question
stringlengths
37
38.8k
group_id
int64
0
74.5k
sentence_embeddings
sequencelengths
1.02k
1.02k
<p>My objective is to implement a topic model for a large number of documents (20M or 30M). Let us assume that the number of topics is fixed at 50.</p> <p>I think implementing an LDA for the above problem would not be difficult. However, I have yet to find an answer for an NMF model. I have read that it is NOT easy to implement an NMF model for a large number of documents.</p> <p>Is it really not possible to implement an NMF model for my problem?</p>
73,901
[ -0.04422234371304512, 0.01013236679136753, 0.004450107924640179, -0.015465149655938148, 0.07204949110746384, 0.000576395948883146, -0.016982926055788994, -0.037304606288671494, 0.01653403602540493, -0.052293453365564346, 0.04650426283478737, 0.013537081889808178, 0.0780952051281929, 0.010701067745685577, 0.0019553566817194223, 0.014829630963504314, 0.02029814012348652, 0.021366987377405167, -0.0005478103994391859, -0.00050375732826069, -0.007777221035212278, 0.06582196056842804, 0.04489268735051155, -0.003146418137475848, -0.008534685708582401, 0.004220311529934406, 0.011445627547800541, -0.034503791481256485, 0.004033707547932863, 0.04564801976084709, -0.022199338302016258, -0.04399918392300606, 0.041606657207012177, 0.033207956701517105, 0.035441797226667404, -0.005263220984488726, -0.03080488182604313, -0.043037477880716324, -0.017359212040901184, -0.009170293807983398, -0.008319152519106865, -0.024357743561267853, 0.005738903768360615, 0.026883482933044434, -0.053070828318595886, 0.03524164855480194, 0.017784569412469864, -0.01706467755138874, 0.02923036739230156, -0.045490629971027374, 0.08439578115940094, -0.0008318963809870183, 0.04456184431910515, 0.03434433788061142, -0.03482922166585922, -0.04619705677032471, 0.02793259546160698, 0.08840698003768921, 0.010984579101204872, -0.012986418791115284, -0.06275652348995209, -0.004232860170304775, 0.014164984226226807, -0.02307317778468132, -0.04907216131687164, 0.031177379190921783, -0.025189924985170364, 0.03228262811899185, 0.012262633070349693, 0.023015592247247696, 0.009421523660421371, -0.02905968390405178, 0.054746948182582855, 0.011245178058743477, 0.013406560756266117, -0.0384998619556427, -0.0032208524644374847, -0.014403882436454296, 0.012134398333728313, 0.03895992785692215, -0.006030963733792305, 0.027020253241062164, -0.010111188516020775, 0.014532597735524178, 0.010550678707659245, -0.011668947525322437, 0.05784037709236145, -0.006113220937550068, 0.016028625890612602, -0.009173714555799961, -0.03863487020134926, -0.0065645575523376465, 0.03464614227414131, -0.013481209985911846, -0.014218004420399666, 0.007790482137352228, 0.003324738470837474, 0.011650331318378448, 0.030143098905682564, -0.023372424766421318, -0.000541282061021775, -0.016285177320241928, -0.00009987356315832585, 0.039726756513118744, -0.032005924731492996, 0.009257783181965351, -0.05448373034596443, -0.037213850766420364, -0.008492564782500267, 0.016530372202396393, -0.012726719491183758, 0.02909308299422264, 0.01928466185927391, -0.01817668415606022, 0.014430539682507515, 0.0033198995515704155, -0.0206427201628685, -0.03072633594274521, 0.007979074493050575, 0.10425274819135666, 0.006326605565845966, -0.031554412096738815, 0.017515340819954872, -0.03183124214410782, -0.040584102272987366, -0.007280651479959488, 0.008810334838926792, 0.0076689706183969975, -0.05259998142719269, 0.03871646150946617, -0.0012410931522026658, -0.0022531053982675076, 0.029890993610024452, -0.022432109341025352, 0.03164837881922722, -0.0003944971249438822, -0.07488957047462463, -0.07803528755903244, 0.042549021542072296, -0.016269830986857414, 0.02450307458639145, -0.07590524852275848, -0.00007232383359223604, 0.04139487445354462, 0.008238260634243488, 0.01448196079581976, 0.008597598411142826, 0.06712384521961212, 0.03467841446399689, -0.023251796141266823, -0.026960788294672966, 0.001939896261319518, -0.04314596951007843, 0.0047342791222035885, -0.04668343812227249, -0.08718535304069519, 0.025694891810417175, 0.03784928843379021, 0.02543221414089203, -0.031182171776890755, 0.018443642184138298, 0.040644001215696335, 0.004672328010201454, -0.009156451560556889, 0.011710574850440025, -0.025919832289218903, 0.07555023580789566, 0.019057622179389, 0.05188252404332161, 0.03254042565822601, -0.009637809358537197, 0.009587067179381847, 0.023933090269565582, 0.018680904060602188, 0.02690739743411541, -0.011121737770736217, 0.0027486931066960096, -0.004983753431588411, 0.0323365181684494, 0.028642747551202774, -0.025718575343489647, -0.04036380723118782, -0.02422589808702469, 0.03403639420866966, 0.031192954629659653, 0.012163989245891571, -0.007507766596972942, 0.022950438782572746, 0.024695856496691704, -0.041094109416007996, -0.010522929951548576, -0.032250501215457916, 0.033134594559669495, -0.02956441417336464, 0.019617756828665733, 0.018762651830911636, -0.027381591498851776, -0.008793981745839119, -0.009260155260562897, -0.026337508112192154, -0.04798528179526329, -0.01961519382894039, 0.015918614342808723, -0.011435731314122677, -0.009758532047271729, 0.015063093975186348, 0.02327125519514084, -0.05960525944828987, 0.03288644552230835, -0.06682008504867554, -0.07555856555700302, -0.026544321328401566, -0.0435054637491703, 0.055893298238515854, 0.009452623315155506, -0.021750066429376602, -0.01672881282866001, 0.0026097455993294716, -0.028923399746418, 0.03251226246356964, -0.05133618414402008, 0.08172576874494553, 0.05940861254930496, -0.011288334615528584, -0.016393402591347694, -0.009749654680490494, 0.030430732294917107, 0.0006250484730117023, 0.0057698567397892475, -0.030089963227510452, -0.11575088649988174, -0.02695591002702713, 0.04078817367553711, 0.04073821380734444, -0.05764997750520706, -0.0083759231492877, 0.09724631160497665, 0.0512164831161499, 0.01979609578847885, 0.011352051980793476, -0.03352568671107292, -0.02157263644039631, 0.01611926220357418, 0.05946533381938934, 0.017811017110943794, 0.023607080802321434, -0.00898897647857666, -0.005244351923465729, 0.0015829711919650435, -0.02851542830467224, -0.002408380154520273, 0.0648479089140892, 0.04510848969221115, -0.0019280151464045048, -0.02938687615096569, -0.008921761065721512, 0.05752939730882645, -0.03999849781394005, 0.0032645640894770622, 0.061808016151189804, 0.0005105568561702967, -0.0036017908714711666, 0.006570202298462391, -0.031673263758420944, 0.006836769171059132, 0.017410758882761, -0.007906823419034481, -0.012758545577526093, 0.01268036849796772, -0.010778033174574375, 0.009719152934849262, -0.0068736509419977665, -0.005665769800543785, 0.00791031215339899, 0.04019095003604889, 0.052941400557756424, -0.02214636281132698, 0.012297576293349266, 0.006978841032832861, -0.011439893394708633, 0.0331738144159317, -0.04559390991926193, -0.013767573051154613, 0.010786888189613819, -0.05544504523277283, -0.00508595397695899, 0.020584654062986374, -0.030077069997787476, 0.028614340350031853, 0.007392583414912224, 0.00963798351585865, 0.043649524450302124, -0.008738992735743523, -0.0717318058013916, -0.03208900988101959, -0.002053413772955537, 0.024700576439499855, -0.03741250932216644, -0.03314327076077461, 0.05249872803688049, 0.014434593729674816, -0.029436422511935234, -0.0334416925907135, -0.02006244659423828, -0.04187532886862755, -0.051615819334983826, -0.014617624692618847, -0.0005223150365054607, -0.008909997530281544, -0.01892261579632759, 0.02403814159333706, -0.055081807076931, 0.0027971144299954176, -0.05401450768113136, -0.07418167591094971, 0.016001340001821518, -0.0031704693101346493, 0.0636042058467865, 0.0054639047011733055, -0.010757188312709332, 0.04899394139647484, 0.012617847882211208, -0.05976821854710579, -0.01643291860818863, -0.052529964596033096, -0.025135722011327744, -0.06839033961296082, 0.007316539995372295, 0.004960839170962572, -0.016808293759822845, 0.0313640721142292, -0.009587043896317482, -0.02886018343269825, 0.04576340317726135, 0.025730866938829422, 0.0014122340362519026, 0.008405309170484543, 0.01761944591999054, 0.0060809096321463585, 0.04903601482510567, 0.036323051899671555, -0.0320039764046669, -0.01745637319982052, -0.04075779765844345, 0.0231180377304554, 0.017369339242577553, -0.017956890165805817, 0.017603309825062752, -0.04397525265812874, -0.014060546644032001, -0.02800273895263672, 0.00490882433950901, 0.0002672222617547959, -0.025726862251758575, 0.0009573715506121516, 0.008264361880719662, 0.04766634479165077, -0.014405416324734688, -0.03112608939409256, 0.0565311573445797, 0.029338257387280464, -0.01161907333880663, -0.025679657235741615, -0.04125222936272621, -0.0008838060894049704, -0.02826176956295967, -0.013951275497674942, 0.03878306224942207, 0.022972846403717995, 0.056282248347997665, 0.03590163215994835, -0.014171378687024117, -0.004382701590657234, 0.0005443296977318823, -0.05336923524737358, 0.00818559993058443, -0.022557420656085014, 0.041024789214134216, 0.009003694169223309, -0.003987045492976904, -0.018798960372805595, 0.01158536970615387, 0.021626874804496765, 0.0010314490646123886, -0.08678577840328217, -0.010162845253944397, -0.06611742079257965, 0.0011081391712650657, 0.028329191729426384, -0.022394301369786263, 0.049212779849767685, 0.034343790262937546, -0.01637364737689495, -0.023113854229450226, 0.057352785021066666, -0.03015822172164917, 0.015489986166357994, -0.01803245209157467, -0.009630167856812477, -0.000313031516270712, 0.018518084660172462, 0.0228278711438179, -0.03215489163994789, 0.0273345485329628, 0.05960547551512718, -0.01619919389486313, -0.0353822335600853, -0.03653470054268837, 0.012116234749555588, -0.004980893339961767, 0.053463105112314224, -0.015894830226898193, 0.03381285443902016, -0.05517735332250595, 0.0507616363465786, 0.028968801721930504, 0.037491604685783386, 0.049193594604730606, 0.006731214467436075, 0.00739521998912096, -0.055205799639225006, -0.018181290477514267, 0.00041213174699805677, 0.020784718915820122, 0.0022437640000134706, -0.01580558903515339, 0.016252759844064713, -0.011736535467207432, -0.04083101451396942, -0.012768741697072983, 0.058992091566324234, 0.027588529512286186, -0.002880101092159748, -0.025814512744545937, 0.01855689287185669, 0.025261452421545982, 0.010040605440735817, 0.04652516171336174, -0.002255335683003068, -0.010847759433090687, 0.0024970851372927427, 0.06898806989192963, -0.032288599759340286, -0.06206443905830383, 0.010054552927613258, -0.009209098294377327, 0.03569293022155762, 0.025325512513518333, -0.03489214554429054, 0.009137301705777645, 0.06329935044050217, 0.03838607668876648, 0.007752853445708752, -0.011992694810032845, -0.1050390973687172, -0.02299077995121479, -0.0043220845982432365, 0.007290372159332037, -0.014701134525239468, -0.0034605893306434155, -0.02640884555876255, -0.011034061200916767, 0.04345740005373955, -0.015541359782218933, 0.018381653353571892, 0.017246516421437263, 0.024700576439499855, 0.005773935467004776, -0.02537349984049797, -0.013327163644134998, 0.008661947213113308, -0.015106849372386932, 0.03352365642786026, -0.030893927440047264, -0.017832180485129356, -0.04094067960977554, 0.0038332478143274784, 0.05706443265080452, 0.02859313227236271, -0.006082475651055574, 0.017651671543717384, 0.008429235778748989, 0.03726028650999069, -0.0409722700715065, -0.08410518616437912, 0.02554219961166382, 0.03668132796883583, -0.009009785018861294, 0.00476721441373229, -0.018751947209239006, -0.04096303880214691, 0.008233982138335705, 0.02203960530459881, -0.04655211791396141, -0.020737918093800545, -0.027818627655506134, 0.030983230099081993, 0.028870221227407455, 0.007100591901689768, 0.08139602094888687, 0.01992843486368656, -0.006145205348730087, 0.027128010988235474, -0.027415180578827858, -0.001391464495100081, -0.03804810717701912, 0.02638097293674946, -0.00917121022939682, 0.03545758128166199, -0.020181793719530106, 0.03765129670500755, -0.018201759085059166, 0.030149998143315315, -0.01773759350180626, -0.0033805451821535826, -0.026830073446035385, 0.018196264281868935, 0.007677032612264156, -0.014392005279660225, 0.016280947253108025, 0.027018968015909195, 0.04439786449074745, -0.02680964581668377, 0.04432951286435127, -0.03267360478639603, -0.009439936839044094, 0.01571733132004738, -0.01601070910692215, -0.0361781045794487, -0.038979094475507736, -0.021961413323879242, -0.012930908240377903, -0.024347469210624695, 0.037958696484565735, -0.02005855366587639, 0.024313218891620636, 0.04846526309847832, -0.06453216820955276, 0.017390312626957893, 0.038521964102983475, 0.017493434250354767, -0.005969695281237364, -0.01555990893393755, -0.007909697480499744, -0.016266703605651855, -0.010891884565353394, -0.051403727382421494, -0.02454543486237526, 0.037171848118305206, -0.0029926951974630356, -0.02207481861114502, -0.02769237942993641, -0.005873772781342268, 0.011142049916088581, -0.029409851878881454, -0.02681879512965679, 0.05761702358722687, -0.025914765894412994, -0.030526980757713318, 0.027586303651332855, 0.002462296048179269, 0.06378614902496338, -0.00392198096960783, -0.0032662509474903345, 0.00073904829332605, -0.0026481258682906628, 0.0047400533221662045, -0.060476575046777725, 0.02045583724975586, -0.019688710570335388, -0.020307425409555435, -0.03591461852192879, -0.0030986976344138384, 0.035299308598041534, -0.01738080382347107, 0.01579672284424305, 0.02120640128850937, -0.016953235492110252, -0.023582758381962776, -0.04706306383013725, -0.015445102006196976, 0.007897586561739445, 0.022085217759013176, -0.017856085672974586, 0.01847962848842144, 0.0019207525765523314, -0.019838858395814896, 0.048636745661497116, -0.003533722599968314, 0.042807936668395996, -0.007192837540060282, 0.0839955136179924, -0.013187459670007229, 0.016218941658735275, -0.008184073492884636, -0.022796552628278732, 0.03412894532084465, -0.003599068382754922, 0.014064225368201733, -0.004045245237648487, -0.010843450203537941, -0.007505670189857483, -0.07243034988641739, 0.0005381307564675808, -0.0048319618217647076, 0.03166249766945839, 0.0036339813377708197, -0.00038430531276389956, 0.027628734707832336, 0.00028316915268078446, 0.017205173149704933, -0.038079164922237396, -0.0072319647297263145, 0.00892303790897131, 0.013108302839100361, 0.03187422826886177, -0.011816902086138725, -0.00558573380112648, 0.04239092022180557, 0.05187699571251869, 0.05035370960831642, 0.04176178202033043, 0.0488785095512867, -0.002219696994870901, 0.027989061549305916, 0.0017805317183956504, -0.03501730039715767, 0.028104495257139206, -0.020966343581676483, 0.028776109218597412, -0.03320593014359474, -0.0377030149102211, 0.06526907533407211, 0.011540831997990608, -0.01105751283466816, -0.01601947657763958, -0.014831878244876862, -0.03195634484291077, 0.016266651451587677, 0.025484183803200722, 0.031540077179670334, 0.02161628194153309, -0.01751234196126461, -0.0033067886251956224, 0.0007536619668826461, 0.012076062150299549, 0.006806693971157074, -0.08410501480102539, -0.04431231692433357, 0.0035010052379220724, -0.04357529431581497, 0.016466200351715088, 0.002153105800971389, -0.015017382800579071, -0.008161505684256554, -0.02312725968658924, 0.01991679146885872, 0.016855012625455856, 0.052336182445287704, -0.015125324949622154, 0.03943421691656113, 0.0022576183546334505, 0.07143532484769821, -0.007628734223544598, 0.020975593477487564, 0.10442283749580383, 0.08372294902801514, 0.048911791294813156, -0.047741878777742386, 0.0028773192316293716, 0.013607916422188282, 0.00046329968608915806, -0.042544104158878326, 0.025815431028604507, -0.020134635269641876, 0.0017181866569444537, 0.036247849464416504, 0.0206233412027359, -0.004493596963584423, 0.018839480355381966, 0.07724714279174805, -0.07872027903795242, -0.03095823898911476, 0.024021480232477188, -0.028911102563142776, -0.01250625029206276, -0.011013786308467388, -0.043995749205350876, 0.034950897097587585, 0.02407849207520485, -0.017010876908898354, -0.011237850412726402, -0.010590155608952045, 0.01755419187247753, -0.02732580155134201, -0.03928646817803383, -0.014290854334831238, 0.01749308966100216, -0.00011673801054712385, 0.009881626814603806, 0.024228667840361595, 0.054142583161592484, 0.00033959432039409876, -0.0021549209486693144, 0.013037702068686485, 0.01352153904736042, 0.010952722281217575, -0.018750419840216637, 0.009033836424350739, -0.05068095400929451, -0.04582888260483742, -0.02951749786734581, 0.014134780503809452, -0.026498453691601753, 0.048437971621751785, 0.015954338014125824, 0.008063394576311111, -0.000014978285435063299, 0.004955945070832968, -0.007893099449574947, 0.01378637459129095, 0.04103164002299309, -0.014329598285257816, -0.02852090448141098, -0.024406075477600098, 0.03718345984816551, -0.025705909356474876, 0.029714955016970634, 0.010889598168432713, 0.03900541737675667, -0.008346714079380035, -0.020786747336387634, 0.019223790615797043, 0.01985657960176468, 0.012547873891890049, -0.0372932106256485, 0.004989613778889179, -0.012989756651222706, -0.01611100509762764, -0.0017194338142871857, 0.022522486746311188, 0.03867320343852043, -0.014286055229604244, -0.0069775450974702835, -0.044328201562166214, -0.034967511892318726, 0.0021292460151016712, -0.007841433398425579, -0.04894108697772026, -0.04109629616141319, 0.03682558238506317, -0.006823508068919182, 0.04104762524366379, 0.01528053916990757, 0.0207236148416996, -0.020981574431061745, 0.004121792037039995, 0.032052237540483475, -0.053513042628765106, -0.013613240793347359, -0.0322595052421093, -0.02904367633163929, 0.0001383243507007137, -0.0217713825404644, 0.06176304444670677, 0.03959217667579651, 0.0020630150102078915, -0.020843470469117165, 0.05927024036645889, -0.010195029899477959, 0.012004425749182701, 0.014160014688968658, -0.03804820030927658, 0.034384723752737045, 0.03941861540079117, 0.02889634296298027, -0.026128970086574554, -0.01303175650537014, -0.03121774271130562, -0.03708241507411003, 0.05277184024453163, 0.008636780083179474, -0.022397389635443687, -0.01713082753121853, -0.0011881743557751179, 0.02487695962190628, -0.0382438562810421, -0.017410650849342346, -0.006936466787010431, 0.022083623334765434, -0.019308460876345634, -0.00045235222205519676, -0.04815632104873657, 0.021275974810123444, -0.02411925420165062, 0.007805692497640848, 0.014779314398765564, -0.0030182856135070324, 0.007601076737046242, -0.008318197913467884, 0.010116847231984138, 0.0178151186555624, 0.055955205112695694, -0.013960937969386578, -0.010953794233500957, 0.037735600024461746, -0.06643318384885788, 0.00795281957834959, -0.0051602646708488464, 0.007622653618454933, 0.03432837873697281, 0.0394316092133522, 0.0018555803690105677, -0.03486376628279686, 0.04241499677300453, -0.010848202742636204, -0.03400848060846329, -0.017544975504279137, -0.02443857677280903, 0.0017208439530804753, -0.0270401518791914, -0.005623445380479097, 0.020862126722931862, -0.009731307625770569, 0.009956748224794865, 0.02690565027296543, 0.011006096377968788, -0.02620493806898594, 0.03633908927440643, -0.005155761260539293, 0.002303372137248516, -0.02554355189204216, 0.0355355441570282, 0.013149703852832317, 0.055696651339530945, -0.04570460319519043, 0.028923241421580315, 0.004545144736766815, 0.036424849182367325, -0.05814630538225174, 0.010942623019218445, -0.020757216960191727, -0.01916959322988987, 0.043916571885347366, -0.053134385496377945, -0.00816352665424347, 0.04053698480129242, -0.0353565476834774, 0.030314933508634567, -0.006899289786815643, -0.002735828747972846, -0.05683715641498566, 0.01340580079704523, -0.08065354079008102, 0.012031525373458862, 0.024895068258047104, 0.050898268818855286, 0.028320204466581345, 0.038593731820583344, 0.010310130193829536, -0.029755504801869392, -0.03432701900601387, -0.02996375784277916, 0.015150504186749458, -0.02923455834388733, 0.0491986945271492, -0.031504422426223755, -0.056025050580501556, 0.04691081494092941, -0.014436909928917885, 0.017570307478308678, 0.0450163297355175, 0.002769185695797205, 0.02964957430958748, 0.011679583229124546, 0.0492749959230423, -0.00038620023406110704, 0.007763063535094261, 0.031969353556632996, -0.035827167332172394, 0.008859986439347267, 0.006130425725132227, 0.026606913655996323, 0.028960859403014183, -0.03542939946055412, -0.020884418860077858, 0.03156064450740814, -0.005555818323045969, -0.005428750067949295, -0.000788183300755918, -0.01814831979572773, 0.0038101933896541595, -0.024985726922750473, -0.007088597398251295, 0.006486811675131321, 0.0034622219391167164, 0.060476675629615784, -0.01961474120616913, -0.01887427642941475, 0.005396320018917322, 0.0025391746312379837, -0.05060352012515068, 0.025306133553385735, -0.007519757375121117, -0.0038228207267820835, -0.09531904011964798, 0.011471756733953953, 0.027948899194598198, -0.036132894456386566, -0.04496452212333679, -0.0162748321890831, -0.03058178909122944, 0.03972049057483673, -0.04931601509451866, 0.027968691661953926, 0.015986043959856033, -0.027716003358364105, -0.0031779352575540543, -0.05442631617188454, 0.03983257710933685, -0.0011186619522050023, 0.03463459014892578, -0.000605253444518894, -0.01687713898718357, 0.009744848124682903, -0.019680190831422806, 0.02647862397134304, -0.022028272971510887, 0.015510303899645805, -0.017940578982234, 0.01115002017468214, 0.03099176101386547, -0.004778965841978788, 0.00697976304218173, -0.02675367146730423, -0.0008583245216868818, -0.009996907785534859, -0.022628219798207283, -0.013327441178262234, -0.021972082555294037, 0.012946497648954391, -0.013618643395602703, -0.02425241284072399, -0.0031582904048264027, 0.0010317706037312746, 0.00340015790425241, -0.0010326186893507838, -0.001012840191833675, 0.04411516338586807, 0.017627907916903496, 0.0011723878560587764, -0.006262300070375204, 0.012273883447051048, -0.030313266441226006, 0.012774075381457806, -0.05647831782698631, 0.0006887966301292181, 0.03705208748579025, 0.037095218896865845, -0.007608032785356045, -0.05674254894256592, -0.03191561996936798, 0.054304320365190506, -0.022481882944703102, 0.010619325563311577, 0.04097268730401993, -0.004096541088074446, 0.034620195627212524, 0.0320139080286026, 0.011467094533145428, 0.024796804413199425, 0.00015086217899806798, -0.00211739307269454, 0.001452706870622933, 0.021137947216629982, -0.014038465917110443, 0.03219178691506386, 0.025648124516010284, -0.03301186487078667, 0.018186628818511963, 0.004347848705947399, 0.029793472960591316, -0.028680766001343727, -0.038288671523332596, 0.03509398549795151, 0.03945703059434891, 0.017643338069319725, 0.02153211086988449, 0.0008623397443443537, 0.06366734206676483, -0.01940736174583435, 0.012792148627340794, -0.058363478630781174, -0.009095271117985249, -0.023013591766357422, 0.03153589740395546, -0.028221622109413147, 0.05550004541873932, -0.004152574110776186, 0.013033810071647167, 0.016506299376487732, -0.04119443520903587, 0.046328555792570114, 0.0036584422923624516, 0.01772278919816017, -0.006816104054450989, 0.018056785687804222, -0.027070902287960052, -0.01256607100367546, -0.02069186605513096, -0.004880113061517477, 0.01205602940171957, 0.031090227887034416, 0.018970871344208717, -0.009545359760522842, -0.00692463805899024, -0.0018929769285023212, 0.017369888722896576, -0.04581252485513687, 0.01861470565199852, -0.040870532393455505, -0.02357644960284233, -0.026800720021128654, -0.04242582991719246 ]
<p>I wonder if someone can explain what is the main difference between omega and alpha reliabilities?</p> <p>I understand an omega reliability is based on hierarchical factor model as shown in the following picture, and alpha uses average inter-item correlations.</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/QH4Mf.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>What I don't understand is, in what condition, omega reliability coefficient would be higher than alpha coefficient, and vice versa?</p> <p>Can I assume if the correlations between the subfactors and the variables are higher, the omega coefficient would also be higher (as shown in the above picture)?</p> <p>Any advice is appreciated!</p>
73,902
[ -0.03404322266578674, -0.01183689758181572, 0.01988309435546398, -0.021577907726168633, 0.05056622251868248, 0.011394551955163479, -0.005974229890853167, -0.01984795741736889, 0.0560794323682785, -0.039310142397880554, -0.0062998561188578606, 0.009141986258327961, 0.04033040627837181, -0.014162259176373482, -0.0007795526180416346, -0.004467665683478117, 0.011254612356424332, 0.0073904613964259624, -0.009910737164318562, -0.011093095876276493, -0.010458777658641338, -0.0007988957804627717, 0.011302643455564976, -0.021743956953287125, -0.021258516237139702, 0.04915214702486992, 0.04017429053783417, -0.019594455137848854, 0.04168371483683586, 0.014058533124625683, -0.009266586974263191, -0.00018831106717698276, 0.006770412437617779, 0.05160217359662056, -0.0017972112400457263, -0.022031040862202644, -0.009823925793170929, 0.0203497763723135, -0.05279643461108208, 0.032815273851156235, -0.04272495582699776, -0.04604954645037651, 0.0015283259563148022, 0.04291384667158127, -0.003989174496382475, -0.01585206761956215, -0.01980726234614849, -0.02020397037267685, 0.026192331686615944, -0.0142287602648139, 0.029543865472078323, -0.01384900975972414, 0.05672968551516533, 0.050122905522584915, -0.0006958795129321516, -0.016225533559918404, 0.07491476088762283, 0.0691598653793335, -0.02995164692401886, -0.05419766530394554, -0.037255529314279556, -0.01636350527405739, -0.0047902208752930164, -0.013902830891311169, -0.04016508534550667, 0.02631852589547634, 0.0032371478155255318, -0.007809949107468128, 0.028804773464798927, 0.027981320396065712, 0.021426957100629807, 0.03209675848484039, 0.0475686714053154, -0.020974673330783844, 0.019983066245913506, -0.02166302315890789, 0.0038532293401658535, 0.0014963657595217228, 0.040810178965330124, 0.0399642139673233, 0.020870206877589226, 0.013217329978942871, 0.012074734084308147, 0.006590221077203751, -0.0009625361999496818, -0.04166838526725769, 0.055125392973423004, 0.010342149063944817, -0.01087114680558443, -0.00041785993380472064, -0.042296867817640305, 0.029008235782384872, 0.013466747477650642, -0.007383895106613636, -0.022643843665719032, 0.03668401017785072, -0.02393876388669014, 0.01773928664624691, 0.01966443471610546, 0.03003547713160515, 0.0035152568016201258, -0.03632073104381561, 0.013082503341138363, 0.051643241196870804, 0.005424079485237598, -0.026434075087308884, -0.0404525063931942, 0.0012525535421445966, -0.003423779970034957, -0.0300716832280159, -0.011856292374432087, 0.04609077051281929, 0.007182169705629349, 0.01821213588118553, 0.029578877612948418, -0.014147689566016197, 0.007177420426160097, -0.03346385061740875, 0.06894022971391678, 0.06498970836400986, 0.022597791627049446, -0.03140731155872345, 0.004631428048014641, -0.004701582249253988, -0.03544779121875763, 0.005942144431173801, 0.029683370143175125, -0.02257097326219082, -0.03360595926642418, 0.05307815596461296, -0.0011924052378162742, -0.013877196237444878, 0.022813647985458374, 0.011693962849676609, 0.03262694925069809, 0.002810153877362609, -0.11606181412935257, -0.044663332402706146, 0.027034204453229904, 0.008909052237868309, -0.015305722132325172, -0.04355612024664879, 0.038960278034210205, 0.05020371824502945, 0.024633590131998062, 0.023725086823105812, 0.016199368983507156, 0.01685628481209278, 0.027993863448500633, 0.030718965455889702, -0.029507221654057503, -0.03489908203482628, 0.004340089857578278, -0.018813088536262512, 0.007107139565050602, -0.08946695923805237, -0.02356097102165222, -0.007444032002240419, -0.017592942342162132, -0.021955739706754684, 0.04717729613184929, 0.006222813855856657, -0.01887185499072075, 0.003918027970939875, 0.03663862496614456, -0.030431514605879784, 0.044859953224658966, -0.01701299101114273, 0.032121382653713226, 0.047309499233961105, -0.03613704442977905, 0.012863616459071636, 0.01858389563858509, 0.01953684166073799, 0.01502698939293623, 0.00760479923337698, -0.030962102115154266, -0.04430371895432472, 0.035141170024871826, 0.0012798710959032178, -0.061114195734262466, -0.023400841280817986, -0.03469435125589371, -0.019184503704309464, 0.013299113139510155, 0.06901005655527115, -0.0106849679723382, -0.007820873521268368, 0.030634164810180664, -0.011610870249569416, -0.052923500537872314, -0.025190042331814766, 0.03937110677361488, -0.028606850653886795, -0.03955678641796112, 0.03787294402718544, -0.004917108919471502, -0.007402007468044758, -0.020704496651887894, -0.0018745387205854058, -0.03675739839673042, 0.00524479802697897, -0.004267863929271698, -0.06348005682229996, 0.05121125653386116, 0.0531432069838047, 0.010443072766065598, -0.005726057570427656, 0.033044565469026566, -0.04250268265604973, -0.05690786615014076, 0.022582264617085457, -0.05419531092047691, 0.005046369507908821, -0.03219086676836014, -0.04575847461819649, 0.03648195415735245, 0.0046247802674770355, -0.03129396215081215, 0.021747291088104248, -0.04104509577155113, 0.07967013865709305, 0.03265468403697014, 0.005576040130108595, 0.008135094307363033, 0.01978030614554882, -0.015390132553875446, -0.002718953415751457, -0.03937596082687378, -0.0024260268546640873, -0.0630512684583664, -0.03818294405937195, 0.02759266272187233, -0.029863839969038963, -0.05219374597072601, 0.02541355974972248, 0.03717007860541344, 0.020647510886192322, -0.005152468103915453, 0.016754455864429474, 0.033169083297252655, -0.020419806241989136, -0.020698832347989082, 0.01315915398299694, 0.02195611409842968, 0.04725586250424385, -0.009974371641874313, 0.0026764986105263233, 0.007851758040487766, -0.018907232210040092, -0.018572669476270676, 0.0687427744269371, -0.016821354627609253, 0.0037129095289856195, -0.011192777194082737, -0.033443547785282135, 0.0321010984480381, -0.0400984100997448, 0.027791019529104233, 0.053495168685913086, -0.016091860830783844, -0.007475296966731548, 0.021538615226745605, -0.04163388907909393, 0.03274410963058472, 0.03783481940627098, -0.02869522199034691, -0.04909050092101097, -0.005263079889118671, 0.007072451524436474, -0.015641318634152412, -0.03157573193311691, 0.0018761326791718602, -0.004625412169843912, -0.016748396679759026, 0.06935093551874161, -0.023177383467555046, 0.03432324528694153, 0.0015143565833568573, -0.01677088625729084, 0.0047237323597073555, 0.007654946763068438, 0.012567982077598572, -0.02168429084122181, -0.06290827691555023, -0.025101492181420326, -0.029632123187184334, -0.03304233402013779, 0.027099484577775, 0.005274523980915546, -0.042540717869997025, -0.004637571517378092, 0.02720283344388008, -0.03672090172767639, -0.017673328518867493, 0.0030438597314059734, -0.006905116140842438, -0.04634099453687668, -0.05155687779188156, 0.06190086528658867, -0.04744703695178032, -0.006580936722457409, 0.02359412983059883, -0.048168033361434937, -0.037608977407217026, 0.007742384914308786, -0.007225359324365854, -0.009792553260922432, 0.01202388945966959, 0.03379462659358978, 0.026903342455625534, -0.05550743266940117, -0.015961727127432823, -0.03690861538052559, -0.06165991351008415, 0.04656444862484932, -0.00818578340113163, 0.041719064116477966, 0.0014112013159319758, -0.030942946672439575, 0.06431689858436584, 0.02962334267795086, -0.02497837319970131, -0.0026394957676529884, 0.015512330457568169, -0.040654174983501434, -0.0403984971344471, 0.015688560903072357, 0.03053305484354496, 0.028690556064248085, 0.039845019578933716, 0.0018122004112228751, 0.010689101181924343, 0.023057257756590843, -0.009864239022135735, 0.01516595110297203, 0.01681722141802311, 0.043584976345300674, -0.012789472937583923, 0.012103749439120293, -0.009024900384247303, -0.030144745483994484, -0.04402129724621773, 0.029787210747599602, 0.017638947814702988, -0.030513931065797806, -0.025498172268271446, -0.0032653824891895056, -0.018809577450156212, -0.010863926261663437, -0.043008241802453995, -0.008836298249661922, 0.020658789202570915, -0.007033905945718288, 0.021939514204859734, 0.03554244711995125, 0.058220259845256805, -0.005053410772234201, 0.007544416934251785, 0.03840116783976555, 0.033613599836826324, -0.02797883190214634, 0.008185971528291702, -0.038196392357349396, 0.0037758818361908197, 0.039863817393779755, -0.002074915450066328, -0.018204741179943085, 0.040830098092556, 0.024928532540798187, 0.04266536235809326, 0.0011595410760492086, -0.052077312022447586, 0.0019276599632576108, -0.09128889441490173, -0.013037104159593582, -0.04501733556389809, 0.08769278973340988, 0.007557054050266743, 0.07222182303667068, 0.036001384258270264, 0.005592517554759979, -0.012704354710876942, 0.014307249337434769, -0.06309836357831955, -0.0005474101053550839, -0.05435055494308472, -0.01989799365401268, 0.01677962765097618, -0.00666451221331954, 0.030399078503251076, -0.005285090301185846, -0.011633167043328285, -0.0003396907704882324, 0.03601982817053795, -0.012446867302060127, 0.01964966021478176, -0.021485352888703346, 0.03621045872569084, -0.001490159658715129, 0.010961669497191906, -0.028623878955841064, -0.022722309455275536, 0.03724300488829613, 0.06548065692186356, -0.01849205233156681, 0.02910691499710083, -0.056616783142089844, -0.00663111312314868, 0.029498694464564323, 0.001986781833693385, 0.045316677540540695, 0.03209301084280014, -0.00918363407254219, -0.00915645994246006, 0.03724837303161621, 0.030562760308384895, 0.051782041788101196, -0.024979203939437866, -0.0027686108369380236, -0.009941138327121735, -0.02169160172343254, -0.029942354187369347, 0.034638661891222, -0.016977153718471527, -0.015684889629483223, 0.020340867340564728, -0.011546776629984379, -0.0520273819565773, 0.027751823887228966, 0.028887121006846428, 0.016410084441304207, 0.0010368460789322853, -0.03340468555688858, -0.04483131319284439, -0.034581854939460754, -0.02975485473871231, 0.031117241829633713, 0.011928502470254898, -0.006526113022118807, -0.0015592831186950207, 0.02631145343184471, -0.044050224125385284, -0.03363136947154999, 0.010202252306044102, 0.0014230582164600492, 0.00332466303370893, 0.012668791227042675, -0.06163520738482475, -0.005687049124389887, 0.05081752687692642, 0.06342070549726486, 0.03656420484185219, 0.009992997162044048, -0.042869050055742264, -0.012518057599663734, 0.013879920355975628, -0.01022909115999937, -0.007468001917004585, -0.027528837323188782, -0.026973681524395943, -0.06135713309049606, 0.03286551311612129, -0.021106142550706863, 0.061553630977869034, 0.017036477103829384, 0.0005187708302401006, -0.019873540848493576, -0.039854466915130615, -0.02906263992190361, 0.0230987798422575, 0.0400899276137352, 0.00810464471578598, -0.011366439051926136, -0.004023373126983643, -0.035523273050785065, -0.012071792036294937, 0.03826902434229851, 0.04166221246123314, -0.013866358436644077, 0.0013707352336496115, -0.011577744036912918, 0.03606511652469635, 0.0016712552169337869, -0.057419825345277786, -0.029751144349575043, -0.003731036325916648, 0.0013267536414787173, 0.030367562547326088, 0.0038951903115957975, -0.01563323847949505, 0.007625889498740435, 0.004123933147639036, -0.026860995218157768, -0.022765029221773148, -0.009599234908819199, 0.07578146457672119, 0.039078112691640854, -0.004706232342869043, 0.06955845654010773, 0.021129939705133438, -0.0183052197098732, -0.027399767190217972, -0.01730830781161785, 0.008890197612345219, -0.037762001156806946, -0.009954971261322498, -0.026177270337939262, 0.02020423859357834, -0.03024008497595787, 0.050792112946510315, -0.00275921612046659, 0.039290040731430054, -0.0409049354493618, -0.017901457846164703, 0.028722602874040604, 0.023404285311698914, -0.00783475674688816, 0.014431053772568703, 0.018986210227012634, 0.005861773621290922, 0.029934532940387726, -0.02762332744896412, 0.0174542386084795, -0.01831592433154583, 0.018852028995752335, 0.009921181946992874, -0.06226807460188866, 0.010256752371788025, -0.03699853643774986, -0.038551848381757736, 0.024091748520731926, -0.016328588128089905, 0.018454216420650482, -0.023629073053598404, 0.016274526715278625, -0.011959672905504704, -0.037345677614212036, 0.005328673869371414, 0.02675965242087841, -0.04176386818289757, 0.054595690220594406, 0.009955761954188347, 0.029361899942159653, 0.010052436962723732, -0.024872591719031334, -0.08536651730537415, -0.061446662992239, 0.013993315398693085, 0.01425363589078188, 0.0014786190586164594, 0.013614988885819912, 0.023886434733867645, -0.012267299927771091, -0.02163739688694477, -0.005164012778550386, 0.03533889725804329, -0.016376150771975517, -0.008946607820689678, 0.0068647111766040325, 0.01261698454618454, 0.04097467660903931, 0.0045104012824594975, -0.020073961466550827, 0.003950351383537054, -0.030053364112973213, -0.008181766606867313, 0.003922237083315849, 0.020112426951527596, -0.04257151484489441, -0.021878045052289963, -0.022484630346298218, 0.01820746622979641, 0.05307928845286369, 0.019664542749524117, -0.014575322158634663, -0.012511874549090862, -0.0029080526437610388, 0.01374131441116333, 0.000990121508948505, 0.02300945296883583, -0.010802359320223331, 0.006200957112014294, -0.005876235198229551, 0.009179738350212574, -0.049609534442424774, -0.030701061710715294, 0.03226161375641823, 0.00500665744766593, -0.008917129598557949, 0.04355752468109131, 0.08230718970298767, -0.03485625982284546, 0.04958475008606911, -0.047859419137239456, -0.011017411947250366, 0.04123568534851074, 0.03095226176083088, 0.011122377589344978, 0.041928764432668686, 0.03267180919647217, -0.022976862266659737, -0.026330571621656418, -0.04360596835613251, 0.014022208750247955, 0.06398402899503708, -0.020896034315228462, 0.04707785323262215, 0.03340188041329384, -0.017990095540881157, -0.028711099177598953, -0.062457453459501266, -0.00582334166392684, 0.026000596582889557, -0.028183596208691597, 0.05054885149002075, -0.02855365164577961, -0.02565351501107216, 0.032604046165943146, 0.008518465794622898, 0.015601634979248047, 0.026387851685285568, 0.0413847379386425, 0.06831272691488266, -0.03879695385694504, -0.012083595618605614, -0.045844655483961105, 0.04624233767390251, -0.02282431721687317, 0.026188798248767853, -0.03356427699327469, -0.025986649096012115, 0.027190571650862694, 0.060171108692884445, 0.011570054106414318, -0.05767643079161644, -0.0104273846372962, -0.0017315809382125735, 0.03554069623351097, 0.048918817192316055, -0.002618158468976617, -0.011191228404641151, -0.018636450171470642, 0.047341905534267426, 0.002858708379790187, 0.021295277401804924, -0.00008614888793090358, -0.07469804584980011, -0.041579797863960266, 0.012389471754431725, -0.063088059425354, 0.005672782193869352, 0.002722289878875017, -0.017767013981938362, 0.023262780159711838, -0.0421280637383461, 0.009196223691105843, 0.03104877658188343, 0.03139040246605873, -0.02412467449903488, 0.06845957040786743, -0.005739883054047823, 0.036583997309207916, 0.019222034141421318, -0.02567855268716812, 0.10418593883514404, 0.10781680792570114, 0.012908779084682465, -0.016448473557829857, 0.03912346810102463, -0.028667431324720383, 0.017548823729157448, -0.03953729197382927, 0.008226599544286728, 0.0011621692683547735, -0.02534634619951248, 0.05244492366909981, 0.07135062664747238, 0.028451619669795036, 0.0074452669359743595, 0.0695476159453392, -0.07448692619800568, -0.02482224814593792, -0.026087820529937744, -0.007361161056905985, -0.0061808740720152855, 0.0007838685996830463, 0.00611297320574522, 0.03675736486911774, 0.004840017296373844, -0.03161025792360306, -0.04035954549908638, 0.020269092172384262, 0.02459798753261566, -0.020459208637475967, -0.007261360064148903, -0.020056627690792084, 0.028661370277404785, -0.005631839856505394, 0.010337128303945065, 0.014263751916587353, 0.023366380482912064, -0.046880174428224564, 0.014823396690189838, 0.024289611726999283, -0.02881457470357418, -0.010459046810865402, 0.02004517801105976, 0.009139011614024639, -0.058137401938438416, -0.038723114877939224, -0.045834098011255264, 0.0035811206325888634, -0.032312069088220596, -0.002213739324361086, -0.04945312440395355, -0.001835994771681726, -0.011946470476686954, -0.033767711371183395, 0.006837230175733566, 0.028198903426527977, 0.006805900018662214, -0.03718838095664978, -0.049578625708818436, -0.045737527310848236, 0.03127443045377731, 0.006167510524392128, 0.06645486503839493, 0.019247904419898987, -0.046532437205314636, -0.026837708428502083, -0.0669059231877327, 0.02178809978067875, 0.005847829394042492, 0.017470598220825195, -0.002728389110416174, 0.01969931274652481, -0.027360348030924797, 0.01697590760886669, 0.003789800452068448, 0.024182960391044617, 0.054571472108364105, 0.021723704412579536, -0.019911250099539757, -0.03461863473057747, -0.0026365628000348806, -0.018454963341355324, -0.021949347108602524, -0.057848330587148666, -0.03135563060641289, -0.016412151977419853, 0.022295009344816208, 0.0329669751226902, 0.015582706779241562, 0.030061371624469757, -0.008055332116782665, 0.014745716005563736, 0.02464413456618786, -0.05629384145140648, -0.024341367185115814, -0.0065787131898105145, -0.03176568076014519, -0.02744169905781746, -0.04479246214032173, 0.017091581597924232, 0.03308949992060661, -0.0038343374617397785, -0.019549788907170296, 0.03770868107676506, 0.005585704930126667, 0.007113391999155283, 0.012995670549571514, -0.022307327017188072, -0.016644125804305077, 0.03404513746500015, 0.03276251628994942, -0.026511427015066147, -0.006713721435517073, -0.020003892481327057, -0.011513332836329937, 0.0029004549141973257, -0.012154155410826206, -0.020860275253653526, -0.01824791356921196, -0.02808605134487152, 0.035744402557611465, -0.01834605075418949, -0.006987597793340683, 0.0022468448150902987, 0.023327259346842766, 0.009462137706577778, -0.004767164122313261, -0.02561040408909321, 0.017616692930459976, -0.007781551219522953, -0.0043111382983624935, 0.02240614779293537, 0.035185765475034714, -0.00033445199369452894, 0.001982159214094281, 0.004379794467240572, 0.015708256512880325, 0.07358290255069733, -0.03041655570268631, -0.005821387283504009, 0.025168348103761673, -0.012064522132277489, -0.020907586440443993, 0.014559172093868256, 0.01811000518500805, 0.011051095090806484, 0.02952427789568901, 0.01980612426996231, -0.024063976481556892, 0.05104619637131691, -0.056588176637887955, -0.024802522733807564, -0.024685518816113472, -0.011569692753255367, -0.021885951980948448, 0.012741338461637497, -0.02140599861741066, -0.01646883599460125, 0.012323128059506416, 0.016070714220404625, 0.04403414577245712, 0.002875048201531172, -0.01618499867618084, 0.02374814637005329, 0.012444540858268738, 0.007223590277135372, 0.01751268096268177, 0.013836028054356575, 0.016035987064242363, 0.049359068274497986, -0.023818735033273697, 0.04978369548916817, 0.01930239051580429, -0.008684824220836163, -0.06278000771999359, -0.03560813143849373, 0.005664362106472254, 0.012917027808725834, 0.05052177980542183, -0.017952755093574524, 0.018282074481248856, 0.05586947500705719, -0.03837534040212631, 0.04187812656164169, 0.018947618082165718, 0.007737070322036743, -0.07016883790493011, 0.0078748082742095, -0.0068098874762654305, 0.05067451298236847, 0.028349684551358223, 0.0028292809147387743, -0.00045997780398465693, 0.022605502977967262, 0.012807301245629787, -0.011367089115083218, -0.030794592574238777, 0.03122086077928543, -0.003092584665864706, -0.031658247113227844, 0.05188708379864693, -0.03548373654484749, -0.02920740470290184, 0.03175906091928482, 0.011400982737541199, 0.0004597402294166386, 0.01991167664527893, 0.0388515405356884, 0.014291083440184593, 0.019754141569137573, -0.0038842838257551193, 0.007237790152430534, -0.01487269438803196, 0.042490653693675995, 0.024692347273230553, 0.009900283068418503, -0.0374259315431118, -0.006437969859689474, 0.013054882176220417, -0.015412048436701298, -0.040923502296209335, 0.01846041902899742, 0.0065941461361944675, -0.0038627327885478735, 0.0014436697820201516, -0.037559863179922104, 0.02150510624051094, -0.0028528987895697355, 0.020063316449522972, -0.05399865284562111, -0.01652652397751808, 0.03539889678359032, 0.006646567489951849, -0.002937289420515299, -0.016907701268792152, -0.002830945421010256, -0.006581918336451054, 0.0339411236345768, -0.006048446986824274, -0.015971841290593147, -0.04589930921792984, -0.0053406148217618465, -0.024978170171380043, 0.007883329875767231, 0.02238055318593979, -0.013873874209821224, -0.02636122703552246, 0.025095568969845772, -0.036270901560783386, 0.00467749172821641, 0.019847029820084572, -0.031099556013941765, -0.008049321360886097, -0.07161521166563034, 0.056812748312950134, -0.01644841954112053, -0.03615185618400574, -0.015753988176584244, -0.003920930903404951, -0.03598025068640709, -0.0016907253302633762, 0.03821946680545807, 0.004146697465330362, 0.023773184046149254, -0.011333922855556011, 0.006214224733412266, 0.010128848254680634, -0.04131917655467987, 0.06581486016511917, 0.004973568953573704, -0.042063236236572266, -0.025361161679029465, 0.007147757336497307, 0.032078322023153305, 0.006024220027029514, 0.01715647429227829, -0.04770418256521225, 0.043420545756816864, -0.006885401904582977, 0.0028321349527686834, 0.02319093979895115, -0.012228240258991718, -0.014659550040960312, 0.06678273528814316, -0.0335351936519146, 0.014950461685657501, 0.0367550402879715, -0.0034029853995889425, -0.04943545162677765, 0.04190957173705101, 0.006931640207767487, 0.019198328256607056, -0.013902840204536915, 0.02437068335711956, -0.032926272600889206, -0.06708609312772751, -0.006363922264426947, 0.03980926424264908, -0.056275054812431335, -0.0383024699985981, 0.05516543984413147, 0.019912930205464363, 0.049624744802713394, -0.020136961713433266, -0.00951142143458128, 0.022716546431183815, -0.06502597779035568, -0.001401750952936709, 0.03714318200945854, 0.06028533726930618, -0.002428322099149227, 0.04926399886608124, 0.04900272563099861, 0.02510596625506878, 0.03661733865737915, -0.026302281767129898, 0.0409136563539505, -0.05276573821902275, -0.042492933571338654, 0.0282770823687315, -0.007157163694500923, 0.03665295988321304, 0.028882231563329697, 0.012054353021085262, 0.03368563577532768, -0.05200333148241043, -0.016443056985735893, -0.028415333479642868, -0.015725476667284966, -0.07828293740749359, -0.002363900188356638, 0.022613056004047394, 0.045305270701646805, 0.005344789940863848, 0.01265961118042469, -0.024587737396359444, -0.01864059641957283, 0.029654094949364662, 0.014450721442699432, 0.020672908052802086, -0.01672123372554779, 0.01782245561480522, -0.025213757529854774, -0.012228520587086678, -0.03993113338947296, -0.02862144261598587, 0.011518646031618118, 0.04687460884451866, 0.053833968937397, 0.003116061445325613, -0.04833710938692093, 0.010391613468527794, 0.033272989094257355, -0.06146461144089699, -0.0033305371180176735, -0.032942160964012146, 0.024148456752300262, 0.020269442349672318, 0.026416165754199028 ]
<p>Note that there are some distributions that can be derived from the others (continuous as well as discrete).</p> <p>For example student and chi-square distribution are derived from normal distribution and binomial distribution can be derived from Bernoulli distribution.</p> <p>Of course, the term "derived" can be understood in two ways - directly derived (for example normal - student) or using some limit (binomial - poisson).</p> <p>Is there any diagram depicting these kind of relation? If not, it is possible to draw it with at least the most known discrete and continuous distributions? I would prefer graph with nodes as distributions and directed edges that would mean that one distribution can be derived from another (limit cases should be also depicted).</p>
98
[ -0.03919634968042374, -0.01185810286551714, 0.029955584555864334, -0.006388245616108179, 0.022841650992631912, -0.0041498588398098946, 0.007529892958700657, -0.0021989764645695686, 0.030268516391515732, -0.050538234412670135, 0.0274729635566473, 0.015476728789508343, 0.04818563908338547, 0.01811695657670498, 0.0088032316416502, 0.02935539186000824, -0.03828170895576477, 0.013858098536729813, -0.013859451748430729, -0.027739999815821648, 0.024524277076125145, 0.007773542311042547, 0.02181721106171608, 0.02664214000105858, -0.03381184861063957, 0.03613162040710449, 0.035906579345464706, 0.009450899437069893, 0.004074317403137684, 0.07305251806974411, -0.028220387175679207, -0.027081796899437904, 0.0031159783247858286, 0.046455349773168564, -0.002680961973965168, 0.012202613055706024, -0.03383982181549072, -0.03719102591276169, -0.03224705904722214, 0.012206189334392548, -0.03900955244898796, -0.01140624564141035, -0.026367157697677612, 0.03186026215553284, -0.039689380675554276, 0.005189308896660805, 0.010742098093032837, -0.040083371102809906, 0.02724480628967285, -0.06901460886001587, 0.08839951455593109, -0.01763727515935898, 0.07651599496603012, 0.032718535512685776, -0.00916171446442604, 0.0016470005502924323, 0.05845700949430466, 0.06136791780591011, -0.01479250192642212, -0.07823770493268967, 0.012553040869534016, -0.045980218797922134, -0.02150818146765232, -0.02911517024040222, -0.037670910358428955, 0.012365479953587055, -0.010996393859386444, -0.05208529531955719, 0.023189572617411613, 0.004679403733462095, -0.01580413058400154, 0.07094027101993561, 0.0756697878241539, 0.014270063489675522, 0.033567607402801514, 0.006577149499207735, 0.009209275245666504, -0.021603882312774658, 0.03946441039443016, 0.004349064081907272, -0.003367739263921976, 0.04347899556159973, 0.015477295033633709, 0.027983199805021286, 0.007339315488934517, -0.04103683680295944, 0.09924536198377609, -0.012226765975356102, -0.004917938262224197, 0.0015838445397093892, -0.020835764706134796, -0.019666466861963272, 0.03161543235182762, -0.010101797990500927, -0.05417364835739136, 0.022641826421022415, -0.010553418658673763, -0.0011491149198263884, 0.005565747618675232, -0.022738682106137276, 0.011300801299512386, -0.033617593348026276, 0.03600814938545227, 0.061286766082048416, -0.01255723275244236, 0.004071407485753298, -0.054789748042821884, 0.006733017507940531, -0.011728154495358467, 0.0029587491881102324, -0.02279816009104252, 0.050446052104234695, 0.018442202359437943, 0.03456656634807587, -0.04487745836377144, -0.027999045327305794, 0.0017906945431604981, -0.012030575424432755, 0.06384590268135071, 0.07268920540809631, 0.00761202210560441, -0.039706721901893616, 0.037661850452423096, -0.005987090989947319, -0.07051253318786621, 0.025460049510002136, 0.007385906297713518, -0.017251748591661453, -0.028211550787091255, 0.0457901768386364, -0.02855185605585575, -0.006218383088707924, 0.04803775995969772, 0.015220764093101025, 0.04837567359209061, -0.00566901033744216, -0.08723316341638565, -0.04421282187104225, -0.006042229011654854, -0.018894709646701813, 0.011486474424600601, -0.033743392676115036, 0.03581859916448593, 0.042309463024139404, 0.01937488093972206, 0.0024627235252410173, 0.006388799287378788, -0.05526280403137207, -0.009425626136362553, 0.00814665388315916, -0.00619494030252099, -0.002818459877744317, 0.006590265315026045, -0.03143717721104622, -0.010365903377532959, -0.06985751539468765, 0.02221585251390934, 0.006022286601364613, -0.003955062944442034, -0.031089521944522858, 0.02801612950861454, -0.018530776724219322, -0.02152181789278984, -0.03103075735270977, 0.04185329005122185, -0.04275444149971008, 0.09859222918748856, 0.016460038721561432, -0.0007796299760229886, -0.00886087492108345, -0.010746695101261139, 0.015772532671689987, 0.04503965750336647, 0.04092464968562126, 0.03175901994109154, -0.04407009482383728, -0.03356330841779709, 0.001294997869990766, 0.0024224738590419292, 0.009383692406117916, -0.011083697900176048, -0.0024114924017339945, -0.03558740019798279, 0.0021049566566944122, -0.013354948721826077, 0.021992754191160202, -0.006338852923363447, -0.0169062502682209, 0.0331152006983757, -0.039906494319438934, 0.004140870179980993, -0.06809491664171219, -0.013418314047157764, -0.03830033540725708, -0.03407607972621918, 0.019736802205443382, 0.03249095007777214, -0.0013650659238919616, -0.007717421278357506, -0.01038573682308197, -0.013494167476892471, -0.0408921055495739, 0.017656655982136726, -0.029348192736506462, -0.020246589556336403, 0.05990735813975334, 0.06215803697705269, 0.008084705099463463, 0.020542221143841743, -0.03716077283024788, -0.04762266203761101, 0.01623292826116085, -0.0719471275806427, 0.032152388244867325, -0.006444253493100405, 0.0270246472209692, 0.0082939974963665, 0.031263966113328934, -0.04949086159467697, 0.023242279887199402, -0.04905223101377487, 0.03438175097107887, 0.10985894501209259, 0.04904212802648544, -0.005371682345867157, 0.008736327290534973, 0.02240300551056862, 0.01951991394162178, -0.01638573408126831, -0.014298972673714161, -0.06705720722675323, 0.01316365972161293, 0.01513930968940258, 0.021404661238193512, -0.03659360483288765, 0.028273930773139, 0.0016597539652138948, 0.02523464523255825, 0.024468718096613884, 0.008016793988645077, -0.021764470264315605, -0.0335363931953907, 0.008741054683923721, 0.025299983099102974, 0.024845853447914124, 0.011572725139558315, 0.008349936455488205, -0.002548696007579565, 0.017292333766818047, -0.014860580675303936, -0.029150178655982018, 0.03799724206328392, -0.004646391607820988, -0.010854321531951427, 0.01363553386181593, -0.013302206061780453, 0.036249928176403046, -0.032291628420352936, -0.004214202053844929, 0.04671536386013031, -0.04742557182908058, -0.03467017784714699, 0.02185909077525139, -0.020522184669971466, 0.015910053625702858, 0.019380610436201096, -0.049063071608543396, -0.012886233627796173, 0.015526056289672852, -0.019958799704909325, -0.0003173283184878528, -0.01712954230606556, -0.0066022067330777645, -0.02272668108344078, 0.03377264738082886, 0.03378680720925331, 0.025997746735811234, 0.02148144505918026, -0.013963131234049797, -0.04212355241179466, -0.013379119336605072, -0.019989237189292908, 0.01383688859641552, 0.0108664995059371, -0.040305305272340775, 0.01982371136546135, -0.03127361461520195, -0.04855126887559891, 0.024297496303915977, -0.019450655207037926, 0.010176579467952251, 0.02364552766084671, -0.00830037146806717, -0.04293527081608772, -0.0002143514866475016, -0.012189284898340702, 0.04767001420259476, -0.04004574194550514, -0.019367868080735207, 0.031104395166039467, 0.03266653046011925, -0.007605306338518858, 0.013031931594014168, -0.02668059431016445, -0.06411167979240417, -0.026287684217095375, -0.003056510118767619, 0.04633278027176857, 0.007557673379778862, 0.020940877497196198, 0.03307849541306496, -0.025084517896175385, -0.017863228917121887, -0.05836201086640358, -0.057246532291173935, 0.02261967957019806, 0.012333806604146957, 0.03282248228788376, 0.014373877085745335, 0.00043760568951256573, 0.06244266778230667, 0.028658617287874222, -0.04512624070048332, -0.019856534898281097, 0.003802541410550475, -0.007295968942344189, -0.012890363112092018, 0.025024648755788803, 0.011820519343018532, -0.01894640177488327, -0.017714451998472214, 0.04310350492596626, 0.014834833331406116, 0.05264302343130112, -0.03197723254561424, -0.00989809911698103, 0.05375188589096069, 0.010480441153049469, -0.028218615800142288, 0.051937270909547806, -0.0028341945726424456, -0.05215685814619064, -0.019378799945116043, -0.006291328463703394, 0.03409142419695854, -0.012566149234771729, -0.05016326904296875, 0.022117113694548607, 0.009745585732161999, -0.024976840242743492, -0.059911422431468964, 0.012542206794023514, 0.034827250987291336, -0.04763762280344963, 0.030993632972240448, 0.050562746822834015, 0.02598065882921219, -0.04562139883637428, 0.0040678768418729305, 0.03828836977481842, 0.03395136073231697, -0.03638305515050888, -0.036348819732666016, -0.00007046443352010101, -0.007766377180814743, 0.0476103313267231, -0.028726598247885704, 0.01598266139626503, 0.01727364771068096, 0.005290736444294453, 0.03070608712732792, 0.018713874742388725, -0.03300665691494942, 0.010745637118816376, -0.04922066628932953, 0.02612791396677494, -0.018752137199044228, 0.07068366557359695, 0.009099609218537807, 0.0628809779882431, -0.026469552889466286, 0.0072900066152215, -0.012273386120796204, 0.01316283643245697, -0.060584478080272675, 0.010872511193156242, -0.01795830763876438, -0.002932914299890399, -0.011952374130487442, -0.004680202808231115, 0.027262115851044655, -0.0020994525402784348, -0.03125710040330887, -0.013214408420026302, 0.008275116793811321, -0.023406416177749634, -0.0019459492759779096, -0.02365175075829029, -0.04613218083977699, -0.021807268261909485, -0.013155431486666203, -0.011487162671983242, 0.0018043331801891327, 0.038696955889463425, 0.012050176039338112, 0.04089684784412384, -0.0069219027645885944, -0.03767489269375801, 0.012233360670506954, 0.03685075417160988, 0.025913482531905174, 0.027467044070363045, 0.019311312586069107, 0.005050101783126593, 0.00893493928015232, 0.00026492681354284286, 0.06754008680582047, 0.023629890754818916, -0.01870158687233925, 0.020668158307671547, -0.05817144736647606, -0.015302670188248158, -0.011416742578148842, 0.01399021502584219, 0.016278669238090515, 0.0190263818949461, 0.06113053485751152, 0.013783667236566544, -0.04256439581513405, 0.047768354415893555, 0.04030260443687439, -0.019122712314128876, -0.022721651941537857, 0.015033888630568981, 0.022983532398939133, -0.025045612826943398, -0.02088914066553116, 0.0002353276067879051, 0.03866777941584587, 0.004246994853019714, 0.05684896185994148, 0.017708180472254753, 0.009562415070831776, -0.01423656102269888, -0.0005733900470659137, 0.010516047477722168, 0.04474230110645294, -0.01603284478187561, -0.03674161061644554, 0.03257638216018677, 0.021112648770213127, 0.015350785106420517, 0.02686321921646595, -0.004197782836854458, -0.08486201614141464, 0.015362866222858429, 0.03732972964644432, 0.02210763841867447, -0.006559732370078564, -0.022209560498595238, -0.04367231950163841, -0.006455590017139912, 0.00813852809369564, 0.006199055351316929, 0.01973932422697544, -0.03368614241480827, 0.017807021737098694, -0.011346295475959778, -0.04294523969292641, -0.001043719588778913, 0.04307561740279198, -0.011466298252344131, -0.005649210419505835, -0.017591742798686028, 0.040647801011800766, -0.04509780928492546, 0.010308636352419853, 0.007335869129747152, 0.0856713131070137, 0.016022542491555214, -0.02829774096608162, -0.005091333761811256, 0.03240036591887474, -0.00784617755562067, -0.05479195713996887, 0.015698155388236046, 0.03336910530924797, -0.004186195787042379, 0.05402802675962448, -0.02367609180510044, 0.014135953038930893, -0.001060093054547906, -0.021760758012533188, -0.04360688477754593, 0.026850730180740356, -0.005354465916752815, 0.05858854576945305, 0.030179543420672417, -0.03586960211396217, 0.024556316435337067, 0.04521667957305908, -0.024024702608585358, -0.032330140471458435, -0.025680726394057274, 0.0411820113658905, -0.039901748299598694, -0.02356913313269615, -0.05051204934716225, 0.00720955990254879, -0.01884712278842926, 0.006971894297748804, -0.011815665289759636, 0.02504417859017849, -0.009809449315071106, -0.02798825316131115, -0.006204175762832165, 0.018736466765403748, 0.015124872326850891, 0.03853514418005943, -0.0032769902609288692, 0.01982184126973152, 0.028641346842050552, -0.01774671860039234, 0.05072612315416336, 0.006965976674109697, -0.005359796341508627, 0.003669274505227804, -0.01795128360390663, 0.006058109924197197, -0.05504812300205231, -0.012394954450428486, 0.007551508955657482, -0.029291629791259766, 0.04092741385102272, 0.001475631375797093, 0.04023578763008118, 0.02796964719891548, -0.05337277799844742, -0.03832389414310455, 0.013242216780781746, 0.008164417929947376, 0.008575593121349812, -0.03134842962026596, 0.04506203904747963, -0.037314556539058685, -0.013722075149416924, -0.0756688341498375, -0.04450227692723274, 0.023005258291959763, -0.01742437109351158, -0.03206982836127281, -0.050359103828668594, 0.00589999184012413, 0.005442310590296984, -0.03023143671452999, 0.04764164611697197, 0.03774761036038399, -0.003395572304725647, -0.014193026348948479, -0.012606436386704445, 0.0014202747261151671, 0.0876716673374176, 0.008090568706393242, 0.0027099084109067917, -0.006475701928138733, 0.011293451301753521, 0.009527713060379028, 0.01200838852673769, 0.04717834293842316, -0.01502050831913948, 0.028937503695487976, 0.0032082735560834408, 0.0027245813980698586, 0.06527280807495117, -0.06663662195205688, -0.028837325051426888, -0.016872446984052658, 0.00560875004157424, -0.004864197224378586, -0.019228581339120865, 0.011725006625056267, -0.016335060819983482, 0.007132008671760559, -0.02451697178184986, 0.003984904382377863, 0.0027999572921544313, 0.003491549752652645, -0.0037586470134556293, 0.017310017719864845, -0.018433284014463425, 0.04604198783636093, 0.053047869354486465, -0.004276961553841829, -0.005789776798337698, 0.031080109998583794, -0.010990829207003117, 0.01794344373047352, -0.034081973135471344, -0.004030491225421429, 0.03471418097615242, 0.01634175144135952, -0.028878232464194298, 0.025657011196017265, -0.053052693605422974, 0.0027535634580999613, 0.022983072325587273, -0.0020009377039968967, 0.053425468504428864, 0.027976617217063904, 0.0040282076224684715, 0.014385096728801727, 0.009999356232583523, -0.0054123601876199245, -0.028743380680680275, 0.00025986271793954074, 0.05222552642226219, -0.03665884956717491, -0.004211971070617437, 0.04311886802315712, 0.008249237202107906, -0.009737953543663025, 0.028261039406061172, -0.027684947475790977, -0.004804522730410099, 0.019177565351128578, -0.009173423983156681, -0.03247993811964989, 0.04309064522385597, -0.02510908618569374, 0.046236395835876465, -0.0068323551677167416, -0.04642525687813759, 0.03606421500444412, 0.009324484504759312, -0.008178254589438438, -0.04018440097570419, -0.000028136859327787533, -0.033252209424972534, 0.037150729447603226, 0.028188101947307587, 0.03262709081172943, -0.0031730234622955322, -0.012301627546548843, 0.0363486222922802, -0.012098131701350212, 0.02981293573975563, -0.014706872403621674, -0.07480688393115997, -0.02402847819030285, -0.03618346154689789, -0.03267423063516617, 0.011391369625926018, -0.004281122237443924, -0.026747865602374077, -0.0049619488418102264, -0.01800811104476452, 0.017722081393003464, 0.015933312475681305, 0.028144102543592453, 0.004644346889108419, 0.08837636560201645, -0.008201348595321178, 0.015044084750115871, 0.011159448884427547, -0.019637318328022957, 0.1195095106959343, 0.05736418068408966, 0.017730046063661575, -0.05466179922223091, -0.004535709973424673, 0.004905791953206062, 0.024086574092507362, -0.013280617073178291, 0.053319014608860016, 0.02344408445060253, -0.009413613937795162, 0.03480259329080582, 0.04502520710229874, -0.008834009058773518, 0.011948016472160816, 0.05562739819288254, -0.012875977903604507, -0.02947920933365822, -0.005362187046557665, 0.030574174597859383, -0.010888203978538513, 0.019717568531632423, -0.09164011478424072, 0.009444894269108772, -0.004331548698246479, 0.00016470506670884788, -0.02209373190999031, -0.013241106644272804, 0.022210869938135147, -0.010400018654763699, -0.03565078601241112, -0.027899229899048805, 0.0555792860686779, -0.00520242378115654, -0.005996373947709799, -0.027781259268522263, -0.003477483056485653, -0.025625795125961304, -0.0051763057708740234, 0.058180712163448334, 0.032419342547655106, 0.008634790778160095, 0.02662454918026924, 0.0070873647928237915, -0.03450099378824234, -0.011057227849960327, -0.05080193653702736, -0.00008934259676607326, -0.018512841314077377, 0.010043993592262268, -0.009275641292333603, -0.003892980283126235, -0.007364301476627588, -0.03556514158844948, -0.048364605754613876, -0.02936564013361931, 0.03841733559966087, -0.011761504225432873, -0.027253713458776474, -0.023107271641492844, 0.03387852758169174, -0.03142319992184639, 0.02072312869131565, -0.015920650213956833, -0.023209575563669205, -0.03633581101894379, -0.045847345143556595, 0.05237424746155739, -0.01766764186322689, -0.023719333112239838, -0.006232771556824446, -0.03426077961921692, -0.02523401379585266, 0.01520045567303896, -0.0055987536907196045, 0.006502292584627867, 0.0216542836278677, 0.029610639438033104, 0.010741590522229671, 0.018868958577513695, -0.014974165707826614, 0.033429067581892014, -0.01903567649424076, -0.0016310624778270721, -0.040266457945108414, 0.017632998526096344, 0.03783267363905907, 0.052448760718107224, -0.016513347625732422, 0.04335583373904228, -0.02452695555984974, 0.020011039450764656, 0.029164312407374382, -0.03990628570318222, 0.0012306610587984324, 0.0109410984441638, -0.01828891411423683, -0.01257060095667839, -0.012949853204190731, 0.05396921932697296, 0.013645288534462452, 0.03564509004354477, -0.023316655308008194, 0.043776027858257294, 0.01685769110918045, 0.06329906731843948, -0.021158168092370033, -0.062126606702804565, 0.018089573830366135, 0.024258768185973167, -0.025107575580477715, -0.029292913153767586, -0.037264127284288406, -0.006919908337295055, -0.0065773711539804935, -0.011558049358427525, -0.0014483877457678318, -0.019617045298218727, -0.048578474670648575, -0.043743737041950226, 0.010297977365553379, -0.01820988953113556, 0.00007276191900018603, -0.03139558807015419, -0.028600675985217094, -0.014487536624073982, -0.041678525507450104, -0.0008113521034829319, 0.025642991065979004, 0.013926888816058636, 0.015582236461341381, 0.030004998669028282, 0.048496514558792114, 0.011043313890695572, -0.015445820055902004, 0.01396835595369339, 0.005968883633613586, 0.03982199355959892, -0.034414030611515045, 0.012759802863001823, 0.019418274983763695, -0.03421350568532944, -0.003360638627782464, -0.007830072194337845, 0.018647558987140656, 0.023679647594690323, -0.03303568810224533, -0.019029907882213593, -0.019907737150788307, 0.055110301822423935, -0.033687859773635864, -0.0048887827433645725, -0.013974414207041264, -0.01735352911055088, 0.0032598800025880337, -0.00041911721928045154, -0.004767987411469221, 0.01627178303897381, 0.0007776902639307082, 0.018924210220575333, 0.01327280793339014, 0.02184249646961689, -0.003588584018871188, 0.020571786910295486, -0.008792337030172348, 0.02360428497195244, 0.03253616392612457, 0.01164449006319046, 0.06981823593378067, 0.018328294157981873, -0.03772762417793274, 0.02128850296139717, 0.010541806928813457, 0.021215079352259636, -0.08168499916791916, -0.01830350235104561, 0.02857372723519802, 0.01736011914908886, 0.03512328490614891, -0.06784283369779587, -0.025534486398100853, 0.005766622722148895, -0.04190269857645035, 0.03079761564731598, -0.0005048791645094752, -0.012725342065095901, -0.011946016922593117, 0.004865961614996195, 0.0068221259862184525, 0.07152135670185089, 0.010724671185016632, 0.054435014724731445, 0.02304806187748909, 0.028414631262421608, -0.010088016279041767, 0.019230656325817108, -0.04794248193502426, -0.021618613973259926, 0.010935124941170216, -0.0802726149559021, 0.044935766607522964, -0.024847010150551796, -0.03575177863240242, 0.04680011048913002, 0.034473717212677, 0.0012257039779797196, 0.026579786092042923, 0.031453341245651245, 0.030784549191594124, 0.02258206717669964, 0.017337262630462646, -0.0332510769367218, -0.0064925868064165115, -0.0058367601595819, 0.02488568425178528, 0.039986174553632736, -0.02706207148730755, -0.004942631348967552, 0.044237591326236725, -0.027783870697021484, -0.048858270049095154, 0.049958735704422, -0.005050556734204292, -0.059683334082365036, -0.03873775526881218, -0.02715320698916912, 0.02502432093024254, 0.006513523403555155, 0.043747372925281525, -0.06929807364940643, -0.03188834711909294, 0.01938481628894806, 0.012333612889051437, 0.010899255983531475, 0.04502689838409424, 0.0009321546531282365, -0.03901702165603638, -0.02974003367125988, 0.00899941474199295, -0.007877331227064133, -0.04537411034107208, 0.029895970597863197, -0.01606377214193344, 0.0026781922206282616, -0.004771263338625431, -0.06616435199975967, -0.011042352765798569, 0.021503260359168053, -0.008605514653027058, -0.020400522276759148, 0.05549202859401703, -0.01487033162266016, 0.020855756476521492, -0.07118230313062668, 0.02815588004887104, 0.004767142701894045, -0.033810172230005264, -0.05807197466492653, 0.012634246610105038, -0.029935412108898163, -0.003181141335517168, 0.04699690639972687, -0.009395365603268147, 0.006735960952937603, -0.03694326803088188, 0.042071159929037094, 0.038906171917915344, -0.04868893697857857, -0.003167482791468501, -0.050565920770168304, -0.018342675641179085, -0.024341100826859474, 0.0021046013571321964, -0.006072807591408491, 0.040955908596515656, 0.005381105467677116, -0.01072476152330637, -0.0006338373059406877, -0.0016230368055403233, -0.033028531819581985, 0.0021481425501406193, 0.01905650645494461, -0.03520239517092705, 0.06117343157529831, -0.05365369841456413, -0.01723647676408291, 0.004803095478564501, 0.01889255829155445, -0.02574741654098034, 0.04611553996801376, 0.007394025102257729, -0.01616879366338253, -0.033961474895477295, -0.016236232593655586, 0.021798687055706978, -0.06839217245578766, -0.006979925557971001, 0.004529813304543495, -0.03185836598277092, -0.004630791489034891, 0.0033332016319036484, 0.027918798848986626, 0.06355790048837662, 0.010183008387684822, -0.010474186390638351, -0.015008862130343914, -0.033846303820610046, 0.0037817556876689196, 0.008615371771156788, 0.016830457374453545, -0.03049335815012455, -0.007994894869625568, -0.00250679487362504, -0.018107809126377106, 0.03901283070445061, 0.015055486001074314, 0.03445269167423248, -0.026905734091997147, 0.02366374246776104, 0.025179464370012283, -0.003167347516864538, 0.015040585771203041, 0.01952098309993744, -0.033378105610609055, 0.061070848256349564, -0.00333756604231894, 0.053417086601257324, -0.008138441480696201, -0.02362236939370632, -0.06397150456905365, -0.010221513919532299, 0.015902452170848846, 0.024121547117829323, -0.03088400699198246, -0.0022695830557495356, -0.014453544281423092, -0.022613350301980972, 0.029966264963150024, -0.01955472119152546, 0.0396401584148407, -0.006816389504820108, -0.007999293506145477, 0.001121432869695127, -0.024580396711826324, -0.027778640389442444, -0.025820497423410416, 0.041405513882637024, 0.07294207066297531, 0.04132482409477234, 0.010541061870753765, -0.027667216956615448, 0.002315618097782135, 0.05594019964337349, -0.07772034406661987, -0.019848160445690155, -0.051088348031044006, 0.01886095106601715, 0.014049801044166088, 0.0019583157263696194 ]
<p><strong>Modified question to better explain the context of my problem:</strong></p> <p>I am studying young stars. When a star is born, it is surrounded by a disk of dust called "protoplanetary disk". Planets form in these disks, so understanding how they evolve gives information on plaent formation. Current theories and observations suggest that every star is born with one of these disks. However, different processes make these disks dissipate in about 10 million years. The usual way to study this subject is to study the fraction of stars with protoplanetary disks at different ages to see how dissipate. Past studies have found "hints" of massive stars loosing their disks earlier than low-mass stars, and therefore they may form different planetary systems. My aim is to determine the truthfulness of this dependence with stellar mass.</p> <p>To study these disks, we look at the flux measured at infrared wavelengths. When you know the type of star is (lets say, you know its temperature), you can apply a stellar model. If the flux you measure is signicalty higher (defined in some way) than the expected from the stellar model (a naked star), that could mean you have additional infrared flux emited by the protoplanetary disk. Also, you need an age estimate for the star, and another one for the stellar mass if you want to compare different masses. So, there are several sources of uncertainties:</p> <ul> <li><p>errors from the infrared measurements</p></li> <li><p>errors from the estimated temperature of the star</p></li> <li><p>errors from the age estimate</p></li> <li><p>errors from the mass estimate.</p></li> </ul> <p>The origin and behaviour of these uncertainties are very complicated, and usually not included in the calculations.</p> <p>I have built a large sample of young stars, and I want to see which evidence there is of the stellar mass affecting the evolution/dissipation of protoplanetary disks. To do so, I have subdivided the sample in two mass and ages bins (the cuts having some physical meaning). As a result, I have four bins: "young low-mass", "young high-mass", "old young-mass", "old low-mass". Computing the % of protoplanetary disks for each of these bins is simple, but that is not enough prove or discard the mass influence. On the other hand, assigning errors to that % by error propagation is extremely complicated. Usually, one assumes simple Poisson errors, but that is not correct as it does not account for these uncertainties. That is why I thought I could use bootstrapping, and vary these quantities within reasonable ranges during the iterations to account for them. </p> <p>As a result of that process, I end up with a list of % values for each bin, and therefore I can get statistical quantities from them (mean, standard deviation,…). They also provide and estimate of the correspoding PDFs.</p> <p><em>I would like to know how to quantify the statistical evidence of these bins having different protoplanetary disk fractions, which translates into evidence of stellar mass having an impact on their evolution.</em></p> <p>This is an example of the outcome. sample1 is "young, low-mass stars". sample2 is "young, high-mass stars". And their means and standard deviations are:</p> <p>sample1: 61 +- 2</p> <p>sample2: 47 +- 5 </p> <p>also, these are the obtained PDFs.</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/mMnIx.png" alt="enter image description here"></p>
36,447
[ -0.01739274337887764, -0.025561723858118057, -0.040311820805072784, -0.016718130558729172, 0.05390669032931328, -0.021344460546970367, -0.020018242299556732, -0.02358042076230049, 0.003006445011124015, -0.022828076034784317, 0.031104424968361855, 0.03298797085881233, 0.051676828414201736, 0.04060647636651993, -0.0037614984903484583, 0.03532032668590546, -0.012196213006973267, -0.036489032208919525, -0.028922555968165398, 0.019687995314598083, -0.01858157478272915, 0.01566452533006668, 0.021559007465839386, 0.01137221697717905, -0.046335600316524506, 0.016120480373501778, 0.03136178478598595, -0.029270092025399208, -0.012041316367685795, 0.061535436660051346, -0.045400746166706085, -0.009605476632714272, 0.030962882563471794, 0.027224594727158546, 0.038688983768224716, 0.016561945900321007, -0.005590544082224369, 0.001365087111480534, -0.0275874063372612, 0.04312659054994583, -0.0527101494371891, 0.017451459541916847, -0.002450833097100258, -0.00847379956394434, 0.014187455177307129, 0.00039022494456730783, -0.0042825983837246895, 0.017287790775299072, 0.044136326760053635, -0.043475762009620667, 0.026667002588510513, 0.012099024839699268, 0.02523990534245968, 0.042208898812532425, -0.02884131856262684, 0.0047331517562270164, 0.0669572502374649, 0.09488976746797562, -0.001257662777788937, -0.04457036405801773, -0.004356100223958492, 0.016131972894072533, 0.0019831706304103136, -0.028104739263653755, -0.016262006014585495, 0.016954611986875534, -0.013563420623540878, -0.008770464919507504, 0.03282630071043968, 0.023089788854122162, 0.033277466893196106, -0.015929780900478363, -0.01397536601871252, 0.002593242796137929, 0.015524831600487232, -0.03856939077377319, -0.003616637783125043, 0.02938207983970642, 0.049380071461200714, 0.033034153282642365, -0.025830144062638283, 0.02839774824678898, 0.0284521896392107, 0.011623186059296131, 0.012446373701095581, -0.006354986224323511, 0.05099668726325035, -0.018847698345780373, 0.018404416739940643, 0.008064739406108856, -0.019537271931767464, 0.017959419637918472, 0.04976862296462059, -0.012989696115255356, 0.02660890854895115, -0.00221959943883121, -0.022264791652560234, 0.0175898689776659, -0.056081611663103104, -0.022477176040410995, 0.01562894880771637, 0.013326985761523247, 0.02754213847219944, 0.07180076837539673, -0.002716140355914831, -0.017585204914212227, -0.05133635550737381, -0.02510383166372776, -0.02680378220975399, -0.05175970122218132, -0.011127335019409657, 0.023866133764386177, -0.023085027933120728, 0.010374510660767555, -0.0212713610380888, -0.04014893248677254, 0.02672985941171646, -0.022305728867650032, 0.05840093642473221, 0.04061618074774742, 0.03485653176903725, -0.05050528049468994, -0.003988403361290693, -0.01876075007021427, -0.02342718467116356, 0.016889261081814766, 0.03289014846086502, -0.01778719201683998, -0.022839199751615524, 0.02925417758524418, -0.0008934979559853673, -0.026660917326807976, 0.03229321166872978, -0.04479354992508888, -0.007980368100106716, -0.007083171047270298, -0.07919008284807205, -0.05909009650349617, 0.01810614950954914, -0.013636114075779915, -0.025879735127091408, -0.03845905885100365, 0.020118461921811104, 0.036988403648138046, 0.09112096577882767, 0.008978479541838169, 0.015694353729486465, -0.0024151229299604893, 0.06832747906446457, -0.003851484041661024, -0.020180724561214447, -0.010680615901947021, -0.01671864464879036, 0.0021359380334615707, -0.022665370255708694, -0.06789630651473999, 0.019181396812200546, 0.025675229728221893, -0.009641684591770172, 0.0051622455939650536, 0.015712108463048935, -0.04187694564461708, -0.005728770978748798, 0.01955009065568447, 0.05623667687177658, -0.029510097578167915, 0.07597818970680237, 0.014321217313408852, -0.02125345543026924, 0.013795365579426289, -0.025620456784963608, 0.005282612983137369, 0.023659417405724525, 0.009657085873186588, 0.06180436536669731, -0.011349902488291264, -0.019322853535413742, -0.059432484209537506, 0.019494876265525818, 0.0031303558498620987, -0.041254933923482895, -0.03767726570367813, -0.040583088994026184, -0.022091740742325783, 0.034486010670661926, 0.03745890036225319, 0.018973274156451225, 0.0016177725046873093, 0.04168080538511276, -0.03966319561004639, -0.013624628074467182, -0.05010067671537399, 0.004460434895008802, 0.009175557643175125, -0.015510751865804195, 0.00317873596213758, -0.011231926269829273, 0.016664670780301094, 0.006064102053642273, -0.005259204190224409, -0.0049773710779845715, 0.026782551780343056, 0.026466216892004013, 0.003483058651909232, 0.02539064548909664, 0.043598439544439316, 0.05565828084945679, -0.012145313434302807, 0.02831065095961094, -0.023890582844614983, -0.04993140324950218, -0.002806171542033553, -0.039615340530872345, -0.009706221520900726, 0.006513656582683325, -0.005994612351059914, 0.016529759392142296, 0.00960182398557663, 0.035470105707645416, -0.01127361599355936, -0.017713405191898346, 0.09361668676137924, 0.035020098090171814, 0.0007101040682755411, -0.016215138137340546, 0.03532502055168152, 0.016861481592059135, 0.031760118901729584, -0.06516803056001663, -0.014093561097979546, -0.05878157913684845, -0.00963438581675291, 0.03255041688680649, 0.025321634486317635, -0.05258728936314583, 0.010248872451484203, 0.05760940909385681, -0.004048772156238556, 0.010786209255456924, -0.022602103650569916, -0.028366317972540855, -0.040123168379068375, 0.0608205683529377, -0.023390602320432663, 0.03318840265274048, 0.045801348984241486, 0.03771882504224777, 0.021885327994823456, 0.00855723675340414, -0.025532618165016174, -0.0007390480022877455, 0.012469112873077393, -0.011859158053994179, -0.01017619390040636, -0.01686857081949711, -0.02273889258503914, 0.018145138397812843, -0.01407475396990776, 0.014707203954458237, 0.026658743619918823, 0.006153882015496492, 0.007179696578532457, -0.006745775230228901, 0.009220905601978302, 0.050146475434303284, 0.012252925895154476, -0.006270097568631172, -0.00940016470849514, 0.012319774366915226, -0.018942050635814667, 0.03774963319301605, -0.022777056321501732, -0.02785654179751873, -0.03782622888684273, -0.014935738407075405, 0.027209866791963577, -0.009891807101666927, 0.033516064286231995, -0.032257359474897385, 0.006371797062456608, -0.005578453652560711, -0.02720978856086731, -0.008876186795532703, 0.0355054996907711, -0.08141525089740753, -0.0023892775643616915, -0.028128797188401222, -0.043050602078437805, 0.017326388508081436, 0.012032381258904934, 0.014053525403141975, 0.02458631806075573, 0.010103145614266396, -0.019661862403154373, -0.006835476495325565, -0.011631240136921406, -0.048019394278526306, -0.024222610518336296, 0.02288082055747509, 0.016272971406579018, -0.02241579256951809, -0.03806328400969505, 0.037703901529312134, -0.05143395811319351, -0.018471848219633102, -0.030562402680516243, -0.036544039845466614, -0.008978987112641335, -0.007227436173707247, 0.030753880739212036, 0.02162066288292408, 0.023006515577435493, -0.00930691696703434, -0.02459399215877056, -0.026711534708738327, 0.03529180586338043, -0.03387587517499924, 0.037029825150966644, -0.0030502162408083677, -0.009431167505681515, 0.06052449718117714, 0.030038949102163315, 0.020126108080148697, -0.044628456234931946, 0.021184882149100304, -0.0015734527260065079, -0.00954840425401926, 0.02627270668745041, -0.04067373648285866, -0.004113825969398022, 0.008491996675729752, 0.002121721161529422, -0.018689710646867752, 0.02683398313820362, 0.008515983819961548, -0.0012163460487499833, 0.011960417032241821, -0.020123979076743126, -0.004390657879412174, 0.07432183623313904, 0.0017502829432487488, -0.005462548229843378, 0.04036027565598488, -0.02634798362851143, 0.07984798401594162, 0.027079423889517784, -0.06961669772863388, 0.014567630365490913, -0.028174009174108505, -0.018656045198440552, -0.024088382720947266, 0.018409334123134613, -0.0035242498852312565, -0.01464064046740532, 0.03360952436923981, 0.010706710629165173, 0.05350223183631897, 0.018218282610177994, -0.0012292943429201841, 0.03764013200998306, 0.014532124623656273, 0.011209428310394287, 0.024934357032179832, -0.005511339288204908, -0.031658709049224854, 0.010527128353714943, -0.05490945652127266, -0.012657934799790382, 0.06315431743860245, 0.03939300402998924, -0.007066864054650068, -0.009950011037290096, -0.022961756214499474, -0.0028482878115028143, -0.06509493291378021, -0.0019348664209246635, -0.025091182440519333, 0.06044476851820946, 0.00425117090344429, 0.02069152146577835, 0.003604746423661709, 0.009803961962461472, 0.0011292537674307823, -0.020457541570067406, -0.08869802951812744, 0.013096386566758156, 0.024032525718212128, -0.04415792226791382, -0.03871440142393112, -0.0044487654231488705, -0.024787431582808495, -0.05757696554064751, 0.018599195405840874, -0.021030906587839127, 0.02181752771139145, -0.026751233264803886, 0.023650644347071648, -0.02470310963690281, -0.019793130457401276, -0.009801646694540977, 0.04465340077877045, 0.07852373272180557, -0.021320927888154984, 0.052812542766332626, 0.008902110159397125, 0.011408839374780655, -0.026212122291326523, -0.05914733186364174, 0.013457372784614563, -0.00008249048551078886, 0.04804051294922829, 0.01596677117049694, 0.02474604733288288, -0.03174060583114624, 0.01708325743675232, 0.0354941189289093, 0.046586327254772186, 0.03480721637606621, -0.0018737413920462132, -0.012378226034343243, -0.008471609093248844, 0.017371296882629395, 0.020102892071008682, 0.04995030537247658, -0.04902465268969536, -0.002874471712857485, -0.005477581638842821, 0.004591897130012512, -0.0166849996894598, 0.00699149863794446, 0.053467899560928345, -0.0169394388794899, 0.0086797084659338, -0.042219217866659164, -0.03636263683438301, -0.027236267924308777, -0.0057785785757005215, 0.020156852900981903, 0.04673442244529724, 0.031304776668548584, -0.021104924380779266, 0.03505915775895119, 0.0025612383615225554, -0.060053497552871704, 0.013234540820121765, -0.03199530020356178, 0.04286913573741913, -0.0416756272315979, 0.006789631210267544, 0.014785700477659702, 0.05221527814865112, 0.04167133942246437, -0.01595187745988369, 0.030604977160692215, -0.08690924942493439, -0.04425526410341263, 0.04202398657798767, 0.031195329502224922, 0.0010904342634603381, -0.025174563750624657, -0.05264025181531906, -0.017428191378712654, 0.054905958473682404, 0.004030163865536451, 0.057127442210912704, -0.014677675440907478, 0.012546529062092304, 0.028963850811123848, -0.015175089240074158, -0.014622502028942108, 0.002402103040367365, -0.0016000480391085148, 0.013139110058546066, -0.06080085039138794, 0.002947006141766906, -0.017518658190965652, -0.01157980877906084, 0.039866480976343155, 0.04627338424324989, -0.037356648594141006, -0.026898149400949478, 0.03784392029047012, -0.021113445982336998, -0.037143196910619736, -0.04029684513807297, 0.0170550886541605, -0.02918098494410515, -0.0022139307111501694, 0.032313864678144455, -0.04623900726437569, -0.0599612295627594, 0.0437813326716423, 0.001132848090492189, -0.04364651441574097, -0.0018640704220160842, -0.03261296823620796, 0.025997700169682503, 0.030635593459010124, -0.0009628343977965415, 0.06323885172605515, 0.04164551943540573, -0.04487898200750351, 0.01440348755568266, -0.050854168832302094, 0.01473427563905716, -0.03503136336803436, -0.038541316986083984, -0.04229241609573364, -0.020265592262148857, -0.03403538092970848, 0.03427537903189659, 0.007378301117569208, 0.03690828010439873, -0.007127369288355112, -0.015003212727606297, 0.03140047937631607, 0.03308430686593056, -0.020347964018583298, 0.029494427144527435, -0.0034565820824354887, 0.03449582681059837, -0.0059888046234846115, -0.004856165498495102, 0.04735170677304268, 0.025150572881102562, -0.0032239356078207493, 0.010749468579888344, -0.05187540873885155, 0.06096867844462395, -0.03720630332827568, -0.02112305723130703, 0.006053250283002853, 0.006225985009223223, 0.02907375618815422, -0.005217759869992733, 0.05301794037222862, 0.030465731397271156, -0.04845379665493965, -0.007530259899795055, -0.025529710575938225, -0.05663987249135971, 0.0006238601636141539, -0.017722703516483307, 0.006254278589040041, -0.01860697939991951, 0.0069050840102136135, -0.057725291699171066, 0.014680642634630203, 0.024124622344970703, 0.05319250747561455, -0.024242036044597626, -0.027745086699724197, 0.021087223663926125, -0.003112677950412035, -0.01943514682352543, 0.0015999000752344728, 0.04609226435422897, -0.03385702148079872, -0.012489406391978264, 0.005915402434766293, 0.02163168601691723, 0.05983103811740875, -0.035255663096904755, 0.013591456227004528, 0.01816023327410221, -0.019500073045492172, -0.006027670577168465, 0.010030766017735004, -0.013898271135985851, -0.015648705884814262, -0.04928812384605408, -0.014670747332274914, 0.03141957148909569, 0.03337963670492172, -0.019904915243387222, -0.01961798034608364, 0.05176926776766777, -0.0039765131659805775, 0.015571095049381256, -0.013214172795414925, 0.024718936532735825, -0.057211026549339294, -0.025085151195526123, -0.02871556393802166, 0.00045910209883004427, 0.013140564784407616, -0.03610936924815178, 0.04202452301979065, -0.031629160046577454, -0.008666079491376877, -0.0051977364346385, 0.03857365623116493, -0.03495888411998749, -0.03377494588494301, -0.000846480717882514, -0.021027224138379097, 0.019476644694805145, 0.015782061964273453, -0.0135914646089077, 0.004568847361952066, 0.003662356175482273, -0.03790770098567009, -0.018590452149510384, -0.041985560208559036, -0.03758743032813072, 0.08315777778625488, 0.03210856020450592, 0.04576878622174263, -0.005466809496283531, 0.0206891018897295, 0.008807077072560787, -0.03165200352668762, -0.03784044086933136, 0.02486422285437584, 0.001214246149174869, 0.015875983983278275, -0.034222912043333054, -0.013570686802268028, 0.0338696725666523, 0.008412279188632965, -0.007832708768546581, 0.045118626207113266, 0.027866479009389877, -0.00025481879129074514, 0.028809284791350365, -0.026926226913928986, -0.04436115175485611, 0.013677183538675308, -0.06506908684968948, 0.010350177064538002, -0.029519475996494293, 0.015781806781888008, 0.0523599348962307, 0.03304428979754448, 0.026417504996061325, -0.06870051473379135, -0.02455928549170494, -0.05033600330352783, 0.03459137678146362, 0.05102243646979332, -0.005811902228742838, 0.027423791587352753, 0.028908006846904755, 0.016764571890234947, -0.0148428650572896, 0.021842099726200104, -0.04663347825407982, -0.07339824736118317, -0.04466741532087326, -0.021138397976756096, -0.04301847890019417, 0.05203625559806824, -0.01355441939085722, -0.03014792501926422, 0.013280930928885937, 0.0004234683874528855, 0.01447425875812769, 0.00945567712187767, 0.037242770195007324, -0.03394617512822151, 0.02050042524933815, -0.01200457476079464, 0.011329611763358116, -0.02357526868581772, 0.05016043409705162, 0.15290546417236328, 0.04341524466872215, 0.04620765149593353, -0.03824338689446449, 0.034162215888500214, 0.041590407490730286, 0.001440850319340825, 0.023248886689543724, 0.04028560593724251, 0.0006047165370546281, -0.01587487757205963, 0.0070999604649841785, -0.013798643834888935, -0.03872152417898178, -0.031248783692717552, 0.02911553718149662, -0.04130617901682854, 0.004105918109416962, 0.009982943534851074, 0.022455407306551933, 0.002378873759880662, 0.023915983736515045, -0.044398512691259384, 0.03056757152080536, -0.003714871359989047, -0.01187476608902216, -0.015912802889943123, -0.009220080450177193, 0.0030104266479611397, 0.019678793847560883, -0.08072177320718765, 0.0367732010781765, 0.024387545883655548, -0.024273289367556572, 0.01915004663169384, 0.025110391899943352, -0.0014773767907172441, -0.02163000963628292, -0.005991999059915543, 0.019417209550738335, 0.0057215504348278046, 0.009259226731956005, 0.01224470790475607, 0.026498008519411087, -0.04216689243912697, -0.02464894764125347, -0.04792506992816925, 0.060179583728313446, 0.004967732820659876, -0.02438979782164097, -0.024425365030765533, -0.009083103388547897, 0.025293711572885513, -0.030299458652734756, 0.031229494139552116, 0.029878787696361542, 0.009486760012805462, -0.0048601930029690266, -0.052879709750413895, 0.007210726849734783, 0.04386065527796745, 0.023082908242940903, 0.02385054901242256, 0.04198191314935684, -0.02815774455666542, -0.038652513176202774, -0.027064502239227295, 0.04119861498475075, 0.016062386333942413, 0.00006794820365030318, 0.006438784301280975, -0.029572902247309685, -0.026423638686537743, -0.043110523372888565, 0.012783698737621307, 0.03565320000052452, 0.040631379932165146, 0.015580247156322002, -0.024809371680021286, -0.00981377437710762, -0.02739999070763588, -0.01807069033384323, -0.005011320114135742, -0.014666187576949596, -0.0033262595534324646, -0.037191860377788544, 0.03158227726817131, 0.01336740143597126, 0.007180183660238981, 0.039594948291778564, 0.022185388952493668, 0.0759275034070015, 0.008257069624960423, -0.05560027435421944, -0.028598664328455925, -0.0011823771055787802, -0.05045441538095474, -0.00881034042686224, -0.01658773422241211, 0.03575052693486214, 0.037207938730716705, 0.011569313704967499, 0.022731594741344452, 0.0227095577865839, -0.002922029234468937, 0.02443377487361431, -0.008637111634016037, -0.02443714253604412, 0.011531691998243332, -0.00886156689375639, 0.025975344702601433, -0.031299956142902374, -0.009882375597953796, -0.024019062519073486, -0.03817709907889366, -0.016599012538790703, -0.02389473468065262, -0.03375918045639992, 0.04482859745621681, -0.02635813318192959, -0.0036281184293329716, -0.011245864443480968, -0.012577575631439686, -0.0317138135433197, -0.0015046763001009822, 0.004279440734535456, 0.006816823501139879, -0.0011762477224692702, 0.0077807665802538395, -0.020836787298321724, -0.06357215344905853, 0.026415150612592697, -0.03645065054297447, 0.023925235494971275, 0.007076478097587824, 0.0077582006342709064, -0.014266503043472767, 0.030510371550917625, 0.002498622750863433, -0.02730242908000946, -0.0008440634119324386, -0.029555991291999817, -0.0434737429022789, 0.05147804319858551, 0.007100164424628019, 0.038192618638277054, 0.01709931343793869, -0.002016398124396801, -0.023907281458377838, 0.05175883695483208, -0.026950454339385033, -0.04900120198726654, -0.0073282476514577866, 0.002735822694376111, -0.00507487403228879, 0.028625311329960823, 0.025951549410820007, 0.00023303284251596779, -0.0015055108815431595, 0.05122753977775574, -0.004201128147542477, -0.03411749750375748, -0.024212026968598366, -0.03126625716686249, -0.012654446996748447, -0.0010637318482622504, 0.007643474731594324, 0.012029225938022137, 0.049251917749643326, 0.02841218188405037, -0.015509361401200294, 0.05620526522397995, 0.03479469195008278, -0.00983262900263071, -0.10780846327543259, -0.03322897106409073, -0.016520150005817413, 0.059738241136074066, 0.036000873893499374, -0.049012623727321625, 0.04973262920975685, 0.017138952389359474, -0.04021249711513519, -0.018774520605802536, -0.01608743518590927, 0.004165506921708584, -0.021605849266052246, -0.007465192582458258, -0.0515204481780529, -0.005617580376565456, -0.009861398488283157, 0.014652328565716743, 0.03037266992032528, 0.031139729544520378, -0.023101968690752983, -0.06536581367254257, -0.01951826922595501, -0.0034755917731672525, 0.003740790067240596, -0.030712388455867767, 0.0430489256978035, -0.015488902106881142, -0.009693972766399384, 0.007907919585704803, -0.017751965671777725, 0.03635358437895775, -0.0025467381346970797, 0.023938599973917007, 0.014689304865896702, -0.013456438668072224, 0.026262585073709488, -0.021457089111208916, 0.030754825100302696, -0.007319651544094086, -0.007815754972398281, 0.03751887381076813, -0.005861999467015266, 0.028346119448542595, 0.05396881699562073, -0.031041458249092102, 0.011226506903767586, 0.016588743776082993, -0.022978609427809715, 0.027164749801158905, -0.023059522733092308, 0.02216118760406971, -0.017661379650235176, -0.060167234390974045, 0.019144274294376373, -0.037104055285453796, 0.009089953266084194, 0.012675657868385315, 0.0473511628806591, -0.022881465032696724, 0.01573985628783703, -0.008511760272085667, -0.017570044845342636, -0.00025097327306866646, -0.022226279601454735, -0.004045392386615276, -0.0089573347941041, -0.01893855445086956, 0.014964896254241467, -0.010389839299023151, -0.030036037787795067, -0.02011261321604252, -0.08664416521787643, 0.044368959963321686, -0.03196946904063225, -0.01626923866569996, -0.0420323945581913, -0.052556440234184265, -0.010431841015815735, -0.051244910806417465, 0.039700478315353394, -0.003576611401513219, 0.005726731847971678, -0.03711613267660141, -0.0309134554117918, -0.020242121070623398, -0.0012807842576876283, 0.030074460431933403, 0.03481195867061615, -0.026730231940746307, 0.023011697456240654, -0.014556294307112694, 0.03870260342955589, -0.06467904150485992, 0.02853545919060707, -0.02295651286840439, 0.00801642332226038, 0.03143278881907463, -0.008223609067499638, 0.018041156232357025, 0.012552110478281975, 0.048295777291059494, -0.015445522964000702, 0.030729809775948524, 0.056063879281282425, -0.004774352535605431, 0.054348673671483994, -0.004908818751573563, 0.023460721597075462, 0.038491956889629364, 0.033157460391521454, 0.005971498321741819, 0.08456777036190033, 0.024550843983888626, -0.043655652552843094, 0.046593766659498215, 0.0020460353698581457, -0.005444658920168877, -0.00929850060492754, 0.0016356721753254533, -0.007073552347719669, -0.06554417312145233, -0.006981648970395327, 0.0435858890414238, -0.020467858761548996, -0.0034445866476744413, 0.045141808688640594, -0.01280189584940672, 0.03792358189821243, 0.0038894512690603733, 0.03507630154490471, 0.008149868808686733, -0.05578315258026123, -0.011721877381205559, 0.005836328025907278, 0.015744557604193687, 0.019238943234086037, 0.05163711681962013, 0.008227331563830376, 0.013827006332576275, 0.008015163242816925, -0.01401501428335905, 0.03318626061081886, -0.030018487945199013, -0.01858626864850521, 0.02908034436404705, 0.02273258939385414, 0.0318954698741436, 0.015120631083846092, -0.005105904303491116, 0.07949225604534149, -0.020330455154180527, -0.004373700357973576, -0.040672268718481064, 0.016420679166913033, -0.033681269735097885, 0.02932433970272541, -0.019306641072034836, 0.041171882301568985, 0.022076725959777832, -0.003810390131548047, -0.033411458134651184, 0.014347627758979797, 0.00413266196846962, -0.06043601036071777, -0.006965633947402239, 0.030084265395998955, 0.022956034168601036, -0.02265939489006996, 0.0038236540276557207, -0.0010704785818234086, -0.027131183072924614, 0.03408529609441757, 0.04895368590950966, -0.00604498665779829, 0.011048146523535252, -0.04272587224841118, -0.031028583645820618, -0.0020377598702907562, -0.06149647757411003, -0.020248185843229294, 0.012254824861884117, 0.04396061971783638, 0.0033055173698812723, -0.041813451796770096 ]
<p>Note that this is a simplified example:</p> <p>I have some time series that I made stationary by differencing twice. Then I ran <code>arima</code> on it, and set d = 0 to prevent additional differencing (I'm aware that <code>auto.arima</code> could detect the order of integration, but I'm hard-coding this myself for other reasons). Now I want to use <code>fitted</code> data from my <code>arima</code> object to determine what the <em>non-stationary</em> fit would look like.</p> <p>For example:</p> <pre><code>library('forecast') # simulate ARIMA(1,2,0) time series: rawData &lt;- arima.sim(n = 20, list(order = c(1,2,0), ar = 0.7)) # use diff function to make the series stationary: stationaryData &lt;- diff(diff(rawData)) # fit ARIMA on them appropriately rawDataFit &lt;- arima(rawData, c(1,2,0)) # include.mean = FALSE by default stationaryDataFit &lt;- arima(stationaryData, c(1,0,0), include.mean = FALSE) # stationaryData is already twice differenced # notice that there is very small variance between the AR(1) coefficients: coef(rawDataFit) coef(stationaryDataFit) </code></pre> <p>In this particular instance, my AR(1) coefficeints are 0.5511049 and 0.5511048. I also forced my ARIMA to exclude an intercept, so these ARIMA objects so be similar.</p> <pre><code># plot of rawData and the fitted values plot(rawData, type = "l") lines(fitted(rawDataFit), col = "slategrey") </code></pre> <p>Here's an example of what that plot could look like: <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/5R0cM.png" alt="Here&#39;s an example of what that plot could look like"></p> <p>I want to recreate the above plot, <em>without</em> using the rawDataFit object</p> <pre><code># using the diffinv function, I can easily replicate the rawData: recoveredRawData &lt;- diffinv(stationaryData, differences = 2, xi = rawData[1:2]) # Now I also want to "recover" the non-stationary data from the fitted AR(1) object: recoveredFit &lt;- diffinv(fitted(stationaryDataFit), differences = 2, xi = c(0,0)) # plot of rawData and the fitted values plot(recoveredRawData, type = "l") lines(recoveredFit, col = "slategrey") </code></pre> <p>Here's the attempt to recreate the above plot, using the results from my stationaryDataFit:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/xZuKH.png" alt="Here&#39;s the attempt to recreate the above plot, using the results from my stationaryDataFit"></p> <p>The shape looks correct, but the values are clearly off. I am <em>not</em> expecting to recover exactly the same results from both methods of fitting, but I still expect them to be reasonably close. </p> <p>I strongly suspect the problem is with my choice of xi in the <code>diffinv</code> function, since that's really the only place I'm making any assumptions. But I'm having trouble reconciling the issue.</p> <p>To integrate the data, <code>diffinv</code> requires the first observations of the integrated data. This is how I can convert the stationaryData back to the rawData, by passing the first two values of rawData to the <code>diffinv</code> xi argument. But I'm unsure what to use as the starting values to integrate <code>fitted(stationaryDataFit)</code>. The first two values of the (integrated) rawData are 0, so that's what I'm trying for now...</p> <p>Any ideas?</p> <p><strong>EDIT:</strong> Is this a legitimate work-around? Take the residuals from my stationaryDataFit object, and just subtract those from my rawData? For example:</p> <pre><code># prefix 2 zeros, so the vectors are the same length (due to secord-differencing): recoveredFit &lt;- rawData - c(rep(0, 2), stationaryDataFit$residuals) </code></pre> <p>My concern is about whether I need to transform my residuals from the stationaryDataFit somehow? In fact, the residuals from both fits are extremely close (within several decimals).</p> <p>Thank you!</p>
19,043
[ 0.0003308141021989286, 0.047103241086006165, -0.011099628172814846, 0.0192536860704422, 0.010845838114619255, -0.01416498888283968, -0.01615055650472641, -0.04624732956290245, 0.016247399151325226, -0.005619416479021311, 0.037816159427165985, 0.0179664958268404, 0.022592434659600258, 0.03237898647785187, 0.040726982057094574, 0.005419911351054907, 0.015806380659341812, -0.0017782283248379827, 0.0070544942282140255, -0.008730174042284489, -0.028084678575396538, 0.007425985299050808, -0.019437985494732857, -0.01043680403381586, 0.017776954919099808, 0.05337261036038399, -0.005285819061100483, -0.013047726824879646, 0.009282590821385384, 0.0650421679019928, -0.05654847249388695, -0.027422264218330383, -0.0011039763921871781, 0.050535719841718674, 0.020430512726306915, 0.017770567908883095, 0.01465475745499134, -0.03558594360947609, 0.015079513192176819, 0.042012766003608704, -0.014369496144354343, 0.01724543422460556, 0.007934795692563057, 0.05448640137910843, -0.002060034079477191, 0.030726825818419456, 0.03106999397277832, 0.014442703686654568, 0.08328323066234589, -0.011854207143187523, 0.07312963157892227, -0.05261969938874245, 0.013113334774971008, 0.033051181584596634, -0.07434187829494476, -0.025898750871419907, 0.05087199807167053, 0.03932839259505272, -0.011278345249593258, -0.06493554264307022, -0.028878524899482727, -0.010032988153398037, -0.001360640861093998, -0.018640054389834404, -0.03925430029630661, 0.02241828292608261, 0.021470636129379272, -0.021921776235103607, 0.004616500809788704, -0.0388377383351326, 0.024084225296974182, -0.024137115105986595, 0.024243392050266266, -0.038060665130615234, 0.032997891306877136, -0.017537599429488182, -0.017461469396948814, -0.02758605033159256, 0.024611303582787514, 0.033313460648059845, 0.016894107684493065, 0.055629417300224304, 0.04957250878214836, 0.021132398396730423, 0.043624334037303925, 0.017390726134181023, 0.05252780765295029, 0.004742355085909367, 0.015757987275719643, 0.016058804467320442, -0.0003917629364877939, 0.03767866641283035, 0.07252715528011322, 0.0022619639057666063, -0.00681518716737628, 0.036917947232723236, -0.043919049203395844, 0.027815062552690506, -0.00045159118599258363, -0.0038404983934015036, -0.025267798453569412, -0.013503743335604668, 0.05096953362226486, 0.03168965503573418, 0.02521592192351818, -0.029421407729387283, -0.01903916336596012, -0.032205820083618164, 0.0126183507964015, -0.030920810997486115, -0.01657268963754177, 0.010146652348339558, -0.010232994332909584, 0.004763713106513023, 0.016624262556433678, -0.01973787695169449, -0.00020542459969874471, 0.008995958603918552, 0.019365059211850166, 0.07721498608589172, 0.054192543029785156, -0.004902547691017389, -0.011155553162097931, -0.006555662956088781, -0.043964408338069916, -0.021216638386249542, -0.03477134928107262, 0.00984268356114626, -0.051263660192489624, 0.018630610778927803, -0.017047129571437836, -0.04340849071741104, 0.03795982524752617, -0.028961310163140297, 0.03421882912516594, -0.007311007007956505, -0.07455500215291977, -0.02734684757888317, 0.037126995623111725, -0.01548923272639513, 0.005850448738783598, -0.05516394227743149, 0.011494399979710579, 0.013614805415272713, 0.05324794724583626, 0.017980674281716347, 0.004329863935709, 0.01272567454725504, 0.007920736446976662, -0.024030016735196114, -0.035094622522592545, 0.015373943373560905, -0.018008658662438393, -0.006565985269844532, -0.0066180103458464146, -0.053832463920116425, -0.0015967802610248327, 0.028645962476730347, -0.04281985014677048, 0.020237501710653305, 0.03465021029114723, -0.008210786618292332, -0.005609613843262196, -0.02196292020380497, -0.015923678874969482, -0.029066922143101692, 0.07224513590335846, 0.01688246801495552, -0.007762319408357143, -0.024362698197364807, -0.04295441508293152, 0.030083535239100456, -0.019129544496536255, 0.022918639704585075, 0.052336618304252625, -0.0014719724422320724, 0.022191863507032394, -0.004225521348416805, 0.011495580896735191, 0.01641775108873844, -0.03689315915107727, -0.02817191556096077, -0.009402008727192879, -0.03815392404794693, -0.004680420272052288, 0.039061497896909714, 0.01014171727001667, -0.013480802066624165, 0.052785322070121765, -0.0768698900938034, -0.027828814461827278, -0.03725716099143028, -0.003134232945740223, -0.010276253335177898, 0.0003097494482062757, 0.020591778680682182, 0.02473388984799385, 0.05388253927230835, 0.02014298178255558, -0.019166916608810425, 0.00043249514419585466, -0.0011402517557144165, 0.05166323855519295, -0.052135270088911057, -0.018117466941475868, 0.009378286078572273, 0.05018133670091629, -0.018976466730237007, 0.04221823066473007, -0.03377475589513779, 0.00875069759786129, 0.04173810034990311, -0.07364938408136368, 0.007150775287300348, -0.016643604263663292, -0.0008127202745527029, 0.01754056289792061, 0.009084869176149368, 0.010720337741076946, 0.035605739802122116, -0.03253057599067688, -0.003168931230902672, 0.03203202039003372, -0.024512488394975662, 0.002371680224314332, -0.01005149632692337, -0.006738550495356321, 0.01914774253964424, -0.04002230241894722, -0.019304102286696434, -0.025082387030124664, -0.040307071059942245, 0.04625513777136803, 0.06610188633203506, -0.008968718349933624, 0.01728890836238861, 0.048892490565776825, -0.014815714210271835, -0.001498800003901124, 0.02996390126645565, 0.01148525346070528, -0.021397532895207405, 0.061933036893606186, -0.008388194255530834, 0.01512882113456726, 0.01349825318902731, 0.029760882258415222, -0.01052209921181202, 0.018767306581139565, 0.011079734191298485, -0.024641867727041245, 0.05818626657128334, -0.005830718204379082, -0.01924806833267212, -0.015132117085158825, -0.035043127834796906, 0.03705733269453049, 0.019172726199030876, -0.008120962418615818, 0.01328638382256031, 0.013485669158399105, -0.005370144732296467, 0.0007807548390701413, -0.017545223236083984, -0.004160248674452305, 0.03273436054587364, -0.015801548957824707, -0.01166174840182066, 0.033421944826841354, -0.04563254490494728, 0.013886862434446812, -0.04084278270602226, -0.032205481082201004, -0.04436637461185455, -0.0064877355471253395, 0.047953296452760696, 0.043578799813985825, 0.0032090002205222845, -0.03233940154314041, -0.019404128193855286, -0.017376046627759933, -0.01830313168466091, 0.023396670818328857, -0.011074399575591087, -0.017668848857283592, 0.018040398135781288, -0.03192910552024841, -0.028955668210983276, 0.033975519239902496, -0.006467805709689856, -0.03420286625623703, 0.04804340749979019, -0.0360204316675663, -0.02975652739405632, -0.021222569048404694, -0.0348474457859993, -0.01080418936908245, -0.04897608608007431, -0.05436324700713158, 0.055745065212249756, 0.008229182101786137, -0.024935470893979073, -0.0015036922413855791, -0.06029846519231796, 0.022589240223169327, -0.009254257194697857, -0.03325650840997696, -0.004972916562110186, 0.00015417994291055948, 0.02472233586013317, 0.030688662081956863, -0.0608629509806633, -0.016377286985516548, -0.063575878739357, -0.028103366494178772, 0.02914194017648697, -0.029254982247948647, -0.0013436413137242198, 0.006955613382160664, 0.013689333572983742, -0.0017374820308759809, 0.05448215827345848, -0.018271317705512047, -0.07028579711914062, -0.012258543632924557, -0.025640781968832016, -0.050259098410606384, 0.020366789773106575, 0.03581417724490166, 0.028185272589325905, -0.0009232675656676292, -0.010476072318851948, 0.01993543840944767, 0.036318711936473846, -0.024889077991247177, 0.03402315080165863, 0.01428846176713705, -0.02541794814169407, 0.006608419585973024, 0.05047563463449478, -0.0006997066084295511, 0.0047710551880300045, 0.034915532916784286, 0.015491942875087261, 0.008986813016235828, 0.00782033335417509, -0.01021653600037098, 0.014629848301410675, -0.003003990277647972, 0.036343660205602646, -0.05851126089692116, 0.05392434820532799, -0.02468191273510456, -0.04719875380396843, -0.04967028647661209, -0.007021862082183361, 0.013776537030935287, -0.01869235746562481, 0.018220745027065277, 0.04078991711139679, 0.003341180272400379, -0.03179566189646721, 0.015364565886557102, -0.02870023623108864, -0.029191087931394577, 0.013014771044254303, -0.06086597219109535, -0.02829834446310997, 0.05555568262934685, 0.008681654930114746, -0.01442541554570198, -0.01552749052643776, -0.0385139063000679, -0.018534081056714058, -0.037074267864227295, 0.035003386437892914, -0.015374651178717613, 0.055445604026317596, 0.03371531888842583, 0.02435452677309513, 0.02077523060142994, 0.010552512481808662, 0.015008789487183094, -0.015624267980456352, -0.07339780032634735, 0.09038929641246796, 0.020706236362457275, -0.012951387092471123, 0.012653636746108532, -0.03860734403133392, 0.04070097953081131, -0.05467124655842781, 0.06011470407247543, 0.015348178334534168, -0.010864700190722942, -0.010289620608091354, -0.0009740754030644894, -0.022336561232805252, 0.006888229865580797, -0.04462296515703201, 0.007730513345450163, 0.07515812665224075, 0.009767084382474422, 0.028402138501405716, 0.012984832748770714, 0.0015771012986078858, -0.018678052350878716, -0.047384172677993774, 0.01249215193092823, -0.011577923782169819, 0.04166543856263161, 0.05471939221024513, 0.0026249538641422987, -0.040402933955192566, 0.028799893334507942, 0.026724642142653465, 0.02098955027759075, 0.0431801937520504, -0.011241791769862175, -0.02671521157026291, 0.0016514521557837725, -0.018410122022032738, 0.009294779971241951, -0.0003020097210537642, -0.004017991945147514, -0.02141878567636013, 0.020778460428118706, 0.03529328480362892, -0.008747913874685764, 0.00036818228545598686, 0.04940585047006607, 0.031289536505937576, 0.023953547701239586, -0.0385565459728241, -0.025188330560922623, 0.005120009183883667, 0.03738068789243698, 0.008945067413151264, 0.010347483679652214, -0.008728832937777042, 0.032997261732816696, 0.03771017864346504, -0.03511839359998703, 0.007167431525886059, -0.01691676862537861, 0.05810859426856041, 0.06150546297430992, -0.015606158412992954, -0.027951855212450027, 0.0019027839880436659, 0.035553209483623505, 0.007534508127719164, 0.02406463958323002, 0.006505793891847134, -0.08937916159629822, 0.00958159938454628, 0.06938207894563675, 0.04294481500983238, -0.014172181487083435, -0.04669593274593353, -0.08956802636384964, 0.000579250801820308, 0.03039621189236641, -0.011792448349297047, 0.05361061915755272, 0.0042215194553136826, 0.03624724969267845, -0.03772034868597984, -0.03490544855594635, -0.04555195942521095, 0.05407453700900078, -0.03420926257967949, 0.050474539399147034, -0.05089866369962692, -0.07139898091554642, -0.031189152970910072, 0.011433911509811878, -0.007294318173080683, 0.017634190618991852, -0.04458119347691536, -0.012653200887143612, 0.037053585052490234, 0.013561434112489223, 0.02444600500166416, -0.023152479901909828, 0.036217331886291504, -0.006656779441982508, -0.004828246310353279, 0.023994488641619682, 0.011286498047411442, 0.01905725710093975, -0.016255104914307594, 0.005894275847822428, -0.005870257504284382, 0.011633941903710365, -0.0018512271344661713, 0.037453584372997284, 0.014054195024073124, 0.000054549916967516765, 0.05806978419423103, 0.024114536121487617, 0.016302861273288727, 0.012005387805402279, -0.06052188202738762, 0.008095122873783112, 0.0015659929485991597, -0.03955012187361717, -0.04012058675289154, -0.00462238397449255, -0.05435542017221451, 0.009826166555285454, 0.0034805801697075367, 0.0045857918448746204, -0.02293005958199501, 0.0329522080719471, 0.024380840361118317, 0.044735074043273926, -0.03442392125725746, -0.038345590233802795, 0.016464082524180412, -0.008147897198796272, -0.02792542241513729, 0.025508029386401176, -0.0157572403550148, 0.022615062072873116, -0.01062311977148056, 0.003550179535523057, -0.03200994059443474, 0.044309042394161224, -0.023581137880682945, 0.011681346222758293, 0.021845407783985138, 0.001630016602575779, -0.017879683524370193, 0.018381748348474503, 0.08962611854076385, 0.005672134459018707, -0.04412563890218735, 0.011193378828465939, 0.04618176445364952, -0.04721192643046379, -0.004186058882623911, -0.05285411328077316, 0.046402718871831894, -0.02892521396279335, -0.025736922398209572, -0.044023752212524414, -0.012491002678871155, 0.013767721131443977, 0.008094876073300838, -0.06964104622602463, -0.028426585718989372, -0.03187396004796028, 0.004831491969525814, -0.03610539808869362, -0.00800450798124075, 0.010477518662810326, -0.038281671702861786, 0.002708456479012966, -0.019193220883607864, -0.0014449363807216287, 0.07882070541381836, -0.006083770655095577, -0.014521713368594646, 0.02264251746237278, -0.03409210592508316, -0.041834134608507156, -0.004476741887629032, 0.001533212955109775, -0.018240075558423996, 0.014004536904394627, -0.01705542951822281, -0.011520253494381905, 0.003294223453849554, 0.010982568375766277, -0.01697990857064724, -0.006384896580129862, -0.02092880569398403, -0.0005185758927837014, -0.03299456462264061, 0.0056777894496917725, 0.007879570126533508, -0.017384782433509827, -0.03402642160654068, -0.020009860396385193, 0.02372729778289795, -0.03308817371726036, 0.004039071034640074, -0.027830027043819427, -0.018188433721661568, 0.03713357448577881, 0.06195465475320816, 0.007117984816431999, 0.007885342463850975, -0.03943409025669098, -0.016475338488817215, 0.036449845880270004, -0.00941623467952013, -0.009269081056118011, -0.009731773287057877, -0.0011631734669208527, -0.03414109721779823, -0.029749825596809387, -0.02455982007086277, -0.008004482835531235, 0.04075891152024269, 0.022357167676091194, 0.07064078748226166, 0.03515806421637535, 0.00438370555639267, -0.009479884058237076, -0.02744396962225437, -0.03476335108280182, 0.0006087209330871701, 0.016007671132683754, 0.050307322293519974, 0.010112764313817024, -0.012841285206377506, 0.04756275191903114, -0.008527161553502083, 0.04853147268295288, 0.051438216120004654, -0.01707538217306137, 0.011026331223547459, 0.022349029779434204, -0.0041742827743291855, -0.04045204073190689, 0.024640152230858803, -0.010014967061579227, 0.04107842966914177, -0.02363651432096958, -0.01585199497640133, 0.020952977240085602, 0.047568511217832565, -0.0004379106394480914, -0.0012163363862782717, -0.02106177993118763, -0.06835297495126724, -0.018797019496560097, 0.04495926946401596, -0.010168936103582382, 0.03734023496508598, 0.027851440012454987, 0.01735285110771656, -0.032964643090963364, 0.044077109545469284, -0.008959228172898293, -0.04032062366604805, -0.011446645483374596, -0.044863250106573105, 0.0334315188229084, 0.08364284038543701, 0.001612079911865294, -0.02218012325465679, -0.004789270460605621, -0.033591557294130325, 0.028069593012332916, 0.010583817027509212, 0.010878275148570538, 0.014796992763876915, 0.05879085138440132, -0.038871847093105316, 0.020411377772688866, -0.026028737425804138, -0.03054790012538433, 0.17106565833091736, 0.06909003853797913, 0.039634060114622116, -0.05836581811308861, -0.008809937164187431, 0.017629342153668404, 0.02175362966954708, -0.026191359385848045, -0.01093823742121458, 0.021671729162335396, 0.008059973828494549, 0.046023257076740265, 0.028126081451773643, 0.011941645294427872, 0.00984545610845089, 0.02906806953251362, -0.04844294488430023, 0.02041236311197281, -0.022702932357788086, 0.06452519446611404, 0.0032252990640699863, 0.010176547802984715, -0.07901379466056824, -0.02646421454846859, -0.00989692471921444, -0.023663122206926346, -0.022739900276064873, -0.05094079673290253, 0.004796198103576899, 0.017451895400881767, -0.018768249079585075, 0.043526507914066315, 0.0021029491908848286, 0.005156721454113722, 0.030378717929124832, 0.0201227068901062, 0.013972869142889977, -0.03705686330795288, 0.010890615172684193, 0.021379437297582626, 0.03048405982553959, -0.04445674642920494, -0.0005011378088966012, 0.02742324024438858, -0.01638161763548851, -0.02181343547999859, -0.050816066563129425, 0.036132052540779114, 0.008045575581490993, -0.029995562508702278, -0.0054212030954658985, 0.012579438276588917, 0.017881395295262337, -0.027123695239424706, 0.027665700763463974, 0.001373909879475832, 0.014372211880981922, -0.05753374844789505, -0.0028272911440581083, -0.028063088655471802, 0.015388372354209423, 0.021889496594667435, 0.045553192496299744, 0.033729810267686844, -0.027513571083545685, -0.008501790463924408, -0.058160826563835144, 0.07883752137422562, -0.043300461024045944, 0.005452325101941824, 0.04453955218195915, -0.025081271305680275, -0.024501847103238106, -0.030156519263982773, 0.018790965899825096, 0.012789766304194927, 0.018120596185326576, -0.014607248827815056, -0.012505415827035904, -0.02136843092739582, -0.029307400807738304, -0.00353892776183784, -0.01966768130660057, 0.01304642204195261, -0.01656697876751423, -0.03921864554286003, 0.035202573984861374, 0.009582052938640118, 0.04326699301600456, -0.00969535019248724, -0.032775551080703735, 0.05570663884282112, 0.05253222957253456, -0.040938347578048706, -0.048630304634571075, 0.016175447031855583, -0.04263961315155029, -0.0038051374722272158, 0.010076148435473442, 0.07018349319696426, 0.02028278261423111, 0.000888071779627353, -0.01722213253378868, 0.01815328747034073, -0.013092762790620327, 0.03165339305996895, -0.0061650085262954235, -0.02457009255886078, 0.001689033699221909, 0.014811891131103039, -0.022904107347130775, -0.06623845547437668, -0.0024608224630355835, -0.037872347980737686, -0.03080020286142826, -0.0039018895477056503, 0.011192983016371727, -0.029086202383041382, 0.04433431848883629, -0.0061580766923725605, 0.017611952498555183, -0.03962261974811554, -0.026060087606310844, -0.02750587649643421, -0.03320397436618805, -0.04167122766375542, -0.045011430978775024, -0.014008748345077038, 0.012169391848146915, -0.04094702750444412, -0.008190693333745003, 0.04153834655880928, -0.002528064651414752, 0.02793184667825699, -0.008304532617330551, 0.03155413642525673, -0.012606787495315075, 0.011687037535011768, -0.01348989550024271, -0.04455576092004776, 0.010613605380058289, 0.006526330951601267, -0.03862909600138664, -0.0023077966179698706, -0.009882713668048382, 0.03470234572887421, 0.008781496435403824, -0.023866688832640648, -0.014623313210904598, 0.05623386427760124, -0.0037996380124241114, -0.008267266675829887, 0.018884532153606415, -0.01084577664732933, 0.027042031288146973, 0.015017236582934856, 0.024679943919181824, 0.01141649205237627, -0.013639970682561398, 0.03319312632083893, 0.040940061211586, 0.010931484401226044, -0.019415931776165962, -0.022767331451177597, -0.022968359291553497, -0.010736234486103058, 0.007260989397764206, -0.0027995603159070015, 0.049390505999326706, 0.05570580065250397, -0.028959970921278, 0.0046912808902561665, -0.06258926540613174, -0.02069436013698578, -0.069972924888134, 0.008566295728087425, 0.012455747462809086, 0.007845270447432995, 0.032227739691734314, -0.018833080306649208, 0.008272749371826649, 0.03391207009553909, -0.00968579575419426, 0.014613780193030834, -0.0010887120151892304, 0.015655824914574623, -0.04104537516832352, 0.02142116241157055, -0.04513160511851311, -0.023373542353510857, 0.06994003802537918, 0.035241320729255676, 0.04436109587550163, 0.0017084089340642095, 0.020584477111697197, -0.00007207448652479798, -0.039145346730947495, 0.01924329437315464, 0.012921396642923355, -0.025759095326066017, 0.03400074690580368, -0.022525619715452194, -0.002486062701791525, 0.030344944447278976, -0.030432818457484245, 0.029487058520317078, -0.01147626992315054, 0.031010011211037636, 0.007344119716435671, 0.03397626057267189, 0.009748788550496101, -0.01660747639834881, -0.01607324369251728, 0.0000011318594488329836, 0.03580493479967117, 0.02719181962311268, -0.03811727836728096, 0.0028649407904595137, -0.023717515170574188, -0.007249308750033379, -0.022817982360720634, 0.02102307416498661, 0.004266588483005762, -0.02706855535507202, -0.008718682453036308, -0.0007340318406932056, -0.02278866060078144, -0.011212799698114395, -0.010674795135855675, 0.010246588848531246, 0.030247794464230537, 0.05109396576881409, 0.04535052180290222, -0.04524390771985054, 0.010177334770560265, -0.020150212571024895, -0.01698409579694271, 0.024874508380889893, -0.013736329041421413, -0.00154946802649647, -0.05018385127186775, -0.04864207282662392, 0.009374051354825497, -0.014960253611207008, -0.023589175194501877, 0.01729867234826088, -0.037936218082904816, 0.0007861265330575407, -0.010380320250988007, -0.038315966725349426, 0.03786583989858627, -0.04804889112710953, 0.008358541876077652, -0.09066042304039001, 0.05094768479466438, -0.007866141386330128, -0.02899451181292534, -0.04069814085960388, 0.023549506440758705, -0.04415940120816231, 0.06758139282464981, 0.04848155006766319, 0.0044215344823896885, 0.02034357562661171, 0.005026599392294884, 0.0024263313971459866, -0.016678636893630028, -0.057755742222070694, 0.02865232340991497, 0.0039008725434541702, -0.01125305611640215, 0.02816377766430378, -0.02257171832025051, 0.029002515599131584, 0.013645906932651997, 0.00547716673463583, -0.011834230273962021, 0.03918468579649925, 0.027269400656223297, -0.013628627173602581, 0.010252806358039379, -0.0052198367193341255, -0.008113589137792587, 0.018433494493365288, 0.01444462314248085, -0.024001792073249817, 0.0401846319437027, 0.009354304522275925, -0.06035282090306282, 0.020757032558321953, -0.005308148451149464, 0.002825381699949503, 0.025830909609794617, -0.0006063022883608937, 0.0005057949456386268, -0.045259833335876465, 0.01044557336717844, 0.018217910081148148, 0.0056312195956707, -0.00487995520234108, 0.029392113909125328, 0.010775466449558735, 0.05625605583190918, 0.02091195061802864, 0.02857690118253231, -0.015118313021957874, 0.03511196747422218, 0.03643512725830078, -0.0025623198598623276, 0.012548603117465973, -0.029083535075187683, -0.03124311938881874, 0.03002159111201763, -0.031095001846551895, -0.00929471105337143, -0.032203733921051025, 0.07047362625598907, -0.014167625457048416, -0.05091860517859459, 0.010244855657219887, -0.01739656925201416, 0.055749859660863876, 0.0425373800098896, 0.006367046851664782, 0.04813211038708687, -0.05966446176171303, 0.022662287577986717, 0.027060052379965782, -0.020158939063549042, -0.03649167716503143, 0.03850581869482994, -0.014036023057997227, 0.038979820907115936, -0.02974151447415352, 0.027430962771177292, 0.02070164866745472, -0.04120299965143204, -0.00590691901743412, -0.02828093431890011, 0.002998207462951541, 0.02054530754685402, 0.025713970884680748, -0.02256753481924534, -0.003364675445482135, -0.001074517727829516, -0.046806734055280685, 0.0005405009142123163, 0.01545390672981739, 0.0017106016166508198, -0.017508922144770622, -0.016263579949736595, -0.00356793194077909, 0.03397589921951294, -0.07246202975511551, -0.043955326080322266, -0.020654985681176186, 0.0031407931819558144, 0.004383565858006477, -0.04263835400342941 ]
