01246867049485445, 0.004373941570520401, 0.03406533971428871, 0.00014035786443855613, 0.049476779997348785, -0.042982831597328186, -0.01790512539446354, 0.018209481611847878, -0.00782453641295433, -0.007402588613331318, 0.012826026417315006, 0.02683098055422306, -0.015277046710252762, -0.0021808806341141462, -0.009225918911397457, 0.06208325922489166, 0.023152345791459084, -0.05326614901423454, 0.010030846111476421, -0.003063325770199299, 0.02620285004377365, -0.024401942268013954, 0.029726557433605194, 0.005488176830112934, 0.021661050617694855, -0.04839792847633362, 0.01407642848789692, -0.01596127264201641, 0.028002578765153885, -0.08895949274301529, 0.007528988178819418, 0.0497010312974453, 0.010408264584839344, -0.019291192293167114, -0.030181290581822395, -0.006288852542638779, 0.04440503194928169, -0.05097535252571106, 0.01794918067753315, 0.011413727886974812, 0.020315932109951973, -0.04142937436699867, 0.03047456033527851, -0.07289367914199829, 0.03768394514918327, 0.04348554089665413, 0.01722494140267372, 0.06306503713130951, 0.025219609960913658, 0.008277801796793938, -0.05435185134410858, -0.04029588773846626, 0.05616307258605957, -0.009013717994093895, -0.041343480348587036, 0.013873438350856304, -0.02426503226161003, 0.025074709206819534, 0.0005946910823695362, -0.008871650323271751, -0.03330284357070923, 0.009252458810806274, 0.0010004752548411489, 0.0029901645611971617, 0.06481071561574936, 0.0031727717723697424, 0.0350797213613987, -0.01960155926644802, 0.0015384736470878124, -0.01955599896609783, 0.01031632162630558, -0.007556901313364506, 0.027286440134048462, 0.006121539045125246, -0.0017743689240887761, -0.02346329391002655, 0.0160905160009861, -0.049884065985679626, 0.001163202803581953, -0.03201461583375931, -0.006770992651581764, 0.04065747559070587, -0.05649470537900925, -0.0011144959134981036, 0.002239573048427701, 0.05646415799856186, 0.023611610755324364, 0.02542799711227417, -0.011908925138413906, 0.018306801095604897, -0.011299529112875462, -0.03520553559064865, -0.0029243608005344868, 0.04237012565135956, -0.0187772698700428, -0.02172340452671051, -0.024884559214115143, -0.021550901234149933, -0.014339033514261246, -0.0016398574225604534, 0.02241678722202778, -0.023792264983057976, 0.08073703199625015, -0.01354107353836298, 0.02282900922000408, 0.02151341922581196, 0.006312467157840729, 0.03304443508386612, -0.09684709459543228, 0.013127521611750126, -0.00679013691842556, 0.009120253846049309, -0.03932470455765724, -0.03239715099334717, -0.0207782331854105, 0.03528375178575516, 0.02085333876311779, -0.006671297363936901, 0.001471688854508102, -0.021118488162755966, -0.0012451126240193844, 0.011900641955435276, -0.07648459821939468, 0.06457951664924622, 0.009067568928003311, -0.0172547809779644, -0.009731926023960114, -0.021053418517112732, -0.015284029766917229, -0.009013069793581963, 0.01857978105545044, -0.0020847467239946127, 0.0029209197964519262, -0.0006081589381210506, -0.009562690742313862, -0.006437742151319981, -0.004018617328256369, -0.029907740652561188, 0.03725511580705643, 0.04002011939883232, -0.03775664418935776, 0.04604057967662811, 0.008279137313365936, -0.039322882890701294, 0.028798988088965416, -0.03635149076581001, -0.01650693640112877, -0.0019629443995654583, 0.020977886393666267, -0.019735677167773247, -0.022985126823186874, -0.01972283609211445, 0.005401180125772953, -0.031353045254945755, -0.050206273794174194, 0.010511165484786034, 0.021503658965229988, 0.015431903302669525, -0.016267340630292892, 0.018152572214603424, -0.016169847920536995, 0.014016509987413883, 0.030759183689951897, 0.0005834647454321384, -0.002123833168298006, -0.010923114605247974, -0.00817081518471241, 0.012008583173155785, 0.009463638067245483, 0.026725219562649727, -0.04704848676919937, 0.0503322035074234, 0.022593075409531593, -0.003101580310612917, 0.009528204798698425, -0.03845399618148804, -0.020243393257260323, 0.027934009209275246, 0.01677699200809002, -0.002717394847422838, 0.016186293214559555, -0.0020890829619020224, -0.04124569892883301, 0.015796588733792305, 0.05832010135054588, 0.01891276426613331, -0.018485592678189278, -0.005317111499607563, -0.03035949543118477, -0.03919605910778046, 0.020535198971629143, 0.01104732695966959, 0.02482614293694496, 0.029755620285868645, 0.02982620894908905, -0.03198498487472534, 0.058822888880968094, -0.018850009888410568, -0.041608188301324844, -0.026992494240403175, -0.015440979041159153, 0.025587549433112144, 0.005318370647728443, -0.02188844606280327, 0.010612801648676395, -0.004625238478183746, 0.007199691608548164, 0.03909483924508095, -0.06368274241685867, -0.029328901320695877, -0.031041711568832397, 0.028316238895058632, -0.0006986673106439412, -0.02456287108361721 ]
<p>I have a dataframe called "cleaned", which consists of about 300,000 rows and 13 variables. Except the dependent variable, all variables are categorical and have multiple levels ($\geq2$). The dependent variable is numeric and takes values ranging from -1,500 to 3,296, mostly positive. Here is a summary of the dataframe:</p> <pre><code>&gt; summary(cleaned$SumOf1st.Yr.Cash) Min. 1st Qu. Median Mean 3rd Qu. Max. -1574.00 37.37 101.50 155.60 204.60 3296.00 &gt; dput(head(cleaned)) structure(list(Submit.Qtr = structure(c(2L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 2L, 2L ), .Label = c("1Q11", "2Q11", "3Q11", "4Q11"), class = "factor"), SUBMIT_CAL_MONTH = c(201104L, 201104L, 201104L, 201104L, 201104L, 201104L), SumOf1st.Yr.Cash = c(-221.81, 127.86, 662.09, 77.24, 370.4, 176), CARRIER_NAME = structure(c(56L, 116L, 4L, 116L, 82L, 114L), .Label = c("AARP-branded plans, insured by Aetna", "Aetna", "Aetna Life Insurance Company", "Altius Health Plans", "Altius One", "American Family Life Assurance Company of Columbus (Aflac)", "American Family Life Assurance Company of New York (Aflac New York)", "AmeriHealth - New Jersey", "Ameritas Life Insurance Corp.", "Anthem BCBS. Serving residents of Indiana", "Anthem BCBS. Serving residents of Kentucky", "Anthem BCBS. Serving residents of Ohio", "Anthem Blue Cross", "Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield", "Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield of CT", "Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield of NH", "Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield of VA", "Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield", "Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield Indiana", "Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield Kentucky", "Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield of Connecticut", "Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield of Missouri", "Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield of Wisconsin", "Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield Ohio", "Anthem BlueCross BlueShield", "Anthem Health Plans of Kentucky Inc.", "Anthem Health Plans of New Hampshire Inc.", "Argus", "Arise Health Plan", "Arkansas Blue Cross and Blue Shield", "Assurant", "Assurant Employee Benefits", "Assurant Health", "Asuris Northwest Health", "Avera Health Plans", "AvMed Health Plans", "Bay Dental", "BCBS of GA", "Blue Cross and Blue Shield of GA", "Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Georgia", "Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Illinois", "Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Kansas City", "Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Minnesota", "Blue Cross and Blue Shield of South Carolina", "Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Texas", "Blue Cross Blue Shield", "Blue Cross Blue Shield of Arizona", "Blue Cross Blue Shield of Delaware", "Blue Cross Blue Shield of Florida", "Blue Cross Blue Shield of Georgia", "Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan", "Blue Cross Blue Shield of North Dakota", "Blue Cross of Idaho", "Blue Cross of Northeastern Pennsylvania through its subsidiary First Priority Life Insurance Company", "Blue Shield of California", "BlueCross BlueShield of Louisiana", "BlueCross BlueShield of Montana", "BlueCross BlueShield of Nebraska", "BlueCross BlueShield of Tennessee", "BlueCross BlueShield of Wyoming", "Capital Blue Cross", "Care Improvement Plus", "CareFirst BlueCross BlueShield", "Celtic Ins. Co.", "CeltiCare Healthplan of MA, Inc.", "Cigna", "Clear One Health Plans", "ConnectiCare Inc.", "Coventry", "Coventry Health and Life Insurance Co. FL", "Coventry Health and Life Insurance Company", "Coventry Health Care of Delaware, Inc", "Coventry Health Care of Georgia, Inc.", "Coventry Health Care of Illinois, Inc.", "Coventry Health Care of Iowa, Inc.", "Coventry Health Care of Kansas Inc.", "Coventry Health Care of Louisiana, Inc.", "Coventry Health Care of Missouri, Inc.", "Coventry Health Care of Oklahoma Inc.", "Coventry Health Care of the Carolinas, Inc.", "Coventry Health Plan of Florida, Inc.", "Dean Health Plan, Inc.", "Delta Dental Insurance Company (Delta Dental)", "Delta Dental of California", "Delta Dental of Colorado", "Delta Dental of Iowa", "Delta Dental of Minnesota", "Delta Dental of North Carolina", "Dentegra Insurance Company", "Dominion Dental Services, Inc", "Easy Choice Health Plan of New York", "EmblemHealth", "Empire", "Empire BlueCross", "Evercare by UnitedHealthcare", "Everest Dental Plan", "Fallon Community Health Plan", "Geisinger Choice", "Generic Medicare Carrier", "Group Health", "HCC Life Insurance Company", "HCC Medical Insurance Services", "Health Alliance Plan", "Health Insurance Innovations", "Health Net", "Health Net of Arizona", "Health Net of Oregon", "Health Plan of Nevada", "HealthAmerica", "HealthPartners", "HealthPlus Insurance Company", "Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield Delaware", "Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield West Virginia", "Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey", "Humana", "Humana CompBenefits", "Humana Health Benefit Plan of Louisiana Inc.", "Humana Health Insurance Company of Florida", "Humana Insurance Company of Kentucky", "IHC Group", "IMG Global", "Independence Blue Cross", "Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of the NW", "Kaiser Mid-Atlantic", "Kaiser Permanente CO", "Kaiser Permanente GA", "Kaiser Permanente of CA", "Kaiser Permanente of HI", "Kaiser Permanente of Ohio", "KPS Health Plans", "LifeWise Health Plan of Oregon", "LifeWise Health Plan of Washington", "Lovelace Health Plans", "Madison National Life Insurance Company", "Medica", "Medica of Minnesota", "Medical Mutual", "Mercy Health Plans", "Mutual of Omaha", "Mutual Of Omaha", "Mutual of Omaha Insurance Company", "MVP", "My Health Alliance", "Nationwide Life Insurance Company", "Next Generation Insurance Group", "ODS Alaska", "ODS Health Plan, Inc.", "Optima Health Insurance Company", "Oxford NJ", "Oxford NY", "PacifiCare", "PacificSource Health Plans", "PacificSource Health Plans of Idaho", "Physicians Health Plan of Northern Indiana, Inc.", "Physicians Plus", "PreferredOne Insurance Company", "Premera Blue Cross", "Premera Blue Cross Blue Shield of Alaska", "Presbyterian", "Providence Health Plan", "QCA Health Plan Inc", "Regence Blue Cross Blue Shield of Oregon", "Regence Blue Cross Blue Shield of Utah", "Regence Blue Shield of Idaho", "Regence BlueCross BlueShield of Oregon", "Regence BlueCross BlueShield of Utah", "Regence BlueShield", "Regence BlueShield of Idaho", "Regence Life and Health", "Regence Life and Health Insurance Company", "RegenceBCBS", "RegenceBS", "Rocky Mountain Health Plans", "Scott &amp; White Health Plan", "SecureHorizons by UnitedHealthcare", "Security Health Plan", "Security Life Insurance Company of America", "SelectHealth", "Seven Corners", "Sierra Health and Life", "Standard Security Life", "Standard Security Life Insurance Company", "SummaCare Inc of Ohio", "Symetra Life Insurance Company", "Total Dental Administrators Health Plan, Inc.", "UniCare", "United Concordia Dental", "United of Omaha", "United World", "UnitedHealthcare", "UnitedHealthcare Community Plan", "UnitedHealthOne", "Unity Health Insurance", "Vision Plan of America", "VSP", "WellCare", "WellCare Health Plans of New Jersey, Inc.", "WellCare of Florida, Inc.", "WellCare of New York, Inc.", "WellCare of Ohio, Inc.", "WellCare of Texas, Inc.", "WellCare Prescription Insurance, Inc.", "Wellmark Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Iowa", "Wellmark Blue Cross and Blue Shield of South Dakota", "WellPath Select, Inc.", "WINhealth Partners", "WPS", "WPS Health Insurance" ), class = "factor"), GENDER = structure(c(2L, 2L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L), .Label = c("F", "M", "U"), class = "factor"), FAMILY_TYPE = structure(c(1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 2L, 2L), .Label = c("FAMILY", "INDIVIDUAL", "Unknown" ), class = "factor"), EXECUTIVE_AGE_GROUP = structure(c(5L, 5L, 4L, 3L, 3L, 6L), .Label = c("0-18 (&gt;=0 AND &lt;19)", "19-25 (&gt;=19 AND &lt;26)", "26-29 (&gt;=26 AND &lt;30)", "30-39 (&gt;=30 AND &lt;40)", "40-49 (&gt;=40 AND &lt;50)", "50-64 (&gt;=50 AND &lt;65)", "65+", "Unknown"), class = "factor"), MARITAL_STATUS = structure(c(4L, 1L, 8L, 1L, 7L, 1L), .Label = c("", "D", "L", "M", "O", "P", "S", "W"), class = "factor"), SELECTED_RIDERS = structure(c(11L, 1L, 1L, 10L, 1L, 10L), .Label = c("", "/Dental_Vision/", "/Dental/", "/Dental/Other/", "/Life/", "/Life/Dental_Vision/", "/Life/Dental/", "/Life/Dental/Other/", "/Life/Other/", "/None/", "/Other/", "/Vision/", "/Vision/Dental/", "/Vision/Dental/Other/", "/Vision/Life/", "/Vision/Life/Dental/", "/Vision/Life/Dental/Other/", "/Vision/Life/Other/", "/Vision/Other/"), class = "factor"), STATE_ABBR = structure(c(19L, 44L, 45L, 10L, 49L, 32L), .Label = c("AK", "AL", "AR", "AZ", "CA", "CO", "CT", "DC", "DE", "FL", "GA", "HI", "IA", "ID", "IL", "IN", "KS", "KY", "LA", "MA", "MD", "ME", "MI", "MN", "MO", "MS", "MT", "NC", "ND", "NE", "NH", "NJ", "NM", "NV", "NY", "OH", "OK", "OR", "PA", "RI", "SC", "SD", "TN", "TX", "UT", "VA", "VT", "WA", "WI", "WV", "WY" ), class = "factor"), SumOfAPPROVED.MEMBERS = c(7L, 6L, 4L, 2L, 1L, 1L), PRODUCTLINE_TYPE = structure(c(4L, 3L, 4L, 3L, 4L, 4L), .Label = c("ACC", "CAN", "DT", "IFP", "MA", "MAPD", "MD", "MS", "PDC", "ST", "STU", "TRV", "VSP"), class = "factor"), CHANNEL = structure(c(1L, 1L, 2L, 3L, 2L, 3L), .Label = c("Direct", "Online Advertising", "Performance Partners"), class = "factor")), .Names = c("Submit.Qtr", "SUBMIT_CAL_MONTH", "SumOf1st.Yr.Cash", "CARRIER_NAME", "GENDER", "FAMILY_TYPE", "EXECUTIVE_AGE_GROUP", "MARITAL_STATUS", "SELECTED_RIDERS", "STATE_ABBR", "SumOfAPPROVED.MEMBERS", "PRODUCTLINE_TYPE", "CHANNEL" ), row.names = c(2L, 4L, 5L, 6L, 7L, 8L), class = "data.frame") </code></pre> <p>I was trying to run a mixed effect model on these data </p> <pre><code> lme(SumOf1st.Yr.Cash~ GENDER + FAMILY_TYPE + + EXECUTIVE_AGE_GROUP + MARITAL_STATUS + SELECTED_RIDERS + + PRODUCTLINE_TYPE + CHANNEL, data=cleaned, random= ~1 | STATE_ABBR) </code></pre> <p>But I got an error message that I couldn't understand. </p> <pre><code>Error in MEEM(object, conLin, control$niterEM) : Singularity in backsolve at level 0, block 1 </code></pre> <p>I could run it when there is only one variable in the formula. But even with two I got the same error message.</p> <pre><code>lme(SumOf1st.Yr.Cash~ GENDER + + EXECUTIVE_AGE_GROUP , data=cleaned, random= ~1 | STATE_ABBR) Error in MEEM(object, conLin, control$niterEM) : Singularity in backsolve at level 0, block 1 lme(SumOf1st.Yr.Cash~ GENDER + , data=cleaned, random= ~1 | STATE_ABBR) Linear mixed-effects model fit by REML Data: cleaned Log-restricted-likelihood: -1877607 Fixed: SumOf1st.Yr.Cash ~ GENDER (Intercept) GENDERM GENDERU 146.53490 12.27621 494.77983 Random effects: Formula: ~1 | STATE_ABBR (Intercept) Residual StdDev: 39.21808 177.8023 Number of Observations: 284485 Number of Groups: 51 </code></pre>
36,289
[ -0.035609591752290726, 0.012873455882072449, 0.007526741363108158, 0.0185107309371233, 0.015176991932094097, -0.0040200441144406796, -0.03005005419254303, -0.03567512333393097, 0.024808945134282112, -0.04547587037086487, 0.05678703263401985, 0.015156028792262077, 0.037751127034425735, 0.031820666044950485, 0.030564308166503906, -0.009571684524416924, -0.017142442986369133, -0.01145743764936924, 0.018864938989281654, -0.011248399503529072, 0.018067965283989906, 0.009450639598071575, 0.05289863795042038, -0.024612978100776672, -0.01286401879042387, 0.030988072976469994, 0.011500905267894268, -0.022813893854618073, 0.018032077699899673, 0.0300908163189888, -0.0458381325006485, -0.048555031418800354, 0.007877455092966557, -0.05478347837924957, 0.039655789732933044, 0.00019745263853110373, -0.013128534890711308, -0.031064294278621674, -0.011361702345311642, 0.009324077516794205, -0.022115614265203476, -0.014458930119872093, -0.006829234305769205, 0.007638291921466589, -0.0012478966964408755, -0.02152092754840851, 0.012762505561113358, 0.03736799955368042, 0.05605845898389816, -0.012595394626259804, 0.029547063633799553, -0.03477180749177933, 0.009544716216623783, 0.04823814332485199, -0.06872378289699554, -0.019335143268108368, 0.004351824056357145, 0.047747962176799774, -0.011588666588068008, -0.005548371002078056, -0.011409838683903217, 0.013794499449431896, -0.023759230971336365, -0.01929585263133049, -0.027513820677995682, 0.017713192850351334, -0.009255132637917995, 0.006729129236191511, 0.01582941599190235, -0.032682616263628006, -0.03316318616271019, -0.023652488365769386, -0.021960744634270668, -0.03743947669863701, -0.0060464064590632915, -0.027850281447172165, 0.039189595729112625, 0.006997870281338692, 0.021789878606796265, 0.017414771020412445, -0.010153507813811302, 0.013389677740633488, -0.030105428770184517, 0.0013840675819665194, 0.03782421350479126, 0.01812053844332695, 0.04201628267765045, -0.03301733732223511, 0.023760853335261345, 0.04272744059562683, 0.02737356163561344, 0.009514768607914448, 0.0397573821246624, 0.06864728033542633, -0.03499414399266243, -0.0065387459471821785, -0.026553986594080925, -0.004520496819168329, 0.007030863780528307, -0.0061121596954762936, -0.01501365378499031, -0.04610244184732437, 0.03501743823289871, 0.01608811877667904, -0.005107470788061619, 0.004809632431715727, -0.02215188555419445, -0.054178230464458466, -0.04358988627791405, 0.0033058186527341604, -0.0592661015689373, -0.03293076157569885, -0.027302024886012077, -0.016263872385025024, 0.009423217736184597, -0.06902918219566345, -0.06588978320360184, 0.008524118922650814, 0.010678029619157314, 0.07241638749837875, 0.058602768927812576, -0.022874897345900536, 0.027583183720707893, -0.030339963734149933, -0.0010789671214297414, 0.027505414560437202, -0.022349592298269272, -0.021856870502233505, -0.02243584208190441, 0.039743147790431976, -0.025846054777503014, -0.05078647658228874, 0.05541421100497246, -0.016243495047092438, 0.008404416032135487, 0.028887543827295303, -0.0940915197134018, -0.060348134487867355, 0.03094545751810074, -0.006323355715721846, 0.0328211635351181, -0.04170021414756775, 0.03073846735060215, -0.005500901490449905, 0.029035791754722595, -0.004099770449101925, 0.04542208090424538, 0.059708673506975174, -0.014555150642991066, 0.02819259651005268, -0.029513241723179817, -0.013190412893891335, -0.01699925772845745, 0.03483014553785324, -0.010554531589150429, -0.06254062056541443, -0.010736464522778988, 0.0027412103954702616, -0.012989622540771961, -0.005966949742287397, 0.036972980946302414, 0.0073256767354905605, 0.0330130010843277, -0.022300072014331818, -0.03396384418010712, -0.0063914223574101925, 0.07545147091150284, 0.0022793724201619625, -0.009931184351444244, 0.01614638790488243, -0.03676098957657814, -0.043256718665361404, 0.0002596224658191204, 0.007008073385804892, 0.021204181015491486, -0.03306996822357178, 0.021545685827732086, -0.013760682195425034, -0.004209109116345644, 0.012698924168944359, -0.031060300767421722, -0.010935942642390728, -0.02465333230793476, -0.02291950210928917, 0.015226219780743122, 0.0014818137278780341, -0.0031464467756450176, -0.024773111566901207, 0.04971868917346001, -0.037849269807338715, -0.047717321664094925, -0.015384439378976822, 0.009017218835651875, -0.01384715922176838, -0.028779134154319763, -0.029113631695508957, 0.015670008957386017, 0.03895629197359085, -0.004350066184997559, 0.05364784970879555, -0.025997385382652283, 0.009813145734369755, 0.052540820091962814, 0.0004831378464587033, 0.00022759198327548802, -0.0031076804734766483, 0.06911985576152802, 0.0014523982536047697, 0.001911069848574698, -0.05230553075671196, 0.009964723140001297, 0.0352151095867157, -0.018924567848443985, 0.010633980855345726, -0.0184171125292778, -0.0008371184230782092, 0.054695792496204376, 0.02822212688624859, 0.020521309226751328, 0.059064242988824844, -0.08177181333303452, 0.01995975896716118, 0.02906649000942707, 0.014672725461423397, 0.033156868070364, -0.007814534939825535, -0.013152282685041428, 0.04521917924284935, -0.008361500687897205, -0.0216295775026083, -0.0021776577923446894, 0.003960133530199528, 0.04484473913908005, 0.008663644082844257, 0.026623236015439034, -0.029065847396850586, 0.05762598291039467, -0.014989808201789856, 0.041581083089113235, 0.031642280519008636, 0.016887402161955833, -0.0015207818942144513, 0.056563474237918854, -0.0046065328642725945, -0.014172113500535488, -0.019112009555101395, 0.02395685203373432, 0.001018678885884583, 0.07325220853090286, 0.00659204414114356, 0.0014102687127888203, 0.034690793603658676, 0.042973652482032776, 0.010873853228986263, -0.012580783106386662, -0.02377377077937126, 0.07815784215927124, -0.02861819788813591, -0.007302037440240383, 0.05160579830408096, 0.038213424384593964, -0.02817285805940628, 0.005817261058837175, -0.01910698413848877, -0.0013450906844809651, 0.07307053357362747, -0.03277629241347313, -0.02947954274713993, 0.02473757229745388, -0.04718382656574249, 0.019446568563580513, -0.021270286291837692, -0.005998492240905762, -0.019742701202630997, 0.01864764280617237, 0.044508010149002075, -0.010602586902678013, 0.022285813465714455, -0.06045547127723694, -0.02106930874288082, 0.0053810616955161095, -0.02561575174331665, 0.052839454263448715, -0.0034912554547190666, -0.03943406045436859, -0.013597150333225727, 0.0013734739040955901, -0.008405265398323536, 0.048795461654663086, 0.01683337427675724, -0.061385877430438995, 0.03261573240160942, 0.00811665691435337, -0.03769194707274437, -0.014475847594439983, -0.018702255561947823, 0.017256945371627808, -0.020564723759889603, -0.04406966641545296, 0.05384458601474762, 0.032345741987228394, -0.016758404672145844, -0.05368762090802193, -0.06645120680332184, 0.020638708025217056, 0.01757550984621048, -0.033449918031692505, -0.017146222293376923, 0.006186953280121088, -0.018202126026153564, -0.0030220921617001295, -0.022659625858068466, -0.005790298338979483, -0.06402698904275894, -0.06355847418308258, -0.0025257805828005075, 0.00742917787283659, -0.009765702299773693, 0.003209812333807349, -0.015533833764493465, 0.015524465590715408, 0.045661065727472305, -0.0450613796710968, -0.03320778161287308, 0.010345068760216236, -0.006205810699611902, -0.03367721289396286, 0.0012673327000811696, 0.024303153157234192, 0.0036376924254000187, -0.02100301906466484, 0.006617961451411247, 0.0518966019153595, 0.016732385382056236, -0.010183339938521385, 0.0018215487943962216, 0.028360461816191673, -0.03943345695734024, 0.017148442566394806, 0.02767680212855339, 0.04873785004019737, -0.0026015914045274258, 0.05161803960800171, 0.007955406792461872, -0.007657590322196484, -0.013242940418422222, -0.04386197775602341, -0.001773468917235732, 0.015791775658726692, 0.01787782460451126, -0.04665585979819298, 0.004170047584921122, 0.03450489789247513, -0.03179391473531723, -0.0005325237289071083, -0.0044500636868178844, 0.0617721825838089, -0.04837820306420326, 0.010358013212680817, 0.02632163092494011, 0.014239192008972168, -0.01872255466878414, 0.035997968167066574, -0.0193688552826643, -0.012120125815272331, 0.03129403665661812, -0.038009364157915115, 0.0006523590418510139, 0.02871762029826641, 0.04612692818045616, 0.044032566249370575, 0.023151615634560585, -0.016652699559926987, 0.05538289621472359, -0.0361994132399559, -0.04088553041219711, -0.0014058417873457074, 0.04443543404340744, 0.03814234584569931, 0.0130356065928936, 0.0065957666374742985, 0.012495607137680054, -0.01865782029926777, 0.02923648990690708, -0.0387645959854126, 0.00039992990787141025, 0.025523219257593155, 0.009751689620316029, 0.017449358478188515, -0.05004269257187843, 0.02520664595067501, -0.009814437478780746, -0.011851241812109947, 0.015514944680035114, 0.027829427272081375, -0.012636573053896427, 0.01666140742599964, 0.01216901559382677, 0.020187098532915115, -0.0012537770671769977, -0.013116671703755856, 0.06018983945250511, 0.011516054160892963, -0.0007295317482203245, 0.04017728194594383, 0.005900136660784483, -0.02388882264494896, -0.030642971396446228, -0.011409716680645943, 0.0203159861266613, 0.06690151989459991, 0.0025680505204945803, 0.04372207447886467, -0.024757299572229385, 0.027863454073667526, 0.032689422369003296, 0.014004694297909737, 0.024028969928622246, 0.01154494658112526, 0.0041174269281327724, -0.03255331888794899, -0.024563899263739586, -0.00771321402862668, -0.017180297523736954, 0.006967771798372269, -0.03507177531719208, 0.07784686237573624, 0.039497196674346924, -0.017744844779372215, 0.016902152448892593, 0.044527195394039154, 0.000983247417025268, 0.038192350417375565, -0.019664011895656586, 0.011266754008829594, -0.014103737659752369, -0.010401147417724133, 0.06332199275493622, 0.007869234308600426, 0.024125276133418083, 0.016870293766260147, 0.016864443197846413, -0.047650694847106934, -0.024117182940244675, -0.016365472227334976, 0.017151430249214172, 0.01659783348441124, -0.04546995833516121, -0.011632980778813362, 0.01835361309349537, 0.035688962787389755, 0.02217990718781948, -0.0007332504610531032, 0.005336299072951078, -0.0827750638127327, 0.013518910855054855, 0.03961225599050522, 0.04112054035067558, -0.003022435586899519, -0.014915706589818, -0.04503965377807617, -0.012288828380405903, 0.028455277904868126, -0.05349074676632881, 0.018485182896256447, -0.0008528714533895254, -0.004203510470688343, -0.03551271930336952, -0.02277563512325287, -0.012208922766149044, -0.01538932602852583, -0.044219374656677246, -0.0024168272502720356, -0.006630868185311556, -0.025341292843222618, 0.007371912710368633, -0.00470375781878829, -0.04266994819045067, 0.026186389848589897, -0.017305638641119003, -0.06020784378051758, 0.046114854514598846, -0.004188732709735632, -0.048893555998802185, -0.03024500235915184, -0.018232474103569984, -0.007033204659819603, 0.005621781572699547, 0.06560195237398148, 0.023643678054213524, -0.005761860404163599, 0.022922011092305183, 0.0419551357626915, -0.007490187883377075, -0.017784539610147476, -0.0010478151962161064, 0.020540675148367882, -0.0024925849866122007, 0.0039529819041490555, 0.03510439395904541, 0.000406740145990625, -0.011687058955430984, 0.01598426327109337, -0.06720009446144104, 0.006822048220783472, -0.021006498485803604, -0.08252297341823578, -0.014964407309889793, -0.011949238367378712, -0.00640013488009572, -0.0009511226671747863, -0.04782245308160782, 0.03466735780239105, -0.08762184530496597, 0.022033298388123512, 0.027763541787862778, 0.01153587270528078, -0.023737194016575813, -0.025234751403331757, -0.005203892942517996, -0.010364706628024578, -0.02039884775876999, -0.05288820341229439, 0.03387938439846039, -0.054130908101797104, -0.013223452493548393, 0.00656847795471549, -0.009156647138297558, -0.023536935448646545, -0.01244739256799221, 0.010166477411985397, -0.0001363013288937509, 0.02091050334274769, 0.004621603060513735, -0.010365447960793972, 0.06275662034749985, 0.005775194149464369, -0.019505439326167107, -0.011875608004629612, 0.021338514983654022, -0.04157916083931923, -0.01676519401371479, -0.00986225251108408, 0.05007139593362808, 0.012841388583183289, -0.03628689795732498, -0.03408803418278694, -0.015121417120099068, 0.0431036539375782, 0.01814887672662735, -0.05421395227313042, -0.016759559512138367, 0.012245305813848972, -0.005839921068400145, 0.005637765396386385, -0.027356812730431557, -0.02217523194849491, -0.06561051309108734, 0.01274909358471632, 0.018604975193738937, 0.04934544116258621, 0.03724291920661926, 0.03249361738562584, 0.003947117831557989, 0.024164505302906036, -0.042049795389175415, -0.044035449624061584, -0.009605268016457558, -0.05854921042919159, -0.0212587658315897, -0.06136989966034889, -0.02139391005039215, 0.023081323131918907, 0.04240373149514198, -0.004893314093351364, 0.009533300064504147, -0.0025528976693749428, -0.03654264286160469, 0.033941954374313354, -0.04728084057569504, -0.02687222510576248, -0.0189526230096817, -0.011755318380892277, -0.04912729933857918, -0.007182640954852104, -0.0028133736923336983, -0.046863485127687454, -0.027706673368811607, -0.027271829545497894, -0.03023357130587101, 0.05813036486506462, 0.10847463458776474, -0.024905409663915634, 0.007250369992107153, 0.007670912891626358, -0.030701078474521637, 0.05988170951604843, 0.02379380725324154, -0.023732900619506836, -0.027649229392409325, 0.03331650793552399, 0.006721183657646179, -0.024241801351308823, -0.05387019366025925, 0.013425005599856377, 0.04439373314380646, 0.012346604838967323, 0.016653718426823616, 0.04292316362261772, 0.04276008903980255, 0.025981800630688667, -0.05405793711543083, -0.04884583130478859, -0.011170921847224236, 0.01827220991253853, 0.06756670773029327, 0.015009378083050251, 0.014768469147384167, 0.05246531218290329, -0.02231062389910221, 0.010490583255887032, 0.027814019471406937, 0.023883147165179253, -0.020106779411435127, -0.00019249205070082098, -0.0038322429172694683, -0.018792774528265, -0.025986874476075172, -0.035034142434597015, -0.007527048233896494, -0.027849940583109856, -0.04848773404955864, 0.032432928681373596, 0.011911092326045036, -0.02091672457754612, -0.034371517598629, -0.025585711002349854, -0.037393804639577866, 0.03721240535378456, 0.007485015317797661, 0.008784372359514236, 0.027632243931293488, 0.014570588245987892, 0.07087206840515137, 0.006704938132315874, 0.03852515295147896, -0.03508754074573517, -0.03825855255126953, -0.01731613464653492, -0.03580093756318092, -0.032999858260154724, 0.0294503103941679, 0.03059733659029007, 0.051805540919303894, 0.018835347145795822, -0.0537768118083477, 0.027232088148593903, -0.015677830204367638, 0.02431396208703518, 0.02162543311715126, 0.03592708334326744, -0.006106748711317778, 0.02050161547958851, 0.02901693806052208, -0.018402256071567535, 0.15350618958473206, 0.06013459339737892, 0.01732545532286167, -0.058143965899944305, -0.03398559242486954, 0.05050665885210037, -0.023491866886615753, -0.031332120299339294, -0.03060626983642578, -0.00952091347426176, 0.006669862661510706, 0.05398375913500786, 0.04414089769124985, 0.05513568967580795, 0.013993838801980019, 0.009055601432919502, -0.03106185793876648, 0.013394034467637539, 0.05075688287615776, 0.027789810672402382, -0.049401190131902695, 0.0016828710213303566, -0.0828549861907959, -0.009934939444065094, 0.06030445173382759, -0.05741926655173302, -0.06311636418104172, 0.02017497830092907, -0.005801344756036997, 0.000655482173897326, 0.017894385382533073, 0.01137478742748499, 0.012674808502197266, 0.011972421780228615, 0.023838507011532784, 0.03005066327750683, 0.0339636504650116, -0.041408173739910126, 0.0028518286999315023, 0.05047758296132088, 0.002507499884814024, 0.012334616854786873, 0.010825936682522297, 0.03563458472490311, -0.01677079126238823, 0.02854674682021141, -0.07976951450109482, 0.021079665049910545, -0.04770468547940254, 0.02687748149037361, -0.060187093913555145, -0.013479362241923809, 0.01576831378042698, -0.03448883071541786, 0.03317512944340706, 0.013300582766532898, 0.012581721879541874, -0.03219834715127945, 0.0240261759608984, -0.01750928908586502, -0.0035363787319511175, 0.02082429639995098, -0.0261678546667099, 0.009056059643626213, -0.021043088287115097, -0.012345396913588047, -0.0786142647266388, 0.025196129456162453, -0.034386374056339264, 0.025179259479045868, 0.02549491450190544, 0.026390185579657555, -0.002398950047791004, -0.004626825451850891, 0.020056184381246567, 0.000718914030585438, -0.005735018756240606, 0.020355500280857086, 0.0009318547090515494, -0.013371570967137814, -0.008960889652371407, 0.023610159754753113, 0.0013122573727741838, -0.03654808551073074, -0.02284177951514721, -0.0054727401584386826, -0.00034758460242301226, 0.03645102307200432, -0.005327776540070772, 0.04545643553137779, -0.004977136850357056, 0.06938888132572174, -0.032761868089437485, -0.015422740019857883, -0.016582446172833443, 0.023110413923859596, -0.02088974416255951, 0.023561889305710793, -0.024744560942053795, 0.08120628446340561, 0.02969312109053135, 0.019441118463873863, -0.037296000868082047, 0.02357136271893978, -0.0359141081571579, -0.021617211401462555, 0.033388927578926086, -0.050483305007219315, 0.059706225991249084, -0.0006633876473642886, -0.013217434287071228, -0.014458884485065937, 0.015756497159600258, 0.013866959139704704, -0.07365471124649048, 0.027041714638471603, -0.013261525891721249, -0.04303407669067383, 0.032216403633356094, -0.011705581098794937, 0.012085005640983582, -0.04805288463830948, 0.013048838824033737, -0.06623092293739319, -0.012555859051644802, -0.02766893059015274, -0.037433791905641556, -0.05413791164755821, 0.022420043125748634, -0.026541536673903465, 0.010760863311588764, 0.03263724222779274, 0.011197240091860294, 0.012554069980978966, 0.004573396872729063, 0.00798817165195942, 0.04587944597005844, 0.040720365941524506, -0.0033303587697446346, 0.034534066915512085, 0.01909836381673813, -0.061297353357076645, 0.019445080310106277, -0.002973957220092416, -0.00889294408261776, 0.0549299456179142, 0.018108485266566277, -0.009863215498626232, 0.0046901339665055275, 0.058609090745449066, -0.00416838563978672, 0.004192225635051727, -0.016560643911361694, 0.009281088598072529, 0.04966649040579796, 0.013089119456708431, -0.018379826098680496, 0.017220940440893173, -0.0403292179107666, -0.0009940887102857232, 0.03622513264417648, -0.01901266537606716, -0.02596201002597809, -0.0034409991931170225, 0.014433405362069607, 0.000030130822779028676, 0.017115257680416107, 0.020821670070290565, 0.005789907183498144, 0.02103549614548683, -0.0007270179339684546, 0.04299961403012276, -0.03231072053313255, 0.01881231926381588, -0.07194532454013824, -0.04635520279407501, -0.0022365031763911247, 0.01605217717587948, 0.05604224279522896, -0.022003542631864548, 0.028891470283269882, 0.015320436097681522, -0.04079379141330719, 0.03988191485404968, -0.020231209695339203, 0.00648970203474164, -0.007350625935941935, 0.028674738481640816, -0.027919786050915718, 0.00591623829677701, 0.03774658963084221, 0.007909410633146763, 0.04071403294801712, 0.008298804052174091, 0.030652597546577454, -0.028351910412311554, -0.03703815117478371, 0.01694556139409542, 0.020132513716816902, -0.03731566667556763, 0.025746924802660942, -0.023558875545859337, -0.006101028528064489, 0.013631670735776424, -0.033617764711380005, 0.05782199651002884, 0.030807100236415863, 0.01726754568517208, 0.026905594393610954, 0.05566703900694847, 0.0128098726272583, 0.01070423424243927, -0.02320738695561886, -0.015098092146217823, 0.006295348051935434, 0.0033790762536227703, 0.037967249751091, 0.021003076806664467, 0.037744615226984024, 0.010496916249394417, -0.020778179168701172, 0.0175042524933815, -0.025527415797114372, 0.034077174961566925, 0.00007320826989598572, -0.0013492704601958394, 0.034955039620399475, -0.0012546505313366652, -0.008327341638505459, -0.010511516593396664, 0.04973415285348892, 0.030662478879094124, 0.01987791806459427, 0.0021452498622238636, 0.011283828876912594, -0.016135312616825104, -0.03120645135641098, -0.03735412657260895, 0.006246585864573717, 0.009237547405064106, -0.0021938439458608627, -0.025237085297703743, -0.040304623544216156, -0.016845988109707832, -0.031579289585351944, 0.028952110558748245, -0.03353811055421829, 0.01960025727748871, -0.03413000702857971, -0.005651793908327818, 0.022966664284467697, 0.004773407708853483, 0.04025184363126755, -0.10106024891138077, 0.01927831768989563, 0.021061856299638748, 0.00165897561237216, -0.009983749128878117, -0.027615899220108986, -0.04871015250682831, 0.050543446093797684, 0.04558344557881355, -0.0004560016968753189, 0.01592361181974411, 0.0032263549510389566, 0.0010830763494595885, 0.029370607808232307, -0.027257520705461502, 0.038588471710681915, -0.0085151894018054, -0.004644781816750765, -0.01344948261976242, 0.031584788113832474, 0.036179665476083755, 0.00521808909252286, -0.04832183197140694, 0.015773147344589233, 0.010802465490996838, 0.03821967914700508, -0.026496373116970062, -0.033161330968141556, -0.04747278615832329, -0.015340261161327362, 0.010136343538761139, 0.033996619284152985, -0.006620349362492561, 0.04434363916516304, -0.01135758776217699, -0.06492989510297775, 0.048236314207315445, -0.018083011731505394, -0.008095090277493, -0.03509139269590378, 0.03155432268977165, -0.008771850727498531, -0.010345428250730038, 0.033147141337394714, -0.0057370904833078384, -0.031919289380311966, 0.04608132317662239, 0.04992086812853813, 0.005466187838464975, 0.03695500269532204, -0.004496568348258734, 0.010742018930613995, -0.05546233430504799, -0.08547291904687881, 0.0731423944234848, -0.024815868586301804, -0.024588262662291527, 0.0066010779701173306, -0.023320915177464485, 0.03326829895377159, -0.0028237325605005026, -0.011956335976719856, -0.012261994183063507, 0.025857480242848396, -0.0035770507529377937, -0.009583004750311375, 0.002717442810535431, -0.0017823701491579413, 0.02259940654039383, 0.022169290110468864, 0.026758132502436638, 0.012969452887773514, -0.01860741712152958, 0.03922829404473305, -0.021634753793478012, -0.0008758861804381013, -0.011876441538333893, 0.011872254312038422, -0.0007262530270963907, 0.02203093096613884, -0.012880547903478146, -0.02552124112844467, -0.009595687501132488, -0.0294637531042099, -0.023323822766542435, -0.016788270324468613, 0.0029958325903862715, -0.017161406576633453, -0.018360886722803116, 0.0028093145228922367, 0.007953120395541191, -0.0076401615515351295, -0.004498574882745743, -0.005307807587087154, 0.04622138664126396, 0.009120886214077473, -0.012140210717916489, 0.03244072571396828, 0.012292037717998028, -0.018338672816753387, -0.037364695221185684, 0.008799197152256966, -0.021733228117227554, 0.0199668500572443, 0.032622743397951126, -0.022821493446826935 ]
<p>Am trying to develop a predictive model using high-dimensional clinical data including laboratory values. The data space is sparse with 5k samples and 200 variables. The idea is to rank the variables using a feature selection method (IG, RF etc) and use top-ranking features for developing a predictive model. </p> <p>While feature selection is going well with a Naïve Bayes approach, am now hitting an issue in implementing predictive model due to missing data (NA) in my variable space. Is there any machine learning algorithm that can carefully handle samples with missing data ? </p> <p>Any examples ? </p> <p>Thanks for your help in advance! </p>
33,717
[ -0.029525309801101685, -0.009259385988116264, 0.022712377831339836, -0.0009974557906389236, 0.03720158711075783, -0.012330221012234688, -0.004864533897489309, -0.024997202679514885, 0.03921641781926155, -0.020703217014670372, 0.035360101610422134, 0.010122252628207207, 0.06803133338689804, -0.0035353314597159624, -0.03674301505088806, 0.019046342000365257, -0.0197824165225029, -0.022703342139720917, 0.018387097865343094, -0.002644485328346491, -0.015075590461492538, 0.019968494772911072, 0.056325092911720276, -0.008597585372626781, -0.02600797452032566, 0.040274590253829956, 0.023367201909422874, -0.01278346125036478, -0.001866028644144535, 0.02344348281621933, -0.051354341208934784, -0.022863980382680893, 0.02142176404595375, 0.062291376292705536, -0.007261470891535282, -0.01981460116803646, -0.0070525119081139565, -0.01809590309858322, -0.003596953582018614, 0.035798877477645874, -0.00714533356949687, -0.0466633103787899, 0.0018412896897643805, 0.03817656263709068, -0.017949681729078293, 0.014483657665550709, -0.022172361612319946, -0.009019278921186924, 0.03141247108578682, -0.05287329852581024, 0.05868871882557869, 0.011700400151312351, 0.05898713320493698, 0.019102858379483223, -0.024858571588993073, -0.021487073972821236, 0.039971884340047836, 0.08988162875175476, 0.018669484183192253, -0.07974380999803543, -0.009607668966054916, -0.021047338843345642, -0.0002199227747041732, -0.0008972586947493255, -0.04623152315616608, 0.057147372514009476, -0.030639300122857094, -0.00575598981231451, 0.016999969258904457, 0.019026419147849083, -0.011308585293591022, 0.007425679825246334, 0.00899991113692522, -0.037273842841386795, 0.03718239441514015, -0.0202876478433609, -0.02034119702875614, 0.03136010840535164, 0.040973883122205734, 0.023630904033780098, -0.0033474501688033342, -0.009619146585464478, 0.018961330875754356, 0.042562324553728104, -0.007729602046310902, -0.03467114269733429, 0.02559700235724449, -0.04296679049730301, 0.009804035536944866, 0.01660476066172123, -0.054120972752571106, 0.003115011379122734, 0.049758028239011765, 0.03384988009929657, -0.03216097131371498, -0.0009093208354897797, -0.028085537254810333, 0.047383200377225876, 0.021269526332616806, 0.00236878776922822, 0.012133242562413216, -0.005027927458286285, -0.010651366785168648, 0.08111445605754852, -0.045431479811668396, -0.03195100650191307, -0.02323256991803646, -0.027329029515385628, 0.0005177142447791994, 0.023761887103319168, -0.04609781876206398, 0.005940079689025879, 0.011426521465182304, -0.00860237330198288, 0.025465724989771843, -0.026041872799396515, -0.04831479489803314, -0.05440148711204529, 0.045222606509923935, 0.10626375675201416, 0.006057528778910637, -0.025226714089512825, 0.023995185270905495, -0.027741175144910812, -0.05743846297264099, -0.009937272407114506, -0.0170145221054554, -0.021209290251135826, 0.008587676100432873, 0.04778473824262619, -0.0320865698158741, -0.030882183462381363, 0.06899029016494751, -0.02303295023739338, 0.06690119951963425, -0.01183242816478014, -0.07158546149730682, -0.021930145099759102, 0.018334921449422836, -0.06828499585390091, 0.028963519260287285, -0.045760102570056915, -0.000047492634621448815, 0.04123475030064583, 0.03909378498792648, 0.037248603999614716, 0.0060316105373203754, 0.04221826419234276, 0.027159037068486214, 0.00830172747373581, -0.02441023290157318, -0.0168999582529068, -0.02050080895423889, 0.014804008416831493, -0.009984498843550682, -0.04798329621553421, 0.008477441966533661, 0.029562238603830338, -0.020653430372476578, 0.020014498382806778, 0.009156452491879463, -0.006241241469979286, -0.01963212341070175, -0.009664670564234257, 0.016309494152665138, -0.00227352580986917, 0.0476178415119648, 0.017780516296625137, 0.03935471922159195, 0.03487428277730942, -0.01209561713039875, 0.00029111423646099865, 0.03498473018407822, 0.057650867849588394, 0.028718480840325356, 0.02627190575003624, -0.00836307555437088, -0.008366980589926243, 0.028938742354512215, 0.012487100437283516, 0.0036850320175290108, -0.03719468414783478, 0.0012694845208898187, 0.012960136868059635, -0.014006386511027813, 0.026648186147212982, 0.012831690721213818, -0.01979687623679638, 0.07804472744464874, -0.03441198170185089, -0.025596706196665764, -0.045142289251089096, -0.01325246598571539, 0.014692219905555248, -0.00697636092081666, 0.017207970842719078, 0.007624771911650896, 0.012158147990703583, 0.005447023082524538, -0.012180285528302193, -0.034531641751527786, -0.032021522521972656, 0.01944504678249359, -0.007408826146274805, -0.009969552978873253, 0.03582087159156799, 0.0010966169647872448, -0.032126422971487045, 0.030402084812521935, -0.04297737404704094, -0.06160195916891098, 0.007195951417088509, -0.04032794013619423, 0.0317404568195343, -0.03704826906323433, -0.01738915592432022, 0.011591856367886066, -0.03899693116545677, -0.02216986007988453, 0.036820922046899796, -0.03898869827389717, 0.05707046017050743, 0.0248864758759737, 0.02372097410261631, 0.043034229427576065, 0.0015992658445611596, -0.0008040592074394226, -0.01165773905813694, -0.03718416020274162, -0.00046072868281044066, -0.03391249105334282, -0.008648436516523361, 0.024811988696455956, -0.005479075014591217, -0.04749770835042, 0.03315160050988197, 0.025217153131961823, 0.011321766301989555, 0.03755316883325577, 0.039892975240945816, -0.004665709566324949, -0.021797124296426773, 0.0052527557127177715, 0.03735476732254028, 0.01563042216002941, 0.0044564600102603436, -0.016655417159199715, -0.0005058756796643138, 0.042454738169908524, -0.0252881720662117, -0.015640022233128548, 0.030138378962874413, 0.01179991103708744, -0.01813337951898575, -0.026347465813159943, -0.048155732452869415, 0.04293793812394142, -0.002509467303752899, 0.005549144931137562, 0.047507334500551224, -0.006034243386238813, 0.011303919367492199, 0.007761228829622269, -0.003721923101693392, 0.039118487387895584, 0.04325707256793976, -0.01266480702906847, 0.04315050691366196, 0.014727171510457993, -0.0761123076081276, 0.026646198704838753, -0.00895350705832243, -0.006654154043644667, -0.042714595794677734, 0.016510505229234695, 0.04063328355550766, 0.009415185078978539, 0.03436730057001114, -0.0013284835731610656, -0.029238780960440636, 0.022077742964029312, -0.03960799798369408, 0.012199205346405506, 0.057444360107183456, -0.02598509192466736, -0.019437365233898163, -0.034018777310848236, -0.017607133835554123, 0.04287085309624672, -0.0071325707249343395, -0.040194179862737656, -0.0006683213287033141, -0.023654604330658913, -0.0631222128868103, -0.01585674285888672, -0.0025466212537139654, 0.04097204655408859, 0.025203529745340347, 0.006508694961667061, 0.03815615922212601, -0.0008986727334558964, -0.05233060196042061, -0.022484190762043, -0.020378708839416504, 0.006200883537530899, -0.0368553027510643, -0.006888380274176598, -0.006356766913086176, 0.009482762776315212, -0.017494691535830498, 0.06746979057788849, -0.025785598903894424, 0.0453033410012722, -0.07398678362369537, -0.056495100259780884, 0.02229025959968567, -0.03309709578752518, 0.0172035563737154, 0.036678291857242584, 0.011336859315633774, 0.065483458340168, 0.03964770585298538, -0.05422037094831467, -0.020255500450730324, -0.03295644000172615, -0.021046970039606094, -0.048485685139894485, 0.04325250908732414, 0.007116973865777254, 0.030970102176070213, -0.013832112774252892, -0.01612335629761219, 0.029703153297305107, 0.0624319389462471, 0.023200443014502525, -0.005370655562728643, 0.03670632839202881, -0.002942378632724285, 0.03347489610314369, -0.0031818600837141275, 0.015123486518859863, -0.03246302530169487, -0.004296062979847193, -0.01589585654437542, 0.0431576631963253, 0.00889158621430397, -0.07256203144788742, -0.028924578800797462, -0.03223510831594467, 0.056942086666822433, -0.01110875979065895, -0.025792745873332024, 0.03323112055659294, -0.024608276784420013, -0.008082165382802486, 0.03311567008495331, 0.0414162203669548, -0.011489134281873703, 0.004227827303111553, 0.05479330196976662, 0.02053171955049038, 0.004554251208901405, 0.016066916286945343, 0.006954083684831858, -0.014997506514191628, 0.04058961570262909, -0.05235780403017998, -0.0006439104909077287, 0.02844465710222721, 0.02158329449594021, 0.006953749340027571, 0.014648315496742725, -0.06562475860118866, 0.056581877171993256, -0.06258094310760498, 0.0017966304440051317, -0.002376238349825144, 0.06602450460195541, -0.0031296382658183575, 0.01006828062236309, 0.029155539348721504, 0.019369540736079216, 0.020374001935124397, 0.005256540607661009, -0.07052256911993027, 0.002588971285149455, -0.0012518701842054725, 0.01871010661125183, 0.012334750033915043, -0.008173614740371704, 0.016369126737117767, -0.012546266429126263, -0.004063750617206097, -0.01428844965994358, 0.04617493227124214, -0.03929799422621727, 0.012960514053702354, -0.019962331280112267, 0.022589733824133873, -0.02281320095062256, 0.005978726781904697, 0.028837498277425766, 0.003831038251519203, 0.031710680574178696, 0.03517572209239006, 0.012954482808709145, -0.027726972475647926, -0.006106473971158266, 0.02908247895538807, 0.025848157703876495, 0.06541290879249573, 0.03658033534884453, 0.05446939170360565, -0.050771065056324005, -0.00035864600795321167, -0.019376516342163086, 0.042582813650369644, 0.033214230090379715, -0.0024864543229341507, -0.033599454909563065, -0.03542978689074516, -0.021610211580991745, -0.01986047253012657, 0.002462446689605713, 0.025815119966864586, 0.015747107565402985, 0.029984204098582268, 0.012540633790194988, -0.06447666883468628, 0.009029669687151909, 0.03355573117733002, 0.06321825832128525, 0.005628582090139389, -0.017742302268743515, 0.009103772230446339, -0.0005897661321796477, -0.0070353723131120205, 0.04401664808392525, 0.002131439745426178, -0.010847760364413261, -0.038300346583127975, 0.018922479823231697, -0.006608688272535801, -0.013392767868936062, -0.009499337524175644, 0.03863152116537094, 0.03361979126930237, 0.009417505003511906, -0.00972030870616436, 0.02801513858139515, 0.046429671347141266, 0.02724459581077099, 0.038652922958135605, 0.029238978400826454, -0.11162754893302917, -0.0007385042845271528, 0.025013718754053116, 0.016833601519465446, -0.0027885769959539175, -0.04339269921183586, -0.041383296251297, -0.010134718380868435, 0.03436777740716934, -0.031143048778176308, 0.019250920042395592, -0.019015314057469368, -0.0036711327265948057, -0.023567812517285347, -0.024671196937561035, -0.04025011137127876, 0.00536767253652215, -0.017877670004963875, 0.047552451491355896, -0.02691071294248104, -0.03748789429664612, -0.02715166099369526, 0.02446001023054123, -0.03097650222480297, 0.07037002593278885, 0.03344113007187843, -0.005136969964951277, 0.024617722257971764, 0.06505163013935089, -0.019799459725618362, -0.053271811455488205, 0.011340303346514702, 0.007447977550327778, -0.015459061600267887, 0.0321819931268692, -0.015608084388077259, -0.06886248290538788, 0.02140958234667778, 0.03945811092853546, -0.04248536005616188, -0.03905786946415901, -0.025795679539442062, 0.010178795084357262, 0.02008924074470997, -0.014980590902268887, 0.05501190200448036, 0.0217730775475502, 0.01529920194298029, -0.03444143012166023, -0.02352568879723549, 0.014394798316061497, -0.01214961614459753, -0.027136264368891716, -0.035402629524469376, -0.0428478829562664, 0.0038062722887843847, 0.014876361936330795, 0.014511183835566044, 0.06312795728445053, -0.013270789757370949, -0.00948338396847248, 0.008994430303573608, 0.013448617421090603, -0.018887968733906746, -0.02694241888821125, -0.03454122319817543, -0.003648611484095454, 0.001588953658938408, 0.004681937396526337, 0.049248430877923965, 0.004825908690690994, 0.006472710985690355, 0.016307679936289787, -0.05644901096820831, -0.010685115121304989, -0.0189045500010252, -0.005047329235821962, 0.023799024522304535, 0.013964736834168434, 0.03087020292878151, -0.028307968750596046, 0.03941971808671951, -0.014725545421242714, -0.032025061547756195, -0.022471651434898376, 0.027625862509012222, 0.005344506353139877, 0.020055072382092476, -0.01769023947417736, 0.03888074308633804, -0.028697839006781578, 0.0012926742201671004, -0.06601905077695847, -0.04761958122253418, 0.008331799879670143, 0.02418193407356739, -0.05546387657523155, -0.02329177036881447, 0.021502172574400902, -0.023255258798599243, -0.008408928290009499, -0.0050332434475421906, 0.030763141810894012, -0.023384178057312965, -0.023928049951791763, 0.00723138265311718, -0.014177600853145123, 0.04168219119310379, -0.017125435173511505, -0.024669788777828217, 0.041999537497758865, -0.019195307046175003, 0.028300998732447624, -0.008363286964595318, 0.028140833601355553, -0.04235488921403885, -0.019605975598096848, -0.029535340145230293, 0.006185045465826988, 0.03487660735845566, -0.013807712122797966, 0.010198458097875118, 0.021128078922629356, -0.012439277023077011, 0.012784700840711594, -0.028163738548755646, 0.01253129169344902, -0.012531931512057781, -0.02685215137898922, -0.008376585319638252, 0.007710934150964022, 0.001764004467986524, -0.015238558873534203, 0.004285153467208147, 0.0073820240795612335, 0.01791250705718994, 0.021154925227165222, 0.006987402681261301, -0.009502431377768517, 0.018859360367059708, -0.0009199735359288752, -0.055094439536333084, 0.04070842266082764, 0.020634256303310394, 0.026438238099217415, -0.032627735286951065, 0.016066666692495346, -0.0812942236661911, -0.040883563458919525, -0.045422740280628204, -0.0123257115483284, 0.05854472517967224, -0.02316392958164215, 0.013235910795629025, 0.025004196912050247, -0.01572156883776188, -0.01835828274488449, -0.010092223063111305, -0.008579446002840996, 0.006692856550216675, 0.01283929031342268, 0.04809528961777687, 0.025515273213386536, 0.03079714998602867, 0.021724391728639603, 0.01289792824536562, 0.010539904236793518, 0.0346677303314209, 0.010604890994727612, 0.025337884202599525, 0.016581594944000244, -0.03194066882133484, -0.06137479841709137, -0.00845846813172102, -0.028693245723843575, 0.0038893227465450764, 0.00044066825648769736, -0.032995663583278656, 0.03164246305823326, 0.013785824179649353, 0.021035145968198776, -0.015300856903195381, -0.017398212105035782, -0.031642697751522064, 0.018808087334036827, 0.046693768352270126, -0.03125256672501564, 0.0379914827644825, 0.023903436958789825, 0.03722304850816727, -0.0019300557905808091, 0.035909876227378845, -0.04632670432329178, -0.08218343555927277, -0.02765709161758423, -0.0245140939950943, -0.017831509932875633, 0.029335960745811462, 0.028621383011341095, -0.0024661014322191477, 0.008532987907528877, -0.0021584220230579376, 0.049604300409555435, -0.01743018440902233, 0.038072891533374786, -0.007445475086569786, 0.05876278877258301, 0.013812598772346973, 0.01656646654009819, 0.022473398596048355, 0.013558649457991123, 0.12306594103574753, 0.08276957273483276, 0.08487758785486221, -0.07356476783752441, 0.00858389213681221, -0.003905283287167549, -0.01596164144575596, -0.0208296962082386, 0.023389937356114388, -0.005824297200888395, -0.02506357990205288, 0.03627289459109306, 0.0009197950130328536, 0.005621955730021, 0.02645862102508545, 0.04890966787934303, -0.0813644751906395, -0.040297672152519226, -0.0003607185499276966, -0.001222064602188766, 0.011815633624792099, -0.01860669068992138, -0.04066265746951103, 0.05466203764081001, 0.024785025045275688, -0.07866248488426208, -0.011800069361925125, 0.025272853672504425, -0.009416225366294384, -0.025014542043209076, -0.005569485016167164, 0.020078571513295174, 0.005653850734233856, 0.048036567866802216, 0.01031013485044241, 0.009715428575873375, 0.00492248497903347, 0.0032503947149962187, -0.016332682222127914, -0.008193998597562313, -0.0026087197475135326, -0.0150456503033638, 0.0010398367885500193, 0.002543983981013298, -0.027944745495915413, -0.00998863484710455, -0.023042654618620872, 0.07999789714813232, -0.015194021165370941, -0.010068210773169994, -0.033583518117666245, 0.010925537906587124, 0.005505439359694719, -0.03317055106163025, -0.031087089329957962, 0.04829217866063118, 0.06400471925735474, -0.0381353534758091, -0.032366905361413956, 0.005665735807269812, 0.032666854560375214, 0.013021605089306831, 0.029983950778841972, 0.032284460961818695, 0.002462447388097644, -0.025139424949884415, -0.01537965890020132, 0.02312830463051796, 0.017252646386623383, 0.03216119110584259, 0.014589664526283741, -0.024702589958906174, 0.009852390736341476, -0.01655842922627926, 0.033984698355197906, 0.01659555546939373, -0.012204091995954514, -0.04811451956629753, -0.02566484361886978, -0.024709943681955338, -0.06465443968772888, 0.009467210620641708, -0.0450189933180809, -0.022804828360676765, -0.03705330565571785, 0.012392851524055004, 0.00024474176461808383, 0.06781899183988571, 0.04112652316689491, -0.018890921026468277, 0.03174694627523422, 0.05023474246263504, 0.015370002947747707, -0.04269610717892647, -0.019565891474485397, -0.03155625984072685, -0.046562619507312775, 0.030050775036215782, 0.017994733527302742, 0.052356451749801636, 0.01100234780460596, 0.0239153653383255, -0.004538669250905514, 0.039508234709501266, -0.0007356512942351401, -0.013569923117756844, -0.001653824932873249, -0.046460799872875214, -0.0029429798014461994, -0.04028159752488136, 0.026992807164788246, -0.039189599454402924, -0.019126562401652336, 0.010775002650916576, -0.02136099711060524, 0.018114082515239716, -0.024231327697634697, -0.024827223271131516, 0.00045553978998214006, 0.01737215742468834, 0.016362551599740982, -0.008960826322436333, 0.03864217922091484, -0.04106035828590393, -0.005093988496810198, -0.009261416271328926, -0.034810759127140045, -0.021067442372441292, 0.02086109295487404, -0.05548844859004021, 0.006577188614755869, 0.011839650571346283, -0.018945060670375824, 0.009914974682033062, 0.008070576936006546, 0.00939809437841177, -0.02174815535545349, 0.05053752288222313, -0.0622711256146431, -0.011858846060931683, -0.023167617619037628, -0.06172088906168938, -0.008755041286349297, 0.0413784384727478, -0.02376484125852585, 0.014973441138863564, 0.0229401383548975, -0.00851390790194273, -0.03276093304157257, 0.02343304269015789, -0.01883764937520027, -0.012750744819641113, -0.014198528602719307, 0.05437059327960014, -0.038120564073324203, 0.006149740889668465, -0.01654246263206005, 0.02628634311258793, -0.0254986472427845, 0.0021262546069920063, 0.052206408232450485, 0.05814390629529953, -0.018445152789354324, 0.04282981902360916, 0.006003835238516331, 0.01742139831185341, 0.029282724484801292, 0.0023207305930554867, -0.004604252055287361, 0.01920446939766407, 0.01613830216228962, 0.03985438495874405, 0.016865113750100136, 0.04279336705803871, -0.1149422749876976, -0.047768816351890564, 0.02562611550092697, 0.004932084586471319, 0.04167744144797325, -0.048617925494909286, 0.010817235335707664, 0.03383438289165497, -0.07437251508235931, 0.01928141713142395, 0.032806072384119034, -0.005175685975700617, -0.01080508716404438, 0.016134094446897507, -0.02397417463362217, -0.00954632367938757, 0.034366101026535034, 0.005263208877295256, 0.03711599484086037, 0.026351287961006165, 0.017842385917901993, -0.047522492706775665, -0.02050413377583027, 0.04304691404104233, 0.011148376390337944, -0.0890292301774025, 0.014936843886971474, -0.03260226920247078, -0.03883197158575058, -0.0027030908968299627, -0.010761920362710953, 0.03612125664949417, 0.0209791362285614, 0.0032651147339493036, -0.020061515271663666, 0.05157386139035225, 0.018598850816488266, -0.042945120483636856, 0.00545485457405448, -0.0009228475973941386, -0.006117596291005611, 0.019072217866778374, -0.008129334077239037, 0.044370006769895554, 0.03070627711713314, -0.019333578646183014, 0.004457029048353434, -0.015429397113621235, -0.0017641627928242087, -0.013329284265637398, 0.023288212716579437, 0.027839668095111847, -0.0038166663143783808, -0.03100082464516163, -0.019600985571742058, -0.045941293239593506, -0.0025052474811673164, 0.040028903633356094, 0.021246643736958504, -0.03578730300068855, -0.010742316953837872, -0.002013541292399168, -0.0679415687918663, -0.003517512697726488, 0.025089383125305176, -0.02295818366110325, -0.03799473121762276, -0.00866046454757452, 0.011022346094250679, -0.035458873957395554, 0.0064980159513652325, 0.000707726227119565, -0.04038919135928154, 0.04827774316072464, -0.018699195235967636, 0.043725740164518356, 0.038323622196912766, -0.011037994176149368, 0.04068680480122566, -0.08429797738790512, 0.03431563079357147, -0.0106583246961236, -0.009809397161006927, 0.021840887144207954, -0.0070367357693612576, -0.026062509045004845, -0.005997933447360992, 0.053904224187135696, 0.0028711743652820587, 0.02341432496905327, -0.03391284868121147, 0.005758083425462246, -0.01553288009017706, -0.04675428569316864, 0.05712015926837921, -0.0026067120488733053, -0.0045357998460531235, -0.03486824035644531, 0.01241153571754694, 0.03175424784421921, 0.016446130350232124, 0.013531516306102276, -0.023277664557099342, 0.004974186886101961, 0.00997860822826624, 0.021715305745601654, 0.009113616310060024, -0.007936733774840832, -0.03067331574857235, 0.030894912779331207, -0.006625541485846043, 0.015693822875618935, 0.01673578843474388, -0.009398018009960651, -0.059454161673784256, 0.03835790976881981, -0.037169720977544785, -0.006182114593684673, 0.012081979773938656, 0.004595750942826271, -0.005501292180269957, -0.07420911639928818, 0.009232982061803341, 0.02902872860431671, -0.005032613407820463, 0.01989489607512951, 0.027568167075514793, -0.025514381006360054, 0.020058095455169678, 0.014593536965548992, -0.015348941087722778, 0.01028617937117815, 0.014911247417330742, -0.009313829243183136, 0.0006151144625619054, 0.016780754551291466, 0.0025816329289227724, 0.04053287208080292, 0.02607550099492073, -0.004286014009267092, 0.009178424254059792, -0.007853659801185131, 0.025905661284923553, -0.04144924879074097, 0.000987458974123001, -0.025433525443077087, -0.015847697854042053, 0.03476697579026222, -0.030242810025811195, 0.011644781567156315, 0.07234737277030945, -0.03962711617350578, -0.004339412786066532, -0.05278586968779564, -0.01375133078545332, -0.009977241978049278, 0.0013449330581352115, -0.057925909757614136, 0.045075424015522, -0.002818515757098794, 0.009080310352146626, -0.011665403842926025, -0.021485503762960434, 0.005911628250032663, -0.041634440422058105, -0.00812241155654192, -0.01500855851918459, 0.004863840527832508, 0.007947113364934921, -0.031053602695465088, 0.026102129369974136, -0.013232497498393059, -0.011345981620252132, 0.04309997707605362, 0.03228265792131424, -0.0629534125328064, -0.0015175463631749153, -0.03098108433187008, 0.03489645943045616, -0.024051368236541748, 0.008341796696186066, -0.06753833591938019, -0.0014426433481276035, -0.04561624303460121, -0.012054002843797207 ]
<p>I do a GLM containing 8 predictors on a multivariate data set. Six of these predictors encode effects that have actually been manipulated in my experiment (effects of interest), the other two predictors are noise-predictors of physiological side-effects that influence the data, but are not meant to. </p> <p>It turns out that both noise-predictors have a high load in the GLM. Now I was wondering whether it might be possible to use that knowledge in order to correct for these undesired distortions in the data. Is there generally a way to use the beta weights of the GLM to regularize the data post-hoc, so that when re-estimating the GLM these predictors would be zero?</p> <p>Thanks a lot.</p>
73,794
[ -0.029236115515232086, 0.05698251351714134, 0.023460596799850464, 0.0061913058161735535, 0.04459359124302864, 0.03068692795932293, 0.005469360388815403, -0.010760360397398472, 0.03312132507562637, -0.054963499307632446, 0.018761046230793, 0.03470253199338913, 0.06633913516998291, 0.007272779941558838, 0.022082924842834473, -0.01590277999639511, -0.009724798612296581, -0.018154673278331757, -0.00430602952837944, -0.022279266268014908, 0.00028426310745999217, 0.0461980402469635, -0.01986340992152691, -0.01806538924574852, -0.027322858572006226, 0.07057461887598038, 0.023232433944940567, -0.036087796092033386, -0.03030085749924183, 0.037512876093387604, -0.014078882522881031, -0.02068035490810871, 0.00480018462985754, 0.02908613160252571, 0.000784671981818974, -0.011533649638295174, -0.030202092602849007, -0.01472155936062336, -0.023334065452218056, 0.049816008657217026, -0.006460726261138916, -0.011053447611629963, -0.007817210629582405, 0.056302472949028015, -0.010468507185578346, 0.01550094410777092, -0.0009575005387887359, -0.02064315602183342, 0.03476155921816826, -0.037963345646858215, 0.09789198637008667, -0.02910091169178486, 0.055967316031455994, 0.047832198441028595, -0.01237856037914753, 0.008149147033691406, 0.07014048844575882, 0.07700185477733612, 0.008140039630234241, -0.04480353742837906, -0.007646093610674143, -0.03183823823928833, 0.0187812689691782, -0.0006142069469206035, -0.0047022029757499695, 0.017728980630636215, -0.008004484698176384, -0.01217623706907034, 0.04708264023065567, -0.019062986597418785, 0.03934147581458092, 0.01476367935538292, 0.05716574192047119, 0.025187039747834206, -0.0050149643793702126, -0.024578556418418884, 0.009961800649762154, 0.021232379600405693, 0.05470849201083183, -0.014074482955038548, -0.01659001037478447, 0.001257055439054966, 0.02467804029583931, 0.05997656285762787, -0.016200991347432137, -0.02751903235912323, 0.02685452252626419, -0.05657387524843216, 0.049563925713300705, 0.03890406712889671, -0.01466284692287445, -0.02064562402665615, 0.06155741959810257, 0.023931898176670074, -0.04694036394357681, 0.04198390990495682, -0.014723666943609715, 0.029805734753608704, 0.0012467966880649328, -0.001490808674134314, -0.01188907865434885, -0.03568592295050621, -0.01277682464569807, 0.05174347758293152, -0.04789535701274872, -0.006066355388611555, -0.015691867098212242, -0.013044278137385845, -0.0170905701816082, -0.020745880901813507, -0.03523952513933182, 0.00792823638767004, 0.006421166472136974, -0.05296213924884796, 0.018529724329710007, -0.004246777389198542, -0.022863227874040604, -0.013567742891609669, 0.03598422929644585, 0.047739867120981216, 0.016071047633886337, -0.022328026592731476, 0.026847584173083305, 0.006628621369600296, -0.0322512686252594, 0.01193961687386036, 0.03579835221171379, -0.04567505046725273, -0.04381588473916054, 0.06959906965494156, 0.04421678185462952, -0.049126964062452316, 0.04458974301815033, 0.004994076211005449, -0.001342203700914979, 0.015739576891064644, -0.034767404198646545, -0.06255459040403366, 0.014169206842780113, -0.04496792331337929, -0.002110664267092943, -0.0654112845659256, -0.029275652021169662, 0.017839869484305382, 0.07277163863182068, 0.03496633097529411, 0.02503739297389984, 0.04384538158774376, 0.029972011223435402, 0.017359070479869843, 0.0010579427471384406, -0.028596648946404457, -0.03546998277306557, -0.011122330091893673, -0.04817768931388855, -0.08311008661985397, 0.012723837047815323, 0.018958961591124535, -0.03759480267763138, 0.006486998870968819, 0.022548187524080276, 0.007134256884455681, -0.009618113748729229, -0.03155490383505821, 0.003355191322043538, -0.024411195889115334, 0.0263501089066267, -0.021355459466576576, 0.01855074241757393, 0.016706274822354317, -0.022567836567759514, 0.018888043239712715, -0.03130686655640602, 0.053875647485256195, 0.021008159965276718, -0.020142048597335815, 0.02247939072549343, -0.004233312793076038, 0.03729306906461716, 0.016946887597441673, 0.020091034471988678, -0.011600477620959282, -0.019793091341853142, -0.005546518601477146, 0.02651720494031906, 0.03352547436952591, -0.0029117290396243334, -0.027536315843462944, 0.05468561872839928, -0.023361746221780777, -0.019465455785393715, -0.06992244720458984, -0.01087050698697567, -0.027298854663968086, -0.02021981216967106, 0.02687493897974491, -0.02069585956633091, 0.031541332602500916, -0.01486193761229515, 0.005761232692748308, -0.013079270720481873, -0.004526086617261171, 0.03389500081539154, -0.010155195370316505, -0.016517089679837227, 0.03513684868812561, 0.05044274032115936, -0.03452562540769577, 0.059903889894485474, -0.025668449699878693, -0.020148638635873795, -0.02089274302124977, -0.06516259163618088, 0.016027910634875298, -0.042369548231363297, -0.01976804807782173, 0.024090437218546867, -0.0277630053460598, -0.013728184625506401, 0.0054132407531142235, -0.04567704349756241, 0.037465356290340424, 0.07325506210327148, -0.04448502138257027, 0.014515019953250885, 0.01423756405711174, -0.0019126853439956903, 0.020619317889213562, -0.042875830084085464, -0.03643159940838814, -0.03608732670545578, 0.002220522379502654, 0.03782843425869942, 0.021167529746890068, -0.012365642003715038, -0.003998608328402042, 0.016434673219919205, 0.02116706594824791, 0.020557820796966553, 0.05166681110858917, 0.0005357968620955944, -0.014118264429271221, 0.04021017998456955, 0.004350620321929455, 0.03197524696588516, 0.013597673736512661, 0.01611923612654209, 0.007120321970432997, 0.06453529000282288, -0.04003555700182915, 0.008268963545560837, 0.03026132471859455, -0.003959671128541231, -0.017995299771428108, -0.025143248960375786, -0.035954754799604416, 0.05472290888428688, 0.010098529979586601, 0.08291852474212646, 0.016565922647714615, -0.0011008074507117271, -0.0018245783867314458, 0.019978981465101242, 0.0077714757062494755, 0.02484685368835926, 0.028264451771974564, -0.04207303375005722, 0.021791672334074974, 0.027841320261359215, -0.04168606922030449, 0.024007225409150124, 0.014638296328485012, -0.026250747963786125, -0.012530751526355743, 0.04177483171224594, 0.012073598802089691, 0.01117735356092453, 0.00951298326253891, -0.017548445612192154, -0.016932910308241844, 0.0030127086210995913, -0.008180095814168453, 0.03402016684412956, 0.05494615063071251, -0.058276668190956116, 0.0012415028177201748, -0.028963670134544373, 0.025899691507220268, 0.01851579360663891, -0.004503372125327587, 0.0009704417898319662, 0.015302624553442001, -0.017848925665020943, -0.0645991712808609, -0.01512786652892828, -0.03823881223797798, 0.007300693541765213, 0.02345898374915123, -0.021984783932566643, 0.03292561694979668, 0.04330507293343544, -0.039749495685100555, 0.011702509596943855, -0.01322503574192524, 0.005069105885922909, -0.026813043281435966, -0.014565696008503437, 0.023029619827866554, 0.0017236514249816537, 0.04063492268323898, 0.012571921572089195, -0.02637362666428089, -0.02753486856818199, -0.05974804237484932, -0.06489992141723633, 0.02363484725356102, 0.0014349002158269286, 0.021454578265547752, 0.012239241041243076, -0.05507528781890869, 0.09075906872749329, 0.037975724786520004, -0.03734322637319565, -0.026533054187893867, -0.04276948422193527, -0.011278461664915085, -0.027728058397769928, 0.010790812782943249, 0.028267327696084976, 0.029725447297096252, 0.051407940685749054, -0.010052060708403587, -0.0015370959881693125, -0.005372839979827404, 0.05083465948700905, -0.03911968693137169, 0.011242427863180637, 0.007967428304255009, 0.004621035885065794, 0.01514414045959711, 0.00984769593924284, 0.013059727847576141, 0.008836189284920692, -0.0013566259294748306, -0.010658282786607742, -0.010932854376733303, -0.06581225991249084, -0.026973426342010498, 0.017977025359869003, 0.03875674307346344, -0.025739241391420364, 0.023758359253406525, 0.015632590278983116, -0.05076419934630394, -0.0387633852660656, 0.02154696360230446, 0.030040109530091286, -0.011616149917244911, 0.022268084809184074, 0.03324718773365021, 0.02816099114716053, 0.011325612664222717, -0.0028858911246061325, 0.002505933167412877, 0.0002083879371639341, 0.015571502037346363, -0.03268967196345329, -0.048029445111751556, 0.03191496059298515, 0.03160366788506508, -0.006762540899217129, 0.0012906243791803718, -0.05400591343641281, 0.03252032771706581, -0.05448506399989128, 0.006485908292233944, -0.02750641293823719, 0.013419746421277523, 0.02447262778878212, 0.0244476068764925, 0.004091906361281872, -0.0011884800624102354, 0.01779710128903389, 0.01577361673116684, -0.05041000619530678, 0.03457586467266083, 0.012113090604543686, -0.018579617142677307, 0.02146446704864502, 0.000233339611440897, 0.043799784034490585, -0.046732865273952484, -0.0032304890919476748, 0.003245533909648657, -0.008093194104731083, -0.05661075562238693, -0.013017095625400543, -0.01695919595658779, -0.03402385860681534, -0.02959791198372841, 0.008218087255954742, 0.027417490258812904, -0.02687971293926239, 0.032657235860824585, 0.009450871497392654, -0.004681819584220648, -0.0043643261305987835, -0.060220371931791306, 0.018513308838009834, -0.0029635585378855467, 0.03575475886464119, 0.010865160264074802, 0.014537213370203972, -0.06118876114487648, 0.03263465315103531, 0.01215832494199276, 0.028621848672628403, 0.0390956737101078, 0.005972185637801886, -0.05265209823846817, -0.03318868204951286, -0.017898548394441605, 0.018495481461286545, 0.013406488113105297, 0.024401741102337837, 0.012241510674357414, 0.03455889970064163, 0.02031894028186798, -0.05030469968914986, -0.0032773171551525593, 0.04909924045205116, 0.04054183140397072, 0.0005067696911282837, -0.01315091922879219, 0.006245612166821957, 0.027584653347730637, 0.006618194747716188, 0.004557759501039982, -0.012828742153942585, 0.006409021094441414, 0.004437222145497799, 0.015436515212059021, 0.0006448978092521429, -0.004815305583178997, 0.012243079952895641, 0.04151447117328644, 0.036707621067762375, 0.04537283629179001, -0.014001913368701935, 0.025500908493995667, 0.03584952652454376, 0.05459015816450119, 0.024992458522319794, -0.011727791279554367, -0.07672904431819916, -0.008176099509000778, 0.028386862948536873, 0.05654926970601082, -0.010783875361084938, -0.016569919884204865, -0.024576053023338318, -0.03123088739812374, 0.03902026265859604, -0.030805358663201332, 0.009608656167984009, 0.007306275423616171, 0.012856102548539639, 0.02259279601275921, -0.04540988802909851, -0.06509559601545334, 0.02062288112938404, -0.04662265628576279, 0.036365773528814316, -0.0036930993665009737, -0.04210801422595978, 0.003300946671515703, -0.01598517782986164, -0.012446056120097637, 0.06675834208726883, 0.030336283147335052, -0.01959357224404812, 0.006131621077656746, 0.03133535385131836, -0.02769342251121998, -0.0516662634909153, -0.005411955993622541, -0.004158417694270611, -0.01703348383307457, 0.08041206747293472, -0.00925050862133503, -0.01398251112550497, -0.018843231722712517, 0.04748622700572014, -0.016663923859596252, -0.029062658548355103, -0.03849822282791138, 0.029614364728331566, 0.03501993790268898, -0.0037213650066405535, 0.08072984218597412, 0.06428906321525574, 0.01954258233308792, 0.0028384935576468706, -0.016880594193935394, 0.014693246223032475, -0.035385701805353165, -0.021690521389245987, -0.014505458995699883, -0.00042938374099321663, 0.010757508687675, 0.02654549665749073, -0.02255103550851345, 0.06872840970754623, 0.027370838448405266, -0.019963672384619713, 0.021499449387192726, 0.07370642572641373, -0.015981104224920273, -0.01644749753177166, 0.015704352408647537, 0.048476506024599075, -0.0009321372490376234, -0.002410870511084795, 0.0010336055420339108, 0.02851754054427147, -0.009994246065616608, 0.007281487341970205, -0.06526757776737213, 0.026735477149486542, -0.012468637898564339, 0.0015394764486700296, -0.004816151689738035, -0.018719643354415894, 0.03085990808904171, 0.008227478712797165, 0.007662343326956034, -0.017345158383250237, -0.04987773671746254, -0.008343828842043877, 0.03206731006503105, -0.026726359501481056, -0.001072947634384036, -0.061067335307598114, 0.0031376720871776342, -0.012916124425828457, 0.05698462948203087, -0.038894522935152054, -0.010151947848498821, 0.04327975586056709, 0.02276351861655712, 0.03780220076441765, -0.029577123001217842, 0.004223257303237915, -0.023124366998672485, -0.039423007518053055, -0.01361293438822031, 0.03687781095504761, 0.0004518778878264129, 0.014010844752192497, 0.01308358646929264, 0.023682493716478348, 0.06808926910161972, 0.003509118687361479, 0.013266387395560741, 0.03361702337861061, -0.03114415891468525, -0.035018377006053925, -0.000822939386125654, -0.016087014228105545, -0.036662716418504715, 0.019329482689499855, -0.03491486981511116, -0.006908464711159468, 0.014448498375713825, 0.013191628269851208, -0.011829973198473454, -0.0016510282875970006, 0.0033530332148075104, -0.0016283567529171705, -0.04533298686146736, -0.016213905066251755, -0.02394084818661213, -0.02466033399105072, 0.00945536233484745, 0.02742125652730465, -0.020319338887929916, 0.01920776441693306, 0.05056170001626015, 0.015767212957143784, -0.03945339471101761, -0.026920637115836143, 0.05701536685228348, -0.0011120898416265845, -0.015861833468079567, -0.006615753751248121, -0.04661045968532562, 0.03647619113326073, 0.00903377402573824, 0.01445300318300724, -0.008648784831166267, 0.05283578485250473, -0.08659487962722778, -0.023689022287726402, -0.04633297026157379, -0.01391693763434887, 0.08424314856529236, -0.026444921270012856, 0.0023927418515086174, 0.02390802837908268, -0.006875705439597368, -0.0535065233707428, -0.03894192352890968, 0.008395838551223278, 0.04778093099594116, -0.024737512692809105, 0.056727632880210876, 0.013741292990744114, -0.008183787576854229, 0.0030310875736176968, 0.0021833693608641624, -0.016302060335874557, 0.028265295550227165, -0.022608809173107147, 0.04341402277350426, -0.011734713800251484, -0.05452738329768181, -0.015423953533172607, 0.03567257896065712, -0.05851376801729202, -0.004680128768086433, -0.004615177866071463, -0.016027072444558144, 0.055921558290719986, 0.03762110695242882, 0.02258988656103611, -0.03724955394864082, -0.03867073729634285, -0.027997812256217003, 0.007439298089593649, 0.007736983243376017, -0.05221705883741379, 0.02956327237188816, -0.018574099987745285, 0.02147599682211876, 0.004115884657949209, 0.023756027221679688, -0.06236063688993454, -0.109209343791008, 0.011496656574308872, -0.03285918012261391, 0.013958893716335297, 0.06528085470199585, -0.013180858455598354, -0.05876099318265915, 0.02282407134771347, -0.0436522476375103, 0.02291368506848812, 0.025702442973852158, 0.03408363088965416, 0.005977017804980278, 0.02860441245138645, -0.0199978556483984, -0.01797136291861534, 0.007350172381848097, 0.0021795800421386957, 0.1147167757153511, 0.07805099338293076, 0.03815487027168274, -0.08640102297067642, -0.020502571016550064, 0.015536310151219368, -0.027356356382369995, -0.011935695074498653, 0.004719034768640995, -0.007110874634236097, -0.021279986947774887, 0.01133708655834198, 0.05215699225664139, 0.029602665454149246, 0.0013148790458217263, 0.07962849736213684, -0.009695710614323616, -0.005611327011138201, 0.028474431484937668, 0.020328741520643234, 0.013439079746603966, -0.025979017838835716, -0.04772581160068512, 0.02649332955479622, 0.0021618742030113935, -0.013455068692564964, -0.014184304513037205, 0.033784233033657074, 0.006926315370947123, 0.00520504591986537, 0.02456529624760151, -0.006388754118233919, -0.027298789471387863, 0.04553509131073952, 0.0010843159398064017, -0.007426494266837835, 0.02277727983891964, -0.003081473521888256, 0.002123831305652857, 0.02695949748158455, -0.008337094448506832, 0.014020864851772785, 0.013276394456624985, 0.019038381054997444, -0.036906346678733826, -0.047370344400405884, -0.02939547225832939, 0.03319500386714935, -0.04521617665886879, -0.020105093717575073, 0.027386153116822243, -0.01965625211596489, -0.000945460342336446, -0.056529294699430466, -0.032053329050540924, 0.02289831079542637, -0.019219884648919106, 0.0049134669825434685, 0.010987420566380024, 0.012771525420248508, 0.01696709170937538, 0.01930985040962696, 0.038741495460271835, 0.019777527078986168, -0.0626671090722084, -0.029839495196938515, -0.005628885701298714, 0.041966937482357025, 0.007758773397654295, -0.006682549603283405, 0.011906597763299942, -0.01904282346367836, 0.003149525262415409, -0.019569821655750275, 0.01765899918973446, -0.006027556490153074, 0.01499805599451065, -0.034716375172138214, -0.04265560582280159, -0.05122944712638855, -0.0289752259850502, 0.011331664398312569, -0.028693169355392456, 0.006023744121193886, -0.04688592255115509, -0.0001788795634638518, -0.012412751093506813, 0.05559488385915756, 0.02680438756942749, -0.013079735450446606, -0.0047314041294157505, 0.019895000383257866, 0.0014816969633102417, -0.06012740358710289, -0.004619035869836807, 0.02837115339934826, -0.038487739861011505, 0.009581418707966805, 0.005253552459180355, 0.0859207957983017, -0.004538611974567175, 0.03732168301939964, -0.04427814111113548, 0.06182226538658142, 0.031260136514902115, -0.013422948308289051, -0.010189037770032883, -0.02769511006772518, -0.009043637663125992, -0.008037695661187172, 0.01537640206515789, -0.026380520313978195, -0.02303580939769745, -0.04127901419997215, -0.02422381192445755, 0.026960505172610283, -0.02854173444211483, -0.029619911685585976, 0.00576603040099144, -0.006393155083060265, 0.007182517554610968, -0.02488066628575325, 0.007903172634541988, -0.03106360137462616, -0.003947338089346886, 0.009868394583463669, -0.029711181297898293, 0.02427908033132553, -0.005508420057594776, -0.02550162374973297, 0.002435453934594989, 0.03780490532517433, 0.008113298565149307, 0.002742256037890911, -0.03450825810432434, -0.003466205205768347, 0.02702184021472931, 0.05064631253480911, -0.0029485898558050394, -0.010896296240389347, 0.02167067490518093, -0.042411476373672485, -0.0038586128503084183, 0.012804669328033924, -0.01269388198852539, 0.013444398529827595, 0.026883581653237343, 0.019493188709020615, -0.018528055399656296, 0.0622064471244812, -0.012414115481078625, -0.016350246965885162, -0.01702999323606491, 0.024243157356977463, -0.01830391399562359, 0.013605679385364056, 0.05733702331781387, 0.019999073818325996, 0.02005675807595253, 0.006888117641210556, 0.02351195365190506, 0.047702766954898834, -0.04592396691441536, 0.035964485257864, 0.022350097075104713, 0.008126224391162395, 0.00434507243335247, 0.017205743119120598, -0.01986934058368206, 0.04865564405918121, -0.023442884907126427, 0.026596682146191597, 0.019835952669382095, 0.0023406886029988527, -0.11389350146055222, -0.0414249487221241, 0.013089628890156746, 0.005879546049982309, 0.036491118371486664, -0.019125236198306084, 0.06023267284035683, 0.006451285909861326, -0.05110367387533188, -0.01839020662009716, 0.023072222247719765, -0.03849343582987785, 0.0016973549500107765, 0.05306495726108551, -0.0431760773062706, -0.018618782982230186, 0.046576257795095444, -0.005533609539270401, 0.01603194698691368, 0.006428648717701435, -0.005152679979801178, -0.04461339861154556, -0.01597120612859726, 0.004105023108422756, 0.047392986714839935, -0.029022837057709694, 0.009116636589169502, -0.047307223081588745, -0.04585178941488266, 0.04011987894773483, -0.005195574834942818, 0.013963333331048489, -0.021534482017159462, 0.02285836450755596, 0.014351896941661835, 0.07332699745893478, 0.02726755291223526, -0.007788555696606636, 0.009746472351253033, -0.0034249695017933846, -0.016575081273913383, 0.023390036076307297, -0.05071964114904404, 0.046443745493888855, -0.018431395292282104, 0.018244173377752304, -0.014498522505164146, -0.006446014624089003, -0.018374217674136162, -0.030169574543833733, -0.016099557280540466, 0.005893157795071602, -0.004046237096190453, -0.02276787720620632, -0.007747182622551918, -0.037661414593458176, 0.03269505128264427, 0.04398185759782791, 0.032240964472293854, -0.014781647361814976, 0.02444748394191265, -0.015439510345458984, -0.06607095897197723, -0.0057020834647119045, 0.021919449791312218, -0.02156820520758629, -0.0791158601641655, -0.0011532583739608526, -0.013231104239821434, -0.0323369987308979, -0.019991151988506317, 0.017296889796853065, -0.039637189358472824, 0.07008915394544601, -0.0029898746870458126, 0.007630086503922939, 0.022832980379462242, -0.013624260202050209, 0.005943651776760817, -0.060641296207904816, 0.04468455910682678, 0.015221298672258854, 0.009041057899594307, -0.025262944400310516, 0.004127817694097757, -0.02109975926578045, 0.025849442929029465, 0.03491896018385887, 0.005663341376930475, 0.0010990462033078074, 0.010776089504361153, 0.026520268991589546, -0.04309757053852081, -0.0630757287144661, 0.05242975056171417, 0.026608098298311234, -0.007924322038888931, -0.020552529022097588, 0.007040083408355713, -0.0073919096030294895, 0.013045801781117916, -0.02561531774699688, 0.001334410160779953, -0.006776899099349976, 0.025728553533554077, 0.00428779236972332, 0.02228427864611149, 0.012029963545501232, 0.012371719814836979, 0.015247618779540062, -0.015043449588119984, 0.0337880440056324, -0.0009766792645677924, -0.010279185138642788, -0.06115236505866051, 0.040700919926166534, -0.025696897879242897, -0.02820347249507904, -0.006501344498246908, -0.007880176417529583, -0.022169096395373344, -0.04561327397823334, -0.007887455634772778, 0.010702122002840042, -0.015761520713567734, 0.02733517996966839, 0.036436352878808975, 0.019187016412615776, 0.040358204394578934, -0.04088630527257919, 0.0058470978401601315, 0.004388678818941116, -0.0073217847384512424, 0.012343187816441059, 0.028165683150291443, 0.023411327973008156, 0.0015416350215673447, -0.02161862887442112, 0.0314164012670517, -0.013841905631124973, 0.025310851633548737, -0.004782248754054308, 0.00301140989176929, -0.08792392909526825, -0.018749529495835304, 0.017534758895635605, -0.01395114790648222, -0.0010039733024314046, -0.05655441805720329, 0.0022105735260993242, 0.02998555637896061, -0.052429601550102234, -0.03094087541103363, -0.03986131399869919, -0.04865453392267227, -0.0016840039752423763, -0.03215179592370987, -0.011500725522637367, 0.05401216819882393, -0.00016435161523986608, -0.006531817372888327, -0.015386349521577358, -0.04360423982143402, -0.009355034679174423, -0.008021801710128784, 0.005690148565918207, -0.015857242047786713, -0.009867135435342789, 0.014805130660533905, -0.015148967504501343, -0.020266978070139885, -0.011044958606362343, 0.04231636971235275, 0.0432390533387661, 0.005732664372771978, -0.05298880487680435, -0.044556111097335815, -0.01989944465458393, 0.04371568560600281, -0.040062058717012405, -0.00697371968999505, -0.003431405406445265, -0.0030331166926771402, -0.023722730576992035, -0.011339970864355564 ]
<p>I am conducting analysis on 'Multi-Attribute Decision Making (MADM)', where I have two attributes (a1, a2) to characterize the quality of m alternative approaches. The first attribute, a1, is measured in percentage (hence does not have a unit), whereas the other has a unit. There are some alternatives that have zero as their first attribute value. </p> <p>What I am aiming to do is to compare different alternatives and determine the 'best' alternative by assuming equal weighting of the attributes. I am aware that 'Multi-Attribute Decision Making' methods may yield to the problem called 'rank reversal' (i.e. ranking of the alternatives may change by adding new alternatives). However, as far as I understood (and tested), 'Weighted Product Model (1)' does not suffer from this issue. The issue that arise; however, is that I cannot directly use this method as it requires division of the scores of different alternatives.</p> <p>I thought of increasing all the a1 values by a certain amount and it seems to be working fine. However, if I increase the a1 values more than a value, then rankings start to change. Do you know any other ways to use 'Weighted Product Model' to evaluate alternatives on the presence of zeros?</p> <p>Reference: (1) Triantaphyllou, E. &amp; Mann, S.H., 1989. An examination of the effectiveness of multi-dimensional decision-making methods: A decision-making paradox. Decision Support Systems, 5(3), pp.303–312.</p>
73,795
[ 0.01353314146399498, -0.0006829274352639914, 0.000659480516333133, -0.009112845174968243, 0.04386701434850693, -0.006766004022210836, -0.03116372972726822, -0.02556096948683262, 0.011916672810912132, -0.01867929846048355, 0.009996372275054455, 0.0021580897737294436, 0.07149289548397064, 0.040819358080625534, -0.02640647254884243, 0.004198503214865923, -0.008280360139906406, 0.005337934475392103, 0.006243446841835976, 0.00923714879900217, 0.01608678698539734, 0.029123686254024506, 0.026413647457957268, -0.0408472940325737, -0.00819969642907381, 0.044171709567308426, 0.013571775518357754, -0.04131174832582474, 0.0374712198972702, 0.032771844416856766, -0.05365633964538574, 0.0009024491882883012, 0.02719796448945999, 0.05019436404109001, -0.014380509965121746, -0.013516007922589779, -0.01086951233446598, -0.006245396565645933, -0.06890150159597397, 0.04571259394288063, 0.025968583300709724, -0.05268796160817146, -0.02402294985949993, 0.03693966940045357, -0.005869908723980188, 0.006319707725197077, -0.012530486099421978, -0.03536392003297806, 0.04366392642259598, -0.04353966936469078, 0.07504487782716751, 0.0008509022300131619, 0.027221208438277245, 0.07145608216524124, 0.02318366803228855, -0.0010992451570928097, 0.051403358578681946, 0.05561022460460663, -0.014808150939643383, -0.03133644536137581, -0.037795066833496094, -0.015861712396144867, 0.011560903862118721, -0.006373964715749025, 0.0137742655351758, -0.003371159778907895, 0.0020727189257740974, -0.00335781741887331, 0.03548567742109299, 0.021778376772999763, -0.013762831687927246, 0.03460562229156494, 0.011110471561551094, -0.019431989639997482, -0.0024464321322739124, -0.0625920370221138, 0.002458774484694004, -0.0016482076607644558, 0.08249785006046295, 0.036357332020998, 0.004051604308187962, 0.02486993558704853, -0.017196258530020714, 0.0439273975789547, 0.021491946652531624, -0.033826589584350586, 0.04684194549918175, -0.017745941877365112, 0.0321437232196331, 0.013485239818692207, -0.04992463067173958, -0.024276385083794594, 0.027297576889395714, 0.03171830251812935, -0.04107477515935898, 0.0484636053442955, 0.003760415595024824, 0.04229117929935455, 0.0005844405386596918, 0.0016460843617096543, -0.004521789029240608, -0.025828128680586815, -0.0011445683194324374, 0.02174370177090168, -0.0124839898198843, -0.008898832835257053, -0.03815362602472305, 0.016876814886927605, -0.022736385464668274, -0.010160007514059544, -0.01212712936103344, 0.029055822640657425, 0.04322144761681557, -0.010117822326719761, -0.000010836364708666224, -0.03721366077661514, -0.014691628515720367, -0.05488145723938942, 0.038861535489559174, 0.051025986671447754, 0.019265756011009216, -0.032432518899440765, 0.01752002164721489, -0.03176656365394592, -0.0809386596083641, -0.04234001412987709, -0.014385651797056198, -0.020453481003642082, -0.042549215257167816, 0.041038479655981064, 0.013422446325421333, -0.03399321809411049, 0.07985197752714157, -0.020605728030204773, 0.030226096510887146, 0.0035380576737225056, -0.0691644549369812, -0.04138445854187012, 0.019290510565042496, -0.022350484505295753, 0.01652364246547222, -0.028871655464172363, -0.020094111561775208, 0.04369131475687027, 0.09232650697231293, 0.04732653126120567, 0.0480896458029747, 0.023203516378998756, 0.05861097201704979, 0.011165739968419075, -0.018999148160219193, -0.00558307534083724, -0.012275898829102516, -0.03712961822748184, 0.004836663603782654, -0.0757618322968483, 0.016694379970431328, 0.01295536756515503, -0.010661136358976364, -0.0076439715921878815, 0.0063400487415492535, -0.004879264160990715, -0.03444652631878853, 0.0027756933122873306, -0.0013035719748586416, 0.0023730972316116095, 0.035989172756671906, -0.025314608588814735, 0.0210029948502779, -0.008980873040854931, -0.0029059862717986107, 0.013102342374622822, 0.01662963442504406, 0.05208338424563408, 0.05470050498843193, -0.01994166523218155, 0.015907419845461845, -0.05429401621222496, 0.014295807108283043, 0.019869426265358925, -0.03475840389728546, -0.027690062299370766, -0.05207221955060959, 0.02556769549846649, 0.021846715360879898, 0.017400389537215233, -0.03783665969967842, -0.01345132477581501, 0.03046279586851597, -0.032579824328422546, -0.03224381431937218, -0.07754727452993393, -0.013369533233344555, 0.043156981468200684, -0.002279751468449831, 0.050346747040748596, -0.02869953215122223, -0.018401386216282845, -0.03897548094391823, -0.003728992771357298, -0.03363792225718498, -0.004243090283125639, 0.031135663390159607, -0.020208263769745827, -0.0034089493565261364, 0.05110273137688637, 0.011788222007453442, -0.01876787282526493, -0.0011341023491695523, -0.013671500608325005, -0.059342529624700546, -0.002751892199739814, 0.004409948363900185, 0.038303058594465256, -0.03313097730278969, -0.026965174823999405, 0.02430683560669422, -0.018507709726691246, -0.025946803390979767, 0.031089521944522858, -0.048352744430303574, 0.03428531810641289, 0.1163407638669014, -0.007963751442730427, 0.028292832896113396, 0.0431918241083622, 0.012762920930981636, 0.031603410840034485, 0.0015590802067890763, -0.02622304856777191, -0.05101276561617851, 0.026257982477545738, 0.037528034299612045, 0.012734602205455303, -0.05579085648059845, 0.042782656848430634, 0.05105381831526756, 0.001669548568315804, 0.014965745620429516, 0.03778097406029701, 0.00048319087363779545, -0.003313494846224785, 0.04018210992217064, 0.015447353012859821, 0.021151814609766006, 0.01722279004752636, -0.004752407781779766, -0.023053424432873726, 0.044018056243658066, 0.011492016725242138, 0.00887578446418047, 0.025597168132662773, 0.014769299887120724, 0.022868027910590172, -0.01597709022462368, -0.028801102191209793, -0.0012228972045704722, -0.04531483352184296, 0.017081664875149727, 0.05636759474873543, 0.04600224643945694, -0.029443543404340744, 0.03691718727350235, -0.006710141897201538, 0.013576123863458633, 0.057910144329071045, -0.02315007895231247, 0.004347025416791439, 0.02781660668551922, -0.053655821830034256, 0.014519189484417439, 0.00008927730232244357, -0.019576111808419228, -0.027138778939843178, -0.01790255680680275, 0.035513583570718765, 0.03364065662026405, -0.000259793596342206, -0.005736334715038538, 0.008088351227343082, 0.011437159031629562, -0.0139301847666502, -0.0007791075622662902, 0.0030337655916810036, -0.0443432591855526, 0.011890874244272709, -0.045186638832092285, 0.011673211120069027, 0.0217558853328228, 0.01099763996899128, -0.015603919513523579, 0.012760622426867485, 0.012470472604036331, -0.0299702025949955, -0.0237568486481905, -0.04282700642943382, 0.019836025312542915, -0.01299204584211111, -0.030685175210237503, 0.04586973413825035, 0.027662768959999084, -0.06695675849914551, 0.0164851825684309, -0.025072501972317696, -0.01804032362997532, -0.009836197830736637, 0.00657997652888298, 0.0073453085497021675, -0.03502322733402252, 0.015111017040908337, 0.04084333777427673, 0.003360385773703456, 0.005471167620271444, -0.06098638474941254, -0.0763075053691864, -0.008207767270505428, -0.008378454484045506, 0.03674398362636566, 0.01664010062813759, -0.001671711797825992, 0.08377973735332489, 0.034043170511722565, -0.017768951132893562, -0.034203581511974335, 0.0048615820705890656, -0.014724547043442726, -0.0010937248589470983, -0.02864314243197441, 0.010208088904619217, -0.0346682108938694, 0.021747052669525146, -0.009068905375897884, 0.0401221364736557, 0.06192028149962425, 0.027501584962010384, -0.03588522970676422, 0.025141676887869835, 0.0024277502670884132, 0.0024658890906721354, 0.010959614999592304, 0.011862996965646744, 0.003438120475038886, 0.02062232419848442, 0.007422055583447218, 0.033633407205343246, -0.009991990402340889, -0.06988713145256042, 0.03728555887937546, -0.007463245186954737, 0.005696355365216732, -0.015236456878483295, 0.022615836933255196, 0.027612432837486267, -0.01068214513361454, 0.0012124328641220927, 0.0094446437433362, 0.040749441832304, -0.07075700163841248, -0.026465458795428276, 0.08565967530012131, 0.03495858609676361, 0.013134191744029522, -0.04786675423383713, -0.007498613093048334, -0.009335837326943874, 0.015920309349894524, -0.018107669427990913, -0.012797346338629723, 0.03189919888973236, 0.05500747635960579, 0.01246732845902443, 0.0017830191645771265, -0.03971289470791817, 0.029442232102155685, -0.02706265263259411, -0.007578857243061066, -0.05207422375679016, 0.042815662920475006, 0.010529772378504276, 0.030060095712542534, -0.0034670685417950153, -0.0018661116482689977, -0.025587355718016624, -0.006248740945011377, -0.0462258905172348, 0.04160988703370094, -0.026855185627937317, 0.020847419276833534, 0.02618982270359993, -0.006948928814381361, -0.02266375534236431, -0.032259609550237656, -0.055558737367391586, -0.013599837198853493, 0.04862108454108238, -0.05579404532909393, -0.0012068112846463919, -0.03946680575609207, -0.01363085862249136, -0.0014379216590896249, 0.03639116510748863, -0.015972571447491646, -0.056140121072530746, 0.01796134188771248, 0.02643648162484169, -0.030550897121429443, -0.014823698438704014, -0.010143812745809555, 0.0342390276491642, 0.04657626524567604, 0.03094388172030449, -0.010261679999530315, 0.04229117929935455, -0.035441804677248, 0.048092249780893326, 0.023150479421019554, 0.08086839318275452, -0.010391236282885075, -0.04189864546060562, -0.08168152719736099, -0.021654045209288597, -0.05959443375468254, -0.006609614938497543, 0.044721852988004684, -0.010839714668691158, -0.02643861435353756, 0.006738740019500256, 0.03037932515144348, -0.02684425562620163, 0.0011202878085896373, 0.06589183956384659, 0.041697196662425995, -0.018386028707027435, -0.01364901103079319, -0.011625130660831928, 0.00978647731244564, -0.021494261920452118, 0.03701924905180931, 0.02230294793844223, 0.004476004280149937, -0.04707743600010872, 0.035951633006334305, 0.0106318024918437, -0.049847561866045, 0.02423979341983795, 0.0033467088360339403, 0.026741839945316315, 0.03164627030491829, 0.0036327471025288105, 0.010070348158478737, 0.02145010605454445, 0.02345455251634121, 0.0525522343814373, 0.004145395942032337, -0.06424453854560852, 0.0006960389437153935, 0.009606827050447464, 0.05176275968551636, -0.029385268688201904, -0.0004168381856288761, -0.04325157403945923, -0.045709945261478424, 0.0005155974067747593, -0.05462593585252762, 0.030996674671769142, 0.0026846639811992645, 0.029185598716139793, -0.0030367285944521427, 0.044867269694805145, 0.015503261238336563, 0.016729064285755157, -0.03418676182627678, 0.0156624186784029, 0.027906490489840508, 0.01771467924118042, 0.001950817066244781, 0.004997700452804565, -0.00599364098161459, 0.03207966312766075, -0.016675390303134918, -0.0153939975425601, 0.00046547368401661515, 0.007763800676912069, -0.024990703910589218, -0.0686306357383728, -0.00528497900813818, 0.025788860395550728, -0.03750242665410042, 0.01582777500152588, -0.01412469893693924, -0.020007552579045296, 0.019676784053444862, 0.005164880305528641, -0.021015239879488945, 0.019404126331210136, -0.04421032965183258, 0.022746702656149864, 0.029196998104453087, -0.03391018882393837, 0.03197263926267624, 0.029741842299699783, -0.03096091002225876, 0.0014150012284517288, -0.004127027932554483, 0.010053492151200771, -0.03351640701293945, -0.019192920997738838, -0.03565672039985657, -0.010296965017914772, -0.01040484756231308, 0.0226253904402256, 0.045856643468141556, 0.058775752782821655, -0.0006878646672703326, -0.022889137268066406, -0.03587929531931877, -0.017599456012248993, -0.030489586293697357, -0.02114162966609001, -0.03084900788962841, 0.016944048926234245, 0.01152016595005989, -0.014305801130831242, 0.023610426113009453, -0.04415334761142731, -0.04478849098086357, 0.0012921985471621156, -0.015847284346818924, 0.03119668923318386, -0.016564659774303436, -0.002613804768770933, -0.016080724075436592, -0.005311156623065472, 0.0624040924012661, -0.03333704546093941, -0.009954041801393032, -0.008173876442015171, -0.020513499155640602, -0.019994841888546944, 0.03806840255856514, 0.04467470198869705, 0.03643367812037468, -0.03689371049404144, 0.007357324939221144, -0.016569538041949272, 0.015568522736430168, -0.04519764706492424, -0.010133634321391582, -0.0002130468055838719, 0.026977991685271263, -0.045014020055532455, -0.02246735244989395, -0.030193988233804703, -0.0005949348560534418, -0.01978428103029728, -0.012875383719801903, 0.04561321437358856, -0.039312832057476044, -0.02105250023305416, 0.030464110895991325, 0.05428091436624527, 0.05224303901195526, -0.03418320417404175, -0.030112750828266144, -0.005721752997487783, -0.02671617828309536, 0.014540033414959908, -0.00224318471737206, 0.020891984924674034, -0.05332581326365471, -0.024391693994402885, -0.020969685167074203, -0.006183153484016657, 0.038304079324007034, 0.025245288386940956, 0.0052689677104353905, -0.009401911869645119, -0.0013553089229390025, -0.017590200528502464, 0.0053815050050616264, 0.02319241128861904, -0.01801120676100254, -0.0010973791358992457, -0.027989231050014496, -0.013323070481419563, -0.030382277444005013, 0.001667556120082736, 0.010765491984784603, 0.011368921957910061, -0.02182384952902794, 0.0007044539088383317, 0.09392711520195007, -0.009209595620632172, -0.015022363513708115, 0.021306805312633514, -0.06579732149839401, 0.029424363747239113, 0.037746477872133255, -0.008847956545650959, -0.0076436810195446014, 0.008868779987096786, -0.0006361944833770394, -0.023374028503894806, -0.005683879368007183, 0.021677501499652863, 0.0569780208170414, 0.004005401395261288, 0.022357827052474022, 0.0728541910648346, 0.00289401737973094, -0.003892367472872138, -0.04353078454732895, -0.008817540481686592, -0.005292163696140051, 0.026171887293457985, 0.053818877786397934, 0.005132739897817373, -0.01199282705783844, 0.050602469593286514, 0.03260103985667229, 0.0028809106443077326, 0.02995634824037552, 0.00798293761909008, 0.0326322577893734, 0.03851817548274994, -0.013019812293350697, -0.04854655638337135, -0.0063281129114329815, -0.02605876885354519, -0.002968104090541601, -0.018078643828630447, -0.06538207828998566, 0.039734847843647, -0.01101703941822052, 0.004514704924076796, -0.08348570764064789, -0.029520800337195396, -0.02425403892993927, 0.024669190868735313, -0.014311260543763638, -0.010850596241652966, 0.011203508824110031, 0.0037039327435195446, 0.016238074749708176, -0.029125574976205826, 0.027977608144283295, -0.023717761039733887, -0.04718903824687004, -0.05455436185002327, -0.022485680878162384, -0.03506045415997505, 0.01921871490776539, 0.013976451940834522, -0.009555699303746223, 0.011112622916698456, -0.009043388068675995, 0.025542235001921654, -0.008291044272482395, 0.028848741203546524, 0.004036495927721262, 0.05201120302081108, -0.0010226242011412978, 0.03983517736196518, 0.0041915737092494965, -0.008351413533091545, 0.14855442941188812, 0.06234730780124664, 0.028744753450155258, -0.08632750064134598, 0.02738352119922638, 0.013066723942756653, -0.015415916219353676, -0.04538057744503021, 0.03761928901076317, 0.014236499555408955, -0.004601219668984413, 0.04211033135652542, 0.05015948787331581, -0.0011526746675372124, -0.005025374703109264, 0.06945765763521194, -0.013115319423377514, -0.04648018255829811, -0.019214870408177376, 0.03494591265916824, 0.022403588518500328, -0.0357837937772274, -0.040307044982910156, 0.035383615642786026, 0.0226940605789423, 0.0035779993049800396, 0.021038701757788658, 0.0009157367749139667, -0.013408015482127666, -0.014924608170986176, -0.020131632685661316, 0.00850200280547142, 0.031431082636117935, 0.04818088933825493, -0.00840180553495884, 0.03113373927772045, 0.0397079773247242, -0.0028099906630814075, -0.012364035472273827, 0.03745189681649208, 0.0389011949300766, -0.007006986998021603, 0.03493673726916313, 0.02537650056183338, -0.03220876678824425, 0.02378440462052822, -0.03661241754889488, -0.014668348245322704, -0.0015868728514760733, -0.003144141286611557, -0.03932640329003334, -0.036033518612384796, -0.03182915598154068, -0.04433651641011238, -0.01966920495033264, 0.0335250198841095, 0.04018540680408478, 0.035968929529190063, -0.044487543404102325, 0.02266993373632431, 0.027981873601675034, 0.00426482455804944, 0.022220933809876442, 0.018313944339752197, -0.06150148808956146, -0.030757423490285873, -0.03226117789745331, 0.019832605496048927, 0.04138731583952904, 0.003550780238583684, -0.0034779005218297243, 0.00742677878588438, -0.004683924838900566, 0.004093521740287542, -0.024994058534502983, -0.022325240075588226, 0.04141058772802353, 0.0035254820249974728, 0.005732620134949684, -0.030311107635498047, -0.045228440314531326, 0.014005537144839764, -0.03405746445059776, 0.012972828932106495, -0.015274124220013618, -0.0014568769838660955, 0.0015342669794335961, 0.01187411043792963, 0.00650386419147253, 0.001837808988057077, 0.0064183431677520275, 0.013035876676440239, -0.02312340773642063, -0.05612759292125702, -0.005683691240847111, -0.01038847491145134, -0.05540155991911888, 0.027578314766287804, 0.007124659139662981, 0.03846906125545502, 0.015189001336693764, 0.0183387640863657, -0.04368382692337036, 0.05304702743887901, -0.020329296588897705, 0.012564610689878464, 0.0048548090271651745, -0.04600570350885391, 0.0012635287130251527, 0.013867678120732307, 0.008055484853684902, -0.061570633202791214, -0.030400296673178673, -0.005784450098872185, -0.04792242497205734, -0.010414458811283112, -0.00044156209332868457, 0.04329767823219299, -0.033579397946596146, -0.0063878013752400875, -0.019286921247839928, 0.04328008368611336, -0.014085537753999233, -0.024638546630740166, -0.00893425289541483, -0.0044155665673315525, 0.004753070883452892, 0.010211230255663395, -0.00758971506729722, -0.00012422529107425362, 0.022420499473810196, 0.03158630058169365, 0.009846167638897896, -0.0005572907975874841, -0.021251121535897255, 0.000634085270576179, 0.022846220061182976, 0.037255652248859406, -0.050950787961483, -0.022320814430713654, 0.02049221284687519, -0.011895409785211086, -0.011200635693967342, 0.025737253949046135, 0.00018735385674517602, 0.05879341810941696, -0.0024313137400895357, -0.005590464454144239, -0.05582180246710777, 0.07656370848417282, -0.03849636763334274, -0.023846445605158806, -0.015461260452866554, 0.007332005072385073, -0.018780235201120377, -0.023188188672065735, -0.056028012186288834, 0.040298670530319214, -0.013822367414832115, 0.0076597644947469234, 0.04271309822797775, -0.025424899533391, -0.028812341392040253, 0.010758535005152225, -0.00943742785602808, 0.018920723348855972, 0.03526504337787628, 0.017634114250540733, 0.01910126954317093, 0.04135638475418091, -0.02346332184970379, 0.02210403047502041, 0.009087340906262398, 0.02557496353983879, -0.05427643284201622, -0.01144546177238226, 0.033186037093400955, 0.025170503184199333, 0.017209412530064583, -0.027024347335100174, 0.021481715142726898, 0.02007327787578106, -0.02371511422097683, 0.040664657950401306, 0.009322978556156158, 0.0020063063129782677, -0.011961949057877064, -0.003874382469803095, -0.026719775050878525, 0.0007535009644925594, 0.04243826866149902, 0.0012745403219014406, 0.06137397140264511, -0.025863775983452797, -0.02447384223341942, -0.030198071151971817, 0.017381681129336357, 0.023920880630612373, -0.015486870892345905, -0.028912393376231194, 0.058524150401353836, -0.06062249094247818, -0.08328481763601303, 0.06420192867517471, -0.03175678849220276, 0.01666521467268467, 0.007376457564532757, 0.0013329602079465985, 0.009397783316671848, 0.0397489070892334, 0.017246603965759277, 0.004504537209868431, -0.030085576698184013, -0.0272112637758255, -0.0028409415390342474, -0.015840178355574608, -0.0023821834474802017, 0.05130840465426445, 0.06367272883653641, -0.009449525736272335, -0.043304454535245895, 0.013537080027163029, -0.03303790092468262, -0.037972018122673035, 0.012897834181785583, 0.0014138998230919242, 0.03825791925191879, -0.04217085614800453, -0.00825849361717701, -0.04488911107182503, -0.006635195109993219, 0.05399496108293533, -0.01596372202038765, 0.007206738460808992, 0.00852352287620306, -0.011192621663212776, -0.02878868766129017, 0.03452446684241295, -0.02032359130680561, -0.014121976681053638, -0.07502054423093796, 0.016023363918066025, -0.023354390636086464, -0.02979491837322712, -0.05059777945280075, 0.002621276071295142, -0.019964799284934998, 0.05513448268175125, -0.04400595650076866, 0.01649170182645321, 0.018696188926696777, -0.012548452243208885, 0.017412513494491577, -0.1158442571759224, 0.04499056935310364, -0.015100222080945969, -0.03847946971654892, 0.01904495432972908, -0.020877286791801453, -0.02322329767048359, 0.0014015858760103583, 0.045869238674640656, 0.016287973150610924, -0.014630360528826714, -0.01978706382215023, 0.01677350513637066, 0.007739711087197065, -0.012566070072352886, 0.014478054828941822, 0.013436426408588886, -0.03984164819121361, -0.033261705189943314, -0.018272001296281815, 0.000898475875146687, -0.02835160307586193, -0.014803039841353893, -0.022775428369641304, -0.004557215608656406, -0.011881304904818535, 0.010547023266553879, 0.04468005895614624, -0.002488133730366826, -0.018657086417078972, 0.05540136247873306, 0.0014181392034515738, 0.01606038585305214, -0.014110241085290909, 0.00817954633384943, -0.05752239003777504, 0.04952157661318779, -0.007754964288324118, -0.03300578519701958, -0.01698293723165989, 0.0060591003857553005, 0.003266668878495693, -0.052691277116537094, -0.024097902700304985, 0.04739854857325554, -0.008021567948162556, 0.016775943338871002, 0.01213707122951746, 0.04050607979297638, 0.032312218099832535, 0.02361159957945347, -0.0004210885090287775, -0.014231991954147816, 0.013029688037931919, 0.04652097821235657, 0.009320833720266819, 0.018160708248615265, 0.03390730172395706, 0.019146321341395378, -0.009843428619205952, -0.023630967363715172, 0.016256459057331085, -0.003816627897322178, -0.022748641669750214, -0.0036491048522293568, -0.0070200394839048386, 0.06076763942837715, -0.017170961946249008, 0.007266312837600708, -0.005271333735436201, 0.009389465674757957, 0.0598965622484684, -0.007278229109942913, 0.04647583141922951, -0.045128803700208664, 0.02079775556921959, -0.009177472442388535, -0.023066531866788864, 0.020343635231256485, 0.05396754667162895, -0.02518037147819996, -0.01524746511131525, -0.006877310108393431, -0.023584658280014992, -0.003098418703302741, -0.010444619692862034, 0.016735101118683815, 0.005562672857195139, -0.031490594148635864, 0.03445257619023323, -0.0649069994688034, -0.007962941192090511, 0.024163858965039253, 0.021260788664221764, -0.007849343121051788, 0.06387051939964294, 0.0021396265365183353, -0.031155893579125404, 0.0016814472619444132, 0.020143916830420494, -0.017619023099541664, -0.05611962825059891, -0.007337161339819431, 0.02495022863149643, -0.01683102175593376, -0.021229779347777367 ]
<p>We have a iid sequence of random variables $X_1, X_2, \dots, X_n$, where $E(X_i) = \mu$ and $var(X_i) = \sigma^2$. The sample mean $\bar{X}$ converges to $\mu$ at rate $\sqrt{n}$ thanks to the LLN. </p> <p>If we have a continuous function $f()$, the continuous mapping theorem assures that $f(\bar X)$ converges to $f(\mu)$.</p> <p>My question is the following: at what rate does $f(\bar X)$ converge to $f(\mu)$?</p> <p>Asymptotically I would say $\sqrt{n}$, given that $f()$ is continuous and hence locally linear. But can we have convergence rates very different from $\sqrt{n}$ in small samples?</p>
73,796
[ -0.04503830894827843, -0.021355362609028816, 0.008341076783835888, -0.01523362472653389, 0.017920175567269325, 0.017322946339845657, -0.013591337949037552, -0.036156270653009415, -0.006078979466110468, -0.027056418359279633, 0.052761442959308624, 0.026111751794815063, 0.05773480236530304, 0.01202380284667015, 0.01483057253062725, 0.04205368459224701, -0.03862316906452179, 0.015766305848956108, -0.044152915477752686, 0.013244210742413998, 0.0060148220509290695, 0.05444183573126793, 0.026566069573163986, -0.011249630711972713, -0.08223666995763779, -0.013185282237827778, 0.005143670365214348, 0.0003842655278276652, -0.008434446528553963, 0.08649332821369171, -0.045244354754686356, -0.017889557406306267, 0.02145496942102909, 0.019184982404112816, 0.006888388656079769, 0.0243279617279768, -0.02125113271176815, -0.042717255651950836, 0.01573924534022808, 0.013406096026301384, -0.05958036705851555, -0.020258357748389244, 0.0050294059328734875, 0.04925357550382614, 0.021902009844779968, 0.033354129642248154, 0.004609920550137758, -0.034703101962804794, 0.03576350212097168, -0.019896622747182846, 0.0956316664814949, 0.001692777732387185, 0.0318475216627121, 0.022517168894410133, -0.008368543349206448, -0.025460463017225266, 0.032666102051734924, 0.04336366429924965, -0.01208959799259901, -0.02435842528939247, 0.020204205065965652, -0.04823217913508415, 0.025342490524053574, -0.018591471016407013, -0.013738404028117657, 0.022687286138534546, 0.007933471351861954, -0.008457161486148834, 0.0045196376740932465, -0.03185706585645676, -0.00030993809923529625, 0.002536545740440488, 0.039247043430805206, -0.0009186504175886512, -0.007660092785954475, 0.011195649392902851, -0.008842412382364273, -0.002284970600157976, 0.02074618823826313, 0.01702076382935047, 0.020208964124321938, 0.034648723900318146, 0.04297957941889763, 0.019673531875014305, 0.041037410497665405, -0.015735892578959465, 0.06016388162970543, -0.010812102816998959, 0.024918287992477417, 0.019881464540958405, 0.016676688566803932, 0.0077676610089838505, 0.04823178052902222, -0.029719088226556778, -0.05860459432005882, 0.049327388405799866, -0.018432922661304474, 0.006972299423068762, 0.02066456899046898, -0.003093010513111949, -0.013672460801899433, -0.05788563936948776, 0.023914635181427002, 0.033972371369600296, -0.01774509996175766, -0.03706848993897438, -0.002233189297839999, -0.006256887223571539, -0.05245902016758919, 0.004142239689826965, -0.04154261574149132, 0.025128498673439026, -0.0028321819845587015, 0.03844873234629631, 0.016751280054450035, 0.011410550214350224, 0.009496680460870266, -0.01523758377879858, 0.02904607355594635, 0.09299113601446152, 0.04595391824841499, -0.0182056687772274, 0.002648324705660343, -0.026442190632224083, -0.038606252521276474, 0.04574257507920265, 0.006750033237040043, 0.0018617529422044754, -0.0659790113568306, 0.014111202210187912, 0.003704996546730399, -0.028899403288960457, 0.012405653484165668, 0.037245068699121475, 0.026975946500897408, -0.018342705443501472, -0.08278597146272659, -0.059525974094867706, 0.04556799307465553, -0.032064538449048996, 0.012499750591814518, -0.07852638512849808, 0.034529708325862885, 0.028296664357185364, 0.04996679723262787, 0.03486623615026474, 0.05923999100923538, -0.006063607521355152, 0.00044886511750519276, 0.026342790573835373, -0.03047601878643036, -0.02105051465332508, -0.028888097032904625, -0.024474047124385834, 0.033799491822719574, -0.046175096184015274, 0.028447173535823822, 0.026266105473041534, -0.01218472234904766, -0.0580146498978138, 0.024743234738707542, -0.02446710504591465, -0.004817488603293896, -0.03824443742632866, 0.03179481625556946, -0.023082897067070007, 0.07838970422744751, 0.007912655360996723, 0.041947927325963974, -0.005337282083928585, -0.0030678065959364176, 0.0365913100540638, 0.03388163447380066, 0.06291747093200684, 0.0594928115606308, -0.044183745980262756, -0.019923733547329903, -0.056009553372859955, -0.009366561658680439, 0.044893477112054825, -0.02295350469648838, 0.0071212248876690865, -0.04065178334712982, -0.0058630723506212234, 0.015427177771925926, 0.039504360407590866, 0.011470900848507881, -0.02097170613706112, 0.00042444883729331195, -0.07091332972049713, -0.01832008548080921, -0.08225071430206299, 0.02676507458090782, 0.0030765181872993708, -0.027979345992207527, 0.010349182412028313, -0.0128647955134511, 0.01934191770851612, -0.020154017955064774, -0.0025943403597921133, -0.03291955217719078, 0.007140878587961197, -0.000755811866838485, -0.033665094524621964, 0.013589655980467796, 0.027981039136648178, 0.04024392366409302, 0.006842772476375103, 0.016914548352360725, -0.03189711645245552, -0.04839149862527847, 0.029113024473190308, -0.015469382517039776, 0.005652335938066244, -0.013252326287329197, 0.015896912664175034, -0.036427900195121765, -0.028691120445728302, -0.04043202102184296, 0.013282602652907372, -0.04111963137984276, 0.07711069285869598, 0.04979753866791725, 0.007073172368109226, 0.0038821257185190916, 0.03747771680355072, 0.038449063897132874, -0.0035435885656625032, -0.041459597647190094, -0.014345278963446617, -0.028308125212788582, 0.013039941899478436, 0.048807330429553986, 0.09765567630529404, -0.018103037029504776, 0.03296743705868721, 0.06416625529527664, 0.022342713549733162, -0.0024927996564656496, 0.005821520462632179, -0.013625801540911198, -0.011673207394778728, -0.03546874597668648, -0.028836535289883614, 0.027686970308423042, 0.020705562084913254, 0.0016344735631719232, -0.029013223946094513, 0.03426374867558479, 0.0021536226850003004, 0.01093544065952301, 0.017141051590442657, -0.017943214625120163, 0.0074499924667179585, -0.02893671952188015, -0.02332267165184021, 0.03725171461701393, -0.035207077860832214, -0.03868892416357994, 0.009314398281276226, -0.002447836333885789, 0.03415512666106224, -0.007305172272026539, -0.006852181162685156, 0.04461606964468956, 0.008854102343320847, -0.03375818580389023, -0.03617393225431442, 0.02121935598552227, -0.030590325593948364, -0.00315683800727129, -0.02685837261378765, -0.021583417430520058, -0.01745796576142311, -0.0003413245140109211, -0.01767735369503498, -0.010714438743889332, 0.0007493639714084566, -0.03491148725152016, -0.031094316393136978, 0.014136059209704399, -0.011858065612614155, 0.024464022368192673, -0.034679584205150604, 0.0065475753508508205, 0.01688356138765812, -0.009816081263124943, -0.00871572457253933, 0.025558598339557648, -0.0035284070763736963, -0.011837637983262539, 0.0364057794213295, -0.024559171870350838, -0.07683655619621277, 0.007208997383713722, -0.025188134983181953, -0.00649251090362668, 0.0013650204055011272, -0.014152973890304565, 0.034444328397512436, -0.012226724997162819, 0.015441151335835457, 0.023204142227768898, -0.0059126392006874084, -0.03656021133065224, -0.06059182062745094, 0.028840666636824608, 0.023139741271734238, -0.007593348156660795, 0.032384373247623444, 0.056304771453142166, -0.0006536425207741559, 0.01258020382374525, -0.05479096621274948, -0.04969639703631401, -0.0010968747083097696, -0.0012685991823673248, 0.05139618739485741, 0.009732214733958244, -0.03904004022479057, 0.09027223289012909, 0.04016099125146866, -0.03350205346941948, -0.005644043907523155, 0.01274141389876604, 0.011646535247564316, -0.012576657347381115, 0.016509439796209335, -0.005646469071507454, -0.025042371824383736, 0.01875576563179493, 0.005028608720749617, -0.0020644208416342735, 0.0485653355717659, 0.005433813668787479, 0.04005325585603714, -0.009337570518255234, 0.014725670218467712, 0.0032145176082849503, 0.03887888789176941, 0.04304138198494911, -0.03940449655056, 0.0006838365225121379, 0.013746512122452259, 0.00592200830578804, 0.017614837735891342, -0.0184518750756979, 0.045051515102386475, -0.03318231925368309, -0.005261222831904888, -0.02460024133324623, 0.05729014798998833, 0.03860730677843094, -0.008714788593351841, -0.0053890543058514595, 0.016234802082180977, 0.019205555319786072, 0.014207401312887669, 0.015395796857774258, 0.022295325994491577, 0.03323866426944733, -0.04461496323347092, 0.022342773154377937, -0.00024817962548695505, -0.010475857183337212, 0.02446560189127922, -0.044710516929626465, -0.017163140699267387, 0.01293141022324562, 0.05159872770309448, 0.0031540757045149803, -0.00048022103146649897, -0.003531922586262226, 0.004789113532751799, -0.01683059334754944, 0.03344248980283737, 0.024625064805150032, 0.023645304143428802, -0.0017149843042716384, 0.052777182310819626, -0.0026220132131129503, -0.00625398987904191, 0.0021518527064472437, 0.01156806480139494, -0.0590364895761013, 0.0037741558626294136, -0.0339188389480114, -0.048291269689798355, -0.00927145965397358, -0.012293674983084202, 0.024795854464173317, 0.026164116337895393, 0.017107168212532997, -0.01221586111932993, -0.004579387605190277, 0.010348533280193806, 0.003428379539400339, -0.05596423149108887, -0.03371591866016388, 0.016496267169713974, 0.009165957570075989, 0.0003599080955609679, -0.03099045529961586, 0.016383947804570198, 0.00004186971636954695, -0.029308568686246872, -0.02548106759786606, 0.013809983618557453, 0.00357149844057858, -0.0027102676685899496, 0.04441296309232712, 0.007842428050935268, 0.005802562925964594, 0.001160687068477273, 0.02886808104813099, 0.02722739614546299, 0.039357323199510574, 0.03949982300400734, -0.016766386106610298, 0.0025568432174623013, -0.06292877346277237, -0.034053027629852295, 0.003164273453876376, 0.042290687561035156, 0.04721624776721001, 0.011625957675278187, 0.05746162682771683, 0.0227012000977993, -0.035826440900564194, -0.003874871414154768, 0.04412964731454849, 0.010303480550646782, -0.005685386713594198, -0.05310368165373802, -0.01780582033097744, 0.011325852014124393, -0.006555668078362942, 0.03412826731801033, -0.02111654356122017, 0.00369914504699409, -0.008670462295413017, 0.04082894325256348, 0.016483282670378685, -0.018536929041147232, -0.018267380073666573, 0.00811630580574274, 0.025675702840089798, -0.0016700212145224214, -0.025333361700177193, 0.024849126115441322, 0.06446899473667145, 0.08380373567342758, 0.0379001647233963, 0.0011635002447292209, -0.04817803204059601, 0.018467137590050697, 0.023691151291131973, 0.035043567419052124, -0.039228860288858414, -0.017505832016468048, -0.04914967715740204, -0.017946891486644745, 0.052836380898952484, -0.0066652907989919186, 0.014241310767829418, -0.010299449786543846, 0.029306959360837936, -0.020264577120542526, -0.04800014942884445, -0.059516649693250656, -0.028036436066031456, 0.016918044537305832, 0.023173293098807335, -0.058160290122032166, -0.03264157474040985, -0.056607719510793686, 0.0017694283742457628, 0.05198362469673157, 0.0610429048538208, -0.06415411829948425, 0.028226139023900032, -0.025251086801290512, 0.034165676683187485, -0.009654446505010128, -0.04128893464803696, 0.0706263929605484, 0.007740492466837168, -0.008230776526033878, 0.011298702098429203, -0.011661486700177193, -0.06287452578544617, 0.039355259388685226, -0.00091272167628631, -0.0399940088391304, 0.016752371564507484, -0.03257235512137413, 0.03187466412782669, 0.05593058094382286, 0.04815196245908737, 0.0397365503013134, 0.004657309968024492, 0.0038556032814085484, 0.030605919659137726, -0.02445484697818756, 0.02138325944542885, -0.04205808416008949, -0.021099617704749107, -0.044343676418066025, -0.03415681794285774, -0.01931787095963955, 0.042217254638671875, 0.004171539098024368, 0.03931327164173126, -0.034332260489463806, 0.0023399682249873877, 0.039307110011577606, 0.04070626199245453, 0.014385136775672436, 0.013383745215833187, 0.024814192205667496, 0.03696422651410103, -0.004523591138422489, 0.007671312429010868, 0.03323958441615105, -0.018158985301852226, 0.01606980711221695, 0.03193022683262825, -0.03424155339598656, -0.01018248125910759, -0.03168231621384621, -0.019093632698059082, -0.023502971976995468, -0.03631008043885231, 0.03211991488933563, -0.016262004151940346, 0.0016060569323599339, 0.010498707182705402, -0.04371356591582298, 0.0012169377878308296, 0.004489452578127384, -0.020817585289478302, 0.01522819697856903, -0.054338596761226654, 0.010227369144558907, 0.025169357657432556, -0.002466126112267375, -0.08507236838340759, -0.06002719700336456, 0.0011950305197387934, -0.012421376071870327, -0.009542431682348251, -0.05134434625506401, -0.013550552539527416, -0.03416501730680466, -0.009682443924248219, -0.02956482581794262, 0.06437881290912628, 0.021134553477168083, -0.004793588537722826, -0.029881170019507408, -0.0002932860516011715, 0.059196773916482925, 0.0028664981946349144, -0.031049782410264015, 0.015200276859104633, -0.0135619156062603, -0.010726827196776867, 0.002239696681499481, 0.08184848725795746, -0.03669922798871994, 0.036061521619558334, -0.024569960311055183, -0.031128747388720512, 0.05779044330120087, -0.014076735824346542, -0.019543170928955078, 0.027586374431848526, 0.012683075852692127, 0.0011449602898210287, 0.021960265934467316, -0.00774924922734499, 0.012008494697511196, 0.03346114233136177, -0.020370133221149445, -0.006671452894806862, 0.0026904272381216288, -0.035569820553064346, 0.0423785001039505, 0.034973159432411194, 0.012567387893795967, 0.040435049682855606, 0.07473116368055344, -0.048652589321136475, -0.004958050791174173, -0.0048270458355546, 0.024083923548460007, 0.03307359293103218, 0.014526360668241978, 0.014302993193268776, -0.01602574624121189, -0.0034579469356685877, -0.024551626294851303, -0.05801614001393318, -0.030120503157377243, 0.011380222626030445, 0.0654134675860405, 0.044244006276130676, 0.040929608047008514, 0.04455699771642685, 0.01500310841947794, -0.015289181843400002, -0.0587632991373539, -0.010399853810667992, -0.0372992567718029, -0.008611374534666538, 0.043538231402635574, -0.015422140248119831, -0.031729262322187424, -0.008034056052565575, 0.031454697251319885, 0.027060115709900856, 0.020253870636224747, 0.004576607141643763, 0.03410753980278969, 0.032493919134140015, -0.033509451895952225, -0.0467371866106987, 0.03135263919830322, -0.05842813104391098, 0.045570988208055496, -0.03826022520661354, -0.00470186211168766, 0.047040458768606186, 0.03824837505817413, -0.016787605360150337, -0.026098133996129036, -0.013684049248695374, -0.051904741674661636, 0.0023530013859272003, 0.016992924734950066, 0.03129715844988823, 0.03345488756895065, 0.002074724994599819, 0.030385561287403107, -0.0003285382699687034, 0.04613727331161499, -0.03831392526626587, -0.062462080270051956, -0.023012377321720123, -0.01960803009569645, -0.033737365156412125, 0.01255593542009592, -0.008211554028093815, -0.021249527111649513, 0.002252514474093914, -0.03523664176464081, 0.012200945056974888, -0.022613314911723137, 0.0015407687751576304, -0.016517193987965584, 0.08290855586528778, 0.01637730374932289, 0.036010585725307465, -0.010986522771418095, 0.003038577502593398, 0.10008209198713303, 0.06128561124205589, 0.0009608114487491548, -0.023559320718050003, 0.018782522529363632, -0.02240823209285736, -0.0062094382010400295, -0.01911741867661476, -0.0261769387871027, 0.027887579053640366, -0.003507752437144518, 0.03795963525772095, 0.04265375807881355, 0.020085372030735016, -0.06782836467027664, 0.028318049386143684, -0.01838618516921997, -0.010753954760730267, 0.03070562705397606, -0.005479867570102215, -0.06170310452580452, 0.023431260138750076, -0.004969662521034479, 0.033388491719961166, 0.014785610139369965, -0.009512477554380894, -0.002322664950042963, -0.01384926587343216, -0.008421567268669605, -0.024453962221741676, -0.04123792424798012, -0.002569580916315317, 0.026196151971817017, -0.034711312502622604, -0.02037375420331955, -0.01238366961479187, -0.004855278413742781, -0.005951378960162401, 0.020256105810403824, 0.03456561267375946, -0.008871075697243214, 0.0079957852140069, 0.0016181182581931353, 0.00722493976354599, -0.06703036278486252, -0.04960263893008232, -0.07206623256206512, 0.005426438525319099, -0.006532861385494471, 0.025709500536322594, 0.03124123625457287, 0.025455709546804428, 0.009575637988746166, -0.03228842094540596, 0.0012166289379820228, 0.02235962264239788, 0.015212425030767918, -0.008640469051897526, -0.019201533868908882, -0.03499675914645195, 0.04240685701370239, 0.012785741128027439, -0.024228256195783615, 0.023223834112286568, -0.03859926015138626, -0.011553111486136913, 0.01073845662176609, -0.0012615493033081293, -0.005461836699396372, 0.006202859804034233, 0.0017363089136779308, 0.000689725624397397, -0.014866266399621964, -0.009639791212975979, 0.021009890362620354, -0.03347993642091751, 0.06263332068920135, -0.0023490090388804674, 0.01189738605171442, 0.0003806959721259773, -0.09098690748214722, 0.01363646425306797, -0.018424956128001213, -0.022393446415662766, -0.03834540396928787, -0.006424850784242153, 0.021206805482506752, 0.028035787865519524, 0.014934418722987175, -0.0024347950238734484, 0.0017372089205309749, 0.061305493116378784, 0.0032839193008840084, -0.02513072080910206, -0.0065748486667871475, -0.012955968268215656, -0.008957923389971256, -0.005138053558766842, -0.02246209979057312, 0.0446605421602726, 0.03448345884680748, 0.03152012825012207, 0.016884442418813705, 0.0107479989528656, -0.021441858261823654, 0.02326451987028122, 0.009917628951370716, -0.02413535676896572, 0.008162434212863445, 0.05046136677265167, 0.008666420355439186, -0.023670271039009094, -0.02298554964363575, -0.04831404238939285, 0.015189941972494125, 0.00033336126944050193, -0.021660422906279564, -0.01997273974120617, 0.009449112229049206, -0.010499979369342327, 0.02339598722755909, -0.012626632116734982, -0.03191741928458214, -0.009027783758938313, -0.028764808550477028, -0.0037708079908043146, 0.0008933045319281518, -0.011403595097362995, 0.03161286190152168, -0.0031195771880447865, -0.03928712010383606, 0.027750683948397636, 0.020512161776423454, -0.019198240712285042, 0.0102265989407897, 0.008587624877691269, -0.00856119766831398, 0.03036930039525032, -0.0008319637272506952, -0.014092911034822464, 0.05230272561311722, -0.06052900105714798, -0.036739397794008255, 0.0172630213201046, -0.0035606306046247482, 0.021263672038912773, 0.03943072631955147, -0.029414013028144836, -0.013889245688915253, 0.0017026365967467427, -0.03626316413283348, 0.004512791521847248, -0.05203855410218239, -0.010982814244925976, -0.0007271338836289942, -0.018723320215940475, 0.019160890951752663, -0.00653967447578907, 0.024729225784540176, -0.0024881779681891203, 0.03286337852478027, -0.042352039366960526, 0.023645440116524696, 0.016532322391867638, -0.013798373751342297, -0.024493467062711716, -0.01805594004690647, 0.024964947253465652, 0.005651128012686968, 0.050767362117767334, -0.032692715525627136, 0.0239529050886631, -0.01705397665500641, -0.013356192037463188, -0.12180161476135254, -0.0299795214086771, 0.019022783264517784, 0.0021185872610658407, 0.06352359056472778, -0.06653300672769547, -0.005508928094059229, 0.029160628095269203, -0.08133387565612793, -0.04326753690838814, -0.01350935734808445, -0.0440712533891201, -0.05288311094045639, 0.01762212999165058, 0.010329299606382847, 0.009755068458616734, -0.001644360483624041, 0.04297459498047829, 0.02492048777639866, 0.05314948409795761, 0.020575549453496933, -0.009796618483960629, -0.003927045036107302, 0.009795274585485458, 0.010214310139417648, -0.04973596706986427, 0.038196220993995667, -0.04981009662151337, -0.0010466912062838674, 0.025036538019776344, -0.036393314599990845, -0.008549659512937069, 0.022702161222696304, 0.01989009976387024, 0.0077630458399653435, 0.017415650188922882, 0.00814064685255289, -0.0309715885668993, 0.008288001641631126, -0.007202812470495701, 0.022537151351571083, 0.02753542922437191, -0.06701521575450897, -0.008345779962837696, 0.058604463934898376, 0.0006497011636383832, -0.015929250046610832, -0.006665536668151617, -0.010012012906372547, -0.0352729856967926, 0.03484479710459709, -0.0037334582302719355, 0.010828062891960144, -0.03758640214800835, 0.044906437397003174, -0.007908374071121216, -0.012591124512255192, 0.01791347563266754, 0.035706136375665665, -0.015437155030667782, -0.0024448176845908165, 0.008607402443885803, -0.06285934895277023, 0.005888966377824545, 0.026718128472566605, -0.019019227474927902, -0.07937494665384293, -0.031990885734558105, 0.029539039358496666, 0.002169243060052395, -0.002542302943766117, -0.011310597881674767, -0.005761129781603813, 0.027973240241408348, -0.011367853730916977, 0.016073981299996376, -0.006114097312092781, -0.005644194316118956, -0.004428525920957327, -0.08036361634731293, 0.03651047125458717, -0.022975411266088486, 0.0020683358889073133, -0.02557023987174034, -0.021167458966374397, -0.027551919221878052, -0.02650672197341919, 0.06573212891817093, -0.010020402260124683, 0.009902060963213444, -0.003824880812317133, 0.0426630936563015, 0.021382031962275505, -0.03560001775622368, -0.010250551626086235, -0.03465396910905838, 0.024563543498516083, -0.03880464285612106, -0.012016489170491695, 0.0007248356123454869, -0.007640460971742868, 0.027020223438739777, 0.00560849579051137, 0.0003721030370797962, 0.008091255091130733, -0.02326388657093048, 0.04927745461463928, 0.04757091403007507, -0.0015537200961261988, 0.05617314577102661, -0.03913169726729393, -0.014057321473956108, 0.041229795664548874, -0.014831408858299255, -0.05673988536000252, 0.0036444838624447584, 0.00470755947753787, 0.0016255889786407351, 0.0033547827042639256, 0.03137967735528946, -0.013628857210278511, -0.05551513284444809, -0.01516658067703247, 0.033686500042676926, -0.02785418927669525, 0.014139974489808083, 0.02593509666621685, 0.009522171691060066, 0.04444589838385582, 0.007948396727442741, -0.01564837247133255, -0.0013996557099744678, 0.011928196996450424, 0.0019397628493607044, -0.013046536594629288, 0.04061748459935188, -0.043170370161533356, 0.04378404840826988, 0.00828875694423914, -0.0546293668448925, 0.026099011301994324, -0.013710083439946175, 0.052318841218948364, -0.03913934528827667, -0.029599439352750778, 0.03166864439845085, -0.004711183253675699, -0.013082465156912804, 0.0545809343457222, -0.038123708218336105, 0.07436007261276245, -0.012609473429620266, 0.0392497181892395, 0.0008210691157728434, -0.008887577801942825, -0.034375373274087906, 0.0015988782979547977, -0.0034458674490451813, 0.007605195511132479, 0.030728202313184738, 0.004925629589706659, -0.010298493318259716, 0.005387632176280022, 0.034835442900657654, -0.02454967610538006, 0.021068260073661804, 0.0002365377004025504, -0.003441915847361088, -0.049226973205804825, -0.015327894128859043, -0.011518767103552818, -0.009253253228962421, 0.009972863830626011, 0.03019367903470993, 0.05090348795056343, 0.018949182704091072, -0.01628948003053665, 0.015030506066977978, 0.04970410093665123, -0.08926829695701599, 0.00050864223157987, -0.03928415849804878, -0.013767706230282784, 0.019525934010744095, -0.036893054842948914 ]
<p>I'm a complete newbie :)</p> <p>I'm doing a study with a sample size of 10,000 from a population of about 745,000. Each sample represents a "percentage similarity". The great majority of the samples are around 97%-98% but a few are between 60% and 90%, that is, the distribution is heavily negatively skewed. Around 0.6% of the results are 0%, but these will be treated separately from the sample.</p> <p>The mean of all 10,000 samples is 97.7%, and just in Excel, the StdDev is 3.20. I understand that the StdDev is not really applicable here because the results are not normally distributed (and because the +3.20 would put you above 100%!).</p> <p>My questions are: </p> <ol> <li>Is bootstrapping (a new concept for me) appropriate?</li> <li>Am I bootstrapping correctly :)</li> <li>What is a sufficient sample size?</li> </ol> <p>What I am doing is resampling (with replacement) my 10,000 results and calculating a new mean. I do this a few thousand times and store each mean in an array. I then calculate the "mean of the means" and this is my statistical result. To work out the 99% CI, I choose the 0.5%-th value and the 99.5%-th value, and this produces a very tight range: 97.4% - 98.0%. Is this a valid result or am I doing something wrong?</p> <p>As for sample size, I am sampling only about 1.3% of the population - I have no idea if this is "enough". How do I know if my sample is representative of the population? Ideally, I'd like to be 99% confident of a mean that is +/- 0.50% percentage points (i.e. 97.2% - 98.2%). </p> <p>Thanks in advance for any tips!</p>
36,297
[ -0.03851829096674919, -0.021581780165433884, 0.04444517940282822, 0.008793612010776997, 0.04719119891524315, 0.009420854970812798, -0.0040459479205310345, -0.03812939301133156, -0.0017875186167657375, -0.018851563334465027, 0.06296079605817795, 0.03985767439007759, 0.037115368992090225, 0.01319445576518774, 0.003953914158046246, -0.017003502696752548, -0.027763912454247475, -0.0011573816882446408, -0.03752003610134125, -0.026144593954086304, 0.008029075339436531, 0.03565032780170441, 0.03437724709510803, -0.02497917041182518, -0.043452296406030655, 0.03177117556333542, 0.026464929804205894, -0.011113900691270828, -0.01285941619426012, 0.07706385850906372, -0.03982957452535629, -0.018885422497987747, 0.02998840995132923, 0.00655130110681057, 0.009399613365530968, -0.01765432022511959, -0.02243008278310299, -0.030177727341651917, 0.0032352879643440247, 0.03957125172019005, -0.04265246167778969, 0.007546003442257643, -0.009602298960089684, -0.006599991582334042, 0.014426611363887787, 0.0028269204776734114, -0.0012863489100709558, -0.05712570995092392, 0.014723301865160465, -0.03528042882680893, 0.0675363764166832, -0.000444960460299626, 0.04337134212255478, 0.00724377017468214, -0.029865359887480736, -0.02823415957391262, -0.0024998546577990055, 0.02668391540646553, 0.014547520317137241, -0.012127339839935303, 0.06916927546262741, -0.029235225170850754, -0.007915174588561058, -0.005086369812488556, -0.01940174028277397, 0.0218359362334013, -0.022685103118419647, -0.01063600741326809, 0.05141020938754082, -0.015816140919923782, 0.05978359654545784, 0.02572673000395298, 0.04635820910334587, -0.014843679033219814, 0.010861641727387905, -0.038420647382736206, -0.0067135607823729515, 0.026969993487000465, 0.06494054943323135, 0.042850691825151443, -0.00651787593960762, 0.02960025891661644, 0.012805713340640068, 0.03194526582956314, 0.04113001003861427, -0.030150016769766808, 0.08614857494831085, -0.04714033007621765, 0.009092665277421474, 0.03390052542090416, -0.01604265160858631, -0.022438732907176018, 0.053107813000679016, 0.0061007034964859486, -0.006199517287313938, 0.0452471561729908, -0.0065223220735788345, 0.04546530544757843, -0.04214999079704285, 0.03142785280942917, -0.0022590761072933674, -0.017127517610788345, 0.03368285298347473, 0.03988275304436684, -0.026548586785793304, -0.004020347259938717, -0.034680530428886414, -0.018677053973078728, 0.002833455568179488, -0.011354980058968067, 0.016222696751356125, 0.006734893191605806, 0.01830274425446987, 0.008738835342228413, 0.022745462134480476, 0.010426320135593414, 0.02963443286716938, -0.01245767530053854, 0.03657626360654831, 0.030839240178465843, 0.029364679008722305, -0.014520533382892609, 0.011815236881375313, -0.01446469034999609, -0.040362775325775146, 0.02575114741921425, 0.013527891598641872, 0.0014954835642129183, -0.03681361302733421, 0.0417763814330101, 0.03613489121198654, -0.026295701041817665, 0.07398024201393127, 0.01699436828494072, 0.03334306553006172, -0.029966743662953377, -0.056308429688215256, -0.05687202140688896, 0.04114871844649315, 0.005376182496547699, 0.00685631250962615, -0.05337991937994957, 0.010099227540194988, 0.015391640365123749, 0.025148916989564896, 0.01108136959373951, 0.053366344422101974, -0.02010890282690525, 0.028849614784121513, 0.03649507090449333, -0.05318032205104828, 0.0004807555815204978, -0.02337425947189331, -0.010539030656218529, -0.010998879559338093, -0.09309305250644684, 0.03292500600218773, -0.012988923117518425, 0.018794940784573555, -0.050442203879356384, -0.0015659165801480412, -0.012812859378755093, 0.015161232091486454, -0.026750309392809868, -0.002297723898664117, -0.032914478331804276, 0.07699864357709885, -0.025070281699299812, 0.03087410144507885, -0.005246886983513832, -0.023169904947280884, 0.01867782510817051, 0.022096527740359306, -0.013420327566564083, 0.05208777263760567, -0.033378005027770996, 0.029481664299964905, -0.021298477426171303, 0.008321477100253105, 0.0270831361413002, -0.020837726071476936, -0.008190874941647053, -0.003422335721552372, 0.0027398327365517616, 0.030742928385734558, 0.04077242687344551, 0.0256761834025383, -0.04636172205209732, 0.04181726649403572, -0.04136458411812782, -0.038122937083244324, -0.05553457513451576, -0.014226687140762806, 0.01295529119670391, -0.013422449119389057, 0.02030191197991371, -0.01622713916003704, 0.024786369875073433, 0.007805059663951397, -0.023917181417346, -0.047625914216041565, -0.038281794637441635, 0.05770796537399292, -0.035981711000204086, 0.03848220035433769, 0.09056767076253891, 0.03379937261343002, -0.04233869910240173, 0.03337826579809189, -0.018133949488401413, -0.05408403277397156, -0.015478802844882011, -0.027067461982369423, -0.021985486149787903, 0.004890316165983677, -0.014188949950039387, -0.006648639682680368, 0.02921568974852562, 0.0037279524840414524, 0.04307667538523674, -0.013493642210960388, 0.08373742550611496, 0.03077823296189308, -0.0023975814692676067, 0.005335284862667322, 0.016396135091781616, 0.030909867957234383, 0.004585589282214642, -0.009524966590106487, 0.002578263869509101, -0.05882612615823746, -0.02222365327179432, 0.034488361328840256, 0.014844090677797794, -0.022308310493826866, -0.01938668265938759, 0.06717653572559357, -0.019199442118406296, 0.038668159395456314, 0.0033418696839362383, 0.01260539423674345, -0.00767001137137413, -0.009287508204579353, 0.022105956450104713, 0.03560585156083107, 0.006476820912212133, -0.03539115935564041, 0.010589353740215302, 0.036982301622629166, 0.03359358385205269, 0.013104910962283611, -0.00716191902756691, 0.01675526611506939, 0.007377322297543287, -0.02593895234167576, 0.02117880806326866, 0.040168315172195435, -0.012695807963609695, -0.002099048811942339, 0.02815396897494793, -0.03102104365825653, 0.01797589845955372, -0.009031693451106548, -0.030657026916742325, 0.009038359858095646, 0.06401176005601883, -0.022661523893475533, 0.01920037716627121, 0.00825867522507906, -0.03379817679524422, 0.0034407286439090967, -0.03899943828582764, -0.027490532025694847, -0.057361457496881485, 0.013642018660902977, 0.009959874674677849, -0.008400184102356434, 0.05576624721288681, -0.02641710638999939, -0.007084033917635679, -0.016969770193099976, -0.0035459932405501604, 0.001060090376995504, -0.012638104148209095, -0.0599830187857151, -0.037595901638269424, -0.0018240519566461444, -0.016852514818310738, 0.018542597070336342, -0.00017747763195075095, -0.023949306458234787, 0.006369343958795071, -0.013107419945299625, -0.03529542684555054, -0.017202051356434822, -0.027941599488258362, -0.016815438866615295, -0.009663823992013931, 0.000034453354601282626, 0.044929783791303635, -0.004328843671828508, -0.0378182977437973, 0.06824490427970886, 0.01288977637887001, -0.04395933821797371, -0.028010809794068336, 0.01560421846807003, 0.024717753753066063, -0.012862304225564003, -0.0066505554132163525, -0.0018158534076064825, -0.022318484261631966, -0.006881112698465586, -0.05630087852478027, -0.06800252199172974, 0.003101460635662079, 0.015112132765352726, 0.0346626341342926, 0.003865709761157632, 0.006657653953880072, 0.0717480480670929, 0.03801044821739197, -0.03303561732172966, -0.00894078053534031, 0.013755245134234428, -0.024447720497846603, 0.018178896978497505, -0.00537666492164135, 0.019672658294439316, -0.021594829857349396, -0.011013513430953026, -0.010495690628886223, 0.029878567904233932, 0.05626209080219269, 0.02864292450249195, -0.0027423519641160965, 0.00444243848323822, -0.011835629120469093, -0.02544810250401497, 0.04741907864809036, 0.02123061940073967, -0.05290209501981735, 0.0243087038397789, 0.0021670423448085785, 0.05841100215911865, 0.02116142399609089, -0.06466323882341385, 0.0036005591973662376, -0.017500123009085655, 0.027002641931176186, -0.06348349899053574, 0.0014205200131982565, 0.004215462598949671, -0.014752366580069065, 0.01925439015030861, 0.008951850235462189, 0.013954638503491879, -0.015524007380008698, 0.01581820845603943, 0.03381459042429924, 0.025486906990408897, 0.01943829096853733, -0.0006528030498884618, -0.031117230653762817, -0.015954172238707542, -0.033653151243925095, -0.032017432153224945, -0.008169153705239296, 0.027752114459872246, 0.10018134117126465, 0.031005583703517914, -0.025146521627902985, -0.04017697647213936, 0.026523113250732422, -0.04878273233771324, 0.003496701829135418, -0.017299070954322815, 0.038796234875917435, -0.003593349363654852, 0.05297345668077469, 0.0268507469445467, -0.009148023091256618, 0.014636581763625145, 0.010312541387975216, -0.047858189791440964, 0.02784564532339573, -0.01987270452082157, -0.013966905884444714, -0.005994750186800957, -0.021611053496599197, 0.028495196253061295, -0.011599884368479252, 0.03924224525690079, 0.006716197356581688, 0.03798288106918335, -0.006090017035603523, 0.00806255079805851, 0.001466617570258677, 0.00598007719963789, -0.006117764860391617, 0.00882293377071619, -0.008793070912361145, 0.00044054471072740853, 0.04395062476396561, 0.04910565912723541, -0.007051182445138693, -0.05197663977742195, -0.024504058063030243, 0.059933897107839584, 0.0032055405899882317, 0.027627119794487953, 0.028795724734663963, 0.007185924798250198, -0.04994325339794159, 0.025899725034832954, -0.01566959358751774, 0.05975259840488434, 0.01880720444023609, 0.012048188596963882, -0.022585976868867874, -0.05466223135590553, -0.021195704117417336, 0.023535171523690224, -0.01912251114845276, 0.027372390031814575, -0.016454696655273438, 0.049081433564424515, 0.020246358588337898, -0.09374505281448364, 0.04282329976558685, 0.05772314593195915, -0.008335632272064686, -0.007824827916920185, -0.055695176124572754, -0.026258699595928192, -0.027472689747810364, -0.007330435793846846, 0.0295150987803936, 0.010670209303498268, 0.017117494717240334, -0.012082141824066639, 0.03303830325603485, -0.026788782328367233, -0.025471072643995285, -0.00119953288231045, 0.005029589869081974, 0.07276992499828339, -0.024178054183721542, -0.03751860186457634, 0.032716501504182816, 0.0018408121541142464, 0.020142752677202225, -0.003227711422368884, 0.003988297190517187, -0.0913635715842247, 0.01618606597185135, 0.04068483039736748, 0.06295927613973618, -0.03354594111442566, 0.004563439637422562, -0.06239929422736168, -0.04414583742618561, 0.033643051981925964, -0.056819140911102295, 0.010791358537971973, -0.0069897067733109, -0.01078998576849699, -0.044092435389757156, -0.006697240751236677, -0.043582186102867126, -0.020926468074321747, -0.02928118035197258, 0.008575296960771084, -0.04581739753484726, -0.03584279492497444, -0.06179535388946533, 0.029251888394355774, 0.026527877897024155, 0.057719796895980835, -0.05506139621138573, -0.02410939149558544, 0.004889140371233225, 0.007226511370390654, -0.036220017820596695, -0.04768085479736328, -0.008628493174910545, 0.0019887187518179417, -0.0035636075772345066, 0.020976781845092773, 0.011252201162278652, -0.06155997887253761, 0.035616617649793625, 0.020173903554677963, -0.025925936177372932, -0.028263278305530548, -0.02847922593355179, 0.028990309685468674, 0.008950685150921345, 0.01121760904788971, 0.0556115098297596, -0.0015613667201250792, 0.0036464808508753777, -0.0025786508340388536, -0.043865859508514404, -0.006734807975590229, -0.042727261781692505, 0.0014422971289604902, -0.05899858474731445, 0.009584493935108185, -0.04048063978552818, 0.018767481669783592, -0.00013259737170301378, 0.014657651074230671, -0.01809081807732582, 0.02117440290749073, 0.014148796908557415, 0.02220126986503601, 0.028169408440589905, 0.018148358911275864, 0.011577746830880642, 0.013001500628888607, -0.014661112800240517, 0.00039471586933359504, 0.0413237065076828, -0.010176064446568489, -0.021166935563087463, 0.0025031950790435076, -0.05007293075323105, 0.011370396241545677, -0.059936072677373886, -0.005527837201952934, 0.0025997627526521683, -0.04577567055821419, 0.036406055092811584, 0.001208379166200757, 0.04385920986533165, 0.013535222969949245, -0.003640859154984355, -0.0018800089601427317, 0.023642223328351974, -0.003231172915548086, 0.05109035223722458, -0.05009453371167183, 0.027057169005274773, -0.004457106348127127, 0.0048834774643182755, -0.04738721624016762, -0.0439457930624485, 0.022855229675769806, 0.025901461020112038, 0.00023096906079445034, -0.04412797838449478, -0.020665597170591354, 0.011598456650972366, -0.04072742536664009, -0.013971238397061825, 0.033328406512737274, -0.014600997790694237, -0.02308465726673603, 0.00016007709200493991, 0.01723996177315712, 0.0952916368842125, -0.04523739218711853, -0.005452256184071302, 0.0271463580429554, 0.01437747199088335, -0.022304587066173553, 0.0002782575029414147, 0.036691490560770035, -0.050559498369693756, -0.014579017646610737, -0.03576282411813736, 0.0026267876382917166, 0.056311409920454025, -0.023545315489172935, -0.009364097379148006, -0.0028820422012358904, 0.0033954447135329247, 0.004698971752077341, -0.02107379585504532, -0.020238835364580154, -0.024392805993556976, -0.0037211114540696144, -0.040572792291641235, 0.015783073380589485, -0.03375944495201111, 0.001334165339358151, 0.06173097342252731, 0.018284035846590996, 0.0057608867064118385, -0.016573311761021614, 0.042405880987644196, -0.01976224221289158, 0.0064100297167897224, -0.023831285536289215, -0.026791967451572418, 0.04817117378115654, 0.026660112664103508, -0.02269372157752514, 0.028638120740652084, 0.011076712049543858, -0.05269664153456688, -0.0276050828397274, -0.042283251881599426, -0.023894108831882477, 0.05306379124522209, 0.03198031336069107, 0.04654644429683685, 0.05726061016321182, 0.01133390050381422, 0.0228765569627285, -0.008900444023311138, 0.004948745481669903, -0.009331554174423218, 0.04094213619828224, 0.05908418819308281, 0.012467586435377598, -0.009867804124951363, 0.03768337890505791, -0.0038847795221954584, 0.00048804510151967406, 0.048902302980422974, 0.04518667235970497, 0.015155875124037266, 0.021011529490351677, -0.03938097506761551, 0.007089900318533182, 0.027128232643008232, -0.04503203183412552, 0.028232954442501068, -0.014119423925876617, -0.04498906806111336, 0.01915724016726017, 0.05622350424528122, 0.020671015605330467, -0.012695807963609695, -0.0226630549877882, -0.04593631625175476, -0.026147963479161263, -0.02160472422838211, -0.006207600701600313, 0.020339280366897583, -0.015267611481249332, 0.0247560515999794, 0.0028240373358130455, 0.03032228723168373, -0.06659159809350967, -0.05050671845674515, -0.024233827367424965, -0.02763190120458603, -0.06658133119344711, 0.02435409091413021, 0.009865465573966503, -0.015495282597839832, 0.017330752685666084, -0.026769790798425674, 0.031753890216350555, -0.0007264550658874214, 0.019651127979159355, -0.012978196144104004, 0.06288928538560867, 0.04656575992703438, 0.02574945241212845, -0.002815601183101535, -0.02069028466939926, 0.1366799771785736, 0.0507340170443058, 0.015817517414689064, -0.050473518669605255, 0.04680848866701126, 0.023440062999725342, 0.007735508028417826, -0.010050567798316479, 0.017716554924845695, 0.003985327668488026, 0.002415892668068409, 0.03847263753414154, 0.03256821259856224, -0.004885708447545767, -0.005429720971733332, 0.052816350013017654, -0.013330391608178616, -0.025571657344698906, 0.017230268567800522, -0.012694835662841797, -0.017557062208652496, -0.0433218814432621, -0.02490229159593582, 0.010912004858255386, -0.025803934782743454, -0.013132561929523945, -0.01758907362818718, -0.030391447246074677, -0.008490454405546188, 0.0001400956534780562, 0.0037247231230139732, -0.006147569511085749, 0.018674809485673904, -0.014377081766724586, -0.014554062858223915, -0.024533528834581375, 0.021802503615617752, -0.046660277992486954, 0.011633933521807194, 0.03989269956946373, -0.0024516999255865812, 0.024301202967762947, -0.018758032470941544, 0.00797754991799593, 0.01021669153124094, -0.027920087799429893, -0.04510004445910454, 0.054314661771059036, 0.01238940004259348, -0.0014646296622231603, -0.01719215326011181, 0.01712569035589695, 0.009917222894728184, -0.04836925119161606, 0.015469491481781006, 0.016731301322579384, 0.03441106155514717, -0.019026316702365875, -0.025023777037858963, -0.021927211433649063, 0.015006271190941334, -0.030728939920663834, -0.010229614563286304, 0.037631794810295105, 0.013588071800768375, -0.02668347954750061, -0.003937949892133474, 0.0263106320053339, -0.02289862185716629, 0.017233245074748993, -0.016747375950217247, -0.01403199601918459, -0.02314264327287674, 0.00800216756761074, 0.006994270253926516, -0.01100913342088461, 0.054905831813812256, -0.03355861082673073, -0.008610956370830536, -0.01718379370868206, -0.051724813878536224, 0.049670953303575516, -0.015478584915399551, -0.012624233029782772, -0.02199224755167961, -0.006832764018326998, 0.023935891687870026, 0.0370975024998188, 0.022591225802898407, 0.04431862384080887, -0.011563104577362537, 0.06844010204076767, 0.006241904571652412, -0.03848108649253845, -0.031386278569698334, -0.017522329464554787, -0.031888216733932495, 0.012896659784018993, -0.015193656086921692, 0.08482474833726883, 0.00815952941775322, 0.02024800144135952, 0.007001741323620081, 0.01030885148793459, -0.003974976483732462, 0.02504541538655758, -0.004351133480668068, -0.0552314817905426, -0.018907515332102776, -0.006041141226887703, -0.027774780988693237, -0.009670177474617958, 0.015680238604545593, -0.040952667593955994, -0.03559103608131409, 0.0024635607842355967, -0.017306210473179817, -0.008526801131665707, 0.0041265590116381645, -0.024618469178676605, -0.007961788214743137, -0.03362788259983063, -0.027189161628484726, -0.037123482674360275, 0.007820160128176212, -0.007231741212308407, -0.030026322230696678, -0.01583574153482914, -0.009851360693573952, 0.010509359650313854, 0.0212429016828537, 0.04732861742377281, 0.0069742994382977486, 0.015335938893258572, 0.016293292865157127, -0.0026468473952263594, 0.00009959570888895541, 0.0240339282900095, -0.06673382967710495, 0.008277270011603832, 0.11429000645875931, -0.029839802533388138, -0.01909414306282997, 0.005756084341555834, -0.015292900614440441, 0.03192732483148575, 0.005572744645178318, -0.002081165323033929, 0.00006807714817114174, 0.03529393672943115, -0.014960107393562794, -0.04449254646897316, -0.027559097856283188, -0.011549880728125572, 0.022888081148266792, 0.02021219953894615, -0.004952500574290752, 0.003790966235101223, 0.017241673544049263, 0.05198168754577637, 0.04101049154996872, -0.0031646881252527237, 0.0538000725209713, -0.0025195367634296417, 0.017686547711491585, 0.008124714717268944, 0.02451041340827942, 0.0018036713590845466, 0.013020175509154797, 0.060590408742427826, -0.0421537421643734, 0.03716052696108818, -0.06110886111855507, 0.035563934594392776, -0.07522329688072205, -0.02111170068383217, -0.020122384652495384, 0.004998413845896721, 0.015050341375172138, -0.05110230669379234, 0.0010743713937699795, 0.01628109999001026, -0.014851727522909641, 0.017745770514011383, -0.02364378236234188, -0.01750112697482109, -0.02991827018558979, 0.021358925849199295, -0.03997170552611351, 0.014974272809922695, 0.022426782175898552, 0.021182002499699593, 0.02061554230749607, 0.04565291479229927, 0.03768720477819443, -0.021694272756576538, -0.017847487702965736, 0.02817309834063053, -0.0006261001108214259, -0.052335575222969055, -0.005962424911558628, -0.03811149299144745, -0.02139272913336754, 0.02481682598590851, -0.019616829231381416, 0.04096321761608124, 0.02214684709906578, 0.0208590105175972, -0.0019913141150027514, 0.08219799399375916, 0.015140680596232414, -0.011876032687723637, -0.01124137919396162, -0.01539939921349287, 0.037811532616615295, 0.04826940968632698, 0.010905136354267597, 0.05395476147532463, 0.07719575613737106, 0.004911576863378286, -0.021836360916495323, 0.009814268909394741, -0.024086834862828255, -0.00860675424337387, 0.0144975446164608, 0.006108961068093777, -0.009899867698550224, -0.009643098339438438, 0.038136862218379974, -0.039210837334394455, 0.005518907215446234, 0.0458882637321949, 0.00953449122607708, -0.007750222459435463, 0.006290335673838854, -0.01219602394849062, -0.03998127579689026, -0.00007529103459091857, -0.028679730370640755, -0.009921081364154816, -0.04128016531467438, 0.010669698007404804, 0.01480103563517332, 0.03812812268733978, -0.012674854137003422, -0.01532830111682415, -0.03363952040672302, 0.051113661378622055, -0.010457663796842098, 0.003120752517133951, 0.018823813647031784, 0.0018380610272288322, -0.008589445613324642, -0.09525535255670547, 0.0819217786192894, -0.0018968553049489856, -0.013132086023688316, -0.07404611259698868, -0.04311195760965347, -0.022256068885326385, 0.02192055992782116, 0.03596874698996544, 0.008825425058603287, -0.008432421833276749, -0.030609212815761566, 0.02772190049290657, 0.017704304307699203, -0.07069023698568344, 0.027943868190050125, -0.02643071860074997, -0.0018639006884768605, -0.0025422468315809965, -0.0036727620754390955, 0.021467121317982674, -0.030815312638878822, 0.023971544578671455, -0.03168240562081337, 0.030789827927947044, -0.0018177656456828117, -0.022763362154364586, 0.04223620891571045, 0.02404310181736946, -0.03970291465520859, 0.03930051252245903, -0.010721118189394474, -0.0250686127692461, 0.04006971791386604, -0.010327877476811409, -0.040328964591026306, 0.04537568241357803, -0.011713684536516666, -0.047964151948690414, -0.019330941140651703, -0.009258152917027473, -0.00432064151391387, -0.0859283059835434, -0.0008624516194686294, 0.007465268485248089, -0.04317094385623932, 0.012303476221859455, 0.04868123680353165, 0.03739015758037567, 0.004859373904764652, -0.01226529385894537, 0.01661490835249424, -0.013016420416533947, -0.010233987122774124, -0.004822463262826204, -0.023593127727508545, 0.03217989206314087, -0.007409387733787298, 0.007958713918924332, 0.0424003005027771, 0.005015382077544928, 0.03479820117354393, -0.01287390198558569, 0.04524074122309685, -0.018228432163596153, -0.03678131848573685, 0.009641144424676895, -0.024151844903826714, 0.045152511447668076, 0.010365163907408714, -0.02257782779633999, 0.06316353380680084, -0.02653612568974495, 0.012320377863943577, -0.011928368359804153, -0.04065495356917381, -0.03151276335120201, 0.009912923909723759, 0.005618656519800425, 0.009130958467721939, 0.012183735147118568, -0.0025890585966408253, -0.01592658832669258, 0.03773852437734604, 0.044328197836875916, -0.03937586396932602, 0.032498061656951904, -0.01819276064634323, 0.005771491676568985, 0.0047212992794811726, -0.04397360607981682, -0.005898287054151297, -0.02621605433523655, -0.01608850248157978, 0.023950664326548576, 0.0072634220123291016, 0.0031935321167111397, -0.042069077491760254, 0.004115417134016752, 0.043082401156425476, -0.0584072545170784, -0.024692915380001068, -0.06527851521968842, 0.01645665615797043, -0.007951933890581131, -0.042564719915390015 ]
<p>Let $ Z=X_1^2+X_2^2\cdots\cdots X_j^2 $, such that $X_i \sim \mathcal{N}(\mu_i,\sigma_i^2)$. All $X_i$'s are independent of each other and $\mu_i$ and $\sigma_i^2$ are all different from one another.</p> <p>Question is:</p> <p>1) What is the distribution of Z ?</p> <p>2) If it is non-central Chi square distribution, what it ll be in terms of means and variances?</p> <p>Note: I'm not going to call $X^2$ or $Y^2$ as Chi Square distribution, as that complicates the matter. Since in Central $\mu_i=0$ and in <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noncentral_chi-squared_distribution" rel="nofollow">non-central Chi square distribution</a> each term in divided by respective variance, that don't represent our case.</p>
49,816
[ -0.04950442165136337, -0.0290212482213974, -0.008811100386083126, -0.016087064519524574, 0.06382397562265396, 0.013277621939778328, -0.009356782771646976, -0.044349510222673416, -0.008110888302326202, -0.06355102360248566, 0.059754058718681335, 0.03735422343015671, 0.048543017357587814, 0.0187720637768507, 0.03573988750576973, -0.01754787005484104, -0.04812797158956528, 0.03001956269145012, -0.015186232514679432, -0.0037575759924948215, 0.003003188641741872, 0.006348445080220699, 0.0032317552249878645, 0.006506489589810371, -0.05715745687484741, 0.03685489669442177, 0.005130371078848839, -0.014141194522380829, 0.00584289850667119, 0.06494813412427902, -0.022380637004971504, -0.014169327914714813, -0.0014067605370655656, 0.01816154271364212, -0.01794123463332653, -0.0075151678174734116, -0.03102363646030426, -0.020224234089255333, -0.003961106296628714, 0.022786114364862442, -0.045430392026901245, -0.015126568265259266, -0.0034229117445647717, 0.024605341255664825, -0.045315273106098175, 0.009461610578000546, 0.0009470772929489613, -0.038974106311798096, 0.023753458634018898, -0.04506047070026398, 0.10679828375577927, 0.034310366958379745, 0.006387367378920317, 0.019199829548597336, -0.00029643357265740633, -0.013496472500264645, 0.01880807988345623, 0.048429958522319794, 0.021545903757214546, -0.06464774161577225, -0.006704408209770918, -0.016144799068570137, 0.01919369585812092, -0.04055791720747948, -0.02814250811934471, 0.0018822677666321397, 0.007293258793652058, -0.032607872039079666, 0.013202070258557796, -0.0021053070668131113, 0.007108037825673819, 0.05279196798801422, 0.04997438192367554, -0.04066571593284607, -0.020257633179426193, -0.003382708178833127, 0.02256189100444317, 0.02891436219215393, 0.03368692472577095, -0.0017218481516465545, 0.012644952163100243, 0.007214220240712166, 0.004174430388957262, 0.02231743559241295, 0.0008002342656254768, -0.007611595559865236, 0.10423476248979568, 0.015561169944703579, 0.00868165772408247, 0.0024168947711586952, -0.010260039009153843, -0.0023742332123219967, 0.06638842076063156, -0.017067011445760727, -0.05115187540650368, 0.043479181826114655, -0.030611276626586914, 0.038529038429260254, 0.0034087395761162043, -0.01967090554535389, -0.019679583609104156, -0.0006976522854529321, 0.019771559163928032, 0.07598908990621567, -0.026660803705453873, 0.014685802161693573, -0.03827003762125969, 0.010503229685127735, -0.011986199766397476, -0.02219352126121521, -0.024501284584403038, 0.045818205922842026, -0.02515256777405739, 0.0015041353181004524, 0.02187795378267765, -0.0019138808129355311, -0.026530690491199493, -0.01790119707584381, 0.021377500146627426, 0.06281358748674393, 0.05001117289066315, 0.003311151871457696, 0.0019840311724692583, -0.022696081548929214, -0.03165305405855179, 0.027125360444188118, 0.005719752050936222, 0.002122112549841404, -0.07010610401630402, 0.04586696997284889, -0.002885691821575165, 0.023816723376512527, 0.01851542666554451, 0.020520661026239395, 0.011737033724784851, -0.025438860058784485, -0.09730787575244904, -0.06825365871191025, 0.045473989099264145, -0.03771042078733444, 0.004191810730844736, -0.06833607703447342, 0.0009669436840340495, 0.053101103752851486, 0.0738852322101593, 0.00739136291667819, 0.008505045436322689, 0.015801075845956802, 0.045581426471471786, 0.03271585330367088, -0.021879728883504868, -0.004887523129582405, -0.014629505574703217, -0.05295031517744064, 0.010292855091392994, -0.05329045280814171, 0.028076622635126114, 0.02180192992091179, -0.009804311208426952, -0.04523322358727455, -0.004512649029493332, 0.007828893139958382, 0.016622835770249367, 0.024283533915877342, 0.028642525896430016, -0.037607550621032715, 0.09809739142656326, 0.02739929035305977, 0.03192734718322754, 0.020158953964710236, 0.007486907299607992, 0.015267332084476948, -0.01637488603591919, 0.07482551783323288, 0.0706513300538063, -0.005766342859715223, 0.0015255204634740949, 0.0062214587815105915, 0.02964036352932453, 0.01710514910519123, -0.07027191668748856, 0.003092522267252207, -0.0287326592952013, 0.01550845243036747, -0.012971499934792519, 0.06690195202827454, 0.004525309894233942, -0.020813515409827232, 0.044794052839279175, -0.04168335720896721, -0.01994725503027439, -0.04931376129388809, 0.030507590621709824, 0.006090191192924976, -0.042746152728796005, 0.007289883680641651, 0.020427117124199867, 0.021788936108350754, 0.017742453143000603, -0.026052085682749748, 0.016782792285084724, -0.00482440460473299, 0.017642749473452568, -0.02431178279221058, 0.0009830418275669217, 0.057945020496845245, 0.01830890029668808, -0.020352404564619064, 0.06125989183783531, -0.01671491377055645, -0.07316171377897263, -0.0036949675995856524, -0.022043675184249878, 0.034766994416713715, -0.0077398354187607765, -0.0030820416286587715, 0.0032178719993680716, 0.024805422872304916, -0.012166354805231094, 0.049336645752191544, -0.053031276911497116, 0.047153595834970474, 0.03915410116314888, 0.0021068390924483538, -0.0014683004701510072, -0.003667861223220825, 0.011334627866744995, 0.038793452084064484, -0.023464635014533997, -0.0018349781166762114, -0.0614442378282547, -0.0077034649439156055, 0.015043042600154877, 0.017087047919631004, -0.06027345359325409, 0.026123683899641037, 0.014786208048462868, 0.03544262796640396, 0.014522976242005825, -0.022516148164868355, -0.02230706624686718, -0.035508494824171066, -0.00907041784375906, 0.02611144445836544, 0.006438298150897026, 0.019932443276047707, -0.0029795828741043806, -0.011310958303511143, 0.01425711065530777, -0.011335989460349083, -0.044044312089681625, 0.06300488859415054, -0.025208884850144386, 0.012167083099484444, -0.02155141532421112, 0.01234784722328186, 0.03194010630249977, 0.008412535302340984, 0.011580676771700382, 0.03280417621135712, -0.008502575568854809, -0.017067935317754745, -0.005994278006255627, -0.020351752638816833, 0.010789207182824612, 0.01557556726038456, -0.045229874551296234, 0.021542690694332123, 0.00931660458445549, 0.004677658900618553, -0.01965632662177086, -0.022313229739665985, -0.006650763098150492, -0.013957797549664974, 0.009792829863727093, 0.035414036363363266, -0.002508946228772402, 0.0029028106946498156, -0.0003904072509612888, -0.04661014676094055, -0.0076525709591805935, -0.023719316348433495, -0.0034868824295699596, 0.0204607080668211, -0.03543006256222725, -0.010690954513847828, -0.04720190167427063, -0.007876620627939701, 0.004877330735325813, -0.0035602757707238197, 0.011850929819047451, 0.04377841204404831, -0.005631705280393362, -0.05080019682645798, -0.007493678480386734, -0.02544212155044079, -0.01015450619161129, -0.057993385940790176, -0.015728147700428963, 0.02341778576374054, -0.012528803199529648, -0.006571435369551182, 0.04952231049537659, -0.04839092120528221, -0.08406102657318115, -0.019107986241579056, 0.014561301097273827, 0.06922641396522522, -0.03282039240002632, 0.046780943870544434, 0.025770774111151695, -0.0020255183335393667, 0.013778121210634708, -0.03350139409303665, -0.04133061319589615, 0.0065340325236320496, -0.027355320751667023, 0.006661548279225826, 0.01577545888721943, -0.024306507781147957, 0.03555382788181305, 0.0016838281881064177, 0.0020491371396929026, -0.012528365477919579, 0.0211489237844944, -0.023624558001756668, -0.053969401866197586, 0.03730951249599457, 0.03579648956656456, -0.042007170617580414, 0.030914077535271645, 0.0172708872705698, -0.010771926492452621, 0.06127486750483513, 0.0028329421766102314, -0.02432367578148842, -0.006096045486629009, -0.00715211033821106, -0.010799388401210308, 0.04431142657995224, -0.023980382829904556, -0.014138516038656235, -0.004678328055888414, 0.03277288004755974, 0.028890520334243774, 0.013718306086957455, -0.03075154684484005, 0.042950212955474854, -0.03748191148042679, -0.006026085466146469, -0.04564142972230911, 0.07065098732709885, 0.02789316512644291, -0.03331097587943077, 0.003577581839635968, 0.007269094232469797, 0.013307035900652409, -0.009637203998863697, 0.016918454319238663, 0.0247127003967762, 0.019683819264173508, -0.016407813876867294, -0.006545815616846085, -0.0437563993036747, 0.001968458527699113, 0.04059405252337456, -0.038040634244680405, 0.004701539874076843, 0.016756489872932434, 0.05299654230475426, 0.0036536327097564936, -0.029643187299370766, -0.012001095339655876, 0.0221785306930542, -0.0736021026968956, 0.03364131972193718, -0.038508497178554535, 0.02507309429347515, 0.016263199970126152, 0.057245075702667236, -0.014911329373717308, -0.03358161076903343, -0.00003193229349562898, -0.0027789585292339325, -0.05279494449496269, 0.029154416173696518, -0.015618688426911831, -0.023457296192646027, -0.004312918987125158, -0.016786623746156693, 0.03453321009874344, 0.009995484724640846, 0.056552160531282425, 0.008191434666514397, 0.012991401366889477, -0.025297479704022408, 0.01905415765941143, -0.0439278744161129, -0.02986198104918003, -0.0031747829634696245, 0.04726122319698334, 0.004210724961012602, -0.037994518876075745, 0.02432001382112503, 0.004184366669505835, -0.019190948456525803, 0.0020108583848923445, -0.030025530606508255, 0.019965600222349167, 0.014641845598816872, 0.01434152852743864, -0.0059202141128480434, 0.03357833996415138, -0.0226921197026968, 0.01424100436270237, -0.028247391805052757, 0.03703093156218529, 0.0398058257997036, 0.010485599748790264, 0.014257034286856651, -0.040207091718912125, -0.026825271546840668, 0.014204257167875767, 0.02414323203265667, 0.04602210596203804, -0.008692825213074684, 0.062174733728170395, 0.017261264845728874, -0.02692197822034359, 0.019306395202875137, 0.06643878668546677, 0.014682376757264137, -0.01496371440589428, -0.018468786031007767, -0.028339507058262825, -0.025123313069343567, -0.02264471724629402, 0.028123266994953156, -0.0014617684064432979, 0.013802248984575272, -0.0009082522592507303, 0.03613625839352608, 0.007091936189681292, 0.009768319316208363, -0.006682142615318298, 0.025398574769496918, 0.04936293885111809, 0.019944246858358383, -0.04855947569012642, 0.0037268984597176313, 0.04014010354876518, 0.04368363320827484, -0.002721549244597554, -0.014481695368885994, -0.04194368049502373, 0.003212261013686657, 0.03357921540737152, 0.028834735974669456, -0.014157498255372047, -0.02305941842496395, -0.03771919384598732, 0.00895731057971716, 0.005966008175164461, -0.03743874654173851, 0.06138540804386139, -0.01736561954021454, 0.00517176603898406, 0.0202165637165308, 0.0064996276050806046, -0.047879863530397415, 0.0010651591001078486, -0.004666127730160952, 0.01406624261289835, -0.03376925364136696, -0.010491736233234406, -0.0676627978682518, -0.02920747920870781, 0.006101435981690884, 0.04712055251002312, 0.0024750782176852226, 0.00613651005551219, -0.00772674148902297, 0.08273525536060333, 0.018340062350034714, -0.058815985918045044, 0.018383925780653954, 0.016859285533428192, -0.013503782451152802, 0.0717472955584526, -0.03695962578058243, -0.05101028457283974, 0.013591211289167404, 0.005534046795219183, -0.02220928482711315, 0.03843951225280762, 0.011407647281885147, 0.035639483481645584, 0.04487047716975212, 0.02214496023952961, 0.08266843855381012, 0.010757957585155964, -0.00879872776567936, -0.03937884420156479, -0.0282023623585701, 0.0062241447158157825, -0.03032584674656391, -0.00686259288340807, -0.03942927345633507, -0.0011525170411914587, 0.006490048486739397, 0.014260190539062023, -0.03929027169942856, 0.03849607706069946, -0.04042781889438629, -0.02218349650502205, -0.0016803959151729941, 0.02342887595295906, -0.002897926140576601, 0.03612837195396423, 0.006047496572136879, 0.044308796525001526, 0.011739617213606834, -0.004638299345970154, 0.017686327919363976, -0.01964004710316658, 0.01372881792485714, 0.0038598268292844296, -0.025141006335616112, 0.007806506007909775, -0.051399365067481995, -0.010158429853618145, 0.005005640909075737, -0.01741419918835163, 0.03178061172366142, -0.01079193502664566, 0.021282898262143135, 0.025033852085471153, -0.03394845873117447, -0.02350119687616825, 0.03246051445603371, -0.0013435923028737307, 0.04968533292412758, -0.021105434745550156, 0.030743053182959557, 0.022900676354765892, 0.011937989853322506, -0.079151451587677, -0.023300297558307648, -0.0017782270442694426, -0.01494315080344677, 0.010703595355153084, -0.04031820967793465, -0.033091526478528976, -0.0035929258447140455, -0.055925726890563965, -0.031415749341249466, 0.035678647458553314, 0.009531519375741482, -0.044716402888298035, -0.014796013943850994, 0.015119376592338085, 0.0639868974685669, -0.020304936915636063, -0.037097133696079254, 0.036005713045597076, -0.027970056980848312, -0.007134172599762678, 0.022288905456662178, 0.06460294127464294, -0.032796964049339294, 0.02340020425617695, -0.00035339422174729407, -0.023829486221075058, 0.03431442752480507, -0.0276638250797987, -0.028710538521409035, 0.011034318245947361, 0.003050991566851735, -0.008742132224142551, -0.007096660789102316, -0.019776711240410805, -0.005973683204501867, 0.020592663437128067, -0.019843753427267075, -0.021859141066670418, -0.01929410547018051, 0.008046111091971397, 0.027342913672327995, 0.00905502401292324, -0.005333452485501766, 0.008778916671872139, 0.04764477163553238, 0.0073152692057192326, 0.010603873990476131, -0.028642378747463226, 0.02293887361884117, 0.03772124648094177, 0.01912442408502102, -0.005142416805028915, 0.027131563052535057, 0.023594221100211143, -0.010809304192662239, 0.022333690896630287, -0.028671342879533768, 0.028940103948116302, 0.0697835236787796, -0.005888621788471937, 0.027630895376205444, 0.014290941879153252, 0.018045872449874878, -0.01161154080182314, -0.04382705315947533, 0.029805831611156464, -0.016250567510724068, -0.003782808082178235, 0.031764086335897446, -0.006937782280147076, -0.009238670580089092, 0.05401402711868286, 0.030421363189816475, 0.021282589063048363, 0.05889264494180679, 0.023546654731035233, 0.0010257745161652565, 0.0003050623054150492, -0.008235849440097809, -0.07202809303998947, 0.05788358673453331, -0.03184579685330391, 0.016026858240365982, -0.02872857265174389, -0.029530290514230728, 0.0412825345993042, 0.02905098721385002, 0.018503105267882347, -0.023593593388795853, 0.0030052168294787407, -0.03313102200627327, 0.002334754914045334, 0.017769580706954002, -0.008934028446674347, -0.014503386802971363, -0.019415143877267838, 0.02385018579661846, -0.02628082036972046, 0.01895761303603649, -0.039168909192085266, -0.0894273892045021, 0.008440803736448288, 0.001635420136153698, -0.042871735990047455, 0.0047261836007237434, 0.014293236657977104, -0.04100888594985008, 0.010719669982790947, -0.045704226940870285, 0.01262529008090496, -0.008856900036334991, 0.03986293449997902, -0.010776575654745102, 0.06023243069648743, 0.015902342274785042, 0.029169859364628792, 0.0013329236535355449, -0.023076750338077545, 0.1025877296924591, 0.048904601484537125, 0.015381654724478722, -0.03358157351613045, 0.018907098099589348, -0.05275898054242134, 0.0019072504946962, -0.01411943044513464, -0.0037872479297220707, -0.01253426168113947, 0.001264050486497581, 0.05824969708919525, 0.05577622354030609, 0.015608156099915504, -0.04004596173763275, 0.06697027385234833, -0.03580980375409126, -0.05804036930203438, -0.03906754031777382, -0.015071454457938671, -0.008566578850150108, -0.028953855857253075, -0.059959590435028076, 0.028560224920511246, -0.009710592217743397, -0.006804145872592926, -0.04273136705160141, -0.029432054609060287, -0.017704501748085022, 0.007917312905192375, -0.026574324816465378, -0.0038586053997278214, -0.0031281260307878256, -0.010111410170793533, -0.037525758147239685, -0.01146303303539753, 0.025924457237124443, -0.05607350543141365, 0.038389939814805984, 0.04741724207997322, 0.00256606237962842, 0.0056374818086624146, 0.05853668600320816, 0.0008820319199003279, -0.06712029129266739, 0.0027018242981284857, -0.012385102920234203, 0.035964224487543106, -0.026722747832536697, -0.02348860166966915, -0.02567390725016594, -0.01596859097480774, 0.010692081414163113, 0.0017361451173201203, -0.01340478379279375, 0.012478957884013653, 0.030147721990942955, -0.035640206187963486, -0.0007232058560475707, -0.00925587210804224, 0.029467318207025528, 0.016999123618006706, 0.018723776564002037, 0.02152191288769245, -0.04039831832051277, -0.042518895119428635, -0.020188745111227036, 0.03505050763487816, -0.011085483245551586, -0.0036717599723488092, 0.0035776295699179173, -0.01763213612139225, -0.022828688845038414, 0.02618689462542534, -0.002128513529896736, -0.031447816640138626, 0.038951605558395386, -0.00614679092541337, -0.001285805949009955, 0.009403277188539505, -0.0406661294400692, 0.0013292464427649975, -0.0355660617351532, 0.02385982871055603, -0.01961003802716732, -0.01630275696516037, 0.03996196389198303, 0.022816380485892296, -0.001084634568542242, 0.007334196474403143, -0.012280656024813652, 0.045242246240377426, 0.01794356293976307, -0.036971595138311386, -0.02984813041985035, -0.03884114325046539, 0.0011548090260475874, -0.01853596605360508, -0.049515966325998306, 0.020290056243538857, 0.03201345354318619, 0.06003450229763985, -0.010873254388570786, 0.032436199486255646, 0.0054850210435688496, -0.002142698271200061, 0.041899412870407104, -0.0853157788515091, 0.006911072880029678, 0.04176297411322594, 0.029771825298666954, -0.03373563289642334, -0.01154712587594986, -0.01759408973157406, -0.05725892260670662, -0.0003554330614861101, 0.00011050864850403741, -0.03518623113632202, -0.05345194414258003, -0.01687326282262802, 0.020008832216262817, -0.00472655426710844, 0.007980246096849442, -0.007975435815751553, 0.035287994891405106, 0.021007956936955452, -0.008396564051508904, 0.001361287315376103, 0.02282007597386837, -0.0205656997859478, 0.007997352629899979, 0.022488582879304886, -0.005197309423238039, 0.02887517772614956, -0.017752716317772865, -0.025527682155370712, 0.004389696288853884, 0.041842591017484665, -0.013737157918512821, -0.02553209662437439, 0.06375923752784729, -0.027704164385795593, -0.017927629873156548, 0.04185168072581291, 0.010048535652458668, 0.02948918752372265, 0.019571203738451004, -0.009219649247825146, -0.03934558108448982, 0.01692816987633705, -0.036283597350120544, -0.0006342071574181318, 0.006990650203078985, -0.011340539902448654, 0.009875009767711163, 0.007464196067303419, -0.005056485068053007, -0.004511406645178795, -0.009923525154590607, 0.051442015916109085, 0.06280235946178436, 0.003986043855547905, 0.010724845342338085, 0.008374071680009365, 0.0070457784458994865, 0.003282412188127637, 0.0011851406889036298, 0.01945287361741066, 0.02393590472638607, 0.05714669078588486, -0.05190163850784302, 0.008167813532054424, -0.05530676990747452, 0.006237532943487167, -0.07608558237552643, -0.03146905452013016, 0.040399450808763504, 0.027827147394418716, 0.034299708902835846, -0.029677482321858406, 0.009653574787080288, 0.011855832301080227, -0.09205575287342072, 0.010786022990942001, 0.006982137914747, -0.05522149056196213, -0.030420728027820587, -0.0021935689728707075, 0.0011930118780583143, 0.04821895435452461, 0.00824249442666769, 0.02002052403986454, 0.02310621365904808, 0.033570367842912674, -0.03224426880478859, -0.01483383309096098, -0.0032005382236093283, -0.016477473080158234, 0.017685724422335625, -0.07267604768276215, 0.03093086928129196, -0.024334926158189774, -0.034013476222753525, 0.04182149097323418, -0.013872874900698662, 0.01476379856467247, -0.018123703077435493, 0.008374524302780628, 0.01982964389026165, 0.05514650046825409, 0.006770777516067028, 0.018903788179159164, 0.007770012132823467, 0.017934877425432205, 0.04559672996401787, 0.03434164449572563, -0.06638272106647491, -0.025227457284927368, 0.026540031656622887, -0.002516615903005004, -0.03167314454913139, 0.027999019250273705, -0.014373242855072021, -0.04724537953734398, 0.002335937228053808, -0.017178893089294434, 0.02451421692967415, -0.021688126027584076, 0.06145182624459267, -0.04611434042453766, 0.002853583311662078, 0.014739764854311943, 0.027690213173627853, -0.03397238627076149, -0.004853282123804092, 0.010278657078742981, -0.046184781938791275, 0.009724671021103859, 0.007467429153621197, 0.01256681140512228, -0.039261605590581894, -0.051093585789203644, -0.020042290911078453, -0.026734929531812668, 0.015280412510037422, -0.03052283078432083, -0.018131352961063385, 0.009984323754906654, 0.01526381354779005, 0.01806899718940258, 0.00031930929981172085, -0.0038920221850275993, -0.017936361953616142, -0.08944354951381683, 0.024202680215239525, 0.00897733960300684, -0.013211640529334545, -0.03792469948530197, -0.008005039766430855, -0.07457305490970612, -0.039279259741306305, 0.06924327462911606, 0.047954414039850235, 0.02671961858868599, 0.0020683088805526495, 0.04316302388906479, 0.016212550923228264, -0.05611836537718773, 0.032433271408081055, -0.01479589194059372, -0.045458365231752396, -0.06903363764286041, -0.007613277994096279, 0.013988018035888672, -0.004018302541226149, 0.03541448339819908, -0.001558405114337802, -0.009961883537471294, 0.01051563024520874, 0.00060250487877056, 0.039069801568984985, -0.0030106413178145885, -0.0383705198764801, 0.07655404508113861, -0.00670196395367384, -0.005791341885924339, 0.0408569797873497, -0.011628527194261551, -0.030812464654445648, 0.018671313300728798, -0.02924315258860588, -0.015153944492340088, -0.023289356380701065, 0.017100786790251732, 0.021140405908226967, -0.04418839141726494, 0.010532651096582413, 0.024147868156433105, -0.04204035550355911, -0.022925788536667824, 0.06961335241794586, 0.06862837821245193, 0.026080086827278137, 0.037692591547966, -0.015282676555216312, 0.010913378559052944, -0.010978329926729202, 0.010669463314116001, 0.0167185477912426, 0.008526554331183434, -0.003959632944315672, -0.028035953640937805, 0.016741646453738213, -0.051127839833498, 0.03315043821930885, -0.011969794519245625, 0.016565756872296333, 0.005223593674600124, -0.007900122553110123, 0.023089177906513214, 0.003197723301127553, 0.053635746240615845, -0.02528969570994377, -0.016835961490869522, 0.07351523637771606, 0.008601437322795391, 0.021243656054139137, -0.022911792621016502, -0.015527808107435703, -0.02216251567006111, -0.012341352179646492, 0.004871688317507505, 0.0407034270465374, 0.002149418694898486, -0.0024371780455112457, -0.014570259489119053, -0.025572312995791435, 0.05300102382898331, -0.022019265219569206, 0.035942863672971725, -0.021352382376790047, 0.011553642340004444, 0.005270758643746376, -0.0782168060541153, -0.013321186415851116, -0.026953481137752533, 0.039928097277879715, 0.04179323464632034, 0.029215041548013687, -0.01756100170314312, -0.014119674451649189, 0.015419650822877884, 0.042604539543390274, -0.047870296984910965, -0.010462912730872631, -0.039488304406404495, 0.00841537956148386, 0.004820935428142548, -0.04870252311229706 ]
<p>I have 2 correlation matrices $A$ and $B$ (using the Pearson's linear correlation coefficient through Matlab's <a href="http://www.mathworks.com/help/matlab/ref/corrcoef.html" rel="nofollow">corrcoef()</a>). I would like to quantify how much "more correlation" $A$ contains compared to $B$. Is there any standard metric or test for that? </p> <p>E.g. the correlation matrix</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/4Lhvi.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>contains "more correlation" than</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/WsoUK.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>I am aware of the <a href="http://www.real-statistics.com/multivariate-statistics/boxs-test-equality-covariance-matrices/boxs-test-basic-concepts/" rel="nofollow">Box’s M Test</a>, which is used to determine whether two or more covariance matrices are equal (and can be used for correlation matrices as well since the latter are the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Correlation_and_dependence#Correlation_matrices" rel="nofollow">same</a> as the covariance matrices of standardized random variables). </p> <p>Right now I am comparing $A$ and $B$ via the mean of the absolute values of their non-diagonal elements, i.e. $\frac{2}{n^2-n}\sum_{1 \leq i &lt; j \leq n } \left | x_{i, j} \right |$. (I use the symmetry of the correlation matrix in this formula). I guess that there might be some cleverer metrics.</p> <hr> <p>Following Andy W's comment on the matrix determinant, I ran an experiment to compare the metrics:</p> <ul> <li><em>Mean of the absolute values of their non-diagonal elements</em>: $\text{metric}_\text{mean}()$</li> <li><em>Matrix determinant</em>: $\text{metric}_\text{determinant}()$:</li> </ul> <p>Let $A$ and $B$ two random symmetric matrix with ones on the diagonal of dimension $10 \times 10$. The upper triangle (diagonal excluded) of $A$ is populated with random floats from 0 to 1. The upper triangle (diagonal excluded) of $B$ is populated with random floats from 0 to 0.9. I generate 10000 such matrices and do some counting:</p> <ul> <li>$\text{metric}_\text{mean}(B) \leq \text{metric}_\text{mean}(A) $ 80.75% of the time</li> <li>$\text{metric}_\text{determinant}(B) \leq \text{metric}_\text{determinant}(A)$ 63.01% of the time</li> </ul> <p>Given the result I would tend to think that $\text{metric}_\text{mean}(B)$ is a better metric.</p> <p>Matlab code:</p> <pre><code>function [ ] = correlation_metric( ) %CORRELATION_METRIC Test some metric for % http://stats.stackexchange.com/q/110416/12359 : % I have 2 correlation matrices A and B (using the Pearson's linear % correlation coefficient through Matlab's corrcoef()). % I would like to quantify how much "more correlation" % A contains compared to B. Is there any standard metric or test for that? % Experiments' parameters runs = 10000; matrix_dimension = 10; %% Experiment 1 results = zeros(runs, 3); for i=1:runs dimension = matrix_dimension; M = generate_random_symmetric_matrix( dimension, 0.0, 1.0 ); results(i, 1) = abs(det(M)); % results(i, 2) = mean(triu(M, 1)); results(i, 2) = mean2(M); % results(i, 3) = results(i, 2) &lt; results(i, 2) ; end mean(results(:, 1)) mean(results(:, 2)) %% Experiment 2 results = zeros(runs, 6); for i=1:runs dimension = matrix_dimension; M = generate_random_symmetric_matrix( dimension, 0.0, 1.0 ); results(i, 1) = abs(det(M)); results(i, 2) = mean2(M); M = generate_random_symmetric_matrix( dimension, 0.0, 0.9 ); results(i, 3) = abs(det(M)); results(i, 4) = mean2(M); results(i, 5) = results(i, 1) &gt; results(i, 3); results(i, 6) = results(i, 2) &gt; results(i, 4); end mean(results(:, 5)) mean(results(:, 6)) boxplot(results(:, 1)) figure boxplot(results(:, 2)) end function [ random_symmetric_matrix ] = generate_random_symmetric_matrix( dimension, minimum, maximum ) % Based on http://www.mathworks.com/matlabcentral/answers/123643-how-to-create-a-symmetric-random-matrix d = ones(dimension, 1); %rand(dimension,1); % The diagonal values t = triu((maximum-minimum)*rand(dimension)+minimum,1); % The upper trianglar random values random_symmetric_matrix = diag(d)+t+t.'; % Put them together in a symmetric matrix end </code></pre> <p>Example of a generated $10 \times 10$ random symmetric matrix with ones on the diagonal:</p> <pre><code>&gt;&gt; random_symmetric_matrix random_symmetric_matrix = 1.0000 0.3984 0.1375 0.4372 0.2909 0.6172 0.2105 0.1737 0.2271 0.2219 0.3984 1.0000 0.3836 0.1954 0.5077 0.4233 0.0936 0.2957 0.5256 0.6622 0.1375 0.3836 1.0000 0.1517 0.9585 0.8102 0.6078 0.8669 0.5290 0.7665 0.4372 0.1954 0.1517 1.0000 0.9531 0.2349 0.6232 0.6684 0.8945 0.2290 0.2909 0.5077 0.9585 0.9531 1.0000 0.3058 0.0330 0.0174 0.9649 0.5313 0.6172 0.4233 0.8102 0.2349 0.3058 1.0000 0.7483 0.2014 0.2164 0.2079 0.2105 0.0936 0.6078 0.6232 0.0330 0.7483 1.0000 0.5814 0.8470 0.6858 0.1737 0.2957 0.8669 0.6684 0.0174 0.2014 0.5814 1.0000 0.9223 0.0760 0.2271 0.5256 0.5290 0.8945 0.9649 0.2164 0.8470 0.9223 1.0000 0.5758 0.2219 0.6622 0.7665 0.2290 0.5313 0.2079 0.6858 0.0760 0.5758 1.0000 </code></pre>
73,797
[ -0.03853185474872589, 0.01367979496717453, -0.012733889743685722, -0.017011210322380066, 0.05789344385266304, 0.04697008058428764, -0.0179893895983696, -0.04501242935657501, 0.011556400917470455, -0.04177916422486305, 0.05583280324935913, 0.05618505924940109, 0.016705790534615517, 0.029822390526533127, -0.005173598416149616, 0.0016682770801708102, -0.01441883947700262, 0.002874094992876053, -0.0063017928041517735, -0.00599751016125083, 0.01284200232475996, 0.014583256095647812, 0.04568955674767494, 0.005212392657995224, -0.006499797571450472, 0.06605199724435806, 0.0022353979293257, -0.050346143543720245, 0.005475211422890425, 0.05664708465337753, -0.02610105089843273, -0.04241656884551048, 0.01954684592783451, 0.0023872076999396086, -0.0073547568172216415, -0.0051252394914627075, 0.03730953857302666, 0.00020784491789527237, 0.01927918568253517, 0.06273500621318817, -0.05252683162689209, -0.0462876632809639, -0.020366299897432327, 0.026586415246129036, -0.01938658580183983, 0.01576741598546505, 0.011236324906349182, -0.03808091953396797, -0.003440981497988105, -0.022833706811070442, 0.12043553590774536, 0.032103367149829865, 0.025729451328516006, 0.010067041963338852, -0.0313018262386322, -0.01544957235455513, 0.04661265388131142, 0.044680405408144, 0.01326496060937643, -0.05306576192378998, 0.012253736145794392, -0.03506338223814964, 0.016082344576716423, -0.01901712268590927, -0.028851289302110672, 0.04443718120455742, -0.01591644622385502, 0.021936163306236267, 0.021503852680325508, -0.018308108672499657, 0.013375943526625633, 0.03321312740445137, 0.031372323632240295, -0.07024576514959335, -0.014951328746974468, -0.045156653970479965, 0.008727263659238815, 0.008850590325891972, 0.039543312042951584, 0.02560802549123764, 0.016952065750956535, -0.003448222763836384, 0.019037950783967972, 0.0381164513528347, 0.03890222683548927, 0.003339130198583007, 0.058410514146089554, -0.036168068647384644, 0.0007268079207278788, 0.011463695205748081, -0.0059037297032773495, -0.032375503331422806, 0.03990432620048523, 0.02517981082201004, -0.04311060532927513, 0.026102714240550995, -0.03692987561225891, 0.037009451538324356, 0.016050243750214577, -0.0319666713476181, -0.048632219433784485, -0.028857365250587463, 0.007239909376949072, 0.062066927552223206, -0.00286660878919065, -0.006753645837306976, -0.031427428126335144, 0.010638539679348469, 0.004581071436405182, -0.020759033039212227, -0.028734983876347542, 0.02762201428413391, 0.0016447853995487094, 0.037922319024801254, 0.04461139068007469, -0.02596801519393921, -0.002579707419499755, -0.015477570705115795, 0.026721883565187454, 0.09095901250839233, 0.05024220421910286, -0.00787452980875969, -0.015081188641488552, -0.015910420566797256, -0.03316209092736244, 0.037448715418577194, 0.020000707358121872, 0.005935662891715765, -0.030579445883631706, 0.03218451887369156, 0.01319931447505951, -0.01142966840416193, -0.014678249135613441, -0.007784080691635609, 0.019101014360785484, -0.009645444341003895, -0.09150002151727676, -0.06072080507874489, 0.06104789301753044, 0.0053883204236626625, -0.0417565181851387, -0.03575744107365608, 0.013291793875396252, 0.00225039548240602, 0.06401700526475906, 0.049228694289922714, 0.05873184651136398, 0.004739352036267519, 0.04772668704390526, 0.02749508060514927, -0.008146938867866993, -0.0008512809872627258, -0.02293333224952221, -0.027941875159740448, 0.01003640703856945, -0.05903249606490135, -0.03158756345510483, -0.008164671249687672, -0.0011047637090086937, -0.005116483196616173, 0.011950617656111717, 0.0409650020301342, -0.04516702517867088, -0.009224905632436275, 0.00833666231483221, -0.011588286608457565, 0.04027721285820007, -0.025599926710128784, 0.006231145933270454, -0.006991598289459944, -0.03008425049483776, 0.01660042256116867, 0.017503004521131516, 0.0393575057387352, 0.05220608040690422, -0.032357584685087204, 0.003461521351709962, 0.01223303098231554, 0.0223627258092165, 0.01426167692989111, -0.039589233696460724, -0.05437145382165909, -0.0338270477950573, 0.004815703723579645, 0.027817824855446815, 0.05802915617823601, -0.010016032494604588, -0.005963601171970367, 0.052293963730335236, -0.04216306656599045, -0.018850384280085564, -0.08802802115678787, 0.0097893001511693, 0.008751317858695984, -0.08097255229949951, 0.02889951877295971, 0.0022063488140702248, 0.0021077864803373814, 0.004101844970136881, -0.03612615168094635, -0.009391129948198795, 0.004936567973345518, 0.03682960197329521, -0.02337508089840412, 0.0165021400898695, -0.003519310848787427, 0.04655255749821663, -0.023179713636636734, 0.01100755762308836, -0.020056208595633507, -0.03133810684084892, 0.00871614646166563, -0.04177415743470192, -0.00456412835046649, -0.008306258358061314, -0.016729149967432022, 0.02814449742436409, -0.015783442184329033, -0.04072384163737297, 0.0031397975981235504, -0.02170897088944912, 0.03401045873761177, 0.018845437094569206, 0.03447914868593216, 0.0008025506394915283, 0.014227790758013725, 0.023958759382367134, 0.028228726238012314, -0.04598710313439369, -0.030392708256840706, -0.028363410383462906, -0.005014566704630852, 0.05060236155986786, 0.03755706921219826, -0.06328833103179932, 0.004589567892253399, 0.03196229413151741, -0.0015883533051237464, -0.02023979276418686, 0.014009230770170689, 0.004447297193109989, -0.05790257453918457, -0.03163488581776619, 0.04499150440096855, -0.01058325543999672, 0.03263586759567261, -0.016742952167987823, 0.0020190724171698093, 0.0456484779715538, -0.0038224002346396446, -0.018605725839734077, 0.02679833397269249, -0.01037115603685379, -0.003338312730193138, -0.032255690544843674, 0.0006322359549812973, 0.051049381494522095, -0.010787038132548332, -0.00921144150197506, 0.047052331268787384, 0.001183565123938024, 0.011015447787940502, 0.010034836828708649, -0.0663798525929451, 0.004378329962491989, 0.014776707626879215, -0.01783354952931404, -0.0016179794911295176, -0.006303653120994568, -0.018274927511811256, 0.02070067822933197, -0.007877880707383156, -0.008357890881597996, -0.0053394087590277195, -0.008315058425068855, 0.0455000065267086, 0.01935812272131443, 0.021624386310577393, -0.021512137725949287, 0.010082102380692959, -0.020567836239933968, -0.011540253646671772, 0.0068197548389434814, -0.02292652800679207, -0.04354274645447731, -0.005863406229764223, -0.04647769778966904, 0.0046366136521101, 0.014562792144715786, -0.016506057232618332, -0.021698832511901855, 0.05690639466047287, 0.003406985430046916, -0.04991038143634796, -0.017929069697856903, 0.007649576291441917, -0.004077130928635597, -0.04353858903050423, -0.006694409064948559, 0.03371603041887283, -0.03455800563097, -0.08863724768161774, 0.021312804892659187, -0.01912154071033001, -0.03891919180750847, -0.05731237679719925, -0.011153439991176128, 0.018770024180412292, -0.01712837815284729, 0.0031644999980926514, 0.008557341992855072, 0.01505623385310173, -0.031970128417015076, -0.03908427432179451, -0.028724640607833862, 0.023981645703315735, 0.0156871248036623, 0.04244678467512131, 0.009819316677749157, -0.01866057515144348, 0.08280318975448608, 0.03303880989551544, -0.004161768592894077, -0.06367968767881393, 0.0053377412259578705, -0.009598314762115479, -0.011621307581663132, 0.022249821573495865, 0.02549421414732933, 0.000851149670779705, 0.022410010918974876, -0.0009130830876529217, 0.02405000664293766, 0.00798728410154581, -0.023036018013954163, 0.01186828501522541, 0.03298795968294144, -0.002889591734856367, -0.002154785906895995, 0.06088479235768318, 0.006206983234733343, -0.0378011129796505, -0.010867241770029068, 0.045024435967206955, -0.011904614977538586, 0.01627751626074314, -0.06661071628332138, 0.03237392380833626, -0.05241066962480545, 0.01867159828543663, -0.03190530836582184, -0.007786606904119253, 0.020273655652999878, 0.00031603968818672, -0.005663943476974964, 0.041239913552999496, 0.002814596751704812, 0.023481154814362526, 0.023359514772892, 0.04322577267885208, 0.003341265022754669, 0.0009699346264824271, 0.05226857215166092, -0.01839625835418701, -0.012609845027327538, 0.04029316082596779, -0.044597696512937546, -0.046425387263298035, 0.025743594393134117, 0.030302109196782112, 0.01607237383723259, -0.002315723104402423, -0.02637184038758278, 0.01878262311220169, -0.04321734607219696, -0.025862442329525948, -0.053511712700128555, 0.030162854120135307, 0.0060026454739272594, 0.04505845159292221, -0.01822887733578682, -0.03214527666568756, 0.024988098070025444, 0.006488298065960407, -0.05239841341972351, 0.010847827419638634, -0.015870176255702972, -0.015620972029864788, 0.006802774034440517, -0.04490364342927933, 0.014367129653692245, -0.02447173185646534, 0.02890867181122303, 0.004970710724592209, 0.07761036604642868, -0.044313885271549225, 0.015033130533993244, -0.03551037982106209, -0.01434333436191082, 0.015955517068505287, -0.008876536041498184, 0.013552224263548851, -0.032944053411483765, 0.03896388038992882, 0.015597880817949772, -0.02762492746114731, -0.02289349026978016, 0.0005105449235998094, 0.024438008666038513, 0.041913118213415146, 0.02118552103638649, 0.004281865898519754, 0.051142580807209015, -0.014464707113802433, -0.010369294323027134, -0.016627777367830276, 0.017802370712161064, 0.03957086428999901, -0.005063050892204046, 0.010835248045623302, -0.027937186881899834, -0.01891767419874668, -0.012134046293795109, 0.018694967031478882, -0.004286333918571472, -0.0007217152160592377, 0.04179465025663376, 0.04622126370668411, -0.01981031708419323, 0.002463080920279026, 0.03341709449887276, 0.0306080374866724, 0.011120584793388844, -0.03637605160474777, -0.0332661010324955, -0.016103902831673622, -0.02034456841647625, 0.0339939184486866, -0.02518063224852085, -0.01032276451587677, -0.039100177586078644, 0.04836719483137131, -0.0027319591026753187, -0.02872416563332081, 0.01649046316742897, 0.013988126069307327, 0.021795766428112984, 0.0014071803307160735, -0.02016855962574482, -0.0381549708545208, 0.04987868666648865, 0.012202100828289986, 0.020843608304858208, 0.013030939735472202, -0.04687584191560745, 0.02098732814192772, 0.048426974564790726, 0.028139449656009674, -0.02156233601272106, -0.006663032341748476, -0.007296446710824966, -0.03427812457084656, 0.04478508606553078, -0.00043957613524980843, 0.029613181948661804, 0.0076371533796191216, 0.04403842240571976, -0.05330411344766617, -0.006348486058413982, -0.05352474004030228, 0.019229227676987648, 0.021791428327560425, -0.008121185936033726, -0.02555149607360363, -0.011445206589996815, -0.03122832626104355, 0.0013804460177198052, 0.0577257014811039, 0.06345131993293762, -0.03142818063497543, 0.011371206492185593, 0.03435803949832916, 0.021979954093694687, 0.010225928388535976, -0.04068479686975479, 0.011397670954465866, 0.021506812423467636, -0.06507745385169983, 0.05371539667248726, -0.02264358475804329, -0.02504729852080345, 0.0061072916723787785, -0.03294367343187332, -0.012204899452626705, 0.044419992715120316, -0.010276192799210548, 0.07911233603954315, 0.0537869818508625, 0.008750684559345245, 0.02042361907660961, 0.014537375420331955, 0.0010964875109493732, 0.015111868269741535, -0.04413377866148949, 0.015307614579796791, -0.013967539183795452, -0.046695053577423096, -0.06052251532673836, -0.022896764799952507, -0.05126340314745903, 0.05866827815771103, -0.029857557266950607, 0.041276320815086365, -0.02691088244318962, 0.004148562904447317, 0.01628679409623146, 0.023381227627396584, -0.03544233366847038, 0.01604355126619339, 0.0274110808968544, -0.00509050814434886, 0.004898971412330866, -0.029069680720567703, 0.010838651098310947, -0.037248603999614716, -0.014743423089385033, 0.025705328211188316, -0.053669124841690063, 0.0011115667875856161, -0.04752407595515251, 0.0013041689526289701, -0.047598715871572495, 0.0025996100157499313, 0.05260928347706795, 0.009512522257864475, -0.00525764562189579, -0.003827799577265978, -0.03898489847779274, 0.003677534172311425, 0.05132938548922539, -0.00007184863352449611, 0.04184745252132416, -0.007002482656389475, -0.0011647926876321435, -0.00038161297561600804, -0.015704253688454628, -0.05693643540143967, -0.032556578516960144, 0.012111099436879158, -0.01783779449760914, -0.009172145277261734, -0.06522084027528763, -0.02791423350572586, -0.011584517545998096, -0.007352581713348627, -0.02057185024023056, 0.06934039294719696, -0.012722895480692387, -0.02773311361670494, 0.0016641216352581978, 0.016637656837701797, 0.06366997957229614, -0.03886735439300537, -0.014459925703704357, -0.002533603459596634, 0.007457035128027201, -0.019798103719949722, 0.04134277254343033, 0.00011748779070330784, -0.030101461336016655, -0.012281209230422974, -0.052034568041563034, -0.008872265927493572, 0.05204395577311516, -0.027717530727386475, -0.019843829795718193, 0.004175630863755941, -0.005312892142683268, -0.0027473876252770424, -0.02522427588701248, 0.007815209217369556, 0.01393940206617117, 0.005862180143594742, -0.009023218415677547, -0.020170658826828003, -0.023779667913913727, -0.03471142426133156, 0.0011738386237993836, 0.015120843425393105, -0.030397428199648857, -0.013143676333129406, 0.0692482739686966, -0.0013590286253020167, -0.006214158609509468, 0.0004117210046388209, -0.009049964137375355, 0.012040373869240284, -0.014574487693607807, 0.027760561555624008, 0.00499066011980176, 0.024508120492100716, -0.02088126540184021, -0.03274916112422943, -0.03683875873684883, 0.0054042949341237545, 0.05061289668083191, 0.013099873438477516, 0.04919568821787834, 0.05581609159708023, 0.0016013931017369032, 0.010982836596667767, -0.004426469095051289, 0.04309144988656044, 0.020454861223697662, 0.01795676164329052, 0.050165437161922455, -0.06531082838773727, -0.003018135204911232, 0.04261530563235283, 0.04939204081892967, 0.011637715622782707, 0.039797428995370865, -0.012252634391188622, 0.050807565450668335, 0.032244645059108734, -0.009096097201108932, -0.0712328851222992, 0.039020340889692307, -0.03168065473437309, 0.006963932421058416, -0.025361571460962296, -0.001074148458428681, 0.03499777242541313, 0.05148150026798248, -0.025042936205863953, -0.020848313346505165, -0.047386977821588516, -0.0542590357363224, 0.01146392896771431, 0.03635604679584503, -0.011285989545285702, 0.009280411526560783, -0.009633100591599941, 0.04027138650417328, -0.014212987385690212, 0.03444308787584305, -0.025781620293855667, -0.06855931133031845, 0.00007919135532574728, -0.008556044660508633, -0.04456571489572525, 0.03292524814605713, -0.0010688824113458395, -0.00906074047088623, 0.011864823289215565, -0.03669744357466698, -0.004578329622745514, 0.007608149200677872, 0.009772781282663345, -0.029389506205916405, 0.0582810640335083, -0.033088892698287964, 0.020694391801953316, 0.017642805352807045, -0.03618459030985832, 0.10311594605445862, 0.05478297919034958, 0.03351408988237381, -0.051028743386268616, 0.025963418185710907, 0.015706617385149002, 0.010496285744011402, -0.06669500470161438, 0.011518388986587524, -0.008262727409601212, -0.015214098617434502, 0.04589014872908592, 0.06504020094871521, 0.015546169131994247, -0.0315801277756691, 0.04382941126823425, -0.0001238472032127902, -0.0062249284237623215, 0.017331277951598167, 0.03748805448412895, 0.008412946946918964, -0.015557494945824146, -0.033853013068437576, 0.01963617093861103, -0.00920108426362276, -0.015865353867411613, -0.042182132601737976, 0.02333264984190464, 0.0033330286387354136, -0.0250703115016222, -0.024382174015045166, 0.03603196144104004, 0.05533439666032791, 0.01007283478975296, -0.03018721379339695, 0.00867285206913948, 0.034707099199295044, -0.01655280962586403, 0.030114945024251938, -0.016218174248933792, -0.02276977337896824, 0.02023431658744812, 0.017257705330848694, -0.014751080423593521, -0.03276209160685539, 0.014298157766461372, -0.058472681790590286, 0.030632466077804565, 0.0024163248017430305, -0.02275845594704151, -0.014497694559395313, -0.009898839518427849, -0.017740482464432716, -0.03355853632092476, 0.013385441154241562, 0.027517542243003845, 0.03172816336154938, -0.025303563103079796, 0.008605134673416615, -0.028437068685889244, 0.02357337810099125, 0.009545018896460533, 0.032767314463853836, -0.01261467020958662, -0.027345728129148483, -0.005845770239830017, -0.03453463315963745, 0.050648219883441925, 0.011380372568964958, -0.0393616184592247, -0.01972879096865654, 0.02360145002603531, -0.019245177507400513, -0.024240974336862564, -0.010380159132182598, 0.015596264973282814, 0.032751262187957764, 0.049353960901498795, 0.0041785589419305325, -0.0063740769401192665, -0.06009232997894287, -0.00966687873005867, -0.03168174996972084, -0.01927667111158371, -0.019318899139761925, -0.032503318041563034, 0.05741952732205391, 0.04461095482110977, 0.0006422284059226513, 0.0038360836915671825, 0.010809971019625664, 0.03888566046953201, 0.04175245389342308, -0.017335044220089912, -0.00018955838459078223, -0.025249456986784935, -0.008253118023276329, 0.0006441251025535166, -0.03375445678830147, -0.011996762827038765, 0.027858447283506393, 0.014713859185576439, -0.0063664610497653484, 0.00020958640379831195, -0.026531333103775978, -0.0024514247197657824, 0.0028530689887702465, -0.03189266845583916, -0.0194175336509943, 0.012712384574115276, 0.0014070060569792986, 0.0006384985754266381, 0.014292246662080288, -0.02677145227789879, -0.024052200838923454, 0.023977553471922874, -0.015645870938897133, -0.005244794301688671, -0.053078386932611465, 0.0048988619819283485, 0.020723981782794, -0.04094153642654419, -0.023200135678052902, -0.04989263415336609, -0.004613823257386684, 0.002832057885825634, 0.007847072556614876, -0.017230449244379997, 0.032867223024368286, 0.003813475836068392, 0.036878254264593124, 0.06452663987874985, 0.048541612923145294, 0.026604020968079567, -0.01959613338112831, -0.011617996729910374, 0.0162444356828928, 0.08309570699930191, -0.023978663608431816, -0.009587029926478863, 0.040967799723148346, -0.05638665333390236, 0.024614905938506126, 0.013656812720000744, -0.023663777858018875, -0.0029342034831643105, 0.004346784669905901, -0.002307573100551963, -0.04983806237578392, 0.02509685419499874, -0.03359602764248848, -0.008629201911389828, -0.020561333745718002, 0.00010799120354931802, 0.019078437238931656, -0.012726894579827785, 0.02306460216641426, -0.016638657078146935, -0.016805585473775864, 0.0027987502980977297, 0.06967291235923767, -0.03166787326335907, -0.009393086656928062, -0.0037580588832497597, -0.02963503636419773, -0.004034463781863451, -0.023024292662739754, -0.013387846760451794, 0.025038743391633034, 0.0458952970802784, -0.04422325640916824, 0.01853615790605545, 0.0309420358389616, 0.027649611234664917, -0.09186264127492905, 0.011385681107640266, 0.023224079981446266, 0.035372767597436905, 0.07773838937282562, -0.0677342414855957, 0.01867801882326603, 0.04833390936255455, -0.07030405849218369, 0.035711564123630524, -0.0018979647429659963, -0.01168447732925415, -0.02584291622042656, -0.001147936680354178, -0.03960302844643593, 0.0357566699385643, 0.009576637297868729, 0.03646889701485634, 0.041962310671806335, 0.07169713824987411, -0.04348287358880043, -0.017916688695549965, -0.004029563628137112, 0.0067910864017903805, -0.0034699507523328066, -0.04631507396697998, 0.028191588819026947, 0.0008220372255891562, -0.02319513075053692, 0.058022405952215195, -0.030784286558628082, 0.012844249606132507, 0.0009566969238221645, 0.03788892552256584, -0.00857426319271326, 0.011208946816623211, 0.02304963394999504, -0.010385599918663502, 0.015573752112686634, -0.03113926574587822, 0.057363416999578476, 0.019522398710250854, -0.025815127417445183, 0.019594473764300346, 0.013073386624455452, -0.010844149626791477, -0.03609307110309601, 0.0033908344339579344, -0.021113362163305283, -0.016488630324602127, 0.002019215375185013, -0.025741206482052803, 0.036483682692050934, -0.018253255635499954, 0.020777951925992966, -0.028358954936265945, 0.007285132072865963, 0.038507409393787384, 0.012174747884273529, -0.038781024515628815, 0.0014072636840865016, 0.009226571768522263, -0.028660349547863007, 0.035601694136857986, 0.008622040040791035, 0.0183247160166502, -0.08172323554754257, -0.04176219180226326, -0.013875769451260567, 0.013746253214776516, -0.009377180598676205, -0.04886690899729729, -0.04121594503521919, 0.047178443521261215, -0.012065459974110126, -0.02550601027905941, -0.027047719806432724, 0.020856712013483047, 0.002096788724884391, -0.0978865772485733, 0.0011268145171925426, 0.002503044903278351, -0.027233392000198364, -0.030716659501194954, 0.023550914600491524, -0.027536721900105476, -0.018773278221488, 0.09130510687828064, 0.02412055805325508, 0.0382164865732193, 0.006798003800213337, 0.0007162588881328702, 0.017398091033101082, -0.05415783077478409, 0.05075429007411003, -0.032514531165361404, -0.008944381959736347, -0.008404435589909554, 0.01065460592508316, 0.03186296299099922, -0.011133368127048016, 0.015228135511279106, -0.03930601105093956, -0.008337704464793205, 0.0044789970852434635, 0.004287188407033682, 0.059635233134031296, 0.0038331865798681974, -0.04215795174241066, 0.055573027580976486, -0.0014669462107121944, 0.016119565814733505, 0.013662909157574177, -0.012638167478144169, -0.0337713286280632, 0.03012937121093273, 0.007895896211266518, -0.04791019484400749, 0.007956456393003464, 0.0515374019742012, -0.024867717176675797, -0.06805939227342606, -0.003611571155488491, 0.028276344761252403, -0.03805263713002205, -0.050679758191108704, 0.041619785130023956, 0.029029304161667824, 0.02985895238816738, 0.0031744965817779303, 0.0717955082654953, 0.025390170514583588, -0.03412016108632088, 0.015798944979906082, -0.00009835291712079197, 0.05465186759829521, -0.00016440100444015115, 0.009534892626106739, 0.018906304612755775, -0.02338595502078533, 0.04635589197278023, -0.03683358430862427, 0.020729269832372665, -0.02942338027060032, -0.009872584603726864, 0.03845769912004471, -0.02881830371916294, 0.036001987755298615, 0.012424621731042862, 0.0057768383994698524, 0.05901198834180832, -0.051286280155181885, -0.00040728438762016594, -0.02162681706249714, 0.015474122017621994, -0.04226331412792206, 0.005739458836615086, 0.0057895611971616745, -0.005231107119470835, 0.015481002628803253, 0.02699231542646885, -0.012857237830758095, -0.018967438489198685, 0.010981984436511993, -0.010487101972103119, 0.0474560484290123, 0.016827480867505074, 0.017673814669251442, -0.002659356454387307, -0.029686808586120605, -0.017490874975919724, -0.008001388050615788, 0.05418607220053673, 0.035089049488306046, 0.015960998833179474, -0.01843409799039364, -0.004566643852740526, 0.003125846851617098, 0.05211300775408745, -0.0650363564491272, -0.03532591834664345, -0.036768216639757156, 0.0021195735316723585, -0.008330238051712513, 0.019742373377084732 ]
<p>I am working with a dataset where I need to use non-parametric stats (won't go into details). It is behavioral data on captive animals ($n=8$), where $4$ treatments were introduced $3$ different times randomly. I have tested for difference in my repeats using a Friedman test. None were found. I am looking for a way to analyze my data to see differences between the $4$ treatments but also considering difference between individuals ($8$) interacting. </p> <p><strong>Questions:</strong> </p> <ol> <li>In my mind I should perform a 2-way ANOVA (i.e., the non-parametric equivalent) but most of the tests I have found do not allow for replicated data. </li> <li>Do I average the repeats since no difference was found and then conduct the ANOVA equivalent test?</li> <li>Is there a test that will look for difference in 4 treatments, keeping in mind the individual interaction with replicated data?</li> </ol>
73,798
[ -0.04093979299068451, -0.014974466525018215, -0.012305364944040775, -0.000050103601097362116, 0.0362183079123497, 0.012327020056545734, -0.004756318870931864, -0.03365563601255417, 0.01507569756358862, -0.012609218247234821, 0.05129878968000412, 0.024232713505625725, 0.03604641929268837, 0.015683185309171677, 0.006774966139346361, -0.009046748280525208, -0.037681546062231064, -0.018010932952165604, 0.009701522067189217, -0.004967070184648037, 0.0024966886267066, 0.016986723989248276, -0.020802445709705353, -0.0106576569378376, -0.035691265016794205, 0.05899721756577492, 0.03880453482270241, -0.06275906413793564, -0.0030015036463737488, 0.07165171951055527, -0.05474723130464554, -0.0313091054558754, -0.0010750498622655869, 0.0420539565384388, 0.013794437050819397, 0.010073686949908733, -0.07103407382965088, -0.005860393866896629, 0.02908273972570896, 0.06487224251031876, -0.024732064455747604, 0.011169116012752056, 0.002853036392480135, 0.02311844378709793, 0.007844352163374424, -0.00696563022211194, -0.019964728504419327, 0.010364987887442112, 0.017025301232933998, -0.05398261174559593, 0.05467050522565842, -0.007438886910676956, 0.008022167719900608, 0.03710807487368584, -0.00360171333886683, -0.014346378855407238, 0.04117510840296745, 0.03351788595318794, 0.02657807432115078, -0.06256170570850372, -0.02517768181860447, -0.022981008514761925, 0.019558647647500038, -0.008652681484818459, -0.02386688068509102, 0.02335442416369915, 0.017088601365685463, -0.02038826048374176, 0.021882986649870872, -0.029653556644916534, 0.013415354304015636, 0.03665865957736969, 0.10066993534564972, 0.016957568004727364, -0.0005432653706520796, 0.021303873509168625, 0.018981879577040672, 0.0059885140508413315, 0.06505828350782394, 0.04013659432530403, -0.010827572084963322, 0.017148245126008987, 0.006424107123166323, 0.04469463229179382, 0.029747532680630684, -0.023587871342897415, 0.012007679790258408, -0.013307296670973301, -0.02109774760901928, 0.02830880880355835, 0.015364279970526695, -0.03828985244035721, 0.07591494172811508, 0.013659502379596233, -0.04112621769309044, 0.006998603232204914, -0.010920587927103043, 0.03517060726881027, -0.013258724473416805, -0.003960023168474436, -0.002392167691141367, -0.07368779927492142, -0.001991202589124441, 0.05473931506276131, -0.008538732305169106, -0.0274753849953413, -0.002513062907382846, 0.005425337702035904, -0.017904825508594513, -0.029487481340765953, 0.004940935876220465, 0.037511639297008514, 0.03403083607554436, -0.016021260991692543, 0.033821024000644684, -0.009843275882303715, -0.030145565047860146, -0.006435159128159285, 0.045597564429044724, 0.06494484096765518, 0.01818881370127201, -0.01821114867925644, 0.017947891727089882, -0.026502598077058792, -0.0161754060536623, -0.012046003714203835, 0.019334638491272926, -0.027745623141527176, -0.04132506623864174, 0.06169069558382034, 0.01973493956029415, 0.004969162866473198, 0.019590944051742554, -0.0020483294501900673, 0.027714159339666367, -0.0015707799466326833, -0.08443400263786316, -0.06288598477840424, 0.059472084045410156, -0.04062650352716446, -0.0073531619273126125, -0.07220042496919632, 0.002787057776004076, 0.009301894344389439, 0.02022995427250862, 0.01730426400899887, 0.005789524409919977, 0.024371277540922165, 0.0411418154835701, 0.04339880868792534, 0.017807353287935257, -0.006391832605004311, -0.027423009276390076, -0.01637975499033928, -0.0037474618293344975, -0.06120975688099861, 0.026885559782385826, -0.02543504349887371, -0.015749482437968254, 0.03454547002911568, 0.07107123732566833, 0.001607863581739366, 0.016071364283561707, -0.010824721306562424, 0.02074725553393364, -0.00201317947357893, 0.046882227063179016, -0.027146711945533752, 0.025600865483283997, 0.007253107614815235, -0.03028191439807415, 0.01385152991861105, -0.029508281499147415, 0.048119183629751205, 0.060526106506586075, -0.02318827621638775, -0.013895330019295216, -0.0053954217582941055, -0.00739325862377882, 0.006930929142981768, -0.01346561498939991, -0.006144922226667404, -0.036925967782735825, -0.027402415871620178, 0.03083786368370056, 0.02568906359374523, 0.014162794686853886, 0.015267808921635151, 0.006167470943182707, -0.025525905191898346, -0.07128186523914337, -0.08679085969924927, 0.015211619436740875, 0.004642181098461151, -0.05565684661269188, 0.004928994458168745, -0.021028155460953712, 0.015288262628018856, 0.005435828119516373, -0.025697089731693268, -0.01851058378815651, 0.008074953220784664, 0.05107920244336128, -0.046952493488788605, -0.006167244631797075, 0.05457361787557602, 0.034129995852708817, -0.04888863489031792, 0.009133684448897839, -0.0736256018280983, -0.04558467119932175, -0.009873727336525917, -0.043997880071401596, 0.015904229134321213, 0.015101376920938492, 0.028548672795295715, 0.04096090793609619, 0.00899080652743578, -0.05228450149297714, 0.058774273842573166, -0.06601645797491074, 0.04787864536046982, 0.05438264086842537, -0.02599296160042286, 0.004621488973498344, 0.00440240278840065, -0.0007123828982003033, 0.01855861209332943, -0.027617868036031723, -0.017050305381417274, -0.06170738488435745, -0.009481559507548809, 0.03789486363530159, -0.004057121928781271, -0.03744077682495117, 0.04363382235169411, 0.07857128977775574, 0.027892420068383217, -0.013896792195737362, 0.01376707386225462, 0.020894015207886696, -0.007643543649464846, 0.0426209457218647, 0.03721846267580986, 0.03048587404191494, 0.022147199138998985, -0.0016760069411247969, -0.026183566078543663, 0.06412859261035919, 0.04341409355401993, 0.01061611995100975, 0.023690514266490936, -0.0027082969900220633, 0.024422071874141693, -0.028473924845457077, -0.025456679984927177, 0.023648276925086975, -0.0010423923376947641, 0.03535434603691101, 0.027697013691067696, 0.035427678376436234, 0.002146579325199127, -0.00719712907448411, -0.04147780314087868, 0.018801501020789146, 0.01810927502810955, -0.032018017023801804, -0.022295555099844933, 0.009890219196677208, -0.015288937836885452, 0.021891998127102852, -0.020335666835308075, -0.03157305717468262, 0.004958024248480797, 0.022603482007980347, 0.014410212635993958, -0.025678453966975212, -0.004341016057878733, -0.05255676805973053, 0.014910072088241577, -0.003296100767329335, -0.003355849301442504, -0.0012712093302980065, 0.013238360174000263, -0.06051267683506012, -0.025094300508499146, -0.04570458084344864, 0.0020069482270628214, 0.0044032814912498, 0.00048313531442545354, -0.008891211822628975, 0.06318336725234985, 0.018995899707078934, -0.052726760506629944, -0.026651540771126747, -0.039963800460100174, 0.004728317726403475, -0.059586286544799805, 0.0023826269898563623, 0.04809216409921646, 0.05284394696354866, -0.0352703295648098, 0.009241840802133083, -0.028384529054164886, 0.014652227982878685, 0.02272638864815235, -0.008515204302966595, 0.044128332287073135, 0.0017745057120919228, 0.0009292365284636617, -0.000046846875193296, -0.01566353626549244, -0.02575087361037731, -0.0985439345240593, -0.05407373607158661, -0.004731629975140095, 0.0035648092161864042, 0.029240690171718597, -0.0030309921130537987, -0.011184783652424812, 0.040822114795446396, 0.023533077910542488, -0.026871532201766968, -0.06696673482656479, 0.002037549391388893, -0.03073211945593357, -0.021147405728697777, 0.03799083083868027, -0.012873080559074879, -0.019913090392947197, 0.005588518921285868, 0.005806384142488241, 0.03971057012677193, 0.028535757213830948, 0.021464282646775246, 0.007485645357519388, 0.025394750759005547, 0.04599862918257713, -0.017498627305030823, 0.04779849573969841, 0.02254546247422695, -0.02889498881995678, -0.0004135783528909087, 0.039581865072250366, -0.02091747708618641, 0.027791447937488556, -0.06047787144780159, 0.026394395157694817, -0.004871840123087168, -0.0107920803129673, 0.0011146784527227283, 0.017057271674275398, 0.015333045274019241, -0.004905724432319403, -0.0336165614426136, 0.015669571235775948, 0.01142491027712822, 0.004203297663480043, 0.02971992827951908, 0.06142581254243851, 0.026866959407925606, 0.0041059148497879505, -0.009416750632226467, -0.006067698355764151, -0.0013289432972669601, -0.021820032969117165, 0.0014465441927313805, 0.001907316385768354, 0.008251545950770378, 0.054064780473709106, 0.035196080803871155, 0.0007918369374237955, -0.031747784465551376, -0.024872910231351852, -0.038343749940395355, -0.006556070409715176, -0.054959043860435486, 0.01811201125383377, 0.005270849913358688, 0.0365237258374691, -0.011371380649507046, -0.004328977782279253, 0.011605891399085522, -0.019476812332868576, -0.04881461709737778, 0.01745930314064026, 0.011067173443734646, -0.015520120039582253, 0.02042224444448948, -0.017187049612402916, 0.03201178088784218, -0.005177200306206942, 0.058944087475538254, 0.00454467348754406, 0.023721173405647278, -0.010814777575433254, -0.03397674113512039, 0.0013747544726356864, -0.013491363264620304, -0.03981129452586174, 0.023337548598647118, 0.017210578545928, -0.037175461649894714, 0.03576686605811119, 0.016732269898056984, -0.0018536192364990711, 0.006357231643050909, -0.04469573125243187, -0.0024730979930609465, 0.01193604152649641, 0.03697758540511131, 0.007385095115751028, 0.04536190256476402, -0.029663776978850365, 0.023951033130288124, 0.02642774023115635, 0.040153175592422485, 0.02068687602877617, 0.02968350611627102, -0.021978743374347687, -0.02340664528310299, -0.011835374869406223, 0.030655106529593468, 0.03287763148546219, 0.023491675034165382, -0.010879362933337688, 0.026291973888874054, 0.026677453890442848, -0.03885200247168541, 0.008762857876718044, 0.013691497035324574, -0.01800507865846157, 0.005663878284394741, -0.0386250764131546, -0.02227136306464672, -0.008207196369767189, 0.0003420947468839586, 0.030309047549962997, 0.004765329882502556, -0.0069305445067584515, -0.0021429669577628374, 0.06633038818836212, -0.002930985763669014, -0.017039474099874496, 0.003027619794011116, -0.045363619923591614, 0.014870589599013329, -0.024273715913295746, -0.03242134675383568, -0.021131619811058044, 0.04409867152571678, 0.02643304131925106, 0.004779968410730362, -0.0031341377180069685, -0.0755971223115921, -0.007463856600224972, 0.05676811933517456, 0.0395059809088707, -0.013081198558211327, 0.012108844704926014, 0.019066261127591133, -0.010604099370539188, 0.005851473659276962, -0.026408448815345764, 0.011549416929483414, 0.013503753580152988, 0.005062086973339319, -0.06307777762413025, -0.043881289660930634, -0.022239072248339653, 0.031039725989103317, 0.003851794172078371, 0.028593245893716812, -0.00820329412817955, -0.04335559532046318, -0.01989586092531681, -0.007596200332045555, 0.018696129322052002, 0.010232840664684772, -0.049328140914440155, -0.0030788881704211235, 0.025151412934064865, 0.014032266102731228, -0.03840295970439911, -0.034470949321985245, 0.00906966719776392, -0.006846545729786158, -0.025747772306203842, 0.044233597815036774, -0.023669973015785217, -0.03205641731619835, -0.0034033344127237797, -0.01937841810286045, 0.017391517758369446, -0.011463425122201443, -0.016025114804506302, 0.05711611360311508, 0.01135421171784401, 0.02685440331697464, 0.07862626016139984, 0.04724558815360069, 0.02007557637989521, -0.0017997268587350845, -0.03029748424887657, -0.01158660277724266, -0.040345609188079834, -0.012124869972467422, -0.017546547576785088, 0.003631702158600092, -0.007850265130400658, 0.05790603533387184, -0.02334366738796234, 0.04726797714829445, -0.04775891825556755, 0.012762129306793213, 0.024173760786652565, 0.006706970278173685, 0.012166153639554977, 0.0013451474951580167, -0.0013895855518057942, -0.018187493085861206, 0.0017000084044411778, -0.019439760595560074, 0.010479540564119816, -0.002010709373280406, -0.013230258598923683, 0.01662593148648739, -0.054520878940820694, 0.00982657354325056, -0.04033001884818077, -0.04022727161645889, 0.01247931644320488, -0.0176034364849329, 0.05635114759206772, -0.010595892556011677, 0.02103111520409584, -0.02363552339375019, -0.028133461251854897, -0.017669575288891792, 0.02035064809024334, -0.02338457480072975, 0.022313812747597694, -0.04667741060256958, 0.0384010411798954, -0.03722826763987541, 0.0099490936845541, -0.050519898533821106, -0.03590875491499901, 0.03687673807144165, -0.005459986161440611, 0.01404313649982214, -0.004795144312083721, -0.03701123967766762, 0.0008577587432228029, -0.008114781230688095, -0.03127705305814743, 0.08108863234519958, -0.016248255968093872, -0.007564961910247803, -0.002316051861271262, 0.05811581388115883, 0.08631494641304016, -0.004265241324901581, -0.012932385317981243, -0.017369739711284637, -0.0360412560403347, -0.024778325110673904, -0.032457880675792694, -0.005552180577069521, -0.03941969573497772, -0.019012220203876495, -0.01841667853295803, 0.018010225147008896, 0.05056937783956528, -0.029728857800364494, -0.01038583368062973, 0.03679285943508148, -0.023412415757775307, -0.002312246710062027, -0.06456597149372101, -0.00894336961209774, 0.01415526308119297, 0.007067741826176643, -0.018988776952028275, 0.013773388229310513, -0.011634711176156998, 0.014396192505955696, 0.007886577397584915, 0.0006265706033445895, -0.020172830671072006, 0.008552592247724533, 0.07431591302156448, -0.004786571953445673, -0.0014928934397175908, 0.007448726799339056, -0.02594190090894699, 0.01084048394113779, -0.02430855669081211, -0.004805760458111763, -0.015402277931571007, 0.01854678802192211, -0.054949745535850525, -0.028056522831320763, -0.02495993860065937, -0.026424232870340347, 0.055527929216623306, 0.014358390122652054, 0.023088589310646057, 0.061282142996788025, 0.008745132945477962, 0.012394721619784832, -0.004990344867110252, 0.01447283010929823, 0.003829716006293893, 0.04267239570617676, 0.07547274231910706, 0.001979667227715254, 0.03184744715690613, 0.03922609984874725, 0.026410510763525963, 0.010689775459468365, 0.06948045641183853, 0.016711261123418808, 0.017402326688170433, 0.019225768744945526, -0.016087157651782036, -0.045639291405677795, 0.05413762107491493, -0.07955772429704666, 0.010408527217805386, -0.08225131779909134, 0.004607389215379953, 0.05150671303272247, 0.07602903991937637, 0.012327748350799084, -0.04006725177168846, 0.012712347321212292, -0.061128489673137665, 0.011422398500144482, 0.01974472962319851, -0.00952885765582323, 0.014451712369918823, 0.011615067720413208, 0.08244901895523071, -0.04844724014401436, 0.026796596124768257, -0.011374257504940033, -0.05999375134706497, 0.012916773557662964, 0.014175641350448132, -0.01548160519450903, 0.056878551840782166, -0.0033657969906926155, -0.013921821489930153, -0.006152283865958452, -0.039493147283792496, 0.010918185114860535, 0.03146621212363243, 0.0365840345621109, -0.03233860805630684, 0.054610490798950195, -0.010987390764057636, 0.006080913357436657, -0.024932121858000755, 0.02446693927049637, 0.11257516592741013, 0.055513929575681686, 0.018631480634212494, -0.07313776016235352, 0.03358716517686844, -0.0075508709996938705, 0.016380203887820244, -0.012914488092064857, -0.011095966212451458, 0.007674416992813349, -0.008423969149589539, 0.03196633979678154, 0.04936104640364647, -0.02012915536761284, -0.021485282108187675, 0.05819219723343849, -0.011097073554992676, -0.004679032135754824, -0.0017842474626377225, 0.0008475962677039206, 0.030083060264587402, -0.022047698497772217, -0.015911178663372993, 0.004279458895325661, 0.011121468618512154, -0.00240012863650918, -0.03754647076129913, -0.013724940828979015, -0.02345655858516693, -0.00352305150590837, 0.01659609191119671, 0.025516672059893608, -0.009395509026944637, -0.016808727756142616, -0.05202481523156166, -0.014543125405907631, 0.0018157409504055977, -0.055972062051296234, 0.04867447912693024, 0.05820408836007118, 0.00376803707331419, -0.016094552353024483, 0.020525166764855385, 0.036861054599285126, -0.026841619983315468, -0.03481853008270264, -0.005429447628557682, 0.048886578530073166, -0.002108771586790681, -0.04627075046300888, -0.017351675778627396, 0.015765724703669548, -0.015452808700501919, -0.044783834367990494, -0.033878788352012634, 0.015797626227140427, 0.013159110210835934, -0.07522714138031006, -0.03166813775897026, -0.0031857008580118418, -0.011247712187469006, -0.012901268899440765, 0.030759822577238083, 0.023258183151483536, 0.018591491505503654, -0.027778849005699158, -0.04930700361728668, 0.025889577344059944, -0.0017315781442448497, -0.0009408470359630883, -0.005019466392695904, -0.0015691888984292746, -0.025308599695563316, 0.015682116150856018, -0.03720363229513168, 0.001020723721012473, 0.05272143334150314, 0.013011852279305458, -0.03788226842880249, 0.011044074781239033, -0.0303176436573267, 0.024499839171767235, -0.037486400455236435, 0.021977799013257027, 0.0033820720855146646, -0.01669475808739662, 0.043286364525556564, -0.003544814186170697, -0.018922265619039536, 0.03766348958015442, 0.0029571554623544216, 0.06904410570859909, 0.036077797412872314, -0.04835989326238632, -0.03967522084712982, -0.000059367950598243624, -0.031744107604026794, -0.0497748926281929, -0.02636888436973095, 0.04637384042143822, 0.00446348125115037, -0.0073114363476634026, 0.007646332029253244, 0.016894016414880753, -0.024288402870297432, 0.008077448233962059, 0.02254685014486313, -0.07450693845748901, 0.003940615337342024, 0.0023644347675144672, 0.03198206052184105, -0.022153036668896675, -0.056698791682720184, -0.005630479194223881, -0.012486943043768406, 0.021815313026309013, -0.042387910187244415, -0.014701676554977894, -0.00418130261823535, -0.035853464156389236, 0.03138921782374382, -0.028711780905723572, -0.004424551501870155, -0.04933882877230644, -0.03930382430553436, 0.01776299625635147, 0.04523004591464996, -0.004284320864826441, 0.027052853256464005, -0.00029658383573405445, -0.007631831802427769, 0.0645870640873909, 0.03236920386552811, 0.0018649229314178228, -0.0013012199196964502, -0.02010749839246273, -0.00012411002535372972, 0.01527094841003418, 0.02898791804909706, -0.05770660564303398, 0.053334031254053116, -0.049632683396339417, -0.027023177593946457, 0.009360686875879765, -0.011340533383190632, 0.008894972503185272, 0.009949354454874992, 0.006280564237385988, -0.025820288807153702, 0.025865567848086357, -0.03567701578140259, -0.03466704115271568, -0.03505765274167061, -0.021696148440241814, 0.006703707855194807, 0.017385302111506462, 0.030790111050009727, 0.03772474825382233, -0.016865244135260582, 0.011980435810983181, 0.0472659170627594, 0.008337855339050293, -0.02737368270754814, -0.0028844219632446766, -0.00015472350060008466, 0.012210464105010033, -0.02733762003481388, -0.006329216528683901, 0.033184975385665894, 0.07472240179777145, -0.03885685279965401, 0.023060686886310577, -0.06376931816339493, -0.02217593975365162, -0.0710461363196373, -0.005465141963213682, -0.026818742975592613, 0.025069914758205414, 0.029765987768769264, -0.06758038699626923, 0.0010609350865706801, 0.0009206515387631953, -0.031332697719335556, 0.02101743221282959, 0.011942122131586075, -0.04690401628613472, -0.032699186354875565, 0.01256753783673048, -0.02299472875893116, 0.016125300899147987, 0.0048311552964150906, 0.018249962478876114, -0.0022661215625703335, 0.03708108514547348, -0.007882979698479176, -0.029547132551670074, 0.005786743480712175, 0.009913415648043156, 0.06559561938047409, -0.05556100234389305, 0.022049108520150185, -0.03369995206594467, -0.020692037418484688, 0.0374239943921566, -0.025370392948389053, 0.028888892382383347, -0.009654429741203785, 0.02628742903470993, -0.021252112463116646, 0.05802405998110771, 0.03736886382102966, -0.0041589681059122086, 0.002676071599125862, -0.013006013818085194, 0.008146150968968868, 0.02067676931619644, -0.018590005114674568, 0.016522757709026337, 0.04207005351781845, 0.0038305071648210287, 0.009027192369103432, 0.029469851404428482, -0.013968040235340595, -0.01383606530725956, -0.0036980262957513332, -0.018037164583802223, 0.031146349385380745, 0.003329221159219742, -0.0001403205969836563, -0.00968585629016161, 0.028620058670639992, 0.040556780993938446, 0.012861079536378384, -0.005934129003435373, 0.029684053733944893, -0.007751856464892626, -0.020377403125166893, -0.005642070434987545, 0.005395864602178335, 0.010571937076747417, -0.053168222308158875, -0.018099645152688026, -0.011960878036916256, 0.016376692801713943, -0.014643910340964794, -0.014416411519050598, -0.028173189610242844, 0.002609784249216318, -0.04618941247463226, -0.019614320248365402, 0.005499240476638079, -0.011373707093298435, -0.016113940626382828, -0.06918063014745712, 0.06253818422555923, 0.039426472038030624, -0.016203179955482483, -0.06565878540277481, 0.017535464838147163, -0.047057367861270905, 0.007732491008937359, 0.08821076899766922, 0.025357220321893692, -0.0003309961757622659, -0.007692853454500437, 0.015483404509723186, -0.017368433997035027, -0.08049899339675903, 0.05004716292023659, -0.0028190468437969685, 0.033251333981752396, 0.010036175139248371, 0.01969822309911251, -0.012819183059036732, 0.0008791345171630383, 0.04107377305626869, -0.030034983530640602, 0.013837950304150581, -0.00934536848217249, -0.0024988690856844187, 0.04309280216693878, -0.009137356653809547, -0.04305102303624153, 0.01758182793855667, 0.02651846408843994, 0.0117022804915905, 0.015839502215385437, 0.006328905001282692, -0.029959898442029953, 0.04304364696145058, -0.05372204631567001, -0.029594140127301216, -0.006415707524865866, 0.0011727442033588886, 0.0007106715347617865, -0.08328744024038315, 0.0031716644298285246, 0.01867080293595791, -0.03621838241815567, 0.0020561933051794767, 0.05653486028313637, 0.07417256385087967, 0.006728827953338623, 0.012880828231573105, 0.02005385421216488, -0.02059587650001049, 0.0058043114840984344, 0.006395242642611265, 0.030484801158308983, 0.023678991943597794, 0.0027034389786422253, -0.01822967827320099, 0.012094332836568356, -0.013364297337830067, 0.04915790259838104, -0.01799987256526947, 0.04957748204469681, -0.002426415216177702, 0.0004916043253615499, 0.03264867141842842, -0.015540996566414833, -0.004749407060444355, 0.01111631840467453, 0.0025526888202875853, 0.06345527619123459, -0.044859498739242554, -0.0015781390247866511, -0.014050973579287529, -0.0005237350706011057, -0.051075465977191925, 0.003840482095256448, 0.026300005614757538, 0.026425449177622795, -0.014370232820510864, 0.013470299541950226, -0.012127218768000603, 0.014270350337028503, 0.010297109372913837, -0.022135000675916672, 0.04237566888332367, -0.009096364490687847, 0.02279241569340229, -0.04383166879415512, -0.03376312181353569, -0.017181409522891045, -0.031800977885723114, 0.025490285828709602, 0.018791889771819115, 0.03568602725863457, -0.035555146634578705, -0.028983505442738533, 0.023659974336624146, 0.04078046604990959, -0.06492272764444351, -0.06033090502023697, -0.015784161165356636, 0.016337471082806587, 0.004757567308843136, -0.02132398821413517 ]
<p>I have quarterly unbalanced Panel data and I want to de-trend my dependent variable to make it stationary. how do i do it? I don't want to take differences as it will shorten my observations. The residual series that I get after regressing my dependent variable on time trend does not remove unit root for data . It should be noted my independent variables are stationary? should I transform/detrend them as well.</p> <p>Also can I regress differences on levels in a panel data setting or all variables should be in the same order of integration?</p> <p>Would Hodrick prescott filter be a good choice for detrending quarterly observations? 2002q2 to 2013q4</p>
73,799
[ 0.005065279081463814, 0.01698768325150013, -0.0026336312294006348, 0.033657193183898926, 0.028361862525343895, -0.0013965152902528644, -0.006642991676926613, -0.02807389385998249, 0.03722822666168213, -0.030684275552630424, 0.0002046649024123326, 0.02178558148443699, 0.0496811680495739, 0.00264976778998971, 0.028038926422595978, -0.005386556964367628, 0.0045254346914589405, 0.0069193453527987, -0.015113530680537224, -0.028902849182486534, -0.033598870038986206, 0.027018247172236443, 0.012189827859401703, 0.02072697877883911, -0.04632691666483879, 0.04700915515422821, 0.020522791892290115, 0.011430622078478336, -0.025048138573765755, 0.04791500046849251, -0.048001743853092194, -0.012246256694197655, -0.006713082082569599, 0.009177005849778652, -0.049036502838134766, 0.006465600803494453, 0.01106258574873209, -0.019409285858273506, -0.0075386930257081985, 0.04019187390804291, -0.0485282801091671, 0.0074480739422142506, -0.0219553355127573, 0.0493638813495636, 0.013282069005072117, -0.014233808033168316, 0.019560707733035088, -0.02759845182299614, 0.04263295605778694, -0.034053314477205276, 0.06196826696395874, -0.026955699548125267, 0.025722607970237732, 0.03275741636753082, -0.03474593162536621, -0.008552155457437038, 0.060347478836774826, 0.06124056875705719, -0.02864033728837967, -0.04157852381467819, -0.022034604102373123, 0.0040956223383545876, 0.011814800091087818, -0.02178691141307354, -0.0424061119556427, 0.0373246967792511, -0.0047325375489890575, 0.01862052083015442, 0.032184161245822906, -0.044829294085502625, 0.013545658439397812, -0.004086516797542572, 0.037346433848142624, -0.021472180262207985, 0.008024884387850761, -0.049643103033304214, 0.015111098065972328, 0.026257449761033058, 0.03691302239894867, 0.06012667343020439, 0.015734488144516945, 0.01912548579275608, 0.028542106971144676, 0.035158999264240265, 0.04785627871751785, 0.0056297630071640015, 0.07061632722616196, -0.04205145686864853, 0.013667207211256027, 0.059908587485551834, -0.004876605700701475, -0.0014541482087224722, 0.06835351139307022, 0.0033847417216748, -0.04116605967283249, 0.02321893721818924, -0.01381080411374569, 0.052050016820430756, -0.002908251481130719, 0.0012968819355592132, -0.015438313595950603, -0.024814732372760773, 0.017710501328110695, 0.026640759781003, -0.011133451014757156, 0.03622537851333618, 0.007548181805759668, 0.015453742817044258, -0.014920351095497608, -0.04840310290455818, -0.036650072783231735, -0.014566616155207157, -0.01979503594338894, -0.04273582249879837, 0.029617715626955032, 0.03817470371723175, -0.01330435648560524, -0.017517702654004097, 0.039957333356142044, 0.07235101610422134, 0.011937739327549934, -0.012559054419398308, 0.028273124247789383, 0.014370573684573174, -0.07159275561571121, 0.00030012158094905317, -0.006087489891797304, 0.009054897353053093, -0.05708053335547447, 0.014668968506157398, 0.008146015927195549, -0.04058948904275894, 0.028165558353066444, 0.000422841141698882, 0.06072906404733658, 0.0400637611746788, -0.06753619015216827, -0.07493992149829865, 0.044195763766765594, -0.022174328565597534, 0.040970124304294586, -0.06805102527141571, 0.0024638508912175894, 0.009723958559334278, 0.04986461624503136, -0.0005734989535994828, 0.01283547654747963, 0.03292885422706604, 0.009132127277553082, 0.012369457632303238, -0.015247567556798458, -0.04506336525082588, -0.02536124922335148, -0.012474173679947853, 0.004171957727521658, -0.059999700635671616, 0.007878756150603294, 0.033106885850429535, -0.018655283376574516, 0.037930648773908615, 0.05024886131286621, 0.035792022943496704, -0.06219673901796341, 0.034112147986888885, 0.001917001442052424, -0.03669562563300133, 0.08579222112894058, -0.004770267754793167, 0.00050709507195279, -0.025340350344777107, -0.01949784718453884, 0.02907653898000717, 0.0013777600834146142, 0.05772239342331886, -0.00234205718152225, -0.011651898734271526, 0.010718499310314655, -0.0272357277572155, 0.0016702550929039717, 0.004363619722425938, -0.06343282014131546, -0.029415328055620193, -0.026349328458309174, -0.04433546960353851, 0.02025587111711502, 0.03981625661253929, -0.01948550157248974, -0.02034665457904339, 0.015553966164588928, -0.06589345633983612, -0.04454736039042473, -0.059216950088739395, 0.012282243929803371, 0.013525853864848614, 0.01773015782237053, 0.015456818044185638, -0.004976497497409582, 0.05149313807487488, -0.028770672157406807, -0.008236230351030827, 0.039733994752168655, 0.000787628348916769, 0.008755060844123363, -0.04955893009901047, 0.03514155000448227, 0.010408683679997921, 0.0840529352426529, 0.018722498789429665, 0.06821568310260773, -0.028989583253860474, -0.0054361047223210335, 0.014574240893125534, -0.05654307082295418, 0.03885490819811821, -0.04465768113732338, -0.018562592566013336, 0.013146570883691311, -0.033855535089969635, -0.033341359347105026, 0.02061977982521057, -0.022640390321612358, 0.05453195422887802, 0.03961892053484917, -0.014134454540908337, -0.008184309117496014, 0.005274882074445486, -0.0011514986399561167, 0.0442509725689888, -0.019018298014998436, -0.0027071477379649878, -0.04688195884227753, -0.024027392268180847, 0.014377637766301632, 0.011866667307913303, -0.057549506425857544, 0.03784160315990448, 0.08347471803426743, -0.009084150195121765, 0.01485931035131216, 0.026981564238667488, 0.009283836930990219, -0.009212185628712177, 0.02590824104845524, -0.02249118685722351, -0.015026502311229706, 0.0033545847982168198, 0.02731442078948021, -0.024040140211582184, 0.03557959198951721, 0.007078772410750389, 0.013173836283385754, 0.05486035346984863, 0.03934047743678093, 0.02058505453169346, -0.015369817614555359, -0.05868413299322128, 0.05200941860675812, 0.007531008217483759, 0.006480519659817219, 0.01991426944732666, 0.022973548620939255, -0.009293844923377037, 0.041200537234544754, -0.001579960691742599, 0.009456652216613293, 0.0057496544905006886, -0.03692060336470604, 0.013081640936434269, 0.018361935392022133, -0.03357870876789093, 0.05145376920700073, -0.041185472160577774, -0.021475639194250107, -0.053780313581228256, -0.016042793169617653, 0.037578899413347244, 0.017180627211928368, 0.007825775071978569, -0.007287757471203804, 0.0028487066738307476, -0.010105480439960957, -0.01686614751815796, 0.015983466058969498, -0.007651388179510832, -0.037898819893598557, -0.002470585983246565, -0.012269647791981697, -0.05842692032456398, 0.02904944121837616, 0.006108222529292107, 0.041384465992450714, 0.06429197639226913, -0.0010115305194631219, -0.03583241626620293, -0.060061264783144, -0.008574404753744602, 0.027165332809090614, -0.02800155244767666, -0.0430295467376709, 0.03786933049559593, -0.0327705442905426, 0.015534966252744198, -0.020657585933804512, -0.05704802647233009, -0.010209429077804089, -0.00027791305910795927, 0.00632853526622057, 0.01022794097661972, 0.019634492695331573, 0.01344760786741972, -0.02704676240682602, -0.02043551206588745, 0.02083820477128029, -0.04137365147471428, -0.04730141535401344, 0.0383688360452652, 0.005715410225093365, 0.035356223583221436, 0.014733482152223587, -0.05828923359513283, 0.05955585092306137, 0.027912722900509834, -0.01203847024589777, -0.020673071965575218, -0.02566199004650116, -0.02948523685336113, -0.07588663697242737, 0.021120918914675713, 0.03768511489033699, 0.0241576936095953, 0.034514687955379486, -0.03695610910654068, 0.03672536090016365, 0.03688142076134682, 0.025846201926469803, -0.03233005851507187, -0.005249476991593838, -0.030102424323558807, -0.005143920425325632, 0.016426827758550644, -0.022806541994214058, -0.012838903814554214, 0.011866210028529167, 0.018703870475292206, 0.03246069699525833, 0.012058204039931297, -0.022792736068367958, 0.049373794347047806, 0.012010034173727036, -0.009948940947651863, -0.03616512939333916, 0.03921082988381386, 0.019209980964660645, -0.010244478471577168, -0.047980524599552155, -0.03578891232609749, 0.010812582448124886, 0.006725961808115244, 0.009958448819816113, 0.027735510841012, 0.02302371896803379, -0.007454232778400183, 0.010681736283004284, -0.02976185642182827, -0.016142280772328377, 0.0354374460875988, -0.0042577097192406654, -0.04614322632551193, 0.06365969032049179, 0.01552752684801817, 0.011315908282995224, 0.0073597063310444355, -0.06472498178482056, -0.004436945542693138, -0.08030010759830475, 0.03281426802277565, 0.010486561805009842, 0.07502585649490356, 0.004090658389031887, 0.034493546932935715, 0.04359422251582146, -0.0032109308522194624, 0.010122369043529034, -0.007352106273174286, -0.05263284221291542, 0.057087358087301254, -0.03200705721974373, -0.01276451162993908, -0.0006980301695875823, -0.003546006279066205, 0.014968867413699627, -0.025961004197597504, 0.008946970105171204, 0.009959293529391289, 0.01900462992489338, -0.021065574139356613, -0.02540775015950203, -0.007463501766324043, -0.017500601708889008, -0.010649643838405609, -0.009403304196894169, 0.02814348042011261, -0.052679382264614105, 0.010206177830696106, 0.0365365631878376, 0.007855458185076714, 0.01525783445686102, -0.026015305891633034, -0.0039044031873345375, 0.028843242675065994, 0.033611733466386795, 0.04221038147807121, -0.002219240181148052, -0.018598999828100204, 0.022185655310750008, 0.030211111530661583, 0.023045234382152557, 0.007481171749532223, 0.0007218809914775193, -0.027429936453700066, -0.018325401470065117, 0.002065594308078289, 0.015955334529280663, 0.0403931550681591, 0.019193291664123535, 0.01525967475026846, 0.041961994022130966, 0.008539574220776558, -0.05091368779540062, 0.019389837980270386, 0.08410650491714478, 0.03596613183617592, 0.016311613842844963, -0.029887253418564796, -0.030405620113015175, 0.026356341317296028, 0.008442155085504055, 0.05198975279927254, 0.017384566366672516, -0.01452583633363247, -0.006676824297755957, 0.01750819943845272, -0.006776029709726572, -0.01899896375834942, 0.012255458161234856, 0.01289982907474041, 0.06923225522041321, -0.015559895895421505, -0.026310959830880165, 0.044903770089149475, 0.04419716075062752, 0.04278658330440521, 0.05993102118372917, 0.023134658113121986, -0.10486554354429245, 0.03294225409626961, 0.049070246517658234, 0.03066437877714634, -0.04177100583910942, -0.0091624204069376, -0.06632158905267715, -0.014982794411480427, 0.029968276619911194, -0.03696144372224808, 0.0005802158848382533, -0.03226232901215553, 0.007732232566922903, 0.010297590866684914, -0.023527376353740692, -0.05247332155704498, 0.046670056879520416, 0.006555463187396526, 0.06339693069458008, -0.015772651880979538, -0.06730585545301437, -0.0371725969016552, 0.013319612480700016, -0.009129607118666172, 0.03954355791211128, -0.003048326587304473, 0.01623939909040928, 0.02093966118991375, 0.017544005066156387, -0.020774682983756065, -0.05278196558356285, -0.023777132853865623, 0.0007466711685992777, -0.000748187187127769, 0.03321564197540283, 0.005735051352530718, -0.03257712349295616, -0.042437002062797546, -0.0005247107474133372, 0.026925843209028244, 0.019062811508774757, -0.05241744965314865, 0.06004364788532257, 0.0043527595698833466, 0.015770910307765007, 0.05322878435254097, 0.03775077313184738, -0.00012373921344988048, 0.013775586150586605, -0.01662437990307808, 0.04381103813648224, -0.06750613451004028, -0.021965550258755684, -0.029335424304008484, -0.0313592329621315, -0.021484915167093277, 0.024322694167494774, 0.024477072060108185, 0.011845207773149014, -0.012281232513487339, 0.0041015492752194405, 0.006693773902952671, 0.03126288577914238, -0.004864600487053394, -0.004283379763364792, 0.03408372029662132, -0.012788679450750351, -0.036098990589380264, -0.008824458345770836, -0.016674179583787918, 0.006724126636981964, 0.013504545204341412, -0.002872256562113762, -0.019395362585783005, 0.019598377868533134, -0.0016641159309074283, -0.018081601709127426, -0.004244942218065262, 0.005274335853755474, 0.02549162320792675, -0.018333900719881058, 0.02249855548143387, -0.01411557849496603, -0.05417024344205856, 0.006253607105463743, 0.02151709608733654, -0.014500556513667107, 0.038896411657333374, -0.06971234083175659, 0.07145912200212479, -0.0005394877516664565, -0.019303640350699425, -0.07280363142490387, -0.06278038769960403, -0.00813183095306158, 0.009669133462011814, -0.0054344963282346725, -0.03386761248111725, 0.01735568791627884, -0.03441159054636955, -0.03383224830031395, -0.036315083503723145, 0.05266329273581505, -0.01004298310726881, -0.016574613749980927, -0.0028414849657565355, 0.03649497777223587, 0.08688309043645859, -0.0470612570643425, -0.012886129319667816, 0.0019807007629424334, -0.04618588462471962, -0.03621680662035942, -0.04320022836327553, 0.023797929286956787, -0.026127392426133156, 0.016490956768393517, -0.019167829304933548, -0.018149007111787796, 0.057599715888500214, -0.035532332956790924, -0.0192930456250906, 0.027560574933886528, 0.019556019455194473, -0.037630174309015274, -0.023442262783646584, 0.03655846044421196, -0.040223170071840286, 0.014837080612778664, -0.009795712307095528, 0.024730823934078217, 0.00032445145188830793, -0.06771201640367508, 0.013094709254801273, 0.0019004014320671558, -0.013426964171230793, 0.013879362493753433, 0.044471703469753265, -0.01087387464940548, -0.00117568823043257, 0.004457106348127127, 0.03297215700149536, 0.0389629602432251, -0.006589088588953018, 0.026787659153342247, -0.0312855988740921, -0.008225002326071262, -0.013572752475738525, -0.04346271604299545, -0.01698828488588333, -0.0011406514095142484, 0.05752306431531906, 0.007109953090548515, 0.029213763773441315, 0.05261901393532753, 0.03300943970680237, 0.0008716654847376049, -0.04255368933081627, 0.014619933441281319, -0.014199962839484215, -0.02743236906826496, 0.03539225831627846, 0.009700343944132328, 0.019211480394005775, 0.01000615581870079, -0.009767528623342514, 0.02162562496960163, 0.04561999812722206, 0.01262827217578888, 0.020076140761375427, 0.0047155567444860935, -0.02418920397758484, -0.031235193833708763, 0.005123346112668514, -0.037822261452674866, 0.030594894662499428, -0.03865773603320122, -0.02276201732456684, 0.029423033818602562, 0.04248318076133728, -0.005748228169977665, -0.052007514983415604, -0.01176778506487608, -0.05411569029092789, 0.033943966031074524, 0.027714256197214127, -0.0010885110823437572, 0.0287900660187006, 0.03699606657028198, 0.05431545525789261, -0.002568385098129511, 0.030773308128118515, -0.02291540615260601, -0.05159356817603111, -0.0030615271534770727, -0.07207540422677994, -0.010544512420892715, 0.029778562486171722, -0.022714292630553246, -0.024997159838676453, 0.003460013074800372, -0.04076426476240158, -0.006816451903432608, -0.0030100387521088123, 0.0290239080786705, 0.007018558215349913, 0.08294802904129028, -0.007657324895262718, 0.014841237105429173, -0.018751854076981544, 0.005956281907856464, 0.11610888689756393, 0.06263382732868195, 0.049407124519348145, -0.07018101215362549, 0.020936228334903717, -0.004187076818197966, -0.0006660032668150961, -0.05006278306245804, 0.010087789036333561, -0.014940960332751274, -0.0008120209677144885, 0.03710918873548508, 0.07114236801862717, 0.013329558074474335, 0.007271529641002417, 0.0420980229973793, 0.00021533004473894835, 0.023305824026465416, -0.014061319641768932, 0.042884524911642075, 0.009741813875734806, 0.012584242969751358, -0.06664875894784927, 0.013100584037601948, -0.04001554101705551, -0.019124917685985565, -0.026096085086464882, -0.02044009417295456, -0.023804154247045517, -0.002074497053399682, -0.020489107817411423, -0.018735229969024658, 0.00994784850627184, 0.006972994189709425, -0.011234022676944733, -0.005357888527214527, 0.011656703427433968, -0.038480035960674286, 0.04697031527757645, 0.016550244763493538, -0.0002448881568852812, -0.0038426313549280167, -0.011309480294585228, -0.013397629372775555, -0.018353965133428574, -0.00831725262105465, -0.026571352034807205, 0.01914156600832939, 0.016119999811053276, -0.07776807248592377, 0.008405941538512707, -0.0031943595968186855, -0.0006209183484315872, -0.054466985166072845, -0.02474210411310196, 0.028781116008758545, 0.021906515583395958, -0.04960541054606438, -0.024807963520288467, -0.04626697674393654, 0.011946935206651688, -0.0012419491540640593, 0.038373153656721115, 0.004164771642535925, -0.03263593465089798, -0.01967254839837551, -0.019459042698144913, 0.027726847678422928, -0.02323995716869831, -0.011355847120285034, 0.002999713644385338, -0.0031296515371650457, -0.028546210378408432, -0.01863115467131138, 0.031060850247740746, 0.025415051728487015, -0.03130338340997696, -0.012492131441831589, 0.014810687862336636, -0.013346010819077492, -0.0524083711206913, 0.05016356334090233, -0.018868446350097656, 0.019744226709008217, -0.03011477179825306, 0.01855853945016861, 0.042801447212696075, 0.039304301142692566, -0.0029118843376636505, -0.0039598955772817135, -0.01864207722246647, 0.06298930943012238, 0.04842926561832428, -0.05673118308186531, -0.019575223326683044, -0.02463144063949585, -0.012748917564749718, -0.02648518607020378, -0.003968499135226011, 0.03463975712656975, 0.03985774517059326, -0.02838217094540596, -0.04312768578529358, 0.03370664268732071, -0.03381692245602608, 0.04064594954252243, 0.052386149764060974, -0.07070726156234741, -0.024131327867507935, 0.04933425039052963, -0.016842100769281387, -0.015960782766342163, -0.03031177446246147, 0.0004200266266707331, -0.003998052794486284, -0.022528110072016716, -0.008428262546658516, -0.05644790083169937, 0.05224209651350975, -0.004110727924853563, 0.06466527283191681, -0.044767338782548904, -0.0182855986058712, -0.041189294308423996, -0.011890626512467861, -0.008133819326758385, -0.018204867839813232, -0.011879629455506802, 0.026739835739135742, -0.03321700915694237, -0.0004670525959227234, 0.040863048285245895, 0.013681890442967415, 0.029125738888978958, 0.02257647179067135, 0.01964511163532734, -0.0258770938962698, -0.00002373060124227777, -0.022194501012563705, -0.046423472464084625, 0.0015462697483599186, -0.012650508433580399, -0.013117904774844646, -0.013848058879375458, -0.004097784869372845, 0.024196675047278404, 0.00625237450003624, 0.0021789248567074537, -0.008689195849001408, 0.025284359231591225, -0.01014944538474083, 0.005748712457716465, -0.030352754518389702, -0.001645630574785173, 0.018581019714474678, -0.019735144451260567, 0.022620026022195816, 0.013442081399261951, -0.02017052099108696, 0.02942228689789772, 0.05293003097176552, 0.025227047502994537, -0.01122003048658371, -0.006843829993158579, -0.02259461022913456, 0.016384536400437355, 0.03453421592712402, -0.0029033145401626825, 0.02274719625711441, 0.0540132075548172, -0.02408704161643982, -0.031913816928863525, -0.04371459782123566, -0.005810413043946028, -0.052015360444784164, -0.012455189600586891, 0.01108182780444622, -0.025358235463500023, 0.053592365235090256, -0.021322807297110558, -0.0014178036944940686, 0.026807304471731186, -0.013595844618976116, 0.012794539332389832, -0.019712423905730247, -0.005819003097712994, -0.00967717170715332, 0.016913769766688347, 0.037872977554798126, 0.020160766318440437, 0.03132452815771103, -0.00529003981500864, -0.013311944901943207, 0.030011838302016258, 0.02641717530786991, -0.025235388427972794, 0.008063050918281078, -0.019451312720775604, 0.03751443699002266, -0.054899971932172775, 0.02283131331205368, -0.05655832961201668, -0.01000993698835373, 0.06228700652718544, -0.04789207503199577, 0.026836268603801727, -0.009045970626175404, 0.011239157058298588, -0.014022665098309517, 0.042555417865514755, 0.02878342568874359, 0.007310566026717424, 0.0029594600200653076, -0.014182261191308498, 0.034049153327941895, 0.028020743280649185, 0.007267555221915245, 0.011356662027537823, -0.0028885744977742434, -0.03494865819811821, 0.020418770611286163, -0.009659543633460999, -0.017271483317017555, 0.0158523116260767, -0.023415807634592056, 0.018359612673521042, 0.020165443420410156, 0.005788588896393776, 0.040603455156087875, -0.01394116971641779, -0.011471155099570751, 0.03276955336332321, -0.015382437035441399, -0.038551945239305496, -0.001155609730631113, 0.012479347176849842, -0.022422384470701218, 0.020995870232582092, -0.011562575586140156, -0.02786819078028202, -0.06827155500650406, 0.0050707124173641205, 0.0029007454868406057, -0.03643957898020744, -0.07134920358657837, -0.013402634300291538, 0.0019710222259163857, 0.04229188710451126, 0.0025806608609855175, 0.006514204200357199, -0.009695920161902905, -0.022839339450001717, 0.002634650794789195, -0.064970962703228, 0.05600793659687042, 0.019862694665789604, -0.03157634660601616, 0.0065218801610171795, -0.037401195615530014, -0.06014307588338852, 0.006565929856151342, 0.05133451148867607, -0.00860019214451313, 0.022536711767315865, 0.019469385966658592, -0.025228116661310196, -0.004406705964356661, -0.030093418434262276, 0.04604122415184975, -0.0248161181807518, -0.015593701973557472, 0.010719941928982735, -0.02913062460720539, 0.02638745680451393, 0.003111148253083229, 0.022777190431952477, -0.007949164137244225, 0.005888605955988169, 0.040671829134225845, -0.01362530142068863, 0.037726666778326035, -0.021279677748680115, -0.015983182936906815, 0.049573589116334915, -0.006135037634521723, 0.013751964084804058, 0.033088669180870056, 0.01326462347060442, -0.03846414387226105, -0.0021662041544914246, -0.05088905617594719, -0.03496334329247475, -0.024537697434425354, 0.012423328123986721, 0.013370133005082607, -0.05345816910266876, 0.05469018220901489, 0.02847178466618061, -0.011104107834398746, 0.031885985285043716, 0.029333489015698433, -0.0131704555824399, 0.01457932684570551, 0.012401294894516468, -0.011672766879200935, 0.010986920446157455, 0.024245645850896835, 0.043537307530641556, 0.026717351749539375, -0.01787349209189415, -0.0013709885533899069, 0.005445861257612705, 0.01644267328083515, -0.01820317842066288, 0.01583521068096161, -0.03942098841071129, 0.024803413078188896, -0.014122520573437214, -0.03544679284095764, -0.00023246191267389804, 0.0038533429615199566, 0.020854011178016663, 0.062474869191646576, 0.002351144328713417, 0.02159447781741619, -0.025386203080415726, -0.01688467711210251, -0.02790868654847145, -0.01182952243834734, -0.011263182386755943, 0.008470425382256508, 0.03025699593126774, 0.03340792655944824, -0.01717180758714676, 0.03209851682186127, 0.015228097327053547, -0.005077684763818979, -0.035413458943367004, -0.011172831058502197, 0.005609037820249796, -0.020547645166516304, -0.009128224104642868, -0.004593001678586006, -0.028002850711345673, -0.06620801240205765, -0.04427489638328552, 0.006685980595648289, 0.06018436327576637, 0.01850176975131035, -0.0007867766544222832, -0.00390326208434999, 0.0046849362552165985, 0.020898394286632538, -0.05551725625991821, -0.026652196422219276, -0.01026864629238844, -0.01674574241042137, -0.023960528895258904, -0.022947469726204872 ]
<p>Can someone please provide examples of labelled and unlabelled data? I have been reading definitions of semi supervised learning but it does not make clear on what the two actually are.</p>
73,800
[ -0.012903481721878052, -0.047309041023254395, -0.010533949360251427, -0.010694560594856739, 0.036817848682403564, 0.0017688330262899399, 0.0005489315371960402, -0.018733832985162735, 0.027997532859444618, -0.022974884137511253, 0.025155693292617798, 0.025121474638581276, 0.028637275099754333, 0.021019065752625465, 0.010196718387305737, 0.012444048188626766, -0.0011141407303512096, 0.0012279226211830974, -0.018173938617110252, 0.008756408467888832, 0.010169587098062038, -0.015347075648605824, 0.022717298939824104, 0.016306141391396523, -0.01370957400649786, 0.008381282910704613, 0.0115054277703166, -0.020638741552829742, 0.04185676574707031, 0.0367991141974926, -0.01550711877644062, -0.023929757997393608, -0.02597600780427456, -0.00157736346591264, 0.018799832090735435, -0.012761426158249378, -0.03716424107551575, -0.027908574789762497, -0.02382800169289112, 0.010646858252584934, -0.05487580597400665, -0.0431060865521431, 0.022371316328644753, 0.029888074845075607, -0.009485266171395779, 0.016880834475159645, 0.0034950824920088053, -0.0519697368144989, 0.007602483034133911, -0.040624912828207016, 0.059305340051651, -0.03629389777779579, 0.04249155893921852, 0.03517978638410568, -0.008360444568097591, 0.029749728739261627, 0.07264421880245209, 0.056280072778463364, -0.01343601755797863, -0.04888544976711273, -0.05173872783780098, -0.012923681177198887, -0.008969425223767757, -0.03750348463654518, -0.0478639081120491, 0.04003015160560608, 0.01966496743261814, -0.006352187599986792, 0.047490812838077545, 0.004070584662258625, -0.008388088084757328, 0.01394963450729847, 0.041707348078489304, -0.0036887729074805975, -0.003699406748637557, 0.015050885267555714, 0.025881575420498848, 0.014131561852991581, 0.033417198807001114, 0.011281515471637249, 0.03762711584568024, 0.024077532812952995, 0.022290436550974846, 0.007462309207767248, 0.008270680904388428, -0.02359236776828766, 0.06704424321651459, 0.001094478415325284, 0.014374662190675735, 0.012677023187279701, 0.00040070241084322333, -0.007916513830423355, 0.035721249878406525, -0.024832990020513535, -0.06277051568031311, 0.03235514089465141, -0.004068081732839346, 0.037618834525346756, -0.019816698506474495, -0.053206667304039, 0.013843696564435959, -0.0427992008626461, 0.021197689697146416, 0.05386347323656082, -0.03869708254933357, -0.03340768814086914, -0.009587649255990982, 0.012435411103069782, -0.0016089563723653555, -0.002943845000118017, -0.013239075429737568, 0.0270073264837265, 0.041112590581178665, 0.008387234061956406, 0.011460436508059502, -0.004575447179377079, -0.016411522403359413, 0.00013018192839808762, -0.00027561080059967935, 0.08592935651540756, 0.06076395511627197, -0.05561935901641846, 0.012745413929224014, -0.00029926098068244755, -0.06721533089876175, 0.0023728120140731335, 0.049649279564619064, -0.022699972614645958, -0.04622616618871689, 0.047128014266490936, -0.029076021164655685, -0.008005918003618717, 0.03393646329641342, -0.027024736627936363, 0.010917850770056248, -0.015029922127723694, -0.050191424787044525, -0.06106036528944969, 0.02130615897476673, 0.010934092104434967, 0.023313408717513084, -0.04286199063062668, 0.03401878476142883, 0.02251490205526352, 0.020208053290843964, 0.031600043177604675, 0.02816910669207573, 0.027161980047822, -0.015215069055557251, 0.023900654166936874, -0.009271054528653622, 0.016629287973046303, -0.00192177202552557, -0.01007519569247961, -0.017749134451150894, -0.055183324962854385, 0.012512899935245514, 0.009367420338094234, -0.0009774700738489628, -0.06092170998454094, 0.03307398036122322, -0.03290622681379318, 0.005210038740187883, 0.010935243219137192, -0.007542481180280447, -0.04281868785619736, 0.0794624611735344, 0.014001505449414253, 0.06710939854383469, 0.06810600310564041, 0.003119516186416149, 0.05019054561853409, 0.04020078480243683, 0.04236624762415886, 0.04483911022543907, 0.002055567456409335, -0.05179840698838234, 0.003590888576582074, 0.03709614276885986, 0.005144057795405388, -0.02903101220726967, -0.0323607362806797, -0.01244873832911253, 0.032419681549072266, -0.0019103470258414745, 0.029028819873929024, 0.036356572061777115, -0.029358481988310814, 0.044014234095811844, -0.08411584794521332, -0.01789749599993229, -0.03160608932375908, 0.007473543751984835, -0.04088902473449707, 0.007664413191378117, 0.044896017760038376, -0.0002636746794451028, -0.017878292128443718, -0.047930795699357986, -0.03628986328840256, -0.03877115994691849, 0.002834724960848689, 0.02452263981103897, -0.0662880539894104, 0.011324247345328331, 0.029192199930548668, -0.0066811442375183105, 0.013075506314635277, 0.06388501077890396, -0.058313336223363876, -0.051021937280893326, -0.012811791151762009, -0.03516235947608948, 0.011069877073168755, -0.026901429519057274, 0.01454667467623949, 0.006152729969471693, -0.005683941766619682, -0.032758038491010666, 0.01344269048422575, -0.05471787974238396, 0.06128280237317085, 0.03807138651609421, -0.008718389086425304, -0.02859954908490181, -0.02707008086144924, 0.019119463860988617, 0.021173130720853806, -0.03107711672782898, -0.013504063710570335, -0.049449242651462555, -0.01985337771475315, 0.08652208745479584, 0.023856068029999733, -0.008894012309610844, -0.026365363970398903, 0.02417372539639473, 0.02466125227510929, 0.02397063933312893, 0.013425218872725964, -0.05049705505371094, -0.011052707210183144, 0.025430403649806976, 0.031791482120752335, 0.009017694741487503, -0.007270479574799538, 0.0013821061002090573, -0.004131080117076635, 0.030917169526219368, 0.014223223552107811, -0.023759059607982635, 0.08024365454912186, -0.052963241934776306, -0.006014288403093815, 0.013669656589627266, -0.023225652053952217, 0.04641728103160858, -0.054717790335416794, -0.0007757135899737477, 0.011421267874538898, -0.0033812588080763817, -0.020279156044125557, 0.014510121196508408, -0.009713852778077126, 0.042107511311769485, 0.013647076673805714, -0.018080323934555054, 0.026143059134483337, 0.03358372673392296, -0.04996766149997711, 0.021216418594121933, -0.012602690607309341, -0.017595956102013588, -0.02209872379899025, -0.0003911324602086097, 0.054478809237480164, -0.0067257932387292385, 0.03525932878255844, -0.04007560759782791, -0.02975689433515072, -0.015753798186779022, -0.06948740035295486, 0.04043292626738548, 0.022646749392151833, -0.04517216235399246, 0.04103032127022743, -0.020615924149751663, -0.03231339156627655, 0.04652423784136772, -0.01979919709265232, -0.022718017920851707, -0.00033956891275011003, -0.03875192999839783, -0.0009504238842055202, -0.04384668543934822, -0.0463130846619606, 0.03150024265050888, -0.0029583824798464775, 0.01763838529586792, 0.022184165194630623, -0.0006221209769137204, -0.05164273828268051, 0.0029486462008208036, -0.03926323726773262, -0.03785219043493271, -0.03787762299180031, -0.0069022830575704575, 0.025915855541825294, -0.010149615816771984, 0.010373713448643684, 0.032641615718603134, -0.030773546546697617, -0.003836716990917921, -0.02393864095211029, -0.03336215764284134, 0.05721856653690338, -0.000053417727031046525, -0.02988312393426895, 0.008886316791176796, 0.0014774128794670105, 0.05594224855303764, 0.03158068284392357, -0.024534055963158607, -0.011896000243723392, 0.012878596782684326, -0.03891447186470032, -0.001631401595659554, -0.02196846529841423, -0.01301895547658205, 0.011175870895385742, 0.01246791984885931, 0.031641073524951935, 0.04573944956064224, 0.03190373629331589, 0.021685734391212463, -0.005141088739037514, 0.0356883704662323, 0.009883858263492584, 0.011483957059681416, 0.03882981836795807, 0.038937490433454514, -0.07922689616680145, 0.004698900505900383, 0.002277560066431761, 0.02841743640601635, 0.013624859973788261, -0.004055630415678024, 0.04847467318177223, -0.008142600767314434, 0.04256909713149071, -0.010359077714383602, 0.03371841087937355, 0.025391310453414917, 0.00030031954520381987, 0.004177148453891277, 0.01126850862056017, 0.022771285846829414, -0.03562868386507034, 0.013058771379292011, 0.05893877148628235, 0.05242195352911949, -0.02130296267569065, -0.006840571761131287, 0.008304261602461338, -0.022779280319809914, 0.03488149121403694, -0.0017664988990873098, -0.024425534531474113, 0.03904880955815315, 0.04265899211168289, 0.010311502031981945, 0.013021818362176418, -0.015883641317486763, 0.021982988342642784, -0.07016485184431076, 0.008605974726378918, -0.028862029314041138, 0.014155342243611813, 0.01922428607940674, 0.038250770419836044, -0.005394932348281145, -0.012310468591749668, -0.028700005263090134, 0.038786664605140686, -0.058511968702077866, 0.023502865806221962, -0.045028142631053925, -0.011218302883207798, -0.002712419955059886, 0.008589380420744419, 0.026410017162561417, -0.018993226811289787, 0.00979187898337841, 0.0010228680912405252, 0.0012050928780809045, -0.0598524808883667, 0.000662211503367871, -0.018734710291028023, -0.0018500367878004909, -0.03706924617290497, -0.04363848641514778, -0.02728169411420822, 0.0056008752435445786, 0.00994036067277193, 0.021555008366703987, -0.001416331622749567, 0.0035370599944144487, -0.032660048454999924, -0.004756011068820953, 0.0250741858035326, 0.029136033728718758, 0.00925371889024973, 0.0548948273062706, -0.046544477343559265, 0.048467498272657394, 0.00978093035519123, 0.05100889503955841, 0.009458568878471851, -0.02704346366226673, -0.04403993859887123, -0.07189134508371353, -0.03996511548757553, 0.021248573437333107, 0.029087133705615997, -0.005911204032599926, 0.02030141092836857, 0.035186223685741425, -0.013166427612304688, -0.05674980580806732, 0.014735259115695953, 0.07526488602161407, 0.01861385628581047, 0.0028776652179658413, -0.024964647367596626, -0.014323275536298752, -0.0039054041262716055, -0.001074487459845841, 0.04279787465929985, 0.014673387631773949, 0.020877650007605553, 0.00042699070763774216, 0.009179843589663506, 0.004138599149882793, -0.0306100957095623, -0.019098270684480667, 0.023051505908370018, 0.02069324068725109, 0.0018180736806243658, -0.03976086899638176, 0.014349479228258133, 0.04180043563246727, 0.07111243903636932, 0.039126574993133545, -0.006455213762819767, -0.07750701159238815, 0.025419823825359344, 0.07787258177995682, 0.023634113371372223, -0.0026297965086996555, -0.03781775385141373, -0.009286658838391304, -0.005670325364917517, 0.007132685277611017, -0.005813111085444689, 0.010335579514503479, -0.03635063394904137, 0.0051622167229652405, -0.0038717358838766813, -0.015767252072691917, -0.006514441687613726, 0.007284923922270536, -0.005851977039128542, 0.05837829038500786, -0.008753208443522453, -0.06641615182161331, -0.05569218844175339, -0.0010716421529650688, -0.007553616538643837, 0.06942971795797348, -0.012827020138502121, -0.016841940581798553, 0.026697330176830292, 0.033367060124874115, -0.025944096967577934, -0.06866399198770523, -0.01424461416900158, 0.03889487311244011, -0.0025284828152507544, 0.06053240969777107, -0.022642716765403748, -0.07358131557703018, 0.013013034127652645, -0.010412672534584999, -0.04748423397541046, 0.007444920018315315, -0.0017670326633378863, 0.011189769953489304, 0.01718258298933506, 0.000030171144317137077, 0.07138444483280182, 0.017490137368440628, 0.03340569883584976, -0.022542988881468773, -0.018295112997293472, 0.053066857159137726, -0.04915979132056236, -0.01414485089480877, -0.03405827656388283, 0.0004727373889181763, -0.01787504367530346, 0.03880123794078827, -0.006614303681999445, 0.03131977096199989, -0.04055064544081688, -0.041589975357055664, -0.029298098757863045, 0.003972048871219158, 0.011419537477195263, -0.03854432329535484, -0.02468719705939293, 0.02055833302438259, -0.025562774389982224, 0.002912562806159258, 0.00261948280967772, -0.025624411180615425, 0.0045871734619140625, -0.004851927515119314, -0.024495352059602737, 0.0021439685951918364, -0.023911528289318085, -0.02470467798411846, 0.027463426813483238, -0.00952647253870964, 0.04251139983534813, -0.008379512466490269, 0.01724846288561821, -0.014385038986802101, -0.0904998853802681, -0.027382662519812584, 0.01962685026228428, 0.0003106655494775623, 0.026769619435071945, -0.05995688959956169, 0.03104558028280735, 0.006593584083020687, -0.02084953524172306, -0.062194716185331345, -0.0589747428894043, 0.031023850664496422, 0.00561631191521883, -0.029682261869311333, 0.015741389244794846, 0.0324566625058651, -0.0202697291970253, -0.05702747404575348, 0.004568906966596842, 0.061407897621393204, -0.05905376747250557, -0.010151345282793045, -0.004778788425028324, 0.011420476250350475, 0.01699683628976345, 0.0015129855601117015, -0.011905448511242867, -0.005778421647846699, 0.017874857410788536, -0.0010916033061221242, -0.003981279209256172, 0.013998160138726234, -0.03288732096552849, 0.012327048927545547, -0.04318712651729584, 0.0010082228109240532, 0.03453536704182625, -0.05763106048107147, 0.013257659040391445, 0.01584082469344139, 0.018350381404161453, -0.027378404513001442, -0.018326086923480034, -0.006630198564380407, -0.019757216796278954, -0.014003677293658257, -0.013881418853998184, 0.03194655850529671, 0.021419398486614227, -0.014098888263106346, 0.061401739716529846, 0.026895899325609207, 0.03550363704562187, 0.027271704748272896, 0.04814726114273071, 0.007834291085600853, -0.001437002094462514, 0.008597270585596561, -0.0014738839818164706, 0.0037179540377110243, -0.012470095418393612, 0.04701372608542442, 0.01967674307525158, 0.0418204590678215, -0.01875734142959118, 0.003069481113925576, -0.029980190098285675, -0.02675948105752468, 0.1014203429222107, 0.005206549074500799, 0.058187972754240036, 0.04939979687333107, -0.006115630269050598, 0.005836657248437405, -0.056444406509399414, -0.017169520258903503, 0.010807006619870663, -0.003307213308289647, 0.03323160111904144, 0.014956575818359852, -0.022215381264686584, 0.011920827440917492, -0.007362146861851215, 0.016586406156420708, 0.05997733026742935, 0.024394972249865532, 0.031092515215277672, 0.010565254837274551, -0.03971315175294876, -0.06006201356649399, 0.02730087749660015, -0.01154684741050005, 0.02252097614109516, -0.012046674266457558, -0.016214733943343163, 0.05084064230322838, 0.017671147361397743, 0.01826084405183792, -0.06724739074707031, -0.0221133790910244, -0.061533644795417786, 0.029425669461488724, 0.01634136401116848, -0.014943158254027367, 0.01326584629714489, -0.013208269141614437, 0.022427069023251534, -0.02788052335381508, 0.0038713549729436636, -0.01895999163389206, -0.1016223207116127, -0.05874837934970856, -0.035963818430900574, -0.02563081867992878, 0.06009284406900406, 0.012299933470785618, -0.03764136880636215, 0.008342999964952469, -0.005981468595564365, 0.02815445140004158, 0.024932553991675377, 0.03604703024029732, -0.01643661968410015, 0.04301103577017784, -0.004779628477990627, 0.031168557703495026, -0.009765970520675182, 0.006153294816613197, 0.11956291645765305, 0.08000236749649048, 0.04357476159930229, -0.07060585170984268, -0.0054972534999251366, 0.030550874769687653, -0.0052127414382994175, -0.011121407151222229, 0.012886438518762589, 0.016010809689760208, 0.02773573435842991, 0.03230920806527138, 0.02996870130300522, -0.007876020856201649, 0.016804084181785583, 0.03905778005719185, -0.03215557336807251, -0.038272205740213394, 0.025551913306117058, 0.006250470411032438, 0.01354675181210041, 0.003625335404649377, -0.06025854870676994, 0.01659226045012474, 0.04399551451206207, -0.012369776144623756, -0.02178202010691166, 0.001261028810404241, 0.06066657975316048, 0.027157997712492943, 0.008657013066112995, -0.03214631602168083, 0.010925155133008957, 0.009230115450918674, -0.000878107559401542, 0.015186362899839878, 0.009307635016739368, -0.02398427575826645, -0.013301605358719826, 0.036357130855321884, 0.012274672277271748, -0.039124276489019394, -0.019486989825963974, -0.018527895212173462, -0.05573127791285515, -0.027104860171675682, -0.030010804533958435, 0.032518982887268066, -0.030517717823386192, -0.021177079528570175, 0.0380825437605381, 0.03816002979874611, -0.011396549642086029, -0.009962077252566814, -0.026924317702651024, 0.03463795408606529, 0.015022982843220234, -0.038197726011276245, 0.013422209769487381, -0.03093942627310753, -0.003506616922095418, -0.019203854724764824, 0.01940491609275341, 0.009511245414614677, -0.023477211594581604, 0.00457044830545783, -0.031129878014326096, 0.007568293251097202, 0.008241836912930012, 0.019435567781329155, 0.015028327703475952, -0.004788505379110575, 0.012036987580358982, -0.016654498875141144, -0.005183788016438484, 0.02090185135602951, 0.03812409192323685, 0.005819353740662336, -0.014060054905712605, -0.02563442848622799, -0.019711250439286232, 0.028347168117761612, -0.004973980598151684, -0.026967307552695274, -0.028617337346076965, -0.002740547526627779, 0.034988537430763245, 0.021498188376426697, 0.02517010271549225, 0.044070370495319366, 0.013128872960805893, 0.0016889995895326138, 0.02433241344988346, -0.04758934676647186, -0.026876680552959442, 0.037771910429000854, -0.018911512568593025, 0.001942827831953764, 0.0008734455332159996, 0.04078076779842377, 0.07124483585357666, 0.007553238421678543, -0.018539845943450928, 0.010105418972671032, 0.014981438405811787, 0.023338116705417633, 0.020054763182997704, -0.05824344977736473, -0.010357033461332321, -0.008459365926682949, 0.002119740704074502, -0.04332992807030678, -0.053691644221544266, -0.016585713252425194, -0.03361145406961441, 0.019851816818118095, -0.006475984118878841, -0.017958160489797592, 0.0019269963959231973, -0.010494053363800049, 0.05433462932705879, -0.005407072603702545, -0.03597946837544441, -0.03372710198163986, -0.010987982153892517, 0.009396917186677456, -0.025064565241336823, 0.010566303506493568, -0.009703914634883404, 0.023086266592144966, 0.004430473782122135, 0.04483481124043465, 0.03969322144985199, 0.01750955358147621, 0.011084706522524357, -0.0035172083880752325, -0.03428629785776138, 0.023434005677700043, -0.011716567911207676, 0.004801953677088022, 0.00996970571577549, -0.03398318588733673, 0.002469673054292798, 0.00897308811545372, -0.0023789687547832727, 0.023215947672724724, 0.032617878168821335, -0.025962170213460922, 0.007224802393466234, 0.040070585906505585, -0.033959437161684036, -0.050078134983778, 0.013812967576086521, -0.022666512057185173, -0.016567572951316833, 0.005966655444353819, 0.029044458642601967, 0.01989905536174774, -0.030809488147497177, 0.033285584300756454, 0.022145289927721024, 0.046243224292993546, -0.0387984924018383, 0.017168158665299416, 0.00668597687035799, 0.03501537814736366, 0.02960234135389328, 0.02523539587855339, 0.02221931330859661, 0.036287736147642136, -0.0355704203248024, 0.03419838845729828, 0.025131361559033394, -0.001141809392720461, -0.06395745277404785, -0.03451675549149513, 0.007411549799144268, -0.04414723068475723, 0.046845126897096634, -0.06519494950771332, 0.027505217120051384, 0.02548106759786606, -0.07071027904748917, -0.012130063958466053, -0.009536292403936386, -0.04795699194073677, 0.0013336364645510912, 0.0252277422696352, -0.007854444906115532, 0.026717444881796837, 0.025597354397177696, 0.024799229577183723, 0.0023223001044243574, 0.01940658688545227, -0.04663483053445816, 0.010370984673500061, -0.060436442494392395, 0.012465992011129856, 0.018385503441095352, -0.04065627604722977, 0.029076825827360153, -0.03663080558180809, 0.001895085209980607, 0.06409238278865814, 0.0108489990234375, -0.0048318360932171345, 0.04845000058412552, 0.006028627045452595, -0.0240001417696476, 0.0037465915083885193, 0.013968558050692081, -0.012622811831533909, -0.018547330051660538, 0.02317908965051174, 0.004517546389251947, 0.028855176642537117, -0.006437562871724367, -0.018901033326983452, 0.002885345369577408, -0.00942670926451683, -0.0192642193287611, 0.0236104317009449, -0.0427926629781723, -0.0484914667904377, -0.016020692884922028, -0.014775948598980904, 0.019308116286993027, -0.02078929729759693, 0.02856171689927578, -0.02187001146376133, 0.017508642747998238, 0.0009211679571308196, 0.0020687964279204607, 0.012489082291722298, 0.026615124195814133, -0.025198768824338913, -0.05769635736942291, 0.02116142213344574, 0.012009342201054096, -0.018026303499937057, -0.05706629902124405, 0.028256235644221306, -0.0019958566408604383, -0.03614548221230507, -0.030482357367873192, 0.004830516409128904, -0.039511118084192276, 0.023802369832992554, -0.0009778906824067235, 0.01727113500237465, 0.011939400807023048, -0.03500070422887802, -0.01995101198554039, -0.06379304081201553, 0.07171379029750824, 0.014828751794993877, -0.005061616655439138, -0.02991289272904396, 0.04273403063416481, -0.04609184339642525, 0.013763977214694023, 0.06983739137649536, -0.005964836571365595, 0.028233753517270088, -0.04815185070037842, 0.0012868932681158185, -0.019062791019678116, -0.013917706906795502, 0.039695266634225845, -0.03449513763189316, 0.001738491002470255, -0.03030109405517578, -0.049452897161245346, 0.014852768741548061, 0.006601022090762854, 0.024162791669368744, -0.018386078998446465, 0.015586609952151775, 0.008610418066382408, 0.0024549076333642006, 0.024445954710245132, 0.007829513400793076, 0.0039780461229383945, 0.04953485727310181, 0.004980200435966253, 0.002540657529607415, 0.018766125664114952, -0.0035019770730286837, -0.061588652431964874, 0.0394047349691391, -0.027277467772364616, 0.019116714596748352, 0.003279062919318676, 0.012697537429630756, -0.013426103629171848, -0.05443744361400604, -0.006106322631239891, -0.0026942724362015724, -0.016708286479115486, 0.04285063222050667, 0.015524988994002342, 0.05914401262998581, 0.03725425526499748, -0.0290970616042614, 0.025933999568223953, -0.0039606583304703236, -0.010648068971931934, 0.04585927352309227, 0.03921876847743988, 0.019526373594999313, -0.0005752588040195405, 0.01391688548028469, -0.000016755506294430234, -0.05279592052102089, 0.026732902973890305, -0.017478158697485924, 0.03534890338778496, -0.05479328706860542, -0.03232467919588089, -0.02234322763979435, -0.013621190562844276, 0.014760687947273254, 0.02465745434165001, -0.02148861438035965, 0.05291265249252319, -0.048787686973810196, -0.008115865290164948, -0.07087137550115585, -0.0021697187330573797, -0.0024303726386278868, -0.00570299057289958, 0.003426080569624901, 0.06683425605297089, 0.026028255000710487, -0.0019654056522995234, -0.035698287189006805, -0.026054156944155693, 0.0395352840423584, -0.0005662079202011228, 0.023252960294485092, -0.0056447237730026245, -0.015560300089418888, -0.0091736800968647, -0.02436642535030842, 0.00673414533957839, 0.0035847630351781845, 0.014079277403652668, 0.055869363248348236, 0.03167335316538811, -0.016674764454364777, -0.027236105874180794, -0.003582507139071822, 0.045988284051418304, -0.09222082048654556, -0.007347631733864546, -0.04044782370328903, 0.026665860787034035, -0.02316557615995407, -0.029245639219880104 ]
<p>I'm trying to build a monte-carlo simulation that can revise it's distribution of outcomes of a project based on observed measurements after the project has started.</p> <p><strong>I have a few questions about the best way to do this. I'm not a statistician, so please correct me if I am doing something wildly wrong.</strong></p> <p>For example, let's say I've observed that task <code>x</code> has been selected by person <code>y</code> (whose original 90% CI estimate for the task was [<code>l</code>,<code>h</code>]) , and that <code>y</code> has logged <code>w</code> hours of work to the task.</p> <p>I can use that data to re-simulate the project under new constraints and compute a new, more accurate, distribution of outcomes.</p> <p>For example, if <code>w</code> > <code>l</code>, then I know that the lower bound for the time to complete x is now <code>w</code>, not <code>l</code>, and can adjust the distribution used accordingly. However, <code>w</code> is not a 5% lower bound. It's a 0% lower bound (i.e. the limit), so using [<code>w</code>, <code>h</code>] as a 90% CI didn't quite seem correct. As a result I was thinking I could just pick some arbitrarily small number for <code>p(w)</code>, say 0.0001, and continue using .05 for <code>p(h)</code> and then generate a new distribution for [<code>w</code>, <code>h</code>] (of course, I would just use the number of deviations for <code>h</code> and <code>w</code> rather than the probabilities).</p> <p><strong>Is that sound?</strong></p> <p>What's not immediately clear is what I would do in the case where <code>w</code> > <code>h</code>. I have calibrated estimates with a 90% CI, so I should expect to see this 5% of the time. If I ask: "what do I know in that case", I come up with the following:</p> <ol> <li>I know <code>w</code> and I know my arbitrarily low <code>p(w)</code></li> <li>From the original confidence interval (which assumes a normal distribution), I can determine<code>p(w + sigma)</code>.</li> <li>So, I could produce: <code>[w, w + sigma]</code> as an interval, using <code>p(w)</code> and <code>p(w + sigma)</code>, and then derive a normal distribution from that (again, just using the z-values).</li> </ol> <p><strong>Is that sound as well?</strong></p>
494
[ 0.00581954512745142, -0.008104109205305576, 0.0015945413615554571, -0.04593672975897789, 0.01892356015741825, -0.0069693210534751415, -0.03553817793726921, -0.036240190267562866, 0.01780977100133896, -0.017155809327960014, 0.045883823186159134, 0.09281117469072342, 0.04486134275794029, 0.05615493282675743, 0.01667533442378044, -0.0038749598897993565, 0.0015003012958914042, -0.01264113374054432, -0.02299254573881626, -0.022914238274097443, -0.005600197706371546, -0.002934703603386879, -0.0007332856766879559, -0.017580494284629822, -0.060370489954948425, 0.022191187366843224, 0.01128364447504282, -0.06614997237920761, -0.03003714233636856, 0.08603499829769135, -0.051280710846185684, -0.0085457693785429, -0.00046001962618902326, 0.05050741508603096, 0.0318140871822834, -0.00931093841791153, -0.05387674644589424, -0.05728130042552948, -0.0007549682632088661, 0.033946238458156586, -0.0037630086299031973, 0.04873498156666756, 0.034758660942316055, 0.009640498086810112, 0.024772239848971367, 0.03615715727210045, -0.02159024588763714, -0.03888065367937088, 0.04550684615969658, -0.005597657989710569, 0.02870740368962288, 0.009293446317315102, 0.026052774861454964, -0.00883087795227766, 0.0026038181968033314, -0.027806857600808144, 0.03665401414036751, 0.07484231889247894, 0.023565711453557014, -0.026551125571131706, -0.019877059385180473, -0.035007819533348083, -0.026013445109128952, -0.027729446068406105, 0.010952656157314777, 0.0069665745832026005, -0.03626955300569534, -0.009276255965232849, -0.0010474901646375656, -0.011232432909309864, 0.04806949570775032, 0.035008542239665985, 0.031048230826854706, 0.008660893887281418, 0.041014689952135086, 0.003494330681860447, 0.01262733992189169, 0.007578397169709206, -0.0030633704736828804, 0.020671162754297256, -0.015361223369836807, 0.02333652973175049, 0.0434105321764946, 0.036235835403203964, -0.010600886307656765, -0.03419932350516319, 0.07264846563339233, -0.04347716271877289, -0.025085384026169777, 0.026749102398753166, -0.05060422047972679, -0.007641211152076721, 0.03365113213658333, -0.01735340803861618, -0.018734218552708626, 0.020613662898540497, -0.009714748710393906, 0.02226373553276062, -0.0328197106719017, 0.014340214431285858, -0.04308946058154106, -0.06634850054979324, -0.035864003002643585, 0.023612182587385178, -0.028167299926280975, -0.006332050543278456, 0.015994761139154434, -0.003772684372961521, -0.0053582643158733845, -0.028106363490223885, -0.011207128874957561, 0.0031648678705096245, 0.030493823811411858, 0.0012708110734820366, -0.007013208232820034, 0.008720499463379383, -0.017544152215123177, -0.0384429395198822, 0.06513483822345734, 0.03235136717557907, 0.024488002061843872, -0.010206062346696854, 0.05445588007569313, -0.019364695996046066, -0.045051202178001404, -0.014993936754763126, 0.013089937157928944, -0.037816375494003296, -0.03772026672959328, 0.0543360635638237, 0.017023175954818726, -0.019759373739361763, 0.07028850167989731, 0.017332574352622032, 0.006661134772002697, -0.019197750836610794, -0.07142685353755951, -0.033319465816020966, 0.018491845577955246, 0.035976726561784744, 0.005536685232073069, -0.05084490031003952, -0.020268626511096954, 0.02687700092792511, 0.05193431302905083, 0.02512405626475811, 0.040642958134412766, -0.014068402349948883, 0.007991359569132328, 0.001760012935847044, -0.0438658706843853, 0.03151940554380417, -0.015341510996222496, -0.022858988493680954, -0.010182377882301807, -0.08002571016550064, 0.03211510181427002, 0.03258204460144043, -0.018765201792120934, -0.004364449996501207, -0.008015233092010021, 0.007231040392071009, -0.010513462126255035, -0.020443392917513847, 0.019500046968460083, -0.0451912097632885, 0.08562608808279037, 0.016473283991217613, 0.03472978249192238, -0.024586547166109085, -0.017868874594569206, 0.014551674947142601, 0.015861093997955322, 0.008973466232419014, 0.06939548254013062, -0.03792736306786537, 0.03968830034136772, -0.007493463810533285, 0.00618315115571022, -0.00183846743311733, -0.007861025631427765, 0.017634747549891472, -0.03795567899942398, -0.006162682082504034, 0.008723643608391285, 0.026273716241121292, 0.008182689547538757, -0.004720459692180157, 0.009021805599331856, -0.026476263999938965, -0.0641939714550972, -0.056299492716789246, -0.02695314958691597, 0.04605422914028168, 0.0012682421365752816, 0.03863442316651344, -0.03959955647587776, 0.04116959124803543, 0.0027792537584900856, -0.001157689606770873, -0.0209293644875288, -0.0062673152424395084, 0.05749916657805443, -0.03287373483181, 0.00039525862666778266, 0.06646931171417236, 0.04024859517812729, 0.025560151785612106, 0.07308579236268997, -0.03765326365828514, -0.04861634969711304, -0.03779225796461105, -0.03599920496344566, 0.013212088495492935, 0.013956449925899506, 0.0033520818687975407, -0.002167162485420704, -0.012903522700071335, 0.0024938525166362524, -0.0033138571307063103, 0.0017475639469921589, 0.060730841010808945, 0.0721641257405281, -0.005545456428080797, 0.007489378098398447, 0.020707866176962852, -0.02515868842601776, 0.0068022035993635654, -0.04505453631281853, -0.01244115736335516, -0.023096470162272453, -0.013442857190966606, 0.005687123164534569, 0.001034347340464592, -0.022284409031271935, 0.02591014839708805, 0.026333797723054886, -0.029142379760742188, 0.025770995765924454, 0.04552783444523811, -0.011765389703214169, -0.018230987712740898, 0.03566727414727211, 0.007822559215128422, 0.07372775673866272, 0.009217391721904278, 0.007621621247380972, 0.014552553184330463, 0.005992140620946884, -0.021425453945994377, 0.0024150994140654802, -0.014936202205717564, 0.022168366238474846, 0.00021128439402673393, -0.011071030050516129, -0.037813615053892136, 0.04628130421042442, 0.015197335742413998, -0.002212920691817999, 0.06358211487531662, 0.0007781731546856463, 0.005479327403008938, -0.01184922270476818, -0.061524271965026855, 0.01718958653509617, 0.012113881297409534, 0.01376956794410944, 0.035482075065374374, 0.018811602145433426, 0.011219027452170849, 0.0019544048700481653, -0.012771140784025192, -0.0153074711561203, -0.04258512333035469, 0.022224251180887222, 0.0023409277200698853, 0.014764764346182346, 0.019868474453687668, -0.0052627031691372395, -0.011191124096512794, -0.001254648552276194, 0.023264119401574135, 0.021604441106319427, 0.010599161498248577, -0.04931667819619179, -0.03969093784689903, 0.032427217811346054, -0.0305794570595026, 0.04531173035502434, -0.007322436664253473, -0.022570131346583366, 0.04826166108250618, 0.015036597847938538, -0.030098797753453255, 0.010983353480696678, -0.00437289010733366, -0.0068963379599153996, -0.022435897961258888, -0.011011062189936638, 0.05814182013273239, 0.05526181682944298, -0.08700824528932571, 0.05164477229118347, -0.02252897620201111, -0.05320563167333603, -0.06276630610227585, 0.03185539320111275, -0.01318484079092741, 0.02695547044277191, 0.030519001185894012, 0.0242127887904644, 0.02140488475561142, 0.0004983331309631467, -0.09214002639055252, -0.08021749556064606, 0.024149002507328987, 0.002583614783361554, 0.022239981219172478, 0.004471699707210064, -0.0052741654217243195, 0.10274819284677505, 0.054363444447517395, 0.006402940955013037, -0.0414709746837616, -0.004144431557506323, 0.010886008851230145, 0.0011954654473811388, -0.007684893440455198, 0.02697662077844143, -0.05228769779205322, 0.0072441622614860535, -0.009019408375024796, 0.023921635001897812, 0.015544719062745571, -0.01742212288081646, 0.025024447590112686, 0.02499091438949108, 0.0022826676722615957, -0.029476111754775047, 0.029210511595010757, -0.0048390584997832775, 0.0001972195750568062, 0.021396944299340248, -0.03557373583316803, 0.027136994525790215, 0.018428806215524673, -0.03659667819738388, -0.003195619210600853, -0.022599495947360992, -0.0016643498092889786, -0.048098716884851456, 0.024297473952174187, -0.0046691191382706165, -0.05172225087881088, 0.009820946492254734, -0.005964689888060093, 0.01101467665284872, -0.010988717898726463, -0.009684124030172825, 0.020851021632552147, 0.03975381329655647, 0.022618260234594345, -0.03950994089245796, -0.0539642833173275, -0.021245528012514114, -0.001037062844261527, -0.015469031408429146, -0.02415083907544613, 0.012838460505008698, 0.048141997307538986, 0.04161054268479347, -0.015087527222931385, -0.020160328596830368, 0.0016940830973908305, -0.04817831143736839, 0.002553973812609911, -0.03061535209417343, 0.08555472642183304, 0.007195140700787306, 0.01589534804224968, 0.025957567617297173, -0.006106469314545393, -0.02699112892150879, 0.0014773751609027386, -0.04666202887892723, 0.04364432394504547, 0.013223936781287193, -0.018552960827946663, 0.0030168304219841957, -0.02674413099884987, 0.055439140647649765, -0.03539445251226425, 0.020555023103952408, 0.022139905020594597, 0.03162942826747894, -0.005100999493151903, 0.03379618749022484, -0.02278311178088188, -0.023349622264504433, -0.012970028445124626, -0.025355122983455658, 0.011885231360793114, 0.0042363605462014675, 0.050230782479047775, 0.020810721442103386, -0.0063716876320540905, -0.01906757801771164, -0.00578435231000185, -0.0070875524543225765, 0.006982852704823017, 0.020005324855446815, 0.018105588853359222, 0.07286742329597473, -0.04431426525115967, 0.018436942249536514, -0.006346380803734064, 0.02858879044651985, 0.05450522527098656, -0.013199571520090103, -0.0034683477133512497, -0.025668008252978325, -0.02342316135764122, 0.01847836934030056, 0.008225162513554096, -0.001663813367486, 0.008721411228179932, 0.026803748682141304, -0.006444311700761318, -0.04971945658326149, 0.011407255195081234, 0.07814773917198181, -0.009499739855527878, -0.007481794338673353, -0.008869772776961327, -0.005549555644392967, -0.006009239703416824, -0.0111163891851902, -0.013434985652565956, 0.047822415828704834, 0.009558907710015774, 0.011469583958387375, 0.011289441026747227, -0.01550207193940878, -0.038638509809970856, 0.012384436093270779, -0.007314618676900864, 0.0434456504881382, 0.044856492429971695, -0.012599813751876354, 0.03358757868409157, -0.0029157924000173807, 0.007219660095870495, 0.03639273717999458, 0.002905119676142931, -0.061816051602363586, -0.05160537362098694, 0.051667068153619766, 0.0591328926384449, -0.01893845573067665, 0.006037293467670679, -0.03317379206418991, -0.012225941754877567, 0.04163826256990433, -0.025256473571062088, 0.021400319412350655, 0.01760111190378666, 0.006098618730902672, -0.0016850167885422707, -0.03509432077407837, -0.06243894621729851, 0.010819017887115479, -0.030454648658633232, 0.05571332946419716, -0.04121609404683113, -0.038759566843509674, -0.016673849895596504, -0.004365597385913134, 0.020924387499690056, 0.06465374678373337, -0.015277399681508541, -0.03979937359690666, -0.019573265686631203, -0.014964347705245018, -0.004474229644984007, -0.06019622087478638, 0.00344058102928102, 0.023493865504860878, 0.020635491237044334, 0.03204574063420296, -0.012653063982725143, 0.002440438373014331, 0.05726156011223793, 0.01818963699042797, -0.0149367805570364, -0.01184562873095274, -0.009462414309382439, 0.043075546622276306, 0.036253273487091064, 0.010990450158715248, 0.04266170784831047, 0.028183287009596825, -0.02774125151336193, 0.017394673079252243, -0.03559700772166252, 0.013144666329026222, -0.03320308402180672, 0.05111619830131531, -0.056086692959070206, -0.007948876358568668, -0.017097383737564087, 0.003403152571991086, 0.0043823812156915665, 0.046184662729501724, -0.01717403717339039, -0.03360708802938461, -0.012094143778085709, 0.007054060231894255, 0.02001199871301651, -0.015600497834384441, -0.014517141506075859, -0.02067214623093605, -0.004771408159285784, 0.0035493250470608473, -0.021160606294870377, 0.010355781763792038, 0.019131489098072052, -0.015707869082689285, -0.02986774779856205, -0.009815630502998829, -0.04291500896215439, -0.0010328281205147505, 0.015646236017346382, 0.0002918367099482566, 0.025582289323210716, -0.006537842098623514, 0.04184326156973839, -0.0182596854865551, -0.008608098141849041, -0.020287100225687027, 0.03937128931283951, -0.03273400291800499, 0.012653819285333157, -0.02048862911760807, 0.043692052364349365, -0.044325459748506546, 0.003698097774758935, -0.07864458113908768, -0.017667867243289948, -0.024296959862113, 0.005413208156824112, -0.02841704525053501, -0.018261700868606567, -0.005453080870211124, -0.009029598906636238, -0.03806881606578827, -0.031170153990387917, 0.08486635237932205, -0.022255444899201393, 0.010615984909236431, -0.008026995696127415, 0.014339848421514034, 0.07483752816915512, -0.019453246146440506, -0.010807914659380913, 0.026163389906287193, -0.0313764326274395, -0.014258060604333878, -0.004869010765105486, -0.02958628721535206, -0.04625968262553215, -0.013914239592850208, -0.003566632978618145, 0.03372960910201073, 0.07223325222730637, -0.006480754353106022, -0.012068487703800201, 0.03542422130703926, 0.006735109258443117, -0.000499123998451978, -0.0075575257651507854, 0.016606874763965607, -0.002027700422331691, 0.023379744961857796, -0.015286080539226532, 0.03227222338318825, 0.0009053047397173941, -0.02154049463570118, 0.03363977000117302, 0.021430352702736855, -0.010388562455773354, 0.03259292244911194, 0.026667486876249313, -0.023373428732156754, -0.014471652917563915, 0.004511722829192877, -0.01099787000566721, 0.007449555676430464, 0.013889878056943417, -0.012889552861452103, 0.01769040711224079, -0.004778493195772171, -0.06106625869870186, -0.002998004201799631, -0.05973656848073006, -0.012199589982628822, 0.025602353736758232, -0.009313995949923992, 0.06204521283507347, 0.014412696473300457, -0.0221305713057518, -0.01242231484502554, -0.03756185621023178, -0.011288691312074661, -0.020900635048747063, 0.01732374168932438, 0.05108722299337387, 0.033952582627534866, -0.03431396558880806, 0.05953932926058769, 0.011657754890620708, 0.027191050350666046, 0.007121467497199774, -0.0020984066650271416, -0.014241525903344154, 0.007961823605000973, -0.06131509691476822, -0.04984048381447792, 0.021721402183175087, -0.047394562512636185, 0.006293725688010454, -0.028594553470611572, -0.02052847295999527, 0.031760554760694504, 0.02919999323785305, -0.03737310692667961, -0.047080352902412415, -0.019853677600622177, -0.045981042087078094, -0.005615765694528818, 0.014354964718222618, -0.04840463399887085, 0.035188138484954834, -0.030959151685237885, 0.022323692217469215, -0.019457494840025902, 0.027485845610499382, -0.00645070755854249, -0.06227588281035423, -0.038009703159332275, -0.019425584003329277, -0.04224765673279762, 0.034641753882169724, 0.01511258352547884, -0.024422142654657364, 0.02646835707128048, -0.02519710175693035, 0.020075885578989983, 0.01560306828469038, 0.049998242408037186, 0.006930768955498934, 0.06578660011291504, 0.0036323696840554476, 0.02523679845035076, -0.04853673279285431, -0.0016349287470802665, 0.15223275125026703, 0.0931437760591507, 0.041809044778347015, -0.027002442628145218, 0.02413487434387207, -0.018911514431238174, -0.012858672998845577, -0.018574504181742668, 0.031033972278237343, 0.01579427532851696, -0.0379139669239521, 0.0042095850221812725, 0.03405797854065895, 0.0052625872194767, 0.0038418746553361416, 0.061309125274419785, -0.03217003494501114, -0.025012793019413948, 0.023820139467716217, -0.007050719112157822, 0.014278135262429714, -0.008329191245138645, -0.04857518523931503, -0.016634643077850342, -0.005596783943474293, -0.002094243187457323, 0.01575368642807007, -0.034979112446308136, -0.0016023039352148771, -0.005610501393675804, -0.012984605506062508, -0.0005124416784383357, -0.007913384586572647, 0.009269723668694496, 0.039456550031900406, -0.010259521193802357, 0.007409667130559683, -0.01622023619711399, -0.028949255123734474, 0.05466683208942413, 0.009113910607993603, 0.00017537678650114685, -0.020035697147250175, 0.009538747370243073, -0.049108635634183884, -0.028553146868944168, -0.02528388611972332, 0.031624507158994675, -0.049975618720054626, -0.0043066758662462234, 0.004322894383221865, -0.010406626388430595, -0.0028073182329535484, -0.007207982707768679, 0.001296639908105135, -0.0011005493579432368, 0.025106940418481827, 0.007616981398314238, -0.028928454965353012, 0.008904746733605862, 0.015249008312821388, -0.012711511924862862, 0.013930462300777435, 0.0351661816239357, -0.023927155882120132, -0.040839049965143204, 0.0017782771028578281, 0.051135674118995667, -0.009642232209444046, 0.00522322952747345, 0.015799999237060547, 0.00014832268061582, -0.01672404073178768, -0.01259781327098608, -0.002847317373380065, -0.03869878500699997, 0.005264684557914734, -0.035937607288360596, -0.015213125385344028, -0.0695476308465004, -0.06104740872979164, 0.013144821859896183, -0.026598945260047913, -0.021633699536323547, -0.062090709805488586, 0.0020543562714010477, 0.0034559478517621756, 0.056839704513549805, 0.041924115270376205, -0.0045424168929457664, -0.023254184052348137, 0.033539779484272, 0.026817798614501953, -0.059213053435087204, -0.010210758075118065, 0.010245995596051216, -0.03850558027625084, 0.003222613362595439, 0.013635884039103985, 0.06831395626068115, -0.001844908343628049, -0.028037777170538902, 0.010445128194987774, 0.02244495414197445, 0.011276545003056526, 0.018443914130330086, 0.014904556795954704, -0.06313927471637726, -0.05853402614593506, 0.02754921466112137, -0.00651052501052618, -0.03262165188789368, 0.004449660424143076, -0.04987523332238197, -0.03100595809519291, 0.00905147660523653, -0.015985703095793724, -0.003925060387700796, 0.010266995057463646, -0.027033818885684013, -0.004633546806871891, -0.007757649291306734, 0.001989467302337289, 0.010019962675869465, -0.013156670145690441, -0.03974565118551254, 0.0013542341766878963, 0.004183351993560791, 0.002999227261170745, 0.008034205995500088, 0.0174570232629776, -0.019141381606459618, -0.0031137862242758274, 0.013320257887244225, 0.0011709668906405568, 0.0022094540763646364, 0.020319247618317604, 0.036355309188365936, -0.03391052037477493, 0.007466468494385481, 0.05463780090212822, -0.04376222565770149, -0.0448852963745594, 0.03305410221219063, 0.012135066092014313, 0.06106741353869438, -0.005713227670639753, -0.01953883469104767, 0.0013784575276076794, 0.03457208722829819, -0.053659554570913315, -0.02918568067252636, -0.017005128785967827, 0.002330923220142722, -0.009226126596331596, -0.009461750276386738, 0.03672299534082413, -0.0045189340598881245, 0.00029580286354757845, 0.01030956581234932, 0.012801453471183777, 0.014186246320605278, 0.016294315457344055, 0.017856448888778687, -0.0038610214833170176, 0.005572626832872629, 0.014087265357375145, -0.009943593293428421, -0.011237043887376785, 0.048571642488241196, -0.03601936623454094, 0.028364334255456924, -0.024585504084825516, 0.012859335169196129, -0.10904840379953384, -0.04419548809528351, 0.00012103139306418598, 0.0025850364472717047, 0.0470404326915741, -0.03627810627222061, 0.0017781747737899423, 0.047512978315353394, -0.05087977275252342, 0.05282698571681976, 0.016800610348582268, 0.024589451029896736, -0.04832026734948158, 0.019916942343115807, -0.031142232939600945, 0.0003706157149281353, 0.01968136988580227, 0.004552788566797972, 0.05127786472439766, 0.04865424707531929, 0.01257165428251028, -0.048561614006757736, -0.022278351709246635, 0.022374914959073067, 0.004331708420068026, -0.019990045577287674, 0.035350389778614044, -0.02691373974084854, -0.034937478601932526, 0.03055625781416893, 0.009198382496833801, 0.042418476194143295, -0.05412127077579498, 0.04096915200352669, 0.03233947604894638, 0.07680622488260269, 0.057499490678310394, -0.014553421176970005, 0.014481809921562672, 0.015218343585729599, 0.037275828421115875, 0.03268762305378914, -0.01648698002099991, 0.016612458974123, 0.023648615926504135, 0.0021212033461779356, -0.02895880863070488, 0.05910158529877663, 0.013230133801698685, -0.028839517384767532, 0.026878228411078453, -0.028523845598101616, -0.003927131183445454, -0.0480956993997097, 0.011412769556045532, -0.025673899799585342, 0.0023575343657284975, 0.04813653230667114, 0.0195187758654356, -0.029318928718566895, -0.008554109372198582, -0.02693004719913006, -0.023943275213241577, 0.016529662534594536, -0.0035728546790778637, -0.018476441502571106, -0.04299435019493103, 0.007979124784469604, -0.03445516154170036, 0.01633201539516449, 0.014361664652824402, 0.019352557137608528, -0.032700181007385254, 0.005123940296471119, -0.02526494674384594, -0.020150046795606613, 0.016904715448617935, 0.02325596660375595, 0.015242664143443108, -0.09875603020191193, 0.043199919164180756, 0.012227674014866352, -0.003118857042863965, -0.048881664872169495, -0.02329239621758461, 0.001980958739295602, 0.02084878645837307, 0.05818914622068405, 0.010110140778124332, -0.020754635334014893, -0.02654094621539116, 0.011173440143465996, -0.007979974150657654, -0.051420290023088455, 0.05922345444560051, 0.0028304485604166985, 0.006753101944923401, -0.013954109512269497, -0.028882242739200592, -0.009554273448884487, 0.0030062159057706594, 0.004426763392984867, 0.022428689524531364, 0.0172275323420763, 0.023173250257968903, 0.005751214921474457, 0.03249511122703552, 0.011677677743136883, 0.006419006735086441, 0.042638715356588364, 0.009063225239515305, 0.020332181826233864, -0.008197912946343422, -0.012955783866345882, -0.08288385719060898, 0.025687353685498238, -0.053101129829883575, -0.03046964481472969, 0.02127738855779171, 0.0025953578297048807, 0.0022449104581028223, -0.0599568746984005, -0.012469655834138393, 0.04402856528759003, -0.020056741312146187, 0.0003318590170238167, 0.02592000924050808, 0.0367959588766098, 0.040939848870038986, -0.00989471934735775, 0.015849310904741287, -0.03043365105986595, -0.022748000919818878, 0.021909423172473907, -0.022280389443039894, 0.03892377018928528, -0.04291669279336929, 0.02649948000907898, 0.05152038112282753, 0.0046466016210615635, 0.022079050540924072, -0.01543562300503254, 0.049300145357847214, -0.006775772199034691, -0.018747907131910324, 0.05312327668070793, 0.013166505843400955, -0.015972627326846123, -0.0021908695343881845, -0.008155020885169506, 0.06032444164156914, -0.018716085702180862, 0.008354348130524158, -0.041078370064496994, -0.0195777527987957, -0.02529025264084339, 0.02097233571112156, -0.008630235679447651, 0.05833492800593376, -0.008542685769498348, 0.008297475054860115, -0.012473895214498043, 0.007688584737479687, 0.02916182577610016, -0.012560291215777397, 0.030948372557759285, 0.01868000067770481, 0.027362167835235596, -0.025233622640371323, -0.020176928490400314, -0.022764578461647034, -0.005962290335446596, -0.002351392526179552, 0.06493174284696579, 0.02244636043906212, -0.010214114561676979, -0.08852359652519226, 0.006273678038269281, 0.04202400892972946, -0.007445208728313446, 0.009754185564815998, -0.06124136596918106, 0.03778955340385437, -0.008880306035280228, -0.011111120693385601 ]
<p>I've seen in <a href="http://www.khanacademy.org/video?v=hxZ6uooEJOk" rel="nofollow">video</a> lessons that if the sample size is big enough (n>30) sample distribution standard deviation can be approximated by sample standard deviation. How do we get the sample distribution standard deviation if sample size is small (n=10)?</p>
73,801
[ -0.02640576846897602, -0.012133115902543068, 0.03176156058907509, -0.011992519721388817, 0.06148335710167885, -0.017784176394343376, -0.04178307205438614, -0.02192435972392559, 0.02578483335673809, -0.03837193548679352, -0.00033756394986994565, 0.006443508435040712, 0.05936519429087639, 0.03874192014336586, 0.011204629205167294, 0.023416003212332726, -0.010763509199023247, 0.004638340789824724, -0.01061560120433569, -0.009296677075326443, 0.0002525801828596741, 0.01810801960527897, -0.0035572887863963842, -0.020174400880932808, -0.054014962166547775, 0.028172960504889488, 0.020777558907866478, 0.0067746564745903015, 0.04555083438754082, 0.04909175634384155, -0.025912916287779808, -0.03024381212890148, 0.03196503221988678, 0.0326242595911026, 0.002792506944388151, -0.02077547460794449, -0.020647551864385605, -0.03340394049882889, -0.0001301111187785864, 0.01213469821959734, -0.051150526851415634, -0.008473099209368229, 0.03293725475668907, -0.0019093157025054097, -0.032882727682590485, 0.026584938168525696, -0.023390917107462883, -0.08970481902360916, 0.0455661304295063, -0.041322529315948486, 0.04256424307823181, 0.01806044392287731, 0.023214008659124374, 0.024518974125385284, -0.025907250121235847, -0.014846762642264366, 0.06067333742976189, 0.04250200465321541, -0.00414450466632843, -0.028039410710334778, 0.01575327105820179, -0.019917331635951996, -0.022380348294973373, -0.0035898853093385696, -0.010340608656406403, -0.011060822755098343, -0.013671904802322388, -0.009179330430924892, 0.007514332886785269, -0.006592072080820799, 0.02883300557732582, 0.021042553707957268, 0.029400700703263283, 0.033880606293678284, 0.021992981433868408, -0.038102611899375916, 0.009255568496882915, -0.012235550209879875, 0.06563639640808105, 0.04197712242603302, 0.04392176494002342, 0.024023903533816338, 0.05187554657459259, 0.010038674809038639, 0.02549818530678749, -0.03516583889722824, 0.062273021787405014, -0.009636074304580688, -0.001575631438754499, 0.011395711451768875, -0.012580047361552715, 0.008491379208862782, 0.04692033305764198, -0.028542865067720413, -0.030475368723273277, 0.01652245968580246, -0.05023789405822754, 0.04504580795764923, 0.008779439143836498, -0.01349449623376131, 0.031544849276542664, -0.03533935546875, 0.056688688695430756, 0.05237654969096184, -0.028464093804359436, 0.011299226433038712, 0.008474837988615036, 0.03345238044857979, -0.016326282173395157, -0.021333355456590652, -0.04206324368715286, 0.014544307254254818, 0.020876063033938408, 0.025902222841978073, 0.02177380584180355, 0.003351419698446989, 0.004959365352988243, -0.0015959442825987935, 0.05371658504009247, 0.04798264428973198, 0.015757910907268524, -0.002963676815852523, 0.012785213068127632, -0.023412497714161873, -0.03550208359956741, 0.04783165082335472, 0.00972017738968134, -0.02072763442993164, -0.07359712570905685, 0.060509927570819855, 0.010180892422795296, 0.0004841335176024586, 0.012619828805327415, 0.034615837037563324, 0.029754335060715675, 0.009955663233995438, -0.07956569641828537, -0.026912014931440353, 0.04815669730305672, -0.00937075074762106, -0.006493902299553156, -0.059620823711156845, 0.027651114389300346, 0.02300945296883583, 0.010528750717639923, 0.03633420169353485, 0.03611574321985245, -0.024352092295885086, 0.021392498165369034, 0.01442133728414774, -0.005072995088994503, 0.02705613151192665, -0.027472427114844322, 0.01004304550588131, 0.009714514948427677, -0.07760307192802429, 0.031200332567095757, 0.005045016761869192, 0.007879366166889668, -0.04800848290324211, 0.025184907019138336, 0.007830432616174221, -0.017432156950235367, -0.01783968135714531, 0.019236857071518898, -0.0373062938451767, 0.065402090549469, 0.009409800171852112, 0.01573820225894451, -0.004224376752972603, -0.017279459163546562, -0.0017441142117604613, 0.04671970754861832, 0.02985653281211853, 0.024406852200627327, -0.0009662538068369031, -0.016884367913007736, -0.015506960451602936, 0.023695185780525208, 0.00022699902183376253, -0.05420190095901489, 0.007381076458841562, 0.017564650624990463, 0.03088867850601673, 0.0198516882956028, 0.0492338202893734, -0.01014357153326273, -0.007952161133289337, 0.02483033388853073, -0.045115161687135696, -0.060957252979278564, -0.07376319915056229, 0.013893536292016506, -0.02494155615568161, -0.029271304607391357, 0.0033754215110093355, 0.02173183113336563, 0.017555009573698044, -0.027531147003173828, 0.0005525739979930222, -0.034470148384571075, -0.013719304464757442, 0.006442084908485413, -0.01814855821430683, 0.0023301385808736086, 0.043441399931907654, 0.05959557369351387, -0.03845495730638504, 0.03410301357507706, -0.03163830190896988, -0.05615200474858284, 0.008263328112661839, -0.03612333908677101, 0.02175445482134819, 0.01764112524688244, -0.02020455151796341, 0.004057331010699272, -0.02257578633725643, -0.009426329284906387, 0.045506011694669724, -0.043779343366622925, 0.08621756732463837, 0.08679945021867752, 0.027636853978037834, -0.0002893676864914596, 0.0011390167055651546, 0.025079235434532166, -0.01945563778281212, 0.026639144867658615, -0.030208323150873184, -0.05127130448818207, -0.010205581784248352, 0.03356253355741501, -0.010125481523573399, -0.02515563741326332, -0.012660498730838299, 0.07182545214891434, -0.003339331829920411, 0.027111368253827095, -0.0002944786101579666, 0.012187538668513298, 0.017853304743766785, -0.04254358634352684, 0.016481969505548477, 0.012107372283935547, 0.022909652441740036, -0.009328252635896206, 0.027970094233751297, 0.01268354058265686, 0.043903667479753494, -0.014995532110333443, 0.019222432747483253, -0.014320377260446548, 0.022992683574557304, -0.007028673775494099, -0.005636838264763355, 0.02969597466289997, -0.03586627170443535, -0.025576602667570114, 0.0338626429438591, 0.005833948031067848, 0.030375493690371513, 0.0011571884388104081, -0.02183668315410614, 0.014331703074276447, 0.009808128699660301, -0.029930081218481064, 0.015198910608887672, 0.016662228852510452, -0.01777654141187668, -0.05935855954885483, -0.046454790979623795, -0.042243488132953644, -0.030287278816103935, 0.0026649804785847664, 0.05486736819148064, 0.002877280581742525, 0.010755409486591816, -0.009137820452451706, -0.01766287535429001, -0.003778746584430337, 0.0054625459015369415, 0.01391762774437666, 0.01872001774609089, -0.056335318833589554, 0.04094177111983299, 0.004630899056792259, -0.05867891013622284, 0.007660597562789917, 0.008445730432868004, 0.043041154742240906, 0.027950000017881393, 0.0012946776114404202, -0.03803516551852226, 0.017959486693143845, 0.024764206260442734, 0.03356906399130821, -0.04318499565124512, -0.014478988014161587, 0.023211529478430748, 0.010296091437339783, -0.017962731420993805, 0.05695769935846329, -0.03275436908006668, -0.04322884604334831, -0.06162958964705467, 0.012392916716635227, 0.007378279231488705, -0.01806267909705639, -0.01318495161831379, 0.036854859441518784, 0.0031501485500484705, -0.02579045481979847, -0.01915203407406807, -0.04533272609114647, -0.0049707586877048016, 0.03190651163458824, 0.06060482934117317, 0.011944925412535667, -0.028460368514060974, 0.07242164015769958, 0.0345928780734539, -0.036323703825473785, -0.019789498299360275, 0.009616859257221222, -0.01883513480424881, -0.018359169363975525, 0.03007534146308899, 0.02441294491291046, -0.0024377109948545694, -0.023556353524327278, -0.01811802387237549, 0.020981760695576668, 0.06111330911517143, -0.002520740032196045, -0.006816735025495291, -0.011499461717903614, -0.01839575543999672, -0.0017630979418754578, 0.046457257121801376, 0.013019762933254242, -0.053744006901979446, -0.022782746702432632, 0.009511493146419525, 0.08107645809650421, 0.012635677121579647, -0.021022053435444832, 0.007839879021048546, -0.00997900776565075, 0.009097854606807232, -0.05462278425693512, 0.020664703100919724, 0.02689066343009472, -0.03890205919742584, 0.009604504331946373, -0.005243251100182533, 0.02037655934691429, -0.03126823529601097, -0.017069319263100624, 0.025102846324443817, 0.053117334842681885, -0.030619118362665176, -0.02175760827958584, -0.008132132701575756, -0.020271413028240204, 0.048263631761074066, -0.0018987363437190652, -0.008435267023742199, 0.039571285247802734, 0.07015956193208694, 0.027591658756136894, -0.029593639075756073, -0.036678534001111984, 0.028079526498913765, -0.0795273706316948, -0.01004038192331791, -0.01830166205763817, 0.050281673669815063, 0.010136186145246029, 0.02719772979617119, 0.01648327149450779, -0.02712099254131317, -0.0009134052088484168, 0.011627381667494774, -0.08489693701267242, 0.04074520617723465, -0.025338878855109215, -0.061476342380046844, -0.005983808543533087, -0.018732119351625443, 0.023330476135015488, 0.000725936668459326, 0.05269479751586914, -0.009857813827693462, 0.01613614335656166, 0.0056212586350739, 0.011100384406745434, -0.002521449001505971, -0.013308417983353138, 0.024414844810962677, 0.004552850499749184, 0.04086587578058243, -0.0023069793824106455, 0.007990040816366673, 0.051509033888578415, -0.006761588156223297, -0.009803840890526772, -0.023144034668803215, 0.020248042419552803, 0.010704677551984787, 0.04719019681215286, 0.015406124293804169, 0.024314846843481064, -0.048182036727666855, 0.021950455382466316, -0.00723464647307992, 0.077411949634552, 0.04729875922203064, 0.0007118813809938729, -0.022869404405355453, -0.04541594907641411, -0.012419766746461391, 0.04084856063127518, -0.009309705346822739, 0.0037923066411167383, 0.015772145241498947, 0.05504930019378662, -0.0034429251682013273, -0.06726755946874619, 0.0030283168889582157, 0.05731461942195892, -0.007577153854072094, -0.010985986329615116, -0.03980029374361038, -0.0032240580767393112, -0.019180582836270332, -0.015153325162827969, 0.029972245916724205, 0.011140724644064903, -0.005850925575941801, 0.009848229587078094, 0.07518410682678223, -0.009630694054067135, -0.038025084882974625, -0.02116338722407818, -0.0007675367523916066, 0.061047423630952835, -0.0011773514561355114, -0.036523569375276566, 0.01667102798819542, 0.03364260867238045, 0.0395098440349102, -0.012590685859322548, -0.022600974887609482, -0.05192918702960014, -0.010651618242263794, 0.023933634161949158, 0.018614405766129494, -0.04307210445404053, 0.021447453647851944, -0.08328116685152054, -0.024539649486541748, 0.04101964086294174, -0.017825044691562653, 0.024406133219599724, -0.03350047767162323, 0.04178522899746895, -0.01837484911084175, 0.007219366263598204, -0.01598776876926422, -0.0025934232398867607, -0.021855749189853668, 0.02273591421544552, -0.004471002612262964, 0.00957837700843811, -0.031597185879945755, 0.011774850077927113, 0.05866791680455208, 0.08580789715051651, -0.013899772427976131, -0.030294174328446388, -0.0018421659478917718, 0.03497364744544029, -0.007111908867955208, -0.10128189623355865, 0.02114054746925831, -0.020402265712618828, -0.03843049705028534, -0.010216349735856056, 0.007731339894235134, -0.06880868971347809, 0.03145908936858177, 0.013649923726916313, -0.04083046689629555, -0.03078845515847206, -0.03669280931353569, 0.01673099957406521, 0.019509384408593178, 0.011827881447970867, 0.03925660252571106, -0.007332473061978817, -0.02796138823032379, 0.02251139096915722, -0.042593084275722504, 0.032163266092538834, -0.003759528510272503, -0.003898629453033209, -0.06373929977416992, 0.004047009162604809, 0.0008068741299211979, 0.009415608830749989, -0.003560789627954364, 0.046548034995794296, -0.02397012896835804, -0.013802723959088326, 0.030530180782079697, 0.01696244440972805, 0.03736807405948639, 0.05083155632019043, 0.02595248818397522, 0.017944956198334694, 0.007332358974963427, -0.008803978562355042, 0.039583709090948105, 0.020222818478941917, 0.00599240604788065, 0.0079619400203228, -0.04338546469807625, 0.011607754975557327, -0.06387534737586975, -0.0548502616584301, 0.035128623247146606, -0.04244126379489899, 0.07596708089113235, -0.035677555948495865, 0.03134883567690849, 0.0025552192237228155, 0.004643592517822981, -0.006169415544718504, 0.02447141520678997, -0.032695721834897995, 0.030685685575008392, -0.08461034297943115, 0.03433922305703163, 0.024586357176303864, -0.008789370767772198, -0.07527846097946167, -0.032864633947610855, 0.04385387897491455, 0.009135930798947811, -0.012713541276752949, -0.023612130433321, -0.008056358434259892, 0.003971955738961697, -0.05506039038300514, -0.00046952522825449705, 0.041436564177274704, 0.018634000793099403, -0.042785950005054474, -0.04221402853727341, 0.024828476831316948, 0.07543148845434189, 0.013499703258275986, -0.02709975652396679, -0.009629463776946068, -0.04002794250845909, -0.03347126767039299, 0.012079345993697643, 0.03198698163032532, -0.02472313679754734, 0.0034164737444370985, -0.04796650633215904, -0.009295647963881493, 0.04438334330916405, -0.03609687089920044, -0.0036287482362240553, 0.0045103575102984905, -0.006428750231862068, 0.012682481668889523, -0.006943681742995977, 0.045819226652383804, 0.008234083652496338, 0.03067089430987835, -0.03889341652393341, 0.0029342665802687407, -0.019549421966075897, -0.006486530415713787, 0.019659321755170822, 0.03408108651638031, 0.0058419532142579556, 0.019805051386356354, 0.052984051406383514, -0.04753821715712547, 0.0003910900850314647, -0.0040471251122653484, -0.026794202625751495, 0.024538932368159294, 0.020987089723348618, 0.023705560714006424, 0.02546156570315361, 0.022248761728405952, -0.007651735097169876, -0.022420091554522514, -0.06901181489229202, 0.012082734145224094, 0.07177166640758514, 0.011945360340178013, 0.026917362585663795, 0.03291967883706093, 0.01419401541352272, -0.0011227269424125552, -0.018427660688757896, -0.03732338175177574, -0.044529546052217484, 0.007393333595246077, 0.06214631721377373, 0.013615665026009083, -0.00006075998317101039, 0.019082481041550636, 0.034278009086847305, 0.0005942279822193086, 0.03547276556491852, 0.03824448585510254, -0.03760484978556633, 0.0015617083990946412, -0.006211169064044952, -0.03299878165125847, 0.03809162974357605, -0.040140166878700256, 0.021502070128917694, -0.02539847046136856, 0.022147083654999733, 0.04699181020259857, -0.011042415164411068, 0.0038172288332134485, -0.04402954876422882, -0.019705183804035187, -0.025343874469399452, 0.02315135858952999, -0.020443854853510857, 0.012521791271865368, -0.016429081559181213, -0.046404771506786346, 0.0102601433172822, -0.008989066816866398, 0.04519864171743393, -0.024567656219005585, -0.0682007297873497, -0.04365991801023483, -0.035857927054166794, -0.011317959986627102, 0.030925415456295013, 0.009792495518922806, -0.032637208700180054, 0.005677337292581797, -0.031703975051641464, 0.0636153444647789, 0.00010156483040191233, 0.016639141365885735, -0.005723959766328335, 0.06353809684515, 0.011319899931550026, 0.02562244050204754, 0.024600518867373466, -0.004561463836580515, 0.14706768095493317, 0.02507931739091873, -0.032275862991809845, -0.015318389050662518, 0.02589932642877102, -0.013755455613136292, 0.002677074633538723, 0.03657880797982216, 0.016103291884064674, 0.0005223358748480678, 0.024696247652173042, 0.010752440430223942, 0.025545688346028328, -0.0017868325812742114, -0.02388148568570614, 0.03603769466280937, -0.025692909955978394, -0.03710104897618294, 0.007676797918975353, 0.009722163900732994, -0.015153372660279274, -0.01579085923731327, -0.042814094573259354, 0.036008596420288086, 0.018573150038719177, -0.008625540882349014, -0.05527254939079285, -0.020867109298706055, -0.008027063682675362, -0.031153621152043343, -0.031685855239629745, -0.001472192001529038, 0.03265735134482384, -0.02594815567135811, -0.026879025623202324, -0.00599247170612216, 0.012900241650640965, -0.033864378929138184, -0.009080002084374428, 0.03459623083472252, -0.0173618383705616, -0.010878050699830055, 0.0006937950965948403, 0.01690007746219635, -0.025795474648475647, -0.017377587035298347, -0.03620998188853264, 0.024341482669115067, -0.012732548639178276, 0.024001358076930046, -0.04553229361772537, 0.000721842865459621, -0.013678350485861301, -0.0447167344391346, 0.02314373478293419, 0.028339769691228867, 0.017602410167455673, -0.0437474399805069, -0.03215950354933739, -0.024504827335476875, -0.00486590014770627, -0.0039250534027814865, 0.02547794207930565, 0.030926350504159927, 0.01558087207376957, -0.003109477460384369, 0.025644652545452118, 0.018352624028921127, -0.0023959169629961252, 0.005160081200301647, 0.0031872799154371023, -0.009082785807549953, -0.014487777836620808, 0.020791592076420784, 0.008561945520341396, 0.023450268432497978, 0.023137638345360756, 0.004693292547017336, 0.001254187198355794, -0.0061171455308794975, -0.0190549548715353, 0.024693019688129425, -0.016530361026525497, 0.000831400218885392, -0.039073895663022995, 0.01468371506780386, -0.03733844310045242, 0.07506472617387772, -0.0020374422892928123, 0.01809990406036377, 0.02673519402742386, 0.020709315314888954, 0.027530845254659653, -0.06747853755950928, 0.019362423568964005, -0.005264463368803263, -0.029806960374116898, -0.008844789117574692, 0.005886745639145374, 0.09171454608440399, 0.040045641362667084, 0.02464354783296585, -0.02419419027864933, 0.007792739197611809, 0.0006865322357043624, 0.0347723662853241, 0.0022056088782846928, -0.05715620890259743, 0.0306097399443388, 0.0032926714047789574, -0.0009901243029162288, -0.05944165587425232, -0.013789443299174309, -0.006520296446979046, -0.027653418481349945, 0.010026004165410995, -0.007833714596927166, -0.014080055989325047, 0.002150067361071706, -0.018039250746369362, 0.02953042834997177, -0.0323699451982975, 0.0014742347411811352, -0.005481282714754343, 0.008471585810184479, -0.019142135977745056, 0.00987315084785223, -0.04151653125882149, 0.018110565841197968, 0.00029470608569681644, -0.012088064104318619, 0.030918050557374954, 0.00034060777397826314, 0.04059566929936409, -0.0245851818472147, 0.020153261721134186, -0.012004261836409569, 0.03874605894088745, -0.043468426913022995, -0.008207439444959164, 0.058139681816101074, -0.07035715132951736, -0.03164501115679741, 0.007597841788083315, -0.008103237487375736, 0.029331820085644722, 0.01977485977113247, -0.004442789126187563, 0.014934355393052101, 0.04013967514038086, -0.05773577094078064, -0.05850457400083542, -0.020885642617940903, -0.031200770288705826, 0.004140922334045172, -0.008164986036717892, -0.007866717875003815, -0.019378066062927246, -0.003294602269306779, 0.03775135427713394, 0.022217513993382454, -0.009848236106336117, -0.007126886397600174, 0.01775028556585312, 0.020280566066503525, -0.013585958629846573, 0.007363309618085623, 0.024852877482771873, -0.030983850359916687, 0.06258147209882736, -0.039698634296655655, 0.03457324951887131, -0.02710729092359543, 0.020000172778964043, -0.09898461401462555, -0.05154336616396904, -0.004443300422281027, -0.02903374470770359, 0.03350298851728439, -0.05946239456534386, -0.015465803444385529, 0.02597437985241413, -0.08248990029096603, 0.04608751833438873, -0.01705428771674633, -0.029376622289419174, -0.014643476344645023, 0.022590279579162598, -0.00828427355736494, 0.039440903812646866, -0.002957112155854702, 0.029933413490653038, 0.027119234204292297, 0.01097229402512312, 0.019795892760157585, -0.01409049704670906, -0.031831078231334686, 0.009702258743345737, 0.009857461787760258, -0.04754522070288658, 0.019377008080482483, -0.018595492467284203, -0.025146609172225, 0.04653459042310715, 0.005801368970423937, 0.023047281429171562, 0.01841055229306221, 0.020386772230267525, -0.03361302241683006, 0.049443673342466354, 0.02435898594558239, -0.009540243074297905, -0.01874259114265442, 0.009993593208491802, 0.021607723087072372, 0.002525273710489273, 0.010584614239633083, -0.01191560085862875, 0.08313193917274475, -0.013270550407469273, 0.03455888852477074, 0.01766791194677353, -0.004873527679592371, -0.05355855077505112, 0.016725938767194748, 0.014938306994736195, -0.007580749224871397, -0.03705093264579773, 0.027639899402856827, -0.032834216952323914, -0.030503002926707268, 0.026268525049090385, 0.034948818385601044, -0.01130661740899086, 0.016362562775611877, -0.01818758249282837, -0.02894056960940361, -0.009543309919536114, 0.007148010190576315, -0.02365908958017826, -0.030859628692269325, -0.01260980125516653, 0.0023003648966550827, 0.02068999409675598, -0.001508177723735571, -0.02353771962225437, -0.04939604923129082, 0.03030710481107235, -0.00928056612610817, 0.040812898427248, 0.024471983313560486, -0.04157286509871483, 0.010647507384419441, -0.06423982977867126, 0.06409553438425064, -0.0068464637733995914, 0.0017568444600328803, -0.05518566444516182, -0.01171727105975151, -0.015301711857318878, -0.015384837985038757, 0.03800162300467491, 0.03229546919465065, 0.01764295995235443, -0.021070094779133797, 0.015374097973108292, 0.02844582311809063, -0.0551936998963356, 0.019814657047390938, -0.002011539414525032, -0.01452609058469534, 0.00018319126684218645, -0.025397781282663345, 0.023065058514475822, -0.011964544653892517, -0.015011942945420742, 0.007338926661759615, 0.027401152998209, -0.010542305186390877, -0.009535796009004116, 0.03985808789730072, 0.020910553634166718, -0.002358547179028392, 0.030677733942866325, -0.03362972289323807, 0.014668597839772701, 0.032188110053539276, 0.016780801117420197, -0.041593603789806366, -0.021102402359247208, -0.03998642414808273, -0.03817816078662872, -0.004373532719910145, -0.00328517216257751, 0.039824068546295166, -0.047949016094207764, -0.05082837864756584, 0.04184335470199585, -0.026820393279194832, 0.0005447329021990299, 0.035447124391794205, 0.007681877352297306, 0.027174701914191246, -0.025723934173583984, -0.019925789907574654, -0.001479804515838623, 0.000608742528129369, -0.02226991578936577, 0.01020469143986702, -0.03265197202563286, -0.027146609500050545, 0.022245649248361588, 0.008818741887807846, -0.01785314828157425, 0.013076483272016048, 0.010779998265206814, 0.04707967862486839, -0.016946658492088318, -0.07832556217908859, -0.013475492596626282, -0.011324017308652401, 0.00818888284265995, -0.015007649548351765, -0.018597474321722984, 0.07635369151830673, -0.00261469604447484, 0.012174119241535664, -0.01774047687649727, -0.022865058854222298, -0.05820373445749283, -0.008162179030478, -0.01706647127866745, 0.04722577705979347, -0.01731952279806137, -0.04186511039733887, -0.00993735808879137, 0.0022844623308628798, 0.04968107119202614, -0.025565130636096, 0.026601212099194527, 0.001768887392245233, -0.004537558648735285, -0.04474932700395584, -0.011542019434273243, 0.0033077832777053118, -0.022789370268583298, 0.026243366301059723, 0.029068106785416603, 0.0046018254943192005, 0.02390563115477562, -0.02936387062072754, 0.021765803918242455, 0.0697520449757576, -0.048960600048303604, -0.007488580886274576, -0.014534804970026016, -0.018450964242219925, -0.020690394565463066, -0.04199383407831192 ]
<p>Related to <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/50537/should-one-remove-highly-correlated-variables-before-doing-pca">Should one remove highly correlated variables before doing PCA?</a>, PCA is used a lot in population genetics to essentially cluster individuals into ethnic group based on their genetic markers (SNPs). These SNPs may be highly correlated (linkage disequilibrium, LD), and hence are usually thinned to make them roughly independent. They can also be regressed on each other (<a href="http://www.plosgenetics.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pgen.0020190" rel="nofollow">http://www.plosgenetics.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pgen.0020190</a>) to make them even more independent before doing PCA. But these regressions are slightly "suspect" since the samples are not independent, which is what we're trying to estimate in the first place!</p> <p>So this "chicken and egg" problem seems to suggest an EM-like iterative approach where you first try to estimate SNP relatedness using the samples, then sample relatedness using the SNPs, and repeat. Does this approach make sense and is it already used in some areas?</p>
36,301
[ -0.04736202210187912, 0.0176155436784029, 0.028956497088074684, 0.0016228107269853354, 0.02940342389047146, 0.006657535210251808, -0.04942545294761658, -0.007742791436612606, 0.038823917508125305, -0.038324564695358276, 0.0426434762775898, 0.031571630388498306, 0.04796610027551651, 0.002977928379550576, 0.01200305949896574, 0.00880921445786953, -0.02870047837495804, 0.025750506669282913, 0.015831248834729195, -0.016430465504527092, 0.03348172456026077, 0.017326653003692627, 0.01709185168147087, 0.009422059170901775, -0.023651491850614548, 0.04087367281317711, 0.031249869614839554, -0.06940250843763351, 0.010988796129822731, 0.04654820263385773, -0.05570343881845474, -0.011071650311350822, 0.030921123921871185, 0.03904053196310997, 0.028815550729632378, -0.005012563895434141, -0.005818485282361507, -0.003112316597253084, 0.01292805653065443, 0.09030220657587051, -0.017292972654104233, -0.04870041087269783, -0.02826383151113987, 0.016005754470825195, -0.005620843265205622, 0.027151625603437424, 0.011318676173686981, -0.055776435881853104, 0.002003525849431753, -0.04461057856678963, 0.0947260707616806, -0.007495136931538582, 0.004177407827228308, 0.014079507440328598, -0.010754667222499847, -0.012459957972168922, 0.03746561333537102, 0.04521165043115616, 0.004295343067497015, -0.06854955852031708, 0.004808431025594473, -0.012661167420446873, -0.001197234494611621, 0.007076587062329054, -0.058571040630340576, 0.04616968333721161, 0.005875404924154282, -0.0017194318352267146, 0.05105159059166908, -0.028803158551454544, 0.032381635159254074, 0.014744742773473263, 0.05029783025383949, 0.006266888231039047, 0.010320611298084259, -0.015076556243002415, -0.018437795341014862, 0.030506040900945663, 0.026653898879885674, 0.011697953566908836, -0.0300094373524189, 0.0026032591704279184, 0.0016243550926446915, 0.01756829395890236, 0.016201024875044823, -0.017751365900039673, 0.02991560846567154, -0.04422402381896973, -0.021376926451921463, 0.0017293149139732122, -0.00533519359305501, -0.001473141834139824, 0.06157320737838745, 0.005544161889702082, -0.0597328320145607, 0.046126872301101685, -0.02234022319316864, 0.047375425696372986, -0.0067721582017838955, -0.010849538259208202, -0.022691896185278893, -0.049899082630872726, 0.013407683931291103, 0.03169466182589531, -0.032199013978242874, -0.013448174111545086, -0.044466495513916016, 0.007914014160633087, -0.017518265172839165, -0.025855956599116325, -0.0020927004516124725, -0.01986607350409031, 0.016115013509988785, -0.015724219381809235, 0.03572943061590195, 0.021094102412462234, 0.004522044211626053, 0.007941776886582375, 0.061796121299266815, 0.07628631591796875, 0.01922386698424816, -0.01166579034179449, 0.016140779480338097, -0.02306089550256729, -0.03749053552746773, 0.0020982122514396906, 0.03712986037135124, -0.02703758142888546, -0.028569141402840614, 0.0759393721818924, 0.030929850414395332, -0.02085641212761402, 0.06096450611948967, -0.005576612893491983, 0.02992052398622036, 0.01484971959143877, -0.06960887461900711, -0.05083591490983963, 0.06186145544052124, -0.04048088937997818, -0.0032461052760481834, -0.08694395422935486, 0.042592115700244904, -0.007984810508787632, 0.07761474698781967, -0.01935243047773838, 0.03519466146826744, -0.01593376323580742, 0.0491633266210556, 0.017584223300218582, -0.010727335698902607, -0.046252597123384476, -0.022276706993579865, -0.013486812822520733, -0.031468529254198074, -0.07164569944143295, 0.020887097343802452, 0.028930967673659325, -0.007291433867067099, 0.019283700734376907, 0.04151593893766403, 0.0027642562054097652, 0.003174268640577793, -0.051034413278102875, 0.003082544542849064, -0.033832333981990814, 0.07726266235113144, -0.01555147860199213, 0.003001840552315116, 0.03712984547019005, -0.015749642625451088, 0.05497013032436371, 0.019580384716391563, 0.039157964289188385, 0.03015848621726036, -0.01594056934118271, 0.01550096645951271, 0.007665324956178665, 0.023274483159184456, 0.012203359976410866, -0.050067998468875885, -0.02732134610414505, 0.014702023938298225, 0.01661909744143486, 0.06882256269454956, 0.06488832086324692, 0.0057372599840164185, -0.08261166512966156, 0.04117833450436592, -0.02342870645225048, -0.050783779472112656, -0.07792869955301285, -0.0068833171389997005, -0.004436718299984932, -0.005456696264445782, 0.036468829959630966, -0.03557107225060463, 0.002645065076649189, -0.01654103212058544, -0.02383803203701973, -0.05343259871006012, -0.0052216448821127415, 0.051573287695646286, -0.03475407138466835, -0.0023625551257282495, 0.05337335541844368, 0.03643162548542023, -0.035693295300006866, 0.03633950278162956, -0.05688829347491264, -0.07332686334848404, 0.007157716900110245, -0.03695552796125412, 0.024616647511720657, 0.002266465686261654, 0.013063585385680199, 0.003505089320242405, -0.003856841241940856, -0.045099712908267975, -0.012849897146224976, -0.0538744181394577, 0.06128622591495514, 0.033835556358098984, -0.011198170483112335, -0.014531676657497883, -0.007732326630502939, 0.027582094073295593, -0.000285901827737689, -0.034338925033807755, 0.008430699817836285, -0.05278876796364784, -0.01619803160429001, 0.055121731013059616, 0.005440227687358856, -0.06110314279794693, -0.016490289941430092, 0.03708597272634506, 0.054393377155065536, -0.0014513569185510278, 0.007392706349492073, 0.004872757941484451, -0.041108183562755585, 0.011181765235960484, 0.015518169850111008, -0.03288612887263298, 0.0005118284025229514, -0.015352108515799046, -0.03215854987502098, 0.03464144095778465, 0.010130204260349274, -0.0026886046398431063, 0.03841787204146385, -0.0011252545518800616, -0.033997274935245514, -0.013684133999049664, 0.0024882815778255463, 0.054097022861242294, -0.026267467066645622, 0.023948287591338158, 0.032639507204294205, 0.014694834128022194, -0.02523166313767433, -0.006834635976701975, -0.03789666295051575, -0.0012351355981081724, 0.026723038405179977, -0.07163430750370026, 0.04842536896467209, 0.009074321016669273, -0.01608625240623951, -0.007629684638231993, -0.031640104949474335, -0.03371163830161095, -0.02159961126744747, 0.02635885402560234, 0.05204365402460098, -0.007315304130315781, 0.06267201155424118, -0.03112780675292015, -0.03710905835032463, 0.01294577494263649, -0.03638233616948128, -0.0038986632134765387, 0.0006023142486810684, -0.09760039299726486, -0.012030049227178097, -0.01640951633453369, 0.008299684152007103, -0.004432092420756817, 0.01862012967467308, 0.0016039155889302492, 0.019961992278695107, 0.014551150612533092, -0.06337185204029083, -0.0387989841401577, -0.01356537826359272, -0.005599877797067165, -0.004420428071171045, -0.0385773591697216, 0.029682407155632973, 0.008482499979436398, -0.01634618081152439, 0.00022906134836375713, -0.02602536790072918, -0.01711161807179451, -0.02093019336462021, -0.02640366181731224, 0.01429141778498888, 0.008036934770643711, -0.008220812305808067, 0.024742232635617256, -0.03453146293759346, -0.024252746254205704, -0.045501891523599625, -0.0839683786034584, 0.0400359071791172, -0.024281781166791916, 0.045246195048093796, 0.029178820550441742, -0.033417750149965286, 0.05324311554431915, -0.001008822931908071, -0.00270948582328856, -0.012854507192969322, -0.004897823557257652, -0.042722418904304504, -0.020376211032271385, -0.02380218915641308, 0.017075393348932266, 0.015465296804904938, 0.014103266410529613, -0.012756899930536747, 0.03280129283666611, 0.043069496750831604, 0.012939050793647766, -0.0031205937266349792, 0.03355475142598152, -0.010016520507633686, -0.0019084521336480975, 0.021138399839401245, 0.024832991883158684, -0.012470158748328686, 0.02052181214094162, 0.025341594591736794, 0.0067355032078921795, -0.014431341551244259, -0.024389099329710007, -0.016671663150191307, -0.013755468651652336, 0.011423883959650993, -0.026977773755788803, 0.010085025802254677, 0.042590200901031494, -0.018518520519137383, 0.006481815129518509, 0.031385935842990875, 0.04875776544213295, -0.007094891741871834, 0.006150286179035902, 0.04205749183893204, 0.010603769682347775, 0.007754283957183361, 0.03578392416238785, 0.004416358657181263, -0.009258455596864223, 0.008252779953181744, 0.002919499296694994, 0.007488475181162357, 0.032925523817539215, 0.0292238537222147, 0.015873078256845474, -0.028318539261817932, -0.06265997141599655, 0.02154398150742054, -0.08605226129293442, 0.039173152297735214, -0.050281934440135956, 0.021689893677830696, -0.025378989055752754, 0.05165117233991623, 0.024362266063690186, -0.025639528408646584, -0.02468150481581688, 0.04397016763687134, -0.07031181454658508, -0.023630620911717415, -0.02606402151286602, -0.0015524036716669798, -0.01386452466249466, -0.009994709864258766, 0.04788300767540932, 0.018584690988063812, 0.01981816068291664, -0.022184573113918304, 0.02594946324825287, -0.02437305636703968, 0.006616523489356041, -0.020778385922312737, -0.009694619104266167, -0.010494193993508816, 0.002056958619505167, 0.035369161516427994, 0.005073764827102423, 0.04030272737145424, 0.023541506379842758, -0.022925937548279762, -0.010116643272340298, 0.00684568053111434, 0.0074903047643601894, 0.022076556459069252, 0.016980310901999474, -0.02371794544160366, 0.049197278916835785, -0.018123170360922813, 0.021353142336010933, -0.01726471073925495, 0.03770729526877403, 0.056938380002975464, -0.0021871787030249834, 0.009679511189460754, -0.03161783888936043, -0.053135886788368225, 0.007749305572360754, 0.03396641090512276, 0.011336677707731724, -0.0017113431822508574, 0.029993638396263123, 0.019386211410164833, -0.04645407572388649, -0.006659271195530891, 0.04995317384600639, 0.03637038171291351, -0.006094551645219326, -0.01587141864001751, -0.00632688170298934, 0.00393705815076828, -0.01580401137471199, 0.045867472887039185, 0.005795700009912252, -0.006167643703520298, -0.028246719390153885, 0.00842037983238697, 0.0010609966702759266, -0.0033426755107939243, -0.014819259755313396, 0.016904192045331, 0.054399047046899796, -0.00751024903729558, -0.04200159013271332, -0.0002929283946286887, 0.040823888033628464, 0.022911015897989273, 0.032772887498140335, -0.009319172240793705, -0.08144351840019226, 0.020199082791805267, 0.02639251947402954, 0.04907131940126419, -0.0685323178768158, -0.005612863693386316, -0.03932800516486168, -0.018099075183272362, 0.040648091584444046, -0.012854601256549358, 0.016331447288393974, -0.011489071883261204, 0.004103483632206917, -0.02378246746957302, -0.040956176817417145, -0.07201001048088074, 0.01928366906940937, 0.018310315907001495, 0.02371167205274105, -0.018137222155928612, -0.055217813700437546, -0.04989688843488693, 0.009240369312465191, 0.0034045055508613586, 0.07765282690525055, -0.001416004728525877, -0.020646454766392708, 0.0018964634509757161, 0.033546335995197296, -0.0030993556138128042, -0.04579318314790726, 0.01909775473177433, -0.017536113038659096, -0.029261013492941856, 0.044212277978658676, -0.03668931871652603, -0.06498122960329056, 0.05009610950946808, 0.011481884866952896, 0.00835491344332695, -0.005991153419017792, -0.007222570478916168, 0.05708003416657448, 0.027791867032647133, -0.04235610365867615, 0.0775822177529335, 0.04312398284673691, -0.03285738080739975, -0.006715651135891676, -0.02465861476957798, -0.005874586291611195, -0.049127690494060516, 0.006373089272528887, -0.037883684039115906, -0.018045859411358833, -0.016945242881774902, 0.022329263389110565, -0.022784201428294182, 0.03147369995713234, -0.028109459206461906, 0.027436072006821632, 0.02486530691385269, 0.03234220668673515, -0.05791935697197914, 0.009734917432069778, 0.0037254723720252514, 0.029152831062674522, 0.0047892979346215725, -0.0022990433499217033, 0.019224392250180244, 0.002535636303946376, 0.0007091761217452586, -0.015182281844317913, -0.024900810793042183, -0.022151105105876923, -0.025295143947005272, -0.0311584435403347, 0.01200443971902132, -0.037029847502708435, 0.0510796457529068, -0.01376261468976736, 0.04561581835150719, 0.023399874567985535, -0.033423446118831635, 0.022730570286512375, 0.014204858802258968, -0.004873010329902172, 0.0449487678706646, -0.043925803154706955, 0.06254614144563675, -0.04040375351905823, -0.009754412807524204, -0.039299383759498596, -0.03825865685939789, -0.013449697755277157, -0.0018830597400665283, -0.013043079525232315, -0.08283494412899017, 0.003854422364383936, -0.02865966409444809, -0.02193586714565754, 0.011903399601578712, 0.051025908440351486, -0.04437461122870445, -0.014347161166369915, 0.01632389985024929, 0.027919132262468338, 0.08119206130504608, -0.011865995824337006, -0.04007316008210182, 0.006048392504453659, -0.0476933978497982, -0.0006727370200678706, -0.02968660742044449, 0.0063493759371340275, -0.039637427777051926, 0.01535299327224493, -0.03771257773041725, 0.006371424067765474, 0.04361573979258537, -0.022562654688954353, -0.032959748059511185, 0.020386379212141037, 0.008596284314990044, 0.017901550978422165, -0.027379097416996956, 0.004775580484420061, 0.005679370369762182, 0.013577383942902088, -0.003061422612518072, 0.0169522687792778, 0.003964867442846298, -0.006909942254424095, 0.031893037259578705, 0.017717696726322174, -0.015777459368109703, 0.007627137005329132, 0.06048257276415825, -0.02803615666925907, 0.04345192760229111, -0.017541339620947838, 0.0016624381532892585, 0.05412382632493973, 0.000029569622711278498, 0.01585632748901844, -0.023871848359704018, 0.023591138422489166, -0.020076969638466835, -0.013303497806191444, -0.026814516633749008, -0.006518997717648745, 0.07974068075418472, -0.010845747776329517, 0.03622623160481453, 0.06540938466787338, -0.010229268111288548, 0.022453950718045235, -0.0271527711302042, 0.007577392738312483, -0.01664585992693901, 0.0032236953265964985, 0.04896154627203941, -0.01205923780798912, -0.0027972336392849684, 0.05401616171002388, 0.01216475386172533, 0.01971305161714554, 0.023209858685731888, 0.00034792962833307683, 0.0027615332510322332, 0.034689366817474365, -0.012849151156842709, -0.058543138206005096, 0.0009247276466339827, -0.040151920169591904, 0.004512433893978596, 0.004063036292791367, -0.029808159917593002, 0.06255418807268143, 0.05460386350750923, -0.0007431712583638728, -0.06164998188614845, -0.03294902294874191, -0.048609208315610886, 0.024673372507095337, 0.012902646325528622, -0.004091389011591673, 0.056866005063056946, -0.036148324608802795, -0.004472431261092424, 0.0005297011230140924, 0.008547217585146427, -0.043631695210933685, -0.05969773232936859, -0.030075373128056526, -0.003117778804153204, 0.011941956356167793, 0.03305494785308838, -0.0022954586893320084, -0.05306575447320938, 0.051629289984703064, -0.012483175843954086, -0.00664567481726408, -0.01582314819097519, 0.05804810672998428, -0.03956495225429535, 0.08022955805063248, 0.019803471863269806, 0.021732809022068977, -0.008677582256495953, -0.027904300019145012, 0.10114068537950516, 0.07045488804578781, 0.05106038600206375, -0.030707241967320442, 0.04813458025455475, -0.011072062887251377, -0.018365228548645973, -0.03770879656076431, -0.008115600794553757, 0.007415707688778639, -0.008313335478305817, 0.04961925372481346, 0.06438646465539932, 0.03577384352684021, 0.019050374627113342, 0.0668809711933136, -0.0245536956936121, -0.03137829154729843, -0.013409099541604519, -0.013045158237218857, 0.007029738277196884, -0.04692937061190605, 0.0005585937178693712, 0.00024885739549063146, 0.010068884119391441, -0.022044014185667038, -0.020894018933176994, -0.006468723528087139, -0.014392017386853695, -0.01989606022834778, -0.012568426318466663, 0.00007831037510186434, 0.04229564592242241, 0.03044343926012516, -0.03284488618373871, 0.016785625368356705, 0.01757090538740158, -0.037140216678380966, -0.0062117683701217175, 0.008063949644565582, 0.0016170769231393933, -0.01679408736526966, 0.030728880316019058, 0.019835447892546654, -0.03309948742389679, -0.03153778612613678, -0.024963317438960075, 0.0477399006485939, -0.02401226945221424, -0.004079474601894617, -0.023448465391993523, -0.022569848224520683, 0.03973999619483948, -0.04131326451897621, 0.007230140268802643, 0.025672316551208496, 0.018592046573758125, 0.004215163644403219, 0.0011099036782979965, -0.04580260440707207, 0.019572429358959198, -0.017839111387729645, 0.035866837948560715, 0.021439051255583763, -0.007920671254396439, -0.02461327239871025, -0.018833141773939133, 0.06565390527248383, 0.005217717960476875, -0.0038570542819797993, -0.022305473685264587, -0.02437610551714897, 0.010171978734433651, -0.0017682969337329268, 0.026869768276810646, 0.008163395337760448, 0.047903090715408325, -0.03524378314614296, -0.00835955236107111, -0.019763339310884476, -0.024177365005016327, 0.045657750219106674, -0.03457171469926834, -0.009764092043042183, -0.04986719787120819, -0.0020699610468000174, 0.03691233694553375, 0.05165315419435501, 0.017305994406342506, 0.03792697191238403, -0.03237861394882202, 0.06848369538784027, 0.00015909801004454494, -0.04475092887878418, -0.002521237125620246, -0.04239882156252861, -0.028300201520323753, -0.00816955603659153, 0.02950204536318779, 0.05010209605097771, 0.04033948481082916, 0.019245309755206108, -0.01546553522348404, 0.013591592200100422, 0.003973325714468956, 0.024473829194903374, 0.013289936818182468, -0.06305195391178131, 0.03304825723171234, -0.03208015859127045, -0.01581287942826748, -0.022280316799879074, -0.003808294888585806, -0.021516764536499977, -0.008880219422280788, -0.0002539533015806228, -0.042028117924928665, -0.0529048852622509, -0.01050475798547268, -0.012005121447145939, 0.04245563596487045, -0.032775651663541794, -0.006682038307189941, -0.042255789041519165, -0.014222887344658375, -0.01058556605130434, -0.03244955092668533, 0.013397463597357273, 0.028777791187167168, 0.016757121309638023, 0.04390041157603264, 0.04577239230275154, 0.005112144164741039, 0.04888790845870972, 0.000230746969464235, 0.017539270222187042, -0.010118665173649788, 0.03391076251864433, -0.044162552803754807, -0.012069269083440304, 0.02679361030459404, -0.04522357136011124, -0.038093362003564835, 0.020545069128274918, -0.016773398965597153, 0.03420311585068703, -0.0055017718113958836, -0.00938743818551302, -0.008129489608108997, 0.04368099197745323, -0.007796343881636858, 0.0014267434598878026, -0.007278602570295334, 0.01646602526307106, -0.006413837894797325, -0.0013716650428250432, 0.012388036586344242, 0.011728241108357906, -0.006095509510487318, 0.04292425885796547, 0.04338541999459267, 0.007681539282202721, -0.033549681305885315, 0.03093523345887661, -0.015651032328605652, 0.0006170598790049553, -0.03378653526306152, -0.0032660439610481262, 0.03335641697049141, 0.04184916615486145, -0.010131146758794785, 0.007949953898787498, -0.03891956806182861, 0.009938199073076248, -0.0691886767745018, -0.02654782123863697, -0.05413263291120529, 0.008050907403230667, 0.008165660314261913, -0.03789890557527542, -0.008866516873240471, 0.015005463734269142, -0.06727178394794464, 0.014661344699561596, 0.020636020228266716, 0.003544144332408905, -0.009251691401004791, 0.04401406645774841, -0.004936392419040203, 0.013806179165840149, -0.006392424926161766, 0.04930584877729416, 0.04476434364914894, 0.02452184446156025, -0.007516198791563511, -0.024196015670895576, -0.02478131093084812, -0.010227823629975319, -0.012408364564180374, -0.05569705739617348, 0.039308350533246994, -0.0031652641482651234, -0.04158802330493927, -0.0012584107462316751, -0.015908150002360344, 0.04564976319670677, 0.025198133662343025, 0.03193582966923714, 0.006216500885784626, -0.012521092779934406, 0.041064076125621796, -0.007118952926248312, -0.021375756710767746, -0.016944071277976036, 0.017384186387062073, 0.04518832266330719, -0.019527452066540718, 0.04304436594247818, 0.00988015066832304, 0.004549339413642883, -0.01425714511424303, -0.0022470245603471994, -0.020732181146740913, -0.006795697379857302, -0.01536303386092186, -0.0008904240094125271, -0.013585658743977547, 0.014300248585641384, 0.02950695902109146, -0.03066769801080227, -0.0314861424267292, 0.02321551740169525, 0.02864648588001728, -0.0217453483492136, 0.030237432569265366, -0.008884924463927746, -0.04822002351284027, 0.014772789552807808, -0.0018560157623142004, 0.021799316629767418, -0.05198490619659424, 0.0023237979039549828, 0.030753880739212036, -0.030508778989315033, -0.054553862661123276, -0.034657638520002365, -0.043857865035533905, 0.04597848653793335, -0.027135848999023438, 0.01121602300554514, 0.03925168514251709, 0.01625755801796913, 0.04007650911808014, -0.060265980660915375, 0.0670175701379776, -0.005147996824234724, -0.018896443769335747, -0.024005910381674767, -0.012308119796216488, 0.006810733582824469, 0.012821950949728489, 0.02395724691450596, -0.018295949324965477, 0.028925934806466103, -0.008269887417554855, 0.003629224607720971, 0.004624077584594488, 0.0017526962328702211, 0.05203962326049805, 0.025565216317772865, 0.02227027527987957, -0.02734505757689476, -0.009005434811115265, 0.02229013293981552, 0.004084417596459389, 0.01916779950261116, -0.012936249375343323, -0.008464720100164413, 0.02748081460595131, 0.030320480465888977, 0.01751774735748768, 0.007287577260285616, -0.0019473211141303182, 0.017404817044734955, 0.028363903984427452, 0.01024352852255106, 0.038794636726379395, -0.007860101759433746, -0.045317523181438446, 0.029868528246879578, -0.038966674357652664, -0.04437579959630966, 0.001549969194456935, 0.0476393885910511, 0.003914515022188425, -0.05649610981345177, 0.019393639639019966, -0.002248497912660241, -0.0317293144762516, 0.004384889733046293, 0.022287946194410324, -0.004645231645554304, -0.00783993024379015, 0.013993135653436184, 0.014308664947748184, 0.02593710459768772, -0.028352169319987297, 0.015399194322526455, 0.021949222311377525, 0.031369127333164215, -0.013499276712536812, 0.002305911388248205, 0.002921148668974638, 0.014003717340528965, 0.01779593713581562, -0.025467026978731155, 0.034234900027513504, -0.0682552382349968, 0.0012730011949315667, 0.013999027200043201, 0.019578730687499046, 0.027903428301215172, 0.02111508883535862, -0.030377203598618507, 0.0487954281270504, -0.013032848946750164, -0.010090043768286705, -0.009691325947642326, 0.017916105687618256, -0.000939490448217839, -0.0033352880273014307, -0.012187192216515541, 0.01803756132721901, 0.02082248218357563, 0.00444808742031455, -0.026329582557082176, -0.030947566032409668, 0.035514865070581436, -0.0028740998823195696, 0.006208925507962704, -0.023452866822481155, -0.003739620093256235, -0.001363204326480627, -0.036177631467580795, 0.00783946830779314, -0.014044282957911491, 0.0374886579811573, 0.0295394454151392, 0.0005333935841917992, -0.04527047649025917, -0.015552922151982784, -0.003249432658776641, 0.04713575169444084, -0.06111077964305878, -0.006095821037888527, -0.006113990675657988, 0.007678250316530466, -0.027193425223231316, -0.020213905721902847 ]
<p>I was wondering whether the following mechanical selection procedure will result in a possible bias. First let me introduce the first procedure, we start with a model and only look at the t-value and possibly correct them for it (heteroskedasticity / autocorrelation). We then only add variables into our final model that are significant. However I am well aware this gives us a bias with F-test, since even though some variables can be insignificant, they can be jointly significant.</p> <p>However if we also take that into account, whether adding that variable gives us a "sensible" subset to do a F-test on and only add them if they give a significant result (indicating joinly significance), this would then actually be a pretty good automated method or does this give some bias? Will anything happen that we do <strong>not</strong> like to have? </p> <p>Furthermore is a forward variable selection (starting with small set and increase it) better or backwards variable selection better? </p> <p>Thanks for you answer!</p>
36,302
[ -0.019763024523854256, -0.0012510863598436117, 0.014046967029571533, 0.014283877797424793, 0.034566495567560196, 0.03835996612906456, -0.005100663285702467, -0.029888004064559937, 0.025641389191150665, -0.024794138967990875, -0.003175250720232725, 0.01655374839901924, 0.0318300686776638, -0.01890847459435463, 0.04079469293355942, 0.004844191018491983, -0.02839275449514389, -0.0012905481271445751, 0.015058201737701893, -0.024983620271086693, -0.016158966347575188, 0.020821083337068558, 0.00928187184035778, 0.012229670770466328, -0.018468335270881653, 0.042330510914325714, 0.022206610068678856, -0.0010705735767260194, 0.013282021507620811, 0.032606419175863266, -0.029789799824357033, -0.019606802612543106, 0.026103561744093895, 0.033126652240753174, 0.012731372378766537, -0.00454211188480258, -0.018718162551522255, -0.019884275272488594, 0.010625687427818775, 0.03085526078939438, -0.018386423587799072, -0.031085869297385216, -0.0013158050132915378, 0.023657016456127167, 0.01262012217193842, 0.012803224846720695, -0.02492314763367176, -0.006368646863847971, 0.052912794053554535, -0.04789749160408974, 0.0754106268286705, -0.001572107314132154, 0.04655890539288521, 0.03062540851533413, 0.0172922071069479, -0.02452855557203293, 0.04209781065583229, 0.06752310693264008, -0.026139112189412117, -0.015744900330901146, -0.0008215924026444554, -0.04819873720407486, 0.0037445654161274433, -0.005852098576724529, -0.025962697342038155, 0.032143522053956985, -0.026396432891488075, -0.012426899746060371, 0.048948489129543304, -0.012531604617834091, 0.003994920291006565, 0.00491292541846633, 0.025186073035001755, -0.010413222014904022, 0.001255491399206221, -0.027647852897644043, 0.031884320080280304, 0.019026506692171097, 0.03463868051767349, 0.020629454404115677, -0.0006056900601834059, -0.027135588228702545, 0.04906958341598511, 0.06616050004959106, 0.03545474633574486, 0.01689918525516987, 0.024194424971938133, -0.04177502170205116, 0.028429610654711723, 0.008200588636100292, -0.0388222299516201, -0.007776247337460518, 0.04746635630726814, 0.009015203453600407, -0.040310338139534, 0.03819424286484718, -0.01719297654926777, 0.05470655858516693, 0.00009686327393865213, -0.009017731994390488, -0.04548220708966255, -0.02285749651491642, 0.01934812217950821, 0.05262213200330734, -0.0397786982357502, 0.004575300496071577, -0.01114936824887991, -0.005759254563599825, -0.0011721408227458596, -0.03829798847436905, -0.026400210335850716, -0.00826326198875904, -0.04501892253756523, -0.046974942088127136, 0.06503907591104507, -0.006146418862044811, -0.017733275890350342, -0.046310193836688995, 0.09325863420963287, 0.08432426303625107, 0.06479066610336304, -0.03431571274995804, 0.030897045508027077, -0.01883714087307453, -0.020579323172569275, 0.006970810238271952, 0.026222724467515945, -0.009840141981840134, -0.00510609382763505, 0.04581928998231888, 0.004594883881509304, -0.012544709257781506, 0.03224971145391464, -0.005727680400013924, 0.06148957833647728, -0.0035392283461987972, -0.05744282156229019, -0.048074908554553986, 0.08514443784952164, -0.013854586519300938, 0.048121947795152664, -0.056008417159318924, -0.019323188811540604, 0.046351879835128784, 0.07685306668281555, 0.0149022676050663, 0.035336676985025406, -0.004277842119336128, 0.025666123256087303, 0.007285433355718851, -0.03162128105759621, -0.003949602600187063, -0.029625315219163895, -0.009814596734941006, -0.02286524698138237, -0.11609196662902832, 0.0272239837795496, -0.001987732481211424, -0.011454245075583458, 0.007237221114337444, 0.028003036975860596, -0.012537052854895592, 0.005959646310657263, -0.0010747478809207678, 0.00024038986884988844, -0.010224005207419395, 0.06432974338531494, -0.021226994693279266, 0.02613150328397751, 0.019566960632801056, -0.009380795992910862, -0.0030487305484712124, 0.014125757850706577, 0.043237484991550446, 0.023027289658784866, -0.039024293422698975, 0.001992269651964307, -0.015285591594874859, 0.010231314226984978, -0.01607157476246357, -0.03300509229302406, -0.0472298189997673, -0.03029647096991539, -0.01266530342400074, 0.03877018019556999, 0.04258954897522926, 0.020286740735173225, -0.012879818677902222, 0.05583709850907326, -0.06749778240919113, -0.04603743925690651, -0.06270300596952438, -0.01846013218164444, -0.02645629458129406, -0.044486451894044876, 0.03135916218161583, 0.0011664876947179437, 0.024147499352693558, 0.009080580435693264, -0.008270561695098877, -0.03379647433757782, -0.00312090665102005, 0.0364069901406765, -0.0417865626513958, 0.022990023717284203, 0.04361904039978981, 0.03103775903582573, -0.04939601942896843, 0.03618481755256653, -0.044101204723119736, -0.0605032742023468, 0.03457586467266083, -0.01547640934586525, 0.0320311114192009, -0.0065162633545696735, -0.0434379018843174, 0.021179232746362686, -0.007985217496752739, -0.04879143089056015, 0.0376506932079792, -0.05282421037554741, 0.07600048929452896, 0.033955711871385574, 0.017534945160150528, 0.009074140340089798, 0.0226429533213377, 0.037292879074811935, 0.017000367864966393, -0.011629389598965645, 0.044655691832304, -0.08055731654167175, -0.03960129991173744, 0.016184547916054726, 0.007223522290587425, -0.03990904986858368, 0.006214503198862076, 0.05220845714211464, 0.0035751862451434135, 0.010661915875971317, 0.03648512437939644, 0.007609077263623476, -0.03528232499957085, 0.021319566294550896, 0.060761209577322006, 0.038543954491615295, 0.01267855055630207, 0.014592551626265049, -0.007090642116963863, 0.05123797804117203, 0.021639013662934303, -0.008318478241562843, 0.051246363669633865, 0.00460852961987257, 0.02485336735844612, 0.007860432378947735, -0.03532860055565834, 0.014466648921370506, -0.017866138368844986, 0.019540470093488693, 0.013717534020543098, 0.019274946302175522, -0.000872218341100961, -0.011500658467411995, 0.014932181686162949, 0.002622024854645133, 0.00425272760912776, -0.02828313410282135, -0.012657882645726204, 0.026243461295962334, -0.04502024129033089, -0.009437554515898228, -0.014594007283449173, -0.006305375602096319, -0.05623246729373932, -0.024365128949284554, 0.010185426101088524, -0.022559089586138725, 0.02330000326037407, -0.004542557056993246, 0.007478338200598955, -0.03298771753907204, -0.025785723701119423, 0.03731918707489967, -0.0045392392203211784, -0.0653122141957283, -0.000014687231669086032, -0.04071923717856407, -0.004904304165393114, 0.04737193509936333, -0.022713957354426384, -0.0012692136224359274, 0.0216782595962286, 0.013093957677483559, -0.03293317183852196, -0.02284340374171734, -0.0038957379292696714, 0.028548624366521835, -0.004477518144994974, -0.04601138457655907, 0.03022834286093712, 0.022468771785497665, -0.043725207448005676, 0.008632645010948181, -0.0302396472543478, -0.026478523388504982, -0.02663121186196804, -0.02630716934800148, -0.02248331531882286, -0.008511404506862164, -0.010978160426020622, -0.0008249756065197289, -0.060739174485206604, 0.003545064479112625, -0.053663626313209534, -0.04000839218497276, 0.04982614517211914, -0.004609097260981798, 0.02634286880493164, -0.0006517050205729902, -0.021147605031728745, 0.05560610070824623, 0.04513837397098541, -0.02972905896604061, -0.08478552103042603, 0.015641959384083748, -0.03293132036924362, -0.04420049488544464, 0.011121479794383049, 0.006229258608072996, 0.018454276025295258, 0.028345217928290367, 0.004682695958763361, 0.015006771311163902, 0.016787737607955933, 0.016652299091219902, -0.007440643850713968, 0.022379998117685318, -0.011047890409827232, 0.005145335104316473, -0.0017434648470953107, -0.0003936888533644378, 0.013695605099201202, 0.004866264760494232, -0.029717812314629555, 0.03164699673652649, 0.017025357112288475, -0.00011373362212907523, 0.029746880754828453, -0.010263861157000065, 0.008828241378068924, -0.017366280779242516, 0.014333879575133324, 0.014356138184666634, -0.02684095688164234, -0.02188408188521862, -0.0036117834970355034, 0.037281278520822525, -0.016235286369919777, 0.024666929617524147, 0.0452411025762558, 0.013838727958500385, -0.012914472259581089, 0.028084449470043182, -0.02681802213191986, -0.04483003169298172, 0.028148643672466278, -0.040562715381383896, -0.025720229372382164, 0.0350685641169548, 0.07500535994768143, 0.03381319344043732, 0.010826017707586288, -0.04467480257153511, 0.007397762034088373, -0.04574357345700264, -0.0009388741455040872, -0.008346815593540668, 0.047694262117147446, -0.0007312402594834566, 0.014942492358386517, 0.02067067101597786, -0.01641315408051014, -0.012772833928465843, -0.017938900738954544, -0.06351158022880554, 0.04538733884692192, -0.009685151278972626, 0.012759626843035221, 0.014758938923478127, -0.03302372619509697, 0.00540166674181819, -0.03480294719338417, 0.024553721770644188, -0.049327682703733444, 0.02648300491273403, -0.024911442771553993, -0.0019063360523432493, -0.030410436913371086, -0.004443185869604349, -0.01233740895986557, 0.025860143825411797, 0.02667699195444584, -0.01787070743739605, 0.0535602867603302, 0.02420618385076523, -0.0033962817396968603, -0.03554869443178177, -0.018626486882567406, 0.056481149047613144, 0.044822558760643005, 0.021107029169797897, 0.07507411390542984, 0.03805393725633621, -0.08857419341802597, 0.011805226095020771, 0.008935363031923771, 0.04447305202484131, 0.03411244973540306, 0.0021715264301747084, -0.03877183794975281, -0.05748995766043663, -0.050736866891384125, 0.014847994782030582, 0.012964189052581787, 0.03192773833870888, -0.012093285098671913, 0.06895574182271957, 0.00035125785507261753, -0.038875170052051544, -0.002772287465631962, 0.06191825866699219, 0.02566794492304325, -0.013941183686256409, -0.04098915308713913, -0.012830374762415886, 0.0012337013613432646, -0.013275456614792347, 0.04269341006875038, 0.011114238761365414, -0.030303139239549637, -0.0005123250302858651, 0.02725294418632984, -0.024801652878522873, -0.027953267097473145, 0.021541235968470573, 0.03136906027793884, 0.04258069396018982, 0.045978844165802, -0.05131306126713753, 0.035517290234565735, 0.035332124680280685, -0.008719803765416145, 0.0355675145983696, 0.0038920838851481676, -0.090214304625988, 0.02801314927637577, 0.03289152681827545, 0.04705434292554855, -0.07480136305093765, 0.005136285908520222, 0.004262594971805811, -0.023370906710624695, 0.02033562771975994, -0.006792666390538216, 0.04436500370502472, -0.05527845025062561, -0.004839655011892319, -0.03377765044569969, -0.02613077685236931, -0.06945949792861938, 0.011958528310060501, -0.032352015376091, 0.0130835622549057, -0.030990371480584145, -0.02167128026485443, -0.04798589274287224, -0.007422752678394318, -0.004023697227239609, 0.04382039234042168, -0.025410588830709457, -0.030567869544029236, 0.02105015702545643, 0.01807168498635292, 0.00588113721460104, -0.06755682826042175, -0.006922050379216671, -0.028824936598539352, -0.03573412820696831, 0.03569753095507622, -0.007742051035165787, -0.025901930406689644, 0.031493064016103745, 0.048766929656267166, -0.012115828692913055, -0.012010707519948483, -0.0019645271822810173, 0.005802453495562077, 0.020090240985155106, -0.031693655997514725, 0.06936687231063843, 0.06393080949783325, -0.023138340562582016, 0.04986468702554703, -0.002582618733868003, -0.004719556774944067, -0.053001321852207184, -0.0043640839867293835, -0.05887167900800705, -0.0029161504935473204, -0.01787780411541462, -0.011720542795956135, 0.013103237375617027, -0.005107122007757425, -0.013927573338150978, -0.013767615891993046, 0.01701081171631813, 0.02929762750864029, 0.023882826790213585, -0.02548418752849102, -0.010395501740276814, 0.050880350172519684, -0.03689853847026825, -0.025093503296375275, -0.00955659244209528, -0.004965116735547781, 0.0062218476086854935, 0.03746671602129936, -0.02700609154999256, 0.016856599599123, 0.0036897938698530197, -0.02155158668756485, -0.00921416375786066, -0.00572107033804059, 0.0017581804422661662, 0.0007725874311290681, 0.027532750740647316, -0.0029381122440099716, -0.07027930021286011, 0.022715942934155464, 0.04614728316664696, -0.0018088830402120948, 0.023077383637428284, -0.021857373416423798, 0.05184346064925194, 0.022647349163889885, -0.0021628555841743946, -0.03838504105806351, -0.04551064595580101, -0.014726020395755768, 0.01081726886332035, -0.016767175868153572, -0.02311096154153347, 0.012435114942491055, -0.05992959439754486, 0.007451875600963831, 0.000024828310415614396, 0.06459560245275497, -0.021740270778536797, -0.01824752427637577, 0.054785095155239105, 0.0041536446660757065, 0.04721684381365776, 0.0024650665000081062, -0.02305043488740921, -0.0012237427290529013, -0.009235094301402569, -0.017141586169600487, 0.0032074698247015476, -0.016905274242162704, -0.04842637851834297, 0.013248956762254238, -0.02112211287021637, -0.007426483556628227, 0.003917029593139887, 0.018277915194630623, -0.02408876083791256, 0.0022291624918580055, -0.03017720952630043, 0.018892571330070496, -0.0379607193171978, 0.00017463603580836207, -0.03588630259037018, -0.00043668877333402634, -0.0007608670857734978, 0.03478524088859558, 0.020860455930233, -0.02278452180325985, 0.03655627369880676, 0.0022896542213857174, -0.04943723976612091, -0.0027780772652477026, 0.0450318343937397, -0.0028837607242166996, 0.032662589102983475, -0.00966136995702982, -0.01341431774199009, 0.043476175516843796, -0.0004475159221328795, 0.012387712486088276, -0.003325125202536583, 0.01714024506509304, 0.009749574586749077, 0.0033892467617988586, -0.008406531065702438, -0.018160101026296616, 0.06031361222267151, -0.031159989535808563, 0.0518670454621315, 0.05081459879875183, 0.019458293914794922, -0.03145300969481468, -0.03764486312866211, 0.006153199356049299, -0.012732602655887604, 0.0019576456397771835, 0.04275771230459213, -0.005259104538708925, 0.005341520067304373, 0.024571623653173447, -0.02189037762582302, 0.020368613302707672, 0.02148088812828064, 0.03811071440577507, 0.03232155367732048, 0.02358541451394558, -0.015272720716893673, -0.0306999571621418, 0.028290070593357086, -0.05608171969652176, -0.00805895496159792, -0.028489060699939728, -0.0385114885866642, 0.018627675250172615, 0.04754599183797836, 0.012536810711026192, -0.05222759023308754, -0.027578799054026604, -0.05018975958228111, -0.003844003425911069, -0.01140652596950531, -0.01220963429659605, 0.036039192229509354, 0.0008834076579660177, 0.04307730123400688, 0.016941959038376808, 0.0391453355550766, -0.016608230769634247, -0.06537918746471405, -0.047518983483314514, -0.010785170830786228, -0.027628112584352493, 0.060099080204963684, 0.0071324934251606464, -0.03626551106572151, 0.018987681716680527, -0.01999722421169281, -0.020482469350099564, -0.007354464381933212, 0.041711173951625824, -0.02236282080411911, 0.06982198357582092, -0.014781899750232697, 0.01378200575709343, 0.030899252742528915, -0.03804510459303856, 0.07903753221035004, 0.1064935028553009, 0.020474262535572052, -0.07916954904794693, 0.03778209164738655, 0.002159046707674861, -0.006832065060734749, -0.012516098096966743, -0.0029644158203154802, 0.01924058422446251, 0.0027761675883084536, 0.02666880562901497, 0.05948628857731819, -0.020697135478258133, -0.006026531103998423, 0.06293604522943497, -0.03549604490399361, -0.025818586349487305, 0.021884454414248466, 0.026425527408719063, -0.006119080353528261, -0.025046980008482933, -0.048793014138936996, -0.013964158482849598, 0.020438140258193016, -0.022726742550730705, 0.002514829160645604, -0.015000873245298862, -0.029762709513306618, 0.00728284427896142, -0.010249361395835876, 0.0006320796092040837, 0.014207576401531696, -0.005503042601048946, -0.028253085911273956, -0.005220343358814716, 0.018036091700196266, -0.0339430496096611, 0.0038024678360670805, 0.0216741394251585, -0.0258697047829628, -0.01906737871468067, 0.001527050626464188, 0.024727189913392067, -0.05580471083521843, -0.011527646332979202, -0.040130436420440674, 0.05320671200752258, 0.006949701812118292, -0.01588827557861805, -0.014138348400592804, 0.01319628581404686, 0.03919467702507973, -0.02870750054717064, -0.01204110961407423, 0.03142606467008591, 0.029452171176671982, -0.017054935917258263, -0.008035933598876, -0.05364307016134262, 0.024583647027611732, 0.02714509330689907, 0.02294768951833248, 0.01787514053285122, -0.05441772937774658, 0.0074290926568210125, -0.004040789790451527, 0.06905616819858551, 0.02431587316095829, -0.008072245866060257, -0.0007609322783537209, -0.014123029075562954, -0.050606779754161835, 0.015721121802926064, 0.02342008240520954, -0.0016019487520679832, 0.037529319524765015, -0.02973140776157379, 0.016859253868460655, -0.024628734216094017, -0.03180931508541107, 0.011568637564778328, -0.007531070150434971, 0.0009772985940799117, -0.06484586000442505, -0.013588464818894863, -0.0009660159121267498, 0.01861497387290001, 0.04583362489938736, 0.017559640109539032, 0.007007287349551916, 0.04263018071651459, 0.006150079425424337, -0.07658041268587112, -0.009786286391317844, -0.009772827848792076, -0.02935834787786007, 0.005443545524030924, -0.03723330423235893, 0.035271674394607544, 0.01443023793399334, 0.013008288107812405, 0.012478227727115154, 0.010267606005072594, 0.012991540133953094, 0.0014475735370069742, 0.02637280896306038, -0.06081204116344452, -0.011446402408182621, -0.00904956553131342, -0.02079179137945175, -0.05841958522796631, -0.013005999848246574, -0.035068217664957047, -0.00983356311917305, 0.015355182811617851, -0.016841409727931023, -0.052651919424533844, 0.028989611193537712, -0.013821311295032501, 0.032961249351501465, -0.04466734826564789, 0.002873768797144294, -0.04463348165154457, -0.01789773814380169, 0.003356955014169216, -0.014273691922426224, 0.0210481658577919, 0.020000241696834564, -0.03209623694419861, 0.005720506887882948, 0.028147544711828232, 0.02036348357796669, 0.024311205372214317, -0.03289502486586571, 0.03216917812824249, -0.014884604141116142, 0.025037018582224846, -0.03361460939049721, 0.012646997347474098, 0.03715747967362404, -0.040453579276800156, -0.01562732458114624, 0.010639403015375137, 0.01072372030466795, 0.022525731474161148, -0.003736617276445031, -0.015174982137978077, -0.03824770078063011, 0.03422911837697029, -0.038024887442588806, -0.019978893920779228, 0.014339045621454716, 0.018613198772072792, -0.00774863176047802, -0.012835592962801456, -0.010417241603136063, 0.005775658413767815, 0.0024085009936243296, 0.022684510797262192, 0.07105530798435211, 0.018232185393571854, -0.033004436641931534, 0.003184335073456168, -0.022145777940750122, 0.026539403945207596, 0.005204560700803995, -0.04490301012992859, 0.014322839677333832, 0.05317852646112442, -0.020291892811655998, 0.056674711406230927, 0.01361109409481287, -0.017049377784132957, -0.0784517154097557, -0.030641784891486168, 0.024070926010608673, 0.01440886314958334, 0.030246537178754807, -0.06329789012670517, 0.01500928308814764, 0.019322289153933525, -0.04362301155924797, 0.00010604377166600898, -0.003486278234049678, 0.003044119803234935, -0.02915569394826889, -0.028919389471411705, -0.00941968709230423, 0.010847460478544235, 0.011426655575633049, 0.02088475041091442, 0.047026827931404114, -0.002464915160089731, -0.008358114399015903, -0.04461522772908211, -0.028304671868681908, 0.017274945974349976, 0.0003279348893556744, -0.07357758283615112, 0.05222722142934799, -0.02539628930389881, -0.0717124342918396, 0.014346848241984844, 0.027424871921539307, 0.04021056741476059, 0.0040462384931743145, 0.05683256685733795, 0.029198674485087395, 0.03201402723789215, 0.02664838917553425, 0.01447205152362585, 0.04708518460392952, 0.03486713767051697, 0.002032350515946746, 0.03566616028547287, 0.005081334616988897, 0.01259074080735445, 0.003135574981570244, -0.016149751842021942, -0.0118648000061512, 0.015039403922855854, -0.02575797587633133, 0.016804654151201248, -0.0023471186868846416, 0.000541812158189714, -0.006483929231762886, -0.009884889237582684, 0.02334129810333252, -0.013704474084079266, -0.040348026901483536, 0.03905019909143448, 0.04177389293909073, -0.0018561015604063869, 0.005070457700639963, 0.0061158775351941586, -0.014049100689589977, 0.019902000203728676, -0.004629313014447689, 0.006857303902506828, -0.06744837760925293, -0.005846141837537289, 0.02769339270889759, -0.029570814222097397, -0.0602448508143425, -0.011877079494297504, -0.011695844121277332, 0.05962761864066124, -0.024909546598792076, 0.013493786565959454, 0.022109858691692352, -0.03588481247425079, 0.020707501098513603, -0.1008172258734703, 0.06862587481737137, -0.0063033741898834705, -0.030291136354207993, 0.002261118730530143, 0.0046055312268435955, -0.031524404883384705, -0.0027254128362983465, 0.03322708234190941, 0.0039307959377765656, 0.01756872609257698, -0.018229808658361435, 0.0422976054251194, 0.013245748355984688, -0.0500749796628952, 0.0685989260673523, -0.014438088983297348, -0.013116240501403809, 0.000888030044734478, -0.04879382997751236, 0.0183517225086689, 0.018862832337617874, 0.02823329158127308, -0.042150646448135376, 0.015564191155135632, 0.014212903566658497, -0.006671846378594637, 0.032682884484529495, -0.020936669781804085, -0.019432857632637024, 0.04250026121735573, 0.001035059685818851, 0.040426090359687805, 0.03692156821489334, -0.0065379515290260315, -0.051148880273103714, 0.015029190108180046, -0.01889980025589466, 0.020934410393238068, -0.026214975863695145, 0.030040185898542404, -0.029607562348246574, -0.03325304016470909, 0.021143028512597084, 0.001768649322912097, -0.024533454328775406, 0.010458402335643768, -0.0018350302707403898, -0.001356625696644187, 0.026699285954236984, 0.008157910779118538, 0.05539461597800255, 0.030979659408330917, -0.02461155690252781, -0.0034183794632554054, 0.00983351469039917, 0.023268943652510643, 0.005227970890700817, 0.020597316324710846, 0.042149294167757034, -0.027061857283115387, 0.046631623059511185, -0.008975626900792122, 0.006912019103765488, -0.03147503733634949, -0.03433777019381523, 0.0061279358342289925, 0.014509918168187141, 0.02602682262659073, -0.025333786383271217, 0.006611020769923925, 0.05422845482826233, -0.05822188779711723, -0.008269493468105793, -0.004676538519561291, -0.024880580604076385, 0.020001279190182686, 0.007361772004514933, 0.015240181237459183, 0.013218345120549202, 0.019765201956033707, 0.03182171657681465, 0.008459851145744324, 0.0016584335826337337, 0.00828326866030693, -0.028496045619249344, 0.05589944124221802, -0.049243390560150146, -0.0028164051473140717, 0.007227355148643255, 0.011656508781015873, -0.04146338254213333, -0.011630355380475521, 0.02768401801586151, 0.05930516496300697, 0.01506031583994627, -0.06394539028406143, -0.033812858164310455, 0.009069231338799, 0.050432756543159485, -0.023369479924440384, -0.01937800832092762, -0.04965350031852722, 0.010320661589503288, 0.0006216911715455353, -0.0037836506962776184 ]
<p>I am working on a prediction model in which I have several factor variables that have many levels. These factor variables have a nested structure, in the form of a Category, a Sub-Category, and a Sub-Sub-Category. For example suppose that I had one field that was the type of device a user browsed the website with (pc, tablet, phone), which then can be sub segmented into ((Apple, windows, linux), (kindle, iOS, android), (windows, iOS, android, RIM)), and then each of those could be subdivided into version numbers.</p> <p>Is there a standard way of handling nested features like this in tree models. At an intuitive level, I don't think the tree should be splitting on one of the subgroupings until it has first split on one of the major groups (since a windows phone and a windows PC are quite different). Creating a single factor that describes the full tree path would have too many possible levels.</p>
73,802
[ -0.020661208778619766, 0.00820640753954649, -0.012696151621639729, 0.008767287246882915, 0.020771851763129234, -0.022366901859641075, -0.004954611882567406, -0.007851528003811836, 0.0754643976688385, -0.03384460136294365, 0.033260688185691833, 0.00670928880572319, 0.033002618700265884, -0.050032418221235275, -0.01665971800684929, 0.0009602619102224708, 0.018379725515842438, -0.02422797679901123, 0.0006625064415857196, -0.0021351408213377, -0.014297009445726871, 0.01579713262617588, -0.017050277441740036, 0.005987775512039661, -0.005470172502100468, 0.07528489828109741, 0.03405196964740753, -0.018388532102108, -0.0015654896851629019, -0.006588459480553865, 0.0012221180368214846, -0.027995415031909943, 0.003395425621420145, 0.06839484721422195, 0.012632399797439575, -0.017854982987046242, -0.010044987313449383, -0.0611497163772583, -0.06581815332174301, 0.014219759032130241, -0.013082488439977169, 0.038703083992004395, -0.05027519538998604, 0.0328923724591732, -0.018898047506809235, 0.03661542758345604, -0.029798101633787155, 0.004013005178421736, 0.043713562190532684, -0.03878569230437279, 0.0477982722222805, -0.017978036776185036, 0.05600159615278244, 0.04386601597070694, -0.03704635053873062, 0.01954330876469612, 0.06701542437076569, 0.06982605159282684, 0.00039130792720243335, -0.00023440446238964796, -0.05710382014513016, -0.02638843283057213, 0.037209637463092804, -0.011954646557569504, -0.03695999085903168, 0.047516148537397385, 0.000027921836590394378, -0.031695038080215454, 0.03544015809893608, -0.01413562148809433, 0.020062195137143135, -0.045406654477119446, 0.051024626940488815, 0.003432191675528884, 0.011026977561414242, -0.028830504044890404, 0.027908245101571083, 0.03879783675074577, 0.041673969477415085, 0.013166668824851513, 0.010470696724951267, 0.016616130247712135, -0.03132549673318863, -0.017874862998723984, 0.02080819569528103, 0.009747653268277645, 0.06819255650043488, -0.009541175328195095, -0.024000704288482666, 0.05493761971592903, -0.011030004359781742, -0.027624215930700302, 0.058012355118989944, -0.032373420894145966, -0.055700771510601044, 0.07272961735725403, -0.009198489598929882, -0.027988698333501816, 0.040696099400520325, 0.04964492842555046, 0.00396755151450634, -0.028023486956954002, 0.017913689836859703, 0.04579273238778114, -0.04971901699900627, -0.008346278220415115, -0.035240717232227325, -0.039165616035461426, 0.01139240525662899, 0.0023777680471539497, 0.000807562842965126, -0.004455850925296545, -0.014469310641288757, 0.0023452432360500097, 0.026059815660119057, -0.0024999091401696205, -0.020896947011351585, -0.045619551092386246, 0.0628039762377739, 0.05297744274139404, 0.055793195962905884, -0.05521668866276741, 0.06689026206731796, -0.014944269321858883, -0.05937662348151207, 0.023101601749658585, -0.0048244115896523, -0.005668992176651955, -0.03580278158187866, 0.01868404634296894, -0.03707044571638107, -0.00921770092099905, 0.05928221717476845, -0.05037485435605049, 0.015212967060506344, 0.0183709729462862, -0.04500749334692955, -0.07393413782119751, 0.002603282919153571, 0.0002958906115964055, 0.012119248509407043, -0.04463976249098778, 0.023173632100224495, 0.030989566817879677, 0.0710739716887474, -0.031600479036569595, 0.03269977122545242, 0.049033720046281815, 0.03287358582019806, 0.011335275135934353, -0.024266771972179413, -0.015178201720118523, -0.011785345152020454, 0.011029614135622978, -0.015710508450865746, -0.07053045183420181, 0.04139353707432747, 0.0004906321410089731, -0.02281792275607586, 0.008148256689310074, 0.012462595477700233, -0.00955512560904026, -0.027526114135980606, -0.0014924206770956516, 0.02311861142516136, -0.01612434908747673, 0.048504963517189026, -0.032057009637355804, 0.046189382672309875, 0.05793450400233269, 0.043526191264390945, -0.02010655589401722, 0.007546191569417715, 0.023043252527713776, 0.04352912679314613, 0.03422039747238159, 0.0017946228617802262, -0.0020805969834327698, -0.015250532887876034, -0.016226263716816902, -0.0076136463321745396, -0.04546257108449936, -0.030643615871667862, 0.005907017271965742, 0.025223899632692337, -0.006287517491728067, 0.0012572447303682566, -0.02623971551656723, 0.04320164769887924, -0.07031115889549255, -0.03677139803767204, -0.010610852390527725, 0.013322612270712852, -0.013949709013104439, 0.011355020105838776, 0.028666334226727486, -0.02832457423210144, 0.010994638316333294, -0.007590307388454676, -0.02967713214457035, -0.032986436039209366, -0.007060490548610687, 0.006409664638340473, -0.07368941605091095, -0.012748653069138527, 0.015641063451766968, 0.007218935992568731, -0.023928700014948845, 0.04494939371943474, -0.0059798965230584145, -0.041513048112392426, -0.008472471497952938, -0.04054068401455879, 0.01015252061188221, -0.05108179897069931, -0.010176748037338257, 0.01583390310406685, 0.0028583405073732138, -0.008987605571746826, 0.0176010113209486, -0.07330819964408875, 0.024922408163547516, 0.0800330862402916, 0.0014071661280468106, 0.007623095531016588, -0.015207262709736824, 0.0013848250964656472, 0.022742049768567085, -0.011708857491612434, -0.023078296333551407, -0.044217243790626526, -0.03387962281703949, 0.03465108573436737, -0.016659656539559364, -0.024868560954928398, 0.02388642728328705, 0.045456595718860626, 0.041225939989089966, 0.02616041712462902, 0.020148135721683502, -0.014469030313193798, 0.05443675071001053, 0.03530037775635719, 0.013455585576593876, 0.0005871948087587953, 0.0052025835029780865, -0.0013100228970870376, -0.00950251892209053, 0.008926830254495144, -0.008513192646205425, -0.013921216130256653, 0.03159096837043762, 0.02546875551342964, 0.03511321172118187, -0.0011668853694573045, -0.021759485825896263, 0.047013625502586365, -0.02940192259848118, 0.015355002135038376, 0.0480024628341198, 0.0010841096518561244, -0.02829909510910511, 0.00002203917938459199, -0.007763714529573917, -0.002215735847130418, 0.08417212218046188, -0.05627425014972687, -0.016863586381077766, 0.012037976644933224, -0.01929324120283127, 0.04701737314462662, -0.04245685040950775, -0.0016810923116281629, -0.02884163334965706, 0.007636526599526405, 0.026814719662070274, -0.01768294721841812, 0.020384574308991432, -0.018701517954468727, -0.006800321862101555, -0.03125733509659767, -0.007113480940461159, 0.028484538197517395, -0.036864545196294785, -0.05215807631611824, 0.03159761056303978, -0.02240302599966526, -0.011477009393274784, 0.027787746861577034, 0.004698879085481167, -0.05731106549501419, -0.035550981760025024, 0.00532161770388484, -0.05162913352251053, -0.02365899831056595, -0.027911297976970673, 0.028452623635530472, -0.03256675601005554, -0.032347649335861206, -0.004507273435592651, 0.008667778223752975, 0.014527462422847748, -0.024533435702323914, -0.03914419934153557, -0.018703516572713852, -0.013980358839035034, -0.03624174743890762, -0.03747185692191124, 0.012609196826815605, 0.023519910871982574, 0.03651568293571472, -0.01670614816248417, 0.02700342796742916, -0.07148592919111252, -0.10837563872337341, 0.024408243596553802, 0.02600126340985298, 0.06556614488363266, 0.02447756752371788, 0.045109931379556656, 0.07806980609893799, 0.015603011474013329, -0.03704876825213432, -0.03226796165108681, -0.010383167304098606, -0.005957898683845997, -0.029599178582429886, 0.0015042945742607117, 0.03520990535616875, 0.001635003020055592, 0.012420463375747204, 0.006312107667326927, 0.009286380372941494, 0.0643170103430748, 0.017372168600559235, -0.0372873991727829, 0.0558072030544281, 0.018645359203219414, 0.019234558567404747, -0.0011798391351476312, 0.02820873260498047, 0.004219796042889357, 0.039857812225818634, -0.07179025560617447, -0.0008114439551718533, 0.01302326750010252, -0.02940189838409424, -0.009602541103959084, -0.021035611629486084, -0.013506920076906681, -0.03287431597709656, 0.023255567997694016, 0.021765725687146187, -0.045505307614803314, -0.0011531353229656816, 0.04289543256163597, 0.03656662628054619, 0.016319304704666138, 0.0019603713881224394, 0.03276395797729492, 0.02509528025984764, -0.03533947840332985, -0.033696990460157394, -0.004653844051063061, 0.01264980249106884, 0.02176167629659176, 0.011815083213150501, 0.004197061061859131, 0.04079144448041916, 0.039346013218164444, 0.02618733048439026, 0.00839772168546915, -0.04900049790740013, 0.02878832072019577, -0.055202022194862366, 0.032902900129556656, -0.014894425868988037, 0.027848830446600914, 0.0006644399836659431, 0.021130267530679703, 0.010293424129486084, -0.012205180712044239, 0.011118280701339245, 0.028842655941843987, -0.042810771614313126, -0.011966504156589508, -0.005195220001041889, 0.012815410271286964, -0.021399471908807755, -0.0147500429302454, 0.0035230021458119154, -0.007638635579496622, -0.016993818804621696, 0.0034994049929082394, 0.02261042594909668, -0.01044727023690939, -0.01912197284400463, -0.02134326659142971, 0.00035930096055381, -0.023495525121688843, -0.026547729969024658, 0.05151616036891937, 0.02821517363190651, 0.032014988362789154, 0.014257112517952919, 0.02039393037557602, -0.00901209656149149, -0.032697271555662155, -0.02158639021217823, -0.002206750214099884, 0.03323894739151001, 0.005552130751311779, 0.008166700601577759, -0.023198982700705528, 0.0030397544614970684, 0.014350195415318012, 0.033009614795446396, 0.044925492256879807, -0.012108445167541504, 0.017714833840727806, 0.005331795662641525, -0.043295156210660934, 0.012895381078124046, 0.018177993595600128, -0.008381477557122707, -0.007001235615462065, 0.03558497130870819, 0.04502762854099274, -0.04848353564739227, 0.00026522608823142946, 0.07238636165857315, 0.022000627592206, -0.05744821950793266, -0.0043776268139481544, -0.00009020725701702759, 0.020287783816456795, -0.015725089237093925, -0.0016652217600494623, 0.033299561589956284, -0.005589684005826712, 0.009869088418781757, -0.0018955133855342865, -0.02685626596212387, -0.058520495891571045, 0.04824139550328255, 0.0034544721711426973, 0.028315074741840363, -0.0065946620889008045, -0.022278789430856705, 0.02492787316441536, 0.04270001873373985, -0.011021271347999573, 0.04741742089390755, -0.015506522729992867, -0.11971226334571838, 0.0006032974342815578, 0.04599754512310028, 0.02972748689353466, -0.02555554173886776, -0.028894009068608284, -0.026689739897847176, -0.039797592908144, 0.017848258838057518, 0.006435123737901449, 0.04810505360364914, 0.00822372268885374, 0.012016244232654572, 0.0057240817695856094, -0.04542097449302673, -0.024486595764756203, 0.01086554117500782, -0.04518727585673332, 0.0266198068857193, 0.002355406992137432, 0.006444994360208511, -0.033661000430583954, 0.03156181797385216, 0.024572864174842834, 0.0311738308519125, -0.020698102191090584, -0.04359285905957222, -0.019801443442702293, 0.011117704212665558, -0.014377331361174583, -0.032441191375255585, -0.0026652971282601357, 0.026058334857225418, -0.001859683427028358, 0.03857113793492317, -0.009971925057470798, -0.04254164919257164, 0.0370129831135273, 0.03487372025847435, -0.004743852652609348, -0.0006472558598034084, 0.010889053344726562, 0.05271763727068901, 0.0023435016628354788, -0.019012833014130592, 0.049401719123125076, 0.04723310098052025, 0.008808582089841366, 0.002492596162483096, -0.03293093666434288, 0.015305673703551292, -0.007303494960069656, -0.03722398355603218, -0.04849543049931526, -0.020739169791340828, -0.007965290918946266, 0.032835911959409714, -0.002542685717344284, 0.03928976505994797, -0.05374455451965332, -0.03529553860425949, -0.0024893495719879866, 0.02005781978368759, -0.031517259776592255, -0.020921705290675163, 0.028156232088804245, 0.03706119582056999, 0.030697207897901535, -0.006188740488141775, 0.0011060044635087252, -0.03236699849367142, 0.029229439795017242, 0.009673778899013996, -0.012385089881718159, 0.021785486489534378, -0.05240994319319725, -0.05289556458592415, 0.013650719076395035, -0.015674442052841187, 0.029594918712973595, -0.02278185449540615, 0.019635016098618507, 0.017486633732914925, -0.0163345318287611, 0.01778339594602585, 0.03334903344511986, -0.0024449811317026615, 0.03650103136897087, -0.029203997924923897, 0.01357092522084713, -0.059379901736974716, -0.01900305412709713, -0.04671118035912514, -0.017065629363059998, 0.00494184996932745, 0.0002594032557681203, -0.013152958825230598, -0.01720466837286949, 0.03363128751516342, -0.051712680608034134, -0.017427608370780945, -0.002987226005643606, 0.021888090297579765, -0.03137112036347389, 0.023231355473399162, 0.018958445638418198, 0.03643697872757912, 0.06116729974746704, 0.023923886939883232, 0.018005577847361565, -0.005668052472174168, 0.02284771390259266, 0.020158272236585617, -0.0029884607065469027, -0.0247090682387352, -0.028401993215084076, -0.00827186368405819, -0.023652072995901108, 0.039140038192272186, 0.03802267834544182, -0.022010045126080513, 0.018898747861385345, -0.008020116947591305, -0.005076433531939983, 0.0026823505759239197, -0.008354793302714825, 0.022519540041685104, 0.004340857733041048, -0.024849042296409607, -0.016669321805238724, 0.008783997967839241, -0.0012007378973066807, -0.0193313118070364, -0.016748810186982155, -0.02908756583929062, 0.006963755004107952, 0.008297206833958626, 0.0494181327521801, -0.030085043981671333, 0.03910451382398605, 0.038395561277866364, -0.05969369783997536, 0.050063539296388626, 0.005482373293489218, -0.012818856164813042, 0.012926171533763409, 0.039409250020980835, -0.023759892210364342, -0.0034971539862453938, 0.00790940411388874, -0.019920215010643005, 0.05834042653441429, -0.044107891619205475, -0.0036910991184413433, 0.034060098230838776, -0.025680799037218094, -0.00937450211495161, -0.07819609344005585, -0.021272895857691765, 0.029372336342930794, 0.007347567938268185, 0.0908958911895752, 0.00870350282639265, 0.04153125733137131, 0.040865905582904816, 0.01870216615498066, 0.0020887148566544056, 0.06809909641742706, 0.02377246879041195, -0.0032060635276138783, -0.006388586480170488, -0.04527640342712402, -0.017796095460653305, 0.008341476321220398, -0.05267861485481262, -0.026908235624432564, -0.025041628628969193, -0.008143370039761066, 0.04031459614634514, 0.031384702771902084, -0.000353538227500394, -0.04155481606721878, -0.01696965843439102, -0.037625644356012344, 0.029830792918801308, 0.025210829451680183, 0.027645256370306015, 0.01382570993155241, -0.004620722960680723, 0.013188118115067482, 0.007154503837227821, -0.003197873244062066, -0.023066824302077293, -0.07163245230913162, -0.05468762665987015, -0.04388481006026268, -0.04506201297044754, 0.0054380279034376144, 0.014489763416349888, -0.0022705080918967724, 0.027306819334626198, -0.013090381398797035, 0.010632792487740517, -0.0032723129261285067, 0.0520067922770977, -0.004924032837152481, 0.0774453803896904, 0.014542846940457821, 0.006197675131261349, -0.005411447491496801, 0.012249458581209183, 0.11222164332866669, 0.07500986009836197, 0.04134823754429817, -0.012186800129711628, 0.02264893427491188, -0.008654908277094364, -0.012526478618383408, -0.020221790298819542, 0.01289602741599083, -0.020040838047862053, -0.0038598470855504274, 0.007323756814002991, 0.03849827125668526, 0.01625959575176239, 0.05606222152709961, 0.04439879208803177, -0.051015518605709076, 0.03450217843055725, 0.01888461224734783, 0.021124951541423798, -0.0063947392627596855, -0.012201683595776558, -0.025591304525732994, 0.014544909819960594, 0.015846505761146545, 0.005104046314954758, -0.012410403229296207, 0.0074353767558932304, 0.023904625326395035, -0.006824564654380083, -0.02008390985429287, -0.012783379293978214, 0.04265819862484932, 0.005017582327127457, 0.03167558088898659, -0.020634165033698082, 0.021829567849636078, -0.008387367241084576, 0.034684523940086365, 0.045623037964105606, 0.012527029030025005, -0.006245948374271393, -0.030356843024492264, 0.02350710518658161, -0.04719330370426178, -0.02574911154806614, -0.044945258647203445, -0.009577141143381596, -0.018692387267947197, 0.003374736523255706, -0.03204154223203659, 0.017643002793192863, 0.00768295768648386, -0.03547177091240883, -0.003993139136582613, 0.029235215857625008, 0.021006204187870026, 0.0006297964719124138, -0.024982180446386337, -0.001365011790767312, 0.02398865669965744, -0.00953142624348402, 0.012702351436018944, -0.035661909729242325, -0.019920464605093002, -0.000006688387657050043, -0.06484739482402802, 0.005251016933470964, 0.015184675343334675, -0.002643182408064604, 0.023835476487874985, 0.017619149759411812, -0.02131328545510769, -0.008679935708642006, 0.0360763780772686, -0.006071886047720909, 0.02978591062128544, -0.022896595299243927, -0.01617620512843132, -0.02848486602306366, -0.012360842898488045, 0.00035752126132138073, -0.028895195573568344, -0.02169938012957573, -0.03786640614271164, 0.03274477645754814, -0.004061609972268343, 0.029276365414261818, 0.005881127901375294, 0.042892035096883774, -0.03645389527082443, 0.05872835963964462, 0.012942256405949593, -0.08596587181091309, -0.02459382638335228, 0.012232793495059013, -0.03563322499394417, 0.006006796844303608, -0.012200690805912018, 0.08738347887992859, 0.011493456549942493, -0.008066772483289242, -0.030793355777859688, 0.03770478442311287, -0.013332180678844452, 0.019082706421613693, -0.0009056553826667368, -0.06426169723272324, -0.007610802538692951, -0.007582490798085928, -0.015088739804923534, -0.003678853390738368, -0.034721970558166504, -0.012258762493729591, -0.013524821028113365, 0.013081187382340431, -0.02523980848491192, -0.02497280202805996, 0.021486015990376472, -0.04553112015128136, 0.03313484415411949, -0.004600257147103548, -0.019761797040700912, -0.018934216350317, 0.006890805903822184, 0.002663879655301571, -0.05251148343086243, 0.030298085883259773, 0.04646018519997597, -0.05062005668878555, -0.002767695812508464, 0.032824769616127014, 0.04619979485869408, 0.019133009016513824, -0.0041814991272985935, -0.003873406443744898, 0.003858199343085289, 0.03450069949030876, -0.04349548742175102, -0.009338921867311, -0.013175933621823788, -0.022834232077002525, -0.03196031600236893, 0.03479927405714989, -0.013414649292826653, 0.03334905207157135, -0.025879664346575737, 0.0018727598944678903, -0.008488158695399761, 0.00615672767162323, -0.019085386767983437, -0.030942274257540703, 0.021065646782517433, 0.04792028293013573, 0.016988294199109077, -0.0048023974522948265, -0.00800306349992752, 0.0056909844279289246, -0.04157138988375664, 0.003266345476731658, 0.029242772608995438, 0.015059782192111015, -0.04028348997235298, 0.0031880128663033247, -0.045454297214746475, 0.026043271645903587, -0.015124799683690071, -0.006464005447924137, 0.041965335607528687, 0.02851942926645279, -0.008708256296813488, 0.0312175452709198, 0.03633193299174309, 0.00824250653386116, -0.05274244770407677, -0.06600343436002731, 0.026724059134721756, 0.024003803730010986, 0.018339812755584717, -0.04440024495124817, -0.007539892103523016, 0.04992787167429924, -0.06266757845878601, 0.014514909125864506, 0.0015532213728874922, -0.0013186607975512743, -0.0500815287232399, -0.042348507791757584, -0.031249649822711945, 0.024392690509557724, 0.031103352084755898, 0.019772298634052277, 0.03562753647565842, 0.025938574224710464, -0.018670108169317245, -0.0851837545633316, -0.02063998393714428, -0.02735709957778454, -0.0010649225441738963, -0.04326167702674866, 0.04080388695001602, -0.03731051832437515, -0.04838944226503372, 0.022504162043333054, -0.03449920564889908, 0.013595610857009888, 0.05561532452702522, 0.0006458471762016416, 0.07334765046834946, 0.03700338304042816, 0.040145277976989746, -0.010962373577058315, -0.003755731275305152, 0.009843653067946434, -0.03090554289519787, 0.018007073551416397, 0.015578472055494785, 0.01563057117164135, 0.0053482018411159515, -0.02718716859817505, -0.007958931848406792, -0.015370341017842293, -0.022379668429493904, 0.010242698714137077, -0.01957951858639717, 0.0014236230636015534, -0.001559301745146513, -0.018517883494496346, -0.028958313167095184, -0.051423683762550354, 0.04215240478515625, 0.02118157036602497, -0.028954163193702698, -0.015351909212768078, 0.00754542788490653, -0.02476494200527668, -0.044689565896987915, 0.02179078571498394, 0.03320809826254845, -0.016496269032359123, -0.06778310239315033, -0.0012915348634123802, -0.007964344695210457, -0.04201101139187813, -0.03211399167776108, -0.017251107841730118, -0.026202626526355743, 0.040931034833192825, -0.058632634580135345, 0.02361292392015457, 0.03744274750351906, -0.026204576715826988, 0.03060700185596943, -0.06517164409160614, 0.05082567408680916, 0.03019466996192932, 0.002836017170920968, -0.025700237601995468, -0.021246107295155525, -0.03566015139222145, 0.01905660517513752, 0.05557916685938835, -0.026917558163404465, 0.04258374869823456, -0.009742929600179195, 0.03846338763833046, 0.004612233955413103, -0.06164262816309929, 0.012201824225485325, 0.006518794223666191, -0.012255393899977207, -0.03826797381043434, 0.00976691022515297, 0.011084877885878086, -0.008967499248683453, -0.003355908440425992, -0.0027690634597092867, -0.016373855993151665, 0.02825986221432686, 0.039323195815086365, -0.00219540111720562, -0.0074019297026097775, 0.006548820994794369, 0.04354443773627281, 0.0103595657274127, -0.01649789698421955, 0.053034938871860504, 0.010967100039124489, -0.039029136300086975, 0.023087626323103905, -0.036022819578647614, -0.013126694597303867, -0.023104626685380936, 0.0565556064248085, 0.05013801530003548, -0.04590949788689613, -0.01722821593284607, 0.03361232578754425, -0.05655178427696228, 0.02304663322865963, 0.06526504456996918, 0.02337397076189518, 0.06774156540632248, 0.00041642479482106864, -0.008372912183403969, 0.053388383239507675, -0.0309299286454916, -0.00271176197566092, 0.0036213656421750784, 0.03088834322988987, 0.017041705548763275, 0.043068282306194305, -0.0061756884679198265, -0.013520579785108566, 0.018306495621800423, -0.029059067368507385, 0.05488419905304909, -0.026562999933958054, 0.009843220002949238, 0.013936014845967293, -0.008629228919744492, 0.03617113456130028, 0.018874546512961388, -0.03611399605870247, 0.030116429552435875, 0.0005797796766273677, -0.02123294025659561, -0.08281942456960678, 0.0246333759278059, -0.011003086343407631, 0.028612151741981506, 0.014085213653743267, 0.0496240109205246, -0.002018599072471261, 0.009572378359735012, -0.008289889432489872, 0.01619008183479309, 0.033351752907037735, -0.007009691558778286, 0.03581990674138069, -0.0524459071457386, -0.01579390838742256, 0.026545686647295952, -0.01353210024535656, -0.04424775391817093, -0.020004095509648323, 0.008846275508403778, 0.019171379506587982, 0.0544649139046669, -0.005341857206076384, -0.01800522953271866, 0.023236408829689026, -0.00909550953656435, -0.05380421131849289, 0.016867807134985924, -0.031958192586898804, 0.011553490534424782, 0.007531024515628815, -0.01775290258228779 ]
<p>I want to know if the initiation of a state Renewable Portfolio Standard affects the level of renewable energy output in that state.</p> <p>I don't have access to Stata right now, so I'm stuck using excel. I have data for renewable energy output for all thirty states that have initiated Renewable Portfolio Standards, with energy output levels from 1990-2011. I also know when each state initiated their respective RPS within that time frame, and I want to know if following the initiation, did the level of renewable energy output change significantly.</p>
36,303
[ -0.036523424088954926, -0.02828471176326275, -0.016948353499174118, 0.028794044628739357, 0.014448664151132107, 0.02202014997601509, -0.0455094575881958, -0.04482647776603699, 0.027140164747834206, -0.05765942856669426, 0.02842184156179428, 0.02600954659283161, 0.031021827831864357, 0.011108528822660446, 0.009781516157090664, -0.0013545762049034238, -0.003575945273041725, 0.009561103768646717, -0.015537803061306477, 0.040363747626543045, -0.036823537200689316, 0.022693663835525513, -0.01362351793795824, -0.0050231292843818665, -0.007441237568855286, 0.06435336172580719, 0.029337724670767784, -0.0018655977910384536, 0.010749504901468754, 0.07874689251184464, -0.007097057532519102, -0.03138846158981323, -0.010650811716914177, 0.022732745856046677, 0.006311788223683834, 0.004454051610082388, -0.039207033812999725, -0.0531214214861393, 0.013420277275145054, 0.06125560402870178, -0.021142620593309402, -0.009440068155527115, -0.033540353178977966, 0.005264993291348219, -0.0467759408056736, 0.020932883024215698, 0.007727723103016615, -0.021164286881685257, 0.04541536420583725, -0.03153986111283302, 0.0594877228140831, 0.013204628601670265, 0.02162221260368824, 0.02348189428448677, -0.03883371874690056, 0.014270439743995667, 0.01897178776562214, 0.031918056309223175, 0.03089054301381111, -0.03790511190891266, -0.0022894153371453285, -0.011602852493524551, -0.004144398961216211, -0.06024446338415146, -0.06423068791627884, 0.009295094758272171, 0.024779358878731728, -0.018555589020252228, 0.056115925312042236, -0.014791726134717464, 0.005905766971409321, -0.007782262749969959, 0.005636667832732201, 0.028960401192307472, 0.019434789195656776, -0.04767629876732826, 0.01460676547139883, 0.0007129417499527335, 0.023981573060154915, 0.043574847280979156, -0.00985641684383154, 0.024294260889291763, 0.02886606752872467, 0.03725741431117058, 0.049205176532268524, 0.022489087656140327, 0.05482843890786171, -0.027020888403058052, 0.047306474298238754, -0.00007388043741229922, 0.0016254584770649672, -0.015259556472301483, 0.06032451242208481, 0.020306093618273735, -0.013340595178306103, 0.021233055740594864, -0.042818766087293625, 0.06049976497888565, -0.008436811156570911, -0.028976043686270714, 0.029773708432912827, -0.020034175366163254, 0.029427433386445045, 0.05354803800582886, 0.010430173948407173, -0.028812291100621223, -0.030843181535601616, -0.015117999166250229, -0.014450836926698685, -0.01336436253041029, -0.062409449368715286, 0.0056776260025799274, -0.0036683506332337856, -0.04088122770190239, 0.0034871124662458897, -0.014946671202778816, -0.00080727634485811, 0.022924665361642838, 0.04357282072305679, 0.04448772966861725, 0.05976800248026848, -0.008823100477457047, -0.007109682075679302, -0.0005919901304878294, -0.03804023191332817, 0.03908153623342514, 0.0020097452215850353, -0.047196634113788605, -0.06186002120375633, 0.047425609081983566, -0.013618090189993382, -0.023274224251508713, 0.00846173893660307, -0.045006077736616135, 0.0080442875623703, 0.014394612051546574, -0.0787343680858612, -0.07555179297924042, 0.0349883995950222, 0.02963801473379135, 0.013550342060625553, -0.05099489167332649, -0.006074443459510803, -0.010341661982238293, 0.06440286338329315, -0.011814834550023079, 0.03988324850797653, 0.027846509590744972, 0.026103122159838676, -0.023514648899435997, -0.08596692234277725, -0.0192792359739542, 0.017088396474719048, -0.03938513994216919, -0.025944069027900696, -0.03812776133418083, 0.025545185431838036, 0.01925944723188877, 0.0007488929550163448, 0.005356848705559969, 0.02804175391793251, 0.02969648316502571, -0.01770315133035183, 0.03345299884676933, -0.012583326548337936, -0.04589385166764259, 0.08294578641653061, 0.0009143628412857652, 0.011965220794081688, -0.009936576709151268, -0.005394523963332176, 0.004087656736373901, 0.00765728484839201, 0.006930239032953978, 0.06457582861185074, -0.0022713439539074898, -0.019162874668836594, -0.030328767374157906, -0.02091994136571884, -0.018737930804491043, -0.04467383772134781, -0.017367206513881683, -0.010030541568994522, -0.02598082274198532, 0.0010719436686486006, 0.04916495457291603, -0.02323434129357338, -0.029520325362682343, -0.007199739571660757, -0.028105001896619797, -0.03566639870405197, -0.06676828116178513, 0.010385693982243538, -0.029469406232237816, -0.031112538650631905, 0.006479451898485422, 0.0034455826971679926, 0.03727737441658974, 0.0048291985876858234, 0.0034372354857623577, -0.013346784748136997, -0.016346663236618042, 0.011577548459172249, -0.0037768923211842775, -0.007454167120158672, 0.018605099990963936, 0.06246425211429596, -0.00619127182289958, 0.04662732034921646, -0.045747626572847366, -0.0378086231648922, 0.006761068478226662, -0.029042575508356094, 0.017362790182232857, 0.0045113954693078995, 0.013825255446135998, -0.013076266273856163, -0.009477350860834122, -0.0341632105410099, 0.025815622881054878, -0.023631175979971886, 0.03924529626965523, 0.04332299157977104, -0.004994100891053677, -0.0003880314470734447, 0.007364437449723482, 0.006116251926869154, 0.007556339725852013, -0.033330969512462616, -0.01694466546177864, -0.012568349950015545, 0.013359133154153824, 0.036066994071006775, 0.040678419172763824, -0.04104890301823616, -0.005748101510107517, 0.05492006987333298, 0.006880700122565031, 0.010643823072314262, 0.03898625448346138, 0.005800607614219189, -0.0295764971524477, 0.02193657122552395, -0.0016391074750572443, -0.020665060728788376, 0.036585964262485504, -0.001974374521523714, 0.014286466874182224, 0.02600204199552536, 0.02949100360274315, -0.006713775917887688, 0.06396780908107758, -0.0023596559185534716, -0.01573745347559452, -0.009138579480350018, -0.032732900232076645, 0.060954347252845764, -0.046681392937898636, 0.0006279450608417392, 0.01852230168879032, 0.051102880388498306, 0.009802864864468575, -0.006385068874806166, -0.014267956838011742, 0.015414126217365265, 0.009502897039055824, 0.017851321026682854, 0.0062405625358223915, 0.014961916022002697, -0.008811535313725471, 0.038009002804756165, -0.03982725739479065, 0.004760737530887127, -0.019820960238575935, -0.046153128147125244, 0.016674121841788292, -0.026049280539155006, 0.017595963552594185, -0.031127527356147766, 0.0016413050470873713, -0.0013357722200453281, -0.006036605220288038, 0.020237399265170097, -0.0010939838830381632, -0.016224008053541183, 0.0033349930308759212, 0.022653188556432724, -0.006775245536118746, 0.009889887645840645, -0.040200311690568924, -0.05378502979874611, 0.04076356068253517, -0.010557329282164574, -0.039909329265356064, -0.002795497188344598, -0.01680772751569748, -0.022398555651307106, -0.015753384679555893, -0.024010293185710907, 0.053491294384002686, 0.010563487187027931, -0.035654738545417786, 0.026466907933354378, -0.052911821752786636, 0.003816047450527549, -0.023286640644073486, -0.0074541023932397366, 0.0048562390729784966, 0.006569974590092897, 0.0058426926843822, -0.005141363479197025, -0.07352132350206375, 0.01642892137169838, -0.07609085738658905, -0.03717329353094101, 0.017878161743283272, 0.0010335437254980206, 0.06730325520038605, -0.020950907841324806, -0.06683351844549179, 0.01659521833062172, 0.045025598257780075, -0.03208655118942261, -0.044175706803798676, -0.005072605796158314, 0.02924199588596821, -0.039356786757707596, 0.01782366633415222, 0.01856660097837448, -0.013422185555100441, 0.013155483640730381, -0.027495555579662323, 0.0563962422311306, 0.015794361010193825, 0.01529951673001051, 0.015308048576116562, 0.035097040235996246, -0.013980149291455746, 0.020815877243876457, 0.08150982111692429, 0.028642114251852036, -0.013518065214157104, 0.0015676161274313927, -0.029753495007753372, 0.02686021290719509, 0.009127181954681873, -0.04101273790001869, 0.02427618019282818, -0.030796416103839874, 0.0004461155040189624, -0.060580864548683167, 0.032577626407146454, 0.028553621843457222, -0.008326934650540352, -0.006510636303573847, -0.022574851289391518, 0.013035416603088379, 0.0030683339573442936, -0.018570641055703163, -0.0041815610602498055, 0.028134064748883247, 0.030984511598944664, 0.008001991547644138, -0.0021168836392462254, 0.004711252637207508, 0.011778568848967552, -0.0023305928334593773, -0.0395587757229805, 0.06878279894590378, 0.02678784541785717, 0.029277514666318893, -0.004305923357605934, -0.03729597106575966, -0.006930653937160969, -0.07081247121095657, -0.03489141911268234, -0.016884449869394302, 0.058892060071229935, -0.004493989981710911, 0.02217732183635235, -0.009972350671887398, 0.0017326140077784657, -0.006538867484778166, -0.026213262230157852, -0.03528774529695511, 0.011268938891589642, 0.00029904235270805657, -0.0009921162854880095, 0.025765368714928627, -0.0035864131059497595, -0.018650682643055916, -0.0028663205448538065, -0.00500065041705966, -0.009557526558637619, -0.005286301486194134, -0.0409574955701828, -0.009872420690953732, 0.0018236462492495775, -0.013078014366328716, 0.03470679000020027, -0.00026353521388955414, 0.0008217759313993156, -0.05763857439160347, 0.07632077485322952, 0.026121284812688828, -0.035606976598501205, 0.003340944880619645, -0.04248533397912979, 0.008734355680644512, 0.004421639256179333, 0.02817622385919094, 0.04981319606304169, 0.01307260524481535, -0.009996934793889523, 0.045451365411281586, -0.002669012639671564, 0.05069981887936592, 0.022965898737311363, 0.01690344326198101, -0.0258884746581316, -0.027985993772745132, -0.02622935175895691, 0.007911691442131996, -0.03020137920975685, -0.0004441689234226942, -0.013280823826789856, 0.04280854016542435, -0.00037266197614371777, -0.03437170013785362, 0.02049975097179413, 0.02510487660765648, 0.01711028255522251, 0.027363020926713943, -0.013809647411108017, -0.018892502412199974, 0.028236109763383865, -0.023840345442295074, 0.0003360403352417052, 0.024423038586974144, -0.011439843103289604, 0.03167680278420448, 0.031646810472011566, -0.03310435637831688, -0.04943319410085678, 0.0020066609140485525, -0.0034121365752071142, 0.05743763595819473, 0.038307175040245056, -0.01972503960132599, 0.04117266833782196, 0.029807239770889282, 0.0063353232108056545, -0.0117590157315135, 0.058195456862449646, -0.09572158008813858, -0.0070556895807385445, 0.06629408150911331, 0.032944440841674805, -0.04085538536310196, -0.036936067044734955, -0.022573838010430336, -0.0031688211020082235, 0.043391965329647064, -0.03498128801584244, 0.00031706891604699194, -0.035741519182920456, 0.005424481350928545, -0.01709008403122425, -0.037399519234895706, -0.030258579179644585, -0.01594415307044983, 0.00008984395390143618, 0.07597988098859787, -0.01328260637819767, -0.05528677627444267, -0.007326091639697552, 0.009468278847634792, 0.009528293274343014, 0.04018016159534454, -0.017748111858963966, -0.03371063992381096, 0.018867071717977524, 0.05250922963023186, -0.04251524806022644, -0.04509240761399269, 0.018627746030688286, -0.022166723385453224, 0.02093098871409893, 0.04779406264424324, -0.006589887663722038, -0.047181304544210434, -0.012949204072356224, 0.001631737221032381, -0.009317233227193356, -0.015031055547297001, -0.04564586654305458, 0.04753466695547104, 0.03420589119195938, 0.011576810851693153, 0.03602788969874382, 0.06692202389240265, -0.0276377871632576, 0.024291418492794037, -0.02172764390707016, 0.048727262765169144, -0.025892430916428566, -0.0396830290555954, -0.03433246538043022, -0.012483506463468075, 0.0036098675336688757, 0.015107683837413788, -0.004899310413748026, 0.04870627820491791, -0.03219827637076378, -0.0012513019610196352, 0.013164440169930458, 0.03542155772447586, -0.052944302558898926, 0.007193184923380613, -0.03391159698367119, 0.0579267181456089, -0.01577524095773697, -0.04362976551055908, 0.006907033734023571, 0.00848097912967205, 0.007423712871968746, 0.0029769625980407, -0.016171753406524658, 0.04235836863517761, -0.022498002275824547, -0.009181972593069077, -0.014938043430447578, -0.012773299589753151, 0.049667198210954666, -0.015597929246723652, 0.01444106362760067, 0.00012910964142065495, -0.04982098937034607, -0.02075611613690853, 0.03158147260546684, -0.018822241574525833, 0.00883018784224987, -0.017416207119822502, 0.01237555593252182, -0.029648801311850548, -0.030921433120965958, -0.027317428961396217, -0.05124174430966377, 0.005053945817053318, 0.022462107241153717, -0.013991553336381912, -0.0208731796592474, 0.009038896299898624, 0.02983243204653263, 0.006966700777411461, -0.01409345492720604, 0.030256079509854317, -0.07177656888961792, 0.016361217945814133, 0.005606803111732006, 0.02930823527276516, 0.0870005190372467, -0.07617319375276566, 0.021064970642328262, -0.0050138188526034355, -0.023180745542049408, -0.058656882494688034, -0.04966744780540466, 0.006760193966329098, -0.03625725582242012, -0.003478730097413063, -0.020816633477807045, -0.016599591821432114, 0.02976972796022892, -0.018662668764591217, 0.005316145718097687, 0.062420155853033066, -0.03595295548439026, 0.017288871109485626, -0.010515743866562843, -0.0009856960969045758, -0.018936067819595337, -0.0085452226921916, -0.016448328271508217, -0.018077366054058075, 0.010294858366250992, -0.019444135949015617, 0.022726111114025116, -0.01993817836046219, 0.003953759092837572, 0.014828243292868137, 0.07440081983804703, -0.0173677746206522, 0.009092596359550953, 0.028849303722381592, -0.0007721737492829561, 0.03387288376688957, -0.01028635073453188, -0.02954285964369774, -0.003134377533569932, -0.028436293825507164, -0.04003762826323509, -0.060844238847494125, -0.02483104169368744, 0.01137456577271223, 0.035698868334293365, 0.016299236565828323, 0.010127706453204155, 0.003885099897161126, -0.034235674887895584, 0.03651450201869011, -0.10100127756595612, 0.015110342763364315, 0.019274095073342323, 0.00944780558347702, 0.03505028784275055, 0.03353192284703255, -0.0007187031442299485, 0.04025103524327278, 0.0197204127907753, -0.00166647182777524, 0.039056167006492615, 0.05883074924349785, 0.003534977324306965, 0.04686726629734039, -0.025956852361559868, -0.05372260883450508, -0.013697064481675625, -0.0318540595471859, 0.00046396604739129543, -0.03732497990131378, -0.013951100409030914, 0.03400002047419548, 0.036990635097026825, -0.01875012367963791, -0.055409591645002365, 0.0011371151776984334, -0.08781955391168594, 0.028592053800821304, -0.016817251220345497, -0.012022062204778194, 0.04086481034755707, 0.021173398941755295, 0.031351108103990555, 0.0056065586395561695, 0.018181435763835907, -0.05699051916599274, -0.052778538316488266, -0.03335731476545334, -0.013360108248889446, -0.019199924543499947, 0.01850012317299843, 0.00464900815859437, -0.015494287014007568, 0.038755152374506, -0.024271806702017784, -0.013326297514140606, -0.0007635194342583418, 0.04941696673631668, -0.008320893160998821, 0.08983998745679855, -0.013953768648207188, 0.03463738411664963, -0.03298233449459076, 0.012830554507672787, 0.12751448154449463, 0.07862646132707596, 0.03828226402401924, -0.05393016338348389, -0.0004351147508714348, 0.052932433784008026, 0.0054485248401761055, 0.0060544745065271854, -0.0033442501444369555, 0.005976539105176926, -0.05376380309462547, 0.000490581092890352, 0.05716888606548309, -0.015420145355165005, 0.0021879852283746004, 0.05966392159461975, -0.0249937754124403, -0.00686864135786891, 0.034586891531944275, 0.011978677473962307, 0.0012645672541111708, 0.022907977923750877, -0.07152444124221802, -0.019783444702625275, -0.02573125995695591, -0.020397670567035675, -0.01787320338189602, -0.013443614356219769, 0.02218218334019184, 0.005332783795893192, -0.003594205481931567, 0.008988309651613235, 0.022898539900779724, 0.042200978845357895, -0.0504394993185997, -0.016243334859609604, 0.029568688943982124, -0.01079225167632103, 0.00021234793530311435, 0.04482806473970413, -0.01977497898042202, -0.00353034446015954, -0.016417980194091797, -0.005593231413513422, -0.05736267939209938, 0.005862760357558727, -0.02646445855498314, 0.01634330488741398, 0.002693905495107174, -0.030881782993674278, -0.02553040347993374, -0.006705054547637701, -0.021455585956573486, 0.0005457057268358767, 0.0033962547313421965, 0.01306894887238741, -0.0042542824521660805, -0.030062468722462654, 0.0015524548944085836, -0.03164489567279816, -0.008110549300909042, -0.04272770881652832, 0.013901288621127605, 0.0025194534100592136, -0.021087780594825745, 0.033040229231119156, -0.052635226398706436, 0.031273625791072845, -0.025585278868675232, -0.017651136964559555, 0.014500959776341915, 0.031448569148778915, -0.019045842811465263, -0.049789249897003174, 0.04015617072582245, 0.01842867210507393, 0.056549303233623505, 0.022563261911273003, -0.00020999567641410977, -0.007610384374856949, -0.058042868971824646, 0.02263128198683262, -0.016230443492531776, -0.00572701171040535, -0.07073808461427689, 0.027698032557964325, 0.050426214933395386, 0.03637140616774559, 0.02209431864321232, 0.01977752521634102, 0.009688246995210648, 0.044674474745988846, 0.054719228297472, -0.05698821321129799, -0.012600555084645748, -0.015431977808475494, -0.026944423094391823, -0.021396715193986893, -0.04249643534421921, 0.024462316185235977, 0.037442829459905624, 0.02406362071633339, -0.020576875656843185, 0.05031460523605347, 0.014211430214345455, -0.0032754619605839252, 0.012323775328695774, -0.021854357793927193, -0.0038917053025215864, -0.018400821834802628, 0.01740849018096924, -0.01566988229751587, 0.024744953960180283, 0.004097911063581705, -0.0224432572722435, 0.014526845887303352, -0.026245631277561188, -0.0692833811044693, 0.03759997338056564, -0.036273520439863205, 0.029486291110515594, -0.015469453297555447, -0.004700383637100458, -0.056424032896757126, -0.03564005345106125, 0.02895861677825451, 0.01845710724592209, 0.006730486173182726, 0.05606629326939583, -0.01630004681646824, 0.0007322398014366627, 0.04377642273902893, -0.01204990316182375, 0.03834991529583931, -0.010012662969529629, 0.007153714075684547, 0.01040050107985735, 0.027875760570168495, -0.0451919361948967, -0.048656661063432693, 0.05025152117013931, -0.019406672567129135, -0.010667572729289532, 0.013710133731365204, 0.010289080440998077, 0.037704914808273315, 0.034378040581941605, -0.026931116357445717, -0.04349231347441673, 0.059684183448553085, 0.032162994146347046, 0.022371923550963402, -0.013725976459681988, 0.03446367010474205, 0.04756782203912735, 0.024777727201581, 0.014121003448963165, 0.002102100057527423, -0.012214927934110165, 0.00511394627392292, 0.024926362559199333, -0.0473451241850853, -0.012309607118368149, -0.005219232756644487, 0.004481927957385778, -0.04765074700117111, -0.012607574462890625, 0.008228342048823833, 0.01663913205265999, 0.017832942306995392, 0.001766243833117187, 0.002324096392840147, 0.035822562873363495, -0.005011445842683315, -0.04394732043147087, -0.004647324327379465, -0.005337586160749197, -0.03154439851641655, -0.0016900666523724794, -0.010758312419056892, 0.05311395227909088, 0.04076730087399483, -0.055760789662599564, -0.024933947250247, 0.0023829711135476828, -0.01941843144595623, -0.049647510051727295, 0.020808028057217598, -0.01752496510744095, 0.029257813468575478, 0.008179847151041031, 0.015721185132861137, 0.016104724258184433, 0.030984560027718544, -0.0012079395819455385, -0.013988937251269817, -0.04825102165341377, 0.010129693895578384, 0.047252945601940155, -0.03860137611627579, 0.014170844107866287, -0.04818861931562424, -0.026441365480422974, 0.02007462829351425, -0.03251722827553749, 0.04125968739390373, -0.007942019030451775, 0.02667822130024433, 0.0016449486138299108, 0.07236842066049576, 0.04123292863368988, 0.023773325607180595, -0.006309925112873316, -0.03351706266403198, 0.005259198602288961, -0.019640721380710602, -0.016673989593982697, 0.03646262362599373, 0.023776214569807053, -0.010594786144793034, 0.004585241433233023, -0.0005064779543317854, -0.02742614783346653, 0.004021647851914167, 0.003055923618376255, -0.02763631008565426, 0.010123803280293941, 0.01174361351877451, 0.015230861492455006, -0.025815529748797417, -0.009407324716448784, 0.06528676301240921, 0.010458585806190968, -0.010283537209033966, -0.0029788524843752384, 0.012130982242524624, -0.026102369651198387, 0.029634898528456688, -0.02051878534257412, -0.03685516491532326, -0.06101629510521889, 0.004165590740740299, -0.013469253666698933, -0.003930853679776192, -0.06958969682455063, 0.05264852195978165, -0.019186487421393394, 0.01479408796876669, 0.042957156896591187, -0.024726947769522667, 0.030138250440359116, -0.018972737714648247, 0.03092830628156662, -0.05542745068669319, 0.08489186316728592, 0.03527713194489479, -0.026783781126141548, -0.024455418810248375, -0.018562249839305878, -0.020690161734819412, 0.01296649593859911, 0.013250678777694702, -0.017642298713326454, -0.008748441934585571, -0.001097246422432363, 0.01502128317952156, 0.03637140616774559, -0.020579295232892036, 0.08336920291185379, 0.02863372303545475, 0.015606889501214027, 0.0005006120773032308, -0.030204283073544502, 0.018877310678362846, -0.0022420843597501516, 0.006306622177362442, 0.016773540526628494, -0.016798293218016624, 0.013204040005803108, -0.012926696799695492, 0.022793972864747047, 0.012795768678188324, -0.020535215735435486, 0.05350559577345848, -0.008869441226124763, 0.03750508651137352, 0.01320568099617958, 0.010808245278894901, -0.03290294110774994, 0.02495540864765644, -0.05945653095841408, -0.039946217089891434, 0.0375484824180603, -0.010562916286289692, 0.014634447172284126, -0.028905121609568596, 0.018100133165717125, 0.00040802659350447357, -0.007084558252245188, 0.029857993125915527, 0.08252823352813721, 0.027620425447821617, 0.05147320777177811, 0.01253554318100214, 0.02198082208633423, 0.035841748118400574, -0.014629893936216831, -0.01855013146996498, 0.045911069959402084, 0.053059350699186325, -0.003463319968432188, 0.03311094269156456, 0.04215336963534355, -0.0038847578689455986, -0.007341673597693443, 0.026109732687473297, 0.0038727179635316133, -0.025240588933229446, -0.05369130149483681, 0.0370589941740036, 0.030989674851298332, 0.028484640643000603, 0.050848010927438736, -0.023473307490348816, 0.038031432777643204, -0.00453959871083498, 0.0001337457651970908, -0.04463791102170944, 0.03139569237828255, -0.04383748769760132, -0.023876501247286797, 0.01854417286813259, 0.02943292073905468, -0.0022106694523245096, 0.02563585713505745, 0.002779416972771287, 0.03483753651380539, 0.03573156148195267, -0.04138671234250069, 0.016811441630125046, -0.005002198740839958, 0.011228037066757679, -0.007417891174554825, -0.006740707904100418, -0.009322522208094597, -0.017225008457899094, 0.026922203600406647, 0.012031788006424904, -0.016985995694994926, -0.027743514627218246, -0.05982455983757973, 0.013048558495938778, 0.048561837524175644, -0.02375863306224346, -0.033053141087293625, -0.00400380976498127, -0.024855773895978928, -0.04089942201972008, -0.03752103075385094 ]
<p>I am working with culture cells where one dish has been transfected with a scrambled knockdown clone and two dishes which have been transfected with two knockdown clones each knocking down the expression of a single gene. </p> <p>An example of an experiment I have performed is to measure the mitochondrial membrane potential (using a fluorescent dye) in these cells using a confocal microscope. This experiment was repeated on three independent occasions.</p> <p>On each experimental day, the intensity of the laser which I used (the laser "gain") varies therefore I cannot combine all experimental days without expressing the dye intensity of each knockdown clone as a percent of the control "scrambled" clone (e.g. control = 100% mean intensity; knockdown clone 1 = 50% mean intensity). </p> <p>Therefore, <strong>I need to test for a difference in means between my control scrambled clone and each of the knockdown clones</strong>, where my control scrambled clone is set to 100% dye intensity on each experimental day and my knockdown clones are normalised to this control. Therefore, my control has no variance (100% for all three experimental days) while my knockdown clones do have variance. </p> <p>I know an ANOVA would not be feasible given the difference in variance. I will look into the procedure suggested by Michael Lew, but <strong>would a t-test be unacceptable as well?</strong> (I have seen papers using ANOVA and t-tests in these circumstances, but in spite of this I am assuming these should not be used). Thanks in advance.</p>
73,803
[ -0.02750258892774582, 0.01857449859380722, -0.011967421509325504, -0.02856449782848358, 0.043101318180561066, 0.002478797221556306, 0.021212970837950706, 0.004593930207192898, 0.03724179416894913, -0.014503872953355312, 0.06441236287355423, 0.03408537805080414, 0.08286251872777939, 0.012016741558909416, 0.014408762566745281, -0.012315668165683746, -0.029826238751411438, -0.03668579086661339, -0.015045764856040478, 0.012686763890087605, -0.014362054876983166, 0.020994167774915695, -0.0006398172117769718, -0.016979441046714783, -0.023509010672569275, 0.01144262496381998, -0.004476600326597691, -0.021350888535380363, -0.007971559651196003, 0.07768291980028152, -0.046770431101322174, -0.0364699512720108, -0.009615294635295868, 0.044934213161468506, 0.029033925384283066, 0.006597685627639294, -0.0242446418851614, -0.008435103110969067, -0.010626775212585926, 0.024874834343791008, -0.015123697929084301, 0.014436646364629269, -0.002790018217638135, 0.07431955635547638, 0.014560448937118053, 0.034652065485715866, -0.01138122659176588, -0.015647409483790398, 0.030049452558159828, -0.07450338453054428, 0.06182820722460747, -0.025687305256724358, 0.009604312479496002, 0.058453552424907684, -0.0033381094690412283, -0.013361429795622826, 0.04803653433918953, 0.05164972320199013, -0.022587567567825317, -0.03541761264204979, -0.009565363638103008, -0.01205663662403822, 0.01273309625685215, -0.0005193865508772433, -0.0383753702044487, 0.030682073906064034, -0.025792444124817848, -0.042488742619752884, 0.050341758877038956, -0.031617630273103714, 0.008083450607955456, 0.013106086291372776, 0.0380217470228672, -0.008268075063824654, -0.033984292298555374, -0.0032626420725136995, 0.03590358421206474, 0.011346357874572277, 0.03213613107800484, 0.039839476346969604, -0.00015849174815230072, 0.010881222784519196, 0.00048274340224452317, 0.06245923414826393, 0.031553205102682114, -0.03627564013004303, 0.03507111966609955, -0.05425756424665451, 0.004578711930662394, 0.05039023607969284, -0.017262296751141548, -0.00928555428981781, 0.0734853595495224, 0.012211575172841549, -0.04732898995280266, 0.000045396587665891275, -0.01713102124631405, 0.030252959579229355, -0.04493521526455879, 0.020779220387339592, -0.008434891700744629, -0.04585287719964981, 0.048544708639383316, 0.022396497428417206, -0.012904004193842411, -0.017328744754195213, 0.03466266021132469, 0.008201029151678085, -0.011357489973306656, 0.0010744589380919933, -0.012575751170516014, 0.025330910459160805, -0.0016670932527631521, -0.008599972352385521, 0.02428274042904377, -0.00774786714464426, -0.02856152318418026, 0.008529597893357277, 0.07848919928073883, 0.07503843307495117, 0.05210120975971222, -0.06589853018522263, 0.028887389227747917, -0.02062668837606907, -0.02105381153523922, 0.06862994283437729, 0.03127158433198929, -0.004871123470366001, -0.013968126848340034, 0.0861639752984047, 0.021519292145967484, -0.015592186711728573, 0.014078723266720772, -0.015941448509693146, 0.04061032459139824, -0.026348110288381577, -0.0861874595284462, -0.052288152277469635, 0.05494781583547592, -0.03449972718954086, -0.006567248608916998, -0.09288551658391953, -0.009060671553015709, 0.02108515053987503, 0.07680036872625351, 0.019161298871040344, 0.028278833255171776, -0.00005127802069182508, 0.03996525704860687, 0.018037252128124237, 0.004059382248669863, -0.002913877833634615, 0.007298929616808891, -0.03377726301550865, -0.020000135526061058, -0.058679912239313126, 0.0087980842217803, 0.023130949586629868, 0.006717101205140352, 0.0185988899320364, 0.05658125504851341, -0.015228216536343098, -0.004960829857736826, 0.0016353419050574303, 0.040096465498209, -0.02365628071129322, 0.06464630365371704, -0.0248222928494215, 0.014317420311272144, 0.03102942742407322, -0.04939132183790207, 0.007026283536106348, -0.008060641586780548, 0.010952549055218697, -0.0009882122976705432, -0.025146950036287308, 0.02215856872498989, -0.00722508504986763, 0.02574961818754673, 0.029022831469774246, -0.029362069442868233, 0.009852155111730099, -0.019638828933238983, -0.0032337047159671783, 0.00552744185552001, 0.03951973095536232, -0.015473654493689537, 0.012419873848557472, 0.038823202252388, -0.035608306527137756, -0.05593091621994972, -0.03266049921512604, 0.009003538638353348, -0.01382793765515089, -0.03572332113981247, 0.011053957976400852, -0.006896591745316982, 0.01433488167822361, 0.02280898205935955, -0.007312502712011337, -0.0012426377506926656, -0.010252343490719795, 0.024185674265027046, -0.025481251999735832, 0.046399571001529694, 0.034650180488824844, 0.04214392229914665, -0.03824950382113457, 0.028976421803236008, -0.014779080636799335, -0.0074541764333844185, 0.01289407443255186, -0.0458492711186409, 0.02984859049320221, 0.004555416293442249, -0.021682901307940483, -0.011732615530490875, -0.002062432933598757, -0.006313770078122616, 0.03274386003613472, -0.06191026791930199, 0.07323342561721802, 0.07162267714738846, 0.003596992464736104, 0.04501383751630783, 0.018271731212735176, 0.022675758227705956, 0.008648807182908058, -0.014923918060958385, -0.023188594728708267, -0.04010752961039543, -0.004729220177978277, 0.03788292407989502, -0.016338424757122993, -0.02367890253663063, 0.02353166788816452, 0.08045380562543869, -0.03566064313054085, 0.025067312642931938, 0.036046333611011505, 0.006659578066319227, -0.03882208094000816, 0.01129703875631094, 0.04700377956032753, 0.009781536646187305, -0.01011737436056137, -0.017841937020421028, -0.025603974238038063, 0.02364637888967991, 0.02182970754802227, 0.0020583225414156914, -0.0011282576015219092, -0.014647803269326687, -0.01800275221467018, -0.041174210608005524, -0.03602880239486694, 0.053769536316394806, -0.03283946216106415, 0.023161401972174644, 0.029685022309422493, -0.02333701215684414, -0.0007199267274700105, -0.010085675865411758, -0.021711142733693123, 0.018328282982110977, 0.006099036429077387, -0.03686792403459549, 0.03050994500517845, 0.021380895748734474, -0.010703474283218384, -0.007008077576756477, -0.007327067665755749, 0.015526246279478073, -0.029594190418720245, -0.023378923535346985, -0.0004317694983910769, -0.0213309396058321, 0.04577469825744629, -0.04233156889677048, 0.006710004527121782, -0.01252563577145338, -0.03159739822149277, 0.023046251386404037, 0.009948458522558212, -0.03384963050484657, 0.0038725531194359064, 0.009547649882733822, -0.012999323196709156, 0.03796948492527008, -0.01022731140255928, 0.0015282741514965892, 0.03497513011097908, 0.03061007335782051, -0.04891796037554741, -0.036125462502241135, -0.014254694804549217, 0.019244268536567688, 0.014205176383256912, -0.015778979286551476, 0.030454620718955994, 0.040210895240306854, -0.055884771049022675, 0.04929514229297638, -0.014484865590929985, -0.00341203436255455, 0.010964288376271725, 0.021059660241007805, -0.005249790847301483, -0.028184033930301666, 0.03147519379854202, 0.03456473723053932, -0.04360628500580788, -0.03301514685153961, -0.04402019828557968, -0.07241293042898178, 0.04044510796666145, 0.014082618057727814, 0.04743644967675209, -0.021867338567972183, -0.04407406598329544, 0.060323379933834076, 0.0268394835293293, -0.04540363699197769, -0.051816679537296295, 0.0065543800592422485, -0.04806582257151604, -0.02028036303818226, 0.04576370120048523, -0.017302170395851135, -0.04084761440753937, 0.04315846413373947, 0.008370805531740189, 0.022329282015562057, 0.07322628796100616, -0.001352490158751607, -0.0221837367862463, 0.0061681014485657215, 0.025704996660351753, -0.022700700908899307, 0.021072156727313995, 0.03225935250520706, -0.02463456243276596, 0.008207415230572224, -0.01611451618373394, -0.0007259725243784487, 0.00602822145447135, -0.0427389070391655, 0.026701845228672028, -0.007870872505009174, 0.013108083978295326, -0.025101467967033386, 0.01162764336913824, 0.008689386770129204, -0.005121205467730761, 0.005645778030157089, 0.04000299051403999, 0.02087869495153427, -0.04185596480965614, 0.004687223117798567, 0.0693618506193161, 0.047923069447278976, 0.0012032343074679375, -0.028372475877404213, -0.031430669128894806, 0.0044640423730015755, 0.011452999897301197, -0.02530546858906746, -0.003717529121786356, 0.03075559251010418, 0.03681262955069542, 0.01903717592358589, -0.013107776641845703, -0.01539433654397726, -0.007145988289266825, -0.04873359948396683, 0.018530873581767082, -0.04856029525399208, 0.023390352725982666, 0.016555188223719597, 0.030020635575056076, 0.0366094633936882, -0.022297581657767296, -0.0004827247466892004, -0.03169878572225571, -0.04446260258555412, 0.0042479382827878, 0.032653000205755234, -0.040208958089351654, -0.010038968175649643, 0.007007375359535217, 0.005554615054279566, -0.004146383609622717, 0.005771902855485678, -0.013809995725750923, 0.029459530487656593, -0.07000034302473068, 0.015285314992070198, -0.023850802332162857, -0.023761019110679626, -0.02837865799665451, 0.026058830320835114, 0.025632137432694435, -0.02037368342280388, 0.0069863395765423775, 0.021469146013259888, -0.0320529043674469, -0.011973570100963116, 0.013857140205800533, -0.002760913921520114, 0.012055153958499432, 0.0598946176469326, 0.026842668652534485, 0.07531704753637314, -0.040564585477113724, 0.03251257911324501, 0.01835820823907852, 0.005978368688374758, 0.025150703266263008, 0.004247856792062521, -0.021768076345324516, -0.033245790749788284, -0.03161151707172394, 0.027635492384433746, 0.021964235231280327, 0.044826410710811615, -0.016756556928157806, 0.018574440851807594, 0.02774914540350437, -0.010126105509698391, 0.003679414978250861, 0.04345205798745155, -0.008263183757662773, 0.0071319290436804295, -0.06197759136557579, -0.0020059109665453434, -0.011047212406992912, -0.023966461420059204, 0.043799445033073425, 0.049125880002975464, 0.034349918365478516, 0.007796815130859613, 0.041458290070295334, 0.012382008135318756, -0.02093670517206192, 0.015894733369350433, -0.007272286806255579, 0.022682616487145424, -0.0273780208081007, -0.016842812299728394, -0.008998386561870575, 0.018274853006005287, -0.0053251259960234165, 0.05223734304308891, -0.0263220202177763, -0.07772277295589447, -0.02684766799211502, 0.05679086968302727, 0.05625874176621437, -0.031955815851688385, 0.015926076099276543, -0.008631780743598938, 0.0002585471956990659, 0.012628186494112015, -0.042771730571985245, 0.03129573166370392, -0.013374625705182552, -0.020023351535201073, -0.01590433344244957, -0.01032071840018034, -0.01932344026863575, 0.011756404303014278, -0.01569347456097603, 0.026174262166023254, -0.0250967089086771, -0.015623793005943298, -0.008737101219594479, 0.013576795347034931, 0.005517952144145966, 0.06008458510041237, -0.05402369797229767, -0.0633065402507782, 0.017638806253671646, 0.00945156067609787, -0.029242858290672302, -0.05892908200621605, 0.04884503409266472, 0.0009866640903055668, 0.02372400276362896, 0.052195657044649124, -0.03494231402873993, -0.002841601148247719, 0.03775939345359802, 0.02736044116318226, -0.015196901746094227, -0.001520408084616065, -0.007869580760598183, 0.00851491093635559, 0.020879283547401428, 0.024657461792230606, 0.0839768499135971, 0.015017706900835037, 0.011356978677213192, 0.018132256343960762, -0.022799212485551834, 0.015966879203915596, -0.06100205332040787, -0.03057367540895939, -0.0390920490026474, -0.044818006455898285, -0.0030139342416077852, 0.022918397560715675, 0.02927241101861, 0.025257974863052368, 0.00020367195247672498, -0.013241580687463284, 0.03736967220902443, 0.00447593629360199, 0.01205537747591734, -0.03940998762845993, -0.023869207128882408, 0.03321782499551773, 0.021675094962120056, -0.009702462702989578, -0.008394495584070683, -0.021725619211792946, 0.028784509748220444, -0.024058494716882706, -0.062216322869062424, 0.014838451519608498, -0.04195176437497139, -0.033521853387355804, 0.026377515867352486, -0.010018296539783478, 0.05106540769338608, -0.017252521589398384, 0.03562013804912567, -0.01712595298886299, -0.09534331411123276, -0.011260489001870155, 0.03572133183479309, -0.020241985097527504, 0.026780657470226288, -0.06066811457276344, 0.04109703749418259, -0.03165314346551895, -0.00585360499098897, -0.05109107494354248, -0.012101172469556332, -0.010957813821732998, 0.002244365867227316, 0.01720273122191429, -0.005014767870306969, -0.026525277644395828, -0.011212962679564953, 0.0005850840825587511, -0.043133124709129333, 0.01700727827847004, -0.006049453280866146, -0.014882882125675678, 0.017909862101078033, 0.005432382691651583, 0.060353703796863556, -0.005683164577931166, 0.02336226962506771, -0.010323409922420979, -0.038431741297245026, -0.010277018882334232, -0.01112283393740654, -0.015910238027572632, -0.03866817429661751, -0.004432311747223139, -0.0027023539878427982, 0.01036987267434597, 0.022431785240769386, -0.030476832762360573, -0.0367300920188427, 0.031912822276353836, 0.0036288045812398195, 0.001160928513854742, -0.04027039185166359, 0.020501552149653435, -0.030286656692624092, -0.012577617540955544, -0.020422661677002907, 0.02546268329024315, -0.004020652733743191, -0.006914852652698755, 0.03245093300938606, -0.005248833913356066, -0.03402755782008171, 0.01450312975794077, 0.058479662984609604, 0.018158772960305214, -0.005736516322940588, 0.005204722285270691, -0.04350899159908295, 0.02368910238146782, -0.029801417142152786, 0.025764502584934235, -0.02128772810101509, 0.017597442492842674, -0.035760726779699326, -0.024310825392603874, -0.020671822130680084, 0.004266280215233564, 0.05173388868570328, 0.002022061962634325, 0.056839536875486374, 0.058167655020952225, 0.01990685425698757, -0.025303903967142105, -0.00965224951505661, -0.009867566637694836, -0.001994629856199026, 0.0462585873901844, 0.056666050106287, 0.0069263409823179245, -0.015321841463446617, 0.04156988486647606, 0.038142453879117966, 0.003358130343258381, 0.04272481054067612, 0.03705630451440811, 0.050171345472335815, 0.0552222803235054, -0.022149967029690742, -0.03848550468683243, 0.035077523440122604, -0.05563730746507645, 0.029941804707050323, -0.05101178213953972, -0.0005926465382799506, 0.03345382213592529, 0.03717565909028053, -0.010598087683320045, -0.05882340297102928, -0.018030157312750816, -0.06587975472211838, 0.046089064329862595, -0.008241953328251839, -0.015529224649071693, 0.06019072234630585, -0.01009674184024334, 0.0648617073893547, -0.014425198547542095, 0.020728185772895813, -0.07583378255367279, -0.06195412948727608, -0.015103231184184551, -0.0336356945335865, -0.01375962607562542, 0.04204479232430458, -0.011218300089240074, -0.03464286029338837, 0.00839914195239544, -0.027313219383358955, 0.03284057229757309, -0.017025094479322433, 0.04472970589995384, -0.021219760179519653, 0.05754474923014641, 0.013056456111371517, 0.011400338262319565, -0.014746518805623055, -0.00162755127530545, 0.09313557296991348, 0.046533986926078796, 0.012305768206715584, -0.06503020226955414, 0.030981170013546944, -0.03504834324121475, 0.014250345528125763, -0.01202146802097559, 0.025433151051402092, 0.023165803402662277, -0.0247810035943985, 0.01641976647078991, 0.05573522672057152, 0.004429571330547333, -0.004245043266564608, 0.04298775643110275, -0.02338792197406292, -0.03519178926944733, 0.05293433368206024, 0.005472694057971239, 0.03108804300427437, -0.05831558257341385, -0.014403910376131535, 0.020334990695118904, -0.0075759440660476685, 0.0009909188374876976, 0.024562126025557518, -0.02507772296667099, 0.021877629682421684, 0.02054729126393795, -0.021411757916212082, 0.01685146614909172, -0.02535824477672577, 0.004165836609899998, -0.06849835067987442, -0.0009470443474128842, 0.006975030060857534, -0.022288506850600243, -0.016530828550457954, 0.06452398002147675, 0.021748898550868034, -0.022643767297267914, 0.007092494051903486, 0.04558991640806198, -0.05323341116309166, -0.018821129575371742, -0.026571078225970268, 0.016556506976485252, -0.012402386404573917, -0.025399422273039818, -0.021482665091753006, 0.028051909059286118, 0.0009476427221670747, -0.04258580878376961, -0.025209810584783554, 0.029935002326965332, -0.012693320401012897, -0.02786308154463768, -0.013925253413617611, 0.002679957076907158, 0.02034945972263813, 0.005729495082050562, 0.023397639393806458, 0.025312406942248344, 0.0184377022087574, -0.024986224249005318, -0.023383110761642456, 0.04740346968173981, 0.026081768795847893, -0.012551638297736645, -0.03191316872835159, -0.022522512823343277, -0.028613414615392685, 0.022149862721562386, 0.005752447061240673, 0.03582444414496422, 0.01851470395922661, 0.002098460914567113, -0.005723442882299423, 0.011085368692874908, -0.06356791406869888, 0.03536025807261467, -0.03485920652747154, -0.020027387887239456, -0.011429699137806892, 0.00720339547842741, 0.054414600133895874, 0.05258926376700401, 0.004340791143476963, 0.011157800443470478, 0.01040203683078289, 0.05245555192232132, 0.021594887599349022, -0.07522519677877426, -0.009192532859742641, -0.02820902317762375, -0.021089131012558937, -0.06854237616062164, -0.03157373145222664, 0.020613601431250572, 0.032873086631298065, 0.030430445447564125, -0.009165464900434017, -0.006990802939981222, -0.008600130677223206, 0.0031417920254170895, 0.010022352449595928, -0.05759303644299507, -0.04500856250524521, -0.01040950883179903, 0.004721906501799822, -0.013331476598978043, -0.006202741526067257, -0.030384264886379242, -0.02506936341524124, 0.01921122521162033, -0.032327886670827866, -0.007419748697429895, -0.02392762340605259, 0.013614015653729439, 0.01237971056252718, -0.03786720335483551, -0.007770034950226545, -0.020731573924422264, 0.01634746603667736, -0.01661542057991028, 0.025268681347370148, -0.015431482344865799, 0.01989944465458393, -0.023563772439956665, -0.0177988912910223, 0.03947798162698746, 0.0008383759995922446, 0.03274990990757942, 0.012983910739421844, -0.006217784248292446, -0.00699970405548811, 0.04195168614387512, 0.0030398336239159107, -0.006837793625891209, 0.05138712748885155, -0.07237207889556885, -0.008690109476447105, 0.009065726771950722, -0.02013462968170643, 0.029668565839529037, 0.04545413702726364, -0.028200911357998848, -0.03953373804688454, 0.04830189421772957, 0.005973179824650288, -0.023832185193896294, 0.0021843593567609787, -0.0012219009222462773, 0.0007843257626518607, 0.01728055439889431, 0.014142153784632683, 0.02132388949394226, -0.0015827977331355214, 0.02841217629611492, 0.05666250362992287, -0.004811941646039486, -0.0017475227359682322, -0.02048003114759922, -0.0016357065178453922, 0.017339475452899933, -0.04322168231010437, -0.013330317102372646, 0.020596176385879517, 0.0854475274682045, -0.010466320440173149, 0.0018531399546191096, -0.04393802583217621, -0.0018975756829604506, -0.09817428141832352, -0.017520025372505188, -0.01748865284025669, 0.020265020430088043, 0.011812923476099968, -0.04324536770582199, 0.03294401988387108, 0.0482114776968956, -0.09340938180685043, -0.027444185689091682, -0.04123283177614212, -0.019987257197499275, -0.04904719442129135, 0.007456912659108639, -0.02258097380399704, -0.005268862936645746, -0.02341209352016449, 0.004352227784693241, 0.017455991357564926, 0.04290824756026268, -0.01440648827701807, 0.018526285886764526, 0.014859214425086975, 0.0375317744910717, 0.04648375138640404, -0.03467382490634918, 0.013867267407476902, -0.004939311183989048, -0.07219988852739334, 0.011522531509399414, -0.02459753304719925, 0.03646004572510719, -0.022739114239811897, 0.02728039026260376, 0.027021100744605064, 0.019518887624144554, 0.02394070290029049, 0.014440661296248436, 0.01613645628094673, -0.024054937064647675, 0.004887876566499472, 0.013286164030432701, -0.006721870508044958, 0.02316969260573387, 0.0615975484251976, 0.021299082785844803, 0.000050039154302794486, 0.0008364823879674077, -0.0005305910599417984, 0.005600438918918371, 0.012577008455991745, 0.012312466278672218, 0.022053338587284088, 0.02638270892202854, -0.026446985080838203, -0.06792739033699036, 0.014793743379414082, -0.0009668719139881432, 0.015569744631648064, -0.043475907295942307, 0.007515607867389917, -0.013956490904092789, -0.04401329904794693, 0.0025404691696166992, -0.03354468196630478, -0.0204588882625103, -0.04687557369470596, -0.007070555817335844, 0.006346698850393295, 0.021984903141856194, -0.03140776976943016, -0.05606035888195038, -0.03375834599137306, 0.03685445711016655, -0.03176073357462883, 0.011318258941173553, 0.004435198847204447, 0.002242753282189369, 0.006903822999447584, -0.06549272686243057, 0.04793811962008476, 0.02327832579612732, -0.01342353131622076, -0.05712759122252464, -0.023811690509319305, -0.022594397887587547, 0.050397247076034546, 0.021718129515647888, 0.013767065480351448, -0.0049603525549173355, 0.007032135967165232, 0.029324736446142197, -0.017393406480550766, -0.05255332216620445, 0.04391399770975113, -0.02443004958331585, 0.0062832580879330635, -0.014981826767325401, 0.03001539781689644, 0.00492426473647356, 0.019935298711061478, 0.04271076247096062, -0.03574920818209648, 0.02380097657442093, 0.00977677945047617, -0.018125910311937332, 0.028301484882831573, -0.03282763436436653, -0.02098475582897663, 0.03675789386034012, 0.008943427354097366, 0.0033887531608343124, -0.0035114155616611242, 0.000870349642354995, -0.04317564517259598, 0.027371371164917946, -0.046289294958114624, 0.01675027422606945, -0.020866738632321358, 0.004279616288840771, -0.012807848863303661, -0.027710089460015297, 0.001395161496475339, -0.007131126709282398, -0.03437964618206024, 0.00627492181956768, 0.04700898379087448, 0.06011096015572548, -0.0006579902837984264, 0.019676711410284042, 0.013569328002631664, -0.017221864312887192, 0.030646689236164093, -0.021203480660915375, 0.006132077891379595, 0.009155521169304848, 0.0452265590429306, 0.05085856840014458, 0.011959888972342014, -0.0424431674182415, 0.0276127178221941, -0.012402853928506374, 0.035987768322229385, -0.010513104498386383, -0.012867969460785389, 0.0141708729788661, -0.0063369967974722385, -0.013001751154661179, 0.00748069304972887, 0.002538028173148632, 0.0781349316239357, -0.052063848823308945, 0.01833975501358509, -0.019867965951561928, -0.028445623815059662, -0.026962213218212128, 0.007267390377819538, -0.015145068988204002, 0.0292617566883564, -0.020997684448957443, -0.0054059927351772785, -0.026591548696160316, 0.009311907924711704, 0.010760044679045677, -0.04368055984377861, 0.028236642479896545, -0.0372038260102272, -0.015420744195580482, -0.050164319574832916, 0.023282917216420174, -0.0432242713868618, -0.011265466921031475, -0.01472829282283783, 0.01445684488862753, 0.01104578748345375, -0.05943944305181503, -0.03265588358044624, 0.011964716017246246, 0.04196761175990105, -0.0488935224711895, -0.045220084488391876, -0.015622573904693127, 0.02163485437631607, -0.004571893252432346, -0.02430855669081211 ]
<p>Can you please tell me the formula (I am more interested in the approach than the answer) to answer the following question? Let’s say I drive an unreliable car that is not expected to start 1 out of every 5 mornings. When the car doesn't start, I miss work. I work 5 days a week.<br> What is the expected number of days of work that I will miss per week? Thanks. </p>
36,304
[ -0.021665697917342186, 0.014189034700393677, -0.0021874667145311832, 0.03431778773665428, 0.0642370879650116, -0.01615249179303646, -0.004962977487593889, -0.005159598775207996, 0.017310088500380516, 0.0229935459792614, 0.027279606088995934, 0.07326656579971313, 0.031166542321443558, 0.005664525553584099, 0.013284142129123211, -0.021713778376579285, -0.017251407727599144, -0.01684081181883812, -0.019398873671889305, -0.02630452625453472, 0.023282630369067192, -0.024621423333883286, 0.02844548039138317, -0.008068558759987354, -0.04464128240942955, 0.035755056887865067, 0.025106891989707947, 0.008748742751777172, -0.015276582911610603, 0.07273347675800323, -0.002619114937260747, -0.015519274398684502, -0.015103976242244244, 0.05778812617063522, 0.0009129432146437466, 0.033820249140262604, -0.03163433447480202, -0.013043316081166267, -0.02308012545108795, 0.02639731764793396, -0.009828301146626472, -0.01826809160411358, 0.004898805171251297, 0.03298944979906082, -0.0004472492728382349, 0.000766741402912885, 0.008222361095249653, -0.020250791683793068, 0.031318824738264084, -0.04099084064364433, 0.09336487948894501, -0.02410442940890789, 0.05456326901912689, -0.01329805701971054, -0.03722667321562767, -0.034609027206897736, 0.052583131939172745, 0.03723064437508583, -0.0011725296499207616, -0.05493545904755592, -0.03646502271294594, -0.02155175805091858, -0.034231048077344894, -0.00986209325492382, -0.03587714582681656, 0.04209981858730316, -0.03590058907866478, -0.022256379947066307, 0.052568111568689346, -0.006480338051915169, -0.0002499737893231213, -0.0016927795950323343, 0.04980442672967911, -0.02727784402668476, 0.02825654111802578, -0.03040372207760811, 0.021854739636182785, 0.012223925441503525, 0.02002773992717266, 0.01605672389268875, -0.024345122277736664, -0.0008451217436231673, 0.04544192552566528, 0.019856303930282593, -0.0014612997183576226, -0.023911191150546074, 0.08893509209156036, -0.01204095408320427, 0.060220494866371155, 0.01458023115992546, -0.003258591517806053, 0.019758574664592743, 0.06302065402269363, -0.01632586307823658, -0.01989199034869671, 0.05006709322333336, -0.0022461090702563524, 0.012591563165187836, -0.01603160984814167, -0.000716810580343008, 0.028084030374884605, -0.03931966423988342, 0.011332985013723373, 0.008893691934645176, 0.008238761685788631, -0.031099790707230568, -0.013565151020884514, 0.025965357199311256, 0.00232980796135962, -0.04335195943713188, 0.010929945856332779, 0.04429516941308975, 0.01497875340282917, -0.025917792692780495, 0.006040929351001978, 0.010636469349265099, -0.003107421100139618, -0.01507025957107544, 0.009677944704890251, 0.06942927092313766, 0.04996425285935402, -0.04642966762185097, 0.03678765520453453, -0.045401476323604584, -0.0339222215116024, -0.026653306558728218, 0.00643948232755065, -0.029203124344348907, 0.005445064511150122, 0.04346056655049324, 0.013189535588026047, -0.04552203044295311, 0.05943460017442703, 0.03141859546303749, 0.03392773121595383, -0.02271963097155094, -0.04252905026078224, -0.041914623230695724, 0.0008585082832723856, -0.00809137150645256, -0.0016349481884390116, -0.04033517464995384, 0.012749260291457176, 0.03843270614743233, 0.05281306430697441, 0.022856762632727623, 0.035823799669742584, 0.009159950539469719, 0.022644907236099243, -0.0026340957265347242, -0.03366346284747124, -0.03177029639482498, -0.02617967687547207, -0.03281084820628166, 0.048656169325113297, -0.0664929673075676, 0.022126730531454086, 0.037923697382211685, 0.0174550898373127, -0.035104844719171524, 0.02925451099872589, 0.00917130894958973, -0.05872523784637451, 0.0012549718376249075, 0.023620475083589554, -0.01903071068227291, 0.07658679038286209, 0.01446720864623785, 0.01891585811972618, 0.00840724352747202, 0.0290355421602726, 0.0008923271670937538, 0.0005775316385552287, 0.050700172781944275, 0.06508910655975342, -0.045740026980638504, -0.014911847189068794, -0.014445465058088303, 0.029410647228360176, 0.03294893354177475, -0.052560023963451385, -0.009460163302719593, 0.029338594526052475, -0.010900292545557022, -0.017687717452645302, 0.005721522029489279, 0.01448047161102295, 0.011684062890708447, 0.02253655530512333, 0.003949440084397793, -0.051039647310972214, -0.01200526300817728, 0.027333350852131844, -0.002131275599822402, -0.015454663895070553, 0.01226548757404089, -0.023256586864590645, 0.02539287507534027, -0.007333936169743538, 0.0032323715277016163, 0.015551958233118057, -0.021990032866597176, 0.0074515133164823055, -0.035981908440589905, -0.03852658346295357, 0.05675775185227394, 0.06963314116001129, 0.0013530341675505042, 0.04550231993198395, -0.04575594514608383, 0.0013035750016570091, -0.03110187128186226, -0.07027175277471542, 0.039517901837825775, -0.02256803959608078, -0.016221394762396812, 0.02986752986907959, 0.0048872013576328754, 0.005003227386623621, 0.04637626186013222, -0.045276444405317307, 0.00670764921233058, 0.06058872491121292, 0.022103236988186836, 0.02386302687227726, 0.002601674757897854, 0.02684573270380497, 0.007576059550046921, -0.03131356090307236, -0.03207680955529213, -0.00026290208916179836, 0.013014432974159718, 0.04691595584154129, -0.03947833925485611, 0.00721248472109437, 0.018410993739962578, 0.07756206393241882, 0.025440270081162453, 0.014021750539541245, 0.04330635443329811, -0.03986404463648796, 0.021130971610546112, 0.013541162945330143, -0.0021217281464487314, 0.034855108708143234, 0.018617717549204826, -0.01826401986181736, -0.0034900777973234653, -0.013688922859728336, 0.0007426940137520432, -0.0193911362439394, 0.05167881399393082, -0.016637196764349937, 0.016441797837615013, -0.009544518776237965, -0.035806987434625626, 0.06670688092708588, -0.005245988257229328, -0.04325079172849655, 0.036125537008047104, -0.00656311446800828, -0.005655079614371061, 0.018820973113179207, -0.005102800205349922, -0.0034287271555513144, -0.008666839450597763, -0.0696139931678772, -0.01253421138972044, 0.007309681735932827, 0.00924694910645485, 0.022482503205537796, -0.007119158282876015, -0.02769671566784382, -0.030589355155825615, -0.033908870071172714, 0.02696777507662773, 0.010670456103980541, 0.04523578658699989, 0.0024348909500986338, -0.008427280001342297, 0.0014578815316781402, -0.016287563368678093, 0.02143803797662258, -0.0021995564457029104, -0.025032801553606987, -0.0065760985016822815, -0.007555349729955196, -0.03166821226477623, 0.06690220534801483, -0.0013418563175946474, -0.029827436432242393, 0.03698645159602165, -0.0033871459309011698, -0.01583048887550831, -0.017004908993840218, -0.025532543659210205, 0.02084159478545189, -0.048378437757492065, -0.03657349571585655, 0.033480625599622726, 0.016981573775410652, -0.04835106432437897, -0.010500924661755562, -0.07003725320100784, -0.040422406047582626, -0.07642100751399994, -0.004997903481125832, -0.010525072924792767, -0.017487946897745132, 0.021287282928824425, 0.008886401541531086, -0.0213204063475132, 0.016360225155949593, -0.0713915228843689, -0.08307898044586182, -0.010318250395357609, -0.04681387543678284, 0.003975074738264084, -0.012859247624874115, -0.0050697289407253265, 0.05295366421341896, 0.05302199721336365, -0.04550081118941307, -0.013090686872601509, -0.023628517985343933, -0.00008807716221781448, -0.03155609592795372, -0.027710502967238426, 0.053117070347070694, 0.017516305670142174, 0.01879079081118107, 0.010612228885293007, 0.00572901451960206, 0.054677218198776245, 0.024116335436701775, -0.016872098669409752, 0.006908823736011982, -0.005303317680954933, 0.0211722943931818, 0.0024160961620509624, 0.020070308819413185, -0.017147019505500793, 0.01971489004790783, -0.018259231001138687, 0.04652896896004677, 0.018515607342123985, -0.0472022145986557, -0.002139878459274769, -0.041296735405921936, 0.011074262671172619, -0.04680803418159485, 0.0591818131506443, 0.016663461923599243, -0.010969282127916813, 0.00430501950904727, 0.03330427408218384, 0.030159465968608856, -0.03662485629320145, -0.023456186056137085, 0.052083857357501984, 0.01756032556295395, -0.004675597418099642, -0.06395402550697327, -0.055984560400247574, -0.004949844907969236, 0.009295808151364326, -0.04265931248664856, -0.05976394936442375, 0.007185113150626421, 0.014580884017050266, 0.0360197052359581, -0.0015780663816258311, -0.047704700380563736, 0.003197228768840432, -0.07784121483564377, -0.03529512137174606, 0.03861153498291969, 0.05153767764568329, 0.0114247752353549, 0.009526531212031841, -0.004686351399868727, -0.032364945858716965, 0.006998446770012379, -0.0017725203651934862, -0.08039848506450653, 0.05269467085599899, -0.00776720093563199, -0.01665627211332321, -0.0006134220748208463, -0.00027636592858470976, 0.04006609693169594, -0.03856947645545006, -0.015684066340327263, 0.017790663987398148, 0.028472900390625, -0.06231554597616196, 0.02727675251662731, -0.028854655101895332, 0.009127218276262283, -0.0016381889581680298, -0.01937766559422016, 0.04308787360787392, 0.020517978817224503, -0.000281956628896296, 0.010429237969219685, -0.028457580134272575, -0.02082166075706482, -0.0012097290018573403, -0.030813967809081078, -0.016916558146476746, 0.020637014880776405, 0.04708848521113396, 0.05217675119638443, -0.03678765892982483, 0.009449326433241367, -0.0290033221244812, 0.01387060061097145, 0.03882938623428345, 0.025966014713048935, -0.049089465290308, -0.051894038915634155, -0.0032611500937491655, 0.003925074357539415, -0.00528640765696764, -0.02548549696803093, 0.04122450202703476, 0.06887753307819366, -0.02665865048766136, -0.05757435783743858, 0.01087498664855957, 0.07556404173374176, 0.0386689268052578, -0.017987800762057304, -0.02520916424691677, -0.014825423248112202, -0.02568875066936016, -0.016066372394561768, 0.011384663172066212, 0.029207170009613037, -0.0036568567156791687, 0.008030056953430176, -0.005388755351305008, -0.022767886519432068, 0.03273298218846321, -0.03134522587060928, -0.013981673866510391, 0.029296714812517166, 0.018766645342111588, -0.031371794641017914, 0.034179721027612686, 0.015178924426436424, 0.0357801727950573, 0.01357285212725401, -0.01698829047381878, -0.08881599456071854, -0.00034666387364268303, 0.020299019291996956, -0.011567164212465286, -0.02875952422618866, 0.0000404660968342796, -0.012943262234330177, -0.0028877221047878265, 0.07274076342582703, -0.04805506393313408, 0.021097097545862198, 0.0005599409341812134, 0.009184170514345169, 0.004459662362933159, -0.015011983923614025, -0.0387812964618206, 0.033900026232004166, 0.015232114121317863, 0.07416245341300964, -0.00872660893946886, -0.031739186495542526, -0.04662299528717995, 0.008999801240861416, 0.03173516318202019, 0.0676489844918251, 0.0034231916069984436, -0.010880980640649796, -0.013146895915269852, 0.029816122725605965, -0.02032630331814289, -0.040766000747680664, -0.0025709988549351692, 0.002964611863717437, -0.006510911509394646, 0.0024611831177026033, -0.03260692209005356, -0.02346780151128769, 0.013241077773272991, 0.017359953373670578, -0.010104485787451267, -0.01618272438645363, -0.039061855524778366, 0.02351267822086811, -0.0013991531450301409, 0.014116216450929642, 0.04613647982478142, -0.01901892200112343, 0.021387498825788498, 0.017209341749548912, -0.001835403498262167, 0.01865038275718689, 0.00015847878239583224, -0.040953367948532104, -0.00934547744691372, -0.006312386132776737, -0.03446221724152565, 0.029862042516469955, -0.01667921245098114, -0.001941514085046947, -0.04471929743885994, -0.03213056921958923, -0.014068507589399815, 0.0010078453924506903, -0.002803446725010872, -0.007512670010328293, -0.017809461802244186, -0.007872114889323711, 0.027585381641983986, -0.01827215403318405, 0.0046060471795499325, -0.027262071147561073, 0.014236919581890106, 0.003417897503823042, -0.0191948339343071, 0.0021934739779680967, -0.043252937495708466, -0.027377383783459663, 0.028064345940947533, -0.00947316363453865, -0.008098767139017582, -0.022507039830088615, 0.06113717705011368, -0.01664634793996811, -0.04284445196390152, -0.014437099918723106, 0.015284741297364235, -0.01124988030642271, 0.04312553629279137, -0.01934138685464859, 0.04153665155172348, -0.0011207079514861107, -0.04007904976606369, -0.08237482607364655, -0.08097346872091293, 0.054404180496931076, 0.02853834256529808, -0.02155948244035244, -0.002446262165904045, 0.015210099518299103, -0.026407532393932343, -0.054501648992300034, -0.003519980236887932, 0.021910736337304115, -0.034651707857847214, -0.017164558172225952, -0.0018661809153854847, 0.01438578125089407, 0.06135331839323044, 0.011100785806775093, 0.010708807967603207, 0.033183347433805466, -0.03158068656921387, -0.008606930263340473, -0.01023022085428238, 0.01908770203590393, -0.0344887338578701, -0.016321050003170967, -0.026676194742321968, 0.009717389941215515, 0.034014929085969925, -0.01552877388894558, -0.022524716332554817, 0.027249908074736595, 0.006415703799575567, -0.009960360825061798, -0.032121628522872925, 0.03277347981929779, 0.017713068053126335, -0.0004537067434284836, 0.021554261445999146, -0.014892631210386753, -0.018828660249710083, -0.015199597924947739, 0.0013903375947847962, -0.005867244675755501, 0.027496404945850372, 0.019490228965878487, 0.06935761123895645, 0.015311806462705135, -0.0005604010657407343, 0.023036262020468712, -0.0015069288201630116, 0.0005140338325873017, 0.01999102346599102, -0.010368864983320236, 0.02362785115838051, -0.0054360684007406235, -0.038215555250644684, -0.048079509288072586, -0.03704346716403961, 0.008848831057548523, 0.029613658785820007, -0.05648031830787659, 0.006535369902849197, 0.021979814395308495, 0.02559654973447323, -0.024501105770468712, -0.006646622437983751, 0.008720831014215946, 0.008502701297402382, 0.02404000796377659, 0.034265048801898956, -0.013106901198625565, 0.0344146192073822, 0.03699328377842903, 0.050489455461502075, 0.020045621320605278, 0.036641817539930344, 0.011247480288147926, 0.023714249953627586, -0.011797836050391197, 0.00044315127888694406, -0.05492386221885681, 0.014410402625799179, 0.0054601323790848255, 0.02176791802048683, -0.02284400723874569, 0.00228960532695055, 0.07478116452693939, 0.03240274637937546, -0.008511743508279324, -0.014747275039553642, -0.007966935634613037, -0.027566809207201004, 0.007315874099731445, 0.024153174832463264, -0.03274505212903023, 0.057607244700193405, 0.03161323443055153, 0.015198403038084507, -0.021203691139817238, 0.016248038038611412, -0.013082529418170452, -0.03506776690483093, 0.0335066057741642, -0.01127547025680542, -0.0909046158194542, 0.05351397395133972, 0.009777150116860867, -0.012838292866945267, -0.007319987285882235, 0.008744521997869015, -0.011925646103918552, 0.026415711268782616, 0.07589957863092422, 0.03821980208158493, 0.12690164148807526, 0.02642311528325081, -0.021347234025597572, -0.01798930950462818, 0.02407948113977909, 0.0871901661157608, 0.08046329766511917, 0.05489610135555267, -0.039825037121772766, 0.021385198459029198, -0.031783577054739, 0.015331280417740345, -0.020216986536979675, 0.07614980638027191, -0.013540279120206833, -0.019351977854967117, 0.06832243502140045, 0.04296165332198143, -0.02027703821659088, -0.005110075697302818, 0.031219299882650375, -0.04171566665172577, -0.020820526406168938, -0.026379242539405823, 0.015415770001709461, 0.0361284501850605, -0.012845193035900593, -0.027808481827378273, 0.03875955939292908, -0.0028268336318433285, -0.017963584512472153, 0.0023415065370500088, -0.03057379089295864, 0.00460786372423172, 0.0029633059166371822, 0.0020496277138590813, 0.031499233096838, 0.04538944363594055, 0.01817430928349495, -0.008806401863694191, 0.013299561105668545, 0.03048640675842762, -0.00497815664857626, 0.014052133075892925, 0.04381502792239189, 0.01114526204764843, -0.0017604795284569263, 0.012877692468464375, 0.013767578639090061, -0.03763207048177719, -0.0021978116128593683, -0.04189576208591461, 0.037560559809207916, 0.005556359421461821, 0.03625408932566643, -0.007410592865198851, 0.006669171620160341, 0.01923648826777935, -0.060453616082668304, -0.0033115472178906202, 0.012338831089437008, 0.023040181025862694, -0.06249218061566353, -0.012722895480692387, -0.015129085630178452, 0.02754150703549385, 0.04031847044825554, 0.015093526802957058, 0.0859353318810463, -0.04281274601817131, -0.027551323175430298, -0.010208416730165482, 0.052494000643491745, -0.010242199525237083, 0.003727484028786421, -0.028184503316879272, -0.022460928186774254, -0.019388537853956223, -0.0040499428287148476, 0.032577574253082275, 0.025035589933395386, 0.008451279252767563, -0.043500762432813644, -0.014055655337870121, 0.009123392403125763, -0.05720840394496918, 0.006700854282826185, -0.012438789941370487, -0.011166916228830814, -0.04722587391734123, 0.016418857499957085, 0.014973812736570835, 0.011366637423634529, 0.014660181477665901, 0.02291092835366726, 0.008121359162032604, 0.06958426535129547, 0.0010223056888207793, -0.0364319272339344, 0.01786290481686592, -0.00017529455362819135, -0.03903018683195114, -0.0007160956156440079, -0.0041443477384746075, 0.03093859553337097, 0.013687673024833202, -0.009344710037112236, -0.004878634586930275, 0.05649908259510994, -0.012271525338292122, 0.013637962751090527, -0.03091561235487461, -0.07047732174396515, -0.020847897976636887, 0.01809028536081314, 0.023296117782592773, -0.028163932263851166, -0.021937239915132523, -0.0031523113138973713, -0.017907900735735893, 0.01645752228796482, -0.00541251664981246, -0.030408671125769615, 0.0020599598065018654, 0.02649853192269802, 0.03720908984541893, -0.041831716895103455, 0.015455258078873158, -0.008691775612533092, 0.0053675128147006035, -0.006177172996103764, -0.007670815568417311, -0.029634030535817146, 0.006909804418683052, 0.007363771554082632, 0.014929596334695816, 0.029931940138339996, -0.007991595193743706, 0.03352908790111542, -0.01565687358379364, -0.008646981790661812, -0.03995705768465996, 0.05145033448934555, -0.04532398283481598, -0.025604117661714554, 0.0346456877887249, -0.053131166845560074, -0.012921441346406937, 0.00549424160271883, -0.01829746551811695, 0.049878742545843124, 0.016807809472084045, -0.01589502952992916, -0.017407303676009178, 0.08226409554481506, -0.023541035130620003, -0.012177741155028343, -0.010607913136482239, 0.042916346341371536, -0.0044996473006904125, -0.01482794526964426, -0.03851618245244026, 0.01719934120774269, -0.009436712600290775, -0.018585482612252235, 0.09769868850708008, 0.0030643173959106207, 0.008989941328763962, 0.047584157437086105, 0.04515079781413078, -0.03638848662376404, 0.0036129290238022804, -0.00682221120223403, -0.0021324018016457558, 0.02410358190536499, -0.021818770095705986, 0.0229444932192564, -0.034680403769016266, 0.006675270851701498, -0.07860627770423889, -0.03708331659436226, 0.010749808512628078, 0.010641993023455143, 0.047365304082632065, -0.034144990146160126, -0.005592180881649256, 0.013837059959769249, -0.04260769858956337, 0.005123320501297712, 0.0037948291283100843, -0.010734698735177517, -0.034535329788923264, 0.0025269524194300175, -0.014879188500344753, -0.02422446943819523, 0.02149081602692604, 0.011125098913908005, 0.039451438933610916, 0.005540786776691675, -0.0342894122004509, -0.06271032243967056, 0.03213571012020111, 0.0441167876124382, 0.02850545197725296, -0.022012164816260338, 0.04366430267691612, -0.04501914232969284, -0.012931513600051403, 0.030681904405355453, -0.025393299758434296, 0.051764439791440964, -0.01093039009720087, -0.0009393618092872202, 0.002950418507680297, 0.04651205241680145, 0.019567808136343956, -0.01805746555328369, 0.014234502799808979, -0.017822500318288803, 0.015436461195349693, -0.000012657043043873273, -0.025200648233294487, 0.007478103507310152, 0.03826407715678215, -0.0012368358438834548, -0.07395222783088684, 0.021706324070692062, 0.03325140103697777, -0.002728428225964308, -0.03465833514928818, -0.009405428543686867, 0.00787106342613697, -0.02271992899477482, -0.0005905355210416019, -0.05645456910133362, 0.024354947730898857, 0.05033184960484505, -0.011335805058479309, -0.023013323545455933, 0.012521261349320412, -0.009665217250585556, -0.04376500844955444, 0.02375851385295391, -0.00430601229891181, -0.030763844028115273, -0.03870518505573273, -0.020358439534902573, 0.011964037083089352, 0.013524900190532207, 0.019264360889792442, -0.03787492215633392, -0.0013608274748548865, 0.02684001624584198, 0.012708139605820179, -0.03171943873167038, 0.0133083276450634, -0.04444011300802231, -0.0033297056797891855, -0.04847545921802521, 0.04757160693407059, 0.00798109918832779, -0.021758824586868286, -0.018078986555337906, -0.03697464242577553, -0.006484705489128828, 0.0035617141984403133, 0.0586148239672184, -0.01674846187233925, -0.07419522106647491, -0.016873160377144814, 0.007636805530637503, -0.005151054356247187, -0.02247689850628376, 0.028513627126812935, 0.006388555746525526, -0.038164783269166946, -0.028621451929211617, 0.010689424350857735, 0.03148451820015907, -0.020487433299422264, 0.008180356584489346, 0.015944954007864, 0.013166964054107666, 0.022488301619887352, -0.019206805154681206, -0.010700390674173832, 0.026132944971323013, -0.0009400255512446165, 0.047863543033599854, -0.0305203665047884, 0.01631961017847061, 0.04764385521411896, 0.0015124878846108913, -0.06829903274774551, 0.04654931649565697, -0.06703460961580276, 0.02551659569144249, 0.026519453153014183, 0.02396903559565544, 0.00511953653767705, -0.06300054490566254, -0.028771018609404564, 0.017366589978337288, 0.00389938335865736, -0.012881218455731869, 0.004615943878889084, 0.041035108268260956, 0.048793159425258636, -0.04107009992003441, -0.0006268259021453559, 0.022796595469117165, 0.018309522420167923, -0.013908633962273598, 0.020344026386737823, 0.002558894222602248, -0.02504679188132286, -0.006846756208688021, 0.03153334930539131, -0.017544398084282875, 0.04219461604952812, -0.011572440154850483, 0.011022109538316727, -0.025300154462456703, -0.01841711439192295, -0.001991046592593193, 0.0022828003857284784, -0.010697361081838608, 0.012934320606291294, -0.014204462990164757, 0.04969356209039688, -0.009132993407547474, 0.0062196385115385056, -0.051049765199422836, -0.002704016398638487, -0.04531460627913475, 0.01305369008332491, 0.010053755715489388, 0.024162521585822105, -0.0006921321037225425, 0.027463892474770546, 0.027185577899217606, 0.006946156267076731, 0.03769244998693466, -0.013832204043865204, 0.009712311439216137, -0.01227237842977047, 0.01475383061915636, -0.05559356510639191, -0.038285717368125916, -0.04762851074337959, -0.03055064007639885, 0.011887290515005589, 0.06137673556804657, -0.0021633757278323174, -0.02915678173303604, -0.029974831268191338, 0.0048658037558197975, 0.06571557372808456, -0.05083655193448067, -0.017002588137984276, -0.06260886043310165, 0.0062756589613854885, -0.026509150862693787, -0.01896163821220398 ]
<p>For fantasy basketball, I want to quantify a player's output based on his Points, Rebounds, Assists, Steals, 3s, and Blocks production.</p> <p>Let's pretend that over the course of an imaginary basketball season there are total of 245,000 Points, 100,000 Rebounds, 53,000 Assists, 18,000 steals, 12,000 blocks, and 16,000 3points ever recorded (these are totals by all players who played).</p> <p>How do I weight each stat category so that I know what 1 block might be worth in points, assists, or in any of the other categories?</p> <p>I do not have stat background but this sounds like a basic stat question that people here can help me understand.</p>
73,804
[ -0.031124254688620567, 0.0058036306872963905, -0.05334709584712982, -0.04881761968135834, 0.06759669631719589, 0.0014775666641071439, 0.009823986329138279, -0.015222463756799698, 0.000023342592612607405, 0.0003998678002972156, 0.025805355980992317, 0.027044963091611862, 0.04528065025806427, 0.03167891502380371, -0.009297186508774757, -0.0076063829474151134, 0.0046433196403086185, -0.01644313521683216, -0.0013062155339866877, -0.02334422990679741, -0.014094658195972443, 0.008948937989771366, -0.007712080143392086, 0.025435106828808784, -0.040205422788858414, 0.06253793090581894, 0.024850351735949516, -0.03870619088411331, 0.026544226333498955, 0.0288186427205801, -0.00901254266500473, 0.0070344009436666965, 0.03174478933215141, 0.024286897853016853, 0.009740099310874939, 0.00775359570980072, -0.0355851911008358, -0.039521895349025726, -0.022417141124606133, 0.014515334740281105, -0.053581248968839645, -0.01924302987754345, -0.014662574045360088, -0.0035706160124391317, -0.022854812443256378, 0.03337743133306503, -0.03539242967963219, 0.015350048430263996, 0.03560424968600273, -0.07254907488822937, 0.10784339904785156, 0.03662056848406792, 0.050937119871377945, 0.03100927174091339, -0.042861953377723694, 0.012498573400080204, 0.042750995606184006, 0.06467138975858688, 0.01862342096865177, -0.028651151806116104, -0.019169947132468224, 0.005235106684267521, -0.0011063669808208942, -0.07908239215612411, -0.009799362160265446, 0.02680528536438942, 0.012021542526781559, -0.021526990458369255, 0.07577095180749893, 0.0016782751772552729, 0.011666876263916492, 0.001557445153594017, 0.016653219237923622, -0.004354112781584263, 0.019110871478915215, -0.04158314689993858, 0.03551878407597542, 0.002506226534023881, 0.05373040586709976, 0.049745429307222366, 0.001469727256335318, 0.049190230667591095, 0.028306443244218826, 0.04018734395503998, 0.028264690190553665, -0.019208082929253578, 0.05350736901164055, -0.016352305188775063, 0.002093443414196372, 0.0064630089327692986, -0.005250441376119852, -0.04375743865966797, 0.041378453373909, -0.007708552293479443, -0.016788598150014877, 0.01058078370988369, -0.007912018336355686, 0.015190977603197098, 0.007490812800824642, -0.004166589118540287, 0.02452656999230385, -0.03426595777273178, 0.04741494357585907, 0.01901240460574627, -0.01887529343366623, 0.012116272002458572, -0.027008600533008575, -0.02361138164997101, 0.006035180762410164, -0.010254434309899807, 0.016049835830926895, 0.02429390884935856, 0.007072639185935259, -0.035619478672742844, 0.036191437393426895, -0.027180828154087067, -0.01715870201587677, -0.016740815714001656, 0.038520447909832, 0.013132283464074135, 0.04857425391674042, -0.029670778661966324, 0.06042982265353203, -0.04131307080388069, -0.0683899000287056, -0.011700453236699104, -0.0021348351147025824, -0.006006572861224413, -0.035760533064603806, 0.057263877242803574, -0.0017815985484048724, -0.0322352834045887, 0.04806572571396828, -0.012328259646892548, 0.024881478399038315, -0.03768342733383179, -0.07186681777238846, -0.04413343966007233, 0.0004120037774555385, -0.0009487455827184021, -0.035534244030714035, -0.04185578227043152, 0.007004487793892622, 0.008523245342075825, 0.01594829186797142, 0.014198441058397293, 0.03517644852399826, 0.03988456726074219, 0.02669188193976879, 0.04311669245362282, -0.02044503204524517, -0.04744027927517891, -0.050329964607954025, -0.03001238964498043, 0.042746447026729584, -0.04732397943735123, -0.006681632250547409, -0.0013025625376030803, -0.005425572395324707, -0.004175548907369375, 0.01988876610994339, 0.03731057047843933, -0.04998095706105232, 0.01001734659075737, -0.02443787083029747, 0.004746000282466412, 0.025333410128951073, -0.010287908837199211, 0.018859097734093666, 0.00232121953740716, 0.0291132815182209, 0.01884513907134533, 0.02237948216497898, 0.059057172387838364, 0.08661918342113495, -0.007518540136516094, -0.007027104496955872, -0.018390372395515442, 0.001039057387970388, -0.00916121806949377, -0.0426936149597168, -0.048702821135520935, 0.022896908223628998, -0.008363291621208191, 0.03929935768246651, 0.051586151123046875, 0.006589416414499283, 0.011027895845472813, -0.001848764717578888, -0.017436711117625237, -0.03632635623216629, -0.08272754400968552, 0.010339026339352131, -0.01018407940864563, -0.011927939020097256, 0.00892974529415369, 0.03480404242873192, 0.02005799487233162, -0.017937306314706802, -0.02022203989326954, -0.015291199088096619, 0.011151519604027271, 0.04359645023941994, -0.022167691960930824, -0.01432129181921482, 0.024719856679439545, 0.05934455990791321, -0.015259761363267899, 0.004734830465167761, -0.0535401776432991, -0.0269473884254694, 0.023648705333471298, -0.029570123180747032, 0.017083771526813507, 0.025427235290408134, -0.012090325355529785, 0.018741050735116005, -0.02084614709019661, -0.0035978464875370264, 0.014084944501519203, -0.015509437769651413, 0.04004629701375961, 0.04877614602446556, -0.0012842131545767188, -0.01010843738913536, 0.012623916380107403, -0.020489776507019997, 0.029637373983860016, 0.0007876022136770189, -0.0058679948560893536, -0.019392039626836777, 0.01739136129617691, 0.00838236790150404, 0.030095325782895088, -0.04610028490424156, 0.0035540445242077112, 0.054817792028188705, 0.002832078840583563, 0.011170445941388607, 0.02791871502995491, -0.039521828293800354, 0.011505846865475178, 0.004062480293214321, 0.01819918118417263, -0.001925289398059249, -0.0064678676426410675, 0.03644708916544914, 0.04542018100619316, -0.010151829570531845, 0.009304002858698368, -0.005643902812153101, 0.04145967215299606, 0.008771290071308613, 0.03851117566227913, -0.008682259358465672, -0.0717456117272377, 0.02252071350812912, -0.02355288155376911, 0.02596074528992176, 0.06062505766749382, -0.0062697832472622395, -0.0211022961884737, 0.031286682933568954, -0.010374941863119602, -0.0002704751677811146, 0.035274688154459, -0.0027535229455679655, -0.002899762475863099, 0.01656024344265461, -0.029371211305260658, 0.04089672118425369, 0.039880964905023575, -0.013221877627074718, -0.038893092423677444, 0.006841672584414482, 0.011742140166461468, -0.006285045295953751, 0.010846463963389397, -0.01474331971257925, -0.03618297725915909, -0.008230521343648434, -0.029859375208616257, -0.0028023449704051018, 0.003934825304895639, -0.08485164493322372, -0.02641337364912033, -0.026400893926620483, -0.022980766370892525, 0.04155667498707771, -0.028532957658171654, -0.05172450467944145, 0.04711102321743965, 0.01039889082312584, -0.01097404956817627, 0.0032400016207247972, -0.02302432432770729, 0.024975627660751343, -0.0399848073720932, -0.00007615533104399219, 0.02316775545477867, -0.01242973655462265, -0.061870407313108444, -0.01675485074520111, -0.07658647000789642, 0.0016601358074694872, -0.028437107801437378, -0.015717895701527596, 0.00046864975593052804, -0.015028134919703007, 0.025783710181713104, 0.024602288380265236, -0.015633178874850273, -0.0037039583548903465, -0.06183891370892525, -0.05653270706534386, 0.00142098858486861, 0.0007750820368528366, 0.009647275321185589, 0.03529231250286102, -0.05433801934123039, 0.09302519261837006, -0.005406789481639862, -0.05746462568640709, -0.03475732356309891, -0.03483514487743378, -0.0219294261187315, -0.019552836194634438, 0.002861857181414962, 0.014168809168040752, -0.018735792487859726, 0.028014544397592545, 0.007293154019862413, 0.007436720188707113, 0.04921191185712814, 0.038287509232759476, -0.02529148943722248, -0.017059773206710815, -0.029306741431355476, -0.0008905045106075704, 0.054769545793533325, -0.024154696613550186, -0.02820545621216297, -0.0016977769555523992, -0.017075469717383385, 0.038740333169698715, 0.0041470713913440704, -0.02908497489988804, 0.00027945308829657733, -0.01950984075665474, -0.00807911902666092, -0.04463305324316025, 0.024247007444500923, 0.0012525726342573762, 0.000365271553164348, -0.0032060013618320227, 0.039189521223306656, 0.0026619264390319586, -0.0031316978856921196, -0.021723676472902298, 0.07237359136343002, 0.05077927187085152, -0.014412958174943924, -0.024200424551963806, -0.02116175927221775, 0.005582816433161497, 0.02703806944191456, -0.010696937330067158, -0.00792674534022808, 0.022410253062844276, -0.015201551839709282, 0.015343012288212776, 0.03228047862648964, -0.03502596542239189, -0.001043348922394216, -0.04044785723090172, 0.006693495903164148, -0.00408736290410161, 0.0583069808781147, -0.015259373933076859, 0.0789007693529129, 0.015437634661793709, -0.010813548229634762, -0.013827105984091759, -0.005499145016074181, -0.01116680447012186, 0.03824674338102341, 0.011802494525909424, 0.015463966876268387, 0.0063451556488871574, 0.010045877657830715, 0.008122516795992851, -0.05830441415309906, 0.00031139375641942024, -0.01527141872793436, 0.022986728698015213, -0.035328153520822525, -0.017567448318004608, 0.01457600761204958, -0.0020147175528109074, -0.0018724846886470914, 0.013744689524173737, 0.029987983405590057, -0.007439661771059036, 0.052169229835271835, 0.03669389709830284, -0.0173468217253685, -0.024472273886203766, -0.026689864695072174, 0.04040316864848137, 0.009514854289591312, 0.014084561727941036, 0.000616649747826159, 0.049525581300258636, 0.014752460643649101, 0.04529765993356705, -0.03434015437960625, 0.03343847766518593, 0.02728734351694584, -0.017634058371186256, -0.00630441727116704, -0.08584978431463242, -0.0006522875046357512, -0.005672720726579428, -0.002195607637986541, 0.016602056100964546, 0.0009919964941218495, 0.037125833332538605, 0.02407841570675373, -0.03706756979227066, 0.03595057129859924, 0.08352208137512207, 0.024731338024139404, -0.043279629200696945, -0.07841943949460983, 0.016390463337302208, -0.015622744336724281, -0.0031842223834246397, 0.03348197788000107, 0.020128989592194557, 0.03640281781554222, 0.005399439483880997, 0.011807527393102646, -0.05364817753434181, -0.0054888599552214146, 0.018970560282468796, 0.009128651581704617, 0.04913149029016495, -0.04057454317808151, -0.023558152839541435, 0.04426294565200806, 0.05008060485124588, 0.021261198446154594, 0.006326467730104923, 0.03473777323961258, -0.10737813264131546, -0.012961417436599731, 0.011871999129652977, 0.06039554625749588, -0.018763436004519463, -0.011429993435740471, -0.0024595134891569614, 0.0078030601143836975, 0.044757504016160965, -0.039057619869709015, 0.05820260941982269, 0.005588540341705084, 0.03348282724618912, 0.02234250120818615, 0.006816364824771881, -0.013408883474767208, 0.015351356938481331, -0.03949236497282982, 0.03669779375195503, 0.01886855810880661, -0.0013036411255598068, -0.027966709807515144, 0.03522913530468941, 0.028180407360196114, 0.040389444679021835, -0.016149988397955894, 0.037026546895504, 0.0021509635262191296, 0.04220262169837952, -0.025977924466133118, -0.05499039590358734, -0.01940062642097473, 0.010633822530508041, -0.0047781202010810375, 0.02543429471552372, -0.0076068383641541, -0.034971244633197784, -0.009967033751308918, -0.025228947401046753, -0.016848471015691757, 0.03806684538722038, 0.0030076121911406517, 0.041624996811151505, 0.02482650615274906, 0.01376615185290575, 0.05434989184141159, 0.03048602119088173, -0.01814747415482998, 0.0069329687394201756, -0.04062054306268692, 0.026435600593686104, 0.01093935314565897, -0.017969470471143723, -0.050349898636341095, 0.019761621952056885, -0.03009440004825592, -0.0009779089596122503, -0.017696430906653404, 0.0699683204293251, 0.0020841918885707855, -0.02041291631758213, 0.00009338594099972397, -0.0177802424877882, 0.003272343659773469, -0.010724443010985851, 0.027017638087272644, 0.009816220961511135, 0.00896034762263298, -0.031592220067977905, -0.005490013398230076, 0.014123771339654922, 0.014459879137575626, -0.029924411326646805, -0.010936271399259567, 0.04965783283114433, -0.029828235507011414, 0.0001985474955290556, -0.006999311037361622, -0.06780136376619339, 0.055135518312454224, -0.003771362593397498, 0.03436394780874252, 0.016405543312430382, -0.048973165452480316, -0.023699456825852394, -0.004465890116989613, 0.019866595044732094, 0.03502925485372543, -0.04395526647567749, 0.02783719077706337, -0.02906939759850502, -0.020480383187532425, -0.0422537662088871, -0.034840427339076996, 0.04350242391228676, 0.045976489782333374, -0.014490796253085136, -0.03582843393087387, 0.052687354385852814, 0.0007981684757396579, -0.0007854623254388571, -0.020946552976965904, 0.020884692668914795, -0.012951819226145744, -0.03256189823150635, 0.03545529395341873, 0.01138352882117033, 0.0663091242313385, 0.021803133189678192, -0.008587160147726536, 0.02018131874501705, 0.018559878692030907, -0.03877873718738556, 0.0045322938822209835, -0.005611644126474857, -0.02891160361468792, -0.005684820469468832, 0.002036794787272811, -0.013503307476639748, 0.05437174439430237, -0.017669152468442917, 0.024203231558203697, -0.0036445043515414, 0.01845129393041134, 0.000880558043718338, -0.016958236694335938, 0.017070159316062927, 0.026980118826031685, 0.015371361747384071, -0.02880706638097763, -0.005000600125640631, -0.0779973715543747, 0.04058077931404114, -0.011288096196949482, -0.000611891271546483, 0.034154776483774185, -0.014522762037813663, 0.01565416157245636, 0.011772573925554752, -0.0024789420422166586, 0.021985534578561783, 0.015250165946781635, 0.040171727538108826, 0.010241411626338959, -0.011401756666600704, 0.01935674250125885, 0.03446199744939804, -0.014242181554436684, -0.013870014809072018, -0.019050128757953644, 0.022757377475500107, 0.07150915265083313, -0.024973202496767044, 0.05937695503234863, 0.04927291348576546, 0.004053359851241112, 0.022847719490528107, -0.021230636164546013, 0.009024403989315033, -0.0008039139793254435, -0.01047931145876646, 0.02804248407483101, 0.0037725097499787807, 0.009194517508149147, 0.04161867871880531, -0.014445748180150986, -0.008428056724369526, 0.022187236696481705, 0.018460307270288467, -0.01458057202398777, 0.020114324986934662, -0.021365467458963394, -0.00986249465495348, 0.034767355769872665, -0.05234520137310028, 0.0068142954260110855, -0.009428285993635654, -0.007905557751655579, 0.07647940516471863, 0.010583555325865746, -0.010655936785042286, -0.03611352667212486, -0.04404003918170929, -0.04280721768736839, 0.0036499781999737024, 0.03469604253768921, -0.016231510788202286, 0.0061965035274624825, 0.025556717067956924, 0.061987027525901794, -0.03905966132879257, 0.04828822240233421, -0.014735025353729725, -0.0563424788415432, -0.020261501893401146, -0.014776946976780891, -0.0411684513092041, -0.028850208967924118, 0.005268680397421122, 0.013738934881985188, 0.012791173532605171, -0.015557981096208096, 0.012374010868370533, -0.03053324483335018, 0.013082736171782017, -0.04113151133060455, 0.06474176794290543, 0.011646331287920475, -0.005405587609857321, 0.0032068488653749228, -0.01608342118561268, 0.10021080076694489, 0.08768633008003235, 0.053823746740818024, -0.06408002227544785, -0.012806731276214123, -0.016382340341806412, -0.008672651834785938, -0.025497624650597572, 0.03635312244296074, -0.017832299694418907, 0.0034380394499748945, 0.01820058375597, 0.04957209527492523, 0.012979351915419102, 0.00874844379723072, 0.07297199219465256, -0.017979642376303673, -0.02976701408624649, 0.006483152043074369, 0.03256935626268387, 0.012284227646887302, 0.0036804690025746822, -0.03664185106754303, 0.051347196102142334, 0.017380738630890846, -0.028315823525190353, -0.045598842203617096, -0.025794416666030884, -0.006515916902571917, -0.006050892174243927, -0.0014085094444453716, 0.02374931424856186, 0.013709405437111855, -0.001150669064372778, -0.019690783694386482, -0.019631750881671906, 0.029401205480098724, -0.02515103854238987, -0.007316264323890209, 0.01304696686565876, 0.01631299965083599, 0.009021803736686707, -0.03122759610414505, 0.008797739632427692, -0.058199442923069, -0.045889269560575485, -0.04199310019612312, 0.018424298614263535, 0.011670966632664204, 0.00009317003423348069, -0.027164658531546593, 0.021887261420488358, -0.0257884431630373, -0.06947801262140274, -0.019605299457907677, 0.04568006470799446, 0.04705009236931801, -0.00755913695320487, -0.04969439283013344, -0.022682683542370796, 0.02202421799302101, -0.025674743577837944, 0.015552472323179245, 0.0027881544083356857, -0.027637073770165443, -0.034494124352931976, -0.07214359939098358, 0.03219408914446831, -0.003472687443718314, 0.0019157874630764127, -0.018225928768515587, -0.03555801510810852, -0.037447139620780945, -0.025117510929703712, -0.018153397366404533, 0.004839343950152397, 0.005007506813853979, -0.002720640739426017, 0.0080318758264184, -0.0019145490368828177, -0.041492704302072525, -0.02931135520339012, -0.044498737901449203, -0.006253665313124657, -0.05743872746825218, 0.032474227249622345, 0.024769680574536324, 0.03627817705273628, 0.019546231254935265, -0.010114801116287708, -0.012055064551532269, 0.04556729272007942, 0.012032190337777138, -0.07370483875274658, -0.005686698481440544, 0.016028450801968575, -0.040537185966968536, 0.036518506705760956, -0.016197843477129936, 0.07515767961740494, 0.04576858505606651, 0.022300073876976967, -0.015986859798431396, 0.049378592520952225, -0.000050246406317455694, -0.0026012067683041096, -0.017317617312073708, -0.07314375042915344, 0.01186339184641838, 0.012545352801680565, -0.012358594685792923, -0.03338984400033951, 0.004776213318109512, -0.045664723962545395, -0.01985877938568592, -0.007396220695227385, -0.002562375506386161, -0.024974409490823746, 0.013842069543898106, -0.005587463732808828, -0.0012526661157608032, 0.0038209552876651287, -0.0053284186869859695, -0.028213171288371086, -0.007219393737614155, 0.028597470372915268, 0.001436946215108037, -0.003646288998425007, 0.0009172156569547951, -0.05020642280578613, -0.02796012908220291, 0.04028809070587158, -0.047334935516119, 0.008059305138885975, -0.060715701431035995, -0.011753824539482594, -0.041068632155656815, 0.06819287687540054, 0.0072875432670116425, 0.0003521735197864473, 0.03340655192732811, -0.028660127893090248, 0.011950810439884663, 0.02662784792482853, 0.0017430450534448028, 0.037070732563734055, 0.026946159079670906, -0.023560738191008568, -0.032144129276275635, 0.03603577986359596, -0.01443749200552702, 0.00029437278863042593, -0.027568941935896873, -0.002390344860032201, 0.015572580508887768, 0.0034052643459290266, 0.007104439195245504, 0.010601605288684368, -0.0043940008617937565, 0.0017231713281944394, -0.0007742809830233455, 0.005572723690420389, -0.007667900528758764, -0.017322050407528877, 0.03941308334469795, -0.0015456343535333872, 0.029245790094137192, -0.008410505950450897, 0.0353238619863987, 0.033995918929576874, -0.034187667071819305, 0.02537660300731659, -0.003254782874137163, -0.014829713851213455, -0.08405528217554092, -0.019945679232478142, -0.0015286157140508294, -0.042867809534072876, 0.03847000375390053, -0.038916561752557755, 0.04001694545149803, 0.0008245165226981044, -0.058109600096940994, 0.003719256492331624, -0.016739431768655777, -0.008610126562416553, -0.007712135091423988, 0.01414648536592722, -0.005804568529129028, -0.006067925598472357, 0.004939012695103884, 0.017944682389497757, 0.010903730057179928, 0.005311539862304926, -0.0015996736474335194, -0.04602186381816864, -0.0018319407245144248, 0.030194023624062538, 0.014936824329197407, -0.050092559307813644, 0.019572054967284203, -0.06626368314027786, -0.02984589897096157, 0.04239649698138237, -0.022680073976516724, 0.01917281188070774, 0.034544140100479126, 0.038429226726293564, -0.01916581206023693, 0.06626821309328079, 0.03768492117524147, 0.005063466727733612, -0.013236897066235542, -0.029206711798906326, -0.02601340226829052, 0.022634413093328476, -0.014045254327356815, 0.011547673493623734, 0.05008089542388916, -0.029440773651003838, -0.010412403382360935, -0.0030832744669169188, -0.022597305476665497, 0.00027180075994692743, -0.007395788095891476, -0.0036801183596253395, 0.002774910070002079, -0.02486560121178627, 0.010079128667712212, -0.011954471468925476, 0.01487288624048233, 0.04515056312084198, -0.02563246712088585, 0.0019007748924195766, 0.00344667537137866, 0.006646177265793085, -0.02504998818039894, 0.028642687946558, 0.026173248887062073, -0.06488901376724243, -0.04349599406123161, -0.03527837619185448, 0.04609131067991257, -0.01673818938434124, -0.05465206131339073, -0.022399256005883217, -0.0641476958990097, 0.045455656945705414, -0.0022523077204823494, 0.019420184195041656, 0.019542274996638298, -0.026345402002334595, 0.016807643696665764, -0.10688745230436325, 0.040134020149707794, 0.04431596025824547, -0.03313728794455528, -0.05279533192515373, -0.015213178470730782, 0.009034067392349243, -0.0035708555951714516, 0.040483128279447556, -0.03428567945957184, -0.019118657335639, -0.06270596385002136, 0.008681898936629295, -0.010260752402245998, -0.03954697400331497, 0.008893543854355812, 0.03246353566646576, -0.034400466829538345, -0.02238018624484539, -0.014996291138231754, 0.02229788899421692, -0.011087107472121716, 0.01828436739742756, -0.03874226287007332, -0.025558916851878166, -0.03840062767267227, 0.009045061655342579, 0.04105602577328682, 0.031390998512506485, -0.020129065960645676, 0.03285476937890053, 0.02500355802476406, 0.009447932243347168, 0.04118935763835907, -0.03332971781492233, -0.03955445438623428, 0.04334166273474693, -0.02879154682159424, 0.0012225786922499537, -0.020852869376540184, 0.018268462270498276, 0.02808108925819397, -0.07518283277750015, 0.011050588451325893, 0.05716632679104805, 0.030283765867352486, 0.03767520189285278, 0.06275615096092224, 0.05521206930279732, 0.03606470674276352, 0.006303318310528994, 0.006070242263376713, 0.008915822021663189, -0.07018033415079117, 0.006803468801081181, 0.03923608362674713, 0.0626857802271843, 0.02417527325451374, 0.0030179452151060104, 0.023318829014897346, 0.01691758818924427, 0.04549802094697952, 0.04314040392637253, 0.03516225889325142, -0.011335082352161407, -0.00039535434916615486, -0.03960748761892319, -0.0019537764601409435, 0.038723766803741455, 0.0062588537111878395, -0.04289301484823227, 0.04447596147656441, -0.04783511906862259, -0.01900777965784073, -0.04592909663915634, 0.01901945471763611, -0.002630863105878234, -0.045980531722307205, 0.009484902955591679, 0.03475946933031082, -0.028172044083476067, -0.01915719360113144, 0.009488487616181374, 0.02541646547615528, -0.010241598822176456, 0.007881985045969486, 0.04290924221277237, -0.00862131267786026, 0.011986026540398598, -0.015592193230986595, 0.006955746095627546, -0.04817093163728714, 0.00797833688557148, 0.022749699652194977, 0.016694558784365654, 0.02403826080262661, 0.006159971468150616, -0.019770821556448936, -0.027406739071011543, -0.0058998530730605125, -0.036668408662080765, -0.018880218267440796, -0.08870603889226913, 0.04405830800533295, 0.009155439212918282, 0.0027960902079939842 ]
<p>I am trying to manually calculate P-Value (right tailed) from F-Test to understand it better. Would like to learn how the value obtained from the F-Test.</p> <p>Have obtained the below parameters,</p> <pre><code>ndf = 1 ddf = 238 Β(ndf/2,ddf/2) = 0.162651 critical value, x (α=0.005) = 8.028403472 F_stat = 8983.6418 </code></pre> <p>Using equation below, referred from [1]</p> <blockquote> <p>P value = [1/Β(ndf/2,ddf/2)] * [(ndf*x)/(ndf*x + ddf)]^(ndf/2) * [1-(ndf*x)/(ndf*x + ddf) ]^(ddf/2) * 1/x</p> </blockquote> <p>I got, <strong>P_value = 7.06096E-05</strong></p> <p>When comparing this with automatic calculation by Excel using F.DIST.RT,</p> <blockquote> <p>P_value=F.DIST.RT(8983.6418,1,238)</p> </blockquote> <p>I got, <strong>P_value=5.2396E-191</strong></p> <p>Some how the P_value obtained via manual calculation and automatically by Excel is not the same. I have verified F_stat calculated by Excel and manually calculated by me from the formula in [2] is accurate. Hence the F.DIST.RT result should not be wrong, the help page also mentioned it is a right tailed test too.</p> <p>Questions:</p> <ol> <li><p>Have I got the wrong formula for P_value calculation using F-Test.</p></li> <li><p>Could you advice me, where I can learn more on the right formula. Many write up in the internet often using software/tools to calculate this. I like to learn the fundamental mathematics behind it. I will learn it no matter how hard is its mathematical complexity. Just need some guidance.</p></li> <li><p>What is the formula used by Excel when F.DIST.RT is invoked. Excel's help page only shows how to use the command without elaborating the fundamentals. My search on internet to find this was not successful.</p></li> </ol> <p>Thank you very much.</p> <pre><code>Reference: [1] http://easycalculation.com/statistics/f-test-p-value.php [2] http://www.originlab.com/forum/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=4823 </code></pre>
73,805
[ -0.0023345130030065775, -0.009098684415221214, 0.0010031182318925858, -0.007628964260220528, 0.04522492364048958, 0.01385543029755354, 0.008790556341409683, -0.03382673114538193, 0.03601787984371185, -0.043515704572200775, 0.047983359545469284, 0.030893199145793915, 0.004910954739898443, 0.010365116409957409, 0.0006749420426785946, 0.0009238753700628877, 0.02598884329199791, 0.02957962453365326, -0.012252680025994778, -0.006863367278128862, 0.01324464287608862, 0.05336518958210945, -0.011394123546779156, -0.007843631319701672, -0.00023991442867554724, 0.06610913574695587, 0.033726077526807785, -0.024797014892101288, 0.002377729397267103, 0.08346009254455566, -0.02986769564449787, -0.01911994256079197, 0.02559201419353485, 0.016176510602235794, 0.01386649813503027, 0.044725652784109116, 0.001315553323365748, 0.013849093578755856, -0.030305733904242516, 0.03345940262079239, 0.002603984670713544, -0.032259050756692886, 0.02338460087776184, 0.026718052104115486, 0.010456684045493603, 0.021491263061761856, 0.007402333896607161, -0.025602592155337334, 0.05999353900551796, -0.05745229125022888, 0.0465993732213974, -0.03705120459198952, 0.07710286229848862, -0.005762823391705751, -0.008732220157980919, -0.041698139160871506, 0.02411779761314392, 0.05281175300478935, 0.01285670604556799, -0.04964831843972206, 0.012267333455383778, -0.021962272003293037, 0.01661515049636364, -0.03082641027867794, -0.03123459592461586, 0.019556820392608643, 0.013024158775806427, -0.014387100003659725, 0.04056137800216675, 0.010397437959909439, 0.03425240144133568, 0.030574996024370193, 0.034500688314437866, -0.028559193015098572, 0.06085972487926483, -0.02432820573449135, 0.007190832402557135, -0.013886543922126293, 0.02205740474164486, 0.0481446348130703, -0.009040233679115772, 0.02762075513601303, 0.04786316305398941, 0.015823014080524445, 0.03785722330212593, -0.015260052867233753, 0.03979842737317085, -0.012948144227266312, 0.029274865984916687, 0.03243890032172203, -0.0006020095897838473, -0.009464343078434467, 0.06195135414600372, -0.031809378415346146, -0.01189910713583231, 0.030808936804533005, -0.02726031094789505, -0.005618262570351362, -0.019175542518496513, -0.004455300513654947, -0.016919324174523354, -0.05806239694356918, 0.032430991530418396, 0.05229475721716881, -0.03761206567287445, -0.011097300797700882, -0.031045494601130486, -0.02949645183980465, 0.019693464040756226, -0.03202015161514282, -0.012740669772028923, 0.044569481164216995, -0.027064558118581772, -0.020016109570860863, 0.02703067474067211, -0.018386388197541237, -0.03444279730319977, -0.0008857437642291188, 0.05861559882760048, 0.029317820444703102, 0.01904252916574478, 0.016287047415971756, -0.0066824667155742645, -0.013979875482618809, -0.026023732498288155, -0.016773123294115067, 0.052723478525877, -0.00456913560628891, -0.04758595675230026, 0.03022569790482521, 0.018619375303387642, -0.027627332136034966, 0.05066593736410141, 0.03144470602273941, 0.01949755847454071, 0.008698757737874985, -0.07198858261108398, -0.050979357212781906, 0.05374153330922127, -0.028567645698785782, -0.018390363082289696, -0.06207473203539848, -0.01484820619225502, 0.03985872119665146, 0.015860872343182564, 0.010462392121553421, 0.026919836178421974, -0.008405671454966068, 0.00502783665433526, -0.017088931053876877, -0.0634428933262825, -0.01321087870746851, -0.003786587854847312, -0.010115188546478748, -0.034956950694322586, -0.07636788487434387, 0.018948707729578018, -0.0099958386272192, 0.003812239971011877, -0.0017696578288450837, 0.004494577180594206, -0.004876736085861921, -0.009952481836080551, -0.02910694293677807, -0.01520965714007616, -0.04149121418595314, 0.07895021885633469, 0.0024661030620336533, 0.022975090891122818, -0.003422508714720607, -0.02921385131776333, 0.02435353957116604, -0.016276054084300995, -0.0035171383060514927, 0.01615186780691147, -0.0183928981423378, -0.014629780314862728, -0.02557186409831047, 0.027722366154193878, -0.020536262542009354, -0.07284951210021973, -0.002141694538295269, -0.025707414373755455, -0.007318516261875629, -0.0027276251930743456, 0.057422954589128494, 0.02449321746826172, -0.0016375096747651696, 0.07588208466768265, -0.08442719280719757, -0.032289888709783554, -0.04325404763221741, -0.009368550963699818, 0.011386686936020851, -0.038288477808237076, -0.03107256442308426, -0.016386251896619797, 0.020977720618247986, 0.02278093248605728, 0.025793947279453278, -0.0166489165276289, 0.010004261508584023, 0.06031685322523117, -0.03843523934483528, 0.030537830665707588, 0.09091875702142715, 0.025285251438617706, -0.024869807064533234, 0.020242944359779358, -0.03776731342077255, -0.0045707933604717255, 0.025553466752171516, -0.07232793420553207, 0.01384386420249939, 0.018602635711431503, -0.05466551333665848, 0.0557594895362854, 0.020785802975296974, 0.0007347537903115153, 0.006942722946405411, -0.03374595567584038, 0.03596421703696251, 0.05603082478046417, 0.040086179971694946, 0.030083809047937393, -0.014593188650906086, 0.004472704138606787, -0.012796993367373943, -0.05449758470058441, 0.0076453848741948605, -0.04548830911517143, -0.03972651809453964, 0.0478547066450119, 0.00228203390724957, -0.013607687316834927, -0.012887741439044476, 0.05940157547593117, -0.040686048567295074, 0.01773759350180626, 0.05196287855505943, 0.009814048185944557, -0.024030370637774467, 0.012290236540138721, 0.028981070965528488, 0.02975628711283207, 0.010459915734827518, -0.00901928823441267, -0.0022776592522859573, 0.037999365478754044, -0.005906886886805296, -0.019842568784952164, 0.03824751451611519, 0.01982778310775757, -0.03790557011961937, -0.015871474519371986, 0.005331540014594793, 0.022136904299259186, -0.0179585013538599, 0.00016560603398829699, 0.027111956849694252, -0.03354109451174736, 0.012095467187464237, -0.033537961542606354, -0.048145052045583725, 0.05116959661245346, 0.059260547161102295, -0.022951828315854073, -0.06702248007059097, 0.0203541312366724, -0.009099517948925495, 0.02628987468779087, -0.029601501300930977, -0.015826363116502762, 0.004657649900764227, -0.011308283545076847, 0.007804683409631252, -0.013969254679977894, -0.005250308196991682, 0.029986361041665077, 0.026375217363238335, -0.026421520859003067, -0.02464992366731167, -0.012091671116650105, -0.02466714195907116, -0.03419042378664017, -0.038034532219171524, -0.004342075902968645, 0.010633524507284164, 0.04695912078022957, -0.004039758816361427, -0.024591943249106407, 0.02208467572927475, 0.01461211871355772, -0.03317379578948021, -0.031247297301888466, -0.03490684553980827, -0.027110068127512932, -0.03412839025259018, 0.0027608221862465143, 0.039840374141931534, -0.03331027552485466, -0.052350323647260666, 0.05922579765319824, -0.05356966331601143, -0.012325899675488472, -0.018779126927256584, -0.020971354097127914, -0.01616269163787365, -0.010927127674221992, 0.0008599087013863027, -0.02524416521191597, -0.03342709317803383, -0.00555711193010211, -0.046555884182453156, -0.022871069610118866, 0.002711415523663163, -0.04011953994631767, -0.017722565680742264, -0.01810704730451107, -0.01022413931787014, 0.06614303588867188, 0.04842168837785721, -0.014679007232189178, -0.020291969180107117, -0.007456332445144653, -0.015944452956318855, -0.047761574387550354, 0.00576830143108964, 0.039420582354068756, 0.015152357518672943, 0.026245450600981712, -0.05968891456723213, 0.04923005774617195, 0.03164740279316902, 0.013908990658819675, 0.006616920232772827, 0.029596349224448204, -0.00461546191945672, -0.015764476731419563, 0.06989334523677826, 0.002781727584078908, 0.0028266343288123608, 0.038189034909009933, 0.00920372549444437, 0.043068986386060715, -0.004798522684723139, -0.05397803336381912, -0.007555390242487192, -0.01639247126877308, 0.02492097020149231, -0.03667990863323212, 0.00443325424566865, 0.006384610198438168, -0.03524908795952797, -0.009173172526061535, -0.005371726118028164, 0.015466940589249134, -0.00706411013379693, -0.0028073552530258894, 0.06840917468070984, 0.04579802602529526, -0.003612047992646694, -0.04966532066464424, -0.06176989525556564, 0.0017249135999009013, 0.023464737460017204, -0.008068764582276344, -0.008514353074133396, 0.03190695866942406, 0.05453504994511604, 0.026043009012937546, -0.015680095180869102, -0.022695226594805717, -0.027360644191503525, -0.04479195550084114, -0.007561091799288988, -0.029746217653155327, 0.05003581568598747, 0.01193920336663723, 0.018434064462780952, 0.011094341054558754, -0.017959225922822952, 0.0005685623618774116, -0.00585705554112792, -0.062152259051799774, 0.044451963156461716, 0.028003530576825142, -0.04562950134277344, -0.029435796663165092, -0.019540993496775627, 0.006417470518499613, -0.02088228613138199, -0.0035017828922718763, -0.012032030150294304, 0.009724711999297142, -0.04887225106358528, 0.0020454605109989643, 0.04278732091188431, 0.027011411264538765, -0.019046809524297714, 0.026513028889894485, 0.0039062381256371737, -0.013250277377665043, 0.030876904726028442, 0.03349341079592705, -0.03589111194014549, 0.015486734919250011, 0.007112642750144005, 0.03351306542754173, 0.04753267765045166, 0.028991786763072014, 0.010234959423542023, 0.004012445919215679, -0.04679670184850693, 0.030660422518849373, 0.010806236416101456, 0.019929317757487297, 0.06979913264513016, -0.02226548083126545, -0.039628177881240845, -0.04804372787475586, 0.01091622095555067, -0.009239387698471546, -0.027861684560775757, -0.005258447024971247, 0.036653805524110794, 0.05318346992135048, 0.003095477819442749, -0.00863402709364891, 0.03297296166419983, 0.031263530254364014, 0.014627333730459213, 0.016097737476229668, -0.0497039295732975, -0.03103429079055786, -0.04914243519306183, -0.027852622792124748, 0.004271307960152626, 0.02978263981640339, 0.0012888498604297638, -0.01243868749588728, 0.045328766107559204, -0.0014802548103034496, -0.015192822553217411, -0.003659844631329179, 0.039269112050533295, 0.00563586363568902, -0.019884519279003143, -0.01933293044567108, 0.05167593061923981, 0.012556557543575764, 0.00809451099485159, 0.027515769004821777, 0.026449767872691154, -0.05067451298236847, 0.01675577275454998, 0.023272836580872536, 0.06173260137438774, -0.021835049614310265, -0.000976758310571313, -0.027626588940620422, -0.019533487036824226, 0.01695479452610016, -0.05321480333805084, 0.04681529104709625, -0.020406411960721016, 0.03249671310186386, -0.010240627452731133, -0.02511180005967617, -0.047878362238407135, -0.003784584579989314, -0.005532164126634598, 0.013877520337700844, -0.03253231570124626, -0.02573961205780506, -0.02553359791636467, 0.01984451897442341, -0.0027174383867532015, 0.04928150027990341, -0.020392024889588356, -0.016653023660182953, -0.016616027802228928, 0.01941770501434803, -0.028034914284944534, -0.055909886956214905, -0.0018833697540685534, -0.021151576191186905, 0.04608004167675972, 0.04093614220619202, -0.018457291647791862, -0.02280953899025917, 0.009646757505834103, 0.03397035971283913, 0.001016250578686595, 0.01186043955385685, -0.0324859656393528, 0.02096349559724331, 0.04649434983730316, -0.032390400767326355, 0.07420296967029572, 0.05707067251205444, -0.019104206934571266, -0.018644757568836212, -0.06274702399969101, 0.013054757378995419, -0.0010654235957190394, -0.008818197064101696, -0.03818714991211891, 0.02518046461045742, 0.022779785096645355, -0.011762047186493874, 0.02928430773317814, 0.03768901526927948, -0.04113193601369858, -0.014342349022626877, 0.026934819296002388, -0.01389057096093893, 0.021946031600236893, 0.005850751884281635, -0.0015739572700113058, 0.0128361526876688, 0.02820604294538498, 0.004030633717775345, -0.002236531814560294, 0.015397762879729271, 0.017338164150714874, 0.025322791188955307, -0.02928537130355835, 0.001998475519940257, 0.012120815925300121, -0.030231889337301254, 0.006592690013349056, -0.032801151275634766, 0.010071888566017151, 0.010642940178513527, -0.022594017907977104, 0.044782526791095734, -0.01891293190419674, -0.00961203034967184, 0.06818343698978424, 0.005799534264951944, 0.044432949274778366, -0.038254011422395706, 0.04576824605464935, -0.0040247272700071335, -0.057584360241889954, -0.05394037440419197, 0.004263258073478937, 0.04456793889403343, 0.007540457416325808, -0.0803983137011528, -0.015341097488999367, -0.046938344836235046, 0.00905886571854353, -0.042414840310811996, -0.0009142581257037818, 0.0324782133102417, -0.007497464772313833, -0.029980259016156197, 0.011451724916696548, -0.003111393190920353, 0.06886723637580872, -0.014607401564717293, -0.016250280663371086, -0.025371627882122993, 0.02484481781721115, -0.03522462025284767, -0.002507375320419669, 0.0220201276242733, -0.03173493966460228, 0.01846461184322834, 0.016326237469911575, -0.004453613888472319, 0.026253366842865944, 0.008882085792720318, -0.02422817423939705, -0.01363514456897974, -0.02725980058312416, 0.005299610551446676, -0.04600033164024353, -0.018895074725151062, 0.0017386219697073102, 0.0251685231924057, 0.010749664157629013, 0.014050750061869621, -0.009649701416492462, 0.004097833298146725, 0.014696108177304268, -0.018721725791692734, 0.018028540536761284, 0.011700904928147793, 0.049924060702323914, -0.004758775699883699, 0.002640762133523822, -0.04656770080327988, -0.028204716742038727, -0.020849106833338737, 0.028368493542075157, -0.015397610142827034, -0.012735207565128803, 0.029044266790151596, -0.04870723932981491, -0.03009018488228321, -0.06914852559566498, 0.024242911487817764, 0.04192375764250755, -0.028906146064400673, 0.02573700062930584, -0.015833646059036255, 0.03199097141623497, -0.030005978420376778, -0.021988196298480034, 0.009116848930716515, -0.01741688884794712, -0.002725285477936268, 0.05640147626399994, 0.013738412410020828, 0.004505252465605736, 0.06008981540799141, 0.01018452551215887, 0.03240150585770607, 0.023336511105298996, 0.05070090293884277, -0.028615958988666534, 0.015387005172669888, -0.01128999050706625, -0.008964130654931068, 0.006588613148778677, -0.03252105042338371, 0.03538694605231285, -0.016131896525621414, 0.009480958804488182, 0.04704411327838898, 0.02534434199333191, -0.002015376463532448, -0.04507225379347801, 0.0005455317441374063, -0.0066949776373803616, -0.01381752546876669, 0.004355836194008589, -0.028720485046505928, 0.039746347814798355, 0.027565889060497284, 0.057907432317733765, -0.020233426243066788, 0.008640279993414879, -0.0021802436094731092, -0.02300032041966915, -0.015648936852812767, -0.03605550527572632, -0.04813401401042938, 0.05707431957125664, -0.06421637535095215, -0.02462923899292946, -0.02451900579035282, -0.013351737521588802, 0.055445246398448944, 0.0184251107275486, 0.04531428962945938, -0.020711952820420265, 0.0779067650437355, -0.024817882105708122, 0.033563919365406036, -0.016881974413990974, -0.04405537247657776, 0.14582592248916626, 0.06572733074426651, 0.019477222114801407, -0.0574609711766243, -0.007436967920511961, 0.010762562043964863, 0.056766409426927567, -0.01599334366619587, -0.01938237063586712, 0.01031680591404438, -0.016942529007792473, 0.07232137024402618, 0.051473237574100494, 0.030698349699378014, -0.027426570653915405, 0.01065448485314846, -0.0410568043589592, -0.0728650838136673, -0.017098108306527138, 0.008201929740607738, 0.009736140258610249, -0.034835509955883026, -0.0508936271071434, 0.01734297350049019, 0.013722416013479233, 0.01183123979717493, -0.05492710694670677, -0.038070518523454666, 0.0051950267516076565, -0.028625430539250374, -0.028577681630849838, -0.01009459886699915, 0.035428255796432495, -0.01516407635062933, 0.01565035618841648, -0.001205014530569315, 0.0004427858511917293, -0.041113052517175674, 0.010784248821437359, 0.06179437041282654, 0.011895128525793552, -0.0039437604136765, 0.010279873386025429, 0.022308973595499992, -0.03157341107726097, -0.009347972460091114, -0.028377708047628403, 0.016527272760868073, -0.0036974602844566107, -0.021221090108156204, 0.01918388344347477, -0.014404892921447754, -0.02499374933540821, -0.03987601771950722, 0.00032251098309643567, 0.03247968479990959, 0.023917239159345627, -0.028484756126999855, -0.02327420562505722, -0.00811675377190113, 0.020022224634885788, -0.011514277197420597, 0.0019293151563033462, 0.016995828598737717, -0.03295024111866951, -0.011279669590294361, -0.03899596631526947, 0.07685964554548264, -0.023984471336007118, 0.04155733808875084, -0.02038814127445221, -0.005982598289847374, -0.019576197490096092, 0.0031057654414325953, 0.0027494493406265974, 0.008402641862630844, 0.05913252383470535, -0.01688913255929947, -0.009475341066718102, -0.030471019446849823, -0.024231281131505966, 0.06628605723381042, -0.06403753161430359, 0.023468155413866043, -0.0814942717552185, -0.036299291998147964, 0.005150260403752327, 0.03723302111029625, 0.022405121475458145, 0.011870165355503559, -0.007720698602497578, 0.06429736316204071, 0.042239733040332794, -0.04236555099487305, -0.04350683465600014, 0.008474779315292835, -0.007649297825992107, 0.0017195228720083833, -0.009496014565229416, 0.04428670182824135, 0.017445089295506477, -0.0013739005662500858, -0.001172884600237012, 0.012850478291511536, 0.014726966619491577, -0.016812579706311226, -0.037730082869529724, -0.01604076661169529, 0.009001930244266987, 0.022110488265752792, -0.04536109045147896, -0.052691373974084854, -0.003724296111613512, -0.02347741834819317, -0.043342962861061096, 0.048661500215530396, 0.007235559169203043, -0.05031872168183327, -0.016694379970431328, -0.03724391758441925, 0.0013666226295754313, 0.022400716319680214, -0.016560638323426247, -0.021440448239445686, -0.002946039428934455, -0.05680534243583679, -0.014031479135155678, -0.029260681942105293, -0.024025345221161842, 0.01718512549996376, 0.03698454797267914, 0.047385744750499725, 0.02383260615170002, 0.033177491277456284, -0.005232360679656267, 0.023579582571983337, -0.0013205648865550756, 0.004684091545641422, -0.002972562098875642, 0.00450790673494339, 0.063298299908638, -0.021808603778481483, -0.06651593744754791, 0.044287677854299545, 0.03872812166810036, 0.0035766721703112125, -0.012798874638974667, 0.02603532001376152, 0.0015318290097638965, 0.05569891259074211, -0.02269926108419895, -0.02504521980881691, -0.007589028682559729, -0.009682302363216877, 0.03652701899409294, -0.010619954206049442, -0.012701871804893017, -0.02518070489168167, -0.013208999298512936, 0.023896299302577972, 0.04751404747366905, -0.03412764519453049, 0.057357750833034515, 0.026148967444896698, -0.013047726824879646, 0.016791509464383125, 0.01911097951233387, 0.010159937664866447, 0.01274845190346241, 0.03549632057547569, 0.013994958251714706, 0.01857810653746128, -0.051084890961647034, -0.01162007823586464, -0.061693474650382996, -0.03689626604318619, 0.00009414807573193684, -0.00042662236955948174, 0.025002457201480865, -0.02170809917151928, 0.016065513715147972, 0.049703460186719894, -0.022796163335442543, 0.025356609374284744, -0.013124498538672924, -0.011424844153225422, -0.015493111684918404, 0.025672316551208496, -0.013268650509417057, 0.03912654146552086, 0.04695577919483185, 0.016867337748408318, 0.07209596782922745, 0.019136518239974976, -0.007649272680282593, -0.02080482244491577, -0.005790212657302618, 0.0008521195268258452, 0.014664599671959877, -0.04637965187430382, 0.02420356124639511, -0.00587508175522089, -0.00024286587722599506, 0.009685473516583443, -0.013245703652501106, 0.01651057042181492, 0.016215737909078598, 0.028248777613043785, 0.037439629435539246, 0.058733753859996796, 0.012348875403404236, 0.01651807688176632, -0.0386178158223629, -0.013145470060408115, 0.02476416528224945, 0.03667980805039406, -0.03760213032364845, 0.013744400814175606, 0.01435022708028555, 0.011507232673466206, -0.01841767504811287, 0.025352781638503075, -0.029358748346567154, 0.011348914355039597, 0.0138828931376338, 0.003850964829325676, -0.0206716638058424, -0.037355173379182816, 0.02410830743610859, 0.003024002071470022, 0.02052927576005459, 0.039857279509305954, -0.0048191482201218605, -0.030764957889914513, 0.04632965475320816, 0.0038571690674871206, -0.038739290088415146, 0.035787343978881836, -0.028901232406497, -0.0012757477816194296, -0.01321315485984087, -0.02455482818186283, 0.0016814838163554668, -0.030074840411543846, -0.033602211624383926, -0.00013321339793037623, -0.03271622210741043, -0.0009938469156622887, -0.0012013083323836327, 0.005792110227048397, 0.04077065363526344, -0.0017629389185458422, 0.022366417571902275, -0.10023295134305954, 0.0263882614672184, -0.005778274964541197, -0.076213538646698, -0.012542694807052612, 0.011224217712879181, -0.006358679383993149, 0.015279972925782204, 0.0441097728908062, 0.015374040231108665, -0.011448361910879612, -0.03548789396882057, 0.028732500970363617, 0.003604849334806204, -0.08325211703777313, 0.043332427740097046, -0.03735320270061493, -0.0312730148434639, -0.028577979654073715, 0.004421941004693508, 0.0023555888328701258, 0.024614328518509865, -0.005264492239803076, -0.004189592786133289, 0.015241486020386219, 0.006740754470229149, 0.010799743235111237, 0.04666261747479439, 0.026889821514487267, -0.024589961394667625, 0.0513114258646965, -0.0014684309717267752, 0.03188930079340935, 0.028918318450450897, 0.00013889215188100934, -0.0638265311717987, 0.007750747725367546, -0.01509525440633297, -0.036544330418109894, -0.008252200670540333, -0.005197846330702305, 0.015942474827170372, -0.05974802002310753, -0.024025987833738327, 0.040518272668123245, -0.008434952236711979, -0.018327953293919563, 0.03893378749489784, 0.034319475293159485, 0.013989456929266453, -0.0015718729700893164, 0.03382396325469017, -0.009429260157048702, -0.02825467847287655, 0.032218482345342636, 0.0006067354697734118, 0.009054876863956451, -0.04524106904864311, 0.03566660359501839, 0.053214337676763535, -0.016975034028291702, 0.05702809989452362, 0.02370276488363743, 0.063500314950943, -0.010125522501766682, -0.010311651043593884, 0.012662291526794434, -0.022438667714595795, 0.023167625069618225, 0.006986171472817659, -0.004762380849570036, 0.03287086263298988, -0.06149908900260925, -0.0009713304461911321, 0.025447003543376923, -0.014058741740882397, -0.048277515918016434, -0.011928935535252094, 0.05130632966756821, 0.00003828983608400449, -0.01870550401508808, 0.013782929629087448, 0.027256950736045837, 0.01703338511288166, 0.018939567729830742, -0.026157967746257782, -0.017269540578126907, -0.0033174059353768826, 0.0148686608299613, -0.01535401213914156, -0.019589094445109367, -0.03072197549045086, -0.015034554526209831, 0.0029852751176804304, 0.0050864252261817455, 0.00025761532015167177, -0.03382689878344536, -0.016756603494286537, 0.0339369960129261, 0.05354296788573265, -0.052074309438467026, -0.024140367284417152, -0.043596863746643066, 0.02595825307071209, -0.010746654123067856, -0.021378636360168457 ]