<p>I am looking at streaming data (i.e. online model), and looking for a specific discrete event. I want to stochastically model the time until this even happens, or if easier, say, model the probability that it happens within the next 30 seconds. What is a simple, practical way to tackle this problem? What kind of technique can I use, and how can I train the model and backtest it?</p> <p>Note that the training is happening offline on historical data, and then the model is applied online, on live, streaming data.</p>
73,903
[ -0.02314082719385624, -0.05061608552932739, -0.0064391642808914185, -0.02072877436876297, 0.00874344166368246, -0.047571249306201935, 0.00025084795197471976, -0.0029265698976814747, 0.039472416043281555, 0.012123041786253452, 0.032007209956645966, 0.045453522354364395, 0.0012839307310059667, 0.01572008989751339, 0.002357211895287037, 0.02126426249742508, 0.0003468316572252661, -0.059264011681079865, -0.03607501462101936, -0.008960671722888947, 0.007104623597115278, -0.009241688996553421, 0.03287016227841377, -0.024129711091518402, -0.02152600698173046, 0.008899889886379242, 0.030374756082892418, 0.007612324319779873, -0.025337649509310722, 0.057929281145334244, -0.0371994823217392, -0.037204597145318985, 0.009613027796149254, 0.05974043905735016, 0.02470599114894867, 0.020351791754364967, -0.03828166425228119, -0.05824058875441551, -0.0037358859553933144, 0.010607345961034298, -0.0365850105881691, -0.0002903001441154629, 0.013015837408602238, 0.05300281569361687, -0.03207869082689285, 0.0014351338613778353, -0.03336304798722267, -0.012058242224156857, 0.038087718188762665, -0.017751773819327354, 0.06870315223932266, -0.059788595885038376, 0.05267485976219177, -0.017551586031913757, -0.005356481298804283, 0.0014804331585764885, 0.07453923672437668, 0.0872698724269867, 0.02346975915133953, -0.0303457323461771, 0.0029251123778522015, -0.040452662855386734, -0.003587629646062851, -0.03184528276324272, -0.006590612232685089, -0.006775198969990015, 0.013389471918344498, -0.02792600356042385, 0.01301460713148117, -0.038838084787130356, 0.01251715887337923, -0.002010208321735263, 0.07149921357631683, 0.03494400531053543, 0.032830700278282166, -0.018454313278198242, 0.0275206808000803, 0.025121774524450302, 0.03493630513548851, 0.04629962518811226, -0.015975745394825935, -0.035069696605205536, 0.0053733703680336475, 0.0696958526968956, 0.030215173959732056, -0.0284357238560915, 0.09767135232686996, 0.00450771301984787, 0.02173638716340065, 0.002173430286347866, -0.053640976548194885, -0.0018312371103093028, -0.007061546202749014, -0.023838361725211143, -0.03844684734940529, 0.023754898458719254, -0.028281478211283684, 0.02087949402630329, 0.018179237842559814, -0.007247504312545061, 0.0011417374480515718, -0.07320908457040787, 0.011351142078638077, 0.07623516768217087, -0.045889999717473984, 0.010082182474434376, -0.01960078626871109, -0.023406555876135826, -0.03998953476548195, -0.01710755005478859, -0.061812449246644974, 0.022801140323281288, 0.0024125054478645325, 0.001960036577656865, -0.011098881252110004, 0.01795465126633644, 0.01067714300006628, -0.002512639621272683, 0.052491508424282074, 0.0593169741332531, 0.047319408506155014, -0.04209570586681366, 0.016311222687363625, -0.057281915098428726, -0.005646167788654566, 0.001001593074761331, -0.005562857259064913, -0.02019801177084446, -0.04807630926370621, 0.06965983659029007, -0.024927133694291115, -0.03927289694547653, 0.07219263911247253, -0.033005520701408386, 0.07590745389461517, -0.007614612579345703, -0.06708583235740662, -0.03926484286785126, 0.03749973699450493, -0.012570126913487911, -0.0173492431640625, -0.050743963569402695, 0.013034684583544731, 0.003345012664794922, 0.03600345924496651, 0.021273799240589142, 0.04527971148490906, 0.02395317517220974, 0.0009489327785558999, -0.022803694009780884, -0.036510080099105835, 0.00820958148688078, -0.01981697790324688, 0.056107573211193085, -0.004472905304282904, -0.0495917946100235, 0.02234094962477684, 0.0023369668051600456, -0.012776204384863377, -0.014772783033549786, 0.03284488245844841, 0.004361350554972887, -0.019438989460468292, 0.020422611385583878, 0.026403365656733513, -0.05011584237217903, 0.07294536381959915, 0.015965498983860016, -0.0037406031042337418, -0.019154753535985947, 0.026230035349726677, -0.0017550966003909707, 0.05273126810789108, 0.03742797300219536, 0.03834656998515129, -0.00885773729532957, -0.005362993571907282, -0.00987770315259695, -0.003312684129923582, 0.03435473144054413, 0.02599971927702427, 0.00859700608998537, -0.018320657312870026, -0.00035460060462355614, -0.002864065347239375, 0.011315335519611835, 0.020500490441918373, -0.0036083918530493975, 0.01361300889402628, -0.039912011474370956, -0.03304951637983322, -0.06547140330076218, 0.0382331907749176, -0.00930006243288517, 0.022495165467262268, 0.014176716096699238, -0.0009339607204310596, 0.011205549351871014, -0.038539040833711624, -0.0035517814103513956, -0.028168626129627228, -0.01344755757600069, 0.033212874084711075, -0.04354756698012352, -0.023040592670440674, 0.05449145659804344, 0.023862360045313835, -0.027912292629480362, 0.004318325314670801, 0.001431187498383224, -0.04098616540431976, -0.059210702776908875, -0.060915764421224594, 0.03225579857826233, -0.04898713529109955, -0.00710709486156702, 0.037815067917108536, -0.013848275877535343, -0.005142320413142443, -0.004211436957120895, -0.02870783768594265, 0.052447643131017685, 0.07013855874538422, 0.014814152382314205, -0.01061411015689373, -0.017810901626944542, 0.01352796982973814, -0.013294474221765995, 0.010709683410823345, -0.02040211297571659, -0.06233322247862816, 0.0073197949677705765, 0.06751453876495361, 0.0026590307243168354, 0.019665980711579323, 0.012299150228500366, 0.060150813311338425, 0.01814582571387291, 0.027068907395005226, 0.042864393442869186, -0.03673886880278587, 0.01912282407283783, 0.006453335285186768, -0.022184941917657852, 0.018577592447400093, 0.00019851859542541206, 0.017724936828017235, -0.009608194231987, 0.019674474373459816, -0.00450844457373023, -0.02423897571861744, -0.00934892613440752, 0.00878164917230606, 0.016611160710453987, -0.014349812641739845, -0.04122179374098778, 0.021481871604919434, -0.018095113337039948, -0.015789931640028954, -0.00015421240823343396, 0.008531764149665833, 0.053297970443964005, 0.010576511733233929, -0.03018820844590664, 0.014477746561169624, 0.021784771233797073, -0.02480609156191349, 0.004069948103278875, 0.02970748208463192, -0.025631234049797058, 0.008336160331964493, -0.004490143619477749, -0.041912991553545, -0.023997200652956963, 0.023705681785941124, 0.022593524307012558, 0.0035317139700055122, 0.02682846412062645, -0.01721513457596302, -0.016619989648461342, 0.010602857917547226, -0.013973347842693329, 0.019383320584893227, 0.03621354326605797, -0.025426451116800308, 0.022255323827266693, 0.015046419575810432, -0.021667085587978363, 0.029611440375447273, 0.00956291425973177, 0.0028820692095905542, 0.011678961105644703, -0.006598351988941431, -0.042810384184122086, -0.013441004790365696, -0.026447363197803497, 0.025727562606334686, -0.04343899339437485, -0.004304751753807068, 0.04631204158067703, 0.012899408116936684, -0.06732181459665298, 0.029696300625801086, -0.029168955981731415, -0.00676667969673872, -0.04200268164277077, 0.02213849127292633, 0.018540499731898308, -0.054235998541116714, 0.008946576155722141, 0.02664121799170971, -0.009676442481577396, 0.023953402414917946, -0.053648509085178375, -0.06362291425466537, 0.00389304687269032, -0.01718316785991192, 0.04022844135761261, 0.014497452415525913, -0.009027504362165928, 0.0589902363717556, 0.016006622463464737, -0.018940357491374016, -0.01872939243912697, -0.00031752418726682663, -0.00815331470221281, -0.05241956189274788, 0.02078268676996231, -0.003049681195989251, -0.016504038125276566, -0.020806221291422844, -0.005929945968091488, -0.00814852211624384, 0.07522793859243393, 0.03715086355805397, 0.0024940245784819126, 0.013610757887363434, -0.017419880256056786, 0.01892450638115406, 0.02714303880929947, 0.03320971131324768, -0.04059053584933281, 0.03204766660928726, -0.047383300960063934, 0.029340313747525215, 0.02447938174009323, -0.043232377618551254, 0.02049899660050869, -0.01672353222966194, -0.04603961110115051, -0.03725382313132286, 0.0657229870557785, -0.017274273559451103, -0.042079340666532516, -0.029014838859438896, 0.03427165374159813, 0.026008255779743195, 0.0014497486408799887, 0.029619652777910233, 0.039152175188064575, 0.05621718615293503, -0.03132433071732521, -0.04129467159509659, -0.04665573686361313, -0.014183172024786472, 0.014486999250948429, -0.044306281954050064, 0.01863674819469452, 0.010986222885549068, 0.0059537808410823345, 0.008079218678176403, -0.013641473837196827, -0.01835382729768753, -0.044463492929935455, -0.08266974240541458, 0.025204181671142578, -0.03032456710934639, 0.06575287878513336, 0.01614936999976635, 0.04803469777107239, 0.021027347072958946, 0.0017703829798847437, 0.0421733632683754, 0.009149252437055111, -0.06952662765979767, 0.039446279406547546, -0.022975068539381027, -0.028012234717607498, -0.017719781026244164, -0.01204383373260498, 0.019090117886662483, -0.040638264268636703, -0.02052212320268154, -0.01759602129459381, 0.02572295255959034, -0.030631287023425102, 0.009450308047235012, -0.024258719757199287, -0.000032375799492001534, -0.012437169440090656, -0.03220639377832413, 0.025849834084510803, -0.006648167036473751, 0.029782796278595924, 0.02566656656563282, 0.01251143217086792, -0.01705510914325714, -0.008770045824348927, -0.012681866064667702, 0.02196330577135086, 0.006790351588279009, 0.023572362959384918, 0.0302397683262825, -0.04220579192042351, 0.06322116404771805, -0.0003819853300228715, 0.035508573055267334, 0.043855223804712296, -0.024591488763689995, -0.01870746538043022, -0.06484945118427277, -0.0025345408357679844, 0.041213735938072205, 0.021263452246785164, 0.029484141618013382, -0.012006931938230991, 0.05034349858760834, -0.0021147921215742826, -0.07011942565441132, -0.013541272841393948, 0.06424015760421753, 0.021058181300759315, -0.02575511299073696, -0.036611754447221756, -0.0034709740430116653, 0.022615015506744385, 0.0159324761480093, -0.00598085206001997, 0.013954613357782364, 0.030738146975636482, -0.0023874472826719284, 0.0191134512424469, -0.004317192360758781, 0.001249282737262547, -0.004130655899643898, 0.014800305478274822, 0.04253537580370903, 0.03435351327061653, -0.031762704253196716, 0.00854373350739479, 0.07084934413433075, 0.028924454003572464, 0.024107791483402252, -0.00038805551594123244, -0.10883981734514236, -0.01850743405520916, 0.036789339035749435, 0.015517047606408596, 0.005794362165033817, -0.0392930693924427, -0.032115425914525986, 0.013672826811671257, 0.007187338080257177, -0.01610788144171238, 0.020827658474445343, -0.00250927428714931, 0.016824854537844658, 0.001043773372657597, -0.025195639580488205, -0.029298728331923485, 0.009279397316277027, -0.010582291521131992, 0.06540948152542114, -0.029531024396419525, -0.04772082716226578, -0.06685297191143036, 0.037789780646562576, 0.03083057515323162, 0.05345798656344414, -0.012704900465905666, 0.0035083373077213764, -0.008353198878467083, -0.0033747742418199778, -0.004703478887677193, -0.07084042578935623, -0.011480369605123997, -0.010340074077248573, -0.0015210210112854838, 0.00490295747295022, -0.007557420525699854, -0.022327303886413574, 0.009373592212796211, 0.0027123421896249056, -0.05430608242750168, 0.010241517797112465, -0.05177323520183563, 0.014053339138627052, -0.005706205032765865, 0.029784375801682472, 0.02925211936235428, 0.016540950164198875, 0.010431986302137375, -0.019901474937796593, 0.014775806106626987, 0.02927757240831852, -0.015009366907179356, 0.003149684751406312, -0.01853647455573082, -0.00006298824155237526, -0.013120192103087902, 0.010644277557730675, -0.0010237036040052772, 0.02515418268740177, 0.01080401986837387, -0.02600676566362381, -0.024034878239035606, 0.05892464518547058, 0.0019503567600622773, -0.01440481562167406, -0.0020477042999118567, 0.003724584588780999, -0.01971864514052868, 0.026022331789135933, 0.027080796658992767, -0.010153871960937977, 0.02511567249894142, 0.030337173491716385, -0.041465140879154205, 0.007743122521787882, -0.0341278538107872, -0.04319657012820244, 0.03625598922371864, -0.014054314233362675, 0.03832469880580902, 0.013569636270403862, 0.028118474408984184, 0.019810941070318222, -0.022603459656238556, 0.016272861510515213, 0.004827721044421196, 0.00893763080239296, 0.01703912764787674, -0.05314893275499344, 0.010939649306237698, -0.0008070495096035302, 0.007954227738082409, -0.05391912907361984, -0.06448940932750702, 0.07945776730775833, -0.012130193412303925, -0.03293401375412941, -0.059652481228113174, 0.007799897342920303, -0.009330864995718002, -0.017327930778265, -0.0004657262470573187, 0.046994615346193314, 0.0009418037952855229, 0.00863852258771658, -0.015555025078356266, 0.01404102984815836, 0.05467616021633148, 0.02398529089987278, 0.008630922064185143, 0.007819602265954018, -0.0007650380721315742, -0.06274669617414474, 0.006764995865523815, 0.05477951467037201, -0.024821685627102852, 0.01174395065754652, -0.009117444045841694, 0.013680881820619106, 0.040205035358667374, -0.019671862944960594, 0.005700007546693087, -0.00572262704372406, -0.016497280448675156, 0.003266038605943322, -0.0383637361228466, 0.02667391300201416, 0.03880767896771431, -0.005870436318218708, -0.02847817726433277, -0.004940626211464405, 0.0027840174734592438, 0.006910372991114855, 0.028786499053239822, 0.0041333530098199844, -0.005313006229698658, 0.01094315480440855, 0.01582546904683113, -0.0085583021864295, -0.0006483034230768681, -0.01273059006780386, -0.004804797004908323, 0.05208557844161987, -0.03556906804442406, -0.02061230130493641, 0.022670455276966095, -0.021847348660230637, -0.06828176975250244, -0.021762210875749588, -0.04082925245165825, -0.03376784548163414, 0.03499318286776543, -0.014859054237604141, 0.1078357994556427, 0.02494416944682598, 0.038960594683885574, -0.021188093349337578, -0.010290450416505337, 0.022482065483927727, -0.015738023445010185, -0.014187208376824856, 0.02857186086475849, 0.015410496853291988, 0.0063114045187830925, -0.004049288108944893, -0.004864415619522333, 0.032274212688207626, 0.06270667910575867, 0.043871186673641205, -0.015237657353281975, 0.07930393517017365, -0.017202632501721382, -0.006794300861656666, -0.003567645326256752, -0.07649454474449158, 0.002781017916277051, -0.04135480150580406, -0.03337660804390907, 0.03852498531341553, 0.018306231126189232, -0.01154250092804432, -0.03706856817007065, 0.027827231213450432, -0.0947294756770134, -0.0032830717973411083, 0.03034653700888157, -0.019077681005001068, 0.033303771167993546, 0.019820237532258034, 0.034612543880939484, 0.0010327224154025316, 0.02087530493736267, 0.0007163313566707075, -0.059545572847127914, -0.011826114729046822, -0.047878820449113846, -0.06073470786213875, 0.01597530208528042, 0.006136918440461159, -0.036385856568813324, -0.005575731862336397, -0.0013874070718884468, 0.012273374013602734, 0.01093342900276184, 0.03719868138432503, -0.03542714938521385, 0.08254020661115646, -0.030188344419002533, -0.011221379041671753, -0.00011525091395014897, -0.006343539338558912, 0.09137947112321854, 0.07408684492111206, 0.034048233181238174, -0.05552440136671066, -0.008246375247836113, -0.0016220920952036977, 0.007594244088977575, -0.028525235131382942, 0.008076256141066551, 0.0229533389210701, -0.02529904618859291, 0.03230158984661102, -0.03214826434850693, 0.026317568495869637, -0.008289230056107044, 0.055166613310575485, -0.06287505477666855, 0.00027241933275945485, -0.0018290503649041057, -0.0010394171113148332, 0.02712894417345524, 0.00013137786299921572, -0.05571967735886574, 0.045629121363162994, -0.016000069677829742, -0.038638681173324585, 0.01307324692606926, -0.035693876445293427, -0.02738512121140957, -0.008414971642196178, -0.03673649579286575, 0.002196014393121004, 0.03762664645910263, 0.0066757421009242535, 0.020878423005342484, -0.013684923760592937, -0.014304312877357006, 0.008725658059120178, 0.004618774633854628, 0.0013107889099046588, 0.03945518285036087, 0.0013782776659354568, -0.011567141860723495, 0.011910458095371723, -0.034333858639001846, -0.06583885103464127, -0.06440002471208572, 0.006557628978043795, -0.011105288751423359, 0.005923318676650524, 0.002558239968493581, 0.022552164271473885, 0.02530813403427601, -0.030201023444533348, -0.006594655103981495, 0.025447770953178406, 0.04753793776035309, -0.029651768505573273, -0.017406363040208817, -0.017397746443748474, -0.0019983418751507998, -0.009694049134850502, 0.008019031956791878, 0.02593335695564747, -0.01029603835195303, -0.004737693816423416, -0.030068423599004745, 0.020961573347449303, 0.016965124756097794, 0.012718573212623596, 0.019038716331124306, -0.04487087205052376, -0.0076409694738686085, 0.025081800296902657, 0.040082547813653946, -0.04884304106235504, 0.004901593551039696, -0.009573840536177158, -0.024367932230234146, -0.02509401924908161, 0.0007176284561865032, -0.0035578066017478704, -0.027041545137763023, 0.007578614633530378, -0.04187175631523132, 0.014326939359307289, 0.015948645770549774, 0.03281004726886749, 0.01898644119501114, 0.03900853544473648, -0.01782604679465294, 0.041186898946762085, 0.04900975525379181, -0.0511622279882431, 0.009138000197708607, -0.0005842353566549718, -0.02227872423827648, 0.01187113393098116, 0.012111322954297066, 0.08434095233678818, 0.033290524035692215, -0.017229098826646805, -0.003249943954870105, 0.00906613003462553, 0.010453872382640839, 0.00457743601873517, 0.007826394401490688, -0.05152592435479164, -0.008626447059214115, -0.0037011983804404736, 0.0133926747366786, -0.01611378602683544, -0.031050095334649086, -0.0106199374422431, 0.0014296474400907755, -0.014895872212946415, -0.016439294442534447, -0.03284856677055359, 0.034111473709344864, -0.004756344482302666, 0.033147409558296204, -0.021300021559000015, 0.027284447103738785, -0.012421111576259136, -0.016560766845941544, -0.026044774800539017, -0.04361802339553833, -0.012813495472073555, 0.006814676336944103, 0.011277582496404648, -0.024117840453982353, 0.003934225998818874, 0.007397583685815334, 0.010197619907557964, 0.005573554430156946, 0.04768015444278717, -0.021980134770274162, 0.019936760887503624, -0.017660966143012047, -0.03519716113805771, 0.03202163055539131, -0.03715009242296219, 0.0036638982128351927, 0.054174017161130905, 0.0066159563139081, 0.04578206688165665, -0.008161711506545544, -0.019000470638275146, 0.03810355067253113, 0.034369438886642456, -0.013450643047690392, -0.05535145848989487, 0.015045547857880592, 0.01538979634642601, 0.01195091288536787, 0.028389036655426025, 0.040722377598285675, -0.0032618630211800337, 0.019452903419733047, -0.006582554895430803, 0.015779875218868256, 0.0029989255126565695, 0.018992798402905464, 0.021389173343777657, -0.00728184450417757, 0.043956458568573, -0.004711627494543791, 0.005313203204423189, 0.009656541049480438, 0.04538249969482422, -0.021667931228876114, 0.015879780054092407, -0.006667289882898331, -0.016214055940508842, -0.09233725816011429, -0.01120693888515234, 0.023187411949038506, -0.03292863816022873, 0.04513730853796005, -0.07329010963439941, -0.006386479828506708, 0.07509324699640274, -0.052971020340919495, 0.009374409914016724, 0.027968013659119606, -0.009031202644109726, -0.024958888068795204, 0.016181794926524162, -0.00042037537787109613, 0.006639064289629459, 0.023899031803011894, 0.04349668696522713, 0.05547884851694107, 0.03178595006465912, 0.0003374623483978212, -0.03149187192320824, -0.024538952857255936, 0.04453343152999878, 0.047701820731163025, -0.010265331715345383, 0.033124882727861404, -0.07762213796377182, 0.009203717112541199, 0.012495949864387512, -0.015653524547815323, 0.014781354926526546, 0.03771865367889404, 0.05210763216018677, -0.00544347008690238, 0.03569522872567177, 0.04116879776120186, -0.03823423385620117, 0.03889377415180206, 0.024203317239880562, 0.03346487134695053, 0.03669305518269539, -0.053475480526685715, 0.004132062662392855, 0.018629588186740875, -0.00765515211969614, -0.019891710951924324, 0.029488347470760345, -0.007920429110527039, -0.038404371589422226, 0.05020897462964058, -0.0015876106917858124, -0.008187510073184967, -0.030613968148827553, -0.00523284450173378, -0.0071665700525045395, -0.008249705657362938, 0.029278934001922607, 0.01765812374651432, -0.04899013414978981, -0.02241189032793045, -0.04879870265722275, -0.024139301851391792, 0.020534127950668335, 0.01642104983329773, -0.02019825205206871, -0.06334566324949265, -0.02089112438261509, -0.008097889833152294, 0.010140910744667053, -0.036750659346580505, -0.006154520437121391, 0.011374974623322487, 0.051371801644563675, 0.021709272637963295, 0.016555577516555786, 0.06455610692501068, -0.011321323923766613, 0.004233154933899641, -0.07577475905418396, 0.049056276679039, 0.011863645166158676, 0.010572658851742744, -0.027656355872750282, -0.02713838778436184, -0.005193472374230623, -0.021732814610004425, 0.055253174155950546, -0.004491444677114487, -0.005383812822401524, 0.0017692080000415444, 0.02351195365190506, 0.013882468454539776, -0.008034024387598038, -0.014629273675382137, -0.0346047580242157, -0.01836121641099453, 0.0046291290782392025, -0.03392358124256134, 0.00904806423932314, 0.0002224697091151029, -0.0008586549083702266, 0.01879388466477394, -0.013850024901330471, 0.011017090640962124, -0.028016215190291405, 0.03889977186918259, 0.026608912274241447, 0.0045198374427855015, 0.042360883206129074, 0.004744816571474075, -0.04441304877400398, -0.005951347295194864, -0.013239933177828789, -0.07117384672164917, 0.030560113489627838, -0.03792529180645943, -0.01403303723782301, -0.0034191336017102003, 0.007101184222847223, -0.020559122785925865, -0.06207239255309105, -0.0015574917197227478, 0.01850161701440811, -0.007488718256354332, 0.028479672968387604, 0.01957836002111435, 0.00800677202641964, 0.059773486107587814, -0.016772300004959106, 0.01664101332426071, 0.008799798786640167, 0.028743797913193703, -0.03800252079963684, 0.026768729090690613, 0.017317501828074455, -0.05819280818104744, 0.0657370537519455, 0.02131211757659912, 0.019466960802674294, 0.051117151975631714, -0.02760617434978485, -0.0017609733622521162, -0.00015196233289316297, -0.0371287576854229, 0.034843847155570984, 0.009030451998114586, 0.0013191798934713006, 0.018837405368685722, 0.001154248253442347, 0.029034042730927467, -0.014095759019255638, 0.017082901671528816, -0.021140312775969505, -0.014011337421834469, -0.017126144841313362, 0.020187875255942345, 0.0237011406570673, 0.01316991075873375, -0.004427818115800619, 0.0019955968018621206, 0.011002430692315102, 0.0004966903943568468, 0.04524364322423935, -0.025592898949980736, 0.022374821826815605, 0.01841731369495392, 0.01656634546816349, -0.012231802567839622, -0.0571448877453804, -0.018630191683769226, -0.03908291459083557, 0.004359159618616104, 0.03138457238674164, 0.0012189724948257208, 0.0255875401198864, -0.025691872462630272, -0.019885843619704247, 0.023377085104584694, -0.09207272529602051, 0.005217436235398054, -0.06380065530538559, 0.04270424693822861, -0.018778009340167046, -0.03429067134857178 ]
<p>If the inflation indices was reset to 100 in the the 3rd quarter, what would be the fourth quarter inflation index for food. I have no idea how to do this . Below is the graph:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/geO3v.png" alt="enter image description here"></p>
73,904
[ -0.005574362352490425, -0.02033863216638565, 0.012115050107240677, 0.05323683097958565, 0.0398823618888855, 0.008008386939764023, 0.01160656102001667, -0.023933470249176025, 0.012248667888343334, -0.0077018216252326965, 0.0019483210053294897, 0.04220549389719963, 0.06015513464808464, 0.020109880715608597, -0.022989491000771523, 0.0074982186779379845, 0.0004972947062924504, -0.02971462719142437, -0.009756390005350113, -0.023293130099773407, 0.03304553031921387, -0.012790248729288578, -0.025028301402926445, 0.01694692298769951, -0.060447849333286285, 0.03862787410616875, 0.055857811123132706, 0.019023671746253967, -0.0029957969672977924, 0.030171319842338562, -0.03538630157709122, -0.052005790174007416, 0.029572322964668274, -0.007440576795488596, 0.04795226454734802, 0.009078574366867542, -0.04667509347200394, -0.04068562388420105, -0.05586092174053192, 0.03987633436918259, -0.051010556519031525, 0.010699323378503323, -0.005521844141185284, 0.0011340120108798146, -0.013418023474514484, 0.0006505625206045806, 0.0006256984197534621, 0.025141097605228424, 0.035890333354473114, -0.0399458222091198, 0.07439205050468445, -0.0009180327760986984, 0.04507141560316086, 0.04820092394948006, -0.001176224322989583, -0.04072026535868645, 0.04908804967999458, 0.056060098111629486, -0.004947175737470388, -0.031086698174476624, -0.008351475931704044, -0.006539878901094198, -0.00834712479263544, -0.04833434522151947, -0.0323454812169075, -0.005592186003923416, -0.028527848422527313, -0.005075280088931322, 0.034280866384506226, -0.027000941336154938, -0.0041693150997161865, 0.021623417735099792, 0.06065948307514191, -0.030061161145567894, 0.022046256810426712, -0.035116758197546005, 0.0505995973944664, 0.013578791171312332, 0.042040664702653885, 0.02123032510280609, 0.008940258994698524, 0.016789907589554787, 0.030683260411024094, 0.07574471831321716, 0.017719637602567673, 0.011574102565646172, 0.06143084913492203, -0.015508070588111877, 0.031089844182133675, 0.04385623708367348, -0.007704343181103468, 0.0002667061926331371, 0.04462667554616928, -0.037975966930389404, -0.02685222029685974, 0.025201797485351562, -0.017603134736418724, 0.025838833302259445, -0.029636574909090996, 0.023314863443374634, 0.029952211305499077, -0.0030892568174749613, -0.0245121568441391, 0.09010560065507889, 0.012648536823689938, 0.015067316591739655, -0.0387149304151535, 0.009656050242483616, -0.01328718289732933, -0.02863176539540291, -0.005672674626111984, 0.0014397386694326997, -0.024087896570563316, -0.02713990956544876, 0.039648156613111496, -0.03847125917673111, -0.011875871568918228, -0.006790776737034321, -0.0010305284522473812, 0.02068951353430748, 0.03302665054798126, -0.007696596905589104, 0.05276978760957718, -0.011123090982437134, -0.09650357067584991, 0.025886379182338715, -0.009329077787697315, -0.008754410780966282, -0.037995632737874985, 0.03769984096288681, -0.006424998864531517, -0.04330999776721001, 0.03291868045926094, -0.04535079002380371, 0.033924683928489685, -0.009124493226408958, -0.04290582984685898, -0.030110424384474754, 0.06284161657094955, 0.010445238091051579, 0.005960851442068815, -0.07262248545885086, 0.014837821945548058, 0.015137341804802418, 0.020765969529747963, 0.007357690948992968, -0.0038719249423593283, 0.02136322483420372, 0.02058381959795952, 0.032603319734334946, -0.05079672858119011, -0.01456146128475666, -0.028814813122153282, -0.04227010905742645, 0.035077743232250214, -0.05616140365600586, 0.01033550314605236, 0.021017348393797874, -0.009822119027376175, -0.02146011032164097, 0.02552316151559353, 0.004879315849393606, 0.007985268719494343, 0.01673983223736286, -0.02915855310857296, -0.02815135195851326, 0.05377509444952011, -0.029572421684861183, -0.038150202482938766, 0.0031258808448910713, -0.022393889725208282, 0.028751583769917488, -0.017775453627109528, 0.03068431280553341, 0.05573921278119087, -0.02671702764928341, -0.005790127441287041, -0.046167369931936264, -0.007703608367592096, 0.013208500109612942, -0.02826715260744095, -0.039152879267930984, 0.014039205387234688, -0.006410551257431507, 0.06672988831996918, 0.007115151267498732, -0.008326440118253231, -0.016072910279035568, 0.0189109668135643, -0.07788819819688797, -0.028662819415330887, -0.0803416445851326, -0.01272666733711958, 0.0022299166303128004, -0.007298795506358147, -0.0063511463813483715, -0.008776473812758923, -0.013950077816843987, 0.023912860080599785, -0.0330781415104866, -0.011653789319097996, 0.03946024551987648, 0.03607667237520218, -0.03962687402963638, 0.015159857459366322, 0.08749507367610931, 0.04556846246123314, -0.032448820769786835, 0.00024635615409351885, -0.04100321978330612, -0.0008972821524366736, -0.007340886630117893, 0.0033556316047906876, 0.0011445947457104921, -0.042761772871017456, -0.03853362053632736, 0.0378243662416935, 0.0318693108856678, -0.03126972168684006, 0.05029063671827316, -0.07690547406673431, 0.05106319114565849, 0.053659483790397644, -0.007837056182324886, 0.020557692274451256, 0.010945077054202557, 0.040157973766326904, 0.0663236603140831, -0.01827274076640606, -0.01068661455065012, -0.05884090065956116, -0.015873108059167862, -0.00882950983941555, 0.008984187617897987, -0.0070245834067463875, 0.036291349679231644, 0.0854540467262268, 0.007209816947579384, 0.0037013913970440626, 0.03148471564054489, 0.030326252803206444, 0.017291419208049774, -0.0023200330324470997, -0.02608725056052208, 0.03056224063038826, 0.032124727964401245, 0.014256754890084267, -0.024896863847970963, 0.021406779065728188, 0.02593800611793995, 0.020283514633774757, 0.014418339356780052, 0.020726440474390984, 0.03275757282972336, -0.014819199219346046, -0.012875493615865707, 0.02758616767823696, -0.02644369751214981, -0.0036689674016088247, 0.03532486781477928, 0.012837342917919159, -0.004455599468201399, 0.014531774446368217, 0.011115354485809803, -0.00023538869572803378, 0.026161540299654007, -0.03581782057881355, -0.028991179540753365, 0.015340348705649376, -0.009762493893504143, 0.017633099108934402, 0.014336623251438141, 0.011996031738817692, -0.029835687950253487, -0.015627646818757057, 0.042516324669122696, 0.021843688562512398, -0.022514065727591515, -0.03485281765460968, -0.04209047555923462, 0.05063202977180481, -0.007478995714336634, 0.008022730238735676, 0.006205185316503048, -0.032796211540699005, 0.03441489115357399, 0.013279926031827927, -0.01277936901897192, 0.002062726067379117, 0.007927163504064083, 0.0060853478498756886, 0.037626396864652634, 0.01853676699101925, 0.000049063852202380076, 0.00016172518371604383, -0.012126740999519825, 0.03081747330725193, -0.07529839873313904, -0.02126312628388405, 0.02987709827721119, -0.0032117003574967384, -0.015818165615200996, -0.02110876888036728, -0.06611195206642151, -0.03012440726161003, -0.04562438279390335, 0.02374649979174137, -0.014991262927651405, 0.021284285932779312, -0.0020639407448470592, -0.0011634769616648555, -0.0021756330970674753, 0.0065118130296468735, -0.06855401396751404, -0.06640839576721191, -0.008619074709713459, 0.009271734394133091, 0.027006596326828003, 0.011091014370322227, -0.05396617203950882, 0.03807292506098747, -0.005211552605032921, -0.028884192928671837, -0.013676855713129044, -0.014669224619865417, -0.009571217000484467, -0.04813729599118233, 0.005610284861177206, -0.01727495901286602, -0.006031988654285669, -0.018012944608926773, 0.025098443031311035, 0.02967836521565914, 0.0469319187104702, 0.05066272243857384, -0.005991977173835039, 0.0131641561165452, 0.030839862301945686, -0.010618436150252819, 0.04671236872673035, 0.00931102130562067, -0.014095894992351532, 0.00878062192350626, 0.0026321883779019117, -0.01335947122424841, 0.011194516904652119, -0.05693243816494942, 0.0313873291015625, -0.02880147099494934, 0.0005974749801680446, -0.04239380359649658, 0.054429784417152405, 0.04384991154074669, 0.043828923255205154, -0.0242211502045393, -0.029374347999691963, 0.06286076456308365, -0.0017266474897041917, 0.0034849902149289846, 0.05630747228860855, 0.026680558919906616, -0.05388779565691948, -0.00841111782938242, -0.0063536749221384525, -0.00859967153519392, -0.00035543888225220144, -0.02229345589876175, -0.009258123114705086, 0.05314764380455017, 0.04337533190846443, 0.01660744845867157, -0.01148875243961811, -0.026948150247335434, 0.006927503738552332, -0.09185263514518738, -0.020836040377616882, -0.03567662835121155, 0.05960717424750328, 0.004025225527584553, 0.04956791549921036, 0.012659250758588314, 0.015300585888326168, 0.025134796276688576, 0.03168889507651329, -0.05193250626325607, 0.02348180301487446, 0.03274660184979439, 0.022059621289372444, 0.005969807971268892, -0.018256880342960358, 0.031092826277017593, -0.004067933186888695, 0.00956739205867052, -0.016069320961833, 0.016335224732756615, -0.021028682589530945, -0.0001381781476084143, 0.011475794017314911, 0.00019532587612047791, 0.004213104490190744, -0.01857866160571575, 0.038980983197689056, 0.01731802709400654, 0.039199359714984894, 0.07007287442684174, -0.0036668595857918262, -0.015643982216715813, -0.01008883211761713, 0.004751537460833788, 0.0010853721760213375, 0.044159695506095886, 0.02848072536289692, -0.011755164712667465, -0.032555874437093735, 0.013064424507319927, 0.07677988708019257, 0.043810002505779266, -0.0000916070057428442, 0.030869068577885628, -0.024928685277700424, -0.057438965886831284, -0.0018897003028541803, -0.009008090943098068, 0.046482913196086884, 0.000453520828159526, -0.027480730786919594, 0.040940821170806885, 0.023748472332954407, -0.027423156425356865, 0.034797318279743195, 0.08676829934120178, -0.008085946552455425, -0.014817805029451847, -0.04109691455960274, -0.00518067367374897, -0.025189705193042755, -0.01451948843896389, 0.02455516904592514, -0.0006843861774541438, 0.010789482854306698, 0.03307582065463066, 0.05397843196988106, -0.009419746696949005, -0.007616947405040264, 0.0038199452683329582, -0.0041454387828707695, 0.06268805265426636, -0.002611201023682952, -0.038157086819410324, -0.008217957802116871, 0.03793059661984444, 0.010683487169444561, 0.01165202260017395, -0.042522504925727844, -0.09543021023273468, 0.011138081550598145, 0.019851204007864, 0.022922225296497345, -0.037609171122312546, -0.006994776427745819, -0.08007887750864029, -0.02573520317673683, 0.029107188805937767, -0.049875639379024506, 0.05751674249768257, -0.028866615146398544, 0.03151291236281395, 0.03005596436560154, -0.026180529966950417, -0.016758764162659645, -0.009635445661842823, -0.014319461770355701, 0.005023104604333639, 0.016340486705303192, 0.014137130230665207, -0.020801523700356483, -0.023810718208551407, 0.004081500228494406, 0.04695059359073639, -0.01936987414956093, 0.00025100994389504194, -0.0010011998238041997, 0.00522675272077322, -0.0699336901307106, -0.06642410904169083, 0.00471750320866704, 0.00403247494250536, 0.023831041529774666, 0.01147687342017889, -0.007552963215857744, 0.007810044568032026, -0.0022765733301639557, 0.0035724760964512825, 0.02373635582625866, -0.03166220709681511, -0.055187683552503586, 0.018600573763251305, 0.02888229489326477, 0.03054928593337536, 0.060563862323760986, 0.05045303702354431, 0.010908289812505245, -0.0025081373751163483, -0.017434723675251007, 0.01441905926913023, -0.04350653663277626, -0.004352315329015255, 0.01731850579380989, 0.019469521939754486, -0.01970645785331726, 0.03225607052445412, -0.03399358317255974, 0.02930244617164135, -0.07126963138580322, -0.004291840363293886, -0.01440377812832594, -0.01911400817334652, 0.0014393460005521774, -0.014683866873383522, -0.011400948278605938, -0.029872506856918335, 0.021846497431397438, -0.05133368447422981, 0.024283383041620255, -0.029870683327317238, -0.00940511655062437, 0.007847543805837631, -0.003984934184700251, 0.022530952468514442, -0.001145892427302897, -0.004802316892892122, -0.017180873081088066, -0.03603495657444, 0.022499822080135345, -0.03973349928855896, 0.020330330356955528, 0.00019422594050411135, -0.05697568878531456, -0.023344755172729492, 0.016286654397845268, 0.02435717172920704, 0.012722937390208244, -0.02184692583978176, 0.028620116412639618, 0.019135303795337677, 0.005892558954656124, -0.0845695212483406, -0.051017455756664276, 0.036067523062229156, -0.00034169101854786277, -0.061591122299432755, -0.02700183354318142, -0.007935132831335068, -0.01092203613370657, -0.02230345830321312, -0.03990376740694046, 0.08014091104269028, -0.02397001162171364, 0.0046654874458909035, -0.014425680972635746, -0.005693576764315367, 0.06113025173544884, -0.012797225266695023, -0.019894389435648918, 0.004996873438358307, -0.0063446578569710255, -0.033797722309827805, 0.00488258944824338, 0.0065565393306314945, -0.009955618530511856, -0.0015771349426358938, -0.018741905689239502, -0.025560224428772926, 0.0048844884149730206, -0.024769991636276245, 0.0007709561614319682, 0.0163370743393898, 0.030618567019701004, -0.030658435076475143, -0.04809991270303726, 0.007927294820547104, 0.00326633476652205, -0.008045783266425133, -0.03557689115405083, 0.013922564685344696, -0.026062287390232086, -0.004936017096042633, 0.004870287142693996, -0.052260205149650574, 0.009749495424330235, -0.0030725710093975067, 0.09785931557416916, -0.015687596052885056, -0.03230847790837288, -0.0031860526651144028, 0.020900890231132507, 0.02784053608775139, 0.011427663266658783, -0.015202406793832779, 0.005048236344009638, -0.014640084467828274, -0.04135040193796158, -0.028667021542787552, -0.027813369408249855, -0.013933084905147552, 0.09273574501276016, -0.004854515194892883, -0.008543447591364384, 0.014109577983617783, -0.006859972607344389, 0.02055218257009983, -0.0049658059142529964, 0.02013484761118889, 0.05771200358867645, -0.027618257328867912, 0.03536131978034973, -0.031264301389455795, -0.025248249992728233, 0.03658822178840637, 0.02230764739215374, -0.008378938771784306, 0.025497768074274063, 0.011417332105338573, 0.03124593198299408, -0.007695021573454142, -0.04939186945557594, -0.06389971822500229, 0.034682441502809525, 0.010116416029632092, 0.014235652051866055, -0.04503712058067322, -0.0736754983663559, 0.07167752832174301, 0.04741194471716881, -0.041348278522491455, -0.0023605346214026213, -0.010119869373738766, -0.039546769112348557, 0.008041292428970337, 0.02411777898669243, -0.015185784548521042, 0.011938587762415409, 0.014543993398547173, 0.019352035596966743, 0.013195044361054897, 0.020390748977661133, -0.0038547355215996504, -0.055465877056121826, -0.03165721148252487, 0.0007802501204423606, -0.011391433887183666, 0.00036324546090327203, -0.026968417689204216, 0.021779365837574005, -0.015806077048182487, -0.021161599084734917, -0.022376881912350655, -0.002009256975725293, 0.024025719612836838, 0.006228533573448658, 0.05540940910577774, 0.02495303750038147, 0.04074821248650551, -0.016097750514745712, 0.01975843869149685, 0.1327500343322754, 0.07672622799873352, -0.01647508703172207, -0.07293243706226349, 0.017491674050688744, 0.0009143491624854505, 0.0434645339846611, -0.021527882665395737, 0.03921225666999817, 0.012573002837598324, 0.024394666776061058, 0.0417155921459198, 0.06255770474672318, -0.042824529111385345, 0.04895981773734093, 0.047665953636169434, 0.003527786349877715, -0.000449170678621158, 0.0022192676551640034, 0.025239842012524605, 0.009463967755436897, 0.007965466007590294, -0.07228279858827591, 0.05565810203552246, -0.03658381476998329, 0.0018470539944246411, -0.04593978449702263, -0.03544234856963158, 0.025420475751161575, -0.006834668107330799, -0.017318937927484512, 0.02297413907945156, -0.016927022486925125, -0.002661833306774497, -0.030474049970507622, 0.01831713877618313, -0.006529810838401318, -0.015962563455104828, 0.026896879076957703, 0.02801671251654625, 0.02662036381661892, 0.005774025339633226, -0.01625676080584526, 0.015207778662443161, -0.0265741515904665, -0.003366190940141678, -0.032355330884456635, 0.018813494592905045, -0.016653647646307945, -0.021926624700427055, -0.028569582849740982, 0.027840401977300644, -0.00828995369374752, -0.017230508849024773, -0.0027174274437129498, -0.0017385075334459543, 0.023737316951155663, -0.009604588150978088, 0.0030329395085573196, -0.006285845767706633, -0.01206501666456461, -0.028982453048229218, 0.04172056168317795, -0.02053695172071457, -0.029240775853395462, -0.00970072578638792, -0.01177674438804388, 0.06509637832641602, -0.01961447298526764, -0.03005055896937847, 0.04184049367904663, -0.0017413002206012607, -0.02065846137702465, 0.007370668929070234, -0.013095495291054249, 0.04622900113463402, 0.04032965376973152, 0.008093742653727531, 0.01668267883360386, 0.0024802428670227528, -0.0011979738483205438, 0.021341225132346153, -0.013865943998098373, -0.0100324135273695, -0.07365366816520691, -0.015564990229904652, 0.022592220455408096, 0.07506874203681946, -0.03421001881361008, 0.013914713636040688, -0.030718013644218445, 0.011265108361840248, 0.047147318720817566, -0.03929002955555916, -0.008628611452877522, 0.0012756433570757508, -0.037852462381124496, -0.015444271266460419, -0.047295406460762024, 0.08587560057640076, 0.054240498691797256, 0.012974307872354984, 0.014346498064696789, 0.0010029700351879, -0.0024699748028069735, 0.02003691904246807, 0.016569774597883224, -0.04334248974919319, 0.003778367303311825, 0.04875461757183075, -0.00898418202996254, -0.06840238720178604, -0.04160822555422783, -0.01255678478628397, -0.010273462161421776, -0.048281919211149216, 0.035021472722291946, -0.02342698723077774, 0.009892968460917473, -0.01467294991016388, 0.0025899948086589575, -0.033564239740371704, 0.02048727124929428, -0.05207759514451027, -0.03650161623954773, 0.03806902468204498, -0.00551254115998745, -0.03902213275432587, 0.04182073101401329, -0.038602314889431, 0.02025027573108673, 0.04012048617005348, 0.01033097505569458, -0.006035918835550547, -0.022599974647164345, 0.02626545913517475, 0.04789062589406967, 0.032998375594615936, 0.018475471064448357, -0.038900744169950485, 0.021594978868961334, -0.051146481186151505, -0.051712486892938614, -0.01742362789809704, 0.014149048365652561, 0.03950090706348419, 0.028602441772818565, 0.018169982358813286, -0.030290303751826286, 0.05176202952861786, -0.03054250031709671, 0.03100661002099514, -0.012077389284968376, -0.01761685311794281, 0.040641654282808304, 0.034019168466329575, -0.01743076741695404, 0.0071731070056557655, 0.002158442744985223, -0.005307748448103666, 0.020017463713884354, -0.020191101357340813, -0.0036128945648670197, -0.009490778669714928, -0.02974720112979412, -0.04175940155982971, -0.021081097424030304, 0.002066057873889804, 0.010971350595355034, 0.04521360620856285, 0.008609691634774208, -0.004157971125096083, -0.004666920285671949, 0.002028148854151368, -0.030579455196857452, 0.03354716673493385, 0.013101797550916672, 0.0028823825996369123, 0.03746113181114197, 0.007636707741767168, 0.036355044692754745, 0.027362477034330368, -0.04924105852842331, 0.035756275057792664, -0.008707471191883087, 0.012296878732740879, -0.024457121267914772, 0.009474486112594604, 0.016346756368875504, 0.03133383020758629, 0.04111366346478462, 0.008754262700676918, 0.01911412551999092, -0.007100523449480534, 0.0017390998546034098, -0.02688114158809185, 0.02076411247253418, 0.027299387380480766, 0.024244150146842003, -0.02688097208738327, -0.0036864541471004486, -0.059400252997875214, -0.015485786832869053, 0.0022507319226861, -0.01916930265724659, 0.03189802169799805, -0.01923554018139839, 0.018673602491617203, -0.010404991917312145, 0.06825856864452362, 0.003984324634075165, 0.041818536818027496, -0.0186174213886261, -0.026881180703639984, -0.004015101585537195, 0.026870345696806908, 0.003455580910667777, -0.0008630481897853315, 0.007759560365229845, -0.021071450784802437, -0.03905153274536133, -0.016953442245721817, -0.009637470357120037, 0.0035987170413136482, 0.005402302835136652, -0.0377839133143425, -0.0008087292080745101, -0.021936846897006035, 0.01788838766515255, -0.04423757269978523, 0.01747378706932068, 0.06127943471074104, -0.03671196475625038, -0.010688409209251404, -0.047901496291160583, 0.025474252179265022, -0.01835671439766884, 0.024915874004364014, -0.0010622384725138545, -0.050281066447496414, -0.06417550891637802, 0.010949205607175827, -0.014501579105854034, 0.004626052919775248, -0.02129969745874405, 0.004178405739367008, -0.04383449628949165, 0.026136083528399467, 0.007584166247397661, -0.03263679891824722, 0.010377269238233566, -0.0036729436833411455, 0.019468659535050392, -0.06627537310123444, 0.008334903046488762, 0.022991716861724854, -0.03262604400515556, -0.007547798566520214, -0.03200250118970871, -0.05490659177303314, 0.0043369862250983715, 0.03569081053137779, -0.00707564502954483, -0.04051515460014343, -0.014709582552313805, -0.0041462029330432415, 0.03943612799048424, -0.07779622822999954, 0.0416015163064003, 0.012017130851745605, -0.005797856952995062, 0.011423728428781033, 0.0009540091268718243, -0.010536001063883305, -0.02242305502295494, -0.021577918902039528, 0.011528979055583477, 0.021624870598316193, -0.007365132216364145, 0.002357791643589735, -0.0005014802445657551, -0.01899595558643341, -0.021727627143263817, 0.042284172028303146, 0.03946782648563385, -0.01837465539574623, 0.06179211288690567, 0.018567334860563278, -0.03894190490245819, 0.006418471224606037, -0.008763947524130344, 0.003402095753699541, -0.012597267515957355, 0.0033445325680077076, 0.014012683182954788, -0.0709485411643982, 0.0022788902278989553, 0.010173623450100422, -0.034637801349163055, -0.01184920221567154, 0.025245727971196175, 0.004245622083544731, 0.035047076642513275, 0.020698904991149902, 0.03218957781791687, -0.01592332310974598, -0.024139853194355965, 0.032431166619062424, -0.0018277369672432542, -0.0033282602671533823, -0.002208005404099822, 0.023268789052963257, 0.057743851095438004, 0.027657819911837578, 0.012421474792063236, -0.006427429616451263, 0.04444991052150726, -0.004225550219416618, -0.015923282131552696, 0.0040738401003181934, -0.03607563301920891, 0.007970653474330902, 0.07217364013195038, 0.010471463203430176, 0.016726801171898842, -0.018806476145982742, 0.015134846791625023, -0.0058253612369298935, 0.026202764362096786, -0.07117302715778351, 0.04086059331893921, -0.02620929479598999, -0.023405328392982483, -0.04919516295194626, 0.021923372521996498, 0.0028908795211464167, 0.01717413030564785, 0.010583479888737202, -0.010555754415690899, -0.009252728894352913, -0.01152965147048235, -0.015292798168957233, -0.04537152498960495, 0.0007855638978071511, -0.03779717907309532, 0.002245740732178092, 0.04101741686463356, -0.0024147238582372665, 0.03389071673154831, 0.04043940082192421, -0.009154453873634338, -0.012481196783483028, 0.05572519823908806, -0.02926834486424923, -0.009276282042264938, -0.02975223772227764, 0.007409669924527407, -0.012015679851174355, -0.04004900902509689 ]
<p><strong>I have applied the lm() to a data set. The independent variables are categorical. First, I use lm() with intercept and I got the next results:</strong></p> <pre><code>&gt; model &lt;- lm(y ~ factor(x)) &gt; summary(model) Call: lm(formula = y ~ factor(x)) Residuals: Min 1Q Median 3Q Max -5.3085 -1.8132 -0.4136 1.4323 11.2480 Coefficients: Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(&gt;|t|) (Intercept) 9.3085 0.4064 22.907 &lt;2e-16 *** factor(x)0.75 0.1435 0.6896 0.208 0.836 factor(x)1.5 0.9062 0.6272 1.445 0.151 factor(x)3 0.9040 0.6989 1.293 0.198 --- Signif. codes: 0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1 Residual standard error: 2.786 on 126 degrees of freedom Multiple R-squared: 0.0238, Adjusted R-squared: 0.0005601 F-statistic: 1.024 on 3 and 126 DF, p-value: 0.3844 </code></pre> <p><strong>In the second model I don't use intercept:</strong></p> <pre><code>&gt; model.1 &lt;- lm(y ~ factor(x) - 1) &gt; summary(model.1) Call: lm(formula = y ~ factor(x) - 1) Residuals: Min 1Q Median 3Q Max -5.3085 -1.8132 -0.4136 1.4323 11.2480 Coefficients: Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(&gt;|t|) factor(x)0.25 9.3085 0.4064 22.91 &lt;2e-16 *** factor(x)0.75 9.4520 0.5572 16.96 &lt;2e-16 *** factor(x)1.5 10.2147 0.4778 21.38 &lt;2e-16 *** factor(x)3 10.2125 0.5687 17.96 &lt;2e-16 *** --- Signif. codes: 0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1 Residual standard error: 2.786 on 126 degrees of freedom Multiple R-squared: 0.9267, Adjusted R-squared: 0.9243 F-statistic: 398 on 4 and 126 DF, p-value: &lt; 2.2e-16 </code></pre> <p>If I don't understand the difference between the R-squared value of them? Could I accept the second one as a fit model?</p> <p>Would somebody help me to understand this problem?</p>
73,905
[ -0.007757255341857672, 0.05264035612344742, 0.0035545139107853174, -0.0008045280701480806, 0.025509607046842575, 0.015506796538829803, 0.00340647017583251, -0.03268151357769966, 0.051794007420539856, -0.04319474473595619, 0.0193036962300539, 0.034939225763082504, 0.05087636783719063, -0.002067888854071498, 0.03340943157672882, 0.011161457747220993, 0.01041586883366108, -0.00006946150097064674, 0.02661021053791046, -0.01979677565395832, -0.02854909934103489, 0.016838887706398964, 0.017935186624526978, 0.010447030887007713, -0.008332304656505585, 0.054558463394641876, 0.05821901559829712, 0.0009240233339369297, 0.00675700418651104, 0.010683869943022728, -0.03531297668814659, -0.0010920395143330097, -0.006388109177350998, -0.01942167617380619, 0.00041934585897251964, 0.041721802204847336, 0.006115834228694439, -0.009550364688038826, -0.013360973447561264, 0.029813731089234352, 0.01809779740869999, -0.0006970011163502932, -0.014326581731438637, 0.007119789253920317, 0.011298523284494877, 0.0010456603486090899, 0.02334328554570675, -0.007394089363515377, 0.08192578703165054, -0.0002011976030189544, 0.060383498668670654, -0.0003952448896598071, 0.013909084722399712, 0.020934615284204483, -0.05365768447518349, -0.017581351101398468, 0.05012715607881546, 0.05753438547253609, -0.005204247776418924, -0.03161834180355072, -0.00792967714369297, -0.05343102291226387, 0.007356950547546148, -0.021249664947390556, -0.033610668033361435, 0.011153812520205975, 0.016115767881274223, -0.016353674232959747, 0.029989341273903847, -0.023492105305194855, 0.008563808165490627, 0.01582457311451435, 0.015199151821434498, -0.017750432714819908, 0.016759980469942093, 0.007011075969785452, 0.00628235936164856, 0.0041637783870100975, 0.003314306028187275, 0.03215011581778526, -0.01623542793095112, 0.016608303412795067, 0.031175898388028145, 0.03840578719973564, -0.019482269883155823, -0.0011181975714862347, 0.05758490785956383, -0.003987621050328016, -0.005598200019448996, 0.0014902196126058698, -0.05520131066441536, 0.027759362012147903, 0.0477026104927063, 0.001794808660633862, -0.01710440032184124, 0.040352996438741684, 0.0007477623294107616, 0.018337473273277283, 0.03334629535675049, -0.004746055696159601, -0.020145326852798462, -0.07305321097373962, 0.013138544745743275, 0.025049077346920967, -0.018149305135011673, -0.029044440016150475, -0.02738027088344097, -0.002584803616628051, 0.010372009128332138, -0.049790043383836746, 0.0024018536787480116, -0.010958675295114517, -0.021317511796951294, -0.04592043533921242, 0.012914376333355904, -0.05481446906924248, -0.00713544525206089, -0.022402919828891754, 0.05916186794638634, 0.04032429680228233, 0.05024091526865959, -0.05252489820122719, -0.024579063057899475, -0.023586083203554153, -0.030293738469481468, -0.00877476204186678, 0.005844746250659227, -0.0034702294506132603, -0.014864682219922543, 0.016575418412685394, -0.003606107784435153, -0.025616995990276337, 0.043043218553066254, 0.009459836408495903, -0.0023382774088531733, 0.010554365813732147, -0.06099395826458931, -0.053679872304201126, 0.02851656638085842, 0.006315398495644331, 0.009989525191485882, -0.04262271150946617, -0.012136165052652359, 0.05625583976507187, 0.05181156098842621, 0.019081275910139084, 0.03128640726208687, 0.03653537109494209, 0.0061019896529614925, 0.03302660956978798, -0.034468114376068115, 0.0033355006016790867, -0.05167741701006889, -0.0027552801184356213, -0.021928923204541206, -0.06409672647714615, -0.04826290160417557, -0.008515583351254463, -0.050495315343141556, 0.03201964870095253, 0.02445780672132969, 0.008553595282137394, 0.010671562515199184, 0.004312600940465927, -0.010880566202104092, -0.008532542735338211, 0.05494279786944389, -0.032970674335956573, 0.03454554080963135, 0.042501527816057205, -0.017280610278248787, -0.015445111319422722, 0.003030691761523485, 0.04973161220550537, -0.003612802131101489, -0.020100537687540054, 0.02171918749809265, -0.02478242665529251, 0.02413274720311165, 0.0456206239759922, -0.09423381835222244, -0.02209954708814621, -0.006016403436660767, -0.03029891848564148, 0.0243911724537611, 0.06227193772792816, -0.01773008704185486, -0.02910015918314457, 0.06415928155183792, -0.048804450780153275, -0.04807509109377861, -0.03800603747367859, -0.02864334173500538, 0.010589669458568096, -0.041712772101163864, 0.00821352656930685, 0.016563070937991142, 0.02614464797079563, 0.010478435084223747, 0.051439810544252396, -0.0562593899667263, -0.013404648751020432, 0.05622486025094986, -0.029113441705703735, 0.014404652640223503, 0.049001507461071014, 0.0683266893029213, 0.0036299345083534718, 0.0265519917011261, -0.006831104401499033, -0.007771259639412165, 0.058523669838905334, -0.04438448324799538, 0.0043649435974657536, -0.02926565706729889, -0.0526406466960907, 0.008213968947529793, 0.002071249997243285, -0.029752055183053017, 0.02744213119149208, -0.0373050794005394, 0.03954443708062172, 0.03466913849115372, 0.014780625700950623, -0.031542085111141205, -0.00979058537632227, -0.027909578755497932, 0.04362247884273529, -0.04332389310002327, 0.04817855358123779, -0.035515252500772476, -0.02666071429848671, 0.041165709495544434, 0.029650021344423294, -0.04157749190926552, -0.0030454176012426615, 0.014337092638015747, -0.03222157061100006, 0.032322078943252563, 0.025692151859402657, -0.004687148611992598, -0.03086153045296669, 0.03765188157558441, 0.0038219671696424484, 0.0217478945851326, 0.006437497679144144, 0.035690829157829285, 0.006535204127430916, 0.016681427136063576, 0.003871453460305929, 0.004330210387706757, 0.049541134387254715, -0.029482603073120117, -0.025824399664998055, -0.012890683487057686, -0.02789407968521118, 0.0374230220913887, 0.005186119116842747, -0.011516126804053783, 0.053596459329128265, 0.00276202242821455, -0.0035791194532066584, -0.003740910440683365, 0.005585638340562582, 0.007750207092612982, 0.022062044590711594, -0.011143626645207405, -0.02728467620909214, 0.013099080882966518, -0.021706968545913696, 0.002977361436933279, -0.062124770134687424, -0.029258277267217636, -0.02147502452135086, -0.011431153863668442, 0.023878714069724083, -0.0008851863676682115, -0.01669975370168686, -0.01984539069235325, 0.03898585960268974, -0.02582511678338051, 0.0072457436472177505, 0.06288615614175797, -0.006675240583717823, -0.05753425508737564, -0.04219603165984154, -0.030225323513150215, -0.003701627952978015, 0.024723639711737633, -0.0030249746050685644, -0.05974540486931801, 0.011750882491469383, -0.027289429679512978, -0.04129453003406525, -0.027739103883504868, -0.021394899114966393, -0.010530781000852585, -0.006173701491206884, -0.024803249165415764, 0.05985728278756142, -0.01528991386294365, -0.03146299719810486, 0.028255589306354523, -0.038941871374845505, -0.028539851307868958, -0.01612471602857113, 0.01202973909676075, -0.00970386154949665, 0.00508650578558445, -0.01126857940107584, 0.01575930044054985, -0.015484832227230072, -0.009145183488726616, -0.10140152275562286, -0.02198001742362976, 0.012216395698487759, -0.0040731970220804214, -0.006209667772054672, 0.0003553226706571877, 0.0032848368864506483, 0.04860055819153786, 0.0061308853328228, -0.036322060972452164, -0.05127471685409546, 0.014410072937607765, -0.04294617846608162, -0.028634220361709595, 0.01747259497642517, 0.031806834042072296, 0.059078920632600784, 0.031291112303733826, -0.04865316301584244, 0.017977382987737656, 0.00962381437420845, -0.010795125737786293, 0.001219653757289052, 0.04784681648015976, 0.00688121747225523, -0.027691496536135674, 0.03552446514368057, 0.04366573691368103, 0.01866811513900757, 0.02075894922018051, 0.018946563825011253, 0.05714612454175949, -0.030213691294193268, -0.020967228338122368, -0.006914180237799883, -0.03980318456888199, 0.006602391134947538, -0.058030251413583755, 0.011878321878612041, 0.02009955793619156, -0.012978870421648026, -0.012206710875034332, -0.02362237684428692, 0.017498407512903214, -0.025260601192712784, 0.017941655591130257, 0.056550282984972, 0.03377649933099747, 0.007269092835485935, 0.01851818710565567, -0.026589790359139442, -0.02797381393611431, 0.058555543422698975, -0.04516903683543205, 0.01271870918571949, 0.05935182422399521, 0.017859959974884987, 0.02443609945476055, -0.005048790946602821, -0.023308467119932175, 0.02347976341843605, -0.03871368244290352, 0.022100623697042465, -0.010319596156477928, 0.03751625120639801, -0.004230050835758448, 0.04357536882162094, -0.013637986965477467, -0.02151769958436489, -0.01403270848095417, -0.02879202552139759, -0.04151388257741928, 0.03100738488137722, 0.0076264976523816586, -0.025543823838233948, 0.026553139090538025, -0.03681180626153946, 0.03223681077361107, -0.05730513483285904, 0.03383320942521095, -0.021394314244389534, -0.01746542379260063, 0.008425883017480373, 0.0079259742051363, 0.006786250974982977, 0.05670982226729393, -0.013430347666144371, 0.027589278295636177, 0.0038126674480736256, -0.0270265843719244, -0.0020029256120324135, 0.04560330510139465, -0.03164278715848923, 0.011999373324215412, -0.04788413643836975, -0.0042848787270486355, 0.04169982299208641, 0.04181195795536041, 0.06409700214862823, 0.02394910715520382, -0.029084462672472, 0.031086040660738945, 0.0017083979910239577, 0.011385868303477764, 0.06299030780792236, -0.0025471928529441357, -0.024644766002893448, -0.019223323091864586, -0.022917933762073517, -0.019155282527208328, 0.013602335937321186, -0.009991900064051151, -0.013136402703821659, 0.05007229000329971, 0.03934852033853531, -0.056046515703201294, 0.051030319184064865, 0.03214162215590477, 0.006051983218640089, -0.019466811791062355, -0.04810971021652222, -0.02749144285917282, -0.017917772755026817, -0.017630286514759064, 0.05950315669178963, 0.0034184292890131474, -0.0015595705481246114, -0.01992158219218254, 0.05264861509203911, -0.04195108264684677, -0.059527527540922165, 0.004725419916212559, 0.06570306420326233, 0.00526599632576108, 0.003620853880420327, -0.032653532922267914, -0.0033534609246999025, 0.04305161535739899, 0.013425767421722412, -0.0054723951034247875, 0.03066837787628174, -0.09843134880065918, 0.0028314765077084303, 0.025048427283763885, 0.04089265689253807, -0.03937844932079315, -0.0004490504798013717, -0.040881842374801636, -0.030808379873633385, 0.002375510288402438, -0.03464812785387039, 0.034704964607954025, -0.01446735579520464, 0.018565399572253227, 0.015255196951329708, -0.01418578252196312, -0.0688544511795044, 0.018540238961577415, 0.01427525095641613, 0.028165407478809357, -0.021775702014565468, -0.013380413874983788, -0.02635672315955162, 0.016479797661304474, 0.013911214657127857, 0.02361905388534069, -0.05804990604519844, -0.025795666500926018, 0.03310365974903107, 0.018973447382450104, 0.008633309043943882, -0.06600406765937805, 0.011541197076439857, 0.006553660612553358, 0.005598679184913635, 0.03467944264411926, -0.016592184081673622, -0.0074478439055383205, -0.005152435507625341, 0.013674045912921429, 0.0073615978471934795, 0.010628027841448784, -0.02447030507028103, 0.03345256298780441, 0.015306783840060234, -0.015233269892632961, 0.05855990946292877, 0.013020666316151619, -0.034607112407684326, 0.006754408590495586, -0.04515797272324562, 0.030590971931815147, -0.024404555559158325, -0.05418957397341728, -0.04098797217011452, -0.013857221230864525, 0.02990574948489666, 0.03145797923207283, -0.010928071103990078, 0.009079850278794765, -0.04409870505332947, 0.01853446662425995, 0.024604184553027153, 0.0030621951445937157, 0.0015048148343339562, 0.011979173868894577, 0.01585821434855461, 0.016729069873690605, -0.03275315836071968, -0.0363384373486042, -0.000615673023276031, -0.018907053396105766, -0.04084945097565651, 0.004029413685202599, -0.04804302752017975, -0.026117637753486633, 0.024565374478697777, -0.02505923993885517, -0.02261519618332386, 0.023051893338561058, 0.002055191434919834, -0.003064806805923581, 0.044155657291412354, -0.022409813478589058, -0.036163996905088425, -0.023572752252221107, 0.030929675325751305, 0.008342183195054531, 0.007906858809292316, -0.003959077410399914, 0.021003691479563713, 0.020955024287104607, -0.02911227010190487, -0.04772847890853882, -0.0244513638317585, 0.016847150400280952, -0.008892164565622807, -0.056961242109537125, -0.004973644390702248, -0.06450877338647842, 0.005109206307679415, 0.008807890117168427, -0.017364224418997765, 0.04703223705291748, -0.04619000852108002, -0.036710385233163834, -0.015509511344134808, 0.010005020536482334, 0.027861645445227623, -0.04476820304989815, 0.006918213330209255, 0.015740176662802696, -0.038648538291454315, -0.022760923951864243, 0.018369076773524284, -0.03508736565709114, -0.017984870821237564, -0.004856475628912449, -0.024496540427207947, 0.0029909852892160416, 0.053068675100803375, -0.01236888486891985, -0.04003014415502548, -0.0051347254775464535, 0.003115580417215824, 0.021917622536420822, -0.027581822127103806, -0.003854782087728381, -0.019992660731077194, 0.015865517780184746, -0.00904768891632557, 0.02921138145029545, 0.00018241882207803428, 0.02345097064971924, 0.037079762667417526, -0.03907260298728943, -0.06038641929626465, 0.019885079935193062, 0.0767814889550209, 0.012888345867395401, 0.02176954597234726, -0.02846856601536274, -0.024503068998456, 0.05835269019007683, 0.010004095733165741, 0.014852765947580338, 0.004661818500608206, 0.034423310309648514, -0.020263662561774254, -0.012296296656131744, -0.02780669927597046, 0.019201526418328285, 0.03105403296649456, 0.005381021648645401, 0.020153837278485298, 0.018539559096097946, -0.019037391990423203, 0.009358487091958523, -0.04643416777253151, -0.03711607679724693, 0.013154193758964539, 0.015981096774339676, 0.0713750422000885, -0.020535951480269432, -0.006533327978104353, 0.0516740083694458, -0.012039300985634327, 0.018159590661525726, -0.0010697238612920046, -0.005567389074712992, -0.0029553640633821487, 0.0005693701095879078, -0.016577769070863724, -0.022747492417693138, 0.014114759862422943, -0.04324115067720413, 0.01561023760586977, -0.041150420904159546, -0.01805667206645012, 0.02733275666832924, 0.02135596238076687, 0.002479495480656624, -0.06603662669658661, -0.029103808104991913, -0.05902949348092079, -0.016302961856126785, 0.032036229968070984, 0.005939121823757887, 0.019336039200425148, -0.008552758023142815, 0.07165428251028061, -0.0027862200513482094, 0.05797204375267029, -0.03182804957032204, -0.0630045011639595, -0.04716259986162186, 0.01970726065337658, 0.011631162837147713, 0.07298991084098816, 0.00871585588902235, 0.0009424055460840464, 0.061998359858989716, -0.06094973906874657, 0.03588582202792168, 0.03410736098885536, 0.04384329542517662, 0.006412974093109369, 0.055642157793045044, 0.019689613953232765, 0.0015133540146052837, -0.012989222072064877, -0.02658725343644619, 0.1389475017786026, 0.09102445095777512, 0.04660242423415184, -0.06230787932872772, 0.021174263209104538, 0.03229578956961632, 0.015081668272614479, 0.014975309371948242, -0.024937305599451065, 0.03131270408630371, -0.03575269132852554, 0.06037893518805504, 0.04895390197634697, 0.05753256380558014, -0.030959680676460266, 0.03208974748849869, -0.009851033799350262, 0.011276055127382278, -0.013736182823777199, 0.02798406407237053, 0.023870114237070084, -0.03030685894191265, -0.013886378146708012, -0.02406495250761509, -0.0070877838879823685, -0.029589831829071045, -0.040654588490724564, 0.009330619126558304, -0.021544199436903, -0.0005542670842260122, -0.056424688547849655, 0.023023752495646477, 0.006786458194255829, 0.013061928562819958, 0.011936651542782784, -0.012023163959383965, 0.03266061469912529, -0.032623082399368286, 0.008731355890631676, 0.025898993015289307, -0.015335844829678535, 0.012396116741001606, 0.005132488440722227, 0.02757987007498741, -0.03860775753855705, -0.03834909945726395, -0.03729541227221489, 0.03734913840889931, 0.031500443816185, -0.0036921855062246323, -0.011207283474504948, 0.0024814377538859844, -0.015960268676280975, -0.00751180574297905, 0.00868393387645483, 0.033913932740688324, -0.017771851271390915, -0.025789601728320122, 0.00230382289737463, -0.015405169688165188, 0.0650315061211586, -0.010836329311132431, -0.006080481689423323, 0.029235664755105972, -0.03257863596081734, -0.010474682785570621, -0.0681876391172409, 0.06231047213077545, 0.0017001196974888444, 0.04173646494746208, 0.013732762075960636, -0.006138784810900688, -0.000866259797476232, 0.002955598058179021, 0.023016231134533882, 0.028095556423068047, 0.02219208888709545, -0.012749134562909603, 0.002192251617088914, -0.04630618542432785, -0.03579312562942505, 0.03504912555217743, -0.02741157077252865, -0.011699954979121685, -0.054577089846134186, -0.033993132412433624, 0.021259715780615807, 0.005952863954007626, 0.018685728311538696, 0.011412614025175571, -0.009509294293820858, 0.04426579922437668, -0.017320899292826653, -0.05298832058906555, -0.022561155259609222, 0.03522133454680443, -0.019382981583476067, 0.014135187491774559, -0.028632458299398422, 0.05075101926922798, 0.06368973106145859, 0.04251037910580635, 0.004673127084970474, 0.012267716228961945, 0.012542461045086384, -0.002379099139943719, 0.02366887778043747, -0.022981174290180206, 0.009462447836995125, 0.03415832296013832, -0.027403686195611954, 0.006846467033028603, 0.0019908600952476263, -0.06660440564155579, -0.06209735944867134, 0.0017940805992111564, 0.012513034977018833, -0.0423823781311512, 0.029626181349158287, -0.009357945993542671, 0.001013443456031382, -0.014425402507185936, -0.017806971445679665, -0.029140684753656387, -0.0010969843715429306, -0.037622902542352676, -0.06736861169338226, -0.051613468676805496, 0.03536492958664894, 0.011699963361024857, 0.004294097889214754, 0.026263361796736717, -0.016535446047782898, 0.05368300899863243, -0.019307978451251984, 0.029823698103427887, 0.031710077077150345, 0.009658792987465858, 0.011078360490500927, -0.014338817447423935, 0.0013775484403595328, -0.019261032342910767, -0.0399991050362587, 0.005790082272142172, -0.018053440377116203, 0.021210787817835808, 0.04132642224431038, 0.049268290400505066, -0.02499769814312458, 0.04168989136815071, -0.002298344625160098, -0.022167548537254333, -0.0018331604078412056, -0.013057434931397438, 0.012660768814384937, -0.028696635738015175, 0.006814258638769388, -0.004102577455341816, -0.021524276584386826, 0.021534059196710587, 0.07835177332162857, -0.03629567101597786, 0.026093127205967903, 0.033536627888679504, -0.03569774329662323, 0.017189081758260727, 0.022727416828274727, -0.01536142360419035, 0.010679916478693485, 0.020870964974164963, -0.0017701057950034738, 0.05578109622001648, -0.02370748110115528, 0.03382067009806633, -0.1086110845208168, -0.023313255980610847, -0.008810745552182198, 0.03777890279889107, 0.05336059257388115, -0.05953732132911682, -0.007680610753595829, 0.04107498750090599, -0.02617649920284748, 0.0031645006965845823, -0.009725880809128284, 0.022749273106455803, -0.030651234090328217, 0.016859794035553932, -0.028665322810411453, -0.0028427904471755028, 0.037867624312639236, 0.027024343609809875, 0.05376947671175003, 0.013161725364625454, 0.01768123172223568, -0.020040396600961685, -0.026597535237669945, -0.009542237035930157, 0.021988768130540848, -0.025850363075733185, -0.0020151424687355757, -0.03665107488632202, 0.003232039976865053, 0.005935074761509895, 0.012302345596253872, 0.02201884053647518, 0.013104893267154694, 0.022239383310079575, 0.023501604795455933, 0.03177196532487869, 0.017195431515574455, 0.012171183712780476, -0.01238152664154768, 0.006738985888659954, 0.03607416898012161, 0.012244539335370064, -0.024108976125717163, 0.008258175104856491, -0.020172059535980225, 0.009584121406078339, 0.0004776007845066488, 0.02699919417500496, 0.0020361256320029497, 0.010124877095222473, -0.012439621612429619, 0.046120136976242065, 0.005119992885738611, -0.03483552485704422, -0.0023621933069080114, -0.04216586798429489, 0.0016268460312858224, 0.04011937230825424, 0.04714537411928177, -0.014315524138510227, 0.026827454566955566, -0.0022331057116389275, -0.0003774446959141642, 0.022296061739325523, -0.027553150430321693, 0.008927561342716217, -0.045775704085826874, -0.011582541279494762, 0.007603632751852274, 0.0034809382632374763, -0.026434611529111862, 0.00329434871673584, -0.05980147793889046, 0.025484250858426094, -0.03563970699906349, -0.015545940957963467, 0.013086194172501564, -0.006682808045297861, 0.051414042711257935, -0.11589857935905457, 0.03651747107505798, 0.016925830394029617, -0.012140193022787571, -0.027754422277212143, -0.00846155546605587, -0.0653211697936058, 0.048676591366529465, 0.04390586540102959, 0.04362814128398895, -0.02706269733607769, -0.009401077404618263, 0.04585304111242294, 0.00963553786277771, -0.03667372837662697, 0.0351380929350853, 0.00907693151384592, 0.012564406730234623, -0.00014812772860750556, -0.01054457202553749, 0.0322001576423645, 0.03275285288691521, 0.03260607644915581, 0.011136201210319996, 0.013840323314070702, 0.005361270625144243, -0.035670869052410126, 0.04413016512989998, -0.021552328020334244, -0.008936132304370403, 0.04482542350888252, 0.006925380323082209, 0.01954229362308979, 0.09140214323997498, 0.01703966036438942, -0.0769353061914444, 0.03406280279159546, -0.0017319052712991834, 0.01047847792506218, 0.01368691399693489, -0.005742999725043774, -0.00985807552933693, -0.05434958636760712, 0.017146959900856018, 0.03051041252911091, -0.03197536990046501, -0.005969391204416752, -0.011477542109787464, 0.024771934375166893, 0.019402174279093742, 0.022980621084570885, 0.013932295143604279, 0.016207179054617882, -0.03445800393819809, 0.06468195468187332, 0.016383303329348564, 0.037268929183483124, 0.011457564309239388, 0.02506832219660282, 0.028018655255436897, -0.03666125237941742, 0.00032193560036830604, -0.01783466525375843, 0.048685505986213684, -0.01701403222978115, -0.023012831807136536, 0.01697959005832672, 0.0038595213554799557, 0.03158392012119293, -0.014265415258705616, -0.010127091780304909, 0.009033010341227055, -0.05732535570859909, 0.013591326773166656, 0.009228003211319447, 0.009377176873385906, -0.031894221901893616, -0.014646229334175587, -0.002917597070336342, 0.02071608416736126, -0.018937649205327034, 0.005540746729820967, 0.020941002294421196, -0.033281110227108, -0.03601393103599548, 0.006441366858780384, 0.0069568948820233345, -0.0054414845071733, 0.002711834851652384, -0.05421968549489975, -0.04418640583753586, -0.039184022694826126, -0.07071464508771896, 0.009615964256227016, 0.053481150418519974, 0.010026095435023308, -0.06360314041376114, -0.024088570848107338, -0.017151858657598495, 0.024471981450915337, -0.036365170031785965, -0.01716853864490986, -0.02398623339831829, 0.01838778331875801, 0.015396100468933582, -0.012339928187429905 ]
<p>I am working on a self-study question where </p> <blockquote> <p>A study indicates that the typical American woman spends USD 340 per year for personal care products. The distribution of the amount follows a right-skewed distribution with a standard deviation of USD 80 per year. If a random sample of 100 women is selected, what is the probability that the sample mean of this sample will be between USD320 and USD350?</p> </blockquote> <p>I made two attempts to answer the question: one using normal distribution and another using CLT. However, neither approach has helped me achieve the goal answer of 0.8882.</p> <p><strong><em>My Normal Distribution Approach</em></strong></p> <blockquote> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/umt1i.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> </blockquote> <p><strong><em>My CLT Approach</em></strong></p> <blockquote> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/Ap99x.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> </blockquote> <p>Appreciate some guidance and advice please</p>
73,906
[ -0.023213110864162445, -0.03821709007024765, 0.052471455186605453, -0.00233585387468338, 0.022768760100007057, -0.02049480751156807, 0.002501677954569459, 0.0012870590435341, 0.0062883710488677025, -0.017926210537552834, 0.039319004863500595, 0.050793878734111786, 0.02834988385438919, 0.03041769191622734, 0.021828260272741318, 0.027098556980490685, -0.02029729075729847, -0.020295388996601105, -0.00837923027575016, -0.02637743577361107, 0.0024250983260571957, -0.005638145841658115, -0.01393077801913023, -0.03776584938168526, -0.04386421665549278, 0.03405608609318733, 0.02945195697247982, -0.05407935380935669, 0.009635403752326965, 0.050421301275491714, -0.022544803097844124, -0.019924890249967575, -0.0028561786748468876, 0.02196553163230419, 0.04909651726484299, -0.0021309207659214735, 0.0018546644132584333, -0.0102577805519104, 0.01005540695041418, 0.0343182273209095, -0.009397171437740326, 0.01956665888428688, -0.013729967176914215, 0.029156245291233063, -0.019180556759238243, 0.03577590733766556, 0.01668619178235531, -0.07070926576852798, 0.036496035754680634, -0.05144839361310005, 0.043104033917188644, -0.007197702769190073, 0.016081171110272408, 0.011549157090485096, -0.025807887315750122, -0.0441562756896019, 0.026716668158769608, 0.030400259420275688, -0.004141517914831638, -0.060014497488737106, -0.006478708237409592, 0.0074666645377874374, -0.04218260943889618, -0.007407058961689472, -0.02492997609078884, -0.04349360242486, 0.00265121809206903, -0.028995607048273087, 0.028180807828903198, 0.02504054270684719, 0.052780333906412125, 0.0238617155700922, 0.024740466848015785, 0.0010669957846403122, 0.040617935359478, -0.02786877006292343, 0.01845538057386875, 0.04041814059019089, 0.03460683673620224, 0.02188052237033844, 0.03214999660849571, -0.005094287917017937, -0.01682398095726967, 0.055496945977211, 0.021154720336198807, -0.029654985293745995, 0.09013305604457855, 0.018232740461826324, 0.012425461784005165, 0.06727096438407898, 0.0245961956679821, -0.04290204867720604, 0.054109837859869, 0.015241933986544609, -0.01541067473590374, 0.06639734655618668, -0.030587971210479736, 0.026199733838438988, 0.007864936254918575, 0.03205830231308937, 0.007945036515593529, -0.03627869114279747, 0.025472035631537437, 0.06255792081356049, 0.009226439520716667, 0.016193019226193428, 0.012743315659463406, 0.013877722434699535, 0.006256677210330963, 0.015607130713760853, -0.01648070476949215, -0.003677796106785536, -0.016520079225301743, 0.010034628212451935, 0.010874379426240921, 0.013627754524350166, -0.01673749089241028, -0.033218201249837875, 0.05483928322792053, 0.018699178472161293, 0.01726442389190197, -0.031196098774671555, 0.024520667269825935, -0.012233147397637367, -0.02617417834699154, 0.033168867230415344, -0.011828024871647358, 0.020124156028032303, -0.01529079768806696, 0.023910872638225555, 0.020596789196133614, 0.014734971337020397, 0.037352174520492554, -0.01316677313297987, 0.005060294177383184, -0.003118319669738412, -0.07305674999952316, -0.07108161598443985, 0.04720529913902283, -0.007049652747809887, -0.001415973179973662, -0.051480136811733246, 0.006831789389252663, 0.013453982770442963, 0.026992393657565117, -0.033804751932621, 0.0581318661570549, 0.0007053946610540152, 0.01593022048473358, 0.016722697764635086, -0.016307620331645012, -0.00418095150962472, 0.003315276699140668, -0.015493050217628479, -0.00012115461140638217, -0.09415553510189056, 0.01882128231227398, 0.0075114406645298, 0.03574308007955551, -0.019892720505595207, -0.006390338763594627, 0.013195089995861053, 0.016087252646684647, -0.024599844589829445, 0.00705510750412941, -0.04802064970135689, 0.07356929033994675, -0.00567278079688549, 0.04149719700217247, -0.006295482628047466, -0.036408159881830215, 0.00862723495811224, 0.01452364306896925, -0.004823579452931881, 0.05262691527605057, -0.019022008404135704, 0.023047739639878273, -0.02452475018799305, -0.003756931982934475, 0.011195071041584015, -0.021668221801519394, 0.0160817913711071, -0.008692000061273575, 0.016721902415156364, 0.028574641793966293, 0.019693007692694664, -0.02450691908597946, -0.03517433628439903, 0.023507213220000267, -0.046440768986940384, -0.04156295210123062, -0.044149111956357956, -0.02344960905611515, -0.003071380313485861, -0.06336650997400284, -0.001168607734143734, -0.030741296708583832, 0.03304757922887802, -0.015387092716991901, -0.020246271044015884, -0.022184453904628754, -0.0020108448807150126, 0.04105309396982193, -0.013030072674155235, -0.016505921259522438, 0.06251054257154465, 0.03995134308934212, -0.016464971005916595, 0.023390918970108032, -0.03518400341272354, -0.03849569335579872, -0.012265937402844429, -0.030907168984413147, 0.03509187698364258, 0.027736030519008636, -0.0002048180904239416, 0.03070962242782116, 0.019812876358628273, -0.015210719779133797, 0.041619643568992615, -0.04879840835928917, 0.05327724665403366, 0.09327574819326401, -0.016150519251823425, -0.00887922290712595, 0.003071908373385668, 0.011580724269151688, -0.025171808898448944, 0.027365852147340775, -0.04195357486605644, -0.03644593805074692, -0.015789920464158058, -0.009403001517057419, -0.02956012263894081, -0.03522628918290138, -0.022002659738063812, 0.06054547056555748, 0.005198312923312187, 0.05273746699094772, -0.007630234584212303, -0.0015960871241986752, -0.051805827766656876, 0.03557933494448662, -0.007294278126209974, -0.008337674662470818, 0.009730770252645016, 0.003303988603875041, -0.03757133334875107, 0.013921537436544895, 0.02551371231675148, -0.012750914320349693, 0.04120950773358345, 0.022358866408467293, -0.012491430155932903, -0.029450511559844017, -0.0031435510609298944, 0.053097981959581375, -0.037474535405635834, -0.04219115898013115, 0.03842572495341301, -0.01129766646772623, -0.009857824072241783, -0.04678776115179062, -0.01754681020975113, -0.0060575902462005615, 0.056465670466423035, -0.05896308645606041, 0.007530215661972761, 0.007483385037630796, -0.015823863446712494, 0.009328982792794704, -0.01571262814104557, -0.05708033964037895, -0.029746415093541145, -0.010462407022714615, 0.03794296085834503, 0.047126829624176025, 0.0251337718218565, -0.014992830343544483, -0.018562471494078636, -0.022856367751955986, 0.044895634055137634, -0.00848744623363018, -0.036828357726335526, -0.04180174320936203, 0.003338744631037116, 0.0005264157662168145, -0.03145778551697731, 0.01177046075463295, 0.020349416881799698, -0.006866786628961563, 0.05651155486702919, 0.02789980173110962, -0.03245881199836731, -0.006917063612490892, -0.00023152896028477699, 0.03685661405324936, -0.01851801574230194, -0.03813450410962105, 0.043051235377788544, 0.039680518209934235, 0.0021751243621110916, 0.03200766071677208, -0.010788657702505589, -0.04295182228088379, -0.029952416196465492, 0.0013434882275760174, -0.007653776090592146, 0.017288563773036003, 0.023619364947080612, -0.024722613394260406, -0.01736093871295452, 0.023632479831576347, -0.09571593254804611, -0.07152537256479263, 0.004420342389494181, -0.015689769759774208, 0.03967522829771042, 0.012806281447410583, 0.029921937733888626, 0.11194096505641937, 0.062156423926353455, -0.020403506234288216, -0.017875559628009796, -0.029629986733198166, -0.0381937213242054, -0.02266339771449566, 0.04041271284222603, 0.02975970134139061, -0.025459252297878265, 0.02108341082930565, -0.007499139290302992, 0.02584151178598404, 0.050170429050922394, -0.0160777997225523, 0.009410042315721512, -0.005160580854862928, -0.001629440812394023, 0.0071128495037555695, 0.044483575969934464, 0.047611840069293976, -0.01449210662394762, -0.020008869469165802, -0.008256529457867146, 0.017198385670781136, -0.0006678762729279697, -0.0858987495303154, 0.03317459672689438, -0.03426584601402283, 0.0113008888438344, -0.04300088807940483, 0.019242368638515472, 0.03213097155094147, -0.051542747765779495, 0.01335163228213787, -0.017468268051743507, 0.03310432657599449, -0.02484462969005108, 0.024017004296183586, 0.07037331163883209, 0.071861632168293, -0.008539002388715744, -0.04185016080737114, -0.038635481148958206, 0.00872224010527134, 0.004473007749766111, -0.013572153635323048, -0.007539986167103052, -0.008214053697884083, 0.08158932626247406, 0.024604635313153267, -0.001617919304408133, -0.048013605177402496, -0.022993268445134163, -0.08099189400672913, 0.0008897474035620689, -0.01122349500656128, 0.035929322242736816, 0.022284870967268944, 0.024948816746473312, 0.04294663295149803, -0.0061158547177910805, -0.0008543470175936818, 0.0004217975365463644, -0.05342718958854675, 0.0642964243888855, 0.017844464629888535, 0.00413627689704299, -0.005574021954089403, -0.0436469204723835, -0.0015218358021229506, -0.003863732097670436, 0.008165190927684307, -0.003212735755369067, 0.05238316208124161, 0.031032223254442215, 0.002247688826173544, 0.0038490856532007456, 0.0013734028907492757, 0.042548760771751404, 0.013000868260860443, 0.004962597507983446, -0.015273277647793293, -0.002982896054163575, 0.03938061743974686, 0.0009963226038962603, -0.03540877252817154, -0.05774426832795143, 0.02664197050035, 0.01003275066614151, 0.072716124355793, 0.0012284998083487153, 0.017900830134749413, -0.01199598703533411, 0.04814885929226875, 0.03260033577680588, 0.05076558142900467, 0.03453707695007324, -0.0014286793302744627, -0.03107982501387596, -0.05701448395848274, 0.009336870163679123, -0.00015372088819276541, -0.01797361858189106, 0.002377287717536092, 0.015969349071383476, 0.04979502409696579, 0.019662458449602127, -0.062005434185266495, -0.020116424188017845, 0.04018232226371765, 0.01771351508796215, -0.01669660583138466, -0.039042823016643524, -0.0030578812584280968, 0.00184944411739707, -0.005061733070760965, 0.049266111105680466, 0.02945493720471859, 0.003199622966349125, -0.00915459543466568, 0.034723859280347824, 0.03411685675382614, -0.060246847569942474, 0.020526500418782234, 0.007384675554931164, 0.03825421631336212, -0.02191612310707569, -0.03717741742730141, 0.030352842062711716, 0.015395442955195904, 0.028776410967111588, -0.009741995483636856, 0.01782987080514431, -0.038880616426467896, -0.012189004570245743, 0.035528361797332764, 0.05869610235095024, -0.05628388747572899, 0.011992672458291054, -0.048960793763399124, 0.010324270464479923, 0.023454802110791206, -0.043619174510240555, -0.01065159123390913, -0.02403048239648342, 0.03440151736140251, 0.004215802066028118, -0.030260365456342697, -0.030110441148281097, -0.003252703230828047, -0.0009191190474666655, -0.020007940009236336, -0.011536487378180027, -0.06054000183939934, -0.04691988229751587, 0.055451977998018265, 0.035244304686784744, 0.04883629083633423, -0.049148187041282654, -0.026512140408158302, 0.0440170057117939, 0.01291652675718069, 0.028146563097834587, -0.06633884459733963, -0.0234529972076416, -0.001128060044720769, -0.004695630632340908, 0.030285194516181946, 0.019968345761299133, -0.016220591962337494, 0.021141109988093376, -0.013958830386400223, -0.05652078986167908, -0.026971405372023582, -0.02364766038954258, 0.03815925866365433, 0.032249078154563904, 0.025107061490416527, 0.024470889940857887, -0.006980042904615402, 0.0008127380278892815, -0.02104688622057438, -0.023487841710448265, 0.013654600828886032, -0.00014491011097561568, -0.005368099547922611, -0.060363564640283585, -0.046896204352378845, 0.027493242174386978, 0.003509894711896777, -0.006579432170838118, 0.02690560184419155, -0.04984311759471893, -0.007476096041500568, -0.0011030827881768346, 0.028705015778541565, 0.0361299067735672, 0.03275466710329056, -0.003978924360126257, 0.007741787936538458, -0.011750057339668274, -0.01355667319148779, 0.0029670167714357376, -0.06826397776603699, -0.010248438455164433, -0.00180602609179914, -0.030859192833304405, -0.004223771393299103, -0.0618109367787838, -0.027395358309149742, 0.00010685515007935464, -0.03789897263050079, 0.04162150248885155, 0.037095941603183746, 0.08778729289770126, 0.03258562460541725, -0.0017541961278766394, -0.020317114889621735, 0.03059099242091179, 0.007680172566324472, 0.06355888396501541, -0.036944568157196045, 0.03221752867102623, -0.0002622797910589725, 0.012090610340237617, -0.03746001422405243, -0.04543349891901016, -0.0020908049773424864, 0.02973398193717003, -0.015063241124153137, -0.02166498452425003, 0.011255449615418911, 0.01454678364098072, -0.01964564062654972, -0.003192261094227433, 0.031172439455986023, 0.005270544905215502, -0.032857540994882584, -0.03470862656831741, 0.02159045822918415, 0.08441007882356644, -0.020672282204031944, 0.011863253079354763, 0.01867440901696682, -0.0216926671564579, -0.05674818530678749, -0.06521999835968018, -0.009214092046022415, -0.03130593150854111, -0.0357389859855175, -0.01832551136612892, 0.005642618052661419, 0.05494553968310356, -0.04310831427574158, -0.0009462158777751029, 0.028314804658293724, 0.022042974829673767, 0.006939738057553768, -0.029338419437408447, -0.034338366240262985, 0.03063862770795822, 0.0350470170378685, -0.025306036695837975, -0.005425774492323399, -0.01611144281923771, 0.011372165754437447, 0.003947971388697624, 0.005602567922323942, -0.015701476484537125, 0.048581670969724655, 0.04736575856804848, -0.028009269386529922, 0.020700596272945404, -0.040513817220926285, -0.02955477498471737, 0.011159125715494156, 0.023426495492458344, -0.0049631232395768166, 0.007063923869282007, 0.007998128421604633, -0.02369534969329834, -0.04445411264896393, -0.023687882348895073, 0.01089220680296421, 0.03400733694434166, -0.008480960503220558, 0.060171592980623245, 0.03590235486626625, 0.003442477434873581, -0.02804332971572876, -0.03041575290262699, -0.02899288386106491, 0.0037526192609220743, 0.0046314033679664135, 0.0419696681201458, -0.017282938584685326, 0.033063340932130814, 0.03887457773089409, -0.017428098246455193, 0.019749030470848083, 0.06345930695533752, 0.004412859212607145, 0.0021557598374783993, 0.029021624475717545, -0.0242255050688982, -0.03133459761738777, 0.036550916731357574, -0.07678884267807007, 0.058807436376810074, -0.06908892095088959, -0.03941071778535843, 0.010080721229314804, 0.018667617812752724, -0.050582125782966614, -0.016766291111707687, -0.001623976626433432, -0.036284469068050385, -0.04256062209606171, 0.01938827894628048, -0.022956248372793198, 0.01877504773437977, 0.01974724978208542, 0.03214050084352493, 0.0038087128195911646, 0.03788872808218002, -0.02908245660364628, -0.04436056688427925, 0.008499003015458584, -0.005771476775407791, -0.044221892952919006, 0.020754117518663406, -0.032058436423540115, 0.025324931368231773, 0.019299715757369995, -0.07775341719388962, 0.043185364454984665, 0.011795430444180965, 0.009198424406349659, 0.008771025575697422, 0.06637650728225708, 0.006165631581097841, 0.04040057212114334, -0.024198276922106743, -0.01503212470561266, 0.1348872184753418, 0.041238829493522644, 0.017224468290805817, -0.05993899703025818, -0.012400137260556221, -0.01788085140287876, -0.004631027113646269, 0.007135813590139151, 0.030199222266674042, 0.005065403413027525, 0.012801664881408215, 0.053657785058021545, 0.009567024186253548, -0.01506753172725439, 0.014657741412520409, 0.006604777183383703, -0.0299242977052927, -0.03165140002965927, 0.019767142832279205, -0.007976952940225601, 0.006172846537083387, -0.009672130458056927, -0.01877196878194809, 0.06686902791261673, -0.017651790753006935, -0.013075584545731544, -0.01487609650939703, -0.011957514099776745, 0.018360406160354614, -0.018556026741862297, -0.014695634134113789, 0.003526747925207019, 0.03946789726614952, 0.021122420206665993, 0.021073609590530396, -0.04533877223730087, 0.029840894043445587, -0.03989766910672188, 0.041196390986442566, 0.012738117016851902, -0.0113007090985775, -0.014770113863050938, 0.009916730225086212, 0.013669366016983986, -0.03623385727405548, -0.03617541864514351, -0.0403660349547863, 0.004941259510815144, -0.024454958736896515, -0.028084708377718925, -0.028214052319526672, 0.02034296840429306, -0.004463003482669592, -0.027904823422431946, 0.0027160884346812963, 0.025283344089984894, 0.035676077008247375, 0.0003119902976322919, -0.014303416945040226, -0.024719564244151115, 0.018840910866856575, 0.0012582740746438503, 0.02135339565575123, 0.04452225938439369, -0.0005563569138757885, -0.05296602100133896, -0.029255257919430733, 0.01568557694554329, 0.008893953636288643, -0.012854081578552723, -0.011075605638325214, -0.0059928297996521, -0.010101525112986565, 0.0210946686565876, -0.0021437378600239754, -0.03137132525444031, 0.07305692136287689, -0.009030943736433983, 0.004846664611250162, -0.02903786301612854, -0.013534218072891235, -0.013336011208593845, 0.002768662991002202, 0.011493324302136898, -0.0352516770362854, 0.012205918319523335, 0.012035496532917023, 0.06820093095302582, 0.006904992274940014, 0.00945708155632019, 0.049368903040885925, 0.06026305630803108, 0.012828979641199112, 0.01585387997329235, -0.017214829102158546, -0.006838209927082062, -0.037292808294296265, 0.01869223266839981, -0.03699035570025444, 0.07016962021589279, 0.0053158593364059925, 0.026072338223457336, -0.01428667176514864, -0.005591099616140127, -0.012893415987491608, 0.013962220400571823, 0.031800657510757446, -0.08644179999828339, -0.032373372465372086, 0.026961054652929306, -0.014238827861845493, -0.01778363436460495, -0.009791840799152851, -0.010928441770374775, -0.033719152212142944, 0.0044807386584579945, 0.010802687145769596, -0.0038447286933660507, 0.01978559046983719, -0.004796531982719898, 0.020032256841659546, 0.006834595929831266, 0.006251305341720581, -0.011430405080318451, 0.009356045164167881, -0.0018981837201863527, 0.03433407098054886, -0.04728076979517937, 0.031531985849142075, 0.03489380329847336, 0.029707329347729683, 0.01293622050434351, 0.006775377783924341, 0.014616819098591805, -0.018850049003958702, 0.005193938035517931, 0.006716721225529909, -0.0023317760787904263, -0.0239221453666687, 0.002966540399938822, 0.06770201772451401, -0.041084107011556625, -0.002470683539286256, 0.002717516850680113, -0.019405454397201538, 0.021627794951200485, 0.02436806820333004, -0.006915456615388393, 0.02737848460674286, 0.03258858621120453, -0.039571862667798996, -0.01458338089287281, -0.04227390140295029, -0.0007402323535643518, 0.028023656457662582, -0.004431577865034342, -0.00935086514800787, 0.010667174123227596, -0.0036060090642422438, 0.03209150955080986, 0.021366389468312263, -0.019024712964892387, 0.014940617606043816, -0.009006403386592865, -0.015970656648278236, -0.030373526737093925, 0.0018476751865819097, 0.004378442652523518, 0.011247234418988228, 0.03194746375083923, -0.023175768554210663, 0.009111236780881882, -0.051792629063129425, -0.0022458015009760857, -0.06873700767755508, -0.03085457719862461, 0.024578679352998734, -0.058708444237709045, 0.03985606133937836, -0.03529658168554306, -0.007670119404792786, 0.0059255072847008705, -0.04851669818162918, 0.006807693745940924, -0.032915107905864716, -0.007783901412039995, -0.07477819919586182, 0.03898971155285835, -0.025971774011850357, -0.0011155640240758657, 0.009392820298671722, 0.03456837311387062, 0.026804428547620773, 0.03610813990235329, 0.05179267004132271, 0.009619960561394691, 0.011007065884768963, 0.0335109606385231, 0.00758562283590436, -0.07488255947828293, 0.03970437869429588, -0.04203397408127785, -0.028319932520389557, 0.030085694044828415, -0.02390485256910324, 0.020127959549427032, 0.005850412882864475, 0.04389818012714386, -0.018348990008234978, 0.058318130671978, 0.05083680525422096, 0.02590871974825859, -0.0066878218203783035, -0.011225761845707893, 0.06494130939245224, 0.02027510479092598, 0.015490581281483173, -0.01765431836247444, 0.0468263179063797, -0.03126564621925354, -0.021985262632369995, 0.020119791850447655, 0.0010056884493678808, -0.05247517675161362, 0.028419408947229385, -0.02733617275953293, 0.009028335101902485, 0.007664746139198542, -0.012049735523760319, -0.0373832993209362, -0.0007532393210567534, 0.04649397358298302, 0.02396322786808014, -0.016548877581954002, 0.03138835355639458, -0.005835785996168852, -0.046483322978019714, 0.001397092710249126, 0.019801458343863487, -0.0002914265787694603, -0.02314073219895363, -0.013971611857414246, -0.01529635675251484, -0.011376981623470783, -0.026153983548283577, -0.00438233045861125, -0.0332690104842186, 0.015238288789987564, -0.027818210422992706, 0.033163778483867645, 0.015987155959010124, -0.00560076255351305, 0.0006832008366473019, -0.1240195780992508, 0.06979337334632874, -0.0027626219671219587, -0.01614420674741268, -0.025104686617851257, -0.011535786092281342, -0.05919434875249863, 0.005726849194616079, 0.053710855543613434, -0.012647967785596848, -0.026369193568825722, -0.018378226086497307, 0.008606044575572014, 0.015843501314520836, -0.05484195426106453, 0.0211357232183218, -0.028646795079112053, -0.02529498189687729, -0.03496386483311653, 0.02884049527347088, 0.022834166884422302, 0.002197151305153966, 0.010341963730752468, -0.012802095152437687, 0.015444895252585411, 0.03774825856089592, 0.01962653361260891, 0.030846990644931793, 0.007980161346495152, -0.02961071766912937, 0.037593740969896317, -0.0026623227167874575, 0.010940773412585258, 0.021984748542308807, -0.035737134516239166, -0.05343814566731453, -0.006082909647375345, -0.008607611060142517, 0.006302813999354839, -0.024254940450191498, 0.012675297446548939, -0.008675016462802887, -0.06168125942349434, 0.014723907224833965, 0.0412333644926548, -0.0237455815076828, 0.007773810066282749, 0.01528400368988514, -0.008044359274208546, 0.01711784489452839, 0.004700805991888046, -0.007838934659957886, -0.008397434838116169, 0.004946999717503786, -0.01826953887939453, -0.034257225692272186, -0.00540909031406045, -0.008866414427757263, -0.009935551322996616, 0.027454955503344536, -0.033837124705314636, 0.03160339966416359, -0.020553117617964745, 0.011264012195169926, -0.008540796115994453, -0.015142923220992088, 0.05414954200387001, 0.009237866848707199, 0.001820393605157733, -0.019753068685531616, -0.0114744259044528, 0.04973887652158737, -0.00858644675463438, -0.006707658991217613, -0.047819700092077255, 0.013093344867229462, -0.05324418842792511, 0.024547221139073372, 0.011788408271968365, -0.0045053912326693535, 0.012566574849188328, -0.005922175943851471, -0.009528840892016888, 0.02586783841252327, 0.03929466754198074, 0.005215377081185579, 0.012863914482295513, -0.00933640357106924, -0.03665298968553543, -0.014880205504596233, -0.032274212688207626, -0.01614234410226345, -0.024501105770468712, 0.0007517540361732244, 0.03775886446237564, 0.001602683449164033, 0.03608554229140282, -0.006846884731203318, 0.032782141119241714, 0.07163037359714508, -0.022721949964761734, -0.01960173062980175, -0.03592175990343094, -0.014703976921737194, 0.00192345236428082, -0.04003087431192398 ]
<p>I want to use VIF to check the multicollinearity between some ordinal variables and continuous variables. When I put one variable as dependent and the other as independent, the regression gives one VIF value, and when I exchange these two, then the VIF is different. And once the VIF value more than 3, and the other time it is less than 3. Then how I do make a decision to keep the variable or not, and which one should I keep? Ultimately I am going to use these variables in a logistic regression, how important it is to see multi-collinearity in logistic regression? Thanks, aruna</p>
36,454
[ -0.04142855107784271, 0.01333414763212204, -0.030149592086672783, 0.050923097878694534, 0.03863693028688431, 0.014597753062844276, -0.02276633121073246, -0.01528237760066986, 0.05512385070323944, -0.031742390245199203, 0.029408009722828865, 0.03051963448524475, 0.042979028075933456, -0.0023580114357173443, 0.044565774500370026, 0.010114875622093678, 0.023652657866477966, 0.015239305794239044, 0.020603472366929054, -0.006550696678459644, -0.018618905916810036, 0.0006724582053720951, 0.028796903789043427, 0.0017872320022433996, -0.007873354479670525, 0.07969465851783752, 0.018953006714582443, -0.009049734100699425, 0.031214265152812004, 0.019255194813013077, 0.006197826471179724, -0.027091531082987785, 0.004925892688333988, 0.050623565912246704, -0.019380804151296616, 0.03627863526344299, 0.007511702366173267, -0.00889786146581173, -0.007641004864126444, 0.023784112185239792, -0.04443651810288429, -0.039554402232170105, -0.01791209727525711, 0.04420297220349312, -0.017048368230462074, -0.016491910442709923, 0.021677937358617783, -0.0146958502009511, 0.037135686725378036, -0.029035696759819984, 0.07811448723077774, -0.004850154276937246, 0.029448607936501503, 0.03310106694698334, 0.015506411902606487, 0.005951933097094297, 0.019550275057554245, 0.047814346849918365, 0.013664268888533115, -0.017421232536435127, -0.018983939662575722, -0.013192687183618546, -0.0114073371514678, 0.03846340253949165, -0.00811957661062479, 0.016343509778380394, -0.010917490348219872, 0.0014028699370101094, 0.031573258340358734, -0.03940930217504501, 0.008525350131094456, 0.03302406519651413, 0.05469370633363724, -0.03146899864077568, -0.00042655918514356017, -0.010240340605378151, -0.0073865302838385105, 0.023673275485634804, 0.02626439929008484, 0.03128783032298088, 0.016675734892487526, 0.007138590328395367, 0.024014323949813843, 0.020700756460428238, 0.0294822845607996, -0.008037304505705833, 0.030396975576877594, -0.03444485738873482, 0.047494370490312576, 0.05113429203629494, -0.026459379121661186, -0.014123345725238323, 0.046375494450330734, 0.05101364105939865, -0.04278574511408806, 0.0436665304005146, -0.03498421981930733, 0.038875874131917953, 0.019896214827895164, 0.010100167244672775, -0.03461840748786926, -0.032799817621707916, 0.020974809303879738, 0.04862833768129349, -0.01796353980898857, 0.020549941807985306, -0.03393784165382385, -0.01228627935051918, -0.005490551702678204, -0.043360624462366104, 0.01662534847855568, 0.0006159247132018209, -0.0068718078546226025, 0.008628906682133675, 0.031072909012436867, 0.0010695351520553231, 0.0008686356013640761, -0.010450165718793869, 0.0698937252163887, 0.07590091228485107, 0.022265499457716942, -0.017534486949443817, 0.050954680889844894, -0.005906146485358477, -0.030012566596269608, 0.010606068186461926, 0.019428066909313202, 0.010774885304272175, -0.0424935407936573, 0.06742465496063232, 0.004906649701297283, -0.017677364870905876, 0.0012684001121670008, 0.010880936868488789, -0.03744663670659065, 0.01606467366218567, -0.07398360967636108, -0.03699532523751259, 0.049700718373060226, -0.03373154252767563, 0.006123595405369997, -0.0326584056019783, 0.009621181525290012, 0.0267780888825655, 0.013152939267456532, -0.0019329722272232175, 0.026017026975750923, -0.0061125075444579124, -0.0003468120994511992, -0.018222345039248466, -0.022793767973780632, -0.034889768809080124, -0.02721150405704975, -0.07542327791452408, -0.011912836693227291, -0.07259214669466019, 0.02175058424472809, -0.004386022221297026, 0.03487129509449005, -0.01048246119171381, 0.05506904795765877, 0.02285955846309662, -0.05625898391008377, -0.003007851541042328, -0.026678230613470078, -0.009463767521083355, 0.0658256933093071, -0.04448896273970604, 0.027221661061048508, 0.025868769735097885, 0.02103768289089203, -0.0007337778806686401, 0.0005438167136162519, 0.05873195827007294, 0.018991313874721527, -0.005826165433973074, 0.0004409377870615572, -0.05249159410595894, 0.025297824293375015, 0.0066215782426297665, -0.01801314577460289, -0.019795183092355728, -0.016531215980648994, -0.01640276424586773, 0.008834035135805607, 0.02770836465060711, -0.00901385024189949, -0.009590663947165012, 0.04390040040016174, -0.04332106187939644, -0.03157326951622963, -0.009017798118293285, -0.002109931083396077, 0.01864137314260006, -0.05541167035698891, 0.05070146918296814, 0.027161452919244766, 0.04635367542505264, 0.0019971744623035192, 0.006028337869793177, -0.020021658390760422, 0.0065434700809419155, 0.005246641114354134, -0.0420021153986454, 0.046646106988191605, -0.0003831345238722861, 0.037389125674963, -0.006346148904412985, 0.031148307025432587, -0.02739480696618557, -0.0362347736954689, 0.013602877035737038, -0.008359073661267757, -0.015675406903028488, -0.020732471719384193, -0.03494354337453842, 0.03249184414744377, 0.0019033349817618728, -0.04061276465654373, 0.02695448510348797, -0.05552856996655464, 0.08995538204908371, 0.041154615581035614, -0.0009970248211175203, -0.008495092391967773, 0.006049086339771748, -0.01606491021811962, 0.006777123082429171, -0.03635188937187195, -0.024471234530210495, -0.04117191582918167, -0.04285386577248573, 0.001280080759897828, 0.044020239263772964, -0.006588550750166178, 0.02569676749408245, 0.07066766917705536, 0.01892019435763359, 0.03629346564412117, 0.04101221263408661, 0.005998014006763697, -0.017943158745765686, -0.003841040190309286, 0.01422316487878561, 0.015241073444485664, 0.03087831847369671, -0.003393597900867462, 0.018640805035829544, 0.028458641842007637, -0.03449302911758423, -0.025668378919363022, 0.028577854856848717, -0.004180993884801865, -0.002078380435705185, -0.01965976506471634, 0.00003873170498991385, 0.050960149616003036, -0.03866257146000862, 0.02284691110253334, 0.06403081119060516, 0.011692930944263935, -0.010769804008305073, 0.017203129827976227, 0.0014947903109714389, 0.02865302935242653, 0.07009751349687576, -0.10739248245954514, 0.01024626474827528, -0.003320552408695221, -0.03444673866033554, 0.02122662402689457, -0.010530845262110233, 0.005033910274505615, -0.0404716394841671, -0.0004646253364626318, 0.007258518133312464, -0.02681744284927845, 0.00676574744284153, 0.008004381321370602, -0.03200836479663849, -0.007991768419742584, -0.05360538139939308, 0.008604122325778008, -0.024965032935142517, -0.02477082423865795, -0.023571794852614403, 0.013095162808895111, -0.0007682088180445135, 0.012589046731591225, -0.016131794080138206, 0.014187335968017578, 0.02817702665925026, 0.014233470894396305, -0.09662871807813644, -0.017975980415940285, -0.010323958471417427, 0.008372711017727852, 0.008087158203125, -0.02212395705282688, 0.019747354090213776, 0.0014542199205607176, -0.02927418239414692, 0.003637495683506131, -0.07281560450792313, -0.033107414841651917, -0.02285032719373703, 0.009355966001749039, 0.015643062070012093, -0.0001236048265127465, 0.013013181276619434, 0.03716889023780823, -0.03457226976752281, -0.02715279348194599, -0.09046763926744461, -0.06542961299419403, -0.0007310152868740261, 0.01978449709713459, 0.0030718129128217697, -0.015552043914794922, -0.054310329258441925, 0.06703460961580276, 0.023189373314380646, -0.03218325972557068, -0.03345107287168503, -0.02100498415529728, -0.049503058195114136, -0.019848449155688286, 0.014432968571782112, -0.0032585093285888433, 0.038465715944767, 0.01705671101808548, -0.0015752667095512152, 0.035248685628175735, 0.05362604558467865, -0.0312979631125927, 0.017906272783875465, 0.03492744266986847, 0.025241460651159286, -0.008081522770226002, 0.015409919433295727, 0.020891409367322922, -0.0319659560918808, -0.003295570844784379, 0.01514931209385395, -0.004037132486701012, -0.014401662163436413, -0.017597543075680733, 0.011818728409707546, 0.013776123523712158, 0.016748791560530663, -0.013218161650002003, 0.004735568538308144, 0.04655749723315239, 0.008959946222603321, 0.00003555834700819105, 0.007449655793607235, 0.06915941834449768, -0.0511479526758194, 0.018863776698708534, 0.04582646116614342, 0.031457770615816116, 0.0042932541109621525, -0.002930892864242196, -0.022656677290797234, -0.02077425643801689, 0.021312961354851723, -0.05664387717843056, -0.032886967062950134, 0.04509181156754494, 0.01574346423149109, 0.0008145581232383847, -0.01804870180785656, -0.05145152658224106, 0.02943223901093006, -0.023795029148459435, 0.0033376782666891813, 0.020086785778403282, 0.02091357111930847, 0.039877861738204956, 0.010484796948730946, 0.03049926459789276, 0.00396859971806407, 0.000028951770218554884, 0.017198331654071808, -0.044672466814517975, 0.03635084256529808, 0.017327701672911644, 0.009365370497107506, -0.005579317919909954, -0.006800970062613487, 0.034647371619939804, -0.023271499201655388, 0.018546968698501587, 0.015561788342893124, 0.018316779285669327, 0.014501094818115234, 0.006825827993452549, -0.0273762084543705, -0.0077879950404167175, -0.014194178394973278, 0.024305639788508415, 0.013417940586805344, -0.019107047468423843, 0.04335297271609306, 0.052429769188165665, -0.04998350143432617, -0.03491916507482529, -0.016650903970003128, -0.02512451633810997, 0.029349522665143013, 0.06529366225004196, -0.0056081414222717285, 0.004747746977955103, -0.038006290793418884, 0.025769831612706184, -0.014226126484572887, 0.05323401466012001, 0.039063192903995514, -0.01690104603767395, -0.02633628435432911, -0.03475677967071533, -0.027704128995537758, -0.010102760046720505, 0.015434445813298225, 0.03585808724164963, -0.014544305391609669, 0.06122709438204765, 0.01502274814993143, -0.06624598056077957, 0.012459136545658112, 0.07657711207866669, 0.024004552513360977, -0.029138045385479927, -0.015573735348880291, 0.013199368491768837, 0.014452223666012287, -0.005758543498814106, 0.027958111837506294, 0.03774172440171242, -0.029911119490861893, -0.027935216203331947, 0.03673800081014633, -0.014215407893061638, 0.011603040620684624, 0.004888860043138266, 0.040742237120866776, 0.031620364636182785, 0.006563336588442326, -0.09174840152263641, -0.010086014866828918, 0.04436950758099556, 0.023223767057061195, 0.041610170155763626, 0.045059870928525925, -0.06346999853849411, -0.023700177669525146, 0.03945308178663254, 0.03411710262298584, -0.05358225107192993, -0.022895697504281998, -0.04210580140352249, -0.0022803538013249636, 0.05843551084399223, -0.043763741850852966, 0.035734809935092926, -0.0044804406352341175, 0.038290996104478836, 0.005134020932018757, -0.04980755224823952, -0.08266854286193848, 0.009825855493545532, -0.023370230570435524, 0.015137802809476852, -0.032516855746507645, 0.005329500418156385, -0.020080599933862686, 0.038824230432510376, 0.018064649775624275, 0.07281006872653961, -0.0072609493508934975, 0.0035670744255185127, 0.023520229384303093, 0.007323855999857187, -0.006337176542729139, -0.03648323938250542, 0.0355181023478508, -0.012125701643526554, 0.01197902113199234, 0.07239734381437302, -0.00007103096868377179, -0.07078252732753754, -0.04001493379473686, 0.031407929956912994, -0.020465388894081116, 0.038876861333847046, -0.020079607143998146, 0.06706412136554718, -0.025621885433793068, -0.03674820810556412, 0.034777432680130005, 0.04959128797054291, 0.011490292847156525, -0.01675722561776638, -0.03990105167031288, 0.060634031891822815, -0.027256425470113754, -0.018672538921236992, -0.032715726643800735, -0.026742439717054367, -0.05129854381084442, 0.042989812791347504, 0.009075609035789967, 0.03263694420456886, -0.005433835554867983, 0.0034461107570677996, 0.0031813730020076036, 0.027627913281321526, -0.009672196581959724, -0.02155301719903946, -0.0009223023080267012, -0.002518689027056098, -0.03345758840441704, -0.030744213610887527, 0.015235794708132744, -0.02916555479168892, -0.006028260104358196, 0.02677050232887268, -0.016124973073601723, -0.03539963439106941, -0.029940519481897354, -0.015999911352992058, -0.026759633794426918, -0.020272865891456604, -0.001204972737468779, 0.024502471089363098, 0.020766668021678925, -0.002990960143506527, -0.046904563903808594, 0.0177426990121603, 0.019919229671359062, -0.017668738961219788, 0.053270939737558365, -0.039966780692338943, 0.03519377112388611, -0.03432760760188103, -0.010201908648014069, -0.08867958933115005, -0.06929118186235428, 0.026981960982084274, -0.00530831515789032, -0.022752011194825172, -0.03977027162909508, 0.017244646325707436, -0.0015452282968908548, 0.006302939262241125, -0.0010456173913553357, 0.03689664602279663, 0.006103355437517166, 0.007081984542310238, -0.02839183807373047, 0.02503468468785286, 0.05946506932377815, -0.02836836501955986, 0.012933011166751385, -0.024421697482466698, -0.018509017303586006, 0.004104101099073887, -0.00524642039090395, 0.009509957395493984, -0.025950966402888298, -0.016408313065767288, -0.029202155768871307, -0.022819804027676582, 0.02059505321085453, -0.018132466822862625, -0.026391208171844482, -0.03947696462273598, -0.02270755171775818, 0.01709275133907795, -0.014006177894771099, -0.004498262889683247, -0.000039071521314326674, 0.009258460253477097, -0.018830204382538795, 0.010919461958110332, -0.019713977351784706, -0.011534706689417362, 0.02030036598443985, -0.016453711315989494, -0.05376068130135536, 0.021332766860723495, 0.05725467950105667, 0.004725340753793716, 0.02823561616241932, -0.013057193718850613, 0.007487517315894365, 0.027947304770350456, -0.0304622370749712, -0.011821383610367775, -0.005828334484249353, 0.03449453413486481, -0.053795695304870605, -0.03374877944588661, -0.04772751405835152, 0.007160342298448086, 0.03949219360947609, -0.02894623577594757, 0.06072566658258438, 0.06917524337768555, -0.019169993698596954, 0.018993066623806953, -0.03533133864402771, -0.0021711932495236397, -0.011681415140628815, -0.005031160544604063, 0.010793839581310749, -0.010121849365532398, 0.03260023519396782, 0.037828441709280014, 0.015797890722751617, -0.001608481747098267, 0.02354596182703972, 0.011108970269560814, 0.023881563916802406, 0.04742534086108208, -0.01700752228498459, -0.027515346184372902, 0.01148261409252882, 0.0064884633757174015, 0.01018569152802229, 0.002013360382989049, -0.013952348381280899, 0.05086002126336098, 0.06738828867673874, 0.008824787102639675, -0.06932450085878372, -0.04971453174948692, -0.04250507429242134, 0.004708272870630026, 0.018250124529004097, -0.013521789573132992, 0.04928620904684067, 0.014165765605866909, 0.025190552696585655, -0.01906285621225834, 0.00004451843778952025, -0.05887993797659874, -0.08962614834308624, 0.008906805887818336, -0.010099838487803936, 0.006720567122101784, 0.020975518971681595, -0.01425754465162754, -0.06204867735505104, 0.02221125364303589, 0.010309139266610146, -0.023024188354611397, -0.009889447130262852, 0.03641585260629654, 0.010955878533422947, 0.08117903023958206, 0.008124787360429764, 0.016103051602840424, 0.0038610687479376793, 0.028715534135699272, 0.12394619733095169, 0.07390335947275162, 0.028418391942977905, -0.07146409898996353, 0.04745675250887871, 0.01097369845956564, -0.006504904944449663, -0.027679327875375748, -0.010564835742115974, -0.0037047644145786762, -0.0094536691904068, 0.05970935896039009, 0.0315246619284153, 0.026585184037685394, -0.009134124033153057, 0.07259324193000793, -0.02516215294599533, 0.005140199325978756, -0.0001876384485512972, 0.03648098558187485, 0.012657595798373222, -0.029206564649939537, -0.058822907507419586, 0.028643429279327393, 0.010441317223012447, -0.02253609709441662, -0.002324543194845319, 0.007007949985563755, 0.05377829819917679, -0.007480117492377758, 0.02802685834467411, 0.0029869747813791037, 0.057320114225149155, 0.024941425770521164, -0.027150550857186317, 0.0029104866553097963, 0.010709568858146667, -0.03584417328238487, 0.007320054341107607, -0.005660988390445709, 0.0033990649972110987, -0.001276372349821031, 0.010469204746186733, -0.025713909417390823, -0.04105344042181969, -0.039899710565805435, -0.04883676767349243, 0.03702325373888016, 0.020317750051617622, -0.029483167454600334, -0.05988854169845581, 0.02385246939957142, 0.007006089203059673, -0.044967882335186005, -0.021049031987786293, 0.0057119945995509624, -0.010407326743006706, -0.04575009644031525, -0.011118573136627674, -0.03314676135778427, 0.014163212850689888, -0.002161061391234398, 0.0287287887185812, 0.028375359252095222, -0.04525010287761688, -0.011573133058845997, -0.038223013281822205, 0.05035156384110451, -0.009194016456604004, -0.0038833559956401587, 0.01734892465174198, -0.0023045784328132868, -0.012252389453351498, -0.008741599507629871, -0.020690793171525, 0.00878983549773693, 0.023568179458379745, -0.045785658061504364, -0.02210448496043682, -0.04999358579516411, -0.035639263689517975, 0.004608733579516411, -0.025806935504078865, -0.02529042214155197, -0.035395387560129166, 0.021987682208418846, 0.013774503022432327, 0.007956024259328842, 0.048781897872686386, 0.047760237008333206, -0.021114427596330643, 0.030323492363095284, 0.0027708960697054863, -0.04908120632171631, 0.01326174009591341, -0.0072918906807899475, -0.03879094868898392, -0.004697006661444902, -0.06185770034790039, 0.06605089455842972, 0.03863987699151039, 0.02259230986237526, 0.0022563820239156485, 0.02645544521510601, -0.010761250741779804, 0.04265880957245827, 0.022050315514206886, -0.044646818190813065, 0.029779093340039253, 0.013566652312874794, -0.002219107002019882, 0.01714257150888443, -0.02006940357387066, -0.022297870367765427, -0.06194563955068588, -0.014035115949809551, -0.012717673555016518, -0.03586127236485481, -0.02896883338689804, -0.010021224617958069, 0.0663415864109993, -0.03451380506157875, -0.04189728572964668, -0.025769928470253944, 0.02279992215335369, 0.011765426024794579, 0.0008177051204256713, 0.008576751686632633, 0.015058024786412716, -0.0002696882002055645, 0.003752585966140032, 0.020553436130285263, -0.010329531505703926, 0.016649125143885612, -0.05840420722961426, 0.0036409476306289434, 0.0077579147182404995, 0.05971922352910042, -0.025235045701265335, -0.032336264848709106, 0.023099787533283234, 0.007237812504172325, -0.01867666281759739, 0.023704005405306816, 0.005145949777215719, 0.020617013797163963, 0.026712115854024887, 0.024897776544094086, -0.03790286183357239, 0.0397915355861187, 0.005819087382405996, -0.0002245907235192135, -0.016530275344848633, -0.004359947517514229, -0.01699010469019413, -0.016878535971045494, -0.038560569286346436, 0.002827051095664501, -0.012531592510640621, 0.012652364559471607, 0.028884805738925934, 0.01903671957552433, -0.008220060728490353, 0.008488519117236137, 0.01638631708920002, 0.01357360277324915, 0.02096491865813732, -0.029990043491125107, 0.05081579089164734, 0.07107636332511902, -0.0021529048681259155, 0.03044820949435234, 0.027603620663285255, 0.03950994834303856, -0.09895186871290207, -0.03325491398572922, 0.0012594782747328281, 0.02132634073495865, 0.037441812455654144, -0.036250319331884384, 0.013562251813709736, 0.02846767008304596, -0.020252689719200134, 0.0018683919915929437, 0.005282850470393896, -0.015165865421295166, -0.04921424388885498, -0.013473127968609333, -0.0008074255893006921, -0.003078906098380685, 0.01676643081009388, -0.008235079236328602, 0.038720205426216125, 0.03830846771597862, -0.02494056336581707, -0.06704138219356537, -0.027415147051215172, 0.013171453028917313, 0.0030536805279552937, -0.08151333034038544, 0.05142817273736, -0.027940277010202408, -0.032634884119033813, 0.0363578237593174, -0.02875908464193344, 0.010218307375907898, 0.038349490612745285, 0.03429413586854935, 0.012853763066232204, 0.047131363302469254, 0.029188277199864388, -0.02545124664902687, -0.016312675550580025, -0.02670472301542759, 0.0202257689088583, 0.007813836447894573, -0.013836161233484745, 0.013349388726055622, 0.03635292500257492, -0.011901507154107094, -0.03844751790165901, 0.0012477792333811522, -0.021046360954642296, -0.025452570989727974, -0.047696277499198914, -0.013306176289916039, 0.0141712361946702, -0.0048117549158632755, 0.013278045691549778, -0.05555710196495056, -0.01901213265955448, 0.045628130435943604, 0.032039906829595566, 0.0008612434030510485, -0.043320152908563614, -0.03046536073088646, -0.0340324304997921, 0.013165083713829517, -0.019442304968833923, 0.009878139942884445, -0.04835693538188934, 0.01693081483244896, -0.011991310864686966, -0.046372078359127045, -0.04139402136206627, 0.009636571630835533, -0.012756875716149807, 0.06364188343286514, -0.03017108142375946, 0.0141239482909441, -0.004201959818601608, -0.032625727355480194, 0.03512975946068764, -0.08435320109128952, 0.05761495605111122, 0.020185664296150208, -0.06793791055679321, -0.02568609081208706, -0.002786426106467843, -0.04545029252767563, -0.0026033413596451283, 0.04971969872713089, -0.00019836619321722537, 0.004763276316225529, -0.01441764086484909, 0.02703043632209301, -0.017255697399377823, -0.011459250003099442, -0.007105753291398287, -0.014851684682071209, 0.007409732788801193, -0.017195358872413635, -0.007776142098009586, 0.01429765485227108, -0.00111696298699826, -0.006548629142343998, -0.013593259267508984, 0.00986009556800127, -0.013322967104613781, 0.004216816741973162, -0.00665569631382823, -0.0037914710119366646, -0.003518857527524233, 0.049221910536289215, -0.01099577359855175, 0.019517963752150536, 0.005196445621550083, 0.00892932340502739, -0.05510208383202553, 0.010038512758910656, -0.010807744227349758, -0.017238441854715347, 0.016609452664852142, 0.02704821713268757, 0.01995210535824299, -0.05532945692539215, 0.0021256140898913145, 0.0349946990609169, -0.03458056598901749, -0.0014300637412816286, 0.026775704696774483, 0.03221580386161804, 0.03216055780649185, -0.018483752384781837, 0.016486147418618202, 0.013524613343179226, -0.05349801853299141, 0.018972259014844894, -0.017391176894307137, 0.008739952929317951, 0.030441254377365112, 0.012784728780388832, 0.004266640637069941, -0.02278003841638565, 0.050354551523923874, 0.0005395752377808094, 0.04496762901544571, 0.015828192234039307, -0.007946540601551533, -0.00195903773419559, 0.017773283645510674, 0.03504881635308266, -0.006822347175329924, 0.015157966874539852, 0.03663644567131996, -0.040659479796886444, -0.015341680496931076, -0.03151780366897583, 0.0005825637490488589, -0.04676193743944168, -0.0120036406442523, 0.014620188623666763, 0.019186601042747498, -0.00772334448993206, 0.03272995352745056, 0.01149944681674242, 0.008084102533757687, 0.02829579822719097, -0.011477606371045113, 0.030601266771554947, -0.02993789128959179, -0.008359207771718502, 0.035217635333538055, -0.00999975111335516, -0.04836101084947586, -0.031454991549253464, 0.01460293773561716, 0.021111194044351578, 0.02347423881292343, -0.03445865213871002, -0.02709559164941311, 0.00981379859149456, 0.03840744122862816, -0.04521465301513672, -0.03200618550181389, -0.04720115661621094, 0.011936102993786335, 0.00797029584646225, 0.0012965918285772204 ]
<p>G. Monette and J. Fox provide in <a href="http://www.r-project.org/conferences/useR-2009/slides/Monette+Fox.pdf" rel="nofollow">these slides</a> a framework for the Type II Analysis of Variance/Deviance tests in terms of <em>conditional hypothesis</em>. My questions are:</p> <ul> <li><p>In this frequentist approach, the "conditional hypothesis" $L_1\beta=0 \mid L_2\beta=0$ is only symbolic (isn't it?). Is there a Bayesian analogue to this approach such as inference on $L_1 \beta$ under the posterior distribution of $\beta$ taken conditionally to $L_2 \beta =0$ ?</p></li> <li><p>Monette &amp; Fox rigorously define the conditional hypothesis as a classical hypothesis $L_{1\mid 2}\beta =0$ for a certain matrix $L_{1\mid 2}$ but this matrix depends on the estimated asymptotic covariance matrix of the parameters $\beta$. That sounds strange. Does it actually depends on the true asymptotic covariance matrix and then $L_{1\mid 2}$ is only an estimate of a theoretical matrix ? Even for the true asymptotic covariance that sounds strange because it still depends on the choice of the estimating method.</p></li> </ul> <p>In fact I have never seen the notion of conditional hypothesis before, is it presented in some textbooks ?</p> <h2>Update1</h2> <p>Still sick today but here are some thoughts. Consider a classical linear model $y = X\beta+\sigma\epsilon$ and the Jeffreys prior. Then the posterior distribution of $(\beta \mid \sigma)$ is ${\cal N}(\hat\beta, V)$ where $V$ is the asymptotic covariance matrix of the least-squares estimator $\hat\beta$, or (I do not remember), $V$ is this matrix up to a factor close to $1$. Then it is easy to see that $(L_1 \beta \mid L_2\beta=0)$ has the distribution of $L_{1 \mid 2} \beta$ under the conditional posterior distribution $(\beta \mid \sigma)$, where $L_{1 \mid 2}$ is a $V$-orthogonal complement as defined in Monette &amp; Fox's slides. And the Wald statistic $Z_{1|2}$ should be related to the norm of $L_{1 \mid 2} \beta$. </p> <p>For more general models the approach should asymptotically coincide with the Bayesian approach when $\hat\beta$ is taken to be the maximum-likelihood estimate.</p> <p>Too sick to continue...</p> <h2>Update2</h2> <p>I really wonder about whether this an old or a recent approach. As shown in <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/a/53041/8402">my answer to myself here</a>, this is not the way used by SAS. But the "old" <code>anova()</code> R function uses this approach. Indeed, for a generalized least-squares model such as </p> <pre><code>glsfit &lt;- gls(value ~ group*variable, data=ldat, correlation=corSymm(form= ~ 1 | id), weights=varIdent(form = ~1 | variable)) </code></pre> <p>the type II hypothesis Wald F-test statistic of the <code>variable</code> factor is provided by:</p> <pre><code>&gt; anova(glsfit) Denom. DF: 45 numDF F-value p-value (Intercept) 1 1401.9971 &lt;.0001 group 4 2.3793 0.0658 variable 2 79.5687 &lt;.0001 group:variable 8 1.4759 0.1929 </code></pre> <p>(and for the <code>group</code> factor one has to exchange the order of the factors:</p> <pre><code>glsfit.reverse &lt;- update(glsfit, model = value ~ variable*group) anova(glsfit.reverse) </code></pre> <p>) </p> <p>Or is it a new theoretical justification of an old approach ?..</p>
6,873
[ -0.004718742333352566, -0.007443408016115427, 0.03842535242438316, -0.020140888169407845, 0.06418701261281967, 0.027331771329045296, -0.0153685063123703, -0.01676294021308422, 0.030437324196100235, -0.05427618697285652, 0.042480308562517166, 0.021151475608348846, 0.07102564722299576, 0.0068637290969491005, 0.04025944694876671, 0.023444868624210358, -0.00754573056474328, -0.005923681426793337, -0.04228116199374199, 0.013694732449948788, 0.013324685394763947, 0.022349145263433456, 0.0032838352490216494, -0.005202688276767731, -0.014898264780640602, 0.02268252894282341, 0.0002106436004396528, -0.0427253432571888, -0.01628924161195755, 0.06279785186052322, -0.043692611157894135, -0.013796825893223286, 0.02947291173040867, -0.022613955661654472, 0.0017160385614261031, 0.008937100879848003, 0.042412497103214264, -0.038444884121418, 0.025785287842154503, 0.05831991881132126, -0.03618223965167999, -0.021893439814448357, -0.025170864537358284, 0.02928699366748333, -0.030104443430900574, 0.017780447378754616, -0.0016418203013017774, -0.0224891509860754, 0.012476385571062565, -0.0390525683760643, 0.07019289582967758, -0.016415288671851158, -0.0025239926762878895, 0.0328761525452137, -0.018512751907110214, -0.015735385939478874, 0.04941365495324135, 0.06046374514698982, 0.017298875376582146, -0.06236066669225693, -0.04344548285007477, -0.03422936797142029, -0.0030311690643429756, -0.022852560505270958, -0.03494277223944664, -0.020004162564873695, 0.015743907541036606, -0.015360847115516663, 0.021022729575634003, -0.007336456794291735, -0.010329149663448334, -0.011101696640253067, 0.0026187975890934467, 0.027314238250255585, 0.032034289091825485, 0.003868662053719163, -0.012678739614784718, 0.006151361390948296, 0.030015787109732628, -0.012779678218066692, 0.021546384319663048, 0.02811085619032383, -0.007434448227286339, 0.06181146949529648, 0.018300162628293037, -0.0016912634018808603, 0.07031062990427017, -0.031080028042197227, 0.022625863552093506, 0.01441066525876522, -0.07031314820051193, -0.028972500935196877, 0.01151806116104126, -0.02743971347808838, -0.03808804228901863, 0.05694181099534035, -0.002241512993350625, 0.025846417993307114, -0.008444318547844887, -0.016927912831306458, -0.026538118720054626, -0.005215079057961702, 0.00528468145057559, 0.06763540208339691, -0.008787724189460278, -0.040666550397872925, 0.028743844479322433, 0.032572392374277115, -0.054888464510440826, -0.053668782114982605, -0.04080463573336601, 0.08245806396007538, 0.003745076945051551, 0.031342387199401855, 0.006067193578928709, -0.008757871575653553, 0.010815490037202835, -0.007892881520092487, 0.06578989326953888, 0.08365697413682938, 0.04162081331014633, -0.01154059823602438, 0.00027404387947171926, -0.017777126282453537, -0.020701110363006592, 0.024580981582403183, 0.01834210939705372, -0.029877688735723495, -0.026705587282776833, 0.04318327456712723, 0.00010766067134682089, -0.04813545197248459, 0.012445776723325253, 0.028963182121515274, 0.0005715220468118787, -0.008474312722682953, -0.08316455036401749, -0.013339841738343239, 0.04076601564884186, 0.01613616943359375, -0.010679811239242554, -0.07033730298280716, -0.024821190163493156, 0.022771578282117844, 0.044804833829402924, -0.023828668519854546, 0.0521477535367012, 0.055063486099243164, 0.0423826202750206, 0.000731612672097981, -0.05298060551285744, -0.0437026172876358, -0.046891603618860245, -0.006422634236514568, -0.039159685373306274, -0.09077423810958862, -0.010810798034071922, 0.029646506533026695, 0.0061495546251535416, 0.00114164047408849, 0.049773309379816055, 0.004713963717222214, -0.041113827377557755, 0.0057787601836025715, 0.010200525633990765, -0.024424847215414047, 0.02814110554754734, -0.002473281929269433, 0.04613975062966347, 0.014496003277599812, -0.0068990085273981094, 0.022746263071894646, -0.02376149408519268, 0.08330930769443512, 0.042611341923475266, -0.05438889190554619, -0.004747023805975914, -0.022534551098942757, 0.014725004322826862, 0.0011206584749743342, -0.04430853947997093, 0.02354835718870163, -0.01390591636300087, -0.03546741232275963, 0.01265483908355236, 0.06911805272102356, 0.02919497899711132, -0.013989799655973911, 0.03234917297959328, -0.024693559855222702, -0.025779319927096367, -0.07509525120258331, -0.03226416930556297, -0.007369566708803177, -0.005949349608272314, 0.031714897602796555, 0.0068282983265817165, -0.0020681070163846016, -0.0006854995735920966, 0.014492473565042019, -0.03429322689771652, 0.004076702985912561, 0.020894473418593407, -0.05203470587730408, 0.02010849304497242, 0.02028661221265793, 0.04863766208291054, 0.003842317732051015, 0.03632478043437004, -0.04364959895610809, -0.06402534991502762, 0.022470206022262573, -0.023266009986400604, 0.015403344295918941, 0.007925285957753658, 0.002799631329253316, 0.011198973283171654, -0.0172837246209383, -0.04395988583564758, 0.03565579280257225, -0.04462793096899986, 0.017280733212828636, 0.04549993574619293, 0.0032318662852048874, 0.0027073766104876995, 0.008388534188270569, 0.015342101454734802, 0.01947253756225109, -0.030242906883358955, 0.011529131792485714, -0.024085726588964462, 0.0009682282689027488, 0.06771838665008545, 0.014553919434547424, 0.0020028939470648766, 0.031128279864788055, 0.014587543904781342, 0.03930079564452171, -0.015192989259958267, 0.04377085343003273, -0.0051295277662575245, -0.018964257091283798, -0.010752805508673191, -0.014775731600821018, -0.0016394708072766662, 0.007170006167143583, 0.03149518370628357, 0.00785769522190094, 0.042822737246751785, 0.0073759364895522594, -0.014155338518321514, 0.05072074383497238, -0.00436246395111084, -0.03245517238974571, -0.06505333632230759, -0.004528139252215624, 0.06579387187957764, 0.004700448829680681, -0.002411737572401762, 0.03118971548974514, 0.017636306583881378, -0.009934304282069206, -0.015359621495008469, -0.02064543403685093, 0.045637961477041245, 0.03037712350487709, -0.02362338826060295, 0.010901723057031631, 0.020334212109446526, -0.03405764698982239, 0.04319218173623085, -0.03547385334968567, -0.05668516084551811, 0.030989116057753563, 0.005954229272902012, 0.037230756133794785, -0.019344445317983627, 0.004296903032809496, -0.023222152143716812, -0.024817636236548424, 0.03138190135359764, -0.01528352964669466, 0.051670141518116, 0.039248738437891006, -0.032183099538087845, 0.011410760693252087, -0.03385863080620766, 0.017048051580786705, 0.033534396439790726, 0.030299261212348938, 0.009566056542098522, 0.0077195800840854645, -0.028318312019109726, -0.045859355479478836, -0.05948038399219513, 0.011555763892829418, -0.026739725843071938, -0.04483500123023987, -0.020475618541240692, 0.029696745797991753, 0.01905496045947075, -0.017421415075659752, 0.023005157709121704, -0.0321938693523407, -0.032746322453022, -0.043670929968357086, -0.03871995955705643, 0.01753055676817894, 0.02861412800848484, 0.06809548288583755, 0.018695315346121788, -0.013604582287371159, 0.031705163419246674, -0.07470923662185669, -0.04689432680606842, 0.03197362273931503, -0.005546258296817541, 0.05002279579639435, -0.008677495643496513, -0.030850764364004135, 0.06687887758016586, 0.016097282990813255, -0.002397385658696294, -0.026984356343746185, 0.015156598761677742, -0.04190673306584358, -0.038601700216531754, -0.007106036879122257, 0.001197953475639224, 0.012416357174515724, 0.051940981298685074, -0.04551992937922478, -0.007527777459472418, 0.017283305525779724, 0.04955296963453293, 0.009090263396501541, 0.0016469743568450212, -0.010759836062788963, 0.014217676594853401, -0.0012690344592556357, 0.020180489867925644, -0.010955932550132275, -0.0023188944905996323, -0.032714713364839554, 0.030135100707411766, -0.0026875396724790335, -0.051730480045080185, -0.008020392619073391, -0.0508754625916481, 0.011312573216855526, -0.028264015913009644, 0.06106873229146004, 0.049198441207408905, -0.028999513015151024, -0.027374248951673508, -0.0040555293671786785, -0.001128516742028296, -0.011047541163861752, 0.016734516248106956, 0.0263214148581028, 0.022587593644857407, -0.02949821576476097, 0.0018361812690272927, 0.018101882189512253, 0.0020402090158313513, 0.034866608679294586, -0.039863161742687225, 0.0015303122345358133, 0.022400015965104103, 0.04772135242819786, -0.0038328436203300953, -0.013782844878733158, -0.006517745554447174, 0.005459445063024759, -0.016703110188245773, -0.008438622578978539, -0.0009595557930879295, 0.023931074887514114, -0.013209162279963493, 0.01813853718340397, 0.004227562341839075, 0.010549246333539486, 0.01731301285326481, -0.014182914048433304, -0.07087539881467819, -0.026137439534068108, -0.013347621075809002, -0.03905211016535759, 0.03378456458449364, 0.015627173706889153, 0.06027889996767044, -0.0015139530878514051, -0.03026900812983513, -0.054318640381097794, 0.040894851088523865, -0.02893521450459957, 0.013477149419486523, -0.053794920444488525, -0.03463541343808174, 0.019782235845923424, -0.010607318952679634, 0.023934226483106613, -0.01887006126344204, -0.010125039145350456, 0.04033217206597328, -0.004464932717382908, 0.01451931707561016, -0.0015197040047496557, 0.023281395435333252, 0.04526003077626228, 0.0139852873980999, 0.028712674975395203, 0.038893360644578934, -0.03497011959552765, 0.033182840794324875, 0.011751145124435425, 0.0702759325504303, 0.04986952617764473, 0.0023774777073413134, 0.01599450781941414, -0.00393253518268466, -0.03677855432033539, -0.0011278772726655006, 0.020559480413794518, -0.008868475444614887, 0.0024479208514094353, 0.05253076180815697, 0.013770487159490585, -0.013108029961585999, 0.04056921601295471, 0.04990359768271446, 0.0034171894658356905, -0.013455904088914394, -0.03725164011120796, 0.017496738582849503, 0.0033580372110009193, -0.007808007299900055, 0.03510040417313576, -0.01777442917227745, -0.019025765359401703, -0.00539332116022706, 0.02804582566022873, 0.007839701138436794, -0.015415184199810028, -0.004595903679728508, 0.052165575325489044, 0.024675020948052406, 0.014631018042564392, -0.04756150767207146, 0.031023314222693443, 0.03363536670804024, 0.045050669461488724, 0.03173701465129852, 0.02630225196480751, -0.0789165273308754, 0.020301578566432, 0.004890714306384325, 0.025374414399266243, -0.044403064996004105, -0.010648439638316631, -0.038678236305713654, -0.04860023409128189, 0.016916334629058838, 0.010339118540287018, 0.022174861282110214, 0.006761623080819845, 0.02409837767481804, -0.018405476585030556, 0.009447755292057991, -0.04636376351118088, -0.02056335099041462, -0.02941918559372425, 0.014444515109062195, -0.01833977736532688, -0.03782452270388603, -0.03694623336195946, -0.017600180581212044, 0.011297113262116909, 0.048017408698797226, -0.02124442160129547, 0.011619491502642632, -0.011128327809274197, 0.02620212361216545, -0.0035331302788108587, -0.05925401672720909, 0.05558495968580246, 0.009071562439203262, -0.0367656946182251, 0.03960967808961868, -0.038565780967473984, -0.024202095344662666, 0.008004206232726574, -0.039562124758958817, -0.030166732147336006, 0.013037494383752346, -0.02366420440375805, 0.03811745345592499, 0.004622388165444136, 0.025632992386817932, 0.040979743003845215, 0.02578257955610752, -0.02598937600851059, 0.01202957984060049, -0.053313519805669785, 0.01356454286724329, -0.07177963852882385, -0.028639303520321846, -0.08866546303033829, -0.000312708638375625, -0.006435515359044075, 0.03795177862048149, 0.015282489359378815, 0.012178133241832256, -0.00024176636361517012, -0.02010236121714115, 0.02709026448428631, 0.0137921292334795, -0.027041886001825333, -0.023540005087852478, -0.008390952832996845, 0.03271351754665375, 0.00025365728652104735, -0.013276517391204834, 0.023972835391759872, -0.05090731009840965, -0.009719346649944782, -0.015769798308610916, -0.008889821358025074, -0.01987881027162075, -0.05117987468838692, -0.008662484586238861, 0.022015582770109177, -0.022605517879128456, 0.041281335055828094, 0.003567193169146776, 0.014067091979086399, 0.003768121125176549, -0.0506562702357769, -0.013211516663432121, 0.04502635449171066, -0.04304470866918564, 0.02569277584552765, -0.0011874944902956486, -0.01736805960536003, 0.028661105781793594, -0.010159309953451157, -0.04851905256509781, -0.014912789687514305, 0.007824217900633812, -0.028183311223983765, -0.026046322658658028, -0.002352008828893304, -0.02658832259476185, -0.039599042385816574, -0.028227508068084717, -0.014592918567359447, 0.045418355613946915, -0.018861614167690277, -0.0037925508804619312, 0.005160239525139332, 0.0318947471678257, 0.06557488441467285, 0.027736255899071693, -0.03037836030125618, 0.03970346599817276, -0.03184051811695099, 0.026768554002046585, 0.010007468983530998, 0.023002667352557182, -0.026695087552070618, 0.00668962812051177, -0.03628088906407356, 0.014429613016545773, 0.026214109733700752, -0.030664075165987015, -0.02188986726105213, 0.026651695370674133, 0.003801075741648674, 0.0048032947815954685, -0.03238242492079735, -0.019735081121325493, 0.018528228625655174, 0.04529528319835663, -0.03781016916036606, -0.0007470767595805228, 0.03693225234746933, 0.001567248022183776, 0.016972776502370834, 0.0021263742819428444, 0.0026962216943502426, 0.002263829577714205, 0.008378362283110619, -0.03245210647583008, -0.014057409949600697, -0.007255870848894119, -0.005322929937392473, 0.009531166404485703, 0.03128718584775925, 0.011769751086831093, 0.005512998905032873, 0.006232638377696276, -0.036582205444574356, -0.05794072896242142, -0.037573546171188354, 0.01995002292096615, 0.07375204563140869, 0.00022712245117872953, 0.014788186177611351, 0.04334380477666855, -0.00005178274659556337, -0.0007561753154732287, -0.03546708822250366, 0.032962631434202194, 0.006674135569483042, 0.002446267055347562, 0.00765058770775795, -0.07287339121103287, -0.018564840778708458, 0.03773660957813263, -0.026513880118727684, 0.01012911181896925, 0.017328927293419838, 0.02469121478497982, 0.046492014080286026, 0.012981909327208996, -0.013371541164815426, -0.04746756702661514, 0.07172537595033646, -0.0360473208129406, -0.008539971895515919, -0.07816308736801147, -0.008174974471330643, 0.032531626522541046, 0.050072286278009415, 0.02361973002552986, -0.07319185882806778, -0.04139101132750511, -0.07507257908582687, 0.035912733525037766, 0.015520812012255192, 0.007519692648202181, 0.035917870700359344, -0.02536304108798504, 0.024195287376642227, -0.03225838392972946, 0.022654063999652863, -0.0321531780064106, -0.12024188041687012, -0.007880129851400852, 0.027740787714719772, -0.0015034608077257872, 0.001154519384726882, 0.020897775888442993, -0.0363420806825161, 0.028286825865507126, -0.05515340343117714, 0.014584326185286045, 0.02421778440475464, 0.03140825033187866, -0.03213176503777504, 0.05786767601966858, -0.031119804829359055, 0.0234203077852726, -0.048589300364255905, -0.026158606633543968, 0.1408640295267105, 0.06865096837282181, 0.038553886115550995, -0.041869331151247025, 0.030984438955783844, -0.016145959496498108, 0.007942690514028072, -0.042083799839019775, 0.021259116008877754, -0.022279955446720123, -0.018279828131198883, 0.015261860564351082, 0.06586679816246033, -0.002772050676867366, -0.0060767740942537785, 0.008504985831677914, -0.06115242838859558, 0.013854765333235264, -0.010340157896280289, -0.007699734531342983, -0.009243723005056381, 0.028052862733602524, -0.01778670772910118, 0.014999830164015293, 0.015646953135728836, 0.006625923328101635, -0.02970363199710846, -0.017718492075800896, -0.020009750500321388, -0.024866506457328796, -0.013365994207561016, -0.031092414632439613, 0.05809509754180908, -0.01879248209297657, 0.019728299230337143, -0.007484568748623133, 0.03226099908351898, -0.036411382257938385, 0.029086202383041382, 0.016758056357502937, -0.03880062326788902, -0.008988061919808388, 0.006183710880577564, 0.01309396792203188, -0.0367293544113636, -0.030569259077310562, 0.004715373273938894, 0.05349606275558472, -0.007382563315331936, -0.0113145736977458, -0.028523070737719536, 0.008376690559089184, 0.023172520101070404, -0.021145032718777657, 0.008569268509745598, 0.012606409378349781, 0.014170055277645588, -0.020987888798117638, -0.014282769523561, -0.04456024244427681, 0.019156694412231445, 0.0097553925588727, 0.032450120896101, 0.012517956085503101, -0.04043738543987274, -0.05073947831988335, 0.05210861191153526, 0.03805733099579811, 0.038847915828228, 0.023914752528071404, 0.002219249727204442, 0.0042038061656057835, -0.012105067260563374, -0.05125068128108978, 0.002163797849789262, -0.008990035392343998, 0.0033986882772296667, -0.009016924537718296, 0.0015857453690841794, -0.014241013675928116, -0.054211411625146866, 0.001432889373973012, -0.028538428246974945, -0.02380201779305935, -0.0013647134182974696, 0.010282178409397602, 0.030872000381350517, 0.04252494126558304, -0.011909768916666508, -0.010322224348783493, 0.003788308473303914, 0.032449934631586075, -0.005009328480809927, -0.05205410718917847, -0.02207990363240242, 0.002985534956678748, 0.003950392361730337, -0.014824737794697285, -0.03973842412233353, 0.0184857789427042, 0.04792437702417374, 0.03236773610115051, -0.025113258510828018, 0.026802727952599525, -0.001541515695862472, 0.012022864073514938, 0.017077798023819923, -0.034779585897922516, -0.006535958033055067, 0.00788904819637537, 0.033992357552051544, -0.01312435232102871, -0.015018106438219547, -0.03248727694153786, -0.021245023235678673, 0.011372481472790241, -0.038681644946336746, -0.04203236475586891, -0.0136466259136796, -0.007772570010274649, -0.01020515151321888, -0.014544086530804634, -0.036448728293180466, 0.018388036638498306, -0.004670230206102133, -0.0051574320532381535, -0.015280202962458134, -0.017742125317454338, 0.04804639890789986, -0.01975390315055847, 0.008629287593066692, 0.028744172304868698, 0.0036296891048550606, 0.013067925348877907, 0.0045944685116410255, 0.021718690171837807, 0.008109045214951038, 0.04985683783888817, -0.0020680862944573164, -0.002417820505797863, 0.015875397250056267, -0.032019373029470444, -0.05220094695687294, 0.04479729011654854, 0.0149250328540802, 0.021560415625572205, 0.0165688656270504, 0.009832287207245827, -0.06616687029600143, -0.01678001694381237, -0.035180188715457916, 0.01829988695681095, 0.012898929417133331, 0.009390909224748611, -0.004537837114185095, -0.0465557761490345, 0.010173988528549671, 0.04203786700963974, 0.041989248245954514, 0.026887021958827972, 0.03323366492986679, 0.0035451455041766167, -0.0033234271686524153, 0.020759711042046547, -0.004775104578584433, -0.017411265522241592, 0.01027625147253275, -0.007333450485020876, 0.002784501761198044, 0.06453505158424377, -0.013576660305261612, 0.0506291389465332, -0.009312750771641731, 0.008266393095254898, -0.12679104506969452, -0.028170885518193245, 0.03138503432273865, 0.052300579845905304, 0.05057360976934433, -0.024386560544371605, -0.006269474048167467, 0.019087880849838257, -0.06091053783893585, -0.01743600331246853, 0.00996879767626524, -0.03755095228552818, -0.03342759236693382, -0.042464420199394226, -0.011665858328342438, 0.051980942487716675, -0.0014012639876455069, 0.007092672865837812, 0.03291907161474228, 0.024603206664323807, 0.020237941294908524, -0.01072737853974104, -0.017677484080195427, 0.032099008560180664, 0.04111027717590332, -0.05455427244305611, 0.0375700369477272, -0.02054346539080143, 0.0005993499653413892, 0.03334376960992813, 0.042617253959178925, 0.04754723608493805, 0.00477792089805007, 0.058538783341646194, 0.009549367241561413, 0.059739015996456146, 0.004990722984075546, 0.03532448410987854, 0.013096818700432777, -0.007405364885926247, 0.0009695620974525809, 0.013656983152031898, -0.017872605472803116, 0.013401824049651623, 0.00044516430352814496, -0.03581500053405762, -0.004412331618368626, -0.020787827670574188, -0.02296343259513378, -0.008794967085123062, 0.013639645650982857, -0.032155703753232956, -0.00470054242759943, -0.008150874637067318, 0.03597252815961838, -0.02877393551170826, 0.0002611299860291183, 0.028642239049077034, 0.030531838536262512, -0.008375166915357113, 0.060822151601314545, -0.020366474986076355, -0.024820618331432343, 0.060260724276304245, 0.025358112528920174, -0.026271173730492592, -0.0823979601264, -0.015734421089291573, -0.0023487438447773457, -0.01678375154733658, -0.02804669179022312, 0.004949509631842375, -0.06491096317768097, 0.03486914560198784, -0.011971625499427319, 0.024783216416835785, -0.031123382970690727, 0.04497682303190231, 0.02444480173289776, -0.06954777985811234, 0.07638148218393326, 0.006591745186597109, -0.016526564955711365, -0.00861338246613741, 0.007354793604463339, 0.0007165423012338579, -0.023930273950099945, 0.05605822429060936, 0.031775351613759995, 0.03763876110315323, -0.004155981820076704, 0.026671946048736572, 0.0015467246994376183, -0.03267787769436836, 0.019197285175323486, 0.00911504402756691, -0.0226307176053524, -0.012282416224479675, -0.03381667286157608, 0.03390863165259361, 0.014845496043562889, 0.023481203243136406, -0.004777208901941776, 0.006344903260469437, 0.013843277469277382, 0.006280878558754921, 0.018525123596191406, 0.00756769860163331, -0.007990666665136814, 0.04750387743115425, -0.06228117644786835, 0.048505090177059174, 0.0041245389729738235, -0.016711845993995667, -0.0500604510307312, 0.020675884559750557, -0.03683837503194809, -0.03336606174707413, 0.01660103164613247, -0.003921905532479286, -0.012505595572292805, -0.02402968890964985, 0.02765585482120514, 0.02819591388106346, 0.006798586342483759, 0.014079197309911251, 0.03227454796433449, -0.008906304836273193, 0.046179309487342834, -0.015036721713840961, 0.008541201241314411, 0.03034191019833088, 0.005470887757837772, 0.005890514235943556, -0.006466385442763567, 0.04341557249426842, -0.010507420636713505, -0.024585358798503876, 0.045189253985881805, -0.021843208000063896, 0.03177855536341667, 0.0019138799980282784, 0.016369890421628952, -0.025924183428287506, -0.0032255686819553375, 0.02825869247317314, -0.020524732768535614, 0.005774966906756163, -0.018137184903025627, 0.008496832102537155, 0.04324256256222725, -0.017400963231921196, -0.033611781895160675, 0.006394491530954838, 0.015973469242453575, -0.03468975052237511, -0.006901770364493132, -0.010978749953210354, 0.005723031237721443, 0.025838468223810196, 0.022182930260896683, -0.005971498787403107, -0.011724070645868778, 0.008132082410156727, -0.03191725164651871, -0.00826011598110199, 0.0011623644968494773, -0.009336406365036964, -0.03196977451443672, -0.023424610495567322, -0.031737759709358215, -0.020430173724889755, -0.017726749181747437, -0.004915044642984867, 0.03392453491687775, -0.04801694303750992, 0.013873465359210968, 0.00851823203265667, 0.05070701986551285, -0.06101612001657486, 0.011435098946094513, -0.041437335312366486, 0.02995895780622959, 0.0005002818652428687, 0.005348627921193838 ]
<p>I have to calculate half life of an advertisement using Kalman filter in R. The paper 'Estimating the Half-life of Advertisements' (<a href="http://link.springer.com/article/10.1023%2FA%3A1008158119567" rel="nofollow">Naik, 1999</a><sup>[1]</sup>) provides the base but am unable to understand how exactly the estimation is being done and since a lot of parameters that go in as the input to the kalman filters are unknown i am unable to move forward with my project.</p> <p>Any suggestion as in how to go forward? </p> <p>[1]: Naik, P.A. (1999),<br> "Estimating the Half-life of Advertisements,"<br> <em>Marketing Letters</em> 10:3, 351-362 </p>
73,907
[ -0.027412174269557, -0.014809275977313519, 0.010604782029986382, 0.007661405950784683, 0.006355134770274162, -0.0024628187529742718, -0.04271399974822998, -0.013955472968518734, 0.020988237112760544, -0.0014574374072253704, 0.01772068440914154, 0.062474630773067474, 0.030466103926301003, 0.04899394139647484, 0.008322963491082191, -0.008496569469571114, -0.007602297235280275, 0.0062805828638374805, 0.009521260857582092, 0.012393494136631489, 0.025772009044885635, 0.023596467450261116, -0.0035186477471143007, -0.002622219268232584, -0.017141830176115036, 0.042910534888505936, 0.011940115131437778, -0.043261267244815826, 0.02249765209853649, 0.041868049651384354, -0.010660868138074875, -0.03254102170467377, 0.011777488514780998, 0.018031777814030647, 0.008939536288380623, 0.011011756025254726, -0.03680356591939926, -0.048501040786504745, 0.007744721602648497, 0.059769295156002045, -0.06599404662847519, -0.003557274816557765, 0.01849662885069847, 0.03979367017745972, -0.021409450098872185, 0.016865679994225502, -0.011674949899315834, -0.026386458426713943, 0.027219122275710106, -0.030317755416035652, 0.0633019357919693, -0.013388603925704956, 0.013426858000457287, 0.01351214200258255, -0.027512775734066963, 0.0016764284810051322, 0.05065925791859627, 0.07943576574325562, -0.00044804398203268647, -0.08076512813568115, -0.02773611806333065, -0.02744593843817711, -0.02754211612045765, -0.044383153319358826, -0.017634497955441475, 0.03192795068025589, 0.010670063085854053, -0.037804991006851196, 0.05787894129753113, -0.0027444656006991863, 0.027092646807432175, -0.019676001742482185, 0.026281816884875298, 0.006037572398781776, 0.014376073144376278, -0.03457462042570114, -0.003990229219198227, 0.01805453933775425, 0.050336726009845734, 0.06074617803096771, -0.011045626364648342, -0.025299733504652977, -0.0011792178265750408, 0.07314649224281311, 0.013886743225157261, 0.0215899795293808, 0.09751088917255402, -0.011263550259172916, 0.04090709239244461, 0.017786365002393723, -0.021453360095620155, 0.03233237937092781, 0.05516059696674347, 0.037365857511758804, -0.023910041898489, 0.0744720920920372, -0.00015280260413419455, 0.05219823122024536, 0.004608882591128349, -0.0069363838993012905, 0.03026791661977768, -0.04934115707874298, -0.008657315745949745, 0.07259314507246017, -0.0032925400882959366, -0.0014021849492564797, 0.013947239145636559, -0.02475328929722309, -0.029023798182606697, -0.04658205062150955, -0.017335927113890648, 0.02524498663842678, -0.018413212150335312, 0.0038776416331529617, 0.0007394489366561174, -0.01727861911058426, -0.030421901494264603, -0.0067128525115549564, 0.03856900706887245, 0.024559229612350464, 0.05715092644095421, 0.0004235698143020272, -0.014642840251326561, -0.012306955642998219, -0.034433286637067795, 0.0234129186719656, 0.021189332008361816, 0.01244768500328064, -0.04587624594569206, 0.07510650157928467, 0.03118235245347023, -0.06309649348258972, 0.03306744992733002, 0.021318918094038963, 0.03610861301422119, -0.01794910989701748, -0.08856479078531265, -0.020465336740016937, 0.031737521290779114, -0.009956059977412224, 0.03999974951148033, -0.08280914276838303, -0.008066019974648952, 0.02200128138065338, 0.055455490946769714, -0.012577946297824383, 0.017484202980995178, 0.035553038120269775, 0.001179398619569838, 0.0141676627099514, -0.04300323501229286, -0.03683893010020256, -0.013301506638526917, 0.010599551722407341, -0.004547631833702326, -0.07022031396627426, -0.014881249517202377, 0.022316599264740944, -0.023682476952672005, -0.031523823738098145, 0.01785956509411335, 0.03980549797415733, -0.04636995494365692, 0.017395196482539177, 0.013723245821893215, -0.044535018503665924, 0.044221315532922745, 0.011388431303203106, 0.012557951733469963, -0.005314234644174576, -0.037323247641325, 0.042969148606061935, 0.0011115886736661196, 0.0028549220878630877, 0.05528692528605461, -0.018282225355505943, 0.006010068114846945, -0.045410722494125366, -0.0002801946538966149, 0.011392279528081417, -0.04165628179907799, -0.03217373788356781, -0.00013396261783782393, -0.00492867361754179, 0.03943713754415512, 0.01947750709950924, -0.01903434470295906, 0.002572368597611785, 0.02287258394062519, -0.013429971411824226, -0.05410885438323021, -0.08121177554130554, -0.01909392885863781, -0.03621893748641014, -0.029773928225040436, 0.004406248219311237, -0.027874985709786415, 0.011326846666634083, 0.018134934827685356, -0.010946682654321194, -0.018221203237771988, -0.01527685858309269, 0.019889559596776962, -0.026418441906571388, 0.0001464106171624735, 0.04496701434254646, 0.056357841938734055, -0.01925986260175705, 0.02045254409313202, -0.05242764577269554, -0.03193613886833191, -0.03259136155247688, -0.008601207286119461, 0.036205925047397614, -0.012683801352977753, -0.054386138916015625, 0.026397880166769028, -0.019630782306194305, 0.02349737472832203, 0.015890879556536674, -0.05114932730793953, 0.038199540227651596, 0.09501682221889496, 0.00962816271930933, 0.03979707136750221, 0.017367282882332802, 0.023933516815304756, 0.04749094694852829, -0.006821189075708389, -0.02514088712632656, -0.07580040395259857, -0.024087820202112198, 0.05573379620909691, -0.0315893292427063, 0.00913696363568306, 0.019793305546045303, 0.04771363362669945, 0.009722942486405373, 0.02882574498653412, 0.02262350730597973, -0.008809441700577736, -0.021287640556693077, 0.026371877640485764, 0.013676191680133343, -0.020792445167899132, 0.0075807091780006886, 0.037927523255348206, -0.006965937092900276, 0.06521441042423248, 0.010163210332393646, -0.0317486934363842, 0.04875090345740318, -0.006021539214998484, 0.0031450882088392973, -0.01513209380209446, -0.007383191958069801, 0.041737139225006104, -0.025933867320418358, -0.0018560887547209859, 0.02638126164674759, 0.025269508361816406, 0.026880012825131416, 0.01241424959152937, -0.030198857188224792, -0.020836954936385155, 0.024315841495990753, -0.027429915964603424, -0.012889308854937553, -0.012402508407831192, -0.0026915413327515125, 0.05475081503391266, -0.02997715398669243, -0.048260416835546494, 0.019370147958397865, -0.009704221971333027, 0.014933256432414055, 0.027810435742139816, -0.016935566440224648, -0.03385377675294876, -0.017625883221626282, 0.000037144956877455115, -0.02640289068222046, 0.03151283413171768, 0.05513524264097214, -0.019376900047063828, 0.021790599450469017, 0.03014630638062954, -0.02889549359679222, 0.008591578342020512, 0.004579124506562948, 0.023673588410019875, 0.0448833703994751, -0.003196992911398411, -0.04352721571922302, -0.03014416992664337, -0.035307519137859344, 0.009949011728167534, -0.06839124858379364, 0.003429178847000003, 0.012938270345330238, 0.02936924248933792, -0.03088267706334591, 0.0019651937764137983, -0.0473473034799099, -0.024770652875304222, -0.013859492726624012, 0.0035678185522556305, 0.015436969697475433, -0.013005303218960762, 0.024849822744727135, 0.03256240859627724, 0.01594468578696251, -0.02925116941332817, -0.08776155859231949, -0.08289646357297897, 0.06109817326068878, 0.008700466714799404, 0.029779763892292976, 0.006307758390903473, 0.007258583325892687, 0.11676100641489029, 0.025370530784130096, -0.02244216576218605, -0.03849155828356743, -0.025369824841618538, -0.0017084527062252164, -0.03480260446667671, -0.0012032516533508897, -0.00026928214356303215, -0.016454851254820824, 0.027796870097517967, -0.012976422905921936, -0.00172039947938174, 0.0406978502869606, -0.023563643917441368, 0.016267014667391777, 0.0009862935403361917, -0.02017797902226448, 0.019646210595965385, 0.05250499024987221, 0.046262338757514954, 0.02457784116268158, 0.015880724415183067, -0.0014217266580089927, 0.016368072479963303, 0.0016163898399099708, -0.06898023188114166, -0.019879382103681564, -0.036768969148397446, -0.03376808017492294, -0.04375293478369713, 0.012731201015412807, -0.006379090249538422, -0.03214447200298309, -0.012692035175859928, -0.005715270526707172, 0.07532808184623718, -0.028542809188365936, -0.0043041580356657505, 0.006848179269582033, 0.028707312420010567, -0.03682563081383705, -0.03194955363869667, -0.045189425349235535, -0.0015260311774909496, -0.030779272317886353, -0.04026779532432556, -0.0196915864944458, 0.017806697636842728, 0.003367743920534849, 0.01621103100478649, 0.0027239914052188396, -0.016569850966334343, -0.028895797207951546, -0.055225521326065063, -0.03496226668357849, -0.019274484366178513, 0.0189521461725235, 0.006500037852674723, 0.012548277154564857, -0.008926363661885262, -0.018998373299837112, -0.019183600321412086, 0.0003590295382309705, -0.05930132046341896, 0.04822978377342224, 0.008305530995130539, -0.021823640912771225, 0.003890909953042865, -0.017082855105400085, 0.03056800551712513, -0.03697321563959122, 0.011726419441401958, -0.01492747850716114, 0.011859305202960968, -0.039433132857084274, -0.022710196673870087, -0.01176830381155014, -0.012576913461089134, -0.0026221449952572584, -0.007290320936590433, 0.04035385325551033, -0.011654178611934185, 0.0004338152939453721, 0.026163484901189804, -0.031775932759046555, -0.023517079651355743, -0.04375389218330383, -0.009095462039113045, 0.041188642382621765, 0.0264021884649992, 0.007404412608593702, 0.003762344364076853, -0.014240780845284462, 0.051199063658714294, 0.029846882447600365, 0.05608421936631203, 0.054463185369968414, -0.011702707968652248, -0.03629092127084732, -0.055803827941417694, 0.01595310866832733, 0.0071535310707986355, 0.008839108981192112, -0.025746572762727737, -0.003968338016420603, 0.06776867806911469, 0.03375088423490524, -0.0030610307585448027, -0.013309163972735405, 0.05284513533115387, 0.04237739369273186, 0.01963726617395878, -0.0276507455855608, -0.025507621467113495, 0.005114598199725151, 0.006452666595578194, 0.04131946712732315, -0.002111191861331463, 0.010895277373492718, 0.013308070600032806, 0.0009831347269937396, -0.04940585792064667, -0.04175124689936638, 0.007146195042878389, 0.02255798503756523, 0.04961898922920227, -0.01875135488808155, -0.03962147235870361, 0.003312254324555397, 0.07684072107076645, 0.03815144672989845, 0.011961190029978752, 0.03573291003704071, -0.10061084479093552, 0.005250046029686928, 0.029342837631702423, 0.037583984434604645, 0.0038732518441975117, -0.012418984435498714, -0.07700591534376144, -0.03566688299179077, -0.006343008950352669, -0.04729222133755684, 0.023740937933325768, -0.019593043252825737, -0.0018708438146859407, -0.01144479587674141, -0.01120668649673462, -0.031147019937634468, -0.010606791824102402, -0.022744737565517426, 0.0009689885773696005, 0.014988898299634457, -0.02404666505753994, -0.0192815363407135, 0.035037893801927567, 0.013887593522667885, 0.04476599767804146, -0.016340522095561028, 0.009273282252252102, 0.03783852979540825, 0.008716768585145473, -0.039410464465618134, -0.011875458993017673, 0.022981954738497734, -0.007739250548183918, 0.011807315982878208, 0.04626879468560219, -0.024615289643406868, -0.03123735636472702, 0.06847994029521942, 0.01824069209396839, -0.009400622919201851, -0.04411473125219345, -0.055432453751564026, -0.012408715672791004, 0.038630057126283646, -0.006331280805170536, 0.03560645878314972, -0.006004233378916979, -0.0004669910704251379, 0.0389375314116478, -0.028911318629980087, -0.0020313826389610767, -0.027214154601097107, -0.0155067453160882, -0.032877396792173386, -0.010683993808925152, -0.01764203980565071, 0.039302725344896317, 0.01311692874878645, 0.039842378348112106, -0.050782639533281326, -0.017143256962299347, 0.00780449016019702, 0.03939263895153999, -0.020120961591601372, 0.004288921598345041, 0.04037773609161377, 0.02964092046022415, 0.023413078859448433, 0.009455106221139431, -0.0021101338788866997, -0.050265002995729446, 0.022952653467655182, -0.001009976607747376, -0.06726650893688202, -0.0009352695196866989, -0.0202346108853817, -0.033421169966459274, 0.03933585062623024, -0.0061716544441878796, 0.03543264418840408, -0.03391120955348015, 0.005963256116956472, 0.03426793962717056, -0.05896161496639252, 0.011243739165365696, 0.023509621620178223, -0.007350633852183819, 0.05049576982855797, -0.004295152612030506, 0.03143203631043434, 0.012587783858180046, -0.004310604650527239, -0.044445548206567764, -0.008291986770927906, 0.05299652740359306, 0.0007953319000080228, -0.06240665540099144, -0.019931117072701454, 0.03694676235318184, 0.0013619092060253024, -0.040825873613357544, -0.02236252650618553, 0.03628911077976227, -0.028119774535298347, -0.0013081295182928443, -0.006431859917938709, 0.017171617597341537, 0.052701979875564575, 0.034854717552661896, -0.0002702492638491094, 0.012726092711091042, -0.02142786979675293, -0.05208665877580643, -0.00929368194192648, 0.01405831053853035, -0.0037774827796965837, -0.011946264654397964, -0.032286033034324646, 0.027319611981511116, 0.04681682586669922, -0.03150163218379021, 0.010658926330506802, 0.010043143294751644, 0.004203621298074722, 0.011839843355119228, -0.05763007700443268, -0.006337070371955633, 0.027920695021748543, 0.02464194782078266, 0.007344044744968414, -0.0018700718646869063, -0.008881310932338238, 0.013427793979644775, 0.034037571400403976, -0.029432181268930435, -0.003994959406554699, 0.007561392150819302, 0.07214127480983734, 0.00015847240865696222, 0.007904847152531147, 0.023318296298384666, -0.04186101257801056, 0.047800708562135696, -0.00075239670695737, -0.027004295960068703, 0.03130534291267395, -0.024540122598409653, -0.043278783559799194, -0.02921329066157341, -0.06330226361751556, -0.0001620227558305487, 0.0734071210026741, -0.004745518788695335, 0.000996854156255722, 0.030226899310946465, 0.01578720472753048, 0.004151775036007166, -0.0033270257990807295, -0.002312200143933296, 0.0018242974765598774, 0.01640208438038826, 0.05474505200982094, 0.025066012516617775, -0.013677221722900867, 0.026855990290641785, 0.003505130996927619, 0.03496173024177551, -0.009131917729973793, 0.010422452352941036, 0.05175764113664627, -0.006222444120794535, -0.02422606199979782, -0.032495975494384766, 0.03172710910439491, -0.005217809230089188, 0.017979474738240242, -0.06180925667285919, -0.025952057912945747, 0.04604415223002434, 0.04398316890001297, 0.0029135558288544416, -0.05213030427694321, -0.02465728484094143, -0.03040982224047184, 0.000980017939582467, 0.034093622118234634, -0.018538136035203934, 0.021236630156636238, 0.023788724094629288, 0.01784615032374859, 0.00523213017731905, 0.057421062141656876, -0.014843737706542015, -0.03623764589428902, 0.014123518951237202, -0.02705637738108635, -0.043568797409534454, 0.029233260080218315, 0.022326448932290077, -0.00030066995532251894, 0.00292724696919322, -0.04397398605942726, 0.013961661607027054, 0.02371182292699814, 0.0330289788544178, -0.00993624608963728, 0.08106846362352371, -0.01053017470985651, 0.036321450024843216, -0.014834574423730373, -0.019638800993561745, 0.13233065605163574, 0.07127021998167038, 0.038489051163196564, -0.051077183336019516, -0.00583426421508193, -0.010070816613733768, 0.004409776534885168, -0.04248717799782753, 0.020685341209173203, -0.0022179698571562767, -0.00012310082092881203, 0.02921752631664276, 0.02622031234204769, -0.008685912005603313, 0.0038801743648946285, 0.02038019336760044, -0.02388550527393818, -0.026857811957597733, -0.010513970628380775, -0.017156846821308136, -0.00884578749537468, -0.02668074332177639, -0.06981096416711807, 0.062935009598732, 0.0009641418582759798, -0.0328153595328331, -0.04126933217048645, 0.010286697186529636, 0.01502277236431837, -0.05601729452610016, -0.017554419115185738, 0.013835913501679897, -0.008693305775523186, 0.0038766684010624886, -0.0012945730704814196, 0.018992207944393158, 0.01792145147919655, -0.0027921581640839577, 0.018887216225266457, 0.016284245997667313, 0.029809368774294853, 0.0003305368300061673, 0.01008693128824234, 0.01380189973860979, -0.03845890983939171, -0.02831832319498062, -0.04859898239374161, 0.0377669520676136, -0.030816612765192986, 0.00028076444868929684, -0.016648372635245323, 0.012781950645148754, -0.025730755180120468, -0.08270525187253952, 0.006629338022321463, 0.038471922278404236, 0.0018127546645700932, -0.03125093877315521, -0.016415545716881752, -0.02931351400911808, 0.005702724680304527, 0.012770649045705795, 0.056562669575214386, 0.03216874599456787, -0.0328635573387146, -0.02638796530663967, -0.03549976274371147, 0.00730436434969306, -0.02153671346604824, -0.02056829445064068, -0.0019652412738651037, -0.004198453389108181, -0.025362500920891762, 0.01036717277020216, 0.009604554623365402, -0.019980603829026222, 0.015238153748214245, -0.027542276307940483, 0.025423185899853706, -0.050201572477817535, -0.038050729781389236, 0.017361091449856758, 0.004222332965582609, -0.026244312524795532, -0.04504799097776413, -0.032052990049123764, 0.04306567832827568, 0.023683754727244377, 0.0032445774413645267, 0.03158712014555931, 0.002756074070930481, 0.01461665891110897, 0.016559956595301628, -0.038309480994939804, 0.018332911655306816, 0.01670616865158081, -0.02385619841516018, -0.011816360987722874, -0.02301858365535736, 0.05756102502346039, 0.021644357591867447, 0.022591447457671165, -0.00877835601568222, 0.013901627622544765, -0.03908270597457886, -0.014014129526913166, 0.0024515758268535137, -0.05856313928961754, 0.02953588031232357, -0.05548708513379097, 0.021150439977645874, -0.06702812016010284, 0.0028786216862499714, -0.01053533237427473, 0.009035852737724781, -0.007027723826467991, -0.03493497520685196, -0.005408172030001879, 0.0538499690592289, -0.04388722404837608, 0.013754715211689472, -0.02015533857047558, 0.0469961054623127, -0.0049014766700565815, 0.010070905089378357, -0.014785201288759708, -0.003758189268410206, -0.033093422651290894, 0.010601325891911983, 0.0006193455192260444, 0.02270514704287052, 0.017618786543607712, 0.003799785627052188, -0.010335930623114109, -0.016672683879733086, 0.0310429185628891, -0.030291318893432617, 0.04022938758134842, -0.025686029344797134, -0.03568392992019653, 0.027350615710020065, -0.017581656575202942, -0.03166839852929115, -0.024127934128046036, 0.005593390204012394, 0.024455476552248, 0.06253626197576523, -0.03428008779883385, 0.008613236248493195, 0.020652806386351585, -0.0048867492005229, 0.014173456467688084, 0.011930087581276894, 0.010420107282698154, 0.01681831106543541, 0.008825822733342648, 0.01714351400732994, 0.011477645486593246, -0.00785257201641798, 0.014267412014305592, 0.007085391785949469, -0.03981196507811546, 0.002683084225282073, 0.005069143138825893, -0.04589054733514786, -0.012042142450809479, -0.018004436045885086, 0.029490914195775986, 0.040767814964056015, 0.033282313495874405, 0.007283796090632677, 0.022309189662337303, -0.0112293791025877, 0.00272712972946465, -0.09102705866098404, 0.0021473916713148355, 0.010934467427432537, 0.029681356623768806, 0.040100518614053726, -0.06774287670850754, -0.0034396634437143803, 0.048453439027071, -0.055593341588974, 0.037593040615320206, -0.02934609167277813, 0.009163620881736279, -0.026881404221057892, 0.01586732640862465, -0.0014206633204594254, 0.030123243108391762, 0.03924446180462837, -0.0095133688300848, 0.041408225893974304, 0.003723699366673827, 0.00857651885598898, -0.019807498902082443, 0.025540564209222794, 0.01266955304890871, 0.025253498926758766, -0.024286765605211258, 0.07342099398374557, -0.03787456080317497, -0.00175690115429461, 0.057977091521024704, 0.01899309642612934, 0.061863794922828674, 0.0018226592801511288, 0.013613181188702583, 0.008116096258163452, 0.047334350645542145, 0.02424555830657482, 0.009081406518816948, -0.015711268410086632, -0.02534405328333378, 0.017083341255784035, 0.027701789513230324, -0.011497884057462215, 0.021278278902173042, 0.02478952519595623, -0.022969694808125496, -0.04084017500281334, -0.0016252887435257435, 0.008203278295695782, -0.0012123910710215569, -0.012610960751771927, -0.039016205817461014, 0.00033594187698327005, -0.04747113585472107, 0.015460536815226078, -0.018939148634672165, -0.0006734674680046737, 0.04347184672951698, 0.009853335097432137, -0.03792787343263626, 0.023824568837881088, -0.022767892107367516, -0.038259509950876236, 0.04511541500687599, -0.014443385414779186, -0.01116129569709301, -0.07841553539037704, 0.018258055672049522, -0.0008647970971651375, 0.011335320770740509, -0.06967245787382126, 0.0175668653100729, -0.026594150811433792, 0.05082911625504494, 0.05201311036944389, -0.0019488779362291098, -0.0035764069762080908, -0.026978280395269394, -0.0047234101220965385, -0.10595670342445374, 0.038874439895153046, 0.008032193407416344, -0.01749817654490471, -0.036440666764974594, -0.02472636103630066, -0.010695436969399452, -0.014645233750343323, 0.048298180103302, -0.023717621341347694, -0.007127301301807165, -0.0006550500402227044, 0.017410017549991608, -0.0182319525629282, -0.06499896943569183, 0.03806893154978752, -0.023895684629678726, -0.03400171548128128, -0.028287725523114204, -0.008283672854304314, -0.026510275900363922, 0.007872669026255608, -0.0055158971808850765, 0.02746868133544922, 0.04188621789216995, 0.010426001623272896, -0.011064120568335056, 0.03245588764548302, 0.03864084929227829, -0.005439154338091612, 0.035112373530864716, -0.0015893031377345324, 0.03620292246341705, 0.03514046221971512, -0.016659969463944435, -0.056897424161434174, 0.022048458456993103, -0.02126675844192505, -0.010094926692545414, -0.004207873251289129, -0.038830727338790894, 0.027435364201664925, -0.026375537738204002, -0.028031805530190468, 0.039769094437360764, -0.003244105027988553, 0.024330977350473404, 0.034037694334983826, -0.0005594149697571993, 0.02182839624583721, 0.00633262051269412, 0.01399093959480524, 0.036277517676353455, 0.016274571418762207, -0.0018050388898700476, 0.01392907090485096, -0.013843336142599583, -0.011431780643761158, 0.014920259825885296, 0.0272597037255764, 0.012557114474475384, 0.017470624297857285, -0.0025947329122573137, 0.034509290009737015, -0.03270869329571724, 0.004720412194728851, -0.004400802776217461, 0.010250487364828587, -0.04633411392569542, 0.011257486417889595, -0.029416583478450775, 0.06284917891025543, 0.003363227006047964, 0.014565288089215755, -0.006371051538735628, -0.00393020361661911, -0.041859161108732224, 0.034861914813518524, -0.01771561987698078, -0.004444419872015715, -0.008805271238088608, 0.06578928977251053, 0.02180836722254753, 0.000632269075140357, -0.0012480096193030477, -0.008256403729319572, 0.0006332214106805623, 0.0176002848893404, -0.012266426347196102, -0.023516368120908737, 0.00900284294039011, -0.034659240394830704, 0.01234191469848156, 0.016644887626171112, 0.03595352917909622, 0.014987237751483917, -0.03338842839002609, 0.027432505041360855, 0.002396333497017622, 0.05410730838775635, -0.05245554447174072, -0.01194402389228344, -0.021434593945741653, -0.006616063416004181, 0.01048012264072895, -0.018353162333369255 ]
<p>In relation to web usage mining from a log file, can you cluster data without performing User and/or Session identification? </p> <p>I mean,let's say I have these entries:</p> <blockquote> <p>123.234.324.122 [timestamp] "GET /cars/sport/porsche.jpg" 200 23432 "http://topgear.com/cars" "Mozilladsfsd" </p> <p>120.23.324.122 [timestamp] "GET /bikes/sport/r1.jpg" 200 23432 "http://topgear.com/cars" "Mozilladsfsd" </p> <p>13.234.324.122 [timestamp] "GET /cars/utility/micra.jpg" 200 23432"http://topgear.com/cars" "Mozilladsfsd" </p> </blockquote> <p>So,in this scenario, I just need to cluster based on which cars have been viewed more frequently etc etc..Do I need user identification and session identification then? Or can I just consider the URLs and cluster on them? </p> <p>Because as far as the traditional Web Usage Mining approach goes and all the papers I've gone through suggest, you do preprocessing,then the pattern-discovery comes along..</p> <p>My question is why not jump to the pattern discovery straight-away????</p>
45,351
[ -0.027547426521778107, 0.0004331051022745669, -0.002616527955979109, 0.008110365830361843, 0.024057768285274506, 0.00801776722073555, 0.009336256422102451, -0.021395575255155563, -0.004216265399008989, -0.02543346770107746, 0.010871306993067265, 0.038205068558454514, -0.021300461143255234, 0.0011303467908874154, 0.037431586533784866, -0.00218159519135952, -0.007307196501642466, -0.008468530140817165, -0.0006023078458383679, 0.02129121869802475, -0.014589996077120304, -0.002998210024088621, -0.01912202313542366, 0.013476005755364895, -0.03779880329966545, 0.0004490594146773219, -0.011112239211797714, -0.022171268239617348, 0.024801671504974365, 0.020954325795173645, -0.02240600623190403, -0.0010060948552563787, -0.003082247916609049, 0.02913329377770424, -0.012077282182872295, -0.0020922422409057617, -0.06276436150074005, 0.005347188096493483, -0.017522819340229034, 0.008309923112392426, -0.02790556661784649, 0.008959830738604069, -0.014794295653700829, 0.06547439843416214, -0.0030531594529747963, 0.011162858456373215, 0.0035481080412864685, -0.024094540625810623, 0.01283008512109518, -0.05494437739253044, 0.06597093492746353, -0.03421912342309952, 0.01995724067091942, 0.024872243404388428, -0.03394945338368416, -0.011686409823596478, 0.049066003412008286, 0.050473734736442566, -0.034073345363140106, -0.004991266410797834, -0.0472782701253891, 0.011766742914915085, 0.030963579192757607, -0.030836770310997963, -0.01769624650478363, 0.03219683840870857, -0.010414454154670238, -0.009637494571506977, 0.06394029408693314, -0.007082452066242695, -0.003273504786193371, -0.012886334210634232, 0.07152175903320312, -0.021701408550143242, 0.005862626247107983, -0.043469540774822235, 0.008018145337700844, 0.018796831369400024, 0.06032312288880348, 0.03419122472405434, 0.028226414695382118, 0.015234249643981457, 0.012555273249745369, 0.03498654440045357, 0.07070722430944443, 0.004341051448136568, 0.06420215964317322, -0.03528954088687897, 0.007808055263012648, 0.03892183303833008, 0.009057053364813328, -0.0035000904463231564, 0.05868619680404663, 0.0030781731475144625, -0.02421300858259201, 0.047563984990119934, 0.006782154086977243, 0.0035367105156183243, 0.008511959575116634, 0.011369208805263042, -0.002868346404284239, -0.036046016961336136, -0.012219498865306377, 0.021621977910399437, -0.02448769100010395, -0.027077216655015945, -0.08232178539037704, -0.006914910860359669, -0.02892320044338703, -0.013208914548158646, -0.026135331019759178, 0.00838824175298214, 0.018135972321033478, -0.01846213825047016, 0.0204655509442091, 0.007779239676892757, -0.053572602570056915, -0.012884324416518211, 0.0262422077357769, 0.05023060366511345, 0.02560119889676571, -0.02308087982237339, 0.0020057244691997766, -0.05900080129504204, -0.05239865183830261, -0.008637634105980396, 0.04283151403069496, -0.02331455983221531, -0.0047919861972332, 0.02199336513876915, -0.024266595020890236, -0.03294963762164116, 0.04506577178835869, -0.015160473063588142, 0.026327630504965782, -0.002630640985444188, -0.08815145492553711, -0.029278218746185303, 0.051389142870903015, -0.006939092185348272, 0.02042478695511818, -0.04429512470960617, 0.0012115073623135686, 0.032162025570869446, 0.043616268783807755, 0.013603860512375832, 0.010203320533037186, 0.02407744713127613, -0.013879012316465378, 0.004887725226581097, -0.008325074799358845, -0.04677782207727432, -0.0196414515376091, -0.008269073441624641, -0.00810184795409441, -0.06110648810863495, 0.030991407111287117, 0.01028146967291832, 0.005119193345308304, 0.008498509414494038, 0.005662070587277412, 0.02407725714147091, -0.026209397241473198, -0.007576971314847469, 0.015163308940827847, -0.014856345020234585, 0.06226096674799919, -0.005750057753175497, 0.059642352163791656, -0.014689230360090733, 0.003434370271861553, 0.022229211404919624, 0.006509521510452032, 0.04026605933904648, 0.07121554762125015, -0.001060855109244585, -0.002509110141545534, 0.011525863781571388, 0.044613584876060486, -0.04492546617984772, -0.031797803938388824, -0.06090785935521126, -0.01565452292561531, 0.014283734373748302, 0.0037285685539245605, 0.04336104169487953, 0.006488215643912554, -0.007795299403369427, 0.027630385011434555, -0.04639236256480217, -0.011663244105875492, -0.06416922807693481, 0.0037249017041176558, -0.030233193188905716, -0.013543030247092247, 0.031331297010183334, -0.03762460872530937, -0.029487455263733864, 0.000916370889171958, -0.04116615280508995, -0.01626521348953247, -0.010658713057637215, 0.023718038573861122, -0.043114256113767624, -0.049356959760189056, 0.029004840180277824, -0.009925196878612041, -0.05148674175143242, 0.043832339346408844, -0.05365357920527458, -0.06356976926326752, 0.008252047933638096, -0.031621795147657394, 0.013876278884708881, -0.02543656714260578, -0.01555781438946724, 0.024956386536359787, 0.006420568097382784, -0.04908832535147667, 0.011813989840447903, -0.048373859375715256, 0.07113876938819885, 0.07007409632205963, 0.04798060283064842, -0.014965800568461418, -0.006253888364881277, 0.001213464536704123, 0.0136330034583807, -0.022438019514083862, -0.02643299289047718, -0.0859559029340744, -0.031090721487998962, 0.0629727691411972, 0.019067859277129173, -0.05129500851035118, 0.003400526475161314, 0.0650138258934021, 0.06543322652578354, -0.027580874040722847, 0.036781150847673416, -0.01636452227830887, 0.021228814497590065, 0.00970518123358488, 0.046427831053733826, 0.029154818505048752, -0.012625418603420258, 0.02683599479496479, -0.003479244653135538, 0.03474900498986244, -0.0014077051309868693, -0.020015360787510872, 0.03181944414973259, -0.0015020455466583371, -0.0015109145315364003, 0.011923929676413536, 0.010896459221839905, 0.034122683107852936, -0.029610486701130867, 0.007198632229119539, -0.008849688805639744, 0.04996819049119949, 0.0030014216899871826, 0.021235531195998192, -0.040032193064689636, 0.00275030336342752, 0.01629231497645378, -0.014554671943187714, -0.014753318391740322, 0.02722163125872612, -0.06091754138469696, 0.02722453698515892, -0.006838726345449686, -0.021440889686346054, -0.028165943920612335, 0.050046972930431366, 0.024346973747015, -0.017945371568202972, 0.016623605042696, -0.014464089646935463, -0.017405889928340912, -0.019766639918088913, -0.032579924911260605, -0.01070250105112791, -0.0019418051233515143, -0.0493210032582283, -0.010515961796045303, 0.020494259893894196, -0.01395919919013977, 0.008210415951907635, -0.019866671413183212, -0.005731412209570408, -0.010201545432209969, 0.010623404756188393, -0.060665108263492584, -0.03331758454442024, -0.016252029687166214, 0.0372554287314415, 0.020481092855334282, -0.01978432573378086, 0.03366075083613396, 0.015605737455189228, -0.051583725959062576, 0.018566938117146492, -0.049643632024526596, -0.027779096737504005, -0.040519315749406815, -0.0072392853908240795, 0.0020188847556710243, -0.023773394525051117, 0.016859902068972588, -0.005591655150055885, -0.045816536992788315, 0.03736446052789688, -0.058333370834589005, -0.05262358486652374, 0.005932128522545099, 0.0032148724421858788, 0.02354881353676319, -0.0036955459509044886, -0.016124572604894638, 0.036313366144895554, 0.017925800755620003, -0.06448633968830109, -0.04644439369440079, -0.02081863395869732, -0.0347035750746727, -0.02116396836936474, 0.020395994186401367, 0.02117602527141571, 0.007613832596689463, -0.019358651712536812, 0.017774023115634918, 0.032858707010746, 0.053676899522542953, 0.0146409310400486, -0.008631251752376556, 0.008570260368287563, -0.01592819020152092, 0.02923002652823925, 0.02808644063770771, 0.025428500026464462, -0.012606584466993809, 0.0338093526661396, -0.01634237915277481, 0.007045995444059372, 0.06634946167469025, -0.027980301529169083, 0.03050285205245018, 0.0014551260974258184, 0.003118419088423252, -0.01941179484128952, -0.0021298949141055346, 0.030446749180555344, -0.04151620715856552, -0.010183185338973999, 0.035306256264448166, 0.003067723475396633, -0.0004767241480294615, -0.012026199139654636, 0.027060676366090775, 0.06668845564126968, -0.02335486002266407, -0.05416877940297127, 0.00040906303911469877, -0.06665720045566559, 0.01846254989504814, -0.024664530530571938, -0.0092599643394351, 0.019250620156526566, 0.0658901035785675, 0.012361996807157993, -0.001059638918377459, -0.04105434566736221, -0.006002152804285288, -0.09954507648944855, -0.03373635932803154, -0.021495236083865166, 0.05306781828403473, -0.02546381577849388, 0.02239440195262432, 0.005077045876532793, -0.015963224694132805, 0.00962566863745451, -0.012984048575162888, -0.06891081482172012, 0.003960548900067806, -0.029958080500364304, 0.018603812903165817, 0.004562215879559517, -0.056221507489681244, 0.03305659070611, -0.038608651608228683, 0.026323974132537842, -0.005841051694005728, 0.00978767592459917, -0.052888184785842896, -0.005971393082290888, -0.021422509104013443, -0.029203014448285103, -0.034462664276361465, 0.02063520811498165, 0.05451342836022377, 0.02646527998149395, 0.07293800264596939, 0.013180258683860302, -0.018393240869045258, -0.016569098457694054, -0.021749021485447884, 0.024744290858507156, -0.01763734221458435, 0.029556984081864357, -0.006904334761202335, 0.0076856608502566814, -0.06674370914697647, 0.012738756835460663, -0.03481801971793175, 0.019620558246970177, 0.02465604431927204, 0.00012818719551432878, -0.0006840595160610974, -0.06493238359689713, -0.01978209987282753, 0.028433259576559067, 0.02349180355668068, -0.025486420840024948, 0.00632950384169817, 0.021854154765605927, -0.00980489794164896, -0.0354895181953907, 0.04571298509836197, 0.09010305255651474, 0.020065009593963623, -0.02792130783200264, -0.022819476202130318, 0.010777578689157963, 0.05014237388968468, -0.007028657477349043, 0.017298772931098938, 0.010484907776117325, -0.001002031727693975, -0.04919551685452461, 0.03025197610259056, -0.008498883806169033, -0.0292342659085989, 0.02783767692744732, 0.01572493091225624, 0.052884649485349655, -0.012887793593108654, -0.02782331593334675, 0.042967721819877625, 0.030650701373815536, 0.060857485979795456, 0.027399785816669464, -0.024722987785935402, -0.09527494013309479, -0.015234126709401608, 0.031710341572761536, 0.04032079502940178, -0.019223859533667564, 0.010552987456321716, 0.009791064076125622, 0.0025564797688275576, 0.030099518597126007, -0.05038033425807953, 0.053571026772260666, -0.0558144673705101, -0.0029774669092148542, -0.05330248922109604, -0.017493026331067085, -0.010440913960337639, 0.012143895030021667, -0.021343234926462173, 0.05686718970537186, -0.022850949317216873, -0.0017194051761180162, -0.08025407046079636, -0.009450390934944153, -0.009016809985041618, -0.00281711108982563, -0.029586896300315857, 0.009948967024683952, 0.010158170945942402, 0.045627303421497345, -0.015575999394059181, -0.035991206765174866, 0.020819028839468956, 0.0019897560123354197, 0.00046147016109898686, 0.04177173599600792, 0.00015628250548616052, -0.01756518892943859, -0.008905368857085705, 0.0015509681543335319, -0.02937868796288967, -0.00011151802755193785, -0.03007606789469719, 0.014833131805062294, 0.05831405892968178, 0.022309692576527596, 0.030301189050078392, 0.03232911229133606, 0.013031043112277985, 0.01815137267112732, -0.0063386899419128895, -0.004273104015737772, -0.036499038338661194, 0.001372058060951531, -0.013380446471273899, 0.0354771614074707, -0.0248925369232893, 0.033068522810935974, -0.020217137411236763, 0.005943139083683491, -0.043614745140075684, -0.040548745542764664, 0.008568719029426575, 0.02023475058376789, 0.004884230904281139, 0.003937738481909037, 0.010782331228256226, 0.0515536293387413, -0.002419369528070092, -0.021107235923409462, -0.010188995860517025, -0.014254682697355747, 0.006345581263303757, 0.013474613428115845, 0.0050825513899326324, 0.010951933450996876, -0.024856943637132645, 0.024624720215797424, 0.03688684478402138, -0.023665547370910645, 0.050343096256256104, -0.014660157263278961, 0.0027865436859428883, 0.023730166256427765, -0.04073807969689369, 0.03177255764603615, 0.0003206820983905345, -0.008859522640705109, 0.025431200861930847, -0.03335440903902054, 0.09967612475156784, 0.004061151295900345, -0.06002998352050781, -0.06801529228687286, -0.06480703502893448, 0.029212895780801773, 0.0007748376810923219, -0.04078160226345062, -0.03199433907866478, 0.02060825563967228, -0.015357974916696548, -0.0601634755730629, -0.023831000551581383, 0.04113326221704483, -0.021572880446910858, 0.0016955699538812041, 0.033798348158597946, 0.06448786705732346, 0.09313458204269409, 0.040526099503040314, -0.011226070113480091, 0.025363869965076447, 0.017308538779616356, -0.014405342750251293, -0.02138737216591835, 0.011614035815000534, -0.017603017389774323, -0.004359687678515911, -0.027139412239193916, 0.00487083476036787, 0.04398981109261513, -0.048051618039608, 0.00016813393449410796, 0.022932853549718857, 0.04764886200428009, 0.0052500879392027855, -0.026034312322735786, 0.025386560708284378, 0.008126303553581238, -0.017035840079188347, -0.004706391599029303, 0.02217487245798111, 0.004332655109465122, -0.0011346926912665367, 0.03800801560282707, 0.02358616329729557, 0.021271327510476112, 0.02811051905155182, 0.0527629554271698, 0.005294657312333584, -0.007231155876070261, 0.001924515818245709, -0.04464409127831459, 0.02946089766919613, 0.008190377615392208, 0.011159012094140053, 0.006597611121833324, 0.007572439964860678, -0.0033425968140363693, -0.04138016328215599, 0.003821378340944648, -0.030255721881985664, 0.04593130201101303, 0.020274078473448753, 0.027048954740166664, 0.02710774540901184, -0.017349593341350555, 0.008292300626635551, -0.031516313552856445, -0.011052676476538181, -0.06236535683274269, 0.013256741687655449, 0.03834670037031174, -0.00718417763710022, 0.02333257347345352, 0.01580306887626648, 0.011050385423004627, 0.04281676933169365, 0.054576415568590164, 0.059486255049705505, 0.04960707575082779, 0.022470494732260704, -0.02734873816370964, -0.026750735938549042, 0.013487606309354305, -0.014612981118261814, 0.014484860002994537, -0.023453455418348312, 0.0036800638772547245, 0.04121942073106766, 0.015034724026918411, 0.021199407055974007, -0.02390805445611477, 0.0021771963220089674, -0.028758354485034943, 0.0251549631357193, 0.03432526811957359, 0.003544391365721822, 0.0007125959382392466, 0.008248495869338512, 0.025380350649356842, 0.011861689388751984, 0.017278054729104042, 0.03571173548698425, -0.03431688994169235, -0.03624950721859932, -0.008938943035900593, -0.04355499520897865, 0.040745969861745834, 0.0025430701207369566, -0.07276131212711334, 0.03519612178206444, -0.013984470628201962, 0.0010984429391101003, 0.005804837681353092, 0.07740447670221329, 0.006242377683520317, 0.06579849123954773, 0.015283692628145218, 0.02842087112367153, 0.0019432234112173319, -0.02133808098733425, 0.1329457312822342, 0.0877942368388176, 0.06079256907105446, -0.045190174132585526, 0.008897756226360798, -0.012898217886686325, 0.001293943845666945, -0.026192639023065567, 0.022406158968806267, -0.007604022044688463, 0.007151602301746607, 0.04391202703118324, 0.014707542024552822, 0.015773499384522438, 0.008974511176347733, 0.058396290987730026, -0.029592089354991913, -0.03371967002749443, -0.002919143298640847, 0.028696808964014053, -0.028500225394964218, -0.014032719656825066, -0.046451181173324585, 0.026421716436743736, 0.025452403351664543, -0.013598212040960789, -0.0006186116370372474, -0.0335066132247448, -0.02409576252102852, -0.016002727672457695, -0.006310862954705954, 0.005686591845005751, 0.010726828128099442, -0.02161768265068531, -0.052509501576423645, -0.007797091268002987, 0.011406620033085346, -0.0019494428997859359, -0.003454001387581229, 0.026152655482292175, 0.025582794100046158, -0.03137444332242012, -0.031040819361805916, 0.025347523391246796, -0.03345327824354172, -0.017416471615433693, -0.03183967247605324, 0.045429158955812454, -0.013674529269337654, 0.004223651718348265, -0.010116075165569782, -0.01068047434091568, 0.0111442431807518, 0.003035608446225524, -0.01577424444258213, -0.0039696963503956795, 0.025827370584011078, -0.01873723417520523, -0.043576013296842575, -0.052522171288728714, 0.024894364178180695, 0.009923690930008888, 0.0006930491654202342, 0.01881386898458004, -0.007202628068625927, -0.007693240884691477, -0.024679875001311302, 0.015944262966513634, 0.014033259823918343, 0.00727091496810317, -0.01584276370704174, -0.013553689233958721, -0.0474475659430027, -0.013743357732892036, 0.01495106890797615, -0.012807702645659447, 0.04788479581475258, -0.0015044404426589608, 0.009533056989312172, -0.0029178650584071875, -0.003141605295240879, 0.010152502916753292, -0.04184417426586151, -0.023481721058487892, -0.03493054211139679, 0.04198925569653511, 0.011123212985694408, 0.04499140754342079, 0.012007671408355236, 0.010741682723164558, 0.0119721544906497, 0.039444826543331146, 0.009060565382242203, -0.021009834483265877, -0.021427221596240997, -0.006984890904277563, -0.008197503164410591, 0.03342272341251373, 0.020183995366096497, 0.025886844843626022, 0.010672303847968578, -0.03213789314031601, -0.007612769957631826, 0.029504545032978058, 0.03209291025996208, 0.019276898354291916, 0.009319688193500042, -0.023603180423378944, -0.0036612101830542088, -0.00962032563984394, -0.008758329786360264, -0.0019298156257718801, -0.07876314967870712, -0.015403175726532936, 0.008669390343129635, 0.010013081133365631, -0.03005240485072136, -0.017268043011426926, 0.03080441802740097, -0.03515414148569107, 0.03691190853714943, -0.011537293903529644, -0.012698886916041374, -0.05170615389943123, 0.015810322016477585, -0.015465988777577877, 0.003858295502141118, -0.03339030221104622, 0.01722574047744274, -0.00206639408133924, 0.015569309704005718, 0.02726774290204048, 0.029423024505376816, -0.015513232909142971, -0.020571449771523476, 0.017772812396287918, -0.08606725186109543, 0.016893822699785233, -0.055642858147621155, -0.020728856325149536, 0.024347778409719467, -0.048278193920850754, -0.01077785063534975, 0.002946204971522093, 0.018661009147763252, 0.012657900340855122, 0.008658645674586296, 0.012060550041496754, -0.011846262961626053, 0.038410674780607224, 0.00038469102582894266, -0.007521966937929392, 0.047803886234760284, 0.010751811787486076, 0.027542708441615105, 0.013990435749292374, 0.021496320143342018, 0.024561094120144844, -0.018159667029976845, 0.011726561933755875, 0.02789182774722576, 0.019822152331471443, -0.017429765313863754, -0.0004034374142065644, 0.02593194879591465, 0.03109589032828808, -0.04959239810705185, -0.004779473412781954, 0.07099302113056183, 0.021835066378116608, -0.06587153673171997, 0.003716522827744484, -0.028179354965686798, -0.008437772281467915, -0.03476632758975029, -0.036111924797296524, 0.028420276939868927, -0.008822579868137836, 0.05752776935696602, -0.03835827857255936, -0.03168143704533577, 0.01128220371901989, -0.05386456847190857, 0.02071329578757286, 0.0016720087733119726, -0.02250043675303459, -0.06391433626413345, -0.0004756064445246011, -0.009316514246165752, 0.00939630065113306, 0.06874590367078781, 0.03870740905404091, 0.026857711374759674, 0.022434793412685394, -0.024111460894346237, -0.011103915050625801, -0.035658955574035645, 0.006319444160908461, 0.03856043517589569, -0.03673645481467247, 0.07964762300252914, -0.03732744976878166, -0.04240111634135246, 0.003944266587495804, -0.03547152504324913, -0.008573661558330059, 0.06563686579465866, -0.004931322764605284, -0.020510399714112282, 0.04738086462020874, 0.061406828463077545, -0.03803692385554314, 0.009021892212331295, 0.04788295552134514, -0.017489204183220863, 0.013346217572689056, 0.02949478104710579, 0.016577264294028282, -0.014764566905796528, 0.01350224670022726, -0.018100017681717873, 0.033586032688617706, -0.026077019050717354, -0.010382079519331455, 0.00722048245370388, 0.0385991670191288, -0.0006299047381617129, 0.003770100884139538, -0.026347126811742783, -0.02350502647459507, 0.035735614597797394, 0.032938484102487564, 0.02111968956887722, 0.005029201041907072, 0.0309747327119112, -0.03811030834913254, -0.05055681988596916, 0.03020380064845085, 0.002469288418069482, -0.005550092086195946, -0.05234769731760025, 0.0014749002875760198, 0.013333354145288467, -0.04358212277293205, -0.03422170132398605, 0.011118849739432335, 0.047525420784950256, 0.054657671600580215, -0.012736830860376358, 0.023483192548155785, 0.04401605576276779, -0.017149878665804863, 0.006806465331465006, -0.03111717291176319, 0.04931303858757019, 0.0012633297592401505, -0.00006334358477033675, -0.03777766600251198, -0.039201803505420685, -0.044177643954753876, -0.017046773806214333, 0.05134639889001846, -0.02583780325949192, -0.0057412865571677685, -0.04787442460656166, 0.03201776370406151, -0.0121336430311203, -0.017923487350344658, 0.04562666639685631, -0.002934231422841549, -0.04196837544441223, 0.020197350531816483, -0.026115024462342262, -0.015761103481054306, 0.00716373510658741, 0.028694909065961838, -0.0077925510704517365, -0.012849418446421623, 0.005696109961718321, -0.026382094249129295, 0.025293603539466858, -0.01072640996426344, 0.030230049043893814, 0.0523197241127491, 0.01239212416112423, 0.0019241373520344496, 0.05189293995499611, 0.02671113610267639, -0.03658390790224075, 0.02208663895726204, -0.08451106399297714, -0.008304300718009472, 0.018262900412082672, 0.0007364280754700303, 0.02406538464128971, -0.05776253342628479, 0.000021279371139826253, -0.012103401124477386, 0.00969051755964756, 0.005920313764363527, 0.041744716465473175, 0.03729981184005737, 0.03245503827929497, 0.032415688037872314, 0.04523073136806488, 0.001636049011722207, -0.05332827940583229, -0.0022712447680532932, 0.04082265496253967, 0.005244551692157984, -0.001465946203097701, 0.014595392160117626, 0.03967105224728584, 0.030611207708716393, 0.015846334397792816, -0.03572345897555351, 0.06163131818175316, -0.05210856720805168, 0.0012729269219562411, -0.004515402019023895, -0.03761334344744682, 0.016790922731161118, 0.04797673225402832, -0.003197216894477606, 0.04102581366896629, -0.05826854333281517, -0.02818743698298931, -0.032731007784605026, -0.008574556559324265, -0.05148728936910629, 0.028761621564626694, -0.016696088016033173, 0.03211507946252823, -0.014101560227572918, 0.01932722143828869, 0.02659616805613041, 0.008586139418184757, 0.014103345572948456, 0.018158335238695145, -0.0022959692869335413, -0.03504316508769989, -0.010988373309373856, -0.0012836107052862644, -0.024490609765052795, -0.03491450473666191, -0.0030801643151789904, -0.006269452627748251, 0.0884815901517868, -0.0064865401946008205, -0.011047594249248505, -0.006153264548629522, -0.01662016659975052, 0.014351063407957554, -0.037651848047971725, 0.02232363633811474, -0.056429460644721985, -0.015835348516702652, 0.007164774928241968, -0.054186027497053146 ]
<p>I want to determine the significance of a particular variable, among many confounders. If I fit a model on the training set and observe a small p value, should I discard the model because it extrapolates poorly on the test set (negative $R^2$ value), or should I keep it since I wasn't interested in predictions anyway?</p>
73,908
[ -0.024376340210437775, 0.0052048638463020325, -0.02304140292108059, -0.027743007987737656, 0.013749091885983944, 0.03647821396589279, -0.005951846018433571, -0.026684749871492386, 0.02923601306974888, -0.01693284884095192, 0.024375302717089653, 0.049267977476119995, 0.047819532454013824, -0.01579529605805874, 0.00016624873387627304, 0.01252542994916439, -0.010578196495771408, 0.003863339778035879, -0.0036328178830444813, -0.0082407770678401, -0.011660992167890072, 0.026215318590402603, 0.02309129759669304, 0.002798698842525482, -0.057179272174835205, 0.05632849410176277, 0.03905412182211876, -0.016100792214274406, 0.00770146306604147, 0.0559975802898407, -0.03441355377435684, -0.01729563996195793, 0.0018513916293159127, 0.03487761691212654, 0.04025242105126381, 0.014135852456092834, -0.014407635666429996, -0.032323095947504044, 0.026927318423986435, -0.0014887566212564707, 0.006971301045268774, -0.04050396755337715, 0.06450285017490387, 0.024178722873330116, 0.016788963228464127, -0.012175990268588066, -0.002683251863345504, -0.061972726136446, 0.050095319747924805, -0.06256737560033798, 0.03587235137820244, 0.01923956722021103, 0.01909913867712021, 0.06728658080101013, 0.00019527591939549893, -0.010829419828951359, 0.039039090275764465, 0.07233208417892456, -0.03082152083516121, -0.06375114619731903, -0.014959745109081268, 0.00243912055157125, -0.005727479699999094, -0.003452413948252797, -0.026402032002806664, 0.023663189262151718, 0.0003902525349985808, -0.03423311561346054, 0.04470411315560341, -0.029081888496875763, 0.018534427508711815, 0.019251985475420952, 0.019124437123537064, -0.0024705941323190928, 0.03916896879673004, -0.005097378045320511, -0.0005632865359075367, 0.0036232322454452515, 0.0353078730404377, 0.034700747579336166, 0.015461871400475502, -0.008709900081157684, 0.018767904490232468, 0.0450785867869854, 0.02179405651986599, -0.004430623725056648, 0.04189860075712204, -0.005655078217387199, -0.0061473906971514225, 0.031146572902798653, -0.05458804965019226, -0.005469186697155237, 0.047417134046554565, -0.03141099587082863, -0.023041998967528343, 0.048868659883737564, -0.014506947249174118, 0.05269154533743858, 0.016387568786740303, -0.00322684645652771, -0.06346514075994492, -0.03463037684559822, 0.021526992321014404, 0.04508432000875473, -0.018835129216313362, -0.01847577467560768, -0.0038663174491375685, 0.011602460406720638, -0.0029405986424535513, -0.029878197237849236, 0.028039537370204926, 0.0447118878364563, 0.012583617120981216, 0.015284177847206593, 0.05319879949092865, -0.008840386755764484, -0.014928873628377914, -0.0390862300992012, 0.050551991909742355, 0.054853588342666626, 0.036313433200120926, -0.008299969136714935, 0.03783677518367767, -0.025290051475167274, -0.018386662006378174, -0.0137220723554492, 0.043066032230854034, -0.0322762168943882, -0.01836402527987957, 0.019707318395376205, 0.02191917784512043, -0.02827475219964981, 0.020825015380978584, -0.00870237872004509, 0.0403951033949852, 0.03439227491617203, -0.07077933847904205, -0.04778450354933739, 0.0405968613922596, -0.026729082688689232, 0.009547342546284199, -0.0387352891266346, -0.04706384614109993, 0.04347996413707733, 0.03781012073159218, 0.004845773801207542, 0.029621565714478493, -0.0006950916722416878, 0.051862683147192, -0.01032292004674673, -0.006545885931700468, -0.02587667666375637, -0.05364401638507843, -0.020874930545687675, -0.05322721600532532, -0.0963943675160408, 0.02201266959309578, 0.0389169305562973, -0.006143481004983187, 0.0009219278581440449, 0.034592464566230774, -0.01982038840651512, -0.011832388117909431, -0.019505398347973824, 0.0007007529493421316, 0.01591847464442253, 0.09112818539142609, 0.005504617467522621, 0.02920754812657833, 0.021402154117822647, 0.016789307817816734, 0.02966482564806938, 0.029399551451206207, 0.04107183590531349, 0.03656300529837608, 0.03298749774694443, 0.007076039910316467, -0.056636109948158264, 0.044891130179166794, 0.014708912931382656, -0.04650424048304558, -0.034992534667253494, -0.0218496173620224, -0.010487507097423077, 0.0032691736705601215, 0.04025227576494217, 0.009225969202816486, -0.021888326853513718, 0.08194095641374588, -0.04927976429462433, -0.05403679981827736, -0.05592251941561699, -0.0121720340102911, 0.01074275467544794, -0.00045626837527379394, 0.020607054233551025, 0.016322514042258263, 0.03374756500124931, 0.0008968876209110022, 0.019925221800804138, -0.030337432399392128, -0.006829207297414541, 0.03718430548906326, -0.03460466116666794, 0.006275632418692112, 0.03637678921222687, 0.03430822119116783, -0.004172561690211296, 0.03385380282998085, -0.04796152561903, -0.05217272415757179, 0.021091066300868988, 0.004513865802437067, -0.02982296049594879, -0.016103707253932953, -0.02818477898836136, -0.014707856811583042, -0.039466239511966705, -0.031208790838718414, 0.03305639326572418, -0.0343574658036232, 0.07352005690336227, 0.045633189380168915, 0.01582113839685917, 0.0006698349607177079, 0.005860170349478722, 0.021482961252331734, 0.0163527000695467, -0.012050077319145203, 0.004058632999658585, -0.035057246685028076, -0.003797273151576519, 0.05015922710299492, 0.02558963932096958, -0.02872404269874096, 0.0306304432451725, 0.023664245381951332, -0.004657819867134094, 0.02093416638672352, 0.014337222091853619, -0.013175706379115582, -0.01787620596587658, 0.02308143861591816, 0.021191835403442383, 0.008108656853437424, -0.019344640895724297, -0.003356160596013069, -0.004630676470696926, 0.016693683341145515, -0.023860938847064972, 0.016491588205099106, 0.012951924465596676, 0.0025304146111011505, 0.019979003816843033, -0.02186068706214428, -0.0026149346958845854, -0.0035295092966407537, -0.007073277607560158, 0.019414309412240982, 0.02412373013794422, -0.002439847681671381, 0.024033060297369957, -0.015724102035164833, -0.03559797629714012, 0.028269652277231216, 0.015186327509582043, -0.04617304727435112, -0.02013631910085678, 0.04897669702768326, -0.051989953964948654, -0.027211183682084084, -0.009128655306994915, -0.04383346065878868, -0.05381525680422783, 0.045898936688899994, 0.017550453543663025, -0.021480685099959373, -0.0018427178729325533, -0.0196771789342165, -0.023666515946388245, 0.004823233000934124, -0.013627358712255955, -0.005186507478356361, 0.019962415099143982, -0.023500921204686165, -0.035462021827697754, -0.036991432309150696, -0.017217587679624557, 0.032298848032951355, -0.01127124484628439, 0.007758042775094509, 0.008627348579466343, 0.01340525597333908, -0.008780412375926971, -0.019943829625844955, -0.02471151389181614, -0.009111120365560055, -0.010537415742874146, -0.09479264914989471, 0.045262422412633896, -0.001178145408630371, -0.03073878027498722, 0.04526868090033531, -0.05965055152773857, -0.02329271286725998, -0.005640567280352116, 0.0025477649178355932, 0.06488010287284851, 0.013661677949130535, 0.0006956153665669262, -0.012322290800511837, -0.031275711953639984, -0.003088517114520073, -0.05583634227514267, -0.0784732922911644, 0.010792681947350502, 0.005216910969465971, -0.005304492078721523, -0.0024947531055659056, -0.0003955774300266057, 0.10416919738054276, 0.03706325963139534, 0.0064596571028232574, -0.002542981645092368, 0.017929481342434883, -0.03444031998515129, -0.041434187442064285, -0.0008907668525353074, 0.008259575814008713, 0.026042615994811058, 0.025132067501544952, -0.020415108650922775, 0.0349622406065464, 0.010344326496124268, 0.028227485716342926, -0.04829293116927147, 0.023800279945135117, 0.009126815013587475, 0.01808280684053898, -0.003514401614665985, 0.023580871522426605, -0.0031434549018740654, 0.023669304326176643, 0.0013492953730747104, 0.029990581795573235, 0.03007340244948864, -0.034821514040231705, 0.008984526619315147, -0.022017518058419228, 0.017558880150318146, 0.01536818128079176, 0.041387856006622314, 0.030077045783400536, -0.029028544202446938, -0.05796867981553078, -0.017712173983454704, 0.026087496429681778, -0.020308971405029297, 0.011446824297308922, 0.05536230653524399, 0.007755662780255079, 0.008803279139101505, 0.000641030550468713, -0.01668882742524147, 0.0022675322834402323, 0.039909202605485916, -0.0060020252130925655, -0.019572053104639053, 0.065614253282547, 0.038894109427928925, -0.0026268314104527235, -0.020216163247823715, -0.03869986906647682, 0.00679722661152482, -0.05680345743894577, 0.001961557660251856, -0.033335983753204346, 0.031227106228470802, 0.014350412413477898, 0.002519481349736452, 0.0287834033370018, -0.045394618064165115, -0.001563452067784965, 0.019309474155306816, -0.06540405750274658, 0.04450400173664093, -0.0009129699319601059, -0.015200445428490639, -0.008845136500895023, -0.017685426399111748, 0.047419026494026184, -0.02328784577548504, 0.022523393854498863, -0.013003521598875523, 0.03152041509747505, -0.044080495834350586, -0.0029702852480113506, -0.033019810914993286, -0.0061207967810332775, -0.017884239554405212, 0.029108654707670212, 0.04682820290327072, -0.006398490164428949, 0.017410164698958397, 0.010851029306650162, -0.014131950214505196, -0.019368471577763557, -0.019124725833535194, -0.0014030165039002895, 0.010105631314218044, 0.027844542637467384, 0.02151428535580635, 0.0494353324174881, -0.04121552035212517, 0.023337123915553093, -0.0155918775126338, 0.016271838918328285, 0.025714470073580742, 0.008527840487658978, -0.031023714691400528, -0.02908606454730034, -0.028725646436214447, -0.010138655081391335, 0.04878616705536842, 0.020955177024006844, -0.03325115144252777, 0.0819711983203888, -0.000784139265306294, -0.028246188536286354, 0.011339669115841389, 0.02182222530245781, 0.03357366472482681, -0.002054804004728794, -0.015478689223527908, 0.0304538756608963, -0.017912043258547783, 0.01102514285594225, 0.02540348470211029, 0.0018589169485494494, -0.021092519164085388, -0.039420630782842636, 0.02031782642006874, 0.007087587378919125, -0.011593932285904884, -0.01843312382698059, 0.047651901841163635, 0.03510832414031029, 0.00010776737326523289, -0.020369505509734154, 0.0393642783164978, 0.036849334836006165, 0.0345027856528759, 0.019528353586792946, 0.0343913659453392, -0.09743215143680573, 0.01123964786529541, 0.0743548646569252, 0.03928183391690254, 0.0027402641717344522, -0.0019258998800069094, -0.03428712859749794, 0.018601637333631516, 0.03877100348472595, -0.04516895115375519, -0.00009806255548028275, -0.009710791520774364, 0.03133949637413025, -0.013605872169137001, -0.01921062357723713, -0.07931410521268845, -0.020862270146608353, -0.03809367120265961, 0.0427122600376606, -0.02051372081041336, -0.03532687947154045, -0.050025030970573425, 0.005302943754941225, -0.0024030304048210382, 0.06591054797172546, -0.011383086442947388, -0.030272576957941055, 0.018245941027998924, -0.024371180683374405, 0.011639627628028393, -0.0729081928730011, -0.025444818660616875, -0.009698440320789814, -0.007864827290177345, 0.0391613245010376, -0.02484329789876938, -0.03388655558228493, -0.012313943356275558, 0.0020612480584532022, -0.020465699955821037, 0.027401704341173172, -0.06260976195335388, 0.04164501279592514, 0.027161728590726852, -0.0032776067964732647, 0.0375562384724617, 0.0151473144069314, 0.025934379547834396, -0.0005369203863665462, -0.03227322921156883, 0.02057582698762417, -0.02591758407652378, 0.0017989905318245292, -0.04183114692568779, -0.030539916828274727, 0.003822585567831993, 0.028721123933792114, -0.00008469365275232121, 0.056607671082019806, -0.01338114868849516, -0.0105344383046031, 0.030404571443796158, 0.023120572790503502, 0.01129389088600874, -0.02179938554763794, 0.008737859316170216, 0.007448631804436445, -0.03176778182387352, -0.007583085913211107, -0.010649817995727062, 0.007779435720294714, 0.04387194663286209, 0.029952988028526306, -0.036412108689546585, 0.03538128733634949, -0.03454330936074257, -0.033697519451379776, 0.003070480888709426, -0.02458435297012329, 0.007912652567029, 0.0006928324000909925, 0.018825218081474304, -0.006005456671118736, -0.03452528640627861, -0.010936001315712929, 0.04711727052927017, 0.008457773365080357, 0.05278577655553818, -0.042750127613544464, 0.01883675716817379, -0.04557157680392265, 0.008047779090702534, -0.06258790194988251, -0.04558275267481804, 0.01546940766274929, 0.005540892016142607, -0.026216350495815277, -0.015326796099543571, -0.00420623691752553, -0.010831711813807487, -0.01331847533583641, -0.02114746905863285, 0.054073624312877655, -0.03662052005529404, -0.013430682010948658, -0.019010568037629128, 0.007806628476828337, 0.09986193478107452, -0.019814282655715942, 0.027046041563153267, 0.06982681155204773, 0.005497261881828308, -0.03834958374500275, 0.010090908035635948, 0.00809931755065918, -0.04158729314804077, -0.00042513012886047363, -0.02945171482861042, -0.03148045390844345, 0.011439485475420952, -0.009079976938664913, -0.0019224608549848199, 0.018777284771203995, -0.005461549386382103, 0.008125126361846924, -0.01958394981920719, -0.02591533400118351, -0.03629828244447708, 0.020497331395745277, -0.002382890088483691, -0.0029189761262387037, 0.014983006753027439, -0.0062792482785880566, 0.0078071970492601395, 0.01749873347580433, -0.02161511406302452, -0.00046254770131781697, 0.017060594633221626, 0.007470869924873114, -0.012608234770596027, -0.026845280081033707, -0.03240319713950157, 0.02080254629254341, 0.031553059816360474, 0.0008137415279634297, -0.025221748277544975, 0.07532075047492981, -0.04786225035786629, -0.014385826885700226, -0.04657599329948425, -0.04557035118341446, 0.05380820482969284, -0.022329170256853104, 0.03897484019398689, 0.03916920721530914, -0.008433971554040909, 0.015375403687357903, -0.03314730525016785, 0.00661687646061182, -0.013475382700562477, 0.018837954849004745, 0.031460169702768326, -0.007046418730169535, 0.021735677495598793, 0.00413064518943429, 0.008644393645226955, 0.03147318959236145, 0.02914588712155819, 0.013458939269185066, 0.02513112686574459, 0.026161734014749527, -0.041566796600818634, -0.049506593495607376, 0.03214177116751671, -0.05050981417298317, -0.017396755516529083, -0.02852632664144039, -0.013959524221718311, 0.03599622845649719, 0.017094571143388748, 0.04022595286369324, -0.041300222277641296, -0.03393492102622986, -0.028783543035387993, -0.027794616296887398, -0.001201509265229106, -0.016216345131397247, -0.0026264360640197992, -0.010526617057621479, 0.009055874310433865, 0.01893456093966961, 0.05399371683597565, -0.04179589822888374, -0.09139508754014969, -0.047404929995536804, -0.012816887348890305, 0.0019979511853307486, 0.0008319399203173816, -0.0009214993915520608, -0.0385136753320694, 0.018037961795926094, -0.0458449050784111, 0.02786559797823429, 0.006190839223563671, 0.020761651918292046, -0.04143327847123146, 0.00899752788245678, -0.0037633583415299654, -0.019519684836268425, 0.020382774993777275, -0.017173364758491516, 0.13043980300426483, 0.08476676791906357, 0.0443541593849659, -0.059471625834703445, 0.01551747228950262, -0.04637743905186653, -0.01945795863866806, -0.030135829001665115, 0.0019160963129252195, -0.007197467144578695, -0.012280839495360851, 0.048175472766160965, 0.05412937328219414, 0.00172936893068254, -0.01824977807700634, 0.036723505705595016, -0.04093460366129875, -0.013196193613111973, 0.007458217907696962, 0.02170071378350258, -0.022652732208371162, -0.03459077700972557, 0.0007011286215856671, 0.002311480464413762, -0.011987553909420967, -0.0060172975063323975, -0.029998255893588066, 0.011623884551227093, -0.013128556311130524, -0.0007560107042081654, -0.007594463415443897, 0.009034632705152035, -0.004929279442876577, 0.016662050038576126, 0.007091909181326628, -0.022627266123890877, 0.01652269810438156, -0.017179951071739197, -0.009082122705876827, 0.04741417244076729, 0.004283158108592033, 0.018716804683208466, 0.02365858480334282, 0.02660432644188404, -0.06927510350942612, -0.02033691667020321, -0.0008138615521602333, 0.07640352845191956, 0.02086918242275715, 0.008179736323654652, 0.012732522562146187, -0.013624565675854683, -0.011149927042424679, -0.053344182670116425, -0.07435213774442673, 0.0375756174325943, -0.012906626798212528, -0.0037073709536343813, 0.0000318644852086436, -0.04053010791540146, 0.025182295590639114, 0.019708475098013878, 0.021651016548275948, 0.04375830665230751, -0.03728374466300011, -0.045728620141744614, 0.025773078203201294, 0.05565734952688217, 0.016788659617304802, 0.008115214295685291, 0.02793407440185547, -0.026422692462801933, -0.016206899657845497, 0.006802233401685953, 0.01732523739337921, 0.000056537173804827034, 0.028192132711410522, -0.031251147389411926, 0.012787659652531147, -0.04774435609579086, -0.050419263541698456, 0.007281231693923473, -0.017800647765398026, 0.03898407518863678, -0.06101756915450096, -0.018864706158638, -0.012122643180191517, 0.03448556736111641, 0.02641037479043007, -0.019198887050151825, 0.00551400613039732, 0.09061810374259949, 0.02438187412917614, -0.02645079605281353, -0.012067796662449837, -0.022812724113464355, -0.04888434708118439, 0.03597370535135269, -0.007211908232420683, 0.05432208627462387, 0.013697895221412182, -0.002841922454535961, 0.003167875576764345, 0.028331639245152473, -0.01069582812488079, 0.02164810337126255, 0.017243094742298126, -0.07151760905981064, 0.01664051041007042, -0.011344760656356812, 0.02353796735405922, -0.03871874511241913, -0.012087744660675526, -0.012340579181909561, -0.06143855303525925, 0.024458007887005806, 0.010365224443376064, -0.02384212240576744, 0.026588162407279015, 0.028918543830513954, 0.03526955842971802, -0.02037082239985466, -0.02745453454554081, -0.08726624399423599, -0.02831980027258396, -0.0005974449450150132, -0.028638476505875587, 0.014703621156513691, 0.006461659446358681, -0.02815791219472885, 0.008534198626875877, 0.030217599123716354, -0.015139891766011715, -0.0005318387411534786, -0.022609014064073563, -0.02527277171611786, -0.011054345406591892, 0.05518481507897377, -0.021371353417634964, -0.017408879473805428, 0.05282359570264816, -0.03749043494462967, -0.013760245405137539, 0.037375807762145996, 0.013998332433402538, 0.04522048309445381, 0.007017745636403561, 0.018895931541919708, -0.01757667027413845, 0.018922660499811172, -0.01697409711778164, -0.03637268394231796, -0.0022734503727406263, 0.011289803311228752, -0.014518962241709232, 0.0079668452963233, 0.021787062287330627, 0.00515073724091053, 0.010463692247867584, 0.035155437886714935, 0.0496225506067276, 0.0251787006855011, -0.010041474364697933, -0.014718174934387207, 0.002093719784170389, 0.013136926107108593, -0.013406234793365002, -0.009623488411307335, 0.001398170250467956, 0.012046268209815025, -0.01992531307041645, 0.041986532509326935, -0.004457448609173298, 0.004182101227343082, -0.12099412828683853, -0.05515033379197121, 0.01022383850067854, 0.021747322753071785, 0.013205147348344326, -0.04602097347378731, 0.03781002387404442, 0.017925629392266273, -0.0467546321451664, 0.04358622059226036, -0.027564257383346558, -0.02252211607992649, -0.030573027208447456, -0.012250017374753952, -0.02014368586242199, 0.007083768490701914, 0.0016252913046628237, 0.028645217418670654, 0.04509556293487549, -0.00981670618057251, -0.008440100587904453, -0.014239873737096786, -0.004329113755375147, 0.033911436796188354, -0.004732545465230942, -0.07094436138868332, 0.02318672277033329, -0.01737208105623722, -0.017238739877939224, 0.03471425175666809, -0.013185243122279644, 0.01769757829606533, -0.00017386407125741243, 0.00956382043659687, 0.006281899753957987, 0.06649373471736908, 0.05177495256066322, -0.029507486149668694, 0.001263642800040543, -0.0044002411887049675, -0.001223698491230607, 0.015529143624007702, -0.048841629177331924, 0.02214290015399456, -0.0014170421054586768, -0.027167294174432755, 0.005127982702106237, 0.02471703477203846, 0.00500367721542716, 0.003089827485382557, 0.018811844289302826, 0.015286725014448166, -0.02421286143362522, -0.03442654013633728, 0.015033958479762077, -0.03591924533247948, 0.01795836165547371, 0.026282569393515587, 0.06016911193728447, -0.03452504426240921, 0.011241953819990158, -0.018798891454935074, -0.06695608049631119, -0.003937047906219959, -0.016315465793013573, -0.010803931392729282, -0.06155654415488243, -0.027449604123830795, -0.012888102792203426, -0.019246872514486313, -0.02375519461929798, -0.017419928684830666, -0.03404984250664711, 0.04470735043287277, -0.030759230256080627, 0.03437032178044319, 0.027444718405604362, -0.03738933056592941, 0.015416039153933525, -0.12428689002990723, 0.05199960619211197, -0.014924959279596806, -0.015038099139928818, -0.006792344618588686, 0.013312222436070442, -0.014993446879088879, 0.01705809123814106, 0.07076658308506012, 0.02279285527765751, 0.03448864072561264, -0.03853698447346687, 0.0343003123998642, -0.023413673043251038, -0.029514269903302193, 0.04025837033987045, 0.010996894910931587, 0.03368281200528145, -0.024400247260928154, -0.01940660923719406, 0.034038931131362915, 0.027285005897283554, 0.01079501397907734, 0.029260609298944473, 0.040546026080846786, 0.025347711518406868, -0.007787477690726519, 0.04856588691473007, 0.008886009454727173, 0.014280437491834164, 0.04906689003109932, 0.001542980084195733, 0.03256574645638466, 0.04401746764779091, -0.023900622501969337, -0.04193840175867081, 0.042492594569921494, -0.026854824274778366, -0.040619250386953354, 0.05094491317868233, 0.03975442796945572, -0.0073988176882267, -0.030178852379322052, 0.013411241583526134, 0.03202624246478081, 0.004718252457678318, -0.01357103232294321, 0.000057063665735768154, 0.01810513436794281, 0.02930334024131298, -0.006541329901665449, 0.024008216336369514, 0.018655888736248016, 0.005151886492967606, 0.0032541174441576004, 0.01499203685671091, 0.004180196672677994, -0.0020834344904869795, 0.044980667531490326, 0.017052052542567253, -0.03822413459420204, -0.0026358775794506073, -0.011370419524610043, 0.012064029462635517, -0.026736777275800705, -0.01497355755418539, 0.011198298074305058, 0.0004475602472666651, 0.02985694818198681, -0.04421650990843773, -0.028359821066260338, 0.03331873565912247, -0.03750639781355858, 0.0022739125415682793, -0.041852232068777084, -0.052591174840927124, -0.013062304817140102, 0.02361653745174408, 0.040480177849531174, 0.018835103139281273, 0.03963670879602432, 0.01912510022521019, -0.024732468649744987, 0.01953934133052826, 0.008939964696764946, -0.03130790591239929, 0.026315748691558838, -0.02091456577181816, 0.018486149609088898, -0.01803756318986416, -0.013293133117258549, -0.015263974666595459, -0.0055327932350337505, 0.02592276781797409, 0.07956812530755997, 0.018803313374519348, -0.053915414959192276, -0.0006415998796001077, 0.015125037170946598, 0.01586054265499115, -0.05483267456293106, -0.0074530672281980515, -0.03673619031906128, 0.0010176022769883275, -0.010544192045927048, -0.031774647533893585 ]
<p>I'm doing my PhD in geomechanics. I thought we use a Poisson-Weibull distribution (for the variability of a parameter at the rock), but reading more about the subject I think maybe is a Poisson-Weibull process and I don't know the difference (sorry I'm just a stupid engineer). To complete the problem I'm not too knowledgeable about the language of mathematics, so if you could give me an example it would be awesome!</p>
36,456
[ 0.018773481249809265, -0.054565250873565674, -0.0067877438850700855, -0.05865047872066498, 0.04632724076509476, 0.012134282849729061, 0.05287191644310951, 0.008427215740084648, 0.031612299382686615, 0.015002154745161533, 0.01732441782951355, 0.04416690021753311, 0.04110307618975639, -0.011277244426310062, 0.053203728049993515, 0.02704264596104622, -0.010951703414320946, -0.020555196329951286, -0.023277245461940765, -0.0026275941636413336, 0.007091829553246498, -0.02864915318787098, -0.013912185095250607, -0.019994443282485008, -0.006000134628266096, 0.013861527666449547, 0.03277335688471794, -0.005346929654479027, 0.032987676560878754, 0.037504710257053375, -0.021752476692199707, -0.022751329466700554, 0.016382306814193726, 0.061829257756471634, 0.009011777117848396, 0.006200030446052551, -0.02921275608241558, -0.03500223904848099, -0.0310035552829504, 0.04522505775094032, -0.0432988665997982, -0.0066834683530032635, -0.008671874180436134, 0.007008652202785015, -0.017956575378775597, 0.04715025797486305, 0.020984739065170288, -0.0811765193939209, 0.04636310786008835, -0.03667863830924034, 0.049916092306375504, -0.02157421223819256, 0.05160844698548317, 0.027888644486665726, -0.014283210039138794, -0.004267524927854538, 0.08086955547332764, 0.07316732406616211, 0.0003384556621313095, -0.061164431273937225, -0.02648615837097168, -0.015120535157620907, -0.029302017763257027, -0.05175061151385307, -0.031435687094926834, 0.029602080583572388, -0.028395477682352066, -0.06026444584131241, 0.027046512812376022, 0.004085605964064598, 0.025177055969834328, 0.007454444654285908, 0.07083569467067719, -0.04796411842107773, -0.00001284592417505337, -0.003217486198991537, 0.027599431574344635, -0.001878112554550171, 0.01652071624994278, 0.0034273031633347273, -0.0007837974117137492, -0.011211169883608818, 0.029879814013838768, 0.04150272533297539, 0.003999538253992796, -0.05990104377269745, 0.06371544301509857, -0.01117729116231203, 0.01609005779027939, -0.004352382384240627, -0.04018676280975342, -0.016557378694415092, -0.00034542017965577543, 0.003252615686506033, -0.02904403768479824, 0.018213732168078423, -0.01792515628039837, 0.0457952506840229, 0.004398693796247244, 0.015471689403057098, 0.027349578216671944, -0.05477707460522652, 0.023125434294342995, 0.07023701071739197, -0.029208332300186157, -0.03037117049098015, -0.014939902350306511, 0.009230288676917553, -0.017279136925935745, -0.004474356304854155, -0.02009752206504345, 0.03241725265979767, -0.004571450408548117, -0.0055819787085056305, 0.018274834379553795, 0.0077081467024981976, 0.011841430328786373, -0.016574200242757797, 0.045640937983989716, 0.03779494762420654, 0.05214029178023338, -0.036245524883270264, 0.06211152300238609, -0.07192601263523102, -0.04332802817225456, -0.011325153522193432, 0.02861664816737175, -0.006752213463187218, -0.05802913382649422, 0.04297954589128494, 0.024875419214367867, -0.0015591727569699287, 0.02711300738155842, -0.019180351868271828, 0.05470483377575874, -0.024286989122629166, -0.06327827274799347, -0.04217291623353958, 0.042008694261312485, -0.010014406405389309, 0.0204999428242445, -0.061436690390110016, 0.013324223458766937, 0.028112733736634254, 0.02328317239880562, 0.04255347326397896, 0.02405618317425251, -0.00696745328605175, 0.014849529601633549, -0.008681724779307842, -0.03662078455090523, -0.015860741958022118, 0.029264302924275398, -0.03426090627908707, 0.028814489021897316, -0.11992712318897247, -0.005661388859152794, -0.013084759935736656, 0.005624241661280394, -0.044597651809453964, 0.02871893160045147, -0.009893253445625305, -0.013827734626829624, 0.007391287945210934, 0.0246861781924963, -0.012866484001278877, 0.08183667808771133, -0.0036366041749715805, 0.010649734176695347, 0.006991086062043905, 0.05213817581534386, 0.010062476620078087, 0.04352197423577309, 0.03582070395350456, 0.061875395476818085, -0.024837763980031013, 0.024661781266331673, -0.00960646290332079, 0.007084439042955637, 0.01630331017076969, -0.01087255124002695, 0.0015713130123913288, 0.017717720940709114, 0.014514598064124584, 0.007963575422763824, 0.009394008666276932, 0.007896983996033669, -0.013207396492362022, 0.034982237964868546, -0.006738262716680765, -0.0013796230778098106, -0.04061346873641014, 0.048409003764390945, -0.03757137805223465, 0.011995447799563408, 0.03307009115815163, -0.008141649886965752, -0.019980579614639282, -0.05793718993663788, -0.020834945142269135, -0.0005467715673148632, -0.006395027507096529, -0.002418783726170659, -0.044066157191991806, -0.01909998431801796, 0.03964979201555252, 0.020425057038664818, 0.01330734882503748, 0.060679689049720764, -0.012361629866063595, -0.0160114336758852, -0.0239902101457119, -0.030522823333740234, 0.014164002612233162, -0.019539061933755875, -0.021754052489995956, 0.028823286294937134, 0.01550003420561552, -0.005207518115639687, 0.007574997376650572, -0.042904067784547806, 0.043570637702941895, 0.0825861319899559, 0.013393719680607319, -0.018836913630366325, -0.011824466288089752, -0.033201999962329865, 0.013507062569260597, -0.00580202741548419, -0.04358848184347153, -0.04051794856786728, 0.009848292917013168, 0.03202524408698082, 0.007647012360394001, -0.018546562641859055, 0.004151646047830582, 0.04942392185330391, 0.031373437494039536, 0.03686261549592018, 0.0355905257165432, 0.0038856645114719868, -0.006474669557064772, 0.009602333419024944, 0.04772062227129936, 0.026771437376737595, 0.00042345255496911705, 0.008221023716032505, 0.025136936455965042, 0.02468179352581501, -0.03850770369172096, -0.0014006326673552394, 0.045471567660570145, -0.0275430828332901, 0.027438057586550713, 0.011321501806378365, 0.006510990206152201, 0.05721089616417885, -0.025859128683805466, 0.005018746946007013, 0.05908903852105141, -0.019511204212903976, -0.018716510385274887, -0.0013676360249519348, -0.017143137753009796, 0.02613399550318718, 0.008375772275030613, -0.028167759999632835, -0.009007953107357025, 0.02510382980108261, 0.01376735046505928, 0.0006779817049391568, -0.012146290391683578, -0.029601654037833214, -0.04166470095515251, 0.024019494652748108, 0.04639891907572746, -0.0000654553368804045, 0.026604292914271355, 0.013540898449718952, -0.04555320739746094, -0.00597386434674263, -0.022668667137622833, 0.03779391199350357, 0.019761862233281136, -0.04654332250356674, 0.042562466114759445, -0.005855419207364321, -0.028369149193167686, 0.04091232642531395, -0.007327496074140072, -0.01765347085893154, 0.013476475141942501, -0.007098581176251173, -0.04658186808228493, 0.014821948483586311, -0.02676442451775074, 0.014322665520012379, -0.03833108767867088, 0.008619469590485096, 0.042714279145002365, -0.012346119619905949, -0.013425064273178577, 0.01720007322728634, -0.05295335128903389, -0.04158950224518776, -0.036299172788858414, -0.008620338514447212, 0.01853484846651554, 0.004954637493938208, 0.015630800276994705, 0.06431671977043152, -0.0206623412668705, -0.037357307970523834, -0.04772108420729637, -0.0789196565747261, 0.012714246287941933, -0.041277751326560974, 0.033254750072956085, -0.0243044625967741, -0.04196590557694435, 0.09133681654930115, 0.03734176605939865, -0.030660880729556084, 0.001249954686500132, 0.014454813674092293, -0.020906547084450722, -0.025841040536761284, 0.045942869037389755, -0.005853728391230106, 0.0040284134447574615, 0.04047048091888428, 0.0278055090457201, 0.0302596352994442, 0.03486747667193413, 0.006940767168998718, -0.0007241510902531445, -0.013302255421876907, 0.025482269003987312, 0.011973511427640915, 0.02263856679201126, 0.0021158040035516024, -0.04080025106668472, 0.029716050252318382, -0.02359957993030548, 0.010815542191267014, -0.008192493580281734, -0.059962108731269836, 0.032636016607284546, 0.0030531613156199455, 0.006793933920562267, -0.04274088144302368, 0.01364508643746376, -0.011247892864048481, -0.01651460863649845, 0.027556294575333595, 0.04025812819600105, 0.013869337737560272, -0.036014996469020844, -0.0015007323818281293, 0.02918846532702446, 0.061266954988241196, -0.03215814009308815, -0.018543969839811325, -0.003338955342769623, 0.014447657391428947, 0.0302231777459383, -0.004245338495820761, -0.04849005490541458, 0.04965147748589516, 0.011486801318824291, 0.020745282992720604, -0.01370230596512556, -0.02264920063316822, 0.008499406278133392, -0.09509266912937164, 0.009947755374014378, 0.02465071529150009, 0.0381242036819458, 0.01138465665280819, 0.018363106995821, 0.03220577910542488, 0.002106201834976673, 0.022324275225400925, 0.0012545009376481175, -0.041224513202905655, 0.038719773292541504, -0.02667306177318096, -0.014671003445982933, -0.005117991007864475, -0.022679215297102928, 0.039753567427396774, -0.030088018625974655, -0.009131904691457748, 0.018009642139077187, -0.0015677325427532196, -0.049350306391716, 0.007978556677699089, -0.04653875157237053, -0.02669738046824932, -0.02631715126335621, 0.006254630163311958, 0.009263560175895691, 0.018412429839372635, 0.024307677522301674, 0.04686330631375313, 0.0189075730741024, -0.0024973514955490828, -0.00348153174854815, 0.00013308158668223768, 0.025570888072252274, 0.03190107271075249, 0.00006581929483218119, 0.04386625438928604, -0.02191792242228985, 0.0544290728867054, 0.0023737011943012476, 0.058270588517189026, 0.05156322941184044, 0.008256152272224426, -0.0038774420972913504, -0.053560927510261536, 0.01051015593111515, -0.006104770582169294, 0.0054805525578558445, -0.012933127582073212, -0.014423281885683537, 0.03333886340260506, 0.01605234667658806, -0.05146768316626549, 0.04896196722984314, 0.04338165745139122, 0.008173293434083462, -0.00015502097085118294, -0.03337821736931801, 0.00017968275642488152, 0.00820974726229906, -0.022230155766010284, -0.0034287571907043457, 0.04541024565696716, -0.03528251498937607, 0.02310098335146904, 0.035860978066921234, -0.000021316867787390947, -0.005111267324537039, 0.022409144788980484, -0.009687347337603569, 0.0071083796210587025, 0.008324068039655685, -0.019816741347312927, 0.019365830346941948, 0.01889866217970848, 0.01231822557747364, 0.038275208324193954, -0.01288080308586359, -0.08733245730400085, -0.03157082572579384, 0.029669346287846565, -0.00795161072164774, -0.03672933578491211, -0.033915817737579346, -0.029019339010119438, -0.03775021433830261, 0.0675894170999527, -0.00598895875737071, -0.003248981898650527, 0.010157134383916855, 0.0343962088227272, 0.018814263865351677, -0.0023470039013773203, -0.027387237176299095, 0.048210509121418, -0.015706904232501984, 0.009110013954341412, 0.005351262632757425, -0.0003295980568509549, -0.0318734236061573, 0.013533292338252068, 0.05152016133069992, 0.08295266330242157, 0.021085623651742935, -0.015682779252529144, -0.02787204086780548, 0.01865006610751152, -0.00976848229765892, -0.0680127814412117, 0.010494429618120193, 0.016925696283578873, -0.009315095841884613, 0.033886414021253586, -0.02941688522696495, -0.0552736259996891, 0.029711371287703514, -0.002337240381166339, -0.009242536500096321, 0.009345181286334991, 0.010327770374715328, 0.03902385011315346, 0.05212309584021568, 0.020612088963389397, 0.07208094745874405, 0.025232216343283653, -0.004132493864744902, -0.00937147717922926, -0.042767275124788284, 0.034189119935035706, -0.039401907473802567, -0.02541070245206356, -0.03503961116075516, 0.04112131521105766, -0.012003546580672264, 0.034230660647153854, 0.010871507227420807, 0.019235525280237198, -0.015226992778480053, -0.04529273509979248, 0.014664342626929283, 0.011769633740186691, 0.014894658699631691, 0.007833081297576427, 0.016006864607334137, -0.014268811792135239, 0.01785377599298954, -0.057363178580999374, -0.02287665195763111, 0.0015986320795491338, -0.006930993404239416, -0.005736323539167643, -0.035390835255384445, -0.004324234556406736, -0.04751139134168625, -0.023563599213957787, 0.035722516477108, -0.0390586256980896, 0.04160604253411293, -0.0017210361547768116, 0.04246359318494797, 0.034888509660959244, -0.021796880289912224, -0.01785276271402836, -0.004486069083213806, -0.0025241824332624674, 0.06495646387338638, -0.05302339047193527, 0.022802231833338737, -0.034814707934856415, 0.00763156870380044, -0.10742497444152832, -0.058527614921331406, 0.04627162963151932, -0.004407521802932024, -0.045710306614637375, -0.054184891283512115, -0.006073107477277517, 0.015024629421532154, -0.04061969369649887, -0.007113069295883179, 0.08644069731235504, -0.009054040536284447, 0.003944377414882183, 0.007832949049770832, -0.008442365564405918, 0.07880466431379318, -0.01059724297374487, -0.016858043149113655, 0.018007297068834305, -0.008537180721759796, -0.0072534941136837006, -0.014335207641124725, 0.027843128889799118, -0.04066808149218559, 0.01688060723245144, -0.004606141243129969, -0.014683717861771584, 0.020781641826033592, -0.060656070709228516, 0.002504908014088869, 0.0003071568498853594, 0.04714460298418999, 0.024519560858607292, -0.005023294128477573, 0.01350707933306694, 0.006706454325467348, -0.0044671762734651566, -0.042536117136478424, -0.017277244478464127, -0.011982000432908535, -0.02965397760272026, 0.011816620826721191, 0.026627978309988976, 0.019582949578762054, 0.04801434278488159, 0.07628149539232254, -0.027972234413027763, -0.05029682815074921, -0.0009841735009104013, -0.02563571184873581, -0.011420280672609806, -0.013823604211211205, -0.013932857662439346, 0.010909868404269218, -0.0026474122423678637, -0.0453374981880188, -0.022203778848052025, -0.03681665658950806, -0.004186284262686968, 0.05150918662548065, -0.020411251112818718, 0.03373459354043007, 0.05510878562927246, 0.007573895156383514, -0.003881913609802723, -0.007994059473276138, -0.04654991254210472, -0.00007065712998155504, -0.023836683481931686, 0.05922023952007294, -0.008331934921443462, 0.03596969693899155, 0.01155103836208582, 0.04207828268408775, -0.020258834585547447, 0.05780710279941559, -0.03145560622215271, 0.04006509482860565, 0.019008852541446686, -0.01218481082469225, -0.05153075233101845, 0.06718482822179794, -0.030965937301516533, 0.030375348404049873, -0.018967879936099052, -0.03230662643909454, 0.05935981124639511, 0.022793902084231377, -0.013875359669327736, -0.020280888304114342, -0.0038418311160057783, -0.034626420587301254, 0.02919459156692028, 0.01828383281826973, 0.022374598309397697, 0.01981399394571781, 0.03067029081285, 0.012241216376423836, 0.015547248534858227, 0.014928963035345078, -0.030321229249238968, -0.07867544889450073, 0.005224842578172684, -0.017552757635712624, -0.07865475863218307, 0.01583966054022312, 0.0014733070274814963, -0.017504634335637093, 0.024463683366775513, -0.036864813417196274, 0.006290017161518335, 0.01814466342329979, 0.010771621949970722, -0.006365309003740549, 0.10765067487955093, 0.0399237684905529, 0.01628902181982994, -0.011420657858252525, 0.007984092459082603, 0.1021650955080986, 0.05469926819205284, 0.030078016221523285, -0.03334420174360275, -0.0005452363402582705, -0.026792172342538834, -0.017183754593133926, -0.02984766848385334, 0.03586737811565399, 0.03504015505313873, -0.013550988398492336, 0.04801126569509506, 0.054059892892837524, -0.005163881927728653, -0.021238330751657486, 0.06243586912751198, -0.009381616488099098, -0.0220014825463295, -0.015598460100591183, -0.011132385581731796, -0.016464125365018845, -0.00571822002530098, 0.001426266971975565, 0.029736369848251343, -0.008569600060582161, 0.00991262961179018, -0.009716137312352657, -0.010765418410301208, 0.009690869599580765, 0.032829347997903824, -0.011662445962429047, 0.012273726053535938, 0.004387369379401207, -0.012647539377212524, -0.022449461743235588, -0.00297218537889421, -0.014625046402215958, -0.03771045058965683, 0.019266320392489433, 0.031611472368240356, 0.007962008006870747, -0.002757489215582609, -0.02940770797431469, 0.00800612848252058, -0.03708479925990105, -0.02283407747745514, -0.058556992560625076, 0.014788174070417881, -0.009666111320257187, 0.03870256617665291, -0.0018621085910126567, -0.009058862924575806, 0.001031789812259376, 0.002428264357149601, -0.024060115218162537, -0.01124690193682909, 0.014120419509708881, -0.027685215696692467, -0.032297175377607346, -0.018429795280098915, 0.006082882639020681, 0.0074796914122998714, 0.040876518934965134, 0.038753438740968704, -0.02920358255505562, 0.012834470719099045, -0.013325927779078484, 0.03716767206788063, -0.01901395432651043, -0.02846519462764263, -0.02750043198466301, -0.02621147781610489, -0.03891248255968094, -0.0006791297346353531, -0.011534630320966244, -0.017383556813001633, 0.059526003897190094, -0.032526712864637375, -0.021990995854139328, 0.019366644322872162, -0.015566454268991947, 0.03194423392415047, -0.006956149823963642, -0.017174826934933662, -0.04111934080719948, -0.000887039874214679, 0.019538022577762604, 0.04472726583480835, -0.0000073923856689361855, -0.009305736981332302, -0.037935856729745865, -0.002378657925873995, 0.023215176537632942, -0.05671459808945656, -0.014701942913234234, 0.014833756722509861, -0.030309360474348068, -0.016920728608965874, -0.017330285161733627, 0.01809430494904518, 0.02268344908952713, 0.0119909243658185, -0.0061323801055550575, 0.0079072630032897, -0.020499954000115395, 0.03709546849131584, 0.007181689143180847, -0.04472297430038452, -0.03050496056675911, 0.020381353795528412, -0.018048474565148354, -0.039101894944906235, -0.023757554590702057, -0.007066667545586824, -0.006518383510410786, -0.010031750425696373, 0.01682872883975506, -0.039473164826631546, -0.005080294329673052, -0.030283816158771515, 0.013344093225896358, 0.024310903623700142, 0.025337031111121178, -0.022205356508493423, -0.022984148934483528, 0.051053907722234726, 0.012819015420973301, -0.02403636835515499, -0.005970883183181286, 0.006326178088784218, -0.03884141892194748, 0.009687231853604317, 0.02071596309542656, 0.036430854350328445, 0.021379634737968445, 0.035894621163606644, -0.015456560999155045, 0.0413505993783474, -0.015823213383555412, 0.0035868664272129536, 0.04194631800055504, -0.04016457125544548, -0.05430474132299423, 0.05482534319162369, 0.011396174319088459, 0.016577651724219322, 0.006134030409157276, -0.018132375553250313, -0.00828979630023241, 0.036123547703027725, -0.02780883200466633, -0.03499307483434677, -0.01440478302538395, -0.01846812106668949, -0.03445040434598923, -0.008051533252000809, 0.010666401125490665, -0.0016131300944834948, -0.00476338155567646, 0.002043976681306958, 0.031872719526290894, -0.017910348251461983, -0.004463332239538431, 0.0041833119466900826, -0.041096482425928116, 0.023585455492138863, 0.036378245800733566, 0.008209879510104656, 0.0122348228469491, 0.06113269552588463, -0.026658326387405396, 0.008515235036611557, -0.0039624618366360664, 0.015480424277484417, -0.09170527756214142, -0.047467734664678574, 0.0334034226834774, -0.02673294022679329, 0.03272421658039093, -0.05661378800868988, 0.004500893875956535, 0.03871536627411842, -0.020750975236296654, 0.016970481723546982, -0.04722870886325836, -0.023872779682278633, -0.04249168932437897, -0.012916874140501022, -0.022782782092690468, 0.03749307245016098, -0.0008679805905558169, 0.030444271862506866, 0.027341529726982117, 0.029603464528918266, -0.042156048119068146, 0.01274796947836876, -0.0022291154600679874, 0.02535073645412922, 0.00876003596931696, 0.0031754234805703163, 0.06651492416858673, -0.017702525481581688, -0.02140040695667267, 0.008613751269876957, -0.016196461394429207, -0.014896462671458721, 0.02301260642707348, 0.01686871238052845, 0.0017022646497935057, 0.04057431221008301, 0.026681646704673767, -0.014851277694106102, -0.011772177182137966, 0.022792242467403412, 0.03437868133187294, 0.04792872071266174, -0.03981075435876846, 0.0055314889177680016, 0.01423496101051569, -0.031606972217559814, -0.011307715438306332, 0.04705332592129707, 0.023874733597040176, -0.012239530682563782, 0.0014486873988062143, -0.028476601466536522, 0.025688977912068367, -0.012858717702329159, 0.03688719496130943, -0.03606688603758812, 0.009113126434385777, 0.03791398927569389, -0.0060664815828204155, -0.022468628361821175, 0.02651742659509182, -0.01581556163728237, -0.018678534775972366, -0.04633621498942375, -0.013270492665469646, -0.06054472550749779, -0.05629856511950493, 0.011272933334112167, -0.01855001226067543, -0.0067678894847631454, -0.03412073105573654, -0.02882123738527298, -0.03402514383196831, 0.0593554750084877, -0.0011674193665385246, 0.019184991717338562, 0.022062407806515694, -0.02114260569214821, 0.016370246186852455, -0.08265572041273117, 0.06293745338916779, -0.01818995364010334, -0.03949130326509476, -0.0370677150785923, -0.00035755804856307805, -0.008350370451807976, 0.008162079378962517, 0.04421226307749748, -0.0007051122956909239, -0.015212178230285645, 0.016054119914770126, -0.007450656499713659, 0.01459147222340107, -0.06422066688537598, -0.005751331802457571, -0.015357892028987408, -0.01477913185954094, -0.018747467547655106, 0.010691544972360134, 0.004766505211591721, -0.023522740229964256, 0.02550588548183441, -0.0039194985292851925, 0.016125235706567764, 0.00036826662835665047, -0.030362915247678757, 0.02802109904587269, -0.0022744007874280214, -0.0026741279289126396, 0.07767574489116669, -0.04406009614467621, 0.013916491530835629, -0.013243245892226696, 0.017530974000692368, -0.05275285616517067, 0.05486707016825676, -0.046101074665784836, -0.007306497078388929, -0.011311660520732403, 0.01457988191395998, 0.015555883757770061, -0.07817266881465912, -0.043264590203762054, 0.011606195010244846, -0.05806053802371025, -0.004018639214336872, -0.00609995611011982, 0.029594002291560173, 0.031793512403964996, -0.03006218746304512, -0.012001440860331059, -0.028067834675312042, 0.0101084653288126, 0.0021084886975586414, 0.0034370822831988335, 0.018678098917007446, -0.02081829495728016, 0.020309168845415115, 0.020268095657229424, -0.039286933839321136, 0.019068505614995956, 0.04596306011080742, 0.04640188440680504, -0.029573455452919006, -0.03547057881951332, -0.006529366131871939, -0.023023948073387146, 0.03062352165579796, 0.016474014148116112, -0.02073984406888485, 0.06997745484113693, 0.004742620978504419, -0.001899798633530736, -0.036269910633563995, 0.016804806888103485, -0.008671778254210949, -0.03166428580880165, 0.025128431618213654, 0.014889923855662346, -0.023902704939246178, 0.005889557301998138, -0.010517765767872334, 0.008954823948442936, 0.05104125291109085, -0.04721647873520851, 0.03708748519420624, -0.000059576250350801274, -0.012934387661516666, -0.020004216581583023, -0.023766105994582176, -0.038909316062927246, -0.011493368074297905, 0.027406642213463783, 0.03863294795155525, 0.028192929923534393, 0.013099350966513157, -0.0010091504082083702, -0.023316863924264908, 0.05000349134206772, -0.08123669028282166, 0.0032416207250207663, -0.06561320275068283, 0.0328005813062191, -0.007021499797701836, -0.013028518296778202 ]