<p>I have a group of 200 children who came to clinic at months 0, 1, 2, 3, 6, 9, and 12 this year. At each clinic visit the children were weighed.</p> <pre><code># Set seed to create reproducible example data set.seed(50) # Create patient ID numbers, genders, and ages control &lt;- NULL control$Age_0 = round(runif(200,1,10), digits = 1) # Create monthly weights control$Weight_0 = ((control$Age_0 + 4) * 2) control$Weight_1 = (control$Weight_0 * 1.1) control$Weight_2 = (control$Weight_0 * 1.2) control$Weight_3 = (control$Weight_0 * 1.3) control$Weight_6 = (control$Weight_0 * 1.4) control$Weight_9 = (control$Weight_0 * 1.6) control$Weight_12 = (control$Weight_0 * 1.8) # Store as data frame control &lt;- as.data.frame(control) </code></pre> <p>I want to study how their weights vary with time. I thought the best way to do this would be to simply plot their mean weights at every visit versus time.</p> <pre><code># Plot mean weights versus time plot(c(0,1,2,3,6,9,12), c(mean(control$Weight_0), mean(control$Weight_1), mean(control$Weight_2), mean(control$Weight_3), mean(control$Weight_6), mean(control$Weight_9), mean(control$Weight_12)), xlab = "Month", ylab = "Weight (Kilograms)", main = "Weight versus time", ylim = c(0,50)) </code></pre> <p>I would like to put some vertical error bars on this plot. My questions are:</p> <ol> <li>Should I plot standard deviation, standard error, or a 95% confidence interval?</li> <li>How do I add vertical error bars to the plot?</li> </ol> <p>There is another group of children who got growth hormone injections during the year. I want to compare their growth over time to that of the children in the control group.</p> <pre><code># Create patient ID numbers, genders, and ages growth &lt;- NULL growth$Age_0 = round(runif(200,1,10), digits = 1) # Create monthly weights growth$Weight_0 = ((growth$Age_0 + 6) * 2) growth$Weight_1 = (growth$Weight_0 * 1.3) growth$Weight_2 = (growth$Weight_0 * 1.4) growth$Weight_3 = (growth$Weight_0 * 1.6) growth$Weight_6 = (growth$Weight_0 * 1.8) growth$Weight_9 = (growth$Weight_0 * 1.9) growth$Weight_12 = (growth$Weight_0 * 2.0) # Store as data frame growth &lt;- as.data.frame(growth) plot(c(0,1,2,3,6,9,12), c(mean(growth$Weight_0), mean(growth$Weight_1), mean(growth$Weight_2), mean(growth$Weight_3), mean(growth$Weight_6), mean(growth$Weight_9), mean(growth$Weight_12)), xlab = "Month", ylab = "Weight (Kilograms)", main = "Weight versus time", ylim = c(0,50)) </code></pre> <ol> <li>Does this change the kind of error bars I should create (i.e., should I use confidence intervals if I want to examine whether or not there is a difference between the groups)?</li> <li>How do I plot this on the same plot as the control group?</li> </ol> <p>Am I thinking of this problem the right way? Any other suggestions?</p>
73,806
[ -0.03725647181272507, -0.03167692944407463, 0.019684823229908943, -0.017206663265824318, 0.035048045217990875, 0.013455338776111603, -0.01732374168932438, -0.02266613207757473, 0.033054422587156296, -0.019676700234413147, 0.05712689831852913, 0.06340507417917252, 0.05971037596464157, 0.03968288004398346, 0.03226258233189583, 0.017980068922042847, -0.014338452368974686, -0.017331037670373917, -0.011375367641448975, -0.015668664127588272, -0.037459369748830795, -0.007202844135463238, 0.008786935359239578, -0.011100582778453827, -0.004205133765935898, 0.034840889275074005, 0.041239604353904724, -0.03992703557014465, 0.0024552722461521626, 0.07510848343372345, -0.08502042293548584, -0.03748178482055664, 0.049014415591955185, -0.02418743073940277, 0.04608479142189026, 0.037965625524520874, 0.0029180373530834913, -0.04459138959646225, 0.005048283841460943, 0.002466079080477357, -0.04965226352214813, 0.048001810908317566, 0.028100207448005676, -0.019273629412055016, 0.014491126872599125, 0.043214038014411926, 0.0005311128916218877, 0.019373632967472076, 0.052135080099105835, 0.004136006347835064, 0.02808329463005066, -0.04225248470902443, 0.031970325857400894, 0.03921950235962868, -0.05303379148244858, -0.012194309383630753, 0.019872283563017845, 0.01355204451829195, 0.016017964109778404, -0.05759043246507645, 0.033979084342718124, 0.0036446054000407457, -0.02248540148139, 0.0005458749947138131, 0.006943088956177235, -0.02853255718946457, 0.015845373272895813, 0.022440003231167793, 0.006966009736061096, -0.016488898545503616, -0.008836914785206318, 0.026820603758096695, 0.009463876485824585, -0.021167729049921036, -0.0015756373759359121, -0.028705185279250145, 0.026208030059933662, -0.013756094500422478, 0.06130363047122955, 0.020435001701116562, -0.013721423223614693, 0.02578027732670307, 0.03450116515159607, 0.020373666658997536, -0.009212265722453594, -0.008527380414307117, 0.04983428120613098, 0.01914907805621624, 0.05273202806711197, 0.027094241231679916, 0.011990690603852272, 0.03442667797207832, 0.02481023408472538, 0.05980343744158745, -0.018417848274111748, 0.016332179307937622, -0.006336958613246679, 0.01879780739545822, -0.0059102242812514305, 0.005925161298364401, -0.00038702847086824477, -0.05535462498664856, 0.011450440622866154, 0.03644134849309921, -0.03736366704106331, -0.022674234583973885, -0.022858846932649612, -0.05025393143296242, -0.0008808764978311956, 0.001714431680738926, -0.015613272786140442, -0.00928475335240364, -0.009244141168892384, -0.018077269196510315, 0.010599762201309204, -0.036605000495910645, 0.007668134290724993, 0.026106126606464386, 0.0569116584956646, -0.0036854443605989218, 0.04312172904610634, -0.026009732857346535, 0.042342375963926315, -0.00004704538514488377, -0.057211246341466904, 0.004867103416472673, 0.016342315822839737, 0.010279381647706032, -0.011262797750532627, 0.04112923890352249, 0.016263453289866447, -0.025092601776123047, 0.07338279485702515, -0.027220765128731728, 0.0161297507584095, 0.005433093756437302, -0.064534492790699, -0.0790947824716568, 0.00986482109874487, -0.00404888391494751, -0.025459425523877144, -0.040039557963609695, 0.017749672755599022, 0.038541071116924286, 0.019208254292607307, 0.020065439864993095, 0.006182221695780754, 0.013974000699818134, 0.012800945900380611, 0.01392732746899128, -0.021874578669667244, 0.020468443632125854, 0.011946246959269047, -0.0027037409599870443, -0.03852954879403114, -0.07251904904842377, 0.029922135174274445, 0.008781054057180882, -0.009483733214437962, -0.018450113013386726, 0.030115090310573578, -0.03689224272966385, 0.039010073989629745, -0.01764834113419056, -0.03673005476593971, -0.011033913120627403, 0.06873180717229843, 0.0024985691998153925, -0.006529014557600021, 0.04510755091905594, -0.032956626266241074, 0.009146621450781822, 0.0007653761422261596, 0.0172293558716774, 0.05299770087003708, 0.0044805873185396194, 0.008902558125555515, -0.0022784946486353874, -0.016442470252513885, 0.022960780188441277, -0.024517614394426346, -0.029996180906891823, -0.02733335644006729, -0.024484172463417053, 0.03401361405849457, 0.01605675183236599, 0.006306037772446871, -0.021450981497764587, 0.0378526896238327, -0.049786511808633804, -0.023452317342162132, -0.0904877632856369, 0.012822222895920277, -0.010243276134133339, -0.044958438724279404, -0.013322141952812672, -0.007550565060228109, 0.014799403958022594, 0.006718593183904886, 0.0026082508265972137, -0.027109188959002495, 0.02032265067100525, 0.057779088616371155, -0.025121048092842102, -0.01705980859696865, 0.03965945541858673, 0.06831347197294235, -0.019296342507004738, 0.016088120639324188, -0.04026539623737335, 0.012963030487298965, -0.03668677806854248, -0.05547647550702095, -0.012848039157688618, 0.00025983419618569314, -0.0005446592695079744, -0.011608637869358063, 0.004827104974538088, -0.018065718933939934, 0.03907505050301552, -0.03671406954526901, 0.037479598075151443, 0.07413885742425919, -0.02284621074795723, 0.021278126165270805, -0.015183216892182827, 0.0060369535349309444, 0.05438997223973274, -0.00760678993538022, -0.01328867394477129, -0.04102504625916481, -0.01756635494530201, 0.0100102499127388, -0.00327374623157084, -0.00045167672215029597, 0.015415546484291553, 0.04469822347164154, -0.011619796976447105, -0.02024766430258751, 0.019332248717546463, 0.01716344617307186, 0.01381070539355278, 0.002244391245767474, 0.0271355751901865, 0.03345716744661331, 0.012492189183831215, 0.02915624901652336, 0.016005869954824448, 0.029326504096388817, 0.011202202178537846, 0.01814647763967514, 0.022649675607681274, -0.008643735200166702, 0.015107612125575542, 0.013159496709704399, -0.03013552911579609, 0.057724613696336746, -0.00013709033373743296, -0.024332186207175255, 0.04229208827018738, -0.019859077408909798, -0.007513010874390602, 0.0009172189747914672, -0.012495337054133415, -0.029482049867510796, 0.06605081260204315, -0.017468685284256935, 0.004997523967176676, 0.001693114172667265, -0.01447021123021841, 0.041800856590270996, -0.027802571654319763, -0.04740168899297714, -0.038892511278390884, 0.03177276626229286, 0.006846108939498663, -0.000782442803028971, -0.013174599967896938, -0.0141381174325943, -0.03745533898472786, 0.007298723328858614, 0.01425846479833126, 0.05127115920186043, -0.011015207506716251, -0.04794008657336235, -0.0023056939244270325, -0.010024089366197586, -0.012654757127165794, 0.04547080025076866, -0.005379146430641413, -0.03219771385192871, 0.03368431702256203, -0.0017129246843978763, -0.03337860479950905, -0.02107638493180275, -0.03945844992995262, -0.019031604751944542, -0.005498053040355444, -0.0110673438757658, 0.05810284987092018, -0.001875019515864551, -0.018943598493933678, 0.016627995297312737, -0.054634906351566315, 0.01639762707054615, -0.010086504742503166, 0.028574705123901367, -0.00611161720007658, 0.02162240445613861, 0.009221903048455715, 0.022275447845458984, -0.021500596776604652, -0.04268517345190048, -0.06111443042755127, -0.010194136761128902, 0.011553614400327206, 0.014934000559151173, 0.04536158964037895, 0.011653007939457893, 0.011356823146343231, 0.08677973598241806, 0.04418580234050751, -0.02545972913503647, -0.039652738720178604, 0.0017992699285969138, -0.027378829196095467, -0.028027506545186043, 0.058095041662454605, -0.009103596210479736, 0.003980537410825491, -0.04067060351371765, 0.005063692107796669, 0.01122408639639616, 0.02619180455803871, -0.01037906389683485, 0.0461893230676651, -0.028351858258247375, -0.01773855835199356, -0.017698559910058975, 0.06317507475614548, 0.035595767199993134, -0.028354741632938385, -0.015427863225340843, -0.02140115015208721, 0.00993631687015295, -0.010981598868966103, -0.08279208838939667, -0.002342544263228774, -0.008294885978102684, 0.036379050463438034, -0.025193573907017708, 0.02674952521920204, 0.002446305239573121, -0.026601355522871017, -0.025203881785273552, -0.016183406114578247, 0.04738495498895645, -0.02355629950761795, -0.01905738189816475, 0.008939392864704132, 0.05642889067530632, -0.035246968269348145, 0.01983189955353737, 0.022370873019099236, -0.0300054419785738, 0.008907094597816467, -0.07519307732582092, -0.03364840894937515, 0.03561587631702423, 0.04175896197557449, -0.0096626291051507, 0.0015167235396802425, -0.02293195202946663, 0.015101125463843346, -0.06520494073629379, -0.010366599075496197, -0.01689591445028782, 0.04763073846697807, 0.04106791689991951, 0.05701539292931557, 0.014652889221906662, -0.012182206846773624, 0.009744957089424133, -0.046685006469488144, -0.08210662752389908, 0.016975443810224533, 0.012121550738811493, 0.0030505768954753876, 0.00480478722602129, -0.03850417956709862, 0.027652831748127937, -0.03550385311245918, 0.029354389756917953, 0.004750513471662998, 0.0052576870657503605, 0.020445071160793304, -0.010869032703340054, -0.00904571358114481, 0.006759327370673418, -0.04584397003054619, 0.0041244239546358585, 0.025968700647354126, -0.015761706978082657, 0.059007678180933, 0.01818040758371353, 0.004154375288635492, -0.03897339478135109, -0.02687019854784012, -0.01773298718035221, 0.012209082953631878, 0.02879764325916767, 0.023662418127059937, -0.0042833322659134865, -0.05286412686109543, 0.016507066786289215, 0.008277766406536102, 0.025495246052742004, 0.07034562528133392, 0.015825696289539337, 0.009702704846858978, -0.001686047064140439, 0.009450657293200493, 0.016358021646738052, -0.023531848564743996, 0.007677854038774967, -0.02875371277332306, 0.04104739800095558, -0.007334141992032528, -0.03276590257883072, 0.02406691387295723, 0.03905859217047691, 0.028688276186585426, 0.013406588695943356, -0.030955202877521515, 0.007885012775659561, -0.02978641726076603, -0.025105787441134453, 0.021553024649620056, 0.018767409026622772, 0.019220590591430664, 0.012765943072736263, 0.016316654160618782, 0.006887729279696941, -0.017090171575546265, 0.03868915140628815, 0.0404469296336174, 0.039752256125211716, 0.004789825528860092, -0.04002498462796211, 0.022660570219159126, 0.022105969488620758, 0.02048315666615963, 0.00005638647417072207, -0.008606977760791779, -0.0795106589794159, -0.015949254855513573, 0.051177747547626495, 0.06362185627222061, -0.034191060811281204, -0.03268394619226456, -0.022103063762187958, -0.01360055711120367, 0.05454953387379646, -0.02393697202205658, 0.024250399321317673, -0.04116232320666313, 0.010840804316103458, -0.026577046141028404, -0.04789215326309204, -0.06574083864688873, 0.022141601890325546, -0.05852852016687393, -0.024375269189476967, -0.029332393780350685, -0.0009379959665238857, -0.012369036674499512, 0.003491602372378111, -0.000286346476059407, 0.08756560832262039, -0.0439426526427269, -0.015389393083751202, 0.03484390303492546, -0.01828298717737198, -0.03185061365365982, -0.029072320088744164, -0.006575027480721474, -0.012779517099261284, 0.014447079040110111, 0.05297376587986946, 0.011539172381162643, -0.007895350456237793, 0.022132689133286476, 0.05381587892770767, -0.0016015523578971624, 0.0034617187920957804, -0.025796445086598396, 0.01510122325271368, 0.03737581893801689, 0.018877224996685982, 0.03416771814227104, 0.030619852244853973, 0.012195868417620659, 0.0172527227550745, -0.0694180279970169, 0.005533227697014809, -0.0011097576934844255, -0.011815221980214119, -0.04974272474646568, -0.008385521359741688, 0.009617566131055355, -0.0018265483668074012, 0.009562680497765541, -0.0012413543881848454, -0.038191042840480804, 0.009877593256533146, 0.03808635473251343, 0.025897826999425888, 0.02452898770570755, -0.03886498510837555, -0.027838272973895073, -0.015600549057126045, 0.004230596125125885, -0.014944166876375675, 0.012734794057905674, -0.009291180409491062, 0.03620590642094612, 0.024149592965841293, -0.06577038764953613, 0.012370203621685505, -0.022301722317934036, 0.019027577713131905, 0.005736467428505421, -0.026909375563263893, -0.013731595128774643, -0.007651632186025381, 0.02523726038634777, -0.0017603153828531504, -0.016938181594014168, -0.00038826503441669047, 0.005070144310593605, -0.020838340744376183, 0.002085555111989379, -0.01061789970844984, 0.04105314984917641, 0.006289759185165167, 0.010977093130350113, -0.06076280400156975, -0.0524955689907074, 0.009820563718676567, -0.013624227605760098, -0.026662614196538925, -0.011712825857102871, -0.00919250212609768, 0.013070241548120975, -0.01127270795404911, -0.011830485425889492, 0.02972295507788658, -0.025873996317386627, 0.019256003201007843, -0.01886293850839138, 0.030652280896902084, 0.08809354156255722, 0.01191814336925745, 0.01860940270125866, -0.009494046680629253, -0.014559691771864891, -0.023132607340812683, -0.0077129993587732315, -0.026081284508109093, -0.022820908576250076, -0.01726650632917881, -0.015303514897823334, 0.019515370950102806, 0.04297333583235741, -0.01801157183945179, -0.013487990014255047, -0.006276311352849007, 0.01162020955234766, 0.02258354425430298, -0.08457095921039581, 0.0057665398344397545, -0.04199228063225746, 0.019769735634326935, -0.03669121116399765, 0.01876690238714218, -0.03856261819601059, -0.007327929604798555, 0.01251230388879776, 0.013905949890613556, -0.03835054859519005, 0.021707404404878616, 0.06415258347988129, -0.009560941718518734, -0.006888826843351126, -0.017598450183868408, -0.01926632970571518, 0.0003833702940028161, -0.01353803463280201, -0.03934989869594574, 0.020657524466514587, 0.0061079212464392185, -0.006318757776170969, 0.024691807106137276, -0.06565970927476883, 0.0037158397026360035, 0.06643896549940109, 0.019743870943784714, 0.06720622628927231, 0.05685785040259361, 0.025663023814558983, 0.009157981723546982, -0.04416213929653168, -0.05120838060975075, -0.02708766795694828, 0.02441735751926899, 0.06308161467313766, 0.004603851120918989, -0.01013075653463602, 0.056142885237932205, 0.02221956104040146, 0.021374104544520378, 0.03877386450767517, -0.0025652076583355665, -0.050742704421281815, 0.008701909333467484, -0.0409439392387867, -0.04554154351353645, 0.013090628199279308, -0.012957892380654812, 0.044237952679395676, -0.06244441866874695, -0.03845757618546486, 0.014275100082159042, 0.035412002354860306, -0.0560152493417263, -0.025019163265824318, -0.004018100444227457, -0.06436412781476974, -0.008331824094057083, 0.03250306472182274, -0.015668507665395737, 0.016061309725046158, 0.041373271495103836, 0.06180475279688835, -0.03858141973614693, 0.029282741248607635, -0.056349001824855804, -0.07232005149126053, -0.022052403539419174, -0.02237825095653534, -0.05243222042918205, 0.07682763040065765, -0.016681691631674767, -0.019208166748285294, -0.012229843065142632, -0.04054119437932968, 0.015348320826888084, 0.01777581125497818, 0.015775537118315697, -0.004246338736265898, 0.05901900678873062, -0.01868230476975441, -0.015327440574765205, 0.005422886926680803, 0.0002979129203595221, 0.1444493979215622, 0.046576302498579025, 0.015755794942378998, -0.05905143916606903, 0.010761520825326443, 0.028844309970736504, 0.007474447134882212, -0.005277876742184162, 0.016620200127363205, 0.04032859578728676, -0.007173536345362663, 0.05100303143262863, 0.026039013639092445, -0.002188349375501275, 0.012921282090246677, 0.04976750910282135, -0.011867975816130638, 0.00022028562671039253, -0.010679555125534534, -0.0025952321011573076, -0.007086265366524458, -0.0004922427469864488, -0.07465557008981705, 0.025234824046492577, 0.036239515990018845, -0.012422722764313221, -0.039279185235500336, -0.045061659067869186, -0.0017586235189810395, 0.01185016892850399, -0.024599673226475716, 0.03997915983200073, 0.0035752453841269016, 0.008167227730154991, -0.009260725229978561, -0.04697278141975403, 0.004901524167507887, -0.08063936233520508, 0.03005596064031124, 0.05630040168762207, -0.03137769550085068, -0.022034965455532074, -0.046740029007196426, 0.026899732649326324, -0.0453018955886364, -0.02310956083238125, -0.04743276908993721, 0.02517290972173214, -0.019237956032156944, -0.038608890026807785, 0.026924462988972664, 0.015193593688309193, 0.021271372213959694, -0.028797591105103493, -0.0024908108171075583, 0.031583238393068314, 0.02047743834555149, -0.020915035158395767, 0.04249389097094536, -0.013767487369477749, -0.018576182425022125, -0.009039994329214096, 0.014349261298775673, 0.0606594979763031, -0.027804037556052208, -0.014001937583088875, -0.050656016916036606, 0.013187102042138577, -0.03186856582760811, 0.02314688451588154, 0.058827582746744156, 0.0029938924126327038, -0.004027512390166521, 0.010687566362321377, 0.03650372847914696, 0.026615232229232788, 0.008766120299696922, 0.026726270094513893, -0.02040155790746212, 0.032523803412914276, 0.007973333820700645, 0.013253960758447647, -0.019635742530226707, -0.03196863830089569, -0.011605631560087204, 0.02417529933154583, 0.03234577551484108, 0.05374256893992424, 0.03629784658551216, 0.006391775328665972, -0.007861226797103882, 0.06592924147844315, -0.004437858704477549, -0.03926960006356239, 0.00022059321054257452, 0.040568407624959946, -0.0007326020859181881, -0.002521117916330695, -0.01280195638537407, 0.07151782512664795, -0.006356511265039444, 0.012540282681584358, 0.006002258509397507, 0.0261763297021389, 0.03857013210654259, -0.00434546172618866, 0.013756407424807549, -0.04076651483774185, 0.045367151498794556, -0.018647029995918274, 0.01192100066691637, -0.024954110383987427, 0.011880939826369286, -0.03354192152619362, -0.04839254915714264, -0.0024317330680787563, -0.02178865112364292, -0.016139425337314606, 0.04961945489048958, -0.0002240860922029242, -0.004806909244507551, -0.04416347295045853, -0.00018592382548376918, -0.04490751400589943, -0.03464870527386665, 0.0058370837941765785, -0.0170926321297884, -0.009482777677476406, 0.022119712084531784, -0.04475797340273857, 0.014152400195598602, 0.013322977349162102, 0.009990938007831573, 0.012728667818009853, 0.023578427731990814, 0.00706074433401227, 0.030436180531978607, 0.018574126064777374, -0.0058627501130104065, 0.015553580597043037, 0.015874044969677925, -0.0389958880841732, -0.02168572135269642, -0.017981618642807007, 0.0139711769297719, 0.015230139717459679, 0.019997550174593925, -0.03410622105002403, 0.006372314412146807, 0.008973534218966961, -0.014572826214134693, -0.014525570906698704, -0.04193776100873947, -0.027363017201423645, -0.004482948686927557, 0.023132070899009705, 0.024485884234309196, -0.007175224367529154, -0.011962847784161568, 0.010036462917923927, 0.023204416036605835, -0.024473197758197784, -0.020683811977505684, -0.0028880219906568527, -0.0025825928896665573, -0.010860729031264782, -0.014446952380239964, -0.018787873908877373, 0.042989183217287064, 0.0420658178627491, -0.0585632249712944, 0.024225084111094475, -0.03287670761346817, -0.009703111834824085, -0.09963228553533554, -0.03618616983294487, 0.012204230763018131, 0.009330928325653076, -0.007988524623215199, -0.03705715760588646, -0.0022369390353560448, 0.007752318400889635, -0.02685021236538887, 0.010216220282018185, 0.0022210886236280203, 0.007878567092120647, -0.01576310209929943, 0.053297437727451324, -0.012510853819549084, 0.014197074808180332, 0.02570059522986412, 0.008847572840750217, 0.010482706129550934, 0.047785185277462006, 0.048758894205093384, -0.029809698462486267, -0.011913909576833248, 0.0033055832609534264, 0.015892885625362396, -0.0667470395565033, 0.0031720586121082306, -0.03214630112051964, 0.01687711849808693, 0.0027330846060067415, 0.019676296040415764, 0.04176747798919678, -0.00025599764194339514, -0.0104358596727252, -0.03072577901184559, 0.08576259016990662, -0.014403492212295532, -0.005923899821937084, 0.0005358266062103212, -0.014027047902345657, 0.030520517379045486, 0.011777594685554504, -0.014393752440810204, 0.0340520478785038, 0.03162138909101486, 0.01448377687484026, -0.039681028574705124, 0.011916663497686386, -0.0008844377007335424, -0.03037240169942379, 0.0010317681590095162, -0.016329409554600716, -0.009751729667186737, -0.02305448055267334, 0.011171470396220684, -0.014913104474544525, -0.007429397664964199, 0.015577058307826519, 0.01879715360701084, -0.01660102605819702, 0.027953466400504112, 0.017350349575281143, -0.004612110089510679, -0.039410870522260666, 0.0035508975852280855, -0.01679474487900734, -0.01615586318075657, -0.0006657649646513164, -0.027050340548157692, -0.00035708380164578557, -0.016523217782378197, -0.001135355792939663, -0.040603093802928925, 0.025507254526019096, -0.026151807978749275, -0.018569834530353546, 0.019947638735175133, 0.019321875646710396, 0.03991357237100601, -0.10899550467729568, 0.06366804987192154, -0.0002117260592058301, -0.007177375722676516, -0.045225292444229126, -0.004101584665477276, -0.06938730180263519, 0.04626256972551346, 0.05644466355443001, 0.06257040798664093, 0.014214621856808662, -0.0023889802396297455, 0.021455859765410423, 0.016643540933728218, -0.07467319816350937, 0.08284571021795273, -0.011734621599316597, -0.00475457776337862, -0.005731762852519751, 0.0037714687641710043, -0.009029925800859928, 0.01835571601986885, 0.006065495777875185, -0.02671482414007187, 0.015865806490182877, 0.01211104728281498, -0.027876660227775574, 0.008597716689109802, -0.0054507777094841, -0.03285422548651695, 0.045331645756959915, 0.027866117656230927, 0.00021271445439197123, 0.05620528385043144, 0.005377703811973333, -0.05026324838399887, 0.02997448295354843, -0.03496304899454117, -0.0006787068559788167, -0.022521503269672394, -0.033039312809705734, -0.03039523959159851, -0.07340104132890701, 0.020748749375343323, 0.009888477623462677, -0.013346295803785324, -0.02723442018032074, 0.04854130372405052, 0.02618107758462429, 0.039442189037799835, -0.01631755381822586, 0.017322588711977005, -0.0331023707985878, -0.03673823922872543, 0.012058224529027939, -0.028208687901496887, 0.018248679116368294, -0.014799872413277626, 0.003209686605259776, 0.04678451642394066, 0.013982542790472507, 0.047112058848142624, 0.019526541233062744, 0.09481102228164673, 0.0031849404331296682, -0.022329721599817276, -0.006109853740781546, -0.016533439978957176, -0.0011506120208650827, -0.0017183944582939148, -0.0021523975301533937, 0.028577761724591255, -0.029274947941303253, -0.009284982457756996, -0.0305156409740448, -0.04792521893978119, -0.02855994552373886, -0.01939057558774948, 0.018972767516970634, 0.0631638839840889, 0.002004287438467145, 0.009537053294479847, -0.025828136131167412, 0.0001583710400154814, 0.001007823389954865, 0.02865835279226303, 0.04661746323108673, -0.018775993958115578, 0.009516517631709576, -0.006648180540651083, 0.007173055317252874, -0.0022949601989239454, -0.022240355610847473, 0.0491967499256134, 0.0512424111366272, 0.01244179904460907, -0.05680331587791443, -0.011379611678421497, 0.017712190747261047, 0.021707085892558098, -0.02004976011812687, -0.06627947837114334, -0.004580444190651178, 0.009421901777386665, 0.0678698867559433, -0.02690727636218071 ]
<p>I have been trying to implement a Bayesian inference procedure from scratch for a specific problem, but I have implemented the procedure, and it doesn't seem to work. </p> <p>Since, I can't just post the code online and ask community to debug my code, I was wondering if someone could provide with a broader checklist when going about coding up a Bayesian inference procedure. (regardless of language) </p> <p><strong>EDIT: Specifics of the problem</strong></p> <p>I am trying to implement the procedure described in Section 5 of <a href="http://uai.sis.pitt.edu/papers/11/p736-wilson.pdf" rel="nofollow">this paper</a> on <strong>MATLAB</strong> . Briefly put, the procedure I've implemented is - </p> <ol> <li>I have 3 zero mean variables (i.e., $D = 3$ time series) for $500$ timepoints. I'm using initial $N = 350$ data points as training sample.</li> <li>The covariance function I'm using is a squared exponential kernel with 1 hyperparameter - characteristic length scale $l$. I'm assuming it to be the same for all 3 timeseries.</li> <li>I'm keeping degrees of freedom constant, $\nu = D + 1$.</li> <li>$L$, the lower Cholesky decomposition of the scale matrix $V$ is computed as the $D \times D$ covariance matrix of the $N \times D$ training dataset.</li> <li><p>The sampling procedure essentially involves 2 steps (using Gibbs sampling)</p> <p>5.1 Sample $u$ ($N \times D \times \nu$) dimensional vector, assuming Gaussian process prior (as defined in equation 19 of the paper). I've assumed a Gaussian likelihood function (as defined in equation 24). For this I'm using <a href="http://homepages.inf.ed.ac.uk/imurray2/pub/10ess/elliptical_slice.m" rel="nofollow">Elliptical Slice Sampling</a></p> <p>5.2 Sample GP hyperparameter $l$, using a lognormal prior (assumption, $mean=1.5$, $var = 1$). I've used <a href="http://homepages.inf.ed.ac.uk/imurray2/teaching/09mlss/slice_sample.m" rel="nofollow">slice sampling for this</a> with posterior as product of GP prior(eq. 19) and lognormal density.</p></li> </ol> <p>I let this Gibbs sampler run for $10000$ iterations ($5000$ burn-in). But convergence plot of $u$ doesn't seem to converge. </p> <p>I also tried this with smaller $N$ (~ $50$) and increased no. of iterations but didn't work.</p>
73,807
[ -0.005184744950383902, -0.014483001083135605, 0.035418104380369186, -0.0030622510239481926, 0.055949196219444275, 0.0039152768440544605, -0.052755627781152725, -0.05059658735990524, 0.031028782948851585, -0.053139571100473404, 0.029176127165555954, 0.03734264895319939, 0.05171804875135422, 0.029750190675258636, 0.005770068150013685, 0.019479988142848015, -0.025122905150055885, 0.041762713342905045, -0.004553649108856916, -0.04861500486731529, 0.010822003707289696, 0.0301611740142107, -0.005472161807119846, -0.03375221788883209, -0.016710074618458748, 0.026229234412312508, 0.0348101444542408, -0.028233395889401436, -0.0042663319036364555, 0.06904925405979156, -0.05825703591108322, -0.012430286034941673, 0.01835242658853531, 0.02035411261022091, -0.019695071503520012, 0.002599777188152075, -0.008345159702003002, -0.043735574930906296, 0.026682434603571892, 0.05401786416769028, -0.04980284720659256, 0.006088646128773689, 0.008590309880673885, 0.0334109328687191, -0.0032845446839928627, 0.036131080240011215, 0.01235645916312933, -0.00982319749891758, 0.028057226911187172, -0.00010563365503912792, 0.06767541915178299, 0.006784786470234394, 0.012123008258640766, 0.0006276542553678155, -0.024670712649822235, -0.03186371177434921, 0.011064354330301285, 0.04028775170445442, 0.023866938427090645, -0.038309864699840546, -0.027186501771211624, -0.03757014498114586, 0.013420420698821545, -0.028690585866570473, -0.012432411313056946, 0.004395181313157082, 0.008462349884212017, -0.0034028124064207077, -0.0049034771509468555, -0.046815115958452225, 0.042495738714933395, 0.01315377838909626, -0.021318970248103142, -0.030189530923962593, -0.005446429364383221, -0.013371501117944717, 0.007451022509485483, 0.04186299443244934, 0.06522181630134583, 0.008181178011000156, -0.006231727544218302, 0.010328968055546284, -0.015051780268549919, 0.04417048767209053, -0.010129749774932861, 0.021573001518845558, 0.06405897438526154, -0.03960912302136421, 0.02722800150513649, 0.009738655760884285, -0.04445361718535423, 0.036351095885038376, 0.05336872860789299, -0.030353734269738197, -0.04611589387059212, 0.06524604558944702, 0.01044618058949709, 0.033648792654275894, -0.04170257970690727, -0.005506943911314011, -0.008749807253479958, -0.06353578716516495, 0.020638370886445045, 0.04686551168560982, 0.028696978464722633, 0.005416718311607838, -0.0034080022014677525, -0.003178725717589259, -0.03073483146727085, -0.07156555354595184, -0.05374772101640701, 0.023716479539871216, 0.015270349569618702, -0.007768543437123299, -0.0021969780791550875, -0.005861315876245499, -0.010806066915392876, -0.0242164246737957, 0.016630442813038826, 0.07628992944955826, 0.036978814750909805, -0.034269049763679504, 0.010165384039282799, -0.05196676775813103, -0.070234015583992, 0.0027577269356697798, -0.016630137339234352, 0.016151370480656624, -0.03554244339466095, 0.03853181004524231, 0.004982395097613335, -0.02033841982483864, 0.057347483932971954, 0.0217047818005085, -0.01576928421854973, 0.0026652163360267878, -0.07983338087797165, -0.023970572277903557, 0.04111284762620926, -0.020041927695274353, 0.007482748478651047, -0.04490022733807564, 0.001915458939038217, 0.0038544833660125732, 0.04764920100569725, -0.019415322691202164, 0.06327956169843674, 0.03287817910313606, 0.0614934116601944, 0.003144386224448681, -0.026984235271811485, 0.008315752260386944, -0.05032606050372124, 0.019510673359036446, -0.030351607128977776, -0.0732177272439003, 0.045048803091049194, 0.018558863550424576, -0.03156101703643799, 0.02052810601890087, 0.057520121335983276, 0.03161672130227089, 0.0023567748721688986, -0.03212419152259827, 0.003614098997786641, -0.04979361966252327, 0.07116605341434479, 0.014434128999710083, 0.03415483981370926, -0.002545200753957033, -0.03605185076594353, -0.013586078770458698, 0.010086036287248135, 0.03602784499526024, 0.06331587582826614, -0.007877222262322903, 0.010896270163357258, 0.0010193472262471914, 0.016975276172161102, 0.029500126838684082, -0.003984370268881321, -0.033762093633413315, 0.025866597890853882, -0.018625235185027122, 0.027310676872730255, 0.011567439883947372, 0.01846008189022541, 0.017323188483715057, 0.025842027738690376, -0.05444516986608505, -0.0023398417979478836, -0.025260472670197487, -0.019471801817417145, 0.02121661975979805, -0.024897590279579163, 0.026572393253445625, -0.031854670494794846, 0.03405786678195, 0.03701743483543396, -0.04812821000814438, -0.012185492552816868, -0.020340215414762497, 0.04073747619986534, -0.03792313486337662, 0.06111842393875122, 0.04774118959903717, 0.064143106341362, -0.01792757771909237, 0.050856538116931915, 0.007474076002836227, 0.01675783470273018, 0.03183406963944435, -0.01908222585916519, 0.029210882261395454, 0.008207746781408787, 0.01711535081267357, 0.019954809918999672, 0.013208123855292797, -0.0016151334857568145, 0.038496363908052444, -0.03516577184200287, 0.031685713678598404, 0.11430304497480392, -0.004391563590615988, 0.016301104798913002, 0.023890424519777298, 0.028671765699982643, 0.047425225377082825, 0.006203599274158478, -0.012371006421744823, -0.0689203068614006, -0.014946525916457176, 0.0331694558262825, 0.04514288902282715, -0.020915869623422623, 0.027386460453271866, 0.03903034329414368, 0.017494505271315575, 0.015450331382453442, 0.03624440357089043, -0.0002196717105107382, -0.06851120293140411, 0.015141256153583527, 0.010386606678366661, 0.011595922522246838, -0.03160477057099342, -0.027393095195293427, -0.008919711224734783, 0.05767069011926651, -0.011717465706169605, -0.010049725882709026, 0.027365855872631073, -0.010244403965771198, 0.006301407236605883, -0.04628269374370575, -0.0049700550734996796, 0.016895001754164696, 0.03147733584046364, -0.0164469163864851, 0.05746252462267876, -0.0007484360248781741, 0.002772059291601181, -0.021192098036408424, -0.04293958470225334, 0.0307315606623888, 0.05260071903467178, -0.01218950655311346, 0.002395559335127473, 0.007106705568730831, -0.022795341908931732, 0.01575850322842598, 0.00008675175195094198, -0.041316352784633636, -0.04048382118344307, 0.009931888431310654, 0.019784480333328247, -0.00604819692671299, -0.01971622183918953, -0.05080394819378853, -0.023965682834386826, 0.039471499621868134, 0.01846267282962799, 0.045209210366010666, 0.0412263497710228, -0.06032949313521385, 0.023261500522494316, -0.008171114139258862, 0.028206655755639076, 0.007791836746037006, -0.008872698061168194, -0.004928597714751959, 0.029256468638777733, -0.029142584651708603, -0.05406581610441208, -0.04062860459089279, 0.013427183963358402, 0.0003151821147184819, -0.03298722207546234, -0.017633412033319473, 0.05790296196937561, 0.01550825871527195, -0.04038349911570549, 0.03935108706355095, -0.007239104248583317, -0.011807113885879517, -0.043690264225006104, 0.004068312700837851, -0.025127390399575233, -0.013408402912318707, 0.03924814611673355, 0.0044919406063854694, -0.0023046538699418306, 0.008631751872599125, -0.05501953884959221, -0.06762538850307465, 0.010032099671661854, 0.018283486366271973, 0.04056311026215553, -0.000886453955899924, 0.009751846082508564, 0.03862004727125168, 0.02145935408771038, -0.010706642642617226, -0.016124606132507324, -0.011326992884278297, -0.028059467673301697, -0.057609304785728455, 0.02679210901260376, -0.016292711719870567, -0.0018208717228844762, 0.002008084673434496, -0.04333823174238205, 0.01948324218392372, 0.04557632654905319, 0.0033814236521720886, 0.017528938129544258, 0.02450367622077465, -0.007051635533571243, -0.015618986450135708, 0.039461899548769, 0.007578745484352112, 0.018013132736086845, 0.014300060458481312, -0.011358305811882019, 0.022160666063427925, 0.04166967049241066, -0.08215973526239395, -0.000643552397377789, -0.01656952314078808, -0.008281341753900051, -0.043548326939344406, 0.006922909524291754, 0.014805471524596214, -0.06399061530828476, 0.016053207218647003, -0.0019735069945454597, 0.04943879321217537, -0.031930580735206604, 0.002463481854647398, 0.037351060658693314, -0.0018752076430246234, -0.0019942689687013626, 0.004500302020460367, -0.00956410076469183, -0.031088510528206825, 0.008124271407723427, -0.007255173288285732, 0.012469937093555927, 0.00006223918899195269, 0.04971356689929962, 0.017396394163370132, -0.002731175860390067, -0.0268058180809021, -0.011845087632536888, -0.030377371236681938, 0.010884015820920467, -0.04053238779306412, 0.05101204663515091, -0.0015726735582575202, 0.03242771327495575, 0.03295649215579033, -0.005908964667469263, 0.007938585244119167, -0.010150972753763199, -0.039911575615406036, 0.0124337337911129, -0.02391832321882248, -0.0038855148013681173, 0.013947107829153538, -0.015384888276457787, 0.05271061137318611, -0.022864487022161484, 0.029767727479338646, -0.005498476792126894, 0.019696174189448357, -0.046447910368442535, 0.03365425020456314, -0.051670659333467484, -0.028811130672693253, -0.02475695312023163, 0.03391255810856819, 0.04844281077384949, -0.007190412376075983, 0.006035671569406986, 0.02763533964753151, 0.002800664631649852, 0.0049166991375386715, 0.011042377911508083, 0.032628003507852554, 0.0060446304269135, 0.012262435629963875, 0.011352984234690666, 0.013040007092058659, -0.03690684959292412, 0.04835955798625946, 0.009328823536634445, 0.02355438657104969, 0.04587176442146301, -0.02127242647111416, 0.004376404453068972, -0.034828025847673416, 0.0035861360374838114, 0.05381373316049576, 0.023287231102585793, 0.017897622659802437, -0.014514084905385971, 0.05382750183343887, 0.02279229648411274, -0.03503819927573204, 0.04655938968062401, 0.06412366777658463, -0.01448262669146061, -0.005117311142385006, -0.0576307587325573, -0.023265386000275612, -0.018047934398055077, 0.005026595201343298, 0.04454765468835831, 0.01678064651787281, -0.014374645426869392, -0.01815982349216938, 0.028877604752779007, 0.014295904897153378, -0.007761855609714985, 0.018764618784189224, 0.05345180258154869, 0.05008699372410774, 0.013780264183878899, -0.04849882423877716, 0.017114045098423958, 0.016091899946331978, 0.0253253523260355, 0.050489116460084915, 0.03514709323644638, -0.06445787101984024, 0.0008504896541126072, 0.019712230190634727, 0.03191777691245079, -0.031939055770635605, 0.023639420047402382, -0.06024342402815819, -0.0432845838367939, 0.01351063884794712, 0.007011587731540203, 0.013426610268652439, -0.028221573680639267, -0.009049627929925919, -0.03652792051434517, -0.020345622673630714, -0.059746891260147095, -0.014376403763890266, -0.041695307940244675, 0.04591205716133118, -0.03247043117880821, -0.03912516310811043, -0.0019461954943835735, 0.007109526079148054, 0.02481909655034542, 0.040716394782066345, -0.013313467614352703, -0.04671717435121536, 0.0013816016726195812, 0.005452919751405716, -0.026215175166726112, -0.05592423304915428, 0.04767651855945587, 0.030458051711320877, -0.01051179226487875, 0.03659862279891968, -0.04971559718251228, -0.044433385133743286, 0.013547542504966259, 0.012599117122590542, 0.011825468391180038, 0.006436504889279604, -0.010358482599258423, 0.04356786236166954, 0.004834507592022419, -0.018502220511436462, 0.04975910112261772, 0.027216752991080284, -0.01299546379595995, 0.026779934763908386, -0.0753791332244873, 0.022176198661327362, -0.036887288093566895, -0.0052745891734957695, -0.06085282564163208, 0.04631993547081947, 0.003611517371609807, 0.023299632593989372, -0.011240984313189983, 0.020497165620326996, -0.023374607786536217, -0.02599967271089554, 0.01914745196700096, 0.034577224403619766, -0.04282015189528465, 0.005129305180162191, -0.009612232446670532, 0.014027547091245651, 0.015997089445590973, 0.0261902566999197, 0.008537735790014267, -0.029653400182724, 0.013054092414677143, -0.0012166680535301566, -0.04225147143006325, -0.05060771107673645, -0.03266341984272003, -0.005220993887633085, 0.03210827708244324, -0.04820134863257408, 0.03878834843635559, -0.033010635524988174, 0.037772078067064285, 0.007649009115993977, -0.01374181266874075, 0.01558583602309227, 0.019574705511331558, -0.02395028807222843, 0.05140914022922516, -0.013126405887305737, -0.005789240822196007, -0.017531059682369232, 0.01727769710123539, -0.06053059548139572, -0.0367276668548584, 0.007958095520734787, -0.031067080795764923, -0.012604345567524433, -0.03816921263933182, -0.028598129749298096, -0.004630294628441334, -0.011645126156508923, -0.043957289308309555, 0.05227268487215042, -0.003334230277687311, -0.0040670400485396385, 0.0026021122466772795, 0.040661439299583435, 0.07451899349689484, -0.010000747628509998, -0.009938369505107403, 0.03342678025364876, -0.00029435977921821177, -0.0034547399263828993, -0.01160478312522173, 0.02139045111835003, -0.027273638173937798, -0.004365579225122929, -0.005772799719125032, -0.014434504322707653, 0.03488987684249878, -0.028330931439995766, -0.06167507916688919, 0.014694423414766788, -0.041231103241443634, -0.01737281121313572, -0.061572592705488205, -0.010263477452099323, -0.008498330600559711, -0.02847718633711338, -0.0303819477558136, -0.011436733417212963, 0.004436688497662544, -0.012825218960642815, 0.0250540878623724, -0.028914891183376312, 0.012333027087152004, 0.035953473299741745, 0.02578350156545639, 0.031867124140262604, 0.017239049077033997, 0.004506049212068319, -0.02289450354874134, 0.005410275887697935, 0.02544940635561943, 0.04376322403550148, 0.03436003625392914, -0.017365720123052597, -0.013581730425357819, -0.02854672074317932, -0.09320653229951859, 0.030931808054447174, 0.06752434372901917, 0.02121582254767418, 0.02748614363372326, 0.03864206373691559, 0.005254092160612345, 0.03727918863296509, -0.03890158608555794, 0.00804314948618412, -0.01117100939154625, -0.013755952008068562, 0.026770252734422684, -0.027038976550102234, -0.054991692304611206, 0.04440047964453697, -0.010792897082865238, 0.043988946825265884, 0.05029388517141342, 0.016770128160715103, -0.0024083813186734915, 0.012671086937189102, -0.06534060090780258, -0.051413394510746, 0.05644398182630539, -0.03233174607157707, 0.030405374243855476, -0.035402633249759674, -0.033520255237817764, 0.039238519966602325, 0.07101204991340637, 0.0019043455831706524, -0.02405296452343464, 0.004545810632407665, -0.07727586477994919, 0.01374106202274561, 0.03949970379471779, -0.003098886227235198, 0.025483228266239166, -0.013357825577259064, 0.048972081393003464, 0.0014654172118753195, -0.003974386025220156, -0.016492320224642754, -0.04174225777387619, -0.029701607301831245, -0.003457857295870781, -0.020331939682364464, 0.05839627981185913, -0.0039945743046700954, -0.010709571652114391, -0.020559174939990044, -0.011328724212944508, 0.056346260011196136, -0.0006382779101841152, 0.02832140028476715, 0.013774298131465912, 0.04508201405405998, -0.014096365310251713, 0.024766864255070686, -0.02931639552116394, -0.016675567254424095, 0.12931357324123383, 0.05810276046395302, 0.04604751244187355, -0.03304921090602875, 0.028921378776431084, 0.019259387627243996, -0.03132598474621773, -0.025416884571313858, -0.0005025664577260613, -0.021073458716273308, -0.06899532675743103, -0.027599189430475235, 0.036303889006376266, 0.004246261902153492, -0.011709603480994701, 0.020731810480356216, -0.03323448449373245, -0.008458718657493591, -0.004221494309604168, -0.0070448643527925014, -0.0077003249898552895, -0.020390775054693222, -0.04089823737740517, 0.02428983524441719, -0.03992529958486557, -0.0517587810754776, -0.029260778799653053, -0.013518874533474445, -0.011493214406073093, 0.01648806408047676, 0.004468061961233616, 0.003016091650351882, 0.00764660956338048, -0.0016694074729457498, 0.039556700736284256, 0.02570745162665844, -0.013152703642845154, -0.029753291979432106, 0.02122649922966957, 0.01939776912331581, 0.004770144820213318, 0.011682679876685143, -0.00890351366251707, -0.008434279821813107, 0.003404541639611125, -0.07020028680562973, -0.03188737854361534, 0.07249850034713745, 0.0200677290558815, -0.014217657037079334, 0.010202870704233646, -0.019857754930853844, 0.0034837713465094566, -0.062397297471761703, 0.021659286692738533, -0.004598574712872505, 0.04980449378490448, -0.025810273364186287, -0.035460568964481354, 0.00755273038521409, 0.04149224981665611, -0.013439456932246685, 0.040122345089912415, 0.01846950873732567, 0.011246533133089542, 0.006993776652961969, -0.029773803427815437, 0.042718008160591125, 0.011319969780743122, -0.008386188186705112, 0.013164104893803596, -0.02034645527601242, -0.0333295501768589, -0.02198970690369606, 0.013300708495080471, -0.0026966831646859646, 0.02377227507531643, 0.00399275217205286, -0.019700517877936363, -0.012291626073420048, -0.05804072320461273, 0.002962549449875951, 0.01599125750362873, -0.023126963526010513, -0.004748636391013861, -0.006944968365132809, 0.01845613121986389, 0.03899012878537178, 0.010578087531030178, 0.026703206822276115, -0.029553798958659172, 0.028116662055253983, 0.023952210322022438, -0.045690882951021194, -0.0243210569024086, 0.019770994782447815, -0.01355744432657957, 0.019509658217430115, -0.006993657443672419, 0.02533755451440811, 0.020076673477888107, 0.03417240083217621, 0.016066893935203552, 0.04909658804535866, -0.032237205654382706, 0.00002656021388247609, -0.010610771365463734, -0.014242720790207386, 0.015927540138363838, 0.01293755043298006, -0.018067238852381706, -0.04149020463228226, -0.023853955790400505, -0.04181162267923355, -0.023982897400856018, -0.027934443205595016, -0.034870248287916183, -0.04501688480377197, -0.00880463607609272, -0.029003150761127472, -0.011730138212442398, -0.029304224997758865, 0.028317570686340332, 0.038139842450618744, 0.005155845079571009, -0.0446418821811676, 0.025547867640852928, -0.025522327050566673, 0.02056475728750229, -0.028232427313923836, -0.006956764496862888, 0.011636125855147839, -0.016716113314032555, 0.02591799385845661, -0.04357919096946716, 0.022059366106987, -0.021965691819787025, 0.039808422327041626, -0.009607547894120216, -0.005469261668622494, 0.03548334166407585, -0.05746917054057121, -0.017030369490385056, 0.012451221235096455, 0.032580479979515076, 0.0328170470893383, 0.00175760081037879, 0.010106771253049374, -0.013691714033484459, 0.02404656819999218, -0.03476475179195404, 0.019268138334155083, -0.009483265690505505, 0.011688687838613987, -0.003003337187692523, -0.0031079670879989862, 0.014735047705471516, 0.03422033041715622, 0.005018571391701698, 0.02904338389635086, 0.032414887100458145, 0.009793655946850777, 0.01551378145813942, 0.009678415954113007, -0.0411713607609272, 0.003215998876839876, 0.018790319561958313, -0.02120787464082241, 0.050334036350250244, 0.08092818409204483, 0.0069607701152563095, 0.02936813235282898, -0.024034656584262848, 0.0072668809443712234, -0.11329492181539536, -0.008487854152917862, -0.03483542054891586, 0.05273039638996124, 0.05266396701335907, -0.058854710310697556, -0.01940401829779148, 0.03915027901530266, -0.0380251482129097, 0.0486602820456028, -0.011754960753023624, 0.02826542966067791, -0.026821590960025787, 0.007101232185959816, -0.031091636046767235, 0.0106494827196002, 0.034033145755529404, 0.008527529425919056, 0.04552072286605835, 0.03433665633201599, -0.016728485003113747, -0.02745925821363926, -0.008391285315155983, 0.038455359637737274, 0.021842841058969498, -0.05000312998890877, 0.004567955620586872, -0.009973283857107162, -0.008067766204476357, 0.026446454226970673, 0.02335018292069435, 0.017908219248056412, -0.013105335645377636, 0.02967136912047863, -0.0033210625406354666, 0.03738166391849518, 0.05044417455792427, 0.011041337624192238, 0.057893797755241394, -0.011400953866541386, -0.004668150097131729, 0.004583426285535097, -0.005758803803473711, 0.009461370296776295, 0.04283127933740616, -0.013247629627585411, -0.01673341728746891, 0.014304153621196747, -0.011316092684864998, 0.0020298250019550323, 0.0064013064838945866, -0.017487704753875732, -0.03613771125674248, -0.019653096795082092, 0.02870490774512291, -0.03209396451711655, 0.007123464718461037, 0.03819015994668007, -0.005379310809075832, -0.027226155623793602, 0.005230390001088381, -0.037389710545539856, -0.06387414038181305, -0.005644206423312426, -0.026159802451729774, -0.006651405710726976, -0.019664209336042404, -0.01627032458782196, 0.0027502947486937046, 0.0003342088602948934, -0.0341358408331871, 0.0018161762272939086, -0.05772237479686737, 0.028430871665477753, 0.004840657580643892, 0.001239009783603251, -0.0034575234167277813, -0.0006298650987446308, 0.010815075598657131, -0.09225388616323471, 0.04859417676925659, -0.007670032791793346, -0.07089351862668991, -0.014625459909439087, -0.031023981049656868, -0.032436154782772064, 0.0028640099335461855, 0.052859511226415634, 0.012518862262368202, 0.009096771478652954, 0.030397219583392143, 0.011547675356268883, 0.028243638575077057, -0.02777416817843914, 0.034880027174949646, -0.023007502779364586, -0.011028780601918697, 0.004213621374219656, -0.02324281819164753, -0.008089479058980942, 0.0035110206808894873, 0.03323039412498474, -0.027208857238292694, 0.0031329800840467215, 0.007146601099520922, -0.03912588953971863, 0.001513991504907608, -0.013590843416750431, -0.02164493128657341, 0.03154416382312775, -0.015282666310667992, 0.0016988591523841023, 0.0034450909588485956, 0.005436933133751154, -0.06681865453720093, -0.027877775952219963, -0.045169346034526825, -0.058552537113428116, -0.01618151366710663, 0.0006030525546520948, 0.02180473692715168, -0.049831170588731766, 0.011365938000380993, 0.02717670612037182, -0.021671872586011887, 0.014641277492046356, 0.03392503783106804, -0.0009281868115067482, 0.005838158540427685, 0.03489028662443161, -0.004439060110598803, 0.027444766834378242, 0.03171033039689064, 0.05032852292060852, 0.005637379363179207, 0.0587431900203228, -0.03011203557252884, -0.037592656910419464, 0.044084854423999786, -0.051516901701688766, -0.002878270111978054, -0.02491341345012188, 0.03915929049253464, -0.01879226602613926, -0.04434438422322273, 0.024421319365501404, -0.0003617249021772295, -0.01399869192391634, -0.0031176526099443436, 0.008856894448399544, 0.05066778510808945, -0.019513709470629692, 0.0072518992237746716, -0.0007748435600660741, 0.005776516627520323, -0.04274355247616768, 0.051343612372875214, -0.03491031005978584, 0.018894433975219727, -0.021099360659718513, 0.018653996288776398, -0.021453017368912697, -0.025543969124555588, 0.0024693028535693884, -0.0394011065363884, 0.015400651842355728, 0.042139407247304916, 0.008499234914779663, 0.01021401397883892, -0.040868714451789856, -0.029152024537324905, -0.04833841323852539, -0.015294666402041912, -0.010896824300289154, 0.01821298338472843, -0.039268430322408676, 0.0136603694409132, -0.005643135868012905, 0.007155960891395807, -0.0517253614962101, -0.010460296645760536, -0.0239951740950346, 0.06276418268680573, 0.013516846112906933, 0.0022823410108685493 ]
<p>I have some $d$-dimensional data points ($d \ge 2$). I want map them to a circle such that locality is preserved as much as possible. </p> <p>I know that PCA only maps points to a line ($d'=1$) or a plane ($d'=2$), but I want them on a circle. </p>
36,306
[ -0.039958447217941284, -0.005421680863946676, 0.02338002622127533, -0.014337800443172455, 0.010979849845170975, -0.023114705458283424, -0.05138041079044342, 0.005052995402365923, 0.02086528390645981, -0.03440970182418823, 0.025356844067573547, 0.021236836910247803, 0.06980814784765244, 0.030070248991250992, -0.007376819849014282, -0.013678008690476418, -0.018792612478137016, -0.00436197267845273, -0.03295820206403732, -0.04361017420887947, 0.014592564664781094, 0.022535009309649467, 0.03090447187423706, -0.040156640112400055, 0.006409543100744486, 0.06749598681926727, 0.008492391556501389, -0.01442642230540514, -0.011864034458994865, 0.0924895778298378, -0.06417181342840195, -0.03158363327383995, -0.0036084260791540146, 0.06582726538181305, 0.01431827712804079, 0.01011020690202713, -0.04565611481666565, -0.010737189091742039, 0.024733208119869232, 0.03118656575679779, -0.04396576061844826, -0.03199991583824158, 0.033100008964538574, 0.0487169586122036, 0.01168691087514162, 0.02419751137495041, 0.006896095350384712, -0.01745540462434292, 0.017948152497410774, -0.033988334238529205, 0.08298692852258682, -0.014010916464030743, 0.004735645372420549, 0.017019279301166534, -0.016600338742136955, -0.008067240007221699, 0.05491442605853081, 0.07186231017112732, -0.013576660305261612, -0.05292058736085892, -0.025763731449842453, -0.028793230652809143, 0.024120217189192772, -0.03362547233700752, -0.023302780464291573, 0.008903478272259235, 0.021672448143363, 0.00995020754635334, -0.030259182676672935, -0.04162454232573509, -0.007872064597904682, 0.011954301968216896, 0.02874584123492241, -0.0242462158203125, -0.005923155229538679, 0.023858893662691116, 0.0362253412604332, 0.02874971739947796, 0.03365945443511009, 0.008272620849311352, -0.0034541180357337, 0.025711871683597565, 0.002389915520325303, -0.004455322865396738, -0.006748284678906202, 0.03946790099143982, 0.037223026156425476, -0.018948443233966827, 0.012810109183192253, 0.03310314938426018, 0.025246834382414818, -0.015184063464403152, 0.05437930300831795, -0.01835433952510357, -0.03085842728614807, -0.00803312286734581, 0.0028089999686926603, 0.04489960893988609, -0.03333296254277229, -0.010632780380547047, 0.0006599940825253725, -0.034666214138269424, -0.0023224479518830776, 0.02902437560260296, -0.019543813541531563, 0.011071768589317799, -0.0017722700722515583, -0.000028829657821916044, -0.04105166718363762, 0.006325909867882729, -0.03620431572198868, 0.01354772225022316, 0.01807774417102337, 0.022235151380300522, 0.05057290196418762, -0.00005282345227897167, -0.014879497699439526, -0.01646599732339382, 0.030335411429405212, 0.04624788090586662, 0.032016973942518234, -0.024389514699578285, 0.007222815416753292, -0.06873264163732529, -0.04680733382701874, 0.021046625450253487, 0.018520254641771317, -0.004859688226133585, -0.029263067990541458, -0.003964980132877827, 0.013268494978547096, -0.03423730656504631, 0.05654370039701462, -0.008301343768835068, 0.03075069561600685, -0.003491339972242713, -0.10563355684280396, -0.017740238457918167, 0.04521871730685234, 0.010712074115872383, 0.03488773852586746, -0.07485003024339676, 0.013138670474290848, 0.008615530095994473, 0.06115654483437538, -0.02425658330321312, 0.007009080611169338, 0.06670449674129486, 0.05773138254880905, 0.008449029177427292, -0.04439448565244675, -0.03321258723735809, -0.01372536737471819, -0.042142052203416824, -0.04908290132880211, -0.043610695749521255, 0.039528291672468185, 0.07438590377569199, -0.010725211352109909, -0.014819511212408543, 0.0363631471991539, -0.02720620296895504, 0.005382266361266375, -0.029694413766264915, -0.0011027611326426268, 0.0026235212571918964, 0.04033726453781128, 0.016081547364592552, 0.0200673695653677, -0.0060521624982357025, -0.009942788630723953, 0.047980017960071564, 0.012471570633351803, 0.036849863827228546, 0.06207239255309105, -0.0175020769238472, -0.010930752381682396, -0.009265820495784283, 0.003383245784789324, 0.03822088614106178, -0.030791660770773888, -0.03046758472919464, -0.017693324014544487, 0.017378337681293488, 0.006707272492349148, 0.05038699507713318, -0.010114874690771103, -0.019481046125292778, 0.023827580735087395, -0.02581574209034443, -0.006251780316233635, -0.07055791467428207, 0.02535988576710224, -0.0036154892295598984, -0.008095667697489262, 0.009238230995833874, 0.005237397737801075, 0.0059172348119318485, -0.02213144861161709, -0.03981449827551842, -0.020372318103909492, -0.04078902304172516, 0.06078910455107689, -0.06603673845529556, -0.01796572282910347, 0.044674500823020935, 0.0522579550743103, -0.025934407487511635, 0.017207453027367592, -0.022101525217294693, 0.026588009670376778, -0.001083454699255526, 0.011382365599274635, 0.02692868933081627, -0.029397914186120033, 0.021495722234249115, -0.031027330085635185, 0.03331524133682251, -0.04918577894568443, 0.005937647074460983, -0.02434483915567398, 0.07292457669973373, 0.05904431268572807, -0.0012202879879623652, 0.006589123979210854, -0.025478357449173927, 0.004029641393572092, -0.008889430202543736, -0.006766314152628183, -0.026761773973703384, -0.06251495331525803, -0.0007083804230205715, 0.06158735230565071, 0.0551164373755455, -0.044622670859098434, -0.002616660203784704, 0.06281715631484985, 0.07563240081071854, 0.0005709514953196049, 0.0035898343194276094, -0.03801549971103668, -0.016000356525182724, 0.004306315444409847, 0.011445323936641216, -0.006449775770306587, -0.03945670649409294, 0.01947556622326374, -0.010402302257716656, 0.034434378147125244, 0.017706649377942085, -0.00866386666893959, 0.02200821414589882, -0.034747518599033356, -0.015030392445623875, -0.008701725862920284, 0.00963096134364605, 0.05136142671108246, 0.001192564144730568, -0.014782849699258804, 0.032540611922740936, 0.00455964170396328, -0.010253914631903172, -0.007991914637386799, -0.03288252651691437, 0.03320002928376198, 0.06318631023168564, -0.04260125756263733, 0.011944402009248734, 0.026271415874361992, -0.02368788793683052, 0.016966404393315315, -0.017490500584244728, -0.014459510333836079, -0.020916437730193138, 0.0545867420732975, 0.07729871571063995, 0.006537499837577343, 0.009755119681358337, -0.04072186350822449, -0.04064645245671272, -0.017249125987291336, -0.012451930902898312, 0.021431660279631615, 0.0576837956905365, -0.059461627155542374, -0.000722057418897748, -0.01433663908392191, 0.025008931756019592, -0.009923651814460754, 0.0007535205804742873, 0.013152983039617538, 0.003214859403669834, -0.020606553182005882, -0.04128308966755867, -0.0015884342137724161, -0.03353733941912651, 0.03382554650306702, -0.0487840436398983, -0.014271986670792103, 0.034652404487133026, 0.036021795123815536, -0.04264626279473305, -0.009777992032468319, -0.005330002401024103, 0.00945198629051447, -0.003153903177008033, -0.022312622517347336, 0.037478454411029816, -0.02629007399082184, 0.015070180408656597, 0.021288443356752396, -0.002113638911396265, 0.011568517424166203, -0.04751576855778694, -0.058744508773088455, 0.02808075211942196, -0.00006694925832562149, 0.028328590095043182, 0.009828224778175354, -0.01639358513057232, 0.06576350331306458, 0.02156563475728035, -0.06221306324005127, -0.020465685054659843, -0.004154492169618607, -0.0677579939365387, -0.021553227677941322, -0.008107337169349194, 0.0033309669233858585, 0.021216517314314842, 0.0038121624384075403, 0.0077979676425457, 0.013136755675077438, 0.08662412315607071, 0.035125140100717545, -0.06448513269424438, 0.03134386986494064, 0.009790400043129921, -0.0020227127242833376, 0.006303754169493914, 0.031137553974986076, -0.04296967759728432, -0.005732678808271885, 0.012504173442721367, -0.013678442686796188, 0.010733287781476974, -0.030971741303801537, -0.013829050585627556, -0.055476486682891846, 0.02648485079407692, -0.027669943869113922, -0.00586770661175251, 0.018680129200220108, -0.029881291091442108, -0.011924325488507748, 0.03316851705312729, 0.04417257383465767, -0.01990196853876114, -0.005622696131467819, 0.03093874640762806, 0.022432856261730194, 0.020070530474185944, 0.024510396644473076, 0.006157807540148497, 0.019888535141944885, 0.027121499180793762, -0.009697635658085346, 0.026027951389551163, 0.027670523151755333, 0.008873425424098969, 0.0017758077010512352, 0.052262984216213226, -0.04734636843204498, 0.038513630628585815, -0.05199950560927391, 0.036912951618433, -0.01601998694241047, 0.044070277363061905, 0.005545622669160366, 0.021956805139780045, 0.0467175655066967, -0.037096694111824036, -0.02086356095969677, 0.0073889498598873615, -0.06218040734529495, -0.03269325569272041, -0.0020606571342796087, 0.026326127350330353, 0.015062922611832619, 0.00030208626412786543, 0.034636083990335464, 0.0016994101461023092, 0.009840494953095913, 0.030185798183083534, 0.0007793687400408089, -0.029182324185967445, 0.01086921151727438, -0.005227784160524607, -0.020912040024995804, -0.04979695752263069, 0.06352608650922775, 0.0681915357708931, -0.01826952025294304, 0.04135080426931381, 0.031710609793663025, -0.02936696819961071, -0.00817438866943121, -0.01631992682814598, 0.012357641942799091, 0.03393316641449928, 0.04228890687227249, -0.030326073989272118, 0.025351203978061676, 0.007224961183965206, 0.00006964959902688861, -0.012428002431988716, 0.029694750905036926, 0.01728646643459797, -0.009728169068694115, 0.022019490599632263, -0.06098264828324318, -0.03436847776174545, 0.008789781481027603, 0.06211259216070175, -0.024093329906463623, 0.014637171290814877, 0.025506069883704185, 0.012897982262074947, -0.08016172796487808, -0.01203243900090456, 0.06721749156713486, 0.006238288711756468, -0.014264197088778019, -0.020396828651428223, -0.05696854740381241, 0.02528560347855091, 0.0029721760656684637, 0.03598761931061745, -0.04187021031975746, -0.022378357127308846, -0.0319821797311306, 0.012906434945762157, 0.010413910262286663, -0.03265881538391113, -0.01715720072388649, -0.005805179942399263, 0.02849285677075386, -0.027682393789291382, -0.003402915084734559, 0.01923627406358719, 0.01259082555770874, 0.025846445932984352, 0.03868646174669266, 0.011563130654394627, -0.07114505022764206, 0.00044119227095507085, 0.023644236847758293, 0.050187814980745316, 0.045053642243146896, -0.03936019539833069, -0.07295369356870651, -0.03257254883646965, 0.050860483199357986, -0.04088404402136803, 0.008581345900893211, -0.007460579741746187, -0.019620759412646294, -0.05383313074707985, -0.03891832381486893, -0.05559215694665909, -0.005766598042100668, -0.0023115440271794796, 0.03668857365846634, -0.043861083686351776, -0.0553065650165081, -0.061503954231739044, 0.0034274000208824873, 0.007054263725876808, 0.05493909865617752, 0.03191441297531128, -0.0074037774465978146, -0.022247716784477234, 0.02891487255692482, 0.0044728415086865425, -0.0387691892683506, 0.02781646139919758, 0.049363259226083755, -0.005740172695368528, 0.058100052177906036, -0.038773778825998306, -0.040649544447660446, 0.0043649072758853436, -0.04414215311408043, 0.004818140994757414, 0.008321990258991718, -0.003048090497031808, 0.06850016117095947, -0.005783150903880596, 0.00625914242118597, 0.06677526235580444, 0.001954203238710761, 0.020666994154453278, -0.019849680364131927, -0.03423256799578667, 0.024164967238903046, 0.0028335009701550007, 0.005983441602438688, -0.034409988671541214, 0.0015250546857714653, -0.013656745664775372, 0.007926753722131252, 0.01774251088500023, 0.025285590440034866, -0.02016756869852543, -0.02446078509092331, -0.017006946727633476, 0.07091696560382843, -0.002509162062779069, 0.010267113335430622, -0.00845630094408989, 0.024707991629838943, 0.019571427255868912, -0.016618357971310616, 0.04657449945807457, -0.016041819006204605, -0.01624435931444168, 0.018478577956557274, -0.02251019887626171, -0.012434338219463825, -0.06501275300979614, -0.03608007729053497, -0.005334633402526379, -0.05769564211368561, 0.03490797057747841, -0.022883795201778412, 0.027813095599412918, 0.035615768283605576, -0.08513570576906204, 0.0323348194360733, -0.013356073759496212, 0.0016142145032063127, 0.028732826933264732, -0.05568369850516319, -0.000583230284973979, -0.031089847907423973, 0.030121155083179474, -0.06707801669836044, -0.07124540209770203, -0.00736763421446085, 0.0015475151594728231, -0.019745375961065292, -0.06225399300456047, -0.006922389380633831, -0.01135339681059122, -0.010902329348027706, -0.02291540801525116, 0.05698806419968605, -0.02357187494635582, 0.013158565387129784, 0.017804402858018875, 0.00997068453580141, 0.07388357818126678, -0.039482854306697845, -0.009884621016681194, 0.007211304735392332, -0.02353188768029213, 0.00200852332636714, -0.02009640447795391, 0.03802989795804024, -0.0626690536737442, -0.01658346690237522, -0.0414343923330307, 0.026152709499001503, 0.022928478196263313, 0.0014725190121680498, -0.0076713524758815765, -0.010867775417864323, -0.05030028894543648, -0.02084832265973091, -0.013158231042325497, -0.046649105846881866, -0.02481134422123432, -0.03097185492515564, -0.04066479951143265, 0.015161439776420593, 0.0013959372881799936, 0.01979464665055275, 0.004381279461085796, 0.04402030631899834, -0.0034964499063789845, 0.0155324162915349, 0.029957598075270653, -0.005427991040050983, 0.01436412800103426, -0.011560776270925999, -0.04820546880364418, 0.02988065779209137, -0.009489626623690128, -0.0034470229875296354, -0.00583786703646183, -0.0019611259922385216, -0.06126478686928749, -0.03261417895555496, -0.042419612407684326, -0.01454662624746561, 0.043649833649396896, 0.04523439332842827, 0.0747925341129303, 0.049444761127233505, 0.007077877409756184, 0.00934242457151413, -0.01949157565832138, 0.0015521462773904204, 0.027418315410614014, -0.014177560806274414, 0.059039611369371414, 0.016517741605639458, -0.023533005267381668, -0.002460646675899625, 0.05236908048391342, 0.02546507492661476, 0.02940155379474163, -0.0010396011639386415, -0.019325563684105873, 0.019183460623025894, -0.03442046791315079, -0.03678513690829277, 0.027719279751181602, -0.052727650851011276, 0.022106515243649483, 0.009096179157495499, -0.03995697572827339, 0.059276945888996124, 0.002623726148158312, 0.005225654691457748, -0.0251466017216444, -0.025207271799445152, -0.047782640904188156, -0.0017167533515021205, 0.011349763721227646, 0.007955190725624561, -0.008381757885217667, -0.01911863312125206, 0.022097943350672722, -0.014348208904266357, 0.0017433062894269824, -0.019091784954071045, -0.034601129591464996, -0.03253253176808357, -0.003879753639921546, -0.01745450496673584, 0.006798495072871447, 0.02546839602291584, -0.04950222373008728, 0.037304848432540894, -0.03521159291267395, 0.0387546606361866, 0.0008573671220801771, 0.030675534158945084, 0.01258693914860487, 0.05132010579109192, 0.021110324189066887, -0.00043011351954191923, 0.0014835844049230218, -0.014246572740375996, 0.11840774863958359, 0.04753107205033302, 0.02812638320028782, -0.09610264003276825, 0.05851833522319794, -0.0035148896276950836, 0.008805446326732635, -0.0548957921564579, 0.012986722402274609, -0.008214880712330341, 0.001724065514281392, 0.0398232601583004, 0.03732724487781525, 0.03253421187400818, 0.02496284246444702, 0.056903913617134094, -0.049543485045433044, -0.015182464383542538, 0.01075288187712431, -0.015782183036208153, -0.011207381263375282, 0.006500013638287783, -0.024394331499934196, 0.02214392088353634, -0.02000952884554863, -0.04964941367506981, -0.03564247488975525, -0.018714044243097305, 0.018411999568343163, -0.030499709770083427, -0.03955788537859917, -0.001416043029166758, 0.002343788743019104, -0.0032110160682350397, -0.020046409219503403, 0.0025059450417757034, -0.01447694655507803, -0.013797853142023087, 0.01809871755540371, 0.00713481567800045, -0.010307054035365582, 0.026878999546170235, 0.004229141864925623, -0.009543328545987606, -0.021138422191143036, -0.041836097836494446, -0.033719900995492935, 0.058353226631879807, -0.0410587377846241, 0.006655387580394745, 0.009538629092276096, 0.02160528115928173, 0.001254906295798719, -0.0743340253829956, -0.004609363153576851, 0.015088342130184174, 0.03558329865336418, 0.029454737901687622, -0.014380531385540962, -0.023870009928941727, 0.031715236604213715, -0.01345723308622837, 0.03309344872832298, -0.015009511262178421, -0.023741157725453377, -0.0038158034440129995, 0.0026095726061612368, 0.06550704687833786, 0.025683825835585594, 0.01854969747364521, -0.006431101355701685, -0.0021040930878371, -0.01664486899971962, -0.04232722148299217, -0.005763723514974117, -0.028995631262660027, 0.034475281834602356, 0.0006298694061115384, -0.026113102212548256, 0.007482239510864019, -0.016668975353240967, -0.015234610065817833, -0.03765794634819031, -0.016163822263479233, -0.023931104689836502, 0.014129617251455784, 0.03547137975692749, 0.049803413450717926, 0.03004494495689869, -0.019299201667308807, -0.049636658281087875, 0.047770123928785324, 0.03608304262161255, -0.004999218974262476, 0.01655312068760395, -0.010297461412847042, -0.04309041053056717, 0.026091163977980614, -0.015807336196303368, 0.04243628680706024, 0.04947631061077118, -0.01113115157932043, 0.012390256859362125, 0.05943739414215088, -0.009823045693337917, 0.00458483025431633, 0.006390589289367199, -0.06403865665197372, 0.021230226382613182, 0.0021206976380199194, 0.0015408736653625965, -0.03682709112763405, 0.002476150169968605, -0.03840942680835724, -0.01075330562889576, -0.02806791663169861, -0.009035024791955948, -0.007354779168963432, 0.00265744561329484, -0.02344859391450882, 0.03385576233267784, -0.013791525736451149, 0.006663277745246887, -0.010073408484458923, 0.02338477410376072, 0.0004852468555327505, -0.0034481859765946865, -0.013803062960505486, 0.0065875183790922165, 0.012953509576618671, 0.013833282515406609, 0.032678961753845215, 0.0034509492106735706, 0.014258932322263718, 0.026462512090802193, 0.01969163306057453, 0.01811947114765644, 0.05789199471473694, -0.027818648144602776, -0.03557981550693512, 0.03486908599734306, -0.048361167311668396, -0.018029730767011642, 0.028306206688284874, -0.03162360563874245, 0.056422341614961624, 0.015484626404941082, 0.005002711899578571, -0.009079954586923122, 0.02372162602841854, -0.008791912347078323, -0.05112830176949501, 0.02503012679517269, 0.01867084950208664, 0.041722990572452545, 0.007419111207127571, 0.02108549140393734, -0.028205689042806625, -0.014205453917384148, 0.02369125559926033, 0.030716683715581894, 0.0025613773614168167, 0.0012737832730636, 0.017015881836414337, -0.022777067497372627, 0.015521625988185406, 0.017456041648983955, 0.02694481611251831, 0.05376594141125679, 0.024769935756921768, -0.03777190297842026, -0.001665553660131991, -0.017520993947982788, 0.007635041140019894, -0.10556821525096893, -0.0066786836832761765, -0.008227660320699215, -0.0005160023574717343, 0.04260149970650673, -0.07992855459451675, 0.0048021054826676846, 0.049488212913274765, -0.07453657686710358, 0.039584431797266006, 0.002812316408380866, -0.02040807530283928, -0.03327047824859619, -0.0008164393366314471, -0.026496928185224533, 0.016127560287714005, 0.009256423451006413, 0.0634022206068039, 0.030870303511619568, 0.03028823435306549, -0.02149735391139984, -0.019731873646378517, 0.004531369544565678, 0.028303997591137886, -0.0105741573497653, -0.031472597271203995, 0.05080118775367737, -0.02680237591266632, -0.008236654102802277, -0.001861459924839437, -0.027848243713378906, -0.028254203498363495, 0.02332303859293461, 0.010268892161548138, 0.008086130023002625, 0.0204854067414999, 0.021674785763025284, 0.005815683864057064, -0.024216337129473686, -0.027761230245232582, 0.021546781063079834, 0.03125082328915596, -0.026210416108369827, 0.0255991593003273, 0.023660924285650253, -0.004231234081089497, -0.01353988703340292, 0.0076447888277471066, -0.008646274916827679, -0.012100813910365105, -0.0019649711903184652, -0.003648012410849333, 0.004233371466398239, -0.02766479179263115, 0.006413673982024193, -0.014764471910893917, 0.0006755956565029919, 0.02945723570883274, -0.03228284791111946, 0.000901706051081419, 0.003782451618462801, 0.01672445796430111, -0.054791178554296494, 0.02662649191915989, 0.022874819114804268, 0.003810695605352521, -0.04435674101114273, -0.035842105746269226, 0.04313729703426361, -0.030734160915017128, -0.0020609621424227953, -0.029803195968270302, -0.014578673057258129, 0.014902006834745407, 0.016190240159630775, 0.0021086588967591524, -0.006708313245326281, 0.0013357428833842278, -0.0010294009698554873, -0.04529040679335594, 0.032936252653598785, 0.0014190248912200332, -0.01665232889354229, -0.011553231626749039, -0.009559174999594688, -0.019347142428159714, 0.02768958918750286, 0.011965704150497913, 0.022208496928215027, 0.019169490784406662, -0.0017150766216218472, 0.004243612289428711, 0.01704590395092964, -0.027754046022892, 0.02849431149661541, -0.047643281519412994, 0.0024783159606158733, -0.022196967154741287, -0.031008023768663406, -0.023607846349477768, 0.0294604804366827, 0.019530728459358215, 0.010777744464576244, 0.022769110277295113, 0.009871109388768673, -0.04646633192896843, 0.03276209533214569, -0.008654430508613586, 0.00932968407869339, 0.05558197572827339, 0.05891583487391472, 0.0049746292643249035, 0.019420770928263664, 0.0021565293427556753, -0.01372683234512806, 0.019587205722928047, -0.04025179520249367, -0.05039162188768387, -0.00018294365145266056, 0.05258600041270256, 0.0006363234715536237, -0.023052960634231567, 0.0395803339779377, 0.026890095323324203, -0.024042269214987755, -0.013270013965666294, 0.02125684544444084, 0.010847336612641811, 0.04247279092669487, 0.001638987334445119, 0.012389065697789192, 0.008324136957526207, 0.02116400934755802, 0.019282789900898933, -0.0007308932254090905, 0.011487818323075771, 0.00041122143738903105, 0.017156871035695076, 0.002606513909995556, -0.0073287468403577805, 0.022552814334630966, -0.02904643677175045, 0.06607221066951752, -0.030077176168560982, 0.006176607683300972, 0.03502187877893448, -0.02242875099182129, 0.019338367506861687, -0.02716657891869545, -0.026655159890651703, 0.050132181495428085, -0.026051905006170273, -0.0012899445137009025, -0.04179218411445618, -0.03184325248003006, -0.02458946779370308, 0.013049582950770855, -0.00581043167039752, 0.06403087824583054, -0.014070047996938229, 0.02699020318686962, -0.01007867231965065, -0.015329904854297638, 0.01127875316888094, -0.04571966826915741, 0.01906573958694935, 0.02799823321402073, 0.035682421177625656, 0.004602080211043358, 0.008588132448494434, 0.0015803108690306544, -0.02041618339717388, -0.0010478537296876311, 0.04746696352958679, 0.02801402099430561, -0.003165213158354163, 0.015603815205395222, 0.018847275525331497, 0.039392441511154175, -0.09498216211795807, -0.031956933438777924, -0.036341968923807144, 0.012272768653929234, -0.004127530846744776, 0.004110129550099373 ]
<p>I'm wondering how to fit multivariate linear mixed model and finding multivariate BLUP in R. I'd appreciate if someone come up with example and R code. Thanks</p> <p><strong>Edit</strong></p> <p>I wonder how to fit multivariate linear mixed model with <code>lme4</code>. I fitted univariate linear mixed models with the following code:</p> <pre><code>library(lme4) lmer.m1 &lt;- lmer(Y1~A*B+(1|Block)+(1|Block:A), data=Data) summary(lmer.m1) anova(lmer.m1) lmer.m2 &lt;- lmer(Y2~A*B+(1|Block)+(1|Block:A), data=Data) summary(lmer.m2) anova(lmer.m2) </code></pre> <p>I'd like to know how to fit multivariate linear mixed model with <code>lme4</code>. The data is below:</p> <pre><code>Block A B Y1 Y2 1 1 1 135.8 121.6 1 1 2 149.4 142.5 1 1 3 155.4 145.0 1 2 1 105.9 106.6 1 2 2 112.9 119.2 1 2 3 121.6 126.7 2 1 1 121.9 133.5 2 1 2 136.5 146.1 2 1 3 145.8 154.0 2 2 1 102.1 116.0 2 2 2 112.0 121.3 2 2 3 114.6 137.3 3 1 1 133.4 132.4 3 1 2 139.1 141.8 3 1 3 157.3 156.1 3 2 1 101.2 89.0 3 2 2 109.8 104.6 3 2 3 111.0 107.7 4 1 1 124.9 133.4 4 1 2 140.3 147.7 4 1 3 147.1 157.7 4 2 1 110.5 99.1 4 2 2 117.7 100.9 4 2 3 129.5 116.2 </code></pre> <p>Thank in advance for your time and cooperation.</p>
16,787
[ -0.019452497363090515, -0.0018942173337563872, 0.032962165772914886, -0.005334943998605013, 0.060127951204776764, -0.005618090275675058, 0.007768808864057064, -0.024832066148519516, 0.037886764854192734, -0.034275300800800323, 0.04768412932753563, 0.05576394125819206, 0.05155400559306145, -0.007557154633104801, 0.037324611097574234, -0.014545590616762638, 0.011247236281633377, 0.013900313526391983, 0.030266739428043365, -0.009383263066411018, -0.008389163762331009, -0.023814167827367783, 0.019356103613972664, -0.012522272765636444, -0.021141257137060165, 0.048029810190200806, 0.014704062603414059, -0.025760773569345474, 0.010936284437775612, 0.04081737622618675, -0.02473503351211548, -0.06927988678216934, 0.01390982698649168, 0.01860009878873825, -0.015565718524158001, 0.003574748756363988, -0.011758035980165005, -0.004585464019328356, -0.0007012119167484343, 0.014129321090877056, -0.00988082867115736, -0.005867437459528446, -0.005100153852254152, 0.017469385638833046, 0.019440924748778343, 0.019489048048853874, -0.005471698474138975, 0.016268959268927574, 0.060277365148067474, -0.01266485545784235, 0.07229524105787277, -0.02087923139333725, 0.057714324444532394, 0.002859663451090455, -0.05063258856534958, 0.011848061345517635, 0.049260273575782776, 0.06724271178245544, 0.029619533568620682, -0.0748293399810791, -0.013154524378478527, -0.02704749070107937, 0.04905858263373375, -0.03178006783127785, -0.04293321073055267, 0.018842529505491257, 0.03620501980185509, -0.015526923350989819, 0.022308088839054108, -0.0006231067236512899, 0.04973653331398964, 0.00806194357573986, 0.05679471418261528, -0.02646205574274063, 0.03963274136185646, -0.02908000722527504, -0.011152636259794235, 0.0018940665759146214, 0.009899327531456947, 0.007019807118922472, -0.02497960440814495, 0.04080589488148689, 0.005758910905569792, 0.0031436216086149216, 0.024365531280636787, 0.0013007995439693332, 0.0559689886868, 0.00783089641481638, 0.026861289516091347, 0.009979705326259136, -0.006659809034317732, 0.005883799400180578, 0.05491287633776665, 0.041872672736644745, -0.01807245798408985, 0.047469612210989, -0.003073693485930562, 0.034222036600112915, 0.03438694775104523, -0.014597959816455841, -0.00040910873212851584, -0.03132854774594307, 0.023578351363539696, 0.069703608751297, 0.02016545459628105, 0.03575211390852928, -0.01239798404276371, 0.013481575064361095, 0.009028319269418716, -0.005172146484255791, -0.0007970732403919101, 0.04027492552995682, -0.014268160797655582, -0.03255343809723854, 0.019464438781142235, -0.03631872311234474, -0.031662579625844955, -0.005465363617986441, 0.05728838965296745, 0.019065147265791893, 0.023244701325893402, -0.04359946399927139, 0.011923879384994507, -0.009792734868824482, -0.03656446188688278, -0.029591932892799377, -0.009414729662239552, -0.017029449343681335, -0.04694916307926178, 0.05544646084308624, 0.02447984181344509, -0.023633522912859917, 0.004924212582409382, 0.03447234630584717, 0.02395145781338215, -0.019511057063937187, -0.051422521471977234, -0.07992265373468399, 0.005141004454344511, -0.02690284326672554, 0.037723660469055176, -0.04910237714648247, 0.005970146972686052, -0.003304458921775222, 0.06679181754589081, -0.005625081714242697, 0.022026505321264267, 0.02132488042116165, 0.004542103968560696, 0.0019895602017641068, -0.023965615779161453, 0.02876627817749977, -0.036402154713869095, -0.008275979198515415, 0.009605071507394314, -0.11093809455633163, 0.0032549211755394936, -0.02046322636306286, -0.046865690499544144, 0.01644841767847538, 0.02952534891664982, 0.013169710524380207, -0.021497873589396477, -0.02942710369825363, -0.01988675631582737, -0.012379641644656658, 0.07203780859708786, -0.05054169520735741, 0.02262718975543976, 0.021533207967877388, -0.024813057854771614, 0.014679519459605217, -0.014367172494530678, 0.03852696716785431, 0.029450181871652603, -0.02100875787436962, 0.01933332346379757, 0.02413093112409115, 0.015372054651379585, 0.052812494337558746, -0.07890541851520538, -0.05076107010245323, -0.05213973671197891, -0.02481548674404621, 0.02031688392162323, 0.05511647090315819, 0.00057132204528898, 0.007976758293807507, 0.07620977610349655, -0.016676710918545723, -0.01921306736767292, -0.0513511523604393, -0.04485562816262245, 0.003134970087558031, -0.008185411803424358, -0.010892471298575401, -0.01846846379339695, -0.006549878977239132, 0.024039460346102715, -0.02308608591556549, 0.00028696126537397504, -0.006562311667948961, 0.05310456082224846, -0.0011372946901246905, 0.0022517764009535313, -0.00803434755653143, 0.041688960045576096, -0.025413310155272484, 0.04617589712142944, -0.021422909572720528, 0.018725233152508736, -0.008766097947955132, -0.05231701582670212, -0.018152562901377678, 0.0023009893484413624, -0.013756331987679005, -0.005593647714704275, 0.004466446116566658, -0.020693471655249596, 0.022741856053471565, -0.05252012982964516, 0.04628024250268936, 0.05380317568778992, 0.00018786282453220338, -0.012042742222547531, 0.01311283279210329, -0.008384662680327892, 0.04328297823667526, -0.04865003749728203, 0.004050176590681076, -0.035955674946308136, -0.02683665044605732, 0.047530416399240494, -0.01974780298769474, -0.034140460193157196, 0.02960410714149475, 0.01704895682632923, -0.02436853013932705, -0.0031865774653851986, 0.03240180015563965, -0.021005727350711823, -0.01533076073974371, 0.028128575533628464, 0.004360123537480831, -0.017820358276367188, 0.01753869466483593, 0.019703321158885956, 0.004671778995543718, 0.055083148181438446, -0.01826607622206211, -0.009727180935442448, 0.00724219623953104, 0.02567235939204693, -0.02177486941218376, -0.05280548334121704, -0.03162955492734909, 0.08405996859073639, -0.021061770617961884, 0.0011057091178372502, 0.055257074534893036, -0.001232946990057826, 0.017409957945346832, -0.01585368812084198, -0.035260654985904694, 0.025027399882674217, 0.04287637397646904, -0.010672477073967457, -0.011761118657886982, 0.029817139729857445, -0.044514767825603485, 0.050405945628881454, 0.0038096618372946978, -0.011976415291428566, -0.015404910780489445, 0.015062086284160614, -0.01927989348769188, 0.011854251846671104, -0.013630358502268791, -0.03772231563925743, -0.025122186169028282, -0.006410627625882626, 0.004270714242011309, 0.05035269632935524, -0.03703499212861061, -0.03806318715214729, 0.003804984502494335, -0.031107131391763687, 0.028499463573098183, -0.0033929916098713875, 0.01633692905306816, -0.028479866683483124, 0.05451183393597603, -0.006010046228766441, -0.03462977334856987, -0.04113197699189186, 0.013199804350733757, 0.026622910052537918, -0.01712971366941929, 0.0052041057497262955, 0.02171790786087513, 0.013533727265894413, -0.0354849211871624, 0.015648270025849342, -0.05859346315264702, -0.00448218546807766, 0.00029152666684240103, -0.0018665557727217674, 0.019259024411439896, 0.046766024082899094, 0.025393640622496605, 0.01631549932062626, 0.008992329239845276, -0.024688532575964928, -0.05247778072953224, -0.013624361716210842, -0.013957515358924866, 0.01424822211265564, 0.009338002651929855, 0.012183984741568565, -0.028606824576854706, 0.07319261133670807, 0.0241536982357502, -0.026795227080583572, -0.07997161895036697, -0.0006599425687454641, 0.012426663190126419, 0.001596675836481154, 0.050882864743471146, 0.020717674866318703, -0.002812830964103341, 0.0021141935139894485, 0.003630452323704958, 0.018058035522699356, 0.05226947367191315, 0.03115067444741726, 0.009686560370028019, 0.022918803617358208, -0.01668349839746952, -0.016859620809555054, -0.022522851824760437, 0.007315916009247303, 0.011683303862810135, 0.02845992147922516, 0.004979134537279606, 0.017219465225934982, -0.017563696950674057, -0.041669655591249466, -0.0025846995413303375, -0.02454882115125656, 0.010716856457293034, -0.04210539162158966, 0.011742598377168179, 0.0013541773660108447, -0.04866105690598488, 0.010959767736494541, -0.0017031504539772868, 0.05141407251358032, 0.005527092609554529, 0.020545771345496178, 0.07021107524633408, 0.042533375322818756, -0.02752162702381611, 0.024078471586108208, -0.002199463779106736, -0.015051650814712048, 0.040123265236616135, -0.04095581918954849, 0.025843754410743713, 0.005836104042828083, 0.04324524849653244, -0.021039217710494995, 0.01681436225771904, -0.022218827158212662, 0.004094164352864027, -0.04958188533782959, 0.01572847180068493, -0.011032883077859879, 0.034862667322158813, 0.0012900849105790257, 0.03487211838364601, -0.0012253217864781618, -0.02240786887705326, 0.01893961988389492, -0.021622100844979286, -0.02451598457992077, 0.0305752195417881, 0.010763321071863174, 0.003937724977731705, 0.006205370649695396, -0.02149043045938015, 0.00034858559956774116, -0.055093053728342056, 0.03086358681321144, -0.017499877139925957, 0.01144738681614399, 0.011062088422477245, 0.015426062978804111, -0.010088755749166012, -0.017344193533062935, -0.04693400114774704, 0.030800310894846916, 0.029726563021540642, 0.01261154469102621, 0.013428493402898312, 0.019255654886364937, -0.010730953887104988, -0.01696266420185566, -0.013339967466890812, -0.026336517184972763, 0.017239082604646683, 0.012979297898709774, 0.002063548658043146, 0.027367612347006798, -0.008780425414443016, 0.008099968545138836, 0.0064962622709572315, 0.04194485396146774, 0.023558981716632843, 0.0059223780408501625, 0.010054186917841434, -0.012461092323064804, 0.0055846162140369415, -0.0112752765417099, -0.014410966075956821, 0.009889240376651287, -0.01958903670310974, 0.03355693444609642, 0.037038903683423996, -0.024397598579525948, 0.019945872947573662, 0.07128860801458359, 0.025656795129179955, 0.03343290090560913, -0.02913656458258629, 0.009847584180533886, -0.011246749199926853, 0.02761870063841343, 0.015670472756028175, 0.00016049046826083213, 0.015690553933382034, -0.002750782063230872, 0.030871808528900146, -0.002192595973610878, -0.014684083871543407, -0.018828943371772766, 0.03233319893479347, 0.049308259040117264, -0.02052592858672142, -0.0643986240029335, -0.03252333402633667, 0.04038505628705025, 0.01251467876136303, -0.001523737097159028, 0.02114478498697281, -0.09805282950401306, 0.026040824130177498, 0.02787850610911846, 0.07115410268306732, -0.00966512132436037, 0.009714699350297451, -0.01832704432308674, -0.029658246785402298, 0.001753453747369349, 0.021981317549943924, 0.05319194868206978, 0.02074948512017727, 0.009341669268906116, -0.013273634016513824, -0.03359305486083031, -0.05837603658437729, -0.00022052372514735907, -0.012448581866919994, -0.022148480638861656, -0.027462506666779518, -0.04672219604253769, -0.0030192635022103786, 0.0038348687812685966, -0.009426341392099857, 0.010433560237288475, -0.04173776134848595, -0.0036215127911418676, 0.0057723671197891235, 0.020949887111783028, -0.018992971628904343, 0.00031643459806218743, 0.04869730770587921, -0.007884793914854527, -0.01797403022646904, 0.053914014250040054, -0.025397570803761482, -0.030580798164010048, 0.06086941435933113, 0.0034798700362443924, 0.03272983059287071, 0.019144905731081963, 0.012261084280908108, 0.01652224361896515, 0.022057436406612396, 0.0485566183924675, 0.044666681438684464, 0.02317308448255062, -0.0033272753935307264, 0.02368343621492386, -0.09045011550188065, 0.0007099579088389874, 0.03185749053955078, -0.08345513045787811, -0.05711399018764496, -0.037353597581386566, -0.013425319455564022, 0.022662023082375526, -0.0036347745917737484, 0.03441790118813515, -0.052900541573762894, -0.04318259283900261, 0.02237473428249359, 0.007103112060576677, -0.025701913982629776, -0.01604747585952282, 0.004194564186036587, -0.01760173588991165, 0.003278791904449463, -0.0022734063677489758, -0.003101196838542819, -0.018905851989984512, -0.002278495579957962, 0.0072389752604067326, -0.0007559345103800297, -0.006880313158035278, 0.004210774786770344, -0.016602490097284317, 0.0030644447542726994, 0.00427491357550025, 0.008285998366773129, 0.012538621202111244, -0.011445989832282066, -0.02597050741314888, -0.05195675045251846, 0.006600304041057825, 0.03681172803044319, -0.0162778589874506, 0.037338536232709885, -0.017075853422284126, 0.0343654528260231, -0.012129433453083038, -0.04960767552256584, -0.040598832070827484, -0.041721656918525696, 0.01245026383548975, -0.006496698595583439, -0.013480449095368385, -0.07278299331665039, -0.034204721450805664, -0.045721106231212616, -0.0198298841714859, 0.01210397481918335, 0.03697861358523369, -0.013315579853951931, 0.031167875975370407, -0.02206815779209137, -0.025674806907773018, 0.039460379630327225, 0.00012076168059138581, -0.009023028425872326, -0.010903814807534218, -0.00867268443107605, -0.0028334336820989847, 0.0012606820091605186, -0.006322239059954882, -0.03808224946260452, 0.011144152842462063, -0.009322197176516056, -0.015372475609183311, 0.062127165496349335, 0.005634290166199207, -0.037491630762815475, 0.01649433933198452, -0.006719966419041157, 0.009171697311103344, -0.0795360580086708, -0.02203817293047905, 0.0009354836074635386, 0.016515139490365982, -0.06325773149728775, 0.022374555468559265, -0.004083067644387484, -0.01958378590643406, 0.007486572954803705, -0.05939187854528427, -0.0272709671407938, -0.028078632429242134, 0.06728971004486084, -0.005906389560550451, 0.018257033079862595, -0.03107561729848385, -0.005412125028669834, 0.027605120092630386, 0.007052245084196329, -0.0023261364549398422, 0.01604049652814865, 0.024057472124695778, -0.036280568689107895, -0.015380664728581905, -0.020184816792607307, 0.015729371458292007, 0.04500087723135948, 0.026103856042027473, 0.026863649487495422, 0.06120370328426361, -0.021514063701033592, 0.030691755935549736, -0.03953969478607178, -0.042744290083646774, 0.02450486645102501, 0.016956906765699387, 0.10346125811338425, 0.012294887565076351, -0.01643257960677147, 0.05032555013895035, -0.006900630425661802, 0.0311227198690176, 0.04098762199282646, 0.0009674217435531318, 0.0033359022345393896, 0.017314521595835686, 0.01867699809372425, -0.018060391768813133, 0.03671852871775627, -0.038068097084760666, 0.004180341958999634, -0.033729188144207, -0.03469791263341904, 0.03807070851325989, 0.04398336261510849, 0.00008234025881392881, -0.04375012218952179, -0.013658332638442516, -0.05651756376028061, -0.0029824955854564905, 0.040356654673814774, -0.014805469661951065, 0.03586896136403084, 0.016051124781370163, 0.04943150654435158, 0.029035095125436783, 0.04002128541469574, -0.030271878466010094, -0.07654285430908203, -0.026928922161459923, -0.0028410458471626043, -0.007265121676027775, 0.03955242037773132, -0.020367180928587914, 0.0033035913947969675, 0.010307975113391876, -0.027427805587649345, 0.01934655010700226, -0.026852257549762726, 0.060932181775569916, -0.035393718630075455, 0.04043426364660263, -0.0236751027405262, 0.033781927078962326, -0.018015824258327484, -0.016678454354405403, 0.1323677897453308, 0.07716595381498337, 0.029338134452700615, -0.09777764976024628, 0.06307215988636017, 0.02774914726614952, -0.028991952538490295, -0.016433093696832657, -0.012492614798247814, -0.0008838819921948016, -0.029734570533037186, 0.04689152166247368, 0.06219450384378433, 0.04052194952964783, 0.00877597089856863, 0.018561389297246933, 0.022430717945098877, -0.013200008310377598, -0.0055577741004526615, 0.011650157161056995, -0.03789065033197403, 0.015878019854426384, -0.06258733570575714, -0.0038853976875543594, -0.00518335634842515, -0.039262112230062485, -0.02687188982963562, -0.012628196738660336, 0.015294685959815979, 0.013421093113720417, -0.008298399858176708, 0.03821852058172226, -0.0022028698585927486, -0.01687862165272236, 0.00481461314484477, 0.02673591859638691, 0.023983797058463097, -0.02703266032040119, 0.02816871739923954, 0.04639564827084541, 0.004832163918763399, 0.026313411071896553, -0.04378461465239525, 0.017884697765111923, -0.022348560392856598, -0.011012551374733448, -0.00900873914361, 0.022900057956576347, 0.00546062970533967, -0.059117693454027176, 0.009889473207294941, -0.0034805950708687305, 0.007328417617827654, 0.017553890123963356, 0.013276943936944008, 0.03422630578279495, 0.025675315409898758, -0.019552377983927727, 0.009437895379960537, -0.02911662869155407, -0.0015720821684226394, -0.003431984456256032, 0.009119180962443352, 0.01327522937208414, -0.038469329476356506, -0.001811003079637885, -0.02166329324245453, 0.05159495025873184, 0.014729861170053482, 0.00974430050700903, -0.007884278893470764, 0.010011032223701477, -0.003068242920562625, -0.04623621702194214, 0.04524799436330795, 0.0061309137381613255, 0.004323948174715042, 0.01646350510418415, -0.02450639382004738, -0.044407956302165985, -0.035728391259908676, 0.012848537415266037, -0.012686090543866158, -0.03470897674560547, -0.029350731521844864, -0.0004195698711555451, 0.01029992289841175, 0.056957390159368515, -0.020604554563760757, -0.025284435600042343, -0.031074682250618935, 0.0712541937828064, 0.02704741805791855, -0.07056649774312973, -0.024069687351584435, -0.00010608539014356211, -0.019876353442668915, -0.04173162579536438, -0.024343393743038177, 0.028531888499855995, 0.026055216789245605, 0.007269032299518585, -0.0161303523927927, 0.046190761029720306, -0.04493691027164459, -0.01879582740366459, -0.006400475278496742, -0.04721848666667938, 0.005063960328698158, -0.0036272001452744007, -0.02866649441421032, 0.0023992217611521482, 0.011923225596547127, -0.03063816949725151, -0.0403253547847271, 0.004768728278577328, -0.02891644462943077, -0.022786423563957214, -0.0004003747890237719, 0.004602083005011082, -0.029476577416062355, -0.029055623337626457, 0.0228576622903347, 0.0025087078101933002, -0.0167843010276556, 0.0012971252435818315, 0.0028731569182127714, -0.0020661165472120047, -0.018474729731678963, -0.01403104979544878, 0.016004081815481186, 0.04735979437828064, 0.026616623625159264, 0.022423401474952698, -0.007050795014947653, 0.027171673253178596, 0.008434967137873173, 0.05970790982246399, 0.024773312732577324, 0.012923161499202251, -0.010832279920578003, -0.043449874967336655, -0.026908177882432938, 0.0020175573881715536, -0.014340097084641457, 0.006502285599708557, 0.006543374620378017, -0.006887845695018768, -0.017337560653686523, 0.0677126869559288, -0.01213749311864376, 0.006012099329382181, -0.04356750473380089, 0.00490246107801795, 0.022684035822749138, 0.009361671283841133, 0.026240458711981773, 0.014556577429175377, -0.02387108840048313, 0.03975784406065941, 0.0016088971169665456, -0.021576879546046257, 0.01609501801431179, 0.008303872309625149, -0.03555058315396309, 0.048245079815387726, 0.0055309319868683815, -0.02909511886537075, 0.05642898008227348, 0.020142726600170135, -0.016375292092561722, 0.04384389519691467, -0.0425511971116066, -0.028411230072379112, -0.07597970962524414, -0.0500650517642498, -0.009503748267889023, -0.024237390607595444, 0.020844653248786926, -0.031195737421512604, 0.024071941152215004, 0.08128093928098679, -0.04689483717083931, -0.037133052945137024, 0.0032864937093108892, 0.004440764896571636, -0.004157457035034895, 0.00791944656521082, -0.04708943888545036, -0.02839360386133194, -0.0024827260058373213, 0.002623994369059801, 0.03452017530798912, 0.01820262521505356, 0.029418129473924637, -0.019682882353663445, 0.015058984979987144, -0.012726917862892151, 0.05284219607710838, -0.0850774496793747, 0.0425887256860733, -0.03653454780578613, -0.035771116614341736, 0.027004031464457512, -0.02989937923848629, 0.032287076115608215, 0.019461186602711678, 0.024900250136852264, 0.0034885958302766085, 0.07991430163383484, 0.0024942602030932903, 0.03336955979466438, 0.008582470007240772, -0.02452896535396576, 0.013104232028126717, -0.006834660656750202, -0.030450914055109024, 0.03673024848103523, 0.021928584203124046, 0.03327859193086624, -0.04881155490875244, -0.025628460571169853, -0.01978614367544651, -0.018342483788728714, -0.013458783738315105, -0.02775168977677822, -0.0058615547604858875, -0.04045899212360382, -0.025530660524964333, -0.03226208686828613, 0.00808105617761612, 0.05723237991333008, 0.055711597204208374, -0.007294394541531801, -0.01375448890030384, -0.045292098075151443, -0.014815956354141235, -0.006482658442109823, 0.016685474663972855, -0.03159623593091965, -0.027714798226952553, -0.017689835280179977, 0.013765565119683743, -0.022085553035140038, -0.037387944757938385, 0.022503171116113663, -0.021729320287704468, 0.016285760328173637, -0.0023124786093831062, -0.017508847638964653, -0.00890261773020029, 0.010244806297123432, 0.02645450457930565, -0.1134839653968811, 0.036780983209609985, 0.0013832154218107462, -0.008723129518330097, -0.06604143977165222, 0.03987516462802887, -0.021302400156855583, 0.007740728557109833, 0.06799653172492981, 0.032746754586696625, 0.04452250525355339, 0.013246778398752213, 0.02658274583518505, 0.007329255808144808, -0.05303142964839935, 0.05543365702033043, 0.024924226105213165, 0.0147419897839427, -0.013645591214299202, -0.003313482506200671, 0.001772504998371005, 0.0077917445451021194, -0.0155728654935956, -0.018915724009275436, -0.015947997570037842, -0.0053253816440701485, -0.008221040479838848, 0.015274951234459877, 0.013997210189700127, -0.058851029723882675, 0.031100796535611153, -0.01191020105034113, -0.014346824027597904, 0.03860300034284592, 0.00872117280960083, -0.07205028831958771, -0.011441904120147228, -0.008195118047297001, 0.03624528646469116, -0.02460668794810772, -0.02359943836927414, 0.020725172013044357, -0.08057048171758652, 0.045040979981422424, -0.004013299476355314, 0.010064707137644291, -0.02022506110370159, 0.04473823681473732, 0.0229408647865057, 0.027902202680706978, 0.011651268228888512, 0.020940789952874184, -0.03285584971308708, -0.04148687794804573, 0.02095615118741989, 0.0033518674317747355, 0.033224545419216156, -0.016338743269443512, 0.016734039410948753, 0.025257933884859085, 0.01743713580071926, 0.03236379474401474, -0.03840237483382225, 0.08329185843467712, 0.04101434722542763, -0.024580731987953186, 0.021519215777516365, -0.026893969625234604, 0.04212825000286102, 0.03345155343413353, -0.031113779172301292, 0.0424363911151886, -0.104759581387043, 0.007321559824049473, -0.03107772208750248, -0.04546128213405609, -0.01017443835735321, 0.021914782002568245, 0.01858331449329853, 0.0007287099142558873, 0.00664531160145998, 0.02753298170864582, -0.00767657533288002, -0.04394856467843056, 0.03032960742712021, 0.022847803309559822, 0.0005500994739122689, -0.010542331263422966, 0.005996666848659515, -0.002179898088797927, -0.018582196906208992, -0.03514343127608299, -0.045253854244947433, 0.023361027240753174, 0.02037191577255726, -0.0032733615953475237, -0.04486604407429695, -0.03325866162776947, 0.00674185436218977, 0.03704505041241646, -0.05838891118764877, -0.03055643104016781, -0.02077247016131878, -0.009045731276273727, -0.009227952919900417, -0.017269177362322807 ]
<p>Modularity: I understand that modularity is supposed to represent sophistication of structure on a macro level, but what does it mean on the individual level? </p> <p>Page Rank: I'm dealing with a dataset of people asking questions and answering questions. If someone answers a question, the arrow is drawn from the person who asked the question to the person who answered the question. If an individual has a high page rank value in this situation, what does that mean?</p> <p>Force Atlas 2: I have no idea how this works compared to the other layout algorithms.</p>
73,808
[ -0.004461394622921944, -0.013375497423112392, -0.020708683878183365, -0.004427899606525898, 0.027337079867720604, 0.02635534480214119, -0.0009060102747753263, -0.00962749496102333, 0.021533504128456116, -0.04030696302652359, 0.01690986193716526, -0.007747616618871689, 0.03921612724661827, 0.006865748204290867, 0.01641818694770336, -0.02230030857026577, 0.02755799889564514, -0.00011621123121585697, 0.006650158204138279, 0.027736030519008636, 0.0029889249708503485, 0.010690990835428238, 0.02072191797196865, 0.02214106172323227, -0.004553078208118677, 0.08120235800743103, 0.014208421111106873, -0.036666177213191986, -0.011482772417366505, 0.0411478653550148, -0.06078946962952614, -0.0029736950527876616, -0.006108775734901428, 0.005867491941899061, 0.028444763273000717, -0.021325163543224335, -0.01383662037551403, -0.035890571773052216, -0.0017930339090526104, 0.0019426047801971436, -0.013105597347021103, 0.002765578916296363, -0.04934217780828476, 0.02885456569492817, -0.015779787674546242, 0.03968692570924759, -0.029068535193800926, 0.0013290715869516134, 0.0007237745448946953, -0.04857927933335304, 0.06381846964359283, 0.03848234936594963, 0.005284064915031195, 0.038445428013801575, -0.024674667045474052, -0.013950503431260586, 0.024477535858750343, 0.05291298031806946, 0.007539308629930019, -0.0656929537653923, -0.034839779138565063, 0.007502428721636534, -0.0032202377915382385, -0.02451138012111187, -0.024329742416739464, 0.07690142095088959, -0.02189680188894272, -0.011578635312616825, 0.04424673318862915, -0.004804941359907389, -0.01962745189666748, 0.01841704733669758, 0.04086998850107193, -0.07054191082715988, 0.019496267661452293, -0.03431200981140137, 0.0027425535954535007, 0.012682359665632248, 0.017521070316433907, 0.036261316388845444, 0.005217838566750288, -0.011361553333699703, -0.02611316554248333, 0.023020200431346893, 0.0013603486586362123, -0.0169955063611269, 0.09439141303300858, -0.037799350917339325, -0.017545128241181374, 0.005424485541880131, -0.009505783207714558, -0.01079182792454958, 0.04324189946055412, 0.013372569344937801, -0.04046594351530075, 0.010429151356220245, 0.005544302519410849, 0.0028678053058683872, 0.020985931158065796, 0.0010745713952928782, -0.02894480712711811, -0.022472407668828964, -0.010719616897404194, 0.027210870757699013, 0.026560107246041298, 0.025228893384337425, -0.01601790450513363, -0.004472643136978149, -0.02059207297861576, 0.03851734474301338, -0.018701378256082535, -0.0096054058521986, -0.029116448014974594, 0.02694583684206009, 0.013628806918859482, -0.05470786616206169, -0.013633963651955128, -0.010393884032964706, 0.022265003994107246, 0.08575165271759033, 0.03254272788763046, -0.007496476639062166, 0.031666360795497894, -0.007344671990722418, -0.07353846728801727, 0.004733421839773655, 0.029587522149086, -0.04697277024388313, -0.04123925045132637, 0.059948794543743134, 0.007365502417087555, 0.00673218397423625, -0.006804018747061491, -0.021633220836520195, 0.0030706797260791063, 0.04016480594873428, -0.10153106600046158, -0.07950935512781143, 0.06282052397727966, 0.010710484348237514, 0.0017051115864887834, -0.023245012387633324, 0.032661810517311096, 0.026319589465856552, 0.03596547991037369, 0.02183855138719082, 0.011062674224376678, 0.014656627550721169, 0.022259175777435303, -0.014487174339592457, -0.03598218411207199, 0.006364285014569759, -0.028981726616621017, -0.012551612220704556, -0.013028807938098907, -0.06489629298448563, 0.0034358419943600893, 0.01875038631260395, -0.015246148221194744, -0.02638065814971924, 0.05044608190655708, -0.009500195272266865, 0.005224164575338364, -0.02852102369070053, -0.047223757952451706, 0.0002321627107448876, 0.05147968977689743, -0.005496216472238302, 0.052867818623781204, 0.037201929837465286, 0.004357618745416403, 0.020631281659007072, -0.010506529361009598, 0.013880659826099873, 0.052258577197790146, 0.006224147975444794, -0.026885170489549637, -0.001144208712503314, -0.026162613183259964, -0.003977724350988865, -0.04854708909988403, -0.0978776291012764, -0.00840506050735712, 0.025151792913675308, 0.017499927431344986, 0.018371161073446274, 0.011726419441401958, 0.007505213376134634, 0.07301946729421616, 0.00845401268452406, -0.04174567013978958, -0.12646886706352234, 0.028119679540395737, -0.021361809223890305, 0.008939458057284355, 0.013079731725156307, 0.01000720914453268, -0.012685040943324566, -0.007834361866116524, -0.01406443677842617, -0.029287083074450493, 0.029743855819106102, 0.018250735476613045, -0.015163852833211422, -0.008498886600136757, 0.06917715817689896, -0.02224874310195446, -0.04361351951956749, 0.04131602495908737, -0.05626853555440903, -0.0441497266292572, 0.03475453332066536, -0.02570316009223461, 0.043519873172044754, -0.04831051081418991, 0.010929988697171211, 0.02223913185298443, 0.030991772189736366, -0.02564101852476597, 0.004094548989087343, -0.030581170693039894, 0.07288642972707748, 0.06691702455282211, 0.02182830683887005, 0.027399638667702675, 0.008307860232889652, -0.0006155063747428358, 0.006936673074960709, 0.0023499035742133856, 0.009861609898507595, -0.0653420090675354, -0.0322466678917408, 0.040059663355350494, -0.019450807943940163, 0.007019379176199436, 0.03928418830037117, 0.03287187218666077, 0.04387766495347023, 0.02496570348739624, -0.007969946600496769, -0.009438020177185535, 0.012055063620209694, 0.012620131485164165, 0.026289738714694977, 0.04466305673122406, 0.005421966779977083, -0.0012183518847450614, 0.01417472679167986, 0.027602113783359528, 0.011460247449576855, 0.017317377030849457, 0.050764117389917374, 0.04000692442059517, -0.02145172655582428, -0.02025241032242775, -0.014990272931754589, 0.07258548587560654, 0.015982449054718018, 0.019541507586836815, 0.0459921658039093, 0.009965992532670498, 0.0008982701692730188, -0.06903257220983505, -0.06514599174261093, -0.011732004582881927, 0.053864408284425735, -0.0047974009066820145, -0.010265431366860867, 0.03343024477362633, -0.04360106587409973, 0.042471643537282944, 0.0010467171669006348, -0.00843177642673254, -0.0371008962392807, 0.014824124053120613, 0.05806351453065872, -0.01109861396253109, 0.06487367302179337, -0.06561526656150818, 0.006728459615260363, 0.03847075626254082, -0.0261743925511837, 0.025088462978601456, -0.009455759078264236, -0.0633210763335228, -0.019192054867744446, -0.020382311195135117, -0.01480660680681467, 0.006900741718709469, 0.03993798792362213, 0.0030524989124387503, 0.03632097318768501, 0.0062868655659258366, -0.04161563888192177, -0.0418715626001358, -0.018768401816487312, 0.05039265751838684, -0.011623726226389408, -0.0257733091711998, 0.03289081156253815, -0.020588837563991547, -0.018432077020406723, 0.020102927461266518, -0.017513969913125038, 0.0012806961312890053, 0.010035722516477108, -0.010230674408376217, 0.0016081768553704023, 0.005647809244692326, -0.03472596034407616, 0.05141732469201088, -0.004625726956874132, -0.014574767090380192, -0.04848435893654823, -0.05946166068315506, -0.0015179598703980446, -0.02686547301709652, 0.024418143555521965, 0.02898295409977436, -0.008461385034024715, 0.07552231103181839, 0.02282932586967945, -0.056094732135534286, -0.053919050842523575, -0.024279365316033363, -0.007525634951889515, -0.0497179739177227, 0.03746958449482918, -0.005503480788320303, -0.004444383084774017, -0.009680490009486675, 0.042699702084064484, 0.05587128549814224, 0.04197912663221359, -0.00878357794135809, -0.028518306091427803, 0.005824882537126541, 0.022361626848578453, -0.05163407325744629, 0.033845141530036926, -0.006054431665688753, -0.022457197308540344, 0.05022759735584259, -0.017994487658143044, 0.0070008402690291405, 0.024795951321721077, -0.012324532493948936, 0.00779614457860589, -0.03545146808028221, -0.015698475763201714, -0.051575079560279846, 0.028906311839818954, -0.014875289984047413, -0.02489163912832737, -0.021198386326432228, 0.01970083825290203, 0.02057643234729767, -0.03808418661355972, -0.016069894656538963, 0.005667649209499359, 0.013798179104924202, -0.017023738473653793, 0.0042607709765434265, -0.024440212175250053, -0.00013271717762108892, 0.008257051929831505, -0.02599146030843258, -0.013843970373272896, 0.06154267117381096, 0.06908436864614487, -0.00505640497431159, 0.0473516620695591, -0.05296191945672035, -0.019772034138441086, -0.08335284143686295, 0.003877822542563081, -0.05965592712163925, 0.05287981405854225, -0.017103487625718117, 0.047070953994989395, 0.00685472134500742, 0.0385681577026844, 0.004079518839716911, 0.0049150860868394375, -0.07498445361852646, 0.026070041581988335, -0.02702322043478489, 0.01586925983428955, 0.023203225806355476, -0.009655538946390152, 0.058708492666482925, -0.006877649109810591, -0.05079038068652153, -0.004246034659445286, 0.04848015308380127, -0.010293668136000633, 0.019677309319376945, -0.01771230436861515, -0.029322028160095215, 0.004693158436566591, 0.001732876873575151, 0.013413088396191597, -0.028889387845993042, 0.05702638253569603, 0.03241391107439995, 0.0035708975046873093, -0.03016785718500614, -0.004219467751681805, -0.0010583032853901386, -0.017175892367959023, 0.03412269055843353, -0.0021369028836488724, 0.019870053976774216, -0.01888914592564106, 0.010330463759601116, 0.007197094149887562, 0.05264577269554138, 0.016480185091495514, 0.02043142355978489, 0.014775184914469719, -0.036214374005794525, -0.0389217771589756, -0.016523439437150955, -0.013357128947973251, -0.005931903142482042, 0.01947050914168358, 0.03648903965950012, 0.029942993074655533, -0.05585964396595955, 0.008801877498626709, 0.05396422743797302, 0.018732015043497086, -0.04348519816994667, -0.054603081196546555, -0.02560976892709732, 0.011449628509581089, -0.024806521832942963, 0.03911728784441948, -0.028615541756153107, 0.007644238881766796, 0.03194115683436394, -0.013441866263747215, -0.05289347097277641, -0.04962492361664772, 0.024429209530353546, -0.003920258488506079, 0.008474815636873245, -0.0014656877610832453, 0.015890879556536674, 0.001014886423945427, 0.016681596636772156, 0.07103535532951355, 0.014735489152371883, -0.016473665833473206, -0.07946821302175522, 0.021503126248717308, 0.05370931699872017, 0.0658867135643959, -0.04378613457083702, -0.019472528249025345, -0.037755511701107025, -0.031060073524713516, 0.017263637855648994, -0.039335258305072784, 0.029605038464069366, -0.02495221607387066, -0.0015003344742581248, -0.05691679194569588, 0.007234214339405298, -0.020056018605828285, 0.010332747362554073, 0.0067330715246498585, 0.0525510199368, -0.01249001082032919, -0.013798903673887253, -0.056082602590322495, 0.016980690881609917, 0.0037539536133408546, -0.013026522472500801, -0.03234246373176575, 0.022923313081264496, -0.014290479011833668, 0.02522006630897522, -0.057628143578767776, -0.08057373762130737, 0.00914999283850193, 0.026695160195231438, -0.015730027109384537, 0.027177464216947556, -0.006521853152662516, -0.03640943765640259, 0.03228965774178505, 0.006207448896020651, -0.0035865826066583395, -0.029686635360121727, 0.013137801550328732, 0.05870368704199791, 0.05654910206794739, 0.004779741633683443, 0.03562334552407265, 0.022226206958293915, -0.009125138632953167, -0.033342473208904266, 0.007376588881015778, 0.00292846467345953, -0.01805458590388298, 0.026956073939800262, -0.02238198183476925, -0.009834440425038338, -0.04238206520676613, 0.02506704442203045, -0.01066519133746624, 0.02856864221394062, -0.035929083824157715, -0.022228874266147614, -0.01583385467529297, 0.031557053327560425, 0.03154740855097771, -0.008653881028294563, 0.053172893822193146, 0.03219302371144295, 0.00697921309620142, -0.025881366804242134, 0.029034141451120377, -0.03301398456096649, 0.0038199254777282476, -0.008617028594017029, -0.0054336972534656525, 0.000005382101790019078, -0.005572826601564884, 0.012891250662505627, -0.00037244599661789834, -0.019930841401219368, 0.06982656568288803, 0.0034925087820738554, 0.006359763443470001, 0.04391489177942276, -0.035581331700086594, -0.033448148518800735, 0.015588853508234024, -0.0140636982396245, 0.0179413091391325, 0.013077267445623875, 0.059275973588228226, -0.037418365478515625, -0.02050480619072914, -0.012017601169645786, -0.027656126767396927, 0.03519030660390854, 0.03255464509129524, -0.03715880960226059, -0.029381291940808296, -0.0004741585289593786, -0.0012461345177143812, -0.06051480397582054, -0.01834515668451786, 0.04796554148197174, -0.04749593883752823, -0.014046960510313511, 0.03876516595482826, 0.00553764495998621, 0.05609201267361641, 0.023088602349162102, 0.001050206832587719, -0.005286256317049265, -0.0014825406251475215, 0.0048550767824053764, -0.017625678330659866, 0.027483131736516953, -0.0277339369058609, -0.009492980316281319, -0.027651190757751465, 0.02337642014026642, 0.026414887979626656, -0.02692381851375103, 0.012629315257072449, -0.012660397216677666, -0.015549859032034874, -0.005905237048864365, 0.007831282913684845, 0.013879171572625637, 0.007000574376434088, 0.034986238926649094, -0.014128907583653927, 0.050664231181144714, 0.012621469795703888, -0.026894325390458107, 0.010808167979121208, 0.00894781481474638, 0.01838359422981739, 0.022633064538240433, 0.053437646478414536, -0.038515638560056686, 0.036225419491529465, 0.040214527398347855, -0.031025223433971405, 0.051101334393024445, -0.0027533064130693674, 0.021393662318587303, -0.02572767436504364, 0.026544103398919106, -0.055277906358242035, -0.021078886464238167, -0.001573829329572618, -0.012659863568842411, 0.05865898355841637, -0.018486090004444122, 0.00926107820123434, 0.06950291991233826, -0.04869043454527855, 0.037459492683410645, 0.026345130056142807, -0.04511253163218498, -0.023351160809397697, 0.017267046496272087, 0.04983864724636078, -0.053081806749105453, -0.02933480218052864, 0.032322175800800323, 0.03836130350828171, -0.0010643876157701015, -0.024262091144919395, 0.03700673580169678, 0.02392924576997757, 0.000635902804788202, -0.054843392223119736, -0.04956188052892685, 0.05284908041357994, -0.01560688205063343, -0.009842648170888424, -0.02660209685564041, -0.0076901777647435665, 0.05266869068145752, 0.03666118532419205, -0.005244165193289518, -0.03786894306540489, -0.017621969804167747, -0.0369994193315506, 0.0036706039682030678, 0.020435838028788567, -0.003570481901988387, 0.00008862788672558963, -0.011660420335829258, 0.05797828361392021, -0.026763826608657837, -0.00545519171282649, 0.005706805270165205, -0.08020707219839096, -0.043238457292318344, -0.01539985928684473, -0.05271744355559349, 0.03696605935692787, -0.006672787480056286, -0.015977952629327774, 0.06268270313739777, -0.03169756010174751, 0.022562090307474136, 0.027049778029322624, 0.06296879053115845, -0.015573031269013882, 0.04717401787638664, -0.011182637885212898, 0.017176367342472076, -0.03817833587527275, -0.011631893925368786, 0.11152142286300659, 0.07859843224287033, 0.03194431960582733, -0.04999484121799469, 0.021833572536706924, -0.012803182937204838, -0.02188822813332081, -0.012343807145953178, 0.006625920534133911, -0.0066057052463293076, 0.012430216185748577, 0.035509414970874786, 0.04435158520936966, 0.04410025477409363, 0.020090559497475624, 0.030432844534516335, -0.0643279030919075, -0.07017695158720016, -0.01269465684890747, -0.022904932498931885, -0.03716615214943886, 0.008687124587595463, -0.06503637880086899, 0.013263317756354809, 0.04069291055202484, -0.015478177927434444, -0.01448937226086855, -0.055986616760492325, 0.027476513758301735, -0.0043432689271867275, -0.004531601443886757, 0.011055165901780128, -0.01068420335650444, -0.004383208695799112, -0.011089781299233437, 0.045903269201517105, -0.008311745710670948, 0.0012247300473973155, 0.03555820509791374, 0.053948722779750824, -0.0008834087639115751, -0.010701573453843594, -0.008159062825143337, 0.007605098187923431, -0.05142459273338318, -0.022530682384967804, -0.025242647156119347, 0.036314792931079865, -0.01803256757557392, -0.008828524500131607, -0.0038432315923273563, 0.02329384908080101, 0.01019980013370514, -0.02051657997071743, -0.008686274290084839, 0.016693567857146263, 0.0038570098113268614, -0.033209428191185, -0.026164554059505463, -0.06020158529281616, 0.03251354768872261, -0.030450018122792244, -0.02314615808427334, 0.028843803331255913, 0.015811072662472725, -0.0068190451711416245, -0.023861495777964592, 0.06094545125961304, -0.012325792573392391, -0.011044269427657127, -0.020493371412158012, -0.006468114443123341, -0.03698766231536865, 0.0074803088791668415, -0.006382281892001629, 0.029820986092090607, 0.009913165122270584, -0.0012684010434895754, 0.011673382483422756, -0.040072470903396606, 0.002739877672865987, 0.019710106775164604, 0.0012022578157484531, 0.02735842578113079, -0.03987693786621094, 0.031278979033231735, 0.05869889259338379, 0.01677715964615345, 0.015724407508969307, 0.00865279883146286, -0.003143292386084795, 0.031141141429543495, -0.015225118026137352, -0.040391601622104645, -0.024742519482970238, 0.006693039555102587, -0.02193284034729004, -0.008520432747900486, 0.004157000686973333, 0.02723209373652935, 0.005541165824979544, -0.03880742937326431, 0.004818318877369165, 0.0329250693321228, -0.006274031940847635, 0.003058514790609479, 0.016247253865003586, -0.06330867111682892, 0.016429807990789413, 0.007759583182632923, -0.0032870627474039793, -0.060458146035671234, -0.04036521911621094, 0.011101674288511276, -0.017359444871544838, 0.010180000215768814, 0.0293203666806221, 0.0006109949317760766, -0.009407567791640759, -0.006983509752899408, 0.043129462748765945, -0.039609022438526154, -0.014985866844654083, -0.04166680946946144, -0.011553211137652397, -0.012948285788297653, -0.0001319942093687132, 0.013328156433999538, 0.0057725561782717705, -0.00805506482720375, 0.011073499917984009, 0.01843847706913948, 0.0002444986021146178, 0.00993021484464407, -0.011368067003786564, -0.013335154391825199, 0.0199863500893116, -0.002390835667029023, -0.00022843183251097798, -0.04539111256599426, 0.030887069180607796, -0.009460845962166786, -0.05602887645363808, 0.029079632833600044, -0.023258965462446213, 0.0292391125112772, -0.010499352589249611, -0.04271233081817627, 0.017953863367438316, 0.0409851148724556, -0.013799193315207958, -0.033639904111623764, 0.004632363561540842, 0.010206680744886398, -0.015335537493228912, 0.005340130068361759, 0.0010904637165367603, 0.011247096583247185, -0.017668141052126884, 0.013016406446695328, 0.01792868599295616, -0.032956451177597046, -0.028626874089241028, 0.020786704495549202, 0.026667464524507523, 0.00018444475426804274, -0.01636117696762085, 0.033380329608917236, 0.020866472274065018, 0.016900204122066498, -0.029847797006368637, 0.010097119025886059, 0.003191610099747777, -0.012404855340719223, -0.005885409191250801, -0.0020143166184425354, -0.0022603189572691917, 0.0096939317882061, 0.02436020039021969, -0.06453271955251694, -0.0005710174445994198, 0.016039568930864334, -0.043069276958703995, 0.0344824343919754, -0.0029453299939632416, -0.0297005046159029, -0.03203234449028969, 0.03747612610459328, 0.0034524223301559687, 0.06902839988470078, 0.015168603509664536, 0.01780349761247635, 0.01067890040576458, 0.022561825811862946, 0.010827649384737015, -0.036702875047922134, -0.033407390117645264, 0.04260515421628952, -0.023177487775683403, -0.04804041236639023, 0.02052914723753929, -0.005552095826715231, -0.06091794744133949, 0.027570556849241257, -0.008769442327320576, 0.012210284359753132, 0.05182398110628128, -0.011961206793785095, -0.014246108010411263, 0.030900822952389717, 0.02995911054313183, 0.005905471742153168, -0.0551285482943058, 0.006898661144077778, -0.016873231157660484, 0.0069571444764733315, 0.0077596260234713554, 0.0338410846889019, 0.033796392381191254, 0.008232677355408669, 0.03479276970028877, 0.03457361087203026, -0.05046889930963516, -0.031113099306821823, 0.000991267617791891, -0.02911502495408058, 0.017607182264328003, -0.016668640077114105, 0.025910403579473495, -0.0025904783979058266, -0.008330382406711578, 0.027193346992135048, -0.010177317075431347, 0.0062896013259887695, 0.034847620874643326, -0.014663361944258213, 0.011839848943054676, 0.026315508410334587, 0.0322277694940567, -0.028831876814365387, -0.041582778096199036, 0.01117874588817358, 0.004542370326817036, 0.022620851173996925, 0.013976993039250374, -0.04200632497668266, -0.0054908376187086105, 0.03246333822607994, 0.01788668893277645, 0.00681892829015851, -0.0031548175029456615, -0.01047644391655922, 0.0018133545527234674, -0.04966450482606888, 0.0405760332942009, 0.047644540667533875, 0.009041708894073963, -0.021721092984080315, 0.01569078303873539, -0.038200780749320984, 0.05723587051033974, 0.05968852713704109, -0.012358974665403366, 0.018467899411916733, -0.04700467362999916, 0.0037769614718854427, 0.005545790772885084, -0.050198670476675034, 0.03165605664253235, -0.016933603212237358, -0.026444733142852783, 0.003167394082993269, -0.03209546580910683, 0.015728861093521118, 0.008749273605644703, 0.036664996296167374, 0.012202850542962551, 0.0008056459482759237, -0.04233315959572792, -0.009720228612422943, 0.014941977337002754, 0.008854994550347328, -0.02366769313812256, 0.08247625827789307, 0.03919140622019768, 0.025394335389137268, 0.010406091809272766, -0.032888222485780716, -0.0035835271701216698, 0.039299026131629944, -0.05286611616611481, -0.028736410662531853, -0.021106213331222534, 0.011815907433629036, 0.024191828444600105, -0.06524725258350372, 0.015022295527160168, 0.0002001202228711918, -0.03797915577888489, 0.019854197278618813, 0.059649985283613205, 0.03021468222141266, -0.0025288809556514025, 0.003058265894651413, 0.0009673579479567707, 0.033244457095861435, -0.01808340661227703, -0.012375461868941784, 0.016296150162816048, 0.05158909782767296, -0.011988616548478603, 0.011158847250044346, 0.04474147781729698, -0.004126294050365686, 0.013656159862875938, -0.04095110669732094, 0.042082931846380234, -0.029978904873132706, -0.018110470846295357, 0.011847290210425854, -0.030056189745664597, 0.0013760882429778576, 0.028038162738084793, -0.011826605536043644, 0.0680060014128685, -0.022673143073916435, 0.011495204642415047, -0.026505809277296066, -0.02164064534008503, -0.05040512606501579, 0.0038998716045171022, 0.022021489217877388, 0.05565165355801582, 0.008333221077919006, -0.0006497836438938975, -0.03576817736029625, -0.011674109846353531, 0.029973385855555534, -0.014070732519030571, 0.0025968246627599, -0.016164464876055717, -0.01212066225707531, 0.02487592212855816, 0.002877748105674982, -0.03957373648881912, -0.007678591646254063, 0.03523707389831543, 0.01848697103559971, 0.007794532924890518, -0.011649332009255886, -0.019960932433605194, 0.005025036167353392, 0.025730185210704803, -0.05042559280991554, -0.020773516967892647, -0.06254018843173981, 0.007433600723743439, -0.035311535000801086, 0.021610615774989128 ]
<p>I am a complete newbie in statistical modeling and I never got the opportunity to learn how to express a model in algebraic form and its respective matrix notation. I know how to define models in R code, but I do not understand how to write it in mathematic form, e.g. with β as the vector of a fixed effect. I am trying to find good literature on this topic, but have a hard time finding any. Does anyone know where can I learn this? Sorry if this is a basic and maybe inappropriate question here, and something that I should probably have learned long ago. However I have not had the need to use any "advanced" models until now.</p> <p>As an example, I have a longitudinal dataset of biomass from an experiment. The subjects have been exposed of 3 different treatments (LOW, MED, HI) during 200 days, and measured repeatedly at 40 occasions. I have constructed a linear mixed model in R, with lme (from nlme package), with a autocorrelation structure (AR1) and a random intercept and slope:</p> <pre><code>Biomass.lme&lt;-lme(Biomass~Treatment*Day,random=~Day|Subject,data=longterm, na.action=na.exclude,corr=corAR1(form=~Day|Flask)) </code></pre> <p>Where Treatment is a factor and Day continuous variable. Hence, I am interested to see if the responses of the groups is dependent on the exposure time (i.e. the interaction of treatment and time).</p> <p>I would be happy if someone could explain to me how this model would look in algebraic form and why, or provide me with some information on how to do express model.</p>
73,809
[ -0.032583143562078476, -0.0030193324200809, -0.008508621715009212, -0.005586707033216953, 0.01236684713512659, -0.0014027341967448592, -0.013762901537120342, -0.006382787600159645, 0.051033321768045425, -0.024837562814354897, 0.03203759342432022, 0.03667096793651581, 0.0905575305223465, -0.008118623867630959, 0.019026095047593117, -0.01776549033820629, -0.01965491473674774, -0.00948441680520773, -0.03025742433965206, 0.0004253594088368118, 0.0037604731041938066, 0.009083010256290436, 0.012604914605617523, -0.012490416876971722, 0.003435685997828841, 0.07869578152894974, 0.03396926820278168, -0.002894492819905281, -0.015426991507411003, 0.029391253367066383, -0.022089144214987755, -0.07621599733829498, 0.0014260869938880205, -0.011482500471174717, -0.01687082275748253, -0.01063646748661995, -0.015028956346213818, -0.02624112367630005, -0.0031665111891925335, 0.04624182730913162, -0.035264573991298676, -0.029152967035770416, -0.00713049340993166, 0.032260309904813766, -0.04092543199658394, 0.020133698359131813, -0.01602519489824772, -0.011915091425180435, 0.0680578276515007, -0.015151552855968475, 0.10253062099218369, 0.00848943181335926, 0.044716157019138336, 0.014361266046762466, 0.007937329821288586, 0.004230924881994724, 0.0344877615571022, 0.04792533069849014, 0.019224019721150398, -0.03965776786208153, -0.02947714552283287, -0.02592325583100319, 0.0022214760538190603, 0.0009177606552839279, -0.0029713937547057867, -0.024272309616208076, 0.031211471185088158, -0.01132146641612053, 0.04515329375863075, -0.014310683123767376, -0.0033495649695396423, 0.003490995615720749, 0.04252670332789421, 0.01653146557509899, 0.02122354321181774, -0.02375500462949276, 0.009118286892771721, 0.005745777860283852, 0.023514356464147568, 0.01760011911392212, -0.03813520446419716, 0.013079783879220486, -0.009048854000866413, 0.043472982943058014, -0.0027319176588207483, -0.049457188695669174, 0.034301940351724625, -0.018313702195882797, 0.029068084433674812, 0.014427275396883488, -0.03668547421693802, 0.040104255080223083, 0.03129696473479271, 0.019386490806937218, -0.0491366870701313, 0.05496032536029816, 0.015974033623933792, 0.045155592262744904, 0.01507203932851553, 0.025594437494874, -0.011278954334557056, -0.036251552402973175, 0.023536907508969307, 0.03866772726178169, -0.0086553068831563, -0.0018943968461826444, -0.05397656559944153, 0.004485565237700939, -0.041721850633621216, -0.042183130979537964, -0.02712206356227398, 0.03051130659878254, 0.012538179755210876, -0.03148350492119789, 0.02164914458990097, -0.06266014277935028, -0.009116342291235924, -0.02568567730486393, 0.07161898165941238, 0.06898445636034012, 0.04735401272773743, -0.0001145368951256387, 0.04307343065738678, -0.022946784272789955, -0.0587935745716095, 0.0008680776809342206, 0.008786221034824848, -0.03435492888092995, -0.04907010868191719, 0.0672682523727417, 0.03294747695326805, -0.04788155481219292, 0.033039383590221405, -0.038403261452913284, 0.03154338523745537, -0.020988084375858307, -0.07552267611026764, -0.026156658306717873, -0.007970633916556835, -0.013582522980868816, 0.030629731714725494, -0.05225537717342377, -0.0013532186858356, 0.014583301730453968, 0.06302032619714737, 0.005729156546294689, 0.02118447981774807, 0.03395095840096474, 0.020790813490748405, -0.00844911951571703, -0.046174757182598114, -0.005320659372955561, -0.01724092662334442, -0.011385233141481876, -0.027267061173915863, -0.07326103001832962, 0.03852188214659691, 0.013853555545210838, 0.019908539950847626, 0.00833298172801733, 0.06007586419582367, -0.003637139219790697, -0.0358659103512764, 0.04689183831214905, -0.021698135882616043, -0.02147950977087021, 0.06920377165079117, -0.023175455629825592, 0.04999416321516037, 0.017801126465201378, -0.011105889454483986, 0.045241668820381165, 0.01251047570258379, 0.06923899799585342, 0.04947718605399132, -0.01603323593735695, 0.012879465706646442, 0.015910090878605843, -0.009501209482550621, 0.05467058718204498, -0.04643898084759712, -0.02265043742954731, -0.011820645071566105, -0.008614451624453068, 0.009355759248137474, 0.029576348140835762, -0.001889414037577808, -0.02173687517642975, 0.04720103740692139, -0.02093449793756008, -0.027021022513508797, -0.08309493958950043, 0.021719668060541153, 0.0018547821091488004, -0.034138962626457214, -0.00016737246187403798, -0.01906932331621647, 0.02362065203487873, 0.026727061718702316, 0.004731316119432449, -0.02921299636363983, -0.0005122410366311669, 0.03583676740527153, -0.017003078013658524, 0.031070131808519363, 0.0005416976055130363, 0.03214478865265846, -0.014667961746454239, 0.061868805438280106, -0.03473049774765968, -0.011718281544744968, -0.010975394397974014, -0.02947264537215233, 0.02971573919057846, 0.005402375012636185, -0.02228240855038166, 0.017644571140408516, -0.020855695009231567, -0.020813850685954094, 0.07091373950242996, -0.046346791088581085, 0.04096630588173866, 0.08235525339841843, -0.010275955311954021, -0.010432395152747631, 0.03273613378405571, 0.021435044705867767, 0.003961635287851095, -0.0442194789648056, -0.011737256310880184, -0.035944752395153046, -0.00019659112149383873, 0.036876045167446136, 0.0006210556020960212, -0.0028775434475392103, 0.030521061271429062, 0.009910869412124157, 0.03397662937641144, 0.034615788608789444, 0.039178550243377686, 0.012715673074126244, -0.0017460862873122096, 0.008476006798446178, 0.02967199869453907, -0.02895280346274376, -0.018541697412729263, 0.01919548027217388, -0.0010541172232478857, 0.04656504839658737, -0.004407122731208801, -0.007470446638762951, 0.07096242159605026, -0.02161545865237713, -0.016193388029932976, -0.018592234700918198, -0.03043888695538044, 0.04818247631192207, -0.018642054870724678, 0.010456000454723835, 0.055306777358055115, -0.0046888478100299835, -0.02043858915567398, -0.006239934824407101, -0.005380693357437849, 0.005750826559960842, 0.015432114712893963, -0.033420633524656296, -0.040268637239933014, 0.020505433902144432, -0.017076509073376656, 0.04980872943997383, -0.004285162314772606, -0.03159279748797417, -0.04641450569033623, -0.004310034681111574, 0.005355536937713623, 0.01696610637009144, 0.027912098914384842, -0.01993793435394764, -0.0014566000318154693, 0.019562415778636932, -0.037526752799749374, 0.04600614681839943, 0.009699749760329723, -0.04478070139884949, 0.0017951529007405043, -0.037720225751399994, -0.006318094674497843, 0.03588214889168739, -0.010732455179095268, -0.02804831601679325, 0.0097532719373703, -0.03184987232089043, -0.06252636760473251, -0.04498127102851868, -0.023738214746117592, 0.01577700860798359, 0.00279909186065197, -0.03486865758895874, 0.038232605904340744, 0.03519080951809883, -0.016027385368943214, 0.010579315945506096, -0.07055014371871948, 0.016426971182227135, 0.010895979590713978, -0.011499728076159954, -0.0027771240565925837, 0.006610474549233913, -0.009639398194849491, 0.007401293143630028, -0.05217817798256874, -0.017949659377336502, -0.09436024725437164, -0.03874622657895088, -0.0027304450049996376, 0.04833393543958664, 0.012659712694585323, 0.029822129756212234, 0.00038173687062226236, 0.07522708177566528, 0.036794520914554596, -0.0385153628885746, -0.04152674973011017, 0.0026196164544671774, -0.008509449660778046, -0.031679414212703705, 0.04902411624789238, 0.00590296508744359, 0.002359818434342742, 0.013771496713161469, -0.012968863360583782, 0.036814142018556595, 0.04640371352434158, 0.019093982875347137, -0.014610747806727886, 0.02525143511593342, -0.0012000218266621232, -0.006849437952041626, 0.01927431859076023, 0.005030997097492218, 0.00974134262651205, 0.04041668772697449, -0.04567234590649605, 0.0206025131046772, -0.0038258249405771494, -0.08968398720026016, -0.007596520707011223, -0.004177287686616182, 0.0051366002298891544, -0.015071270056068897, 0.0280366912484169, -0.016323566436767578, -0.053261205554008484, 0.02514696680009365, 0.008594388142228127, 0.026612240821123123, -0.031545113772153854, 0.00853253249078989, 0.0470355749130249, 0.09067994356155396, -0.015174147672951221, -0.008031677454710007, 0.0009684974793344736, 0.004071441944688559, 0.03121592290699482, -0.0732286125421524, -0.004833609331399202, 0.044497475028038025, -0.011076848953962326, -0.008702876977622509, -0.004318587947636843, -0.025963101536035538, 0.0034453861881047487, -0.08799594640731812, 0.007318750489503145, -0.024403339251875877, 0.058074951171875, 0.0018878038972616196, 0.05050923302769661, 0.0022478895261883736, -0.04496053233742714, 0.029223518446087837, 0.003591808956116438, -0.02361893095076084, 0.03483695164322853, 0.024717794731259346, -0.015277854166924953, 0.05219661071896553, 0.010599146597087383, 0.024570941925048828, 0.034096088260412216, -0.023866670206189156, 0.006330785341560841, 0.01416450459510088, -0.03710396960377693, 0.005140126682817936, -0.04377070069313049, -0.04923784360289574, -0.045527972280979156, 0.010145308449864388, 0.006603269372135401, -0.017238084226846695, 0.01140591874718666, 0.04122995212674141, 0.003572992514818907, 0.011143852025270462, -0.013703647069633007, -0.01716257818043232, 0.053846415132284164, 0.031424909830093384, 0.011554554104804993, 0.00919641088694334, -0.04104720428586006, 0.06555182486772537, -0.003810507943853736, 0.02762920781970024, 0.029624419286847115, 0.03318602219223976, -0.008376018144190311, -0.03912048414349556, 0.01753583922982216, 0.034071821719408035, -0.01304781436920166, 0.009919075295329094, -0.0028711939230561256, 0.049199048429727554, 0.02937793917953968, -0.04017169028520584, 0.022905191406607628, 0.051257021725177765, 0.0307125523686409, -0.017299171537160873, -0.04420267045497894, 0.020177464932203293, 0.005379850510507822, 0.033927395939826965, 0.017255961894989014, 0.0011895165080204606, 0.022918054834008217, 0.007611745037138462, 0.05138082057237625, -0.022938759997487068, 0.012636111117899418, 0.011906691826879978, 0.036663442850112915, -0.004017591942101717, -0.008917872793972492, -0.052914705127477646, 0.006171470042318106, 0.054989054799079895, 0.04473321884870529, 0.009102145209908485, 0.03826797381043434, -0.08643849194049835, 0.011093748733401299, 0.021754484623670578, 0.018424740061163902, -0.0030353839974850416, 0.00707115326076746, -0.03506598621606827, -0.026294512674212456, 0.0031992795411497355, 0.012230792082846165, 0.027560967952013016, -0.04136652499437332, 0.021943315863609314, 0.004561402834951878, -0.0033278309274464846, -0.026424750685691833, 0.010028286837041378, -0.009730073623359203, 0.006529306527227163, 0.029198063537478447, -0.04706640541553497, 0.022414829581975937, -0.0013854596763849258, 0.008624975569546223, 0.016410021111369133, -0.0015946794301271439, -0.022871743887662888, 0.051276031881570816, 0.008854101411998272, 0.002146986545994878, -0.01976798288524151, 0.04237819090485573, 0.015931986272335052, 0.0010800225427374244, 0.04879982769489288, -0.010289398021996021, 0.01710570976138115, -0.011366656050086021, 0.04659563675522804, 0.01741054095327854, -0.04443001374602318, -0.05856037512421608, 0.041294295340776443, 0.02527589164674282, -0.03081115335226059, 0.10139952600002289, 0.03171170502901077, 0.0020375095773488283, 0.015154888853430748, -0.053702857345342636, 0.01568513736128807, 0.025624515488743782, -0.028767451643943787, -0.07401377707719803, 0.022862672805786133, 0.0012818777468055487, 0.0449267141520977, 0.0010426247026771307, 0.02401907369494438, -0.027491766959428787, -0.025441693142056465, 0.012011834420263767, 0.03978513926267624, -0.05097762867808342, -0.02084340900182724, -0.006378195248544216, -0.000026325527869630605, -0.008775509893894196, -0.040906187146902084, 0.042582251131534576, -0.031428996473550797, 0.008406603708863258, -0.0011992197250947356, -0.00438704201951623, 0.006753149908035994, 0.001382796443067491, -0.025844424962997437, 0.017665758728981018, -0.03691401332616806, 0.015224847011268139, -0.015208961442112923, 0.032656777650117874, -0.023300321772694588, -0.02991343103349209, -0.03185039386153221, 0.05153154209256172, -0.031243422999978065, 0.015551610849797726, -0.0009838673286139965, 0.019769299775362015, 0.0016923013608902693, 0.004827313590794802, -0.05863582715392113, -0.09790532290935516, 0.03206291422247887, -0.011561202816665173, -0.03463837504386902, -0.04588025435805321, -0.010932180099189281, -0.033509306609630585, 0.011051212437450886, -0.0016325184842571616, 0.03956662118434906, -0.04626157879829407, 0.027236556634306908, -0.01934230513870716, 0.03112695924937725, 0.07852812856435776, 0.014176218770444393, -0.019618315622210503, 0.012235758826136589, -0.00351716298609972, -0.01802830398082733, -0.016338832676410675, -0.0018617300083860755, -0.035548076033592224, 0.021204272285103798, -0.06692345440387726, -0.006229114718735218, 0.0648939460515976, -0.010626774281263351, -0.04054364189505577, 0.02378843165934086, -0.006506518926471472, 0.004878672771155834, -0.04087919741868973, 0.018613290041685104, 0.005610181950032711, 0.02933868020772934, -0.028655629605054855, -0.013500427827239037, -0.017521562054753304, -0.01423144806176424, 0.04150673747062683, -0.031949423253536224, -0.015456334687769413, 0.028289105743169785, 0.04051150754094124, -0.013836353085935116, 0.016478383913636208, 0.01663321629166603, -0.000975641596596688, 0.042368244379758835, -0.02181955613195896, -0.024963757023215294, 0.016596326604485512, 0.0007246121531352401, -0.03684418275952339, -0.04405820742249489, -0.04721768572926521, -0.005027159582823515, 0.04446222260594368, -0.009344452992081642, 0.014114871621131897, 0.04778478667140007, -0.013212130405008793, -0.029092902317643166, -0.03311457857489586, 0.009015442803502083, -0.02257412299513817, 0.012558374553918839, 0.0777902603149414, -0.03650977462530136, -0.04686187580227852, 0.044909752905368805, 0.035593993961811066, 0.005106459371745586, 0.037793710827827454, 0.009658136405050755, 0.025847788900136948, 0.007364405319094658, 0.001306233461946249, -0.04667504131793976, 0.01690593548119068, -0.03871366009116173, 0.026900719851255417, -0.03205175697803497, -0.04913078993558884, 0.016959019005298615, 0.052356548607349396, -0.012538139708340168, -0.07649042457342148, -0.017617320641875267, -0.04417028650641441, 0.024235539138317108, 0.031917788088321686, -0.0008722469210624695, 0.01838459074497223, 0.009989768266677856, 0.06286227703094482, -0.011882426217198372, 0.021983249112963676, -0.02561071515083313, -0.04487625136971474, -0.001901121810078621, -0.03402450680732727, -0.005289873573929071, 0.018558437004685402, 0.0005241571343503892, -0.03969892859458923, -0.013993253000080585, -0.04339239373803139, -0.005417732056230307, 0.01768372394144535, 0.03806305676698685, 0.020989594981074333, 0.05574547126889229, -0.008715393021702766, -0.01848258450627327, -0.0024088071659207344, -0.01107664592564106, 0.11293654143810272, 0.07369794696569443, 0.001995544182136655, -0.06026993691921234, 0.022382454946637154, 0.0342448428273201, 0.0011213291436433792, -0.0472414568066597, -0.010783127509057522, -0.00662987120449543, -0.026897069066762924, 0.052657969295978546, 0.06098990887403488, 0.003458182094618678, -0.004588115029036999, 0.03527401015162468, -0.01609872281551361, -0.0334249772131443, 0.015972036868333817, -0.013774902559816837, 0.004803788848221302, 0.008587702177464962, -0.06286118924617767, 0.0487145371735096, 0.034192994236946106, -0.022927595302462578, -0.0039795273914933205, -0.0002835655468516052, 0.00165939936414361, 0.02472262643277645, 0.00023426311963703483, 0.026403212919831276, -0.021860424429178238, 0.030350323766469955, 0.004083404317498207, -0.0001846921950345859, 0.010001580230891705, -0.02864009700715542, 0.023844191804528236, 0.027334576472640038, 0.010688413865864277, 0.00469747930765152, 0.01718924194574356, 0.02675078622996807, -0.019699137657880783, -0.047743335366249084, -0.013166955672204494, 0.045022740960121155, -0.00960483867675066, -0.043902501463890076, -0.013673335313796997, -0.008662696927785873, 0.015152866020798683, -0.03480326384305954, -0.03704289346933365, 0.017627622932195663, 0.012057764455676079, -0.02814915031194687, 0.026686115190386772, -0.0135917654260993, -0.0011379419593140483, -0.00016960671928245574, 0.022373786196112633, 0.036668941378593445, -0.0379052571952343, 0.00671315798535943, -0.04257519170641899, 0.019377194344997406, 0.026208871975541115, 0.014969569630920887, 0.012431366369128227, -0.01940268464386463, -0.018674656748771667, -0.011249935254454613, 0.026993175968527794, 0.044107478111982346, 0.03559622913599014, -0.03099115379154682, -0.012388286180794239, -0.018543340265750885, -0.071466363966465, -0.031828589737415314, 0.02165192738175392, -0.0145766232162714, -0.048914238810539246, -0.0061782170087099075, 0.0019983963575214148, 0.03574328124523163, -0.041849538683891296, 0.00131795066408813, -0.03912912309169769, 0.033445507287979126, 0.005644160322844982, -0.07034187018871307, -0.05701611563563347, 0.028460649773478508, 0.004510877653956413, -0.021652426570653915, -0.015417858958244324, 0.07313167303800583, 0.01071250531822443, -0.018887799233198166, -0.03843018040060997, 0.043861329555511475, 0.0038031376898288727, -0.004245868418365717, 0.029714040458202362, -0.014194768853485584, 0.05284108221530914, -0.02209235355257988, 0.011114873923361301, -0.028341619297862053, -0.003980189561843872, -0.038272675126791, -0.04635545611381531, -0.006957723759114742, -0.02375100553035736, 0.004001542925834656, 0.00044588575838133693, -0.03373892232775688, -0.004930274561047554, -0.01708321087062359, 0.029028551653027534, -0.049326859414577484, -0.001750114606693387, 0.010892975144088268, -0.01868363842368126, -0.018712062388658524, 0.030134307220578194, -0.027103658765554428, -0.013466130010783672, 0.006157420575618744, -0.003536506090313196, 0.0022075194865465164, -0.002437161048874259, 0.013621455989778042, 0.0022908346727490425, 0.05745045095682144, 0.02285163849592209, -0.025018515065312386, -0.004254201892763376, -0.04252954199910164, -0.017190424725413322, 0.005246918648481369, 0.005434098187834024, 0.03428484871983528, 0.020691832527518272, 0.005686265416443348, -0.003219151869416237, 0.066953644156456, -0.04355834424495697, -0.001516271266154945, -0.030768169090151787, -0.011114862747490406, -0.03373930975794792, -0.008689707145094872, 0.012001527473330498, 0.04507935792207718, 0.004783971700817347, 0.014964940957725048, 0.04928666725754738, 0.007545496802777052, 0.010920950211584568, -0.015248391777276993, -0.0008167672785930336, 0.0187032762914896, 0.021757975220680237, 0.01736091636121273, 0.008486829698085785, 0.06786362081766129, -0.0320855937898159, 0.04702192544937134, -0.00153776491060853, 0.019146505743265152, -0.08462246507406235, -0.01230531930923462, 0.02733055129647255, 0.006756443530321121, 0.02508792094886303, -0.036824781447649, 0.0020633917301893234, 0.02728719636797905, -0.0386338047683239, -0.010165504179894924, -0.0266314297914505, 0.015533006750047207, 0.004639295861124992, 0.011262908577919006, -0.014206675812602043, 0.0103500597178936, 0.022360295057296753, -0.008087025955319405, 0.03303312510251999, 0.012226417660713196, 0.031934868544340134, -0.031195443123579025, 0.029373779892921448, 0.012864748015999794, 0.040408115833997726, -0.06853863596916199, 0.015103324316442013, -0.00508746225386858, -0.0079313600435853, 0.024449771270155907, -0.025201700627803802, 0.03181994706392288, 0.04485847428441048, 0.03793438524007797, 0.004061904735863209, 0.058365967124700546, 0.009829417802393436, -0.025287793949246407, -0.020468274131417274, -0.005955884233117104, 0.0005887364386580884, -0.01686774007976055, -0.011931649409234524, 0.01727205701172352, 0.003382499562576413, -0.0015482971211895347, -0.04401819407939911, 0.004307127092033625, 0.015834618359804153, -0.04004983976483345, -0.00937590654939413, -0.014803231693804264, 0.0034130618441849947, -0.04903962090611458, 0.013588953763246536, -0.023811381310224533, 0.007267935201525688, 0.03520897775888443, -0.00375732290558517, -0.03886089846491814, 0.01245652511715889, -0.04164402186870575, -0.03605924919247627, -0.007137595675885677, 0.030274342745542526, -0.0019300272688269615, -0.054986413568258286, -0.01977364718914032, -0.029475318267941475, -0.02815835177898407, -0.03900318965315819, 0.021662293002009392, -0.05137409269809723, 0.050584763288497925, -0.014587772078812122, -0.014308786951005459, 0.0009080922463908792, -0.025692932307720184, 0.03959309682250023, -0.06734984368085861, 0.046644728630781174, 0.017693255096673965, -0.004672946408390999, -0.0553317591547966, 0.011972587555646896, -0.02290228195488453, 0.015635943040251732, 0.0339331217110157, 0.017675325274467468, -0.0004173160996288061, 0.012412183918058872, 0.049169283360242844, -0.0326869934797287, -0.018333038315176964, 0.07561047375202179, 0.008588047698140144, -0.02978484146296978, -0.02474338747560978, -0.0031006229110062122, -0.01491002831608057, -0.0064222551882267, -0.021448466926813126, -0.018410909920930862, -0.003702771384268999, -0.02191832661628723, -0.03073783405125141, -0.008077357895672321, 0.012163626030087471, -0.0035870084539055824, 0.03876090049743652, -0.01793895848095417, 0.01682635024189949, 0.044353511184453964, -0.02763788402080536, -0.05251449719071388, 0.027598125860095024, -0.04549368470907211, 0.01331147737801075, 0.02880629152059555, -0.022371064871549606, 0.0012350468896329403, -0.09397488832473755, 0.016282960772514343, 0.0040166643448174, 0.0078044612891972065, -0.0025551714934408665, 0.03612380474805832, 0.009519273415207863, 0.051514048129320145, -0.018583588302135468, -0.0052609010599553585, -0.003793279407545924, 0.02168981544673443, 0.011213625781238079, 0.008361530490219593, 0.04012913256883621, -0.012040634639561176, -0.016689231619238853, 0.007530218921601772, -0.03357762098312378, 0.0184364952147007, 0.0013724775053560734, 0.02731110341846943, 0.0027198714669793844, 0.009025314822793007, -0.002322232350707054, -0.009723733179271221, -0.005038397386670113, 0.0295159462839365, 0.020307091996073723, 0.016059676185250282, -0.05853384733200073, 0.016056964173913002, 0.005247052758932114, -0.012274965643882751, -0.025387341156601906, 0.005034316796809435, 0.019553687423467636, 0.04020752012729645, -0.026687724515795708, 0.017157286405563354, -0.010294487699866295, -0.03582056239247322, -0.0019495845772325993, -0.02806158736348152, -0.004399497993290424, 0.006978433579206467, -0.005337827373296022, 0.0062599144876003265, -0.03856833651661873, -0.02160453423857689, -0.052893511950969696, 0.043244391679763794, 0.004707919433712959, 0.02964126132428646, -0.03626760467886925, -0.003874510060995817, 0.017275700345635414, 0.06583064049482346, -0.08323173969984055, -0.01880999654531479, -0.025030232965946198, -0.013283918611705303, -0.006069318391382694, 0.005901331547647715 ]
<p>According to <a href="http://jarrodwilcox.com/expert-investor/diversification-helps-growth/" rel="nofollow">this extract of a paper</a> posted on the web, the average return of a fair coin flip that pays 100% for heads and loses 50 percent for tails over 3 periods is 25 percent per period, while the geometric mean or compound annual return is 8.3 percent. </p> <p>To calculate the average return, you first calculate the terminal value then calculate the equivalent per period value. The terminal values is $0.125\cdot 8 + 0.375\cdot 2 + 0.375\cdot 0.5 + 0.125\cdot 0.125$, or $1.9531$ and the per period value is $1.9531^{1/3}$, or $1.25$. Subtracting $1$ gets you $25\%$ per period.</p> <p>To calculate the average geometric return or or mean compound return you take the cube root of each possible outcome and then apply the probabilities to each of the results. So the geometric mean is $0.125\cdot 100\% + 0.375\cdot 26\% + 0.375\cdot (-20.6\%) + 0.125\cdot (-50\%)$, or only $8.3\%$.</p> <p>My question is how should one interpret the geometric mean return? Does it describe the expected growth in your capital such that if I ran an experiment where I made a number of 3 year investments, the expected growth of my capital over the 3 years would be $8.3\%$? </p> <p>Why does the the geometric mean return decline with with period?</p>
73,810
[ -0.021462013944983482, -0.011743328534066677, 0.010875768959522247, -0.035717833787202835, 0.04922139644622803, 0.02189469151198864, -0.029645400121808052, -0.04540063813328743, 0.02365528978407383, -0.0415477454662323, 0.07442758977413177, 0.041284624487161636, 0.057809486985206604, 0.04095575958490372, 0.004832589998841286, 0.0327041894197464, -0.02083710767328739, -0.021573849022388458, -0.00965798832476139, -0.015351571142673492, 0.005576268304139376, 0.02042633295059204, 0.005758052226155996, -0.008985585533082485, -0.022490471601486206, 0.053708065301179886, 0.030333805829286575, -0.002344300504773855, -0.010663177818059921, 0.036907441914081573, -0.015855122357606888, -0.01989797130227089, 0.04801563173532486, 0.02161925844848156, -0.007275113835930824, 0.003198101185262203, 0.004716144409030676, 0.001090984558686614, -0.015608793124556541, 0.024806883186101913, -0.008112184703350067, -0.01784372888505459, -0.02104729600250721, 0.016391150653362274, 0.008659600280225277, 0.0077329883351922035, -0.01494073960930109, -0.024159332737326622, 0.03995554894208908, -0.05750647932291031, 0.05622062087059021, 0.016247747465968132, 0.01988985389471054, -0.002377162454649806, -0.0030241941567510366, 0.010504432022571564, 0.05308312177658081, 0.033216819167137146, -0.016699863597750664, -0.05087215080857277, 0.01659914292395115, -0.008370503783226013, -0.002720943419262767, -0.013112267479300499, 0.004676683805882931, 0.040662385523319244, 0.01191056426614523, -0.005633571185171604, 0.04188265651464462, -0.00939963199198246, 0.011300700716674328, 0.02229430340230465, 0.024157611653208733, 0.042909082025289536, 0.032783180475234985, -0.012572837062180042, -0.004365976434201002, 0.04649350047111511, 0.05873998999595642, 0.04785773903131485, 0.019147327169775963, -0.007879301905632019, 0.01085811946541071, 0.01476016454398632, 0.0085055036470294, 0.009748965501785278, 0.0808347538113594, -0.003848946886137128, 0.04402293264865875, 0.02273157611489296, 0.013307551853358746, -0.01229762937873602, 0.04802405834197998, -0.0038604033179581165, -0.05265158787369728, 0.04667442664504051, -0.006495940499007702, -0.020921142771840096, -0.03107631579041481, -0.0074265385046601295, -0.040785305202007294, -0.06347501277923584, 0.06226662918925285, 0.016752541065216064, 0.01925007812678814, 0.037534911185503006, -0.035322826355695724, 0.011020981706678867, -0.04337063804268837, -0.04321072995662689, -0.019237196072936058, 0.031559549272060394, -0.00905753392726183, -0.008841055445373058, 0.014339465647935867, -0.009637268260121346, 0.011834566481411457, -0.0122175058349967, 0.032698310911655426, 0.028811154887080193, 0.023661544546484947, -0.011921485885977745, 0.00611321022734046, -0.042517855763435364, -0.07352523505687714, 0.013136249035596848, 0.004829042591154575, -0.02943814918398857, -0.05307406559586525, 0.04824112355709076, 0.004404407925903797, -0.01050914078950882, 0.030303727835416794, 0.03657422214746475, 0.0025914309080690145, -0.009816623292863369, -0.1024886816740036, -0.044287487864494324, 0.08616256713867188, 0.013003921136260033, 0.018671290948987007, -0.08196758478879929, 0.005365017801523209, 0.04852376878261566, 0.017051937058568, 0.002911204006522894, 0.038802240043878555, 0.011894723400473595, 0.0678282380104065, 0.03001093678176403, -0.0805170014500618, 0.0038901695515960455, 0.005944419652223587, -0.04220879450440407, -0.01195508148521185, -0.0686589777469635, 0.027454666793346405, 0.004181532189249992, -0.003237077733501792, -0.0019370503723621368, 0.04041539877653122, 0.024262886494398117, -0.02684551663696766, 0.003759085899218917, -0.04011531546711922, -0.018503068014979362, 0.0843205526471138, 0.0311124324798584, 0.02002868242561817, 0.004472087603062391, 0.022356536239385605, -0.017848320305347443, 0.008595717139542103, 0.048751942813396454, 0.04212125018239021, -0.029130036011338234, 0.05543484538793564, -0.027290772646665573, -0.025183923542499542, -0.00673347432166338, -0.08433909714221954, 0.02068254165351391, -0.06037040427327156, 0.014240221120417118, 0.029191462323069572, 0.025712348520755768, -0.0010802546748891473, 0.0020921770483255386, 0.005824623629450798, -0.012678015045821667, -0.05152107775211334, -0.07944726943969727, -0.010054860264062881, -0.039806365966796875, -0.015004526823759079, -0.023970572277903557, -0.020304430276155472, 0.04185924679040909, -0.007236582692712545, -0.016134826466441154, 0.030980153009295464, 0.00926603190600872, 0.05915509909391403, -0.035740554332733154, -0.017678946256637573, 0.04210023581981659, 0.039627667516469955, -0.020274708047509193, -0.03035004995763302, -0.026834512129426003, -0.007525224704295397, -0.012045733630657196, -0.017447518184781075, 0.016848430037498474, 0.0036378251388669014, -0.034104883670806885, 0.021417388692498207, 0.007595141418278217, 0.023244081065058708, 0.030942561104893684, -0.03842164948582649, 0.04044168069958687, 0.0625486895442009, 0.010576548054814339, 0.0016024356009438634, 0.008437530137598515, -0.012358701787889004, 0.032207030802965164, 0.015072496607899666, 0.011264408007264137, -0.018259825184941292, 0.00034447567304596305, 0.02800871431827545, 0.024115238338708878, -0.013322693295776844, 0.051902350038290024, 0.071479432284832, -0.012920986860990524, -0.020930513739585876, 0.026043053716421127, 0.017019258812069893, 0.009707140736281872, 0.015069503337144852, 0.037544719874858856, -0.003321468597277999, -0.003274058923125267, 0.017370564863085747, 0.0034858407452702522, -0.005261664744466543, 0.009120128117501736, -0.012855720706284046, 0.028140190988779068, -0.007293717470020056, 0.018702194094657898, -0.028107328340411186, -0.02240600623190403, 0.031039394438266754, -0.0013994217151775956, -0.025378230959177017, 0.03593607619404793, 0.0017520631663501263, -0.02431514300405979, 0.0023896892089396715, -0.03444642573595047, -0.04377448558807373, 0.021127978339791298, -0.0223910640925169, -0.05346640199422836, 0.021049687638878822, -0.018405918031930923, 0.032202377915382385, -0.031915776431560516, -0.017680414021015167, -0.05124736577272415, 0.0022875010035932064, -0.00906322617083788, -0.020082758739590645, 0.023419182747602463, -0.027132762596011162, -0.041183311492204666, 0.0005382286617532372, 0.0306383203715086, -0.005946059711277485, -0.02426503226161003, -0.07570189982652664, -0.012954076752066612, 0.019608357921242714, -0.030864322558045387, 0.016011744737625122, -0.024455053731799126, 0.010199480690062046, 0.02380257658660412, 0.024626417085528374, -0.04327954351902008, -0.0274492297321558, -0.04598133638501167, 0.008906951174139977, -0.024543602019548416, -0.048472970724105835, 0.03381530940532684, -0.0036459139082580805, 0.000834319565910846, 0.03304008021950722, -0.03852853924036026, -0.028377143666148186, -0.013093794696033001, 0.013464368879795074, 0.014468943700194359, 0.00045691433479078114, -0.003938054200261831, 0.00047844176879152656, -0.05445147678256035, -0.01582859829068184, -0.1001838967204094, -0.04918057844042778, -0.01954013481736183, 0.010899038054049015, -0.006307234987616539, 0.020854728296399117, -0.04016444832086563, 0.07948628813028336, 0.02279607765376568, -0.04329702630639076, -0.03132939338684082, -0.006263948976993561, -0.017573868855834007, -0.024701276794075966, 0.0038717996794730425, 0.04890906810760498, 0.013326125219464302, 0.012346915900707245, -0.021252766251564026, 0.028823163360357285, 0.04957094043493271, 0.0021375613287091255, -0.002219698391854763, -0.010719445534050465, -0.015020922757685184, -0.007895661517977715, 0.03659423813223839, 0.07371705025434494, -0.03273069113492966, 0.007628703024238348, 0.05182776600122452, 0.04794225096702576, 0.023328833281993866, -0.04784635454416275, 0.025103282183408737, -0.02326040528714657, 0.008878816850483418, -0.010948114097118378, 0.035791050642728806, -0.006583085283637047, -0.009946024976670742, 0.005685254465788603, -0.048052843660116196, 0.0011015812633559108, 0.01596943475306034, 0.019349364563822746, 0.01908448152244091, 0.027091076597571373, 0.002229950623586774, -0.009256789460778236, -0.03326408937573433, -0.007667242083698511, 0.01986650750041008, -0.006081622559577227, 0.015475591644644737, 0.038374919444322586, 0.028887268155813217, 0.03562847524881363, 0.004549622070044279, -0.016346994787454605, 0.000809948134701699, -0.08521749079227448, -0.0019266598392277956, -0.006982001475989819, 0.014508336782455444, 0.0009441783768124878, 0.0030049195047467947, 0.002323161344975233, -0.0246176328510046, 0.041210684925317764, -0.03538421541452408, -0.0709962248802185, 0.048967424780130386, -0.025722960010170937, -0.019699782133102417, -0.01327438186854124, -0.03805191442370415, 0.028696486726403236, -0.02139401249587536, -0.005520557053387165, 0.048137880861759186, 0.00021274163736961782, -0.030805569142103195, 0.027116799727082253, 0.014307266101241112, -0.003553152084350586, -0.007483245339244604, -0.016251711174845695, 0.04825408011674881, 0.005253780633211136, 0.07029272615909576, 0.0635644719004631, -0.027394266799092293, 0.00952979177236557, -0.017185036092996597, 0.03109055943787098, 0.046010442078113556, 0.010535351000726223, 0.06014333292841911, 0.023019636049866676, -0.009303180500864983, 0.06479766964912415, 0.035099729895591736, 0.02519969269633293, 0.004624881315976381, -0.01668841578066349, -0.012442286126315594, -0.0296946968883276, -0.01190258376300335, 0.00551286805421114, -0.035393986850976944, 0.038932934403419495, 0.013337926007807255, 0.04866049438714981, 0.004578753840178251, -0.003923437092453241, 0.011178046464920044, 0.03450773283839226, 0.019582774490118027, 0.003448106348514557, -0.019452666863799095, -0.02641194313764572, -0.00806063786149025, -0.03359775245189667, 0.03457465022802353, -0.03635626658797264, -0.01510734111070633, 0.004172803368419409, 0.05746108666062355, -0.02615906111896038, -0.011168236844241619, 0.006350195035338402, -0.011638296768069267, 0.04640759155154228, -0.022739198058843613, -0.03044196031987667, 0.024936823174357414, 0.05110534280538559, 0.010968933813273907, 0.0289507694542408, -0.003517204662784934, -0.07342653721570969, 0.00029497756622731686, 0.031759750097990036, 0.048891954123973846, -0.029768945649266243, -0.009056341834366322, -0.044116269797086716, -2.0554224988700298e-7, 0.02768767438828945, -0.005798787344247103, 0.02051139995455742, -0.023307524621486664, 0.0036616134457290173, -0.004780101589858532, -0.021508654579520226, -0.05322790518403053, 0.00033402483677491546, -0.03350774198770523, -0.004693302325904369, 0.0003856050316244364, -0.00018796151562128216, 0.01165570504963398, 0.01834031380712986, 0.02853373996913433, 0.0032865419052541256, -0.06343335658311844, 0.03863157704472542, -0.0019473072607070208, 0.01167451124638319, -0.005390075035393238, -0.0890214815735817, 0.033728525042533875, -0.010681895539164543, -0.00668516056612134, 0.02874669060111046, -0.021770386025309563, -0.05833091959357262, -0.0028941368218511343, -0.006028137169778347, -0.021711327135562897, -0.008548302575945854, -0.04404164105653763, 0.054937947541475296, 0.009061320684850216, 0.0070648519322276115, 0.048515573143959045, 0.0032357408199459314, 0.0006733101326972246, 0.00039827742148190737, -0.03467823937535286, 0.041208405047655106, -0.05181906744837761, 0.016878874972462654, -0.02114691212773323, 0.01167711429297924, 0.025247961282730103, 0.06499295681715012, -0.012782204896211624, 0.015804413706064224, -0.06052456051111221, 0.01229336578398943, 0.01522431056946516, 0.012531209737062454, 0.008846446871757507, -0.03141939640045166, 0.016717661172151566, -0.012748469598591328, 0.027987834066152573, -0.008481827564537525, -0.009827573783695698, -0.02411746233701706, 0.012928766198456287, 0.016926534473896027, -0.01944490149617195, -0.007766723167151213, -0.016620459035038948, 0.02201036736369133, -0.019011761993169785, -0.010099679231643677, 0.048024971038103104, -0.019691748544573784, 0.008831244893372059, 0.030229566618800163, -0.014213468879461288, -0.003947662189602852, -0.021382253617048264, 0.020695563405752182, -0.0059793912805616856, -0.0643858015537262, 0.0209690872579813, -0.03126009926199913, 0.011087310500442982, -0.03918099030852318, -0.04887986183166504, 0.016319947317242622, 0.03273504227399826, -0.027153130620718002, -0.023039931431412697, -0.00978509709239006, -0.02200379967689514, -0.03621828928589821, -0.033239878714084625, 0.019502289593219757, -0.02407526597380638, -0.04805944114923477, 0.009339367970824242, 0.0543084554374218, 0.07736780494451523, -0.02097814716398716, -0.0034700899850577116, 0.024318672716617584, 0.015941813588142395, -0.0177800040692091, -0.017389371991157532, 0.017123617231845856, -0.04428790509700775, -0.012314725667238235, -0.002396917901933193, -0.027284221723675728, 0.029367506504058838, -0.046313539147377014, -0.010092905722558498, 0.0019071196438744664, -0.0023857313208281994, 0.0005365405231714249, 0.009073168970644474, -0.0007614665664732456, 0.017566177994012833, 0.04550321027636528, 0.027083570137619972, 0.02112162485718727, -0.009929800406098366, -0.017105795443058014, 0.026352552697062492, 0.0021449150517582893, -0.03721579164266586, 0.019905202090740204, 0.06261200457811356, -0.01740463264286518, -0.011034682393074036, -0.025919834151864052, -0.01244514249265194, 0.0035467396955937147, 0.0018326686695218086, 0.01520634163171053, 0.03012654557824135, 0.002082445425912738, -0.03435380011796951, -0.0191821102052927, -0.01617155410349369, 0.004183546639978886, 0.04140356555581093, -0.041679974645376205, 0.000587228627409786, 0.017657272517681122, -0.017179692164063454, 0.00898709986358881, -0.025979872792959213, -0.009566135704517365, -0.016651585698127747, -0.007526954170316458, 0.035140033811330795, -0.020252110436558723, 0.018408358097076416, 0.032739266753196716, 0.0341208390891552, -0.02710730955004692, 0.01076593343168497, 0.02157290279865265, 0.031914133578538895, 0.02080988883972168, -0.022213587537407875, -0.03309585526585579, 0.056366436183452606, -0.010810602456331253, 0.05194465443491936, -0.06554211676120758, -0.04108547419309616, 0.03673239424824715, 0.05304865166544914, -0.03135452792048454, -0.05372373014688492, 0.006276820786297321, -0.027223432436585426, 0.005038639530539513, 0.025563908740878105, -0.053181134164333344, 0.023137344047427177, -0.006740879733115435, 0.04996947944164276, -0.01588258147239685, 0.06259068846702576, -0.020294776186347008, -0.06863892823457718, -0.00867378432303667, -0.05397207289934158, -0.05103349685668945, 0.0034808930940926075, -0.006939228158444166, -0.023642029613256454, 0.02355337329208851, -0.05679575353860855, 0.0035134416539222, -0.0009427836048416793, -0.016865717247128487, -0.015719514340162277, 0.10937102138996124, 0.03999754786491394, 0.009470212273299694, -0.019116351380944252, -0.014865949749946594, 0.13152028620243073, 0.03216031938791275, 0.0009037312120199203, -0.06971670687198639, 0.02907686121761799, -0.03937029838562012, 0.04346520081162453, -0.032205455005168915, 0.04881232976913452, 0.016566267237067223, 0.02953369915485382, 0.0537240244448185, 0.04231851547956467, -0.021220603957772255, -0.016943879425525665, 0.026074359193444252, -0.045180417597293854, -0.019163427874445915, 0.0022607743740081787, 0.014376684091985226, 0.003524881089106202, -0.01310171838849783, -0.023810219019651413, 0.007608767133206129, -0.0101309884339571, 0.012476091273128986, -0.006809859536588192, -0.04071163386106491, 0.00043543073115870357, 0.04192157834768295, -0.011461898684501648, -0.009804521687328815, 0.02740316465497017, -0.02579537220299244, -0.009722966700792313, -0.01815814897418022, 0.020698802545666695, -0.03818004950881004, 0.021397752687335014, -0.00926321279257536, 0.005249102134257555, -0.0022551524452865124, 0.02131792902946472, 0.012530268169939518, -0.05472984164953232, 0.0016505923122167587, -0.010798310860991478, 0.042801566421985626, -0.0378015972673893, -0.01342465914785862, -0.0703192800283432, -0.01461632177233696, -0.021356850862503052, -0.046277064830064774, 0.0023475196212530136, 0.012834095396101475, 0.006224437616765499, -0.04966675490140915, -0.04900005832314491, -0.00025905476650223136, -0.022287605330348015, -0.023044075816869736, 0.0691128522157669, 0.011912943795323372, -0.031649231910705566, 0.000934947223868221, -0.03367611765861511, 0.02996637299656868, -0.011220828630030155, -0.012822065502405167, -0.06107695773243904, 0.010314859449863434, -0.04788131266832352, -0.00027197072631679475, 0.0017324379878118634, -0.006068725138902664, 0.020581165328621864, -0.011273247189819813, 0.009649191051721573, 0.04086786508560181, -0.01210458017885685, 0.057393841445446014, -0.005677611567080021, -0.007865984924137592, -0.05871958285570145, 0.024535518139600754, 0.02656337432563305, 0.0034764474257826805, -0.03622083738446236, 0.0030565131455659866, -0.004676236771047115, 0.05833058804273605, 0.02011755108833313, 0.003319731680676341, 0.012408832088112831, 0.023639015853405, -0.05105912312865257, -0.04950994998216629, -0.03265535831451416, 0.07175292074680328, 0.02467396669089794, 0.009521077387034893, -0.015255160629749298, 0.01578317955136299, -0.016770493239164352, 0.014812071807682514, -0.008266867138445377, -0.034944940358400345, 0.031763769686222076, 0.04454665258526802, 0.006030335556715727, -0.0550822988152504, -0.021385103464126587, 0.002431632252410054, -0.00872066430747509, 0.05645301565527916, 0.0333978570997715, -0.0187990702688694, 0.03337714821100235, -0.054365914314985275, 0.04565790295600891, -0.02504836395382881, -0.03438327834010124, -0.03794026002287865, 0.022039910778403282, 0.003126655938103795, 0.026042291894555092, -0.015981042757630348, 0.02588506229221821, 0.006864064838737249, 0.0013390936655923724, 0.055421870201826096, 0.031081991270184517, -0.013778340071439743, -0.030954618006944656, 0.006923194974660873, -0.01250844169408083, 0.011179313063621521, -0.030966471880674362, -0.018143881112337112, 0.05980842188000679, -0.004821763373911381, -0.008546900004148483, -0.036971744149923325, 0.021234603598713875, 0.05527995154261589, 0.006446291692554951, -0.016022808849811554, -0.030801305547356606, 0.012169761583209038, -0.02565729431807995, -0.01856534369289875, -0.03474589064717293, 0.0057938601821660995, 0.0715474933385849, -0.030354909598827362, -0.025746023282408714, 0.015902971848845482, -0.003118575783446431, 0.019042525440454483, 0.010742347687482834, -0.024442652240395546, -0.002132848836481571, -0.005303824320435524, 0.005701692774891853, -0.05975921079516411, 0.039214275777339935, 0.006319351028650999, 0.06153688207268715, 0.0365566685795784, -0.008301145397126675, 0.03764047846198082, -0.014514829032123089, 0.0020469040609896183, -0.04524185508489609, 0.011585469357669353, 0.013829143717885017, -0.026782264932990074, 0.029551081359386444, -0.024098066613078117, -0.013792796991765499, 0.003525430802255869, -0.03170477971434593, 0.014896021224558353, -0.0012309429002925754, -0.03492787852883339, -0.0618039108812809, -0.017127541825175285, 0.019505199044942856, 0.010570220649242401, -0.012910532765090466, 0.02885575033724308, 0.03786791115999222, 0.018123673275113106, -0.004100974183529615, -0.03753160685300827, 0.023967506363987923, 0.019350627437233925, -0.015801863744854927, -0.042696475982666016, 0.05129675194621086, -0.030934810638427734, -0.033029813319444656, 0.046334415674209595, -0.0025827232748270035, 0.01479361206293106, 0.015464860945940018, 0.026618337258696556, 0.0002447339065838605, 0.021302582696080208, 0.06424461305141449, 0.009659123606979847, -0.02330014668405056, -0.01726827211678028, 0.04050086811184883, 0.012550078332424164, 0.015465466305613518, 0.019166812300682068, 0.0053009516559541225, -0.018361898139119148, -0.01939806528389454, 0.00014064418792258948, -0.008265813812613487, 0.015621647238731384, 0.021691566333174706, -0.004028045106679201, 0.003501316299661994, 0.015981020405888557, 0.028238680213689804, -0.009329384192824364, -0.0022623585537075996, 0.015891756862401962, -0.02631860226392746, 0.014243295416235924, -0.002962172031402588, -0.016042543575167656, -0.02971038594841957, 0.0002025248686550185, -0.00024129304802045226, -0.013612180948257446, -0.0402839295566082, -0.0024720015935599804, 0.03684035688638687, 0.008860896341502666, 0.005001645535230637, -0.024208184331655502, -0.03386906534433365, 0.018792571499943733, 0.03373239189386368, 0.03604986146092415, 0.005322655197232962, 0.003933264873921871, 0.00397102627903223, -0.10622774064540863, 0.10583314299583435, 0.04604581743478775, -0.04143606126308441, -0.06066451594233513, 0.003725543152540922, -0.03616362065076828, -0.011998875997960567, 0.06177956238389015, 0.00167419936042279, -0.00652828486636281, -0.010722373612225056, 0.02740336023271084, 0.0005930226179771125, -0.05259312316775322, 0.04892900213599205, 0.0016418694285675883, -0.010815526358783245, -0.007710175588726997, 0.0062805707566440105, 0.022360458970069885, -0.01103846076875925, 0.03133554756641388, -0.04083959385752678, 0.02843848057091236, 0.005029602441936731, 0.025587350130081177, 0.028042588382959366, -0.00639181537553668, -0.044866517186164856, 0.06610523909330368, -0.014833536930382252, -0.0011828374117612839, 0.028808116912841797, -0.003229361493140459, -0.041425466537475586, 0.03989262506365776, -0.027687622234225273, -0.021051913499832153, -0.018940173089504242, 0.008453847840428352, 0.07194341719150543, -0.057353675365448, 0.00959243904799223, 0.0307324081659317, -0.04584085941314697, 0.0022723705042153597, 0.051776498556137085, -0.0033933341037482023, 0.024710243567824364, -0.022116122767329216, -0.015786651521921158, 0.018505554646253586, -0.04110891744494438, -0.022807205095887184, -0.02773427404463291, 0.02820373699069023, -0.026097912341356277, -0.00008523697761120275, 0.03744396194815636, 0.0033400566317141056, 0.024119190871715546, 0.020505642518401146, 0.049737632274627686, -0.041928067803382874, -0.02424125373363495, 0.023347148671746254, -0.014997944235801697, -0.005707917734980583, -0.018974673002958298, 0.0010229668114334345, 0.023336712270975113, 0.005124450195580721, -0.007377201225608587, 0.004029588773846626, -0.020765025168657303, -0.032728783786296844, -0.029716745018959045, 0.02554190345108509, 0.016562728211283684, 0.020535461604595184, -0.016597189009189606, -0.0046894485130906105, 0.02827541157603264, 0.015557592734694481, 0.021086502820253372, 0.04199973866343498, -0.014924873597919941, 0.01722930371761322, -0.011709807440638542, -0.01379477884620428, -0.042742546647787094, -0.060065772384405136, 0.015106158331036568, 0.0012370863696560264, 0.051172271370887756, -0.013717930763959885, 0.008022123947739601, 0.025478467345237732, 0.09294471889734268, -0.043657053261995316, -0.014130228199064732, -0.05926963686943054, -0.0052093700505793095, 0.017873665317893028, -0.02283794991672039 ]
<p>Assume there are two candidate models, $\hat{f}(\beta)$ and $\hat{g}(\beta,\theta)$. If the true data generating process is $f(\beta)$, then $\hat{g}(\beta,\theta)$ is unbiased but inefficient. If, on the other hand, the true DGP is $g(\beta, \theta)$, then $\hat{f}(\beta)$ is biased.</p> <p>Under a classical model selection regime, the analyst begins with $\hat{f}$ and has to reject $h_0:\theta = 0$ in order to justify using $\hat{g}$. The consequence of Type I error is biased estimate of $\beta$, and the consequence of a Type II error is an inefficient model.</p> <p>In a new model selection regime, the analyst begins with $\hat{g}$ and must reject $h_0:\theta\neq0$. The consequences of Type I and Type II errors are now precisely reversed.</p> <p>Is there a statistical advantage to the new method? It seems somehow "safer," but is there a way to justify this statistically? In general, would you prefer risk to be on the Type I or Type II error?</p>
73,811
[ -0.033099643886089325, -0.01496796403080225, 0.03384414315223694, -0.041609711945056915, 0.02719072811305523, 0.02454671449959278, 0.010485476814210415, -0.01627967320382595, 0.07090150564908981, -0.004528308752924204, 0.010529537685215473, 0.01983688957989216, 0.07762764394283295, 0.014549405314028263, 0.03636125102639198, 0.012941441498696804, -0.004928279668092728, 0.023214539512991905, -0.0014786474639549851, -0.03155409172177315, -0.0029332744888961315, 0.013633698225021362, 0.02364375628530979, -0.016670089215040207, -0.032477349042892456, 0.023161929100751877, 0.03513999655842781, -0.01909465342760086, -0.05180615186691284, 0.049525678157806396, -0.03173725679516792, 0.031752657145261765, 0.007713017985224724, 0.04952292889356613, -0.001525952946394682, -0.005006168968975544, 0.0013524678070098162, -0.04366780444979668, -0.0038737072609364986, 0.047748323529958725, -0.04251454770565033, -0.05404976010322571, -0.02331148274242878, 0.011332785710692406, 0.02371797524392605, 0.009117263369262218, -0.03931029513478279, -0.026476707309484482, -0.017210273072123528, -0.05132003128528595, 0.029904736205935478, -0.019278330728411674, 0.009496444836258888, 0.04091719910502434, -0.03219211846590042, -0.0002739086339715868, 0.041521694511175156, 0.077901192009449, -0.036875415593385696, -0.03189738467335701, -0.0313199907541275, -0.03014083206653595, 0.021722102537751198, 0.0006422303267754614, -0.01694469526410103, 0.019214237108826637, -0.005150710232555866, -0.0656731128692627, 0.019066335633397102, -0.019854482263326645, -0.004271561745554209, -0.001759332255460322, -0.011071979068219662, 0.020682010799646378, 0.04941656067967415, -0.01860892027616501, -0.001965882023796439, 0.05189003050327301, 0.06412286311388016, 0.015320979058742523, 0.03267998248338699, 0.0038457068149000406, 0.05112745612859726, 0.036422524601221085, 0.027058634907007217, 0.031294260174036026, 0.06970638781785965, -0.00534947169944644, 0.024915635585784912, 0.030756402760744095, -0.013343583792448044, 0.0012102075852453709, 0.013437803834676743, -0.034309130162000656, -0.017985302954912186, 0.033146750181913376, -0.010193844325840473, 0.06132596731185913, 0.005556171294301748, -0.0055033257231116295, 0.005296670366078615, -0.0315077044069767, 0.0018961562309414148, 0.0351090244948864, -0.01916171796619892, -0.020155921578407288, 0.0021540767047554255, -0.005440100561827421, -0.03405426815152168, -0.0429212749004364, -0.036861810833215714, 0.039072755724191666, -0.022554628551006317, -0.010649820789694786, 0.01654684543609619, -0.02295171469449997, 0.00831898208707571, -0.013808566145598888, 0.0933634340763092, 0.06280870735645294, 0.04256334900856018, 0.005232811905443668, 0.024423323571681976, -0.02763655036687851, -0.02261502854526043, -0.003033170010894537, 0.027281949296593666, -0.0395268052816391, -0.033776748925447464, 0.018889324739575386, 0.015538631938397884, -0.031854547560214996, 0.0269783902913332, 0.02467341162264347, 0.018969379365444183, -0.008163806982338428, -0.07505642622709274, -0.024258563295006752, 0.07065092027187347, 0.008296661078929901, 0.036981649696826935, -0.07161777466535568, -0.0400925911962986, 0.010487642139196396, 0.06974568217992783, 0.013389957137405872, 0.055317748337984085, 0.033286213874816895, 0.037760473787784576, 0.003097147447988391, 0.0007561432430520654, -0.01504038367420435, 0.0061279344372451305, -0.005968346260488033, -0.04894884675741196, -0.10642940551042557, 0.039202772080898285, 0.004334007389843464, -0.016377752646803856, -0.010013245046138763, 0.0218469500541687, -0.025560596957802773, -0.019714536145329475, -0.025118373334407806, -0.01381770521402359, 0.010688727721571922, 0.04542257636785507, 0.009942158125340939, 0.03560999408364296, 0.023538025096058846, 0.04850653186440468, 0.04317891225218773, 0.004672997165471315, 0.04436059296131134, 0.010917908512055874, -0.04372088983654976, 0.009802104905247688, -0.04356151074171066, -0.0008087786263786256, -0.01811278983950615, -0.022409679368138313, -0.0027101936284452677, -0.011471598409116268, -0.02023041620850563, 0.04243805631995201, 0.03801343962550163, -0.0029024998657405376, 0.005235600285232067, 0.0382394976913929, -0.010377644561231136, -0.07163640856742859, -0.08111311495304108, -0.001071215607225895, -0.032379262149333954, 0.0011005040723830462, 0.0555136613547802, 0.0012889256468042731, 0.013372061774134636, 0.008465911261737347, -0.008917845785617828, -0.005666670855134726, 0.0005351245636120439, 0.05237240716814995, -0.05889774486422539, 0.008983989246189594, 0.0494031198322773, 0.009343997575342655, -0.002411971101537347, 0.025790663436055183, -0.0337488166987896, -0.07435794174671173, 0.0037503610365092754, -0.02065785974264145, 0.004313517361879349, -0.0004653525829780847, -0.04184548184275627, 0.0038706911727786064, -0.03568709269165993, -0.006004635244607925, 0.023869819939136505, -0.05614761263132095, 0.053857382386922836, 0.07950882613658905, 0.012189116328954697, -0.002584903733804822, 0.03813064470887184, 0.019126569852232933, -0.008920068852603436, 0.006404621060937643, -0.0029100803658366203, -0.03233170881867409, -0.0004963507526554167, 0.0473327711224556, 0.02573375590145588, -0.04323940724134445, 0.02917793020606041, 0.0597052201628685, 0.0365220308303833, -0.0015904433093965054, 0.01952630840241909, -0.003906690515577793, -0.03494659438729286, 0.02144291065633297, 0.02053862065076828, -0.007415300700813532, -0.007362681441009045, 0.028285229578614235, -0.000215025051147677, 0.002078239107504487, -0.012274237349629402, -0.005278507247567177, 0.06091183051466942, -0.0031666846480220556, -0.011181804351508617, 0.015950480476021767, 0.0030286943074315786, 0.010525067336857319, -0.04284900799393654, 0.01743817701935768, 0.04390694573521614, -0.0012693856842815876, -0.004520878661423922, -0.002178541151806712, 0.00492094224318862, 0.027497673407197, 0.02197759971022606, -0.00722866365686059, 0.017525173723697662, 0.05444604530930519, -0.05608795955777168, -0.019013212993741035, -0.05896574631333351, -0.02685381844639778, -0.041229333728551865, 0.010278170928359032, -0.01607634499669075, 0.0038345023058354855, 0.010027861222624779, 0.0112721286714077, -0.032848723232746124, 0.0027480563148856163, -0.016000881791114807, 0.028999213129281998, 0.01692531257867813, -0.04981117323040962, -0.009655604138970375, -0.06342881172895432, 0.012124375440180302, 0.058740921318531036, -0.01114245317876339, 0.007460032589733601, -0.006396453361958265, 0.04410606250166893, -0.030270667746663094, -0.03668525815010071, -0.0327441431581974, 0.0037026279605925083, -0.003479686798527837, -0.07972139120101929, 0.039207857102155685, -0.009515784680843353, -0.038935430347919464, 0.045304566621780396, -0.05079822614789009, -0.04107162356376648, -0.025571197271347046, 0.010563254356384277, 0.015613360330462456, -0.031781602650880814, 0.020400037989020348, 0.017459455877542496, -0.06007331237196922, 0.010883242823183537, -0.07095755636692047, -0.04566389322280884, 0.0031931260600686073, -0.007446449249982834, -0.01819092594087124, 0.010882837697863579, -0.0075722141191363335, 0.07280926406383514, 0.05720728263258934, 0.009364677593111992, -0.01441468857228756, 0.005631931591778994, -0.04040888696908951, -0.0516786128282547, 0.005652215331792831, 0.00272004003636539, 0.028084011748433113, 0.019589746370911598, -0.019584650173783302, 0.009177100844681263, 0.05111405625939369, 0.015463992953300476, -0.008710037916898727, 0.009257637895643711, -0.017461324110627174, 0.007898742333054543, 0.0013636000221595168, 0.022816389799118042, 0.02625594101846218, 0.0031908147502690554, -0.004925131797790527, 0.024301473051309586, 0.03854210674762726, -0.035257887095212936, 0.031509190797805786, -0.024448519572615623, -0.003132712561637163, 0.013410880230367184, 0.038819048553705215, 0.014710690826177597, -0.009312366135418415, -0.021932533010840416, 0.015608592890202999, 0.061851002275943756, -0.049302056431770325, -0.01279100775718689, 0.006923049688339233, 0.04724319651722908, -0.0035654022358357906, -0.026038335636258125, -0.0021142936311662197, -0.01392151229083538, 0.028973393142223358, -0.018386168405413628, -0.033788662403821945, 0.026126541197299957, 0.04990973696112633, 0.0011611634399741888, -0.016909107565879822, -0.013910125941038132, -0.02651161141693592, -0.05397861450910568, 0.023250654339790344, -0.018956007435917854, 0.059203002601861954, 0.015229185111820698, 0.02033703401684761, 0.014950288459658623, -0.053484778851270676, -0.018642958253622055, 0.01351913157850504, -0.05803871899843216, 0.04233366623520851, -0.004730137996375561, 0.021167706698179245, 0.02578193135559559, -0.006621960084885359, 0.037768635898828506, -0.03676917776465416, -0.0063386098481714725, -0.03364376723766327, 0.03174610808491707, -0.016641804948449135, 0.062039174139499664, -0.029802246019244194, -0.03329716622829437, 0.010757180862128735, 0.016385184600949287, 0.02702614665031433, -0.011251779273152351, 0.020941073074936867, 0.05108826607465744, -0.0051938132382929325, 0.005536176264286041, -0.043313030153512955, 0.03881943225860596, 0.01829150691628456, 0.03038203716278076, 0.031087173148989677, 0.037469375878572464, -0.03007485158741474, 0.009844512678682804, 0.014574007131159306, 0.0448501817882061, 0.04237335920333862, 0.002232797909528017, -0.01026518177241087, -0.06733542680740356, -0.04827362671494484, 0.000017880680388770998, 0.010890823788940907, -0.02542917989194393, -0.029990091919898987, 0.06283897161483765, 0.006721974816173315, -0.013767591677606106, 0.006929830182343721, 0.04521745443344116, 0.014581900089979172, -0.0012306544231250882, -0.01537349633872509, -0.021769318729639053, 0.00689059030264616, -0.04409870505332947, 0.03296738490462303, 0.020522210747003555, -0.021161505952477455, -0.021937817335128784, 0.03583963215351105, -0.005782118998467922, -0.012247662991285324, -0.003811177099123597, 0.05163378268480301, 0.04209916666150093, 0.048903245478868484, -0.022158946841955185, 0.03569909557700157, 0.04486863687634468, 0.048939112573862076, 0.04725385457277298, 0.005152036435902119, -0.07732698321342468, 0.009795754216611385, 0.05387464165687561, 0.031906869262456894, -0.05712924152612686, -0.02254962921142578, -0.026673894375562668, -0.013323900289833546, 0.03845059126615524, -0.0031364664901047945, 0.01930970512330532, -0.06184522435069084, -0.012369881384074688, -0.020368702709674835, -0.020036635920405388, -0.04530055820941925, 0.01728980429470539, -0.004080017562955618, 0.01274312287569046, 0.005644253455102444, -0.0006096205906942487, -0.03232843428850174, -0.0067196134477853775, -0.024089990183711052, 0.04950061812996864, -0.028325630351901054, -0.022043317556381226, -0.01931898295879364, 0.029280928894877434, -0.0054235914722085, -0.06720933318138123, -0.012788224034011364, -0.010196970775723457, -0.031206009909510612, 0.03760591521859169, -0.012775770388543606, -0.05678430199623108, -0.0055520543828606606, -0.0011705426732078195, 0.00916625838726759, 0.017080271616578102, 0.004766932688653469, 0.018494155257940292, 0.02287827618420124, 0.041441820561885834, 0.06658758968114853, 0.029416095465421677, 0.01637650653719902, 0.00961202010512352, -0.0317336730659008, -0.008494206704199314, -0.02265704609453678, -0.042352136224508286, -0.044435348361730576, 0.01784004271030426, -0.023813879117369652, 0.02133263647556305, 0.041134122759103775, 0.04351188987493515, -0.009242868050932884, -0.04090317711234093, -0.012117202393710613, 0.0075528561137616634, -0.005336536094546318, -0.038467079401016235, -0.02417786605656147, 0.042613983154296875, -0.009789583273231983, 0.019111959263682365, 0.001164194312877953, -0.04762833192944527, 0.013787704519927502, 0.0140024833381176, -0.040604762732982635, 0.03506990149617195, -0.028657706454396248, -0.016546929255127907, 0.008844439871609211, -0.034583352506160736, 0.04593143239617348, 0.01658560335636139, 0.020538438111543655, -0.015076477080583572, -0.0615837387740612, -0.006790142972022295, 0.009956277906894684, -0.00013734788808505982, 0.02294870652258396, -0.04816194623708725, 0.024603791534900665, -0.00001663935836404562, -0.016299579292535782, -0.0845341756939888, -0.019277112558484077, 0.009464822709560394, 0.022390000522136688, 0.001925607561133802, -0.018915439024567604, 0.0315675288438797, -0.006068378686904907, -0.038426149636507034, -0.03851952776312828, 0.03143204376101494, 0.010516887530684471, -0.01356602180749178, 0.02034437656402588, 0.05176793783903122, 0.06128871068358421, -0.007062912918627262, 0.00022480405459646136, 0.02977306768298149, -0.055830925703048706, 0.0036277268081903458, 0.0004630355106201023, -0.01992507092654705, -0.04678809270262718, -0.007400420494377613, -0.029208039864897728, -0.032748885452747345, 0.027093075215816498, 0.02478972263634205, -0.019208677113056183, 0.03700953349471092, -0.030067885294556618, 0.015991970896720886, -0.012618271633982658, -0.025472896173596382, -0.037286385893821716, 0.03694366291165352, -0.006930565927177668, 0.00017858637147583067, 0.035030923783779144, -0.0009499213192611933, 0.032173041254282, -0.0011264567729085684, -0.0359218493103981, 0.03180054575204849, 0.026115285232663155, -0.04432244971394539, -0.0014972967328503728, -0.0048408713191747665, -0.040583159774541855, 0.022402051836252213, 0.034375548362731934, 0.03225605934858322, 0.03403373435139656, 0.02452593296766281, -0.01857522875070572, -0.03963552787899971, -0.020094167441129684, 0.03364424407482147, 0.05477934330701828, -0.01385168731212616, 0.05258208513259888, -0.012580333277583122, 0.03041764721274376, -0.006215839646756649, -0.04518108814954758, 0.005211050622165203, -0.008485889062285423, -0.013298632577061653, 0.04915877431631088, -0.014074960723519325, -0.012416566722095013, 0.06461258977651596, -0.023036375641822815, 0.04379238188266754, 0.03210875764489174, 0.0049026841297745705, 0.031353533267974854, 0.0013341758167371154, -0.023439588025212288, -0.01743488572537899, 0.04259827360510826, -0.07064051181077957, -0.0010557069908827543, -0.03204232454299927, -0.02609972655773163, 0.03949848935008049, -0.008605490438640118, -0.020474690943956375, -0.04520486667752266, -0.019763635471463203, -0.07821313291788101, 0.002766072517260909, 0.005908568389713764, -0.03169768303632736, 0.03116552159190178, -0.02309529297053814, -0.0030456893146038055, -0.01276886835694313, 0.020508866757154465, -0.013764028437435627, -0.08331182599067688, -0.04902650788426399, 0.0059509254060685635, -0.05666999891400337, 0.05166736990213394, -0.012540428899228573, 0.0008483393467031419, 0.02139381505548954, -0.021083880215883255, -0.016263946890830994, -0.010005987249314785, 0.02362714521586895, -0.05729471147060394, 0.08725940436124802, 0.0003233016759622842, 0.009504465386271477, 0.025424029678106308, -0.03730414807796478, 0.12220301479101181, 0.07563747465610504, 0.05588887259364128, -0.04507678374648094, 0.0073394556529819965, -0.02257566526532173, 0.013151813298463821, -0.004101036116480827, 0.04438844695687294, 0.016632338985800743, -0.0023338671308010817, 0.031362440437078476, 0.05935325101017952, 0.017947733402252197, 0.015745939686894417, 0.0771682932972908, -0.040325265377759933, 0.026213180273771286, -0.017781071364879608, 0.028941866010427475, 0.01242972631007433, 0.008697998709976673, 0.015297619625926018, -0.015317151322960854, 0.020889131352305412, 0.020034274086356163, 0.011843747459352016, -0.01251857727766037, -0.03057030774652958, 0.011131263338029385, -0.023419523611664772, -0.02937340922653675, 0.01896640844643116, 0.03603034466505051, -0.009307576343417168, -0.008078512735664845, -0.009290742687880993, -0.03878740221261978, 0.020186595618724823, 0.010878435336053371, -0.0335564911365509, -0.015128116123378277, -0.00703566474840045, -0.009175117127597332, -0.034680403769016266, -0.02382744662463665, 0.000001704213559605705, 0.01011575385928154, -0.01988915540277958, 0.0004755878180731088, -0.005128948017954826, -0.023623380810022354, 0.034764599055051804, -0.032098714262247086, -0.05260095372796059, 0.03910000994801521, 0.03228209912776947, -0.03736278787255287, -0.03866276144981384, -0.014142177067697048, 0.005823120474815369, -0.0035721519961953163, 0.0783109962940216, 0.005116680171340704, -0.06620219349861145, -0.04542608559131622, -0.0036630912218242884, 0.0639709010720253, 0.03025318682193756, 0.00645584799349308, -0.03235137462615967, 0.0060473112389445305, -0.06237846612930298, -0.049832575023174286, 0.022137507796287537, -0.0018194004660472274, 0.060138992965221405, -0.0012312366161495447, 0.014702069573104382, -0.010916522704064846, -0.009946001693606377, 0.00831690989434719, -0.00915602222084999, 0.01881486177444458, -0.05819984897971153, 0.021448444575071335, -0.004157822113484144, 0.008835573680698872, 0.02011457458138466, -0.0185934416949749, 0.025622639805078506, 0.0074787321500480175, 0.018831944093108177, -0.07671348005533218, -0.029093466699123383, -0.012734424322843552, -0.0027245478704571724, 0.007971364073455334, -0.0002374141477048397, 0.025720136240124702, 0.010773950256407261, 0.025580206885933876, -0.04029962420463562, 0.025074001401662827, 0.014641057699918747, 0.00959034264087677, 0.01730862632393837, -0.03025156259536743, -0.018205808475613594, 0.004137205891311169, 0.014205770567059517, -0.02030573971569538, -0.01587645336985588, -0.05214961990714073, -0.010334670543670654, -0.009058807976543903, 0.024891117587685585, -0.05203280597925186, 0.012091261334717274, -0.012435615994036198, 0.04789305850863457, 0.003109500277787447, 0.0030470257624983788, -0.01229945756494999, 0.021526746451854706, -0.02116505429148674, -0.021722635254263878, 0.025014664977788925, 0.035616129636764526, -0.016802674159407616, -0.03426783159375191, 0.020097915083169937, 0.04241429641842842, 0.017355890944600105, 0.023954445496201515, -0.009449074976146221, -0.016669567674398422, 0.02357880026102066, -0.029065106064081192, -0.016674434766173363, 0.03937225788831711, -0.021554261445999146, -0.033458903431892395, 0.03457222506403923, 0.053985439240932465, 0.05215757340192795, 0.005783580709248781, 0.01035870611667633, -0.007364929188042879, -0.0027271113358438015, -0.037320591509342194, -0.028246846050024033, -0.005812460090965033, 0.010040055960416794, -0.013343701139092445, -0.022901518270373344, 0.0005460332613438368, 0.01353145856410265, 0.026623070240020752, 0.017056627199053764, 0.012900655157864094, 0.01670726388692856, -0.030328940600156784, 0.019496137276291847, -0.01600714586675167, 0.04019876569509506, -0.0024117992725223303, 0.0127946762368083, 0.0032474996987730265, 0.06301356106996536, -0.015375119633972645, 0.01069504115730524, 0.0059806061908602715, 0.007586713880300522, -0.09397751092910767, -0.04222476854920387, 0.04131018742918968, -0.012800682336091995, 0.04958619549870491, -0.028826143592596054, 0.008997862227261066, 0.036310285329818726, -0.0454261377453804, 0.015970421954989433, 0.006135533098131418, -0.004553609993308783, -0.03680289536714554, -0.035568445920944214, -0.04772889241576195, 0.010049981065094471, 0.040864355862140656, -0.014620356261730194, 0.03975783661007881, -0.004512738902121782, 0.029333731159567833, 0.003398227272555232, 0.0071615735068917274, -0.0013599469093605876, -0.019188301637768745, -0.062691830098629, 0.05532717704772949, -0.061355311423540115, -0.04626113176345825, 0.04099465534090996, 0.03189444541931152, 0.02550377883017063, 0.011692465282976627, 0.014124486595392227, 0.016374487429857254, 0.007802652660757303, 0.04338911175727844, -0.003985743969678879, -0.01711190864443779, -0.008536750450730324, 0.03012697771191597, 0.018803659826517105, 0.010925537906587124, 0.0031796677503734827, -0.035572364926338196, -0.0172500591725111, -0.043267060071229935, -0.015572872012853622, 0.005615694914013147, -0.0020604536402970552, 0.02784668654203415, -0.002546351868659258, -0.009470588527619839, -0.011307917535305023, 0.027942487969994545, -0.021293457597494125, -0.022759729996323586, 0.047528158873319626, 0.013629749417304993, -0.002243578666821122, 0.025279825553297997, -0.04132702574133873, -0.038073133677244186, -0.0017704572528600693, -0.044016238301992416, -0.01684054732322693, -0.05084400251507759, 0.015288706868886948, -0.0032704626210033894, -0.019159050658345222, -0.03321045637130737, -0.007636326365172863, -0.02572900615632534, 0.059003230184316635, -0.05590729042887688, 0.03839080035686493, -0.024959685280919075, -0.017512153834104538, 0.002382473321631551, -0.07115716487169266, 0.061766739934682846, -0.006551018450409174, -0.025097601115703583, 0.009238077327609062, -0.005662687588483095, -0.048235706984996796, -0.0038533485494554043, 0.07196185737848282, 0.016769645735621452, 0.0013058874756097794, -0.019793841987848282, 0.06570697575807571, -0.01761871762573719, -0.04349875450134277, 0.008255809545516968, 0.003172090742737055, -0.017222359776496887, 0.006977710872888565, -0.017169993370771408, 0.017952851951122284, 0.02342883311212063, -0.00852927565574646, -0.02925693430006504, 0.04364066943526268, 0.06577234715223312, 0.004053719807416201, 0.010129567235708237, -0.011766276322305202, -0.012374750338494778, 0.05737394839525223, -0.014412550255656242, 0.018211711198091507, 0.019006941467523575, -0.0173251461237669, -0.050043877214193344, 0.029949620366096497, -0.01880652830004692, -0.029259419068694115, -0.014758467674255371, 0.025550488382577896, 0.004574690945446491, -0.0023499822709709406, 0.018789157271385193, 0.0005419275839813054, -0.033805765211582184, 0.00193053821567446, -0.007783620152622461, 0.003263078397139907, 0.06105561554431915, -0.0007217822130769491, 0.0019805917982012033, 0.031670719385147095, 0.02051137015223503, -0.006008000113070011, 0.029319461435079575, 0.0384705476462841, -0.01689915917813778, 0.04275275021791458, 0.026626937091350555, -0.002185555174946785, 0.028811266645789146, 0.009237013757228851, 0.016904635354876518, -0.04130670055747032, -0.045709751546382904, 0.02319905534386635, 0.010921206325292587, -0.01636023074388504, -0.03514369949698448, -0.004970315378159285, 0.03301246836781502, -0.01193409226834774, -0.03319425880908966, -0.023066667839884758, -0.014357024803757668, -0.010241802781820297, -0.022509118542075157, 0.009884904138743877, 0.04449721798300743, 0.021236542612314224, 0.011116486974060535, -0.02414574846625328, 0.00373268430121243, 0.01430925540626049, -0.0065696570090949535, 0.01841711439192295, -0.0012621738715097308, -0.02623753249645233, -0.025249062106013298, -0.03611990436911583, -0.02835153602063656, -0.023214232176542282, 0.010505171492695808, 0.02698911912739277, 0.042372122406959534, -0.008221148513257504, -0.04775482788681984, 0.010244227014482021, 0.005930874031037092, -0.031211283057928085, -0.02082883007824421, -0.01622353121638298, 0.013581540435552597, -0.004052489995956421, -0.02370009943842888 ]
<p>DISCLAIMER: I don't have a lot of stats experience, so please don't laugh too hard if my question is trivial.</p> <p>I have run an experiment with 5 categorical factors. The factors have anywhere between 2 and 8 levels each. I have one response variable, which is continuous in the range of 0 to 100. All-in-all, I have run a fully factorial experiment with 800-something combinations. Each combination has 10 samples. In total, in R-speak, I have a data frame with 6 columns and 8607 rows.</p> <p>My goal: determine the level of each factor that results in the best performance. For example, I want to be able to say "Performance is generally the best when factor1 is level "A", factor2 is level"C", ..., and factor5 is level "E". Conclusions: always use level "A" for factor1 ....". </p> <p>How do I achieve this?</p> <p>I first thought of PCA, but this isn't quite correct because the components that PCA finds are combinations of factors, but I need to be able to say which factor level is best, for each and every factor. I want to keep the factors in tact.</p> <p>I also thought of ANOVA, which may be what I want, but I'm not sure how to use its output. For example, in R, I get:</p> <pre><code>&gt; summary(aov(...)) Df Sum Sq Mean Sq F value Pr(&gt;F) preprocess 7 21.430 3.061 180.771 &lt; 2.2e-16 *** bugData 2 5.276 2.638 155.782 &lt; 2.2e-16 *** fileData 5 6.462 1.292 76.315 &lt; 2.2e-16 *** param1 2 255.766 127.883 7551.306 &lt; 2.2e-16 *** param2 1 15.579 15.579 919.887 &lt; 2.2e-16 *** Residuals 8589 145.457 0.017 --- Signif. codes: 0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1 </code></pre> <p>I don't know how to interpret these results. Is it that param1 has the largest effect, because it's "Sum Sq" is largest? How do I know what level of param1 is best?</p> <p>So, this is my idea: For each factor, compare the "winning-percentage" of each level against every other level. That is, the number of times that level X "beats" level Y, given that all other factors are equal. I can compare level X and level Y a lot of times, because there are so many other factors and levels of those factors. So, I change the level of the other factors, compare level X and level Y in the current factor, and keep track of who won. Doing this, I should end up with something like "For factor1, levelX beats levelY 85% of the time, and therefore is the better choice."</p> <p>Does this approach make sense? Is there a name for it? Or is there another approach altogether that achieves what I want?</p> <p>Any help or pointers is greatly appreciated. I would prefer if my answer is implementable in R, but I can adapt. I have a very beefy machine to use (16 processors, 196G RAM), so I'm not too worried about the efficiency of the algorithm that solves my problem.</p>
73,812
[ -0.04772350192070007, 0.006845533382147551, -0.006580414716154337, 0.008987542241811752, 0.03573015704751015, -0.0038933565374463797, 0.036747779697179794, -0.034535739570856094, 0.009376723319292068, -0.009083608165383339, 0.018836431205272675, 0.03933631628751755, 0.04789375886321068, 0.01657138578593731, 0.013154170475900173, 0.0006464992766268551, -0.002939264988526702, 0.006416379939764738, 0.004666940309107304, -0.04764999821782112, -0.006968509405851364, 0.013085857965052128, -0.026884213089942932, -0.022404605522751808, -0.010423044674098492, 0.05589618161320686, 0.04381496086716652, -0.05307691544294357, -0.03594408556818962, 0.04810080677270889, -0.03553038835525513, -0.027889849618077278, -0.00529527897015214, 0.0378464013338089, 0.03566882759332657, 0.02926461398601532, 0.019047284498810768, 0.03068108856678009, 0.004405561368912458, 0.03929637372493744, -0.02084195986390114, -0.03172767534852028, -0.011891360394656658, 0.009247426874935627, 0.026157110929489136, 0.03337588161230087, -0.004854109138250351, 0.011795500293374062, 0.017120126634836197, -0.0772138312458992, 0.04648663476109505, 0.02885298989713192, 0.00857930351048708, 0.05236879736185074, -0.05026257038116455, -0.019390884786844254, 0.03540261089801788, 0.051811907440423965, 0.010201875120401382, -0.05693182349205017, -0.012230776250362396, -0.03835669904947281, 0.005012728739529848, -0.0020256752613931894, -0.042318422347307205, 0.037389446049928665, 0.010251135565340519, -0.019640322774648666, 0.009688039310276508, -0.040835414081811905, 0.02101346105337143, -0.040252819657325745, 0.02930206060409546, 0.0028556203469634056, 0.01575012505054474, -0.020461663603782654, 0.02037702314555645, 0.01358055416494608, 0.03210568055510521, 0.05146179348230362, -0.031257834285497665, 0.026008952409029007, 0.00520789111033082, 0.010940805077552795, -0.002469815779477358, 0.026493607088923454, 0.055598579347133636, -0.02973814681172371, -0.028968945145606995, 0.0425211526453495, -0.02756377123296261, -0.01759946346282959, 0.042700786143541336, 0.05164550244808197, -0.04880569130182266, 0.023054061457514763, -0.0016846454236656427, -0.008420797996222973, -0.0095741618424654, -0.008374116383492947, -0.0043775360099971294, -0.011878550983965397, 0.008403049781918526, 0.04714098200201988, -0.012014884501695633, 0.02295420505106449, -0.025363437831401825, -0.030912011861801147, -0.02666257508099079, -0.0046097165904939175, 0.017230594530701637, 0.006792593747377396, -0.002253117971122265, -0.004681280814111233, 0.01821330189704895, -0.024340622127056122, -0.028481099754571915, -0.00380174582824111, 0.07497870177030563, 0.05382414162158966, 0.030936673283576965, -0.0357358381152153, -0.016404859721660614, -0.0029850422870367765, -0.0023433060850948095, -0.007592831272631884, -0.002643898129463196, 0.0027657316531986, -0.01788640394806862, 0.0595303475856781, -0.014293833635747433, -0.043860580772161484, 0.03297347575426102, -0.001717333565466106, 0.0013819830492138863, -0.01955137774348259, -0.07482248544692993, -0.04959799721837044, 0.04022317752242088, -0.049658551812171936, -0.015174725092947483, -0.051184188574552536, -0.006991378962993622, 0.0398380346596241, 0.03458743542432785, 0.00317437294870615, 0.027589622884988785, 0.008030514232814312, 0.017997607588768005, 0.04289768636226654, -0.034241754561662674, -0.020896444097161293, -0.02846449427306652, -0.01802867464721203, -0.0029390021227300167, -0.05166342109441757, 0.0005579525022767484, -0.02103259041905403, 0.027076052501797676, 0.025547122582793236, 0.015920404344797134, -0.0046094367280602455, -0.022326618432998657, -0.01497762929648161, 0.02478257194161415, 0.021706920117139816, 0.03868376836180687, -0.010719609446823597, 0.027905669063329697, 0.019570348784327507, -0.019483471289277077, -0.02168666198849678, 0.0054025473073124886, 0.006973885465413332, 0.059352610260248184, -0.036444563418626785, 0.025946589186787605, -0.053701795637607574, 0.0066384198144078255, 0.015328403562307358, -0.0398818664252758, -0.029543042182922363, -0.008443751372396946, -0.006042427849024534, 0.05034995079040527, 0.05774640291929245, -0.008116145618259907, -0.019100895151495934, 0.05321020260453224, -0.0392426960170269, -0.03527656942605972, -0.0657307356595993, -0.01198799442499876, 0.024659225717186928, -0.05518046021461487, 0.005288741085678339, -0.012942072935402393, 0.008514387533068657, -0.01008286327123642, 0.00034494666033424437, -0.04012275114655495, -0.027628855779767036, 0.042388420552015305, -0.032366249710321426, 0.005970632191747427, 0.020836006850004196, 0.04972195625305176, -0.03509289398789406, 0.06158554553985596, -0.01992391049861908, -0.04964727163314819, -0.00013940216740593314, -0.020098460838198662, 0.03852926194667816, -0.004622820299118757, 0.0006693309405818582, 0.02284643054008484, 0.010114224627614021, -0.042164597660303116, 0.014944959431886673, -0.059790294617414474, 0.046980418264865875, 0.08544321358203888, 0.012488797307014465, -0.014104139059782028, -0.03365207463502884, -0.014110906980931759, 0.031849514693021774, -0.025860624387860298, 0.05145607143640518, -0.027070248499512672, -0.017794298008084297, 0.03616752848029137, 0.0009289469453506172, -0.04731494560837746, 0.010549924336373806, 0.05164453759789467, -0.025263918563723564, 0.04187636077404022, 0.07062234729528427, 0.02661062777042389, 0.01170989591628313, 0.017939966171979904, 0.030005205422639847, 0.0260973758995533, 0.00132078118622303, 0.0405857190489769, 0.018865296617150307, 0.04885660856962204, 0.007168916519731283, 0.017625709995627403, 0.027670085430145264, 0.02150970883667469, -0.008179360069334507, -0.059807948768138885, -0.020650822669267654, 0.0399797298014164, -0.022264394909143448, 0.020375574007630348, 0.045982543379068375, 0.006675336975604296, 0.0038486281409859657, -0.0035478936042636633, -0.04001516476273537, 0.02413630113005638, 0.04319768399000168, -0.035576820373535156, -0.015118350274860859, 0.02447473257780075, -0.0006489948136731982, 0.0026201982982456684, -0.0322919599711895, -0.006921467371284962, -0.03565198555588722, -0.007875793613493443, 0.04694076627492905, -0.006570462603121996, 0.010555549524724483, -0.006588801741600037, -0.005132272373884916, -0.015409902669489384, 0.00667110551148653, 0.04026993736624718, 0.01123391930013895, -0.05599727854132652, -0.037032343447208405, -0.005871141329407692, -0.02122710645198822, 0.05932290107011795, -0.0038959167432039976, -0.044620610773563385, 0.04787759855389595, 0.013262331485748291, -0.048704225569963455, -0.027657700702548027, -0.030267011374235153, -0.006439198274165392, -0.04687497392296791, -0.01925654709339142, 0.009084013290703297, 0.007452401332557201, -0.03705459460616112, -0.007236720062792301, -0.03411407023668289, -0.016440704464912415, 0.021499885246157646, -0.015900177881121635, 0.011507307179272175, 0.004539045970886946, -0.0019530346617102623, 0.027945183217525482, -0.03137160465121269, 0.018771011382341385, -0.06079131364822388, -0.055014897137880325, -0.022498931735754013, -0.003804531181231141, 0.02514917030930519, -0.008634332567453384, -0.02344396710395813, 0.05047979950904846, 0.02916925773024559, -0.06827443093061447, -0.06405507028102875, 0.01519253570586443, -0.013056735508143902, -0.035035520792007446, 0.026145922020077705, 0.010122234933078289, -0.004842528607696295, 0.004545192234218121, -0.05009624361991882, 0.021597126498818398, 0.06358783692121506, 0.018985992297530174, -0.0011822010856121778, 0.011563561856746674, 0.000725192076060921, -0.04112595319747925, 0.011129563674330711, 0.03008520044386387, -0.027538305148482323, 0.027013346552848816, 0.01443046610802412, 0.03090900368988514, -0.01117782760411501, -0.025978371500968933, -0.005636797286570072, -0.023248175159096718, 0.0024294238537549973, -0.03619226813316345, -0.01934579573571682, 0.03474678099155426, -0.030856365337967873, 0.0036452373024076223, 0.021338053047657013, 0.004819563589990139, -0.020724983885884285, 0.029477888718247414, 0.04715718701481819, 0.05361170321702957, -0.01488969475030899, -0.006653820164501667, 0.011775652877986431, 0.013440527021884918, 0.016322342678904533, 0.002725977450609207, 0.005370979197323322, 0.04330126941204071, 0.01290986780077219, 0.004740871489048004, 0.013100639916956425, -0.025901859626173973, 0.052123479545116425, -0.05463502183556557, 0.02438131347298622, -0.05777056887745857, 0.052317749708890915, -0.006313486024737358, 0.05923624709248543, 0.007905509322881699, -0.00033767009153962135, -0.024030592292547226, -0.0005052664782851934, -0.04844995588064194, 0.008992255665361881, 0.03626008331775665, -0.020427023991942406, 0.0048232050612568855, -0.04067809507250786, 0.015427332371473312, -0.022359205409884453, 0.011324221268296242, 0.022711895406246185, 0.044499658048152924, 0.022775575518608093, -0.03302045166492462, -0.013559456914663315, 0.0078821936622262, -0.047411076724529266, -0.011445937678217888, 0.024417463690042496, -0.011410478502511978, 0.05378150939941406, 0.015439087525010109, -0.03487811237573624, 0.018407437950372696, -0.014872102998197079, 0.006246546283364296, 0.003919104114174843, 0.03027021326124668, -0.00021358874801080674, 0.04602379351854324, -0.03822917863726616, 0.05005957931280136, -0.043615084141492844, 0.05389874801039696, 0.023850994184613228, -0.007763679139316082, -0.011391941457986832, 0.013509847223758698, -0.030150873586535454, -0.0038867120165377855, 0.005360629875212908, -0.004026209935545921, -0.02445213496685028, 0.01475861482322216, 0.031989917159080505, -0.07676217705011368, 0.030362965539097786, 0.05395243316888809, -0.023815279826521873, -0.02016996219754219, -0.0335310697555542, -0.02599041350185871, -0.003900660667568445, 0.010363444685935974, 0.03142203763127327, 0.02872382290661335, 0.017499826848506927, -0.010877585038542747, 0.046669770032167435, -0.01289611030369997, -0.061490125954151154, 0.011421950533986092, 0.004743363242596388, 0.02916538156569004, -0.010893044993281364, -0.031054049730300903, -0.02142668515443802, 0.020113276317715645, 0.027270207181572914, 0.03117801994085312, 0.02170650102198124, -0.0826878622174263, -0.027787525206804276, 0.030216533690690994, 0.04147760570049286, -0.02382243052124977, -0.013181394897401333, 0.006170178763568401, -0.040908072143793106, 0.009849519468843937, -0.03251081332564354, 0.052318938076496124, -0.0006291095050983131, 0.04776660352945328, -0.06961659342050552, -0.026551857590675354, -0.03991084173321724, 0.006381678860634565, -0.020268844440579414, 0.0029748084489256144, 0.0032843388617038727, -0.02358395606279373, -0.08763357996940613, -0.01339094340801239, 0.013316897675395012, 0.033744506537914276, -0.008324574679136276, -0.021132702007889748, 0.0342673622071743, -0.002551811281591654, -0.025558387860655785, -0.022366410121321678, 0.033581286668777466, 0.004771288484334946, -0.008483300916850567, 0.06127937138080597, 0.004830570425838232, -0.015420851297676563, 0.030984017997980118, -0.019180133938789368, 0.030509890988469124, 0.014353502541780472, -0.012954534962773323, 0.06686406582593918, 0.020906925201416016, 0.00614565797150135, 0.045490775257349014, 0.02115033194422722, -0.00795807596296072, 0.029820410534739494, -0.033664144575595856, 0.011415504850447178, -0.003377991495653987, -0.07981180399656296, -0.03366152197122574, -0.013292539864778519, -0.0152139225974679, 0.0023624892346560955, -0.014904921874403954, 0.07838641852140427, -0.02317189797759056, -0.011112483218312263, 0.022676603868603706, -0.00037661445094272494, -0.03217931464314461, -0.030681192874908447, 0.04544564336538315, 0.010676738806068897, -0.0006690894952043891, -0.020245665684342384, -0.01615740731358528, -0.007179213222116232, -0.008970496244728565, 0.011793382465839386, -0.04279385134577751, 0.0018018089467659593, -0.04676830396056175, -0.02050876058638096, -0.027691885828971863, -0.034843236207962036, 0.039847616106271744, -0.010602102614939213, 0.05258072912693024, -0.0009625914972275496, -0.06369289010763168, -0.03308924287557602, 0.08998370915651321, 0.03413659334182739, 0.03434910997748375, -0.024838343262672424, 0.022883400321006775, -0.02904362604022026, -0.02413134276866913, -0.06107991188764572, -0.005009947344660759, -0.0027833820786327124, 0.05512114241719246, -0.045674052089452744, -0.014755500480532646, -0.012706777080893517, -0.03750208020210266, 0.03654450923204422, -0.017069395631551743, 0.04180340841412544, -0.031491320580244064, 0.01859024167060852, 0.02571490779519081, 0.018724696710705757, 0.05328601598739624, 0.015622150152921677, -0.008756631053984165, 0.009755647741258144, -0.025049332529306412, -0.008220469579100609, 0.02123514749109745, -0.012270428240299225, -0.04123087227344513, 0.029330376535654068, 0.005415001884102821, 0.024991385638713837, 0.03302610665559769, 0.01696177013218403, 0.021312976256012917, -0.0027825410943478346, -0.013019823469221592, -0.008821467868983746, -0.046821970492601395, 0.0014179171994328499, -0.027164559811353683, 0.02377953752875328, 0.00015454547246918082, -0.00011364577221684158, -0.020809581503272057, 0.010041491128504276, -0.0011933239875361323, -0.010895321145653725, -0.04493702948093414, 0.009345507249236107, 0.05657363310456276, 0.006576623767614365, 0.010807069949805737, -0.04065714031457901, -0.003231022274121642, 0.021701591089367867, 0.027573177590966225, 0.011627987958490849, 0.013439536094665527, 0.012109975330531597, -0.01192514505237341, -0.026700006797909737, -0.044740185141563416, -0.014269974082708359, 0.04757176339626312, -0.02756245620548725, -0.006758261471986771, 0.050188373774290085, 0.01376004796475172, -0.018763834610581398, -0.03848285600543022, -0.029824363067746162, 0.007563851308077574, 0.04442653805017471, 0.0681738406419754, 0.013835884630680084, 0.013282966800034046, 0.002658237935975194, -0.01510432455688715, 0.005126048810780048, 0.01718914695084095, 0.001513836206868291, 0.045003317296504974, 0.013051950372755527, -0.007278828881680965, -0.014323343522846699, 0.016025913879275322, -0.0782993957400322, -0.001078283879905939, -0.017996713519096375, -0.03551371023058891, 0.009773788042366505, 0.02584245428442955, -0.02055799588561058, -0.055417925119400024, -0.03322494402527809, -0.07565172016620636, 0.018354101106524467, 0.0327751487493515, -0.03107241913676262, 0.04966292902827263, 0.015882158651947975, 0.05455053225159645, -0.04228764399886131, 0.029822202399373055, -0.04076239839196205, -0.027941562235355377, -0.02805507555603981, 0.0050748432986438274, -0.035184625536203384, 0.025025371462106705, 0.0005220150924287736, -0.035524312406778336, 0.03989564999938011, -0.03321676701307297, 0.02301713265478611, -0.0009872136870399117, 0.05377284064888954, 0.033475834876298904, 0.030758768320083618, -0.005180785432457924, 0.009093754924833775, 0.01019333302974701, 0.013571039773523808, 0.14858461916446686, 0.0730753019452095, 0.07393426448106766, -0.06085480749607086, -0.002195327542722225, 0.01114196889102459, 0.00748006347566843, -0.026188308373093605, -0.021883392706513405, 0.0034146704711019993, -0.00758837116882205, 0.06916586309671402, 0.05543706193566322, 0.057671841233968735, 0.022909319028258324, 0.033655356615781784, -0.01946028508245945, 0.019752398133277893, 0.013884580694139004, 0.028617994859814644, -0.006341814529150724, -0.014219323173165321, -0.01162367407232523, 0.002349420450627804, 0.032137949019670486, 0.011580387130379677, -0.0416468121111393, 0.0010522184893488884, -0.03806238994002342, -0.02543610706925392, -0.015382091514766216, 0.008942960761487484, 0.013067131862044334, 0.017295874655246735, 0.005871105473488569, 0.004338867962360382, 0.02658957429230213, -0.041912734508514404, 0.004906949587166309, 0.01731191575527191, 0.01864522695541382, -0.010126009583473206, -0.005132941994816065, 0.028731318190693855, 0.0003727619186975062, -0.027934465557336807, -0.03490648791193962, 0.035950466990470886, -0.020701101049780846, -0.013035452924668789, -0.01035518478602171, -0.00048332949518226087, -0.016489576548337936, -0.01868860237300396, 0.023663263767957687, 0.02165250852704048, 0.03372209146618843, -0.014097679406404495, -0.029947323724627495, -0.023858940228819847, 0.010970382019877434, -0.024576738476753235, 0.010612891055643559, 0.005630931351333857, -0.03247319906949997, -0.059091996401548386, -0.03738372400403023, 0.060182515531778336, 0.009794031269848347, -0.027072027325630188, 0.04493575915694237, -0.00878872536122799, -0.020192617550492287, 0.006117367185652256, 0.04518211632966995, -0.019059142097830772, 0.00717513170093298, -0.00807815883308649, 0.006164516322314739, -0.01865551434457302, -0.035309575498104095, 0.0008907706942409277, -0.053509507328271866, 0.004762860480695963, 0.0011389757273718715, 0.00010368759103585035, -0.0005318300682120025, 0.015094694681465626, 0.011402636766433716, 0.00819324143230915, -0.020061224699020386, 0.06735621392726898, 0.009273188188672066, -0.04849123954772949, -0.02218879573047161, 0.008613756857812405, -0.018826309591531754, 0.006472512613981962, -0.014234182424843311, 0.10523007065057755, 0.019278794527053833, -0.01856337860226631, 0.004288817755877972, 0.02092532254755497, -0.020714040845632553, -0.005047968588769436, 0.04295456036925316, -0.04204171523451805, -0.004462024196982384, 0.00450685853138566, -0.02662580832839012, 0.007888881489634514, -0.009461036883294582, -0.04169975221157074, -0.06653030216693878, -0.023597994819283485, -0.03196176886558533, 0.010178969241678715, 0.02982080541551113, -0.00207607657648623, -0.03472115471959114, -0.014037735760211945, 0.011624325066804886, -0.01658712513744831, 0.011502661742269993, -0.010777173563838005, -0.00816394668072462, -0.016731852665543556, 0.061376795172691345, -0.03953827545046806, 0.0019007452065125108, 0.040108822286129, 0.02586190029978752, 0.054553963243961334, -0.03752893954515457, 0.01765979826450348, 0.007029225118458271, 0.049102962017059326, 0.014508064836263657, -0.019050776958465576, 0.00033460379927419126, -0.0441344790160656, -0.03922580927610397, 0.02928105928003788, -0.003130550729110837, 0.051221221685409546, 0.013281606137752533, 0.013124760240316391, -0.03072698973119259, 0.04947424679994583, -0.018221955746412277, -0.023151881992816925, -0.01780891977250576, 0.009487094357609749, 0.030988730490207672, -0.008936039172112942, 0.0062324427999556065, -0.019725361838936806, 0.0012867607874795794, -0.0025253414642065763, 0.04461686685681343, -0.019593235105276108, -0.019699713215231895, 0.019725125283002853, -0.0338461734354496, -0.0032424109522253275, 0.011798454448580742, -0.025142602622509003, 0.03469643369317055, 0.047381043434143066, -0.012990203686058521, 0.000840845808852464, -0.048828188329935074, 0.014501234516501427, -0.09536883980035782, -0.0357503779232502, -0.010718639940023422, 0.018131157383322716, 0.04835609346628189, -0.026125194504857063, 0.016520153731107712, 0.03151119872927666, -0.04069790989160538, 0.03417252004146576, 0.01426355354487896, 0.009779754094779491, -0.024407651275396347, 0.031179439276456833, -0.03845677152276039, 0.01148547325283289, -0.017521396279335022, 0.030125172808766365, 0.0544472336769104, 0.00592418760061264, 0.021034937351942062, -0.03222249820828438, 0.012975539080798626, 0.012671234086155891, 0.024667775258421898, -0.08287690579891205, 0.026090817525982857, -0.037370145320892334, -0.018034012988209724, 0.032590944319963455, -0.014760873280465603, 0.018540916964411736, 0.02039952017366886, 0.03570975363254547, 0.0015401571290567517, 0.08012007921934128, -0.012235542759299278, -0.009149392135441303, -0.03655744716525078, 0.0025806070771068335, 0.006481523159891367, 0.010858245193958282, -0.02511642500758171, 0.03917943313717842, 0.05321427434682846, 0.037098851054906845, -0.038128942251205444, 0.012390609830617905, -0.011976590380072594, -0.008815874345600605, 0.03101743757724762, -0.010253559798002243, -0.008874299004673958, -0.028361981734633446, -0.017294026911258698, -0.019831810146570206, 0.05275852978229523, 0.0043570054695010185, 0.013117223978042603, -0.001510923495516181, 0.003677832195535302, -0.027873756363987923, -0.03351321443915367, -0.01754998229444027, 0.047381699085235596, 0.012735200114548206, -0.009201554581522942, -0.021803220734000206, 0.023764651268720627, -0.034402888268232346, -0.004531894810497761, -0.036560386419296265, -0.023098666220903397, -0.01750013791024685, -0.03080158494412899, 0.0022914535365998745, 0.020455723628401756, 0.0034159128554165363, 0.044356949627399445, -0.1189519613981247, 0.05536523833870888, 0.037735261023044586, 0.00039330305298790336, -0.04105563834309578, 0.03567958250641823, -0.027030102908611298, 0.04694250598549843, 0.0428670309484005, 0.004753374494612217, 0.0031819064170122147, -0.055732473731040955, 0.025866268202662468, 0.020178545266389847, -0.041713595390319824, 0.09260021150112152, -0.023638784885406494, -0.04142456874251366, -0.038513485342264175, 0.03007795289158821, 0.02971780113875866, -0.008736909367144108, 0.005484954919666052, 0.0034707668237388134, -0.015429740771651268, -0.025533543899655342, -0.0173295047134161, 0.03457378223538399, -0.001351554412394762, -0.035708650946617126, 0.02840922772884369, -0.025364739820361137, -0.016087844967842102, 0.04463807865977287, 0.013807510957121849, -0.02369583584368229, 0.03690372407436371, -0.007336894050240517, 0.012368807569146156, 0.003275031689554453, 0.024388756603002548, 0.0030729619320482016, -0.07592353969812393, 0.04099459573626518, 0.021150603890419006, -0.05815356224775314, 0.010803734883666039, 0.04376554489135742, 0.022525187581777573, 0.026732919737696648, -0.005656487308442593, 0.03739377483725548, -0.012278765439987183, -0.031434495002031326, -0.024869250133633614, 0.023470275104045868, 0.018949853256344795, 0.0028572569135576487, -0.005001549609005451, 0.01896071992814541, -0.011458129622042179, 0.01675383560359478, -0.03140782564878464, 0.03491007164120674, -0.00944160670042038, 0.018295392394065857, 0.016751868650317192, -0.036145567893981934, 0.007908260449767113, 0.000756516121327877, -0.022795483469963074, 0.06519682705402374, -0.08396156132221222, -0.02102094516158104, -0.04569721221923828, 0.023273013532161713, -0.03615002706646919, -0.025700297206640244, 0.013770652934908867, 0.03004242107272148, 0.00517677329480648, 0.02677994780242443, 0.010490890592336655, -0.02230517752468586, -0.009809739887714386, 0.0025211337488144636, 0.06672295182943344, 0.004774320404976606, -0.020474236458539963, 0.002248200587928295, -0.0041957637295126915, -0.0681130588054657, -0.03971179947257042, 0.026830002665519714, -0.01962343230843544, 0.01731409691274166, -0.011967293918132782, -0.017095152288675308, 0.023529186844825745, 0.019201083108782768, -0.032403718680143356, -0.005223692394793034, -0.04463937506079674, 0.022541815415024757, -0.0021633526775985956, 0.02732897736132145 ]
<p>I use a MLP with one hidden layer (15 nodes) and one output node. I use a sigmoid activation function, atan as error function, the error itself is calculated with MSE, 5-fold crossvalidation, resilient backpropagation for a batched binary classification task where within each batch approx. 1000 samples are available.</p> <p>My original dataset has a ratio of approx. 30/70 positive vs. negative samples. No matter what NN setup I tried (more features, more samples) the training error didn't go beneath 0.1, the f-measure I used for evaluation was between 0.3-05, precision 0.6-0.8 and recall only between 0.2-0.4.</p> <p>Then I tried oversampling in order to increase the positive/negative value to approx. 1. Now with the same setup I the error decreased only to 0.09, but now I get a constant f-measure of > 0.85 , precision around 0.8 and recall 0.95-1(!?).</p> <p>Now I'm really wondering if my setup is completely wrong or if have found a way to fit my data well.</p> <p>Does anybody have some hints where I might have made a mistake or do you think my setup is ok and my classifier, too?</p>
47,877
[ -0.017940500751137733, -0.011332984082400799, -0.0036802387330681086, 0.017872832715511322, 0.0564151257276535, 0.009985687211155891, -0.02429281361401081, -0.008580947294831276, 0.014392455108463764, -0.025963127613067627, 0.044030047953128815, 0.03752695396542549, 0.04609671235084534, 0.024472061544656754, -0.022310463711619377, -0.029700350016355515, -0.032681431621313095, 0.0010642564157024026, 0.011475631967186928, -0.01946070045232773, -0.012706778943538666, 0.06521043926477432, 0.004545722622424364, -0.027385560795664787, -0.01995007134974003, 0.03475814312696457, 0.008094706572592258, 0.019669828936457634, 0.023472102358937263, 0.06839914619922638, -0.0255495123565197, -0.03193778917193413, 0.02991051971912384, 0.036243412643671036, 0.020728055387735367, 0.018482593819499016, -0.014046486467123032, -0.04228673502802849, -0.057445745915174484, 0.024244558066129684, 0.02146364003419876, -0.009317933581769466, -0.012809108011424541, 0.03096943534910679, 0.006916172802448273, -0.02494249865412712, -0.0017034388147294521, 0.016217375174164772, 0.05695445090532303, -0.04533401131629944, 0.06380271166563034, 0.025032594799995422, 0.018749719485640526, 0.06657250225543976, 0.009149904362857342, -0.01140629593282938, 0.06340613216161728, 0.0662354901432991, 0.0003525374340824783, -0.04697968065738678, 0.008319380693137646, -0.06938805431127548, 0.012134876102209091, 0.01927516795694828, -0.01071840152144432, 0.0356639139354229, -0.008131842128932476, -0.017900701612234116, 0.011448443867266178, 0.010119164362549782, 0.0401032492518425, 0.009873613715171814, 0.01947804167866707, -0.00406285747885704, 0.0010600393870845437, -0.02241714484989643, 0.01960865594446659, 0.01954435557126999, 0.028231598436832428, 0.05175130441784859, -0.007354541681706905, 0.018355509266257286, 0.0015995327848941088, 0.0350944958627224, 0.029908081516623497, -0.004340829327702522, 0.07096492499113083, -0.03435486927628517, 0.03806952387094498, 0.026455527171492577, -0.041874177753925323, 0.023717056959867477, 0.04407881200313568, 0.010103405453264713, -0.0574372373521328, 0.02203521504998207, 0.005246454384177923, 0.015769626945257187, 0.02551998570561409, -0.020496195182204247, -0.024538250640034676, -0.01519222091883421, 0.0034412776585668325, 0.05958009883761406, -0.02127987891435623, 0.0106205390766263, -0.04697210714221001, -0.022633036598563194, 0.024823635816574097, -0.03533189743757248, -0.013441662304103374, 0.026404833421111107, -0.015160284005105495, 0.00403516786172986, -0.006883140187710524, -0.03952210769057274, -0.021790871396660805, -0.019874121993780136, 0.012805386446416378, 0.02602245658636093, 0.036083806306123734, -0.0026565503794699907, 0.04815834015607834, -0.0027784451376646757, -0.03231267258524895, 0.011143038980662823, 0.028851715847849846, -0.007842633873224258, -0.018133698031306267, 0.05020667240023613, 0.02891095168888569, -0.024139493703842163, 0.06529057770967484, -0.004396280739456415, 0.05719538405537605, -0.006540656089782715, -0.07402735203504562, -0.07393168658018112, 0.03776674345135689, -0.01997515559196472, 0.026285318657755852, -0.05580970644950867, -0.0339062437415123, 0.03771673142910004, 0.06837049126625061, 0.036027029156684875, 0.011384175159037113, 0.02563409134745598, -0.003350136335939169, 0.0271877683699131, -0.024837275967001915, -0.0007490416173823178, -0.03059486113488674, 0.021198097616434097, -0.06869577616453171, -0.0581798292696476, 0.041446007788181305, -0.006235053762793541, -0.01724238507449627, -0.00892647448927164, 0.012654325924813747, -0.025062520056962967, -0.002808096818625927, 0.009425914846360683, -0.003926845267415047, -0.055611900985240936, 0.04979409649968147, 0.00658210925757885, 0.04342563822865486, 0.022274209186434746, -0.0334891714155674, 0.0040839132852852345, 0.034783985465765, 0.028156382963061333, 0.05646614357829094, -0.02123279497027397, -0.0005235837306827307, -0.04907413199543953, 0.015288600698113441, 0.03107297047972679, -0.031707849353551865, -0.040648434311151505, -0.035400114953517914, 0.003981486428529024, -0.0023402716033160686, -0.012080797925591469, -0.011027422733604908, -0.028902480378746986, 0.0691533088684082, -0.051379311829805374, -0.04531273618340492, -0.03833020478487015, 0.008601323701441288, -0.05412333831191063, 0.005338342860341072, -0.004062289837747812, 0.0023576957173645496, 0.024334339424967766, 0.0030584963969886303, -0.01166761014610529, -0.013824018649756908, 0.012974869459867477, 0.03161565959453583, -0.0007197413360700011, 0.02089151181280613, 0.051495809108018875, -0.032950084656476974, -0.023744843900203705, 0.04888775199651718, -0.03850894048810005, -0.05096087604761124, 0.02446911856532097, 0.0047115664929151535, -0.005364178214222193, -0.01296904031187296, -0.03379132226109505, 0.036095332354307175, 0.010296790860593319, -0.007726305164396763, 0.06084846705198288, -0.05380446836352348, 0.0815158262848854, 0.059828486293554306, -0.006680448539555073, -0.008657640777528286, 0.03467225283384323, 0.00694573950022459, 0.037269800901412964, -0.05101172998547554, 0.028798438608646393, -0.07442640513181686, -0.01145657617598772, 0.0351044200360775, 0.0004336314741522074, 0.0025252397172152996, 0.02766432799398899, 0.044938717037439346, -0.028335200622677803, 0.04526956379413605, 0.016210488975048065, 0.02336823008954525, -0.04872440546751022, 0.0021621701307594776, 0.040361158549785614, 0.008115665055811405, 0.007274688687175512, 0.01205085963010788, -0.006416690070182085, 0.04367263615131378, 0.003222502302378416, -0.007751148659735918, 0.036927174776792526, -0.006960135418921709, 0.009424247778952122, -0.013523641042411327, -0.00001459383565816097, 0.0015966680366545916, -0.0077004446648061275, -0.018580930307507515, 0.04598916321992874, -0.00799229834228754, 0.014668482355773449, -0.005893139634281397, 0.0031306615564972162, 0.04469677060842514, 0.01721210777759552, -0.007957123219966888, 0.006496007554233074, 0.013363626785576344, -0.04736503213644028, -0.004516384564340115, -0.031659264117479324, -0.011758026666939259, -0.026463603600859642, 0.04426087066531181, 0.024867700412869453, 0.002008457900956273, 0.043662045150995255, -0.0629829689860344, -0.004254025872796774, -0.014168125577270985, -0.01923949643969536, 0.051544614136219025, -0.013073282316327095, -0.04371798411011696, 0.005560641176998615, 0.0004954732139594853, -0.016452200710773468, 0.038467686623334885, -0.005498476326465607, -0.014160088263452053, -0.04064100608229637, -0.0017921766266226768, -0.003557188669219613, -0.04315495118498802, -0.08575735986232758, -0.007695215288549662, -0.004273309372365475, -0.03375684469938278, 0.038141828030347824, -0.001552085974253714, -0.03545953333377838, 0.03245798498392105, 0.013180932030081749, 0.002949789632111788, -0.02689293399453163, -0.004647639114409685, 0.005382959730923176, -0.01471518911421299, -0.021676937118172646, 0.035844750702381134, 0.0022127791307866573, 0.019124042242765427, -0.06322744488716125, -0.06066087633371353, -0.024641070514917374, 0.01040155254304409, -0.0018987393705174327, 0.014411711134016514, 0.028029300272464752, 0.082159124314785, 0.03419394791126251, -0.0084904246032238, -0.03845793381333351, 0.0011974213412031531, -0.016512000933289528, -0.01443455833941698, 0.01492250058799982, 0.02837267331779003, 0.033737778663635254, 0.03675026819109917, -0.03799882531166077, 0.021636510267853737, 0.07685977965593338, -0.02553897723555565, -0.007382597308605909, 0.036849990487098694, 0.000037875885027460754, -0.04696051403880119, 0.043932389467954636, 0.014997925609350204, -0.015449867583811283, 0.031150057911872864, 0.015570415183901787, 0.04135245457291603, 0.01853109896183014, -0.024798573926091194, 0.016091369092464447, -0.018165223300457, 0.004703160375356674, -0.03378612548112869, 0.015542160719633102, -0.014701236970722675, -0.027314769104123116, -0.0352884903550148, 0.018978895619511604, 0.06636255234479904, -0.02986517734825611, 0.0039066835306584835, 0.07884632796049118, -0.0018061635782942176, 0.00404277304187417, -0.03410380706191063, -0.018253561109304428, -0.014820585958659649, -0.009654673747718334, -0.0002746609679888934, 0.026669912040233612, 0.006934746168553829, 0.04142529144883156, 0.021453799679875374, 0.017907900735735893, -0.03618546202778816, -0.006881538312882185, -0.017088213935494423, 0.006973558571189642, -0.02599802054464817, 0.07091096043586731, 0.026396876201033592, 0.009361309930682182, 0.00444795610383153, -0.03925276920199394, 0.013855253346264362, 0.015169634483754635, -0.07193334400653839, 0.036745183169841766, 0.015581979416310787, -0.029735350981354713, 0.013756684958934784, -0.04241972044110298, -0.0012549171224236488, -0.06053534150123596, 0.0010830345563590527, 0.011923772282898426, 0.031006382778286934, -0.029253046959638596, 0.016583263874053955, -0.004470029380172491, 0.027296120300889015, -0.02857552282512188, -0.007258825935423374, 0.011315193958580494, -0.0009205525857396424, 0.01645250804722309, -0.0014470646856352687, 0.0213177427649498, -0.04627609625458717, -0.04692672938108444, 0.023128816857933998, 0.025271959602832794, 0.05791826918721199, 0.016835181042551994, 0.05981019139289856, -0.07309547066688538, 0.03065062314271927, -0.013395844958722591, 0.04116467386484146, 0.03563909977674484, -0.008094286546111107, -0.03284083679318428, -0.08587177842855453, -0.05867404863238335, 0.04853656888008118, 0.015996169298887253, 0.016500256955623627, -0.007596876006573439, 0.05358964577317238, 0.00016958173364400864, -0.060081981122493744, 0.009881925769150257, 0.06658143550157547, -0.006723170168697834, 0.01061917282640934, -0.05486157909035683, -0.009949427098035812, -0.011928042396903038, 0.017929814755916595, 0.04002893343567848, -0.012433058582246304, -0.027129393070936203, -0.0308131854981184, 0.047305211424827576, -0.028372611850500107, -0.025655485689640045, -0.03575604036450386, 0.009146478027105331, 0.032070860266685486, -0.008368859998881817, 0.011217025108635426, -0.005148891359567642, 0.005740910302847624, 0.051351968199014664, 0.01449309941381216, 0.0008098696707747877, -0.11318418383598328, -0.02921368181705475, 0.05021039396524429, 0.044979631900787354, -0.008021431975066662, -0.005066402722150087, -0.05316473916172981, -0.036225683987140656, 0.01017187349498272, -0.04961011931300163, 0.025983385741710663, -0.004308002069592476, 0.020681489259004593, -0.01809845305979252, -0.005505279637873173, -0.022506816312670708, -0.0008515851222909987, -0.035055674612522125, 0.055969394743442535, -0.004689639434218407, -0.032160405069589615, -0.052552230656147, 0.029020046815276146, -0.005893205292522907, 0.06406354904174805, -0.006609267555177212, -0.04240451753139496, 0.0205222200602293, -0.005803171545267105, -0.019786041229963303, -0.08409015834331512, -0.0036859677638858557, -0.03567423298954964, 0.003999120090156794, 0.010335041210055351, 0.009772649966180325, -0.05156742408871651, 0.029349638149142265, 0.0392741896212101, -0.031120218336582184, -0.06506379693746567, -0.04447738453745842, 0.026299364864826202, 0.02233494259417057, -0.002939032157883048, 0.060231249779462814, -0.006096834782510996, -0.00960320234298706, 0.0341874323785305, -0.032717760652303696, 0.013211352750658989, -0.020528826862573624, -0.013940058648586273, -0.03280086815357208, -0.005438074003905058, -0.01859719306230545, 0.04661906883120537, 0.03787541761994362, 0.07029782235622406, -0.0038142427802085876, -0.03535699471831322, 0.00020701716130133718, -0.0074012367986142635, -0.012514709495007992, 0.025370804592967033, 0.007414677646011114, 0.0130300959572196, -0.02715080976486206, 0.01815447397530079, 0.0032831376884132624, -0.02151896059513092, 0.015593056567013264, 0.06642673909664154, -0.04449821263551712, 0.0020341495983302593, -0.008088803850114346, -0.019390769302845, -0.004193771164864302, -0.00526625057682395, 0.036962416023015976, 0.03281308338046074, 0.03617594763636589, -0.009498302824795246, -0.013302028179168701, -0.005982664413750172, 0.014192914590239525, -0.012487788684666157, 0.026462547481060028, -0.052574269473552704, 0.03830881044268608, -0.027224412187933922, 0.016996663063764572, -0.05965263769030571, -0.029828639701008797, 0.014362861402332783, -0.02620161883533001, -0.04264875128865242, -0.02728879079222679, 0.008028628304600716, 0.027043556794524193, -0.001970739336684346, -0.0029408009722828865, 0.06255322694778442, -0.01454325020313263, -0.012536627240478992, 0.02056843973696232, -0.011857377365231514, 0.04947194829583168, -0.053743306547403336, 0.007203374989330769, -0.014846461825072765, -0.015100864693522453, -0.0392053984105587, 0.03005795180797577, 0.016609719023108482, -0.037051428109407425, -0.03043507970869541, -0.01196901872754097, 0.0170351080596447, 0.054962072521448135, 0.0001093427708838135, 0.006886275019496679, -0.0053421915508806705, -0.012063223868608475, 0.014374320395290852, -0.009509840048849583, 0.014835436828434467, -0.0067203654907643795, -0.02788168005645275, -0.005424270872026682, -0.004765297751873732, -0.014131218194961548, -0.024435508996248245, 0.031529251486063004, -0.00838010385632515, -0.023342425003647804, -0.0020012191962450743, 0.08006612956523895, -0.010418606922030449, -0.008866384625434875, -0.015335501171648502, -0.0746833011507988, 0.06002276763319969, 0.03336368873715401, 0.003579117823392153, -0.0044447556138038635, 0.02982071228325367, -0.07657387107610703, -0.01520486082881689, -0.03282585367560387, -0.003100425936281681, 0.03021492063999176, 0.026239780709147453, 0.01210826262831688, 0.011037899181246758, 0.007959439419209957, 0.0076788244768977165, 0.008625869639217854, -0.006707331165671349, 0.00662264646962285, 0.004099303390830755, 0.04142278432846069, -0.012548454105854034, 0.006856026127934456, -0.02861257828772068, 0.032084304839372635, 0.0222042053937912, 0.031174398958683014, 0.013477644883096218, 0.0018782223341986537, 0.004017010796815157, -0.012075589969754219, -0.031112009659409523, 0.024829119443893433, -0.016097551211714745, -0.0010234207147732377, -0.00023835788306314498, -0.03915735334157944, 0.031965699046850204, 0.0244887825101614, 0.0473954901099205, -0.025187959894537926, -0.0249039176851511, -0.03430075943470001, -0.03370948135852814, -0.009328491054475307, 0.0017966711893677711, 0.028368011116981506, 0.008206367492675781, 0.01236272044479847, 0.03148679807782173, 0.020428365096449852, -0.03624049946665764, -0.07775716483592987, -0.02815299667418003, -0.0337577685713768, -0.038034893572330475, 0.029055075719952583, -0.005489678122103214, -0.056902460753917694, 0.04823747277259827, -0.015485109761357307, 0.05470585823059082, 0.005165762733668089, 0.01967107318341732, -0.0011734508443623781, 0.02778559736907482, -0.016690757125616074, 0.03142648562788963, 0.020711882039904594, 0.036929044872522354, 0.11813352257013321, 0.10284698754549026, -0.009249810129404068, -0.04898208752274513, 0.01756107434630394, -0.022492576390504837, -0.019877566024661064, -0.002904444234445691, 0.04483576864004135, 0.006528929807245731, -0.0014001791132614017, -0.012083605863153934, 0.012510986067354679, 0.015762902796268463, -0.030863041058182716, 0.0569111667573452, -0.010553642176091671, -0.008693711832165718, 0.01983349211513996, 0.010002480819821358, 0.018710577860474586, -0.04376080632209778, -0.03194817155599594, 0.00842067040503025, -0.03550947085022926, -0.03491620719432831, -0.0088425874710083, -0.03388534113764763, 0.021986186504364014, -0.017965611070394516, -0.006627068854868412, 0.023408684879541397, -0.020585430786013603, 0.01568324863910675, 0.009297679178416729, 0.013740811496973038, -0.029787778854370117, -0.02389884740114212, 0.009598753415048122, 0.04723487049341202, 0.02810549922287464, 0.0004556802741717547, 0.001299675670452416, -0.0013286072062328458, -0.03948788344860077, -0.05372750759124756, -0.031838562339544296, 0.07617581635713577, 0.015866002067923546, -0.01383217703551054, 0.03142175078392029, 0.021856646984815598, 0.007754877675324678, -0.047279104590415955, -0.001460069790482521, 0.01413883175700903, 0.004217938054352999, -0.00638947356492281, -0.0688055232167244, 0.003113096347078681, 0.03751488775014877, 0.007237081881612539, -0.037399426102638245, 0.01028596330434084, 0.016852015629410744, -0.01324829738587141, 0.0013602768303826451, 0.03765103593468666, 0.021835410967469215, 0.02423991821706295, 0.02178577333688736, -0.00916611310094595, -0.02280823327600956, -0.015171613544225693, 0.007426736876368523, -0.008650706149637699, 0.020154811441898346, -0.012747256085276604, -0.04633757472038269, -0.040407512336969376, -0.062273379415273666, 0.0334993414580822, -0.01423769723623991, 0.0039398642256855965, -0.02984069101512432, -0.0316912978887558, -0.022842692211270332, 0.01457829587161541, 0.02842341922223568, 0.026697518303990364, 0.01830686628818512, 0.032279033213853836, 0.008074723184108734, -0.014981464482843876, -0.012751867063343525, -0.04085984826087952, -0.031125063076615334, 0.01937028206884861, 0.023513313382864, 0.05181651934981346, -0.021855594590306282, 0.03323817625641823, -0.004702515434473753, 0.04577687755227089, -0.022792218253016472, -0.00937661249190569, -0.0005563074955716729, -0.024349380284547806, 0.018663253635168076, -0.02543623000383377, 0.007350004743784666, -0.031870581209659576, -0.03196154162287712, -0.02679089456796646, -0.0471673309803009, 0.0019571033772081137, 0.017987722530961037, -0.030307039618492126, -0.024098854511976242, -0.002711278386414051, 0.020179955288767815, -0.012959920801222324, 0.013923331163823605, -0.009245078079402447, 0.01930098608136177, -0.03332488238811493, -0.011131529696285725, -0.02787187695503235, -0.007535066921263933, 0.0019055537413805723, -0.023312073200941086, 0.033869627863168716, -0.02324322797358036, 0.013484177179634571, -0.022710956633090973, 0.01694134995341301, 0.02716909907758236, 0.04554289951920509, -0.0400422178208828, 0.012298907153308392, 0.06258466839790344, -0.03359658271074295, -0.02664174512028694, 0.03356226161122322, 0.0035769811365753412, 0.03689661994576454, 0.025468790903687477, -0.019362427294254303, 0.019998647272586823, 0.06451203674077988, -0.0007082855445332825, -0.0102259935811162, -0.0036642770282924175, -0.0059218802489340305, 0.017759807407855988, 0.04369153827428818, 0.004889443516731262, -0.011257532984018326, -0.012093670666217804, 0.008123773150146008, 0.02258371002972126, 0.023302119225263596, -0.001972644357010722, 0.025608649477362633, -0.04927229508757591, 0.027583103626966476, -0.009892539121210575, -0.005479582119733095, 0.0029440077487379313, -0.014536556787788868, -0.02775852009654045, 0.020046841353178024, -0.021726565435528755, 0.03380993381142616, -0.05738039314746857, -0.011224295943975449, -0.01838500052690506, 0.012283388525247574, 0.034031398594379425, -0.05579196289181709, 0.0033676340244710445, 0.028782200068235397, -0.02163606323301792, -0.020166752859950066, -0.03216470777988434, -0.012231536209583282, -0.01523519866168499, -0.009266972541809082, -0.03337130695581436, -0.010199072770774364, 0.007540009915828705, 0.013647584244608879, 0.0355786494910717, 0.00517591368407011, -0.03331451863050461, -0.010249803774058819, -0.04692322015762329, 0.04377021640539169, 0.006108161993324757, -0.05126741901040077, 0.002637833124026656, -0.025602692738175392, -0.05812433362007141, 0.04727968946099281, -0.013895751908421516, -0.0038157403469085693, 0.05328088253736496, 0.061206307262182236, 0.026080818846821785, 0.0537106990814209, 0.012386229820549488, -0.015746699646115303, 0.039444707334041595, -0.0018025062745437026, -0.004407178610563278, 0.017677342519164085, -0.01724967546761036, 0.022220607846975327, 0.029116125777363777, 0.00995022151619196, -0.029103638604283333, 0.00726330978795886, -0.02781776152551174, 0.0034278968814760447, -0.011754303239285946, 0.02060014009475708, -0.0047451588325202465, -0.03050466999411583, 0.027282362803816795, -0.01750420220196247, 0.0042936173267662525, 0.02602434903383255, 0.050006430596113205, -0.022918131202459335, 0.009843248873949051, -0.00336832064203918, -0.04419941082596779, -0.042352642863988876, -0.010071950033307076, -0.021901383996009827, -0.012824837118387222, 0.005239091347903013, 0.020603135228157043, 0.00922384113073349, -0.02068176493048668, -0.019472571089863777, -0.040411096066236496, 0.061408571898937225, -0.027162304148077965, 0.04693492874503136, 0.025190776214003563, -0.030244914814829826, -0.005354514345526695, -0.12017057090997696, 0.05714307352900505, 0.0035027863923460245, -0.013652193360030651, -0.02315191552042961, 0.0071705412119627, -0.025451291352510452, -0.0033132683020085096, 0.06337571144104004, -0.004187446553260088, 0.0014077549567446113, -0.005851047579199076, 0.0022038021124899387, 0.02914433553814888, -0.039086975157260895, 0.03891070932149887, -0.019247084856033325, -0.037086959928274155, -0.0276634581387043, -0.026158712804317474, -0.02550574578344822, -0.005423411726951599, 0.0016945133684203029, -0.03490276262164116, 0.002557032275944948, -0.009956059977412224, 0.011163734830915928, 0.03640483692288399, -0.0038838698528707027, -0.019908171147108078, 0.031873319298028946, 0.013545619323849678, 0.0009014334646053612, 0.027177616953849792, 0.00845293328166008, -0.1037803441286087, 0.034463897347450256, 0.03026394359767437, -0.0013229063479229808, -0.035918574780225754, 0.02581098861992359, 0.002744603669270873, -0.07719353586435318, -0.018026301637291908, 0.03597724810242653, -0.023497503250837326, 0.006359807215631008, 0.046462539583444595, 0.00663418136537075, -0.00834088958799839, -0.0073579223826527596, 0.06760448217391968, 0.001320085721090436, 0.02042427472770214, 0.038549795746803284, 0.004002731293439865, 0.0010033260332420468, -0.007935860194265842, 0.047852735966444016, 0.030642380937933922, -0.042556364089250565, 0.050197627395391464, -0.02231108769774437, 0.05183405056595802, -0.033738188445568085, 0.006115511525422335, 0.029018530622124672, -0.012546579353511333, 0.01952378824353218, 0.018412331119179726, -0.01015207264572382, 0.06620803475379944, -0.025654742494225502, 0.02455739676952362, -0.01422029733657837, -0.046837218105793, -0.005405965726822615, 0.006412476301193237, 0.0030100808944553137, 0.05797596648335457, 0.02332431450486183, 0.0035786968655884266, 0.007915145717561245, -0.018613599240779877, 0.03941572457551956, -0.046616390347480774, -0.012807036750018597, -0.0022559859789907932, -0.0040046744979918, -0.01897444948554039, -0.02139408327639103, -0.033736053854227066, -0.020073076710104942, 0.014376111328601837, 0.02083349972963333, 0.001359793241135776, -0.004186422564089298, -0.04297284036874771, 0.01693447306752205, 0.018369875848293304, -0.05820750072598457, 0.002157600363716483, -0.02025166153907776, 0.027402576059103012, -0.002822940470650792, -0.03953360393643379 ]
<p>I am using SPSS to analyse the 3-way mixed model ANOVA of my study. I have split my variables down to interpret simple interaction effects and found that whilst the graph displays an interaction effect between the variables, the spss output (test within subjects and test between subjects) does not display any significant main effect or interaction effect. </p> <p>How should I report this finding? </p> <p>Thanks!</p>
73,813
[ -0.02220538817346096, 0.028525670990347862, -0.03971896320581436, 0.015730883926153183, 0.050638772547245026, 0.031209701672196388, -0.01260586827993393, -0.04168742150068283, 0.038115277886390686, -0.01418850664049387, 0.04060500115156174, -0.0024018092080950737, 0.0507429875433445, 0.025153744965791702, 0.010131238959729671, -0.0008541104034520686, 0.014184324070811272, -0.02050674334168434, 0.036647625267505646, 0.00448570167645812, -0.07417440414428711, 0.017515748739242554, 0.013625124469399452, 0.004619728308171034, -0.0006928162765689194, 0.02790157124400139, 0.046576231718063354, -0.04235275834798813, 0.027689877897500992, 0.03519417718052864, -0.046123478561639786, -0.047804612666368484, -0.016804387792944908, -0.00020139945263508707, 0.016283046454191208, -0.015611360780894756, -0.018491720780730247, -0.016812199726700783, 0.017380785197019577, 0.04418431594967842, -0.017691057175397873, 0.0042922114953398705, -0.005842543672770262, 0.04759753495454788, -0.019362444058060646, 0.015601175837218761, 0.004117319360375404, 0.00842200219631195, 0.04491603747010231, -0.060317374765872955, 0.047578342258930206, -0.010791465640068054, 0.050228383392095566, 0.028167549520730972, -0.004378601908683777, 0.017944084480404854, 0.03914685919880867, 0.0486835278570652, -0.003251111600548029, -0.05329849570989609, -0.0012978712329640985, -0.01977924071252346, 0.0065981135703623295, 0.011071713641285896, -0.056268781423568726, 0.009740783832967281, 0.0010673434007912874, -0.019801991060376167, 0.05769142508506775, 0.022265257313847542, 0.0007087119738571346, 0.0030166730284690857, 0.04352603480219841, -0.0010489759733900428, -0.0038757973816245794, -0.016744598746299744, 0.04809214174747467, 0.0058789243921637535, 0.05887912958860397, 0.03915359452366829, 0.004993867129087448, 0.029231684282422066, -0.004264382645487785, 0.023028895258903503, 0.01580718345940113, 0.010759936645627022, 0.051648445427417755, -0.02137787453830242, -0.013830145820975304, 0.010526740923523903, -0.05207398161292076, 0.03090881183743477, 0.0710797905921936, 0.030121563002467155, -0.019108984619379044, 0.01721232384443283, -0.01086548063904047, 0.0332220084965229, 0.017069196328520775, -0.019808996468782425, -0.01738051511347294, -0.02047118917107582, 0.051357682794332504, 0.03778809681534767, -0.0022010132670402527, -0.0007701340946368873, -0.048025067895650864, 0.012797705829143524, -0.009371781721711159, -0.05255846679210663, -0.002883767941966653, 0.018951525911688805, 0.030531231313943863, 0.005923321004956961, -0.009786454029381275, -0.020651275292038918, 0.0042420681565999985, 0.01549090538173914, 0.04068232700228691, 0.0301415603607893, 0.028650645166635513, -0.046718526631593704, 0.020307395607233047, -0.02434873767197132, -0.049434032291173935, -0.009930438362061977, -0.008713490329682827, -0.043192729353904724, -0.03530557453632355, 0.08154706656932831, 0.02163270115852356, 0.0064416006207466125, 0.018826676532626152, -0.026489803567528725, 0.005317570175975561, 0.0013924888335168362, -0.09472039341926575, -0.044767528772354126, 0.02176009863615036, -0.016174856573343277, 0.022875308990478516, -0.02884242683649063, -0.02001633122563362, 0.029523180797696114, 0.06972964107990265, -0.012281117960810661, 0.006829687859863043, 0.023661842569708824, 0.052534930408000946, 0.016514373943209648, -0.018468758091330528, -0.030567025765776634, -0.024381933733820915, -0.04001173749566078, -0.0010680875275284052, -0.06976859271526337, 0.010059649124741554, 0.029239237308502197, 0.02017040364444256, 0.019904285669326782, 0.013037992641329765, 0.011996318586170673, 0.03286506235599518, 0.009580958634614944, 0.017222091555595398, -0.00033096829429268837, 0.048144496977329254, -0.04006441310048103, 0.044279299676418304, 0.028192074969410896, -0.005709874909371138, -0.0005805609980598092, -0.00680032093077898, 0.07380160689353943, 0.011001897975802422, -0.011959870345890522, -0.03368164226412773, 0.005775317084044218, -0.007204107474535704, 0.0009032216039486229, -0.05002177506685257, -0.015904948115348816, -0.04328340291976929, 0.04132551699876785, 0.016431478783488274, 0.06456319242715836, 0.0000950780522543937, -0.030007267370820045, 0.021908095106482506, -0.031184589490294456, -0.0677637979388237, -0.06067390739917755, 0.005769131239503622, -0.006411490961909294, -0.05641651526093483, -0.007690291851758957, -0.00967868510633707, 0.01562418695539236, -0.013641594909131527, -0.02533082477748394, -0.017097653821110725, -0.0051410505548119545, 0.0459803007543087, -0.036181673407554626, 0.01089315116405487, 0.04189186915755272, 0.059857893735170364, -0.03785499557852745, 0.004778311122208834, -0.02408377267420292, -0.01998424530029297, 0.04477423429489136, -0.014417668804526329, 0.006214049644768238, -0.022252535447478294, -0.03125661239027977, -0.01295403577387333, 0.0660303607583046, -0.02015974372625351, 0.06597886234521866, -0.03529133275151253, 0.07619091868400574, 0.05184420570731163, -0.03040371462702751, -0.010550484992563725, 0.017647257074713707, 0.04658963531255722, 0.0011393680470064282, -0.013144122436642647, 0.014461011625826359, -0.03288187459111214, -0.04214015230536461, 0.03927546739578247, -0.018022727221250534, -0.046183474361896515, -0.013008277863264084, 0.03215549513697624, -0.009303059428930283, 0.0005834177136421204, 0.04522879794239998, -0.007992650382220745, -0.01613820344209671, 0.03506281226873398, 0.02723066322505474, 0.03461534529924393, -0.003315248992294073, -0.0009768710006028414, 0.02699928730726242, 0.05443767458200455, 0.012385011650621891, 0.004982009995728731, 0.05059044063091278, -0.004673405084758997, 0.04885250702500343, -0.01268976740539074, -0.00832525733858347, 0.01808091811835766, -0.040506742894649506, 0.01476506981998682, 0.06503359228372574, 0.004323065746575594, -0.021157605573534966, 0.017420856282114983, -0.022361062467098236, 0.03909004479646683, 0.01825644075870514, -0.027619298547506332, -0.0009472073870711029, 0.012743267230689526, -0.024577539414167404, 0.01668725721538067, -0.022372033447027206, -0.024259483441710472, -0.04532149061560631, 0.026821251958608627, 0.02777744270861149, -0.011541428044438362, 0.03704512491822243, -0.039896685630083084, -0.028208628296852112, -0.01593467779457569, -0.0013882821658626199, 0.024428043514490128, -0.014997059479355812, -0.04186815395951271, -0.006061473861336708, -0.00993496272712946, -0.009383915923535824, -0.003695066086947918, -0.037730272859334946, -0.02737993374466896, 0.010030106641352177, -0.004906094633042812, -0.028169935569167137, -0.03399128094315529, -0.025109384208917618, 0.0033370184246450663, -0.010737488977611065, -0.024693764746189117, 0.02289373241364956, 0.026902008801698685, -0.006948426365852356, 0.005265830550342798, -0.003759009763598442, -0.005601296667009592, 0.024737831205129623, 0.0007483199005946517, 0.01426009926944971, 0.010653315111994743, 0.004307669587433338, -0.0037573331501334906, -0.02819795347750187, -0.030829116702079773, -0.058026332408189774, -0.04756544530391693, 0.0033661893103271723, 0.022271819412708282, 0.011790974996984005, -0.048141829669475555, -0.013702920638024807, 0.05332788825035095, -0.018000224605202675, -0.016354894265532494, -0.0386756956577301, -0.03989025950431824, -0.04442250356078148, -0.03515500947833061, 0.05302061140537262, 0.0001908922422444448, 0.008029789663851261, 0.047012533992528915, -0.01607501320540905, 0.043716028332710266, 0.017601026222109795, 0.03498955816030502, -0.033761296421289444, 0.03133639320731163, 0.005772096570581198, -0.014370421878993511, 0.002121507190167904, 0.04294440150260925, -0.03428514674305916, -0.013397623784840107, -0.00621519610285759, 0.02337772026658058, -0.010436833836138248, -0.03433532267808914, 0.013918832875788212, -0.055068377405405045, 0.03644310310482979, -0.03983820974826813, -0.001245868275873363, 0.04302120953798294, -0.010742666199803352, -0.018833063542842865, 0.017610693350434303, 0.04339255392551422, -0.009750396944582462, 0.009494567289948463, 0.06543298065662384, 0.018337994813919067, -0.01736573688685894, -0.025810670107603073, -0.011665488593280315, -0.012030989862978458, 0.00105338788125664, 0.042874500155448914, -0.01930205337703228, 0.024167196825146675, 0.027674458920955658, -0.0016687678871676326, -0.00012528759543783963, -0.050287794321775436, -0.010454347357153893, -0.0689651146531105, 0.005986043717712164, -0.051680658012628555, 0.013702420517802238, 0.006612676661461592, 0.03742719814181328, 0.0253994632512331, -0.0325741246342659, -0.028162546455860138, -0.004779133480042219, -0.03012310341000557, 0.04657822102308273, -0.01943623460829258, -0.001518464065156877, 0.03498193249106407, -0.027375292032957077, 0.005140792112797499, -0.023250501602888107, 0.0060607618652284145, -0.0065576909109950066, 0.01944039762020111, -0.025728730484843254, -0.007731637451797724, 0.0070009673945605755, 0.01143745705485344, -0.032404929399490356, 0.023651832714676857, 0.00915867555886507, -0.00910919439047575, 0.024583246558904648, 0.025092363357543945, -0.041656557470560074, -0.04519135504961014, -0.028587665408849716, -0.011262508109211922, 0.027192285284399986, 0.05448593944311142, 0.02365720458328724, 0.01654902473092079, -0.03272755816578865, 0.044548243284225464, -0.0017257774015888572, 0.022039761766791344, -0.0010157349752262235, -0.00724035082384944, -0.010588645935058594, -0.015973281115293503, 0.004736038390547037, 0.006370118353515863, 0.023791708052158356, 0.005633916240185499, 0.04019472748041153, 0.027627425268292427, 0.023592008277773857, -0.053069453686475754, 0.02908453904092312, 0.048917483538389206, 0.04131210222840309, -0.008501438423991203, -0.025891607627272606, -0.0025640560779720545, -0.02221485786139965, -0.034162215888500214, 0.02412581816315651, 0.01594850793480873, 0.010440539568662643, 0.0005842216778546572, 0.04944249242544174, -0.0031892708502709866, -0.014467697590589523, 0.017351379618048668, -0.0161312036216259, 0.015394497662782669, 0.03403698652982712, -0.040257539600133896, 0.002497807377949357, 0.04433511570096016, 0.002150157233700156, 0.010897376574575901, -0.01300439890474081, -0.10581085085868835, 0.004661667626351118, 0.06041039153933525, 0.045903027057647705, -0.03133118897676468, -0.015983130782842636, 0.012057134881615639, 0.003938311245292425, -0.012317865155637264, -0.059116847813129425, 0.046775057911872864, -0.03665316477417946, 0.03132012486457825, -0.050339289009571075, -0.020304499194025993, -0.04767350107431412, 0.02900850772857666, -0.008598082698881626, 0.02822873741388321, 0.010211543180048466, -0.029349038377404213, -0.02141742780804634, -0.015771815553307533, 0.011974036693572998, 0.008292627520859241, -0.0040899477899074554, -0.01272874791175127, 0.004025960806757212, 0.04595990106463432, -0.01444997824728489, -0.0581180639564991, 0.050185780972242355, -0.015026258304715157, -0.0076819779351353645, 0.058478496968746185, -0.015479476191103458, -0.011458110064268112, -0.005933871492743492, 0.013539916835725307, 0.00791873224079609, -0.017039667814970016, -0.014950606040656567, 0.0640602707862854, 0.0008655014098621905, -0.03400120139122009, 0.06486377120018005, 0.047133639454841614, 0.004208693280816078, -0.00976397842168808, -0.012610863894224167, 0.025814002379775047, -0.06067349389195442, -0.027959689497947693, -0.01519734039902687, 0.011389639228582382, -0.026507548987865448, 0.03240606561303139, -0.0016036435263231397, 0.031520526856184006, -0.06751501560211182, -0.014450478367507458, 0.018173733726143837, 0.0020514095667749643, 0.0009656039765104651, -0.007986527867615223, -0.0074995639733970165, -0.009990591555833817, 0.003676171414554119, -0.0073438468389213085, 0.002850793767720461, -0.03642404451966286, -0.026573412120342255, 0.0063600302673876286, -0.0069393436424434185, 0.009508994407951832, -0.025030752643942833, -0.057021159678697586, -0.019420674070715904, -0.028275538235902786, 0.00856271106749773, -0.04979052394628525, 0.04233260825276375, -0.01850612834095955, -0.051093220710754395, -0.013698350638151169, 0.02088100090622902, 0.051947981119155884, 0.03478451445698738, -0.02870115078985691, 0.052257731556892395, -0.022631721571087837, 0.003670418169349432, -0.06312037259340286, -0.0711611807346344, 0.029734455049037933, -0.00834132544696331, 0.013261017389595509, 0.001380093744955957, -0.02380644902586937, 0.009610838256776333, 0.0007137236534617841, -0.015499429777264595, 0.019796613603830338, -0.05662515014410019, -0.004240270238369703, 0.0010586577700451016, -0.0012350623728707433, 0.043849341571331024, 0.00998175609856844, 0.008510657586157322, 0.0007237251847982407, -0.008005854673683643, -0.02817855216562748, -0.010705467313528061, 0.004032972734421492, -0.01487477496266365, -0.019291622564196587, -0.009177296422421932, 0.010061351582407951, 0.05986173823475838, -0.01960652507841587, -0.0002539849083404988, 0.010370464064180851, 0.001529524801298976, 0.013446812517940998, -0.024293068796396255, -0.005882165860384703, 0.008566961623728275, 0.011940945871174335, -0.015283883549273014, 0.01243546511977911, -0.04522382840514183, 0.01651996187865734, 0.02992701344192028, -0.042742613703012466, -0.07322387397289276, 0.0008683194755576551, 0.07080894708633423, 0.051027391105890274, 0.03379947319626808, -0.011292444542050362, 0.009640897624194622, 0.011733783408999443, -0.007241364568471909, 0.032518770545721054, 0.010961455292999744, 0.013502252288162708, -0.04121601954102516, 0.0004092710732948035, -0.03430857136845589, -0.017174798995256424, 0.07334385812282562, -0.019422374665737152, 0.02608102560043335, 0.04257947951555252, -0.02273429185152054, -0.039191894233226776, -0.06475762277841568, 0.016118567436933517, -0.014576325193047523, 0.03341640159487724, 0.0507209375500679, -0.00735731003805995, 0.016022326424717903, 0.032144151628017426, 0.028140338137745857, -0.0028041198384016752, 0.049611855298280716, 0.02351764403283596, -0.0030045064631849527, 0.03304438665509224, 0.012175621464848518, -0.052714042365550995, 0.027531398460268974, -0.04065472260117531, 0.0021299163345247507, -0.023284416645765305, -0.015472035855054855, 0.02479451522231102, 0.044018086045980453, 0.013244702480733395, -0.05739276483654976, 0.0026782893110066652, -0.03816543519496918, -0.0171810332685709, 0.02390705980360508, -0.03818027675151825, 0.001678133150562644, 0.018794862553477287, 0.049611646682024, -0.016564862802624702, 0.009226685389876366, -0.04236859083175659, -0.07787894457578659, -0.014962398447096348, -0.03345058858394623, -0.01277492567896843, 0.0541839674115181, -0.044242870062589645, -0.03122272528707981, 0.019957780838012695, -0.03149544075131416, 0.007832369767129421, -0.023626131936907768, 0.022040870040655136, -0.004674278665333986, 0.035174984484910965, 0.02145669236779213, 0.011665920726954937, 0.02923523634672165, 0.020484624430537224, 0.12220796942710876, 0.055019985884428024, 0.029108839109539986, -0.08537662029266357, 0.0440201461315155, 0.00011314494622638449, 0.0074348365887999535, -0.004904354456812143, 0.010171700268983841, 0.006852026097476482, -0.03473479673266411, 0.04392983764410019, 0.06204584613442421, 0.028086792677640915, -0.00744941970333457, 0.05087389424443245, -0.025622857734560966, -0.03956818953156471, 0.007735297549515963, 0.00653429189696908, -0.0013853556010872126, -0.036896713078022, -0.03689979389309883, -0.01036032009869814, -0.022593166679143906, -0.031168801710009575, -0.01124637946486473, 0.0052855429239571095, 0.009479102678596973, 0.01499426644295454, -0.037518441677093506, 0.02553531713783741, 0.010163920931518078, 0.024549484252929688, -0.04982297495007515, -0.040632590651512146, 0.04076017066836357, -0.047468990087509155, 0.012924756854772568, 0.02364763617515564, -0.01782248355448246, -0.0189974308013916, 0.006641129031777382, 0.03110613115131855, -0.06725604832172394, -0.06297089904546738, 0.05194513499736786, 0.03918062150478363, 0.01363092940300703, -0.02492593787610531, -0.055661894381046295, 0.016406822949647903, -0.013911167159676552, -0.03283055126667023, -0.01857488602399826, -0.021517891436815262, 0.017781181260943413, -0.05358569696545601, -0.032532282173633575, -0.04166434705257416, -0.03512490540742874, -0.037299055606126785, 0.03258620202541351, 0.044993408024311066, 0.0010183703852817416, 0.011658098548650742, -0.04350178688764572, 0.008609231561422348, 0.015799622982740402, 0.003445098642259836, 0.0025017252191901207, -0.016571156680583954, -0.018992556259036064, 0.025998713448643684, 0.02863994799554348, 0.03137737140059471, 0.001696800347417593, -0.002120483899489045, -0.010600424371659756, -0.05810592323541641, -0.04568478465080261, 0.013862771913409233, 0.00133209687191993, -0.006530814804136753, -0.03277597576379776, 0.015541900880634785, 0.06748220324516296, 0.050328876823186874, 0.02863796055316925, -0.016053983941674232, -0.019623247906565666, 0.033945828676223755, 0.03490448370575905, -0.035990774631500244, -0.029691750183701515, 0.039467304944992065, -0.037745315581560135, -0.011691566556692123, -0.029211150482296944, 0.03942307457327843, 0.029936959967017174, 0.0350053571164608, -0.013827437534928322, 0.03318352997303009, -0.012844137847423553, 0.028477642685174942, 0.01798231154680252, -0.07151086628437042, -0.0003138486354146153, -0.004520125687122345, -0.011419412679970264, 0.0031830950174480677, -0.021603332832455635, -0.02880849502980709, -0.01053745299577713, 0.0214826837182045, -0.006652642972767353, -0.017612572759389877, 0.010830932296812534, 0.0018582113552838564, 0.020472697913646698, -0.052382782101631165, -0.004588979296386242, -0.09135796874761581, -0.0439702607691288, 0.021437468007206917, -0.014768360182642937, 0.010423521511256695, 0.011311598122119904, 0.0068798731081187725, 0.04620836302638054, 0.04291773587465286, -0.009039568714797497, 0.0015967648942023516, -0.04088699445128441, 0.027235273271799088, 0.009548778645694256, 0.05927160754799843, 0.023574063554406166, -0.020507073029875755, 0.040017303079366684, -0.048814255744218826, -0.03075222112238407, 0.005679370369762182, -0.014637501910328865, 0.057703036814928055, 0.032796937972307205, -0.006132038775831461, -0.040848586708307266, 0.045866575092077255, 0.010347929783165455, -0.031400106847286224, -0.0017273570410907269, -0.007542820181697607, 0.00044684408931061625, -0.000733634049538523, -0.03843162581324577, 0.008376066572964191, -0.020262986421585083, 0.06669390946626663, 0.04734111577272415, 0.02232271619141102, -0.02200803905725479, -0.0027127424255013466, 0.006667828653007746, 0.00533295376226306, 0.029496632516384125, -0.034418076276779175, 0.06706041842699051, 0.02591298334300518, -0.042412564158439636, 0.021029405295848846, -0.029147794470191002, 0.01999448612332344, -0.08569130301475525, -0.01802491955459118, -0.030692175030708313, 0.03410973772406578, 0.021322935819625854, -0.04501557722687721, 0.03048623912036419, 0.028232352808117867, -0.05283908173441887, 0.013591795228421688, -0.015221736393868923, -0.009330907836556435, -0.03636149689555168, -0.01614578440785408, -0.02449740841984749, 0.0037083036731928587, 0.024619219824671745, 0.03032652661204338, 0.00666010519489646, 0.029137086123228073, 0.009509551338851452, -0.005469148978590965, -0.017925595864653587, 0.014202555641531944, -0.0005500686238519847, -0.07911211252212524, 0.021019412204623222, -0.030626118183135986, -0.030891161412000656, 0.033467113971710205, -0.019960004836320877, 0.015109029598534107, 0.04959293454885483, 0.020044220611453056, 0.024842744693160057, 0.05076640099287033, 0.03472692146897316, 0.001682103262282908, -0.0034835445694625378, 0.0024169250391423702, 0.011323487386107445, 0.018993910402059555, -0.004508948884904385, 0.020063085481524467, 0.006673850119113922, -0.04327825456857681, -0.03350013121962547, -0.013790328055620193, -0.025621464475989342, -0.01231531985104084, -0.026885591447353363, -0.010739384219050407, 0.07255499064922333, -0.041186168789863586, 0.0018383985152468085, -0.028242746368050575, -0.0021579170133918524, 0.030372152104973793, 0.016356896609067917, 0.0043443432077765465, 0.00602117320522666, -0.0020834351889789104, 0.0057685235515236855, -0.007168943993747234, -0.014126887544989586, 0.022343315184116364, -0.04493389651179314, -0.021143687888979912, 0.012192504480481148, 0.0009432085207663476, -0.024022160097956657, 0.005781278479844332, -0.0057786135002970695, 0.036936014890670776, -0.024566087871789932, -0.024249907582998276, 0.007916665636003017, -0.04329380765557289, 0.028189048171043396, -0.09346245974302292, 0.06328719854354858, 0.017752379179000854, -0.03148466721177101, -0.06961008906364441, -0.01582123339176178, -0.050807930529117584, 0.009328087791800499, 0.029415728524327278, -0.0011002221144735813, -0.0005956129753030837, -0.03801880404353142, 0.07935144752264023, 0.01463816873729229, -0.03320753946900368, 0.06975512951612473, 0.019747411832213402, -0.008815808221697807, 0.007803762797266245, -0.04509855434298515, -0.0061152176931500435, 0.038224782794713974, 0.008333072997629642, -0.023917680606245995, 0.02406521700322628, -0.00238926918245852, -0.017377955839037895, 0.014710045419633389, 0.012449954636394978, -0.039586227387189865, 0.05363733321428299, -0.007642668671905994, 0.017090843990445137, 0.0676642432808876, 0.028847727924585342, -0.020055174827575684, 0.04835406318306923, -0.00998757965862751, 0.01672164723277092, -0.017965909093618393, 0.026080703362822533, 0.004562041722238064, -0.07360079139471054, 0.017288068309426308, 0.0052347248420119286, -0.01341237686574459, 0.007184324320405722, 0.03510698676109314, 0.0548701286315918, 0.039490967988967896, 0.0322834774851799, 0.013282052241265774, -0.004070972558110952, 0.00030332812457345426, 0.06030000001192093, 0.03247787803411484, 0.02404838800430298, 0.03394446521997452, -0.02728714980185032, 0.038231074810028076, -0.03291638568043709, 0.03531014174222946, -0.013582172803580761, 0.018790025264024734, -0.006984129082411528, 0.0024662341456860304, 0.009678472764790058, -0.021772464737296104, 0.037001948803663254, 0.03419755771756172, 0.004226377233862877, 0.035715360194444656, -0.035164736211299896, 0.020683052018284798, -0.025837844237685204, 0.020477978512644768, -0.028380626812577248, 0.010929293930530548, 0.05742551386356354, 0.02406781166791916, 0.020897096022963524, -0.040679752826690674, -0.01717536896467209, -0.00784487184137106, -0.008356710895895958, 0.008362052030861378, 0.026500551030039787, -0.03534947335720062, 0.008829419501125813, -0.0494106188416481, -0.012053314596414566, -0.02148396335542202, -0.010825881734490395, 0.05619083717465401, 0.0457037054002285, 0.016969675198197365, -0.06697871536016464, -0.023174596950411797, -0.01656153053045273, 0.03811502829194069, -0.03937733173370361, -0.05193604901432991, -0.030470110476017, 0.029647309333086014, 0.0012066990602761507, -0.013829975388944149 ]