<p>I'm given two random sample datasets of sample size n=20, where the first dataset represents the weights of random boys, and second group represents weights of random girls. I need to find the significance level of saying that boys on average weight more than girls.<br> To solve this problem I'm assuming that the null hypothesis of saying that boys weight the same as girls (no difference) is true, and building a sampling distribution of <strong>differences</strong> of weights between boys and girls with the mean difference of 0 (since I'm assuming that there is no difference in general).<br> I've calculated the standard deviation for this sampling distribution and I know the <strong>difference</strong> of mean weights of two <strong>sample</strong> datasets (which is supposedly a part of this sampling distribution).<br> Now if I divide the difference of sample means by standard deviation of this sampling distribution what value do I get? Is that a t-value? How do I find the significance level from that?</p>
73,909
[ -0.04396717995405197, -0.04504123702645302, -0.004267740994691849, -0.021893728524446487, 0.002603718312457204, 0.03072582185268402, 0.015061240643262863, -0.036966390907764435, 0.0048681278713047504, -0.011666383594274521, 0.03323309123516083, 0.042390353977680206, 0.06956787407398224, 0.036434710025787354, 0.03511645644903183, -0.0040004621259868145, -0.01800934225320816, 0.004585999995470047, 0.013484951108694077, -0.010638494975864887, -0.011541284620761871, 0.01922672428190708, -0.009326055645942688, -0.01688665896654129, -0.04423533007502556, 0.04577942192554474, 0.04515884816646576, -0.03326256945729256, -0.004395165015012026, 0.0348859466612339, -0.07055414468050003, -0.018568651750683784, 0.03336651623249054, 0.005983360111713409, 0.025571979582309723, -0.01913997158408165, -0.03679132089018822, -0.005223920103162527, -0.011440090835094452, 0.012816413305699825, -0.03719779849052429, -0.007440937217324972, 0.009361762553453445, 0.032519713044166565, 0.0013322429731488228, 0.016551582142710686, -0.003274676389992237, -0.03664321079850197, 0.02333001047372818, -0.057598792016506195, 0.059847474098205566, -0.001440643216483295, 0.033525966107845306, 0.0303847324103117, -0.026862291619181633, -0.015994967892766, 0.02685577981173992, 0.02730182744562626, 0.00227804621681571, -0.05581536144018173, -0.0056281983852386475, -0.017453955486416817, 0.0004246977041475475, -0.0019741461146622896, -0.02294454723596573, -0.012910908088088036, -0.05276910215616226, -0.03725501894950867, 0.043324053287506104, -0.012358656153082848, 0.024474797770380974, 0.04891383647918701, 0.04667169973254204, -0.000007421579539368395, -0.014582258649170399, -0.03370291739702225, 0.03556423634290695, -0.008098473772406578, 0.05361073836684227, 0.05213310942053795, 0.005916370544582605, 0.026592666283249855, 0.04262968897819519, 0.06237561255693436, -0.0090447086840868, -0.006348755676299334, 0.048576243221759796, 0.024874810129404068, 0.006061511114239693, 0.013202346861362457, -0.02278771810233593, -0.016887644305825233, 0.029215658083558083, -0.016324803233146667, -0.04017103835940361, 0.011256858706474304, -0.019349226728081703, 0.03458699211478233, 0.004260961432009935, -0.021448511630296707, 0.0022536928299814463, -0.05341942980885506, 0.057944830507040024, 0.06967844069004059, -0.02369542419910431, 0.002446854254230857, -0.0052710846066474915, -0.005996287800371647, -0.026209594681859016, -0.013210724107921124, -0.0014367853291332722, 0.02394336275756359, 0.010069929994642735, -0.015043802559375763, 0.01782212033867836, -0.009587230160832405, 0.014173051342368126, 0.0018228442640975118, 0.06677477061748505, 0.03891480714082718, 0.07004795223474503, -0.013779583387076855, 0.008134602569043636, 0.009478472173213959, -0.05105002969503403, 0.031669847667217255, 0.01052094902843237, -0.022675098851323128, -0.02231096848845482, 0.060061149299144745, -0.019408270716667175, 0.006733651272952557, 0.017200537025928497, -0.03603014722466469, 0.016095774248242378, -0.017781846225261688, -0.060329921543598175, -0.06737952679395676, 0.02518368884921074, -0.01868325285613537, -0.016276057809591293, -0.04089606553316116, -0.013046348467469215, 0.041473060846328735, 0.026688750833272934, 0.020304588600993156, 0.031150124967098236, -0.031181270256638527, 0.025820335373282433, 0.014619271270930767, 0.007188620511442423, -0.008684767410159111, -0.001889703911729157, 0.000984924379736185, -0.007827429100871086, -0.0895375981926918, 0.002285460475832224, 0.013911630026996136, -0.013018451631069183, -0.020255018025636673, 0.0058572543784976006, -0.03559046983718872, -0.02528860792517662, 0.012861466966569424, 0.03009253926575184, -0.01030485238879919, 0.04588887467980385, 0.02673734351992607, 0.024299152195453644, 0.006369912531226873, -0.015097161754965782, 0.01414653193205595, 0.01436737272888422, 0.04202873259782791, 0.01061256043612957, -0.0020555497612804174, -0.017111849039793015, -0.02559792436659336, 0.029250118881464005, -0.00805477425456047, -0.015972454100847244, -0.014916310086846352, -0.02989250421524048, -0.011185825802385807, 0.024370655417442322, -0.006674515549093485, 0.013960822485387325, 0.006469912361353636, 0.016122518107295036, -0.032885655760765076, -0.0672050192952156, -0.08698371797800064, -0.0238807313144207, -0.04299171641469002, -0.025740738958120346, -0.005680285859853029, 0.027234578505158424, 0.04583192989230156, -0.049238674342632294, 0.017400473356246948, -0.01500572357326746, -0.014422457665205002, -0.005809534806758165, -0.045988570898771286, 0.012745322659611702, 0.03887603059411049, 0.0449928343296051, -0.032294344156980515, 0.07697037607431412, -0.052606094628572464, -0.04123004153370857, 0.022188300266861916, -0.056556202471256256, -0.020085830241441727, 0.013898921199142933, 0.0026496085338294506, 0.011375448666512966, -0.02372591570019722, -0.016294121742248535, 0.027486102655529976, -0.051767393946647644, 0.09014467895030975, 0.06758316606283188, 0.0037345080636441708, -0.021227480843663216, 0.016703713685274124, 0.014758870005607605, 0.021855857223272324, 0.006684149149805307, 0.0009194743470288813, -0.06126214191317558, -0.017270946875214577, 0.011710898019373417, 0.013624063692986965, -0.03587065264582634, 0.004479590803384781, 0.061410289257764816, -0.00740706454962492, 0.028703132644295692, 0.03158910572528839, -0.010393539443612099, -0.013206315226852894, 0.012520760297775269, 0.008733867667615414, 0.016279280185699463, 0.045503973960876465, 0.00835435837507248, 0.024641621857881546, 0.05704357847571373, 0.03418605029582977, -0.015050285495817661, 0.03568341210484505, 0.012006833218038082, 0.006697220262140036, -0.005221156403422356, -0.027441633865237236, 0.040144700556993484, -0.036341384053230286, -0.0034683109261095524, 0.0277491994202137, 0.004714187700301409, 0.004452280234545469, 0.00377409509383142, -0.05325961485505104, 0.005910462699830532, 0.022972051054239273, 0.02129492163658142, 0.043274737894535065, 0.012352420948445797, -0.027688270434737206, -0.0011404386023059487, 0.0018663976807147264, -0.03710499405860901, -0.03055400587618351, -0.018479928374290466, 0.003149050520732999, -0.005829674191772938, 0.006116398610174656, -0.0213614609092474, -0.014656489714980125, -0.020131491124629974, -0.012008735910058022, -0.019266171380877495, -0.013785175047814846, -0.07459035515785217, 0.034681133925914764, -0.010444431565701962, -0.03632216155529022, 0.022389210760593414, -0.0019388407235965133, 0.009713884443044662, 0.053007155656814575, -0.01625969633460045, -0.019442545250058174, 0.0029447320848703384, -0.02221975103020668, 0.019806087017059326, -0.03444564342498779, 0.006276539992541075, 0.03405025601387024, -0.026894696056842804, -0.021531784906983376, 0.024695083498954773, -0.020080389454960823, -0.0313686840236187, -0.04653408005833626, 0.027934135869145393, 0.01868678256869316, 0.010531384497880936, -0.01842794008553028, 0.029973730444908142, -0.04562385752797127, -0.01743132248520851, -0.05277746543288231, -0.03900408372282982, 0.029924163594841957, 0.01393071748316288, 0.03988490626215935, 0.003626973368227482, -0.018107887357473373, 0.08437781780958176, 0.039293352514505386, -0.007300043012946844, -0.04974539577960968, 0.00009461640001973137, -0.024960998445749283, -0.004641390405595303, 0.03150700405240059, 0.004942458122968674, 0.0033296234905719757, -0.009047512896358967, 0.008875315077602863, 0.029666196554899216, 0.05863966420292854, -0.007376438472419977, -0.013685988262295723, -0.0023285856004804373, 0.008944987319409847, -0.006409888155758381, 0.05349180847406387, 0.007150602992624044, -0.05511455982923508, 0.00506665138527751, 0.0002716040180530399, 0.01661485806107521, 0.012344282120466232, -0.014760133810341358, 0.00707412650808692, 0.009023014456033707, -0.013824881985783577, -0.03938467428088188, 0.05667530745267868, 0.014566310681402683, -0.03324100747704506, 0.01852070912718773, 0.008336418308317661, 0.019763262942433357, -0.04548066854476929, -0.018518904224038124, 0.07025311142206192, 0.05186556652188301, -0.03518214076757431, -0.04990817978978157, -0.019036024808883667, -0.011700390838086605, 0.005820438731461763, -0.04810842499136925, -0.028668507933616638, 0.03807666152715683, 0.056644272059202194, 0.030426912009716034, -0.0006521866889670491, -0.06932028383016586, 0.014449850656092167, -0.05160461366176605, 0.03540174663066864, -0.014597090892493725, 0.05646542087197304, -0.022117074579000473, 0.08376328647136688, 0.010950395837426186, 0.040789246559143066, 0.019464097917079926, -0.026318760588765144, -0.04299972206354141, 0.07036302238702774, -0.03806516155600548, -0.020280154421925545, 0.05463581159710884, -0.011136659421026707, 0.004006348084658384, -0.00999439973384142, 0.049204275012016296, -0.007430307101458311, 0.026844173669815063, -0.011186625808477402, 0.013836453668773174, -0.02471679449081421, 0.006187664810568094, 0.015480320900678635, 0.021905863657593727, 0.010780100710690022, -0.04603586718440056, 0.025890743359923363, 0.03344947099685669, -0.03796534985303879, -0.0174336526542902, -0.06522287428379059, 0.018541593104600906, 0.01722894422709942, 0.07523684203624725, 0.05498373135924339, 0.055737514048814774, -0.03538871929049492, -0.013826515525579453, -0.005552793387323618, 0.0603485144674778, 0.03385475277900696, -0.005131856072694063, -0.015895279124379158, -0.011594492942094803, -0.022205470129847527, -0.019262956455349922, 0.014305843971669674, -0.03928084298968315, -0.008525517769157887, 0.0451497882604599, 0.022782180458307266, -0.045685552060604095, 0.04345904663205147, 0.04584033042192459, 0.036141227930784225, 0.001654230523854494, -0.03759273886680603, -0.025785617530345917, -0.062067486345767975, -0.022475091740489006, 0.038422826677560806, 0.000947645225096494, 0.012190751731395721, 0.009612256661057472, 0.03756162151694298, -0.0019938377663493156, -0.05112031474709511, 0.0038712022360414267, -0.0026782460045069456, 0.0274208951741457, 0.013139246962964535, -0.024995677173137665, 0.008446170948445797, 0.015470325015485287, 0.01590570993721485, 0.010154091753065586, 0.018109627068042755, -0.061769887804985046, -0.013568229973316193, 0.03274322301149368, 0.033731020987033844, -0.051271770149469376, 0.0032843537628650665, -0.009229798801243305, 0.015098238363862038, 0.06033160164952278, -0.030358092859387398, -0.006302273366600275, -0.011602547951042652, 0.029554398730397224, -0.014701560139656067, 0.02652548998594284, -0.03211124241352081, 0.003478879574686289, -0.051724087446928024, 0.036137886345386505, -0.005819728597998619, -0.05176803842186928, -0.06895114481449127, 0.008078250102698803, 0.017866259440779686, 0.04620831459760666, -0.060322679579257965, -0.029269596561789513, -0.0009360790136270225, 0.009420983493328094, -0.003567710518836975, -0.07368212938308716, -0.00824316218495369, 0.009843312203884125, 0.00579717056825757, 0.07535535842180252, -0.00440734950825572, -0.04052544757723808, 0.041392575949430466, 0.007596591953188181, -0.039033304899930954, -0.004685673862695694, -0.019528361037373543, 0.04698612168431282, 0.043454669415950775, 0.016565579921007156, 0.047773055732250214, -0.004647159017622471, 0.02087313123047352, 0.01892927661538124, -0.03676176443696022, 0.02286745049059391, -0.011196759529411793, -0.005826305132359266, -0.06567851454019547, -0.019856750965118408, -0.03629632666707039, 0.022405613213777542, 0.013336488977074623, 0.0067078606225550175, -0.014523922465741634, -0.0064098588190972805, 0.013213815167546272, 0.03653257340192795, 0.02812381647527218, 0.008756609633564949, -0.00837057363241911, -0.00260088755749166, -0.0005445752758532763, -0.02582256868481636, 0.014332935214042664, -0.012438981793820858, 0.012229851447045803, -0.0002870904572773725, -0.047202177345752716, 0.033432260155677795, -0.03632114827632904, -0.009521332569420338, 0.02359323389828205, -0.031548094004392624, 0.012786773964762688, -0.012804683297872543, 0.046917710453271866, -0.009496414102613926, -0.030184071511030197, -0.015038909390568733, 0.03017396666109562, 0.03425892814993858, 0.02576160989701748, -0.04829198867082596, 0.059233516454696655, 0.014713972806930542, -0.001695239101536572, -0.06993713974952698, -0.0037063350901007652, 0.008788594044744968, 0.040257010608911514, -0.042123958468437195, -0.02832651324570179, -0.010535933077335358, 0.010175737552344799, -0.0044166031293570995, 0.01772558130323887, 0.0698670819401741, 0.009169959463179111, -0.03459522873163223, 0.007874777540564537, -0.013476246036589146, 0.08287882804870605, -0.01795036718249321, 0.00087072973838076, -0.03387117758393288, -0.00610560504719615, -0.02523314580321312, 0.01805805042386055, 0.01203964650630951, -0.02929253876209259, -0.020207319408655167, -0.02518928237259388, 0.0215722918510437, 0.04803333431482315, -0.013656374998390675, -0.009154094383120537, 0.008844527415931225, -0.01738227903842926, 0.02375900000333786, -0.04770845174789429, 0.017669687047600746, -0.024702243506908417, 0.014438290148973465, -0.0378946028649807, 0.003015076508745551, -0.01868680864572525, -0.0076089054346084595, 0.039253395050764084, 0.0192161425948143, -0.02504347264766693, -0.0023767519742250443, 0.052007608115673065, -0.028868913650512695, -0.017669223248958588, -0.025429630652070045, -0.03797976300120354, 0.04261323809623718, -0.009739130735397339, -0.03198240324854851, 0.020653367042541504, 0.016449714079499245, -0.030518045648932457, 0.004705426748842001, -0.0548466295003891, 0.0049911686219275, 0.07496359199285507, -0.009226663038134575, 0.04925943911075592, 0.033423811197280884, -0.0008933457429520786, 0.016718758270144463, -0.03386105224490166, -0.022033758461475372, -0.00013553648022934794, 0.015435485169291496, 0.018962351605296135, -0.008633926510810852, 0.012692145071923733, 0.048473767936229706, 0.018041560426354408, 0.015215305611491203, 0.05259716510772705, 0.05619101971387863, -0.02432709001004696, 0.041649170219898224, -0.033610910177230835, -0.040133003145456314, 0.04126689210534096, -0.017284754663705826, 0.018386593088507652, -0.029143719002604485, -0.007832100614905357, 0.047304898500442505, 0.02038227580487728, 0.007617267780005932, -0.04591171443462372, -0.048089344054460526, -0.0574873685836792, -0.011815526522696018, 0.0345601886510849, -0.02875416912138462, 0.022252226248383522, 0.03496946766972542, 0.01569708250463009, -0.024878213182091713, 0.015525241382420063, -0.0710185244679451, -0.06004492938518524, -0.04215578734874725, -0.03681381419301033, -0.03751419857144356, 0.01986205019056797, -0.019004281610250473, -0.0047417073510587215, 0.03212813287973404, -0.04955357313156128, 0.060923896729946136, 0.024469643831253052, 0.02955329418182373, -0.0273818988353014, 0.04602108895778656, -0.005490121431648731, 0.03766810894012451, 0.03601521998643875, -0.03411554917693138, 0.1054791659116745, 0.025351207703351974, 0.01910003274679184, -0.043320510536432266, 0.01583610288798809, -0.011619451455771923, -0.024560831487178802, 0.006343513261526823, -0.036254383623600006, 0.017801962792873383, 0.014467977918684483, 0.0381380058825016, 0.061128463596105576, 0.013697642832994461, -0.011073964647948742, 0.06616474688053131, -0.04091623052954674, -0.03085312806069851, 0.004238226916640997, 0.030444730073213577, -0.00808960571885109, -0.044563792645931244, -0.044433966279029846, 0.014029521495103836, -0.002040890511125326, 0.0047532920725643635, -0.04050895944237709, 0.005787868518382311, -0.023211272433400154, -0.01915578357875347, -0.044673770666122437, 0.012342135421931744, 0.00021926482440903783, 0.018477199599146843, -0.026162242516875267, -0.0076367212459445, 0.011666491627693176, -0.02292659692466259, 0.021840030327439308, 0.03458500653505325, -0.005708782933652401, 0.012477199546992779, -0.006239743437618017, 0.021541917696595192, -0.052123237401247025, -0.0559249073266983, -0.012524129822850227, 0.03826518356800079, -0.012415221892297268, -0.03284582868218422, 0.0029695474077016115, 0.0232178196310997, -0.0016903369687497616, -0.006375497672706842, 0.019998585805296898, 0.00013656431110575795, 0.01715330220758915, -0.048968374729156494, -0.0016852549742907286, -0.028778165578842163, 0.024254340678453445, -0.009580333717167377, 0.020213207229971886, 0.042537931352853775, -0.014529295265674591, -0.02807171456515789, -0.003070925595238805, 0.038946304470300674, -0.002544596791267395, -0.03645998239517212, 0.003561965888366103, -0.012718256562948227, 0.010404000990092754, 0.018166158348321915, -0.006893882993608713, 0.001817460055463016, 0.01567663438618183, 0.006849576253443956, -0.015203011222183704, -0.015784893184900284, -0.017350327223539352, 0.018753018230199814, -0.04071062430739403, -0.0056525543332099915, -0.010836377739906311, 0.010139590129256248, -0.0067170290276408195, 0.04975670203566551, 0.04525608941912651, 0.01383038517087698, 0.04137063026428223, 0.047478947788476944, 0.026506468653678894, -0.07129136472940445, -0.020491167902946472, -0.0033302183728665113, -0.02844354882836342, -0.0003738317172974348, 0.02685091644525528, 0.05314251780509949, 0.02568870410323143, 0.04687843844294548, -0.0024122013710439205, -0.008769928477704525, -0.023189377039670944, -0.009089005179703236, -0.05280065909028053, -0.042343124747276306, 0.004377932287752628, 0.04952991008758545, -0.017602579668164253, -0.03225083649158478, 0.0020720039028674364, -0.0427948497235775, -0.033163826912641525, 0.0068520414642989635, -0.006985609885305166, -0.025859791785478592, -0.027396200224757195, -0.017828920856118202, 0.024781379848718643, -0.033362820744514465, 0.017512885853648186, -0.02140939049422741, -0.025516752153635025, 0.04548290744423866, 0.02001357451081276, -0.031300950795412064, 0.011779602617025375, -0.014647027477622032, -0.0003126511292066425, 0.02442862093448639, -0.0010127652203664184, 0.030934877693653107, 0.02258036471903324, 0.004853792022913694, 0.00045273060095496476, 0.030519502237439156, 0.0174985621124506, -0.002163872355595231, 0.07384749501943588, -0.052101265639066696, -0.0066954270005226135, 0.05176630616188049, 0.002107652137055993, 0.03639091178774834, 0.0015629914123564959, -0.01711851917207241, 0.013767239637672901, 0.035080306231975555, -0.031857214868068695, -0.005283250007778406, -0.02115974761545658, -0.01603109948337078, -0.008528116159141064, -0.0076798065565526485, 0.006814504973590374, 0.020582208409905434, 0.007304677739739418, 0.015206811018288136, 0.03136778250336647, -0.010919935069978237, 0.013382384553551674, 0.0014443363761529326, 0.03191738203167915, 0.019831378012895584, -0.007393073756247759, -0.0033123965840786695, 0.03993730992078781, 0.08539849519729614, -0.020491207018494606, 0.01428306009620428, -0.013285092078149319, 0.006779709365218878, -0.11034747213125229, -0.004133458249270916, -0.00033359829103574157, -0.023853328078985214, 0.04749685153365135, -0.05344269052147865, 0.05613970384001732, 0.02486255392432213, -0.03740868717432022, 0.011800264939665794, -0.021113554015755653, -0.0048907664604485035, 0.002052091294899583, 0.020520903170108795, -0.014615174382925034, 0.018979942426085472, -0.004278584849089384, 0.04678288847208023, 0.02361580915749073, 0.02579409070312977, 0.026272282004356384, -0.015131011605262756, -0.034930355846881866, -0.010612216778099537, 0.017237981781363487, -0.0715269148349762, 0.00732061080634594, -0.03002871572971344, -0.034361306577920914, 0.03716878220438957, -0.024029741063714027, 0.011013154871761799, 0.011195442639291286, 0.0040980237536132336, -0.006406921427696943, 0.05095682293176651, -0.0009844581363722682, -0.009484292939305305, -0.015277286991477013, 0.019452877342700958, -0.006429264321923256, 0.03407735750079155, -0.049485694617033005, -0.03204752132296562, 0.03566427528858185, -0.034005653113126755, 0.015081091783940792, 0.003912640735507011, -0.008638854138553143, -0.028398605063557625, 0.012157334946095943, -0.032054461538791656, 0.0014762216014787555, -0.045084621757268906, 0.02763092704117298, -0.034135110676288605, -0.00008486580918543041, 0.014365083537995815, 0.03760981559753418, -0.056250181049108505, 0.028082389384508133, -0.021305609494447708, -0.06465689837932587, -0.04335746541619301, 0.00009583460632711649, -0.04819541424512863, -0.04225628077983856, 0.0002416014322079718, -0.017983930185437202, 0.04302014783024788, -0.02312758006155491, -0.01025342009961605, -0.044975314289331436, 0.025115326046943665, -0.02712695114314556, 0.04030595347285271, 0.008700217120349407, -0.00323357991874218, 0.01769223064184189, -0.09132353216409683, 0.06024152785539627, 0.034507907927036285, -0.007362292613834143, -0.034000005573034286, 0.015620570629835129, -0.047031302005052567, 0.04084330424666405, 0.0597924143075943, 0.0545501634478569, 0.020434534177184105, 0.0070165181532502174, 0.029354816302657127, -0.003934336360543966, -0.06996971368789673, 0.041546232998371124, -0.005225752014666796, -0.04001691937446594, 0.0016115009784698486, -0.009966918267309666, 0.008845163509249687, 0.014719490893185139, -0.003837245050817728, -0.017000455409288406, -0.00027990550734102726, -0.001841429970227182, 0.029913371428847313, 0.035327568650245667, 0.018756913021206856, -0.02729005552828312, 0.03494499251246452, 0.006210135295987129, -0.011083466000854969, -0.0006547211087308824, 0.027755647897720337, -0.032726868987083435, 0.07001043856143951, -0.02067943662405014, -0.0040735527873039246, 0.02817274071276188, 0.02567114308476448, -0.003768992144614458, -0.061665136367082596, -0.02113995887339115, 0.0224550049751997, 0.0000021475930225278717, 0.011169344186782837, 0.014273060485720634, 0.04759140685200691, 0.015304217115044594, 0.011527059599757195, 0.0035825103987008333, -0.019717296585440636, -0.038323573768138885, 0.05137911066412926, 0.026337288320064545, 0.005710326600819826, 0.00004648380127036944, 0.015925060957670212, 0.010442710481584072, -0.014335456304252148, 0.006734139285981655, 0.00823158584535122, 0.019761910662055016, 0.009824260137975216, -0.0770537257194519, 0.002296449849382043, 0.021463152021169662, 0.009923954494297504, 0.0000446376834588591, -0.005471026059240103, 0.0936654657125473, -0.0006203786469995975, -0.006913752760738134, -0.0213320292532444, 0.009182082489132881, -0.012985642068088055, -0.012113447301089764, 0.02998357266187668, 0.015643881633877754, 0.004303257912397385, 0.03283237665891647, -0.015034541487693787, -0.023975633084774017, 0.026521097868680954, -0.038151197135448456, 0.0409732386469841, -0.020095596089959145, -0.008675778284668922, -0.029903016984462738, -0.026292013004422188, -0.048878468573093414, 0.01616077870130539, 0.054570987820625305, 0.02902977541089058, 0.024632055312395096, 0.0060075148940086365, -0.024707572534680367, 0.022173553705215454, 0.021818136796355247, -0.05817648023366928, -0.042002275586128235, -0.03685203939676285, -0.011762970127165318, -0.0006978670717217028, -0.06688771396875381 ]
<p>I have a data set of repeated observations and I am trying to determine if any of the observations are outliers. The research I've done has only shown methods that would determine if one value (maximum, minimum, or one questioned value) is an outlier, or if both the highest and lowest value are outliers. What I would like to be able show is if multiple values throughout the data set are outliers, as I suspect, without knowing exactly how many outliers are present. Any help or direction you could give me would be much appreciated. </p>
73,910
[ -0.03591862693428993, 0.008565795607864857, 0.0005497846868820488, 0.02345157414674759, 0.03135497123003006, 0.0030054585076868534, 0.040282197296619415, -0.0199244637042284, 0.004176441580057144, -0.03595130518078804, 0.03400709480047226, 0.03331264480948448, 0.032361406832933426, 0.014253622852265835, 0.02592092752456665, -0.01645001210272312, -0.049386896193027496, 0.006651910021901131, 0.01625847816467285, -0.007492057513445616, 0.0009580753976479173, 0.0028227809816598892, 0.04248620942234993, -0.01744564063847065, -0.03934488445520401, 0.021229125559329987, 0.04501945897936821, -0.011830476112663746, 0.05354991927742958, 0.042368099093437195, -0.03633556142449379, -0.021108707413077354, 0.034487731754779816, 0.03385906666517258, 0.038633521646261215, -0.005270812194794416, -0.02404104359447956, 0.01760970614850521, -0.032762933522462845, 0.02446908876299858, -0.011640284210443497, -0.021861892193555832, 0.012919527478516102, 0.03295833617448807, -0.014214315451681614, -0.027304047718644142, 0.005869103129953146, -0.03464457765221596, 0.03797750547528267, -0.06823218613862991, 0.1249626949429512, -0.011454359628260136, 0.03653790056705475, 0.034837543964385986, -0.002968945074826479, 0.018670635297894478, 0.05913862586021423, 0.06988149136304855, -0.0030651914421468973, -0.05373436585068703, -0.03457653522491455, -0.011952846311032772, -0.004113221541047096, -0.008870869874954224, -0.06701979786157608, 0.046906109899282455, -0.03608252480626106, -0.024733830243349075, 0.020390748977661133, 0.0046590291894972324, -0.008763715624809265, 0.010481182485818863, 0.048436205834150314, -0.011649306863546371, -0.0081718098372221, -0.034357473254203796, 0.008529359474778175, 0.018993234261870384, 0.04913906380534172, 0.04136424511671066, 0.022117890417575836, 0.017132431268692017, 0.0014142079744488, 0.024410635232925415, 0.03391079977154732, -0.03380174934864044, 0.06545602530241013, -0.03427613154053688, 0.016441183164715767, 0.02630145102739334, -0.032286811619997025, -0.015486961230635643, 0.018800731748342514, 0.028720790520310402, -0.07447583973407745, 0.0045746187679469585, -0.017688320949673653, 0.04003916680812836, -0.029734494164586067, -0.004207006189972162, 0.03059583343565464, -0.01389469113200903, 0.02420027181506157, 0.04589982330799103, -0.042260874062776566, -0.004268126096576452, -0.027346881106495857, -0.0018149748211726546, 0.012127600610256195, -0.00993647612631321, -0.005316567607223988, 0.012339919805526733, 0.027627525851130486, -0.016162987798452377, 0.039576079696416855, 0.014811057597398758, 0.0007357902359217405, -0.028076279908418655, 0.00263262283988297, 0.06380904465913773, 0.021675802767276764, -0.02586604841053486, 0.01924857497215271, -0.028910698369145393, -0.026313455775380135, 0.013176141306757927, 0.011173494160175323, 0.007080781273543835, -0.04463554173707962, 0.06884032487869263, -0.024127274751663208, -0.007756975479424, 0.025531675666570663, -0.02124992199242115, 0.06872650980949402, -0.014952262863516808, -0.08144089579582214, -0.05767480656504631, 0.021288245916366577, -0.011052340269088745, -0.010471787303686142, -0.056278157979249954, -0.007756585255265236, 0.027424201369285583, 0.00922329816967249, 0.03473358973860741, 0.018055999651551247, 0.02781006507575512, 0.01435303594917059, 0.021142667159438133, -0.021782800555229187, -0.00030729235731996596, -0.004335654899477959, -0.03516790270805359, 0.0019556889310479164, -0.08883371204137802, -0.00008130334026645869, 0.004432092886418104, -0.025000566616654396, -0.02570362575352192, 0.022529002279043198, -0.007357623893767595, -0.003754713572561741, -0.01760617084801197, 0.030733920633792877, 0.012821224518120289, 0.08210883289575577, -0.015478134155273438, 0.0320015475153923, 0.036366939544677734, -0.005573759321123362, 0.02545618824660778, 0.030549075454473495, 0.04270577058196068, 0.058775272220373154, 0.004331584554165602, -0.025683211162686348, -0.02572820708155632, 0.03553922474384308, 0.01063943188637495, -0.03678588941693306, -0.026784420013427734, -0.0016640014946460724, 0.00015751058526802808, 0.012787499465048313, 0.03630984202027321, -0.011210646480321884, -0.05734570696949959, 0.039551787078380585, -0.04966632276773453, -0.006656545680016279, -0.05438441410660744, 0.013899696059525013, -0.039211489260196686, -0.03886149078607559, 0.019350100308656693, 0.03506912291049957, 0.01997692510485649, -0.04383934289216995, -0.009450025856494904, -0.026433046907186508, -0.0000449557883257512, 0.04278639331459999, -0.06880223751068115, 0.003802187042310834, 0.01090995129197836, 0.022740215063095093, -0.0010200717952102423, 0.049202095717191696, -0.04945990815758705, -0.02694811299443245, 0.00853669922798872, -0.05681325122714043, -0.01825227588415146, 0.004285036586225033, 0.0015190421836450696, 0.03363962844014168, -0.0035081200767308474, -0.010124248452484608, 0.01626194640994072, -0.035103581845760345, 0.06392724812030792, 0.03507362678647041, 0.01653471775352955, -0.03383805230259895, -0.03309252858161926, 0.0025786040350794792, -0.020188603550195694, -0.02243874967098236, -0.027712669223546982, -0.06474284827709198, -0.007711913902312517, 0.026920104399323463, 0.0198281928896904, -0.055070094764232635, 0.022524219006299973, 0.0678502693772316, 0.024023329839110374, 0.016411833465099335, 0.04179207608103752, -0.02005172148346901, -0.008956636302173138, 0.004595616366714239, 0.030024869367480278, 0.011515532620251179, 0.01684432476758957, 0.031114285811781883, 0.04973544925451279, 0.02667406015098095, 0.022972896695137024, 0.024951722472906113, 0.047904226928949356, -0.008252713829278946, 0.035855960100889206, -0.009797326289117336, -0.012216047383844852, 0.03295935317873955, -0.03147270530462265, 0.01771368272602558, 0.033211831003427505, -0.004818172659724951, -0.008045750670135021, 0.010348212905228138, -0.022022608667612076, 0.02804170362651348, 0.042219486087560654, -0.054431378841400146, 0.018654216080904007, 0.014456653967499733, -0.04567014053463936, 0.03155684843659401, -0.03919413685798645, -0.034515131264925, -0.016607234254479408, 0.029622573405504227, 0.06015196070075035, -0.0007108799763955176, 0.008125899359583855, -0.013643745332956314, -0.0058588795363903046, -0.02358969673514366, -0.046324849128723145, -0.011046015657484531, -0.020831460133194923, -0.06278429925441742, -0.0039411792531609535, -0.0061514005064964294, 0.000681014615111053, 0.031011832877993584, -0.011802407912909985, 0.01691000908613205, 0.0368502177298069, 0.000977069023065269, -0.03447935730218887, 0.01206626370549202, -0.042838096618652344, 0.04388412460684776, -0.010167811065912247, -0.021638307720422745, 0.02520911395549774, 0.0018150530522689223, -0.017928961664438248, 0.0236064363270998, -0.023342177271842957, -0.022517243400216103, -0.040947750210762024, 0.01191670261323452, 0.02781306393444538, -0.007867170497775078, 0.0007104044780135155, 0.026421183720231056, -0.03076481819152832, -0.0075800796039402485, -0.0431729331612587, -0.07795816659927368, -0.01875166967511177, 0.024816308170557022, 0.02982119470834732, -0.005778606049716473, -0.057484522461891174, 0.06788188964128494, 0.028166217729449272, -0.0527074970304966, -0.03424961492419243, -0.021763736382126808, -0.031334374099969864, -0.030303793027997017, 0.031913213431835175, -0.00402899319306016, -0.004037613049149513, 0.005650356411933899, 0.012191396206617355, 0.01893569901585579, 0.046327460557222366, 0.013704182580113411, -0.018268000334501266, -0.006149462889879942, 0.023877808824181557, -0.0004954473697580397, 0.022541727870702744, 0.023461882025003433, -0.047119565308094025, 0.0021160405594855547, 0.0369848757982254, 0.033419232815504074, -0.0045609623193740845, -0.008469290100038052, 0.02025463432073593, -0.004369353409856558, 0.007597428280860186, -0.028114905580878258, 0.01091162022203207, 0.017841074615716934, 0.025615517050027847, -0.016196617856621742, 0.011769197881221771, 0.0196953397244215, -0.02420024201273918, 0.00870449747890234, 0.09005656838417053, 0.02755831927061081, -0.02093370631337166, 0.02319439873099327, -0.015164721757173538, -0.027142053470015526, 0.009922362864017487, -0.026275545358657837, -0.0068922871723771095, 0.04468657821416855, 0.02543768472969532, 0.019605880603194237, 0.006884039379656315, -0.04158056899905205, 0.03844914957880974, -0.061600591987371445, -0.015622729435563087, -0.0172888096421957, 0.04315970838069916, -0.015131605789065361, 0.03889186307787895, 0.04188080132007599, -0.009153668768703938, 0.007622994016855955, -0.011703557334840298, -0.04925374314188957, 0.042304325848817825, -0.025346502661705017, -0.00252948678098619, -0.0085901552811265, -0.0445779450237751, 0.005501709412783384, -0.02092920057475567, 0.024301700294017792, 0.00689008180052042, 0.016673706471920013, -0.029462547972798347, 0.030399151146411896, -0.02201719954609871, 0.033729538321495056, -0.007218653801828623, 0.03489694744348526, 0.011491942219436169, -0.03457662835717201, 0.02887018397450447, 0.03405473008751869, -0.006059258710592985, -0.02755725011229515, -0.042823828756809235, -0.02322053723037243, 0.011175572872161865, 0.054749276489019394, -0.007439929060637951, 0.024262428283691406, -0.023015832528471947, 0.026996757835149765, -0.024754732847213745, 0.05881033465266228, 0.0289099533110857, -0.006516155321151018, -0.03930765017867088, -0.016080031171441078, -0.013426638208329678, -0.0032352760899811983, 0.035544149577617645, -0.01857130229473114, 0.017382768914103508, 0.04624977335333824, 0.003572134068235755, -0.08599579334259033, 0.03748703375458717, 0.06254225224256516, 0.04382668063044548, -0.0028114942833781242, -0.022032620385289192, -0.02292362041771412, 0.005611186381429434, -0.0167049840092659, 0.009417634457349777, 0.005785106215626001, 0.01040343102067709, -0.00215683551505208, 0.03094169683754444, -0.010368568822741508, -0.03621497377753258, -0.011798085644841194, 0.002907685237005353, 0.051583100110292435, -0.021974215283989906, -0.024223243817687035, 0.01783657819032669, 0.01847364939749241, 0.022517098113894463, 0.044447045773267746, 0.004803161136806011, -0.10004152357578278, 0.002368907444179058, 0.06489989906549454, 0.04511669650673866, -0.019751716405153275, 0.006524889264255762, -0.01993746869266033, 0.007973751984536648, 0.045758143067359924, -0.038131456822156906, 0.026982180774211884, -0.0011068438179790974, 0.014709972776472569, -0.0028854766860604286, -0.0008786231628619134, -0.02793354168534279, 0.005645251367241144, -0.019978763535618782, 0.03355361148715019, -0.03259414806962013, -0.014926765114068985, -0.059226520359516144, 0.0043523493222892284, 0.012937266379594803, 0.08020942658185959, 0.003984652925282717, 0.015870723873376846, 0.024661239236593246, 0.024575214833021164, -0.023803193122148514, -0.05694613978266716, 0.013733896426856518, -0.00890896376222372, 0.009046878665685654, 0.08162140846252441, -0.009649654850363731, -0.053550027310848236, 0.00553880212828517, 0.008333205245435238, -0.006229925900697708, -0.014694549143314362, -0.011256995610892773, 0.03169615939259529, 0.015680287033319473, 0.015575527213513851, 0.038999248296022415, 0.03052208200097084, 0.02779935859143734, -0.0016135249752551317, -0.02498488500714302, 0.01922771707177162, -0.03619373217225075, -0.04919999837875366, -0.03222687914967537, -0.013526424765586853, -0.037039004266262054, 0.04574614018201828, -0.012399880215525627, 0.025179851800203323, -0.005949521902948618, -0.005606469698250294, 0.0019036465091630816, 0.0441473126411438, 0.005341490730643272, 0.005823030136525631, -0.01594134420156479, 0.03272810950875282, -0.022124595940113068, -0.02417769283056259, 0.02519291266798973, -0.03466790169477463, -0.013093782588839531, 0.012526878155767918, -0.07211839407682419, 0.019505387172102928, -0.05279594287276268, -0.016015728935599327, 0.00019530195277184248, -0.012232635170221329, 0.04117991402745247, -0.035514481365680695, 0.0037090396508574486, 0.009077616967260838, -0.05635463446378708, -0.01169457845389843, 0.048211194574832916, -0.022317880764603615, 0.057562749832868576, -0.021487509831786156, 0.07147447764873505, -0.014916710555553436, 0.0062154908664524555, -0.08865997195243835, -0.05710621178150177, 0.03381945565342903, 0.052305568009614944, -0.025232810527086258, -0.00354907033033669, -0.016307657584547997, -0.0076369065791368484, -0.002886139554902911, -0.053565613925457, 0.06736244261264801, 0.0053563048131763935, -0.031097035855054855, 0.015152010135352612, 0.004229496233165264, 0.08840028941631317, -0.015426388010382652, -0.014370826072990894, 0.022955548018217087, -0.004489277955144644, -0.02241288311779499, 0.00339123560115695, 0.006197268608957529, -0.02471253275871277, -0.03375093638896942, -0.04890568554401398, 0.030313335359096527, 0.01974032260477543, -0.048105254769325256, -0.003416982479393482, -0.0003407487238291651, -0.0030142879113554955, 0.023126304149627686, -0.013868615962564945, 0.0039846040308475494, -0.009499264881014824, -0.004935587756335735, -0.017253698781132698, -0.0019643402192741632, -0.01800740696489811, -0.016264531761407852, 0.020934876054525375, -0.0068829115480184555, -0.012529628351330757, -0.004056224133819342, 0.07837043702602386, 0.011578485369682312, -0.0038896026089787483, -0.037272319197654724, -0.037364598363637924, 0.035664740949869156, -0.00774889113381505, -0.006182958837598562, -0.018380647525191307, 0.05598032474517822, -0.047368403524160385, -0.016206005588173866, -0.0063375742174685, -0.022341756150126457, 0.06362779438495636, 0.010267000645399094, 0.04508750140666962, 0.07023558020591736, 0.012441513128578663, 0.01747622899711132, -0.017308222129940987, -0.0226224884390831, 0.009990560822188854, 0.006259487941861153, 0.029324211180210114, 0.0011558699188753963, 0.033422961831092834, -0.0069109052419662476, 0.0006930484669283032, 0.02801666595041752, 0.040743544697761536, 0.0010235881200060248, 0.03835490718483925, 0.03173571079969406, -0.0107872374355793, -0.05419507995247841, 0.007560727186501026, -0.023907294496893883, 0.017501965165138245, -0.021873753517866135, -0.04835078492760658, 0.026680385693907738, 0.02959316223859787, 0.012817629612982273, -0.0032769558019936085, -0.025933511555194855, -0.04860426485538483, 0.05582933872938156, -0.008612377569079399, -0.004057151731103659, 0.011437377892434597, 0.03503229841589928, 0.02766142226755619, -0.0012060062726959586, -0.012408878654241562, -0.048098791390657425, -0.08305396884679794, -0.024450184777379036, 0.014590940438210964, -0.02155623398721218, 0.01464095152914524, 0.016110040247440338, -0.059266526252031326, 0.017756542190909386, -0.025951100513339043, -0.0026964920107275248, 0.011845898814499378, 0.06146220117807388, -0.024950221180915833, 0.05441847816109657, 0.0010577172506600618, 0.023796405643224716, 0.009505228139460087, 0.028477823361754417, 0.09911099821329117, 0.09877444058656693, 0.024085545912384987, -0.09192384034395218, 0.0262675192207098, 0.005721863824874163, -0.012751631438732147, -0.03901684656739235, 0.025231607258319855, 0.018786579370498657, 0.023473400622606277, 0.04000537097454071, 0.029775962233543396, 0.0036466766614466906, 0.011806461028754711, 0.0913696214556694, -0.008738157339394093, -0.02855403535068035, 0.013876911252737045, 0.0396551713347435, -0.010681732557713985, -0.01007136795669794, -0.0662558451294899, 0.05331936106085777, -0.005844864994287491, -0.020028164610266685, -0.011283689178526402, -0.0181395523250103, -0.002627559704706073, 0.005975708365440369, 0.0075840731151402, -0.00872895773500204, 0.016049232333898544, -0.006334963720291853, -0.033032096922397614, -0.008554607629776001, 0.0070824273861944675, -0.021305885165929794, 0.012004978023469448, 0.015426396392285824, 0.006011622957885265, -0.021082855761051178, 0.017090503126382828, 0.02751827798783779, -0.02604256384074688, -0.03477451950311661, -0.013027193024754524, 0.0510869026184082, 0.0131266750395298, -0.00442984513938427, -0.021482866257429123, 0.02566022239625454, -0.015547560527920723, -0.044505525380373, -0.026896659284830093, 0.0029812834691256285, 0.018967507407069206, -0.0553881973028183, -0.025928985327482224, -0.028887569904327393, 0.013138453476130962, -0.025841401889920235, 0.042332541197538376, 0.00693716574460268, -0.026328647509217262, -0.017749806866049767, -0.03892568126320839, 0.04605986177921295, 0.008984042331576347, 0.0009237385238520801, -0.006054782308638096, -0.04058460146188736, -0.008532317355275154, 0.019482754170894623, 0.027863580733537674, 0.020767010748386383, 0.017427802085876465, 0.027383727952837944, -0.008950727060437202, -0.007445462513715029, -0.03335466608405113, 0.0316954143345356, -0.023073112592101097, -0.010948006063699722, -0.03737867996096611, -0.002196467714384198, 0.062245726585388184, 0.021809851750731468, 0.01579403318464756, 0.029817597940564156, -0.018700258806347847, 0.036440495401620865, 0.005463824141770601, -0.05664358288049698, -0.0005642994656227529, -0.005992625840008259, -0.03352724760770798, 0.0035352453123778105, -0.022799760103225708, 0.054338809102773666, 0.02921466715633869, 0.0183551125228405, 0.0013549739960581064, 0.04797641932964325, -0.029436815530061722, -0.0010775148402899504, 0.031905725598335266, -0.05803839862346649, -0.003695906139910221, -0.007008811924606562, -0.005174857098609209, -0.009497426450252533, -0.03559492155909538, -0.025200437754392624, -0.014706702902913094, 0.012437860481441021, 0.011907531879842281, -0.0426662415266037, 0.006644557695835829, -0.0064653055742383, -0.01406790316104889, -0.02095235139131546, -0.004922589287161827, -0.04958957061171532, -0.0295560322701931, -0.004574635997414589, -0.00017954414943233132, -0.015639062970876694, -0.0015870557399466634, 0.012198005802929401, -0.005104632582515478, 0.07181333005428314, 0.04246949031949043, 0.02703670971095562, 0.007580795791000128, 0.005724602844566107, -0.010978860780596733, 0.047210052609443665, -0.021504119038581848, -0.014519698917865753, 0.05840405821800232, -0.029094787314534187, -0.002973047085106373, 0.022418180480599403, -0.018446698784828186, 0.007991483435034752, 0.0323353037238121, -0.004019697196781635, -0.022184887900948524, 0.039314910769462585, -0.017676789313554764, -0.012190190143883228, -0.03221949562430382, 0.031233571469783783, -0.0006650301511399448, -0.007964063435792923, 0.013294515199959278, -0.0038484602700918913, -0.0298655666410923, -0.01114507857710123, 0.054158348590135574, 0.022570010274648666, -0.025986699387431145, 0.001316791051067412, 0.03696800023317337, 0.0419815294444561, -0.009174603968858719, -0.002834532642737031, 0.03914327919483185, 0.061879854649305344, -0.051098961383104324, 0.02929798513650894, -0.03426323086023331, 0.024459537118673325, -0.09649629890918732, -0.010636275634169579, -0.010955899953842163, 0.0031701182015240192, 0.035546302795410156, -0.04738054424524307, 0.014962428249418736, 0.07925871759653091, -0.016390182077884674, 0.01653210073709488, -0.024912286549806595, -0.010201854631304741, -0.031089553609490395, -0.002584952861070633, -0.02472863532602787, 0.014983724802732468, 0.02494046837091446, 0.01984439231455326, 0.02660004049539566, 0.02306920476257801, -0.013816396705806255, -0.021717838943004608, -0.013192787766456604, 0.02160448394715786, 0.04704557731747627, -0.06390154361724854, 0.007386099547147751, -0.027088124305009842, -0.0252778772264719, 0.03592390939593315, -0.0394105464220047, 0.014379535801708698, 0.032661911100149155, 0.01983759179711342, -0.0015805820003151894, 0.056708741933107376, 0.018092237412929535, 0.009828024543821812, -0.02999519184231758, -0.009038371033966541, -0.017353225499391556, 0.016182903200387955, -0.02500554919242859, 0.025398481637239456, 0.017281584441661835, -0.02817303128540516, -0.029014231637120247, 0.006468719802796841, -0.024186689406633377, -0.00018491409718990326, -0.012705467641353607, -0.006722497288137674, 0.025055386126041412, -0.04345143586397171, 0.025745104998350143, -0.04942505061626434, 0.012505579739809036, 0.02525332011282444, 0.03582141548395157, -0.013700387440621853, 0.03273152559995651, -0.011216978542506695, -0.03122990019619465, 0.010408005677163601, 0.006402025930583477, -0.041161008179187775, -0.09143587201833725, 0.005675161723047495, -0.013603287748992443, -0.019846415147185326, -0.03103361278772354, -0.006702841259539127, -0.01544206403195858, 0.047964636236429214, -0.012071826495230198, -0.014270399697124958, 0.027086680755019188, -0.041633326560258865, -0.03106260672211647, -0.061802852898836136, 0.07267880439758301, 0.010315743274986744, -0.005672664847224951, -0.03977193310856819, -0.019377073273062706, -0.03850018233060837, -0.005392608232796192, 0.028648220002651215, 0.0040395502001047134, 0.016174642369151115, -0.007565991021692753, 0.023561498150229454, -0.0020963421557098627, -0.05625529587268829, 0.028709664940834045, -0.009947193786501884, -0.03107590787112713, -0.008314549922943115, -0.034286804497241974, 0.015019365586340427, -0.019797665998339653, -0.0012944680638611317, -0.023496456444263458, 0.01591511256992817, 0.014453246258199215, -0.0009465781622566283, 0.035502053797245026, 0.005117208696901798, -0.023835355415940285, 0.032092638313770294, -0.029176140204072, 0.0006943304906599224, 0.049084581434726715, 0.00043621237273328006, -0.045736078172922134, 0.04594268649816513, -0.019060950726270676, -0.031931471079587936, 0.007311179768294096, 0.03166966885328293, -0.002615339355543256, -0.06726149469614029, -0.010580168105661869, 0.003467203350737691, -0.018851935863494873, -0.0005886918515898287, 0.02822406031191349, 0.011690960265696049, 0.022476138547062874, -0.0069345226511359215, -0.004098656587302685, 0.019146837294101715, -0.012439887970685959, 0.00462727015838027, 0.03674990311264992, -0.005334966816008091, 0.020090071484446526, 0.007852649316191673, 0.02754085697233677, 0.00042689169640652835, 0.03973731771111488, -0.015422521159052849, 0.022775746881961823, -0.026582984253764153, -0.015144885517656803, -0.002046615583822131, -0.03355932980775833, 0.040013302117586136, 0.005444965325295925, -0.01653381809592247, 0.03171971067786217, -0.04265906661748886, -0.00587682006880641, -0.05839705467224121, -0.01582639291882515, -0.004372529219835997, 0.0009214052697643638, 0.030680067837238312, 0.025247542187571526, -0.03916655108332634, -0.0035100409295409918, 0.009473254904150963, 0.018245110288262367, 0.030345451086759567, -0.033281825482845306, 0.0584566704928875, -0.05732885003089905, 0.014813954010605812, -0.04880428686738014, -0.012725256383419037, -0.058538421988487244, 0.02332250215113163, 0.027748212218284607, 0.03396231681108475, 0.03252280130982399, -0.014307619072496891, -0.03694969415664673, -0.030198153108358383, 0.028974873945116997, -0.07863005250692368, -0.0007849991670809686, -0.058620478957891464, 0.024002056568861008, -0.04014473780989647, -0.043625202029943466 ]
<p>I've just come across a statement in </p> <p>Good, P. I.: Resampling methods. Springer, 2001 </p> <p>and wondered if someone could explain it to me.<br> If you want to construct a 95% confidence interval for, let's say the mean of a normal distribution then the bounds would be $\bar{X}\pm 1.96s/\sqrt{n}$ with $\hat X$ being the sample mean and $s$ being the standard deviation of the sample. </p> <p>So obviously if you want to halve the size of your confidence interval you'd have to multiply the sample size by 4 (i.e. take 400 samples instead of 100). So the width of the CI is proportional to $n^{-\frac{1}{2}}$. CI's with this feature are called first order exact (I guess most of you know that, I'm just repeating it because I didn't) </p> <p>Now what Good says is that $BC_\alpha$ intervals are second order exact, that is their width for large samples is proportional to $n^{-1}$. Why is that so?</p>
73,911
[ -0.007158699445426464, -0.051665645092725754, 0.05864765867590904, 0.0023134455550462008, 0.03096502274274826, 0.04454930126667023, 0.01295877993106842, -0.017421431839466095, -0.0034747726749628782, -0.04169227182865143, 0.022073857486248016, 0.031781647354364395, 0.0639970526099205, 0.04145607352256775, -0.002407113555818796, -0.0036114875692874193, -0.022586597129702568, 0.0093352310359478, -0.04460662230849266, -0.030064206570386887, 0.020143406465649605, 0.03793107718229294, 0.03141661733388901, -0.01371470931917429, -0.017222696915268898, 0.015398477204144001, 0.006493974477052689, 0.019753217697143555, -0.0031001470051705837, 0.08035483956336975, -0.01249934732913971, -0.03548254072666168, 0.01355094462633133, 0.035847872495651245, 0.0014579386916011572, 0.0026907583232969046, -0.02606498822569847, -0.035243019461631775, 0.03351748362183571, 0.04723590984940529, -0.0712137445807457, 0.009955057874321938, 0.00804098229855299, -0.010083690285682678, -0.006684874650090933, 0.03509758040308952, -0.031409379094839096, -0.05800647661089897, 0.016375232487916946, -0.03068067878484726, 0.04937230795621872, -0.01634121872484684, 0.05742719769477844, 0.04265915974974632, -0.0028245991561561823, -0.006568911951035261, 0.008908181451261044, 0.04158860072493553, -0.022765083238482475, -0.05065499246120453, 0.009203123860061169, -0.03708511218428612, 0.01964011788368225, 0.03733339533209801, 0.01997588388621807, 0.011910559609532356, -0.021696653217077255, -0.023904060944914818, -0.01257647667080164, -0.02858353592455387, 0.013837546110153198, 0.02696484886109829, 0.04552934691309929, -0.020820870995521545, -0.000998141709715128, -0.028070468455553055, 0.010838303714990616, 0.012713269330561161, 0.06068486347794533, 0.06992479413747787, -0.0195610448718071, 0.001553674228489399, 0.03148702532052994, 0.05395426228642464, 0.0046560801565647125, -0.005160974338650703, 0.10628338158130646, -0.0276988185942173, 0.06533927470445633, 0.029451195150613785, -0.002482618670910597, 0.03402199223637581, 0.050312962383031845, -0.05323347449302673, -0.02022382616996765, 0.017716068774461746, -0.0015137220034375787, 0.023148203268647194, -0.00884417537599802, -0.01740609109401703, -0.012992186471819878, -0.0503595732152462, 0.02757914923131466, 0.05921332910656929, 0.012162500061094761, -0.02759695053100586, -0.04779369756579399, 0.013985579833388329, -0.00047978514339774847, -0.030307961627840996, -0.009638539515435696, -0.0006171735585667193, 0.013245392590761185, 0.03549458831548691, 0.01720770075917244, -0.005526367574930191, 0.012225514277815819, -0.012158929370343685, 0.03980029374361038, 0.05629442259669304, 0.02245398424565792, 0.006077127996832132, 0.04299021512269974, -0.0011513062054291368, -0.0520014725625515, 0.07497401535511017, 0.004787761718034744, -0.026664411649107933, -0.04518118128180504, 0.014395950362086296, -0.007798067759722471, -0.0104335006326437, -0.002468481194227934, 0.039043329656124115, 0.03730228170752525, -0.01017575990408659, -0.08784119039773941, -0.06321335583925247, 0.03990933671593666, 0.04663471877574921, -0.008920254185795784, -0.07641104608774185, 0.05138837918639183, 0.07067197561264038, 0.04991907626390457, 0.011085872538387775, 0.04206370189785957, -0.03222639486193657, 0.008961006067693233, 0.03624257817864418, -0.06771373003721237, -0.02937985211610794, -0.013155248947441578, 0.007563396356999874, -0.029630186036229134, -0.088507741689682, 0.03520930930972099, -0.003070118138566613, 0.012769261375069618, -0.061912406235933304, 0.03762106969952583, -0.0065920003689825535, -0.014530893415212631, -0.025372233241796494, -0.007684230804443359, -0.010969809256494045, 0.07429540157318115, 0.001838614814914763, 0.02220921218395233, 0.016618432477116585, 0.00474955141544342, 0.02065320685505867, 0.018574988469481468, 0.01905306987464428, 0.0449054017663002, -0.051717765629291534, -0.044542308896780014, -0.03994664549827576, 0.010263325646519661, 0.06861357390880585, -0.0286062341183424, 0.006022214889526367, 0.0016673918580636382, 0.025297367945313454, -0.0026163903530687094, 0.055352453142404556, -0.0008095303783193231, -0.03444904834032059, 0.03348608687520027, -0.045078568160533905, -0.04250961169600487, -0.06472277641296387, 0.033283792436122894, 0.03569478169083595, -0.0353451706469059, 0.014041867107152939, 0.005771173629909754, 0.0009556142031215131, -0.014997471123933792, -0.02026170678436756, -0.011510713957250118, -0.006257803179323673, 0.04421943053603172, -0.06782010197639465, 0.0442105270922184, 0.06046367809176445, 0.014427934773266315, -0.031080259010195732, 0.05952061340212822, -0.030417803674936295, -0.07587304711341858, 0.005621364340186119, -0.04931323602795601, 0.00982794351875782, -0.018188076093792915, -0.030372098088264465, 0.0018241688376292586, -0.019721096381545067, 0.005445418413728476, 0.05325470492243767, -0.04917615279555321, 0.026047244668006897, 0.03803495317697525, 0.00722955958917737, 0.017307812348008156, 0.01726183295249939, 0.0478241965174675, -0.03510123863816261, -0.01349225640296936, -0.030337227508425713, -0.05261846259236336, 0.009500976651906967, 0.04084087163209915, 0.008210409432649612, -0.027775820344686508, 0.0014325259253382683, 0.06291688978672028, -0.002478155307471752, 0.05083769932389259, 0.01959724724292755, 0.015003832057118416, -0.00028375702095218003, -0.006669952534139156, 0.02796872705221176, 0.04938261955976486, 0.015892300754785538, -0.025654222816228867, 0.010980295948684216, 0.047299597412347794, 0.04350016638636589, 0.019714653491973877, -0.012345720082521439, 0.0032925377599895, -0.00035039547947235405, 0.014563913457095623, -0.009414358995854855, 0.026703838258981705, -0.026501992717385292, 0.01469843927770853, 0.045914214104413986, 0.007938859052956104, -0.005029048305004835, 0.0010136687196791172, 0.00758176576346159, 0.04165108501911163, 0.011187493801116943, -0.04078388214111328, -0.009121479466557503, 0.011333491653203964, -0.035394925624132156, -0.010764175094664097, -0.01570386439561844, -0.025094812735915184, -0.0361005924642086, -0.006543945521116257, 0.032357409596443176, 0.019358260557055473, 0.015509312972426414, -0.03358917683362961, -0.01467814203351736, 0.0046231308951973915, -0.010664255358278751, 0.018796076998114586, 0.01109109167009592, -0.021621719002723694, 0.017885996028780937, -0.0022338039707392454, -0.024236684665083885, 0.01193831954151392, 0.0004255140956956893, 0.00274850195273757, -0.001501461025327444, -0.011638709343969822, -0.04512406140565872, -0.012334738858044147, 0.001973733538761735, -0.03266916424036026, -0.005508937407284975, -0.02699285000562668, 0.037653952836990356, 0.041088785976171494, -0.024111242964863777, 0.04168520122766495, 0.007721634116023779, -0.024136457592248917, -0.04457900673151016, 0.011704112403094769, 0.05166789889335632, 0.0008993748924694955, 0.02060116082429886, -0.000860320869833231, -0.003960220608860254, -0.019107932224869728, -0.04157648980617523, -0.07113485038280487, -0.002501984126865864, 0.01799054816365242, 0.023582246154546738, 0.016662664711475372, -0.015275768004357815, 0.08838336914777756, 0.037594880908727646, 0.008302277885377407, -0.008886031806468964, -0.02535960078239441, -0.02012608014047146, -0.030014971271157265, 0.0021835220977663994, -0.012403064407408237, 0.00019910323317162693, -0.012300768867135048, -0.012851609848439693, 0.05863124504685402, 0.03363011032342911, 0.022989077493548393, 0.026618562638759613, 0.006334174890071154, -0.03191927447915077, -0.022446898743510246, 0.0010547712445259094, 0.006504715885967016, -0.022259730845689774, -0.011797327548265457, 0.012144074775278568, 0.05195185914635658, 0.025615597143769264, -0.051704030483961105, 0.020327985286712646, -0.04761025682091713, 0.0005526664899662137, -0.0368693508207798, 0.03795049712061882, 0.013390805572271347, -0.022247491404414177, -0.008757148869335651, 0.00703022675588727, 0.03403818607330322, -0.04044504463672638, -0.01390757504850626, 0.0253693126142025, 0.025647467002272606, -0.009534589014947414, 0.0007493228185921907, -0.01880594529211521, -0.0210901889950037, -0.010564719326794147, -0.05051160603761673, -0.011860341764986515, 0.005965293850749731, 0.06623179465532303, 0.013927645981311798, -0.02583637274801731, -0.02520911768078804, -0.007109421771019697, -0.04720184952020645, 0.008616434410214424, -0.05091254785656929, 0.03045211173593998, 0.011530312709510326, 0.05177760869264603, 0.04938824847340584, 0.009893753565847874, 0.004180345218628645, 0.006075035780668259, -0.05025649815797806, 0.03303738310933113, -0.02264406532049179, -0.029451999813318253, -0.009889990091323853, -0.0002814372710417956, 0.027058079838752747, 0.011559780687093735, -0.000916230957955122, -0.030219342559576035, 0.040373295545578, -0.05290403962135315, 0.009069874882698059, -0.018867837265133858, -0.016472943127155304, 0.002629044698551297, 0.029155822470784187, 0.036487702280282974, -0.006918760947883129, 0.027654385194182396, 0.011115930043160915, -0.0028246340807527304, -0.04044410586357117, -0.014123725704848766, 0.014274712651968002, 0.02589339390397072, 0.03371202573180199, 0.04920126497745514, -0.005325799807906151, -0.02337622083723545, 0.009903979487717152, -0.008303215727210045, 0.08015243709087372, 0.03649325668811798, 0.0006172169232740998, 0.01661461405456066, -0.02969561703503132, -0.0029083029367029667, 0.0165268387645483, 0.018423747271299362, 0.003114992054179311, 0.009027419611811638, 0.08763673156499863, 0.0018471060320734978, -0.05477720499038696, 0.02074408158659935, 0.0480034202337265, 0.0044973790645599365, 0.005843660794198513, -0.07222677767276764, -0.000583346642088145, -0.003237168537452817, 0.009321819059550762, -0.002749144332483411, -0.013261758722364902, -0.01776796020567417, -0.021112805232405663, 0.0751759484410286, -0.03255283460021019, -0.041481081396341324, -0.007461125031113625, 0.02479613572359085, 0.02869066409766674, 0.002835700986906886, -0.02071756310760975, -0.0048280335031449795, -0.005271851550787687, 0.06593208760023117, -0.0025306909810751677, -0.01095790509134531, -0.07325156778097153, 0.012526731938123703, -0.0028776528779417276, 0.03680584952235222, -0.037087034434080124, 0.0216971505433321, -0.044685155153274536, -0.011253121308982372, 0.03478869050741196, -0.050672005861997604, 0.04240909218788147, -0.018170930445194244, -0.013573030941188335, -0.04000433161854744, -0.015095719136297703, -0.039244454354047775, -0.002446933416649699, -0.014437730424106121, 0.0054396651685237885, 0.0022454119753092527, -0.015453088097274303, -0.056919753551483154, 0.014412479475140572, 0.0275979395955801, 0.06688898056745529, 0.0008912076009437442, -0.030664457008242607, -0.010697543621063232, 0.027811406180262566, -0.04360143095254898, -0.06161778047680855, 0.04070265591144562, 0.013999814167618752, -0.011067715473473072, 0.026329634711146355, -0.00042291288264095783, -0.054651468992233276, 0.03723881021142006, 0.021088436245918274, -0.006242777686566114, -0.04068470746278763, -0.006950457580387592, 0.03985760360956192, -0.0027960583101958036, 0.03817395120859146, 0.06876426935195923, 0.013695194385945797, -0.01245824433863163, -0.004158605355769396, -0.03965896740555763, 0.04607165604829788, -0.029090821743011475, -0.019137443974614143, -0.028601733967661858, -0.011951821856200695, -0.05809103325009346, 0.011596315540373325, 0.002729574451223016, 0.022069185972213745, -0.008873865939676762, -0.010700620710849762, 0.022274233400821686, 0.016354409977793694, 0.004656614735722542, -0.014036075212061405, -0.007290542125701904, 0.04331078752875328, 0.036993563175201416, -0.0034433414693921804, 0.024453207850456238, -0.0163589995354414, 0.00901868287473917, 0.035311441868543625, -0.032881803810596466, 0.011706224642693996, -0.04369913786649704, -0.020146464928984642, 0.019217031076550484, -0.020890947431325912, 0.03553669899702072, -0.02040264755487442, 0.007120879832655191, -0.012444471009075642, -0.004537719767540693, -0.027556614950299263, 0.024373751133680344, -0.03070303611457348, 0.02191711775958538, -0.055287472903728485, 0.020606376230716705, 0.031219782307744026, 0.033544834703207016, -0.0940246656537056, -0.03203551471233368, 0.03610182926058769, 0.0025435786228626966, 0.0008673156844452024, -0.020743342116475105, -0.021817848086357117, 0.01968243718147278, 0.002939641708508134, -0.016945049166679382, 0.031818654388189316, 0.018346158787608147, -0.011184673756361008, -0.003935451619327068, 0.024788403883576393, 0.04681568220257759, 0.02237831987440586, 0.005811986979097128, -0.004768848419189453, -0.015944598242640495, -0.01352471113204956, 0.03756903484463692, 0.01143550779670477, -0.037367671728134155, -0.002854545833542943, -0.03289670869708061, 0.018662670627236366, 0.001970970770344138, 0.024774806573987007, -0.02442837879061699, 0.006544441916048527, 0.01908399723470211, 0.010622589848935604, -0.018036216497421265, -0.057947661727666855, -0.011039135046303272, 0.030734630301594734, 0.008991899900138378, -0.021810734644532204, -0.009446556679904461, 0.005521565675735474, 0.02479485794901848, 0.013890163972973824, 0.0287524051964283, -0.008804966695606709, 0.07330694049596786, -0.03500969335436821, -0.004285967443138361, 0.003936749417334795, -0.024570390582084656, 0.009246133267879486, 0.06164161115884781, -0.009998481720685959, 0.04455285891890526, 0.011770705692470074, -0.030055752024054527, -0.011310367844998837, -0.025208935141563416, 0.01780638098716736, 0.06332346051931381, 0.01592681184411049, 0.04162059724330902, 0.01849217899143696, 0.02356509491801262, 0.0027622533962130547, -0.01446614135056734, -0.0020773299038410187, -0.04235116019845009, -0.014881130307912827, 0.010441545397043228, -0.028652289882302284, -0.03480643406510353, 0.0069633787497878075, 0.010577906854450703, -0.006307021249085665, 0.011857740581035614, 0.006944469176232815, 0.026348914951086044, 0.012614928185939789, -0.002059333026409149, -0.01578809879720211, 0.05404902249574661, -0.044231727719306946, -0.02751280926167965, -0.01061401516199112, -0.005651178769767284, 0.0443493127822876, -0.004292626399546862, 0.017741436138749123, -0.032549869269132614, -0.021931851282715797, -0.04489826038479805, -0.018014123663306236, -0.0061282804235816, -0.03805167227983475, 0.017817722633481026, -0.03502944856882095, -0.002286783652380109, 0.01399553194642067, 0.033380549401044846, -0.020487727597355843, -0.05299045890569687, -0.033729422837495804, -0.010556160472333431, -0.041217781603336334, 0.03287548944354057, -0.033039577305316925, -0.04181163012981415, 0.029225345700979233, -0.04210219532251358, 0.039268799126148224, 0.0036060360725969076, 0.021321794018149376, 0.00420125899836421, 0.05255785956978798, 0.0253794863820076, 0.03293045982718468, 0.011213177815079689, -0.025542190298438072, 0.132185161113739, 0.07195791602134705, -0.006164985708892345, -0.06100225821137428, 0.05532703176140785, -0.02423374354839325, -0.0020804989617317915, -0.0020592366345226765, 0.01706116460263729, -0.011706885881721973, 0.00400224095210433, 0.05105946213006973, 0.059873659163713455, 0.006898978259414434, 0.012568632140755653, 0.04541119933128357, -0.03120279312133789, -0.010513750836253166, -0.0008866745629347861, 0.02477082796394825, -0.027434932067990303, -0.05295334756374359, -0.03927900269627571, -0.000606135290581733, -0.01165656466037035, -0.002336497651413083, -0.01516796462237835, -0.017264045774936676, -0.0014925675932317972, 0.02627882920205593, -0.009692833758890629, 0.006114639341831207, 0.0011966810561716557, 0.0036113178357481956, -0.027299214154481888, -0.009714117273688316, 0.017682436853647232, 0.013074544258415699, 0.0019984019454568624, 0.05876074358820915, -0.013804777525365353, 0.022658666595816612, -0.015585755929350853, 0.05829079449176788, -0.03253974765539169, -0.06005317345261574, -0.06580237299203873, 0.02509886398911476, -0.025474853813648224, 0.0012593413703143597, -0.0222641434520483, -0.016909759491682053, -0.025061003863811493, -0.014174718409776688, 0.01025767158716917, 0.051102180033922195, 0.026037633419036865, -0.05758620798587799, 0.010091040283441544, -0.024020323529839516, 0.0017801526701077819, -0.00901465117931366, 0.0028764046728610992, 0.04000336676836014, -0.01921888254582882, -0.032241567969322205, 0.002059160266071558, -0.005549414083361626, -0.0071400851011276245, -0.019377397373318672, 0.0006761933327652514, -0.002495436230674386, -0.08977866172790527, -0.005446969531476498, 0.010314788669347763, -0.04007254168391228, 0.05675642937421799, -0.047809746116399765, -0.01889667846262455, -0.012755190953612328, -0.02819180302321911, 0.023683663457632065, -0.024909978732466698, -0.021461650729179382, -0.03205287083983421, 0.00355475302785635, -0.016068389639258385, 0.03100111335515976, -0.005356615409255028, 0.018911151215434074, -0.00023448263527825475, 0.055964138358831406, 0.015935620293021202, -0.04738706350326538, -0.024718301370739937, -0.0008132634684443474, -0.02045089565217495, 0.010101797059178352, 0.020895246416330338, 0.054816778749227524, 0.03548277169466019, 0.01786142960190773, 0.020009435713291168, 0.016724133864045143, -0.051202140748500824, 0.01681772619485855, 0.01591528207063675, -0.05825258791446686, 0.03766675665974617, 0.04160120338201523, 0.017572272568941116, -0.04164193570613861, -0.013139709830284119, -0.038130324333906174, -0.0242299847304821, -0.01695205830037594, 0.0056940242648124695, -0.02385333552956581, -0.017149558290839195, 0.0031103380024433136, 0.016813505440950394, -0.04820244386792183, -0.017132891342043877, -0.050527554005384445, 0.020425159484148026, -0.008582508191466331, -0.0017641016747802496, 0.021114272996783257, -0.01700051687657833, -0.0027159282471984625, -0.016915597021579742, 0.04753251001238823, 0.006534629501402378, 0.01876135915517807, -0.021157359704375267, 0.011105199344456196, 0.032759882509708405, -0.0015582948690280318, -0.041714947670698166, -0.014439795166254044, 0.05688253417611122, -0.07313372194766998, -0.06660578399896622, 0.021965960040688515, 0.005881596356630325, 0.00045046635204926133, 0.014686720445752144, -0.004795595072209835, -0.0050385575741529465, 0.046565718948841095, -0.04395413398742676, -0.02690996043384075, -0.01704488694667816, -0.0032353410497307777, 0.002017310354858637, -0.008605417795479298, -0.0038107403088361025, -0.015718890354037285, 0.022743957117199898, 0.02016213908791542, -0.001699166838079691, -0.005979462526738644, -0.02102263644337654, 0.00903804786503315, 0.022607380524277687, 0.019254866987466812, 0.023022932931780815, 0.015359440818428993, 0.011990291066467762, 0.08236736804246902, -0.031061319634318352, 0.04176421836018562, -0.029063692316412926, 0.02615770325064659, -0.07507345825433731, 0.0034391942899674177, -0.03995874151587486, 0.023372316733002663, 0.013374139554798603, -0.044618263840675354, 0.028551531955599785, 0.014717677608132362, -0.022804846987128258, 0.021085109561681747, -0.06445876508951187, 0.024624960497021675, -0.04124794900417328, 0.00674597080796957, -0.03397656977176666, 0.02436230517923832, 0.05279575660824776, -0.020101219415664673, 0.00908441748470068, -0.019231164827942848, -0.00844147801399231, -0.03416650742292404, 0.0004887611139565706, 0.03869841247797012, 0.0021021049469709396, -0.08878997713327408, 0.01072326023131609, -0.007297900505363941, -0.01997377537190914, 0.042405255138874054, -0.019399667158722878, 0.0261966735124588, 0.023108627647161484, 0.045716769993305206, 0.044934552162885666, 0.04573902487754822, 0.0214865580201149, -0.005337337497621775, -0.013036898337304592, -0.029387012124061584, 0.03181774541735649, -0.0016200115205720067, 0.0226129163056612, 0.01973727159202099, 0.062451738864183426, -0.031206857413053513, -0.04371648654341698, 0.00909196212887764, -0.005329920444637537, -0.03496653959155083, 0.0191901084035635, -0.00369822490029037, -0.04204774275422096, -0.00674908934161067, 0.07903935015201569, -0.014157604426145554, -0.008192150853574276, 0.03076326660811901, 0.04239761829376221, -0.03451738879084587, 0.007904095575213432, -0.012104320339858532, -0.04884381219744682, 0.011533422395586967, 0.010266040451824665, -0.03951923921704292, -0.055635906755924225, -0.013235938735306263, -0.016368497163057327, 0.0219692625105381, -0.030810199677944183, -0.008035528473556042, -0.017323797568678856, 0.05441608652472496, -0.016400668770074844, -0.0015409805346280336, -0.02540227398276329, -0.0001479051570640877, -0.01271845493465662, -0.0781884640455246, 0.08592159301042557, -0.0022430862300097942, -0.019324565306305885, -0.034676551818847656, -0.01209933403879404, -0.007836423814296722, -0.022747760638594627, 0.06108758598566055, 0.05331163480877876, -0.016915906220674515, -0.0009528424707241356, 0.03407309576869011, 0.017273452132940292, -0.025313684716820717, 0.008108691312372684, -0.0191690344363451, -0.008560149930417538, 0.01291055977344513, -0.009602758102118969, -0.013463042676448822, 0.01601227931678295, 0.004039750900119543, -0.021424397826194763, 0.03146594017744064, -0.012598147615790367, 0.013010983355343342, 0.03002186119556427, 0.03125312179327011, -0.015550805255770683, 0.038787905126810074, -0.008102324791252613, 0.02045658603310585, 0.03364429622888565, -0.0050064148381352425, -0.060816530138254166, 0.013150684535503387, -0.00015272894233930856, -0.04364383965730667, -0.017560673877596855, 0.012408284470438957, -0.005958044435828924, -0.015486170537769794, -0.032019197940826416, -0.0010064952075481415, -0.03937656804919243, -0.002041494008153677, 0.024981312453746796, 0.014859173446893692, 0.014997987076640129, -0.0007601082907058299, -0.02304922230541706, 0.03000393882393837, -0.013029748573899269, -0.005123003851622343, 0.003629941027611494, 0.0025999315548688173, -0.011021092534065247, 0.02298537641763687, 0.032762881368398666, -0.021362487226724625, 0.036798350512981415, 0.006466781720519066, 0.030131971463561058, -0.012327714823186398, -0.05534260720014572, 0.023022333160042763, -0.033397987484931946, 0.013530050404369831, 0.0059183696284890175, -0.0163909699767828, 0.07437009364366531, -0.026861194521188736, 0.03201993554830551, -0.02159234508872032, -0.02520197257399559, -0.032282862812280655, 0.02452380582690239, -0.00646872166544199, 0.02264324203133583, 0.01575395092368126, 0.009462004527449608, 0.005378513131290674, -0.03623802587389946, 0.02204923890531063, -0.0471317432820797, 0.01753857173025608, 0.0154649643227458, 0.007873880676925182, -0.03287747502326965, -0.008564287796616554, -0.009196773171424866, -0.029875755310058594, 0.00972405169159174, 0.00556162791326642, 0.01187441498041153, 0.04827854782342911, -0.04853133484721184, 0.010301711969077587, 0.05502854287624359, -0.06760848313570023, -0.022259199991822243, -0.01145335752516985, 0.011470522731542587, 0.008603694848716259, -0.04163302853703499 ]
<p>I have annual data that seem to have a bimodal density function. My explaination is that there is a distinction between wet and dry years. For my work I would like to use an ar(1)-model for this. When I simulate from a fitted ar(1)-model with normally distributed innovations I of course get normally distributed data. Since the simulation results look different from the historical data this is not satisfactory. When I generate my innovations by just sampling from the residuals which also show a bimodal density function I get better results concerning the density function. By doing so my innovations are still white noise. But not Gaussian white noise any more. This approach is called "model based resampling" and was (I guess) introduced by Freedman (1984). That approach has some disadvantages but for me it seems to be an improvement. </p> <p>But I am not certain if I still can use (standard) MLE to estimate the ar-parameter(s) in the model based resampling approach. Or if I might use least squares instead. I suppose that least squares is better since there is no gaussian assumption. I was really looking for publications for this but the few I found are extremely difficult to understand. I found a lot concerning fitting of distributions and structural equation modeling, saying that small deviations from normal are not a problem for MLE as long as there are no extreme outliers. But I guess time series may not be the same.</p> <p>Can you help me?</p>
36,457
[ 0.008956003934144974, 0.007051533553749323, 0.019138531759381294, -0.02716928720474243, 0.02514687553048134, -0.001981699839234352, -0.0016250679036602378, -0.04032445698976517, 0.043845128268003464, -0.04599066078662872, 0.011126922443509102, 0.05249088257551193, 0.0577240027487278, 0.026512550190091133, 0.03816986456513405, -0.01980556920170784, 0.0038398096803575754, -0.02630462497472763, -0.003610041458159685, -0.01273659709841013, -0.009927038103342056, 0.00022856584109831601, 0.002530316123738885, -0.016856050118803978, -0.033089347183704376, 0.04058004543185234, 0.0031527106184512377, -0.005042701493948698, 0.002358032390475273, 0.05451422184705734, -0.022831859067082405, -0.022505704313516617, -0.00023895796039141715, 0.053342610597610474, 0.01252516359090805, -0.007311663590371609, -0.021849198266863823, -0.031849462538957596, -0.006258872803300619, 0.04624444618821144, -0.036926139146089554, -0.011342215351760387, -0.01764754392206669, 0.009301943704485893, -0.01579877734184265, -0.013443930074572563, 0.050434403121471405, -0.06209777668118477, 0.07208363711833954, -0.008434527553617954, 0.05096084997057915, 0.006274176761507988, 0.020050106570124626, 0.039097290486097336, -0.008952747099101543, -0.01869156025350094, 0.0446004681289196, 0.053602904081344604, 0.010222836397588253, -0.06940259784460068, 0.010556419380009174, -0.012068417854607105, 0.03461400792002678, 0.027096621692180634, -0.017444133758544922, -0.008208105340600014, 0.0032103026751428843, -0.0486428439617157, 0.039606448262929916, 0.01295466162264347, -0.0027577311266213655, -0.005360443610697985, 0.06048723682761192, 0.03612146154046059, 0.02911495976150036, 0.011777200736105442, -0.010896692052483559, -0.02649424970149994, 0.060080863535404205, 0.026710906997323036, -0.026748603209853172, 0.0027032087091356516, -0.015629708766937256, 0.01831519417464733, 0.008076682686805725, -0.01794040948152542, 0.06802745163440704, -0.04224086552858353, 0.011141379363834858, 0.02715396136045456, -0.06297867745161057, -0.003091881051659584, 0.04382173717021942, 0.023509791120886803, -0.0453965999186039, 0.032601866871118546, -0.009392920881509781, 0.011831256560981274, 0.015445214696228504, 0.01419244334101677, -0.03061898611485958, -0.0342717282474041, 0.0071103391237556934, 0.046155188232660294, -0.0009335544309578836, -0.04664964601397514, -0.0024860745761543512, -0.008142158389091492, -0.03636503592133522, -0.04159020259976387, -0.04203276336193085, 0.006323289591819048, 0.022598430514335632, -0.020259834825992584, 0.03279272839426994, -0.0013734048698097467, 0.006821913179010153, 0.0035362544003874063, 0.050330858677625656, 0.08454930037260056, 0.04285889491438866, -0.0012113159755244851, 0.03801049664616585, -0.022913336753845215, -0.041142549365758896, 0.01738528534770012, -0.000506764801684767, -0.004192848224192858, -0.035923585295677185, 0.05044351518154144, 0.02122252807021141, 0.012210211716592312, 0.06323947757482529, -0.020519880577921867, 0.058466847985982895, 0.007157127372920513, -0.08003748208284378, -0.04907342046499252, 0.038667112588882446, 0.026113077998161316, 0.03480534628033638, -0.050243839621543884, 0.009458625689148903, 0.008165454491972923, 0.04541132226586342, 0.022981610149145126, 0.06002979353070259, 0.005738902371376753, 0.016416477039456367, -0.005528830923140049, -0.034469012171030045, -0.028406184166669846, 0.00915859080851078, 0.010034695267677307, -0.023753724992275238, -0.11216834932565689, 0.05202895402908325, 0.020193831995129585, -0.00674239918589592, 0.014025464653968811, 0.052322063595056534, 0.05129597708582878, -0.004773152060806751, -0.012542285025119781, 0.013052192516624928, -0.03459290787577629, 0.056550901383161545, -0.0018896935507655144, 0.036807578057050705, 0.0456802062690258, 0.008963285945355892, 0.006754623726010323, 0.010957104153931141, 0.03506290912628174, 0.016600066795945168, -0.02640978991985321, 0.0007504522800445557, -0.026294821873307228, 0.003091369057074189, 0.032398223876953125, -0.019365578889846802, 0.014920519664883614, 0.0014160347636789083, -0.029971763491630554, -0.002667112974449992, 0.006217207293957472, -0.01664240099489689, -0.050398923456668854, 0.053243447095155716, -0.06637284904718399, 0.004646379966288805, -0.05517934635281563, -0.005375462118536234, -0.010801133699715137, 0.022182969376444817, 0.025105897337198257, -0.04524253308773041, 0.020686419680714607, 0.023410171270370483, 0.007511807139962912, -0.044301826506853104, -0.009378144517540932, 0.028475049883127213, -0.0549948625266552, 0.0019296887330710888, 0.0312659852206707, 0.021925318986177444, -0.009439845569431782, 0.0068356809206306934, -0.05094797536730766, -0.022506188601255417, 0.014817186631262302, -0.04865151271224022, -0.004689162131398916, 0.00573735823854804, -0.01363483164459467, 0.021032845601439476, -0.017593324184417725, -0.003444839036092162, 0.011815258301794529, -0.01268878672271967, 0.030048837885260582, 0.04673554003238678, -0.004396582022309303, -0.022555818781256676, 0.025502154603600502, 0.015219039283692837, -0.011140596121549606, -0.03854674473404884, 0.0073957196436822414, -0.019879154860973358, -0.034140124917030334, 0.05937204509973526, 0.008592193014919758, -0.006392067763954401, 0.04870646446943283, 0.06858412176370621, -0.0013699086848646402, 0.049380794167518616, 0.02156219072639942, 0.0025846483185887337, -0.03551936522126198, 0.02517513372004032, 0.008765083737671375, 0.005391320679336786, -0.006201295182108879, 0.002932463539764285, -0.016967691481113434, 0.037612587213516235, -0.010638078674674034, 0.04777052626013756, 0.01696835085749626, -0.009236568585038185, 0.014565498568117619, -0.03540607914328575, 0.0040054465644061565, 0.03414793685078621, -0.06507566571235657, -0.039861440658569336, 0.023933695629239082, 0.017147544771432877, 0.003955202177166939, -0.011036266572773457, -0.003509433241561055, 0.024191537871956825, -0.009924657642841339, -0.032135434448719025, -0.0005268067470751703, 0.012640899047255516, -0.03656972199678421, 0.031832050532102585, -0.005935746245086193, -0.03549102321267128, -0.06743184477090836, 0.02386666089296341, 0.04081461578607559, 0.0288393571972847, 0.006843451410531998, 0.0015006219036877155, -0.02068997733294964, 0.025569749996066093, 0.046558208763599396, 0.008495097979903221, 0.01039138063788414, -0.009340131655335426, 0.012079411186277866, -0.020493123680353165, 0.025631001219153404, 0.03044792078435421, -0.014212903566658497, -0.020566487684845924, -0.022955797612667084, 0.04169458523392677, -0.029661983251571655, -0.018318789079785347, -0.07652527838945389, -0.01716001145541668, -0.022525472566485405, -0.03737760707736015, 0.06421428918838501, 0.013287162408232689, -0.014188040979206562, -0.0030129023361951113, -0.06801195442676544, -0.007023265585303307, -0.03770965337753296, 0.014717631042003632, 0.012484952807426453, 0.03432245925068855, 0.023664500564336777, -0.004238251596689224, -0.004969669505953789, 0.028553465381264687, -0.06919874250888824, -0.0673946887254715, 0.013886695727705956, 0.002992332214489579, 0.033458154648542404, 0.006207652390003204, -0.022391291335225105, 0.029641281813383102, 0.04500359669327736, -0.028905583545565605, -0.025624720379710197, -0.012479380704462528, -0.00845661573112011, -0.055878881365060806, 0.03485463932156563, 0.021554499864578247, -0.00840873084962368, 0.04209305718541145, -0.01582823507487774, -0.005591544322669506, 0.02036997489631176, -0.005906432401388884, -0.00006140926416264847, 0.04089231789112091, -0.03755202889442444, -0.005573378875851631, 0.045758094638586044, -0.0008828730788081884, 0.00434387382119894, 0.019005734473466873, -0.034611981362104416, 0.008593595586717129, 0.04846971109509468, -0.03388082981109619, 0.05443596467375755, -0.029665354639291763, -0.020993655547499657, -0.042620088905096054, 0.00879485160112381, -0.0031310224439948797, -0.01617034710943699, -0.014866277575492859, -0.00914024654775858, -0.010745125822722912, 0.010844750329852104, -0.006181572563946247, 0.02469656616449356, 0.036232683807611465, 0.023420030251145363, 0.0037228583823889494, -0.026498954743146896, -0.009560925886034966, 0.02886536531150341, -0.017990589141845703, 0.0013273187214508653, 0.058206211775541306, 0.028427081182599068, 0.024256199598312378, -0.05483193323016167, -0.05025835707783699, -0.02364840731024742, -0.08308621495962143, 0.015280693769454956, -0.05790609493851662, 0.06048116087913513, -0.009205036796629429, 0.016419148072600365, 0.009556296281516552, -0.021423200145363808, -0.013296477496623993, -0.015385286882519722, -0.04804423823952675, 0.03140682727098465, 0.009198574349284172, 0.003095076885074377, 0.019994139671325684, -0.02085687778890133, 0.03439612314105034, -0.040092263370752335, 0.0026342705823481083, 0.022756444290280342, 0.02414226345717907, -0.04808711260557175, -0.02685474045574665, -0.08135396242141724, -0.04253245145082474, -0.0029600709676742554, -0.012525695376098156, -0.0030075237154960632, -0.043095313012599945, 0.017527664080262184, 0.03281846269965172, 0.014191281981766224, 0.0017420114018023014, -0.035790130496025085, 0.021626250818371773, 0.03256339579820633, 0.03869084268808365, 0.047766998410224915, 0.004880701657384634, -0.024392006918787956, 0.04631964489817619, 0.07533171027898788, 0.05566985905170441, 0.014140074141323566, 0.03999266028404236, -0.033134832978248596, -0.02496861107647419, -0.04473618045449257, 0.046483270823955536, -0.004138515796512365, 0.010376532562077045, 0.0018249970162287354, 0.013118370436131954, -0.002771358471363783, -0.04315905272960663, 0.005512623116374016, 0.026611467823386192, -0.016222991049289703, 0.023495901376008987, -0.026485541835427284, -0.018920307978987694, 0.026367146521806717, 0.004689299967139959, 0.026535354554653168, 0.00784702692180872, -0.010176793672144413, -0.0005483978311531246, 0.04640806466341019, -0.01725473813712597, 0.012829545885324478, -0.01611071266233921, 0.031264230608940125, 0.03083128109574318, -0.0032200273126363754, 0.00462309317663312, 0.022196615114808083, 0.018836570903658867, 0.06883995980024338, 0.05921537056565285, 0.02143794484436512, -0.10854952037334442, 0.0033537449780851603, 0.04521150514483452, 0.022136716172099113, -0.03518904000520706, 0.010572530329227448, -0.07776928693056107, -0.032119184732437134, 0.013411669060587883, 0.0030418287497013807, -0.01594517193734646, 0.008631969802081585, 0.03262285143136978, 0.013410096988081932, -0.013898249715566635, -0.027586735785007477, -0.018422743305563927, 0.002347495872527361, 0.03964156657457352, 0.01231635082513094, -0.04949576035141945, -0.06751016527414322, 0.009885409846901894, -0.0066393716260790825, 0.058017995208501816, -0.040493112057447433, -0.020378336310386658, 0.032877758145332336, -0.0038338524755090475, -0.0019962864462286234, -0.09040191024541855, 0.025800760835409164, -0.021013222634792328, -0.007527390494942665, 0.014990121126174927, -0.01116611436009407, -0.04473048076033592, 0.01795302703976631, 0.024654405191540718, -0.012806852348148823, -0.006176396273076534, -0.01371860597282648, 0.021449416875839233, -0.027169806882739067, 0.02499835379421711, 0.028335390612483025, 0.03336314484477043, -0.005494346376508474, -0.014063785783946514, -0.022533686831593513, 0.029200874269008636, -0.01685582473874092, -0.029022665694355965, -0.06026747450232506, -0.012232759036123753, -0.0025380905717611313, 0.03842705488204956, 0.011978697963058949, 0.05273514240980148, -0.044821105897426605, -0.03576527535915375, 0.019902311265468597, 0.047848090529441833, -0.04505688324570656, -0.033148448914289474, 0.0007806885405443609, 0.021784847602248192, -0.013604093343019485, 0.017244556918740273, -0.0020040657836943865, -0.02566366456449032, -0.018733911216259003, 0.03192795440554619, -0.03787172585725784, 0.029815886169672012, -0.03909308835864067, -0.03159573674201965, 0.010945924557745457, -0.0013132771709933877, 0.03903559222817421, -0.011939370073378086, 0.0637352466583252, -0.006965856067836285, -0.026076368987560272, -0.01001411210745573, -0.013259359635412693, -0.013251619413495064, 0.06096853315830231, -0.021526191383600235, -0.022183381021022797, -0.030544165521860123, -0.021474549546837807, -0.07701581716537476, -0.04808906093239784, 0.057191044092178345, -0.0014605745673179626, -0.04347056895494461, -0.014228626154363155, -0.018845049664378166, -0.01754716970026493, -0.006782347336411476, -0.016746435314416885, 0.07016640901565552, -0.033461060374975204, 0.007546704728156328, -0.005109808407723904, 0.049089040607213974, 0.08535535633563995, -0.02295542135834694, 0.012290979735553265, 0.021743305027484894, -0.048870380967855453, -0.05289788544178009, -0.0026211044751107693, 0.02833123691380024, -0.05684015527367592, 0.03361774981021881, -0.010928798466920853, -0.027882233262062073, 0.06929928064346313, -0.052834104746580124, -0.04109686613082886, 0.06034573167562485, 0.005172139499336481, 0.02108854614198208, -0.004338675644248724, -0.005770459771156311, -0.027854878455400467, 0.022805852815508842, -0.005253559444099665, -0.008794214576482773, -0.016442948952317238, 0.003479368519037962, 0.038716189563274384, -0.020463507622480392, 0.006744326092302799, 0.026718968525528908, 0.056806452572345734, -0.011852700263261795, -0.028654420748353004, 0.022433064877986908, -0.010937088169157505, 0.032820869237184525, 0.00224507343955338, -0.005396055988967419, 0.0036018916871398687, 0.043450016528367996, -0.031190374866127968, -0.028583552688360214, 0.0005306912935338914, -0.0012033190578222275, 0.027693891897797585, 0.03203173354268074, 0.03493634983897209, 0.02562134712934494, 0.006805253680795431, -0.004802402574568987, -0.023060109466314316, -0.028876736760139465, -0.008555907756090164, -0.04058682173490524, 0.05003848299384117, -0.03178032487630844, 0.012310395948588848, 0.005329276900738478, -0.01798412576317787, -0.0016853534616529942, 0.08976149559020996, -0.010496743023395538, 0.036099132150411606, 0.039530836045742035, -0.033731937408447266, -0.057873014360666275, 0.07175301760435104, -0.025865692645311356, 0.027409274131059647, 0.012811190448701382, -0.012538056820631027, 0.019005155190825462, 0.040695670992136, -0.0037207251880317926, -0.03654390573501587, -0.04588952288031578, -0.08551902323961258, 0.01480972208082676, 0.03975171223282814, -0.011560470797121525, 0.006159447133541107, 0.03573675453662872, 0.031893715262413025, -0.0038414588198065758, 0.0033971236553043127, -0.016942379996180534, -0.072744220495224, 0.025870997458696365, 0.004425625316798687, -0.0783640593290329, 0.008857861161231995, -0.0354933962225914, -0.007348916959017515, 0.006409700494259596, -0.04532935842871666, 0.021710265427827835, 0.028358720242977142, 0.02015351876616478, -0.0047887894324958324, 0.08211973309516907, -0.00933048501610756, 0.018735673278570175, -0.04488949105143547, 0.04700889065861702, 0.12097053229808807, 0.07562871277332306, 0.038349661976099014, -0.020385650917887688, -0.017987340688705444, -0.015625033527612686, 0.01547795906662941, -0.020146522670984268, 0.04505946487188339, -0.009772688150405884, -0.007554659619927406, 0.03535715490579605, 0.031413864344358444, 0.011183352209627628, -0.02542884647846222, 0.04784686118364334, 0.005819274112582207, 0.008054186590015888, 0.0035867553669959307, 0.01358954980969429, -0.020865075290203094, 0.020114202052354813, -0.0374690480530262, 0.009396549314260483, -0.03562115877866745, -0.03584878891706467, -0.008100667037069798, -0.03509332984685898, 0.015945838764309883, 0.016409261152148247, -0.02710632048547268, 0.011550061404705048, 0.005938950926065445, 0.05037972331047058, 0.005479128565639257, -0.0055563682690262794, 0.0012925239279866219, -0.03526359796524048, 0.03950132802128792, 0.032261986285448074, 0.03836018219590187, 0.00782274454832077, 0.014663993380963802, -0.00976516306400299, -0.03749949857592583, -0.05623113736510277, -0.03186609596014023, 0.032040733844041824, -0.021175365895032883, 0.00479368818923831, -0.02286529168486595, -0.012291576713323593, 0.03184421733021736, -0.03860628604888916, -0.02965962514281273, 0.01427858043462038, 0.007496638689190149, -0.01422090269625187, -0.0209627915173769, -0.01736530475318432, 0.0004414099676068872, -0.011153118684887886, 0.06305166333913803, -0.013091749511659145, -0.048599738627672195, -0.037062253803014755, -0.026248948648571968, 0.04111026972532272, 0.0008533016080036759, -0.0231651458889246, -0.004943491891026497, -0.035290706902742386, -0.043078988790512085, -0.02063359133899212, 0.015120442025363445, -0.014126276597380638, 0.04655023291707039, -0.011282950639724731, -0.003831895301118493, -0.01569969393312931, -0.048395171761512756, 0.008953381329774857, -0.01683443784713745, 0.022972363978624344, -0.022335955873131752, -0.004931264091283083, 0.03432341292500496, 0.01283896155655384, 0.02774132788181305, -0.006188911385834217, -0.006784661207348108, 0.024074742570519447, 0.018031496554613113, -0.06894095242023468, -0.04064160957932472, -0.025394348427653313, -0.03862519934773445, -0.002075843047350645, -0.02213176153600216, 0.05350073054432869, 0.02363538183271885, 0.019644208252429962, -0.046139635145664215, 0.035440098494291306, -0.02084067277610302, 0.018068775534629822, -0.0008752019493840635, -0.06408589333295822, 0.0011749769328162074, 0.009160971269011497, -0.004824892617762089, 0.0048339697532355785, -0.049554307013750076, -0.02242746576666832, -0.005122514441609383, -0.012233552522957325, -0.001641969894990325, -0.04012083262205124, -0.012318232096731663, 0.006616218481212854, 0.022476937621831894, -0.014856690540909767, -0.006115924566984177, -0.02202109806239605, -0.029962388798594475, -0.020331090316176414, 0.02903204783797264, 0.008378751575946808, 0.010301337577402592, -0.007247761357575655, -0.010861225426197052, -0.004032932221889496, 0.0026644601020962, 0.016040746122598648, -0.010022228583693504, -0.00967315025627613, 0.021984659135341644, 0.06575927138328552, -0.012759566307067871, -0.017493711784482002, 0.06701791286468506, -0.021584775298833847, -0.021930694580078125, 0.008735833689570427, 0.0037312929052859545, 0.016276216134428978, 0.011335158720612526, 0.0017172724474221468, -0.02768520452082157, 0.061589185148477554, -0.0040406095795333385, 0.04334951564669609, -0.021757839247584343, 0.01514679566025734, 0.05818192660808563, -0.0017836636397987604, 0.009141343645751476, 0.006822158582508564, -0.023970885202288628, 0.02227185107767582, 0.02815934270620346, 0.034199852496385574, -0.04178232327103615, 0.027328232303261757, -0.03118831105530262, -0.01770123280584812, -0.00011219218140468001, 0.012347251176834106, 0.05115078389644623, 0.026819325983524323, -0.01764802820980549, 0.0026876251213252544, -0.03063262440264225, 0.015799542888998985, -0.038895610719919205, -0.0021461867727339268, 0.025410132482647896, 0.03379024937748909, 0.03412129729986191, -0.02781478315591812, -0.01762601174414158, 0.03982449322938919, -0.018951401114463806, -0.013774625957012177, -0.014449876733124256, 0.033619508147239685, -0.055831022560596466, 0.010904000140726566, -0.03930901736021042, 0.0037849429063498974, -0.01826457679271698, -0.010142626240849495, 0.011215857230126858, 0.03519698232412338, 0.0014617585111409426, -0.010255961678922176, 0.0002911920309998095, 0.03491179645061493, 0.05113039165735245, -0.04783227667212486, 0.02242615446448326, -0.06829194724559784, -0.0068984744139015675, 0.04506145045161247, -0.022745463997125626, 0.01965998113155365, 0.012750509195029736, 0.01704150252044201, -0.003917344845831394, 0.03602788224816322, 0.06571995466947556, 0.0021185423247516155, 0.02088528871536255, -0.007119594607502222, 0.024881090968847275, -0.014719107188284397, -0.043117646127939224, 0.007676082197576761, -0.007048419676721096, -0.051091231405735016, -0.017206663265824318, 0.020964128896594048, -0.023368658497929573, 0.0007116486667655408, -0.002436994109302759, 0.012121200561523438, 0.0018593965796753764, -0.00968796107918024, 0.028339531272649765, -0.015862271189689636, 0.0343950130045414, 0.05210929736495018, 0.035542525351047516, -0.03318953514099121, 0.034624360501766205, 0.028129298239946365, -0.046628985553979874, -0.008291319943964481, -0.03997593745589256, -0.00952795147895813, -0.03697582334280014, -0.03721242398023605, -0.0029375788290053606, 0.04074965417385101, -0.049114882946014404, 0.012079589068889618, -0.024520041421055794, 0.020319638773798943, -0.03215350955724716, -0.01480573695152998, 0.009782927110791206, -0.02918369509279728, 0.014466337859630585, -0.09494994580745697, 0.07223129272460938, 0.0046583060175180435, -0.02922854758799076, -0.019463343545794487, -0.017434272915124893, -0.021568121388554573, -0.013757778331637383, 0.047397784888744354, 0.0031461999751627445, 0.0031776477117091417, 0.000806327851023525, 0.03072904795408249, 0.008297961205244064, -0.017600806429982185, 0.054105788469314575, 0.006745464168488979, -0.03371288999915123, 0.015643414109945297, -0.014160031452775002, 0.04385954886674881, -0.00391443632543087, 0.034542933106422424, -0.027391914278268814, 0.021258072927594185, 0.020645683631300926, -0.01791580766439438, 0.022378329187631607, 0.014471137896180153, -0.036586590111255646, 0.03177141025662422, -0.006981286685913801, 0.00723010441288352, 0.00025539181660860777, -0.026950150728225708, -0.04103820398449898, 0.004597190301865339, -0.008376521058380604, -0.03051777370274067, 0.029029080644249916, 0.013618424534797668, -0.004439045209437609, -0.05182025209069252, -0.015015432611107826, 0.010781614109873772, 0.003183797001838684, 0.010519237257540226, 0.05131150409579277, -0.018215661868453026, 0.0383215956389904, -0.011275917291641235, 0.0025276020169258118, 0.02083323523402214, 0.023181388154625893, -0.031483348459005356, 0.01972034201025963, 0.04147958382964134, 0.004796418361365795, -0.010574430227279663, 0.0161497313529253, -0.009292147122323513, 0.03766076639294624, -0.018417472019791603, 0.027617448940873146, -0.008157537318766117, -0.0045882840640842915, 0.041604071855545044, 0.01651790551841259, -0.008004748262465, 0.018972164019942284, -0.009824736043810844, 0.057565897703170776, -0.0000764273718232289, -0.00913931243121624, -0.021687963977456093, 0.007871820591390133, -0.04924491420388222, 0.0310900267213583, -0.007083293981850147, 0.022654784843325615, -0.004456489346921444, -0.012039880268275738, -0.03194345906376839, -0.010513074696063995, 0.026903724297881126, -0.022256365045905113, -0.006645648740231991, -0.01810162328183651, 0.031049730256199837, -0.022704150527715683, -0.03889121487736702, -0.03393579646945, -0.0310053750872612, 0.01953531615436077, 0.016331197693943977, 0.05623982846736908, -0.013591764494776726, -0.03978363797068596, 0.01843280717730522, 0.05593230202794075, -0.04008173570036888, -0.010722078382968903, 0.00020968864555470645, -0.0078422324731946, -0.02240574359893799, -0.04468763992190361 ]
<p>According to the WinBUGS manual the gamma distribution is defined by:</p> <p><code>dgamma(r,mu)</code></p> <p>However, what is <code>r</code>? Is it the shape, scale or rate parameter? I'm pretty new to statistics and googling didn't really help. Above that in most explanations I've found <code>r</code>is usually not mentioned. It's either k, <code>theta</code>, <code>beta</code> or <code>alpha</code>.</p>
73,912