<p>Ryan Tibshirani introduced once a more general type of Lasso, where the regularizer is $$\parallel D \alpha \parallel_1$$ instead of $\parallel \alpha \parallel_1$. <a href="http://www.stat.cmu.edu/~ryantibs/papers/genlasso.pdf" rel="nofollow">See paper</a></p> <p>However, there is nearly no discussion about this form and I wonder why since its a great way to deal with derivative smoothness regularizers.</p> <ul> <li><p>Is there an easy way I overlooked to transform a general Lasso to the standard Lasso form? </p></li> <li><p>Which algorithm can be used for the gen. lasso? Currently I only tested quadratic programs, but this is quite slow.</p></li> </ul> <p>Thank you!</p>
73,814
[ -0.04913888871669769, 0.021727830171585083, 0.03751183673739433, -0.043576762080192566, 0.024699533358216286, -0.007661101408302784, -0.04247027635574341, 0.004029701463878155, 0.04041139781475067, -0.045630499720573425, 0.025854675099253654, -0.0016362929018214345, 0.04736793786287308, 0.007081147748976946, 0.015308036468923092, -0.0023133866488933563, 0.015574700199067593, -0.03788495808839798, -0.0014670060481876135, 0.0008745976374484599, 0.02661963738501072, 0.029675142839550972, 0.00507350591942668, -0.016334332525730133, 0.013623332604765892, 0.024048546329140663, -0.010552858002483845, 0.002122935140505433, -0.00009614515875000507, 0.06110343337059021, -0.02989932894706726, -0.022280100733041763, -0.002784411422908306, 0.035866595804691315, -0.007403016556054354, 0.023899346590042114, -0.0036411762703210115, -0.033441852778196335, 0.003761250525712967, 0.07066590338945389, -0.008230363018810749, -0.04193902388215065, -0.0032910897862166166, 0.0499645359814167, -0.02253376506268978, 0.040044885128736496, 0.0180753655731678, -0.02990788035094738, 0.039616845548152924, -0.0556691437959671, 0.08854512870311737, -0.011740465648472309, 0.03441513702273369, -0.0013882503844797611, -0.05396707355976105, 0.0027100550942122936, 0.03253548964858055, 0.06282960623502731, 0.021468190476298332, -0.053126752376556396, -0.017929965630173683, -0.013069236651062965, 0.03407824784517288, -0.009209468960762024, -0.05484180152416229, 0.01227897685021162, 0.0023096632212400436, -0.014172819443047047, -0.025407979264855385, -0.042405396699905396, -0.016308410093188286, -0.011950978077948093, 0.04786134511232376, 0.010552520863711834, -0.0031310373451560736, 0.01652507483959198, -0.023655757308006287, 0.009734316729009151, 0.06650791317224503, 0.03363529592752457, 0.04344796761870384, 0.04024256765842438, 0.020902637392282486, 0.007219366729259491, -0.01907564140856266, 0.008085794746875763, 0.06680108606815338, -0.024592995643615723, -0.012636512517929077, 0.05678010731935501, -0.004880041349679232, 0.019574331119656563, 0.06436388939619064, -0.009485454298555851, -0.029424462467432022, 0.031019920483231544, 0.01430213451385498, 0.008738214150071144, 0.020474940538406372, -0.02018960379064083, 0.010833519510924816, -0.0460607185959816, -0.020202670246362686, 0.03272496908903122, -0.010583216324448586, 0.01495380513370037, -0.011032619513571262, 0.01344864908605814, -0.025089265778660774, -0.01289677806198597, -0.03487841412425041, 0.006355895195156336, -0.019020825624465942, -0.02111797407269478, 0.0005496349185705185, -0.016526443883776665, 0.004220223054289818, 0.009185191243886948, 0.03157525882124901, 0.07406272739171982, 0.010758205316960812, -0.047970205545425415, 0.06523081660270691, -0.055136386305093765, -0.023048684000968933, -0.01624101772904396, 0.017993800342082977, 0.006405381951481104, -0.04827060177922249, 0.02411011978983879, -0.034785639494657516, -0.028814241290092468, 0.03302914649248123, 0.008693342097103596, -0.006196934264153242, -0.01659618690609932, -0.08036716282367706, -0.05509588494896889, 0.03893136605620384, -0.008772511035203934, 0.04804438352584839, -0.08194635063409805, -0.010821836069226265, 0.023640356957912445, 0.0821588933467865, -0.0016040254849940538, 0.03481728211045265, 0.04555381089448929, 0.039635591208934784, -0.028619414195418358, 0.0111327413469553, -0.04361950233578682, -0.010669817216694355, -0.015108209103345871, -0.03437225893139839, -0.05394493043422699, 0.013166842050850391, 0.033832792192697525, -0.02206411398947239, 0.03936387971043587, 0.07632998377084732, -0.010530008003115654, -0.016512300819158554, 0.019997896626591682, 0.008635950274765491, -0.012352966703474522, 0.059252820909023285, -0.0010712990770116448, 0.04735412076115608, 0.02133578062057495, -0.006285835988819599, -0.0076779574155807495, 0.02155781164765358, 0.017925286665558815, 0.013725650496780872, -0.03799915686249733, -0.0161918792873621, -0.009257075376808643, -0.007387187797576189, 0.015377342700958252, -0.009337223134934902, -0.017181290313601494, -0.03486794978380203, 0.013826407492160797, 0.018325354903936386, 0.04676121845841408, 0.0043884506449103355, -0.026613272726535797, 0.04611104354262352, -0.06003497913479805, -0.04037201404571533, -0.04673083499073982, 0.03821304813027382, 0.03867321088910103, 0.0176582969725132, 0.0077946861274540424, 0.008373769000172615, 0.004264045972377062, 0.0118437884375453, -0.013540852814912796, 0.05814424157142639, 0.009110989980399609, 0.030649593099951744, -0.0265145655721426, -0.0012914205435663462, 0.05029299482703209, 0.01254400797188282, -0.039917685091495514, 0.04328359290957451, -0.027478763833642006, -0.0581345334649086, 0.012027157470583916, -0.024949466809630394, 0.05992672219872475, -0.04204336926341057, 0.04396222531795502, -0.010225099511444569, -0.021799083799123764, -0.018226657062768936, -0.01641617901623249, -0.0719103217124939, 0.03495539352297783, 0.06073332950472832, 0.016623688861727715, 0.032849207520484924, -0.03788527473807335, 0.007755069527775049, -0.0018586957594379783, -0.01683349907398224, 0.008696946315467358, -0.03877416253089905, -0.0028987510595470667, 0.046751003712415695, 0.04217090830206871, -0.05639323592185974, 0.026518646627664566, 0.06076960638165474, 0.06485643237829208, 0.04176487773656845, 0.029277747496962547, -0.015525108203291893, -0.01959316059947014, 0.028935683891177177, 0.02332489937543869, 0.026796486228704453, 0.006345883011817932, 0.022120459005236626, -0.006293705198913813, 0.014209868386387825, 0.01319679245352745, -0.011250508017838001, 0.041254445910453796, 0.004450774751603603, -0.01131118182092905, 0.028954394161701202, -0.04401850700378418, 0.03290020674467087, -0.010707881301641464, 0.008173997513949871, 0.02747988887131214, 0.017232658341526985, 0.0218947920948267, 0.0077115558087825775, -0.02406553365290165, 0.04699282348155975, 0.0035427880939096212, -0.02889890968799591, -0.01007516123354435, 0.02242755889892578, -0.05341481417417526, 0.03164193779230118, -0.039292145520448685, 0.0062270741909742355, -0.047722458839416504, -0.0192132405936718, -0.004435519687831402, 0.013439851813018322, 0.011613650247454643, -0.0436619371175766, 0.023673586547374725, 0.023999232798814774, -0.02702980302274227, 0.04368393123149872, 0.03601223975419998, -0.05111025646328926, 0.005135273095220327, -0.06495745480060577, 0.018100924789905548, 0.06464909017086029, 0.03190267086029053, -0.012276602908968925, 0.015709541738033295, 0.0012975061545148492, -0.06868047267198563, -0.06581041216850281, -0.0523625873029232, 0.01326586864888668, -0.02666367031633854, -0.01047538686543703, 0.050053343176841736, -0.017903370782732964, -0.04730414226651192, 0.00998498871922493, -0.016550125554203987, 0.02317359298467636, -0.015368787571787834, -0.010786361061036587, 0.009527524933218956, 0.035416409373283386, 0.026981620118021965, 0.011511284857988358, -0.040956977754831314, 0.03229475021362305, -0.08883760124444962, -0.030269790440797806, 0.016596630215644836, 0.002875720616430044, 0.006833507213741541, 0.0161235723644495, -0.03492625430226326, 0.05350770428776741, 0.02181723713874817, -0.03535524010658264, -0.055742889642715454, 0.03714664280414581, -0.008477038703858852, -0.06106001138687134, 0.02298196591436863, -0.003042740048840642, 0.002236730419099331, -0.009208887815475464, -0.042549196630716324, 0.01789052225649357, 0.09830914437770844, 0.026258297264575958, -0.0003383490548003465, 0.02576461061835289, -0.015942662954330444, 0.016788538545370102, 0.013714983128011227, 0.02194029837846756, -0.010203350335359573, -0.0016333110397681594, -0.022447209805250168, 0.015178783796727657, -0.01731906644999981, -0.06348682194948196, 0.0003733480698429048, 0.007209677714854479, -0.00013647032028529793, -0.030999459326267242, -0.0006411680369637907, -0.0045802234672009945, -0.03650740161538124, 0.00035299366572871804, 0.037123676389455795, 0.02958599664270878, -0.01977521739900112, 0.009709103032946587, 0.02321251854300499, 0.012412406504154205, -0.007272668648511171, 0.0016434770077466965, -0.026701971888542175, -0.02482881024479866, 0.01547987200319767, -0.037729308009147644, -0.020534520968794823, 0.02061815746128559, 0.001204436644911766, -0.008374915458261967, -0.008513360284268856, -0.046361781656742096, 0.030390597879886627, -0.040961526334285736, 0.008701032027602196, -0.01607413962483406, 0.06607815623283386, 0.05776762589812279, 0.06269924342632294, 0.0301137063652277, -0.0011295947479084134, 0.009845414198935032, -0.0018841901328414679, -0.08525268733501434, -0.005539111327379942, -0.018533432856202126, 0.004910536576062441, -0.0006340255495160818, 0.012315252795815468, 0.03320315107703209, -0.0013125805417075753, 0.0002764504461083561, 0.00043410470243543386, 0.02126925252377987, -0.06215869262814522, 0.009408342652022839, 0.006792054511606693, -0.04919727146625519, -0.024025920778512955, -0.0075961388647556305, 0.03504779189825058, -0.015859954059123993, 0.017955845221877098, 0.026692219078540802, -0.006420029792934656, -0.02030578814446926, -0.03267005458474159, 0.042254071682691574, 0.016889793798327446, 0.02780340239405632, 0.02277362160384655, 0.01008573453873396, -0.0323011577129364, 0.0160366278141737, -0.010427952744066715, 0.02309408038854599, 0.011655883863568306, -0.014309348538517952, 0.008190548978745937, -0.0665457546710968, -0.023320022970438004, 0.006948883645236492, 0.014034963212907314, -0.010582503862679005, 0.021589139476418495, 0.002140168333426118, 0.055676233023405075, -0.045302294194698334, 0.010454347357153893, 0.04315289109945297, -0.019517002627253532, -0.006849959027022123, -0.08314232528209686, -0.004291960969567299, -0.00479107815772295, 0.027407532557845116, 0.00816319976001978, -0.024828920140862465, -0.011535067111253738, -0.02065405622124672, 0.008023309521377087, -0.04996731877326965, 0.01159299910068512, -0.03731553629040718, 0.03243676573038101, 0.05638587474822998, -0.010729418136179447, -0.014010531827807426, 0.0035166842862963676, 0.05126631259918213, 0.0457972027361393, 0.03331616893410683, 0.022090177983045578, -0.07205423712730408, -0.03213987872004509, 0.017985332757234573, 0.061303526163101196, -0.005666633602231741, -0.010393958538770676, -0.027538491412997246, -0.056588102132081985, 0.04217606037855148, -0.011158066801726818, 0.012463870458304882, 0.0006871951627545059, 0.003974771127104759, -0.0206849854439497, -0.058330878615379333, -0.02801663614809513, 0.00005007459185435437, -0.0069663566537201405, 0.0611879788339138, -0.01005642767995596, -0.0351654551923275, -0.029681222513318062, 0.0013157286448404193, -0.006087138317525387, 0.048877693712711334, 0.003312144661322236, -0.028221433982253075, 0.0024087284691631794, 0.02139418199658394, -0.030206924304366112, -0.07558118551969528, -0.0022765088360756636, -0.015165617689490318, -0.021648777648806572, 0.05460916832089424, -0.03362889960408211, -0.06941776722669601, 0.005385387688875198, 0.015497498214244843, -0.021475424990057945, 0.012301601469516754, -0.006690099369734526, 0.04382999613881111, 0.034653473645448685, 0.016542691737413406, 0.07379394769668579, 0.03214550018310547, -0.007656436879187822, -0.013141894713044167, -0.05152062326669693, -0.0039339070208370686, -0.02172905020415783, -0.07149036228656769, -0.030622700229287148, -0.016967330127954483, 0.00976797565817833, 0.005276743788272142, -0.027157926931977272, 0.031146494671702385, 0.006640276871621609, -0.05619277432560921, 0.009222728200256824, 0.013493616133928299, -0.022810740396380424, -0.06002896651625633, 0.029840337112545967, 0.036997709423303604, 0.0393020398914814, -0.022174658253788948, -0.0003403698792681098, -0.002203272422775626, 0.024980055168271065, 0.017629262059926987, -0.03685629367828369, 0.023323867470026016, -0.00676525104790926, -0.009690050967037678, 0.019857456907629967, -0.04291906952857971, 0.006100432015955448, 0.0017465217970311642, 0.06691408902406693, 0.0006360773695632815, -0.05286845937371254, 0.0035873802844434977, -0.031856730580329895, -0.011466357856988907, -0.0014907597796991467, -0.07860847562551498, -0.02354448288679123, -0.031169883906841278, -0.0006842704606242478, -0.053919173777103424, -0.025103339925408363, 0.045279838144779205, 0.020085593685507774, -0.026007823646068573, -0.010691032744944096, 0.005025108344852924, -0.014234093949198723, -0.028063002973794937, -0.010992526076734066, 0.06834954023361206, -0.0004528519057203084, 0.025065641850233078, -0.0037486145738512278, 0.04268568754196167, 0.04004610329866409, -0.00853880774229765, 0.017416222020983696, -0.008198298513889313, 0.0010052809957414865, -0.0022442745976150036, -0.04211254045367241, 0.009225141257047653, -0.05038483813405037, 0.0020569954067468643, -0.01979883760213852, 0.004536827094852924, 0.02196650765836239, 0.014979133382439613, 0.006225205026566982, 0.015446314588189125, -0.02945598028600216, 0.013276372104883194, -0.016746213659644127, -0.02917267009615898, 0.02078869752585888, -0.0037950153928250074, -0.013014070689678192, -0.004129402805119753, 0.022948920726776123, -0.02174059860408306, -0.003446632996201515, 0.008052488788962364, -0.005454498343169689, 0.025239747017621994, 0.031024251133203506, -0.01806051656603813, -0.002862764522433281, 0.015411042608320713, -0.019652705639600754, 0.03232121467590332, 0.017251934856176376, 0.02910613641142845, 0.00034682542900554836, -0.004344039596617222, -0.049293357878923416, -0.018393300473690033, -0.04139066860079765, 0.027956465259194374, 0.05785122141242027, 0.04363391548395157, 0.033793967217206955, 0.03050905652344227, 0.00872274674475193, -0.007262290455400944, -0.05032934620976448, 0.006214395631104708, 0.01316269114613533, 0.0005590945947915316, 0.04285359010100365, -0.008387875743210316, -0.010107098147273064, 0.023849764838814735, -0.013179438188672066, -0.010609791614115238, 0.0035554964561015368, 0.005672943312674761, 0.00782542023807764, 0.029822533950209618, -0.037121452391147614, -0.05058823525905609, 0.032495178282260895, -0.02675286866724491, -0.011610561050474644, -0.004252159968018532, -0.01860406994819641, 0.060659974813461304, 0.022634470835328102, 0.021371662616729736, -0.02584557794034481, -0.01410670392215252, -0.04432361200451851, 0.030875368043780327, 0.03532973676919937, -0.008773555047810078, 0.03542151674628258, 0.005383029114454985, 0.04246722534298897, 0.03184907138347626, 0.04364730045199394, -0.00936407782137394, -0.06057427451014519, 0.00812758319079876, 0.009000690653920174, -0.04949920251965523, 0.044824644923210144, 0.024722503498196602, -0.05352277308702469, -0.006839278619736433, -0.04011421650648117, 0.02007158286869526, 0.018169712275266647, 0.04684875160455704, 0.03815165162086487, 0.06121175363659859, -0.003857622854411602, -0.005156563129276037, -0.026092655956745148, -0.0135123860090971, 0.16032181680202484, 0.09361021965742111, 0.056820496916770935, -0.06763038784265518, 0.04468691349029541, -0.03780964016914368, -0.015067536383867264, -0.006626423913985491, -0.01943228207528591, -0.01598512940108776, -0.01604899950325489, 0.01126343198120594, 0.03469432145357132, 0.03578281030058861, -0.00720922090113163, 0.044299717992544174, -0.0404006652534008, -0.007466636132448912, 0.002056805184110999, -0.0022304814774543047, -0.016497880220413208, -0.011614946648478508, -0.005056088324636221, 0.022324496880173683, -0.039455268532037735, -0.054180849343538284, -0.02964746206998825, -0.03286954015493393, -0.0045041367411613464, -0.05243784561753273, -0.008223754353821278, -0.006081273779273033, 0.03224153816699982, 0.011027525179088116, -0.003520480589941144, 0.02026342786848545, -0.008795710280537605, -0.02605791576206684, 0.0011137539986521006, 0.030560825020074844, -0.0024198570754379034, 0.01125690620392561, -0.00944644957780838, -0.020888034254312515, -0.0388663075864315, 0.002633806550875306, -0.05092316120862961, 0.05671512708067894, -0.03165297955274582, 0.00544138764962554, 0.01698390766978264, -0.00705714151263237, 0.0237437691539526, -0.045818980783224106, -0.007706744130700827, 0.016842560842633247, 0.011087963357567787, 0.0009156065061688423, 0.0029683292377740145, -0.004849736113101244, 0.043442826718091965, 0.02064795233309269, 0.025144187733530998, 0.016633592545986176, -0.02517622523009777, -0.01802206039428711, -0.006166126579046249, 0.060267120599746704, -0.012982962653040886, 0.00774455675855279, -0.03735339641571045, 0.015260899439454079, -0.03151175379753113, -0.016178619116544724, 0.031494930386543274, -0.005341933574527502, 0.04894724115729332, -0.0071653095073997974, -0.027861230075359344, -0.0413348525762558, -0.05116964876651764, 0.014094405807554722, -0.01718274876475334, 0.04415004700422287, -0.044393692165613174, 0.016613438725471497, 0.03598495572805405, 0.04350771754980087, -0.0025353701785206795, 0.016360130161046982, -0.03259440138936043, 0.04777346923947334, 0.022984838113188744, -0.009182835929095745, -0.031709395349025726, -0.04200933128595352, -0.005763474851846695, -0.009395669214427471, 0.013876884244382381, 0.08335493505001068, 0.02666485495865345, 0.042613498866558075, -0.04809357598423958, 0.017186390236020088, -0.000765663746278733, 0.029704835265874863, -0.008794263936579227, -0.0634482279419899, 0.0016763416351750493, -0.00003316618312965147, 0.02680104225873947, -0.042843353003263474, 0.00008236232679337263, -0.05125093832612038, -0.02194863185286522, 0.032141439616680145, 0.014542734250426292, -0.027009477838873863, -0.017139310017228127, -0.015217586420476437, 0.04674019291996956, -0.038415756076574326, -0.007699281442910433, 0.011267846450209618, 0.0058301337994635105, -0.061435047537088394, -0.052863262593746185, 0.03564724326133728, -0.0011972092324867845, -0.004500890616327524, -0.008051573298871517, 0.026465008035302162, 0.005506329238414764, 0.016031451523303986, -0.02735603041946888, 0.03000784106552601, -0.016288738697767258, 0.04794555902481079, -0.03351515904068947, -0.013396576046943665, 0.023254789412021637, -0.02695327252149582, -0.03272813558578491, 0.02305692993104458, -0.0016783947357907891, 0.03690652549266815, 0.008301075547933578, -0.007537581026554108, -0.02798428200185299, 0.016419939696788788, 0.006513822358101606, 0.004245263524353504, -0.002943882253021002, 0.000825740396976471, 0.025877827778458595, -0.030105838552117348, -0.014396391808986664, 0.005870344582945108, -0.009930508211255074, -0.022737547755241394, -0.0029667657800018787, -0.0049660117365419865, 0.007395358756184578, 0.02623969502747059, -0.011725575663149357, 0.0052993143908679485, 0.0161603931337595, 0.045331425964832306, 0.04393792152404785, 0.04897206649184227, -0.010006140917539597, -0.029867831617593765, -0.010782022960484028, 0.01794522814452648, -0.08449619263410568, -0.02989940345287323, -0.030668476596474648, 0.029174938797950745, 0.024014590308070183, -0.07217710465192795, 0.0218950267881155, 0.045886438339948654, -0.057528167963027954, 0.054130323231220245, -0.005008309613913298, 0.031527940183877945, -0.02775677852332592, 0.016834862530231476, -0.008422776125371456, 0.03339499235153198, 0.009820732288062572, 0.023072024807333946, 0.034487154334783554, 0.021680304780602455, -0.007585120853036642, -0.004296049941331148, -0.008397162891924381, 0.012339813634753227, 0.006861137226223946, -0.04419311136007309, 0.02892366424202919, -0.021620962768793106, -0.0005697662127204239, 0.02751346118748188, 0.018546121194958687, 0.027763444930315018, 0.019534554332494736, 0.036130089312791824, 0.01186491921544075, 0.023151129484176636, 0.044699545949697495, 0.019539741799235344, -0.0032624434679746628, -0.0053496998734772205, -0.0003920658491551876, 0.021928466856479645, 0.019047942012548447, 0.018138740211725235, 0.035296935588121414, -0.014868474565446377, 0.02500038594007492, 0.027680905535817146, -0.007191501557826996, -0.06205388158559799, 0.017532408237457275, -0.018342331051826477, -0.013541560620069504, -0.011790539138019085, 0.012184463441371918, -0.026845688000321388, 0.0026459209620952606, 0.03436844423413277, -0.006243414711207151, -0.005991949234157801, -0.008816531859338284, 0.007587148807942867, -0.0766557976603508, 0.04404662176966667, -0.04258150979876518, 0.007504917681217194, -0.02764943055808544, -0.009392094798386097, -0.02099311351776123, -0.025165066123008728, -0.016165804117918015, -0.012355196289718151, -0.004247595090419054, 0.026533830910921097, 0.010485486127436161, 0.006631223019212484, 0.013772834092378616, -0.034491006284952164, -0.004179275594651699, -0.06866831332445145, 0.06299591809511185, 0.017824359238147736, -0.06331557035446167, -0.004978772718459368, 0.0012898423010483384, -0.027040261775255203, -0.03926880285143852, 0.06975917518138885, -0.003220893209800124, -0.0061494093388319016, 0.004426479339599609, 0.0291909109801054, -0.00506947236135602, -0.021919099614024162, 0.0026063520926982164, 0.04093918204307556, -0.008167747408151627, -0.011547720991075039, 0.013418848626315594, 0.003537655109539628, 0.02730834111571312, 0.015042241662740707, 0.026315052062273026, -0.007134672254323959, 0.000980124343186617, 0.005304168444126844, 0.02925274521112442, 0.002421862678602338, -0.033309146761894226, 0.028582502156496048, -0.004743864294141531, -0.01961897313594818, -0.003680927213281393, -0.03411886841058731, -0.06119668111205101, -0.017510825768113136, -0.06712508946657181, -0.018307888880372047, -0.03345336392521858, 0.014979803934693336, 0.02886476181447506, -0.019882792606949806, -0.0034677786752581596, 0.0030241101048886776, -0.0318417064845562, -0.008072118274867535, 0.05125413089990616, -0.0021542746108025312, 0.05381627008318901, -0.013137971982359886, 0.016336631029844284, 0.02802276238799095, 0.017307477071881294, 0.009274473413825035, 0.019549395889043808, 0.031469836831092834, 0.013485874980688095, 0.01740076020359993, 0.009780777618288994, -0.03547151759266853, 0.011162854731082916, 0.017315927892923355, 0.02370271645486355, -0.030829614028334618, -0.04413870349526405, 0.024481378495693207, 0.0019258629763498902, -0.0057877846993505955, 0.00466399360448122, -0.03191061690449715, 0.07794692367315292, -0.030264364555478096, -0.02159682661294937, 0.0019506796961650252, -0.023003866896033287, -0.02080962434411049, 0.01699019782245159, -0.01865457184612751, 0.06099019944667816, -0.005670689046382904, -0.0036095031537115574, 0.008591325022280216, -0.028145110234618187, 0.0249380711466074, -0.03894010931253433, 0.036787670105695724, -0.0018443637527525425, -0.019278908148407936, 0.0038801939226686954, -0.03067607805132866, -0.017522623762488365, -0.031403396278619766, 0.014599054120481014, 0.01757173426449299, 0.04050099477171898, -0.04621388763189316, -0.01417980995029211, -0.023421114310622215, 0.03430333361029625, -0.06693748384714127, 0.0027252824511379004, -0.017304612323641777, 0.006462466437369585, -0.004183657933026552, 0.01196112111210823 ]
<p>Someone has surveyed a number of people and put the results in a database (Survey 1). Each observation has additional information that, for any subpopulation (men only, young only, etc.), gives a national-level estimate of the number of people in that subpopulation, as well as a confidence interval for that estimate. As expected, the sum of the estimates for mutually exclusive subgroups (number of men plus number of women) gives the estimate for the total number of people in the population. </p> <p>I don't know how the survey was conducted, the sampling method, etc. All I have is the database. All estimated counts coming from the database are assumed to be log-normally distributed. </p> <p>Someone else has done another survey (Survey 2). A lot more people were interviewed. This survey was not meant to estimate anything -- it was just meant to give information on those people who were interviewed.</p> <p>For the population as a whole, and for any subpopulation, Survey 2 gives an undercount, since not everyone in the population was interviewed. Often, the estimate based on Survey 1 is greater than the count from Survey 2, but that's not always the case.</p> <p><strong>Question:</strong> What is the best way to combine the information from the two surveys? I am fine with an approximate solution.</p> <p>If I only had Survey 1, my point estimate for the number of people in subpopulation A would be E(A). However, from Survey 2, I know that A > $min(A)$. So should I be computing E(A|A > $min(A)$)?</p> <p>Doing so leads to a contradiction. Namely, the sum of estimated counts in mutually exclusive subpopulations comes out to be greater than the estimated count for the entire population.</p> <p>Thank you for your help. I hope this is clear. If not, please ask, I will try to explain. :-)</p>
36,312
[ -0.03268173709511757, -0.02813895046710968, 0.005503777414560318, 0.010072679258883, -0.010608945041894913, -0.013431034050881863, -0.012318354099988937, -0.04693866893649101, 0.010332099162042141, -0.009984144009649754, 0.048215318471193314, 0.05241434648633003, 0.032049428671598434, 0.0162187572568655, 0.01666531339287758, 0.02679196186363697, -0.008931846357882023, 0.030786871910095215, -0.019284123554825783, -0.015291464515030384, -0.028704321011900902, 0.015714865177869797, 0.020655004307627678, -0.019921790808439255, -0.03181542456150055, 0.05178678780794144, 0.0012409668415784836, -0.03905180096626282, -0.0010482158977538347, 0.09920299798250198, -0.04278480261564255, -0.06830117106437683, -0.011009437032043934, 0.023540999740362167, 0.01394564751535654, 0.05175632983446121, -0.041609443724155426, 0.014731517992913723, 0.010775077156722546, 0.025648480281233788, -0.039671890437603, 0.017670385539531708, 0.0177654717117548, -0.010923990048468113, -0.049884650856256485, 0.03674251213669777, -0.0017852153396233916, -0.04957567900419235, 0.03440878540277481, -0.040894296020269394, 0.02956327237188816, 0.003111286088824272, 0.04231984168291092, 0.003888846142217517, -0.022546719759702682, -0.0036791858728975058, 0.016652893275022507, 0.07506141811609268, 0.019351061433553696, -0.03678145259618759, -0.015027294866740704, -0.017955675721168518, -0.0013891314156353474, -0.02089746482670307, -0.03855722025036812, 0.03128422424197197, -0.03115675039589405, -0.019764162600040436, 0.022119279950857162, -0.01306213904172182, 0.03522305563092232, 0.01203545369207859, 0.035152189433574677, 0.014990536496043205, 0.030032912269234657, -0.03213341534137726, 0.015611332841217518, 0.015296944417059422, 0.04794744774699211, 0.017859838902950287, -0.017465949058532715, 0.005771646276116371, 0.05920720472931862, 0.030713535845279694, -0.00558322062715888, -0.011265539564192295, 0.05488439276814461, -0.030335796996951103, -0.015059818513691425, -0.003149712458252907, -0.0015708999708294868, -0.014125136658549309, -0.010078881867229939, -0.0028929461259394884, -0.045466117560863495, 0.0474872812628746, -0.013710759580135345, 0.04688539728522301, 0.01928853988647461, -0.00591503968462348, 0.0049261245876550674, -0.03257014602422714, 0.04534912109375, 0.05293279141187668, -0.00239153322763741, -0.0012034120736643672, -0.015338822267949581, -0.00848325528204441, -0.01352484431117773, -0.0411992110311985, 0.010365421883761883, -0.0018047920893877745, 0.007438322529196739, 0.014243550598621368, 0.008870640769600868, 0.03316690772771835, 0.01088204886764288, -0.01137581653892994, 0.05679812282323837, 0.033758025616407394, 0.03306964039802551, -0.022720985114574432, 0.011897485703229904, -0.04031998664140701, -0.08625815063714981, -0.013969439081847668, -0.011371554806828499, 0.00876227393746376, -0.08162615448236465, 0.035914815962314606, -0.005763772409409285, 0.009621547535061836, 0.042847611010074615, 0.005691096652299166, 0.04377175495028496, -0.004692374262958765, -0.07462973892688751, -0.06225156784057617, -0.004921243526041508, 0.004779075738042593, 0.022849123924970627, -0.0724111869931221, 0.01936594769358635, 0.035931605845689774, 0.0333675891160965, -0.021067064255475998, 0.04393301531672478, 0.0025878429878503084, 0.04445469751954079, 0.014976061880588531, -0.013181138783693314, -0.005487816408276558, -0.04694347828626633, -0.014798101969063282, -0.03252093866467476, -0.09082138538360596, 0.048019424080848694, 0.015532238408923149, -0.013091797940433025, -0.01669696718454361, 0.04871493577957153, 0.03219730406999588, -0.032408490777015686, -0.0033258297480642796, 0.029463883489370346, -0.03366727754473686, 0.067166768014431, 0.018293950706720352, 0.02529716119170189, 0.04114168882369995, 0.0020128909964114428, 0.02771070785820484, 0.002451495500281453, 0.015623701736330986, 0.03566312789916992, -0.03522679954767227, -0.0169016532599926, -0.0059065078385174274, 0.03408313915133476, 0.032389190047979355, -0.04744356498122215, -0.012480574660003185, -0.014340145513415337, 0.004723397549241781, 0.04330817982554436, 0.023313846439123154, 0.003196610836312175, -0.05254519358277321, 0.009950834326446056, -0.04551498964428902, -0.07711391896009445, -0.050472792237997055, -0.021282797679305077, 0.0019253966165706515, -0.01957983896136284, 0.01619603857398033, -0.007257211022078991, -0.008179696276783943, -0.020860392600297928, -0.040025390684604645, -0.03718114644289017, 0.010181759484112263, 0.03251827508211136, -0.05000648647546768, -0.01838412508368492, 0.056449711322784424, 0.03402639925479889, -0.014569402672350407, 0.057633254677057266, -0.023201748728752136, -0.06088201329112053, 0.00452010752633214, -0.033843640238046646, -0.0064600552432239056, 0.04417366534471512, 0.014572838321328163, -0.01634468138217926, 0.0020122600253671408, -0.013504231348633766, 0.009813935495913029, -0.07174869626760483, 0.05987297371029854, 0.058490537106990814, -0.01755225658416748, -0.008981253951787949, 0.047114647924900055, 0.031107427552342415, 0.015124749392271042, 0.0024706858675926924, -0.012040086090564728, -0.07249461859464645, 0.027554523199796677, 0.013917146250605583, -0.021403344348073006, -0.037512488663196564, -0.014676135964691639, 0.04082099720835686, 0.009480012580752373, -0.020097844302654266, 0.025637034326791763, -0.015346013009548187, 0.010610914789140224, 0.02951274998486042, 0.034391265362501144, -0.0224294550716877, 0.04310537874698639, -0.005507247522473335, 0.009252132847905159, 0.005877248477190733, 0.022564711049199104, 0.011074373498558998, 0.015999097377061844, 0.008262722752988338, 0.03869328647851944, -0.007464852184057236, 0.008578954264521599, 0.02621857263147831, -0.0450141541659832, 0.011314105242490768, -0.008759007789194584, -0.01765941083431244, -0.00469152070581913, -0.013712843880057335, -0.02973981574177742, 0.0027407770976424217, 0.04832099750638008, -0.04246051609516144, 0.01013267319649458, 0.026074405759572983, -0.03409268334507942, 0.001728726434521377, -0.04402875155210495, -0.04580545797944069, -0.021491363644599915, -0.013907345943152905, 0.037468139082193375, -0.012960508465766907, 0.04137364402413368, -0.0561898909509182, -0.003498431760817766, -0.0590987429022789, -0.01929798536002636, 0.012245656922459602, 0.016448313370347023, -0.0678536668419838, 0.0031067263334989548, 0.0040528429672122, -0.03239233419299126, 0.022690817713737488, 0.015643158927559853, 0.01146987359970808, 0.03629783168435097, 0.010482918471097946, -0.03503444790840149, -0.023388130590319633, -0.018721479922533035, 0.0463460311293602, -0.011418705806136131, -0.018319372087717056, 0.038876358419656754, 0.014038819819688797, -0.015731552615761757, 0.02953357994556427, -0.044242002069950104, -0.031576789915561676, -0.04075352102518082, -0.001729217474348843, 0.0074849240481853485, 0.015715325251221657, -0.020585060119628906, 0.016574354842305183, 0.004056032281368971, -0.03760645166039467, -0.09739125519990921, -0.04770807549357414, 0.03242971748113632, -0.012049064040184021, 0.031250011175870895, -0.0062143560498952866, -0.02603698894381523, 0.06495221704244614, 0.05271723493933678, -0.03303748741745949, -0.005684986244887114, 0.015762479975819588, -0.01816009357571602, 0.0010304724564775825, 0.02789708413183689, 0.02246495522558689, 0.01260310783982277, 0.053487733006477356, -0.0160147063434124, 0.027334660291671753, 0.02890307642519474, 0.005779470317065716, 0.011107764206826687, 0.028244085609912872, 0.009448926895856857, 0.009411059319972992, 0.06369329243898392, 0.031060636043548584, -0.028455618768930435, 0.003693582722917199, -0.0342547781765461, 0.02368958853185177, 0.017111869528889656, -0.03914450854063034, 0.008041431196033955, -0.03219679743051529, -0.012552999891340733, -0.08173758536577225, 0.06299503892660141, 0.04173923283815384, -0.02700876072049141, 0.016365481540560722, 0.018904034048318863, 0.04286421090364456, -0.03677748888731003, -0.03037630394101143, 0.08211815357208252, 0.07487010955810547, -0.022700555622577667, -0.03459149971604347, -0.009207851253449917, 0.035199377685785294, 0.012780671939253807, -0.007866822183132172, -0.005828538443893194, 0.032743774354457855, 0.07998877018690109, -0.005740636959671974, -0.029860930517315865, -0.06716201454401016, -0.02087646722793579, -0.10035672038793564, 0.004847320262342691, -0.03474891558289528, 0.09014523029327393, -0.00786938052624464, 0.0455719493329525, 0.025678835809230804, -0.0020246386993676424, -0.0029084058478474617, 0.0030672361608594656, -0.07531099766492844, -0.008084839209914207, 0.013167026452720165, -0.01421575527638197, 0.006709875073283911, -0.06571676582098007, 0.03634146973490715, -0.011873714625835419, 0.001608067424967885, -0.02108580246567726, 0.022465242072939873, -0.028471294790506363, -0.011559078469872475, -0.03211336210370064, -0.005908922292292118, 0.04495086520910263, 0.03825328126549721, -0.011530536226928234, -0.007049952168017626, 0.017624231055378914, 0.03410916402935982, 0.0057469019666314125, -0.038970157504081726, -0.03735810145735741, 0.0017917434452101588, 0.007401664275676012, 0.045006539672613144, -0.014103049412369728, 0.03244227543473244, -0.03479895740747452, 0.00448969891294837, -0.0037186071276664734, 0.059094157069921494, 0.014016983099281788, -0.006253382191061974, -0.02271127514541149, 0.0018953223479911685, -0.014600987546145916, 0.0043705482967197895, -0.005440252833068371, -0.014934839680790901, 0.002796685788780451, 0.06374146789312363, 0.0603644885122776, -0.053949207067489624, 0.041416049003601074, 0.03774227946996689, 0.012957943603396416, 0.022758714854717255, -0.024518970400094986, -0.017081763595342636, -0.018326077610254288, 0.014886110089719296, 0.02192535623908043, -0.006283004302531481, -0.006184486206620932, -0.029429404065012932, 0.06917834281921387, -0.018169449642300606, -0.03863966092467308, -0.005160413216799498, 0.03204607218503952, 0.033128805458545685, 0.01915683038532734, -0.03104226663708687, 0.031941916793584824, 0.015440517105162144, 0.03542236611247063, -0.0013310702051967382, 0.029403597116470337, -0.09575571119785309, -0.03517802432179451, 0.056106436997652054, 0.006651447154581547, -0.029095925390720367, -0.010569721460342407, -0.044852375984191895, 0.012143210507929325, -0.0015989368548616767, -0.011111514642834663, 0.003033083165064454, -0.02975171059370041, -0.005152354948222637, 0.009556320495903492, -0.05145515874028206, -0.04102158173918724, -0.0037571347784250975, -0.0022655113134533167, 0.02459925413131714, 0.01551496610045433, -0.02743116021156311, -0.03449641913175583, 0.03403801843523979, 0.050537243485450745, 0.0736895203590393, -0.044717203825712204, -0.03330545499920845, 0.013157225213944912, 0.03928244486451149, -0.014971436932682991, -0.06575918942689896, 0.022046802565455437, -0.022029228508472443, -0.014207964763045311, 0.0312698669731617, -0.008575514890253544, -0.019177522510290146, 0.0239882692694664, 0.005385316908359528, 0.008459108881652355, -0.00014862031093798578, -0.019597742706537247, 0.052261386066675186, 0.01651446335017681, 0.03499380126595497, 0.02414526417851448, -0.0048378389328718185, -0.021606169641017914, 0.021719591692090034, -0.022465486079454422, 0.0025850292295217514, -0.009476901963353157, 0.009051162749528885, -0.04388228803873062, 0.011474767699837685, -0.032980598509311676, 0.008627637289464474, 0.019766511395573616, 0.017404062673449516, -0.03052368201315403, -0.04003133997321129, -0.0008760332711972296, 0.0015771350590512156, 0.01011509820818901, 0.033947546035051346, -0.0013245713198557496, 0.036454442888498306, 0.03621060773730278, -0.017021765932440758, 0.019761284813284874, -0.021907102316617966, -0.0051275077275931835, -0.00271792896091938, -0.06158960983157158, 0.003237187396734953, -0.06239379197359085, -0.04431169852614403, 0.05261152982711792, -0.022522078827023506, 0.02595231868326664, 0.0026742941699922085, 0.053309887647628784, 0.014063572511076927, -0.03141702711582184, 0.008228068239986897, -0.01389465481042862, 0.02121603488922119, 0.02456352673470974, -0.02354249730706215, 0.052015889436006546, 0.03172358497977257, -0.011590255424380302, -0.06534024327993393, -0.019240638241171837, 0.03366483375430107, 0.008008167147636414, -0.01124865934252739, -0.05575438588857651, -0.0038876179605722427, -0.008126086555421352, -0.01105374563485384, 0.006786041427403688, 0.04979073628783226, -0.0017347526736557484, -0.024770576506853104, -0.024527963250875473, 0.05480051413178444, 0.08015845715999603, -0.013271772302687168, 0.030245983973145485, 0.028635982424020767, 0.011200583539903164, -0.00400239322334528, -0.014315015636384487, 0.02887824736535549, -0.02742084488272667, -0.01637205295264721, -0.004655344877392054, 0.009716627188026905, 0.051888708025217056, -0.008368537761271, 0.016400370746850967, 0.050060778856277466, -0.00532842893153429, -0.020895326510071754, 0.0077643971890211105, -0.021740885451436043, -0.010955735109746456, 0.028540700674057007, -0.04697103798389435, 0.02626049518585205, -0.004749547690153122, 0.00861454475671053, 0.029795749112963676, -0.01680733449757099, -0.04618130624294281, -0.0036430987529456615, 0.05834565311670303, -0.0072951228357851505, -0.003235957818105817, -0.0006321187829598784, -0.0005442880792543292, 0.06468886882066727, 0.0007526109693571925, -0.010462197475135326, 0.04587381333112717, 0.05332642421126366, -0.03027764894068241, -0.006249731406569481, -0.01596878655254841, 0.020802857354283333, 0.03715156763792038, -0.01634584553539753, 0.057669419795274734, 0.030428986996412277, 0.012752961367368698, -0.0060092792846262455, -0.030709119513630867, -0.014673115685582161, -0.003490371396765113, -0.0034287767484784126, 0.027003776282072067, -0.012173607014119625, -0.008869217708706856, 0.023136725649237633, 0.008112821727991104, 0.012821733951568604, 0.0038356618024408817, 0.014143380336463451, 0.034962814301252365, -0.014993545599281788, -0.0236155167222023, -0.03502723574638367, 0.03721064329147339, -0.0448029600083828, -0.03386642783880234, -0.00017474159540142864, -0.024473411962389946, 0.0364273339509964, 0.002611675765365362, 0.018395446240901947, -0.02012263610959053, -0.021195238456130028, -0.043931521475315094, -0.03863173723220825, 0.006013948004692793, -0.0011978457914665341, 0.029434410855174065, -0.029291965067386627, 0.01855911687016487, -0.013822978362441063, -0.0024335230700671673, -0.03707408905029297, -0.09085889905691147, -0.046228427439928055, -0.027454359456896782, -0.06205875426530838, 0.013110578991472721, 0.013678093440830708, -0.00033866273588500917, 0.039939332753419876, -0.038356222212314606, 0.0021580413449555635, 0.01680172048509121, 0.03094935044646263, -0.018186872825026512, 0.051479533314704895, 0.03414304181933403, 0.06828051805496216, -0.03710488975048065, -0.006966029293835163, 0.12016364932060242, 0.03840676322579384, 0.06053318828344345, -0.07244974374771118, 0.04221285134553909, 0.0339890755712986, 0.006930316332727671, -0.0028424072079360485, -0.013682281598448753, 0.0121497493237257, -0.010878000408411026, 0.04452623426914215, 0.045327361673116684, 0.0036376281641423702, 0.01167487632483244, 0.05218486115336418, -0.04567904770374298, -0.02901441976428032, 0.045212272554636, 0.006975657306611538, 0.005556353833526373, -0.031717125326395035, -0.02807178534567356, 0.015478686429560184, 0.006867686752229929, -0.020677516236901283, -0.010849753394722939, -0.018041500821709633, -0.004493635147809982, -0.008055194281041622, -0.02814962901175022, 0.0256314929574728, 0.025442615151405334, -0.02115504816174507, 0.003549360204488039, -0.02274344116449356, -0.005347761791199446, -0.018347274512052536, 0.008260922506451607, 0.02905506081879139, -0.03282427787780762, 0.013750722631812096, 0.017907610163092613, 0.02857297845184803, -0.050159621983766556, -0.0062926700338721275, -0.03460818901658058, 0.032828230410814285, -0.031107433140277863, 0.013485427014529705, -0.03226511925458908, -0.01652682200074196, -0.05233199894428253, -0.005839018616825342, -0.013575459830462933, -0.008680001832544804, 0.033847562968730927, 0.006868673954159021, -0.04736686125397682, -0.013269406743347645, 0.043036025017499924, -0.010592233389616013, -0.00243170652538538, 0.042819030582904816, -0.046036217361688614, -0.010758906602859497, 0.00867132842540741, 0.026906752958893776, -0.019744254648685455, 0.0019973774906247854, -0.0025992169976234436, -0.0036955324467271566, -0.02602030523121357, -0.02573353238403797, -0.0007312070811167359, -0.007377984002232552, 0.058761611580848694, -0.02146107330918312, 0.0074705579318106174, -0.002977136755362153, -0.03470831736922264, -0.005097095388919115, -0.026717515662312508, 0.02038038708269596, -0.03380176052451134, 0.007768180686980486, 0.007383652031421661, -0.011422544717788696, 0.008044489659368992, -0.012990923598408699, 0.016050497069954872, 0.07923441380262375, -0.020877284929156303, -0.03435347601771355, -0.03881596773862839, -0.02296733856201172, -0.03533428534865379, 0.00586139690130949, -0.012858747504651546, 0.03262021020054817, 0.0004800870083272457, 0.02767970599234104, 0.023518620058894157, 0.004584835842251778, -0.0040596951730549335, 0.016546910628676414, 0.016661807894706726, -0.07439940422773361, -0.018077844753861427, 0.0064086467027664185, 0.0012825302546843886, 0.0040242974646389484, 0.023167060688138008, 0.00516729848459363, -0.023104513064026833, 0.059760674834251404, -0.014035088010132313, -0.03906989097595215, 0.02003847062587738, -0.02359875850379467, -0.006845938041806221, -0.005706111900508404, -0.003924061078578234, -0.030115323141217232, -0.02128947153687477, -0.014283854514360428, -0.00244097039103508, -0.016723256558179855, -0.013743570074439049, -0.0036715783644467592, 0.015325091779232025, 0.023639244958758354, 0.01947246491909027, 0.0005815161857753992, 0.0169382244348526, 0.023817885667085648, 0.017628636211156845, 0.03241750970482826, 0.014469589106738567, -0.0333789587020874, 0.04324229434132576, -0.028516730293631554, -0.034175608307123184, 0.01906815730035305, -0.0035162291023880243, 0.05119876191020012, 0.03604043647646904, -0.028675459325313568, -0.016055168583989143, 0.04727734252810478, -0.050094909965991974, -0.03015175834298134, -0.012354401871562004, 0.0259751807898283, 0.03254866227507591, -0.011644348502159119, 0.011240178719162941, 0.00589026091620326, -0.010787621140480042, 0.0250700730830431, 0.05149228125810623, -0.02925274521112442, -0.01069755107164383, 0.005872149020433426, 0.03221283480525017, 0.04308542609214783, 0.006239286623895168, -0.01958162523806095, 0.035816773772239685, 0.04258323460817337, -0.015110280364751816, 0.017236288636922836, -0.0073780338279902935, -0.01735866442322731, -0.053537603467702866, -0.03461570292711258, 0.021611059084534645, -0.01323880534619093, -0.0005546880420297384, -0.05036989226937294, -0.020242437720298767, 0.02542826533317566, -0.026730505749583244, 0.01626851037144661, 0.005572417285293341, 0.03498566150665283, -0.041651468724012375, 0.01103255059570074, -0.03442554175853729, 0.007859550416469574, -0.00989429373294115, 0.039678990840911865, 0.016727691516280174, 0.04033806920051575, 0.009203638881444931, -0.03616977855563164, -0.0576680451631546, 0.007922615855932236, 0.029872797429561615, -0.059481795877218246, 0.03656703978776932, -0.03041744977235794, -0.04226098582148552, 0.04871588572859764, -0.011548875831067562, 0.034017208963632584, 0.004781123250722885, 0.012116268277168274, -0.034956276416778564, 0.02472667209804058, 0.04547491669654846, 0.005725077353417873, 0.014523644931614399, 0.03029646724462509, 0.013305656611919403, 0.02132902666926384, -0.044798195362091064, 0.015278665348887444, 0.041989702731370926, -0.009819434955716133, 0.0032755727879703045, 0.02367269992828369, 0.013232966884970665, 0.013587383553385735, -0.029414819553494453, -0.02975562773644924, 0.03520835191011429, -0.06126086041331291, 0.010377535596489906, -0.015829751268029213, 0.028110073879361153, 0.038842424750328064, 0.046042658388614655, -0.016063788905739784, 0.0345662459731102, 0.007601498626172543, -0.02295360527932644, 0.01744171418249607, 0.009008591063320637, 0.01331587415188551, -0.0633772537112236, 0.004598862957209349, 0.0030634431168437004, 0.008213873952627182, -0.009306231513619423, 0.007324215956032276, -0.04285607486963272, 0.025033429265022278, -0.017947960644960403, -0.014061314053833485, -0.021637681871652603, -0.02069450169801712, 0.006130052264779806, -0.10379879921674728, 0.05499269440770149, 0.02151280827820301, 0.01536568719893694, -0.019091475754976273, -0.029745951294898987, -0.02224358543753624, 0.037729207426309586, 0.03200388699769974, 0.03672410175204277, -0.014618471264839172, 0.030268631875514984, 0.003775260876864195, -0.003695390187203884, -0.002512823324650526, 0.05654824152588844, -0.03249357268214226, -0.014530019834637642, -0.002378809731453657, -0.012121101841330528, 0.011489516124129295, -0.009355687536299229, -0.009050996974110603, -0.0030427821911871433, 0.004239235073328018, 0.008165297098457813, 0.03513884171843529, 0.03272932395339012, -0.005860036239027977, 0.00006820016278652474, 0.005744965746998787, -0.00851428136229515, 0.015239047817885876, 0.0057691908441483974, 0.015481372363865376, -0.035369642078876495, 0.025701506063342094, -0.04535607621073723, -0.03634103387594223, -0.0014457437209784985, 0.025410225614905357, 0.010366888716816902, -0.03336868807673454, -0.017123166471719742, 0.04387172311544418, -0.04878753796219826, -0.010310143232345581, 0.032253198325634, 0.025576315820217133, 0.0418429933488369, -0.008553998544812202, 0.025956187397241592, 0.02902541123330593, -0.039997197687625885, -0.00490508321672678, 0.02009057253599167, 0.02632787823677063, 0.007802390027791262, -0.008136195130646229, 0.05025392025709152, 0.009296140633523464, 0.034313756972551346, -0.009673192165791988, 0.05778803676366806, -0.018675263971090317, -0.04408108815550804, 0.02437748946249485, 0.0291870329529047, 0.0064471024088561535, -0.0010695814853534102, -0.009071959182620049, 0.06354692578315735, 0.012037239037454128, -0.0005552961956709623, -0.05916798114776611, -0.020036345347762108, -0.004190972540527582, -0.03763694688677788, 0.028916798532009125, 0.025443831458687782, 0.03608011454343796, 0.009997940622270107, -0.022809237241744995, 0.0027687104884535074, -0.005807413253933191, -0.0431896448135376, 0.04668306186795235, -0.020652897655963898, -0.0010076483013108373, -0.005277892574667931, -0.03677293658256531, -0.014535189606249332, -0.032081589102745056, 0.024031206965446472, 0.03638289123773575, 0.03987631946802139, -0.018323112279176712, -0.034912239760160446, -0.0006926371133886278, 0.04574492946267128, -0.0456043966114521, -0.05145087093114853, -0.06032716855406761, -0.027744309976696968, -0.009145737625658512, -0.03830801695585251 ]
<p>Gelman &amp; Hill (2006) say:</p> <blockquote> <p>In Bugs, missing outcomes in a regression can be handled easily by simply including the data vector, NA’s and all. Bugs explicitly models the outcome variable, and so it is trivial to use this model to, in effect, impute missing values at each iteration.</p> </blockquote> <p>This sounds like an easy way to use JAGS to do prediction. But do the observations with the missing outcomes also affect parameter estimates? If so, is there an easy way to keep these observations in the dataset that JAGS sees, but to not have them affect the parameter estimates? I was thinking about the cut function, but that's only available in BUGS, not JAGS.</p>
30,695
[ -0.013723830692470074, -0.0008548108744435012, -0.026933541521430016, 0.01932143233716488, 0.010430769063532352, 0.03929820656776428, -0.005307289771735668, -0.007662437856197357, 0.0016330942744389176, -0.016664693132042885, 0.032688021659851074, 0.01739145815372467, 0.03224357217550278, -0.012026487849652767, -0.029075611382722855, 0.011232074350118637, -0.044600628316402435, -0.00897260569036007, 0.015558689832687378, 0.001464183209463954, -0.0056212060153484344, 0.04194806143641472, -0.002344334265217185, -0.002202287781983614, 0.031944457441568375, 0.019623935222625732, 0.0446012020111084, -0.011154673993587494, 0.0160310547798872, 0.034081295132637024, -0.02425840124487877, -0.015508475713431835, 0.01876138523221016, 0.056508228182792664, -0.030754059553146362, -0.013684852980077267, 0.0038447307888418436, -0.02593017928302288, -0.011185696348547935, 0.03236433118581772, -0.017048761248588562, 0.00536198727786541, -0.014896895736455917, 0.033837929368019104, -0.018001893535256386, 0.02687772549688816, -0.016734888777136803, -0.008647536858916283, 0.003904134500771761, -0.006682838778942823, 0.04473040625452995, 0.011676998808979988, 0.02112051285803318, 0.004299437161535025, -0.01726558431982994, 0.009018861688673496, 0.072626493871212, 0.07290410995483398, 0.005913573782891035, -0.04376039654016495, -0.003280441276729107, -0.04086296632885933, 0.027090653777122498, 0.014782886952161789, -0.018902434036135674, -0.00014424313849303871, -0.0008759781485423446, -0.0482829250395298, 0.033911511301994324, -0.0166714396327734, -0.007772513199597597, 0.02368778921663761, 0.027937179431319237, 0.06065405160188675, 0.026999985799193382, -0.034812211990356445, -0.023590801283717155, 0.047675542533397675, 0.04901566728949547, 0.02233104035258293, 0.00755695253610611, 0.024783097207546234, 0.02510959468781948, 0.05381901562213898, 0.009802810847759247, 0.011673014611005783, 0.05715376138687134, -0.04772027209401131, 0.022631360217928886, -0.0022191449534147978, -0.0639234185218811, -0.016462335363030434, 0.04398033395409584, -0.0033654493745416403, -0.03738943114876747, 0.01800091750919819, -0.020582567900419235, 0.032067976891994476, 0.03153318539261818, 0.003860792610794306, -0.019847868010401726, -0.03542890399694443, -0.01136055402457714, 0.04070737585425377, -0.02411567233502865, -0.04822113737463951, -0.026418037712574005, -0.022730130702257156, -0.008821036666631699, -0.051887042820453644, -0.021606752648949623, 0.007887027226388454, -0.0369214192032814, 0.008317273110151291, 0.016764136031270027, -0.01699553057551384, 0.016130514442920685, -0.03203269839286804, 0.027650421485304832, 0.08287648856639862, 0.04978400841355324, -0.035279009491205215, 0.008196961134672165, 0.011169089935719967, -0.03841216862201691, 0.015140535309910774, 0.013831770978868008, -0.037544023245573044, -0.033714909106492996, 0.02740180306136608, -0.02042776718735695, -0.02093520574271679, 0.06211927533149719, 0.009078267961740494, 0.0420018769800663, 0.013086572289466858, -0.05323933809995651, -0.05881713703274727, 0.01601828821003437, -0.04750246927142143, 0.028974488377571106, -0.07354259490966797, 0.015061339363455772, 0.005124191287904978, 0.037949446588754654, 0.021317405626177788, -0.004963373299688101, 0.020215027034282684, 0.03974572569131851, 0.023912722244858742, 0.003909402992576361, -0.01106948871165514, -0.023928022012114525, -0.013380065560340881, -0.037508346140384674, -0.06495105475187302, 0.055763885378837585, 0.030823372304439545, 0.007242306135594845, -0.03699992597103119, 0.05232353135943413, 0.011757554486393929, 0.027113961055874825, -0.01717422343790531, -0.004673314280807972, -0.031612567603588104, 0.07067746669054031, -0.006160651799291372, 0.04785623773932457, 0.009732282720506191, 0.02563571184873581, 0.016110267490148544, 0.01607687398791313, 0.0672302320599556, 0.03217596933245659, -0.004253341816365719, -0.0065645757131278515, -0.03207073733210564, -0.00043732437188737094, -0.013588158413767815, -0.03717956691980362, -0.011320697143673897, 0.009919220581650734, -0.0021223104558885098, -0.0007707997574470937, 0.034106310456991196, 0.01011742651462555, -0.026346400380134583, 0.07341213524341583, -0.047979146242141724, -0.020452935248613358, -0.060276374220848083, 0.028024468570947647, 0.028422798961400986, -0.004680816549807787, 0.007147472817450762, -0.019530292600393295, 0.046206530183553696, 0.02268722653388977, -0.025918152183294296, 0.004998184274882078, -0.007656512316316366, 0.04455871880054474, -0.04631109535694122, 0.00003772550917346962, 0.06372175365686417, 0.06096915528178215, -0.020958419889211655, 0.05651720613241196, -0.05912395939230919, -0.050080038607120514, 0.010935721918940544, -0.03987151011824608, 0.01674470119178295, -0.015435267239809036, -0.0015842708526179194, 0.013814707286655903, -0.039417557418346405, 0.000848923169542104, -0.0005262343329377472, -0.055056698620319366, 0.049396008253097534, 0.0688638687133789, -0.02970118075609207, -0.008331751450896263, 0.006403126288205385, 0.0010363608598709106, 0.026967983692884445, -0.03665662184357643, 0.003254010807722807, -0.05931380018591881, -0.005702516064047813, 0.004740576259791851, -0.04023582488298416, -0.055718496441841125, 0.01485926378518343, 0.056092314422130585, -0.016663406044244766, 0.010288902558386326, 0.03149636834859848, -0.0019241655245423317, 0.013317414559423923, 0.01575431041419506, -0.009010277688503265, 0.07041570544242859, -0.027369802817702293, -0.0020902184769511223, 0.026408469304442406, 0.0018467659829184413, -0.02618466131389141, 0.005695095751434565, 0.0398474857211113, 0.03715077415108681, -0.0010509358253329992, -0.028952116146683693, -0.04108680784702301, 0.036001697182655334, -0.02666081301867962, 0.016560669988393784, 0.04149065166711807, 0.007294837851077318, -0.018746934831142426, 0.03684835135936737, -0.018472490832209587, 0.014577801339328289, 0.03277623653411865, -0.02583608776330948, 0.058731984347105026, 0.02358243800699711, -0.05010179802775383, 0.029559453949332237, -0.01785239577293396, 0.016044050455093384, -0.04580371826887131, 0.015088922344148159, 0.023723911494016647, 0.010265973396599293, 0.031913407146930695, -0.041617780923843384, -0.026615573093295097, 0.010383252054452896, 0.00928613543510437, 0.021786930039525032, 0.09662305563688278, -0.005597616080194712, -0.01266253087669611, -0.02615051530301571, -0.012957225553691387, 0.010354171507060528, -0.016343146562576294, -0.038834694772958755, -0.002628910820931196, -0.03526090830564499, -0.015934111550450325, -0.03596736490726471, -0.0007845844374969602, -0.00017034864868037403, -0.03744751214981079, -0.03790054842829704, 0.05473492294549942, 0.03372792527079582, -0.017850810661911964, -0.0011417933274060488, -0.007524376735091209, -0.004365940578281879, -0.05200972408056259, -0.022910501807928085, 0.025808200240135193, 0.004927731119096279, 0.0110331354662776, 0.044446904212236404, -0.03401347994804382, 0.02261972986161709, -0.06551115214824677, -0.06127602607011795, 0.018900908529758453, 0.009239819832146168, -0.00015997406444512308, -0.001009522471576929, 0.015833957120776176, 0.09865657985210419, 0.0176932942122221, -0.010011796839535236, -0.04631076008081436, -0.007073432207107544, 0.0016052573919296265, -0.033076461404561996, -0.0183690395206213, 0.020889785140752792, 0.04716559872031212, 0.007235953118652105, -0.024850478395819664, 0.04923360049724579, 0.02977723628282547, 0.04112876579165459, 0.020026741549372673, -0.03133346885442734, -0.010661029256880283, 0.001271408167667687, -0.002904673805460334, 0.051120106130838394, -0.010388271883130074, 0.008378410711884499, -0.019574806094169617, 0.02884441427886486, -0.005618035327643156, -0.05306586995720863, -0.0010114809265360236, -0.010434932075440884, 0.03249707818031311, -0.001680155866779387, -0.001692960737273097, 0.06323753297328949, -0.03764107823371887, -0.020966114476323128, 0.03378215432167053, 0.03918371722102165, -0.018748700618743896, -0.013582035899162292, 0.008281380869448185, -0.016395214945077896, -0.010838762857019901, -0.0016228000167757273, -0.018446793779730797, -0.005947892554104328, 0.03816000744700432, -0.008539341390132904, 0.013531043194234371, 0.04063505679368973, 0.007288139779120684, -0.02009209617972374, 0.00040848078788258135, -0.061759114265441895, 0.016919227316975594, -0.05319390445947647, -0.006589886266738176, -0.023599911481142044, -0.0012446700129657984, 0.011118779890239239, 0.0158831924200058, 0.015684057027101517, 0.028772838413715363, 0.015533646568655968, 0.020110324025154114, -0.07397966831922531, 0.003908725921064615, -0.014525728300213814, -0.012521324679255486, -0.01361074484884739, -0.02503558062016964, 0.04053281992673874, -0.023282593116164207, 0.011556845158338547, -0.0009164510411210358, 0.00272910064086318, -0.016490226611495018, 0.006995777133852243, -0.026481518521904945, -0.015929298475384712, 0.013945354148745537, -0.020001551136374474, 0.04880313575267792, -0.037338901311159134, -0.009976202622056007, 0.03683173283934593, -0.008769401349127293, -0.01818389631807804, -0.0035782100167125463, 0.017316360026597977, 0.0036004246212542057, 0.043366339057683945, 0.050651468336582184, 0.036648109555244446, -0.0380764938890934, -0.0024432800710201263, 0.022600188851356506, 0.0260930098593235, 0.03264094144105911, -0.0141714783385396, -0.028632791712880135, 0.002399184973910451, -0.024179348722100258, 0.009409451857209206, 0.02177431993186474, 0.004233147948980331, 0.03356960043311119, 0.09024985879659653, 0.027471421286463737, -0.022973129525780678, 0.001440570573322475, 0.02275940403342247, 0.04875408858060837, -0.01675787754356861, -0.020602725446224213, 0.009627392515540123, 0.013033682480454445, -0.01057577133178711, 0.0212864950299263, 0.013227344490587711, 0.02265896089375019, 0.009181125089526176, 0.016485365107655525, -0.0017007446149364114, -0.04065680131316185, -0.02105914056301117, 0.04284004494547844, 0.06433883309364319, 0.03487100079655647, 0.0011054248316213489, 0.03455240651965141, 0.08511796593666077, 0.006594892591238022, 0.006366979330778122, -0.01382810901850462, -0.10005238652229309, 0.01764053851366043, 0.043690960854291916, 0.008882974274456501, -0.0038261977024376392, -0.029353929683566093, -0.04815385118126869, -0.014791610650718212, 0.015684746205806732, -0.029004313051700592, -0.0002445998543407768, 0.006062901113182306, 0.013458114117383957, -0.007460273336619139, -0.02765788696706295, -0.05070161074399948, 0.015349109657108784, -0.034260693937540054, 0.033701833337545395, -0.013000947423279285, -0.02495882473886013, -0.007456548046320677, 0.014855868183076382, -0.0001283656747546047, 0.07504920661449432, 0.002408886095508933, -0.00012111270916648209, 0.015460587106645107, 0.014859368093311787, -0.004007074981927872, -0.05964712053537369, 0.0006633448647335172, 0.020486801862716675, -0.02070416510105133, 0.049774959683418274, -0.00578157277777791, -0.008206581696867943, 0.020783476531505585, 0.029304608702659607, -0.03805655986070633, -0.025932777673006058, -0.05078933760523796, 0.004980848170816898, -0.0030102410819381475, -0.01430839579552412, 0.060192860662937164, 0.0068433103151619434, 0.01850980706512928, 0.017614448443055153, -0.04881058633327484, 0.0028436335269361734, -0.03411092236638069, -0.02811114490032196, -0.06103106215596199, -0.005001694895327091, 0.007016370538622141, 0.034450750797986984, -0.002965460764244199, 0.003388715907931328, -0.02404364012181759, -0.02478751540184021, 0.02210310287773609, -0.013535204343497753, -0.016373202204704285, -0.008449262008070946, -0.045323695987463, 0.039190154522657394, 0.01975514553487301, 0.00996814388781786, 0.025371888652443886, -0.03907225653529167, 0.012330228462815285, 0.04286633059382439, -0.08702436089515686, 0.002242214046418667, -0.033183105289936066, -0.0204115379601717, 0.03647515922784805, -0.005466048140078783, -0.005121115129441023, -0.026427414268255234, 0.028459198772907257, -0.022021839395165443, -0.028753506019711494, -0.011724483221769333, -0.016740938648581505, 0.01833915337920189, -0.00015973190602380782, -0.0200212299823761, 0.04134610667824745, -0.019398106262087822, -0.002007456962019205, -0.06984452158212662, -0.033248014748096466, -0.002225854666903615, 0.0013501807115972042, -0.03799424320459366, 0.018981976434588432, 0.002609729766845703, -0.028964083641767502, -0.01048908568918705, -0.022575821727514267, 0.034833747893571854, -0.032964762300252914, -0.004463467746973038, 0.011339422315359116, 0.04238170012831688, 0.031381428241729736, 0.019325220957398415, 0.007766334339976311, 0.05119969695806503, -0.0510857030749321, -0.014039909467101097, 0.004307600203901529, 0.015689020976424217, -0.017072729766368866, 0.0070727672427892685, -0.019441932439804077, -0.0061425501480698586, 0.04118482768535614, -0.003907558973878622, 0.0028153136372566223, 0.029353506863117218, 0.015948710963129997, -0.002592589473351836, 0.011964228935539722, -0.015403417870402336, -0.03113713301718235, 0.010081938467919827, -0.003580869873985648, 0.031718697398900986, 0.022569669410586357, 0.024627413600683212, 0.04324565455317497, 0.013194122351706028, -0.005895113106817007, 0.00863102450966835, 0.04360375180840492, -0.0015036709373816848, -0.010433858260512352, 0.032964810729026794, -0.035464003682136536, 0.06283432990312576, 0.03425288572907448, 0.0463600754737854, -0.001192024676129222, 0.031752727925777435, -0.035802602767944336, -0.06527121365070343, -0.06114130839705467, -0.007829076610505581, 0.056256819516420364, -0.044534824788570404, 0.006339275743812323, 0.01566210202872753, 0.00702162180095911, -0.002656700788065791, -0.06429525464773178, 0.008028728887438774, 0.016483429819345474, 0.009536114521324635, 0.045361846685409546, 0.012081228196620941, -0.009121140465140343, 0.008848070167005062, 0.004223368596285582, -0.0001533966133138165, 0.015145390294492245, -0.014112724922597408, 0.03518374264240265, -0.02930583618581295, -0.018419072031974792, -0.02740429900586605, -0.001738016726449132, -0.05754821002483368, -0.0393732450902462, -0.034985680133104324, -0.041606247425079346, 0.040425609797239304, 0.025635356083512306, 0.021765204146504402, -0.053534042090177536, -0.031156636774539948, -0.05988813191652298, 0.01583882048726082, 0.0019972622394561768, -0.02608436532318592, 0.046516839414834976, -0.007495334837585688, 0.025382675230503082, -0.05626982823014259, 0.030688202008605003, -0.07864775508642197, -0.0794345811009407, -0.03704593703150749, -0.02622337080538273, -0.01929044909775257, 0.048166725784540176, 0.02462766505777836, -0.006355161312967539, 0.028198573738336563, -0.0027348187286406755, 0.03428421914577484, -0.034457288682460785, 0.07204733788967133, 0.007460859138518572, 0.07533381134271622, -0.013554464094340801, -0.008449436165392399, -0.029593003913760185, -0.006611585151404142, 0.14037200808525085, 0.07071595638990402, 0.0559258908033371, -0.05602170154452324, -0.00400619488209486, 0.0029776040464639664, -0.006158363539725542, 0.013442658819258213, -0.017063535749912262, 0.04336140304803848, 0.015555715188384056, 0.048747215420007706, 0.024295253679156303, 0.0097837895154953, -0.010465452447533607, 0.03329956904053688, -0.041636545211076736, 0.009096813388168812, 0.0037801365833729506, 0.021667534485459328, 0.01886141300201416, -0.030744677409529686, -0.03300562500953674, 0.0307772159576416, 0.03467542678117752, -0.020571265369653702, -0.028716284781694412, -0.017472974956035614, -0.019738664850592613, -0.0006220839568413794, -0.01741199381649494, 0.00920409057289362, 0.05053677037358284, 0.047847311943769455, 0.02783009223639965, 0.0029447779525071383, 0.012568834237754345, -0.027007615193724632, 0.005753905046731234, 0.005460078362375498, 0.011180052533745766, 0.01743955723941326, 0.008977626450359821, 0.009864171035587788, -0.05012967064976692, -0.024234239012002945, -0.014085318893194199, 0.03284439817070961, -0.029099779203534126, 0.005658546928316355, -0.04525256156921387, -0.003221080405637622, 0.024585533887147903, -0.03410259261727333, -0.044903725385665894, 0.028186703100800514, 0.018538977950811386, -0.0036754461470991373, -0.02804436907172203, 0.00614620465785265, -0.012115872465074062, 0.01177874393761158, 0.025461168959736824, 0.05309157446026802, -0.035407476127147675, -0.05070175230503082, 0.007167772855609655, 0.039945196360349655, -0.015431471168994904, -0.03121383860707283, 0.009038836695253849, -0.000073361283284612, -0.0030211510602384806, -0.0036414023488759995, 0.015181542374193668, 0.02561538852751255, 0.014017605222761631, -0.02607712894678116, 0.017094578593969345, -0.03932269290089607, -0.06099449098110199, -0.005341122858226299, -0.024705830961465836, -0.0030350356828421354, -0.03577245771884918, 0.01202438399195671, 0.026504062116146088, 0.051304563879966736, 0.01878390647470951, 0.00020826955733355135, -0.026688799262046814, 0.0612838938832283, -0.010927739553153515, -0.04864046722650528, -0.022843115031719208, 0.005594276823103428, -0.04379134252667427, 0.024611983448266983, 0.012661570683121681, 0.08460316807031631, -0.0007297545089386404, 0.044195473194122314, -0.03403618559241295, 0.043463513255119324, 0.0049934121780097485, 0.020663000643253326, 0.017226209864020348, -0.08004804700613022, -0.0007039431948214769, -0.016157004982233047, 0.041394028812646866, -0.03509938344359398, 0.009357721544802189, -0.007722270209342241, -0.014884726144373417, 0.006434632930904627, -0.053144242614507675, -0.0729190856218338, 0.010334833525121212, 0.0004102686943951994, 0.021701578050851822, -0.034089893102645874, 0.025735899806022644, -0.021244898438453674, -0.04706370830535889, 0.0026963339187204838, -0.033016085624694824, 0.036430474370718, -0.0006632836884818971, -0.03391513600945473, -0.00015318565419875085, 0.021710801869630814, 0.011192364618182182, 0.030825166031718254, 0.01612912118434906, -0.005041421391069889, -0.0032384630758315325, 0.053096454590559006, -0.05046556890010834, -0.03929143399000168, 0.013803385198116302, -0.044599082320928574, -0.03774455189704895, 0.0460248664021492, 0.0037049625534564257, 0.026663925498723984, -0.0012897113338112831, -0.023389944806694984, -0.05483391135931015, 0.03286304324865341, -0.05495675653219223, -0.006368085276335478, 0.004487055819481611, 0.007888132706284523, -0.04686369746923447, -0.00973119679838419, 0.0068404958583414555, 0.013868143782019615, 0.015921255573630333, 0.005123096983879805, 0.0048180329613387585, 0.05372295528650284, -0.02444017492234707, 0.033047307282686234, 0.015290462411940098, 0.020216509699821472, -0.026553230360150337, 0.02075722999870777, -0.014746520668268204, 0.04894854128360748, 0.024014262482523918, 0.07144466042518616, 0.039529215544462204, 0.04613864794373512, -0.0798846036195755, -0.011306836269795895, 0.004008352756500244, 0.029423346742987633, 0.033201295882463455, -0.030961336567997932, 0.031065328046679497, 0.011447911150753498, -0.015857888385653496, 0.012159016914665699, -0.025641269981861115, 0.010294411331415176, -0.01815236359834671, 0.002282388973981142, -0.048065442591905594, -0.004527645651251078, 0.05074252188205719, -0.012299006804823875, 0.015779774636030197, 0.023068727925419807, 0.027757054194808006, -0.03882531076669693, -0.03792458400130272, -0.001804283238016069, 0.010271674953401089, -0.04471994563937187, 0.04349285364151001, -0.023499419912695885, -0.04416237398982048, 0.0012744034174829721, -0.011920270510017872, 0.01705528050661087, -0.018353495746850967, 0.012383703142404556, 0.04059919714927673, 0.049842577427625656, 0.025624949485063553, -0.02111196145415306, 0.015512358397245407, 0.0025321543216705322, -0.02000231295824051, -0.0042783888056874275, -0.020116055384278297, 0.0371888242661953, 0.02827676199376583, -0.004693152848631144, -0.012166684493422508, -0.026611309498548508, -0.037849314510822296, -0.013937512412667274, 0.0023232761304825544, 0.004696585703641176, -0.002369866706430912, -0.026043759658932686, 0.003222564235329628, -0.05947466939687729, 0.05306805297732353, 0.06272312998771667, 0.029425468295812607, -0.04494408890604973, 0.008707089349627495, -0.018758250400424004, -0.052255094051361084, -0.021429765969514847, -0.007616295479238033, -0.00915378425270319, -0.03261011466383934, 0.018019406124949455, -0.014853176660835743, -0.006973060313612223, -0.02875060774385929, -0.004434114322066307, -0.05332939699292183, 0.0411776527762413, -0.051876574754714966, 0.03035036101937294, 0.022002868354320526, -0.04412177577614784, 0.031860023736953735, -0.08232653141021729, 0.08551646023988724, 0.020271657034754753, -0.009447508491575718, -0.005459892563521862, -0.014266605488955975, -0.006805759388953447, 0.02064938098192215, 0.07726813852787018, -0.03344135731458664, 0.00643358426168561, 0.0008532458450645208, 0.03228903189301491, -0.008203170262277126, 0.0028340101707726717, 0.042363088577985764, -0.026203414425253868, 0.01821650005877018, -0.02965010330080986, -0.0038283634930849075, -0.01870580203831196, 0.010061487555503845, -0.00240893242880702, -0.004928328562527895, 0.004208606667816639, 0.00915957149118185, 0.0136029701679945, 0.013779440894722939, 0.03294641524553299, -0.004054251592606306, 0.02787919156253338, 0.022509010508656502, 0.030405135825276375, 0.04385613650083542, -0.007242964580655098, -0.034311164170503616, 0.07605671137571335, -0.029964489862322807, -0.021711871027946472, 0.010163478553295135, -0.010916543193161488, -0.0166925098747015, -0.017611058428883553, 0.0031592051964253187, 0.027044445276260376, -0.02572270669043064, 0.027375146746635437, 0.0037127425894141197, -0.025268901139497757, 0.036221954971551895, -0.0027162330225110054, -0.005887399427592754, 0.051649075001478195, 0.007268463261425495, 0.006281872279942036, 0.001786589389666915, 0.0327346995472908, 0.030490059405565262, -0.002855225233361125, 0.006612400524318218, -0.016530726104974747, 0.03495081514120102, -0.032313816249370575, 0.01886657439172268, -0.020792115479707718, -0.03656255826354027, -0.014528884552419186, -0.016174107789993286, -0.0012050315272063017, -0.040591735392808914, 0.012660385109484196, 0.022225793451070786, -0.032707665115594864, 0.007841933518648148, -0.08346261829137802, -0.0031422358006238937, -0.015942443162202835, -0.011867918074131012, -0.03445669636130333, 0.007681780494749546, 0.011269415728747845, -0.0276789627969265, 0.012240901589393616, -0.00694296695291996, 0.014530202373862267, -0.015595154836773872, -0.002807256765663624, -0.012038356624543667, -0.012076976709067822, -0.00616738386452198, -0.030647261068224907, -0.008281204849481583, 0.010947836562991142, 0.002684719627723098, -0.002667373279109597, -0.000398358068196103, -0.06305548548698425, -0.05500548332929611, -0.010215316899120808, 0.05328097939491272, -0.08951541781425476, -0.025542201474308968, -0.04696204140782356, 0.044383320957422256, -0.0028269169852137566, -0.006342742126435041 ]
<p>I want to compare the distance/similarity of 2D flood frequency data maps. The maps are square with YxY grid size and in each cell of the map is stored its flood frequency. For example in a 5x5 grid we may have this two flood frequency maps of the same area for the past 10 years, where we observe how many times the corresponding cell/place flooded:</p> <p>0 0 0 0 0 &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 0 0 0 0 0<br> 0 1 2 1 0 &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 0 2 3 1 0<br> 0 4 6 2 0 &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 9 9 8 7 6<br> 0 1 2 1 0 &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 0 2 3 1 0<br> 0 4 6 2 0 &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 9 9 8 7 6</p> <p>I can easily transform these maps into a probability map that will add up to one. So the question now is what is the most meaningful way of comparing these kind of maps with each other to find their (dis)similarity. A distance metric taken from information theory field like JSD or L1 (and many others) or a similarity metric taken from the image processing field like the area under ROC (and many others)?</p>
36,315
[ -0.017333097755908966, -0.005511827766895294, -0.020614521577954292, 0.019513892009854317, 0.05442269518971443, -0.014886893332004547, 0.026252496987581253, -0.01662515662610531, 0.03914153575897217, -0.006028232630342245, 0.024602098390460014, 0.027982376515865326, 0.04961329326033592, 0.014163457788527012, 0.029678473249077797, -0.0018065223703160882, -0.04745551198720932, 0.02877187170088291, -0.018094394356012344, -0.04635125771164894, 0.030299609526991844, 0.026437703520059586, 0.05434086546301842, -0.018314888700842857, -0.058820657432079315, 0.04025139659643173, 0.018390648066997528, -0.027905896306037903, 0.004888115916401148, 0.06633193045854568, -0.016812266781926155, -0.037965498864650726, -0.011363903991878033, 0.06314214318990707, -0.01807725615799427, 0.0013344194740056992, -0.06403296440839767, -0.030196405947208405, -0.01634344272315502, 0.028173673897981644, -0.03516552597284317, -0.06609825044870377, -0.048257529735565186, 0.05253579095005989, -0.004548262804746628, 0.008409709669649601, -0.02722213976085186, -0.023680390790104866, -0.0056817117147147655, 0.0024064062163233757, 0.10539417713880539, -0.011439966037869453, 0.0458776094019413, -0.00645181629806757, -0.00955958478152752, 0.000186530698556453, 0.03696088492870331, 0.0821344181895256, -0.03157661482691765, -0.03681641444563866, -0.03024022839963436, -0.005475987214595079, 0.020320938900113106, -0.0401933379471302, 0.011994750238955021, 0.0367460735142231, -0.027237460017204285, -0.037993986159563065, 0.030943939462304115, 0.00942541565746069, -0.0255495086312294, 0.016558699309825897, 0.05625491961836815, -0.016641076654195786, 0.04154178500175476, -0.04383454844355583, 0.0009094841661863029, 0.01039755530655384, 0.03029794991016388, -0.014417433179914951, -0.005396177992224693, 0.03719036653637886, -0.00038606204907409847, 0.017667921259999275, 0.03539841249585152, -0.02118046022951603, 0.05602313578128815, -0.023294581100344658, -0.006203724071383476, 0.01042881142348051, -0.00038446823600679636, -0.027829108759760857, 0.018930450081825256, 0.008871289901435375, -0.04644540324807167, 0.010511212050914764, 0.004136824514716864, 0.016300460323691368, 0.00867721252143383, 0.006526299752295017, -0.03985964134335518, -0.0691482201218605, -0.00196003052406013, 0.02754398249089718, -0.00771317956969142, 0.01038292981684208, -0.03968941420316696, -0.0038110713940113783, -0.05513502657413483, 0.007636330556124449, -0.03679277002811432, -0.00567992590367794, 0.01096433773636818, -0.004610142670571804, 0.00433655409142375, -0.006271130405366421, 0.03869882598519325, -0.04074997827410698, 0.02688390016555786, 0.09204378724098206, 0.04664276912808418, -0.03572496399283409, -0.009471812285482883, -0.021825646981596947, -0.05602652207016945, 0.050066955387592316, 0.01782963052392006, -0.02980864606797695, -0.06256819516420364, 0.06911788135766983, -0.013305339962244034, -0.027447231113910675, 0.04896485060453415, -0.022118430584669113, 0.01762367971241474, -0.004441588651388884, -0.07725979387760162, -0.04531381279230118, 0.04033564776182175, -0.018853526562452316, -0.006387821398675442, -0.04804648831486702, 0.001334097352810204, 0.013750073499977589, 0.00783620961010456, -0.016388393938541412, 0.021149422973394394, 0.0039200554601848125, 0.040272798389196396, 0.014055180363357067, -0.03322678431868553, -0.009746169671416283, -0.011618961580097675, -0.004170863423496485, -0.020661652088165283, -0.04220273345708847, 0.00352774397470057, -0.00020282214973121881, -0.04808517172932625, -0.034382741898298264, 0.031202413141727448, 0.006600544787943363, 0.023007266223430634, -0.015683908015489578, -0.004756735172122717, -0.021736083552241325, 0.07075568288564682, -0.0014443766558542848, 0.04509752616286278, 0.014365711249411106, -0.04000129550695419, 0.042767755687236786, 0.05317089334130287, 0.04502542316913605, 0.06178892031311989, -0.0060210032388567924, -0.021345799788832664, -0.009003632701933384, 0.005420312285423279, -0.004654336255043745, -0.0021975208073854446, -0.02679012529551983, -0.05135239288210869, -0.023639220744371414, 0.03212093561887741, 0.03294389694929123, -0.029147282242774963, -0.031638503074645996, 0.04837436601519585, -0.038881540298461914, -0.0139944301918149, -0.06184938922524452, 0.0018062982708215714, -0.003836732590571046, 0.04394369199872017, 0.012408477254211903, -0.038577012717723846, 0.002583566587418318, 0.039982859045267105, 0.011987957172095776, -0.05000264197587967, -0.015714429318904877, 0.012853692285716534, -0.02363678626716137, -0.014577720314264297, 0.027795208618044853, 0.01924786902964115, -0.012295559048652649, 0.04580966755747795, -0.039697665721178055, -0.04741928353905678, -0.02564234659075737, -0.00027032606885768473, -0.021504074335098267, -0.035510990768671036, 0.012904303148388863, 0.006792102940380573, -0.007021029945462942, -0.017087357118725777, -0.012007155455648899, -0.05873836576938629, 0.08046513795852661, 0.05593302100896835, 0.0031260820105671883, -0.021224332973361015, -0.018449829891324043, 0.02051863819360733, 0.030117232352495193, -0.012704364955425262, 0.00015982144395820796, -0.05233077332377434, 0.028153367340564728, 0.05178281292319298, 0.043067850172519684, -0.026747586205601692, 0.0033842590637505054, 0.06787049025297165, -0.002394910668954253, -0.004166785627603531, -0.023909268900752068, 0.0038332657422870398, 0.01822321116924286, 0.016674483194947243, 0.039414871484041214, 0.026416340842843056, -0.009448235854506493, 0.02737724408507347, 0.009842799045145512, 0.01361705083400011, -0.008143302984535694, -0.022968916222453117, 0.02088025026023388, -0.0017732246778905392, 0.031728584319353104, -0.049379922449588776, 0.01545247994363308, 0.05735856294631958, 0.011927316896617413, -0.042287006974220276, 0.0329202301800251, -0.011254225857555866, 0.004379803314805031, -0.008014128543436527, -0.021660087630152702, 0.011701272800564766, -0.000580021005589515, -0.041741177439689636, -0.002853275276720524, 0.01502701174467802, -0.04291526973247528, 0.05182276666164398, 0.01783033087849617, -0.011675282381474972, -0.014316573739051819, 0.04967975243926048, 0.05149146169424057, -0.03997635096311569, 0.011446749791502953, -0.03136433660984039, -0.024069564417004585, 0.01926550455391407, -0.0006896372069604695, 0.015635859221220016, 0.017729921266436577, -0.058781757950782776, 0.00934950914233923, -0.04468313232064247, 0.004735215567052364, 0.04777209460735321, -0.024886174127459526, -0.038452986627817154, -0.020240318030118942, -0.015990762040019035, 0.0007759045693092048, -0.002008400158956647, -0.05799853056669235, 0.03675410524010658, 0.001390104996971786, -0.0030036289244890213, 0.0589510016143322, -0.020169982686638832, -0.05506119504570961, 0.015137366019189358, -0.008616380393505096, -0.02335570938885212, -0.03825191780924797, 0.02734532579779625, -0.008933589793741703, -0.01481059193611145, -0.0010616983054205775, 0.02333650551736355, -0.03180985152721405, 0.00392037583515048, -0.012568534351885319, -0.07624609023332596, 0.017465226352214813, -0.002600787440314889, 0.03851664438843727, -0.010467613115906715, -0.02836131677031517, 0.05852222815155983, 0.034669410437345505, -0.027629034593701363, -0.04684526100754738, 0.022477051243185997, -0.02109476365149021, -0.0034008051734417677, 0.007402463816106319, 0.021087948232889175, -0.013824282214045525, -0.0023647043853998184, 0.0015776199288666248, 0.02293309010565281, 0.06951501220464706, -0.03277456760406494, -0.004192789550870657, 0.041213639080524445, 0.0064578731544315815, 0.00013531322474591434, 0.031861573457717896, 0.006208391860127449, -0.04109351709485054, 0.017901768907904625, 0.018471166491508484, -0.030703306198120117, 0.007969255559146404, -0.06665875017642975, -0.01719765178859234, -0.013218029402196407, 0.018554294481873512, -0.04646408185362816, 0.00004842818816541694, 0.017093582078814507, 0.012151866219937801, 0.05025631934404373, 0.05835684388875961, 0.05720566213130951, 0.012318017892539501, -0.015541911125183105, 0.038675133138895035, 0.02232939936220646, -0.011491935700178146, 0.03566761314868927, -0.021168071776628494, 0.01810387521982193, 0.026597950607538223, -0.05009760335087776, -0.01751694455742836, 0.007223994936794043, 0.0055543119087815285, 0.005350205115973949, -0.003920172806829214, -0.013955383561551571, 0.02117796801030636, -0.009208942763507366, -0.04345205798745155, -0.015048767440021038, 0.0516708604991436, 0.01889016292989254, 0.030505748465657234, 0.04640403762459755, -0.023776846006512642, -0.005926788318902254, -0.008930806070566177, -0.04689899459481239, -0.01035380456596613, -0.010672688484191895, 0.010273659601807594, -0.013732167892158031, -0.011625676415860653, 0.017670853063464165, -0.03716198727488518, -0.008596541360020638, 0.017552493140101433, 0.019211314618587494, -0.05623558908700943, -0.009374070912599564, -0.007806915324181318, 0.0003485972702037543, -0.014109781011939049, 0.04363640397787094, -0.008952929638326168, -0.01584201119840145, 0.036382049322128296, 0.01254771277308464, 0.004890192300081253, -0.02388484962284565, 0.031138377264142036, 0.019641239196062088, 0.021812161430716515, -0.009832865558564663, 0.001621762989088893, 0.053103163838386536, -0.010297863744199276, -0.0012669569114223123, 0.005409366451203823, 0.018922109156847, 0.017039034515619278, 0.00256384932436049, -0.007105938624590635, -0.04896211996674538, 0.018130265176296234, -0.009651074185967445, 0.06297048926353455, -0.027208682149648666, -0.00279256165958941, 0.04316633939743042, 0.05698251724243164, -0.03814734145998955, 0.024155883118510246, 0.05098063498735428, -0.007495264522731304, 0.004317778162658215, -0.009054488502442837, -0.05257212743163109, 0.0010328406933695078, -0.02423868514597416, 0.03009824827313423, 0.006843829061836004, -0.015208435244858265, -0.02055703103542328, 0.04968796297907829, -0.01294154766947031, -0.04414764791727066, -0.0244663767516613, 0.02262846939265728, 0.020255165174603462, -0.044475190341472626, 0.006664942484349012, 0.005772537551820278, 0.02508656680583954, 0.0407523475587368, 0.039799757301807404, -0.005098578054457903, -0.08419370651245117, 0.005985736381262541, 0.050498999655246735, 0.04317935183644295, -0.0031865721102803946, -0.014993343502283096, -0.07391297817230225, -0.04411287233233452, 0.04226486757397652, 0.0011175064137205482, 0.00823887623846531, 0.018947524949908257, -0.004171563778072596, -0.00735232699662447, 0.0036875195801258087, -0.0050287991762161255, 0.018284661695361137, 0.028335047885775566, 0.03828980028629303, -0.06302152574062347, -0.025314386934041977, -0.04660681262612343, 0.012625202536582947, 0.021004417911171913, 0.02995564602315426, -0.03672485798597336, 0.024344826117157936, -0.018155761063098907, 0.00689252745360136, -0.006339393090456724, -0.04026170074939728, 0.046128906309604645, 0.011277633719146252, -0.03153151273727417, 0.06748740375041962, 0.013690195977687836, -0.01565011776983738, 0.010139139369130135, -0.01581750437617302, -0.043109528720378876, 0.024334512650966644, -0.0037098608445376158, 0.07177624106407166, 0.02911122515797615, 0.01798214204609394, 0.02134992741048336, 0.02514735236763954, 0.0048338863998651505, 0.020669858902692795, -0.04152756556868553, 0.024354804307222366, -0.0406547412276268, -0.002285529626533389, -0.058282520622015, -0.00610183784738183, -0.024863818660378456, 0.057641029357910156, -0.009315398521721363, 0.029725315049290657, -0.010481636971235275, -0.011543803848326206, 0.0010330257937312126, 0.044974278658628464, -0.03424026444554329, -0.002378421602770686, 0.02579122595489025, 0.032983046025037766, -0.007963216863572598, -0.01438436284661293, 0.031945399940013885, -0.02568739652633667, 0.00475655123591423, -0.02238176017999649, -0.034058645367622375, 0.031391460448503494, -0.051230624318122864, 0.0045362613163888454, 0.05902989208698273, -0.014825716614723206, 0.05849568173289299, 0.010187915526330471, -0.001725450623780489, 0.00406006770208478, -0.048240527510643005, 0.00154001300688833, 0.009236901067197323, 0.018830202519893646, 0.02259473316371441, -0.013798306696116924, 0.022448958829045296, 0.02206135168671608, -0.010423336178064346, -0.09414157271385193, -0.017209015786647797, 0.018204761669039726, 0.0446324497461319, -0.0168573260307312, -0.0711778774857521, 0.005822078790515661, 0.00007739692955510691, -0.015543198212981224, -0.0192123930901289, 0.0592169463634491, 0.0028634993359446526, -0.03850722312927246, -0.0058480724692344666, -0.012832673266530037, 0.07888821512460709, -0.0037328279577195644, 0.004541769623756409, 0.02574901469051838, -0.0018280340591445565, 0.003435158636420965, -0.009907295927405357, 0.042857516556978226, -0.039738208055496216, -0.02115437388420105, -0.032196883112192154, 0.016780685633420944, 0.06401710212230682, -0.048265695571899414, 0.0013568677240982652, -0.010917031206190586, 0.009638444520533085, 0.0073732733726501465, 0.0020818179473280907, -0.01739812269806862, -0.052316050976514816, 0.005323060788214207, -0.052504051476716995, 0.003986212890595198, 0.009479415602982044, -0.0025471162516623735, 0.006906392518430948, -0.003694650949910283, 0.0056851585395634174, 0.00311898160725832, 0.05012524873018265, -0.025966409593820572, -0.02430199645459652, -0.0018489991780370474, -0.011634544469416142, 0.049721237272024155, -0.021891118958592415, 0.0219378974288702, 0.03368212282657623, 0.07946588844060898, -0.008470326662063599, -0.030861184000968933, -0.047419093549251556, 0.01423630304634571, 0.071784608066082, -0.019528253003954887, 0.020499350503087044, 0.04511632025241852, -0.003365711309015751, -0.005413200706243515, -0.031021760776638985, 0.0070568048395216465, 0.01995495706796646, -0.010961438529193401, 0.05849612131714821, -0.023642532527446747, -0.010833636857569218, 0.023820148780941963, 0.014302768744528294, 0.03333864361047745, 0.03471783921122551, 0.002177524846047163, 0.04498764127492905, 0.06511344015598297, -0.03989372402429581, -0.013368925079703331, 0.02786526270210743, -0.033928245306015015, 0.039696235209703445, -0.015857165679335594, -0.04010018706321716, 0.0846085250377655, 0.024800684303045273, -0.04756155610084534, -0.03924430534243584, -0.052964843809604645, -0.07868373394012451, 0.032116759568452835, 0.042330216616392136, 0.017574355006217957, 0.029285652562975883, 0.010306929238140583, 0.0034809806384146214, 0.004050807561725378, -0.015957655385136604, -0.035210076719522476, -0.04900112375617027, 0.025551721453666687, 0.012319344095885754, -0.08392675966024399, 0.0025244983844459057, 0.028942812234163284, -0.015080137178301811, 0.007059980183839798, -0.004106348380446434, 0.01367863081395626, 0.02154192514717579, 0.040481649339199066, -0.027959154918789864, 0.06007767841219902, 0.00921612698584795, 0.025410495698451996, -0.01300184428691864, -0.016500994563102722, 0.12079265713691711, 0.07107830792665482, 0.018866125494241714, -0.04189866781234741, 0.029475942254066467, 0.001558871939778328, -0.007408155128359795, -0.052234213799238205, 0.03795108571648598, 0.041344985365867615, -0.01961670257151127, 0.06110056862235069, 0.030483782291412354, 0.01905221678316593, -0.01263341959565878, 0.036397822201251984, 0.0032472540624439716, 0.021733589470386505, 0.02599676325917244, 0.015038058161735535, -0.000306188128888607, -0.016244124621152878, -0.02099614404141903, 0.010829150676727295, 0.04155808314681053, 0.01559990830719471, -0.01853991486132145, -0.04850833863019943, 0.01122596487402916, 0.007727163378149271, -0.005508787464350462, 0.04593401774764061, 0.031567998230457306, 0.023693060502409935, -0.0007968796417117119, 0.010461338795721531, -0.008816367946565151, -0.005096980836242437, 0.0069093527272343636, 0.009935611858963966, 0.0037551315035670996, -0.017961746081709862, -0.03782522305846214, -0.010809700936079025, 0.005084645003080368, -0.020006587728857994, -0.08812157809734344, 0.03248797357082367, -0.0027813774067908525, 0.010880100540816784, 0.008542235009372234, 0.013258920051157475, 0.013403249904513359, -0.05240959674119949, -0.03703758493065834, 0.03507693111896515, 0.04568299278616905, 0.018680237233638763, -0.0023858495987951756, -0.013812294229865074, 0.04204247519373894, -0.025367040187120438, 0.020703671500086784, 0.04548145458102226, -0.043107014149427414, -0.0355086512863636, -0.01688619889318943, 0.07508454471826553, 0.015952659770846367, 0.001004607998766005, -0.025035709142684937, -0.027675161138176918, -0.017526399344205856, -0.02740795537829399, -0.016621863469481468, -0.009995208121836185, 0.028390977531671524, 0.048308152705430984, -0.0177500881254673, 0.028959864750504494, -0.03825311362743378, -0.0085422582924366, -0.013340567238628864, 0.002540444489568472, -0.04061758890748024, -0.039662718772888184, 0.05072696506977081, 0.005460255313664675, 0.027665002271533012, 0.016985373571515083, -0.013218142092227936, 0.043470125645399094, -0.008330043405294418, -0.07309826463460922, -0.007277746219187975, -0.01627665013074875, -0.01819385401904583, 0.011949182488024235, -0.006644989363849163, 0.034846752882003784, 0.02357594482600689, -0.00451479759067297, 0.04807024821639061, 0.016306649893522263, -0.020242827013134956, 0.024200133979320526, -0.014607210643589497, -0.06247859075665474, -0.014051339589059353, -0.0052550677210092545, 0.0048305680975317955, -0.015866747125983238, -0.01660330966114998, -0.031026823446154594, -0.02103985846042633, 0.008100387640297413, 0.002617532853037119, -0.042171504348516464, -0.04188671335577965, -0.006314057856798172, -0.00041946148849092424, 0.012635979801416397, -0.030650876462459564, -0.005111725069582462, -0.008982704021036625, -0.030664777383208275, -0.05736350640654564, -0.006558376830071211, -0.01196588110178709, -0.00855825375765562, 0.0022596968337893486, 0.00715623190626502, -0.0017263212939724326, -0.009634062647819519, 0.027049658820033073, 0.00047287935740314424, 0.007125949487090111, 0.07683417946100235, -0.04301813617348671, -0.007297105621546507, 0.05104169622063637, -0.02974713034927845, -0.03704984113574028, 0.05934120714664459, -0.04958628490567207, 0.025643901899456978, 0.015586941502988338, -0.0057928054593503475, -0.03829306736588478, 0.08037915825843811, 0.011692160740494728, 0.0026711050886660814, -0.011266252025961876, 0.0029958386439830065, 0.013776221312582493, -0.003301826538518071, 0.01714777946472168, -0.013044462539255619, 0.0014674453996121883, -0.0015341064427047968, 0.010641652159392834, -0.004840081091970205, 0.0010212723864242435, 0.005883506964892149, -0.01257207989692688, 0.01331034954637289, -0.024962127208709717, -0.006338472943753004, 0.029955139383673668, 0.040965817868709564, -0.01232073549181223, 0.00413177814334631, -0.003182339249178767, 0.018651848658919334, -0.05086316540837288, 0.021727928891777992, 0.029500404372811317, 0.02339540608227253, 0.018961114808917046, -0.0858873650431633, -0.010735318064689636, 0.034816499799489975, -0.04921133443713188, 0.005947641562670469, 0.022662878036499023, -0.014372902922332287, -0.02807731181383133, 0.02770810015499592, -0.009829292073845863, 0.0031215744093060493, 0.02427338808774948, 0.016054118052124977, 0.02553585357964039, -0.0035764328204095364, -0.005247591994702816, -0.01484629511833191, -0.02722053974866867, -0.0003414579259697348, 0.02645730972290039, -0.021158529445528984, 0.03450307622551918, -0.06708937883377075, -0.007835986092686653, 0.00706687243655324, -0.025658413767814636, -0.014573454856872559, 0.018806667998433113, 0.03696662560105324, -0.00813364703208208, 0.021080542355775833, 0.038294870406389236, -0.012364977970719337, -0.006260118912905455, -0.04381001740694046, 0.010786243714392185, 0.008246688172221184, 0.0033103323075920343, 0.032928500324487686, 0.023235687986016273, 0.01742255873978138, -0.02070176601409912, 0.019342951476573944, -0.02461637370288372, -0.03761263191699982, 0.006421037949621677, -0.01565241627395153, 0.03439375385642052, -0.024892909452319145, 0.023742998018860817, -0.028194550424814224, 0.02153247408568859, 0.031045330688357353, -0.009255018085241318, -0.038422033190727234, 0.024142669513821602, 0.011478746309876442, -0.06821044534444809, -0.035623494535684586, -0.0039579132571816444, -0.019593531265854836, -0.04680614545941353, -0.010534380562603474, -0.036163777112960815, 0.014427987858653069, 0.00212581898085773, -0.02714184671640396, -0.03609941154718399, 0.022456791251897812, -0.024906793609261513, -0.000366503547411412, 0.029831307008862495, 0.014562919735908508, 0.01908920705318451, -0.07134503126144409, 0.03040984831750393, 0.033054452389478683, -0.011094825342297554, -0.0194151159375906, -0.001085186144337058, 0.0056448644027113914, 0.024255815893411636, 0.0594337172806263, 0.016595616936683655, 0.009635473601520061, -0.006027766969054937, 0.010882831178605556, 0.0507095605134964, -0.013100956566631794, -0.008754868991672993, -0.04216379299759865, -0.01883801817893982, 0.016402030363678932, -0.02098361775279045, 0.05017272010445595, 0.006002494599670172, 0.011453461833298206, -0.005491637624800205, 0.0043031019158661366, -0.013895238749682903, -0.0298337172716856, 0.0001640867121750489, 0.007366330362856388, -0.042370960116386414, 0.049987927079200745, 0.0031521739438176155, -0.006149201188236475, -0.004162604454904795, -0.005902478471398354, -0.045247726142406464, 0.06314960867166519, -0.012322448194026947, -0.030024560168385506, 0.04927658662199974, -0.028270402923226357, 0.025421809405088425, -0.09501105546951294, -0.008255303837358952, 0.015135535039007664, -0.03409909829497337, -0.017102384939789772, 0.058979474008083344, 0.02613401971757412, 0.0019044775981456041, 0.007480597589164972, 0.020136337727308273, -0.015790877863764763, 0.00040114394505508244, -0.027563180774450302, 0.0025627119466662407, 0.01933610811829567, -0.007131253369152546, 0.0356522798538208, 0.012464228086173534, -0.011142191477119923, -0.010422038845717907, -0.01819685846567154, 0.03115924820303917, 0.022335540503263474, -0.025882378220558167, 0.02631138265132904, -0.003908947110176086, 0.0016482546925544739, 0.0007764261099509895, 0.005664291325956583, 0.0357261560857296, 0.004690714180469513, 0.007633707951754332, -0.0710047036409378, -0.061345700174570084, -0.046824414283037186, 0.026655886322259903, 0.028552375733852386, 0.031460244208574295, 0.030176393687725067, 0.027481067925691605, -0.006032112054526806, -0.021306337788701057, 0.0017652391688898206, -0.029203103855252266, 0.030586816370487213, -0.0461445115506649, 0.017951032146811485, 0.04141256958246231, -0.004128236789256334, -0.040631506592035294, 0.01236402615904808, -0.0018346883589401841, 0.0017904994310811162, 0.04122617095708847, 0.032921966165304184, -0.04903121665120125, -0.0008368166745640337, 0.025197114795446396, -0.06801542639732361, -0.047177672386169434, -0.05693894624710083, 0.016102366149425507, 0.01562080904841423, -0.00587547617033124 ]
<p>In gaussian_kde from scipy library there are two methods to estimate the bandwidth, "scott" and "silverman"</p> <p>The silverman rule of thumb is explained <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kernel_density_estimation#Practical_estimation_of_the_bandwidth" rel="nofollow">here</a> and the equivalent function in R is provided <a href="http://stat.ethz.ch/R-manual/R-patched/library/MASS/html/bandwidth.nrd.html" rel="nofollow">here</a></p> <p>So my question is, why the Silverman method in "gaussian_kde" doesn't look like same. You can see the code <a href="https://github.com/scipy/scipy/blob/v0.12.0/scipy/stats/kde.py#L432" rel="nofollow">here</a> . There is nothing about the variance and other stuff. the only parameters that the methods use is the dimension of the data !</p> <p>Last but not least, I to have different number of bandwidth given the number of dimension. Each dimension should have its own bandwidth.</p> <p>might be I am mistaken and this "silverman_factor" is not exactly silver man estimation. if so some one provide me how can I calculate the bandwidth using this library or other library in Python?</p> <p><strong>UPDATE</strong></p> <p>before going to the code, I would like to remind myself the Silverman's rule of thumb for bandwidth selection. So basically it is equal to 1,06*std*n**1/5 where std is standard deviation and n is the dimension of data.</p> <p>here is a R impelentation </p> <p>library(MASS) n.grid = 25</p> <pre><code>x = c(1, 9, 4, 10) y = c(11, 3, 5, 7) delta = c(bcv(x), bcv(y)) # 14.66375 11.78500 kde2d.xy &lt;- kde2d(x, y, n = 25, h = delta) FXY &lt;- kde2d.xy$z + .Machine$double.eps dx &lt;- kde2d.xy$x[2] - kde2d.xy$x[1] dy &lt;- kde2d.xy$y[2] - kde2d.xy$y[1] PXY &lt;- FXY/(sum(FXY)*dx*dy) PX &lt;- rowSums(PXY)*dy PY &lt;- colSums(PXY)*dx HXY &lt;- -sum(PXY * log(PXY))*dx*dy #entropy </code></pre> <p>and the equivalent python code :</p> <pre><code>import numpy as np import scipy.stats as stats from scipy.stats.stats import pearsonr def colSum(x): return sum(x) def rowSum(x): return sum(x.T) a = (1, 9, 4, 10) b = (11, 3, 5, 7) n = 25 tt = np.array( [ a, b ] ) rvs = tt.T kde = stats.gaussian_kde(rvs.T, bw_method='silverman') #~ kde = stats.gaussian_kde(rvs.T) #~ kde.set_bandwidth(11) kde.silverman_factor() x_flat = np.r_[rvs[:,0].min():rvs[:,0].max():25j] y_flat = np.r_[rvs[:,1].min():rvs[:,1].max():25j] # Regular grid to evaluate kde upon x,y = np.meshgrid(x_flat,y_flat) grid_coords = np.append(x.reshape(-1,1),y.reshape(-1,1),axis=1) z = kde(grid_coords.T) z = z.reshape(n,n) rho = pearsonr(a, b)[0] FXY = z + np.finfo(np.float).eps dx = x[0][2] - x[0][1] dy = y[1][0] - y[0][0] PXY = FXY/sum(sum(FXY))*dx*dy PX = rowSum(PXY)*dy PY = colSum(PXY)*dx HXY = -sum(sum(PXY * np.log(PXY)))*dx*dy print 'X : ' + str(a) print 'Y : ' + str(b) print 'bw : ' + str(kde.covariance_factor()) print kde.covariance print 'entropy: ' + str(HXY) bw1 bw2 H python 11.34 7.39 0.13 R 14.66 11.78 4.32 </code></pre> <p>I also have to add from what @rroowwllaanndd said the actual <em>silverman factor</em> is calculated in <code>_compute_covariance</code> function and the bandwidth values are diagonal of <code>kde_object.covariance</code> matrix even though <code>kde_object.silverman_factor()</code> does not return these diagonals.</p> <p>It is also very confusing that when I feed the R code with band width values from python, the entropy is not comparable to the python's value.</p> <pre><code>library(MASS) n.grid = 25 x = c(1, 9, 4, 10) y = c(11, 3, 5, 7) # delta = c(bcv(x), bcv(y)) delta = c(11.34, 7.39) # scipy bandwidth estimations from python code kde2d.xy &lt;- kde2d(x, y, n = n.grid, h = delta) FXY &lt;- kde2d.xy$z + .Machine$double.eps dx &lt;- kde2d.xy$x[2] - kde2d.xy$x[1] dy &lt;- kde2d.xy$y[2] - kde2d.xy$y[1] PXY &lt;- FXY/(sum(FXY)*dx*dy) PX &lt;- rowSums(PXY)*dy PY &lt;- colSums(PXY)*dx HXY &lt;- -sum(PXY * log(PXY))*dx*dy </code></pre>
73,815
[ -0.046764153987169266, 0.027150578796863556, 0.01548626646399498, -0.025022277608513832, 0.054040323942899704, 0.004696362651884556, 0.0026753959245979786, -0.0475093238055706, -0.004012707155197859, -0.038077451288700104, 0.029488487169146538, 0.027338877320289612, 0.06627383828163147, 0.03164036571979523, 0.007170432712882757, 0.0027254223823547363, 0.029920006170868874, -0.006832466926425695, -0.004930021706968546, -0.05134454742074013, -0.009799242950975895, 0.01941985823214054, -0.0012765562860295177, -0.0026570549234747887, -0.07933687418699265, 0.07230944186449051, 0.011810462921857834, -0.036353446543216705, -0.01407479215413332, 0.04274971783161163, -0.015985237434506416, -0.03545387461781502, 0.012968462891876698, -0.0017664439510554075, 0.0069552636705338955, 0.002613323274999857, -0.053822193294763565, -0.024376826360821724, -0.004104421474039555, 0.017015822231769562, -0.04469028487801552, -0.00568013358861208, -0.005782061256468296, 0.0013077612966299057, 0.022001178935170174, 0.04411354288458824, 0.059905871748924255, -0.019425466656684875, 0.04497268423438072, -0.02028963901102543, 0.06412772089242935, -0.0057481140829622746, 0.020497391000390053, 0.03259295970201492, -0.02892054058611393, 0.004267461597919464, 0.049759089946746826, 0.04271411523222923, -0.03613841161131859, -0.0909099206328392, 0.004542567301541567, -0.03193758428096771, -0.0035641684662550688, 0.0071561988443136215, 0.01981697790324688, 0.0025797542184591293, 0.0024272436276078224, -0.01901738904416561, 0.02722640335559845, -0.0035985875874757767, 0.023670848459005356, -0.008358532562851906, 0.04805661365389824, -0.023042161017656326, 0.03155647590756416, -0.011799967847764492, -0.01370656955987215, 0.0211283341050148, 0.02529814839363098, 0.05700548365712166, 0.0047762333415448666, 0.023984115570783615, 0.012712021358311176, -0.024184897541999817, 0.04226977750658989, 0.021082213148474693, 0.07080411165952682, -0.015989376232028008, 0.010298295877873898, 0.028351617977023125, -0.018268119543790817, -0.006400208920240402, 0.08946649730205536, -0.0042242067866027355, -0.01024702563881874, 0.03572721406817436, -0.0017882566899061203, -0.008072692900896072, -0.05074785277247429, -0.0453154630959034, -0.008552237413823605, -0.05528644844889641, -0.013747614808380604, 0.06716243922710419, -0.03852973133325577, -0.033673245459795, -0.02112063579261303, 0.00018050200014840811, -0.017376141622662544, -0.02942502312362194, -0.042784370481967926, 0.02424037456512451, -0.00026099340175278485, -0.0007515852339565754, 0.004828851670026779, -0.028016556054353714, -0.00727801863104105, 0.008086448535323143, 0.051523253321647644, 0.08376610279083252, 0.0130285220220685, -0.004331241827458143, 0.0001359431626042351, -0.012879601679742336, -0.03429262712597847, 0.02388542890548706, 0.017467861995100975, -0.020808501169085503, -0.016907284036278725, 0.0318181999027729, 0.023371621966362, -0.02357340231537819, 0.07637891918420792, 0.02118104137480259, 0.018144816160202026, 0.001065630465745926, -0.08520976454019547, -0.06415693461894989, 0.04956428334116936, -0.01717391237616539, 0.031363945454359055, -0.048801735043525696, 0.015486248768866062, -0.001785004511475563, 0.06065220385789871, 0.0350443460047245, 0.03899151831865311, -0.0005994932143948972, 0.0019671309273689985, -0.009844682179391384, -0.07258199155330658, 0.00898768287152052, -0.030039651319384575, -0.006779263261705637, -0.0019558954518288374, -0.04443421959877014, 0.006524528376758099, -0.002479187911376357, 0.010310211218893528, 0.009192177094519138, 0.011810088530182838, 0.034519389271736145, -0.013460367918014526, -0.0024981172755360603, 0.016136664897203445, -0.031639017164707184, 0.04595547541975975, 0.046409521251916885, 0.08041601628065109, -0.0314013846218586, -0.015025141648948193, -0.028140714392066002, -0.031817417591810226, 0.02775757573544979, 0.011656195856630802, -0.035118263214826584, -0.0024277621414512396, -0.0469108410179615, -0.0031491145491600037, -0.00006378693069564179, -0.0531899631023407, -0.023270931094884872, 0.0021501434966921806, -0.04197253659367561, 0.01168255414813757, 0.039374418556690216, 0.008382120169699192, 0.038792844861745834, 0.04465557262301445, -0.05863703042268753, -0.03831961378455162, -0.020049631595611572, -0.008105864748358727, 0.003599944058805704, -0.01340007409453392, -0.02570764347910881, 0.0017700635362416506, 0.038685623556375504, 0.006040000356733799, 0.025525927543640137, 0.00974294263869524, 0.005544178653508425, 0.01435356680303812, -0.01966048963367939, -0.030075371265411377, 0.05526801198720932, 0.038565125316381454, -0.013037122786045074, -0.0011219177395105362, -0.026204178109765053, -0.019340112805366516, 0.030429890379309654, -0.03256165608763695, 0.02215866930782795, -0.0018349423771724105, -0.05500410124659538, 0.04100453481078148, 0.013595717027783394, -0.01583763211965561, 0.047648075968027115, -0.07199226319789886, 0.06814776360988617, 0.05768875777721405, 0.011434436775743961, -0.007784666493535042, 0.01406091172248125, -0.04950163513422012, 0.023005817085504532, -0.03896087408065796, -0.03061705268919468, -0.03399018198251724, -0.026038089767098427, 0.044492557644844055, 0.028898807242512703, -0.01791044883430004, -0.013541913591325283, 0.0558522567152977, -0.02879462204873562, 0.027972670271992683, -0.00563915865495801, -0.010091624222695827, -0.03828061372041702, -0.0033830818720161915, -0.004380206577479839, -0.0005794044118374586, 0.011326344683766365, 0.016761599108576775, -0.00036809794255532324, 0.053233176469802856, -0.006755485199391842, 0.001891988911665976, 0.03720877692103386, -0.019180700182914734, -0.029771724715828896, -0.008544424548745155, 0.005745272152125835, 0.0369223952293396, -0.010647423565387726, -0.011514203622937202, 0.048703573644161224, 0.0006041863816790283, 0.017828142270445824, -0.018875008448958397, 0.014651667326688766, -0.0006625103997066617, 0.017589565366506577, -0.048298127949237823, -0.012490905821323395, 0.0037433579564094543, -0.021881630644202232, -0.016134871169924736, -0.01285962387919426, -0.013827716000378132, -0.023025762289762497, -0.003288653213530779, 0.04324157536029816, 0.0137178311124444, 0.03875427693128586, -0.03429219871759415, 0.018438218161463737, 0.00852622278034687, 0.022561201825737953, 0.038473986089229584, 0.017246779054403305, -0.01212370302528143, 0.0015936191193759441, 0.007594211958348751, 0.0005710707046091557, 0.007968489080667496, -0.051841046661138535, -0.0014170958893373609, 0.012441429309546947, 0.020645176991820335, -0.03667621314525604, 0.040544673800468445, -0.014278351329267025, 0.03203415498137474, 0.008594132028520107, -0.005427767522633076, 0.031180309131741524, -0.01573566533625126, -0.0682447999715805, 0.040694911032915115, -0.04058797284960747, -0.041282035410404205, -0.023577770218253136, 0.025634784251451492, -0.02494187094271183, -0.027328282594680786, -0.006362594198435545, 0.06954565644264221, 0.02253669686615467, -0.017079802230000496, -0.03370526805520058, -0.06130280718207359, 0.02583577111363411, 0.0022592891473323107, 0.05056920275092125, -0.013558111153542995, -0.0010791972745209932, 0.041087958961725235, 0.045524243265390396, -0.00961617473512888, -0.038897816091775894, -0.01167226117104292, -0.04040052369236946, -0.018249034881591797, 0.04644632339477539, 0.032062556594610214, 0.012305816635489464, -0.02072792500257492, 0.0264489334076643, 0.01725742779672146, 0.034398261457681656, -0.031034354120492935, -0.0001758555881679058, -0.03227813169360161, -0.01979878731071949, -0.01012255996465683, 0.04718809574842453, 0.010764546692371368, -0.007153005804866552, -0.003556938376277685, -0.05343225598335266, 0.019209694117307663, 0.015255044214427471, -0.050598807632923126, -0.009218339808285236, -0.02598855085670948, 0.029448455199599266, -0.05110934004187584, -0.019299646839499474, 0.04043586552143097, -0.06419328600168228, 0.007276992313563824, 0.03432563319802284, 0.015194361098110676, -0.004141921177506447, -0.007815730758011341, 0.04999609664082527, 0.030343621969223022, 0.011232455261051655, 0.04335822910070419, -0.019501807168126106, -0.008110369555652142, -0.015233485959470272, -0.017141947522759438, -0.019157718867063522, 0.006284445058554411, 0.05322127044200897, -0.034390028566122055, -0.03460000455379486, -0.03532902151346207, 0.022590065374970436, -0.09697020798921585, -0.014605424366891384, -0.01316723134368658, 0.024756895378232002, -0.0032307994551956654, 0.021683959290385246, 0.05208803713321686, 0.0002554532256908715, -0.014554492197930813, -0.025239691138267517, -0.06124505400657654, -0.008284686133265495, -0.014593455009162426, -0.0330728255212307, 0.013918324373662472, -0.02180880308151245, 0.010551759973168373, 0.004434350412338972, 0.033437326550483704, 0.0023715458810329437, 0.0057167597115039825, -0.054548799991607666, -0.0011686144862324, 0.00484464643523097, -0.004805251024663448, -0.011059465818107128, 0.018044155091047287, 0.08190831542015076, 0.02001471072435379, 0.05056924745440483, 0.015142337419092655, 0.010096234269440174, -0.02702358365058899, 0.023799171671271324, 0.004015910904854536, 0.016766704618930817, 0.06659717112779617, -0.026206808164715767, 0.007644364144653082, -0.0652027353644371, 0.02180604264140129, -0.020395247265696526, 0.03640659898519516, 0.037457339465618134, -0.010047105140984058, -0.0057557569816708565, -0.025818150490522385, 0.012150827795267105, 0.014988663606345654, -0.032666150480508804, -0.011467812582850456, 0.014935305342078209, 0.05749879777431488, -0.006676619406789541, -0.013618710450828075, 0.0008369061979465187, 0.03438464552164078, 0.010754016228020191, 0.01216286700218916, -0.016835756599903107, -0.008687986992299557, 0.0030218816827982664, -0.026058735325932503, 0.03304982930421829, 0.04862722381949425, -0.004650854971259832, 0.03032325580716133, 0.05911955609917641, -0.0048737907782197, -0.021281594410538673, 0.008032698184251785, 0.04039709270000458, 0.039686232805252075, -0.04317906126379967, -0.021755551919341087, -0.01785901002585888, 0.003443625755608082, 0.029429255053400993, 0.005176958162337542, -0.02264784649014473, -0.07306820899248123, -0.02239002287387848, 0.0033681709319353104, 0.0216112919151783, -0.002264950191602111, 0.011889563873410225, -0.07035429775714874, 0.0006483634933829308, -0.017948292195796967, -0.03851243853569031, 0.03948308527469635, -0.023914996534585953, 0.021362265571951866, -0.0014319008914753795, -0.0380345918238163, 0.00030894469819031656, 0.00024706884869374335, 0.014638065360486507, 0.021005867049098015, -0.018615582957863808, -0.03996150568127632, -0.023151502013206482, 0.024238646030426025, -0.004540018271654844, 0.058776479214429855, -0.014915513806045055, -0.023267695680260658, 0.030420253053307533, 0.03849446773529053, 0.013205260969698429, -0.03649762645363808, 0.051406580954790115, 0.02267645299434662, 0.04561782628297806, 0.05730658024549484, -0.026402678340673447, -0.05377482995390892, 0.020431092008948326, 0.027315653860569, -0.032917898148298264, 0.022347809746861458, -0.012378762476146221, 0.07008698582649231, 0.008770919404923916, 0.013173442333936691, 0.06658632308244705, 0.04630838334560394, -0.03358083963394165, 0.02213837020099163, -0.03477801755070686, -0.0011404325487092137, -0.03883867710828781, -0.03259934112429619, -0.03891569375991821, -0.00033335102489218116, -0.021987393498420715, 0.023308729752898216, 0.012191347777843475, 0.06095032021403313, -0.03730590268969536, 0.006043198984116316, 0.020348751917481422, 0.01598450168967247, -0.013086482882499695, 0.024022703990340233, 0.016299763694405556, 0.04704935476183891, 0.0038922885432839394, 0.019057296216487885, 0.009839056059718132, -0.010644393041729927, -0.00457741878926754, 0.015858137980103493, -0.03839365765452385, -0.036257553845644, -0.031968455761671066, -0.038261428475379944, 0.0133615517988801, -0.03611477091908455, 0.039712902158498764, -0.009860705584287643, 0.013274848461151123, 0.003594230394810438, -0.01225003506988287, -0.031910426914691925, 0.0022626551799476147, -0.031831514090299606, 0.028333138674497604, 0.002006475580856204, -0.00876589585095644, 0.014566641300916672, 0.03687288984656334, -0.0789756178855896, 0.013433343730866909, 0.048804692924022675, -0.009771711193025112, -0.03040129691362381, -0.03135725483298302, -0.0036165586207062006, -0.014635837636888027, -0.004551256075501442, 0.010644913651049137, 0.017494453117251396, -0.01172956358641386, 0.016080720350146294, -0.016476137563586235, 0.032183945178985596, 0.05172945186495781, -0.006420711055397987, 0.009981359355151653, 0.02908952161669731, -0.002994117559865117, -0.00998299103230238, -0.020198576152324677, 0.027750730514526367, -0.012330998666584492, 0.03788395971059799, -0.02954225242137909, -0.012989522889256477, 0.033296387642621994, 0.008946399204432964, -0.04224349185824394, -0.0034456788562238216, -0.013892444781959057, -0.016888251528143883, -0.036184173077344894, -0.02307194471359253, -0.025778843089938164, -0.007960055023431778, 0.005518728867173195, -0.023799357935786247, -0.029920073226094246, -0.016749661415815353, 0.0391744002699852, -0.01834617555141449, -0.003441068110987544, 0.021975388750433922, 0.0828666165471077, 0.01941116899251938, -0.018243087455630302, -0.011606382206082344, -0.027282509952783585, 0.015198267996311188, -0.022836817428469658, -0.008459672331809998, 0.012016015127301216, 0.02183179184794426, -0.03468877449631691, -0.05339355766773224, -0.07994964718818665, 0.03568756952881813, 0.0517180897295475, -0.01618361845612526, 0.04970276355743408, 0.004739739932119846, -0.052452005445957184, -0.0077367303892970085, -0.025347532704472542, -0.019107379019260406, -0.0016572038875892758, -0.021804537624120712, 0.025377927348017693, 0.04557414725422859, -0.016803106293082237, 0.08114197105169296, 0.02370266616344452, 0.02410574071109295, 0.07123801857233047, 0.005697502754628658, -0.0038913332391530275, 0.018983155488967896, -0.022542830556631088, -0.0019800583831965923, 0.030485404655337334, 0.021294232457876205, 0.04900428652763367, -0.04812973365187645, 0.023906581103801727, 0.009815027005970478, 0.028232688084244728, 0.009347164072096348, -0.0693524032831192, -0.013320229947566986, -0.054891545325517654, 0.008199482224881649, 0.054168399423360825, -0.02333591878414154, 0.017716528847813606, 0.015820737928152084, 0.03013203665614128, -0.005032267887145281, 0.033190999180078506, -0.00895968172699213, -0.03838234394788742, -0.010105784982442856, -0.03510238230228424, -0.02214076556265354, 0.04648739844560623, 0.00007782149623380974, -0.044569458812475204, -0.007617764174938202, -0.010082818567752838, 0.05411307513713837, -0.009624183177947998, 0.026309534907341003, 0.013874631375074387, 0.06655016541481018, -0.0068741003051400185, 0.005340632051229477, -0.06661444157361984, -0.010901546105742455, 0.14760766923427582, 0.054608240723609924, 0.05807879567146301, -0.022533556446433067, -0.02087794616818428, 0.026464516296982765, -0.007975912652909756, -0.037802331149578094, 0.0012449611676856875, -0.04413469135761261, -0.0041852351278066635, 0.06171545758843422, 0.011001581326127052, 0.015534122474491596, -0.019949166104197502, 0.02017350308597088, -0.02579028159379959, 0.03384235128760338, 0.00237262318842113, 0.007620931603014469, 0.004007499665021896, -0.02105358988046646, -0.06955480575561523, 0.06609021127223969, -0.0019394784467294812, -0.01808703877031803, -0.04971710592508316, 0.01928584650158882, 0.014423859305679798, -0.008974622003734112, -0.0643966943025589, 0.0046391962096095085, -0.016499096527695656, -0.010083787143230438, 0.06552781164646149, 0.023681191727519035, 0.026168763637542725, -0.025379477068781853, 0.01691293902695179, 0.025966472923755646, -0.009479611180722713, 0.000525624374859035, 0.013379386626183987, 0.00986073911190033, -0.0021881794091314077, -0.01881348341703415, -0.005859247408807278, 0.03730849549174309, -0.021556515246629715, 0.02816840633749962, 0.010791992768645287, 0.02403251826763153, -0.015289145521819592, -0.0575694665312767, -0.017244329676032066, -0.016335753723978996, 0.05341224744915962, -0.015846358612179756, 0.018506702035665512, -0.0010132420575246215, -0.01625535823404789, -0.05498502403497696, 0.049499284476041794, 0.01978430151939392, -0.024548405781388283, -0.05517631024122238, -0.02145758830010891, 0.0640205517411232, 0.017227834090590477, 0.023645730689167976, -0.013194991275668144, -0.05148524045944214, -0.04473084956407547, -0.04255364462733269, -0.012672645971179008, -0.004632236436009407, -0.0022915967274457216, -0.03505561873316765, -0.029567280784249306, -0.023426955565810204, -0.028924044221639633, 0.008607440628111362, 0.004871181212365627, -0.00015593989519402385, -0.03456360474228859, -0.010030386969447136, 0.039793241769075394, -0.01032120082527399, 0.01575392857193947, 0.038477666676044464, -0.010281259194016457, 0.017905283719301224, 0.03638555854558945, -0.060361385345458984, -0.02868545614182949, -0.01542190182954073, -0.03597009554505348, -0.023596934974193573, 0.013337694108486176, 0.0241412203758955, 0.02933596447110176, 0.028169600293040276, 0.012734953314065933, 0.02029598318040371, -0.031775400042533875, 0.00024108054640237242, -0.029723001644015312, -0.05621855705976486, 0.03348705172538757, 0.014483422972261906, 0.03300042450428009, -0.0676693394780159, 0.0035558983217924833, -0.030169259756803513, -0.052461057901382446, -0.014304924756288528, -0.017051590606570244, -0.01802479662001133, -0.010692515410482883, 0.013519437052309513, -0.01714295893907547, -0.009530602023005486, 0.0046343328431248665, 0.023799551650881767, 0.012957282364368439, -0.042743511497974396, -0.010954970493912697, -0.019003519788384438, -0.015419162809848785, -0.030543474480509758, 0.013395154848694801, 0.020128821954131126, -0.0002593671379145235, 0.0426822192966938, -0.036280471831560135, 0.036910530179739, -0.01430357526987791, 0.0026079616509377956, 0.0031066201627254486, -0.016397938132286072, 0.03401162475347519, -0.07564778625965118, -0.07347497344017029, 0.02624497190117836, -0.017897192388772964, 0.007457046769559383, -0.007398037239909172, -0.005833127070218325, -0.026619315147399902, 0.05992256850004196, -0.030530450865626335, -0.008605738170444965, 0.0014989195624366403, 0.004026839509606361, 0.00587606942281127, -0.02037275955080986, 0.008597525767982006, -0.01820947974920273, 0.017349274829030037, 0.049628082662820816, 0.032268960028886795, -0.03225778043270111, -0.0286848284304142, 0.02540913037955761, -0.05386517569422722, -0.014866285026073456, 0.006586935371160507, -0.0020683957263827324, 0.03918555751442909, 0.0449710376560688, -0.029384838417172432, -0.01359042339026928, -0.02522991970181465, 0.025594696402549744, -0.11295941472053528, -0.006235545966774225, 0.022616058588027954, 0.0364794060587883, 0.027710556983947754, -0.02175496146082878, 0.02829643338918686, 0.022956227883696556, -0.06675981730222702, 0.0629582554101944, 0.04886120930314064, 0.0016669802134856582, -0.057056017220020294, 0.03843625262379646, -0.020524507388472557, -0.013143271207809448, 0.038958948105573654, 0.018453523516654968, 0.05201517790555954, 0.03465627506375313, -0.02364281378686428, -0.02778763510286808, -0.03966790810227394, 0.022469358518719673, -0.002214292995631695, -0.0575992688536644, 0.02967851236462593, -0.018832890316843987, -0.001640323200263083, 0.05255284905433655, -0.014685047790408134, 0.027262568473815918, -0.010909329168498516, 0.030067218467593193, 0.014903968200087547, 0.043450623750686646, 0.061934929341077805, -0.007154407445341349, -0.008611207827925682, -0.0053690047934651375, 0.02472306601703167, 0.008301224559545517, -0.018528377637267113, 0.012362400069832802, 0.028321921825408936, -0.02823898009955883, 0.00776309659704566, -0.015805669128894806, -0.007992963306605816, -0.012253230437636375, 0.023109352216124535, -0.017564179375767708, -0.001881190575659275, -0.02425592578947544, 0.021434590220451355, -0.0481514148414135, 0.013824129477143288, 0.01612676866352558, 0.00900824461132288, -0.05808462202548981, 0.03428496792912483, -0.005065076518803835, -0.028533214703202248, 0.0006520278402604163, 0.012776345945894718, -0.012006190605461597, -0.026493625715374947, 0.01624087058007717, -0.006127798464149237, 0.016244344413280487, 0.016853656619787216, -0.017783774062991142, -0.0432237833738327, 0.036940060555934906, 0.0003052030224353075, 0.02110004611313343, -0.01576978899538517, -0.011530437506735325, -0.0035255891270935535, -0.07315117120742798, 0.043236568570137024, 0.004978189244866371, -0.056938719004392624, -0.00622845534235239, -0.010179788805544376, -0.0163975041359663, 0.003771767485886812, 0.07986095547676086, 0.01723654754459858, -0.006595013663172722, -0.020794300362467766, 0.03329746052622795, -0.0029857049230486155, -0.0561203733086586, -0.008284619078040123, -0.014948329888284206, -0.06074594706296921, 0.016492992639541626, -0.01849932223558426, 0.03052387200295925, 0.025062019005417824, 0.005872417241334915, 0.016958126798272133, 0.010229106992483139, 0.019528696313500404, -0.013415055349469185, -0.004356951918452978, 0.036088425666093826, -0.020974500104784966, 0.03647124394774437, 0.01975611038506031, -0.030864611268043518, -0.0011602964950725436, 0.023105276748538017, -0.017861241474747658, 0.009180971421301365, 0.022777486592531204, 0.00250113382935524, 0.00010296257096342742, 0.00510042067617178, 0.03561504930257797, -0.07755719870328903, -0.032985713332891464, 0.07215515524148941, -0.032700635492801666, -0.0020009076688438654, 0.020914636552333832, 0.0016501516802236438, 0.018772223964333534, 0.02922694943845272, 0.025663331151008606, -0.008929833769798279, -0.017669562250375748, 0.00749808456748724, 0.03366032615303993, -0.01267522107809782, 0.008827781304717064, 0.009828075766563416, 0.042752135545015335, -0.009984083473682404, 0.0034777445252984762, -0.04688159003853798, 0.046813637018203735, -0.029654648154973984, -0.01157829537987709, -0.018984226509928703, 0.006344637367874384, -0.012219543568789959, 0.03034891001880169, -0.014046730473637581, 0.0726410448551178, -0.033299267292022705, -0.022503139451146126, 0.020388752222061157, -0.006918847095221281, -0.022917000576853752, 0.0037084557116031647, -0.009704215452075005, 0.012974416837096214, 0.009873626753687859, 0.01615580916404724, 0.02933148853480816, -0.009265161119401455, 0.006751790642738342, -0.03854596987366676, 0.006197270005941391, 0.020204124972224236, 0.022849109023809433, 0.012774797156453133, 0.03257891163229942, 0.010427271015942097, 0.005485892295837402, 0.024177901446819305, 0.030989451333880424, 0.004463153425604105, 0.0028913221322000027, -0.04779502749443054, -0.0037724184803664684, 0.04438997805118561, -0.04551532492041588, -0.002644923748448491, -0.009720871224999428, -0.012092331424355507, 0.008099169470369816, 0.007884078659117222 ]
<p>Let $$X_1,\dots,X_m$$ are i.i.d. with distribution function $F$ and $$Y_1,\dots,Y_n$$ are i.i.d. with distribution function $G$. Suppose that there exists an unknown function $\psi:\mathbb{R}\mapsto\mathbb{R}$ such that $\psi(X_i)\sim N(0,1)$ and $\psi(Y_j)\sim N(0,\sigma^2)$ for all $i=1,\dots,m$ and $j=1,\dots,n$. I'd like to estimate $\sigma^2$ in this problem.</p> <p>I have obtained the following facts:</p> <p>Note that $F(x)=P(X\le x)=P(\psi(X)\le \psi(x))=\Phi(\psi(x))$ where $\Phi$ is the cumulative standard normal distribution. This implies $\psi(x)=\Phi^{-1}(F(x))$.</p> <p>Recall that $\psi(Y_j)\sim N(0,\sigma^2)$. So, $$\check\sigma^2=\frac1n\sum_{j=1}^n\psi^2(Y_j)$$ is an optimal estimator for $\sigma^2$. Since $F$ is unknown then I replace it with its empirical distribution function $\hat F_m$ based on $X_1,\dots,X_m$. Hence, it is natural to replace $\psi$ with $\hat\psi=\Phi^{-1}(\hat F_m)$. Therefore, I conjecture that $$\hat\sigma^2=\frac1n\sum_{j=1}^n\hat\psi^2(Y_j)$$ is an optimal estimator. I have tried to show $\check\sigma^2$ and $\hat\sigma^2$ are asymptotically equivalent, but I was failed. Could anyone help me? Or does any one have another approach?</p>
73,816
[ -0.03188887983560562, -0.01145217940211296, 0.015604416839778423, -0.031178520992398262, -0.010032455436885357, -0.02775861881673336, -0.016187062487006187, -0.044731657952070236, 0.016318192705512047, -0.055485885590314865, 0.05715362727642059, 0.026567857712507248, 0.06200534477829933, 0.028541333973407745, 0.036488305777311325, 0.0058246334083378315, -0.05167737230658531, 0.039971232414245605, -0.04529031738638878, 0.017855534330010414, -0.006592841818928719, 0.04924352094531059, 0.009732375852763653, -0.00558877270668745, -0.05753471329808235, 0.054366759955883026, -0.0023695691488683224, -0.015768950805068016, -0.03288368508219719, 0.1124715581536293, -0.041371993720531464, -0.012499751523137093, 0.03698258101940155, 0.062002792954444885, 0.04348281770944595, -0.0006049845833331347, -0.03613880276679993, -0.045986007899045944, 0.0051016416400671005, 0.028573928400874138, -0.035585902631282806, -0.020138971507549286, 0.029820652678608894, 0.007645346689969301, -0.017185602337121964, 0.04756100848317146, -0.02364899218082428, -0.026654865592718124, 0.031756870448589325, -0.05335565656423569, 0.09766169637441635, 0.020151183009147644, 0.015722978860139847, 0.03319317474961281, 0.003306928789243102, -0.0333324559032917, 0.0412130132317543, 0.07559604942798615, 0.016798920929431915, -0.06300078332424164, -0.005767331458628178, -0.04643642529845238, 0.016373613849282265, -0.0328831784427166, -0.025426072999835014, 0.003345103934407234, -0.008213242515921593, -0.024516219273209572, -0.006486847996711731, -0.04112732782959938, 0.011894372291862965, 0.0006998811149969697, 0.017900319769978523, -0.0068881092593073845, 0.02127283439040184, 0.00717397965490818, 0.0020615572575479746, 0.04247539862990379, 0.018588975071907043, 0.005715245846658945, 0.06480715423822403, 0.02065006084740162, 0.03677740693092346, 0.014816743321716785, 0.024768104776740074, 0.008353992365300655, 0.08676548302173615, 0.0031512111891061068, 0.04864969849586487, 0.04437638074159622, 0.010677925311028957, 0.0028372269589453936, 0.053941383957862854, -0.036479659378528595, -0.025773748755455017, 0.010659233666956425, -0.018029753118753433, -0.007837987504899502, 0.009601243771612644, -0.03750122711062431, -0.013008221983909607, -0.04992103576660156, -0.012418321333825588, 0.06967033445835114, -0.01178941410034895, -0.016119344159960747, -0.03182180970907211, -0.004598724655807018, -0.01766292192041874, -0.02284080535173416, -0.002368014305830002, 0.049735698848962784, -0.02718556858599186, 0.005123998038470745, 0.009496308863162994, 0.00918849091976881, -0.016986776143312454, -0.010084574110805988, 0.03557189553976059, 0.06839752197265625, 0.042541537433862686, 0.00989726185798645, -0.04005521535873413, -0.01810704730451107, -0.011422972194850445, 0.028216777369379997, 0.025284919887781143, 0.0020643670577555895, -0.0702715814113617, 0.035804130136966705, 0.026800302788615227, -0.038863398134708405, 0.02972562052309513, 0.0278338510543108, 0.026729267090559006, -0.007647248916327953, -0.06297426670789719, -0.007778970059007406, 0.02851244993507862, -0.018760493025183678, 0.05049098655581474, -0.07056768238544464, -0.0066439807415008545, 0.04883782938122749, 0.05735623463988304, 0.006695371586829424, 0.04779113456606865, -0.007258355151861906, 0.04702158644795418, 0.018313517794013023, 0.006573708727955818, -0.06957722455263138, -0.012448213063180447, -0.058521904051303864, -0.04008888825774193, -0.05724019184708595, 0.032096538692712784, 0.036484815180301666, -0.023753071203827858, -0.012493468821048737, 0.033875226974487305, 0.043927330523729324, -0.00034030003007501364, -0.021275343373417854, 0.008951602503657341, -0.028337908908724785, 0.017032453790307045, 0.01485324464738369, 0.05338137224316597, 0.0063281371258199215, -0.04885386303067207, 0.01740412414073944, -0.018435297533869743, 0.046177372336387634, 0.016608381643891335, -0.08062122017145157, -0.030298952013254166, -0.03782488405704498, -0.0034633269533514977, 0.030949540436267853, -0.0035996553488075733, 0.017176808789372444, -0.043433256447315216, -0.004883042071014643, 0.03565632179379463, 0.03774481639266014, 0.03216491639614105, -0.046355124562978745, -0.0009333912748843431, -0.05843153968453407, -0.0287787988781929, -0.051611848175525665, -0.004215606953948736, -0.004662036430090666, -0.05229312181472778, 0.041848570108413696, -0.0039157927967607975, -0.001149238203652203, 0.0008049658499658108, 0.018702639266848564, -0.016209157183766365, -0.011860418133437634, 0.03793559968471527, -0.029234498739242554, 0.013778467662632465, 0.012063298374414444, 0.0643385499715805, 0.017259731888771057, 0.04970027878880501, -0.05594215169548988, -0.041771113872528076, -0.0018090847879648209, -0.026072271168231964, 0.014879758469760418, -0.0022478727623820305, -0.01754642277956009, 0.026405267417430878, -0.012793537229299545, 0.003573526395484805, 0.0008465747814625502, -0.07210268825292587, 0.016662605106830597, 0.025335421785712242, -0.0040523032657802105, -0.005153374746441841, -0.0005808862042613328, 0.04787105321884155, 0.01632324978709221, -0.03172428905963898, 0.007683431729674339, -0.04789526015520096, -0.0074242339469492435, 0.04736897349357605, 0.06345442682504654, -0.04182843863964081, -0.0021554462146013975, 0.03469645977020264, 0.04806779697537422, 0.019773272797465324, -0.007416693493723869, -0.012504303827881813, -0.05715930461883545, 0.008874206803739071, -0.0007129585719667375, 0.015917478129267693, 0.025196779519319534, 0.03854428604245186, 0.010672695003449917, 0.027035165578126907, 0.03037308156490326, -0.011923410929739475, 0.05189391225576401, -0.010263169184327126, -0.008586861193180084, -0.004496991168707609, 0.012206679210066795, 0.015576200559735298, -0.03734126687049866, -0.018229907378554344, 0.0340149812400341, -0.004671914502978325, -0.00047780227032490075, -0.02391321212053299, 0.0004939085338264704, 0.051304444670677185, -0.00016031140694394708, -0.02030622772872448, 0.010127336718142033, 0.012534781359136105, -0.024131717160344124, -0.024661028757691383, -0.02352302335202694, -0.005934765562415123, -0.004677799995988607, -0.010443897917866707, 0.026281317695975304, 0.022036870941519737, -0.028615128248929977, -0.013065729290246964, 0.0028870687820017338, 0.007811272516846657, 0.005105738528072834, 0.04387535899877548, 0.027364520356059074, -0.03384954854846001, -0.041050732135772705, -0.05922337621450424, 0.0006490322994068265, 0.05492830276489258, -0.0348416306078434, 0.0015788788441568613, 0.009046416729688644, 0.01254761591553688, -0.04761946573853493, 0.012956308200955391, -0.04840856418013573, 0.02282581478357315, -0.053884945809841156, -0.004683817736804485, 0.020662318915128708, 0.03350849077105522, -0.039573315531015396, 0.039697736501693726, -0.033217672258615494, -0.03932025283575058, -0.032093096524477005, -0.01756174862384796, 0.01832810789346695, -0.005816172808408737, 0.015692856162786484, 0.006897978484630585, 0.00010861146438401192, 0.0019541981164366007, -0.08089760690927505, -0.038882654160261154, 0.01904345490038395, 0.013451422564685345, 0.011311783455312252, 0.007776202633976936, 0.0000423088604293298, 0.0638914629817009, 0.04861893877387047, -0.012455902062356472, -0.025246301665902138, 0.03653363510966301, 0.022040268406271935, -0.047887641936540604, 0.0031090041156858206, 0.0316748321056366, 0.004803945776075125, 0.03477877750992775, -0.011145713739097118, -0.019868765026330948, 0.04215448722243309, -0.012838639318943024, -0.008822866715490818, 0.03400935232639313, -0.020517846569418907, 0.015217137522995472, 0.05202925205230713, -0.005194697063416243, 0.014844060875475407, -0.040206145495176315, 0.05152473598718643, -0.025515561923384666, -0.005249578505754471, -0.016532812267541885, 0.036322303116321564, -0.04001431167125702, -0.004833681508898735, -0.03518417105078697, 0.03648495674133301, 0.011051885783672333, -0.05439059063792229, -0.0054277158342301846, 0.024067461490631104, 0.032546576112508774, 0.005823350045830011, 0.01379847526550293, 0.04471535608172417, 0.016759537160396576, 0.0009862110018730164, 0.005882618948817253, -0.022266294807195663, -0.01831454038619995, 0.037592142820358276, -0.04476253688335419, -0.04670899361371994, 0.003410955658182502, 0.05561074987053871, 0.01840152218937874, -0.022547682747244835, 0.012385872192680836, -0.002289742464199662, -0.027779078111052513, 0.022443663328886032, -0.01966995559632778, 0.06357670575380325, 0.016717873513698578, 0.04413379728794098, 0.015120857395231724, -0.013656510971486568, -0.0022712862119078636, 0.021038539707660675, -0.06830643862485886, 0.025885168462991714, 0.003950841724872589, -0.011588534340262413, 0.006748191546648741, -0.004871583078056574, 0.05589691549539566, -0.027363920584321022, 0.040409039705991745, 0.00922506581991911, 0.01790658012032509, -0.018252059817314148, -0.024998672306537628, -0.029935264959931374, -0.014609633944928646, -0.01199160423129797, 0.06392619758844376, 0.0021275172475725412, -0.025452995672822, -0.007067115977406502, 0.025990089401602745, 0.00969425868242979, -0.006731035187840462, -0.0322621688246727, 0.0006028530187904835, 0.010526072233915329, 0.041189856827259064, -0.0014694458805024624, 0.029043618589639664, -0.032846033573150635, 0.010493442416191101, -0.01930074766278267, 0.03666487708687782, 0.03672162815928459, -0.035329669713974, 0.028459582477808, 0.017847195267677307, -0.026941776275634766, 0.011133307591080666, 0.046761222183704376, 0.018506398424506187, -0.00825522467494011, 0.06106719374656677, -0.016817742958664894, 0.005478553008288145, 0.013874895870685577, 0.04306334629654884, 0.0012646873947232962, 0.036633189767599106, -0.039798952639102936, -0.03013193979859352, -0.02876953035593033, 0.03778282552957535, -0.00021225932869128883, 0.0015434519154950976, -0.024934640154242516, -0.029901189729571342, 0.03216275945305824, 0.024224530905485153, 0.012549379840493202, -0.026992741972208023, 0.046932730823755264, 0.04455554112792015, 0.022267363965511322, -0.029919655993580818, 0.02986183762550354, 0.05114620551466942, 0.03055846318602562, 0.011281975544989109, -0.02160114422440529, -0.06340185552835464, 0.01399206928908825, 0.02997049316763878, 0.008019027300179005, -0.027055732905864716, 0.00478948513045907, -0.03603297099471092, -0.0035090306773781776, 0.011436888948082924, 0.004999440163373947, 0.030877184122800827, -0.009449864737689495, -0.02034115232527256, -0.0030180506873875856, -0.054429907351732254, -0.07193700224161148, -0.0040415567345917225, -0.014684895984828472, -0.005600365810096264, -0.0697336420416832, -0.018632490187883377, -0.07049757242202759, -0.01592215895652771, 0.019773509353399277, 0.057016756385564804, -0.017593368887901306, -0.0029134696815162897, -0.016989391297101974, 0.03757316246628761, -0.011324885301291943, -0.0570983812212944, 0.05276716500520706, -0.015384192578494549, -0.010559099726378918, 0.017713582143187523, -0.02174503728747368, -0.046879421919584274, 0.04992847517132759, -0.014468560926616192, -0.04268239438533783, 0.04100336506962776, -0.03459593653678894, 0.027833255007863045, 0.022419702261686325, 0.03231194242835045, 0.01900525949895382, 0.018270963802933693, -0.00489595765247941, 0.029399890452623367, -0.03988412022590637, -0.03405500575900078, -0.04591289162635803, -0.058332107961177826, -0.02120763249695301, -0.030216611921787262, 0.004142482299357653, 0.034699104726314545, 0.006602287292480469, 0.06784490495920181, -0.009604785591363907, -0.021055009216070175, 0.044214487075805664, 0.026308005675673485, -0.01722029782831669, 0.015408540144562721, -0.01446501538157463, 0.03740561753511429, 0.005239260382950306, -0.02135995402932167, 0.024970849975943565, 0.021848570555448532, -0.00037980201886966825, 0.015800904482603073, -0.011236211284995079, 0.02918214164674282, -0.045224130153656006, -0.04580586031079292, -0.018070440739393234, -0.014817067421972752, 0.028318051248788834, -0.013593186624348164, 0.041356220841407776, 0.041726551949977875, -0.03421570360660553, -0.02192908711731434, 0.028058558702468872, -0.008344440720975399, 0.0233986247330904, -0.007442695554345846, -0.01400366798043251, 0.010860098525881767, 0.009835876524448395, -0.07879901677370071, 0.004619958344846964, -0.0030616146977990866, -0.030635986477136612, -0.009868146851658821, -0.015296436846256256, 0.03940051794052124, -0.03233819827437401, -0.030085433274507523, -0.021068645641207695, 0.044247280806303024, 0.022588245570659637, -0.03302506357431412, -0.0010182842379435897, 0.017434831708669662, 0.025941237807273865, -0.023165302351117134, -0.016201160848140717, 0.03654639050364494, -0.036869633942842484, -0.020098192617297173, -0.004130204673856497, 0.025120573118329048, -0.00005825434345752001, 0.01434321515262127, -0.02124090865254402, -0.0379861518740654, 0.0035099987871944904, -0.026639455929398537, -0.029304008930921555, 0.0310368575155735, 0.012468325905501842, -0.0063528153114020824, -0.029705235734581947, -0.05518336594104767, -0.021920068189501762, 0.015205941163003445, -0.03661760687828064, -0.021074799820780754, 0.012431257404386997, -0.023095468059182167, 0.020268844440579414, -0.014859967865049839, -0.009926739148795605, 0.027020422741770744, 0.05768462270498276, 0.0026808055117726326, -0.007278205826878548, -0.018515869975090027, 0.022683484479784966, 0.00812569446861744, 0.008648928254842758, 0.010289947502315044, 0.001446181326173246, 0.022309884428977966, -0.037730805575847626, -0.011663055047392845, -0.033216025680303574, 0.027191156521439552, 0.05148780718445778, 0.06496308743953705, 0.015347420237958431, -0.024760708212852478, 0.010722816921770573, -0.0516023188829422, -0.0537947341799736, 0.020848382264375687, 0.02556290104985237, -0.016118908300995827, 0.043307118117809296, -0.007517318241298199, -0.017470398917794228, 0.06151432916522026, -0.011230560019612312, -0.0041497861966490746, 0.038333017379045486, -0.04756847023963928, 0.03790471330285072, 0.011214757338166237, -0.034782376140356064, -0.04023101553320885, 0.03963078558444977, -0.05251887068152428, 0.01196991465985775, -0.03694097325205803, -0.02475927025079727, -0.01399252936244011, 0.05995440110564232, -0.013693468645215034, -0.01585387997329235, -0.025795994326472282, -0.03818174824118614, -0.017180901020765305, 0.04157678037881851, -0.03255980834364891, 0.02605145052075386, 0.01323104277253151, -0.012614727020263672, -0.024775348603725433, 0.036996208131313324, -0.01699189282953739, -0.08689200133085251, -0.008451026864349842, -0.005678995046764612, -0.04243290796875954, -0.012169703841209412, -0.010438293218612671, -0.023336689919233322, 0.0037341308780014515, -0.012969945557415485, 0.025616347789764404, 0.014773433096706867, 0.01137816347181797, 0.0074545289389789104, 0.07481099665164948, 0.018147557973861694, 0.038446567952632904, -0.030310919508337975, 0.013780364766716957, 0.12464231997728348, 0.04245811700820923, 0.058591872453689575, -0.014468279667198658, -0.01791154406964779, -0.025452032685279846, 0.027858827263116837, -0.024049902334809303, -0.0041237762197852135, -0.010601029731333256, -0.013228886760771275, 0.011279024183750153, 0.06566125899553299, -0.018877286463975906, -0.016923382878303528, 0.032093536108732224, -0.04784536361694336, 0.01880655251443386, -0.015895601361989975, 0.009024213999509811, -0.015307913534343243, 0.003372136503458023, -0.03354388475418091, 0.04524749144911766, -0.005132075399160385, -0.015657559037208557, -0.014718255959451199, -0.007694339845329523, -0.03541477769613266, -0.018366552889347076, -0.046897489577531815, -0.021440092474222183, 0.02783121168613434, -0.03279576078057289, -0.0008060077670961618, 0.018987243995070457, 0.005830701440572739, -0.06786452233791351, 0.02072139084339142, 0.011540304869413376, 0.011153877712786198, 0.0305748600512743, 0.03224153444170952, -0.023619022220373154, -0.04954121261835098, -0.014270881190896034, -0.033720601350069046, 0.051927097141742706, -0.02501003071665764, -0.02545749954879284, 0.016560949385166168, -0.006186686456203461, -0.021854514256119728, -0.020022302865982056, -0.0035120199900120497, 0.00899074412882328, 0.02134963497519493, -0.018241653218865395, -0.006339478772133589, -0.03180300071835518, 0.0443308986723423, 0.022970551624894142, 0.05789188668131828, 0.010894578881561756, -0.03852934017777443, -0.055517811328172684, 0.025163909420371056, 0.03275866433978081, 0.03442634642124176, 0.005751398392021656, 0.02467985264956951, -0.03638320788741112, -0.00880143977701664, -0.06894893944263458, 0.02545645460486412, -0.049342080950737, 0.06716781854629517, 0.02454526536166668, -0.013277499005198479, -0.01581891067326069, -0.04749632626771927, -0.025046978145837784, -0.02705378830432892, 0.01703874208033085, -0.0035987398587167263, -0.033790335059165955, 0.02859403006732464, -0.0077426852658391, 0.004780244082212448, -0.035036634653806686, 0.028397105634212494, 0.054599206894636154, 0.04916173592209816, -0.03218812867999077, -0.05958201736211777, 0.00046977473539300263, 0.015612447634339333, 0.020655743777751923, 0.010038002394139767, 0.013686069287359715, 0.0383324958384037, 0.03170960023999214, -0.006725677289068699, 0.008715733885765076, -0.05695474147796631, 0.03512359783053398, -0.005123532842844725, -0.029603978618979454, -0.024327760562300682, 0.04216577112674713, 0.01777992583811283, -0.04080396145582199, 0.006253425031900406, -0.017009669914841652, 0.01387406513094902, -0.00994312297552824, -0.0578085258603096, -0.030460398644208908, 0.013246340677142143, 0.0003042596799787134, 0.010069405660033226, -0.014478394761681557, -0.008752912282943726, -0.015801457688212395, -0.04349897429347038, -0.02308526076376438, -0.0015218064654618502, -0.011781049892306328, 0.018962759524583817, -0.034895334392786026, -0.011719034984707832, 0.049963079392910004, 0.006853295490145683, -0.0222915168851614, -0.005715843755751848, 0.008307096548378468, -0.013742371462285519, 0.024858180433511734, 0.008579443208873272, 0.00575648108497262, 0.024821056053042412, -0.02658303827047348, -0.02135530672967434, 0.03268365561962128, 0.003803607076406479, 0.018030604347586632, 0.030053142458200455, -0.010070204734802246, -0.04195115715265274, 0.01757354661822319, -0.02268115244805813, 0.005643918178975582, -0.046493932604789734, 0.011686830781400204, 0.04163757711648941, -0.00790097564458847, 0.01992613449692726, -0.04641908407211304, -0.0008212438551709056, 0.011192196048796177, 0.029976736754179, -0.001223337952978909, -0.0327383391559124, 0.03425236791372299, -0.010275979526340961, 0.0012644389644265175, 0.009542766958475113, 0.0032746708020567894, 0.03814332187175751, -0.0015014492673799396, -0.03494470939040184, 0.03719843551516533, -0.02192790061235428, -0.006276983767747879, -0.08426453918218613, -0.026463855057954788, 0.0363306999206543, 0.038336075842380524, 0.05201805382966995, -0.03989230468869209, -0.009012098424136639, 0.02695327252149582, -0.025207549333572388, 0.018886998295783997, 0.008674305863678455, 0.0014572920044884086, -0.020197933539748192, 0.027304992079734802, -0.017582429572939873, 0.0004731197841465473, -0.006205401849001646, 0.046399228274822235, 0.01667919009923935, 0.05662866309285164, 0.0009126013610512018, -0.006448129191994667, -0.0368482880294323, 0.02258293144404888, 0.03051300346851349, -0.048864465206861496, 0.03774406388401985, -0.03344663232564926, 0.056543342769145966, 0.02098271995782852, 0.022502370178699493, 0.0020634671673178673, -0.001077663036994636, 0.024427443742752075, 0.015432018786668777, 0.023365765810012817, 0.0056624943390488625, 0.01001365389674902, 0.05850520357489586, -0.004186003934592009, 0.05378180742263794, -0.00031414907425642014, -0.05512702092528343, -0.009500885382294655, -0.018544914200901985, -0.014800812117755413, -0.05125642567873001, -0.0261712484061718, 0.037844784557819366, -0.03268900886178017, 0.0263883825391531, -0.003383201314136386, -0.005910094827413559, -0.01728188991546631, 0.04788534715771675, -0.0293258186429739, -0.023348623886704445, 0.011815850622951984, 0.03443069010972977, -0.008370461873710155, 0.03926236927509308, 0.00376528431661427, -0.035433974117040634, 0.03948112204670906, 0.012586218304932117, -0.025360889732837677, -0.04547816514968872, 0.0026735609862953424, -0.007655632216483355, 0.007993344217538834, 0.015041490085422993, -0.005650780163705349, -0.052078794687986374, 0.03614998981356621, 2.0149042256889516e-7, -0.017395513132214546, 0.006282619200646877, -0.00038832766585983336, 0.017767462879419327, -0.07667392492294312, 0.05259867385029793, 0.03164229542016983, -0.02063971385359764, 0.004409505520015955, -0.011119499802589417, -0.014965767040848732, -0.02243744395673275, 0.07290761917829514, -0.016025856137275696, 0.01920001022517681, -0.014314328320324421, 0.04717790707945824, 0.02849213033914566, -0.04932922497391701, 0.03227393701672554, -0.004258237313479185, -0.00836685486137867, -0.013103913515806198, 0.004237034358084202, 0.032662127166986465, 0.0032367072999477386, 0.0020460118539631367, -0.03419287130236626, 0.012269687838852406, 0.02363021858036518, -0.031833257526159286, -0.004503120202571154, 0.012624658644199371, 0.0031067361123859882, 0.07110205292701721, -0.017517704516649246, 0.009212877601385117, 0.03187486529350281, -0.011178795248270035, -0.08218711614608765, 0.008498317562043667, -0.03302453085780144, -0.02769503928720951, 0.007211703807115555, 0.038456711918115616, -0.007298985030502081, -0.02128981240093708, -0.012555936351418495, 0.04224630072712898, -0.011263790540397167, -0.030679604038596153, 0.02950963005423546, 0.007649367209523916, 0.04782462120056152, 0.035738009959459305, 0.019973400980234146, -0.015928840264678, 0.0018111790996044874, 0.028219403699040413, 0.004107888787984848, 0.00554179260507226, -0.016629641875624657, 0.008410172536969185, 0.035708047449588776, -0.034902408719062805, 0.028613653033971786, -0.014347332529723644, 0.048084892332553864, -0.04761156439781189, -0.00683582853525877, 0.0517013855278492, -0.026990769430994987, 0.011156680062413216, -0.0013682633871212602, -0.018833426758646965, 0.044500838965177536, -0.026305673643946648, 0.01675870642066002, -0.025791296735405922, -0.01270264107733965, -0.01689806580543518, 0.037546440958976746, -0.005030847620218992, 0.016230182722210884, 0.0073101334273815155, 0.015126148238778114, 0.014101741835474968, 0.006735434290021658, 0.010098442435264587, -0.006742802448570728, 0.0435609295964241, 0.016850585117936134, 0.0016534526366740465, -0.009720101952552795, -0.02182961255311966, 0.003782049287110567, -0.03409585356712341, 0.0034894549753516912, 0.03283272683620453, 0.02714243158698082, -0.00421347888186574, -0.033016882836818695, 0.013827701099216938, 0.07864512503147125, -0.08701565861701965, -0.004809570033103228, -0.024051642045378685, -0.01814717799425125, -0.024511054158210754, -0.05516905337572098 ]
<p>I'm not used to using variables in the date format in R. I'm just wondering if it is possible to add a date variable as an explanatory variable in a linear regression model. If it's possible, how can we interpret the coefficient? Is it the effect of one day on the outcome variable? </p> <p>See my <a href="https://gist.github.com/blaquans/5966314" rel="nofollow">gist</a> with an example what I'm trying to do. </p>
73,817
[ 0.0014753103023394942, -0.023077787831425667, -0.029429392889142036, 0.042843177914619446, 0.019810350611805916, 0.03214661031961441, -0.0237724706530571, -0.0029228483326733112, 0.03899639472365379, -0.048888105899095535, 0.01708897575736046, 0.048931997269392014, 0.04850573092699051, -0.021712597459554672, 0.02528037130832672, 0.038869645446538925, -0.0050840722396969795, 0.015182354487478733, -0.012958088889718056, 0.025378072634339333, 0.014287997968494892, 0.008423170074820518, 0.0038971328176558018, -0.0020272661931812763, -0.0024127860087901354, 0.04343250021338463, 0.027694467455148697, 0.00260757002979517, 0.010522288270294666, 0.04911831393837929, 0.012548570521175861, -0.03566310182213783, 0.04458988830447197, 0.026136120781302452, 0.02372703328728676, -0.04033883661031723, -0.0008250703103840351, -0.035368192940950394, 0.014396452344954014, 0.017885178327560425, 0.0047697946429252625, -0.024994229897856712, 0.010944354347884655, 0.05831850692629814, -0.000327944231685251, 0.030463770031929016, -0.020057016983628273, -0.011140675283968449, 0.037689149379730225, -0.025443749502301216, 0.05567197874188423, -0.01692262478172779, 0.02852221578359604, 0.03391371667385101, -0.022930514067411423, 0.019200686365365982, 0.04032265022397041, 0.06467074900865555, 0.010357670485973358, -0.027818836271762848, -0.00958928931504488, -0.03385266661643982, 0.017870724201202393, -0.00845576822757721, -0.04073016345500946, 0.008953364565968513, 0.009831453673541546, 0.003206399967893958, 0.017347566783428192, -0.05363078787922859, -0.0009983937488868833, 0.016178125515580177, 0.02135685831308365, 0.003988232463598251, -0.008120541460812092, -0.04387647286057472, 0.013791424222290516, -0.004186889622360468, 0.05209194868803024, 0.0233183391392231, 0.00458367308601737, 0.008221723139286041, 0.013704906217753887, 0.008874069899320602, 0.029951168224215508, 0.01731208898127079, 0.08142435550689697, -0.02216368354856968, 0.03716930001974106, 0.031167898327112198, -0.03371630609035492, 0.03224201127886772, 0.05418389290571213, 0.021621664986014366, -0.0357821099460125, 0.008578295819461346, 0.0022590993903577328, 0.04054947942495346, 0.03391079977154732, -0.002663673833012581, -0.014560310170054436, -0.035552311688661575, 0.03235448896884918, 0.032890088856220245, -0.031301066279411316, -0.009302757680416107, 0.00608157180249691, 0.0035210123751312494, -0.009715182706713676, -0.042363882064819336, -0.02568153664469719, 0.02211444452404976, -0.011043179780244827, -0.04520291090011597, 0.024125898256897926, -0.05693311616778374, -0.022512944415211678, -0.011818209663033485, 0.04745996370911598, 0.05582822859287262, 0.01619895175099373, -0.06298182904720306, 0.041505854576826096, 0.000027828880774904974, -0.038628898561000824, 0.009113148786127567, -0.0035790835972875357, -0.008349865674972534, -0.0003652231825981289, 0.06274943798780441, -0.001477880054153502, -0.02720682881772518, 0.03053794428706169, -0.005445751827210188, 0.04494421184062958, 0.016426363959908485, -0.07728389650583267, -0.061813369393348694, 0.02581021375954151, -0.026341727003455162, 0.024683376774191856, -0.032809216529130936, 0.01160761434584856, -0.02485882304608822, 0.06675345450639725, 0.032897964119911194, 0.03362898901104927, 0.047919824719429016, 0.011888210661709309, 0.005059588234871626, -0.02261648140847683, -0.00010793433466460556, -0.007042695768177509, -0.04882911592721939, -0.04466912895441055, -0.07935810834169388, -0.0005145512404851615, 0.03195366635918617, 0.0028990248683840036, -0.01115481462329626, 0.059515297412872314, 0.00022353754320647568, -0.0170933548361063, 0.049315210431814194, -0.008707588538527489, -0.03779328614473343, 0.0711069405078888, 0.00477385800331831, 0.002259996021166444, 0.04039084538817406, -0.017839916050434113, 0.024997977539896965, 0.013881784863770008, 0.0695003792643547, 0.002517921617254615, 0.0030098031274974346, -0.02498561702668667, 0.006022624671459198, 0.02096434496343136, 0.017085425555706024, -0.04410651698708534, -0.03099747933447361, -0.030022963881492615, -0.0375998392701149, 0.008270078338682652, 0.06943145394325256, -0.020136786624789238, -0.019908148795366287, 0.028405794873833656, -0.06345010548830032, -0.040697962045669556, -0.061158083379268646, 0.04165215045213699, 0.003567137522622943, -0.018206531181931496, -0.03510230779647827, 0.007291422225534916, 0.05458177626132965, -0.011788041330873966, -0.015744825825095177, -0.011596668511629105, 0.011895650066435337, 0.028875939548015594, -0.0390409417450428, -0.03691224381327629, 0.029862428084015846, 0.08283136039972305, -0.0011622017482295632, -0.003288532607257366, -0.06407356262207031, -0.039310064166784286, 0.021955469623208046, -0.06967970728874207, 0.008675492368638515, -0.054408665746450424, 0.00917078834027052, 0.00999500509351492, 0.006734217517077923, -0.033860139548778534, 0.03768778219819069, -0.023577364161610603, 0.060687508434057236, 0.0639706552028656, -0.012175464071333408, 0.006274204235523939, -0.009657510556280613, 0.0649663582444191, 0.025182759389281273, -0.03526197001338005, -0.010353462770581245, -0.03586072847247124, -0.03714194893836975, 0.03222556412220001, 0.020004406571388245, -0.029251711443066597, 0.018385110422968864, 0.04258853569626808, 0.02839737758040428, 0.012691458687186241, 0.047324299812316895, 0.009167845360934734, 0.003112891921773553, -0.014312462881207466, -0.0424036905169487, 0.016210978850722313, -0.004582051187753677, 0.04966779053211212, -0.01412256620824337, 0.06369410455226898, 0.004337206482887268, 0.021165749058127403, 0.022150618955492973, -0.01688358560204506, -0.0022432496771216393, -0.024978160858154297, -0.0006431412184610963, 0.06064693629741669, -0.031588371843099594, 0.010298985987901688, 0.03401900827884674, 0.002852319972589612, -0.028412530198693275, 0.014591079205274582, -0.029256301000714302, 0.0006278551882132888, 0.05151738226413727, -0.046934567391872406, 0.013675962574779987, 0.015399768017232418, -0.024860896170139313, 0.03643345087766647, -0.023742541670799255, -0.014551565051078796, -0.007811116985976696, 0.02593778260052204, 0.015729870647192, 0.03353699669241905, 0.018748879432678223, -0.028456561267375946, -0.012450678274035454, 0.01731001026928425, -0.016398822888731956, -0.019481845200061798, 0.0013268464244902134, -0.030117396265268326, -0.0017391147557646036, -0.009901082143187523, -0.0314614474773407, 0.01667621172964573, -0.007303456775844097, -0.013631967827677727, 0.03732673451304436, -0.013114117085933685, -0.057825133204460144, -0.03089965507388115, -0.039168402552604675, 0.008588485419750214, -0.02270699106156826, -0.044327639043331146, -0.009738934226334095, 0.0012913463870063424, -0.003943413030356169, -0.028718391433358192, -0.06361614167690277, 0.04364856332540512, -0.011550470255315304, -0.027061667293310165, 0.01245152484625578, -0.0014944751746952534, 0.004333857912570238, 0.03362575173377991, -0.021586960181593895, -0.013142487965524197, -0.05674489587545395, -0.04883413016796112, 0.045959413051605225, 0.009778531268239021, 0.016625870019197464, -0.01418782863765955, -0.013594463467597961, 0.06619955599308014, 0.03645012155175209, -0.004235806409269571, -0.05295659601688385, -0.0206976979970932, -0.004432088229805231, -0.03552236035466194, 0.038615643978118896, -0.005388394929468632, 0.027532067149877548, 0.02932560257613659, -0.0012895048130303621, -0.010906022042036057, 0.056772008538246155, 0.034055765718221664, 0.01877722516655922, -0.010391718707978725, -0.033435314893722534, 0.0013160642702132463, 0.01946386881172657, 0.02863847091794014, -0.0219162255525589, 0.029641954228281975, -0.02156899869441986, 0.04146800935268402, -0.020630881190299988, -0.07207683473825455, 0.018892068415880203, 0.0030087565537542105, 0.013396412134170532, -0.03297986462712288, 0.03489154577255249, -0.001380119938403368, -0.009875577874481678, -0.009078599512577057, 0.015924492850899696, 0.038757260888814926, -0.032212235033512115, 0.01900859922170639, 0.04677053168416023, 0.007602054625749588, -0.03192606195807457, -0.001913736225105822, 0.02120891585946083, -0.008861334063112736, 0.03448011726140976, -0.03573562204837799, 0.03114922344684601, 0.04408060759305954, 0.014878234826028347, 0.00633962033316493, 0.012644004076719284, -0.045460425317287445, 0.030340859666466713, -0.05350791662931442, -0.014146769419312477, -0.002420176053419709, 0.02695685811340809, 0.027549954131245613, 0.02333015762269497, 0.004637774545699358, -0.020862257108092308, 0.058522649109363556, -0.031020743772387505, -0.06386593729257584, 0.030824711546301842, -0.009804140776395798, -0.026422403752803802, 0.008795853704214096, -0.018579905852675438, 0.027218593284487724, -0.026215745136141777, 0.003093709936365485, 0.012962451204657555, -0.007272816263139248, -0.032608482986688614, -0.007415211293846369, 0.006024823058396578, -0.021776936948299408, -0.015943974256515503, -0.013943541795015335, 0.043650902807712555, 0.002977237105369568, -0.02106781117618084, 0.0535786896944046, 0.021954696625471115, -0.03607724979519844, -0.029044564813375473, -0.021397322416305542, 0.014821749180555344, 0.053161706775426865, 0.03133401274681091, 0.008594464510679245, -0.022937064990401268, 0.04145674780011177, -0.0014962708810344338, 0.00962081365287304, 0.025101715698838234, 0.01529630459845066, -0.028025953099131584, -0.05570116266608238, 0.009253880009055138, 0.008562056347727776, -0.01616554893553257, 0.0017426533158868551, 0.036877598613500595, 0.06677860766649246, 0.012426484376192093, -0.03553285449743271, 0.006543905008584261, 0.05327577888965607, 0.022393591701984406, -0.010129435919225216, -0.03600133955478668, 0.010077932849526405, -0.0029169803019613028, -0.013545779511332512, 0.012501450255513191, 0.0030289122369140387, 0.008801850490272045, 0.013261345215141773, 0.009243298321962357, -0.02355365641415119, 0.01529331412166357, -0.03971131518483162, 0.028617290779948235, 0.066770039498806, 0.02820993959903717, -0.02869011089205742, 0.012478571385145187, 0.07059551775455475, 0.025922337546944618, -0.0011686113430187106, -0.0006668117712251842, -0.09036733955144882, 0.0063252984546124935, 0.022540321573615074, 0.060915619134902954, -0.0602150522172451, -0.029222039505839348, -0.019050966948270798, 0.016285864636301994, 0.04153425619006157, -0.011036236770451069, 0.01077207364141941, -0.018595879897475243, 0.00502292113378644, -0.028397707268595695, -0.03085688315331936, -0.08150213211774826, 0.02400275133550167, -0.04957805946469307, 0.019213715568184853, -0.010470051318407059, -0.05157705768942833, -0.03890835866332054, 0.004754353780299425, 0.016567865386605263, 0.03140868619084358, -0.01011583674699068, -0.01927771046757698, 0.0009994186693802476, 0.009790252894163132, -0.010351607576012611, -0.04985404387116432, 0.009107204154133797, 0.01783590018749237, -0.014040515758097172, 0.04320485517382622, -0.005847001913934946, 0.01516931876540184, 0.02267828956246376, 0.05213535577058792, -0.0239881444722414, -0.02610132284462452, -0.04827573150396347, -0.002445157850161195, 0.012397799640893936, -0.04671794921159744, 0.05756807327270508, 0.04887506365776062, 0.03157656267285347, 0.021859683096408844, -0.032095544040203094, 0.02311580628156662, -0.009977368637919426, -0.048347845673561096, -0.017225665971636772, -0.019011346623301506, 0.026388341560959816, -0.0047298320569098, 0.008079406805336475, -0.0020686103962361813, -0.023174339905381203, -0.007851249538362026, -0.0007887562387622893, 0.051997654139995575, -0.015038996003568172, -0.024421297013759613, -0.026948168873786926, -0.004999340977519751, -0.035713888704776764, -0.030241651460528374, -0.0186977069824934, -0.011938182637095451, 0.005379817448556423, 0.00045094091910868883, -0.009920762851834297, 0.020210767164826393, 0.0375652052462101, -0.033989571034908295, 0.03583960980176926, -0.016623247414827347, 0.008394075557589531, -0.043793097138404846, 0.012114753015339375, -0.036666590720415115, -0.06539865583181381, 0.027239849790930748, 0.04181768372654915, 0.003171495860442519, -0.0009842668659985065, -0.029906831681728363, 0.02582082338631153, -0.008140326477587223, -0.009070584550499916, -0.05702603608369827, -0.07298159599304199, -0.015381943434476852, -0.03548869118094444, -0.017843086272478104, -0.02361554652452469, -0.017451168969273567, -0.051573481410741806, -0.01835278980433941, -0.0066750310361385345, 0.05590357631444931, -0.020864397287368774, -0.02473960630595684, -0.01840383931994438, -0.013216231018304825, 0.06395315378904343, 0.014295951463282108, -0.030737243592739105, 0.010054148733615875, -0.025807620957493782, -0.019508324563503265, -0.017594262957572937, 0.020027335733175278, -0.02456064149737358, 0.01209835521876812, -0.021719766780734062, -0.025582391768693924, 0.032092198729515076, -0.001275935210287571, -0.0684938132762909, 0.007589502260088921, -0.01403944194316864, 0.023047445341944695, -0.059418391436338425, 0.007807885762304068, -0.012636629864573479, 0.011546050198376179, -0.007159966044127941, 0.007130438927561045, -0.019241362810134888, -0.0154946967959404, 0.03530813381075859, -0.01475308183580637, 0.006179486401379108, 0.02371285855770111, 0.0880657508969307, 0.00038915264303795993, 0.024907371029257774, -0.010021950118243694, 0.0025625720154494047, 0.02197449840605259, 0.03605368733406067, 0.009459238499403, 0.004719567950814962, 0.013047760352492332, -0.037879254668951035, -0.02527610771358013, -0.04148455336689949, -0.014978453516960144, 0.05823371186852455, -0.03462907299399376, 0.040121521800756454, 0.057706307619810104, -0.00804727990180254, -0.0007040585041977465, -0.041672322899103165, 0.006092539988458157, 0.014770465902984142, -0.008446643128991127, 0.06517360359430313, 0.010157804936170578, -0.013248606584966183, 0.01827976107597351, 0.016651665791869164, 0.022433223202824593, 0.06487086415290833, 0.010725516825914383, 0.023093968629837036, 0.019180171191692352, -0.00024984616902656853, -0.0655582994222641, 0.01699172891676426, -0.010152638889849186, 0.008271128870546818, -0.01766171306371689, -0.045147716999053955, 0.026404092088341713, 0.03277849778532982, 0.003079243004322052, -0.051140110939741135, -0.036660753190517426, -0.044902779161930084, -0.003244006307795644, 0.05058140680193901, -0.01619577966630459, 0.06051936373114586, -0.007253451272845268, 0.07184133678674698, -0.005930854473263025, 0.03658410534262657, -0.03446242958307266, -0.0742618590593338, -0.012929955497384071, -0.03338601067662239, -0.004246722906827927, 0.034666016697883606, -0.0007147059659473598, -0.007338196504861116, 0.023008164018392563, -0.04225809872150421, -0.02347804792225361, 0.003687012242153287, 0.055525120347738266, 0.0012447951594367623, 0.09834565967321396, -0.026279252022504807, -0.06085842102766037, -0.015967074781656265, 0.011407908983528614, 0.1357899159193039, 0.0969444066286087, 0.03403759375214577, -0.05707813799381256, 0.03612585365772247, 0.01831524819135666, 0.003221020568162203, -0.01567939668893814, -0.013860568404197693, -0.009123450145125389, -0.0205696951597929, 0.06803685426712036, 0.04938608780503273, -0.0001153234115918167, -0.01267946232110262, 0.042226072400808334, -0.03448338806629181, -0.014831519685685635, 0.00018243737576995045, -0.025120845064520836, 0.015543599613010883, -0.0327557735145092, -0.05068032070994377, 0.0037360552232712507, -0.004049235954880714, -0.03781742602586746, -0.006762421224266291, -0.014549201354384422, 0.000348746805684641, -0.0021902834996581078, -0.018300127238035202, -0.0076866294257342815, 0.030170433223247528, 0.04649415612220764, -0.011202470399439335, -0.007727283518761396, 0.02597680501639843, -0.01572452113032341, 0.005562841426581144, 0.023497816175222397, -0.01224422361701727, -0.013750551268458366, 0.014899385161697865, 0.019837623462080956, -0.054589200764894485, 0.0005658336449414492, -0.015370517037808895, 0.02494458109140396, -0.00920761190354824, -0.029523463919758797, -0.035495687276124954, 0.007141624111682177, 0.0178958959877491, -0.028242813423275948, -0.025929199531674385, 0.044614825397729874, 0.049626823514699936, 0.0030452341306954622, -0.018759706988930702, -0.02113276720046997, -0.02425347827374935, -0.013769494369626045, 0.06411229074001312, 0.039858780801296234, -0.023350153118371964, 0.045283976942300797, -0.01430473942309618, 0.028675999492406845, -0.012499009259045124, -0.010391537100076675, 0.016019390895962715, -0.021627074107527733, -0.0507957898080349, -0.01849937252700329, 0.04163925722241402, -0.011067558079957962, -0.011859585531055927, -0.01122627779841423, 0.011979475617408752, -0.04971938207745552, -0.03367549553513527, 0.004005696624517441, -0.0010454258881509304, 0.011069096624851227, -0.06495541334152222, 0.0439157597720623, 0.07260321080684662, 0.026451746001839638, 0.023946497589349747, -0.02516753226518631, -0.024917518720030785, 0.03103392943739891, 0.006787250749766827, -0.016579322516918182, -0.02172672003507614, 0.006807724945247173, -0.0051845982670784, -0.008411172777414322, -0.02145998924970627, 0.0330219604074955, 0.029025712981820107, -0.015842486172914505, -0.016577286645770073, 0.015554428100585938, -0.02639320120215416, 0.01869526505470276, 0.039845772087574005, -0.059810154139995575, 0.000103023812698666, -0.0221693217754364, 0.017464647069573402, 0.002887146547436714, -0.03250288963317871, -0.012367608025670052, -0.044657886028289795, 0.012981356121599674, -0.040101900696754456, -0.054265785962343216, 0.03808436542749405, -0.02699500508606434, 0.013154392130672932, -0.030662178993225098, 0.0027509413193911314, -0.06840059161186218, -0.007935695350170135, 0.015522804111242294, -0.06544914841651917, 0.025837643072009087, 0.02454286254942417, -0.023674868047237396, 0.003053162945434451, 0.05271228402853012, 0.051176443696022034, 0.024718185886740685, -0.008097287267446518, 0.0371408574283123, 0.00048828020226210356, 0.045421794056892395, -0.03665079176425934, -0.04019542783498764, 0.011812596581876278, -0.055113308131694794, -0.025385595858097076, 0.041305121034383774, 0.0052385530434548855, 0.035645391792058945, 0.0186003427952528, 0.006393063813447952, -0.005598003976047039, 0.05045950785279274, -0.02356625162065029, 0.012410636991262436, 0.00993004348129034, 0.018784696236252785, -0.00852940697222948, -0.011428055353462696, -0.019844554364681244, 0.033941850066185, -0.007975355722010136, 0.02377556823194027, 0.031934116035699844, 0.014523124322295189, -0.00524857547134161, 0.037584565579891205, -0.0065457941964268684, -0.00858735479414463, 0.02166864648461342, -0.04000670462846756, 0.03595295548439026, 0.021721206605434418, -0.0455130971968174, 0.04951528087258339, 0.0006843075389042497, 0.019182700663805008, -0.09112381935119629, -0.007020062301307917, 0.01728866621851921, 0.018435603007674217, 0.04900292679667473, -0.03706289455294609, 0.007694019470363855, -0.00461542559787631, -0.022842740640044212, -0.01043841801583767, 0.020648803561925888, -0.015626534819602966, -0.005581422708928585, -0.013676105067133904, 0.008179369382560253, 0.034904394298791885, 0.04651682451367378, 0.040266573429107666, 0.02432510443031788, 0.028501303866505623, 0.039660170674324036, -0.028769437223672867, 0.0037831019144505262, 0.015560128726065159, 0.03853031247854233, -0.09114865213632584, 0.04019125550985336, -0.03152097761631012, -0.02009698748588562, 0.001442658482119441, -0.018903106451034546, 0.030896373093128204, 0.05574929341673851, 0.012582016177475452, -0.0005670061218552291, 0.04482346400618553, 0.033322714269161224, -0.02545345015823841, -0.0478668212890625, 0.011015547439455986, 0.0035112700425088406, 0.02794465981423855, -0.005851084366440773, -0.018576372414827347, -0.0034014652483165264, -0.03102724999189377, -0.018580229952931404, 0.0025447611697018147, -0.0061018457636237144, -0.006740934681147337, -0.012372514232993126, 0.000779754773247987, -0.02439493127167225, -0.024298079311847687, 0.015525772236287594, -0.024365318939089775, -0.005750341806560755, 0.0598858967423439, 0.010166732594370842, -0.04215865209698677, -0.024274900555610657, 0.01526789739727974, -0.056683726608753204, 0.020214341580867767, 0.01159217581152916, -0.0031776626128703356, -0.03769668564200401, 0.020857036113739014, -0.017377257347106934, -0.03732968494296074, -0.03346582129597664, 0.03774907439947128, -0.04167211428284645, 0.04485432058572769, -0.0203703660517931, 0.0018171737901866436, 0.03837355971336365, -0.03313141688704491, 0.028598852455615997, -0.05682020261883736, 0.0712037906050682, 0.021515555679798126, -0.01012453343719244, -0.021011333912611008, -0.007149520795792341, -0.02179892733693123, 0.007577857002615929, 0.04829001799225807, -0.013115878216922283, -0.0157358106225729, 0.01079428568482399, 0.04425356164574623, -0.025642596185207367, 0.005340597126632929, 0.042871296405792236, 0.001961731119081378, -0.023230839520692825, -0.0014582565054297447, -0.010935436934232712, -0.005051788873970509, 0.028164222836494446, 0.0006088412483222783, -0.04856658726930618, 0.02251838706433773, 0.0022749551571905613, -0.01617521047592163, 0.04352962225675583, 0.004505597986280918, -0.03902660310268402, 0.052941638976335526, 0.0038774292916059494, 0.007708214223384857, 0.033972181379795074, -0.011619596742093563, -0.051355671137571335, 0.023309776559472084, -0.05726328492164612, 0.01976010948419571, 0.0053693088702857494, -0.019656110554933548, -0.04450414329767227, -0.05741399526596069, 0.014667728915810585, 0.0019269470358267426, -0.013813948258757591, 0.016665685921907425, 0.008727754466235638, 0.0045447270385921, 0.045389045029878616, 0.006207780912518501, 0.01928451843559742, -0.014870105311274529, -0.0033507184125483036, -0.00398989487439394, 0.01882871799170971, 0.026928048580884933, -0.005702726077288389, -0.016373928636312485, 0.02132314443588257, 0.03352566063404083, 0.016251327469944954, 0.007917353883385658, 0.01917690597474575, -0.014010438695549965, -0.01837683469057083, -0.024528777226805687, 0.031323738396167755, 0.047619063407182693, -0.018986959010362625, 0.0018502171151340008, -0.011728358455002308, -0.053269773721694946, -0.006041597109287977, -0.030556468293070793, -0.04199177026748657, -0.037487179040908813, 0.007882803678512573, 0.021809307858347893, 0.03480085730552673, -0.004324910696595907, -0.011810172349214554, 0.0305356252938509, -0.006829549558460712, 0.021140674129128456, -0.012969055213034153, -0.006864628754556179, -0.02474665641784668, -0.019149839878082275, -0.004386786837130785, -0.02127140760421753, -0.0032298672012984753, -0.03739848732948303, 0.033651359379291534, 0.03292405977845192, 0.017049619928002357, -0.04780682176351547, -0.012878650799393654, 0.020995909348130226, 0.0393211804330349, -0.08489241451025009, -0.026691894978284836, -0.009614910930395126, 0.03514387458562851, -0.03572468087077141, -0.02072661556303501 ]
<p>I want to run Levene's test to test the equality of variances between a full sample a number of sub-samples. I can't find anything about Levene's test that states whether this would violate the assumptions of the test. In other words, given the null hypothesis that $\mathrm{Var}(X_{1}) = \mathrm{Var}(X_{2})$, does Levene's test require that $X_{1} \cap X_{2} = \varnothing$?</p>
73,818
[ -0.040253326296806335, 0.010222235694527626, -0.009098254144191742, 0.010377301834523678, 0.02461462840437889, 0.02421479858458042, 0.022275393828749657, -0.006412481423467398, 0.024302562698721886, -0.022517209872603416, 0.05041423812508583, 0.05868684500455856, 0.03851436823606491, -0.0012544112978503108, 0.034728825092315674, 0.00791300367563963, -0.023322947323322296, 0.005744683090597391, -0.004253278020769358, -0.010464487597346306, -0.04215788468718529, 0.031517840921878815, 0.03442180156707764, -0.029026422649621964, -0.038389287889003754, 0.0167368333786726, 0.0069769201800227165, -0.015101302415132523, 0.014031564816832542, 0.07040882855653763, -0.034824978560209274, -0.006057772785425186, 0.013805403374135494, 0.03296046704053879, -0.002410098910331726, -0.027449050918221474, -0.003704334842041135, -0.036434561014175415, 0.009952961467206478, 0.06552466005086899, -0.054156769067049026, 0.025718219578266144, -0.025240182876586914, 0.035670116543769836, -0.022290043532848358, 0.020575521513819695, -0.02080371417105198, -0.020514020696282387, -0.006649660877883434, -0.024302717298269272, 0.10174589604139328, 0.02082817628979683, 0.03767971694469452, 0.04001617804169655, 0.0015247699338942766, 0.01863183081150055, 0.051966678351163864, 0.07564810663461685, -0.01128886267542839, -0.02844930998980999, -0.04408744350075722, -0.022187365218997, 0.001334191532805562, -0.019846366718411446, -0.05723737180233002, 0.020638277754187584, 0.019245514646172523, -0.02019388973712921, 0.01986808329820633, -0.007914687506854534, 0.007284790277481079, -0.020093493163585663, 0.030407408252358437, -0.0008625435875728726, 0.008367227390408516, 0.019956642761826515, 0.045154739171266556, 0.02723454311490059, 0.0032351927366107702, 0.020532390102744102, 0.021147262305021286, 0.016613498330116272, 0.05223284289240837, 0.03228965401649475, 0.023656625300645828, 0.00043456070125102997, 0.012887046672403812, 0.0003356126544531435, 0.010423615574836731, 0.03433280438184738, -0.019847489893436432, -0.02222442254424095, 0.07025778293609619, -0.0076884254813194275, -0.06449820846319199, 0.021531233564019203, -0.027931084856390953, 0.018032755702733994, -0.012159809470176697, -0.026710372418165207, -0.017491333186626434, -0.004213051404803991, 0.06308382004499435, 0.020217252895236015, -0.028718966990709305, -0.04023916646838188, 0.007174196653068066, 0.021274926140904427, 0.0038499073125422, -0.01014786772429943, -0.03680633008480072, 0.011370334774255753, -0.013245224952697754, 0.017443012446165085, 0.04140758141875267, -0.017715342342853546, -0.00169805355835706, 0.005847204010933638, 0.038693130016326904, 0.06243384629487991, 0.07213349640369415, 0.0026102059055119753, 0.020041652023792267, 0.023890744894742966, -0.04651755839586258, 0.026179281994700432, -0.009668069891631603, 0.005656902212649584, -0.04763297364115715, 0.06576897203922272, 0.016115278005599976, -0.016735460609197617, 0.0000062452263591694646, -0.023091671988368034, 0.05192211642861366, -0.005022733937948942, -0.0910361036658287, -0.0558045320212841, 0.02286556363105774, -0.010235646739602089, -0.019499264657497406, -0.06665445119142532, 0.011758027598261833, 0.03522485867142677, 0.051917992532253265, 0.003202203894034028, 0.0178559310734272, -0.014457357116043568, -0.010455179959535599, 0.04160354658961296, -0.04807587340474129, -0.04220351204276085, -0.0060920678079128265, -0.03510605916380882, -0.021020036190748215, -0.07657212764024734, -0.00140496960375458, 0.013450146652758121, -0.023323778063058853, 0.006030825432389975, 0.004500187002122402, 0.03815144672989845, 0.03495244309306145, -0.02920382469892502, 0.017525725066661835, -0.02797805704176426, 0.061650920659303665, -0.012349479831755161, 0.023833628743886948, 0.0024037701077759266, 0.007626497186720371, 0.03940064460039139, 0.004055777098983526, 0.0472140796482563, 0.06537401676177979, -0.007276793476194143, -0.008291295729577541, -0.019238818436861038, 0.05133979395031929, 0.03418857976794243, -0.04701835289597511, 0.014484704472124577, -0.015167277306318283, 0.0170713122934103, -0.0034903311170637608, 0.023426758125424385, -0.0016205584397539496, 0.004411028698086739, 0.04279901459813118, -0.06031891703605652, -0.013093259185552597, -0.069217748939991, 0.009026596322655678, 0.003804513020440936, -0.06544572114944458, 0.033327002078294754, 0.02981957420706749, 0.03560775890946388, -0.031805772334337234, -0.01860818825662136, -0.02841608226299286, 0.014008225873112679, 0.020903516560792923, -0.029909776523709297, 0.03030315414071083, 0.0341472290456295, 0.052907269448041916, 0.0025254751089960337, 0.03620129078626633, -0.018214043229818344, -0.035852111876010895, 0.011233201250433922, -0.01771167665719986, 0.009144026786088943, 0.022228924557566643, 0.003779937978833914, 0.015386296436190605, 0.04153364896774292, -0.008978892117738724, 0.0857066661119461, -0.07217324525117874, 0.06610214710235596, 0.05796872079372406, 0.013121760450303555, 0.0007710675126872957, -0.02315179817378521, 0.047154154628515244, -0.01093203853815794, -0.034918397665023804, -0.0037805703468620777, -0.023275336250662804, 0.011317779310047626, 0.009659449569880962, 0.0028312401846051216, -0.03212414309382439, -0.005739180371165276, 0.0710100308060646, 0.025976743549108505, -0.020814483985304832, 0.012338402681052685, -0.0031125335954129696, -0.04198257252573967, -0.025752905756235123, 0.03168075531721115, 0.04159735515713692, 0.014634004794061184, -0.0010910213459283113, 0.010231513530015945, 0.023680496960878372, 0.023007690906524658, 0.0004005110531579703, 0.04535380005836487, -0.017839420586824417, 0.006642770022153854, -0.000978710944764316, -0.02758224867284298, 0.035457685589790344, 0.009850882925093174, 0.031127195805311203, 0.061045773327350616, 0.02597876824438572, -0.009102278389036655, -0.0004576323844958097, -0.00940069742500782, 0.045281779021024704, 0.027934690937399864, -0.05409699305891991, -0.005578844342380762, 0.01150844432413578, -0.040168698877096176, 0.002700757933780551, -0.03039398603141308, -0.03403786942362785, -0.03498993068933487, 0.004223836585879326, 0.03303101658821106, -0.006080676801502705, 0.029532942920923233, -0.04541001468896866, -0.024108774960041046, -0.0492946058511734, -0.008366372436285019, 0.03273181989789009, -0.01052932906895876, -0.04242868348956108, 0.032365016639232635, -0.006433566100895405, -0.008871512487530708, 0.032176557928323746, 0.0072090718895196915, 0.013715031556785107, 0.037362776696681976, -0.021847741678357124, -0.02456001192331314, -0.011294757016003132, -0.03646641969680786, 0.02390448749065399, -0.011547856964170933, 0.004907640162855387, 0.02255035936832428, 0.0493895560503006, -0.06341203302145004, 0.04521820321679115, -0.03846425563097, -0.03875112906098366, -0.037459131330251694, -0.01460079476237297, -0.011292104609310627, 0.018208274617791176, 0.041890062391757965, 0.035484496504068375, -0.03641889616847038, -0.024903537705540657, -0.0430774986743927, -0.09175273776054382, 0.030021468177437782, 0.019708301872015, 0.03361254930496216, -0.015283911488950253, -0.051475994288921356, 0.07035330682992935, 0.02444068156182766, -0.012683819979429245, -0.007619677577167749, -0.002493253443390131, -0.014606469310820103, -0.022300563752651215, 0.020181499421596527, -0.03739325329661369, 0.013616319745779037, 0.0442451536655426, 0.019871490076184273, 0.03643088787794113, 0.050308097153902054, -0.008148729801177979, 0.012063967995345592, 0.0033751805312931538, 0.01949380338191986, 0.015445315279066563, 0.05891629308462143, 0.03257538005709648, 0.013129367493093014, -0.013960936106741428, 0.016831060871481895, 0.020142488181591034, -0.007598580792546272, -0.03330202400684357, 0.03420058265328407, -0.04523312672972679, 0.047578249126672745, -0.0520293153822422, 0.029310422018170357, -0.0047419508919119835, 0.01746692880988121, 0.00008797689952189103, 0.01599457859992981, 0.04514491930603981, -0.002845868468284607, -0.006712036207318306, 0.048479314893484116, 0.02316366881132126, -0.041353628039360046, -0.02131061442196369, -0.014800583943724632, -0.018391793593764305, 0.050581399351358414, -0.02046659216284752, -0.013928341679275036, 0.03189016506075859, 0.044138990342617035, 0.03163360804319382, 0.01777801662683487, -0.04773619771003723, 0.020951101556420326, -0.0277200136333704, 0.02829410508275032, -0.03174243122339249, 0.021641450002789497, -0.013260317966341972, 0.037429969757795334, 0.032366324216127396, 0.0062555959448218346, -0.02024480514228344, -0.0003151402052026242, -0.032129429280757904, 0.015485012903809547, -0.0005008170264773071, -0.00952980201691389, -0.013004436157643795, -0.016293779015541077, 0.036058202385902405, 0.011559315025806427, -0.002335628727450967, -0.01181570440530777, -0.004087940324097872, -0.049459557980298996, 0.003731069155037403, -0.011464661918580532, -0.0029412603471428156, 0.01286581251770258, 0.07798601686954498, 0.00046411744551733136, -0.0359392985701561, 0.02888873778283596, 0.030016081407666206, -0.017182379961013794, -0.022470790892839432, 0.002280901651829481, 0.05211985111236572, 0.01815190538764, 0.029718225821852684, 0.005882075056433678, 0.021709762513637543, -0.036453332751989365, 0.017753370106220245, 0.010983251966536045, 0.059185467660427094, 0.018198691308498383, 0.000058932360843755305, -0.015227113850414753, -0.014300068840384483, -0.03530701994895935, 0.004127215128391981, -0.004726130049675703, 0.02002430334687233, 0.0017542702844366431, 0.04235141724348068, 0.05524713546037674, -0.027609338983893394, 0.03923329710960388, 0.07328739762306213, -0.008108936250209808, 0.024444714188575745, 0.0006959424936212599, 0.006589294411242008, 0.007539559621363878, -0.020822491496801376, 0.008875135332345963, -0.014484993182122707, -0.04483547434210777, -0.011960635893046856, 0.007732717785984278, -0.019144998863339424, -0.026073886081576347, 0.013572321273386478, 0.016125820577144623, 0.05019146203994751, 0.0017118928954005241, -0.03300333395600319, 0.060804907232522964, 0.03205406665802002, -0.002317354315891862, 0.05256019905209541, 0.008901776745915413, -0.05542365834116936, -0.0010868231765925884, 0.02527998760342598, 0.035569753497838974, -0.05201849341392517, 0.0218367762863636, -0.021988902240991592, -0.0024207760579884052, 0.04123588278889656, -0.04344145208597183, 0.04157935455441475, -0.011634468100965023, 0.0042411633767187595, -0.018751638010144234, -0.018691524863243103, -0.02548116445541382, 0.012335803359746933, -0.03766600042581558, 0.03158356621861458, -0.00865203607827425, -0.029944485053420067, -0.014638945460319519, -0.0016010188264772296, 0.01886751689016819, 0.0859861969947815, -0.022584229707717896, 0.00049680593656376, 0.008688399568200111, 0.038247037678956985, -0.03225668519735336, -0.06149451434612274, 0.0305811557918787, -0.007525318302214146, 0.005947767291218042, 0.05624906346201897, -0.008660492487251759, -0.05567212402820587, 0.053560521453619, -0.00789722055196762, 0.010199854150414467, 0.014880159869790077, 0.014819017611443996, 0.05263044685125351, 0.04842130094766617, 0.006402112543582916, 0.07614614069461823, 0.009929670952260494, 0.030341636389493942, -0.009076382033526897, -0.021793602034449577, 0.025575004518032074, -0.0563957616686821, -0.035645417869091034, -0.04572359472513199, -0.004155389498919249, -0.019550856202840805, 0.03353026136755943, -0.009512880817055702, 0.044556874781847, -0.01920727640390396, 0.0031872610561549664, 0.017975378781557083, 0.0073682088404893875, 0.002398308366537094, -0.01644100807607174, -0.0036832336336374283, 0.017565039917826653, -0.008506092242896557, -0.025037361308932304, 0.05222378671169281, -0.024759571999311447, -0.02530868537724018, -0.018333859741687775, -0.03250482678413391, -0.0010273020016029477, -0.04976942762732506, -0.0040655299089848995, -0.02088553085923195, 0.013626571744680405, 0.04516507312655449, -0.012587868608534336, 0.010901201516389847, 0.00026544256252236664, -0.05555864796042442, -0.01207243837416172, 0.0379272922873497, -0.011807551607489586, 0.03867319971323013, -0.04754199832677841, 0.02577936463057995, 0.012346929870545864, -0.007621180731803179, -0.1042749211192131, -0.032451383769512177, -0.023774703964591026, 0.023105433210730553, 0.02906341478228569, -0.044174693524837494, -0.02495363913476467, 0.017098477110266685, -0.01970500499010086, -0.030123012140393257, 0.026937050744891167, -0.021523501724004745, -0.017822200432419777, -0.02768649533390999, 0.007266617845743895, 0.09045423567295074, -0.0036284697707742453, 0.004317503422498703, -0.010298177599906921, -0.042444922029972076, -0.018630865961313248, 0.008343501016497612, 0.01186424307525158, -0.030678879469633102, 0.0030012656934559345, -0.009609270840883255, 0.01015991810709238, 0.040974415838718414, -0.052746206521987915, -0.02677767723798752, 0.006301569286733866, -0.0069916462525725365, 0.03891008347272873, -0.022776208817958832, -0.016661038622260094, -0.04489096626639366, 0.004232592415064573, -0.013981522060930729, 0.01752178929746151, 0.02706262655556202, -0.031241128221154213, 0.004391332622617483, 0.01245164591819048, 0.016941357403993607, 0.04028711095452309, 0.09859181940555573, -0.010638072155416012, -0.02429346926510334, 0.0023049162700772285, -0.006963171064853668, -0.019310707226395607, 0.007543239276856184, 0.01172905508428812, 0.013783903792500496, 0.04568260535597801, -0.035008497536182404, -0.02840212546288967, -0.0159238763153553, 0.023434706032276154, 0.0725686177611351, -0.0209280364215374, 0.02628551796078682, 0.07683280855417252, -0.022494986653327942, -0.012201137840747833, -0.09182053804397583, 0.03675907105207443, -0.007913925684988499, -0.010684517212212086, 0.04527629539370537, 0.00874598789960146, 0.005157534033060074, 0.03226155787706375, 0.024358069524168968, 0.03514046594500542, 0.02120545133948326, 0.022804228588938713, 0.05480591580271721, -0.004670706111937761, -0.017031142488121986, -0.05906950682401657, -0.00393646489828825, -0.05882289260625839, 0.0016536632319912314, -0.04936303198337555, -0.015327070839703083, 0.043071333318948746, 0.019376607611775398, -0.009646563790738583, -0.02842090092599392, -0.09105737507343292, -0.04889172688126564, 0.029037902131676674, 0.024471310898661613, -0.003167113522067666, 0.017732277512550354, 0.020908642560243607, 0.030731458216905594, -0.007743502035737038, 0.011431192979216576, -0.056622911244630814, -0.08574085682630539, -0.03731361776590347, -0.005726536735892296, 0.009961427189409733, 0.03132285550236702, 0.0017226201016455889, -0.008972562849521637, 0.0005478002713061869, -0.0017816422041505575, 0.012803817167878151, -0.012053540907800198, 0.032359473407268524, 0.013426398858428001, 0.08066242188215256, 0.004491128958761692, 0.039830151945352554, -0.025201525539159775, 0.006988188251852989, 0.08878302574157715, 0.04640057682991028, 0.03764953836798668, -0.06612979620695114, 0.01683255098760128, -0.016261223703622818, -0.005956792738288641, -0.014797133393585682, 0.016435205936431885, 0.01495823822915554, -0.021581171080470085, 0.022182609885931015, 0.07452370226383209, 0.00614739628508687, -0.03534404933452606, 0.04793361946940422, -0.01157466508448124, -0.01592807099223137, -0.003003231482580304, 0.018784867599606514, -0.010363816283643246, 0.0007137366337701678, -0.03930655121803284, 0.010406061075627804, 0.018319718539714813, -0.011554992757737637, -0.04520660638809204, 0.005942505318671465, 0.009923933073878288, 0.038623541593551636, -0.025935515761375427, -0.021198531612753868, 0.004740093369036913, -0.01319525483995676, -0.07713456451892853, -0.06756934523582458, 0.014457466080784798, -0.00963970459997654, 0.026980705559253693, 0.0426398403942585, 0.0013076314935460687, 0.0006919628940522671, -0.0030073344241827726, 0.01024438813328743, -0.03985279053449631, 0.017284709960222244, -0.01197606697678566, 0.01992216892540455, 0.0008938421960920095, -0.010378223843872547, -0.015403690747916698, -0.011671417392790318, -0.008963329717516899, -0.08130811154842377, -0.010720797814428806, -0.0064696683548390865, 0.009948504157364368, -0.033430054783821106, 0.0024268676061183214, -0.051893509924411774, 0.039218720048666, 0.014298858121037483, 0.014534211717545986, -0.0007799952873028815, -0.03696683794260025, -0.012056779116392136, -0.06232732906937599, 0.008926283568143845, 0.006656234618276358, -0.023403234779834747, -0.013420742005109787, -0.03198105841875076, -0.010184220038354397, -0.012330574914813042, 0.018621735274791718, 0.016589531674981117, 0.059127140790224075, -0.01553113479167223, -0.0294161606580019, 0.019965432584285736, -0.0709831714630127, 0.021642565727233887, -0.020719747990369797, -0.009356806986033916, -0.035902902483940125, -0.009755939245223999, 0.042338158935308456, 0.010573743842542171, -0.033371392637491226, 0.01183689758181572, -0.002489244332537055, 0.0810607522726059, -0.011002006009221077, -0.05440061166882515, -0.03250178322196007, -0.015506310388445854, -0.022000355646014214, -0.0070351650938391685, -0.05630738288164139, 0.03377234935760498, 0.06335077434778214, 0.04908399283885956, -0.013692867010831833, 0.006487474776804447, -0.006395564414560795, 0.00576425064355135, -0.01797191984951496, -0.025756090879440308, -0.0023192435037344694, 0.02673456072807312, 0.02095799706876278, -0.022090835496783257, -0.014813483692705631, -0.04414525255560875, -0.02993270941078663, -0.0012121566105633974, -0.0410219207406044, -0.04279915615916252, -0.015118665061891079, -0.016751587390899658, -0.008137546479701996, -0.04646863415837288, -0.004835398402065039, -0.003237673547118902, -0.016100764274597168, 0.015008036978542805, -0.002314231125637889, -0.00987418182194233, -0.002023132983595133, -0.04962439835071564, -0.010778854601085186, 0.04531805217266083, 0.0052049667574465275, -0.0007851642440073192, -0.0020792323630303144, 0.0054594227112829685, 0.011947544291615486, 0.03350529819726944, -0.07485051453113556, -0.009466292336583138, 0.06645147502422333, -0.047798410058021545, -0.003952281549572945, 0.027522962540388107, -0.008553785271942616, 0.0334344319999218, -0.00031229641172103584, 0.004650792106986046, -0.05920626223087311, 0.0025072149001061916, -0.018891163170337677, 0.031644850969314575, -0.0019660210236907005, 0.014882944524288177, 0.00933559238910675, -0.009100795723497868, 0.012376292608678341, 0.03781115263700485, -0.014141254127025604, 0.025333141908049583, 0.055315081030130386, 0.007265610620379448, -0.04819926247000694, 0.007143576163798571, -0.006346262991428375, -0.014476850628852844, 0.009851178154349327, -0.0003625605022534728, 0.02753112092614174, 0.050090059638023376, -0.03209595009684563, 0.028489649295806885, -0.01771307736635208, 0.008193804882466793, -0.09776965528726578, -0.02019675448536873, 0.008605708368122578, 0.01000422053039074, 0.017099706456065178, -0.025224387645721436, -0.0034432895481586456, 0.02931867353618145, -0.017541877925395966, -0.03513115644454956, -0.02148348279297352, -0.008199719712138176, -0.10051239281892776, -0.0036872071214020252, -0.01421433873474598, 0.026376284658908844, -0.0030753600876778364, 0.022328536957502365, 0.021641574800014496, 0.00577374966815114, -0.022172782570123672, -0.04533860832452774, -0.0473356656730175, -0.009639443829655647, 0.009678228758275509, -0.05867760255932808, 0.010946621187031269, -0.019694358110427856, -0.0269857756793499, -0.008448024280369282, -0.014939917251467705, 0.01717667654156685, 0.0038655095268040895, 0.028577076271176338, 0.010397258214652538, 0.00926144141703844, 0.023166170343756676, 0.009987987577915192, 0.017912287265062332, -0.005329364910721779, 0.008791424334049225, 0.029554005712270737, -0.02451975643634796, -0.03534909337759018, 0.05207635834813118, -0.015800537541508675, -0.011424289084970951, 0.004804634489119053, -0.022355638444423676, -0.050004828721284866, -0.006551519501954317, 0.01280317921191454, 0.023163627833127975, -0.02112692967057228, 0.028197484090924263, -0.03345185145735741, -0.026633473113179207, 0.048172447830438614, 0.032005712389945984, -0.02449779026210308, 0.015372616238892078, -0.005891420412808657, -0.041103556752204895, 0.014602274633944035, 0.035631485283374786, -0.014986000023782253, -0.06320879608392715, -0.014095230028033257, 0.011463372968137264, -0.04900113120675087, -0.004777164198458195, -0.06137726083397865, -0.025176294147968292, 0.011089705862104893, -0.009897883981466293, 0.011139027774333954, -0.014104750007390976, -0.015625817701220512, 0.015459108166396618, -0.07095327228307724, 0.07122982293367386, -0.010159245692193508, -0.011696732603013515, -0.04613747075200081, -0.02684222348034382, -0.027872459962964058, -0.020600462332367897, -0.010904532857239246, 0.002570963930338621, 0.025110062211751938, 0.0008916684309951961, 0.023868590593338013, -0.019206129014492035, -0.040587738156318665, 0.05933315306901932, -0.03067866526544094, -0.018477855250239372, 0.00817444734275341, -0.012517604045569897, 0.010131053626537323, -0.004589729011058807, 0.005847068969160318, 0.000020415773178683594, 0.004984445404261351, -0.0032274972181767225, -0.01365344226360321, 0.013209288939833641, 0.0003426198672968894, 0.01054081879556179, 0.019808363169431686, -0.008662243373692036, 0.012185005471110344, 0.014946497976779938, 0.030967598780989647, -0.06676080077886581, 0.035334110260009766, -0.060650814324617386, 0.004345315508544445, 0.002163006691262126, 0.04156827926635742, -0.0327303409576416, -0.010196628049015999, 0.0019366444321349263, 0.010114525444805622, -0.014392156153917313, -0.011944349855184555, 0.0469454824924469, 0.020795270800590515, 0.05367515981197357, -0.018044855445623398, 0.005800171755254269, 0.01728443056344986, -0.018243461847305298, 0.025325732305645943, 0.00417248485609889, 0.026993688195943832, 0.019136814400553703, -0.020150814205408096, 0.044931549578905106, -0.007117053959518671, 0.028728097677230835, 0.015682494267821312, 0.0443524494767189, -0.0036095355171710253, -0.037933457642793655, -0.00662276754155755, -0.004812699276953936, 0.017237460240721703, -0.047245245426893234, -0.03221029043197632, 0.026355978101491928, -0.02297474630177021, 0.04350058734416962, -0.011419561691582203, 0.00358232157304883, -0.005564085207879543, -0.0029140429105609655, 0.02775750868022442, 0.013578362762928009, -0.024953819811344147, -0.015964362770318985, -0.01593753509223461, -0.01362305972725153, 0.015247312374413013, -0.010189707390964031, 0.015106715261936188, -0.016568640246987343, 0.001428462564945221, -0.013373175635933876, -0.019650323316454887, -0.02936103567481041, -0.03571260720491409, -0.0026256900746375322, 0.02503502182662487, 0.048060037195682526, -0.026204204186797142, -0.018620209768414497, 0.027709132060408592, 0.042245376855134964, -0.04682398587465286, -0.01298394612967968, -0.05281929671764374, 0.005749324802309275, -0.007206583395600319, 0.011903811246156693 ]
<p>Is there a way to simplify this equation? </p> <p>$$\dbinom{8}{1} + \dbinom{8}{2} + \dbinom{8}{3} + \dbinom{8}{4} + \dbinom{8}{5} + \dbinom{8}{6} + \dbinom{8}{7} + \dbinom{8}{8}$$</p> <p>Or more generally,</p> <p>$$\sum_{k=1}^{n}\dbinom{n}{k}$$</p>
25,114
[ -0.041776932775974274, -0.015684587880969048, -0.022887185215950012, 0.01056640688329935, 0.028780793771147728, -0.013047164306044579, -0.023332668468356133, -0.006097505800426006, 0.015292149968445301, -0.04401690885424614, 0.04666799306869507, 0.018493542447686195, 0.02760263904929161, 0.008517105132341385, 0.025738034397363663, 0.023766690865159035, -0.05171387642621994, 0.011532604694366455, 0.01909870281815529, -0.03115798719227314, -0.00241378927603364, 0.019491706043481827, -0.0017760402988642454, 0.019883861765265465, -0.0004810926038771868, 0.03714441508054733, 0.0730939581990242, 0.012945693917572498, 0.04152942821383476, 0.057233359664678574, 0.0022707730531692505, -0.017019622027873993, 0.05092900991439819, 0.07195814698934555, 0.03112844191491604, 0.005372585263103247, -0.002598857507109642, -0.009301911108195782, -0.006855576764792204, 0.02347763627767563, -0.010159125551581383, -0.04592794552445412, -0.0034871066454797983, 0.01498288381844759, -0.03842020779848099, 0.027367684990167618, -0.011047393083572388, -0.013869388028979301, 0.0337776355445385, -0.07294535636901855, 0.08115933835506439, 0.01519668847322464, 0.03619261831045151, 0.04827094450592995, -0.02452818863093853, 0.006810938939452171, 0.022106358781456947, 0.05663459002971649, 0.013621196150779724, -0.02666357159614563, 0.0005303462967276573, -0.022503580898046494, 0.014355264604091644, 0.00433763861656189, -0.007849745452404022, 0.03482600301504135, 0.01567748375236988, -0.0022580900695174932, 0.0186177846044302, -0.009436600841581821, -0.0047424472868442535, 0.04416956752538681, 0.05132811889052391, -0.02957046777009964, 0.018287619575858116, -0.02292933501303196, 0.017074985429644585, -0.0005313518340699375, 0.07152414321899414, 0.03135997802019119, -0.001581496326252818, 0.016033172607421875, 0.01769416034221649, 0.010039347223937511, 0.01758299581706524, -0.012279012240469456, 0.05611224099993706, 0.0015425465535372496, 0.020149920135736465, 0.018338453024625778, -0.0045278482139110565, 0.018335366621613503, 0.04006433114409447, 0.016091065481305122, -0.019445903599262238, 0.007835905067622662, -0.015151211060583591, 0.011702470481395721, 0.037476565688848495, -0.032695457339286804, -0.002776414854452014, -0.03730755299329758, 0.0019265626324340701, 0.07393841445446014, -0.017395121976733208, 0.01760881580412388, -0.054536256939172745, 0.019535619765520096, 0.016816241666674614, -0.00017961897538043559, -0.01733339950442314, -0.012948253192007542, -0.0045035420916974545, -0.029340332373976707, -0.024283669888973236, -0.01848583295941353, -0.026223130524158478, 0.0038125936407595873, 0.030720122158527374, 0.08818376809358597, 0.033736854791641235, -0.02119245007634163, 0.07448971271514893, 0.005885617807507515, -0.061822667717933655, 0.014532557688653469, 0.011431708931922913, -0.04003768786787987, -0.011879860423505306, 0.06463295966386795, -0.021395210176706314, -0.024748006835579872, 0.028272315859794617, 0.001317378832027316, 0.035862237215042114, 0.005748379044234753, -0.0639411062002182, -0.07118147611618042, 0.03710372745990753, -0.024552788585424423, -0.04322834685444832, -0.06996316462755203, 0.033073730766773224, 0.022560525685548782, 0.026646602898836136, 0.00638838205486536, -0.004571783356368542, 0.04883713647723198, -0.0009862505830824375, 0.043689172714948654, -0.004128103610128164, -0.03319043293595314, 0.020799074321985245, -0.048535991460084915, 0.0156722255051136, -0.061025217175483704, 0.013977788388729095, 0.04310572147369385, -0.0016408269293606281, 0.018991457298398018, 0.04982297495007515, 0.0018898642156273127, -0.008411741815507412, -0.01544389221817255, -0.030384445562958717, -0.030715154483914375, 0.07124999165534973, 0.02403266169130802, 0.013778279535472393, 0.04011593386530876, 0.005641020834445953, 0.018235094845294952, -0.00775404367595911, 0.02583567425608635, 0.024997470900416374, -0.030891098082065582, -0.00006483757169917226, -0.03452473506331444, 0.017730582505464554, 0.02994958683848381, -0.01926799863576889, -0.043190453201532364, 0.0220219437032938, 0.014439739286899567, 0.03946033492684364, 0.05530120059847832, 0.00986139290034771, -0.04171522334218025, -0.012590641155838966, -0.009881066158413887, -0.001671086996793747, -0.0848456621170044, -0.024557849392294884, -0.02240421250462532, -0.008777904324233532, -0.002881028689444065, 0.020329710096120834, 0.022924307733774185, -0.01451061386615038, -0.020697584375739098, 0.015331110917031765, 0.01270876731723547, 0.014587240293622017, -0.040155790746212006, -0.0071952431462705135, 0.049388401210308075, 0.07844408601522446, -0.019598938524723053, 0.031029872596263885, -0.05168605595827103, 0.0064836544916033745, -0.04888198897242546, -0.00007811257091816515, 0.01865297555923462, -0.02179558388888836, -0.01837298832833767, 0.02077559195458889, -0.00508189806714654, 0.04122983291745186, 0.058247316628694534, -0.04795168340206146, 0.06615816801786423, 0.06657558679580688, 0.05138364061713219, 0.008718408644199371, -0.014122450724244118, 0.06956586986780167, 0.020511893555521965, -0.009571087546646595, -0.022109780460596085, 0.0011686867801472545, 0.04224669188261032, 0.07037666440010071, 0.01929539069533348, -0.045052409172058105, 0.0066174715757369995, 0.09399690479040146, 0.04438186064362526, 0.029798349365592003, 0.02697269804775715, -0.02604898437857628, 0.015219113789498806, -0.0070517705753445625, -0.005439301487058401, -0.03206197917461395, 0.022237755358219147, 0.015044682659208775, -0.010376092046499252, 0.01902035064995289, 0.014823264442384243, -0.04104067012667656, 0.02983967959880829, 0.01718580164015293, -0.011897895485162735, -0.031889550387859344, -0.04617926478385925, 0.034539032727479935, -0.006205128040164709, 0.03305959701538086, -0.024408802390098572, 0.014258168637752533, 0.018371857702732086, -0.01032869890332222, -0.009998339228332043, -0.0158607829362154, -0.01756872422993183, -0.04654781520366669, -0.016615236178040504, 0.029080575332045555, -0.05086597800254822, 0.04287710785865784, -0.047083381563425064, 0.0027749959845095873, -0.01245818380266428, 0.007567811291664839, 0.0127509580925107, -0.016093343496322632, 0.020099062472581863, -0.035643864423036575, -0.00671430304646492, -0.020978806540369987, -0.022356435656547546, 0.0035521017853170633, 0.010951106436550617, -0.03946147486567497, -0.014965384267270565, 0.004098978824913502, -0.01938953623175621, 0.051891230046749115, -0.006998653523623943, 0.0101752495393157, 0.014533801935613155, 0.01180172711610794, -0.04093143343925476, -0.018494591116905212, -0.043329112231731415, 0.047603949904441833, -0.059908103197813034, -0.0023117519449442625, 0.027093838900327682, -0.005087085533887148, -0.00834842212498188, 0.03397544100880623, -0.031474024057388306, -0.04541664943099022, -0.023530151695013046, -0.0027902591973543167, 0.027242427691817284, -0.027530204504728317, 0.012257968075573444, 0.0022129956632852554, -0.06736791878938675, 0.005318973679095507, -0.08143028616905212, -0.052051279693841934, 0.02358013577759266, -0.02811058796942234, 0.043589137494564056, 0.00466915313154459, -0.08761581778526306, 0.10224735736846924, -0.00489529874175787, -0.0017632560338824987, -0.032489340752363205, -0.000583995773922652, 0.006901327520608902, -0.04100464656949043, -0.007882175967097282, 0.034463055431842804, -0.022370077669620514, 0.03683564066886902, -0.0012927837669849396, 0.001727218390442431, 0.07635460793972015, -0.01815861277282238, -0.014247585088014603, 0.0254958625882864, -0.013686385937035084, 0.003617333248257637, 0.029035035520792007, 0.01236677821725607, -0.009873111732304096, -0.0006352424970827997, 0.03429683670401573, 0.03178355097770691, -0.01014628354460001, -0.03517116233706474, 0.017642199993133545, 0.0384138822555542, 0.044644422829151154, -0.04502303898334503, 0.0327986404299736, 0.011599639430642128, 0.004553807899355888, -0.014580382965505123, 0.02800353430211544, 0.03082934021949768, -0.06286776065826416, 0.03213801607489586, 0.028424398973584175, 0.03392598778009415, -0.034654755145311356, -0.02506207674741745, 0.008155974559485912, -0.010552335530519485, 0.020627746358513832, -0.026403913274407387, 0.026047898456454277, 0.025449609383940697, 0.009228961542248726, 0.016820307821035385, 0.027704128995537758, -0.015484473668038845, 0.030413217842578888, -0.08172868937253952, -0.012707098387181759, -0.009180106222629547, 0.01231421995908022, -0.024607375264167786, 0.05488266795873642, -0.0005137874977663159, 0.005234313663095236, 0.05226840451359749, 0.020885558798909187, -0.06602024286985397, 0.009329664520919323, -0.007675564847886562, -0.02794998697936535, 0.0018340981332585216, -0.016262231394648552, -0.014456644654273987, -0.007652592845261097, -0.030813973397016525, -0.006938972510397434, 0.0059801870957016945, -0.014832179993391037, 0.014564949087798595, 0.0023676708806306124, 0.0045764087699353695, 0.016630524769425392, 0.028904732316732407, 0.0663851723074913, -0.03392821550369263, -0.010790178552269936, 0.053500544279813766, -0.01780731789767742, 0.0031343651935458183, -0.052425868809223175, 0.00785844773054123, -0.01181462500244379, 0.0032020227517932653, 0.019215842708945274, 0.03927605226635933, -0.03600647673010826, 0.01412187423557043, -0.01810065470635891, 0.054181281477212906, -0.010690498165786266, 0.0030265047680586576, -0.0016604431439191103, -0.04437553882598877, -0.024469098076224327, -0.0025580257643014193, 0.014620555564761162, 0.016037506982684135, 0.04296230897307396, 0.024792227894067764, 0.0050500668585300446, -0.05367608740925789, 0.0545966699719429, 0.07486409693956375, 0.0058713615871965885, -0.06752218306064606, -0.01622110791504383, 0.009669962339103222, -0.03529887646436691, -0.010954716242849827, 0.006215278524905443, 0.040157172828912735, -0.012496460229158401, -0.005090316757559776, 0.016180410981178284, -0.009258576668798923, -0.006980759557336569, 0.03831779211759567, 0.009202832356095314, 0.022014159709215164, -0.009925642982125282, 0.007193319965153933, 0.03142903000116348, 0.03410852700471878, 0.012263053096830845, 0.011441057547926903, -0.01390253845602274, -0.049698248505592346, -0.011669873259961605, 0.0669475644826889, 0.054579541087150574, -0.025806866586208344, 0.027313176542520523, -0.06249536946415901, -0.006877065636217594, 0.03908437490463257, -0.030243070796132088, 0.053363263607025146, 0.009831423871219158, 0.017538752406835556, 0.01678849197924137, -0.01537471916526556, -0.0379912406206131, 0.025738634169101715, -0.03894410282373428, 0.03116978518664837, -0.011545568704605103, -0.0000035397117699176306, -0.021575629711151123, 0.024628380313515663, 0.03384613245725632, 0.04473290964961052, 0.004666431341320276, -0.013942419551312923, 0.028678059577941895, 0.004274745937436819, -0.03830130770802498, -0.07105234265327454, 0.00526819983497262, -0.01807076297700405, -0.004531675949692726, 0.025422731414437294, -0.047104887664318085, -0.0561605729162693, 0.011442290619015694, 0.011098685674369335, -0.0004354534321464598, 0.0070311506278812885, -0.061139125376939774, 0.06141867861151695, 0.08463069796562195, 0.023144150152802467, 0.05842513218522072, 0.023790588602423668, -0.03928112983703613, 0.007806156296283007, -0.04123355448246002, -0.019425781443715096, -0.0095326267182827, -0.019812947139143944, -0.010057288222014904, 0.004632802680134773, -0.015540032647550106, 0.04689927399158478, -0.015537177212536335, -0.008104536682367325, 0.03005286678671837, -0.022970207035541534, -0.018427949398756027, 0.0123532023280859, 0.0270636398345232, -0.010303440503776073, 0.02568736858665943, 0.030755603685975075, 0.02100326120853424, -0.022530807182192802, 0.04014674201607704, -0.00723304832354188, -0.003967918921262026, 0.01045167539268732, -0.007086639758199453, 0.001859173527918756, -0.04444853588938713, -0.003106788033619523, 0.01408991776406765, -0.046310070902109146, 0.05637553706765175, 0.0003044493787456304, 0.03405488654971123, -0.01415472012013197, -0.08391506224870682, -0.047572292387485504, -0.008147245272994041, 0.004492849577218294, 0.00523965572938323, -0.037115760147571564, 0.02544410340487957, 0.012773039750754833, -0.032914578914642334, -0.06529312580823898, -0.05986461788415909, 0.04788227006793022, -0.002265340182930231, 0.014263599179685116, -0.02677506022155285, -0.019857244566082954, 0.006515591870993376, -0.03613412380218506, -0.0005452397745102644, 0.03894531726837158, -0.034550148993730545, -0.01572902873158455, 0.008873805403709412, 0.009818332269787788, 0.07428302615880966, 0.023797018453478813, 0.00534075777977705, 0.010114587843418121, -0.04477876424789429, -0.004159177653491497, 0.0017030189046636224, 0.04140571877360344, -0.03673148900270462, -0.02419099025428295, -0.015318159013986588, -0.03128974139690399, 0.022064756602048874, -0.01782970316708088, -0.009084772318601608, 0.002434318419545889, 0.014218115247786045, 0.017276326194405556, -0.04032115265727043, 0.009929731488227844, -0.010701118037104607, 0.0536481998860836, -0.011389188468456268, 0.008614209480583668, -0.014285012148320675, -0.012155085802078247, -0.006096454802900553, 0.009663378819823265, -0.044335439801216125, -0.012770846486091614, 0.07659512013196945, 0.005793612450361252, -0.014717542566359043, 0.008795349858701229, 0.021026110276579857, 0.04326087236404419, 0.05721777305006981, -0.021823646500706673, 0.0013734298991039395, 0.021282298490405083, -0.02657560631632805, -0.025406798347830772, -0.015662183985114098, 0.007198136765509844, 0.0507570318877697, -0.045526523143053055, 0.037256885319948196, 0.0270541999489069, 0.024544445797801018, 0.012472777627408504, 0.010616643354296684, 0.0067560006864368916, -0.006837849505245686, 0.011397956870496273, 0.05545884370803833, -0.007339362055063248, 0.03935037925839424, 0.009266158565878868, 0.03152912110090256, 0.019916674122214317, 0.01821545511484146, -0.0008042927365750074, -0.024238917976617813, 0.005600419826805592, -0.005863530561327934, -0.03294195607304573, 0.018400000408291817, -0.045257411897182465, 0.012110443785786629, -0.010644068010151386, -0.0475606843829155, 0.07768220454454422, -0.03071250393986702, 0.008095711469650269, -0.000533019716385752, -0.026933863759040833, -0.006467960309237242, -0.018526427447795868, 0.036434806883335114, -0.015381885692477226, 0.027884431183338165, -0.0000986884260782972, 0.03834247961640358, -0.0054669566452503204, 0.01754133403301239, -0.014528196305036545, -0.04913095757365227, 0.013428634963929653, -0.004190593957901001, -0.05497074872255325, 0.012778631411492825, 0.03911878168582916, -0.009667509235441685, 0.015032040886580944, 0.03134065493941307, 0.023544959723949432, 0.021462932229042053, 0.0015303954714909196, -0.020296528935432434, 0.046281617134809494, -0.004386508371680975, -0.015191442333161831, 0.005868669133633375, -0.004076062701642513, 0.11531354486942291, 0.0410093292593956, 0.03405456617474556, -0.0922093391418457, 0.00608573853969574, -0.014924854971468449, -0.015476378612220287, -0.012458298355340958, 0.012839709408581257, -0.0073836250230669975, 0.017138907685875893, 0.03736920282244682, 0.04172666743397713, -0.006183277349919081, 0.02373148687183857, 0.025791844353079796, -0.06332585960626602, -0.019525492563843727, 0.013576170429587364, -0.001913105952553451, 0.030624356120824814, 0.026252424344420433, -0.07665297389030457, 0.006946358364075422, -0.029661526903510094, -0.036544110625982285, -0.05680681765079498, -0.0140864672139287, 0.024154819548130035, 0.03703581914305687, -0.013800183311104774, 0.0047334544360637665, 0.024265175685286522, -0.03903310373425484, -0.025622934103012085, 0.013839177787303925, 0.02188801020383835, -0.0460410937666893, 0.02413911186158657, 0.020049192011356354, 0.014376701787114143, 0.0060173869132995605, -0.0030655094888061285, -0.0013490836136043072, -0.032328084111213684, 0.013835453428328037, -0.016411785036325455, 0.01395662035793066, -0.021380925551056862, 0.0004557674110401422, -0.009344170801341534, -0.015514631755650043, -0.006315257865935564, -0.10270892083644867, 0.00163075712043792, 0.04134385287761688, -0.004082837142050266, -0.043744105845689774, -0.02979467622935772, -0.02311752364039421, -0.030018648132681847, -0.039597511291503906, 0.037611089646816254, 0.004852206911891699, -0.015754902735352516, 0.018577007576823235, -0.009763001464307308, 0.020714258775115013, -0.009006107226014137, -0.025171076878905296, 0.005139185115695, -0.015906207263469696, -0.023823147639632225, 0.0042471326887607574, 0.0022717295214533806, 0.003976065665483475, 0.00804832298308611, 0.024955235421657562, 0.0006918517756275833, 0.0018467445624992251, -0.026388106867671013, 0.03942638635635376, -0.01826280541718006, 0.014009290374815464, -0.024004191160202026, -0.023323677480220795, 0.031235307455062866, 0.02514711581170559, -0.022410696372389793, 0.02041957899928093, 0.0007355376146733761, 0.07529144734144211, 0.041761480271816254, -0.02478301152586937, -0.02547844499349594, -0.007017436902970076, -0.01533669326454401, 0.013266138732433319, -0.0029772580601274967, 0.055153101682662964, 0.0285385400056839, -0.020725805312395096, 0.008703520521521568, 0.040516823530197144, -0.031028946861624718, 0.017163928598165512, -0.023757129907608032, -0.02574051171541214, 0.02356254868209362, -0.009126770310103893, -0.015577947720885277, 0.008355367928743362, 0.018565041944384575, -0.011633817106485367, -0.013964870944619179, 0.025684267282485962, 0.004256978165358305, -0.044061873108148575, 0.033706165850162506, -0.025101186707615852, -0.016788193956017494, -0.009942836128175259, 0.00245646177791059, -0.061218928545713425, -0.025141539052128792, -0.008544113487005234, 0.0000772781713749282, -0.015156028792262077, 0.028436195105314255, -0.03917204216122627, 0.017884068191051483, 0.05858913064002991, 0.01630060002207756, 0.02304089069366455, -0.022527914494276047, 0.008094476535916328, -0.020079154521226883, 0.036495391279459, -0.05771628022193909, -0.05394897982478142, 0.06204425171017647, -0.0348784439265728, -0.019717615097761154, -0.008190887048840523, -0.033974822610616684, 0.012066646479070187, 0.050263065844774246, -0.03786902502179146, -0.04614369198679924, 0.018444977700710297, -0.02107662335038185, 0.007220979779958725, 0.03702830150723457, -0.002594176447018981, 0.015085756778717041, 0.012842296622693539, -0.03736170381307602, 0.00919416919350624, -0.039649467915296555, -0.041397638618946075, 0.05886166915297508, -0.00744119705632329, -0.039105866104364395, 0.02007748745381832, 0.023632070049643517, 0.008097328245639801, 0.02084134891629219, 0.009398595429956913, -0.004275871906429529, -0.023674549534916878, -0.04390556737780571, 0.007686493918299675, -0.02017463557422161, -0.029878338798880577, -0.08393149822950363, -0.02083328366279602, -0.010268554091453552, 0.0011826548725366592, 0.013694542460143566, -0.04051339626312256, 0.0040524969808757305, -0.008949867449700832, -0.032187968492507935, 0.013788874261081219, -0.028578966856002808, -0.022793367505073547, -0.01958209089934826, -0.01097446121275425, 0.004348147660493851, 0.05579318106174469, -0.009733399376273155, 0.05015856772661209, 0.039520811289548874, -0.023058751598000526, -0.01885306090116501, -0.048812299966812134, 0.02115248516201973, 0.008694544434547424, 0.010217603296041489, -0.05746462196111679, 0.019837725907564163, -0.04016542807221413, -0.0199304036796093, 0.0058471569791436195, -0.003917939495295286, 0.002960258862003684, 0.0038310950621962547, 0.01819692738354206, 0.0010387902148067951, 0.048948321491479874, -0.029009204357862473, -0.0301324762403965, -0.02094344049692154, -0.00017434565233998, -0.005546714179217815, 0.0203822273761034, -0.005252509843558073, -0.015096582472324371, 0.05147507041692734, 0.014348829165101051, -0.0723087340593338, 0.038453444838523865, -0.018189309164881706, 0.0010974786709994078, -0.03137465566396713, -0.022573087364435196, 0.021286509931087494, -0.05567887797951698, 0.012128902599215508, -0.050495024770498276, 0.03851888328790665, 0.018180565908551216, -0.027929944917559624, -0.012928967364132404, 0.00185708689969033, 0.020898867398500443, -0.03061310015618801, -0.011691566556692123, 0.03298918530344963, -0.012447093613445759, -0.04996050149202347, 0.020935963839292526, 0.0410398468375206, -0.01602279208600521, 0.014228418469429016, -0.04356421157717705, -0.010388207621872425, 0.027618132531642914, 0.021914321929216385, 0.02654140442609787, -0.00631951866671443, -0.06670046597719193, -0.006400271784514189, -0.05591754615306854, 0.05142732337117195, 0.037023384124040604, 0.00354082346893847, -0.017817150801420212, -0.020358778536319733, -0.011979085393249989, 0.006097903475165367, 0.08623864501714706, -0.02927282266318798, -0.042820531874895096, -0.0074901282787323, -0.02053447626531124, 0.04708898067474365, -0.041772715747356415, 0.0027849397156387568, -0.007248943671584129, -0.032994214445352554, -0.004895441699773073, -0.01711990125477314, 0.0071183121763169765, 0.019504738971590996, 0.012268614023923874, -0.004222169052809477, -0.015807893127202988, -0.03673752024769783, -0.03244056925177574, 0.026900259777903557, -0.006235085893422365, -0.028713352978229523, 0.05399163439869881, -0.025408880785107613, 0.00643573421984911, 0.027188733220100403, 0.0023930282332003117, -0.02730870619416237, -0.008832510560750961, -0.04683664068579674, -0.03468000888824463, -0.02788989245891571, 0.0009265589178539813, 0.02637874148786068, -0.06538387387990952, 0.010056819766759872, 0.03198438882827759, -0.0477365218102932, -0.02382548339664936, 0.057674210518598557, 0.035717327147722244, 0.04886970296502113, -0.022691279649734497, 0.0023365477100014687, -0.003118250286206603, -0.04189290478825569, 0.01608254387974739, 0.016723161563277245, 0.030992776155471802, 0.02204863354563713, 0.0332086905837059, 0.0015813384670764208, 0.02446935698390007, 0.016115905717015266, 0.008113767020404339, 0.008839244022965431, -0.0577283538877964, -0.035639211535453796, 0.0076913125813007355, -0.05411402881145477, 0.02831018529832363, 0.003557971678674221, -0.016914190724492073, 0.07595405727624893, -0.005133482627570629, 0.030283113941550255, -0.035971760749816895, 0.009095573797821999, -0.026990875601768494, -0.018062321469187737, -0.010308309458196163, 0.014873594976961613, -0.033537592738866806, -0.02814623713493347, 0.012254705652594566, 0.009213599376380444, 0.026811355724930763, -0.008978001773357391, -0.015475716441869736, -0.029061174020171165, -0.008591377176344395, -0.013775473460555077, 0.013896209187805653, -0.05586818605661392, -0.012285534292459488, 0.04927993193268776, 0.022465158253908157, 0.007175875827670097, 0.011158326640725136, -0.008049104362726212, -0.0048295590095222, 0.05118340626358986, -0.05017275735735893, -0.024516481906175613, -0.05262883007526398, 0.014682512730360031, -0.010272317565977573, 0.002791874809190631 ]
<p>Say I have below example data, where rows are observations and columns are variables, and NAs stand for missing values.</p> <pre><code> 1 2 NA 4 5 6 14 5 2 6 13 7 1 11 4 NA 9 6 15 12 3 12 NA 8 3 7 12 8 1 NA 7 8 9 4 6 1 </code></pre> <p>I want to impute the missing values by regression (I know I can impute by means, but I need to see how regression performs). There is a CRAN package named 'Amelia' for imputation by regression, but it gives an error for above data saying that #observations is smaller than #variables. 'mi' package also gives an error. I can code myself, but I do not want to reinvent the wheel since I am sure there is already a package for that which would work faster than the one I write (Speed is important since I will run this imputation for thousands of variables and hundreds of observations with lots of missing values). So, does anybody know about a package which would impute the values above by regression? Thanks.</p>
73,819
[ -0.04884157329797745, 0.026204554364085197, -0.02297026850283146, 0.0004592142067849636, 0.030670974403619766, 0.0033878975082188845, -0.027601193636655807, 0.0015335064381361008, 0.007013136986643076, -0.00494831008836627, 0.024717725813388824, 0.041395626962184906, 0.03542506694793701, -0.023342175409197807, 0.0005526317982003093, 0.02365083619952202, -0.05201762542128563, 0.027491165325045586, -0.000662733509670943, -0.030555900186300278, -0.01316374633461237, 0.017075298354029655, 0.026621796190738678, 0.004633191041648388, -0.011070553213357925, 0.03125278279185295, 0.027115991339087486, -0.014453348703682423, -0.0017884675180539489, 0.04601015895605087, -0.01819058507680893, -0.023561818525195122, -0.009688944555819035, 0.011786950752139091, 0.0013601562241092324, 0.0005305563099682331, 0.018720459192991257, -0.008684860542416573, -0.010479954071342945, 0.03538605943322182, -0.0003592927532736212, -0.01890711858868599, 0.020167000591754913, 0.033606257289648056, 0.009436899796128273, 0.01055633369833231, -0.0035361945629119873, 0.002009374788030982, 0.021486887708306313, -0.057378511875867844, 0.06541439145803452, -0.0011377813061699271, 0.04059051722288132, 0.026218252256512642, -0.039019618183374405, -0.002891930751502514, 0.0816475972533226, 0.08044359087944031, -0.002219269284978509, -0.09152857214212418, -0.0011858055368065834, -0.045509401708841324, 0.010635418817400932, -0.008058655075728893, -0.026357892900705338, 0.027009250596165657, -0.011014540679752827, 0.0151473768055439, 0.027791937813162804, -0.03187870234251022, 0.015911448746919632, 0.005715558305382729, 0.046336136758327484, -0.01837637647986412, -0.0010599450906738639, -0.020297491922974586, 0.020353199914097786, 0.02273641712963581, 0.046566300094127655, 0.02037953771650791, -0.0030938584823161364, 0.025685163214802742, 0.03552791103720665, 0.021754369139671326, 0.002998689655214548, 0.0007832305855117738, 0.053759969770908356, -0.04468672722578049, 0.019234562292695045, 0.01823955774307251, -0.04045770317316055, 0.0029190212953835726, 0.06326762586832047, 0.045975856482982635, 0.003284741658717394, 0.009387783706188202, -0.005415615160018206, 0.04099626466631889, -0.010837174020707607, -0.002719916868954897, 0.017586562782526016, -0.029605070129036903, -0.006723808590322733, 0.02722953073680401, -0.0171661414206028, -0.0035848538391292095, -0.031358446925878525, -0.016139984130859375, -0.01675633154809475, -0.016015850007534027, -0.002610541181638837, 0.03449389338493347, -0.01591079868376255, -0.0045145596377551556, 0.010909667238593102, -0.06958512216806412, -0.0020800544880330563, -0.015683412551879883, 0.036540329456329346, 0.08242833614349365, 0.04431689903140068, -0.028382400050759315, 0.038790974766016006, -0.01042407937347889, -0.029191209003329277, 0.014294746331870556, -0.021677395328879356, -0.03496024012565613, -0.022909685969352722, 0.028357069939374924, -0.03404414653778076, -0.046367812901735306, 0.08991055190563202, -0.0000034789043183991453, 0.06131720915436745, -0.009484829381108284, -0.06028316915035248, -0.05901263654232025, -0.0003755943907890469, -0.08231798559427261, 0.006526469253003597, -0.02409197762608528, 0.0343937911093235, 0.008462678641080856, 0.062338437885046005, 0.059082649648189545, 0.05425075441598892, 0.053322933614254, 0.001749943126924336, -0.00483319815248251, -0.00853001605719328, -0.03571268916130066, -0.001416034996509552, -0.0028786417096853256, 0.0013891267590224743, -0.05993558466434479, 0.04061320796608925, 0.023468665778636932, -0.014668243937194347, 0.023478519171476364, 0.06262969970703125, 0.015058845281600952, -0.032340846955776215, -0.0033927627373486757, -0.008886952884495258, -0.042907338589429855, 0.07724235951900482, 0.011509491130709648, 0.02000131830573082, 0.021613435819745064, -0.021685557439923286, 0.02844393253326416, 0.012133830226957798, 0.03073931857943535, 0.058004479855298996, -0.012858860194683075, -0.032896269112825394, -0.0053724427707493305, 0.00992310605943203, 0.06486774235963821, -0.0511445514857769, -0.027109233662486076, -0.0013596597127616405, -0.026072535663843155, 0.020779117941856384, 0.0014137914404273033, 0.009932421147823334, -0.05118325725197792, 0.08994079381227493, -0.07425674051046371, -0.019425202161073685, -0.041380248963832855, 0.007019467186182737, 0.004611464217305183, 0.008383494801819324, -0.014052248559892178, 0.03337249904870987, 0.03049270622432232, 0.024637626484036446, -0.02542373165488243, -0.01173061691224575, -0.038578398525714874, 0.028554925695061684, -0.02345203049480915, -0.04072381183505058, 0.03795427083969116, 0.05071527883410454, -0.0348910428583622, 0.05777918919920921, -0.024296455085277557, -0.02503114566206932, 0.04386528953909874, -0.03786080703139305, 0.017421193420886993, -0.038331881165504456, -0.020717130973935127, -0.0034376545809209347, 0.0020755829755216837, -0.016403596848249435, 0.041306618601083755, -0.053176455199718475, 0.04655022546648979, 0.06516722589731216, 0.030435124412178993, -0.008579298853874207, -0.04480797424912453, 0.003725728252902627, 0.020244954153895378, -0.04081135615706444, -0.016215752810239792, -0.04663631319999695, -0.026559798046946526, 0.024847708642482758, -0.004146776162087917, -0.031165288761258125, 0.0026476795319467783, 0.059985723346471786, -0.01918540894985199, 0.02910127118229866, 0.04149201512336731, -0.014835666865110397, -0.03690509498119354, -0.00863722525537014, -0.0010936694452539086, 0.02603631094098091, 0.011851334944367409, -0.0011685076169669628, 0.005790672730654478, 0.058497119694948196, 0.004935684148222208, 0.010112241841852665, 0.03202670067548752, 0.005521912127733231, -0.023040518164634705, -0.0196633692830801, -0.05570352450013161, 0.05691464990377426, -0.048404090106487274, 0.0030878675170242786, 0.01302213966846466, -0.013768495060503483, -0.0022751542273908854, 0.017311131581664085, 0.020060252398252487, 0.017868680879473686, 0.028616759926080704, -0.03761252760887146, 0.04216922074556351, -0.00685062725096941, -0.02345096506178379, 0.03346940875053406, -0.02692878246307373, -0.01940339431166649, -0.09301962703466415, 0.03604632243514061, 0.023306896910071373, 0.022479316219687462, 0.015689782798290253, -0.005239814054220915, -0.013060935772955418, 0.009305574931204319, -0.0380471795797348, 0.024234896525740623, 0.045248448848724365, -0.013590021058917046, -0.03610856086015701, -0.010777896270155907, -0.04477609321475029, 0.05362526699900627, -0.020144755020737648, -0.020229820162057877, 0.03021603636443615, -0.013014184311032295, -0.042349811643362045, -0.026829369366168976, -0.008909018710255623, 0.008572257123887539, -0.007027361076325178, -0.02833518199622631, 0.037279509007930756, 0.025319503620266914, -0.03717203438282013, -0.03638172894716263, -0.0652124434709549, -0.015995211899280548, -0.028360866010189056, 0.0113390376791358, 0.026945648714900017, -0.017930032685399055, 0.01623450219631195, 0.03243141621351242, 0.013090081512928009, 0.011788404546678066, -0.05317218229174614, -0.05455975979566574, 0.036600787192583084, 0.006021376233547926, -0.02408532425761223, 0.02272462472319603, -0.009872161783277988, 0.07356566935777664, 0.016477813944220543, -0.028999796137213707, -0.050907768309116364, -0.0069043622352182865, 0.0033990179654210806, -0.009809792041778564, 0.01926290988922119, -0.00031785652390681207, 0.04966622218489647, -0.001895786845125258, -0.017311941832304, 0.0250028595328331, 0.03166957572102547, 0.021479712799191475, 0.033334869891405106, -0.01789231225848198, -0.023913785815238953, -0.010186374187469482, 0.01149415411055088, 0.011068909429013729, -0.022752398625016212, -0.002998423995450139, -0.03388413041830063, 0.04083098843693733, -0.02257784642279148, -0.032712191343307495, -0.03469982370734215, -0.00474594347178936, 0.05991336703300476, -0.021617164835333824, 0.005400473717600107, 0.018419861793518066, 0.00013194729399401695, 0.02256225049495697, 0.04477399215102196, 0.03532906249165535, -0.023110784590244293, -0.0002207599172834307, 0.05346991866827011, -0.019108040258288383, -0.010494454763829708, 0.03690282255411148, -0.025855202227830887, -0.01215820200741291, -0.0023679931182414293, -0.03086191974580288, -0.010500472970306873, 0.0546659491956234, 0.03372028097510338, 0.013589663431048393, 0.004342914558947086, -0.05062452703714371, 0.07932296395301819, -0.051388636231422424, 0.019889505580067635, 0.009643886238336563, 0.05019700154662132, 0.0012509559746831656, 0.03715493902564049, 0.008009935729205608, 0.010182016529142857, 0.05036092922091484, -0.02982957474887371, -0.09574277698993683, -0.005251825321465731, 0.01208917424082756, -0.0017456508940085769, -0.022929545491933823, -0.0040099299512803555, 0.0209195539355278, -0.023430144414305687, 0.010987093672156334, 0.0049698445945978165, 0.0019479290349408984, -0.01309147197753191, 0.04206829518079758, -0.010878115892410278, 0.037566572427749634, -0.0018950223457068205, -0.021280935034155846, 0.047361280769109726, -0.01996489241719246, 0.012520948424935341, 0.019440600648522377, -0.0027745605912059546, -0.02610737271606922, -0.035074763000011444, 0.010255294851958752, -0.006256743799895048, 0.035723134875297546, 0.04435642436146736, 0.052275948226451874, -0.04051198065280914, 0.0009331880137324333, -0.05195779725909233, 0.009153366088867188, 0.03316744789481163, 0.005741221364587545, -0.03573771193623543, -0.013836567290127277, 0.007090178783982992, -0.0102155152708292, 0.0279704499989748, 0.021581675857305527, -0.000497372995596379, 0.06800151616334915, 0.015848301351070404, -0.03984680771827698, 0.031200023368000984, 0.05045151337981224, 0.040844228118658066, -0.002535057021304965, -0.024856865406036377, 0.009239000268280506, -0.007920605130493641, 0.014986853115260601, 0.053142935037612915, 0.0031163222156465054, 0.019538411870598793, -0.013475422747433186, 0.02878127247095108, -0.028215013444423676, -0.0052995746955275536, -0.01446996908634901, 0.034316033124923706, 0.02743675746023655, 0.007765615824609995, -0.03343990072607994, -0.00962817668914795, 0.05263424664735794, 0.03363398090004921, 0.022366203367710114, 0.019863413646817207, -0.094806008040905, 0.027088722214102745, 0.053962238132953644, 0.01641109213232994, -0.052813801914453506, -0.007897578179836273, -0.04583311080932617, -0.0153740169480443, 0.04227391630411148, -0.04761040210723877, 0.002422694116830826, -0.004449410364031792, 0.018223734572529793, -0.013492153026163578, -0.018644314259290695, -0.015139084309339523, 0.016911234706640244, -0.030245693400502205, 0.01927252486348152, -0.02233021706342697, -0.02127142809331417, -0.02987959235906601, 0.033327747136354446, 0.011620530858635902, 0.07478028535842896, 0.010720144957304, 0.010569015517830849, 0.04779094457626343, 0.05589937046170235, -0.020249642431735992, 0.007509418297559023, 0.008674098178744316, -0.042821940034627914, -0.032802022993564606, 0.036031365394592285, -0.011223792098462582, -0.03377407789230347, 0.03476910665631294, 0.019705217331647873, -0.04409833252429962, -0.010860919021070004, -0.013977606780827045, 0.011698084883391857, 0.007437643129378557, -0.0053397235460579395, 0.052911825478076935, 0.025813257321715355, -0.00869869813323021, -0.00965948961675167, -0.07214795053005219, -0.014320394024252892, -0.015574121847748756, -0.061360254883766174, -0.04718846455216408, -0.02406044490635395, -0.012850288301706314, 0.03728414326906204, 0.01406361348927021, 0.017104504629969597, -0.016718950122594833, -0.01487243827432394, 0.0008141858852468431, 0.031075002625584602, -0.015910152345895767, 0.004052550997585058, -0.003951000981032848, -0.0003857107076328248, 0.00183962716255337, 0.0011580631835386157, 0.05048650875687599, 0.001347675221040845, -0.008281883783638477, 0.02487865835428238, -0.07311008870601654, 0.019200781360268593, -0.020107656717300415, -0.024079889059066772, 0.0311425868421793, 0.006061878055334091, -0.008951987139880657, -0.03797077387571335, 0.04024209454655647, -0.03432011604309082, -0.0479021817445755, -0.01651736907660961, 0.037800971418619156, -0.020377157256007195, 0.018363647162914276, -0.04818607121706009, 0.043930575251579285, -0.026472946628928185, 0.0005523556610569358, -0.05677918344736099, -0.0574888251721859, 0.013234147801995277, -0.011832826770842075, -0.040096133947372437, -0.030196767300367355, -0.025845225900411606, -0.0006069898954592645, 0.005776474718004465, 0.007216783706098795, 0.0410948172211647, -0.02958049438893795, -0.004793084226548672, -0.018557239323854446, -0.012532612308859825, 0.05631346255540848, 0.004503168631345034, -0.012628459371626377, 0.02530880831182003, -0.04542779549956322, -0.001078503904864192, 0.016386516392230988, -0.012837025336921215, -0.01994425244629383, -0.017164982855319977, -0.030445381999015808, -0.012336592189967632, 0.022150231525301933, 0.0332423634827137, -0.007205729838460684, -0.023167282342910767, 0.006677860394120216, 0.0038354084827005863, -0.029607681557536125, -0.0020560813136398792, -0.03629007190465927, -0.009997989982366562, -0.041248757392168045, -0.014228723011910915, -0.014909602701663971, 0.037000223994255066, 0.013312616385519505, -0.014418544247746468, -0.011414330452680588, 0.0024014159571379423, 0.048189692199230194, 0.029874825850129128, 0.017059246078133583, 0.010642942041158676, 0.010876973159611225, 0.04101170226931572, 0.047527868300676346, 0.0270290058106184, -0.051187388598918915, 0.0349477156996727, -0.05887278541922569, -0.0477333702147007, -0.028909383341670036, 0.005354711785912514, 0.017031872645020485, -0.022120585665106773, 0.027515094727277756, 0.02618877962231636, 0.010781027376651764, 0.005943631753325462, 0.009366702288389206, -0.017584318295121193, 0.005100169684737921, 0.003736862214282155, 0.07400857657194138, 0.018626870587468147, 0.006399702746421099, 0.013474520295858383, 0.018703507259488106, 0.01522062812000513, 0.08859618753194809, -0.020032785832881927, 0.023342791944742203, 0.006781423464417458, -0.0037343406584113836, -0.034850142896175385, 0.006739377975463867, -0.019874684512615204, -0.027284421026706696, -0.038866087794303894, -0.048208754509687424, 0.03256151080131531, 0.007077473681420088, 0.036670319736003876, -0.006992893293499947, -0.029511425644159317, -0.03583955764770508, -0.0223925169557333, 0.03175433352589607, -0.01456639263778925, 0.0024242782965302467, 0.014252343215048313, 0.040771905332803726, -0.020218318328261375, 0.06917627155780792, -0.07085777819156647, -0.07987264543771744, -0.020348038524389267, -0.022297373041510582, -0.011826473288238049, 0.03050893545150757, 0.027090927585959435, -0.023858297616243362, 0.009343770332634449, -0.0023371491115540266, -0.01435178704559803, -0.013028308749198914, 0.041494306176900864, 0.011232043616473675, 0.058342382311820984, -0.0037796413525938988, -0.014343863353133202, 0.004948848858475685, -0.0029542185366153717, 0.11341151595115662, 0.07203902304172516, 0.05494769662618637, -0.08902130275964737, 0.023937132209539413, 0.021634554490447044, -0.020244013518095016, -0.05327281355857849, -0.003946925979107618, 0.018829040229320526, -0.019957633689045906, 0.07643944025039673, 0.05188805237412453, 0.001722925459034741, 0.02768189087510109, 0.046193014830350876, -0.05306198447942734, -0.005439008120447397, -0.000210096244700253, 0.018711594864726067, 0.0007045459351502359, -0.027217041701078415, -0.08341940492391586, 0.029068993404507637, 0.03881556913256645, -0.02423248253762722, -0.016389764845371246, 0.012622459791600704, -0.026634205132722855, 0.009341091848909855, -0.03840628266334534, 0.03200707957148552, -0.004691524431109428, 0.03431243821978569, 0.004754193592816591, 0.004078045021742582, 0.005238628480583429, -0.028122764080762863, -0.003385593881830573, 0.03595491498708725, 0.007960282266139984, 0.02173137292265892, -0.0039081391878426075, 0.008203881792724133, -0.03148824721574783, 0.00725040677934885, -0.006558171007782221, 0.040348462760448456, -0.009474074468016624, -0.012104112654924393, -0.003082457697018981, -0.005654688458889723, -0.0070898933336138725, -0.02967892587184906, -0.016867201775312424, 0.03267626091837883, 0.014297561720013618, -0.0033914376981556416, -0.020614508539438248, 0.014752416871488094, -0.0003291110915597528, -0.004793846048414707, 0.03133579343557358, 0.029445383697748184, -0.0187759418040514, 0.0045624468475580215, -0.030755851417779922, 0.03863999620079994, -0.02172759920358658, 0.014387953095138073, 0.026544621214270592, -0.007223131600767374, 0.001007893937639892, -0.019083818420767784, 0.053642384707927704, -0.0023924647830426693, 0.002985086292028427, -0.016271371394395828, 0.0033973841927945614, -0.004742464981973171, -0.0455084927380085, 0.018209222704172134, -0.04013526439666748, -0.01579500176012516, -0.04540020227432251, 0.01064945850521326, 0.03942710533738136, 0.026027357205748558, 0.026842696592211723, 0.020764369517564774, -0.030411791056394577, 0.05731526017189026, -0.016741666942834854, -0.051054228097200394, -0.02093484438955784, -0.04455235227942467, -0.01856614649295807, -0.012470494955778122, -0.021463310346007347, 0.028671061620116234, 0.024077357724308968, 0.009366224519908428, -0.020492739975452423, 0.03460511192679405, -0.014441282488405704, 0.009498963132500648, 0.015975771471858025, -0.07679229229688644, 0.026036929339170456, -0.017550557851791382, 0.05775486305356026, -0.034944284707307816, 0.004998675547540188, -0.0328107625246048, -0.03167570382356644, 0.02420390397310257, -0.03575639799237251, -0.055674631148576736, 0.04672873765230179, 0.007055412977933884, -0.021938404068350792, -0.032634053379297256, 0.028793757781386375, -0.05266505479812622, -0.017337646335363388, -0.005819875281304121, -0.024285096675157547, -0.01653888262808323, 0.013137856498360634, -0.07012901455163956, 0.015103698708117008, 0.0343303419649601, -0.03717581927776337, -0.006434600334614515, 0.030631758272647858, 0.010256635956466198, -0.00781781505793333, 0.06483249366283417, -0.0361783467233181, -0.0020801236387342215, 0.014361151494085789, -0.07833146303892136, -0.05071889981627464, 0.022521179169416428, -0.033839043229818344, 0.04716671258211136, -0.0014532508794218302, -0.02473125047981739, -0.05679870396852493, 0.05503985285758972, -0.018428172916173935, -0.000976508017629385, -0.029315292835235596, 0.03024924173951149, -0.008439258672297001, 0.016623176634311676, -0.02785363234579563, 0.0057626161724328995, -0.026202375069260597, -0.013090908527374268, 0.0690554603934288, 0.04218015447258949, -0.020197836682200432, 0.008578319102525711, 0.01714019477367401, 0.006457559764385223, -0.0014295043656602502, -0.02646121382713318, 0.017634473741054535, 0.02098962292075157, -0.02231692336499691, 0.02486882172524929, 0.018367869779467583, 0.04668581858277321, -0.08977445960044861, 0.00797708984464407, -0.025358373299241066, 0.04060683399438858, 0.013863682746887207, -0.02524891123175621, 0.032584309577941895, 0.003835424780845642, -0.04499560967087746, 0.0009170582634396851, 0.02381446212530136, 0.019208138808608055, -0.010003944858908653, 0.03434477746486664, -0.021916275843977928, 0.02618345618247986, 0.036133524030447006, 0.02072599157691002, 0.02991461381316185, 0.010173790156841278, 0.028213851153850555, -0.042792461812496185, -0.039059001952409744, -0.0055716754868626595, 0.021004825830459595, -0.06361370533704758, 0.036857686936855316, -0.026142343878746033, -0.014467157423496246, 0.00477677071467042, -0.01053997129201889, 0.03725023940205574, 0.02434350736439228, 0.041141994297504425, -0.009660808369517326, 0.07659792900085449, -0.006302569527179003, 0.020150188356637955, -0.0032559128012508154, 0.0014748210087418556, -0.01326130609959364, 0.0178222618997097, -0.02594638802111149, 0.031917184591293335, 0.028009144589304924, -0.0045276423916220665, 0.008285080082714558, 0.025095682591199875, 0.009920746088027954, 0.01676587015390396, -0.0023613320663571358, -0.01691698282957077, 0.009164929389953613, -0.008107976987957954, -0.014898503199219704, -0.03167048469185829, 0.04090220108628273, 0.05227009579539299, 0.007709908299148083, -0.017702361568808556, 0.009953588247299194, 0.01849980466067791, -0.029803449288010597, 0.001020427094772458, -0.0002166392805520445, 0.00891437940299511, -0.04183294251561165, -0.010501578450202942, 0.016742218285799026, -0.023063797503709793, -0.02961980737745762, -0.007140982896089554, -0.05613557994365692, 0.05010663717985153, -0.009439729154109955, -0.007911055348813534, 0.03851286694407463, -0.018849408254027367, 0.04286603257060051, -0.08935362845659256, 0.055585991591215134, -0.032808348536491394, 0.021257054060697556, -0.015021196566522121, 0.03307928517460823, -0.022719189524650574, 0.004995387978851795, 0.04086704179644585, -0.005619372706860304, -0.0050518405623734, -0.0166507288813591, 0.01822359301149845, 0.004483135417103767, -0.037570130079984665, 0.03530622273683548, 0.022063493728637695, -0.03154337778687477, -0.03535056486725807, -0.014929288998246193, -0.0017152264481410384, 0.007699820213019848, -0.012064172886312008, 0.02006985992193222, -0.006172922905534506, 0.011406896635890007, -0.01798146776854992, 0.011532907374203205, 0.0002842023968696594, -0.000755682063754648, 0.019104300066828728, -0.008635622449219227, 0.00935358740389347, 0.0658675953745842, 0.02872789464890957, -0.06672883778810501, 0.032390233129262924, -0.06792864203453064, -0.005331570282578468, 0.012401764281094074, -0.009504532441496849, -0.016216449439525604, -0.04448053985834122, 0.02160920388996601, 0.004166134633123875, -0.022398894652724266, -0.0010317069245502353, 0.011505719274282455, 0.02054392173886299, 0.0575275681912899, -0.00653099687770009, 0.008442246355116367, 0.0061746882274746895, -0.0069619459100067616, 0.01805337704718113, 0.009933742694556713, 0.0007402060437016189, -0.011504625901579857, -0.003045356133952737, -0.0014477254590019584, 0.0018838236574083567, 0.019451338797807693, -0.006837553344666958, 0.02053176425397396, -0.006932771299034357, -0.013939734548330307, -0.0075203427113592625, -0.014299195259809494, 0.049901604652404785, -0.003149036318063736, -0.001875263056717813, 0.023230940103530884, -0.03943737596273422, 0.010208227671682835, -0.04758768901228905, -0.00989082083106041, -0.028442807495594025, 0.014780507422983646, -0.045955706387758255, 0.040255311876535416, -0.018197450786828995, 0.005390239413827658, 0.02140645682811737, -0.026728186756372452, -0.0027551408857107162, -0.03965917229652405, 0.010710676200687885, -0.028473544865846634, 0.008183635771274567, -0.012379095889627934, -0.027365650981664658, 0.002183527685701847, -0.021519692614674568, 0.0022059280890971422, 0.05310794338583946, 0.01355560403317213, -0.06218957155942917, -0.019375566393136978, 0.008793850429356098, 0.021055147051811218, -0.07683253288269043, -0.018908126279711723, -0.03169264644384384, 0.005899603012949228, -0.017886130139231682, -0.04329843446612358 ]
<p>I have two dependent groups that could have a disease before and after a treatment. My sample size is 12214 subjects. Before the treatment, 7 of them had the disease and after the treatment 14 of them had the disease.</p> <p>Percentages of total sample are very low although the number of patients with disease doubled. Does it make sense that McNemar gives me a significant p-value here? Why?</p> <p>Here is my R code:</p> <pre><code>mat=matrix(c(12207, 7, 12200, 14),2) mcnemar.test(mat) </code></pre> <p>Is there any size test I can run after McNemar? Have I chosen the right test?</p>
73,820