[ -0.020065806806087494, -0.03291523456573486, 0.016543317586183548, -0.020776748657226562, 0.01039885077625513, 0.03087974153459072, -0.0011560139246284962, -0.004083458799868822, 0.018343456089496613, -0.05593470484018326, 0.05729082226753235, 0.04027211293578148, 0.049511779099702835, 0.0036565044429153204, 0.024067817255854607, 0.010994384065270424, -0.02731282077729702, -0.0016495485324412584, -0.025905421003699303, -0.031209124252200127, 0.018747368827462196, -0.0057050553150475025, 0.0007386088836938143, -0.029923683032393456, -0.019807126373052597, 0.04354241117835045, 0.020501263439655304, 0.01268764864653349, 0.013515029102563858, 0.05458235740661621, -0.04430859163403511, -0.02158917300403118, 0.0022587876301258802, 0.024813508614897728, -0.006959369871765375, 0.006091280374675989, -0.02541569620370865, -0.02489839494228363, -0.03448697179555893, 0.05521300062537193, -0.03157327324151993, -0.02229669690132141, 0.007384130265563726, -0.006166952196508646, -0.017137518152594566, 0.009886224754154682, 0.001108573516830802, -0.028347281739115715, 0.04562048986554146, -0.03243061155080795, 0.07530716061592102, -0.013021765276789665, 0.030923357233405113, 0.013629493303596973, -0.012014292180538177, -0.010365472175180912, 0.0725766271352768, 0.05923525243997574, -0.01621992699801922, -0.059028685092926025, -0.0016321574803441763, -0.032966673374176025, -0.014973945915699005, -0.03293623775243759, 0.01026411447674036, 0.018723171204328537, -0.015226193703711033, -0.010497371666133404, 0.0476154163479805, 0.03808604180812836, 0.033093083649873734, 0.05999532341957092, 0.040943387895822525, 0.024349793791770935, 0.05259019136428833, -0.028633976355195045, 0.01420064177364111, 0.006051795557141304, 0.038012273609638214, 0.02031599171459675, -0.01903703808784485, 0.03342410922050476, 0.023341147229075432, 0.0011373263550922275, 0.004599668085575104, -0.0017104342114180326, 0.0831671804189682, -0.002019098959863186, 0.012431265786290169, 0.011440547183156013, -0.032936643809080124, 0.017442626878619194, 0.01884765736758709, -0.009120791219174862, -0.011068389751017094, 0.06465502828359604, -0.018529312685132027, 0.051136214286088943, -0.0009226003894582391, -0.015122594311833382, -0.0024659025948494673, -0.049681078642606735, 0.02209838666021824, 0.07841187715530396, -0.03178738057613373, -0.018057873472571373, -0.038673631846904755, -0.013137469999492168, -0.017973650246858597, -0.042034924030303955, -0.04766868054866791, 0.012058336287736893, -0.023999687284231186, 0.0020579288247972727, 0.05675715580582619, 0.01402683649212122, 0.003102309303358197, 0.042348094284534454, 0.07579544931650162, 0.03783305734395981, 0.03965981677174568, -0.029949747025966644, 0.01932448148727417, 0.0011301384074613452, -0.04351969435811043, 0.015976229682564735, 0.010838585905730724, -0.023464541882276535, -0.0778660774230957, 0.03658922389149666, -0.03864660859107971, -0.03256194293498993, 0.041688233613967896, 0.002307402901351452, 0.008847473189234734, -0.001775877783074975, -0.04993697255849838, -0.07421478629112244, 0.023968059569597244, -0.007549630012363195, -0.0024083848111331463, -0.06193229928612709, -0.010031655430793762, 0.015605056658387184, 0.061293404549360275, -0.00257544731721282, 0.010186907835304737, -0.0038640398997813463, 0.012623357586562634, -0.01963716186583042, -0.023523731157183647, -0.002541958587244153, -0.012294014915823936, -0.02357560768723488, 0.006010553799569607, -0.03826812654733658, 0.012264054268598557, 0.005825831554830074, -0.0113989794626832, -0.0165563952177763, 0.04484718292951584, -0.01871059276163578, 0.0013018822064623237, -0.008476749993860722, -0.02925000712275505, -0.04106365889310837, 0.06859633326530457, 0.005415786057710648, 0.018767092376947403, 0.017892051488161087, -0.008289959281682968, 0.03476894274353981, 0.019975880160927773, 0.034006938338279724, 0.05437349155545235, -0.0011016560019925237, -0.046285469084978104, -0.024727363139390945, 0.002899190643802285, -0.001959599554538727, -0.044884245842695236, -0.005207601934671402, 0.006517349276691675, -0.015341261401772499, 0.028323670849204063, 0.01248524896800518, -0.01368425041437149, -0.009267818182706833, 0.016450533643364906, -0.02567557990550995, -0.04531879723072052, -0.02452169544994831, 0.006313145626336336, -0.06292078644037247, -0.00041321219759993255, -0.009772762656211853, 0.005066219717264175, 0.00840661209076643, 0.015048627741634846, -0.014040120877325535, -0.021863695234060287, 0.008103507570922375, 0.028630556538701057, -0.02047915942966938, -0.004225168842822313, 0.05645084008574486, 0.04935150593519211, -0.05011099949479103, 0.025157837197184563, -0.006584312301129103, 0.0018851289059966803, -0.0049522267654538155, -0.03685977682471275, 0.007685318123549223, -0.028351174667477608, -0.027441980317234993, -0.0073743234388530254, 0.043869830667972565, -0.014635425060987473, -0.001614497508853674, -0.03443122282624245, 0.029552176594734192, 0.05416582524776459, 0.02130158431828022, 0.0233958400785923, 0.003101886948570609, -0.03275628015398979, 0.01899861916899681, -0.040927570313215256, -0.016191698610782623, -0.038813136518001556, 0.009144957177340984, 0.04435068741440773, -0.031677693128585815, -0.040879834443330765, 0.007168920710682869, 0.019685151055455208, 0.05646964907646179, 0.003974342253059149, 0.030850276350975037, 0.0016752739902585745, -0.014013690873980522, -0.01499667577445507, 0.01137138158082962, -0.009769456461071968, -0.018081605434417725, 0.03860455006361008, 0.01732158288359642, 0.04488849267363548, -0.02267531491816044, 0.01642969623208046, 0.04870200902223587, -0.040735334157943726, -0.006616354454308748, -0.03878868371248245, -0.02854466438293457, 0.07849016785621643, -0.04071429744362831, -0.014288978651165962, 0.030595535412430763, -0.023304004222154617, -0.0010433252900838852, 0.013365519233047962, -0.032151538878679276, 0.01666090451180935, 0.038648445159196854, -0.007442505098879337, -0.0032446435652673244, -0.002187622245401144, -0.015228109434247017, -0.0004475736932363361, -0.022453369572758675, -0.02099723555147648, -0.02681485004723072, 0.018081746995449066, 0.014773475006222725, 0.020208699628710747, 0.012078996747732162, 0.004141034558415413, -0.03847477212548256, -0.010590353980660439, -0.023141268640756607, -0.0065470109693706036, 0.011837567202746868, -0.02721152827143669, -0.005776369944214821, -0.008124098181724548, 0.001999117434024811, -0.010682540014386177, -0.01221935823559761, -0.04160528630018234, 0.011220978572964668, -0.01484435610473156, -0.06642085313796997, 0.012540308758616447, 0.009942732751369476, 0.04077250882983208, -0.047449514269828796, -0.0005037367227487266, 0.059410758316516876, -0.016057826578617096, -0.022730303928256035, 0.03468902409076691, -0.05779698118567467, -0.03330407291650772, -0.03165305033326149, 0.015845177695155144, 0.025536470115184784, 0.006187682040035725, 0.013218650594353676, 0.05188705027103424, -0.07133494317531586, 0.01874961145222187, -0.031887661665678024, -0.024539168924093246, -0.009041663259267807, -0.010361475870013237, -0.013225957751274109, -0.00629699882119894, -0.010576180182397366, 0.06982016563415527, 0.012162862345576286, -0.011956513859331608, -0.02062397450208664, 0.029702726751565933, -0.044031474739313126, -0.041714493185281754, 0.03579053282737732, 0.031289391219615936, 0.024261610582470894, -0.010241868905723095, -0.005523126106709242, 0.038855817168951035, 0.023473991081118584, -0.009757954627275467, 0.023741837590932846, 0.0415654256939888, 0.028540583327412605, -0.03307705372571945, 0.052821241319179535, 0.016440926119685173, -0.01113105844706297, 0.013319541700184345, 0.015279443003237247, 0.029706116765737534, 0.01256213802844286, -0.00758783845230937, -0.0031361777801066637, 0.0005353560554794967, 0.002275304403156042, -0.002785459626466036, -0.005262529943138361, 0.030142543837428093, -0.06149623543024063, -0.009246569126844406, 0.024968504905700684, 0.06176894158124924, -0.03516770526766777, -0.0014899912057444453, 0.010733477771282196, 0.06055869162082672, -0.0651734471321106, -0.03802903741598129, -0.007079362403601408, -0.03225967288017273, 0.007824736647307873, 0.010078639723360538, 0.02161848358809948, 0.08180489391088486, 0.01608813740313053, 0.010462203063070774, -0.01144341193139553, -0.07062716782093048, -0.028816184028983116, -0.09466821700334549, 0.004273399710655212, -0.02915492281317711, 0.03338101506233215, 0.01174881961196661, 0.05950611084699631, 0.04300474002957344, -0.030523473396897316, 0.03195520117878914, 0.010609670542180538, -0.04162515699863434, 0.05041472986340523, -0.035236284136772156, -0.004761084448546171, 0.007220200262963772, -0.026025237515568733, 0.010000009089708328, 0.019756311550736427, 0.0006271866150200367, 0.010469196364283562, -0.03270495682954788, -0.011415397748351097, 0.009849549271166325, -0.005396540276706219, -0.0291137658059597, -0.0032665126491338015, 0.014190709218382835, -0.008610028773546219, -0.015440884977579117, 0.021351702511310577, 0.06218113750219345, 0.012375707738101482, 0.01329740323126316, -0.016329331323504448, 0.00838466640561819, 0.0135507145896554, 0.02208803780376911, 0.025227898731827736, 0.011646314524114132, -0.014287371188402176, -0.008377904072403908, 0.03629795461893082, 0.05201716721057892, 0.05548861250281334, -0.0344366654753685, -0.014828591607511044, -0.050881121307611465, -0.012251749634742737, 0.0073608760721981525, -0.0014446136774495244, 0.022870423272252083, 0.008531379513442516, 0.05225290358066559, 0.03133352845907211, -0.045911770313978195, 0.028200624510645866, 0.07859832048416138, 0.005426997784525156, -0.052091874182224274, -0.032943204045295715, 0.00832399819046259, 0.0030220423359423876, 0.0002512980136089027, -0.01229092851281166, 0.0408078134059906, -0.03323889896273613, 0.005962110590189695, 0.023158010095357895, -0.03166588768362999, -0.023457089439034462, -0.062242988497018814, 0.036143891513347626, 0.006404051091521978, -0.018307019025087357, -0.04258660599589348, 0.022342514246702194, 0.017763672396540642, 0.043729495257139206, 0.0339876264333725, -0.03144966810941696, -0.03636031970381737, 0.012541445903480053, 0.05133993923664093, 0.01628824695944786, -0.020532650873064995, -0.039450209587812424, -0.02159300073981285, 0.017348727211356163, 0.028780948370695114, -0.03114958480000496, 0.041142430156469345, -0.033959899097681046, 0.02303495444357395, 0.008476046845316887, -0.01335963886231184, -0.0242544487118721, 0.043410345911979675, -0.009086216799914837, 0.0111739132553339, -0.023630501702427864, 0.0032769059762358665, -0.024532172828912735, 0.029792988672852516, -0.0015678376657888293, 0.055435553193092346, -0.017885422334074974, -0.021590718999505043, 0.001563612837344408, 0.016513824462890625, 0.027730770409107208, -0.06235872581601143, 0.025013651698827744, -0.0030037567485123873, -0.002775884000584483, 0.04377476125955582, -0.019202087074518204, -0.03413621708750725, -0.009377806447446346, 0.03664594888687134, -0.016620080918073654, 0.012839390896260738, -0.05657639354467392, 0.05693894624710083, 0.06590845435857773, 0.01306932047009468, 0.05950543284416199, 0.031009195372462273, -0.0017401418881490827, -0.04526926577091217, -0.07441394776105881, 0.03325658291578293, -0.03139367699623108, 0.004105703439563513, -0.04537651315331459, 0.006734645925462246, -0.009459123015403748, 0.023324931040406227, 0.02486938238143921, 0.02199515700340271, -0.02112698368728161, -0.011881997808814049, -0.039203546941280365, 0.010873591527342796, -0.03974002227187157, -0.012677333317697048, 0.05023195594549179, 0.028891419991850853, -0.014849965460598469, 0.006474635563790798, 0.02199048176407814, -0.024764133617281914, -0.030049793422222137, 0.053813863545656204, -0.02405676245689392, 0.001544936210848391, 0.008230634033679962, -0.014004030264914036, 0.020487897098064423, -0.034949395805597305, 0.04509890079498291, -0.005339737515896559, 0.003656806191429496, 0.007522218395024538, -0.05696694180369377, -0.032185811549425125, -0.005309849977493286, 0.0012176618911325932, 0.05399118736386299, -0.0482645221054554, 0.06962627917528152, -0.02106359414756298, 0.0045847478322684765, -0.09251963347196579, -0.05911411717534065, 0.05045833811163902, -0.01267215609550476, -0.03844773769378662, -0.016752973198890686, 0.020057784393429756, -0.009718758054077625, -0.025098156183958054, 0.005876446608453989, 0.04037992283701897, -0.0067233555018901825, -0.005044412799179554, -0.028979025781154633, 0.01833622343838215, 0.08471957594156265, 0.02184535749256611, -0.028935657814145088, 0.06254801154136658, 0.0041964091360569, -0.004371430724859238, 0.015839822590351105, 0.03834913671016693, -0.027863942086696625, 0.0208634864538908, -0.017843447625637054, 0.009341226890683174, 0.04686247557401657, -0.022242477163672447, -0.01201130822300911, 0.028217509388923645, 0.006128298118710518, 0.02108115330338478, -0.024131355807185173, 0.011234968900680542, -0.016395404934883118, 0.011060075834393501, -0.030131958425045013, -0.05430188030004501, -0.03118239715695381, 0.02532581053674221, 0.04639222472906113, 0.0358133539557457, 0.001767116249538958, 0.06150375306606293, 0.07389897853136063, -0.03313300758600235, -0.014784315600991249, -0.04512224718928337, -0.020098356530070305, 0.022097747772932053, 0.012853621505200863, 0.003156939521431923, -0.006601412780582905, 0.0021940162405371666, -0.03236870840191841, 0.018126776441931725, -0.06270037591457367, 0.004424738697707653, 0.06616878509521484, 0.014343536458909512, 0.04928040876984596, -0.022901223972439766, -0.011479705572128296, 0.01416485570371151, -0.031039491295814514, -0.02113252878189087, -0.0534299872815609, 0.017559293657541275, 0.03685814142227173, 0.006334373261779547, -0.015562975779175758, 0.011630360968410969, 0.0006256626220420003, -0.008088212460279465, 0.03880909085273743, 0.03237612545490265, 0.01234646700322628, 0.00231531891040504, -0.014597508125007153, -0.04272749274969101, 0.038100700825452805, -0.044194065034389496, 0.015115737915039062, -0.00426057493314147, 0.0008276078151538968, 0.046200770884752274, 0.01591668650507927, 0.014778459444642067, -0.05005410686135292, 0.024295775219798088, -0.03464527055621147, 0.010796943679451942, 0.009216940961778164, -0.024727314710617065, 0.00635312357917428, -0.028718484565615654, 0.021302388980984688, -0.0075861262157559395, 0.02219010517001152, -0.03412600979208946, -0.0480489619076252, -0.03582127019762993, -0.03420844301581383, -0.04745134338736534, 0.023174650967121124, -0.0011911762412637472, -0.05587964877486229, -0.018577832728624344, -0.04257076978683472, 0.03699369728565216, 0.00627803523093462, 0.027355266734957695, 0.0012808038154616952, 0.09690685570240021, -0.02174047753214836, 0.012771581299602985, 0.006986144930124283, -0.04350154101848602, 0.12042661756277084, 0.06890356540679932, 0.005727189593017101, -0.025189297273755074, -0.015433846972882748, -0.021604958921670914, 0.018581176176667213, 0.022460905835032463, -0.002612318843603134, 0.020674917846918106, -0.009119323454797268, 0.056590620428323746, 0.021268362179398537, 0.025549154728651047, 0.008767076767981052, 0.05148197337985039, -0.02813165821135044, -0.04263054579496384, 0.021945763379335403, 0.020118266344070435, -0.005342116579413414, 0.010200328193604946, -0.037910014390945435, 0.0009971061954274774, 0.019338298588991165, 0.0023749510291963816, -0.02642940543591976, -0.028426287695765495, -0.012974750250577927, -0.006784379482269287, -0.012248847633600235, -0.03486389294266701, -0.01055477187037468, 0.036150600761175156, 0.02158254012465477, -0.024790674448013306, 0.009828423149883747, -0.01586654968559742, 0.001831608358770609, 0.0145788062363863, 0.03266851603984833, 0.015194091945886612, -0.019551105797290802, 0.014432116411626339, -0.045343417674303055, -0.01272409688681364, 0.005363604053854942, -0.005753044504672289, -0.033457837998867035, 0.008825141005218029, -0.018630538135766983, 0.045809876173734665, -0.04724590852856636, -0.034678276628255844, 0.0071283793076872826, 0.0030439277179539204, -0.00412293104454875, -0.0034651514142751694, -0.044550709426403046, -0.013583993539214134, 0.005522686522454023, -0.06089223921298981, 0.05143512785434723, 0.0004036020836792886, -0.0324791744351387, 0.01701822504401207, -0.06658416241407394, 0.06624022871255875, -0.03921645134687424, 0.001244253944605589, 0.02544230781495571, -0.025659138336777687, -0.025169318541884422, -0.011201107874512672, 0.025795379653573036, 0.007350176107138395, -0.005815775599330664, 0.008893691934645176, 0.007834568619728088, -0.017960404977202415, -0.024717874825000763, 0.024648595601320267, 0.002067592926323414, -0.03195150941610336, -0.051228176802396774, -0.005245749372988939, -0.004043099004775286, 0.05114346370100975, 0.004504261538386345, 0.018411841243505478, -0.045061416923999786, 0.0294264554977417, 0.02758878655731678, -0.033151909708976746, 0.013603980652987957, 0.04698966071009636, -0.02324577048420906, -0.020692866295576096, -0.005192633718252182, 0.046161577105522156, 0.028909439221024513, 0.027960393577814102, -0.00662755873054266, -0.007331338245421648, -0.013692853972315788, -0.018884360790252686, -0.021931782364845276, -0.03066614642739296, -0.002046573208644986, -0.0219923984259367, -0.03925033286213875, -0.05733221396803856, -0.016975918784737587, -0.03751828894019127, 0.00509979110211134, -0.019206849858164787, 0.010395416989922523, -0.04802148789167404, -0.02454756759107113, -0.0289588775485754, -0.027388669550418854, 0.012295644730329514, -0.021955039352178574, -0.0001326985948253423, 0.0063303494825959206, -0.022588344290852547, -0.0073212748393416405, 0.005141862668097019, 0.022690802812576294, 0.011754004284739494, 0.0006071034003980458, -0.009521793574094772, 0.039569124579429626, 0.013087132945656776, 0.04167214035987854, -0.020792361348867416, -0.007733281701803207, 0.04492701217532158, -0.017052292823791504, 0.010815821588039398, 0.03326203674077988, -0.05633927509188652, -0.03624458983540535, 0.02272794209420681, -0.00993441790342331, 0.02622547373175621, -0.0072049289010465145, -0.0015853273216634989, 0.019605793058872223, 0.0412570983171463, -0.019183753058314323, -0.014132113195955753, -0.0013892307179048657, 0.0014061869587749243, 0.01878610998392105, 0.007869317196309566, -0.005542651284486055, -0.012367630377411842, 0.014858988113701344, 0.022876054048538208, 0.009357682429254055, -0.04631834849715233, 0.020055321976542473, -0.0026379895862191916, 0.00022498365433420986, 0.005975669715553522, 0.01819661073386669, 0.006461150478571653, 0.054054804146289825, 0.0281179491430521, -0.0010905965464189649, 0.034749019891023636, -0.03774503618478775, -0.007199128158390522, -0.10935243964195251, -0.04020499065518379, 0.033187385648489, -0.032302144914865494, 0.04541805386543274, -0.059333015233278275, 0.009814382530748844, 0.01785673014819622, -0.06813465058803558, 0.008071796968579292, -0.009014089591801167, -0.0030350014567375183, -0.03499972075223923, 0.005490844137966633, -0.005647070240229368, 0.06715953350067139, 0.012592349201440811, 0.05752858519554138, 0.05649435520172119, -0.028542807325720787, -0.011739195324480534, -0.029483774676918983, -0.003888571634888649, 0.03623552992939949, -0.00923190824687481, -0.035581257194280624, 0.05344795808196068, -0.0342039130628109, 0.0027995994314551353, 0.024822473526000977, -0.03104066662490368, 0.03037359192967415, 0.0316312238574028, 0.018061866983771324, 0.002499210648238659, 0.06170370429754257, 0.07221612334251404, -0.02888393960893154, -0.057196445763111115, 0.0022557030897587538, 0.06653180718421936, 0.06538791954517365, -0.017622103914618492, -0.006226500030606985, 0.0094284163787961, -0.023034164682030678, -0.0164052601903677, 0.026459502056241035, -0.039421066641807556, -0.05564132705330849, 0.014342382550239563, -0.005952038336545229, 0.0006215207395143807, -0.043919969350099564, 0.03341804817318916, -0.04844243824481964, -0.01816514879465103, 0.022738195955753326, 0.02172532118856907, 0.016664516180753708, 0.0013001160696148872, -0.006551951635628939, -0.03612856566905975, -0.03279498592019081, 0.011001495644450188, -0.03371035307645798, -0.011340450495481491, 0.03426210582256317, 0.02710622549057007, 0.007744211703538895, -0.008181306533515453, 0.00012864322343375534, -0.04022450000047684, 0.045722488313913345, -0.0009254952892661095, -0.021076936274766922, 0.05863969027996063, -0.013995383866131306, 0.039250679314136505, -0.08512764424085617, 0.057619430124759674, -0.018770365044474602, -0.03831072524189949, -0.04148552939295769, -0.025747235864400864, -0.01946576125919819, -0.011784137226641178, 0.0758485198020935, 0.02100827544927597, -0.025125088170170784, 0.00975438766181469, 0.04461131617426872, 0.002075069583952427, -0.07180768251419067, 0.008599628694355488, -0.012164332903921604, -0.028164556249976158, -0.025834979489445686, 0.029823048040270805, 0.0019068876281380653, 0.0019468729151412845, -0.016477322205901146, 0.013857483863830566, 0.017434384673833847, -0.021476048976182938, -0.027189800515770912, 0.028310060501098633, 0.015988094732165337, -0.03453564643859863, 0.037633080035448074, -0.03355717658996582, -0.008596736937761307, 0.05990757420659065, 0.014401718974113464, -0.03303974121809006, 0.05273446440696716, -0.002784880343824625, -0.02953176014125347, 0.03008933551609516, 0.007977645844221115, 0.026870829984545708, -0.0432186983525753, -0.017684565857052803, 0.059436798095703125, -0.032872945070266724, -0.020881392061710358, 0.016691913828253746, 0.04639194533228874, 0.07045859098434448, -0.0019841408357024193, -0.033098820596933365, 0.022425679489970207, -0.032336004078388214, -0.023029452189803123, 0.028707988560199738, 0.009211943484842777, -0.01773853786289692, 0.013188422657549381, -0.009211662225425243, -0.02283342555165291, 0.0289570651948452, -0.018337460234761238, 0.06627000868320465, -0.003388558281585574, -0.010210730135440826, 0.0151894586160779, 0.014619528315961361, 0.034485626965761185, 0.01005857065320015, -0.009132823906838894, 0.0523824617266655, -0.0009186272509396076, 0.004697431344538927, 0.0020518151577562094, -0.009873481467366219, -0.05245502293109894, 0.001339802984148264, 0.03963644430041313, 0.027996286749839783, 0.015436043962836266, 0.015467141754925251, 0.00347996992059052, 0.006241147872060537, 0.04951689764857292, -0.03887886554002762, 0.03131365031003952, 0.01667945459485054, 0.01897588185966015, -0.03823813796043396, 0.0037155919708311558, -0.013463705778121948, -0.006173832807689905, 0.014774194918572903, 0.0022255312651395798, -0.00925290398299694, 0.00010319013381376863, -0.02152961678802967, -0.0059147304855287075, 0.06040337309241295, -0.04246308654546738, -0.02444850280880928, -0.045708104968070984, 0.011815526522696018, 0.026471255347132683, 0.0034871846437454224 ]
<p>For Univariate Linear Regression I can calculate the parameters (And most everything else) from simple sum of squares. Is there a corresponding method for Logistic Regression? Any pointers to code (in any language) would be helpful.</p> <p>(Yes there are many solvers, but I want to implement as a simple Map-Reduce algorithm, as I have for Univariate Linear Regression)</p>
73,913
[ -0.04055188596248627, 0.0009843131992965937, -0.025493012741208076, 0.01117615308612585, 0.03825482726097107, -0.00006847029726486653, -0.013880504295229912, -0.012583748437464237, 0.052976153790950775, -0.05414067208766937, 0.04671672731637955, 0.03164646029472351, 0.02887677401304245, 0.009123903699219227, 0.020021289587020874, -0.0294538252055645, -0.023512108251452446, 0.015530179254710674, 0.006358305923640728, -0.006620785221457481, 0.0225458275526762, 0.0019637758377939463, 0.02976609207689762, 0.006098083686083555, 0.010179715231060982, 0.03888693079352379, 0.030271941795945168, -0.02024172805249691, -0.015438740141689777, 0.08747276663780212, -0.026734480634331703, -0.010530930943787098, 0.028259985148906708, 0.06691261380910873, 0.04111017286777496, 0.01917305216193199, -0.012381302192807198, -0.02944856509566307, -0.041778501123189926, 0.027497882023453712, 0.012608399614691734, -0.056435778737068176, -0.00020878271607216448, 0.011150755919516087, -0.017452077940106392, 0.01752324029803276, -0.026011504232883453, -0.03701511397957802, -0.0043658665381371975, -0.05653189867734909, 0.0800352469086647, -0.0055819484405219555, 0.05317319184541702, 0.03123518079519272, -0.03241240978240967, 0.03028099425137043, 0.028906045481562614, 0.057947199791669846, 0.004917559679597616, -0.06044944375753403, -0.01702817715704441, -0.008652245625853539, 0.023510485887527466, -0.03718842193484306, -0.0573761872947216, -0.00009841766586760059, -0.005778209771960974, -0.03221982717514038, 0.03297131136059761, -0.005103917792439461, 0.009302019141614437, 0.023048164322972298, 0.04862270504236221, -0.008879810571670532, -0.002759769791737199, -0.014279150404036045, -0.003606231417506933, -0.0007025786908343434, 0.03874344751238823, -0.006000312976539135, 0.007900817319750786, 0.017921755090355873, 0.048224084079265594, 0.013477712869644165, 0.005958188325166702, -0.01275242306292057, 0.056951045989990234, 0.001970734680071473, 0.017619196325540543, 0.02584933303296566, -0.014724580571055412, 0.003899038303643465, 0.03769175335764885, -0.0021145830396562815, -0.045785948634147644, -0.00906215701252222, -0.004633304197341204, 0.03930927813053131, 0.033980127424001694, 0.021776657551527023, -0.009578499011695385, -0.028488272801041603, -0.0067483363673090935, 0.054804909974336624, -0.02371649257838726, -0.01741432584822178, -0.025728842243552208, -0.0007719765999354422, -0.005826192907989025, -0.038681693375110626, -0.010055691003799438, -0.028883546590805054, -0.012913238257169724, -0.025631936267018318, 0.01668207161128521, -0.025039242580533028, -0.05821520462632179, -0.053864121437072754, 0.030987365171313286, 0.06303910166025162, 0.02327582985162735, -0.04129105061292648, 0.035546332597732544, -0.004786741454154253, -0.052145861089229584, 0.016286512836813927, -0.002312975935637951, -0.02077735774219036, -0.04920133948326111, 0.05977044999599457, -0.000974118709564209, -0.07983969897031784, 0.03591945022344589, 0.020414916798472404, 0.004626158624887466, 0.004443202167749405, -0.038117796182632446, -0.06315180659294128, -0.019731678068637848, -0.009004496969282627, 0.011728649958968163, -0.022264814004302025, 0.006648148875683546, 0.025573458522558212, 0.026817521080374718, 0.03238065168261528, 0.023281089961528778, 0.030077558010816574, 0.018730495125055313, 0.007737279403954744, -0.011448473669588566, -0.02224086970090866, -0.033285848796367645, -0.015589913353323936, 0.006550834514200687, -0.0743633508682251, 0.010641592554748058, 0.023748960345983505, -0.0016237330855801702, -0.012894303537905216, 0.04164505749940872, 0.02304462157189846, 0.009107922203838825, 0.021770713850855827, -0.018761293962597847, -0.02086780220270157, 0.06321372091770172, -0.012828627601265907, 0.039680369198322296, -0.00007433706923620775, -0.02292550913989544, -0.02201978489756584, 0.027214836329221725, 0.03445322811603546, 0.05601846054196358, -0.005771346390247345, -0.01928289420902729, -0.03541949391365051, 0.01972503587603569, 0.04342427849769592, -0.015632065013051033, -0.04947507753968239, 0.012099073268473148, -0.02566089853644371, 0.036468081176280975, 0.05098794773221016, 0.004922752268612385, -0.0464056134223938, 0.037194572389125824, -0.06929182261228561, -0.018634699285030365, -0.05745124816894531, 0.02020586095750332, 0.017836613580584526, 0.0042516812682151794, 0.02564222924411297, 0.018370376899838448, 0.015414075925946236, -0.005368479527533054, -0.004579045344144106, -0.012224743142724037, 0.013336746953427792, 0.05542357638478279, -0.03673657029867172, -0.008306333795189857, 0.05895164608955383, 0.05497368425130844, -0.021419277414679527, 0.08811385184526443, -0.04586784169077873, -0.03573152422904968, -0.00556596927344799, -0.013422716408967972, -0.01873592659831047, -0.03408943861722946, -0.03128761798143387, 0.004609240684658289, 0.010453479364514351, -0.03175562247633934, 0.028739551082253456, -0.08364373445510864, 0.0492437481880188, 0.07727831602096558, 0.03332814574241638, 0.019283300265669823, 0.005442493595182896, -0.011069769971072674, 0.013896363787353039, -0.02800494246184826, -0.015425216406583786, -0.018599320203065872, -0.00763699971139431, 0.007989772595465183, 0.01919243112206459, -0.04150151461362839, -0.007717284373939037, 0.09583716839551926, 0.011634750291705132, 0.0494738332927227, 0.009774483740329742, -0.047567788511514664, 0.0028450991958379745, -0.0012333199847489595, 0.01671980880200863, 0.0026134185027331114, 0.006637574639171362, -0.009789574891328812, 0.015750031918287277, 0.02547675184905529, 0.0020161105785518885, -0.04482974857091904, 0.004132197704166174, 0.008259017020463943, -0.05068538710474968, -0.04653558135032654, -0.017896078526973724, 0.03520972654223442, -0.005294081289321184, 0.020619314163923264, 0.023786304518580437, 0.03800605610013008, 0.006254898849874735, -0.006748504471033812, -0.006521693896502256, 0.01024056039750576, 0.036714937537908554, -0.053825873881578445, 0.019049879163503647, 0.026330986991524696, -0.05159924551844597, 0.036376792937517166, -0.021506886929273605, -0.0047835600562393665, -0.03948424383997917, 0.03035079687833786, -0.004796717781573534, 0.017232785001397133, 0.009984772652387619, -0.010991712100803852, -0.032619409263134, 0.01324498001486063, -0.02537616156041622, 0.0015648287953808904, 0.011018435470759869, -0.07579004764556885, 0.002034461125731468, -0.020468121394515038, -0.03345593065023422, 0.046911176294088364, -0.008278261870145798, -0.0001315626286668703, 0.024877481162548065, -0.005634521134197712, -0.07859960198402405, -0.02456742152571678, -0.03912912681698799, -0.005444396287202835, -0.023181308060884476, 0.04174485802650452, 0.0027698560152202845, 0.009326223284006119, -0.06137976050376892, -0.004120272118598223, -0.03794005140662193, 0.0015608657849952579, -0.046217404305934906, -0.03446807712316513, 0.024366989731788635, -0.0007705594762228429, -0.011918083764612675, 0.028814928606152534, -0.033128511160612106, 0.018889307975769043, -0.09396236389875412, -0.05091330409049988, 0.013832096941769123, 0.029765410348773003, 0.046952515840530396, 0.0071657574735581875, -0.04056097939610481, 0.06430315226316452, 0.0007324250182136893, -0.04401693493127823, -0.06339230388402939, 0.021600184962153435, 0.010118063539266586, -0.009733390994369984, 0.02540055476129055, -0.013212740421295166, 0.023778030648827553, 0.04518904164433479, -0.02344956435263157, -0.01953117735683918, 0.07579302787780762, 0.03871464729309082, 0.015493777580559254, 0.029128670692443848, -0.012616000138223171, -0.007476485334336758, 0.03920629993081093, 0.007190278731286526, -0.059372905641794205, 0.07022298872470856, 0.01820262148976326, 0.010362631641328335, -0.0007390565006062388, -0.059529587626457214, -0.003855900838971138, 0.019957173615694046, -0.00012015661923214793, -0.011875786818563938, -0.009523571468889713, 0.01039071660488844, -0.032726917415857315, 0.026961516588926315, 0.05169888958334923, 0.025888647884130478, 0.0041219391860067844, 0.0035351573023945093, 0.013517686165869236, 0.06023841351270676, -0.039516597986221313, -0.010884249582886696, 0.008482057601213455, -0.0053024073131382465, 0.0121832937002182, 0.011747618205845356, -0.012385656125843525, 0.05266580730676651, 0.023057566955685616, -0.007805181201547384, 0.0036172817926853895, -0.03513806313276291, 0.017992079257965088, -0.05472389981150627, -0.011593567207455635, -0.006250949110835791, 0.05638224631547928, 0.004718102049082518, 0.01621178351342678, 0.00953174103051424, 0.00023364338267128915, 0.0397433303296566, 0.022835001349449158, -0.08862657845020294, 0.022430816665291786, 0.013908689841628075, -0.0402790829539299, 0.01578177884221077, -0.02238113060593605, -0.016066517680883408, -0.050686776638031006, 0.012470613233745098, -0.010443040169775486, 0.006834227591753006, -0.032075878232717514, 0.014640914276242256, 0.020087353885173798, -0.017170753329992294, -0.02293766476213932, -0.0322938896715641, -0.016279904171824455, -0.007484389469027519, -0.013160964474081993, 0.055485788732767105, 0.000386908563086763, 0.011205269023776054, -0.0024365705903619528, 0.029181113466620445, 0.012411660514771938, 0.055124636739492416, 0.008414066396653652, 0.014662828296422958, -0.04722500219941139, 0.026679469272494316, -0.0038017865736037493, 0.029657449573278427, 0.009701134636998177, -0.01651063747704029, 0.012834731489419937, -0.03251156583428383, -0.025972794741392136, -0.007956198416650295, -0.012125120498239994, -0.0022911475971341133, 0.010103344917297363, 0.027376484125852585, 0.04763156548142433, -0.051785461604595184, -0.009845606982707977, 0.09401854127645493, 0.002662780461832881, -0.02182767167687416, -0.022953808307647705, -0.013315772637724876, -0.01505381427705288, 0.016716299578547478, 0.030797315761446953, 0.01947922259569168, -0.016193851828575134, 0.015434793196618557, 0.009547918103635311, -0.02706432156264782, 0.0016122147208079696, -0.03864295035600662, 0.03704829886555672, 0.05024251714348793, -0.03019952028989792, -0.036690905690193176, 0.022016437724232674, 0.07046011090278625, 0.0034089903347194195, 0.026253771036863327, 0.014904080890119076, -0.05937877297401428, 0.022377558052539825, 0.01863781362771988, 0.037463992834091187, -0.028201648965477943, -0.014261105097830296, -0.010211111046373844, -0.006854490377008915, 0.031527165323495865, 0.01982548087835312, 0.0047630248591303825, 0.009911928325891495, 0.020289715379476547, 0.002453454304486513, -0.027304664254188538, -0.040452904999256134, 0.037694454193115234, -0.031001659110188484, 0.014980003237724304, -0.04246380180120468, -0.00015009197522886097, -0.055088110268116, 0.020892614498734474, -0.013417691923677921, 0.07896969467401505, -0.0054396032355725765, -0.010767296887934208, 0.022170530632138252, 0.024939659982919693, -0.013617192395031452, -0.05878424644470215, -0.015339042991399765, 0.028315043076872826, -0.06091016158461571, 0.04555407911539078, -0.004311408847570419, -0.013658070005476475, 0.04949840158224106, 0.025094684213399887, -0.0027643039356917143, 0.0005788840353488922, -0.024727148935198784, 0.02230345830321312, 0.04692770540714264, 0.027480879798531532, 0.09356865286827087, 0.020735925063490868, -0.030505333095788956, -0.00922096986323595, -0.04498827084898949, 0.009766395203769207, -0.00742651941254735, -0.06253072619438171, -0.01097884215414524, -0.0022532662842422724, 0.007913707755506039, 0.012006638571619987, 0.006798255257308483, -0.0024364187847822905, -0.0007112115854397416, -0.01433020830154419, -0.057526931166648865, 0.04397173598408699, 0.023304229602217674, -0.011548793874680996, 0.051679577678442, 0.05073161423206329, -0.005259257275611162, -0.02741488814353943, 0.024861980229616165, -0.02420082874596119, 0.011177864857017994, -0.00503000570461154, -0.02951815351843834, 0.02235645242035389, -0.02582571841776371, -0.020644228905439377, 0.04293646663427353, -0.024288663640618324, 0.023831883445382118, 0.0010911851422861218, 0.0281249787658453, 0.009048586711287498, -0.07182397693395615, -0.015303141437470913, -0.01458772737532854, 0.026838507503271103, 0.00392321078106761, -0.039445869624614716, -0.004644717555493116, -0.018169423565268517, -0.041565749794244766, -0.07342100143432617, -0.03027692623436451, 0.014832304790616035, 0.012377615086734295, -0.0417562760412693, -0.03315703198313713, 0.011099210940301418, -0.016496559605002403, -0.010081261396408081, -0.024888016283512115, 0.07524509727954865, -0.03389104828238487, -0.0010013037826865911, -0.034429166465997696, 0.008120746351778507, 0.029911594465374947, 0.01516134012490511, 0.009554106742143631, 0.013967765495181084, -0.036291785538196564, -0.011946165934205055, 0.02661234326660633, 0.047763872891664505, -0.03024381957948208, -0.011226238682866096, -0.014836236834526062, -0.013801551423966885, 0.04741381108760834, 0.0063996994867920876, -0.011288804933428764, -0.012212073430418968, -0.008580419234931469, -0.01760018989443779, -0.021129678934812546, 0.027787037193775177, -0.0007385830977000296, 0.023204563185572624, -0.030300198122859, -0.011737019754946232, 0.0032161499839276075, 0.02144399657845497, 0.018776141107082367, 0.007784802466630936, 0.0111119719222188, -0.0007426225929521024, 0.06707336753606796, 0.030584655702114105, -0.003145522903650999, -0.012063163332641125, -0.003916008397936821, 0.05543910339474678, -0.0005964332958683372, -0.002577338833361864, 0.02776537463068962, 0.04535350948572159, -0.019523117691278458, -0.05513617396354675, -0.03333882614970207, 0.007761253509670496, 0.04668179899454117, -0.014822922646999359, 0.06584435701370239, 0.05781334266066551, 0.022889021784067154, 0.0004369180533103645, -0.011915089562535286, -0.029430938884615898, 0.012772186659276485, 0.02937951683998108, 0.07345521450042725, 0.013016127049922943, -0.008390765637159348, 0.030982721596956253, 0.015972545370459557, 0.018919754773378372, 0.027403023093938828, -0.012762762606143951, 0.03183549642562866, 0.014561605639755726, -0.020677732303738594, -0.04481153562664986, 0.033003874123096466, -0.041541170328855515, 0.020087983459234238, -0.021524902433156967, -0.04632100090384483, 0.05638232082128525, 0.014345704577863216, 0.00012261094525456429, -0.04829518124461174, -0.0376773439347744, -0.05905195698142052, 0.007973020896315575, 0.006781040225178003, -0.033532995730638504, 0.0024163005873560905, 0.008025899529457092, -0.021768582984805107, -0.0037644226104021072, 0.01737043261528015, -0.012313135899603367, -0.0937480479478836, -0.017202747985720634, 0.012377269566059113, -0.02164451964199543, 0.016836516559123993, 0.052512578666210175, -0.021778054535388947, -0.012421224266290665, -0.03621005639433861, 0.016957493498921394, 0.01310084667056799, 0.05330377072095871, -0.0038428734987974167, 0.06794720143079758, 0.009719040244817734, 0.006831656210124493, -0.012921605259180069, -0.005107794888317585, 0.09069816023111343, 0.07615705579519272, 0.017258334904909134, -0.08277212083339691, 0.010955401696264744, 0.016851769760251045, -0.04356347769498825, -0.012175285257399082, -0.00722849927842617, 0.02224111557006836, 0.004398970864713192, 0.05730324611067772, 0.031851548701524734, 0.01026428584009409, -0.02042597159743309, 0.032463449984788895, -0.0474199503660202, -0.017488453537225723, 0.014360509812831879, 0.022380908951163292, 0.01379556767642498, 0.009256440214812756, -0.026772717013955116, 0.01599089801311493, -0.03505156934261322, -0.022884026169776917, -0.04259353503584862, -0.032064225524663925, 0.023528078570961952, -0.018970897421240807, -0.03515029698610306, -0.004237587563693523, 0.04818832129240036, 0.008549521677196026, 0.005757462233304977, 0.03360126167535782, 0.03879283741116524, -0.03924737498164177, 0.0016425366047769785, 0.005894094705581665, 0.014695021323859692, 0.005936569068580866, -0.027431244030594826, -0.006789304316043854, 0.00818397756665945, -0.010576953180134296, -0.04804753139615059, 0.040359977632761, -0.025957636535167694, 0.03040432371199131, 0.0136313047260046, 0.005338000599294901, 0.025527359917759895, -0.04111865162849426, 0.003448367351666093, 0.040269095450639725, 0.02917453832924366, -0.018671657890081406, -0.01770014502108097, -0.004432051908224821, 0.05614089593291283, 0.020072609186172485, 0.015246478840708733, 0.04045609384775162, -0.032326050102710724, -0.0023676822893321514, -0.020040281116962433, 0.030892495065927505, -0.0184211153537035, -0.006327840965241194, 0.02147306688129902, -0.027243725955486298, 0.0007450845441780984, -0.021103017032146454, 0.030374079942703247, 0.023226657882332802, 0.009110954590141773, -0.04036807268857956, -0.00770194036886096, -0.023630045354366302, -0.05554821342229843, -0.011966962367296219, -0.05050748959183693, 0.024647889658808708, -0.05752057209610939, 0.010902141220867634, 0.048981923609972, 0.03157885745167732, 0.00829404592514038, 0.02539205178618431, -0.037236545234918594, 0.02744758129119873, -0.03797769919037819, -0.061933863908052444, -0.03605806827545166, 0.01692274957895279, -0.025428609922528267, 0.031023981049656868, -0.013060917146503925, 0.07256314158439636, 0.017619960010051727, 0.04558921232819557, -0.033426664769649506, 0.042916446924209595, 0.0005750911659561098, 0.0032660861033946276, -0.006908262614160776, -0.03423571214079857, -0.0023784113582223654, 0.0005716410232707858, 0.01758464239537716, 0.013666610233485699, 0.0011965048033744097, -0.05965437367558479, -0.056563060730695724, 0.038650911301374435, -0.005905458237975836, -0.05351271480321884, 0.027413884177803993, 0.009727460332214832, 0.014002812094986439, -0.020717879757285118, 0.014061746187508106, -0.01898849941790104, -0.01699395291507244, -0.001869490835815668, -0.06699159741401672, 0.008404924534261227, 0.004025996662676334, -0.005678943824023008, 0.019740451127290726, 0.02868201583623886, 0.03157314285635948, 0.05442638322710991, 0.02763945981860161, 0.028857361525297165, -0.005689060781151056, 0.05190545693039894, -0.025621674954891205, -0.04130961745977402, 0.001253482885658741, -0.05074337497353554, -0.040166594088077545, 0.026259353384375572, -0.0006476797861978412, 0.007991867139935493, 0.03786679729819298, 0.02562648430466652, -0.042539555579423904, 0.01759047992527485, 0.01554778590798378, 0.006648081820458174, -0.021733080968260765, 0.00996710266917944, -0.018663184717297554, 0.007129020057618618, 0.02910686656832695, -0.004553917795419693, -0.0002092051727231592, -0.020720522850751877, 0.032148994505405426, -0.019496610388159752, 0.018520178273320198, 0.028718382120132446, 0.006813336163759232, 0.024963319301605225, 0.018485242500901222, -0.01384344045072794, 0.016498321667313576, 0.04990440979599953, -0.007537460420280695, 0.030249085277318954, 0.004099136218428612, 0.0667169988155365, -0.10417681932449341, -0.021138779819011688, 0.01571856252849102, -0.002198996255174279, 0.03686372935771942, -0.07371786236763, 0.0033988365903496742, 0.04081181064248085, -0.04173972085118294, 0.012069537304341793, -0.020192772150039673, -0.011208868585526943, -0.01418235246092081, -0.020211007446050644, 0.01905243657529354, 0.038305263966321945, 0.014458988793194294, 0.028976477682590485, 0.04421012103557587, 0.024353204295039177, 0.043610990047454834, -0.030601998791098595, -0.02354518137872219, 0.002165780169889331, 0.01679030805826187, -0.06589990854263306, 0.023149874061346054, -0.05419042333960533, -0.02116025984287262, 0.011440470814704895, 0.005466173402965069, 0.000001795814796423656, 0.040526945143938065, 0.04685479402542114, 0.013093728572130203, 0.04451141878962517, 0.010867424309253693, -0.007320991717278957, -0.00016431028780061752, 0.0007791560492478311, -0.01086891908198595, 0.0422012098133564, -0.05016091465950012, 0.04868678003549576, 0.004534068983048201, 0.0036789956502616405, -0.03056865744292736, 0.007816901430487633, -0.008681241422891617, -0.015147649683058262, -0.01799772121012211, -0.02126225084066391, -0.025794675573706627, -0.0390164814889431, 0.008934041485190392, -0.05983366444706917, 0.046423621475696564, 0.023310907185077667, 0.004851535428315401, -0.06431408226490021, 0.012196325697004795, 0.006422293838113546, -0.018430855125188828, -0.012515890412032604, -0.018582623451948166, 0.017813095822930336, -0.03247235342860222, 0.009252090007066727, 0.029767220839858055, -0.04769738018512726, -0.020875627174973488, -0.011624802835285664, -0.03067990392446518, 0.048175837844610214, -0.03368549421429634, -0.018963303416967392, 0.030683603137731552, -0.018375057727098465, 0.024782255291938782, -0.07775630056858063, 0.0453917533159256, 0.03259928897023201, -0.009107775054872036, 0.003215014934539795, -0.00532973138615489, -0.022299323230981827, 0.013657261617481709, 0.041872818022966385, -0.036601223051548004, 0.011036014184355736, 0.0001590770552866161, 0.04675056412816048, 0.0010954787721857429, -0.0060044098645448685, 0.006363497115671635, -0.02442370541393757, -0.03373880684375763, -0.032475609332323074, 0.00018853753863368183, 0.001431990065611899, -0.016173234209418297, 0.03399400785565376, -0.00406790804117918, -0.01498284749686718, -0.018893316388130188, -0.020700575783848763, 0.025516046211123466, 0.001579996314831078, -0.007551093120127916, 0.05751635879278183, 0.008784064091742039, 0.008592011407017708, 0.02937815524637699, 0.003300877520814538, -0.054326288402080536, 0.03170615807175636, -0.06326716393232346, -0.013500713743269444, 0.0023924445267766714, -0.005827529821544886, 0.0010513321030884981, -0.047738853842020035, 0.019864020869135857, 0.03314819931983948, -0.037105005234479904, -0.0036456070374697447, 0.01979953795671463, -0.007932824082672596, 0.02433457225561142, 0.006006105802953243, 0.008742463774979115, 0.02559536322951317, -0.02326318807899952, -0.00227233930490911, 0.007402957882732153, 0.016761165112257004, 0.022396527230739594, -0.020277082920074463, -0.0002221440663561225, -0.014540965668857098, 0.052133798599243164, -0.014955850318074226, 0.017627980560064316, -0.03393339738249779, -0.017557980492711067, -0.014206956140697002, -0.009219479747116566, 0.041151706129312515, -0.02781769633293152, -0.01253916509449482, 0.0604759082198143, -0.03234419226646423, 0.004689634777605534, -0.06331173330545425, 0.0019610202871263027, -0.021538052707910538, -0.03544488176703453, 0.005915981717407703, 0.04515164718031883, -0.023906053975224495, 0.019314974546432495, 0.02432643435895443, 0.010716579854488373, 0.03537822887301445, 0.011469653807580471, 0.0362015962600708, -0.011258522979915142, 0.018647905439138412, -0.005409329663962126, -0.04336433857679367, -0.016523774713277817, -0.02642359770834446, 0.029479410499334335, 0.02234979346394539, 0.031206995248794556, 0.016799231991171837, -0.016192421317100525, -0.02487890236079693, 0.02970021404325962, -0.07001397013664246, -0.004601683467626572, -0.03327237069606781, 0.014533881098031998, -0.02240488864481449, -0.017732510343194008 ]
<p>I am trying to cluster data. Each point in this dataset is connected to some other points. I want to define clusters "depending on how much the points are connected to each other". After some research, I read about k-core clustering (and saw it has applications in social networking for instance). I think this is the algorithm I want to apply, but, according to what I found, it can only be used to "visualize" a network. Isn't it possible to cluster data with this method?</p>
36,458
[ -0.043871741741895676, 0.013731647282838821, 0.015021984465420246, -0.011855977587401867, 0.025706645101308823, 0.010819999501109123, -0.006496901623904705, -0.018149815499782562, -0.0030220348853617907, -0.03690585121512413, 0.03576929494738579, 0.05471181124448776, 0.01360397506505251, 0.031409792602062225, 0.023245442658662796, 0.011934063397347927, -0.03273564577102661, -0.017931688576936722, -0.021490028128027916, -0.023817293345928192, -0.002825988456606865, 0.0035802186466753483, 0.003318109316751361, -0.021286996081471443, -0.0197940431535244, 0.030742205679416656, -0.005121742840856314, -0.012568383477628231, 0.009836932644248009, 0.039574034512043, -0.003376350272446871, -0.030830170959234238, 0.01055152341723442, 0.051552534103393555, 0.02047557197511196, -0.02162395790219307, -0.03536811098456383, -0.01628304459154606, -0.027639426290988922, 0.01368542667478323, -0.014724751003086567, -0.04404069483280182, -0.0020492949988693, 0.04815231263637543, -0.03013378009200096, 0.015881720930337906, -0.008114350028336048, -0.07804436981678009, 0.01881507970392704, -0.02443002164363861, 0.09068389236927032, 0.004685258958488703, 0.020853430032730103, 0.03613363578915596, 0.010982117615640163, 0.016340916976332664, 0.06002281978726387, 0.05957770347595215, -0.02609049156308174, -0.03800535574555397, -0.017173059284687042, -0.008172063156962395, 0.003241765545681119, -0.031441885977983475, -0.05619412660598755, 0.04596765711903572, -0.022794123739004135, -0.003354338463395834, 0.03962872177362442, -0.0008279657922685146, -0.01571021042764187, 0.014446621760725975, 0.06245473399758339, -0.03427368402481079, -0.03377332538366318, -0.011837232857942581, 0.010621882043778896, -0.03682192414999008, 0.04496007412672043, 0.034367889165878296, 0.012738756835460663, 0.024909190833568573, -0.0015378869138658047, -0.015319003723561764, 0.04017914459109306, 0.0039594401605427265, 0.053609415888786316, -0.03429797664284706, -0.010123657062649727, 0.04650422930717468, -0.05372326076030731, -0.020372610539197922, 0.03667604550719261, 0.01703345775604248, -0.02722139284014702, 0.016602972522377968, 0.004425250459462404, 0.03459781035780907, -0.01403562631458044, 0.0028864978812634945, 0.017607375979423523, -0.013682948425412178, -0.01864134892821312, 0.015181970782577991, -0.004707232117652893, 0.0031983507797122, -0.04320518672466278, 0.0063557373359799385, -0.0032236201222985983, 0.009554324671626091, -0.019089078530669212, -0.017507309094071388, 0.03341512009501457, 0.0022913524881005287, 0.05954284220933914, -0.03565576300024986, -0.010734261013567448, -0.008890067227184772, 0.00510662654414773, 0.0590193085372448, 0.030581194907426834, -0.003762601874768734, 0.05251697450876236, -0.041245002299547195, -0.06472663581371307, 0.010121837258338928, -0.007452245336025953, -0.026548821479082108, 0.0033544853795319796, 0.04441886022686958, -0.02364407852292061, 0.00374955078586936, 0.0035969545133411884, -0.03804120793938637, 0.067062146961689, -0.02394687570631504, -0.0891454890370369, -0.02397475391626358, 0.024466324597597122, -0.0038125331047922373, 0.02852960303425789, -0.0440511517226696, 0.016070246696472168, 0.0066906060092151165, 0.04993923380970955, 0.03824423998594284, -0.009100785478949547, 0.0011985410237684846, 0.03361950069665909, 0.02477893978357315, -0.042356058955192566, -0.025872284546494484, -0.026314301416277885, -0.035098847001791, 0.005852614063769579, -0.06617232412099838, -0.0005316194728948176, 0.01409350335597992, 0.014381133019924164, -0.027518250048160553, 0.03099524974822998, 0.004861053545027971, -0.010553775355219841, 0.027992887422442436, -0.02208598516881466, -0.01981118693947792, 0.093758225440979, 0.01273784227669239, 0.04383089020848274, 0.01620996929705143, -0.013437465764582157, 0.03204741328954697, 0.018930720165371895, 0.04614810645580292, 0.037217844277620316, 0.00560521287843585, 0.009513847529888153, -0.02652588114142418, 0.04965449124574661, 0.01974491775035858, -0.03055296093225479, -0.04015198349952698, 0.010384761728346348, 0.04040490835905075, 0.017408765852451324, 0.07103976607322693, -0.016137326136231422, -0.062125109136104584, 0.016328370198607445, -0.030042478814721107, -0.018634924665093422, -0.020854931324720383, 0.027413079515099525, -0.017421510070562363, -0.012767517007887363, 0.0006403291481547058, 0.008231086656451225, 0.006857502739876509, -0.025856459513306618, -0.04501409828662872, -0.017998740077018738, -0.011830579489469528, 0.045355647802352905, -0.026310734450817108, -0.020823488011956215, 0.049769870936870575, 0.013026222586631775, -0.0029935191851109266, 0.06627417355775833, -0.027864541858434677, -0.045912887901067734, -0.024285444989800453, -0.013100954703986645, 0.0036799039226025343, 0.002533914288505912, 0.005807376466691494, 0.006287645548582077, 0.03725191950798035, -0.022229181602597237, 0.016226917505264282, -0.04398370161652565, 0.09356264024972916, 0.05519169569015503, -0.00203245528973639, 0.010971520096063614, -0.021219154819846153, 0.004185792990028858, 0.009621293283998966, -0.015307844616472721, 0.002816132502630353, -0.08076588809490204, 0.01447110716253519, 0.07361757755279541, 0.009524134919047356, -0.04909946024417877, -0.02415725588798523, 0.05677512288093567, 0.049319058656692505, 0.0080790463835001, 0.027995441108942032, -0.031339097768068314, 0.016668912023305893, 0.005327874794602394, 0.01873146928846836, 0.017014918848872185, -0.004277775529772043, 0.04696687310934067, 0.015591650269925594, 0.02408503368496895, -0.02248554676771164, -0.02212720736861229, 0.05542398616671562, -0.02193721942603588, -0.007079549599438906, 0.036740850657224655, -0.006111653987318277, 0.04622231423854828, -0.04068102315068245, 0.006314011290669441, -0.006032437086105347, 0.0046660443767905235, 0.0013443162897601724, 0.009916920214891434, -0.02269737236201763, 0.008618803694844246, 0.05643414333462715, -0.04736866056919098, 0.010789048857986927, -0.0017792509170249104, -0.008505662903189659, 0.017804495990276337, -0.01845233142375946, -0.005445372313261032, -0.05774793028831482, 0.03178334981203079, 0.048393361270427704, -0.017035268247127533, 0.009591127745807171, -0.023091517388820648, -0.032559238374233246, -0.0007007610402069986, -0.0264603178948164, -0.006867160554975271, 0.02533761039376259, -0.039223816245794296, -0.006473509129136801, 0.016881128773093224, -0.020606137812137604, -0.0015829274198040366, -0.021789884194731712, -0.00927329994738102, -0.01636175997555256, -0.0061825234442949295, -0.05415916070342064, 0.015088483691215515, -0.015373721718788147, 0.04546206444501877, -0.008499788120388985, 0.017224213108420372, 0.0231796745210886, 0.004325794987380505, -0.045135509222745895, 0.0317472368478775, -0.02222561463713646, -0.047964032739400864, -0.027630485594272614, -0.020840121433138847, 0.03810286149382591, -0.03918581083416939, 0.006988702807575464, 0.04656236246228218, -0.06772372126579285, 0.017135217785835266, -0.043326277285814285, -0.07367072254419327, 0.04124936833977699, -0.03476608544588089, 0.02191653847694397, 0.0033450950868427753, -0.04016530141234398, 0.0898255929350853, -0.009267016313970089, -0.0515524223446846, -0.05059618130326271, -0.01001968514174223, -0.05188756808638573, 0.0034393123351037502, 0.02473066747188568, 0.007406504824757576, -0.005521545652300119, -0.023801788687705994, 0.009574542753398418, 0.024853656068444252, 0.09155673533678055, -0.005420213099569082, -0.009608417749404907, 0.002641781233251095, 0.0006671095034107566, 0.02539471536874771, 0.02535945735871792, 0.01287467684596777, -0.052797697484493256, 0.018851006403565407, 0.005559489596635103, 0.01470846589654684, 0.025612272322177887, -0.005404970142990351, 0.018225722014904022, -0.0037190497387200594, 0.021652264520525932, -0.04377836361527443, 0.0007318787393160164, 0.010409076698124409, -0.002758449874818325, 0.022292712703347206, 0.05644525960087776, 0.05429680645465851, -0.007393625099211931, -0.03074777126312256, 0.04921366274356842, 0.03523906692862511, -0.01716744340956211, -0.01215883158147335, 0.016930481418967247, -0.011749775148928165, -0.015933839604258537, -0.005736519116908312, -0.01664455235004425, 0.018374353647232056, 0.0310849379748106, -0.002485064323991537, 0.026554161682724953, -0.024138877168297768, 0.023231368511915207, -0.05050937086343765, -0.0069185895845294, -0.04433100298047066, 0.046927355229854584, -0.03521961718797684, 0.04734950512647629, 0.025650842115283012, -0.00018754959455691278, -0.009804847650229931, 0.003199793165549636, -0.037362802773714066, 0.014496196992695332, -0.04914180561900139, -0.005884258542209864, -0.00706770084798336, -0.029825052246451378, 0.02328801155090332, -0.0014504778664559126, 0.01297839730978012, 0.010738084092736244, 0.00970075000077486, -0.02304108999669552, -0.013678024522960186, -0.002725776517763734, 0.029424045234918594, -0.005639873910695314, 0.003291009459644556, 0.07079672813415527, -0.0018204044317826629, 0.03801346570253372, 0.02179022692143917, 0.009825745597481728, -0.014160542748868465, -0.011389505118131638, -0.002948242472484708, 0.04132269322872162, 0.0162715632468462, 0.001696131774224341, 0.028777142986655235, -0.016327818855643272, -0.00985675398260355, -0.008191063068807125, 0.06462807953357697, 0.00849657692015171, -0.015130444429814816, 0.014268049970269203, -0.06412722915410995, -0.026034744456410408, -0.015114564448595047, 0.052196063101291656, -0.01769840717315674, 0.007678092457354069, 0.027276646345853806, 0.0029511405155062675, -0.057892587035894394, 0.00901595689356327, 0.07275833189487457, 0.04085685685276985, -0.05917901545763016, -0.04733419790863991, -0.010829837992787361, 0.021861782297492027, -0.0032790168188512325, 0.025839954614639282, -0.005540468730032444, -0.0030403202399611473, 0.01739456318318844, 0.039105676114559174, -0.03446601331233978, -0.033475641161203384, 0.0031715824734419584, -0.014235300943255424, 0.01999959535896778, -0.024097593501210213, -0.01450857613235712, 0.013587613590061665, 0.020503919571638107, 0.03292299807071686, 0.03892463818192482, -0.008176703937351704, -0.1054828092455864, -0.029375910758972168, 0.03592371195554733, -0.012867406010627747, -0.0021523127797991037, 0.005418855231255293, -0.024924594908952713, 0.0012278819922357798, 0.07787268608808517, -0.051463522017002106, 0.05377267673611641, -0.04528973624110222, 0.010214013047516346, -0.008939960040152073, 0.018470194190740585, -0.0026497654616832733, -0.006840860936790705, -0.054300159215927124, 0.04009002447128296, -0.04515231400728226, 0.01723218709230423, -0.04624615237116814, 0.0231879111379385, 0.009241418913006783, 0.05945304408669472, -0.003507389687001705, -0.037573132663965225, 0.026136817410588264, 0.027446629479527473, -0.0018502381863072515, -0.04025602340698242, 0.01754630170762539, 0.03649197518825531, -0.0008491688058711588, 0.06891286373138428, -0.020797574892640114, -0.030738184228539467, 0.03424020856618881, -0.0043922727927565575, -0.005691145546734333, 0.006772699765861034, -0.006671328097581863, 0.06377054005861282, 0.027034355327486992, -0.012724416330456734, 0.04505232349038124, 0.03053727000951767, 0.010838600806891918, 0.012898755259811878, -0.0379277803003788, 0.014185371808707714, -0.024402936920523643, 0.01111758965998888, -0.006662212312221527, 0.005230048671364784, 0.00043348793406039476, 0.007247576490044594, -0.006705827079713345, 0.009891930036246777, -0.012678945437073708, -0.01836763694882393, -0.009432394057512283, 0.017669878900051117, 0.016944075003266335, 0.004598166793584824, 0.025510691106319427, 0.017078444361686707, 0.04187372699379921, -0.036948371678590775, 0.005382930394262075, -0.021412020549178123, -0.014802473597228527, 0.009002474136650562, -0.03275204077363014, -0.0463532879948616, -0.05322938412427902, -0.011519261635839939, 0.023911356925964355, -0.03050041012465954, 0.04449770227074623, -0.021692907437682152, -0.000005856743428012123, 0.0029225742910057306, -0.057518113404512405, -0.02870863303542137, -0.015874430537223816, -0.028576208278536797, 0.027775924652814865, -0.009206901304423809, 0.03983768820762634, 0.0040500895120203495, -0.01956813409924507, -0.06090676411986351, -0.025685450062155724, 0.015062673017382622, -0.009021258912980556, 0.0015137605369091034, -0.0835917517542839, 0.01631137542426586, 0.006528386380523443, -0.0034334047231823206, 0.009162936359643936, 0.04287652671337128, -0.014673258177936077, -0.03553123027086258, 0.02227100357413292, -0.014450525864958763, 0.06397737562656403, 0.004443123936653137, -0.01293169055134058, 0.005374345928430557, -0.003319624811410904, -0.009816818870604038, -0.014423234388232231, 0.007783669512718916, -0.01567089557647705, -0.022556455805897713, -0.0637136846780777, 0.006588619202375412, 0.04962644726037979, -0.022870562970638275, -0.009407003410160542, 0.0026065062265843153, 0.03341412544250488, 0.010960953310132027, -0.032331433147192, -0.01597399264574051, -0.0014394974568858743, -0.0021909840870648623, -0.055118855088949203, 0.010249524377286434, -0.011657366529107094, -0.0020449708681553602, 0.042685311287641525, 0.0143435662612319, -0.0018534401897341013, 0.030052293092012405, 0.06040995195508003, 0.014265474863350391, -0.03672514855861664, -0.025044631212949753, -0.044384367763996124, 0.0013383596669882536, -0.012197080068290234, -0.02389642223715782, -0.020875627174973488, 0.08059117197990417, -0.02732486091554165, -0.009146168828010559, 0.0019728182815015316, -0.010288485325872898, 0.05970674008131027, -0.00936261098831892, 0.04552480950951576, 0.062390897423028946, -0.021063197404146194, 0.024765292182564735, -0.018458928912878036, 0.00940451119095087, -0.016236206516623497, -0.022922061383724213, 0.05036943778395653, -0.006834326311945915, -0.02539055608212948, 0.03536627069115639, 0.03665816783905029, -0.038376275449991226, 0.05473334714770317, 0.015103221870958805, 0.04539130628108978, -0.014270135201513767, 0.0033660458866506815, -0.0636439323425293, 0.025827525183558464, -0.043549057096242905, 0.013918188400566578, -0.032385095953941345, -0.05440615490078926, 0.02894594892859459, 0.009996183216571808, -0.008408956229686737, 0.0014342362992465496, -0.02476080134510994, -0.024387728422880173, 0.015513514168560505, -0.002121690893545747, -0.017101306468248367, -0.006943863816559315, 0.0035473930183798075, 0.011392462998628616, 0.02607741951942444, -0.004755016881972551, 0.00040532529237680137, -0.06961334496736526, -0.06541388481855392, -0.04090369865298271, -0.04902062192559242, 0.012994441203773022, 0.03088005632162094, -0.06448379158973694, 0.05993367359042168, -0.0069478047080338, 0.02947283536195755, 0.015292218886315823, 0.04860811308026314, 0.0009895358234643936, 0.06229411065578461, 0.016268562525510788, 0.023737270385026932, 0.00910594966262579, 0.004478449933230877, 0.11008322238922119, 0.07867704331874847, 0.01181714702397585, -0.08823423087596893, 0.031192170456051826, -0.01912149228155613, -0.018179919570684433, -0.0479755625128746, 0.05541125684976578, -0.0008831440936774015, 0.02137335203588009, 0.0077783637680113316, 0.07713425904512405, 0.006843323819339275, 0.02032981440424919, 0.0999578982591629, -0.006253434345126152, -0.04403037950396538, -0.0005249152891337872, -0.028307080268859863, -0.03318600356578827, -0.00907264556735754, -0.09549286216497421, 0.03032616339623928, -0.01687650941312313, -0.01991800218820572, -0.0019768914207816124, 0.003232706105336547, 0.023766227066516876, 0.008951455354690552, -0.021764887496829033, -0.010856851004064083, 0.022248869761824608, -0.021446555852890015, -0.023542946204543114, -0.017002258449792862, 0.031887251883745193, -0.015207142569124699, 0.031442295759916306, -0.0020783916115760803, -0.003636334789916873, 0.006541795562952757, -0.025571513921022415, -0.0019101576181128621, -0.027991987764835358, -0.021102432161569595, -0.03298313543200493, 0.03302861377596855, -0.012346441857516766, 0.03069266490638256, -0.007330181077122688, 0.014289263635873795, 0.0002317738690180704, -0.0028157674241811037, 0.004386059939861298, -0.005254991352558136, 0.03981487452983856, 0.01217234693467617, -0.02411457523703575, -0.07006089389324188, 0.01943226344883442, -0.036401379853487015, 0.03462677076458931, 0.03858586400747299, 0.0009349932661280036, 0.006025743205100298, -0.00925682857632637, 0.022213077172636986, -0.0074266367591917515, -0.03207399696111679, -0.014254891313612461, 0.002531741512939334, -0.0036717639304697514, 0.011029847897589207, 0.006614592857658863, -0.008644957095384598, 0.026717716827988625, 0.0058886329643428326, -0.022197769954800606, -0.004526822827756405, 0.01291734166443348, 0.005311588291078806, -0.028626754879951477, -0.044268421828746796, -0.0156549159437418, 0.011173181235790253, 0.06179637461900711, 0.055583368986845016, -0.007132063154131174, 0.019426995888352394, -0.033344101160764694, -0.02429124526679516, -0.0029356516897678375, -0.035026419907808304, -0.007421273272484541, -0.020992141216993332, -0.06042775139212608, 0.021056175231933594, -0.03169482946395874, 0.0361514575779438, 0.02756744809448719, -0.021677449345588684, -0.011088245548307896, 0.03989430144429207, 0.0039120824076235294, 0.016337059438228607, 0.013493342325091362, -0.05309372395277023, 0.021206369623541832, -0.003028217237442732, 0.002032360527664423, -0.04151994735002518, -0.02794559672474861, -0.015557459555566311, -0.029593661427497864, 0.011418181471526623, 0.006581238936632872, -0.001669725519604981, -0.0010860265465453267, -0.006929649505764246, 0.030843572691082954, -0.036046598106622696, -0.022650424391031265, -0.060990042984485626, -0.022364163771271706, -0.05119140446186066, 0.00997475627809763, -0.021438976749777794, 0.010743077844381332, 0.02735837921500206, 0.04576294496655464, 0.043943315744400024, 0.023362288251519203, 0.01049377303570509, 0.002903045155107975, 0.00780232809484005, -0.008692469447851181, 0.04129981994628906, -0.052377425134181976, -0.021940262988209724, 0.07021105289459229, -0.06287863850593567, -0.03359976410865784, -0.00303100049495697, -0.002577230567112565, 0.04571676626801491, 0.022963395342230797, -0.025662541389465332, -0.013642538338899612, 0.03659519553184509, -0.010529214516282082, -0.010177591815590858, 0.01065505389124155, 0.0062233214266598225, -0.0010657281382009387, 0.014044699259102345, -0.028474103659391403, 0.011459855362772942, -0.022028660401701927, -0.02355280891060829, 0.02437099814414978, 0.006856928579509258, -0.02870982699096203, 0.006857140921056271, 0.033696409314870834, 0.015272588469088078, 0.00379379466176033, -0.001236037933267653, 0.07287013530731201, 0.03131141513586044, -0.05013827607035637, 0.027320142835378647, -0.001162378117442131, 0.012587448582053185, -0.06264292448759079, -0.0058769905008375645, -0.028169799596071243, -0.026257753372192383, 0.040579576045274734, -0.05601953715085983, -0.018136505037546158, 0.015935899689793587, -0.04784215986728668, 0.04377434030175209, 0.019418729469180107, -0.02962774597108364, -0.062467847019433975, 0.0068315984681248665, -0.0299367718398571, 0.031488168984651566, 0.04141741618514061, 0.054777830839157104, 0.0045081754215061665, 0.006844936870038509, 0.009065093472599983, 0.029613787308335304, -0.011921210214495659, -0.013538368977606297, -0.01747327856719494, -0.03767573460936546, 0.03566163778305054, -0.04207608848810196, -0.04386429116129875, 0.016762588173151016, -0.03223874419927597, -0.008724209852516651, 0.06572877615690231, 0.006654526572674513, 0.0005587671184912324, 0.057821258902549744, 0.01940372958779335, -0.02823059633374214, 0.004317498300224543, 0.02872239053249359, 0.01740362122654915, 0.022216156125068665, 0.01901593618094921, 0.0374937430024147, 0.027598563581705093, -0.03392273560166359, -0.02301914244890213, 0.034768979996442795, -0.020155271515250206, -0.009077364578843117, -0.017736006528139114, -0.02091750130057335, 0.02870657853782177, -0.026778604835271835, 0.012640758417546749, -0.02554618939757347, -0.00665903789922595, 0.04855711758136749, 0.015528530813753605, 0.0012420370476320386, 0.014101793058216572, 0.00010585702693788335, -0.06652061641216278, 0.007195769343525171, 0.0021670605055987835, -0.0013270924100652337, -0.08095700293779373, 0.014843137003481388, 0.0220764372497797, -0.001567426254041493, -0.005526045802980661, -0.014195096679031849, 0.034109462052583694, 0.056020963937044144, -0.009893660433590412, 0.039958804845809937, 0.04690631106495857, -0.036249998956918716, 0.005140874534845352, -0.05712167173624039, 0.05269896611571312, 0.008526594378054142, 0.036127109080553055, -0.015129952691495419, 0.001982305897399783, -0.021275244653224945, -0.0032959196250885725, 0.03811774030327797, 0.0076610310934484005, 0.018298925831913948, -0.024585014209151268, 0.025206103920936584, 0.012767153792083263, -0.04711686074733734, -0.001317470334470272, -0.029649365693330765, -0.04537695646286011, -0.0010349116055294871, -0.029339661821722984, -0.03789970278739929, -0.005222022533416748, 0.014944762922823429, 0.03415030613541603, -0.01774783991277218, -0.012822932563722134, -0.008526261895895004, 0.028179166838526726, 0.007586247753351927, -0.009765512309968472, 0.04610178992152214, 0.009646644815802574, -0.01912558265030384, 0.05209524184465408, -0.007099991664290428, 0.007291226647794247, 0.04972853511571884, -0.05988781154155731, -0.02464590221643448, 0.027994848787784576, -0.021270278841257095, -0.015343764796853065, -0.06340400129556656, -0.045651353895664215, 0.027144137769937515, -0.04462314769625664, 0.002721561584621668, 0.034262798726558685, 0.015185322612524033, 0.026570703834295273, -0.005778207443654537, 0.009056247770786285, 0.012545892037451267, -0.01415540836751461, 0.056756358593702316, 0.025030523538589478, 0.009507199749350548, 0.012518071569502354, 0.014465145766735077, -0.0000497996479680296, 0.00902570504695177, 0.014838729053735733, -0.03897180035710335, 0.043599631637334824, -0.023235909640789032, -0.016326308250427246, 0.0010907660471275449, -0.011652357876300812, 0.057230524718761444, 0.02460891380906105, 0.0024681701324880123, 0.04872181639075279, -0.039522506296634674, 0.017045609652996063, -0.01135998871177435, -0.05048510804772377, 0.006315360777080059, 0.050688643008470535, 0.009419397450983524, 0.04287448897957802, -0.0316925011575222, 0.016645243391394615, 0.0060219475999474525, -0.027962319552898407, 0.03891737386584282, 0.009853897616267204, 0.030240824446082115, -0.02798403799533844, -0.004791208542883396, 0.025750990957021713, -0.007611050270497799, -0.018722178414463997, -0.023427067324519157, 0.014079260639846325, 0.05184566229581833, 0.021518202498555183, 0.010652272030711174, -0.012478897348046303, -0.004120724741369486, 0.02770780771970749, -0.08219671994447708, -0.00007550906593678519, -0.06082499399781227, -0.017755961045622826, -0.009591457433998585, -0.006342620588839054 ]
<p>Let $x[n]$ be some time series in 1D or $x[m,n]$ in 2D, of length $N$ (resp. $N^2$) How can I assess whether it is <em>stationary</em>? At least in the weak sense. I can check whether the <em>stdev</em> remains constant, but this is only a necessary condition.</p>
36,459
[ -0.0027067610062658787, -0.028583841398358345, -0.01578914001584053, -0.011759737506508827, 0.026532195508480072, 0.01949240267276764, -0.0005367172998376191, -0.030512627214193344, 0.017425820231437683, -0.055907636880874634, 0.049612872302532196, 0.012679106555879116, 0.07364796102046967, 0.057136788964271545, 0.016563106328248978, -0.026010120287537575, -0.01777990348637104, -0.011523519642651081, 0.004657091107219458, -0.007539944723248482, -0.02144106850028038, 0.0412897951900959, 0.05924351513385773, -0.016361519694328308, -0.04080979526042938, 0.03266393020749092, -0.02265087328851223, -0.0021483292803168297, -0.00207758997566998, 0.06156832352280617, -0.06591757386922836, -0.02000598795711994, 0.01461770385503769, 0.04438810050487518, -0.005863652564585209, -0.0125297075137496, -0.031937457621097565, -0.04899689927697182, 0.036749500781297684, 0.03571299463510513, -0.035007040947675705, -0.038904301822185516, 0.011666142381727695, 0.03992178663611412, -0.01868007704615593, 0.0076707215048372746, 0.013194700703024864, -0.0059512644074857235, 0.05929747223854065, -0.012927815318107605, 0.08323758095502853, -0.01942357048392296, 0.035425007343292236, 0.015489892102777958, -0.03256545215845108, -0.025335505604743958, 0.03762603923678398, 0.006960455793887377, -0.00936361774802208, -0.02100067399442196, -0.022065086290240288, 0.0071446881629526615, 0.022477680817246437, -0.021866800263524055, -0.018741603940725327, 0.021173421293497086, -0.021847005933523178, -0.015756677836179733, 0.023424405604600906, -0.0333896242082119, -0.02811300940811634, 0.02081994153559208, 0.03323500603437424, -0.013037125580012798, -0.010957230813801289, 0.00462993374094367, 0.028675179928541183, 0.05090489238500595, 0.04098213464021683, 0.03017842024564743, 0.018106967210769653, 0.0004799719899892807, 0.046959467232227325, 0.04126258194446564, 0.02787110023200512, 0.0005023025441914797, 0.05818886309862137, -0.019298292696475983, 0.021352913230657578, 0.002470189705491066, 0.00928693637251854, -0.023093916475772858, 0.022293807938694954, -0.00891080778092146, -0.03787840157747269, 0.0073211900889873505, 0.009576020762324333, 0.03630073368549347, -0.002369575435295701, -0.0275228563696146, -0.0150083526968956, -0.03403936326503754, 0.029283585026860237, 0.028645772486925125, -0.035203590989112854, 0.0021349829621613026, 0.000039583163015777245, -0.00771605409681797, -0.037640281021595, 0.007391404360532761, -0.04097505286335945, 0.008956409059464931, 0.013147745281457901, 0.012932048179209232, 0.03534810245037079, 0.004103868268430233, 0.0009915687842294574, -0.009100532159209251, 0.0075851986184716225, 0.09437169134616852, 0.030693311244249344, -0.006255970802158117, 0.02685822732746601, -0.014800338074564934, -0.07512005418539047, 0.030835140496492386, 0.02073926292359829, -0.007837720215320587, -0.06636586040258408, 0.07050366699695587, -0.01289073470979929, -0.01694691926240921, 0.013611395843327045, -0.02898034080862999, 0.06324752420186996, 0.02431810274720192, -0.07285305112600327, -0.04462156444787979, 0.049521684646606445, -0.025418050587177277, -0.0053431871347129345, -0.08181985467672348, -0.0033174511045217514, 0.03365463763475418, 0.07132980972528458, -0.019254857674241066, 0.04934107884764671, 0.029557334259152412, 0.03659439831972122, -0.004973048809915781, -0.041748225688934326, -0.05071170628070831, 0.023040518164634705, -0.028672659769654274, 0.010512125678360462, -0.04203164577484131, -0.004290461074560881, 0.04989010468125343, -0.024935485795140266, -0.006936231162399054, 0.05098562687635422, 0.005398135632276535, 0.0007450075936503708, 0.0005893628695048392, 0.011257600970566273, -0.04220195859670639, 0.060821279883384705, -0.0024376423098146915, 0.06016971170902252, -0.013156413100659847, 0.0031241578981280327, 0.028590090572834015, 0.0389406755566597, 0.03573533520102501, 0.03448939323425293, 0.007522684056311846, -0.003943284973502159, 0.026033610105514526, 0.006216464098542929, 0.03572273626923561, -0.05580061674118042, -0.004023444838821888, -0.02006545104086399, -0.02770652249455452, 0.002898832317441702, 0.07549736648797989, 0.0040068114176392555, -0.009810449555516243, 0.01366415899246931, -0.054919466376304626, -0.023608384653925896, -0.05405447259545326, 0.030849851667881012, 0.02128414250910282, -0.013441299088299274, 0.04222573712468147, 0.009816310368478298, 0.01948685012757778, -0.028476277366280556, -0.03384394198656082, -0.03843900188803673, 0.00574516924098134, 0.003609889652580023, -0.04572337493300438, 0.0065285214222967625, -0.0028664041310548782, 0.050493281334638596, 0.013943950645625591, 0.016892556101083755, -0.00320654665119946, -0.048559870570898056, 0.012755368836224079, -0.04202348366379738, 0.0055051217786967754, -0.038181692361831665, -0.03787077218294144, 0.004808411467820406, -0.04772195219993591, -0.012331224977970123, 0.04084163159132004, -0.014607066288590431, 0.04698794335126877, 0.04262851923704147, 0.0002290906268171966, 0.008847875520586967, -0.0028526620008051395, 0.0336938202381134, -0.004247581586241722, -0.017638735473155975, -0.03657849505543709, -0.045083388686180115, -0.02291293628513813, 0.05460606887936592, 0.09761735796928406, -0.07186248898506165, 0.027214685454964638, 0.05382450670003891, 0.013314803130924702, 0.014084717258810997, 0.010279216803610325, -0.008785608224570751, -0.013828342780470848, 0.021885886788368225, 0.003085698466747999, -0.004008791409432888, -0.004192465450614691, 0.015906160697340965, 0.017094356939196587, 0.014954188838601112, -0.014628123492002487, -0.006838751956820488, 0.05383856222033501, -0.008339549414813519, -0.004238923080265522, -0.0064611658453941345, -0.046050120145082474, 0.05660121515393257, 0.007413114421069622, 0.008726638741791248, -0.014059758745133877, 0.026093656197190285, 0.052504464983940125, -0.009722694754600525, -0.00825828779488802, 0.040131110697984695, -0.012738221324980259, -0.004375773016363382, -0.04741007089614868, 0.03372637555003166, -0.01941383257508278, 0.024626875296235085, -0.04372859373688698, -0.026297811418771744, 0.004554064478725195, -0.012771380133926868, 0.05449556186795235, 0.005946997553110123, 0.006446591578423977, -0.009716988541185856, -0.00029631995130330324, -0.008455867879092693, -0.04025336727499962, 0.04236672446131706, 0.03160678595304489, -0.007972721941769123, 0.012351867742836475, -0.005220446735620499, -0.015708956867456436, 0.054991889744997025, -0.02045154757797718, 0.0070864236913621426, 0.06378959864377975, -0.02698449231684208, -0.037113796919584274, -0.013614879921078682, -0.046936143189668655, 0.011857155710458755, -0.03943392261862755, -0.027515431866049767, 0.06456076353788376, -0.021963946521282196, -0.03897704556584358, 0.02215285412967205, -0.0008376978221349418, -0.018225720152258873, -0.05823269858956337, 0.0022875359281897545, 0.019037874415516853, -0.05192936584353447, 0.0276197399944067, 0.056000471115112305, -0.03918024152517319, -0.002721494762226939, -0.05015827715396881, -0.06618477404117584, 0.02086600847542286, -0.044585034251213074, 0.028740810230374336, 0.005257302429527044, -0.0609716922044754, 0.04385498911142349, 0.02620905637741089, -0.02234225906431675, -0.021154776215553284, -0.00707815820351243, -0.02600410208106041, -0.057199232280254364, -0.005720637273043394, -0.023116305470466614, 0.018295397982001305, 0.016231197863817215, 0.0317516103386879, 0.010588179342448711, 0.057926472276449203, -0.013135447166860104, -0.040907122194767, 0.026615744456648827, -0.02222725935280323, 0.02330939471721649, 0.0025871838442981243, 0.0038526838179677725, -0.019029119983315468, -0.013689234852790833, 0.022661354392766953, 0.009166819974780083, 0.03927227109670639, -0.025355150923132896, 0.04583112522959709, -0.03379017114639282, 0.016171114519238472, -0.018376439809799194, 0.034657400101423264, -0.004158361349254847, 0.0011449467856436968, -0.058775827288627625, 0.028276847675442696, -0.013732455670833588, -0.00020315664005465806, 0.023231131955981255, 0.052910346537828445, 0.026558415964245796, -0.012788417749106884, -0.010900902561843395, 0.000406929844757542, -0.008197770453989506, 0.018876604735851288, -0.021066581830382347, -0.03297337889671326, 0.02683744952082634, -0.006705391686409712, 0.031795304268598557, -0.013483733870089054, -0.017990797758102417, -0.002089464571326971, -0.05230914428830147, 0.015656376257538795, 0.02127739042043686, 0.03338709473609924, 0.00010448318789713085, 0.01973699778318405, 0.011486000381410122, -0.025766495615243912, 0.01899699866771698, 0.016212154179811478, -0.06832850724458694, 0.016560614109039307, -0.03772095590829849, -0.01281492318958044, -0.0067834388464689255, 0.011656714603304863, 0.008825824595987797, -0.029849477112293243, 0.040601085871458054, -0.010268951766192913, 0.0183690395206213, -0.06857659667730331, -0.02374376356601715, -0.05691457539796829, -0.033019501715898514, -0.036374930292367935, 0.01867598667740822, 0.06378673762083054, -0.0539344884455204, 0.0060841720551252365, 0.054785747081041336, -0.017247971147298813, 0.010833743959665298, -0.0033068889752030373, -0.014979877509176731, -0.013319132849574089, 0.016979632899165154, 0.011674189008772373, 0.00841124914586544, -0.015584705397486687, 0.02739693596959114, 0.021020298823714256, 0.02665632776916027, 0.017203545197844505, 0.012280779890716076, -0.00348834041506052, -0.026869600638747215, -0.021532287821173668, 0.018279558047652245, 0.017994297668337822, 0.055730439722537994, -0.010553723201155663, 0.06697610020637512, 0.03231046348810196, -0.060263291001319885, 0.02970942109823227, 0.05732453987002373, 0.01271737553179264, 0.004090559668838978, -0.022701211273670197, -0.0190290417522192, -0.010958605445921421, 0.00798849854618311, 0.039669353514909744, -0.02076452225446701, -0.0021572771947830915, -0.00011833239841507748, -0.016901060938835144, 0.0005698027671314776, -0.02351633459329605, 0.004827545024454594, 0.0010484523372724652, 0.04191192239522934, -0.0058309887535870075, -0.014271073043346405, 0.0320005863904953, 0.048179741948843, 0.006768742110580206, 0.02517472393810749, -0.0031814109534025192, -0.09433236718177795, 0.019820261746644974, 0.02620069682598114, 0.0029223773162811995, -0.01921132020652294, -0.01968042179942131, -0.0633164644241333, 0.032392051070928574, 0.03798874095082283, -0.020168738439679146, 0.04008181393146515, 0.012873310595750809, 0.009039653465151787, -0.05063333362340927, 0.011773217469453812, -0.025737272575497627, 0.034132860600948334, 0.02521679550409317, 0.05558309704065323, -0.018374266102910042, -0.030823035165667534, -0.038212865591049194, -0.012483327649533749, -0.002543935552239418, 0.05098207667469978, 0.002285689814016223, 0.009614144451916218, 0.0055771502666175365, 0.02324657142162323, 0.008058808743953705, -0.07085948437452316, 0.004825382027775049, 0.03940705209970474, -0.02026633732020855, 0.04401033744215965, -0.019136223942041397, -0.06816152483224869, 0.015203923918306828, -0.0016928915865719318, -0.003440883941948414, 0.04875731095671654, -0.012823295779526234, 0.04439558461308479, 0.012003354728221893, 0.03330497816205025, 0.03538632020354271, 0.0318363681435585, 0.007245538756251335, -0.007548442110419273, 0.029240204021334648, 0.00014619594730902463, -0.05189979448914528, 0.011132783256471157, -0.029868097975850105, -0.022726863622665405, -0.052344705909490585, 0.04747629165649414, -0.006659702397882938, 0.024639036506414413, 0.030065465718507767, 0.02452242560684681, -0.029469523578882217, 0.05994970351457596, 0.012464146129786968, -0.007639450021088123, -0.0021779132075607777, -0.0009411172359250486, -0.043785713613033295, -0.012132281437516212, 0.010557705536484718, -0.019692469388246536, 0.017917267978191376, 0.013947904109954834, -0.021232759580016136, 0.003765054978430271, -0.041986770927906036, 0.0052576689049601555, -0.03029610961675644, -0.007139176595956087, 0.02969423681497574, 0.00394519604742527, 0.024885540828108788, -0.012371481396257877, -0.05322045832872391, 0.053492095321416855, 0.018243735656142235, 0.03336268663406372, 0.020827695727348328, -0.0200398750603199, 0.00843666959553957, 0.022503722459077835, 0.002929658629000187, -0.0789262130856514, -0.05006375536322594, 0.018318960443139076, 0.024864085018634796, -0.0018516089767217636, -0.04200874641537666, 0.01433433685451746, -0.017922744154930115, -0.027750177308917046, -0.02008623071014881, 0.03940882161259651, 0.029759177938103676, -0.04096313565969467, 0.022832762449979782, 0.005849581677466631, 0.08020010590553284, -0.029000695794820786, 0.009730890393257141, 0.005814617965370417, -0.03444920480251312, -0.012487728148698807, -0.045695673674345016, 0.03356637433171272, -0.031336709856987, 0.0013917096657678485, -0.043370507657527924, -0.01929602213203907, 0.03861813247203827, -0.04869585111737251, -0.024451076984405518, 0.04475303739309311, -0.04691894352436066, -0.014140588231384754, -0.031134897843003273, -0.017404232174158096, -0.04324201121926308, 0.007883862592279911, 0.005379385780543089, -0.02270638570189476, 0.04611831158399582, -0.04115043580532074, 0.027058525010943413, 0.007056477479636669, -0.027628136798739433, 0.021874813362956047, 0.024182487279176712, 0.016745204105973244, -0.024255596101284027, 0.012831195257604122, 0.026305727660655975, 0.03850823640823364, -0.0014093485660851002, -0.004324561450630426, 0.007229299284517765, 0.024786122143268585, -0.03093133307993412, -0.06132273003458977, -0.019581640139222145, 0.022562552243471146, 0.05360688269138336, 0.012056914158165455, 0.043906111270189285, 0.02728859893977642, -0.017538931220769882, -0.009403318166732788, 0.008513705804944038, 0.0001010028863674961, -0.03256393224000931, -0.003079092362895608, 0.0331030935049057, -0.009850110858678818, 0.04165349155664444, 0.033921755850315094, -0.0027316634077578783, 0.005284551996737719, 0.015034438110888004, -0.00132885726634413, 0.0023120937403291464, 0.036973271518945694, -0.0029693639371544123, -0.04228619486093521, 0.0592956505715847, -0.023203780874609947, 0.003080362919718027, -0.025209080427885056, 0.005563372280448675, 0.010247631929814816, 0.03593190386891365, 0.021173710003495216, -0.0350375771522522, -0.009568332694470882, -0.05538664013147354, -0.037031032145023346, 0.025827204808592796, 0.016867386177182198, 0.01928916946053505, 0.01810743287205696, 0.016181379556655884, 0.0012987976660951972, 0.034111686050891876, 0.0005806632689200342, -0.019099654629826546, 0.0018472647061571479, -0.030388541519641876, -0.017539190128445625, 0.06577368825674057, 0.028891270980238914, -0.019238384440541267, 0.0017262656474485993, -0.03147173300385475, 0.03243856504559517, 0.04456553980708122, 0.038122184574604034, -0.009160277433693409, 0.07277832180261612, -0.006113828159868717, 0.0017427403945475817, -0.014163932763040066, -0.02243422344326973, 0.11636324971914291, 0.07503335922956467, 0.03984219580888748, -0.06246422976255417, 0.016281912103295326, -0.02655457891523838, -0.0024611405096948147, -0.02666649967432022, -0.003913189750164747, 0.01578124798834324, -0.02547261118888855, 0.00986239779740572, 0.04967440664768219, -0.0019159808289259672, -0.005886609200388193, 0.04995771124958992, -0.04440869390964508, 0.01562001183629036, 0.020833676680922508, 0.01086744200438261, -0.01476229913532734, -0.008902888745069504, -0.05642576143145561, 0.03767412155866623, -0.031346552073955536, -0.035375725477933884, 0.005165810231119394, -0.015674684196710587, 0.0075223008170723915, -0.008186708204448223, -0.027885310351848602, -0.025439228862524033, 0.04310666024684906, 0.02216320112347603, -0.0535292886197567, -0.0007163668633438647, -0.00680005457252264, -0.015723200514912605, 0.05561711639165878, 0.018937790766358376, -0.014315635897219181, -0.011124770157039165, 0.023763781413435936, -0.020568300038576126, -0.015852438285946846, -0.03572474420070648, -0.0455620139837265, 0.023830844089388847, 0.03485531359910965, 0.0022031262051314116, 0.014386946335434914, 0.02561326138675213, 0.015582188963890076, -0.029872490093111992, -0.009253999218344688, 0.003206827910616994, 0.054012835025787354, -0.05817199870944023, -0.00544785475358367, -0.040266942232847214, 0.0026533252093940973, 0.004927769768983126, 0.013841768726706505, 0.0038484600372612476, -0.03771812468767166, 0.009861113503575325, 0.012244983576238155, 0.028785349801182747, 0.011067819781601429, -0.014805209822952747, -0.018967188894748688, -0.0260253194719553, -0.014803250320255756, -0.009687518700957298, 0.031228700652718544, 0.0067702424712479115, -0.007962185889482498, 0.015460863709449768, -0.041734479367733, 0.0397004708647728, -0.08791452646255493, 0.03262864053249359, -0.05100863426923752, -0.00474062655121088, -0.026261277496814728, -0.023527737706899643, 0.04124457389116287, 0.021151838824152946, 0.034263189882040024, 0.0013627094449475408, -0.010885821655392647, 0.04698718711733818, 0.034333087503910065, -0.06967585533857346, -0.0034069775138050318, -0.015712540596723557, -0.0076994202099740505, 0.021709756925702095, -0.01620563492178917, 0.0015961546450853348, 0.018784889951348305, 0.012738758698105812, -0.017149237915873528, 0.03514641523361206, -0.03353326395153999, 0.002541441237553954, -0.006251215934753418, -0.05187654495239258, -0.0319557711482048, 0.022312670946121216, -0.02660169079899788, -0.035167086869478226, -0.05422645062208176, -0.03679102286696434, 0.03743883967399597, -0.014486587606370449, -0.004646872635930777, -0.03814886137843132, -0.008298717439174652, -0.013393538072705269, -0.005021329503506422, -0.039808522909879684, -0.006169436499476433, -0.025157662108540535, -0.015900833532214165, 0.039311300963163376, -0.032667528837919235, -0.013027341105043888, 0.011010530404746532, -0.031342893838882446, -0.027437793090939522, 0.025734378024935722, -0.0027708043344318867, 0.013143974356353283, -0.011826280504465103, 0.00006686193228233606, -0.028447316959500313, 0.03718780726194382, -0.023347927257418633, -0.05519229546189308, 0.03642237186431885, -0.04027711600065231, 0.014322946779429913, 0.05239497870206833, -0.037441495805978775, 0.017621122300624847, 0.03325262665748596, -0.0009128336096182466, 0.01241153385490179, 0.013107797130942345, -0.025082048028707504, 0.001899953349493444, 0.03688281401991844, -0.03327782824635506, -0.01229518186300993, -0.006222367752343416, 0.03788046911358833, 0.01835436187684536, -0.009178891777992249, 0.014950516633689404, 0.04691582918167114, 0.02846628427505493, -0.015089062042534351, 0.003365197218954563, -0.0010211232583969831, 0.01693836972117424, 0.03357069939374924, 0.00413811719045043, 0.05255766585469246, 0.08257248252630234, -0.03755522891879082, -0.014487020671367645, -0.042817652225494385, -0.021661793813109398, -0.0924990326166153, 0.008146421052515507, 0.013882136903703213, 0.0029794026631861925, 0.06155719608068466, -0.05615267902612686, 0.010417528450489044, 0.04346223548054695, -0.05981659144163132, -0.0028688497841358185, 0.0033794317860156298, -0.010722308419644833, -0.03811521455645561, -0.009953953325748444, -0.02272139862179756, 0.04213908687233925, 0.02878984436392784, 0.056255001574754715, 0.018146459013223648, 0.04493986442685127, -0.0012314722407609224, 0.012716591358184814, 0.015241927467286587, 0.028880421072244644, -0.0017410622676834464, -0.03387107700109482, 0.01828528195619583, -0.022813599556684494, -0.011075814254581928, 0.018115807324647903, -0.015784960240125656, 0.010988233610987663, -0.007858994416892529, 0.032933346927165985, -0.022681746631860733, 0.01139832567423582, -0.01417657732963562, -0.05154747888445854, 0.008851399645209312, -0.013549890369176865, 0.009028618223965168, 0.04379567876458168, -0.044676195830106735, -0.01596989668905735, 0.009491754695773125, -0.042656585574150085, -0.03612978011369705, 0.001203239313326776, -0.016783729195594788, -0.03782400116324425, 0.00924265943467617, -0.004411704838275909, 0.003667798824608326, 0.00034491883707232773, 0.04828091710805893, -0.011624615639448166, 0.012024883180856705, 0.005477415397763252, 0.01155531033873558, -0.03069337271153927, -0.006212391424924135, -0.0017988693434745073, -0.06444568186998367, 0.0520649254322052, -0.017579663544893265, -0.02196737565100193, -0.07339247316122055, -0.04816402494907379, -0.006945151835680008, 0.008351746015250683, -0.04692288115620613, -0.011991784907877445, -0.02332635037600994, 0.039757076650857925, 0.025465944781899452, 0.0010262567084282637, -0.023148685693740845, -0.06815271824598312, -0.010792247951030731, -0.04168175160884857, 0.026784149929881096, 0.03411436825990677, -0.01905285008251667, -0.04878893122076988, -0.018632998690009117, -0.0405803918838501, -0.012907200492918491, 0.05915199592709541, 0.008226371370255947, 0.004805272910743952, 0.02105080522596836, 0.0347585529088974, 0.015162971802055836, -0.03377769514918327, -0.0005743266083300114, -0.03576817736029625, -0.014421761967241764, -0.022359205409884453, -0.027191029861569405, 0.027478937059640884, 0.008678973652422428, 0.0241882111877203, 0.004891039803624153, -0.002054252428933978, 0.04028739407658577, -0.02379036322236061, 0.05733495578169823, -0.007547155953943729, -0.014303062111139297, 0.0794246569275856, -0.02601873129606247, 0.017009947448968887, 0.00023432941816281527, -0.009836841374635696, -0.039862338453531265, 0.025320226326584816, -0.02414412423968315, -0.02903244085609913, -0.0013883133651688695, 0.02150377258658409, 0.007982634007930756, -0.020680097863078117, -0.061896465718746185, 0.033737313002347946, -0.007251986768096685, -0.004033977165818214, 0.024845002219080925, 0.04225699231028557, 0.016261151060461998, 0.0343034490942955, 0.026466086506843567, 0.026369910687208176, 0.05633286386728287, 0.02646155282855034, 0.056290801614522934, 0.061558160930871964, -0.012727177701890469, 0.004911273252218962, -0.012729008682072163, -0.04314792901277542, 0.013178330846130848, -0.010026398114860058, 0.0213673897087574, -0.01811928302049637, -0.03204438090324402, 0.00671015027910471, -0.02035883627831936, -0.006781143136322498, -0.014998861588537693, -0.0022959820926189423, 0.054511018097400665, -0.010680275037884712, 0.00775880878791213, -0.018466288223862648, -0.040127743035554886, -0.01082746870815754, 0.006578195374459028, 0.046203020960092545, 0.004348342306911945, -0.03306327760219574, 0.04099945351481438, 0.01455390639603138, -0.005767407361418009, 0.023800499737262726, -0.0077548399567604065, 0.009514225646853447, 0.02297472022473812, -0.005556268617510796, -0.020865464583039284, -0.013232688419520855, -0.016415663063526154, -0.03501300886273384, 0.012108438648283482, 0.046320077031850815, 0.038836490362882614, -0.008938106708228588, 0.007897638715803623, -0.057604625821113586, 0.035457249730825424, -0.10136022418737411, 0.012768706306815147, -0.044704802334308624, 0.01653926819562912, 0.02101820707321167, -0.0014655451523140073 ]
<p>I am trying to apply a simple Naive Bayes or SVM (libSVM) algorithms to a large data set, which I've constructed as an .arff file.</p> <p>The number of features in my set is ~180k and there are ~6k examples. Also there are 8 classification classes. The data is of size ~3.2GB.</p> <p>I am working with Weka's Java API and Eclipse, I am increasing JVM's memory to the maximum, but I am always getting a heap space error.</p> <p>I am on a MacBook Pro, 2.3 GHz Intel Core i5, 4GB 1333 MHz DDR3.</p> <p>Do I need to find another machine to work with or is it possible that I am having an memory leaks programmatically?</p>
31,626
[ -0.02349410578608513, -0.0020432756282389164, -0.029275938868522644, -0.017483938485383987, 0.032617565244436264, -0.010342510417103767, -0.0027152078691869974, -0.01900532841682434, 0.005556185729801655, -0.021616511046886444, 0.03055115044116974, 0.0691768079996109, 0.03195330128073692, 0.07252044975757599, 0.00514482194557786, -0.044160570949316025, 0.023546699434518814, -0.04366740211844444, 0.02390122599899769, 0.0019052820280194283, -0.026404792442917824, 0.010686163790524006, 0.031326036900281906, -0.016551826149225235, -0.04235461726784706, 0.017813578248023987, 0.030318215489387512, -0.009551848284900188, 0.004960286431014538, 0.03064778633415699, -0.02776508592069149, -0.03545825183391571, 0.016502832993865013, 0.040148697793483734, 0.02049383707344532, -0.002245621057227254, -0.029312094673514366, -0.04362165555357933, -0.015008967369794846, 0.018738122656941414, 0.0010126328561455011, 0.007880853489041328, -0.004312368109822273, 0.03766942769289017, -0.012569098733365536, -0.021763795986771584, 0.029571743682026863, -0.030492499470710754, 0.0250790286809206, -0.020223980769515038, 0.05575413629412651, -0.01475441548973322, 0.05781511589884758, 0.035513944923877716, 0.002261098939925432, -0.0033979963045567274, 0.027289919555187225, 0.07598701864480972, -0.023031268268823624, -0.000691403285600245, 0.009185985662043095, -0.004282684065401554, -0.004809556528925896, -0.003640513401478529, -0.00979720987379551, 0.05094695836305618, -0.04617144167423248, -0.02158932201564312, 0.002994491485878825, 0.007513894233852625, 0.017428161576390266, -0.012951421551406384, 0.06176961958408356, -0.04842932149767876, 0.06077740341424942, -0.00562503095716238, 0.014866003766655922, 0.031179124489426613, 0.027793841436505318, 0.03240415081381798, 0.022143512964248657, 0.02973231114447117, -0.013440840877592564, 0.017893271520733833, 0.03388574719429016, -0.03692218288779259, 0.030768180266022682, 0.007856086827814579, -0.023556379601359367, 0.055046986788511276, -0.00886000506579876, 0.01613241620361805, 0.045961372554302216, -0.009085415862500668, -0.01218921784311533, 0.002524149604141712, -0.014290919527411461, 0.04621974378824234, -0.0005973380175419152, -0.01217486709356308, 0.03028404526412487, -0.02195790782570839, 0.006311424076557159, 0.0497218519449234, -0.031340859830379486, -0.03283942490816116, -0.05406447499990463, 0.012744586914777756, -0.013617906719446182, -0.019336096942424774, -0.05656794086098671, 0.007758689112961292, 0.0067916265688836575, 0.0012774558272212744, 0.013359688222408295, 0.0019405517959967256, -0.03201553225517273, -0.004103285260498524, 0.001661111251451075, 0.07393532991409302, 0.06224874407052994, -0.026304610073566437, 0.0439135767519474, -0.049909334629774094, -0.0771741196513176, 0.027664445340633392, -0.027600904926657677, -0.057310812175273895, -0.03163553401827812, 0.03176381438970566, -0.008050591684877872, -0.04730026423931122, 0.024080758914351463, -0.04367957264184952, 0.05623418837785721, 0.0030481459107249975, -0.07727031409740448, -0.05968298763036728, -0.0014684632187709212, -0.006565269082784653, 0.03761725500226021, -0.05235505849123001, 0.02678574249148369, 0.015558051876723766, 0.02826504223048687, 0.014564497396349907, 0.021586019545793533, 0.05352245271205902, 0.0385112538933754, -0.0413643978536129, -0.031899720430374146, 0.011405110359191895, -0.04526107758283615, 0.01991981267929077, -0.005582502577453852, -0.077647864818573, 0.001418725005351007, 0.035418324172496796, 0.015855126082897186, -0.0269403588026762, -0.031131627038121223, 0.000889306073077023, -0.009386938065290451, -0.03776034712791443, -0.02344280667603016, -0.036272503435611725, 0.037654515355825424, 0.023304875940084457, 0.06804784387350082, 0.02230801433324814, -0.007422615308314562, -0.0007529417052865028, 0.03423043712973595, 0.016026942059397697, 0.05841149389743805, -0.004869858734309673, 0.0127920713275671, -0.05397753044962883, 0.007416432723402977, 0.029553519561886787, -0.016093779355287552, -0.042080480605363846, 0.011192632839083672, 0.014817812480032444, -0.006280940491706133, 0.05072479322552681, 0.00045137706911191344, -0.007194906007498503, 0.0034519750624895096, -0.025064988061785698, -0.0475536547601223, -0.059240762144327164, 0.038248032331466675, -0.03899180144071579, -0.04098812863230705, 0.01307747047394514, -0.01622912846505642, 0.04348687827587128, -0.01462955866008997, -0.02580138109624386, -0.01725415326654911, 0.009623074904084206, 0.03203998878598213, -0.06271104514598846, -0.011266901157796383, 0.059659674763679504, -0.00444220844656229, -0.03659842163324356, 0.03143864497542381, -0.02679368108510971, -0.07689706236124039, 0.03260219469666481, -0.005039872135967016, -0.04075111448764801, -0.03324950858950615, -0.02329922653734684, 0.03536788001656532, 0.014847970567643642, 0.016629783436655998, 0.0068417019210755825, -0.013434887863695621, 0.05848822742700577, 0.06589141488075256, 0.029427820816636086, 0.013704964891076088, -0.029124828055500984, -0.0347059965133667, 0.004017012193799019, -0.011891556903719902, 0.03574330359697342, -0.05989587679505348, -0.003963013645261526, 0.04730924591422081, -0.010770571418106556, -0.03539660945534706, 0.011578868143260479, 0.04549667239189148, -0.005920227617025375, 0.018056994304060936, 0.019971361383795738, -0.014143007807433605, 0.00902341865003109, 0.01611301116645336, 0.015663236379623413, 0.030389804393053055, 0.019170042127370834, -0.004855016712099314, 0.034980904310941696, 0.03888663277029991, -0.0067813401110470295, -0.04087388515472412, 0.026835232973098755, 0.010137480683624744, -0.009629610925912857, -0.03003968484699726, -0.02783612161874771, 0.03550771623849869, -0.02443520538508892, 0.00013045223022345454, 0.05212564766407013, -0.00578900333493948, 0.021070001646876335, 0.00954973604530096, -0.03485705330967903, 0.00969531200826168, 0.02176424115896225, 0.0070203859359025955, -0.014891243539750576, 0.017975471913814545, -0.08136262744665146, 0.0015737863723188639, 0.018401533365249634, -0.018977100029587746, -0.05358738452196121, 0.06693046540021896, 0.03077704645693302, -0.0224709901958704, 0.007825258187949657, -0.03157411888241768, 0.013532314449548721, 0.011047587729990482, -0.01942320540547371, -0.008796820417046547, -0.0092830341309309, -0.019059661775827408, 0.02248019352555275, 0.012274857610464096, -0.027035148814320564, 0.0485830195248127, 0.011089247651398182, -0.036456987261772156, 0.046439845114946365, -0.001245039515197277, -0.019455399364233017, -0.018353022634983063, -0.008743693120777607, 0.01449456438422203, 0.017947055399417877, -0.004747302271425724, 0.04430728778243065, 0.014181478880345821, -0.007787469308823347, -0.006952099967747927, -0.002684767125174403, -0.01483073364943266, -0.02797374501824379, -0.0313013531267643, 0.01306807529181242, -0.00282568228431046, -0.033246126025915146, 0.01341106928884983, -0.018324317410588264, 0.011049794033169746, -0.041477132588624954, -0.06519986689090729, 0.0010230307234451175, 0.0016194452764466405, 0.017920982092618942, 0.007485163398087025, 0.004752965644001961, 0.06913036108016968, 0.040230199694633484, -0.038912974298000336, -0.009574721567332745, -0.05587055906653404, -0.022166961804032326, -0.01587960496544838, -0.018959445878863335, 0.010084637440741062, 0.030133098363876343, 0.003017739625647664, -0.04300767928361893, -0.017449703067541122, 0.049188628792762756, 0.004401787184178829, -0.04240165278315544, 0.021344460546970367, -0.02043767273426056, -0.03421781584620476, 0.056991077959537506, 0.0011303843930363655, -0.04177688807249069, 0.013211476616561413, -0.02281312830746174, 0.009492728859186172, 0.012567338533699512, -0.024281956255435944, 0.019810235127806664, -0.023881645873188972, 0.018415668979287148, -0.058544423431158066, 0.02164488472044468, 0.025665223598480225, -0.045651283115148544, 0.02575402893126011, 0.02338581532239914, 0.04095902666449547, -0.001272890018299222, -0.01275920495390892, -0.0049916706047952175, 0.035068005323410034, -0.008046431466937065, -0.03798561170697212, -0.05085218697786331, 0.004076669923961163, 0.013012411072850227, 0.016522081568837166, 0.0069406782276928425, 0.022912967950105667, 0.06479527056217194, 0.04493790119886398, -0.012790072709321976, -0.05388638377189636, 0.014033244922757149, -0.06327856332063675, 0.02579064667224884, -0.013030603528022766, 0.030172886326909065, 0.016496341675519943, -0.0005087621975690126, 0.0453181229531765, -0.001273825648240745, 0.04199079051613808, -0.017526043578982353, -0.033288732171058655, -0.007362061180174351, 0.013049616478383541, -0.030469432473182678, 0.01603543758392334, -0.04778129234910011, 0.023500919342041016, -0.008679687045514584, 0.010008132085204124, 0.0009142698836512864, 0.006054309196770191, -0.04475008323788643, 0.027155693620443344, -0.003089041216298938, -0.0018053340027108788, -0.004695475101470947, 0.021848082542419434, 0.014499318785965443, -0.020810863003134727, 0.017118247225880623, 0.014872482977807522, -0.02104666829109192, -0.038415953516960144, 0.009462840855121613, 0.0036050642374902964, -0.048668716102838516, 0.030889179557561874, 0.01999654807150364, 0.04472603648900986, -0.03701898455619812, -0.017294693738222122, -0.0023035299964249134, 0.0375189445912838, 0.0210048146545887, -0.013599530793726444, 0.004841866437345743, -0.030326100066304207, -0.013565168716013432, -0.005879641976207495, 0.031711701303720474, -0.001075922278687358, 0.026931053027510643, 0.008872832171618938, 0.04299907758831978, -0.0556882880628109, -0.038717903196811676, 0.07355213910341263, -0.015540280379354954, -0.004317425191402435, -0.0176339503377676, -0.022301899269223213, 0.017536818981170654, -0.007922411896288395, 0.057063665241003036, 0.02383348159492016, -0.04638250917196274, -0.0028349095955491066, -0.010085302405059338, -0.07375722378492355, -0.01732751354575157, 0.05253324657678604, 0.012086562812328339, 0.027294229716062546, -0.019750529900193214, 0.03436485677957535, 0.020989177748560905, 0.03604456037282944, 0.011496268212795258, 0.0009060417069122195, -0.005547478795051575, -0.10429451614618301, -0.020209835842251778, 0.04793800786137581, 0.020524458959698677, 0.005182603839784861, 0.019764689728617668, -0.05001584067940712, -0.017779143527150154, 0.025587495416402817, -0.04954252019524574, 0.03590366989374161, 0.024799101054668427, 0.029094981029629707, -0.02193671092391014, -0.02373587153851986, -0.027345459908246994, -0.03027637116611004, -0.06493132561445236, 0.07089786976575851, -0.005368981510400772, -0.029467973858118057, -0.04881175979971886, 0.01908702775835991, 0.03656256943941116, 0.08010748028755188, -0.016384629532694817, 0.026735641062259674, 0.004801629576832056, -0.00407643336802721, -0.004461882635951042, -0.039395127445459366, 0.00024049010244198143, -0.03699929639697075, -0.027011675760149956, 0.045344747602939606, -0.021579261869192123, -0.021127978339791298, 0.02728804387152195, 0.04251735284924507, -0.07406623661518097, -0.056004639714956284, -0.03642258048057556, 0.011198692955076694, 0.014692984521389008, 0.023210516199469566, 0.017371447756886482, -0.0035332241095602512, 0.0236246045678854, 0.005547233857214451, -0.03081252984702587, 0.0076082549057900906, -0.03909692540764809, 0.021673843264579773, -0.049884334206581116, -0.025008171796798706, -0.011820072308182716, 0.04549134895205498, 0.023320553824305534, -0.0033928346820175648, -0.021796097978949547, -0.026224220171570778, 0.023852363228797913, 0.0016468713292852044, 0.005364787299185991, -0.0277007557451725, -0.011507777497172356, 0.005623302888125181, -0.020814839750528336, 0.02494414895772934, 0.029238682240247726, -0.03788630664348602, 0.009780238382518291, 0.03803131356835365, -0.0331842266023159, 0.00607886491343379, -0.05023426562547684, 0.0008478207164444029, -0.005830757319927216, -0.030889982357621193, 0.0559503436088562, 0.015223989263176918, 0.06593749672174454, 0.04382585361599922, -0.046372201293706894, -0.029644081369042397, -0.029812738299369812, 0.0008863431285135448, 0.07531672716140747, -0.04298292100429535, 0.05713824927806854, -0.010446150787174702, 0.03600022941827774, -0.06331504881381989, -0.024339688941836357, 0.009233337827026844, 0.005352984182536602, -0.00542141729965806, -0.048210155218839645, -0.010246791876852512, 0.02800264023244381, -0.01685757376253605, 0.005782406311482191, 0.044322364032268524, -0.01753944344818592, 0.01763365976512432, 0.02846672013401985, 0.014563643373548985, 0.04775422066450119, 0.00663378369063139, 0.035854849964380264, 0.018312174826860428, 0.007133965380489826, -0.030504731461405754, -0.0012337140506133437, 0.01587229035794735, -0.015675386413931847, -0.018045654520392418, -0.0006662450614385307, 0.00042573909740895033, 0.012792724184691906, -0.015445167198777199, -0.02577855996787548, 0.0575299970805645, -0.006703269202262163, -0.001393627724610269, -0.0219978429377079, 0.019724780693650246, 0.024824483320116997, -0.016353895887732506, -0.025674963369965553, -0.008575774729251862, 0.0010506308171898127, 0.009429838508367538, 0.00982059445232153, 0.024016348645091057, 0.0015410622581839561, 0.011224226094782352, 0.022476375102996826, -0.06630662828683853, 0.014269552193582058, 0.0066567687317729, -0.027326229959726334, 0.016044382005929947, 0.014908385463058949, 0.010316073894500732, -0.028995364904403687, 0.00741606717929244, -0.03681166470050812, 0.02922876365482807, -0.056881871074438095, -0.003826769068837166, 0.03462006524205208, 0.027583664283156395, 0.033885180950164795, 0.07411626726388931, 0.02751171961426735, -0.00073579529998824, -0.0421866811811924, -0.023511072620749474, -0.006504532415419817, 0.000317936617648229, 0.04955587536096573, 0.013960063457489014, 0.04108898714184761, 0.05054376274347305, 0.02614564634859562, -0.0007070646388456225, 0.05082366243004799, -0.011354239657521248, 0.0262153297662735, 0.011143473908305168, -0.02297935262322426, -0.04519142955541611, 0.02824609912931919, -0.009308885782957077, 0.043122801929712296, -0.01193977054208517, -0.02896970324218273, 0.05601486936211586, -0.0016765468753874302, 0.028577439486980438, -0.03999871760606766, -0.05556631460785866, -0.031124763190746307, 0.017923178151249886, 0.02804121933877468, -0.0020975973457098007, 0.018012862652540207, 0.014344798400998116, 0.034180764108896255, 0.00841430202126503, -0.003482009982690215, -0.015494930557906628, -0.07263213396072388, -0.039526429027318954, -0.034757912158966064, -0.049661651253700256, 0.01859644241631031, -0.004687575623393059, -0.03920840471982956, 0.011929072439670563, -0.0003856474650092423, 0.06378162652254105, -0.019139643758535385, 0.06437929719686508, 0.02484985440969467, 0.049536366015672684, -0.005849458277225494, 0.017531394958496094, -0.007604796439409256, 0.062083739787340164, 0.13206559419631958, 0.04071469232439995, 0.05156569182872772, -0.02955891378223896, -0.015623470768332481, -0.02044251374900341, -0.007525943219661713, -0.037049323320388794, 0.02979537658393383, -0.030994713306427002, -0.004035783465951681, 0.032503530383110046, -0.011814109049737453, 0.03323166444897652, -0.014788910746574402, 0.055596042424440384, -0.03048713132739067, 0.01475586835294962, 0.030958320945501328, 0.03073970228433609, 0.042278025299310684, -0.002142503159120679, -0.029668960720300674, -0.006369165610522032, -0.02315216325223446, -0.06511453539133072, -0.020063817501068115, -0.02789737470448017, 0.028823858126997948, 0.008137292228639126, -0.00981682538986206, 0.020270729437470436, -0.01040834840387106, 0.02778141014277935, 0.023909734562039375, -0.006397314369678497, 0.02610822580754757, -0.0014070210745558143, -0.017437374219298363, 0.03116861917078495, 0.0321992002427578, -0.0010948809795081615, 0.008928658440709114, 0.00238338066264987, -0.01988157257437706, -0.04615684971213341, -0.022995542734861374, 0.05755503103137016, -0.012263336218893528, 0.010333826765418053, -0.010552216321229935, 0.01836826093494892, 0.01751682721078396, -0.07723405212163925, -0.02748267352581024, 0.020300623029470444, -0.020876241847872734, -0.007608747109770775, -0.012491796165704727, -0.020158397033810616, 0.042441174387931824, -0.027111558243632317, 0.03120824322104454, 0.005247359164059162, -0.0054532610811293125, -0.02071079984307289, -0.022956600412726402, 0.011653583496809006, 0.009299010969698429, 0.021496573463082314, -0.028876949101686478, -0.04735014960169792, 0.003525512758642435, -0.027932345867156982, 0.045179158449172974, -0.007271680515259504, -0.009690401144325733, -0.027165472507476807, -0.04501223564147949, -0.033864885568618774, -0.0425746813416481, -0.026397138833999634, -0.06004876270890236, -0.028641628101468086, -0.053386133164167404, 0.009711403399705887, 0.009842596016824245, 0.01057907473295927, 0.02675749734044075, -0.027873720973730087, 0.02726302109658718, 0.05452761799097061, 0.0012821315322071314, 0.005776230711489916, -0.01705220155417919, -0.009362518787384033, -0.043379660695791245, 0.04674732685089111, -0.005618860013782978, 0.09861177951097488, 0.04844139143824577, -0.008338884450495243, 0.0383722148835659, 0.00582026457414031, -0.019232304766774178, 0.011322901584208012, 0.0148393539711833, -0.012262573465704918, 0.004795474465936422, 0.0012460530269891024, 0.0014956304803490639, -0.009405960328876972, 0.002101294929161668, -0.039085667580366135, -0.04586484655737877, 0.018682295456528664, 0.005537232384085655, -0.03414446860551834, 0.034945107996463776, -0.007262306287884712, 0.0356258749961853, -0.04806619510054588, -0.0021712612360715866, -0.033090244978666306, -0.017835689708590508, -0.018747292459011078, 0.006407520733773708, -0.017331475391983986, -0.003041153075173497, -0.003431688528507948, -0.020929038524627686, 0.04466569423675537, 0.007160901557654142, -0.009360495023429394, 0.030056869611144066, 0.017382057383656502, 0.008253337815403938, 0.04096401855349541, -0.017370063811540604, -0.020233454182744026, 0.04935763031244278, -0.061423491686582565, -0.001172686810605228, 0.029882173985242844, -0.028197836130857468, 0.03288125619292259, 0.034318145364522934, -0.002656290540471673, -0.0220798272639513, 0.07485559582710266, -0.00004763253309647553, -0.0171565692871809, 0.00972591619938612, 0.010340017266571522, -0.0009062797762453556, 0.031438861042261124, 0.023908013477921486, -0.020687954500317574, -0.013904541730880737, 0.007453042082488537, 0.026405656710267067, 0.019523143768310547, 0.007229388225823641, 0.03418542072176933, 0.0013249124167487025, 0.0008440267411060631, 0.032911479473114014, -0.02417225018143654, 0.038341179490089417, 0.0049462877213954926, -0.032774150371551514, 0.037717826664447784, -0.027305936440825462, 0.03445391356945038, -0.08652341365814209, -0.003186925547197461, 0.005982935894280672, 0.013083313591778278, 0.024643709883093834, -0.024785667657852173, 0.024404896423220634, 0.04255885258316994, -0.03625145182013512, 0.018765423446893692, 0.015339196659624577, 0.017888851463794708, -0.062146611511707306, 0.02700483240187168, 0.020658686757087708, -0.013441244140267372, 0.023045595735311508, 0.05638359487056732, 0.06152154132723808, 0.04484347999095917, -0.03802680969238281, -0.04112919047474861, -0.04883556067943573, 0.04231550171971321, -0.00035196621320210397, -0.03427644446492195, 0.032887570559978485, -0.024509873241186142, -0.027669096365571022, 0.005418491084128618, 0.0077581824734807014, 0.01607203669846058, 0.08555714786052704, 0.04472506418824196, 0.027786053717136383, 0.01577509008347988, 0.07628929615020752, -0.02191295102238655, 0.005704872775822878, -0.010856089182198048, -0.026843223720788956, 0.003787389025092125, 0.009242766536772251, 0.0415070615708828, 0.022045470774173737, -0.030256012454628944, 0.02771448716521263, 0.022555077448487282, -0.027571167796850204, -0.017354771494865417, 0.006902747321873903, 0.022059448063373566, 0.001445056521333754, -0.037972670048475266, -0.01535295695066452, -0.02235838957130909, 0.017237083986401558, -0.0028770759236067533, 0.0003080737078562379, -0.03696344047784805, 0.0249235387891531, 0.004522775299847126, -0.005308916326612234, -0.021347923204302788, 0.0015683862147852778, -0.00775499502196908, -0.04070800542831421, 0.022562935948371887, -0.02107858844101429, 0.0009042188758030534, -0.009954758919775486, -0.04604600369930267, -0.04133696109056473, 0.020207129418849945, -0.047065719962120056, 0.008252831175923347, 0.01462205033749342, 0.022651229053735733, 0.02142368070781231, -0.052038442343473434, 0.03972199186682701, 0.013438025489449501, -0.010238997638225555, -0.051129721105098724, -0.0007540498627349734, -0.023599203675985336, 0.03316890448331833, 0.024175608530640602, 0.0062669143080711365, 0.0580151304602623, -0.024257555603981018, -0.031714558601379395, 0.01907923072576523, -0.04915500432252884, 0.032937753945589066, -0.01659885235130787, -0.056716278195381165, 0.022578272968530655, -0.02393633872270584, 0.039953313767910004, 0.0305766761302948, 0.02263203077018261, 0.00901002623140812, -0.005193866323679686, -0.01657840795814991, -0.019240984693169594, -0.03413926064968109, -0.03297954797744751, 0.015776949003338814, 0.04204745218157768, 0.011300486512482166, -0.015611888840794563, 0.03427177667617798, -0.021855711936950684, -0.049937810748815536, 0.0195620134472847, -0.0316108874976635, -0.009356250986456871, 0.0061316704377532005, 0.009507052600383759, 0.019561266526579857, -0.09760070592164993, -0.014654085971415043, 0.044032979756593704, -0.03831816837191582, -0.019094685092568398, 0.04651210829615593, -0.003031500382348895, 0.034279078245162964, 0.016665851697325706, 0.022054282948374748, -0.022867079824209213, -0.013627760112285614, -0.019524259492754936, 0.03215676546096802, -0.017503082752227783, -0.026937704533338547, 0.04723012447357178, 0.05798827111721039, -0.009930245578289032, 0.005830379668623209, -0.0089860325679183, 0.03342386707663536, -0.011603257618844509, -0.018598681315779686, -0.01825740374624729, 0.0024370045866817236, -0.001505275839008391, 0.024362638592720032, -0.02207919768989086, 0.09390199184417725, -0.009364556521177292, -0.005266692489385605, -0.035335078835487366, -0.018932191655039787, -0.049996472895145416, 0.02890254184603691, -0.03229459375143051, -0.0197757501155138, -0.01422309409826994, -0.017742779105901718, -0.027719473466277122, -0.006706012412905693, 0.0410020537674427, -0.02975456975400448, -0.021516812965273857, -0.008023825474083424, 0.015090860426425934, -0.029034536331892014, -0.00034492622944526374, 0.01533648744225502, -0.005447776522487402, 0.006172941066324711, 0.051665112376213074, 0.012316758744418621, -0.0239791888743639, -0.023729121312499046, 0.010326382704079151, 0.016450269147753716, -0.01675483211874962, 0.017985038459300995, -0.05852267146110535, -0.008918446488678455, -0.034354064613580704, -0.04002406820654869 ]
<p>I have data of a continuous random variable within the range [-1,1], which sometimes is concentrated around 0, while other times is concentrated toward -1 and 1, while zero is relatively underpopulated. </p> <p>What measure can I use for both these cases to measure the divergence from a uniform distribution?</p> <p>In other terms: I am looking for a measure of how evenly spread out the data is within the range, but standard dispersion measures (like variance) don't seem to work, since they favor distributions in which the tails are higher than the 'peak', e.g., when the region around zero is relatively underpopulated.</p>
73,914
[ -0.009028328582644463, 0.014200766570866108, -0.0006689694127999246, -0.01347267720848322, 0.017085596919059753, -0.00811518169939518, 0.0034673879854381084, 0.013104147277772427, -0.001874596462585032, -0.04741310328245163, 0.03713031858205795, 0.03565610572695732, 0.043585363775491714, -0.002575180260464549, 0.007951251231133938, -0.009472631849348545, -0.01525499764829874, 0.009297063574194908, -0.028956327587366104, -0.02711179479956627, 0.02088513784110546, -0.004860319197177887, 0.020427873358130455, 0.009648305363953114, -0.06734248250722885, 0.055654797703027725, 0.021597957238554955, 0.005416735541075468, -0.018314985558390617, 0.06629452854394913, -0.06251759082078934, -0.04500451311469078, 0.03607185184955597, 0.04917661100625992, 0.032804250717163086, 0.0152091383934021, -0.02992779016494751, -0.0424431674182415, -0.04928165301680565, 0.026527244597673416, -0.018576903268694878, -0.04252003878355026, -0.04196318984031677, 0.009828450158238411, -0.008976423181593418, -0.006570879835635424, 0.01429785043001175, -0.06857605278491974, 0.06338673830032349, -0.05906986445188522, 0.09045632928609848, 0.005779525730758905, 0.040155183523893356, 0.015366670675575733, 0.017304938286542892, 0.011485893279314041, 0.03632713109254837, 0.07733247429132462, 0.00010623273556120694, -0.07759986817836761, -0.020261086523532867, -0.04636137932538986, -0.021724758669734, -0.030734432861208916, -0.01726655662059784, 0.023672282695770264, -0.013129878789186478, -0.03217248618602753, 0.04012025147676468, 0.0003629325656220317, 0.0046318997628986835, 0.025355231016874313, 0.01654307171702385, -0.007910425774753094, 0.021132545545697212, -0.04239092022180557, 0.00003760729305213317, 0.0010975995101034641, 0.040240328758955, 0.027133582159876823, 0.003926882054656744, 0.00548352999612689, 0.016201602295041084, 0.016403978690505028, -0.0009625302045606077, -0.010452499613165855, 0.09344808012247086, -0.04056993126869202, 0.012439625337719917, 0.053183890879154205, -0.025783736258745193, 0.0013597264187410474, 0.030807778239250183, 0.006518325302749872, -0.052050236612558365, 0.04086843505501747, -0.008588206022977829, 0.03417642414569855, -0.010873524472117424, -0.04060787335038185, -0.023494800552725792, -0.06752808392047882, 0.04465051367878914, 0.08080871403217316, -0.006821721792221069, 0.021359872072935104, -0.05745362490415573, -0.010477447882294655, -0.04328252375125885, -0.009970206767320633, 0.0029260837472975254, 0.012119906023144722, 0.0425601452589035, 0.002618816215544939, 0.041408516466617584, 0.020176192745566368, 0.01791035570204258, -0.030256155878305435, 0.04797638580203056, 0.0553673692047596, 0.04586615785956383, -0.0043187388218939304, 0.044715866446495056, 0.006631593219935894, -0.06633104383945465, 0.012460495345294476, 0.02235877513885498, 0.017882483080029488, -0.04362168163061142, 0.05725594609975815, -0.03151528537273407, 0.008366619236767292, 0.06389586627483368, -0.008439768105745316, 0.024134714156389236, 0.007193108554929495, -0.07322665303945541, -0.06760582327842712, 0.0070738764479756355, -0.0171304140239954, -0.008271405473351479, -0.027102867141366005, -0.025981463491916656, 0.028897102922201157, 0.003435321617871523, -0.000417197123169899, 0.04315607249736786, -0.04142261669039726, 0.004200519993901253, -0.016378220170736313, -0.002869230229407549, -0.0346306711435318, -0.04243449494242668, -0.03433268889784813, 0.002226185752078891, -0.032520443201065063, 0.012819260358810425, 0.04456086829304695, -0.01576186716556549, -0.00232926313765347, 0.02506762556731701, 0.008075485937297344, 0.024557387456297874, -0.0036420561373233795, 0.023964595049619675, -0.0022247745655477047, 0.07772504538297653, 0.010844468139111996, 0.0011167825432494283, 0.016772141680121422, 0.023195605725049973, 0.00016134700854308903, 0.010324079543352127, 0.0166940875351429, 0.05472886934876442, -0.04288167878985405, 0.0038837927859276533, -0.03167199715971947, 0.011309328489005566, 0.053105492144823074, -0.04739883169531822, 0.0006224369863048196, -0.01601448468863964, 0.008625563234090805, 0.027452174574136734, 0.03715318441390991, -0.011183424852788448, -0.01995619386434555, 0.0415571928024292, -0.04382810369133949, -0.02737566828727722, -0.035228028893470764, 0.010933530516922474, 0.02857315167784691, -0.01285527553409338, 0.048581935465335846, 0.04268709570169449, 0.02854149043560028, -0.0374613031744957, -0.022786082699894905, -0.04218088090419769, -0.02357623167335987, 0.027826320379972458, -0.03337526321411133, 0.01687300018966198, 0.059708595275878906, 0.02311745658516884, -0.04487387835979462, 0.08530427515506744, -0.00824497826397419, -0.0374140702188015, -0.026411177590489388, -0.04910430312156677, 0.036017369478940964, 0.006405423860996962, 0.017362447455525398, 0.006335045211017132, 0.0085339630022645, 0.008187304250895977, 0.010949724353849888, -0.054089758545160294, 0.06696052104234695, 0.06335998326539993, 0.01063552126288414, 0.01036589965224266, -0.010645514354109764, 0.011915124021470547, 0.009015955962240696, -0.02120816707611084, -0.051781535148620605, -0.03286755457520485, 0.027538413181900978, 0.07292404025793076, 0.0108973802998662, -0.026242827996611595, -0.023789959028363228, 0.046455807983875275, -0.0013826475478708744, 0.023234833031892776, 0.0327264703810215, -0.028044817969202995, -0.010300617665052414, 0.029213789850473404, 0.027069056406617165, 0.02994575910270214, -0.005671042948961258, 0.04212707281112671, 0.0115052480250597, 0.010656198486685753, -0.0029519929084926844, -0.00276500778272748, 0.02318132109940052, 0.040167104452848434, 0.008548147976398468, -0.013143732212483883, 0.00009143861097982153, 0.006641756277531385, -0.014065135270357132, -0.004614702425897121, 0.04156387597322464, -0.0048161279410123825, 0.015601773746311665, 0.026221314445137978, -0.06409406661987305, 0.04480636864900589, 0.05353448912501335, -0.026488205417990685, -0.015044438652694225, 0.03530142456293106, -0.03111918643116951, 0.013155517168343067, -0.029654841870069504, -0.052306514233350754, -0.03750847280025482, -0.002368900692090392, 0.06743161380290985, 0.050711922347545624, -0.0032076514326035976, -0.036782532930374146, -0.011134499683976173, -0.01765551045536995, 0.003958210814744234, -0.0003946186916437, 0.03452957794070244, -0.04350895807147026, -0.0047756824642419815, 0.007588200271129608, -0.021079031750559807, 0.027497708797454834, 0.026485426351428032, -0.012643483467400074, -0.0054880166426301, -0.013223701156675816, -0.0416887141764164, -0.02050415240228176, -0.01415284350514412, 0.007031145039945841, -0.01445127185434103, -0.034796494990587234, 0.06005342677235603, -0.012414825148880482, -0.06313606351613998, 0.03052867390215397, -0.041692692786455154, -0.04325106367468834, -0.03721451386809349, -0.006047112867236137, 0.06592085212469101, 0.01531317550688982, 0.036972999572753906, 0.03234903886914253, -0.023871727287769318, -0.019738977774977684, -0.06789711117744446, -0.07391288876533508, -0.001304479083046317, -0.03236989676952362, 0.01665976643562317, 0.01924988254904747, -0.019736403599381447, 0.07127226889133453, 0.045940741896629333, 0.006187153048813343, -0.027573086321353912, -0.02281644381582737, -0.03595744073390961, 0.01141608040779829, -0.0007817260921001434, -0.01607947237789631, 0.01751902513206005, 0.01175038330256939, -0.006675580516457558, 0.06145929917693138, 0.02291823737323284, 0.018094103783369064, -0.0245987381786108, 0.04808317497372627, -0.003956987056881189, -0.011652128770947456, 0.005763856228441, 0.0303029827773571, -0.01984509825706482, 0.022910844534635544, -0.014494522474706173, 0.04019275680184364, 0.012625758536159992, -0.03262278437614441, -0.00007569517038064077, 0.013552239164710045, 0.021295756101608276, -0.015763340517878532, 0.029642213135957718, -0.0018713157624006271, -0.0007175547070801258, -0.026555906981229782, 0.02834474667906761, 0.03934832662343979, -0.012168213725090027, -0.014129085466265678, 0.06843949854373932, 0.05105459317564964, -0.01287460420280695, -0.01676245778799057, -0.02973661944270134, 0.03001387231051922, 0.009410233236849308, 0.006606004200875759, -0.04123421385884285, 0.046311166137456894, 0.023734387010335922, -0.008131511509418488, -0.008448796346783638, -0.05466010794043541, -0.007802307140082121, -0.06414977461099625, -0.002132419729605317, 0.006925332825630903, 0.06587286293506622, 0.006090991199016571, 0.0359668955206871, 0.02657453715801239, 0.015162348747253418, -0.006845936644822359, 0.0005361483199521899, -0.07694020122289658, 0.023851068690419197, -0.027726149186491966, -0.03555184602737427, -0.025038104504346848, 0.00009135479922406375, 0.014705976471304893, -0.025503763929009438, -0.0012514408444985747, 0.0162640567868948, 0.026659084483981133, -0.028211507946252823, -0.011094078421592712, -0.005342079792171717, -0.026832034811377525, -0.051502592861652374, 0.006020785309374332, -0.009912216104567051, 0.002033479977399111, 0.05029446631669998, 0.009937957860529423, 0.0454610176384449, -0.004651322960853577, -0.0075350129045546055, 0.025865379720926285, 0.004263965412974358, 0.03626067936420441, 0.010652475990355015, 0.034853413701057434, -0.02459072321653366, 0.03961192071437836, 0.018749214708805084, 0.04984534531831741, -0.006339280866086483, -0.011198243126273155, -0.014081249944865704, -0.042161725461483, -0.030617745593190193, -0.011059179902076721, 0.009393807500600815, 0.0010708338813856244, 0.047700341790914536, 0.04690646752715111, 0.029239896684885025, -0.03249617666006088, 0.0040182918310165405, 0.04579952359199524, 0.010459455661475658, 0.024811040610074997, -0.013214987702667713, 0.0032894592732191086, -0.010004211217164993, 0.026939796283841133, 0.006374091375619173, 0.0071098641492426395, -0.005225840024650097, 0.009186001494526863, 0.047975897789001465, 0.015659721568226814, -0.022687068209052086, -0.034958213567733765, 0.019522396847605705, 0.03646634519100189, -0.02595413289964199, -0.04547210782766342, 0.046827532351017, -0.0021352011244744062, 0.0429861806333065, 0.05535252392292023, 0.015778129920363426, -0.10263937711715698, -0.007763353176414967, 0.05412527173757553, 0.005516673903912306, 0.0029533107299357653, -0.010359229519963264, -0.04775894060730934, -0.02498897723853588, 0.0398598313331604, -0.04226145148277283, -0.004828368779271841, -0.017515754327178, -0.000990461790934205, 0.0058119166642427444, -0.012934819795191288, -0.053665801882743835, 0.03796257823705673, -0.01178648415952921, 0.030512942001223564, -0.004704949911683798, -0.03272135183215141, -0.04594555124640465, 0.021724732592701912, 0.0056893969886004925, 0.08515726774930954, 0.007629232481122017, -0.01995030790567398, 0.016641687601804733, 0.05204988643527031, 0.021390728652477264, -0.05935883894562721, 0.017271365970373154, 0.008351498283445835, -0.003941268194466829, 0.03591205179691315, 0.00721903657540679, -0.016451461240649223, 0.02985304966568947, 0.015673475340008736, -0.006799065042287111, 0.025343619287014008, -0.018236927688121796, 0.0352424755692482, 0.010490699671208858, 0.01945335976779461, 0.05021819472312927, 0.03309866786003113, 0.027817780151963234, -0.0029756659641861916, -0.019315484911203384, 0.032081179320812225, -0.025724662467837334, -0.022704672068357468, -0.05299215391278267, -0.022329237312078476, -0.0355709083378315, 0.013045800849795341, 0.005302467383444309, 0.06641774624586105, -0.015100168064236641, -0.04735059663653374, 0.00020429430878721178, -0.0023773128632456064, 0.010580084286630154, 0.009732590988278389, 0.03833766654133797, 0.01540716364979744, -0.0021173744462430477, -0.003758033737540245, 0.048836641013622284, -0.011043811216950417, -0.014594638720154762, -0.010861353017389774, -0.04502179101109505, 0.021902410313487053, -0.031072992831468582, -0.030367933213710785, 0.008707421831786633, -0.00588254677131772, 0.02213664911687374, -0.007751642260700464, 0.0377722829580307, 0.012638899497687817, -0.03268918767571449, -0.0014923849375918508, 0.04136734828352928, 0.021379824727773666, 0.06455598771572113, -0.03997919708490372, 0.0204476285725832, -0.038378309458494186, -0.00416055042296648, -0.12716849148273468, -0.03564012050628662, 0.0021791274193674326, 0.024671947583556175, 0.009179425425827503, -0.05965634435415268, -0.013880101963877678, 0.006128801964223385, 0.0019671297632157803, -0.031393781304359436, 0.02505115605890751, 0.011610765010118484, -0.017730023711919785, -0.013949059881269932, 0.0032392963767051697, 0.08419295400381088, -0.039218414574861526, -0.022514628246426582, 0.01752840168774128, 0.004276413936167955, -0.02380266785621643, 0.01853271946310997, 0.05172395333647728, -0.03251795843243599, -0.010082152672111988, 0.010571187362074852, -0.005815589334815741, 0.03306759521365166, -0.033206529915332794, -0.0452449806034565, 0.012218514457345009, -0.003706749062985182, 0.009248942136764526, -0.011873770505189896, 0.008236597292125225, -0.01537291333079338, -0.035927727818489075, -0.06169340759515762, -0.01664428785443306, -0.03954106569290161, -0.025245893746614456, 0.020234018564224243, 0.01142354216426611, -0.023396436125040054, 0.008529854007065296, 0.0713038444519043, 0.008411337621510029, -0.012687182985246181, 0.01818517968058586, 0.015541929751634598, 0.03895052894949913, 0.0018099155277013779, -0.005772829987108707, 0.019801102578639984, 0.044858429580926895, -0.014225466176867485, 0.015369575470685959, -0.03374515473842621, -0.04473565146327019, 0.028585853055119514, 0.012815509922802448, 0.07674697041511536, 0.05773504078388214, 0.014491722919046879, 0.0035380602348595858, -0.0014195567928254604, -0.020812086760997772, -0.010582705959677696, -0.01380888745188713, 0.04503283649682999, -0.0419209860265255, 0.008364394307136536, 0.015721464529633522, 0.05095268413424492, 0.016874248161911964, 0.058647558093070984, -0.011842169798910618, 0.010507437400519848, 0.04162851348519325, 0.006437311414629221, -0.039842069149017334, 0.04249851778149605, -0.05146417021751404, 0.017037050798535347, -0.0037582218647003174, -0.041201796382665634, 0.01396386232227087, -0.0015239921631291509, -0.014002625830471516, -0.03644930198788643, 0.00028628529980778694, -0.021748093888163567, 0.02812100201845169, -0.01332829985767603, -0.02355828881263733, -0.0030763722024858, 0.002388786291703582, 0.031155051663517952, -0.009482677094638348, 0.0034953460562974215, -0.00542822340503335, -0.049482688307762146, -0.01551838219165802, -0.05683170258998871, -0.06742775440216064, -0.01409220416098833, 0.010693772695958614, -0.025374693796038628, 0.012014979496598244, -0.022358430549502373, -0.0018226642860099673, 0.009794139303267002, -0.02068239450454712, -0.007900736294686794, 0.06744557619094849, 0.01482454314827919, 0.034412454813718796, -0.0014358526095747948, -0.009139941073954105, 0.1103513240814209, 0.050800297409296036, 0.0170548465102911, -0.042903389781713486, -0.023463863879442215, -0.0023377437610179186, 0.0009078234434127808, -0.04309404268860817, -0.0009365373989567161, 0.019281169399619102, 0.0180889293551445, 0.06745175272226334, 0.04417823255062103, 0.0266722459346056, -0.0024224284570664167, 0.04616915062069893, -0.01911807991564274, -0.022989675402641296, 0.02036384865641594, 0.022778524085879326, 0.016406841576099396, -0.03591355308890343, -0.06445545703172684, 0.052181925624608994, 0.01824101433157921, -0.00817693118005991, -0.04657282307744026, -0.04123659431934357, 0.014476717449724674, 0.009819173254072666, -0.038986437022686005, -0.0001775991840986535, -0.008244710974395275, -0.010783451609313488, -0.017456041648983955, -0.05318412557244301, 0.0028246843721717596, -0.03931208699941635, 0.0007018386386334896, 0.03432006388902664, 0.009917243383824825, -0.009176192805171013, -0.012974660843610764, 0.009663058444857597, -0.03562835603952408, -0.01853524148464203, -0.035368986427783966, 0.03392745181918144, -0.025650687515735626, -0.005542989354580641, 0.0016025936929509044, 0.03809800371527672, 0.0016167607391253114, -0.05313817039132118, -0.03665672987699509, -0.00996366236358881, 0.020304806530475616, -0.042271483689546585, -0.027578013017773628, -0.00019182063988409936, 0.017494333907961845, 0.016065819188952446, -0.005008920561522245, 0.009073804132640362, -0.03014996461570263, -0.035547517240047455, 0.011611918918788433, 0.07673541456460953, -0.0064732083119452, -0.008010218851268291, 0.011855819262564182, -0.01590149849653244, -0.013603536412119865, 0.04412278160452843, 0.0015846125315874815, -0.031392902135849, 0.0013620334211736917, 0.011286607012152672, -0.00271290959790349, -0.0037903410848230124, -0.03491472825407982, 0.02978753112256527, -0.03182065114378929, 0.016788141801953316, -0.025223752483725548, -0.022335154935717583, 0.0183202363550663, 0.0237597543746233, 0.007511619944125414, -0.003940442577004433, -0.0006910983938723803, 0.06492306292057037, 0.013700355775654316, -0.014600281603634357, -0.008414823561906815, -0.0038875043392181396, -0.039052482694387436, 0.011958252638578415, -0.0020743904169648886, 0.04892376810312271, -0.003803190542384982, 0.0003189199196640402, 0.0015952122630551457, 0.027783222496509552, -0.030492151156067848, 0.027155745774507523, -0.00915835052728653, -0.066190704703331, -0.04427122324705124, 0.016955025494098663, -0.04172881320118904, -0.01739390753209591, -0.024582283571362495, -0.022356679663062096, -0.005842622835189104, 0.001545192557387054, 0.031782492995262146, 0.006574959494173527, -0.012307475320994854, 0.0051970272324979305, -0.006676780059933662, -0.001780383987352252, 0.00048275914741680026, -0.034903883934020996, -0.011775420047342777, -0.03178325295448303, 0.010522688739001751, 0.004737997427582741, -0.012905293144285679, -0.0062425993382930756, 0.013986793346703053, 0.029036138206720352, 0.005992151331156492, 0.016005337238311768, 0.01759483851492405, 0.04894864559173584, 0.027413278818130493, 0.0632864385843277, -0.02761227823793888, 0.0014685672940686345, 0.057527169585227966, -0.027978405356407166, -0.06814373284578323, 0.02349623665213585, 0.007295082323253155, 0.03229038044810295, -0.03701828792691231, -0.014508630149066448, -0.024902507662773132, 0.050062816590070724, 0.0016621019458398223, -0.020064527168869972, -0.039727114140987396, 0.027299899607896805, -0.0009080463205464184, 0.009326837956905365, 0.007797307334840298, -0.00306835793890059, -0.028139958158135414, 0.01481456309556961, 0.03468644991517067, -0.004799923859536648, 0.00029075340717099607, 0.01655595377087593, -0.043691541999578476, -0.01730826310813427, 0.0003584331425372511, -0.028044717386364937, 0.050848767161369324, 0.05329801142215729, -0.054565899074077606, -0.0034492057748138905, -0.023900339379906654, 0.026540623977780342, -0.04028576239943504, -0.031316399574279785, 0.01680036261677742, 0.005161472130566835, 0.006557410582900047, -0.06413956731557846, -0.04596541449427605, 0.004824625328183174, -0.011368382722139359, 0.033824317157268524, -0.012260941788554192, 0.014108936302363873, -0.030379589647054672, 0.00672189611941576, -0.02479899674654007, 0.03465956449508667, 0.01274457573890686, 0.03479171171784401, 0.023248711600899696, 0.046159885823726654, -0.015984361991286278, -0.03476634621620178, -0.0060289641842246056, 0.0027579120360314846, 0.021057935431599617, -0.027818258851766586, 0.013482978567481041, -0.01501237228512764, -0.004283560439944267, 0.01750539056956768, -0.0566999688744545, -0.02114277333021164, 0.03961043804883957, 0.012521208263933659, -0.004973575472831726, 0.05287480354309082, 0.029036246240139008, -0.0018724757246673107, -0.00048293074360117316, 0.012116796337068081, 0.022395465523004532, 0.007314119953662157, -0.03433484956622124, 0.017734363675117493, 0.05677442625164986, -0.032082997262477875, -0.01642853580415249, 0.0437336191534996, -0.009278801269829273, -0.03707841783761978, 0.005076129455119371, 0.01389285922050476, 0.04074709489941597, -0.04160056635737419, 0.046929508447647095, -0.045175399631261826, -0.008483740501105785, 0.007253668736666441, 0.011151802726089954, -0.045593082904815674, 0.011838646605610847, -0.01792816072702408, -0.049264952540397644, 0.002454747213050723, 0.01575750857591629, -0.014694896526634693, -0.049295660108327866, -0.029086830094456673, -0.05849156901240349, 0.004817996174097061, 0.005295692943036556, -0.032046008855104446, -0.02091650478541851, 0.006494530942291021, -0.009726149961352348, -0.03164925053715706, 0.035285308957099915, 0.008181524462997913, -0.0027816949877887964, -0.07651130110025406, 0.04643811658024788, 0.006903864908963442, 0.011278627440333366, -0.026905948296189308, -0.0046968585811555386, -0.04696813225746155, 0.045764196664094925, 0.03905187547206879, 0.031039880588650703, 0.006126223132014275, 0.02750498428940773, -0.003861777251586318, 0.02703203447163105, -0.04063652083277702, 0.024754852056503296, -0.023556064814329147, -0.09305036067962646, 0.010494901798665524, -0.008326089940965176, -0.00869861152023077, 0.0068594622425735, -0.0028090053237974644, 0.004639443941414356, -0.038462892174720764, -0.0021576397120952606, -0.014364589937031269, 0.0545274019241333, 0.013384716585278511, -0.035161491483449936, 0.0410054586827755, -0.021265804767608643, 0.01198461465537548, 0.0025293780490756035, -0.0025506585370749235, -0.04820169508457184, 0.024244103580713272, -0.03696998581290245, -0.03048606775701046, 0.006044060457497835, 0.031835559755563736, 0.021158311516046524, -0.04363865777850151, -0.013967516832053661, -0.011403162032365799, -0.04977572336792946, 0.00589925330132246, -0.003063865937292576, 0.0003848085179924965, 0.059902310371398926, -0.02004975453019142, -0.005944067146629095, 0.012739226222038269, 0.007499531377106905, -0.0011331670684739947, 0.051531657576560974, 0.01664048060774803, -0.01670152135193348, 0.019884739071130753, -0.014562915079295635, -0.021484047174453735, 0.055111244320869446, -0.0042962124571204185, 0.010722015053033829, 0.003880213713273406, 0.01369419228285551, 0.03925962373614311, -0.0053044999949634075, 0.006848902907222509, 0.004465621430426836, -0.016786010935902596, 0.0373348630964756, -0.012580259703099728, -0.002049746923148632, -0.05891245976090431, -0.041313767433166504, 0.0012364527210593224, -0.008354059420526028, -0.0027386448346078396, 0.04586624726653099, 0.002380287740379572, -0.00025524961529299617, 0.02081880159676075, -0.006084667053073645, 0.03148148953914642, -0.037555843591690063, 0.04323627054691315, -0.040187377482652664, 0.019543243572115898, -0.022156329825520515, -0.01055389828979969, -0.029917096719145775, -0.012904282659292221, 0.016555799171328545, 0.043408967554569244, 0.0673707127571106, -0.002368738641962409, -0.0233767107129097, 0.007655010093003511, 0.036707039922475815, -0.04336987063288689, -0.051364704966545105, -0.03793341666460037, 0.020124321803450584, -0.01199450995773077, -0.02953748032450676 ]
<p>Here's <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/125/what-is-the-best-introductory-bayesian-statistics-textbook">a link</a> to a good question regarding Textbooks on Bayesian statistics from some time ago.</p> <p>People suggested John Kruschke's "Doing Bayesian Data Analysis: A Tutorial Introduction with R and BUGS" as one of the best options to get an introduction to Bayesian statistics. Meanwhile, a potentially interesting book called "Bayesian and Frequentist Regression Methods" by Jon Wakefield was released, which also provides code for R and BUGS. Thus, they esentially both seem to cover the same topics.</p> <p>Question 1: If you have read the book, would you recommend it to a frequentist economics masters graduate as both an introduction to Bayesian statstics and reference book for both frequentist and bayesian approaches?</p> <p>Question 2: If you have read both Wakefield's and Kruschke's book, which one would you recommend better?</p>
36,463
[ -0.0483575314283371, 0.008080949075520039, 0.014054921455681324, -0.011685313656926155, 0.026927214115858078, 0.02369457297027111, 0.033683281391859055, -0.013308890163898468, 0.03148749843239784, -0.028283368796110153, 0.02663397416472435, 0.06070290133357048, 0.05782962590456009, 0.015273363329470158, 0.02675863914191723, -0.010185040533542633, -0.01934145949780941, -0.009301966056227684, -0.06666809320449829, 0.00011090713815065101, 0.011476149782538414, 0.006760763470083475, 0.02441629022359848, 0.0008459123782813549, -0.03537072241306305, 0.027315810322761536, 0.01905701495707035, -0.010596135631203651, -0.019945768639445305, 0.05277247354388237, -0.05425509437918663, 0.013914327137172222, 0.013516728766262531, 0.02325085736811161, 0.014035625383257866, 0.006067762617021799, -0.012203842401504517, -0.01621558517217636, -0.024879174306988716, 0.04360879957675934, -0.03721034899353981, -0.020786695182323456, 0.0006859467248432338, 0.006810061167925596, -0.025492586195468903, 0.0016496250173076987, 0.005059515591710806, -0.02327132411301136, 0.00044284717296250165, -0.019122807309031487, 0.040002960711717606, -0.0067299408838152885, 0.0003223489038646221, 0.04082304239273071, 0.03474736958742142, -0.023875122889876366, 0.049580805003643036, 0.08239845931529999, -0.027681080624461174, -0.07257630676031113, 0.0003273186448495835, -0.020512664690613747, -0.014005716890096664, -0.03908246383070946, -0.06395351141691208, 0.0449787974357605, 0.005586676299571991, -0.02419259399175644, 0.05130533501505852, -0.0014820630894973874, 0.021026968955993652, 0.005551840644329786, 0.036248695105314255, -0.020102377980947495, 0.023871252313256264, -0.034462496638298035, -0.023486949503421783, 0.0339508019387722, -0.008478594943881035, 0.06775341182947159, -0.01985139399766922, 0.0050290594808757305, 0.06581169366836548, 0.045652151107788086, 0.01568824239075184, -0.04006427153944969, 0.0748148187994957, -0.015552078373730183, -0.04239251837134361, 0.014694640412926674, -0.027296125888824463, 0.0028115613386034966, 0.007773632183670998, -0.03433828800916672, -0.03363194689154625, 0.06041107699275017, -0.02260832116007805, 0.04625636339187622, -0.006976123433560133, -0.007335144095122814, 0.011983474716544151, -0.030753953382372856, 0.0013842753833159804, 0.054333172738552094, -0.02353561297059059, -0.06975102424621582, -0.016026800498366356, 0.02792566455900669, -0.06671009212732315, -0.047150686383247375, -0.03357633575797081, 0.035407841205596924, -0.03175080195069313, 0.0073063974268734455, 0.004691821523010731, -0.006738685537129641, 0.06561308354139328, -0.009498399682343006, 0.09348161518573761, 0.05025019869208336, 0.06256178766489029, -0.02915901131927967, 0.007086584810167551, -0.037259675562381744, -0.06608248502016068, -0.006845592521131039, 0.010764787904918194, -0.05233223736286163, -0.013248471543192863, 0.04279068112373352, -0.02480599842965603, 0.01467688474804163, 0.047512710094451904, 0.05841151624917984, 0.005909728351980448, 0.020255286246538162, -0.07610151916742325, -0.053625646978616714, 0.07746127992868423, -0.01714208349585533, -0.02874738536775112, -0.055637259036302567, 0.02797890640795231, 0.016912447288632393, 0.03123391978442669, 0.010915528982877731, 0.024456650018692017, -0.00881995726376772, 0.04351053759455681, -0.029481135308742523, -0.024953234940767288, -0.03822943568229675, 0.005775831174105406, -0.008432012982666492, -0.004358804319053888, -0.08564858883619308, 0.001372096361592412, 0.030160780996084213, 0.005517421290278435, -0.011673522181808949, 0.04054555669426918, 0.022764509543776512, -0.006345192436128855, -0.0004709805070888251, 0.008292712271213531, 0.002974444068968296, 0.06826938688755035, 0.015611100941896439, 0.03661876171827316, 0.0058389329351484776, -0.0311777051538229, 0.005608654581010342, -0.0035527239087969065, 0.010314319282770157, 0.04394165053963661, -0.03678746521472931, -0.007284906692802906, -0.021143076941370964, 0.01988566666841507, -0.03362085297703743, -0.007664056029170752, 0.00888369046151638, -0.010413951240479946, -0.032245270907878876, -0.009267840534448624, 0.025123151019215584, 0.041822295635938644, -0.009973347187042236, 0.022976865991950035, -0.03695869445800781, -0.044966887682676315, -0.07694574445486069, -0.026250967755913734, -0.028199119493365288, -0.021996911615133286, 0.06483299285173416, 0.0036341361701488495, -0.016788506880402565, -0.023172279819846153, -0.00127225904725492, -0.02195100113749504, -0.01776588149368763, 0.020202351734042168, -0.027247129008173943, -0.008919861167669296, 0.061625704169273376, 0.057630505412817, -0.05891941115260124, 0.015190213918685913, -0.06438878923654556, -0.052769165486097336, 0.00285247596912086, -0.014173101633787155, 0.03731071949005127, -0.001361340400762856, 0.002575605409219861, 0.030055539682507515, 0.031018665060400963, -0.05445672944188118, 0.002479465678334236, -0.0781426951289177, 0.04138787463307381, 0.041613612323999405, 0.031717587262392044, -0.003951675724238157, 0.040035445243120193, -0.0007998336805030704, 0.03316827118396759, 0.004040684551000595, 0.028597716242074966, -0.05764598026871681, 0.034335844218730927, 0.04110874980688095, 0.019874220713973045, -0.01727054826915264, 0.030369874089956284, 0.036092810332775116, 0.0236820075660944, 0.001241635880433023, 0.02479836344718933, -0.030141683295369148, -0.07431409507989883, 0.0023794500157237053, -0.003216590965166688, -0.020115308463573456, 0.034468840807676315, 0.042043156921863556, 0.015910988673567772, 0.04832202568650246, 0.027855079621076584, 0.001272340421564877, 0.00987385306507349, -0.00848394725471735, -0.019063329324126244, -0.008239280432462692, -0.015346157364547253, 0.04232005774974823, -0.03748665377497673, -0.018337881192564964, 0.01133863627910614, 0.003968011122196913, 0.009251279756426811, 0.01565982960164547, -0.011212407611310482, -0.00009600299381418154, 0.03281708061695099, -0.039640624076128006, 0.020247841253876686, 0.028824683278799057, -0.07067424058914185, 0.014351683668792248, -0.0147156473249197, -0.03911984711885452, -0.04828488454222679, 0.010335532948374748, -0.0030989244114607573, -0.005443069152534008, 0.015412859618663788, -0.022457769140601158, -0.029259460046887398, 0.020306289196014404, -0.007493188139051199, 0.007904406636953354, -0.015132922679185867, -0.04921118542551994, 0.005507708992809057, -0.022331571206450462, -0.013999151065945625, 0.024584531784057617, -0.010671350173652172, -0.015008624643087387, 0.010732720606029034, 0.018491456285119057, -0.043786726891994476, -0.024546124041080475, -0.017760876566171646, 0.008162225596606731, -0.024384845048189163, -0.030787674710154533, 0.034640535712242126, 0.012774989940226078, -0.0014784885570406914, 0.005194711033254862, -0.049102652817964554, -0.044242069125175476, -0.028425196185708046, -0.0028759457636624575, -0.003399939276278019, 0.026501402258872986, -0.011541698127985, 0.02811080776154995, -0.04384145140647888, 0.004288366995751858, -0.07047474384307861, -0.06391634047031403, -0.003400177229195833, -0.02146105095744133, 0.004961937200278044, 0.011120228096842766, 0.005991613958030939, 0.04561735317111015, 0.03300681337714195, -0.004544889088720083, -0.0281792264431715, -0.00831542070955038, -0.02902291901409626, -0.009127344004809856, -0.004089991562068462, 0.03427226096391678, -0.007463893853127956, -0.008497621864080429, -0.030651969835162163, 0.03225470706820488, 0.03750567138195038, 0.03352641314268112, 0.04109254106879234, 0.013811958953738213, 0.0019444898935034871, -0.005737477447837591, 0.0130571024492383, 0.0033767137210816145, -0.027547378093004227, -0.01968449540436268, -0.03426246717572212, 0.034905288368463516, 0.034952495247125626, -0.028900276869535446, 0.016873683780431747, 0.013963468372821808, -0.016845202073454857, -0.07835572212934494, 0.023162130266427994, 0.00792696699500084, -0.03314322978258133, 0.014727665111422539, -0.01503835991024971, 0.0023553064092993736, -0.005310878623276949, 0.021224692463874817, 0.039483290165662766, 0.0518566258251667, -0.02054261416196823, -0.017438355833292007, 0.013279585167765617, 0.0027338475920259953, 0.022800222039222717, -0.006586783565580845, -0.006009597331285477, 0.048309504985809326, 0.019439231604337692, 0.02332759089767933, -0.017080241814255714, -0.059541814029216766, -0.005632368382066488, -0.08012907952070236, -0.012501975521445274, -0.04173140600323677, 0.03946557641029358, -0.006716037634760141, 0.023982852697372437, -0.006007846910506487, -0.006468279752880335, -0.005204302724450827, -0.0013507193652912974, -0.08312279731035233, 0.0017653029644861817, -0.034198496490716934, -0.047206129878759384, 0.0049574850127100945, 0.010012803599238396, 0.03756038099527359, -0.012874755077064037, 0.004177072085440159, -0.03451140597462654, -0.013129966333508492, -0.06321010738611221, 0.029180755838751793, -0.03993499279022217, -0.04489630460739136, 0.013945444487035275, 0.0032976206857711077, 0.02432766556739807, -0.024707617238163948, 0.02190817892551422, 0.011643359437584877, -0.03486856073141098, 0.011540310457348824, 0.009442090056836605, 0.038254767656326294, 0.01491407211869955, 0.0010752849048003554, 0.0038240118883550167, 0.03952784463763237, -0.010036645457148552, 0.04215463995933533, 0.02942955680191517, 0.024930007755756378, 0.02874130755662918, -0.055666789412498474, -0.027562502771615982, -0.023008745163679123, -0.017474841326475143, -0.02425098791718483, 0.018358884379267693, -0.0092983553186059, 0.022028299048542976, 0.0676313266158104, 0.024422762915492058, -0.03564686328172684, 0.044330570846796036, 0.009301167912781239, -0.029789041727781296, 0.0015656647738069296, -0.006743664853274822, -0.006885929498821497, -0.011632906273007393, 0.013751213438808918, 0.018202928826212883, 0.011373532935976982, -0.045686107128858566, 0.02795051783323288, 0.024381905794143677, 0.0007708595367148519, -0.01637115143239498, -0.013215003535151482, 0.02852535992860794, 0.02965351566672325, 0.010429718531668186, -0.06297069787979126, 0.004416728392243385, 0.02398558147251606, 0.05408761277794838, 0.027573231607675552, -0.015814511105418205, -0.06350758671760559, -0.016386374831199646, 0.053980499505996704, 0.03186124563217163, -0.046100515872240067, 0.02637983113527298, -0.04889804124832153, -0.014503630809485912, 0.05343211442232132, -0.03178361430764198, 0.033080924302339554, -0.027790071442723274, 0.0068791587837040424, -0.02764282003045082, -0.024006810039281845, -0.07220050692558289, -0.03032308630645275, -0.004974417854100466, 0.03189345449209213, -0.0002357493358431384, -0.01772189326584339, -0.055458154529333115, -0.007018118631094694, 0.024315208196640015, 0.07218118011951447, -0.023559151217341423, -0.013750331476330757, -0.0046504708006978035, -0.031755488365888596, -0.016319530084729195, -0.060397032648324966, -0.010939905419945717, -0.01685364544391632, -0.026273958384990692, 0.028197359293699265, -0.01615026220679283, -0.03764525055885315, 0.05059139430522919, -0.03276761993765831, -0.05318280681967735, -0.004739032126963139, -0.02921643666923046, 0.030482124537229538, 0.0465049110352993, -0.002944069681689143, 0.060046594589948654, -0.00308443745598197, 0.002413321752101183, 0.05385983735322952, -0.0392250120639801, 0.02800721861422062, -0.05529828742146492, -0.02192409336566925, -0.052718181163072586, -0.017619546502828598, -0.02967912331223488, 0.03971702232956886, 0.009291203692555428, 0.014418496750295162, -0.0447617769241333, -0.057122476398944855, 0.01564733125269413, 0.03896505758166313, -0.0159144289791584, 0.01172186341136694, 0.004856674000620842, 0.0004717805713880807, 0.006238068453967571, 0.001623012707568705, 0.05003124848008156, -0.01850161887705326, 0.020857591181993484, 0.013446886092424393, -0.01085135992616415, 0.04873581975698471, -0.02234063483774662, -0.029652483761310577, 0.022279592230916023, -0.02145935222506523, 0.054232507944107056, 0.025196999311447144, 0.060462065041065216, 0.01065397821366787, -0.016348352655768394, -0.05297945812344551, -0.01162762101739645, 0.02171577513217926, 0.021396446973085403, -0.02968636155128479, 0.030082376673817635, -0.011771335266530514, -0.017875192686915398, -0.06083888188004494, -0.020133860409259796, 0.019024863839149475, -0.005371564533561468, -0.054311446845531464, -0.005266884341835976, 0.062184397131204605, -0.014261954464018345, -0.01381466444581747, -0.04219026863574982, 0.046514756977558136, -0.030781392008066177, 0.001062221359461546, 0.010397450067102909, -0.00011980174167547375, 0.07586736232042313, 0.044659875333309174, -0.012628424912691116, 0.0068099284544587135, 0.007254528813064098, -0.0025171060115098953, 0.014893265441060066, 0.03780248388648033, 0.0002383729733992368, -0.018040936440229416, -0.007505327928811312, 0.0397910512983799, 0.03629503399133682, -0.012859459966421127, 0.0016909351106733084, 0.05899791046977043, 0.029177024960517883, -0.008097711950540543, -0.047104887664318085, -0.009035404771566391, 0.008057867176830769, 0.019965870305895805, -0.055599719285964966, -0.017261270433664322, 0.03111158311367035, -0.02320290543138981, 0.009651079773902893, 0.012322530150413513, -0.02208893559873104, 0.016960248351097107, 0.05775689706206322, -0.027953211218118668, 0.023146871477365494, 0.020771831274032593, -0.0072554717771708965, 0.02951834909617901, -0.015916908159852028, 0.011554279364645481, 0.0037333520594984293, -0.010231612250208855, -0.014669445343315601, -0.04990750178694725, -0.07095729559659958, 0.002816232619807124, 0.08085444569587708, 0.013704268261790276, 0.029825398698449135, 0.0480356365442276, -0.00015409487241413444, -0.002276896731927991, -0.05205067992210388, -0.01308447401970625, -0.024051688611507416, 0.038028303533792496, 0.025557002052664757, -0.036447200924158096, -0.010746559128165245, 0.051718927919864655, -0.014705408364534378, 0.0028434190899133682, 0.026282915845513344, 0.0059692454524338245, 0.04077332094311714, 0.04525380581617355, -0.006324038375169039, -0.05091254413127899, 0.0326639786362648, -0.05932930111885071, 0.031818024814128876, -0.04743846505880356, -0.06684627383947372, 0.033341675996780396, 0.02451680228114128, -0.01729877106845379, -0.0365615077316761, -0.02911841869354248, -0.033307384699583054, 0.01996966078877449, -0.011658933945000172, 0.022187260910868645, 0.03652374446392059, -0.012909461744129658, 0.036596838384866714, -0.01950130984187126, 0.010193117894232273, -0.013171682134270668, -0.05692092701792717, -0.026512613520026207, 0.02242409624159336, -0.026566678658127785, 0.01972919888794422, 0.010670796036720276, -0.04167250916361809, 0.012936838902533054, -0.07288523018360138, 0.01824791170656681, -0.0005108619807288051, 0.03242620453238487, 0.010177327319979668, 0.06232177093625069, -0.06558563560247421, -0.0030312545131891966, -0.021128153428435326, -0.024060606956481934, 0.13255245983600616, 0.05361304059624672, 0.04654720053076744, -0.07558052241802216, 0.034142158925533295, 0.0199047289788723, 0.03195128217339516, -0.023459967225790024, 0.003084978787228465, 0.03283128887414932, -0.023566486313939095, 0.05418461933732033, 0.05576332286000252, 0.03234744444489479, -0.02775133028626442, 0.017579320818185806, -0.019974160939455032, -0.004402991384267807, 0.005320877768099308, 0.002341893734410405, 0.015450332313776016, 0.012556714005768299, -0.033658333122730255, -0.014703254215419292, -0.001795597723685205, -0.032616470009088516, -0.030693475157022476, -0.018289919942617416, -0.031740911304950714, 0.011891215108335018, 0.00578700564801693, -0.04093482345342636, 0.026498621329665184, -0.050272293388843536, -0.00172339694108814, -0.02611449733376503, 0.007001119665801525, -0.036448828876018524, 0.04490898177027702, 0.020254891365766525, -0.0028098423499614, 0.0011522781569510698, 0.012104043737053871, 0.017925215885043144, -0.056101638823747635, 0.023396002128720284, -0.011299005709588528, 0.012668445706367493, -0.03434348106384277, 0.01395316794514656, -0.02817934937775135, 0.007315620314329863, 0.04471130296587944, -0.01782866194844246, 0.0005381024093367159, 0.014045662246644497, 0.03910957649350166, -0.04641149938106537, -0.033585887402296066, -0.0028018606826663017, 0.0350484773516655, -0.014836789108812809, 0.041755352169275284, 0.038280386477708817, -0.050406329333782196, -0.05132080987095833, -0.016491593793034554, 0.03772496432065964, -0.01649627834558487, 0.0007452464778907597, -0.002828227123245597, 0.026280947029590607, -0.054778292775154114, -0.017066920176148415, -0.00613196287304163, 0.01584290713071823, -0.007427906151860952, -0.024187395349144936, 0.0015165364602580667, 0.01035764068365097, -0.040784578770399094, 0.008343427442014217, -0.009209206327795982, 0.028456872329115868, -0.02046140842139721, 0.006445703562349081, 0.024911655113101006, 0.014953062869608402, 0.026968011632561684, 0.005413955543190241, -0.006346581503748894, 0.04003366827964783, 0.0054162852466106415, -0.04471564292907715, 0.003255317220464349, -0.024356823414564133, -0.036314707249403, -0.0002876393555197865, -0.014615429565310478, 0.025093961507081985, 0.015716753900051117, 0.029688673093914986, 0.0035808386746793985, 0.0017029339214786887, 0.01019209623336792, 0.012395324185490608, -0.005229047033935785, -0.03961038589477539, -0.0008896593935787678, 0.0799609124660492, 0.009494156576693058, -0.010498415678739548, -0.02363160252571106, 0.009428691118955612, 0.023156560957431793, 0.02335198037326336, -0.01655760407447815, -0.06014283746480942, 0.055090006440877914, 0.01405204925686121, 0.000945292878895998, -0.025366980582475662, 0.024414796382188797, -0.01670786365866661, -0.004656716715544462, -0.023577988147735596, 0.027772706001996994, 0.018959179520606995, 0.050008442252874374, -0.0006980581092648208, 0.007179222535341978, 0.03342684358358383, 0.0001698390842648223, 0.016247322782874107, -0.011443722993135452, 0.03283676132559776, -0.03194045275449753, 0.03744557499885559, 0.024824151769280434, 0.00158878683578223, 0.05105746537446976, -0.02049870416522026, -0.058576833456754684, 0.012137243524193764, 0.005942264571785927, 0.0067812977358698845, -0.018005073070526123, -0.0007434989092871547, -0.026230206713080406, 0.05351701378822327, -0.01564316637814045, -0.027591457590460777, -0.004563665483146906, 0.011408135294914246, -0.003383008996024728, -0.013294328935444355, 0.018965793773531914, 0.028185119852423668, 0.008647355251014233, 0.017328234389424324, 0.043097808957099915, 0.02343321405351162, 0.00515088252723217, 0.0226011760532856, -0.034353967756032944, -0.008832154795527458, -0.022570129483938217, -0.030113622546195984, 0.04721938446164131, 0.03627549856901169, -0.012645112350583076, 0.06188088282942772, -0.02269994653761387, -0.010950866155326366, -0.09710560739040375, -0.026265479624271393, 0.039307851344347, 0.04043818637728691, 0.005039978306740522, -0.02707926742732525, 0.008205894380807877, 0.028247391805052757, -0.027790751308202744, 0.03178282454609871, 0.017663199454545975, 0.00008130107744364068, -0.021699007600545883, 0.016180524602532387, 0.00143973168451339, 0.02053718827664852, -0.004406380001455545, 0.01870378665626049, 0.03533662483096123, 0.03721027448773384, 0.023357432335615158, -0.015322670340538025, -0.028138617053627968, 0.05170470103621483, -0.005608586594462395, -0.017971215769648552, 0.055508628487586975, -0.011214181780815125, -0.030556080862879753, 0.04139445722103119, 0.04783754423260689, 0.04289714992046356, -0.00324842007830739, 0.010491046123206615, 0.03147948905825615, 0.027988426387310028, 0.06403745710849762, -0.004186092875897884, -0.015545137226581573, -0.0075868661515414715, 0.0027498335111886263, 0.03533610329031944, 0.003074849722906947, -0.001922518014907837, -0.0014383252710103989, 0.005194373894482851, -0.0072009870782494545, 0.0024150500539690256, 0.02085978351533413, -0.015031196177005768, 0.040218714624643326, 0.03543486073613167, 0.009117165580391884, 0.015514303930103779, 0.008187102153897285, -0.07296790182590485, 0.012170502915978432, 0.05345173552632332, -0.01702231727540493, 0.0018642677459865808, 0.014741980470716953, -0.03757268190383911, -0.03398994728922844, 0.026844220235943794, -0.020769232884049416, 0.014872689731419086, -0.02377605065703392, -0.019015280529856682, 0.022489912807941437, 0.018504001200199127, -0.018715880811214447, -0.023882687091827393, -0.0378999188542366, -0.005050663370639086, -0.0455925427377224, -0.001262233592569828, -0.004703307058662176, 0.020861564204096794, 0.010568199679255486, -0.04423655569553375, 0.07582969963550568, 0.017061825841665268, -0.003098608460277319, -0.027935955673456192, -0.014113618060946465, 0.0023820046335458755, 0.007394848857074976, 0.03526987507939339, 0.007881252095103264, 0.0035990651231259108, -0.011263050138950348, 0.003463281085714698, 0.026973649859428406, -0.0467611663043499, 0.042544178664684296, -0.004044011700898409, -0.005640396382659674, -0.013207814656198025, -0.0014543593861162663, -0.0029609089251607656, 0.019057732075452805, 0.017473571002483368, 0.0032142207492142916, -0.008577268570661545, -0.0007404782227240503, -0.0012427577748894691, 0.039929646998643875, 0.04615647345781326, 0.027332263067364693, 0.02389957197010517, -0.016889743506908417, 0.031702473759651184, 0.03880664333701134, -0.02175305224955082, -0.026593763381242752, 0.015150484628975391, -0.021168112754821777, -0.04740976542234421, 0.024420754984021187, -0.0006922018365003169, -0.028675232082605362, -0.06767995655536652, 0.0214760210365057, 0.02622300572693348, -0.024966398254036903, 0.04407916218042374, 0.022721264511346817, 0.010162917897105217, 0.05985456332564354, 0.003942425828427076, -0.00427846098318696, 0.037422433495521545, -0.03680871054530144, -0.031227989122271538, 0.005300010554492474, 0.048152100294828415, 0.034540314227342606, 0.037676576524972916, 0.0311192087829113, 0.0066989935003221035, -0.010970896109938622, -0.047570280730724335, 0.015263737179338932, -0.039027437567710876, -0.008990932255983353, -0.0012625094968825579, 0.01181688904762268, -0.02867208607494831, 0.003555872244760394, 0.008737181313335896, 0.06197882443666458, -0.020449919626116753, 0.015246297232806683, 0.022913452237844467, -0.007135002873837948, -0.03477879986166954, -0.025804925709962845, -0.035828493535518646, 0.026492668315768242, 0.028169188648462296, 0.023058336228132248, 0.0025335149839520454, -0.008966279216110706, 0.02970222197473049, -0.007246063090860844, 0.006636001169681549, 0.005082317627966404, 0.0032732931431382895, -0.013928313739597797, 0.005837193690240383, -0.026325903832912445, -0.027107831090688705, 0.023294176906347275, 0.02624647505581379, 0.004600428510457277, -0.023787816986441612, -0.022545941174030304, -0.013596552424132824, 0.02774842083454132, -0.04248753562569618, 0.013479968532919884, -0.05655790865421295, 0.02483489364385605, -0.00890984944999218, -0.01192325260490179 ]
<p>I am looking for a (commonly used) probability density function, which would look like a normal distribution flipped upside down. It would look like a uniform distribution with a dent in the middle.</p> <p>Just to be clear, I am dealing with a continuous random variable within some range, say <code>[-1,1]</code>.</p> <p>Sometimes I have data which is concentrated around zero, but other times I have data which is concentrated toward 1 and -1, while the region around zero is relatively underpopulated. Is there a kind of pdf which (depending on some parameter) can represent these two cases?</p>
1,028
[ -0.032339226454496384, -0.0037400044966489077, 0.005798263009637594, -0.002180590061470866, 0.024277526885271072, 0.01831880211830139, 0.023442454636096954, 0.004213670734316111, -0.00026604998856782913, -0.05010601133108139, 0.03623703867197037, 0.05119406431913376, 0.05574388802051544, 0.0031715191435068846, 0.0450177937746048, 0.009549479000270367, -0.03435009345412254, -0.0036477961111813784, -0.05010448768734932, -0.03337041661143303, 0.0281855296343565, -0.01592741347849369, 0.04013493284583092, 0.00480905594304204, -0.030102582648396492, 0.034774716943502426, 0.02576316148042679, -0.01682691089808941, 0.021446915343403816, 0.07191650569438934, -0.03807404637336731, -0.04121885821223259, 0.0035162915010005236, 0.05180130898952484, 0.018760496750473976, -0.004935430828481913, -0.019544001668691635, -0.03015776164829731, -0.034092310816049576, 0.01900387741625309, -0.03506535664200783, -0.017570720985531807, 0.003030886873602867, 0.04187682643532753, 0.007312684785574675, 0.03337966278195381, 0.0011102308053523302, -0.02464907430112362, 0.05003293231129646, -0.07418999820947647, 0.08781297504901886, -0.01509222760796547, 0.046989794820547104, 0.030162015929818153, 0.026930851861834526, -0.027681104838848114, 0.06288950145244598, 0.09653116762638092, 0.005901638884097338, -0.09511104226112366, -0.018320880830287933, -0.04401498660445213, -0.04865993186831474, -0.020570924505591393, -0.0016215519281104207, 0.018503619357943535, -0.03630441799759865, -0.046087924391031265, 0.005576652474701405, -0.005871590692549944, -0.0038309760857373476, 0.03440998122096062, 0.01044746395200491, -0.03228093311190605, -0.004756579641252756, -0.03444986045360565, 0.028470275923609734, -0.020465239882469177, 0.028222430497407913, 0.030151011422276497, 0.011770354583859444, -0.011759849265217781, 0.021769162267446518, 0.023213336244225502, 0.0345955416560173, -0.015794159844517708, 0.09404504299163818, -0.029641255736351013, 0.003768263151869178, 0.044290464371442795, -0.042776357382535934, -0.016290340572595596, 0.023705309256911278, -0.0031844673212617636, -0.05356825888156891, 0.029968254268169403, 0.01084923092275858, 0.05176066234707832, -0.0023051726166158915, -0.02122657373547554, -0.021543456241488457, -0.039985571056604385, 0.017720062285661697, 0.06798572093248367, -0.02346188761293888, 0.0003173502627760172, -0.029689915478229523, -0.012269478291273117, 0.0009061534656211734, 0.03142528608441353, 0.004435685463249683, 0.006506572011858225, 0.010724041610956192, -0.0018662034999579191, 0.0352703221142292, 0.0035889269784092903, -0.008176839910447598, -0.011828693561255932, 0.021435467526316643, 0.040571849793195724, 0.05568218231201172, -0.02090764231979847, 0.04359826073050499, -0.0621272437274456, -0.05770532786846161, -0.014400217682123184, 0.016092833131551743, 0.01759088784456253, -0.033088963478803635, 0.06014881283044815, -0.030507810413837433, -0.01047880481928587, 0.09541989117860794, -0.02253742702305317, 0.05686363950371742, 0.002099968958646059, -0.04404419660568237, -0.04245820641517639, 0.0034147235564887524, -0.006691119633615017, 0.010154402814805508, -0.05895276740193367, 0.0033072703517973423, 0.02950572408735752, -0.014222635887563229, 0.020606722682714462, 0.023712709546089172, -0.0175178200006485, 0.029911745339632034, 0.006552445702254772, 0.003388681448996067, -0.007600332144647837, -0.016581695526838303, -0.03953962400555611, -0.006828014738857746, -0.06009698659181595, 0.02596748061478138, 0.004937144462019205, 0.013956808485090733, -0.043230090290308, 0.06376601755619049, -0.024649884551763535, -0.00003497472425806336, -0.03516405448317528, -0.03558986634016037, -0.02665075473487377, 0.08611004054546356, 0.020535165444016457, -0.0006766731385141611, 0.0325220488011837, -0.01960746757686138, 0.0008571575745008886, -0.006199379451572895, 0.02635974995791912, 0.06523825973272324, -0.046903811395168304, -0.011163596995174885, -0.022519763559103012, 0.03233761340379715, 0.028343036770820618, -0.0033139639999717474, 0.02363380417227745, -0.004174704197794199, 0.00489776348695159, 0.022675907239317894, 0.006757177412509918, 0.012036164291203022, -0.03876108676195145, 0.025372333824634552, -0.0689333826303482, -0.03218431398272514, -0.02512980066239834, 0.005700740031898022, -0.012661010958254337, -0.0027936941478401423, 0.041998956352472305, 0.06249324604868889, 0.038237065076828, -0.03274965658783913, -0.03394710272550583, -0.02733604609966278, -0.02393319271504879, 0.0011653854744508862, -0.056144408881664276, -0.03277098760008812, 0.03581699728965759, 0.03139906004071236, -0.02720428816974163, 0.030203893780708313, -0.007158350199460983, 0.008254648186266422, -0.032297004014253616, -0.04862945154309273, 0.023489603772759438, -0.03600211814045906, 0.005888790357857943, 0.03599942475557327, 0.023687900975346565, 0.025000793859362602, -0.018115898594260216, -0.04891832917928696, 0.020931610837578773, 0.08504696190357208, 0.009780791588127613, 0.01636340096592903, -0.008743932470679283, 0.014664971269667149, 0.007647878490388393, -0.004265871364623308, -0.010976619087159634, -0.04197896271944046, 0.034307025372982025, 0.05132373422384262, -0.025750508531928062, -0.04356454312801361, 0.02354598231613636, 0.055936701595783234, -0.004197111818939447, 0.02413453347980976, 0.03313931077718735, -0.005368197336792946, -0.03427624702453613, 0.0029970002360641956, -0.006783067248761654, 0.028324518352746964, -0.008128774352371693, 0.029296021908521652, -0.0023075088392943144, 0.00641793105751276, -0.003958733752369881, -0.0435744933784008, 0.025713538751006126, -0.031133797019720078, 0.04383246600627899, -0.021147457882761955, -0.03540068492293358, 0.04247723147273064, -0.029149185866117477, -0.0032647757325321436, 0.024124708026647568, -0.04664234444499016, 0.003644143231213093, 0.015636729076504707, -0.01424777414649725, -0.004513755906373262, 0.062016069889068604, -0.008035404607653618, -0.014184301719069481, 0.03984753414988518, -0.03328237682580948, 0.018968023359775543, 0.004194031469523907, -0.009493954479694366, -0.03311017155647278, 0.011038647033274174, 0.07097132503986359, 0.020285215228796005, 0.013954423367977142, -0.00746502261608839, -0.029377885162830353, 0.02391723543405533, -0.006588656920939684, 0.023136863484978676, 0.022904682904481888, -0.052263449877500534, -0.002532944083213806, -0.00935457181185484, -0.04344872012734413, 0.03650769963860512, 0.03757636621594429, -0.0325932577252388, -0.021960357204079628, -0.0024611216504126787, -0.0312906913459301, -0.015199701301753521, -0.05445203557610512, 0.005084064323455095, -0.024325665086507797, -0.02733786217868328, 0.05546284466981888, 0.0033906397875398397, -0.02591281197965145, 0.034138403832912445, -0.023999754339456558, -0.03276962414383888, -0.05554664880037308, -0.010286088101565838, 0.052628349512815475, 0.0013371529057621956, 0.012688995338976383, 0.026044156402349472, -0.016206739470362663, 0.010066728107631207, -0.04410957545042038, -0.05019398778676987, -0.015235474333167076, -0.0015408988110721111, 0.04652649536728859, 0.02181144431233406, -0.01189700048416853, 0.042700521647930145, 0.03346000611782074, -0.010220774449408054, -0.02345224656164646, -0.031818099319934845, -0.02358715422451496, 0.002466794103384018, -0.0018024856690317392, -0.0028810969088226557, -0.0010595472995191813, 0.03432035073637962, -0.028702974319458008, 0.005591951310634613, 0.03090202994644642, 0.02877461165189743, -0.03021291270852089, 0.0529492162168026, -0.02154715359210968, -0.0017736325971782207, 0.009087265469133854, 0.011047059670090675, -0.01656569540500641, 0.02148790843784809, -0.004705509636551142, -0.0005327180842868984, 0.03944506123661995, 0.008211957290768623, 0.021819395944476128, 0.017459772527217865, 0.01639009267091751, -0.04212162271142006, 0.0172848142683506, 0.0028227721340954304, -0.040434468537569046, -0.029517438262701035, 0.050158604979515076, 0.040799032896757126, -0.024132655933499336, 0.0027464027516543865, 0.04323197156190872, 0.035145144909620285, -0.02193381078541279, -0.03615942224860191, 0.014026103541254997, 0.028631722554564476, 0.01926138438284397, -0.006652369629591703, -0.023758742958307266, 0.06723125278949738, 0.0411873422563076, 0.03348040208220482, 0.004524087067693472, -0.029519198462367058, 0.045811012387275696, -0.05929698050022125, -0.006692360620945692, -0.009434407576918602, 0.04390105605125427, 0.01582590490579605, 0.022851066663861275, 0.03430406004190445, 0.02189788594841957, 0.008294000290334225, 0.025158779695630074, -0.09043476730585098, 0.028388220816850662, 0.004333243705332279, 0.034347884356975555, -0.05500093102455139, -0.0004373456467874348, 0.02676796168088913, -0.016643458977341652, 0.0010202148696407676, 0.04440871626138687, 0.013541962020099163, -0.03936517983675003, -0.020897144451737404, -0.00759885972365737, -0.010511736385524273, -0.03697894513607025, 0.026655301451683044, -0.003641948103904724, -0.00895914901047945, 0.031498655676841736, 0.028256580233573914, 0.014638314954936504, -0.02381202019751072, -0.015352347865700722, 0.021680530160665512, 0.0090941796079278, 0.05334952473640442, 0.007976644672453403, 0.039056919515132904, -0.04541024565696716, 0.02580571174621582, 0.02695532701909542, 0.05645468831062317, 0.02353607676923275, -0.005842964164912701, -0.020615478977560997, -0.010945605114102364, -0.036107387393713, -0.008392642252147198, 0.015247429721057415, -0.01822544075548649, 0.028680378571152687, 0.021369464695453644, 0.02739439159631729, -0.03685373812913895, 0.003611538792029023, 0.056193605065345764, 0.023841435089707375, 0.01589471474289894, -0.02440098486840725, 0.016127774491906166, -0.03812618553638458, 0.022814301773905754, 0.011022069491446018, 0.02100992016494274, -0.01678192801773548, 0.03128153458237648, 0.03127697855234146, -0.00000993267440208001, 0.0083831287920475, -0.010812783613801003, -0.007114094216376543, 0.03082667477428913, -0.015831170603632927, -0.01296575553715229, 0.040138740092515945, 0.04530983045697212, 0.04573260620236397, 0.07369635999202728, -0.013103989884257317, -0.09263525158166885, 0.008528543636202812, 0.05960853397846222, 0.01989123784005642, -0.008953717537224293, -0.003828686196357012, -0.07537470012903214, -0.01887461543083191, 0.036961041390895844, -0.04940858483314514, -0.03177206218242645, -0.023428834974765778, -0.016395865008234978, 0.014101264998316765, 0.002500721253454685, -0.059340424835681915, 0.03278909996151924, -0.008791208267211914, -0.0006887724157422781, 0.003189000766724348, 0.0003593596920836717, -0.08526413887739182, 0.04776604846119881, -0.004768106155097485, 0.06084543466567993, -0.006324281916022301, -0.018193546682596207, 0.0023302361369132996, 0.02965538389980793, 0.007944181561470032, -0.07630733400583267, -0.003211595816537738, 0.009008764289319515, 0.03002062998712063, 0.03516271337866783, 0.0023165782913565636, -0.016101330518722534, 0.009256954304873943, -0.017148073762655258, -0.026764854788780212, 0.03671292960643768, -0.001955985790118575, 0.027481073513627052, 0.0013358619762584567, 0.011591991409659386, 0.04222378507256508, 0.03782476484775543, 0.004491192288696766, -0.020608821883797646, -0.05393371358513832, 0.004958175588399172, -0.0247466042637825, 0.012032181955873966, -0.05483347550034523, -0.016610100865364075, -0.035350650548934937, 0.01772473379969597, 0.011339778080582619, 0.056309767067432404, 0.01121838390827179, -0.03146963566541672, -0.017288781702518463, 0.03242645412683487, -0.015687113627791405, -0.020294006913900375, -0.004815622698515654, -0.008112230338156223, 0.011710552498698235, -0.015612010844051838, 0.024807147681713104, -0.02343543991446495, -0.010862207971513271, 0.005626684054732323, -0.05736022815108299, 0.013383617624640465, -0.04723871871829033, -0.044667646288871765, 0.01670663058757782, -0.019542047753930092, 0.03258933126926422, 0.002455457579344511, 0.043454211205244064, 0.026132920756936073, -0.04229104891419411, -0.0004594252968672663, 0.04273483529686928, 0.003860717173665762, 0.05062314495444298, -0.05116334185004234, 0.02183099463582039, -0.01974332705140114, 0.007374754175543785, -0.07718343287706375, -0.04345027729868889, 0.014662021771073341, -0.013533622026443481, -0.02922765724360943, -0.06437128037214279, -0.005034151487052441, 0.027774887159466743, -0.018826669082045555, 0.0013654438080266118, 0.03851573169231415, 0.003828036831691861, -0.003656008280813694, -0.000680102442856878, -0.016470447182655334, 0.06298176199197769, 0.002758768852800131, 0.009713784791529179, 0.04183878004550934, -0.004072781186550856, -0.02908988855779171, -0.004522467032074928, 0.03590715676546097, -0.03970032557845116, 0.009287197142839432, -0.01521845068782568, -0.046548906713724136, 0.03104296512901783, -0.03721323609352112, -0.010560146532952785, -0.0050271484069526196, -0.00017414390458725393, -0.0036756484769284725, -0.009398042224347591, -0.02403595857322216, -0.05204065889120102, -0.03577764704823494, -0.0661296471953392, -0.006064117886126041, -0.02535811997950077, -0.029111217707395554, 0.034782525151968, 0.012295039370656013, -0.017445139586925507, 0.034552257508039474, 0.08757410943508148, 0.010082638822495937, -0.017169399186968803, -0.0008717662421986461, -0.020191127434372902, 0.03677407279610634, 0.019737984985113144, -0.004427590407431126, 0.06099828705191612, 0.010133611969649792, -0.01476490218192339, 0.002568974392488599, -0.018763137981295586, -0.02696874737739563, 0.018067732453346252, 0.010937356390058994, 0.043219972401857376, 0.028175227344036102, 0.009713515639305115, -0.008066900074481964, 0.035036031156778336, -0.013658554293215275, 0.013025594875216484, 0.0029973648488521576, 0.05467703565955162, -0.0015346665168181062, 0.028414679691195488, 0.00827720481902361, 0.04376353323459625, 0.011296997778117657, 0.06993592530488968, -0.010539193637669086, 0.03790880739688873, 0.05483530834317207, 0.007702830247581005, -0.04030333086848259, 0.07007221132516861, -0.026903904974460602, 0.021023700013756752, -0.0011086208978667855, -0.05108669027686119, 0.04757555574178696, 0.008127310313284397, -0.01120295561850071, -0.043709252029657364, 0.002426567254588008, -0.016836421564221382, 0.012536510825157166, 0.004113532602787018, -0.0014794983435422182, 0.006217306014150381, -0.002555669518187642, 0.04689466580748558, -0.01134578324854374, 0.014402554370462894, -0.031878408044576645, -0.04911031574010849, -0.03128724545240402, -0.03726897016167641, -0.05520549416542053, -0.015336473472416401, 0.017434656620025635, 0.011312202550470829, 0.03138783574104309, -0.02171558514237404, 0.012894412502646446, 0.026300547644495964, -0.005382340867072344, 0.0037352675572037697, 0.050273433327674866, 0.015995247289538383, 0.031151752918958664, -0.038795433938503265, -0.03289730101823807, 0.11756353825330734, 0.07410408556461334, 0.042068395763635635, -0.07493743300437927, -0.005196554120630026, -0.032745666801929474, 0.03586914762854576, -0.022112159058451653, 0.017213603481650352, 0.031182853505015373, 0.02247948944568634, 0.049702126532793045, 0.05705917626619339, 0.022954177111387253, 0.015441064722836018, 0.03416730463504791, -0.0179982278496027, -0.028204921633005142, -0.011914349161088467, 0.030741095542907715, 0.0001338656438747421, -0.02413451485335827, -0.07519315183162689, 0.020508717745542526, -0.01892806962132454, -0.014493795111775398, -0.03977623209357262, -0.03309445083141327, -0.007321157027035952, -0.009850387461483479, -0.04301474615931511, -0.015324316918849945, 0.008966080844402313, -0.017275815829634666, 0.011724581010639668, -0.020618438720703125, -0.011369908228516579, -0.016801411285996437, 0.002792684594169259, 0.0010503820376470685, 0.04465116560459137, 0.00608478207141161, 0.02004707232117653, -0.0024689817801117897, -0.02457275800406933, -0.018051885068416595, -0.03951022028923035, 0.01549327839165926, -0.04645185172557831, 0.041219890117645264, -0.013311384245753288, 0.026327477768063545, -0.013229581527411938, -0.04974977672100067, -0.02229543775320053, 0.0014750624541193247, 0.0532769076526165, 0.009808999486267567, -0.032024696469306946, -0.015875553712248802, 0.040282029658555984, 0.006941080559045076, 0.014920070767402649, 0.009008747525513172, -0.0347013846039772, 0.009152624756097794, -0.00616551423445344, 0.10045323520898819, 0.004692034795880318, -0.03282520920038223, 0.0032976276706904173, -0.019627206027507782, -0.005640844348818064, 0.011235577054321766, 0.009060509502887726, -0.026963278651237488, 0.0015746471472084522, 0.014916075393557549, 0.008257726207375526, -0.009732335805892944, -0.019697511568665504, 0.04869139939546585, -0.043657682836055756, 0.00670127896592021, -0.015305306762456894, -0.03071735054254532, 0.02674846723675728, 0.01829434186220169, 0.02381642907857895, 0.01210001576691866, -0.017208637669682503, 0.045640695840120316, 0.0005131010548211634, -0.05546535924077034, -0.033700570464134216, 0.012769152410328388, -0.03736010193824768, 0.014606527052819729, -0.019171779975295067, 0.02662709727883339, -0.0020869693253189325, -0.007869452238082886, -0.021878618746995926, 0.03885837644338608, -0.034302499145269394, -0.011646172031760216, -0.02390238828957081, -0.07636351138353348, -0.0147385373711586, 0.004556519910693169, 0.008620334789156914, -0.040341995656490326, -0.04577578231692314, 0.000730494677554816, -0.014257870614528656, -0.03967161476612091, 0.04679284989833832, -0.002915285062044859, -0.036557089537382126, -0.0010919827036559582, -0.0010755239054560661, 0.026469988748431206, 0.001965908333659172, -0.011205637827515602, -0.03257899358868599, -0.006530746351927519, -0.013917756266891956, -0.012071911245584488, 0.0006448168423958123, 0.009058554656803608, 0.02503829635679722, 0.007857120595872402, -0.009439371526241302, 0.0025733490474522114, 0.03188498318195343, 0.0032410987187176943, 0.021006572991609573, 0.022107858210802078, -0.02063477411866188, 0.00938563235104084, 0.04900938645005226, -0.047173697501420975, -0.08715552091598511, 0.024703456088900566, 0.030219370499253273, 0.03142715245485306, 0.00022559138596989214, -0.00021038601698819548, -0.02545798011124134, 0.05966200679540634, 0.024328412488102913, -0.02019648626446724, -0.01333700492978096, 0.008544032461941242, 0.036860883235931396, -0.004011140204966068, -0.021533798426389694, -0.023077528923749924, -0.040434934198856354, 0.022502092644572258, 0.03068670816719532, -0.0038924335967749357, -0.021399566903710365, 0.018039263784885406, -0.018268972635269165, 0.04206203669309616, -0.015064503997564316, 0.0054620057344436646, 0.0012555872090160847, 0.009700128808617592, -0.044897571206092834, 0.011916030198335648, -0.008555661886930466, 0.008877262473106384, -0.0603848434984684, -0.019697794690728188, 0.061831988394260406, -0.03703053295612335, 0.011074968613684177, -0.08596257865428925, -0.05129178985953331, 0.019375376403331757, -0.03257257863879204, 0.019090117886662483, 0.003502568230032921, -0.03539150580763817, -0.02467162348330021, -0.0144959082826972, -0.029740851372480392, 0.03473507985472679, 0.01884852722287178, 0.010218536481261253, 0.023388294503092766, 0.004629493225365877, -0.02666238695383072, -0.0005637636641040444, 0.008619725704193115, 0.021161794662475586, 0.01650235429406166, -0.03277435153722763, 0.044681139290332794, -0.03254711627960205, -0.011975443921983242, 0.04300617799162865, -0.011099487543106079, -0.023129770532250404, 0.0076653738506138325, 0.02163870446383953, -0.008704581297934055, 0.030369389802217484, 0.030229218304157257, 0.007354887202382088, -0.025583744049072266, 0.006385842803865671, 0.04489897936582565, 0.004937284160405397, -0.034162487834692, 0.026596931740641594, 0.008530545979738235, -0.006773985456675291, -0.03598054498434067, 0.041798677295446396, -0.017669716849923134, -0.009998675435781479, -0.028925063088536263, -0.020434312522411346, 0.038217779248952866, -0.016570795327425003, 0.015307883732020855, -0.07077709585428238, -0.002968162763863802, -0.0045558554120361805, -0.02218525856733322, -0.005948948208242655, 0.05205514281988144, -0.026445899158716202, -0.05619266256690025, 0.01774575375020504, 0.01864231564104557, -0.02813679538667202, -0.046622566878795624, -0.002081414684653282, -0.00026454738690517843, 0.006861807778477669, 0.01888773962855339, -0.01701834239065647, -0.008801955729722977, 0.03229933977127075, -0.010615551844239235, 0.0038427417166531086, 0.07019200921058655, -0.003886914113536477, 0.0043830908834934235, -0.07022184878587723, 0.060709528625011444, 0.005113213323056698, 0.006315491162240505, 0.0017131901113316417, -0.013897733762860298, -0.019788654521107674, 0.011834822595119476, 0.031655203551054, 0.024650482460856438, -0.002441421849653125, 0.012279028072953224, 0.016326457262039185, 0.034358277916908264, -0.055496297776699066, 0.011506873182952404, -0.021895507350564003, -0.05002658814191818, 0.01541683916002512, 0.01175299845635891, 0.0036811477039009333, 0.01613670215010643, 0.00035961216781288385, -0.012270137667655945, -0.023055318742990494, -0.023745855316519737, -0.02019917406141758, 0.028779057785868645, -0.00217174063436687, -0.029468869790434837, 0.046637021005153656, -0.03143096715211868, 0.003907724749296904, -0.028374969959259033, -0.01010798942297697, -0.02014380693435669, 0.020124148577451706, -0.011161859147250652, -0.0488436184823513, -0.02273249253630638, 0.02177571877837181, 0.015244394540786743, -0.03247314691543579, -0.03694258630275726, -0.013866610825061798, -0.0650082528591156, 0.012661309912800789, 0.0306647177785635, 0.022240590304136276, 0.07067424803972244, -0.034255191683769226, 0.008551191538572311, 0.019625971093773842, 0.009738997556269169, 0.002216261113062501, -0.0251072496175766, 0.008066139183938503, -0.013307329267263412, 0.02989191934466362, 0.008430728688836098, -0.02640112116932869, 0.049690693616867065, -0.014770546928048134, 0.029308434575796127, -0.017825646325945854, 0.014944721013307571, 0.04078716039657593, 0.0001688886113697663, 0.028355933725833893, -0.03380360081791878, -0.0011123188305646181, 0.01604008860886097, -0.0029119744431227446, 0.03664851933717728, -0.07549555599689484, -0.013592605479061604, -0.018442964181303978, 0.01306706853210926, -0.015116787515580654, 0.029695041477680206, -0.008286846801638603, 0.0033822432160377502, 0.014965571463108063, 0.01875515840947628, 0.06845200806856155, -0.02677643857896328, 0.025731343775987625, -0.033548753708601, 0.0019441257463768125, 0.015217575244605541, -0.007407688535749912, -0.02190646342933178, -0.04748040437698364, -0.013926390558481216, 0.02220897190272808, 0.04539383575320244, 0.018696624785661697, -0.002777017652988434, 0.02991834469139576, 0.043707866221666336, -0.04764138534665108, -0.03702615201473236, -0.04805000126361847, 0.0264971312135458, 0.01131176482886076, -0.0025843249168246984 ]
<p>In the context of REML estimation there is the result (ignoring some constants) that (my interest is in the matrix algebra so some notation is suppressed):</p> <p>$l(\mathbf V_0)=\log |\mathbf V_0| + \text{tr}(\mathbf V_0^{-1}\mathbf S) \tag{1}$</p> <p>Where both $\mathbf V_0$ and $\mathbf S$ are symmetric and invertible. I am told that the following expression can be obtained from (1) by differentiating with respect to a parameter $\sigma_i$ of $\mathbf V_0$:</p> <p>$\text{tr}\left[\mathbf V_0 \frac{\partial \mathbf V_0^{-1}}{\partial \sigma_i}\right]-\text{tr}\left[\frac{\partial \mathbf V_0^{-1}}{\partial \sigma_i}(\mathbf V_0 - \mathbf S)\right] \tag{2}$</p> <p>I'm trying to see what steps got this, but am stuck.</p> <p>Now I'm obviously lacking some machinery for dealing with these things but I don't know where to look. The issue is that, say, both terms in (1) are scalar, and we are differentiating w.r.t a scalar, so the it would seem the answer should be scalar. But my workings end up matrix valued. E.g.</p> <p>$\frac{\partial \log |\mathbf V_0|}{\partial \sigma_i} = \mathbf V_0^{-1} \frac{\partial \mathbf V_0}{\partial \sigma_i} $</p> <p>Clearly the trace gets involved wrapping it all up into a scalar, but I don't know how or why!</p>
73,915
[ -0.006170616485178471, -0.012739608064293861, -0.028768792748451233, 0.0037871270906180143, 0.0004615446669049561, 0.03346475213766098, -0.00977353285998106, 0.019937383010983467, 0.013628740794956684, -0.02858571894466877, -0.0153322983533144, 0.04513033106923103, 0.08638271689414978, -0.010959314182400703, 0.034050118178129196, 0.0046224286779761314, -0.00542976800352335, 0.015518883243203163, 0.0003846440522465855, -0.0060990736819803715, 0.010539961978793144, 0.03735969960689545, 0.0011567071778699756, -0.002628325717523694, -0.014859423972666264, 0.01800093799829483, -0.010944246314466, -0.01699249818921089, -0.006010145880281925, 0.05753927305340767, -0.023460255935788155, -0.008208747953176498, -0.0004484350502025336, -0.005716811399906874, -0.00028248687158338726, 0.01886758580803871, -0.04821908846497536, -0.02156996726989746, -0.0016432865522801876, 0.04614577069878578, -0.04848609119653702, -0.021331200376152992, -0.02112831361591816, 0.07800226658582687, -0.01246024202555418, 0.008894667960703373, -0.017566317692399025, -0.01686265878379345, 0.04439399763941765, -0.027262091636657715, 0.07837910205125809, 0.006977509707212448, 0.054263368248939514, 0.025106625631451607, -0.022758545354008675, 0.00415248004719615, 0.04259573668241501, 0.09499423205852509, 0.017170704901218414, -0.01370493695139885, -0.022416776046156883, -0.0038098532240837812, 0.013496951200067997, -0.02091548964381218, -0.0158840324729681, -0.01114032231271267, 0.021512605249881744, 0.002909421920776367, 0.03755791112780571, -0.020929759368300438, 0.009747442789375782, -0.007814600132405758, 0.025179067626595497, -0.016883688047528267, 0.015558954328298569, -0.012194284237921238, -0.013786910101771355, 0.03105206787586212, 0.01164776086807251, -0.0011927136220037937, -0.004471570253372192, -0.032512206584215164, -0.008869585581123829, 0.04533078521490097, 0.01537514291703701, -0.005369413644075394, 0.09027748554944992, -0.0033488275948911905, 0.028533054515719414, 0.03842756897211075, 0.005209216382354498, 0.035860758274793625, 0.02456510439515114, 0.002458376344293356, -0.0621342808008194, 0.06410186737775803, -0.006144764367491007, 0.04851444810628891, 0.014014574699103832, -0.029119865968823433, -0.030221138149499893, -0.06382081657648087, -0.011860175989568233, 0.04224298521876335, -0.01772761158645153, 0.021130677312612534, 0.015392014756798744, 0.003634420456364751, -0.015135295689105988, -0.053745731711387634, -0.013390726409852505, 0.05508921295404434, -0.00642457464709878, -0.02940126694738865, -0.04145513474941254, -0.03702548146247864, -0.015914522111415863, -0.01698911003768444, 0.014399132691323757, 0.06713736802339554, 0.013325858861207962, 0.007174517493695021, -0.008487832732498646, -0.009318293072283268, -0.0742034837603569, 0.02013976313173771, 0.018339309841394424, -0.05256744101643562, -0.057566653937101364, 0.02469063363969326, 0.052838828414678574, -0.012239555828273296, 0.06214378401637077, -0.018138062208890915, 0.030049284920096397, -0.03156115487217903, -0.07395169883966446, -0.059570830315351486, 0.0399194061756134, -0.02143280953168869, 0.03951992839574814, -0.0803816020488739, -0.03003026731312275, 0.03014283813536167, 0.058026187121868134, -0.002892865799367428, 0.03532048687338829, 0.007060404401272535, 0.0070266337133944035, -0.004712878260761499, -0.036477651447057724, -0.053297895938158035, -0.03193138912320137, 0.010566354729235172, -0.014691740274429321, -0.05474935844540596, 0.029085662215948105, 0.04586704447865486, -0.037538230419158936, 0.012428198009729385, 0.09110897034406662, 0.043363504111766815, -0.007369994651526213, 0.02326882816851139, -0.004781493917107582, -0.02773176319897175, 0.05737553909420967, -0.008440187200903893, 0.023103948682546616, 0.02405642531812191, 0.025984376668930054, 0.009267116896808147, -0.00723795173689723, 0.04583529382944107, 0.062035299837589264, -0.04292367398738861, -0.018679114058613777, 0.02394946664571762, 0.012019921094179153, 0.03937787190079689, -0.05635751411318779, -0.05169187858700752, -0.0029434754978865385, -0.002300470834597945, 0.023443851619958878, 0.005950356367975473, -0.016227319836616516, -0.0017668433720245957, 0.001781624392606318, -0.01380980759859085, 0.019509756937623024, -0.03422237187623978, -0.000671827991027385, -0.0059432582929730415, -0.03210240975022316, 0.05487970635294914, -0.023406896740198135, 0.008734420873224735, 0.011911757290363312, -0.07241645455360413, 0.013563437387347221, 0.028435925021767616, 0.039783772081136703, 0.00048738266923464835, 0.00780020235106349, 0.011249328032135963, 0.047664377838373184, 0.009024062193930149, 0.06844509392976761, -0.03829755634069443, -0.02648705244064331, 0.014149980619549751, 0.0013493095757439733, 0.011122731491923332, 0.030263442546129227, -0.037272654473781586, -0.007767784409224987, -0.006616094149649143, 0.02287970669567585, 0.012639052234590054, -0.028176696971058846, 0.015729855746030807, 0.06379793584346771, 0.04043222963809967, -0.04157973453402519, 0.000983735197223723, -0.02652512490749359, 0.04062937572598457, -0.008275392465293407, -0.048935309052467346, -0.01291422639042139, -0.012760652229189873, 0.021263178437948227, 0.02816239558160305, -0.014536397531628609, 0.0074787018820643425, 0.049701202660799026, 0.024101950228214264, 0.029598843306303024, 0.01759994402527809, -0.030765654519200325, -0.010523086413741112, 0.020601904019713402, -0.008924061432480812, -0.010667894035577774, 0.029604598879814148, 0.0252781193703413, 0.00501206936314702, 0.050786856561899185, -0.00880767498165369, -0.012911967001855373, 0.04105808213353157, -0.010457796044647694, -0.002538867760449648, -0.008885271847248077, 0.005682543385773897, 0.06256606429815292, 0.0011211183154955506, 0.03700769320130348, 0.03926905617117882, -0.007205348461866379, 0.020987434312701225, -0.0009665979305282235, -0.0156549084931612, 0.04886757954955101, -0.002112110611051321, -0.02496902458369732, 0.011791172437369823, 0.01945565827190876, -0.025464417412877083, 0.00652665738016367, -0.022649968042969704, 0.0008410409791395068, -0.030342116951942444, 0.03493759036064148, 0.04644768685102463, -0.01352041307836771, -0.009417720139026642, -0.026745665818452835, -0.0332602858543396, 0.033170778304338455, 0.003549188608303666, 0.04079313948750496, 0.02840369939804077, -0.04202796146273613, 0.03282826021313667, -0.027259308844804764, -0.008162506856024265, -0.0034217736683785915, 0.026379937306046486, -0.02083783969283104, 0.017519667744636536, -0.013881069608032703, -0.07966810464859009, -0.06236852705478668, -0.0037792420480400324, 0.00427313894033432, -0.024559004232287407, 0.01550237461924553, 0.03830587491393089, -0.013109409250319004, -0.004305984824895859, 0.004471678752452135, -0.04220021143555641, -0.0372295044362545, 0.0077888634987175465, -0.004319441504776478, -0.03304839879274368, -0.02225981280207634, 0.059451907873153687, 0.0011177234118804336, -0.02067798189818859, -0.015622022561728954, -0.06311117857694626, -0.027952924370765686, 0.03062552772462368, 0.025088468566536903, 0.01759471744298935, 0.031668875366449356, -0.05127468705177307, 0.0855797678232193, 0.020638395100831985, 0.004591974429786205, -0.03270106017589569, 0.013015390373766422, -0.01356748677790165, -0.06065010279417038, 0.005113134626299143, -0.008124393410980701, 0.0166156068444252, 0.06848730146884918, 0.008734178729355335, 0.03610914573073387, 0.05871610343456268, -0.018263882026076317, -0.03302423283457756, 0.022036699578166008, -0.03533695265650749, -0.02006932906806469, 0.05958811566233635, -0.0029259417206048965, 0.03878530487418175, 0.009544940665364265, 0.0020749694667756557, 0.01218889094889164, 0.01717447303235531, -0.05718405917286873, 0.0051668970845639706, 0.012225589714944363, -0.016453515738248825, -0.009052639827132225, 0.04050304368138313, 0.03692762553691864, -0.018038086593151093, -0.011308643966913223, 0.006635210011154413, -0.001325275981798768, -0.03882504999637604, 0.010093032382428646, 0.0410325862467289, 0.03281552344560623, -0.0007864651270210743, -0.03674576058983803, -0.01631125994026661, 0.0024968350771814585, 0.009091498330235481, -0.031750988215208054, 0.0037074305582791567, 0.027458125725388527, 0.0448366142809391, -0.025534942746162415, -0.057243842631578445, -0.03449247404932976, -0.046170175075531006, -0.039867013692855835, 0.04172075539827347, 0.000826741277705878, 0.06455086916685104, 0.007058624178171158, 0.026346152648329735, 0.016352541744709015, -0.0033195135183632374, 0.02843361720442772, 0.005647982005029917, -0.061303235590457916, 0.02325298823416233, -0.033064331859350204, -0.03104465641081333, 0.0015269939322024584, -0.015117676928639412, 0.06487231701612473, -0.04674091935157776, -0.010625466704368591, -0.015678314492106438, 0.01307188905775547, -0.05613662302494049, 0.010148323141038418, -0.03333045542240143, -0.03368331119418144, -0.01857784390449524, -0.007339143194258213, 0.03840173780918121, -0.0022852979600429535, -0.0015887025510892272, 0.0302893053740263, -0.004908524453639984, 0.01874111220240593, -0.042501334100961685, 0.01900457963347435, 0.016147010028362274, 0.023183930665254593, 0.024821991100907326, -0.025856606662273407, -0.030005959793925285, 0.025058360770344734, -0.006320219486951828, 0.04751092195510864, 0.019800668582320213, 0.014008648693561554, -0.02763117291033268, -0.030142072588205338, -0.018467698246240616, 0.00006773960194550455, 0.04577095806598663, 0.0049774618819355965, 0.009704222902655602, 0.06943712383508682, 0.01632692478597164, -0.03758161514997482, -0.0072998483665287495, 0.02609480731189251, 0.007173707243055105, -0.006165716331452131, -0.030587155371904373, -0.0027554966509342194, 0.02466476522386074, -0.013336128555238247, 0.031586527824401855, -0.013830208219587803, -0.009844992309808731, -0.03237151727080345, 0.024705050513148308, 0.0080801360309124, 0.0050581470131874084, 0.010753086768090725, 0.029857320711016655, 0.007080544717609882, -0.004464324098080397, -0.00881961639970541, 0.010789366438984871, 0.04507134482264519, 0.02788764238357544, -0.007583494298160076, 0.021818362176418304, -0.09413900226354599, -0.004936065059155226, -0.014176573604345322, 0.02359725907444954, -0.030215593054890633, 0.014513996429741383, -0.0529281385242939, -0.03255407512187958, 0.03409866243600845, -0.005050855688750744, 0.05014025419950485, -0.008275744505226612, 0.001788502442650497, -0.00448958296328783, -0.04071663320064545, -0.014226676896214485, 0.013029958121478558, -0.012336524203419685, 0.016130613163113594, -0.014093280769884586, -0.01130140945315361, -0.02480394020676613, 0.00537092937156558, 0.0019073276780545712, 0.07195326685905457, 0.001539007411338389, -0.0010484711965546012, -0.005984138231724501, 0.05777953565120697, -0.02309391461312771, -0.08145112544298172, -0.011225510388612747, -0.011240809224545956, -0.011362597346305847, 0.026464717462658882, -0.01426635030657053, -0.035725269466638565, 0.05977645143866539, 0.017959212884306908, 0.018001986667513847, -0.010383379645645618, 0.0003050525556318462, 0.07731172442436218, 0.027151020243763924, 0.008830435574054718, 0.08354050666093826, 0.0282114390283823, 0.020381290465593338, 0.012222583405673504, 0.001789267873391509, 0.01961241476237774, -0.012262830510735512, -0.014779328368604183, -0.03178783878684044, 0.02057880535721779, -0.01164169143885374, 0.0410248227417469, -0.005156754981726408, 0.032053228467702866, -0.0026412622537463903, -0.025341639295220375, 0.003954516723752022, 0.049848876893520355, -0.01516102533787489, -0.017646534368395805, 0.01875320076942444, 0.038679882884025574, 0.010750087909400463, -0.01332861464470625, -0.008037497289478779, -0.007269005291163921, 0.013763058930635452, 0.018344696611166, -0.0032425671815872192, 0.04721985012292862, -0.00010950204159598798, -0.02089262753725052, 0.026452790945768356, -0.05586939677596092, 0.03033793345093727, 0.011454539373517036, 0.016733737662434578, 0.008673488162457943, -0.010689476504921913, 0.008257430046796799, -0.015816835686564445, -0.020175784826278687, 0.019423896446824074, -0.03227170556783676, 0.0073643340729177, 0.02269371785223484, 0.007947375997900963, -0.08738330751657486, -0.05812595412135124, -0.009705821983516216, 0.013090251944959164, -0.0714539885520935, -0.022968055680394173, -0.04144740477204323, 0.0035256685223430395, -0.02198522351682186, 0.02941792458295822, 0.0567425899207592, -0.02488454431295395, -0.013813230209052563, 0.010859128087759018, 0.05965415760874748, 0.03949999064207077, -0.005906280595809221, 0.022005625069141388, -0.01264765951782465, -0.02480403147637844, -0.014452602714300156, 0.041916266083717346, 0.02607005648314953, -0.015104204416275024, 0.004702538717538118, -0.04980407655239105, 0.025164391845464706, 0.04300861433148384, -0.007361946627497673, -0.005796009209007025, -0.018243061378598213, 0.03713436797261238, 0.010493597947061062, -0.026552531868219376, -0.021889839321374893, -0.010862617753446102, 0.03381524980068207, 0.02554604597389698, -0.022345660254359245, -0.03270186856389046, -0.007944461889564991, 0.023312240839004517, 0.016556205227971077, 0.01962183602154255, -0.012735455296933651, 0.07191638648509979, -0.005605446640402079, 0.034462280571460724, 0.04353040084242821, 0.02982376329600811, 0.06587714701890945, -0.018053147941827774, 0.009795472957193851, 0.06369069963693619, 0.010270630940794945, -0.04228849336504936, -0.05543603375554085, -0.031941380351781845, 0.037729404866695404, 0.05366971343755722, 0.007961241528391838, 0.06067219376564026, -0.003036568174138665, -0.028227882459759712, 0.005839724093675613, -0.02286575175821781, -0.04441860318183899, -0.0060154045931994915, -0.02239849977195263, 0.039110347628593445, -0.031318146735429764, -0.013942739926278591, 0.012453061528503895, 0.020340267568826675, -0.012133520096540451, 0.010438288561999798, 0.024640554562211037, 0.00753742503002286, 0.013866130262613297, -0.007343505509197712, -0.005433514714241028, 0.04996326193213463, 0.0009526403155177832, 0.03965217247605324, 0.0057563274167478085, -0.0027128958608955145, 0.06854656338691711, 0.014253268018364906, 0.024215778335928917, -0.02386588230729103, -0.03231896832585335, -0.07355499267578125, 0.003983220551162958, 0.004948888905346394, -0.0063066501170396805, 0.04756186902523041, 0.024941151961684227, 0.005600579548627138, -0.007947464473545551, 0.008751662448048592, -0.041843775659799576, -0.07477211207151413, 0.014592806808650494, -0.0005665078642778099, -0.00928949099034071, 0.048414163291454315, 0.0024582946207374334, -0.040064141154289246, 0.02425449900329113, -0.026888087391853333, 0.036841847002506256, 0.012234839610755444, 0.026668058708310127, -0.00983705185353756, 0.0778891071677208, 0.02124807983636856, 0.023607460781931877, -0.011259128339588642, -0.004514952655881643, 0.09865681082010269, 0.07751979678869247, -0.011746756732463837, -0.059147875756025314, 0.011651449836790562, -0.018712257966399193, -0.016338426619768143, -0.04360319674015045, 0.02827424742281437, -0.004361261148005724, -0.0005840114317834377, -0.0034826346673071384, 0.03383149579167366, -0.028782900422811508, 0.0014239129377529025, 0.015678968280553818, -0.03857939690351486, -0.02695087343454361, 0.005852578207850456, -0.01572909764945507, -0.0024013803340494633, -0.007309832610189915, -0.010135402902960777, 0.043919216841459274, 0.011962005868554115, -0.018136635422706604, -0.039445143193006516, -0.052245136350393295, 0.003689433215186, -0.017726188525557518, -0.002353954128921032, 0.007548160385340452, 0.018686208873987198, 0.021579517051577568, 0.0034860195592045784, 0.010804101824760437, 0.03643064945936203, 0.01674995943903923, 0.03401127830147743, 0.03983889892697334, 0.0001673497463343665, -0.005212840624153614, -0.0063411155715584755, -0.006107001565396786, -0.034756049513816833, -0.038780517876148224, -0.04577183350920677, 0.05572238191962242, -0.02331707626581192, -0.00451561389490962, 0.013904903084039688, -0.04667050018906593, 0.025391429662704468, -0.07022831588983536, -0.01875375397503376, 0.03078252635896206, 0.012446325272321701, -0.03598961979150772, -0.0019939506892114878, -0.020972149446606636, 0.02042955346405506, 0.013803774490952492, -0.0026310142129659653, 0.035749804228544235, -0.04429357871413231, -0.028664372861385345, -0.01607433147728443, 0.05669305846095085, -0.04152974858880043, -0.016315098851919174, -0.006802634336054325, -0.034936632961034775, -0.0314047746360302, -0.04861322417855263, 0.0364995039999485, -0.005650185514241457, 0.019262593239545822, -0.03608989343047142, -0.008283776231110096, -0.011253945529460907, -0.09289601445198059, -0.005097623448818922, -0.03695959970355034, -0.0022330547217279673, -0.03152318671345711, 0.036352019757032394, 0.019892530515789986, 0.04480470344424248, -0.008429196663200855, 0.03489315137267113, 0.061009787023067474, 0.050847072154283524, 0.025589661672711372, -0.0627688467502594, -0.0418686717748642, 0.017399096861481667, -0.011369193904101849, 0.02414713427424431, 0.0074243564158678055, 0.02941383607685566, -0.012072592973709106, -0.0022768278140574694, -0.04293267801403999, 0.04862702265381813, -0.027441401034593582, 0.021131522953510284, 0.03567851707339287, -0.028381409123539925, 0.012022181414067745, 0.0014784310478717089, 0.005905992351472378, -0.010824945755302906, 0.016192276030778885, -0.014580560848116875, -0.0007402232149615884, -0.017220759764313698, -0.002291726181283593, -0.050522904843091965, 0.014033502899110317, -0.036386869847774506, 0.008439728058874607, -0.03873137757182121, -0.0001377282605972141, 0.00245212996378541, 0.044226374477148056, -0.000558166007976979, 0.02918069250881672, -0.02075394243001938, -0.0109436996281147, -0.02710026502609253, -0.043570730835199356, 0.052193254232406616, 0.04215428978204727, 0.026857445016503334, -0.024219384416937828, 0.006839136127382517, 0.00627902802079916, 0.029532749205827713, -0.02976415492594242, -0.04262226074934006, 0.035025469958782196, -0.03139859065413475, -0.035255979746580124, 0.041538678109645844, 0.04716934263706207, 0.014395663514733315, -0.005653386935591698, -0.01294652745127678, -0.021260827779769897, 0.05133606493473053, -0.0010697458637878299, 0.005627545993775129, -0.03405987471342087, -0.02571067214012146, -0.0021766137797385454, -0.04670121520757675, 0.014798041433095932, -0.015645701438188553, 0.02422003634274006, 0.016305916011333466, 0.004470622166991234, -0.06674943119287491, 0.010503485798835754, 0.008183580823242664, 0.009231310337781906, 0.024058936163783073, 0.02812260203063488, 0.013700969517230988, 0.017017874866724014, 0.03303113952279091, -0.011192339472472668, 0.02518634684383869, 0.015844276174902916, 0.007540254388004541, -0.07074402272701263, -0.022837141528725624, -0.015992937609553337, -0.0006729111773893237, -0.006627161055803299, -0.08625561743974686, -0.016535110771656036, 0.020274417474865913, -0.009495850652456284, 0.002901296364143491, -0.04037356749176979, 0.02411157451570034, -0.027202118188142776, 0.002730209846049547, -0.001885749981738627, 0.0047368211671710014, 0.014911995269358158, 0.013643557205796242, 0.034565530717372894, 0.027002738788723946, -0.0038015551399439573, -0.05060427263379097, -0.025469686836004257, 0.015820594504475594, 0.032174449414014816, -0.059739962220191956, 0.05158679187297821, -0.05806268751621246, -0.02525002881884575, 0.003418377134948969, -0.0018220149213448167, 0.026767250150442123, 0.013608588837087154, 0.04270936921238899, -0.0051682498306035995, 0.05694040283560753, 0.022237244993448257, 0.0038707605563104153, 0.03141164779663086, -0.01417271513491869, -0.006960459053516388, 0.008354170247912407, -0.03390784561634064, -0.008863759227097034, 0.007971322163939476, -0.019471673294901848, 0.007276009768247604, 0.01871025748550892, -0.038656432181596756, -0.013440882787108421, -0.015496685169637203, -0.04773247614502907, -0.0015962329925969243, -0.034287456423044205, 0.026244333013892174, -0.02831242047250271, -0.011705911718308926, 0.02388639561831951, 0.029055673629045486, -0.0708475336432457, 0.025802716612815857, -0.00295173074118793, -0.04410955682396889, 0.03204492852091789, -0.0017552307108417153, -0.030260536819696426, -0.08657920360565186, -0.01275648269802332, -0.011433335021138191, -0.019341060891747475, -0.02398821897804737, -0.00975213572382927, -0.031832046806812286, 0.04939223453402519, -0.025391802191734314, 0.01430201530456543, -0.011035431176424026, 0.0007870185654610395, 0.0015730028972029686, -0.09567894786596298, 0.06456700712442398, 0.00836047064512968, -0.050624094903469086, -0.007097612600773573, -0.06276630610227585, -0.0013098743511363864, 0.017165767028927803, 0.05189569666981697, -0.012107698246836662, -0.046558670699596405, 0.015333726070821285, 0.034328412264585495, -0.013102342374622822, -0.01841466873884201, 0.013867808505892754, -0.026326103135943413, -0.00523483008146286, -0.005777131766080856, -0.0396619588136673, -0.038281623274087906, 0.00805006641894579, -0.016298357397317886, 0.007237131241708994, -0.030954208225011826, -0.015915926545858383, -0.04290297254920006, 0.012246278114616871, -0.012392942793667316, -0.026824038475751877, 0.06511292606592178, 0.018052315339446068, 0.00600916612893343, 0.02144208364188671, -0.020688438788056374, -0.04141192138195038, 0.020666468888521194, -0.011476743035018444, -0.04415573552250862, -0.008435369469225407, -0.006346093490719795, 0.0480145625770092, -0.04934117570519447, -0.01302206702530384, 0.023506129160523415, -0.018655624240636826, -0.0067527322098612785, 0.045609001070261, 0.018305597826838493, 0.01728539541363716, 0.0077378638088703156, 0.04890935495495796, 0.023656556382775307, 0.0136097501963377, 0.006957453675568104, 0.04963280260562897, 0.013288561254739761, 0.013234013691544533, 0.0015431343344971538, 0.04364174231886864, -0.03702753409743309, 0.031376421451568604, -0.02987694926559925, -0.0023428958375006914, -0.04926242306828499, -0.024473432451486588, 0.008405261673033237, -0.04314900562167168, 0.00020376023894641548, -0.037382014095783234, -0.04756658896803856, 0.07963912934064865, -0.01868513971567154, -0.0077064791694283485, -0.028939640149474144, 0.028200311586260796, 0.003196811070665717, 0.013504375703632832, 0.007118316367268562, 0.03338143229484558, -0.018903736025094986, 0.022037558257579803, -0.009782364591956139, -0.04609649255871773, 0.002858498366549611, -0.05539106950163841, 0.010611958801746368, 0.005598563700914383, -0.033532172441482544, -0.00910872034728527, -0.03381548449397087, -0.02029932662844658, -0.015945304185152054, -0.0002890680043492466, 0.03142411634325981, 0.03525830805301666, -0.010079736821353436, -0.03956667333841324, 0.006248943507671356, 0.0630330964922905, -0.049270860850811005, -0.029020534828305244, -0.012629679404199123, -0.000596489931922406, -0.022241435945034027, -0.022373974323272705 ]
<p>Can the standard deviation be calculated for the harmonic mean? I understand that the standard deviation can be calculated for arithmetic mean, but if you have harmonic mean, how do you calculate the standard deviation or CV?</p>
73,916
[ -0.018330547958612442, -0.008953369222581387, 0.00020845366816502064, -0.016952356323599815, 0.04419486224651337, 0.00543585792183876, -0.02390742488205433, -0.04822242259979248, 0.017785517498850822, -0.02492053434252739, 0.028145918622612953, -0.011839434504508972, 0.07444533705711365, 0.012098661623895168, 0.03479214385151863, -0.0017363923834636807, -0.020823031663894653, 0.025238551199436188, -0.009457399137318134, -0.023421647027134895, -0.02101711928844452, 0.005629238206893206, 0.006234063301235437, -0.02063225582242012, -0.015031534247100353, 0.038685835897922516, 0.06059214472770691, 0.019170844927430153, 0.006900580134242773, 0.05814081430435181, -0.027017809450626373, -0.04369453340768814, 0.05868863686919212, 0.07326743006706238, 0.020852679386734962, 0.00047032846487127244, -0.009929816238582134, -0.011355496942996979, -0.032566964626312256, 0.0470564141869545, -0.014848596416413784, 0.011847379617393017, 0.026427872478961945, 0.01895713061094284, 0.007907702587544918, 0.02605673111975193, -0.016791637986898422, -0.03457723557949066, 0.0015731725143268704, -0.04597686603665352, 0.09607166796922684, -0.013178767636418343, 0.03670106455683708, 0.01876145601272583, 0.003913168329745531, 0.04139411821961403, 0.04373680427670479, 0.03477047011256218, 0.0008612554520368576, -0.04898083209991455, 0.0011690700193867087, -0.018871000036597252, -0.025914540514349937, -0.0466766357421875, -0.006906772498041391, -0.034338586032390594, -0.01988779753446579, -0.01504142489284277, 0.04245096072554588, -0.009285574778914452, 0.003697441192343831, 0.03855246305465698, -0.020740032196044922, -0.016397695988416672, 0.0020740744657814503, -0.02056960016489029, 0.013795492239296436, -0.026202987879514694, 0.02528313547372818, 0.009313625283539295, 0.008851421996951103, -0.0068218824453651905, 0.02038794383406639, 0.030887765809893608, -0.006810222752392292, -0.02804141491651535, 0.06922286003828049, -0.01093030720949173, 0.020316211506724358, 0.012935729697346687, 0.016032451763749123, -0.011203468777239323, 0.06730598956346512, -0.019491003826260567, -0.03326530382037163, 0.012927934527397156, -0.030518852174282074, 0.051985327154397964, 0.03419486805796623, -0.01703450456261635, 0.03652183338999748, -0.010782917030155659, 0.0543699786067009, 0.07596620917320251, -0.005092831794172525, -0.0293095912784338, 0.00612668739631772, 0.03687607869505882, 0.02774832397699356, -0.02453295886516571, -0.009080778807401657, -0.007943101227283478, 0.008814623579382896, 0.01470648217946291, 0.03168553113937378, 0.01560929510742426, -0.0013966544065624475, -0.02331564389169216, 0.024413179606199265, 0.06569600850343704, 0.02948569506406784, -0.026998871937394142, 0.00936100259423256, -0.017584608867764473, -0.040024857968091965, 0.03808306157588959, 0.009850713424384594, -0.025811754167079926, -0.04243471100926399, 0.05220530927181244, 0.020474959164857864, -0.04189024120569229, 0.03203390911221504, -0.0026326272636651993, 0.012343634851276875, -0.013285880908370018, -0.06869785487651825, -0.051823802292346954, -0.023124461993575096, 0.0018019158160313964, -0.030375810340046883, -0.06565368175506592, 0.00832328014075756, 0.027859484776854515, 0.030468005686998367, 0.04539021849632263, 0.0417741984128952, -0.005180359352380037, 0.030305515974760056, 0.02481638453900814, -0.02270858734846115, -0.02833200804889202, -0.00009531021350994706, -0.0390351302921772, -0.00335133820772171, -0.06753402948379517, 0.009216533973813057, -0.037722811102867126, 0.024286627769470215, -0.009714195504784584, 0.02361258491873741, 0.019158542156219482, -0.004065098240971565, 0.014314080588519573, 0.012295449152588844, -0.04799308627843857, 0.05888161435723305, -0.00795812252908945, -0.004197767004370689, -0.014298418536782265, 0.006483255885541439, 0.01223956048488617, 0.01901724934577942, 0.03230547904968262, 0.07520473748445511, -0.012999935075640678, 0.0034590207505971193, -0.035768911242485046, 0.054504502564668655, 0.007929985411465168, -0.02335507981479168, -0.005709208548069, -0.007580144796520472, 0.031153596937656403, 0.014329295605421066, 0.05148028954863548, 0.007618311792612076, -0.006407361943274736, 0.005261807236820459, -0.01846005767583847, 0.01123056374490261, -0.041464272886514664, 0.02394939959049225, -0.01207753736525774, -0.02056581899523735, 0.008172193542122841, 0.021183187142014503, 0.06682486087083817, -0.04570212587714195, 0.014253172092139721, -0.02288353629410267, 0.01796439290046692, 0.030312474817037582, -0.06771013140678406, 0.03984527289867401, 0.04089660942554474, 0.05525875836610794, 0.012168645858764648, 0.06491118669509888, -0.035921454429626465, -0.0206469614058733, -0.012923771515488625, -0.024557767435908318, 0.015554547309875488, 0.008695320226252079, -0.014172722585499287, -0.01086035929620266, 0.015959104523062706, 0.004752209410071373, 0.05482129007577896, 0.0032625331077724695, 0.09789270907640457, 0.05041572079062462, 0.0319456122815609, 0.007450170814990997, 0.02576567977666855, 0.038071729242801666, -0.016053583472967148, 0.01220917422324419, -0.048224031925201416, -0.02978292666375637, 0.03414495289325714, 0.05657525360584259, 0.021622326225042343, -0.028033744543790817, -0.0005189636722207069, 0.0957476943731308, 0.01174207590520382, 0.04137799143791199, 0.015314328484237194, -0.0011328869732096791, -0.009839924983680248, -0.005428260192275047, 0.009794900193810463, 0.03368351235985756, -0.011939882300794125, -0.00024829196627251804, 0.032010454684495926, 0.03266527131199837, 0.050625916570425034, -0.027675841003656387, 0.039226122200489044, 0.029960835352540016, -0.021175062283873558, 0.0027514563407748938, -0.014161949045956135, 0.04259469360113144, -0.025097167119383812, 0.022089580073952675, 0.04412364214658737, -0.016061538830399513, -0.035864751785993576, 0.020788444206118584, -0.03212892264127731, 0.030537612736225128, 0.03125649690628052, -0.026741528883576393, 0.009797218255698681, 0.018549388274550438, -0.045848388224840164, 0.01589377596974373, -0.025035753846168518, -0.006671725306659937, -0.012037764303386211, -0.011581791564822197, 0.01585891656577587, -0.013483059592545033, 0.03380963206291199, -0.006980755366384983, -0.005999749526381493, -0.01242885086685419, -0.01379125751554966, -0.0021399864926934242, -0.0414254292845726, -0.041656918823719025, -0.0060880426317453384, -0.011456068605184555, -0.043565280735492706, -0.006368936505168676, -0.028053194284439087, 0.012646717019379139, 0.019939322024583817, -0.009011677466332912, -0.06058799847960472, 0.020780574530363083, -0.001554285641759634, 0.01570078916847706, -0.02411913312971592, 0.003217041026800871, 0.005473099648952484, 0.002714386209845543, -0.04320304095745087, 0.04973690211772919, -0.01544842030853033, -0.043663088232278824, -0.05320815369486809, 0.01078315731137991, 0.019719084724783897, -0.04176617041230202, 0.06137082725763321, 0.011991984210908413, -0.0789136216044426, -0.010920093394815922, -0.042086951434612274, -0.02474481426179409, 0.03147294372320175, -0.0011652136454358697, 0.024815930053591728, 0.01852731965482235, -0.054501380771398544, 0.0826333612203598, 0.033504419028759, -0.045452069491147995, -0.027996109798550606, 0.025292040780186653, -0.010306630283594131, 0.0012300770031288266, -0.0015988886589184403, 0.01924908347427845, 0.010733069851994514, 0.009936823509633541, 0.0002823038666974753, -0.013438350521028042, 0.0678141713142395, 0.0027024908922612667, -0.02407594583928585, 0.012598278932273388, 0.003208824200555682, 0.0051869903691112995, 0.02524595893919468, 0.021376410499215126, -0.009771717712283134, 0.019896842539310455, 0.03599262237548828, 0.04350588843226433, -0.020951129496097565, -0.020106513053178787, 0.016749637201428413, -0.02216750755906105, 0.007627849001437426, -0.053621191531419754, 0.021518319845199585, 0.024967938661575317, 0.014227742329239845, 0.014490186236798763, 0.02122173272073269, -0.018803266808390617, -0.00701390253379941, 0.02758355438709259, 0.030230680480599403, 0.046986501663923264, -0.008911838755011559, -0.05428894981741905, -0.007811183109879494, 0.0006129311514087021, 0.028726652264595032, 0.0004830528923776001, -0.04883306473493576, 0.0324472151696682, 0.05952128395438194, 0.023411106318235397, -0.000664577994029969, -0.03033772110939026, 0.01345832273364067, -0.08308784663677216, -0.013377334922552109, -0.021646276116371155, 0.02408469095826149, -0.0008649606024846435, 0.03694408759474754, 0.01702927239239216, -0.019352396950125694, 0.0044196369126439095, 0.0015486832708120346, -0.05992856249213219, 0.017982590943574905, -0.020763125270605087, -0.028754951432347298, -0.030869171023368835, -0.042088549584150314, 0.03486265987157822, -0.0005092899082228541, 0.03282735124230385, -0.05019161105155945, -0.0035540314856916666, -0.024502873420715332, -0.022453198209404945, 0.027353905141353607, 0.006428809836506844, -0.003359719179570675, 0.010607182048261166, 0.00038865863461978734, -0.0452599935233593, 0.022148966789245605, 0.03253471851348877, -0.010782085359096527, -0.009291479364037514, -0.03214753419160843, 0.03571780398488045, -0.02755953185260296, 0.032849185168743134, -0.0019050040282309055, 0.06025419011712074, -0.0030677313916385174, 0.040181390941143036, 0.01171769481152296, 0.07736658304929733, 0.03659425303339958, 0.0029728924855589867, -0.015615196898579597, -0.019530819728970528, -0.008807061240077019, 0.017198612913489342, -0.01651916652917862, 0.014216303825378418, 0.018459618091583252, 0.02745840884745121, -0.012179072946310043, -0.07380537688732147, 0.034905944019556046, 0.05354422703385353, -0.0021159681491553783, -0.030457744374871254, -0.048669055104255676, -0.011535592377185822, -0.011984753422439098, -0.04675821214914322, 0.02914869226515293, 0.03762535750865936, -0.004022417590022087, 0.03167787566781044, 0.03275604918599129, -0.005063767544925213, -0.019080249592661858, -0.03472939878702164, 0.01716691628098488, 0.03855310007929802, -0.02406925894320011, -0.00680523132905364, 0.022081201896071434, 0.008955155499279499, 0.04356582835316658, 0.004657119978219271, 0.009794464334845543, -0.10190875828266144, 0.006582367233932018, 0.028474580496549606, 0.023537546396255493, -0.037564318627119064, -0.0017705324571579695, -0.017253102734684944, -0.01582888886332512, 0.07457850128412247, 0.016727525740861893, 0.0024411689955741167, -0.044625043869018555, -0.006764005869626999, -0.023593051359057426, -0.011000081896781921, -0.022215597331523895, 0.007551050744950771, -0.006479695904999971, -0.012397640384733677, -0.01540080364793539, -0.014673168770968914, -0.023115305230021477, -0.01149529218673706, 0.03763933107256889, 0.06504271924495697, -0.010618822649121284, -0.02451327070593834, 0.0030555776320397854, 0.04668741673231125, -0.007656205911189318, -0.0733095034956932, 0.008675714023411274, -0.006717170588672161, -0.008485501632094383, 0.0227504875510931, 0.013750600628554821, -0.03861456736922264, 0.04087087884545326, 0.015881601721048355, 0.0029885037802159786, -0.01014141459017992, 0.009743401780724525, 0.05432044342160225, 0.038243889808654785, 0.028698183596134186, 0.09024806320667267, 0.03763421252369881, -0.030022187158465385, -0.030556315556168556, -0.026979947462677956, 0.05726512894034386, -0.033396828919649124, -0.0464952252805233, 0.00031797573319636285, -0.027859322726726532, 0.012781905941665173, 0.020320801064372063, -0.022777127102017403, 0.036875855177640915, 0.012894921936094761, 0.0014145440654829144, 0.01928708888590336, 0.003131709061563015, 0.013958350755274296, -0.019083991646766663, -0.014600998722016811, -0.008180155418813229, -0.0009232229203917086, -0.05270398408174515, 0.0008666916401125491, -0.0011387114645913243, 0.02991117164492607, 0.008645827881991863, -0.04758074879646301, -0.027335725724697113, -0.05056361109018326, -0.005989417899399996, 0.011444316245615482, -0.011696802452206612, 0.04094766080379486, -0.03692914545536041, 0.02659505233168602, 0.0078258216381073, -0.05891621485352516, -0.023861190304160118, 0.027760688215494156, -0.025550084188580513, 0.03682674840092659, -0.046152714639902115, 0.061985958367586136, -0.0006085946806706488, -0.009084483608603477, -0.07902146875858307, -0.028601815924048424, 0.033770132809877396, 0.027978483587503433, -0.004089684691280127, -0.031195925548672676, 0.017864538356661797, -0.001769658992998302, -0.03597825765609741, -0.013338389806449413, 0.06011762097477913, -0.016179069876670837, -0.015628542751073837, -0.008902313187718391, 0.009848840534687042, 0.07537957280874252, -0.002470681443810463, -0.021104665473103523, 0.028233317658305168, -0.022671394050121307, -0.0065643978305161, 0.0007788260700181127, 0.035069238394498825, -0.036536142230033875, 0.01498557347804308, -0.014206761494278908, -0.031947873532772064, 0.03525499999523163, -0.0229780450463295, -0.030577560886740685, 0.01712431013584137, -0.0033453619107604027, 0.022298188880085945, -0.027410972863435745, 0.02054222859442234, -0.020321384072303772, 0.03941226378083229, -0.01822085864841938, -0.036214862018823624, -0.036379601806402206, 0.021932465955615044, 0.011186007410287857, 0.03753574192523956, -0.010284808464348316, 0.015773722901940346, 0.04465249180793762, 0.01563449390232563, 0.009300834499299526, -0.023680955171585083, -0.004903443623334169, -0.0008947195019572973, -0.0016655097715556622, 0.0009020082652568817, 0.03478188440203667, 0.014656635001301765, -0.006165473256260157, -0.019760655239224434, -0.04630524665117264, -0.03552746772766113, 0.08669620007276535, -0.007160261273384094, 0.04651893302798271, 0.020365092903375626, 0.009424317628145218, -0.014172490686178207, -0.03171584755182266, -0.013596945442259312, 0.009504199959337711, 0.005223492160439491, 0.052487459033727646, 0.010454440489411354, 0.024061935022473335, 0.05069480091333389, 0.027576547116041183, -0.022227510809898376, 0.04360011965036392, -0.008624793030321598, 0.03293678164482117, 0.005334066692739725, 0.017104588449001312, -0.030401337891817093, 0.03374357894062996, -0.035947494208812714, 0.01475649792701006, -0.035031918436288834, -0.032955024391412735, 0.021538779139518738, -0.004515510052442551, -0.0029449337162077427, -0.060920435935258865, -0.02193194068968296, -0.024954423308372498, 0.0164614487439394, -0.004461589735001326, 0.0027708353009074926, 0.030247054994106293, -0.011518118903040886, 0.0027806060388684273, -0.02215818502008915, 0.009186110459268093, -0.014447658322751522, -0.08735331147909164, -0.03491118550300598, -0.03207279369235039, -0.01158231496810913, 0.013162082061171532, 0.047455985099077225, -0.031847033649683, 0.016859637573361397, -0.026910359039902687, 0.050945620983839035, 0.004126987885683775, 0.016278432682156563, -0.003488111076876521, 0.073496013879776, 0.0018016123212873936, 0.002501147799193859, -0.02802017331123352, 0.01201148796826601, 0.10110629349946976, 0.03368963673710823, 0.04479748010635376, -0.05585195869207382, -0.01968473382294178, -0.010015085339546204, 0.0006024242611601949, -0.03774041682481766, 0.028847254812717438, -0.004223904572427273, -0.011752407066524029, 0.005483007989823818, 0.09681960940361023, 0.02828853763639927, -0.025799265131354332, 0.04602401331067085, -0.0004035483580082655, -0.013603144325315952, 0.031593482941389084, 0.012788918800652027, -0.0055088805966079235, 0.010825670324265957, -0.04719923809170723, 0.03168386220932007, -0.010378322564065456, -0.025408510118722916, -0.06868112087249756, -0.019365109503269196, -0.0067650796845555305, 0.027163520455360413, -0.026869909837841988, -0.0016506249085068703, 0.04297332093119621, 0.012427541427314281, -0.022648075595498085, -0.024775078520178795, 0.019123276695609093, -0.030383212491869926, -0.008640025742352009, 0.005149650387465954, 0.013155151158571243, 0.0072006955742836, 0.00021393421047832817, -0.0303010493516922, -0.036738067865371704, -0.013432786799967289, -0.01143055409193039, 0.013789528049528599, 0.0008605292532593012, -0.013175803236663342, -0.013581275939941406, -0.004030031617730856, -0.041002675890922546, -0.03759658336639404, 0.0032460240181535482, -0.03330228477716446, 0.019100267440080643, -0.02515466883778572, -0.02619139291346073, -0.03212932124733925, 0.01824190653860569, -0.0336759015917778, 0.02826039493083954, 0.0060098543763160706, -0.052206143736839294, -0.016552703455090523, -0.016755642369389534, 0.028177831321954727, -0.014835381880402565, -0.06259101629257202, 0.03315345197916031, -0.01251087337732315, -0.03208492696285248, -0.028726225718855858, 0.006073091644793749, -0.01446213386952877, 0.040125567466020584, 0.005585637874901295, -0.009512966498732567, 0.0151757737621665, -0.11297117173671722, 0.003217171411961317, 0.008268694393336773, -0.009849227033555508, -0.024935025721788406, 0.013734804466366768, 0.04361956566572189, 0.046733029186725616, -0.010273223742842674, 0.02369714342057705, -0.005807314999401569, 0.05348878726363182, 0.048687372356653214, -0.06411882489919662, 0.02096494846045971, 0.03010225109755993, 0.007947581820189953, -0.013282387517392635, -0.02903529815375805, 0.060650646686553955, 0.052147217094898224, 0.055935587733983994, -0.037550006061792374, 0.04574873670935631, -0.02065240405499935, 0.006021471228450537, -0.039118047803640366, -0.032815150916576385, 0.004825536627322435, 0.014738955534994602, 0.024876028299331665, -0.042621321976184845, -0.031415071338415146, -0.029849158599972725, -0.04357106238603592, 0.03690660744905472, -0.008676803670823574, -0.025964774191379547, 0.013914164155721664, -0.014813994988799095, -0.00583933899179101, -0.022775353863835335, -0.008717085234820843, 0.003587171668186784, 0.01630798541009426, -0.002631760435178876, 0.00804608128964901, -0.025733690708875656, 0.005507434718310833, -0.006856916006654501, 0.008738743141293526, 0.04467233642935753, 0.024371718987822533, 0.03745327144861221, 0.011433068662881851, 0.00017099970136769116, -0.0329354889690876, -0.0031154996249824762, -0.043745316565036774, 0.006431702524423599, 0.08195855468511581, -0.04250780865550041, -0.022646695375442505, -0.008015187457203865, 0.006322675850242376, 0.006502536591142416, 0.011943795718252659, 0.006199326831847429, 0.023232288658618927, 0.03905811905860901, -0.0313388854265213, 0.002643241547048092, -0.02034495212137699, -0.04387754946947098, -0.03199097141623497, 0.011886914260685444, 0.008809009566903114, 0.006000776309520006, -0.016822315752506256, 0.034374482929706573, 0.04047902673482895, -0.007669838145375252, 0.01714359223842621, 0.023814573884010315, -0.012591582722961903, 0.02447563037276268, 0.05657212808728218, 0.024551212787628174, 0.024333328008651733, 0.019398393109440804, -0.004788243677467108, 0.054001182317733765, -0.02045854926109314, 0.003645967924967408, -0.08956877142190933, -0.04582451656460762, 0.015501247718930244, -0.022490782663226128, 0.055811140686273575, -0.05202033743262291, 0.011287330649793148, 0.01364117581397295, -0.0695454403758049, 0.005778572987765074, -0.028534656390547752, -0.07023760676383972, -0.026681391522288322, 0.0023096646182239056, 0.03174448385834694, 0.000872451753821224, 0.025799985975027084, 0.030716152861714363, 0.02827868051826954, 0.0022715837694704533, -0.002073068870231509, -0.010735169053077698, -0.04185459017753601, -0.010137786157429218, 0.009532397612929344, -0.0751771479845047, 0.017824159935116768, -0.042620718479156494, -0.02579427883028984, 0.02114271931350231, -0.027575021609663963, -0.006989542860537767, -0.02809014916419983, 0.037410520017147064, -0.01719055324792862, 0.03869619965553284, 0.021898996084928513, -0.009544827975332737, -0.03045930527150631, 0.029193928465247154, 0.007776666898280382, 0.025291942059993744, -0.026594646275043488, -0.02397673949599266, 0.02426443062722683, 0.007663033436983824, -0.04736411198973656, 0.022426053881645203, 0.0030758162029087543, -0.05695631355047226, -0.005950863007456064, -0.02253449708223343, 0.017839305102825165, -0.04265465959906578, 0.040790803730487823, -0.029429301619529724, 0.008964085951447487, 0.013245362788438797, 0.0306412186473608, -0.023694518953561783, 0.00012737927318084985, -0.03480502963066101, -0.043836385011672974, 0.013036253862082958, 0.00495065888389945, -0.05582508444786072, -0.05755892023444176, -0.0035019959323108196, 0.026599308475852013, -0.02155480347573757, 0.013020103797316551, -0.033272091299295425, -0.01249273307621479, 0.04333724454045296, 0.004376501310616732, 0.024364793673157692, -0.004058375023305416, -0.030216030776500702, -0.010525289922952652, -0.035154394805431366, 0.051313553005456924, 0.02236965298652649, -0.011316663585603237, -0.024204039946198463, 0.005049819126725197, -0.033470623195171356, -0.029269477352499962, 0.066177137196064, -0.020980950444936752, 0.005000174045562744, -0.012386172078549862, -0.016352007165551186, 0.013518042862415314, -0.037602201104164124, 0.014094134792685509, -0.02974269911646843, -0.04890291392803192, -0.03017772175371647, -0.01110011525452137, -0.02600347064435482, 0.00016790903464425355, -0.021301306784152985, -0.02935326099395752, 0.037496283650398254, 0.012224217876791954, 0.026676351204514503, 0.04593754559755325, 0.030150044709444046, -0.03168895095586777, 0.032184381037950516, -0.03505587577819824, -0.02242564596235752, 0.014330676756799221, 0.019149700179696083, -0.06274352222681046, -0.02418692037463188, -0.04161510616540909, -0.04099424555897713, -0.019386228173971176, 0.025125516578555107, -0.0052284193225204945, -0.03317489102482796, -0.017502883449196815, 0.05054308474063873, -0.032714951783418655, 0.0024240247439593077, 0.031013933941721916, 0.01908540539443493, 0.03171867877244949, 0.00020924265845678747, -0.03455677628517151, 0.0016207218868657947, 0.010605111718177795, 0.035702966153621674, 0.009733224287629128, 0.05101805925369263, 0.005124932155013084, -0.004873964004218578, 0.010961988009512424, -0.0037226572167128325, 0.050215113908052444, 0.018245628103613853, 0.0642651915550232, 0.00015657524636480957, -0.03287900984287262, -0.030052220448851585, -0.012602610513567924, 0.01116667315363884, 0.02278890460729599, -0.027677234262228012, 0.08629263192415237, -0.028224222362041473, 0.017092524096369743, -0.030870772898197174, -0.02668505534529686, -0.010074850171804428, -0.04228898137807846, 0.0370255783200264, -0.0036972155794501305, -0.01715492270886898, -0.028346866369247437, -0.0038057160563766956, 0.025283267721533775, 0.02712402492761612, -0.051194872707128525, 0.021158820018172264, -0.013658424839377403, 0.000006262905117182527, -0.02808164618909359, 0.0037679520901292562, -0.033856168389320374, -0.008250557817518711, 0.006702674552798271, 0.06311748176813126, 0.031151119619607925, 0.03277021646499634, -0.014453397132456303, -0.003723693313077092, 0.054064396768808365, -0.08189630508422852, -0.02701285295188427, -0.028135942295193672, -0.02674565464258194, -0.027225187048316002, -0.024809889495372772 ]
<p>I have a classification problem with two classes working on nominal data. I want to apply <a href="http://www.jair.org/media/953/live-953-2037-jair.pdf" rel="nofollow">SMOTE-N</a> to deal with imbalanced data. However, it is not clear to me how to use SMOTE-N for generating N synthetic data for each feature vector in the minority class. SMOTE-N uses a modified version of the value difference metric (VDM) to find the k-nearest neighbors for each feature vector in the minority class and then the new minority class feature vector is generated by creating new set feature values by taking the majority vote of the feature vector in consideration and its k nearest neighbors (k-nn). But, how is this process repeated to generate multiple synthetic feature vectors for each feature vector in the minority class? The way the algorithm is stated, it seems that one feature vector from the minority class can generate only one synthetic feature vector (using its K-nn)?</p>
36,467