[ -0.025330260396003723, -0.03060394711792469, 0.012294577434659004, -0.019403990358114243, 0.02902555651962757, 0.01291124988347292, -0.029521271586418152, -0.05334833636879921, -0.009410236962139606, -0.0018399528926238418, 0.025292009115219116, 0.00813030730932951, 0.033795759081840515, 0.00019888342649210244, 0.01709054224193096, 0.047201815992593765, -0.009762772358953953, 0.010976976715028286, -0.000022790876755607314, 0.04017612710595131, 0.0004671916540246457, 0.0017544996226206422, 0.02224678173661232, -0.020261311903595924, -0.006293843034654856, 0.0476372092962265, -0.006560193374752998, -0.026057083159685135, 0.035021621733903885, 0.06173967197537422, -0.008770642802119255, -0.0441116988658905, 0.04086613655090332, -0.003069806843996048, -0.021159160882234573, -0.01705312915146351, 0.0065679363906383514, 0.0021102873142808676, 0.004263352137058973, 0.03023216873407364, 0.026240035891532898, -0.01287152897566557, 0.009035062044858932, 0.019171949476003647, 0.0004356870776973665, 0.0672130435705185, -0.0028390639927238226, -0.05523271486163139, 0.07202032953500748, -0.04752147197723389, 0.09929215908050537, -0.0302573312073946, 0.05100540816783905, 0.008078217506408691, 0.007611246779561043, -0.03588559851050377, 0.03227495402097702, 0.09009133279323578, 0.004886828828603029, -0.044430557638406754, -0.021543653681874275, -0.028657158836722374, 0.00028629822190850973, -0.01764945313334465, -0.027598386630415916, -0.000052714622142957523, -0.03756182640790939, -0.01487409882247448, 0.04337470605969429, -0.017991604283452034, -0.00529149966314435, 0.01922633871436119, 0.023352956399321556, -0.029675418511033058, 0.00653016846626997, 0.016825087368488312, 0.02374601550400257, 0.028317321091890335, 0.025857005268335342, 0.04103678837418556, 0.013832945376634598, 0.013715988956391811, 0.018668370321393013, 0.030180610716342926, 0.042032476514577866, -0.028522999957203865, 0.004381066653877497, -0.02793481945991516, 0.02337508089840412, -0.0010462888749316335, -0.049841176718473434, -0.005084457341581583, 0.07889223843812943, 0.028351109474897385, -0.052491866052150726, 0.031038014218211174, -0.0400586761534214, 0.054100435227155685, 0.015806429088115692, 0.037713147699832916, -0.029185155406594276, -0.07223567366600037, -0.010892770253121853, 0.029506631195545197, -0.023664576932787895, -0.012866991572082043, -0.041848476976156235, -0.014862415380775928, -0.005793851334601641, -0.009850473143160343, -0.00964932981878519, 0.026994876563549042, 0.04464774206280708, 0.0005307155661284924, 0.02639513649046421, -0.01642996445298195, -0.03014991618692875, 0.01763913594186306, 0.0788494423031807, 0.0839826762676239, 0.021947024390101433, 0.022293010726571083, 0.03238968923687935, -0.05849079042673111, -0.016420699656009674, 0.046503644436597824, 0.008989963680505753, -0.013179571367800236, -0.04579829052090645, 0.06810066848993301, -0.015236865729093552, 0.008388747461140156, 0.028905382379889488, 0.01867567002773285, 0.051082950085401535, 0.02188200131058693, -0.06342984735965729, -0.03568801283836365, 0.053350407630205154, -0.03154278174042702, -0.0005694822175428271, -0.05094384774565697, 0.0002713147259783, 0.03299449384212494, 0.057787176221609116, 0.018979402258992195, 0.06250627338886261, 0.006850704550743103, 0.028786972165107727, 0.02160482108592987, -0.016271822154521942, 0.00279802642762661, -0.014329676516354084, -0.0007546917768195271, -0.03857411444187164, -0.1279262900352478, -0.00041265678009949625, 0.03953329846262932, 0.022574644535779953, 0.0025326251052320004, 0.04852711409330368, 0.02656317688524723, -0.001580879557877779, -0.04488865286111832, -0.03676019608974457, -0.015840327367186546, 0.06266419589519501, 0.021023496985435486, 0.026907185092568398, -0.0025871118996292353, 0.036194417625665665, 0.028155852109193802, 0.036553069949150085, 0.052245572209358215, -0.001394299790263176, 0.009437763132154942, 0.01159956119954586, 0.0457846038043499, 0.030897952616214752, 0.025156453251838684, -0.052904993295669556, -0.006828500423580408, -0.0465998537838459, -0.009564757347106934, 0.03350310027599335, 0.07089544087648392, 0.024129044264554977, -0.005169319454580545, 0.017038438469171524, -0.02410094439983368, -0.051627304404973984, -0.04734579473733902, 0.0038374988362193108, -0.029102079570293427, -0.05442418158054352, -0.008802481926977634, 0.02372279204428196, 0.010138235054910183, 0.03716142848134041, 0.007943760603666306, -0.019567377865314484, -0.0019122471567243338, 0.0077917445451021194, -0.0005048823659308255, -0.0012692154850810766, 0.048174113035202026, 0.06504935771226883, -0.03651181980967522, 0.011267928406596184, -0.029003094881772995, -0.013184892013669014, 0.04457010701298714, 0.0028829355724155903, -0.011454228311777115, -0.012060465291142464, -0.05210119113326073, 0.011203196831047535, -0.0077757160179317, -0.007941816933453083, 0.044512659311294556, -0.0369410365819931, 0.055386099964380264, 0.046831194311380386, -0.022710302844643593, 0.029451139271259308, -0.02220679633319378, 0.014305382035672665, 0.012714804150164127, 0.001092150923795998, 0.011908411979675293, -0.05077193304896355, -0.004590846598148346, 0.029519427567720413, 0.02039000391960144, -0.010866503231227398, 0.014980703592300415, 0.06973383575677872, -0.03139850124716759, -0.0033499374985694885, 0.014607728458940983, 0.022602982819080353, -0.038054343312978745, 0.030533215031027794, 0.02936861664056778, 0.03306347504258156, -0.0015883606392890215, 0.019832022488117218, 0.009212467819452286, 0.06347043067216873, 0.0033964202739298344, -0.0046583544462919235, 0.03564699366688728, -0.025940939784049988, -0.005105169489979744, -0.0034759051632136106, -0.02769467607140541, 0.0076851206831634045, 0.009704717434942722, -0.010515929199755192, -0.006761463358998299, 0.012800219468772411, 0.0005031112814322114, -0.02430487610399723, -0.026127908378839493, 0.0077096219174563885, 0.0406435988843441, -0.03963335230946541, -0.02294336073100567, 0.006395814009010792, -0.050295140594244, -0.009824962355196476, -0.01914278045296669, -0.022262774407863617, -0.05178024247288704, 0.04373079538345337, 0.029909852892160416, 0.008731787092983723, 0.04564807564020157, -0.010196339339017868, 0.012882592156529427, -0.0026992179919034243, -0.020610913634300232, 0.02930276468396187, -0.02946390025317669, -0.06153597682714462, -0.0052713011391460896, -0.024281874299049377, -0.0016610949533060193, 0.03638673946261406, -0.0250436719506979, -0.0016413411358371377, 0.008004173636436462, 0.027896534651517868, -0.003543836995959282, -0.06467850506305695, -0.030178898945450783, -0.012510864064097404, -0.00810195505619049, -0.05568656697869301, 0.05083797499537468, 0.018178990110754967, -0.006383436266332865, 0.010572045110166073, -0.019595598801970482, 0.0436389185488224, -0.014553162269294262, -0.0049678971990942955, -0.00021101307356730103, -0.008674007840454578, 0.01949441246688366, 0.005034522153437138, -0.027807801961898804, -0.027493154630064964, -0.07329254597425461, -0.02032027579843998, 0.02227383852005005, -0.006716414354741573, 0.03841300308704376, -0.004008826799690723, -0.043354254215955734, 0.038833137601614, 0.031568314880132675, -0.0024884850718080997, -0.016306573525071144, 0.02753492072224617, -0.060894325375556946, -0.01033969596028328, 0.02108745649456978, 0.026286808773875237, 0.03231317922472954, -0.0030723637901246548, -0.003275227965787053, 0.055552590638399124, 0.03384893015027046, 0.009201612323522568, -0.013465497642755508, 0.0176437608897686, 0.004543151240795851, -0.04061787202954292, 0.022159550338983536, 0.012863547541201115, 0.0022504099179059267, 0.03852403908967972, 0.013224853202700615, 0.023879894986748695, 0.002361675724387169, -0.05364026129245758, -0.02310854382812977, 0.02112768404185772, 0.022893117740750313, -0.029697176069021225, 0.0341854989528656, 0.010136672295629978, -0.01139809750020504, 0.008509982377290726, -0.003776642493903637, 0.035175349563360214, -0.029095744714140892, 0.02119865082204342, 0.04375053197145462, 0.01850791648030281, -0.02332366816699505, 0.012581411749124527, -0.0021379217505455017, -0.015386528335511684, -0.01592002436518669, -0.03411516547203064, -0.011878905817866325, 0.022845273837447166, 0.02661622315645218, 0.04586229473352432, -0.011242917738854885, -0.026992369443178177, -0.011752855964004993, -0.052694015204906464, 0.032879769802093506, -0.03941124305129051, 0.01903999038040638, -0.01604073867201805, 0.03477528318762779, 0.00832805410027504, -0.024004114791750908, 0.022265365347266197, -0.012452566996216774, -0.06708160042762756, 0.04627033323049545, -0.004522695671766996, 0.012516327202320099, 0.028104519471526146, -0.013365036807954311, 0.010933625511825085, 0.001506150932982564, 0.014786441810429096, 0.03006948158144951, 0.011402858421206474, -0.03111780621111393, -0.005402690730988979, -0.021198580041527748, 0.00307256611995399, 0.004475804977118969, 0.04989016056060791, 0.007036673836410046, 0.022792093455791473, 0.02046213671565056, 0.025309784337878227, -0.003050032537430525, -0.012386541813611984, 0.004425633233040571, 0.019551854580640793, 0.0071262698620557785, 0.04451724886894226, 0.06014551222324371, 0.041118521243333817, -0.03272201865911484, 0.011070524342358112, 0.003062556032091379, -0.0010980700608342886, -0.011354978196322918, 0.019973240792751312, -0.028502309694886208, -0.05452106520533562, -0.007998595014214516, -0.018146075308322906, -0.0073029883205890656, 0.03803854435682297, -0.03098081611096859, 0.03492354974150658, -0.014374190010130405, -0.05261877179145813, 0.021479083225131035, 0.06471002101898193, 0.015965323895215988, 0.00041467617847956717, -0.02702745608985424, 0.016894159838557243, -0.013598654419183731, -0.0005181971937417984, 0.024463362991809845, 0.03019837848842144, -0.014648186974227428, -0.02816534787416458, 0.02924622967839241, -0.04459947347640991, -0.018848299980163574, -0.0066962349228560925, -0.0036047070752829313, 0.03522779420018196, 0.025955036282539368, -0.027003489434719086, 0.021433712914586067, 0.013029116205871105, 0.022219175472855568, 0.008056510239839554, 0.0020902594551444054, -0.0841548889875412, 0.02408027835190296, 0.03219998627901077, 0.07614380866289139, -0.07873189449310303, 0.012183777987957, -0.05553041398525238, 0.005215211305767298, 0.021753353998064995, -0.04203817620873451, 0.03697902709245682, -0.014074834063649178, 0.025547247380018234, -0.04748780280351639, -0.027179332450032234, -0.04602372646331787, 0.03169572353363037, -0.03696512058377266, 0.011580482125282288, -0.03873557597398758, -0.03450304642319679, -0.030584821477532387, 0.004834655672311783, 0.009954185225069523, 0.057491205632686615, -0.03372155502438545, -0.028723236173391342, 0.01896466128528118, 0.018379131332039833, -0.02524419128894806, -0.045804429799318314, 0.00928147230297327, -0.02531888708472252, -0.01239983830600977, 0.021679949015378952, -0.0039941174909472466, 0.013580495491623878, 0.02443455532193184, -0.009959526360034943, -0.014619369991123676, -0.02663414366543293, -0.027540327981114388, -0.004243663512170315, -0.011533078737556934, -0.043877165764570236, 0.030198853462934494, 0.011389817111194134, 0.03179575130343437, -0.014538859948515892, -0.04443403705954552, 0.013085102662444115, -0.01802038587629795, -0.006232048384845257, -0.05587262287735939, 0.027945341542363167, -0.031812891364097595, 0.0660383328795433, 0.01735125109553337, 0.020768646150827408, -0.03452391177415848, -0.012614483013749123, 0.03270161896944046, 0.05300004035234451, 0.021864112466573715, -0.004925755318254232, 0.007655570283532143, -0.018156399950385094, -0.014174295589327812, 0.032653842121362686, 0.03042365051805973, -0.031172653660178185, 0.01930769346654415, 0.037134744226932526, -0.05966777727007866, 0.03169826418161392, 0.003260179189965129, -0.025831323117017746, 0.0016659550601616502, -0.054639607667922974, -0.005713662598282099, 0.011872145347297192, 0.022582484409213066, -0.02059256285429001, -0.03091447241604328, 0.02655106969177723, 0.022962624207139015, -0.006267158314585686, 0.03993654251098633, -0.06870236247777939, 0.04105066880583763, 0.010281214490532875, 0.018544349819421768, -0.08261924982070923, -0.05385822057723999, 0.011097969487309456, 0.015477736480534077, -0.007690068334341049, -0.029232367873191833, -0.021930808201432228, -0.017699861899018288, -0.0008557121036574244, -0.015550567768514156, 0.0595136359333992, -0.0072061181999742985, 0.0039061899296939373, -0.011304158717393875, 0.002345165004953742, 0.07909120619297028, -0.02239939011633396, 0.005555541720241308, 0.01013266947120428, -0.03400781750679016, -0.0064469873905181885, -0.004654621239751577, -0.022947201505303383, -0.024169640615582466, -0.03248751908540726, -0.056763697415590286, -0.011611082591116428, 0.06925313174724579, -0.011695505119860172, -0.01986704021692276, -0.01660548895597458, -0.012021468952298164, 0.03606459125876427, -0.014537900686264038, 0.005983313079923391, -0.06498943269252777, 0.007998494431376457, -0.014519530348479748, 0.017028886824846268, -0.027462344616651535, 0.01641163043677807, -0.02864794060587883, 0.007652601692825556, -0.020269623026251793, 0.02416861802339554, 0.0998438373208046, -0.024525539949536324, 0.022482125088572502, -0.02664071135222912, -0.01787109486758709, 0.006291613914072514, 0.016882820054888725, 0.0020206745248287916, -0.0029063429683446884, 0.016371652483940125, -0.062221597880125046, 0.004921603016555309, -0.02371812053024769, 0.013407444581389427, 0.04529828205704689, 0.014062028378248215, 0.026346391066908836, 0.024530628696084023, 0.0070462580770254135, 0.009741323068737984, 0.003828053129836917, 0.0028861097525805235, -0.02031809650361538, 0.008421467617154121, 0.04939150810241699, -0.01449388824403286, 0.01708332821726799, 0.05796322971582413, 0.025048458948731422, 0.009140071459114552, 0.03404306620359421, 0.024533793330192566, -0.01630004309117794, 0.040680188685655594, -0.041595879942178726, 0.002651796443387866, 0.06447338312864304, -0.040710341185331345, 0.037088967859745026, -0.06249798461794853, -0.015074435621500015, 0.061178822070360184, 0.05584403872489929, -0.022413622587919235, -0.021077875047922134, -0.0053777205757796764, -0.02798813208937645, -0.030857162550091743, 0.020347610116004944, 0.009705528616905212, 0.04874401539564133, 0.007165658287703991, 0.05099518969655037, 0.011473380029201508, 0.042080942541360855, -0.034242432564496994, -0.07580102980136871, -0.03115852177143097, -0.01682681031525135, -0.05151117965579033, 0.029289089143276215, -0.013849624432623386, -0.021398307755589485, 0.030278228223323822, -0.04823588952422142, 0.03291372209787369, -0.010023915208876133, 0.027761369943618774, -0.008731252513825893, 0.03283819556236267, -0.02179574780166149, 0.015133300796151161, 0.04228125140070915, -0.01958434097468853, 0.11977137625217438, 0.06788548082113266, 0.0030553529504686594, -0.05452403798699379, 0.06038951128721237, 0.014532861299812794, -0.006163483019918203, -0.05055679753422737, 0.0047560567036271095, 0.011434795334935188, -0.02515328675508499, 0.06891193240880966, 0.03346773982048035, 0.02140885591506958, -0.0036913827061653137, 0.03694463521242142, 0.014347809366881847, -0.02651294507086277, -0.0033920512069016695, 0.0037925115320831537, -0.03274078667163849, -0.012752749025821686, -0.03567906841635704, -0.008030887693166733, 0.013739235699176788, 0.014083858579397202, -0.023579278960824013, 0.003005438018590212, -0.030042482540011406, 0.022178662940859795, -0.0033435672521591187, -0.0009161054040305316, 0.0039931912906467915, 0.04259428381919861, -0.06156797334551811, -0.028861593455076218, -0.00497097335755825, -0.026366829872131348, -0.029729897156357765, 0.04889390245079994, -0.010350780561566353, -0.016108280047774315, -0.016874490305781364, 0.02337074466049671, -0.0480809323489666, -0.0429702028632164, -0.007311261724680662, 0.05653945356607437, 0.023195495828986168, -0.006153278052806854, 0.0008487971499562263, -0.022454503923654556, -0.0167290847748518, -0.0751514807343483, -0.03259873390197754, 0.037027791142463684, 0.016393110156059265, -0.037404272705316544, -0.018849121406674385, -0.031078802421689034, 0.004420023411512375, -0.025417353957891464, 0.022937379777431488, 0.055748049169778824, -0.04226290434598923, -0.017075907438993454, -0.03450120612978935, 0.027560610324144363, 0.0028111678548157215, 0.02478577010333538, 0.005787039641290903, -0.029619116336107254, -0.03133987635374069, -0.009244621731340885, -0.003813742659986019, -0.00016760308062657714, -0.007193866651505232, -0.014489998109638691, -0.013858247548341751, -0.024375271052122116, -0.005762672983109951, 0.015518796630203724, -0.025125673040747643, -0.008472482673823833, -0.045784302055835724, -0.0017849121941253543, 0.015496587380766869, 0.02498597651720047, 0.00011104464647360146, 0.029819710180163383, 0.017478033900260925, 0.027220888063311577, -0.0036553055979311466, -0.0786450207233429, -0.03326137363910675, -0.03352843225002289, -0.013411028310656548, 0.0016816116403788328, -0.037542883306741714, 0.03455277532339096, -0.013626789674162865, -0.018735822290182114, -0.0015533025143668056, 0.017660096287727356, -0.0332474522292614, 0.034526631236076355, 0.04061353951692581, -0.06444771587848663, -0.005746465642005205, -0.017418721690773964, -0.01711038313806057, -0.05064200237393379, 0.01528684701770544, -0.05227062106132507, -0.023938013240695, 0.010443775914609432, -0.04394271597266197, -0.01805279031395912, 0.00786200724542141, -0.005872995126992464, 0.03309888392686844, -0.00027912823134101927, -0.03285617008805275, -0.0265028178691864, -0.01659625954926014, 0.013231491670012474, -0.009918605908751488, -0.015019622631371021, 0.034001532942056656, -0.043655216693878174, 0.02259858325123787, 0.03516774624586105, 0.007814052514731884, 0.006077420432120562, -0.01507445890456438, 0.02542176842689514, 0.036841072142124176, 0.05490221455693245, -0.01960509456694126, 0.027306461706757545, 0.07853370159864426, -0.07016816735267639, -0.04232417792081833, -0.014259083196520805, 0.007148621138185263, 0.04308732971549034, -0.0076596722938120365, 0.012401821091771126, 0.008343180641531944, 0.020666971802711487, -0.02887849323451519, -0.008697833865880966, -0.02451767586171627, -0.008471604436635971, 0.02108144760131836, 0.0072876703925430775, -0.010425708256661892, 0.03620893880724907, -0.00462656794115901, 0.04089484363794327, 0.019671399146318436, 0.02639143168926239, -0.03315886855125427, 0.007338677998632193, 0.016042547300457954, 0.009244476445019245, -0.0023554277140647173, 0.0002459505049046129, 0.030300814658403397, 0.03066731058061123, -0.012730657123029232, -0.0014818337513133883, -0.03104688972234726, 0.004373086616396904, -0.10220907628536224, -0.01936279982328415, -0.027653547003865242, 0.006627490743994713, 0.014779995195567608, -0.03685791417956352, -0.01588805392384529, 0.00023086575674824417, -0.08700144290924072, 0.011098251678049564, -0.011535847559571266, -0.010535353794693947, -0.034794386476278305, -0.009451651014387608, -0.02592269331216812, 0.026036756113171577, 0.04597212374210358, 0.021913204342126846, 0.04079081490635872, 0.018608596175909042, 0.01933199167251587, -0.025344930589199066, -0.007762978784739971, 0.039770226925611496, -0.002319778548553586, -0.07869719713926315, 0.018521413207054138, -0.027066024020314217, -0.04502540081739426, 0.01744179241359234, -0.017627108842134476, 0.0741146057844162, 0.005532772745937109, 0.05102649703621864, 0.009031175635755062, 0.0368586964905262, 0.017399553209543228, -0.014331217855215073, -0.014064108952879906, -0.020021701231598854, -0.02546735480427742, 0.016043782234191895, 0.006677457597106695, 0.00007674317748751491, 0.02439337596297264, -0.022673683241009712, 0.019402382895350456, 0.015732355415821075, 0.0038094634655863047, -0.013954064808785915, -0.01055890042334795, -0.007838031277060509, -0.020459815859794617, -0.045902736485004425, 0.022990049794316292, -0.02502322569489479, -0.009258564561605453, 0.06859659403562546, 0.051197271794080734, -0.01628582552075386, 0.07128483802080154, -0.0058186715468764305, -0.010765778832137585, 0.012749195098876953, -0.02338300459086895, -0.006181794218719006, -0.048305753618478775, -0.004019677173346281, -0.005808892659842968, 0.0033974801190197468, -0.01936258003115654, -0.012189807370305061, -0.04390662908554077, 0.05816256254911423, -0.004476797301322222, 0.017405346035957336, 0.004311121068894863, 0.02730397880077362, 0.039372168481349945, -0.07854144275188446, 0.004369797185063362, -0.03790096938610077, -0.003563810372725129, -0.052047792822122574, -0.026194164529442787, -0.03130133077502251, 0.00813503097742796, 0.027873720973730087, 0.02279396913945675, 0.0026480841916054487, -0.01735510863363743, 0.024974342435598373, -0.013031077571213245, -0.08614078164100647, 0.039996206760406494, -0.0067309485748410225, 0.012856543995440006, -0.0326097197830677, 0.020923901349306107, 0.07113621383905411, 0.011103685013949871, -0.014508002437651157, -0.00883594062179327, -0.013817494735121727, -0.03266631066799164, -0.03110732138156891, 0.02135520987212658, 0.003864969126880169, -0.025721970945596695, 0.04380660504102707, 0.0029541817493736744, 0.03758362680673599, 0.043119169771671295, 0.019838277250528336, -0.030047496780753136, 0.007773505058139563, -0.027600139379501343, -0.006435377988964319, -0.006262632552534342, -0.015415585599839687, 0.008135801181197166, -0.03238383308053017, -0.002847847994416952, 0.0014747136738151312, -0.0111463638022542, -0.025985421612858772, 0.02596232108771801, 0.039145857095718384, 0.018811864778399467, -0.034487225115299225, 0.023891836404800415, 0.0007674007792957127, 0.003106971736997366, -0.03688076511025429, 0.0049827066250145435, 0.023933248594403267, -0.00466635636985302, 0.013706478290259838, 0.0643509104847908, -0.016262250021100044, -0.009037110954523087, 0.017019571736454964, 0.021183006465435028, -0.025715483352541924, -0.004154536873102188, 0.009569997899234295, -0.03031773678958416, 0.03950658440589905, -0.000257372681517154, -0.004736007656902075, 0.014493300579488277, -0.017228586599230766, -0.011177459731698036, 0.012243267148733139, -0.017758352681994438, -0.038938648998737335, 0.0023641835432499647, 0.008031155914068222, 0.0014654879923909903, 0.000022758767954655923, -0.009287279099225998, 0.016072019934654236, -0.015686262398958206, 0.010968304239213467, -0.03811680153012276, -0.005679368041455746, -0.02446373552083969, -0.025747481733560562, -0.004112080670893192, 0.030279265716671944, -0.005757446400821209, -0.041404854506254196, -0.0008866863790899515, 0.061275068670511246, 0.0023150125052779913, -0.029498551040887833, -0.02112865075469017, 0.048592302948236465, 0.07320301234722137, -0.03969845920801163, -0.03677916154265404, -0.052036408334970474, 0.00812985934317112, 0.014804755337536335, 0.005854511633515358 ]
<p>I paper I am trying to replicate used Eviews to estimate their state space model (by maximizing the associated maximum likelihood). They used the BHHH and Marquardt algorithms.</p> <p>My question is given that the Marquardt algorithm is generally used to solve least square type problems what is Eviews doing to allow it to be applied to maximum likelihood problems?</p> <p>1.) Does it change the Marquardt algorithm? If so how?</p> <p>2.) Does it reformulate the log likelihood maximization as a least squares problem? If so how?</p> <p>Baz</p>
36,322
[ -0.008551841601729393, -0.014774365350604057, -0.00140019366517663, 0.013831962831318378, 0.016633355990052223, 0.025138359516859055, -0.033717039972543716, -0.02857426181435585, 0.05261758714914322, -0.04544985666871071, 0.024999871850013733, 0.024115024134516716, 0.08652275055646896, 0.022570200264453888, 0.0378505140542984, -0.005921390373259783, -0.0075318580493330956, 0.06120874732732773, -0.030073845759034157, 0.005240189377218485, -0.05110461264848709, 0.003125963034108281, 0.030692698433995247, -0.018486617133021355, -0.009074210189282894, 0.04056837037205696, 0.021508535370230675, -0.017888598144054413, 0.022312460467219353, 0.025306424126029015, -0.021271338686347008, -0.027264947071671486, 0.00031056487932801247, 0.048892274498939514, -0.024087628349661827, 0.00673559820279479, -0.03044956922531128, -0.04771614074707031, 0.02535592019557953, 0.06566458195447922, -0.03879891335964203, 0.017796264961361885, -0.004420779179781675, 0.026000866666436195, -0.034763094037771225, 0.052438195794820786, -0.010081316344439983, -0.0033252588473260403, 0.009119336493313313, -0.03852921351790428, 0.06185774877667427, -0.03257158398628235, -0.023934124037623405, 0.03366116061806679, -0.01602916046977043, 0.006317464169114828, 0.05628257617354393, 0.05354006215929985, 0.03378297761082649, -0.0348806269466877, -0.011929335072636604, 0.014869362115859985, 0.018303558230400085, 0.006641725078225136, -0.03574685752391815, 0.012838821858167648, -0.005358394235372543, -0.005925289820879698, 0.057062555104494095, -0.004408702719956636, -0.01680031418800354, 0.022201599553227425, 0.037889882922172546, -0.02278061769902706, 0.03012879565358162, -0.013309934176504612, 0.0067133828997612, 0.0400126613676548, -0.004489128477871418, 0.024218261241912842, -0.03262297809123993, 0.012541480362415314, -0.002501789014786482, 0.04849722236394882, 0.02550286427140236, -0.005872119218111038, 0.077151820063591, -0.05093277618288994, 0.044763483107089996, -0.001393237616866827, -0.040831729769706726, 0.04348313435912132, 0.03209857642650604, 0.004253357648849487, -0.027761762961745262, 0.05169636383652687, 0.01310808677226305, 0.05812233313918114, 0.014468268491327763, -0.014021797105669975, 0.007153987884521484, -0.03953135758638382, -0.010653710924088955, 0.008059410378336906, -0.016647977754473686, -0.015520166605710983, -0.008043874055147171, -0.010910814628005028, -0.027355603873729706, -0.010458111763000488, -0.04710247740149498, 0.003022674936801195, -0.0028693024069070816, -0.006140963640064001, 0.028172453865408897, -0.023860061541199684, -0.0253828763961792, -0.03542649373412132, 0.01860029622912407, 0.060531795024871826, 0.07265491783618927, -0.024174856022000313, 0.009944518096745014, -0.016530796885490417, -0.059031084179878235, -0.018819468095898628, -0.022661497816443443, -0.00016543545643799007, -0.04459886625409126, 0.06774494051933289, 0.010115538723766804, -0.02278847061097622, 0.05967020243406296, 0.004588880576193333, 0.041659556329250336, 0.003035764442756772, -0.09321452677249908, -0.04748447239398956, 0.07263023406267166, -0.005528055597096682, 0.03492974117398262, -0.055025845766067505, -0.008594509214162827, 0.031299054622650146, 0.05125737562775612, -0.0211546178907156, 0.06580550968647003, -0.0027829145547002554, 0.04959460347890854, 0.0014154198579490185, -0.04397029057145119, -0.013443414121866226, -0.011275609955191612, 0.0001116875428124331, 0.0010598060907796025, -0.06107388809323311, 0.023071037605404854, -0.005356845445930958, -0.019875597208738327, -0.023293139412999153, 0.046620599925518036, 0.013208122923970222, -0.07158227264881134, -0.04672521725296974, -0.0036709809210151434, -0.028083860874176025, 0.04335532709956169, -0.010071441531181335, 0.04298988729715347, 0.016071325168013573, -0.026425927877426147, 0.03701381757855415, 0.00930775236338377, 0.032504744827747345, 0.048908475786447525, -0.01700413227081299, -0.041105594485998154, -0.02138429507613182, 0.02279350906610489, 0.02424558624625206, -0.02726701647043228, -0.011051645502448082, -0.024781741201877594, 0.010238420218229294, 0.005462333094328642, 0.06490848958492279, -0.006494190543889999, 0.006213376298546791, 0.04038092494010925, -0.0529789961874485, -0.03495536372065544, -0.061615295708179474, 0.0366048701107502, -0.019955774769186974, 0.028409278020262718, 0.04191560670733452, -0.023443836718797684, 0.03248056769371033, -0.009077704511582851, -0.013890785165131092, -0.02087293565273285, 0.012151297181844711, 0.00651189498603344, 0.0013252750504761934, 0.001933596096932888, -0.008886969648301601, 0.03909548372030258, -0.009899930097162724, 0.023057356476783752, -0.025675639510154724, -0.026074333116412163, 0.009077473543584347, -0.007801117841154337, 0.005869089625775814, -0.02001859061419964, -0.032827723771333694, -0.008964664302766323, -0.0013929863926023245, -0.019251050427556038, -0.009245586581528187, -0.03883889690041542, 0.02128177508711815, 0.08001004904508591, -0.023288464173674583, 0.02253137156367302, 0.03262794017791748, 0.01856493018567562, 0.027607906609773636, 0.027816815301775932, -0.003092482453212142, -0.05340093374252319, -0.013633336871862411, 0.00412330124527216, 0.007573796436190605, -0.04108019173145294, 0.004483860917389393, 0.008810637518763542, 0.0063516683876514435, 0.022385956719517708, 0.025557992979884148, -0.006298326421529055, 0.0005634589469991624, 0.017612159252166748, 0.048137255012989044, -0.002126159379258752, 0.003368699923157692, 0.02259775809943676, 0.00843122135847807, 0.030989740043878555, -0.024632606655359268, -0.03054799698293209, 0.07035675644874573, -0.032518528401851654, -0.023163186386227608, -0.05733921751379967, -0.030248628929257393, 0.03018484078347683, -0.009294007904827595, 0.01949583925306797, 0.023301448673009872, -0.0007066189427860081, 0.013714161701500416, -0.004517771769315004, -0.02786600962281227, -0.012417678721249104, 0.027783917263150215, -0.007942356169223785, -0.008339419960975647, 0.022145019844174385, -0.057143498212099075, 0.011087623424828053, -0.031217841431498528, -0.02408595010638237, -0.0038060895167291164, 0.038235943764448166, 0.022794324904680252, -0.009713034145534039, -0.004352615214884281, -0.01752760075032711, -0.0509876050055027, 0.013394119217991829, -0.0337081179022789, 0.036390163004398346, 0.012982113286852837, -0.040769558399915695, -0.021718179807066917, -0.034938912838697433, 0.031831469386816025, -0.013234241865575314, -0.0016854841960594058, 0.010693872347474098, -0.002454765373840928, -0.00028919184114784, -0.021324148401618004, -0.026517033576965332, -0.012412290088832378, -0.006678145844489336, 0.01872982271015644, -0.010345968417823315, 0.022149987518787384, 0.07041160017251968, 0.001947052194736898, 0.01142817921936512, -0.07882600277662277, -0.0037781239952892065, -0.019185354933142662, -0.010784891434013844, 0.012492712587118149, 0.010157309472560883, 0.03202179819345474, 0.04352463409304619, -0.023105692118406296, 0.006621501874178648, -0.0703381597995758, -0.07282175868749619, 0.010861855931580067, 0.012870763428509235, 0.036422111093997955, 0.018601534888148308, -0.030439523980021477, 0.07657811790704727, 0.01752825267612934, -0.06746911257505417, -0.014561113901436329, 0.023588871583342552, -0.009944633580744267, -0.032464031130075455, 0.017318423837423325, 0.02825251966714859, -0.0031106239184737206, 0.02331819385290146, -0.012162122875452042, 0.01778407394886017, 0.04322316125035286, -0.02406873181462288, 0.006275583989918232, 0.015217150561511517, 0.04066939651966095, 0.005101736169308424, 0.06126353517174721, 0.03933662176132202, 0.01357207540422678, 0.01821059361100197, 0.006066472269594669, -0.007668984122574329, 0.0002584264730103314, -0.02843751199543476, 0.07680810987949371, 0.004431040957570076, 0.006514562293887138, -0.05197093263268471, 0.03589161857962608, 0.04859582707285881, -0.05283408239483833, 0.00603093346580863, 0.009066842496395111, -0.006825024727731943, -0.009188720025122166, 0.0026979472022503614, 0.0097660506144166, 0.027920590713620186, 0.0006599850603379309, -0.0033497281838208437, -0.011645939201116562, 0.0013276704121381044, 0.01497132983058691, -0.0015196403255686164, -0.008218471892178059, 0.0517624132335186, 0.012214536778628826, 0.004836039151996374, -0.013575737364590168, -0.040114495903253555, -0.04251307249069214, -0.0864437073469162, 0.034749265760183334, 0.006096014752984047, 0.04183131828904152, 0.008152676746249199, 0.046548716723918915, -0.018316300585865974, 0.013700938783586025, 0.0441257543861866, -0.02361759915947914, -0.12706908583641052, 0.014585547149181366, -0.038597311824560165, -0.0024822556879371405, 0.03162921592593193, -0.03088248521089554, 0.0368228480219841, -0.024639802053570747, -0.007882540114223957, -0.019445518031716347, 0.0026135847438126802, -0.07218372076749802, -0.007170083466917276, -0.03394797071814537, -0.0034395046532154083, 0.0005811388837173581, -0.016141101717948914, 0.022879188880324364, -0.016086211428046227, -0.006410649977624416, 0.05662701278924942, -0.03143281117081642, -0.04102938249707222, -0.023537088185548782, 0.005295522045344114, 0.03145747631788254, 0.04530777782201767, 0.0425262376666069, 0.07453538477420807, -0.051745131611824036, 0.03061068430542946, 0.04615403711795807, 0.03878958150744438, 0.03588706627488136, 0.001351626473478973, -0.048403557389974594, -0.008896545507013798, -0.045745600014925, 0.007964111864566803, 0.04069392755627632, 0.04136667773127556, 0.014763511717319489, 0.049030642956495285, 0.0251111201941967, -0.016358641907572746, -0.011199746280908585, 0.037900637835264206, 0.005407136864960194, 0.020243840292096138, -0.01740368828177452, -0.025745229795575142, 0.020016521215438843, 0.018591200932860374, 0.03392579033970833, 0.0115336449816823, -0.012566561810672283, 0.0022962798830121756, 0.03970472142100334, -0.00979380588978529, -0.03923509269952774, 0.019681595265865326, 0.03101843222975731, 0.03357928246259689, 0.01698409765958786, 0.006848151329904795, -0.005804963409900665, 0.019030779600143433, 0.05072995647788048, -0.010893560014665127, -0.0031240673270076513, -0.07325248420238495, -0.01568218320608139, 0.022178705781698227, 0.03550206497311592, -0.03130779042840004, 0.01320019643753767, -0.0655394196510315, -0.015604994259774685, 0.03205081447958946, -0.00974996667355299, 0.02913503348827362, 0.013596898876130581, -0.008111707866191864, -0.02720090001821518, -0.029549160972237587, -0.05218997970223427, -0.014427648857235909, -0.02079489454627037, 0.01654478907585144, -0.019219795241951942, 0.005577866453677416, -0.028763391077518463, 0.020897066220641136, -0.010307558812201023, 0.04242873191833496, 0.008566878736019135, -0.0012445562751963735, 0.02854474075138569, 0.024089042097330093, -0.03455130383372307, -0.013259210623800755, -0.006116423290222883, 0.0392264686524868, -0.03790125250816345, -0.0028044262435287237, 0.03263410925865173, -0.0528348907828331, 0.029627075418829918, -0.0061472575180232525, -0.04332517087459564, -0.0576549656689167, 0.014423656277358532, 0.007090425118803978, 0.0492175817489624, -0.01671713963150978, 0.0377090647816658, 0.004672377835959196, -0.019072430208325386, -0.023951150476932526, -0.02537602186203003, 0.03546727076172829, -0.029161976650357246, -0.004844129551202059, -0.03445154428482056, 0.02531825192272663, -0.02182188630104065, 0.03188975155353546, -0.0007466008537448943, 0.06173093616962433, -0.047453463077545166, 0.0020447636488825083, 0.03741126507520676, 0.06507182121276855, -0.035267144441604614, 0.0014993564691394567, 0.02973286435008049, 0.04900892823934555, -0.003361755982041359, -0.03270837664604187, 0.019979579374194145, -0.030370773747563362, -0.015018414705991745, -0.0011839558137580752, -0.018568255007267, 0.027582524344325066, -0.025926662608981133, -0.020554091781377792, 0.04499942436814308, 0.0015141107141971588, 0.013091666623950005, -0.037559863179922104, 0.00012895753025077283, 0.043249018490314484, -0.05005937069654465, 0.00141622475348413, 0.00755707174539566, -0.02224077098071575, 0.0151451975107193, -0.016549021005630493, 0.018324706703424454, 0.00003704090340761468, -0.02084432542324066, -0.05578000098466873, -0.0520331971347332, 0.014734242111444473, 0.006189985666424036, -0.03641117736697197, -0.04351057484745979, -0.02035895362496376, -0.002073221141472459, -0.019603408873081207, -0.037367597222328186, 0.04079105705022812, -0.02223404310643673, -0.004544742405414581, 0.010414998978376389, 0.048637863248586655, 0.06361504644155502, 0.03960971534252167, 0.006877570413053036, 0.05873342603445053, -0.04202453792095184, -0.005269581452012062, 0.004160668700933456, 0.05145691707730293, -0.02474285662174225, -0.021467873826622963, -0.0056900824420154095, -0.0014023503754287958, 0.046656809747219086, -0.026286985725164413, -0.004313954152166843, 0.04054923355579376, 0.02224777638912201, -0.010341686196625233, -0.015722814947366714, -0.037131909281015396, -0.04123577103018761, -0.010151393711566925, -0.0005631488165818155, 0.004594956990331411, 0.017326228320598602, -0.01947363279759884, 0.0502341128885746, -0.002059729304164648, -0.015510013327002525, -0.0034786800388246775, 0.0557049997150898, -0.02275099605321884, 0.017263485118746758, 0.040237776935100555, -0.024497399106621742, 0.033447060734033585, 0.010106101632118225, 0.0136593421921134, 0.015529785305261612, 0.02224649488925934, -0.016573049128055573, -0.05249437689781189, -0.06004853919148445, 0.03509073331952095, 0.07191085815429688, -0.0068114991299808025, 0.05371840298175812, 0.02633694000542164, -0.005056002642959356, -0.009561633691191673, -0.07642260938882828, -0.016065100207924843, 0.007383414078503847, -0.014452907256782055, 0.04367957264184952, -0.028870265930891037, -0.022891538217663765, 0.0007071247091516852, -0.0005719638429582119, 0.00952383503317833, -0.006878329906612635, 0.030941080302000046, 0.03327476978302002, 0.03128752112388611, -0.008297797292470932, -0.023167025297880173, 0.04716590791940689, -0.03861697390675545, 0.0069346302188932896, -0.036966972053050995, -0.008274788968265057, 0.032383400946855545, 0.04245411604642868, 0.02744138054549694, -0.06666764616966248, -0.03213053569197655, -0.049888886511325836, 0.04419085755944252, 0.027710041031241417, 0.02562115341424942, 0.04296683520078659, 0.0008404928375966847, 0.0037539303302764893, -0.03286058083176613, 0.05615096166729927, -0.06638608127832413, -0.057476215064525604, -0.0182743351906538, 0.02614516206085682, -0.03321181237697601, 0.028243744745850563, -0.004299882799386978, -0.038539763540029526, 0.03710086643695831, -0.035069625824689865, 0.04035471752285957, 0.0010898227337747812, 0.040177199989557266, 0.0005958675756119192, 0.08511733263731003, -0.003951834049075842, -0.0007056028116494417, -0.021290715783834457, -0.00566698657348752, 0.13262027502059937, 0.06767183542251587, 0.04699808359146118, -0.06659270823001862, -0.01687566190958023, -0.0011231784010306, -0.021177371963858604, -0.03434433043003082, -0.009165078401565552, 0.009857753291726112, 0.02048696018755436, 0.0036524799652397633, 0.0026817794423550367, 0.02355208806693554, -0.025065071880817413, 0.014091080985963345, -0.03701907396316528, -0.06787668913602829, 0.037371791899204254, 0.01569930836558342, 0.006948670372366905, -0.008288130164146423, -0.03907640278339386, 0.023038247600197792, -0.03406526520848274, -0.06522200256586075, -0.006966870278120041, -0.035653311759233475, 0.003180759260430932, 0.004750225227326155, -0.026105893775820732, 0.03978503867983818, 0.016256321221590042, 0.021985217928886414, -0.017848828807473183, 0.021307287737727165, 0.009441543370485306, -0.011521623469889164, 0.03924039006233215, 0.05807124823331833, 0.014984306879341602, -0.017615465447306633, -0.00004887897739536129, -0.003351158695295453, -0.03516354784369469, -0.004536856897175312, -0.024025535210967064, 0.05351272225379944, -0.021349819377064705, -0.0025033378042280674, -0.010926849208772182, 0.002333547919988632, 0.0011866079876199365, -0.01766490377485752, -0.0012175582814961672, 0.017587197944521904, 0.015055338852107525, 0.015956789255142212, -0.012319975532591343, -0.030094292014837265, -0.02515403740108013, 0.01476521510630846, 0.019417064264416695, 0.014615933410823345, -0.04214155673980713, -0.00881809089332819, -0.022854728624224663, 0.05319342762231827, -0.04724760353565216, -0.03547458350658417, 0.0002045707224169746, 0.003486491274088621, -0.014803496189415455, -0.04655736684799194, 0.019785724580287933, 0.014817091636359692, 0.04588117450475693, -0.023992037400603294, 0.012181549333035946, -0.019078727811574936, -0.0758119523525238, -0.0024981286842375994, -0.0516635961830616, 0.03252016007900238, -0.032913025468587875, 0.00948521587997675, 0.07282527536153793, 0.018626471981406212, 0.011678348295390606, 0.0035391487181186676, -0.029237939044833183, 0.04133857041597366, -0.03265609219670296, -0.052689991891384125, -0.040692057460546494, 0.005761717911809683, -0.029468178749084473, 0.009639875963330269, -0.023391608148813248, 0.05896950885653496, 0.03481672704219818, 0.031145647168159485, -0.018355004489421844, 0.013457401655614376, 0.0014425107510760427, 0.028444752097129822, 0.00043589179404079914, -0.05879819393157959, 0.002743110526353121, -0.008002464659512043, 0.025512147694826126, 0.0007179261883720756, 0.002049599774181843, -0.012765627354383469, -0.018801121041178703, -0.014371257275342941, -0.03502325713634491, -0.027056537568569183, 0.03916437551379204, -0.005427884869277477, 0.010816622525453568, -0.008831693790853024, 0.0026884530670940876, 0.014982144348323345, 0.008182335644960403, -0.026839952915906906, -0.016102617606520653, -0.00048171679372899234, -0.030731407925486565, -0.04106398671865463, -0.03133945167064667, 0.04959859326481819, 0.017613865435123444, -0.0020937342196702957, -0.023984471336007118, -0.00022295677626971155, 0.02748808264732361, 0.05595775693655014, -0.025495268404483795, 0.013248623348772526, 0.017937658354640007, -0.04057891294360161, -0.02192249707877636, 0.00557468319311738, -0.019832637161016464, 0.00336073013022542, 0.020716356113553047, 0.023443900048732758, -0.047172077000141144, 0.015002311207354069, -0.008004030212759972, 0.017641520127654076, 0.005290195345878601, -0.03078065626323223, 0.013015404343605042, 0.005743064917623997, -0.005089153535664082, 0.027070339769124985, -0.011000183410942554, 0.0341954343020916, 0.03914501890540123, -0.007323029916733503, 0.004667793866246939, -0.01876758225262165, 0.010100144892930984, 0.012392469681799412, 0.013937490060925484, -0.00538452947512269, 0.03559982776641846, 0.033508848398923874, -0.009431581012904644, -0.023753898218274117, -0.01491057313978672, 0.013418866321444511, -0.09796104580163956, -0.01393912173807621, 0.015230908989906311, 0.006497485563158989, 0.05003152787685394, -0.06862641870975494, 0.018814923241734505, 0.012436693534255028, -0.05956309288740158, -0.014360782690346241, -0.014559521339833736, 0.005911700427532196, -0.04950390383601189, 0.018279647454619408, -0.02144664339721203, 0.04874427616596222, 0.032369405031204224, 0.002447297563776374, 0.04417470470070839, -0.002033734228461981, 0.0001577338989591226, -0.015921611338853836, 0.020689990371465683, 0.019489040598273277, 0.04398193582892418, -0.028014877811074257, 0.03722699359059334, -0.07760543376207352, -0.04727856069803238, 0.03253556787967682, -0.020712219178676605, 0.03363506868481636, 0.0022132431622594595, -0.002550732344388962, 0.010270534083247185, 0.020442083477973938, 0.055448442697525024, 0.028226209804415703, -0.00330003397539258, 0.006264649331569672, 0.009790842421352863, 0.05651372671127319, -0.0038400618359446526, 0.013285255990922451, -0.026350833475589752, -0.009584357030689716, -0.02352799102663994, 0.020966675132513046, 0.03877224400639534, -0.020426856353878975, -0.013660218566656113, -0.033971063792705536, -0.0063180881552398205, -0.005978579167276621, -0.0021703410893678665, -0.02566486783325672, -0.012509278953075409, 0.04557732865214348, 0.04211089015007019, -0.024217968806624413, -0.022104235365986824, -0.026604484766721725, -0.037189360707998276, -0.0019286231836304069, -0.02626773715019226, -0.01191966887563467, -0.03625015914440155, -0.032674092799425125, 0.02364799939095974, -0.004030715208500624, -0.04922659695148468, 0.0174625962972641, -0.0347825363278389, 0.049689993262290955, -0.02145129069685936, 0.005466428119689226, -0.025761907920241356, -0.009193834848701954, 0.0033774664625525475, -0.050932709127664566, 0.05757933482527733, -0.018467310816049576, -0.043959882110357285, 0.005123661365360022, -0.01938961260020733, 0.026033056899905205, -0.0022373751271516085, 0.05722961947321892, 0.0041519696824252605, -0.011914840899407864, 0.0011791633442044258, 0.01995524764060974, 0.0033385232090950012, 0.006436352152377367, 0.033687785267829895, -0.02490261010825634, -0.005290444009006023, 0.02015651948750019, -0.0010541122173890471, 0.004959645215421915, 0.017826711758971214, 0.016900718212127686, -0.022225329652428627, -0.01647903583943844, 0.002005499554798007, -0.04273857921361923, 0.007607928477227688, -0.01797541230916977, -0.01435839757323265, 0.021863194182515144, 0.006837365683168173, 0.005030103027820587, -0.002043583430349827, 0.000022878577510709874, -0.06343063712120056, 0.027688289061188698, -0.053804777562618256, -0.016780856996774673, 0.011804462410509586, -0.03294453024864197, 0.01307868305593729, 0.005464137531816959, -0.03947178274393082, 0.028758499771356583, -0.018490957096219063, 0.015621474012732506, 0.05365364998579025, 0.0027006505988538265, 0.0355457104742527, -0.0013814207632094622, 0.014085444621741772, 0.01755528897047043, 0.029158078134059906, 0.008488696068525314, 0.030335992574691772, -0.0012083693873137236, 0.0026900863740593195, 0.009791108779609203, 0.04365522786974907, -0.04719548672437668, 0.04629122093319893, 0.002238584915176034, -0.0037011229433119297, -0.034984711557626724, -0.010871977545320988, 0.03681614249944687, -0.03155595809221268, 0.010474958457052708, -0.04412953555583954, 0.007098033092916012, 0.08871057629585266, -0.048775773495435715, -0.0004834239953197539, -0.0315621942281723, 0.012557229027152061, -0.03072688914835453, 0.005483390297740698, -0.04612700641155243, 0.019020535051822662, 0.032273583114147186, 0.0012238388881087303, 0.027645256370306015, 0.015835532918572426, 0.03893018141388893, 0.01842649281024933, 0.010231563821434975, -0.03875241428613663, -0.025526246055960655, 0.03355539217591286, -0.022677775472402573, -0.043134208768606186, -0.021682258695364, -0.0008209521183744073, 0.02191564440727234, 0.029874298721551895, -0.011869605630636215, -0.050030142068862915, -0.040539760142564774, 0.03319385647773743, -0.043450504541397095, 0.013761592097580433, -0.030009251087903976, -0.02061377838253975, -0.009137019515037537, -0.035211529582738876 ]
<p>I'm really new to stats and R and I suspect I'm missing something obvious. I have a set of memberships all who start after a point in time (six months ago). I have done my query to estimate the number of days in the membership to today marking those still ongoing as censored. I've done my plot from the data so the max number is 180 days and the survival rate drops to zero for 180 days. Is this the best way to look at this data. I'm a bit unsure of the best approach. It's Kaplan's survival algorithm. Given that a lot of the memberships are ongoing/censored should the probability for 180 days be zero.</p>
73,821
[ 0.010695322416722775, -0.02817476913332939, 0.013684132136404514, 0.023921798914670944, 0.014219013042747974, 0.00017718660819809884, 0.022311773151159286, -0.027687918394804, -0.02327456884086132, -0.041998013854026794, 0.02348187379539013, 0.04580187797546387, 0.01006909180432558, 0.03628230094909668, 0.017052192240953445, -0.0012054909020662308, -0.027661757543683052, -0.00398006197065115, -0.008893534541130066, -0.00093455909518525, -0.024770589545369148, 0.015798671171069145, 0.0032326814252883196, -0.05182090029120445, -0.07428999990224838, 0.05569420009851456, 0.00217556138522923, -0.0038567082956433296, -0.04479379206895828, 0.06376572698354721, -0.0793033093214035, -0.05853607878088951, 0.030936304479837418, 0.023909466341137886, 0.03322305530309677, 0.015681283548474312, -0.05367574468255043, -0.04782938212156296, -0.034217797219753265, 0.011679966002702713, -0.037493303418159485, -0.014362122863531113, 0.00795939564704895, 0.026422955095767975, -0.008650732226669788, 0.023469103500247, -0.02247658185660839, -0.007750915363430977, 0.026812909170985222, -0.006213675253093243, 0.048461779952049255, -0.01480801310390234, 0.01987188681960106, 0.016989581286907196, -0.006019569467753172, 0.012328947894275188, 0.008384560234844685, 0.04327347129583359, 0.00657534459605813, -0.043696943670511246, -0.0009460625587962568, -0.03233655169606209, -0.010892227292060852, -0.0044331843964755535, -0.02341029979288578, 0.010857411660254002, 0.009190217591822147, -0.01020061131566763, 0.04000577703118324, -0.018060918897390366, -0.0164954736828804, 0.05753630772233009, 0.02932894416153431, 0.0008574500679969788, 0.01613701693713665, -0.005939753260463476, 0.000015050050024001393, 0.01380978524684906, 0.027160704135894775, 0.022270498797297478, -0.04921707883477211, -0.03712862357497215, -0.01499052532017231, 0.0600404292345047, 0.022374100983142853, -0.003142047906294465, 0.05378483235836029, -0.022230934351682663, 0.0389540009200573, 0.030734587460756302, -0.04239356145262718, 0.021066702902317047, 0.03881341964006424, 0.009560988284647465, -0.06801892817020416, 0.06991954892873764, -0.01394531037658453, 0.036916594952344894, 0.005582891404628754, -0.0024620203766971827, 0.01156232226639986, -0.07925058901309967, 0.01674274541437626, 0.02865229919552803, -0.05058363080024719, 0.004448777996003628, -0.02955116331577301, -0.04507018253207207, 0.017492782324552536, -0.05107906460762024, -0.046050094068050385, 0.02827790006995201, 0.02879338338971138, -0.023929929360747337, 0.006047881208360195, -0.023439835757017136, -0.019732501357793808, -0.008747560903429985, 0.05111480876803398, 0.04165267571806908, 0.027772635221481323, -0.0020267274230718613, 0.032098591327667236, -0.02283800020813942, -0.07070083171129227, 0.013972698710858822, -0.011925643309950829, -0.0340409055352211, -0.019364504143595695, 0.029497109353542328, 0.01410922221839428, -0.025937803089618683, 0.05976434797048569, -0.044577933847904205, 0.05996863543987274, 0.008681588806211948, -0.0680043026804924, -0.02396155521273613, 0.0129903145134449, -0.02597004547715187, 0.0026069364976137877, -0.04167477786540985, -0.017960095778107643, 0.01703953929245472, 0.039532411843538284, -0.004919571802020073, 0.05245211720466614, -0.02623746171593666, 0.015327908098697662, 0.00444692512974143, 0.0077984933741390705, 0.008594751358032227, -0.028381027281284332, -0.023884912952780724, -0.033708181232213974, -0.0714787095785141, 0.014548143371939659, 0.02705307863652706, 0.009406347759068012, -0.050520025193691254, 0.04374826326966286, -0.01050935871899128, 0.03181547299027443, -0.030587907880544662, 0.005504067055881023, -0.030190711840987206, 0.08199302852153778, 0.031284723430871964, 0.03101319447159767, -0.0031901253387331963, 0.018078546971082687, 0.04286247119307518, 0.03469059616327286, 0.029309118166565895, 0.028555382043123245, -0.03198856860399246, 0.030766934156417847, -0.02947661094367504, 0.03490496426820755, 0.02691595070064068, -0.019635414704680443, -0.002956988522782922, -0.01602093316614628, -0.017283331602811813, 0.026066331192851067, 0.016860924661159515, 0.006094985641539097, -0.03618872910737991, 0.028882432729005814, -0.007573443464934826, -0.02671007439494133, -0.07259703427553177, -0.00962013192474842, 0.0004605643334798515, -0.019895300269126892, -0.004063730128109455, -0.008879847824573517, 0.01812264509499073, -0.011174282990396023, 0.0043151709251105785, -0.010835915803909302, -0.014269626699388027, -0.0029370489064604044, -0.06979062408208847, 0.009792627766728401, 0.01897093839943409, 0.06348434835672379, 0.006205874960869551, 0.023059630766510963, -0.08230406790971756, -0.02157086506485939, -0.015615075826644897, -0.06026604026556015, 0.023151185363531113, 0.017522769048810005, -0.0003809373883996159, 0.021704889833927155, -0.03591332957148552, -0.0066159130074083805, 0.04403780773282051, -0.02138853445649147, 0.027630280703306198, 0.06481912732124329, -0.017763346433639526, 0.009081793949007988, -0.009373475797474384, 0.02281181327998638, 0.023886125534772873, 0.0034684878773987293, -0.05622880905866623, -0.06981039047241211, 0.015451828017830849, 0.04218997061252594, -0.04779898375272751, -0.015123716555535793, 0.01985337771475315, 0.050999850034713745, -0.018388545140624046, -0.002003535395488143, 0.011866355314850807, -0.01814756914973259, 0.03728942573070526, -0.0026254802942276, 0.02085607312619686, 0.0019689532928168774, -0.011472128331661224, 0.030031278729438782, -0.010605774819850922, 0.0473606176674366, 0.010202870704233646, 0.003039760049432516, 0.044188596308231354, 0.0012662814697250724, -0.0025646607391536236, -0.02858678624033928, -0.04131937026977539, 0.038393229246139526, -0.008524490520358086, -0.002447964623570442, -0.010114681906998158, 0.011108702048659325, 0.01194352749735117, -0.012747264467179775, -0.036450374871492386, 0.020461875945329666, 0.04664512351155281, -0.03723317012190819, 0.006194998975843191, 0.01800481416285038, 0.014553568325936794, -0.0038947665598243475, -0.034195948392152786, -0.09108742326498032, -0.01075322087854147, -0.00631397869437933, 0.034288015216588974, -0.010940978303551674, 0.03819565102458, -0.04416725039482117, -0.04530849680304527, -0.01388597209006548, -0.012586536817252636, 0.03956294804811478, 0.02200140431523323, -0.09060579538345337, -0.018619604408740997, 0.047094184905290604, -0.03954124450683594, -0.0015568092931061983, -0.03236296772956848, -0.0026707728393375874, 0.02322661317884922, -0.03449928015470505, -0.016418565064668655, -0.012086188420653343, 0.004253630992025137, -0.00042655912693589926, -0.022431636229157448, -0.0027157538570463657, 0.04887997731566429, 0.0015986771322786808, -0.03202337026596069, 0.013655418530106544, -0.08511574566364288, -0.016566110774874687, -0.00786768551915884, 0.014469515532255173, 0.028604082763195038, -0.0019275839440524578, -0.005036447197198868, 0.013705738820135593, -0.019971322268247604, -0.0005473875789903104, -0.07754494249820709, -0.07559609413146973, 0.04752517491579056, -0.04195030778646469, 0.015146722085773945, 0.03524055331945419, -0.001863929908722639, 0.08819672465324402, 0.04984566196799278, -0.010230972431600094, 0.017531903460621834, -0.006706241052597761, -0.03554578498005867, -0.014522659592330456, 0.002931669121608138, -0.00427350215613842, 0.05245078727602959, -0.0021162722259759903, -0.021789388731122017, 0.009392584674060345, 0.041431792080402374, 0.014518569223582745, -0.016118638217449188, -0.014764382503926754, 0.025520561262965202, 0.001357321278192103, 0.02872760035097599, 0.03592327609658241, -0.016090530902147293, 0.05110751464962959, -0.006996530573815107, 0.03106459602713585, -0.0066284597851336, -0.08012953400611877, 0.01162919495254755, -0.030345235019922256, 0.021386360749602318, 0.008348572999238968, 0.03548247367143631, -0.0008285434450954199, -0.013346041552722454, -0.010518158785998821, -0.003958147019147873, 0.021301904693245888, -0.03040727786719799, 0.015432885847985744, -0.0009434764506295323, 0.02586251124739647, -0.008116113021969795, -0.014296680688858032, -0.0016683569410815835, -0.015641719102859497, 0.01520064938813448, -0.02417803555727005, -0.011091000400483608, 0.013899197801947594, 0.004590112250298262, 0.033708605915308, -0.020443733781576157, -0.01227142196148634, -0.018305201083421707, -0.05329705774784088, 0.013920010067522526, -0.008101739920675755, 0.05256348103284836, 0.0029976179357618093, -0.021691948175430298, 0.008154247887432575, -0.005622467957437038, -0.030000275000929832, 0.05339588597416878, -0.040667202323675156, 0.0287206768989563, -0.024090493097901344, -0.018688073381781578, 0.0016353405080735683, -0.019948694854974747, 0.0569404773414135, 0.019132161512970924, -0.01781591586768627, -0.008833836764097214, 0.0100770965218544, -0.04842564836144447, -0.01028759777545929, -0.05645032599568367, 0.039484791457653046, -0.03365221247076988, -0.0010116567136719823, 0.04538087919354439, 0.033024709671735764, 0.06239278241991997, 0.04152665659785271, 0.006820046808570623, -0.009653930552303791, 0.002177266404032707, 0.014268317259848118, 0.06684473901987076, 0.024593038484454155, 0.02503407932817936, 0.02174593135714531, -0.01655329391360283, 0.02140323631465435, 0.0007516526966355741, 0.022024618461728096, 0.040461257100105286, -0.0018682393711060286, 0.014473842456936836, -0.03868681192398071, -0.008054058998823166, 0.003132080426439643, -0.035868048667907715, 0.001219266909174621, -0.023038972169160843, 0.06379832327365875, -0.0036862774286419153, -0.05684885010123253, -0.018197301775217056, 0.07311517000198364, 0.028835803270339966, -0.03240324929356575, 0.0007416615844704211, -0.013506785966455936, 0.01204486470669508, -0.014232459478080273, 0.025876369327306747, 0.03635171800851822, -0.01169726625084877, -0.00430769007652998, 0.044292327016592026, -0.006340432446449995, -0.040706880390644073, 0.0005711317644454539, -0.008383340202271938, 0.048674389719963074, 0.0074965753592550755, -0.0550851970911026, 0.03600209951400757, 0.032822344452142715, 0.02305234596133232, -0.0059943716041743755, 0.04474366456270218, -0.059406884014606476, 0.014042891561985016, 0.06936032325029373, 0.04103255644440651, -0.004577843006700277, -0.015572937205433846, -0.04683526232838631, -0.027706503868103027, 0.011689098551869392, -0.037958960980176926, -0.000625837012194097, -0.017700232565402985, 0.015424113720655441, -0.015158465132117271, -0.0215376615524292, -0.044911500066518784, -0.023762088268995285, -0.054922617971897125, 0.0498589463531971, -0.01746208406984806, -0.0010317926062271, -0.018792858347296715, 0.004451307933777571, 0.0009580749901942909, 0.049821481108665466, 0.00964499544352293, -0.0090849744156003, 0.04696047306060791, -0.0028186042327433825, -0.010929809883236885, -0.03915073722600937, 0.02843744121491909, -0.005270263180136681, 0.02912193164229393, 0.036151718348264694, -0.009467838332057, -0.003873318200930953, 0.046853817999362946, 0.05197037011384964, -0.019843261688947678, -0.015414384193718433, -0.02865517884492874, 0.007496143225580454, 0.0033650491386651993, -0.001276062917895615, 0.053723517805337906, 0.07067447155714035, 0.011576897464692593, 0.028131240978837013, -0.024915538728237152, 0.011498341336846352, -0.004011858254671097, 0.021226562559604645, -0.035077981650829315, -0.003973592538386583, -0.022734304890036583, -0.0007729617645964026, -0.005528496578335762, 0.026522301137447357, -0.04548735171556473, 0.019731735810637474, 0.03489164263010025, 0.002710328670218587, -0.007456766441464424, 0.008095715194940567, 0.017137514427304268, 0.021302321925759315, 0.013616889715194702, 0.006564107723534107, 0.03194490447640419, -0.055816832929849625, -0.019588837400078773, 0.01835249550640583, -0.05393276736140251, 0.031281840056180954, -0.006727963220328093, -0.05444316938519478, 0.040052108466625214, -0.008887524716556072, 0.001514865318313241, -0.01731519214808941, 0.02760901115834713, 0.004988962784409523, -0.007286095060408115, 0.017503807321190834, -0.007656807545572519, -0.006527032237499952, 0.009639737196266651, -0.01918564923107624, 0.07787923514842987, 0.025788564234972, -0.007606853730976582, -0.07449062913656235, -0.04837885499000549, 0.015508183278143406, 0.017503205686807632, -0.0472034215927124, -0.051379989832639694, 0.0222916342318058, 0.012225044891238213, 0.0022001126781105995, 0.010942244902253151, 0.012232562527060509, -0.004387639928609133, -0.009772708639502525, -0.008857043460011482, 0.03526207432150841, 0.03532423451542854, 0.02501314878463745, 0.006799560971558094, 0.02176823653280735, -0.031404249370098114, -0.03457999229431152, 0.002847075229510665, 0.027261074632406235, -0.021011076867580414, -0.00305301696062088, -0.04120980203151703, 0.004804873373359442, 0.0465700700879097, -0.02991095557808876, -0.045295313000679016, 0.009765245951712132, -0.013485156930983067, 0.04075879231095314, -0.027313781902194023, -0.010681436397135258, -0.049153558909893036, -0.00009400591079611331, -0.0048084137961268425, -0.009794356301426888, 0.017829298973083496, -0.03293837979435921, 0.004223087336868048, 0.00914036389440298, 0.00708747049793601, 0.032710812985897064, 0.06042616441845894, -0.04124307259917259, -0.004775841720402241, -0.007480685133486986, -0.02330411784350872, 0.013125980272889137, 0.04344501346349716, -0.011695201508700848, 0.025967484340071678, -0.010123568587005138, -0.028808485716581345, -0.016836807131767273, -0.0564441978931427, 0.014044356532394886, 0.0366818904876709, -0.006915553007274866, 0.01713051274418831, 0.019925899803638458, 0.03334761783480644, 0.018067121505737305, -0.03466596454381943, -0.004101762548089027, -0.013987747952342033, -0.018032344058156013, 0.043196335434913635, -0.05236684903502464, 0.004788412246853113, 0.02421908639371395, 0.020411938428878784, 0.036578595638275146, 0.047210443764925, 0.03924992308020592, 0.0005685647483915091, 0.02910175733268261, -0.017140770331025124, -0.0277849193662405, 0.027237536385655403, -0.008975109085440636, 0.032236721366643906, -0.0503363162279129, -0.0339486189186573, 0.00004623808854375966, 0.014008152298629284, 0.006892565172165632, -0.016081511974334717, -0.03485299274325371, -0.043565571308135986, -0.01151359360665083, 0.059162747114896774, -0.008350163698196411, 0.032667238265275955, 0.010056640021502972, 0.016882531344890594, 0.00993330404162407, 0.03373825550079346, -0.01880558393895626, -0.03191913664340973, 0.0033357273787260056, -0.02222917228937149, -0.0574922151863575, -0.01840786635875702, 0.0015648272819817066, 0.0009215199388563633, 0.01801571249961853, -0.03678974136710167, -0.0063773635774850845, 0.01458909921348095, 0.06485733389854431, 0.006271464750170708, 0.07611188292503357, 0.01293624471873045, -0.015489490702748299, 0.03221067786216736, -0.020999733358621597, 0.14059902727603912, 0.07476773113012314, 0.005958398804068565, -0.08034829795360565, 0.010036180727183819, 0.05505426228046417, 0.018604500219225883, -0.02625151164829731, 0.007056831382215023, 0.016034379601478577, 0.004010907839983702, 0.07781029492616653, 0.04017505794763565, -0.027342278510332108, 0.005651978310197592, 0.0606640949845314, -0.031814709305763245, -0.03677762299776077, -0.015101347118616104, 0.012581869028508663, 0.015326441265642643, -0.049796149134635925, -0.039127133786678314, 0.05035439506173134, 0.089637890458107, -0.039461683481931686, -0.00775533402338624, -0.024237951263785362, 0.00613625580444932, 0.0058680446818470955, -0.009628981351852417, 0.02348407544195652, 0.009652584791183472, 0.012166589498519897, -0.024640504270792007, -0.005626184865832329, 0.0009684747783467174, -0.013183871284127235, 0.030108146369457245, 0.05208555981516838, 0.011115851812064648, 0.0059968349523842335, 0.008458293974399567, 0.00028799817664548755, -0.05828070640563965, -0.05106261372566223, -0.0486539825797081, 0.03024069033563137, -0.002171143190935254, 0.013172656297683716, 0.0063489265739917755, -0.00957340095192194, 0.04048747569322586, -0.0369449183344841, -0.025248359888792038, 0.003204136621206999, 0.015315080061554909, -0.020142782479524612, 0.016260024160146713, -0.013975678943097591, 0.012388186529278755, -0.011847277171909809, 0.010060813277959824, 0.05150982365012169, -0.022025149315595627, -0.039332833141088486, -0.04399922117590904, 0.016179528087377548, -0.027434999123215675, 0.004035998601466417, 0.005933897104114294, -0.008507386781275272, 0.015496688894927502, 0.011780825443565845, -0.006256838329136372, 0.015111408196389675, 0.030996276065707207, -0.049567341804504395, 0.0009102339972741902, -0.005422892980277538, -0.032268352806568146, 0.010965822264552116, 0.018560253083705902, -0.0012754659401252866, -0.014411521144211292, -0.009851506911218166, 0.02880130708217621, 0.03508033603429794, 0.008972524665296078, 0.030067091807723045, 0.020892079919576645, 0.07217130810022354, 0.013211825862526894, -0.029888099059462547, 0.0017036068020388484, -0.00454727141186595, -0.05572054535150528, 0.01012745313346386, -0.011945758014917374, 0.047905053943395615, -0.009492065757513046, 0.04035565257072449, 0.004835472442209721, 0.004050427116453648, 0.006639835890382528, 0.021633418276906013, 0.007485907059162855, -0.08365944772958755, 0.04161810502409935, -0.012096143327653408, 0.004136621952056885, -0.05694897845387459, -0.06121990829706192, -0.017056776210665703, -0.002970574889332056, 0.008436276577413082, -0.01094649638980627, -0.0254062432795763, 0.036305032670497894, 0.007209832780063152, -0.019481690600514412, -0.0332612581551075, 0.0032826182432472706, -0.05804425850510597, -0.024158580228686333, -0.00981818325817585, 0.01880049891769886, -0.018792519345879555, -0.027052562683820724, 0.026695193722844124, -0.004327043425291777, 0.01988975889980793, 0.003986744210124016, -0.0071072205901145935, -0.03613515570759773, 0.04084423556923866, 0.004587508738040924, 0.03754077106714249, -0.025312433019280434, 0.0022893636487424374, 0.03466903418302536, -0.04703045263886452, -0.00863258820027113, 0.019722329452633858, 0.01705588772892952, 0.009532441385090351, -0.02638085000216961, -0.033616818487644196, 0.020786229521036148, 0.028396757319569588, -0.03888832405209541, -0.02532532997429371, -0.030938943848013878, 0.00902542658150196, -0.006577112711966038, 0.007081981282681227, -0.03924471139907837, 0.04848461598157883, 0.02819845825433731, 0.009120799601078033, 0.06480863690376282, -0.028721824288368225, -0.023091400042176247, -0.02781905233860016, 0.0031139072962105274, 0.0017975311493501067, 0.019613200798630714, -0.010213535279035568, 0.033962052315473557, 0.04588049650192261, -0.0006362695712596178, 0.055933985859155655, -0.014133712276816368, -0.01628279685974121, -0.0749274417757988, 0.006079728249460459, -0.002368596149608493, 0.03002982959151268, 0.026140475645661354, -0.05527257174253464, -0.024788083508610725, 0.05044946074485779, -0.01600492000579834, 0.012353078462183475, -0.012867559678852558, 0.011105824261903763, -0.05983525142073631, 0.039945147931575775, -0.014908808283507824, 0.041316334158182144, 0.047564078122377396, 0.019801020622253418, 0.04518123343586922, 0.015389067120850086, -0.0038520481903105974, -0.039391107857227325, 0.005035885609686375, 0.041820209473371506, 0.023852389305830002, -0.07485564053058624, 0.030318733304739, -0.037216007709503174, -0.034709516912698746, 0.005232283379882574, -0.03895801305770874, 0.016506271436810493, 0.04978744685649872, 0.005424903705716133, 0.009933680295944214, 0.05056106671690941, 0.012769104912877083, -0.04717433452606201, -0.030665680766105652, 0.009477290324866772, 0.014971300028264523, 0.03125220164656639, -0.03667503595352173, 0.010745283216238022, 0.030121032148599625, -0.023858284577727318, -0.05252213403582573, 0.013992893509566784, 0.004946054890751839, -0.001437919563613832, -0.02659156545996666, -0.013036289252340794, 0.01611044816672802, -0.02048685774207115, 0.023981306701898575, -0.038517262786626816, -0.0014379979111254215, 0.07431137561798096, 0.03843820467591286, 0.02375364489853382, 0.010159537196159363, -0.050068601965904236, -0.07247353345155716, 0.016136275604367256, 0.03193807974457741, -0.01107281818985939, -0.017974350601434708, -0.002243118593469262, -0.06210196763277054, -0.019058221951127052, -0.01064404845237732, 0.024065811187028885, -0.04494394361972809, 0.03427322953939438, 0.016884570941329002, 0.013052706606686115, 0.05237024277448654, -0.015483062714338303, 0.007140409201383591, -0.07501818239688873, 0.08861637115478516, 0.0035031710285693407, 0.0019358682911843061, -0.026665670797228813, -0.031145703047513962, -0.03642149269580841, -0.006066861096769571, 0.015727972611784935, 0.0031161904335021973, 0.00827455148100853, -0.004764702171087265, 0.019627036526799202, 0.008151255548000336, -0.044388655573129654, 0.025762900710105896, -0.019338328391313553, -0.006511925254017115, -0.015319588594138622, -0.006589510012418032, 0.0026045090053230524, 0.021468020975589752, -0.03570482134819031, -0.03807955980300903, 0.024190060794353485, 0.03695026785135269, -0.023636164143681526, 0.03711331635713577, -0.01063339039683342, -0.027715517207980156, 0.0474521778523922, 0.020191740244627, -0.0005878159427084029, 0.06897401064634323, -0.01701206900179386, -0.024244651198387146, 0.06342054903507233, -0.03285283222794533, 0.006836464162915945, 0.04079288989305496, -0.020809901878237724, -0.032853808254003525, -0.030314655974507332, -0.028583798557519913, 0.018766937777400017, -0.00804382935166359, 0.03477463871240616, -0.010964028537273407, -0.0034641262609511614, 0.04318631440401077, -0.016105130314826965, 0.02846600115299225, 0.023480938747525215, 0.0031459133606404066, 0.01328681968152523, -0.009747018106281757, -0.01254984736442566, -0.009608136489987373, 0.02823617309331894, 0.026416214182972908, 0.002883131615817547, 0.028084469959139824, -0.0226356852799654, 0.038917120546102524, -0.014487763866782188, -0.0099296560510993, -0.016147702932357788, 0.0026656128466129303, -0.016688384115695953, -0.01339755579829216, 0.0006546282093040645, 0.04742421209812164, -0.003188185393810272, 0.033535879105329514, 0.013147929683327675, -0.08844797313213348, -0.04002166911959648, 0.008836988359689713, 0.03585859760642052, 0.018128596246242523, -0.009805264882743359, 0.000749737024307251, -0.008725198917090893, 0.024145640432834625, 0.030272044241428375, -0.01727334037423134, 0.048413168638944626, 0.017213841900229454, -0.004577243700623512, -0.023159703239798546, -0.027765758335590363, -0.011080008931457996, -0.0402425117790699, 0.0103957150131464, 0.0629403218626976, 0.02080773003399372, -0.022313300520181656, -0.013656833209097385, 0.00993876438587904, 0.04959458112716675, -0.010324654169380665, -0.01845891773700714, -0.024807104840874672, 0.00027071835938841105, -0.0008738653850741684, -0.03862796351313591 ]
<p>I often hear the claim that Bayesian statistics can be highly subjective. The main argument being that inference depends on the choice of a prior (even though one could use the principle of indifference o maximum entropy to choose a prior). In comparison, the claim goes, frequentist statistics is in general more objective. How much truth is there in this statement? </p> <p>Also, this makes me wonder: </p> <ol> <li>What are concrete elements of frequentist statistics (if any) that can be particularly subjective and that are not present or are less important in Bayesian statistics?</li> <li>Is subjectivity <strong>more prevalent</strong> in Bayesian than in frequentist statistics? </li> </ol>
73,822
[ -0.030352424830198288, -0.020917022600769997, -0.0022695346269756556, -0.04863389953970909, 0.06150318309664726, 0.023458214476704597, -0.003452389035373926, 0.010446538217365742, 0.002841378329321742, -0.04006575793027878, 0.025984929874539375, 0.03343770653009415, 0.0501764640212059, 0.008750191889703274, 0.002324150176718831, -0.01715495064854622, -0.011277938261628151, 0.010470233857631683, -0.017502715811133385, 0.0067277224734425545, 0.02658720128238201, 0.04761120304465294, 0.04727324843406677, -0.028099752962589264, -0.03511887416243553, 0.004618613515049219, 0.03255802392959595, -0.0017561463173478842, 0.004709199070930481, 0.06741265952587128, -0.011021637357771397, 0.0013006349327042699, 0.003535989671945572, 0.044896647334098816, 0.0409458763897419, -0.028811972588300705, -0.013615516014397144, 0.023129988461732864, -0.0066835153847932816, 0.048052430152893066, -0.021113676950335503, -0.038635898381471634, -0.007849253714084625, 0.018646549433469772, -0.04620029032230377, -0.007248920854181051, 0.0189359188079834, -0.027575526386499405, 0.0010610587196424603, -0.043154001235961914, 0.020154565572738647, 0.026244185864925385, 0.010600634850561619, 0.06095978617668152, 0.006330752279609442, -0.008822889067232609, 0.0383414700627327, 0.07688654959201813, -0.0185924731194973, -0.06831163167953491, -0.022039780393242836, -0.019916653633117676, 0.011118440888822079, -0.028271956369280815, -0.03571263328194618, 0.028764430433511734, -0.01616528443992138, -0.022860590368509293, 0.044506270438432693, 0.009442772716283798, -0.010558592155575752, 0.031142637133598328, 0.014593387022614479, 0.006286180578172207, 0.018250325694680214, -0.022470494732260704, 0.007157767191529274, 0.022825270891189575, 0.021034490317106247, 0.05422566086053848, 0.0010049990378320217, -0.024315010756254196, 0.026591796427965164, 0.045924946665763855, 0.029901117086410522, -0.018361138179898262, 0.061195358633995056, -0.022776400670409203, 0.003891266882419586, 0.0021776442881673574, -0.036834966391325, -0.00964793935418129, 0.009893919341266155, -0.008407402783632278, -0.08625706285238266, 0.04159663990139961, -0.027092304080724716, 0.041654083877801895, 0.02635769173502922, -0.036523763090372086, -0.01925935223698616, -0.013128332793712616, 0.039201054722070694, 0.07318560779094696, -0.036201294511556625, -0.05162765458226204, -0.03674955666065216, -0.00003135265797027387, -0.029952777549624443, -0.04318413883447647, -0.007852021604776382, 0.058439552783966064, 0.012967259623110294, 0.024942461401224136, 0.026531092822551727, -0.02714482694864273, 0.039735034108161926, -0.039443518966436386, 0.05139757692813873, 0.06430840492248535, 0.04561078920960426, 0.005088676232844591, 0.029209643602371216, -0.024642109870910645, -0.03940967097878456, -0.00008225875353673473, 0.023604968562722206, -0.012942536734044552, 0.011324181221425533, 0.0423039086163044, -0.027823833748698235, 0.013101081363856792, 0.04982380196452141, 0.03688789904117584, -0.005556579679250717, -0.010801134631037712, -0.0912165641784668, -0.022209331393241882, 0.07843951135873795, 0.007149674464017153, -0.024051571264863014, -0.07257167994976044, 0.0001721158332657069, 0.04069921374320984, 0.00009460115688852966, -0.0012150733964517713, 0.03203922137618065, 0.011196773499250412, 0.016797803342342377, -0.013983104377985, -0.0408259853720665, -0.03610440343618393, -0.003102768212556839, -0.006731428671628237, -0.024436185136437416, -0.08757977187633514, -0.01369111705571413, 0.006079490762203932, 0.017137998715043068, -0.020819688215851784, 0.04169338941574097, -0.01666693389415741, -0.022681880742311478, 0.008937100879848003, -0.018040580675005913, -0.0002576475089881569, 0.08921504765748978, 0.006347147282212973, 0.03571436181664467, 0.049772709608078, 0.008433726616203785, 0.02685835026204586, 0.040415652096271515, 0.031502366065979004, 0.033146798610687256, -0.052838414907455444, -0.036585915833711624, 0.02399660274386406, 0.03689345344901085, -0.011605418287217617, -0.006021488457918167, 0.023529179394245148, -0.02429703250527382, -0.036731746047735214, -0.0014971228083595634, 0.0153407147154212, 0.01818101666867733, -0.034764617681503296, 0.026688791811466217, -0.03626767545938492, -0.042154017835855484, -0.08711034804582596, -0.014741337858140469, 0.016228627413511276, -0.021860500797629356, 0.05808078870177269, 0.006694650277495384, 0.023774264380335808, -0.03008051961660385, -0.0013075636234134436, -0.02295501157641411, -0.014309531077742577, 0.019552553072571754, -0.029261598363518715, 0.01703566685318947, 0.05540916323661804, 0.025821944698691368, -0.006040419917553663, 0.027056895196437836, -0.02097661793231964, -0.09230787307024002, -0.014682807959616184, -0.018859809264540672, 0.006591496989130974, -0.006622281391173601, -0.01501715648919344, 0.013670835644006729, -0.02005860023200512, -0.02406947687268257, 0.024027857929468155, -0.05473385378718376, 0.08090527355670929, 0.03553047031164169, 0.00530354306101799, -0.007164079695940018, 0.029266351833939552, 0.007023366633802652, 0.0009894355898723006, -0.0016183072002604604, 0.009942698292434216, -0.05908504128456116, 0.040259696543216705, 0.07270962744951248, 0.03758172318339348, -0.01557392068207264, 0.031665317714214325, 0.007511087693274021, 0.051847197115421295, 0.0203913152217865, 0.038220394402742386, -0.013326689600944519, -0.05074428394436836, -0.0032380663324147463, 0.0013697752729058266, 0.02140590362250805, 0.012866716831922531, 0.030787305906414986, 0.02015889249742031, 0.04257722571492195, -0.021661808714270592, -0.0008217328577302396, 0.043088436126708984, -0.03912779688835144, -0.011766600422561169, 0.01514243520796299, -0.009269307367503643, -0.0069268797524273396, -0.027411626651883125, 0.00008722395432414487, 0.00326990126632154, 0.007547785062342882, 0.0031137801706790924, -0.011579672805964947, -0.026134464889764786, 0.031127311289310455, 0.022444501519203186, -0.05725504085421562, -0.00811849907040596, 0.00897950865328312, -0.00864617433398962, 0.005188923329114914, -0.03131236135959625, -0.0081859789788723, -0.01073739118874073, 0.008515805006027222, 0.0325409434735775, -0.010663112625479698, -0.004608757793903351, 0.0025269195903092623, -0.034214530140161514, 0.005548538640141487, -0.027992436662316322, -0.000985756516456604, 0.019698718562722206, -0.06141030415892601, 0.013218482956290245, -0.03391210362315178, -0.013636873103678226, 0.02240779995918274, -0.03826266899704933, -0.02789795771241188, -0.024441713467240334, 0.023200830444693565, -0.053425539284944534, 0.022423312067985535, -0.028528133407235146, 0.00017556140664964914, -0.03241511434316635, -0.022787122055888176, 0.01698886789381504, -0.0018354454077780247, 0.003775831777602434, 0.04170268774032593, -0.004268402699381113, -0.06359124183654785, -0.012333927676081657, -0.0034429964143782854, 0.018614092841744423, 0.008566492237150669, 0.02304193191230297, 0.01968666911125183, -0.06943347305059433, -0.018596794456243515, -0.06368989497423172, -0.07061081379652023, 0.04704277962446213, -0.0068427580408751965, 0.022721534594893456, -0.003034473629668355, -0.027636850252747536, 0.025769375264644623, 0.02824018895626068, -0.04572749882936478, 0.005003619473427534, 0.011613129638135433, -0.028387445956468582, 0.014806712046265602, -0.015354393050074577, -0.016413165256381035, -0.02013821341097355, 0.04210974648594856, -0.0018355058273300529, 0.02595924586057663, 0.0003400086716283113, 0.004474038723856211, 0.017094852402806282, 0.037901606410741806, 0.028558216989040375, -0.011096414178609848, -0.011535119265317917, 0.04134492948651314, -0.02398240938782692, 0.01641279086470604, 0.0007880747434683144, 0.022421393543481827, 0.02063640020787716, -0.02640374004840851, 0.02816822938621044, 0.016999714076519012, 0.020231038331985474, -0.04633989557623863, 0.026233425363898277, -0.01333968248218298, 0.026248430833220482, 0.007677140645682812, 0.022969303652644157, -0.006823561619967222, -0.017757520079612732, 0.017313946038484573, 0.05992377921938896, 0.04894605278968811, -0.032692622393369675, -0.028926584869623184, 0.004297418519854546, 0.018325142562389374, 0.032602496445178986, 0.0026601196732372046, 0.01393301784992218, 0.030449731275439262, 0.029798312112689018, 0.02540288120508194, -0.007294116076081991, -0.06367706507444382, 0.009955539368093014, -0.06781066209077835, -0.0014738872414454818, -0.008790271356701851, 0.01771591417491436, 0.008410715498030186, 0.027336249127984047, 0.001927034929394722, 0.005543730687350035, -0.03315677493810654, 0.005721561145037413, -0.05326502025127411, -0.00223744148388505, -0.03208240494132042, 0.005407721269875765, -0.0033289920538663864, -0.010190598666667938, 0.03913422301411629, -0.03549976646900177, -0.018072934821248055, -0.04204796254634857, 0.03978627175092697, -0.04724778234958649, 0.018515825271606445, -0.05500670149922371, -0.015519312582910061, 0.0052909948863089085, 0.03022182546555996, 0.016288362443447113, -0.029514778405427933, 0.04422754421830177, 0.016347818076610565, -0.021133292466402054, -0.031292352825403214, -0.0040894909761846066, 0.018699876964092255, 0.030394989997148514, 0.013827301561832428, 0.008293316699564457, 0.039802875369787216, -0.02052782103419304, 0.07072799652814865, 0.0238198135048151, 0.04956431686878204, 0.03860190883278847, -0.0453331358730793, -0.02386607602238655, -0.03902534022927284, -0.042651839554309845, 0.017614537850022316, 0.03446195274591446, 0.011545680463314056, -0.013082340359687805, 0.0526629276573658, 0.014616329222917557, -0.04776378348469734, 0.03960758447647095, 0.01427735760807991, -0.009630795568227768, -0.0005624698242172599, -0.02319006249308586, -0.018892986699938774, -0.02477138303220272, -0.008214323781430721, 0.057638321071863174, 0.01305240299552679, -0.02097238600254059, -0.005173936020582914, 0.003451430471614003, -0.03270424157381058, -0.036708295345306396, -0.004285183269530535, -0.00769760413095355, 0.009191603399813175, 0.023250948637723923, -0.02740340307354927, 0.019473623484373093, 0.02485126256942749, 0.03926188871264458, 0.03269791230559349, -0.005971652455627918, -0.06652361154556274, 0.010750463232398033, 0.03936034440994263, 0.02073018066585064, -0.0571134127676487, 0.02979801595211029, -0.03525003418326378, -0.005680328235030174, 0.06864908337593079, -0.028234414756298065, 0.0024609018582850695, -0.037001874297857285, 0.006842570845037699, -0.025284603238105774, -0.03784071281552315, -0.03110335022211075, -0.027229756116867065, 0.00031842270982451737, 0.036555834114551544, -0.01007949560880661, -0.02076858840882778, -0.04249778017401695, -0.014058103784918785, 0.004432882182300091, 0.05674163997173309, 0.026512252166867256, -0.015542563982307911, -0.019255856052041054, -0.011369137093424797, 0.0020806665997952223, -0.0653986856341362, 0.022086547687649727, 0.0005789098795503378, -0.019958171993494034, 0.02420808933675289, -0.011067272163927555, -0.03718489781022072, 0.015229715965688229, -0.0349578820168972, -0.05151652172207832, 0.03268897533416748, -0.0211184062063694, 0.04878987371921539, 0.01790899783372879, -0.00039465550798922777, 0.06255906820297241, -0.012941460125148296, -0.03218798711895943, 0.009062564000487328, -0.040229253470897675, 0.03901508077979088, -0.06488146632909775, 0.012684086337685585, -0.044495563954114914, -0.015841547399759293, -0.019022664055228233, 0.024812093004584312, 0.015566441230475903, 0.02068748138844967, 0.006413058377802372, -0.021620964631438255, -0.00838280189782381, 0.018148299306631088, 0.03474222123622894, 0.01825813576579094, -0.0261466633528471, 0.00288123800419271, -0.03047090582549572, -0.013339906930923462, 0.024430042132735252, 0.0021985431667417288, 0.01208769716322422, 0.006977257784456015, -0.039962418377399445, 0.016994452103972435, -0.0492747537791729, -0.017603710293769836, 0.020614316686987877, -0.05547194555401802, 0.03482566028833389, -0.0021264057140797377, 0.02121291682124138, 0.00995256844907999, -0.06702516973018646, -0.01593169756233692, 0.010713106021285057, 0.0015733178006485105, 0.05090037360787392, -0.02688666246831417, 0.011024984531104565, -0.016761111095547676, 0.021629182621836662, -0.08891009539365768, -0.0165175199508667, -0.004308855161070824, -0.004546568728983402, -0.04622499272227287, -0.013174261897802353, 0.03529730066657066, -0.012322277761995792, -0.00570227624848485, -0.0015930439112707973, 0.05322105810046196, 0.0017897007055580616, -0.021443063393235207, 0.0004743811732623726, 0.01740657538175583, 0.08051230758428574, 0.0036533691454678774, -0.0038241841830313206, 0.01638364978134632, -0.0028602052479982376, -0.003800733247771859, -0.002896927297115326, 0.02431832067668438, -0.015103095211088657, -0.03458474949002266, 0.0026921378448605537, 0.011715490370988846, 0.035098426043987274, -0.007313935086131096, -0.014385439455509186, 0.0358586423099041, -0.002192026237025857, 0.0018258903874084353, 0.0015985147329047322, -0.01743648201227188, -0.025864575058221817, 0.026389330625534058, -0.040130432695150375, -0.024518657475709915, 0.0043070390820503235, -0.04655807465314865, 0.03160632401704788, -0.0033442447893321514, -0.0069583686999976635, 0.020069092512130737, 0.04346185550093651, -0.004296913743019104, 0.004895043093711138, 0.00030902313301339746, -0.028072915971279144, 0.020112626254558563, -0.0077348207123577595, 0.005536628887057304, -0.0003998516476713121, -0.003326407168060541, -0.021481787785887718, -0.028808558359742165, -0.03948288410902023, -0.00518774101510644, 0.07551564276218414, 0.01391272060573101, 0.07126151770353317, 0.010367440059781075, -0.009686830453574657, 0.008045307360589504, -0.01977950893342495, 0.008865718729794025, -0.03333042562007904, 0.04258410632610321, 0.018082721158862114, -0.032076746225357056, -0.009884560480713844, 0.04676949605345726, -0.004173807334154844, 0.016764523461461067, 0.010798938572406769, 0.02577805705368519, 0.049011338502168655, 0.034810520708560944, -0.03339119628071785, -0.07305506616830826, 0.024023642763495445, -0.0640113428235054, 0.03621458262205124, -0.010262499563395977, -0.06595133990049362, 0.025004098191857338, 0.007993261329829693, -0.0040578763000667095, -0.04208165779709816, -0.03981385380029678, -0.032485928386449814, 0.04295052960515022, 0.004814875312149525, 0.052786730229854584, -0.0065477509051561356, -0.05262291431427002, 0.01824764348566532, -0.0025909829419106245, 0.01825590617954731, 0.005690761376172304, -0.08282357454299927, -0.05031081661581993, 0.008884120732545853, -0.019192613661289215, 0.017031706869602203, 0.003723122412338853, -0.031875863671302795, -0.001978668151423335, -0.04226313903927803, 0.02161225862801075, 0.03629046678543091, 0.039696767926216125, -0.02552974224090576, 0.0655984953045845, -0.02929581329226494, 0.0299212783575058, -0.011314292438328266, -0.004299209453165531, 0.11296624690294266, 0.0848618894815445, 0.029612157493829727, -0.045523304492235184, 0.05125173181295395, -0.011362247169017792, -0.006555423606187105, -0.008338363841176033, 0.03232895955443382, 0.017774071544408798, -0.011521936394274235, 0.003676388645544648, 0.03896993398666382, 0.01592276617884636, -0.04984399676322937, 0.06669937819242477, -0.04218433424830437, -0.0223618783056736, -0.020383350551128387, 0.005184861831367016, -0.01728181727230549, 0.012656685896217823, -0.07386891543865204, -0.02282542735338211, -0.00506956409662962, -0.03244122117757797, -0.017557166516780853, -0.02168137952685356, -0.047248125076293945, 0.016012398526072502, 0.005973248742520809, -0.03787385672330856, 0.03101140446960926, -0.027879197150468826, -0.025577504187822342, -0.009547133930027485, -0.02384929731488228, -0.020255591720342636, -0.013379818759858608, 0.02392052300274372, 0.026283208280801773, 0.007117788773030043, 0.007262845989316702, 0.051583047956228256, -0.04229884222149849, -0.00699499249458313, -0.010198883712291718, 0.026878690347075462, -0.02190779149532318, 0.008037306368350983, -0.030783357098698616, -0.027820110321044922, -0.0062886010855436325, -0.048831965774297714, 0.0060343253426253796, 0.024579662829637527, 0.03967324644327164, -0.01917216368019581, -0.03567715734243393, 0.013813411816954613, 0.04360431805253029, -0.01318299025297165, 0.0202295184135437, 0.029496053233742714, -0.03374992311000824, -0.06949176639318466, -0.014494912698864937, 0.01812012679874897, 0.023875528946518898, -0.0006398636614903808, 0.00927210133522749, -0.0038366136141121387, -0.06990010291337967, -0.01093419548124075, -0.022278867661952972, -0.03745126724243164, 0.05011497437953949, -0.014319555833935738, -0.0008520659175701439, 0.010457036085426807, -0.009168293327093124, -0.0015938942087814212, -0.017387650907039642, -0.015947071835398674, -0.013021246530115604, 0.03996245935559273, 0.03441069275140762, 0.012179335579276085, 0.02562086097896099, 0.02264527976512909, -0.03565765544772148, 0.025951184332370758, 0.004752759356051683, -0.043345119804143906, 0.009922444820404053, -0.008308970369398594, -0.02931908890604973, -0.005139383487403393, 0.02424520067870617, 0.05087415874004364, 0.03589610010385513, 0.014422453939914703, -0.006779736839234829, 0.01080052088946104, 0.008540838956832886, 0.007317541167140007, 0.005312398541718721, -0.04176385700702667, -0.008691664785146713, 0.015052884817123413, -0.0048402175307273865, -0.04467335715889931, -0.04188917577266693, -0.06147865578532219, 0.01838051900267601, 0.006932662334293127, -0.019137607887387276, -0.023825494572520256, 0.0037591925356537104, 0.039928026497364044, 0.042616382241249084, -0.030421150848269463, -0.010053684003651142, -0.0026283536572009325, -0.012619559653103352, -0.02831353433430195, 0.026037054136395454, 0.014622109942138195, 0.02623586356639862, -0.009194246493279934, -0.03574087843298912, 0.02668163552880287, 0.008436585776507854, 0.032361019402742386, -0.015547714196145535, 0.04854314401745796, 0.0014579801354557276, 0.05327795445919037, -0.03584419563412666, -0.029880935326218605, 0.046346522867679596, -0.044239435344934464, -0.048156775534152985, 0.02051112800836563, -0.0012824469013139606, 0.018623970448970795, 0.025642478838562965, -0.005119069013744593, -0.01702094078063965, 0.021721400320529938, -0.004717293661087751, 0.0056982990354299545, 0.01076490804553032, 0.01167651079595089, -0.020526813343167305, -0.027346055954694748, -0.005035564303398132, 0.007039948366582394, 0.012306157499551773, 0.030153850093483925, 0.015965430065989494, 0.011142841540277004, -0.008968527428805828, 0.00766451470553875, -0.015793748199939728, -0.012205611914396286, 0.01809011772274971, -0.017046833410859108, 0.035362835973501205, 0.03223612532019615, -0.03481840714812279, 0.05442507565021515, -0.029278350993990898, 0.0008791241561993957, -0.10398906469345093, -0.024602385237812996, 0.0209660604596138, 0.024567890912294388, 0.043653834611177444, -0.00955496821552515, 0.015896406024694443, 0.03235141187906265, -0.04324233904480934, 0.027122093364596367, -0.008534549735486507, -0.008129448629915714, -0.030849775299429893, -0.004817419219762087, -0.04881436750292778, 0.05269581452012062, 0.0038368196692317724, 0.018821636214852333, 0.0356452651321888, 0.022785460576415062, 0.025326445698738098, -0.014512530528008938, -0.036580201238393784, 0.050282932817935944, -0.03220343962311745, -0.04262895509600639, 0.053225718438625336, -0.013718548230826855, -0.018018078058958054, 0.051029082387685776, 0.04047834128141403, 0.03699614852666855, 0.015364327467978, 0.022827167063951492, 0.0235860925167799, 0.03842491656541824, 0.03293668106198311, 0.0014288472011685371, -0.03788824379444122, 0.011576310731470585, -0.012511612847447395, 0.03925330936908722, -0.005898038856685162, -0.004491419997066259, 0.027597250416874886, -0.03856320679187775, -0.0228817667812109, 0.019064094871282578, -0.004574573133140802, -0.038955625146627426, 0.01286609098315239, -0.0022822623141109943, 0.01493904646486044, -0.01962575688958168, 0.049178436398506165, -0.020962804555892944, -0.007687942124903202, 0.04767323657870293, -0.013977330178022385, -0.0015623446088284254, -0.021743465214967728, -0.008488530293107033, -0.04525722190737724, 0.010582027956843376, 0.00030985596822574735, -0.0050179786048829556, -0.044952236115932465, 0.003567830426618457, 0.013585446402430534, -0.0031543720979243517, 0.0027371938340365887, -0.04101281240582466, -0.047642782330513, 0.03907833248376846, -0.022420352324843407, -0.0010323190363124013, -0.008274031803011894, 0.007832944393157959, -0.02409396506845951, -0.07349234819412231, 0.0802728682756424, -0.021439524367451668, -0.0009361781412735581, -0.07024288177490234, -0.005848192609846592, 0.003185765352100134, 0.0010938565246760845, 0.06817424297332764, -0.0011839349754154682, -0.0074223605915904045, -0.0048608663491904736, 0.01905493438243866, 0.028765281662344933, -0.019371772184967995, 0.034285906702280045, -0.026995794847607613, -0.02059340476989746, -0.03412254899740219, -0.03855494037270546, -0.0032659361604601145, 0.03678988292813301, 0.028024420142173767, -0.019884072244167328, 0.011313543654978275, -0.016743773594498634, -0.000566726375836879, 0.0844435915350914, -0.0038436856120824814, -0.008911346085369587, 0.03412549942731857, -0.00978945754468441, 0.05413465201854706, 0.0016396642895415425, -0.010798126459121704, -0.021445807069540024, 0.027179425582289696, -0.004914143122732639, -0.06572552025318146, 0.0524912104010582, 0.03391118347644806, 0.020278971642255783, -0.05215014889836311, -0.03686506673693657, 0.049292027950286865, -0.05132291093468666, 0.005724554415792227, 0.02966383285820484, 0.015705741941928864, 0.036055389791727066, 0.007286557927727699, 0.03029761277139187, 0.001722353626973927, -0.017844049260020256, -0.0011403813259676099, 0.03083513118326664, 0.07129455357789993, 0.019888129085302353, 0.0391373485326767, 0.0556766614317894, -0.012500551529228687, 0.029777992516756058, 0.04589884728193283, 0.07840975373983383, -0.05255284905433655, -0.0019553357269614935, 0.0023155277594923973, 0.016368210315704346, 0.0007528589922003448, 0.000951010559219867, 0.018422262743115425, 0.0573703870177269, -0.016159234568476677, -0.005184841342270374, -0.022769581526517868, 0.0058320872485637665, -0.04047466814517975, -0.002119336975738406, 0.01098954863846302, 0.03616379201412201, 0.018586941063404083, 0.009497016668319702, 0.017015790566802025, 0.006426571402698755, 0.04325995221734047, -0.04366772621870041, 0.010832392610609531, 0.005164514295756817, -0.01557563990354538, -0.02274393104016781, 0.001804571831598878, -0.03865870088338852, 0.008218667469918728, 0.008914562873542309, 0.032701801508665085, 0.040376611053943634, 0.01136032585054636, -0.05487176775932312, -0.028289005160331726, 0.03866439312696457, -0.08197095990180969, 0.05570945143699646, -0.039973169565200806, 0.03820204362273216, -0.0033227044623345137, 0.016207868233323097 ]
<p>How to guess what should be the starting values for beta estimates, which we need to specify in PARMS or PARAMETERS statement while using PROC NLIN (PROC NLIN is used to run non-linear regression in SAS)</p>
30,769
[ -0.01911506988108158, -0.025128772482275963, -0.009602551348507404, 0.04143987223505974, 0.014769647270441055, 0.013381162658333778, -0.00010802695760503411, -0.01201244443655014, 0.050971731543540955, -0.054558902978897095, 0.020882267504930496, 0.03862916678190231, 0.02328306809067726, 0.001369229517877102, 0.01411362923681736, 0.005216273944824934, -0.01214059442281723, 0.00606935890391469, -0.02857394888997078, 0.010722961276769638, 0.016313543543219566, 0.017894333228468895, -0.009403713047504425, 0.016260964795947075, -0.03094303421676159, 0.04938146471977234, 0.03497008606791496, -0.043865129351615906, 0.004426088649779558, 0.06296011060476303, 0.015070824883878231, -0.03297971561551094, 0.06113078445196152, 0.01984463632106781, 0.007152757607400417, -0.016651341691613197, -0.02651778794825077, -0.013450137339532375, -0.0245684627443552, 0.05178969353437424, -0.0397220104932785, 0.000527183641679585, 0.03478867560625076, 0.006880827248096466, -0.0413052961230278, -0.011294813826680183, 0.02270282618701458, 0.005314224399626255, 0.02804773673415184, -0.03449602052569389, 0.03327754884958267, -0.0006695789052173495, 0.03945416584610939, 0.02026853896677494, -0.019650625064969063, -0.007651257328689098, 0.034395456314086914, 0.061444755643606186, 0.014235610142350197, -0.05412823334336281, 0.0019130641594529152, -0.02404266595840454, 0.01250430941581726, -0.03157107159495354, -0.02368568629026413, 0.03445807844400406, 0.003356696804985404, -0.004044731147587299, 0.008845397271215916, -0.016302412375807762, 0.03711031377315521, 0.0044458466582000256, 0.030163804069161415, 0.02809629589319229, 0.0220797061920166, -0.03672308102250099, 0.002953592222183943, 0.003637798363342881, 0.03385033831000328, 0.030376426875591278, 0.014748670160770416, 0.03999398648738861, 0.020790642127394676, 0.04760514944791794, -0.02066483162343502, -0.0025497584138065577, 0.04639113321900368, -0.042209506034851074, 0.04969809204339981, 0.03714771196246147, 0.03285496309399605, 0.006553352810442448, 0.05289522185921669, 0.01704336144030094, -0.042309898883104324, 0.021653195843100548, -0.015244625508785248, 0.039583634585142136, -0.021947667002677917, -0.0018801434198394418, 0.025074055418372154, -0.04240696132183075, 0.02460533007979393, 0.012888402678072453, -0.02278447151184082, -0.017081087455153465, -0.027095742523670197, -0.0016724142478778958, -0.004929922521114349, -0.05541183799505234, -0.0381971150636673, 0.044467493891716, -0.032272614538669586, 0.007898031733930111, -0.010512576438486576, -0.02020973712205887, -0.0327916294336319, -0.043911274522542953, 0.04825623705983162, 0.01065029762685299, 0.008815072476863861, -0.008581121452152729, 0.003011697204783559, 0.0015416956739500165, -0.04179791733622551, -0.0023777137976139784, -0.00977578666061163, -0.03467851132154465, -0.050666794180870056, 0.03711807355284691, 0.006928085815161467, -0.02396944910287857, 0.06207592040300369, 0.002739149844273925, 0.02033810503780842, 0.03206106647849083, -0.03643215075135231, -0.03417337313294411, 0.005178928840905428, -0.05008229985833168, 0.003759001148864627, -0.06747288256883621, 0.002367279725149274, 0.040647245943546295, 0.05376897379755974, -0.03253905847668648, 0.03939447179436684, 0.04870617762207985, -0.006705694366246462, -0.023917794227600098, -0.012692236341536045, -0.029900234192609787, -0.05443358048796654, -0.027461372315883636, -0.02542096935212612, -0.060317669063806534, 0.054941147565841675, 0.017407620325684547, -0.013328651897609234, -0.029428066685795784, -0.013757382519543171, 0.014842715114355087, -0.025795457884669304, -0.022511404007673264, 0.01275940053164959, -0.04607570171356201, 0.0672580897808075, 0.0025829258374869823, -0.003912062384188175, 0.02956019714474678, -0.04141177609562874, 0.018368784338235855, -0.026714222505688667, 0.022616364061832428, 0.07311695069074631, -0.024348396807909012, -0.012704395689070225, 0.002467990154400468, 0.01729961298406124, 0.0139464121311903, -0.04777305945754051, -0.0017450719606131315, -0.0021039117127656937, 0.011852660216391087, 0.024118509143590927, 0.045230716466903687, 0.0028177048079669476, -0.01088141929358244, 0.02341105230152607, -0.042928196489810944, -0.04359284043312073, -0.08370602130889893, 0.002387561136856675, 0.002492463681846857, -0.03439273685216904, 0.03775492683053017, 0.008868584409356117, 0.02436147630214691, 0.01751021109521389, -0.016253655776381493, -0.0745328739285469, -0.017494160681962967, 0.07337629050016403, -0.06355511397123337, 0.020994003862142563, 0.06701081246137619, 0.04392906278371811, -0.04264643043279648, 0.011750324629247189, -0.062349285930395126, -0.04043404385447502, 0.016215771436691284, -0.023024503141641617, 0.01515194308012724, -0.005298960953950882, -0.025215495377779007, -0.03056974709033966, -0.004463357850909233, 0.014167987741529942, 0.01222691684961319, -0.026173893362283707, 0.05945901200175285, 0.07736743986606598, 0.018489772453904152, -0.020142454653978348, 0.008321140892803669, 0.011390073224902153, -0.0019109888235107064, -0.045635469257831573, 0.009860651567578316, -0.03771521523594856, -0.03136551007628441, 0.035575661808252335, 0.007982644252479076, -0.04527847468852997, 0.011303393170237541, 0.0636528804898262, -0.023387566208839417, 0.003917735535651445, 0.045844126492738724, -0.01169954240322113, 0.009096628986299038, -0.017026422545313835, -0.005847066640853882, 0.04813201352953911, 0.025590527802705765, 0.011547661386430264, 0.055913690477609634, 0.03420798107981682, -0.004144580569118261, 0.007754050195217133, 0.05331074446439743, 0.041087932884693146, -0.025571417063474655, -0.016956640407443047, -0.05155254527926445, 0.08076935261487961, -0.009279122576117516, 0.006457972340285778, 0.047099191695451736, 0.018898656591773033, 0.017183955758810043, 0.053869981318712234, -0.01900044083595276, 0.01474593672901392, 0.014948504976928234, -0.034377481788396835, 0.017381740733981133, 0.02457713894546032, -0.048082780092954636, 0.06136907637119293, 0.005182201974093914, -0.01618850603699684, -0.008181358687579632, -0.003647653851658106, 0.015248199924826622, -0.002894551260396838, 0.03648168966174126, -0.035093873739242554, -0.0462026484310627, 0.0019659781828522682, -0.01210324838757515, 0.0008431984460912645, 0.011117427609860897, -0.047914836555719376, 0.007518605329096317, -0.00726677943021059, 0.00953795574605465, -0.0032732277177274227, 0.024181842803955078, -0.02257777750492096, 0.04703483358025551, -0.042819131165742874, -0.06553775072097778, -0.026998091489076614, -0.01857527531683445, -0.009191588498651981, -0.02775159850716591, -0.01816774718463421, 0.014710734598338604, 0.023451020941138268, -0.02895238623023033, 0.029963258653879166, -0.03271585330367088, 0.0021835858933627605, -0.04849303513765335, 0.019739383831620216, -0.009597161784768105, -0.010916891507804394, 0.02056100219488144, -0.02746264636516571, -0.025645365938544273, 0.021000847220420837, -0.054789602756500244, -0.057166457176208496, 0.013969484716653824, 0.046696145087480545, 0.006487588863819838, 0.025390461087226868, -0.010340646840631962, 0.08283249288797379, -0.02100747637450695, -0.027124525979161263, -0.05394571274518967, -0.005047881044447422, -0.03058747574687004, -0.05349782481789589, 0.014558072201907635, 0.03870166093111038, 0.030892830342054367, 0.007580405101180077, -0.007390398997813463, 0.021870065480470657, 0.0691954493522644, 0.011728595942258835, 0.02867830917239189, -0.022044919431209564, -0.013263167813420296, -0.03073365055024624, 0.041130661964416504, 0.021308831870555878, 0.00673066359013319, 0.01315347570925951, -0.028355272486805916, 0.023489713668823242, -0.006276803556829691, -0.031917911022901535, 0.018973715603351593, -0.030332481488585472, 0.00021721117082051933, -0.014485263265669346, 0.02568775974214077, 0.021483289077878, -0.028327861800789833, 0.029798833653330803, -0.014380467124283314, 0.024460947141051292, -0.04067197069525719, -0.0004962101811543107, 0.009726181626319885, -0.006939248647540808, 0.015338744036853313, -0.02021041512489319, 0.005569052416831255, -0.06119834631681442, -0.013594399206340313, 0.0005268554086796939, 0.010497408919036388, 0.03896236792206764, 0.04720588028430939, 0.016287047415971756, 0.010511406697332859, -0.05032367259263992, 0.0009338557138107717, -0.06378357112407684, -0.004892058204859495, -0.005589357577264309, 0.03765463829040527, -0.015414051711559296, 0.05310390517115593, 0.00594676798209548, 0.0074072228744626045, 0.021248118951916695, -0.010494248010218143, -0.0657859742641449, 0.024208925664424896, -0.036121949553489685, 0.0007701254216954112, 0.01691810041666031, -0.023520374670624733, 0.024966182187199593, -0.049741603434085846, 0.02215251512825489, 0.002458302304148674, 0.02780567668378353, -0.013636552728712559, 0.016918737441301346, -0.03731400519609451, 0.005863570142537355, 0.005396487656980753, 0.009849206544458866, 0.006032830569893122, -0.00014720499166287482, 0.02064119651913643, 0.06219073385000229, 0.019226115196943283, -0.004688045009970665, -0.04177939519286156, 0.015145235694944859, -0.010894116945564747, 0.04498456418514252, 0.03933084383606911, 0.018221627920866013, -0.05980744957923889, 0.019390709698200226, -0.008293249644339085, 0.0339958593249321, 0.07111677527427673, 0.0009983096970245242, -0.026140742003917694, -0.0072417850606143475, 0.02753552235662937, -0.00989399291574955, -0.0038047132547944784, 0.00017734483117237687, 0.010339293628931046, 0.05977826938033104, -0.0010656852973625064, -0.0282971803098917, 0.029048515483736992, 0.08641306310892105, 0.029539383947849274, -0.01556435227394104, -0.04914278909564018, -0.020154161378741264, 0.0018431439530104399, -0.019831662997603416, -0.015440003015100956, 0.007222750689834356, 0.009936033748090267, 0.012529248371720314, 0.016697658225893974, -0.05049179866909981, -0.0007037689792923629, 0.022683655843138695, 0.008248223923146725, 0.05353104695677757, 0.009484739974141121, -0.06793917715549469, 0.020653430372476578, 0.029515549540519714, 0.030413653701543808, 0.011797333136200905, -0.013228020630776882, -0.09533282369375229, -0.014615355059504509, 0.029134215787053108, 0.02988624945282936, -0.023647917434573174, -0.033022671937942505, -0.014961308799684048, 0.006275267340242863, 0.04312905669212341, -0.033793993294239044, 0.024960549548268318, -0.030112767592072487, 0.005544333253055811, -0.029943129047751427, -0.025078028440475464, -0.06825724244117737, 0.009313266724348068, -0.013545391149818897, 0.03164718672633171, -0.043665144592523575, 0.0039101894944906235, -0.03277251496911049, 0.005009494721889496, -0.0037784832529723644, 0.058793939650058746, -0.013022108934819698, -0.011962790973484516, 0.03015371970832348, 0.04254666343331337, -0.01386293675750494, -0.029226891696453094, 0.03603258356451988, -0.009482460096478462, -0.007877036929130554, 0.028731869533658028, -0.006356149446219206, -0.04737154394388199, 0.030488213524222374, 0.02482813224196434, -0.00886748917400837, -0.01042075827717781, -0.05684395134449005, 0.01711438037455082, 0.03124118410050869, 0.007449906785041094, 0.07918227463960648, 0.02879761904478073, -0.020352819934487343, -0.020677143707871437, -0.04556628689169884, 0.019647929817438126, -0.008027749136090279, -0.0343753956258297, -0.047749508172273636, -0.0011437402572482824, -0.021740298718214035, 0.03804145008325577, 0.00709620350971818, 0.017354445531964302, 0.010816780850291252, -0.005596261937171221, 0.03926977887749672, 0.035729940980672836, 0.028762906789779663, 0.016466334462165833, 0.00575529458001256, 0.017122598364949226, -0.006998725235462189, -0.013093443587422371, 0.009053816087543964, -0.008279701694846153, 0.023545410484075546, 0.022687500342726707, -0.0321938693523407, -0.001491305767558515, -0.024205083027482033, -0.0354590117931366, 0.027268383651971817, -0.04472378268837929, 0.005789363291114569, 0.019232014194130898, 0.00487917847931385, 0.02915755845606327, -0.023768702521920204, -0.028923112899065018, 0.039938755333423615, -0.02038448676466942, 0.008425666950643063, -0.045528363436460495, 0.051108986139297485, -0.0015497549902647734, 0.017191274091601372, -0.031148208305239677, -0.05323228985071182, 0.015418319962918758, 0.035384904593229294, -0.01580939255654812, -0.006512441206723452, 0.030175266787409782, -0.037701256573200226, -0.033600419759750366, -0.035926442593336105, 0.0502813458442688, -0.0061324178241193295, 0.0027061807923018932, -0.008524097502231598, 0.021555783227086067, 0.04949473962187767, -0.0027587939985096455, 0.0013187606818974018, 0.031273648142814636, -0.014076250605285168, -0.020439494401216507, 0.011822993867099285, -0.00988177489489317, -0.021718235686421394, -0.02611144818365574, -0.024411672726273537, 0.005045662634074688, 0.04897439479827881, 0.015960760414600372, 0.014322417788207531, -0.004967298824340105, -0.02066422440111637, -0.029146160930395126, -0.00597017165273428, -0.01643015630543232, -0.049772534519433975, 0.022163130342960358, 0.007836032658815384, -0.01559685543179512, -0.012253635562956333, 0.023482365533709526, 0.08259911090135574, 0.014915529638528824, 0.006088834721595049, -0.004177826922386885, 0.07876429706811905, 0.013728373683989048, 0.01678299717605114, 0.0014868698781356215, 0.007926884107291698, 0.04354991391301155, 0.04705054312944412, 0.01938566006720066, 0.017720598727464676, 0.0018612005515024066, -0.026458509266376495, -0.01628599874675274, -0.04232890531420708, -0.019005652517080307, 0.03671233355998993, -0.04209873452782631, 0.0036447264719754457, -0.01287502609193325, -0.014597599394619465, 0.011486757546663284, -0.039275702089071274, 0.004027236718684435, -0.04165026918053627, -0.0008770856657065451, 0.06595470011234283, 0.011336865834891796, -0.020289363339543343, 0.0025720419362187386, 0.005249396897852421, 0.03039098158478737, 0.023757847025990486, 0.015456633642315865, 0.03267321363091469, 0.01041504181921482, -0.04112396389245987, -0.021804869174957275, -0.0034253394696861506, -0.009149665012955666, -0.005952588282525539, -0.020388806238770485, -0.04263675585389137, 0.03840542957186699, 0.02804129756987095, 0.01346589345484972, -0.06274006515741348, 0.017111174762248993, -0.013215458020567894, 0.000639207661151886, 0.02269875817000866, -0.04052898660302162, 0.036702513694763184, 0.06892096251249313, 0.010684178210794926, -0.015875326469540596, 0.054133765399456024, -0.05710175633430481, -0.029558464884757996, -0.025438161566853523, -0.024420471861958504, -0.02195478044450283, 0.0348394550383091, -0.015620790421962738, -0.031687427312135696, 0.0165401678532362, -0.044414252042770386, 0.027851685881614685, -0.01142662949860096, 0.061870064586400986, 0.01837499812245369, 0.08195483684539795, -0.004405584651976824, -0.005148251075297594, -0.014057068154215813, 0.02682286687195301, 0.13475286960601807, 0.0962480679154396, 0.024160191416740417, -0.0978342667222023, -0.006975112948566675, 0.015362835489213467, -0.019054396077990532, 0.023674821481108665, -0.016597887501120567, 0.003029094310477376, -0.030120156705379486, 0.05023005232214928, 0.04806534945964813, 0.0006193913868628442, 0.05066613480448723, 0.02550463378429413, -0.05897815525531769, -0.008544174022972584, 0.05465212091803551, 0.0027916347607970238, -0.017001671716570854, -0.038502588868141174, -0.004573121666908264, 0.030970893800258636, 0.06113441288471222, -0.01619264855980873, 0.0037606116384267807, -0.02043255977332592, 0.023654762655496597, -0.005618116352707148, 0.004226387944072485, 0.008946014568209648, 0.012620724737644196, 0.031136702746152878, 0.025261739268898964, -0.038798119872808456, -0.0009496771963313222, -0.04832664132118225, 0.008126544766128063, -0.0010987829882651567, -0.0002560662687756121, -0.002072215313091874, -0.035267479717731476, 0.01060921885073185, -0.04801461473107338, -0.011941570788621902, -0.023739973083138466, 0.023668969050049782, -0.012085050344467163, -0.04138559848070145, -0.005918133072555065, 0.018597649410367012, 0.0071078455075621605, -0.06871334463357925, 0.010545224882662296, 0.009309804067015648, 0.0037771197967231274, -0.02382015250623226, 0.0030206802766770124, -0.00737555418163538, -0.01563679240643978, -0.002038903534412384, 0.045208171010017395, -0.007128175813704729, -0.049553968012332916, 0.024303236976265907, -0.02459494210779667, 0.06118613854050636, -0.0031997044570744038, 0.0029614560771733522, 0.028903774917125702, -0.004573852755129337, -0.038336385041475296, -0.005330788437277079, 0.02342093549668789, -0.036021675914525986, 0.031057246029376984, -0.024352282285690308, 0.0244431234896183, -0.023800013586878777, -0.04875800013542175, 0.020173227414488792, -0.027117827907204628, 0.011072770692408085, -0.0918286070227623, 0.0024890941567718983, 0.030407574027776718, 0.053951386362314224, -0.007308229338377714, 0.02606389671564102, -0.03918389976024628, 0.036161158233881, 0.006822635885328054, -0.08623508363962173, 0.022268403321504593, 0.04756786674261093, -0.016543136909604073, 0.029032869264483452, -0.03462518751621246, 0.0849914625287056, 0.0027017216198146343, 0.04234069213271141, -0.027000268921256065, 0.021467134356498718, -0.012208505533635616, -0.003749210387468338, -0.024207906797528267, -0.048903923481702805, -0.02168331854045391, -0.007732009049504995, 0.01617235690355301, -0.04066300019621849, -0.030697524547576904, -0.036947332322597504, -0.03002850152552128, 0.022728972136974335, -0.005193923134356737, -0.028218062594532967, 0.05513722822070122, -0.014050091616809368, -0.020371442660689354, -0.018757786601781845, -0.002151183784008026, 0.025646226480603218, 0.02702707052230835, 0.0022416531573981047, 0.005509128328412771, 0.011921449564397335, -0.025035163387656212, -0.05177847295999527, -0.021996501833200455, 0.030575184151530266, 0.03271353244781494, 0.04075958952307701, 0.00888032652437687, -0.005578729789704084, -0.021448945626616478, 0.02075820043683052, -0.03413889929652214, -0.03164460510015488, -0.009731121361255646, -0.034964531660079956, -0.05876728519797325, -0.009714644402265549, 0.0316937193274498, 0.005373410880565643, 0.038957033306360245, 0.008283334784209728, 0.0009829667396843433, 0.016532529145479202, -0.04094676673412323, -0.01629767194390297, -0.002528047887608409, 0.014011369086802006, 0.00913226418197155, 0.022926578298211098, 0.03617916256189346, 0.02092835120856762, -0.026141079142689705, 0.022967061027884483, 0.020080363377928734, -0.02911246195435524, -0.005326995626091957, 0.024062838405370712, 0.008814595639705658, -0.004679657984524965, -0.006000819616019726, 0.015028944239020348, -0.024515768513083458, 0.033450350165367126, -0.03129817917943001, 0.056647587567567825, 0.0025847447104752064, -0.010178891941905022, -0.08867868036031723, -0.01549135148525238, -0.016765350475907326, -0.009971542283892632, 0.026914352551102638, -0.0696411058306694, 0.05566968023777008, 0.06343872845172882, -0.03176093101501465, -0.007799684535712004, 0.031981460750103, 0.015185131691396236, -0.010425686836242676, 0.012784596532583237, -0.02013094164431095, 0.006109938956797123, 0.03673897311091423, -0.00792797189205885, 0.020411638543009758, -0.001094904146157205, -0.012461917474865913, -0.02667725831270218, 0.0029000460635870695, 0.011856474913656712, 0.025154445320367813, -0.07012544572353363, 0.0054311021231114864, -0.03251206502318382, -0.029223952442407608, 0.022368181496858597, 0.005816881079226732, -0.0034568929113447666, 0.015328529290854931, -0.021154657006263733, -0.01011424046009779, 0.046858400106430054, 0.03480226919054985, -0.004167870152741671, 0.005024683196097612, -0.007387795951217413, 0.008711505681276321, 0.033752504736185074, -0.016337094828486443, -0.006444800645112991, 0.032595422118902206, 0.036122627556324005, -0.04569241777062416, -0.0001462279469706118, -0.030009616166353226, -0.05129801109433174, 0.01870456524193287, -0.01063357014209032, -0.03461601212620735, -0.030714279040694237, 0.021433068439364433, -0.030894197523593903, 0.016842950135469437, 0.030473358929157257, 0.00281112571246922, -0.015540196560323238, -0.008344393223524094, -0.011665889993309975, -0.03802934288978577, 0.032293979078531265, 0.02563025988638401, -0.034199390560388565, -0.04356953129172325, 0.031098369508981705, 0.016368065029382706, -0.007542341016232967, 0.012624015100300312, 0.007504941429942846, -0.017761383205652237, 0.07888076454401016, -0.027996011078357697, 0.009796462953090668, 0.043284133076667786, -0.0169080700725317, 0.03573929890990257, -0.08965658396482468, 0.07845053821802139, -0.004953613504767418, -0.0029008269775658846, -0.044144406914711, 0.015110275708138943, -0.039474811404943466, 0.0034978718031197786, 0.03875420615077019, -0.003476383164525032, -0.02543879859149456, -0.008779817260801792, 0.04787321016192436, -0.03443533554673195, -0.015592154115438461, 0.05125565454363823, 0.016499551013112068, -0.008147741667926311, -0.040190793573856354, 0.007450447883456945, 0.01826002635061741, 0.046408046036958694, -0.022664804011583328, 0.0008699249592609704, 0.017522349953651428, 0.00939991232007742, 0.009142880327999592, -0.008296770974993706, 0.023267695680260658, -0.027686811983585358, 0.023229070007801056, 0.01900096982717514, -0.004287336952984333, 0.023252420127391815, 0.00364224286749959, -0.05534076690673828, 0.022333920001983643, -0.02135378308594227, -0.0575711727142334, -0.019431820139288902, -0.016852103173732758, 0.00179704197216779, -0.05441221594810486, 0.005384257063269615, 0.0006227858830243349, -0.027174949645996094, 0.0016792939277365804, 0.0011139829875901341, 0.006035504397004843, 0.029496099799871445, -0.0078448336571455, 0.01775801181793213, 0.021147264167666435, 0.00007779610314173624, 0.014675953425467014, 0.013369586318731308, 0.03405613452196121, -0.019061297178268433, 0.009054234251379967, 0.04882797598838806, 0.0018508420325815678, 0.0490238182246685, -0.04671114310622215, 0.043838851153850555, -0.010214975103735924, -0.01980605721473694, 0.00437929667532444, -0.0346219502389431, -0.02111908234655857, -0.01936173439025879, 0.007925824262201786, 0.06933420896530151, -0.037070222198963165, 0.012298786081373692, -0.02757478505373001, 0.02559375762939453, -0.015464138239622116, -0.031379684805870056, -0.027961552143096924, 0.0025096815079450607, 0.03375000134110451, 0.0032018995843827724, 0.017096877098083496, -0.010726084932684898, 0.07529087364673615, -0.02832806669175625, -0.03337794169783592, -0.0012638171901926398, 0.02299473062157631, -0.0025452724657952785, -0.026339465752243996, -0.0486515536904335, -0.001152612385340035, 0.02923656813800335, 0.015969974920153618, 0.009895999915897846, 0.0028307917527854443, -0.04579182341694832, 0.020093504339456558, 0.05518996715545654, -0.0367400236427784, 0.007935420610010624, -0.011105455458164215, -0.028724756091833115, -0.0420963279902935, -0.026549460366368294 ]
<p>How can I test heteroskedasticity of a time series in R? I have heard of two tests <code>McLeod.Li.test</code> and <code>bptest</code> (Breusch-Pagan test). Can I use these two tests? and what are the differences and assumptions of these tests if I can use them?</p> <p>Thanks</p>
73,823
[ -0.006134205963462591, -0.02142968587577343, 0.003535535419359803, -0.015103681944310665, 0.02593635581433773, -0.010671674273908138, -0.00671997107565403, -0.047859858721494675, 0.04301338270306587, -0.013495776802301407, 0.04738986864686012, 0.05833941325545311, 0.04464274272322655, 0.022575706243515015, 0.03985678032040596, -0.013962341472506523, -0.00981870200484991, 0.0018023272277787328, -0.004755803383886814, 0.016395244747400284, -0.016697555780410767, 0.0027329011354595423, 0.0020329004619270563, -0.004584229085594416, -0.018299374729394913, 0.05969744548201561, 0.03647135943174362, 0.019864995032548904, 0.005702583119273186, 0.06983550637960434, -0.031524378806352615, -0.03412996977567673, -0.020921023562550545, 0.042625997215509415, -0.01004111673682928, 0.024790693074464798, -0.01685723289847374, -0.033548034727573395, -0.02776782587170601, 0.015407534316182137, -0.03504685312509537, -0.024935407564044, 0.005474405828863382, 0.02222100831568241, -0.006696745287626982, 0.026971574872732162, -0.010841029696166515, 0.0023740874603390694, 0.015007968060672283, -0.042180877178907394, 0.05484404042363167, -0.04141217842698097, 0.014008956030011177, 0.01602691411972046, -0.003118549706414342, -0.006911795120686293, 0.04553867504000664, 0.08558441698551178, -0.058075446635484695, -0.04757705703377724, -0.03364071995019913, -0.007608251646161079, 0.009164073504507542, -0.021404989063739777, -0.05907566472887993, 0.04567969590425491, -0.0088516129180789, -0.02338251657783985, 0.045709166675806046, 0.0054351105354726315, 0.009535914286971092, -0.014770505018532276, 0.022725244984030724, -0.03325321525335312, -0.0057148863561451435, -0.004209130071103573, 0.005197396036237478, 0.026165027171373367, 0.03300132229924202, 0.042528629302978516, 0.0366530641913414, 0.01004177425056696, 0.011102055199444294, 0.011013532057404518, 0.0942925363779068, 0.013321270234882832, 0.05090157315135002, -0.02320466749370098, -0.0006986960652284324, 0.020724371075630188, -0.005129596218466759, -0.025570813566446304, 0.04973137006163597, 0.03747914358973503, -0.037542834877967834, 0.014735899865627289, -0.0014000098453834653, 0.029183415696024895, -0.0010370175587013364, -0.01195868756622076, 0.03446999564766884, -0.05093824490904808, 0.036189448088407516, 0.025285780429840088, 0.008364582434296608, -0.01740635745227337, 0.0028309905901551247, -0.023264244198799133, -0.04444640874862671, -0.03358554095029831, -0.01678011752665043, 0.01768989861011505, -0.04710458964109421, -0.022536208853125572, 0.03478564694523811, 0.012764408253133297, -0.028784113004803658, -0.013484427705407143, 0.055416300892829895, 0.06034993380308151, 0.0502755381166935, 0.021726347506046295, 0.010570917278528214, -0.019788704812526703, -0.021878384053707123, 0.028827205300331116, 0.017186926677823067, -0.034096091985702515, -0.06472492218017578, 0.06333433091640472, 0.01172842737287283, -0.03470699489116669, 0.012349364347755909, 0.020276902243494987, 0.058513034135103226, -0.00441130343824625, -0.08353573083877563, -0.04380889609456062, 0.0292357187718153, -0.0047346181236207485, -0.01821899600327015, -0.048273682594299316, 0.027172880247235298, -0.01815584860742092, 0.052702710032463074, 0.020043224096298218, 0.02370939403772354, -0.0028019279707223177, 0.016109051182866096, 0.022549763321876526, -0.02939477190375328, -0.01833028346300125, 0.018886230885982513, 0.006852124817669392, 0.016397986561059952, -0.0912557989358902, -0.05099381506443024, 0.02656998299062252, -0.009378206916153431, 0.02266945317387581, 0.01741105131804943, 0.01821681670844555, -0.019187672063708305, -0.026972156018018723, -0.01641581952571869, -0.02085486426949501, 0.07519165426492691, -0.015381439588963985, 0.03154166787862778, -0.010487000457942486, -0.04028500244021416, 0.007966693490743637, 0.007724292576313019, 0.052627503871917725, 0.025932563468813896, -0.022264951840043068, -0.003886919468641281, 0.024863598868250847, 0.018163954839110374, 0.020558923482894897, -0.05422335863113403, 0.007344432175159454, -0.006873543839901686, -0.0293705016374588, -0.021595977246761322, 0.053458284586668015, 0.011268149130046368, -0.015633288770914078, 0.053752440959215164, -0.06004771217703819, -0.04633884131908417, -0.06702537089586258, 0.00037780223647132516, -0.010277938097715378, -0.03450516238808632, 0.023338239639997482, 0.03809956833720207, 0.04320353642106056, -0.023887591436505318, 0.008538200519979, -0.05960679054260254, 0.012474555522203445, -0.010115856304764748, -0.054327547550201416, -0.007146886549890041, 0.03950021043419838, 0.03795676305890083, -0.055709876120090485, 0.009566511027514935, -0.01935487613081932, -0.017791064456105232, 0.03771861642599106, -0.05687097832560539, 0.03435983881354332, 0.014050477184355259, 0.008791342377662659, 0.007378622889518738, -0.0066209398210048676, -0.012505907565355301, 0.06880210340023041, -0.052782393991947174, 0.043666351586580276, 0.04297921434044838, -0.005132379941642284, 0.022353865206241608, -0.0281870998442173, 0.007108218502253294, 0.0147485276684165, -0.03577789291739464, 0.0010645522270351648, -0.05165714770555496, 0.03599138557910919, 0.043626561760902405, 0.00709918700158596, -0.011693146079778671, 0.018608644604682922, 0.08237911015748978, 0.02067052386701107, 0.0019863047637045383, 0.02632906660437584, 0.021501105278730392, -0.0006913569523021579, -0.011533464305102825, 0.00496033625677228, 0.022703934460878372, 0.006830723024904728, 0.041680216789245605, -0.020263729616999626, 0.07265874743461609, -0.008256026543676853, -0.02680295519530773, 0.062446869909763336, 0.008147439919412136, 0.0027639959007501602, -0.014504851773381233, -0.02580254152417183, 0.021915411576628685, -0.010218528099358082, 0.010056570172309875, 0.04050281271338463, 0.026657938957214355, 0.022818995639681816, 0.035219285637140274, -0.009084205143153667, 0.00893240887671709, 0.010624488815665245, -0.015764670446515083, -0.0400356650352478, 0.016846541315317154, -0.043615806847810745, 0.010343804955482483, -0.0010968433925881982, -0.012777984142303467, -0.05889515206217766, -0.019620250910520554, 0.027377726510167122, 0.05480484291911125, 0.032753411680459976, -0.033537786453962326, -0.03366590291261673, 0.027932142838835716, -0.035808105021715164, 0.02225320227444172, -0.028643188998103142, -0.021331414580345154, 0.01835576444864273, -0.02380291558802128, 0.0056196837686002254, 0.0314345620572567, -0.0011530682677403092, -0.02948831394314766, 0.05285938084125519, -0.03200257569551468, -0.022396422922611237, -0.011870753020048141, -0.049869511276483536, -0.003957446664571762, -0.03807826712727547, -0.03314824774861336, 0.03498897701501846, 0.015137482434511185, -0.035120151937007904, -0.00584930507466197, -0.04410265013575554, 0.010727392509579659, -0.023503970354795456, 0.02250697836279869, -0.003471208270639181, -0.0049933516420423985, 0.03706179931759834, 0.020197460427880287, -0.04284825921058655, 0.005143721122294664, -0.044225919991731644, -0.06681176275014877, 0.024376915767788887, 0.003019802737981081, 0.016651634126901627, -0.023491330444812775, -0.037984106689691544, 0.018245281651616096, 0.04901153966784477, -0.035556938499212265, -0.030670201405882835, -0.009953574277460575, -0.045320261269807816, -0.017558015882968903, 0.022656820714473724, 0.05524186044931412, 0.01196353044360876, -0.005555361043661833, 0.038486674427986145, 0.04180784896016121, 0.04539968818426132, 0.018138399347662926, 0.007587083149701357, 0.01659020408987999, -0.001594935660250485, 0.009737716987729073, 0.009493459016084671, 0.015795208513736725, -0.017358772456645966, 0.013584129512310028, -0.0028320897836238146, -0.0005838488577865064, 0.013807072304189205, -0.03160986304283142, 0.009969898499548435, -0.014109832234680653, 0.005951184779405594, -0.055997516959905624, 0.04083320498466492, -0.004454956855624914, 0.009862225502729416, -0.014611216261982918, -0.011909151449799538, 0.02478138729929924, -0.0038096485659480095, 0.022451212629675865, 0.012239045463502407, 0.008090028539299965, -0.025221088901162148, -0.004555088933557272, -0.009048053063452244, -0.05478637292981148, 0.0417611338198185, -0.05252685770392418, -0.01804930530488491, 0.026950066909193993, 0.02004052698612213, 0.028853682801127434, 0.05956529825925827, -0.024532359093427658, 0.007660408969968557, -0.07378873229026794, 0.021386969834566116, -0.005483892280608416, 0.030761461704969406, 0.04837115481495857, 0.041048262268304825, 0.058975573629140854, -0.022533025592565536, 0.019592465832829475, -0.06511250883340836, -0.05469578877091408, 0.05991748720407486, 0.001525947474874556, 0.015247744508087635, 0.002735584508627653, -0.04859691858291626, 0.008787828497588634, -0.03171910345554352, 0.0403529591858387, 0.01865501143038273, 0.005686081480234861, -0.04299543797969818, 0.02851712889969349, -0.008425062522292137, -0.01143704168498516, 0.013571876101195812, 0.009954793378710747, 0.009710172191262245, -0.013490086421370506, 0.038444288074970245, 0.0542420856654644, 0.010182183235883713, -0.016251029446721077, 0.008510401472449303, 0.0038438867777585983, 0.0366339348256588, 0.02692275680601597, 0.04898881912231445, 0.015732428058981895, -0.03948572278022766, 0.02110767550766468, 0.019412070512771606, 0.036794085055589676, 0.024463219568133354, 0.02417636848986149, -0.018914083018898964, -0.009778963401913643, -0.0029403071384876966, -0.021233098581433296, -0.005545837804675102, 0.027336111292243004, -0.01726173795759678, 0.04707388952374458, 0.022339213639497757, -0.025248054414987564, 0.01336570456624031, 0.071689672768116, 0.018118178471922874, 0.02763056755065918, -0.035072632133960724, -0.008861715905368328, -0.017590954899787903, 0.004270310513675213, 0.028465919196605682, -0.017971543595194817, -0.019567258656024933, 0.01859872415661812, 0.048466164618730545, -0.011133373714983463, -0.025893036276102066, -0.009374384768307209, 0.030181897804141045, 0.04268176481127739, 0.004308987874537706, -0.030587632209062576, 0.03566713258624077, 0.020198537036776543, 0.03686566650867462, 0.0316074974834919, 0.014835967682301998, -0.06671126931905746, 0.021425042301416397, 0.055481258779764175, 0.01830100826919079, -0.055214568972587585, -0.02186891809105873, -0.018857210874557495, 0.006007031537592411, 0.017508655786514282, -0.0370202399790287, 0.005241685546934605, -0.0020607674960047007, -0.0021150826942175627, -0.05654394254088402, 0.0034654743503779173, -0.01721971482038498, 0.016699325293302536, -0.035919688642024994, 0.010601315647363663, -0.06431501358747482, -0.0361848920583725, -0.007997333072125912, 0.019256126135587692, -0.0015317192301154137, 0.030612610280513763, -0.0537029504776001, -0.006920128595083952, 0.002324508037418127, 0.03116619400680065, 0.002681052079424262, -0.057930249720811844, 0.010840312577784061, 0.005011086817830801, 0.004241511691361666, 0.07898221164941788, 0.005821136757731438, -0.015549986623227596, 0.01593971811234951, -0.010978682897984982, -0.02071823552250862, -0.017978021875023842, 0.01913074031472206, 0.014957157894968987, 0.014852884225547314, -0.0006907382048666477, 0.05957425385713577, 0.022425483912229538, 0.0008684996864758432, 0.01294821035116911, -0.030994156375527382, 0.010306566022336483, -0.05556149780750275, -0.0147462273016572, -0.06437701731920242, -0.024486077949404716, -0.04187601059675217, 0.013022894971072674, -0.01779692806303501, -0.0017643137834966183, -0.05855197459459305, 0.009110353887081146, 0.01125157531350851, 0.04029431194067001, 0.010180073790252209, -0.0260024294257164, 0.001286851242184639, -0.03335767611861229, -0.02207798883318901, 0.003542777616530657, 0.03989681228995323, -0.024502262473106384, 0.0014833499444648623, -0.023600004613399506, -0.030884718522429466, 0.012818343006074429, -0.004007336683571339, -0.0039835586212575436, 0.007154801394790411, 0.016034604981541634, 0.04503009840846062, -0.0015595585573464632, 0.01733282022178173, -0.004212620668113232, -0.034725360572338104, 0.00667500589042902, 0.02929965779185295, -0.020432591438293457, 0.03283903747797012, -0.04087861627340317, 0.049918048083782196, 0.015266741625964642, -0.002939439145848155, -0.08199344575405121, -0.054330553859472275, 0.0417301245033741, -0.0056429775431752205, -0.033380456268787384, -0.013064522296190262, -0.016193097457289696, 0.012515397742390633, 0.012343702837824821, -0.022265218198299408, 0.0657234787940979, -0.007212609518319368, 0.0013395557180047035, -0.03285399079322815, 0.015161238610744476, 0.08484000712633133, 0.014855099841952324, -0.00521952286362648, -0.010432088747620583, -0.011313503608107567, -0.0025107914116233587, -0.010809188708662987, 0.03382024168968201, -0.03619140759110451, -0.01796399988234043, -0.014644674025475979, -0.002432535868138075, 0.014084145426750183, -0.011488571763038635, -0.03637034073472023, -0.006029099691659212, -0.0044052377343177795, 0.028612930327653885, -0.0487954281270504, 0.03237413614988327, -0.046923041343688965, 0.03387610986828804, -0.04660876467823982, -0.03232431784272194, -0.03789548948407173, -0.03668627515435219, 0.009373351000249386, -0.003604310331866145, -0.014038407243788242, 0.027903005480766296, 0.08643560856580734, -0.01952517218887806, 0.01788514107465744, -0.0008330107084475458, -0.028688939288258553, 0.020773887634277344, -0.01014002040028572, 0.00858269166201353, -0.00545137282460928, 0.04133160412311554, -0.04527457430958748, -0.047436125576496124, -0.04090123251080513, -0.00028841005405411124, 0.07340160757303238, -0.017665768042206764, 0.07320712506771088, 0.08014946430921555, 0.010293135419487953, 0.02519645169377327, -0.008131392300128937, -0.01232785265892744, 0.016985012218356133, 0.021207308396697044, 0.05219317600131035, -0.0026973122730851173, 0.021888459101319313, 0.03952483832836151, 0.024017006158828735, -0.0020394271705299616, 0.04925856366753578, -0.007194345351308584, 0.04330376908183098, 0.02000843547284603, -0.007333177607506514, -0.03913973644375801, 0.06190246716141701, -0.06527023017406464, 0.02094525843858719, -0.03518563136458397, -0.002538252156227827, 0.05002451688051224, 0.05339891090989113, -0.01800192892551422, -0.05004066601395607, -0.009710180573165417, -0.039880771189928055, 0.019719459116458893, 0.018385663628578186, 0.01026602741330862, 0.02200411446392536, 0.02574794739484787, 0.06005821377038956, -0.012118222191929817, 0.036470722407102585, -0.041757114231586456, -0.074868343770504, -0.019372528418898582, 0.012539518997073174, -0.028572307899594307, 0.03312434256076813, -0.014272135682404041, -0.004188263323158026, -0.004785106983035803, -0.015051761642098427, 0.005502957385033369, -0.010170543566346169, 0.01439268421381712, 0.006673512980341911, 0.08516621589660645, -0.01861986704170704, 0.0059970952570438385, -0.002137969946488738, 0.01356472447514534, 0.12077348679304123, 0.034752167761325836, 0.04156806692481041, -0.09774377942085266, 0.009846597909927368, 0.011869674548506737, 0.028183359652757645, -0.03639562055468559, -0.0008190204971469939, -0.007431332021951675, -0.01594698242843151, 0.06968240439891815, 0.07442150264978409, 0.011425486765801907, -0.05332072824239731, 0.051361944526433945, 0.005768922623246908, 0.004880536813288927, 0.014017256908118725, 0.014869562350213528, -0.0017533497884869576, -0.02228492684662342, -0.039497144520282745, -0.006903321482241154, -0.010947788134217262, -0.00679798936471343, -0.015351656824350357, -0.03225485235452652, -0.0013939730124548078, 0.04955615848302841, 0.023660974577069283, 0.0015139624010771513, 0.022391125559806824, 0.020529527217149734, 0.007759522181004286, 0.006704946514219046, 0.02404697611927986, -0.0386771634221077, 0.027341675013303757, 0.04655492305755615, 0.011477209627628326, -0.03621119260787964, -0.022208208218216896, 0.03563898056745529, -0.030880115926265717, 0.0070799970999360085, -0.04836248233914375, 0.005804397631436586, -0.0106370123103261, -0.012357999570667744, -0.009354251436889172, 0.014231007546186447, -0.04034014418721199, -0.05924706161022186, -0.012682455591857433, 0.017021583393216133, 0.005115095525979996, -0.057467080652713776, -0.015533517114818096, -0.06497669965028763, 0.008918480016291142, -0.009748305194079876, 0.06257306039333344, 0.02121846377849579, -0.06032991781830788, 0.011466127820312977, -0.016561361029744148, 0.04193498566746712, -0.012904391624033451, 0.008534856140613556, 0.028510699048638344, 0.002355510601773858, -0.023007197305560112, -0.021665392443537712, 0.01843179762363434, -0.01683967374265194, 0.04113194718956947, -0.0038367845118045807, -0.05508290231227875, 0.016080792993307114, -0.045112378895282745, 0.025249166414141655, -0.017063306644558907, -0.01663508452475071, -0.05902380496263504, 0.0004037352919112891, 0.07363621890544891, 0.013934727758169174, 0.01966460421681404, 0.028678687289357185, -0.023077165707945824, 0.007367991842329502, 0.04934866726398468, -0.06823709607124329, -0.051723137497901917, 0.004670531954616308, -0.01963699236512184, -0.032989777624607086, -0.041328877210617065, 0.04851917549967766, 0.043183792382478714, -0.004049572162330151, -0.04955791309475899, -0.004872207064181566, -0.034398626536130905, 0.0020410220604389906, 0.010194486007094383, -0.07002377510070801, -0.040277041494846344, 0.008951050229370594, 0.006885390263050795, -0.03558715432882309, -0.03700076416134834, -0.03417094424366951, -0.005879363976418972, 0.031081901863217354, -0.022982189431786537, -0.04537828639149666, 0.007853895425796509, -0.006287758704274893, 0.029712839052081108, -0.05245571583509445, 0.0023805396631360054, -0.01291885320097208, -0.022439584136009216, 0.010617192834615707, -0.015142646618187428, 0.020134951919317245, 0.0015607321402058005, -0.022940071299672127, -0.006153303198516369, 0.07115469872951508, 0.02259427309036255, 0.00498912064358592, 0.03173007816076279, 0.029793862253427505, -0.014812789857387543, 0.0033286097459495068, -0.0030760644003748894, -0.018276000395417213, 0.036964815109968185, -0.039789874106645584, -0.02826623246073723, -0.008051367476582527, -0.01130539271980524, 0.034331317991018295, -0.0032366157975047827, -0.009246151894330978, -0.020821675658226013, 0.051114436239004135, 0.014617121778428555, -0.0007116221240721643, 0.003949702717363834, 0.0020073209889233112, 0.013570699840784073, -0.011632249690592289, -0.012272791936993599, 0.02234034612774849, 0.004584405571222305, -0.003971170634031296, 0.06367448717355728, 0.015154510736465454, -0.022441869601607323, -0.023666072636842728, -0.03445708006620407, 0.0036990393418818712, 0.021477194502949715, -0.05300822854042053, 0.025673728436231613, 0.027060817927122116, -0.025938868522644043, 0.01394468080252409, -0.043486930429935455, 0.00855282787233591, -0.07442260533571243, -0.00485282251611352, -0.017444083467125893, -0.00828743726015091, 0.005655844695866108, -0.034859344363212585, 0.02089480683207512, -0.0020703990012407303, -0.06276898831129074, 0.013286917470395565, -0.0006992131238803267, -0.024960936978459358, -0.05342453718185425, -0.0012446544133126736, -0.04101414978504181, 0.03696340322494507, 0.01589958369731903, 0.024460500106215477, 0.033082906156778336, 0.010265115648508072, 0.043344009667634964, -0.005102276336401701, 0.02469126135110855, 0.005762765184044838, 0.024535726755857468, -0.07419580221176147, 0.013416771776974201, -0.04507066681981087, -0.043426040560007095, 0.023504119366407394, -0.009760024026036263, 0.020751915872097015, 0.03770172595977783, 0.019466452300548553, 0.01811845600605011, 0.024347709491848946, -0.00902209710329771, 0.0005997580592520535, -0.02209625206887722, -0.023780301213264465, -0.009749723598361015, 0.04975017532706261, -0.030194098129868507, 0.004462437704205513, 0.006390620023012161, -0.008921503089368343, -0.016720149666070938, 0.001454632030799985, -0.008637622930109501, -0.050515394657850266, -0.021204466000199318, -0.0154878506436944, 0.021343860775232315, 0.005463266279548407, 0.021911876276135445, -0.0028025892097502947, 0.004215541295707226, 0.0519823394715786, 0.03508015722036362, -0.01929635927081108, 0.016076236963272095, -0.006455258000642061, -0.024541685357689857, 0.003212162060663104, 0.0048381732776761055, -0.00246522668749094, -0.03315393254160881, -0.02097502164542675, 0.013494161888957024, -0.011621342971920967, -0.06127147749066353, -0.00882178358733654, 0.015052668750286102, 0.0405103825032711, -0.0032080395612865686, -0.0053102378733456135, 0.0293840654194355, -0.00894899945706129, 0.008032974787056446, -0.06525483727455139, 0.08635807782411575, -0.0117880217730999, -0.020564932376146317, -0.04458851367235184, -0.009890032932162285, -0.05010882392525673, -0.025723494589328766, 0.03450597822666168, -0.015489805489778519, 0.027659151703119278, -0.0023031621240079403, 0.027304600924253464, -0.031325604766607285, -0.02034105360507965, 0.035048216581344604, -0.013389253988862038, -0.015186475589871407, 0.00010444235522300005, -0.032037053257226944, 0.01737767457962036, 0.03723477944731712, 0.01142118126153946, -0.048456259071826935, 0.007289217785000801, 0.026825644075870514, -0.01156009640544653, 0.02506810426712036, 0.0052217477932572365, 0.00747083080932498, 0.04757976159453392, -0.017969613894820213, 0.008668677881360054, 0.005632719956338406, -0.00882862787693739, -0.04173636436462402, 0.00867853406816721, -0.01278266217559576, -0.005722429137676954, -0.0010411256225779653, 0.028143206611275673, -0.04401863366365433, -0.022748935967683792, -0.00991702452301979, -0.00814022496342659, -0.05169316753745079, 0.041217703372240067, 0.030915576964616776, 0.018716955557465553, 0.04553966596722603, -0.031208334490656853, -0.01916416361927986, -0.0026960792019963264, 0.0005652267718687654, 0.014716182835400105, 0.015080598182976246, 0.0453125424683094, 0.005742121487855911, 0.022474724799394608, -0.005593359936028719, -0.02552003413438797, 0.04151691123843193, -0.014529362320899963, 0.057215165346860886, -0.002982676262035966, -0.03073141910135746, -0.005765815731137991, -0.022366736084222794, 0.01654915325343609, 0.031102562323212624, -0.012943512760102749, 0.04948015883564949, -0.037711989134550095, 0.01767103560268879, 0.0003523621417116374, -0.01333138719201088, -0.02537749521434307, 0.023841816931962967, 0.016572130843997, -0.0035133021883666515, -0.011781307868659496, 0.021074526011943817, 0.02252599596977234, -0.013517485931515694, 0.003927513491362333, -0.03230414539575577, 0.012424955144524574, -0.006209842395037413, -0.012708200141787529, -0.0073189022950828075, -0.020900197327136993, -0.021124420687556267, -0.023424429818987846, 0.025254223495721817, 0.018357284367084503, 0.02956204302608967, -0.05027838051319122, -0.011831097304821014, 0.014170193113386631, 0.05718136578798294, -0.08195744454860687, -0.004299596417695284, -0.050368957221508026, -0.010330784134566784, -0.0006041376618668437, 0.0005566896288655698 ]
<p>How do I interpret this model:</p> <p>$$ Price = -7.095 - 9.471[\ln(Number Of Different Kinds Of Fruits)] + 53.942 \sqrt{Number Of Customer} + ... $$</p> <p>Is that:</p> <ul> <li>If there are no kinds of fruits nor visitors nor other variables, the expected average price will be -7.095</li> <li>If the natural logarithm of Number Of Different Kinds Of Fruits increases with one and all other things remain the same, the expected average price will decrease with 9.471</li> <li>If there is one extra customer and all other variables remain the same, the average expected price will increase with 53.942</li> </ul>
73,824
[ -0.022975869476795197, -0.05411161109805107, 0.011336332187056541, 0.025190310552716255, 0.006727772764861584, 0.006779235787689686, 0.02160045877099037, -0.005695025902241468, -0.013698890805244446, 0.0009709433652460575, 0.04388296231627464, 0.048833876848220825, 0.024962518364191055, 0.03601447120308876, 0.030274128541350365, 0.04346282780170441, -0.022418908774852753, 0.004203808959573507, -0.022612595930695534, -0.011937412433326244, 0.013462750241160393, 0.032478392124176025, 0.009713799692690372, 0.005028340965509415, 0.0014884761767461896, 0.04427177459001541, 0.059597279876470566, -0.009441939182579517, 0.009278527460992336, 0.03733808547258377, -0.003977044019848108, 0.0131053626537323, 0.00096410809783265, 0.04170520603656769, 0.04524712264537811, 0.027925217524170876, -0.017959849908947945, -0.020339127629995346, -0.03059474192559719, -0.0021046509500592947, 0.0008171674562618136, 0.006547919008880854, 0.024182142689824104, -0.015101505443453789, -0.04535892605781555, 0.044024426490068436, 0.0012531164102256298, -0.026345616206526756, 0.05018158257007599, -0.026934893801808357, 0.06965043395757675, -0.005401666276156902, -0.013430639170110226, 0.03006790764629841, -0.004581801127642393, 0.011475862003862858, 0.03733723238110542, 0.0564558282494545, 0.00329271680675447, -0.0670882910490036, -0.002080058678984642, -0.03642185777425766, 0.011404704302549362, -0.025228654965758324, -0.008019057102501392, 0.009424926713109016, 0.024660255759954453, -0.008234555833041668, 0.0452672615647316, 0.022961925715208054, 0.04853682219982147, 0.04193642735481262, 0.04760286584496498, -0.0023495140485465527, 0.018687816336750984, 0.0010689161717891693, 0.009215109050273895, 0.0395725853741169, 0.03350595757365227, 0.0218640323728323, 0.03757848963141441, -0.004289616364985704, 0.013170544989407063, 0.021104371175169945, 0.021721797063946724, -0.02905777283012867, 0.0614001490175724, -0.013932936824858189, 0.018012039363384247, 0.020456360653042793, 0.025919102132320404, 0.04987543448805809, 0.042494628578424454, -0.025356026366353035, -0.04874103516340256, 0.046800799667835236, -0.007069950457662344, 0.01556195318698883, -0.0032279915176331997, 0.005433765705674887, -0.029981344938278198, -0.02674766443669796, 0.007482525426894426, 0.01900734379887581, -0.018646089360117912, -0.008003299124538898, -0.05246216058731079, -0.023815404623746872, -0.0006115648429840803, -0.0470288023352623, -0.012150365859270096, -0.014372041448950768, 0.07652545720338821, -0.0034958035685122013, -0.01942417584359646, -0.018205270171165466, -0.013341398909687996, -0.0012663165107369423, 0.04425818845629692, 0.02527419477701187, 0.04146503284573555, -0.01389054674655199, 0.01779928430914879, -0.00974482111632824, -0.048590779304504395, -0.022762637585401535, -0.008665439672768116, -0.034292131662368774, -0.06586337834596634, 0.015684591606259346, -0.02791381999850273, -0.015654444694519043, 0.013785888440907001, 0.01443712692707777, 0.0453597828745842, -0.0056211440823972225, -0.05964143946766853, -0.08210355788469315, 0.03619430214166641, -0.011647266335785389, 0.03431154787540436, -0.013188911601901054, -0.017067639157176018, 0.06451977044343948, 0.0326591432094574, -0.03206893056631088, 0.015035643242299557, 0.016255220398306847, -0.012691173702478409, 0.019964691251516342, -0.05129566416144371, 0.01549266092479229, -0.014857892878353596, -0.019984818994998932, -0.014875231310725212, -0.10936615616083145, 0.03496905416250229, 0.03170530125498772, -0.02214522287249565, -0.03556878864765167, 0.031173810362815857, -0.007552457507699728, -0.012697473168373108, 0.0023694001138210297, -0.010286854580044746, -0.0011390161234885454, 0.09147978574037552, -0.0026584495790302753, 0.0235502440482378, 0.04090433940291405, 0.026643279939889908, 0.03353624790906906, -0.03296400606632233, 0.022738466039299965, 0.03546930477023125, 0.02901461534202099, 0.0013464443618431687, -0.040389250963926315, 0.02923731878399849, 0.03464346379041672, -0.030579302459955215, -0.0287907924503088, -0.022105710580945015, 0.011899624951183796, 0.003319951007142663, 0.007791261654347181, -0.013446798548102379, -0.024266626685857773, 0.05232676863670349, -0.028886806219816208, -0.08398221433162689, -0.07768957316875458, 0.019916195422410965, -0.007203550077974796, 0.011470706202089787, -0.002376832067966461, 0.016409646719694138, 0.0036195272114127874, -0.009222425520420074, 0.019680893048644066, -0.016698088496923447, 0.00047419554903171957, 0.04352091997861862, -0.04906228929758072, 0.003637751331552863, 0.0759124755859375, 0.022681638598442078, -0.049454040825366974, 0.020012427121400833, -0.03419015556573868, -0.0175224170088768, 0.006620913743972778, -0.06232920661568642, -0.010071874596178532, 0.014809470623731613, -0.0023179452400654554, 0.026874957606196404, -0.013623081147670746, -0.007096837740391493, 0.06317528337240219, -0.053296931087970734, -0.0002911074261646718, 0.07494183629751205, 0.025918036699295044, 0.03256317228078842, 0.0044668884947896, -0.025669211521744728, 0.06162666901946068, -0.034283049404621124, -0.035034213215112686, -0.035944949835538864, -0.025737863034009933, 0.03157833591103554, 0.029462946578860283, 0.00878117885440588, -0.002172589534893632, 0.07647780328989029, 0.014956763945519924, 0.0016085444949567318, 0.01347359735518694, -0.021223464980721474, 0.009201832115650177, 0.02556559070944786, 0.0189363993704319, 0.0387723445892334, 0.0037062224000692368, -0.012918718159198761, -0.017717070877552032, 0.02341935597360134, 0.003758474253118038, 0.027629856020212173, 0.00553480489179492, 0.01797047071158886, 0.04795248433947563, -0.011668824590742588, 0.030803920701146126, 0.021950026974081993, -0.024417363107204437, 0.019342802464962006, 0.023467300459742546, -0.018596159294247627, -0.004838956519961357, -0.0010378427105024457, -0.020733287557959557, -0.022510288283228874, 0.02273792028427124, -0.003267784835770726, -0.04351780563592911, 0.042253874242305756, -0.03262312337756157, 0.04075353220105171, -0.013521585613489151, -0.06608209013938904, -0.023920562118291855, 0.03317156061530113, 0.012376777827739716, -0.012545708566904068, 0.05806434899568558, -0.009583014994859695, -0.03167235478758812, -0.014592763036489487, -0.011284182779490948, -0.007871408946812153, 0.007205058820545673, -0.04623306542634964, -0.021048087626695633, 0.005842291750013828, 0.0016430666437372565, 0.01832517795264721, 0.005546422675251961, 0.0038118832744657993, 0.04215986281633377, -0.022527264431118965, -0.013118996284902096, -0.05105041339993477, -0.019643938168883324, 0.005386199336498976, -0.013189557939767838, -0.05040920153260231, 0.04210320860147476, 0.025000127032399178, -0.002754420740529895, 0.01114573422819376, -0.08395655453205109, -0.024747252464294434, -0.024608207866549492, 0.003690156387165189, 0.004125724546611309, -0.009789668954908848, 0.009496144019067287, -0.014799234457314014, 0.003151137148961425, 0.005073447246104479, -0.10090931504964828, -0.07494412362575531, -0.024466773495078087, -0.006074394099414349, 0.042387451976537704, -0.008548528887331486, -0.0012013502418994904, 0.06480108946561813, 0.03389091044664383, -0.00620212871581316, -0.0015718078939244151, -0.010631417855620384, -0.04244152456521988, -0.03836947679519653, 0.017554396763443947, 0.028765801340341568, -0.059801604598760605, 0.050126928836107254, 0.028786610811948776, 0.04683414846658707, 0.015146047808229923, 0.011364874430000782, -0.014187848195433617, 0.015450868755578995, -0.007636684458702803, 0.002296661725267768, 0.020106002688407898, 0.0189240463078022, -0.02527235448360443, 0.046436093747615814, -0.004374240059405565, 0.034735389053821564, 0.03365130349993706, -0.037458907812833786, 0.05453405901789665, 0.020806023851037025, -0.0035837339237332344, -0.019083218649029732, 0.013265185058116913, -0.0036244497168809175, -0.028490634635090828, -0.005192330572754145, 0.0008829059661366045, 0.0011402128729969263, -0.014602724462747574, -0.015687886625528336, 0.04188206046819687, 0.05511065572500229, -0.04460068419575691, -0.02374669350683689, 0.000056816323194652796, -0.03630375117063522, 0.010084397159516811, 0.011432363651692867, 0.004679206293076277, 0.02570944093167782, 0.05375134199857712, -0.0022922956850379705, -0.00654982402920723, -0.019516265019774437, -0.015674911439418793, -0.03883149102330208, -0.014949928969144821, 0.000974005670286715, 0.004135565832257271, 0.006380372680723667, 0.02544553019106388, -0.013681513257324696, -0.01627722941339016, 0.048412129282951355, 0.012324848212301731, -0.06290362775325775, 0.04272567853331566, 0.017668170854449272, 0.0044447132386267185, 0.0014040098758414388, -0.02269962802529335, 0.05376991257071495, -0.01372371707111597, 0.00927878450602293, -0.002958714496344328, 0.02235637791454792, -0.03801988065242767, 0.00754281273111701, -0.02873334102332592, 0.011520300060510635, -0.011364473029971123, -0.006108874920755625, 0.022359313443303108, -0.02019253559410572, -0.01407339982688427, 0.03151995316147804, -0.021886542439460754, -0.028225399553775787, -0.026600748300552368, -0.0030987688805907965, 0.030698932707309723, 0.04720568656921387, 0.027884487062692642, 0.008652966469526291, 0.015193020924925804, 0.026861591264605522, 0.036650657653808594, 0.025648441165685654, 0.015605876222252846, -0.010879427194595337, -0.012486206367611885, -0.04573937878012657, -0.009103996679186821, -0.005174827761948109, 0.03861221298575401, 0.0022048340179026127, 0.02836369350552559, 0.06446018069982529, 0.030524400994181633, -0.012026272714138031, -0.0004365241329651326, 0.03436834737658501, -0.007842286489903927, -0.028317492455244064, 0.0034497438464313745, -0.008955167606472969, -0.038553543388843536, 0.00025660800747573376, 0.0009497871506027877, 0.006539659574627876, -0.016879761591553688, 0.027217218652367592, 0.02700287289917469, -0.011205393821001053, -0.02873391844332218, -0.03027542680501938, -0.003727787174284458, 0.025845538824796677, -0.029174569994211197, -0.08210110664367676, 0.02795221284031868, 0.07532087713479996, -0.02877255715429783, 0.014172445982694626, 0.02247420698404312, -0.10674422234296799, -0.012111772783100605, 0.010592077858746052, 0.05664902552962303, -0.027206845581531525, -0.011666690930724144, -0.055252887308597565, 0.026219991967082024, 0.005007094703614712, -0.028676925227046013, 0.039334192872047424, 0.030194267630577087, 0.02741444669663906, -0.007211596239358187, -0.018133336678147316, -0.06123421713709831, 0.016962187364697456, -0.065122090280056, 0.01914733275771141, -0.025780947878956795, -0.002059859922155738, -0.037304457277059555, 0.014694479294121265, 0.02136712148785591, 0.02409110777080059, -0.046961888670921326, -0.004958529490977526, -0.004769491497427225, 0.00024652827414684, -0.03915439173579216, -0.052214693278074265, 0.02157650515437126, -0.015584391541779041, -0.005071363877505064, 0.05525440350174904, -0.019607262685894966, -0.054997533559799194, -0.010011576116085052, 0.018112663179636, -0.00008181322482414544, -0.014493308030068874, -0.04007219150662422, 0.0217716246843338, 0.042257390916347504, 0.0032773343846201897, 0.051796313375234604, 0.010103854350745678, -0.02139260247349739, 0.004263808019459248, -0.03221661597490311, -0.006904855836182833, -0.006312815938144922, -0.006335604935884476, -0.0510580837726593, 0.004966007545590401, 0.010847305878996849, 0.05170498415827751, 0.0021340367384254932, 0.03462774306535721, -0.052025482058525085, -0.012644299305975437, -0.025211088359355927, -0.0029454692266881466, 0.019473817199468613, 0.009311520494520664, 0.00004861042179982178, -0.013879628852009773, 0.017596663907170296, -0.017126375809311867, 0.006444853730499744, -0.0483994297683239, 0.04161496087908745, 0.0028651615139096975, 0.004560055211186409, 0.002140703145414591, -0.018384132534265518, -0.042463939636945724, 0.04583088681101799, -0.05397174134850502, 0.014898690395057201, 0.011715911328792572, 0.053939539939165115, 0.04799698665738106, -0.0158246960490942, -0.02810567244887352, 0.003996081184595823, -0.0028893225826323032, -0.005603823345154524, -0.022593772038817406, 0.04032919928431511, -0.011466366238892078, -0.003946943208575249, -0.0376429446041584, -0.034754373133182526, 0.026228467002511024, -0.014271560125052929, -0.02378026582300663, 0.012042324058711529, -0.05680852010846138, -0.020023930817842484, -0.045816630125045776, -0.05239914730191231, 0.026047483086586, 0.005421444773674011, 0.019427867606282234, -0.0009614453883841634, 0.029454246163368225, 0.050210531800985336, 0.06448002904653549, -0.014560695737600327, 0.034264806658029556, 0.0011294182622805238, -0.0204473789781332, -0.0068763624876737595, 0.047500524669885635, -0.02450660429894924, -0.004078984260559082, -0.017069026827812195, 0.008377754129469395, 0.008117256686091423, -0.05265074223279953, -0.008560560643672943, -0.028694139793515205, 0.03813941776752472, -0.02937711589038372, -0.01174780074506998, 0.013766327872872353, 0.029579240828752518, 0.034598641097545624, 0.015016257762908936, 0.02320653386414051, 0.018752289935946465, -0.030212989076972008, 0.0473054014146328, -0.009426639415323734, -0.025178203359246254, 0.008817230351269245, 0.09379059076309204, 0.01508788950741291, 0.011316715739667416, -0.01682569645345211, -0.02829442359507084, 0.030227087438106537, -0.019655399024486542, -0.007704490330070257, -0.0023569355253130198, 0.027851935476064682, -0.05267380550503731, -0.01237267442047596, -0.019444407895207405, 0.02209920808672905, 0.03708590939640999, -0.023808786645531654, 0.038155753165483475, 0.03656180575489998, 0.015744540840387344, 0.015527469106018543, -0.02081345021724701, -0.014968090690672398, -0.008873259648680687, 0.026727566495537758, 0.059663038700819016, -0.005989138502627611, -0.0032770303077995777, 0.05187365785241127, 0.036656949669122696, 0.023154225200414658, 0.038281891494989395, 0.0022603091783821583, -0.0028701217379420996, -0.01085063349455595, -0.02757207863032818, -0.043002594262361526, 0.07636895775794983, -0.0026392852887511253, 0.05045957863330841, -0.038390133529901505, -0.022840896621346474, 0.07903159409761429, 0.044384948909282684, -0.0012004050659015775, -0.05832136049866676, -0.01074580941349268, -0.0432610921561718, 0.008523852564394474, -0.02129358984529972, 0.025338107720017433, -0.017537185922265053, -0.0009952412219718099, -0.004888503346592188, -0.03362177312374115, 0.032319195568561554, 0.008240340277552605, -0.05382009223103523, -0.024012327194213867, 0.0015694493195042014, -0.016231602057814598, 0.017043229192495346, -0.022918978706002235, -0.0067919716238975525, 0.0005330968415364623, -0.044690631330013275, -0.0021219926420599222, -0.0011831138981506228, -0.027351612225174904, 0.02209637500345707, 0.06763124465942383, 0.021899383515119553, 0.0000102641115518054, -0.04538226127624512, 0.021354930475354195, 0.1253076195716858, 0.05424881353974342, -0.003922443836927414, -0.04374875873327255, -0.014673330821096897, 0.0038917334750294685, 0.009309615939855576, -0.017145231366157532, -0.012076299637556076, 0.007422520313411951, 0.04835623875260353, 0.045236069709062576, 0.01944470778107643, -0.02835254557430744, -0.0278825331479311, 0.04738619551062584, -0.04505804553627968, -0.039685048162937164, 0.01855708658695221, -0.021781373769044876, 0.0005918029928579926, -0.01868431828916073, -0.04681679233908653, 0.021358216181397438, 0.011759212240576744, 0.025606289505958557, -0.007625438738614321, -0.03192121908068657, 0.019138852134346962, -0.015005510300397873, -0.01018491666764021, 0.027721229940652847, 0.03320722654461861, 0.0036931345239281654, -0.022161561995744705, 0.02194691263139248, 0.005034064874053001, -0.0315156951546669, 0.017189746722579002, 0.05114581808447838, -0.006673945114016533, -0.036782365292310715, 0.017433125525712967, 0.017153089866042137, -0.06333433091640472, -0.005483401473611593, -0.01804051734507084, 0.016475297510623932, 0.031390052288770676, 0.012002715840935707, -0.04646987095475197, 0.029730385169386864, -0.018158167600631714, -0.06194542720913887, -0.03602011874318123, 0.008600009605288506, 0.02605244517326355, -0.03290640190243721, -0.027286989614367485, -0.01389154139906168, -0.03754398971796036, 0.00022734585218131542, 0.022903190925717354, 0.01546501088887453, -0.024748533964157104, -0.009148052893579006, -0.0327143594622612, 0.029328428208827972, -0.03990161046385765, -0.010093198157846928, -0.046115532517433167, 0.01914300210773945, -0.04046310856938362, -0.0024885518942028284, -0.015327279455959797, 0.006366379093378782, 0.025261517614126205, -0.0068237329833209515, 0.005801249295473099, -0.01653112657368183, 0.005253688432276249, 0.04211750254034996, -0.010769282467663288, 0.011047331616282463, -0.01439040619879961, 0.0017814590828493237, -0.020685695111751556, 0.00573039660230279, 0.019118066877126694, -0.015040166676044464, -0.0007342746248468757, 0.08523473143577576, -0.0013664468424394727, -0.0005603655008599162, -0.025332296267151833, -0.030849970877170563, -0.0661979392170906, -0.043487925082445145, -0.0039458926767110825, 0.08058153092861176, -0.0013903486542403698, 0.0015321803512051702, 0.0032851933501660824, 0.007122496142983437, 0.0035006208345294, 0.0009148335084319115, 0.01320323534309864, -0.05827727168798447, 0.05245266854763031, 0.05315020680427551, 0.019374193623661995, -0.029017407447099686, -0.01661929488182068, 0.026609595865011215, -0.027759237214922905, 0.008784160017967224, 0.0014238229487091303, -0.03329728916287422, 0.012553920038044453, -0.030237456783652306, 0.0327758826315403, -0.008588197641074657, -0.016234472393989563, -0.04894004017114639, -0.012572786770761013, -0.005477619357407093, 0.0010682947468012571, 0.004428707994520664, 0.03338341787457466, 0.0021185812074691057, -0.0017320627812296152, 0.02082603983581066, 0.051859572529792786, 0.004466899670660496, -0.041832081973552704, 0.03465418517589569, 0.010686923749744892, 0.019884072244167328, -0.028361205011606216, -0.05812028795480728, 0.044015150517225266, 0.01073803473263979, -0.01823047548532486, -0.04038173705339432, 0.02321970835328102, 0.07380833476781845, 0.019466526806354523, 0.0024235497694462538, -0.036802925169467926, -0.002886686474084854, -0.06799287348985672, -0.016236649826169014, -0.016125338152050972, -0.023749710991978645, 0.021392591297626495, -0.05493533983826637, -0.03755936026573181, 0.04133421182632446, -0.012308917939662933, 0.013643845915794373, 0.04375378414988518, -0.04143042862415314, -0.010057032108306885, -0.01695951074361801, -0.02273814007639885, 0.01678462140262127, -0.02277931198477745, 0.016305627301335335, 0.01778295263648033, 0.01991388387978077, 0.0028026869986206293, 0.031956691294908524, -0.02158360555768013, -0.008239666000008583, -0.02537190355360508, -0.008960560895502567, 0.029783962294459343, -0.0008236701251007617, 0.03311416506767273, -0.07641410082578659, 0.006822071969509125, 0.015517630614340305, -0.016970589756965637, -0.011790885590016842, -0.012114097364246845, -0.016654839739203453, -0.02883003279566765, -0.011086523532867432, -0.025638438761234283, 0.032271578907966614, 0.06709618121385574, 0.031113432720303535, 0.007495796773582697, 0.004958976060152054, 0.01906598173081875, -0.04732956737279892, -0.008807479403913021, 0.016406426206231117, 0.004835012834519148, -0.02836764045059681, 0.017494050785899162, -0.049107957631349564, 0.0092862443998456, 0.06338583678007126, -0.017294002696871758, 0.018469862639904022, 0.03105839341878891, 0.002458815462887287, 0.03741612285375595, 0.03554432839155197, 0.03533162176609039, 0.013594173826277256, -0.028910990804433823, -0.0286535806953907, 0.017293788492679596, 0.025302192196249962, 0.009677452966570854, -0.010903440415859222, -0.0004768560756929219, -0.02954736351966858, -0.01408408023416996, 0.010733629576861858, -0.004772231448441744, 0.008460155688226223, -0.00038171076448634267, 0.0020529450848698616, -0.004994276911020279, -0.030058912932872772, -0.0004897968610748649, -0.02091361954808235, 0.042504407465457916, 0.04588904231786728, -0.005525405518710613, -0.01594921573996544, -0.030802471563220024, 0.004475080873817205, -0.008797852322459221, 0.01314191147685051, 0.029081402346491814, 0.006410724483430386, -0.04240376874804497, -0.008665149100124836, -0.019326908513903618, -0.02724563516676426, -0.005904369987547398, 0.01778896525502205, -0.11035829037427902, 0.008860304951667786, -0.006153566297143698, 0.022630982100963593, 0.025840139016509056, -0.0662076324224472, 0.037378955632448196, -0.10016951709985733, 0.08492262661457062, 0.03641410171985626, -0.0008537115645594895, -0.04681459441781044, -0.015044947154819965, -0.04059504345059395, 0.011340797878801823, 0.07552862912416458, 0.013810740783810616, -0.005196343641728163, 0.026628514751791954, 0.06292081624269485, 0.009996428154408932, -0.04860850051045418, 0.029217319563031197, -0.03683260828256607, 0.00987996906042099, 0.006860790774226189, -0.004990478977560997, 0.03607349842786789, -0.0007285871542990208, 0.014075573533773422, -0.03470047935843468, -0.013108781538903713, -0.021540064364671707, -0.019117143005132675, 0.021845275536179543, -0.001270391745492816, -0.0022038233000785112, 0.053889621049165726, -0.01729007437825203, 0.021631533280014992, 0.0036070598289370537, -0.008695900440216064, -0.04308546707034111, 0.02962736412882805, -0.044146470725536346, -0.02046814374625683, -0.023751843720674515, -0.007043264806270599, 0.033262670040130615, -0.029056860134005547, -0.0345916710793972, 0.05675667151808739, -0.0410015732049942, -0.02724737860262394, 0.025082001462578773, 0.04107214882969856, 0.05835077166557312, -0.0005541426362469792, -0.0011470630997791886, -0.013062480837106705, -0.028331642970442772, -0.027206990867853165, -0.00663276482373476, 0.04172036424279213, -0.004285190254449844, 0.004383582156151533, 0.02218327671289444, -0.01882287859916687, 0.02790539152920246, -0.011653379537165165, 0.026483388617634773, -0.003360695904120803, -0.012782633304595947, 0.019724931567907333, 0.0233024712651968, 0.059175144881010056, 0.004797356203198433, 0.015472250990569592, 0.03799176216125488, -0.010040249675512314, 0.0009423071169294417, -0.01985333114862442, -0.0022247224114835262, -0.0020127641037106514, -0.01900949887931347, 0.029111262410879135, -0.018102673813700676, 0.017759909853339195, 0.01051095686852932, 0.01227665040642023, 0.019933871924877167, 0.03241892158985138, -0.025639234110713005, 0.005010326858609915, 0.006851571146398783, -0.05365646257996559, -0.017716292291879654, -0.06409949064254761, -0.017367660999298096, -0.02737514115869999, 0.05719983950257301, 0.021825848147273064, 0.035688046365976334, 0.007821994833648205, -0.0037310714833438396, 0.013686648570001125, 0.0733095034956932, -0.07812169939279556, -0.060204003006219864, -0.058676037937402725, -0.025339260697364807, -0.00007847863162169233, -0.08214585483074188 ]
<p>I am investigating a common discrepancy between male and female self-reports on a survey about sexual experiences. Generally, women report ~2/3 higher rates then men do. I have modified the survey and now need to find out if/how the discrepancy between males' and females' reporting rates may have changed. Males and Females each fill out both verisons (modified and original) of there gender-specific survey. So, what i want to compare is the difference between male-and-female difference scores on the original survey, and male-and-female differences on the newer/modified survey. What specific statistical test could I use here?</p>
73,825
[ -0.050759054720401764, -0.023353442549705505, -0.00959477573633194, 0.01877729967236519, 0.027214907109737396, -0.00044809310929849744, 0.01451549306511879, -0.024692853912711143, 0.008752060122787952, 0.014174651354551315, 0.03729397803544998, 0.04619591310620308, 0.04257948696613312, -0.002065722132101655, 0.020660124719142914, -0.0027519462164491415, -0.013409511186182499, 0.006978464312851429, 0.00613149581477046, 0.0021220955532044172, -0.009540359489619732, 0.009892073459923267, -0.002363295527175069, -0.007383692543953657, -0.028940923511981964, 0.03058108687400818, 0.0446820966899395, -0.06117311865091324, 0.03353286534547806, 0.03406958654522896, -0.031595055013895035, -0.017958451062440872, 0.010181369259953499, 0.03230258449912071, -0.011594561859965324, -0.014871197752654552, -0.03286989405751228, -0.0026897932402789593, -0.01251013670116663, 0.06957139819860458, -0.03718109056353569, 0.011452818289399147, -0.013385838828980923, 0.05308481678366661, -0.03586374595761299, -0.012826571241021156, -0.01634223200380802, -0.02019294537603855, 0.024949127808213234, -0.0545894131064415, 0.06260541081428528, 0.006022041663527489, 0.0408671498298645, -0.005430411547422409, -0.031288016587495804, 0.025522317737340927, 0.0690319687128067, 0.06722591072320938, -0.007943025790154934, -0.05332823097705841, -0.02395910955965519, -0.029315285384655, 0.023181302472949028, -0.022664504125714302, -0.06669747084379196, 0.017880890518426895, -0.05804255232214928, -0.054156187921762466, 0.02677377313375473, -0.03135562315583229, 0.013475805521011353, 0.0544583797454834, 0.05041107162833214, 0.0022850779350847006, -0.0027369253803044558, -0.06624971330165863, 0.00021738924260716885, 0.03662854805588722, 0.02478967234492302, 0.02987837605178356, -0.01895095221698284, 0.014616579748690128, 0.027411216869950294, 0.04516759514808655, 0.017861148342490196, -0.055046189576387405, 0.057555679231882095, -0.0003175404272042215, -0.0062898206524550915, 0.028267482295632362, -0.04942947253584862, -0.020254366099834442, -0.007698568049818277, 0.01305939070880413, -0.04799482226371765, 0.0010370865929871798, -0.011586152017116547, 0.055590201169252396, -0.011991092935204506, -0.036353569477796555, 0.02017979882657528, -0.022129883989691734, 0.05644094944000244, 0.039771731942892075, -0.036974359303712845, -0.010920625180006027, -0.02379399910569191, 0.00596351595595479, -0.005056607071310282, -0.00978454202413559, -0.001019465271383524, 0.014983689412474632, 0.012870865873992443, 0.005031272303313017, 0.07066909968852997, 0.018569333478808403, -0.004856121260672808, -0.04312397539615631, 0.08582063019275665, 0.05548440292477608, 0.03177134692668915, -0.017950154840946198, 0.03700701892375946, -0.0203224029392004, -0.029993437230587006, 0.002241181442514062, 0.03303763270378113, 0.0029041545931249857, -0.00904632918536663, 0.04247497394680977, -0.024131042882800102, -0.02376067079603672, 0.04382315278053284, -0.03467327728867531, 0.010522814467549324, 0.00921853817999363, -0.09468543529510498, -0.04997573792934418, 0.004799272399395704, 0.008143264800310135, -0.013688717037439346, -0.07571478188037872, -0.0021611996926367283, 0.03534557297825813, 0.029594022780656815, 0.004760715179145336, 0.06798579543828964, 0.007415027357637882, 0.025415632873773575, 0.03223130851984024, -0.028283266350626945, -0.036895751953125, -0.02389357052743435, -0.035217683762311935, -0.009949375875294209, -0.0683986023068428, 0.006560360547155142, 0.004478794988244772, -0.034021008759737015, -0.010534320957958698, 0.01843993365764618, -0.007844620384275913, -0.0327397845685482, 0.010229699313640594, 0.06233091279864311, -0.012810800224542618, 0.0894562229514122, 0.015632502734661102, -0.011087452061474323, 0.0049481987953186035, -0.007296001072973013, 0.038854289799928665, 0.0263403058052063, 0.030080853030085564, 0.03958549350500107, -0.001659166649915278, -0.04390290752053261, 0.012638777494430542, 0.030658762902021408, -0.008977439254522324, -0.02062956616282463, 0.01833711937069893, -0.01929507590830326, -0.020709093660116196, -0.003003176301717758, 0.019497934728860855, -0.0005332037108018994, -0.04930427297949791, 0.01170799508690834, -0.0501016229391098, -0.06156359612941742, -0.079653300344944, -0.0016221585683524609, -0.002489720471203327, -0.027174487709999084, 0.0006466753548011184, 0.02072931081056595, 0.06808498501777649, -0.03253098204731941, -0.027470950037240982, -0.018880465999245644, -0.011609182693064213, 0.024894673377275467, -0.034082699567079544, -0.013626356609165668, 0.03389829397201538, 0.039912231266498566, -0.008805669844150543, 0.01731841266155243, -0.02712985686957836, -0.03478337079286575, 0.024358151480555534, -0.04596878960728645, 0.0032573516946285963, -0.02152174338698387, 0.0045848870649933815, 0.006320224609225988, -0.002124444581568241, -0.0024761678650975227, 0.019343184307217598, -0.04590142145752907, 0.07784450054168701, 0.03540056198835373, -0.020836718380451202, -0.010977678000926971, -0.010111220180988312, 0.040203068405389786, -0.01778305508196354, -0.005538275931030512, -0.02566615864634514, -0.05938703939318657, 0.014180292375385761, 0.019012073054909706, -0.02815726213157177, -0.04629388079047203, 0.0032695159316062927, 0.054816991090774536, -0.009816617704927921, -0.01977064646780491, 0.03525421395897865, 0.02430102601647377, -0.05641448497772217, 0.006922501605004072, 0.027348816394805908, 0.003387933364138007, 0.05254017934203148, 0.045967161655426025, 0.019473597407341003, 0.048882145434617996, 0.026027411222457886, 0.014725511893630028, 0.03215218335390091, -0.0298859141767025, -0.005178453400731087, -0.003781246952712536, -0.015867508947849274, 0.04252921789884567, -0.04615645483136177, -0.01688956841826439, 0.033918946981430054, -0.00565649988129735, 0.019063442945480347, 0.015764981508255005, -0.00871813390403986, 0.01176975667476654, 0.035668063908815384, -0.024550721049308777, 0.009623633697628975, 0.010425965301692486, -0.021891135722398758, 0.015123593620955944, -0.02659780904650688, 0.002430725609883666, -0.03418796509504318, -0.022732125595211983, 0.01789437234401703, 0.013880969025194645, -0.0006027014460414648, 0.011817023158073425, -0.005245732143521309, -0.01373608224093914, -0.009108309634029865, 0.019049473106861115, -0.02453107200562954, -0.06554881483316422, 0.0037527969107031822, 0.0273412074893713, -0.010499943047761917, 0.0213699359446764, -0.014409231953322887, 0.017510490491986275, 0.05120203644037247, 0.002021216321736574, -0.043181829154491425, 0.016998182982206345, -0.000004305561560613569, 0.018427744507789612, -0.010415447875857353, -0.021875932812690735, 0.040919624269008636, 0.005841528996825218, -0.006238026078790426, 0.030435670167207718, -0.03357069566845894, -0.002947145840153098, -0.003985538613051176, -0.010813454166054726, 0.017820172011852264, -0.032304830849170685, -0.0016238278476521373, 0.026996778324246407, -0.019306665286421776, 0.00948654767125845, -0.03681397810578346, -0.05465874820947647, 0.027987780049443245, 0.0037722084671258926, 0.028147373348474503, -0.029509451240301132, 0.00356435333378613, 0.01815125159919262, 0.06176777929067612, -0.022425223141908646, -0.0410027951002121, 0.02422906458377838, -0.03891010954976082, -0.0035732414107769728, 0.024010924622416496, 0.008085905574262142, 0.0031960762571543455, 0.02329198271036148, 0.025754226371645927, 0.01819486729800701, 0.021590808406472206, 0.016605563461780548, -0.02444479987025261, 0.010094690136611462, 0.027194304391741753, -0.02280525676906109, 0.022659558802843094, 0.005639059003442526, -0.043805062770843506, -0.017928995192050934, 0.012691888958215714, 0.013770903460681438, -0.0017774016596376896, -0.028454259037971497, 0.03429540619254112, 0.006068564485758543, -0.02261824533343315, -0.0007547378190793097, 0.02709210105240345, -0.009019237942993641, 0.010987861081957817, -0.023384742438793182, 0.015714628621935844, 0.004903463181108236, -0.02017918974161148, 0.01233033835887909, 0.06321478635072708, 0.03951007127761841, -0.014541391283273697, -0.00497593404725194, -0.02353944070637226, 0.011944041587412357, 0.045312196016311646, -0.005881558638066053, -0.038246456533670425, 0.07055714726448059, 0.03020215965807438, 0.03818574920296669, -0.00898986030369997, -0.03745028004050255, 0.022123487666249275, -0.049691975116729736, 0.017684103921055794, 0.005377988796681166, 0.032813288271427155, -0.015623380430042744, 0.04972746968269348, 0.044855549931526184, 0.029482457786798477, 0.00011750934208976105, -0.00812793429940939, -0.05485856533050537, 0.03934738412499428, -0.031706858426332474, 0.00695313885807991, 0.03308306634426117, 0.009945605881512165, 0.02742225117981434, 0.0016959479544311762, -0.01708170212805271, 0.01741962693631649, 0.0069895414635539055, -0.031911637634038925, 0.012322519905865192, -0.02192786894738674, -0.0015143270138651133, 0.03160803020000458, 0.04455668479204178, -0.005196418147534132, -0.01375512033700943, 0.015981432050466537, 0.023863311856985092, 0.009680931456387043, -0.03473038598895073, -0.04282752051949501, 0.01786472648382187, -0.004041226115077734, 0.0574558824300766, 0.025119800120592117, 0.03120320849120617, -0.02401898428797722, 0.05225042626261711, -0.01733274944126606, -0.0013868631795048714, 0.0582381971180439, 0.011538517661392689, -0.01617315411567688, -0.011386971920728683, 0.004725927021354437, -0.03405752778053284, 0.016002895310521126, 0.020369157195091248, 0.005081926938146353, 0.037941206246614456, 0.04968953877687454, -0.05649613216519356, 0.01255169790238142, 0.027490820735692978, 0.016351846978068352, 0.007939056493341923, -0.025489442050457, -0.029602233320474625, -0.02293309010565281, -0.04777655377984047, 0.028516128659248352, 0.04655054956674576, 0.009321511723101139, -0.027981869876384735, 0.04572011157870293, -0.02765832096338272, -0.06738297641277313, -0.009053434245288372, -0.005422528833150864, 0.032242629677057266, 0.004396419040858746, -0.012564715929329395, 0.01802281104028225, 0.030409686267375946, 0.04214506596326828, 0.007433023769408464, -0.012461280450224876, -0.06767607480287552, 0.003491342766210437, 0.04112962260842323, 0.042704060673713684, -0.06729652732610703, -0.03703201934695244, 0.00413153413683176, 0.011506498791277409, 0.03212853521108627, -0.01563783921301365, -0.015110171400010586, 0.002103336388245225, 0.0019539122004061937, -0.026669222861528397, 0.01974349096417427, -0.035937342792749405, 0.02942516654729843, 0.0066977920942008495, 0.007910482585430145, -0.011010796763002872, -0.034216757863759995, -0.022904224693775177, -0.00307174283079803, 0.060988057404756546, 0.09267162531614304, -0.0059203701093792915, 0.01104417722672224, -0.0023255120031535625, -0.007841313257813454, -0.023860467597842216, -0.03823688253760338, 0.011097938753664494, 0.017447737976908684, 0.00838914792984724, 0.05302795395255089, -0.019072089344263077, -0.004246833734214306, -0.004923352971673012, 0.0012307929573580623, -0.023810027167201042, 0.014817350544035435, -0.011956489644944668, 0.04045897722244263, 0.011750237084925175, 0.017320245504379272, 0.061171434819698334, 0.003209668444469571, 0.02191975712776184, 0.015613345429301262, -0.02366427704691887, 0.0029776650480926037, -0.03811827301979065, -0.026463495567440987, -0.02850119210779667, 0.014285091310739517, -0.008694302290678024, 0.06594911962747574, -0.016788896173238754, -0.008802350610494614, -0.046020686626434326, -0.006368144880980253, 0.012835662811994553, 0.0197751484811306, -0.00160011847037822, 0.009431346319615841, 0.012957417406141758, 0.01200717594474554, -0.003076554974541068, 0.011877577751874924, -0.00327847758308053, -0.028771014884114265, -0.042163923382759094, -0.010286470875144005, -0.05184497311711311, 0.009582570753991604, -0.04482598230242729, -0.052316706627607346, 0.04038380831480026, -0.023417970165610313, 0.0545198880136013, -0.032313890755176544, 0.026894204318523407, 0.02656097523868084, -0.07509846985340118, 0.0149195222184062, 0.015518193133175373, 0.014158341102302074, 0.042994629591703415, -0.02871905267238617, 0.028354600071907043, 0.0004413504502736032, -0.0081583671271801, -0.09156936407089233, -0.06624031066894531, 0.05072630196809769, -0.00213939999230206, -0.04272829368710518, -0.00708296662196517, 0.01254116091877222, -0.02800772897899151, 0.004198145121335983, -0.016609860584139824, 0.07122199982404709, 0.016035879030823708, -0.020425355061888695, -0.0058408984914422035, -0.007936235517263412, 0.06778542697429657, -0.008341720327734947, 0.0033937455154955387, -0.009241733700037003, -0.012485647574067116, -0.012937940657138824, -0.024166198447346687, -0.002911918330937624, -0.033539824187755585, -0.026515934616327286, -0.014992065727710724, -0.009244107641279697, 0.06804000586271286, -0.03898519277572632, -0.00821866374462843, -0.006451819092035294, -0.014658722095191479, 0.012016522698104382, -0.03743968531489372, 0.011712264269590378, -0.046939920634031296, -0.01680516079068184, -0.06544715166091919, -0.0070871710777282715, -0.00344189559109509, 0.007863317616283894, 0.026058383285999298, 0.022691313177347183, -0.04632978513836861, -0.005716775543987751, 0.060147158801555634, 0.003498557722195983, -0.002477718284353614, 0.01534022856503725, -0.004422453697770834, 0.018569495528936386, 0.006652602460235357, -0.023240303620696068, -0.011412842199206352, 0.03343570604920387, -0.05065805837512016, -0.00851947907358408, -0.017185404896736145, -0.0010764902690425515, 0.06760886311531067, -0.005503347609192133, 0.03455960005521774, 0.02842124179005623, 0.03370935842394829, 0.01627556048333645, -0.03275619447231293, 0.022556334733963013, 0.010049179196357727, -0.026549890637397766, 0.01836915872991085, -0.0266380924731493, 0.010391565971076488, 0.028041282668709755, 0.02309487946331501, 0.003907643724232912, 0.06829337030649185, 0.03128345310688019, 0.030014924705028534, 0.06976432353258133, -0.041647668927907944, -0.05545888841152191, 0.03300507366657257, -0.044205442070961, 0.022520503029227257, -0.044876180589199066, 0.011334279552102089, 0.04701296240091324, 0.02360902540385723, 0.008115706965327263, -0.009906898252665997, -0.03756663575768471, -0.07495547086000443, -0.01235567219555378, 0.02006564661860466, -0.006029023323208094, 0.024369830265641212, 0.012728139758110046, 0.05356555059552193, 0.0010336826089769602, 0.018407797440886497, 0.004534499254077673, -0.09459065645933151, -0.0034943558275699615, 0.009360921569168568, -0.05335889756679535, 0.0461147278547287, -0.008682049810886383, -0.0001701788860373199, 0.02555898204445839, -0.025369439274072647, -0.005397356580942869, -0.0011632846435531974, 0.014152535237371922, -0.009555764496326447, 0.04497446492314339, -0.035310592502355576, 0.019066860899329185, -0.003583414014428854, 0.02750531956553459, 0.08151188492774963, 0.06442609429359436, 0.051574792712926865, -0.05816194787621498, 0.07854289561510086, -0.006333307363092899, 0.0034177887719124556, 0.014825449325144291, 0.020384743809700012, 0.0294951144605875, -0.028041856363415718, 0.04502390697598457, 0.056075938045978546, 0.01865988038480282, -0.008419245481491089, 0.08042538166046143, 0.00962877832353115, -0.03469584137201309, 0.008693992160260677, -0.001252576825208962, 0.03795268014073372, -0.009582535363733768, -0.03517553210258484, -0.012255172245204449, 0.029691800475120544, -0.019875865429639816, -0.03165609762072563, -0.029354341328144073, 0.019376587122678757, 0.03492644429206848, -0.022930463775992393, 0.008051354438066483, 0.002780121983960271, 0.039102230221033096, -0.04491078853607178, -0.035060152411460876, 0.013172454200685024, -0.019201943650841713, 0.01407619845122099, 0.03439199924468994, -0.001288768369704485, -0.0036741825751960278, 0.012158962897956371, 0.017552806064486504, -0.055286508053541183, -0.05928143858909607, -0.040405016392469406, 0.02565516158938408, 0.02529064379632473, -0.026876334100961685, -0.016494328156113625, 0.0005155032849870622, -0.04162069037556648, -0.0225550327450037, -0.02226600982248783, 0.025711411610245705, 0.02670121379196644, -0.011175296269357204, -0.0024339016526937485, -0.042716097086668015, 0.0077741616405546665, -0.019883235916495323, 0.04327933117747307, 0.055248554795980453, -0.024734456092119217, -0.03241575509309769, -0.021161137148737907, 0.016607630997896194, -0.01607237569987774, -0.032222915440797806, 0.03237207233905792, 0.012492514215409756, -0.0034488521050661802, -0.0028771795332431793, -0.006712833885103464, 0.022103728726506233, 0.031405895948410034, 0.00004058587001054548, -0.0010108628775924444, -0.014193402603268623, -0.017592575401067734, -0.00089572265278548, 0.002236289205029607, 0.01855895109474659, -0.06533966213464737, -0.0059447381645441055, 0.07421815395355225, -0.007061005104333162, 0.05102936550974846, -0.007048254832625389, 0.0016279106494039297, 0.04328484833240509, 0.06819728761911392, -0.0540270172059536, -0.016712453216314316, 0.003734495723620057, -0.028428617864847183, -0.030859528109431267, -0.05690847709774971, 0.040723249316215515, 0.003385499818250537, 0.011120785027742386, -0.006706909276545048, -0.03026115521788597, -0.008440613746643066, 0.011305727064609528, -0.0014070904580876231, -0.029828926548361778, -0.05450517311692238, -0.008910125121474266, 0.0001269854255951941, 0.006289844401180744, -0.041483212262392044, -0.0632566288113594, -0.006497617345303297, 0.012037331238389015, -0.018895836547017097, -0.02147122658789158, 0.0005831813905388117, -0.018968774005770683, -0.029657859355211258, -0.001845551305450499, -0.026391219347715378, -0.01563018560409546, -0.04428714141249657, 0.030628306791186333, 0.013916606083512306, -0.006959218531847, -0.00105132011231035, -0.03229905292391777, 0.007941249758005142, 0.03880411386489868, 0.002973673865199089, 0.01421903446316719, 0.014134937897324562, 0.0013947851257398725, 0.03101956471800804, 0.06674734503030777, -0.01850847154855728, -0.03398324176669121, 0.03904185816645622, -0.07452541589736938, -0.02613719552755356, 0.059680141508579254, -0.0037283957935869694, 0.021736662834882736, 0.008364335633814335, -0.006937284022569656, 0.03931162506341934, 0.06449001282453537, -0.02240118384361267, -0.011343319900333881, -0.015375385992228985, 0.016230018809437752, 0.020251354202628136, 0.006391260772943497, -0.0029243433382362127, -0.0015102281467989087, -0.043977126479148865, 0.03997548669576645, 0.04237271472811699, 0.0063031502068042755, 0.01998133398592472, -0.010129382833838463, 0.005147139076143503, 0.006680991500616074, 0.0205010324716568, -0.016524847596883774, 0.03467736020684242, 0.07009676098823547, -0.042258016765117645, 0.006965120323002338, -0.008143470622599125, 0.008137525990605354, -0.09298472106456757, -0.005641255993396044, 0.0005739019252359867, -0.001423289650119841, 0.013310011476278305, -0.06841973960399628, 0.057735852897167206, 0.02021149918437004, -0.0408758707344532, 0.0164535790681839, -0.02207016758620739, 0.0015046721091493964, -0.030964192003011703, -0.019831236451864243, -0.02229216694831848, 0.01436832919716835, 0.03519897907972336, 0.011758088134229183, -0.01483213808387518, 0.02065066620707512, -0.01004710141569376, -0.012535703368484974, -0.004801269620656967, 0.018298741430044174, 0.016369055956602097, -0.07004933059215546, -0.010110631585121155, -0.06150227040052414, -0.0781869888305664, 0.03387812152504921, -0.035427276045084, 0.03326629847288132, 0.005604978185147047, 0.008446179330348969, -0.008420122787356377, 0.0322418212890625, 0.015671947970986366, -0.00042912393109872937, -0.03050779178738594, 0.005702737718820572, -0.03112306445837021, 0.04537234082818031, -0.045723769813776016, 0.005858848337084055, 0.04264213517308235, -0.01515632588416338, -0.00037123667425476015, 0.005964940879493952, -0.03196634352207184, -0.0031957020983099937, -0.01310269720852375, -0.03361067920923233, 0.07153214514255524, -0.02627572976052761, 0.005168784409761429, -0.057905666530132294, -0.0232931450009346, 0.03474532067775726, 0.038827791810035706, -0.03701307252049446, 0.009436318650841713, 0.021827947348356247, -0.023139556869864464, 0.003609929932281375, -0.0009673839085735381, 0.006531537510454655, -0.06972090154886246, -0.008100510574877262, -0.0274162907153368, 0.033916160464286804, -0.01749751716852188, 0.005510058719664812, 0.031514544039964676, 0.04653901234269142, -0.038945868611335754, -0.03128064051270485, 0.01225301343947649, -0.016390196979045868, 0.021507427096366882, -0.06983570754528046, 0.039495307952165604, 0.012008411809802055, -0.06795945763587952, -0.02797788567841053, -0.0156288743019104, -0.030762039124965668, 0.006182572804391384, 0.07081274688243866, -0.0028499749023467302, -0.02696683071553707, -0.012301340699195862, 0.03878500312566757, -0.020924441516399384, -0.06584878265857697, 0.03366127982735634, -0.03387979790568352, -0.007938260212540627, -0.006621883250772953, -0.006824892945587635, -0.007065373472869396, 0.02211972512304783, 0.024092767387628555, -0.025315534323453903, 0.016461485996842384, -0.03262695297598839, 0.0215480774641037, 0.011745898053050041, 0.04262453690171242, -0.01022379845380783, 0.023962467908859253, -0.013261153362691402, 0.024236561730504036, 0.009827304631471634, 0.02190226875245571, -0.055050771683454514, 0.0409436896443367, -0.009218735620379448, -0.0017780933994799852, 0.03317635506391525, 0.015223530121147633, -0.008050513453781605, -0.04010222479701042, 0.00013487602700479329, 0.011971728876233101, 0.0011552117066457868, 0.012767767533659935, 0.01525400672107935, 0.030658718198537827, -0.009295723401010036, -0.02085511013865471, 0.00899693462997675, 0.03486168757081032, -0.04072121903300285, 0.002348996000364423, 0.02765950933098793, 0.04314510524272919, 0.021170100197196007, 0.007006136234849691, 0.007404872216284275, -0.03280098736286163, 0.04234972223639488, 0.018454765900969505, 0.018809648230671883, -0.002638298086822033, -0.00036797914071939886, 0.03645837679505348, -0.0029908306896686554, 0.01462556142359972, 0.0006020974251441658, -0.011253545060753822, 0.026898443698883057, -0.013085812330245972, -0.015195736661553383, -0.04868755862116814, -0.021782152354717255, -0.03187654912471771, -0.04110169783234596, 0.05723147466778755, 0.017823655158281326, 0.021293265745043755, -0.010182016529142857, 0.02797280065715313, -0.02086488902568817, 0.05417098104953766, -0.0014784419909119606, 0.04327771067619324, -0.03751080110669136, 0.009760758839547634, -0.02042602188885212, -0.010156828910112381, -0.04028245806694031, 0.03375804424285889, 0.06903277337551117, 0.016102155670523643, 0.014879358932375908, -0.008336988277733326, -0.021586552262306213, -0.023053715005517006, 0.05395987629890442, -0.05819501355290413, -0.0651901364326477, -0.046020835638046265, 0.014055458828806877, 0.010968667455017567, -0.028734175488352776 ]
<p>I am trying to find a more aesthetic way to present an interaction with a quadratic term in a logistic regression (categorisation of continuous variable is not appropriate).</p> <p>For a simpler example I use a linear term.</p> <pre><code>set.seed(1) df&lt;-data.frame(y=factor(rbinom(50,1,0.5)),var1=rnorm(50),var2=factor(rbinom(50,1,0.5))) mod&lt;-glm(y ~ var2*var1 , family="binomial" , df) #plot of predicted probabilities of two levels new.df&lt;-with(df,data.frame(expand.grid(var1=seq(-2,3,by=0.01),var2=levels(var2)))) pred&lt;-predict(mod,new.df,se.fit=T,type="r") with(new.df,plot(var1,pred$fit)) #plot the difference in predicted probabilities trans.logit&lt;-function(x) exp(x)/(1+exp(x)) pp&lt;-trans.logit(coef(mod)[1] + seq(-2,3,by=0.01) * coef(mod)[3]) -trans.logit((coef(mod)[1]+coef(mod)[2]) + seq(-2,3,by=0.01) * (coef(mod)[3]+coef(mod)[4])) plot(seq(-2,3,by=0.01),pp) </code></pre> <h3>Questions</h3> <ul> <li>How can I plot the predicted probability difference between the two levels of var2 (rather than the 2 levels separately) at different values of var1?</li> <li>Is there a way to define contrasts so I can use these in the glm so I can then pass this to predict? - I need a CI for the difference in probabilities</li> </ul>
73,826
[ -0.04478347301483154, 0.01460637990385294, 0.010759442113339901, 0.018427491188049316, 0.00887167826294899, 0.017507359385490417, -0.014577539637684822, -0.04385851323604584, 0.07357387244701385, -0.02021491713821888, 0.05376556143164635, 0.043057333678007126, 0.0341622419655323, 0.02890307828783989, 0.058816056698560715, 0.01803642138838768, 0.007282850798219442, -0.009334031492471695, 0.004662245977669954, 0.015475303865969181, -0.025469915941357613, -0.0024067810736596584, 0.011544938199222088, 0.01955992542207241, -0.02048507332801819, 0.07606682926416397, 0.04088423028588295, -0.022180521860718727, -0.03509581461548805, 0.0662241205573082, -0.03690975904464722, -0.032012708485126495, 0.03373585268855095, 0.009174054488539696, 0.03383152559399605, 0.05064873397350311, 0.007418008521199226, -0.023877857252955437, 0.0015832623466849327, 0.007726478390395641, -0.028679899871349335, 0.003630825085565448, 0.013654228299856186, 0.03755290061235428, -0.008606789633631706, 0.004544386174529791, -0.009707829914987087, 0.02552652917802334, 0.06355006247758865, -0.028397556394338608, 0.028015021234750748, 0.000554436061065644, 0.02983594499528408, 0.021129563450813293, -0.04816625639796257, -0.013028237968683243, 0.05517766997218132, 0.0676346868276596, 0.0020441708620637655, -0.038928188383579254, -0.030629785731434822, -0.03894089162349701, -0.009726041927933693, -0.03418001905083656, -0.010174709372222424, -0.015511359088122845, 0.029215559363365173, 0.000928661203943193, 0.03543908894062042, -0.025215016677975655, 0.004191596060991287, 0.017559392377734184, 0.018586257472634315, -0.011439408175647259, 0.018200688064098358, -0.020687507465481758, -0.02960146591067314, -0.030916105955839157, 0.030944425612688065, -0.012647922150790691, -0.031185753643512726, 0.023541735485196114, 0.0005005784914828837, 0.030493205413222313, -0.012753425166010857, -0.008160543628036976, 0.03910372406244278, -0.025559548288583755, 0.03081185556948185, 0.02122592367231846, -0.0346175953745842, 0.032780952751636505, 0.0632312223315239, 0.016497867181897163, -0.027127666398882866, 0.05580448731780052, 0.002956582698971033, 0.012836976908147335, 0.03967062756419182, 0.022781934589147568, -0.02564917504787445, -0.042814262211322784, 0.031094251200556755, 0.04078800603747368, -0.023585129529237747, -0.011638090945780277, -0.0182843878865242, -0.02036166749894619, 0.043415989726781845, -0.052809376269578934, 0.004391721915453672, 0.04589439183473587, -0.008876552805304527, 0.013043657876551151, -0.017334410920739174, -0.06774026900529861, -0.0045680636540055275, -0.025637462735176086, 0.0568658784031868, 0.04870307818055153, 0.04624427109956741, -0.02053416706621647, 0.013851884752511978, -0.02374645508825779, -0.06926935911178589, -0.02693473920226097, 0.03107035718858242, 0.00920286774635315, -0.026381030678749084, 0.03852728381752968, -0.014400939457118511, -0.0440940335392952, 0.02740759216248989, -0.0024647528771311045, -0.0006491789827123284, -0.000501499860547483, -0.06052134931087494, -0.029578499495983124, 0.01591626927256584, -0.011189217679202557, -0.0027644350193440914, -0.04023940488696098, -0.010941960848867893, 0.023201067000627518, 0.045542869716882706, 0.015285078436136246, 0.009037049487233162, 0.01422965805977583, 0.010950377210974693, 0.015167265199124813, -0.004543266259133816, 0.03232401981949806, -0.03719848766922951, -0.018731698393821716, -0.023718098178505898, -0.048915185034275055, 0.018566763028502464, 0.0065056337043643, -0.03011338785290718, 0.008681485429406166, 0.015368148684501648, -0.03488590195775032, -0.005472109187394381, -0.009745944291353226, -0.018431955948472023, -0.023026341572403908, 0.047667473554611206, -0.01727994531393051, 0.01100203488022089, 0.03372781351208687, -0.05220421776175499, 0.006079549435526133, -0.02413089945912361, 0.028156988322734833, 0.012655639089643955, -0.010405204258859158, 0.02690611593425274, -0.041534699499607086, 0.010016072541475296, 0.016063271090388298, -0.018586674705147743, -0.01830773614346981, -0.00608667079359293, -0.04797358065843582, 0.01715864986181259, -0.006215710658580065, 0.014579370617866516, -0.0037383371964097023, 0.08958610892295837, -0.027029812335968018, -0.047006502747535706, -0.0546620711684227, -0.028919270262122154, 0.00903294887393713, -0.03851063922047615, 0.012841396033763885, 0.014017398469150066, 0.05471673235297203, -0.0034893271513283253, 0.002184647833928466, -0.03298494964838028, 0.01608828827738762, 0.01980089396238327, -0.026951758190989494, 0.002615374978631735, 0.027823688462376595, 0.035855188965797424, -0.009682726114988327, 0.043822549283504486, -0.039608750492334366, -0.021897705271840096, 0.007919308729469776, -0.024157974869012833, 0.007858514785766602, 0.0051757269538939, -0.04641837254166603, -0.02826528064906597, 0.03813573345541954, -0.043556150048971176, 0.032245103269815445, -0.09198277443647385, 0.02022486925125122, 0.10024150460958481, -0.0036652053240686655, -0.00499377679079771, 0.0023215252440422773, -0.021049970760941505, 0.03890199959278107, -0.0219036266207695, -0.01660996489226818, -0.0249820277094841, -0.017455769702792168, 0.0653967633843422, 0.01917949877679348, 0.029027141630649567, -0.00641055591404438, 0.04482496902346611, -0.06184523180127144, 0.026816165074706078, 0.04856622591614723, 0.03530081361532211, -0.0022631515748798847, 0.029931463301181793, 0.0037396668922156096, 0.02356943115592003, -0.01089696679264307, 0.039735738188028336, 0.013307908549904823, 0.021597757935523987, -0.02313319593667984, -0.027879808098077774, 0.06156834214925766, -0.017579423263669014, -0.021370504051446915, -0.01769145019352436, 0.011399086564779282, 0.048121847212314606, 0.02170727215707302, 0.003858528332784772, 0.041736770421266556, 0.0165224839001894, -0.008068257942795753, 0.00991670973598957, -0.027947846800088882, 0.005379904992878437, 0.0897412970662117, -0.03926766663789749, 0.008505763486027718, 0.01690620556473732, -0.04146449640393257, 0.02058391645550728, 0.0017695113783702254, -0.03617040812969208, -0.05314530059695244, -0.03574301302433014, -0.0008268360979855061, 0.00351211940869689, 0.010622186586260796, -0.044418156147003174, -0.03739827871322632, 0.061854038387537, -0.0012912062229588628, 0.03801238164305687, -0.02095109410583973, -0.04841816425323486, -0.01918153464794159, -0.0442689023911953, -0.031216206029057503, 0.009284384548664093, -0.0040706973522901535, -0.03420146927237511, 0.01466446928679943, -0.005756306927651167, -0.04822070151567459, -0.031434644013643265, -0.038776181638240814, -0.024330435320734978, -0.003693927312269807, -0.056085940450429916, 0.05346335843205452, 0.026370719075202942, -0.03753810003399849, -0.03368343040347099, -0.02886868454515934, 0.007497556507587433, -0.028991539031267166, -0.013960246928036213, 0.031151503324508667, 0.028849145397543907, 0.01865612156689167, 0.012089020572602749, -0.011327534914016724, -0.006804845295846462, -0.0812075063586235, -0.03436419740319252, 0.0026338244788348675, 0.04521302506327629, 0.015800144523382187, -0.0010427196975797415, -0.0026003257371485233, 0.054245416074991226, 0.03252381831407547, 0.008511184714734554, -0.0812530517578125, -0.00031022075563669205, -0.015486173331737518, -0.00024156298604793847, -0.021869076415896416, 0.0002488968602847308, 0.04262261465191841, 0.02329709753394127, -0.018769845366477966, 0.023646946996450424, 0.011658793315291405, -0.006994559429585934, -0.005162311717867851, 0.0039161089807748795, -0.007743136957287788, -0.02087666466832161, 0.04880886152386665, -0.005027770064771175, -0.009724433533847332, 0.045227713882923126, -0.004445392172783613, -0.009596575051546097, -0.01720762439072132, -0.02162960357964039, 0.004435580689460039, 0.004789894912391901, 0.03970721736550331, -0.017713062465190887, 0.03971545398235321, 0.0014462595572695136, -0.04524415731430054, 0.005537488032132387, -0.008816528134047985, 0.056882210075855255, -0.020063884556293488, 0.015449171885848045, 0.04046076536178589, 0.026866968721151352, -0.0338265523314476, 0.02987856976687908, 0.017131084576249123, -0.014937493950128555, 0.004659919533878565, -0.04736265912652016, -0.0015194296138361096, 0.05095531418919563, 0.04194246605038643, -0.0028288201428949833, -0.030038898810744286, -0.0004935480537824333, -0.012906501069664955, -0.020685965195298195, 0.009565494023263454, -0.04428975656628609, 0.04818391427397728, 0.025425879284739494, 0.05077502503991127, -0.0021129692904651165, -0.018566204234957695, -0.00224046572111547, 0.0054430607706308365, -0.06595505774021149, 0.03533121943473816, 0.008503397926688194, 0.011431227438151836, -0.014324470423161983, -0.0036339275538921356, 0.045027002692222595, -0.010901043191552162, -0.008482400327920914, 0.013459340669214725, -0.005058131646364927, 0.008399304002523422, 0.0031865190248936415, 0.01150111760944128, 0.0048998212441802025, -0.042304206639528275, -0.007140995003283024, 0.026288216933608055, -0.004246341995894909, 0.034412529319524765, 0.03377510607242584, -0.023413047194480896, 0.03238687664270401, -0.023294653743505478, 0.002976264338940382, 0.043373387306928635, 0.036440249532461166, 0.01891391910612583, 0.011064342223107815, -0.012125215493142605, 0.03484788164496422, 0.0072323596104979515, 0.02698931284248829, 0.07712877541780472, -0.029723357409238815, -0.013282358646392822, 0.006683868356049061, -0.03226416930556297, 0.013988735154271126, 0.018120529130101204, 0.018171066418290138, 0.010935170575976372, 0.05343237146735191, 0.008449919521808624, -0.017971815541386604, 0.028327476233243942, 0.0719555914402008, 0.036652933806180954, -0.02735022082924843, -0.03141719475388527, -0.013522126711905003, -0.017293157055974007, -0.004045689478516579, 0.0052734254859387875, 0.02063901536166668, 0.025419145822525024, -0.008795187808573246, 0.027481136843562126, -0.047206632792949677, -0.010423814877867699, 0.020646532997488976, 0.04345032572746277, 0.04670022800564766, 0.005104056093841791, -0.06947135180234909, -0.04326041787862778, 0.022806119173765182, 0.01158338412642479, -0.022997569292783737, 0.017461350187659264, -0.09734561294317245, -0.005729580298066139, 0.08447898924350739, 0.06056727096438408, -0.031467780470848083, -0.03781072050333023, -0.036576028913259506, -0.028782177716493607, -0.005069300532341003, -0.04855639114975929, 0.0012279241345822811, -0.022861480712890625, 0.008195316419005394, -0.03153557330369949, -0.04633595049381256, -0.09092377126216888, 0.03341525048017502, -0.06638128310441971, 0.0036475544329732656, -0.008609239012002945, -0.028884567320346832, -0.023792382329702377, 0.025683701038360596, 0.007463002111762762, 0.05730206146836281, -0.055829521268606186, -0.04847787320613861, 0.01595720648765564, -0.00168809131719172, -0.008686935529112816, -0.0114928362891078, 0.021253814920783043, 0.011400444433093071, 0.008189835585653782, 0.05118570104241371, -0.0009146776865236461, -0.005573654547333717, -0.009302600286900997, 0.018855510279536247, -0.009732293896377087, 0.004398394376039505, -0.01482249516993761, 0.03526647016406059, 0.02491159550845623, -0.051492754369974136, 0.07251914590597153, 0.05163165181875229, -0.023177480325102806, 0.01812964677810669, -0.04322224110364914, -0.009210523217916489, -0.008753828704357147, -0.05974479392170906, -0.051054444164037704, -0.01890254020690918, -0.00846986472606659, -0.002762825461104512, -0.03516405448317528, 0.010564017109572887, -0.050304461270570755, 0.014982089400291443, 0.01259899977594614, 0.02478805184364319, -0.002377195516601205, -0.012644934467971325, 0.0036414170172065496, -0.005529751069843769, -0.006167205516248941, 0.0018180684419348836, 0.02411729469895363, 0.007684496697038412, 0.015101286582648754, 0.006227341014891863, -0.06696460396051407, -0.0025646458379924297, -0.0005355041939765215, -0.008680769242346287, -0.0008145790779963136, -0.038791805505752563, 0.02308644913136959, 0.0109120337292552, 0.05028754472732544, -0.00825650803744793, -0.05687347799539566, -0.006963134277611971, 0.04258060082793236, -0.008211673237383366, -0.01838117092847824, -0.01680624671280384, 0.020181888714432716, -0.012498578988015652, -0.04065314307808876, -0.03777096047997475, -0.038353580981492996, -0.007650112733244896, -0.03498763591051102, -0.01927226036787033, -0.02646518312394619, -0.017397023737430573, -0.006733390968292952, -0.011316160671412945, 0.008613299578428268, 0.006695491261780262, -0.03603261336684227, 0.03596882149577141, -0.03684649243950844, 0.02215585671365261, 0.05354207009077072, 0.005599356256425381, 0.00208631856366992, 0.00998036190867424, 0.004540006630122662, -0.027975257486104965, 0.005266375839710236, -0.04896029457449913, -0.015067607164382935, -0.0007603442645631731, 0.0220172218978405, 0.017064806073904037, 0.037893861532211304, -0.01448027603328228, -0.05184585973620415, 0.0016928629484027624, -0.005206758622080088, 0.015004861168563366, -0.05311321094632149, 0.0010626219445839524, -0.0001445312227588147, 0.025495655834674835, -0.03729712963104248, 0.0015048471977934241, -0.023237263783812523, -0.029076308012008667, 0.042198654264211655, -0.04406154155731201, 0.009005569852888584, 0.01289320271462202, 0.07791459560394287, 0.01614968664944172, 0.021453430876135826, -0.007241842336952686, -0.015481393784284592, 0.027253592386841774, -0.0003034931141883135, -0.017628004774451256, 0.04787559062242508, 0.015668993815779686, -0.014425445348024368, -0.017707377672195435, -0.04164259880781174, 0.0041784667409956455, 0.0429881252348423, -0.006401112303137779, 0.04003692790865898, 0.04689482972025871, -0.026017360389232635, 0.013791467063128948, -0.03271884843707085, -0.006776277907192707, -0.0005162174929864705, 0.04425344616174698, 0.06627629697322845, -0.028098145499825478, 0.001638354267925024, 0.03510293364524841, 0.024597635492682457, 0.013397341594099998, 0.03786418214440346, -0.010848047211766243, 0.01005526352673769, 0.029935218393802643, -0.0390249639749527, -0.02111838199198246, 0.027735786512494087, -0.02954176440834999, 0.007732979953289032, -0.07048238068819046, -0.05106227844953537, 0.04930133745074272, 0.020088637247681618, -0.0062325941398739815, -0.05169078707695007, -0.036349523812532425, -0.0758926197886467, -0.006950847338885069, 0.04443402960896492, -0.030454985797405243, 0.021451562643051147, 0.007739790715277195, 0.04874374344944954, -0.01723390817642212, 0.04174230992794037, -0.04902656376361847, -0.09935574978590012, -0.020060140639543533, -0.029363013803958893, -0.016682250425219536, 0.06488700211048126, -0.0025658858940005302, -0.02296699769794941, 0.030046094208955765, -0.031905900686979294, 0.019570408388972282, 0.01142734196037054, 0.008834426291286945, -0.003872855333611369, 0.05302548408508301, -0.01603241264820099, 0.016438404098153114, -0.02335977368056774, -0.0030970945954322815, 0.15281160175800323, 0.036178287118673325, 0.04325806722044945, -0.051022954285144806, 0.016761139035224915, 0.028380565345287323, 0.0025540455244481564, 0.0008603284368291497, -0.026730002835392952, 0.010017916560173035, 0.002271740697324276, 0.05489952862262726, 0.05377570912241936, 0.031165042892098427, 0.010612424463033676, 0.04669283330440521, -0.019116096198558807, -0.00015418864495586604, -0.024661805480718613, 0.029864149168133736, -0.012028291821479797, -0.0158896055072546, -0.03149474412202835, -0.003569006687030196, 0.01483402494341135, -0.018537934869527817, -0.04238087683916092, -0.007153814192861319, 0.004873915109783411, -0.00021820332040078938, -0.01192801259458065, 0.020161496475338936, 0.011408040300011635, -0.013082959689199924, 0.01761128567159176, -0.011465942487120628, 0.031093956902623177, -0.0450517013669014, -0.00034426010097377, 0.02348833903670311, -0.02792379818856716, -0.027662508189678192, -0.016742870211601257, 0.019559362903237343, -0.057887252420186996, -0.007191393058747053, -0.05866748094558716, 0.02169164828956127, 0.002525115152820945, -0.047961633652448654, -0.01730327680706978, 0.02438642457127571, 0.037434086203575134, -0.01781800203025341, -0.016778508201241493, 0.03048117086291313, 0.00511561892926693, -0.028206851333379745, -0.01563568226993084, -0.03693186491727829, 0.028567582368850708, -0.003406576346606016, 0.052427440881729126, 0.011251886375248432, -0.050730522722005844, -0.039571065455675125, -0.03458132967352867, 0.024898439645767212, -0.024954117834568024, 0.012571531347930431, 0.050294410437345505, 0.02944488637149334, -0.016914108768105507, -0.030817383900284767, 0.00010466699313838035, 0.012156973592936993, 0.0185781829059124, 0.02214941754937172, -0.003843864193186164, -0.026788463816046715, -0.03419548273086548, 0.030859457328915596, -0.02152900956571102, 0.005634231027215719, -0.014614695683121681, 0.03855161368846893, 0.04597117006778717, 0.018188124522566795, 0.03568178415298462, 0.016238782554864883, 0.014720991253852844, 0.04039423540234566, 0.01796569861471653, -0.03613307327032089, -0.034532833844423294, 0.029396427795290947, -0.03999609500169754, -0.04597639665007591, 0.012571698054671288, 0.05572832375764847, 0.005967481527477503, -0.02377895824611187, -0.0026440012734383345, 0.03125527501106262, -0.014788834378123283, 0.00014864452532492578, 0.03823002800345421, -0.022306740283966064, 0.00030834233621135354, -0.00315351621247828, 0.014902796596288681, 0.0198293998837471, -0.00008332946890732273, -0.03268744796514511, -0.06343642622232437, 0.020643794909119606, -0.015789121389389038, -0.022368060424923897, -0.007016040850430727, -0.018054243177175522, 0.007589257787913084, -0.03605882450938225, -0.03323516249656677, -0.03309151902794838, -0.011527876369655132, -0.015767846256494522, -0.07597154378890991, 0.020814813673496246, 0.02384951338171959, -0.02376062050461769, 0.0028123839292675257, 0.03281739354133606, 0.03540441021323204, 0.039618708193302155, 0.012916835956275463, 0.07059937715530396, 0.006381265819072723, 0.03962773457169533, 0.012270644307136536, -0.01100318692624569, 0.026105577126145363, -0.024039044976234436, -0.03716571629047394, -0.0014405176043510437, 0.013223993591964245, 0.0398302786052227, 0.0016923343064263463, -0.006860165856778622, -0.028931261971592903, 0.03313108906149864, -0.008325531147420406, -0.0016595885390415788, -0.011812751181423664, 0.009468214586377144, 0.008605726063251495, -0.036006614565849304, -0.0014124945737421513, -0.0011358732590451837, 0.007815311662852764, 0.019578272476792336, 0.05129193514585495, -0.007010679692029953, -0.026089774444699287, -0.0007775195990689099, -0.052851058542728424, 0.016977129504084587, 0.005330001004040241, 0.003027632599696517, 0.023071400821208954, 0.031433556228876114, -0.044106289744377136, 0.04594377800822258, -0.0020256750285625458, 0.02361302636563778, -0.13546107709407806, -0.04319700598716736, 0.0072586121968925, 0.0331256203353405, 0.04542303457856178, -0.009332502260804176, 0.002201155526563525, 0.008130092173814774, 0.014283765107393265, 0.013067234307527542, 0.005344908218830824, 0.008310806006193161, -0.016206778585910797, 0.035074714571237564, 0.006205393932759762, 0.013478829525411129, 0.017476165667176247, 0.005150719080120325, 0.05060673505067825, 0.02982325293123722, -0.014347774907946587, -0.02481267601251602, -0.018847893923521042, -0.011364643462002277, 0.001296321745030582, -0.040846701711416245, 0.01911053992807865, -0.011307068169116974, 0.013123322278261185, 0.0520508848130703, 0.006104677449911833, 0.038853079080581665, 0.02395039238035679, 0.031127804890275, 0.027434855699539185, 0.06318657100200653, 0.03065120428800583, 0.0028078879695385695, 0.012580664828419685, 0.010026037693023682, 0.005769034381955862, 0.03273098170757294, -0.04325469955801964, 0.007553070317953825, 0.022509532049298286, 0.02494954504072666, -0.018117964267730713, 0.021358240395784378, -0.009496600367128849, -0.02558737061917782, -0.059240665286779404, 0.0012156938901171088, -0.028563257306814194, -0.029051247984170914, 0.0024625116493552923, -0.030693115666508675, -0.0023778395261615515, 0.02357115037739277, 0.03706129640340805, -0.006320464890450239, 0.02500024065375328, -0.031756650656461716, -0.04165352135896683, 0.007277486380189657, -0.018347308039665222, 0.0032844285015016794, -0.028821300715208054, 0.0004893573932349682, -0.02098296768963337, -0.00011622470628935844, -0.004481316544115543, -0.001807316206395626, -0.0857546254992485, 0.0386047437787056, -0.042000662535429, 0.029182378202676773, 0.024608861654996872, 0.031834591180086136, 0.023396385833621025, -0.0962766483426094, 0.06788729876279831, 0.005025339312851429, -0.020482664927840233, -0.049604158848524094, 0.02732979692518711, -0.05421847477555275, 0.04962925240397453, 0.05288034677505493, -0.0010194178903475404, 0.003658642992377281, 0.005673309788107872, 0.04481407254934311, 0.0022618453949689865, -0.017724091187119484, 0.04527777433395386, -0.006567574571818113, -0.012920975685119629, -0.0022111788857728243, 0.003354437183588743, 0.01040160283446312, 0.032049935311079025, 0.0018953465623781085, -0.015079781413078308, -0.006847620941698551, -0.007829373702406883, -0.03449046239256859, 0.01503969170153141, -0.0023300934117287397, -0.032859500497579575, 0.017173781991004944, -0.0006155093433335423, 0.024059677496552467, 0.031131286174058914, 0.01941220462322235, -0.061690520495176315, 0.013715221546590328, -0.054838478565216064, -0.022676926106214523, 0.008091680705547333, -0.022512560710310936, 0.0035970185417681932, -0.05451034754514694, 0.03093416802585125, 0.019196126610040665, -0.02466347999870777, 0.032910943031311035, 0.02254086174070835, 0.008503084070980549, 0.07165692746639252, -0.009150255471467972, 0.04162909463047981, -0.02786083146929741, -0.029450731351971626, 0.04272543266415596, -0.0002594585530459881, 0.026534749194979668, -0.01986880972981453, 0.0019625641871243715, 0.018200473859906197, -0.0015337285585701466, -0.0021775991190224886, 0.018503207713365555, 0.06337190419435501, -0.0160891804844141, 0.015832433477044106, 0.03939683362841606, -0.016448238864541054, 0.0034432976972311735, 0.004498034715652466, -0.0044427476823329926, 0.038984980434179306, -0.035834744572639465, -0.011993909254670143, -0.032167814671993256, -0.03489195182919502, -0.01168496161699295, -0.011274040676653385, 0.026675956323742867, 0.047999247908592224, 0.03382188826799393, 0.0303958673030138, 0.010251116007566452, -0.02712804265320301, -0.03136822208762169, 0.01708919368684292, 0.01923856884241104, -0.021162111312150955, 0.005329016130417585, 0.0016339780995622277, -0.03376122936606407, 0.008426410146057606, -0.028801169246435165, 0.03343510627746582, -0.002981341676786542, 0.02616235427558422, -0.04394790530204773, -0.024775413796305656, 0.017628544941544533, 0.052816469222307205, -0.048639874905347824, -0.012131776660680771, -0.031545285135507584, 0.011233087629079819, 0.01532072015106678, -0.035951148718595505 ]
<p>I overhead a professor speak about the Cauchy meta-distribution, but I am unable to find anything about it on the web. My question is what is the Cauchy meta distribution and what is the theory behind it?</p>
73,827
[ -0.0355738028883934, -0.01369256991893053, 0.025985801592469215, -0.0596378818154335, 0.025775380432605743, 0.020694416016340256, 0.0032549030147492886, -0.006851577199995518, 0.004489134531468153, -0.04548235237598419, 0.028232160955667496, 0.0446481928229332, 0.0399780236184597, 0.006626217160373926, 0.019235733896493912, 0.030668437480926514, -0.038421403616666794, 0.004842653404921293, -0.029142338782548904, -0.027226785197854042, 0.0031292138155549765, 0.028684943914413452, 0.025685323402285576, -0.03177386149764061, -0.020405245944857597, -0.003045789897441864, 0.018719971179962158, -0.003714216174557805, 0.054908644407987595, 0.013729038648307323, -0.05970067158341408, -0.006262254901230335, -0.01771470531821251, 0.02073705568909645, -0.004075191915035248, -0.005161994602531195, -0.0423663891851902, -0.04163791984319687, -0.01251892652362585, 0.05485595762729645, -0.0503358468413353, -0.029406927525997162, -0.0008693371783010662, 0.0414336621761322, -0.034442346543073654, -0.011508980765938759, -0.014112873002886772, -0.03607757017016411, 0.03485404700040817, -0.08403731137514114, 0.11064457893371582, 0.005526204593479633, 0.032827187329530716, 0.009278924204409122, -0.01304017473012209, 0.01634988561272621, 0.06264188140630722, 0.057844944298267365, -0.02331116795539856, -0.06886760145425797, -0.02728203684091568, -0.021805232390761375, 0.006126243621110916, -0.035821761935949326, -0.009403279051184654, 0.04614652693271637, 0.017118077725172043, -0.033980462700128555, 0.07712123543024063, 0.03407389670610428, 0.0034243131522089243, 0.03063179738819599, 0.029429355636239052, 0.016256190836429596, 0.020913569256663322, -0.015093037858605385, 0.04223434999585152, 0.0075696795247495174, 0.054578229784965515, 0.014132749289274216, 0.03138656169176102, 0.000990276806987822, -0.01214755792170763, 0.024154452607035637, -0.0025071988347917795, -0.02085821144282818, 0.1144532635807991, -0.018558509647846222, 0.009849188849329948, 0.017063438892364502, -0.04389571771025658, -0.008798205293715, 0.0038935861084610224, -0.009597934782505035, -0.0573309026658535, 0.04980200529098511, -0.011140808463096619, 0.03431175649166107, -0.028562815859913826, -0.03944665938615799, 0.01777762733399868, -0.03693727031350136, 0.002893629018217325, 0.04103719815611839, -0.006173403933644295, -0.01388394646346569, -0.03743602707982063, 0.014374851249158382, -0.03990573436021805, 0.000613762007560581, -0.04362672567367554, 0.03335072845220566, 0.017665447667241096, 0.025706591084599495, 0.03586917743086815, 0.012690733186900616, 0.020037908107042313, -0.042483165860176086, 0.02571108192205429, 0.0795091837644577, 0.033661484718322754, -0.01653938740491867, 0.026710685342550278, -0.013890869915485382, -0.06184829771518707, -0.0031496465671807528, -0.007612751796841621, -0.0057227835059165955, -0.03231852501630783, 0.03348289430141449, -0.024426426738500595, -0.03038184344768524, 0.05533205717802048, 0.013525265268981457, 0.022827740758657455, -0.05379458889365196, -0.11605162173509598, -0.04998723417520523, 0.0366886742413044, -0.013593204319477081, 0.021145958453416824, -0.06004975363612175, 0.012584693729877472, 0.011339287273585796, 0.055625125765800476, 0.02111174538731575, 0.037956155836582184, -0.017759662121534348, 0.027995146811008453, 0.013721673749387264, -0.002180539770051837, -0.056610338389873505, 0.028907783329486847, -0.013710788451135159, 0.02528235875070095, -0.07916631549596786, 0.01760062761604786, 0.013422484509646893, -0.010957431979477406, -0.029376985505223274, 0.042607199400663376, -0.0018773137126117945, -0.034287501126527786, -0.02453804388642311, 0.006897339131683111, -0.017474358901381493, 0.08074487000703812, -0.0005475328653119504, 0.010034611448645592, 0.014042978174984455, -0.03392215073108673, 0.004178444389253855, 0.04979002848267555, 0.07836460322141647, 0.026325339451432228, -0.024789664894342422, 0.012695727869868279, -0.031217673793435097, 0.013151786290109158, 0.009535478428006172, -0.026765983551740646, -0.017278803512454033, 0.026260750368237495, 0.02676117978990078, -0.005383947864174843, 0.014292962849140167, 0.009315512143075466, -0.004686012864112854, 0.0372353233397007, -0.07031664997339249, -0.03771483898162842, -0.028120024129748344, 0.012554802931845188, -0.03933578357100487, 0.0029494587797671556, 0.02871672622859478, 0.021888477727770805, -0.005012323148548603, -0.00046393988304771483, -0.0021974784322082996, -0.0038477431517094374, -0.031902994960546494, 0.021081427112221718, -0.0146348150447011, 0.005799517966806889, 0.0673096776008606, 0.00693553127348423, -0.0021103036124259233, 0.03909744694828987, 0.006248640362173319, -0.05740050598978996, -0.0020784141961485147, -0.014168466441333294, 0.02975461818277836, -0.020060241222381592, -0.01149667240679264, -0.0051041049882769585, 0.007317261304706335, -0.015107623301446438, 0.015312813222408295, -0.04801107197999954, 0.031977329403162, 0.0997825413942337, 0.04615303501486778, 0.0015876279212534428, 0.03909601643681526, 0.01663249358534813, -0.02352125197649002, -0.00012712269381154329, -0.01403136644512415, -0.06287144124507904, -0.008574321866035461, 0.03396511450409889, 0.027409382164478302, -0.011213173158466816, 0.02533111535012722, 0.037943825125694275, 0.0455223023891449, 0.026886429637670517, 0.031237680464982986, -0.015422427095472813, -0.026347076520323753, -0.0029943808913230896, -0.023723965510725975, 0.016493601724505424, 0.008124163374304771, 0.024637464433908463, 0.029793601483106613, 0.022706057876348495, -0.03916645795106888, -0.045834530144929886, 0.05238862335681915, -0.019447695463895798, 0.017750093713402748, -0.008237049914896488, 0.0012324288254603744, 0.00750445993617177, -0.04656345024704933, 0.02446245215833187, 0.032247982919216156, -0.005079323425889015, 0.035372622311115265, -0.009353171102702618, -0.020844485610723495, 0.02784102037549019, 0.0523996539413929, 0.010989908128976822, -0.00954362191259861, 0.011560956947505474, -0.0035486083943396807, 0.008881173096597195, -0.03483547642827034, -0.01378262136131525, -0.004277918022125959, -0.008868570439517498, 0.001885531353764236, 0.022487813606858253, 0.015429065562784672, -0.0025335100945085287, -0.07374555617570877, 0.00899213831871748, -0.03395049646496773, 0.010111644864082336, 0.005140228662639856, -0.02148047462105751, 0.0016011340776458383, -0.003852350637316704, 0.005145432893186808, 0.03270276263356209, -0.021709727123379707, 0.006644190289080143, 0.008548562414944172, -0.049642208963632584, -0.048603225499391556, 0.002354996744543314, -0.0034698392264544964, 0.004578348249197006, -0.044767044484615326, -0.008365903981029987, 0.0361943356692791, 0.013489099219441414, -0.046354059129953384, 0.025371868163347244, -0.03487193584442139, -0.07881374657154083, -0.03182154521346092, 0.007039846386760473, 0.02165241353213787, -0.028360337018966675, 0.0265917107462883, 0.03754178434610367, -0.021693861111998558, -0.004741692915558815, -0.052448272705078125, -0.05576013773679733, 0.02896433137357235, -0.015923256054520607, 0.04812852665781975, 0.019722314551472664, -0.030441347509622574, 0.05877922475337982, -0.010516517795622349, -0.02738245576620102, 0.015317054465413094, -0.000317828671541065, 0.0017412281595170498, -0.019786925986409187, 0.004207951948046684, -0.004632655065506697, 0.02017972618341446, 0.009213249199092388, 0.05039056017994881, 0.02730816975235939, 0.02742750570178032, -0.00954565592110157, -0.010640080086886883, 0.011249590665102005, -0.013249344192445278, -0.0018587145023047924, 0.03009096533060074, 0.018449673429131508, -0.03451116010546684, 0.014378765597939491, -0.019249938428401947, 0.0501771979033947, -0.003041947726160288, -0.015126170590519905, 0.025419296696782112, 0.0001276843686355278, -0.008530350401997566, -0.0643923208117485, 0.039852745831012726, -0.024204572662711143, -0.03459224849939346, 0.015772636979818344, 0.026574574410915375, 0.030523128807544708, 0.004148449748754501, 0.0038614824879914522, 0.05661614611744881, 0.03999835252761841, -0.03813597932457924, 0.0015690582804381847, -0.024564867839217186, -0.009069801308214664, 0.021462755277752876, 0.004383254796266556, -0.049819216132164, 0.038998402655124664, 0.03483482822775841, 0.0010777798015624285, -0.007450180593878031, -0.015962528064846992, 0.0050879232585430145, -0.03802145645022392, 0.020565366372466087, 0.02551770769059658, 0.03404989466071129, 0.011981070041656494, 0.041417643427848816, 0.021649612113833427, 0.0016528676496818662, 0.01673225127160549, -0.02554859220981598, -0.04471738636493683, -0.01624617539346218, -0.04557706415653229, 0.037453532218933105, -0.03977153077721596, -0.013322722166776657, 0.047099873423576355, 0.008461241610348225, -0.01894950307905674, -0.04024139791727066, 0.018622159957885742, -0.04793769121170044, 0.008213764987885952, -0.011050406843423843, 0.003571809735149145, -0.0563821941614151, 0.011875759810209274, 0.013163789175450802, 0.0014068420277908444, 0.02522045187652111, 0.05098460242152214, -0.01697082817554474, -0.02370651252567768, -0.023312609642744064, 0.030375055968761444, 0.025409286841750145, 0.02539200149476528, 0.01854206994175911, 0.05250854417681694, -0.021052755415439606, 0.025693435221910477, -0.005476522725075483, 0.08310121297836304, 0.05379858613014221, -0.03144976869225502, -0.046842366456985474, -0.05783446133136749, -0.029741713777184486, -0.020881809294223785, 0.011492704972624779, 0.033745843917131424, -0.0038062564563006163, 0.032962653785943985, 0.01696142740547657, -0.059105075895786285, 0.04868012294173241, 0.04230405390262604, 0.03490268439054489, 0.00447725597769022, -0.03355666622519493, 0.011413472704589367, -0.014470568858087063, 0.005576564930379391, 0.016598686575889587, 0.011882216669619083, -0.01644989475607872, 0.0009139089961536229, 0.03210001066327095, -0.011877764947712421, -0.02652840130031109, -0.019339997321367264, 0.0017000477528199553, 0.012324015609920025, -0.007347395643591881, -0.024268515408039093, 0.00468538049608469, 0.04484373703598976, 0.050310246646404266, 0.03297100588679314, -0.013459901325404644, -0.05804536119103432, -0.024113323539495468, 0.040310245007276535, -0.013539029285311699, 0.011093542911112309, 0.010035472922027111, -0.03905733674764633, 0.005614554975181818, 0.04494650289416313, -0.0070417760871350765, 0.02386806719005108, -0.007106379605829716, 0.03761650621891022, -0.014929949305951595, -0.017910579219460487, 0.029149504378437996, 0.019385715946555138, -0.0027695486787706614, -0.004897186532616615, -0.04568485915660858, -0.007310134824365377, -0.05206881836056709, 0.0005908559542149305, 0.010540174320340157, 0.05054144561290741, 0.004949042573571205, -0.020301153883337975, -0.018909001722931862, 0.044429440051317215, -0.008777806535363197, -0.08211486041545868, -0.017394451424479485, 0.0016225532162934542, -0.005496631842106581, 0.041607968509197235, -0.05279454588890076, -0.07004279643297195, -0.0050282953307032585, 0.021448859944939613, -0.01444627158343792, 0.0049378941766917706, -0.03129497915506363, 0.023567702621221542, 0.029896507039666176, -0.013441751711070538, 0.025206876918673515, -0.02134147472679615, -0.02720079943537712, -0.014060947112739086, -0.011264577507972717, 0.02000684291124344, -0.025174163281917572, -0.013067164458334446, -0.009948685765266418, -0.026646094396710396, -0.053692854940891266, 0.011257939040660858, -0.007221577689051628, 0.030665218830108643, -0.05020168423652649, -0.01643536239862442, -0.03876196965575218, -0.004766767844557762, 0.02339908294379711, 0.009878899902105331, -0.006684002000838518, 0.010534945875406265, 0.03286678344011307, 0.003885171841830015, 0.031138796359300613, -0.0063108415342867374, 0.008404592983424664, 0.040947042405605316, -0.010584399104118347, 0.003288842039182782, -0.045562148094177246, -0.05644034966826439, 0.03246729075908661, -0.017814502120018005, 0.029866481199860573, -0.01529168151319027, 0.024528181180357933, 0.011173106729984283, -0.044398944824934006, -0.03902982547879219, 0.0014764126390218735, -0.008302060887217522, 0.053399957716464996, -0.033437639474868774, 0.049722734838724136, -0.0076968069188296795, -0.0012827072059735656, -0.0819731280207634, -0.01914478838443756, 0.03371657803654671, 0.011242988519370556, -0.03255121782422066, -0.048599760979413986, 0.012799746356904507, -0.00024988065706565976, -0.056087322533130646, 0.022756030783057213, 0.009892918169498444, 0.015779979526996613, -0.010391993448138237, -0.0115437563508749, -0.006551060825586319, 0.06694493442773819, -0.015425866469740868, -0.021401846781373024, 0.024302184581756592, 0.0100143076851964, 0.0008634929545223713, -0.03911742568016052, 0.039767440408468246, -0.015589826740324497, 0.004543629474937916, -0.01136400830000639, 0.03301873430609703, 0.044860951602458954, -0.04659813642501831, -0.004027195740491152, -0.013875452801585197, -0.000575374870095402, 0.018579285591840744, -0.023414699360728264, 0.013507761061191559, -0.015647977590560913, 0.017909539863467216, -0.04115927591919899, -0.0045514944940805435, -0.029677117243409157, -0.01565524749457836, 0.0379248671233654, -0.009868993423879147, 0.014867323450744152, 0.020447764545679092, 0.02969750389456749, -0.036446958780288696, -0.017268413677811623, -0.004914619494229555, -0.030731046572327614, -0.01981402561068535, 0.047601718455553055, 0.0014891993487253785, 0.015347160398960114, 0.009273448027670383, -0.025930020958185196, 0.00004245691525284201, -0.06706773489713669, 0.02733113244175911, 0.08102180063724518, -0.02212284505367279, 0.04040434584021568, 0.037604693323373795, 0.0018339280504733324, -0.0026012423913925886, -0.003981906920671463, -0.028709331527352333, 0.005646005272865295, -0.01248183287680149, 0.04188557714223862, -0.011967684142291546, 0.01616346277296543, 0.002100901445373893, 0.03816757723689079, -0.0007544505060650408, 0.04193011671304703, 0.039895303547382355, 0.022958768531680107, 0.041612137109041214, -0.03284592926502228, -0.04026412591338158, 0.05585537850856781, -0.027058947831392288, 0.008114827796816826, -0.00866321288049221, -0.0049673207104206085, 0.005760223604738712, 0.004739734809845686, -0.0009462764719501138, -0.04484575614333153, -0.013711015693843365, -0.029634715989232063, 0.04028245434165001, 0.007668651174753904, 0.010410211980342865, 0.025752976536750793, 0.003844890743494034, 0.02732551470398903, -0.010287130251526833, 0.04841475561261177, 0.016506286337971687, -0.061795733869075775, -0.016366293653845787, -0.03437688201665878, -0.06043938174843788, 0.0051132808439433575, 0.00036763548268936574, -0.006224415265023708, -0.007428901270031929, -0.030093573033809662, 0.02190462313592434, 0.015939831733703613, 0.026802953332662582, -0.017853735014796257, 0.11456140130758286, 0.00913988333195448, 0.04214866831898689, -0.0020716588478535414, -0.021090267226099968, 0.13485144078731537, 0.040690287947654724, 0.029373062774538994, -0.08123904466629028, -0.016504617407917976, -0.007976234890520573, -0.004996978212147951, -0.044423580169677734, 0.028907064348459244, 0.005682648625224829, 0.017528487369418144, 0.035293202847242355, 0.049533411860466, 0.0012819957919418812, -0.005666346754878759, 0.04925037547945976, -0.032344430685043335, -0.04855005443096161, 0.016474135220050812, -0.014563338831067085, -0.01439734548330307, 0.034133315086364746, -0.07971334457397461, 0.01317141018807888, 0.002545952098444104, -0.018720543012022972, -0.017486581578850746, -0.02385975979268551, 0.001459983759559691, -0.012346182018518448, -0.008775006048381329, -0.019417140632867813, 0.0193279180675745, -0.0074846986681222916, 0.0009685647673904896, 0.0008299453184008598, 0.03378520533442497, -0.017650697380304337, 0.030026517808437347, 0.027447165921330452, 0.003879811381921172, -0.0038956892676651478, 0.004027845803648233, 0.025489961728453636, -0.00844702497124672, -0.02867889031767845, -0.021416369825601578, 0.024548880755901337, -0.023101504892110825, 0.0229427982121706, -0.022312114015221596, -0.01407483872026205, 0.012049117125570774, -0.02676781825721264, -0.025738723576068878, -0.016430573537945747, 0.054639626294374466, -0.03920764476060867, -0.03375735506415367, -0.03139667958021164, 0.017028793692588806, -0.01640874706208706, 0.047877438366413116, 0.006291281897574663, -0.02758401446044445, -0.007120748050510883, -0.0201528649777174, 0.020427148789167404, 0.010513662360608578, -0.011297313496470451, -0.003939867485314608, -0.001949104480445385, -0.02406550571322441, 0.00267965579405427, -0.014207147061824799, -0.05445212498307228, 0.04711459204554558, -0.0049785734154284, -0.0017623588209971786, -0.010329551994800568, -0.0475529208779335, 0.014882681891322136, -0.04357517883181572, -0.016146335750818253, -0.04956325143575668, 0.010197045281529427, 0.018948562443256378, 0.06159961223602295, -0.004267288837581873, 0.042288899421691895, -0.019372420385479927, 0.03930630534887314, 0.029309533536434174, -0.024096636101603508, 0.014003794640302658, -0.019139302894473076, -0.032838135957717896, -0.025930946692824364, -0.03563607111573219, 0.03670654818415642, 0.034386277198791504, 0.024657132104039192, 0.022187013179063797, 0.017113400623202324, -0.000492167950142175, -0.011452114209532738, -0.013493231497704983, -0.0741589143872261, 0.016374638304114342, 0.01870887167751789, 0.005938585381954908, -0.04000457748770714, -0.0006860563880763948, -0.00086038070730865, 0.0031365416944026947, 0.008744199760258198, 0.022083941847085953, -0.023717643693089485, -0.0006587097886949778, -0.0020835367031395435, 0.0005899197421967983, -0.015069750137627125, -0.02286747843027115, 0.004009880591183901, 0.019469091668725014, -0.018916228786110878, 0.00583640718832612, -0.03216305747628212, 0.0063627250492572784, 0.0036109520588070154, 0.004438025411218405, 0.021492652595043182, 0.021492497995495796, -0.01339211966842413, 0.0291206706315279, 0.030699776485562325, -0.002936856122687459, 0.03711877390742302, -0.016560768708586693, 0.007797469384968281, 0.09262910485267639, -0.047121692448854446, -0.04982330650091171, 0.016355548053979874, -0.01966971717774868, 0.043395034968853, 0.011624844744801521, -0.009474334307014942, -0.038847554475069046, 0.03805502876639366, -0.027204664424061775, -0.0009535138960927725, -0.014060316607356071, -0.008105412125587463, 0.013446690514683723, 0.007983244024217129, -0.001301643787883222, -0.017974624410271645, -0.02177630178630352, 0.029135925695300102, 0.03764120861887932, 0.00831170566380024, 0.014324155636131763, 0.03574373200535774, -0.014540618285536766, 0.04637020826339722, -0.004980077967047691, 0.014279423281550407, 0.051515888422727585, 0.04706956073641777, -0.030743945389986038, 0.009852120652794838, -0.027105674147605896, -0.020870575681328773, -0.10514702647924423, -0.004827990662306547, 0.028737904503941536, -0.006245918571949005, 0.05734552443027496, -0.028872478753328323, -0.0037832220550626516, 0.026362935081124306, -0.034945737570524216, -0.004265293944627047, -0.02921685390174389, -0.04112382233142853, -0.03700367361307144, 0.016351232305169106, -0.020165588706731796, 0.07004572451114655, 0.029256047680974007, 0.018556103110313416, 0.05910789221525192, 0.031090425327420235, -0.006977982819080353, -0.02496420405805111, -0.009494193829596043, -0.017769472673535347, -0.013134047389030457, -0.029784226790070534, 0.07619688659906387, 0.001814782852306962, -0.02894759178161621, 0.07963643968105316, 0.024949340149760246, 0.002609570510685444, -0.007366870995610952, 0.005537264049053192, 0.03398057073354721, 0.018567007035017014, 0.030709754675626755, -0.007152370642870665, -0.005611848086118698, -0.005238241050392389, 0.046775221824645996, 0.04224839434027672, -0.015246842987835407, 0.02187722735106945, 0.0070879231207072735, -0.039477087557315826, -0.04101689159870148, 0.018027910962700844, -0.009746148250997066, -0.007709275931119919, 0.022643497213721275, -0.03809739649295807, 0.014831083826720715, -0.018963860347867012, 0.0562400296330452, -0.03448643907904625, -0.02604636736214161, 0.04424651712179184, 0.02184189483523369, -0.005371453240513802, 0.03419255092740059, -0.014304421842098236, -0.044817306101322174, -0.00007557468779850751, -0.005704722832888365, -0.004233380779623985, -0.0474674329161644, 0.003497938858345151, -0.031049396842718124, 0.004529999103397131, -0.038914408534765244, -0.03917352482676506, -0.027715517207980156, 0.03500529006123543, 0.02886594831943512, 0.03416359797120094, 0.01063712127506733, -0.05173525586724281, 0.0030213932041078806, -0.06184697151184082, 0.057017892599105835, -0.014346637763082981, -0.015739846974611282, -0.025863004848361015, -0.010535850189626217, -0.0277990885078907, 0.0016793172108009458, 0.036422934383153915, -0.0019004731439054012, -0.0069308714009821415, -0.016025129705667496, 0.032391443848609924, 0.02913546934723854, -0.08050550520420074, 0.011881024576723576, -0.005814001429826021, -0.032163284718990326, -0.01914537511765957, 0.007894257083535194, 0.002551494399085641, 0.002780156210064888, 0.014632540754973888, -0.00375939579680562, 0.011334010399878025, -0.0019527210388332605, -0.04263729229569435, 0.012799026444554329, 0.023532487452030182, -0.04382746294140816, 0.03627850115299225, -0.012555471621453762, 0.03233371675014496, -0.01374109834432602, 0.02629208378493786, -0.057660046964883804, 0.04116920009255409, -0.000681250705383718, -0.005213296972215176, -0.02561798319220543, -0.01173846609890461, -0.009878971613943577, -0.04016367346048355, -0.03360404074192047, 0.06019989773631096, -0.04396925866603851, -0.0037207533605396748, 0.029102228581905365, 0.010082272812724113, 0.060164228081703186, 0.027981124818325043, -0.023182984441518784, -0.03517426177859306, 0.02161368541419506, 0.010286075994372368, 0.010602849535644054, -0.005425285082310438, -0.042315054684877396, 0.009481406770646572, 0.013382038101553917, -0.03530619293451309, 0.04073798656463623, -0.0023720089811831713, 0.032222941517829895, -0.03903742879629135, -0.00850819330662489, -0.015029968693852425, -0.026908984407782555, 0.029513932764530182, 0.02873367816209793, -0.03638434410095215, 0.08126583695411682, 0.003289017593488097, 0.0297903623431921, -0.0069295307621359825, 0.011071251705288887, -0.036989957094192505, -0.03330414742231369, -0.014014307409524918, 0.029494019225239754, 0.006567947566509247, 0.013040155172348022, 0.027377787977457047, 0.021299147978425026, 0.037211641669273376, -0.020454561337828636, 0.04036394879221916, 0.0032157793175429106, 0.02069786563515663, 0.002375675830990076, 0.0018587250960990787, -0.02394828200340271, -0.01435135118663311, -0.018893828615546227, 0.037633463740348816, 0.06512392312288284, 0.01839808002114296, -0.050856899470090866, -0.013939685188233852, 0.040714751929044724, -0.08801207691431046, 0.0005425743875093758, -0.028619127348065376, 0.009378048591315746, -0.004581663757562637, -0.026737302541732788 ]
<p>I'm trying to find the probability that two randomly-selected letters from "average" text in a language will be the same. </p> <p>For example, if my hypothetical language contains four letters which each occur on average with the following frequency:</p> <pre><code>A = 60% B = 25% C = 10% D = 5% </code></pre> <p>What is the probability that selecting any two letters from a representational text will be the same?</p> <p>My intuition for solving this is first to find the chance that they're different, so the sum over the probabilities that a letter is chosen and then some other letter is chosen next, over each letter in the alphabet:</p> <pre><code>(0.6 * (1 - 0.6) + 0.25 * (1 - 0.25) + 0.1 * (1 - 0.1) + 0.05 * (1 - 0.05)) = 0.565 </code></pre> <p>Then the chance that they are the same: </p> <pre><code>1 - 0.565 = 0.435 </code></pre> <p>Is this reasoning sound? It seems like a very basic probability problem, but I always seem to be thinking about these things in the wrong way and would appreciate a sanity check (and any pointers to materials which would help me be more confident about this kind of thing in the future!)</p>
73,828
[ -0.04689070209860802, -0.030249765142798424, -0.02118982933461666, -0.033723268657922745, 0.020893430337309837, 0.05298737436532974, 0.006819347385317087, -0.015056139789521694, 0.01847820170223713, -0.03238659352064133, 0.01650696061551571, 0.056184474378824234, 0.0533878467977047, 0.02431304194033146, 0.0435512512922287, 0.010993042029440403, 0.002556899795308709, -0.029658233746886253, -0.0021942274179309607, -0.0023009716533124447, 0.010475287213921547, 0.024268202483654022, -0.0030247396789491177, -0.05204705893993378, -0.02545815333724022, 0.04021510109305382, -0.005713044200092554, -0.04867154732346535, 0.034767910838127136, 0.04644166678190231, -0.026077168062329292, -0.007904252037405968, 0.05673683062195778, 0.03816992789506912, 0.061027683317661285, 0.007659072522073984, -0.005018352065235376, -0.007059226743876934, -0.016706284135580063, 0.01095688808709383, -0.02716047130525112, 0.006961160805076361, -0.026304583996534348, 0.01231883279979229, -0.012554585933685303, 0.001234042108990252, -0.01726529560983181, -0.029107684269547462, -0.0021707164123654366, -0.06353595852851868, 0.07199317216873169, -0.0008655799902044237, 0.04313066229224205, 0.028852181509137154, -0.002067737514153123, -0.01699969545006752, 0.03056967444717884, 0.05750495195388794, 0.014265068806707859, -0.0223240964114666, -0.011639044620096684, 0.008807512931525707, 0.017745675519108772, -0.0031950287520885468, -0.05136438086628914, 0.01624307408928871, -0.053492505103349686, -0.008831684477627277, 0.06465942412614822, -0.01381013821810484, 0.030601467937231064, 0.04878687858581543, 0.04381933435797691, -0.010791505686938763, 0.019423143938183784, 0.005554877687245607, 0.044060733169317245, 0.03631976619362831, 0.028781326487660408, 0.019821902737021446, -0.021496837958693504, -0.007508248556405306, 0.019540710374712944, 0.03836836293339729, 0.028991365805268288, -0.013262693770229816, 0.032312579452991486, -0.03569389134645462, 0.008726325817406178, 0.013047276064753532, 0.0053521511144936085, -0.024736113846302032, 0.040370747447013855, 0.020019710063934326, -0.03955266252160072, 0.04319962486624718, -0.0038906040135771036, 0.04827753081917763, 0.008357113227248192, -0.022826720029115677, -0.026370801031589508, -0.05231355130672455, 0.022333472967147827, 0.06427419185638428, -0.012287955731153488, -0.02055516093969345, -0.05021334066987038, 0.014043249189853668, 0.004915930330753326, 0.023667603731155396, -0.015778163447976112, 0.030295459553599358, 0.014707469381392002, -0.013909909874200821, 0.02142740972340107, 0.013067674823105335, 0.0015534507110714912, -0.003471963806077838, 0.06318095326423645, 0.06088366359472275, 0.01771053485572338, -0.04902687296271324, 0.05665229633450508, -0.04492119699716568, 0.012683919630944729, -0.01463073119521141, -0.002703784964978695, 0.008265049196779728, -0.014744841493666172, 0.05996130034327507, -0.0498221218585968, -0.025756966322660446, 0.006893042009323835, -0.01924656145274639, 0.024605480954051018, 0.019341329112648964, -0.0646253377199173, -0.0200826246291399, 0.015109680593013763, -0.042360153049230576, -0.04065323248505592, -0.07217293232679367, 0.0056675998494029045, 0.04263005778193474, 0.030127335339784622, 0.008341909386217594, 0.06015666201710701, -0.010920346714556217, 0.00867605209350586, 0.05063265189528465, -0.02816934511065483, -0.021251821890473366, -0.005644325166940689, -0.043387819081544876, 0.007211659103631973, -0.06864725053310394, -0.01269219908863306, -0.016833586618304253, -0.006433131173253059, -0.017508454620838165, 0.03173099830746651, -0.0001377600128762424, -0.016255943104624748, -0.02753516659140587, 0.05950698256492615, -0.03494788706302643, 0.06401446461677551, 0.03236183524131775, 0.03784264996647835, 0.024086695164442062, 0.017373818904161453, -0.0032578674145042896, 0.01471208967268467, 0.015808740630745888, 0.07832668721675873, -0.036969948559999466, 0.026548558846116066, 0.0004084580868948251, 0.03263005614280701, -0.04777776077389717, -0.0217024777084589, -0.028182681649923325, -0.0015974368434399366, 0.019073983654379845, 0.005265258252620697, 0.043709591031074524, 0.032526277005672455, -0.03113553673028946, -0.0005336287431418896, 0.002229413017630577, -0.02394501306116581, -0.06806446611881256, -0.0011533659417182207, 0.014025883749127388, -0.023439478129148483, 0.01999802328646183, 0.008753799833357334, 0.01118442602455616, -0.019155509769916534, -0.01827925257384777, -0.07858195155858994, 0.003555127652361989, 0.015542087145149708, -0.04038766399025917, -0.008225002326071262, 0.03755622357130051, 0.02393457293510437, -0.016563352197408676, 0.04571181535720825, -0.012180909514427185, -0.05185439810156822, -0.0037336868699640036, -0.024438602849841118, -0.012001316994428635, -0.012211674824357033, -0.009291539900004864, 0.05079227685928345, 0.04721858352422714, 0.004947362933307886, -0.0033598130103200674, -0.06053655222058296, 0.04118630662560463, 0.0049877772107720375, 0.01014284323900938, 0.02626011334359646, 0.0282723531126976, 0.0027465433813631535, 0.0030170518439263105, -0.003305968828499317, -0.03428123518824577, -0.025761395692825317, -0.0018020846182480454, 0.05405221879482269, 0.0017445845296606421, -0.03895482048392296, -0.002757512265816331, 0.04645640775561333, 0.011355715803802013, -0.005113815423101187, 0.04995948076248169, 0.03052837774157524, -0.015264623798429966, -0.01642496883869171, 0.012454165145754814, 0.027611684054136276, 0.009895525872707367, 0.007824025116860867, 0.006493488326668739, -0.0072804223746061325, 0.0009673832100816071, -0.017900286242365837, 0.022204460576176643, 0.019057858735322952, 0.06775831431150436, -0.05505024641752243, -0.013082374818623066, 0.03957930952310562, -0.011001062579452991, -0.012692078948020935, 0.052114468067884445, -0.0039913468062877655, -0.040628258138895035, 0.024799173697829247, -0.0393366813659668, -0.022522514685988426, 0.023871323093771935, -0.02524355985224247, -0.011773034930229187, 0.015715161338448524, -0.0034969013649970293, 0.006591309327632189, -0.019830990582704544, -0.011241016909480095, 0.0071152881719172, 0.010158505290746689, 0.018722547218203545, -0.006096369121223688, 0.04435180872678757, -0.011854654178023338, -0.011607631109654903, -0.0022831098176538944, 0.01669602282345295, 0.00232351734302938, 0.00974718201905489, -0.0953207015991211, 0.026102054864168167, -0.01520904153585434, -0.046766865998506546, 0.050329845398664474, -0.028332935646176338, -0.0487896166741848, 0.021688053384423256, -0.010155309922993183, -0.04614171013236046, 0.010151241905987263, -0.058184199035167694, 0.01722746714949608, -0.04671972617506981, 0.006336577236652374, 0.05724235996603966, -0.003935403656214476, -0.07708805799484253, 0.03313935175538063, -0.034563109278678894, -0.07548651844263077, -0.009753979742527008, -0.02915872633457184, -0.0005573409725911915, -0.03453562781214714, -0.008023690432310104, -0.0008547893958166242, 0.004411053378134966, -0.005066143348813057, -0.07675649225711823, -0.07472971081733704, 0.03412915766239166, -0.02036195993423462, 0.045243654400110245, 0.0185384638607502, -0.011093412525951862, 0.0705183744430542, 0.03321787714958191, -0.03864827752113342, 0.004046959336847067, 0.000228407938266173, -0.008160857483744621, 0.01314364094287157, 0.026194967329502106, 0.03412538394331932, -0.044923085719347, 0.01613631099462509, 0.05043165385723114, 0.013667353428900242, 0.043963298201560974, -0.023478198796510696, 0.018266132101416588, 0.016908036544919014, 0.013357923366129398, -0.027015462517738342, 0.030376581475138664, 0.025398576632142067, -0.025748183950781822, 0.04104214906692505, 0.006209316197782755, -0.008572862483561039, 0.005676879081875086, -0.014526627957820892, 0.0377882644534111, 0.005562337581068277, 0.012441347353160381, -0.028012732043862343, 0.046157851815223694, 0.019932560622692108, -0.004571340978145599, 0.03829699009656906, -0.024846188724040985, 0.036065492779016495, -0.024426275864243507, 0.025239979848265648, 0.0331951342523098, 0.037491198629140854, 0.01280246488749981, -0.004977733362466097, -0.031063228845596313, 0.007569200359284878, 0.005677254870533943, -0.015884801745414734, -0.032084882259368896, 0.03506847470998764, 0.04571478068828583, 0.05134916678071022, 0.014222204685211182, -0.024071678519248962, 0.019125720486044884, -0.08790472894906998, -0.017466383054852486, -0.03264930844306946, 0.03936217352747917, -0.011456964537501335, 0.03372985124588013, 0.0492241196334362, -0.0007121583912521601, -0.005793167278170586, 0.024015070870518684, -0.1170249953866005, 0.03338293358683586, -0.017870845273137093, -0.006260211113840342, -0.03007473610341549, -0.013641925528645515, 0.025168370455503464, -0.021855762228369713, -0.02168792486190796, -0.0007216338999569416, -0.01960436999797821, -0.050489675253629684, 0.02382156252861023, -0.004432424437254667, 0.00246615638025105, -0.027591589838266373, 0.0347168929874897, -0.016819944605231285, -0.015972670167684555, 0.015369610860943794, 0.032687198370695114, -0.030210552737116814, 0.0016037366585806012, -0.0349312461912632, 0.01751692220568657, 0.06417404860258102, 0.04664585366845131, 0.0885855033993721, 0.06135834380984306, -0.03400268405675888, -0.008840261027216911, 0.015947353094816208, 0.031893376260995865, 0.029121248051524162, -0.05089090019464493, -0.006445317529141903, -0.07888085395097733, -0.018367327749729156, -0.009228660725057125, -0.007771507371217012, -0.03605446591973305, 0.030929716303944588, 0.025191012769937515, 0.015783125534653664, -0.03726973757147789, 0.04220561683177948, 0.04975434020161629, -0.02235274948179722, 0.012919881381094456, -0.02895216830074787, -0.00037185251130722463, -0.009469959884881973, -0.010795059613883495, 0.03286721929907799, -0.005863819271326065, 0.0042970688082277775, -0.015688365325331688, 0.005952740088105202, -0.025143377482891083, -0.031396571546792984, 0.008841671980917454, -0.025779174640774727, -0.008383121341466904, -0.001306817983277142, -0.04085039347410202, -0.022903135046362877, 0.05377950519323349, -0.01113208383321762, 0.01439791452139616, -0.02818322367966175, -0.02928178571164608, 0.014666636474430561, 0.03553047403693199, 0.0705152153968811, -0.05258908122777939, 0.008616414852440357, -0.02875174582004547, -0.027957074344158173, 0.02859088033437729, -0.02776086889207363, 0.015099621377885342, 0.02890113927423954, -0.021711822599172592, 0.003044725861400366, 0.008670244365930557, -0.017035480588674545, 0.04472004994750023, 0.00040729224565438926, 0.03465287759900093, -0.009003883227705956, 0.003880947595462203, -0.01901101879775524, 0.03766332566738129, 0.030131390318274498, 0.03452571481466293, -0.06867904961109161, -0.048943206667900085, -0.02572762779891491, -0.0031945761293172836, -0.0011583904270082712, -0.04576839879155159, -0.002458297647535801, -0.022872833535075188, -0.02075408212840557, 0.035863615572452545, -0.043427761644124985, -0.052999332547187805, 0.036297399550676346, 0.013986267149448395, 0.00610136054456234, -0.003004139754921198, 0.020737841725349426, 0.020158914849162102, 0.04989497363567352, 0.006522464565932751, 0.03520558774471283, -0.028502123430371284, -0.011872202157974243, 0.013806471601128578, -0.05429403856396675, 0.008404909633100033, -0.025241771712899208, 0.010692671872675419, -0.0524020753800869, -0.012209217995405197, -0.016431765630841255, 0.05028391629457474, -0.00780327245593071, 0.0077930414117872715, -0.03206278383731842, 0.012524210847914219, -0.04218883067369461, -0.02698698081076145, -0.0001275587419513613, -0.01705833710730076, 0.023898407816886902, -0.02537812665104866, -0.025018272921442986, 0.006644302513450384, 0.029310259968042374, -0.04056784510612488, 0.0008169632637873292, -0.020197520032525063, -0.0214629415422678, -0.01237938180565834, -0.026787783950567245, -0.014349304139614105, 0.02434214949607849, -0.051298629492521286, 0.04183242842555046, -0.018507514148950577, 0.0762661024928093, 0.02975619211792946, -0.044315580278635025, -0.06094984710216522, 0.030015552416443825, 0.01727360673248768, 0.03556768596172333, -0.02403515763580799, 0.05005117505788803, -0.04039435088634491, -0.005764572415500879, -0.06523447483778, -0.013151486404240131, 0.02749745361506939, 0.014906416647136211, -0.04256122559309006, -0.024150513112545013, -0.012985682114958763, -0.00805134791880846, -0.01178804598748684, 0.006193724926561117, 0.05541912093758583, -0.007027450017631054, -0.01603868417441845, -0.006272119469940662, 0.01985851675271988, 0.10073478519916534, 0.0010792156681418419, -0.0395699143409729, 0.01580817811191082, -0.017573045566678047, 0.014971795491874218, -0.031237337738275528, 0.025016479194164276, -0.03786515071988106, -0.025859244167804718, -0.015810156241059303, 0.03560493513941765, 0.037489697337150574, -0.041280362755060196, -0.013101390562951565, 0.005477515514940023, -0.012382511980831623, 0.017238033935427666, -0.03282143920660019, -0.019670577719807625, 0.017950210720300674, 0.023223619908094406, -0.004887080751359463, 0.036331821233034134, -0.01152306143194437, 0.02786436304450035, 0.023945245891809464, 0.03542130067944527, -0.03293952718377113, 0.016497818753123283, 0.06137772649526596, -0.026428384706377983, -0.010057234205305576, -0.013668914325535297, -0.015334627591073513, 0.013444838114082813, 0.015827789902687073, -0.015029989182949066, 0.047858286648988724, -0.0028020059689879417, -0.0462009459733963, 0.007015583571046591, -0.045983415096998215, 0.005603330209851265, 0.03651847690343857, -0.006339650135487318, 0.06807168573141098, 0.058342330157756805, 0.028855379670858383, 0.010447926819324493, 0.035751670598983765, -0.038339219987392426, -0.028272368013858795, -0.007829095236957073, 0.049224913120269775, -0.005745626986026764, -0.03342403471469879, 0.03305688500404358, -0.00030637148302048445, 0.040318869054317474, 0.0327053926885128, 0.04174356162548065, -0.002397899515926838, 0.053077854216098785, -0.05288839712738991, -0.019001541659235954, 0.014776202850043774, -0.060078032314777374, 0.011785207316279411, -0.004063422791659832, -0.038341399282217026, 0.036953043192625046, 0.03504931554198265, -0.047024451196193695, -0.048791106790304184, -0.032341282814741135, -0.018481269478797913, -0.0022289548069238663, 0.016396427527070045, 0.006506836507469416, 0.026479549705982208, -0.015503509901463985, 0.008854887448251247, 0.00048147456254810095, 0.04069627821445465, -0.0038422010838985443, -0.05279884859919548, 0.012273445725440979, -0.05289074033498764, -0.021830540150403976, 0.04141807556152344, 0.029932230710983276, -0.04105253517627716, 0.014512664638459682, -0.042996253818273544, 0.028574787080287933, 0.054764047265052795, 0.009000268764793873, -0.028812240809202194, 0.09461775422096252, -0.012572015635669231, 0.060243599116802216, -0.0073005263693630695, -0.033357419073581696, 0.11916272342205048, 0.06736400723457336, 0.01487024687230587, -0.06545108556747437, 0.03504369780421257, -0.007441159337759018, 0.012973773293197155, -0.012162613682448864, 0.03457675129175186, 0.008470316417515278, 0.03427644819021225, 0.04699599742889404, 0.02459697239100933, 0.00863307248800993, -0.031231045722961426, 0.024756543338298798, -0.03594976291060448, -0.0383707620203495, -0.010103898122906685, 0.030692318454384804, 0.03526582941412926, -0.029553910717368126, -0.034779660403728485, -0.02208062633872032, 0.029304593801498413, -0.00038393065915443003, -0.05177478492259979, -0.03336676210165024, -0.014227243140339851, 0.01191113330423832, 0.009327194653451443, 0.005635938141494989, 0.021061312407255173, -0.007947680540382862, 0.009054271504282951, 0.008394789882004261, 0.022815823554992676, -0.02302389405667782, 0.010569478385150433, -0.007439956534653902, 0.0035491257440298796, 0.010632118210196495, 0.04185216501355171, 0.041872382164001465, -0.04115058109164238, -0.027760818600654602, -0.0542864054441452, 0.02537458762526512, -0.006631682626903057, -0.026488540694117546, 0.0024915931280702353, 0.029626665636897087, 0.00520632928237319, -0.06270872801542282, -0.016048740595579147, 0.014404979534447193, 0.008447333239018917, -0.01415699627250433, -0.014143889769911766, 0.0058718156069517136, 0.04767291247844696, -0.002596908947452903, 0.015692787244915962, -0.0003593737492337823, -0.03502009063959122, -0.02616962231695652, -0.0509331114590168, 0.01638748124241829, 0.003664878197014332, -0.02557447738945484, -0.011722374707460403, -0.0043555255979299545, -0.05165752395987511, 0.0009310949826613069, -0.05179908871650696, 0.01647578738629818, 0.06623823195695877, -0.0322435237467289, -0.013066859915852547, -0.002290902426466346, 0.008212242275476456, 0.016017906367778778, 0.007982776500284672, -0.004655621945858002, -0.028978412970900536, 0.00016973064339254051, 0.01882309280335903, 0.016277410089969635, -0.017234092578291893, 0.013666301965713501, 0.020827390253543854, 0.04499305412173271, -0.00787531677633524, -0.03737270459532738, 0.029582684859633446, -0.018563874065876007, -0.022123189643025398, -0.0030012286733835936, 0.0008730249246582389, 0.039941731840372086, 0.04003390669822693, 0.017639579251408577, 0.03907938674092293, 0.049145977944135666, -0.017077719792723656, -0.011819482780992985, -0.02236592024564743, -0.06839877367019653, -0.024279190227389336, 0.03207460045814514, -0.00004351090683485381, -0.06508427113294601, -0.004573758225888014, -0.026526523754000664, 0.0005266110529191792, 0.021173221990466118, -0.01630760356783867, -0.030954614281654358, -0.00934892613440752, -0.038933876901865005, 0.0025681941770017147, -0.01813213899731636, -0.02877826988697052, -0.004412004724144936, -0.028506556525826454, -0.02378818951547146, -0.0036647487431764603, -0.019776804372668266, 0.005490565672516823, 0.019979974254965782, -0.007470397278666496, 0.017813678830862045, 0.010366738773882389, -0.019124897196888924, -0.015294518321752548, 0.015702398493885994, -0.024185430258512497, 0.01975494995713234, -0.04244202747941017, -0.0384795218706131, 0.012265969067811966, -0.016339445486664772, -0.05868298187851906, 0.014041431248188019, -0.006135669071227312, 0.014179321937263012, 0.03924087807536125, 0.002572664525359869, 0.03923604264855385, 0.096702940762043, -0.02311404049396515, -0.025190051645040512, -0.005936773028224707, 0.02848624810576439, 0.019445575773715973, 0.0004346524365246296, 0.0009933996479958296, 0.032740406692028046, -0.00017960942932404578, 0.020947767421603203, 0.04440676048398018, 0.0026242374442517757, 0.024143101647496223, 0.035353437066078186, 0.010842720046639442, -0.011534846387803555, 0.033292822539806366, -0.022890832275152206, -0.023849397897720337, 0.0066346460953354836, 0.012217198498547077, 0.04324062541127205, -0.0044522895477712154, -0.0033181242179125547, -0.05810469761490822, 0.014052481390535831, 0.019518908113241196, -0.0025352633092552423, 0.061331529170274734, -0.050200991332530975, -0.00032325784559361637, 0.028591033071279526, -0.0331723727285862, 0.008491302840411663, -0.0347837470471859, -0.01695512793958187, -0.044482871890068054, 0.015036765486001968, -0.042696353048086166, 0.010562620125710964, 0.022681737318634987, 0.02706933207809925, 0.06412064284086227, 0.01839790865778923, -0.0252511166036129, -0.010496224276721478, 0.007839754223823547, 0.04106367751955986, -0.012339984066784382, 0.00605512922629714, 0.0506267286837101, -0.029172303155064583, -0.060675036162137985, 0.03774578124284744, 0.011653001420199871, -0.004877630155533552, 0.0022314416710287333, 0.025997847318649292, 0.023425055667757988, 0.021236389875411987, 0.0373232327401638, -0.010203059762716293, -0.012174130417406559, -0.01745009422302246, 0.04831026867032051, 0.033485740423202515, -0.03663049638271332, 0.0037750271148979664, 0.002384694991633296, 0.0007143954280763865, -0.03972122073173523, 0.014277271926403046, 0.006265975069254637, 0.00729281734675169, -0.02800542116165161, 0.0023452662862837315, 0.011883311904966831, -0.009784627705812454, -0.01475113071501255, -0.07220696657896042, 0.007335778791457415, -0.00559137761592865, -0.011633271351456642, 0.0163573045283556, 0.023642566055059433, -0.020654847845435143, -0.0048767803236842155, -0.009675630368292332, 0.00431153504177928, -0.0015373644419014454, -0.015976937487721443, -0.03314559534192085, 0.007291528396308422, 0.0207939762622118, 0.020079325884580612, -0.04632237181067467, -0.02781335450708866, 0.0125336404889822, -0.007955322042107582, 0.014314749278128147, 0.005675188265740871, -0.0037748757749795914, 0.00501177366822958, -0.09166140854358673, 0.0671398937702179, 0.015353301540017128, -0.007899783551692963, -0.06826004385948181, -0.02436703070998192, -0.042221713811159134, 0.06509264558553696, 0.037081748247146606, 0.007924020290374756, -0.014590675011277199, -0.023771462962031364, -0.0028486810624599457, 0.00498343538492918, -0.06142927706241608, 0.00862779002636671, -0.01905321516096592, -0.014720356091856956, -0.01974702812731266, 0.01824069768190384, 0.014799882657825947, -0.008077866397798061, -0.012168091721832752, -0.047687992453575134, 0.0018695075996220112, 0.00921537447720766, -0.0026241743471473455, 0.03353269398212433, 0.025726357474923134, -0.01540972851216793, 0.016368091106414795, -0.025482237339019775, 0.02478899247944355, 0.008529512211680412, -0.007133855484426022, -0.061931684613227844, 0.02970755659043789, -0.0009291499154642224, -0.038986802101135254, -0.012480983510613441, 0.030424343422055244, 0.031378187239170074, -0.03969264030456543, 0.02556893788278103, 0.017994578927755356, -0.03236908093094826, -0.009742394089698792, -0.0013995867921039462, 0.008555269800126553, 0.042713675647974014, -0.007170391734689474, 0.035184744745492935, -0.021122436970472336, -0.022188406437635422, 0.0008376197656616569, -0.051318928599357605, -0.006551297847181559, 0.004236656706780195, 0.045409005135297775, 0.00814656913280487, -0.01642822101712227, 0.015123983845114708, 0.03248852118849754, 0.0530402809381485, -0.04611450806260109, 0.006102458573877811, 0.03031744994223118, 0.005721959751099348, -0.015772640705108643, -0.005119623150676489, 0.020337333902716637, 0.047398511320352554, 0.0010290461359545588, 0.023265572264790535, -0.04212962090969086, -0.009480173699557781, -0.023946352303028107, -0.015300845727324486, 0.009882851503789425, -0.025982746854424477, -0.00254235346801579, 0.00662241643294692, -0.006597772240638733, 0.004085110034793615, 0.034591373056173325, -0.02803168259561062, 0.029583333060145378, -0.018540505319833755, -0.0026506909634917974, -0.03643667325377464, 0.00939265824854374, -0.03448842093348503, -0.01732567884027958, 0.03897612914443016, 0.025964034721255302, 0.024467434734106064, -0.013214614242315292, -0.030121520161628723, 0.01426312979310751, 0.06585440784692764, 0.011634653434157372, 0.011277664452791214, -0.046339064836502075, 0.0739678293466568, 0.02597920410335064, -0.014364185743033886 ]
<p>Please see the model below (<a href="http://i.stack.imgur.com/CspnD.png" rel="nofollow">link to bigger image</a>). The independent variables are properties of 2500 companies from 32 countries, trying to explain companies' CSR (corporate social responsibility) score. </p> <p>I am worried about the VIF scores of especially the <code>LAW_</code>, <code>GCI_</code> and <code>HOF_</code> variables but I really need them all included in the model to connect it to the theoretical background the model is built upon. All variables are discrete numeric values, except the law <code>LAW_</code> variables: they are dummies as to which legal system applies in the companies' country of origin (either english, french, german or scandinavian).</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/CspnD.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>Amongst other articles, I have read <a href="http://www.thejuliagroup.com/blog/?p=1405" rel="nofollow">this article</a> about dealing with collinearity. Often-suggested tips are removing the variable with highest VIF-score (in my model this would be <code>LAW_ENG</code>). But then other VIF-scores increase as a result. I do not have the proper knowledge to see through what is going on here and how I can solve this problem. </p> <p>I have uploaded the corresponding data <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/tw6vyz0sx89fnch/stackexchange.sav" rel="nofollow">here</a> (in SPSS <code>.sav</code> format). I would really appreciate somebody with more experience having a quick look and tell me a way to solve the collinearity problem without taking out (any or too many) variables.</p> <p>Any help is greatly appreciated.</p> <p>P.S. For reference, I am including a correlation table (<a href="http://i.stack.imgur.com/Q4eiY.png" rel="nofollow">link to bigger image</a>):</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/Q4eiY.png" alt="enter image description here"></p>
36,327
[ -0.07898075878620148, -0.019845938310027122, 0.0058078160509467125, 0.07947146892547607, 0.05188818648457527, -0.0007627225131727755, -0.030525898560881615, -0.03579818457365036, 0.018987400457262993, -0.03154241666197777, 0.0171755813062191, 0.051686517894268036, 0.03636870160698891, 0.061607424169778824, 0.005750758573412895, 0.02167927846312523, 0.0288550965487957, 0.02688366360962391, -0.0048326910473406315, -0.004606776870787144, 0.03185983747243881, 0.006432836875319481, -0.025223392993211746, -0.0011425010161474347, 0.01762424223124981, 0.05813611298799515, 0.001927043660543859, -0.03177238255739212, 0.023123009130358696, 0.014680227264761925, -0.020303549244999886, -0.031207095831632614, 0.011935614980757236, 0.011868517845869064, -0.013073951005935669, 0.029020706191658974, 0.04608704894781113, 0.005017825402319431, -0.01846952550113201, 0.008627217262983322, -0.03308296576142311, -0.005707690492272377, -0.024103183299303055, 0.07884009182453156, 0.00931435078382492, -0.00613027811050415, 0.03414836898446083, -0.005918242037296295, 0.01898089237511158, -0.04125431180000305, 0.0878906324505806, 0.005301236640661955, 0.02481907047331333, 0.01702931709587574, 0.0014064557617530227, -0.005509329028427601, 0.010062203742563725, 0.032521024346351624, 0.001678028958849609, -0.019217783585190773, -0.010684344917535782, 0.01712869480252266, -0.003217299934476614, 0.005836098454892635, 0.0047830697149038315, 0.025349240750074387, 0.00758718466386199, 0.02096579596400261, 0.031474437564611435, -0.008547920733690262, 0.05126616731286049, 0.022520558908581734, 0.01731651835143566, -0.004806001204997301, 0.03809596598148346, -0.018027644604444504, -0.025581922382116318, 0.03312765061855316, 0.01366602722555399, 0.01873571239411831, -0.011083239689469337, -0.002633668016642332, -0.010813623666763306, 0.010593430139124393, 0.02388613112270832, -0.007216961123049259, 0.05806140601634979, -0.021658869460225105, 0.035992734134197235, 0.04263772815465927, -0.03257286921143532, -0.017225490882992744, 0.062228284776210785, 0.03604031726717949, -0.030951710417866707, 0.023237057030200958, -0.016748005524277687, 0.048714421689510345, 0.025771576911211014, -0.011805042624473572, -0.029814306646585464, -0.020988019183278084, -0.01106103416532278, 0.0531759150326252, -0.015276648104190826, -0.003582969307899475, -0.0031011411920189857, -0.0011563625885173678, 0.006279253866523504, -0.03118700347840786, -0.03529595956206322, 0.02712618000805378, 0.018818901851773262, -0.006943776737898588, 0.0197537150233984, -0.0068732621148228645, -0.034406013786792755, -0.010293734259903431, 0.024243539199233055, 0.04129503667354584, 0.02161819487810135, -0.04212666302919388, 0.02294347807765007, -0.003561593359336257, -0.0313108004629612, 0.0440182164311409, 0.016945939511060715, 0.01411120779812336, -0.02276727929711342, 0.028030550107359886, 0.041427481919527054, -0.03566795587539673, -0.0003952393599320203, -0.010496523231267929, 0.00872520450502634, 0.014373988844454288, -0.06942349672317505, -0.06922049820423126, 0.026389775797724724, -0.00040476088179275393, 0.04733322560787201, -0.06001707538962364, -0.0322975218296051, -0.016813907772302628, 0.057794298976659775, -0.020967185497283936, 0.04444490000605583, 0.0512261763215065, -0.005379077512770891, -0.008068504743278027, 0.02754976414144039, -0.028524309396743774, -0.03451317921280861, -0.04107685759663582, -0.005880454089492559, -0.06314350664615631, 0.023350069299340248, 0.028713932260870934, 0.004164647776633501, -0.008625996299088001, 0.02400548942387104, 0.019687121734023094, -0.04203854128718376, -0.007117280270904303, 0.03200427070260048, -0.0219500083476305, 0.026214776560664177, -0.023855388164520264, 0.020449621602892876, 0.03330821916460991, -0.0022610214073210955, -0.02194344624876976, -0.034522101283073425, 0.025715110823512077, 0.0076753427274525166, -0.005080424249172211, 0.011693986132740974, -0.05474577099084854, 0.005508051719516516, 0.025153212249279022, -0.052430037409067154, -0.04545135051012039, -0.01117232721298933, 0.023874089121818542, 0.02590569294989109, 0.05900432541966438, -0.019625622779130936, -0.037218283861875534, 0.060129813849925995, -0.04579726606607437, -0.04914609342813492, -0.0379108190536499, 0.03785267472267151, -0.013379909098148346, -0.04299881309270859, 0.024673808366060257, 0.01708708330988884, 0.03509179502725601, 0.0018443982116878033, -0.008694969117641449, -0.03490806370973587, -0.010899888351559639, 0.06975694745779037, -0.053447116166353226, 0.025218036025762558, -0.019552279263734818, 0.04407583549618721, -0.011450831778347492, 0.04970061779022217, -0.011259477585554123, -0.05402454733848572, 0.013958215713500977, -0.037695057690143585, 0.022451726719737053, -0.008286548778414726, -0.02990812063217163, 0.03134869039058685, 0.02270536683499813, -0.003842676291242242, 0.009889824315905571, -0.01806357130408287, 0.06351188570261002, 0.03053610399365425, -0.009786015376448631, -0.003219722304493189, 0.017858440056443214, -0.003606379497796297, 0.03708004951477051, -0.03473003953695297, -0.02323741838335991, -0.043116435408592224, -0.04998713359236717, 0.011286161839962006, 0.011135367676615715, -0.03238219767808914, -0.04005132615566254, 0.05500488355755806, 0.016599459573626518, 0.04326928034424782, -0.007566752377897501, 0.005660390481352806, -0.027643008157610893, 0.0174882709980011, -0.01432078331708908, -0.010404858738183975, 0.018911221995949745, -0.027373040094971657, 0.019207308068871498, 0.036348674446344376, -0.04114077240228653, 0.012552989646792412, 0.0333612784743309, 0.03866637498140335, 0.007030688226222992, -0.03682512789964676, -0.026790477335453033, 0.05397653579711914, -0.046656906604766846, 0.005866753403097391, 0.08364850282669067, -0.008006807416677475, -0.02005835995078087, 0.010402156971395016, -0.025330128148198128, -0.011010754853487015, 0.0660962238907814, -0.04076872020959854, 0.01576395519077778, 0.010082840919494629, -0.039163097739219666, 0.007523076143115759, -0.012891541235148907, 0.018065420910716057, -0.05215602368116379, 0.030537443235516548, 0.03658606484532356, -0.016833467409014702, 0.028900938108563423, -0.0010280197020620108, 0.005332458298653364, -0.029706543311476707, 0.0023664783220738173, 0.015554707497358322, -0.005698015913367271, -0.017198853194713593, -0.037383273243904114, 0.01724558137357235, -0.00372460950165987, 0.03422723338007927, 0.016210049390792847, -0.010591620579361916, 0.04519462585449219, -0.002853229409083724, -0.04628028720617294, -0.02758646011352539, -0.021777605637907982, 0.05101220682263374, -0.013239582069218159, -0.0012923369649797678, -0.02442147210240364, 0.025510920211672783, -0.0707608237862587, 0.02377641759812832, -0.042937252670526505, -0.03504270315170288, -0.0010883164359256625, -0.004262717440724373, -0.006616836879402399, -0.011518276296555996, -0.03132699429988861, 0.01507411990314722, 0.024771803990006447, -0.01879919320344925, -0.055004723370075226, -0.05191799998283386, -0.00019879231695085764, 0.018827233463525772, 0.03277366980910301, -0.04235503822565079, -0.010729855857789516, 0.09066437929868698, 0.045523349195718765, -0.015329490415751934, -0.0329064205288887, -0.054663222283124924, -0.01279384084045887, -0.023460138589143753, 0.02927478402853012, 0.05075721815228462, -0.001891668769530952, 0.002964700572192669, -0.03719320893287659, 0.0399649515748024, 0.04801102355122566, -0.028347384184598923, 0.004922547843307257, 0.021017378196120262, -0.014521345496177673, -0.013149878941476345, 0.051135048270225525, 0.03386913985013962, -0.03370159491896629, -0.0058691115118563175, 0.02617521770298481, 0.04948665201663971, 0.01840868964791298, -0.03546267747879028, 0.012433075346052647, -0.017213480547070503, 0.005789663176983595, -0.03813044726848602, -0.014152847230434418, 0.02673959732055664, -0.03769116476178169, -0.007324512582272291, -0.026158079504966736, 0.024678099900484085, -0.005682890769094229, 0.005848363041877747, 0.041472166776657104, 0.008339458145201206, 0.01507935207337141, 0.01440860703587532, -0.06070590019226074, -0.008225465193390846, 0.006475845817476511, -0.03612057864665985, 0.014284874312579632, 0.030253635719418526, 0.04739907383918762, 0.017421074211597443, -0.0082321185618639, -0.04355434700846672, -0.01430579088628292, -0.08009948581457138, -0.012342280708253384, -0.043990351259708405, 0.033369164913892746, 0.059669867157936096, 0.02315778285264969, -0.00881409551948309, 0.0032048742286860943, -0.004795026499778032, 0.008081862702965736, -0.028975285589694977, 0.0058846441097557545, -0.02817428484559059, 0.03205972909927368, 0.009387980215251446, -0.011406383477151394, 0.020246252417564392, 0.005951789673417807, 0.008076781406998634, 0.004574697930365801, 0.02324991300702095, -0.024380914866924286, 0.012002566829323769, -0.008471953682601452, 0.001026309677399695, 0.014899635687470436, 0.02066301740705967, 0.010049667209386826, -0.007198925595730543, 0.022774027660489082, 0.02738978900015354, -0.005694504827260971, -0.018453700467944145, -0.03883861005306244, -0.042049627751111984, 0.05317028984427452, 0.11188188940286636, -0.011756927706301212, -0.011951463297009468, -0.02637244574725628, -0.004710043780505657, 0.013197590596973896, 0.017107078805565834, 0.05153327435255051, 0.0034707756713032722, 0.014130160212516785, -0.061886485666036606, -0.0329878143966198, -0.0057175541296601295, 0.007004495710134506, 0.000815699459053576, 0.003810622962191701, 0.03336969017982483, 0.020080793648958206, -0.03802851215004921, -0.02503002993762493, 0.03819604590535164, 0.07723820954561234, 0.03939888998866081, 0.0013418820453807712, -0.008615013211965561, 0.0064145843498408794, -0.030735010281205177, 0.005455136764794588, 0.04627559334039688, -0.009256566874682903, -0.016964880749583244, 0.07070042192935944, -0.011117467656731606, -0.054947033524513245, 0.007644266821444035, -0.003441191976889968, 0.034667860716581345, -0.012647745199501514, -0.0559430830180645, -0.004543295595794916, 0.02498469687998295, 0.028389373794198036, 0.020414769649505615, 0.035592127591371536, -0.08124503493309021, -0.03748799487948418, 0.0423477441072464, 0.009594845585525036, -0.037805911153554916, -0.0156844612210989, -0.03696398064494133, -0.03711811825633049, 0.03341950103640556, -0.04350195825099945, 0.03949039429426193, 0.021874532103538513, 0.03885141760110855, -0.008809123188257217, -0.08157461881637573, -0.02909708395600319, 0.02328822948038578, 0.018205080181360245, 0.020692644640803337, -0.023581989109516144, -0.009327462874352932, -0.014362298883497715, 0.02442449890077114, 0.041224461048841476, 0.014913882128894329, 0.0016185614513233304, -0.023393213748931885, 0.026906680315732956, 0.026808684691786766, -0.00024972212850116193, -0.05486951768398285, 0.040194593369960785, 0.011808772571384907, -0.001374323503114283, 0.06204024702310562, -0.00927707925438881, -0.0626785159111023, 0.008231567218899727, 0.040852513164281845, -0.021513400599360466, 0.016802402213215828, -0.025840742513537407, 0.05923587456345558, 0.020710326731204987, -0.014280007220804691, 0.003817268880084157, 0.023211292922496796, -0.029356230050325394, 0.004029593896120787, -0.05324782803654671, 0.009500940330326557, -0.026113171130418777, -0.03750820457935333, -0.025882363319396973, -0.033069808036088943, -0.0017565430607646704, -0.004268373362720013, 0.013758997432887554, 0.029129114001989365, -0.050290901213884354, 0.04414375498890877, -0.017495064064860344, -0.008150527253746986, -0.023207802325487137, -0.028749827295541763, -0.021263858303427696, 0.02302931435406208, -0.009392083622515202, -0.037701670080423355, 0.028623241931200027, -0.03154529258608818, -0.017150944098830223, -0.0261693075299263, -0.022323356941342354, -0.033753037452697754, -0.03534553572535515, -0.017762018367648125, -0.019700471311807632, -0.035584717988967896, 0.05420033633708954, -0.005401021335273981, 0.009039840660989285, 0.019390355795621872, -0.032133474946022034, 0.007145988754928112, 0.02435101941227913, -0.003725602990016341, 0.007413011509925127, -0.005555730778723955, 0.004407085012644529, -0.021481523290276527, -0.03822656720876694, -0.05713063105940819, -0.0577671192586422, 0.02277030609548092, -0.006775373127311468, -0.051373500376939774, -0.0400933101773262, -0.030426958575844765, 0.029674381017684937, -0.017804719507694244, 0.0023621718864887953, 0.040014978498220444, -0.017684876918792725, 0.0179805438965559, -0.010077044367790222, 0.030483894050121307, 0.061215922236442566, -0.05144096910953522, 0.010797319933772087, 0.029545215889811516, -0.03775397315621376, 0.02242913655936718, -0.040718160569667816, 0.010260717011988163, -0.03849034756422043, -0.010241871699690819, -0.053866151720285416, -0.016654718667268753, 0.02915794588625431, 0.03976975753903389, 0.003078481648117304, -0.027404969558119774, -0.03206384927034378, -0.014656050130724907, -0.0004387374792713672, -0.005856899544596672, 0.013277470134198666, 0.0006656788755208254, -0.013263004831969738, 0.007401346694678068, -0.03486160561442375, -0.005014197435230017, 0.02277013286948204, -0.03159003704786301, -0.019239021465182304, 0.005605547223240137, 0.07861129194498062, -0.006147788837552071, 0.018896637484431267, -0.004981826525181532, 0.018531085923314095, 0.046326927840709686, -0.0039129056967794895, 0.03021697700023651, -0.023258477449417114, 0.04614578187465668, -0.023370740935206413, -0.02380996383726597, -0.042434800416231155, 0.003572355257347226, 0.05827629938721657, -0.013373378664255142, 0.04419573023915291, 0.040238719433546066, -0.014867332763969898, 0.02379048988223076, -0.06746184080839157, -0.00834820605814457, 0.028156181797385216, 0.02072819694876671, 0.026997877284884453, -0.017757384106516838, -0.009459690190851688, 0.06109681352972984, 0.02066314034163952, 0.056279439479112625, 0.006888404488563538, 0.02408389002084732, 0.011534623801708221, 0.020390495657920837, -0.025452468544244766, -0.0037790436763316393, 0.017406918108463287, 0.011923483572900295, 0.024705559015274048, 0.004850808531045914, -0.01950865052640438, 0.025020381435751915, 0.05644829571247101, 0.0028312415815889835, -0.05257128179073334, -0.02721000649034977, -0.047651953995227814, 0.01709679700434208, 0.011818962171673775, -0.024700334295630455, 0.00895632989704609, 0.006518997717648745, 0.03762013465166092, 0.006297118961811066, 0.02732967771589756, -0.06715962290763855, -0.07703738659620285, 0.030051926150918007, -0.03382669389247894, -0.007355805486440659, 0.05175846442580223, -0.016690272837877274, -0.02824464626610279, 0.04243316501379013, -0.025804689154028893, -0.026817819103598595, -0.02265465259552002, 0.025588510558009148, 0.006578128319233656, 0.07176211476325989, 0.007469563279300928, 0.016004865989089012, -0.019197996705770493, -0.0073008351027965546, 0.14430102705955505, 0.05022871866822243, 0.01216559112071991, -0.02003847062587738, 0.0339839793741703, 0.05503128841519356, -0.013742275536060333, -0.04730965569615364, -0.017396869137883186, -0.022088350728154182, -0.020076479762792587, 0.03631008416414261, 0.04590242728590965, 0.02248535491526127, -0.011221207678318024, 0.050844546407461166, -0.055894885212183, -0.006515184883028269, -0.03416358307003975, 0.03559441864490509, -0.011271165683865547, -0.03618926182389259, -0.0482947863638401, 0.011381709948182106, 0.017058733850717545, -0.030264558270573616, -0.02520626410841942, 0.018803661689162254, 0.034407272934913635, -0.0060804057866334915, -0.0026535524521023035, 0.01837047003209591, 0.022557463496923447, 0.007934852503240108, -0.021607881411910057, -0.0027272605802863836, 0.06104854866862297, -0.04396941885352135, -0.0010699043050408363, 0.001623716321773827, -0.05234145373106003, 0.02584541216492653, 0.007921983487904072, -0.010228748433291912, -0.04146859422326088, -0.036739882081747055, -0.04968573525547981, 0.027108049020171165, 0.026464760303497314, -0.03331245109438896, -0.027575938031077385, 0.020314529538154602, -0.014919298700988293, -0.03861914202570915, 0.004674035124480724, 0.0033105220645666122, -0.013535777106881142, 0.00935708824545145, -0.010924231261014938, -0.019808892160654068, 0.02280752919614315, -0.02821516990661621, 0.03739606961607933, 0.015088452957570553, -0.012012531980872154, -0.03406602144241333, -0.06308597326278687, 0.08053629845380783, 0.010939069092273712, -0.008654730394482613, 0.0017027314752340317, -0.0037785929162055254, -0.006239405367523432, -0.016447613015770912, 0.013849696144461632, 0.03996507078409195, 0.020790334790945053, -0.020765697583556175, 0.011905073188245296, -0.086246058344841, -0.03710157424211502, 0.002385491505265236, -0.028784282505512238, -0.02037503756582737, -0.0691884234547615, 0.0036805043928325176, 0.01134631596505642, 0.008447401225566864, 0.009948085993528366, 0.0351831316947937, -0.01852952130138874, 0.07048573344945908, 0.0010989251313731074, -0.015997635200619698, -0.0015499151777476072, -0.03956014662981033, -0.0714590847492218, 0.0028828145004808903, -0.02684307098388672, 0.0777190551161766, 0.033799078315496445, 0.007924194447696209, 0.008056310005486012, 0.041670218110084534, -0.025283245369791985, 0.010498471558094025, 0.006770140957087278, -0.0777675211429596, -0.01105837058275938, 0.019483497366309166, 0.006570945959538221, -0.006031946744769812, 0.006903983186930418, 0.006573317106813192, -0.023715345188975334, 0.026739265769720078, 0.016668735072016716, -0.031391870230436325, -0.007504031993448734, -0.018522895872592926, 0.06916412711143494, -0.04684733971953392, -0.02753314934670925, -0.010899472050368786, 0.011273827403783798, -0.03915862739086151, 0.0014996621757745743, -0.020538033917546272, -0.0014711761614307761, 0.011005682870745659, 0.03715294227004051, 0.025339916348457336, 0.015391804277896881, 0.0355248786509037, -0.045917805284261703, 0.0008235280402004719, 0.01392604224383831, 0.03026513196527958, -0.0035662385635077953, -0.03770323842763901, 0.014589189551770687, 0.0202231016010046, -0.046053189784288406, -0.024107500910758972, 0.005895659793168306, 0.06970760226249695, -0.02216407284140587, 0.03848139941692352, -0.031670451164245605, 0.0406099408864975, -0.0010620026150718331, 0.023004917427897453, 0.014407687820494175, 0.019072672352194786, 0.032862599939107895, -0.031800080090761185, 0.0005694329156540334, 0.02658591978251934, -0.023589765653014183, 0.017969097942113876, 0.049073226749897, -0.02213827706873417, 0.0123075470328331, 0.01959591545164585, -0.04686169698834419, 0.003185794223099947, 0.009456121362745762, 0.005149954929947853, 0.026364127174019814, 0.00034488961682654917, 0.00399906188249588, 0.038119152188301086, 0.029879316687583923, 0.036679722368717194, -0.051147472113370895, -0.012071236036717892, 0.004064210224896669, 0.008036303333938122, 0.040466248989105225, -0.03097345679998398, 0.004946392495185137, 0.019559958949685097, -0.057358890771865845, 0.020134015008807182, 0.024787796661257744, 0.004960845690220594, -0.044295623898506165, -0.01697404310107231, -0.023911193013191223, 0.03044416382908821, -0.0012947957729920745, 0.01776064932346344, 0.037972673773765564, 0.049699943512678146, 0.005236025433987379, -0.08581455051898956, -0.028540028259158134, -0.01274737250059843, -0.016398850828409195, -0.04125070944428444, 0.02604118548333645, -0.0433860644698143, -0.0021061000879853964, 0.0016432579141110182, -0.02565978467464447, 0.021972423419356346, 0.018837880343198776, 0.023692410439252853, 0.012212635949254036, 0.040851712226867676, 0.05101938545703888, 0.016236500814557076, -0.017669426277279854, -0.022969698533415794, 0.04126434773206711, 0.0031610310543328524, 0.010626773349940777, 0.013507022522389889, 0.04849941283464432, -0.020499849691987038, -0.010272243060171604, -0.014587520621716976, -0.003794550895690918, 0.017397262156009674, -0.035652223974466324, -0.009666478261351585, 0.02386167272925377, -0.0009492899407632649, -0.004417031537741423, -0.07602708041667938, 0.01968901790678501, 0.05338804051280022, 0.0049691167660057545, 0.016531769186258316, 0.0010617530206218362, -0.025835344567894936, -0.03381580114364624, 0.01647326350212097, -0.0046014259569346905, 0.010524431243538857, -0.035325683653354645, -0.008210231550037861, -0.000010363522960687988, -0.02701047621667385, -0.04552173614501953, 0.03507247939705849, -0.007999597117304802, 0.05820971727371216, -0.036934878677129745, -0.005568170920014381, 0.0008465313003398478, -0.02872946858406067, 0.04494220390915871, -0.06138495355844498, 0.0516195073723793, -0.007765204645693302, -0.04990839585661888, -0.020149776712059975, -0.036761753261089325, 0.004423751030117273, 0.005735471844673157, 0.039644353091716766, -0.03407992795109749, 0.004308957606554031, -0.0046457224525511265, 0.00016289106861222535, -0.003005963983014226, -0.00938247051090002, 0.04569327458739281, -0.004623002372682095, 0.0233799759298563, 0.003904406214132905, 0.007686840835958719, 0.0228734090924263, -0.010219438932836056, -0.0006076213903725147, -0.027691299095749855, -0.019389474764466286, 0.01339650433510542, -0.0023423824459314346, -0.017221590504050255, -0.013858321122825146, -0.01585969887673855, 0.061689697206020355, 0.0052407593466341496, -0.0281208548694849, 0.04978597164154053, 0.016421498730778694, -0.05542910471558571, 0.008030320517718792, -0.010185847990214825, -0.03261310234665871, 0.025337187573313713, 0.02523500844836235, 0.04236699640750885, -0.07060153037309647, 0.038987740874290466, 0.06211542710661888, -0.022806035354733467, 0.005556383170187473, 0.018981868401169777, 0.0008628194336779416, -0.011704615317285061, -0.016787998378276825, -0.00608164444565773, -0.007737994194030762, -0.02070719189941883, 0.029159486293792725, -0.011742574162781239, 0.039367035031318665, 0.02639455534517765, -0.009427939541637897, 0.028865953907370567, 0.0010348225478082895, 0.0708148255944252, 0.003009504172950983, 0.0030033786315470934, -0.026661327108740807, 0.006699130404740572, 0.014237931929528713, 0.021546103060245514, 0.01847940869629383, 0.008001323789358139, 0.00139568280428648, 0.059543367475271225, -0.04413040354847908, -0.02792394906282425, -0.03451653942465782, 0.006794652435928583, -0.060496143996715546, 0.0007117228815332055, 0.0064122797921299934, 0.007930498570203781, -0.0037777195684611797, -0.022680263966321945, -0.005085467826575041, -0.007355198729783297, 0.021208791062235832, -0.003242360195145011, 0.04953691363334656, -0.01867806538939476, 0.02333841286599636, 0.02792225033044815, -0.036890435963869095, -0.019243931397795677, 0.016232378780841827, 0.04101790860295296, -0.0017859825165942311, -0.00821642018854618, -0.05007719248533249, 0.0023343435022979975, 0.028442250564694405, 0.04516997188329697, -0.04715050011873245, -0.05297229811549187, -0.02734038606286049, -0.026376472786068916, -0.023275405168533325, -0.013534284196794033 ]
<p>I want to see if there is a correlation (or any sort of relationship) between two time series I am working with.</p> <p>One of them is a times series of temperature data, the other one is concentration of a substance. I am trying to see if there is a relationship between the concentration and temperature.</p> <p>However, temperature data series is not stationary (and there are gaps in it), and neither is the concentration series. The problem is that I don't have enough information on the temperature data series since I don't have data for even one period (one year). </p> <p>What can I do?</p>
73,829
[ 0.013241433538496494, -0.01162938866764307, -0.026105143129825592, 0.03630925342440605, 0.005094633903354406, 0.017978517338633537, -0.011433040723204613, -0.002089531160891056, 0.02013591304421425, -0.012809045612812042, 0.07875588536262512, 0.04067197069525719, 0.011098487302660942, 0.037574876099824905, 0.01677333563566208, 0.016715358942747116, -0.010978595353662968, 0.013479573652148247, 0.024881476536393166, -0.00002991233668581117, -0.030476687476038933, 0.008760575205087662, 0.032512400299310684, 0.013746235519647598, -0.02122582122683525, 0.04126216471195221, -0.007404692005366087, -0.013458387926220894, -0.0026096501387655735, 0.0540449358522892, -0.07322104275226593, -0.036476049572229385, 0.0028859428130090237, 0.05614136531949043, 0.05560309439897537, 0.0011303320061415434, -0.04275200515985489, -0.01818961650133133, 0.0077755628153681755, 0.042552266269922256, -0.02284279651939869, -0.03047700971364975, 0.01890048198401928, 0.04095277190208435, -0.026205535978078842, 0.01650288514792919, 0.03563527762889862, -0.017994068562984467, 0.03882504627108574, -0.051691390573978424, 0.044428449124097824, -0.030568324029445648, 0.05987225100398064, 0.0694679468870163, -0.027924751862883568, -0.004163977224379778, 0.05992506816983223, 0.050807081162929535, -0.010455227456986904, -0.049449507147073746, -0.014067390002310276, 0.001219491590745747, -0.019112981855869293, -0.025048762559890747, -0.05177020654082298, 0.019901728257536888, -0.03028079867362976, -0.03707360848784447, 0.035033054649829865, -0.016672726720571518, 0.035346537828445435, 0.013276278041303158, 0.033573515713214874, -0.022208111360669136, -0.006437048781663179, -0.054786764085292816, -0.0009550249669700861, 0.03235933184623718, 0.05824996531009674, 0.04933130741119385, -0.0006370573537424207, 0.014482102356851101, 0.0358264185488224, 0.014741778373718262, 0.03603700175881386, 0.003260469064116478, 0.05919830873608589, -0.026098288595676422, -0.009991737082600594, 0.033292580395936966, -0.005801517516374588, -0.0020372311118990183, 0.04203419014811516, 0.027108866721391678, -0.011303192004561424, -0.0030861974228173494, -0.019883036613464355, 0.038805797696113586, 0.016141531988978386, 0.013789678923785686, 0.010075266472995281, -0.02604367583990097, 0.026249153539538383, 0.04521065205335617, -0.023438585922122, -0.03329307958483696, -0.005333121865987778, 0.016338789835572243, -0.0005615639383904636, -0.014741905964910984, -0.04142259061336517, -0.01331396959722042, 0.0066506280563771725, 0.013536221347749233, 0.020860567688941956, -0.009672391228377819, -0.029831847175955772, -0.02030586637556553, 0.06325124204158783, 0.06879858672618866, 0.03731025382876396, -0.001754302647896111, -0.004204409196972847, 0.011133898980915546, -0.04469781368970871, 0.001329513848759234, -0.007544955238699913, 0.015383563935756683, -0.003947923891246319, 0.08158896863460541, -0.05093858391046524, -0.02271178737282753, 0.021412674337625504, -0.021378561854362488, 0.055326420813798904, 0.025809817016124725, -0.08388244360685349, -0.030867356806993484, 0.04327782243490219, -0.02288137748837471, -0.02364223077893257, -0.07014258205890656, 0.029630931094288826, 0.010848048143088818, 0.06293844431638718, 0.014211100526154041, 0.014861461706459522, -0.009997723624110222, 0.03411524370312691, 0.019797248765826225, -0.008361471816897392, -0.025109272450208664, 0.018497617915272713, -0.015608455054461956, 0.005346810445189476, -0.05715277045965195, 0.005849714390933514, 0.04777640476822853, 0.012082146480679512, 0.012166635133326054, 0.014422283507883549, 0.01854110322892666, 0.002798394300043583, 0.014259149320423603, 0.03591882437467575, -0.04379408434033394, 0.06091258302330971, -0.010296172462403774, 0.00383105524815619, -0.019563112407922745, 0.022170836105942726, 0.033241767436265945, 0.0235358327627182, 0.03236988186836243, 0.05238719657063484, 0.017514176666736603, -0.018073027953505516, 0.01274250540882349, -0.01647745817899704, 0.03137833625078201, -0.04543759673833847, -0.03297877311706543, -0.03497195243835449, -0.018334759399294853, 0.046579066663980484, 0.06358794122934341, 0.03459936007857323, -0.024638429284095764, 0.020035922527313232, -0.06683313846588135, -0.0010306305484846234, -0.07724519819021225, -0.03028728999197483, -0.044508934020996094, -0.02802196703851223, 0.029585139825940132, 0.01969834417104721, 0.036336176097393036, -0.056139733642339706, -0.06588906049728394, -0.019608989357948303, -0.025789372622966766, 0.029624486342072487, -0.03704410418868065, 0.0179028008133173, 0.02954944595694542, 0.056335318833589554, -0.01337785180658102, 0.052389420568943024, -0.04525017365813255, -0.03818042203783989, 0.008518088608980179, -0.03888249024748802, 0.005670071113854647, -0.015876367688179016, -0.00829522218555212, 0.004037330858409405, -0.005886284168809652, -0.02535839006304741, 0.023401061072945595, -0.038579311221838, 0.08474835008382797, 0.04999156668782234, 0.023815570399165154, 0.013713022693991661, -0.007272698916494846, 0.06212121248245239, 0.0029049536678940058, -0.029530450701713562, -0.013992364518344402, -0.043162643909454346, 0.012389554642140865, 0.030233468860387802, 0.05120445787906647, -0.06029985472559929, 0.014729260466992855, 0.05882669612765312, 0.016083789989352226, -0.00019168485596310347, 0.02913869544863701, -0.0076521034352481365, -0.013921404257416725, 0.0061058159917593, -0.015873068943619728, 0.005525501444935799, 0.023510955274105072, 0.023967355489730835, 0.016972165554761887, 0.06188834458589554, -0.01548404898494482, -0.03139803558588028, 0.037437789142131805, 0.018125910311937332, 0.004492606967687607, 0.007469684351235628, -0.004416089970618486, 0.0535426065325737, -0.007530526723712683, 0.0016449039103463292, 0.004537675529718399, 0.007461235858500004, 0.00042724391096271574, 0.015185654163360596, -0.020382482558488846, -0.008383039385080338, 0.02196853794157505, -0.04364526644349098, -0.006558595225214958, 0.03081998974084854, -0.060694191604852676, -0.011411299929022789, -0.03296072036027908, -0.018846269696950912, -0.041328705847263336, 0.0022562379017472267, 0.031899914145469666, 0.03551587462425232, 0.0541883148252964, -0.02170330286026001, -0.030943211168050766, 0.000029013386665610597, -0.020577047020196915, -0.0008777013281360269, -0.00025464186910539865, -0.03184022381901741, 0.0016980174696072936, 0.032152604311704636, -0.017328431829810143, 0.027150964364409447, -0.01171627826988697, -0.015494359657168388, 0.030836254358291626, -0.03203531354665756, -0.04520536959171295, -0.06539524346590042, -0.020429736003279686, 0.02829594537615776, -0.017232485115528107, -0.003322853473946452, 0.036155760288238525, -0.03602897748351097, -0.04943397268652916, 0.007365494966506958, -0.04119497537612915, -0.010835351422429085, -0.05811711400747299, 0.008152675814926624, 0.0010926605900749564, -0.04159679636359215, 0.010271778330206871, 0.02455756813287735, -0.022120576351881027, 0.004622914362698793, -0.06494885683059692, -0.05198611319065094, 0.016353288665413857, 0.011626658029854298, 0.026788704097270966, -0.008846571668982506, -0.03388777747750282, 0.03685753047466278, 0.008261446841061115, -0.002835333114489913, -0.0637269914150238, -0.029329074546694756, -0.06743315607309341, -0.027876392006874084, 0.02040065824985504, 0.01851237192749977, 0.011442020535469055, -0.010077603161334991, 0.028172409161925316, 0.032037459313869476, 0.05040965601801872, 0.006606008857488632, 0.016230328008532524, 0.02906361036002636, 0.0031269791070371866, 0.010013299994170666, 0.07030703127384186, 0.02863674983382225, -0.04254931956529617, -0.00009009197674458846, -0.020150676369667053, 0.0349147692322731, 0.03867960721254349, -0.03398289903998375, -0.0007231483468785882, 0.011629417538642883, 0.033202607184648514, -0.060497116297483444, 0.04083841294050217, 0.00837071891874075, 0.015114954672753811, -0.044692885130643845, 0.01537226140499115, 0.03149507939815521, 0.012591296806931496, -0.012891770340502262, 0.06785225868225098, 0.01767783612012863, -0.023680049926042557, -0.012213386595249176, -0.0026626421604305506, -0.016867423430085182, 0.027105366811156273, -0.0025269496254622936, -0.023561734706163406, 0.04732171818614006, 0.009141378104686737, 0.003435614053159952, 0.013560126535594463, -0.04830286279320717, -0.009153258055448532, -0.08868024498224258, -0.014403090812265873, -0.00027055927785113454, 0.06170514225959778, 0.004559593740850687, 0.05734853073954582, 0.02722623199224472, -0.010214396752417088, 0.059407368302345276, -0.0071935891173779964, -0.06032070517539978, 0.05908221751451492, -0.020799094811081886, -0.034753333777189255, 0.0015702374512329698, 0.002596271689981222, 0.004386228043586016, -0.06741731613874435, 0.020493147894740105, 0.022176453843712807, 0.010865935124456882, -0.027759414166212082, 0.006561512127518654, -0.039655327796936035, -0.0009980964241549373, -0.025791209191083908, -0.013547951355576515, 0.04180692136287689, -0.0040999846532940865, 0.050133854150772095, 0.05038478597998619, 0.002172366250306368, -0.005676903761923313, -0.0212428979575634, 0.00828006211668253, 0.037109676748514175, 0.02446206472814083, -0.0021273393649607897, 0.02938740886747837, -0.033799055963754654, 0.010999918915331364, 0.009299675934016705, 0.02716602012515068, 0.01078620832413435, 0.009457061998546124, -0.008428830653429031, -0.02010180614888668, 0.005589445121586323, 0.012482031248509884, 0.020844541490077972, 0.004367548506706953, 0.002387292217463255, -0.004730707965791225, -0.0005692467675544322, -0.03924532234668732, 0.011995199136435986, 0.0784933790564537, 0.024537159129977226, 0.0275502260774374, -0.00017097414820455015, -0.027422571554780006, -0.017839359119534492, 0.011569160036742687, 0.03851199522614479, 0.018750855699181557, 0.00778170395642519, -0.019085275009274483, 0.012006049044430256, 0.025816746056079865, -0.014449690468609333, 0.005124198272824287, 0.021766100078821182, 0.06356105953454971, -0.003478158265352249, -0.03582412376999855, 0.06296584010124207, 0.022093120962381363, 0.033427078276872635, -0.011476408690214157, 0.02730814926326275, -0.1141991913318634, 0.009872603230178356, 0.0653396025300026, 0.015850255265831947, -0.04042118415236473, -0.030788246542215347, -0.055506616830825806, 0.0005890815518796444, 0.05458574742078781, -0.04296092689037323, 0.041272759437561035, 0.001576117123477161, -0.0009331791661679745, -0.0008099166443571448, -0.05496006831526756, -0.03460850939154625, 0.030334172770380974, -0.010120806284248829, 0.02592131495475769, -0.010326399467885494, -0.0467621274292469, -0.04256932809948921, 0.0018134319689124823, 0.004939446225762367, 0.06913074105978012, -0.03427118435502052, -0.021803392097353935, 0.010764334350824356, 0.014789084903895855, -0.002611354924738407, -0.08859824389219284, 0.02870020642876625, -0.020229971036314964, -0.004400081932544708, 0.04847186431288719, -0.002136669121682644, -0.01612590253353119, 0.0018256158800795674, -0.01735772378742695, -0.04233293980360031, 0.006162066012620926, -0.018611842766404152, 0.05796463415026665, 0.03414824232459068, 0.04785188287496567, 0.05032309144735336, 0.0412045493721962, 0.032114867120981216, -0.0029715504497289658, -0.031522300094366074, 0.020681871101260185, -0.019797639921307564, 0.021816115826368332, -0.04010048136115074, -0.005175441037863493, -0.05753215774893761, 0.024616315960884094, 0.008438282646238804, 0.010630642995238304, -0.008484491147100925, 0.006319846957921982, 0.012451191432774067, 0.02331235632300377, -0.003876581322401762, -0.0252885390073061, 0.007755673490464687, -0.006824989337474108, -0.047191500663757324, -0.010140908882021904, 0.02475510537624359, -0.021236177533864975, -0.01413116604089737, 0.008915964514017105, -0.031899306923151016, 0.012998562306165695, -0.02497182972729206, -0.018121493980288506, -0.015702268108725548, -0.024412404745817184, 0.032971154898405075, -0.011403456330299377, 0.04242640733718872, 0.01674657128751278, -0.03217831999063492, -0.005060095805674791, 0.034528326243162155, 0.01455332525074482, 0.02644083835184574, -0.066238634288311, 0.08091124892234802, -0.020485009998083115, -0.02877378836274147, -0.05352909117937088, -0.06002858281135559, 0.012510910630226135, 0.036409348249435425, -0.044280778616666794, -0.06975577771663666, 0.008866176940500736, -0.005207625683397055, -0.005353462882339954, -0.029030216857790947, 0.03789745271205902, -0.007625200320035219, -0.028418436646461487, 0.025491205975413322, 0.034085873514413834, 0.061213985085487366, 0.001369600766338408, 0.008727367967367172, 0.030099155381321907, -0.026724515482783318, -0.04628569260239601, -0.01758734881877899, 0.007144162897020578, -0.017973247915506363, -0.039430487900972366, -0.03490123525261879, -0.0031634531915187836, 0.048432622104883194, -0.027020998299121857, -0.03893256187438965, 0.02428506128489971, 0.032176803797483444, 0.000014146783541946206, -0.06872504949569702, 0.03151005506515503, -0.017592640593647957, -0.0178205668926239, -0.0321505181491375, 0.008780082687735558, -0.0007563073304481804, -0.03185981512069702, -0.013697913847863674, -0.002183587523177266, -0.055055681616067886, 0.02020242065191269, 0.03682996332645416, -0.021821975708007812, 0.0005431090830825269, 0.010715708136558533, 0.03765012323856354, -0.0015403247671201825, 0.0063711777329444885, 0.010953265242278576, -0.005681491922587156, 0.01649792306125164, -0.06404294073581696, -0.02319376729428768, 0.014453180134296417, -0.020750710740685463, 0.08726753294467926, -0.0034177580382674932, 0.07452427595853806, 0.03282296657562256, -0.0020436907652765512, 0.011886125430464745, 0.007164152339100838, -0.012477155774831772, 0.00024804193526506424, -0.01093138474971056, 0.03697335347533226, -0.02473820373415947, -0.0029371774289757013, 0.0326693020761013, 0.007778615690767765, 0.013730478473007679, 0.040413808077573776, 0.006271617487072945, -0.013029157184064388, 0.039059340953826904, -0.0034993505105376244, -0.03473574295639992, 0.030973108485341072, -0.02744372934103012, 0.03265046700835228, -0.015988744795322418, 0.0008102837018668652, 0.02878130041062832, 0.04406377300620079, -0.020653866231441498, -0.0457880012691021, -0.03544657677412033, -0.03776656091213226, -0.0061147320084273815, 0.033473700284957886, -0.02409057319164276, 0.03420437499880791, 0.020544102415442467, 0.04052542895078659, 0.013832547701895237, -0.0022232052870094776, -0.019676867872476578, -0.04354748874902725, -0.006747625768184662, -0.03524187207221985, -0.02086465433239937, 0.06823550164699554, -0.005086111836135387, -0.04477984085679054, 0.006536038592457771, -0.0054486882872879505, 0.014350755140185356, 0.013549691066145897, 0.034272391349077225, -0.013236502185463905, 0.06864960491657257, 0.024615537375211716, 0.022510085254907608, 0.007964007556438446, 0.02358907461166382, 0.09251696616411209, 0.04694586992263794, 0.03339020535349846, -0.0616002082824707, -0.0032520215027034283, 0.0064868442714214325, 0.0064321355894207954, -0.03532617166638374, 0.03742731362581253, 0.004572720266878605, -0.003691207617521286, 0.05490662157535553, 0.024519355967640877, 0.0190418791025877, 0.005635442677885294, 0.08382707089185715, -0.011507273651659489, -0.00126801454462111, -0.007638774812221527, -0.004075979348272085, -0.010105115361511707, 0.015704775229096413, -0.04558169096708298, 0.0024660732597112656, -0.03969607129693031, -0.021858053281903267, -0.03746366873383522, -0.02959568426012993, 0.016191869974136353, 0.005715042818337679, -0.060592543333768845, -0.0021405653096735477, 0.035422924906015396, 0.036391038447618484, -0.006714638788253069, -0.021918226033449173, 0.025678090751171112, -0.024208171293139458, 0.005525668617337942, 0.023693230003118515, 0.009424450807273388, -0.005628082901239395, 0.001698349486105144, 0.0074339392594993114, -0.016299596056342125, -0.006699724588543177, -0.02360740303993225, 0.048518359661102295, -0.009913098067045212, -0.018190700560808182, -0.0010237426031380892, 0.008142339065670967, -0.006208079867064953, -0.01700957491993904, -0.0318823866546154, -0.009664245881140232, 0.03876988962292671, -0.05735836923122406, 0.008840694092214108, -0.043949875980615616, 0.011638128198683262, -0.0034189391881227493, 0.023523977026343346, 0.05092858523130417, -0.02383851446211338, 0.010394806042313576, -0.008743343874812126, 0.05090687796473503, -0.0261007621884346, -0.012332171201705933, 0.007676416542381048, -0.019003678113222122, -0.005965981166809797, -0.02656910941004753, 0.029677359387278557, 0.01148783415555954, 0.0023979602847248316, -0.007940948940813541, -0.016885148361325264, 0.010506759397685528, -0.03706813603639603, 0.017443295568227768, 0.008123336359858513, -0.0029017727356404066, -0.012462697923183441, 0.00613904744386673, 0.02711276151239872, 0.04140710458159447, -0.009132853709161282, -0.020856276154518127, 0.017288118600845337, 0.03761972114443779, 0.05716649442911148, -0.048883773386478424, -0.0390319861471653, -0.02270922251045704, -0.03392886370420456, 0.03384013846516609, 0.00023340326151810586, 0.04819972440600395, 0.02925480157136917, 0.021911069750785828, 0.012362132780253887, 0.004126645624637604, -0.022337699308991432, 0.02950284443795681, 0.003827932057902217, -0.038777705281972885, -0.03705313429236412, 0.0025860306341201067, -0.010186807252466679, -0.010967367328703403, -0.032467328011989594, -0.025916296988725662, 0.022888127714395523, 0.010853046551346779, 0.02181251533329487, -0.05919023975729942, 0.01201813854277134, 0.007103111129254103, 0.0009675043984316289, -0.03214418515563011, 0.005089317914098501, -0.09850022196769714, -0.03913746029138565, 0.01957118883728981, -0.0024904145393520594, -0.01393367163836956, 0.008110010996460915, -0.026966452598571777, -0.002743686316534877, 0.024979960173368454, 0.018573516979813576, 0.016529230400919914, -0.03660206496715546, -0.002402307465672493, -0.02638402208685875, 0.04070930927991867, -0.04550810158252716, -0.043358493596315384, 0.04437219724059105, -0.014447605237364769, 0.0020968664903193712, 0.0028609605506062508, 0.005436137318611145, 0.04246605187654495, 0.02267506904900074, -0.016417939215898514, 0.00664797518402338, 0.04841729253530502, 0.013949580490589142, 0.005435485392808914, -0.023165438324213028, -0.017961401492357254, 0.02273109182715416, 0.0001627890596864745, 0.01313046645373106, 0.013205664232373238, -0.022550227120518684, -0.0025448568630963564, 0.061524130403995514, 0.03806157782673836, -0.018639255315065384, -0.0019527762196958065, 0.01653278060257435, -0.0032283186446875334, 0.022576119750738144, -0.03462329879403114, 0.042480818927288055, 0.03783847391605377, -0.0312972366809845, -0.021241044625639915, 0.005760421976447105, 0.021510832011699677, -0.08343397080898285, -0.0013543431414291263, -0.0002209094091085717, 0.0013853257987648249, 0.024407770484685898, -0.03387213870882988, -0.013293502852320671, 0.037503961473703384, -0.04679107666015625, -0.003246331587433815, 0.0033705057576298714, -0.02157345414161682, -0.004486413672566414, 0.004727357067167759, -0.008251131512224674, 0.012591852806508541, 0.05523751303553581, 0.06972572207450867, 0.005215733777731657, 0.04366585612297058, 0.023111240938305855, -0.00249089696444571, -0.03322602063417435, -0.0037057551089674234, 0.002926543354988098, -0.052358198910951614, 0.0006742293480783701, -0.03925826773047447, -0.017832163721323013, 0.0021483772434294224, -0.04054976999759674, 0.03407510370016098, 0.01640504226088524, 0.007192518562078476, -0.02096870355308056, 0.0390511155128479, -0.015446633100509644, -0.022887805476784706, -0.008053231984376907, -0.014034470543265343, 0.025945011526346207, 0.039257802069187164, -0.03439660370349884, -0.0006367245805449784, -0.00011928938329219818, -0.0224431362003088, -0.034678999334573746, 0.022753607481718063, -0.019066685810685158, 0.020106865093111992, 0.02648192271590233, -0.00017651861708145589, 0.021553456783294678, -0.012000888586044312, -0.014491376467049122, -0.02625568024814129, 0.008449750952422619, 0.04071894288063049, 0.013856669887900352, -0.0566459484398365, -0.017157208174467087, -0.024112528190016747, -0.03368034586310387, 0.021128306165337563, -0.0042808037251234055, 0.005517963320016861, -0.03764595091342926, -0.022047104313969612, -0.006463957950472832, -0.0114983469247818, -0.023872479796409607, -0.03214041888713837, -0.04803987592458725, 0.05656903237104416, 0.005170214455574751, -0.02766081877052784, 0.002367934212088585, -0.009601584635674953, -0.01563984900712967, -0.07617425918579102, 0.03644213825464249, 0.0005959769478067756, -0.014794225804507732, -0.04475096985697746, -0.00758135924115777, -0.0776456817984581, 0.016216499730944633, 0.053253285586833954, -0.0035558862145990133, 0.014315697364509106, 0.008893825113773346, -0.002691889414563775, 0.020419297739863396, -0.05736192315816879, 0.04389285668730736, -0.009101804345846176, -0.03277880325913429, 0.032055485993623734, -0.018571626394987106, 0.008437174372375011, 0.0047872415743768215, 0.010313521139323711, -0.013413434848189354, 0.01362069696187973, 0.04485788568854332, -0.023714015260338783, 0.024020306766033173, 0.0034802823793143034, -0.026787200942635536, 0.03354654461145401, 0.006771001033484936, 0.014860059134662151, 0.03158073499798775, 0.002376221353188157, -0.06732870638370514, 0.04886139556765556, -0.04869602248072624, -0.03634648397564888, 0.02505829557776451, -0.01872384361922741, -0.028614018112421036, -0.07005683332681656, -0.011602958664298058, 0.006177883595228195, -0.04982999339699745, 0.009527195245027542, 0.006910768337547779, -0.0006906097987666726, 0.03545907512307167, -0.01871734857559204, 0.015563745982944965, 0.004714875016361475, 0.0018689697608351707, 0.019962254911661148, 0.01050644088536501, 0.03809639438986778, -0.0016324924072250724, 0.0017549474723637104, 0.031857579946517944, 0.015697751194238663, -0.029232807457447052, -0.02933380752801895, 0.01988034136593342, -0.03951987624168396, -0.018705593422055244, 0.0047790552489459515, -0.01464154850691557, 0.035222698003053665, 0.047319285571575165, 0.0025617284700274467, 0.03867576643824577, -0.05240654572844505, 0.013316885568201542, -0.03762728348374367, 0.00032248382922261953, -0.014422773383557796, 0.02097117155790329, 0.02424682304263115, -0.03606528043746948, -0.02424795553088188, 0.0009434677194803953, 0.009460500441491604, -0.015161949209868908, 0.006531586870551109, -0.037066757678985596, 0.010684856213629246, -0.01547322515398264, -0.016509125009179115, -0.02292340062558651, -0.002657931996509433, -0.05134476721286774, -0.023702256381511688, 0.06813693046569824, 0.048495519906282425, -0.004848903976380825, -0.04292906075716019, -0.03519945219159126, -0.025859761983156204, 0.03227619454264641, -0.06084487587213516, -0.01121678575873375, -0.04462392255663872, 0.033528756350278854, 0.01606881245970726, -0.030691394582390785 ]
<p>Lets say I want to generate data with particular <strong>association matrix</strong>. I am taking <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phi_coefficient" rel="nofollow">phi coefficient</a>` as measure degree of association.</p> <p>Here are examples using R. </p> <pre><code> require(psych) var1 &lt;- sample(c("P", "A"), 10000, replace = TRUE) var2 &lt;- sample(c("P", "A"), 10000, replace = TRUE) mydf &lt;- data.frame (var1, var2) # degree of association require(psych) # No association case: # random variables means 0 association expected phi(table(var1, var2)) [1] -0.01 # copy of same variable, 1 association expected. var3 &lt;- var1 phi(table(var1, var3)) </code></pre> <p>Assuming that I have 4 x 4 matrix of <strong><em>phi coefficients</em></strong> between the four categorical variables. Say the following is <strong>association matrix</strong> (just like correlation matrix)</p> <pre><code>amat &lt;- matrix (c(1,0.5,0.4, 0.3, 0.5,1,0.5,0.3, 0.4,0.5,1,0.2, 0.3, 0.3, 0.2,1), 4) rownames(amat) &lt;- c("VarA", "VarB", "VarC", "VarD") colnames (amat) &lt;- c("VarA", "VarB", "VarC", "VarD") amat VarA VarB VarC VarD VarA 1 0.5 0.4 0.3 VarB 0.5 1 0.5 0.3 VarC 0.4 0.5 1 0.2 VarD 0.3 0.3 0.2 1 </code></pre> <p>Is there any way to generate a data with four variables with say 10000 observations that approximately hold the above association ? I know from <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/100770/generating-a-correlated-data-matrix-where-both-observations-and-variables-are-co">the post</a> how we can do similar thing in quantitative variables. The examples does not need to be R specific, I know it only the idea, which can translated into any programming language. </p>
73,830
[ -0.03388557955622673, 0.03037519007921219, 0.04892696440219879, 0.025601454079151154, 0.015179851092398167, 0.031014131382107735, -0.004271300509572029, -0.028293699026107788, 0.04087970778346062, -0.011818289756774902, 0.021969914436340332, 0.05207362398505211, 0.055689487606287, 0.03403221443295479, 0.060336701571941376, -0.008149523288011551, 0.011937960051000118, -0.0028286350425332785, 0.0034609930589795113, -0.012188496068120003, 0.0017537057865411043, 0.001662900554947555, 0.008215573616325855, 0.0026390834245830774, 0.00035346715594641864, 0.06513430178165436, 0.005906577222049236, -0.023430880159139633, 0.008580761030316353, 0.050375424325466156, -0.07798051834106445, -0.01353748980909586, 0.017172735184431076, 0.0012895462568849325, 0.04641064256429672, 0.005627923645079136, -0.02231721021234989, -0.01023187581449747, -0.00533592002466321, 0.004607642535120249, -0.003860235447064042, -0.021103527396917343, 0.011072876863181591, 0.022098299115896225, -0.03885259851813316, -0.0035439508501440287, 0.003831306239590049, -0.016234377399086952, 0.03676701337099075, -0.003746024565771222, 0.05908738821744919, 0.003522253828123212, 0.028762992471456528, 0.046088121831417084, -0.05041209235787392, -0.009714371524751186, 0.022691350430250168, 0.01967168226838112, -0.005751564633101225, -0.055648259818553925, -0.010272442363202572, -0.03484579548239708, -0.021262062713503838, -0.03664281219244003, -0.0510253980755806, 0.008625592105090618, -0.018816454336047173, -0.02271103486418724, 0.04020143300294876, -0.020846011117100716, 0.04513075575232506, 0.03841860964894295, 0.014508575201034546, -0.031185252591967583, 0.032062362879514694, 0.0156827624887228, -0.004686875268816948, 0.003212262876331806, 0.01952482759952545, 0.025901271030306816, -0.010660954751074314, 0.044785939157009125, 0.014228866435587406, 0.01625901274383068, 0.02233259566128254, -0.02014043554663658, 0.023251034319400787, -0.06756632775068283, 0.019642513245344162, 0.01474951021373272, -0.007739993743598461, -0.009170235134661198, 0.051448576152324677, 0.04421279951930046, -0.027673842385411263, 0.04486905038356781, -0.026581991463899612, 0.043618094176054, 0.01829555630683899, 0.010844828560948372, -0.04311581701040268, -0.017383906990289688, 0.006574886851012707, 0.019726049154996872, -0.019615795463323593, -0.04962708428502083, -0.014279249124228954, -0.02552991732954979, -0.012531784363090992, -0.056718114763498306, 0.009813767857849598, 0.046674322336912155, 0.0014014561893418431, -0.012290301732718945, 0.032248809933662415, -0.05631216615438461, 0.011314332485198975, 0.002086142310872674, 0.07664639502763748, 0.06927622109651566, 0.04190114140510559, -0.026183094829320908, 0.021768823266029358, -0.047728173434734344, -0.0257057286798954, 0.008409494534134865, 0.003696331987157464, -0.009406933560967445, -0.02133285440504551, 0.04731206223368645, -0.025164643302559853, -0.01081621553748846, 0.01893543265759945, 0.007077875547111034, 0.024373581632971764, -0.01077653095126152, -0.07706312090158463, -0.025510292500257492, 0.01029146183282137, -0.03308878466486931, 0.019736725836992264, -0.06001986190676689, 0.061731863766908646, 0.015179273672401905, 0.05726350098848343, -0.0059880949556827545, 0.03997395560145378, 0.014289911836385727, 0.02181600034236908, 0.039733365178108215, -0.029163425788283348, 0.01023737620562315, -0.03774167597293854, -0.01783066987991333, -0.04900553449988365, -0.10737732797861099, 0.035586293786764145, -0.0065995375625789165, -0.014654924161732197, 0.018565019592642784, 0.004533823579549789, 0.025387564674019814, -0.007842655293643475, -0.03564463555812836, -0.014370155520737171, 0.021424949169158936, 0.04880716651678085, 0.0003929220838472247, -0.0035284054465591908, 0.022832686081528664, -0.06838276982307434, -0.00623750127851963, -0.008266999386250973, 0.05172707885503769, 0.07199455797672272, -0.005946559831500053, 0.0010387242073193192, -0.025642285123467445, 0.04677967727184296, -0.008167543448507786, -0.0037790462374687195, -0.03447685018181801, 0.006112406030297279, -0.0035765499342232943, 0.0202347245067358, 0.0009169045952148736, 0.038817986845970154, 0.003022458404302597, 0.03222815319895744, -0.035128481686115265, -0.07429462671279907, -0.04642907530069351, 0.021775247529149055, -0.00778662646189332, -0.05226075276732445, 0.018691396340727806, 0.02231631986796856, -0.000726357742678374, 0.031353309750556946, -0.021654652431607246, -0.06272266805171967, -0.01621534675359726, 0.03847469016909599, -0.06124209612607956, -0.006871508900076151, 0.04975101351737976, 0.04670208692550659, -0.010802626609802246, 0.05922432616353035, -0.047277744859457016, -0.033748559653759, 0.01182353775948286, -0.03905069828033447, 0.002121557714417577, 0.023988984525203705, -0.019213398918509483, -0.001658738125115633, 0.0230940580368042, -0.04579542204737663, 0.016095250844955444, -0.05731331557035446, 0.028699366375803947, 0.03986794501543045, 0.016064971685409546, -0.024051660671830177, -0.011272866278886795, -0.01576283574104309, -0.0108862966299057, -0.0434894934296608, 0.015272960066795349, -0.03429747745394707, -0.005855605471879244, -0.004578207153826952, 0.07660666853189468, -0.03703729808330536, 0.008068225346505642, 0.05003366246819496, -0.017325880005955696, 0.009129432030022144, 0.06662838906049728, 0.029653189703822136, -0.011485598050057888, 0.02674734592437744, 0.021406078711152077, 0.01657305844128132, 0.0126492353156209, -0.01592538319528103, 0.014874216169118881, 0.04208509251475334, 0.006154351867735386, -0.012941133230924606, 0.024373909458518028, 0.008420675992965698, -0.029381275177001953, -0.01420852355659008, 0.006830072030425072, 0.04310429096221924, 0.01788961887359619, 0.009994902648031712, 0.03370306268334389, 0.0038504349067807198, -0.021533185616135597, 0.00487407436594367, -0.035305991768836975, 0.0034995311871170998, 0.06734070926904678, -0.034975260496139526, -0.02675086259841919, 0.015234222635626793, -0.03602604195475578, 0.0017221352318301797, -0.018664592877030373, -0.022374413907527924, -0.044723909348249435, 0.011297592893242836, 0.018547983840107918, 0.013697684742510319, 0.010583881288766861, 0.0039333864115178585, -0.03146935999393463, 0.004787802696228027, 0.0015459785936400294, 0.03665737807750702, -0.017703741788864136, -0.05424727126955986, -0.03250182420015335, -0.023704564198851585, -0.013676789589226246, 0.02762705273926258, -0.009557371027767658, -0.05752034857869148, 0.04568660631775856, 0.0038501957897096872, -0.05419605225324631, 0.016601992771029472, 0.010382588021457195, 0.012470072135329247, -0.058688290417194366, 0.003564347280189395, 0.007057978771626949, 0.011397230438888073, -0.09095802158117294, -0.0165372584015131, -0.05045381933450699, -0.007376468274742365, -0.0418119840323925, 0.010359831154346466, 0.02077098749577999, 0.008429444395005703, 0.028612380847334862, 0.043765414506196976, 0.0008768942207098007, -0.009221318177878857, -0.06184818223118782, -0.0163852721452713, 0.0296290572732687, 0.025139642879366875, 0.03056124597787857, 0.018742607906460762, 0.006975887808948755, 0.06450188159942627, 0.04257271811366081, -0.05781939998269081, -0.04757034033536911, -0.011876653879880905, -0.03296130523085594, -0.018421724438667297, 0.021485529839992523, 0.009611248038709164, 0.04024138301610947, 0.0013169932644814253, 0.0028544680681079626, 0.023003075271844864, 0.04081011936068535, -0.012242034077644348, 0.03982016071677208, 0.0324251689016819, 0.0107652572914958, -0.05429958552122116, 0.03681700676679611, 0.007893598638474941, -0.012744542211294174, 0.004190560895949602, 0.01898636668920517, 0.01741580292582512, -0.029079770669341087, -0.014679172076284885, -0.002623362233862281, -0.013310221023857594, 0.050666335970163345, -0.051926933228969574, 0.022734547033905983, -0.001910451683215797, -0.04776204377412796, -0.01032068021595478, 0.029407024383544922, 0.005785895045846701, -0.020974459126591682, -0.0056382641196250916, 0.054363712668418884, 0.021706031635403633, -0.02689407207071781, 0.03210480138659477, -0.027811933308839798, -0.01483354065567255, 0.02601269818842411, -0.051691628992557526, 0.0013869167305529118, 0.015012203715741634, 0.033400967717170715, 0.007870610803365707, 0.02744567207992077, -0.017756594344973564, 0.022364133968949318, -0.013697070069611073, 0.02743861824274063, -0.03838508203625679, 0.056773554533720016, 0.020831480622291565, 0.08801921457052231, 0.023473229259252548, 0.0067678578197956085, -0.009799915365874767, -0.025636490434408188, -0.0938095822930336, -0.00908305961638689, -0.0018653591396287084, -0.001998502528294921, 0.002743104938417673, -0.03904856741428375, 0.04037376865744591, -0.02037723921239376, -0.01005998719483614, 0.020575029775500298, -0.003404546994715929, -0.031006891280412674, 0.027105575427412987, -0.028826512396335602, 0.03172368183732033, -0.03384450823068619, 0.017823103815317154, 0.05414522439241409, 0.021139344200491905, 0.05199161171913147, 0.04286988824605942, -0.013537000864744186, 0.014202224090695381, -0.019976435229182243, 0.015127154998481274, 0.02575179934501648, 0.02784113958477974, 0.044359754770994186, 0.06254960596561432, -0.00861477293074131, 0.017589528113603592, -0.017193691805005074, 0.03402385860681534, 0.06996974349021912, 0.0015035163378342986, 0.022992756217718124, -0.007555893622338772, -0.010286674834787846, 0.002524295821785927, 0.039499431848526, 0.014771918766200542, -0.008511325344443321, 0.004233459010720253, 0.025857752189040184, -0.06725464761257172, 0.022164179012179375, 0.06157398968935013, 0.06392908096313477, -0.012105369940400124, -0.00026153121143579483, -0.0006845077150501311, 0.011760080233216286, -0.009054834023118019, 0.0031761820428073406, -0.003927659243345261, -0.004995162133127451, -0.005562376696616411, 0.000589467235840857, -0.03448540344834328, -0.03546088561415672, 0.011836245656013489, -0.01640789769589901, 0.0007750796503387392, -0.021652258932590485, -0.05219433084130287, -0.026530180126428604, 0.030370274558663368, 0.013221177272498608, -0.009320381097495556, 0.019241606816649437, -0.08165018260478973, 0.0074978540651500225, 0.0363566055893898, 0.05795235559344292, -0.012849055230617523, -0.004879369866102934, -0.015231416560709476, -0.04216839373111725, 0.027233771979808807, -0.03455917537212372, 0.056507959961891174, -0.02722952514886856, 0.00990285538136959, -0.0168187003582716, -0.01479062344878912, -0.06220769137144089, 0.02763478271663189, -0.03546204790472984, 0.013037235476076603, -0.008394630625844002, -0.03634445369243622, -0.01762494072318077, 0.017931155860424042, 0.02496379055082798, 0.03392783924937248, -0.06909854710102081, -0.0323706679046154, 0.027392659336328506, 0.012237165123224258, 0.022798625752329826, -0.055636804550886154, 0.04748927801847458, -0.0026381502393633127, 0.01001080870628357, 0.05655330792069435, -0.007010564673691988, 0.005235241260379553, -0.01948016695678234, 0.02603888511657715, 0.029453212395310402, 0.04114895686507225, -0.0034165631514042616, 0.02416176348924637, -0.016123123466968536, -0.013477721251547337, 0.06510857492685318, 0.02507125586271286, -0.022253291681408882, 0.010851633735001087, -0.09693440794944763, -0.01654147170484066, -0.008914654143154621, -0.02327209711074829, -0.055062755942344666, 0.005196357145905495, -0.014497114345431328, 0.015618100762367249, -0.038316961377859116, 0.017284393310546875, -0.028596872463822365, 0.0373024046421051, -0.001069116173312068, 0.005227222107350826, -0.027978193014860153, -0.008306782692670822, -0.004845638759434223, 0.008156991563737392, -0.006835395470261574, -0.023644285276532173, 0.014529981650412083, -0.046856839209795, -0.01093827374279499, -0.012781748548150063, -0.052022650837898254, -0.006834722124040127, -0.01053317729383707, -0.030592024326324463, -0.02025086060166359, -0.018231844529509544, 0.029213659465312958, -0.009059060364961624, 0.0794600248336792, 0.0223073810338974, -0.04571583494544029, -0.007196752354502678, 0.04381045699119568, -0.02438131347298622, 0.008828280493617058, 0.009885341860353947, 0.030154630541801453, -0.026952918618917465, -0.025945356115698814, -0.01513904333114624, -0.07408299297094345, -0.0009476506384089589, 0.007443179842084646, -0.030815275385975838, -0.058537330478429794, -0.019337913021445274, -0.035172238945961, -0.01883232407271862, -0.026756472885608673, 0.028287941589951515, -0.03188782185316086, -0.003354811342433095, 0.02645018696784973, -0.01886533759534359, 0.021745605394244194, 0.009248187765479088, -0.023308230563998222, 0.04876827448606491, -0.025442730635404587, 0.02870006114244461, 0.0009036034462042153, -0.06051400676369667, -0.019532332196831703, -0.01901380904018879, -0.011388587765395641, -0.009081445634365082, 0.027704915031790733, -0.0047119613736867905, -0.021339941769838333, -0.004193441942334175, -0.009161577560007572, 0.013335958123207092, -0.05189499258995056, -0.01762061007320881, -0.03619814291596413, -0.008192744106054306, -0.010868607088923454, -0.019165970385074615, -0.027057962492108345, 0.016643574461340904, 0.03920508176088333, -0.02506939135491848, 0.005413838196545839, 0.0016939647030085325, 0.07684441655874252, -0.006434374488890171, 0.015083924867212772, -0.02019723691046238, -0.0053858766332268715, 0.035157691687345505, 0.022076155990362167, 0.0023104657884687185, 0.0038558642845600843, 0.024500645697116852, 0.009437549859285355, -0.014720860868692398, -0.03059297241270542, -0.0027166593354195356, 0.0476129986345768, 0.01801861636340618, 0.03961033746600151, 0.059209730476140976, -0.007302501704543829, 0.011628374457359314, 0.005502971820533276, -0.020429184660315514, 0.030705463141202927, 0.0033308519050478935, 0.0582219660282135, -0.0019419877789914608, -0.009013365022838116, 0.019459756091237068, 0.021989203989505768, 0.001649019424803555, 0.0490524061024189, -0.011828585527837276, 0.01348326075822115, 0.013898594304919243, -0.009958352893590927, -0.027007201686501503, 0.014929801225662231, -0.04924720153212547, 0.04255899786949158, -0.024568313732743263, -0.04055842012166977, 0.0137705747038126, 0.022534307092428207, 0.014672686345875263, -0.05067089572548866, -0.026148583739995956, -0.03593984246253967, 0.007465800736099482, 0.025814708322286606, -0.016353396698832512, 0.015458969399333, -0.018450940027832985, 0.005046354606747627, -0.043666597455739975, 0.05480857938528061, -0.025497818365693092, -0.0627240538597107, -0.017845220863819122, -0.008619464933872223, -0.009770837612450123, 0.06386885792016983, 0.037687838077545166, -0.02755434811115265, 0.01586725190281868, -0.04835069179534912, 0.014662853442132473, 0.03300640732049942, 0.04105299711227417, -0.010199290700256824, 0.0693078339099884, 0.007983159273862839, 0.030621536076068878, -0.007373882923275232, -0.04223651438951492, 0.1478925198316574, 0.07358695566654205, 0.032675568014383316, -0.076053686439991, 0.008105333894491196, 0.008232771418988705, -0.029977722093462944, -0.041136484593153, -0.023941021412611008, -0.012564301490783691, 0.016677126288414, 0.06778127700090408, 0.06803205609321594, 0.02105807140469551, 0.046026844531297684, 0.04150247573852539, -0.0326935313642025, -0.014627472497522831, 0.0003567847888916731, 0.0004818770685233176, -0.03024977259337902, -0.005334306042641401, -0.03079790621995926, -0.016972698271274567, 0.03399084880948067, -0.011499954387545586, -0.020376339554786682, 0.01635110192000866, -0.000586276815738529, 0.007923317141830921, 0.020921260118484497, 0.0076842112466692924, 0.032599370926618576, -0.010800212621688843, 0.042298439890146255, -0.014976119622588158, 0.026192935183644295, -0.04267717897891998, 0.000869445560965687, 0.029190022498369217, 0.015067808330059052, -0.00024155297433026135, 0.0027499827556312084, 0.010136648081243038, -0.010544276796281338, -0.016713781282305717, -0.03443216159939766, 0.034515462815761566, -0.0050192237831652164, -0.01384163647890091, -0.03147510811686516, 0.029325252398848534, 0.016641346737742424, -0.043674346059560776, -0.020302830263972282, 0.014181959442794323, 0.03711741045117378, -0.06275579333305359, 0.017481908202171326, -0.028775891289114952, 0.024206507951021194, -0.013311682268977165, 0.03683600202202797, 0.015825700014829636, -0.01254954468458891, -0.01454631146043539, -0.07085815072059631, 0.0562296099960804, -0.02043922059237957, -0.008702458813786507, -0.0036987741477787495, -0.029954180121421814, -0.028550755232572556, -0.04192216694355011, 0.004538255278021097, 0.01210194081068039, 0.012233139015734196, -0.007211725227534771, -0.0029554881621152163, -0.004307122901082039, 0.005997629836201668, -0.009880317375063896, -0.004631360527127981, -0.04825665429234505, -0.00018659289344213903, 0.009822298772633076, 0.04818323254585266, 0.02255857363343239, 0.03731684386730194, 0.0026683355681598186, 0.005721773486584425, 0.06347911804914474, 0.042278606444597244, -0.05118926987051964, -0.0388641357421875, -0.0048340605571866035, -0.0407768115401268, -0.008186962455511093, -0.011817949824035168, 0.038545288145542145, 0.056665193289518356, -0.011636447161436081, -0.01985458843410015, -0.009902747347950935, 0.005322352051734924, 0.0006917795399203897, 0.023245127871632576, -0.02981371060013771, -0.0004566003626678139, 0.008019859902560711, -0.04220244288444519, -0.027331635355949402, 0.013261334970593452, -0.04070331156253815, -0.05519244819879532, 0.011039119213819504, -0.018104759976267815, -0.03587597236037254, 0.005322459619492292, -0.002698375377804041, 0.000059538586356211454, 0.0030446110758930445, -0.04266136512160301, -0.023008204996585846, -0.005930453073233366, -0.009224741719663143, 0.002542507369071245, -0.014822217635810375, 0.054482586681842804, -0.0412268228828907, -0.010061454027891159, 0.030889039859175682, 0.03243287652730942, 0.01757858879864216, 0.012212972156703472, -0.015811724588274956, -0.002908744616433978, 0.04441587254405022, 0.0009022289887070656, -0.0398385189473629, 0.025899453088641167, -0.07839702069759369, 0.014874706044793129, 0.001024087192490697, 0.014071975834667683, 0.03346768394112587, 0.01542804017663002, 0.009887034073472023, -0.013549422845244408, 0.050196532160043716, -0.02480962686240673, -0.01461011916399002, -0.021286923438310623, 0.020723558962345123, -0.007655707653611898, 0.03508639708161354, -0.017082225531339645, -0.0011211595265194774, -0.010435504838824272, 0.01008928008377552, 0.057384688407182693, -0.004313291981816292, -0.016091933473944664, 0.03647402673959732, 0.00008993274241220206, -0.00930200144648552, 0.0015451835934072733, -0.00858201365917921, 0.012236849404871464, 0.033388372510671616, -0.0027740595396608114, 0.007051154505461454, -0.006667693145573139, 0.0312858447432518, -0.0933217704296112, -0.04651396721601486, 0.039940547198057175, -0.01352961640805006, 0.009744630195200443, -0.05479932203888893, 0.02181001380085945, -0.0026663595344871283, -0.07902814447879791, 0.01818963885307312, 0.011844725348055363, 0.03807073086500168, -0.02935323677957058, 0.031838055700063705, -0.018013685941696167, 0.04067514091730118, 0.04727275297045708, 0.007883564569056034, 0.036704227328300476, 0.01150471344590187, 0.017317384481430054, -0.029373111203312874, -0.06872955709695816, 0.0017653950490057468, 0.017065830528736115, -0.0599108561873436, 0.02083546109497547, -0.04963168501853943, -0.022410888224840164, 0.0014131291536614299, -0.04877167567610741, 0.0006730474415235221, 0.04467295855283737, 0.038534391671419144, 0.01954152248799801, 0.07110926508903503, 0.011193739250302315, -0.004755604080855846, -0.026934487745165825, -0.03781776502728462, 0.03330698236823082, 0.034685131162405014, -0.036569155752658844, 0.03613685443997383, 0.03318265080451965, -0.011015813797712326, -0.007689093239605427, 0.0008297447930090129, -0.021719494834542274, 0.003241298021748662, -0.04118864983320236, -0.02115619368851185, 0.006425786297768354, 0.0018567407969385386, 0.00009192933066515252, -0.02575661428272724, 0.0064622582867741585, 0.033354148268699646, 0.04374955967068672, 0.014833570457994938, 0.030457820743322372, -0.017284894362092018, -0.029546083882451057, 0.01800544001162052, 0.0006780498661100864, -0.00610559806227684, -0.036645933985710144, -0.03402319177985191, -0.008194434456527233, 0.0159903671592474, 0.00953943096101284, 0.0006720115197822452, -0.05009288340806961, 0.0406164713203907, -0.020444435998797417, 0.002283053705468774, 0.006503889337182045, -0.00022860175522509962, 0.04415520280599594, -0.07578986138105392, 0.042408958077430725, -0.009737933054566383, -0.02865784801542759, -0.05841433256864548, 0.018642736598849297, -0.05492020770907402, 0.06014581769704819, -0.008201409131288528, 0.0007927633705548942, 0.010571903549134731, -0.03341308981180191, 0.04187639430165291, -0.0028020564932376146, -0.04249708727002144, 0.05780159309506416, 0.016946278512477875, 0.009980143047869205, -0.001988842850551009, 0.02904869057238102, 0.02522270195186138, -0.008166829124093056, -0.045412834733724594, -0.05530404672026634, -0.002283926587551832, 0.026473449543118477, -0.039675381034612656, 0.013205298222601414, -0.020389266312122345, -0.022630954161286354, 0.006952578201889992, 0.01025412604212761, 0.00477668596431613, 0.07108041644096375, 0.014465023763477802, -0.018858637660741806, 0.02117726393043995, -0.05097677931189537, -0.01724652759730816, 0.0298941470682621, 0.010227924212813377, -0.0009444435709156096, -0.0654931515455246, 0.01712273247539997, 0.003547233995050192, -0.04005824774503708, 0.005095472559332848, 0.008950450457632542, -0.01172907929867506, 0.059636082500219345, 0.004162966273725033, 0.03151259943842888, -0.05625663697719574, -0.04810640588402748, 0.02348066121339798, 0.01686752215027809, 0.02386166714131832, -0.015399093739688396, 0.028551774099469185, 0.024402489885687828, 0.000029872166123823263, -0.007174044381827116, -0.036936573684215546, 0.03459829092025757, -0.00882286299020052, 0.0026539668906480074, 0.04146673530340195, -0.025206133723258972, 0.055266015231609344, 0.03481557220220566, -0.004128437489271164, 0.031036803498864174, -0.04182141646742821, -0.013909943401813507, 0.0001871136191766709, -0.005179604049772024, -0.019794674590229988, 0.0179251991212368, 0.015282774344086647, 0.023516608402132988, 0.019435716792941093, 0.02183276228606701, 0.033284202218055725, -0.0186756644397974, -0.020336739718914032, -0.004474989604204893, 0.02153218351304531, -0.014867603778839111, 0.02298552915453911, 0.01862073875963688, 0.007758971303701401, -0.01722126081585884, -0.01769784837961197, 0.018670527264475822, 0.013628099113702774, 0.0042128367349505424, -0.03756903484463692, -0.00417834147810936, 0.023917241021990776, 0.0033098170533776283, -0.024469690397381783, -0.012522006407380104, -0.001663497881963849, 0.005742213223129511, -0.011704063042998314, -0.025191402062773705 ]
<p>I have a fairly basic statistics application question. Lets say I have a set of four fold-change values, representing the abundance of a factor as it passes through four consecutive time points:</p> <pre><code>x&lt;-c(1.0, 1.2, 15.3, 0.2) </code></pre> <p>And I want to define its "trend" ie, a single-number representation of how it acts during the entirety of the time course. </p> <p>In the example given, x has a general increasing trend. </p> <p>I have tried using trendlines, but I get a lot of over-generalization of the trend, and my info is lost. Is there a more-informative solution to defining a "trend" of values as they pass through a time series?</p>
36,329
[ -0.01862126775085926, -0.008323095738887787, -0.01161503791809082, 0.038258153945207596, 0.007130783051252365, 0.042972952127456665, 0.03718086704611778, -0.011548703536391258, 0.026954835280776024, -0.013810593634843826, 0.04850012809038162, 0.044438429176807404, 0.042342059314250946, -0.006305778864771128, 0.037124838680028915, -0.004485733807086945, -0.029323657974600792, 0.002690276363864541, -0.013431317172944546, -0.01712106354534626, 0.016000865027308464, -0.01196051575243473, -0.007403143681585789, 0.00012333897757343948, -0.0077970572747290134, 0.04595370590686798, 0.034095969051122665, 0.0006659981445409358, 0.019257618114352226, 0.07161806523799896, -0.048716556280851364, -0.04993396997451782, 0.02298092283308506, 0.05312135070562363, 0.02156739868223667, -0.004814951214939356, -0.008791049011051655, -0.025082280859351158, 0.004645626526325941, 0.054331690073013306, -0.05219918489456177, -0.022046780213713646, 0.01145282480865717, 0.019679035991430283, -0.0015524552436545491, 0.008403836749494076, -0.013913562521338463, -0.004297868814319372, 0.044420190155506134, -0.045706771314144135, 0.09695452451705933, -0.02760222740471363, 0.056514840573072433, 0.03097231313586235, -0.018272429704666138, -0.0017877547070384026, 0.07604828476905823, 0.04371349886059761, -0.018929719924926758, -0.061373885720968246, -0.02650279924273491, -0.011879569850862026, 0.02447385899722576, -0.0213147159665823, -0.03260520100593567, 0.023815380409359932, -0.03753567859530449, -0.004417415242642164, 0.056665875017642975, -0.05977913364768028, 0.007865199819207191, 0.0032056006602942944, 0.036335285753011703, -0.033915381878614426, -0.0014193858951330185, -0.01605256460607052, 0.031043481081724167, -0.01028804574161768, 0.04964079335331917, 0.06349305063486099, -0.007518219295889139, 0.017662854865193367, 0.02211073786020279, 0.030293557792901993, 0.0052376664243638515, 0.008794787339866161, 0.07805895060300827, -0.03453853726387024, 0.02775084227323532, 0.040888264775276184, 0.0016014714492484927, 0.0001226874883286655, 0.06016381084918976, 0.0032648583874106407, -0.05667412653565407, 0.015083636157214642, -0.034203577786684036, 0.02221646159887314, 0.011393238790333271, 0.008456215262413025, 0.03809472173452377, -0.0404181145131588, 0.0035447196569293737, 0.03139454126358032, -0.06161004304885864, 0.013465046882629395, -0.042087554931640625, -0.0336846262216568, -0.0012025181204080582, -0.004018813371658325, -0.00955256912857294, 0.0021766687277704477, 0.01917584054172039, -0.00946579035371542, 0.01718226447701454, -0.037114519625902176, -0.0293369609862566, -0.015772176906466484, 0.01914902776479721, 0.05368906632065773, 0.05259520933032036, -0.023879313841462135, 0.05763264000415802, 0.006051550153642893, -0.0164286307990551, 0.01804198883473873, 0.002196693094447255, -0.010006607510149479, -0.01074297446757555, 0.042665012180805206, -0.030270058661699295, -0.0485820546746254, 0.045897722244262695, -0.014084151946008205, 0.051159609109163284, -0.012735092081129551, -0.06119822710752487, -0.0443514846265316, 0.026441428810358047, -0.030005179345607758, -0.02144358493387699, -0.06864828616380692, -0.006460326258093119, 0.014050784520804882, 0.027118172496557236, 0.024628248065710068, 0.008407452143728733, 0.023855967447161674, 0.013620128855109215, 0.04583907872438431, -0.03580791503190994, -0.006551325786858797, 0.011347861029207706, -0.024753790348768234, 0.00226837326772511, -0.0690692886710167, 0.009351070038974285, 0.0031658713705837727, -0.01675247773528099, -0.0060266368091106415, 0.06144118309020996, 0.010095787234604359, -0.019637132063508034, -0.012614889070391655, 0.024924203753471375, 0.004484402481466532, 0.0432966984808445, -0.036439958959817886, 0.002599915023893118, 0.0193533506244421, 0.010551976040005684, 0.002681380370631814, 0.002610265975818038, 0.046621669083833694, 0.04083821550011635, -0.020058006048202515, -0.016678763553500175, -0.002150298561900854, -0.03423914313316345, 0.03781688213348389, -0.01970377005636692, -0.05090142786502838, 0.010313733480870724, -0.02341834083199501, 0.029116272926330566, 0.013032985851168633, -0.003332202322781086, -0.037654198706150055, 0.02692599780857563, -0.06368670612573624, -0.016243847087025642, -0.09538216888904572, 0.013250641524791718, 0.000313299591653049, -0.007985417731106281, 0.011270646937191486, 0.013174914754927158, 0.060311395674943924, -0.028072206303477287, -0.02870759926736355, -0.03482852876186371, -0.025552311912178993, 0.027785802260041237, -0.06750278174877167, -0.0283296350389719, 0.019820652902126312, 0.03388993442058563, -0.029011882841587067, 0.04611169174313545, -0.014627357944846153, -0.02401914820075035, 0.015042155049741268, -0.03833736851811409, 0.01934177055954933, 0.0012665677350014448, -0.026946211233735085, -0.011158328503370285, -0.00436467956751585, -0.012657834216952324, 0.04192332550883293, -0.050923917442560196, 0.05161561816930771, 0.05882815644145012, 0.008461762219667435, -0.009225700050592422, -0.03431600332260132, -0.0048672910779714584, 0.026338446885347366, -0.04355035722255707, -0.035598862916231155, -0.05235116928815842, 0.02585776522755623, 0.041606590151786804, 0.05181310698390007, -0.032773323357105255, -0.006692115217447281, 0.07108723372220993, 0.03490906581282616, 0.0280070211738348, 0.06594958156347275, 0.02764439955353737, 0.013918811455368996, -0.013941021636128426, 0.014214558526873589, 0.01860186830163002, 0.009218585677444935, 0.024858126416802406, 0.0034322626888751984, 0.0394473560154438, 0.03747688978910446, -0.005839782301336527, 0.021969011053442955, 0.0168001726269722, 0.020312471315264702, -0.03208382800221443, -0.014090869575738907, 0.03491484373807907, -0.02666720747947693, -0.016808265820145607, 0.02434036135673523, 0.02722010388970375, -0.018637489527463913, 0.01739947311580181, 0.007229078095406294, 0.0049113016575574875, 0.05248532444238663, -0.03913528472185135, -0.021490981802344322, 0.008260069414973259, -0.01281429361552, 0.04526488482952118, -0.05148309841752052, -0.03205083683133125, -0.04979760944843292, 0.004179905168712139, 0.029621776193380356, 0.015394768677651882, 0.01079837791621685, -0.03889813646674156, -0.035774894058704376, 0.011377068236470222, -0.02394617721438408, -0.0017384508391842246, -0.00939709972590208, -0.0278554055839777, -0.00414499593898654, 0.00909173022955656, -0.04344548285007477, 0.04850129038095474, -0.01950867474079132, -0.031936440616846085, 0.005799612496048212, -0.00696251867339015, -0.02633451111614704, -0.013146363198757172, -0.052929818630218506, 0.017997981980443, -0.009316976182162762, 0.014228289015591145, 0.053303856402635574, -0.04344763606786728, -0.03694193437695503, 0.0074500879272818565, -0.06348385661840439, -0.024605127051472664, -0.06411317735910416, -0.0033753104507923126, 0.006032123230397701, 0.01011647004634142, 0.021900378167629242, 0.011968385428190231, -0.040135566145181656, 0.010224328376352787, -0.053667258471250534, -0.0697888433933258, 0.010253237560391426, -0.00021983189799357206, 0.027389507740736008, 0.017750268802046776, 0.003430795855820179, 0.04875907674431801, 0.031926389783620834, -0.040798284113407135, -0.06548400968313217, -0.02029169350862503, -0.010523566976189613, -0.02303054928779602, 0.027860580012202263, 0.018504442647099495, 0.026763681322336197, -0.024203985929489136, -0.00783492811024189, 0.03879529610276222, 0.05418059229850769, -0.0048037138767540455, -0.004077039659023285, 0.008321470580995083, 0.0025169660802930593, 0.015273023396730423, 0.014183096587657928, 0.02719743363559246, -0.02791420929133892, 0.029551248997449875, -0.0329974889755249, 0.008653919212520123, -0.004666206426918507, -0.0059051611460745335, 0.015141788870096207, -0.017440948635339737, 0.02909153327345848, -0.014323760755360126, 0.03213805705308914, 0.011514576151967049, -0.0038624145090579987, -0.03520819544792175, 0.027395665645599365, 0.015049335546791553, 0.010377788916230202, 0.011240099556744099, 0.04553621634840965, 0.015688618645071983, -0.061273425817489624, 0.03486279398202896, 0.0033770876470953226, -0.01383050438016653, 0.0025200543459504843, -0.029793620109558105, -0.01238491665571928, 0.03432602807879448, 0.021510081365704536, 0.03261495754122734, 0.03294839337468147, -0.05348479747772217, 0.026900969445705414, -0.049790944904088974, 0.005511210300028324, 0.0008556086104363203, 0.03213151916861534, 0.010398208163678646, 0.07724875211715698, 0.027814388275146484, -0.014991787262260914, 0.05370510742068291, -0.03181442990899086, -0.06899008899927139, 0.05156673491001129, -0.032440923154354095, 0.015775810927152634, 0.004468991421163082, 0.003677595406770706, 0.010881509631872177, -0.005792062263935804, 0.008372350595891476, -0.004078027326613665, 0.00540382182225585, -0.03128596395254135, -0.0016645329305902123, -0.019488202407956123, 0.0020596375688910484, -0.012159189209342003, -0.015811720862984657, 0.05304744839668274, -0.008917461149394512, 0.04639149084687233, 0.023727528750896454, 0.011997980065643787, -0.009636569768190384, -0.026094522327184677, -0.009095731191337109, 0.030904049053788185, -0.009931961074471474, 0.04110177233815193, 0.025562075898051262, -0.05572408065199852, 0.0542004220187664, -0.007867204025387764, 0.057582441717386246, 0.048522885888814926, -0.009102503769099712, -0.0018571146065369248, -0.02345181256532669, -0.002572485711425543, 0.021554656326770782, 0.01131488662213087, 0.051033325493335724, -0.004352774936705828, 0.04920072481036186, 0.019286731258034706, -0.07909487932920456, 0.050519879907369614, 0.08723341673612595, 0.014396901242434978, -0.009414754807949066, -0.034235287457704544, 0.032428078353405, -0.00017461570678278804, -0.01316532026976347, 0.03200406953692436, -0.0029740280006080866, 0.011144041083753109, 0.02094435691833496, 0.004155043512582779, -0.03635251149535179, -0.04474586993455887, 0.002382582752034068, 0.017589380964636803, 0.04199866205453873, 0.004116592928767204, -0.02274915762245655, -0.006293680518865585, 0.027377963066101074, 0.018645083531737328, 0.03586333617568016, 0.011367300525307655, -0.11987285315990448, 0.005163345020264387, 0.054920341819524765, 0.025653891265392303, -0.03147260099649429, -0.04478348046541214, -0.004318749066442251, -0.019795918837189674, 0.05803404375910759, -0.024580426514148712, 0.04733727127313614, -0.026058994233608246, -0.0017827094998210669, -0.01091710664331913, -0.016671961173415184, -0.05462945997714996, 0.023808423429727554, -0.07054479420185089, 0.036741238087415695, 0.00013021923950873315, 0.004251589998602867, -0.07560652494430542, 0.02894698642194271, -0.02042010799050331, 0.07000473141670227, -0.018797675147652626, -0.025877483189105988, 0.01941789500415325, 0.01185455359518528, -0.010487140156328678, -0.03292364627122879, 0.007714452687650919, 0.003618953749537468, 0.0011873075272887945, 0.008778812363743782, 0.03813495486974716, -0.02463405393064022, -0.015558800660073757, 0.002626841887831688, -0.009411854669451714, 0.019847450777888298, 0.006387380883097649, 0.02800789102911949, 0.04746679961681366, 0.003869455074891448, 0.060415610671043396, 0.057804498821496964, 0.014958478510379791, 0.03167848661541939, -0.02296331152319908, 0.033139824867248535, -0.0055876183323562145, -0.017056742683053017, -0.03152453899383545, -0.004476654343307018, -0.03243081271648407, 0.04041852802038193, -0.015511301346123219, 0.013610342517495155, -0.019502446055412292, 0.020052114501595497, 0.04196292161941528, 0.037564586848020554, 0.006395101547241211, -0.03589646518230438, 0.0079055055975914, 0.007727490738034248, -0.013682610355317593, -0.021801220253109932, 0.01024756021797657, -0.016696428880095482, -0.027255617082118988, 0.011219652369618416, -0.00022657644876744598, 0.013925697654485703, -0.018385257571935654, -0.061568595468997955, -0.0066488091833889484, -0.04504101723432541, 0.038983289152383804, -0.005403539631515741, 0.02078237570822239, 0.007841590791940689, -0.0755285918712616, -0.0035671310033649206, 0.04147651046514511, 0.03438233956694603, 0.008261538110673428, -0.05974900722503662, 0.038588691502809525, -0.030317602679133415, 0.023342106491327286, -0.07611437886953354, -0.06406224519014359, 0.02699800580739975, 0.010939229279756546, -0.04926346242427826, -0.02759106643497944, 0.016344884410500526, -0.018120000138878822, 0.01576792448759079, -0.03528017923235893, 0.03996530920267105, -0.03645668178796768, -0.010214139707386494, 0.00952046737074852, 0.044012099504470825, 0.08068065345287323, -0.0056489803828299046, -0.007981846109032631, -0.004751509055495262, 0.006338650826364756, -0.012503433041274548, -0.02344488352537155, -0.004900898784399033, -0.045611925423145294, 0.018526839092373848, -0.016238687559962273, -0.004512909334152937, 0.05498098209500313, -0.03908105567097664, 0.001508828834630549, 0.008048750460147858, -0.0017496281070634723, 0.010634363628923893, -0.05619204044342041, 0.008500773459672928, -0.06106757000088692, -0.011493958532810211, -0.015913115814328194, -0.014049235731363297, -0.005673736799508333, -0.041716523468494415, 0.016681862995028496, -0.0025346495676785707, 0.008435684256255627, 0.013933018781244755, 0.04153430461883545, -0.008723787032067776, -0.012925035320222378, -0.010000321082770824, -0.002261959481984377, 0.020636145025491714, 0.02394196391105652, 0.006412569899111986, 0.00009217382466886193, -0.021518880501389503, -0.014008060097694397, -0.028500376269221306, -0.008926882408559322, -0.024117423221468925, 0.04784275218844414, -0.020689595490694046, 0.05016211047768593, 0.049211811274290085, 0.013042734935879707, 0.03355533629655838, 0.004116919822990894, 0.0031590231228619814, 0.004083316307514906, -0.00037954727304168046, 0.04086614027619362, -0.009264027699828148, 0.015547875314950943, 0.017540082335472107, -0.003950579557567835, 0.016351012513041496, 0.059316251426935196, -0.005490405485033989, -0.008927153423428535, 0.025674575939774513, 0.020262541249394417, -0.02987561747431755, 0.010868396610021591, -0.015406905673444271, 0.01949165388941765, -0.03498080372810364, -0.05902469903230667, 0.016450271010398865, 0.008661051280796528, -0.024388398975133896, -0.044307176023721695, -0.012470655143260956, -0.023012986406683922, -0.02373374253511429, 0.027758873999118805, -0.016896771267056465, 0.034880705177783966, 0.0331631638109684, 0.028784064576029778, 0.00479046581313014, 0.02403426729142666, -0.033623356372117996, -0.07258111238479614, -0.011106708087027073, -0.009892209433019161, -0.04319582134485245, 0.012806744314730167, 0.03458118066191673, -0.025362368673086166, 0.0017869769362732768, -0.022038154304027557, -0.005759887397289276, 0.0045262835919857025, 0.040264349430799484, 0.002116874558851123, 0.08147227764129639, 0.0077199991792440414, 0.013018353842198849, -0.00743675883859396, -0.00011470224126242101, 0.10203064978122711, 0.08916233479976654, 0.02689179964363575, -0.051125720143318176, 0.012134531512856483, -0.010672340169548988, -0.0043776691891252995, -0.04749556630849838, 0.032530054450035095, 0.018177635967731476, 0.006065541412681341, 0.02568846195936203, 0.07819356769323349, 0.0064415778033435345, 0.00775695126503706, 0.07212924212217331, -0.002220440423116088, 0.01398870162665844, 0.008638224564492702, 0.03247475251555443, -0.021565847098827362, 0.017339671030640602, -0.10029985755681992, 0.043244656175374985, 0.002907090587541461, -0.010347230359911919, -0.017320938408374786, -0.03179505467414856, -0.014336677268147469, 0.023230882361531258, -0.0354609489440918, -0.007612399756908417, 0.0023093789350241423, -0.021867526695132256, -0.010010595433413982, -0.02511969394981861, 0.016176648437976837, -0.009655703790485859, 0.038665857166051865, 0.04180910810828209, 0.010670174844563007, -0.016772398725152016, -0.01917388290166855, 0.010037031024694443, -0.02062513679265976, -0.037161506712436676, -0.06296742707490921, 0.02605968527495861, -0.008117063902318478, 0.023573921993374825, -0.011023915372788906, 0.025153208523988724, -0.030686689540743828, -0.05830597132444382, -0.0031018482986837626, 0.009184423834085464, 0.029671890661120415, -0.00046420880244113505, 0.004915413912385702, -0.011288685724139214, 0.0017935523064807057, -0.027146752923727036, 0.018051786348223686, 0.0018022825242951512, -0.045068833976984024, 0.009170939214527607, -0.07497094571590424, 0.04373730346560478, -0.015904603525996208, -0.021355118602514267, 0.020438101142644882, -0.016947638243436813, -0.04891466721892357, 0.0028866087086498737, 0.027223292738199234, -0.01927383989095688, -0.013984468765556812, 0.0017851341981440783, 0.005599078722298145, 0.010535596869885921, -0.02297366037964821, 0.023738941177725792, 0.014228367246687412, -0.018552884459495544, -0.01830175332725048, -0.015335747972130775, 0.03893187269568443, 0.022096863016486168, 0.0006062762113288045, 0.011241450905799866, -0.039556730538606644, 0.05490856617689133, 0.03781948238611221, -0.06826668977737427, -0.020664334297180176, 0.0001743264583637938, 0.013468258082866669, -0.0021400509867817163, -0.03081202134490013, 0.06414175778627396, 0.0385640524327755, -0.004293604753911495, -0.01992706209421158, 0.05578922480344772, -0.02226436138153076, 0.04333536699414253, 0.030985327437520027, -0.04240964725613594, 0.01568611152470112, -0.013406552374362946, -0.019777821376919746, -0.0423884280025959, -0.06203718110918999, -0.04250841215252876, -0.004013781435787678, 0.00343760522082448, -0.02342897653579712, -0.038722749799489975, 0.04630265757441521, -0.029065590351819992, -0.008099946193397045, -0.025153592228889465, -0.013608893379569054, -0.06609851866960526, -0.01991925574839115, -0.010099023580551147, -0.012074370868504047, 0.015537401661276817, 0.047610849142074585, -0.040633250027894974, 0.00821936409920454, 0.04379742965102196, 0.011103753000497818, 0.031349677592515945, 0.0025314432568848133, 0.008682574145495892, -0.017470143735408783, 0.028146952390670776, -0.018131455406546593, -0.04651053994894028, 0.026517609134316444, -0.0472668819129467, -0.018071454018354416, 0.016029158607125282, -0.005007392261177301, 0.014346646144986153, 0.0033030505292117596, 0.024793006479740143, -0.007716457825154066, 0.004161962307989597, -0.007643500808626413, 0.025928817689418793, 0.0007153031183406711, 0.027280094102025032, 0.016594788059592247, -0.007439440581947565, -0.009223475120961666, 0.0354061983525753, 0.002351529663428664, -0.024501672014594078, 0.06612367182970047, 0.011573437601327896, -0.00937589816749096, -0.0037172501906752586, -0.037352949380874634, -0.006072988733649254, 0.005696836393326521, -0.01892237924039364, 0.08558504283428192, 0.0414804182946682, -0.061072926968336105, 0.0003350128827150911, -0.021803757175803185, 0.006461446173489094, -0.061068397015333176, 0.01263276394456625, -0.027825795114040375, -0.020155156031250954, 0.028912104666233063, -0.053205396980047226, -0.01446251105517149, 0.014814070425927639, -0.0182687658816576, 0.037532590329647064, -0.02055143192410469, -0.0014833982568234205, -0.0014089556643739343, -0.009019456803798676, 0.001812337781302631, 0.03013935498893261, 0.03717215359210968, 0.04661104455590248, 0.035870082676410675, -0.0029036100022494793, 0.020635217428207397, -0.02909409999847412, -0.003451031167060137, -0.002373975468799472, 0.022166723385453224, -0.06533393263816833, -0.0022571557201445103, -0.0237107016146183, -0.010913739912211895, 0.015506131574511528, -0.032047610729932785, 0.048358410596847534, 0.042366065084934235, 0.01883060298860073, -0.007147128693759441, 0.08018404990434647, 0.016932770609855652, -0.02338244765996933, -0.011498436331748962, 0.00847869087010622, -0.0033133975230157375, 0.008069164119660854, -0.018867311999201775, 0.0002601491578388959, 0.03063080832362175, -0.03994855657219887, -0.015533044002950191, -0.02488909289240837, -0.01677609048783779, 0.01380482129752636, -0.03424537554383278, -0.011926578357815742, 0.01348934043198824, -0.02378375642001629, 0.01863487996160984, -0.008018974214792252, -0.010716604068875313, 0.030009476467967033, 0.009238687343895435, 0.004664924461394548, -0.009974567219614983, -0.003355372231453657, -0.03627139329910278, -0.002765895798802376, -0.008565718308091164, -0.0032278290018439293, -0.07270743697881699, -0.006031278986483812, 0.008679814636707306, -0.0300968736410141, -0.034692998975515366, -0.015454547479748726, -0.006889686919748783, 0.03319976106286049, -0.003181064734235406, 0.01817914843559265, 0.03895801305770874, -0.004532699938863516, 0.01912859082221985, -0.09212899208068848, 0.08043347299098969, 0.02279064431786537, -0.0074735237285494804, -0.033868007361888885, 0.018411846831440926, -0.044503986835479736, 0.026179177686572075, 0.05458256974816322, 0.006292520556598902, 0.013672961853444576, -0.017452683299779892, 0.05508509650826454, 0.01884179748594761, -0.05137299746274948, 0.037757981568574905, -0.008330189622938633, -0.016612553969025612, -0.013206722214818, -0.01811726577579975, 0.006923731882125139, -0.007846671156585217, -0.0007734119426459074, -0.006190508138388395, -0.0017702840268611908, 0.005474039353430271, -0.019238123670220375, -0.005837222561240196, 0.017472757026553154, -0.05419011041522026, 0.012731111608445644, -0.015309502370655537, 0.0020713682752102613, 0.06896322220563889, 0.021706292405724525, -0.04966327175498009, 0.03580331429839134, -0.052107442170381546, -0.039251215755939484, 0.018112335354089737, 0.007332987617701292, -0.014632717706263065, -0.08920992165803909, -0.05096547305583954, 0.0033633660059422255, -0.025445278733968735, 0.026526782661676407, 0.037579093128442764, 0.017902612686157227, 0.05197206512093544, -0.004652463831007481, 0.005868994630873203, -0.0030513224191963673, 0.025979718193411827, -0.002737524686381221, 0.00018971248937305063, 0.01460296381264925, -0.006083841435611248, 0.03300582990050316, 0.00012559535389300436, -0.020308589562773705, 0.008073569275438786, -0.007570039946585894, 0.014351466670632362, 0.0029825379606336355, 0.008277707733213902, -0.00009840624989010394, -0.011151308193802834, 0.02321004867553711, 0.014712070114910603, -0.0029680845327675343, 0.03464534506201744, -0.0499323345720768, -0.0036284099332988262, -0.045053254812955856, -0.015240559354424477, -0.039506226778030396, 0.010159541852772236, -0.0014968293253332376, 0.012819409370422363, -0.001125798444263637, 0.018367622047662735, 0.03608623519539833, 0.0010585496202111244, 0.013791285455226898, -0.0208355113863945, 0.03086245059967041, -0.03248698636889458, -0.0005258009769022465, 0.004841148387640715, -0.0031080490443855524, -0.04137881472706795, -0.015758533030748367, 0.017389953136444092, 0.0230494886636734, 0.054689325392246246, -0.008400959894061089, 0.003793848678469658, 0.008709516376256943, 0.004895668942481279, -0.060077205300331116, -0.008385404013097286, -0.05250090733170509, 0.00992136262357235, 0.007353365886956453, -0.034265805035829544 ]
<p>Suppose I have two events $B$ and $A^c$ and I wish to compute the probability of their intersection. I just want to ensure that the following proof holds (i.e., is correct -- I'm a little rusty). <strong>Updated!</strong> Assume the events are independent.</p> <p>\begin{gather*} P(A^c) = 1- P(A) \\ \end{gather*} so \begin{align*} P(B \cap A^c) &amp;= P(B) \times \Big(1-P(A)\Big) \\ &amp;= P(B) - P(B)P(A) \\ &amp;= P(B) - P(B \cap A) \end{align*}</p> <p>Another way to look at it, $A$ and $B$ are two events in some sample space $\mathcal{F}$, i.e., $A,B \in \mathcal{F}$. This means:</p> <p>\begin{align*} B = (A\cap B) \cup (B\cap A^c) \end{align*}</p> <p>so </p> <p>\begin{align*} P(B) &amp;= P(A\cap B) + P(B \cap A^c) \\ P(B \cap A^c) &amp;= P(B) - P(A \cap B) \end{align*}</p>
36,332
[ -0.03400107100605965, -0.020957767963409424, -0.0040909294039011, 0.016363495960831642, -0.020381152629852295, 0.03670218586921692, 0.035131603479385376, 0.01867692545056343, 0.0177911426872015, 0.005729358643293381, 0.03613172844052315, 0.045652251690626144, 0.029079535976052284, -0.012555823661386967, 0.01405420247465372, -0.020763209089636803, 0.0053674341179430485, -0.010459898971021175, -0.009966795332729816, -0.0288079846650362, 0.006820437032729387, 0.029713472351431847, 0.0433729812502861, -0.016393335536122322, -0.00736126909032464, 0.029817625880241394, 0.0012603278737515211, -0.018800826743245125, -0.0030403672717511654, 0.10601712763309479, -0.03962874040007591, -0.052878059446811676, 0.033681754022836685, 0.0715118870139122, 0.011354861781001091, 0.005626864265650511, -0.017740663141012192, -0.02893391251564026, 0.010204941965639591, 0.009558557532727718, -0.031086985021829605, -0.020491234958171844, -0.006359833292663097, 0.03758884593844414, -0.04137761518359184, 0.01622084528207779, -0.015380177646875381, -0.043716028332710266, 0.019986344501376152, -0.06834383308887482, 0.04885794222354889, 0.021258577704429626, 0.06097886711359024, 0.02765027806162834, -0.044521309435367584, -0.008712696842849255, 0.033809687942266464, 0.05707678571343422, 0.017840882763266563, -0.04179966449737549, 0.011434893123805523, -0.05435645207762718, 0.008854848332703114, -0.003050680737942457, -0.0777382105588913, 0.03608021140098572, 0.0003037851711269468, -0.0034133498556911945, 0.012660720385611057, -0.053965743631124496, 0.00357335084117949, 0.010129483416676521, 0.052589427679777145, -0.018801871687173843, 0.025713728740811348, -0.03724920004606247, 0.03344309329986572, 0.05844426155090332, 0.051433514803647995, 0.03166818991303444, -0.0033384528942406178, 0.034545283764600754, 0.03169889375567436, 0.001870287349447608, 0.01904105767607689, -0.007252376526594162, 0.06795075535774231, -0.000015457011613762006, -0.006471408065408468, -0.003892260603606701, -0.013184142298996449, -0.010487469844520092, 0.040024533867836, -0.0618395060300827, -0.029203152284026146, 0.05183292180299759, -0.047054264694452286, 0.026370259001851082, 0.01787763647735119, -0.004887422546744347, -0.05541636422276497, -0.03536065295338631, 0.024942105636000633, 0.06135128065943718, -0.005318423733115196, -0.016948267817497253, -0.036584243178367615, 0.031083161011338234, 0.02134079486131668, -0.01483976747840643, -0.0336463637650013, 0.02026478387415409, 0.012410745024681091, 0.01321696862578392, 0.0008783224038779736, -0.03172759711742401, -0.0027590878307819366, 0.01107718050479889, 0.03258875012397766, 0.034886717796325684, 0.06442643702030182, 0.003774031763896346, 0.01921500451862812, -0.04662717506289482, -0.052295949310064316, 0.0071837943978607655, 0.033176250755786896, -0.00262273196130991, -0.06652168184518814, 0.058418381959199905, 0.0020531192421913147, -0.008494057692587376, 0.01379322074353695, 0.018845288082957268, 0.007111472077667713, -0.015576379373669624, -0.0564146488904953, -0.025307750329375267, 0.03634534031152725, 0.009203702211380005, -0.02046867087483406, -0.048338450491428375, 0.04782217741012573, 0.05192354694008827, 0.08129879087209702, -0.0008675353601574898, 0.04538290947675705, -0.0027551548555493355, 0.0020892147440463305, 0.0201858002692461, -0.0356314517557621, -0.020611656829714775, 0.008988508023321629, 0.01070437766611576, -0.015847060829401016, -0.07791872322559357, 0.03471344709396362, 0.018996331840753555, -0.00978025421500206, -0.05076788365840912, 0.08009573817253113, -0.01333575788885355, -0.012282759882509708, -0.03218601271510124, 0.02118515409529209, -0.03147356957197189, 0.08082224428653717, 0.01601913943886757, 0.019840829074382782, 0.011040768586099148, 0.02860405668616295, 0.04996844008564949, 0.01274541299790144, 0.019608300179243088, 0.03963679075241089, -0.02568664215505123, -0.023459509015083313, -0.03403704985976219, 0.03386220708489418, 0.025899775326251984, -0.006298872642219067, -0.009559362195432186, -0.07463647425174713, -0.007885654456913471, 0.019653037190437317, -0.006443453952670097, 0.009096321649849415, -0.020194780081510544, 0.011944139376282692, -0.02585706114768982, -0.05045117065310478, -0.13204213976860046, 0.0033331657759845257, 0.015153502114117146, -0.03577146306633949, 0.03599947690963745, -0.009765063412487507, 0.016385748982429504, -0.017356913536787033, -0.05191696807742119, -0.03548165038228035, 0.02392251044511795, 0.00807368103414774, -0.03967861086130142, -0.007818658836185932, 0.05013556778430939, 0.060271453112363815, -0.02049263007938862, 0.033063385635614395, -0.01906583644449711, -0.03271844983100891, 0.020974159240722656, -0.02450849674642086, -0.02559623122215271, -0.041904475539922714, -0.014628294855356216, 0.012549864128232002, 0.006764937192201614, 0.011086746118962765, 0.021577952429652214, -0.046564310789108276, 0.06126364320516586, 0.0630236491560936, 0.03915833309292793, 0.018756255507469177, 0.002051860559731722, 0.04996766522526741, 0.004176565445959568, 0.0028952716384083033, -0.013529947027564049, -0.031080976128578186, 0.007015088573098183, -0.006142836529761553, 0.01484864391386509, -0.0037773372605443, -0.016230285167694092, 0.02715100534260273, 0.010598239488899708, 0.010708305053412914, 0.05118248611688614, 0.008714462630450726, -0.016250817105174065, -0.023757923394441605, 0.017556017264723778, 0.03997817263007164, -0.014388586394488811, -0.002669892506673932, -0.008273126557469368, 0.008707133121788502, -0.005676757078617811, -0.06695514172315598, 0.005014106165617704, 0.012826431542634964, 0.01547553576529026, -0.030827628448605537, -0.001610085368156433, 0.04577690735459328, -0.019651424139738083, 0.021044796332716942, -0.012087489478290081, 0.026510415598750114, -0.0017970422049984336, -0.026654228568077087, -0.01484085712581873, 0.007608585990965366, 0.0061111608520150185, -0.05364299938082695, -0.0029093206394463778, 0.0073179686442017555, -0.019268698990345, 0.004558097571134567, 0.01726561039686203, -0.04547251760959625, -0.022451989352703094, 0.018061621114611626, -0.011787423864006996, 0.006135187111794949, 0.03492462635040283, -0.04573626071214676, -0.03977053984999657, -0.02966354601085186, 0.016199439764022827, 0.017008978873491287, 0.005011573899537325, -0.06665152311325073, 0.020756714046001434, -0.014578811824321747, 0.011656001210212708, 0.01526743546128273, -0.013873896561563015, -0.008160240948200226, -0.027021225541830063, 0.024103648960590363, -0.032453011721372604, -0.037120550870895386, -0.011794863268733025, 0.013449246063828468, -0.05673479288816452, -0.013513403944671154, 0.039498861879110336, 0.04434661567211151, -0.07799720764160156, 0.01696043834090233, 0.011969277635216713, -0.028296545147895813, -0.03763098269701004, -0.0006022226298227906, 0.00984033290296793, -0.057664431631565094, -0.02134597674012184, 0.02837521955370903, -0.0016724434681236744, -0.02990034595131874, -0.06712047010660172, -0.06995449960231781, 0.004854923579841852, 0.000710985972546041, 0.01718323864042759, -0.0045677367597818375, -0.03764497861266136, 0.043244618922472, 0.021939119324088097, -0.014007974416017532, 0.00871894508600235, 0.012294787913560867, -0.020688990131020546, 0.026968514546751976, 0.003084316849708557, -0.01269530225545168, -0.02502650022506714, 0.04185248166322708, 0.027788924053311348, -0.006447263993322849, 0.060900378972291946, 0.043916214257478714, 0.0008898411178961396, 0.016263917088508606, -0.012360207736492157, 0.009985122829675674, 0.02348988503217697, -0.012936471030116081, 0.013684539124369621, -0.0020976834930479527, 0.02634402923285961, -0.00035922168171964586, -0.009608663618564606, -0.03885545954108238, 0.008552917279303074, -0.0211543720215559, 0.03539380803704262, -0.02621849812567234, 0.03996597230434418, 0.02487623505294323, -0.01258827280253172, 0.03271184861660004, 0.0054132454097270966, 0.04298600181937218, -0.037365663796663284, -0.0016516828909516335, 0.02746409922838211, 0.05984655022621155, -0.04707789793610573, -0.05534456670284271, -0.025846075266599655, -0.008175436407327652, 0.05229201167821884, -0.00979852955788374, 0.0021963019389659166, 0.0424780510365963, 0.053939927369356155, -0.010731179267168045, -0.0396394208073616, -0.006746185012161732, -0.03752199560403824, -0.08240966498851776, 0.012708314694464207, -0.007146273273974657, 0.008720653131604195, 0.01796642132103443, 0.07088153064250946, 0.012496435083448887, -0.01990674063563347, 0.03331264108419418, 0.03118179365992546, -0.04969170689582825, 0.015559080056846142, -0.02254129759967327, -0.045871879905462265, 0.0047482955269515514, -0.0008625057525932789, 0.09040771424770355, 0.016928324475884438, -0.037339650094509125, -0.04285237193107605, -0.003155079670250416, -0.040896542370319366, 0.018656620755791664, -0.009183491580188274, -0.06111094355583191, 0.036187686026096344, -0.00920796487480402, 0.03284461051225662, 0.011925055645406246, 0.05976693332195282, 0.08578034490346909, -0.00872776098549366, 0.0025041380431503057, -0.0006830989732407033, 0.01257754024118185, 0.022478824481368065, -0.008044173941016197, 0.030612535774707794, 0.060386594384908676, 0.0007142904214560986, 0.014533888548612595, -0.015110588632524014, 0.037867698818445206, 0.027837300673127174, -0.018515676259994507, 0.019166357815265656, -0.05813523381948471, -0.051273711025714874, -0.013506625778973103, 0.020251959562301636, -0.015895597636699677, -0.0023074455093592405, 0.0552927628159523, 0.03399083763360977, -0.028535371646285057, 0.04796404018998146, 0.05962677672505379, 0.012512368150055408, -0.016365744173526764, -0.02160104550421238, 0.0028405182529240847, -0.03261168673634529, -0.031916216015815735, 0.011900573037564754, -0.002706293947994709, -0.015925822779536247, -0.04018678143620491, 0.054483622312545776, -0.025264348834753036, -0.03600560501217842, 0.03351640701293945, -0.01885940320789814, -0.013243397697806358, 0.018100254237651825, -0.034353334456682205, 0.043907031416893005, 0.029657386243343353, -0.013116600923240185, 0.024300668388605118, -0.005347238853573799, -0.013104816898703575, -0.00843790266662836, 0.03992241621017456, 0.05823415890336037, 0.00028539326740428805, -0.020878273993730545, -0.040314387530088425, -0.022530827671289444, 0.01410597376525402, -0.024055780842900276, 0.03170642629265785, -0.0008989220368675888, -0.015806730836629868, -0.013172296807169914, -0.032636016607284546, -0.027768878266215324, 0.015422477386891842, -0.020677834749221802, 0.027066830545663834, 0.0024135513231158257, -0.009105267934501171, -0.028179379180073738, 0.01795382983982563, 0.042169179767370224, 0.06369202584028244, -0.046329475939273834, -0.035791460424661636, -0.028507480397820473, 0.038090307265520096, -0.008622598834335804, -0.07421316206455231, 0.0452781580388546, -0.016921423375606537, -0.042727697640657425, 0.05285974591970444, -0.01743895746767521, -0.031047122552990913, 0.03572004660964012, 0.011147577315568924, -0.0003490573726594448, 0.02209424041211605, -0.005477640312165022, 0.06069330871105194, 0.04083143174648285, 0.015931690111756325, 0.07367521524429321, 0.028029141947627068, -0.018412521108984947, -0.01884317770600319, -0.007870669476687908, -0.002058507176116109, -0.0038137503433972597, 0.0023361057974398136, -0.02068438194692135, -0.016351833939552307, -0.04245786368846893, 0.008732152171432972, -0.015597442165017128, 0.01654568687081337, -0.01353649701923132, -0.03436265140771866, -0.017134016379714012, 0.016760747879743576, 0.02433878555893898, 0.03943662345409393, 0.012765503488481045, -0.019349263980984688, 0.036898594349622726, -0.004108506720513105, 0.0192151740193367, -0.017532994970679283, -0.004425584338605404, -0.034053247421979904, -0.015422435477375984, 0.01275927945971489, -0.04136256128549576, -0.0016887320671230555, -0.019338881596922874, -0.02806897647678852, 0.03513823077082634, -0.005088401027023792, 0.021029917523264885, -0.0009405752061866224, -0.028453350067138672, -0.04633224382996559, 0.00775641854852438, 0.003536149160936475, -0.006784289143979549, -0.06191397085785866, 0.010318049229681492, 0.013265770860016346, -0.032638825476169586, -0.06526505947113037, -0.04558777064085007, 0.00539002101868391, 0.021007681265473366, -0.02589005045592785, -0.03385036066174507, 0.0022427213843911886, 0.0077350083738565445, -0.0006071585230529308, -0.0351647213101387, 0.04363895580172539, -0.04173694923520088, -0.026872873306274414, 0.01738005131483078, -0.02088974229991436, 0.0550973080098629, 0.01133346650749445, -0.010508308187127113, 0.0069739739410579205, -0.03189564496278763, -0.017869703471660614, 0.036283545196056366, 0.0093096187338233, -0.02430923469364643, -0.04355406016111374, -0.018563829362392426, -0.02821112982928753, 0.010452072136104107, -0.010982861742377281, -0.02471635304391384, 0.02259008400142193, 0.048354897648096085, -0.00507737509906292, 0.0017020481172949076, -0.042116016149520874, 0.008231153711676598, 0.012461213394999504, 0.0051701851189136505, 0.007652384229004383, 0.04619777575135231, -0.020543821156024933, -0.008986524306237698, -0.035181280225515366, -0.05584828928112984, -0.009849125519394875, 0.08041789382696152, -0.012390542775392532, 0.017699265852570534, -0.03045901469886303, -0.009220771491527557, 0.055885232985019684, -0.015131281688809395, 0.0008324094815179706, 0.009840193204581738, 0.00444022798910737, -0.05876586586236954, 0.0062833018600940704, -0.03161242976784706, 0.02164362743496895, 0.049229953438043594, -0.00586228771135211, 0.0524742491543293, 0.046601925045251846, -0.00018529038061387837, 0.00003477819700492546, -0.0038813920691609383, 0.004359780345112085, -0.0009523500339128077, -0.002583074849098921, 0.061950694769620895, -0.023031052201986313, 0.033889446407556534, 0.04548845812678337, 0.015418819151818752, -0.005863044410943985, 0.023048561066389084, 0.0206157099455595, 0.02500390261411667, 0.05021540820598602, 0.02758917026221752, -0.0056780255399644375, 0.02905241958796978, -0.057674340903759, -0.036806829273700714, -0.004796762950718403, -0.03292500972747803, 0.049713827669620514, -0.00565375154837966, -0.04257037118077278, -0.015106482431292534, -0.05299675837159157, -0.01936347223818302, -0.004273058380931616, -0.017123060300946236, 0.03725220635533333, 0.04725305736064911, -0.04726735129952431, 0.0028874757699668407, 0.007569896522909403, 0.050732050091028214, -0.033806364983320236, -0.07761168479919434, -0.03555916249752045, -0.0604502372443676, -0.020538249984383583, -0.011604730039834976, 0.029254693537950516, 0.025424404069781303, 0.028318405151367188, -0.023959489539265633, 0.013592179864645004, 0.0362144336104393, 0.038297511637210846, -0.01760770194232464, 0.06336446106433868, 0.03385453671216965, 0.050806112587451935, -0.020898563787341118, -0.03438244387507439, 0.11154268682003021, 0.028841258957982063, 0.03192109614610672, -0.0776718407869339, 0.047537606209516525, 0.022426918148994446, 0.002004582667723298, -0.043516624718904495, -0.00871631596237421, -0.007564537227153778, -0.002150821266695857, 0.005413171369582415, 0.0669475570321083, 0.05580075457692146, -0.016776541247963905, 0.03293635696172714, -0.033585865050554276, -0.041229382157325745, 0.0062637957744300365, 0.03373488783836365, -0.01875957101583481, -0.030420705676078796, -0.028135797008872032, -0.002420548815280199, -0.006728211417794228, -0.03781461715698242, -0.05288252606987953, 0.005422186106443405, 0.015017234720289707, 0.019502684473991394, -0.0013582516694441438, 0.01609106920659542, 0.059084296226501465, -0.03508491441607475, 0.016399921849370003, 0.0024588501546531916, 0.030295077711343765, -0.011805220507085323, 0.0028831891249865294, 0.03258364647626877, 0.017496520653367043, 0.00903777964413166, 0.029154326766729355, 0.00977886002510786, -0.06567783653736115, -0.021934345364570618, -0.033518221229314804, 0.030431481078267097, -0.02799381874501705, 0.04177248477935791, -0.030540835112333298, -0.05021190270781517, 0.01140222791582346, -0.05091031268239021, -0.017323635518550873, 0.011559810489416122, 0.03607797995209694, -0.04374858736991882, 0.007371155079454184, -0.017839014530181885, 0.05569033324718475, -0.006554123479872942, 0.01391463354229927, -0.001225125975906849, -0.02524730935692787, -0.01730118878185749, -0.03263910859823227, 0.02681754343211651, 0.02540002577006817, 0.006062465254217386, -0.011316274292767048, 0.0009153445716947317, -0.03860057517886162, -0.009568912908434868, -0.01689819246530533, 0.012384888716042042, 0.026723427698016167, -0.010214281268417835, 0.01152039784938097, 0.023541122674942017, -0.02896549552679062, 0.00007372570689767599, -0.056763678789138794, 0.006186391692608595, -0.05405941978096962, 0.0011978836264461279, 0.02998734824359417, 0.0243816077709198, -0.009115462191402912, -0.0006166754174046218, -0.023729730397462845, 0.0732445940375328, 0.007280881982296705, -0.0227802824229002, 0.014055869542062283, -0.007769439835101366, 0.018385913223028183, -0.020264210179448128, 0.004999914206564426, 0.06132055073976517, 0.03696984797716141, 0.03275779262185097, -0.0030027886386960745, -0.010851976461708546, -0.001526512554846704, -0.004358991980552673, -0.010741624981164932, -0.0180507879704237, -0.014509924687445164, 0.03007527068257332, 0.014607155695557594, -0.002112687099725008, -0.0006663319654762745, 0.0022312903311103582, 0.03757081180810928, 0.031178073957562447, -0.027738571166992188, -0.06768102943897247, 0.00010588635632302612, -0.003005141159519553, 0.04852006211876869, -0.009020633064210415, 0.0000661397643852979, -0.03243890777230263, -0.03518432006239891, 0.019710930064320564, -0.0014921765541657805, -0.029535217210650444, 0.014879398979246616, -0.016856137663125992, -0.018013212829828262, 0.0239468514919281, 0.030615350231528282, 0.001102882670238614, -0.007336112670600414, 0.04234979674220085, 0.0038116176147013903, 0.02379830740392208, -0.02633483335375786, -0.012921448796987534, 0.04425406455993652, -0.05136087164282799, -0.004019625950604677, 0.019387252628803253, 0.030458930879831314, 0.06423915922641754, 0.01165440771728754, -0.006394937168806791, -0.007130302023142576, 0.012356637977063656, -0.03824618458747864, -0.022159410640597343, 0.011059814132750034, 0.01422133482992649, 0.011434435844421387, 0.03170941025018692, -0.005298857111483812, -0.01617160625755787, 0.020512210205197334, -0.002911915071308613, 0.035560060292482376, -0.005286211613565683, -0.01617986522614956, 0.017339440062642097, 0.029416026547551155, 0.038805365562438965, -0.03908224403858185, -0.03659876063466072, -0.001638977788388729, 0.0345638245344162, 0.017588140442967415, 0.030626541003584862, -0.0010232310742139816, 0.013836750760674477, -0.05360667034983635, -0.018618814647197723, 0.03644620627164841, -0.0008193017565645278, 0.05414486303925514, -0.028539305552840233, 0.0076842703856527805, 0.03463811054825783, -0.04212818667292595, -0.005318840034306049, -0.00894541759043932, 0.029831411316990852, -0.011702978052198887, 0.030844757333397865, -0.035803187638521194, 0.013216745108366013, -0.009959653951227665, 0.03457494452595711, 0.03304145485162735, 0.026982013136148453, -0.018592780455946922, -0.020643623545765877, -0.034096866846084595, -0.02054005116224289, 0.010234218090772629, -0.024526024237275124, 0.03389740735292435, -0.016741948202252388, -0.013381704688072205, 0.03173460438847542, -0.0023142320569604635, -0.03782450407743454, 0.0009558020392432809, 0.030154043808579445, 0.026600200682878494, 0.006731088738888502, 0.008122709579765797, 0.0137281883507967, -0.005595515947788954, -0.003920824732631445, 0.039058078080415726, 0.040812574326992035, -0.03035692311823368, 0.002747453050687909, 0.03619078919291496, -0.01022164523601532, -0.03327592834830284, 0.028121402487158775, -0.0021340292878448963, -0.009879095479846, -0.024927407503128052, -0.029623622074723244, 0.00006900893640704453, -0.01206765417009592, 0.0002590717049315572, -0.032764699310064316, -0.001762561034411192, 0.04441094771027565, -0.005995527841150761, -0.014423639513552189, -0.012360360473394394, -0.006466106045991182, -0.0483720600605011, 0.05335500091314316, 0.03493616729974747, -0.013545203022658825, -0.043960921466350555, -0.01012659352272749, 0.023871010169386864, 0.008695513941347599, 0.02531966008245945, -0.05335785076022148, -0.07474677264690399, -0.027975600212812424, -0.018559008836746216, -0.003475232282653451, 0.010205618105828762, 0.016111047938466072, 0.02960856445133686, -0.06729985028505325, 0.04590533301234245, 0.024056270718574524, 0.005727270618081093, -0.07143626362085342, 0.0027958874125033617, 0.002995806047692895, 0.0017374937888234854, 0.011727610602974892, 0.0032914939802139997, -0.015037701465189457, -0.000005025336577091366, 0.043569114059209824, 0.008380131796002388, -0.03462052717804909, 0.006393457297235727, -0.02852673828601837, -0.01093085017055273, -0.009383901953697205, -0.0003856599796563387, 0.03893982991576195, 0.0151184918358922, 0.008232712745666504, -0.02749147079885006, 0.01541316881775856, -0.023201048374176025, -0.0056371367536485195, 0.0359405055642128, 0.0064135887660086155, -0.022207126021385193, 0.06009502708911896, 0.018312036991119385, 0.017630411311984062, 0.0011549410410225391, -0.00877634808421135, -0.02194516360759735, 0.029798101633787155, -0.04923848435282707, -0.0480283685028553, -0.003466986818239093, 0.002557127270847559, -0.014224170707166195, -0.037929899990558624, -0.02091457135975361, -0.006227462086826563, -0.051138997077941895, -0.0065858252346515656, 0.02925271727144718, -0.01601908542215824, 0.055735278874635696, 0.0038026825059205294, 0.011073058471083641, 0.02464306354522705, -0.02674407884478569, 0.02282770350575447, 0.0029108605813235044, 0.04015222191810608, -0.020393526181578636, 0.015801293775439262, 0.018405986949801445, 0.00869768112897873, 0.01123100332915783, 0.029387537389993668, 0.04161057621240616, -0.023646101355552673, -0.03428927809000015, 0.01095348410308361, -0.0051895929500460625, 0.05418074131011963, 0.009594636969268322, -0.025264838710427284, 0.04591594263911247, 0.005638045258820057, 0.04769385606050491, -0.03963923081755638, 0.014216125011444092, -0.009383541531860828, -0.019081957638263702, 0.02600894123315811, -0.007280406076461077, -0.010317579843103886, -0.033636726438999176, -0.006962254177778959, -0.031116284430027008, 0.03253518417477608, -0.03379964828491211, 0.024958278983831406, 0.001932190963998437, -0.0067597744055092335, -0.03367625176906586, -0.049310628324747086, 0.042236894369125366, -0.05243575572967529, 0.03502045199275017, 0.03191988915205002, 0.017287874594330788, 0.0001610865438124165, -0.012900945730507374, -0.0150130745023489, 0.06361804157495499, -0.07111431658267975, 0.012783221900463104, -0.060360681265592575, 0.013226950541138649, -0.01442680973559618, -0.0054072430357337 ]
<p>I am trying to carry out the discretized process suggested by the authors in this <a href="http://web.mit.edu/dbertsim/www/papers/Finance/Optimal%20control%20of%20execution%20costs.pdf" rel="nofollow">paper</a>, i.e. the numerical optimization, and would be grateful for some pseudo code or better still R code that might explain how this is carried out practically speaking.</p> <p>But am unsure how to practically implement this due to the path dependency nature of the problem, whilst also incorporating the boundary condition that the original trade size is completed by the time $t=T$, i.e. $W_T+1=0$ and $W_1=\bar{S}$</p> <p>If discretizing the state and control space, how is one able to evaluate the value function, if the prices depend on the previous period's actions, and states?</p> <p>Should the grid search for optimal values be starting from $t=T$ or $t=1$? If starting from $T$ $t=1$ to get an optimal value for $S^*_1$, which is then used for the $t=2$ optimisation, then how does one make sure that the sum of the optimal values equals the original trade size?</p> <p>If going in the reverse direction, and continually optimizing, again, how does one ensure that the sum of the optimal values equals the original trade size, but also if starting from $t=T$, then how does one deal with the fact that the path of trades until until $T-1$ is still unknown when carrying out this optimisation?</p> <p>Any help would be much appreciated.</p>
73,831
[ 0.0033246430102735758, -0.017395474016666412, -0.00470020342618227, -0.005733570083975792, 0.026141278445720673, 0.0017787516117095947, -0.032746199518442154, -0.034189529716968536, 0.03831564262509346, -0.017247634008526802, 0.009751405566930771, 0.03317857161164284, 0.056033551692962646, 0.0391346737742424, 0.015501832589507103, -0.023781083524227142, -0.011551918461918831, -0.016209373250603676, -0.017777645960450172, -0.006881112698465586, -0.005541876889765263, 0.02864995412528515, -0.0291950311511755, 0.007780193816870451, -0.05043116956949234, 0.019104670733213425, 0.0032601566053926945, 0.018639272078871727, -0.014756831340491772, 0.05563478171825409, -0.03705171123147011, -0.04648733139038086, 0.011320757679641247, 0.030467098578810692, 0.01437536533921957, 0.02346397377550602, -0.07562309503555298, -0.07578150928020477, 0.010647757910192013, -0.014602595940232277, -0.03855425491929054, -0.010741899721324444, -0.025579119101166725, 0.02206585183739662, 0.01583940163254738, 0.040746964514255524, -0.01060037687420845, -0.01597762107849121, 0.05908952280879021, -0.042355019599199295, 0.08767054975032806, 0.02493523806333542, 0.03227545693516731, -0.006826749537140131, 0.021223651245236397, -0.016474565491080284, 0.028402766212821007, 0.05743331462144852, 0.021024277433753014, -0.013639385811984539, -0.012795990332961082, 0.0008969822083599865, 0.04967275261878967, -0.03761475905776024, -0.038939062505960464, 0.03361579403281212, 0.022211113944649696, -0.012321701273322105, -0.01800422929227352, -0.027121979743242264, 0.01522895134985447, 0.0008854623301886022, 0.01275778841227293, -0.0012413442600518465, 0.03978325054049492, 0.016421547159552574, 0.01127100270241499, 0.05359496548771858, 0.031221264973282814, 0.03258810564875603, 0.0167288389056921, -0.0033340435475111008, 0.03841594606637955, 0.038943611085414886, -0.004281965550035238, 0.03430597484111786, 0.0570148341357708, -0.005057447589933872, 0.041624657809734344, 0.012880933471024036, 0.0031522822100669146, -0.022647498175501823, 0.031621407717466354, -0.0005475066718645394, -0.03532376512885094, 0.022253600880503654, -0.0019854907877743244, 0.025991640985012054, -0.020098982378840446, -0.04198981076478958, -0.022078944370150566, -0.09461677819490433, -0.028256941586732864, 0.04511888325214386, 0.005878109484910965, 0.015705572441220284, -0.003319854149594903, 0.035447586327791214, -0.027234196662902832, -0.008829832077026367, -0.05931989476084709, 0.025041397660970688, -0.02214277721941471, -0.043898507952690125, -0.005767507012933493, -0.008022468537092209, -0.028835488483309746, -0.030185682699084282, 0.03504275903105736, 0.05987169221043587, 0.029060250148177147, -0.022354530170559883, 0.03294887766242027, -0.0022123565431684256, -0.07281141728162766, 0.009896276518702507, 0.012147985398769379, -0.01208433322608471, -0.07163747400045395, 0.03606688976287842, 0.021452950313687325, -0.04561043903231621, 0.027774294838309288, 0.00047262193402275443, 0.0323721207678318, -0.007071435451507568, -0.07700929045677185, -0.06301355361938477, 0.05761164426803589, -0.02772192470729351, 0.03837573528289795, -0.07699611037969589, -0.02793465182185173, 0.03826828673481941, 0.0598326250910759, -0.024739155545830727, 0.01639830693602562, 0.06474617123603821, 0.04752325266599655, 0.021201888099312782, -0.04141402989625931, 0.023339150473475456, -0.03867905214428902, -0.008810616098344326, -0.02666366472840309, -0.033119965344667435, 0.01547799352556467, 0.054374780505895615, -0.020205622538924217, -0.007390363607555628, 0.056929852813482285, 0.03803756460547447, -0.03265335410833359, 0.018703844398260117, -0.017684362828731537, 0.0021176300942897797, 0.049372490495443344, 0.017376283183693886, 0.016763173043727875, -0.004739228170365095, 0.014399007894098759, -0.01663961261510849, -0.014672291465103626, 0.02355046384036541, 0.03240787610411644, -0.018452201038599014, -0.024128060787916183, -0.023846207186579704, -0.019199075177311897, 0.012358909472823143, 0.0018465111497789621, -0.026801452040672302, -0.01804892159998417, 0.03442191332578659, 0.029951589182019234, 0.02909882739186287, -0.016273612156510353, 0.014758780598640442, -0.03294460102915764, -0.08912386000156403, -0.049599915742874146, -0.0738791897892952, -0.004707804415374994, -0.0414409413933754, -0.011698887683451176, 0.027785811573266983, -0.021802576258778572, -0.006945467088371515, 0.02863181196153164, -0.045417916029691696, 0.0015213759616017342, 0.031422268599271774, 0.06322304904460907, -0.006310625467449427, 0.013304296880960464, 0.04997837916016579, 0.07365003228187561, 0.005874412599951029, 0.032957885414361954, -0.03625855594873428, -0.05301469564437866, -0.024387380108237267, -0.027165688574314117, 0.01624308153986931, 0.00035861553624272346, -0.026258429512381554, 0.0314645953476429, -0.012463035061955452, -0.01077616959810257, -0.016311584040522575, -0.04935996234416962, 0.04898680001497269, 0.0898313894867897, 0.01989901252090931, -0.014790019020438194, 0.055781058967113495, 0.012289531528949738, 0.055180624127388, -0.02232062816619873, -0.012429174967110157, -0.028661202639341354, 0.007805921137332916, 0.032531265169382095, 0.05573798343539238, -0.0053629488684237, -0.017140928655862808, 0.05718963220715523, -0.002225064905360341, 0.0007729945937171578, 0.02117539756000042, -0.019903531298041344, 0.020255619660019875, 0.05409344658255577, 0.017324967309832573, 0.02873949147760868, 0.019172729924321175, 0.02429177612066269, -0.008361684158444405, -0.013791771605610847, 0.010065610520541668, -0.04032302647829056, 0.03606065735220909, -0.010871135629713535, 0.020127397030591965, -0.0269632451236248, -0.02160497009754181, 0.043125297874212265, -0.03146081417798996, 0.009720352478325367, 0.025964003056287766, 0.022359078750014305, 0.01451448630541563, -0.007110342383384705, 0.008181184530258179, -0.01884518750011921, 0.001860433374531567, -0.015172853134572506, -0.002312244148924947, 0.02068234421312809, -0.05427437275648117, 0.021373499184846878, -0.020756438374519348, -0.023243248462677002, -0.0077712261117994785, -0.003686493495479226, 0.02488476037979126, -0.007199788466095924, -0.00048562363372184336, -0.044979024678468704, -0.03266941383481026, -0.046953894197940826, 0.014385481365025043, 0.014417550526559353, 0.05029899999499321, -0.03841383010149002, 0.007607703097164631, -0.0006534326239489019, -0.02427823655307293, 0.04242211952805519, 0.0063756657764315605, 0.009475947357714176, 0.016110606491565704, 0.013594851829111576, -0.04705626517534256, -0.03306225687265396, -0.04932909086346626, 0.012244508601725101, -0.01004727277904749, 0.032633308321237564, 0.058463599532842636, 0.0448727048933506, -0.04617699235677719, 0.030240921303629875, -0.024901049211621284, -0.0007561052334494889, -0.02924981154501438, -0.024521205574274063, 0.01005251519382, -0.005093941930681467, 0.0003657214983832091, 0.01807277463376522, -0.01337222009897232, 0.0061183590441942215, -0.08800917118787766, -0.04833788797259331, 0.00572105823084712, -0.016516927629709244, 0.036821793764829636, 0.005224030930548906, -0.04173758625984192, 0.10830983519554138, 0.017382849007844925, -0.021171506494283676, -0.021825220435857773, 0.01295152585953474, -0.014975008554756641, -0.02689809538424015, 0.02815205790102482, 0.03605480492115021, 0.010323972441256046, -0.008446404710412025, 0.014210534282028675, 0.020710553973913193, 0.0715351328253746, -0.029003871604800224, 0.004000558517873287, 0.04119144380092621, -0.017816312611103058, 0.0174454003572464, 0.0006628819974139333, -0.0034870801027864218, 0.03797474503517151, 0.011105112731456757, 0.007649491541087627, 0.0031711398623883724, 0.0215541310608387, -0.06689722836017609, 0.016080353409051895, -0.005654413718730211, 0.0005318246548995376, -0.007950888946652412, 0.04596205800771713, -0.00622949143871665, -0.04392807558178902, -0.03237811103463173, -0.006193228531628847, 0.012629160657525063, 0.0034577029291540384, 0.0017956617521122098, 0.023266790434718132, 0.034030284732580185, -0.015216738916933537, -0.012665950693190098, 0.012354047037661076, -0.01640741527080536, 0.02098732441663742, -0.028762923553586006, -0.037322141230106354, 0.03679240122437477, 0.008494987152516842, 0.01849929615855217, 0.0077070011757314205, -0.014193839393556118, -0.010485341772437096, -0.09997899830341339, -0.025805361568927765, -0.04345875605940819, 0.06729687750339508, 0.01062916498631239, 0.019744737073779106, -0.006808813661336899, 0.019694451242685318, 0.009633461013436317, 0.019136197865009308, -0.08747048676013947, 0.04056056961417198, 0.0011284739011898637, -0.0005269460380077362, 0.015260481275618076, -0.003075306536629796, 0.018279869109392166, -0.025824135169386864, 0.011966824531555176, -0.0022799440193921328, 0.02291683293879032, -0.04800758883357048, -0.02876896597445011, -0.015927666798233986, -0.004707539454102516, -0.017849985510110855, 0.014829820021986961, 0.05514952540397644, -0.022500181570649147, 0.041182246059179306, 0.060072630643844604, -0.027819974347949028, -0.003503800369799137, -0.014009461738169193, 0.03723268210887909, 0.04582035541534424, 0.0329878143966198, 0.03653065115213394, 0.016883758828043938, -0.011249366216361523, 0.02718542329967022, 0.00887181144207716, 0.04626360535621643, 0.03486137464642525, 0.028127115219831467, -0.015287420712411404, -0.056431159377098083, 0.017679495736956596, 0.01959659531712532, -0.0026083290576934814, 0.013495039194822311, -0.03998526558279991, 0.06937702745199203, -0.0012039561988785863, -0.032678574323654175, 0.03237508237361908, 0.09328921139240265, 0.03846833482384682, 0.011108161881566048, -0.04015156999230385, -0.0007216176600195467, -0.02178121916949749, 0.0013046648818999529, 0.03558158501982689, 0.0009621764766052365, -0.010220411233603954, 0.017327088862657547, -0.005062494892627001, 0.023049067705869675, 0.0032797791063785553, 0.011887379921972752, 0.008584978058934212, 0.08915126323699951, 0.016904110088944435, -0.015186662785708904, 0.035281579941511154, 0.01617352105677128, 0.020705223083496094, 0.009928598068654537, 0.013535832986235619, -0.09983594715595245, -0.04336294159293175, 0.008913539350032806, 0.016061341390013695, 0.0011424655094742775, 0.027662493288517, -0.059958022087812424, -0.010214620269834995, 0.021764174103736877, -0.022708602249622345, 0.031517647206783295, -0.012763582170009613, -0.009877804666757584, -0.0220649354159832, -0.019889237359166145, -0.01921396143734455, 0.0160788893699646, -0.006448572501540184, 0.013284939341247082, 0.005090706516057253, 0.01681917905807495, -0.031000249087810516, -0.0011153439991176128, 0.015510241501033306, 0.04453718662261963, -0.02201416902244091, 0.006241458933800459, 0.0007693628431297839, 0.017013907432556152, -0.04597492143511772, -0.07395961880683899, 0.018956784158945084, 0.009294424206018448, 0.0021999049931764603, -0.004741398151963949, -0.011112445034086704, -0.05713358521461487, 0.03626435250043869, 0.022839657962322235, 0.0002827376301866025, -0.01237875409424305, -0.010535300709307194, 0.05447399988770485, 0.051914770156145096, -0.017871413379907608, 0.021746380254626274, 0.05949859321117401, -0.006144045852124691, 0.04182666912674904, 0.025670276954770088, 0.01666564680635929, 0.018891246989369392, -0.009759348817169666, -0.055213045328855515, -0.002844311762601137, 0.0009034234681166708, 0.027042319998145103, 0.011517220176756382, 0.02957983873784542, -0.07401248812675476, -0.01391990389674902, 0.0031610834412276745, 0.052758581936359406, 0.030258288607001305, -0.04819277301430702, 0.020117035135626793, 0.06099442020058632, -0.01352965272963047, -0.03527981787919998, 0.00538167729973793, -0.03128746896982193, 0.015362736769020557, 0.03803761303424835, -0.004762653261423111, 0.023666977882385254, -0.055165041238069534, -0.008749126456677914, -0.0011213627876713872, -0.046426497399806976, 0.06492071598768234, -0.016873536631464958, 0.009983713738620281, 0.012319935485720634, -0.02925734594464302, -0.00625591492280364, -0.012259326875209808, 0.004804560448974371, -0.04106972739100456, -0.042596470564603806, 0.021025238558650017, 0.013092353008687496, -0.014758158475160599, -0.07172425836324692, -0.037813130766153336, 0.021730642765760422, 0.006118244957178831, -0.039856065064668655, -0.04032886400818825, 0.024310508742928505, -0.04678778722882271, -0.02495615929365158, -0.06562238931655884, 0.042040981352329254, -0.00798069592565298, 0.01768159121274948, 0.01386184711009264, 0.059984978288412094, 0.04851020500063896, 0.005767588037997484, 0.02394050918519497, 0.009237869642674923, -0.011942681856453419, -0.02753349393606186, -0.029780633747577667, 0.02064070664346218, -0.03800632059574127, -0.0046529462561011314, -0.036294568330049515, 0.014543358236551285, 0.014548009261488914, -0.014503083191812038, 0.012847932055592537, 0.007424756418913603, -0.025042271241545677, 0.020983943715691566, -0.03356504440307617, -0.04016253352165222, -0.003644049633294344, 0.010021963156759739, 0.00465742452070117, -0.009355287067592144, -0.01410664338618517, -0.02714710310101509, -0.02936614491045475, -0.04366830736398697, -0.030779121443629265, 0.002733934437856078, 0.062183622270822525, -0.015969805419445038, 0.0155608169734478, 0.015680406242609024, -0.007462688256055117, 0.012279253453016281, -0.010176258161664009, 0.0060813468880951405, 0.05635343864560127, 0.0006129035609774292, -0.025242576375603676, -0.022984908893704414, -0.04451604187488556, 0.030879126861691475, 0.045259732753038406, -0.02357691340148449, 0.03292157128453255, 0.006531371735036373, -0.004149210639297962, 0.023776203393936157, -0.03259778767824173, -0.026899179443717003, -0.032701633870601654, 0.000910125847440213, 0.05061644688248634, 0.003910902887582779, -0.013210351578891277, 0.05721622705459595, -0.008023897185921669, 0.01021890714764595, -0.01934749260544777, 0.024712663143873215, -0.029478412121534348, 0.01578308455646038, -0.04786740243434906, -0.038047268986701965, 0.028064902871847153, -0.0286586694419384, 0.02614165097475052, -0.048899296671152115, -0.022525228559970856, 0.037492766976356506, 0.02412719652056694, -0.010346096940338612, -0.012359538115561008, -0.03128935769200325, -0.03411148115992546, 0.03854439780116081, 0.03833247348666191, -0.02047969587147236, 0.05246633663773537, 0.02768039144575596, 0.032966144382953644, -0.002645015250891447, 0.04332529008388519, 0.0041222055442631245, -0.027392728254199028, -0.008488019928336143, -0.050892576575279236, -0.05100877210497856, 0.06278922408819199, 0.03347835689783096, 0.010211371816694736, 0.0049859280698001385, -0.013048119843006134, -0.0009414330124855042, 0.011662937700748444, 0.01938098482787609, -0.010150458663702011, 0.09086500853300095, 0.004917701240628958, 0.043171387165784836, -0.04056420922279358, 0.003039696253836155, 0.12008494883775711, 0.09551332890987396, 0.01630132645368576, -0.07033239305019379, 0.016781644895672798, 0.01788024790585041, -0.0012709475122392178, -0.009467954747378826, 0.03087201714515686, 0.004954623524099588, -0.023702038452029228, 0.015305443666875362, 0.018342040479183197, -0.04570547863841057, 0.03393504396080971, 0.026013923808932304, -0.06435716152191162, -0.017731044441461563, 0.017382489517331123, -0.006697052624076605, -0.011387779377400875, -0.03572225570678711, -0.03943920135498047, 0.0012796944938600063, -0.03095574863255024, -0.03877468407154083, -0.008592924103140831, -0.039471592754125595, -0.024693738669157028, -0.001027383143082261, -0.005815266165882349, -0.01614256016910076, -0.01288036908954382, 0.026660030707716942, -0.02302202396094799, -0.015216211788356304, -0.010794268921017647, -0.011532816104590893, 0.020510923117399216, 0.061083532869815826, 0.018750349059700966, -0.013155882246792316, -0.008536645211279392, 0.04040892422199249, -0.042401108890771866, -0.005515859462320805, -0.012101106345653534, 0.040533397346735, -0.04125885292887688, -0.015812063589692116, -0.017511827871203423, 0.013693227432668209, 0.01184437982738018, -0.044405024498701096, -0.02277427725493908, 0.005176054313778877, 0.03444438427686691, -0.014019439928233624, 0.01633494719862938, -0.02584495022892952, -0.016235239803791046, -0.031163537874817848, 0.020265182480216026, 0.006803292781114578, -0.05321882292628288, -0.02562718093395233, -0.004144139122217894, 0.05386006459593773, 0.004889361560344696, 0.013313565403223038, -0.017588583752512932, -0.0021754042245447636, -0.01066657155752182, 0.006696068216115236, -0.0035277388524264097, 0.009045534767210484, 0.01662510260939598, -0.029851818457245827, -0.0023385719396173954, -0.03139613941311836, -0.06019052863121033, 0.009809724986553192, -0.029598407447338104, -0.028392991051077843, -0.03929653763771057, 0.004849759861826897, 0.043448302894830704, 0.026452934369444847, -0.01832718960940838, 0.005368716549128294, -0.00811715330928564, 0.029225405305624008, 0.023800475522875786, -0.043512362986803055, 0.000387118459912017, -0.01503943745046854, -0.02321169339120388, -0.009957206435501575, 0.0102925393730402, 0.04247012361884117, 0.013243728317320347, 0.04033759608864784, 0.006781740114092827, 0.015624186024069786, 0.008723418228328228, 0.017763253301382065, 0.020919784903526306, -0.05246033892035484, 0.02135508507490158, 0.024169497191905975, 0.0026558663230389357, -0.025839779525995255, 0.006616795901209116, 0.0032559761311858892, 0.018273765221238136, -0.01182164903730154, 0.02128925919532776, -0.039940088987350464, 0.0340559184551239, -0.01615685597062111, -0.013084016740322113, -0.03197570517659187, -0.009526976384222507, -0.015205337665975094, -0.015498749911785126, -0.03507876396179199, 0.00831347145140171, 0.021084241569042206, 0.01873537339270115, -0.007520568091422319, -0.009594899602234364, -0.008895883336663246, 0.008401244878768921, 0.006920946296304464, -0.025967197492718697, -0.02667057141661644, 0.004617882426828146, 0.0335199311375618, -0.016493627801537514, -0.051956839859485626, 0.00574024673551321, -0.021671107038855553, -0.000030006596716702916, -0.019833210855722427, -0.002961669582873583, 0.03519267588853836, 0.024310391396284103, -0.031213240697979927, -0.029588934034109116, 0.02026721090078354, 0.0053615388460457325, -0.0034093272406607866, 0.021710216999053955, -0.0025078284088522196, 0.012135174125432968, -0.03999779745936394, 0.011371088214218616, -0.0035003493539988995, -0.011153913103044033, -0.006513465661555529, 0.01837058924138546, -0.0006671212613582611, -0.0014912914484739304, 0.017204374074935913, 0.0004173133638687432, -0.01358721125870943, -0.00168707431294024, -0.015178097411990166, 0.03775046765804291, 0.03756636008620262, 0.017591390758752823, 0.004892199765890837, -0.01350934337824583, 0.013608822599053383, -0.09840461611747742, 0.02365223318338394, 0.021641485393047333, 0.0034586291294544935, 0.02702738344669342, -0.03327564150094986, 0.007870173081755638, 0.013491435907781124, -0.04131127521395683, 0.027323579415678978, -0.027579933404922485, 0.023695800453424454, -0.008713661693036556, -0.044468216598033905, -0.038694895803928375, 0.05931412801146507, 0.03273424133658409, 0.006855340208858252, 0.04536640644073486, -0.002065894892439246, -0.008020677603781223, -0.03341639041900635, -0.0013216466177254915, 0.03393327444791794, -0.013309127651154995, -0.05344885587692261, 0.05335454270243645, -0.03864544630050659, -0.02034374326467514, -0.0001455887540942058, -0.0015026795445010066, 0.0003521763428580016, -0.008863668888807297, 0.025622855871915817, 0.0018635108135640621, 0.033998433500528336, 0.03164470195770264, 0.010827666148543358, 0.00863042101264, -0.03418225422501564, 0.013895021751523018, -0.016312049701809883, -0.024741390720009804, 0.049265384674072266, 0.03609678894281387, -0.02004147507250309, -0.013130281120538712, -0.000049103506171377376, -0.05851966142654419, -0.012270164676010609, 0.010435473173856735, -0.010294187813997269, 0.010631740093231201, -0.023653624579310417, -0.0032325172796845436, 0.022123482078313828, -0.06601268798112869, 0.028775323182344437, 0.016553016379475594, -0.009414653293788433, -0.002355543663725257, 0.0052893818356096745, -0.05310484394431114, 0.06174173206090927, 0.02103065326809883, -0.02895178087055683, -0.05443670228123665, 0.002075618365779519, 0.011530213057994843, -0.02154409885406494, -0.05238346755504608, -0.022511940449476242, 0.01480155810713768, 0.038157351315021515, -0.012278012931346893, 0.0029230674263089895, -0.0017144657904282212, -0.008661382831633091, 0.02502199448645115, -0.10448982566595078, 0.0686921551823616, 0.015030994080007076, -0.051077790558338165, 0.02834954671561718, -0.018004512414336205, -0.012928555719554424, -0.010924101807177067, 0.059532348066568375, -0.008593508042395115, 0.0002682264894247055, 0.017668331041932106, 0.0310768224298954, 0.03844495490193367, -0.049905311316251755, 0.04347950220108032, -0.01338158268481493, 0.004422712605446577, -0.0034390673972666264, -0.039225053042173386, 0.015225249342620373, 0.022231480106711388, -0.006295043043792248, 0.022385479882359505, -0.0071482895873487, 0.000673761242069304, -0.017361436039209366, 0.023392103612422943, 0.004812026862055063, -0.00322670373134315, 0.08742749691009521, 0.020203949883580208, 0.019033700227737427, 0.03549390286207199, -0.023258749395608902, -0.06942786276340485, 0.014317604713141918, -0.06274326145648956, -0.032993171364068985, -0.004330859519541264, 0.008689617738127708, 0.024371832609176636, -0.0493539534509182, 0.012742257677018642, 0.041195426136255264, 0.012085182592272758, -0.027173927053809166, 0.04900965094566345, 0.00436520716175437, 0.012439906597137451, 0.00020450848387554288, 0.025689134374260902, 0.03376550227403641, 0.010563553310930729, -0.01621033065021038, 0.02283409796655178, 0.02662651240825653, 0.007026209495961666, 0.008100823499262333, 0.019150104373693466, -0.01210558507591486, 0.035977236926555634, -0.006972448900341988, 0.020846623927354813, -0.0454140342772007, -0.05342215672135353, 0.041749946773052216, -0.012554211542010307, -0.04027332365512848, -0.009036610834300518, -0.04576948285102844, 0.05416078865528107, -0.01237387116998434, 0.0130764776840806, 0.005325923673808575, 0.02529652789235115, -0.026682574301958084, 0.010394798591732979, -0.00016261989367194474, 0.054607197642326355, 0.001174350269138813, 0.016730839386582375, 0.0006496029673144221, 0.029580608010292053, 0.009352101944386959, -0.013589714653789997, 0.027058087289333344, 0.014695456251502037, -0.01462459098547697, -0.023186253383755684, -0.036176566034555435, -0.04761405289173126, -0.03780407831072807, 0.0134196225553751, 0.033906761556863785, -0.01222157571464777, -0.0106749776750803, -0.014763557352125645, -0.01733357273042202, 0.06896401941776276, -0.05063296854496002, -0.014036011882126331, -0.016891291365027428, -0.02067464403808117, 0.00887886993587017, 0.021041229367256165 ]
<p>I followed <a href="http://rtutorialseries.blogspot.hk/2010/01/r-tutorial-series-basic-hierarchical.html" rel="nofollow">this tutorial</a> to learn Hierarchical Linear Regression (HLR) in R, but couldn't understand how to interpret its sample output of <code>&gt;anova(model1,model2,model3)</code></p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/MxXIM.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>The tutorial simply says </p> <blockquote> <p>each predictor added along the way is making an important contribution to the overall model.</p> </blockquote> <p>But I would like some more details to <strong>quantify</strong> the contribution of each explanatory variable, like:</p> <ol> <li><p>"UNEM" explains <code>X</code> (or <code>X%</code>) variance</p></li> <li><p>Adding the "HGRAD" variable explains <code>Y</code> (or <code>Y%</code>) more variance</p></li> <li><p>Adding the "INC" variable further explains <code>Z</code> (or <code>Z%</code>) more variance</p></li> </ol> <p>So, can I get the value of <code>X</code>, <code>Y</code>, and <code>Z</code> using the above ANOVA table? How? Specifically, what do <code>Res.Df</code>, <code>RSS</code>, <code>Sum of Sq</code> mean in this ANOVA table?</p>
36,333
[ -0.04609386622905731, -0.00597936799749732, -0.010517328046262264, 0.011423653922975063, 0.06602577865123749, 0.0008547933539375663, -0.010042346082627773, -0.028705857694149017, 0.03299746662378311, -0.02963406965136528, 0.042808521538972855, 0.02927926369011402, 0.06014484167098999, 0.002365316264331341, 0.06461979448795319, 0.021711820736527443, -0.006889776326715946, -0.008665645495057106, 0.026942620053887367, -0.002393104834482074, -0.03405517712235451, -0.019333139061927795, 0.018920931965112686, -0.01051259133964777, -0.017023470252752304, 0.054487939924001694, 0.032244473695755005, -0.014052996411919594, 0.028287075459957123, 0.018993627279996872, 0.012358063831925392, -0.0011471770703792572, -0.015470528043806553, 0.014058697037398815, -0.0018503130413591862, 0.009668810293078423, -0.0012828279286623001, -0.014577534981071949, 0.03969402611255646, 0.027283454313874245, -0.023414811119437218, -0.026451360434293747, 0.010055262595415115, 0.054482605308294296, -0.0024094870314002037, 0.011554391123354435, -0.030417777597904205, 0.02604086510837078, 0.0496426522731781, -0.026115264743566513, 0.05304022133350372, 0.0247047021985054, 0.04719546064734459, 0.05746112018823624, -0.03743239492177963, 0.008548159152269363, 0.06062700226902962, 0.06326476484537125, -0.00009393321670359, -0.047745175659656525, -0.005347697529941797, -0.033713020384311676, -0.016900887712836266, -0.04513222351670265, -0.044832922518253326, 0.016943491995334625, -0.0020666385535150766, -0.012614990584552288, 0.05623406544327736, -0.010334433987736702, 0.014501056633889675, 0.02049894630908966, 0.03141792491078377, -0.010835097171366215, 0.012705386616289616, -0.0011232034303247929, -0.009661545976996422, -0.011576768942177296, 0.033387769013643265, 0.032787077128887177, 0.018692122772336006, 0.007996449247002602, 0.029128190129995346, 0.019750002771615982, 0.002394372131675482, 0.008637214079499245, 0.09412331879138947, 0.0125574991106987, 0.005524855572730303, -0.0034595250617712736, 0.0015205644303932786, 0.012325518764555454, 0.03635094687342644, 0.038773711770772934, -0.03731563314795494, 0.0327700711786747, -0.014399726875126362, 0.003071398474276066, 0.0014122433494776487, 0.002007017843425274, 0.003174098674207926, -0.018199823796749115, 0.023903323337435722, 0.03664717823266983, -0.052266135811805725, -0.02166682481765747, -0.021918632090091705, -0.003872467437759042, -0.045986954122781754, -0.016913756728172302, -0.010937944985926151, 0.04745291918516159, -0.03281202167272568, -0.009732050821185112, 0.006060633342713118, -0.04834505170583725, -0.02126248925924301, 0.0009347954764962196, 0.07091853767633438, 0.04107808321714401, 0.05386371910572052, -0.03471506014466286, 0.013772862032055855, -0.013407627120614052, -0.07957746833562851, 0.021479027345776558, 0.0010823772754520178, -0.01239186991006136, -0.024625195190310478, 0.0510709211230278, -0.028917670249938965, -0.018433405086398125, -0.0025772815570235252, 0.008701538667082787, -0.003566524712368846, 0.007396142464131117, -0.1099589467048645, -0.07304947078227997, 0.030338862910866737, -0.04587261378765106, 0.009770950302481651, -0.07024303078651428, -0.013592639937996864, 0.005186690483242273, 0.05066896229982376, 0.020559275522828102, 0.011599209159612656, 0.007728571072220802, 0.0064389375038445, 0.023545648902654648, -0.04081122204661369, 0.007501580286771059, -0.024756645783782005, -0.042713459581136703, -0.0038267611525952816, -0.09339810162782669, -0.011351280845701694, 0.038909342139959335, -0.015515850856900215, -0.005294824950397015, 0.023471485823392868, -0.0030035267118364573, 0.003232868853956461, 0.008006870746612549, -0.0019277692772448063, -0.01563766598701477, 0.06490398943424225, -0.02497810497879982, 0.040486086159944534, 0.04936609044671059, -0.02016379125416279, 0.010881857015192509, -0.010561061091721058, 0.021908821538090706, 0.05236108973622322, 0.01884828321635723, 0.007856881245970726, 0.005060737021267414, -0.0045134830288589, 0.0052030072547495365, -0.06319166719913483, -0.06617525219917297, -0.013443169184029102, -0.002072107046842575, 0.020022492855787277, 0.029858078807592392, -0.024076618254184723, -0.014376034960150719, 0.03493015468120575, -0.03747386112809181, -0.06154673174023628, -0.10018476843833923, 0.009152038022875786, -0.02089238539338112, -0.03916856274008751, -0.008526762947440147, -0.013219261541962624, 0.04168648645281792, -0.001902296906337142, -0.0071706464514136314, -0.021723994985222816, -0.009838423691689968, 0.0400359183549881, -0.020445751026272774, -0.00037810916546732187, 0.00973614864051342, 0.0630326196551323, -0.019695308059453964, 0.05163407325744629, -0.03561258688569069, -0.04517894238233566, 0.0011392266023904085, -0.03034081496298313, 0.0019894966389983892, -0.05086258426308632, -0.023320944979786873, -0.008427760563790798, 0.024851564317941666, 0.030072282999753952, 0.05353735759854317, -0.04819531366229057, 0.07014836370944977, 0.05682674050331116, 0.037158846855163574, -0.0014617964625358582, 0.014666642993688583, 0.011611663736402988, 0.05075957253575325, -0.05562010034918785, 0.013276827521622181, -0.06622470170259476, -0.031858284026384354, 0.048447102308273315, -0.00752852950245142, -0.03505183756351471, -0.0005994334351271391, 0.035404521971940994, -0.012003214098513126, -0.01280977763235569, 0.03530708700418472, -0.030312011018395424, -0.0014694695128127933, -0.01614329218864441, -0.00041821948252618313, 0.02501041628420353, 0.02867431938648224, 0.008266846649348736, 0.03250003606081009, 0.06153738498687744, 0.012209584005177021, 0.014190743677318096, 0.05853552371263504, -0.03678290918469429, -0.000015492263628402725, -0.024172015488147736, -0.021190527826547623, 0.02833537757396698, -0.004556250758469105, -0.004517626017332077, 0.06279262900352478, 0.0068045915104448795, -0.012793809175491333, -0.004509889520704746, -0.022070277482271194, 0.004687096923589706, 0.022450746968388557, -0.028467943891882896, 0.015132020227611065, 0.0005234591662883759, 0.0009788628667593002, 0.06746096163988113, -0.0498124435544014, -0.02160697616636753, -0.02705228328704834, -0.008154131472110748, 0.024308331310749054, -0.008086292073130608, 0.022063668817281723, -0.06010747328400612, -0.026370517909526825, -0.0021457949187606573, -0.028449522331357002, 0.017178719863295555, -0.02651195228099823, 0.006915373262017965, 0.0010280964197590947, -0.022937782108783722, 0.004868512973189354, 0.03490136191248894, 0.015370662324130535, -0.04534214362502098, 0.021417750045657158, 0.0007324392790906131, -0.028763046488165855, -0.039156731218099594, 0.0020992420613765717, 0.0459587424993515, -0.01321359071880579, -0.00868710782378912, 0.02406405471265316, 0.000894583878107369, -0.016526777297258377, 0.03876842185854912, -0.03368902951478958, 0.0028128421399742365, -0.00023028592113405466, 0.017206983640789986, 0.004960515070706606, 0.005212878808379173, 0.01533354353159666, 0.022605929523706436, -0.042648617178201675, -0.019003594294190407, -0.04149366170167923, -0.05744122341275215, 0.014578773640096188, 0.023601224645972252, 0.029090341180562973, -0.02677931636571884, -0.027399541810154915, 0.05889537185430527, 0.017574438825249672, -0.026077335700392723, -0.0693722739815712, -0.020369576290249825, -0.01731054112315178, -0.035641688853502274, 0.05083691328763962, 0.021656082943081856, 0.0022988084238022566, 0.007406475022435188, -0.0013387978542596102, 0.03622287139296532, 0.03561015799641609, -0.002960072597488761, 0.0402931310236454, 0.0006178133189678192, -0.0060139987617731094, -0.02664700709283352, 0.025182299315929413, 0.021461911499500275, -0.02167370915412903, -0.004301202483475208, 0.023973170667886734, 0.020129093900322914, -0.01217585988342762, -0.031152991577982903, 0.00927105825394392, -0.023456865921616554, -0.015517471358180046, -0.049206335097551346, 0.03362365439534187, 0.03876830264925957, -0.006931324489414692, 0.008071068674325943, 0.0013612646143883467, 0.03499312698841095, -0.000039077174733392894, -0.014274739660322666, 0.04599029943346977, 0.016889039427042007, -0.021902291104197502, 0.010218353942036629, -0.018408244475722313, -0.008503524586558342, -0.007291152607649565, -0.0242312029004097, -0.014026266522705555, 0.0310991108417511, 0.06573643535375595, -0.019058965146541595, 0.0013434395659714937, -0.050933580845594406, 0.050505127757787704, -0.05831931158900261, 0.008575460873544216, -0.05280867964029312, 0.017714353278279305, 0.000348211353411898, 0.07784237712621689, -0.020170917734503746, 0.00890361424535513, 0.03300391510128975, -0.04112258180975914, -0.025016119703650475, 0.023278774693608284, 0.019642580300569534, -0.013357283547520638, -0.0121987946331501, -0.020457327365875244, 0.04094871133565903, -0.013066538609564304, 0.007927533239126205, 0.018961001187562943, 0.009718434885144234, 0.007407828234136105, 0.003802303457632661, 0.009336247108876705, 0.003358150366693735, -0.009913275018334389, -0.011358387768268585, 0.022909168154001236, -0.012138254940509796, 0.008186527527868748, 0.03899024799466133, -0.005149035714566708, -0.007630371954292059, -0.03827720880508423, -0.0036708556581288576, 0.034145694226026535, 0.024017643183469772, 0.029128696769475937, -0.00018293081666342914, -0.030645649880170822, 0.040668193250894547, -0.012484893202781677, 0.03941550850868225, 0.03267461806535721, -0.003168032504618168, 0.005138653330504894, -0.007079496514052153, -0.01586000993847847, 0.035614013671875, -0.014942188747227192, -0.02173599600791931, 0.03241574391722679, 0.0654553547501564, 0.04413006082177162, -0.03173317387700081, 0.032870858907699585, 0.03479990363121033, 0.010727130807936192, 0.009976919740438461, -0.06182146072387695, -0.009628101252019405, -0.027195269241929054, -0.024432377889752388, 0.06043427065014839, 0.001855727517977357, 0.006889637093991041, -0.016438400372862816, 0.017884988337755203, -0.0018767924048006535, -0.009299100376665592, -0.012469178065657616, 0.020270533859729767, 0.05442654341459274, -0.007129096891731024, -0.04211496561765671, -0.03749936446547508, 0.045274849981069565, 0.0376642644405365, -0.0032985680736601353, -0.04984374716877937, -0.09946834295988083, -0.02866206504404545, 0.03262026235461235, 0.06305014342069626, -0.02430408075451851, -0.011164586059749126, -0.009153543040156364, -0.02568512037396431, 0.032401032745838165, -0.02828630991280079, 0.04498343914747238, -0.01592596247792244, -0.0004791450046468526, -0.0419686920940876, -0.0369597002863884, -0.0534033365547657, -0.0004326887137722224, -0.025146285071969032, 0.027116216719150543, -0.010985245928168297, -0.02418884076178074, -0.032933853566646576, 0.019747518002986908, 0.008563283830881119, 0.02102062664926052, -0.05002819746732712, -0.0045801857486367226, -0.014724972657859325, 0.03471413627266884, -0.0018331623869016767, -0.053388580679893494, 0.023232020437717438, -0.0015045457985252142, -0.023132186383008957, 0.06020178273320198, -0.04498083516955376, -0.042494889348745346, 0.03142334148287773, 0.04011049121618271, -0.02497430145740509, -0.022479811683297157, -0.015539431944489479, 0.03371606394648552, 0.044119931757450104, 0.004285586532205343, 0.07891292870044708, 0.016269627958536148, -0.014935191720724106, 0.019344065338373184, -0.018613582476973534, -0.004772537387907505, -0.015165337361395359, -0.04430674761533737, -0.03454438969492912, -0.0003340406983625144, -0.011332755908370018, 0.052164625376462936, 0.035812631249427795, 0.023074151948094368, -0.06035865098237991, -0.01475911308079958, 0.02711106464266777, 0.01165195181965828, -0.029490269720554352, -0.03242013603448868, 0.004386703949421644, 0.0043743569403886795, 0.0025448896922171116, -0.023006469011306763, 0.02978390082716942, -0.00832439586520195, 0.004285038448870182, -0.0015288798604160547, -0.026097120717167854, 0.0078122252598404884, -0.0009557034354656935, -0.004690262954682112, 0.05056491866707802, -0.015966475009918213, 0.022369850426912308, -0.009742683731019497, 0.02322547696530819, -0.030803613364696503, -0.04510466754436493, -0.03207087889313698, 0.03216363862156868, -0.03027529828250408, -0.002644697902724147, -0.006960669532418251, 0.041190050542354584, -0.017640240490436554, -0.011236949823796749, -0.02992849051952362, -0.010857049375772476, 0.00029629445634782314, 0.023007208481431007, -0.002136693801730871, -0.01837005838751793, -0.036771081387996674, -0.02225343883037567, -0.030055435374379158, -0.009568487294018269, 0.04076623171567917, -0.04805005341768265, 0.0214932132512331, -0.0030241278000175953, 0.010062805376946926, 0.07467678934335709, 0.021696848794817924, 0.004582297522574663, 0.030633550137281418, -0.006679239682853222, -0.031970396637916565, 0.02404186688363552, 0.01196329202502966, -0.033687278628349304, 0.004853894002735615, -0.032854437828063965, 0.024484869092702866, 0.06462527811527252, -0.005210044328123331, -0.021431056782603264, -0.003443619003519416, 0.00548014510422945, 0.01866588555276394, -0.07990090548992157, 0.02259579673409462, 0.003578503616154194, 0.041833989322185516, -0.026677420362830162, 0.011901711113750935, -0.031816769391298294, -0.00980786420404911, 0.05344110727310181, -0.005934663116931915, 0.0033153709955513477, 0.0018958088476210833, 0.08626328408718109, -0.014225699938833714, 0.027351772412657738, 0.0012794614303857088, -0.022730085998773575, 0.051067233085632324, 0.01068274024873972, 0.03170022740960121, 0.027982188388705254, 0.04457908868789673, -0.01168847642838955, -0.0353323370218277, -0.04205901920795441, 0.029476361349225044, 0.06422139704227448, -0.039047177881002426, 0.03344632685184479, 0.07017871737480164, -0.04047757759690285, 0.00973114650696516, -0.025409666821360588, -0.02622365765273571, 0.002199921291321516, 0.033750325441360474, 0.0691712498664856, -0.006495712790638208, 0.003123071976006031, 0.05740200728178024, -0.011773960664868355, 0.008359481580555439, 0.01208103820681572, 0.014412038028240204, 0.0018244324019178748, -0.016490379348397255, -0.015951497480273247, -0.04943806305527687, 0.03141709044575691, -0.03547876700758934, 0.03290743753314018, -0.046519193798303604, -0.003355202730745077, 0.06232822686433792, 0.06513331085443497, -0.0011390501167625189, -0.06630761921405792, -0.02728608436882496, -0.06525107473134995, 0.0005830605514347553, 0.02374158799648285, -0.035842519253492355, -0.0032281202729791403, 0.0028189111035317183, 0.034266501665115356, -0.02599693275988102, 0.008777156472206116, -0.05584260821342468, -0.08127635717391968, -0.04553581401705742, 0.002118839882314205, 0.006047822535037994, 0.04214540123939514, 0.024228360503911972, -0.03941003605723381, 0.00886473711580038, -0.030013451352715492, 0.009967582300305367, -0.019724436104297638, 0.04201678931713104, -0.0158663522452116, 0.046982571482658386, -0.017307410016655922, 0.002175707370042801, -0.009831437841057777, -0.013465172611176968, 0.10554438084363937, 0.08632337301969528, 0.03835461288690567, -0.06299639493227005, 0.03069727122783661, 0.015272303484380245, 0.029208164662122726, 0.004263853654265404, -0.049514904618263245, 0.01363314874470234, -0.011452261358499527, 0.022967584431171417, 0.05958087369799614, 0.008671214804053307, 0.018178274855017662, 0.05024506524205208, -0.06317371875047684, -0.0341319665312767, -0.011432521976530552, -0.01572551392018795, -0.004968315362930298, -0.010048781521618366, -0.07472679764032364, -0.03029773384332657, 0.055549025535583496, -0.0032059496734291315, -0.031948719173669815, 0.004243889823555946, -0.001688427641056478, -0.011243749409914017, -0.017684178426861763, 0.038719821721315384, 0.009929073974490166, 0.009423780255019665, 0.007670149207115173, -0.0016461850609630346, 0.038164377212524414, -0.017141198739409447, -0.0013238316169008613, 0.010231931693851948, 0.01177298091351986, -0.016187913715839386, -0.031654056161642075, 0.003283408936113119, -0.04971405491232872, -0.009523886255919933, -0.007014867849647999, 0.013554142788052559, -0.02182592637836933, -0.010625876486301422, -0.03184623271226883, 0.02131134644150734, -0.01768050715327263, -0.011657478287816048, -0.0004211628111079335, 0.04931706190109253, 0.053570203483104706, -0.021979913115501404, -0.015988938510417938, -0.011512327007949352, -0.038567591458559036, -0.03735809773206711, 0.020351093262434006, 0.023822084069252014, -0.010305851697921753, -0.007891811430454254, -0.09370510280132294, 0.031836312264204025, -0.027623001486063004, -0.013984336517751217, -0.0028553088195621967, 0.01201391126960516, -0.005048131104558706, -0.00703295785933733, 0.004073932766914368, -0.01248228270560503, 0.008305882103741169, 0.024781683459877968, 0.01989840529859066, -0.016660474240779877, -0.06049523875117302, 0.022722171619534492, -0.007391186896711588, 0.00027656860766001046, -0.03774610534310341, 0.005274253897368908, 0.017322996631264687, 0.04395280033349991, 0.03631499782204628, 0.028425496071577072, -0.001520860125310719, 0.05180588737130165, -0.009731900878250599, -0.023106884211301804, -0.00790685135871172, 0.029372263699769974, -0.003996505867689848, -0.038243040442466736, -0.018440693616867065, 0.062000904232263565, 0.02182876504957676, 0.01242850162088871, 0.010125361382961273, 0.023541893810033798, -0.02656296081840992, 0.008642802946269512, 0.01455279253423214, -0.04522229731082916, 0.044847410172224045, 0.021012896671891212, 0.01213144138455391, -0.02283942885696888, -0.017674658447504044, -0.016038037836551666, -0.05622948333621025, 0.020898539572954178, -0.008525772020220757, -0.04037928953766823, 0.010958991013467312, -0.00661466596648097, 0.03147462382912636, -0.032768942415714264, -0.008409651927649975, -0.04079855605959892, -0.008830924518406391, 0.013324634172022343, -0.05120624601840973, 0.019072024151682854, 0.001010156120173633, -0.003775477409362793, 0.015065818093717098, 0.009412942454218864, 0.03382006287574768, 0.037557076662778854, -0.024491675198078156, -0.022729674354195595, 0.006401399150490761, 0.045961156487464905, -0.013581876643002033, -0.039029210805892944, 0.025182759389281273, -0.04148774594068527, -0.034930720925331116, 0.013129974715411663, -0.002469183411449194, 0.039701830595731735, -0.003236042335629463, -0.016490228474140167, -0.05106886103749275, 0.03583405539393425, -0.011304851621389389, -0.004624257329851389, -0.0064282650128006935, -0.01679953746497631, 0.016948606818914413, -0.030787747353315353, 0.01330265961587429, 0.011242792941629887, -0.0008577915141358972, 0.053373072296381, 0.060086969286203384, 0.004484544973820448, -0.006376590579748154, 0.0008158042910508811, -0.004790380131453276, 0.009320477955043316, -0.01733260788023472, -0.008472745306789875, 0.06031941622495651, 0.049414921551942825, -0.037329718470573425, 0.040237173438072205, -0.03697598725557327, 0.008435232564806938, -0.08537966012954712, -0.04156000167131424, -0.014818228781223297, 0.03068273700773716, 0.0213901586830616, -0.07631932944059372, 0.0004397246229927987, 0.014775888994336128, -0.02432546205818653, 0.04165416955947876, 0.025941168889403343, -0.0234683845192194, -0.0009658127673901618, 0.012944222427904606, -0.015391374938189983, 0.017660632729530334, 0.03545833379030228, 0.022641051560640335, 0.0351279154419899, 0.016567131504416466, 0.042276859283447266, -0.04227503389120102, -0.01947244256734848, 0.00341627630405128, -0.011814744211733341, -0.05308496579527855, 0.011567559093236923, 0.01772627793252468, -0.0006738400552421808, 0.01573970727622509, -0.03617562726140022, -0.002059245016425848, 0.015957290306687355, 0.0175488144159317, 0.028703197836875916, 0.06373373419046402, -0.013620059005916119, 0.007534329779446125, -0.0435490645468235, -0.02087772823870182, 0.012108413502573967, 0.012404841370880604, -0.0015043498715385795, 0.012753446586430073, 0.04168675094842911, 0.014323941431939602, 0.007761972025036812, 0.0073119173757731915, -0.04678116738796234, 0.005388365592807531, -0.004322386812418699, -0.01849270612001419, -0.005184284411370754, -0.03717321157455444, -0.001438816194422543, -0.0264577679336071, 0.0042142197489738464, 0.030618002638220787, 0.037900425493717194, -0.017334099858999252, -0.012498350813984871, -0.0008067032904364169, -0.019797418266534805, 0.013666168786585331, -0.002207428216934204, -0.012478796765208244, -0.03550923243165016, 0.007721318863332272, 0.013218925334513187, -0.023731518536806107, -0.005342327989637852, 0.003184510162100196, -0.0630645900964737, 0.013159921392798424, -0.014737976714968681, -0.0037174602039158344, 0.012339148670434952, -0.03086678497493267, 0.03243691474199295, -0.09706471115350723, 0.07176867127418518, 0.02503604255616665, -0.03641050308942795, -0.06739573925733566, 0.025024602189660072, -0.023919451981782913, 0.011315109208226204, 0.06110827997326851, 0.01703125610947609, 0.02711167000234127, -0.010784386657178402, 0.05639941617846489, 0.007340502459555864, -0.017596904188394547, 0.07232942432165146, -0.007743348833173513, -0.00276718707755208, -0.005242554470896721, -0.02603529766201973, 0.014937776140868664, 0.027502741664648056, 0.0010515087051317096, -0.013630243949592113, 0.016809934750199318, -0.014097419567406178, 0.014278121292591095, 0.013461796566843987, -0.008483407087624073, -0.035974688827991486, 0.03809487447142601, -0.0012622748035937548, -0.04628600925207138, 0.05202107131481171, 0.016517890617251396, -0.03505431488156319, 0.003351029707118869, -0.02516050636768341, 0.010993381030857563, 0.03000253438949585, -0.022144097834825516, 0.016179783269762993, -0.056148331612348557, -0.008272819221019745, 0.017708858475089073, -0.0227004736661911, -0.012557005509734154, 0.0438188761472702, 0.047612935304641724, 0.04664326831698418, 0.010980678722262383, -0.006414814852178097, -0.01349650789052248, -0.04521144926548004, -0.020460916683077812, 0.03243877738714218, 0.05402202159166336, -0.013507469557225704, 0.01009951252490282, 0.02155032381415367, -0.0034517240710556507, 0.023447997868061066, -0.0016773117240518332, 0.04853155091404915, -0.0334586463868618, -0.03584356606006622, 0.004102702718228102, -0.021076327189803123, 0.015930375084280968, -0.008410828188061714, -0.010039586573839188, 0.055309709161520004, -0.05063830316066742, -0.007713695522397757, -0.009465320035815239, 0.005303399637341499, -0.02788492478430271, 0.01018874254077673, 0.011415621265769005, 0.046106040477752686, 0.012497618794441223, 0.0016236579976975918, -0.012134194374084473, -0.021841173991560936, 0.030571788549423218, -0.00289457431063056, 0.03386944159865379, -0.028603170067071915, -0.00467647286131978, 0.01751844212412834, -0.013893659226596355, -0.03871742635965347, -0.020222626626491547, 0.04400903731584549, 0.037521325051784515, 0.02526433952152729, -0.04797447472810745, -0.03489473834633827, 0.0047734505496919155, 0.04487169533967972, -0.06829247623682022, -0.007425257470458746, -0.03639129921793938, -0.0008021504036150873, -0.0009413284715265036, -0.026313288137316704 ]
<p>The following figures show examples of ROC curves:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/yPqte.png" alt="t1"></p> <p>First of all ignoring the picture, from a logical point one can say: When the <strong>cutoff</strong> value <strong>decreases</strong>, more and more cases are allocated to class 1 and therefore the <strong>sensitivity</strong> will <strong>increase</strong> (true positives in relation to total actual positives). The specificity will decrease (these are true negatives in relation to total actual negatives and it will decrease, because less and less cases are allocated to class 0 so there will be less true negatives).</p> <p>I got that and I think it is correct. But I got confused when I looked at the picture.</p> <p>Lets take this point here:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/j4cXT.png" alt="t2"></p> <p>Now when I decrease the cutoff probability from this point, I move "down" so I get this point as a result:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/0DHRE.png" alt="t4"></p> <p>So I decrease the cutoff value, but one can see clearly that the value of the sensitivity on the y-axis also decreased ($x2&lt;x1$).</p> <p>Where is my logical error?</p>
73,832
[ -0.012535328976809978, -0.04584337770938873, -0.006853974424302578, -0.010580607689917088, 0.024852685630321503, 0.036333560943603516, 0.010986299254000187, -0.00799556728452444, 0.015208582393825054, -0.014754708856344223, 0.03548852354288101, 0.050599195063114166, 0.06818006932735443, 0.023331189528107643, 0.0025133623275905848, 0.005909895524382591, -0.007568426430225372, -0.011769062839448452, -0.007585062179714441, 0.007907631807029247, -0.03395344689488411, 0.023743683472275734, 0.03549474477767944, 0.025060126557946205, -0.021768858656287193, 0.020835313946008682, 0.031111715361475945, 0.011520997621119022, 0.03430840000510216, 0.051260415464639664, -0.023196222260594368, -0.0034389698412269354, -0.0018607855308800936, 0.011709148995578289, 0.007268005050718784, -0.008359994739294052, -0.01919727213680744, -0.017164412885904312, -0.005377089139074087, 0.005826801992952824, 0.006802509538829327, -0.008799431845545769, 0.0022079104091972113, 0.05895017459988594, -0.027414439246058464, -0.013123209588229656, 0.03525242209434509, -0.02740078791975975, 0.040234412997961044, -0.03599207475781441, 0.06269971281290054, -0.025066867470741272, 0.041556231677532196, 0.04265914857387543, -0.0021299999207258224, -0.01370033249258995, 0.05743061751127243, 0.08281998336315155, -0.03251108527183533, -0.02381673827767372, -0.02178042382001877, -0.05159227177500725, 0.004792902618646622, 0.0006709510344080627, 0.00987983774393797, 0.015993917360901833, -0.028051255270838737, -0.05533519387245178, -0.0068525164388120174, -0.03344603255391121, 0.01577971875667572, 0.019323091953992844, -0.019678166136145592, -0.02170330472290516, 0.03295458108186722, -0.03221236169338226, 0.001916083157993853, 0.028696423396468163, 0.019443996250629425, 0.0129063306376338, 0.011971277184784412, 0.01616845652461052, 0.024338942021131516, 0.035480648279190063, 0.002342426450923085, 0.0018110269447788596, 0.05565623566508293, -0.018986664712429047, 0.018999261781573296, 0.0327618345618248, -0.021505068987607956, 0.010208621621131897, 0.013333728536963463, -0.027453232556581497, -0.04489457607269287, 0.034094978123903275, 0.03020290471613407, 0.012403846718370914, 0.009730654768645763, 0.009686113335192204, -0.01027605589479208, -0.061603985726833344, 0.041658587753772736, 0.05187505483627319, -0.026979438960552216, 0.00901470985263586, -0.029788199812173843, -0.00901507493108511, 0.011959350667893887, -0.016356945037841797, -0.022418811917304993, 0.02438068389892578, 0.013018387369811535, -0.01874946430325508, 0.00010630703036440536, -0.03608100861310959, -0.02094603329896927, -0.0071390168741345406, 0.048325102776288986, -0.010265502147376537, 0.08034053444862366, -0.012847357429564, 0.022854935377836227, -0.00797282624989748, -0.02384197898209095, 0.0367409884929657, 0.022342802956700325, -0.030302435159683228, -0.03243045508861542, 0.036097753793001175, 0.02102390117943287, 0.013730344362556934, 0.02017894573509693, 0.007143092807382345, -0.00038585442234762013, -0.0011317352764308453, -0.05699024721980095, -0.030751662328839302, 0.020390989258885384, 0.02047080360352993, -0.001908077858388424, -0.06300685554742813, -0.029672710224986076, 0.08838338404893875, 0.059400055557489395, 0.000490840058773756, 0.03558238595724106, 0.011052764020860195, 0.011993061751127243, 0.012125092558562756, -0.004532383754849434, 0.03874875605106354, -0.07811395823955536, -0.015581399202346802, -0.06914515793323517, -0.07935550808906555, 0.029979540035128593, 0.01969384029507637, -0.02706257253885269, -0.051472075283527374, 0.0607585683465004, -0.03898398205637932, 0.006006146781146526, -0.022117597982287407, -0.011469864286482334, 0.0045103225857019424, 0.0919903963804245, 0.02311592549085617, -0.017677677795290947, 0.04279821366071701, -0.00543602742254734, 0.021644707769155502, 0.011848939582705498, 0.03153523802757263, 0.023130565881729126, -0.023656059056520462, -0.011557850055396557, -0.0368681401014328, 0.00783921405673027, -0.0028515520971268415, -0.034228868782520294, -0.01896676979959011, -0.059613268822431564, -0.002621878869831562, 0.02661251835525036, 0.048247043043375015, -0.031133893877267838, -0.03048991598188877, 0.01615753583610058, -0.034500908106565475, -0.062105920165777206, -0.07268283516168594, -0.00019635701028164476, -0.02159765735268593, -0.02854795753955841, 0.00773972924798727, 0.010112599469721317, 0.008768235333263874, 0.010685021057724953, 0.01726723462343216, -0.03849922493100166, -0.024791955947875977, 0.03469732031226158, -0.054939065128564835, 0.008842680603265762, 0.038338553160429, 0.02117023803293705, -0.004343803506344557, 0.056007713079452515, -0.06783320009708405, -0.013489697128534317, 0.04812369495630264, 0.009311949834227562, 0.021510649472475052, -0.011769751086831093, -0.024996096268296242, -0.010384527035057545, -0.025379464030265808, -0.011196812614798546, 0.035331886261701584, -0.060274530202150345, 0.08426483720541, 0.04293117672204971, -0.01657913438975811, 0.012436114251613617, -0.0003069837111979723, -0.007233144249767065, 0.015083461999893188, -0.026954539120197296, -0.0016124894609674811, -0.04975887015461922, -0.025417014956474304, 0.015612811781466007, 0.0096059525385499, -0.02889740839600563, -0.002940545091405511, 0.03442487493157387, -0.013935857452452183, -0.01140695158392191, 0.018021680414676666, 0.0399114154279232, -0.004890116862952709, 0.006668922025710344, 0.036091916263103485, 0.004486667457967997, 0.006594670470803976, 0.02195112220942974, 0.009799441322684288, 0.03379124402999878, 0.0024936310946941376, -0.013174607418477535, 0.044049058109521866, -0.01488432940095663, 0.030067741870880127, -0.039653412997722626, -0.01499929092824459, 0.04772327467799187, -0.02203221432864666, 0.005384506657719612, 0.07468973845243454, 0.011226640082895756, 0.00592734245583415, -0.009376194328069687, 0.009249295108020306, 0.03094109706580639, 0.023417210206389427, -0.01663169637322426, 0.0307614728808403, 0.005301577039062977, -0.02818620204925537, -0.0181278008967638, -0.02228214032948017, -0.034806665033102036, -0.04492728039622307, 0.03588772565126419, 0.042352259159088135, 0.012391672469675541, 0.013588102534413338, -0.03128913417458534, -0.004473208915442228, -0.02154182456433773, 0.003602222539484501, 0.06304116547107697, 0.010045968927443027, -0.059897471219301224, -0.011927169747650623, -0.03234083205461502, -0.03328978642821312, 0.020106777548789978, 0.001474643824622035, -0.03824356198310852, -0.00005643854456138797, -0.01834484003484249, -0.025297844782471657, -0.04469463601708412, -0.05687833949923515, -0.020960038527846336, -0.009472493082284927, -0.0598461851477623, 0.043495237827301025, 0.011269913986325264, 0.008690525777637959, 0.0397767536342144, -0.017476124688982964, -0.036210086196660995, -0.05193499103188515, 0.02270202711224556, 0.009390759281814098, -0.004547016695141792, -0.002366706496104598, 0.012779245153069496, 0.012158162891864777, -0.013208027929067612, -0.06423947960138321, -0.05476388335227966, 0.008947574533522129, 0.0036111155059188604, 0.04404320567846298, -0.01923801377415657, -0.022765759378671646, 0.08214494585990906, 0.034628041088581085, -0.013292894698679447, -0.03477641940116882, 0.003198338905349374, -0.055215951055288315, -0.021769938990473747, -0.007584140636026859, 0.04732547700405121, 0.021358437836170197, 0.046385832130908966, 0.006811358965933323, 0.012607433833181858, 0.02579137310385704, 0.010370507836341858, -0.03722571209073067, 0.019334279000759125, -0.010165149345993996, -0.040287431329488754, 0.048034701496362686, 0.05423999950289726, -0.009498076513409615, 0.023889662697911263, 0.004644243512302637, 0.02786455675959587, 0.01689840853214264, -0.030108699575066566, 0.022170642390847206, -0.00536214979365468, 0.03522495925426483, -0.0010072453878819942, 0.02910027652978897, -0.0036376311909407377, -0.011542096734046936, -0.009528538212180138, 0.007613794412463903, 0.048156820237636566, -0.05509693920612335, -0.0348682701587677, 0.04169989004731178, 0.03322657197713852, -0.012205329723656178, -0.015601273626089096, 0.007578435353934765, -0.01718720979988575, 0.05195328965783119, -0.04720429703593254, -0.015023225918412209, 0.038492601364851, 0.027435382828116417, 0.018644418567419052, 0.011425746604800224, -0.022441785782575607, 0.008543074131011963, -0.057506904006004333, 0.002806035801768303, -0.029776036739349365, 0.04571056365966797, 0.006996451411396265, 0.0006249069701880217, 0.01229203213006258, -0.020117685198783875, 0.01711755432188511, 0.015536988154053688, -0.08199220895767212, 0.023534271866083145, 0.005307815503329039, -0.010893797501921654, 0.011369219981133938, -0.01744869537651539, 0.02645122818648815, -0.037655435502529144, -0.0014394507743418217, -0.043759535998106, 0.012554439716041088, -0.04029054939746857, 0.00047637190436944366, 0.013444495387375355, 0.007233970798552036, -0.06709692627191544, 0.013170991092920303, 0.029077159240841866, 0.012298590503633022, 0.02993200719356537, 0.045057568699121475, -0.023906012997031212, 0.017533695325255394, -0.046409331262111664, -0.0013239317340776324, 0.05735663324594498, 0.04890019819140434, 0.029567988589406013, 0.024558154866099358, -0.03530304133892059, 0.014373643323779106, 0.00817195326089859, 0.054610785096883774, 0.022235330194234848, -0.027430430054664612, 0.001011286280117929, -0.025078030303120613, -0.04589686170220375, -0.0120208989828825, 0.01960388571023941, -0.001977561041712761, -0.03611961752176285, 0.029680881649255753, 0.009698010049760342, -0.05214323103427887, 0.005202117376029491, 0.04417138546705246, 0.018986979499459267, 0.0392877496778965, -0.040638238191604614, -0.024269580841064453, -0.04095514863729477, -0.019076373428106308, 0.030687527731060982, 0.0012622245121747255, -0.05985049903392792, -0.008450855500996113, 0.052339524030685425, -0.0000012446886330508278, -0.01082549523562193, -0.020766880363225937, -0.00864496175199747, 0.01950239948928356, 0.019711129367351532, -0.0011677122674882412, 0.04567847028374672, 0.024854442104697227, 0.018526388332247734, -0.007930292747914791, 0.001684054615907371, -0.10529545694589615, -0.036820635199546814, 0.03524300828576088, 0.06264606863260269, -0.014939798973500729, -0.020860591903328896, -0.039374977350234985, -0.005530902184545994, 0.027762677520513535, -0.03635168820619583, 0.03965899720788002, -0.017491186037659645, 0.002113079186528921, -0.021519416943192482, -0.03449456766247749, -0.052483949810266495, 0.0037451949901878834, 0.013235758990049362, 0.059674423187971115, -0.02611711621284485, 0.02994011715054512, -0.053655531257390976, -0.02247220277786255, 0.02477249689400196, 0.06218057870864868, -0.028559792786836624, -0.0109903858974576, -0.009333600290119648, 0.003970419056713581, -0.019968049600720406, -0.07187077403068542, -0.009742960333824158, 0.0023918873630464077, 0.0156562477350235, 0.07425045967102051, -0.0021455101668834686, 0.037006475031375885, 0.011210397817194462, 0.03543781489133835, -0.021142251789569855, -0.006782501470297575, -0.046081945300102234, 0.0534200556576252, 0.03723885491490364, -0.004524692893028259, 0.05457569658756256, 0.007840852253139019, -0.005119737237691879, 0.0076226284727454185, -0.012389570474624634, 0.0002690883702598512, -0.025641677901148796, -0.009075956419110298, -0.04475225880742073, 0.008195296861231327, -0.01575765572488308, 0.032842058688402176, 0.0076174382120370865, 0.050530217587947845, -0.03651365637779236, -0.024089541286230087, 0.037043847143650055, -0.00497492216527462, -0.01852887123823166, 0.0066978419199585915, -0.003861995181068778, 0.028033951297402382, 0.01911970041692257, 0.021292291581630707, -0.015887022018432617, -0.05794722959399223, 0.021874772384762764, 0.02217734418809414, -0.04837936908006668, -0.004009908996522427, -0.04607319459319115, -0.01236953865736723, -0.009019396267831326, -0.046308498829603195, 0.03245573490858078, 0.005398671608418226, -0.014191551133990288, -0.0020348818507045507, 0.007513283286243677, -0.01234410796314478, 0.005875344388186932, -0.0008846457931213081, 0.027263401076197624, -0.028365857899188995, 0.042495276778936386, 0.0316682793200016, 0.007203460205346346, -0.057894039899110794, -0.025264956057071686, -0.007975730113685131, 0.012071982957422733, -0.034722570329904556, -0.016091350466012955, -0.02873825468122959, -0.006451603956520557, -0.032939400523900986, -0.03418438136577606, 0.06492523849010468, 0.002324025146663189, -0.05465234816074371, 0.032292988151311874, -0.005833261646330357, 0.07161534577608109, -0.01811975985765457, 0.004133510868996382, -0.0008472288609482348, 0.00791728962212801, -0.048532892018556595, -0.016308864578604698, 0.02283303253352642, -0.05587899684906006, -0.03770625963807106, -0.025201311334967613, 0.017285745590925217, 0.03499853238463402, -0.017557241022586823, -0.020160969346761703, -0.02048942632973194, -0.0013173801125958562, 0.030955487862229347, -0.03385353833436966, -0.02371557615697384, 0.01591401919722557, -0.02684829570353031, 0.009065931662917137, 0.0064362576231360435, -0.030172858387231827, -0.0328981839120388, 0.0123057309538126, 0.005576530937105417, -0.0387716107070446, 0.03955501317977905, 0.07525470107793808, 0.0064959959127008915, 0.008502788841724396, -0.03946851193904877, -0.04978806525468826, 0.05581029877066612, 0.04486427083611488, -0.006690177600830793, 0.0359233021736145, 0.04006219282746315, -0.01884482428431511, 0.037326421588659286, -0.057322908192873, 0.02727585658431053, 0.02873450517654419, 0.006369999144226313, 0.024461153894662857, 0.006736749783158302, -0.0015153448330238461, -0.012871936894953251, -0.04965546727180481, -0.024797767400741577, -0.022887229919433594, -0.0024290482979267836, 0.042356979101896286, -0.028469819575548172, 0.013310713693499565, 0.01819763518869877, -0.03962980583310127, 0.0316951759159565, 0.0041422052308917046, 0.023878123611211777, 0.01735810376703739, 0.049934908747673035, -0.044484738260507584, 0.00423310836777091, 0.03877712041139603, -0.02873452939093113, 0.015500067733228207, 0.000043287480366416276, -0.027430977672338486, 0.035789791494607925, -0.0038690485525876284, -0.0026805633679032326, -0.049446724355220795, -0.016105270013213158, -0.064981609582901, 0.014794961549341679, 0.0061928643845021725, 0.0014179764548316598, 0.027862198650836945, -0.003895766334608197, 0.023902621120214462, 0.015218432061374187, 0.026627836748957634, -0.02386951446533203, -0.04908899962902069, -0.038453295826911926, -0.02067558653652668, -0.02539071813225746, 0.010979056358337402, -0.010296766646206379, -0.026587307453155518, 0.04297538474202156, -0.05079363286495209, 0.03973274677991867, 0.022970635443925858, 0.052169494330883026, -0.021648600697517395, 0.034741465002298355, 0.0024318434298038483, 0.03149845078587532, 0.038312144577503204, -0.023782072588801384, 0.14050789177417755, 0.12087532132863998, -0.0037462390027940273, -0.0644436702132225, 0.03242015838623047, -0.010918918065726757, 0.005741472356021404, -0.0018309055594727397, 0.012715732678771019, 0.03338528797030449, -0.0025772438384592533, 0.002761533483862877, 0.03918736055493355, 0.001043729018419981, -0.026009144261479378, 0.07110181450843811, -0.032250095158815384, -0.015499640256166458, -0.0023052694741636515, 0.05768010392785072, 0.003624082077294588, -0.02376749739050865, -0.02149192802608013, 0.015523632988333702, -0.007910726591944695, -0.019836459308862686, -0.0025220741517841816, -0.01860686205327511, 0.007761998102068901, -0.03991840407252312, -0.027617359533905983, 0.025141069665551186, 0.0051505002193152905, -0.018787676468491554, 0.007125476375222206, 0.004893938545137644, -0.0022343683522194624, -0.042110033333301544, 0.014593695290386677, 0.050489965826272964, 0.0018037321278825402, -0.012512436136603355, 0.005964669398963451, 0.017288455739617348, -0.040663063526153564, -0.01897771842777729, -0.05369221046566963, 0.033838748931884766, -0.015159599483013153, 0.001971083227545023, 0.0075940582901239395, 0.009757200255990028, -0.0008878375519998372, -0.045987848192453384, -0.03247635439038277, 0.033405862748622894, 0.016139613464474678, 0.008568093180656433, -0.02372748777270317, -0.02429644949734211, 0.024278564378619194, 0.006686026696115732, -0.006504443008452654, 0.043229054659605026, -0.021667033433914185, -0.02061636559665203, -0.01848151534795761, 0.02910473942756653, 0.001390043180435896, -0.005805336404591799, 0.015654273331165314, 0.00288839777931571, -0.01850200816988945, -0.006579811684787273, 0.01488147396594286, 0.005654759239405394, 0.015672991052269936, 0.02190289832651615, -0.02779531665146351, 0.04829687625169754, -0.053752753883600235, -0.014201576821506023, -0.042916279286146164, 0.009020837023854256, -0.024561807513237, -0.03638862445950508, -0.027955032885074615, 0.017770865932106972, 0.0066019161604344845, -0.001820669393055141, 0.021314550191164017, 0.07096923142671585, -0.00415979977697134, -0.02508351020514965, -0.033403974026441574, 0.032194994390010834, -0.025764133781194687, -0.010822951793670654, 0.016449594870209694, 0.10872005671262741, 0.00907904002815485, 0.009418314322829247, 0.026463361456990242, 0.007021097466349602, -0.00938042625784874, 0.014280281029641628, 0.03287691995501518, -0.025936413556337357, 0.0029706081841140985, 0.0010887320386245847, -0.010904185473918915, -0.04966410622000694, -0.010578285902738571, -0.038394343107938766, -0.05590863153338432, 0.031190447509288788, 0.025914374738931656, 0.010576826520264149, -0.0011592006776481867, -0.0069635240361094475, -0.0062515949830412865, -0.016225745901465416, -0.009798092767596245, -0.031119367107748985, 0.003970802761614323, 0.0002704416692722589, -0.029807744547724724, 0.0003996658488176763, -0.006233092397451401, 0.015242129564285278, -0.016468873247504234, 0.028446398675441742, 0.020275702700018883, 0.01002763956785202, -0.00945911556482315, 0.012652670964598656, -0.009143254719674587, 0.03594060614705086, -0.041724350303411484, -0.0036388104781508446, 0.02658454328775406, -0.05114483833312988, -0.003109003184363246, 0.028324464336037636, 0.018198126927018166, 0.010084995999932289, 0.02846659906208515, 0.0018185280496254563, -0.011869649402797222, 0.05648703873157501, 0.007171664386987686, -0.017463786527514458, 0.015561620704829693, 0.02784317545592785, -0.02720610611140728, -0.014949595555663109, 0.010641394183039665, 0.018633641302585602, -0.0011243739863857627, 0.006078110542148352, 0.021962476894259453, -0.015320808626711369, -0.007839253172278404, 0.0007663443102501333, -0.033592503517866135, 0.0229448601603508, -0.009205026552081108, 0.004718405194580555, 0.028762435540556908, 0.025461096316576004, -0.01623854599893093, 0.03656579926609993, -0.03028399869799614, 0.028214389458298683, -0.10091914981603622, -0.002511614700779319, 0.030635252594947815, 0.0011704277712851763, 0.02795024774968624, -0.06807077676057816, 0.02573375031352043, 0.028620781376957893, -0.025029899552464485, -0.003985015209764242, -0.031814832240343094, 0.021420782431960106, -0.06347756087779999, -0.019941940903663635, -0.03825799748301506, 0.02142580784857273, 0.0212135910987854, 0.02141408622264862, 0.048749521374702454, 0.017318427562713623, -0.029292741790413857, -0.004404701758176088, 0.007768407929688692, 0.03950880095362663, -0.010183567181229591, -0.09190025925636292, 0.03943845257163048, -0.037459760904312134, -0.027070414274930954, 0.031050903722643852, -0.03753254935145378, -0.01756257377564907, 0.06169098988175392, 0.04775259271264076, 0.025851188227534294, 0.009815201163291931, 0.042245328426361084, 0.012366725131869316, 0.06059116870164871, 0.021821705624461174, 0.028887547552585602, 0.003304256359115243, -0.014180188067257404, 0.0046068113297224045, 0.036098625510931015, -0.020301364362239838, -0.033896155655384064, 0.025194870308041573, 0.0036922290455549955, 0.00006860096618765965, -0.0035693880636245012, 0.01938236504793167, -0.01015184260904789, -0.040557462722063065, 0.026010172441601753, -0.04089953377842903, -0.005200819578021765, 0.05108729004859924, 0.0500028096139431, 0.004079622216522694, -0.004182814620435238, -0.03875259682536125, -0.05916135758161545, 0.006204718723893166, 0.009406767785549164, -0.009667310863733292, -0.03388512134552002, 0.019440805539488792, -0.007824229076504707, -0.0018080556765198708, 0.004348709248006344, 0.008748919703066349, -0.04685625806450844, 0.010862884111702442, -0.04200011119246483, -0.0023261590395122766, 0.023711413145065308, -0.02590765617787838, -0.00468889344483614, -0.1218162402510643, 0.05004090070724487, 0.036444153636693954, -0.03439881280064583, -0.013057837262749672, 0.003970299381762743, -0.09395073354244232, 0.04273354262113571, 0.04540737345814705, 0.05128662288188934, -0.015271451324224472, -0.00971329677850008, 0.018050968647003174, 0.01408124528825283, -0.013144140131771564, 0.04803839325904846, -0.011050728149712086, -0.004854637663811445, 0.02109300158917904, -0.00225652358494699, 0.009180182591080666, 0.03158392384648323, 0.004291929304599762, -0.008474564179778099, 0.004823471885174513, 0.009296360425651073, 0.010379518382251263, 0.025375327095389366, -0.03601309657096863, 0.016396677121520042, 0.08118526637554169, -0.010171130299568176, 0.010666322894394398, -0.0032775430008769035, -0.007414155174046755, -0.050262100994586945, 0.0133676091209054, 0.0067345453426241875, -0.000974849215708673, 0.03196992725133896, -0.007420284673571587, 0.01434747502207756, -0.045337095856666565, 0.01611657626926899, 0.018264496698975563, 0.00864375103265047, -0.0279635488986969, 0.01966255158185959, 0.03745841607451439, 0.02734106034040451, -0.019633037969470024, 0.045745849609375, -0.016936495900154114, -0.02896532230079174, 0.026315173134207726, 0.012863662093877792, 0.01279851607978344, 0.009127632714807987, 0.03323504701256752, 0.04483413323760033, -0.017895828932523727, 0.022826841101050377, 0.010301179252564907, 0.04736902937293053, -0.02224954590201378, -0.007599416188895702, -0.005781619809567928, -0.03687344864010811, 0.024960530921816826, -0.027504971250891685, 0.004978629760444164, 0.016329621896147728, -0.01422719843685627, -0.022424601018428802, -0.01122246216982603, -0.02081400528550148, -0.021327193826436996, 0.00656594755128026, 0.04279885068535805, 0.05188263580203056, -0.0020080439280718565, -0.006156418938189745, 0.012812484987080097, -0.01890225149691105, 0.015912052243947983, -0.049502402544021606, 0.051153700798749924, -0.013163979165256023, -0.02506921999156475, -0.01899336650967598, 0.000977776595391333, 0.0018606033409014344, -0.004166170489042997, 0.01026267372071743, 0.05934058874845505, 0.0150651466101408, -0.013303925283253193, -0.05850565806031227, -0.0054023792035877705, 0.01192384958267212, -0.04296072944998741, -0.011536161415278912, -0.04850122705101967, -0.004994788207113743, 0.006991858594119549, -0.06755171716213226 ]
<p>I have a series of daily log returns and I am looking to fit them to an AR() process. </p> <p>Any suggestions?</p>
37,761
[ 0.012889251112937927, 0.036669302731752396, -0.005870116408914328, 0.014872517436742783, 0.018430501222610474, -0.0158983264118433, 0.012963640503585339, -0.006155681796371937, 0.01671157218515873, 0.011781278997659683, 0.04223271831870079, 0.04558423534035683, 0.027932921424508095, 0.01998462714254856, -0.00811561569571495, -0.009064484387636185, -0.008992495946586132, -0.008788441307842731, 0.025808891281485558, -0.0263628289103508, -0.01273396611213684, -0.0059816609136760235, -0.009232033975422382, 0.0020468616858124733, -0.024875082075595856, 0.042746953666210175, 0.03292446210980415, 0.0015172857092693448, -0.023333260789513588, 0.08081258833408356, -0.06379424035549164, -0.024083277210593224, -0.0052647371776402, 0.05944255366921425, 0.0033036586828529835, -0.0006494240369647741, -0.04063417389988899, -0.002729853382334113, -0.019785353913903236, 0.08314523100852966, -0.024416210129857063, 0.0026459102518856525, -0.0020633237436413765, -0.0056167421862483025, 0.0028149988502264023, 0.01851518638432026, -0.019374217838048935, -0.03068242408335209, 0.040884874761104584, -0.021772565320134163, 0.07753438502550125, -0.031556807458400726, 0.028069110587239265, 0.019330661743879318, -0.023882271721959114, -0.02910817787051201, 0.0528862327337265, 0.04586618393659592, 0.011163264513015747, -0.009390617720782757, 0.021991949528455734, -0.023893460631370544, -0.005237785633653402, -0.027726925909519196, 0.00441346038132906, -0.04093237221240997, -0.004590267781168222, 0.014676854945719242, -0.026928002014756203, -0.008773958310484886, 0.03545985743403435, 0.01745215430855751, 0.04592284932732582, 0.003991072531789541, 0.011305509135127068, -0.010769681073725224, -0.011884335428476334, 0.006243579555302858, 0.06696610152721405, 0.013794182799756527, 0.009504110552370548, 0.015174146741628647, 0.05363239720463753, 0.0073271566070616245, 0.01986791007220745, -0.016281846910715103, 0.04772048071026802, -0.01395505666732788, -0.019503368064761162, 0.048877596855163574, 0.017771616578102112, -0.033432893455028534, 0.0954451635479927, 0.062066640704870224, -0.06131182983517647, 0.02260849066078663, -0.008874081075191498, 0.023094868287444115, 0.009365509264171124, 0.00804442260414362, -0.03603900969028473, -0.03995314985513687, 0.016681822016835213, 0.039430852979421616, -0.015348466113209724, 0.013954001478850842, -0.006674152333289385, -0.0326184518635273, -0.010441294871270657, 0.006243885029107332, -0.04411512613296509, 0.010194575414061546, -0.03283492103219032, -0.007348272483795881, 0.03594426438212395, -0.02210429310798645, -0.030793625861406326, -0.023334447294473648, 0.05617992952466011, 0.05353935807943344, 0.040514327585697174, -0.0027629081159830093, 0.03348918631672859, -0.033992089331150055, -0.08971694856882095, 0.012368488125503063, -0.025850972160696983, -0.052822500467300415, -0.06250660121440887, 0.06479360163211823, -0.0164178516715765, -0.01983538828790188, 0.040174443274736404, -0.05577163025736809, 0.02131052315235138, 0.015226942487061024, -0.0780482217669487, -0.03715517371892929, 0.010949784889817238, -0.003997861873358488, 0.018106333911418915, -0.045261938124895096, 0.013749656267464161, 0.02223307080566883, 0.06411011517047882, 0.028992537409067154, 0.02718265913426876, 0.04555486515164375, 0.015579016879200935, -0.04681900516152382, -0.04751076176762581, -0.004567191936075687, -0.002721040276810527, -0.020542217418551445, 0.002645200351253152, -0.049916066229343414, 0.0046871742233633995, 0.007466303650289774, -0.011715143918991089, 0.01565260998904705, 0.050490789115428925, 0.01928955875337124, -0.015059351921081543, -0.010879307053983212, 0.00300372252240777, -0.05934053286910057, 0.06593675166368484, -0.010394208133220673, -0.0026170022320002317, -0.007134294603019953, -0.036985382437705994, 0.009925239719450474, 0.03243689984083176, 0.008202570490539074, 0.07209250330924988, 0.03518469259142876, -0.004286235198378563, -0.019401535391807556, -0.0031756700482219458, 0.041509535163640976, 0.004564726259559393, -0.03557109832763672, -0.04555922746658325, -0.015031683258712292, -0.014753608033061028, 0.022791005671024323, -0.014729497954249382, -0.030413247644901276, 0.04299994930624962, -0.059255000203847885, -0.02475951611995697, -0.04416234418749809, 0.008436352014541626, -0.027103755623102188, 0.01406492292881012, 0.019061854109168053, -0.016726108267903328, 0.0342760868370533, 0.008671320974826813, -0.037804409861564636, 0.002601862885057926, -0.02866305038332939, 0.055162135511636734, -0.030068911612033844, -0.004315448459237814, 0.04111208766698837, 0.02156728506088257, -0.0289381705224514, -0.0019963711965829134, -0.018192948773503304, 0.006598323117941618, -0.04768044129014015, -0.02568480372428894, -0.00039286704850383103, -0.021888593211770058, -0.014044457115232944, 0.04589960351586342, 0.013408073224127293, -0.006345275789499283, -0.0024090486112982035, -0.022352343425154686, 0.05168140307068825, 0.049902062863111496, 0.011443637311458588, -0.0005709489341825247, -0.008249524980783463, 0.024926960468292236, -0.0014754004077985883, -0.03439711034297943, -0.005075735040009022, -0.014771081507205963, -0.01061500795185566, 0.02852429449558258, 0.024817485362291336, -0.0059418268501758575, 0.035564202815294266, 0.0835261270403862, 0.02369767799973488, 0.004411597270518541, 0.07026007026433945, 0.010229737497866154, 0.018576042726635933, 0.005166188348084688, -0.007747465278953314, 0.05136720463633537, -0.019047150388360023, 0.006155882030725479, 0.007996935397386551, 0.027454610913991928, -0.029935739934444427, -0.01705063506960869, 0.015421314164996147, -0.004012660123407841, 0.03751511499285698, -0.009879257529973984, -0.046071603894233704, 0.04442766681313515, -0.029138891026377678, -0.02192361280322075, 0.06950758397579193, 0.021211227402091026, 0.004559291061013937, 0.033851005136966705, -0.039569515734910965, -0.013772120699286461, 0.01865256205201149, -0.00714315939694643, -0.0470791757106781, 0.037793081253767014, -0.027429647743701935, 0.01859123446047306, -0.049007873982191086, -0.023410433903336525, -0.06987728923559189, 0.019180163741111755, 0.01803593710064888, 0.013084345497190952, 0.02448514848947525, -0.02215174399316311, -0.028196552768349648, 0.03719475865364075, 0.003646873403340578, 0.0012135454453527927, 0.011426710523664951, -0.04588792473077774, -0.015518479980528355, 0.006788949482142925, -0.02573595568537712, -0.00241068028844893, -0.0035038909409195185, -0.0098453089594841, 0.03980999439954758, 0.02066604420542717, -0.06964602321386337, -0.01717161200940609, -0.007641246542334557, 0.018701059743762016, -0.044666897505521774, -0.01557671558111906, 0.047311488538980484, 0.036280326545238495, -0.06982883810997009, 0.004832300823181868, -0.03568751737475395, 0.02196919359266758, -0.06170334666967392, -0.024413125589489937, 0.0011374552268534899, 0.003021863056346774, 0.008364664390683174, 0.014854922890663147, -0.029648426920175552, 0.021961497142910957, -0.06603144109249115, -0.04894040524959564, -0.013772360049188137, 0.0005226931534707546, 0.023622939363121986, 0.01734114997088909, -0.026875775307416916, 0.046328868716955185, 0.012063920497894287, -0.05527010187506676, -0.04024932160973549, -0.03648049384355545, -0.025727257132530212, -0.058966875076293945, 0.016506453976035118, 0.017400864511728287, -0.008424652740359306, 0.010112220421433449, -0.04342341423034668, 0.015146622434258461, 0.057058870792388916, 0.03047945536673069, -0.012384671717882156, 0.032238271087408066, 0.011647915467619896, 0.0011482799891382456, 0.006111930590122938, 0.006686554756015539, 0.023743636906147003, 0.061306871473789215, -0.007621636614203453, -0.011514291167259216, 0.012977955862879753, -0.0554640032351017, 0.03625388815999031, -0.012598111294209957, -0.013665013946592808, 0.00762189831584692, -0.011386138387024403, -0.03409814462065697, -0.07091493159532547, -0.04550330340862274, 0.007930455729365349, 0.018584495410323143, -0.011246781796216965, 0.027673743665218353, 0.04181533679366112, 0.08251573890447617, 0.0022084068041294813, -0.008892818354070187, -0.034086305648088455, -0.00987800769507885, 0.012853672727942467, -0.026392662897706032, 0.005223259329795837, 0.03504901006817818, 0.018503950908780098, 0.057972948998212814, -0.029279354959726334, -0.06715447455644608, 0.009829781018197536, -0.0954841673374176, 0.03511109575629234, -0.028893975540995598, 0.0712604820728302, -0.0018163517815992236, 0.03304831683635712, 0.0292340200394392, -0.02106892131268978, 0.05668601393699646, 0.014603166840970516, -0.0295941773802042, 0.01725628599524498, -0.0071017444133758545, 0.039721183478832245, 0.03531670942902565, -0.029436320066452026, 0.022413916885852814, -0.026065248996019363, 0.04231277480721474, 0.01854943484067917, 0.019342385232448578, -0.01622951216995716, 0.0004856983432546258, -0.03590232878923416, -0.007215189281851053, 0.007156118750572205, -0.012295466847717762, 0.01809566654264927, 0.02560831792652607, 0.04226791113615036, 0.04924895241856575, 0.013605635613203049, -0.013461683876812458, 0.01814095862209797, 0.031257640570402145, 0.0023410290013998747, 0.043132998049259186, 0.01452514436095953, 0.021071838214993477, -0.029025951400399208, 0.025076506659388542, -0.012726726941764355, 0.00991701241582632, -0.0005215562996454537, -0.004381480626761913, -0.013716303743422031, -0.038108594715595245, -0.03505063056945801, 0.027433963492512703, 0.005946534685790539, 0.015080233104526997, 0.024406421929597855, 0.016785332933068275, 0.009063606150448322, -0.05141741409897804, -0.035160645842552185, 0.07243514806032181, 0.031682152301073074, -0.03564375266432762, 0.015599063597619534, 0.001585885533131659, 0.05327186733484268, 0.000003842470050585689, 0.01229863055050373, -0.00413163099437952, -0.029289081692695618, -0.005619486793875694, 0.006562098860740662, -0.04508064687252045, -0.02734091691672802, -0.004000273533165455, 0.016539400443434715, 0.028307680040597916, -0.008795742876827717, -0.03527252748608589, 0.03913360461592674, 0.057205937802791595, 0.004950168542563915, 0.03716462478041649, 0.005148210562765598, -0.11784477531909943, 0.03483644872903824, 0.0644240751862526, 0.04086493328213692, -0.01507805660367012, -0.031163841485977173, -0.03558914735913277, -0.019886529073119164, 0.03868598863482475, -0.034492988139390945, 0.007741289213299751, -0.0318182110786438, 0.041092272847890854, -0.0023384224623441696, -0.04590712860226631, -0.052031975239515305, -0.0012026543263345957, -0.035376280546188354, 0.013774682767689228, -0.015650486573576927, -0.04558652639389038, -0.040118832141160965, 0.014547895640134811, -0.009300094097852707, 0.032705120742321014, -0.010838058777153492, 0.01084753219038248, -0.010718708857893944, 0.015048179775476456, -0.024317750707268715, -0.05595184490084648, -0.013316902332007885, -0.013872049748897552, -0.00206987583078444, 0.04553771764039993, 0.025748509913682938, -0.028759174048900604, -0.015226731076836586, -0.008447802625596523, -0.025166058912873268, -0.023249875754117966, -0.05445424094796181, 0.014807537198066711, 0.04243085905909538, -0.004399544093757868, 0.04811544716358185, 0.041464146226644516, 0.008193409070372581, -0.0037228178698569536, -0.014619612134993076, 0.010423698462545872, 0.009002081118524075, -0.002527967095375061, -0.029496124014258385, 0.01025901734828949, 0.000451127125415951, -0.0065901996567845345, 0.004711352754384279, 0.01793881319463253, -0.031783971935510635, -0.025852926075458527, 0.006150375586003065, 0.03925890475511551, -0.04317088425159454, -0.015589496120810509, 0.032647036015987396, -0.026907838881015778, -0.018445957452058792, -0.004331869073212147, 0.010139626450836658, -0.005262611899524927, 0.010465453378856182, 0.01626463420689106, -0.009853913448750973, 0.012054430320858955, -0.04118156433105469, 0.012072944082319736, 0.0020098392851650715, -0.006843205075711012, 0.02858089469373226, 0.01997457444667816, 0.05130346491932869, 0.03182343393564224, -0.040290165692567825, 0.009855475276708603, 0.014503675512969494, -0.05222400277853012, 0.028970330953598022, -0.04464317858219147, 0.06248542293906212, -0.05675244703888893, -0.01592152938246727, -0.0651022419333458, -0.05407823249697685, 0.02057380974292755, -0.006866279989480972, -0.04104488715529442, -0.04541923105716705, -0.02028493769466877, -0.023169519379734993, 0.02244609408080578, -0.03726976737380028, 0.01789565570652485, -0.024767206981778145, -0.00402196915820241, 0.027848580852150917, 0.04382011666893959, 0.07592688500881195, 0.033416856080293655, 0.05169568583369255, 0.029041048139333725, -0.01741207018494606, -0.03868860751390457, -0.03540369123220444, -0.0028547807596623898, -0.045780669897794724, -0.03369560465216637, -0.003648728597909212, 0.004215324763208628, 0.046514175832271576, -0.04071100056171417, 0.027841998264193535, 0.017480121925473213, -0.002158150542527437, 0.004407119005918503, -0.020805131644010544, 0.02581351064145565, -0.03753146529197693, 0.006201708223670721, 0.0036191861145198345, -0.030259350314736366, -0.01832437515258789, 0.002117452910169959, 0.017371874302625656, 0.0036968085914850235, -0.0019191602477803826, 0.05783562362194061, 0.043752238154411316, -0.017536167055368423, -0.0021627626847475767, 0.00649199029430747, 0.011883007362484932, 0.022091923281550407, -0.01864158920943737, 0.006664591375738382, 0.03009064309298992, -0.006163215264678001, -0.06752055883407593, -0.050386399030685425, -0.018806716427206993, -0.04256950318813324, 0.02231692336499691, 0.01953527145087719, 0.040709689259529114, -0.0013054274022579193, 0.03526315093040466, 0.018484672531485558, 0.01013936847448349, -0.015210794284939766, -0.009224021807312965, 0.007486339658498764, 0.08322567492723465, -0.001173608936369419, 0.027636874467134476, -0.033028505742549896, -0.039211682975292206, 0.054909080266952515, 0.03515830636024475, 0.011182990856468678, 0.022924503311514854, -0.0012026331387460232, -0.041936181485652924, -0.03265472874045372, 0.01320003904402256, -0.02533188834786415, 0.02560785971581936, -0.018026595935225487, -0.037241458892822266, 0.05311274155974388, -0.000801151676569134, -0.0038289453368633986, -0.021274922415614128, -0.022042425349354744, -0.03487779200077057, -0.018620913848280907, 0.035425879061222076, -0.030744723975658417, 0.03438609465956688, 0.0035424032248556614, 0.06204724684357643, 0.008569375611841679, 0.021935960277915, -0.006224178709089756, -0.07261068373918533, 0.03319611772894859, -0.016061870381236076, -0.07948753982782364, 0.046902626752853394, -0.01115366443991661, -0.00925980880856514, -0.001643828465603292, -0.0019784136675298214, -0.002290027914568782, 0.03367086499929428, 0.03556067496538162, 0.003293893299996853, 0.07707655429840088, 0.003221352118998766, -0.026509493589401245, -0.025046581402420998, -0.0030206027440726757, 0.14200977981090546, 0.10006851702928543, 0.03933224081993103, -0.05993720144033432, -0.013199126347899437, -0.0677173063158989, -0.005964259151369333, -0.021718353033065796, 0.02774740569293499, 0.013286222703754902, -0.04263610765337944, 0.05349378287792206, 0.03810613229870796, -0.024640701711177826, 0.009499559178948402, 0.05332951247692108, -0.017760546877980232, 0.028933614492416382, 0.010297108441591263, -0.0015568208182230592, -0.005098882596939802, 0.010600666515529156, -0.054093826562166214, -0.010267368517816067, -0.02379610575735569, -0.04096900671720505, 0.017347801476716995, -0.02355307713150978, 0.010367501527071, 0.014125349000096321, -0.02280443347990513, -0.013209454715251923, 0.014057059772312641, 0.03980076685547829, 0.02423943765461445, -0.02740730345249176, 0.01666596531867981, -0.03890273720026016, 0.010097023099660873, 0.02983415685594082, 0.020971152931451797, -0.012378731742501259, -0.032794512808322906, -0.01642610877752304, -0.02670893445611, -0.04908965155482292, -0.02578558959066868, 0.012319479137659073, -0.01644660346210003, 0.02856578305363655, -0.02869310788810253, 0.014537988230586052, 0.02260536327958107, -0.027846576645970345, 0.004416787531226873, 0.03776843845844269, 0.031617388129234314, -0.03841922804713249, -0.02214229293167591, -0.02821604162454605, 0.0008282667840830982, 0.010252268053591251, 0.05775216966867447, 0.0028193590696901083, -0.008851698599755764, -0.00763819320127368, -0.014821271412074566, 0.05505785346031189, -0.0032597954850643873, 0.013611857779324055, -0.02113186940550804, 0.0015580694889649749, -0.017505180090665817, -0.00003444627873250283, 0.050313759595155716, -0.030285894870758057, 0.011307165957987309, 0.005375667940825224, -0.0018012791406363249, 0.00216494663618505, -0.028167229145765305, 0.009691653773188591, -0.029285404831171036, 0.004227368161082268, -0.06754760444164276, 0.014096817933022976, 0.03738844767212868, 0.0293007493019104, 0.05812017247080803, -0.01872425712645054, -0.06143515929579735, 0.06577881425619125, 0.04792577028274536, -0.029756996780633926, -0.031986795365810394, -0.014242359437048435, -0.038890063762664795, -0.017388012260198593, -0.010393927805125713, 0.09226658940315247, 0.0027269250713288784, 0.002837179461494088, -0.0013549940194934607, 0.004191942512989044, -0.043761130422353745, -0.013153991661965847, 0.009996292181313038, -0.0324421152472496, -0.01346531230956316, -0.00007520466897403821, -0.01191315334290266, -0.039236780256032944, -0.0039000040851533413, -0.021126415580511093, -0.00972689688205719, -0.01315496489405632, -0.012584357522428036, 0.008669713512063026, 0.04171384871006012, -0.03247394412755966, 0.029942965134978294, -0.02832959033548832, 0.0275719054043293, -0.03363296389579773, -0.042090822011232376, -0.02370038814842701, 0.006018003448843956, -0.024373887106776237, 0.02216370403766632, 0.015021085739135742, -0.01840968430042267, 0.030921751633286476, -0.0019855538848787546, 0.02535073459148407, -0.008514314889907837, 0.012871455401182175, -0.007892316207289696, 0.0052563101053237915, -0.03004646487534046, -0.04992740973830223, 0.016288692131638527, -0.0008882934926077724, 0.026219794526696205, -0.01962427608668804, 0.003429100150242448, 0.022001147270202637, -0.011124900542199612, -0.03286277502775192, -0.010408151894807816, 0.052679967135190964, -0.007892166264355183, -0.03073262795805931, -0.023416446521878242, 0.024944569915533066, 0.042979564517736435, 0.015965096652507782, 0.026533814147114754, 0.016785141080617905, -0.014478386379778385, -0.010485121048986912, 0.035984691232442856, 0.025310130789875984, 0.014223652891814709, 0.012577010318636894, 0.029475685209035873, -0.010881179012358189, 0.01674068719148636, -0.020814230665564537, 0.012273491360247135, -0.03412996605038643, -0.04436860978603363, 0.010379492305219173, 0.006130208261311054, 0.02252369374036789, -0.020269110798835754, 0.030149511992931366, 0.02863464131951332, -0.0255135428160429, 0.07440212368965149, -0.060192957520484924, -0.029763326048851013, 0.026777155697345734, -0.009514781646430492, -0.00040852295933291316, 0.0040368083864450455, 0.000008778673873166554, -0.04890641197562218, -0.004956994205713272, -0.008401449769735336, 0.03080681525170803, 0.01568511873483658, 0.01952979527413845, 0.034491606056690216, 0.014168079942464828, 0.0013779773144051433, -0.03729112073779106, 0.023942267522215843, 0.02593214437365532, 0.018900536000728607, -0.015734946355223656, 0.04361285641789436, -0.04142780974507332, -0.009011376649141312, 0.03685014322400093, -0.008245136588811874, 0.027793753892183304, -0.0028885442297905684, 0.022915925830602646, 0.012123243883252144, 0.03752189502120018, 0.0019949255511164665, -0.015460990369319916, 0.0033519042190164328, 0.000031011441024020314, 0.020852359011769295, 0.0162375308573246, -0.009977558627724648, 0.04056078568100929, 0.001529320259578526, -0.02649594657123089, -0.028671346604824066, 0.02402559295296669, 0.052204106003046036, -0.0025050605181604624, -0.0007064469973556697, 0.014722621068358421, -0.016430474817752838, -0.006409813184291124, -0.006806498859077692, 0.01021292433142662, 0.036225732415914536, 0.06137616187334061, -0.024404963478446007, -0.06319541484117508, -0.0019888950046151876, 0.001741114305332303, -0.057693928480148315, 0.003938873298466206, -0.005917173344641924, -0.015506347641348839, -0.02062859944999218, -0.006760552991181612, -0.0029108456801623106, 0.014424074441194534, -0.030116932466626167, -0.01595868542790413, 0.0049761622212827206, 0.016183719038963318, -0.02343829534947872, -0.001084640040062368, 0.030334776267409325, -0.013333507813513279, 0.01414266973733902, -0.042638201266527176, 0.08693868666887283, 0.014032873325049877, 0.00504746288061142, -0.017628375440835953, -0.03743104636669159, 0.006356736645102501, 0.011803513392806053, 0.06959466636180878, -0.004684466868638992, -0.013918112963438034, -0.040401678532361984, 0.023941010236740112, -0.025084808468818665, -0.003557249903678894, 0.03845413774251938, 0.00039169410592876375, -0.016962604597210884, 0.0027619844768196344, -0.009187602438032627, 0.00689444225281477, 0.009652565233409405, 0.008042384870350361, -0.015289240516722202, -0.06200028210878372, -0.004054230637848377, -0.04300452768802643, 0.013689063489437103, -0.0016969190910458565, -0.014527377672493458, 0.05397196114063263, 0.014350947923958302, -0.017160484567284584, 0.023825548589229584, -0.018311189487576485, -0.03580484166741371, 0.033457525074481964, -0.037621282041072845, -0.027298297733068466, 0.002033060183748603, 0.02730610780417919, 0.01049911417067051, -0.06764990091323853, -0.0207077506929636, 0.02267548069357872, -0.01543496549129486, -0.013152217492461205, 0.030699903145432472, 0.006233260501176119, 0.04936870560050011, -0.03660135343670845, 0.03402610123157501, 0.024551093578338623, 0.04161785915493965, -0.01866810768842697, 0.012291002087295055, 0.021139835938811302, -0.016387762501835823, -0.010856542736291885, 0.023327231407165527, -0.01608508639037609, 0.06089695543050766, -0.00803484208881855, 0.04467545077204704, -0.025104904547333717, -0.01800784282386303, 0.01212097518146038, -0.04214804619550705, 0.02015928365290165, 0.03038310818374157, -0.006359841674566269, 0.0594874732196331, -0.04405773803591728, 0.012972152791917324, -0.0351717472076416, -0.030298233032226562, -0.02151235193014145, 0.0251130610704422, -0.003270573914051056, -0.0029687117785215378, -0.029711522161960602, 0.05197317898273468, 0.017246047034859657, 0.0229541826993227, 0.006088588386774063, -0.01750866509974003, -0.02582005225121975, -0.003360572038218379, -0.003928633406758308, 0.018299302086234093, -0.05306735634803772, -0.03620900213718414, -0.026031898334622383, 0.02137283980846405, 0.07208042591810226, 0.004925950895994902, 0.005577790550887585, 0.01393929123878479, -0.02326672151684761, 0.02948487363755703, -0.05170167237520218, -0.014498102478682995, -0.038631051778793335, -0.009072087705135345, -0.021146608516573906, -0.010675155557692051 ]
<p>After R reads the data, say-</p> <pre><code>v1 &lt;- c(1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,3,3,3,3,3,4,5,6) v2 &lt;- c(1,2,1,1,1,1,2,1,2,1,3,4,3,3,3,4,6,5) v3 &lt;- c(3,3,3,3,3,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,5,4,6) v4 &lt;- c(3,3,4,3,3,1,1,2,1,1,1,1,2,1,1,5,6,4) v5 &lt;- c(1,1,1,1,1,3,3,3,3,3,1,1,1,1,1,6,4,5) v6 &lt;- c(1,1,1,2,1,3,3,3,4,3,1,1,1,2,1,6,5,4) m1 &lt;- cbind(v1,v2,v3,v4,v5,v6) </code></pre> <p>if I run-</p> <pre><code>factanal(~v1+v2+v3+v4+v5+v6, factors = 3, scores = "Bartlett")$scores </code></pre> <p>I can get observation-wise factor scores. But when I do this-</p> <pre><code>r&lt;-cor(m1) library(psych) fa&lt;-fac(r,nfactors=3,rotate="varimax", scores="Bartlett") fa$score </code></pre> <p>I can't get individual-wise factor scores. Is it possible to get individual-wise factor scores using psych? Actually I need to use psych, because I need to put spearman's rank correlation matrix as the starting point for factor analysis. Kindly suggest me.</p> <p>Thank You</p>
73,833
[ -0.022796981036663055, 0.019472526386380196, -0.011608855798840523, 0.0005951906205154955, 0.02020898275077343, -0.0045570917427539825, -0.03964800015091896, -0.018891973420977592, -0.0003305143618490547, -0.033850692212581635, 0.018514886498451233, 0.04558001086115837, 0.04244941845536232, 0.027424445375800133, -0.0004900829517282546, -0.005831010174006224, 0.013116826303303242, 0.04349891096353531, -0.007402120623737574, 0.015273615717887878, 0.0007174445781856775, 0.031589481979608536, -0.0025129576679319143, -0.03156294301152229, 0.007178397849202156, 0.06444103270769119, 0.028912298381328583, -0.014161531813442707, 0.0199163518846035, 0.03886816278100014, -0.04197070375084877, -0.01961124874651432, 0.008891143836081028, -0.016226351261138916, 0.014860613271594048, 0.0005155031685717404, 0.016952546313405037, 0.011696967296302319, -0.0086269685998559, 0.017017917707562447, -0.008801697753369808, -0.01898401789367199, 0.005047124344855547, 0.04597681760787964, 0.001781384227797389, 0.013248887844383717, -0.024713069200515747, 0.04274948313832283, 0.01674497313797474, -0.003963240422308445, 0.067593514919281, 0.00886301789432764, 0.029412053525447845, 0.02232091873884201, -0.04033010080456734, 0.02079947106540203, 0.03936270996928215, 0.0538683757185936, 0.023807495832443237, -0.046665895730257034, -0.029749996960163116, -0.0531546026468277, 0.0009024969767779112, -0.03068358078598976, -0.04844079911708832, -0.011681719683110714, 0.014146191999316216, -0.005273738410323858, 0.037279583513736725, -0.05199933052062988, 0.026321515440940857, 0.025293270125985146, 0.0349242240190506, -0.053816843777894974, -0.025534318760037422, -0.044385332614183426, 0.00935051403939724, -0.03780270367860794, 0.04743468388915062, 0.006171945482492447, 0.0026173307560384274, 0.03709392994642258, -0.0027104115579277277, 0.0282277874648571, 0.052701711654663086, -0.005052486900240183, 0.05747239664196968, -0.03885715454816818, 0.010862215422093868, 0.05142856016755104, -0.010222358629107475, 0.006322025787085295, 0.03271673619747162, 0.014781313948333263, -0.041451647877693176, 0.0506419911980629, 0.012901367619633675, 0.0424085408449173, 0.005432506091892719, -0.0001521741069154814, -0.011051754467189312, -0.037748806178569794, -0.027263391762971878, 0.02851720154285431, -0.03141702339053154, -0.01610502414405346, -0.019676782190799713, -0.014882360585033894, -0.019299397245049477, -0.04332301393151283, 0.0012091667158529162, 0.024721940979361534, 0.011788945645093918, -0.022834284231066704, 0.011691857129335403, -0.04986236244440079, -0.0017535417573526502, -0.021119683980941772, 0.09873910993337631, 0.0756741315126419, 0.0385894738137722, -0.0029526622965931892, -0.01396222598850727, -0.013549163937568665, -0.04216865450143814, -0.0061891512013971806, 0.020033735781908035, -0.006487640086561441, -0.006520567461848259, 0.006519791670143604, 0.0138108404353261, -0.03301925212144852, 0.04474908858537674, 0.00817476212978363, -0.03614263981580734, -0.011752522550523281, -0.09938586503267288, -0.0026068477891385555, 0.027023259550333023, -0.02945614606142044, -0.009089801460504532, -0.04008106514811516, 0.0042957463301718235, 0.004592181649059057, 0.031304847449064255, 0.020670123398303986, 0.048386070877313614, 0.021790893748402596, 0.018057668581604958, 0.006334786769002676, -0.03272032365202904, -0.011875553987920284, -0.06469202041625977, -0.002534137573093176, -0.029056498780846596, -0.0678413137793541, -0.01216420903801918, 0.01839401014149189, -0.01122051477432251, 0.03080114535987377, 0.020597437396645546, 0.017247891053557396, -0.001870686304755509, -0.03124331496655941, -0.007678652182221413, 0.0009587130625732243, 0.01366257295012474, -0.009910272434353828, 0.015368144027888775, -0.000618285033851862, -0.038863684982061386, -0.010252721607685089, -0.016719836741685867, 0.055767688900232315, 0.05367289111018181, -0.03737529739737511, -0.00046406773617491126, 0.00538482703268528, 0.04258272796869278, -0.000005620493539026938, -0.014877261593937874, -0.05262593924999237, 0.000023069544113241136, -0.023409491404891014, 0.026623226702213287, 0.051444895565509796, -0.019128721207380295, 0.033566128462553024, 0.04979637637734413, -0.04512358829379082, -0.0465112142264843, -0.05144680663943291, -0.008015832863748074, 0.018269555643200874, -0.04870526120066643, 0.020829787477850914, -0.011242114938795567, 0.058401357382535934, 0.043662503361701965, -0.011189954355359077, -0.028180332854390144, -0.0052629150450229645, 0.06368929892778397, -0.029646562412381172, -0.00031587149715051055, 0.020708108320832253, 0.06335648149251938, -0.0069211069494485855, 0.04280099272727966, -0.01804671436548233, -0.022588171064853668, 0.031281907111406326, -0.02703040838241577, 0.027506453916430473, -0.004514421336352825, -0.012782185338437557, 0.008837043307721615, 0.047811899334192276, -0.06611376255750656, 0.020883934572339058, -0.027866223827004433, 0.02473044954240322, 0.07906008511781693, 0.009662587195634842, -0.01761089824140072, -0.019194580614566803, -0.012575711123645306, 0.01862666942179203, -0.057923492044210434, 0.020011207088828087, -0.045369379222393036, -0.024956433102488518, -0.004381873644888401, 0.0396362841129303, -0.022386038675904274, 0.011363482102751732, 0.04628109559416771, 0.013703367672860622, -0.010770654305815697, 0.026548925787210464, 0.023586051538586617, 0.000006043378107278841, 0.012150600552558899, 0.02105013281106949, 0.019778013229370117, 0.021227797493338585, 0.02400152198970318, 0.028941767290234566, 0.06791748106479645, 0.015005986206233501, -0.002229172270745039, 0.03992115706205368, -0.009774917736649513, -0.030185308307409286, -0.02091669663786888, -0.032811421900987625, 0.02613399736583233, -0.0011936768423765898, 0.01410093903541565, 0.044215280562639236, 0.028405645862221718, -0.024709364399313927, 0.0021116018760949373, -0.016195138916373253, -0.011307207867503166, 0.06807184219360352, -0.009594694711267948, -0.02506563626229763, 0.006217191461473703, -0.018679678440093994, 0.007398686371743679, -0.021450471132993698, 0.02234930917620659, -0.057589780539274216, 0.03712190315127373, 0.020635923370718956, -0.014817088842391968, 0.004803478252142668, -0.021292367950081825, -0.015866348519921303, 0.034710220992565155, -0.024504823610186577, 0.045822836458683014, 0.009838845580816269, -0.07638265192508698, 0.011517742648720741, -0.01123584434390068, -0.004433820024132729, 0.02696123905479908, 0.012385980226099491, -0.07218582928180695, 0.06734316051006317, -0.03638589009642601, -0.05578387528657913, -0.00035653775557875633, -0.011927744373679161, 0.02519289031624794, -0.0380200557410717, 0.01249583251774311, 0.009834771044552326, 0.004020247142761946, -0.08275700360536575, -0.043409865349531174, -0.03837886452674866, -0.023461295291781425, 0.0005907822051085532, -0.015217575244605541, 0.004949223715811968, 0.016827590763568878, 0.011576640419661999, 0.02586166001856327, -0.014381889253854752, -0.00071397062856704, -0.054719921201467514, -0.025011826306581497, 0.03004869818687439, 0.046199049800634384, -0.017914868891239166, 0.015979791060090065, 0.0004880792985204607, 0.02109173685312271, 0.004747034981846809, -0.06934864819049835, -0.06137259304523468, 0.01763438619673252, -0.0032912776805460453, -0.019197911024093628, 0.026430822908878326, -0.021226035431027412, 0.02545643411576748, 0.021544134244322777, -0.05597025528550148, 0.039945244789123535, 0.051168110221624374, -0.018688926473259926, 0.00986554566770792, 0.0037945604417473078, -0.009420313872396946, -0.009701563976705074, 0.029096312820911407, 0.0026140438858419657, -0.010926640592515469, 0.01309015229344368, 0.02902318723499775, 0.036351993680000305, -0.0018868951592594385, -0.03603760525584221, 0.027688514441251755, -0.013831689953804016, 0.03480681777000427, -0.07241696864366531, -0.005095417145639658, -0.003481941996142268, -0.014313670806586742, -0.020985344424843788, -0.010002467781305313, 0.030470162630081177, -0.02224930003285408, -0.015145646408200264, 0.0621485561132431, 0.003935057669878006, -0.013077771291136742, 0.024319903925061226, 0.006758347153663635, -0.020460572093725204, 0.03023645281791687, -0.034226223826408386, -0.02798483893275261, 0.015361521393060684, 0.06823432445526123, 0.0016938046319410205, 0.01339858490973711, -0.011052567511796951, 0.03732719644904137, -0.018066411837935448, 0.030083920806646347, -0.05816187337040901, 0.010380175895988941, 0.012474686838686466, 0.06433765590190887, 0.026466980576515198, -0.006677401252090931, -0.0017074157949537039, -0.028179392218589783, -0.04645232483744621, -0.016421619802713394, 0.025926655158400536, -0.019646378234028816, 0.003830823814496398, -0.010608429089188576, 0.02339293621480465, -0.023284753784537315, 0.01530918013304472, 0.02431911788880825, 0.018031470477581024, -0.03009241260588169, -0.013324734754860401, -0.00640033558011055, 0.020390711724758148, -0.010447212494909763, 0.029374727979302406, 0.06409422308206558, -0.03277409449219704, 0.09610836207866669, 0.020625965669751167, 0.0012403493747115135, 0.03094158135354519, -0.019257724285125732, -0.01691758818924427, 0.029707079753279686, 0.03562338650226593, 0.034544385969638824, -0.0013900325866416097, -0.019114861264824867, 0.04641317203640938, -0.01471593789756298, 0.03461113199591637, 0.07806756347417831, -0.03443865105509758, 0.013620980083942413, 0.02137058973312378, -0.010936291888356209, 0.020524675026535988, 0.008460212498903275, -0.010889198631048203, -0.017908986657857895, 0.04134146496653557, 0.03692600876092911, -0.020448539406061172, 0.017149444669485092, 0.09066116809844971, 0.028755204752087593, 0.0034113903529942036, -0.04140537977218628, -0.00907451193779707, -0.02256808802485466, -0.027309134602546692, 0.014512596651911736, 0.003964077215641737, -0.008238605223596096, 0.00007219632243504748, 0.025948168709874153, -0.02616068720817566, -0.03560716658830643, 0.012428308837115765, 0.01227273978292942, 0.02543504349887371, -0.022275110706686974, -0.03128781542181969, 0.013120006769895554, 0.03842456638813019, 0.05068785324692726, -0.023314833641052246, 0.0011643283069133759, -0.07256057858467102, 0.015139937400817871, 0.047413766384124756, 0.03882710635662079, -0.04488923028111458, -0.009684048593044281, -0.0018905254546552896, -0.011126137338578701, 0.035055071115493774, -0.023530514910817146, 0.019319595769047737, -0.017704328522086143, -0.002316378289833665, -0.0017448848811909556, -0.028439955785870552, -0.06529132276773453, 0.019715111702680588, -0.03462163358926773, 0.014346124604344368, -0.04482702165842056, 0.0026447537820786238, -0.03324479982256889, 0.011493542231619358, 0.007731059566140175, 0.01911340281367302, -0.03708374500274658, -0.014288400299847126, 0.01622535102069378, 0.014138652943074703, -0.01615612395107746, -0.036859218031167984, 0.04204662889242172, 0.005802150350064039, -0.024497801437973976, 0.049401700496673584, 0.009290624409914017, -0.003095140215009451, -0.011145672760903835, -0.0009175871964544058, 0.03441430628299713, -0.008361750282347202, -0.0057348874397575855, 0.06968993693590164, 0.0075839520432055, 0.014537770301103592, 0.058343324810266495, 0.03523847833275795, -0.011692704632878304, 0.004802965093404055, -0.061528101563453674, 0.0003103664785157889, -0.00813683494925499, -0.05578093230724335, -0.06305777281522751, -0.006494653876870871, 0.00768927251920104, 0.001405978575348854, -0.012453057803213596, 0.041437577456235886, -0.09957744926214218, 0.0017177502159029245, 0.011768549680709839, 0.009212772361934185, -0.021163374185562134, 0.008920014835894108, -0.010344954207539558, -0.004894875455647707, 0.014102057553827763, -0.016541020944714546, 0.0162032563239336, -0.032429855316877365, -0.015936104580760002, -0.015172988176345825, -0.018435601145029068, -0.01833362691104412, 0.018300989642739296, -0.009763617068529129, -0.008215521462261677, -0.031135745346546173, -0.0035664262250065804, 0.009864053688943386, 0.012381454929709435, -0.0018644504016265273, -0.04697548970580101, -0.01729944720864296, 0.04194996505975723, -0.02417665533721447, -0.004458218347281218, -0.0031492356210947037, 0.0316149964928627, -0.019090017303824425, -0.013022848404943943, -0.03534343093633652, -0.021777695044875145, 0.0019149566069245338, -0.0029714854899793863, -0.06953820586204529, -0.02802419476211071, -0.028082063421607018, 0.0073309834115207195, 0.040269941091537476, -0.0006038529681973159, 0.007573059760034084, -0.0012917834101244807, 0.03150356560945511, 0.062044497579336166, 0.033106766641139984, 0.05106659606099129, -0.02094387076795101, 0.026217294856905937, -0.0022647050209343433, 0.01410328783094883, -0.008551510982215405, 0.020381299778819084, -0.017302246764302254, -0.014063570648431778, 0.002138920594006777, -0.006079419981688261, 0.023561013862490654, 0.053649064153432846, 0.01350020058453083, 0.017019769176840782, -0.061807580292224884, -0.03541738912463188, 0.003777560777962208, -0.031909551471471786, 0.0006460898439399898, -0.014997590333223343, -0.0033946139737963676, -0.01903078705072403, 0.02348206751048565, -0.03948812559247017, 0.005833788774907589, -0.01342936884611845, -0.004827939439564943, -0.00918026827275753, 0.007649277802556753, 0.06577452272176743, -0.012530182488262653, 0.02049676887691021, 0.0034091281704604626, -0.028287716209888458, 0.03023763746023178, 0.06954953074455261, 0.004688350483775139, -0.015260539948940277, 0.011730101890861988, -0.0011685180943459272, -0.027613386511802673, -0.04228172078728676, -0.0032657028641551733, 0.08323260396718979, 0.006277077831327915, 0.020210769027471542, 0.0358007587492466, 0.04238825663924217, 0.007191559765487909, -0.057349562644958496, -0.029939251020550728, 0.01994066685438156, 0.039101485162973404, 0.06506086140871048, -0.03157910704612732, -0.004574911203235388, 0.025203129276633263, 0.014175120741128922, 0.036973997950553894, 0.06157796457409859, -0.007446408271789551, 0.006806692108511925, 0.00104437954723835, -0.0033269450068473816, -0.03337784856557846, 0.033393919467926025, -0.021414754912257195, -0.03040335327386856, -0.02576897293329239, -0.05345587432384491, 0.026080328971147537, 0.036146823316812515, -0.010699561797082424, -0.07114899903535843, -0.051807649433612823, -0.02952256053686142, 0.00784938782453537, 0.04746263101696968, -0.020538264885544777, 0.027466213330626488, -0.018837712705135345, 0.03627137839794159, -0.006605673581361771, 0.0479767806828022, -0.013038736768066883, -0.0828859731554985, -0.05057188868522644, -0.013093953020870686, -0.04490234702825546, 0.05017316713929176, 0.011166535317897797, -0.016486460343003273, 0.012660867534577847, -0.02715335413813591, 0.03593193739652634, 0.01303950697183609, 0.04422849044203758, 0.019706187769770622, 0.028680352494120598, -0.00018732807075139135, -0.0032614273950457573, 0.016586244106292725, 0.004392346367239952, 0.15676729381084442, 0.05114135518670082, 0.021787315607070923, -0.06245766207575798, 0.001984221860766411, 0.013076585717499256, -0.01701708324253559, -0.00925435684621334, -0.005570441950112581, -0.0036304034292697906, -0.051219359040260315, 0.03554100543260574, 0.09012352675199509, 0.031188417226076126, 0.018908794969320297, 0.032260097563266754, -0.04356022924184799, -0.0116844791918993, -0.026123572140932083, 0.006355538032948971, -0.035829246044158936, -0.038920823484659195, -0.02851513959467411, -0.014988504350185394, 0.04851493611931801, 0.001645693089812994, -0.027956517413258553, 0.016161922365427017, -0.012503077276051044, -0.0017700886819511652, -0.023135321214795113, 0.02777392603456974, 0.0018243890954181552, 0.02211705967783928, 0.034887418150901794, -0.008175339549779892, 0.06168094649910927, -0.04806893318891525, 0.03143765777349472, 0.021360548213124275, 0.002624330809339881, 0.019807081669569016, -0.019732827320694923, 0.024905137717723846, -0.014680181629955769, -0.046590108424425125, -0.02418346330523491, 0.01270315982401371, -0.008827904239296913, 0.006259600166231394, -0.015157269313931465, -0.0010783188045024872, 0.005917890463024378, -0.04736924543976784, -0.016106439754366875, 0.03012792393565178, 0.014924789778888226, -0.0253402478992939, -0.009344297461211681, -0.021461013704538345, -0.004803253337740898, -0.007124252151697874, 0.029240921139717102, 0.033166468143463135, -0.004270567093044519, 0.010530874133110046, -0.055014170706272125, 0.05239230766892433, 0.010859482921659946, 0.027263304218649864, 0.008308373391628265, 0.008898574858903885, -0.03896981105208397, -0.04243718460202217, 0.01946263387799263, 0.009763703681528568, 0.025211287662386894, -0.007941384799778461, -0.030976420268416405, 0.0028314560186117887, 0.0019457543967291713, -0.0274676401168108, -0.02563517354428768, -0.0308460034430027, -0.01130514033138752, 0.01538809109479189, 0.02912735939025879, 0.02143682911992073, 0.020276989787817, 0.02827189303934574, -0.010168728418648243, 0.052249111235141754, -0.00420988118276, -0.021355874836444855, -0.030894091352820396, 0.031035080552101135, -0.039140231907367706, -0.006055604200810194, -0.011163860559463501, 0.02211027219891548, 0.03356734663248062, 0.008860421366989613, -0.05031859874725342, 0.033426620066165924, 0.0023397994227707386, 0.023370958864688873, 0.062374480068683624, -0.018296940252184868, 0.0433197021484375, 0.008660714142024517, 0.0008053351775743067, -0.06458498537540436, -0.017832299694418907, -0.046080853790044785, -0.030374007299542427, 0.014752546325325966, 0.0014133201912045479, -0.042904097586870193, -0.017528438940644264, 0.016037454828619957, 0.007022951263934374, -0.022070767357945442, -0.0024426900781691074, -0.013428322039544582, 0.025115566328167915, -0.003247062675654888, 0.00865203607827425, -0.03579474613070488, 0.039144594222307205, -0.06363479048013687, 0.011308418586850166, 0.016256410628557205, 0.03473424166440964, 0.0292933601886034, -0.04207262024283409, 0.013439994305372238, 0.00527293561026454, 0.08395971357822418, 0.03039911948144436, -0.02842111699283123, -0.00218766531907022, -0.07063350081443787, -0.04547406733036041, 0.0026386308018118143, -0.00021365765132941306, 0.039249345660209656, 0.0053057377226650715, 0.007836837321519852, -0.03371867164969444, 0.05044605955481529, -0.024830274283885956, 0.008361256681382656, -0.02721525728702545, 0.020729031413793564, -0.009653150103986263, 0.021803485229611397, -0.026269277557730675, -0.008681980893015862, -0.03979361057281494, 0.00607701763510704, 0.058200184255838394, -0.006463486235588789, -0.013034514151513577, -0.008246462792158127, -0.02613510563969612, 0.016711775213479996, 0.011141194961965084, -0.030993381515145302, 0.007183735258877277, 0.05136383697390556, -0.00859874952584505, 0.04562728479504585, -0.001312585431151092, 0.005877492483705282, -0.10456609725952148, -0.030665269121527672, 0.0036410526372492313, 0.020740361884236336, 0.005139383487403393, -0.04329333081841469, 0.004516499117016792, 0.01206811424344778, -0.0779740959405899, 0.033796366304159164, 0.03616151958703995, -0.008728048764169216, 0.015524549409747124, 0.06711523979902267, -0.001535348012112081, 0.03018300049006939, 0.01858389936387539, -0.02331094816327095, 0.028574004769325256, 0.017563721165060997, -0.004505131859332323, -0.03259431943297386, -0.05122159793972969, 0.0030323676764965057, -0.006394155323505402, -0.026320191100239754, 0.036809418350458145, -0.024083152413368225, -0.015678178519010544, -0.04687749594449997, -0.023678353056311607, 0.027397936210036278, 0.022857435047626495, 0.04290584847331047, 0.031635746359825134, 0.04857178032398224, 0.005474649835377932, 0.01468458492308855, 0.00728479353711009, 0.009121192619204521, -0.03624069690704346, -0.0012312857434153557, -0.03773846849799156, 0.034537430852651596, 0.00919452216476202, 0.022244751453399658, -0.044233813881874084, -0.03228866308927536, -0.02933107130229473, -0.017224302515387535, -0.020262327045202255, 0.01729987934231758, -0.009781289845705032, -0.04111449792981148, 0.018852580338716507, -0.06625474989414215, -0.02068369649350643, 0.035841990262269974, 0.012981749139726162, -0.01177875604480505, 0.008777488954365253, -0.030155081301927567, -0.041205573827028275, -0.004288236610591412, 0.022775905206799507, -0.0031081554479897022, -0.05288461223244667, -0.023547761142253876, 0.017256371676921844, -0.03701186552643776, 0.017300711944699287, -0.02194860577583313, -0.0031468956731259823, 0.03637360781431198, -0.02574518322944641, -0.01619367115199566, 0.028342414647340775, -0.008146901614964008, 0.011470139026641846, -0.09059374034404755, 0.017142292112112045, -0.0020410208962857723, 0.001970775192603469, -0.022223955020308495, -0.021947648376226425, -0.04055529087781906, 0.05698974058032036, 0.016794482246041298, -0.0009360710973851383, 0.03764728456735611, -0.007456280291080475, 0.011090582236647606, -0.0004665780870709568, -0.07519876956939697, 0.05933002009987831, 0.014480453915894032, 0.01720740646123886, -0.00891601201146841, 0.006128856446594, -0.0009138583554886281, -0.020858649164438248, -0.023500489071011543, -0.039851658046245575, -0.016526835039258003, -0.03140821307897568, -0.030133044347167015, 0.028321649879217148, -0.02322080172598362, -0.009272566996514797, 0.027431707829236984, -0.02377629652619362, 0.011812633834779263, 0.06392458081245422, 0.037904027849435806, -0.014211229979991913, 0.007029261440038681, -0.03299340978264809, -0.03565092384815216, 0.034742556512355804, 0.04047326371073723, 0.0032234080135822296, -0.0820779874920845, 0.05204382538795471, 0.01616978459060192, -0.044641658663749695, 0.010871276259422302, 0.028957461938261986, -0.015272285789251328, 0.010717079043388367, -0.023076200857758522, 0.031571198254823685, -0.005513681564480066, -0.05762224644422531, 0.03558994084596634, 0.02311640791594982, 0.0357414074242115, 0.016483834013342857, -0.011305946856737137, 0.050709180533885956, -0.024075116962194443, 0.024372350424528122, -0.031688570976257324, 0.07773596793413162, -0.00010260640556225553, -0.013024642132222652, 0.0036933778319507837, -0.02477692998945713, 0.024602610617876053, -0.04272078722715378, 0.0001451419375371188, 0.04042813181877136, -0.04359450936317444, 0.038695234805345535, -0.014924478717148304, -0.006726932246237993, -0.04339015111327171, -0.0005246559157967567, -0.010846863500773907, 0.03348065912723541, -0.02098841592669487, 0.02377130836248398, 0.0008795019239187241, -0.03382492437958717, -0.005840540863573551, -0.025990255177021027, 0.016961723566055298, -0.00018396890664007515, 0.03336581960320473, 0.000080853198596742, 0.008674007840454578, -0.023749737069010735, 0.0032739557791501284, 0.039345189929008484, 0.002345177112147212, 0.0067534735426306725, -0.059343088418245316, -0.00858708843588829, -0.013298300094902515, 0.04350395128130913, -0.012625482864677906, -0.025894053280353546, -0.027051521465182304, 0.03986164927482605, -0.013977865688502789, 0.005968186538666487 ]
<p>I have a training set with 4 different 3D position vectors as some of the features. I have defined a new 3D coordinate system based on the first 3 of these position vectors to achieve translational and rotational invariance. Then transformed the original points to this new system. Since the last point also originally resides in the same coordinate system, I have transformed that one also. To explain the situation better:</p> <p>Training data was before (Here assume first 3 vectors are used to describe the new coordinate system and $(x_s,y_s,z_s)$ is the last position vector which will also be converted):</p> <p>$x_1, y_1, z_1, x_2, y_2, z_2, x_3, y_3, z_3, x_s, y_s, z_s\ldots$ (and other features)</p> <p>Applying my coordinate system transformation it became</p> <p>$x_{t1}, x_{t2}, z_{t2}, x_{t3}, x_{ts}, y_{ts}, z_{ts}\ldots$ (and other features)</p> <p>Number of features decreased in the second case because in the new coordinate system some values are always zero ($y_{t1},y_{t2},z_{t1}$ etc) or equal to another value ($z_{t2} = -z_{t3}$)</p> <p>The new features are not in similar value ranges, generally $x_{ts}, y_{ts}, z_{ts}$ are much larger than the others $x_{t1}, z_{t2}$ etc. So I want to introduce normalization, but at the same time I don't want to lose semantic relation between the points described in the same new coordinate system.</p> <p>How should I do it? My initial thought is to look at min-max values of all $x_{t1}, x_{t2}, z_{t2}, x_{t3}, x_{ts}, y_{ts}, z_{ts}$ features and apply min-max normalization with same paramaters to each of them. So $z_{ts}$ for example will be much larger than $x_{t1}$ even after normalization. Does it make sense to do so?</p>
43,892
[ -0.0014489766908809543, 0.017156871035695076, -0.006092774216085672, -0.0002546484174672514, 0.033719923347234726, 0.0191476009786129, -0.04801059141755104, -0.06221938133239746, 0.00805369671434164, -0.01907079853117466, 0.014247950166463852, -0.0075765675865113735, 0.005114031955599785, 0.012193424627184868, 0.009663035161793232, -0.012032948434352875, -0.03377338871359825, -0.01988290436565876, -0.03133579343557358, -0.02686816267669201, 0.022232212126255035, 0.005228047724813223, 0.041994959115982056, -0.007972965016961098, -0.018055155873298645, 0.005359155125916004, -0.0034105200320482254, -0.042153965681791306, -0.0007114806212484837, 0.05691538006067276, -0.031007008627057076, -0.026165233924984932, -0.000488312158267945, 0.020521406084299088, 0.017651580274105072, 0.02850985713303089, -0.003176244208589196, -0.008399812504649162, 0.01587081328034401, 0.023396965116262436, -0.03432781621813774, 0.006335671525448561, -0.014998510479927063, 0.06443725526332855, 0.019273681566119194, 0.011943920515477657, -0.033747635781764984, 0.01813391037285328, -0.016920622438192368, -0.02618802711367607, 0.0917283147573471, 0.01596532203257084, 0.008302311412990093, 0.01240736898034811, -0.0027559115551412106, -0.01808949187397957, 0.06667952239513397, 0.013437647372484207, -0.01015886478126049, -0.0664530023932457, 0.009761941619217396, -0.067344069480896, -0.003066794481128454, -0.012688235379755497, 0.008390776813030243, 0.022388027980923653, 0.005027359817177057, 0.019370736554265022, 0.017957255244255066, -0.0634632483124733, 0.03344249352812767, 0.025935659185051918, 0.024269241839647293, -0.04658501595258713, 0.003498667851090431, -0.0030061188153922558, 0.026930317282676697, 0.0328536294400692, 0.03651530295610428, 0.0007578308577649295, 0.028921063989400864, 0.00611544493585825, -0.010619224049150944, 0.015644896775484085, 0.016033416613936424, -0.021841799840331078, 0.06986302882432938, -0.017761200666427612, 0.04305359348654747, 0.05142246559262276, -0.006193902809172869, -0.017690986394882202, 0.04333405941724777, -0.04440569877624512, -0.028664670884609222, 0.025856338441371918, 0.022900162264704704, 0.019891507923603058, -0.006031713914126158, -0.02039647102355957, 0.002684718929231167, -0.05816946178674698, -0.05703410506248474, 0.025880668312311172, 0.0070649427361786366, 0.032831981778144836, -0.007060902193188667, -0.0241407360881567, -0.01884661801159382, -0.02592889778316021, -0.008043034933507442, 0.0309442225843668, -0.0022313580848276615, 0.02721920609474182, 0.016733257099986076, -0.00427018478512764, 0.015863638371229172, -0.025902841240167618, 0.016863372176885605, 0.06345944851636887, 0.012313393875956535, -0.04684412479400635, 0.00732782855629921, -0.014077870175242424, -0.050326742231845856, -0.0022622854448854923, 0.006437721196562052, 0.01799614168703556, -0.012301460839807987, -0.007928267121315002, 0.019142793491482735, -0.01160120964050293, 0.035345111042261124, -0.028409233316779137, 0.01903305947780609, 0.03564135730266571, -0.06303834915161133, -0.030724981799721718, 0.03841766342520714, -0.013120612129569054, 0.022071897983551025, -0.060841139405965805, 0.0011418667854741216, 0.02313738875091076, 0.031655870378017426, 0.021385395899415016, 0.017392339184880257, 0.057688262313604355, 0.05114667862653732, -0.015656786039471626, 0.017964709550142288, 0.003806344699114561, -0.044923242181539536, -0.02616913802921772, -0.04111387953162193, -0.05676225200295448, 0.03216111660003662, 0.029721872881054878, -0.0035136081278324127, 0.0016228159656748176, 0.017385920509696007, -0.01106218434870243, 0.005524074658751488, 0.021229570731520653, 0.022892368957400322, 0.011186611838638783, 0.008860773406922817, -0.01965455338358879, 0.028843626379966736, 0.01628059521317482, 0.007446971721947193, 0.005059096496552229, -0.007136836647987366, 0.0563640221953392, 0.05595136433839798, -0.018816184252500534, -0.016659649088978767, -0.02113690786063671, -0.012425948865711689, 0.02213490568101406, -0.026814989745616913, -0.04166346788406372, -0.018460188060998917, 0.020736046135425568, 0.02630283497273922, 0.06164270266890526, -0.026272181421518326, -0.029525985941290855, 0.03307786211371422, -0.06893128901720047, 0.008238906040787697, -0.0462663508951664, -0.005883030127733946, -0.04433467611670494, -0.01345809269696474, 0.055787812918424606, 0.005618484225124121, 0.01942153461277485, -0.012887880206108093, -0.002253812737762928, -0.02566596493124962, -0.0051375641487538815, 0.060382090508937836, -0.035555221140384674, 0.014272112399339676, 0.07412625104188919, 0.03974660485982895, 0.0025233987253159285, -0.0006889362121000886, -0.006463434547185898, -0.005436059087514877, 0.0289041455835104, 0.005005614832043648, -0.006949544418603182, -0.012137995101511478, -0.006266772281378508, 0.007111730519682169, 0.020090878009796143, -0.04456046596169472, 0.000984493992291391, -0.0712142139673233, 0.05823149159550667, 0.07127313315868378, -0.05872461199760437, 0.026503322646021843, 0.01314688753336668, 0.009389949031174183, 0.047465600073337555, 0.033469345420598984, -0.023781422525644302, -0.05080518499016762, -0.048834048211574554, 0.03895009681582451, 0.07216712832450867, -0.07876334339380264, -0.032287370413541794, 0.05402201786637306, 0.018178826197981834, 0.024712463840842247, 0.010444993153214455, -0.0021889035124331713, -0.028163427487015724, 0.04365243762731552, -0.009209678508341312, 0.020574435591697693, -0.001042350078932941, 0.006939096376299858, -0.004749099723994732, 0.02597784623503685, 0.02310818061232567, -0.017550714313983917, 0.0175528135150671, 0.03952531889081001, 0.004924238659441471, -0.0054409438744187355, 0.0022980784997344017, -0.006619131192564964, -0.010312228463590145, -0.01974768005311489, 0.04345446079969406, -0.0062455362640321255, -0.0043066744692623615, -0.03301139548420906, 0.011954538524150848, 0.0028801688458770514, 0.04993375763297081, 0.010279917158186436, 0.022185316309332848, 0.0057402681559324265, -0.07359578460454941, 0.007975528948009014, -0.009905724786221981, -0.05559520050883293, -0.05435299128293991, 0.00021388483582995832, 0.07752951234579086, 0.016529630869627, -0.0005652435356751084, -0.04640723764896393, 0.004500756971538067, -0.0009745119605213404, 0.038043081760406494, 0.021211806684732437, 0.0434112474322319, -0.04644728824496269, -0.006982860155403614, -0.03016000986099243, -0.038247838616371155, 0.019824562594294548, -0.008233839645981789, 0.024651244282722473, 0.0459725596010685, 0.0003453192475717515, -0.03661827743053436, -0.04942640662193298, -0.031414762139320374, 0.03698444738984108, 0.014289802871644497, -0.007349656894803047, 0.08191628009080887, 0.010098613798618317, -0.0931314006447792, -0.011479984037578106, -0.01901165209710598, -0.023434722796082497, -0.029444411396980286, -0.009603956714272499, 0.004545154049992561, -0.038085345178842545, 0.007275027222931385, 0.030570868402719498, -0.018025482073426247, 0.03894013538956642, -0.032606061547994614, -0.0448770634829998, 0.011385231278836727, -0.0037872062530368567, 0.06074213609099388, 0.012275772169232368, -0.019879667088389397, 0.10411418974399567, 0.036984942853450775, -0.022798605263233185, -0.025731954723596573, 0.04279003664851189, -0.019662799313664436, -0.027183396741747856, 0.010473953559994698, 0.01139847096055746, 0.039004065096378326, 0.013529568910598755, 0.01538797002285719, 0.050108157098293304, 0.06120433658361435, -0.015830110758543015, 0.025021454319357872, -0.0007608759333379567, 0.041076548397541046, 0.002674510469660163, 0.005820096470415592, 0.020968034863471985, -0.016630880534648895, 0.01880468986928463, 0.018524499610066414, 0.016547854989767075, -0.0023361281491816044, -0.05709494277834892, 0.0054635475389659405, -0.012987363152205944, 0.030867816880345345, -0.009264431893825531, 0.032981593161821365, 0.0025481656193733215, -0.03137156367301941, -0.042784448713064194, 0.06008033826947212, 0.016326215118169785, -0.021908629685640335, -0.015782859176397324, 0.0372559130191803, 0.013832500204443932, -0.027794187888503075, 0.009236722253262997, -0.0027677377220243216, -0.031271062791347504, 0.03278627619147301, 0.0019458516035228968, -0.018731949850916862, 0.013964125886559486, 0.034296076744794846, 0.020906874909996986, 0.022816192358732224, 0.007284354418516159, 0.011269626207649708, -0.006121505983173847, 0.012224446050822735, 0.009987367317080498, 0.049121733754873276, -0.012515759095549583, 0.02365211769938469, 0.03275158628821373, -0.0012110265670344234, 0.0016382044414058328, 0.020900605246424675, -0.07600750029087067, 0.031481966376304626, 0.0057952809147536755, 0.006321026477962732, -0.007956065237522125, -0.034550171345472336, 0.03635381907224655, -0.059128452092409134, -0.004663294181227684, -0.0010623810812830925, 0.030142098665237427, -0.06036105379462242, 0.03491368889808655, -0.012317358516156673, -0.008409923873841763, -0.028097277507185936, 0.07531623542308807, 0.040855392813682556, -0.02518509142100811, 0.02378782443702221, 0.03494108095765114, -0.01110022235661745, -0.0015741890529170632, -0.02501455694437027, 0.043621860444545746, 0.030469320714473724, 0.031023696064949036, 0.01082452479749918, 0.028629671782255173, -0.008850009180605412, 0.009175103157758713, -0.0274745412170887, 0.046910613775253296, 0.03762579336762428, 0.001194847747683525, -0.01610306091606617, -0.06422147154808044, -0.012157549150288105, 0.008942187763750553, 0.052701059728860855, 0.020264942198991776, -0.015262112021446228, 0.02290230616927147, 0.010585404932498932, -0.026628801599144936, -0.002097324701026082, 0.05056047812104225, 0.042411983013153076, -0.03774323686957359, -0.047546643763780594, -0.015805110335350037, 0.015330906957387924, -0.01824541762471199, 0.05147669091820717, 0.0037111600395292044, -0.027763882651925087, 0.0014063355047255754, 0.033684611320495605, 0.012209989130496979, -0.06115449592471123, -0.00010507836122997105, -0.005872153677046299, 0.02179347723722458, 0.020355671644210815, 0.010439598001539707, 0.004102128557860851, -0.014246981590986252, 0.0664575845003128, -0.011510806158185005, -0.011486035771667957, -0.09486112743616104, 0.0022804471664130688, 0.018464507535099983, 0.03199801221489906, -0.005728887394070625, 0.00387442484498024, -0.016034463420510292, -0.029867345467209816, 0.029427533969283104, -0.01340179517865181, 0.043116018176078796, 0.015396797098219395, -0.02905793860554695, -0.06543315947055817, -0.039540112018585205, -0.05776617303490639, 0.010743777267634869, -0.05037834122776985, 0.04093465209007263, -0.01993953250348568, 0.004174965433776379, -0.02213287726044655, -0.028027689084410667, -0.009600634686648846, 0.03441096097230911, 0.00550089729949832, -0.010585528798401356, 0.001714885700494051, 0.0432763546705246, -0.000774826155975461, -0.052620451897382736, 0.0334022082388401, 0.06804972141981125, -0.00772450678050518, 0.04344457760453224, -0.028747819364070892, -0.03113206848502159, 0.034642089158296585, -0.002156464383006096, -0.0011163930175825953, 0.003570078406482935, -0.02002560719847679, 0.039622560143470764, 0.024496925994753838, -0.021224087104201317, 0.040524549782276154, 0.014857901260256767, 0.0074324822053313255, -0.00013533719175029546, -0.03624546527862549, 0.023128174245357513, -0.025722919031977654, -0.033799946308135986, -0.04633733630180359, 0.033396344631910324, 0.0053464313969016075, 0.06177232414484024, -0.04676971212029457, 0.028173837810754776, -0.03361974656581879, 0.008580380119383335, 0.01923934929072857, 0.023108050227165222, -0.030995607376098633, -0.030184965580701828, -0.020946402102708817, 0.019848166033625603, -0.017438838258385658, -0.016565531492233276, -0.022913753986358643, -0.023415157571434975, -0.009922153316438198, 0.020215189084410667, -0.030126098543405533, 0.006205808836966753, -0.016300594434142113, 0.0102209048345685, -0.0027658056933432817, -0.03001546673476696, 0.001596952322870493, 0.018971078097820282, -0.0021202932111918926, 0.02679445594549179, -0.0004399601020850241, 0.010218853130936623, 0.00046676344936713576, 0.018232254311442375, 0.00886626448482275, -0.05645374953746796, -0.002483225893229246, -0.009021858684718609, 0.06791404634714127, -0.05880093201994896, -0.02379991114139557, 0.015991948544979095, 0.009235533885657787, -0.011464607901871204, -0.05532412603497505, -0.01368242409080267, 0.0018064012983813882, -0.029009900987148285, -0.01837385818362236, 0.057197343558073044, -0.051638636738061905, -0.007880431599915028, 0.018132736906409264, -0.009806196205317974, 0.05437283217906952, -0.044334977865219116, 0.033549461513757706, 0.013063955120742321, 0.02328621782362461, 0.01671913079917431, 0.01959952898323536, 0.0003581952478270978, -0.02836092934012413, -0.012045050039887428, -0.02783723548054695, 0.0039817714132368565, 0.0033089322969317436, 0.01665419153869152, -0.025944583117961884, -0.028963904827833176, -0.025745168328285217, -0.016792796552181244, -0.03794727474451065, -0.04502129182219505, -0.007000668905675411, -0.01908479630947113, -0.024573370814323425, 0.03388386219739914, 0.0020967195741832256, -0.013762555085122585, 0.009508095681667328, 0.004478585906326771, -0.012842700816690922, -0.02718745358288288, 0.03232691064476967, 0.010859954170882702, 0.024613387882709503, -0.02342759259045124, -0.028974246233701706, 0.08087444305419922, 0.03449529409408569, -0.007179092615842819, 0.009130040183663368, 0.001773316995240748, -0.021021787077188492, 0.019184811040759087, -0.06756670027971268, -0.010000818409025669, 0.08984540402889252, -0.001848050975240767, 0.07132191210985184, 0.04147651791572571, -0.0008223361219279468, -0.0022923743817955256, -0.02604898251593113, 0.017525088042020798, 0.03291258215904236, -0.03078867867588997, 0.01793607324361801, -0.001193815958686173, -0.004018134903162718, -0.0024350101593881845, 0.025989126414060593, -0.0003521665057633072, 0.045296210795640945, -0.02710454910993576, -0.009302417747676373, 0.011977090500295162, -0.08434181660413742, -0.05762644112110138, 0.02691562846302986, -0.021102681756019592, 0.0023950068280100822, 0.02629079297184944, -0.02543105185031891, 0.0261335838586092, 0.03317192196846008, 0.03601233661174774, -0.04619123786687851, -0.036864668130874634, -0.055807940661907196, 0.04589587077498436, 0.01609775796532631, -0.056449808180332184, 0.01650259643793106, 0.011519324034452438, 0.04579045996069908, -0.012483044527471066, -0.0056115444749593735, -0.04701070114970207, -0.06026234105229378, 0.008119124919176102, -0.03713137283921242, -0.017560334876179695, 0.046362411230802536, -0.009218450635671616, -0.007083904929459095, -0.022605285048484802, -0.02809455245733261, 0.035289790481328964, -0.015245930291712284, 0.029681598767638206, -0.0289560928940773, 0.04347587749361992, 0.009517023339867592, 0.035279761999845505, 0.0007994275074452162, 0.006777268368750811, 0.1144079938530922, 0.08242848515510559, 0.02126501128077507, -0.03556700795888901, 0.039034534245729446, 0.016324952244758606, -0.017551397904753685, -0.04453730583190918, 0.04183404520153999, 0.043948713690042496, 0.006555871106684208, -0.03647445887327194, 0.007219323422759771, 0.01531515084207058, -0.02616957761347294, 0.05254000797867775, -0.05607086047530174, 0.0013229168253019452, -0.0019589154981076717, 0.02300145849585533, -0.007944050244987011, -0.015998758375644684, -0.048731107264757156, 0.013723679818212986, -0.04855688661336899, 0.007015137933194637, -0.024843577295541763, -0.004421031102538109, 0.00226003210991621, -0.013220362365245819, -0.03409751504659653, 0.010089647956192493, 0.01972014270722866, 0.012600072659552097, -0.024936864152550697, 0.014335939660668373, -0.003288596635684371, -0.01150086522102356, 0.022410651668906212, 0.0369461290538311, -0.0028974239248782396, -0.002518459688872099, 0.014061413705348969, -0.012440127320587635, -0.03437181934714317, -0.03778816759586334, -0.050425656139850616, 0.06068522855639458, -0.01902000419795513, 0.015628984197974205, 0.007765396498143673, 0.040799494832754135, 0.010774617083370686, -0.051331985741853714, 0.013677028007805347, 0.026491263881325722, 0.01367122121155262, 0.022220995277166367, 0.013705199584364891, -0.001954889390617609, 0.025174470618367195, 0.02547977678477764, 0.035146430134773254, -0.004080566111952066, 0.013001274317502975, -0.0013062026118859649, -0.01358888577669859, 0.06599506735801697, 0.004256412852555513, 0.017971158027648926, -0.026247570291161537, -0.0266621895134449, 0.01319112442433834, -0.04473324492573738, 0.025247128680348396, -0.03002430498600006, 0.030941395089030266, 0.011182376183569431, -0.013644580729305744, -0.05840928852558136, -0.03896470367908478, -0.014918637461960316, -0.004915524739772081, 0.017150964587926865, -0.017343971878290176, 0.013933571055531502, 0.016929248347878456, 0.06167754903435707, -0.008145519532263279, 0.009489431045949459, -0.010076906532049179, 0.039257314056158066, 0.035122279077768326, -0.021106423810124397, -0.016247985884547234, 0.0012001413851976395, -0.04514103755354881, 0.020047880709171295, -0.03993584215641022, 0.057270560413599014, 0.0439537838101387, 0.03765498474240303, 0.015182185918092728, 0.04673134908080101, -0.017513850703835487, -0.006326578091830015, 0.011907491832971573, -0.016322243958711624, 0.011169955134391785, 0.035619791597127914, 0.005619408562779427, -0.0342889167368412, 0.01645897515118122, 0.004854113794863224, -0.037212345749139786, 0.03975467383861542, 0.0023059207014739513, -0.019512677565217018, -0.006000865716487169, -0.018765738233923912, 0.004345667082816362, 0.008361950516700745, -0.025988925248384476, -0.022978680208325386, 0.036811795085668564, -0.027766020968556404, -0.00732871750369668, -0.022894220426678658, -0.003456873819231987, 0.008523051626980305, -0.014926502481102943, 0.019994530826807022, 0.007860636338591576, 0.0006208921549841762, -0.04261371120810509, -0.03680235147476196, 0.011506758630275726, 0.028099048882722855, -0.003030915278941393, -0.007206642534583807, -0.022981736809015274, -0.012951847165822983, 0.009776534512639046, 0.013355549424886703, -0.00900332536548376, 0.036628320813179016, -0.001141449436545372, -0.022258305922150612, -0.035833559930324554, 0.041331592947244644, 0.011138983070850372, 0.0016847379738464952, -0.03134101629257202, -0.0005925347795709968, -0.017775895074009895, 0.008266612887382507, 0.050141774117946625, -0.012072117999196053, -0.040079496800899506, -0.01612061820924282, 0.05352400615811348, -0.02505454793572426, -0.016818685457110405, 0.007329238578677177, -0.011148374527692795, -0.02657310850918293, 0.007019547745585442, -0.010163841769099236, 0.05863497406244278, 0.0487881563603878, -0.02624107338488102, -0.009209144860506058, 0.020399361848831177, 0.0296154972165823, -0.10167383402585983, -0.010599269531667233, 0.04117630049586296, -0.00279087177477777, 0.012182827107608318, -0.058021169155836105, -0.004880116321146488, -0.0007506916299462318, -0.06541981548070908, 0.04290973022580147, -0.0014832543674856424, 0.006109070032835007, -0.012161950580775738, -0.023237930610775948, 0.0015448800986632705, 0.009707403369247913, 0.013573989272117615, 0.01746460609138012, -0.006891540251672268, 0.06309009343385696, -0.04950236156582832, -0.011827267706394196, -0.02077745646238327, 0.0060317073948681355, 0.03218981996178627, -0.04984133318066597, -0.0022719218395650387, -0.029524290934205055, -0.035908959805965424, 0.00007431747508235276, -0.01940310187637806, -0.023893484845757484, 0.019158897921442986, 0.036986902356147766, 0.026958376169204712, 0.026336047798395157, 0.039871394634246826, -0.005503630265593529, -0.010387873277068138, -0.0401424840092659, 0.021856561303138733, -0.0021072360686957836, -0.025781620293855667, -0.002983083948493004, -0.0016980270156636834, -0.032263725996017456, -0.025189677253365517, -0.011319308541715145, -0.04106023162603378, -0.003612049389630556, 0.011012178845703602, 0.005626634228974581, -0.010986331850290298, -0.03312253952026367, -0.01897493004798889, -0.035812441259622574, -0.007731447461992502, 0.024434195831418037, -0.00028558200574479997, 0.015010512433946133, -0.006834626663476229, -0.04172623157501221, -0.04045812040567398, 0.0023086497094482183, -0.013633711263537407, -0.015130020678043365, -0.09609409421682358, 0.012294375337660313, -0.0012914349790662527, -0.047997381538152695, -0.036037128418684006, -0.020808445289731026, -0.04555661603808403, 0.05086855962872505, 0.0013489486882463098, 0.03569189831614494, -0.019303353503346443, -0.014688296243548393, -0.013618784956634045, -0.09561644494533539, 0.034430306404829025, -0.008351610042154789, -0.054751161485910416, -0.013658720999956131, 0.005730707664042711, -0.029637664556503296, 0.06231854856014252, 0.038933221250772476, 0.031578920781612396, 0.02938860096037388, -0.028768740594387054, 0.06300897896289825, 0.05341320112347603, -0.044827014207839966, 0.0073114982806146145, 0.029647670686244965, -0.01555935200303793, 0.027794400230050087, -0.042396269738674164, 0.010497634299099445, -0.009988734498620033, -0.011880063451826572, -0.015364180319011211, 0.016894100233912468, 0.03504670411348343, 0.010253987275063992, 0.02056458219885826, -0.0037648386787623167, -0.02347365766763687, 0.035875122994184494, 0.020421970635652542, -0.014070232398808002, 0.032891083508729935, -0.004619267303496599, -0.040610089898109436, -0.04683796316385269, -0.07726521044969559, -0.011729597114026546, -0.025141263380646706, 0.02065497264266014, 0.05101568251848221, -0.029542841017246246, 0.04111485555768013, 0.040543943643569946, -0.026608619838953018, -0.031369149684906006, 0.06234615668654442, 0.027609962970018387, 0.022837599739432335, -0.008265843614935875, 0.06587199121713638, -0.007221564184874296, -0.04766188934445381, 0.07385724782943726, 0.006076732650399208, -0.010883672162890434, -0.004462303593754768, -0.0020415480248630047, 0.0010666998568922281, -0.0016337723936885595, 0.005752681754529476, 0.00017391347500961274, 0.04015849158167839, -0.018866699188947678, 0.011502078734338284, 0.05620225518941879, -0.008779204450547695, 0.009417333640158176, 0.008358564227819443, 0.016683977097272873, 0.05984055995941162, -0.01752455346286297, -0.03309953957796097, -0.05575380474328995, -0.007292140740901232, -0.03115251287817955, 0.030595241114497185, -0.01687389798462391, 0.05289217084646225, 0.011677050031721592, 0.031739383935928345, -0.026563609018921852, -0.01597246155142784, 0.010517735034227371, -0.01564936526119709, 0.01718130148947239, -0.010560308583080769, 0.020197095349431038, 0.06488204002380371, -0.003995533101260662, -0.04693746566772461, -0.032301370054483414, 0.02368558757007122, 0.04359088093042374, 0.05564946308732033, -0.02763969823718071, -0.000969443644862622, -0.04222187027335167, -0.025602761656045914, -0.03491167351603508, -0.0684082880616188, -0.009403004311025143, 0.005864847917109728, 0.001102864625863731, -0.036956787109375 ]
<p>I am trying to come up with estimates on the outcomes from a layered-earth inversion calculation whereby the calculation provides a posterior covariance matrix for the best-fitting model parameters given the data. In particular, I want to see how long a particular feature of the model persists from the surface (ie, I am looking for values $m_{i} \ge x_{0}, i=1..M$ . I believe this is a conditional probability question:</p> <ol> <li>What is probability layer 1 satisfies condition? $P(m_1 \ge x_0|m_2,...m_M, d_1,d_2,...,d_N)$</li> <li>What is probability layer 2 also satisfies condition? $P(m_2 \ge x_0|m_1 \ge x_0, m_2,...m_M, d_1,d_2,...,d_N)$</li> </ol> <p>... and so on. In this question, my model parameters are correlated through the posterior covariance matrix, and the postulate of the inversion provides me with Gaussian distribution of the parameters. I have been looking around for days how to evaluate an integral of this sort, but the best I could find was for the bivariate case where it was stated that the problem is not closed and must be evaluated numerically. I typically program in Matlab, but am happy to use any method to solve this problem. Is there anyone who can assist with this, please?</p>
73,834