[ -0.036189232021570206, -0.0015854438534006476, 0.0016223597340285778, -0.0039515187963843346, 0.005568400025367737, 0.02549622766673565, -0.018482625484466553, -0.027844896540045738, 0.02809155359864235, -0.010305564850568771, 0.020303158089518547, 0.027094397693872452, 0.06456629186868668, -0.0012333444319665432, -0.018307045102119446, -0.004068104084581137, -0.013492651283740997, 0.007216418161988258, -0.010043890215456486, -0.0557645708322525, -0.005551998969167471, 0.023201098665595055, 0.023779084905982018, -0.042419712990522385, 0.0012901586014777422, 0.029314382001757622, 0.02152458392083645, 0.017719365656375885, 0.06245123967528343, 0.004921360407024622, -0.016080401837825775, -0.006340999621897936, -0.007433759979903698, 0.020868491381406784, -0.012209635227918625, 0.0076567730866372585, -0.026724986732006073, -0.006788390222936869, -0.011530406773090363, -0.0021012211218476295, 0.0026748767122626305, -0.020856531336903572, -0.020352287217974663, 0.04211440682411194, -0.008843096904456615, 0.0173027440905571, -0.002677755896002054, -0.005674042273312807, 0.0056582605466246605, -0.04174937307834625, 0.09792164713144302, 0.02558734640479088, 0.02303045615553856, 0.058051202446222305, -0.005328802391886711, 0.027717912569642067, 0.05603007599711418, 0.06074149161577225, -0.027938799932599068, 0.012460811994969845, -0.008662805892527103, -0.04461280256509781, -0.008971834555268288, -0.00912951584905386, -0.047138407826423645, 0.025174984708428383, -0.002322897780686617, 0.002909525763243437, 0.012364199385046959, -0.02566978521645069, 0.02598181739449501, -0.006478391122072935, 0.005318858195096254, -0.044175565242767334, 0.011550567112863064, -0.028677718713879585, 0.018228400498628616, 0.01826361007988453, 0.04528289660811424, -0.009693332947790623, 0.020707515999674797, 0.011415117420256138, -0.0013682054122909904, 0.018750052899122238, 0.03304656594991684, -0.03996366262435913, 0.07296207547187805, -0.018691524863243103, 0.050482288002967834, 0.040303632616996765, -0.018533388152718544, -0.00787329487502575, 0.0382712297141552, -0.01515820249915123, -0.054310958832502365, 0.01456331368535757, -0.006352086551487446, 0.03335382416844368, 0.014552644453942776, -0.0350804328918457, -0.00034777470864355564, -0.02468704804778099, -0.0006520828464999795, 0.013467827811837196, -0.04385550692677498, -0.000610086543019861, -0.01950664632022381, -0.0065658423118293285, -0.005179849453270435, 0.03826469928026199, -0.011660218238830566, 0.019244035705924034, -0.02230202965438366, -0.014846955426037312, 0.015483710914850235, -0.008853739127516747, -0.0012530229287222028, -0.023728448897600174, 0.02098703198134899, 0.07867348194122314, 0.034776560962200165, -0.020981494337320328, 0.042593490332365036, -0.04251273348927498, -0.054860420525074005, 0.0030647823587059975, -0.004610325675457716, -0.02798566408455372, -0.012934579513967037, 0.02248002216219902, -0.03081297129392624, -0.04956863075494766, 0.03977816551923752, -0.006593223661184311, 0.017043277621269226, -0.007932097651064396, -0.08986175805330276, -0.03353288397192955, 0.012170763686299324, -0.04163024201989174, 0.02925398200750351, -0.060900356620550156, 0.0037676591891795397, 0.0015355413779616356, 0.05083262547850609, 0.051488496363162994, 0.03553717955946922, 0.04862689971923828, 0.03333358094096184, 0.023923717439174652, -0.01441514864563942, -0.019647182896733284, -0.030762653797864914, 0.0032124463468790054, -0.036426424980163574, -0.06625637412071228, 0.05724315717816353, 0.020314186811447144, -0.028021492063999176, 0.0017112960340455174, 0.015947427600622177, 0.0051012104377150536, 0.006721477024257183, 0.03627258166670799, 0.04579351097345352, -0.0008705822983756661, 0.019936878234148026, 0.006785645615309477, 0.0348176434636116, 0.013250424526631832, -0.02498101443052292, 0.015838345512747765, 0.016733728349208832, 0.06466231495141983, 0.031011858955025673, 0.012470370158553123, 0.008721088990569115, -0.01474052108824253, 0.032164499163627625, -0.006357189267873764, 0.0012267613783478737, -0.03960208594799042, 0.007393009029328823, 0.019856955856084824, -0.004342160187661648, 0.026803385466337204, -0.02514706738293171, -0.010236674919724464, 0.031902432441711426, -0.029460515826940536, -0.027019932866096497, -0.043251000344753265, -0.023694343864917755, -0.01972154900431633, -0.07178118824958801, -0.0152775589376688, 0.02827499248087406, 0.042511120438575745, -0.012527613900601864, -0.028631800785660744, -0.028906362131237984, -0.03744138032197952, 0.05715871602296829, -0.02578730136156082, -0.03325273096561432, 0.03380957245826721, -0.007532509509474039, -0.0014549478655681014, 0.05808393284678459, -0.03225916996598244, -0.05260305851697922, 0.01840621791779995, -0.0088261179625988, 0.0006042602472007275, -0.020302141085267067, -0.020967762917280197, 0.020969059318304062, 0.03442327305674553, 0.009025479666888714, 0.029910292476415634, -0.044567566365003586, 0.08436150848865509, 0.08423619717359543, 0.009831452742218971, 0.010946288704872131, 0.007681434042751789, -0.010359873995184898, 0.004097591154277325, -0.03800112009048462, -0.024064645171165466, -0.04700984060764313, -0.03811021149158478, 0.04020712897181511, -0.021480347961187363, -0.06631337851285934, 0.047457221895456314, 0.06866679340600967, 0.004961137659847736, 0.013565843924880028, 0.016716698184609413, -0.03767525032162666, 0.032041165977716446, 0.02228953130543232, 0.02168303355574608, 0.021113278344273567, -0.028832269832491875, 0.017195234075188637, 0.0108826644718647, 0.006339623127132654, 0.01518039871007204, -0.023601990193128586, 0.08422769606113434, -0.02801569737493992, 0.020538652315735817, 0.006267413031309843, -0.036666106432676315, 0.013282888568937778, -0.019487641751766205, -0.02594943717122078, 0.05177789926528931, 0.0033881012350320816, -0.001818582764826715, 0.018609805032610893, -0.006964325439184904, 0.03191245719790459, 0.05852138623595238, 0.011157765984535217, 0.015345756895840168, 0.012537791393697262, -0.06577613204717636, 0.0058069983497262, -0.019293641671538353, -0.0490187406539917, -0.018213849514722824, 0.015253474935889244, 0.04809495434165001, -0.035747211426496506, 0.02017199993133545, -0.02179250679910183, -0.005584158468991518, 0.008158457465469837, -0.020220788195729256, 0.024217814207077026, -0.010799871757626534, -0.060907281935214996, 0.0023408399429172277, -0.0003063190961256623, -0.025338729843497276, 0.0031007484067231417, 0.006283850409090519, -0.023102398961782455, -0.0001151537144323811, -0.0028289409819990396, -0.06528737396001816, -0.017011798918247223, -0.02734101004898548, 0.006822284776717424, -0.021046990528702736, -0.004311283119022846, 0.03279092535376549, 0.0338018536567688, -0.035049114376306534, 0.026164855808019638, -0.0030964117031544447, -0.014239821583032608, -0.041609443724155426, -0.014271307736635208, 0.020993953570723534, -0.035607680678367615, -0.0042058550752699375, 0.044597260653972626, -0.03825611621141434, 0.02990054525434971, -0.07147473841905594, -0.058126311749219894, 0.03724294528365135, 0.011637351475656033, 0.05353495851159096, 0.05259161815047264, -0.01304667815566063, 0.0916374996304512, 0.020329905673861504, -0.028726128861308098, -0.024725250899791718, 0.019225604832172394, -0.013983632437884808, -0.038873594254255295, -0.02573322504758835, 0.009907107800245285, 0.008339468389749527, 0.032950498163700104, 0.03985556587576866, -0.00348874949850142, 0.08166152238845825, -0.04517817869782448, -0.02363545075058937, 0.01970527693629265, 0.02691313438117504, 0.018633322790265083, 0.041300058364868164, 0.013177920132875443, -0.015641920268535614, -0.01711609773337841, 0.0033511051442474127, 0.0186753012239933, -0.03223258629441261, -0.03422849252820015, -0.0045962342992424965, -0.023199331015348434, -0.006536670029163361, -0.03933405503630638, 0.008888713084161282, -0.007216403726488352, -0.011347495950758457, -0.012410870753228664, 0.03151527792215347, 0.03493674471974373, -0.07544615864753723, -0.022504085674881935, 0.05193474143743515, 0.040268637239933014, 0.01956966333091259, -0.019167136400938034, 0.009915212169289589, -0.01388598047196865, 0.007690166588872671, -0.0036333859898149967, 0.0324859544634819, -0.012876498512923717, 0.03306145593523979, 0.030606014654040337, 0.04059428721666336, -0.0311264730989933, 0.048015471547842026, -0.02231009677052498, -0.02105194702744484, -0.03664783015847206, 0.02323482558131218, -0.03017202764749527, 0.044991862028837204, 0.03532681241631508, -0.0033509444911032915, 0.0008353732991963625, 0.006928366608917713, -0.0358896404504776, 0.005996054969727993, -0.012753148563206196, -0.007999339140951633, 0.006006947718560696, -0.01935374177992344, 0.022519277408719063, -0.003882001154124737, -0.043511901050806046, 0.00671924976631999, 0.013398990035057068, -0.06571142375469208, 0.005538993049412966, -0.0323762409389019, 0.010595164261758327, -0.020350381731987, 0.05764170363545418, 0.02874625474214554, -0.03628234565258026, 0.011785956099629402, 0.03920493274927139, 0.03528697043657303, 0.011705907993018627, -0.004331097938120365, 0.01643270067870617, -0.008943263441324234, 0.030781734734773636, 0.016115589067339897, 0.024041002616286278, -0.04163895174860954, 0.003308719489723444, 0.004535499960184097, 0.08025066554546356, 0.077987901866436, -0.014707682654261589, -0.03797020763158798, -0.039859168231487274, -0.011466837488114834, -0.01705659180879593, 0.03513266146183014, 0.008674024604260921, 0.019245436415076256, 0.05032575502991676, 0.049041882157325745, -0.07160349190235138, 0.026159705594182014, 0.08184835314750671, 0.017664466053247452, -0.013441767543554306, -0.042610786855220795, 0.04041079804301262, 0.012838023714721203, -0.03303330019116402, 0.043797507882118225, 0.01462196372449398, 0.02815580554306507, 0.01936701126396656, 0.04756021872162819, -0.026746537536382675, -0.035221777856349945, -0.0016719045815989375, 0.026731813326478004, 0.01565277762711048, -0.0029521428514271975, -0.00919929426163435, -0.0051818229258060455, 0.06636299937963486, 0.045171674340963364, -0.008030476979911327, -0.009803416207432747, -0.10373442620038986, 0.00033205156796611845, 0.02269728295505047, 0.03188629820942879, -0.014342263340950012, -0.02415926568210125, -0.051034871488809586, 0.011699941009283066, 0.02925916574895382, -0.05677111819386482, 0.03971446305513382, 0.004024171270430088, -0.009872153401374817, -0.03520933538675308, 0.032762784510850906, -0.0019645618740469217, 0.015507551841437817, -0.02550273947417736, 0.07355286180973053, 0.01127270981669426, -0.027276773005723953, 0.0011117190588265657, 0.013997881673276424, 0.01676374115049839, 0.051742661744356155, -0.013794236816465855, -0.005317270755767822, -0.010865540243685246, 0.01656213216483593, 0.002532285638153553, -0.03540069982409477, -0.0037973462603986263, 0.007263714913278818, -0.02104918472468853, 0.02539977990090847, -0.013476386666297913, -0.008501597680151463, 0.04952091723680496, 0.020782731473445892, 0.013542444445192814, -0.025662289932370186, -0.040200889110565186, -0.010354242287576199, 0.012131321243941784, -0.015277978964149952, 0.05422740429639816, -0.0038609784096479416, -0.010166452266275883, 0.01827359013259411, -0.010518906638026237, 0.008175057359039783, -0.04808814451098442, -0.0673261433839798, -0.015559975989162922, 0.005420506000518799, -0.012505143880844116, 0.02669098600745201, 0.011665434576570988, -0.005854366812855005, -0.0450129471719265, 0.027752557769417763, -0.018681904301047325, 0.01081094704568386, -0.010407926514744759, -0.03910689055919647, -0.025600280612707138, 0.04587007686495781, 0.015404321253299713, 0.003126829629763961, 0.04066331684589386, -0.025456920266151428, 0.009918068535625935, -0.004063063766807318, -0.055351369082927704, 0.008801007643342018, -0.0445859394967556, -0.018485667183995247, 0.015620567835867405, -0.037618085741996765, 0.0395304411649704, -0.019973551854491234, 0.04439655318856239, 0.0341111421585083, -0.05551868677139282, 0.012699601240456104, -0.024459613487124443, -0.013238922692835331, 0.023591719567775726, -0.02997567318379879, 0.03425213694572449, 0.010507362894713879, 0.012123136781156063, -0.07531892508268356, -0.01729467883706093, 0.02435118518769741, -0.0420541986823082, -0.034891288727521896, -0.02335348166525364, -0.008852713741362095, 0.00703537929803133, -0.025574028491973877, 0.029280170798301697, 0.0565066896378994, -0.02244146354496479, -0.05028710886836052, 0.004115811083465815, 0.0453147254884243, 0.040765855461359024, 0.0006900338339619339, 0.038814347237348557, 0.007744346279650927, -0.02122735232114792, -0.02149253524839878, 0.030367020517587662, 0.013066422194242477, -0.0387139692902565, 0.002373728435486555, -0.0392780676484108, 0.010499969124794006, 0.015543682500720024, -0.005755452439188957, 0.0183015838265419, -0.0029263889882713556, 0.011323456652462482, 0.005782565101981163, -0.04229395091533661, 0.002173289656639099, 0.023098710924386978, 0.006647867616266012, -0.056647174060344696, 0.037423714995384216, 0.019823361188173294, 0.013985716737806797, 0.02070133201777935, 0.01514344196766615, 0.02417423389852047, 0.011266806162893772, 0.05183269456028938, -0.04177058860659599, -0.006651820614933968, -0.018152613192796707, -0.055413950234651566, 0.0289627593010664, 0.022358037531375885, -0.008351804688572884, -0.012489343993365765, 0.01563187874853611, -0.027348484843969345, -0.022860335186123848, -0.021955322474241257, 0.014815053902566433, 0.0688665583729744, -0.028688786551356316, 0.06609804928302765, 0.026006978005170822, 0.016303349286317825, 0.02144952490925789, -0.04304784536361694, -0.0002006510621868074, -0.006514689419418573, -0.012816172093153, 0.055426955223083496, 0.028942691162228584, -0.008487887680530548, 0.018820665776729584, 0.04822058603167534, 0.037467487156391144, 0.03237473964691162, 0.008397293277084827, 0.03853948786854744, -0.008880840614438057, 0.011107085272669792, -0.04905657470226288, 0.025961291044950485, -0.010483307763934135, 0.02819284237921238, 0.00006314679922070354, -0.04276752844452858, 0.020167700946331024, 0.010837160982191563, 0.0564742237329483, -0.06053890287876129, -0.016673119738698006, -0.06569509953260422, 0.042525019496679306, -0.004959146026521921, 0.00005276022420730442, 0.03623417764902115, 0.030023418366909027, 0.004970329813659191, 0.0016017634188756347, -0.00027399056125432253, -0.029703879728913307, -0.0656951367855072, -0.05616310238838196, -0.03638167679309845, -0.045041054487228394, 0.01320478692650795, -0.009319297969341278, -0.052972495555877686, 0.05707671493291855, -0.0008830950246192515, 0.0698007270693779, -0.054160457104444504, 0.024459902197122574, 0.01901870407164097, 0.04634478688240051, 0.0036775183398276567, 0.0726533755660057, -0.0017216434935107827, -0.0095131304115057, 0.12638835608959198, 0.07178899645805359, 0.041996050626039505, -0.06857627630233765, 0.005361583549529314, -0.02288803830742836, -0.02671677991747856, -0.008047148585319519, 0.03126298263669014, 0.02688654325902462, -0.009540459141135216, 0.014935984276235104, 0.007927590049803257, 0.027521587908267975, -0.010672192089259624, 0.05860411003232002, -0.025022517889738083, -0.014698157086968422, 0.027004651725292206, -0.011297199875116348, -0.01364821381866932, -0.027293333783745766, -0.04281511530280113, 0.025339627638459206, 0.0020019037183374166, -0.040793027728796005, -0.01485396921634674, -0.0122149009257555, 0.024260608479380608, -0.00007486412505386397, 0.009450102224946022, 0.006255935877561569, 0.01369472499936819, 0.005256312899291515, 0.0035095922648906708, 0.00037833568057976663, -0.013698874972760677, -0.003940134309232235, 0.0007819674210622907, 0.023649686947464943, 0.0267611313611269, -0.02251138910651207, 0.013012245297431946, -0.0009711242164485157, -0.04398839920759201, 0.0007122160168364644, -0.029190504923462868, 0.0400250218808651, -0.0026835997123271227, -0.004440461751073599, -0.017622707411646843, -0.002172242384403944, 0.017786461859941483, -0.03245077282190323, -0.023050345480442047, 0.03959307074546814, 0.016741745173931122, -0.002748423721641302, -0.03150505572557449, -0.028363224118947983, 0.04347528889775276, -0.019202154129743576, 0.04666238650679588, -0.007734119892120361, -0.020292654633522034, -0.0260994303971529, -0.035639576613903046, 0.0024467511102557182, 0.006352468393743038, -0.01080278865993023, -0.025311708450317383, -0.017475657165050507, -0.0006398833938874304, -0.033781521022319794, -0.04896257817745209, -0.021730920299887657, -0.0034530539996922016, -0.02699279598891735, -0.03192052245140076, -0.016238633543252945, -0.022101912647485733, 0.00163601478561759, -0.008204827085137367, -0.008077112026512623, -0.04542238637804985, 0.017353219911456108, 0.009533907286822796, 0.05413563549518585, 0.0007842868217267096, 0.03996244817972183, 0.02524898573756218, 0.034667059779167175, -0.001969984034076333, -0.04331190139055252, -0.005306566599756479, -0.005403038114309311, -0.053131550550460815, 0.01812378317117691, -0.05197155475616455, 0.060667045414447784, 0.020909655839204788, 0.024711325764656067, 0.014081982895731926, 0.03958165645599365, -0.021805955097079277, 0.02603793516755104, -0.008937912993133068, -0.039594825357198715, 0.04335953667759895, -0.026932120323181152, -0.0018792011542245746, -0.04032992571592331, -0.008450151421129704, -0.0011479412205517292, -0.049247317016124725, 0.02862798050045967, -0.013479840941727161, -0.05727164074778557, -0.0020682921167463064, -0.01336409617215395, 0.025535911321640015, -0.0023389856796711683, -0.036554086953401566, -0.0026198793202638626, 0.044606294482946396, -0.03520869091153145, 0.012337210588157177, -0.0042115175165236, -0.006659848615527153, -0.010796329006552696, 0.02517618052661419, 0.02018633298575878, 0.03496817126870155, 0.027550678700208664, -0.022482482716441154, 0.03589228540658951, 0.00562192453071475, 0.04393783584237099, -0.029720120131969452, -0.0196303091943264, 0.05771927535533905, -0.05107744410634041, -0.02506398782134056, -0.022515863180160522, 0.004495466127991676, 0.03549585118889809, 0.02186773717403412, 0.001580563373863697, -0.027508283033967018, 0.06470087915658951, -0.04193414747714996, -0.019301922991871834, -0.014345559291541576, -0.004798652604222298, -0.016156747937202454, -0.012565464712679386, -0.02103336900472641, 0.005349047482013702, -0.0015588634414598346, 0.02205907739698887, 0.03232770785689354, 0.0072243656031787395, -0.02551082894206047, 0.016856074333190918, -0.0006222602678462863, 0.04245305806398392, 0.02630372904241085, 0.021061716601252556, 0.012859641574323177, 0.03855755180120468, 0.025468427687883377, 0.007178356871008873, -0.014592590741813183, 0.005832340102642775, -0.07467850297689438, -0.032478392124176025, 0.002393808215856552, -0.019125979393720627, 0.03248050436377525, -0.03670426830649376, 0.02675440162420273, 0.011921619065105915, -0.04433748871088028, 0.013250934891402721, 0.003937695175409317, -0.030283011496067047, -0.03599000349640846, 0.034291114658117294, -0.0006113863782957196, -0.001533132279291749, 0.03930804133415222, -0.0017851917073130608, 0.036505263298749924, 0.009691564366221428, 0.02741398476064205, -0.03639457747340202, -0.05254703760147095, 0.001949321012943983, 0.000958807417191565, -0.0928870439529419, 0.05194498226046562, -0.01591825671494007, -0.03495216369628906, 0.013921648263931274, -0.02276156097650528, 0.012023355811834335, 0.06265867501497269, 0.04104895889759064, 0.042329899966716766, 0.03778906911611557, 0.028934035450220108, -0.002558452542871237, 0.009839363396167755, 0.002196182031184435, 0.04050573706626892, 0.0032741918694227934, -0.007902869954705238, -0.012195366434752941, 0.03489924967288971, -0.013075628317892551, 0.02290423959493637, -0.006134400609880686, -0.05923677608370781, -0.04598436504602432, -0.004049781244248152, -0.009196688421070576, 0.023372165858745575, -0.035779453814029694, 0.03229505941271782, -0.03057652898132801, -0.013794745318591595, 0.010406553745269775, 0.002700736513361335, 0.002795357024297118, 0.013254315592348576, -0.04336356744170189, -0.04195050895214081, -0.02750040404498577, 0.007170365657657385, 0.0056788381189107895, -0.05902381241321564, 0.021632330492138863, 0.041486382484436035, -0.01829824410378933, 0.003740031039342284, 0.007484644651412964, -0.01403719186782837, 0.06365249305963516, -0.036883287131786346, 0.05702168866991997, -0.0034253892954438925, -0.05004524812102318, -0.003982687834650278, -0.06777699291706085, 0.06932973116636276, 0.019482605159282684, -0.03897731006145477, -0.033298082649707794, -0.008039126172661781, -0.04024628549814224, -0.006032384932041168, 0.02515803650021553, 0.010659557767212391, 0.03940114378929138, -0.032457105815410614, 0.019905302673578262, 0.007674879394471645, -0.03556084632873535, 0.029783224686980247, -0.008713332004845142, -0.024020275101065636, 0.0005001398385502398, -0.024795271456241608, -0.015662943944334984, 0.0007892203284427524, -0.0032137392554432154, -0.02223806269466877, -0.013623874634504318, 0.04266280308365822, 0.002967547858133912, 0.0033812550827860832, -0.026181885972619057, 0.0081623625010252, 0.008785879239439964, -0.0201365165412426, 0.006454244256019592, 0.05971343815326691, 0.06887529790401459, -0.07016564160585403, 0.0003128988028038293, -0.051202401518821716, -0.021621331572532654, -0.007217559032142162, 0.00999936182051897, 0.02158970572054386, -0.07743746042251587, 0.00433237012475729, 0.017768502235412598, -0.021341640502214432, 0.014097136445343494, 0.034162163734436035, -0.024679381400346756, 0.01966557465493679, -0.016841009259223938, 0.028143974021077156, -0.007490897551178932, -0.02124706655740738, 0.03523513674736023, 0.002847300609573722, 0.02184987999498844, -0.00865962728857994, 0.013324478641152382, 0.008068845607340336, -0.021875647827982903, 0.055621057748794556, -0.0034997020848095417, 0.02029501646757126, 0.005796361248940229, -0.021966667845845222, 0.015936588868498802, -0.026028785854578018, 0.0073092118836939335, 0.008981684222817421, -0.005758481100201607, 0.07503125816583633, -0.03895752504467964, -0.002938993042334914, -0.03072555735707283, -0.0360134057700634, 0.005404249299317598, -0.005439457017928362, -0.026289012283086777, 0.029248716309666634, 0.018163427710533142, -0.006281713489443064, 0.019706441089510918, -0.010154077783226967, -0.009120799601078033, -0.06033707410097122, 0.04848954454064369, -0.020951276645064354, 0.02513362467288971, -0.0022956272587180138, -0.011632826179265976, -0.025136595591902733, -0.002666764659807086, -0.00353409955278039, 0.025726595893502235, 0.04274994134902954, -0.002128581516444683, -0.05628412589430809, -0.01622481644153595, 0.018113505095243454, -0.04729705676436424, -0.027518702670931816, -0.07761461287736893, -0.004360569640994072, 0.010816968977451324, -0.05320713296532631 ]
<p>I have got a set $\{Y_t\}$ of observations consisting of two subsets $\{Y_{t,1}\}$ and $\{Y_{t,2}\} \subset \{Y_t\}$ with $\{Y_{t,1}\} \sim \mathcal{N}(\mu_1,\sigma^2)$ and $\{Y_{t,2}\} \sim \mathcal{N}(\mu_2,\sigma^2)$ i.e. <em>different means but the same variance</em> (resulting from a regime switching model).</p> <p>I know the means and want to draw a sample of $\sigma^2$ in a step of a MCMC estimation. </p> <p>In the case of $\mu_1 = \mu_2$ I would have used the conjugate prior of the Inverse Gamma distribution (see [1], "Normal with known mean").</p> <p>Can I use a conjugate prior in the case of $\mu_1 \neq \mu_2$ as well? For example by setting $\beta = \beta_0 + \frac{1}{2}\sum_{i=0}^n(Y_i - \mu_{I_i})^2 $ ($I_i$ being the correct indices according to the observations)?</p> <p>Or will I have to use Metropolis-Hastings to get my sample of $\sigma^2$?</p> <p>Best, Matt</p> <p>[1] <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conjugate_prior#Continuous_distributions" rel="nofollow">http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conjugate_prior#Continuous_distributions</a></p>
73,917
[ -0.010197317227721214, -0.010810773819684982, 0.015107757411897182, -0.023109527304768562, 0.031953368335962296, 0.037675607949495316, -0.007639281917363405, -0.03820612281560898, 0.01064996886998415, -0.05201566964387894, 0.06052359193563461, 0.04542255401611328, 0.09267397224903107, 0.01618369109928608, 0.03854598104953766, -0.013211042620241642, -0.02695704624056816, -0.01135464757680893, -0.03963227570056915, -0.0015567251248285174, 0.016474727541208267, 0.01587076485157013, 0.042330168187618256, -0.009443461894989014, -0.05221376195549965, 0.019409246742725372, 0.0003009714710060507, 0.010919111780822277, -0.05366581305861473, 0.047028329223394394, -0.04195118322968483, -0.027979986742138863, 0.012510526925325394, 0.02372528612613678, -0.01027811411768198, -0.010586518794298172, -0.004326857626438141, -0.0357968807220459, 0.008937598206102848, 0.01839597336947918, -0.051308151334524155, 0.0022957909386605024, -0.03216339647769928, -0.005504806060343981, -0.0016831611283123493, 0.010222921147942543, 0.014870760962367058, -0.037536270916461945, 0.03379250317811966, -0.03306559473276138, 0.06653570383787155, -0.020207153633236885, 0.0004528081917669624, 0.06002925708889961, -0.011793777346611023, -0.024307703599333763, 0.02002970688045025, 0.050281766802072525, 0.017698045819997787, -0.0462997630238533, 0.012796515598893166, -0.005118040833622217, 0.023407595232129097, -0.014518411830067635, -0.03789651393890381, 0.028059257194399834, 0.01033056527376175, -0.014109917916357517, -0.005023842677474022, -0.02369776740670204, 0.028706388548016548, -0.010952791199088097, 0.028198467567563057, -0.0025738573167473078, 0.04565630853176117, -0.015189862810075283, 0.010392255149781704, 0.04805348068475723, 0.04359092190861702, 0.011498533189296722, 0.009645025245845318, -0.008168148808181286, 0.026092929765582085, 0.025400757789611816, -0.016965067014098167, -0.014795503579080105, 0.08342137187719345, -0.01958668790757656, 0.030887098982930183, 0.012959622777998447, -0.025577351450920105, 0.012403490953147411, 0.043337732553482056, -0.028697112575173378, -0.03648172318935394, 0.04135484620928764, -0.015530113130807877, 0.030585460364818573, -0.020458552986383438, -0.009013043716549873, -0.04706060141324997, -0.03904294967651367, 0.03160030394792557, 0.05324278399348259, 0.02468704618513584, -0.017448553815484047, -0.022388679906725883, 0.0061602164059877396, -0.029362572357058525, -0.03809823840856552, -0.04523598030209541, 0.04057952016592026, -0.009283746592700481, 0.02258053980767727, 0.025479964911937714, 0.0012245570542290807, -0.006498630624264479, -0.009091431275010109, 0.03750067204236984, 0.09545032680034637, 0.02537466026842594, -0.02117997780442238, -0.007909196428954601, -0.01813993789255619, -0.06881050020456314, -0.019563304260373116, 0.02343716472387314, -0.017015518620610237, -0.044796597212553024, 0.013703487813472748, 0.017749784514307976, -0.011750767007470131, 0.054954878985881805, 0.011650924570858479, 0.009817386977374554, 0.013035403564572334, -0.07344958186149597, -0.050268031656742096, 0.04474654421210289, -0.020252525806427002, 0.00834877509623766, -0.07387568801641464, 0.0012728089932352304, 0.052378032356500626, 0.03922469913959503, -0.011497458443045616, 0.029808154329657555, 0.002537169260904193, 0.04699981212615967, -0.003336922498419881, -0.04216499999165535, -0.04108228534460068, -0.0008528660982847214, -0.014030175283551216, -0.023570554330945015, -0.09518177807331085, 0.038554541766643524, 0.0341181680560112, 0.005701896268874407, -0.0019490093691274524, 0.04419378191232681, 0.005609044339507818, 0.00593843637034297, 0.008856307715177536, 0.004247923847287893, -0.04051816835999489, 0.06005092337727547, 0.03352634608745575, 0.030968135222792625, 0.0180087648332119, -0.007238390389829874, 0.015146937221288681, 0.002788815414533019, 0.039908166974782944, 0.0020121654961258173, -0.021578824147582054, -0.028382034972310066, 0.0033130254596471786, 0.006199023686349392, 0.018924042582511902, 0.003108758246526122, -0.013856534846127033, -0.05047338828444481, -0.03003820963203907, 0.05276064947247505, 0.021036366000771523, 0.013182483613491058, 0.010194731876254082, 0.016616275534033775, -0.06374019384384155, -0.01510530337691307, -0.04803553223609924, -0.022594621405005455, -0.026928797364234924, -0.02324381284415722, 0.04055602848529816, -0.017557168379426003, 0.02736961469054222, 0.028930606320500374, -0.03972594439983368, -0.0068643828853964806, -0.03951958194375038, 0.032983627170324326, -0.026005566120147705, 0.008187271654605865, 0.0493890717625618, 0.04672854393720627, -0.012890638783574104, 0.03917435184121132, -0.032994870096445084, -0.07297191768884659, -0.017697812989354134, -0.03424253687262535, 0.020787056535482407, 0.016883736476302147, -0.012727978639304638, 0.005627794656902552, -0.005588574334979057, -0.03535359725356102, 0.04069260507822037, -0.0737823098897934, 0.015335005708038807, 0.0929429829120636, 0.0062645310536026955, 0.018661823123693466, 0.048193369060754776, -0.0007513819728046656, 0.03289695456624031, 0.0016413534758612514, 0.01577708125114441, -0.053600117564201355, -0.010493735782802105, 0.04773877188563347, 0.056012559682130814, -0.04176126420497894, 0.005025660153478384, 0.02351701445877552, 0.03221236541867256, 0.01395019143819809, -0.007578526623547077, 0.017146244645118713, -0.0230176392942667, 0.013820959255099297, 0.017606837674975395, 0.005771293770521879, -0.020405394956469536, 0.014090191572904587, -0.020577380433678627, 0.014566105790436268, -0.026580622419714928, 0.0202257689088583, 0.03216816112399101, -0.016866756603121758, -0.028783738613128662, -0.031078366562724113, -0.029060794040560722, 0.03391273692250252, -0.000021029414710938, 0.005215397570282221, 0.0397421270608902, 0.012956020422279835, -0.03513554483652115, 0.012919994071125984, 0.017484495416283607, 0.018285641446709633, 0.03481486067175865, -0.02192244865000248, -0.017087988555431366, 0.01797453500330448, -0.04605623334646225, -0.012255801819264889, 0.003747350536286831, -0.031157856807112694, -0.01771443709731102, 0.0009027463966049254, -0.010753387585282326, -0.021138785406947136, -0.02317519672214985, -0.024513114243745804, -0.048429448157548904, -0.005737936124205589, 0.004230793099850416, 0.035958871245384216, 0.018810603767633438, -0.03049105778336525, 0.024686167016625404, -0.025343606248497963, 0.010564900003373623, -0.004560296889394522, -0.00177215994335711, -0.031798794865608215, 0.008609292097389698, 0.007828866131603718, -0.05747673287987709, -0.040834665298461914, -0.03714219480752945, 0.0004322206659708172, -0.01867813616991043, -0.026120740920305252, 0.026363825425505638, 0.05060728266835213, -0.051976483315229416, 0.0034598081838339567, -0.022006021812558174, -0.04745747148990631, -0.04902486503124237, -0.011311310343444347, 0.04044020175933838, -0.0017012382159009576, 0.02586270123720169, 0.07460399717092514, -0.031342942267656326, 0.005255671683698893, -0.06266587227582932, -0.07499564439058304, 0.039193615317344666, -0.0051218015141785145, -0.00862937606871128, 0.000846556038595736, -0.012405329383909702, 0.02931583672761917, 0.02267158031463623, -0.008319825865328312, 0.014319409616291523, 0.038032520562410355, 0.00554088456556201, -0.0485868901014328, 0.01359190046787262, 0.019181644544005394, -0.022186174988746643, 0.01803543232381344, 0.0069198003038764, 0.013156694360077381, 0.04550766944885254, 0.01500082015991211, 0.04417939856648445, 0.013326575979590416, 0.011283120140433311, 0.01847640424966812, 0.024467194452881813, -0.0023871995508670807, 0.003041614079847932, 0.014058317989110947, -0.015568308532238007, 0.031859640032052994, 0.030713029205799103, -0.037687815725803375, 0.015211150050163269, -0.022737285122275352, -0.012432900257408619, -0.06974973529577255, 0.04570809751749039, 0.022908566519618034, -0.03445371985435486, -0.020497512072324753, 0.010608742013573647, -0.009268105961382389, -0.019768638536334038, 0.001456920406781137, 0.061890359967947006, 0.04304702579975128, -0.02087274007499218, -0.0065412139520049095, -0.015365572646260262, -0.018381593748927116, 0.00040625070687383413, -0.054163672029972076, 0.011882648803293705, 0.02090468443930149, 0.04623574763536453, 0.03253207728266716, -0.01884288527071476, -0.005801591090857983, -0.029788333922624588, -0.11370760202407837, 0.029292460530996323, -0.03899804875254631, 0.05304596573114395, 0.005819106940180063, 0.026401272043585777, -0.004614543169736862, 0.036414582282304764, -0.018581043928861618, -0.007751945871859789, -0.07580528408288956, 0.011920330114662647, 0.013479664921760559, -0.013170203194022179, 0.0001739103754516691, -0.025779850780963898, 0.058992285281419754, -0.010572172701358795, 0.02344682812690735, 0.001709687290713191, 0.005844085942953825, -0.05373941734433174, 0.004649924114346504, -0.061063166707754135, -0.00003376799213583581, 0.020860077813267708, 0.026908261701464653, 0.003645124612376094, -0.039212875068187714, 0.014758306555449963, 0.023156719282269478, -0.0030018677935004234, -0.007322898134589195, -0.025634219869971275, 0.04715107008814812, -0.005081802140921354, 0.012990112416446209, 0.039143774658441544, 0.048507578670978546, -0.013670146465301514, 0.044192198663949966, 0.02913963608443737, 0.05518965423107147, 0.035008255392313004, 0.0023539471440017223, -0.013702530413866043, -0.011996682733297348, -0.024853169918060303, 0.01943817175924778, 0.020770937204360962, 0.01258534099906683, -0.018426906317472458, 0.05504278466105461, -0.000252152414759621, -0.021208634600043297, 0.04318619146943092, 0.056919146329164505, -0.00508250342682004, 0.024533431977033615, -0.032513100653886795, -0.01899835467338562, -0.0025602662935853004, 0.009802129119634628, 0.035365015268325806, 0.03288087621331215, -0.03317682817578316, 0.018111757934093475, 0.04757992550730705, 0.02002990059554577, -0.007370315957814455, 0.03609466552734375, 0.05743842571973801, 0.0655861645936966, 0.04175341874361038, -0.030278978869318962, 0.0014527991879731417, 0.008951445110142231, 0.03263620659708977, 0.018276115879416466, -0.02966131642460823, -0.10385715961456299, -0.023742079734802246, 0.008635503239929676, 0.018885692581534386, -0.027391577139496803, -0.010632561519742012, -0.05876140668988228, -0.02734096720814705, 0.027568479999899864, -0.008614884689450264, 0.03435799852013588, -0.04670485109090805, -0.01688784919679165, 0.023949751630425453, -0.04078537970781326, -0.034469541162252426, 0.024189690127968788, 0.008949666284024715, 0.014720245264470577, -0.023324936628341675, 0.016140373423695564, -0.03819715976715088, 0.0037362216971814632, -0.013290824368596077, 0.06684799492359161, -0.039664942771196365, 0.0038238863926380873, 0.0021627384703606367, 0.019069306552410126, 0.0025073932483792305, -0.06521105021238327, 0.01337767019867897, 0.011996920220553875, -0.01755041442811489, 0.01720949448645115, -0.009188671596348286, -0.026844285428524017, 0.034505389630794525, 0.02808966115117073, -0.018003370612859726, 0.030955631285905838, 0.0024918944109231234, 0.04958765581250191, 0.02463524229824543, 0.00729008112102747, 0.061559926718473434, 0.024344272911548615, 0.0418359749019146, 0.01286148838698864, -0.025548910722136497, 0.016452673822641373, -0.027878785505890846, 0.029996739700436592, -0.028752455487847328, -0.016292043030261993, -0.015858113765716553, 0.029257213696837425, -0.037653129547834396, 0.05790170654654503, 0.016269151121377945, -0.03825495019555092, 0.012345421127974987, 0.034346841275691986, 0.0217807088047266, -0.027409739792346954, -0.02016047202050686, 0.012703175656497478, -0.01570439152419567, -0.01114194467663765, 0.04971130192279816, -0.015613262541592121, -0.0072517311200499535, -0.008643792942166328, -0.025117792189121246, 0.019982613623142242, -0.02943701483309269, 0.021474262699484825, 0.0023719649761915207, -0.002170201390981674, 0.03503389656543732, 0.012035170570015907, 0.04126276448369026, 0.002231206279247999, -0.01752764917910099, -0.0012711978051811457, 0.012622336857020855, -0.012722332030534744, -0.032922569662332535, -0.0626741498708725, 0.03376692533493042, 0.009546457789838314, 0.026663951575756073, -0.05520002543926239, -0.06278010457754135, 0.013879528269171715, -0.02215125598013401, -0.0053305127657949924, -0.02214198186993599, 0.0424547903239727, -0.005787229165434837, -0.04371381923556328, -0.030880432575941086, 0.04690135642886162, -0.0010054989252239466, -0.0691341757774353, -0.023455262184143066, 0.0840572714805603, 0.041448116302490234, 0.00827209185808897, -0.023774510249495506, 0.03858846798539162, -0.004815724212676287, -0.007430487312376499, 0.025241855531930923, 0.020335182547569275, -0.007460801396518946, 0.0035980879329144955, -0.01345425471663475, -0.012309900484979153, 0.037574585527181625, -0.024637090042233467, -0.03333644941449165, 0.07472493499517441, 0.020764779299497604, 0.011153040453791618, -0.039389193058013916, -0.05447232723236084, -0.026491276919841766, 0.02644316852092743, -0.0526365227997303, -0.021912958472967148, -0.007384737022221088, -0.02700570598244667, 0.026237929239869118, 0.00560351787135005, -0.023771455511450768, 0.026728712022304535, 0.0733582153916359, -0.025772029533982277, 0.004142749588936567, -0.0013749210629612207, -0.003352947300300002, 0.024405475705862045, 0.007705869153141975, -0.004340543411672115, 0.013214261271059513, -0.002278145868331194, -0.047851886600255966, 0.008031428791582584, -0.04831288754940033, 0.023238161578774452, 0.0622851587831974, -0.01718016527593136, 0.03803468868136406, 0.03108428418636322, 0.0019183139083907008, 0.016152596101164818, -0.06317605078220367, 0.01548315305262804, -0.005070138722658157, -0.012901583686470985, 0.05020385608077049, -0.011677819304168224, 0.014688688330352306, 0.057597409933805466, 0.0036491311620920897, 0.029252199456095695, 0.009485118091106415, 0.006371866445988417, 0.05032121390104294, 0.017046991735696793, -0.056754015386104584, -0.05080656707286835, 0.032814279198646545, -0.06153315305709839, 0.018268028274178505, -0.06924194097518921, -0.04973487928509712, 0.019443193450570107, 0.018580825999379158, -0.004712350200861692, -0.018461374565958977, -0.020461421459913254, -0.022118426859378815, 0.031220464035868645, 0.031428441405296326, -0.002764209872111678, 0.043821368366479874, -0.011399202980101109, 0.0672740787267685, -0.04622071981430054, 0.015946131199598312, -0.029938841238617897, -0.09416777640581131, -0.027538351714611053, -0.0044512078166007996, -0.029184019193053246, -0.00204795622266829, 0.004581682849675417, 0.00391733692958951, 0.022956833243370056, -0.029043834656476974, -0.002486797980964184, -0.0029516241047531366, 0.015386810526251793, -0.026164008304476738, 0.07634054869413376, 0.019665539264678955, 0.02717619389295578, -0.04182745888829231, -0.020833788439631462, 0.12073022872209549, 0.06649300456047058, 0.0377318374812603, -0.049849070608615875, -0.005724907852709293, 0.009684363380074501, 0.005181010812520981, -0.040626395493745804, 0.019301844760775566, 0.03501616418361664, -0.028683407232165337, 0.01397001277655363, 0.05084254592657089, 0.018941165879368782, -0.007336746901273727, 0.020175814628601074, -0.04405078664422035, 0.0004685479507315904, 0.012363821268081665, -0.0011751052225008607, -0.017169704660773277, -0.00770633015781641, -0.05021622031927109, 0.00009294732444686815, 0.008596065454185009, -0.0033729947172105312, 0.0047404030337929726, -0.01119446475058794, 0.006636111531406641, 0.028314786031842232, 0.008151217363774776, 0.006321384105831385, 0.033532287925481796, -0.010633021593093872, 0.013711265288293362, -0.02582092024385929, 0.022157689556479454, -0.050356123596429825, -0.002261427929624915, 0.03175295889377594, 0.0013716357061639428, 0.025014404207468033, 0.006446574814617634, 0.0011160471476614475, -0.03442159295082092, -0.007687683682888746, -0.03348619490861893, 0.020999658852815628, -0.020396951586008072, -0.008902812376618385, -0.013977918773889542, -0.009350656531751156, -0.0035543639678508043, -0.01079412642866373, -0.005669989623129368, 0.017605427652597427, 0.02999943122267723, -0.015064473263919353, 0.016241172328591347, -0.03323986008763313, 0.05101396515965462, -0.007128283381462097, 0.03425336629152298, 0.009419002570211887, -0.06415317952632904, -0.07060779631137848, -0.006741320248693228, 0.032754749059677124, 0.016155989840626717, -0.006039377301931381, 0.001226463820785284, -0.016252443194389343, -0.027818961068987846, -0.035360634326934814, 0.0162147656083107, -0.01186479814350605, 0.04023638367652893, -0.020181600004434586, -0.000914163829293102, -0.016780417412519455, -0.02269301936030388, -0.00544408243149519, -0.037197332829236984, 0.0020489059388637543, -0.016948208212852478, -0.0265599824488163, 0.0457499697804451, 0.029798170551657677, 0.007740766741335392, 0.0015332174953073263, 0.006510549690574408, 0.030248470604419708, 0.024637790396809578, -0.027444547042250633, -0.05675468221306801, 0.009816679172217846, -0.016570355743169785, 0.011588755063712597, -0.02288788929581642, 0.05506846308708191, 0.022373465821146965, 0.051287632435560226, -0.007707692217081785, 0.04371906444430351, -0.029271984472870827, 0.024707525968551636, 0.012541202828288078, -0.07177485525608063, -0.020770154893398285, -0.005736344028264284, 0.025031408295035362, -0.02183135598897934, -0.003631145227700472, -0.007448186166584492, -0.010333818383514881, 0.015618237666785717, -0.00913886446505785, -0.029709843918681145, 0.009043332189321518, 0.005205197259783745, 0.019463716074824333, -0.005802616011351347, 0.012008244171738625, 0.006727732252329588, -0.039828069508075714, -0.050278984010219574, -0.00646100053563714, 0.0029959692619740963, 0.027720877900719643, -0.032681506127119064, 0.00306983501650393, 0.035677745938301086, 0.02791261300444603, 0.006393649615347385, 0.0030739495996385813, -0.029839005321264267, 0.020716585218906403, 0.02445354498922825, -0.022321505472064018, -0.005938870366662741, 0.005177781451493502, -0.009589157998561859, 0.014152690768241882, 0.006933725904673338, 0.022206315770745277, 0.047861408442258835, 0.033458489924669266, 0.006910666823387146, -0.020547104999423027, 0.048910245299339294, -0.04578951746225357, 0.003942323382943869, 0.012795619666576385, 0.004385305568575859, -0.004596316255629063, -0.011615956202149391, 0.016999566927552223, 0.025721978396177292, 0.019911427050828934, 0.027677619829773903, 0.018242811784148216, 0.00869615375995636, -0.035217415541410446, 0.004962248727679253, -0.009309881366789341, -0.0006078459555283189, 0.003264338942244649, 0.007009859196841717, 0.056953199207782745, 0.01764446496963501, -0.016413021832704544, 0.0407777838408947, -0.024128837510943413, -0.007257775869220495, -0.07846903055906296, -0.04137691110372543, 0.03673097863793373, 0.03037303127348423, 0.046363573521375656, -0.009621145203709602, 0.03231029957532883, 0.013856248930096626, -0.043797433376312256, 0.005240512080490589, 0.0073488084599375725, 0.010328580625355244, -0.03222060948610306, 0.01988237537443638, -0.023641405627131462, 0.01752101257443428, 0.01839480735361576, 0.025617338716983795, 0.035449594259262085, 0.02708534710109234, -0.015807991847395897, -0.014099308289587498, 0.018893476575613022, 0.005023484118282795, 0.03805559128522873, -0.07392110675573349, 0.032629504799842834, -0.05375212803483009, -0.045328520238399506, 0.020100930705666542, 0.042564790695905685, 0.03159588575363159, -0.025939341634511948, 0.05565999820828438, 0.02063211426138878, 0.03396104648709297, 0.04121117293834686, 0.011270114220678806, 0.04241468757390976, -0.01740298420190811, 0.023229187354445457, 0.003981909714639187, -0.01566622406244278, -0.025617018342018127, 0.030714666470885277, -0.003472329583019018, -0.02208426408469677, 0.007504868786782026, -0.011520858854055405, -0.03672885522246361, 0.016874274238944054, -0.004348601680248976, 0.015080700628459454, -0.005321916658431292, 0.03128743916749954, -0.038357436656951904, -0.018721800297498703, 0.06346159428358078, 0.0264003686606884, 0.011931848712265491, -0.010237960144877434, -0.02409992180764675, -0.05260522663593292, 0.04359905794262886, -0.0002678689197637141, -0.009027441032230854, -0.09492357075214386, -0.015367398969829082, -0.0004155036003794521, 0.005667445715516806, -0.01782606542110443, -0.011742308735847473, -0.02063656784594059, 0.03320916369557381, -0.006188878323882818, -0.01310131885111332, 0.012532982043921947, 0.016370058059692383, -0.00026102704578079283, -0.06498263776302338, 0.03187471255660057, 0.0056250556372106075, -0.04123891890048981, 0.002224728697910905, -0.015238841995596886, -0.06597352027893066, -0.013538387604057789, 0.06556940823793411, 0.017418665811419487, 0.022961260750889778, -0.025578735396265984, 0.03280533105134964, 0.021009700372815132, -0.04520653933286667, 0.032888028770685196, -0.02138267457485199, -0.04714902862906456, -0.0017831828445196152, -0.0110629266127944, 0.020578574389219284, -0.00013000884791836143, 0.03936018794775009, -0.027500497177243233, 0.01447282638400793, 0.01582331210374832, 0.03170222416520119, -0.008668038062751293, -0.00040315004298463464, 0.004746604710817337, 0.022110845893621445, 0.0013700461713597178, 0.008983030915260315, 0.031004710122942924, -0.006455811206251383, -0.0925418958067894, 0.018966278061270714, -0.029718440026044846, -0.04136238619685173, -0.006111320108175278, -0.04443446919322014, -0.015514861792325974, -0.030830038711428642, -0.00747692259028554, 0.010148870758712292, -0.04291081055998802, 0.0059512038715183735, 0.048746075481176376, 0.027521897107362747, 0.055303070694208145, 0.024363083764910698, 0.01559544075280428, 0.02825320139527321, 0.013721383176743984, 0.027943085879087448, 0.018510153517127037, 0.04087714105844498, -0.036758050322532654, -0.007345938123762608, 0.03721432387828827, -0.026212438941001892, -0.004922762978821993, -0.004891563672572374, 0.04892198368906975, 0.009247849695384502, -0.01246825885027647, 0.0008670614915899932, -0.03721989318728447, 0.0012544522760435939, -0.008355808444321156, -0.011253148317337036, 0.05956941843032837, -0.021220041438937187, 0.028825141489505768, -0.005971809849143028, 0.017964931204915047, -0.018178729340434074, 0.000029617582185892388, -0.04743586853146553, -0.0035468144342303276, 0.05105525255203247, -0.008872206322848797, -0.027333242818713188, -0.014585667289793491, 0.028337420895695686, -0.050374433398246765, 0.029270995408296585, -0.006484507583081722, 0.010747409425675869, 0.02942257560789585, -0.05305785685777664, -0.025271134451031685, -0.07255976647138596, -0.02491069585084915, 0.012179757468402386, -0.0070060016587376595, -0.035395413637161255, -0.06546589732170105, -0.013533991761505604, 0.018990719690918922, -0.06118742376565933, 0.013106419704854488, -0.04496201127767563, -0.024765994399785995, -0.016405515372753143, -0.03913383185863495 ]
<p>I built a classifier with 13 features ( no binary ones ) and normalized individually for each sample using scikit tool ( Normalizer().transform).</p> <p>When I make predictions it predicts all training sets as positives and all test sets as negatives ( irrespective of fact whether it is positive or negative )</p> <p>What anomalies I should focus on in my classifier, feature or data ???</p> <p>Notes: 1) I normalize test and training sets (individually for each sample) separately.</p> <p>2) I tried cross validation but the performance is same</p> <p>3) I used both SVM linear and RBF Kernels</p> <p>4) I tried without normalizing too. But same poor results</p> <p>5) I have same number of positive and negative datasets ( 400 each) and 34 samples of positive and 1000+ samples of negative test sets.</p>
73,918
[ -0.05517466366291046, 0.017706241458654404, -0.031165404245257378, 0.03682444617152214, 0.048384808003902435, -0.005368501413613558, -0.0018970150267705321, -0.00609356677159667, 0.005641819443553686, 0.007612735498696566, 0.05775666981935501, 0.024095499888062477, 0.003954205196350813, -0.01758734881877899, -0.017552759498357773, -0.019556459039449692, 0.0018220359925180674, -0.035889338701963425, 0.0038995551876723766, 0.025587135925889015, 0.01335117407143116, 0.03868948668241501, 0.05868303403258324, 0.019772807136178017, -0.033322811126708984, 0.041638121008872986, 0.014261062256991863, -0.0373443067073822, 0.006063744891434908, 0.023230500519275665, -0.02129559963941574, -0.025009779259562492, -0.004947255831211805, 0.013041636906564236, 0.021600399166345596, 0.022308293730020523, -0.008352238684892654, -0.02793613076210022, -0.041956834495067596, 0.019918188452720642, 0.011847244575619698, -0.015589158982038498, 0.010626042261719704, 0.09721338003873825, 0.008615877479314804, 0.01115170493721962, 0.010654301382601261, -0.00688594626262784, 0.02578609064221382, -0.07861195504665375, 0.049937259405851364, -0.014157946221530437, 0.047124870121479034, 0.05125029757618904, 0.016445541754364967, -0.029976990073919296, 0.051593080163002014, 0.07737260311841965, -0.011576267890632153, -0.08638066053390503, 0.03308054059743881, -0.01613539084792137, -0.03149965777993202, 0.013762190006673336, -0.02685876563191414, 0.05944575369358063, 0.005721912253648043, -0.02158578671514988, 0.03290543705224991, -0.00878065824508667, 0.05180501192808151, 0.004136372357606888, 0.02778913825750351, -0.021406671032309532, 0.0030702485237270594, -0.0016249548643827438, -0.014825509861111641, 0.025528980419039726, 0.027214201167225838, 0.041185855865478516, 0.03961070626974106, -0.00369041389785707, -0.013107233680784702, 0.038081537932157516, 0.03279180824756622, -0.02296578697860241, 0.0659283921122551, 0.01830606907606125, 0.008983229286968708, 0.027885302901268005, -0.018086358904838562, -0.009317850694060326, 0.08045554906129837, -0.00303830998018384, -0.04231271520256996, 0.02748965471982956, -0.013492701575160027, -0.005134820006787777, 0.030406778678297997, -0.01573858968913555, -0.015002396889030933, -0.007904911413788795, 0.025083942338824272, 0.06577273458242416, -0.06198163703083992, -0.0009274051408283412, -0.06229659542441368, -0.0112387016415596, -0.027379626408219337, -0.0017388340784236789, 0.00887492299079895, -0.003156474558636546, 0.016419164836406708, -0.014759154990315437, -0.0015317668439820409, 0.009189821779727936, -0.007097360212355852, -0.016924548894166946, -0.015169576741755009, 0.016108514741063118, -0.015973083674907684, -0.018800556659698486, 0.018080055713653564, -0.013526964001357555, -0.031235840171575546, 0.010303161107003689, 0.02681981585919857, 0.000026955654902849346, -0.0207296721637249, 0.03853645920753479, 0.0031912820413708687, -0.02324102818965912, 0.025726402178406715, -0.010485639795660973, 0.05287593603134155, 0.016422992572188377, -0.11267758160829544, -0.09820692986249924, 0.03324156999588013, -0.036630261689424515, 0.023225825279951096, -0.012132006697356701, -0.030453359708189964, 0.024013657122850418, 0.04703550413250923, 0.004979155026376247, 0.001843122998252511, 0.0448145791888237, 0.0211058147251606, -0.0015636392636224627, 0.019865795969963074, 0.013880033977329731, -0.049656178802251816, 0.02054777555167675, -0.059103235602378845, -0.05166115611791611, 0.02578885108232498, -0.019338451325893402, -0.00627238629385829, -0.010832564905285835, -0.013370512053370476, 0.010889452882111073, 0.010869056917726994, 0.013321774080395699, -0.014484717510640621, -0.026607705280184746, 0.03732927143573761, 0.019652165472507477, 0.061210427433252335, 0.030381513759493828, -0.020141249522566795, 0.01686561293900013, -0.0076728761196136475, 0.025361156091094017, 0.005938053596764803, -0.013595541007816792, -0.011077401228249073, -0.053687550127506256, 0.05838446691632271, 0.006706772372126579, -0.04408804699778557, -0.03722704201936722, -0.060640767216682434, 0.021070314571261406, 0.022570297122001648, 0.040970318019390106, 0.0003085753705818206, -0.041102513670921326, 0.05531715601682663, -0.06177825108170509, -0.02479243464767933, -0.06071170046925545, 0.009753498248755932, -0.056614942848682404, -0.02215331420302391, 0.02739674039185047, -0.007234437391161919, 0.021943349391222, -0.01703210547566414, 0.018561923876404762, 0.0013722475850954652, -0.006102877669036388, 0.0286280307918787, -0.038762398064136505, 0.021928295493125916, 0.04411979019641876, 0.0167243592441082, -0.03370041772723198, 0.0267807487398386, -0.04089556261897087, -0.04131697490811348, 0.03554040566086769, -0.031157691031694412, 0.0002656483557075262, -0.021885110065340996, -0.01819160394370556, 0.04756104573607445, 0.05205830931663513, -0.011298103258013725, -0.002547479933127761, -0.06404764205217361, 0.06653111428022385, 0.042631421238183975, -0.03682735562324524, 0.004294643644243479, -0.007352774031460285, -0.0215374194085598, 0.03617846593260765, -0.02332395687699318, 0.006860746536403894, -0.05691136047244072, -0.012065212242305279, 0.046671997755765915, 0.03298439458012581, -0.013086318038403988, 0.010358533822000027, 0.0628373920917511, -0.020988615229725838, -0.009286747314035892, 0.01054519135504961, 0.0012851885985583067, -0.04178473725914955, 0.016779296100139618, 0.011202455498278141, 0.013562312349677086, 0.011347580701112747, 0.009478684514760971, -0.038443662226200104, 0.0309075228869915, -0.01813690736889839, -0.03429805114865303, 0.05214998871088028, 0.008691215887665749, 0.021776339039206505, -0.017255520448088646, -0.02594638615846634, 0.024922236800193787, -0.01747806929051876, -0.03390922397375107, 0.015527005307376385, 0.012840136885643005, 0.014196569100022316, -0.020548777654767036, -0.01867607608437538, 0.02255362458527088, 0.06239550560712814, 0.0019231223268434405, 0.011914584785699844, 0.008213447406888008, -0.09115684777498245, -0.009555640630424023, -0.0017776977038010955, -0.03176126256585121, -0.04450629651546478, 0.004496980924159288, 0.06644660979509354, -0.002638252219185233, 0.041984234005212784, -0.01992751657962799, 0.01132907997816801, 0.03425414487719536, -0.0017662006430327892, 0.052420344203710556, 0.020495805889368057, -0.02722608670592308, -0.014533329755067825, -0.022486237809062004, -0.013740905560553074, 0.03946062549948692, -0.023324422538280487, -0.005862712394446135, 0.01558938343077898, -0.0015064020408317447, -0.02107272855937481, -0.0760236382484436, -0.06187434867024422, 0.04072142764925957, -0.004499883856624365, -0.037094779312610626, 0.06631789356470108, 0.010737338103353977, -0.03202410787343979, 0.0129935247823596, 0.004664367996156216, -0.012301833368837833, -0.012978360056877136, -0.02725405804812908, 0.031762681901454926, -0.005403556395322084, -0.0069084265269339085, 0.03335123509168625, 0.0018032954540103674, 0.02191786840558052, -0.05770877003669739, -0.021537108346819878, 0.006207503378391266, 0.001887355581857264, 0.035237498581409454, 0.0074560078792274, 0.008112865500152111, 0.05970161408185959, 0.059086985886096954, -0.004677448887377977, -0.06241442263126373, 0.0008236411376856267, -0.1015656366944313, -0.04236776754260063, 0.011453199200332165, 0.043910495936870575, 0.03309556841850281, 0.026658883318305016, -0.00895143486559391, 0.024023041129112244, 0.024471109732985497, 0.003162036882713437, -0.06337195634841919, 0.032812729477882385, 0.018310803920030594, -0.010899682529270649, 0.05830904096364975, 0.024828949943184853, 0.00491607328876853, -0.02013392187654972, 0.020056286826729774, -0.0022852567490190268, 0.023364443331956863, -0.04795072600245476, 0.007926073856651783, -0.03646034374833107, 0.04521418735384941, -0.046973615884780884, 0.000248572847340256, 0.001311048399657011, -0.05848865583539009, -0.022096233442425728, -0.014348986558616161, 0.03245288133621216, -0.010754246264696121, 0.015592101961374283, 0.043026745319366455, 0.04157531261444092, -0.004249287769198418, -0.016614027321338654, -0.025523992255330086, -0.024005237966775894, 0.015270143747329712, -0.009943008422851562, 0.025725029408931732, 0.05170784890651703, 0.06829685717821121, 0.011981017887592316, 0.017191382125020027, -0.06199408322572708, 0.001292404835112393, -0.03906906768679619, -0.005776483565568924, -0.019234851002693176, 0.03548549860715866, 0.02874188870191574, 0.004244574345648289, 0.02944072149693966, -0.022821221500635147, 0.013028468005359173, 0.014871286228299141, -0.07507794350385666, 0.009647767059504986, 0.008491099812090397, -0.005070796702057123, -0.017676837742328644, -0.053194351494312286, 0.008696312084794044, -0.039237819612026215, 0.012834371998906136, 0.011504696682095528, 0.03785696625709534, -0.053123850375413895, 0.0053996071219444275, -0.013892264105379581, 0.0015787893207743764, 0.0034235971979796886, -0.0009902473539113998, -0.020816495642066002, 0.00829570647329092, 0.02619357220828533, 0.012830027379095554, 0.01242904458194971, -0.028164321556687355, -0.023268332704901695, 0.028030045330524445, 0.00846547819674015, 0.04586174711585045, -0.00013208811287768185, 0.03459066525101662, -0.08936859667301178, 0.02174392342567444, -0.003199114929884672, 0.022786691784858704, 0.020598940551280975, 0.01758698932826519, -0.014939509332180023, -0.045753009617328644, -0.03393521532416344, -0.01934930868446827, 0.001825092826038599, 0.04671609774231911, 0.015191986225545406, 0.03295690566301346, 0.008517325855791569, -0.040999311953783035, -0.03738807141780853, 0.06551695615053177, 0.009357107803225517, -0.01347291562706232, -0.03456737846136093, -0.008335137739777565, 0.013655230402946472, 0.010042021051049232, 0.02654612809419632, 0.0003936136490665376, -0.04793558642268181, -0.002228811150416732, 0.04668709635734558, -0.03515022248029709, -0.024042321369051933, 0.016346978023648262, 0.017186453565955162, 0.03717606142163277, 0.007422018330544233, 0.009280222468078136, 0.0020833115559071302, 0.02459956519305706, 0.04167892783880234, 0.004229947924613953, -0.02325921319425106, -0.09640423208475113, 0.004913216456770897, 0.056603945791721344, 0.02199687249958515, 0.006011645775288343, -0.02918102964758873, -0.033126749098300934, -0.014799156226217747, 0.00965808518230915, -0.060496170073747635, 0.01875624805688858, 0.022162942215800285, 0.033244721591472626, -0.034302718937397, -0.06279004365205765, -0.0418766550719738, 0.009599793702363968, -0.021580126136541367, 0.052958447486162186, -0.0021428209729492664, -0.030239984393119812, -0.03822406753897667, 0.015350544825196266, 0.005462148226797581, 0.08397331088781357, -0.018128734081983566, 0.016033895313739777, -0.003276441479101777, 0.009359805844724178, 0.025227852165699005, -0.08924797177314758, -0.017853738740086555, 0.00923792365938425, 0.0013417372247204185, 0.060667313635349274, 0.003361675189808011, -0.04258957505226135, -0.024360591545701027, 0.011518615297973156, -0.03888939693570137, -0.030845388770103455, -0.07532937824726105, -0.014129734598100185, 0.014790312387049198, -0.02309863455593586, 0.021625567227602005, 0.030433127656579018, -0.009307455271482468, 0.00633500749245286, -0.03212279826402664, 0.00509410398080945, -0.024830110371112823, -0.033010538667440414, -0.02580057457089424, -0.01714150421321392, -0.0005666311481036246, 0.030725417658686638, 0.03371979296207428, 0.06803972274065018, 0.002742786193266511, -0.009236392565071583, 0.009104853495955467, 0.008953421376645565, -0.015279944986104965, -0.027154559269547462, -0.022408705204725266, 0.0013540692161768675, 0.0010392834665253758, -0.00845265481621027, -0.023946037515997887, -0.019368261098861694, 0.008490635082125664, 0.051707204431295395, -0.023244330659508705, 0.00697062024846673, -0.013973735272884369, -0.02300204150378704, -0.01228935644030571, -0.01937827095389366, 0.020807387307286263, 0.011122221127152443, 0.026389427483081818, 0.004436101298779249, -0.03138548508286476, -0.0034268840681761503, 0.02169772796332836, 0.00555966142565012, 0.05762616917490959, -0.015218798071146011, 0.04209935665130615, -0.0030452064238488674, -0.011779077351093292, -0.059696078300476074, -0.0417170487344265, 0.019355319440364838, -0.0018172552809119225, -0.037148479372262955, -0.022258663550019264, -0.011379396542906761, 0.02185637503862381, -0.0030483142472803593, 0.0013952937442809343, 0.059080079197883606, -0.06366539746522903, -0.0005647100042551756, 0.027977516874670982, -0.018890898674726486, 0.06755612045526505, -0.04411088302731514, 0.008889611810445786, 0.02015737071633339, 0.014014337211847305, -0.04123137518763542, 0.030460938811302185, -0.009886527433991432, -0.0204525925219059, -0.025457430630922318, -0.039518460631370544, -0.00015945624909363687, 0.0440918505191803, 0.017783809453248978, 0.012188419699668884, -0.0252589900046587, 0.021974483504891396, 0.00642430642619729, 0.004718927666544914, 0.012886673212051392, 0.022909285500645638, -0.025071093812584877, 0.004711649380624294, -0.008060291409492493, -0.06424025446176529, -0.04969627037644386, 0.047153156250715256, 0.018705355003476143, -0.024101441726088524, 0.0036221982445567846, 0.04368416219949722, -0.019024904817342758, -0.01451107021421194, -0.013836788944900036, -0.030049379914999008, 0.046798817813396454, 0.0021713420283049345, 0.0399206168949604, -0.009065847843885422, 0.013351907022297382, -0.034572530537843704, 0.004021280445158482, -0.04085554555058479, -0.022604133933782578, 0.020819848403334618, 0.015035763382911682, 0.05717449635267258, 0.01865961216390133, 0.011231813579797745, -0.008931868709623814, -0.04149878770112991, -0.0018854521913453937, 0.018718551844358444, 0.013585159555077553, 0.03619721159338951, 0.012658100575208664, 0.034028735011816025, 0.013608330860733986, 0.03321559727191925, 0.025014979764819145, 0.030714083462953568, 0.011854302138090134, 0.01987874135375023, 0.017536118626594543, -0.004111849702894688, -0.03179005905985832, 0.035038456320762634, -0.030494723469018936, 0.017457161098718643, 0.0011131416540592909, 0.012855488806962967, 0.040562305599451065, 0.027469336986541748, 0.025920769199728966, -0.06915301084518433, -0.023391813039779663, -0.033577557653188705, 0.008237333968281746, 0.01719074323773384, -0.041686154901981354, 0.03043990582227707, 0.0372239388525486, 0.045230694115161896, -0.010268386453390121, 0.014412902295589447, -0.04789485037326813, -0.08865700662136078, -0.010014803148806095, -0.04107123613357544, -0.03926641866564751, 0.020885799080133438, -0.038741279393434525, -0.007932589389383793, -0.02161460369825363, -0.0370638445019722, 0.04214293137192726, 0.011551587842404842, 0.031840212643146515, -0.014961447566747665, 0.005774710793048143, -0.013652066700160503, 0.003678553504869342, 0.005297999829053879, 0.0007518564816564322, 0.12453439831733704, 0.08281305432319641, 0.03063923306763172, -0.0729256346821785, -0.025404278188943863, 0.007008199580013752, 0.013824017718434334, -0.02136974409222603, 0.02262498065829277, -0.0021829078905284405, -0.007317984011024237, 0.01620563678443432, 0.017142660915851593, 0.03456374257802963, -0.0183174517005682, 0.03582176938652992, -0.0021823018323630095, 0.018356909975409508, 0.0191213209182024, 0.018047984689474106, 0.0028946937527507544, 0.008223754353821278, -0.07726680487394333, 0.03723730146884918, -0.05721587687730789, -0.039006829261779785, -0.028199361637234688, 0.0033500385470688343, 0.005489018280059099, -0.006458799354732037, 0.0006120693287812173, 0.0012221079086884856, 0.0002887898881454021, -0.013766937889158726, 0.017684463411569595, -0.017568638548254967, 0.011527974158525467, -0.026744885370135307, 0.03488238528370857, 0.02927747555077076, 0.016831908375024796, -0.004668810870498419, 0.006511446554213762, 0.009622374549508095, -0.07865245640277863, 0.0015751792816445231, -0.01915358379483223, 0.07057014852762222, 0.00942723173648119, -0.019922057166695595, 0.019271336495876312, -0.0034961779601871967, -0.02026965655386448, -0.04005813971161842, -0.03231848403811455, -0.01727447845041752, -0.0024569854140281677, -0.04131046310067177, -0.045266393572092056, -0.007259703706949949, 0.028495976701378822, 0.03243139758706093, 0.035337746143341064, -0.00030182331101968884, 0.011397561058402061, -0.028087053447961807, -0.00356573099270463, 0.047685541212558746, -0.004832361359149218, 0.03945588693022728, -0.0005871367175132036, -0.035524506121873856, 0.014769469387829304, 0.008900882676243782, 0.017212143167853355, 0.02592124231159687, 0.0207167100161314, -0.018799640238285065, -0.017022304236888885, -0.04985303431749344, -0.016081759706139565, 0.01191954966634512, -0.025239402428269386, 0.00985186081379652, 0.005945302080363035, 0.026279721409082413, -0.02699146792292595, 0.050460491329431534, 0.035752132534980774, -0.006489460356533527, 0.053860027343034744, 0.04136045649647713, 0.01874162070453167, -0.025067919865250587, -0.03822837397456169, -0.026433441787958145, -0.03021109476685524, 0.030824100598692894, -0.013270641677081585, 0.05586953088641167, 0.021383240818977356, 0.0036612930707633495, -0.010338377207517624, 0.01995077170431614, -0.013050554320216179, -0.0012259541545063257, 0.0006669971626251936, -0.043350718915462494, -0.019748199731111526, 0.012878237292170525, -0.014674562960863113, -0.01683470979332924, -0.036500364542007446, 0.009963025338947773, -0.024775002151727676, 0.04087226092815399, 0.0021419955883175135, -0.028108825907111168, -0.0026256623677909374, 0.009887292049825191, 0.05970087647438049, -0.013841682113707066, -0.0015244660899043083, -0.04133386164903641, 0.016029754653573036, -0.04113335162401199, -0.029985900968313217, -0.006548816338181496, 0.004030517768114805, 0.04794599488377571, -0.003119448199868202, 0.04686780273914337, 0.010913917794823647, 0.03145384415984154, -0.011290612630546093, 0.0150900324806571, -0.015468940138816833, 0.011670284904539585, 0.004299902822822332, -0.01944165676832199, 0.023595275357365608, -0.033333905041217804, -0.006636472884565592, 0.04383057728409767, 0.026028266176581383, 0.03461841866374016, -0.013730663806200027, 0.007405306678265333, -0.01065988652408123, 0.05563618987798691, 0.018877439200878143, -0.0007279550773091614, -0.024005545303225517, 0.032575927674770355, 0.004628223367035389, 0.035371892154216766, 0.006330410949885845, -0.021334631368517876, -0.011853466741740704, 0.006086968816816807, 0.020257405936717987, -0.007334724068641663, -0.02046343684196472, 0.01851535402238369, -0.012179260142147541, 0.02378162369132042, 0.007564097177237272, 0.0018204323714599013, 0.034731216728687286, -0.013928163796663284, -0.05138121917843819, 0.038229815661907196, -0.047538742423057556, 0.013604115694761276, -0.04923134669661522, -0.01583302952349186, 0.023046031594276428, 0.0024776621721684933, 0.0005377975176088512, -0.037453703582286835, 0.0020933630876243114, 0.02740146964788437, -0.03095375932753086, 0.0383366234600544, 0.016661928966641426, -0.005259307567030191, -0.0520133338868618, 0.019557660445570946, -0.01308596320450306, -0.009242156520485878, 0.002056242898106575, 0.02504172921180725, -0.001388882170431316, 0.06933916360139847, -0.017095031216740608, -0.03332415595650673, -0.03699418529868126, 0.019328560680150986, -0.002766586607322097, -0.049354519695043564, 0.002413508016616106, -0.03623146936297417, -0.019436081871390343, 0.032443128526210785, -0.0373641662299633, -0.04315388202667236, 0.0882209837436676, 0.03843121603131294, 0.026748528704047203, 0.06540168821811676, 0.01985907554626465, -0.02639690414071083, 0.001550967455841601, -0.0056961714290082455, 0.01021184679120779, 0.02350294217467308, 0.0040130289271473885, 0.014161779545247555, 0.01817481592297554, -0.04031269624829292, 0.019496040418744087, 0.005996682681143284, -0.037454959005117416, -0.019598038867115974, -0.017728768289089203, -0.0001741493324516341, 0.017142226919531822, -0.0078397486358881, -0.02344893291592598, -0.02873934432864189, 0.012303639203310013, 0.0002556455146986991, 0.033696211874485016, -0.0045593418180942535, -0.003441975452005863, -0.016060587018728256, -0.030379457399249077, 0.008288536220788956, 0.010861140675842762, 0.027759023010730743, -0.02929854393005371, 0.004067540634423494, 0.009704170748591423, -0.01260924618691206, -0.015827367082238197, -0.02736549824476242, -0.04138744994997978, 0.049204252660274506, -0.012111379764974117, 0.04190587252378464, 0.030154632404446602, -0.011051245033740997, -0.0058755166828632355, -0.10523795336484909, 0.024592947214841843, -0.011525283567607403, -0.009398746304214, -0.006004199851304293, 0.02036184072494507, -0.0611182302236557, -0.0011462175752967596, 0.05636198818683624, -0.005991353653371334, 0.011621341109275818, -0.04523465409874916, -0.008346379734575748, 0.024133309721946716, -0.040039919316768646, 0.020571758970618248, -0.037806425243616104, -0.047093573957681656, 0.03563908860087395, -0.043655458837747574, -0.0034027774818241596, 0.007513851393014193, -0.007923522032797337, -0.030789801850914955, -0.008711029775440693, -0.008731428533792496, -0.011781495995819569, 0.039765164256095886, 0.015642790123820305, 0.00572177255526185, 0.046814657747745514, 0.03543977439403534, -0.014496877789497375, 0.017888065427541733, -0.008373623713850975, -0.04216383770108223, 0.02613985165953636, -0.0013669939944520593, -0.03539410978555679, -0.026754332706332207, 0.019677767530083656, 0.036589860916137695, -0.039725955575704575, -0.029885470867156982, 0.05637224763631821, 0.005167871713638306, 0.021417582407593727, 0.060302864760160446, 0.019192572683095932, 0.014006376266479492, -0.018859488889575005, 0.046451691538095474, 0.0037980442866683006, 0.02110486850142479, 0.0038740516174584627, 0.0077763390727341175, -0.02327529527246952, 0.002000627340748906, -0.004840020556002855, 0.028446154668927193, -0.005236656405031681, 0.04464135318994522, -0.009552264586091042, 0.028630893677473068, -0.028200486674904823, 0.03513791784644127, -0.000824295450001955, 0.005215143784880638, 0.03002728335559368, -0.002654832787811756, -0.0008151584770530462, 0.07228983938694, -0.06891421973705292, -0.0066453153267502785, -0.044390950351953506, -0.05280699208378792, -0.020106343552470207, 0.019307075068354607, 0.020393678918480873, 0.03710782527923584, 0.020556049421429634, -0.00745750404894352, -0.02062183804810047, 0.013427524827420712, 0.08045607060194016, -0.03954906389117241, 0.03087584674358368, -0.01372765563428402, -0.003431967692449689, 0.0366080105304718, -0.023221170529723167, 0.012880326248705387, -0.03314584493637085, -0.005312009248882532, 0.059482213109731674, 0.018794642761349678, -0.020251531153917313, -0.0029297375585883856, 0.012282174080610275, 0.025142962113022804, -0.02194271609187126, -0.04013446345925331, -0.028442662209272385, 0.02444775216281414, -0.00007963509415276349, -0.050668664276599884 ]
<p>Given a $n$-dimensional multivariate normal distribution $X=(x_i) \sim \mathcal{N}(\mu, \Sigma)$ with mean $\mu$ and covariance matrix $\Sigma$, what is the probability that $\forall j\in {1,\ldots,n}:x_1 \geq x_j$?</p>
73,919
[ -0.043474212288856506, -0.010780362412333488, 0.024187946692109108, -0.019903328269720078, 0.024023091420531273, 0.04197009652853012, 0.005477834492921829, -0.03625079244375229, 0.01661895029246807, -0.04288302734494209, 0.05306868255138397, 0.04562684893608093, 0.05812988802790642, 0.03339387848973274, 0.02701210044324398, 0.006864799652248621, -0.030287476256489754, 0.015701819211244583, -0.01897752471268177, -0.006586720701307058, -0.011899162083864212, 0.0435757078230381, 0.014310797676444054, -0.0454779751598835, -0.023477911949157715, 0.05459122359752655, 0.010521356016397476, -0.02250024676322937, 0.01683477871119976, 0.09683176130056381, -0.041481863707304, -0.026789072901010513, 0.0380675233900547, 0.039391618221998215, -0.004520263057202101, 0.014587029814720154, 0.01057016383856535, -0.030705755576491356, -0.01130615919828415, 0.010565957054495811, -0.0551607646048069, -0.028957536444067955, 0.0007192546036094427, 0.03445403277873993, -0.011878293007612228, 0.04641987755894661, -0.03309984132647514, -0.04917045310139656, 0.02046927437186241, -0.02325352281332016, 0.10384224355220795, 0.005881681106984615, 0.04444107785820961, 0.01246301457285881, -0.024496661499142647, 0.004732921253889799, 0.027504246681928635, 0.08622250705957413, 0.015428813174366951, -0.054879624396562576, -0.00263353087939322, -0.06771544367074966, 0.008803361095488071, -0.016408711671829224, 0.0066229552030563354, 0.037918634712696075, -0.02772343158721924, -0.017807073891162872, 0.007335429545491934, -0.015403872355818748, -0.018899992108345032, 0.03461790084838867, 0.02333078719675541, -0.009123317897319794, 0.009445288218557835, 0.0057488102465868, 0.02650645188987255, 0.014450037851929665, 0.03561115637421608, -0.008990124799311161, 0.05087568238377571, 0.012340211309492588, 0.02873721718788147, 0.025011787191033363, 0.002973481547087431, 0.018474547192454338, 0.07010447978973389, -0.03763323649764061, 0.03659886494278908, 0.03288233280181885, -0.029561981558799744, -0.0012907936470583081, 0.019924186170101166, 0.00042996948468498886, -0.07101815938949585, 0.06073885038495064, -0.019844403490424156, -0.006346500478684902, -0.015605674125254154, -0.008656502701342106, -0.042016565799713135, -0.03736622631549835, 0.038501664996147156, 0.037424974143505096, 0.0004098605422768742, 0.02959488518536091, -0.04270658269524574, -0.012166091240942478, -0.02262302115559578, 0.0001355579006485641, -0.02835690975189209, 0.05512590333819389, 0.006301283370703459, 0.008460945449769497, 0.029718751087784767, -0.00858759693801403, 0.025006944313645363, -0.035630643367767334, 0.04674655571579933, 0.07475581020116806, 0.036482956260442734, 0.0035996586084365845, 0.02329072915017605, -0.009853234514594078, -0.07582096010446548, 0.03726426512002945, 0.036648254841566086, -0.002801045309752226, -0.09158185869455338, 0.03479371219873428, -0.014837128110229969, -0.010309915989637375, 0.021737921983003616, 0.010029695928096771, 0.04329412803053856, 0.009321797639131546, -0.08742187172174454, -0.0510539747774601, 0.05435466766357422, -0.031206058338284492, -0.018896862864494324, -0.05388316884636879, 0.014494736678898335, 0.03075278550386429, 0.06312375515699387, -0.010598182678222656, 0.08247864991426468, 0.028390325605869293, 0.020542217418551445, -0.0010944147361442447, -0.008596912957727909, -0.0298059843480587, 0.0026869168505072594, -0.007154308259487152, 0.00019809043442364782, -0.08010687679052353, 0.024840418249368668, 0.028117915615439415, -0.014131958596408367, -0.020755352452397346, 0.029363326728343964, 0.0006914066034369171, -0.008642605505883694, -0.05014750361442566, 0.029513483867049217, -0.039181508123874664, 0.05128978565335274, 0.010771387256681919, 0.04977882280945778, -0.0024812063202261925, -0.0003834841481875628, 0.006635784637182951, -0.009616637602448463, 0.06910695880651474, 0.057781461626291275, -0.005358866415917873, 0.0146838603541255, 0.012585405260324478, 0.02336284890770912, 0.018444037064909935, -0.01957068033516407, 0.00941257644444704, -0.03189704567193985, -0.007499351631850004, 0.02469068020582199, -0.017018495127558708, 0.0036626318469643593, -0.01608177088201046, -0.0006982447230257094, -0.013621069490909576, -0.0220567025244236, -0.07330269366502762, 0.020917898043990135, 0.03314320743083954, -0.0469328872859478, 0.03568674996495247, -0.007917332462966442, 0.005685876589268446, -0.008929508738219738, -0.013054579496383667, -0.01174185425043106, 0.009732517413794994, 0.019605837762355804, -0.058674708008766174, -0.0272388756275177, 0.05328991636633873, 0.08566103875637054, -0.013701691292226315, 0.05817236751317978, -0.006692309398204088, -0.05514081194996834, -0.017736442387104034, -0.030980832874774933, 0.019912390038371086, -0.010617569088935852, -0.0013206731528043747, 0.022492824122309685, -0.02210831455886364, -0.0181050393730402, 0.02308334782719612, -0.057702526450157166, -0.0010679967235773802, 0.05165712907910347, 0.01375802792608738, -0.009038497693836689, -0.012097313068807125, 0.019191034138202667, -0.0173598974943161, -0.010631063021719456, -0.029307659715414047, -0.027299363166093826, -0.022096196189522743, 0.0154787078499794, 0.06540070474147797, -0.02575124427676201, 0.025430504232645035, 0.026506246998906136, 0.027985522523522377, -0.003861181205138564, 0.03625104948878288, 0.0025334127712994814, -0.053635016083717346, -0.02231854572892189, 0.011160057038068771, 0.000323850370477885, 0.002962075872346759, -0.008184580132365227, 0.001703901682049036, 0.02967146225273609, -0.012584739364683628, -0.028275733813643456, 0.028106961399316788, 0.0019326035398989916, 0.016279591247439384, -0.0016528127016499639, -0.026956431567668915, 0.02036810852587223, 0.005445718765258789, 0.011436749249696732, 0.012657392770051956, -0.00002362322629778646, 0.020044736564159393, -0.006029349286109209, -0.026501549407839775, -0.0016246356535702944, 0.03590402379631996, -0.020346717908978462, 0.023885514587163925, 0.015479224734008312, -0.042594924569129944, 0.006321234162896872, -0.028867287561297417, -0.03234225511550903, 0.0178164541721344, -0.001761866733431816, 0.0349988117814064, -0.04326343536376953, 0.036997806280851364, -0.029073351994156837, -0.03542139753699303, 0.020649554207921028, -0.016660917550325394, 0.022353138774633408, -0.007880671881139278, -0.03692733868956566, 0.008348525501787663, -0.02098040096461773, -0.021224210038781166, 0.009724386036396027, -0.0259610153734684, 0.021923335269093513, 0.06739971786737442, -0.0052463579922914505, -0.012475238181650639, -0.010724883526563644, -0.0003803404688369483, 0.0005690205725841224, -0.05901945009827614, -0.031327176839113235, 0.047931935638189316, 0.002285060239955783, -0.03867697715759277, 0.0028723771683871746, 0.006051621399819851, -0.04563560336828232, -0.06727661937475204, 0.03036518581211567, 0.013101127929985523, -0.010083270259201527, 0.025769393891096115, 0.03812912479043007, 0.012278617359697819, -0.01490566972643137, -0.03878014534711838, -0.037293724715709686, 0.002327511552721262, -0.022805050015449524, 0.05263492092490196, -0.007323847617954016, -0.00460359500721097, 0.08291534334421158, 0.04609398543834686, 0.013122042641043663, -0.023283282294869423, -0.008853216655552387, -0.00757263321429491, -0.03532341122627258, 0.04264282435178757, 0.009638295508921146, 0.0007753312820568681, 0.04661985859274864, 0.005504322703927755, 0.0027473235968500376, 0.04897364228963852, -0.004299222957342863, -0.018939029425382614, 0.0005732192657887936, -0.015320551581680775, -0.0025269563775509596, 0.03561635687947273, -0.0006495096022263169, -0.005024370737373829, 0.004101538099348545, 0.03168594837188721, 0.012449798174202442, 0.011447148397564888, -0.05699704587459564, 0.037615153938531876, -0.05225967615842819, 0.03912831097841263, -0.03446253016591072, 0.052050650119781494, 0.05330595374107361, -0.0335628017783165, -0.010130147449672222, 0.03089025989174843, 0.02785353548824787, -0.040035396814346313, 0.01134155597537756, 0.02553548291325569, 0.02627890184521675, -0.025796476751565933, 0.026210350915789604, -0.033700909465551376, -0.010079224593937397, -0.0049256011843681335, -0.04985427483916283, -0.051398806273937225, 0.022613979876041412, 0.025408824905753136, -0.015233435668051243, -0.03108745440840721, -0.03710903972387314, -0.027431214228272438, -0.029738061130046844, 0.036726608872413635, -0.020788628607988358, 0.02212231606245041, 0.015615195967257023, 0.05001311004161835, 0.008647717535495758, -0.024091817438602448, -0.006251102779060602, -0.011141743510961533, -0.07045720517635345, 0.004191355314105749, -0.04631282016634941, 0.011722293682396412, -0.005530121270567179, -0.03819091245532036, 0.023518625646829605, 0.016423532739281654, 0.016641825437545776, 0.0017019255319610238, 0.048570889979600906, -0.04507710412144661, -0.0023820556234568357, -0.05136796459555626, -0.04747779667377472, 0.0005436897627077997, 0.02510025165975094, 0.0349796898663044, -0.01425339374691248, 0.033849626779556274, 0.01087135635316372, -0.025974690914154053, -0.01739906147122383, 0.000628896348644048, -0.0031810442451387644, 0.0235141608864069, 0.009909450076520443, -0.01646524854004383, 0.037498533725738525, -0.013710261322557926, 0.018312621861696243, -0.02499137632548809, 0.052231427282094955, 0.03704795613884926, -0.01011146791279316, 0.02557048387825489, -0.05816509574651718, -0.01943087764084339, 0.011653870344161987, 0.024474531412124634, -0.02898075059056282, -0.019136665388941765, 0.044298361986875534, 0.047843825072050095, -0.06619905680418015, 0.00954633578658104, 0.05479668080806732, 0.05393567308783531, -0.013827238231897354, -0.015106700360774994, -0.0035978856030851603, -0.027859104797244072, 0.004209989216178656, 0.007771286182105541, -0.016902420669794083, -0.031186874955892563, -0.010099709033966064, -0.0018782862462103367, -0.017281075939536095, -0.01518762856721878, -0.029377948492765427, 0.0030433805659413338, 0.035342857241630554, 0.00786473136395216, -0.029603630304336548, 0.008759645745158195, 0.021816952154040337, 0.03993455320596695, 0.028046535328030586, 0.03678442910313606, -0.044952359050512314, 0.009351176209747791, 0.04675060510635376, 0.028983313590288162, -0.0320810005068779, 0.0031395868863910437, -0.025257742032408714, -0.0014820192009210587, 0.047227032482624054, -0.018742945045232773, 0.015472348779439926, -0.01412656344473362, 0.021030867472290993, -0.0241707656532526, -0.013921086676418781, -0.025216255336999893, -0.0038625954184681177, 0.019635478034615517, 0.04392566904425621, 0.019694101065397263, 0.007535216864198446, -0.06644120067358017, -0.0022405381314456463, 0.04312405735254288, 0.06389293074607849, 0.02377169579267502, 0.007600265089422464, -0.009592162445187569, 0.017718516290187836, -0.004854136146605015, -0.04545261710882187, 0.04511876031756401, 0.014845633879303932, -0.04420237988233566, 0.04587765038013458, -0.055074214935302734, -0.034431342035532, 0.025759583339095116, 0.002581127919256687, -0.025123726576566696, 0.024685021489858627, 0.01022021472454071, 0.05811866372823715, 0.027882840484380722, -0.004409934859722853, 0.007515354081988335, -0.012545322999358177, -0.002323611406609416, 0.03476431593298912, -0.021324455738067627, 0.0024015232920646667, -0.03233916312456131, -0.032357778400182724, -0.030867528170347214, -0.03181502968072891, -0.017572879791259766, 0.03153403103351593, -0.0063165402971208096, 0.04996189475059509, 0.006546819116920233, -0.015056448057293892, -0.01972244493663311, 0.04861491546034813, -0.019071001559495926, -0.002763601951301098, 0.010980084538459778, 0.02671053446829319, 0.013912171125411987, -0.03444279357790947, 0.04011636599898338, 0.002922806655988097, 0.007359906565397978, 0.0009341516997665167, -0.018434245139360428, 0.006076346151530743, -0.06661079078912735, -0.02157307043671608, 0.00521269254386425, -0.02837918885052204, 0.04251033440232277, -0.020008334890007973, 0.01888403855264187, 0.023670276626944542, -0.034419476985931396, -0.013235777616500854, 0.044692885130643845, -0.020717758685350418, 0.0237584225833416, 0.011407441459596157, 0.035323746502399445, 0.004035123623907566, 0.001442453940398991, -0.07592062652111053, -0.019790198653936386, -0.024427233263850212, -0.0009204269736073911, -0.010385680012404919, -0.0534854419529438, -0.025606300681829453, -0.02475866675376892, -0.03319798409938812, -0.00837339274585247, 0.024773232638835907, 0.01165131013840437, -0.015619526617228985, -0.015490185469388962, 0.013977362774312496, 0.058497924357652664, -0.03396663814783096, -0.00803412776440382, -0.012334679253399372, -0.04444324970245361, -0.008013177663087845, -0.016078051179647446, 0.034041233360767365, -0.024749625474214554, -0.011444725096225739, -0.010590426623821259, -0.020816924050450325, 0.02105645276606083, -0.0204770527780056, -0.031222857534885406, 0.02298235148191452, -0.024253493174910545, -0.0031057707965373993, -0.02641185186803341, -0.008372639305889606, -0.005126636940985918, 0.040543749928474426, 0.013145389966666698, -0.006504761520773172, 0.006550882011651993, -0.016322877258062363, 0.03189985454082489, 0.04545086994767189, 0.012288088910281658, 0.010307477787137032, 0.030205706134438515, -0.030000150203704834, -0.006593564059585333, -0.02899315394461155, 0.001552051049657166, 0.030935274437069893, -0.017460333183407784, -0.010046510025858879, 0.02703181840479374, 0.02147708646953106, -0.039728712290525436, -0.04104071483016014, -0.017929961904883385, 0.016951212659478188, 0.016107792034745216, -0.03405868634581566, 0.011378494091331959, 0.03227830305695534, -0.02039395458996296, -0.01346330251544714, -0.010045451112091541, 0.005945519078522921, 0.016336455941200256, 0.002423791913315654, 0.03834645077586174, -0.03186158463358879, -0.002886212896555662, 0.051695581525564194, 0.031606920063495636, -0.005915414076298475, 0.030198223888874054, 0.003104075323790312, 0.02985808067023754, 0.018684256821870804, -0.033960431814193726, -0.020577801391482353, 0.06721127033233643, -0.043314799666404724, -0.0034681162796914577, -0.033873070031404495, -0.00048015278298407793, 0.009435049258172512, 0.026798028498888016, -0.034653935581445694, 0.011621001176536083, -0.02944565750658512, -0.010890018194913864, -0.012024025432765484, 0.01512208767235279, 0.01230011135339737, 0.01902609132230282, 0.011091940104961395, 0.029737776145339012, -0.0162566676735878, 0.01413996983319521, -0.008854605257511139, -0.08286813646554947, -0.027301833033561707, -0.009630140848457813, -0.04934051260352135, 0.005531946197152138, 0.014814875088632107, -0.026385724544525146, -0.008842998184263706, -0.01988942176103592, -0.009217368438839912, 0.000024237955585704185, 0.02631491981446743, -0.00780103262513876, 0.0625547394156456, 0.021882161498069763, 0.03516518697142601, 0.03367204964160919, 0.001987565541639924, 0.11283260583877563, 0.08121883124113083, 0.03754202648997307, -0.04662441834807396, 0.01891420967876911, -0.034419260919094086, -0.04612518846988678, -0.03014708310365677, 0.021353719756007195, 0.007901876233518124, -0.0057648345828056335, 0.02544315904378891, 0.05368887633085251, -0.020674211904406548, -0.012393301352858543, 0.029914168640971184, -0.0491601899266243, -0.030274687334895134, -0.02368578501045704, -0.007795039564371109, 0.004305243492126465, -0.004518558271229267, -0.02711811475455761, 0.046207308769226074, -0.004622075706720352, -0.0222491342574358, -0.034229572862386703, -0.032338377088308334, -0.0014649422373622656, -0.026720216497778893, -0.00723891519010067, 0.011270683258771896, 0.02810855209827423, 0.010767770931124687, 0.0027147247456014156, 0.0008297290769405663, 0.0024189408868551254, 0.002429098589345813, 0.019907841458916664, 0.006665642838925123, -0.0332685187458992, 0.04581928253173828, 0.01780669018626213, 0.0023565252777189016, -0.042765017598867416, -0.039667993783950806, -0.029065556824207306, 0.02647382579743862, 0.005151769146323204, 0.02243218570947647, -0.006546376273036003, -0.009434856474399567, -0.004500770941376686, -0.027639133855700493, -0.0379156693816185, 0.01414579153060913, 0.06253165751695633, 0.004666312597692013, -0.019882729277014732, 0.014264054596424103, 0.01310428325086832, -0.002404503058642149, 0.050671350210905075, -0.0012413423974066973, -0.059817712754011154, -0.0039610122330486774, 0.0017072666669264436, 0.04603390395641327, 0.008610920049250126, -0.00462431600317359, -0.036262039095163345, -0.0345279797911644, 0.015569507144391537, -0.06390777975320816, 0.0038694716058671474, -0.029407987371087074, 0.04102901741862297, 0.029314305633306503, -0.008789407089352608, 0.02209414169192314, -0.053523898124694824, -0.016075918450951576, -0.05182477459311485, 0.025735190138220787, -0.04250764474272728, -0.021557074040174484, 0.008873486891388893, 0.022941038012504578, 0.025514747947454453, 0.017566878348588943, 0.0019761817529797554, 0.07067345082759857, 0.023416120558977127, -0.019041351974010468, -0.008583600632846355, -0.03463013470172882, -0.028883587568998337, 0.017030254006385803, 0.0032503476832062006, 0.019535072147846222, 0.01500834058970213, 0.0462631992995739, 0.035918787121772766, 0.029724789783358574, -0.04711834713816643, -0.0073441448621451855, 0.028668617829680443, -0.05433107912540436, -0.005398151930421591, 0.04992097616195679, 0.017989126965403557, -0.03134320303797722, -0.026945052668452263, -0.0020815471652895212, 0.003102771705016494, 0.03902123123407364, -0.0038036981131881475, -0.02014690265059471, -0.04434555023908615, 0.009941212832927704, 0.042848315089941025, -0.014175997115671635, -0.03221671283245087, 0.0031182444654405117, 0.03854809328913689, 0.010740193538367748, -0.025326592847704887, -0.055892981588840485, -0.010571382008492947, -0.00866125151515007, 0.0015872381627559662, 0.011868830770254135, 0.0002576594415586442, 0.013751300051808357, -0.01752600446343422, 0.030817678198218346, -0.02629748173058033, 0.03292468935251236, -0.03118066117167473, -0.012787318788468838, 0.04597180336713791, -0.05282909795641899, -0.012833790853619576, 0.026566991582512856, -0.0049404967576265335, 0.044976137578487396, 0.015784669667482376, -0.02014613151550293, -0.04372698441147804, 0.04183567687869072, -0.052346523851156235, -0.013292494229972363, -0.019891364499926567, 0.03561718016862869, -0.004590766504406929, -0.018136072903871536, 0.016171226277947426, -0.005246995948255062, -0.020055226981639862, 0.025388604030013084, 0.047824613749980927, -0.015761440619826317, -0.0009860295103862882, 0.02806806191802025, -0.0011981995776295662, 0.008914360776543617, 0.012756730429828167, -0.00568888196721673, 0.03407825902104378, 0.05509311333298683, -0.029624784365296364, 0.039231520146131516, -0.004741705488413572, 0.008885116316378117, -0.09809248149394989, -0.008030496537685394, 0.02555130235850811, 0.0028176959604024887, 0.07298727333545685, -0.037208542227745056, -0.003310726722702384, 0.02679562196135521, -0.06953904032707214, 0.019768565893173218, 0.022323213517665863, -0.030282488092780113, -0.06471935659646988, 0.031137211248278618, -0.00045398264774121344, 0.03896988928318024, -0.011389132589101791, 0.022268099710345268, 0.03236830607056618, 0.046924784779548645, -0.015498760156333447, -0.05176220461726189, -0.008135453797876835, 0.04356690123677254, -0.017100924625992775, -0.06722543388605118, 0.04127318784594536, -0.03382764756679535, -0.019704895094037056, 0.017274223268032074, -0.00788702629506588, -0.0015658135525882244, 0.010811710730195045, 0.027467556297779083, -0.006475559901446104, 0.050568170845508575, 0.02838335745036602, 0.005753484088927507, 0.06123180314898491, -0.0067222812213003635, 0.042240727692842484, -0.008474466390907764, -0.047186583280563354, -0.007977995090186596, 0.07805968075990677, -0.011140622198581696, -0.04730377346277237, -0.008061179891228676, 0.02686265856027603, -0.016066132113337517, -0.007003909908235073, 0.002628658665344119, 0.007926065474748611, -0.04912705346941948, 0.050121620297431946, -0.01925594173371792, -0.011994247324764729, 0.03065657988190651, 0.05629026144742966, -0.02300955355167389, 0.0040008267387747765, 0.038794226944446564, -0.04749676212668419, 0.014381149783730507, 0.020748842507600784, -0.017958058044314384, -0.07535066455602646, -0.02665923349559307, -0.003746972419321537, 0.01980837620794773, -0.021714158356189728, -0.03842116519808769, -0.035056717693805695, 0.028494540601968765, 0.03551560640335083, 0.03282349929213524, 0.010981389321386814, -0.0387316457927227, -0.003432326251640916, -0.08224301785230637, 0.02049100585281849, -0.0014411312295123935, -0.0027420418336987495, -0.018031327053904533, 0.0048448736779391766, -0.020312752574682236, -0.0336032509803772, 0.06558029353618622, 0.0540229007601738, -0.011685012839734554, 0.015704486519098282, 0.061125729233026505, 0.004916904028505087, -0.06654402613639832, 0.010589664801955223, -0.054731085896492004, -0.06170562282204628, -0.04178639501333237, -0.026970624923706055, 0.009378032758831978, -0.0030721460934728384, -0.016882682219147682, -0.01953473500907421, -0.0007937953341752291, 0.028417255729436874, 0.029517244547605515, 0.029452957212924957, 0.0012233604211360216, -0.03768974170088768, 0.052943430840969086, -0.0076086679473519325, -0.016328804194927216, 0.004882080480456352, 0.019012106582522392, -0.06284628063440323, 0.030553018674254417, -0.04905544966459274, -0.0315701998770237, -0.0222314540296793, 0.04416361823678017, -0.006453351117670536, -0.048368699848651886, 0.010307393036782742, 0.05086043104529381, -0.026417700573801994, -0.01847613789141178, 0.03657647967338562, 0.036239102482795715, 0.05008099228143692, 0.00553869316354394, 0.011098370887339115, 0.00701258284971118, 0.006763114593923092, 0.01626935414969921, 0.032914359122514725, 0.003782582702115178, -0.03266317769885063, 0.005658808164298534, 0.0075593669898808, -0.05168038234114647, 0.029401808977127075, -0.02821485884487629, 0.032330188900232315, -0.010175453498959541, -0.023295503109693527, 0.043595023453235626, -0.013682227581739426, 0.0165072251111269, -0.0065844859927892685, 0.003961913287639618, 0.0638355165719986, -0.031868502497673035, -0.005985138937830925, -0.04466449096798897, -0.0023388422559946775, -0.02821611985564232, -0.02040586620569229, 0.030297506600618362, 0.02354930154979229, -0.007243317551910877, 0.030262060463428497, 0.00806629192084074, 0.017397869378328323, 0.027638239786028862, -0.03621157631278038, 0.048852723091840744, 0.025845453143119812, 0.01516024861484766, -0.05580386146903038, -0.026745276525616646, -0.025802351534366608, -0.00427005672827363, 0.01743047684431076, 0.025288673117756844, 0.015284307301044464, 0.02626446820795536, -0.02901136316359043, -0.005117333028465509, 0.033464204519987106, -0.04176957160234451, -0.04306289181113243, -0.0769324079155922, -0.0034700471442192793, -0.014518020674586296, 0.025138158351182938 ]
<p>I have to write code to implement regression using random forests (by default Weka provides random forests for classification). Is this possible to do? </p>
73,920
[ -0.020164892077445984, -0.028669264167547226, -0.00019019251340068877, 0.012668675743043423, 0.03164790943264961, 0.01007177121937275, -0.02596345543861389, -0.02564474195241928, 0.027462944388389587, -0.04066797345876694, 0.02390790916979313, 0.04429098963737488, 0.027953779324889183, 0.019958917051553726, 0.01886567659676075, 0.0220005102455616, -0.005195599049329758, 0.01252432819455862, 0.01142897643148899, -0.018255755305290222, -0.02553459443151951, 0.0507655031979084, 0.006391760427504778, 0.0002875252685043961, -0.01151574868708849, 0.05349159613251686, 0.04173387214541435, -0.01107542309910059, -0.011117645539343357, 0.027500290423631668, -0.02233351767063141, -0.03578086569905281, 0.029161669313907623, 0.06785039603710175, 0.04144429787993431, -0.00873249676078558, -0.034190211445093155, -0.048171814531087875, -0.025224871933460236, 0.011158674024045467, 0.02230541594326496, 0.004609592258930206, 0.011100610718131065, 0.03295439854264259, -0.006079838145524263, 0.027289295569062233, -0.02412285842001438, -0.05668724328279495, 0.0037719043903052807, -0.040748972445726395, 0.06956442445516586, -0.014678383246064186, 0.044308364391326904, 0.06443899869918823, -0.021978184580802917, -0.0031107875984162092, 0.04066431522369385, 0.06346748024225235, -0.015241476707160473, -0.01947036385536194, -0.009858178906142712, -0.03574264422059059, 0.009109094738960266, -0.006071804091334343, -0.028703615069389343, -0.005009871907532215, -0.0031838850118219852, -0.02718474715948105, 0.011921465396881104, -0.0238245390355587, 0.035929955542087555, -0.0011915351497009397, 0.037852056324481964, -0.01958075352013111, 0.02249097265303135, -0.010531865991652012, -0.005627756472676992, 0.02456425316631794, 0.02266525849699974, -0.006106032989919186, -0.02513868175446987, 0.022884588688611984, 0.02068544551730156, -0.0045190779492259026, 0.010113445110619068, -0.001047445461153984, 0.04191070795059204, -0.004490104969590902, 0.01628905162215233, 0.05326899141073227, 0.001617067027837038, -0.014867202378809452, 0.042101576924324036, 0.03348643705248833, -0.045257262885570526, 0.01506178267300129, 0.003237595548853278, 0.04845612496137619, 0.018397705629467964, 0.0008288137032650411, 0.05375625938177109, -0.022656669840216637, -0.006130507215857506, 0.03436247631907463, -0.07697355002164841, -0.0346156470477581, -0.019525524228811264, -0.006034529767930508, 0.006963526830077171, -0.005421224981546402, -0.04489113762974739, 0.01601048931479454, -0.000488552323076874, -0.04776708036661148, 0.04388225078582764, -0.001711145043373108, -0.02602144330739975, 0.0011342280777171254, 0.025113023817539215, 0.07659897208213806, 0.028586462140083313, -0.06526187807321548, 0.018031734973192215, -0.001850730273872614, -0.039938561618328094, 0.017319999635219574, -0.026666143909096718, -0.02237716317176819, -0.04663333669304848, 0.020168449729681015, -0.03503567725419998, -0.03545595705509186, 0.03900005668401718, -0.0006569635588675737, 0.027531050145626068, 0.00374629907310009, -0.06454245746135712, -0.05881523713469505, -0.008838034234941006, -0.02376684918999672, 0.033387068659067154, -0.04588468745350838, 0.03418925777077675, 0.03590017929673195, 0.05871393531560898, 0.04968162253499031, 0.047108687460422516, 0.02147575095295906, 0.0025644979905337095, -0.03222924843430519, -0.0097978999838233, -0.020355641841888428, -0.04322431981563568, 0.0037470199167728424, -0.021229375153779984, -0.08569451421499252, 0.003409791039302945, 0.0029382070060819387, -0.014801197685301304, -0.007293356582522392, 0.011935202404856682, -0.02580174058675766, -0.0005994754610583186, 0.006935644894838333, -0.00981440395116806, -0.030467737466096878, 0.05577811226248741, 0.020687909796833992, 0.0670793429017067, -0.001425477908924222, -0.022209366783499718, 0.017274601384997368, 0.04038645699620247, 0.03839603066444397, 0.07348877191543579, 0.014659789390861988, -0.02361096814274788, -0.0070523968897759914, 0.05061842501163483, -0.014909652993083, -0.0334126278758049, -0.03431006148457527, 0.02758566476404667, -0.0005487767048180103, 0.00023264424817170948, 0.045341163873672485, 0.0052750008180737495, -0.015979401767253876, 0.042627595365047455, -0.056875064969062805, -0.014791889116168022, -0.049788009375333786, 0.017661189660429955, -0.019765926524996758, 0.0005498186219483614, 0.00942212250083685, 0.012241203337907791, 0.016039272770285606, -0.01658661477267742, -0.04925918951630592, -0.03622893616557121, 0.00933412928134203, 0.03839854523539543, -0.03093661740422249, -0.03202269598841667, 0.04609435796737671, 0.021192077547311783, -0.024556230753660202, 0.07776911556720734, -0.04007598012685776, -0.07240220159292221, 0.021019848063588142, -0.04023810103535652, -0.024620383977890015, -0.009832363575696945, -0.010504033416509628, 0.03963587433099747, 0.021836472675204277, -0.012565999291837215, 0.006699107121676207, -0.049183376133441925, 0.06162749603390694, 0.07518503814935684, 0.03794567659497261, -0.0019354568794369698, -0.02596532180905342, 0.01105843111872673, -0.01303462777286768, -0.01933993212878704, -0.02156558446586132, -0.04724713787436485, -0.013876196928322315, 0.027913430705666542, 0.0007009421242401004, -0.07621332257986069, 0.006809039507061243, 0.06971766799688339, 0.03224907070398331, 0.04263554513454437, 0.029996132478117943, -0.007738387677818537, 0.03548181429505348, -0.018442252650856972, -0.007328307721763849, 0.0257035493850708, 0.0006679959478788078, -0.012896274216473103, 0.01594533957540989, 0.019391531124711037, 0.01258770003914833, -0.026825591921806335, 0.03188840299844742, -0.0005330790299922228, 0.006701442878693342, 0.006135111209005117, -0.07968784123659134, 0.02726600505411625, -0.016674963757395744, 0.03923153132200241, 0.021880224347114563, 0.02762114629149437, -0.00795640517026186, 0.022784672677516937, -0.01345937792211771, 0.013739597983658314, 0.05891463905572891, -0.023493899032473564, 0.011698303744196892, 0.035409774631261826, -0.045472122728824615, 0.025171399116516113, -0.0006946625071577728, -0.006936420686542988, -0.07677601277828217, 0.02282932586967945, 0.008116398006677628, -0.0025706004817038774, 0.017928948625922203, 0.010896862484514713, -0.012973856180906296, 0.02497771754860878, -0.030265849083662033, -0.002680043922737241, -0.013529256917536259, -0.0330699160695076, 0.007269914727658033, 0.010664103552699089, -0.015038511715829372, 0.01942746713757515, -0.007976473309099674, -0.035661425441503525, 0.048696428537368774, -0.04386245831847191, -0.051352359354496, -0.036111995577812195, -0.04272623732686043, 0.04792121797800064, -0.005877326708287001, -0.00044378440361469984, 0.026367783546447754, -0.02432924322783947, -0.03202175721526146, 0.005563992541283369, 0.0075402045622467995, -0.0159241184592247, -0.018440118059515953, -0.043042708188295364, -0.011187399737536907, -0.006215687841176987, 0.015676045790314674, 0.017543692141771317, -0.0484008751809597, 0.008642548695206642, -0.04978805407881737, -0.06233445927500725, 0.057788390666246414, 0.002577459439635277, 0.03199296444654465, 0.021939653903245926, -0.0012642503716051579, 0.06851495802402496, 0.007874038070440292, -0.03671189770102501, -0.032739680260419846, -0.018331468105316162, -0.018600720912218094, -0.04176126420497894, 0.012174905277788639, -0.006743479520082474, 0.004748782142996788, 0.015388206578791142, -0.026252422481775284, 0.00020110310288146138, 0.07417625188827515, -0.012615556828677654, -0.024938875809311867, 0.023467672988772392, 0.015885522589087486, 0.021222641691565514, 0.04467987269163132, -0.006759522017091513, -0.03564407303929329, 0.008238645270466805, -0.027538534253835678, 0.011839362792670727, 0.042619023472070694, -0.022432850673794746, 0.005687746684998274, -0.016135066747665405, 0.027593165636062622, -0.03569694980978966, 0.03043914958834648, -0.0129705760627985, -0.03007441759109497, -0.00873113889247179, 0.0030066913459450006, 0.058209262788295746, -0.005221116356551647, -0.001833960646763444, 0.0114845409989357, 0.03448051959276199, 0.006250152364373207, -0.014970619231462479, -0.010052772238850594, -0.02091038040816784, 0.027182405814528465, 0.027934275567531586, 0.001515831216238439, 0.09292247146368027, 0.03787360340356827, 0.025414880365133286, 0.01626463234424591, -0.04187369719147682, 0.002600464504212141, -0.0339641310274601, 0.019727392122149467, -0.008374842815101147, 0.029676036909222603, -0.001960665686056018, 0.009485257789492607, -0.0038557499647140503, -0.013135264627635479, 0.04196396470069885, -0.005408507771790028, -0.054724182933568954, 0.006152644753456116, -0.030006159096956253, -0.02121712639927864, 0.0024888592306524515, -0.042780861258506775, -0.004393791314214468, -0.03417865186929703, 0.012255643494427204, -0.021318603307008743, -0.023220395669341087, -0.024407057091593742, 0.0023635325487703085, 0.004809318110346794, -0.03032742626965046, 0.0049298470839858055, 0.00597981084138155, 0.001076232991181314, -0.02495722286403179, 0.015222987160086632, 0.02271883934736252, 0.007508826907724142, -0.013807035982608795, -0.012803585268557072, -0.011000744998455048, -0.01075692567974329, 0.04794646427035332, 0.04963340982794762, -0.0031857360154390335, -0.06480591744184494, 0.025128711014986038, -0.008186462335288525, 0.020959215238690376, 0.04546194151043892, 0.0012171673588454723, -0.008608841337263584, -0.015494716353714466, -0.020954102277755737, -0.0016384455375373363, 0.021139083430171013, 0.007651408202946186, 0.00045789574505761266, 0.026682749390602112, -0.0024645859375596046, -0.08848661184310913, -0.015402741730213165, 0.09307991713285446, -0.00694148289039731, -0.02237887680530548, -0.017756856977939606, 0.012477903626859188, 0.024517059326171875, -0.012798858806490898, 0.033457428216934204, 0.021473541855812073, -0.028812898322939873, 0.015804577618837357, 0.017018970102071762, -0.04535955935716629, -0.0022893596906214952, 0.01314170565456152, 0.023543421179056168, 0.07214441895484924, -0.007100093178451061, -0.031279176473617554, 0.007477275561541319, 0.06125567480921745, -0.007097868248820305, 0.01630680076777935, 0.02349943108856678, -0.10710468143224716, 0.00524155655875802, 0.05114908143877983, 0.01757451705634594, -0.050257161259651184, -0.0008115388336591423, -0.014199500903487206, -0.008887060917913914, 0.05178268626332283, -0.006378124933689833, 0.0036001394037157297, 0.010264505632221699, 0.0234342273324728, -0.0015891494695097208, 0.012903074733912945, -0.033066291362047195, 0.05187506228685379, -0.04841490089893341, 0.029840359464287758, 0.0005782733205705881, -0.04031879082322121, -0.03495010361075401, 0.01739078387618065, 0.03412843495607376, 0.08910834044218063, 0.010822633281350136, 0.009368404746055603, -0.017042862251400948, 0.016015322878956795, -0.016956444829702377, -0.07170286774635315, -0.007654614746570587, 0.021914279088377953, -0.002025710418820381, 0.04570009186863899, -0.002435211790725589, -0.02942206710577011, 0.01759677194058895, 0.03297220170497894, -0.05016208440065384, -0.03450988605618477, -0.011205598711967468, 0.022191742435097694, 0.03940877690911293, -0.005294642876833677, 0.05713074281811714, 0.06900081038475037, 0.012605998665094376, -0.022303929552435875, -0.014266991056501865, 0.02388930320739746, -0.03632495924830437, -0.008160337805747986, -0.016679372638463974, -0.021176766604185104, -0.020437195897102356, -0.031951505690813065, 0.015003839507699013, 0.020452406257390976, -0.017607349902391434, -0.016243772581219673, -0.018851157277822495, 0.043479546904563904, -0.0013656712835654616, -0.018365897238254547, -0.010498154908418655, -0.010660361498594284, -0.02406809851527214, -0.03426726907491684, 0.0013730162754654884, 0.020376302301883698, 0.023891450837254524, 0.0116306496784091, -0.022222189232707024, 0.00784589909017086, -0.042670294642448425, -0.02884412370622158, -0.01843125931918621, -0.05324844270944595, 0.054231442511081696, -0.0009008991182781756, 0.029105931520462036, -0.010322163812816143, -0.05147211253643036, -0.011433809995651245, 0.020300094038248062, 0.006409121211618185, 0.03308671712875366, -0.039020322263240814, 0.04064444079995155, -0.03001062572002411, -0.016997935250401497, -0.03619210422039032, -0.025938402861356735, 0.005372022278606892, 0.0006465184269472957, -0.0192228052765131, -0.022893093526363373, 0.024477645754814148, -0.013185822404921055, -0.014201657846570015, -0.0032683147583156824, 0.06505204737186432, -0.03281121701002121, 0.006112708244472742, -0.011348509229719639, 0.005884828045964241, 0.05958885699510574, 0.014578672125935555, 0.02088196761906147, 0.031118452548980713, -0.019016718491911888, -0.025197912007570267, 0.01144071202725172, 0.01748077943921089, -0.03367040678858757, 0.019523832947015762, -0.041901975870132446, 0.0060332478024065495, 0.04397250711917877, 0.004178865812718868, 0.027756698429584503, 0.022588128224015236, 0.01248414721339941, 0.008393049240112305, -0.05130038037896156, 0.03109869919717312, 0.01963973417878151, -0.03938281536102295, -0.012134968303143978, 0.0019527004333212972, 0.006614772602915764, 0.03868299350142479, 0.02619151771068573, 0.028378823772072792, -0.0017738965107128024, 0.0012154050637036562, 0.04706975445151329, -0.04137054458260536, 0.013270995579659939, 0.002708216430619359, -0.03700168430805206, 0.0015667285770177841, 0.0006669992581009865, 0.011326919309794903, 0.010323789902031422, 0.0464911013841629, -0.03421463817358017, -0.015169980004429817, -0.03716522455215454, -0.030410312116146088, 0.08798675984144211, -0.007485624868422747, 0.05170729383826256, 0.047805797308683395, 0.028790723532438278, -0.009990139864385128, -0.041260574012994766, -0.042427342385053635, 0.0009900652803480625, -0.022777698934078217, 0.05383843556046486, 0.043764784932136536, 0.048880450427532196, 0.032034166157245636, 0.003857739269733429, 0.025168931111693382, 0.05701258033514023, -0.0005528575275093317, 0.009966216050088406, 0.007806549314409494, 0.005302519537508488, -0.03294370323419571, 0.019955433905124664, -0.04322004318237305, -0.008270266465842724, -0.010341809131205082, -0.04071267321705818, 0.055953990668058395, 0.028300167992711067, 0.00377444620244205, -0.02709130197763443, -0.028420353308320045, -0.05195167288184166, 0.038697753101587296, -0.0269616786390543, 0.008782095275819302, 0.028155820444226265, 0.04467181861400604, -0.0006477338029071689, -0.017920436337590218, -0.006316286511719227, -0.026678582653403282, -0.0826379805803299, -0.0483839176595211, -0.037429384887218475, -0.026919331401586533, 0.047081269323825836, 0.01846770942211151, -0.0544462613761425, 0.015565210022032261, -0.018262818455696106, 0.02442365698516369, 0.016035718843340874, 0.08077443391084671, 0.033799897879362106, 0.04558403044939041, 0.03178955987095833, 0.005212223622947931, 0.01983894780278206, 0.018116218969225883, 0.12379156053066254, 0.07802324742078781, 0.056772246956825256, -0.04899945482611656, 0.007524940650910139, -0.023721784353256226, -0.035502202808856964, -0.025705164298415184, 0.0037591159343719482, 0.009179274551570415, -0.014865369535982609, 0.02719101496040821, -0.006753099616616964, 0.021223457530140877, -0.03095552884042263, 0.05895860493183136, -0.00989842601120472, -0.01592070609331131, 0.008398403413593769, -0.0022014924325048923, 0.04395122453570366, 0.020364010706543922, -0.05970209464430809, 0.016510222107172012, -0.01774967461824417, -0.048927370458841324, -0.01297629065811634, -0.025202404707670212, 0.02019326202571392, -0.0003867625491693616, -0.03162647411227226, -0.018284741789102554, 0.020454509183764458, 0.02162346802651882, -0.009643805213272572, 0.017874140292406082, 0.01477867178618908, -0.0022684100549668074, -0.00818207859992981, 0.002604086883366108, 0.04974113404750824, -0.044196490198373795, -0.004697928670793772, 0.01071220077574253, -0.04816862940788269, -0.013142384588718414, -0.020876027643680573, 0.021314432844519615, -0.0012591073755174875, -0.035860735923051834, -0.02599429339170456, 0.009612170979380608, 0.014338108710944653, -0.067939393222332, 0.016428017988801003, 0.0358099527657032, 0.03982207924127579, -0.009429076686501503, -0.028741182759404182, 0.007100523449480534, 0.0372450165450573, -0.032083094120025635, 0.022319257259368896, -0.000989435357041657, -0.02955731563270092, 0.011991278268396854, -0.05009939521551132, 0.01783708482980728, -0.011831670999526978, -0.011265695095062256, -0.005448224954307079, -0.004742390941828489, -0.010881592519581318, -0.021507125347852707, 0.0462847575545311, 0.003985031507909298, -0.015128910541534424, -0.024987956508994102, -0.015973016619682312, -0.0178968645632267, -0.046022962778806686, -0.009868002496659756, -0.05052568018436432, 0.0047508301213383675, -0.06619299203157425, 0.004281953442841768, 0.03418216109275818, 0.06860730797052383, 0.02323022112250328, -0.01928778365254402, 0.0014467410510405898, 0.034997232258319855, -0.003745289519429207, -0.0454813651740551, -0.03227896988391876, -0.004361035767942667, -0.07087179273366928, 0.030644753947854042, 0.020281082019209862, 0.08252628147602081, 0.05309395119547844, 0.015074414201080799, -0.018879065290093422, 0.012962888926267624, -0.028966771438717842, 0.0352247953414917, 0.006358054466545582, -0.033736538141965866, -0.0063982028514146805, -0.016701696440577507, 0.008366729132831097, -0.01857364922761917, -0.02347676455974579, -0.042336929589509964, -0.04516095295548439, -0.012211878784000874, 0.009682848118245602, -0.024671591818332672, 0.027123935520648956, -0.010398856364190578, 0.017647279426455498, -0.041385747492313385, -0.006205181125551462, -0.04299696534872055, -0.02267080917954445, 0.021673066541552544, -0.03943305090069771, -0.019218577072024345, -0.018280893564224243, 0.012141283601522446, 0.024491623044013977, 0.05872977897524834, 0.030177734792232513, 0.00866589043289423, 0.02796514518558979, 0.00233062612824142, -0.04782610759139061, 0.03506840392947197, -0.04182572662830353, -0.037724126130342484, 0.029607094824314117, -0.04421970993280411, -0.002770507475361228, 0.015916261821985245, -0.009140007197856903, 0.05096011236310005, 0.04690878465771675, -0.012494232505559921, -0.011864793486893177, 0.06019725650548935, 0.004792263265699148, -0.01562409196048975, -0.004839112516492605, -0.0035306629724800587, 0.018694447353482246, 0.000919068232178688, 0.04160883277654648, -0.008045660331845284, -0.015269189141690731, -0.004686279222369194, 0.05424036085605621, 0.037997663021087646, -0.02528075873851776, 0.052823618054389954, 0.026702826842665672, 0.0016724250745028257, 0.0324743278324604, -0.02821243554353714, 0.02232873998582363, 0.02517949603497982, -0.02729763463139534, 0.04782494902610779, -0.011597977951169014, 0.022331323474645615, -0.08580806106328964, -0.03676612675189972, 0.03662971034646034, 0.005339185241609812, 0.030903659760951996, -0.04571068659424782, -0.0029883503448218107, 0.028592396527528763, -0.03722349554300308, 0.002740733325481415, 0.01227651722729206, -0.04625321924686432, -0.035748206079006195, 0.05515621230006218, -0.0042275176383554935, 0.005564315710216761, 0.05295135825872421, 0.049219947308301926, 0.011737482622265816, 0.017498407512903214, 0.0009224507375620306, -0.015397579409182072, -0.03214552253484726, 0.005351652856916189, 0.016396082937717438, -0.04629608243703842, 0.02286141738295555, -0.046950459480285645, -0.023990554735064507, 0.01331594679504633, -0.022204240784049034, 0.032485704869031906, 0.06441818922758102, 0.026321271434426308, 0.03810765594244003, 0.014743505977094173, 0.03524801507592201, 0.0030029218178242445, -0.008224020712077618, -0.02981274574995041, 0.004651367664337158, -0.009601698257029057, -0.014326319098472595, 0.046288274228572845, 0.006702057085931301, -0.011300412006676197, 0.0028252373449504375, 0.032843366265296936, -0.011421320959925652, -0.039312489330768585, -0.023581814020872116, 0.01661810837686062, -0.014252829365432262, -0.027412032708525658, -0.02464919537305832, -0.05028586462140083, 0.02789045125246048, 0.028663579374551773, -0.00405021570622921, -0.031222740188241005, -0.001910834340378642, -0.018430357798933983, -0.04025110602378845, 0.01320264395326376, -0.0007199879619292915, -0.01812465488910675, -0.0509796105325222, 0.007543785497546196, -0.0031434069387614727, -0.0410335399210453, -0.023774532601237297, -0.015279341489076614, 0.00689428998157382, 0.0190897136926651, -0.013055702671408653, -0.004675168078392744, 0.04909172281622887, 0.0024124488700181246, 0.026373809203505516, -0.055162955075502396, 0.07158670574426651, 0.015248800627887249, -0.016017122194170952, -0.0483534075319767, 0.006123657338321209, -0.027348950505256653, -0.0024083068128675222, 0.04674426093697548, -0.025901073589920998, 0.05258386954665184, -0.036410413682460785, 0.0375056229531765, 0.0057571218349039555, -0.05295971781015396, 0.04679494723677635, -0.02767978049814701, -0.038976967334747314, -0.022515833377838135, -0.03484884649515152, 0.00828362163156271, 0.02140013501048088, 0.0063823796808719635, 0.02804429829120636, -0.0009045052574947476, 0.00879453495144844, -0.005028240382671356, 0.03246821463108063, -0.022343069314956665, 0.025254089385271072, 0.040642570704221725, -0.012512818910181522, -0.0007300335564650595, 0.03755809739232063, 0.010804546996951103, -0.014012045226991177, 0.027555756270885468, -0.05228777229785919, -0.021734345704317093, -0.03060285560786724, -0.0008530758204869926, -0.012546973302960396, -0.07906372100114822, -0.023994751274585724, 0.029677100479602814, -0.045440059155225754, 0.018436377868056297, 0.043322525918483734, -0.014342629350721836, 0.04428916797041893, -0.0030561708845198154, -0.013260174542665482, 0.019589995965361595, 0.000932761759031564, 0.011922640725970268, 0.014304758049547672, 0.011627687141299248, -0.00043242363608442247, 0.051018502563238144, 0.03698338568210602, -0.005015664733946323, 0.013326938264071941, 0.006597463507205248, 0.03273734077811241, -0.026299139484763145, 0.006764607969671488, -0.02934945747256279, -0.0019611231982707977, 0.03411377593874931, 0.02177775464951992, -0.01876239851117134, 0.06384283304214478, -0.04417463392019272, -0.01276046596467495, -0.0804678276181221, -0.03729287534952164, -0.023863835260272026, 0.0037073621060699224, 0.008226796984672546, 0.005723397247493267, -0.02116253785789013, 0.004412745125591755, 0.008591405116021633, 0.015161438845098019, 0.02656329795718193, -0.035952258855104446, 0.0020700625609606504, -0.011744154617190361, -0.022457648068666458, -0.033921174705028534, -0.01915169693529606, -0.004713683854788542, -0.020297711715102196, 0.02793538011610508, 0.03313422575592995, 0.01544155739247799, -0.012173021212220192, -0.00958160124719143, -0.017123598605394363, 0.0305122472345829, -0.062017492949962616, -0.00682284077629447, -0.02486111782491207, 0.031907182186841965, -0.005425690673291683, -0.028101887553930283 ]
<p>I was hoping someone could propose an argument explaining why the random variables $Y_1=X_2-X_1$ and $Y_2=X_1+X_2$, $X_i$ having the standard normal distribution, are statistically independent. The proof for that fact follows easily from the MGF technique, yet I find it extremely counter-intuitive.</p> <p>I would appreciate therefore the intuition here, if any.</p> <p>Thank you in advance.</p> <p><strong>EDIT</strong>: The subscripts do not indicate Order Statistics but IID observations from the standard normal distrubution. </p>
36,470