[ -0.003897041082382202, -0.016524845734238625, -0.009417984634637833, -0.014014698565006256, 0.05671754106879234, 0.027928896248340607, -0.0020920350216329098, -0.05990328639745712, 0.029205024242401123, -0.03371330350637436, 0.01479812990874052, 0.0730014517903328, 0.07200933992862701, 0.03461599722504616, 0.015463870018720627, 0.016971303150057793, -0.005461792927235365, -0.02262173406779766, 0.008069226518273354, -0.023310258984565735, -0.025870922952890396, 0.013557328842580318, 0.016765983775258064, -0.007229560520499945, -0.01105490792542696, 0.03341085463762283, 0.011648047715425491, -0.04534266144037247, 0.027656154707074165, 0.07317237555980682, -0.012168101966381073, -0.029433254152536392, 0.03863159939646721, 0.06422530859708786, -0.00835796445608139, 0.015397694893181324, -0.01162481214851141, -0.044867414981126785, -0.01465774979442358, 0.05138326436281204, -0.0026813386939466, -0.04588738828897476, 0.005147716961801052, 0.04288499429821968, 0.003679727204144001, 0.03434249758720398, 0.02016362175345421, -0.02460699900984764, 0.048438794910907745, -0.029281646013259888, 0.06766998022794724, -0.003090279409661889, 0.0666365697979927, 0.029088182374835014, 0.00800804141908884, -0.02688496746122837, 0.06569508463144302, 0.07487545907497406, 0.038668688386678696, -0.059236280620098114, -0.0617615170776844, -0.03886215016245842, 0.003031233325600624, -0.02140793204307556, -0.02817438170313835, 0.027936674654483795, 0.002423020778223872, -0.015551355667412281, -0.0027607306838035583, -0.01212355773895979, -0.002619196893647313, 0.005236572120338678, 0.02748645842075348, -0.01677045039832592, 0.003778946353122592, -0.009344260208308697, 0.02658217027783394, 0.03479262441396713, 0.0037792811635881662, 0.0062312292866408825, 0.0031332275830209255, -0.00471860496327281, -0.007754183374345303, 0.05423892289400101, -0.009210222400724888, 0.0294566061347723, 0.04967590793967247, -0.012478895485401154, 0.023649727925658226, -0.008653285913169384, -0.048206131905317307, 0.011759055778384209, 0.03008549101650715, 0.007931348867714405, -0.052478618919849396, 0.0011851664166897535, 0.027248812839388847, 0.04982708394527435, -0.03709888458251953, 0.021886397153139114, -0.016082923859357834, -0.025504477322101593, 0.008875844068825245, 0.06648320704698563, 0.026420993730425835, 0.01673213392496109, 0.00023359779152087867, 0.0006417223485186696, -0.013390772044658661, -0.029472719877958298, -0.022509926930069923, 0.04620444029569626, -0.0054074497893452644, 0.018704647198319435, 0.021434564143419266, -0.038306836038827896, -0.006879604421555996, -0.03335035592317581, 0.04283103346824646, 0.06940508633852005, 0.06247393786907196, -0.011284553445875645, 0.02819373831152916, -0.0674566850066185, -0.07605607062578201, 0.0016163976397365332, 0.010769704356789589, 0.008072193711996078, -0.0458228699862957, 0.06887064129114151, 0.032033152878284454, -0.059881240129470825, 0.007566024083644152, -0.006088960915803909, 0.02161676064133644, -0.009207763709127903, -0.06765802204608917, -0.04618306830525398, 0.004532454535365105, -0.04511929303407669, 0.02380162850022316, -0.06313629448413849, 0.013352246955037117, 0.0397251732647419, 0.07195261120796204, 0.007757179439067841, 0.04690070450305939, -0.009797974489629269, 0.060863785445690155, 0.0005389139987528324, -0.046952731907367706, -0.04443064332008362, -0.03683982789516449, -0.020579611882567406, -0.04547309875488281, -0.1017327830195427, 0.022213712334632874, 0.006967912428081036, -0.04806571453809738, -0.005593419075012207, 0.06962502747774124, 0.022236431017518044, -0.005066509824246168, -0.018932124599814415, 0.013985157012939453, -0.030563276261091232, 0.06631819903850555, 0.0087666567414999, 0.024115076288580894, 0.030669711530208588, 0.016455860808491707, -0.007631095126271248, -0.012808225117623806, 0.03985294699668884, 0.03505048528313637, -0.04509728029370308, 0.03744688630104065, -0.0037956556770950556, -0.00033965116017498076, 0.01775289699435234, -0.027956519275903702, -0.007105965632945299, 0.00450827507302165, -0.03719114884734154, 0.04148128628730774, 0.018134908750653267, 0.0010281475260853767, -0.045946910977363586, 0.00734080420807004, -0.005112191662192345, -0.000938418204896152, -0.04880635067820549, 0.031884659081697464, 0.05637584254145622, -0.014291252940893173, 0.0023959032259881496, -0.0300661139190197, 0.028173772618174553, 0.004015237558633089, -0.004633800126612186, -0.04342624545097351, -0.016341721639037132, 0.01998332515358925, -0.020186148583889008, 0.015430426225066185, 0.03161744400858879, 0.04244246333837509, -0.011302861385047436, 0.03651425614953041, -0.009710986167192459, -0.022496147081255913, -0.013026917353272438, -0.029027970507740974, 0.028987085446715355, -0.019767625257372856, -0.03671524301171303, -0.01296394132077694, -0.01287761703133583, 0.02421654388308525, -0.012354095466434956, -0.044809915125370026, 0.04078555479645729, 0.07757224887609482, 0.0338267982006073, -0.008809445425868034, 0.0011592450318858027, -0.01144846435636282, 0.018215304240584373, 0.0023604249581694603, -0.03269045427441597, -0.04460390284657478, -0.005851972382515669, 0.010954846628010273, 0.029401550069451332, -0.006369621958583593, 0.03658825159072876, 0.01926359534263611, 0.0036013349890708923, 0.0007137396023608744, 0.02659798599779606, 0.009077842347323895, -0.02501058019697666, 0.013877182267606258, -0.01378050446510315, 0.004123094025999308, 0.014601655304431915, -0.01628446951508522, 0.02455887943506241, 0.017883433029055595, -0.00678251963108778, 0.0029602537397295237, 0.033909872174263, -0.0126521997153759, 0.01386876031756401, -0.06056298315525055, -0.0025655825156718493, 0.023501044139266014, -0.0033645383082330227, -0.007956493645906448, 0.043265968561172485, 0.01629742421209812, -0.022116757929325104, -0.0323997363448143, -0.001495623728260398, 0.07091749459505081, 0.009789892472326756, -0.024992620572447777, -0.035378918051719666, 0.016938060522079468, -0.008590039797127247, 0.02131037600338459, 0.0039054143708199263, -0.023184435442090034, -0.006974015850573778, 0.0008569222991354764, 0.01927994377911091, 0.00734745291993022, 0.009464510716497898, -0.0014162464067339897, -0.03404992073774338, -0.0019309247145429254, 0.019793564453721046, 0.029167117550969124, 0.006466524209827185, -0.04210038110613823, 0.004807729739695787, -0.021335911005735397, -0.008856149390339851, 0.06545812636613846, -0.017121993005275726, -0.0184493251144886, 0.0366179384291172, -0.01407754048705101, -0.06394030898809433, -0.026008008047938347, -0.01697727106511593, -0.011644519865512848, -0.03478945419192314, -0.023644810542464256, 0.03646080940961838, 0.012374983169138432, -0.013691437430679798, 0.030852388590574265, -0.043083857744932175, -0.030181029811501503, -0.03789344057440758, -0.006327263545244932, 0.011638609692454338, 0.023168815299868584, 0.03723958507180214, -0.005682532675564289, 0.002542502246797085, -0.013598655350506306, -0.052100662142038345, -0.05953468009829521, 0.055989231914281845, -0.027786990627646446, -0.0126071497797966, -0.03559473529458046, -0.0373830609023571, 0.04848279803991318, 0.05306016281247139, -0.026571938768029213, -0.007905025035142899, -0.0008715570438653231, 0.006273997947573662, 0.004146569408476353, -0.001632450264878571, -0.022351959720253944, 0.006820799317210913, 0.04736746847629547, -0.00016095385944936424, 0.028800273314118385, 0.04113711416721344, 0.0031386064365506172, 0.005276682320982218, 0.06572747230529785, -0.009573583491146564, 0.010086161084473133, 0.02278192527592182, 0.03240644186735153, 0.005616227630525827, 0.031006913632154465, -0.03670316934585571, -0.017257243394851685, 0.012577399611473083, -0.054829541593790054, 0.015175445936620235, -0.041214365512132645, -0.0008566218893975019, -0.04725039377808571, 0.06928388774394989, 0.031305428594350815, -0.017545189708471298, 0.012018677778542042, 0.05933383107185364, 0.04456277936697006, -0.013200531713664532, 0.01586219109594822, 0.03955819085240364, 0.020023465156555176, 0.009602782316505909, -0.008725343272089958, 0.008819636888802052, 0.018962150439620018, 0.014162000268697739, -0.04413369297981262, -0.04544913023710251, 0.044481560587882996, 0.018306994810700417, 0.004900588653981686, -0.01137481164187193, -0.031116481870412827, -0.002704043174162507, -0.0469120591878891, 0.006495037581771612, -0.02068750560283661, 0.05738392844796181, 0.01630599983036518, 0.0018130064709112048, 0.024048708379268646, -0.03270822390913963, 0.018712783232331276, 0.006065955851227045, -0.055805470794439316, 0.02065456472337246, -0.0004388767993077636, 0.001621317584067583, -0.018420059233903885, -0.022656014189124107, 0.0450751818716526, -0.03276858478784561, -0.0044067976996302605, 0.005092502571642399, 0.03071770630776882, -0.05974650755524635, -0.003797604236751795, -0.03931443393230438, -0.023499762639403343, -0.022582504898309708, 0.0523831732571125, 0.0005716344458051026, -0.01762312464416027, 0.03354973345994949, 0.03461883217096329, -0.03284132480621338, 0.005007895175367594, -0.009306461550295353, -0.01842781901359558, 0.017816731706261635, 0.021722078323364258, 0.016794243827462196, 0.024092605337500572, -0.01994507387280464, 0.02920173853635788, 0.007086620666086674, 0.0687469020485878, 0.04897297918796539, 0.00622196588665247, -0.00889502838253975, -0.024051610380411148, 0.021506721153855324, 0.030950285494327545, 0.022249668836593628, -0.024952158331871033, -0.004993708338588476, 0.05042627826333046, 0.02847244031727314, -0.05391325056552887, 0.0645199567079544, 0.03901568427681923, 0.0072030723094940186, 0.01956765726208687, -0.038992661982774734, -0.027233881875872612, -0.049098286777734756, -0.006514437031000853, 0.02992582879960537, -0.00370616908185184, -0.026559913530945778, -0.0463724285364151, 0.010942012071609497, 0.004726164974272251, 0.025697646662592888, 0.0030776660423725843, 0.04426001384854317, 0.04884856194257736, 0.01248315442353487, -0.02389451488852501, 0.01248082984238863, 0.04308195784687996, 0.01125497929751873, 0.02559545822441578, 0.017614444717764854, -0.06473351269960403, -0.01401559915393591, 0.051578618586063385, 0.03916701301932335, -0.016367463394999504, -0.021263308823108673, -0.07139811664819717, -0.03358209505677223, 0.024864817038178444, 0.01012409571558237, 0.006190912798047066, -0.004346663597971201, 0.013535969890654087, 0.00023120184778235853, -0.004099704325199127, -0.024117032065987587, 0.0010984089458361268, 0.0026538942474871874, 0.04026401787996292, -0.03888050094246864, -0.013034523464739323, -0.011875476688146591, 0.028861964121460915, 0.021922091022133827, 0.05331601947546005, -0.00425114156678319, -0.0033650118857622147, -0.01193074882030487, -0.007195630110800266, 0.00264483829960227, -0.04675775766372681, -0.00511645432561636, 0.005103213246911764, -0.04446647688746452, 0.057329751551151276, -0.03860844671726227, -0.04989774525165558, 0.050994887948036194, 0.01738714799284935, 0.015317382290959358, -0.006004819646477699, -0.0005133224185556173, 0.05031459406018257, -0.019962497055530548, 0.015399680472910404, 0.028925953432917595, -0.03173365071415901, -0.012639668770134449, -0.004463635850697756, -0.015760963782668114, 0.02427242510020733, -0.023956768214702606, -0.023510022088885307, -0.05850314721465111, 0.0037338254041969776, -0.03701215982437134, 0.03597867488861084, 0.0031210335437208414, 0.01796720176935196, -0.027142539620399475, -0.0031004201155155897, 0.0035969580058008432, 0.029613710939884186, -0.03523179888725281, 0.025040173903107643, 0.00872016791254282, -0.0014011577004566789, -0.010985994711518288, -0.02488693781197071, -0.005540028214454651, -0.02564035728573799, -0.010121134109795094, -0.0037403693422675133, -0.03705446422100067, -0.00214502215385437, -0.014815096743404865, -0.024966495111584663, -0.02185128442943096, -0.03111596591770649, 0.012393705546855927, 0.013314963318407536, 0.043654464185237885, 0.014614526182413101, -0.04403049126267433, 0.009797394275665283, 0.02510758303105831, 0.0012629666598513722, 0.04636246711015701, -0.040060725063085556, 0.0013777260901406407, -0.012787781655788422, 0.037702057510614395, -0.050175990909338, -0.04880240187048912, 0.013824916444718838, 0.007519746199250221, -0.05374733731150627, -0.04084761068224907, -0.009882313199341297, -0.029143190011382103, -0.023632967844605446, 0.0009990258840844035, 0.07282718271017075, -0.009303362108767033, 0.010091799311339855, 0.008534019812941551, 0.03913120552897453, 0.06595505028963089, -0.007036695722490549, 0.004273980390280485, 0.04027486592531204, -0.024337315931916237, -0.048136789351701736, -0.017410440370440483, -0.011295239441096783, -0.030775846913456917, 0.004666600842028856, -0.044990066438913345, 0.024992894381284714, 0.04577213153243065, -0.011469949036836624, -0.032809074968099594, 0.009141781367361546, -0.0015494017861783504, -0.025405630469322205, -0.0002712414716370404, -0.010182906873524189, -0.04280630126595497, 0.021162163466215134, -0.0052248830907046795, 0.0004236026725266129, -0.019423674792051315, -0.008600009605288506, -0.013644387014210224, -0.025077488273382187, -0.026018019765615463, 0.000662042002659291, 0.07282999157905579, 0.02744058519601822, -0.000986127881333232, 0.014348231256008148, 0.011249423027038574, 0.02302028425037861, 0.004722454585134983, -0.022046012803912163, 0.044595230370759964, 0.009074912406504154, -0.04764435812830925, -0.032425835728645325, -0.038741663098335266, 0.015178048051893711, 0.06560993194580078, -0.0769999697804451, 0.0483669638633728, 0.020293166860938072, 0.008229500614106655, -0.011036605574190617, -0.014726825058460236, -0.01370790135115385, -0.009264672175049782, -0.011808767914772034, 0.03532569482922554, -0.0479133240878582, -0.028210237622261047, 0.026920784264802933, 0.019179344177246094, -0.021480776369571686, 0.03569604083895683, -0.038313716650009155, 0.05751268193125725, 0.03191841393709183, -0.026156995445489883, -0.03320130333304405, 0.03734337165951729, -0.052383046597242355, -0.012857766821980476, -0.015937818214297295, -0.025829346850514412, 0.04650086537003517, 0.06911987066268921, -0.0007448288379237056, -0.01777171529829502, -0.03620627149939537, -0.05147969722747803, 0.018745839595794678, 0.04754187539219856, 0.01303867157548666, -0.013063388876616955, 0.011432533152401447, 0.014806951396167278, -0.014820722863078117, -0.013695750385522842, -0.03636964410543442, -0.1003502830862999, -0.024929216131567955, -0.029923053458333015, -0.05108802765607834, 0.04197249561548233, 0.032812077552080154, -0.016359521076083183, 0.0029364912770688534, -0.044342562556266785, 0.0036550438962876797, 0.004936765879392624, 0.009566591121256351, -0.03489705175161362, 0.12461962550878525, -0.011385040357708931, -0.0028787681367248297, -0.005699176341295242, 0.007714602164924145, 0.08986829966306686, 0.09035443514585495, 0.059982191771268845, -0.06526298820972443, 0.009924253448843956, -0.023287508636713028, -0.005186530761420727, -0.0609034039080143, 0.01179353054612875, 0.0063853636384010315, -0.03999917954206467, 0.018984956666827202, 0.0462879054248333, -0.02336501143872738, -0.00546632194891572, 0.04909300059080124, -0.021089207381010056, -0.008057096041738987, 0.021384578198194504, 0.008209269493818283, -0.05426008999347687, -0.034470126032829285, -0.04426758363842964, 0.0008278667810373008, -0.005965873599052429, -0.0034929164685308933, -0.020426129922270775, 0.007436325307935476, 0.013752907514572144, 0.010305099189281464, -0.014088146388530731, 0.011243795976042747, -0.0038255511317402124, 0.033716872334480286, 0.004516410641372204, 0.020499644801020622, 0.015955183655023575, 0.002786514814943075, 0.02340126968920231, 0.05582038685679436, -0.0003848454507533461, 0.014156989753246307, 0.01756720058619976, 0.01796663925051689, -0.02154812216758728, -0.041897132992744446, -0.043142955750226974, 0.06741625815629959, -0.020310785621404648, -0.03345091640949249, 0.013135083951056004, -0.0070298826321959496, 0.014031355269253254, -0.052800502628088, -0.014995445497334003, 0.0020834968890994787, 0.0560237392783165, 0.011618431657552719, -0.003655064385384321, 0.006090719718486071, 0.023240812122821808, 0.022448431700468063, 0.012748559936881065, -0.001726625021547079, -0.0466272197663784, -0.02506597526371479, -0.014970340766012669, 0.07516493648290634, 0.0030984398908913136, -0.020344942808151245, -0.016390008851885796, -0.05964505299925804, -0.033772923052310944, -0.004418004769831896, 0.013499930500984192, -0.03204517811536789, 0.010629093274474144, -0.013224326074123383, -0.011447860859334469, 0.007298526354134083, -0.03003592975437641, -0.00027446565218269825, -0.009809378534555435, 0.01914862170815468, -0.011917202733457088, -0.01559457741677761, 0.039099566638469696, 0.0227210633456707, -0.0010242536664009094, -0.0005166876362636685, 0.006174416746944189, 0.0057272594422101974, -0.02214990183711052, -0.06757024675607681, -0.03956601396203041, -0.014119347557425499, -0.02550671249628067, -0.008241530507802963, -0.015629779547452927, -0.0001627821911824867, -0.020512951537966728, 0.023906826972961426, 0.0022285606246441603, 0.04818063601851463, -0.019637223333120346, 0.025362305343151093, -0.04104543849825859, -0.03391517326235771, -0.000008531191269867122, -0.006020289845764637, -0.0024403876159340143, -0.026197992265224457, 0.011848527938127518, -0.005811463110148907, 0.0008735067676752806, 0.02612389624118805, -0.025990501046180725, -0.07209163904190063, -0.0005274353898130357, -0.013852027244865894, -0.020803047344088554, 0.0065886774100363255, 0.021406669169664383, -0.005722700618207455, 0.0002645613858476281, 0.0027424630243331194, 0.0011485422728583217, 0.0025360905565321445, 0.012775760143995285, -0.0579339861869812, -0.028714118525385857, 0.022828567773103714, -0.0002164302277378738, 0.011064019054174423, 0.010260462760925293, 0.0033055387903004885, -0.012026469223201275, 0.08341807872056961, -0.03618720546364784, -0.018887611106038094, 0.016903409734368324, -0.032950788736343384, -0.033617179840803146, 0.04681377112865448, -0.00014560857380274683, 0.05036040395498276, 0.021390922367572784, -0.0014603623421862721, -0.06139562651515007, 0.056919634342193604, -0.01731136254966259, -0.011311670765280724, -0.0046066720969974995, 0.011099264025688171, -0.012380573898553848, 0.0010067926486954093, 0.019133657217025757, 0.012881620787084103, 0.016011754050850868, -0.0008927778690122068, 0.007313944865018129, -0.01824347861111164, 0.0034494148567318916, 0.009513987228274345, -0.02501927874982357, -0.0015196569729596376, 0.02400416135787964, -0.036611415445804596, 0.025597335770726204, 0.09097396582365036, 0.0006172682042233646, 0.03500499203801155, 0.02589123696088791, 0.008745069615542889, -0.07205542922019958, -0.009412466548383236, 0.006496033631265163, 0.06459315866231918, 0.05006701871752739, -0.06017051264643669, 0.01728084124624729, 0.05324937775731087, -0.0429246760904789, 0.030254065990447998, 0.015349523164331913, 0.013218185864388943, -0.01844354346394539, 0.003983973525464535, -0.02720777317881584, 0.02164117805659771, 0.03978252410888672, 0.022280022501945496, 0.07001089304685593, 0.04076175019145012, -0.016609428450465202, -0.019271880388259888, -0.011154089123010635, 0.045895785093307495, 0.02658035419881344, -0.010479537770152092, 0.06120806932449341, -0.010765661485493183, -0.04549870640039444, 0.055592987686395645, -0.027342354878783226, 0.013670559041202068, -0.011639639735221863, 0.05622275918722153, 0.003791758557781577, 0.03870600089430809, 0.04307090491056442, 0.009367357939481735, 0.04113619774580002, 0.022124817594885826, 0.019425030797719955, -0.029196931049227715, -0.04420236125588417, 0.0020385931711643934, 0.010258971713483334, 0.019550012424588203, -0.012628195807337761, 0.03224755451083183, -0.015874721109867096, 0.006068158894777298, -0.026623429730534554, -0.026107514277100563, 0.019687693566083908, -0.037415601313114166, 0.007618715520948172, -0.04733367636799812, -0.0009988738456740975, 0.023791827261447906, 0.030934516340494156, -0.0473652146756649, 0.011623195372521877, -0.0009313835762441158, -0.06637334078550339, 0.03747225180268288, -0.018616294488310814, -0.02541733905673027, -0.06398004293441772, -0.006123898550868034, 0.0033102992456406355, -0.009160537272691727, 0.0026762960478663445, -0.0060636019334197044, -0.07296814024448395, 0.047930020838975906, 0.0029921799432486296, 0.022742250934243202, 0.006254015956073999, -0.03687838092446327, 0.016247758641839027, -0.0670272558927536, 0.04747467860579491, -0.022856641560792923, -0.01816767267882824, -0.010893789120018482, -0.01604655012488365, -0.0021145555656403303, -0.019297350198030472, 0.042581554502248764, -0.007922941818833351, 0.011856031604111195, -0.004269141238182783, 0.012584242038428783, 0.005339625757187605, -0.055036481469869614, 0.02116662636399269, 0.013585601933300495, -0.018670057877898216, -0.01418611966073513, -0.02848847396671772, 0.051790475845336914, 0.010245004668831825, 0.012763641774654388, -0.02075212448835373, 0.01692301221191883, 0.022259078919887543, 0.011187069118022919, 0.012937506660819054, 0.008601346984505653, -0.024052457883954048, 0.0608006976544857, -0.027816304937005043, -0.0038601835258305073, -0.030687320977449417, 0.02212616614997387, -0.05664737895131111, 0.020802102982997894, -0.024948259815573692, -0.04197818413376808, 0.012443093582987785, 0.041064292192459106, -0.011261620558798313, -0.06257188320159912, 0.006074140314012766, 0.021692384034395218, -0.014206328429281712, -0.014245551079511642, 0.04196157678961754, -0.004503864794969559, 0.05664181336760521, 0.0001839449250837788, 0.04073009639978409, 0.0031478276941925287, 0.002003543544560671, -0.0013061159988865256, 0.017919287085533142, 0.028495771810412407, -0.060433994978666306, 0.019991116598248482, 0.010549594648182392, -0.006509316153824329, 0.01871436834335327, 0.008462422527372837, -0.001238042488694191, -0.03491470590233803, -0.020297162234783173, 0.06437348574399948, -0.022783445194363594, -0.013107599690556526, -0.054546140134334564, -0.000477299967315048, 0.023633019998669624, -0.02192937768995762, -0.011384164914488792, -0.02460515685379505, 0.023129180073738098, -0.025349074974656105, 0.02920863963663578, 0.041714008897542953, 0.007740335538983345, 0.004063081927597523, -0.01524528581649065, 0.004193679429590702, 0.004058798775076866, 0.013752051629126072, -0.04511796310544014, 0.029967796057462692, -0.02095499448478222, 0.0025894083082675934, 0.0075369104743003845, -0.012244584038853645, -0.04443218559026718, 0.005602923687547445, 0.008268927223980427, 0.017132071778178215, 0.041915230453014374, -0.00853731669485569, 0.00345719326287508, -0.02462989091873169, 0.03128784894943237, -0.07607891410589218, 0.0056578353978693485, -0.04036711901426315, 0.02548328787088394, 0.0158468596637249, -0.011873098090291023 ]
<p>Say I have a set of classifier models, each generated using feature selection inside a repeated k-fold cross-validation. Each classifier model is generated using a different set of regularization parameters or hyperparameters. </p> <p>I understand that choosing the 'best' model of this set, i.e. one that yields best k-fold cross validation classication estimate could produce an optimistically biased estimate of generalized performance. However is bias avoided if the final performance estimate, is based on a separate repeated k-fold cross validation using the features and hyperparameters selected above? </p> <p>I have found this procedure (10 folds, 10 repetitions) works well in practice (model appears stable on genuinely unseen data) on a data set with Cases > Features however I wonder if any remaining bias could be considered unacceptable? I suspect this procedure is less acceptable in the case where Features >> Cases</p> <p>My question is related to <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/q/11602/11030">Training with the full dataset after cross-validation?</a></p> <p>Apologies if this question appears ignorant or repeats material discussed elsewhere.</p>
36,336
[ -0.0415501706302166, 0.013652087189257145, -0.004718586336821318, 0.021176652982831, 0.04153934493660927, 0.019964296370744705, -0.018547648563981056, -0.019638240337371826, 0.02449657954275608, -0.012855034321546555, 0.041281044483184814, 0.0305411908775568, 0.05318926274776459, -0.009978396818041801, -0.0014197065029293299, -0.008984725922346115, -0.012612919323146343, -0.01285827998071909, 0.009342438541352749, -0.015475990250706673, -0.0024245402310043573, 0.03920600190758705, -0.014632171019911766, -0.018259793519973755, -0.030116142705082893, 0.01662481762468815, 0.01622987538576126, -0.018114039674401283, 0.021084165200591087, 0.024432938545942307, -0.012022966518998146, -0.004612181801348925, 0.01049239095300436, 0.07618114352226257, 0.004357048310339451, 0.0037556567694991827, -0.0028349896892905235, -0.05559852346777916, -0.026180677115917206, 0.05457167699933052, -0.006162769626826048, -0.021078189834952354, 0.0042437538504600525, 0.023726042360067368, 0.017548447474837303, 0.03261809051036835, -0.057511020451784134, -0.016150226816534996, 0.02605891413986683, -0.0419662781059742, 0.06351637840270996, -0.01542093139141798, 0.048156991600990295, 0.057922057807445526, -0.017597554251551628, 0.007046581711620092, 0.0725616067647934, 0.07805649936199188, -0.003705639159306884, -0.04430041462182999, 0.00365484319627285, -0.033008210361003876, 0.022963428869843483, -0.0038767934311181307, -0.046129535883665085, 0.05894756689667702, 0.017905406653881073, -0.02634597010910511, 0.023194149136543274, -0.024409811943769455, 0.020956976339221, 0.010063186287879944, 0.05447797104716301, -0.018902894109487534, 0.012737700715661049, -0.003363315248861909, 0.015398460440337658, 0.03798192739486694, 0.03686913475394249, 0.0014907635049894452, 0.030146807432174683, 0.01588807813823223, 0.024744343012571335, 0.058956328779459, 0.021525554358959198, 0.011917226016521454, 0.04527078941464424, 0.008363869972527027, 0.04085284098982811, 0.03208580240607262, 0.011521791107952595, 0.015683209523558617, 0.046953026205301285, -0.028803689405322075, -0.06417253613471985, 0.04759671911597252, 0.017801906913518906, 0.035812124609947205, 0.018863936886191368, 0.005103777162730694, -0.018105028197169304, -0.039640575647354126, -0.024399086833000183, 0.044274818152189255, -0.02924460731446743, 0.005743175279349089, -0.021336620673537254, -0.03224020078778267, -0.021045740693807602, -0.017912236973643303, -0.009255965240299702, 0.0015012146905064583, -0.004595817532390356, -0.03217316046357155, 0.02307332493364811, 0.017968151718378067, -0.018119104206562042, -0.012446459382772446, 0.025854123756289482, 0.05390578508377075, 0.030196119099855423, -0.05627170205116272, 0.029276413843035698, -0.04519941285252571, 0.005375485401600599, -0.015760838985443115, 0.019605549052357674, -0.01618969812989235, -0.038026683032512665, 0.036717094480991364, -0.017179448157548904, -0.04875706136226654, 0.012696202844381332, 0.011453468352556229, 0.003912653308361769, -0.012057350017130375, -0.06553611159324646, -0.047114696353673935, 0.018644677475094795, -0.018226830288767815, 0.03599150851368904, -0.052482929080724716, -0.02442624606192112, 0.03591740503907204, 0.06196779012680054, 0.0019474150612950325, 0.025765877217054367, 0.025746341794729233, 0.058871835470199585, -0.0017721711192280054, -0.0029692435637116432, -0.036859285086393356, -0.006450952030718327, -0.014262138865888119, -0.0649203360080719, -0.11431802064180374, 0.002036038087680936, -0.0025017906446009874, -0.012339749373495579, -0.006350353360176086, 0.0006260405061766505, -0.019852958619594574, 0.010309295728802681, -0.016472911462187767, 0.013225537724792957, -0.022665027529001236, 0.06426107883453369, 0.015282798558473587, 0.08750373870134354, 0.013677353970706463, -0.024175090715289116, -0.011389648541808128, 0.036047179251909256, 0.039830632507801056, 0.019419271498918533, -0.031327322125434875, 0.04618204012513161, -0.03917200490832329, 0.029714368283748627, -0.011413770727813244, -0.026645027101039886, -0.01704537123441696, -0.0049959998577833176, -0.021007902920246124, 0.006267248187214136, 0.04746244475245476, -0.004909713286906481, -0.02418704703450203, 0.025750434026122093, -0.03811035305261612, -0.02844182588160038, -0.052881330251693726, -0.013754365965723991, -0.028327321633696556, -0.038692496716976166, 0.0249610785394907, -0.008374666795134544, 0.04329768568277359, -0.01719975285232067, -0.02303563989698887, -0.004034352023154497, -0.02611723355948925, 0.03266717493534088, -0.04203994572162628, 0.012836864218115807, 0.05749688297510147, -0.0009279795922338963, -0.0398259274661541, 0.0739252045750618, -0.03391299769282341, -0.08311552554368973, 0.034739796072244644, -0.044304683804512024, 0.0008796662441454828, -0.00872108992189169, 0.006024351343512535, 0.030645135790109634, 0.0036469546612352133, -0.01986553892493248, 0.019405480474233627, -0.05097810551524162, 0.04475409910082817, 0.07106903195381165, -0.012261019088327885, -0.006595738232135773, 0.006338269449770451, 0.022060519084334373, 0.045817192643880844, -0.023763161152601242, 0.00458424910902977, -0.03082645870745182, -0.013264083303511143, 0.05910259112715721, 0.00093796820146963, -0.01627918891608715, 0.04786815494298935, 0.04146184027194977, 0.005598242394626141, 0.022857598960399628, 0.012724196538329124, 0.00992749072611332, -0.02061029151082039, 0.00961129181087017, 0.022979695349931717, 0.017212973907589912, 0.01539516169577837, 0.01831844635307789, -0.03376256301999092, 0.011587897315621376, 0.02680930681526661, 0.023106124252080917, 0.06077214702963829, 0.015049559064209461, -0.017765255644917488, -0.013500358909368515, -0.05637121945619583, 0.03055436909198761, -0.009077507071197033, 0.017370931804180145, 0.02890336699783802, 0.017873317003250122, 0.032541822642087936, -0.03191300854086876, 0.004704159218817949, 0.015155459754168987, 0.02799990214407444, -0.043711017817258835, -0.012568220496177673, 0.018150663003325462, -0.056150883436203, -0.004423331934958696, -0.03938212990760803, -0.022220412269234657, -0.010193168185651302, 0.009295739233493805, 0.039646878838539124, -0.03248049318790436, 0.00953433196991682, -0.03224809095263481, -0.006876288913190365, -0.015614288859069347, -0.01860072650015354, 0.0351739339530468, -0.023567747324705124, -0.04338844493031502, 0.02073436975479126, -0.0377945713698864, -0.03247261419892311, 0.04991728067398071, -0.02584129013121128, -0.020675424486398697, 0.013565275818109512, 0.01668694242835045, -0.010894943960011005, -0.05322928726673126, -0.04690733551979065, 0.02566744200885296, -0.03692527487874031, -0.022655079141259193, 0.06211588904261589, 0.02624504640698433, -0.046196870505809784, 0.02909487672150135, -0.00004519394860835746, -0.027811668813228607, -0.014948515221476555, -0.0155798913910985, 0.010874097235500813, -0.01948767900466919, 0.02783277817070484, 0.060071635991334915, -0.013785657472908497, -0.015003155916929245, -0.058620452880859375, -0.0590430349111557, 0.04061291366815567, -0.04276647791266441, 0.02265739254653454, 0.031189845874905586, 0.005173254758119583, 0.08555871993303299, 0.03965453431010246, -0.000477394467452541, -0.04632606357336044, 0.023244207724928856, -0.03183729574084282, -0.019998082891106606, -0.03543716296553612, -0.002884368412196636, -0.010438002645969391, 0.030995603650808334, -0.031763385981321335, 0.011350502260029316, 0.04084446281194687, -0.005886477418243885, -0.02547338604927063, -0.00038987849256955087, 0.0202756579965353, 0.00791094359010458, -0.0027646925300359726, 0.006853665690869093, -0.008815095759928226, -0.015397965908050537, -0.015562457032501698, 0.032387059181928635, 0.026973610743880272, -0.05471717193722725, 0.0378580242395401, -0.027970662340521812, 0.02237525023519993, 0.0064952499233186245, 0.02519090101122856, -0.004475831054151058, -0.02349061891436577, -0.04916483908891678, 0.012621473520994186, 0.04857315495610237, -0.020804675295948982, 0.011197630316019058, 0.04398471489548683, 0.02019771747291088, 0.02663275972008705, -0.02517094835639, -0.01763935759663582, -0.020584458485245705, 0.024509040638804436, 0.005742753390222788, -0.029323644936084747, 0.02591385878622532, 0.0571119487285614, 0.0045020985417068005, 0.019090762361884117, -0.05733231455087662, 0.015682615339756012, -0.05423889309167862, -0.008575153537094593, -0.011825727298855782, 0.05329723283648491, -0.0016216423828154802, 0.003297898918390274, 0.011044103652238846, -0.052151575684547424, -0.02186177298426628, 0.04124658554792404, -0.048848532140254974, 0.04034290462732315, 0.031252842396497726, -0.031056007370352745, 0.007172705605626106, -0.04337219521403313, 0.02773418463766575, -0.0035630494821816683, -0.005445552058517933, 0.01421745028346777, 0.029447179287672043, -0.045369114726781845, 0.0031379719730466604, -0.04325147345662117, -0.016962822526693344, -0.029381385073065758, 0.02924257703125477, 0.009989792481064796, 0.0011893840273842216, 0.04103170335292816, -0.00043231630115769804, -0.005248266737908125, -0.01835760474205017, -0.026667069643735886, 0.04960476607084274, -0.00026547579909674823, 0.04049264267086983, 0.008200344629585743, 0.04137484356760979, -0.09256739169359207, 0.0426962710916996, -0.012117545120418072, 0.04174136742949486, 0.03148471191525459, -0.0005224127089604735, -0.04468255490064621, -0.05578356608748436, -0.028156420215964317, 0.03492141515016556, 0.014874320477247238, -0.0016430827090516686, -0.029706845059990883, 0.05557312071323395, 0.049964677542448044, -0.05248359218239784, -0.022661995142698288, 0.060522884130477905, -0.004872406367212534, -0.004944453947246075, -0.03860272839665413, 0.009214288555085659, -0.0024442935828119516, -0.010447016917169094, 0.01852390356361866, -0.013126063160598278, -0.005065768491476774, -0.004643569700419903, 0.011827491223812103, -0.026482725515961647, -0.03840702027082443, -0.0051231421530246735, 0.0311601385474205, 0.03269577398896217, 0.01745009981095791, -0.028544485569000244, 0.030830221250653267, 0.06659332662820816, 0.05789513140916824, 0.031300999224185944, 0.006487605161964893, -0.07647545635700226, -0.009413481689989567, 0.045654166489839554, 0.026096366345882416, -0.054073791950941086, -0.04295075312256813, -0.0224247258156538, -0.006536825094372034, 0.014950906857848167, -0.01562478393316269, 0.025724424049258232, 0.01632048562169075, 0.0008581728325225413, -0.02511071227490902, -0.0007311427034437656, -0.04100053012371063, 0.018949290737509727, -0.04484296590089798, 0.06926965713500977, -0.010776090435683727, 0.0010664428118616343, -0.021778015419840813, 0.009067400358617306, 0.0015897834673523903, 0.06698551774024963, -0.00472881319001317, -0.040641140192747116, -0.002005930058658123, 0.007217755541205406, -0.018983537331223488, -0.06499902158975601, -0.008654121309518814, -0.003610422369092703, -0.023867208510637283, 0.024156896397471428, -0.019715270027518272, -0.011896858923137188, 0.011478325352072716, 0.015863195061683655, -0.02039741910994053, -0.03814468905329704, -0.0080349650233984, 0.02265886403620243, 0.01923808455467224, -0.005347580648958683, 0.09254850447177887, 0.027916528284549713, 0.02295769192278385, -0.004190246108919382, 0.020454823970794678, 0.00017642497550696135, -0.034741222858428955, -0.03450503200292587, -0.03039124794304371, -0.0035666804760694504, -0.0094575434923172, 0.019723355770111084, -0.007607788313180208, 0.05414118245244026, -0.002077300101518631, -0.01623336598277092, 0.0009581337799318135, 0.012114787474274635, -0.011929105967283249, -0.02320883423089981, -0.020835712552070618, 0.056355636566877365, -0.019772067666053772, 0.004395904950797558, -0.017985908314585686, -0.0156332328915596, 0.0077970619313418865, 0.053613413125276566, -0.045121900737285614, 0.006309595890343189, -0.010317211039364338, -0.00954490713775158, -0.031007645651698112, -0.008467315696179867, 0.00662729749456048, 0.011671674437820911, 0.011505486443638802, -0.0020217399578541517, -0.05127514898777008, 0.013224863447248936, 0.017437098547816277, 0.0206195916980505, 0.021228697150945663, -0.04436608776450157, 0.0294154342263937, -0.010181715711951256, 0.008670725859701633, -0.08263541013002396, -0.026394227519631386, 0.03268495947122574, 0.028708165511488914, -0.027651693671941757, 0.0032691338565200567, 0.011871413327753544, -0.0244456697255373, -0.015489406883716583, 0.0015853068325668573, 0.05484326556324959, -0.02181190811097622, -0.009550257585942745, 0.027824709191918373, 0.019417008385062218, 0.060646578669548035, 0.005187501665204763, 0.045144230127334595, -0.006441843695938587, -0.030118810012936592, -0.019746795296669006, 0.009125209413468838, -0.018757356330752373, -0.044871944934129715, 0.015813082456588745, -0.04499237239360809, 0.02182934060692787, 0.03638839349150658, 0.02440682053565979, -0.023104066029191017, 0.013607542961835861, -0.036853622645139694, 0.005297504365444183, -0.02592533640563488, 0.007609312888234854, -0.020084232091903687, -0.02214960753917694, -0.0009022664162330329, 0.022557944059371948, 0.027544856071472168, -0.007052083499729633, 0.025377271696925163, 0.0018092263489961624, -0.030973050743341446, -0.01780829019844532, 0.05335928872227669, -0.041738804429769516, -0.013592055067420006, -0.037091273814439774, -0.06498760730028152, 0.05845823884010315, 0.005223237909376621, 0.01585923694074154, 0.011721896938979626, 0.033082716166973114, -0.02711094170808792, 0.006986240390688181, -0.030439643189311028, -0.002216839464381337, 0.04903987795114517, -0.02729150839149952, 0.029033375903964043, 0.03651653975248337, 0.023511521518230438, -0.0016038235044106841, -0.06878920644521713, 0.018453549593687057, -0.022964559495449066, 0.004784669727087021, 0.03831016272306442, 0.03418617695569992, 0.00397453224286437, 0.05031300336122513, 0.0060807750560343266, 0.037173863500356674, 0.03172706812620163, 0.001153919380158186, 0.039970096200704575, -0.00534495385363698, -0.02061920054256916, -0.03665363788604736, 0.019274752587080002, -0.0463712252676487, -0.015243268571794033, -0.0009733210317790508, -0.04032287001609802, 0.003380035050213337, 0.052979957312345505, 0.038140423595905304, -0.00927899032831192, -0.030856212601065636, -0.042846038937568665, 0.01938609965145588, -0.010023454204201698, -0.0020111599005758762, 0.04653337970376015, 0.0030611949041485786, -0.0017495881766080856, 0.030639037489891052, 0.012127690948545933, -0.03940293937921524, -0.0941859781742096, -0.020242853090167046, 0.007859816774725914, -0.025603262707591057, 0.021325111389160156, 0.03116530366241932, -0.03876667469739914, 0.029218077659606934, -0.01966923102736473, 0.052071064710617065, 0.013913481496274471, 0.05747770145535469, 0.019615061581134796, 0.04852252081036568, 0.005412125028669834, 0.003571811830624938, 0.022332947701215744, 0.02192733623087406, 0.11814755946397781, 0.09603169560432434, 0.038018353283405304, -0.036433957517147064, 0.004143703728914261, -0.02147115021944046, -0.02171209454536438, -0.00771442661061883, 0.01255236566066742, 0.023893192410469055, -0.02545463852584362, 0.008985787630081177, 0.031114842742681503, 0.00121418631169945, -0.036307357251644135, 0.001414893427863717, -0.02041696570813656, 0.024908382445573807, 0.03937705606222153, 0.012693174183368683, 0.013701112940907478, -0.02425953559577465, -0.03187941387295723, 0.02668873593211174, 0.021281786262989044, -0.003382591065019369, 0.0018414818914607167, -0.0067276726476848125, -0.008638894185423851, -0.002320660976693034, -0.012941664084792137, 0.004695496056228876, -0.005555125419050455, 0.00045584116014651954, -0.04408375173807144, 0.010371635667979717, 0.0032290553208440542, 0.0027200288604944944, 0.015151691623032093, 0.035353563725948334, -0.011744990944862366, 0.004194941371679306, 0.0148814357817173, 0.01884317398071289, -0.03583811968564987, -0.01886153221130371, -0.07234734296798706, 0.052863091230392456, -0.03891446813941002, 0.03351764380931854, 0.01790933683514595, -0.008720443584024906, 0.018314216285943985, -0.05114263296127319, -0.019259367138147354, 0.011910797096788883, 0.012959425337612629, -0.028336090967059135, -0.04800299182534218, -0.052849169820547104, 0.05327795818448067, 0.013830351643264294, 0.033454779535532, -0.018985381349921227, -0.052926260977983475, -0.019208023324608803, -0.015143085271120071, 0.0379510298371315, 0.030090542510151863, 0.014366401359438896, -0.005542011931538582, -0.03767242282629013, -0.05479012057185173, -0.020984800532460213, 0.01903429999947548, -0.023602019995450974, 0.03449214622378349, -0.021762462332844734, -0.02099822461605072, -0.025811979547142982, -0.033475928008556366, 0.0006257320637814701, -0.004860205110162497, 0.012912805192172527, -0.03046184591948986, -0.006366483401507139, -0.026434196159243584, 0.009827489033341408, 0.016266722232103348, -0.0015839464031159878, 0.021459635347127914, 0.02924298495054245, -0.009098421782255173, -0.05826747044920921, -0.022737549617886543, -0.02128021791577339, -0.05955607444047928, 0.02315596304833889, -0.0037522970233112574, 0.07607313990592957, -0.0018734984332695603, 0.028264658525586128, -0.033102478832006454, 0.041184961795806885, 0.024540411308407784, 0.021485136821866035, 0.02078976295888424, -0.05423803627490997, 0.004135035444051027, -0.019143041223287582, -0.005853638984262943, -0.04668891802430153, -0.03230665624141693, -0.04513276368379593, -0.04094589129090309, 0.05702856928110123, -0.039894405752420425, -0.0440511554479599, 0.0249064601957798, -0.01015575509518385, 0.035584378987550735, 0.006728274282068014, -0.016677984967827797, -0.035038962960243225, 0.010122965089976788, -0.033053331077098846, -0.024327561259269714, 0.035128820687532425, 0.017891015857458115, -0.020504871383309364, -0.018690869212150574, 0.04382769763469696, 0.013961362652480602, 0.022379456087946892, -0.015770813450217247, 0.01895677112042904, 0.0014908212469890714, 0.07031653821468353, -0.04981721192598343, -0.013520289212465286, 0.025633301585912704, -0.03680159151554108, -0.006588574964553118, -0.008781997486948967, -0.0060591185465455055, 0.023711415007710457, 0.020843807607889175, -0.009091619402170181, -0.019620561972260475, 0.03179759532213211, -0.022930899634957314, -0.002597320359200239, 0.026862964034080505, 0.03038313426077366, 0.022124923765659332, 0.013200880959630013, 0.015401397831737995, 0.03780907392501831, 0.0009317430085502565, -0.005688754376024008, 0.04244247078895569, 0.004311337601393461, -0.025527406483888626, 0.012008690275251865, -0.005275531206279993, 0.011449271813035011, 0.03443635255098343, 0.007838902994990349, -0.011372428387403488, 0.041162651032209396, -0.056569524109363556, 0.024972256273031235, -0.010152126662433147, 0.020166266709566116, -0.105821393430233, -0.026294773444533348, 0.018969668075442314, 0.02072594128549099, -0.012694817036390305, -0.05080171301960945, 0.003789290552958846, 0.04531882330775261, -0.025847258046269417, 0.03978312760591507, 0.031303949654102325, 0.0005915386136621237, -0.040486980229616165, 0.007915548980236053, -0.01769477315247059, -0.036734528839588165, 0.03642282262444496, 0.0010259905830025673, -0.012446258217096329, 0.01558371540158987, 0.022209659218788147, -0.004856794141232967, -0.061340611428022385, 0.007755395490676165, -0.009725719690322876, -0.04428234323859215, 0.02645873837172985, -0.01435444038361311, -0.07448425143957138, 0.04309536889195442, 0.015388819389045238, -0.001964960480108857, 0.024240313097834587, 0.019422383978962898, 0.03495270758867264, 0.02248832955956459, 0.052673496305942535, -0.026999233290553093, 0.003520757192745805, 0.03278949111700058, 0.008448492735624313, 0.0010483035584911704, -0.016801796853542328, 0.0264351274818182, -0.00022008965606801212, -0.008390504866838455, -0.04868832975625992, 0.02581443265080452, -0.02906941808760166, -0.01638796180486679, 0.0011506907176226377, 0.005359605886042118, -0.0033425206784158945, -0.016749760136008263, 0.02445267140865326, -0.030826453119516373, 0.015547684393823147, 0.024301180616021156, 0.019454365596175194, -0.004488363862037659, 0.011238142848014832, -0.01953018456697464, -0.0440659299492836, -0.005921154748648405, -0.01646752469241619, 0.002225577598437667, -0.050885166972875595, -0.003744907910004258, 0.0375283882021904, -0.024520741775631905, -0.026636533439159393, -0.04603375867009163, -0.033127933740615845, 0.05337686091661453, -0.010762391611933708, 0.07295715808868408, 0.014496062882244587, -0.04518096521496773, -0.016754470765590668, -0.10567373037338257, 0.04646407440304756, -0.011558793485164642, -0.03493538126349449, -0.005326164420694113, 0.017401516437530518, -0.021775847300887108, -0.012318369932472706, 0.0482490099966526, 0.017845066264271736, -0.002368187764659524, -0.028870491310954094, 0.031587500125169754, -0.006230990402400494, -0.06444303691387177, 0.03488623723387718, -0.002139125484973192, -0.019870392978191376, -0.009732971899211407, -0.0072822170332074165, -0.020585009828209877, 0.018765708431601524, 0.05050808563828468, -0.02085093967616558, 0.03381645306944847, 0.02451458014547825, -0.005616056267172098, 0.05552377179265022, 0.014019227586686611, 0.02490488439798355, 0.04339229315519333, 0.02085075154900551, 0.0015825647860765457, 0.026768973097205162, 0.005180032458156347, -0.05172251537442207, 0.016059784218668938, -0.04912634193897247, -0.0032674691174179316, -0.005166197195649147, 0.03662971407175064, -0.018664875999093056, -0.051043011248111725, 0.010146419517695904, 0.04128345474600792, -0.0272001251578331, -0.015217828564345837, 0.03823743015527725, 0.01948663964867592, 0.005897209979593754, -0.022580232471227646, 0.025053920224308968, 0.018883125856518745, 0.026886681094765663, -0.010929097421467304, 0.0024245313834398985, 0.023563772439956665, 0.020568659529089928, 0.04153715819120407, 0.013171663507819176, -0.013313071802258492, 0.04152439534664154, -0.02445966750383377, 0.051154788583517075, -0.05903635174036026, -0.005703204311430454, 0.0032595209777355194, -0.009856494143605232, -0.009988168254494667, -0.049795426428318024, 0.005508001893758774, 0.055786654353141785, -0.04020611196756363, -0.017038309946656227, -0.020540934056043625, -0.06256044656038284, 0.015217006206512451, -0.009317463263869286, 0.001956287771463394, 0.013708784244954586, 0.019098035991191864, 0.026795238256454468, -0.006782895419746637, 0.002583357272669673, 0.055782500654459, -0.006401813589036465, 0.035390641540288925, -0.03369608148932457, 0.002139642369002104, -0.012708103284239769, -0.019457271322607994, -0.005509470589458942, -0.0237148255109787, 0.012605234049260616, 0.02913355641067028, 0.017146814614534378, -0.03565317019820213, -0.007791994139552116, 0.012409303337335587, 0.033010970801115036, -0.05618996545672417, -0.004290283191949129, -0.041289072483778, 0.029558779671788216, 0.010757064446806908, -0.015148162841796875 ]
<p>CLT states in short, that sum/mean of random iid variables from almost any distribution approaches normal distribution. </p> <p>I failed to find information about asymptotic behavior of sample variance when sample is drawn from unknown distribution. Do we have any reason to believe, that variance of random iid variables asymptotically approach any particular distribution (like chi-squared for normal case)?</p> <p>What about covariance of multivariate iid distribution? Can we have any reason to believe, that covariance calculated on sample drawn from it can asymptotically approach Wishart distribution? (or any other?)</p>
36,337
[ -0.025199662894010544, -0.02450682781636715, 0.022988053038716316, -0.011879504658281803, 0.07449893653392792, 0.009612916968762875, -0.046706847846508026, -0.005789755377918482, 0.015009213238954544, -0.08044473081827164, 0.0438028909265995, -0.0042594606056809425, 0.02690097875893116, 0.03703666105866432, 0.018210815265774727, 0.020810449495911598, -0.041303493082523346, -0.005253539886325598, -0.0035231385845690966, -0.0046441503800451756, 0.038955967873334885, 0.05400407314300537, 0.0077729965560138226, -0.03177253529429436, -0.05401235073804855, 0.012931527569890022, -0.006020418833941221, -0.006022085435688496, 0.025701215490698814, 0.07180716097354889, -0.019553186371922493, 0.0005002440302632749, 0.018242422491312027, 0.041522059589624405, 0.01358233205974102, -0.0001647495082579553, -0.005929955281317234, -0.03465200960636139, 0.015103090554475784, 0.013289032503962517, -0.02909875102341175, -0.01277939323335886, 0.005023578181862831, 0.026515793055295944, -0.005460388958454132, 0.016915425658226013, -0.01089439820498228, -0.030228054150938988, 0.019128916785120964, -0.046055927872657776, 0.08411266654729843, -0.005577653180807829, 0.04990845546126366, 0.0034221685491502285, -0.027767419815063477, -0.027815790846943855, 0.04456407576799393, 0.04039542376995087, 0.020084185525774956, -0.06225964426994324, 0.01670611836016178, -0.0013888799585402012, 0.020888417959213257, -0.013088359497487545, -0.022806184366345406, 0.010139154270291328, -0.01370567362755537, -0.03824394941329956, -0.008674565702676773, -0.022910064086318016, 0.011375918053090572, 0.07735219597816467, 0.010619883425533772, 0.01361154019832611, 0.058175574988126755, 0.012619701214134693, 0.0203394778072834, 0.01119679119437933, 0.012687353417277336, 0.004505460150539875, 0.050794824957847595, 0.03324517235159874, 0.03507086634635925, 0.020602043718099594, 0.060346297919750214, -0.00947119202464819, 0.07784403860569, -0.0002688980312086642, 0.0009850689675658941, 0.04707134887576103, 0.03148339316248894, -0.020199451595544815, 0.05848953127861023, -0.009032121859490871, -0.055212050676345825, 0.040464699268341064, -0.04017026349902153, 0.01767857000231743, 0.01508086733520031, 0.015132622793316841, -0.008959784172475338, -0.0069393739104270935, 0.036750566214323044, 0.05418584868311882, 0.020621804520487785, -0.05089101567864418, -0.0132063627243042, 0.0002537575492169708, -0.009145823307335377, -0.01705229841172695, 0.00269045471213758, 0.03314002603292465, 0.024372195824980736, -0.021434549242258072, 0.0036041017156094313, 0.006229706574231386, -0.00006007691990816966, -0.05278356373310089, 0.05990714207291603, 0.0420236773788929, 0.02068127691745758, -0.023801686242222786, 0.00010541872325120494, -0.010614193044602871, -0.028163140639662743, 0.019370926544070244, 0.0278304573148489, -0.020648404955863953, -0.07879766076803207, 0.059477079659700394, 0.009213014505803585, -0.012696247547864914, 0.01076705101877451, 0.048369962722063065, 0.025293083861470222, -0.03758163005113602, -0.08766880631446838, -0.045178551226854324, 0.030855484306812286, -0.047182243317365646, 0.002258565044030547, -0.0650387555360794, 0.029661428183317184, 0.03738677501678467, 0.05188548564910889, -0.016516029834747314, 0.05940471589565277, -0.017200257629156113, 0.03164951875805855, 0.038550663739442825, -0.0357620045542717, -0.05615128204226494, 0.02690022811293602, -0.04191624000668526, 0.00665042269974947, -0.09544521570205688, 0.004429515451192856, 0.0073530892841517925, -0.034724410623311996, -0.03580854460597038, -0.008687252178788185, -0.006313082296401262, 0.00032631465001031756, -0.054452866315841675, 0.04077192395925522, -0.0475381463766098, 0.05983962118625641, -0.02959766425192356, 0.06338799744844437, 0.015954844653606415, -0.017916906625032425, 0.01705758646130562, -0.002564760623499751, 0.042421359568834305, 0.05054613947868347, -0.039724040776491165, -0.005108959041535854, -0.0056654601357877254, 0.0051341732032597065, -0.011986510828137398, -0.029860658571124077, 0.012739075347781181, -0.03446322679519653, -0.0006990011897869408, 0.020896581932902336, 0.04719451442360878, 0.002747368300333619, -0.019437598064541817, 0.0264857467263937, -0.0661606714129448, -0.019296087324619293, -0.04757470637559891, -0.02062535658478737, -0.017392059788107872, -0.07795056700706482, -0.003991078119724989, -0.007626741658896208, 0.041498105973005295, 0.020075084641575813, -0.007706227712333202, -0.039859890937805176, -0.01717262528836727, 0.0107062216848135, -0.016635699197649956, 0.001776224235072732, 0.01509720366448164, 0.027676833793520927, -0.005503881722688675, 0.02229427359998226, -0.010646194219589233, -0.09291685372591019, 0.023923788219690323, -0.02547609992325306, 0.04526817426085472, 0.006691670045256615, 0.019996805116534233, 0.0010732250520959496, 0.0035163206048309803, -0.02344689331948757, 0.04474889487028122, -0.01642482541501522, 0.034240465611219406, 0.05850331485271454, 0.021427493542432785, -0.017639901489019394, 0.06752289086580276, -0.005929224658757448, -0.024676259607076645, -0.01534543838351965, -0.028583664447069168, -0.05155344307422638, -0.01876896806061268, -0.0004562598478514701, 0.054534830152988434, -0.022002464160323143, 0.023621488362550735, 0.0360710471868515, 0.012596255168318748, 0.04323591664433479, 0.03482794389128685, 0.0027252715080976486, -0.042756251990795135, 0.010284450836479664, -0.013787368312478065, 0.03281986340880394, 0.005677034612745047, -0.008459451608359814, -0.040176041424274445, 0.036536697298288345, 0.018362324684858322, -0.03796947002410889, -0.0014944809954613447, -0.012962779961526394, -0.02436205931007862, -0.03775736317038536, -0.0026512942276895046, 0.03165052831172943, -0.01622580736875534, 0.001835738425143063, 0.03233571723103523, 0.01619829796254635, 0.004067141562700272, -0.030211592093110085, -0.014303570613265038, 0.04834747686982155, 0.01412136573344469, -0.03772251307964325, -0.025079499930143356, 0.009725663810968399, -0.038007818162441254, -0.0067998808808624744, -0.03032890148460865, -0.021209878847002983, -0.023793363943696022, 0.010282622650265694, 0.030902618542313576, 0.0012604427756741643, 0.018591083586215973, -0.030261177569627762, -0.02710743434727192, -0.0034918056335300207, 0.012035736814141273, 0.01832984760403633, 0.014595037326216698, -0.013524112291634083, 0.012802156619727612, -0.03526947274804115, -0.029161622747778893, 0.0466972254216671, -0.04750235751271248, 0.02114703319966793, 0.04236089438199997, 0.000015265968613675795, -0.05012673884630203, 0.026504868641495705, 0.01619325391948223, -0.00226427405141294, -0.04223030060529709, 0.0033005427103489637, 0.017960546538233757, -0.005792653653770685, 0.000057825840485747904, 0.05808618292212486, -0.027551529929041862, -0.038108717650175095, -0.03043697029352188, 0.00141949113458395, 0.016629094257950783, 0.005579441320151091, 0.043586377054452896, 0.028392331674695015, -0.015820810571312904, 0.013840727508068085, -0.07977515459060669, -0.062933050096035, 0.0379931814968586, -0.004190496634691954, 0.04423744976520538, 0.022099295631051064, 0.0008209564839489758, 0.05053633078932762, 0.03707423433661461, -0.037149906158447266, -0.017308363690972328, -0.0035042008385062218, 0.009251042269170284, -0.004528260324150324, 0.0294598788022995, 0.0043046665377914906, -0.023107731714844704, 0.038040924817323685, 0.011770418845117092, -0.0030182674527168274, 0.028783800080418587, -0.010155687108635902, 0.010699965991079807, 0.015435349196195602, 0.015359794721007347, 0.0411229208111763, 0.026875639334321022, 0.038638897240161896, 0.004327365662902594, -0.04721764847636223, 0.012534799054265022, 0.011832566931843758, 0.008753479458391666, -0.03028448484838009, 0.04819878563284874, 0.000008377381163882092, 0.03223619982600212, -0.06147876754403114, 0.02715616300702095, 0.039108533412218094, -0.02170509099960327, -0.02619771845638752, 0.006558475084602833, 0.020203251391649246, 0.0005749053088948131, 0.025821348652243614, 0.025272103026509285, 0.02361498773097992, 0.023758014664053917, -0.001943986746482551, -0.01524738036096096, 0.00728982500731945, 0.0322347953915596, -0.021184058859944344, 0.013271556235849857, 0.028182819485664368, 0.06068078801035881, -0.03371462970972061, -0.0058557926677167416, -0.026791932061314583, 0.021117672324180603, -0.057694271206855774, -0.01919238083064556, -0.043854694813489914, 0.05697806179523468, 0.01950463093817234, 0.04761165753006935, 0.02832893468439579, 0.017365185543894768, 0.01049137581139803, -0.008593910373747349, -0.07150864601135254, 0.00888256449252367, -0.0019583813846111298, -0.0026160511188209057, -0.0187038853764534, -0.013623734936118126, 0.01679428666830063, 0.038431067019701004, 0.0014610077487304807, -0.029070908203721046, 0.011048533022403717, -0.023596247658133507, 0.04375580698251724, -0.02132641337811947, -0.042015839368104935, -0.016229864209890366, 0.02115698903799057, -0.006524996366351843, -0.061370763927698135, 0.02985973097383976, 0.018572194501757622, -0.024379804730415344, -0.03819797560572624, -0.036842744797468185, 0.015881525352597237, 0.0030637604650110006, 0.07088817656040192, 0.03435039892792702, 0.017450185492634773, -0.032614607363939285, 0.02080991305410862, 0.018512334674596786, 0.06477000564336777, 0.04231235012412071, -0.005006197839975357, 0.0038846665993332863, -0.0651700496673584, -0.052639588713645935, 0.018699897453188896, -0.013967224396765232, 0.017201552167534828, 0.009335912764072418, 0.044387489557266235, 0.023972462862730026, -0.04726027324795723, 0.0021803807467222214, 0.028939809650182724, 0.023598015308380127, 0.012314637191593647, -0.011392458342015743, 0.0049193669110536575, 0.0003520528262015432, -0.03113764151930809, 0.020209049805998802, -0.016651388257741928, -0.006853471044450998, 0.00020700195454992354, 0.03468365967273712, 0.011689525097608566, -0.04557107016444206, -0.013384416699409485, 0.03472885116934776, 0.0294417105615139, 0.014026341028511524, -0.017396625131368637, 0.039429672062397, 0.036696907132864, 0.046857308596372604, 0.014432694762945175, -0.003819009056314826, -0.07057437300682068, 0.023615824058651924, 0.015537481755018234, 0.05350002273917198, -0.03843534365296364, 0.0019217078806832433, -0.03409076854586601, -0.0003079104353673756, 0.00025855316198430955, 0.00429231533780694, 0.013951116241514683, -0.03738702833652496, -0.011753679253160954, -0.022187653928995132, -0.02930101938545704, -0.04322103038430214, -0.02109753154218197, -0.017681218683719635, -0.002793428022414446, -0.013420582748949528, -0.03126471862196922, -0.04435887187719345, 0.012642291374504566, 0.0346098467707634, 0.055063240230083466, -0.012835812754929066, -0.012440428137779236, 0.0004325010231696069, 0.05007107928395271, -0.037275079637765884, -0.04129884019494057, 0.03941619023680687, 0.0063796998001635075, -0.021582312881946564, 0.0445437990128994, -0.01713160052895546, -0.03400588035583496, 0.013970853760838509, -0.0021949452348053455, -0.045604825019836426, -0.00018035706307273358, -0.014312396757304668, 0.055218350142240524, 0.00829936284571886, 0.033937644213438034, 0.03201449289917946, 0.012797151692211628, 0.00029297659057192504, -0.010583852417767048, -0.011432798579335213, 0.03827099874615669, -0.022727470844984055, -0.015582550317049026, -0.055794455111026764, -0.025831278413534164, -0.02784084901213646, 0.02005949430167675, 0.0039452179335057735, 0.02276395633816719, -0.03398166224360466, -0.0029652651865035295, 0.01211289968341589, 0.028486033901572227, 0.01766008324921131, 0.01990436017513275, -0.004658685065805912, 0.04087822139263153, 0.016138918697834015, -0.021670261397957802, 0.04294538125395775, 0.0021131825633347034, -0.006910803262144327, 0.03755766525864601, 0.0004942435771226883, -0.01133919321000576, -0.037365615367889404, 0.006899797357618809, 0.0026683295145630836, -0.00971862580627203, 0.03317303955554962, -0.015927743166685104, 0.02765236608684063, 0.049472689628601074, -0.019642576575279236, -0.010948512703180313, 0.052983492612838745, -0.039468858391046524, 0.0321904718875885, -0.008745317347347736, -0.0033138184808194637, -0.012797250412404537, -0.00714596314355731, -0.08892112970352173, -0.033538512885570526, 0.02482278272509575, 0.00456630252301693, -0.013663369230926037, -0.009744949638843536, -0.0025484224315732718, -0.016311127692461014, -0.034991536289453506, -0.05297429487109184, 0.042086586356163025, -0.002042195061221719, -0.018832866102457047, -0.011201859451830387, 0.024558711796998978, 0.05274346470832825, -0.015186861157417297, 0.01604291796684265, 0.031526219099760056, -0.04162664711475372, 0.013534809462726116, 0.008453826420009136, 0.044660914689302444, -0.028234228491783142, 0.014291110448539257, 0.014259172603487968, -0.013441400602459908, 0.02328946813941002, -0.034318722784519196, -0.02743985876441002, 0.001286045298911631, -0.01548469066619873, -0.03347472846508026, -0.022728167474269867, -0.03178383782505989, 0.007646061014384031, 0.027270536869764328, -0.018923094496130943, -0.023042550310492516, -0.03805503249168396, -0.012085405178368092, 0.029884550720453262, 0.02966122329235077, -0.02084227465093136, 0.003184386296197772, 0.004215408116579056, 0.009693283587694168, -0.025116998702287674, -0.024114008992910385, 0.010693663731217384, 0.009660354815423489, 0.004212441388517618, -0.0008957965183071792, 0.024335362017154694, 0.029200097545981407, -0.029181933030486107, -0.050004858523607254, -0.043270912021398544, 0.01810944639146328, 0.06121004372835159, -0.005907808430492878, 0.058383263647556305, 0.02671530470252037, -0.005383755546063185, -0.05606972798705101, -0.04788479208946228, -0.018534604460000992, -0.011741185560822487, 0.013346520252525806, 0.05450134351849556, 0.008902786299586296, -0.026013445109128952, -0.003294746857136488, 0.03318759799003601, -0.0007121991366147995, 0.027134526520967484, 0.023623686283826828, -0.018173644319176674, 0.002492206171154976, 0.0012776495423167944, -0.022455336526036263, 0.014969387091696262, -0.03724878281354904, 0.0020110318437218666, -0.03159653767943382, -0.01444920338690281, 0.015703484416007996, 0.015376484952867031, -0.00022218379308469594, -0.034034114331007004, -0.046971116214990616, -0.023841947317123413, 0.0016987052513286471, 0.03402853012084961, 0.028999606147408485, 0.026116950437426567, -0.031190447509288788, 0.024669552221894264, -0.002912030089646578, 0.03218342363834381, -0.03161775693297386, -0.08246026188135147, -0.022841686382889748, 0.0048134117387235165, -0.04891613870859146, -0.0007758595747873187, 0.013541524298489094, 0.0022802618332207203, 0.005707348696887493, -0.040327031165361404, 0.062458280473947525, -0.05238056927919388, 0.03811086341738701, 0.01661032997071743, 0.08583375811576843, 0.027015700936317444, 0.05019612982869148, -0.0014344800729304552, 0.012192685157060623, 0.10005023330450058, 0.05670655891299248, 0.013436811976134777, -0.03830132260918617, 0.020146790891885757, -0.029305240139365196, -0.011563791893422604, -0.017689870670437813, -0.010893519036471844, 0.009604131802916527, 0.01635165885090828, 0.06839001178741455, 0.022696398198604584, -0.015155988745391369, -0.017899351194500923, 0.024332400411367416, -0.05924474820494652, -0.06296413391828537, 0.00851304829120636, 0.01581454463303089, -0.013082928955554962, 0.0034665486309677362, -0.016062475740909576, 0.009860935620963573, -0.016774270683526993, 0.01226077787578106, 0.01039672177284956, -0.03429150581359863, -0.009579461067914963, -0.017240062355995178, -0.0525829941034317, -0.0012608717661350965, 0.0639861449599266, -0.018267061561346054, -0.031109385192394257, -0.02212356962263584, 0.007467786315828562, -0.009896351024508476, 0.0024343354161828756, 0.05113692954182625, -0.00219321739859879, -0.02370816469192505, 0.02739354595541954, 0.027163051068782806, -0.014187457971274853, -0.02788422256708145, -0.010412496514618397, 0.019345980137586594, -0.03203309699892998, 0.017311833798885345, -0.03902311250567436, -0.0217187087982893, 0.018559126183390617, -0.030139291658997536, 0.01124618761241436, 0.008104114793241024, 0.03221319615840912, -0.035984624177217484, -0.031219160184264183, -0.044095229357481, 0.025782594457268715, 0.01610095053911209, 0.012220910750329494, 0.00914671178907156, -0.03482221066951752, 0.012437141500413418, -0.024816179648041725, 0.06363322585821152, 0.006442561745643616, -0.005998627282679081, -0.009655090980231762, -0.025576218962669373, -0.0001422525238012895, -0.013075344264507294, -0.005318989045917988, -0.036767780780792236, 0.0383634939789772, 0.001468235393986106, 0.01086669135838747, -0.013205558061599731, -0.054200202226638794, 0.002816071268171072, -0.04012428969144821, -0.027719290927052498, -0.07649490982294083, 0.004175799898803234, 0.007363437209278345, 0.07309439778327942, 0.0081196753308177, 0.01389274001121521, -0.009473228827118874, 0.07757484912872314, -0.0018150616670027375, 0.00900118425488472, -0.004927410278469324, -0.025783570483326912, -0.02804168127477169, 0.009510030969977379, -0.004194811452180147, 0.025046484544873238, 0.04987576976418495, 0.005001986864954233, -0.026849918067455292, 0.012659087777137756, -0.009154684841632843, 0.026435650885105133, 0.014389701187610626, -0.04439906030893326, -0.0007904617232270539, 0.026489686220884323, 0.02888595685362816, -0.0009948739316314459, -0.004245574586093426, -0.042239267379045486, -0.05319056659936905, -0.0340406559407711, -0.044378116726875305, -0.04183531552553177, -0.015556300058960915, -0.020710188895463943, 0.023613641038537025, -0.01631997711956501, -0.00031129777198657393, 0.02373441308736801, -0.013450954109430313, 0.0022087134420871735, -0.01830432564020157, 0.0017129417974501848, 0.01673339307308197, -0.02003430761396885, -0.020243732258677483, 0.037903234362602234, 0.0090050483122468, -0.024148764088749886, 0.004825957585126162, -0.025842629373073578, -0.016247857362031937, 0.03927990049123764, -0.026202643290162086, -0.004884602036327124, 0.08156286925077438, -0.04650893807411194, -0.03590373322367668, 0.02956598997116089, -0.01262972317636013, 0.0031556016765534878, 0.033920250833034515, 0.02029222622513771, -0.044500090181827545, 0.030217330902814865, -0.008807076141238213, 0.012987316586077213, -0.029564280062913895, -0.0020999170374125242, -0.000014252178516471758, 0.016915330663323402, 0.026355387642979622, -0.01302709523588419, -0.0066093336790800095, 0.027661073952913284, 0.03743520379066467, 0.04704681411385536, 0.019113697111606598, 0.04810652509331703, -0.0021301633678376675, -0.02779192291200161, 0.03117351233959198, -0.024704420939087868, 0.040414441376924515, 0.059383511543273926, -0.022321611642837524, 0.030499178916215897, -0.03848807141184807, 0.021382002159953117, -0.07536590844392776, -0.03145330026745796, 0.024310627952218056, -0.014499817043542862, 0.04834803193807602, -0.03566785156726837, 0.00019626528955996037, 0.0070148371160030365, -0.11214127391576767, 0.01601414382457733, -0.025587860494852066, -0.03697263449430466, -0.02992037683725357, 0.030538354068994522, 0.000011423555406508967, 0.013162600807845592, 0.023765213787555695, 0.015827450901269913, 0.02779507450759411, 0.061879076063632965, 0.03906852751970291, -0.002094284165650606, -0.04661256819963455, 0.019424142315983772, 0.009716316126286983, -0.048124462366104126, 0.0413234606385231, -0.005819116719067097, -0.03837049379944801, 0.025041913613677025, -0.006476869806647301, -0.002237768145278096, 0.0205436572432518, 0.0198349691927433, 0.024859363213181496, 0.04036637395620346, 0.036876190453767776, 0.011992326006293297, 0.010776630602777004, 0.01891174539923668, 0.04203415289521217, 0.005377424880862236, -0.01676650159060955, 0.02124491147696972, 0.05405410751700401, -0.016269482672214508, 0.008687927387654781, 0.027440788224339485, -0.0044747223146259785, -0.056209295988082886, -0.010512751527130604, -0.009677553549408913, -0.006926382426172495, -0.005358282011002302, 0.06841553002595901, -0.057216353714466095, -0.017736021429300308, 0.03255545720458031, 0.04456482082605362, -0.021340182051062584, 0.03245079144835472, -0.0023088071029633284, -0.04607686027884483, 0.010061168111860752, 0.051552046090364456, 0.007212034426629543, -0.031172480434179306, -0.031804561614990234, 0.009980499744415283, 0.02241547219455242, 0.010507578030228615, -0.03374585136771202, -0.045307110995054245, 0.03154365345835686, -0.0014055513311177492, 0.016730576753616333, 0.04729905351996422, -0.014986936934292316, -0.009182918816804886, -0.07747074216604233, 0.08474946767091751, -0.011824262328445911, -0.021445132791996002, -0.0545707605779171, -0.00021985794592183083, -0.015008312650024891, -0.02822643332183361, 0.056841280311346054, -0.020418789237737656, 0.003055292647331953, -0.0007346709608100355, 0.024173330515623093, -0.021291470155119896, -0.04440848156809807, 0.0017156312242150307, -0.0209213774651289, -0.019813215360045433, -0.0337955579161644, -0.008892180398106575, 0.014355041086673737, 0.007944058626890182, 0.001113596372306347, 0.0032500457018613815, 0.03956889361143112, 0.015895085409283638, -0.0570206418633461, 0.014684591442346573, 0.0339178740978241, -0.017830949276685715, 0.063459612429142, -0.02338014729321003, 0.003661652561277151, 0.0012248147977516055, -0.045288510620594025, -0.024749960750341415, 0.03152066841721535, -0.009482176974415779, -0.018055366352200508, -0.04807104915380478, 0.03419478237628937, -0.027024896815419197, -0.06864549219608307, -0.02269132062792778, 0.05839693173766136, -0.026245078071951866, -0.007461247034370899, 0.06317698955535889, 0.01791870966553688, 0.044293954968452454, 0.0011512167984619737, 0.00029848108533769846, 0.014057721011340618, -0.018948810175061226, 0.02761324681341648, 0.01889186166226864, 0.01528347097337246, -0.028443489223718643, 0.00393838994204998, 0.008276772685348988, -0.01738547347486019, 0.056116294115781784, -0.027833763509988785, 0.03619266301393509, -0.035022128373384476, -0.013025272637605667, 0.026620278134942055, -0.007562808692455292, 0.034373730421066284, -0.0039019372779875994, -0.048559509217739105, 0.06753422319889069, -0.029827898368239403, 0.00430870009586215, -0.021774275228381157, -0.028307151049375534, -0.04758329689502716, -0.034817613661289215, -0.009119817055761814, 0.023716233670711517, 0.038085032254457474, 0.013834230601787567, -0.016937486827373505, 0.007202877663075924, -0.010336031205952168, -0.03962697088718414, 0.015319406986236572, -0.02450873889029026, -0.018784115090966225, -0.02081027626991272, -0.038789983838796616, -0.007788117974996567, 0.014703701250255108, 0.005764591507613659, 0.016977041959762573, 0.008802976459264755, 0.023363258689641953, -0.01723594218492508, 0.03385042026638985, 0.0771363154053688, -0.07245758920907974, 0.00943935476243496, -0.007946721278131008, -0.004167868755757809, -0.013488397002220154, -0.032585885375738144 ]
<p>The <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Finite_difference#Forward.2C_backward.2C_and_central_differences" rel="nofollow">central difference</a> is a method to approximate numerically the derivative of a function sampled at discrete intervals. In R, one would do:</p> <pre><code>n&lt;-100 y&lt;-cumsum(rnorm(n)) y_p[1]&lt;-diff(y[1:2]) for(i in 2:(n-1)) y_p[i]&lt;-diff(y[c(i-1,i+1)])/2 y_p[n]&lt;-diff(y[c(n-1,n)]) </code></pre> <p>My question is, what is the comonly accepted inverse to this operator? (preferably in pseudo code form to avoid ambuiguity)</p> <p>Best,</p>
73,835
[ 0.011394611559808254, 0.018994174897670746, -0.0023548670578747988, -0.01204308494925499, 0.026417313143610954, 0.007074046414345503, 0.01747193932533264, -0.026549343019723892, 0.01788361556828022, -0.01963774301111698, 0.01591469533741474, 0.045353423804044724, 0.0796704888343811, 0.023608505725860596, 0.05066515505313873, 0.009105769917368889, -0.042503077536821365, 0.01285866741091013, -0.0016420447500422597, -0.03050430864095688, -0.00553919468075037, 0.03110245056450367, -0.008407693356275558, 0.001116293715313077, -0.04766741394996643, 0.024634478613734245, 0.007890205830335617, 0.012694399803876877, -0.004567334894090891, 0.06984979659318924, -0.06353718787431717, -0.09672082960605621, 0.0049832966178655624, 0.029564104974269867, -0.005200060550123453, 0.022187111899256706, -0.0376925989985466, -0.054888442158699036, -0.015410288237035275, 0.044896963983774185, 0.010389452800154686, -0.050809770822525024, -0.014546079561114311, 0.04520504176616669, -0.009216583333909512, 0.022392937913537025, -0.009583866223692894, -0.01561575848609209, 0.06479120254516602, -0.04918097332119942, 0.10767965763807297, -0.018745703622698784, -0.0034690359607338905, 0.004363968037068844, -0.02738949842751026, 0.02609146572649479, 0.03810279443860054, 0.05833896994590759, -0.01041294727474451, -0.05651231110095978, -0.021463075652718544, -0.011860596016049385, -0.002682506339624524, -0.0023511440958827734, -0.031354982405900955, -0.014181663282215595, -0.012982625514268875, -0.015212486498057842, -0.012683376669883728, -0.02755426988005638, -0.01992223970592022, -0.008534224703907967, 0.03971630334854126, -0.032187219709157944, 0.02339048497378826, -0.038945600390434265, -0.0028661766555160284, 0.01941918581724167, 0.021903563290834427, 0.02046409621834755, -0.04910643771290779, 0.0036460510455071926, 0.004561523906886578, 0.06195056438446045, 0.006117210723459721, -0.013314945623278618, 0.09315243363380432, -0.02407636120915413, 0.05413919314742088, 0.026430023834109306, -0.02165466547012329, -0.012788906693458557, 0.050525594502687454, -0.0187606792896986, -0.04090072587132454, 0.014835349284112453, 0.01800655573606491, 0.02062775380909443, 0.00015674658061470836, -0.029276035726070404, -0.021296324208378792, -0.058772504329681396, -0.01697579212486744, 0.05501416698098183, -0.049837224185466766, 0.02138533443212509, -0.04700050503015518, 0.01194015983492136, 0.009585650637745857, 0.013684652745723724, -0.034641899168491364, 0.0017519720131531358, -0.03611953929066658, 0.01813698187470436, 0.04739699512720108, -0.012219433672726154, -0.02368107996881008, 0.020592767745256424, 0.039037447422742844, 0.03816528990864754, 0.05400262027978897, 0.005884977523237467, 0.048801228404045105, -0.040922608226537704, -0.049499597400426865, -0.01912335306406021, 0.005219717510044575, 0.007507712114602327, -0.03916098177433014, 0.020367298275232315, 0.0005544160958379507, -0.02379140444099903, 0.05332845449447632, -0.0012868356425315142, 0.01958351954817772, -0.009589874185621738, -0.08301279693841934, -0.08091087639331818, 0.025991614907979965, -0.024068914353847504, 0.006539391819387674, -0.10077925026416779, 0.029808493331074715, 0.024768125265836716, 0.05978566035628319, 0.0373428612947464, 0.023760244250297546, 0.004607621114701033, 0.009827736765146255, -0.003378462279215455, -0.024331072345376015, -0.032067544758319855, 0.0260129664093256, -0.03933826461434364, -0.0075074005872011185, -0.04461226984858513, 0.029143625870347023, -0.01575634814798832, -0.035065263509750366, 0.01403593085706234, 0.063979871571064, -0.01684523932635784, 0.007656488101929426, -0.002791876904666424, -0.003241124330088496, -0.03213776275515556, 0.08875833451747894, 0.022012989968061447, 0.003943104762583971, 0.014834709465503693, -0.00031203488470055163, 0.007631781045347452, -0.0012441722210496664, 0.032987311482429504, 0.08603726327419281, -0.05554480105638504, -0.009690169245004654, -0.03154929727315903, 0.009837687015533447, 0.009387511759996414, -0.023457488045096397, -0.016288047656416893, 0.017752841114997864, -0.0032084768172353506, 0.007555743213742971, 0.031936828047037125, -0.010777031071484089, -0.009787507355213165, 0.06669729948043823, -0.02632281742990017, 0.014212950132787228, -0.060253243893384933, -0.03470074012875557, 0.021406402811408043, 0.0011842016829177737, 0.012945814989507198, 0.017144445329904556, 0.014885359443724155, -0.012892247177660465, -0.034764405339956284, -0.019088014960289, -0.0269155390560627, 0.061068255454301834, 0.0028995489701628685, 0.006400256417691708, 0.05375261977314949, 0.062212493270635605, -0.015873055905103683, 0.04055395349860191, -0.044527314603328705, -0.025033434852957726, -0.022933414205908775, -0.045842643827199936, 0.033835381269454956, 0.0034886084031313658, -0.018643399700522423, 0.03980136662721634, 0.007525179535150528, -0.011047480627894402, -0.004159137606620789, -0.0809955969452858, 0.05545508489012718, 0.07279904931783676, 0.06411701440811157, -0.0022701071575284004, 0.0031509073451161385, 0.016931070014834404, 0.005374132189899683, 0.003639345522969961, -0.010125050321221352, -0.04284333065152168, 0.0038560880348086357, 0.027040475979447365, 0.0122520225122571, -0.060316767543554306, 0.018856287002563477, 0.030053140595555305, -0.005311404354870319, 0.033307645469903946, 0.014033153653144836, -0.01727735623717308, -0.040710486471652985, 0.011314615607261658, -0.006417292170226574, 0.028819572180509567, 0.04229484871029854, 0.05543351545929909, 0.011907977983355522, 0.04171218350529671, 0.014317133463919163, -0.02124340832233429, 0.027922555804252625, -0.008050331845879555, -0.01693527027964592, 0.00670835142955184, -0.03230174630880356, 0.03074258752167225, -0.03400151804089546, -0.006659824401140213, 0.05026591569185257, -0.02440847083926201, 0.0053386748768389225, -0.0020910389721393585, 0.008700712583959103, 0.020083505660295486, 0.03724531829357147, -0.04886999353766441, -0.002088692272081971, 0.026507314294576645, -0.001023817341774702, -0.01128475647419691, -0.01935417763888836, -0.013728939928114414, -0.04254675284028053, -0.03300711512565613, 0.0381297767162323, 0.01885053515434265, 0.0004641659033950418, -0.02314060740172863, -0.022596554830670357, -0.02087610773742199, -0.03642608970403671, 0.03333627060055733, -0.009462547488510609, -0.051846943795681, 0.04549770429730415, 0.000896547338925302, -0.0033366482239216566, 0.0026823775842785835, 0.019551342353224754, 0.018870944157242775, 0.00769050745293498, -0.014224945567548275, -0.06546323001384735, 0.002368522807955742, -0.008306002244353294, 0.039534859359264374, -0.02367863990366459, -0.03531241789460182, 0.05969515070319176, -0.03195761516690254, -0.013505572453141212, 0.007317229639738798, -0.06514406204223633, -0.03562663123011589, -0.043147265911102295, 0.03246653079986572, 0.01769879087805748, 0.02653655596077442, -0.005547133274376392, 0.04354816675186157, 0.007865575142204762, 0.005682815797626972, -0.09103572368621826, -0.05094226077198982, 0.013443900272250175, 0.0063901906833052635, -0.012103165499866009, 0.02526114322245121, -0.014954355545341969, 0.08118199557065964, 0.027605999261140823, -0.026327183470129967, -0.033315107226371765, 0.013278146274387836, -0.007335688918828964, -0.012174163945019245, 0.0012797708623111248, -0.006600767374038696, -0.013277892023324966, 0.0032511460594832897, -0.0014557749964296818, 0.018261509016156197, 0.08285877853631973, -0.0038345542270690203, -0.009110216051340103, 0.02159292995929718, -0.020553726702928543, -0.007458273787051439, 0.04834491387009621, -0.020990433171391487, -0.03405977040529251, 0.0037049937527626753, 0.010508399456739426, 0.013942338526248932, 0.037162844091653824, -0.03336229920387268, 0.00674620782956481, -0.01512956339865923, -0.00891879666596651, -0.029063450172543526, 0.044747039675712585, -0.007877188734710217, 0.012677403166890144, -0.017288055270910263, 0.006247788202017546, 0.050086114555597305, -0.04304881393909454, 0.009785223752260208, 0.054637789726257324, 0.024334657937288284, 0.008541448973119259, 0.0316932387650013, 0.016206007450819016, -0.018307244405150414, 0.01629873551428318, -0.014398911036550999, -0.0063860793597996235, 0.024600200355052948, 0.03540927171707153, 0.016899393871426582, 0.0240717101842165, -0.03557230532169342, 0.024319320917129517, -0.0614287368953228, 0.018772434443235397, -0.017798563465476036, 0.08947233110666275, 0.0011791640426963568, 0.051340244710445404, 0.027304546907544136, 0.007581033743917942, 0.039597563445568085, 0.036557190120220184, -0.10527226328849792, 0.044567763805389404, -0.009713342413306236, -0.010339620523154736, -0.04126046225428581, 0.001042341929860413, 0.028757847845554352, 0.0031673212070018053, 0.0012917795684188604, -0.005318795330822468, -0.013311642222106457, -0.035038650035858154, -0.00444698566570878, -0.013462461531162262, -0.0009267627028748393, -0.02394942380487919, 0.023228174075484276, 0.050369180738925934, -0.042689356952905655, 0.03321709856390953, 0.031716298311948776, 0.006439012009650469, -0.004400774370878935, -0.000760251481551677, 0.02245563641190529, 0.028905346989631653, 0.006227567326277494, -0.004006030037999153, 0.038502492010593414, -0.04138614982366562, 0.007360708899796009, -0.013618286699056625, 0.05162210762500763, 0.03457265719771385, -0.026366671547293663, -0.04144831746816635, -0.04044857248663902, 0.00524505227804184, 0.018348155543208122, 0.016994815319776535, 0.023780833929777145, 0.04566064849495888, 0.04236167296767235, 0.062098950147628784, -0.03397441655397415, 0.0018928827485069633, 0.07796236872673035, 0.0022702745627611876, -0.03951280191540718, -0.027745632454752922, -0.011875133030116558, 0.002561344066634774, 0.0011160190915688872, 0.015927236527204514, -0.008219010196626186, 0.007333919871598482, 0.006475827656686306, 0.030716074630618095, 0.032058995217084885, 0.009330174885690212, 0.023724403232336044, 0.01769263669848442, 0.03379673510789871, -0.012913068756461143, 0.0024118092842400074, -0.009679874405264854, 0.006840572692453861, 0.021852927282452583, 0.02329583652317524, -0.01461563166230917, -0.10165605694055557, -0.0009987648809328675, 0.041997767984867096, 0.08508486300706863, -0.03753728047013283, -0.01657685451209545, -0.050712715834379196, -0.02540290728211403, 0.05931493639945984, -0.02941451221704483, 0.0288706012070179, -0.034342437982559204, -0.012156349606812, 0.007010367698967457, -0.017407454550266266, -0.012326321564614773, 0.02832522615790367, -0.00823990534991026, -0.0007302750018425286, -0.015434753149747849, -0.031515080481767654, -0.07055673003196716, -0.02384066954255104, -0.0026620470453053713, 0.05740339308977127, -0.03021990694105625, -0.029977502301335335, 0.0070052077062428, 0.03365721553564072, -0.016903774812817574, -0.00832654070109129, -0.009096908383071423, 0.020504772663116455, -0.009034560061991215, 0.037996843457221985, 0.006434887181967497, -0.01813671365380287, 0.036375951021909714, 0.009078245609998703, 0.017203960567712784, 0.014168252237141132, 0.007373201660811901, 0.03577464446425438, 0.04200538620352745, -0.01406084280461073, 0.0700884610414505, 0.03987504914402962, -0.028452111408114433, -0.01036860328167677, -0.0351412296295166, 0.0016760977450758219, -0.02243025228381157, -0.003603458870202303, -0.034641336649656296, -0.022102614864706993, -0.030239444226026535, -0.0010772804962471128, -0.025458600372076035, 0.028335431590676308, -0.024563409388065338, -0.012090036645531654, -0.003750622970983386, 0.04710401967167854, -0.04027272015810013, 0.007509283255785704, 0.0013592258328571916, -0.0014383405214175582, 0.00953067746013403, -0.04388297349214554, 0.03567196801304817, 0.017959214746952057, -0.023746272549033165, 0.04108577221632004, -0.03962196409702301, -0.0014793927548453212, -0.023350266739726067, -0.021177904680371284, 0.04107242077589035, 0.006885786075145006, 0.029199784621596336, -0.026878567412495613, 0.015107017941772938, 0.014487690292298794, -0.03422469645738602, -0.025152718648314476, 0.030149243772029877, -0.040010005235672, -0.015443929471075535, -0.051194872707128525, 0.03744771331548691, 0.011469763703644276, 0.02183537743985653, -0.049304865300655365, -0.047143422067165375, 0.04444197937846184, -0.006652624811977148, -0.0609249509871006, -0.017258135601878166, -0.019635403528809547, -0.013904472813010216, 0.0015555734280496836, -0.007993414998054504, 0.03762369602918625, 0.023967694491147995, -0.010734320618212223, 0.010966874659061432, -0.029991047456860542, 0.046529676765203476, 0.023600054904818535, 0.014248705469071865, 0.002212582854554057, -0.015084966085851192, -0.031076010316610336, 0.0023868954740464687, 0.05570170283317566, -0.04038013145327568, 0.01859969086945057, -0.01440420188009739, -0.0011522229760885239, 0.03749987483024597, -0.011371373198926449, -0.011160563677549362, 0.03195073828101158, 0.00688930694013834, -0.013859975151717663, -0.027630001306533813, 0.004513103049248457, -0.07236983627080917, -0.0017076707445085049, -0.0329262912273407, -0.006896418984979391, -0.003220419632270932, -0.016450218856334686, 0.0013813228579238057, 0.007132366765290499, -0.03060966730117798, -0.013722861185669899, 0.04809720069169998, -0.03698056936264038, -0.009268948808312416, 0.023210927844047546, -0.026052139699459076, 0.043029557913541794, 0.027143238112330437, 0.00548939872533083, 0.014741403050720692, -0.01660415343940258, -0.05756291747093201, -0.0033606295473873615, -0.028007332235574722, 0.04808686301112175, 0.06546883285045624, -0.016874944791197777, 0.0287124365568161, 0.034711845219135284, 0.01326909288764, -0.005026805680245161, 0.029152631759643555, -0.016416452825069427, 0.024737432599067688, -0.009672218933701515, 0.0528239868581295, -0.001480325241573155, -0.026549143716692924, 0.022815700620412827, 0.01750997267663479, 0.0028177169151604176, 0.04316205531358719, -0.025028351694345474, 0.0031212898902595043, 0.014292242005467415, -0.04820164293050766, -0.009959452785551548, 0.034611716866493225, -0.026605375111103058, 0.021483084186911583, -0.02532440423965454, -0.04887926205992699, 0.045443568378686905, -0.003222439205273986, 0.023193707689642906, -0.03239341452717781, -0.011750713922083378, -0.046017616987228394, -0.04733225703239441, 0.02220078743994236, -0.002376418560743332, 0.010940778069198132, -0.018038194626569748, 0.025199953466653824, 0.006865157745778561, 0.060951367020606995, -0.017036424949765205, -0.08074662834405899, 0.007488145027309656, -0.03924444690346718, -0.04013623297214508, 0.012017730623483658, 0.04470784217119217, -0.04005179554224014, 0.015162301249802113, -0.014489833265542984, 0.032384876161813736, 0.04662982001900673, 0.016592662781476974, 0.024285180494189262, 0.06767728179693222, -0.007347537204623222, 0.0035449930001050234, -0.02853173017501831, -0.06440476328134537, 0.11945144087076187, 0.06244032084941864, 0.016941577196121216, -0.07938501983880997, 0.04057614877820015, -0.008707897737622261, 0.0076903714798390865, 0.00838080607354641, 0.04353976622223854, 0.03212553262710571, 0.021570634096860886, 0.07291634380817413, 0.018904579803347588, 0.01705561764538288, 0.012241781689226627, 0.04169883579015732, -0.022627556696534157, -0.018107496201992035, 0.01795441471040249, 0.010679857805371284, 0.010919000953435898, -0.03814030811190605, -0.06974117457866669, 0.016524983569979668, 0.004202777054160833, 0.014984745532274246, -0.029691994190216064, -0.02619202621281147, -0.002653269562870264, 0.004669751971960068, -0.029902217909693718, 0.011645770631730556, -0.021138284355401993, 0.01305981446057558, -0.024006957188248634, 0.03500213474035263, 0.029650656506419182, -0.01249669399112463, 0.008297525346279144, 0.05587513744831085, 0.0585944838821888, -0.014583926647901535, 0.007386319804936647, -0.005903164856135845, -0.01600492373108864, -0.008576737716794014, -0.03540026769042015, 0.015237154439091682, -0.010237310081720352, -0.019454380497336388, 0.0054116020910441875, -0.015941834077239037, 0.006801396142691374, -0.022919051349163055, -0.0033544066827744246, 0.035124458372592926, 0.03378899022936821, -0.00507294712588191, 0.017662784084677696, -0.04672303795814514, 0.006520338822156191, -0.02631343901157379, 0.008268415927886963, -0.018937520682811737, -0.027662018314003944, -0.04767299443483353, 0.0005465457797981799, 0.06350992619991302, -0.03499783203005791, -0.021228311583399773, 0.0013323415769264102, -0.017367057502269745, -0.032816220074892044, -0.010458571836352348, -0.013557610101997852, -0.015812058001756668, 0.03178603947162628, -0.026617474853992462, -0.02295193076133728, -0.005762909539043903, -0.038948118686676025, 0.02821008861064911, -0.00821190420538187, 0.03582101687788963, -0.0038077898789197206, -0.019753409549593925, 0.03265953063964844, -0.00017737587040755898, 0.016254499554634094, 0.010826747864484787, -0.014609496109187603, 0.045147959142923355, 0.025729933753609657, -0.04909471794962883, -0.031680990010499954, -0.01249654870480299, -0.042972221970558167, 0.010293255560100079, 0.007824977859854698, 0.01714135706424713, 0.001710340497083962, -0.010207372717559338, 0.007806329056620598, 0.009181002154946327, -0.05314378812909126, 0.03340378403663635, 0.0028291852213442326, -0.07688266038894653, 0.02136760950088501, -0.01735774241387844, -0.015352331101894379, -0.05432109907269478, 0.0030786453280597925, -0.022664332762360573, -0.012485283426940441, -0.016582749783992767, 0.03838774934411049, -0.028107259422540665, -0.025243613868951797, -0.013417980633676052, -0.01739649474620819, -0.005845518317073584, 0.01161244884133339, -0.04491524025797844, 0.01205950416624546, -0.016366630792617798, -0.02070496417582035, -0.030069764703512192, 0.01719006896018982, -0.02243184857070446, 0.005416296422481537, 0.04760558158159256, -0.01638788916170597, 0.018118608742952347, -0.007313551381230354, 0.027411580085754395, 0.014613708481192589, 0.027125375345349312, -0.016195598989725113, -0.02752974070608616, 0.044347185641527176, -0.022192509844899178, -0.05120205134153366, 0.017080385237932205, -0.008031527511775494, 0.029412124305963516, 0.0050581227988004684, -0.027805447578430176, -0.007919488474726677, 0.07309726625680923, -0.016002558171749115, 0.012594962492585182, -0.004162843804806471, 0.011476797983050346, 0.025129161775112152, -0.015604713000357151, -0.008225482888519764, -0.029063282534480095, 0.0042211818508803844, -0.014503775164484978, 0.004764793906360865, 0.021520443260669708, -0.002357013989239931, 0.0028763713780790567, -0.011387673206627369, -0.021296819671988487, 0.008615408092737198, 0.007883124984800816, 0.002003364497795701, 0.025077395141124725, -0.04507196694612503, -0.006829036399722099, -0.009198515675961971, 0.03420684114098549, -0.08562544733285904, 0.03339369595050812, 0.004942686762660742, 0.008955149911344051, 0.030521977692842484, -0.06162221357226372, 0.0342148058116436, 0.011149419471621513, -0.022650374099612236, 0.04643074795603752, -0.01603793539106846, -0.031248819082975388, -0.002233757870271802, 0.03915262967348099, -0.02077472023665905, 0.029163744300603867, 0.02163068763911724, 0.006078505422919989, 0.033666905015707016, -0.021828483790159225, -0.007300154305994511, -0.02365056425333023, 0.005651063285768032, -0.014429747126996517, 0.046455398201942444, -0.029945259913802147, 0.032249465584754944, -0.011957927606999874, -0.019966699182987213, 0.04134712740778923, -0.029501162469387054, 0.0577230378985405, -0.005163033027201891, 0.03668956831097603, 0.0026745644863694906, 0.0807400718331337, 0.0029709122609347105, -0.008558575063943863, -0.059186533093452454, 0.006281108129769564, 0.013302216306328773, 0.03149525821208954, 0.00696784071624279, 0.008589541539549828, 0.028872080147266388, 0.026217244565486908, -0.0558917298913002, 0.022278672084212303, -0.0017498076194897294, -0.012987382709980011, -0.009161326102912426, -0.027811121195554733, 0.004212017636746168, -0.0077163758687675, 0.026958854869008064, -0.02215956524014473, -0.03449888154864311, -0.002876666374504566, 0.021090397611260414, -0.042788054794073105, 0.02954019419848919, -0.029972564429044724, -0.059831470251083374, 0.03955419734120369, 0.016637437045574188, -0.006721841637045145, -0.027675693854689598, 0.00030307224369607866, 0.006250459235161543, -0.012182177975773811, -0.024413196370005608, -0.018033849075436592, -0.005719404201954603, 0.024396879598498344, 0.008321256376802921, -0.00011326013191137463, 0.029718179255723953, -0.004003860987722874, 0.02484346181154251, -0.07535181939601898, 0.04628031700849533, -0.0007230687187984586, -0.030043480917811394, 0.006869005039334297, -0.0005623528268188238, -0.019754184409976006, -0.005496426951140165, 0.05380352586507797, 0.002700062934309244, -0.006834716536104679, -0.017074666917324066, 0.04790560156106949, 0.008746549487113953, -0.07582874596118927, -0.00421081343665719, 0.015913188457489014, -0.025839651003479958, -0.005730421282351017, -0.025724587962031364, -0.011974153108894825, 0.028886957094073296, 0.011530537158250809, 0.019897345453500748, 0.0026215852703899145, 0.016126997768878937, 0.0057991580106318, 0.04015415161848068, -0.003997167572379112, -0.027553616091609, 0.05696321651339531, -0.015137271955609322, 0.0009955482091754675, 0.05610008165240288, -0.020116493105888367, -0.046355899423360825, 0.01820051670074463, -0.0006462821620516479, -0.035943180322647095, -0.015057983808219433, -0.015362453646957874, 0.01199372112751007, -0.061378080397844315, -0.018406501039862633, 0.034404490143060684, -0.03564852103590965, 0.01111941784620285, 0.03640158846974373, 0.009080115705728531, 0.013358154334127903, 0.01683931052684784, 0.013758983463048935, 0.01261325553059578, 0.027704503387212753, -0.009795604273676872, 0.0021820629481226206, 0.00038418392068706453, -0.018244609236717224, 0.01271519809961319, 0.004029603209346533, -0.016237402334809303, 0.040310025215148926, -0.025895362719893456, 0.02348359115421772, 0.011209111660718918, -0.012497707270085812, 0.04654266685247421, -0.04140008985996246, 0.012198008596897125, -0.007209781091660261, -0.02620871178805828, 0.047170404344797134, -0.005942316725850105, 0.024960918352007866, 0.0027136611752212048, -0.020657910034060478, -0.03781291842460632, -0.007578923366963863, -0.007669373415410519, -0.02434059977531433, -0.03278087079524994, 0.026748869568109512, 0.02482622303068638, -0.016691144555807114, -0.00329563464038074, -0.03445287048816681, 0.03815396875143051, -0.013927608728408813, -0.00560387410223484, 0.0067610968835651875, -0.027756398543715477, -0.06702177971601486, -0.04051586613059044, 0.02814697101712227, 0.054654113948345184, 0.048526402562856674, 0.033726196736097336, 0.006304772570729256, 0.004548660479485989, 0.039437394589185715, -0.06830087304115295, -0.004543886985629797, -0.018647991120815277, 0.009599241428077221, 0.003955070860683918, -0.043476272374391556 ]
<p>suppose we have a stream of sentences and we need to compare each new sentence with previously received ones . For example , with sentences received in last 30 minutes. What is the best method to do that ? can we use Mahalanobis distance for this ? How ?</p>
38,146
[ -0.03204241022467613, -0.057000283151865005, -0.03040076605975628, -0.0199420303106308, 0.02396586537361145, 0.005644825752824545, 0.032218270003795624, -0.016150742769241333, 0.012999500147998333, 0.028735371306538582, 0.062330856919288635, 0.030194247141480446, 0.024964826181530952, 0.025696810334920883, 0.011711576022207737, -0.00872441940009594, -0.017586516216397285, -0.008715115487575531, -0.004595257807523012, -0.000651355367153883, 0.030077243223786354, -0.006723596714437008, 0.0538746640086174, -0.01839567720890045, -0.040655095130205154, -0.017352962866425514, 0.018691472709178925, -0.020329337567090988, -0.0011011973256245255, 0.040716350078582764, -0.03390048071742058, -0.04199850931763649, 0.04428739473223686, 0.04024771600961685, 0.018963530659675598, 0.0298603568226099, -0.06197506561875343, -0.05364244803786278, -0.01642047055065632, 0.0013591527240350842, -0.042460847645998, -0.03993178904056549, 0.02835502289235592, 0.05208843946456909, -0.061353899538517, 0.004316434729844332, -0.023632390424609184, -0.01089832279831171, -0.014478063210844994, -0.018749337643384933, 0.07216738164424896, -0.02317001111805439, 0.03453924506902695, 0.0031767054460942745, -0.016874277964234352, 0.031097423285245895, 0.04683735966682434, 0.07006043195724487, -0.004279478453099728, -0.039099592715501785, -0.0008848360739648342, -0.02349492534995079, 0.005378588568419218, 0.0043161348439753056, -0.04409228265285492, 0.04315111041069031, -0.00517240958288312, -0.018658936023712158, 0.054559048265218735, -0.0008474292699247599, -0.02316131442785263, -0.005144279915839434, 0.07277249544858932, 0.010241164825856686, 0.025479283183813095, -0.042327746748924255, 0.012076604180037975, 0.01402257476001978, 0.0648685097694397, 0.028450725600123405, 0.020593028515577316, -0.015729963779449463, 0.024883056059479713, 0.04149409756064415, 0.01871662773191929, -0.029675805941224098, 0.06583740562200546, -0.04683864489197731, 0.016100086271762848, 0.05098775774240494, 0.007245710585266352, -0.016235478222370148, -0.00880159717053175, 0.03538814187049866, -0.016981134191155434, -0.008605502545833588, -0.014857567846775055, 0.02260647341609001, 0.022649990394711494, -0.0284863468259573, 0.021271584555506706, -0.04978648200631142, 0.038423653692007065, 0.03661273047327995, -0.0024243078660219908, 0.01513854693621397, -0.033106837421655655, -0.0017675459384918213, 0.0004333128163125366, 0.0024378816597163677, -0.06125888600945473, -0.025799691677093506, 0.019569996744394302, 0.024402061477303505, 0.0022981734946370125, -0.024201594293117523, -0.013128379359841347, -0.0008390918374061584, 0.06540185958147049, 0.08380065113306046, 0.003302050055935979, -0.0024398844689130783, 0.03400930389761925, -0.042072974145412445, -0.021429961547255516, 0.028971556574106216, -0.002443537814542651, -0.0361863449215889, -0.01964450441300869, 0.07375440001487732, -0.029560944065451622, -0.021404331550002098, 0.02478102594614029, -0.0021332327742129564, 0.048836905509233475, 0.0030232456047087908, -0.11245410889387131, -0.021231383085250854, 0.03844423592090607, 0.000983957084827125, 0.013778277672827244, -0.04304277524352074, 0.01391521841287613, 0.003849967150017619, 0.038005292415618896, 0.057849153876304626, 0.011323151178658009, 0.046557940542697906, 0.005673141684383154, 0.008569905534386635, -0.029379818588495255, -0.016032250598073006, -0.014728778041899204, 0.0431574322283268, 0.007811581250280142, -0.051809635013341904, 0.0031428737565875053, 0.030379611998796463, -0.0008057351224124432, -0.06429591029882431, 0.03229440003633499, 0.03347194194793701, -0.0032641475554555655, 0.0007737069390714169, 0.02187371253967285, -0.043756552040576935, 0.08558511734008789, 0.029000313952565193, -0.026050541549921036, -0.009501944296061993, 0.022446248680353165, 0.006068454124033451, 0.015459694899618626, -0.01273714192211628, 0.05513204634189606, 0.001784011721611023, 0.0012421759311109781, 0.0002959508856292814, 0.01960037276148796, 0.044105373322963715, 0.007460359018296003, 0.00956044439226389, -0.02037900686264038, 0.024481208994984627, 0.0037526339292526245, 0.01104986947029829, -0.01349768228828907, 0.03195492550730705, -0.005191869102418423, -0.02213667519390583, 0.012430896982550621, -0.05986776575446129, 0.060819972306489944, -0.0055714319460093975, -0.013608509674668312, 0.030100906267762184, -0.03571571409702301, -0.027061933651566505, -0.035227324813604355, 0.013287528418004513, -0.012014519423246384, 0.019381286576390266, -0.00021076486154925078, -0.015267711132764816, -0.0252192635089159, 0.043377362191677094, 0.02251823991537094, -0.019449258223176003, 0.021353701129555702, -0.012118208222091198, -0.03543270751833916, -0.011063998565077782, -0.007870020344853401, 0.008497980423271656, -0.011928610503673553, 0.00254866317845881, 0.0401807501912117, -0.017492854967713356, -0.025646308436989784, -0.0008535482920706272, -0.05081053078174591, 0.06404000520706177, 0.0869474858045578, 0.02927742339670658, 0.019244637340307236, -0.007565379608422518, 0.028286071494221687, -0.01878964900970459, 0.022173548117280006, -0.055461302399635315, -0.03366074338555336, -0.018241338431835175, 0.03523067757487297, 0.02637878991663456, -0.04616318270564079, 0.00810669269412756, 0.07456507533788681, 0.00810915231704712, 0.01408076100051403, -0.0014427752466872334, -0.02798338606953621, -0.02556706592440605, 0.02293405868113041, 0.03740599751472473, 0.013746485114097595, 0.031310584396123886, 0.00014939805259928107, 0.017245586961507797, 0.017923643812537193, -0.0030835226643830538, 0.01597786508500576, -0.00532853277400136, 0.06277410686016083, 0.0066960654221475124, -0.037818845361471176, -0.056381091475486755, 0.02587970346212387, -0.02303902618587017, 0.016283340752124786, 0.028438692912459373, 0.011431689374148846, 0.0359908826649189, 0.022547205910086632, -0.03143707662820816, 0.02121330238878727, 0.02155241183936596, -0.01963208243250847, 0.003743827110156417, 0.02708042785525322, -0.0704997330904007, 0.033275578171014786, -0.010424217209219933, -0.011546967551112175, -0.020205339416861534, 0.006155543494969606, 0.054734967648983, 0.013216868042945862, 0.03603804111480713, 0.0003814637311734259, 0.017983445897698402, 0.015869947150349617, -0.031634099781513214, -0.007952137850224972, -0.02688628062605858, -0.06462883949279785, 0.032837577164173126, 0.02216985635459423, -0.05301157385110855, 0.012179129756987095, -0.008082681335508823, 0.020689375698566437, 0.038189493119716644, -0.01380240824073553, -0.05809706822037697, 0.002437579445540905, -0.004809529986232519, 0.004438702017068863, -0.026029836386442184, -0.011146316304802895, 0.02750230021774769, 0.022705910727381706, -0.07429539412260056, 0.0030839270912110806, -0.028307104483246803, -0.05396014824509621, -0.06398867815732956, -0.011697453446686268, 0.005093217361718416, -0.021034076809883118, 0.021800652146339417, 0.04341793805360794, -0.01256566308438778, 0.0015972007531672716, -0.0497162900865078, -0.06359940767288208, 0.01843343861401081, -0.03386496752500534, 0.06272055208683014, 0.022106733173131943, -0.03375156968832016, 0.036509133875370026, 0.031159019097685814, -0.06706647574901581, -0.038521658629179, 0.007959100417792797, -0.019653314724564552, -0.04010428488254547, -0.007949375547468662, 0.0008785352110862732, -0.013517250306904316, -0.006363585591316223, 0.04389793053269386, 0.03659933805465698, 0.07833003252744675, -0.01425174530595541, -0.02093626745045185, -0.023387765511870384, 0.001561822253279388, -0.0026680317241698503, 0.04475310072302818, 0.005961697082966566, -0.06462017446756363, 0.015635598450899124, -0.00031046790536493063, -0.0010676984675228596, -0.007405023090541363, -0.016331063583493233, 0.023279564455151558, 0.005707694683223963, -0.025638634338974953, -0.00710099283605814, 0.03835717961192131, -0.03066503442823887, 0.015485861338675022, -0.006019087042659521, 0.04060608893632889, 0.005659179296344519, -0.03930531069636345, 0.01998196169734001, 0.034867994487285614, 0.07233203947544098, -0.04018213972449303, -0.012621449306607246, -0.026711761951446533, -0.0008178144344128668, 0.04001184180378914, -0.014257784932851791, -0.019200947135686874, -0.02090543322265148, 0.023389019072055817, 0.02138974890112877, 0.038222137838602066, -0.02190060168504715, -0.02500077150762081, -0.0425042025744915, 0.01172033604234457, 0.00011304244253551587, 0.0696086660027504, -0.004550520330667496, 0.04179034382104874, 0.030205700546503067, -0.01563918963074684, 0.010175596922636032, -0.012413782067596912, -0.0677751675248146, 0.008392425253987312, -0.029317358508706093, -0.009604341350495815, 0.007206137757748365, -0.030375219881534576, -0.0013692033244296908, -0.049773652106523514, 0.002557663945481181, 0.005636733025312424, 0.0161666851490736, -0.06771764159202576, 0.003593816887587309, -0.03118661791086197, 0.017160968855023384, -0.0029981439001858234, -0.031762804836034775, 0.0562131293118, -0.034478623420000076, 0.02290085144340992, 0.037050511687994, -0.021740632131695747, -0.021340643987059593, -0.0070366766303777695, 0.011818856932222843, 0.011294114403426647, 0.008938292972743511, 0.029524656012654305, 0.05051358416676521, -0.03445585072040558, 0.05699877440929413, 0.007459286600351334, 0.05236104875802994, 0.0071799540892243385, -0.026055805385112762, -0.033877644687891006, -0.03508828580379486, -0.023297006264328957, -0.0043013193644583225, 0.06211608648300171, 0.025851549580693245, -0.017642250284552574, 0.017932265996932983, 0.0057077729143202305, -0.07327225059270859, -0.008518368937075138, 0.06075721234083176, -0.015692174434661865, -0.041955772787332535, -0.029293039813637733, 0.012495073489844799, 0.0176712479442358, -0.012253494933247566, 0.003254009410738945, -0.007634647656232119, 0.008062966167926788, -0.008699484169483185, 0.04407038167119026, -0.016857601702213287, -0.05174586921930313, 0.006640683859586716, 0.002665843116119504, 0.025793662294745445, -0.01752757839858532, -0.0009312849142588675, -0.001914237393066287, 0.04503856971859932, 0.046018268913030624, -0.010349812917411327, 0.0054407003335654736, -0.08886923640966415, 0.025642139837145805, 0.026705902069807053, 0.015144354663789272, -0.03446396812796593, -0.006509157828986645, -0.05087169259786606, 0.007857316173613071, 0.014344505965709686, -0.0008825556724332273, 0.04398788884282112, 0.002276437822729349, -0.01047339104115963, -0.019601471722126007, 0.017978493124246597, -0.005071287974715233, 0.009215324185788631, -0.011835142970085144, 0.03516172990202904, -0.014294179156422615, 0.005108026321977377, -0.04624564200639725, 0.009132008999586105, -0.005533506628125906, 0.05122153088450432, -0.021975338459014893, -0.01096090767532587, 0.016627872362732887, 0.021667931228876114, -0.04802250489592552, -0.017708858475089073, 0.018774738535284996, 0.016993055120110512, -0.038379549980163574, -0.008526984602212906, -0.04051509127020836, -0.019825361669063568, -0.010869650170207024, 0.008902428671717644, -0.04712522029876709, -0.024379566311836243, -0.03259678930044174, 0.010077441111207008, 0.039696015417575836, 0.004869252443313599, 0.04868695139884949, 0.036016710102558136, -0.0038120043464004993, -0.002353740157559514, 0.02271396294236183, 0.046358611434698105, -0.04549850523471832, -0.013105680234730244, -0.031014569103717804, -0.022854184731841087, -0.05793342739343643, 0.032578885555267334, -0.02392132766544819, 0.03797939419746399, 0.008002405986189842, -0.022172514349222183, -0.027664095163345337, 0.055415257811546326, -0.015463210642337799, 0.014905136078596115, 0.013332364149391651, 0.011039274744689465, 0.0162665918469429, -0.01604168303310871, 0.01872994750738144, -0.03304485231637955, 0.038893166929483414, 0.04258721321821213, 0.008114011958241463, 0.011507130227982998, -0.02922987751662731, -0.0038473003078252077, 0.03224263712763786, 0.012382886372506618, 0.029935894533991814, 0.02993212454020977, 0.012654928490519524, 0.05500611662864685, -0.03729439899325371, 0.015003816224634647, 0.024597376585006714, -0.023294877260923386, -0.0059379879385232925, -0.046697091311216354, 0.03558393940329552, 0.0019130343571305275, -0.022532425820827484, -0.09156904369592667, -0.025420457124710083, 0.03826822340488434, -0.015116740018129349, -0.0015398035757243633, -0.061792854219675064, 0.007363049779087305, 0.02286519482731819, -0.015358900651335716, -0.03558499366044998, 0.05132702365517616, 0.017523430287837982, -0.01448595430701971, -0.03474818915128708, -0.002456220332533121, 0.05062805488705635, 0.03534737229347229, 0.002381336409598589, -0.00810324028134346, -0.013545033521950245, 0.01123341079801321, -0.01992790400981903, 0.04589024931192398, -0.01771283894777298, 0.01990232802927494, -0.06355948001146317, 0.03651662543416023, 0.040479302406311035, -0.01180127914994955, 0.0067278314381837845, 0.01676337979733944, -0.040147993713617325, -0.015277190133929253, -0.03136862441897392, -0.00048522817087359726, 0.007064542733132839, 0.006536650005728006, -0.05880272388458252, 0.010823511518537998, -0.028350910171866417, -0.011869275011122227, 0.0289590023458004, 0.03258294239640236, 0.012150940485298634, 0.01144986692816019, 0.03359399363398552, -0.04558609053492546, -0.01571642793715, 0.05102154240012169, -0.001755411853082478, 0.033291030675172806, -0.002250366611406207, -0.01856442168354988, 0.0016107583651319146, 0.01787080243229866, -0.05288755148649216, 0.0028743231669068336, -0.016281310468912125, -0.0043300059624016285, 0.07785838097333908, 0.021118931472301483, 0.06899970024824142, 0.008536674082279205, 0.009479936212301254, -0.03708023950457573, -0.022726189345121384, -0.019895805045962334, -0.019333120435476303, -0.019549261778593063, 0.04235207661986351, 0.002178352791815996, 0.02814275212585926, 0.006824997253715992, 0.054267264902591705, 0.016888536512851715, -0.000545003276783973, 0.009815145283937454, 0.03791029751300812, 0.048377662897109985, -0.03959451615810394, 0.017174484208226204, -0.0036127211060374975, -0.06457307934761047, 0.020134733989834785, -0.018438855186104774, -0.015314696356654167, 0.02579694427549839, 0.01796836405992508, -0.002066944260150194, -0.054143037647008896, -0.026492970064282417, -0.06556610018014908, 0.026294471696019173, 0.006103557534515858, -0.028978189453482628, 0.01748131401836872, 0.028529975563287735, 0.023840542882680893, 0.02761109732091427, 0.04204931482672691, -0.011354765854775906, -0.07986798882484436, 0.013498875312507153, -0.03383176773786545, -0.03447585552930832, -0.00754485372453928, 0.012890001758933067, -0.0454411581158638, -0.019547663629055023, 0.0036383348051458597, 0.027516350150108337, -0.0008324295631609857, 0.02393842488527298, -0.009332952089607716, 0.08337368816137314, -0.025398368015885353, 0.017227407544851303, 0.013305618427693844, 0.006643145810812712, 0.08008290082216263, 0.06711356341838837, 0.033697161823511124, -0.07625234127044678, 0.04789016768336296, 0.02312588505446911, -0.04125241935253143, -0.04263756051659584, 0.043427497148513794, 0.007463701535016298, 0.011787032708525658, 0.03791516274213791, 0.0029357518069446087, -0.0014338877517729998, 0.009864362888038158, 0.04728497192263603, -0.0520508736371994, -0.04601166397333145, 0.026695001870393753, 0.012609955854713917, 0.03706514462828636, 0.019873403012752533, -0.05357607454061508, 0.07352544367313385, 0.022496288642287254, -0.018755393102765083, 0.005196652840822935, -0.029233120381832123, 0.04383426532149315, -0.006834537722170353, 0.019692111760377884, 0.0209820419549942, 0.013421310111880302, 0.032800283282995224, 0.019778523594141006, -0.013819889165461063, 0.03782406076788902, 0.005487134680151939, 0.016589613631367683, 0.003098461776971817, 0.06975884735584259, -0.013268358074128628, 0.010666271671652794, 0.0030537331476807594, -0.03185040503740311, -0.037261463701725006, -0.039017438888549805, 0.008611148223280907, -0.01082785613834858, 0.011987239122390747, 0.05034895986318588, 0.017011284828186035, 0.03112645447254181, -0.05607178062200546, -0.021227944642305374, 0.04415636882185936, 0.025515742599964142, 0.0302291102707386, -0.026428665965795517, -0.04214935749769211, 0.04758504405617714, 0.006343604065477848, 0.018297774717211723, 0.008178678341209888, 0.020866144448518753, -0.018951624631881714, -0.020437227562069893, -0.01894768886268139, -0.04119274392724037, -0.0315401516854763, -0.046284019947052, -0.016800731420516968, 0.001101856934837997, -0.0050647263415157795, 0.01308505143970251, 0.006491193547844887, -0.0030284193344414234, 0.005873228423297405, -0.02963181771337986, -0.022824101150035858, -0.01667059026658535, -0.023427974432706833, -0.02259039506316185, 0.004553645849227905, -0.016908321529626846, -0.020977096632122993, 0.05482631176710129, 0.05594627559185028, 0.032394956797361374, 0.009983274154365063, -0.01958766207098961, 0.07397182285785675, 0.016164259985089302, -0.06153455749154091, 0.008810142986476421, -0.046752359718084335, -0.06205074489116669, -0.036276258528232574, -0.00471760518848896, 0.06533042341470718, 0.03551904112100601, -0.008967188186943531, -0.032264601439237595, 0.023553647100925446, -0.031783413141965866, 0.008292053826153278, 0.022208403795957565, -0.05693968012928963, 0.0012477990239858627, 0.0044405278749763966, -0.00226073176600039, -0.02286064252257347, -0.011956796981394291, -0.006398351397365332, 0.005304434802383184, 0.030487554147839546, -0.021270474418997765, 0.00011815160542028025, 0.01111952681094408, 0.012099864892661572, 0.017459729686379433, -0.0450061559677124, 0.01344760600477457, -0.028207927942276, -0.013722578063607216, -0.05468330904841423, -0.010099670849740505, -0.016022685915231705, 0.028641201555728912, -0.022411201149225235, -0.011972972191870213, 0.016166536137461662, 0.00690446188673377, -0.012301924638450146, -0.013254647143185139, 0.029640434309840202, -0.028500622138381004, 0.055936940014362335, -0.031236980110406876, -0.05623004585504532, 0.02179519273340702, -0.0624060183763504, -0.008614568039774895, 0.03178774565458298, -0.00009485279588261619, 0.018638523295521736, 0.011728151701390743, 0.000029836237445124425, 0.00393617432564497, 0.03811600059270859, 0.002179669449105859, -0.012528506107628345, -0.003568924032151699, -0.04775025323033333, 0.0037862223107367754, 0.007315741386264563, -0.0075190262869000435, 0.008769290521740913, -0.03812278062105179, 0.027118802070617676, 0.026257507503032684, 0.011433688923716545, 0.0053639840334653854, -0.0038386788219213486, 0.004992958158254623, 0.011086237616837025, 0.02739306353032589, 0.0044200303964316845, 0.007975095883011818, 0.05877646431326866, -0.030040999874472618, -0.007700528483837843, -0.023169375956058502, -0.0010215911315754056, -0.03600113093852997, 0.030161052942276, 0.011526308953762054, -0.025434035807847977, 0.03756730630993843, -0.07604190707206726, 0.010452071204781532, 0.05983582139015198, -0.033652618527412415, -0.0011405871482566, 0.012513753958046436, 0.017568396404385567, -0.01600826345384121, 0.07128404825925827, -0.011944117024540901, 0.02390463277697563, 0.005676324479281902, 0.05697311833500862, 0.05369365215301514, 0.012747234664857388, 0.00776359997689724, -0.057153452187776566, -0.021508578211069107, 0.0307606253772974, 0.04101451858878136, 0.004837567452341318, 0.03283970057964325, -0.066872738301754, -0.0362006351351738, 0.05334305390715599, -0.028276462107896805, 0.011940322816371918, 0.005025653634220362, 0.05150696262717247, 0.010910769924521446, 0.009165726602077484, 0.013346054591238499, -0.011699970811605453, 0.02214815281331539, 0.007926140911877155, 0.00036164524499326944, 0.04230254143476486, -0.004606802482157946, -0.0012060095323249698, 0.006911939010024071, -0.0005057332455180585, -0.055382609367370605, 0.024555297568440437, 0.006582132540643215, -0.058583471924066544, -0.0026889347936958075, -0.01432017795741558, 0.0345652736723423, -0.027811909094452858, -0.008776332251727581, -0.0068707591854035854, 0.014080075547099113, 0.04481285810470581, 0.017836907878518105, -0.05020015314221382, -0.006476891227066517, -0.03632232919335365, -0.03997223824262619, 0.016179626807570457, -0.011356395669281483, -0.00491327466443181, -0.058426033705472946, -0.05575406923890114, 0.0030595797579735518, 0.028507085517048836, -0.04494095593690872, -0.039814066141843796, -0.011012235656380653, 0.05786915868520737, -0.028686048462986946, 0.00816135574132204, 0.02243848517537117, 0.0000072632064984645694, -0.026334719732403755, -0.05736323073506355, 0.033016644418239594, 0.018726129084825516, 0.008079402148723602, -0.0453176312148571, -0.02575512044131756, -0.02504965476691723, 0.008543877862393856, 0.07141115516424179, -0.023180581629276276, -0.022467629984021187, -0.01750766858458519, -0.015638208016753197, 0.024019237607717514, -0.04515170678496361, -0.0012279236689209938, -0.0046513499692082405, -0.02403336577117443, -0.0022703197319060564, -0.030168913304805756, -0.00497986888512969, 0.011256039142608643, -0.013035072013735771, 0.018098829314112663, -0.035102542489767075, 0.00041616804082877934, 0.004100512247532606, 0.009605402126908302, 0.015148865059018135, -0.009300663135945797, 0.010749207809567451, 0.010915867984294891, -0.013057094067335129, 0.011717653833329678, 0.005195305682718754, -0.05764821916818619, 0.014960289932787418, -0.02879839949309826, -0.013765146024525166, 0.011074582114815712, 0.015211851336061954, -0.012383496388792992, -0.042582180351018906, -0.051651258021593094, 0.03328217193484306, -0.01633939892053604, 0.05228264629840851, 0.02711474895477295, 0.03238489106297493, 0.04459734633564949, 0.009157155640423298, 0.011006771586835384, -0.00008330524724442512, 0.028918137773871422, 0.02376323565840721, 0.028289783746004105, -0.003912249580025673, -0.020592911168932915, 0.017085574567317963, -0.028317878022789955, -0.02596992813050747, 0.04453599825501442, -0.024574613198637962, 0.03227550908923149, 0.024511946365237236, -0.030619719997048378, -0.01675967313349247, -0.004532806109637022, -0.005848592612892389, 0.008386439643800259, 0.034369535744190216, 0.057271141558885574, -0.04091537743806839, 0.027013111859560013, -0.00850935373455286, -0.03405356779694557, -0.030538076534867287, 0.03441160172224045, 0.014299732632935047, -0.021071329712867737, 0.014807184226810932, -0.015085158869624138, 0.0291366595774889, -0.003589427564293146, 0.017816990613937378, -0.028712447732686996, -0.009383092634379864, -0.005079100374132395, 0.021443752571940422, -0.012915094383060932, -0.059645574539899826, -0.024629272520542145, -0.011395306326448917, 0.03151727095246315, -0.0013100574724376202, 0.03236478939652443, -0.0077402638271451, -0.029837043955922127, -0.050824470818042755, 0.02845868468284607, -0.06858503818511963, -0.012890608981251717, -0.04208194091916084, 0.0034233685582876205, -0.027613678947091103, -0.01901939883828163 ]
<h2>Scenario:</h2> <p>Consider a statement, e.g. "This movie is an action" Then let people vote on that. 1-5 where 1 is "Not action", 3 is "Some action" and 5 is "Pure action". </p> <h2>Question</h2> <p>How does one determine how accurate the the statement from the voting result?</p> <p>1000 votes where 900 is a 5 is pretty accurate, but 1000 votes with 500 1's and 500 5's is not very accurate. Also 3 votes and all a 5 is not so accurate.</p> <p>Basically determine the certainty how much an object is of a specific category from uservotes. </p> <p>I'm having some problem explaining my idea, but ask any questions and I'll try to clarify</p>
36,340
[ -0.038430266082286835, -0.02777091972529888, 0.006061667110770941, 0.0009122309274971485, 0.036036357283592224, -0.002984877908602357, -0.020399415865540504, -0.03091418370604515, 0.027789905667304993, -0.010181942954659462, 0.048217128962278366, 0.014897836372256279, 0.029513541609048843, 0.08571300655603409, -0.046586740761995316, 0.018330983817577362, 0.029550565406680107, -0.0026718988083302975, 0.004039831459522247, -0.008951007388532162, -0.011252027936279774, 0.0036831938195973635, -0.02438429370522499, -0.017562054097652435, -0.022954799234867096, 0.025023436173796654, 0.05215359106659889, 0.009740552864968777, 0.01761864684522152, 0.05183698982000351, -0.03231097757816315, -0.025488615036010742, 0.05128828436136246, 0.02813221886754036, 0.02411634288728237, 0.04675140231847763, -0.011326843872666359, -0.019348911941051483, -0.015510689467191696, 0.00877764355391264, 0.02949274145066738, 0.024725450202822685, 0.00797626655548811, 0.015002643689513206, -0.04673532396554947, -0.006245910655707121, -0.002703634323552251, 0.008924398571252823, 0.010490781627595425, -0.05190015584230423, 0.06534381210803986, -0.00919046625494957, 0.05466319993138313, 0.03297489508986473, 0.020515412092208862, -0.008053842931985855, 0.049110379070043564, 0.07411249727010727, -0.01617455668747425, -0.04533481225371361, -0.04005015641450882, -0.042589277029037476, 0.020079078152775764, -0.04414306953549385, 0.0014406939735636115, 0.017998045310378075, -0.016441896557807922, -0.00581451365724206, 0.02176916040480137, -0.0035757350269705057, -0.022674890235066414, -0.011702635325491428, 0.009853852912783623, 0.022774728015065193, 0.01466442458331585, -0.051739808171987534, 0.03817668929696083, 0.04319971054792404, 0.06477590650320053, 0.041470788419246674, -0.013438867405056953, 0.015519696287810802, 0.0221314188092947, 0.03916100412607193, 0.038754671812057495, -0.02305837906897068, 0.03158488869667053, -0.018210815265774727, 0.0009208693518303335, 0.006452713627368212, -0.005111406557261944, -0.04412652179598808, 0.020542139187455177, 0.031050704419612885, -0.0415026992559433, 0.024047065526247025, -0.017803682014346123, 0.02720307931303978, 0.02198873646557331, 0.02275829389691353, 0.011032690294086933, -0.00770949013531208, 0.03588267043232918, 0.05448256433010101, -0.02670343965291977, -0.010190206579864025, -0.0260927751660347, -0.03741727024316788, -0.010177124291658401, 0.008325223810970783, -0.0045034801587462425, 0.019816162064671516, 0.015568956732749939, -0.005011301022022963, 0.029612084850668907, -0.036037810146808624, -0.033459845930337906, -0.040222346782684326, 0.045181915163993835, 0.020418407395482063, 0.036639850586652756, -0.0040087345987558365, 0.012073608115315437, -0.024696722626686096, -0.034737855195999146, -0.0006142758065834641, 0.05812433362007141, -0.007993512786924839, -0.030575191602110863, 0.04803206026554108, -0.03000424988567829, -0.02398102916777134, -0.004276012070477009, -0.01329046767205, 0.06216667592525482, 0.018408220261335373, -0.08108225464820862, -0.06698027998209, 0.00831653643399477, 0.05758088454604149, -0.05135525390505791, -0.05818658694624901, 0.03160381689667702, 0.02605358324944973, 0.043586526066064835, 0.06574348360300064, 0.012625365518033504, 0.06725579500198364, 0.03446468338370323, 0.03263947740197182, -0.02591618523001671, -0.0048039862886071205, -0.02863181009888649, -0.013265528716146946, -0.03825061023235321, -0.06178268417716026, 0.05135439708828926, -0.02694222889840603, -0.03779454156756401, -0.014104228466749191, -0.01898888126015663, 0.016852354630827904, -0.026205336675047874, 0.011057847179472446, 0.029248487204313278, -0.01074405200779438, 0.06903605163097382, -0.0018284377874806523, 0.004515997599810362, -0.00570495193824172, -0.000014420004845305812, 0.0389094203710556, 0.05138696730136871, 0.011023134924471378, 0.0415804386138916, 0.01028923224657774, -0.028945554047822952, -0.025537891313433647, 0.022244319319725037, -0.0328112356364727, -0.0450638085603714, -0.03342529013752937, -0.04770151898264885, 0.02313699573278427, 0.00984930619597435, 0.016988499090075493, -0.013256186619400978, -0.02096020244061947, 0.038056716322898865, -0.03304228559136391, -0.02759172022342682, -0.04539906978607178, 0.004078252706676722, -0.0064270091243088245, -0.0056323641911149025, -0.007882016710937023, -0.02343457192182541, -0.01821746863424778, -0.027326956391334534, 0.009774655103683472, -0.03922370448708534, 0.007939284667372704, 0.04371747374534607, -0.028122197836637497, 0.020517589524388313, -0.0007776099373586476, 0.014009802602231503, -0.049777161329984665, -0.0024372534826397896, -0.025425409898161888, -0.054973069578409195, -0.019173631444573402, 0.0057685403153300285, -0.012026159092783928, 0.011566122062504292, -0.019367821514606476, 0.05408165976405144, -0.022103887051343918, 0.007138621062040329, 0.03765968605875969, -0.03330650180578232, 0.0865495577454567, 0.050579022616147995, -0.02156222052872181, 0.024165112525224686, -0.0071904039941728115, -0.00954927783459425, -0.017715539783239365, 0.005457598250359297, -0.0026454105973243713, -0.09191172569990158, 0.016867315396666527, 0.02718670479953289, 0.00043522613123059273, -0.0180427897721529, 0.0027341230306774378, 0.03963746875524521, 0.015783589333295822, 0.01419441681355238, 0.015029950067400932, -0.014655712991952896, 0.029460934922099113, 0.017713449895381927, 0.01346784271299839, 0.031186679378151894, 0.012931597419083118, 0.011930934153497219, 0.024041663855314255, 0.03446328639984131, 0.04175024479627609, 0.023483088240027428, 0.04877566546201706, 0.016412727534770966, 0.027187690138816833, -0.004748528823256493, -0.010978467762470245, 0.026430394500494003, 0.00609678914770484, 0.008549110032618046, 0.038857702165842056, 0.004774404689669609, -0.005519840866327286, -0.01193091832101345, -0.007737267762422562, 0.0252776350826025, 0.049119118601083755, -0.045596469193696976, 0.003551742061972618, 0.023128140717744827, 0.017694750800728798, 0.030041327700018883, -0.020028788596391678, -0.009050419554114342, -0.03928348794579506, 0.00884124357253313, 0.032008618116378784, -0.029785461723804474, 0.026566894724965096, -0.04259447753429413, -0.01811460591852665, -0.010823281481862068, -0.037726614624261856, 0.021914320066571236, -0.018747618421912193, -0.09046799689531326, -0.014196081086993217, 0.012382114306092262, 0.002770830411463976, 0.00444440171122551, 0.007975977845489979, -0.05263619124889374, 0.016528042033314705, 0.007465335074812174, -0.05171038582921028, 0.0009503989131189883, -0.032238200306892395, 0.012905425392091274, -0.028741829097270966, -0.015766790136694908, 0.010381225496530533, -0.013550028204917908, -0.051844581961631775, 0.07397463917732239, -0.011016407050192356, -0.05505269393324852, -0.03867487236857414, -0.04442421719431877, 0.006758429575711489, -0.030483679845929146, 0.0346030555665493, 0.040452856570482254, 0.017159536480903625, -0.00022091749997343868, -0.08874807506799698, -0.052346501499414444, 0.037945859134197235, 0.006641120184212923, 0.026082554832100868, 0.01586839370429516, -0.017955409362912178, 0.09746170789003372, 0.009628543630242348, -0.059742894023656845, -0.014446974731981754, -0.016928724944591522, -0.0204718466848135, -0.025510823354125023, -0.019150983542203903, 0.009116064757108688, -0.004718089010566473, 0.023589469492435455, 0.049803778529167175, 0.010605894960463047, 0.017090631648898125, -0.0035478228237479925, -0.010078826919198036, -0.009860473684966564, 0.006348919589072466, -0.004729417618364096, 0.05426245555281639, 0.051526132971048355, -0.06853964924812317, 0.041122227907180786, -0.01229304913431406, -0.0037720827385783195, 0.02936715818941593, -0.04146309942007065, 0.016307927668094635, -0.02688203752040863, 0.010287276469171047, 0.00042815893539227545, 0.025629432871937752, -0.0071670361794531345, -0.017139768227934837, -0.014089955948293209, 0.03519570827484131, 0.03753668814897537, 0.00012922326277475804, -0.008953849785029888, 0.041846517473459244, 0.07118470966815948, -0.011139178648591042, -0.031439702957868576, -0.02165261097252369, -0.007619124837219715, 0.004274923820048571, -0.015539707615971565, -0.0013695376692339778, 0.051420073956251144, 0.02911268174648285, 0.017697980627417564, 0.02780284732580185, 0.0037780392449349165, -0.029624346643686295, -0.033516958355903625, -0.02549397386610508, -0.029761288315057755, 0.05818154662847519, 0.00008337500912602991, 0.04583077132701874, 0.03893042728304863, -0.012733648531138897, -0.03546330705285072, 0.0169498510658741, -0.04185788333415985, 0.009900986216962337, -0.019679732620716095, -0.00768187316134572, -0.011796320788562298, -0.0035766696091741323, -0.018730511888861656, -0.012303175404667854, -0.00955850351601839, -0.005734160076826811, 0.020554348826408386, -0.04257798194885254, -0.014621347188949585, 0.03240706026554108, -0.01327943429350853, -0.015715977177023888, 0.007705540396273136, 0.03096841275691986, 0.02480723150074482, 0.047360144555568695, -0.011450864374637604, 0.014848143793642521, -0.01663777604699135, -0.02726668491959572, -0.016467105597257614, 0.019221415743231773, 0.03763715177774429, 0.0029590229969471693, 0.019482199102640152, -0.015884075313806534, 0.06160441413521767, -0.008887379430234432, 0.03018023818731308, 0.024927614256739616, -0.019445477053523064, -0.04341248422861099, -0.04475616291165352, -0.00649151811376214, 0.003067685291171074, 0.02415681816637516, -0.007452649530023336, -0.037711288779973984, -0.008813845925033092, 0.027325879782438278, -0.03205975517630577, 0.020215755328536034, 0.11146637052297592, -0.015717310830950737, -0.055421456694602966, -0.028860848397016525, 0.022449159994721413, 0.01157284528017044, -0.023726586252450943, 0.019812297075986862, 0.018697720021009445, 0.015860551968216896, -0.02232844941318035, 0.006749140098690987, -0.012322958558797836, -0.07497553527355194, -0.019807107746601105, -0.03754012659192085, 0.027074851095676422, 0.0014592154184356332, -0.021751979365944862, 0.014119512401521206, 0.03183290362358093, 0.06212440878152847, -0.005056306719779968, -0.0035039749927818775, -0.10435736924409866, 0.008998895063996315, 0.033207546919584274, 0.05304987356066704, -0.057159435003995895, -0.02942166104912758, -0.0158891212195158, -0.014190331101417542, 0.018168741837143898, -0.03278889134526253, 0.05977025628089905, -0.027452895417809486, 0.02819955348968506, -0.0013925718376412988, 0.006568003445863724, -0.02848115749657154, -0.014045871794223785, -0.020858855918049812, 0.03921378403902054, -0.01875736191868782, -0.004820380825549364, -0.051606882363557816, -0.009115164168179035, 0.04201335459947586, 0.06116795539855957, -0.02215532585978508, 0.017956899479031563, -0.04676566645503044, 0.0065575758926570415, -0.06285262107849121, -0.052614644169807434, 0.022523649036884308, -0.007733521051704884, -0.034524235874414444, 0.04552575945854187, -0.012231589294970036, -0.03814133629202843, 0.012174392119050026, -0.01959807425737381, -0.01913873292505741, -0.008235306479036808, -0.002126129111275077, 0.013549385592341423, 0.044799454510211945, 0.01962278038263321, 0.019207654520869255, 0.03212637081742287, -0.017043309286236763, 0.024181989952921867, -0.0075936708599328995, -0.003113040467724204, 0.030433621257543564, 0.0034773340448737144, -0.023098161444067955, 0.004941227380186319, -0.05038755387067795, -0.0067976005375385284, 0.028200611472129822, 0.031775880604982376, 0.00102291873190552, -0.01097925379872322, -0.029012780636548996, 0.018393496051430702, -0.0048376345075666904, -0.0015001853462308645, -0.003933385014533997, 0.029743440449237823, 0.016329582780599594, 0.0052553280256688595, 0.019290145486593246, -0.008905439637601376, 0.0023216542322188616, 0.021888896822929382, -0.002741429954767227, 0.019121479243040085, -0.05063273385167122, -0.005644048564136028, -0.0007485039532184601, -0.05731571093201637, 0.037055715918540955, -0.0018624264048412442, 0.00849495455622673, 0.008752841502428055, -0.04516986012458801, -0.020056841894984245, 0.024958563968539238, -0.00008138236444210634, 0.031350359320640564, -0.017694447189569473, 0.04910946264863014, -0.0022758604027330875, -0.01999255269765854, -0.049674950540065765, -0.004447076935321093, 0.0400298647582531, 0.05587220564484596, -0.023614710196852684, -0.033010244369506836, 0.020935263484716415, -0.03589073196053505, -0.007265728432685137, -0.03714167699217796, 0.07593197375535965, -0.0373569019138813, -0.005908078048378229, 0.022853167727589607, -0.0175306499004364, 0.08274559676647186, -0.01718963123857975, -0.003525053383782506, -0.01564894989132881, -0.008161758072674274, 0.004745668265968561, 0.019870620220899582, 0.007084003649652004, -0.04564259201288223, -0.029993180185556412, -0.027582669630646706, 0.029135510325431824, 0.008125126361846924, -0.000164604585734196, 0.07388047128915787, 0.011988643556833267, -0.013721977360546589, -0.002642042003571987, -0.03573227673768997, 0.00701288552954793, -0.0015135833527892828, -0.0071079544723033905, 0.01702767238020897, -0.020156944170594215, -0.02059330977499485, 0.021275658160448074, 0.009708777070045471, 0.013852865435183048, -0.034987010061740875, -0.018640518188476562, 0.06011287495493889, -0.03658050298690796, 0.04801693558692932, 0.04268656298518181, -0.030195845291018486, 0.06430989503860474, 0.00799487717449665, -0.024303168058395386, 0.04269396886229515, 0.039359014481306076, -0.032381221652030945, 0.011973770335316658, -0.022270547226071358, -0.014065963216125965, 0.07117592543363571, -0.005695666186511517, 0.06061380356550217, 0.04127718508243561, 0.03141878917813301, 0.017563970759510994, -0.013244911096990108, -0.009780995547771454, -0.03306400775909424, 0.028836321085691452, -0.004359950311481953, -0.026911383494734764, 0.006678781006485224, 0.014873798005282879, 0.014546883292496204, 0.01606106571853161, -0.002048302674666047, 0.039901960641145706, 0.028421664610505104, 0.04841278865933418, -0.05125056579709053, -0.005317308474332094, 0.004204182885587215, -0.06061346083879471, -0.0169669259339571, 0.012644533067941666, -0.061557888984680176, 0.019045567139983177, -0.004775951150804758, -0.0257783941924572, -0.005580390337854624, -0.01879451796412468, -0.06190039962530136, 0.05436036363244057, -0.007809566333889961, 0.038806553930044174, 0.002509364625439048, -0.009228803217411041, 0.002654883312061429, -0.015544841066002846, 0.0249168798327446, -0.00005376847184379585, -0.09465311467647552, -0.01595141738653183, -0.02176482044160366, -0.061317767947912216, -0.019301652908325195, 0.027197163552045822, -0.021022366359829903, 0.033413056284189224, -0.028319040313363075, -0.005651487968862057, 0.014834984205663204, 0.062783382833004, -0.02307412400841713, 0.040267109870910645, -0.00190248666331172, 0.06120825186371803, -0.006542773451656103, 0.01568560302257538, 0.10484007745981216, 0.0564127042889595, 0.006539667025208473, -0.030156584456562996, -0.011546780355274677, -0.003643646603450179, 0.01079470943659544, -0.01017230935394764, 0.03359207510948181, 0.045823708176612854, 0.027420103549957275, 0.018834589049220085, 0.031860560178756714, 0.04157532751560211, 0.0016335356049239635, 0.04853050410747528, -0.031359802931547165, -0.016127947717905045, 0.03394399583339691, 0.01201238390058279, -0.006189010571688414, -0.033251725137233734, -0.023421669378876686, 0.0457942895591259, 0.04115830361843109, -0.01609129086136818, -0.003963502123951912, -0.021808916702866554, 0.002941800281405449, 0.019991081207990646, -0.028963884338736534, -0.007238286547362804, -0.004238569643348455, 0.03457541763782501, -0.04144613817334175, -0.0008901251712813973, 0.022181028500199318, -0.03629332780838013, 0.017682744190096855, 0.02611609920859337, 0.052497707307338715, -0.008615351282060146, 0.0030255853198468685, 0.0024223255459219217, -0.03911910951137543, -0.04727064445614815, -0.06461058557033539, 0.020848320797085762, -0.0008772226283326745, 0.007777038961648941, -0.05211794748902321, 0.017314305528998375, -0.0214141383767128, -0.05443514138460159, -0.015289083123207092, 0.027783993631601334, 0.012243138626217842, 0.0016614857595413923, -0.0442587174475193, -0.015705980360507965, 0.026621924713253975, -0.04552597925066948, 0.025430837646126747, 0.010764069855213165, 0.015023712068796158, -0.03683412820100784, 0.010652221739292145, 0.009535946883261204, 0.01740218885242939, -0.00785746332257986, -0.004388114903122187, -0.03067782148718834, -0.03447696566581726, 0.005923120304942131, -0.029513269662857056, 0.0377650186419487, 0.025158105418086052, 0.0023347369860857725, 0.021906044334173203, -0.007944433018565178, -0.024195019155740738, 0.020881665870547295, -0.01790105178952217, -0.011183986440300941, -0.047386519610881805, -0.01504852157086134, 0.020229564979672432, -0.02069750614464283, -0.0354020819067955, -0.01556975394487381, 0.03025002032518387, 0.03584069758653641, 0.023975050076842308, -0.04684682935476303, -0.013269230723381042, 0.025968145579099655, -0.029745295643806458, -0.01001899503171444, 0.00837225653231144, 0.0728413537144661, 0.022651689127087593, 0.028553597629070282, 0.013076378032565117, 0.006593699567019939, -0.008657512255012989, 0.02229163609445095, 0.0389939546585083, -0.0575002022087574, -0.021877434104681015, -0.015509398654103279, -0.010338570922613144, -0.0460275374352932, -0.004261696245521307, -0.03785378485918045, -0.04822777211666107, 0.011739633977413177, 0.002216963330283761, -0.018172821030020714, 0.00604315334931016, -0.0217802282422781, 0.0198003351688385, -0.013124284334480762, -0.0015300229424610734, -0.029761532321572304, -0.005946749821305275, 0.014831630513072014, -0.02076585777103901, -0.008021549321711063, -0.007729147560894489, 0.027569258585572243, -0.007215198595076799, 0.012906408868730068, -0.02005905471742153, -0.023936716839671135, -0.03834693506360054, 0.020511554554104805, -0.02459714561700821, 0.04437756910920143, -0.026752419769763947, -0.02216661535203457, 0.03635401651263237, -0.04755163937807083, 0.008366873487830162, 0.038370806723833084, -0.003403330221772194, 0.04004066437482834, 0.03385268524289131, -0.04604310914874077, 0.034024350345134735, 0.04525435343384743, -0.021983878687024117, -0.03523433580994606, 0.03385385498404503, 0.008373216725885868, 0.005669392645359039, 0.03409506753087044, -0.010403480380773544, -0.005734746810048819, 0.010313447564840317, 0.00406789081171155, 0.02086193859577179, 0.02476266771554947, -0.032404426485300064, 0.02926945872604847, 0.008305162191390991, -0.02288726530969143, 0.018101537600159645, 0.0077462526969611645, -0.018120774999260902, 0.057570215314626694, -0.05065570026636124, 0.008928360417485237, -0.01863645575940609, 0.026976317167282104, -0.05435594916343689, -0.035013772547245026, 0.002711353125050664, -0.0017196527915075421, 0.037027642130851746, -0.037825826555490494, 0.058369141072034836, 0.04578353837132454, -0.06004715338349342, -0.008166100829839706, -0.03937605395913124, -0.0006492249667644501, -0.02064923755824566, 0.004985929932445288, -0.019252555444836617, 0.016758978366851807, -0.008499999530613422, 0.00996039342135191, 0.02995465323328972, 0.014334662817418575, -0.02073080651462078, -0.05559023469686508, -0.025986161082983017, 0.04333921894431114, -0.0428982749581337, -0.054082781076431274, 0.040970806032419205, -0.022873159497976303, -0.047757748514413834, 0.03517332673072815, -0.05573475733399391, 0.02990037202835083, 0.031871017068624496, 0.029293926432728767, 0.01065644808113575, -0.006462005898356438, 0.02339627593755722, -0.017016146332025528, -0.05336437746882439, 0.010898423381149769, 0.025723611935973167, 0.041653845459222794, -0.006647629197686911, 0.015440456569194794, 0.03575090318918228, -0.02129163034260273, -0.02326044999063015, 0.03609180822968483, 0.004513130988925695, -0.030251294374465942, 0.010039951652288437, -0.036993034183979034, -0.014187905006110668, -0.016705533489584923, 0.00863321591168642, -0.04344286769628525, 0.013798559084534645, 0.036960430443286896, -0.020946582779288292, 0.011167448945343494, -0.04087832570075989, -0.008841246366500854, -0.05576905608177185, 0.038395240902900696, -0.002321721985936165, -0.033125605434179306, -0.06514532119035721, 0.0007248045294545591, 0.02963089570403099, -0.00834143441170454, 0.009903836995363235, -0.044027432799339294, -0.019793599843978882, 0.042553793638944626, 0.006267354357987642, 0.015043647959828377, 0.022267958149313927, -0.034486375749111176, -0.035622481256723404, -0.08660796284675598, 0.06750369817018509, 0.0350349023938179, -0.022557824850082397, -0.021229814738035202, 0.02612934075295925, -0.02559945359826088, -0.012544454075396061, 0.02704552561044693, 0.00905553624033928, -0.03112832084298134, -0.015262052416801453, -0.04205359145998955, -0.004958734847605228, -0.021775607019662857, -0.008067900314927101, -0.029708335176110268, -0.018338441848754883, -0.059417687356472015, 0.02006179839372635, -0.014030029065907001, -0.005404189694672823, 0.04254058748483658, -0.012990343384444714, -0.034385714679956436, -0.05305209383368492, -0.021096879616379738, 0.040022414177656174, 0.014338486827909946, 0.031395114958286285, 0.02305067703127861, 0.030421944335103035, -0.0071909441612660885, 0.013662530109286308, 0.021090900525450706, -0.009394744411110878, 0.027029119431972504, -0.0038352073170244694, -0.051394786685705185, -0.006051106844097376, 0.0182303786277771, 0.009093566797673702, -0.09634852409362793, -0.015455041080713272, 0.030080009251832962, -0.018847845494747162, 0.029751010239124298, 0.06510575860738754, 0.03375039994716644, 0.04068931192159653, 0.010356352664530277, 0.029779929667711258, 0.012134995311498642, -0.028839481994509697, 0.006348606199026108, 0.0076659442856907845, 0.03661062940955162, 0.029101772233843803, 0.038024161010980606, 0.04792315885424614, -0.003945409320294857, 0.0365821048617363, 0.006056474056094885, 0.06905852258205414, 0.0025403161998838186, 0.03051488660275936, -0.010083136148750782, -0.003309096908196807, 0.0039705499075353146, 0.03445865586400032, -0.03754520043730736, 0.05312951281666756, -0.041221968829631805, -0.010609839111566544, -0.04128243029117584, 0.016887204721570015, -0.02120315656065941, -0.01304782833904028, 0.031727004796266556, 0.041509225964546204, 0.02954825572669506, 0.008847855031490326, -0.007825717329978943, 0.02959875389933586, 0.019821958616375923, 0.0007087362464517355, 0.0249282568693161, -0.028742719441652298, -0.004887111950665712, 0.004784655291587114, -0.01124203484505415, -0.025911998003721237, 0.0051253605633974075, 0.0275203175842762, 0.001866244012489915, 0.04995230957865715, -0.0106969540938735, -0.06064722687005997, -0.04643751680850983, 0.01102522574365139, -0.03451356291770935, -0.01839441992342472, -0.014830204658210278, 0.060063790529966354, 0.0013894352596253157, -0.02961745671927929 ]
<p>I have some satellite tag time-at-depth (TAD) frequency data that I would like some help with.</p> <p>The data was transmitted via satellite as percent time spent in each of 7 depth bins (0m, 0-1m, 1-10m, 10-50m etc.), binned over 6-hour intervals. I categorized each row of data corresponding to a date and time into summer vs. winter, and day vs. night, and then summed and averaged the given % for each depth bin. My data looks like this (for one individual, HG03):</p> <pre><code>HG03.dat Season Time Depth Sum Avrg 1 summ day 0 17.2 0.1702970 2 summ day 1 23.9 0.2366337 3 summ day 10 868.5 8.5990099 4 summ day 50 2698.2 26.7148515 5 summ day 100 419.7 4.1554455 6 summ day 200 266.1 2.6346535 7 summ day 300 1668.6 16.5207921 8 summ day 500 4138.2 40.9722772 9 summ night 0 283.6 5.7877551 10 summ night 1 229.1 4.6755102 11 summ night 10 479.3 9.7816327 12 summ night 50 761.9 15.5489796 13 summ night 100 235.8 4.8122449 14 summ night 200 40.9 0.8346939 15 summ night 300 763.1 15.5734694 16 summ night 500 2106.1 42.9816327 17 wint day 0 0.0 0.0000000 18 wint day 1 0.0 0.0000000 19 wint day 10 0.0 0.0000000 20 wint day 50 0.0 0.0000000 21 wint day 100 7.9 1.1285714 22 wint day 200 92.1 13.1571429 23 wint day 300 0.0 0.0000000 24 wint day 500 600.0 85.7142857 25 wint night 0 43.9 1.7560000 26 wint night 1 0.3 0.0120000 27 wint night 10 0.3 0.0120000 28 wint night 50 0.8 0.0320000 29 wint night 100 10.5 0.4200000 30 wint night 200 51.6 2.0640000 31 wint night 300 411.4 16.4560000 32 wint night 500 1981.2 79.2480000 </code></pre> <p>I wanted to test whether significant differences existed between depth in summer vs. winter, and day vs. night, controlling first for season and then for time of day. I carried out a Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel test, using Average Frequency (Avrg) as the dependent variable (2x2x8 contingency table).</p> <pre><code>&gt; ct&lt;-xtabs(Avrg~Time+Depth+Season,data=HG03.dat) &gt; mantelhaen.test(ct) Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel test data: ct Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel M^2 = 28.4548, df = 7, p-value = 0.0001818 &gt; ct&lt;-xtabs(Avrg~Season+Depth+Time,data=HG03.dat) &gt; mantelhaen.test(ct) Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel test data: ct Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel M^2 = 111.5986, df = 7, p-value &lt; 2.2e-16 </code></pre> <p>However, I'm not sure if these results are valid, since my raw data is already in frequencies, not in counts. When I used Sum as the dependent variable, I obtained different results.</p> <p>I am at a loss on how to proceed. If anyone has any ideas, they would be greatly appreciated. </p>
36,345
[ -0.0011732904240489006, 0.0009075129637494683, -0.03180390223860741, -0.00019279868865851313, 0.044642169028520584, -0.0059857843443751335, -0.008690246380865574, -0.016342170536518097, 0.04903078451752663, -0.06169929355382919, 0.03675917536020279, 0.06852412223815918, -0.0013248047325760126, 0.02504155971109867, 0.02092297188937664, -0.014805766753852367, -0.021734539419412613, -0.015118930488824844, 0.016142645850777626, 0.00028300186386331916, -0.005762315820902586, 0.019198324531316757, -0.0022346843034029007, -0.02457496151328087, -0.025805886834859848, 0.043735750019550323, 0.03789212182164192, 0.0025492326822131872, -0.015611053444445133, 0.04724934697151184, -0.00782649964094162, -0.04724825546145439, 0.02102295495569706, 0.012295372784137726, 0.012333094142377377, 0.022745531052350998, -0.03308519721031189, -0.0285183172672987, -0.01729229837656021, 0.041643738746643066, 0.00045186132774688303, 0.027536164969205856, -0.027060553431510925, -0.0038703735917806625, -0.016350416466593742, 0.006679186597466469, 0.01579294167459011, 0.01596948876976967, 0.04882221668958664, -0.02488045208156109, 0.05005403235554695, -0.010972380638122559, 0.022495118901133537, -0.005142314825206995, -0.03213752061128616, -0.008005782030522823, 0.009774393402040005, 0.055724553763866425, 0.05363096296787262, -0.02184187062084675, -0.005782136227935553, -0.025726940482854843, -0.019312776625156403, -0.03466592729091644, 0.012720867991447449, -0.005726386792957783, 0.00032987675513140857, -0.011390247382223606, 0.0395733118057251, -0.0071588000282645226, 0.008211798034608364, -0.014510314911603928, 0.022520413622260094, -0.026216933503746986, -0.019169121980667114, -0.02020845003426075, 0.033371683210134506, 0.03052518703043461, 0.022976186126470566, 0.02826370857656002, 0.003990365657955408, 0.02457074634730816, 0.004916973877698183, 0.01886710524559021, 0.046253763139247894, 0.004417652264237404, 0.06363516300916672, -0.033280808478593826, 0.008095934987068176, 0.03705378994345665, 0.0012585564982146025, 0.037355076521635056, 0.007778117898851633, 0.05748862400650978, -0.011349738575518131, 0.07302024215459824, -0.004086533561348915, 0.014377058483660221, 0.03308486565947533, -0.01662389747798443, 0.00116362061817199, -0.05047683045268059, 0.027332454919815063, 0.05259758606553078, -0.014988716691732407, -0.014844216406345367, -0.03624747321009636, -0.011005683802068233, -0.02258383482694626, -0.03963182121515274, -0.017892945557832718, 0.021364957094192505, -0.007082105148583651, -0.02742900140583515, -0.006151117384433746, -0.06062130257487297, 0.012569155544042587, 0.001374528743326664, 0.049387384206056595, 0.07078366726636887, 0.08802514523267746, -0.009217413142323494, 0.06116005405783653, -0.04904508963227272, -0.05554309859871864, 0.013365890830755234, -0.017351577058434486, -0.029032554477453232, -0.03283162787556648, 0.049126170575618744, 0.0003392772632651031, -0.038852889090776443, 0.07394003868103027, -0.03729408234357834, 0.013809486292302608, -0.01782255619764328, -0.07449529320001602, -0.040115442126989365, 0.01772703044116497, -0.020913787186145782, 0.03795454278588295, -0.030871393159031868, 0.01259810570627451, -0.012178417295217514, 0.017773142084479332, 0.014073562808334827, 0.03002263233065605, 0.006860912311822176, 0.01346657145768404, 0.026586543768644333, -0.047770269215106964, -0.015576488338410854, 0.0013997935457155108, -0.024592285975813866, -0.01933255046606064, -0.07525680214166641, 0.02109498158097267, -0.01143846195191145, -0.000204469557502307, 0.018168920651078224, 0.0255289189517498, 0.00699631217867136, 0.013600857928395271, -0.018344102427363396, -0.01225167978554964, -0.05185828357934952, 0.06239277869462967, 0.017839543521404266, 0.027942214161157608, 0.0277745109051466, -0.019108939915895462, -0.007321360055357218, -0.02006661519408226, 0.013552701100707054, 0.053739771246910095, -0.02181698940694332, 0.019389286637306213, -0.0006686780252493918, -0.004637869540601969, 0.0073922546580433846, 0.00576798664405942, -0.028532130643725395, -0.01235201209783554, 0.0038699766155332327, 0.056874122470617294, 0.04863835498690605, 0.010071096941828728, -0.01956832781434059, 0.03187386691570282, -0.025039441883563995, -0.02761910855770111, -0.019102497026324272, 0.0025447236839681864, -0.04686031863093376, -0.015886714681982994, -0.036278799176216125, 0.012374009937047958, 0.014884999953210354, 0.030178852379322052, -0.03858226537704468, 0.005825744941830635, 0.011209137737751007, 0.08122573047876358, -0.03655308857560158, -0.031088849529623985, 0.024561908096075058, 0.04139416664838791, 0.015090985223650932, 0.00915592908859253, -0.009855329059064388, -0.015574987046420574, -0.007954697124660015, -0.024538086727261543, 0.004226378630846739, -0.005871616769582033, 0.001241798629052937, 0.04012233018875122, 0.020197169855237007, -0.023208102211356163, 0.009279645048081875, -0.023889070376753807, 0.019632799550890923, 0.063480906188488, 0.002777205314487219, 0.03174351528286934, -0.012910230085253716, -0.0065276590175926685, 0.033740509301424026, 0.0008760079508647323, 0.0028455022256821394, -0.04736907035112381, 0.03279929235577583, 0.020681550726294518, -0.018303226679563522, 0.00983880739659071, 0.002374592935666442, 0.05597300082445145, 0.018924914300441742, 0.05030394718050957, 0.05543997138738632, 0.0012076360872015357, 0.006358901970088482, 0.02138162963092327, 0.026285788044333458, 0.0048097968101501465, -0.012392209842801094, 0.0520063191652298, 0.019986828789114952, 0.011443610303103924, 0.0024627374950796366, -0.02425391972064972, 0.043701425194740295, -0.008614415302872658, 0.013448935002088547, -0.0609646737575531, -0.019112536683678627, 0.04464774206280708, -0.03656382858753204, -0.021058214828372, 0.08394726365804672, -0.0054588899947702885, 0.0024435219820588827, -0.013454285450279713, -0.04269196838140488, 0.0014646531781181693, 0.043158553540706635, -0.007146351505070925, 0.008484989404678345, -0.0009246562840417027, -0.023089824244379997, 0.052325814962387085, -0.042574428021907806, -0.010829450562596321, -0.06103537231683731, 0.019927794113755226, 0.05801694095134735, 0.015124448575079441, 0.010940694250166416, -0.014156870543956757, 0.0050422209315001965, -0.02221699059009552, 0.022543031722307205, 0.006357356905937195, -0.001577656134031713, -0.05103958770632744, -0.03141409158706665, 0.00040832185186445713, -0.020350385457277298, 0.06138243153691292, 0.012782810255885124, -0.050943005830049515, 0.004137805663049221, 0.026157991960644722, -0.03227800503373146, -0.015041716396808624, -0.026111753657460213, 0.008860277943313122, -0.06445622444152832, -0.03711003437638283, 0.06692229956388474, 0.002704746089875698, -0.015907395631074905, 0.02328423596918583, -0.06470434367656708, -0.05335560813546181, -0.014579281210899353, 0.014538951218128204, -0.03049464337527752, -0.011880158446729183, -0.02304905839264393, -0.011632350273430347, -0.048026807606220245, 0.009180624037981033, -0.07026971876621246, -0.06794093549251556, -0.011233710683882236, 0.018189841881394386, -0.03795037791132927, 0.010327651165425777, -0.005401062313467264, 0.07090047001838684, 0.0724542886018753, -0.021348977461457253, -0.02795492857694626, 0.006663655862212181, -0.02283918485045433, 0.01067148707807064, 0.03645138815045357, -0.018685590475797653, 0.0035388704854995012, -0.0076808203011751175, -0.0209902822971344, 0.017371755093336105, 0.06569448113441467, 0.008140175603330135, 0.012162204831838608, 0.057701583951711655, 0.009069166146218777, -0.010210850276052952, 0.0619647279381752, 0.03543156012892723, -0.019915800541639328, -0.002130611799657345, -0.035623546689748764, -0.0009847590699791908, -0.00883170124143362, -0.042139969766139984, -0.005271371454000473, 0.015375218354165554, 0.009603908285498619, -0.024570902809500694, 0.01629500277340412, 0.03784644976258278, -0.01906431093811989, -0.0025812191888689995, 0.014362935908138752, 0.0633251741528511, -0.032797206193208694, -0.03174640238285065, 0.09306071698665619, 0.07583366334438324, -0.00020257105643395334, 0.0012693374883383512, 0.0020329842809587717, 0.012191484682261944, 0.007428311742842197, -0.06653748452663422, -0.014742947183549404, 0.028838559985160828, 0.06053633987903595, 0.03218366205692291, 0.010949881747364998, -0.05124257504940033, -0.008891929872334003, -0.06152266263961792, 0.0005456457147374749, -0.03370317444205284, 0.07324732840061188, 0.017481790855526924, 0.03528844565153122, 0.02447236143052578, -0.008434333838522434, 0.004221137147396803, 0.009090525098145008, -0.01897628791630268, 0.036793701350688934, 0.03351324051618576, -0.00877867266535759, 0.024325355887413025, -0.037297844886779785, -0.011075399816036224, -0.05179096385836601, -0.0069060130044817924, 0.005180463194847107, 0.005068187601864338, -0.016597837209701538, 0.004884494934231043, 0.029097534716129303, 0.010344351641833782, -0.0454007126390934, 0.04924975335597992, 0.05651294067502022, -0.007002559024840593, 0.012325112707912922, 0.05404796451330185, 0.011004474945366383, 0.010680175386369228, -0.04153395816683769, -0.013344946317374706, -0.012679965235292912, 0.006424147170037031, 0.05621481314301491, 0.033820658922195435, -0.045387137681245804, 0.004747308790683746, 0.04459288343787193, -0.008703423663973808, 0.013440803624689579, -0.00008442955004284158, -0.008335945196449757, 0.003418944776058197, 0.020005963742733, 0.05982869863510132, 0.0016450627008453012, 0.03451189771294594, -0.02529907412827015, 0.04946799576282501, 0.027014581486582756, -0.039976704865694046, 0.021498559042811394, 0.04476218298077583, -0.01615060679614544, 0.00299749500118196, -0.04918266460299492, -0.01857178471982479, -0.005217154044657946, -0.0025431590620428324, 0.03186997026205063, 0.036397188901901245, 0.03455878421664238, -0.01177655253559351, 0.016230467706918716, -0.015106947161257267, -0.009439186193048954, 0.02971373312175274, 0.036153171211481094, 0.003394458442926407, -0.0007965940167196095, -0.010079236701130867, 0.007005088031291962, 0.030873877927660942, 0.031321071088314056, -0.0009113882551901042, 0.03238638490438461, -0.11441274732351303, -0.032643914222717285, 0.0396612249314785, 0.06605667620897293, 0.010517300106585026, -0.021729199215769768, -0.031635843217372894, -0.00790003314614296, -0.010286673903465271, -0.0023360794875770807, 0.03706908971071243, 0.0118021285161376, 0.029662787914276123, 0.019952189177274704, -0.06955254077911377, -0.05567355453968048, 0.011089234612882137, -0.028862064704298973, 0.026975518092513084, -0.01352674700319767, -0.05070202425122261, -0.015231638215482235, 0.029628267511725426, 0.00570865860208869, 0.005892294459044933, -0.027538005262613297, -0.026297207921743393, -0.002008731011301279, -0.004502406809478998, -0.021588141098618507, -0.03351689875125885, 0.003960613161325455, 0.0004539776127785444, -0.0025430519599467516, 0.03562352433800697, -0.0036994318943470716, -0.013210495933890343, 0.03172300383448601, 0.03768008202314377, -0.03505481779575348, -0.030401980504393578, -0.04683210328221321, 0.034718532115221024, 0.029039697721600533, -0.0011604224564507604, 0.059075843542814255, 0.018076568841934204, -0.03601794317364693, 0.021291548386216164, -0.06988533586263657, 0.022235851734876633, 0.004509986378252506, -0.02238118276000023, -0.06266210228204727, -0.016490457579493523, 0.017255811020731926, 0.03935530409216881, -0.029544278979301453, 0.013776913285255432, -0.00836467556655407, -0.0016995741752907634, 0.023920616135001183, 0.016186613589525223, -0.029381541535258293, -0.01589706353843212, 0.022020330652594566, 0.015074215829372406, -0.02028920128941536, -0.016875149682164192, 0.012068326584994793, -0.051564641296863556, -0.03655587509274483, 0.015685250982642174, -0.01184793934226036, -0.000625313026830554, 0.004343098029494286, 0.0019025796791538596, 0.010664479807019234, 0.008635527454316616, 0.03731411695480347, -0.018718747422099113, 0.03603873401880264, 0.010065625421702862, -0.02077348902821541, -0.013269635848701, 0.021867549046874046, -0.004036776255816221, 0.02364981919527054, -0.028438495472073555, 0.014296897687017918, 0.015504707582294941, 0.03798408433794975, -0.06358799338340759, -0.05281371623277664, 0.035654108971357346, 0.015462002716958523, -0.05695056915283203, -0.0448768325150013, -0.021553345024585724, -0.0014641426969319582, 0.0020020108204334974, -0.011175251565873623, 0.0546446368098259, -0.04536452516913414, 0.004578812513500452, -0.01566934585571289, 0.014635966159403324, 0.0640357956290245, -0.007963175885379314, 0.03587685525417328, 0.026054054498672485, -0.0000021344260403566295, -0.02285950630903244, 0.00834440253674984, -0.02183624729514122, -0.02392062544822693, -0.018588852137327194, 0.015662621706724167, 0.008185409009456635, 0.04866776242852211, -0.014291460625827312, -0.012275212444365025, -0.014748245477676392, 0.014574008993804455, 0.03357301279902458, -0.012721654959022999, 0.02096753567457199, 0.024950824677944183, 0.036227818578481674, -0.059907324612140656, 0.013265293091535568, -0.054653070867061615, 0.002634279429912567, -0.01201530173420906, -0.023044338449835777, -0.02622883953154087, 0.030991049483418465, 0.07038965821266174, -0.025440571829676628, 0.02660295180976391, -0.00269830203615129, 0.02102934569120407, 0.033212125301361084, 0.021061060950160027, -0.0022088387049734592, 0.017467133700847626, 0.021151212975382805, -0.01203007623553276, 0.020381223410367966, -0.0423729307949543, -0.02245444618165493, 0.10735032707452774, -0.02982911840081215, 0.016717294231057167, 0.0001980175293283537, -0.007169495336711407, 0.026207704097032547, -0.05199963226914406, -0.01685904525220394, 0.003495088079944253, -0.007382952608168125, 0.02795746922492981, -0.022059865295886993, -0.04298917204141617, 0.03398458659648895, -0.0041519408114254475, 0.007064946461468935, 0.06796235591173172, 0.037341389805078506, -0.017242738977074623, -0.006172738038003445, -0.023295415565371513, -0.029874252155423164, -0.02031388133764267, -0.020957551896572113, 0.019973542541265488, -0.005995930638164282, -0.020003261044621468, 0.03587951511144638, 0.05067841336131096, -0.028184227645397186, -0.05817205831408501, -0.0230348389595747, -0.06897604465484619, 0.02175501547753811, 0.020581325516104698, -0.030926864594221115, 0.036440055817365646, 0.020367469638586044, 0.040266986936330795, -0.056734636425971985, -0.01960974931716919, -0.0222618505358696, -0.03514935076236725, -0.0033776736818253994, -0.026419982314109802, -0.06979481130838394, 0.038374144583940506, -0.018053820356726646, -0.030557500198483467, 0.01178593747317791, 0.01221565343439579, 0.005862729623913765, -0.004653362091630697, 0.03783741593360901, 0.01461920328438282, 0.051100339740514755, 0.0134293707087636, 0.010982628911733627, -0.013865604065358639, -0.028145689517259598, 0.15819504857063293, 0.028603237122297287, 0.046626701951026917, -0.018841909244656563, -0.009534952230751514, 0.02911045216023922, -0.009148459881544113, -0.045303888618946075, -0.02342642843723297, 0.02026400715112686, -0.02100629359483719, 0.0435425266623497, 0.0014302837662398815, 0.00641845166683197, -0.02334815263748169, 0.03332376852631569, -0.015321669168770313, -0.002130372915416956, -0.005734682083129883, 0.0061364732682704926, 0.02273540198802948, -0.02776726521551609, -0.08198389410972595, -0.02223150245845318, 0.02669985592365265, 0.006604056805372238, -0.02290143072605133, -0.03508606180548668, -0.023056378588080406, -0.01903362199664116, -0.029363762587308884, -0.001521685509942472, 0.015469159930944443, 0.017174851149320602, 0.003088194178417325, -0.013553466647863388, 0.057529550045728683, -0.04257108271121979, -0.004041808657348156, 0.01287956815212965, 0.030981559306383133, 0.00975231733173132, -0.021690770983695984, 0.005714930593967438, -0.027574962005019188, -0.0056624445132911205, -0.021410983055830002, 0.04696797952055931, -0.004273989237844944, -0.03891364857554436, -0.009297212585806847, 0.0028743648435920477, -0.00874388124793768, -0.01868547685444355, 0.03430011123418808, 0.024483487010002136, 0.022445080801844597, -0.012293601408600807, -0.028623105958104134, -0.000534683174919337, 0.014386066235601902, 0.006245901342481375, 0.01191615592688322, 0.031009089201688766, -0.012399050407111645, -0.04586246609687805, -0.03367038443684578, 0.06465073674917221, -0.019108718261122704, 0.011260582134127617, 0.017883889377117157, -0.04326588287949562, -0.0071830181404948235, -0.015648312866687775, 0.01558256521821022, -0.024142712354660034, 0.01130660343915224, -0.0005858626682311296, -0.03895316645503044, -0.01279916986823082, -0.042110998183488846, -0.006012298166751862, 0.006255926098674536, -0.02880914881825447, -0.027186580002307892, 0.036937545984983444, 0.021129412576556206, 0.02813836559653282, 0.007333317771553993, 0.015121612697839737, -0.006190295796841383, 0.08752577751874924, 0.028885576874017715, -0.05127574875950813, -0.03877381980419159, -0.016039658337831497, 0.010524217039346695, -0.007634658832103014, -0.02715272083878517, 0.041314080357551575, 0.013753311708569527, -0.0077428356744349, -0.022128650918602943, -0.018715068697929382, -0.0024738817010074854, -0.0036648039240390062, 0.009381519630551338, -0.030493667349219322, 0.03916351497173309, 0.03319527581334114, -0.028389226645231247, -0.016057441011071205, 0.0037342801224440336, -0.026364026591181755, -0.004697494208812714, -0.020352821797132492, -0.017369594424962997, -0.0378599539399147, 0.03476531431078911, -0.021998031064867973, -0.030617116019129753, 0.024365726858377457, -0.0030203014612197876, -0.042978595942258835, -0.02754199132323265, -0.006800755392760038, -0.035587865859270096, -0.02573426626622677, 0.0035356024745851755, -0.061961766332387924, -0.011911775916814804, 0.09721636027097702, 0.0042461515404284, 0.013122761622071266, -0.01985108107328415, 0.01958439126610756, -0.008208299055695534, 0.07336083799600601, 0.027363799512386322, -0.014378892257809639, 0.03834495320916176, 0.00959140993654728, -0.03022722154855728, 0.0477311909198761, -0.02491782419383526, 0.029002096503973007, 0.003095956053584814, 0.013086112216114998, -0.015350038185715675, 0.0610191784799099, -0.007646216545253992, -0.014294636435806751, -0.005391269456595182, 0.0020991612691432238, 0.048950567841529846, 0.015201276168227196, -0.014009571634232998, 0.0012662000954151154, -0.03330908343195915, 0.01686284691095352, 0.031344376504421234, 0.002759363269433379, -0.0004763878823723644, -0.02396661601960659, -0.013287976384162903, -0.01440225075930357, -0.01027588453143835, -0.025401975959539413, 0.035574719309806824, 0.06977390497922897, -0.02652255818247795, 0.021890796720981598, -0.016625817865133286, 0.014515544287860394, -0.06536132097244263, -0.011167178861796856, 0.026995616033673286, 0.036333534866571426, 0.022029900923371315, -0.05159009248018265, -0.0031534116715192795, 0.009638648480176926, -0.04076254367828369, 0.04571108892560005, 0.026215728372335434, 0.04291205853223801, -0.042146652936935425, 0.008114015683531761, -0.035087283700704575, -0.03252309560775757, 0.028432264924049377, 0.00937563180923462, 0.04107300564646721, 0.03931737691164017, 0.012884542346000671, -0.048701923340559006, -0.05254756286740303, 0.023091236129403114, 0.034051403403282166, -0.01573229394853115, 0.023510083556175232, -0.04763265699148178, -0.016011672094464302, 0.019148612394928932, -0.05494775250554085, 0.0032800754997879267, -0.008566426113247871, 0.0012183455983176827, -0.001917619607411325, 0.03743422403931618, 0.03237622231245041, 0.01771990768611431, -0.02420378476381302, 0.01860983669757843, 0.012809540145099163, 0.0019680005498230457, -0.011078705079853535, 0.016916656866669655, 0.012242541648447514, -0.008585399948060513, -0.03893419727683067, 0.05481082946062088, 0.0017395593458786607, 0.002958806697279215, -0.0015345016727223992, -0.006584366783499718, 0.0019477475434541702, -0.0443977452814579, -0.034371405839920044, -0.0590028241276741, 0.030042991042137146, 0.0459006130695343, 0.0009831798961386085, -0.029292412102222443, 0.00428658677265048, -0.0005142339505255222, -0.06146656721830368, -0.02148463763296604, 0.004728613421320915, -0.0011283319909125566, -0.004966394044458866, -0.03591647371649742, 0.0007213919307105243, 0.028499964624643326, -0.01083853468298912, 0.01978188008069992, -0.05680372565984726, 0.029836466535925865, -0.025519663468003273, -0.020328767597675323, -0.0039256964810192585, -0.017085181549191475, 0.037480391561985016, -0.09330931305885315, 0.03054964169859886, -0.0005476423539221287, 0.016834605485200882, -0.03893488273024559, -0.021585799753665924, -0.05293892323970795, 0.04533858224749565, 0.020866461098194122, -0.025057749822735786, 0.029140345752239227, -0.0023429945576936007, 0.013169730082154274, -0.02093067392706871, -0.0350763313472271, 0.08968370407819748, -0.002222772454842925, -0.05685797333717346, -0.0028151175938546658, -0.02185210958123207, -0.0033565275371074677, -0.0075380741618573666, -0.0009479136788286269, -0.007196086458861828, 0.0015176060842350125, 0.006546515505760908, -0.033975616097450256, 0.025811543688178062, -0.016711575910449028, -0.03831772133708, 0.009292257018387318, -0.011050618253648281, -0.029327930882573128, 0.048345066606998444, -0.029126517474651337, -0.03433660417795181, 0.04515008255839348, -0.026294546201825142, 0.000619370024651289, 0.03595484048128128, 0.042094118893146515, 0.02316606603562832, -0.08907955884933472, 0.024073520675301552, 0.003090724814683199, 0.008315736427903175, -0.015435962937772274, 0.07448700070381165, -0.0003643709060270339, 0.01977376453578472, -0.019140521064400673, 0.05081867799162865, -0.051141463220119476, -0.02716471627354622, 0.028601817786693573, 0.017875248566269875, 0.0028973997104912996, 0.000501837523188442, 0.019003378227353096, 0.0012968279188498855, 0.00654778303578496, 0.0389317162334919, -0.03306681662797928, 0.020999567583203316, -0.032061364501714706, -0.05122426152229309, 0.03964586928486824, -0.0033469509799033403, -0.02582019567489624, 0.04109937697649002, 0.023072419688105583, 0.018209373578429222, -0.02963462471961975, -0.01082419790327549, -0.015945199877023697, -0.022158991545438766, -0.006112486589699984, 0.03506125137209892, -0.0006550787948071957, -0.000006707865395583212, -0.022284267470240593, -0.029429348185658455, 0.00458490801975131, 0.006697436328977346, 0.00013034435687586665, 0.00671185739338398, 0.021166332066059113, -0.034951843321323395, 0.013724811375141144, 0.009108842350542545, -0.005605397280305624, -0.047584544867277145, -0.00755515368655324, -0.0033638272434473038, 0.023280752822756767, -0.005950183607637882, -0.02151760272681713, -0.01456880196928978, -0.010695632547140121, 0.047962699085474014, -0.07332330197095871, -0.028695175424218178, -0.04415484890341759, 0.011669320054352283, 0.013493170961737633, -0.03183336183428764 ]
<p>Since the mean of the residuals should be close to zero and with my calculations yield the following result:</p> <pre><code>&gt; mean(resid(trees.lm) [1] -3.065293e-17 </code></pre> <p>is it correct to stipulate that the mean is close to zero?</p> <p>My second question is as follows: While I am working with the gamble data set in my class, I need to compute the correlation of the residuals with income. How would I set up the calculation? I'm thinking of <code>cor(residuals(data.lm))</code>.</p>
36,346
[ 0.0019818912260234356, 0.017049334943294525, -0.012343116104602814, 0.03210492432117462, 0.04022861272096634, 0.029953619465231895, -0.006756490096449852, -0.020558316260576248, 0.046619199216365814, -0.02829938940703869, 0.020114557817578316, 0.05049275979399681, 0.04320399463176727, 0.04177510738372803, 0.04399039223790169, -0.02233811467885971, -0.0068255322985351086, -0.003505099331960082, 0.01600361242890358, -0.020693043246865273, -0.013723279349505901, 0.049772460013628006, 0.006954755634069443, -0.004866840783506632, -0.03429829701781273, 0.031136848032474518, 0.02958509884774685, -0.002079757396131754, -0.005167778115719557, 0.03640028461813927, -0.052022501826286316, -0.02075856365263462, -0.0027558854781091213, 0.0012754880590364337, 0.042791739106178284, 0.03301926329731941, -0.0010394459823146462, -0.03225523233413696, 0.00450499914586544, 0.02854466624557972, 0.006013242062181234, -0.003114599036052823, 0.023447168990969658, 0.03642973676323891, -0.015443514101207256, -0.012233350425958633, 0.0189694631844759, -0.013510606251657009, 0.06376597285270691, -0.017297159880399704, 0.049024343490600586, -0.026114152744412422, 0.03534628078341484, 0.04677056893706322, -0.021472034975886345, -0.01618777960538864, 0.023712512105703354, 0.03748017176985741, -0.002340591512620449, -0.03924914821982384, 0.0007273085648193955, -0.042438410222530365, -0.009307308122515678, 0.04579705744981766, -0.023603085428476334, -0.03692842274904251, 0.001402254682034254, -0.03448738157749176, 0.06826219707727432, -0.002577560255303979, 0.03061933070421219, 0.02626737207174301, 0.002826537238433957, 0.0035578899551182985, 0.052788831293582916, 0.014910848811268806, 0.028660332784056664, 0.007464706897735596, 0.0056910160928964615, 0.02492968738079071, -0.003092901548370719, -0.006422596983611584, 0.02909216284751892, 0.03439505025744438, 0.011445746757090092, -0.01906369999051094, 0.0557243674993515, -0.0259430930018425, 0.04275643825531006, 0.04807409271597862, 0.023624423891305923, -0.0011419178918004036, 0.04864809662103653, 0.021775269880890846, -0.043691448867321014, 0.060489851981401443, -0.03202724829316139, 0.02686488814651966, 0.04768072068691254, 0.0026223796885460615, -0.06349631398916245, -0.04200535640120506, 0.025325553491711617, 0.028318893164396286, -0.029754919931292534, -0.018392223864793777, 0.0031402374152094126, 0.015481089241802692, 0.015645265579223633, -0.04513130709528923, 0.01271878369152546, 0.012985695153474808, 0.014596092514693737, 0.004491730127483606, 0.0014796447940170765, -0.025375567376613617, 0.020703015848994255, 0.012306238524615765, 0.03558576852083206, 0.051961496472358704, 0.015852076932787895, -0.018451601266860962, 0.012019505724310875, 0.02273222990334034, -0.05339303985238075, 0.020362794399261475, 0.040212616324424744, -0.012624869123101234, -0.05614979565143585, 0.04417980834841728, -0.0017305767396464944, -0.03065250813961029, 0.061714086681604385, 0.003143472597002983, 0.06480968743562698, -0.01258118823170662, -0.06014757603406906, -0.05487525090575218, 0.0036829712335020304, 0.020643452182412148, 0.008103673346340656, -0.03480690345168114, -0.025654185563325882, 0.026212496683001518, 0.04299243539571762, 0.002185496035963297, 0.022218650206923485, -0.013282528147101402, 0.01869143545627594, 0.0009609349071979523, -0.03751925379037857, -0.009662463329732418, -0.043686509132385254, -0.02974596992135048, -0.061842720955610275, -0.07111016660928726, -0.0039303842931985855, 0.005544119980186224, -0.031081441789865494, -0.020001908764243126, 0.034818295389413834, -0.007396270986646414, -0.00029400995117612183, 0.007700938731431961, -0.03158452361822128, -0.051262401044368744, 0.05529937893152237, 0.020005591213703156, 0.04453181475400925, -0.022574780508875847, 0.016410736367106438, -0.01599865034222603, 0.013637928292155266, 0.04547252506017685, 0.03774026408791542, -0.03539054095745087, 0.006370149087160826, -0.024126149713993073, 0.04487539455294609, 0.005987974349409342, -0.05731802061200142, -0.019879162311553955, -0.023538146167993546, -0.024389710277318954, 0.023690050467848778, -0.007327581290155649, -0.04509666562080383, -0.008973665535449982, 0.04360014572739601, -0.05397379398345947, -0.04745596647262573, -0.0674082413315773, 0.0162688996642828, 0.0038355288561433554, -0.005910850130021572, -0.02216040901839733, 0.018050964921712875, 0.03663363680243492, 0.026373926550149918, 0.036790043115615845, -0.029193872585892677, -0.01747690699994564, 0.047133978456258774, -0.028631489723920822, 0.005185494665056467, 0.014688950963318348, 0.029895467683672905, -0.008759557269513607, 0.03645000979304314, -0.0318976454436779, -0.04354820400476456, 0.02596958726644516, -0.030369950458407402, -0.004986640065908432, -0.011850843206048012, 0.004507455974817276, 0.03662535548210144, 0.022933531552553177, -0.003355511464178562, 0.041873183101415634, -0.029897157102823257, 0.043360769748687744, 0.10657123476266861, 0.03259584307670593, -0.005187002010643482, -0.01051342487335205, -0.014975432306528091, 0.02181161381304264, -0.030797122046351433, 0.0015071965754032135, -0.048293620347976685, 0.007872388698160648, 0.001648876816034317, 0.018006006255745888, 0.014840694144368172, 0.008059914223849773, 0.10863235592842102, 0.0024756668135523796, 0.02188936248421669, 0.01574363000690937, -0.03091130219399929, 0.012704379856586456, 0.005274427589029074, 0.03675655275583267, 0.051857419312000275, 0.007388596888631582, -0.015098318457603455, -0.018690457567572594, 0.024654876440763474, 0.014155781827867031, 0.00235686544328928, 0.047992732375860214, 0.01829306036233902, 0.01439632847905159, -0.019955521449446678, -0.008484596386551857, 0.05784936249256134, -0.007309205364435911, -0.015036406926810741, 0.023996170610189438, 0.007173529826104641, -0.043557461351156235, 0.01612132415175438, -0.0633096694946289, 0.021588455885648727, 0.01757589541375637, -0.04611547663807869, -0.017774660140275955, 0.017020706087350845, 0.0005099125555716455, 0.021213291212916374, -0.023426422849297523, -0.02735954336822033, -0.039195410907268524, 0.014879281632602215, 0.010995695367455482, -0.02214522659778595, 0.02580444887280464, -0.027554916217923164, -0.027478180825710297, -0.04155731201171875, 0.007860440760850906, 0.015879405662417412, -0.014595149084925652, -0.0818619430065155, -0.04027307778596878, -0.005961245391517878, -0.024875393137335777, 0.020427724346518517, -0.0028259227983653545, -0.02419581636786461, 0.029225222766399384, 0.01759522780776024, -0.012969095259904861, -0.02628616988658905, -0.03606664761900902, -0.0016563780372962356, -0.03571704030036926, -0.049864910542964935, 0.038314081728458405, -0.021242452785372734, -0.04079878330230713, 0.01835056021809578, -0.059784550219774246, -0.004256150219589472, -0.0383007787168026, -0.03702973574399948, 0.010566026903688908, 0.017013030126690865, -0.0150592140853405, -0.03175009414553642, 0.0178019180893898, -0.026919670403003693, -0.1093529462814331, -0.07593204826116562, 0.033759523183107376, 0.031291503459215164, -0.015990128740668297, 0.00638336269184947, 0.001910183229483664, 0.038641661405563354, 0.016653036698698997, -0.02596408501267433, -0.05536244064569473, -0.006254447158426046, 0.01112352591007948, -0.053179703652858734, -0.0290176160633564, 0.010395379737019539, 0.029450643807649612, 0.039624471217393875, -0.02275787480175495, 0.014178559184074402, 0.05826159566640854, -0.008355828933417797, 0.00014701405598316342, 0.021541835740208626, -0.02051546797156334, -0.04236555099487305, 0.08708125352859497, 0.044260017573833466, -0.017656441777944565, 0.045286212116479874, -0.016303038224577904, 0.019115792587399483, -0.01582304947078228, -0.055148158222436905, 0.001243619597516954, -0.015352905727922916, 0.023999957367777824, -0.026241376996040344, 0.025245878845453262, -0.0014412730233743787, -0.02911020815372467, 0.006279711611568928, -0.02998061291873455, 0.034326523542404175, 0.0006690482259728014, 0.02829408459365368, 0.0223834328353405, 0.02801961451768875, 0.005955848842859268, -0.018426325172185898, -0.002934393472969532, -0.02647610753774643, 0.02079683169722557, -0.035857222974300385, -0.0024799068924039602, 0.05685877799987793, 0.03615395352244377, -0.004280777648091316, -0.032312799245119095, -0.07405366748571396, 0.011228704825043678, -0.05289147421717644, 0.015094894915819168, -0.04595053568482399, 0.0585726834833622, 0.013997413218021393, 0.025227176025509834, -0.01747831515967846, -0.013257873244583607, -0.0037339909467846155, 0.03078155778348446, -0.06052703410387039, 0.02876838855445385, -0.021064721047878265, -0.021881984546780586, 0.00857630092650652, -0.01550125703215599, 0.036106716841459274, -0.024226203560829163, 0.033720847219228745, -0.0230154599994421, 0.016517382115125656, -0.014152973890304565, -0.022113172337412834, -0.006052632350474596, 0.008447694592177868, -0.012913186103105545, -0.015492811799049377, 0.01766080968081951, 0.018053393810987473, 0.025659093633294106, 0.047362394630908966, 0.014200921170413494, -0.020772557705640793, -0.03248896822333336, 0.005098753143101931, 0.0037805221509188414, 0.017715321853756905, 0.06819938123226166, -0.016570696607232094, -0.025347555056214333, 0.024761563166975975, 0.0038198288530111313, 0.014232158660888672, 0.04997166246175766, 0.02558974362909794, 0.029332241043448448, 0.0037840455770492554, -0.03718796744942665, 0.0006250331643968821, -0.000967363128438592, -0.004093061666935682, -0.03413236886262894, 0.059281282126903534, 0.06364986300468445, -0.0604218952357769, 0.04783434420824051, 0.07436039298772812, -0.0006263004615902901, -0.005886374972760677, -0.045918338000774384, 0.004250679165124893, 0.007258453872054815, -0.027938708662986755, 0.053967397660017014, -0.0021914602257311344, -0.007696174085140228, -0.019446805119514465, 0.009276555851101875, -0.037508197128772736, -0.015094599686563015, 0.0519961416721344, 0.005842814687639475, 0.07140452414751053, -0.032103948295116425, -0.034043919295072556, 0.0097384974360466, 0.032911449670791626, -0.009258261881768703, 0.04020742326974869, 0.007016397081315517, -0.08129329234361649, 0.004315865691751242, 0.02628195844590664, 0.033679116517305374, -0.025089189410209656, -0.012121791951358318, -0.04030758887529373, -0.04344357177615166, 0.028717707842588425, -0.02687663957476616, 0.023814333602786064, -0.01017470471560955, 0.03380779176950455, 0.01214241236448288, -0.015081279911100864, -0.04668005555868149, 0.001192664261907339, -0.017916640266776085, 0.055760156363248825, -0.015333321876823902, -0.053701575845479965, -0.04480806365609169, 0.022063983604311943, 0.011222673580050468, 0.03930893540382385, -0.05963994190096855, -0.024786947295069695, -0.03579169884324074, 0.009961229749023914, 0.012632987461984158, -0.08017167448997498, 0.029803378507494926, -0.01021294854581356, 0.0234578475356102, 0.049741748720407486, 0.04152366891503334, -0.048956964164972305, -0.008545087650418282, 0.01831076107919216, -0.02155952900648117, -0.020478786900639534, -0.05185680091381073, 0.02714604325592518, 0.04460654780268669, -0.0016836364520713687, 0.05762363597750664, 0.04105863347649574, -0.0039478265680372715, 0.009144207462668419, -0.042889293283224106, 0.014884519390761852, -0.007870277389883995, -0.003071874612942338, -0.04619358107447624, -0.02205706387758255, -0.027644313871860504, -0.027458306401968002, 0.006134492810815573, 0.040828637778759, -0.037291672080755234, 0.030686896294355392, -0.02142096310853958, 0.03874573856592178, -0.009968454949557781, -0.0027592440601438284, 0.03208697959780693, -0.003264496335759759, -0.01859542541205883, -0.009335138835012913, 0.009629358537495136, 0.0006835333188064396, 0.006544829346239567, 0.031872522085905075, 0.00753306457772851, 0.004790014587342739, -0.028519628569483757, -0.003158323001116514, -0.022259114310145378, -0.054638948291540146, 0.004586370661854744, 0.020723706111311913, 0.04960641264915466, 0.00678565027192235, -0.003986081574112177, -0.00544700026512146, 0.005523974075913429, -0.0025672807823866606, 0.009764623828232288, -0.04555120691657066, 0.017849816009402275, -0.018954122439026833, -0.029509488493204117, -0.05676719918847084, -0.03802059590816498, -0.030095674097537994, 0.02186344377696514, -0.008240966126322746, 0.0074979267083108425, -0.01223137229681015, -0.014198396354913712, -0.010743703693151474, -0.006219751667231321, 0.08395866304636002, -0.05023759603500366, -0.006400515791028738, -0.013025476597249508, -0.006489783525466919, 0.09642259776592255, -0.03439828008413315, 0.008888387121260166, 0.03717045485973358, -0.049019601196050644, -0.04596336930990219, 0.005461169872432947, 0.01028278935700655, -0.025357764214277267, -0.0193998571485281, -0.06678377836942673, 0.03697991743683815, 0.07917226850986481, 0.011449281126260757, -0.035707034170627594, -0.010247298516333103, 0.007413031533360481, 0.04134527966380119, -0.032269980758428574, 0.01677362062036991, -0.01160582434386015, 0.014778263866901398, 0.026923464611172676, -0.006464033387601376, -0.0356474369764328, 0.01643330231308937, 0.011049581691622734, 0.01275896281003952, 0.006304488983005285, 0.033039458096027374, 0.09268828481435776, -0.04590289667248726, 0.005201516207307577, -0.004841763526201248, -0.014802965335547924, 0.045368507504463196, 0.005308943334966898, -0.007898349314928055, 0.03169267624616623, 0.045791104435920715, -0.054556213319301605, -0.023371456190943718, -0.0432402566075325, -0.0038772684056311846, 0.057867780327796936, -0.026820985600352287, 0.07341715693473816, 0.02262573130428791, -0.012318826280534267, 0.005490987095981836, -0.00905209593474865, -0.020768053829669952, 0.005892064422369003, 0.004897735547274351, 0.03273603692650795, -0.0523175373673439, -0.006783875171095133, 0.054930344223976135, -0.004351318348199129, 0.01413621287792921, 0.018920913338661194, 0.010142781771719456, -0.0004579914966598153, -0.006441654171794653, -0.010231523774564266, -0.018834922462701797, 0.015302401036024094, -0.0007067302940413356, 0.058409858494997025, -0.01982749067246914, -0.054875582456588745, 0.04524260014295578, 0.05112788453698158, -0.006702028680592775, -0.027964415028691292, -0.027119018137454987, -0.03318772464990616, -0.019482260569930077, -0.00339312176220119, -0.05012694373726845, 0.012548629194498062, -0.0023910640738904476, 0.04126705601811409, -0.04420987516641617, 0.040797483175992966, -0.03092818520963192, -0.08012370765209198, -0.007614265661686659, -0.005918839480727911, -0.010310117155313492, 0.04449398070573807, -0.008208333514630795, 0.0033910758793354034, 0.064855195581913, -0.05514286831021309, -0.00859410036355257, 0.037720631808042526, 0.05734856426715851, 0.026028817519545555, 0.04716690257191658, 0.028517484664916992, 0.017246898263692856, -0.020227134227752686, -0.02301493100821972, 0.14607012271881104, 0.06968262791633606, 0.03291493281722069, -0.03674878552556038, 0.0032081755343824625, 0.039481136947870255, 0.0005871354369446635, -0.017780762165784836, 0.015583131462335587, 0.0034656256902962923, 0.01765419915318489, 0.02310998924076557, 0.03170191869139671, -0.008907491341233253, -0.016432614997029305, -0.02145255170762539, -0.005712388549000025, -0.000519581139087677, 0.003556499257683754, 0.011910713277757168, 0.01509423553943634, -0.03475087136030197, -0.04396148771047592, 0.03788923844695091, -0.018297038972377777, -0.014037806540727615, -0.01732373610138893, -0.017637966200709343, -0.0005559855489991605, -0.013753937557339668, -0.030352704226970673, -0.012836304493248463, 0.04628148302435875, 0.0007613889174535871, -0.004005325958132744, -0.02025284245610237, 0.023091500625014305, -0.022894414141774178, 0.01837444305419922, 0.024787629023194313, -0.00020876499183941633, 0.01239970326423645, 0.005734622944146395, 0.03263534978032112, -0.04478947073221207, -0.04059024155139923, -0.03531058505177498, 0.03676881641149521, 0.03478264808654785, -0.016784897074103355, -0.012133651413023472, -0.02159479632973671, -0.007119408342987299, -0.045945752412080765, 0.006638633087277412, 0.022361760959029198, -0.0012205176753923297, -0.03738569840788841, 0.018427638337016106, 0.0026986936572939157, 0.010227534919977188, -0.02504538744688034, 0.0025712389033287764, 0.007337081711739302, -0.016473930329084396, -0.015039999037981033, -0.082687608897686, 0.060086749494075775, -0.021589400246739388, 0.02143171802163124, 0.008904198184609413, -0.03138209506869316, -0.024941999465227127, 0.008715673349797726, -0.010412105359137058, 0.008115283213555813, 0.01571997068822384, -0.01657559536397457, -0.0034953223075717688, -0.02109886333346367, -0.042776647955179214, 0.02881617657840252, -0.04546011611819267, -0.020795034244656563, -0.046631596982479095, -0.036963678896427155, 0.028260713443160057, 0.01760035753250122, 0.028527062386274338, -0.02447372116148472, -0.005710123106837273, 0.06049008667469025, -0.020297667011618614, -0.056734077632427216, -0.014635824598371983, -0.005662363488227129, -0.030128728598356247, 0.006252764258533716, 0.01235111802816391, 0.06311922520399094, 0.0022058766335248947, 0.032338883727788925, -0.026454264298081398, 0.0007141429232433438, 0.01388672273606062, 0.015368803404271603, 0.0038725240156054497, -0.0409146323800087, -0.0051658134907484055, 0.01997293345630169, -0.010328325442969799, 0.012925302609801292, -0.0009088076185435057, -0.024381089955568314, -0.06755436956882477, 0.0042282696813344955, -0.019117312505841255, -0.04531911388039589, 0.0061651174910366535, -0.01818862557411194, 0.03980857878923416, -0.01760590448975563, -0.022790201008319855, -0.05136093124747276, -0.022666288539767265, 0.029967183247208595, -0.03701508417725563, -0.023776093497872353, 0.022981928661465645, 0.00588576216250658, 0.010182096622884274, 0.059213921427726746, 0.004921664949506521, 0.01564631797373295, -0.02370275743305683, -0.004339274019002914, 0.01112469844520092, 0.03898805379867554, -0.010154633782804012, -0.02456054463982582, 0.027142765000462532, -0.021903961896896362, 0.00798729807138443, -0.02207299694418907, -0.004286076873540878, 0.024214109405875206, -0.02388852834701538, 0.002498665824532509, -0.040754154324531555, 0.036071378737688065, -0.022692959755659103, -0.00988648273050785, -0.015430585481226444, -0.01702539436519146, 0.03931446000933647, 0.005707142874598503, 0.00498158996924758, -0.0007300698780454695, 0.01879142038524151, -0.0033702070359140635, 0.04418150335550308, -0.014670982956886292, 0.027830449864268303, 0.02848092094063759, -0.007136865518987179, -0.03665488585829735, -0.006260970141738653, -0.021681196987628937, -0.018122512847185135, 0.02584727294743061, -0.03442287817597389, 0.05431252345442772, -0.028610454872250557, 0.019198138266801834, -0.06885696202516556, -0.017634812742471695, 0.005436748266220093, -0.010570635087788105, 0.04831137880682945, -0.0254331324249506, -0.01944044791162014, 0.023185810074210167, -0.020870737731456757, 0.023467568680644035, 0.013513504527509212, -0.004562736954540014, -0.026348911225795746, 0.022302525117993355, -0.011185522191226482, 0.010821935720741749, 0.03989899903535843, 0.01664010062813759, 0.028148459270596504, 0.01617574319243431, 0.02273877151310444, -0.007006949745118618, -0.018148155882954597, 0.002603636821731925, -0.005887036211788654, -0.03754260390996933, -0.003872806206345558, -0.04590144008398056, 0.010570322163403034, 0.011273376643657684, 0.004113852512091398, 0.005803222302347422, 0.018596408888697624, -0.007943580858409405, 0.011785860173404217, 0.04384775832295418, 0.03913041949272156, -0.012845465913414955, -0.014105590991675854, -0.004567925818264484, 0.005131954792886972, 0.006903916597366333, -0.018105994910001755, 0.04113053157925606, 0.007078574970364571, -0.003554972819983959, -0.03117869794368744, 0.054871998727321625, 0.011979139409959316, -0.010995459742844105, -0.009464486502110958, 0.003794322954490781, 0.004414923023432493, -0.05854382365942001, 0.02319931797683239, -0.030024414882063866, 0.010067153722047806, 0.07849816232919693, 0.03888507932424545, -0.023770416155457497, 0.008995242416858673, -0.010890018194913864, -0.04464467242360115, -0.000671611400321126, 0.025960534811019897, -0.031972337514162064, -0.01734902895987034, 0.002701863180845976, 0.005585992708802223, -0.00942035298794508, -0.022830689325928688, -0.012340579181909561, -0.00860725436359644, 0.01741873100399971, -0.06417689472436905, 0.007313976995646954, 0.0342140793800354, -0.030907200649380684, 0.016927603632211685, -0.08533944189548492, 0.059020206332206726, 0.04231815040111542, 0.02259870059788227, -0.043266672641038895, -0.0002706795639824122, -0.032843854278326035, 0.023187901824712753, 0.03186371177434921, -0.011545484885573387, 0.03564459830522537, -0.025357726961374283, 0.010250928811728954, -0.018649976700544357, -0.03335617110133171, 0.04858054965734482, -0.008856005035340786, -0.012409946881234646, -0.024562804028391838, -0.011428614147007465, 0.015310902148485184, -0.014155266806483269, -0.003263861872255802, -0.009657436981797218, -0.002867187140509486, 0.011639457195997238, -0.0038203762378543615, 0.03596635162830353, 0.004605890717357397, -0.00770068122074008, 0.048967406153678894, 0.017212890088558197, 0.024164536967873573, 0.06837854534387589, -0.005908038932830095, -0.040245506912469864, 0.0739259421825409, -0.03226557746529579, -0.028755949810147285, -0.019638920202851295, 0.005227221176028252, -0.018558630719780922, -0.053797610104084015, -0.003898270195350051, 0.020793652161955833, -0.04774358123540878, -0.0009751167381182313, 0.04977396875619888, -0.008114618249237537, 0.03880874067544937, 0.006477756425738335, 0.03102630190551281, 0.02047611027956009, -0.04417971149086952, 0.033440034836530685, 0.04230893403291702, 0.05558374896645546, -0.024521248415112495, -0.01973278447985649, 0.02207806706428528, 0.0006141182384453714, 0.01680784486234188, -0.044647082686424255, 0.05596618726849556, -0.033434752374887466, 0.016584720462560654, -0.0010554722975939512, 0.0053276135586202145, 0.007329923566430807, 0.010170849040150642, 0.005154448561370373, 0.02208171971142292, -0.036236733198165894, 0.04350549355149269, -0.0037158087361603975, -0.0506860688328743, -0.04224707931280136, 0.018016690388321877, 0.01624334789812565, 0.0245123989880085, 0.0139622138813138, 0.006562180817127228, 0.03175095468759537, 0.0025413180701434612, 0.032887428998947144, -0.006209309212863445, 0.007825554348528385, 0.02890830487012863, -0.02883462980389595, -0.018946224823594093, -0.01782034896314144, -0.03524111583828926, -0.06117815524339676, -0.0019647637382149696, 0.031393591314554214, 0.014453030191361904, -0.01931086741387844, -0.019898539409041405, 0.023597264662384987, 0.03595315292477608, -0.05910628288984299, 0.013842285610735416, -0.021529480814933777, 0.0008554986561648548, 0.010951437056064606, -0.0034564747475087643 ]
<p>I am reading an article that explores correlation between two variables, X and Y. Usually, if the scatter plot show something like this, we can claim that there is a strong correlation of X and Y.</p> <pre><code>Y | | o | o o | o | o o | o | o | o +---------------------&gt;X </code></pre> <p>What about the following case?</p> <pre><code>Y | o o | o o | o oo | o o | oo o | o o | o o | o oo o oo oo o o o oo +---------------------&gt;X x1 x2 </code></pre> <p>Basically, the scatter plot show strong clustering and spikes around a few data point along X axis, e.g. x1 and x2.</p> <p><strong>What kind of statistical property does this imply?</strong></p>
73,836
[ -0.04980330169200897, -0.03222915902733803, 0.022536756470799446, -0.0396583154797554, 0.03966892138123512, 0.032010745257139206, 0.03227648138999939, -0.01445175800472498, 0.048068247735500336, -0.04975251853466034, 0.04073967784643173, 0.053399182856082916, 0.05714375525712967, 0.053110405802726746, 0.036324433982372284, -0.022555014118552208, 0.01489980798214674, 0.004488028585910797, 0.009630050510168076, -0.011265053413808346, -0.013602507300674915, 0.0006505686324089766, -0.014029551297426224, 0.023318152874708176, -0.028806226328015327, 0.056148916482925415, -0.0038904284592717886, 0.003566897241398692, 0.022792208939790726, 0.0503709651529789, -0.0381159782409668, -0.033013660460710526, 0.007026882376521826, 0.0454268641769886, 0.022536538541316986, -0.0071471454575657845, 0.0033024773001670837, -0.0068491119891405106, 0.01699095405638218, 0.016512906178832054, -0.02291087619960308, -0.025683553889393806, -0.013087723404169083, 0.028850413858890533, -0.033792153000831604, 0.018202347680926323, 0.011703775264322758, -0.049510784447193146, 0.0434986874461174, -0.01794697716832161, 0.06614966690540314, -0.004779947455972433, 0.052291687577962875, 0.05992409586906433, -0.013168323785066605, 0.004605589434504509, 0.08966748416423798, 0.05130818486213684, -0.02015632577240467, -0.06404709815979004, -0.00896735955029726, -0.03003247268497944, 0.03680787608027458, -0.001270481152459979, -0.05016211047768593, 0.06251692771911621, -0.01020097453147173, -0.0558810830116272, 0.03510328009724617, 0.014587671495974064, 0.0016237411182373762, 0.04038352519273758, 0.03742390125989914, -0.0386991873383522, 0.011121556162834167, 0.0021070102229714394, 0.017397118732333183, -0.0029583268333226442, 0.007725426461547613, 0.031848687678575516, 0.035375092178583145, 0.027520805597305298, 0.012187828309834003, 0.0071270824410021305, -0.003346901386976242, -0.01735914871096611, 0.08845503628253937, -0.02274838648736477, 0.0028519679326564074, 0.030871013179421425, 0.0007876287563703954, 0.001961618196219206, 0.017993608489632607, 0.05706333369016647, -0.05484861880540848, 0.01916903257369995, 0.008594528771936893, 0.04853568226099014, 0.00844005960971117, -0.005573981907218695, -0.01551578938961029, -0.055283039808273315, -0.005668520927429199, 0.027662167325615883, -0.02219340018928051, -0.045397743582725525, -0.024131307378411293, 0.01495160348713398, -0.04326760023832321, -0.01684918999671936, -0.03287629783153534, -0.002875308506190777, 0.02443847805261612, -0.010962339118123055, 0.037512488663196564, -0.014559296891093254, 0.013469668105244637, 0.014174741692841053, 0.02005726471543312, 0.044377297163009644, 0.010760790668427944, -0.0015533711994066834, 0.013422326184809208, -0.007429278455674648, -0.04720437899231911, 0.012347282841801643, 0.02768576331436634, -0.025678692385554314, -0.04138468950986862, 0.07233539968729019, -0.018782183527946472, 0.026470191776752472, 0.015549196861684322, 0.003370260586962104, 0.0485202893614769, -0.0016858400776982307, -0.09099029749631882, -0.02204313315451145, 0.05960799381136894, -0.0033985173795372248, -0.016893673688173294, -0.04957926273345947, 0.012924248352646828, 0.04816054552793503, 0.053138282150030136, -0.011969640851020813, 0.027790309861302376, -0.0033575885463505983, 0.015967944636940956, 0.03685365244746208, -0.027708712965250015, -0.01311456598341465, 0.0014771856367588043, -0.0446859635412693, -0.0008362584630958736, -0.08975410461425781, -0.006494490895420313, -0.009970429353415966, -0.015043757855892181, -0.04882808029651642, 0.00311236921697855, -0.01947140321135521, -0.007536937948316336, 0.004713961388915777, -0.016181370243430138, -0.024433378130197525, 0.08754170686006546, 0.005519164260476828, 0.049597449600696564, 0.06176026165485382, -0.0306380745023489, 0.05170866847038269, 0.011529413983225822, 0.04348225146532059, 0.03765524923801422, -0.02535821683704853, -0.009015119634568691, -0.0022100184578448534, -0.010553047060966492, 0.014872095547616482, -0.02848934940993786, -0.04661381244659424, -0.04500443860888481, -0.0022591850720345974, 0.011900174431502819, 0.06472233682870865, -0.005907724145799875, -0.02705262042582035, 0.01997300609946251, -0.053356073796749115, -0.04704739525914192, -0.09551627188920975, 0.022816497832536697, -0.016368573531508446, -0.03621866554021835, 0.013589676469564438, 0.019171802327036858, -0.00390925258398056, -0.007819953374564648, -0.017100851982831955, -0.03592144697904587, -0.014937705360352993, 0.024556949734687805, -0.016189776360988617, 0.016943149268627167, 0.046936165541410446, 0.02407792955636978, -0.0173521488904953, 0.028041044250130653, -0.035609111189842224, -0.03093423694372177, 0.006548913195729256, 0.011879620142281055, -0.013903377577662468, -0.044240571558475494, -0.00039673910941928625, 0.02457769215106964, -0.004269556142389774, -0.019732829183340073, 0.030955763533711433, -0.027962176129221916, 0.046080123633146286, 0.04641075059771538, -0.008109423331916332, -0.019617890939116478, 0.026423420757055283, 0.030123881995677948, 0.014900440350174904, -0.008760583586990833, -0.007483912631869316, -0.041482534259557724, 0.026409296318888664, 0.060851287096738815, 0.04903474450111389, -0.06010184437036514, -0.006274855230003595, 0.03682030364871025, 0.035899411886930466, 0.0007423995994031429, 0.028642471879720688, -0.017254430800676346, 0.000892700394615531, 0.00916450284421444, 0.013419270515441895, 0.02028227411210537, 0.005378236528486013, 0.007994789630174637, 0.024280454963445663, 0.001270304317586124, 0.02037154883146286, -0.036626577377319336, 0.019559456035494804, -0.007557539269328117, 0.015441017225384712, -0.023010263219475746, -0.02992604859173298, 0.039302658289670944, -0.021191556006669998, 0.033699482679367065, 0.03989188373088837, 0.036226991564035416, -0.006721210666000843, -0.0380798764526844, -0.012130451388657093, -0.02843576855957508, 0.041024141013622284, -0.017688430845737457, -0.01920844055712223, 0.012342785485088825, -0.008383819833397865, 0.0007412377162836492, 0.011771035380661488, -0.02287766896188259, -0.019857382401823997, 0.031885188072919846, 0.062338683754205704, -0.0024025088641792536, 0.03320116922259331, -0.00716502545401454, -0.049124836921691895, -0.024685807526111603, 0.0007929301355034113, -0.009067520499229431, -0.0017849513096734881, -0.055522624403238297, 0.00289641204290092, -0.017394356429576874, 0.006802720949053764, 0.030179079622030258, -0.031138157472014427, -0.024616308510303497, 0.01933915913105011, -0.00409936998039484, -0.061623990535736084, -0.022494738921523094, -0.03969831392168999, 0.022957395762205124, -0.02407108247280121, -0.01548000331968069, 0.046505700796842575, -0.029950644820928574, -0.042829591780900955, 0.008715002797544003, -0.02043936960399151, -0.029860077425837517, -0.016490640118718147, -0.028872037306427956, 0.026308519765734673, -0.015615877695381641, 0.018666915595531464, 0.0015629105037078261, -0.05938072130084038, -0.018192308023571968, -0.04048367589712143, -0.06206559017300606, 0.03597423806786537, -0.013123596087098122, 0.020777329802513123, -0.028048217296600342, -0.060580361634492874, 0.04806336387991905, -0.01921956054866314, -0.040221769362688065, -0.05706286430358887, -0.009115288034081459, -0.021013353019952774, -0.02523263357579708, 0.014388504438102245, 0.02728211134672165, 0.0362045019865036, 0.04209175333380699, 0.029535701498389244, 0.008690893650054932, 0.03412667661905289, -0.014862287789583206, -0.0006474697147496045, 0.025090010836720467, -0.008027026429772377, -0.00179371889680624, -0.0018263269448652864, 0.03480963781476021, -0.055632367730140686, 0.02708505652844906, 0.009799817577004433, 0.00647291075438261, 0.022706208750605583, -0.03470734879374504, 0.01487862691283226, -0.0017530746990814805, 0.025484176352620125, -0.04875529557466507, 0.036361414939165115, 0.017730720341205597, -0.010291851125657558, -0.01415304932743311, 0.05182983726263046, 0.02820487692952156, -0.007504981942474842, -0.025131355971097946, 0.05657770112156868, 0.04360846430063248, -0.013931130059063435, 0.0113076101988554, -0.015079841017723083, -0.00614664563909173, 0.013126852922141552, -0.036835890263319016, -0.0032653671223670244, 0.046919241547584534, 0.003945757169276476, -0.00014078729145694524, 0.011099196039140224, -0.032206807285547256, 0.004325677640736103, -0.0643056333065033, 0.009152034297585487, -0.03721887245774269, 0.0355147160589695, 0.010589989833533764, 0.08702433109283447, 0.004218973219394684, 0.004467524588108063, 0.007791834883391857, -0.012462527491152287, -0.06636302173137665, 0.022769803181290627, -0.01410299725830555, -0.01875331811606884, -0.009090160951018333, -0.030368437990546227, -0.00981554202735424, -0.02140159159898758, 0.01498198602348566, -0.017436902970075607, 0.015093058347702026, -0.06102652847766876, 0.001988970674574375, 0.004673487972468138, 0.03320182114839554, -0.043330319225788116, 0.018294155597686768, 0.029369452968239784, -0.0207222793251276, 0.05379660800099373, 0.042148418724536896, -0.030032658949494362, -0.015181285329163074, -0.012417899444699287, 0.017009180039167404, 0.0370519757270813, 0.0028612955939024687, -0.01746406778693199, 0.002279454143717885, 0.012298891320824623, 0.008135071024298668, -0.002694300375878811, 0.055725887417793274, 0.056928448379039764, 0.006688978523015976, -0.0014698428567498922, -0.005986134987324476, -0.018827352672815323, 0.027255317196249962, 0.03423243388533592, 0.02832760661840439, 0.003235891228541732, 0.00503339059650898, 0.04258687049150467, -0.05348201096057892, 0.03327178210020065, 0.08563125878572464, 0.04311696067452431, -0.004857510793954134, -0.029906125739216805, -0.04515186697244644, -0.020468290895223618, 0.007942309603095055, 0.003805214539170265, -0.01532149687409401, -0.024812238290905952, 0.03219001367688179, 0.021079154685139656, 0.011793039739131927, -0.05231902003288269, -0.01922769844532013, -0.027544744312763214, 0.014069347642362118, -0.021300602704286575, -0.025213755667209625, -0.0024250508286058903, 0.037194229662418365, 0.029098907485604286, 0.05109591409564018, -0.029335079714655876, -0.08122967183589935, -0.011591627262532711, 0.057423435151576996, 0.04389509558677673, -0.02974468469619751, 0.00687114242464304, -0.023652497678995132, 0.014461358077824116, 0.03937718644738197, -0.023277312517166138, 0.031001156195998192, -0.03282398357987404, -0.0005336424801498652, -0.01104868296533823, -0.03575783967971802, -0.07571940124034882, 0.01172975730150938, 0.004438547417521477, 0.042218439280986786, -0.0060660201124846935, -0.02855602465569973, -0.04073772206902504, -0.013780158944427967, 0.014568185433745384, 0.04451858997344971, -0.0396190769970417, -0.025219377130270004, -0.043886639177799225, 0.05215099826455116, -0.009431680664420128, -0.0707305520772934, 0.027554543688893318, 0.008128751069307327, -0.017193498089909554, 0.08344640582799911, -0.03779890760779381, -0.010183383710682392, -0.004620006773620844, -0.009257536381483078, 0.03687974438071251, -0.00939982756972313, 0.011341623961925507, 0.06857965141534805, 0.06571314483880997, 0.015650659799575806, 0.026200035586953163, 0.025882525369524956, -0.011459474451839924, -0.019610222429037094, -0.014110845513641834, 0.02358723059296608, -0.036082059144973755, 0.011952470056712627, -0.06923413276672363, 0.00010158021177630872, -0.05822368711233139, 0.043245185166597366, -0.015177308581769466, -0.0077195120975375175, -0.03374427184462547, -0.019305706024169922, 0.006224456243216991, 0.027960078790783882, 0.0184907466173172, -0.018284408375620842, 0.005171218421310186, 0.04088518023490906, 0.021848546341061592, -0.022677166387438774, 0.005427862983196974, -0.03248756378889084, -0.020309502258896828, 0.03903070464730263, -0.031509894877672195, -0.013739051297307014, -0.04684380069375038, -0.0010902053909376264, 0.01778804324567318, -0.021859975531697273, 0.015847353264689445, -0.012756092473864555, -0.0037229571025818586, 0.022179923951625824, -0.015279196202754974, -0.02086148038506508, 0.06106666103005409, 0.015666354447603226, 0.053435564041137695, -0.038898590952157974, 0.032649312168359756, 0.004552820231765509, -0.018645329400897026, -0.037949565798044205, -0.07373211532831192, 0.03345394879579544, 0.011337751522660255, -0.010745503008365631, -0.03687898442149162, -0.04335031658411026, -0.024094663560390472, -0.03429573029279709, -0.02307947538793087, 0.016448019072413445, -0.007233850192278624, -0.03506119176745415, 0.038876764476299286, -0.023016393184661865, 0.09040133655071259, 0.007656561676412821, -0.018400566652417183, 0.01732500083744526, 0.0032526550348848104, -0.0034951961133629084, 0.0001612638880033046, 0.007785910740494728, -0.03869083523750305, -0.04472626373171806, -0.055908165872097015, 0.016290580853819847, 0.0446653813123703, -0.04026022553443909, -0.04446139559149742, 0.009022864513099194, 0.02398468740284443, 0.006172194145619869, -0.025510430335998535, -0.00502669345587492, -0.02072618529200554, 0.023515528067946434, -0.0033569070510566235, 0.00010347981879021972, -0.01723274029791355, -0.0016699796542525291, 0.03204047307372093, 0.04762362688779831, -0.04054059460759163, 0.046427711844444275, 0.057670269161462784, 0.01228242926299572, -0.005369527265429497, -0.008370237424969673, 0.009796787053346634, 0.049923669546842575, 0.025611162185668945, 0.014670295640826225, 0.008135933429002762, 0.05530252307653427, -0.030673587694764137, -0.005822297651320696, -0.0003210629802197218, -0.002859909553080797, 0.0622977688908577, -0.008657983504235744, 0.03736834600567818, 0.04112498462200165, -0.029190808534622192, -0.03162548318505287, -0.01247252058237791, -0.014283298514783382, -0.00026848833658732474, -0.02950487844645977, 0.022284135222434998, -0.015494775027036667, -0.00003890477819368243, 0.030630091205239296, 0.019359340891242027, 0.01035355031490326, 0.005343466065824032, 0.04915319383144379, 0.017848964780569077, 0.005433919373899698, -0.024029729887843132, -0.05475641414523125, 0.05887305736541748, -0.03676747530698776, 0.011495893821120262, -0.02022913284599781, -0.020594460889697075, 0.010862817987799644, 0.021930746734142303, -0.018681606277823448, -0.05733951926231384, -0.027408747002482414, -0.032121896743774414, -0.007996872998774052, -0.00039719350752420723, -0.005856705829501152, 0.012308916077017784, 0.015407218597829342, 0.04635702073574066, -0.009005650877952576, 0.013891004025936127, -0.035690147429704666, -0.058045338839292526, -0.032672762870788574, 0.014613023959100246, 0.003980227746069431, 0.04476587101817131, 0.000961140263825655, -0.03440433368086815, 0.03246407210826874, -0.05866881459951401, 0.029453927651047707, 0.023646341636776924, 0.05204020068049431, -0.026328006759285927, 0.05407027155160904, 0.011523780412971973, 0.007898734882473946, -0.013405692763626575, -0.054757535457611084, 0.08940388262271881, 0.09726563841104507, 0.02094961889088154, -0.0490049384534359, 0.025130581110715866, 0.02551426738500595, -0.028499260544776917, -0.03300437331199646, -0.01960650645196438, 0.014087219722568989, 0.0027409715112298727, 0.04656803607940674, 0.03541899845004082, 0.049841590225696564, 0.024812856689095497, 0.04829622432589531, -0.04815734922885895, -0.03957144170999527, 0.014121601358056068, -0.016003135591745377, -0.012555952183902264, -0.01970730535686016, -0.09259258955717087, -0.0010060637723654509, 0.0179864764213562, -0.05029160529375076, -0.014355907216668129, 0.0047978744842112064, 0.014664340764284134, 0.006417328491806984, -0.009110620245337486, 0.0034536069724708796, 0.04350665584206581, -0.009602311067283154, -0.021019671112298965, -0.02667752280831337, 0.015466433018445969, -0.023384569212794304, 0.017651233822107315, 0.013299472630023956, 0.014704390428960323, -0.0030549410730600357, 0.013016875833272934, 0.023262159898877144, -0.022621840238571167, -0.022067280486226082, 0.002971729263663292, 0.023404235020279884, -0.011060350574553013, -0.0030830379109829664, -0.000973989546764642, 0.008252250961959362, -0.013659603893756866, -0.007227764464914799, -0.033110905438661575, 0.024931007996201515, 0.04381068795919418, -0.03617546707391739, 0.00610504811629653, -0.03362320736050606, -0.01301751472055912, -0.031009873375296593, 0.015672145411372185, 0.03480975702404976, -0.023994550108909607, 0.013407375663518906, -0.029674213379621506, 0.042882490903139114, 0.012447255663573742, -0.0013906382955610752, 0.011702568270266056, -0.007407985627651215, -0.015026426874101162, -0.01482898835092783, -0.005306853447109461, -0.009770272299647331, 0.01703706383705139, 0.05454496294260025, -0.0250877533107996, 0.002331232186406851, -0.02285097725689411, 0.03652235493063927, -0.04376613721251488, -0.03880700469017029, -0.06046928092837334, -0.027275754138827324, 0.027452444657683372, 0.03561055660247803, 0.031088242307305336, 0.0068424479104578495, -0.041355423629283905, 0.06377417594194412, 0.016305865719914436, -0.034255292266607285, -0.06424412131309509, 0.008136440068483353, -0.01648889109492302, -0.031491950154304504, 0.02877187170088291, 0.05881604552268982, 0.015614936128258705, 0.0270376056432724, 0.03467981517314911, 0.01623811013996601, -0.023882653564214706, -0.0352475643157959, 0.04586154967546463, -0.039640285074710846, -0.00953182578086853, 0.003183390712365508, -0.04522933438420296, -0.018566640093922615, -0.002291694050654769, -0.01824619621038437, -0.013111390173435211, 0.00628222431987524, 0.010931522585451603, -0.03129023686051369, -0.004216848406940699, 0.008420812897384167, -0.005236258264631033, -0.009511463344097137, -0.013706638477742672, -0.0538962185382843, -0.012313379906117916, -0.006247560493648052, -0.020866138860583305, 0.00563741335645318, 0.034988656640052795, 0.019107570871710777, 0.0312662236392498, 0.016651974990963936, 0.015553893521428108, 0.021615415811538696, 0.011573564261198044, -0.01202059630304575, -0.007998265326023102, 0.018121466040611267, -0.03998006880283356, -0.028863471001386642, 0.037478502839803696, -0.06532147526741028, -0.022507071495056152, 0.015986405313014984, -0.05646800249814987, 0.0018536438001319766, 0.01335529237985611, 0.011188029311597347, -0.02186780795454979, 0.06375030428171158, -0.004087552428245544, -0.0002854436170309782, 0.013152563013136387, -0.0031541502103209496, -0.006110420450568199, 0.017055612057447433, -0.005545456428080797, 0.003905892837792635, -0.031769074499607086, 0.024347491562366486, 0.0506962314248085, 0.0035750106908380985, -0.015427250415086746, 0.0254875048995018, 0.010152149945497513, 0.04293319210410118, -0.03616165369749069, -0.008487808518111706, 0.038561150431632996, 0.050092730671167374, -0.06251650303602219, 0.006944600958377123, -0.012545713223516941, 0.006905696354806423, -0.0811711996793747, -0.011632406152784824, 0.01989462412893772, -0.009177439846098423, 0.03570752590894699, -0.07456643879413605, 0.0010655885562300682, 0.022940197959542274, -0.04664742946624756, -0.0038314752746373415, 0.0008438383811153471, -0.013515444472432137, -0.043832797557115555, 0.021664384752511978, 0.0016514111775904894, 0.04190082848072052, 0.0409320704638958, 0.05048692598938942, 0.0172114260494709, 0.03386886417865753, 0.007614373695105314, -0.00007652800559299067, -0.03587387502193451, 0.014045092277228832, 0.007621085271239281, -0.05638514459133148, 0.06834933906793594, -0.03186966851353645, -0.0188957080245018, 0.03441832959651947, -0.024060413241386414, -0.02589374966919422, 0.05113391950726509, 0.010659853927791119, -0.02500356175005436, 0.028743058443069458, 0.004663458559662104, -0.02289094403386116, -0.006472362671047449, 0.0053411489352583885, 0.023326817899942398, 0.015245833434164524, -0.015517078340053558, 0.016760315746068954, 0.02055278792977333, -0.019809691235423088, -0.01690104231238365, 0.02475471794605255, 0.012507236562669277, -0.01957259699702263, 0.01959783025085926, 0.014375507831573486, 0.027012275531888008, -0.008717725053429604, 0.0348438024520874, -0.06389332562685013, -0.005437971092760563, 0.039544228464365005, 0.04068324714899063, 0.005075216293334961, -0.008761421777307987, -0.029744260013103485, -0.02336263470351696, 0.004703036043792963, -0.016232583671808243, 0.001417251187376678, -0.06768688559532166, 0.00089932483388111, -0.02038285695016384, 0.001320619834586978, -0.002893168944865465, -0.01069548074156046, 0.018916048109531403, 0.05748257786035538, -0.002850028220564127, -0.003004346275702119, 0.036397360265254974, -0.0251673124730587, 0.01781035214662552, -0.0744326114654541, 0.05293691158294678, 0.022367769852280617, -0.010479605756700039, -0.06338898837566376, -0.014850620180368423, -0.05772566422820091, 0.026238074526190758, 0.014452092349529266, 0.008271545171737671, -0.009780935943126678, -0.009775612503290176, 0.023682432249188423, 0.003595191752538085, -0.03940943256020546, 0.03206144645810127, -0.009131964296102524, 0.0052580758929252625, -0.004387591499835253, 0.0010276252869516611, 0.029045522212982178, 0.0013273939257487655, 0.042583029717206955, -0.015348197892308235, 0.010172853246331215, 0.0009532023104839027, -0.02665043994784355, 0.026955360546708107, 0.0006612848374061286, -0.005619444884359837, 0.06749599426984787, 0.012857984751462936, 0.007332357577979565, 0.03531767055392265, -0.00441492535173893, -0.042087383568286896, 0.017273183912038803, -0.022701885551214218, -0.03954480215907097, 0.009801296517252922, -0.0009428273770026863, -0.012844979763031006, -0.07039440423250198, -0.014152100309729576, 0.03009333647787571, -0.005756858270615339, -0.045504577457904816, 0.030406661331653595, 0.051333896815776825, 0.029913557693362236, 0.008000317960977554, -0.004248891491442919, -0.007857556454837322, -0.00922892615199089, -0.014984055422246456, 0.03924369439482689, 0.056140534579753876, 0.02821427956223488, 0.02594750002026558, 0.004593884572386742, 0.00580400787293911, 0.006571362726390362, -0.014414655975997448, 0.02642211504280567, -0.03748702630400658, -0.006712999660521746, 0.02720961533486843, -0.01851816102862358, 0.029939044266939163, 0.01730397157371044, 0.008871365338563919, 0.041948579251766205, -0.0733863115310669, 0.02456180565059185, -0.010329552926123142, -0.010797797702252865, -0.027919264510273933, -0.005385327152907848, 0.03984807804226875, 0.023334696888923645, -0.013178489170968533, 0.01617702655494213, -0.0004483309166971594, -0.026220865547657013, 0.02128009870648384, 0.001884220284409821, 0.025929132476449013, -0.04257579147815704, -0.003543711267411709, 0.03250964358448982, 0.03434298560023308, -0.034338414669036865, -0.008991981856524944, 0.02906407229602337, 0.008662542328238487, -0.0036898977123200893, -0.016199754551053047, -0.03656983748078346, -0.029473666101694107, 0.017917605116963387, -0.07056646794080734, 0.0016976103652268648, -0.05046437308192253, 0.028876645490527153, 0.008244547061622143, -0.026598941534757614 ]
<p>I'm having a problem using the group function in TraMineR. I have a data set that contains SPELL data, so multiple rows per case. I also have demographic data per case, at one row per case. I merge these together and end up with data that has a demographic covariate per row, so multiple rows per case. An example of this data would be:</p> <pre><code>id startmin stopmin activity educ4 4 1 20 work HS 4 20 40 play HS 8 1 15 sleep College 8 15 40 work College </code></pre> <p>I can make sequence data from this, but when I try to run a plot using the group command</p> <pre><code> seqiplot(atus.seq, group = atus.seqdata$educ4, border=NA, withlegend="right", cex.plot=.55) </code></pre> <p>it tells me: </p> <pre><code> &gt;"Error: group must contain one value for each row in the sequence object". </code></pre> <p>I have gotten this to work with the example of the mvad data in the training manual, but I can't seem to get it to work with the groups, whether I link to the original demographic data, the merged data, or try to pass the covariates by seqformat and seqdef. Ideas?</p>
73,837
[ 0.00817984901368618, -0.017943503335118294, -0.017484033480286598, 0.025850847363471985, -0.00762735353782773, -0.0042570121586322784, -0.03044600412249565, -0.020140672102570534, 0.05312629044055939, -0.027249392122030258, 0.04142490774393082, -0.0046011884696781635, 0.07971673458814621, 0.02902725711464882, 0.001726827584207058, -0.019858717918395996, -0.004775564651936293, -0.01946449652314186, 0.004443484358489513, -0.0009618402109481394, -0.036957789212465286, 0.027545390650629997, 0.0003888553474098444, -0.028319787234067917, 0.010311282239854336, 0.013682419434189796, -0.00039223500061780214, -0.006990611087530851, 0.0042687077075243, 0.01607954129576683, -0.030274175107479095, -0.06459946185350418, -0.002252510515972972, -0.012174383737146854, 0.011478194035589695, 0.009737204760313034, 0.005837234202772379, -0.06022394821047783, -0.007890477776527405, -0.0014322454808279872, -0.07206723093986511, 0.005637736525386572, -0.006441676057875156, 0.04184253513813019, -0.014333504252135754, 0.03380518779158592, -0.025068404152989388, 0.02707051672041416, 0.05301107093691826, -0.021116862073540688, 0.04414734989404678, -0.01992213726043701, 0.0029669201467186213, 0.028990846127271652, -0.05956461653113365, 0.013821016997098923, 0.02881043031811714, 0.04674587398767471, 0.04743879660964012, -0.006063958164304495, -0.0009302104008384049, -0.04914137348532677, -0.016929596662521362, -0.014016391709446907, -0.03022470511496067, 0.02495999075472355, -0.008797808550298214, 0.0008746483945287764, 0.019709613174200058, -0.06756079941987991, 0.03951774910092354, 0.00393777247518301, -0.0003438487183302641, -0.002708090003579855, 0.0011254505952820182, -0.008348194882273674, 0.004394800867885351, -0.02093719132244587, 0.0646093413233757, 0.04116714745759964, -0.006917969789355993, 0.04781390726566315, -0.013461052440106869, 0.0336584597826004, 0.0037945571821182966, 0.004995231982320547, 0.047148577868938446, -0.03390626236796379, 0.009717670269310474, 0.032753169536590576, -0.010230747051537037, -0.004177112132310867, 0.07840841263532639, 0.03359586372971535, -0.039746060967445374, 0.06978148967027664, -0.008514775894582272, 0.017986318096518517, -0.03555724024772644, 0.008249915204942226, -0.03991250693798065, -0.017919346690177917, 0.04394989833235741, 0.04631860554218292, 0.0014505346771329641, -0.012763327918946743, 0.0027326680719852448, -0.024390120059251785, 0.001286572776734829, -0.010593402199447155, 0.01121256873011589, -0.020527636632323265, -0.007957465946674347, 0.00546350609511137, 0.0017569169867783785, 0.007503847125917673, -0.0028834103140980005, 0.007659228052943945, 0.05135957896709442, 0.06305519491434097, 0.10017748177051544, -0.016556112095713615, 0.03366117179393768, -0.032268960028886795, -0.07046747952699661, 0.02511250041425228, -0.021262362599372864, -0.00946065317839384, -0.05647601559758186, 0.05472264438867569, -0.0010690714698284864, -0.03633061423897743, 0.0599084347486496, -0.024345796555280685, 0.016665533185005188, -0.037175506353378296, -0.07788056880235672, -0.04947853460907936, -0.01434169802814722, -0.014646128751337528, 0.014786077663302422, -0.07002722471952438, 0.024758128449320793, -0.00206057820469141, 0.05462557449936867, -0.026957988739013672, 0.0353974886238575, 0.03784743323922157, 0.03054678626358509, 0.02684030309319496, -0.03088448941707611, 0.0048233941197395325, -0.05060124397277832, -0.03377837687730789, -0.028942469507455826, -0.05908188596367836, 0.02342386171221733, 0.0001522625534562394, -0.0352131687104702, 0.01727944239974022, 0.04394008591771126, -0.0109779704362154, 0.0043817306868731976, -0.0285776499658823, 0.04063781350851059, -0.016004662960767746, 0.052098143845796585, 0.021223140880465508, 0.025822818279266357, 0.027662452310323715, -0.009279731661081314, 0.038093451410532, -0.0017013640608638525, 0.04553317278623581, 0.02654251456260681, -0.01202317699790001, 0.014541957527399063, 0.011911786161363125, -0.03252555802464485, 0.030310923233628273, -0.011125304736196995, -0.045282214879989624, -0.012323323637247086, -0.03563746437430382, 0.05030627176165581, 0.0020093743223696947, 0.0002705013903323561, -0.02776913531124592, 0.023639004677534103, -0.058563414961099625, -0.06426921486854553, -0.06679204851388931, -0.018271123990416527, 0.003044143784791231, -0.04445968568325043, -0.006143811158835888, -0.015647156164050102, 0.04852328449487686, 0.043358657509088516, -0.051500629633665085, -0.05937650054693222, 0.004585079848766327, 0.02219538390636444, -0.029879845678806305, -0.012166472151875496, -0.015663065016269684, 0.055026501417160034, -0.052531588822603226, 0.012266346253454685, 0.0023298205342143774, -0.009093857370316982, 0.0038369381800293922, -0.020546164363622665, 0.04564579576253891, -0.014965115115046501, -0.007188999559730291, 0.00176092644687742, 0.03255238011479378, -0.02668718248605728, 0.06697461009025574, -0.048625361174345016, 0.027227427810430527, 0.11708187311887741, -0.013800356537103653, 0.011543737724423409, 0.016501687467098236, 0.008698511868715286, 0.00436091935262084, -0.043274544179439545, -0.01965167373418808, -0.029168015345931053, -0.0072736055590212345, 0.03940505534410477, -0.0246186014264822, -0.025364700704813004, 0.04841357842087746, 0.042993806302547455, -0.01816820353269577, -0.023003531619906425, 0.04776445031166077, 0.0020413778256624937, 0.0032696707639843225, 0.008086062036454678, 0.01948552019894123, 0.02048921026289463, -0.03858232498168945, -0.002381472382694483, -0.00031445492641068995, 0.03304772078990936, 0.0355992391705513, 0.03888027369976044, 0.0644749253988266, 0.005421208217740059, -0.007763274479657412, -0.010341041721403599, 0.007820650935173035, 0.016503173857927322, -0.013664735481142998, 0.01387398038059473, 0.032881129533052444, 0.01598218083381653, -0.030260099098086357, 0.021578563377261162, -0.05285283923149109, -0.032399892807006836, 0.017812645062804222, 0.008117584511637688, 0.002808671910315752, -0.001409874763339758, -0.03490753099322319, 0.006095792166888714, -0.003755546873435378, -0.028608696535229683, -0.05175325646996498, 0.03330712020397186, 0.03629140555858612, 0.01430254615843296, 0.03148762509226799, -0.03124416060745716, -0.0031765401363372803, -0.009596273303031921, -0.006085450295358896, 0.07914033532142639, -0.004122063983231783, -0.05238348990678787, 0.03219856694340706, -0.030893243849277496, 0.012692844495177269, 0.034041594713926315, 0.005282809492200613, -0.05071214586496353, 0.027892816811800003, -0.020528338849544525, -0.050143755972385406, -0.03428899869322777, -0.03550638630986214, -0.008294906467199326, -0.04070994257926941, -0.00949135236442089, 0.01854463666677475, 0.03913010656833649, -0.040871888399124146, -0.002149864798411727, -0.03517845273017883, 0.016768252477049828, -0.03252512961626053, -0.007451866753399372, 0.007703772746026516, 0.021172337234020233, 0.017823603004217148, 0.03346166014671326, 0.016599085181951523, -0.014622395858168602, -0.03983696177601814, -0.04924469068646431, 0.0018657305045053363, 0.03666045144200325, 0.05129091814160347, 0.02621498331427574, 0.011374841444194317, 0.02677052654325962, 0.03327392414212227, -0.043299946933984756, -0.04673156142234802, 0.01640302874147892, -0.025430411100387573, -0.01294920314103365, 0.05037844181060791, 0.009159141220152378, 0.026168841868638992, 0.003328684950247407, 0.0023468914441764355, 0.03671036288142204, 0.08170931786298752, -0.044285427778959274, -0.03180184215307236, 0.029834270477294922, 0.02114718034863472, -0.009871438145637512, 0.04326533153653145, 0.029220692813396454, 0.0011681127361953259, 0.020129146054387093, -0.022872792556881905, -0.019696295261383057, -0.029587162658572197, -0.07306840270757675, 0.017331309616565704, -0.01882215589284897, 0.03139251843094826, -0.050001174211502075, 0.02011452428996563, 0.02448592521250248, -0.037593092769384384, -0.03688739612698555, 0.04783342033624649, 0.032894860953092575, -0.0314493328332901, 0.010136226192116737, 0.06260086596012115, 0.04191433638334274, -0.017886189743876457, 0.0194944366812706, -0.009556137025356293, 0.00014356955944094807, 0.025946244597434998, -0.027891235426068306, 0.008268473669886589, -0.009851212613284588, 0.01084468886256218, 0.007093533407896757, 0.008562842383980751, -0.024830421432852745, 0.021501459181308746, -0.043096620589494705, 0.02067808248102665, -0.00791578833013773, 0.045038651674985886, 0.035280752927064896, 0.052627306431531906, 0.013872944749891758, -0.005879701115190983, 0.002097641583532095, -0.036034829914569855, -0.0488433800637722, -0.00043162843212485313, 0.030420472845435143, -0.029928335919976234, -0.013342583552002907, -0.013677486218512058, -0.004431369714438915, 0.022154176607728004, 0.03444720432162285, 0.0181198138743639, 0.025682304054498672, -0.012807652354240417, -0.019980084151029587, -0.03986726701259613, 0.024373425170779228, -0.017053844407200813, 0.009983986616134644, 0.058482855558395386, -0.015565771609544754, 0.026502586901187897, 0.013743961229920387, 0.00803335104137659, -0.024833591654896736, -0.004875963553786278, -0.02412991411983967, -0.011958369985222816, 0.009080920368432999, 0.04172418639063835, -0.0013308209599927068, -0.015220425091683865, -0.014583799988031387, -0.025863980874419212, 0.018334757536649704, 0.056927453726530075, -0.013258826918900013, 0.006228835787624121, 0.018401822075247765, -0.008249701000750065, 0.020654037594795227, 0.03981682285666466, 0.03458177670836449, -0.010982240550220013, 0.02778700180351734, 0.07051701843738556, -0.06360236555337906, 0.02334948256611824, 0.053199946880340576, 0.015173524618148804, 0.010000587441027164, -0.019100617617368698, 0.017026573419570923, -0.0005876689683645964, -0.014668655581772327, 0.020166952162981033, 0.007531242910772562, -0.00350155564956367, 0.002631379757076502, 0.02854163572192192, -0.0035341607872396708, -0.022786598652601242, 0.026006773114204407, -0.016632791608572006, 0.038108423352241516, 0.013455851003527641, 0.0004400176403578371, 0.02648071013391018, 0.02648221142590046, 0.026483183726668358, 0.026726892217993736, 0.014547471888363361, -0.09164109081029892, -0.0008518995018675923, 0.056170202791690826, 0.06116142123937607, -0.009402252733707428, -0.037362176924943924, -0.03653153032064438, 0.0009980828035622835, 0.030545921996235847, -0.04282297566533089, 0.03141483664512634, -0.013598794117569923, -0.009065011516213417, -0.05500376597046852, -0.04173814505338669, -0.049570534378290176, 0.025394299998879433, 0.0051162876188755035, 0.02801821194589138, 0.029425449669361115, -0.0260646790266037, -0.01574101485311985, 0.03998395428061485, -0.00014567865582648665, 0.03855881467461586, -0.036920323967933655, -0.014802876859903336, 0.02591891773045063, 0.023999370634555817, -0.04049263522028923, -0.029396479949355125, 0.03125869482755661, -0.020989369601011276, 0.030221015214920044, 0.05892183259129524, 0.0015857549151405692, 0.006161019206047058, 0.02843867987394333, 0.004749642685055733, 0.0036974595859646797, -0.03955202177166939, -0.03151200711727142, 0.01491804700344801, 0.030553273856639862, 0.018972095102071762, 0.04517075791954994, 0.011860480532050133, -0.012406542897224426, 0.039458777755498886, -0.08986862748861313, -0.001534158829599619, -0.030162706971168518, -0.04028749093413353, -0.04264933615922928, -0.010594956576824188, -0.016264142468571663, 0.0007565557025372982, -0.036566827446222305, 0.029418665915727615, -0.05490291118621826, 0.05514771118760109, 0.05901465564966202, 0.027221526950597763, -0.010119423270225525, -0.0024618597235530615, -0.004466736223548651, 0.02809184230864048, -0.028172116726636887, -0.023231863975524902, 0.05081746354699135, -0.05104675516486168, -0.013112207874655724, 0.006648209877312183, -0.04654897004365921, -0.023028656840324402, 0.006236076354980469, -0.00032557870144955814, 0.010501530021429062, -0.029851362109184265, -0.003487574402242899, -0.032621998339891434, 0.026555616408586502, -0.010152890346944332, -0.04471274092793465, 0.017528165131807327, 0.014997533522546291, -0.04554968699812889, -0.013597667217254639, 0.030642054975032806, 0.06407234072685242, -0.010540543124079704, -0.0022665467113256454, -0.06380095332860947, -0.10219128429889679, -0.008314410224556923, -0.02405964396893978, -0.043851569294929504, -0.045123886317014694, -0.028074651956558228, 0.0032507493160665035, -0.01546768844127655, 0.01654471829533577, 0.038828376680612564, -0.03728829696774483, 0.01712457649409771, -0.04417996108531952, 0.00922248512506485, 0.07427549362182617, 0.03275369480252266, 0.007291469722986221, 0.062134332954883575, 0.0053711640648543835, 0.0032087198924273252, 0.004801712930202484, -0.03327380493283272, -0.028816699981689453, -0.005407399497926235, -0.02002817764878273, -0.00610367301851511, 0.07338476926088333, -0.004068715497851372, 0.006890090648084879, 0.002275617327541113, -0.012896846048533916, 0.024573029950261116, -0.05706382915377617, 0.004473171662539244, -0.02978581003844738, 0.0020381479989737272, -0.055218663066625595, 0.020249873399734497, -0.03333010897040367, -0.002284762216731906, 0.042439281940460205, 0.0018457850674167275, -0.006598573178052902, 0.02265436016023159, 0.07276320457458496, -0.0034890412352979183, 0.033381637185811996, 0.018487602472305298, -0.026458771899342537, 0.029013266786932945, 0.03407562896609306, -0.011313014663755894, -0.002124765422195196, 0.016955137252807617, -0.02959800697863102, 0.007921850308775902, -0.032196979969739914, -0.0032234841492027044, 0.060274720191955566, -0.028641769662499428, 0.04026796296238899, 0.04057291895151138, -0.035697221755981445, -0.016545657068490982, -0.012640808708965778, 0.020459908992052078, -0.02775421366095543, 0.013314940966665745, 0.05454211309552193, 0.0024428183678537607, -0.015925437211990356, -0.023847006261348724, 0.040496014058589935, 0.03197845444083214, 0.00817139819264412, 0.01888852007687092, 0.020835965871810913, -0.00013898646284360439, -0.0058939955197274685, -0.042534615844488144, 0.01829651929438114, -0.007742034737020731, 0.018365783616900444, -0.048361994326114655, -0.04550686478614807, 0.02729603461921215, 0.048477984964847565, -0.0030239582993090153, -0.01911076158285141, -0.04031209647655487, -0.056549008935689926, 0.007052005734294653, 0.02661917544901371, -0.06687285751104355, 0.06045563146471977, -0.009563642553985119, 0.051230836659669876, 0.024012893438339233, 0.028182148933410645, -0.07622019201517105, -0.041079625487327576, 0.0017831947188824415, -0.032433897256851196, -0.023899663239717484, 0.06088363379240036, -0.019916826859116554, 0.006121267098933458, -0.003643803996965289, -0.0073289694264531136, 0.04021238163113594, 0.023381000384688377, 0.0019830050878226757, 0.005748785100877285, 0.05799484997987747, -0.0068783508613705635, 0.031319741159677505, -0.006806099787354469, -0.04244973883032799, 0.1532217562198639, 0.04976323992013931, 0.04240163043141365, -0.03461495414376259, 0.0145953930914402, 0.016127223148941994, -0.024166811257600784, -0.018210191279649734, 0.009724815376102924, 0.025531310588121414, 0.030083270743489265, 0.05226309597492218, 0.06421498954296112, 0.009910321794450283, 0.0387207493185997, 0.03126780316233635, -0.03472308814525604, -0.016729768365621567, 0.03804433345794678, 0.016263289377093315, -0.001015949877910316, -0.029969867318868637, -0.036323461681604385, -0.02757214568555355, 0.0284996647387743, 0.022208239883184433, -0.019437875598669052, -0.023390116170048714, 0.0015817777020856738, 0.031559720635414124, 0.0008901804103516042, 0.028720946982502937, 0.006319064646959305, -0.023260923102498055, 0.001000956050120294, -0.051360681653022766, -0.006871297489851713, -0.04228219389915466, 0.017637360841035843, -0.0016670746263116598, -0.007980887778103352, -0.004955796059221029, -0.0326339490711689, 0.02049444615840912, -0.023001806810498238, -0.030979441478848457, 0.0001894165761768818, 0.04066719487309456, -0.013641833327710629, -0.003010974731296301, 0.018681352958083153, 0.012985057197511196, 0.00021563074551522732, -0.05178799852728844, -0.02715758979320526, 0.00015536359569523484, 0.02849510870873928, 0.01713351346552372, -0.003048353362828493, -0.007024149410426617, -0.02390798181295395, 0.012435141950845718, 0.008563997223973274, 0.0063827745616436005, 0.004245108924806118, -0.007812067866325378, -0.0724741593003273, 0.01659148931503296, -0.01596161536872387, 0.010063418187201023, 0.04074401408433914, -0.023711349815130234, 0.002732427790760994, -0.019581211730837822, 0.03982885926961899, 0.017331978306174278, 0.0071689593605697155, -0.02246377430856228, -0.00927147176116705, 0.0043042427860200405, -0.021483581513166428, -0.0014712424017488956, -0.04106197506189346, -0.06797332316637039, 0.00915028341114521, 0.01982978917658329, 0.03344431519508362, 0.02278825268149376, -0.01948239654302597, 0.009891602210700512, -0.009698851965367794, 0.05345863476395607, 0.018937749788165092, -0.034415848553180695, -0.0043218727223575115, 0.03764823451638222, -0.012949984520673752, -0.013988954946398735, -0.042908888310194016, 0.07528019696474075, -0.0023356869351118803, -0.00528786052018404, 0.00808161124587059, -0.005818221718072891, 0.05397149547934532, 0.006311062257736921, 0.043663933873176575, -0.06182156503200531, 0.03140076994895935, -0.012624048627912998, 0.007294546812772751, -0.03652358055114746, -0.029482604935765266, -0.061319418251514435, -0.054903171956539154, 0.031099528074264526, -0.02999456413090229, -0.04406135901808739, -0.01414650958031416, -0.030840152874588966, 0.01737193763256073, -0.0005828671273775399, 0.016043728217482567, -0.022240815684199333, -0.0033332903403788805, -0.04395749792456627, -0.01884026639163494, -0.027852367609739304, 0.007788015063852072, -0.04119911044836044, 0.03724748268723488, 0.02454088255763054, 0.03364359587430954, 0.0037990338169038296, -0.0063445959240198135, 0.0006229925784282386, -0.010655783116817474, 0.03643355518579483, 0.011227142997086048, -0.00867358036339283, 0.01995418220758438, -0.041155584156513214, 0.002373066730797291, -0.0014704674249514937, -0.016287479549646378, 0.021823067218065262, 0.00507150124758482, 0.00980625580996275, -0.009496285580098629, 0.06322839856147766, 0.004225192591547966, -0.02008538693189621, -0.005613996181637049, -0.003621605923399329, 0.052853114902973175, 0.001816662261262536, -0.018768461421132088, 0.02242090180516243, -0.014806140214204788, 0.01905047334730625, 0.02276342175900936, 0.03700154647231102, -0.019314154982566833, -0.03713354468345642, -0.02651165798306465, 0.03421211615204811, 0.003178536891937256, 0.01745624467730522, 0.031458575278520584, 0.03795421123504639, -0.023628104478120804, -0.0018378559034317732, -0.03236260637640953, 0.027567852288484573, -0.07939484715461731, -0.037199702113866806, -0.02635105885565281, -0.0014204289764165878, 0.007314289920032024, -0.03865337371826172, -0.008253377862274647, 0.015753036364912987, -0.03398948535323143, -0.0036555284168571234, -0.025224780663847923, 0.022790497168898582, -0.05207189917564392, 0.031864043325185776, -0.02412247098982334, 0.03078569285571575, 0.022257117554545403, 0.02536182291805744, 0.024794455617666245, -0.020555129274725914, -0.003640423296019435, -0.029288122430443764, 0.0023604491725564003, 0.01522053126245737, 0.03834386542439461, -0.02307557687163353, 0.01835850067436695, -0.022317450493574142, 0.00472647650167346, 0.015818841755390167, -0.022965718060731888, 0.0012605107622221112, 0.0759451761841774, 0.028065966442227364, -0.008927722461521626, 0.030655762180685997, 0.030481167137622833, 0.005508278030902147, -0.02855209819972515, -0.008899064734578133, -0.014795862138271332, -0.008249427191913128, -0.026466354727745056, -0.00749887153506279, 0.03937717154622078, 0.00852395873516798, -0.02001521736383438, 0.04038526862859726, -0.03907883167266846, -0.026953160762786865, -0.014709798619151115, -0.016365692019462585, 0.0026958349626511335, -0.02596539817750454, 0.006056257523596287, -0.02395225502550602, 0.021986721083521843, 0.03205683454871178, 0.01905304193496704, 0.0140347545966506, -0.0037457419093698263, 0.02274547703564167, -0.06896292418241501, -0.02940174750983715, 0.009714070707559586, -0.002373036462813616, -0.0456664077937603, -0.0027973537798970938, 0.02099297009408474, -0.01586761511862278, -0.03356937691569328, 0.019776608794927597, -0.04027217999100685, 0.062442757189273834, -0.008142431266605854, 0.012538022361695766, 0.03167087584733963, -0.017637699842453003, -0.0011012989562004805, -0.04703907296061516, 0.029486261308193207, -0.02333000861108303, 0.007911900989711285, -0.04192746803164482, 0.008785947225987911, -0.002206200733780861, 0.03934505581855774, 0.025698194280266762, 0.0008933215867727995, 0.001347662415355444, -0.0025462238118052483, -0.01712869666516781, 0.0009076099377125502, 0.008106755092740059, 0.06943085789680481, -0.01563735119998455, 0.009752797894179821, 0.02169639989733696, 0.0076311430893838406, -0.03225020319223404, -0.0013338293647393584, 0.0006615218590013683, -0.033799849450588226, 0.03955494984984398, 0.027526352554559708, 0.009027055464684963, -0.024111390113830566, 0.0006977863959036767, -0.022219248116016388, 0.021339528262615204, -0.030380304902791977, -0.03170431777834892, 0.035956643521785736, 0.03189633786678314, -0.024118296802043915, 0.04054425284266472, -0.04606784135103226, -0.02242734096944332, 0.039201173931360245, -0.017463412135839462, 0.028493357822299004, -0.01882730796933174, 0.02449028380215168, 0.0026128659956157207, -0.028299540281295776, -0.02212694101035595, 0.04838551580905914, 0.020024679601192474, 0.003720981767401099, -0.007872723042964935, 0.025692043825984, -0.02381105162203312, -0.03162446990609169, 0.037315983325242996, 0.017066190019249916, 0.034352321177721024, 0.018341373652219772, 0.006760486401617527, 0.009611274115741253, -0.016688432544469833, 0.02665822207927704, -0.009421379305422306, 0.04281940683722496, -0.014029193669557571, -0.013155793771147728, -0.010893518105149269, -0.039704397320747375, 0.061297930777072906, 0.01377392839640379, 0.0011014154879376292, 0.03178125619888306, -0.03557635098695755, 0.04351538419723511, -0.0420878529548645, -0.050119608640670776, -0.035577576607465744, 0.02364928275346756, 0.026174653321504593, 0.043460775166749954, 0.0017491898033767939, 0.027646206319332123, -0.049911659210920334, -0.020149236544966698, 0.02851502224802971, -0.04403139650821686, -0.015479025430977345, -0.01885252445936203, -0.007400153670459986, 0.01082712970674038, -0.032281294465065, -0.030987264588475227, -0.04808354377746582, -0.030774522572755814, 0.02072891779243946, 0.01410212367773056, -0.04511794075369835, -0.007067037280648947, 0.013773939572274685, 0.023969411849975586, -0.0256493017077446, -0.047673702239990234, -0.042170200496912, 0.0007773855468258262, 0.013120305724442005, -0.004890735726803541 ]
<p>I am trying to estimate a binomial proportion p, say, from a sample of binomials. There are k subjects. Associated with each subject is a sample size $n_i$ and a count $x_i$ of items, where $x_i$ is distributed as a binomial $(p, n_i)$. I can assume that the sample sizes are not a function of $p$. </p> <p>In sampling terms, the sampling unit is the subject, not the number of items $x_i$.</p> <p>I want to estimate p and provide a confidence interval for it.</p> <p>Should I take $$\hat{p}=\frac{\sum_i x_i}{\sum_i n_i}$$ or should I take the average of the cluster means? $$ \frac{1}{k} \sum_i \frac{x_i}{n_i}$$</p> <p>And how should I estimate the standard deviation?</p>
41,434
[ -0.02976791001856327, -0.048959337174892426, 0.004999005701392889, -0.01671428419649601, 0.0069550941698253155, 0.004996470175683498, -0.01802455261349678, -0.021881358698010445, 0.025206295773386955, -0.03221840038895607, 0.07712610065937042, 0.05347402021288872, 0.04661006107926369, 0.028806760907173157, -0.003377073211595416, -0.005265535321086645, -0.03089001402258873, -0.011760739609599113, 0.0015079020522534847, -0.018681293353438377, 0.011939025484025478, 0.013636558316648006, 0.009555811062455177, -0.004232991486787796, -0.013916115276515484, 0.05551677197217941, 0.032163601368665695, -0.017323926091194153, 0.01634257100522518, 0.07370120286941528, -0.04061278700828552, -0.03449678793549538, 0.038339514285326004, 0.016190771013498306, -0.006597447674721479, -0.012983485125005245, -0.026234440505504608, -0.024605974555015564, 0.003371414728462696, 0.02504611946642399, -0.06450827419757843, -0.032865822315216064, 0.029228469356894493, -0.05011938884854317, 0.0034152695443481207, 0.03934166207909584, -0.0077174510806798935, -0.08845726400613785, 0.00893260259181261, -0.05802563950419426, 0.05016371235251427, 0.040919676423072815, 0.03749409690499306, 0.014071576297283173, -0.03950152173638344, 0.01170220784842968, 0.04819432273507118, 0.05327768623828888, -0.006186597980558872, -0.058286283165216446, -0.003530140034854412, -0.052007317543029785, 0.004942342173308134, -0.01934164948761463, -0.04782688245177269, 0.010760309174656868, -0.019589442759752274, -0.007413851097226143, 0.026403216645121574, -0.010992182418704033, 0.020698800683021545, 0.010689511895179749, 0.03807980194687843, -0.00005440408131107688, -0.007197909522801638, -0.05409388989210129, 0.013201858848333359, 0.03154504671692848, 0.06237461417913437, 0.06255839020013809, 0.04249941557645798, -0.014021716080605984, 0.03762509301304817, 0.02168429084122181, 0.0267062745988369, -0.011522284708917141, 0.06971465051174164, 0.0028725143056362867, -0.0020579530391842127, 0.012841728515923023, -0.025725610554218292, -0.011209199205040932, 0.05228386074304581, -0.019779669120907784, -0.009117510169744492, 0.036212559789419174, -0.05067765340209007, 0.04556335136294365, -0.002267371164634824, -0.01434324961155653, 0.003994756378233433, -0.027792491018772125, 0.0011750254780054092, 0.05392194166779518, -0.02079828456044197, -0.02358390763401985, -0.03227991983294487, 0.009601043537259102, -0.010544456541538239, -0.01347716711461544, -0.0031120050698518753, 0.03370650112628937, 0.01533467136323452, 0.01958608254790306, 0.026412498205900192, -0.0027169089298695326, -0.014204364269971848, -0.018201710656285286, 0.04477662965655327, 0.04810133948922157, 0.035981498658657074, -0.012658816762268543, 0.028203340247273445, -0.025725217536091805, -0.048908282071352005, 0.026522619649767876, 0.01028408482670784, -0.0294199101626873, -0.06020472198724747, 0.031548839062452316, 0.011995704844594002, -0.0024457781109958887, 0.06778642535209656, 0.020760705694556236, 0.014110100455582142, 0.007844838313758373, -0.06775454431772232, -0.031038260087370872, 0.004669021815061569, -0.005563955754041672, -0.005783648695796728, -0.0589832067489624, 0.013970630243420601, 0.03486355021595955, 0.029987016692757607, -0.0031042061746120453, 0.035997916013002396, -0.00736176036298275, 0.02969859354197979, 0.009581528604030609, -0.031705718487501144, -0.010332569479942322, -0.0101419473066926, -0.013410977087914944, -0.00010313007805962116, -0.06350381672382355, 0.050006456673145294, 0.03358679264783859, 0.0216324832290411, -0.01005200669169426, 0.004583659581840038, 0.03392098471522331, -0.018215958029031754, 0.0010483020450919867, 0.028400763869285583, 0.005084157455712557, 0.05412758141756058, -0.005476315971463919, 0.06451033055782318, 0.00948368664830923, 0.008215273730456829, -0.0012813213979825377, 0.02898777835071087, 0.01512809470295906, 0.07910053431987762, -0.016864726319909096, -0.014681261964142323, -0.005069774109870195, -0.0059050628915429115, 0.009307046420872211, -0.03454044461250305, -0.023934638127684593, 0.024244247004389763, 0.01428116112947464, 0.037426698952913284, 0.03499063849449158, 0.002358705271035433, -0.04088408499956131, -0.011431747116148472, -0.006099862977862358, -0.04884687066078186, -0.09455406665802002, -0.010230543091893196, 0.012009554542601109, -0.015844453126192093, 0.06703907996416092, -0.011190368793904781, -0.01911291666328907, -0.00676352996379137, -0.010592765174806118, -0.025183605030179024, -0.014594092965126038, 0.04122767224907875, -0.05637155845761299, -0.020707817748188972, 0.04852745309472084, 0.07074522972106934, 0.014193762093782425, 0.040848951786756516, -0.02097664773464203, -0.05916213244199753, -0.03938257694244385, -0.02140638791024685, -0.021219516173005104, -0.014351633377373219, -0.008416381664574146, 0.008710101246833801, -0.017526451498270035, -0.01594899594783783, 0.030225154012441635, -0.04371529817581177, 0.06247485801577568, 0.058188434690237045, -0.004072688985615969, 0.036544881761074066, 0.013580632396042347, 0.019176408648490906, -0.006926293019205332, 0.0064450763165950775, -0.017249368131160736, -0.07342416793107986, 0.0060584512539207935, 0.044878359884023666, -0.004242876544594765, -0.04610889405012131, 0.01278506126254797, 0.048644062131643295, 0.020823273807764053, 0.007389652542769909, -0.0033174629788845778, -0.029761187732219696, -0.015416271053254604, 0.003531826427206397, 0.020505940541625023, 0.0015248516574501991, -0.0008492922643199563, 0.0027340848464518785, -0.018314018845558167, 0.026268482208251953, 0.028125228360295296, 0.008316700346767902, 0.04244836047291756, 0.03186497837305069, 0.005654437001794577, 0.022509479895234108, -0.017173239961266518, 0.025580989196896553, 0.0033630263060331345, -0.006694800220429897, 0.013624655082821846, 0.0006520063034258783, -0.00002763140764727723, 0.006385839078575373, -0.037668127566576004, 0.011034696362912655, 0.051302697509527206, -0.06938111037015915, 0.011984065175056458, -0.00998771097511053, -0.05177892744541168, -0.0004972541937604547, -0.006867750082165003, -0.03667082265019417, -0.047060057520866394, 0.0032851509749889374, 0.003289401065558195, 0.0037327930331230164, 0.00415812898427248, -0.008981192484498024, 0.0002925087756011635, 0.01381145790219307, 0.004274759907275438, -0.000041010480344993994, 0.004174118395894766, -0.06259986013174057, 0.003557693911716342, -0.0433901846408844, 0.0003057287249248475, 0.019761350005865097, -0.003297339426353574, -0.003409002209082246, 0.01932319439947605, 0.023520104587078094, -0.03125761076807976, 0.023348310962319374, 0.0075226700864732265, 0.017299415543675423, -0.03974539414048195, -0.017457203939557076, 0.014841719530522823, 0.011794558726251125, -0.01946198381483555, 0.04862489551305771, -0.03708647936582565, -0.0166579969227314, -0.03268231078982353, 0.012487947940826416, 0.019654419273138046, -0.02206980437040329, -0.020931173115968704, -0.001286626560613513, 0.012335804291069508, 0.006213075015693903, -0.08042997121810913, -0.04659486934542656, -0.01145778689533472, 0.009397873654961586, 0.030125457793474197, 0.038610026240348816, -0.01628141477704048, 0.07156509906053543, 0.020777378231287003, -0.0019987826235592365, 0.0032774361316114664, -0.0061750952154397964, -0.019966701045632362, -0.008458421565592289, 0.023810584098100662, 0.019171081483364105, -0.004061503801494837, 0.00314154289662838, 0.015307598747313023, 0.013281709514558315, 0.026296701282262802, 0.005693200044333935, -0.00690733827650547, 0.0227175522595644, -0.006039254833012819, -0.03144453838467598, 0.057867202907800674, 0.007557610981166363, -0.023642566055059433, -0.019259434193372726, -0.030999334529042244, -0.00814582034945488, 0.01077888160943985, -0.02138160541653633, 0.010364372283220291, -0.05006192624568939, -0.02910582348704338, -0.02607690542936325, 0.043059829622507095, 0.03257596492767334, -0.03424658253788948, 0.033945150673389435, 0.01059481780976057, 0.019425179809331894, -0.023662716150283813, -0.015558493323624134, 0.05930652469396591, 0.059170763939619064, 0.0004563224210869521, -0.017835145816206932, 0.009586441330611706, -0.0024943482130765915, 0.015519516542553902, -0.03424711897969246, -0.04334300756454468, 0.01597793772816658, 0.08413872867822647, 0.03356054797768593, -0.03588719666004181, -0.0481712631881237, 0.01823500543832779, -0.0707772895693779, -0.005687813274562359, -0.04523123800754547, 0.03827664628624916, -0.035480547696352005, 0.0821891725063324, 0.025766758248209953, -0.023017313331365585, 0.01115700975060463, 0.012707884423434734, -0.07604610174894333, 0.03664982691407204, -0.04476803168654442, -0.004782879259437323, -0.01587529666721821, -0.022798696532845497, 0.024901049211621284, 0.005656684748828411, 0.02692815288901329, -0.0022029199171811342, 0.037787165492773056, 0.012427940964698792, 0.014732765033841133, -0.013030788861215115, -0.01890397071838379, 0.03608566150069237, 0.033972837030887604, -0.00899500586092472, -0.03596701845526695, 0.01140462327748537, 0.043283093720674515, 0.02681106887757778, 0.025820324197411537, -0.02132309414446354, 0.01158063393086195, -0.019789746031165123, 0.03926419839262962, 0.02147880382835865, -0.01309871394187212, -0.031036153435707092, 0.033389437943696976, 0.020988088101148605, 0.06699536740779877, 0.03647233545780182, -0.01619572937488556, 0.025671664625406265, -0.029521360993385315, -0.02001478150486946, -0.008496775291860104, 0.006173212546855211, -0.010196716524660587, 0.003817525692284107, 0.07695372402667999, 0.03907858580350876, -0.06459113955497742, -0.005397775676101446, 0.03943323343992233, 0.015194002538919449, 0.009073242545127869, -0.05409159138798714, 0.035284239798784256, 0.012224883772432804, -0.030838415026664734, 0.026714909821748734, 0.03214802220463753, 0.019115295261144638, 0.029935279861092567, 0.058680567890405655, -0.00019438528397586197, -0.07793585956096649, 0.006931154057383537, 0.019926395267248154, 0.03555205464363098, -0.01802152954041958, -0.029314154759049416, 0.03366757556796074, 0.05190615728497505, 0.037924252450466156, 0.00034725407022051513, -0.0033538572024554014, -0.08949388563632965, 0.009949914179742336, 0.05071994662284851, 0.027671290561556816, -0.07300111651420593, 0.009385878220200539, -0.03289887681603432, 0.022273670881986618, 0.02180163562297821, -0.04000340774655342, 0.008906823582947254, -0.04694603756070137, 0.0207879189401865, -0.0071090697310864925, -0.0175812765955925, -0.05958886072039604, 0.007794167380779982, -0.0130047257989645, 0.01623542420566082, -0.012484102509915829, 0.006660880520939827, -0.0291648730635643, 0.025425849482417107, 0.055510878562927246, 0.08201626688241959, -0.03667794540524483, -0.04309874773025513, 0.01774505153298378, 0.03638438507914543, -0.0015072294045239687, -0.06646018475294113, 0.0008547998149879277, -0.008623724803328514, -0.01118911150842905, 0.032124113291502, -0.0276324525475502, -0.060482751578092575, 0.031486839056015015, -0.009354328736662865, -0.027770163491368294, -0.004666328430175781, -0.059160634875297546, 0.053674835711717606, 0.026803378015756607, 0.034424468874931335, 0.05576330050826073, 0.007363523822277784, -0.011993289925158024, 0.012293913401663303, -0.04786398634314537, -0.0020215336699038744, -0.03495757281780243, 0.008491410873830318, -0.015992244705557823, -0.001102834241464734, -0.016741709783673286, 0.014638153836131096, -0.011711017228662968, 0.03247437998652458, -0.0042181662283837795, -0.03039858117699623, 0.014215270057320595, 0.014826648868620396, 0.05245567113161087, 0.034730181097984314, -0.009920623153448105, 0.01127553265541792, 0.015846725553274155, -0.025512434542179108, 0.021333642303943634, -0.02736654132604599, 0.017647389322519302, -0.015621829777956009, -0.04292212799191475, -0.009281650185585022, -0.06664716452360153, -0.032553087919950485, 0.015067989937961102, -0.023616883903741837, 0.0630025640130043, -0.033478930592536926, 0.046921003609895706, -0.003960867412388325, -0.03206779435276985, -0.038810960948467255, -0.011235829442739487, -0.00040954112773761153, 0.04758765920996666, -0.05340774357318878, 0.010504795238375664, -0.0014033864717930555, -0.005322604905813932, -0.06548137962818146, -0.03407419100403786, 0.02483963593840599, 0.011999370530247688, 0.001070624333806336, -0.03312534838914871, 0.01368127390742302, 0.0021982677280902863, -0.04196372255682945, -0.038978517055511475, 0.04386041685938835, -0.027507957071065903, -0.035384707152843475, -0.03856081888079643, 0.02316063642501831, 0.07312478125095367, -0.0003631538129411638, -0.011530833318829536, 0.02145974151790142, -0.0334211103618145, -0.01876767724752426, -0.01907855086028576, -0.024394353851675987, -0.018973201513290405, -0.03027207963168621, -0.03257431834936142, -0.0021776200737804174, 0.04035743325948715, -0.03540823236107826, -0.03292463719844818, 0.02133323810994625, 0.01710827648639679, 0.010019287467002869, -0.0419706329703331, -0.015566672198474407, -0.012592894956469536, 0.04326589033007622, -0.030119601637125015, -0.010396544821560383, -0.020258983597159386, 0.03232239559292793, 0.05209830030798912, 0.04538661241531372, -0.03251803666353226, 0.025898737832903862, 0.054908834397792816, -0.013108071871101856, 0.009043067693710327, 0.03154384717345238, -0.02623145654797554, 0.04176018759608269, 0.02096325159072876, -0.0004926620167680085, 0.05718157812952995, 0.04028340056538582, -0.0037658573128283024, 0.023456411436200142, -0.04410252720117569, -0.0016638502711430192, 0.053636204451322556, 0.033097077161073685, 0.013101751916110516, 0.04290947690606117, 0.008840973488986492, 0.028126779943704605, -0.03398994356393814, -0.013143659569323063, -0.04516348987817764, -0.00007079166971379891, 0.03806013613939285, -0.015179123729467392, 0.009288165718317032, 0.05715031921863556, 0.023774297907948494, -0.017842883244156837, 0.02934625744819641, 0.013603700324892998, 0.02251148596405983, 0.0019969376735389233, -0.028254428878426552, -0.04308199882507324, 0.030777961015701294, -0.06482404470443726, 0.008843185380101204, -0.06900733709335327, -0.03732982650399208, 0.028232745826244354, 0.006302459631115198, 0.00011264198838034645, -0.03534911200404167, -0.014556745998561382, -0.009330975823104382, -0.020004266873002052, -0.014785335399210453, -0.011594374664127827, 0.013232260942459106, -0.0013533696765080094, 0.01387765072286129, -0.04636114463210106, 0.033260803669691086, -0.010225136764347553, -0.07096286118030548, -0.03998642787337303, -0.010026424191892147, -0.07249758392572403, 0.005441431887447834, -0.0035432949662208557, -0.007752235047519207, 0.028913795948028564, -0.022134197875857353, 0.049531228840351105, 0.015315798111259937, 0.044594187289476395, 0.0045806244015693665, 0.060593195259571075, 0.016250934451818466, 0.012580887414515018, 0.0025935566518455744, 0.026873307302594185, 0.12172625213861465, 0.05139676481485367, 0.03903459385037422, -0.04204900562763214, 0.019932610914111137, -0.020502325147390366, -0.0048217084258794785, -0.02835337072610855, 0.017574138939380646, -0.001191828167065978, -0.0014366003451868892, 0.042173925787210464, 0.05091504752635956, 0.0009593848371878266, 0.0036422472912818193, 0.048138149082660675, -0.01624717190861702, -0.01470679696649313, 0.010541778989136219, 0.007888173684477806, -0.01626896671950817, 0.006264510098844767, -0.04067428410053253, 0.006378258112818003, 0.04821302741765976, -0.017377886921167374, -0.03117922507226467, -0.004807939287275076, -0.03292665630578995, 0.017788486555218697, -0.026286175474524498, -0.008586704730987549, 0.03212345391511917, -0.016616351902484894, -0.019823845475912094, -0.031201418489217758, 0.0024810463655740023, -0.04682513698935509, -0.011456151492893696, 0.02235984429717064, -0.0257836002856493, 0.009010190144181252, -0.004859522916376591, 0.014357486739754677, -0.05624869465827942, -0.003368557896465063, -0.03240232542157173, 0.038435835391283035, -0.01001794170588255, 0.02752307802438736, -0.010679135099053383, -0.025624847039580345, -0.005124850198626518, -0.03066842071712017, -0.00544026680290699, 0.020146094262599945, 0.04570281133055687, -0.049741752445697784, -0.03658752143383026, -0.055232979357242584, -0.01614755019545555, -0.010371697135269642, 0.025507507845759392, 0.02135075442492962, 0.0024126318749040365, -0.04043782502412796, -0.007577874697744846, 0.013783341273665428, -0.015272674150764942, 0.0019106233958154917, 0.04376873001456261, 0.003165662055835128, -0.039184119552373886, 0.009021613746881485, 0.02511947602033615, -0.015857165679335594, 0.07092496752738953, 0.0016586531419306993, 0.004239560570567846, 0.0190756656229496, -0.050349701195955276, -0.013442432507872581, -0.029197294265031815, -0.0005857437499798834, -0.029054999351501465, 0.029217593371868134, -0.0013809425290673971, 0.009724910371005535, -0.012566889636218548, 0.006912012584507465, 0.036948882043361664, 0.06436781585216522, 0.005350087769329548, -0.02740352973341942, 0.016716115176677704, -0.013831785880029202, -0.020333582535386086, 0.0012562116608023643, 0.008645525202155113, 0.040709469467401505, 0.03996697813272476, 0.008385246619582176, -0.023707496002316475, 0.009845576249063015, 0.0015256585320457816, 0.03619610145688057, 0.02110874466598034, -0.06105026230216026, -0.00572480633854866, 0.011320965364575386, 0.032673429697752, -0.02742614410817623, -0.012911729514598846, -0.012954650446772575, -0.02716008387506008, 0.03226500004529953, -0.039201632142066956, -0.040425464510917664, -0.008870655670762062, -0.0076121180318295956, 0.013878786005079746, -0.004739883355796337, -0.01802320033311844, -0.031227441504597664, -0.009064569137990475, 0.016127219423651695, 0.020488765090703964, 0.00621218653395772, 0.022507792338728905, -0.02204878441989422, 0.03405027836561203, 0.045168884098529816, 0.014696807600557804, 0.05345764756202698, 0.0013627357548102736, -0.03257164731621742, 0.0017788461409509182, 0.021609187126159668, -0.013915750198066235, -0.0034136821050196886, 0.07469456642866135, -0.033846136182546616, -0.024049710482358932, 0.023580113425850868, -0.009449069388210773, 0.06233104318380356, 0.012358782812952995, -0.02034280076622963, -0.029948091134428978, -0.007906370796263218, -0.06493083387613297, -0.04188486188650131, -0.019834233447909355, -0.010725686326622963, -0.010860581882297993, -0.028088344261050224, -0.005607504863291979, 0.019157130271196365, -0.023790953680872917, 0.019712401553988457, 0.0349966362118721, -0.0016078491462394595, 0.0032980036921799183, 0.03118172660470009, 0.01595385931432247, 0.02394433133304119, 0.008375613950192928, 0.006225780583918095, -0.018087102100253105, 0.028749525547027588, -0.039100565016269684, 0.049246203154325485, -0.0284427423030138, -0.02139553613960743, -0.06362270563840866, -0.0598960816860199, -0.009108585305511951, 0.009119913913309574, -0.005167056806385517, -0.029762212187051773, -0.020804712548851967, 0.03506523743271828, -0.015093214809894562, 0.04951782897114754, -0.01648094318807125, -0.0143911587074399, -0.043118949979543686, 0.03627986088395119, -0.022273752838373184, -0.003166680224239826, 0.0009289466543123126, 0.016119306907057762, 0.007436761166900396, 0.03571804612874985, 0.03487537428736687, -0.032295867800712585, -0.01944800280034542, 0.004421904683113098, 0.02397492155432701, -0.09209941327571869, 0.025185443460941315, -0.00892648659646511, -0.004149751737713814, 0.01993701048195362, 0.033445071429014206, 0.032720111310482025, 0.054919395595788956, 0.005235679913312197, -0.02904805913567543, 0.043445687741041183, -0.002257691929116845, -0.010134062729775906, -0.00067106046481058, -0.0008948703180067241, 0.023464957252144814, 0.020840583369135857, -0.035137880593538284, -0.018518302589654922, 0.029035337269306183, 0.0030471011996269226, -0.025983043015003204, 0.0314628928899765, -0.019279206171631813, -0.04227558150887489, -0.009587566368281841, 0.014045046642422676, -0.010672586970031261, -0.03717086464166641, 0.043507397174835205, -0.06937948614358902, 0.008232193067669868, 0.029636012390255928, -0.008252828381955624, -0.03184586763381958, 0.0226128026843071, 0.012575341388583183, -0.01769433356821537, 0.006575587205588818, -0.001045553246513009, -0.031157387420535088, -0.03954426944255829, 0.00788218341767788, 0.0008255346328951418, 0.06814950704574585, 0.01713361218571663, -0.0008992252987809479, -0.010988341644406319, 0.03563766926527023, -0.05458070710301399, -0.022861670702695847, -0.016610438004136086, -0.0016809816006571054, -0.0024019505362957716, -0.07811450958251953, 0.03481489047408104, 0.02791392058134079, -0.012564757838845253, -0.029176268726587296, -0.016603698953986168, -0.020453300327062607, -0.005054865963757038, 0.058142125606536865, 0.028118079528212547, -0.010812703520059586, 0.003294609719887376, 0.016634369269013405, 0.035168807953596115, -0.04752955958247185, 0.014553479850292206, -0.03982899710536003, -0.029347794130444527, -0.0072584752924740314, -0.030180523172020912, 0.02505461312830448, 0.016681965440511703, 0.026115551590919495, 0.022287873551249504, 0.04798005521297455, -0.007038015406578779, -0.013874536380171776, 0.02708081342279911, 0.028187720105051994, 0.016617752611637115, 0.05088202655315399, 0.015937060117721558, -0.0010625971481204033, 0.04317036271095276, 0.023951001465320587, -0.06572268158197403, 0.031031087040901184, -0.0542265959084034, -0.07675415277481079, 0.012272460386157036, 0.009251139126718044, -0.015668708831071854, -0.06529084593057632, 0.007521460764110088, 0.021762071177363396, -0.053704872727394104, 0.002436420414596796, 0.05128845199942589, -0.00440924521535635, 0.013358622789382935, -0.012654353864490986, 0.012623715214431286, 0.03691873699426651, -0.011904021725058556, 0.0076356385834515095, 0.026659630239009857, 0.02959398552775383, -0.027523892000317574, 0.014213682152330875, 0.00023545465955976397, -0.0023822553921490908, 0.015597786754369736, 0.007040982600301504, 0.04684089496731758, -0.007609700318425894, -0.05005248636007309, 0.00870002806186676, -0.02902679145336151, 0.02471308968961239, 0.03564414381980896, -0.020822489634156227, 0.07507376372814178, 0.011055207811295986, -0.002075421391054988, -0.05465751886367798, -0.02575775608420372, -0.012504496611654758, -0.023894894868135452, 0.020540719851851463, 0.044063858687877655, 0.005936321336776018, 0.02225303277373314, -0.014879628084599972, -0.014392114244401455, 0.027907680720090866, -0.024150962010025978, 0.030585194006562233, -0.003360913135111332, 0.0070380549877882, -0.05005737394094467, -0.0487508662045002, -0.005981951951980591, -0.019914817065000534, 0.02463781274855137, 0.033275824040174484, 0.02648846246302128, 0.026003461331129074, -0.019213594496250153, 0.018911387771368027, 0.042243290692567825, -0.02219768427312374, -0.014658167958259583, -0.042938027530908585, -0.008957206271588802, 0.010008498094975948, -0.005001907702535391 ]
<p>I am dealing with a text classification problem. Where I need to assign tags to a document. The amount of tags I need to assign varies from 1 to 5. I am struggling somewhat on how I should tackle this problem. What I tried was to encode every combination of tags with LabelEncoder() from scikit-learn, I framed it as a regression problem, because this label encoding gave me too many classes. However, since I cannot fit the entire train set in memory I can only train on a small part of the train set. The test is much bigger than the part of the train set I train my regressor on. As a result, my estimator performs really poor on the test set. In cross validation, the regressor actually gave reasonable results, this is a sign for me that framing this as a regression problem isn't the main problem. I am not sure how I should proceed. Should I frame this as a classification problem? Should I use a different encoding of my tags? Or should I simply find a way to train my classifier on more samples?</p>
73,838
[ -0.03944094851613045, 0.01140523049980402, -0.037810180336236954, 0.03590172901749611, 0.01868678815662861, 0.019445432350039482, -0.028250079602003098, 0.0012774532660841942, 0.033393699675798416, -0.011378792114555836, 0.048724956810474396, 0.016897421330213547, -0.0020547236781567335, 0.008942264132201672, -0.005090044345706701, 0.012841518968343735, 0.010503928177058697, -0.013296835124492645, 0.0007690159836784005, -0.015535525046288967, -0.013552481308579445, 0.030766505748033524, -0.016270175576210022, 0.004264153074473143, 0.0009975068969652057, 0.010773108340799809, 0.030584175139665604, -0.032082006335258484, 0.01442632358521223, -0.004157282877713442, -0.025280283764004707, -0.054833512753248215, 0.011545353569090366, 0.03957265987992287, 0.010819881223142147, -0.012628265656530857, -0.010436207987368107, -0.07169651240110397, -0.0023247727658599615, 0.012058046646416187, -0.026611730456352234, -0.021983401849865913, 0.01709320954978466, 0.014065681025385857, -0.0010155749041587114, 0.017383310943841934, -0.031496886163949966, 0.007446674630045891, 0.01715027168393135, -0.017304757609963417, 0.06591068208217621, 0.029882151633501053, 0.031157149001955986, 0.041875604540109634, -0.026588615030050278, -0.01107718050479889, 0.04312784969806671, 0.08591919392347336, -0.0133212860673666, -0.007718244101852179, -0.035814318805933, -0.029979221522808075, 0.004336624406278133, -0.015735745429992676, 0.006503981538116932, 0.03407137468457222, 0.027269698679447174, 0.02939625270664692, 0.033317599445581436, 0.024043196812272072, 0.016383742913603783, -0.02727460116147995, 0.05619960278272629, 0.005086760502308607, 0.01506113726645708, 0.035648319870233536, 0.013364812359213829, 0.03614998608827591, 0.03695386275649071, 0.020875686779618263, -0.005108215380460024, -0.0018389018950983882, 0.013421960175037384, 0.035286854952573776, 0.015684273093938828, 0.00775279151275754, 0.03577078506350517, -0.03240883722901344, 0.030525974929332733, 0.029303045943379402, -0.01630334183573723, -0.024262722581624985, 0.06607430428266525, 0.020989272743463516, -0.022388311102986336, 0.03808969259262085, -0.013309519737958908, 0.000030989736842457205, 0.03753470629453659, -0.01099819503724575, -0.015593593940138817, -0.05018346384167671, 0.001191494520753622, 0.057786375284194946, -0.040886882692575455, 0.01727212220430374, -0.03633889555931091, -0.03828873485326767, 0.007555898744612932, -0.012348500080406666, -0.007344606798142195, 0.031068267300724983, 0.011236405931413174, -0.0026623806916177273, 0.037101469933986664, 0.011731278151273727, 0.005311452317982912, 0.004803414456546307, 0.02773774042725563, 0.05570950359106064, 0.026237614452838898, -0.041886791586875916, 0.06073930114507675, -0.009543195366859436, -0.03987978771328926, -0.008700049482285976, -0.017451049759984016, -0.03328680247068405, -0.021602636203169823, 0.04155769944190979, -0.011971327476203442, -0.026105619966983795, 0.027328025549650192, -0.007076162379235029, 0.019303323701024055, -0.004985750187188387, -0.07270612567663193, -0.058940015733242035, 0.018222207203507423, 0.006881501991301775, -0.0035889637656509876, -0.05045360326766968, 0.008259071037173271, 0.010446328669786453, 0.04291383549571037, 0.02757183648645878, 0.024897048249840736, 0.04846959188580513, -0.019305525347590446, 0.01453458983451128, 0.014781737700104713, 0.007023009937256575, -0.07577860355377197, -0.010242615826427937, -0.011882041580975056, -0.06496318429708481, -0.027251463383436203, 0.021206270903348923, -0.013708019629120827, 0.00753167737275362, -0.012455753982067108, -0.012746497988700867, 0.007601432967931032, -0.018419384956359863, 0.01158649381250143, -0.01778428629040718, 0.0469367690384388, 0.01657741703093052, 0.07396408915519714, 0.028229758143424988, 0.018580511212348938, -0.01145971566438675, 0.02648565173149109, 0.02779959887266159, 0.01928429864346981, -0.019749879837036133, 0.005505155771970749, -0.0018614048603922129, 0.03250801935791969, -0.014112472534179688, 0.022654704749584198, -0.056771378964185715, -0.001367832999676466, 0.026500415056943893, 0.03208739310503006, 0.016507724300026894, 0.010900371707975864, -0.05027247220277786, 0.01414597686380148, -0.04207378253340721, -0.04045432060956955, -0.015513457357883453, 0.015335769392549992, -0.07952447980642319, 0.013541163876652718, 0.0500115267932415, -0.013562986627221107, -0.002223955700173974, -0.018337775021791458, -0.03034280240535736, -0.01848847232758999, 0.0008850888698361814, 0.03041013889014721, -0.0056436555460095406, -0.026369309052824974, 0.03189528360962868, -0.010677549988031387, 0.0016518097836524248, 0.035565536469221115, -0.03371583670377731, -0.0681147649884224, 0.0008266709628514946, 0.008971763774752617, 0.024916259571909904, -0.040116891264915466, 0.005361464805901051, 0.017638035118579865, 0.005128116346895695, -0.04174298793077469, 0.0372353121638298, -0.03205331042408943, 0.0756945013999939, 0.019453413784503937, -0.02938093990087509, 0.0006872435915283859, -0.018621260300278664, 0.00982643198221922, 0.03790336474776268, -0.03692588582634926, -0.015691637992858887, -0.052148181945085526, 0.025661157444119453, 0.03876709192991257, 0.022142672911286354, -0.03984065726399422, -0.01638181507587433, 0.06543494760990143, 0.00700057577341795, 0.032414983958005905, 0.007612657733261585, -0.014812459237873554, 0.0059075732715427876, 0.03082706779241562, 0.04662742093205452, 0.02404719404876232, -0.027492597699165344, 0.027829956263303757, -0.00843709334731102, 0.012125627137720585, 0.0055047390051186085, -0.011361751705408096, 0.03486128896474838, 0.013837775215506554, 0.0022646631114184856, 0.0005869279848411679, -0.022742904722690582, 0.027891289442777634, -0.01724378392100334, 0.01762460730969906, 0.04822416976094246, -0.0032004753593355417, 0.005642494652420282, 0.02074652723968029, -0.003808214096352458, 0.032485947012901306, 0.04343598708510399, -0.009697476401925087, -0.039907678961753845, 0.015486328862607479, -0.058313485234975815, 0.0021222832147032022, 0.019079141318798065, -0.029884619638323784, -0.03470626100897789, 0.04301125928759575, 0.053444985300302505, -0.03672996908426285, 0.01763739064335823, -0.0523257777094841, 0.019158540293574333, 0.009538858197629452, 0.019513040781021118, 0.050018154084682465, -0.02117387391626835, -0.053753823041915894, -0.00410523172467947, -0.05175691097974777, -0.04386729747056961, 0.027824824675917625, 0.007590773981064558, -0.022015035152435303, -0.003471541916951537, -0.028508838266134262, -0.04549208655953407, -0.056218117475509644, -0.05631689727306366, 0.026216184720396996, -0.018883593380451202, -0.047989483922719955, 0.06953821331262589, -0.0037036908324807882, -0.060201823711395264, -0.024453241378068924, -0.022762278094887733, -0.020533982664346695, 0.0011593842646107078, -0.00527576869353652, -0.020239485427737236, -0.022099049761891365, 0.030434630811214447, 0.061621978878974915, 0.017743995413184166, 0.00677088787779212, -0.04169279709458351, -0.0674530416727066, 0.035662535578012466, 0.0007630907348357141, 0.002572203753516078, 0.04567244276404381, 0.01812037266790867, 0.07888536155223846, 0.01747855730354786, -0.011133684776723385, -0.02354395017027855, -0.0028679631650447845, 0.001996236853301525, -0.033450908958911896, -0.022635800763964653, 0.03541611507534981, 0.003529573092237115, 0.012552671134471893, 0.009916998445987701, 0.020170075818896294, 0.0734221339225769, 0.0015224532689899206, -0.013105351477861404, 0.030707063153386116, 0.015092242509126663, 0.014682771638035774, 0.034938544034957886, 0.052061691880226135, -0.011812812648713589, -0.00003022833334398456, -0.007427457720041275, -0.002283484674990177, -0.0079420804977417, -0.01683073863387108, 0.011877286247909069, -0.025041935965418816, 0.03448404371738434, -0.010070662945508957, -0.000933735747821629, 0.008318773470818996, -0.05977565795183182, -0.01769436150789261, 0.03435739502310753, 0.010430890135467052, -0.01029194425791502, 0.0019565271213650703, 0.040855806320905685, 0.04136666655540466, -0.006879420019686222, -0.023281550034880638, -0.044757209718227386, -0.004516526125371456, -0.006813919637352228, 0.02323968894779682, 0.012218106538057327, 0.04335783049464226, 0.01311207190155983, 0.025587541982531548, 0.014402104541659355, -0.04872126877307892, 0.02774076722562313, -0.0587148554623127, 0.009287754073739052, 0.003453272394835949, 0.05823323130607605, 0.007216190453618765, -0.009646066464483738, 0.0038199129048734903, -0.016015058383345604, 0.009780007414519787, 0.05351053550839424, -0.056879401206970215, -0.004230605438351631, 0.004391948226839304, -0.006146915256977081, 0.0007722527952864766, -0.03112809546291828, 0.0393105186522007, -0.047429222613573074, 0.02012445218861103, 0.002872009528800845, 0.016849393025040627, -0.039698515087366104, 0.006169460713863373, 0.020817182958126068, 0.01396690309047699, -0.0010466858511790633, 0.009259774349629879, -0.004639711696654558, 0.02512272074818611, 0.0031051049008965492, 0.02310217171907425, 0.01772402599453926, -0.029694730415940285, -0.04106622934341431, 0.031227074563503265, 0.010667889378964901, 0.021068520843982697, 0.029973309487104416, 0.03489615023136139, -0.05591323971748352, 0.0047445148229599, 0.0002766821125987917, 0.03043432906270027, 0.030092695727944374, -0.01800905354321003, -0.0005130257341079414, -0.06429899483919144, -0.030039750039577484, 0.021165622398257256, 0.010090054012835026, 0.006187655497342348, 0.0022987104021012783, 0.06566213816404343, 0.00826585479080677, -0.03698379918932915, -0.03334551304578781, 0.0941297858953476, -0.015297635458409786, -0.03488363325595856, -0.00904926285147667, -0.011149667203426361, 0.036002278327941895, 0.04175933822989464, 0.02885468490421772, 0.011228904128074646, -0.017047785222530365, 0.013232504948973656, 0.038344964385032654, -0.05081392452120781, -0.03959213197231293, 0.00012675455946009606, -0.017877444624900818, 0.042107902467250824, 0.007916558533906937, -0.004817308858036995, -0.02089955471456051, 0.03816619887948036, 0.025339186191558838, 0.03915967047214508, -0.00922486837953329, -0.1150570660829544, -0.00006160814518807456, 0.04407326877117157, 0.04192928969860077, -0.03253250569105148, 0.012268127873539925, -0.04368260130286217, -0.014041774906218052, 0.0070891776122152805, -0.04342355579137802, 0.014340151101350784, 0.032552167773246765, 0.01955508254468441, -0.0036455802619457245, -0.0396568588912487, -0.023454563692212105, 0.027774158865213394, -0.057915568351745605, 0.06868185847997665, -0.022586148232221603, -0.03169284760951996, -0.01856834627687931, 0.010750540532171726, 0.01690070889890194, 0.046956632286310196, -0.015233825892210007, -0.007277211174368858, 0.03123113512992859, 0.04718352481722832, -0.023096587508916855, -0.07401971518993378, -0.04324917122721672, -0.022962793707847595, 0.012192838825285435, 0.013383815996348858, -0.00841713696718216, -0.05334991216659546, 0.022450251504778862, 0.009100785478949547, -0.05776411294937134, -0.009638866409659386, -0.048992328345775604, 0.03643167018890381, 0.018028676509857178, 0.01169532723724842, 0.05171907693147659, 0.024004509672522545, 0.033499862998723984, 0.04899463430047035, -0.041444942355155945, 0.024727914482355118, -0.038038432598114014, 0.012139325961470604, -0.017561497166752815, -0.015507956966757774, -0.02109857089817524, 0.05420079082250595, -0.020408611744642258, 0.04713889956474304, -0.020619183778762817, -0.04256734997034073, -0.00791339110583067, -0.0018729384755715728, -0.004540230147540569, -0.005108158569782972, 0.016794126480817795, 0.02996990457177162, -0.008231807500123978, 0.018140176311135292, 0.0076773143373429775, -0.007285264320671558, 0.04237550124526024, 0.004176116082817316, -0.042595431208610535, -0.0031359605491161346, -0.026626262813806534, -0.020288832485675812, -0.0008045047288760543, 0.007366696838289499, 0.060165662318468094, 0.0018744434928521514, 0.0394461527466774, -0.038528721779584885, -0.020944129675626755, -0.007256835699081421, 0.020468231290578842, 0.007173387799412012, 0.045235417783260345, -0.02105742134153843, 0.006274733226746321, -0.036591291427612305, -0.03923845291137695, -0.0740320086479187, -0.04651368409395218, 0.0071783815510571, -0.0026298952288925648, -0.043494243174791336, -0.022590667009353638, 0.02983047440648079, 0.003114880295470357, -0.022474074736237526, -0.010138344019651413, 0.07458709180355072, -0.0456070601940155, -0.022996345534920692, -0.029288312420248985, -0.0034087018575519323, 0.056876569986343384, -0.030631475150585175, 0.006860913243144751, 0.015231459401547909, 0.010505554266273975, 0.0030048536136746407, 0.0009461554000154138, -0.007335018832236528, -0.039393484592437744, -0.030873838812112808, -0.04063105583190918, 0.06670186668634415, 0.07099772989749908, -0.00600067712366581, 0.022248568013310432, 0.00015033605450298637, -0.020778696984052658, 0.00023472031170967966, -0.028488701209425926, 0.019923679530620575, 0.029732275754213333, -0.029971377924084663, -0.015897827222943306, 0.06062428653240204, -0.035672627389431, -0.004523661453276873, 0.023459093645215034, 0.013728096149861813, 0.026138998568058014, -0.006934838369488716, 0.10298100113868713, -0.008512997068464756, 0.029021039605140686, 0.004498232156038284, -0.012669960036873817, 0.05291607975959778, 0.01881510764360428, 0.02061539888381958, -0.012044735252857208, 0.02463964745402336, -0.0712168738245964, 0.01278615090996027, -0.021558504551649094, -0.040501918643713, 0.05062636360526085, -0.000553103513084352, 0.030493954196572304, 0.053645674139261246, -0.002860288368538022, 0.009281711652874947, -0.020884305238723755, -0.011831792071461678, -0.0030034990049898624, -0.010460427030920982, 0.03549649193882942, 0.042142029851675034, -0.011274764314293861, 0.024227963760495186, -0.0067053805105388165, 0.029922420158982277, 0.04619796946644783, 0.018380895256996155, 0.023279910907149315, -0.008661183528602123, -0.0632374957203865, -0.03067321516573429, 0.004006997216492891, -0.029811620712280273, -0.011059016920626163, -0.016873780637979507, -0.012922750785946846, 0.04000304266810417, 0.03234811872243881, 0.026924606412649155, -0.007622038945555687, -0.03150884062051773, -0.05384343862533569, 0.023845311254262924, 0.04393600672483444, -0.02500961720943451, 0.017283886671066284, 0.008538072928786278, 0.004756612703204155, -0.004612919874489307, 0.04903116449713707, -0.030468806624412537, -0.045929424464702606, -0.020485149696469307, -0.0272498968988657, -0.019390514120459557, 0.047851718962192535, 0.045114751905202866, -0.008579711429774761, 0.0006355426739901304, -0.026863671839237213, 0.02394658327102661, 0.00043784367153421044, 0.026154236868023872, -0.009971984662115574, 0.056236330419778824, 0.013592050410807133, 0.0031181147787719965, 0.004590337630361319, 0.012138443067669868, 0.12508739531040192, 0.10432387888431549, 0.04532323405146599, -0.058127276599407196, -0.005234492942690849, 0.00782349519431591, -0.01707463711500168, -0.04795355349779129, 0.03170417621731758, -0.010486739687621593, 0.01731317676603794, -0.0037366494070738554, 0.016646303236484528, 0.007740588393062353, -0.020547572523355484, 0.03254479914903641, -0.0564286932349205, 0.016202235594391823, 0.015306609682738781, -0.009068988263607025, 0.06022068113088608, 0.0016627188306301832, -0.06766824424266815, -0.00478324806317687, 0.03278288617730141, -0.019954418763518333, -0.034018564969301224, -0.022065678611397743, -0.010215384885668755, -0.03415527194738388, 0.012330962345004082, -0.014745541848242283, -0.0400145947933197, -0.02184012159705162, -0.008991410955786705, -0.004014759790152311, 0.011436919681727886, 0.012281603179872036, -0.012266058474779129, -0.006599973421543837, 0.015322772786021233, 0.00488742720335722, -0.014373219572007656, -0.0066984593868255615, -0.03131750971078873, -0.03292085602879524, -0.0264289453625679, 0.0747726708650589, 0.0030782835092395544, -0.024930300191044807, 0.04692251235246658, 0.036486003547906876, 0.021291883662343025, -0.03356128931045532, -0.026439232751727104, 0.03474563732743263, -0.002921688137575984, -0.0031656234059482813, -0.02278524450957775, -0.01752655766904354, 0.062201127409935, -0.011154372245073318, 0.030682602897286415, -0.006823768373578787, 0.009635294787585735, -0.009598703123629093, -0.023890310898423195, 0.00671815499663353, 0.04626882076263428, 0.03284011408686638, 0.026749378070235252, -0.011325412429869175, -0.01571190357208252, -0.03765907883644104, 0.0049637542106211185, 0.0051215579733252525, 0.004637560341507196, -0.03645476698875427, -0.03810981661081314, -0.04586824029684067, -0.04147456958889961, -0.01623610220849514, -0.02919495292007923, -0.023092465475201607, -0.05533893406391144, 0.013927453197538853, -0.003976128064095974, 0.04955645650625229, 0.023598816245794296, 0.0399613231420517, 0.03300542011857033, 0.017956530675292015, 0.031111951917409897, -0.03718029707670212, 0.05023585259914398, -0.020954381674528122, -0.04349486157298088, 0.010609536431729794, -0.0030758243519812822, 0.07326782494783401, 0.006396751385182142, 0.003273492678999901, 0.009023078717291355, 0.04062815010547638, -0.0058312383480370045, 0.020170215517282486, 0.013075870461761951, -0.05774201452732086, -0.0101474579423666, 0.009780339896678925, -0.019310228526592255, -0.052079737186431885, -0.030920838937163353, -0.024996154010295868, -0.07429930567741394, 0.03639306500554085, -0.011913618072867393, -0.04618053138256073, 0.022377213463187218, -0.0015301440143957734, 0.05258001387119293, -0.019976289942860603, -0.024798773229122162, -0.040243856608867645, -0.0019222743576392531, -0.03393163904547691, -0.07951006293296814, -0.04417958855628967, -0.005434027407318354, -0.02682897262275219, 0.0006355580408126116, 0.030569564551115036, 0.012897251173853874, -0.008912676945328712, -0.010412154719233513, 0.015057757496833801, -0.00740246195346117, 0.04385748878121376, -0.04959702491760254, -0.020519111305475235, 0.03417021781206131, -0.01721925474703312, 0.0004801013565156609, 0.014203105121850967, -0.03360376134514809, 0.04510939493775368, 0.010563899762928486, -0.016060084104537964, -0.031560447067022324, 0.06725272536277771, -0.005241486709564924, -0.03662990406155586, 0.025669056922197342, 0.007371698506176472, -0.012099266052246094, -0.013774470426142216, 0.007572338916361332, -0.00028039413155056536, 0.000568754505366087, 0.03237345442175865, 0.02711205929517746, 0.048635758459568024, -0.0014878826914355159, 0.05520930886268616, -0.009702309034764767, 0.055825814604759216, 0.038014546036720276, 0.010485956445336342, -0.028680140152573586, 0.01791558973491192, -0.039521537721157074, 0.030101116746664047, -0.02059880830347538, 0.04207237437367439, -0.07200546562671661, -0.012990993447601795, 0.03677664324641228, -0.021264778450131416, 0.04593183472752571, -0.05720435082912445, -0.00648127356544137, 0.030224593356251717, -0.028640178963541985, 0.0062640272080898285, -0.02755637839436531, -0.013727274723351002, -0.03756851702928543, 0.004831313621252775, -0.043281979858875275, 0.023767737671732903, 0.054119449108839035, 0.03690943121910095, -0.008394270204007626, 0.02783104218542576, -0.01753774657845497, -0.06351062655448914, -0.031002553179860115, 0.025304120033979416, 0.034554433077573776, -0.010228672064840794, 0.04788573831319809, -0.010362712666392326, -0.05226557329297066, 0.009753393009305, -0.013398268260061741, -0.025737162679433823, 0.07659154385328293, 0.03635600209236145, -0.00816165842115879, 0.0724915862083435, 0.027429373934864998, -0.03458785265684128, -0.021175283938646317, -0.017209984362125397, -0.023524334654211998, 0.004255394451320171, -0.001625472097657621, -0.01348315179347992, 0.001863409299403429, -0.006137254647910595, -0.021518824622035027, 0.043402496725320816, -0.01945365034043789, -0.028561502695083618, 0.004789749626070261, -0.013616670854389668, 0.04366818442940712, -0.03299729898571968, -0.022748179733753204, -0.04511263594031334, 0.051683209836483, -0.003358663758262992, 0.01640266180038452, 0.00013865515938960016, -0.018963292241096497, -0.04272092506289482, -0.025884412229061127, -0.03233817592263222, 0.012844212353229523, -0.003974210470914841, -0.050222206860780716, 0.009657204151153564, 0.025978410616517067, -0.016554852947592735, -0.03418288007378578, -0.022098712623119354, -0.01840059831738472, 0.03912656009197235, -0.013365465216338634, 0.033149730414152145, 0.021027697250247, -0.019269850105047226, -0.010883215814828873, -0.08919025957584381, 0.05409366264939308, -0.000870779505930841, -0.0034201459493488073, -0.0019638556987047195, -0.0031664278358221054, -0.03968193009495735, 0.028854260221123695, 0.04062458500266075, -0.003613425884395838, -0.00026380247436463833, -0.05670047551393509, -0.001920294133014977, 0.0005626226775348186, -0.030066950246691704, 0.036131277680397034, -0.015211161226034164, -0.02385135181248188, -0.0012873108498752117, -0.03570559620857239, -0.005407191347330809, -0.016337841749191284, 0.020136354491114616, -0.009685828350484371, -0.03210001811385155, -0.003190964926034212, -0.003840364282950759, 0.02526254579424858, -0.01303761638700962, 0.03996866196393967, 0.026296649128198624, 0.02328534610569477, 0.000530966673977673, 0.010712943971157074, 0.0029276248533278704, -0.05498168244957924, 0.012304135598242283, -0.042323824018239975, -0.01687752641737461, -0.038845259696245193, 0.05599305033683777, 0.023421335965394974, -0.06581207364797592, 0.03511514887213707, 0.021807653829455376, -0.032372523099184036, 0.02169371023774147, 0.022914310917258263, 0.020307226106524467, 0.005584370344877243, -0.012522585690021515, 0.034418150782585144, -0.01820651814341545, 0.024590833112597466, 0.013744473457336426, -0.008127416484057903, -0.0014594901585951447, 0.021932778880000114, 0.06666307151317596, 0.010534139350056648, -0.038586463779211044, 0.02046586200594902, -0.013056852854788303, 0.03774460405111313, -0.030741680413484573, 0.0070348577573895454, -0.022141939029097557, 0.019220339134335518, -0.02902301400899887, 0.016656722873449326, -0.00543100805953145, 0.03793790563941002, -0.02205866202712059, -0.03625098615884781, -0.06449814140796661, -0.047102607786655426, 0.02325422130525112, 0.024696800857782364, 0.0017474311171099544, 0.04106440022587776, -0.002032727003097534, 0.008359122090041637, -0.015821825712919235, -0.01676749438047409, 0.054229747503995895, -0.023549271747469902, -0.03044782020151615, -0.01615786924958229, -0.03201029822230339, -0.005827087443321943, -0.006578692700713873, -0.027082543820142746, -0.01903047226369381, 0.0022678293753415346, 0.06421678513288498, 0.0018845230806618929, -0.029952052980661392, -0.03631339222192764, -0.004290591459721327, 0.03248634934425354, -0.035397861152887344, 0.0016780705191195011, -0.03197294473648071, 0.009527803398668766, -0.004846640862524509, -0.022471051663160324 ]
<p>I have some measurement results (about 10000 or even more). How can I say (which methods should I use and how to apply them) to check if my data is time series or is a statistical sample?</p>
49,924
[ -0.012814128771424294, -0.03654446825385094, -0.02667720802128315, -0.00586420064792037, 0.05200853571295738, 0.013320119120180607, -0.012455873191356659, -0.011132045648992062, 0.02033148892223835, 0.013887153938412666, 0.07701171189546585, 0.051219500601291656, 0.02187425270676613, 0.026150550693273544, 0.022394610568881035, -0.006756809074431658, -0.042014315724372864, 0.04837949946522713, -0.00972736906260252, -0.005364947021007538, 0.020701495930552483, 0.0026075351051986217, -0.0022996081970632076, -0.012970627285540104, -0.051922768354415894, 0.025106947869062424, 0.04480388015508652, -0.010540930554270744, 0.0025844296906143427, 0.022583119571208954, -0.050120964646339417, -0.035826560109853745, -0.02801632508635521, 0.030728178098797798, 0.027779337018728256, -0.005980997812002897, -0.0476265512406826, -0.0338180772960186, -0.0057000936940312386, 0.05061434209346771, -0.042757511138916016, -0.015572026371955872, -0.00005028504892834462, 0.016915205866098404, -0.006843821611255407, -0.010998597368597984, 0.003720361040905118, -0.017870353534817696, 0.02395372837781906, -0.04191196709871292, 0.0766187310218811, -0.007543526124209166, 0.04045970365405083, 0.012165648862719536, -0.00750822713598609, -0.010294047184288502, 0.045932549983263016, 0.029906319454312325, -0.038712091743946075, -0.03306707367300987, 0.01317009050399065, 0.0073109944351017475, 0.01121607143431902, -0.026007354259490967, -0.017401225864887238, 0.032169997692108154, -0.02555859461426735, -0.004831531550735235, 0.04208473861217499, -0.00813441164791584, 0.029789328575134277, 0.003464973997324705, 0.028379149734973907, 0.014280349016189575, -0.010443349368870258, -0.027232451364398003, 0.01802421547472477, 0.02539956197142601, 0.07416516542434692, 0.05296691507101059, 0.013486200012266636, -0.0018051088554784656, 0.006700420286506414, 0.0287309642881155, 0.04246663674712181, -0.03295058012008667, 0.0618366114795208, -0.019365273416042328, -0.006704735569655895, 0.0019858498126268387, -0.00847998633980751, -0.014996272511780262, 0.026624655351042747, 0.017042385414242744, -0.04923325031995773, 0.005745468661189079, -0.019008539617061615, 0.05876648426055908, -0.024132290855050087, -0.008741531521081924, 0.023152489215135574, -0.04058198258280754, 0.018554799258708954, 0.023107776418328285, -0.04185133054852486, 0.019293462857604027, 0.004109697882086039, 0.008886189199984074, -0.023893160745501518, -0.021973991766572, -0.005748588591814041, 0.009824092499911785, 0.02865137904882431, 0.007737631909549236, 0.021979432553052902, 0.018464243039488792, 0.005778130143880844, -0.01019840408116579, 0.043454188853502274, 0.09090039879083633, 0.040755514055490494, -0.031501807272434235, 0.012908296659588814, -0.01964828558266163, -0.0359036922454834, 0.023376397788524628, 0.013721630908548832, -0.03143453598022461, -0.048207998275756836, 0.05223618820309639, -0.007252577692270279, -0.03183138743042946, 0.04227013140916824, -0.03693987429141998, 0.06116720288991928, 0.012378055602312088, -0.0763264149427414, -0.04310394078493118, 0.04243118315935135, -0.009029494598507881, -0.023116236552596092, -0.05196378380060196, 0.02951381541788578, -0.0028379145078361034, 0.0067269159480929375, 0.035734523087739944, 0.0520453080534935, 0.021544039249420166, 0.034648701548576355, -0.005201580934226513, -0.044126804918050766, -0.0268583744764328, 0.004815187305212021, -0.03591011092066765, 0.016328662633895874, -0.038602810353040695, 0.0181163027882576, 0.03427531197667122, -0.0005356649053283036, -0.004966815002262592, -0.007837231270968914, 0.01586032100021839, -0.03331771120429039, 0.03168001398444176, 0.017534200102090836, -0.02306760475039482, 0.06769921630620956, -0.008853049948811531, 0.030539128929376602, 0.0258457250893116, -0.004221181385219097, 0.016191180795431137, 0.04774053022265434, 0.010688834823668003, 0.048482704907655716, 0.009388362988829613, -0.016307339072227478, 0.025426557287573814, 0.009644776582717896, 0.014934912323951721, -0.04135795682668686, -0.032439589500427246, -0.005950935184955597, -0.0017437959322705865, 0.05515142157673836, 0.032066669315099716, 0.01836383156478405, -0.05896419659256935, 0.025498056784272194, -0.06203971803188324, -0.043318506330251694, -0.05455423891544342, -0.0016839290037751198, -0.045821890234947205, -0.010277037508785725, 0.027304155752062798, -0.007466560695320368, 0.0036779604852199554, -0.0633283257484436, -0.04143047332763672, -0.024735039100050926, -0.0043744370341300964, 0.03432665392756462, -0.0584326833486557, -0.01011015847325325, 0.03761022165417671, 0.019006967544555664, -0.018708158284425735, 0.04760777950286865, -0.030144788324832916, -0.037623610347509384, -0.01871420443058014, -0.03947598487138748, -0.0008358361665159464, 0.003050903556868434, -0.02736329846084118, 0.034997232258319855, -0.011312621645629406, -0.03388368338346481, 0.02379917912185192, -0.02471543662250042, 0.09519857913255692, 0.06369246542453766, -0.026071321219205856, 0.007940363138914108, 0.006037791259586811, 0.02635115198791027, 0.010437607765197754, 0.007074357010424137, 0.0023212137166410685, -0.06548679620027542, 0.04186849296092987, 0.04678387939929962, 0.029091905802488327, -0.018643399700522423, 0.006623988971114159, 0.07797913998365402, 0.0077687217853963375, 0.011816524900496006, 0.016832219436764717, -0.014342162758111954, -0.03768453374505043, -0.0018376559019088745, 0.015417419373989105, 0.006448138505220413, -0.01789667271077633, -0.016682108864188194, 0.02512267418205738, 0.017209095880389214, -0.010874870233237743, 0.01707196794450283, 0.04761505126953125, -0.02129407599568367, 0.011840227991342545, 0.0028794913087040186, -0.042903851717710495, 0.03199835866689682, -0.01756373420357704, -0.004531813785433769, 0.014138570055365562, -0.010588091798126698, 0.021969720721244812, 0.01549216452986002, -0.011602473445236683, 0.018112771213054657, 0.019084015861153603, -0.042536959052085876, -0.004608673509210348, 0.04855242371559143, -0.0265717301517725, 0.02679256722331047, -0.017856167629361153, -0.061489637941122055, -0.0592043362557888, 0.002784230513498187, 0.04856159910559654, 0.0030748173594474792, 0.049650274217128754, -0.019811401143670082, -0.052116524428129196, 0.022690527141094208, -0.016446713358163834, 0.00928269512951374, 0.010985543951392174, -0.04384657368063927, 0.028312399983406067, -0.03115912154316902, -0.005949701182544231, 0.030036961659789085, -0.0287777129560709, 0.013210456818342209, 0.03711981326341629, 0.0018754053162410855, -0.040435634553432465, -0.032065313309431076, -0.03943289443850517, 0.012650877237319946, 0.007739630993455648, -0.02256774716079235, 0.04482538625597954, -0.013394158333539963, -0.04404605180025101, 0.0185829009860754, -0.039046913385391235, -0.02617892436683178, -0.05051398277282715, -0.00632183812558651, -0.0012895273976027966, -0.030745266005396843, 0.02231804095208645, 0.018736163154244423, -0.035227324813604355, -0.01043018139898777, -0.030786657705903053, -0.07513199746608734, 0.014087539166212082, -0.002280951477587223, 0.04896143078804016, -0.01036927942186594, -0.02694382146000862, 0.05511895939707756, 0.03692065179347992, -0.03836211934685707, -0.02234627865254879, -0.022242864593863487, -0.027567870914936066, -0.04641107842326164, 0.018320634961128235, 0.019771121442317963, 0.010996677912771702, 0.005996521562337875, 0.012358581647276878, 0.016848748549818993, 0.04123527556657791, 0.007082493044435978, -0.0015140536706894636, 0.017750494182109833, 0.019574802368879318, 0.007474598009139299, 0.034537628293037415, 0.01808258704841137, -0.06332511454820633, 0.01879810355603695, 0.004562300629913807, 0.03321203589439392, 0.03161637857556343, -0.04533444717526436, 0.022268597036600113, -0.005930368322879076, 0.01344657689332962, -0.03474068641662598, 0.0243544839322567, 0.00518695916980505, -0.00836275052279234, 0.002445340622216463, 0.027213307097554207, -0.008850019425153732, -0.010455108247697353, 0.007428358308970928, 0.05848507583141327, 0.05019804462790489, -0.02325604297220707, -0.014763726852834225, -0.02304871194064617, -0.021054638549685478, 0.05235767364501953, -0.025327347218990326, -0.04390760138630867, 0.04903845116496086, 0.0505046509206295, 0.02923361398279667, 0.005458074621856213, -0.050851576030254364, 0.0008739781915210187, -0.07117404788732529, -0.014044761657714844, -0.025780638679862022, 0.06060771271586418, -0.0013555740006268024, 0.04882632941007614, 0.031488772481679916, -0.01542743481695652, 0.03447474166750908, -0.007567575201392174, -0.031225379556417465, 0.027718596160411835, -0.005995668470859528, -0.010876818560063839, -0.01457999274134636, -0.018856676295399666, 0.0029508029110729694, -0.05788065120577812, 0.04843812808394432, 0.0017540710978209972, 0.026500161737203598, -0.045227598398923874, 0.013032450340688229, -0.017723115161061287, -0.00854663085192442, -0.013921680860221386, 0.004800834693014622, 0.01916300132870674, -0.007064631208777428, 0.03974588215351105, 0.03846355155110359, 0.028614740818738937, -0.010970180854201317, -0.01053317729383707, 0.005889170803129673, -0.001782598439604044, 0.039462100714445114, 0.006881315261125565, 0.00766196520999074, -0.05450575426220894, 0.05669444799423218, 0.024382514879107475, 0.04343533515930176, 0.016183186322450638, -0.023409821093082428, -0.05089201405644417, -0.036106858402490616, -0.00015308009460568428, 0.037859395146369934, 0.009879758581519127, 0.05113062262535095, -0.039223916828632355, 0.06112254783511162, 0.007790274918079376, -0.06592313200235367, 0.05162516236305237, 0.05098966881632805, 0.01058592926710844, 0.00864402949810028, -0.04054621234536171, -0.011578027158975601, -0.01160453725606203, 0.00257795094512403, 0.04163698852062225, 0.011460360139608383, -0.0005841015372425318, -0.005703662522137165, -0.0020699636079370975, 0.0023237955756485462, -0.023839976638555527, 0.0007779119769111276, 0.029581110924482346, 0.052279140800237656, 0.008427850902080536, -0.03401251882314682, 0.052933353930711746, 0.05389097332954407, 0.018058674409985542, 0.06520899385213852, -0.011044476181268692, -0.09815787523984909, 0.009261003695428371, 0.07291730493307114, -0.02035515382885933, -0.056137509644031525, -0.00841426756232977, -0.036299027502536774, 0.00876265112310648, 0.037842921912670135, -0.020827488973736763, 0.03195489943027496, -0.0020656674169003963, 0.01981201581656933, -0.03493417799472809, 0.01442698109894991, -0.022348836064338684, 0.01736362837255001, -0.001414594822563231, 0.03030078485608101, -0.03708549588918686, -0.016654664650559425, -0.03638892248272896, 0.010662630200386047, 0.017929134890437126, 0.06551108509302139, -0.019146976992487907, -0.000334401149302721, -0.0020598135888576508, 0.00995941273868084, -0.028929738327860832, -0.06684818863868713, 0.01155638974159956, 0.016708044335246086, 0.015735849738121033, 0.032376356422901154, 0.0038442122749984264, -0.05906638130545616, -0.004853350576013327, -0.020896846428513527, -0.0029998631216585636, 0.020730625838041306, -0.024205243214964867, 0.03740505129098892, 0.01938857138156891, 0.01967976987361908, 0.06369363516569138, 0.02318556420505047, 0.03896674886345863, 0.018451252952218056, 0.0021086689084768295, 0.038872841745615005, -0.051709406077861786, -0.02022022008895874, -0.03642353415489197, 0.0020943947602063417, -0.04603546857833862, 0.019618388265371323, -0.0001454996527172625, 0.018814701586961746, -0.001009129686281085, -0.016525350511074066, -0.004658028017729521, 0.03453646972775459, 0.03554058447480202, -0.03927965462207794, -0.014088431373238564, -0.0066777863539755344, -0.02387504279613495, -0.019581910222768784, -0.002984672551974654, -0.005410947371274233, -0.001151287811808288, 0.010996569879353046, -0.024960307404398918, 0.0013647284358739853, -0.05607886612415314, -0.021478712558746338, 0.001303584547713399, -0.018307829275727272, 0.03590941056609154, -0.010052724741399288, 0.0343918539583683, 0.002681525656953454, -0.031337641179561615, -0.007505685091018677, 0.0014996292302384973, 0.02058042399585247, 0.044124916195869446, -0.07682152092456818, 0.049275729805231094, -0.03386544808745384, -0.011407504789531231, -0.08976054936647415, -0.06064922735095024, 0.05122371390461922, 0.03618917614221573, -0.03955991193652153, -0.014008164405822754, 0.0325336754322052, -0.020599376410245895, -0.015449504368007183, -0.040925282984972, 0.0562833733856678, -0.007169391494244337, -0.046470049768686295, -0.00351201300509274, 0.023019185289740562, 0.11297689378261566, -0.01655612513422966, -0.01515126135200262, 0.022430632263422012, 0.0001522107340861112, 0.0008304447983391583, -0.012563660740852356, 0.013396081514656544, -0.03019649349153042, 0.01564505323767662, -0.05203845724463463, -0.002847071038559079, 0.04330406337976456, -0.03885238990187645, 0.013242371380329132, 0.03434218838810921, 0.02227729558944702, -0.0020320280455052853, -0.0337614007294178, 0.034812308847904205, -0.032532401382923126, -0.004722263664007187, -0.004201381932944059, -0.021090427413582802, -0.0182699803262949, 0.00350335706025362, 0.03958383947610855, 0.0002646576031111181, -0.023279136046767235, 0.018256453797221184, 0.01886998862028122, 0.01235269196331501, -0.019224170595407486, 0.005237770266830921, 0.003827858017757535, -0.022477038204669952, 0.015429871156811714, 0.0041664657182991505, 0.02380559779703617, 0.025223392993211746, -0.039819326251745224, -0.036848895251750946, -0.028561819344758987, -0.03420380875468254, 0.07737477123737335, 0.012407023459672928, 0.07196226716041565, 0.0610712431371212, 0.022458234801888466, 0.014162504114210606, -0.026080647483468056, -0.015170804224908352, -0.005802222993224859, 0.04055009409785271, 0.04255416616797447, -0.01404690183699131, 0.008078308776021004, 0.003316610585898161, -0.027690542861819267, 0.013970399275422096, 0.031019087880849838, 0.03224487975239754, 0.035746581852436066, 0.016245637089014053, -0.030219092965126038, -0.037338901311159134, -0.006135689094662666, -0.04055439680814743, 0.027735719457268715, -0.011953704990446568, 0.01569804549217224, 0.0258223544806242, 0.04695778340101242, 0.011492932215332985, -0.017139844596385956, 0.010729143396019936, -0.06542184203863144, -0.022701269015669823, 0.0128396051004529, 0.01244361326098442, 0.03769860044121742, 0.013122755102813244, 0.05029678717255592, -0.008347522467374802, 0.005509241949766874, -0.014541847631335258, -0.03104708343744278, -0.024876924231648445, -0.022330738604068756, -0.060676079243421555, 0.04802388697862625, 0.004032591823488474, -0.025562496855854988, -0.005049102008342743, 0.0034750390332192183, -0.008886453695595264, 0.010492278262972832, 0.029423989355564117, -0.027128316462039948, 0.053470127284526825, 0.022810589522123337, 0.01034360472112894, -0.006477737333625555, 0.020326219499111176, 0.08608780056238174, 0.06154993921518326, 0.04308808967471123, -0.045473575592041016, 0.02645961567759514, 0.016877425834536552, 0.025517713278532028, -0.018080340698361397, 0.02878478728234768, -0.0020003672689199448, -0.015049250796437263, 0.05077299475669861, 0.029889829456806183, -0.009346438571810722, 0.02620941586792469, 0.0693606585264206, -0.005894407629966736, 0.013315606862306595, -0.000836868945043534, 0.009646997787058353, 0.005855914670974016, 0.00012327493459451944, -0.052574727684259415, 0.03587503731250763, -0.0032479704823344946, -0.02332775853574276, 0.014245111495256424, -0.027189623564481735, 0.002862943336367607, 0.016540689393877983, -0.025294966995716095, 0.007812614552676678, 0.06706634908914566, 0.029288282617926598, -0.04224321246147156, -0.03360927477478981, -0.01063656434416771, -0.03111089952290058, 0.004672977142035961, 0.025922855362296104, 0.01659313589334488, -0.02874649316072464, 0.004445471800863743, 0.010164560750126839, -0.0563858225941658, -0.022471996024250984, -0.022942356765270233, 0.021526731550693512, 0.016930509358644485, -0.0067540318705141544, -0.013781903311610222, 0.008327572606503963, -0.010588690638542175, -0.06037981063127518, 0.007884413003921509, -0.019176285713911057, 0.019984804093837738, -0.07156188786029816, -0.04410267993807793, -0.06538747996091843, -0.01101300586014986, -0.03456249460577965, 0.04672859236598015, 0.036469243466854095, 0.011778938584029675, 0.024517618119716644, 0.032159578055143356, 0.03256511315703392, -0.01564217172563076, -0.005421016365289688, 0.003512060735374689, -0.00950781349092722, -0.032821983098983765, 0.0028449988458305597, 0.026354437693953514, -0.010767496190965176, -0.007033721078187227, 0.0022019753232598305, -0.019463909789919853, -0.010768610052764416, -0.05043193697929382, 0.027453936636447906, -0.019500428810715675, -0.004782187752425671, -0.027742726728320122, -0.0031383587047457695, 0.014002280309796333, 0.052627261728048325, 0.005657341331243515, 0.009555483236908913, -0.003955136053264141, 0.04283098131418228, 0.03523554652929306, -0.045016709715127945, 0.01150441076606512, 0.00638903584331274, 0.008993931114673615, 0.023297548294067383, -0.017880262807011604, 0.06075482815504074, 0.05268101766705513, 0.003247020998969674, -0.008769426494836807, 0.0038977027870714664, -0.013340436853468418, 0.015174808911979198, -0.012644588947296143, -0.04199296236038208, -0.009441799484193325, -0.011052068322896957, -0.01319807767868042, -0.027392791584134102, -0.04702702909708023, -0.04233774542808533, -0.00024396424123551697, 0.011076264083385468, 0.003463611239567399, -0.02470957674086094, 0.03554902225732803, -0.009114639833569527, -0.004190931096673012, -0.04271743446588516, 0.011672641150653362, -0.0527665838599205, -0.0379151813685894, -0.013327965512871742, -0.017871897667646408, -0.00941357109695673, 0.01766551099717617, -0.0010405174689367414, 0.0014983422588557005, 0.05249926447868347, -0.011691706255078316, 0.025459883734583855, 0.01601857878267765, -0.00003285987622803077, -0.027017926797270775, 0.04558929055929184, -0.02505481243133545, -0.006654664874076843, 0.059618283063173294, -0.02488824538886547, -0.02841409668326378, 0.049311794340610504, -0.018117573112249374, 0.019469568505883217, 0.04493693262338638, 0.0021035815589129925, 0.03235948830842972, 0.029133522883057594, -0.036610573530197144, -0.007126773241907358, -0.02252926118671894, -0.002616124227643013, -0.02249622344970703, -0.0034176469780504704, 0.042188383638858795, 0.023259703069925308, 0.0008965880842879415, 0.01431194320321083, 0.04728185012936592, 0.03640284016728401, -0.023209810256958008, 0.00948555488139391, 0.029768195003271103, 0.005728285294026136, 0.03521190211176872, -0.03329792991280556, 0.03785843029618263, 0.05712173134088516, -0.03761827200651169, 0.0021019685082137585, -0.04810421168804169, -0.005677198991179466, -0.03674360364675522, -0.024103567004203796, -0.032462477684020996, -0.030403999611735344, 0.031554076820611954, -0.05282816290855408, -0.029126545414328575, 0.024178549647331238, -0.021838465705513954, 0.005052956752479076, -0.016163570806384087, -0.007441570051014423, -0.005551563575863838, 0.01358542125672102, -0.012444770894944668, 0.0455520898103714, 0.02238297462463379, 0.02849070355296135, 0.014077034778892994, 0.05572255328297615, 0.025749579071998596, -0.009754321537911892, -0.010003470815718174, 0.020209012553095818, 0.015649450942873955, -0.06684505939483643, 0.03356211259961128, -0.055605608969926834, -0.04040174186229706, 0.03244666010141373, 0.009077073074877262, 0.04804418981075287, 0.018873799592256546, -0.000982901081442833, -0.022830376401543617, 0.023348813876509666, 0.004303060472011566, -0.04383055865764618, -0.026136644184589386, -0.002750776708126068, -0.010221797041594982, 0.05082657188177109, -0.01563321053981781, 0.019786158576607704, 0.019736506044864655, -0.03955839201807976, -0.04095761850476265, -0.0026664198376238346, -0.007118747103959322, -0.02217884734272957, 0.02502858079969883, -0.01567216031253338, -0.005275065079331398, -0.012167654000222683, 0.04306253418326378, -0.017242345958948135, 0.02948871999979019, 0.04809684678912163, 0.010669698938727379, -0.044639263302087784, 0.0031305153388530016, -0.03394019603729248, -0.05311528593301773, 0.009944869205355644, -0.0031709319446235895, -0.026779208332300186, -0.06897199898958206, -0.016704918816685677, 0.0041742585599422455, -0.02266811393201351, -0.045318279415369034, -0.007150241639465094, -0.037621814757585526, 0.04117315262556076, 0.020817680284380913, -0.02548355422914028, 0.0248801801353693, -0.027992792427539825, -0.020212538540363312, -0.09449080377817154, 0.04461995139718056, 0.007642300333827734, -0.021782441064715385, -0.04184805974364281, -0.015190253034234047, -0.04828525334596634, 0.019170671701431274, 0.0573669895529747, 0.00768411485478282, -0.0036124931648373604, 0.0007119076908566058, 0.010044625960290432, 0.03158903494477272, -0.05709493160247803, 0.035303108394145966, -0.019571473821997643, -0.03834972530603409, -0.00040744367288425565, -0.05518794432282448, 0.0002805808326229453, -0.021817363798618317, 0.016396066173911095, 0.017198652029037476, 0.03655725717544556, 0.01897364668548107, -0.019774803891777992, 0.05916962772607803, 0.005889152642339468, -0.0065694693475961685, 0.023065917193889618, -0.04581204801797867, -0.001895132358185947, 0.04532264918088913, -0.026482703164219856, -0.06302705407142639, 0.023333024233579636, -0.02568267658352852, -0.03234612196683884, 0.005602559540420771, 0.012564258649945259, 0.008516792207956314, -0.0585649199783802, -0.032175470143556595, 0.02963840216398239, -0.031613849103450775, 0.040721096098423004, 0.046606019139289856, -0.0001482683583162725, -0.0025203078985214233, -0.027896596118807793, 0.024976477026939392, 0.01329463254660368, 0.0012300621019676328, -0.03379528224468231, 0.01872420310974121, 0.058256324380636215, -0.009462599642574787, 0.00446837954223156, 0.029376478865742683, 0.0014729502145200968, 0.024686312302947044, 0.019192244857549667, 0.04684969782829285, -0.023872030898928642, -0.014657923951745033, -0.008089283481240273, 0.0015438373666256666, -0.02025412768125534, 0.03177574276924133, -0.019556036219000816, 0.06935391575098038, -0.05816192552447319, -0.013384588062763214, -0.055727578699588776, -0.03876299038529396, -0.04690166562795639, 0.01610654965043068, 0.01511587668210268, 0.02197413519024849, -0.0014922997215762734, 0.005315587390214205, -0.013310432434082031, 0.010414030402898788, 0.027652308344841003, -0.033576760441064835, 0.0281738992780447, -0.01376376673579216, -0.0022118950728327036, -0.02352331392467022, -0.034068260341882706, -0.029937468469142914, -0.017357289791107178, 0.045439355075359344, -0.0016819516895338893, 0.030296914279460907, -0.008879146538674831, -0.023163797333836555, -0.03467724844813347, 0.020107785239815712, -0.08741064369678497, -0.006395294796675444, -0.028083158656954765, 0.042433001101017, 0.005730327218770981, -0.04216671735048294 ]
<p>I am trying to do a small case study in 24 hours + change.</p> <p>For a dataset, I'm using <a href="http://ghtorrent.org" rel="nofollow">GHTorrent.org</a>.</p> <p>A general assumption about virtual work is that richer media leads to greater productivity. I have decided to focus on <a href="http://github.com" rel="nofollow">GitHub</a> and to examine the effects of @mentions on issue resolution.</p> <p>My hypothesis is that mentions are correlated with shorter time to issue resolution.</p> <p>To see if this is true, I figure I can take a look at when an issue opened, when it closed, and how many mentions there were divided by how many comments there were.</p> <p>Does this sound reasonable? I am a final-year master student and this is for a small assignment to get us familiar with writing scientific papers. Any advice is much appreciated.</p>
73,839
[ -0.0011907501611858606, -0.03156866133213043, -0.016904698684811592, -0.024154210463166237, 0.029310481622815132, -0.011515690945088863, -0.019463244825601578, -0.0009933089604601264, -0.016597678884863853, 0.009764201007783413, 0.028029439970850945, 0.03169673681259155, 0.0499381497502327, 0.0267405454069376, 0.003242306876927614, -0.00987281370908022, 0.023027807474136353, -0.03878012299537659, -0.03201263025403023, -0.005218361504375935, 0.007063179276883602, -0.029982751235365868, -0.015404612757265568, 0.002144819824025035, -0.018137887120246887, 0.0018760650418698788, -0.01757505163550377, -0.04969185218214989, -0.03306249901652336, -0.012711898423731327, -0.049294665455818176, -0.016474710777401924, -0.005843715276569128, 0.0020750430412590504, 0.0014112304197624326, -0.02665332332253456, 0.003922645002603531, -0.03402097150683403, -0.022011036053299904, 0.04023871198296547, 0.015092678368091583, 0.03200751170516014, -0.01954163983464241, 0.008268789388239384, -0.04568973183631897, -0.0017973807407543063, 0.005810160655528307, 0.02033032663166523, 0.04768868908286095, -0.003306284546852112, 0.05414716899394989, -0.0062407562509179115, 0.01942303031682968, 0.01785931922495365, -0.004541891627013683, 0.044812578707933426, 0.036574140191078186, 0.06464040279388428, -0.0017778942128643394, -0.0125059112906456, -0.013503435999155045, 0.02325936034321785, -0.019036969169974327, -0.013331019319593906, -0.002977306256070733, 0.03507435321807861, -0.012012798339128494, 0.007093001157045364, 0.020093921571969986, 0.021743208169937134, 0.02375282347202301, 0.005178696475923061, 0.057781171053647995, -0.013695737347006798, 0.03733382746577263, -0.048382893204689026, 0.02622678317129612, 0.010434765368700027, 0.06443800032138824, 0.0488741397857666, -0.05767597258090973, 0.023100215941667557, -0.018264923244714737, 0.025620941072702408, 0.031812455505132675, -0.000721850199624896, 0.053831037133932114, -0.041461773216724396, -0.0006256808992475271, 0.04372422769665718, -0.020501162856817245, -0.014270472340285778, 0.03285720571875572, 0.03948235511779785, -0.04037337750196457, 0.0027301302179694176, -0.00934965442866087, 0.021846583113074303, 0.010079334490001202, -0.005725738126784563, -0.018924498930573463, -0.05806279554963112, -0.0019270728807896376, 0.04619470611214638, 0.007702783681452274, -0.02937512844800949, -0.05414034426212311, -0.018165752291679382, -0.03811650350689888, -0.005756968166679144, -0.034133583307266235, -0.018617717549204826, -0.025519976392388344, -0.018350875005126, 0.020663516595959663, -0.019637027755379677, 0.0030203356873244047, -0.011786310002207756, 0.08985443413257599, 0.05329631268978119, 0.04874645918607712, -0.02240753173828125, 0.05156105384230614, -0.03863823413848877, -0.04671308025717735, 0.013181307353079319, 0.054123926907777786, -0.04736248776316643, -0.02706708014011383, 0.06733448803424835, -0.004839139059185982, 0.006207012105733156, 0.014660654589533806, -0.014305227436125278, 0.030684398487210274, 0.02235518954694271, -0.052362892776727676, -0.07915935665369034, 0.06411341577768326, -0.01342339999973774, 0.026912666857242584, -0.06912970542907715, -0.018445836380124092, -0.006427169311791658, 0.04113257676362991, 0.012078498490154743, 0.02367876097559929, -0.01350650005042553, 0.024851253256201744, 0.01474399957805872, -0.027935707941651344, -0.04880276322364807, 0.034541916102170944, -0.036625899374485016, -0.020197805017232895, -0.058965522795915604, -0.014642397873103619, 0.03149968013167381, 0.03068813867866993, 0.018545150756835938, 0.052790701389312744, 0.026623494923114777, -0.003353807842358947, 0.031111428514122963, -0.006007475312799215, -0.050944916903972626, 0.02956044115126133, -0.006003078073263168, 0.01671617105603218, 0.029965104535222054, 0.020404428243637085, 0.009598806500434875, 0.023149507120251656, 0.013409405015408993, 0.03926851227879524, 0.02091292478144169, 0.04624490812420845, -0.005897534545511007, -0.02155495248734951, -0.00813489593565464, -0.040618497878313065, -0.037731949239969254, -0.02130306325852871, 0.022727834060788155, 0.02693626470863819, 0.0757192075252533, -0.015235151164233685, 0.008665644563734531, 0.028618667274713516, 0.0010314699029549956, -0.050973083823919296, -0.04314612224698067, 0.03960983082652092, -0.0002858891966752708, 0.009886493906378746, -0.04548643156886101, -0.026313520967960358, 0.000009202865840052254, -0.0026555717922747135, 0.0033183228224515915, 0.005740824155509472, 0.01960788108408451, 0.05309175327420235, -0.009829671122133732, -0.025038063526153564, 0.03548746928572655, 0.0019279222469776869, -0.06296630948781967, 0.02067185938358307, -0.04893726482987404, -0.06184179708361626, 0.022682081907987595, -0.021169399842619896, 0.023281192407011986, 0.007322513498365879, -0.0052404142916202545, 0.03263809531927109, 0.05148354917764664, -0.028892727568745613, -0.002997050993144512, -0.03636561706662178, 0.05384664610028267, 0.03244980424642563, 0.0006254285108298063, 0.014311201870441437, -0.0030353828333318233, 0.06680385768413544, 0.02564077451825142, 0.019694866612553596, 0.0023477356880903244, -0.0667380839586258, -0.018809078261256218, 0.04033340513706207, -0.0173244159668684, -0.0038948901928961277, -0.01329913642257452, 0.03685619682073593, 0.018935654312372208, 0.002471033250913024, 0.027956997975707054, 0.04193498566746712, -0.0013617532094940543, 0.02771727368235588, 0.0526362769305706, 0.042587585747241974, -0.011452574282884598, -0.00330126634798944, 0.022549539804458618, 0.0498676560819149, -0.004677765537053347, 0.04020148143172264, -0.0007084939861670136, 0.019003750756382942, -0.016680490225553513, -0.022902293130755424, 0.026664001867175102, 0.05730302259325981, -0.009268618188798428, -0.01149282231926918, 0.04579862579703331, 0.014143558219075203, 0.010805802419781685, -0.017304889857769012, -0.07180677354335785, 0.04684537276625633, -0.006676261313259602, -0.04950624704360962, -0.003911179956048727, 0.03566604107618332, -0.029103007167577744, 0.02162799797952175, -0.014709888957440853, -0.016596533358097076, -0.013621105812489986, 0.016133680939674377, 0.02877889759838581, -0.00369226629845798, 0.037951722741127014, 0.016555529087781906, 0.029403014108538628, -0.01618974655866623, -0.014671536162495613, 0.020333414897322655, 0.00508466549217701, -0.01967950165271759, 0.029933050274848938, 0.01667560450732708, -0.01575705222785473, -0.00494114775210619, -0.04535067081451416, 0.0031885956414043903, 0.010106540285050869, 0.025874575600028038, -0.0547182597219944, -0.00551189249381423, 0.0100955655798316, 0.0322720929980278, -0.02738187648355961, -0.011767366901040077, -0.03352877497673035, -0.022752683609724045, -0.03754512965679169, 0.03600361570715904, -0.04849740490317345, -0.031620655208826065, -0.020902235060930252, -0.00977693684399128, 0.01565936766564846, 0.005811585113406181, -0.01202091109007597, 0.0030789044685661793, 0.014550731517374516, -0.04949603229761124, -0.04951540380716324, -0.07090646028518677, 0.02650851383805275, -0.02548219822347164, 0.021038394421339035, -0.060123104602098465, -0.03128228709101677, 0.04580816254019737, 0.009249784052371979, -0.04501233994960785, -0.018284587189555168, -0.027021881192922592, -0.029622262343764305, -0.017316706478595734, 0.016586434096097946, 0.006147647742182016, 0.005962267983704805, -0.001015545567497611, 0.0032045517582446337, 0.03418578952550888, 0.04250485450029373, 0.05812060832977295, -0.0020068956073373556, -0.012321815825998783, 0.008405905216932297, -0.022239940240979195, 0.005567942280322313, 0.07849514484405518, -0.02245943807065487, 0.02848513424396515, -0.0658809170126915, -0.02848890982568264, -0.010597458109259605, -0.06069052219390869, 0.007665288634598255, 0.02110678143799305, 0.01759226992726326, -0.006519767455756664, -0.018009794875979424, 0.0024522149469703436, -0.0206845011562109, -0.06284257769584656, -0.008878696709871292, 0.04834046959877014, -0.03547829017043114, 0.006024296395480633, 0.051614902913570404, 0.016463618725538254, -0.025736378505825996, -0.03226035460829735, -0.03237827867269516, -0.005880433600395918, -0.02753543108701706, -0.0007023923099040985, 0.013447628356516361, 0.030519774183630943, 0.02095205895602703, 0.015353656373918056, -0.0018761875107884407, -0.03924797475337982, -0.03405219316482544, -0.06657642871141434, -0.010138723999261856, -0.018201440572738647, 0.0466764010488987, -0.0033174422569572926, 0.04181840270757675, 0.012502842582762241, 0.02937096543610096, -0.016011390835046768, -0.024534661322832108, -0.035380229353904724, -0.025967763736844063, -0.052032433450222015, 0.0023767761886119843, 0.04590999335050583, -0.005947837606072426, -0.005313172470778227, 0.0065236445516347885, -0.023672567680478096, 0.011341138742864132, 0.05469260364770889, -0.0356212742626667, 0.011196330189704895, -0.013626251369714737, -0.01969054341316223, -0.02765883319079876, -0.02903776429593563, 0.029401462525129318, 0.0029513793997466564, -0.0012715654447674751, 0.04062264785170555, -0.012166320346295834, -0.015274157747626305, -0.007196428719907999, -0.017482979223132133, 0.01312731858342886, 0.022682201117277145, 0.018032923340797424, 0.023546067997813225, -0.017913922667503357, 0.04912390559911728, -0.009876661002635956, 0.028360696509480476, -0.012584161013364792, 0.015317544341087341, 0.007953089661896229, -0.02122306637465954, -0.03597083315253258, 0.03563988581299782, -0.010027889162302017, -0.06279884278774261, 0.04226827621459961, 0.02373703382909298, -0.028713932260870934, -0.008431662805378437, 0.044050827622413635, 0.026503218337893486, 0.008410075679421425, -0.012578729540109634, -0.041802242398262024, 0.003769409377127886, 0.03811825066804886, -0.0331265889108181, 0.026188701391220093, 0.030309082940220833, 0.010478452779352665, -0.02517748810350895, 0.011557891964912415, -0.007358017843216658, -0.07193604111671448, 0.0282131414860487, -0.04327763617038727, 0.021830474957823753, 0.03268051892518997, -0.01802942343056202, -0.00026515097124502063, 0.07295577973127365, 0.053343504667282104, -0.01128610223531723, -0.01775539480149746, -0.10320562869310379, -0.027655845507979393, 0.08781904727220535, 0.08316969126462936, -0.009372442029416561, -0.014436976052820683, -0.03839568421244621, -0.041094668209552765, 0.05230211466550827, -0.0490761324763298, 0.027625158429145813, -0.0030463121365755796, 0.020181473344564438, -0.016878865659236908, -0.04647291451692581, -0.011287969537079334, 0.027737637981772423, -0.016833128407597542, 0.029142262414097786, -0.006090785376727581, -0.05752228572964668, -0.00718079274520278, 0.02799181081354618, 0.015505132265388966, 0.03113672323524952, 0.01807457022368908, 0.007883481681346893, -0.005766768008470535, 0.011262168176472187, -0.035446930676698685, -0.04324839264154434, 0.006448164116591215, 0.008375806733965874, -0.00392872141674161, 0.05746394023299217, 0.01517330389469862, 0.0033345737028867006, 0.013693645596504211, 0.041315384209156036, -0.03762763366103172, -0.024760086089372635, -0.041685253381729126, 0.01576334424316883, 0.05680223926901817, 0.012253822758793831, 0.047256939113140106, 0.029200730845332146, 0.004487372934818268, 0.011137795634567738, 0.010408149100840092, -0.030029138550162315, -0.026079488918185234, 0.018325790762901306, 0.036528680473566055, 0.010291250422596931, -0.022875098511576653, 0.050035521388053894, -0.003163752844557166, 0.03489090874791145, -0.023993229493498802, 0.01777803711593151, -0.011442771181464195, -0.03001249022781849, -0.006471255794167519, -0.009845648892223835, 0.023984765633940697, -0.02902260050177574, 0.021528340876102448, 0.016473498195409775, 0.030816342681646347, -0.017170604318380356, -0.010098022408783436, 0.009766283445060253, -0.03367595747113228, 0.0017375883180648088, -0.032925575971603394, -0.011224498972296715, 0.010066741146147251, -0.016388172283768654, 0.01972455345094204, -0.007122407667338848, -0.024005690589547157, 0.019268734380602837, -0.030564256012439728, 0.022710397839546204, 0.0176756102591753, -0.022808605805039406, -0.010898340493440628, -0.03376780450344086, 0.061666421592235565, -0.02187267132103443, -0.03350045531988144, -0.060812242329120636, -0.00011988813639618456, 0.01744283363223076, -0.023581521585583687, -0.02558400109410286, -0.02146659418940544, 0.01006722915917635, 0.024069754406809807, -0.024500761181116104, -0.009652265347540379, 0.02722875215113163, -0.03105209581553936, -0.02861613593995571, 0.016578618437051773, 0.05271368846297264, 0.0647139847278595, -0.0029576998203992844, -0.0188167542219162, -0.010138601064682007, 0.02282654121518135, -0.0281202495098114, -0.004756319336593151, 0.022303178906440735, -0.03605324774980545, 0.003984405659139156, -0.027664603665471077, 0.0013233382487669587, 0.02547786384820938, -0.019141707569360733, 0.007844614796340466, 0.058770883828401566, -0.04745132476091385, 0.00660044327378273, -0.035481926053762436, 0.0012289020232856274, -0.010817806236445904, -0.012748444452881813, 0.0028243360575288534, 0.00863190833479166, -0.003139146603643894, -0.00825163908302784, -0.013546555303037167, 0.00609940430149436, -0.026182038709521294, 0.0243756715208292, 0.05921882390975952, -0.02147330529987812, 0.017579512670636177, 0.030888056382536888, -0.047596562653779984, 0.0360710434615612, -0.07288934290409088, -0.013440929353237152, -0.02267555147409439, -0.019249675795435905, -0.018070949241518974, -0.030527886003255844, 0.005516554228961468, -0.016265995800495148, 0.04886671528220177, 0.005270066205412149, 0.04119563847780228, -0.00048098296974785626, -0.017223693430423737, 0.05123423784971237, 0.0017038499936461449, 0.011422882787883282, -0.02324950508773327, 0.049271345138549805, 0.023381058126688004, -0.03220081701874733, 0.0019247439922764897, 0.029903655871748924, 0.006821791175752878, 0.0342903770506382, 0.019314952194690704, 0.04235969856381416, -0.03025089018046856, 0.02602948062121868, -0.08450084924697876, -0.014200904406607151, 0.03160512447357178, -0.08285555988550186, 0.0465259924530983, -0.004548248369246721, 0.002916750032454729, 0.04641120880842209, 0.03489530086517334, 0.006091900635510683, -0.033940259367227554, -0.03904016315937042, -0.061578743159770966, 0.009681200608611107, 0.006872980389744043, -0.057479508221149445, 0.02731899358332157, -0.03212952986359596, 0.05137818679213524, -0.009357142262160778, 0.023680584505200386, -0.030832381919026375, -0.06027459725737572, 0.006626457907259464, -0.007573011331260204, -0.07381676137447357, 0.05341760814189911, 0.014921771362423897, -0.058489974588155746, 0.05096942186355591, -0.053904034197330475, 0.01641356758773327, -0.0018168098758906126, 0.019357720389962196, -0.017683953046798706, 0.09118634462356567, 0.0003704626578837633, 0.023693447932600975, 0.023052582517266273, 0.015187491662800312, 0.11881715059280396, 0.11046614497900009, 0.034130118787288666, -0.0127169881016016, 0.031024320051074028, 0.01046623196452856, 0.01915966160595417, -0.04601912945508957, 0.019689522683620453, -0.03503914177417755, -0.0005520965787582099, 0.08638574928045273, 0.011544585227966309, 0.024773061275482178, 0.005390692036598921, 0.03974221646785736, -0.05202188715338707, -0.05381593480706215, -0.010613123886287212, -0.02296837978065014, 0.04545210674405098, -0.04984430968761444, -0.041778869926929474, 0.020302381366491318, -0.016226977109909058, -0.028081631287932396, -0.006439002696424723, -0.03799731284379959, 0.026462988927960396, 0.027901703491806984, -0.016938189044594765, 0.05366305634379387, -0.003425115253776312, 0.026498831808567047, 0.01990230195224285, -0.03212854638695717, 0.025114065036177635, -0.010553210973739624, 0.03151777759194374, 0.08278518915176392, -0.0003354462387505919, -0.038911424577236176, -0.019637517631053925, 0.02923862263560295, -0.04165008291602135, 0.0021821213886141777, -0.027143297716975212, -0.006354210898280144, -0.02372807078063488, 0.007984776049852371, -0.018633466213941574, -0.0066658263094723225, -0.00863736867904663, -0.0077284094877541065, -0.024327384307980537, 0.03679804131388664, -0.009681412018835545, -0.013225337490439415, -0.026627345010638237, -0.031346164643764496, 0.01475169975310564, -0.001279350370168686, 0.01333371177315712, 0.06065114215016365, -0.008912060409784317, -0.038726989179849625, -0.03925681114196777, -0.008318318985402584, -0.005715886130928993, -0.00045542779844254255, -0.01648131012916565, -0.01904589682817459, -0.006171823013573885, -0.014477672055363655, -0.016406003385782242, -0.0020529362373054028, 0.021925080567598343, -0.014725360088050365, -0.006591231096535921, -0.058764632791280746, -0.028798669576644897, 0.01718207262456417, 0.00854703038930893, -0.02988433837890625, -0.024512428790330887, 0.04694671928882599, 0.005062811076641083, 0.0014429129660129547, 0.029844149947166443, 0.018644195050001144, -0.014872985891997814, 0.04212646558880806, 0.008644061163067818, -0.04358594864606857, -0.018591873347759247, -0.020989997312426567, -0.03368276357650757, -0.02698618918657303, -0.010085862129926682, 0.06949958205223083, -0.01284012384712696, -0.04859568178653717, 0.0540817491710186, 0.017334748059511185, -0.022640589624643326, 0.02209433913230896, 0.03704167529940605, -0.030078185722231865, 0.0004892036668024957, 0.03510887920856476, -0.034318096935749054, -0.05979044735431671, -0.0009688891004770994, -0.0036176687572151423, 0.03323959559202194, 0.033318761736154556, -0.008284819312393665, -0.026098839938640594, 0.0035593747161328793, 0.007351779378950596, 0.05472737178206444, -0.04108749330043793, 0.013619528152048588, -0.016091279685497284, -0.014091268181800842, 0.015604116953909397, 0.03122553415596485, 0.01270284689962864, 0.02225544862449169, 0.019071510061621666, 0.0038412786088883877, 0.028489435091614723, -0.005487469024956226, 0.01010693795979023, -0.002118646865710616, -0.012154880911111832, -0.003729772288352251, 0.01152750477194786, -0.010115552693605423, -0.07119898498058319, 0.026595916599035263, -0.02539265714585781, -0.02308056876063347, 0.006352136377245188, -0.019665684551000595, 0.03402393311262131, -0.01631440594792366, -0.03422906622290611, -0.003194849006831646, 0.07152579724788666, -0.0215461365878582, 0.004614647012203932, 0.005924863740801811, 0.0021640092600136995, -0.0015731512103229761, 0.0014594232197850943, 0.03941165283322334, 0.006327624898403883, -0.006160507444292307, -0.013381055556237698, 0.0266692154109478, 0.0006948702502995729, -0.016127118840813637, -0.02562597393989563, 0.004355895332992077, -0.023239780217409134, 0.0024414353538304567, -0.016186565160751343, 0.06801934540271759, 0.030547991394996643, -0.051754649728536606, 0.018093319609761238, 0.011140819638967514, 0.028882160782814026, -0.06981033086776733, -0.011620200239121914, 0.0014554376248270273, 0.017685335129499435, 0.024878645315766335, -0.028417453169822693, 0.003815628821030259, 0.04086299240589142, -0.02146798186004162, 0.007156417239457369, 0.03324564918875694, -0.03303985670208931, -0.02101733535528183, -0.010318704880774021, -0.017809148877859116, 0.03167426958680153, 0.030498944222927094, 0.034223079681396484, 0.05095815286040306, 0.03492539003491402, -0.03399154171347618, -0.04781336709856987, -0.010834704153239727, 0.03281630948185921, 0.0022828204091638327, -0.0011761212954297662, 0.08791806548833847, -0.02300940826535225, -0.033999793231487274, 0.023352574557065964, -0.04194043576717377, 0.007064683362841606, 0.022502059116959572, 0.03823423758149147, -0.008469212800264359, 0.07277411967515945, 0.03692997992038727, 0.010863382369279861, 0.019470715895295143, -0.021059636026620865, -0.016988340765237808, 0.015414989553391933, 0.07570365071296692, 0.012648019939661026, 0.022215187549591064, 0.0088193379342556, 0.026154419407248497, 0.01606033183634281, -0.00971055869013071, -0.01799747347831726, -0.0034224255941808224, -0.016130642965435982, 0.010131537914276123, -0.014688469469547272, 0.033602528274059296, -0.03814652934670448, 0.015468333847820759, 0.0495738685131073, 0.008890129625797272, -0.024913815781474113, 0.020986586809158325, -0.020545611158013344, -0.041142214089632034, -0.010236849077045918, -0.02200203947722912, -0.06168964132666588, -0.02983975224196911, -0.029998673126101494, -0.00662049138918519, -0.00716029480099678, -0.0510253943502903, 0.019089577719569206, -0.017875952646136284, 0.033859238028526306, -0.016654914245009422, 0.0025541535578668118, 0.007757841609418392, -0.024738313630223274, 0.002659773686900735, -0.07503914833068848, 0.019402410835027695, 0.034053247421979904, 0.02469845861196518, -0.06095360592007637, -0.037668824195861816, -0.0057112374342978, 0.005090498365461826, 0.039196159690618515, -0.0211920365691185, 0.012862986885011196, -0.021897826343774796, -0.04597330093383789, -0.0004799796734005213, -0.04019515961408615, 0.032924849539995193, -0.0009010771755129099, 0.042941637337207794, 0.021357864141464233, -0.016643261536955833, 0.004150319844484329, -0.01529428455978632, 0.03459443151950836, -0.015924572944641113, -0.027024639770388603, 0.01609860733151436, -0.008129477500915527, 0.020653843879699707, 0.015486025251448154, -0.004899149760603905, 0.04629145935177803, 0.04357180744409561, 0.026798363775014877, 0.012297290377318859, 0.007635874208062887, -0.04233085736632347, 0.07180307060480118, -0.032407380640506744, 0.03757775202393532, 0.01189081184566021, -0.04560461640357971, -0.0027885157614946365, -0.08531124889850616, -0.004062998108565807, 0.013009131886065006, -0.0022705835290253162, 0.015468901954591274, -0.013840103521943092, 0.05437449365854263, 0.03431138023734093, -0.01850915513932705, 0.031035052612423897, -0.0023150870110839605, 0.006984781473875046, -0.03543674573302269, -0.002504893811419606, 0.0049756173975765705, 0.023416031152009964, 0.0027824367862194777, 0.004650013986974955, 0.012200815603137016, 0.07939833402633667, -0.023768171668052673, 0.018295204266905785, -0.03251202777028084, -0.0159266646951437, 0.012332990765571594, -0.0143537987023592, -0.04165251925587654, 0.030059250071644783, 0.009550899267196655, 0.04951102286577225, -0.041434042155742645, 0.023135341703891754, -0.022490257397294044, 0.015416043810546398, -0.04018450155854225, -0.009886390529572964, 0.029960764572024345, 0.030269036069512367, -0.026306329295039177, -0.012139497324824333, 0.007983197458088398, -0.020442845299839973, 0.020680340006947517, -0.005561022087931633, 0.028457660228013992, -0.024852892383933067, 0.00411880761384964, -0.0036845970898866653, 0.002998790703713894, -0.005256865173578262, 0.0036155462730675936, 0.06208294630050659, 0.030773522332310677, -0.036091726273298264, -0.011069491505622864, -0.011935935355722904, -0.02039267309010029, 0.03590637817978859, -0.03332544490695, 0.017465418204665184, -0.025585545226931572, 0.007535381708294153, -0.029129154980182648, -0.0380469374358654 ]
<p>I have a observation sequence of around 1000 samples, each observation is a 10 dim vector. I am trying to learn an HMM model based on this. Specifically I am using the GaussianHMM based on this example: <a href="http://scikit-learn.org/stable/auto_examples/applications/plot_hmm_stock_analysis.html#example-applications-plot-hmm-stock-analysis-py" rel="nofollow">http://scikit-learn.org/stable/auto_examples/applications/plot_hmm_stock_analysis.html#example-applications-plot-hmm-stock-analysis-py</a></p> <p>After few iterations it looks like my one of the state's covariance matrix becomes non-positive definite. (Initial values for covars are symmetric and positive definite)</p> <p>I even set the 'covars_prior=0.01' which I thought should prevent this from happening. What could be missing?</p> <p>Thanks in advance.</p>
73,840
[ -0.027507241815328598, -0.015700213611125946, 0.012409904971718788, -0.012321490794420242, 0.05475867539644241, -0.011476969346404076, -0.04178740456700325, -0.03868335485458374, 0.009124260395765305, -0.050240907818078995, 0.023221775889396667, 0.02790239080786705, 0.0703059658408165, 0.029199546203017235, -0.0018380893161520362, -0.019807884469628334, 0.019655821844935417, -0.04198911786079407, 0.015259942039847374, -0.0293309036642313, -0.018183276057243347, 0.07677405327558517, 0.039597928524017334, -0.007129414472728968, -0.008373504504561424, 0.030310865491628647, 0.026235315948724747, -0.023732447996735573, 0.03158897906541824, 0.02295079454779625, -0.055756378918886185, -0.020716235041618347, -0.005163686815649271, 0.02400195226073265, 0.02162742055952549, 0.015362066216766834, -0.011453834362328053, -0.04457546025514603, -0.020021136850118637, 0.025316979736089706, -0.011214017868041992, 0.00046551518607884645, 0.0006659095524810255, 0.10209600627422333, -0.02521168626844883, 0.00879807397723198, 0.025699472054839134, -0.018293404951691628, 0.052233144640922546, -0.03125397488474846, 0.06378583610057831, 0.018886912614107132, 0.03427029773592949, 0.05232212692499161, -0.029318595305085182, -0.017281942069530487, 0.02732968144118786, 0.06215754151344299, 0.023977026343345642, -0.03499378636479378, 0.013026163913309574, -0.08341696858406067, 0.003771863179281354, -0.03983278572559357, -0.029401138424873352, 0.032792117446660995, 0.03535152226686478, 0.003336317604407668, 0.018866468220949173, -0.028806574642658234, 0.012971583753824234, 0.006788367871195078, 0.04505293443799019, -0.021519476547837257, 0.03343799710273743, -0.027516987174749374, -0.001627832418307662, 0.02625017613172531, 0.018409833312034607, 0.042123060673475266, 0.023473283275961876, 0.003388433950021863, -0.012095166370272636, 0.004131653346121311, 0.0035353670828044415, -0.022209662944078445, 0.033414583653211594, -0.035455893725156784, 0.030880894511938095, 0.05394403263926506, -0.023312723264098167, 0.02004220150411129, 0.0892718955874443, 0.01563783548772335, -0.033597808331251144, 0.033915869891643524, -0.021892333403229713, 0.034044504165649414, 0.003092473139986396, -0.025797341018915176, -0.02929164469242096, -0.019175846129655838, 0.058639418333768845, 0.02910708077251911, -0.037618160247802734, 0.001377694308757782, -0.01695121079683304, -0.013640571385622025, -0.01907172240316868, -0.043298207223415375, -0.03472105413675308, 0.004453424364328384, 0.023537935689091682, -0.03584715351462364, 0.002583047142252326, -0.03535002842545509, -0.0037781207356601954, -0.017727341502904892, 0.0066323899663984776, 0.06420516222715378, 0.028453314676880836, -0.006064536981284618, 0.03867635875940323, -0.04426206275820732, -0.047896359115839005, -0.0019869948737323284, -0.004236786626279354, -0.021808642894029617, -0.027276379987597466, 0.06629910320043564, 0.0071252393536269665, -0.02069203555583954, 0.06657300889492035, 0.003923404961824417, 0.01634884998202324, -0.003708803793415427, -0.08879043906927109, -0.031115727499127388, 0.04303513839840889, -0.039351917803287506, 0.02650395967066288, -0.07848931849002838, -0.01103249005973339, 0.035720616579055786, 0.038881637156009674, -0.015991508960723877, 0.05495413392782211, 0.03055710531771183, 0.037238769233226776, -0.028580578044056892, -0.016015982255339622, -0.00973303522914648, -0.0614582896232605, 0.02540673315525055, -0.05238858982920647, -0.05987723916769028, 0.011489521712064743, -0.0019181722309440374, -0.025490356609225273, 0.019396353513002396, -0.01848314143717289, 0.014158204197883606, 0.007900984026491642, -0.0061652096919715405, -0.007142374757677317, -0.07867046445608139, 0.06450041383504868, 0.026348307728767395, 0.032256875187158585, 0.0012683828826993704, -0.00037890620296821, 0.01918935403227806, -0.032979968935251236, 0.03502611070871353, 0.02661953680217266, -0.02864290028810501, 0.0035985452122986317, -0.019849753007292747, 0.047890059649944305, 0.02642807736992836, 0.010017161257565022, -0.041254520416259766, -0.03967911750078201, 0.005586084444075823, 0.01697169616818428, 0.02205606922507286, 0.023815900087356567, 0.010237264446914196, 0.038715019822120667, -0.06384148448705673, -0.050652969628572464, -0.05182170867919922, 0.042773645371198654, -0.022586345672607422, -0.015707843005657196, 0.047237034887075424, -0.027267975732684135, 0.0407806932926178, -0.01449533924460411, -0.0212141964584589, -0.0038383565843105316, -0.029368804767727852, 0.026169825345277786, -0.0308938380330801, -0.0017453123582527041, 0.028262680396437645, 0.009580946527421474, 0.0004926137626171112, 0.03740926831960678, -0.02057855762541294, -0.03850175067782402, 0.0032932402100414038, 0.020042279735207558, 0.007527037989348173, -0.020671067759394646, -0.04578585922718048, 0.022461293265223503, -0.023395143449306488, -0.030721917748451233, 0.02186143584549427, -0.04555337131023407, 0.07610894739627838, 0.08815549314022064, -0.009880587458610535, -0.022292833775281906, 0.009029500186443329, 0.007448423653841019, 0.022463692352175713, -0.017201751470565796, 0.01941966824233532, -0.015467827208340168, 0.030372539535164833, 0.029607592150568962, 0.03625466674566269, -0.0480286069214344, -0.010777510702610016, 0.033981796354055405, 0.019600611180067062, 0.00665443018078804, 0.039660241454839706, -0.0059503125958144665, -0.04913109168410301, 0.03607666492462158, -0.014807222411036491, -0.0028588424902409315, -0.028634488582611084, 0.02255425788462162, -0.021191490814089775, 0.03997965157032013, 0.01096726767718792, -0.033362697809934616, 0.034346435219049454, -0.03331833705306053, -0.0035868457052856684, -0.04716639965772629, -0.02900788001716137, -0.013349039480090141, -0.02575567550957203, 0.01664152927696705, 0.05021928995847702, -0.0018481347942724824, -0.029794838279485703, -0.018191754817962646, -0.04987723007798195, -0.021898670122027397, 0.028891688212752342, -0.026343151926994324, 0.01073403935879469, 0.02047988772392273, -0.07349648326635361, -0.006242742761969566, 0.00014030456077307463, -0.010686097666621208, -0.030219830572605133, 0.018598856404423714, 0.0617520697414875, 0.0016241989796981215, 0.01606597565114498, -0.030101727694272995, -0.008262407965958118, 0.006171747576445341, 0.0021799851674586535, 0.03429746627807617, 0.006890974007546902, -0.05313491076231003, 0.015730783343315125, 0.004016198683530092, -0.005330327898263931, 0.009500815533101559, 0.005822547245770693, -0.010318797081708908, -0.012104345485568047, -0.0157132837921381, -0.013466022908687592, -0.04156194627285004, -0.0207835640758276, 0.003917335066944361, -0.012841717340052128, -0.007516816724091768, 0.04865975305438042, 0.0018890670035034418, -0.006558592431247234, 0.056824736297130585, -0.0058806235902011395, -0.03400162234902382, -0.030747488141059875, -0.014601081609725952, 0.006584870163351297, 0.010475432500243187, 0.040694527328014374, 0.02936745248734951, 0.03292513266205788, 0.016935152933001518, -0.052852511405944824, -0.042060669511556625, -0.00010815734276548028, 0.01930229552090168, 0.009860900230705738, 0.01991093158721924, 0.024446610361337662, 0.01937568560242653, 0.0325901173055172, -0.027313759550452232, -0.03578684851527214, 0.005230174399912357, -0.05204961076378822, -0.06505140662193298, 0.007558874785900116, 0.006350449752062559, -0.012892055325210094, 0.013005070388317108, 0.011927678249776363, 0.04403924196958542, 0.0704207494854927, -0.032043565064668655, -0.005705202464014292, 0.018030602484941483, -0.036240000277757645, 0.008740303106606007, 0.05356724560260773, 0.01821001060307026, 0.018255963921546936, -0.007012215908616781, 0.003347391728311777, 0.024230606853961945, -0.022024452686309814, -0.02608858421444893, 0.024105902761220932, -0.04153665155172348, 0.032307397574186325, -0.057698801159858704, 0.021541275084018707, -0.005854201968759298, -0.04455319046974182, -0.030468713492155075, 0.0005259856698103249, 0.01747460477054119, -0.04588016867637634, 0.029677126556634903, 0.06463699042797089, -0.014204536564648151, 0.04194866120815277, 0.019787268713116646, -0.013746190816164017, -0.010880351066589355, -0.0014942928683012724, -0.015412561595439911, 0.0014986544847488403, 0.027011100202798843, 0.03096032701432705, 0.004323587287217379, -0.0017393850721418858, -0.06451651453971863, 0.015985427424311638, -0.050775136798620224, -0.015528705902397633, 0.009331059642136097, 0.02904650568962097, 0.0001878776674857363, 0.009089065715670586, 0.034297533333301544, 0.016354184597730637, 0.006330935750156641, 0.020612549036741257, -0.045548900961875916, -0.010736909694969654, -0.03348417580127716, -0.033883947879076004, 0.043005283921957016, -0.02868560142815113, 0.011234980076551437, -0.02387058176100254, 0.0578947439789772, 0.00418997323140502, 0.059390000998973846, -0.06688891351222992, 0.0035380003973841667, -0.03077404573559761, 0.01098910067230463, -0.026432771235704422, 0.004006361588835716, 0.04712611436843872, 0.027545642107725143, 0.016638552770018578, 0.003241113619878888, -0.024035895243287086, 0.0034663614351302385, -0.008835950866341591, 0.041242413222789764, 0.009961353614926338, 0.0319526381790638, 0.02216929942369461, 0.018128693103790283, -0.03937048837542534, 0.05262669548392296, -0.016127463430166245, 0.07548532634973526, 0.017069408670067787, -0.004242509137839079, 0.017432957887649536, -0.03329688683152199, -0.020749671384692192, 0.035398200154304504, 0.009481783024966717, -0.008593069389462471, 0.006658951286226511, 0.017944475635886192, 0.02854224294424057, -0.054664622992277145, 0.013398516923189163, 0.06764354556798935, 0.0033350123558193445, 0.0029089529998600483, -0.017210541293025017, -0.011935279704630375, -0.022669974714517593, -0.022638561204075813, 0.025677094236016273, 0.010380495339632034, -0.027630146592855453, 0.02510075271129608, 0.035449180752038956, -0.02600424736738205, 0.0094241201877594, 0.01677963323891163, 0.030345888808369637, 0.06425788998603821, 0.006594839971512556, -0.0016045308439061046, -0.005788236856460571, 0.014408501796424389, 0.024324584752321243, -0.0072707245126366615, 0.009892620146274567, -0.08072475343942642, 0.00868473295122385, 0.03073257766664028, 0.02121862769126892, 0.0066514695063233376, 0.018647992983460426, -0.04379437118768692, -0.02602001465857029, 0.03770851343870163, -0.04322756454348564, 0.02329741232097149, 0.004742281045764685, -0.0011722644558176398, -0.029069041833281517, -0.021363116800785065, -0.04018237069249153, -0.016022102907299995, -0.04087081551551819, 0.05170179530978203, -0.0011098035611212254, -0.04962386190891266, -0.032989975064992905, 0.0014055307256057858, -0.015257829800248146, 0.06438467651605606, -0.05532645061612129, -0.009661328978836536, -0.010111073032021523, 0.04984769970178604, -0.0023405016399919987, -0.05947893112897873, 0.013901570811867714, -0.0473305806517601, -0.010533064603805542, 0.032676249742507935, -0.025734327733516693, -0.03890872374176979, 0.016803111881017685, -0.0014239803422242403, 0.022743111476302147, -0.018338371068239212, -0.007691951468586922, 0.03230167552828789, 0.015825938433408737, -0.022597981616854668, 0.029630526900291443, -0.006521095987409353, 0.011315415613353252, -0.011230106465518475, -0.0005393909523263574, 0.04812723398208618, -0.0663473978638649, 0.0012125682551413774, -0.054707396775484085, 0.004896736238151789, -0.012013362720608711, 0.050634242594242096, 0.012760791927576065, 0.061209604144096375, -0.009980151429772377, 0.02369803749024868, 0.05127551406621933, 0.032614924013614655, -0.018758026883006096, -0.02557368017733097, -0.021573640406131744, 0.030258597806096077, -0.043047431856393814, 0.0076797413639724255, 0.03344091773033142, -0.029740802943706512, -0.009757330641150475, 0.010764618404209614, -0.033468328416347504, 0.006308906711637974, -0.03511141240596771, -0.004395112860947847, 0.0024366583675146103, -0.03438716009259224, 0.00472018588334322, -0.009671862237155437, 0.029685502871870995, 0.01894143968820572, -0.009698390029370785, -0.00478916522115469, 0.030664702877402306, -0.017765186727046967, 0.030847204849123955, -0.015990545973181725, 0.0014334910083562136, -0.001672902493737638, 0.011436756700277328, -0.030276548117399216, -0.05862065404653549, 0.04753189533948898, -0.008702955208718777, -0.00481180427595973, -0.014754540286958218, -0.00901761557906866, 0.013628917746245861, 0.009359347634017467, -0.008311517536640167, -0.006106904242187738, -0.023665497079491615, 0.022183911874890327, 0.017532313242554665, 0.0028786214534193277, 0.07786315679550171, -0.01715637370944023, -0.012176214717328548, 0.04743541404604912, 0.01859048753976822, -0.03376690298318863, -0.006672510411590338, 0.047726962715387344, -0.018147332593798637, 0.008979753591120243, -0.012578806839883327, -0.018332786858081818, 0.06608334928750992, 0.005290306638926268, -0.004347413312643766, 0.016782406717538834, -0.013798494823276997, 0.042068254202604294, -0.0534723661839962, -0.012456146068871021, -0.016502752900123596, -0.020655229687690735, -0.009684551507234573, -0.019104547798633575, 0.03742179274559021, -0.031590674072504044, 0.04159430414438248, 0.01400366984307766, -0.015667034313082695, -0.008408429101109505, 0.0365811325609684, -0.005657986272126436, 0.011292217299342155, 0.02351723611354828, -0.006931852549314499, 0.019890330731868744, -0.001233807997778058, 0.0012916106497868896, -0.010378258302807808, -0.009127242490649223, -0.06289885938167572, -0.03538450598716736, -0.043678347021341324, 0.04261694476008415, 0.06970084458589554, 0.015415852889418602, 0.03306248411536217, 0.017998451367020607, 0.007935796864330769, -0.004704911727458239, -0.033527158200740814, -0.029986148700118065, -0.029362129047513008, 0.01353939063847065, 0.01740458980202675, 0.0011629464570432901, 0.024135641753673553, 0.025514895096421242, 0.009515778161585331, 0.023970909416675568, 0.03891928866505623, 0.01769467256963253, 0.010812290944159031, 0.02024834230542183, 0.019775444641709328, -0.012958432547748089, 0.012556444853544235, -0.01598030887544155, 0.02931075729429722, -0.05956346541643143, 0.0058854552917182446, 0.014868161641061306, 0.055464908480644226, 0.02467695064842701, -0.020534049719572067, -0.029629552736878395, -0.06504447013139725, 0.0010010356782004237, 0.04995785281062126, -0.04497204348444939, 0.02104848250746727, 0.04621986672282219, 0.0553462877869606, 0.027787990868091583, 0.04594685509800911, -0.0495247021317482, -0.05042511969804764, -0.06223675236105919, -0.015400161035358906, -0.000904387328773737, 0.016628464683890343, 0.01371352095156908, -0.027122411876916885, -0.0026776089798659086, -0.009870435111224651, 0.03615586832165718, -0.03933194652199745, 0.018575262278318405, -0.02361113578081131, 0.04675639420747757, 0.020092226564884186, 0.004064721520990133, -0.004056602716445923, 0.01810983195900917, 0.11578989773988724, 0.07308725267648697, 0.04755846783518791, -0.02281864918768406, 0.015516071580350399, -0.0009426753968000412, -0.0260894987732172, -0.03515522927045822, 0.03913448750972748, 0.03162254020571709, -0.03306024521589279, -0.028845634311437607, -0.0065275332890450954, 0.015442478470504284, 0.03837485611438751, 0.018654124811291695, -0.03687761351466179, -0.012542961165308952, -0.03372074291110039, 0.0021431546192616224, -0.005371278151869774, 0.004443273413926363, -0.03389061242341995, 0.035916633903980255, -0.039565734565258026, -0.019621476531028748, -0.014513993635773659, 0.006371601484715939, -0.02176191285252571, 0.03864786773920059, 0.01871829852461815, 0.011049400083720684, 0.004809068515896797, 0.010571608319878578, -0.021309388801455498, 0.03443251922726631, -0.004151103086769581, 0.016744447872042656, 0.0031956012826412916, 0.02384594827890396, 0.018136488273739815, 0.03906431794166565, -0.024352017790079117, -0.010197446681559086, -0.0010989124421030283, -0.02912633679807186, -0.013059822842478752, 0.0960349291563034, -0.00038304226472973824, 0.0024754228070378304, -0.016837429255247116, -0.0161077082157135, 0.014118165709078312, -0.09528454393148422, -0.0046400511637330055, 0.002233360428363085, 0.052244894206523895, -0.010072183795273304, -0.043227940797805786, -0.013974838890135288, -0.01272303331643343, -0.011434059590101242, 0.015886621549725533, 0.019401784986257553, -0.012049750424921513, -0.03578738868236542, -0.042309824377298355, 0.04823576658964157, 0.011180748231709003, -0.010672527365386486, 0.009328697808086872, -0.03618268668651581, -0.018862375989556313, -0.05485353618860245, 0.0001710593787720427, -0.003236335702240467, 0.016122182831168175, -0.026587998494505882, -0.03865978494286537, 0.005658898968249559, -0.034426070749759674, 0.004908399656414986, -0.0019992280285805464, 0.003895563306286931, 0.00042651419062167406, -0.015300552360713482, 0.0016422936460003257, 0.04138922318816185, -0.025412918999791145, 0.026095231994986534, -0.009731891565024853, 0.04766705259680748, 0.011019138619303703, -0.019840404391288757, -0.020585907623171806, 0.015215467661619186, -0.040172331035137177, -0.01882324367761612, 0.013201819732785225, 0.07837298512458801, 0.005147261079400778, 0.047378551214933395, 0.0013888287357985973, 0.0354834645986557, -0.0008470981847494841, -0.007649376522749662, 0.014625177718698978, -0.03836945816874504, 0.029595788568258286, -0.002071085851639509, -0.016097428277134895, -0.046489909291267395, -0.01186403725296259, -0.020726017653942108, -0.023800117895007133, 0.015739805996418, 0.023744044825434685, -0.017315493896603584, 0.01252113375812769, -0.010720551013946533, 0.02644888311624527, 0.006733647547662258, 0.02465631812810898, -0.031213954091072083, 0.012948873452842236, -0.02492711693048477, -0.04798054322600365, -0.017326410859823227, 0.007690255995839834, -0.006753879599273205, -0.023743245750665665, 0.03954102843999863, 0.016720540821552277, 0.04119191691279411, -0.07711227983236313, 0.023531818762421608, -0.009657612070441246, 0.04929292947053909, -0.04351724684238434, -0.024512778967618942, 0.02573726512491703, -0.041919976472854614, -0.011086023412644863, 0.01820334419608116, 0.031548261642456055, 0.04228721559047699, 0.007431497797369957, 0.008893027901649475, 0.004978737328201532, 0.04744340851902962, -0.034176018089056015, 0.018965838477015495, 0.007798514328896999, -0.012384822592139244, -0.009863100945949554, 0.0012106661451980472, -0.020453061908483505, 0.025378312915563583, 0.028729679062962532, 0.03414805978536606, 0.05714205279946327, 0.006266990210860968, 0.008042414672672749, 0.031039590016007423, -0.026246920228004456, 0.002853258978575468, 0.02084389328956604, 0.02929730713367462, 0.03823399916291237, 0.04217388480901718, -0.0174430962651968, -0.005225130822509527, -0.025452420115470886, 0.03616081550717354, -0.05558318272233009, -0.019218655303120613, -0.019869498908519745, -0.005647207610309124, 0.053288534283638, -0.036616675555706024, -0.01347025390714407, 0.04162503033876419, -0.06719913333654404, 0.02157953754067421, 0.00902422983199358, 0.022411391139030457, -0.04550071060657501, -0.011374695226550102, -0.02529987506568432, 0.039116907864809036, 0.02098611369729042, 0.035422150045633316, 0.060438912361860275, 0.061308540403842926, -0.006883349269628525, -0.00925051886588335, -0.04142073169350624, 0.037953879684209824, -0.01928093284368515, -0.04849822446703911, -0.010630516335368156, -0.02613961510360241, -0.009670568630099297, 0.021847296506166458, -0.033698778599500656, -0.0086670508608222, 0.05469949170947075, 0.05600100755691528, 0.015412588603794575, 0.031535401940345764, 0.0560949482023716, 0.01987164095044136, 0.021491026505827904, -0.005841230507940054, 0.010969266295433044, -0.016377747058868408, -0.01186996977776289, 0.025340911000967026, 0.019654838368296623, -0.020067734643816948, 0.0028916869778186083, 0.003235642332583666, -0.01905064284801483, -0.003656794084236026, -0.005334679037332535, 0.002024899935349822, 0.0053424108773469925, -0.050400327891111374, 0.03150531277060509, -0.018572555854916573, 0.004104409832507372, 0.025971410796046257, 0.029478179290890694, -0.042792581021785736, -0.03545753285288811, -0.041787855327129364, -0.056690674275159836, 0.0025541719514876604, -0.007816433906555176, -0.020889636129140854, -0.04821329191327095, 0.008075645193457603, -0.006544126663357019, -0.0246365237981081, -0.007645765785127878, -0.02126636542379856, -0.07876250147819519, 0.08643542230129242, -0.0141318803653121, 0.02866789698600769, -0.002924920292571187, 0.009119776077568531, -0.001576881157234311, -0.11147084087133408, 0.03730546683073044, -0.017147522419691086, -0.05938627943396568, -0.02595287188887596, 0.015874633565545082, -0.013588346540927887, 0.001578881754539907, 0.05436977744102478, -0.01643178053200245, 0.032887425273656845, 0.008264526724815369, 0.005575858987867832, 0.00043543652282096446, 0.021591437980532646, 0.02423243597149849, -0.02068154141306877, -0.03334791958332062, 0.03853094205260277, -0.04368612542748451, 0.04374763369560242, 0.021990451961755753, 0.017348311841487885, -0.01458070706576109, -0.004732364322990179, 0.01712658815085888, -0.0015806545270606875, 0.012917383573949337, -0.0013353804824873805, -0.0008013656479306519, 0.014784744009375572, -0.00924691092222929, -0.028329411521553993, 0.024103451520204544, 0.0013364444021135569, -0.059632085263729095, 0.006531353574246168, 0.003295336617156863, -0.06808464974164963, -0.017250560224056244, -0.011522897519171238, 0.027535760775208473, -0.039140548557043076, -0.011167142540216446, 0.04169792681932449, -0.05757153034210205, 0.023452414199709892, 0.030354127287864685, -0.0003946118231397122, 0.012339750304818153, 0.038687024265527725, 0.011338559910655022, 0.008091164752840996, 0.014856104739010334, 0.020798055455088615, 0.051598310470581055, 0.02168426848948002, -0.03424418345093727, -0.008350951597094536, 0.024621902033686638, -0.06117385998368263, 0.02809610217809677, -0.031151575967669487, 0.03418681398034096, -0.03053901717066765, -0.022130317986011505, -0.031675707548856735, -0.025644849985837936, -0.02247321419417858, -0.024111179634928703, -0.036436595022678375, 0.06489397585391998, -0.028120724484324455, -0.0000559701475140173, 0.016174085438251495, 0.03409203514456749, -0.03983351215720177, 0.00972471572458744, 0.0035409030970185995, 0.017393726855516434, 0.0244468841701746, -0.026268981397151947, -0.013896382413804531, -0.009690098464488983, 0.02359624020755291, -0.08155173808336258, -0.01903793215751648, -0.015049159526824951, -0.012097169645130634, 0.05484577640891075, -0.00828587543219328, -0.004075126722455025, -0.03417561203241348, 0.012474797666072845, -0.003553251503035426, 0.01593749411404133, -0.0503469780087471, -0.051519975066185, -0.0364714041352272, 0.038857366889715195, -0.062295835465192795, 0.020803632214665413, -0.029198234900832176, 0.03133862838149071, -0.011356321163475513, 0.020365381613373756 ]
<p>What Exactly is the difference between decode and score? The documentation seems pretty sparse regarding this.</p> <p>My guess is that: decode represents the probability of the best sequence of states for a observation sequence. score represents the sum of probabilities of all state sequences for a observation sequence.</p> <p>Is this correct? That is, decode is the viterbi probability while score is the forward probability.</p> <p>Thanks in advance.</p>
73,841
[ -0.00749559560790658, -0.039566997438669205, -0.022011667490005493, 0.012052823789417744, 0.022453704848885536, 0.02173587866127491, 0.012520947493612766, 0.011005786247551441, 0.046117402613162994, 0.009690523147583008, 0.023640507832169533, 0.04199763759970665, 0.027179274708032608, 0.03218332305550575, 0.011577971279621124, -0.023772090673446655, 0.02289547771215439, 0.027350107207894325, -0.01252176146954298, 0.009230070747435093, 0.013243160210549831, 0.02142832614481449, 0.0197718758136034, -0.006495826877653599, -0.01988152228295803, 0.04495679959654808, 0.028970129787921906, 0.006297247018665075, 0.029455406591296196, 0.05753061920404434, -0.05285640060901642, -0.04117593541741371, -0.008389797061681747, 0.0530073381960392, 0.01513975765556097, -0.03959721699357033, -0.03410957008600235, -0.03877025470137596, -0.001239695819094777, 0.0249362550675869, -0.022496482357382774, -0.027163373306393623, 0.03331351652741432, 0.049498531967401505, -0.02555031143128872, 0.008420560508966446, 0.009167012758553028, -0.019659701734781265, 0.010345452465116978, -0.04461174085736275, 0.04543910548090935, -0.004587818402796984, 0.0367182195186615, 0.00048547793994657695, -0.0036209996324032545, 0.02188989892601967, 0.06603136658668518, 0.10660215467214584, 0.03428984060883522, -0.036731842905282974, -0.006538378540426493, -0.06974086910486221, 0.0003574964648578316, 0.004337697755545378, -0.04038011655211449, 0.021945003420114517, -0.004665987100452185, -0.045496292412281036, 0.06373967975378036, 0.025605695322155952, -0.018176531419157982, -0.01001122035086155, 0.008888041600584984, -0.022391073405742645, 0.046317145228385925, -0.03366108983755112, 0.018973013386130333, -0.03238658979535103, 0.0060032811015844345, 0.03538301959633827, 0.013924422673881054, -0.010192637331783772, -0.001846548286266625, 0.009323435835540295, 0.012332367710769176, -0.028289232403039932, 0.06537917256355286, -0.03590226545929909, 0.00036011612974107265, 0.02800370194017887, -0.0005069808685220778, 0.015279506333172321, 0.019494453445076942, -0.005324091296643019, -0.028467558324337006, 0.017360489815473557, -0.022868789732456207, 0.03325817734003067, 0.02776176854968071, -0.017176026478409767, -0.03357169032096863, -0.030343325808644295, -0.011378416791558266, 0.03875573351979256, -0.026321135461330414, 0.0001859759504441172, -0.02483050711452961, 0.02162591926753521, -0.008247983641922474, -0.00376557232812047, -0.025120696052908897, 0.03857039660215378, -0.014835003763437271, 0.030623652040958405, 0.022040434181690216, -0.04641842469573021, -0.01978810876607895, -0.0021270914003252983, 0.05101925507187843, 0.029720228165388107, 0.05899960547685623, -0.022590290755033493, -0.016657495871186256, -0.04453654959797859, -0.05298525094985962, -0.030163174495100975, 0.03748728707432747, -0.0050682444125413895, -0.015472626313567162, 0.03487592563033104, -0.008255896158516407, -0.023439470678567886, 0.0534437857568264, 0.04483122378587723, -0.011376813054084778, 0.001373165869154036, -0.09939415752887726, -0.013250346295535564, 0.06976262480020523, 0.013237688690423965, -0.012155408971011639, -0.05121815949678421, 0.008474815636873245, 0.023957960307598114, 0.038216423243284225, 0.001516953227110207, 0.0314502939581871, 0.018239308148622513, 0.007609516382217407, 0.009678252972662449, -0.02031322754919529, -0.013255332596600056, -0.03869820758700371, -0.03073432296514511, -0.0036604434717446566, -0.011825388297438622, -0.006692214868962765, 0.01621726155281067, -0.01681896299123764, -0.030623383820056915, 0.01943325251340866, -0.012801460921764374, -0.013417426496744156, 0.009512168355286121, -0.010899589397013187, -0.007443300448358059, 0.029138077050447464, 0.007731134071946144, 0.024346113204956055, 0.05423133447766304, -0.028675556182861328, 0.0006928594666533172, -0.0013225746806710958, 0.021617477759718895, 0.048424575477838516, -0.03176320716738701, -0.027915118262171745, -0.03297214210033417, 0.013773464597761631, -0.012422159314155579, -0.010972946882247925, -0.022981271147727966, -0.006850055884569883, -0.005880518350750208, 0.02914290875196457, 0.021052248775959015, 0.03127776086330414, 0.004362814594060183, 0.039684273302555084, -0.05831117928028107, -0.04619067907333374, -0.04666125401854515, -0.008389066904783249, -0.04047355055809021, -0.029082993045449257, 0.01077144593000412, 0.021966755390167236, 0.02133280783891678, 0.009168910793960094, -0.01827121712267399, -0.06322932988405228, 0.002530375262722373, -0.0060193417593836784, -0.016865398734807968, -0.024829629808664322, 0.04266900196671486, 0.01709858328104019, 0.007146141026169062, 0.05694379657506943, -0.014114903286099434, -0.04902416467666626, -0.0018882304430007935, -0.009927578270435333, 0.03114091046154499, -0.01999111846089363, -0.0070395879447460175, 0.007792637217789888, 0.00263980939052999, -0.03973997384309769, 0.012017407454550266, -0.05095897614955902, 0.06053002551198006, 0.10129956901073456, 0.025601031258702278, -0.020269593223929405, 0.0036911850329488516, -0.0013574280310422182, -0.003753617173060775, -0.039993781596422195, 0.019539937376976013, -0.07429656386375427, -0.019107917323708534, 0.034793686121702194, 0.0038763713091611862, -0.04649130254983902, 0.008608214557170868, 0.07254737615585327, -0.007320390548557043, 0.030583113431930542, -0.0018592328997328877, -0.01157560758292675, -0.010143667459487915, 0.0033553391695022583, 0.012504102662205696, -0.014240188524127007, -0.006624388508498669, 0.044631633907556534, 0.019243333488702774, 0.01770721934735775, 0.014200556091964245, -0.04200238734483719, 0.03275733441114426, -0.021399637684226036, 0.04313785210251808, -0.02658637799322605, -0.05537068471312523, -0.009293803945183754, -0.02065514214336872, 0.01712917909026146, 0.010052112862467766, 0.006471928674727678, -0.0001067977209459059, 0.0014196833362802863, -0.019063398241996765, -0.010396183468401432, 0.007092960644513369, -0.036973509937524796, -0.02634294331073761, 0.03125057369470596, -0.03560590744018555, 0.008461725898087025, -0.018562057986855507, 0.008749703876674175, -0.05812688171863556, -0.0016451694536954165, 0.015150931663811207, -0.06335589289665222, 0.017163492739200592, -0.02772008441388607, -0.04866679012775421, 0.01740235649049282, -0.04123583808541298, 0.02286052331328392, 0.030441299080848694, -0.07283875346183777, 0.005547605454921722, -0.04038791358470917, -0.04103681817650795, 0.032071590423583984, 0.01708998717367649, -0.027239270508289337, 0.00981700886040926, -0.03120807558298111, -0.02795146405696869, -0.0028135147877037525, -0.05702061951160431, 0.054798632860183716, -0.028127262368798256, 0.004242361057549715, 0.055483169853687286, 0.0022186939604580402, -0.011080507189035416, 0.005038985516875982, -0.0694148913025856, -0.0032310723327100277, -0.03166945278644562, -0.0076919617131352425, 0.032127995043992996, -0.019732125103473663, -0.002036850433796644, 0.04812192544341087, -0.044770024716854095, 0.001801867038011551, -0.040209729224443436, -0.03159821778535843, 0.047125544399023056, 0.024163587018847466, 0.010270202532410622, 0.003987854812294245, 0.0006864273454993963, 0.032969195395708084, 0.04684457182884216, -0.03345269709825516, 0.0019392194226384163, 0.01269847434014082, -0.007755068596452475, -0.0285902451723814, -0.028790118172764778, 0.0033244939986616373, 0.0033698435872793198, 0.058136701583862305, -0.014722723513841629, 0.00961631815880537, 0.05864114314317703, -0.029710764065384865, 0.01305178552865982, -0.005668653640896082, 0.0708431750535965, -0.040634796023368835, 0.04302309453487396, 0.012339525856077671, -0.021775241941213608, -0.002092875773087144, 0.013813872821629047, 0.0059546479023993015, 0.0048920330591499805, -0.01172995287925005, 0.03643696382641792, -0.003587230807170272, 0.025762921199202538, -0.055634427815675735, 0.039727989584207535, -0.03950110450387001, -0.0010315015679225326, -0.0047133625485002995, 0.029278453439474106, 0.021488944068551064, -0.014943120069801807, 0.013590884394943714, 0.036437924951314926, 0.037472836673259735, -0.0186857171356678, -0.049570076167583466, -0.007630355656147003, -0.010359675623476505, 0.023490965366363525, 0.002690806519240141, -0.002780483104288578, 0.031752292066812515, 0.02235148474574089, -0.01084144227206707, 0.013221999630331993, -0.027382059022784233, -0.021961139515042305, -0.0836087316274643, 0.02995140291750431, -0.02208489365875721, 0.02919062413275242, 0.008628863841295242, 0.04954781010746956, 0.010911591351032257, 0.0004717842966783792, 0.02030552551150322, 0.006776873022317886, -0.06756339222192764, 0.04007207229733467, -0.002759020309895277, -0.008187936618924141, 0.014869106002151966, -0.029084859415888786, 0.04242841526865959, -0.058342184871435165, -0.0015163514763116837, 0.0047556678764522076, 0.004628067370504141, -0.0287997554987669, 0.012762126512825489, 0.002695586299523711, 0.008958275429904461, -0.01594769023358822, 0.021776754409074783, 0.02221035584807396, -0.007621080614626408, 0.06065180152654648, 0.05274161696434021, 0.01758040487766266, -0.012410510331392288, -0.0013031724374741316, 0.006450042128562927, 0.02261366881430149, 0.01400182768702507, 0.06874288618564606, 0.004743082448840141, -0.042097385972738266, 0.029710888862609863, -0.004351779352873564, 0.0416630394756794, 0.019597377628087997, -0.05588142201304436, 0.00770574901252985, -0.026520706713199615, -0.036016322672367096, -0.001483151689171791, 0.0035071340389549732, 0.014660819433629513, 0.02970346063375473, 0.02055889181792736, 0.018671218305826187, -0.0021091315429657698, 0.034716371446847916, 0.06834705919027328, -0.01075344905257225, -0.00758417509496212, -0.019866399466991425, -0.010471873916685581, -0.008908365853130817, 0.006587780546396971, -0.0005819215439260006, 0.036867816001176834, 0.012894134037196636, 0.04371834918856621, 0.03375339135527611, -0.041386064141988754, -0.031201748177409172, 0.0058101266622543335, 0.019203273579478264, 0.04812849685549736, 0.0017692025285214186, -0.012367690913379192, 0.03854595497250557, 0.021064043045043945, 0.01578592136502266, 0.028091877698898315, -0.025148868560791016, -0.07472049444913864, -0.023522397503256798, 0.0020143440924584866, 0.02095804177224636, -0.03007705882191658, -0.01963386870920658, -0.08960285037755966, -0.032269932329654694, 0.037368837743997574, -0.019700122997164726, 0.047503624111413956, -0.020116837695240974, -0.012695240788161755, -0.021929381415247917, -0.003069746308028698, -0.05842430144548416, 0.032786574214696884, -0.0008006048738025129, 0.027749881148338318, 0.0027090522926300764, -0.009489701129496098, -0.057512834668159485, -0.042836111038923264, 0.025917991995811462, 0.0660107359290123, -0.03149126097559929, 0.031869761645793915, -0.0019209043821319938, -0.0058478121645748615, -0.019801443442702293, -0.05159474536776543, 0.02259865775704384, -0.0007414516294375062, -0.006518580485135317, 0.0015173169085755944, -0.01716769114136696, -0.04760398715734482, 0.000528054079040885, 0.024554288014769554, -0.04393238201737404, -0.016955947503447533, 0.0038389533292502165, 0.03135906159877777, 0.02490628883242607, 0.011313808150589466, 0.06602626293897629, 0.008634250611066818, 0.012070862576365471, 0.021500252187252045, -0.023680374026298523, 0.06318514794111252, -0.04116974025964737, 0.014058448374271393, -0.02592865377664566, 0.01506200060248375, -0.03541475161910057, 0.005384719930589199, 0.030149992555379868, 0.05688062310218811, -0.040117986500263214, -0.045501988381147385, -0.023774076253175735, 0.036423854529857635, 0.014845681376755238, 0.011412927880883217, -0.0002855851489584893, 0.012517577037215233, -0.01512973103672266, -0.02076307311654091, 0.01232132688164711, -0.03870093822479248, 0.00028589373687282205, 0.006795908324420452, -0.02500247210264206, 0.03480640798807144, -0.037717305123806, -0.023737087845802307, 0.02575787715613842, -0.036577943712472916, 0.02409782074391842, -0.007998469285666943, -0.0072857351042330265, 0.010284476913511753, -0.04373294860124588, -0.024420585483312607, -0.01410202868282795, -0.042699456214904785, 0.012631844729185104, -0.04352141544222832, 0.04085759073495865, -0.018253624439239502, -0.022840222343802452, -0.04998793825507164, -0.03874152526259422, 0.0054468936286866665, 0.040316227823495865, -0.03374825790524483, -0.04180591180920601, 0.021233562380075455, 0.01333379466086626, 0.0009396735695190728, -0.03307458385825157, 0.02246847003698349, -0.005795026198029518, -0.0012826317688450217, 0.012390446849167347, 0.03529466688632965, 0.06556396186351776, 0.00520775793120265, 0.026772508397698402, 0.01774110086262226, 0.03114812821149826, 0.00977138988673687, 0.005365680903196335, 0.035773865878582, -0.03484982252120972, -0.021576009690761566, -0.03804204985499382, -0.009049780666828156, 0.0658036321401596, 0.013308856636285782, -0.0020646771881729364, -0.014804244041442871, 0.000961711339186877, 0.0025416924618184566, -0.013884061016142368, -0.00888143666088581, -0.02558354288339615, 0.005792984738945961, -0.04489090293645859, 0.006402255967259407, -0.019762497395277023, 0.00009830904309637845, 0.005407358519732952, 0.0029616295360028744, 0.001018785173073411, 0.0031430681701749563, 0.08761931210756302, -0.03669743239879608, -0.00416694488376379, 0.0022073632571846247, -0.02224443294107914, 0.02364291623234749, -0.008419818244874477, 0.010998147539794445, 0.036113642156124115, 0.01793362759053707, -0.023439064621925354, -0.013519597239792347, -0.031229384243488312, -0.02815305069088936, 0.08001743257045746, 0.007158169988542795, 0.015909500420093536, 0.02309318073093891, -0.012856326065957546, 0.007756169885396957, -0.06653914600610733, -0.022826414555311203, 0.028204448521137238, 0.004703535232692957, 0.02053939737379551, -0.00979276467114687, -0.0322146974503994, 0.013656328432261944, 0.0373324453830719, 0.013179123401641846, 0.014243854209780693, 0.03643795847892761, 0.006230540107935667, 0.00856391154229641, -0.028005005791783333, -0.0021133015397936106, 0.05701219290494919, -0.04045845568180084, -0.009391916915774345, -0.04634283483028412, -0.02538963221013546, 0.06291750818490982, 0.010343724861741066, -0.020322764292359352, -0.06591235101222992, 0.009863411076366901, -0.030063342303037643, 0.01764651946723461, 0.024076130241155624, -0.01107590738683939, 0.015224495902657509, 0.0070649138651788235, 0.049692489206790924, -0.0118667371571064, 0.025997797027230263, -0.02433173730969429, -0.07211413234472275, -0.04447021707892418, -0.007905355654656887, -0.048863641917705536, 0.01924031414091587, 0.003884902223944664, -0.02070840261876583, 0.01077656727284193, -0.0012569909449666739, 0.058755166828632355, -0.00154782400932163, 0.06623957306146622, -0.020864566788077354, 0.05657310411334038, 0.0003820473502855748, 0.01612536795437336, 0.004165853373706341, -0.0498468354344368, 0.1376919448375702, 0.08470633625984192, 0.010386520996689796, -0.07237449288368225, 0.029629986733198166, 0.017845502123236656, 0.013972478918731213, -0.017262931913137436, 0.000748291437048465, 0.06018361449241638, 0.014888748526573181, 0.03121122531592846, 0.04528684541583061, 0.0064137461595237255, -0.027696168050169945, 0.053179819136857986, -0.04071661829948425, -0.04565788060426712, 0.028728343546390533, 0.009717785753309727, -0.0001816832082113251, 0.03536463901400566, -0.06072529777884483, -0.05084604397416115, 0.020736243575811386, -0.03829684853553772, -0.013921225443482399, -0.036511968821287155, -0.025426490232348442, 0.011592501774430275, 0.022928785532712936, -0.0050203376449644566, 0.03205849975347519, -0.0033460347913205624, -0.015258963219821453, 0.008772965520620346, -0.006313470657914877, -0.0023092865012586117, 0.008720911107957363, 0.03135319799184799, 0.011368954554200172, 0.014055922627449036, -0.01153577771037817, 0.03251234441995621, -0.08113730698823929, -0.003842441365122795, -0.012328555807471275, 0.028825780376791954, -0.011164597235620022, 0.0005571896908804774, -0.01135657075792551, 0.021555110812187195, -0.024032771587371826, -0.015849104151129723, -0.005377487279474735, 0.03904181346297264, 0.020725812762975693, -0.016048969700932503, -0.038776759058237076, -0.06627339869737625, 0.01578821986913681, -0.04024702310562134, 0.018409503623843193, 0.00677043991163373, -0.00003988798562204465, 0.024202968925237656, -0.032454799860715866, 0.053888142108917236, 0.01968853920698166, -0.0010662194108590484, 0.015044594183564186, 0.012107530608773232, -0.04569714516401291, -0.0257442444562912, 0.018947424367070198, -0.013572064228355885, 0.029535098001360893, -0.003216614481061697, 0.010070620104670525, -0.0057560452260077, -0.04238617420196533, 0.05193909630179405, -0.033360812813043594, -0.03752811253070831, -0.040929172188043594, 0.012229986488819122, 0.024594442918896675, 0.013578889891505241, 0.0047208452597260475, 0.031213898211717606, 0.007438744883984327, 0.0461001880466938, 0.0009010910871438682, -0.029277579858899117, -0.0024723499082028866, 0.03691720589995384, -0.011100025847554207, 0.004033868666738272, -0.02246137335896492, 0.07062119245529175, 0.068772092461586, 0.014199815690517426, -0.015143790282309055, -0.005428610369563103, -0.03144546225667, -0.03249508887529373, -0.006237166468054056, -0.03217669203877449, -0.026705194264650345, -0.00427558459341526, 0.0341024324297905, -0.0262734554708004, -0.030101759359240532, -0.03231406956911087, -0.03692719712853432, 0.01540368888527155, -0.03293175622820854, -0.02962266281247139, -0.005748632829636335, -0.019573593512177467, -0.009644963778555393, -0.012086596339941025, -0.030625399202108383, 0.010488392785191536, 0.010243701748549938, -0.026525558903813362, -0.01682073064148426, -0.010497120209038258, -0.024201810359954834, -0.027040274813771248, -0.022197503596544266, 0.014056116342544556, 0.031500887125730515, 0.005813584662973881, -0.006101675797253847, 0.04460086300969124, 0.008210008032619953, 0.0795058086514473, -0.010662387125194073, 0.005511002149432898, 0.04475469887256622, -0.013241622596979141, -0.05321422964334488, 0.058996137231588364, 0.030090034008026123, 0.04547981172800064, 0.007644890807569027, -0.00267970422282815, -0.0068228342570364475, 0.013187051750719547, -0.026771491393446922, -0.008183990605175495, -0.01996537297964096, -0.021817298606038094, -0.01776030659675598, 0.004769349005073309, 0.0026689351070672274, -0.019855817779898643, -0.024295467883348465, 0.023841777816414833, 0.011504299007356167, 0.006710978224873543, 0.04737471416592598, 0.0001477656333008781, 0.0022636866196990013, 0.0324239619076252, 0.0318618081510067, -0.00824311375617981, 0.006840381771326065, 0.02859266847372055, 0.01951010525226593, 0.01903613843023777, 0.0163483414798975, 0.013683863915503025, -0.04870612919330597, -0.0012819078983739018, 0.001907890080474317, -0.02446633204817772, 0.014325715601444244, -0.06328269839286804, -0.0005775803583674133, 0.03552330285310745, -0.047459278255701065, 0.043109793215990067, -0.004483230412006378, -0.006933474447578192, -0.03772755712270737, 0.07325462251901627, -0.02034078538417816, 0.09569939970970154, 0.04584691673517227, 0.031812090426683426, 0.036780960857868195, -0.01191768143326044, -0.007179047912359238, -0.022212497889995575, -0.04388464614748955, 0.02037651464343071, 0.02060905657708645, -0.0467720702290535, 0.06665055453777313, -0.05380171164870262, -0.04709982872009277, 0.02089121751487255, -0.009994465857744217, 0.022257523611187935, 0.015996834263205528, 0.030444921925663948, 0.03548194840550423, 0.021137326955795288, 0.012022798880934715, -0.013379530049860477, -0.008395450189709663, 0.007060313131660223, 0.02395864576101303, 0.02810429036617279, -0.013279899954795837, -0.022469470277428627, 0.008706948719918728, 0.0392591655254364, -0.044250790029764175, 0.030462931841611862, -0.018840312957763672, -0.02367992140352726, 0.005643376149237156, 0.01651836186647415, 0.025523629039525986, -0.06438714265823364, 0.022252220660448074, -0.0146101713180542, 0.010481635108590126, -0.00487370602786541, -0.029400406405329704, 0.016033420339226723, -0.02024274878203869, 0.02054331637918949, -0.02373524010181427, 0.01200377568602562, 0.006832531653344631, 0.007335074245929718, -0.04102819412946701, -0.033888064324855804, 0.020548976957798004, -0.00503111444413662, -0.012332727201282978, 0.01923525519669056, -0.010289285331964493, 0.05518766865134239, 0.0032178089022636414, 0.03181268647313118, 0.025837110355496407, -0.04377001151442528, -0.02085501328110695, -0.08159978687763214, 0.060631465166807175, 0.030489925295114517, -0.017704280093312263, -0.05325726792216301, -0.023744933307170868, -0.0026220481377094984, 0.02170696295797825, 0.05579159036278725, -0.017100322991609573, 0.011085743084549904, 0.008442367427051067, 0.03213072195649147, 0.010901995934545994, -0.01609274372458458, 0.04713016003370285, -0.045454367995262146, -0.011767576448619366, -0.014223666861653328, -0.03719770908355713, -0.004956552293151617, 0.005479669664055109, 0.015438796952366829, -0.03043321706354618, 0.013392660766839981, -0.04940308630466461, 0.04050898551940918, 0.04592384397983551, 0.014866586774587631, 0.0012649167329072952, 0.06098012626171112, -0.030014438554644585, 0.006699842866510153, 0.04220486804842949, -0.01232929341495037, -0.03273465484380722, 0.026844976469874382, -0.009882699698209763, -0.05044480413198471, 0.026046523824334145, -0.006360112223774195, -0.0038966264110058546, -0.056010957807302475, -0.019740434363484383, 0.045522432774305344, -0.06771627068519592, -0.017437290400266647, 0.039528440684080124, 0.015480768866837025, 0.0755813866853714, -0.008902797475457191, 0.04963818937540054, 0.018563905730843544, -0.013879150152206421, -0.003906219732016325, 0.055748533457517624, 0.06765817105770111, -0.010168638080358505, 0.04665093868970871, -0.004383977502584457, -0.027926050126552582, 0.03165541589260101, -0.009239684790372849, 0.05522396042943001, 0.019048351794481277, -0.0010928389383479953, -0.016328521072864532, 0.0036268627736717463, -0.013452920131385326, -0.0069258627481758595, -0.03097895160317421, 0.061524126678705215, -0.0625249370932579, -0.013570343144237995, -0.013131844811141491, 0.0000889156581251882, -0.0701470747590065, -0.038012344390153885, -0.0029507300350815058, 0.006629711948335171, 0.020622411742806435, -0.0068321931175887585, -0.026675567030906677, 0.01602691039443016, 0.036244846880435944, -0.06238122284412384, 0.014122329652309418, -0.005777999293059111, 0.021698497235774994, -0.01266546081751585, 0.006553467363119125, -0.039218734949827194, -0.006037359591573477, 0.017168201506137848, 0.004732505418360233, 0.0020669582299888134, -0.020844193175435066, -0.03426315262913704, -0.017038846388459206, 0.04038439691066742, -0.05011826381087303, -0.013406496495008469, -0.08378001302480698, 0.031047621741890907, 0.019672110676765442, 0.025721540674567223 ]
<p>I used Radial basis function and pseudo inverse to train neurons and then test it. Everything works here. But I read I can use gradient descent method instead of using pseudo inverse which sometimes may be hard to do (may run out of memory, may take too long to compute). But I don't understand few things here.</p> <p>Let say I have this data:</p> <p>$x = [-1, -0.75, -0.5, -0.25, 0, 0.25, 0.5, 0.75, 1]$</p> <p>$y = [-1 -0.75, -0.5, -0.25, 0, 0.25, 0.5, 0.75, 1] $</p> <p>$y$ is calculated using this function:</p> <p>$y_i(f(x_i))= 1/(1+x_i^2)$</p> <p>$N$ - number of train units (or elements)</p> <p>$m_1$ - number of centers.</p> <p>Then I calculate $Phi$ function:</p> <p>$t_j = -1 + (j - 1) g$</p> <p>$gamma = -m_1/4$</p> <p>$Phi = exp(gamma(abs(x - t_j)));$</p> <p>Then I fill $G$ with $Phi$ rows (or vectors)</p> <p>And then I would use $G$ to calculate $w$ vector like:</p> <p>$w = G^+y$</p> <p>where $G^+ = (G'G)^-1G'$ is this so called pseudo inverse.</p> <p>But in: <a href="http://www.ideal.ece.utexas.edu/~gjun/ee379k/html/regression/online_regression/page1.html" rel="nofollow">http://www.ideal.ece.utexas.edu/~gjun/ee379k/html/regression/online_regression/page1.html</a></p> <p>It suggests to use gradient descent method with something like:</p> <p>$E_w[t] = 1/2(y - w[t]Phi(x))^2 $</p> <p>$dE_w[t] =(y - w[t]^T Phi(x)(-Phi(x)))$ </p> <p>$w[t+1] = w[t] - n*dE_w[t]$</p> <p>Can someone explain how can I properly switch pseudo inverse with gradient descent? Also what should be init weight? As with pseudo inverse you get all the weights there, but with gradient descent I don't see what should be the first weight. Should I have some minimum error defined, so learning should stop when error reaches that level? If you could provide matlab example from this data, it would be even better.</p>
36,350
[ -0.004160481505095959, -0.017988689243793488, 0.01652710884809494, 0.0016884143697097898, 0.03630104288458824, -0.0034535990562289953, -0.03392034396529198, -0.02784010022878647, 0.03632308915257454, -0.014370433986186981, 0.03247034177184105, 0.029660983011126518, 0.030854087322950363, 0.02307550422847271, -0.011220737360417843, 0.02494834177196026, -0.04806647077202797, 0.010717521421611309, -0.011713764630258083, -0.030355535447597504, 0.009240779094398022, 0.03046313486993313, -0.018030516803264618, 0.006754969712346792, -0.031168881803750992, 0.024903714656829834, 0.020039228722453117, -0.026470625773072243, -0.010769503191113472, 0.047714222222566605, -0.0415772907435894, -0.015144770964980125, -0.011405318975448608, 0.02161194570362568, 0.013791020028293133, 0.017929960042238235, -0.02464301325380802, -0.03170507028698921, 0.0007448312826454639, 0.03219367191195488, -0.008157053962349892, -0.035599250346422195, 0.025498269125819206, 0.03068433701992035, -0.006336248014122248, 0.014374061487615108, -0.015318231657147408, -0.011170878075063229, 0.04818112403154373, -0.042883820831775665, 0.07870209217071533, 0.018618375062942505, 0.0128771448507905, -0.010620193555951118, -0.008865497075021267, 0.015248586423695087, 0.04516436532139778, 0.03998503088951111, -0.013925331644713879, -0.07476495206356049, 0.010903403162956238, -0.017894795164465904, -0.0018771652830764651, -0.03940878063440323, 0.012898705899715424, -0.0022231184411793947, 0.03853244706988335, 0.0023461300879716873, 0.03132724016904831, -0.058154571801424026, 0.02971723861992359, -0.004658516496419907, 0.03050476312637329, -0.009042448364198208, -0.011598294600844383, 0.007936044596135616, -0.0024568454828113317, 0.048033762723207474, 0.018040945753455162, -0.0182204470038414, -0.04350141063332558, 0.02094968967139721, 0.025915415957570076, 0.05396917462348938, -0.013379235751926899, -0.0012839393457397819, 0.06835144758224487, -0.022291740402579308, 0.06101815402507782, 0.021162215620279312, -0.036925725638866425, 0.026644248515367508, 0.058937400579452515, -0.013671190477907658, -0.012036759406328201, -0.0030735174659639597, -0.012088771909475327, 0.01642429642379284, 0.023585107177495956, 0.021908722817897797, -0.022047387436032295, -0.0382530502974987, -0.027773240581154823, 0.06272025406360626, -0.03761223703622818, -0.04516461119055748, -0.00011236179852858186, -0.002711202949285507, 0.009790489450097084, -0.02004697360098362, -0.037713631987571716, 0.03866169601678848, -0.009232396259903908, -0.030712150037288666, 0.06108742579817772, -0.01288777869194746, -0.018736764788627625, -0.01475521270185709, 0.024187805131077766, 0.0531790666282177, 0.040655896067619324, -0.046391140669584274, 0.016034651547670364, -0.02803267538547516, -0.017565665766596794, 0.00029702039319090545, 0.029812298715114594, -0.028170812875032425, -0.02793167717754841, 0.01941896229982376, 0.027190091088414192, -0.038631267845630646, 0.05096491798758507, -0.006752655375748873, 0.035733018070459366, 0.015847090631723404, -0.07388406246900558, -0.046180274337530136, 0.023344511166214943, -0.039465419948101044, 0.041390907019376755, -0.05064636096358299, 0.029543980956077576, 0.024846769869327545, 0.05467909947037697, 0.0027402257546782494, 0.06074468791484833, 0.029954535886645317, 0.01908143423497677, -0.015349219553172588, -0.013368758372962475, -0.008180802688002586, -0.0686078816652298, -0.029113469645380974, -0.01697566732764244, -0.054537802934646606, 0.04697886481881142, -0.010932469740509987, -0.019235361367464066, -0.018365634605288506, 0.03603782877326012, 0.008977706544101238, 0.005550865083932877, 0.005997264292091131, -0.0042185550555586815, -0.020474685356020927, 0.04880475997924805, 0.01921413280069828, 0.013731141574680805, 0.008884614333510399, -0.038703661412000656, -0.0032843747176229954, -0.02146068774163723, 0.030398773029446602, 0.054984115064144135, -0.017694750800728798, 0.002321546198800206, -0.04200588911771774, 0.023059558123350143, 0.007644949946552515, -0.054666243493556976, -0.03411870449781418, 0.031944580376148224, 0.011397656984627247, 0.05127955973148346, 0.018859921023249626, 0.019306594505906105, -0.011572364717721939, 0.027499575167894363, -0.02205022983253002, -0.04435228183865547, -0.031920503824949265, 0.011869300156831741, -0.00367174344137311, 0.0018728136783465743, -0.0223626047372818, -0.0021302688401192427, -0.005209694616496563, 0.019226856529712677, -0.0011142413131892681, -0.035891685634851456, 0.04491787776350975, 0.038550250232219696, -0.024189654737710953, 0.003778797574341297, 0.02742467075586319, 0.044922392815351486, -0.007484086789190769, 0.07646762579679489, -0.03178917244076729, -0.012909584678709507, 0.007791455369442701, -0.027705449610948563, 0.02837163582444191, 0.006591828539967537, -0.039852309972047806, 0.002644141437485814, 0.022844424471259117, -0.006011104676872492, -0.0030327714048326015, -0.08110130578279495, 0.04037536680698395, 0.05195242911577225, 0.0073585473001003265, 0.04288846254348755, 0.015300651080906391, -0.016238700598478317, 0.04697379842400551, -0.00846775434911251, -0.013003205880522728, -0.021313956007361412, -0.03778200224041939, 0.015831220895051956, 0.0408656969666481, -0.0363609679043293, 0.01956218294799328, 0.066097691655159, 0.007083714008331299, 0.017723018303513527, 0.0009010948706418276, 0.006068363785743713, -0.03307419270277023, 0.026557566598057747, 0.01961422897875309, 0.017486583441495895, 0.007412851322442293, -0.00008446412539342418, 0.026877863332629204, 0.037030864506959915, 0.014912638813257217, 0.018706489354372025, 0.03314866125583649, 0.00886272732168436, -0.02035105787217617, -0.045556798577308655, 0.028037644922733307, 0.06453840434551239, -0.0018806199077516794, -0.005144776310771704, 0.031545061618089676, -0.051823027431964874, 0.01889481581747532, -0.0248076394200325, -0.013257614336907864, -0.0002455842914059758, 0.03258110210299492, -0.031133510172367096, 0.028321094810962677, 0.020336363464593887, -0.061849966645240784, 0.019223688170313835, -0.01793147437274456, -0.017173727974295616, -0.058387767523527145, 0.016712797805666924, 0.02039572410285473, 0.041764918714761734, -0.008882919326424599, -0.01916593126952648, -0.0016799846198409796, 0.0259687602519989, 0.01398289855569601, 0.07074367254972458, 0.009779891930520535, -0.055703241378068924, 0.014073017053306103, -0.05716801434755325, 0.014094540849328041, 0.03355741128325462, -0.006242685951292515, -0.0038580982945859432, 0.026894113048911095, -0.017713893204927444, -0.06331095099449158, -0.03483789414167404, -0.055206794291734695, 0.0045308624394237995, -0.034045733511447906, -0.048549775034189224, 0.03107612393796444, -0.010522476397454739, -0.033440131694078445, 0.010948221199214458, -0.05240039899945259, -0.04429929703474045, -0.03059764951467514, 0.018638556823134422, -0.0034018608275800943, 0.008841178379952908, 0.03190601244568825, 0.008259310387074947, 0.0011463233968243003, 0.024170739576220512, -0.06759820133447647, -0.0454762801527977, 0.0016415378777310252, 0.017735647037625313, 0.008249045349657536, 0.016707971692085266, 0.020070597529411316, 0.09567326307296753, 0.03371057286858559, -0.04566206783056259, -0.0662824735045433, 0.005570688750594854, -0.04794754460453987, -0.019935352727770805, 0.028079720214009285, 0.003557430347427726, 0.037002768367528915, -0.016998181119561195, -0.02430039271712303, 0.022762661799788475, 0.08527470380067825, -0.027524791657924652, 0.014966802671551704, 0.024960242211818695, -0.010230306535959244, -0.024797795340418816, 0.04850092902779579, -0.004328491631895304, 0.009949353523552418, 0.016391262412071228, -0.008769352920353413, -0.011384479701519012, -0.003919483628123999, -0.03249292075634003, 0.018810182809829712, 0.004848936107009649, 0.031575024127960205, -0.03234666958451271, 0.033575065433979034, 0.009719373658299446, -0.03644561395049095, -0.036527227610349655, 0.0398937352001667, 0.04522571712732315, 0.01575734280049801, -0.009741734713315964, 0.016879750415682793, 0.01192016527056694, -0.012261372059583664, 0.03424100950360298, -0.017031634226441383, -0.04116273298859596, 0.028234535828232765, -0.025878261774778366, -0.03298007696866989, 0.03301281854510307, 0.04573974385857582, -0.014406275004148483, 0.004468429367989302, 0.00826661754399538, -0.006746809929609299, -0.042680080980062485, 0.017911721020936966, -0.0357472226023674, 0.08131641149520874, 0.0021187991369515657, 0.037745747715234756, 0.011083747260272503, -0.017766421660780907, 0.02314368635416031, -0.01135808415710926, -0.08145605772733688, 0.018438320606946945, 0.01808813214302063, 0.0007252326468005776, -0.02204727940261364, -0.01056512538343668, 0.058385930955410004, -0.030733665451407433, 0.019882747903466225, 0.03663020581007004, -0.025133945047855377, -0.03735407441854477, 0.023918896913528442, 0.0033778129145503044, 0.03267081826925278, -0.010670438408851624, 0.026124097406864166, 0.041343241930007935, -0.02561851777136326, 0.0008426824933849275, 0.03665238246321678, -0.026046985760331154, 0.006977793760597706, -0.026094404980540276, 0.004078977275639772, 0.06100475788116455, 0.046773720532655716, 0.043696288019418716, 0.05316298082470894, -0.032988179475069046, -0.013546106405556202, 0.001645774464122951, 0.025705238804221153, 0.06060101091861725, 0.019469600170850754, -0.023916155099868774, -0.018234414979815483, 0.013528354465961456, 0.03180944174528122, 0.026863038539886475, 0.013073102571070194, -0.003667625365778804, 0.012925426475703716, 0.01825833134353161, -0.016460414975881577, -0.0011204603360965848, 0.046708326786756516, 0.012529619969427586, 0.0029321026522666216, -0.059374623000621796, 0.003911696374416351, -0.016163663938641548, -0.008383478038012981, 0.04430701211094856, -0.022871248424053192, -0.030508333817124367, -0.011682190001010895, 0.03746015578508377, -0.011504187248647213, 0.03298085927963257, 0.012203404679894447, 0.014383831061422825, 0.004935914184898138, -0.01239627506583929, -0.00936370249837637, -0.03265848755836487, 0.06137380376458168, 0.0776902586221695, 0.003228227375075221, -0.0038729433435946703, -0.08350745588541031, -0.024556778371334076, 0.044900186359882355, 0.018515462055802345, -0.021599655970931053, 0.012295686639845371, -0.03175818547606468, -0.024544473737478256, 0.024519039317965508, -0.009030086919665337, 0.06723793596029282, -0.015219070017337799, 0.010614653117954731, 0.005402686540037394, -0.02742748148739338, -0.033567167818546295, 0.02416945993900299, -0.06444522738456726, 0.009144541807472706, -0.0542544350028038, -0.010862603783607483, -0.04590824618935585, -0.03781083598732948, -0.025768594816327095, 0.08373430371284485, -0.023173978552222252, -0.021782759577035904, 0.003844147315248847, 0.005980893969535828, 0.002984157297760248, -0.007449896074831486, 0.02533242106437683, -0.012053982354700565, -0.0065492065623402596, 0.04583090916275978, -0.0025597286876291037, -0.039150405675172806, 0.04872020706534386, 0.05545446276664734, -0.011181449517607689, -0.016064977273344994, -0.0205524954944849, 0.0324503518640995, 0.021053139120340347, -0.004629136063158512, 0.0499458983540535, 0.005564752034842968, -0.036010436713695526, -0.0012165585067123175, -0.07790409028530121, 0.0011414203327149153, -0.017484653741121292, -0.029325535520911217, 0.008952902629971504, -0.015726586803793907, 0.020020941272377968, 0.023821135982871056, 0.003079202026128769, 0.012434757314622402, -0.027724316343665123, 0.01174564752727747, 0.04036497324705124, 0.03393692523241043, -0.05845014005899429, -0.02930714748799801, 0.002661723643541336, 0.017473693937063217, 0.012592757120728493, -0.02332562580704689, -0.005230376962572336, -0.02736731432378292, 0.004303029738366604, 0.05599934980273247, -0.025658154860138893, -0.03272879868745804, 0.010585981421172619, 0.000584644207265228, -0.004066681023687124, -0.005071007180958986, 0.022926902398467064, -0.03141802176833153, 0.022610533982515335, 0.02201646938920021, -0.032677456736564636, -0.01793556474149227, -0.015719829127192497, 0.0024723384995013475, -0.0017115960363298655, -0.01773299276828766, 0.006766084581613541, 0.008993463590741158, 0.00984477810561657, -0.0643695816397667, -0.020014526322484016, 0.015653174370527267, -0.039113402366638184, -0.05458863079547882, -0.05082513391971588, -0.01434689573943615, -0.021755734458565712, -0.03727602958679199, -0.013639695011079311, 0.022634310647845268, -0.017397841438651085, 0.02472606673836708, 0.011835373938083649, 0.000004010804332210682, 0.05717438459396362, -0.00009105279605137184, -0.011627225205302238, 0.07021314650774002, -0.02506629191339016, -0.04181034117937088, 0.016034923493862152, 0.010330982506275177, -0.03591630607843399, 0.030009610578417778, -0.010624602437019348, 0.013337528333067894, 0.00807611271739006, 0.006329383235424757, -0.04292548820376396, 0.01201644353568554, 0.01120094582438469, 0.0036538976710289717, -0.045064348727464676, -0.004237031564116478, 0.0051935818046331406, -0.015508580952882767, 0.01322566345334053, -0.027935940772294998, 0.0027238018810749054, 0.017886679619550705, 0.041110605001449585, -0.017715122550725937, -0.01380836684256792, 0.0157732293009758, 0.10391615331172943, -0.011372571811079979, -0.011792005971074104, -0.0021493136882781982, -0.03630662336945534, 0.05478112772107124, 0.029982009902596474, 0.026741985231637955, -0.02029760740697384, 0.02701767347753048, -0.06571619212627411, 0.011301186867058277, -0.04568365961313248, 0.046415094286203384, 0.08396803587675095, 0.011281082406640053, 0.06665235757827759, -0.0072502028197050095, 0.027916450053453445, -0.01901249960064888, -0.01699402555823326, 0.010619516484439373, 0.0036382274702191353, -0.023880504071712494, 0.05134136602282524, 0.00719726737588644, -0.016432542353868484, 0.017303764820098877, 0.01393592357635498, -0.002031523734331131, 0.04195269197225571, -0.04041507467627525, 0.015956509858369827, 0.006578613072633743, -0.051806602627038956, -0.051721639931201935, 0.031781185418367386, -0.004667699337005615, 0.0196682196110487, -0.010994643904268742, -0.03169498220086098, 0.03701118752360344, 0.04406200349330902, 0.023778017610311508, -0.08648926764726639, -0.0033771644812077284, -0.03684850409626961, 0.0121213523671031, 0.014292011968791485, -0.05811908468604088, -0.03359461575746536, 0.0510382242500782, -0.035325612872838974, -0.02035430818796158, 0.059616681188344955, -0.027517298236489296, -0.08308624476194382, -0.03763005509972572, -0.04046746715903282, -0.04374577850103378, 0.01688789762556553, 0.03176106885075569, -0.0613061748445034, 0.03166573867201805, -0.017765803262591362, 0.03564233332872391, -0.0031862016767263412, 0.03069615736603737, -0.019931461662054062, 0.04460823908448219, 0.007304632570594549, 0.01703464239835739, -0.018110493198037148, -0.026732390746474266, 0.148323655128479, 0.07954542338848114, -0.0003285189741291106, -0.047534968703985214, -0.009782100096344948, -0.03246328607201576, -0.032077666372060776, -0.03472776338458061, -0.010751767084002495, -0.020411241799592972, 0.003701825626194477, 0.02150942198932171, 0.01541193202137947, 0.01577095128595829, 0.014535300433635712, 0.02475779689848423, -0.04419663920998573, -0.032345060259103775, 0.003980719950050116, -0.0030498462729156017, 0.004158887080848217, -0.00920995231717825, -0.004883148241788149, 0.024440335109829903, -0.03724691644310951, 0.003245093859732151, -0.04207504168152809, -0.020107321441173553, -0.014366984367370605, 0.0021030879579484463, -0.02362627349793911, 0.026149753481149673, -0.02962665632367134, 0.007229996379464865, -0.0030612025875598192, 0.023497169837355614, 0.007881022989749908, -0.03236021846532822, 0.022659171372652054, 0.04991617426276207, -0.0009030926157720387, 0.00992945022881031, 0.013221708126366138, 0.010332530364394188, -0.017532238736748695, -0.007797089871019125, -0.048062991350889206, 0.06183212995529175, -0.009698358364403248, -0.0027767459396272898, 0.025696326047182083, 0.03027777187526226, 0.009563898667693138, -0.021637137979269028, -0.027964336797595024, 0.014334539882838726, 0.03631501644849777, -0.012258509173989296, -0.026532858610153198, -0.012552431784570217, 0.024257631972432137, -0.006279716733843088, 0.0314784049987793, 0.002328168600797653, -0.03378390148282051, -0.0144612155854702, -0.0327354297041893, 0.04818612337112427, -0.005055930465459824, -0.012833872810006142, 0.008965774439275265, -0.07753198593854904, 0.026581546291708946, -0.026594799011945724, 0.0175872053951025, -0.03214460611343384, -0.028209008276462555, -0.02315966971218586, -0.04354740306735039, 0.00647316500544548, -0.05997297167778015, -0.005920044612139463, -0.026845740154385567, 0.01028704084455967, -0.03298857435584068, -0.03852496296167374, 0.037683580070734024, 0.033134303987026215, 0.03680014610290527, -0.006009250413626432, -0.014611774124205112, 0.032451216131448746, 0.0023023313842713833, -0.04712797701358795, -0.045614611357450485, -0.016465134918689728, -0.010670434683561325, 0.0016610082238912582, 0.01317394059151411, 0.016456900164484978, 0.028536267578601837, 0.025174729526042938, 0.0041397083550691605, 0.030320873484015465, 0.001057727844454348, -0.003270370652899146, -0.025888647884130478, -0.05768642947077751, 0.030063221231102943, -0.007011082489043474, 0.007216595578938723, -0.0752943903207779, -0.009136311709880829, -0.013771720230579376, 0.015025811269879341, -0.00462024612352252, -0.003614512039348483, -0.027572600170969963, 0.004093077499419451, 0.020948035642504692, 0.039360348135232925, -0.018078912049531937, -0.00069523009005934, -0.02516268566250801, 0.007036562543362379, -0.024737318977713585, -0.015651363879442215, -0.019619764760136604, -0.006369218695908785, 0.012379319407045841, 0.030569635331630707, 0.047535378485918045, 0.021740978583693504, 0.025575293228030205, 0.0008307227399200201, 0.01617111638188362, -0.009158903732895851, 0.04013775289058685, 0.038709308952093124, -0.01929987594485283, -0.01337726041674614, -0.05936943367123604, -0.016638200730085373, 0.006024294998496771, -0.028543082997202873, 0.030506251379847527, 0.00812569260597229, -0.01029999740421772, -0.019027268514037132, 0.03683173656463623, 0.0109133655205369, 0.024466408416628838, -0.019271107390522957, 0.0059974645264446735, 0.03676587715744972, 0.00289161060936749, -0.008402504026889801, -0.015673786401748657, 0.03795892745256424, -0.025534305721521378, -0.004037868231534958, -0.005168575793504715, -0.04064694792032242, 0.02822193130850792, -0.006446582265198231, -0.04555496200919151, -0.0028372108936309814, -0.003577808616682887, 0.029483899474143982, 0.055230602622032166, -0.00840128306299448, -0.01636304333806038, -0.012885682284832, 0.03263719379901886, -0.07895275205373764, -0.032320357859134674, 0.015859410166740417, -0.02059115655720234, 0.016606932505965233, -0.042412709444761276, 0.011679001152515411, 0.05993416905403137, -0.06897237151861191, 0.04410350322723389, -0.0051919869147241116, 0.005312107969075441, -0.018547173589468002, -0.03932996839284897, 0.01913595013320446, 0.02048591710627079, 0.008633976802229881, 0.026957973837852478, 0.048570916056632996, -0.002597750863060355, -0.0346253328025341, -0.019049225375056267, -0.00960572063922882, 0.026803191751241684, 0.01823626458644867, -0.04500458016991615, 0.03668275102972984, -0.023976270109415054, -0.039707668125629425, 0.015977689996361732, -0.040978897362947464, -0.014840910211205482, -0.003847337793558836, 0.059558428823947906, 0.01230000238865614, 0.0502096563577652, 0.03527868166565895, 0.0035261374432593584, 0.0027162202168256044, -0.024990970268845558, 0.04076861962676048, 0.018719179555773735, -0.007365446537733078, 0.03954210877418518, 0.02740350365638733, 0.03748075291514397, -0.02755642682313919, 0.016017580404877663, -0.015049731358885765, -0.018652014434337616, 0.00772614311426878, 0.003200083039700985, -0.04151756688952446, -0.055136244744062424, 0.007260082755237818, -0.02811240218579769, 0.02813987247645855, 0.006123699247837067, 0.06658495217561722, -0.035000547766685486, -0.015581358224153519, 0.005967764183878899, -0.049020376056432724, 0.026960929855704308, -0.0030538933351635933, 0.01943754218518734, -0.034886278212070465, -0.01378150936216116, 0.021405430510640144, -0.007073370739817619, -0.017855705693364143, -0.03196336701512337, -0.08816129714250565, 0.03373241424560547, 0.02294001542031765, -0.0016136768972501159, 0.020116010680794716, 0.011469259858131409, 0.012830981984734535, -0.09735432267189026, 0.03908255323767662, 0.007433511316776276, -0.0423479788005352, 0.02282715030014515, -0.011842825450003147, -0.006902964320033789, -0.004993334412574768, 0.06075000390410423, -0.011858142912387848, -0.004717531614005566, 0.0005086339660920203, 0.02055557630956173, 0.008728912100195885, -0.05397748947143555, 0.04707397520542145, 0.02623157575726509, -0.023406947031617165, -0.01108891423791647, 0.005961254239082336, 0.015487169846892357, 0.032944776117801666, -0.005929979030042887, 0.013355760835111141, 0.0022541459184139967, 0.0113402483984828, -0.018370451405644417, -0.0208718441426754, -0.002214341191574931, -0.007082747295498848, 0.050313182175159454, 0.0016189082525670528, 0.009732648730278015, 0.004416944459080696, 0.005609380081295967, -0.06601966917514801, -0.0074553522281348705, -0.017974164336919785, -0.014847167767584324, 0.006235552951693535, 0.002542483154684305, 0.04512934386730194, -0.045925311744213104, -0.01917380839586258, 0.05254177749156952, -0.008389844559133053, 0.0003490930248517543, 0.04855059087276459, 0.021120872348546982, 0.006134774535894394, -0.00651288777589798, 0.06133880466222763, -0.007572198286652565, -0.04137784615159035, 0.022692354395985603, 0.021732017397880554, -0.027460208162665367, -0.013463218696415424, 0.04392923042178154, 0.025180526077747345, -0.004390362184494734, 0.0222643855959177, -0.04253147915005684, 0.03354358673095703, -0.02614225074648857, 0.02213701605796814, 0.03930087015032768, -0.005939806811511517, -0.0027592310216277838, 0.013018917292356491, 0.001225967425853014, 0.0847281813621521, -0.0463525764644146, 0.006031285971403122, 0.01060791127383709, -0.018094995990395546, -0.05222569406032562, 0.005477004684507847, 0.028980746865272522, 0.03236379846930504, 0.027082549408078194, 0.0005396053311415017, -0.00712733855471015, -0.014411798678338528, 0.002350328490138054, 0.0002603538741823286, -0.0006248713470995426, 0.02485695481300354, 0.01904119923710823, 0.036065664142370224, -0.01743941567838192, -0.04744279012084007, -0.05797785148024559, 0.017245160415768623, 0.040462907403707504, 0.028097055852413177, -0.030184514820575714, -0.00613087834790349, -0.005660705734044313, 0.03138972446322441, -0.06391111016273499, -0.01807837188243866, -0.0026777153834700584, -0.013784597627818584, -0.0012897002743557096, -0.047542352229356766 ]
<p>I have trouble interpreting interaction plots when there is an interaction between the two independent variables.</p> <p>The following graphs are from <a href="http://courses.washington.edu/smartpsy/interactions.htm">this</a> site:</p> <p>Here, $A$ and $B$ are the independent variables and $DV$ is the dependent variable.</p> <p>Question : There is interaction and main effect of $A$, but no main effect of $B$</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/eC58m.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>I can see that the higher the value of $A$, the higher the value of $DV$, provided B is at $B_1$ otherwise, $DV$ is constant regardless of the value of $A$. Therefore, there is an interaction between $A$ and $B$ and main effect of $A$ (since higher $A$ leads to higher $DV$, holding $B$ constant at $B_1$).</p> <p>Also, I can see that different levels of $B$ will lead to different levels of $DV$, holding $A$ constants. Therefore, there is main effect of B. But this apparently is not the case. So, this must mean I am wrongly interpreting the interaction plot. What am I doing wrong?</p> <p>I am also wrongly interpreting plot 6-8. The logic I used to interpret them is the same as the one I used above so I if I know the error I am making above, I should be able to correctly interpret the rest. Otherwise, I will update this question. </p>
36,351
[ -0.03244563564658165, 0.005646847188472748, -0.007865291088819504, 0.022738715633749962, 0.06102636829018593, 0.017558641731739044, -0.011378336697816849, -0.029227515682578087, 0.03033554181456566, -0.06695643067359924, 0.06289467215538025, -0.0004696217074524611, 0.06465402245521545, 0.02766152285039425, 0.0220646895468235, 0.020428525283932686, 0.005708323325961828, -0.02322789654135704, 0.024640008807182312, 0.023183433338999748, -0.03888764604926109, 0.029011741280555725, 0.03946607932448387, -0.010670291259884834, -0.02381119690835476, 0.0661957859992981, 0.0008473362540826201, -0.00958704948425293, -0.01732723042368889, 0.04384911432862282, -0.019862836226820946, -0.053326431661844254, -0.0017913458868861198, 0.027866411954164505, 0.028123032301664352, 0.015779828652739525, -0.02700408361852169, -0.010493524372577667, 0.021715601906180382, 0.032413143664598465, -0.03856285288929939, -0.005703618749976158, -0.016978461295366287, 0.04645519331097603, -0.022685471922159195, -0.0004760232986882329, 0.025361906737089157, -0.0041698282584548, 0.05576557293534279, -0.04217052087187767, 0.05048096552491188, 0.0051515186205506325, 0.05039500817656517, 0.038984574377536774, -0.029470067471265793, -0.03745189309120178, 0.06460677087306976, 0.07022612541913986, -0.014709736220538616, -0.054911818355321884, -0.00939103402197361, -0.020571351051330566, -0.02151159942150116, 0.01371224969625473, -0.048304274678230286, 0.02598467282950878, -0.005107701290398836, -0.016151657328009605, 0.04084781929850578, 0.00571030518040061, -0.016672680154442787, 0.05150642246007919, 0.014013250358402729, -0.041992999613285065, 0.026850512251257896, -0.015171912498772144, 0.021731821820139885, 0.038921572268009186, 0.0007678561378270388, 0.050037261098623276, -0.022483786568045616, 0.02254503220319748, 0.0351853109896183, 0.03681584820151329, 0.024151694029569626, 0.032625433057546616, 0.044244278222322464, -0.019076984375715256, 0.03485846891999245, 0.01508082915097475, -0.044884297996759415, 0.02415204979479313, 0.03960058465600014, -0.002980498829856515, -0.05323871970176697, 0.013001050800085068, -0.022638190537691116, 0.01879855804145336, 0.015970272943377495, -0.010145021602511406, -0.02216958813369274, -0.024917569011449814, 0.0325484462082386, 0.05485348403453827, 0.022680416703224182, -0.04754163697361946, -0.04447861388325691, 0.020687518641352654, 0.015647372230887413, -0.033556025475263596, -0.04021184891462326, 0.02619408257305622, 0.0096385907381773, 0.011135014705359936, 0.007256025914102793, -0.0477709025144577, -0.026329003274440765, 0.011319039389491081, 0.06854263693094254, 0.007307788822799921, 0.06984812021255493, -0.037140507251024246, 0.03193413093686104, 0.002707838313654065, -0.06016889959573746, -0.004250090103596449, 0.04575447365641594, -0.01782514527440071, -0.03718980401754379, 0.05247611925005913, 0.01643749140202999, -0.002713301219046116, 0.017424793913960457, 0.01134463306516409, 0.02519703470170498, 0.00504494272172451, -0.06387576460838318, -0.0533578060567379, 0.03818194568157196, -0.025593765079975128, 0.012465763837099075, -0.07497114688158035, -0.023524567484855652, 0.04561667889356613, 0.06260541081428528, -0.050183072686195374, -0.013758794404566288, 0.004207693040370941, 0.03734162449836731, 0.02585531584918499, -0.020154578611254692, 0.006830923724919558, -0.003625599667429924, -0.02878178469836712, 0.0014028914738446474, -0.0973377376794815, -0.004860823042690754, 0.04397009313106537, -0.0038416855968534946, -0.00685386685654521, 0.06284268945455551, -0.030343182384967804, 0.0005053813220001757, -0.029014449566602707, 0.03041171282529831, 0.010424129664897919, 0.03433968499302864, -0.017392491921782494, 0.0430905818939209, 0.036254413425922394, 0.014489059336483479, 0.025830103084445, -0.00453965924680233, 0.05856546387076378, 0.005034917499870062, 0.006463800091296434, -0.011428102850914001, -0.04767017439007759, -0.01979236863553524, 0.016358403488993645, -0.04422403872013092, -0.06650224328041077, -0.06833288818597794, -0.0049675144255161285, 0.0030767787247896194, 0.04380163922905922, -0.03732696920633316, 0.004101169295608997, 0.00277279713191092, -0.03558866307139397, -0.06017744168639183, -0.09164085239171982, 0.008373153395950794, -0.023474784567952156, -0.05954848602414131, 0.02512817643582821, 0.0024029514752328396, 0.021359454840421677, -0.045253489166498184, -0.017082445323467255, 0.01510057132691145, -0.0016165346605703235, 0.02292323112487793, -0.014825879596173763, 0.03587070479989052, 0.03934153541922569, 0.06336037069559097, 0.007913146167993546, 0.00835323054343462, -0.04913623631000519, 0.0024011617060750723, 0.047658998519182205, -0.03343149274587631, 0.04316647723317146, -0.022202085703611374, -0.049028124660253525, -0.0038945102132856846, -0.01986839435994625, -0.02042391709983349, 0.057891834527254105, -0.07036741822957993, 0.06165779009461403, 0.07926898449659348, 0.0021475215908139944, 0.007952469401061535, 0.051758334040641785, 0.035523202270269394, 0.027260297909379005, -0.05935830995440483, -0.021702704951167107, -0.041510649025440216, -0.015124659053981304, 0.011868852190673351, 0.006698762532323599, -0.009462214075028896, 0.03954886645078659, 0.03723476827144623, 0.004426315426826477, 0.02061556465923786, 0.02620811201632023, 0.003634629538282752, -0.036153052002191544, 0.0362953282892704, 0.05658761411905289, 0.02415226213634014, 0.01529387291520834, -0.0046296375803649426, 0.02454661950469017, 0.040841300040483475, -0.004862576257437468, 0.005013779737055302, 0.03635808825492859, -0.023814231157302856, 0.011464892886579037, -0.002225262578576803, 0.03326813876628876, 0.03562954440712929, -0.03736669570207596, 0.03843431547284126, 0.03757516294717789, 0.008994460105895996, -0.024777617305517197, 0.011166057549417019, -0.023156344890594482, 0.02653416432440281, 0.011685472913086414, -0.02771618589758873, -0.011472512036561966, 0.008361403830349445, -0.02728877030313015, 0.01346062496304512, -0.030789773911237717, -0.021861642599105835, -0.014037485234439373, -0.005464944988489151, 0.008152944035828114, 0.03535157069563866, 0.04267393797636032, -0.06197105348110199, -0.015372236259281635, -0.005566809792071581, -0.007612122222781181, 0.027898188680410385, -0.012203376740217209, -0.0419146828353405, -0.029087567701935768, -0.033258721232414246, -0.02137085422873497, 0.03146333992481232, -0.003868394298478961, -0.015042922459542751, 0.021245645359158516, -0.004990230780094862, -0.05628158897161484, -0.04409514367580414, -0.017776159569621086, 0.009065208956599236, -0.016068724915385246, -0.03520027920603752, 0.02533826045691967, 0.031474851071834564, 0.008866652846336365, 0.001471862313337624, 0.0060551827773451805, -0.01096653938293457, 0.009157417342066765, -0.011439173482358456, 0.01037624292075634, 0.00859121885150671, 0.007104451768100262, 0.021298052743077278, -0.037077032029628754, -0.02198985405266285, -0.0648089274764061, -0.0875849649310112, 0.037624429911375046, 0.020032117143273354, 0.03684813529253006, -0.030168602243065834, -0.03519285470247269, 0.06441789865493774, 0.015082971192896366, -0.01045268215239048, -0.04716705158352852, -0.026626788079738617, -0.024831905961036682, -0.022156327962875366, -0.008395669981837273, 0.05197566747665405, 0.006453470326960087, 0.03983263671398163, 0.008060852997004986, 0.0480349026620388, 0.025942126289010048, -0.0002646366192493588, -0.028798146173357964, 0.02145162969827652, -0.008712252601981163, 0.01496984250843525, 0.019684845581650734, 0.01763688214123249, 0.020088376477360725, 0.010509366169571877, 0.012139999307692051, 0.03353026881814003, -0.03040546365082264, -0.05361684039235115, 0.05219763144850731, 0.0023891637101769447, 0.029462726786732674, -0.05376235023140907, -0.006494850851595402, 0.015664827078580856, 0.011537286452949047, -0.022419074550271034, 0.01163718942552805, 0.06304751336574554, -0.050482869148254395, 0.008711207658052444, 0.06196661666035652, 0.006515976972877979, -0.022772639989852905, -0.026893721893429756, 0.012741399928927422, -0.021617455407977104, 0.02648898959159851, -0.027787979692220688, -0.0161910243332386, 0.030493389815092087, -0.0013438002206385136, -0.01070168986916542, -0.017778700217604637, -0.06529271602630615, 0.03546878322958946, -0.07013881206512451, -0.0004459379124455154, -0.04612400755286217, 0.01152222603559494, -0.02340421825647354, 0.044342298060655594, -0.0038087647408246994, 0.010085579939186573, -0.0001843231584643945, -0.00030565704219043255, -0.07753273099660873, 0.043009012937545776, -0.017325133085250854, 0.008609050884842873, 0.009123114868998528, 0.007461236789822578, 0.04523491486907005, -0.025791052728891373, -0.0008729029796086252, -0.04551050812005997, 0.018855895847082138, -0.031805843114852905, -0.007728045340627432, -0.038162779062986374, -0.009659373201429844, -0.0419800840318203, -0.0016844774363562465, 0.001958013977855444, -0.048708245158195496, 0.04658341780304909, 0.053932350128889084, -0.030604518949985504, 0.0008642970351502299, -0.06062593683600426, -0.03651652857661247, 0.0708007737994194, 0.030733464285731316, 0.03256034478545189, 0.012071508914232254, -0.0009392478968948126, 0.006385151296854019, 0.008151757530868053, 0.04930707812309265, 0.042484454810619354, -0.01973978988826275, -0.024841636419296265, -0.026963360607624054, -0.009710132144391537, -0.017658241093158722, 0.018119754269719124, -0.008116373792290688, 0.013801653869450092, 0.04654785245656967, 0.010684271343052387, -0.03430655971169472, 0.06143013387918472, 0.055345240980386734, -0.005776811856776476, -0.008489429950714111, -0.04593423381447792, -0.02266494370996952, -0.05833866819739342, -0.005209688562899828, 0.04485344886779785, 0.008276155218482018, -0.027368765324354172, -0.00016528218111488968, 0.05101380869746208, 0.017567187547683716, -0.009594006463885307, -0.011372336186468601, -0.008805773220956326, 0.02862422540783882, 0.029841046780347824, -0.045765362679958344, 0.00379573623649776, 0.022064246237277985, 0.028732188045978546, -0.01787707209587097, 0.011052262037992477, -0.07227969169616699, 0.010286313481628895, 0.0022461607586592436, 0.029905589297413826, -0.005892642308026552, 0.012547151185572147, -0.025894924998283386, 0.0070564295165240765, 0.0044783614575862885, -0.02774410881102085, 0.045652564615011215, -0.0022153945174068213, 0.025536980479955673, -0.036148447543382645, -0.03916652128100395, -0.055229149758815765, -0.01716509647667408, -0.007534932345151901, 0.010007848963141441, -0.016289392486214638, -0.00044350451207719743, -0.029744762927293777, -0.0073880357667803764, 0.014902612194418907, 0.046348102390766144, -0.03355782851576805, -0.019314546138048172, 0.016637150198221207, 0.012926686555147171, -0.0356433242559433, -0.047129351645708084, 0.03977951779961586, -0.0035787972155958414, -0.009515820071101189, 0.07938304543495178, -0.031118743121623993, -0.036846719682216644, 0.03836507722735405, 0.034616097807884216, 0.008979355916380882, 0.005903676152229309, 0.007780330255627632, 0.10434000939130783, 0.025062674656510353, -0.011788679286837578, 0.02453182451426983, 0.00948797632008791, -0.008065840229392052, -0.019037991762161255, -0.010965561494231224, 0.018805505707859993, -0.010929168201982975, -0.03189394623041153, -0.023607319220900536, 0.00957314670085907, -0.0001933729654410854, 0.025533903390169144, -0.0007083957316353917, -0.007463657297194004, -0.051300518214702606, -0.04504590481519699, 0.016362179070711136, 0.01307639293372631, 0.005702894181013107, 0.004219547379761934, -0.01624021679162979, 0.004519389942288399, 0.04735894128680229, -0.03402874991297722, -0.012302584946155548, -0.020459478721022606, 0.0009512317483313382, 0.019650746136903763, -0.05144830048084259, 0.01675857976078987, -0.03762463480234146, -0.02020997926592827, 0.0013842170592397451, -0.05594396963715553, 0.00802688766270876, 0.006457361858338118, 0.016938509419560432, 0.004893098957836628, -0.03520585969090462, -0.03215266019105911, 0.005667146295309067, 0.005285010673105717, 0.015695950016379356, -0.028215590864419937, 0.02410801500082016, -0.025421077385544777, 0.019005198031663895, -0.03997677564620972, -0.05328400433063507, 0.043122440576553345, 0.0012418098049238324, -0.004572049714624882, 0.003964632283896208, -0.01000567153096199, -0.00256670406088233, -0.022722607478499413, -0.015196220949292183, 0.038139402866363525, -0.05027223378419876, -0.023087162524461746, -0.004456301219761372, 0.021178271621465683, 0.062226422131061554, 0.02533525973558426, 0.013986886478960514, -0.007867067120969296, -0.027013463899493217, -0.0033672454301267862, 0.006119143217802048, 0.05405672639608383, -0.01800207793712616, 0.0030741796363145113, 0.018856212496757507, 0.013524753041565418, 0.0778927430510521, -0.010339873842895031, -0.03989800810813904, 0.001720119034871459, 0.0028131287544965744, -0.008728308603167534, -0.023404397070407867, -0.031398966908454895, -0.0005789329297840595, 0.019322076812386513, 0.020818181335926056, 0.018231183290481567, -0.02832948975265026, -0.02742961049079895, 0.00039003565325401723, 0.006591334007680416, -0.052092742174863815, 0.014585217460989952, 0.09834334254264832, 0.045428477227687836, 0.01655830815434456, -0.001964526018127799, -0.022678038105368614, 0.031181136146187782, -0.016409331932663918, 0.0035640995483845472, 0.04209105670452118, 0.028729112818837166, -0.04820351302623749, -0.011638992466032505, -0.05999044328927994, 0.019681628793478012, 0.05575602874159813, -0.018747761845588684, 0.0417189858853817, 0.05489636957645416, -0.010440997779369354, 0.01041199080646038, -0.06420966237783432, -0.004083971027284861, -0.01753481663763523, 0.01149523165076971, 0.040247272700071335, -0.030007274821400642, 0.002210204489529133, 0.03711262717843056, 0.035827022045850754, 0.0075361705385148525, 0.004043303430080414, 0.052283916622400284, 0.006254509557038546, -0.01379037369042635, 0.001064328127540648, -0.05902747064828873, 0.05119748041033745, -0.019601643085479736, 0.04300019145011902, -0.04060734063386917, -0.0015940767480060458, 0.05021298676729202, 0.015690548345446587, 0.011902078986167908, -0.06144287437200546, -0.0339195542037487, -0.04392030090093613, 0.013735727407038212, 0.008187560364603996, 0.01971871592104435, 0.033131539821624756, 0.01630694605410099, 0.009227256290614605, -0.0396704263985157, -0.002015726175159216, -0.05134641379117966, -0.03413524851202965, -0.02772684581577778, -0.025530248880386353, -0.020541196689009666, 0.058633651584386826, -0.03998788446187973, -0.03699399158358574, 0.033824291080236435, -0.04618285968899727, 0.00952681340277195, 0.004456127993762493, 0.009022179991006851, 0.011226522736251354, 0.07087217271327972, -0.004334837663918734, -0.007290524896234274, 0.02679366245865822, 0.02279411442577839, 0.09892933070659637, 0.053581979125738144, -0.0033708016853779554, -0.0672449916601181, 0.01837238110601902, -0.0014275729190558195, 0.003927241079509258, -0.03061726875603199, 0.03242888301610947, 0.028320951387286186, -0.044492509216070175, 0.02043619193136692, 0.026459479704499245, 0.04280218482017517, 0.024538347497582436, 0.07235685735940933, -0.018292197957634926, -0.0641644299030304, 0.006330895237624645, 0.011198661290109158, -0.026354894042015076, -0.023504313081502914, -0.030078334733843803, -0.016713183373212814, -0.0015685531543567777, 0.0032953033223748207, -0.007471123244613409, -0.010516619309782982, 0.00420287624001503, -0.012055841274559498, -0.011442790739238262, 0.017141766846179962, 0.036439791321754456, 0.014692593365907669, -0.036613162606954575, -0.015040283091366291, 0.03114110603928566, -0.04778450354933739, 0.0251389741897583, 0.015352394431829453, -0.03870699182152748, -0.001101495698094368, 0.02211429551243782, 0.009163989685475826, -0.009210332296788692, -0.018352970480918884, 0.005590981338173151, 0.06661172956228256, -0.008894483558833599, -0.004773134831339121, -0.01651657186448574, -0.00020721748296637088, -0.008069554343819618, -0.021250510588288307, -0.032779380679130554, 0.004598895087838173, 0.008612804114818573, -0.017832890152931213, 0.0005159631837159395, -0.029696214944124222, -0.0022128913551568985, 0.0072189257480204105, 0.025280820205807686, 0.031830113381147385, -0.013863998465240002, 0.010917899198830128, -0.03457438200712204, 0.0439501516520977, -0.014524398371577263, 0.01969417929649353, 0.019107293337583542, -0.0059173861518502235, -0.0020148020703345537, -0.032924383878707886, 0.0074426643550395966, 0.04409914091229439, 0.020986389368772507, 0.019011303782463074, -0.022165445610880852, -0.014702492393553257, -0.0374118946492672, 0.023925799876451492, -0.04042358696460724, -0.0017263820627704263, -0.03186241164803505, 0.002855349099263549, 0.014275128953158855, 0.03634408116340637, -0.010135164484381676, 0.029645809903740883, -0.003942124079912901, 0.04180314019322395, -0.004574852529913187, -0.044999610632658005, -0.0191347673535347, 0.02128967083990574, -0.013789222575724125, -0.019657006487250328, 0.01805974543094635, 0.046078745275735855, -0.020497368648648262, -0.0063553741201758385, -0.00609193928539753, 0.03070414625108242, -0.029426688328385353, 0.015615129843354225, 0.015508812852203846, -0.04238253831863403, 0.03204711154103279, 0.02064996026456356, -0.001004632213152945, -0.014265552163124084, -0.022312458604574203, -0.012781284749507904, -0.0034745722077786922, 0.020515330135822296, -0.04080631583929062, 0.00269369431771338, -0.023614512756466866, -0.012984015978872776, -0.03289259225130081, -0.020990291610360146, -0.01355507131665945, -0.0836796835064888, 0.0023058769293129444, 0.04411972686648369, 0.018185576424002647, -0.0012138372985646129, 0.027589302510023117, -0.018002159893512726, 0.021694283932447433, 0.016491573303937912, 0.010412914678454399, -0.006687643006443977, -0.033331308513879776, 0.011705386452376842, 0.0038177717942744493, 0.06366398930549622, -0.023069947957992554, -0.05564020946621895, 0.020563198253512383, -0.03188972547650337, -0.018648484721779823, 0.006162346340715885, 0.025046734139323235, 0.012712236493825912, 0.03862452134490013, -0.00967385619878769, -0.007345583755522966, 0.046256255358457565, 0.017925238236784935, 0.017876818776130676, 0.009894073009490967, -0.02467074804008007, -0.011164543218910694, -0.0448165200650692, -0.0046283891424536705, 0.034420598298311234, 0.03128783404827118, 0.014412013813853264, 0.038077689707279205, -0.005453620571643114, -0.025154732167720795, 0.00009966488141799346, 0.015599770471453667, 0.020604796707630157, -0.008591393008828163, -0.018476257100701332, 0.059550702571868896, 0.04577293246984482, -0.014512179419398308, -0.0022926831152290106, -0.013282514177262783, 0.0010240433039143682, -0.07715337723493576, -0.018317369744181633, -0.017711034044623375, 0.00436030700802803, 0.017078371718525887, -0.04724226891994476, 0.009762240573763847, 0.004166155122220516, -0.06540732830762863, -0.019593896344304085, -0.03321053832769394, 0.006872322876006365, -0.029005367308855057, -0.019337939098477364, -0.022278036922216415, 0.033274345099925995, 0.014515683986246586, 0.03652350977063179, 0.05310661718249321, -0.004053951241075993, 0.014775412157177925, 0.003951226361095905, 0.016539864242076874, 0.04035329073667526, 0.02911352552473545, -0.10381316393613815, 0.03980288654565811, -0.04908148571848869, -0.03826163709163666, 0.03218599408864975, 0.012285630218684673, 0.005175098776817322, 0.0040104272775352, 0.018441785126924515, 0.017076222226023674, 0.049734048545360565, -0.0008071708725765347, 0.001839668140746653, -0.004094901494681835, 0.0023386115208268166, 0.028323113918304443, 0.037605736404657364, 0.014278841204941273, 0.005758280400186777, 0.03435865417122841, -0.0212349072098732, -0.014595651999115944, -0.02324708364903927, -0.03429342806339264, -0.008155492134392262, -0.006615201942622662, -0.011511988006532192, 0.007062726654112339, -0.0463540256023407, 0.0033729763235896826, -0.05300426110625267, -0.032410379499197006, 0.03278902545571327, 0.0020060206297785044, -0.030218597501516342, -0.012202191166579723, 0.010793481022119522, -0.007413059007376432, 0.0020123955328017473, 0.027124224230647087, 0.01633777841925621, -0.04966779425740242, 0.01739732176065445, -0.030196448788046837, -0.008716950193047523, -0.013176647946238518, -0.014738460071384907, -0.050031185150146484, 0.021230215206742287, -0.031095324084162712, 0.004735979717224836, -0.03191862255334854, -0.05437653511762619, 0.018509667366743088, -0.06771876662969589, 0.07046627253293991, 0.02457636035978794, -0.02647699974477291, -0.049769628793001175, 0.014178458601236343, -0.03704284504055977, 0.0056948186829686165, 0.028789427131414413, 0.026628810912370682, -0.01788582094013691, 0.017800474539399147, 0.03181637078523636, 0.03722880780696869, -0.04337487742304802, 0.045448292046785355, 0.006369579117745161, 0.013211005367338657, 0.006587982177734375, 0.03519003465771675, -0.017047932371497154, 0.03647066652774811, 0.004841826856136322, -0.01232318114489317, 0.021200032904744148, 0.007377745117992163, -0.007914736866950989, -0.021999718621373177, -0.006734574679285288, -0.03395406901836395, 0.05874869227409363, 0.0063207196071743965, 0.02785179391503334, 0.04512975364923477, 0.001060627168044448, -0.04891116917133331, 0.0376766175031662, -0.016886422410607338, 0.0014630384976044297, -0.0059455703012645245, 0.004367234650999308, 0.0072741336189210415, -0.07809213548898697, 0.016466615721583366, 0.009647543542087078, -0.03183421120047569, -0.032789114862680435, 0.02038373425602913, 0.028571264818310738, 0.014647504314780235, 0.013342456892132759, 0.03849000483751297, -0.010844486765563488, -0.004236279055476189, 0.038310449570417404, 0.03272586688399315, 0.046211112290620804, 0.00401340564712882, 0.0015771595062687993, 0.04852604866027832, -0.002781059592962265, 0.022773731499910355, 0.004754718393087387, 0.00435304269194603, 0.025473881512880325, -0.027826324105262756, -0.010291246697306633, -0.029885197058320045, -0.0018163362983614206, 0.019361091777682304, 0.025329623371362686, 0.0289918202906847, -0.04673311859369278, 0.00956825539469719, 0.01999661698937416, -0.0003041124145966023, -0.02967038005590439, 0.027373548597097397, 0.043066978454589844, 0.0033077066764235497, -0.001255640760064125, -0.03964700177311897, 0.0043530771508812904, -0.000901531137060374, -0.02132660523056984, -0.0055945939384400845, 0.008824494667351246, 0.005737863481044769, -0.03159848228096962, -0.015135450288653374, 0.0007664966396987438, -0.010675104334950447, -0.05431331321597099, 0.03962093964219093, 0.055156681686639786, 0.0006823838921263814, -0.021172529086470604, -0.039619967341423035, -0.01998041942715645, 0.06137625500559807, -0.04356332868337631, -0.027164800092577934, -0.01611917093396187, -0.020878037437796593, 0.01992950029671192, 0.00959167629480362 ]
<p>I don't know how to grasp what this question is asking, nor how to attempt to solve it...</p> <p>The Polk Company reported that the average age of a car on US roads in a recent year was 7.5 years. Suppose the distribution of ages of cars on US roads is approximately bell-shaped. If 95% of the ages are between 1 year and 14 years, what is the standard deviation of car age?</p> <p>I could calculate the variance but I don't know N. Not sure what the 95% part is there for either or what to do with it.</p> <p>This isn't technically a homework question, but it's on a practice exam. I'd really like some help as to how to go about solving this, the wording is messing me up.</p>
36,352
[ -0.009733038954436779, -0.023331033065915108, 0.004666211549192667, 0.007193056400865316, 0.017685342580080032, -0.017505168914794922, -0.022610552608966827, -0.03177841380238533, -0.008411777205765247, -0.004089423920959234, 0.052434444427490234, 0.04685935005545616, 0.03686169162392616, 0.041881244629621506, 0.01625164970755577, 0.011667047627270222, 0.03174051642417908, 0.023905161768198013, -0.014597760513424873, -0.021446747705340385, -0.007487067487090826, -0.008053585886955261, -0.022204147651791573, -0.03372766822576523, -0.03145221620798111, 0.06784367561340332, 0.01933480054140091, -0.06452824175357819, 0.023270200937986374, 0.04482939839363098, -0.02886296436190605, -0.050680842250585556, 0.02501181699335575, 0.03580643981695175, 0.017605802044272423, -0.003869788022711873, -0.023302774876356125, -0.024150682613253593, -0.03192655369639397, 0.022570744156837463, -0.045585278421640396, 0.012766057625412941, 0.02855604514479637, 0.03373284637928009, -0.003833707654848695, 0.043718378990888596, 0.011416638270020485, -0.026405582204461098, 0.02700093388557434, -0.024757778272032738, 0.0957416519522667, -0.030630851164460182, 0.042644672095775604, 0.011263505555689335, -0.03910744935274124, 0.003117183456197381, 0.06666497886180878, 0.029394347220659256, -0.004149496089667082, -0.06490969657897949, -0.013422112911939621, -0.002996989758685231, -0.039462488144636154, -0.018992671743035316, 0.005756894126534462, -0.06798192113637924, -0.037942610681056976, -0.02296173758804798, 0.07113289833068848, -0.02009022980928421, 0.0005364248645491898, 0.020866364240646362, 0.03822142258286476, -0.02025572769343853, -0.004552576690912247, -0.03845633566379547, 0.049329377710819244, -0.004366735927760601, 0.008672541007399559, 0.016295790672302246, 0.0006489202496595681, -0.01813499815762043, 0.019736073911190033, 0.004313834011554718, 0.02139735035598278, -0.043258775025606155, 0.11339763551950455, -0.026615779846906662, 0.023699359968304634, 0.02806088700890541, 0.028136909008026123, -0.031299419701099396, 0.06324099004268646, 0.020925527438521385, -0.05960993468761444, 0.04254231974482536, -0.00414382154121995, 0.027254529297351837, 0.04057932272553444, -0.006504448130726814, -0.00333808665163815, -0.04583938419818878, 0.0419638529419899, 0.023818818852305412, -0.033363863825798035, -0.012653683312237263, -0.013776988722383976, -0.010452267713844776, -0.01400281023234129, 0.026852965354919434, 0.0015934555558487773, 0.012181809172034264, 0.01314101554453373, -0.028365464881062508, 0.01495263259857893, 0.002652711933478713, -0.03707529231905937, -0.02235843986272812, 0.026743179187178612, 0.04366714507341385, 0.014627690427005291, -0.019491087645292282, 0.019717542454600334, 0.011380740441381931, -0.03280608355998993, 0.02410140074789524, 0.004346088971942663, 0.012987619265913963, -0.026687033474445343, 0.057455554604530334, -0.006656181532889605, -0.020699908956885338, 0.04808751121163368, 0.031453605741262436, 0.012635602615773678, -0.01702195592224598, -0.10041118413209915, -0.09808145463466644, 0.029135998338460922, 0.008332370780408382, -0.01699843443930149, -0.05542554333806038, 0.030819840729236603, 0.0258974339812994, 0.021965155377984047, -0.014904196374118328, 0.050700437277555466, 0.012096469290554523, 0.02886722981929779, 0.051995474845170975, 0.03484739735722542, 0.015134602785110474, 0.018740510568022728, -0.03774683550000191, 0.035644277930259705, -0.06495632231235504, 0.042758774012327194, -0.0018190944101661444, -0.010858642868697643, -0.051906224340200424, 0.035036053508520126, -0.0013513818848878145, -0.03574687987565994, 0.028205662965774536, 0.002010269556194544, -0.03512526676058769, 0.06312650442123413, 0.020370490849018097, 0.012257887050509453, 0.01699185185134411, 0.007029104046523571, 0.02579442597925663, 0.017022859305143356, 0.006382039748132229, 0.05843383073806763, -0.045722007751464844, 0.00791088119149208, 0.025689134374260902, -0.03172368183732033, 0.015006298199295998, -0.024627143517136574, -0.018576057627797127, -0.00858580507338047, -0.01190268900245428, -0.017633983865380287, 0.02609773352742195, 0.01062067225575447, 0.002545143011957407, 0.014955309219658375, -0.0031675943173468113, -0.046292711049318314, -0.03519325703382492, 0.015933576971292496, -0.011413452215492725, -0.01872284896671772, -0.0054588112980127335, -0.008777650073170662, 0.009323772974312305, -0.02761819399893284, -0.031641799956560135, 0.006903096102178097, 0.02148374728858471, 0.014550100080668926, -0.06491484493017197, 0.009504563175141811, 0.06208556145429611, 0.03764983266592026, -0.029972005635499954, 0.04240398108959198, -0.03015558049082756, -0.003090669633820653, -0.015062755905091763, -0.019441748037934303, 0.0051580555737018585, 0.0035314990673214197, 0.0034522616770118475, 0.026428494602441788, -0.028208861127495766, 0.030191266909241676, 0.04345715045928955, -0.03477482497692108, 0.026331597939133644, 0.05721889063715935, 0.02971985749900341, -0.0007765928166918457, 0.043529074639081955, 0.0046554626896977425, 0.06073031201958656, 0.016222385689616203, -0.012985056266188622, -0.03457065671682358, 0.013759341090917587, 0.030397161841392517, 0.008958995342254639, 0.003548202570527792, -0.01865311525762081, 0.06912695616483688, 0.018081028014421463, 0.02132268436253071, 0.015432468615472317, -0.010344094596803188, 0.0224517360329628, 0.023058811202645302, 0.0020964588038623333, 0.02917664125561714, 0.02459132671356201, 0.014026994816958904, 0.019194263964891434, 0.040839046239852905, 0.04124407097697258, -0.02335207909345627, 0.03906746953725815, 0.03179868310689926, 0.04328159615397453, -0.027280576527118683, 0.01118481159210205, 0.06495197117328644, -0.025366447865962982, -0.004547229502350092, 0.04486609250307083, -0.004270678386092186, 0.005892518907785416, -0.002607212634757161, -0.019351420924067497, -0.0010021256748586893, 0.04591430723667145, -0.04647519811987877, 0.006312763784080744, 0.019091764464974403, 0.0181205403059721, 0.028938308358192444, 0.003888022154569626, -0.03004828467965126, 0.015258889645338058, 0.007922960445284843, 0.04655436798930168, -0.02418055571615696, 0.0233343243598938, 0.005199048202484846, -0.011805866844952106, -0.024555601179599762, 0.019062411040067673, -0.024817530065774918, -0.0010569501901045442, -0.11266747862100601, 0.013491789810359478, 0.011207939125597477, -0.017846491187810898, 0.011368813924491405, -0.0039922879077494144, -0.03929363563656807, 0.03749888390302658, 0.015831155702471733, -0.03525114804506302, -0.0070527708157896996, -0.04766275733709335, 0.037560682743787766, -0.02201031893491745, 0.0097176693379879, 0.03231547027826309, 0.021505869925022125, -0.02770443633198738, 0.0420968197286129, -0.054237112402915955, -0.024636616930365562, -0.040768224745988846, -0.014998670667409897, -0.027314212173223495, 0.013791358098387718, 0.032763876020908356, 0.008916952647268772, 0.005809968803077936, -0.0022958272602409124, -0.06773099303245544, -0.09972254931926727, -0.026123564690351486, 0.012911563739180565, 0.036227837204933167, -0.022264989092946053, 0.013856729492545128, 0.07406232506036758, 0.03272700309753418, -0.034423552453517914, -0.001686762785539031, 0.0117009487003088, -0.008862772956490517, -0.04102054610848427, 0.041152484714984894, 0.041741687804460526, -0.026165593415498734, -0.0003588689723983407, 0.019656788557767868, 0.046509645879268646, 0.03738497942686081, -0.011833143420517445, 0.009342563338577747, 0.00942150317132473, -0.033042728900909424, -0.015195551328361034, 0.02550523169338703, 0.03030097484588623, -0.028263568878173828, -0.0065985992550849915, -0.03810669481754303, 0.016106657683849335, 0.036311160773038864, -0.060215629637241364, 0.021650465205311775, -0.03311554715037346, 0.020287105813622475, -0.03641379252076149, 0.034078288823366165, 0.0003757092636078596, 0.006093138828873634, 0.0046975333243608475, -0.021210303530097008, 0.04018602520227432, -0.022481432184576988, -0.005740969907492399, 0.018660711124539375, 0.05893555283546448, -0.03300132602453232, -0.041859887540340424, -0.008977744728326797, -0.013485983945429325, -0.007931687869131565, -0.015467834658920765, -0.01030768547207117, 0.0037363215815275908, 0.03900637477636337, 0.040431033819913864, 0.013690757565200329, -0.04121749848127365, 0.014034304767847061, -0.05855743959546089, 0.0010749843204393983, 0.010536575689911842, 0.011074427515268326, -0.011699363589286804, 0.022050894796848297, 0.016146333888173103, -0.00196106662042439, 0.022510910406708717, -0.021380089223384857, -0.05670443922281265, 0.04354429990053177, -0.026248274371027946, -0.045035090297460556, -0.014275802299380302, -0.045135580003261566, -0.001137512968853116, -0.024060219526290894, 0.048365216702222824, 0.01656026393175125, 0.03413946181535721, -0.008909077383577824, 0.01811547577381134, 0.017945807427167892, -0.02442721463739872, 0.030420154333114624, 0.006736797280609608, -0.0012464491883292794, -0.0022751998621970415, 0.002998980926349759, 0.018536601215600967, 0.044785693287849426, -0.08177349716424942, -0.025282736867666245, -0.024317298084497452, 0.018764689564704895, 0.07171802222728729, 0.0012214527232572436, 0.0013696433743461967, -0.04169509932398796, 0.002958570374175906, 0.007669001817703247, 0.03912394866347313, 0.02433519810438156, 0.021579843014478683, 0.0018979152664542198, -0.033994123339653015, -0.004368897061794996, 0.02228778600692749, 0.0003297840303275734, -0.019245559349656105, -0.006239098496735096, 0.017069080844521523, 0.007605073507875204, -0.052689243108034134, 0.02745414339005947, 0.08214583992958069, -0.02162855491042137, 0.02006404474377632, -0.020902717486023903, -0.023608645424246788, -0.020107297226786613, 0.01214483380317688, 0.026920072734355927, 0.04329221323132515, 0.002002186141908169, 0.025235135108232498, 0.04798028990626335, -0.026633370667696, -0.016835583373904228, -0.011707795783877373, 0.000935838557779789, 0.03522218018770218, -0.03328884020447731, -0.019414346665143967, -0.005143755115568638, 0.012987306341528893, 0.07471172511577606, 0.009439642541110516, -0.014084837399423122, -0.08630054444074631, -0.011176823638379574, 0.003454386256635189, 0.014215342700481415, -0.03659287467598915, 0.0019688946194946766, -0.04922429472208023, 0.016859889030456543, 0.05976283177733421, -0.01145524438470602, 0.03289418667554855, 0.0002166684134863317, 0.02255001664161682, 0.008212434127926826, -0.023319901898503304, -0.043031543493270874, -0.024627652019262314, -0.036215897649526596, 0.017802072688937187, -0.016130946576595306, -0.026313811540603638, -0.024489829316735268, -0.029561756178736687, 0.05341212451457977, 0.04515014961361885, 0.013392838649451733, -0.01853729411959648, -0.028038300573825836, 0.05028051510453224, -0.034484971314668655, -0.04793599620461464, 0.030224967747926712, -0.016468483954668045, -0.021091746166348457, 0.05566123500466347, -0.011111038736999035, -0.05040707439184189, 0.03398435562849045, 0.0036593310069292784, -0.01354135200381279, -0.02587657980620861, -0.009190421551465988, 0.054331641644239426, 0.03282323479652405, 0.04499940946698189, 0.03796384483575821, 0.037122342735528946, 0.025298843160271645, 0.05771080031991005, -0.05198264867067337, 0.01699994131922722, 0.008280055597424507, -0.010659905150532722, -0.014824358746409416, 0.00009563541243551299, -0.023931726813316345, 0.034353289753198624, 0.015250795520842075, 0.04127464070916176, -0.048427764326334, -0.030894339084625244, 0.004709429573267698, 0.01833227090537548, -0.0021267931442707777, -0.005170023068785667, 0.05316276103258133, -0.008581908419728279, 0.023749783635139465, -0.006355737801641226, 0.04563099518418312, -0.023599978536367416, 0.026714952662587166, -0.005791354924440384, -0.01492060162127018, -0.0017278373707085848, -0.010696440003812313, -0.04320420324802399, 0.018805604428052902, -0.023923635482788086, 0.030843228101730347, -0.035826992243528366, 0.042869824916124344, 0.038480326533317566, -0.0451640859246254, -0.005919557996094227, 0.03985229879617691, -0.0038165024016052485, 0.08721816539764404, -0.031650904566049576, 0.041287388652563095, -0.0004253764927852899, -0.01643754169344902, -0.07071609795093536, -0.0432392954826355, 0.02228413335978985, 0.017380625009536743, -0.009619144722819328, 0.01560316514223814, 0.009583014994859695, -0.014283002354204655, -0.018234187737107277, -0.033321965485811234, 0.03537248820066452, -0.024335315451025963, 0.006201022770255804, -0.007410944439470768, 0.0471276193857193, 0.083515465259552, -0.015271900221705437, 0.009350837208330631, 0.011727830395102501, -0.02080446295440197, -0.018645135685801506, -0.037458911538124084, 0.02039331942796707, -0.026110704988241196, 0.003482684027403593, -0.0073246764950454235, 0.017941147089004517, 0.02615465223789215, -0.0238820631057024, -0.01661657728254795, 0.029554616659879684, -0.018420696258544922, 0.0010669375769793987, -0.0009271688759326935, 0.031985025852918625, 0.006086405366659164, -0.005099618807435036, -0.024614470079541206, 0.01019240915775299, 0.0005738314939662814, -0.029435040429234505, -0.006987380795180798, 0.0030177230946719646, 0.022247042506933212, 0.008904931135475636, 0.07885666936635971, -0.04087228327989578, 0.0011641157325357199, 0.019397873431444168, -0.023377656936645508, 0.03511032462120056, 0.023312726989388466, 0.010573658160865307, 0.006354381795972586, -0.020667091012001038, -0.01840074360370636, -0.056094035506248474, -0.019560949876904488, 0.002738864393904805, 0.0748656690120697, -0.006582838017493486, 0.04216017201542854, 0.053945206105709076, 0.04335019364953041, -0.025156725198030472, -0.03483640030026436, -0.05251176282763481, 0.0027091046795248985, -0.009732600301504135, 0.04741701856255531, -0.00314416759647429, 0.027198055759072304, 0.04592817649245262, 0.025867100805044174, 0.003926347475498915, 0.04987746477127075, 0.008781064301729202, -0.00924270786345005, 0.029297560453414917, 0.017791707068681717, -0.04361070320010185, 0.013381724245846272, -0.010145251639187336, 0.0168028324842453, -0.034865934401750565, 0.042790479958057404, 0.0615190714597702, -0.005070495884865522, -0.000802692782599479, -0.04357156902551651, -0.01746833696961403, 0.0001467548863729462, -0.029006352648139, -0.025355640798807144, -0.03086557425558567, -0.009999928995966911, -0.009348788298666477, 0.017591364681720734, -0.006300732493400574, 0.020358271896839142, -0.03011373057961464, -0.052267804741859436, -0.03288714587688446, -0.019444478675723076, -0.07754537463188171, 0.028097013011574745, 0.0005215847631916404, -0.023197252303361893, 0.026319824159145355, -0.014673257246613503, -0.01213174406439066, 0.013522409833967686, 0.023990750312805176, 0.005405114497989416, 0.09891130775213242, 0.025980688631534576, 0.021312355995178223, -0.006457227282226086, -0.0028241840191185474, 0.09160332381725311, 0.020408349111676216, 0.023587075993418694, -0.03600291162729263, 0.010157833807170391, -0.01671130582690239, -0.029727760702371597, -0.04098185896873474, -0.03037855215370655, -0.008644932880997658, 0.03325014188885689, 0.04203566536307335, 0.008604299277067184, -0.0008774040616117418, -0.03265514597296715, -0.00887319352477789, -0.012466170825064182, -0.02050827629864216, -0.0016832321416586637, 0.03189782053232193, 0.02941313199698925, 0.0217395331710577, -0.057799432426691055, 0.014896290376782417, 0.0002956465177703649, 0.003563797101378441, -0.02262890338897705, -0.005247622262686491, 0.011809073388576508, 0.0020908466540277004, -0.02018200233578682, 0.033383190631866455, 0.010352031327784061, -0.018944986164569855, -0.052352383732795715, 0.010964167304337025, 0.016939735040068626, 0.0022398659493774176, -0.006252103019505739, 0.06087667867541313, -0.00513501325622201, -0.03083031065762043, -0.006260698661208153, 0.0014464778359979391, -0.03975196182727814, 0.005553377792239189, -0.03345581889152527, 0.04043765366077423, -0.022524110972881317, -0.008052902296185493, -0.035464245826005936, 0.00572345731779933, -0.005691316444426775, -0.040646642446517944, 0.020291315391659737, -0.015851665288209915, 0.02016109600663185, -0.02637350559234619, -0.026806747540831566, 0.00046406162437051535, -0.028623510152101517, -0.02379019558429718, 0.020541539415717125, 0.03526199981570244, -0.002642958890646696, -0.019034411758184433, -0.07337801903486252, 0.011584937572479248, -0.006795319728553295, -0.04990801960229874, -0.027154410257935524, -0.005753068253397942, -0.022836647927761078, 0.024207396432757378, -0.0023642953019589186, 0.011721594259142876, 0.01278524100780487, -0.018559712916612625, 0.01006876677274704, 0.005612239707261324, -0.03911122679710388, 0.029341889545321465, -0.017377642914652824, -0.029037201777100563, -0.04904932901263237, 0.02207442931830883, -0.008889218792319298, 0.01933968998491764, -0.028491590172052383, 0.03348685801029205, 0.007587826810777187, 0.06746868789196014, 0.015543266199529171, -0.03715495020151138, -0.01895500160753727, 0.00007962926611071452, -0.01956692896783352, -0.012062463909387589, 0.0061895232647657394, 0.0601324737071991, 0.0007368737715296447, 0.024667343124747276, 0.009434887208044529, 0.04143175110220909, 0.009790528565645218, 0.03350525721907616, 0.04547497257590294, -0.04798966646194458, -0.010395180433988571, 0.01008693315088749, 0.00995656382292509, -0.0438179187476635, 0.005914186127483845, -0.011347648687660694, -0.06557714194059372, 0.007210475858300924, -0.024238236248493195, -0.02347671054303646, 0.03173311427235603, -0.01825815625488758, -0.01067147683352232, -0.033175237476825714, 0.01804092340171337, -0.017373615875840187, 0.04083925485610962, 0.016523823142051697, -0.009630715474486351, -0.003851759247481823, 0.056704387068748474, 0.010587905533611774, 0.0071584563702344894, 0.026637980714440346, 0.016400670632719994, 0.03576935455203056, -0.0036794666666537523, 0.002875229576602578, -0.003132456447929144, 0.04174647107720375, -0.032084982842206955, -0.011769680306315422, 0.08407972753047943, -0.06261134147644043, -0.02685702219605446, -0.004774906672537327, 0.0032999191898852587, 0.04141317307949066, -0.023662347346544266, -0.0007790328818373382, -0.019248027354478836, 0.05608046427369118, -0.05292965844273567, -0.04861636832356453, -0.03842540830373764, 0.029711861163377762, 0.018195565789937973, -0.04621561989188194, -0.032460201531648636, 0.024828776717185974, -0.024342847988009453, 0.005690182093530893, 0.05230439081788063, -0.04455116391181946, 0.022597555071115494, 0.010304339230060577, -0.0072786035016179085, -0.012194216251373291, 0.0017464424017816782, 0.043321069329977036, 0.031313396990299225, 0.05252275988459587, -0.03215167298913002, 0.03581509366631508, -0.03156498447060585, -0.014797141775488853, -0.027793748304247856, -0.07024066150188446, 0.020499322563409805, -0.015465452335774899, 0.04666312411427498, -0.07518242299556732, -0.03666206821799278, 0.018732689321041107, -0.05338738113641739, 0.03319120779633522, 0.012112181633710861, -0.050130899995565414, -0.05353280529379845, -0.0028361277654767036, -0.008356602862477303, 0.004182557109743357, 0.011214416474103928, 0.02400629222393036, 0.024754229933023453, 0.00961802527308464, -0.0191344041377306, -0.06060663238167763, -0.02065490186214447, 0.00026684137992560863, 0.036346498876810074, -0.04372524470090866, 0.023209817707538605, -0.04209445044398308, -0.007232894655317068, 0.08367772400379181, -0.0508219413459301, 0.010480253957211971, -0.0019748874474316835, -0.020476406440138817, 0.006509845610707998, 0.008482064120471478, 0.0025301703717559576, -0.009129484184086323, 0.02168932557106018, -0.0030496970284730196, 0.011693358421325684, 0.005938309244811535, 0.022200344130396843, 0.013892237097024918, 0.016724292188882828, -0.04009368643164635, -0.06072331964969635, -0.014603166840970516, 0.013571550138294697, 0.007971011102199554, 0.029253875836730003, -0.05454493686556816, -0.02835175208747387, -0.05540097877383232, -0.0011306373635306954, -0.021916847676038742, 0.0007133697508834302, 0.034383613616228104, 0.03399824723601341, -0.033169496804475784, -0.008650937117636204, -0.04992292821407318, -0.0068988013081252575, -0.0051835873164236546, -0.021364975720643997, -0.005864274222403765, -0.029850957915186882, 0.0008912716875784099, -0.03136700019240379, 0.02056526206433773, 0.013892684131860733, -0.03399629890918732, -0.03413243964314461, 0.02083338424563408, 0.028731931000947952, -0.01018573995679617, -0.00716366758570075, 0.0031747682951390743, 0.011713815852999687, -0.0800037533044815, 0.01228523813188076, 0.026948357000947, -0.013022616505622864, -0.046236515045166016, -0.01420822273939848, -0.07428956776857376, 0.01546467375010252, 0.03584488481283188, 0.023763276636600494, -0.023563677445054054, 0.03731010854244232, -0.010806135833263397, 0.008641496300697327, -0.026413805782794952, 0.057583265006542206, -0.034994930028915405, -0.013503282330930233, -0.024110494181513786, 0.011615139432251453, -0.009255427867174149, -0.015609366819262505, -0.004373159259557724, 0.027718249708414078, 0.021362662315368652, 0.0004148227162659168, -0.028302714228630066, 0.00621115742251277, 0.031645629554986954, -0.014364439994096756, 0.009187230840325356, -0.02490789256989956, -0.016168948262929916, 0.017456436529755592, 0.010204816237092018, -0.049173567444086075, -0.011961786076426506, -0.03479401394724846, -0.017594298347830772, -0.02591397427022457, 0.03258856013417244, 0.026245586574077606, -0.03290132060647011, -0.014239538460969925, 0.04172874614596367, -0.051992401480674744, -0.0494421124458313, 0.015367445535957813, 0.08692003041505814, 0.03298446908593178, -0.01237406674772501, -0.026817698031663895, -0.016705797985196114, -0.019085494801402092, 0.0018700448563322425, 0.007553692441433668, 0.032486263662576675, -0.03987691551446915, 0.013652218505740166, 0.01237992662936449, 0.0008570407517254353, 0.04168880358338356, -0.03469055891036987, 0.032996632158756256, -0.020958365872502327, -0.017110181972384453, 0.028242066502571106, 0.017681699246168137, 0.02668408304452896, 0.047605447471141815, 0.00606791116297245, 0.06657885015010834, -0.014503800310194492, 0.043067146092653275, -0.01352071762084961, 0.008298026397824287, -0.050175417214632034, 0.0032554608769714832, 0.01729908585548401, 0.02171275019645691, -0.00767461396753788, -0.005718710832297802, 0.005454484838992357, 0.03564785048365593, 0.04527471587061882, -0.03219248726963997, 0.01726113259792328, -0.035234659910202026, -0.02096967212855816, -0.048028916120529175, -0.013310273177921772, -0.012124581262469292, -0.018608272075653076, -0.006161693949252367, 0.049246642738580704, 0.015955328941345215, -0.022489245980978012, -0.014364839531481266, -0.005035758949816227, 0.053980618715286255, 0.00029030878795310855, -0.03651060909032822, -0.04303731396794319, -0.001967510674148798, -0.013571839779615402, -0.0203178022056818 ]
<p>If $X_i$ is exponentially distributed $(i=1,...,n)$ with parameter $\lambda$ and $X_i$'s are mutually independent, what is the expectation of</p> <p>$$ \left(\sum_{i=1}^n {X_i} \right)^2$$</p> <p>in terms of $n$ and $\lambda$ and possibly other constants?</p> <p><strong>Note:</strong> This question has gotten a mathematical answer on <a href="http://math.stackexchange.com/q/12068/4051">http://math.stackexchange.com/q/12068/4051</a>. The readers would take a look at it too.</p>
36,354
[ -0.04001902416348457, -0.043875448405742645, 0.0020806302782148123, -0.0036673140712082386, -0.0009027904598042369, 0.005490366835147142, -0.006624125875532627, -0.017115939408540726, 0.004764942452311516, -0.04838469251990318, 0.0726313367486, 0.06849302351474762, 0.06620373576879501, 0.019479166716337204, 0.04950115084648132, 0.012159362435340881, -0.019037112593650818, 0.008840592578053474, 0.017591752111911774, -0.00787136796861887, 0.008175048977136612, -0.008891326375305653, 0.009114200249314308, -0.010318594053387642, -0.04373113811016083, 0.05675973370671272, 0.04704529047012329, -0.01903405599296093, -0.005597508512437344, 0.1208718866109848, -0.035909783095121384, -0.014102280139923096, 0.03890538960695267, 0.05708504840731621, 0.02275092341005802, -0.0004062670632265508, -0.048050716519355774, -0.04997812211513519, 0.009718845598399639, 0.012994656339287758, -0.030570875853300095, -0.043936457484960556, 0.02655913680791855, 0.015421612188220024, 0.004091362934559584, 0.042090270668268204, -0.0056224181316792965, -0.05947498977184296, 0.011623835191130638, -0.06071751192212105, 0.06712137907743454, -0.0036864401772618294, 0.044206395745277405, 0.012351443991065025, -0.001364244380965829, 0.018178915604948997, 0.014877870678901672, 0.035562437027692795, 0.03759538382291794, -0.03640376403927803, 0.009394035674631596, 0.02708316035568714, 0.025090085342526436, -0.027133502066135406, -0.040302809327840805, 0.02819841168820858, 0.0015103074256330729, -0.010228035040199757, 0.011001368053257465, -0.0018014854285866022, 0.021391158923506737, 0.05922000855207443, 0.06240987777709961, -0.0063171954825520515, -0.0004151749308221042, 0.010041873902082443, 0.04325351491570473, 0.024195896461606026, 0.03246398642659187, 0.03120352327823639, -0.009724301286041737, 0.0011661297176033258, 0.07436609268188477, 0.03808381035923958, 0.008973260410130024, 0.007798881735652685, 0.07196325063705444, 0.01597348414361477, 0.008891858160495758, 0.017475439235568047, 0.01837196573615074, 0.025776999071240425, 0.045021697878837585, -0.027562730014324188, -0.04501936584711075, 0.04523549973964691, -0.023295430466532707, 0.03256169334053993, 0.0050534834153950214, -0.025850296020507812, -0.00655272975564003, -0.008865369483828545, 0.006174488924443722, 0.07031962275505066, 0.015214821323752403, 0.005432608537375927, -0.02728450670838356, 0.027296287938952446, -0.05000578984618187, -0.05343093350529671, 0.007743407506495714, 0.03308361768722534, 0.009337024763226509, 0.005158328916877508, 0.016096558421850204, -0.013091105967760086, 0.010420101694762707, -0.017925145104527473, 0.02504534088075161, 0.05975545197725296, 0.052202049642801285, -0.0179301705211401, 0.021324029192328453, -0.008198766969144344, -0.02738065831363201, -0.010423636995255947, 0.027155328541994095, -0.013801687397062778, -0.07083608210086823, 0.07058396190404892, -0.0009519138839095831, -0.03273706138134003, 0.014405559748411179, 0.03731716051697731, 0.019451668485999107, 0.01871367357671261, -0.07319223135709763, -0.075016550719738, 0.03814750909805298, -0.03418916091322899, -0.006545199081301689, -0.06814564764499664, 0.001123192603699863, 0.06615404039621353, 0.046053797006607056, -0.039936281740665436, 0.02790708653628826, -0.0205012746155262, 0.019935915246605873, 0.025442754849791527, -0.029169904068112373, -0.018825065344572067, -0.024420788511633873, -0.03436557576060295, 0.026839127764105797, -0.045847050845623016, -0.02443510852754116, 0.03751787915825844, -0.0016886652447283268, 0.019920965656638145, 0.04538238048553467, 0.02225596085190773, -0.024556556716561317, -0.01793910190463066, 0.02456238865852356, -0.05112765356898308, 0.08073151856660843, 0.015262535773217678, 0.02459906041622162, 0.022011900320649147, -0.014280935749411583, 0.020956071093678474, -0.011695954017341137, 0.01404630672186613, 0.04142502695322037, -0.03556842729449272, -0.02401593141257763, -0.023763861507177353, 0.02240138314664364, 0.011815828271210194, -0.0665750727057457, -0.011963405646383762, -0.025683393701910973, 0.024149876087903976, 0.0376066230237484, 0.015082587487995625, 0.007214345969259739, -0.0132920416072011, -0.048606157302856445, -0.03415829315781593, -0.03367309272289276, -0.035544898360967636, -0.0006957093719393015, 0.00699769938364625, -0.027002809569239616, 0.040395162999629974, -0.015083428472280502, -0.020450184121727943, 0.011620723642408848, -0.005370181053876877, -0.009497755207121372, 0.033928032964468, 0.05773608759045601, -0.024587983265519142, 0.011578107252717018, 0.061385367065668106, 0.07574462890625, -0.035828862339258194, 0.03082471899688244, -0.03538881987333298, -0.0669315904378891, 0.012215811759233475, -0.011459088884294033, 0.03410925716161728, 0.006107857916504145, -0.0026937229558825493, -0.0006631747237406671, -0.006521217059344053, 0.014759024605154991, 0.048029616475105286, -0.054953426122665405, 0.021746814250946045, 0.019978344440460205, 0.06487283110618591, 0.012900697067379951, 0.021199049428105354, 0.035707034170627594, 0.01796899177134037, -0.020288817584514618, -0.008094338700175285, -0.04356566071510315, -0.013028955087065697, 0.01925855688750744, 0.04080125689506531, -0.03428814187645912, 0.006367755588144064, 0.0747540071606636, 0.04611764848232269, 0.0048918211832642555, 0.01810040883719921, -0.01640964113175869, -0.009218699298799038, 0.008664370514452457, 0.014277005568146706, 0.0073038432747125626, -0.005172363948076963, 0.003330216044560075, -0.0023719090968370438, 0.03934044390916824, 0.009045935235917568, -0.007544047199189663, 0.04455123841762543, 0.004247970413416624, 0.004577907267957926, -0.045148953795433044, -0.0198036041110754, 0.04764779657125473, -0.014033866114914417, -0.002911036368459463, -0.00821675080806017, 0.003010379383340478, 0.021545814350247383, -0.0457945317029953, -0.017919696867465973, 0.013655297458171844, -0.026434682309627533, -0.05531798675656319, -0.015535285696387291, 0.015486917458474636, -0.008797534741461277, 0.026158040389418602, -0.0018117544241249561, -0.03534149378538132, -0.0038658457342535257, 0.012878581881523132, -0.0007036133320070803, -0.014149272814393044, -0.0286388099193573, -0.03640760853886604, -0.06448430567979813, -0.021115722134709358, -0.00272328220307827, 0.01428956724703312, -0.006053038407117128, -0.019608167931437492, -0.009303074330091476, -0.012056837789714336, -0.020997226238250732, 0.05244838818907738, -0.027787961065769196, 0.0037515771109610796, 0.01111347135156393, 0.00545888114720583, -0.045522499829530716, -0.018989263102412224, -0.010911008343100548, -0.015645330771803856, -0.059625107795000076, -0.05269583314657211, 0.06460568308830261, -0.03964412584900856, -0.02349868230521679, 0.0416811965405941, -0.040588948875665665, -0.01926858350634575, -0.03743710368871689, 0.007624129764735699, 0.04199599102139473, -0.02842908538877964, 0.01773562654852867, 0.021379051730036736, -0.006076140329241753, 0.0036240643821656704, -0.09262395650148392, -0.08965517580509186, 0.000776630942709744, -0.04243326932191849, 0.03415811434388161, -0.009897870011627674, -0.050016872584819794, 0.04409123584628105, -0.00038894181489013135, -0.008921950124204159, -0.015721691772341728, 0.0070493826642632484, 0.03372596949338913, -0.04630349576473236, 0.03187602385878563, -0.0018130692187696695, -0.029636362567543983, 0.05852461978793144, 0.003997196443378925, 0.004723779857158661, 0.02594941481947899, -0.006086558103561401, 0.00885583832859993, 0.006881239358335733, 0.01801816187798977, 0.00929641630500555, 0.05033499002456665, 0.026314981281757355, 0.0030637062154710293, 0.009332689456641674, 0.026714706793427467, 0.02151256427168846, -0.01152962539345026, -0.026467876508831978, 0.006913301534950733, -0.006663820240646601, 0.022952850908041, -0.05991015583276749, 0.07526544481515884, 0.014159848913550377, -0.021241407841444016, -0.006239463575184345, 0.015602867119014263, 0.014145650900900364, -0.01602521724998951, 0.01800009235739708, 0.054440688341856, 0.058628931641578674, -0.008022964932024479, -0.05133863165974617, -0.02665049210190773, 0.013890084810554981, -0.0017343346262350678, -0.014901027083396912, -0.020252680405974388, 0.022262703627347946, 0.03071623295545578, -0.009787149727344513, -0.0370996855199337, -0.00477899145334959, -0.016394754871726036, -0.05903755500912666, -0.010232898406684399, -0.0038401579950004816, 0.043559908866882324, 0.005182039923965931, 0.07163389772176743, -0.010439189150929451, -0.01738303154706955, 0.00927247665822506, 0.013486217707395554, -0.09196069091558456, 0.006766796577721834, -0.017012249678373337, -0.021400211378932, 0.0036063811276108027, -0.008218985050916672, 0.0254024937748909, -0.018820324912667274, -0.00032414757879450917, 0.010843913070857525, 0.016904769465327263, -0.03776475787162781, 0.018697191029787064, -0.025546876713633537, -0.0241402518004179, 0.010203290730714798, 0.03290180861949921, -0.00876603927463293, -0.01113834511488676, 0.03654992952942848, 0.05432645604014397, -0.02921469137072563, -0.015835842117667198, -0.008624340407550335, 0.0037710436154156923, -0.041617073118686676, 0.048024922609329224, 0.012913892976939678, 0.038909707218408585, -0.018886039033532143, 0.019048672169446945, -0.013293522410094738, 0.04755266755819321, 0.024209724739193916, -0.02513468824326992, 0.0453932024538517, -0.06174621358513832, -0.019375501200556755, -0.01725623942911625, 0.01366114430129528, 0.038834020495414734, 0.006059726700186729, 0.05140030384063721, 0.024690840393304825, -0.042654849588871, 0.0227282103151083, 0.04527972638607025, -0.019095037132501602, -0.006096949335187674, -0.017970968037843704, -0.004415519069880247, -0.027966665104031563, 0.02125478908419609, -0.0008948183967731893, -0.0074970899149775505, 0.013106843456625938, -0.019543366506695747, 0.02182234451174736, -0.006983725819736719, 0.015576496720314026, -0.048168063163757324, -0.01451158057898283, 0.03259902819991112, -0.0429471991956234, -0.03284606710076332, 0.006993734743446112, 0.005141543690115213, 0.025512780994176865, 0.014328917488455772, -0.014606447890400887, -0.03426464647054672, -0.03156857192516327, 0.030568663030862808, 0.06721991300582886, -0.012933562509715557, -0.010378077626228333, -0.01585969887673855, 0.010522382333874702, 0.03667809069156647, 0.015546823851764202, 0.03460131585597992, 0.009485354647040367, -0.025560973212122917, 0.024776477366685867, 0.007997356355190277, -0.0677826851606369, -0.002126553328707814, -0.000015808234820724465, 0.03351590782403946, -0.01827799342572689, -0.0014807537663727999, -0.031906720250844955, 0.016710644587874413, 0.05878131836652756, 0.05938592553138733, 0.0004513544263318181, -0.026296135038137436, -0.007476267870515585, 0.025546271353960037, -0.011402654461562634, -0.05562090873718262, 0.026700707152485847, -0.009500039741396904, -0.022963542491197586, 0.002118621952831745, -0.04275603964924812, -0.05152343958616257, 0.004932386800646782, 0.012331435456871986, -0.017155494540929794, 0.01869499869644642, 0.0058738114312291145, 0.06355899572372437, 0.04712136089801788, -0.006159011274576187, 0.08758098632097244, 0.06280438601970673, -0.010113119147717953, -0.0037271613255143166, -0.01407197117805481, 0.01598305255174637, -0.02576938085258007, 0.0024606024380773306, -0.025591040030121803, -0.007748691365122795, -0.04016511142253876, 0.011667398735880852, -0.027760105207562447, 0.02069312147796154, 0.009654838591814041, -0.014831622131168842, 0.009079508483409882, 0.007615892216563225, 0.000960490491706878, -0.0007016527815721929, 0.012987138703465462, 0.02539869025349617, -0.013917893171310425, -0.013911331072449684, 0.006138859782367945, -0.020949535071849823, 0.02106582187116146, 0.019455021247267723, -0.005218558944761753, 0.016881227493286133, -0.04505687952041626, -0.0024408239405602217, 0.022192124277353287, -0.04190151393413544, 0.024906663224101067, 0.01931026577949524, 0.04995471611618996, 0.027661943808197975, -0.045953769236803055, -0.00905701331794262, 0.007909756153821945, -0.007630754262208939, 0.02664182521402836, -0.028781725093722343, -0.000924798019696027, -0.018493719398975372, -0.017218302935361862, -0.07147711515426636, -0.01260574534535408, 0.029924197122454643, -0.004116565454751253, 0.011146163567900658, -0.028056859970092773, 0.035036563873291016, -0.03375360742211342, -0.022718559950590134, -0.013601823709905148, 0.07763290405273438, -0.0007751253433525562, -0.007543147541582584, -0.014315584674477577, 0.005322641227394342, 0.060734763741493225, 0.03756021335721016, -0.02532997354865074, 0.045145463198423386, -0.00828642025589943, -0.02583748660981655, -0.01151112001389265, 0.043318431824445724, -0.025461941957473755, -0.00946884136646986, 0.0023467889986932278, -0.03989929333329201, 0.006509219296276569, -0.033766258507966995, -0.04856434091925621, 0.021619925275444984, 0.016418946906924248, 0.0016871365951374173, -0.02731279283761978, -0.03717382997274399, -0.004860153421759605, 0.05341890826821327, -0.008337038569152355, -0.031883351504802704, -0.001400460721924901, -0.01642909087240696, 0.010319661349058151, 0.026287879794836044, -0.0011452174512669444, -0.004490779712796211, 0.07803762704133987, 0.0013892380520701408, -0.011122333817183971, -0.017380807548761368, 0.0027344808913767338, 0.0343831330537796, -0.02417907491326332, -0.01674913614988327, 0.023492228239774704, 0.0031054560095071793, -0.026595359668135643, -0.029396312311291695, -0.043803565204143524, -0.002741473028436303, 0.058758512139320374, -0.039822421967983246, 0.04790111631155014, -0.01334565319120884, 0.020779812708497047, -0.02394547499716282, -0.035990092903375626, -0.0018741994863376021, -0.03684946894645691, -0.005460958927869797, -0.0042413268238306046, -0.03275654464960098, 0.010885084047913551, 0.05934883654117584, -0.010288778692483902, 0.02365815080702305, 0.02358078584074974, 0.0024563060142099857, 0.008746342733502388, 0.04420565813779831, -0.027392936870455742, -0.019289419054985046, 0.021603213623166084, -0.045299749821424484, -0.007599338889122009, -0.02703762613236904, -0.03378177061676979, 0.04883415251970291, 0.0157875157892704, -0.005239167250692844, -0.003053316380828619, -0.005867986008524895, -0.03830277547240257, -0.0019787619821727276, 0.017075465992093086, 0.012578357942402363, 0.02088148333132267, 0.029462048783898354, -0.0009842660510912538, -0.029302023351192474, 0.019701503217220306, -0.016604306176304817, -0.07046154141426086, 0.007717642467468977, 0.0030505943577736616, -0.05475785210728645, 0.04144283011555672, 0.018205968663096428, -0.03527040034532547, 0.0048954179510474205, -0.03358624503016472, 0.010348985902965069, -0.02094660885632038, 0.029001008719205856, -0.015420578420162201, 0.09364762902259827, -0.012878618203103542, 0.04227505996823311, -0.047913841903209686, 0.026105739176273346, 0.09068135172128677, 0.045066412538290024, 0.04061226546764374, -0.06106981262564659, 0.0019658049568533897, -0.022109538316726685, -0.013202909380197525, -0.025524044409394264, -0.027264034375548363, -0.020726297050714493, 0.01496458426117897, 0.05354873463511467, 0.05929125100374222, 0.01803923211991787, -0.03838871791958809, 0.049543317407369614, -0.01857941411435604, -0.032201625406742096, 0.008792269974946976, -0.013377720490098, 0.006245493423193693, 0.00785376038402319, -0.03679485246539116, 0.006898431107401848, -0.021720556542277336, -0.005508377682417631, -0.07163728028535843, -0.04378960654139519, -0.010901479981839657, -0.003304404206573963, 0.008987320587038994, -0.04218467324972153, 0.05760050192475319, -0.025392603129148483, -0.01700875349342823, 0.01762400195002556, 0.007570686750113964, -0.014993674121797085, 0.027387093752622604, 0.03564535453915596, 0.022126883268356323, -0.012295262888073921, 0.04371154308319092, -0.0007355048437602818, -0.02306331694126129, -0.04837386682629585, -0.02108069136738777, 0.0358302928507328, -0.025870060548186302, 0.008931980468332767, -0.01277893129736185, -0.02497464045882225, -0.017576517537236214, -0.03434959799051285, -0.021470656618475914, 0.010994919575750828, 0.032747674733400345, -0.025156397372484207, -0.005848398897796869, -0.03710503503680229, 0.039313334971666336, -0.013003372587263584, 0.025847433134913445, 0.013254238292574883, -0.07304422557353973, -0.020408034324645996, -0.022996576502919197, 0.03606841340661049, 0.02565189078450203, -0.040864769369363785, -0.0041085658594965935, -0.045068565756082535, -0.03440224379301071, 0.01409152802079916, 0.011855365708470345, -0.03285978361964226, 0.03963783383369446, -0.011972063221037388, 0.012738844379782677, -0.004779883194714785, -0.03730766102671623, -0.006121593061834574, -0.029671307653188705, 0.014124417677521706, -0.030235303565859795, -0.02884548157453537, 0.005933412350714207, 0.008121469989418983, -0.008242635987699032, 0.009041870012879372, 0.032808877527713776, 0.06367463618516922, 0.029075855389237404, -0.019844727590680122, -0.0132552869617939, 0.0031774346716701984, -0.0202756579965353, -0.0017615844262763858, -0.036469537764787674, 0.05817749723792076, 0.0015298378420993686, 0.01888362690806389, 0.028205208480358124, -0.03332717344164848, -0.0191044844686985, 0.008406424894928932, 0.031036941334605217, -0.04184746369719505, -0.006735810544341803, 0.03718128055334091, 0.008758419193327427, -0.002673458307981491, 0.0183902345597744, -0.027183404192328453, -0.023870142176747322, 0.00026325907674618065, -0.009091269224882126, -0.06100127846002579, 0.03527713939547539, -0.048986513167619705, 0.018705565482378006, -0.009359417483210564, -0.049208588898181915, -0.04131327196955681, -0.012805866077542305, 0.01341587770730257, 0.018019145354628563, 0.005022493656724691, 0.018864063546061516, -0.03616416081786156, -0.012233796529471874, 0.03226335719227791, 0.02717728726565838, 0.018230486661195755, 0.00021478376584127545, -0.011026598513126373, -0.015785709023475647, 0.032673586159944534, -0.024484163150191307, -0.04165865108370781, 0.10379660874605179, -0.015071825124323368, -0.040632206946611404, 0.02306298166513443, 0.0062080267816782, 0.0491073839366436, 0.018361907452344894, -0.021405590698122978, -0.05831695348024368, 0.008069678209722042, -0.037335265427827835, 0.022368228062987328, 0.024580754339694977, -0.03801782429218292, 0.024868521839380264, -0.0007186445291154087, -0.018977906554937363, 0.0037760811392217875, -0.008608374744653702, 0.017950894311070442, 0.025010231882333755, -0.020329240709543228, -0.007410969119518995, 0.02610285021364689, 0.03125020116567612, 0.013298116624355316, 0.015704017132520676, -0.01411149837076664, 0.0009825805900618434, 0.024804843589663506, -0.029956741258502007, 0.026198454201221466, -0.050074685364961624, -0.02438361383974552, -0.08897174149751663, -0.006246287375688553, 0.011758965440094471, -0.00011603524762904271, 0.025892499834299088, -0.04001545161008835, -0.009722435846924782, 0.04217832162976265, -0.07476837933063507, 0.01702171564102173, -0.002054648008197546, -0.02911389246582985, -0.01667931117117405, 0.01869187317788601, -0.00845800619572401, 0.031833622604608536, 0.016625557094812393, 0.07744874060153961, 0.037965238094329834, 0.017708923667669296, 0.019511094316840172, -0.017036503180861473, -0.026371266692876816, 0.018716556951403618, 0.009723824448883533, -0.05886251851916313, 0.040513891726732254, -0.005178359337151051, 0.013268779963254929, 0.04829786717891693, -0.0059423367492854595, 0.027645250782370567, -0.02550157904624939, -0.0007202653796412051, -0.011545327492058277, 0.05588880553841591, 0.008878967724740505, 0.0016046344535425305, 0.00823333952575922, -0.0008610509103164077, 0.0039982576854527, 0.014430871233344078, -0.02937774546444416, -0.03386092931032181, 0.01875928044319153, -0.0047706859186291695, -0.04404885321855545, 0.04206732288002968, 0.024553142488002777, -0.034298915416002274, -0.014247615821659565, -0.004216507077217102, 0.00923539511859417, -0.0174537505954504, 0.045735012739896774, -0.03683638200163841, -0.019899599254131317, 0.02763216570019722, 0.01104263961315155, -0.027266154065728188, -0.009988907724618912, 0.011752632446587086, -0.03423094376921654, -0.008862070739269257, 0.009007316082715988, -0.009376198053359985, -0.05579672381281853, -0.0218091681599617, -0.009474010206758976, 0.01612270064651966, 0.020690925419330597, -0.03878532722592354, -0.03937035799026489, 0.0066874087788164616, -0.005148894619196653, 0.027394387871026993, -0.007355574984103441, -0.03217842057347298, 0.014805956743657589, -0.06742997467517853, 0.04568026587367058, 0.02104073390364647, 0.0012105379719287157, -0.035721056163311005, -0.022424979135394096, 0.01424015499651432, -0.03431897982954979, 0.07739204913377762, 0.020714368671178818, -0.03872247040271759, 0.0019562821835279465, 0.0342765636742115, 0.025063438341021538, -0.03656066581606865, 0.03187616914510727, -0.045463524758815765, -0.019613487645983696, -0.039143916219472885, -0.014607980847358704, 0.0414009690284729, 0.0077486177906394005, 0.032770149409770966, -0.02783072367310524, 0.015086629427969456, -0.026278464123606682, -0.005854600574821234, 0.03786332532763481, 0.015079284086823463, -0.02353392168879509, 0.05248476564884186, 0.006686100270599127, 0.03658260405063629, -0.022573262453079224, 0.01635892689228058, -0.05385800078511238, -0.004216284956783056, -0.04756774380803108, -0.03344812989234924, 0.006120089441537857, 0.029756149277091026, 0.0067962221801280975, -0.07031930983066559, -0.024206746369600296, 0.03797191008925438, -0.03783354535698891, -0.026692073792219162, 0.0464886873960495, 0.026194855570793152, 0.029325494542717934, 0.0344373881816864, 0.03106757625937462, 0.004316222853958607, -0.004539484158158302, 0.011648811399936676, 0.009113729000091553, 0.04919038340449333, -0.0072050997987389565, 0.00996367447078228, 0.024746499955654144, -0.017390649765729904, 0.06966029107570648, -0.004179880488663912, 0.01263999380171299, -0.028631320223212242, -0.0239711906760931, 0.013107684440910816, 0.0066530401818454266, -0.012330416589975357, -0.0019035094883292913, -0.019513946026563644, 0.06021009758114815, -0.0051635392010211945, 0.02409961447119713, -0.03621518239378929, 0.03226398676633835, -0.003133955877274275, -0.03012116439640522, 0.026927785947918892, -0.006724548991769552, -0.00223667174577713, -0.009713784791529179, 0.016436636447906494, -0.0001935745240189135, 0.013268432579934597, -0.03377467021346092, 0.04688055068254471, 0.0037964556831866503, -0.02314162254333496, -0.020840352401137352, -0.01416703313589096, -0.013823707588016987, -0.03657115250825882, 0.0466420017182827, 0.03666926547884941, 0.01932554319500923, 0.022601637989282608, -0.0011445300187915564, 0.011259855702519417, 0.0722462460398674, -0.07640038430690765, 0.020639287307858467, -0.04508296027779579, 0.0036208252422511578, 0.015830757096409798, -0.030085710808634758 ]
<p>I am trying to compute the standard error of the sample <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spectral_risk_measure" rel="nofollow">spectral risk measure</a>, which is used as a metric for portfolio risk. Briefly, a sample spectral risk measure is defined as $q = \sum_i w_i x_{(i)}$, where $x_{(i)}$ are the sample order statistics, and $w_i$ is a sequence of monotonically non-increasing non-negative weights that sum to $1$. I would like to compute the standard error of $q$ (preferrably not via bootstrap). I don't know much about L-estimators, but it looks to me like $q$ is a kind of L-estimator (but with extra restrictions imposed on the weights $w_i$), so this should probably be an easily solved problem. </p> <p><strong>edit</strong>: per @srikant's question, I should note that the weights $w_i$ are chosen <em>a priori</em> by the user, and should be considered independent from the samples $x$.</p>
36,355
[ -0.015681089833378792, -0.010382606647908688, -0.009568345732986927, -0.015690617263317108, 0.02709834836423397, 0.016289105638861656, -0.016617780551314354, -0.009590147994458675, 0.022007279098033905, -0.06257951259613037, 0.042265307158231735, 0.04836476221680641, 0.10462538152933121, 0.03747935965657234, 0.013312784023582935, 0.005993615835905075, -0.032991938292980194, 0.012859567068517208, 0.01174816582351923, -0.01651848666369915, 0.013272492215037346, 0.04409459978342056, 0.008386263623833656, 0.02103996090590954, -0.0508156381547451, 0.011927906423807144, 0.00782188680022955, -0.03172244504094124, 0.012812943197786808, 0.08054456859827042, -0.06005976349115372, -0.0175115168094635, 0.005675613880157471, 0.04724578559398651, 0.0005915788933634758, 0.019611511379480362, -0.046820998191833496, -0.024472277611494064, -0.008567760698497295, 0.021633431315422058, -0.037920042872428894, -0.030514845624566078, 0.004015281796455383, 0.013967946171760559, -0.004326727241277695, 0.0090705007314682, -0.01665550284087658, -0.08261051028966904, 0.01930718682706356, -0.017782511189579964, 0.10082163661718369, 0.012328626587986946, 0.005145950708538294, 0.0031341672874987125, -0.008461343124508858, -0.0090786749497056, 0.0037233682814985514, 0.050285786390304565, 0.013022223487496376, -0.0247944463044405, -0.05997554212808609, -0.015938827767968178, 0.02277837134897709, -0.008241555653512478, -0.042640119791030884, -0.01493577379733324, -0.0248830858618021, -0.032615721225738525, 0.054981768131256104, -0.027597619220614433, -0.012365076690912247, 0.037755876779556274, 0.023213783279061317, -0.004445090424269438, -0.022943753749132156, -0.016690358519554138, -0.036502595990896225, 0.04142799228429794, 0.07260195910930634, 0.0024989985395222902, 0.020251253619790077, 0.017211753875017166, 0.018082961440086365, 0.03301781043410301, -0.004138072952628136, 0.0005035854992456734, 0.08658333122730255, -0.003376772627234459, 0.017866818234324455, -0.0006361829000525177, 0.011546159163117409, -0.03534889221191406, 0.02427138015627861, -0.03994414955377579, -0.019297977909445763, 0.020804395899176598, -0.06142274662852287, 0.004946049302816391, 0.005910814274102449, -0.029940085485577583, 0.02487025037407875, -0.05593990907073021, 0.018376274034380913, 0.04215836152434349, 0.008611883968114853, 0.0035954322665929794, 0.02855130471289158, 0.011155340820550919, -0.02025515027344227, -0.05808919295668602, 0.00043833034578710794, 0.019137851893901825, -0.008394937962293625, -0.02584545686841011, -0.015536167658865452, 0.008481056429445744, -0.0033323520328849554, -0.0013613299233838916, 0.020561233162879944, 0.07522819936275482, 0.03262375667691231, -0.0020492204930633307, 0.021207477897405624, -0.01673198863863945, -0.03644226863980293, 0.05243583396077156, 0.023697195574641228, -0.044180791825056076, -0.057980287820100784, 0.061456046998500824, 0.037905965000391006, -0.04622926190495491, 0.04187281057238579, 0.011572313494980335, 0.00801756326109171, -0.0004046188551001251, -0.10782381147146225, -0.05466105416417122, 0.03827784210443497, -0.022113099694252014, 0.014929196797311306, -0.048009343445301056, -0.04326869919896126, 0.04985259100794792, 0.06060294806957245, 0.043657705187797546, 0.08436258882284164, 0.022788245230913162, 0.03960391506552696, 0.046016279608011246, -0.0411350280046463, -0.003255401970818639, -0.03288636729121208, -0.015161502175033092, 0.000832791905850172, -0.06413640081882477, -0.01923234574496746, 0.012663810513913631, -0.028226057067513466, -0.021785223856568336, 0.02768547274172306, 0.02718707174062729, -0.007453541271388531, -0.00789062399417162, 0.0036021575797349215, -0.05402100458741188, 0.03795010969042778, 0.030520277097821236, -0.0033894984517246485, -0.021024644374847412, -0.01126518752425909, -0.04052157700061798, 0.03261609002947807, 0.022422555834054947, 0.05469167232513428, -0.05277625471353531, 0.018534522503614426, -0.0651770830154419, 0.03813333809375763, 0.014238419942557812, -0.02377697266638279, -0.009417899884283543, 0.008274304680526257, -0.0061215488240122795, 0.033113233745098114, 0.030406443402171135, 0.0008402719395235181, -0.028934519737958908, 0.026917248964309692, -0.020492980256676674, -0.02008391171693802, -0.03945292532444, 0.003822116646915674, -0.0035834244918078184, -0.020890677347779274, 0.03186031058430672, -0.015391556546092033, 0.035774022340774536, -0.001717621460556984, 0.001416481682099402, 0.01967766135931015, 0.0048347958363592625, 0.020172199234366417, -0.04503513500094414, 0.0016763681778684258, 0.03546193242073059, 0.07274733483791351, -0.0028325270395725965, 0.02181200683116913, -0.022555869072675705, -0.05490432679653168, 0.002024819841608405, -0.025319397449493408, 0.02487562969326973, -0.014174822717905045, -0.024164598435163498, 0.01572374626994133, -0.03227752819657326, 0.01221971120685339, 0.03340492397546768, -0.025193551555275917, 0.07326173037290573, 0.07159396260976791, -0.012341318652033806, -0.03477810323238373, 0.03386680409312248, 0.03097105212509632, 0.01735660806298256, -0.00740475719794631, -0.0017199494177475572, -0.0021904902532696724, 0.006235568318516016, 0.049133725464344025, 0.035402119159698486, -0.024661945179104805, -0.02254664897918701, 0.07262381911277771, 0.012701400555670261, -0.003556707873940468, 0.0354803204536438, -0.021661536768078804, -0.042702604085206985, 0.018868833780288696, 0.00567525764927268, 0.017529912292957306, -0.015247815288603306, -0.03392612561583519, -0.004624094348400831, 0.04568648338317871, -0.013037417083978653, -0.00010177779768127948, 0.020462438464164734, -0.03545470908284187, 0.006037612445652485, -0.012613300234079361, -0.04633946344256401, 0.06230348348617554, -0.0224036555737257, 0.011733795516192913, 0.03851907327771187, -0.043274566531181335, 0.012531491927802563, -0.002728888997808099, -0.025494765490293503, 0.009605169296264648, -0.007528452202677727, -0.02139998972415924, 0.006023370660841465, 0.016509469598531723, -0.01828232780098915, -0.0023647923953831196, -0.014404094778001308, -0.007216631434857845, 0.01220623403787613, 0.016320765018463135, 0.02000189758837223, -0.009575341828167439, -0.029035573825240135, -0.03283492848277092, -0.05165666714310646, 0.009009440429508686, -0.011562477797269821, 0.026086503639817238, 0.028647758066654205, -0.03815505653619766, -0.0003336764930281788, -0.003912094980478287, -0.026599368080496788, 0.023211095482110977, 0.00918316189199686, 0.027056485414505005, 0.016293467953801155, 0.004933016374707222, -0.0015580729814246297, -0.010868828743696213, -0.030035464093089104, 0.001123337890021503, -0.009287026710808277, -0.007331618573516607, 0.06402337551116943, -0.006504578050225973, -0.042922403663396835, 0.030281823128461838, -0.04301750659942627, 0.0003427061310503632, -0.06702524423599243, 0.004632479511201382, 0.001480862614698708, -0.028522226959466934, -0.005790465045720339, 0.02458050847053528, -0.007397481240332127, -0.00471544498577714, -0.07190752029418945, -0.06173427775502205, 0.003501801285892725, 0.00637784181162715, 0.00008422657992923632, 0.0368097685277462, -0.04433271288871765, 0.077721007168293, 0.026481451466679573, -0.02756970189511776, -0.031410135328769684, -0.014626034535467625, 0.007788919378072023, -0.03204214945435524, 0.024053432047367096, -0.025982972234487534, -0.00908318255096674, 0.03255336731672287, -0.0001376124273519963, 0.01342497393488884, 0.04579294100403786, -0.0023837352637201548, 0.00959057081490755, 0.029227089136838913, -0.04550206661224365, 0.01352589949965477, 0.060983963310718536, 0.017457686364650726, 0.02919473499059677, -0.0008017084328457713, 0.03415582701563835, 0.01766427792608738, 0.022013289853930473, -0.04830414056777954, 0.025234660133719444, -0.029274798929691315, -0.016778869554400444, -0.019413193687796593, 0.08291532099246979, -0.002343342872336507, -0.006758226081728935, -0.009178105741739273, 0.009396840818226337, -0.023180721327662468, -0.0049254316836595535, 0.019919095560908318, 0.01422414556145668, 0.04694103077054024, -0.01886591501533985, -0.03533162921667099, -0.018609846010804176, -0.01887720637023449, 0.009490923956036568, -0.049918580800294876, -0.04035312682390213, -0.004218130838125944, 0.0822351723909378, 0.022968461737036705, -0.0421021431684494, -0.053657691925764084, 0.026958055794239044, -0.0376562736928463, 0.02331284061074257, 0.0044602276757359505, 0.08066447824239731, 0.009510188363492489, 0.028648948296904564, 0.0011663297191262245, 0.0014869696460664272, 0.0174816083163023, -0.005895235110074282, -0.04325282201170921, 0.039364662021398544, 0.008879345841705799, 0.0023811059072613716, 0.014575115405023098, 0.011974485591053963, 0.016763338819146156, -0.0330575555562973, 0.0020561926066875458, -0.01849418692290783, 0.024803077802062035, -0.016599319875240326, -0.010373334400355816, -0.0336281843483448, -0.00803608912974596, 0.028028948232531548, -0.010939184576272964, 0.0065623498521745205, -0.06176909804344177, 0.013849071227014065, 0.03811320289969444, -0.006765497848391533, -0.016453817486763, -0.0014679096639156342, 0.04410317912697792, 0.01362638734281063, 0.0176768209785223, 0.03962721675634384, 0.028128186240792274, -0.03657010570168495, 0.06441789120435715, -0.0220317505300045, 0.044460542500019073, 0.032629381865262985, -0.003864557947963476, 0.025627147406339645, -0.048844799399375916, -0.01643195003271103, 0.027308760210871696, 0.0010924974922090769, -0.006846440024673939, 0.010635255835950375, 0.07294027507305145, 0.009368556551635265, -0.08588694781064987, -0.00016977268387563527, 0.05492561310529709, 0.008303825743496418, -0.005683056078851223, -0.0054780226200819016, 0.026426462456583977, 0.00600046943873167, -0.010240674950182438, 0.040153756737709045, -0.0002626106725074351, -0.013934044167399406, 0.026386238634586334, 0.01447226945310831, -0.008091572672128677, -0.01570451818406582, -0.004924374632537365, 0.03414943069219589, 0.04960864409804344, -0.0055083720944821835, -0.057470038533210754, 0.02537967637181282, -0.006799308583140373, 0.06557993590831757, 0.013617760501801968, 0.028273360803723335, -0.08340851217508316, 0.02163839153945446, 0.03191395476460457, 0.049865107983350754, -0.023459939286112785, 0.005449713207781315, -0.03850831836462021, -0.020281126722693443, 0.03926505520939827, -0.015324714593589306, 0.03419516608119011, 0.010045706294476986, 0.01969912275671959, -0.012628247030079365, -0.01805134117603302, -0.028579508885741234, 0.018882600590586662, 0.0008525296580046415, 0.00697251595556736, -0.0023950301110744476, -0.018428441137075424, -0.056719791144132614, -0.0011471589095890522, 0.02689945325255394, 0.044076137244701385, -0.04015171155333519, 0.004796949680894613, -0.011818910948932171, 0.06119106337428093, -0.021631289273500443, -0.0702136754989624, 0.0006341877742670476, -0.00189208984375, -0.02682865411043167, 0.02239527739584446, -0.022986216470599174, -0.06470081210136414, 0.02398787811398506, 0.04378321021795273, -0.020492207258939743, -0.005408568307757378, 0.0038724371697753668, 0.026746680960059166, 0.05516284704208374, 0.03578469157218933, 0.05457543581724167, 0.01854928769171238, 0.018334420397877693, 0.03652241453528404, -0.018855875357985497, 0.04253063350915909, -0.02777242846786976, -0.003873647190630436, -0.03882276266813278, 0.0001135472921305336, -0.03794226422905922, 0.0423637256026268, 0.001953679136931896, 0.02131723240017891, -0.007458872627466917, -0.022273989394307137, -0.006398573983460665, -0.0018953534308820963, -0.005005091894418001, -0.0053688096813857555, 0.023359525948762894, 0.031199529767036438, -0.024285180494189262, 0.023702247068285942, -0.0026070792227983475, -0.013338415883481503, -0.02331383340060711, -0.016342226415872574, -0.021647602319717407, -0.012715802527964115, -0.012060964480042458, 0.004837513901293278, -0.025897091254591942, 0.02913730964064598, 0.08052791655063629, -0.0013530236901715398, 0.038082610815763474, -0.04439498484134674, -0.018023895099759102, 0.007058636285364628, 0.009720725007355213, -0.005742963403463364, 0.009944746270775795, -0.06255451589822769, 0.002756055910140276, 0.02964973822236061, -0.022315772250294685, -0.08371798694133759, -0.020917342975735664, 0.0316951759159565, 0.02458086796104908, -0.024297567084431648, -0.03998534381389618, 0.01575886458158493, 0.006218298804014921, -0.031119633466005325, -0.0292199719697237, 0.04226145148277283, -0.008149871602654457, -0.031717345118522644, -0.0058292499743402, 0.016926638782024384, 0.060472339391708374, -0.026721373200416565, 0.01907501555979252, 0.0031015167478471994, -0.024221260100603104, -0.027410631999373436, -0.03293812274932861, 0.016215410083532333, -0.04457436129450798, -0.0033574248664081097, -0.012038253247737885, -0.046613890677690506, 0.015735629945993423, -0.025147590786218643, -0.05100742727518082, 0.013069677166640759, 0.00862948503345251, 0.007785695139318705, -0.027491847053170204, -0.01158799696713686, -0.011614714749157429, 0.019513890147209167, -0.04227978363633156, -0.005826548673212528, -0.009897710755467415, 0.007280529476702213, 0.02577665075659752, 0.004928683862090111, -0.02671596221625805, 0.015394437126815319, 0.05271020159125328, 0.014385748654603958, -0.012336126528680325, 0.013568932190537453, -0.03408902511000633, 0.026441579684615135, 0.008797974325716496, 0.0026992233470082283, 0.02491779252886772, -0.022148050367832184, -0.03086548112332821, -0.05217414349317551, -0.030783379450440407, 0.037696100771427155, 0.07123538106679916, 0.016220420598983765, 0.04659436270594597, 0.04127354547381401, -0.0009514205739833415, -0.009084189310669899, 0.009484361857175827, -0.05079580098390579, 0.013456173241138458, 0.002419879660010338, 0.0333433598279953, 0.006368871778249741, 0.02757537178695202, -0.0000069274083216441795, 0.0073766508139669895, -0.006402501370757818, 0.0015685135731473565, 0.000010812103937496431, 0.033917538821697235, 0.02668566256761551, -0.002297024941071868, -0.028242796659469604, 0.030614541843533516, -0.02401875890791416, 0.0005384631222113967, -0.04526740685105324, -0.01643393747508526, 0.03527485206723213, 0.0017667084466665983, 0.011205652728676796, -0.007725392933934927, -0.04778473451733589, -0.039779648184776306, 0.026654694229364395, 0.00681862561032176, -0.007772847078740597, 0.049295369535684586, 0.005815016105771065, -0.021215148270130157, -0.009302301332354546, 0.047627042979002, -0.0356166735291481, -0.07411334663629532, -0.016932830214500427, -0.019921116530895233, -0.053681012243032455, 0.04838740453124046, 0.02714451588690281, -0.009419373236596584, 0.018452763557434082, -0.045202162116765976, 0.04120204225182533, 0.02163948304951191, 0.04359395056962967, -0.00712135573849082, 0.06885457038879395, -0.00612257793545723, 0.013346409425139427, -0.00879906490445137, 0.0043463874608278275, 0.10168247669935226, 0.0858052596449852, 0.05590727552771568, -0.066718690097332, -0.009822227992117405, 0.0018434454686939716, -0.009423377923667431, -0.005938996095210314, 0.013796834275126457, -0.005721420980989933, -0.031226346269249916, -0.023983286693692207, 0.05391940847039223, -0.02280011959373951, -0.027608290314674377, 0.0491548553109169, -0.042734600603580475, 0.023689143359661102, 0.030324604362249374, -0.03229842334985733, 0.0008181108278222382, 0.004356082994490862, -0.0620601549744606, 0.01798308454453945, 0.008370768278837204, -0.0021770477760583162, -0.020539525896310806, -0.034516263753175735, -0.030303921550512314, -0.04426828399300575, 0.011065136641263962, 0.002508512930944562, 0.022555427625775337, -0.010606554336845875, -0.010870814323425293, 0.026711871847510338, 0.00443338742479682, -0.026474669575691223, 0.03294409438967705, -0.002125967526808381, 0.019391370937228203, 0.0017557127866894007, -0.020506972447037697, 0.008296777494251728, -0.0446019321680069, -0.044746071100234985, -0.02069980278611183, -0.018277039751410484, -0.010908761993050575, 0.010858460329473019, -0.05081774294376373, -0.018652718514204025, -0.016363011673092842, -0.04143045097589493, 0.009794670157134533, -0.001888285856693983, 0.027662882581353188, -0.03203548491001129, -0.003827515058219433, -0.01578482612967491, -0.018302178010344505, -0.026751471683382988, 0.029317526146769524, 0.036509133875370026, -0.06601514667272568, -0.025382686406373978, -0.0015529848169535398, -0.0036504773888736963, 0.007308888714760542, -0.013548271730542183, -0.023354988545179367, -0.01332092471420765, -0.03647913038730621, -0.024921534582972527, -0.021916750818490982, -0.016445418819785118, 0.07250279188156128, -0.007469580974429846, -0.010018935427069664, -0.01833387091755867, -0.07528384029865265, 0.0015074636321514845, -0.03831394016742706, -0.036738596856594086, -0.035680945962667465, -0.011894227005541325, 0.00767558254301548, 0.03936572000384331, -0.014236894436180592, -0.03225642442703247, 0.026547575369477272, 0.03993977978825569, 0.004230855032801628, -0.03553769737482071, 0.013163338415324688, 0.010638183914124966, -0.008398863486945629, 0.000418011040892452, 0.0030803384725004435, 0.07187572866678238, 0.027247069403529167, 0.026775773614645004, -0.0236305333673954, 0.013283297419548035, -0.034222692251205444, 0.003378841793164611, 0.0001629480393603444, -0.04675867781043053, 0.010520018637180328, 0.024737611413002014, -0.022631753236055374, -0.0198714230209589, -0.011081092990934849, -0.03744534030556679, -0.031792234629392624, 0.017758073285222054, -0.02779896929860115, -0.06384655833244324, 0.010525473393499851, 0.0012223310768604279, 0.004761406686156988, -0.026519717648625374, 0.006685750558972359, 0.032124489545822144, 0.02653222531080246, -0.025962287560105324, 0.025971969589591026, -0.0467291921377182, 0.028569664806127548, -0.014340280555188656, -0.023971300572156906, -0.0012566272635012865, 0.020799431949853897, 0.04118714854121208, -0.00784251093864441, -0.011595507152378559, 0.005226521287113428, 0.06337527930736542, -0.004687606357038021, -0.00043159417691640556, 0.04081668704748154, -0.032388463616371155, -0.005898773204535246, 0.03470377251505852, -0.015675337985157967, 0.018939916044473648, 0.03278117626905441, -0.008932067081332207, -0.028782278299331665, -0.0021541991736739874, -0.008175783790647984, -0.013014382682740688, -0.013523532077670097, 0.001216223114170134, -0.004559382796287537, -0.0008378766942769289, 0.01410819310694933, 0.0029082370456308126, 0.01795692928135395, -0.007489968556910753, 0.04786834865808487, -0.05236139893531799, -0.012221984565258026, 0.04561716690659523, -0.004705990664660931, 0.025460172444581985, 0.012127446942031384, -0.004505844786763191, 0.033329952508211136, 0.043556444346904755, -0.031975001096725464, 0.02429240569472313, -0.056148942559957504, -0.016763104125857353, -0.09204666316509247, 0.01479843258857727, 0.01030762866139412, 0.019624244421720505, 0.035650841891765594, -0.06597481667995453, -0.001303432509303093, 0.05554467439651489, -0.037558168172836304, 0.043156206607818604, -0.0000701302124070935, 0.0001986845745705068, -0.061637792736291885, 0.02800513431429863, -0.040704041719436646, 0.01810157671570778, 0.02316446602344513, 0.009968754835426807, 0.045657411217689514, 0.03885293006896973, 0.021741587668657303, -0.0032716484274715185, -0.020023733377456665, 0.007207682356238365, 0.0315338633954525, -0.05596531555056572, 0.023228844627738, -0.010833606123924255, -0.004449870903044939, 0.040895428508520126, 0.04456799849867821, 0.01898052729666233, 0.02503042109310627, 0.06015460938215256, -0.02738877199590206, 0.039560556411743164, 0.024491993710398674, -0.00988440029323101, 0.006101596634835005, 0.00005705789590138011, 0.03843100741505623, 0.015285511501133442, -0.022350730374455452, 0.015491196885704994, 0.04744556173682213, -0.011192318052053452, -0.011225560680031776, 0.035670723766088486, 0.007149717770516872, -0.0008405563421547413, 0.004142462741583586, -0.03237200528383255, -0.003946981392800808, -0.03950544446706772, 0.040093254297971725, 0.027283331379294395, 0.01154846791177988, 0.019570788368582726, 0.0360652320086956, -0.02812434732913971, 0.005048434250056744, 0.0016613593325018883, -0.0819152444601059, 0.038416534662246704, -0.011055506765842438, -0.047319259494543076, -0.0524045005440712, -0.00319640408270061, -0.0012424456654116511, -0.009641162119805813, -0.021185459569096565, 0.007216532249003649, -0.005053792614489794, 0.04367198422551155, -0.04001128301024437, -0.004783678334206343, 0.011437221430242062, 0.02454928494989872, 0.021081285551190376, -0.1033785417675972, 0.10427583754062653, 0.01317199319601059, 0.008425898849964142, 0.011998455971479416, 0.01932350918650627, 0.003059233771637082, 0.000664639170281589, 0.02651025913655758, -0.005289154592901468, -0.024871809408068657, 0.024056239053606987, 0.05130797624588013, 0.01199559960514307, -0.03283146396279335, 0.015342377126216888, -0.042970966547727585, 0.005201153922826052, -0.026158759370446205, -0.018424542620778084, 0.015926944091916084, 0.00530995661392808, 0.006328335031867027, -0.022596918046474457, -0.02448878064751625, -0.017971239984035492, 0.014290804043412209, 0.05610307678580284, 0.0024700057692825794, -0.01499618124216795, 0.06429263949394226, -0.0029770666733384132, -0.013536951504647732, 0.014187643304467201, -0.03868860751390457, -0.04785844311118126, 0.0368909016251564, -0.023620424792170525, -0.02854175865650177, -0.0006004378665238619, 0.014136489480733871, 0.023916373029351234, -0.04318720102310181, -0.029131712391972542, 0.024275943636894226, -0.025254251435399055, -0.012732330709695816, 0.043334461748600006, 0.024733785539865494, 0.02949092909693718, 0.032125771045684814, 0.001158565515652299, 0.014109527692198753, 0.011817584745585918, 0.012725758366286755, 0.01769964024424553, 0.04320535808801651, 0.0077580115757882595, 0.028670379891991615, -0.00555155286565423, -0.039466019719839096, 0.034102387726306915, -0.012446903623640537, -0.002402358455583453, -0.0417124480009079, -0.04173422232270241, 0.029415421187877655, 0.010783692821860313, 0.00911622028797865, -0.0318133607506752, -0.03409794718027115, 0.05972087010741234, -0.017481401562690735, 0.04191690310835838, -0.011573095805943012, 0.013171115890145302, -0.026948895305395126, -0.028475863859057426, -0.0013572042807936668, 0.02719811163842678, -0.015254859812557697, 0.0038486188277602196, -0.004359470680356026, -0.017464954406023026, 0.017886368557810783, -0.048363082110881805, 0.05696895718574524, 0.018879590556025505, 0.00813510175794363, 0.004762180149555206, -0.057915616780519485, 0.01399175077676773, -0.0019528495613485575, -0.024232162162661552, 0.04051873832941055, 0.017969897016882896, -0.02088288404047489, 0.02840614877641201, 0.00502610532566905, 0.03853738307952881, -0.02928103879094124, 0.019908467307686806, -0.02792658470571041, -0.009883427992463112, -0.021648313850164413, -0.02260001003742218 ]
<p>The <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kernel_trick">kernel trick</a> is used in several machine learning models (e.g. <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Support_vector_machine">SVM</a>). It was first introduced in the "Theoretical foundations of the potential function method in pattern recognition learning" paper in 1964. </p> <p>The wikipedia definition says that it is </p> <blockquote> <p>a method for using a linear classifier algorithm to solve a non-linear problem by mapping the original non-linear observations into a higher-dimensional space, where the linear classifier is subsequently used; this makes a linear classification in the new space equivalent to non-linear classification in the original space.</p> </blockquote> <p>One example of a linear model that has been extended to non-linear problems is the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kernel_principal_component_analysis">kernel PCA</a>. Can the kernel trick be applied to any linear model, or does it have certain restrictions?</p>
660
[ -0.02331358939409256, 0.004927325528115034, 0.010713544674217701, 0.008810793049633503, 0.021070025861263275, 0.0030359358061105013, -0.02941492572426796, -0.006618322338908911, 0.038203928619623184, -0.008340477012097836, 0.021679218858480453, -0.00899185799062252, 0.06534156948328018, 0.003503096289932728, 0.008495918475091457, 0.0421711765229702, -0.018572399392724037, -0.0031408248469233513, -0.02870987355709076, 0.026432393118739128, 0.022314099594950676, 0.01668195240199566, -0.014645040966570377, -0.0008684464264661074, -0.02381766587495804, 0.04664900153875351, 0.00584321329370141, -0.02221984788775444, 0.06186941638588905, 0.02992803230881691, -0.029709026217460632, 0.0023310286924242973, 0.027419937774538994, 0.061419032514095306, -0.008787514641880989, 0.00023501670511905104, -0.01609279215335846, -0.01785331778228283, 0.021758131682872772, 0.04455912113189697, -0.012588380835950375, -0.02268138900399208, 0.012378727085888386, 0.082962267100811, -0.01900533400475979, 0.04351396858692169, 0.012692865915596485, -0.03860411047935486, 0.016612695530056953, -0.023132093250751495, 0.08091993629932404, -0.04812982305884361, 0.027916496619582176, 0.027401139959692955, -0.012950356118381023, 0.03576775640249252, 0.05076979100704193, 0.07812073826789856, 0.018441826105117798, -0.042377959936857224, -0.04358435794711113, 0.011559286154806614, 0.00034267440787516534, -0.03655672445893288, -0.023354649543762207, 0.04571197181940079, -0.00568106584250927, 0.005898614414036274, 0.011369666084647179, -0.040547654032707214, -0.018953975290060043, 0.010917761363089085, 0.015605393797159195, 0.01311512477695942, -0.0035618990659713745, -0.020063750445842743, -0.0073240348137915134, -0.007691561710089445, 0.03233266621828079, -0.0033296854235231876, 0.010226977989077568, 0.01444381382316351, 0.01810166984796524, 0.030981507152318954, 0.03610220178961754, -0.019082626327872276, 0.07185208797454834, -0.013183222152292728, 0.04920264333486557, 0.01544503029435873, -0.0035515911877155304, 0.02422652579843998, -0.0032977904193103313, -0.010454527102410793, -0.03762654960155487, 0.045060720294713974, 0.02912306785583496, 0.03298785164952278, 0.047916390001773834, -0.018283536657691002, 0.003197218757122755, 0.0015141710173338652, 0.0049018822610378265, 0.03474199399352074, -0.028689738363027573, -0.024747302755713463, -0.022802148014307022, 0.03219455108046532, 0.0033856669906526804, -0.026952218264341354, -0.041979942470788956, 0.014187394641339779, 0.02503693476319313, 0.03198336064815521, 0.03763265907764435, -0.02341957949101925, -0.010400474071502686, -0.01963398978114128, 0.026880759745836258, 0.04655633866786957, 0.03257228434085846, -0.029848234727978706, 0.02725173905491829, -0.02622145786881447, -0.03591037541627884, 0.02450397051870823, 0.021408723667263985, -0.026721371337771416, -0.03772539272904396, 0.04160229489207268, 0.027933865785598755, -0.05713919550180435, 0.025610439479351044, -0.02968779392540455, 0.009089979343116283, -0.02619396150112152, -0.08100032061338425, -0.030826261267066002, 0.04150617495179176, -0.004537591710686684, 0.003189342562109232, -0.02821042574942112, 0.021893128752708435, 0.048553213477134705, 0.07616928219795227, 0.00705356989055872, 0.02093549631536007, 0.020234117284417152, 0.029240723699331284, -0.036082759499549866, -0.057709235697984695, -0.01122334972023964, 0.00163706683088094, -0.021195512264966965, -0.024356281384825706, -0.08703672140836716, 0.030677981674671173, 0.020808326080441475, -0.008630241267383099, -0.017458096146583557, 0.060724738985300064, 0.0031613456085324287, 0.004879149608314037, -0.011205518618226051, -0.039825864136219025, -0.016382476314902306, 0.06662189215421677, -0.01998193748295307, 0.046646807342767715, 0.029121626168489456, -0.04400913044810295, 0.04245028644800186, 0.003662082366645336, 0.053581636399030685, 0.05752599239349365, -0.0049747987650334835, -0.024958951398730278, -0.018687821924686432, 0.012595905922353268, -0.0136785376816988, -0.08460716158151627, -0.03614847734570503, 0.0018028932390734553, 0.0424918532371521, 0.01785248890519142, 0.04688803479075432, -0.02487361803650856, -0.049886301159858704, 0.019373716786503792, -0.02820337563753128, -0.04794713109731674, -0.04713839665055275, 0.030692555010318756, -0.037241749465465546, -0.012456835247576237, 0.0533483661711216, 0.003730672411620617, 0.018365832045674324, -0.051845334470272064, 0.00172352883964777, -0.028803793713450432, -0.014359151013195515, 0.02122189849615097, -0.05155401676893234, -0.020602481439709663, 0.028576131910085678, 0.05794273689389229, -0.037256915122270584, 0.03472498059272766, -0.03912767767906189, -0.024673067033290863, -0.013374055735766888, -0.0061259507201612, 0.024806205183267593, -0.03942326083779335, 0.026865242049098015, 0.020013345405459404, 0.014642699621617794, -0.02818211540579796, 0.020629005506634712, -0.06008432060480118, 0.032140910625457764, 0.0787881463766098, 0.014837092719972134, -0.0005082050920464098, 0.021959705278277397, -0.02389773353934288, 0.03349483385682106, 0.024873092770576477, 0.006163835525512695, -0.04482889547944069, -0.025598887354135513, 0.021445799618959427, 0.03674716874957085, -0.037744175642728806, 0.03424280136823654, 0.06583170592784882, 0.05415891483426094, -0.008591586723923683, 0.028657909482717514, -0.02980632893741131, -0.00030867932946421206, 0.013489851728081703, -0.01990421861410141, -0.004029549658298492, 0.0028700819239020348, -0.002997136441990733, -0.022182097658514977, 0.03491434454917908, 0.020870232954621315, -0.024909580126404762, 0.03832287713885307, -0.03194540739059448, -0.008838046342134476, -0.0023500651586800814, -0.016134290024638176, 0.04696661978960037, -0.02689659409224987, 0.009293832816183567, 0.03648959472775459, -0.02199726551771164, 0.015134443528950214, -0.019279947504401207, 0.0014353819424286485, -0.00011428668221924454, 0.005465278401970863, -0.01218653004616499, 0.017521187663078308, 0.03941675275564194, -0.07080996781587601, 0.008389633148908615, -0.022059395909309387, 0.013126309029757977, -0.030830033123493195, 0.03501931205391884, 0.04998646304011345, 0.020346082746982574, 0.03896792605519295, 0.00899525173008442, -0.018449587747454643, 0.0030122895259410143, -0.03388215973973274, 0.03155037760734558, 0.013597995974123478, -0.05154154449701309, 0.028229132294654846, -0.04123842716217041, -0.006068419199436903, 0.05718809366226196, -0.0017552610952407122, 0.031100835651159286, -0.0235255416482687, -0.018783818930387497, -0.056572988629341125, -0.027934454381465912, -0.04222753643989563, 0.0445311963558197, 0.00014419428771361709, -0.017885297536849976, 0.01727960631251335, 0.03579525277018547, -0.05623873695731163, 0.016115637496113777, -0.03728214651346207, -0.02687644399702549, -0.027205366641283035, 0.004957861267030239, 0.008897422812879086, -0.01501760445535183, 0.028318721801042557, 0.018221590667963028, -0.009990043938159943, 0.0272468701004982, -0.0672043189406395, -0.024050995707511902, 0.005526535678654909, 0.025183044373989105, 0.03078196942806244, 0.026743780821561813, -0.01776532642543316, 0.09526506066322327, 0.03986843302845955, -0.02983679063618183, -0.03333590552210808, -0.007566481828689575, -0.06973245739936829, -0.0037779526319354773, 0.0101481257006526, 0.00021592364646494389, 0.019849009811878204, 0.020248327404260635, -0.022021178156137466, 0.008018171414732933, 0.04636237770318985, 0.024795686826109886, 0.0026878134813159704, 0.009328695014119148, -0.0408635139465332, -0.011177029460668564, 0.028868133202195168, -0.007084792014211416, -0.04022955149412155, 0.03067585453391075, 0.007834417745471, -0.0415947325527668, -0.000997223425656557, -0.021644195541739464, 0.03891684487462044, -0.01837165653705597, 0.009149541147053242, -0.04588008299469948, 0.011073123663663864, 0.018237438052892685, -0.009804939851164818, 0.036526158452034, 0.02015778049826622, 0.01610383950173855, -0.0291054118424654, 0.0054868063889443874, 0.014405135996639729, 0.017552973702549934, -0.0053543210960924625, 0.009147717617452145, -0.014954334124922752, -0.005937461741268635, 0.01862429268658161, -0.005447324365377426, 0.020652741193771362, 0.058916740119457245, 0.05318325385451317, -0.029170464724302292, 0.01955520734190941, -0.011481879279017448, 0.01647474430501461, -0.07868781685829163, -0.013838879764080048, -0.020451504737138748, 0.05671144276857376, 0.008113857358694077, 0.010525712743401527, 0.006888777017593384, -0.0061942897737026215, 0.021450573578476906, -0.005394128616899252, -0.09702181071043015, -0.007611756678670645, 0.0277693010866642, -0.015412276610732079, 0.02046404406428337, -0.006799700204282999, 0.027730943635106087, 0.014337941072881222, -0.0006042176974005997, -0.004162597935646772, 0.003973520360887051, -0.038224898278713226, 0.02367406338453293, 0.0023279255256056786, -0.0506216324865818, -0.016881069168448448, -0.04661831259727478, 0.05532318726181984, -0.010006533935666084, -0.001267611631192267, 0.025656068697571754, -0.03099558874964714, -0.005400057416409254, -0.024102922528982162, 0.010026156902313232, 0.03860924020409584, 0.0223652683198452, -0.02570667676627636, 0.05678367614746094, -0.0549587681889534, 0.027477886527776718, 0.0066545759327709675, 0.06534714996814728, 0.021575927734375, 0.013872871175408363, -0.030387109145522118, -0.0410778783261776, -0.026324434205889702, -0.01775050163269043, 0.030951764434576035, -0.015610067173838615, -0.0013241677079349756, 0.02162371575832367, 0.025546379387378693, -0.04687705636024475, 0.013942766934633255, 0.044311199337244034, 0.008257423527538776, 0.0005873834597878158, -0.026758922263979912, -0.0057273805141448975, 0.0039236703887581825, -0.00033216847805306315, 0.034161049872636795, -0.0070657446049153805, 0.0002671335532795638, -0.011082586832344532, 0.05312923714518547, -0.0035305917263031006, -0.021071404218673706, 0.013905707746744156, 0.0387505367398262, 0.002453910419717431, -0.020458968356251717, -0.002616764046251774, 0.00046591408317908645, 0.039368290454149246, 0.08118269592523575, 0.0005629615043289959, -0.010205589234828949, -0.07019184529781342, -0.014443658292293549, 0.04359897971153259, 0.02028656378388405, -0.01950075477361679, -0.01677156239748001, -0.03990522772073746, -0.050152115523815155, 0.009175834245979786, -0.006670177914202213, 0.028558656573295593, -0.015052844770252705, 0.011251630261540413, -0.027751581743359566, -0.028967950493097305, -0.03336802124977112, 0.0034113931469619274, 0.013600398786365986, -0.0008539509144611657, -0.03257601708173752, -0.034982334822416306, -0.043293289840221405, 0.0038093472830951214, -0.008881119079887867, 0.060351792722940445, -0.01363451685756445, -0.01747157610952854, -0.021571489050984383, 0.04369053989648819, -0.04893745481967926, -0.08082810044288635, 0.008655266836285591, 0.037950772792100906, -0.06285420805215836, 0.007259891368448734, -0.010554100386798382, -0.04741013050079346, -0.011369723826646805, 0.004548663739115, -0.028877928853034973, -0.03290935978293419, 0.007064950652420521, 0.008948770351707935, 0.03178409859538078, 0.049087636172771454, 0.07327960431575775, 0.028668012470006943, -0.005960284266620874, -0.028805943205952644, -0.027000341564416885, 0.024601489305496216, -0.013800689950585365, -0.009033075533807278, -0.009390980005264282, 0.009813609533011913, -0.022244920954108238, 0.051419392228126526, 0.031400393694639206, 0.053183577954769135, -0.01099781971424818, -0.021036898717284203, -0.021110428497195244, 0.028876909986138344, -0.05122099071741104, -0.04233403876423836, -0.007066508289426565, 0.03263523429632187, 0.013372614048421383, -0.012891814112663269, -0.020992211997509003, 0.046791981905698776, -0.002825773088261485, 0.0547356978058815, -0.01643938198685646, 0.0001887343096313998, -0.01911645196378231, 0.027259115129709244, 0.04378058761358261, -0.03040459379553795, 0.04380277916789055, 0.009077890776097775, 0.0015271429438143969, 0.03738005831837654, -0.07430515438318253, -0.0007713225786574185, 0.026492631062865257, -0.014844591729342937, 0.034274760633707047, -0.02906390093266964, 0.03593672439455986, 0.0130099942907691, -0.0044668591581285, -0.054512087255716324, -0.06474587321281433, 0.019781548529863358, 0.023137448355555534, -0.028187941759824753, -0.04002974182367325, -0.04375015199184418, 0.009496872313320637, -0.04637819901108742, 0.005412156227976084, 0.052307579666376114, -0.03500040993094444, 0.010407776571810246, 0.01964309811592102, -0.014557215385138988, 0.06493224203586578, 0.007015759125351906, -0.007374294102191925, 0.015138168819248676, -0.028630128130316734, 0.01281905546784401, -0.0049341777339577675, 0.01747017540037632, -0.04486506059765816, -0.003220394253730774, -0.04167470335960388, -0.025613486766815186, 0.04379938542842865, 0.037940070033073425, -0.02542453445494175, 0.03570138290524483, -0.0012618234613910317, -0.010284816846251488, 0.0009096090216189623, 0.0039886352606117725, -0.023272909224033356, -0.02459164522588253, -0.011057024821639061, 0.013202855363488197, -0.014657448045909405, -0.01546118501573801, 0.054712291806936264, -0.013590570539236069, -0.017957938835024834, 0.006863406393676996, 0.04661715030670166, -0.03852974250912666, 0.053261686116456985, 0.008938771672546864, -0.04309137910604477, 0.019252678379416466, -0.0006183026125654578, 0.04173596575856209, -0.022917956113815308, -0.0066497414372861385, -0.03291017934679985, -0.04729149863123894, -0.014022517018020153, 0.027629947289824486, 0.05009089410305023, -0.008713585324585438, 0.02954714745283127, 0.06338094174861908, -0.013906504958868027, -0.01024265494197607, -0.022737974300980568, 0.016264697536826134, -0.004857460502535105, -0.004310236312448978, 0.07024513185024261, 0.0002117285184795037, -0.00009837953984970227, 0.05789189785718918, 0.0057601346634328365, 0.021014701575040817, 0.02898148074746132, -0.018676333129405975, 0.034963447600603104, 0.030485523864626884, 0.01768849790096283, -0.05467987433075905, 0.04755788296461105, -0.026628652587532997, -0.005169654730707407, 0.03194727748632431, -0.03599311783909798, 0.04195326939225197, 0.019467679783701897, 0.008512059226632118, -0.06783159077167511, -0.045573487877845764, -0.03825712203979492, -0.006463379133492708, 0.009971710853278637, 0.008121657185256481, 0.05342496559023857, -0.030316554009914398, 0.02995435707271099, -0.006785299628973007, 0.029141344130039215, -0.017628662288188934, -0.066892109811306, -0.03099442832171917, -0.06077124923467636, -0.026299189776182175, 0.024919696152210236, 0.013563745655119419, -0.06551690399646759, 0.01483034435659647, -0.03168366476893425, 0.014823444187641144, 0.034117743372917175, 0.046379540115594864, -0.008763741701841354, 0.040400441735982895, -0.043910034000873566, 0.010504190810024738, -0.02334485948085785, -0.02564273215830326, 0.10293711721897125, 0.068219855427742, 0.026117151603102684, -0.05782581493258476, 0.030462084338068962, -0.029514003545045853, -0.020297810435295105, -0.04757508635520935, -0.022167153656482697, -0.022520001977682114, -0.00432486180216074, 0.02139621041715145, 0.06129210814833641, 0.002124043647199869, 0.005655241198837757, 0.05593288689851761, -0.03165453299880028, -0.0025330802891403437, 0.02088945545256138, -0.033899884670972824, -0.003948845434933901, -0.010768849402666092, -0.044758494943380356, 0.02545388601720333, 0.01792258769273758, -0.027011778205633163, -0.029284201562404633, -0.012484037317335606, 0.02694546990096569, 0.016872117295861244, -0.022173864766955376, 0.04500806704163551, -0.01587081328034401, 0.017967326566576958, 0.01779482513666153, 0.03004668653011322, 0.02398720011115074, -0.01636553928256035, 0.016514824703335762, 0.04585454985499382, 0.030844388529658318, -0.02809613198041916, -0.02004345878958702, -0.016606146469712257, -0.037718482315540314, -0.009446138516068459, -0.04743608087301254, 0.017503708600997925, -0.021719573065638542, 0.00685665151104331, -0.0026193810626864433, -0.030741248279809952, -0.02495536394417286, -0.021152259781956673, -0.03591310605406761, 0.0056027602404356, 0.02882843092083931, 0.004477585665881634, -0.046490758657455444, -0.028309054672718048, -0.013088949024677277, -0.014095061458647251, 0.03182750567793846, 0.00792002771049738, -0.031805481761693954, 0.011593041941523552, -0.009798502549529076, 0.037078551948070526, 0.004272188059985638, 0.0005813423194922507, -0.028712304309010506, -0.00215882807970047, 0.003509828355163336, -0.035207830369472504, 0.007185425143688917, 0.010674268007278442, 0.01788284257054329, -0.018041566014289856, -0.016970228403806686, -0.001972965430468321, -0.07306626439094543, 0.003130266210064292, -0.011693094857037067, 0.02619432471692562, -0.03377774357795715, 0.024122001603245735, 0.013506610877811909, 0.02281680516898632, 0.007289614528417587, -0.026160752400755882, -0.010683290660381317, 0.004718296229839325, 0.015062333084642887, -0.07159566134214401, -0.012145550921559334, 0.005397330969572067, 0.011485022492706776, 0.031165042892098427, 0.0016827561194077134, 0.05857742950320244, 0.0886807069182396, 0.010726225562393665, -0.05769936740398407, 0.02652597799897194, 0.00804536510258913, -0.009924938902258873, 0.008482242934405804, -0.029789917171001434, -0.005797185935080051, -0.0034065654035657644, 0.04608951508998871, -0.05054991692304611, -0.010647588409483433, -0.0055922348983585835, -0.02726096473634243, -0.017086246982216835, 0.023435845971107483, -0.030296338722109795, -0.011593285948038101, -0.02071165293455124, 0.036145735532045364, -0.04494021460413933, -0.010864397510886192, -0.011408410966396332, 0.03566059470176697, -0.01733149215579033, -0.0010155028430745006, -0.01680317521095276, -0.014342105016112328, -0.01584118977189064, 0.014877413399517536, 0.020533950999379158, 0.025729993358254433, 0.009974591434001923, 0.008312995545566082, 0.003224410582333803, -0.02220006473362446, 0.012230749242007732, -0.04992249608039856, -0.0031202698592096567, 0.07363085448741913, -0.06252841651439667, -0.0300100427120924, 0.021877026185393333, -0.018099794164299965, 0.02545151486992836, 0.03248517960309982, 0.0481904037296772, 0.0014418872306123376, 0.014837670139968395, 0.001293696230277419, 0.013777714222669601, -0.015592005103826523, -0.0031741438433527946, -0.03300555795431137, 0.0024006511084735394, 0.010407276451587677, -0.01918170601129532, -0.0351685993373394, 0.005974466446787119, 0.04076308384537697, -0.014534647576510906, -0.039050184190273285, 0.04148561879992485, -0.02698756754398346, 0.011832469142973423, -0.005091702565550804, 0.010647586546838284, 0.07322899252176285, 0.036405354738235474, -0.033014360815286636, 0.03489401936531067, 0.01815403252840042, -0.010843059979379177, -0.09918950498104095, -0.03669625520706177, -0.012054454535245895, -0.014423830434679985, 0.04147443547844887, -0.059407610446214676, 0.0018825068837031722, 0.019912587478756905, -0.08163037151098251, 0.03156398981809616, 0.019841020926833153, -0.01358999963849783, -0.033258382230997086, 0.027654744684696198, -0.034832946956157684, 0.022293580695986748, 0.03272298350930214, 0.002770929830148816, 0.001851861597970128, 0.018279587849974632, -0.0002473141357768327, 0.038587454706430435, -0.0030834125354886055, 0.0020870002917945385, -0.015083035454154015, -0.05101586505770683, 0.04603695869445801, -0.015673911198973656, -0.05205811560153961, 0.022480016574263573, -0.018370885401964188, -0.00684883538633585, 0.04580210521817207, -0.00782999861985445, 0.002099457895383239, 0.02426653727889061, 0.03932151570916176, -0.010977542027831078, -0.03807910159230232, 0.015243750996887684, 0.010605867020785809, 0.03020286187529564, -0.007196101360023022, -0.00253262254409492, -0.0000147146092785988, -0.02422875352203846, -0.02813142165541649, -0.00170966237783432, -0.015704989433288574, -0.027014512568712234, 0.018740735948085785, -0.017816994339227676, -0.04768064618110657, -0.001022126292809844, 0.003793637966737151, -0.03901129215955734, -0.012992650270462036, 0.008512969128787518, 0.003118799300864339, -0.053679294884204865, 0.04044688120484352, -0.0310970451682806, -0.048684075474739075, 0.04095328971743584, 0.01145872101187706, 0.004861275665462017, -0.06718237698078156, 0.00564896035939455, 0.033251866698265076, -0.04761503264307976, -0.026154417544603348, -0.024315085262060165, -0.07877811789512634, 0.059023261070251465, 0.0012762336991727352, -0.0006634540040977299, 0.03781367465853691, -0.026439186185598373, 0.001527460990473628, -0.07163979113101959, 0.06725144386291504, 0.012490596622228622, -0.03627602383494377, -0.010807909071445465, 0.014693542383611202, -0.005301874130964279, 0.002923178020864725, 0.046399254351854324, -0.005355978384613991, 0.004056726582348347, -0.012497116811573505, -0.01861410215497017, -0.023248517885804176, -0.01523769274353981, 0.012462081387639046, -0.013736152090132236, -0.0366598404943943, -0.011350974440574646, -0.01961064152419567, -0.03681617230176926, 0.004413915332406759, 0.04418661817908287, -0.0025561684742569923, 0.015647105872631073, 0.029850395396351814, -0.0037120115011930466, 0.02365592122077942, 0.04820512235164642, -0.0014001838862895966, 0.029203016310930252, 0.017848588526248932, 0.016292059794068336, -0.01868712529540062, 0.0031685559079051018, -0.024175798520445824, -0.017018523067235947, -0.03182069584727287, -0.027615128085017204, -0.0035649442579597235, -0.0051778703927993774, -0.021212035790085793, 0.0002384973777225241, -0.0218048095703125, 0.050914350897073746, -0.01890001818537712, 0.020737003535032272, 0.0288457702845335, -0.011463815346360207, 0.049881696701049805, 0.016034124419093132, -0.008507675491273403, 0.007037930190563202, -0.001745152985677123, -0.012455232441425323, 0.023707324638962746, 0.051319096237421036, -0.02611611969769001, -0.02553611807525158, 0.022970203310251236, 0.01923796907067299, 0.03772668540477753, -0.0012026310432702303, 0.04922914505004883, -0.034865498542785645, -0.009506708942353725, 0.007748246658593416, -0.007920562289655209, 0.02429189905524254, -0.007461166940629482, -0.03475752845406532, 0.07693701237440109, -0.030295955017209053, 0.018111074343323708, 0.002336451318114996, 0.03680561110377312, 0.0048231384716928005, -0.0057990471832454205, 0.02398943156003952, 0.050175976008176804, 0.006046766880899668, 0.006929970812052488, -0.020773399621248245, -0.002238439628854394, 0.04155291989445686, -0.006157191004604101, 0.05576294660568237, -0.021890239790081978, 0.008122110739350319, 0.011074994690716267, -0.029967933893203735, 0.036257125437259674, -0.028020335361361504, 0.008087493479251862, 0.03366273641586304, 0.055067047476768494, 0.008099528960883617, -0.038284432142972946, -0.0020100355613976717, 0.057288698852062225, -0.06476777046918869, -0.028768407180905342, 0.00014732139243278652, -0.0053232647478580475, -0.00519116735085845, -0.026656143367290497 ]