[ -0.028976310044527054, -0.012054147198796272, -0.02845996432006359, -0.013076546601951122, 0.031935915350914, 0.013592848554253578, 0.010629151947796345, 0.02311876229941845, 0.037844181060791016, -0.04945271089673042, 0.041101615875959396, 0.0005310569540597498, 0.0576595738530159, 0.006420593708753586, 0.038906022906303406, 0.01920289732515812, -0.019912533462047577, 0.04915139079093933, 0.012606838718056679, -0.014039535075426102, -0.012006949633359909, 0.04663655534386635, 0.04918151721358299, -0.02942647598683834, -0.040417011827230453, 0.007594457361847162, -0.022749265655875206, -0.031265243887901306, 0.012379935942590237, 0.059491705149412155, -0.028499575331807137, -0.017851272597908974, -0.005223500542342663, 0.049848269671201706, -0.006468845997005701, -0.02846253104507923, -0.011273661628365517, 0.0015281327068805695, 0.032525599002838135, 0.00968621764332056, -0.03288464993238449, -0.02034663036465645, -0.006949628237634897, 0.023380998522043228, -0.03419026359915733, 0.013624102808535099, -0.007132087834179401, -0.032247528433799744, 0.028187384828925133, -0.05128604546189308, 0.07449087500572205, -0.041054073721170425, 0.04640229046344757, 0.04063067585229874, 0.001494081923738122, -0.0016007411759346724, 0.002636115299537778, 0.054600972682237625, 0.0009154065046459436, -0.04550494998693466, -0.007418332155793905, -0.003172283060848713, -0.007028642576187849, 0.0024139906745404005, -0.01984160579741001, 0.0007349601364694536, -0.000978808500804007, -0.005896924063563347, 0.013795766979455948, -0.037304431200027466, 0.022089922800660133, 0.05339731648564339, 0.03609514608979225, -0.0191184114664793, -0.017689960077404976, -0.0025092684663832188, 0.05124403163790703, -0.008183883503079414, 0.025540484115481377, 0.015546602196991444, 0.016719216480851173, 0.0162508562207222, 0.041551463305950165, -0.0004064022214151919, 0.015674728900194168, -0.01146665494889021, 0.0717308297753334, -0.003994112368673086, 0.0360625796020031, 0.033694714307785034, 0.004347808659076691, 0.00348693341948092, 0.0548122376203537, -0.004729493521153927, -0.05302640050649643, 0.024497823789715767, -0.033031098544597626, 0.03471609205007553, -0.0008437018841505051, 0.007027565501630306, -0.044795118272304535, -0.05634482204914093, 0.030963275581598282, 0.07891499251127243, -0.015054435469210148, -0.024212753400206566, -0.023842347785830498, 0.07086588442325592, -0.0064682853408157825, 0.0015288139693439007, -0.009070605970919132, -0.006338122766464949, 0.021795660257339478, -0.04795793443918228, 0.01843280903995037, 0.001688653603196144, 0.012377049773931503, 0.004928603768348694, 0.02060171589255333, 0.058384548872709274, 0.05147949606180191, -0.02399677410721779, 0.0007286756299436092, 0.009256759658455849, -0.023660363629460335, 0.023686712607741356, 0.017355674877762794, -0.01580999046564102, -0.041346777230501175, 0.043391332030296326, 0.01065435167402029, -0.005446416791528463, 0.010101916268467903, 0.02004006877541542, 0.01813375949859619, -0.013658931478857994, -0.11529650539159775, -0.03517349809408188, 0.04906288534402847, -0.030860917642712593, 0.0013051459100097418, -0.05823700502514839, 0.022595951333642006, 0.05706951022148132, 0.03260231390595436, -0.011935065500438213, 0.05050061270594597, -0.013670803979039192, 0.03699079155921936, 0.016935188323259354, 0.025013018399477005, -0.045875970274209976, -0.027949152514338493, -0.038270194083452225, -0.026137473061680794, -0.08933264762163162, 0.03993435576558113, -0.015066254884004593, -0.0031547928228974342, -0.026082316413521767, 0.03707517310976982, 0.01683996059000492, 0.013431564904749393, -0.02226671576499939, 0.0317683070898056, -0.03331651911139488, 0.06932666152715683, 0.005940728820860386, 0.006138153374195099, 0.04975315183401108, 0.010632261633872986, 0.044899728149175644, 0.022358069196343422, 0.05033494532108307, 0.006177509669214487, -0.024806182831525803, -0.03482375666499138, -0.0004309557261876762, 0.01737871952354908, 0.002479791874065995, -0.012530121952295303, -0.007870728150010109, -0.04125817492604256, -0.011697209440171719, 0.00721369544044137, 0.05142637714743614, 0.03683513030409813, -0.015122209675610065, 0.02686856873333454, -0.03851507231593132, 0.00850201491266489, -0.06702359020709991, 0.00370998028665781, 0.015019328333437443, -0.024120435118675232, 0.03226328641176224, 0.00831308588385582, 0.036368582397699356, -0.005773251410573721, -0.01068707276135683, -0.01200758758932352, -0.021836696192622185, 0.04108100384473801, -0.01899467222392559, 0.05271700769662857, 0.010446724481880665, 0.0666239857673645, 0.023050755262374878, 0.04599858820438385, -0.0119180241599679, -0.05442119762301445, 0.028957480564713478, -0.05295025557279587, 0.011304682120680809, -0.0004883832880295813, -0.01862405799329281, 0.01930450275540352, -0.01656103879213333, -0.02432500384747982, 0.047856952995061874, -0.048392556607723236, 0.06120103970170021, 0.03592580929398537, -0.012292701750993729, -0.028027920052409172, 0.022774478420615196, 0.0288313627243042, -0.014686619862914085, -0.020082391798496246, -0.021741576492786407, -0.052414558827877045, -0.04875709488987923, 0.030353229492902756, 0.06269561499357224, -0.05347932130098343, 0.029033413156867027, 0.06526032090187073, 0.034681763499975204, 0.018510647118091583, 0.02958601899445057, 0.0020295288413763046, -0.015755709260702133, 0.014839588664472103, 0.025202950462698936, 0.020204782485961914, 0.005471957381814718, 0.01286370400339365, 0.002048787660896778, 0.008705060929059982, -0.005770823452621698, -0.028574207797646523, 0.022150881588459015, -0.009147241711616516, 0.01104437280446291, -0.013174261897802353, -0.01361939962953329, 0.039099182933568954, 0.003776351222768426, 0.015664326027035713, 0.02049066126346588, -0.0013648509047925472, -0.004761136136949062, -0.024703165516257286, 0.008237226866185665, 0.012707255780696869, -0.03665013611316681, -0.03775373101234436, 0.012258125469088554, 0.025859152898192406, -0.031116226688027382, -0.008545400574803352, -0.06668314337730408, -0.06582528352737427, -0.018918577581644058, -0.014888674952089787, 0.00008101993444142863, 0.02984774485230446, 0.021112164482474327, 0.006159656681120396, -0.011031792499125004, -0.02867262251675129, -0.017864897847175598, -0.005707863252609968, -0.008133098483085632, -0.03357937932014465, 0.02239675261080265, -0.0038175967056304216, -0.023576432839035988, 0.04913970082998276, -0.037755850702524185, 0.00021202757488936186, -0.009486387483775616, 0.0041883839294314384, -0.0435766838490963, -0.020881518721580505, -0.07163343578577042, 0.005817015189677477, -0.04296434298157692, -0.02611560933291912, 0.033516451716423035, -0.013385637663304806, -0.02895192615687847, 0.017852194607257843, -0.020459819585084915, -0.048151131719350815, -0.0015355459181591868, -0.0006636739708483219, 0.03828435763716698, -0.016761448234319687, -0.006625402253121138, 0.040332816541194916, -0.03347956761717796, -0.03298468142747879, -0.06275178492069244, -0.08788596838712692, 0.018438534811139107, -0.00023626569600310177, 0.031816866248846054, -0.009348833933472633, -0.06186361238360405, 0.06721767038106918, 0.03311567381024361, -0.013074982911348343, 0.006638143211603165, -0.02303270623087883, -0.0036580944433808327, -0.011726919561624527, 0.044978298246860504, 0.030275048688054085, 0.015542222186923027, 0.07143136858940125, 0.03862057253718376, -0.007339401636272669, 0.04568585753440857, -0.03276335075497627, -0.013903419487178326, -0.010325176641345024, 0.004001889377832413, 0.0074055683799088, 0.029377352446317673, 0.014545715413987637, -0.01564839854836464, -0.00472354656085372, 0.025232205167412758, 0.05997959151864052, 0.01240837387740612, -0.05314336717128754, 0.07313746213912964, -0.03523190692067146, 0.023302428424358368, -0.0725947767496109, 0.043599121272563934, 0.015547795221209526, -0.026535775512456894, -0.004671979229897261, -0.018836887553334236, 0.02930823527276516, -0.04428040236234665, 0.03245756775140762, 0.03265180438756943, 0.03831189498305321, -0.027241097763180733, -0.023493865504860878, -0.04237300530076027, -0.003756677731871605, 0.04403227940201759, -0.005340543109923601, -0.008796606212854385, 0.03814614564180374, 0.016055641695857048, 0.0011169218923896551, -0.028644654899835587, -0.016279585659503937, -0.003484114073216915, -0.11536754667758942, 0.04619717597961426, 0.0008536037639714777, 0.02398836612701416, 0.035560522228479385, 0.0587482713162899, -0.00012617297761607915, -0.01925434172153473, 0.0003928879741579294, -0.008917064405977726, -0.06413297355175018, 0.00564764766022563, -0.032906148582696915, -0.01993001066148281, -0.01914522983133793, -0.014469564892351627, 0.034166060388088226, -0.012875497341156006, 0.0006075261044315994, -0.007361109368503094, 0.005007255356758833, -0.05157585069537163, -0.03200666978955269, -0.045341651886701584, -0.061821792274713516, -0.0022147956769913435, -0.0002488063764758408, 0.013752754777669907, -0.04613465815782547, 0.01755400188267231, 0.026609858497977257, -0.006719386670738459, -0.036292824894189835, -0.0528511218726635, 0.013736818917095661, 0.02130074054002762, 0.0008061584085226059, 0.03451601043343544, 0.0349242277443409, 0.005443810485303402, 0.011715905740857124, -0.009119123220443726, 0.031173916533589363, 0.023283204063773155, 0.004940821323543787, -0.01986497826874256, -0.04986082762479782, -0.03077574260532856, 0.027907513082027435, 0.008432469330728054, 0.016809331253170967, 0.021074878051877022, 0.037389714270830154, 0.04403857886791229, -0.01910283789038658, 0.01189650408923626, 0.05409091338515282, 0.01016256120055914, 0.03366924077272415, -0.05999863147735596, -0.015504809096455574, -0.0572478324174881, -0.010083770379424095, 0.06402351707220078, -0.02019382268190384, -0.006243439391255379, -0.020208260044455528, 0.046724267303943634, -0.0012302352115511894, 0.018696177750825882, -0.0175132118165493, -0.005922284908592701, 0.0671047568321228, 0.022714665159583092, -0.03212135657668114, 0.009371094405651093, 0.031259533017873764, 0.045763902366161346, 0.04355702921748161, -0.015474974177777767, -0.04454084113240242, 0.01561364158987999, 0.027352582663297653, 0.0022452555131167173, -0.02631320059299469, 0.037028271704912186, -0.03515677526593208, -0.013725848868489265, 0.04893695190548897, -0.019607804715633392, 0.026481011882424355, -0.014133838005363941, -0.010891104117035866, 0.0025351971853524446, -0.03343220427632332, -0.06616697460412979, 0.009762827306985855, 0.032016851007938385, 0.007179826032370329, -0.01775653474032879, -0.04045724868774414, -0.0642617717385292, -0.02001059055328369, 0.023899314925074577, 0.0726502537727356, 0.00861890148371458, -0.005476018413901329, 0.014172792434692383, 0.040543317794799805, 0.001936093089170754, -0.06757348775863647, 0.05792933329939842, 0.001119941589422524, 0.01076506357640028, 0.042056962847709656, -0.038963161408901215, -0.05485968291759491, 0.0064024608582258224, 0.018479779362678528, -0.010448098182678223, 0.030461791902780533, 0.020327767357230186, 0.02100454457104206, 0.043520715087652206, -0.000653212598990649, 0.02811463549733162, -0.013934017159044743, -0.01137153897434473, -0.02798527106642723, -0.017542293295264244, 0.04682644084095955, -0.05339570343494415, -0.006309664808213711, -0.045939698815345764, 0.0037170150317251682, -0.0003935314016416669, 0.0158124677836895, 0.0030416897498071194, 0.032103583216667175, -0.028897490352392197, -0.024277349933981895, 0.006084870081394911, 0.016717607155442238, 0.014134049415588379, 0.00699692452326417, -0.009580828249454498, 0.023833047598600388, -0.02273043803870678, -0.016419177874922752, 0.024845417588949203, -0.020880218595266342, -0.0225625429302454, -0.0048422785475850105, -0.01657816581428051, 0.01172629650682211, -0.04171070456504822, -0.038837067782878876, -0.021036718040704727, -0.02960917353630066, 0.020269446074962616, -0.02818560227751732, 0.02506076917052269, 0.018212374299764633, -0.015615282580256462, -0.008411169052124023, 0.030088916420936584, 0.008137698285281658, 0.031797803938388824, -0.05030845105648041, 0.024248726665973663, 0.01877027004957199, -0.021970201283693314, -0.10908795893192291, -0.06762900948524475, -0.023438313975930214, 0.0073279403150081635, -0.005321263801306486, -0.06950467079877853, 0.02207067795097828, 0.004867529962211847, -0.015837157145142555, -0.008167913183569908, 0.028831688687205315, 0.012224262580275536, -0.04827241972088814, 0.009711861610412598, 0.014423173852264881, 0.07701099663972855, -0.025569289922714233, -0.013973512686789036, 0.02471809647977352, -0.04872486740350723, -0.02771010808646679, -0.0137349683791399, 0.015552163124084473, -0.013833119533956051, 0.0055939131416380405, -0.029185723513364792, -0.031025664880871773, -0.004336186684668064, -0.043659575283527374, -0.04996700584888458, -0.0034451710525900126, 0.017402872443199158, 0.00991698820143938, -0.01035285834223032, -0.02453676052391529, 0.0196453258395195, 0.02366623841226101, -0.021348873153328896, -0.011275001801550388, -0.0024763927794992924, -0.025681711733341217, 0.05527524650096893, -0.011997880414128304, -0.018976563587784767, 0.03610660880804062, 0.07076108455657959, 0.009143663570284843, 0.0021163206547498703, 0.01108655333518982, 0.034302614629268646, 0.03344061225652695, -0.004066436551511288, 0.005900462158024311, 0.015075855888426304, -0.0017158053815364838, -0.03337392956018448, -0.012967443093657494, -0.029074005782604218, 0.04218701273202896, 0.061675310134887695, -0.029257886111736298, 0.0563599169254303, 0.018148409202694893, -0.0005631200037896633, -0.031530220061540604, -0.03047965280711651, 0.004942966625094414, -0.015706993639469147, -0.01863526925444603, 0.04995395988225937, -0.03530050069093704, -0.0014659343287348747, 0.033903274685144424, 0.024755196645855904, -0.010242446325719357, -0.01850726269185543, 0.011198737658560276, 0.006759757176041603, 0.022779680788517, 0.0028598452918231487, -0.03374875709414482, 0.03154885768890381, -0.05410978943109512, -0.002387548564001918, -0.017421994358301163, -0.007936423644423485, 0.03940703719854355, -0.013183927163481712, 0.003744198475033045, -0.057419177144765854, -0.04284622520208359, -0.006316603627055883, 0.00859467126429081, 0.006263918709009886, 0.01177824568003416, 0.058662984520196915, -0.0013352719834074378, 0.005122901406139135, -0.0026854113675653934, 0.028873588889837265, -0.005729795899242163, -0.08876655995845795, -0.009436225518584251, -0.030810657888650894, -0.01773417741060257, 0.03501717001199722, -0.019526375457644463, -0.013141311705112457, 0.028042318299412727, -0.048720404505729675, -0.0027537308633327484, 0.03443046286702156, 0.02330694906413555, -0.025381388142704964, 0.07406637072563171, 0.023393303155899048, 0.017649393528699875, 0.012631592340767384, -0.024167777970433235, 0.09573744237422943, 0.04537278786301613, 0.0313761942088604, -0.05766354501247406, 0.011229250580072403, 0.017161989584565163, 0.015300175175070763, -0.03577622026205063, 0.028450967743992805, 0.014414818026125431, 0.011294032447040081, 0.0621754452586174, 0.020965367555618286, 0.015016916207969189, -0.03730671852827072, 0.05064687132835388, -0.046024542301893234, -0.03496972844004631, -0.00463611027225852, 0.02632427029311657, 0.00002704120743146632, -0.03252450376749039, -0.06098781153559685, 0.018425794318318367, -0.02610832452774048, -0.0013640130637213588, -0.016810912638902664, -0.029548633843660355, -0.004698467440903187, 0.01907999999821186, 0.00474967435002327, 0.013394227251410484, 0.045783478766679764, 0.016904637217521667, -0.020371107384562492, 0.02788909338414669, 0.0019905799999833107, -0.03498492389917374, 0.024778012186288834, -0.010795260779559612, 0.012978353537619114, -0.004379916004836559, 0.034698277711868286, -0.011260481551289558, -0.059111692011356354, -0.022484086453914642, -0.026249960064888, 0.03624071180820465, -0.03271665796637535, 0.003311421489343047, -0.03229665383696556, -0.02131633460521698, 0.0022930996492505074, -0.04582969471812248, -0.013478057458996773, 0.0037711123004555702, 0.023614631965756416, -0.022275341674685478, 0.017210379242897034, -0.009161829017102718, 0.04298194870352745, 0.013212996535003185, -0.002154214773327112, 0.03253622725605965, -0.006674119736999273, -0.02763279341161251, 0.008606159128248692, 0.03708285093307495, 0.032515738159418106, -0.02721545659005642, -0.000006627844868489774, -0.007289541885256767, -0.015846241265535355, 0.031090430915355682, -0.014410761184990406, -0.024075262248516083, 0.0200577974319458, 0.024361010640859604, 0.0110704330727458, -0.009342538192868233, -0.009282244369387627, 0.0025844057090580463, -0.020177993923425674, -0.014221667312085629, 0.003411245997995138, -0.004765946418046951, 0.007529904134571552, 0.053386785089969635, 0.03881833702325821, 0.005538839381188154, 0.035167768597602844, 0.0713474303483963, -0.012799982912838459, -0.048561129719018936, -0.028446916490793228, 0.0018610869301483035, -0.007112747989594936, -0.023426925763487816, 0.01745959371328354, 0.03688541799783707, 0.013988609425723553, 0.040905289351940155, -0.009485037066042423, 0.015035185031592846, -0.01597164385020733, 0.022594742476940155, 0.029645267874002457, -0.05100284889340401, 0.003557433607056737, 0.03475106135010719, -0.0031640336383134127, -0.025347063317894936, -0.022542105987668037, 0.025398947298526764, 0.007691273931413889, 0.017450781539082527, -0.006817794870585203, -0.0362236425280571, -0.021450117230415344, 0.01868440769612789, 0.044293150305747986, -0.010871407575905323, -0.011024998500943184, -0.029210058972239494, -0.004331904463469982, -0.02220134250819683, -0.006381920073181391, -0.019663583487272263, 0.022135326638817787, 0.0031126104295253754, -0.024847930297255516, 0.0417490229010582, 0.017328951507806778, 0.018162639811635017, -0.014876683242619038, 0.01585683971643448, -0.018412908539175987, 0.04953671619296074, -0.02580774761736393, 0.001810595509596169, 0.016910387203097343, -0.025357171893119812, -0.005939284805208445, 0.008068101480603218, 0.018524078652262688, 0.033845242112874985, 0.004583802539855242, -0.017820797860622406, -0.03343549370765686, 0.03096495196223259, -0.0272507406771183, -0.011811207048594952, -0.011851182207465172, 0.01023160945624113, 0.00007067533442750573, -0.05052820220589638, -0.005421251058578491, -0.0038541844114661217, -0.004283504094928503, 0.03006976656615734, 0.010081175714731216, -0.007550294976681471, -0.005560079589486122, 0.021867413073778152, 0.016918687149882317, 0.006709315814077854, -0.01110443938523531, 0.017449146136641502, 0.06743039935827255, 0.03353704884648323, -0.022007549181580544, 0.02185758762061596, -0.024611562490463257, 0.032712530344724655, -0.08654195070266724, -0.001243501785211265, 0.03855695202946663, -0.001548504107631743, 0.030930152162909508, -0.030041182413697243, -0.018563222140073776, 0.02693994902074337, -0.0750773623585701, -0.020689863711595535, -0.01935460790991783, -0.03778386116027832, -0.02117428556084633, 0.008357358165085316, -0.014786499552428722, 0.02828390523791313, 0.025764554738998413, 0.042483750730752945, 0.027737416326999664, 0.05516864359378815, 0.002662535523995757, 0.004684830084443092, -0.07099034637212753, -0.016758255660533905, 0.01692797616124153, -0.019427066668868065, 0.04867394268512726, -0.007663680240511894, -0.004795352928340435, 0.02938324771821499, -0.02044360525906086, -0.02130206488072872, 0.021333735436201096, 0.027794690802693367, 0.026152148842811584, 0.021892765536904335, 0.004887886345386505, -0.027723176404833794, -0.02663610503077507, -0.033703770488500595, 0.0599784180521965, 0.038076069205999374, -0.0038845096714794636, -0.030545473098754883, 0.024428438395261765, -0.019380655139684677, -0.028663165867328644, 0.013267843052744865, -0.0010075297905132174, -0.04137180373072624, 0.007666246499866247, 0.02536197379231453, 0.02157030813395977, -0.03915192559361458, 0.060056861490011215, -0.03858740255236626, -0.02502390369772911, 0.053036656230688095, 0.03771955519914627, -0.04179606959223747, -0.021161839365959167, -0.010037681087851524, -0.04878390207886696, 0.0066171386279165745, 0.04771200194954872, 0.024826377630233765, -0.061392538249492645, 0.0006069114897400141, -0.0095382584258914, -0.016526304185390472, -0.030362097546458244, -0.05707594007253647, -0.03995480388402939, 0.016070043668150902, 0.02486293949186802, 0.02620246261358261, -0.03596467897295952, -0.01874205283820629, -0.003644184675067663, -0.08443722128868103, 0.05045018717646599, 0.0301550030708313, -0.009371159598231316, -0.04606052488088608, -0.010288242250680923, -0.024855919182300568, 0.004047621041536331, 0.05523299053311348, 0.04705512151122093, -0.007984223775565624, -0.006823336239904165, 0.017467085272073746, 0.02793131209909916, -0.006888782139867544, 0.042238377034664154, -0.03624529018998146, 0.0011835080804303288, 0.006439392454922199, -0.05419040471315384, 0.04614631459116936, 0.027646325528621674, 0.018371324986219406, -0.044367097318172455, 0.011571547016501427, -0.008222481235861778, -0.021608402952551842, 0.05025025084614754, -0.0025691415648907423, -0.04185447841882706, 0.06677273660898209, -0.030491570010781288, 0.02320525050163269, -0.010866411961615086, -0.03558078035712242, -0.05740781128406525, 0.022366615012288094, -0.005662288051098585, -0.01746729016304016, -0.03749087080359459, 0.019812086597085, 0.006519782356917858, -0.023413032293319702, -0.014506760984659195, 0.020114485174417496, -0.022367000579833984, -0.028297265991568565, 0.049268610775470734, 0.04855846241116524, 0.02435116283595562, 0.010583603754639626, 0.01801465079188347, 0.014770586974918842, 0.001434538047760725, 0.05341637134552002, 0.036297209560871124, -0.005202719010412693, 0.038268737494945526, 0.002652105875313282, 0.039457473903894424, -0.002745424397289753, 0.023128287866711617, -0.006824748124927282, 0.027407541871070862, 0.0009747115545906126, -0.027505872771143913, -0.00856056623160839, 0.012938338331878185, 0.032231949269771576, -0.0005214500124566257, 0.01207005325704813, 0.054912131279706955, -0.010038583539426327, -0.005637145135551691, -0.04198940843343735, 0.00698931934311986, -0.029028061777353287, -0.03394706919789314, -0.008775164373219013, 0.021729378029704094, -0.0024445427116006613, -0.01278951670974493, 0.0067839240655303, -0.033887553960084915, 0.0368669219315052, 0.034127507358789444, 0.02927999012172222, 0.009614715352654457, -0.00400313688442111, 0.008081700652837753, -0.021311288699507713, -0.0519033819437027, -0.034935202449560165, 0.029266927391290665, 0.07197257876396179, 0.0040260199457407, -0.0129350945353508, -0.026805642992258072, -0.012600505724549294, 0.06251677870750427, -0.07420266419649124, -0.017647134140133858, -0.04550185054540634, 0.00672862259671092, 0.03041849099099636, -0.022563355043530464 ]
<p><strong>CONTEXT:</strong> I am modelling the relation between time (1 to 30) and a DV for a set of 60 participants. Each participant has their own time series. For each participant I am examining the fit of 5 different theoretically plausible functions within a nonlinear regression framework. One function has one parameter; three functions have three parameters; and one function has five parameters.</p> <p>I want to use a decision rule to determine which function provides the most "theoretically meaningful" fit. However, I don't want to reward over-fitting.</p> <p>Over-fitting seems to come in two varieties. One form is the standard sense whereby an additional parameter enables slightly more of the random variance to be explained. A second sense is where there is an outlier or some other slight systematic effect, which is of minimal theoretical interest. Functions with more parameters sometimes seem capable of capturing these anomalies and get rewarded.</p> <p>I initially used AIC. And I have also experimented with increasing the penalty for parameters. In addition to using $2k$: [$\mathit{AIC}=2k + n[\ln(2\pi \mathit{RSS}/n) + 1]$]; I've also tried $6k$ (what I call AICPenalised). I have inspected scatter plots with fit lines imposed and corresponding recommendations based on AIC and AICPenalised. Both AIC and AICPenalised provide reasonable recommendations. About 80% of the time they agree. However, where they disagree, AICPenalised seems to make recommendations that are more theoretically meaningful.</p> <p><strong>QUESTION:</strong> Given a set of nonlinear regression function fits:</p> <ul> <li>What is a good criterion for deciding on a best fitting function in nonlinear regression?</li> <li>What is a principled way of adjusting the penalty for number of parameters?</li> </ul>
36,471
[ -0.026540230959653854, -0.01710803247988224, -0.017517130821943283, -0.030474234372377396, 0.011985828168690205, 0.017209667712450027, -0.02091406285762787, -0.012070256285369396, -0.0028603863902390003, -0.03393073379993439, 0.024041155353188515, 0.040393952280282974, 0.05158914253115654, 0.016851209104061127, 0.013583401218056679, 0.006467588245868683, -0.020680326968431473, 0.02520417980849743, -0.002555390354245901, -0.03637339919805527, 0.013407918624579906, 0.003194579388946295, 0.013558894395828247, -0.01149764470756054, -0.028078962117433548, 0.05114387720823288, 0.024435600265860558, 0.009069254621863365, 0.005833230447024107, 0.02857399731874466, -0.04588574543595314, -0.03644410893321037, 0.010531585663557053, 0.01918818987905979, 0.03059941530227661, 0.006335378158837557, 0.017667915672063828, -0.009606613777577877, -0.033818550407886505, 0.0583016611635685, -0.020207131281495094, -0.020791955292224884, 0.017375104129314423, 0.006663989741355181, -0.005460199434310198, 0.004559969529509544, 0.020355183631181717, -0.03953464701771736, 0.023365948349237442, -0.05539238452911377, 0.054371751844882965, -0.012575168162584305, 0.00860621128231287, 0.028702054172754288, -0.04183346405625343, -0.009964531287550926, 0.04119054600596428, 0.07574894279241562, -0.02538704127073288, -0.06049973890185356, -0.026291953399777412, -0.01699650101363659, 0.04146663472056389, 0.011768816970288754, -0.0427146814763546, 0.06945326179265976, -0.011315644718706608, -0.00617790874093771, 0.04267056658864021, -0.03381267562508583, 0.033123645931482315, -0.013111729174852371, 0.005241197533905506, 0.0089695630595088, 0.021292459219694138, -0.001264165504835546, 0.007533344440162182, 0.016065264120697975, 0.052189894020557404, 0.028391221538186073, 0.022118238732218742, 0.0467061772942543, -0.007365824189037085, 0.04341674968600273, 0.005308950785547495, -0.005258733406662941, 0.07853063195943832, -0.03169581666588783, 0.014605388045310974, 0.0023154588416218758, -0.04104047268629074, 0.026927387341856956, 0.040370553731918335, 0.02517036162316799, -0.026314111426472664, 0.010963497683405876, -0.018284328281879425, 0.024001894518733025, -0.02963215485215187, -0.008464011363685131, -0.05091644078493118, -0.04025346413254738, -0.004184195306152105, 0.05342426896095276, -0.018797140568494797, -0.0006913882098160684, -0.0023831401485949755, -0.002625046530738473, 0.0007676262175664306, -0.06795863807201385, 0.01531246304512024, 0.03242896869778633, -0.01300788763910532, 0.03674907609820366, 0.020449349656701088, 0.016057999804615974, 0.016494043171405792, -0.05040628835558891, 0.07573478668928146, 0.04533199220895767, 0.03469454497098923, -0.0093094976618886, 0.007267378736287355, -0.03462265804409981, -0.04116777330636978, 0.008886908181011677, 0.04420778900384903, 0.013459580019116402, -0.04315950348973274, 0.04295722395181656, 0.0034202318638563156, -0.00915900431573391, 0.007472990546375513, -0.00666389474645257, 0.0060202209278941154, 0.011524987407028675, -0.05910640209913254, -0.055165134370326996, 0.043698668479919434, -0.018026283010840416, -0.007220502942800522, -0.04721891134977341, -0.021763741970062256, 0.05589228868484497, 0.07170260697603226, 0.024164807051420212, 0.007826771587133408, 0.023838331922888756, 0.03460969030857086, 0.002471603685989976, -0.05258442461490631, -0.01607268676161766, -0.04192870855331421, -0.020652595907449722, -0.029092615470290184, -0.07080252468585968, 0.02109893411397934, 0.019586943089962006, -0.0192866213619709, 0.02183368057012558, 0.07213607430458069, 0.00037240845267660916, -0.04461849853396416, -0.007762320339679718, 0.01216389611363411, -0.024551020935177803, 0.02129720151424408, 0.03682934492826462, 0.008292511105537415, 0.0010918714106082916, -0.01806369237601757, 0.038802191615104675, -0.004924108274281025, 0.053195539861917496, 0.04880327358841896, 0.018487581983208656, 0.015461272560060024, -0.030848152935504913, -0.0001175678480649367, 0.032580673694610596, -0.04166803136467934, -0.022807301953434944, -0.055442772805690765, -0.009042242541909218, 0.01839342713356018, 0.031593967229127884, -0.031133165583014488, 0.01999342441558838, 0.034918032586574554, -0.07259272038936615, -0.0451585128903389, -0.034127309918403625, -0.020657137036323547, 0.0183364599943161, -0.029273035004734993, 0.022432349622249603, -0.020103147253394127, 0.019201571121811867, -0.00030819897074252367, -0.035774458199739456, -0.027889415621757507, 0.03424543887376785, 0.0616629421710968, -0.011461949907243252, 0.03223513811826706, 0.04177778214216232, 0.0016937421169131994, -0.03187935799360275, 0.034570179879665375, -0.029618434607982635, -0.04487552493810654, 0.015823090448975563, -0.04943154379725456, 0.00540928402915597, -0.004019399639219046, -0.008474402129650116, 0.01804710552096367, -0.009323167614638805, 0.006577745079994202, 0.028551669791340828, -0.032110653817653656, 0.09740213304758072, 0.05150274559855461, -0.017762167379260063, -0.003369715763255954, 0.06775732338428497, 0.022062871605157852, -0.01945371925830841, -0.04313783720135689, 0.001822743215598166, -0.059694670140743256, -0.03012843243777752, 0.028587888926267624, 0.04602692276239395, -0.02318035066127777, 0.021174700930714607, 0.030603688210248947, 0.008428051136434078, -0.0013315236428752542, 0.03624672815203667, -0.008756729774177074, -0.030302004888653755, 0.028567055240273476, 0.023103564977645874, -0.0009572020499035716, -0.02042955718934536, -0.004157715477049351, 0.009030576795339584, 0.003494445001706481, 0.001781630446203053, 0.0009911914821714163, 0.02338089793920517, 0.015226121060550213, 0.0044599128887057304, -0.028286540880799294, -0.01193168107420206, 0.023876821622252464, -0.046065837144851685, 0.017951831221580505, 0.052558790892362595, 0.017679596319794655, -0.02057133987545967, 0.01671888679265976, -0.002691155532374978, 0.04434829577803612, 0.035320959985256195, -0.01842653751373291, 0.011566264554858208, 0.02190963178873062, -0.03769020363688469, 0.01344925444573164, -0.020712364464998245, -0.018810229375958443, -0.022441012784838676, -0.008953934535384178, 0.006058393977582455, 0.03284602612257004, 0.042123619467020035, -0.007058704737573862, -0.0019967774860560894, -0.005646318197250366, -0.011259166523814201, 0.016376933082938194, 0.013507608324289322, -0.03590954840183258, 0.005001697223633528, -0.023380393162369728, 0.01642514578998089, 0.048500847071409225, -0.018794666975736618, 0.022320540621876717, 0.010236003436148167, -0.01777011714875698, -0.03539587929844856, -0.03704157471656799, -0.004458946641534567, 0.011562280356884003, -0.013750878162682056, -0.04260352626442909, 0.051582809537649155, -0.008658019825816154, -0.08326319605112076, 0.04161621630191803, -0.02008456364274025, -0.0063139330595731735, -0.04510432854294777, 0.022131649777293205, -0.012042982503771782, 0.004210116341710091, 0.0033952021040022373, 0.021597521379590034, -0.03399042412638664, -0.02808445878326893, -0.05293740704655647, -0.057816095650196075, 0.02505972981452942, 0.018425708636641502, 0.037436001002788544, 0.007105401251465082, -0.03349226340651512, 0.055195558816194534, 0.05775884911417961, -0.011998859234154224, -0.08021083474159241, 0.01752481423318386, -0.0214063823223114, -0.0485493466258049, 0.019947107881307602, 0.048234663903713226, 0.022324394434690475, 0.059570055454969406, -0.003998225089162588, 0.0228220596909523, 0.05225268006324768, 0.002378852106630802, 0.014956199564039707, 0.03000611625611782, 0.020758870989084244, -0.042143020778894424, 0.014402004890143871, 0.016372323036193848, 0.0011728613171726465, -0.0187673456966877, -0.012839378789067268, -0.000633924501016736, 0.03039926290512085, -0.026523958891630173, 0.0292670838534832, -0.016546580940485, 0.015076772309839725, -0.012500987388193607, 0.0099288709461689, 0.006722172722220421, -0.06118373945355415, -0.027021314948797226, 0.019992908462882042, 0.01367271039634943, -0.01977946050465107, 0.028221456333994865, 0.04200931265950203, 0.028368182480335236, 0.015291140414774418, -0.030057188123464584, -0.04519876092672348, -0.02296711690723896, 0.007947183214128017, -0.027641186490654945, -0.023552631959319115, 0.017711225897073746, -0.0011976397363469005, 0.00889637228101492, -0.02881990186870098, -0.036497775465250015, 0.014107814989984035, -0.07621397078037262, -0.030595246702432632, -0.06069391593337059, 0.06928189098834991, 0.016478529199957848, -0.007151671219617128, 0.011963852681219578, -0.008378327824175358, 0.016339566558599472, 0.014965209178626537, -0.06226276978850365, 0.07152704894542694, -0.0000621207946096547, 0.009889096021652222, -0.0008346000104211271, -0.012472671456634998, 0.05328403785824776, -0.055428557097911835, 0.04171854630112648, 0.016380183398723602, 0.036655329167842865, -0.01850193366408348, 0.017635570839047432, -0.055390991270542145, -0.012590308673679829, 0.001592417829670012, 0.020071672275662422, 0.04053718224167824, -0.07285009324550629, 0.014768987894058228, 0.03409797325730324, 0.0025587999261915684, -0.039037611335515976, -0.012315302155911922, 0.023341305553913116, -0.000026521916879573837, 0.019825788214802742, 0.02281975746154785, 0.005963101051747799, -0.009285538457334042, 0.032475147396326065, 0.0127974608913064, -0.01519338134676218, 0.0504036508500576, -0.017635460942983627, -0.025322265923023224, -0.012874087318778038, -0.0050748479552567005, 0.02605133131146431, 0.030529778450727463, 0.021286651492118835, -0.038489069789648056, 0.04499635100364685, 0.003646111348643899, -0.015014417469501495, 0.033425867557525635, 0.02287874184548855, 0.004044296219944954, -0.030404381453990936, 0.00030160986352711916, -0.0036901957355439663, 0.0369500033557415, 0.04289305582642555, 0.008392464369535446, 0.017889194190502167, -0.019144894555211067, 0.018704984337091446, 0.047000300139188766, -0.025561880320310593, -0.04658485949039459, 0.015895377844572067, 0.017255418002605438, 0.06383924186229706, 0.036133408546447754, -0.02019798755645752, -0.0052544898353517056, 0.015127744525671005, 0.032344091683626175, 0.06673987209796906, -0.018163342028856277, -0.08760761469602585, -0.006117801647633314, 0.04931636527180672, 0.05989723280072212, -0.045824430882930756, 0.010187339968979359, -0.004967448767274618, -0.006648308597505093, 0.031328096985816956, -0.0013217309024184942, -0.00562751991674304, -0.0021699138451367617, -0.006627341266721487, -0.02220287173986435, -0.06191127374768257, -0.06705225259065628, 0.028910033404827118, 0.026416631415486336, 0.04116705805063248, -0.023357529193162918, -0.04715000092983246, -0.032931264489889145, 0.022211527451872826, -0.022395912557840347, 0.057875219732522964, -0.010168591514229774, -0.029216106981039047, 0.0045601497404277325, 0.0004720654687844217, 0.01227900106459856, -0.030018284916877747, -0.006666561588644981, 0.01240625511854887, -0.010094796307384968, 0.03931337594985962, -0.02922929637134075, -0.027008691802620888, -0.016210045665502548, 0.013235439546406269, -0.01642327569425106, 0.011545785702764988, -0.049668848514556885, 0.06711788475513458, 0.014525420032441616, 0.018721379339694977, 0.041410721838474274, 0.014298195950686932, -0.01658320426940918, 0.028187135234475136, -0.02744869887828827, -0.0375373512506485, -0.005746118258684874, -0.055695533752441406, -0.0159826148301363, -0.04536153003573418, -0.021825656294822693, -0.0018549509113654494, 0.009988857433199883, 0.04320356994867325, -0.03960017114877701, -0.03966960310935974, -0.03320827707648277, 0.045156028121709824, 0.015615006908774376, -0.01025339774787426, 0.03203437477350235, 0.021748868748545647, 0.02110392041504383, -0.01150995958596468, -0.01811903901398182, -0.04916756600141525, 0.019697047770023346, 0.06382475048303604, -0.043481286615133286, 0.015718651935458183, -0.0181373730301857, -0.0002532315847929567, 0.027068298310041428, -0.013562834821641445, 0.05532139539718628, 0.008190447464585304, 0.0013468196848407388, -0.02888227067887783, -0.01808403991162777, -0.005661883391439915, 0.022973159328103065, 0.0053760283626616, 0.04929023236036301, -0.018049556761980057, 0.009464886039495468, -0.029787929728627205, 0.0011446172138676047, -0.05873304232954979, 0.004587830975651741, -0.009252488613128662, -0.014770513400435448, -0.05222439393401146, 0.004892423748970032, -0.009177416563034058, -0.028952063992619514, -0.019174013286828995, -0.0036862713750451803, 0.050870999693870544, -0.0151671152561903, -0.015000305138528347, -0.02804497629404068, 0.012486732564866543, 0.06331136077642441, -0.01868194155395031, -0.004322987515479326, 0.014949901960790157, 0.001421300694346428, 0.016635829582810402, 0.044057153165340424, -0.0019512365106493235, -0.014068654738366604, -0.0047124880366027355, -0.04145081341266632, -0.00503655057400465, 0.02875325456261635, -0.010900615714490414, 0.01624227501451969, 0.04445765167474747, -0.018819574266672134, -0.03847832977771759, -0.015516876243054867, 0.022937962785363197, -0.032195139676332474, 0.021273506805300713, 0.02656748704612255, 0.004092922434210777, 0.01950480416417122, -0.045956917107105255, -0.0038409943226724863, -0.011968336999416351, -0.0516350157558918, 0.0025543628726154566, 0.04270968958735466, 0.017551997676491737, -0.024785634130239487, -0.012065413407981396, 0.006018429063260555, 0.07891374081373215, -0.011039860546588898, 0.008798723109066486, -0.014464435167610645, 0.01923847571015358, -0.0172340776771307, -0.06669308245182037, -0.02078285440802574, -0.006018421147018671, 0.06183816120028496, -0.020647255703806877, 0.07382788509130478, 0.057550251483917236, -0.007263492792844772, -0.014125537127256393, -0.061396293342113495, 0.0181852076202631, -0.017160598188638687, -0.013221757486462593, 0.0591387003660202, -0.027747726067900658, -0.014890764839947224, -0.0006645857938565314, -0.00365022337064147, 0.021967360749840736, 0.0475030317902565, -0.012597457505762577, 0.06431696563959122, 0.0031602317467331886, -0.08706704527139664, -0.07684337347745895, 0.03870045393705368, -0.050489798188209534, 0.008821796625852585, 0.005896637681871653, -0.05114385485649109, 0.027774283662438393, 0.04458894208073616, 0.024478444829583168, -0.0352310910820961, -0.022367822006344795, -0.04831288382411003, -0.00708121620118618, 0.038221150636672974, -0.010091792792081833, 0.03085445985198021, -0.0035885684192180634, 0.018910221755504608, 0.018428245559334755, 0.05412038043141365, -0.008884528651833534, -0.09761709719896317, -0.04035354405641556, -0.027453523129224777, -0.02219604142010212, 0.04734832048416138, 0.009585444815456867, -0.033261921256780624, -0.001127850729972124, -0.040388308465480804, 0.006734779104590416, 0.02036270499229431, 0.026690145954489708, -0.010881492868065834, 0.05997958034276962, -0.048836320638656616, -0.015667596831917763, -0.007365936879068613, -0.030667752027511597, 0.14179639518260956, 0.042589519172906876, 0.016731224954128265, -0.059032145887613297, 0.013128368183970451, 0.01382372621446848, -0.002437001559883356, -0.011179699562489986, -0.008638444356620312, 0.011613840237259865, -0.00031876127468422055, 0.031232912093400955, 0.03705654665827751, 0.002626915229484439, -0.0023540500551462173, 0.07142274081707001, -0.025854310020804405, -0.00546324672177434, 0.02900121361017227, 0.017819959670305252, 0.06169462203979492, -0.019457325339317322, -0.025519395247101784, 0.00808340311050415, -0.020431125536561012, -0.022309985011816025, 0.0027601777110248804, -0.011487483978271484, -0.014308224432170391, -0.00933032762259245, -0.02142706885933876, -0.016274049878120422, 0.03336821123957634, 0.001068596262484789, 0.02731155790388584, 0.005242951679974794, -0.009815635159611702, -0.03908881917595863, 0.003950390033423901, 0.016894474625587463, 0.00035929918522015214, -0.038058772683143616, 0.02717272937297821, -0.001241479767486453, 0.0006621699430979788, -0.06844181567430496, -0.03267557546496391, 0.014218706637620926, 0.021871086210012436, -0.03805160149931908, 0.008894059807062149, 0.008041026070713997, 0.024848880246281624, -0.027840174734592438, -0.033932801336050034, -0.006570944096893072, 0.04603835195302963, -0.026386650279164314, -0.02444923110306263, -0.007823149673640728, -0.024185290560126305, 0.006891863886266947, 0.03465846925973892, 0.04900886490941048, -0.0491119846701622, -0.017654892057180405, 0.01314520463347435, 0.036516979336738586, 0.02542630210518837, 0.015271246433258057, -0.013296280056238174, 0.02873675338923931, -0.03462183475494385, 0.0062635489739477634, 0.029482470825314522, 0.02962910756468773, 0.03029576875269413, -0.0019549252465367317, -0.008643470704555511, -0.04871317744255066, -0.0697273537516594, 0.022793347015976906, -0.01724950224161148, -0.000022851480025565252, -0.03506306931376457, -0.036236103624105453, 0.030913477763533592, 0.01935153268277645, 0.04588881880044937, -0.006053616758435965, -0.026528744027018547, 0.0472569577395916, 0.02105690911412239, -0.052836570888757706, -0.022404789924621582, -0.025058260187506676, -0.028879616409540176, 0.005576251540333033, 0.025383347645401955, 0.08690249174833298, 0.008007824420928955, 0.010890690609812737, 0.024644974619150162, 0.04803743585944176, -0.016712957993149757, 0.004082814324647188, 0.018985286355018616, -0.06890564411878586, 0.014808451756834984, 0.00784570537507534, -0.017225101590156555, -0.06654471904039383, -0.03097350522875786, -0.047467466443777084, -0.005740795284509659, 0.04995175823569298, -0.03487183898687363, -0.04021301120519638, 0.04257058724761009, -0.02332361415028572, -0.023005517199635506, -0.03921880945563316, 0.05853059142827988, 0.004413355607539415, -0.025087682530283928, -0.022314025089144707, -0.0389937087893486, 0.016643859446048737, 0.011410960927605629, -0.03510111942887306, -0.009185384027659893, 0.0602928102016449, 0.029681939631700516, 0.01927565596997738, -0.0025833402760326862, -0.007164941634982824, -0.02616032212972641, 0.05109040066599846, -0.040326692163944244, -0.015226316638290882, 0.01036218460649252, -0.06316981464624405, -0.023398520424962044, 0.0027808083686977625, -0.012739859521389008, -0.0032829858828336, 0.015071253292262554, 0.04016580805182457, -0.03241876885294914, 0.047661371529102325, -0.0416647270321846, 0.006781866308301687, -0.006532470695674419, 0.031066104769706726, -0.013396590948104858, -0.01196334045380354, -0.011802366003394127, -0.004815906751900911, -0.010456183925271034, 0.022944534197449684, 0.050678905099630356, 0.011166540905833244, 0.010522820055484772, 0.0015084733022376895, -0.00011201298184460029, 0.00934936199337244, -0.009436405263841152, 0.0019218905363231897, 0.0384296178817749, 0.04333264380693436, -0.026152582839131355, 0.004476733505725861, 0.001015777001157403, 0.023763902485370636, -0.08907783776521683, 0.007614318747073412, -0.009728808887302876, 0.04346359521150589, 0.01851680874824524, -0.048750799149274826, 0.017425915226340294, 0.015349934808909893, -0.020845556631684303, 0.019798241555690765, -0.021603254601359367, 0.020361797884106636, -0.029275359585881233, -0.0015358226373791695, -0.0259561650454998, 0.0058836182579398155, 0.029603518545627594, 0.004151127301156521, 0.03260935842990875, -0.00822617206722498, 0.024241289123892784, -0.016659365966916084, -0.014542408287525177, 0.026933401823043823, -0.007163492031395435, -0.05159230902791023, 0.021300673484802246, -0.00805493351072073, -0.03059077262878418, 0.023806622251868248, 0.00846705213189125, 0.030945030972361565, -0.0061813341453671455, 0.011124429292976856, -0.012839495204389095, 0.04606843739748001, 0.02104337140917778, -0.023209961131215096, -0.00599637720733881, -0.011402225121855736, 0.016713861376047134, 0.0207346323877573, -0.0036719944328069687, 0.02850811742246151, 0.019328583031892776, -0.008615215308964252, -0.028961550444364548, -0.01383149903267622, 0.0019559331703931093, -0.025366047397255898, 0.004878271371126175, 0.0120196882635355, 0.021838096901774406, -0.00976613536477089, -0.010727818123996258, -0.020037978887557983, -0.006821013521403074, 0.04157862812280655, 0.06640662997961044, -0.0007842612685635686, -0.00036705422098748386, -0.0391976572573185, -0.04184328392148018, -0.013442657887935638, 0.010998181998729706, -0.01997366175055504, -0.061235006898641586, 0.014856585301458836, 0.0009572350536473095, -0.0037149405106902122, -0.03979388624429703, 0.01702119968831539, -0.0289742574095726, 0.03322530910372734, -0.014498933218419552, 0.006343045737594366, 0.021032163873314857, -0.047327399253845215, 0.021875225007534027, -0.08121518045663834, 0.08269698172807693, 0.005994016770273447, -0.0176643468439579, -0.03187704458832741, -0.030606746673583984, -0.01926925592124462, 0.011220378801226616, 0.03530663624405861, -0.009802739135921001, -0.004175076726824045, -0.02207036130130291, 0.018771382048726082, -0.009385869838297367, -0.008964577689766884, 0.04311637952923775, -0.0014790721470490098, -0.00665636733174324, -0.0015809987671673298, 0.008169046603143215, -0.009813857264816761, 0.01643179915845394, 0.01901555433869362, -0.011099397204816341, 0.026648633182048798, 0.04130082577466965, 0.0012314849300310016, 0.041295651346445084, 0.015208935365080833, -0.006749759893864393, 0.017798757180571556, 0.0070314123295247555, 0.01265786774456501, -0.0009410948841832578, 0.012013663537800312, -0.07939235866069794, 0.05319898948073387, -0.02034759148955345, -0.04918086901307106, -0.013493356294929981, 0.023927852511405945, 0.001564284902997315, -0.04722648113965988, 0.01779865473508835, 0.048710811883211136, -0.020495006814599037, -0.012847601436078548, 0.00935737881809473, 0.01478469930589199, 0.048691365867853165, -0.014139067381620407, 0.04837701842188835, 0.027290763333439827, 0.03181067109107971, -0.008643102832138538, -0.01855473592877388, 0.07314605265855789, 0.01825312152504921, 0.009278052486479282, 0.035422906279563904, -0.01402740553021431, 0.012854616157710552, -0.033620066940784454, 0.013260914012789726, -0.03836621344089508, -0.005563181359320879, 0.01507405936717987, -0.012104707770049572, 0.006980122532695532, -0.009458530694246292, 0.008256198838353157, 0.040422823280096054, -0.024699438363313675, -0.0041455477476119995, -0.03461199253797531, -0.020095130428671837, -0.002395300893113017, 0.02270442433655262, 0.02133580856025219, 0.022687288001179695, 0.003185601206496358, 0.0009567838860675693, 0.007184608839452267, -0.012902569025754929, 0.0339212641119957, -0.047357264906167984, -0.007822136394679546, -0.008235293440520763, 0.02584746852517128, -0.033842217177152634, -0.02717832662165165, -0.01866145059466362, -0.02433687634766102, 0.020550420507788658, 0.025696897879242897, 0.0126848379150033, -0.055746667087078094, -0.039990272372961044, -0.008920479565858841, 0.06050776690244675, -0.08215445280075073, -0.0055291298776865005, -0.006179494317620993, 0.004290205426514149, -0.010645798407495022, -0.009429342113435268 ]
<p>I am trying to do a multiple logistic regression for 2 similar groups. I have a few questions:</p> <ol> <li><p>In doing a univariate analysis, do I enter each independent variable, one at a time, first into the binary regression, before going on to do the multivariate analysis? Or is the significance values from Chi-square or t-test enough to go on with?</p></li> <li><p>I have a test group and a control group and I want to determine the effect of independent variables (e.g HIV status, maternal weight etc) on a particular dependent variable (low birth weight). Should I perform the regression on a dataset with both the test and the control cases or should I split the file? In this case I want to see the effect of HIV on birthweight and I am having a hard time knowing how to move on.</p></li> </ol>
19,045
[ -0.025405434891581535, -0.011602882295846939, -0.009953503496944904, 0.04891494661569595, 0.034177958965301514, 0.026961633935570717, 0.0006560705369338393, -0.01775907166302204, 0.045673348009586334, -0.02283894456923008, 0.051732130348682404, 0.026120968163013458, 0.052800580859184265, 0.02679356560111046, 0.012734963558614254, 0.007910475134849548, 0.006676082499325275, 0.004238316789269447, -0.014052264392375946, 0.004659139085561037, -0.015475703403353691, 0.006582525558769703, 0.04739943519234657, 0.028583144769072533, -0.0017103770514950156, 0.05469484254717827, 0.02444140426814556, -0.013572477735579014, -0.005342422518879175, 0.04198739305138588, -0.03396910801529884, -0.04695911332964897, 0.018510855734348297, 0.018015343695878983, 0.04341954365372658, 0.017018180340528488, -0.020824752748012543, 0.02133937180042267, 0.010246348567306995, 0.00851812120527029, -0.03579246997833252, -0.00730922631919384, -0.009302648715674877, 0.012941590510308743, -0.00020392824080772698, 0.03537570312619209, -0.0001862672361312434, -0.017893074080348015, 0.05291784927248955, -0.03340648487210274, 0.03837724030017853, -0.020480740815401077, 0.044107723981142044, 0.04052795097231865, -0.005505959037691355, -0.002274484606459737, 0.05138667672872543, 0.050058797001838684, 0.03674330934882164, -0.03801233321428299, 0.0036959683056920767, 0.0027527562342584133, -0.006520669441670179, -0.004530224483460188, -0.04623520374298096, 0.02102009765803814, 0.02116672322154045, -0.000711120548658073, 0.0160171277821064, 0.004272544756531715, 0.016013355925679207, -0.020613886415958405, 0.03438824415206909, -0.026941964402794838, -0.006370549090206623, -0.013102623634040356, 0.011945688165724277, 0.020521756261587143, 0.028275765478610992, 0.03233678638935089, 0.006021034438163042, 0.037682533264160156, 0.04322832077741623, 0.06063377112150192, 0.028642119839787483, -0.025659723207354546, 0.0551498681306839, -0.002864741487428546, 0.009741619229316711, 0.021106041967868805, -0.020840637385845184, 0.018162034451961517, 0.05727924779057503, 0.020376969128847122, -0.027291886508464813, 0.025373101234436035, -0.036957599222660065, 0.03392026573419571, 0.03405600041151047, -0.0011065874714404345, -0.021485701203346252, 0.00010098644270328805, 0.05072050169110298, 0.0570048987865448, -0.0333477146923542, 0.009070491418242455, -0.028613027185201645, 0.016409361734986305, 0.012247586622834206, -0.05083495378494263, -0.022879477590322495, -0.0008525995654053986, -0.005495366640388966, -0.009745207615196705, -0.006723619997501373, -0.017054717987775803, -0.014556843787431717, -0.012491642497479916, 0.05421802029013634, 0.047879986464977264, 0.04913516342639923, -0.06977446377277374, 0.027804622426629066, -0.022184966132044792, -0.0392366498708725, 0.03783280774950981, 0.010974627919495106, -0.0008369316929019988, -0.05016337335109711, 0.03762112930417061, 0.010411472991108894, -0.018535099923610687, 0.004978444892913103, 0.014783872291445732, 0.007492151577025652, 0.024583781138062477, -0.08077113330364227, -0.06916631758213043, -0.008132338523864746, -0.017322033643722534, 0.030414454638957977, -0.027418235316872597, -0.01509631983935833, 0.030138647183775902, 0.05856854468584061, -0.035795073956251144, 0.01426646113395691, 0.02109220251441002, 0.02605266124010086, 0.0011082914425060153, -0.0015656783943995833, -0.007534824311733246, -0.043684158474206924, -0.005263843107968569, -0.008202760480344296, -0.09141768515110016, 0.01963876746594906, 0.01451132819056511, -0.0007513962336815894, -0.012029201723635197, 0.024325614795088768, -0.011473307386040688, -0.012829415500164032, -0.00774518633261323, 0.0033524995669722557, -0.021598096936941147, 0.0389668270945549, -0.026654353365302086, 0.04748436063528061, 0.023561911657452583, 0.006605083122849464, 0.013949548825621605, 0.010814586654305458, 0.04729495570063591, 0.0245719775557518, 0.018109381198883057, -0.0144201023504138, -0.019198905676603317, 0.015523506328463554, 0.009025939740240574, -0.05171312764286995, -0.050191111862659454, -0.03099633753299713, -0.03485479578375816, 0.03755626827478409, 0.03590038791298866, 0.016966575756669044, -0.017124846577644348, 0.048508577048778534, -0.0580686591565609, -0.04321490600705147, -0.04525667056441307, 0.007669862359762192, -0.009938014671206474, -0.016915200278162956, 0.018422605469822884, -0.012973077595233917, 0.029511485248804092, -0.03250690549612045, -0.03418481722474098, -0.02911433018743992, -0.005459369160234928, 0.045585259795188904, -0.036710500717163086, 0.010667144320905209, 0.07853758335113525, 0.02789619378745556, -0.03296264261007309, 0.02664930932223797, -0.06959175318479538, -0.029104596003890038, 0.026701560243964195, 0.01301721204072237, 0.01852576993405819, -0.039788536727428436, 0.0096092214807868, 0.009830426424741745, 0.018071739003062248, -0.025680383667349815, 0.023387303575873375, -0.07960985600948334, 0.09097503125667572, 0.030149709433317184, -0.02399788796901703, -0.026139887049794197, 0.006151081528514624, 0.006011710502207279, 0.02899712510406971, -0.007332893554121256, -0.02384389378130436, -0.06113957241177559, -0.00336953136138618, -0.008030143566429615, -0.021306825801730156, -0.018690383061766624, 0.015693681314587593, 0.039845917373895645, -0.0026873894967138767, -0.004930123221129179, -0.006685814820230007, -0.013372033834457397, -0.025111382827162743, 0.004650535993278027, 0.04181976616382599, 0.012106972746551037, 0.020791275426745415, 0.03722306713461876, -0.020158229395747185, 0.059879451990127563, 0.0036247503012418747, -0.027937935665249825, 0.06921271979808807, -0.005657379515469074, -0.018407955765724182, -0.012287477031350136, -0.04000851511955261, 0.05508773773908615, -0.021620027720928192, 0.041387300938367844, 0.06241855025291443, 0.04325304180383682, -0.02486661821603775, 0.018045969307422638, 0.0014541196869686246, 0.018091216683387756, 0.04179977625608444, -0.047790996730327606, 0.04739121347665787, 0.008036562241613865, -0.05072076618671417, 0.04188889265060425, -0.009809202514588833, -0.03429970517754555, -0.048783306032419205, 0.01930270902812481, -0.040077876299619675, -0.014990557916462421, 0.016227347776293755, -0.03118458203971386, -0.03901488706469536, -0.02406061813235283, -0.0299167912453413, 0.015526237897574902, -0.0004868249234277755, -0.03836500644683838, -0.004911605268716812, -0.0521089993417263, -0.004934166092425585, 0.03158867731690407, -0.017643678933382034, -0.002481024479493499, 0.013107663951814175, -0.016617916524410248, -0.07169947773218155, -0.05408056080341339, 0.013073251582682133, -0.006552360486239195, -0.00440629618242383, -0.009182567708194256, 0.03499975427985191, 0.015401367098093033, -0.01385074108839035, 0.014989832416176796, -0.04246515780687332, 0.003103634575381875, -0.005960430484265089, 0.014443667605519295, 0.0226694755256176, 0.020384781062602997, -0.00353910936973989, 0.0067577119916677475, -0.023542575538158417, -0.011905656196177006, -0.07666359841823578, -0.05345231294631958, 0.006227766629308462, -0.014281287789344788, 0.04932960122823715, -0.018201805651187897, -0.0002759905473794788, 0.04510819911956787, 0.047125037759542465, 0.016169745475053787, -0.07800405472517014, 0.0019008769886568189, -0.055819980800151825, -0.028603445738554, 0.06004819646477699, 0.014117428101599216, 0.0013925561215728521, -0.0021688747219741344, -0.003028552047908306, 0.040776003152132034, 0.038850411772727966, 0.01980540156364441, 0.018257105723023415, 0.024489961564540863, 0.03105805814266205, -0.05059780180454254, 0.009941564872860909, 0.01440427079796791, -0.00745435943827033, 0.00482593709602952, 0.010444020852446556, 0.021673670038580894, -0.005253552459180355, -0.04704732820391655, 0.0007073553861118853, 0.014767606742680073, -0.0014162923907861114, -0.04908319562673569, -0.012847291305661201, 0.05363878980278969, -0.03438270464539528, 0.011124708689749241, -0.011904986575245857, 0.021218232810497284, -0.021780410781502724, -0.014380832202732563, 0.03004513680934906, 0.051730673760175705, 0.009541775099933147, 0.000029164631996536627, -0.01052865106612444, 0.004510283470153809, 0.028510650619864464, -0.05485919117927551, 0.0058302003890275955, 0.013401170261204243, 0.05347377061843872, 0.019673626869916916, -0.038450926542282104, -0.06224953755736351, -0.00921680312603712, -0.0414750874042511, -0.015239332802593708, -0.028167203068733215, 0.05449524521827698, 0.006692071910947561, 0.05505223572254181, -0.011082129552960396, -0.028281640261411667, 0.035707175731658936, -0.008150101639330387, -0.09023359417915344, 0.009676048532128334, -0.004524934571236372, -0.008902302011847496, 0.048978306353092194, -0.021453924477100372, 0.014224720187485218, -0.04041279852390289, 0.015614736825227737, -0.03188440203666687, 0.027967197820544243, 0.020125985145568848, -0.003022776683792472, -0.009821038693189621, -0.011380634270608425, 0.00530693493783474, -0.0168521236628294, -0.018958691507577896, 0.01590374857187271, 0.008400345221161842, 0.04471944272518158, 0.006126816384494305, 0.0007364268531091511, -0.007943190634250641, -0.018370848149061203, -0.003004138357937336, 0.05515671148896217, 0.007235705386847258, 0.02117319405078888, -0.05332058668136597, 0.008380194194614887, 0.008559336885809898, 0.020544134080410004, 0.03172113001346588, -0.010502864606678486, -0.005858117248862982, 0.0020767804235219955, -0.010498834773898125, -0.02261926606297493, 0.006785838399082422, 0.01192391850054264, 0.0028568191919475794, 0.06876469403505325, 0.034258920699357986, -0.03554816171526909, 0.014890862628817558, 0.07192283123731613, 0.003893638961017132, 0.008325937204062939, -0.02854704111814499, -0.021769553422927856, -0.01772400364279747, 0.014983328059315681, 0.010565941222012043, 0.04643553867936134, -0.021655473858118057, -0.01738615520298481, 0.054661720991134644, -0.017728179693222046, -0.024725819006562233, 0.0022618609946221113, 0.039903674274683, 0.04115713760256767, -0.010039031505584717, -0.053327616304159164, 0.035337988287210464, 0.049933381378650665, 0.005623961333185434, 0.023825358599424362, 0.009967603720724583, -0.06764283031225204, 0.006052677519619465, 0.015270384959876537, 0.02304508164525032, -0.03635266423225403, 0.004494065418839455, -0.010691341012716293, -0.010258976370096207, -0.014367494732141495, -0.020900212228298187, 0.016779061406850815, 0.0036454666405916214, 0.01879531517624855, -0.026680143550038338, -0.03343174234032631, -0.06673450022935867, 0.005145481787621975, -0.02372739277780056, 0.0018993973499163985, -0.02418985404074192, -0.030832624062895775, -0.02960818260908127, 0.06166806071996689, -0.013152189552783966, 0.062415290623903275, -0.01711186207830906, -0.02687893807888031, 0.022366218268871307, 0.019036119803786278, -0.022820746526122093, -0.0331413671374321, -0.0234785545617342, 0.0010084414388984442, -0.019124675542116165, 0.04812861979007721, 0.009640735574066639, -0.03836352378129959, 0.027490166947245598, 0.04244234412908554, -0.03570649027824402, -0.0022754750680178404, -0.046472229063510895, 0.031059585511684418, 0.0022544267121702433, -0.0075449333526194096, 0.058519668877124786, 0.022895900532603264, -0.00040520456968806684, -0.005422507878392935, -0.04105429723858833, 0.02443196251988411, -0.0026781633496284485, -0.01765473186969757, -0.04101750999689102, -0.023285379633307457, -0.005791534204035997, 0.01320112869143486, 0.0010611714096739888, 0.0021172151900827885, -0.01073404774069786, 0.008041361346840858, 0.016431070864200592, 0.0220553670078516, 0.004919120576232672, 0.015623774379491806, 0.0054114037193357944, 0.003211134811863303, -0.0377168133854866, -0.022594721987843513, 0.033890221267938614, -0.005618388764560223, 0.024395616725087166, 0.02691805362701416, -0.06894583255052567, 0.009322742000222206, -0.020621588453650475, -0.03503883630037308, 0.014658494852483273, -0.014271176420152187, 0.009300210513174534, 0.013971787877380848, 0.03544896841049194, -0.005001123528927565, -0.03933249041438103, -0.015667570754885674, 0.03490861877799034, 0.0024970797821879387, 0.009815376251935959, -0.01921253837645054, 0.06625188887119293, -0.020207468420267105, -0.014139008708298206, -0.04751814529299736, -0.009087052196264267, -0.011377262882888317, -0.02352127991616726, 0.0008099446422420442, -0.02674037218093872, 0.029260002076625824, -0.019218647852540016, -0.024029459804296494, -0.017185458913445473, 0.06899620592594147, -0.033952634781599045, 0.003058631671592593, 0.011171302758157253, 0.020305084064602852, 0.0491206981241703, -0.0035913249012082815, -0.02468901127576828, -0.005213058553636074, -0.026739416643977165, 0.0032330870162695646, 0.018603868782520294, -0.028222672641277313, -0.0060264035128057, -0.010282879695296288, -0.029730036854743958, 0.01132970117032528, 0.00014341730275191367, -0.006397245917469263, 0.005325978621840477, 0.010736586526036263, -0.008567470125854015, -0.021872978657484055, -0.03432493284344673, 0.007482994347810745, 0.0041577876545488834, 0.012865077704191208, -0.01580086536705494, 0.014303070493042469, -0.016107171773910522, -0.004044176544994116, 0.028846846893429756, -0.006787552498281002, -0.029930097982287407, 0.02956603281199932, 0.05462189391255379, 0.03149573877453804, 0.016550710424780846, -0.002622001338750124, -0.01950269192457199, 0.02434404008090496, -0.027847573161125183, -0.05768556892871857, 0.02112673409283161, 0.04657059162855148, -0.039057862013578415, -0.016406118869781494, -0.02209017053246498, -0.018955601379275322, 0.03343803435564041, 0.0036403127014636993, 0.03619459643959999, 0.07788543403148651, 0.00940527394413948, 0.007378025446087122, -0.057785000652074814, -0.00950041227042675, -0.018898535519838333, 0.019069135189056396, 0.041749827563762665, -0.006763554643839598, -0.011094897985458374, 0.03823491558432579, 0.017340978607535362, 0.011829981580376625, 0.03492343798279762, 0.005206999368965626, -0.009066056460142136, 0.02462715283036232, -0.02378624491393566, -0.04950706660747528, 0.006606395356357098, -0.0506751649081707, 0.016387993469834328, -0.06738106161355972, -0.023024052381515503, 0.05602924898266792, 0.0842311754822731, 0.020882422104477882, -0.07729009538888931, -0.015042757615447044, -0.057018984109163284, 0.012582373805344105, 0.012743746861815453, -0.018177123740315437, 0.053012702614068985, 0.007194284349679947, 0.03352300077676773, -0.020252695307135582, -0.009403934702277184, -0.03238445520401001, -0.08349120616912842, -0.0412520207464695, -0.01675170101225376, -0.015913724899291992, 0.04292747378349304, -0.01454627513885498, -0.041919056326150894, 0.01677955500781536, -0.04332482069730759, 0.030539212748408318, -0.009013228118419647, 0.021565454080700874, 0.0015163811622187495, 0.07067643105983734, -0.0023859599605202675, -0.017659585922956467, 0.009882008656859398, -0.01151643693447113, 0.11685484647750854, 0.07964075356721878, 0.021705565974116325, -0.08074211329221725, 0.03391457721590996, -0.0007076884503476322, 0.011370604857802391, 0.000779409718234092, -0.007580051198601723, -0.0018884707242250443, -0.022384746000170708, 0.0786840170621872, 0.03635195270180702, 0.019283926114439964, -0.00787490513175726, 0.05308765918016434, -0.030416224151849747, -0.04346509277820587, -0.010503839701414108, 0.016384290531277657, -0.001073239604011178, 0.0073215714655816555, -0.01772741973400116, 0.026241518557071686, -0.00198403955437243, -0.037135496735572815, -0.030321508646011353, -0.030517226085066795, 0.015732398256659508, -0.01583460532128811, -0.005507627502083778, -0.007494582328945398, 0.038925014436244965, -0.0013667853781953454, -0.028950419276952744, -0.0061707450076937675, 0.02118760161101818, -0.08541258424520493, -0.00877249613404274, 0.018307523801922798, -0.04429406672716141, 0.009350418113172054, -0.00348738394677639, 0.007984701544046402, -0.058414679020643234, -0.0035312683321535587, -0.02375160902738571, 0.08907431364059448, -0.004837273620069027, -0.043904516845941544, -0.03540968522429466, 0.029273197054862976, 0.04648978263139725, -0.03222689777612686, -0.03987985476851463, 0.046312324702739716, 0.04527830332517624, -0.04906957969069481, -0.022392190992832184, -0.0290219709277153, 0.0335393063724041, 0.028202183544635773, 0.06132806837558746, 0.02570897340774536, -0.024390781298279762, -0.00833602249622345, -0.05054818093776703, 0.05141519010066986, -0.020276812836527824, 0.02436714991927147, 0.037147533148527145, 0.004563514608889818, 0.0016286297468468547, 0.012927528470754623, 0.010689343325793743, 0.01156718097627163, -0.019793836399912834, -0.013668748550117016, -0.013730332255363464, -0.04956475645303726, -0.04313093051314354, -0.006538212299346924, -0.0399109311401844, 0.017675239592790604, -0.02418617717921734, 0.017935000360012054, 0.030703676864504814, 0.06322287023067474, 0.04867839068174362, 0.01869179494678974, -0.012344103306531906, 0.04845050349831581, 0.035840436816215515, -0.054166391491889954, -0.0016090100398287177, -0.016843577846884727, -0.0026678384747356176, -0.009667661972343922, -0.055729325860738754, 0.04205749183893204, -0.015220653265714645, 0.01303973700851202, 0.006178309675306082, 0.02749200351536274, 0.002675485797226429, 0.009651383385062218, 0.004688275512307882, -0.05202057957649231, -0.03029681369662285, 0.017323682084679604, 0.026087429374456406, 0.03487712889909744, -0.0076591698452830315, -0.03332209214568138, -0.056869834661483765, 0.011509653180837631, -0.05159442126750946, -0.04190985858440399, 0.0500694178044796, -0.03089679591357708, 0.06449401378631592, -0.018750568851828575, 0.01688658632338047, -0.049337420612573624, -0.004092636052519083, 0.010898840613663197, -0.014283489435911179, 0.008017766289412975, 0.018518874421715736, -0.028119239956140518, 0.029589220881462097, 0.026815498247742653, -0.0045556118711829185, 0.03258102387189865, 0.019572973251342773, 0.04730847105383873, -0.01860969513654709, 0.018960310146212578, -0.012949597090482712, 0.019178057089447975, -0.009445618838071823, -0.007811028975993395, -0.005871604196727276, 0.03327552601695061, -0.009981432929635048, 0.04039758816361427, -0.009801162406802177, -0.004606012254953384, -0.02426626905798912, 0.022827427834272385, -0.028181513771414757, -0.04022306576371193, -0.0018985650967806578, -0.01825377531349659, 0.008390012197196484, -0.004243976902216673, -0.007544009014964104, 0.010149244219064713, -0.013363003730773926, 0.02073252946138382, 0.016696982085704803, 0.04031413048505783, -0.02965979464352131, -0.013803801499307156, 0.01837906800210476, 0.03487296774983406, -0.010212091729044914, -0.04075603559613228, 0.043801385909318924, 0.056419190019369125, 0.01767706498503685, 0.06675422936677933, -0.0024797089863568544, 0.03580067306756973, -0.09452340751886368, -0.047794461250305176, -0.008680528029799461, 0.029072226956486702, 0.023743074387311935, -0.06631147861480713, 0.014353352598845959, 0.0033088093623518944, -0.018008703365921974, 0.019894354045391083, 0.00037393398815765977, -0.003263826947659254, 0.002278371248394251, -0.01233583688735962, -0.027876129373908043, 0.007402749266475439, -0.004968075547367334, -0.0010342284804210067, 0.02317405492067337, 0.06464917957782745, -0.002549709053710103, -0.028000326827168465, -0.0097054373472929, 0.004810381680727005, 0.00229371408931911, -0.05023389682173729, 0.023699166253209114, -0.03363817185163498, -0.02818962186574936, 0.014800929464399815, -0.014333385042846203, 0.04390527680516243, 0.04250006377696991, 0.020671788603067398, 0.03781520947813988, 0.0429258793592453, 0.03713862597942352, -0.0008368533453904092, 0.028116686269640923, -0.0008052792982198298, 0.031804896891117096, 0.01283450797200203, -0.025439642369747162, 0.02533644624054432, 0.02484983392059803, 0.01091503631323576, 0.00632205605506897, 0.017965378239750862, -0.013945159502327442, 0.0043686931021511555, -0.016829492524266243, 0.0006443197489716113, -0.01473244372755289, -0.006606052163988352, 0.008671436458826065, -0.050920773297548294, -0.02069767192006111, 0.028878195211291313, 0.024490874260663986, -0.05402921512722969, 0.016119034960865974, 0.02392004057765007, -0.013419889844954014, -0.013372177258133888, -0.029386227950453758, -0.010264381766319275, -0.0261271670460701, 0.027111783623695374, 0.004156501963734627, -0.02502005361020565, -0.059462275356054306, 0.015248795039951801, -0.05149124562740326, 0.007044611964374781, -0.06483859568834305, -0.01841668225824833, 0.009270938113331795, -0.03141700476408005, 0.03335558623075485, -0.07838691771030426, 0.07142211496829987, 0.013586931861937046, -0.024635501205921173, -0.03364304080605507, -0.02291855216026306, -0.0339641273021698, 0.012330879457294941, 0.0820176750421524, 0.022640982642769814, 0.010120633989572525, -0.00584102887660265, 0.04102887958288193, 0.000803110480774194, -0.028237994760274887, 0.024411460384726524, -0.033852361142635345, -0.02756332792341709, -0.03136604651808739, -0.022423110902309418, -0.001907124649733305, 0.0010363220935687423, 0.034273795783519745, -0.028930069878697395, -0.006096570286899805, 0.010378909297287464, 0.014217616058886051, 0.005539241712540388, -0.012348948046565056, -0.020311642438173294, 0.019991785287857056, 0.0040468983352184296, 0.030238313600420952, 0.0654732808470726, -0.010406467132270336, -0.09172356873750687, 0.04332331568002701, 0.004265214316546917, -0.031261324882507324, -0.02353789657354355, 0.0010275349486619234, -0.013878529891371727, -0.05136200040578842, 0.036314092576503754, -0.006745080929249525, -0.027970222756266594, 0.021915815770626068, 0.04713873937726021, 0.01099334191530943, 0.021366944536566734, -0.00716121681034565, 0.04183245077729225, 0.00720352353528142, -0.05296466127038002, 0.018176577985286713, -0.000356732722138986, 0.01539737917482853, -0.0025051545817404985, -0.014690675772726536, 0.0408315546810627, 0.006055939011275768, 0.022192781791090965, -0.011142875999212265, 0.03350392356514931, -0.029893677681684494, -0.011402969248592854, -0.024114711210131645, -0.006497732829302549, 0.015728499740362167, 0.02197851426899433, -0.012602628208696842, 0.060100555419921875, -0.0442611463367939, 0.00464172288775444, -0.017736108973622322, -0.012818588875234127, -0.03341148793697357, 0.0010818428127095103, 0.033937957137823105, 0.0694887638092041, 0.014279722236096859, 0.041616130620241165, -0.029052887111902237, -0.03327466920018196, 0.01587606966495514, 0.01236644946038723, 0.02305147424340248, -0.01818486861884594, -0.014294286258518696, -0.015764547511935234, -0.021585576236248016, -0.022076737135648727, -0.05336732789874077, 0.0320853553712368, 0.05908355861902237, 0.00017934609786607325, -0.03093116544187069, -0.04531414806842804, 0.018486881628632545, 0.03678594157099724, -0.05834373086690903, -0.04556811600923538, -0.05225242301821709, 0.006244578864425421, 0.045119620859622955, -0.006558477878570557 ]
<p>I have two autocorrelation functions measured from the same stationary process, but the two measurements were taken with different instruments that measure different lag times. I would like to combine these two autcorrelation functions together into one single curve that spans the entire lag time of both instruments. It seems that these could be combined in the frequency domain with Wiener-Khinchin theorem, but I have not gotten anything reasonable to come out from this. Thanks!</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/soTIx.jpg" alt="Two autocorrelation functions"></p> <p>The autocorrelation data:</p> <p>Short lag times: {{0.0166638, 1.2427}, {0.0333277, 1.16926}, {0.0499915, 1.18007}, {0.0666553, 1.17344}, {0.0833192, 1.21829}, {0.099983, 1.19867}, {0.116647, 1.14627}, {0.133311, 1.17827}, {0.166638, 1.19614}, {0.199966, 1.19341}, {0.233294, 1.18352}, {0.266621, 1.18402}, {0.333277, 1.18672}, {0.399932, 1.18258}, {0.466587, 1.15333}, {0.533243, 1.17556}, {0.666553, 1.17179}, {0.799864, 1.17035}, {0.933175, 1.18451}, {1.06649, 1.16379}, {1.33311, 1.14078}, {1.59973, 1.13816}, {1.86635, 1.13299}, {2.13297, 1.13205}, {2.66621, 1.09647}, {3.19946, 1.09374}, {3.7327, 1.07922}, {4.26594, 1.06006}, {5.33243, 1.04623}, {6.39891, 1.03004}, {7.4654, 1.02369}, {8.53188, 1.01798}, {10.6649, 1.0145}, {12.7978, 1.00935}, {14.9308, 1.00495}, {17.0638, 1.00267}, {21.3297, 1.00247}, {25.5956, 1.00451}, {29.8616, 1.00155}, {34.1275, 1.00223}, {42.6594, 0.99827}, {51.1913, 1.00015}, {59.7232, 0.996647}}</p> <p>Longer lag times:</p> <p>{{1.483, 1.2196}, {2.966, 1.1595}, {4.4489, 1.1353}, {5.9319, 1.1261}, {7.4149, 1.1126}, {8.8979, 1.0907}, {10.381, 1.0796}, {11.864, 1.0697}, {14.83, 1.0471}, {17.796, 1.0397}, {20.762, 1.0229}, {23.728, 1.0199}, {29.66, 1.0097}, {35.592, 1.0077}, {41.524, 1.0048}, {47.455, 1.004}, {59.319, 1.0023}, {71.183, 1.0008}, {83.047, 1.0011}, {94.911, 0.99988}, {118.64, 1.0013}, {142.37, 1.001}, {166.09, 0.99821}, {189.82, 0.99895}, {237.28, 1.0015}, {284.73, 1.0006}, {332.19, 0.99739}}</p>
73,921
[ 0.00965329259634018, 0.004780217539519072, 0.012454756535589695, -0.006166336126625538, 0.00694301538169384, -0.027840927243232727, -0.047327253967523575, -0.013714050874114037, -0.011973299086093903, -0.02563212625682354, 0.0611114464700222, 0.02142920531332493, 0.05871101841330528, 0.05620937794446945, 0.004185957368463278, -0.010414970107376575, -0.005224470514804125, 0.032240696251392365, -0.018116146326065063, -0.041187360882759094, 0.0014683700865134597, 0.01674473285675049, -0.011395425535738468, -0.02208704501390457, 0.004493196960538626, 0.0345635786652565, 0.010751709342002869, -0.015374884940683842, -0.02953307330608368, 0.056676365435123444, -0.07736439257860184, -0.01400197483599186, 0.004260715562850237, 0.04844854772090912, 0.02902698703110218, 0.01587287150323391, -0.012191935442388058, -0.025600813329219818, -0.002446881029754877, 0.05586490035057068, -0.04247255623340607, 0.039170462638139725, -0.022166557610034943, 0.030441299080848694, -0.007299880031496286, 0.013100787997245789, 0.031139252707362175, -0.008144740015268326, 0.02184031344950199, 0.005701917689293623, 0.08166567236185074, -0.009389220736920834, 0.04679984971880913, 0.018602417781949043, -0.02844063565135002, -0.026108408346772194, 0.05934040620923042, 0.04672294110059738, 0.0017434780020266771, -0.049028608947992325, 0.007978647015988827, 0.014888974837958813, 0.013166357763111591, -0.00015248358249664307, -0.02701941318809986, 0.00935803260654211, -0.011671502143144608, -0.025676526129245758, 0.011398819275200367, -0.030100679025053978, 0.026834458112716675, 0.006775303743779659, 0.03282206505537033, -0.04388035833835602, 0.01972464844584465, -0.04106353968381882, -0.0026821650099009275, 0.03376218304038048, 0.05505230277776718, 0.030143428593873978, 0.0049156625755131245, 0.014026341028511524, 0.039646562188863754, -0.014074292965233326, 0.03671969845890999, -0.002487113233655691, 0.09796340018510818, -0.029853392392396927, 0.000985747086815536, 0.008836082182824612, -0.009785978123545647, 0.018486661836504936, 0.04323500022292137, 0.027127031236886978, -0.0315253920853138, 0.006954689044505358, 0.03353305906057358, 0.025341374799609184, -0.011259154416620731, -0.021914606913924217, -0.0410025417804718, -0.04599225893616676, -0.00486541585996747, 0.06592550873756409, 0.0029199188575148582, 0.004416350275278091, 0.018060842528939247, -0.034493062645196915, -0.0721612423658371, -0.03646719083189964, -0.0004415660514496267, -0.07330530881881714, 0.004656742326915264, 0.0060666995123028755, -0.0011827147100120783, 0.017667219042778015, 0.015197745524346828, -0.0008973447838798165, 0.055972568690776825, 0.051809825003147125, 0.05697561055421829, -0.02523741126060486, -0.0019233804196119308, -0.03723444417119026, -0.09325528144836426, 0.04131634533405304, -0.028075942769646645, 0.011296517215669155, -0.010152068920433521, 0.03851298987865448, 0.00764838932082057, -0.0604076161980629, 0.021017832681536674, -0.017250364646315575, 0.04905138537287712, -0.012134363874793053, -0.05826374143362045, -0.04494474455714226, 0.03539646044373512, -0.009376510977745056, 0.0249729473143816, -0.06229953467845917, 0.021804364398121834, 0.01246947143226862, 0.08590131253004074, 0.011380153708159924, 0.005764312110841274, 0.03497639298439026, 0.04974400997161865, 0.010156882926821709, -0.012335703708231449, -0.02178228460252285, -0.015283883549273014, -0.012157810851931572, -0.020249441266059875, -0.039747580885887146, -0.017502078786492348, 0.01332862488925457, -0.01772879809141159, 0.035899508744478226, 0.01672113686800003, 0.014553384855389595, 0.004976687021553516, -0.027384301647543907, 0.01725502498447895, -0.026376880705356598, 0.05112481489777565, 0.004468339961022139, -0.010752847418189049, -0.006680152844637632, -0.01791243813931942, 0.0011136585380882025, -0.00562476459890604, 0.031939875334501266, 0.030349697917699814, -0.02205340377986431, 0.0027068110648542643, 0.014401333406567574, -0.019744183868169785, 0.06335379928350449, -0.027411192655563354, -0.01784357987344265, -0.015172663144767284, -0.010454004630446434, 0.03889651596546173, 0.030865192413330078, 0.02597878687083721, -0.022383926436305046, 0.006753596011549234, -0.07249975949525833, 0.005019118078052998, -0.026775788515806198, -0.01115371473133564, -0.005731017328798771, -0.0721621960401535, 0.02367948181927204, 0.011219584383070469, -0.005221263039857149, -0.002399432472884655, -0.06748056411743164, -0.03043217957019806, 0.031368106603622437, 0.03791380301117897, -0.0245114304125309, 0.0336759127676487, 0.04494580999016762, 0.06269191205501556, -0.012628789059817791, 0.051799967885017395, 0.012398273684084415, 0.031138001009821892, 0.013695742003619671, -0.05142369121313095, 0.016142256557941437, -0.037504322826862335, 0.03725702315568924, -0.0036660227924585342, -0.02475864812731743, -0.004165283869951963, 0.014063066802918911, -0.057516422122716904, 0.07804824411869049, 0.057730983942747116, -0.007888145744800568, -0.001593256602063775, 0.035140182822942734, 0.02926277182996273, 0.07071514427661896, -0.026916494593024254, -0.028784872964024544, -0.049171607941389084, -0.01075721625238657, 0.022378133609890938, 0.0855865329504013, -0.019228780642151833, -0.0008848367142491043, 0.03802414610981941, 0.02107653021812439, -0.00027467060135677457, 0.023622069507837296, 0.02078765444457531, -0.030091404914855957, 0.018048712983727455, 0.006135597359389067, 0.015029258094727993, -0.04788202419877052, -0.028799191117286682, -0.012395413592457771, 0.03092881105840206, -0.025060126557946205, 0.00530173210427165, 0.024309149011969566, 0.015184805728495121, 0.0020447575952857733, -0.005103061906993389, -0.004972144030034542, 0.014558590948581696, -0.016920261085033417, 0.0009209354175254703, 0.013527894392609596, 0.007380752824246883, -0.019709119573235512, 0.011437006294727325, -0.0029624265152961016, 0.012905657291412354, 0.03362259641289711, -0.01645737700164318, -0.046088848263025284, 0.014902870170772076, -0.01790010929107666, -0.001580356271006167, -0.02650497294962406, -0.036043424159288406, -0.01636854186654091, 0.005372308194637299, 0.040298379957675934, 0.02691422589123249, 0.062295667827129364, -0.027161262929439545, -0.021140430122613907, -0.013150779530405998, 0.005271438043564558, 0.029631584882736206, 0.004916397389024496, -0.0008919239626266062, 0.011132225394248962, -0.0058624958619475365, 0.0027154425624758005, 0.005188386421650648, 0.005835205782204866, -0.02243606559932232, 0.016405362635850906, 0.0026544879656285048, -0.07372023910284042, -0.043062373995780945, -0.04547259211540222, 0.03272730112075806, -0.019214775413274765, 0.01997407153248787, 0.0361286960542202, -0.005602566059678793, -0.08889969438314438, 0.023359514772892, -0.004195101093500853, 0.02494342438876629, -0.0005598191055469215, -0.01017442625015974, 0.005413695238530636, -0.03438986837863922, 0.0016516947653144598, 0.023363223299384117, -0.01074268389493227, -0.00832944456487894, -0.04412790387868881, -0.03530121594667435, 0.005013395566493273, -0.007672269828617573, 0.028012067079544067, 0.012289593927562237, -0.022448785603046417, 0.05045736953616142, 0.019404195249080658, -0.03760102763772011, -0.0512012243270874, 0.011648832820355892, -0.021893322467803955, -0.03277236223220825, 0.007130484562367201, 0.03429653123021126, -0.026372894644737244, 0.048828188329935074, -0.0011021711397916079, -0.00012460190919227898, 0.07267682254314423, 0.015532390214502811, 0.012462756596505642, 0.03668597713112831, 0.012136002071201801, 0.006152678746730089, 0.042934685945510864, 0.011125189252197742, 0.03098439797759056, -0.020597295835614204, -0.020591508597135544, 0.020880119875073433, 0.025370201095938683, -0.0430537573993206, 0.03546367958188057, 0.025953182950615883, -0.0033584819175302982, -0.06597720086574554, 0.01300954632461071, 0.0130312480032444, -0.02754030004143715, -0.09268614649772644, 0.015359778888523579, 0.005875121336430311, 0.006331879645586014, 0.04720180109143257, 0.07185285538434982, 0.0313933789730072, -0.027453957125544548, -0.02881222777068615, -0.06429450958967209, -0.009847860783338547, 0.07133402675390244, -0.04077104106545448, -0.023858511820435524, 0.04501461982727051, 0.006802747026085854, 0.013970790430903435, -0.008839561603963375, -0.037726327776908875, 0.0028068297542631626, -0.07692565768957138, -0.0014504147693514824, -0.0449020154774189, 0.06392783671617508, 0.03380700945854187, 0.06841953098773956, 0.0022166951093822718, -0.039289020001888275, 0.017115462571382523, -0.016866890713572502, -0.06613831967115402, 0.04589736834168434, 0.04651886224746704, -0.026682082563638687, 0.0007618058589287102, -0.044716570526361465, 0.02253805100917816, -0.03888676315546036, 0.01773669384419918, 0.001588155748322606, 0.012940599583089352, -0.019765252247452736, 0.018413282930850983, -0.013233288191258907, -0.03719612583518028, -0.037386175245046616, 0.005337913986295462, 0.03643953055143356, -0.044033002108335495, 0.03634195774793625, 0.0011375838657841086, 0.021295882761478424, 0.0022875547874718904, -0.023550117388367653, 0.02353488653898239, 0.005508278030902147, 0.017765145748853683, 0.013023671694099903, 0.006447410210967064, -0.021534904837608337, 0.037861280143260956, 0.022870639339089394, 0.03359957039356232, 0.0664159432053566, -0.029954977333545685, -0.011263784021139145, -0.01902913860976696, 0.0006262038368731737, 0.018596867099404335, 0.020916607230901718, 0.0065847295336425304, -0.019654039293527603, -0.008242277428507805, 0.013954010792076588, 0.00538813229650259, 0.019237807020545006, 0.009981747716665268, -0.0010224570287391543, 0.01984572224318981, -0.03664373606443405, -0.026690473780035973, 0.0074368673376739025, -0.006768136750906706, 0.01656528003513813, 0.024968821555376053, -0.02020379900932312, -0.011480364948511124, 0.010845707729458809, 0.01876867562532425, -0.04342095926403999, 0.012664376758038998, 0.045533809810876846, 0.02614256739616394, -0.01395329087972641, -0.02970093861222267, 0.023935241624712944, 0.0586627759039402, 0.03119916282594204, 0.03811975568532944, 0.02462281845510006, -0.10070932656526566, 0.005528465379029512, 0.02789239026606083, 0.04081945866346359, -0.03088059090077877, 0.009298570454120636, -0.10396087169647217, -0.029806897044181824, 0.04133874550461769, -0.009295620955526829, 0.06748762726783752, -0.004540178459137678, 0.023022841662168503, -0.047637347131967545, -0.04911234974861145, -0.06254041939973831, 0.04831108823418617, 0.008196292445063591, -0.02131553925573826, -0.03586906939744949, -0.023232022300362587, -0.0005963294534012675, -0.0030191061086952686, 0.0183285903185606, 0.06406430155038834, -0.022104626521468163, 0.015079524368047714, 0.033889949321746826, 0.016807278618216515, 0.010119982063770294, -0.06928256899118423, 0.0006942944601178169, 0.006810613442212343, -0.012780453078448772, 0.04688521847128868, -0.011968259699642658, 0.01748400554060936, 0.029525984078645706, 0.02092709392309189, 0.013689788058400154, 0.03587128594517708, -0.028430432081222534, 0.09711963683366776, 0.049612678587436676, 0.04163780435919762, 0.06788960099220276, 0.053100477904081345, 0.0062950081191957, -0.002710668370127678, -0.020589614287018776, -0.002854987047612667, -0.04288855195045471, -0.004166872706264257, -0.05225891247391701, -0.042598385363817215, -0.042054902762174606, -0.012638203799724579, -0.03513532131910324, 0.008544898591935635, -0.0293374452739954, -0.002304821740835905, -0.005413881503045559, 0.027533868327736855, -0.03216475993394852, -0.012159818783402443, 0.0017427271232008934, 0.014005403034389019, -0.0034083875361829996, -0.020803658291697502, -0.021560806781053543, -0.0216505266726017, 0.026568563655018806, 0.010729625821113586, -0.026616865769028664, 0.02709086425602436, -0.03461256995797157, -0.0038160306867212057, -0.05426635593175888, -0.028941402211785316, 0.008276384323835373, 0.013365652412176132, 0.07427313178777695, 0.027284549549221992, -0.01646055094897747, 0.04164265841245651, 0.006925610359758139, 0.005619618110358715, 0.01802995055913925, -0.038596976548433304, 0.007966840639710426, 0.012160207144916058, -0.031135069206357002, -0.06529448926448822, -0.028692174702882767, 0.020315760746598244, -0.010531124658882618, -0.018265994265675545, -0.03835909068584442, -0.0014970945194363594, 0.0083572156727314, 0.0028239667881280184, -0.0027581818867474794, -0.00012769184831995517, -0.006334305740892887, 0.004704001359641552, -0.01403853204101324, 0.0032028586138039827, 0.055350955575704575, -0.011074980720877647, 0.03686174377799034, -0.014161855913698673, -0.027597632259130478, -0.052252147346735, 0.022592011839151382, -0.0033757875207811594, -0.039946094155311584, -0.015334323979914188, -0.01953662559390068, -0.019009463489055634, 0.03991157189011574, -0.022608254104852676, -0.029688941314816475, 0.017563968896865845, 0.03094533272087574, 0.01135042030364275, -0.0036633764393627644, -0.008380034007132053, 0.031354330480098724, -0.019613495096564293, -0.02548683062195778, 0.04978877678513527, -0.0032543318811804056, -0.024385400116443634, -0.020816925913095474, -0.00952699314802885, -0.07906413823366165, 0.020375747233629227, 0.05568673089146614, -0.02537568286061287, -0.010275933891534805, -0.024631468579173088, -0.004025643225759268, -0.0028835530392825603, 0.007145551033318043, -0.010440253652632236, 0.015258952043950558, 0.012141153216362, -0.0353669635951519, -0.009497279301285744, -0.053869087249040604, -0.040101222693920135, 0.07023750245571136, 0.010417337529361248, 0.06318093091249466, 0.06093135476112366, 0.026387576013803482, -0.023432619869709015, -0.01697419583797455, -0.00537720276042819, -0.020580867305397987, -0.010935593396425247, 0.045842841267585754, -0.021572859957814217, -0.039008647203445435, 0.026954863220453262, 0.016790248453617096, 0.02059229277074337, 0.016515498980879784, -0.047177594155073166, 0.03558259829878807, 0.0023086578585207462, -0.00488805677741766, -0.05075257644057274, 0.03617767617106438, -0.01813555136322975, 0.035504139959812164, 0.0048279049806296825, -0.007864202372729778, 0.008288314566016197, 0.06556271761655807, -0.014474552124738693, -0.05073119327425957, -0.017245011404156685, -0.05978597700595856, 0.018573375418782234, 0.03472306951880455, -0.03859540447592735, 0.06226889789104462, 0.014708016999065876, 0.04044153541326523, 0.018870173022150993, 0.0207448061555624, -0.030031589791178703, -0.036608465015888214, 0.012657500803470612, -0.0299291480332613, -0.021726762875914574, 0.07865682244300842, -0.03089938871562481, -0.04924064874649048, 0.0400727242231369, -0.005492835771292448, 0.019724655896425247, -0.012977633625268936, -0.00034416778362356126, -0.0037170241121202707, 0.0732024684548378, 0.029525408521294594, 0.015928560867905617, -0.0009193565347231925, -0.011827378533780575, 0.14953753352165222, 0.04204333573579788, 0.006065171677619219, -0.054785795509815216, 0.015464164316654205, 0.015365073457360268, 0.010101037099957466, -0.004243351053446531, -0.006646397989243269, -0.01218457892537117, -0.02503383718430996, 0.026887957006692886, 0.02834254503250122, -0.003638615133240819, 0.005268743261694908, 0.0024627093225717545, -0.000332159484969452, 0.02547517418861389, -0.012018836103379726, 0.013634254224598408, -0.01007144246250391, 0.032879915088415146, -0.04334482550621033, -0.0008023175760172307, -0.08457405120134354, -0.0193927101790905, -0.00626026839017868, -0.06836647540330887, 0.016519038006663322, -0.010927432216703892, -0.023411061614751816, 0.030076419934630394, 0.052316173911094666, 0.001536389347165823, -0.004744071513414383, 0.0014774762094020844, 0.007926135323941708, -0.029421890154480934, 0.02697705663740635, 0.013117529451847076, 0.03802887722849846, -0.015542381443083286, -0.008250555954873562, -0.011800083331763744, -0.04030526056885719, -0.02360036037862301, -0.02078709565103054, 0.03761189803481102, -0.0020632799714803696, -0.050964225083589554, -0.03891226276755333, 0.006571491248905659, 0.037433262914419174, -0.02062002755701542, -0.012467192485928535, -0.00760623486712575, -0.006433677393943071, -0.0371839813888073, 0.0035296122077852488, -0.018020406365394592, 0.02108113095164299, 0.041786640882492065, 0.06572899967432022, 0.02993835136294365, -0.03852365165948868, -0.050998151302337646, -0.01847505196928978, 0.04726109281182289, -0.00015566169167868793, -0.016084538772702217, -0.004130746237933636, 0.009441825561225414, -0.03592708706855774, 0.013231013901531696, 0.013238091953098774, 0.04781521111726761, 0.012801562435925007, 0.002835976891219616, -0.008647088892757893, -0.01871461421251297, -0.0565897561609745, 0.006260352674871683, -0.013427873142063618, -0.01495678536593914, 0.000363746949005872, -0.016080524772405624, 0.0231078639626503, 0.030032122507691383, -0.0004351920506451279, 0.009430348873138428, -0.028062958270311356, 0.0713995173573494, 0.034710612148046494, -0.042703017592430115, -0.005344132427126169, -0.007093718741089106, -0.02752365544438362, -0.014279219321906567, -0.006465512793511152, 0.07017321139574051, 0.025133084505796432, 0.001660882611759007, -0.024708151817321777, 0.043748825788497925, -0.007905548438429832, -0.018830500543117523, -0.0036624714266508818, 0.022152287885546684, 0.0005865759449079633, 0.007317104376852512, -0.0035702786408364773, -0.0327666774392128, 0.0028503388166427612, -0.026435531675815582, -0.002672696951776743, 0.014759491197764874, -0.0184328630566597, -0.04123523086309433, 0.02077474072575569, -0.004286360461264849, -0.013883443549275398, -0.02393953874707222, 0.0314880795776844, -0.0341474749147892, -0.007258973084390163, -0.044552031904459, 0.006236694753170013, 0.014449957758188248, 0.05176619067788124, -0.0033739819191396236, -0.01718025654554367, 0.03748578205704689, 0.039512164890766144, -0.015045996755361557, -0.014251960441470146, 0.0260562002658844, 0.03499462082982063, 0.049995727837085724, 0.018937502056360245, -0.013257049024105072, -0.006707294378429651, -0.03812849521636963, -0.021708808839321136, 0.029866531491279602, 0.009264837019145489, 0.03426646441221237, 0.02365417592227459, -0.01069289818406105, -0.011673674918711185, 0.03869607672095299, -0.025904040783643723, -0.00660140672698617, -0.009074162691831589, -0.010988939553499222, 0.022417517378926277, 0.016208438202738762, 0.0035414667800068855, 0.038434021174907684, 0.03213195875287056, -0.004683588165789843, 0.052142176777124405, 0.009936724789440632, -0.00017469172598794103, 0.009352441877126694, 0.00019702085410244763, 0.012594264931976795, -0.012739457190036774, -0.028561247512698174, 0.06583601981401443, 0.02007351629436016, -0.003095701802521944, -0.017128324136137962, -0.003967780154198408, 0.01868337392807007, -0.06983314454555511, -0.011915883980691433, 0.0033039511181414127, -0.0027768935542553663, 0.04952213913202286, -0.04961781203746796, -0.014092456549406052, 0.011544977314770222, -0.02561238966882229, 0.0068177515640854836, -0.02650723233819008, 0.005463339854031801, -0.03513985127210617, -0.021921081468462944, -0.04174235090613365, 0.022080207243561745, 0.05445706099271774, 0.06046546250581741, 0.01972135528922081, 0.042847827076911926, 0.017364976927638054, -0.03042563423514366, -0.05331093817949295, -0.009454614482820034, 0.0025522762443870306, -0.012514067813754082, 0.03853670880198479, -0.05302449315786362, -0.010488656349480152, 0.028658302500844002, -0.0365358330309391, 0.007546307519078255, -0.0039277877658605576, 0.019093383103609085, -0.023360947147011757, 0.010505733080208302, 0.006965586915612221, 0.006889642216265202, 0.014479022473096848, -0.03809068724513054, 0.03372858837246895, 0.010542175732553005, -0.04347480833530426, 0.03364507853984833, 0.036233410239219666, -0.02136296033859253, -0.02653004601597786, -0.006003269460052252, 0.0010851777624338865, -0.022051727399230003, -0.01571519486606121, 0.01346252765506506, 0.005649130791425705, -0.02885848470032215, -0.028151147067546844, 0.0004102891543880105, -0.005860372446477413, 0.0378444530069828, 0.0039604599587619305, -0.018007803708314896, -0.011168044991791248, -0.025638308376073837, -0.04937449097633362, 0.02550489455461502, 0.029875006526708603, -0.03578802943229675, -0.017062842845916748, -0.03114183247089386, -0.0027829459868371487, -0.046072423458099365, -0.014852788299322128, 0.007498030085116625, -0.02978373132646084, 0.012731463648378849, -0.01152377761900425, -0.01570936292409897, -0.026474088430404663, -0.021403908729553223, -0.014095275662839413, -0.0626164972782135, 0.02563399076461792, 0.01257297769188881, -0.01462191715836525, -0.025937162339687347, -0.04236339405179024, -0.02302793227136135, 0.04749494045972824, -0.0020396301988512278, -0.006831486709415913, 0.01849210448563099, -0.011248419061303139, 0.026808761060237885, 0.04499455541372299, -0.013272612355649471, 0.052529752254486084, -0.007261508610099554, 0.007416070904582739, 0.024565039202570915, -0.004525706171989441, -0.0050306920893490314, 0.013206136412918568, 0.018888989463448524, -0.01577143371105194, 0.004210145212709904, 0.041519876569509506, -0.02380751259624958, 0.04114432632923126, -0.025106601417064667, -0.021540669724345207, 0.05554506555199623, -0.02890997752547264, -0.007039851974695921, 0.028320031240582466, -0.030241623520851135, -0.0417473278939724, -0.007568727247416973, -0.029638871550559998, -0.05311298370361328, -0.03720138967037201, 0.02271316945552826, 0.016294250264763832, -0.06076124683022499, -0.0004220929113216698, 0.00657513365149498, -0.04717335104942322, -0.018962349742650986, 0.022531116381287575, -0.03176964446902275, 0.02715221978724003, -0.017629006877541542, 0.04562453180551529, 0.0098068593069911, -0.025836767628788948, 0.01649530604481697, -0.0007298077689483762, 0.01375897042453289, 0.020061297342181206, -0.01395325269550085, -0.028317803516983986, -0.017239093780517578, -0.006674888543784618, -0.00932143535465002, 0.05170384421944618, -0.017857953906059265, -0.01584489829838276, 0.020610349252820015, -0.01529515627771616, 0.005162757821381092, 0.011224071495234966, 0.012943064793944359, 0.061736688017845154, -0.05306054651737213, 0.022737277671694756, -0.03700172156095505, -0.017124760895967484, 0.014429500326514244, 0.004984143190085888, 0.003748698625713587, 0.008972304873168468, -0.016925079748034477, 0.04044802114367485, -0.006033224985003471, -0.002422082470729947, -0.005390780512243509, -0.023885410279035568, 0.015128743834793568, -0.028472954407334328, -0.022775014862418175, 0.004116611089557409, -0.022548168897628784, -0.020091623067855835, -0.06101755425333977, 0.024574320763349533, 0.029801853001117706, -0.012752914801239967, -0.03548815846443176, 0.015609558671712875, -0.019755348563194275, 0.06200374662876129, -0.04608898609876633, 0.003842910286039114, -0.011732610873878002, 0.03326914831995964, 0.03273099660873413, -0.004597542807459831 ]
<p>I want to simulate data from the following model:</p> <p>$\textbf{z}_k=\textbf{H}\textbf{x}_k+\textbf{v}_k$ $\textbf{v}_k \sim N(\textbf{0},\textbf{R})$</p> <p>$\textbf{H}$ does not change over time<br> $\textbf{x}$ is a vector of loadings<br> $\textbf{R}$ is a diagonal of constants</p> <p>$\textbf{x}_k=\textbf{F}\textbf{x}_{k-1}+(\textbf{I}-\textbf{F}){\mu} + \textbf{w}_k $ $\textbf{w}_k \sim N(\textbf{0},\textbf{Q})$</p> <p>$\textbf{I}$ is the identity matrix<br> $\mu$ is the vector of mean values of $\textbf{x}$<br> $\textbf{F}$ is diagonal with the AR(1) params which do not change over time<br> $\textbf{Q}$ is diagonal with the innovation processes for $\textbf{x}$</p> <p>I have the following code in Matlab</p> <pre><code>nDates=20000; %number of dates mats=[1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 12 15 20 25 30]'; %maturities nY=length(mats); %#number of yields z=zeros(nY,nDates); %declare vector for yields x=zeros(3,nDates); %declare vector for factors R=0.00001; %standard deviation I=eye(3); %3*3 identity matrix v=normrnd(0,R,nY,nDates); %generate residuals F=[0.9963 0 0; 0 0.9478 0; 0 0 0.774]; %AR(1) matrix mu=[0.0501; -0.0251;-.0116]; %mean of X lambda=0.5536; q = [0.0026^0.5 0 0;0 0.0027^0.5 0; 0 0 0.0035^0.5]; Q=q*q'; rng('default'); % For reproducibility r = randn(nDates,3); w= (r*Q)'; B= [ones(nY,1),((1-exp(-lambda*mats))./(lambda*mats)),((1-exp(-lambda*mats))./(lambda*mats))-exp(-lambda*mats)]; X(:,1)=mu; for t=2:nDates x(:,t)=F*(x(:,t-1))+(I-F)*mu+w(:,t); z(:,t)=B*x(:,t)+v(:,t); end z(:,1)=[]; </code></pre> <p>It all seems straightforward enough but what test can I so to ensure that it has been implemented correctly?</p> <p>Ones I have thought of:<br> Check the correlation of the factors x on their 1 period lags match the values given in matrix F<br> Check that the variances of v and w are correct<br> Check that the mean of the simulated variables are correct </p> <p>I would like to check that the empirical variance of the parameters matches their theoretical equivalent, but I don't know what the theoretical equivalent should be?</p> <p>Please feel free to suggest further tests that will allow me to know for sure if the implementation is correct.</p>
73,922
[ -0.006388590671122074, -0.03776518628001213, 0.009406437166035175, -0.025341393426060677, 0.04327525570988655, -0.033273156732320786, -0.018332121893763542, -0.002298529725521803, 0.03047564998269081, -0.0342269204556942, 0.007760418113321066, 0.03917573392391205, 0.04368758574128151, 0.036101192235946655, 0.0008149424102157354, 0.032441530376672745, -0.015093188732862473, 0.007764969486743212, -0.012233752757310867, 0.032480232417583466, -0.01725398749113083, 0.04860889911651611, -0.02367131970822811, -0.0002394129114691168, -0.048472724854946136, 0.02052244544029236, 0.02285603992640972, -0.061481352895498276, 0.027847835794091225, 0.044412631541490555, -0.05511055514216423, -0.028123049065470695, 0.012157266028225422, 0.0031992660369724035, -0.019994724541902542, 0.027346206828951836, 0.005282791797071695, -0.0648227110505104, 0.03359467536211014, 0.0413355678319931, -0.02246168442070484, 0.030504906550049782, -0.027321817353367805, 0.04173845425248146, 0.0002634763950482011, 0.0032416023313999176, 0.025512225925922394, 0.015457832254469395, 0.06181884929537773, 0.018665093928575516, 0.04477741941809654, -0.019649015739560127, 0.016876081004738808, 0.01570066809654236, -0.056824084371328354, -0.03215928003191948, 0.006752006243914366, 0.008064244873821735, 0.013114959001541138, -0.02293904311954975, 0.03247092664241791, -0.0036720815114676952, -0.017449142411351204, -0.038463298231363297, -0.03327757865190506, 0.0006951663526706398, 0.019344955682754517, -0.02875169739127159, 0.055284399539232254, -0.04669611528515816, 0.02102343924343586, 0.037676308304071426, -0.012368882074952126, -0.0518212765455246, 0.02977931499481201, -0.016235684975981712, -0.004134302493184805, -0.01986144669353962, 0.015112894587218761, 0.008717898279428482, -0.016324155032634735, -0.010021911934018135, 0.017317593097686768, 0.02161419950425625, 0.010130821727216244, -0.022176124155521393, 0.04190921410918236, -0.000500300491694361, 0.03349081054329872, 0.011583665385842323, -0.04549219086766243, 0.014017967507243156, 0.058892689645290375, 0.013715691864490509, -0.0297455545514822, -0.02122518979012966, -0.009991259314119816, 0.03258174657821655, -0.006005355156958103, 0.008618439547717571, -0.0020129026379436255, -0.06030314415693283, -0.012861073017120361, 0.003013551700860262, -0.030428465455770493, -0.00380709464661777, 0.03019673377275467, -0.04355281963944435, -0.02896389737725258, -0.035985514521598816, -0.013338525779545307, 0.03302201256155968, -0.012493404559791088, -0.02625053934752941, 0.02252308651804924, -0.03499726578593254, -0.0015521032037213445, -0.020289137959480286, 0.02874539978802204, 0.09452472627162933, 0.0006266376003623009, -0.02051588147878647, 0.006862454582005739, -0.03645244985818863, -0.06253454089164734, -0.015283230692148209, -0.007559549529105425, -0.006195227615535259, -0.03763896971940994, 0.04431222751736641, 0.019754761829972267, -0.009917991235852242, 0.05235821008682251, -0.010083375498652458, 0.018978215754032135, -0.011283935979008675, -0.04848513379693031, -0.05802861601114273, 0.036487970501184464, -0.043370358645915985, 0.03398870304226875, -0.052507057785987854, 0.004390144255012274, 0.0272438433021307, 0.05462828651070595, 0.05419858545064926, 0.06008072569966316, 0.023051073774695396, 0.009722505696117878, 0.01881171390414238, 0.0033399711828678846, 0.0037781584542244673, -0.03099716454744339, 0.007945781573653221, 0.0019502595532685518, -0.060165561735630035, 0.002192478394135833, 0.022391725331544876, -0.03269927203655243, -0.005856045987457037, 0.024966692551970482, 0.04065179079771042, -0.0006344745634123683, -0.004827623255550861, -0.038595426827669144, -0.04884283244609833, 0.06375352293252945, -0.010514544323086739, 0.02742144465446472, 0.01671692728996277, -0.029585279524326324, 0.0167082566767931, -0.013662534765899181, 0.05339786782860756, 0.05018128827214241, -0.001320761744864285, 0.031089114025235176, -0.0013071796856820583, 0.012922992929816246, 0.039008282124996185, -0.024634964764118195, -0.00851716473698616, -0.028917014598846436, -0.0268413033336401, 0.008847929537296295, 0.05322474241256714, 0.0016099838539958, 0.006076181773096323, 0.03304506465792656, -0.02266312576830387, 0.00288532511331141, -0.045492153614759445, 0.02515353448688984, -0.008026792667806149, -0.03674723580479622, 0.022664828225970268, -0.015505552291870117, 0.008485794067382812, 0.05881412699818611, -0.03981940820813179, -0.041143570095300674, -0.022812699899077415, 0.030592603608965874, -0.030127327889204025, -0.00041474465979263186, 0.03355097770690918, 0.07120971381664276, 0.0019639667589217424, 0.01681721955537796, -0.019748937338590622, -0.0009589988039806485, 0.013990993611514568, -0.06058971956372261, 0.03916814923286438, 0.0016343968454748392, -0.015158798545598984, 0.03962767496705055, -0.0037626696284860373, 0.017716236412525177, 0.013823797926306725, -0.012591488659381866, -0.003310226835310459, 0.08902410417795181, -0.00674970680847764, -0.015484597533941269, -0.019487284123897552, -0.024015340954065323, 0.05827388912439346, -0.01028476282954216, -0.02445949614048004, -0.01576969586312771, -0.0025720722042024136, 0.03937080129981041, 0.03494245558977127, -0.06390738487243652, 0.020430350676178932, 0.04589126259088516, -0.02420923300087452, 0.016633059829473495, 0.05945727601647377, 0.0017855403712019324, -0.00008383138629142195, 0.03793203458189964, 0.0012151648988947272, 0.05612001195549965, -0.0163124930113554, -0.0019030295079573989, -0.009519685991108418, 0.023280255496501923, -0.01963810622692108, 0.007002956699579954, 0.026936525478959084, -0.01664942130446434, -0.012592902407050133, -0.02661556750535965, -0.006348308175802231, 0.024732910096645355, 0.006541970185935497, -0.04029972106218338, 0.05315577611327171, 0.02223578840494156, 0.004171004518866539, 0.010657785460352898, -0.032590217888355255, 0.0016235039802268147, 0.04884345084428787, -0.0047520785592496395, -0.0046316818334162235, 0.02212579734623432, -0.0034477850422263145, 0.017572443932294846, -0.025085128843784332, -0.02313186787068844, -0.04255754128098488, -0.0036905398592352867, 0.007048361003398895, 0.03757890313863754, -0.03557747229933739, -0.015247341245412827, 0.029585683718323708, 0.00582549162209034, 0.014978386461734772, 0.044285424053668976, 0.015112015418708324, -0.04013453796505928, -0.005774322431534529, 0.0025154834147542715, -0.007900998927652836, 0.04723795875906944, 0.01327423844486475, -0.047807738184928894, 0.06757647544145584, -0.018861833959817886, -0.05022774636745453, -0.031019186601042747, -0.0513860285282135, -0.013707201927900314, -0.025048119947314262, -0.004833312705159187, 0.048800431191921234, 0.022156672552227974, -0.06034822762012482, 0.015861956402659416, -0.0737452432513237, -0.024280842393636703, -0.026528308168053627, -0.03450385108590126, -0.018029045313596725, 0.007839164696633816, 0.008223097771406174, 0.005430999211966991, 0.0027320822700858116, 0.005505095236003399, -0.07602454721927643, -0.04022965952754021, -0.01877334713935852, -0.020457325503230095, 0.006761077791452408, -0.007169811986386776, 0.0126350037753582, 0.04496870934963226, 0.017708446830511093, -0.00861289631575346, -0.027396323159337044, -0.0042443787679076195, -0.0030599955935031176, -0.10461954772472382, 0.04402312636375427, 0.003573670983314514, -0.003578173229470849, 0.02968721091747284, -0.06710189580917358, 0.007033077534288168, 0.07263531535863876, -0.02982448600232601, 0.01470918394625187, -0.003475659526884556, -0.05128978192806244, -0.020447876304388046, 0.05620191991329193, 0.01550007238984108, -0.0011776532046496868, 0.0002017617371166125, -0.024615202099084854, 0.04316648095846176, 0.008088837377727032, -0.0676727220416069, 0.023245785385370255, -0.03571406006813049, 0.005916377529501915, -0.01824291981756687, 0.021095525473356247, -0.03499695658683777, -0.04713603854179382, -0.016197314485907555, -0.005591108463704586, 0.02349279448390007, -0.01665978692471981, 0.014197688549757004, 0.00898163765668869, 0.03787710517644882, -0.029810333624482155, 0.05231575295329094, -0.003133242018520832, -0.008040913380682468, 0.02005046047270298, -0.04808294028043747, 0.00609245989471674, 0.0740489587187767, 0.05271152779459953, 0.024829670786857605, 0.00621650880202651, 0.0025703536812216043, -0.023149902001023293, -0.03813529759645462, 0.010960827581584454, -0.01713181845843792, 0.06681258976459503, 0.018903305754065514, 0.039906006306409836, 0.006272939499467611, -0.00867953896522522, -0.015567025169730186, -0.04674585163593292, -0.05951449275016785, 0.0327661857008934, 0.018538521602749825, 0.0005752372089773417, 0.005669317673891783, -0.05665319412946701, 0.007510102353990078, -0.026988094672560692, 0.03902797773480415, 0.03255903348326683, 0.010621003806591034, -0.06488899141550064, -0.032536912709474564, -0.035938095301389694, -0.006688250228762627, -0.00028021822799928486, 0.02909398451447487, 0.07674290984869003, -0.045835308730602264, 0.015620654448866844, -0.008532948791980743, 0.001424740650691092, 0.0257588978856802, 0.0030714315362274647, 0.02790328487753868, 0.020540932193398476, 0.051628343760967255, 0.04535631462931633, 0.020228659734129906, -0.014143220148980618, 0.049745507538318634, 0.03985936567187309, 0.022095639258623123, 0.05062909796833992, 0.03681866452097893, 0.022207437083125114, -0.020679280161857605, 0.005514916963875294, -0.019781632348895073, -0.005087762605398893, -0.001831689034588635, -0.00504945358261466, 0.03206513077020645, 0.018488669767975807, -0.005316425114870071, 0.008102701976895332, 0.06018974632024765, 0.019741907715797424, 0.015966683626174927, -0.014487236738204956, 0.012668777257204056, 0.030198445543646812, -0.010730812326073647, 0.02021588571369648, 0.022747496142983437, 0.03319777920842171, -0.0041383057832717896, 0.023216016590595245, -0.003951468504965305, 0.015591108240187168, 0.041620925068855286, 0.03908536583185196, 0.06126103177666664, 0.0052559454925358295, 0.004912069067358971, -0.012338452972471714, 0.015875237062573433, 0.02233557403087616, 0.053642638027668, 0.008918923325836658, -0.09390032291412354, 0.005710122175514698, 0.008995890617370605, 0.024078980088233948, -0.015886161476373672, 0.0030880197882652283, -0.054612476378679276, -0.026784228160977364, 0.038257744163274765, -0.007409367244690657, 0.0415789932012558, -0.016684947535395622, 0.05979921296238899, -0.058617815375328064, 0.009454658254981041, -0.009698732756078243, 0.017816470935940742, -0.046802371740341187, 0.04276816546916962, -0.018960440531373024, -0.03961079195141792, 0.004659722559154034, 0.01691557466983795, 0.02447919175028801, 0.045891016721725464, -0.03609870746731758, -0.017150213941931725, 0.060872405767440796, 0.0024593821726739407, -0.01204991340637207, -0.09005358815193176, 0.023800235241651535, 0.03016192652285099, 0.01049650739878416, 0.061851512640714645, -0.026453496888279915, -0.02884525991976261, 0.05001155287027359, 0.027308259159326553, 0.04341966658830643, -0.005582393612712622, -0.04087458550930023, 0.027152985334396362, 0.01765599474310875, -0.026969902217388153, 0.015517305582761765, 0.06922972202301025, 0.000757671776227653, 0.011576593853533268, -0.027023810893297195, -0.019824054092168808, -0.01490867044776678, -0.003568887710571289, -0.06464330852031708, 0.006670004688203335, 0.018084906041622162, 0.032453663647174835, -0.0030068212654441595, 0.006794494576752186, -0.02719595469534397, 0.010371183976531029, 0.023664848878979683, 0.027411310002207756, -0.035818275064229965, -0.01120295375585556, -0.034144800156354904, -0.018656764179468155, -0.030203569680452347, 0.004129157401621342, -0.009098326787352562, -0.014615140855312347, -0.024590859189629555, -0.016016893088817596, 0.009883861057460308, 0.0018684612587094307, -0.01775290071964264, -0.012056650593876839, -0.032033521682024, -0.020680207759141922, 0.03180781006813049, -0.0045626782812178135, 0.06140461191534996, 0.036660049110651016, -0.015877122059464455, 0.01962762326002121, 0.02222590707242489, -0.016014959663152695, 0.012718742713332176, -0.018571926280856133, 0.007307596504688263, 0.016377758234739304, 0.008278810419142246, -0.05039677023887634, -0.05257577821612358, 0.03225742280483246, -0.02239994890987873, -0.05168035998940468, -0.022354956716299057, -0.040672387927770615, -0.005724471062421799, -0.016236282885074615, -0.002949429675936699, 0.03198161721229553, -0.029674919322133064, 0.011498059146106243, 0.010799488052725792, 0.036790475249290466, 0.038323741406202316, -0.004344531334936619, 0.003759666346013546, 0.04822105914354324, -0.0204221960157156, -0.017899466678500175, -0.01399154681712389, -0.023132018744945526, -0.0069300225004553795, 0.04408304765820503, -0.04167315736413002, -0.009728514589369297, 0.0852820873260498, -0.006563113536685705, -0.022313464432954788, 0.027364442124962807, -0.021316595375537872, 0.019934318959712982, -0.027376452460885048, -0.020519359037280083, -0.018569476902484894, 0.015045208856463432, -0.021279579028487206, -0.03898465260863304, 0.026557225733995438, 0.0018331385217607021, -0.0050443424843251705, -0.04113598167896271, -0.024616245180368423, 0.010211391374468803, 0.077499620616436, -0.027968881651759148, -0.021896041929721832, -0.03311978653073311, 0.011942680925130844, 0.02769577130675316, 0.011068262159824371, -0.029532959684729576, -0.010231922380626202, -0.02550041489303112, -0.0033393390476703644, -0.03857094794511795, -0.0852583572268486, 0.03494113311171532, 0.05453663691878319, 0.009580553509294987, 0.02928902581334114, 0.035668373107910156, 0.019898729398846626, -0.005028910934925079, -0.062186889350414276, -0.028909770771861076, 0.0024645249359309673, -0.014171206392347813, 0.06402184069156647, -0.01067865826189518, -0.011735230684280396, 0.03288968279957771, 0.028374677523970604, 0.017348039895296097, 0.03482743352651596, 0.00782437901943922, 0.006410231348127127, 0.0028320152778178453, -0.01956772990524769, -0.060228269547224045, -0.006537483539432287, -0.036035675555467606, 0.05233842134475708, -0.011657850816845894, 0.022552048787474632, 0.019286133348941803, 0.026778550818562508, 0.01822836324572563, -0.052138008177280426, -0.006997119635343552, -0.056654077023267746, -0.0034153414890170097, 0.027685584500432014, -0.017472444102168083, 0.020066574215888977, 0.016783008351922035, 0.08305095881223679, -0.010055046528577805, 0.027857733890414238, -0.030115921050310135, -0.04081664979457855, -0.02133236452937126, -0.02661464549601078, -0.009156814776360989, 0.02774825319647789, -0.022319525480270386, -0.01313387043774128, 0.01028210949152708, -0.012415755540132523, 0.022345498204231262, -0.01974092610180378, 0.024079564958810806, 0.03765207901597023, 0.07346276193857193, 0.0019045110093429685, 0.01773110404610634, -0.03509145230054855, 0.00586936017498374, 0.154901385307312, 0.049694448709487915, 0.0513489730656147, -0.012168584391474724, -0.021715180948376656, -0.007770128082484007, -0.019914716482162476, -0.01831894926726818, 0.018091650679707527, 0.0020386003889143467, -0.046461381018161774, 0.03902342915534973, 0.039712678641080856, 0.015367508865892887, 0.007154265884310007, -0.008905192837119102, -0.04567224904894829, -0.013428561389446259, -0.0515320710837841, 0.028072306886315346, -0.012991349212825298, 0.010777558200061321, -0.04372318461537361, 0.02872185781598091, -0.0026186788454651833, -0.033236224204301834, -0.017520884051918983, -0.010363367386162281, 0.008352958597242832, -0.0029627152252942324, -0.025867991149425507, 0.030588921159505844, 0.020875077694654465, 0.05786057189106941, 0.012829524464905262, 0.03265562653541565, 0.005059643182903528, -0.016367603093385696, 0.03816639259457588, 0.024838721379637718, 0.017899582162499428, -0.027057213708758354, -0.022430554032325745, -0.05708130821585655, -0.057038068771362305, -0.0035862766671925783, -0.049167703837156296, 0.031131546944379807, -0.0037945967633277178, -0.04054870828986168, -0.029851671308279037, -0.007722494192421436, 0.022788694128394127, -0.047049861401319504, -0.0011520710540935397, 0.02592453733086586, -0.03484627977013588, -0.03327818959951401, 0.0203647892922163, -0.0033750496804714203, -0.02071581408381462, 0.014278525486588478, 0.0057202596217393875, 0.04946300387382507, -0.050830941647291183, 0.021276801824569702, -0.0471012219786644, 0.06568662077188492, -0.03682230785489082, -0.005332509055733681, -0.005156353116035461, -0.0046750926412642, -0.00300392578355968, -0.04126425087451935, 0.021364755928516388, 0.009189276956021786, 0.03926809877157211, -0.02942504920065403, 0.010059015825390816, 0.007169515825808048, -0.0445864163339138, -0.0019229436293244362, 0.0033964370377361774, 0.003278783056885004, -0.03266119584441185, 0.015247577801346779, 0.03002539835870266, 0.03882480785250664, 0.020536307245492935, 0.014330802485346794, -0.011793679557740688, 0.05068327486515045, 0.023190248757600784, -0.05300984904170036, -0.07970215380191803, 0.028059832751750946, -0.022337468340992928, 0.02877526357769966, -0.027603188529610634, 0.05644167959690094, 0.026937317103147507, -0.009402287192642689, -0.002892284421250224, 0.05175676569342613, 0.014065759256482124, 0.007357950322329998, 0.013369705528020859, -0.017388969659805298, 0.04342271387577057, 0.016948765143752098, 0.010310393758118153, -0.048873111605644226, -0.009819685481488705, 0.005233009811490774, -0.03018019162118435, -0.01857641153037548, -0.023401394486427307, -0.009379584342241287, 0.01733955182135105, -0.054031550884246826, 0.0036067720502614975, -0.01611403375864029, -0.012411313131451607, 0.006586899049580097, 0.004856177605688572, 0.002150022890418768, 0.018081489950418472, -0.024613425135612488, 0.025047417730093002, -0.058310963213443756, -0.01575402542948723, 0.06281525641679764, 0.025134336203336716, 0.03967400640249252, -0.034835778176784515, 0.002774178981781006, 0.020971570163965225, 0.034691061824560165, 0.0025527148973196745, 0.002515280619263649, 0.018163373693823814, -0.030480902642011642, -0.017969248816370964, 0.002632086630910635, 0.02209850586950779, 0.027783365920186043, 0.021108990535140038, 0.01366334781050682, -0.014555288478732109, 0.02315022610127926, -0.04425213858485222, 0.03283679485321045, -0.025819536298513412, -0.0037153998855501413, -0.012189765460789204, -0.014010640792548656, 0.007422463037073612, 0.026946278288960457, -0.0010945774847641587, 0.0034035241696983576, 0.05005292594432831, -0.03941355273127556, -0.014055955223739147, 0.03136952221393585, -0.026263831183314323, -0.048311747610569, 0.003442786168307066, -0.008278721012175083, 0.035907987505197525, 0.06341441720724106, -0.008151971735060215, -0.01273967046290636, -0.03021819330751896, -0.009082448668777943, -0.07731135189533234, -0.05453156679868698, -0.017965221777558327, -0.0013955853646621108, 0.03738587349653244, -0.03330663591623306, 0.0004978568758815527, 0.0014612460508942604, -0.07442428171634674, 0.03762359917163849, 0.009743798524141312, 0.009347332641482353, -0.01419609971344471, 0.006007237359881401, -0.020876770839095116, 0.017406804487109184, 0.0009426504257135093, 0.018445560708642006, 0.027699392288923264, 0.04202805086970329, 0.008780979551374912, -0.02085437811911106, 0.004158357623964548, -0.012475620955228806, -0.0013801823370158672, -0.008363498374819756, 0.022540342062711716, -0.025930393487215042, -0.016027674078941345, -0.007623650133609772, -0.016497565433382988, 0.022472010925412178, 0.027792003005743027, -0.0036021594423800707, -0.02185560204088688, 0.058909911662340164, 0.030352303758263588, -0.015010682865977287, 0.023764949291944504, -0.038446903228759766, 0.02225644886493683, -0.0010982060339301825, 0.0019555718172341585, 0.0711272582411766, 0.035686057060956955, -0.0008557409164495766, -0.03724256530404091, -0.016582217067480087, 0.026591893285512924, -0.00743525568395853, 0.009505976922810078, 0.000471960986033082, -0.0011445451527833939, -0.014230282977223396, 0.000946963089518249, -0.0168656874448061, 0.020419606938958168, 0.025901759043335915, 0.04546048119664192, -0.016824202612042427, -0.008629458956420422, -0.05451293662190437, -0.043791741132736206, 0.006931337062269449, -0.004592075012624264, -0.022753633558750153, -0.06103092432022095, -0.0426812544465065, -0.02470664493739605, 0.018952541053295135, -0.05051499977707863, -0.010824427008628845, -0.03726835921406746, 0.04765128344297409, -0.050346504896879196, -0.059237364679574966, -0.00609941640868783, -0.019300362095236778, 0.04234069213271141, -0.07195889204740524, 0.03088333271443844, -0.02092164382338524, -0.053539372980594635, -0.025801433250308037, -0.038671452552080154, -0.04609866812825203, 0.0350261926651001, 0.03052169643342495, -0.013189311139285564, 0.020015547052025795, -0.03670954331755638, 0.026243697851896286, 0.03405557945370674, -0.06081409379839897, 0.08083903789520264, 0.01551872305572033, 0.013663268648087978, 0.02407987043261528, -0.0027430756017565727, 0.036099229007959366, 0.006490325089544058, 0.008690407499670982, -0.0009817007230594754, -0.009548906236886978, 0.011179069057106972, -0.04723590612411499, -0.03112194687128067, -0.014772177673876286, -0.03235051408410072, 0.038611266762018204, -0.005823061801493168, 0.03803051635622978, 0.010137231089174747, 0.014947897754609585, -0.051993172615766525, 0.005045715719461441, -0.015419351868331432, -0.008846436627209187, -0.011917298659682274, -0.026615137234330177, 0.0420849584043026, -0.07018238306045532, -0.048916272819042206, 0.0031791843939572573, -0.024717625230550766, 0.013292853720486164, 0.039897892624139786, 0.04207752272486687, 0.024958422407507896, 0.008123255334794521, 0.015768302604556084, -0.02698350138962269, 0.02001389116048813, 0.013771365396678448, 0.009659847244620323, 0.020878562703728676, -0.01476508192718029, 0.025096777826547623, 0.03556808829307556, -0.03758285567164421, 0.013234694488346577, -0.003510416252538562, -0.0018009583000093699, 0.013846658170223236, -0.02655850350856781, 0.03741791099309921, 0.0450330413877964, 0.009317724034190178, 0.032525938004255295, 0.020118124783039093, 0.044159360229969025, -0.03861793130636215, 0.00485583720728755, -0.011482708156108856, 0.010514729656279087, -0.06396251916885376, 0.014335829764604568, -0.018444813787937164, 0.008424967527389526, -0.03177878260612488, -0.03164684772491455, -0.008591564372181892, 0.00003425000613788143, -0.00025819780421443284, -0.013132723979651928, 0.0017680613091215491, 0.0384901687502861, 0.00016869351384229958, -0.0029359052423387766, -0.0160265751183033, -0.014269180595874786, -0.015960199758410454, 0.020146239548921585, 0.019637981429696083, 0.012197641655802727, -0.05166972801089287, 0.005522492807358503, -0.019926048815250397, 0.008990218862891197, -0.01798633486032486, 0.009268863126635551, -0.015529411844909191, 0.03418644890189171, 0.013372543267905712, 0.03366857022047043 ]
<p>In considering (for example) homicide rates reported annually for each country, it occurs to me that the U.S., being larger in population, might thereby be expected to have a rate closer to the worldwide mean.</p> <p>However, I don't know how to evaluate that idea quantitatively. What kind of additional data (if any) and calculations would be required to support that idea (not sure I should call it a hypothesis, because it relates to the model rather than to the world). </p> <p>Another way of thinking about this: with respect to statistics reported per country, does the U.S. look like a group of smaller countries combined?</p>
73,923
[ -0.05729766562581062, 0.0038937393110245466, 0.01455722562968731, -0.01632276549935341, 0.04208718612790108, 0.040595900267362595, -0.03398861736059189, -0.06172080338001251, 0.01885456219315529, -0.010369799099862576, 0.024495039135217667, 0.05365633964538574, 0.06064748764038086, 0.01695985347032547, 0.002740873023867607, -0.018590617924928665, -0.012362753972411156, 0.009222622960805893, -0.013035810552537441, -0.028477836400270462, 0.024712737649679184, 0.05660266429185867, 0.03836182877421379, -0.025798335671424866, -0.0243521761149168, 0.04549277201294899, 0.030863426625728607, -0.022216569632291794, 0.02258233167231083, 0.04606039449572563, 0.0193032119423151, 0.006661235820502043, 0.031168315559625626, 0.03323337435722351, 0.01984643004834652, 0.0305051039904356, -0.04219576343894005, -0.013332350179553032, 0.01669740118086338, 0.038579441606998444, -0.07753606885671616, -0.04079107195138931, -0.009369722567498684, 0.019340941682457924, -0.050614066421985626, 0.02892565354704857, -0.025800487026572227, -0.051764100790023804, 0.03410835191607475, -0.03451862186193466, 0.07228558510541916, 0.040984831750392914, 0.03301034867763519, 0.04766540229320526, 0.0029598954133689404, -0.00821678526699543, 0.05974533408880234, 0.08802077174186707, 0.0026609613560140133, -0.049946676939725876, -0.029121123254299164, -0.018425026908516884, -0.0025264667347073555, -0.04313370957970619, 0.015735607594251633, 0.05724486708641052, -0.03770998492836952, -0.054125405848026276, 0.013579493388533592, 0.009740861132740974, 0.02304374985396862, 0.01883191615343094, 0.02879793755710125, 0.004017970059067011, -0.0024601409677416086, -0.007961458526551723, 0.018565114587545395, 0.0026026577688753605, 0.023160859942436218, 0.015065811574459076, -0.010716450400650501, -0.02056965045630932, 0.040385738015174866, 0.06139910966157913, 0.03742726147174835, -0.016728529706597328, 0.04861878603696823, -0.01348193921148777, -0.03207328915596008, 0.0496949665248394, -0.06066512316465378, -0.010615129955112934, 0.024157429113984108, -0.009013664908707142, -0.04104795306921005, 0.0414569117128849, -0.027559315785765648, 0.05888189747929573, 0.019988413900136948, 0.024752546101808548, -0.027114998549222946, -0.03240552544593811, -0.00931705441325903, 0.012261494994163513, -0.017295602709054947, -0.0274028442800045, -0.02861625701189041, -0.028162667527794838, 0.009782129898667336, 0.019344108179211617, -0.04259610176086426, -0.0010658889077603817, 0.031039534136652946, -0.006182920653373003, 0.020205093547701836, 0.04022672772407532, 0.021021660417318344, -0.041492581367492676, 0.038467150181531906, 0.04338125139474869, 0.03230872377753258, -0.020751450210809708, 0.035498227924108505, -0.034184958785772324, -0.01416765060275793, 0.04442611336708069, 0.0043214778415858746, -0.03006439097225666, -0.01776953414082527, 0.034902166575193405, 0.011349854059517384, -0.023562775924801826, -0.006394232623279095, -0.004813636653125286, 0.09669830650091171, 0.004133902955800295, -0.059424810111522675, -0.06026766449213028, 0.042304087430238724, 0.024517863988876343, -0.008400355465710163, -0.051793694496154785, -0.02012951485812664, -0.03480745479464531, 0.0318271666765213, -0.00028467990341596305, 0.05079200118780136, 0.013698695227503777, 0.02478047087788582, 0.016134057193994522, -0.033624812960624695, -0.0020280980970710516, 0.015555061399936676, -0.0380118265748024, -0.0063195861876010895, -0.09695485234260559, 0.033193401992321014, 0.023430058732628822, 0.00021786395518574864, -0.010384309105575085, 0.02372685633599758, -0.0007334006950259209, -0.03172346577048302, 0.004776610527187586, 0.03567329794168472, 0.0003530633694026619, 0.05306246131658554, -0.013120043091475964, 0.012837250716984272, 0.02309202030301094, -0.0013304948806762695, 0.00016601169772911817, 0.042966049164533615, 0.022168468683958054, 0.04071226343512535, -0.04765242338180542, -0.006084938533604145, -0.00315979216247797, -0.015612599439918995, 0.016665536910295486, -0.04277065396308899, -0.023889150470495224, 0.01272673811763525, -0.012235935777425766, 0.04766218736767769, 0.04034935683012009, -0.002719014650210738, -0.011241169646382332, 0.033216558396816254, -0.05668526142835617, -0.06890702247619629, -0.08130153268575668, -0.023531688377261162, 0.017488960176706314, -0.021964259445667267, 0.005167842842638493, 0.006334448698908091, 0.027489613741636276, -0.020131826400756836, 0.01853145845234394, -0.03428039699792862, -0.010573569685220718, 0.02410774864256382, -0.011958843097090721, -0.0035744751803576946, 0.029612910002470016, 0.04892147704958916, 0.002550009870901704, 0.045430224388837814, -0.045077551156282425, -0.07940875738859177, 0.013690329156816006, -0.0633547380566597, 0.008728720247745514, 0.037289656698703766, -0.0009522710461169481, -0.005158545449376106, -0.002359406091272831, -0.024123158305883408, 0.01756095327436924, -0.03173680230975151, 0.03842360898852348, 0.03553451970219612, -0.01125656720250845, -0.003863314865157008, 0.03916427493095398, 0.022995492443442345, -0.011800338514149189, -0.0014540329575538635, -0.03390898555517197, -0.08269298076629639, 0.01026039570569992, 0.01321996096521616, 0.012206639163196087, -0.04017292335629463, -0.0004091611481271684, 0.06382852792739868, 0.04188917577266693, -0.010542033240199089, -0.036582645028829575, 0.002578135346993804, -0.004270844627171755, -0.0005175006226636469, -0.012037411332130432, 0.020473185926675797, 0.02099836803972721, 0.02159489318728447, 0.012058178894221783, -0.02138884738087654, -0.001570335472933948, -0.024486834183335304, 0.03684912249445915, -0.021387573331594467, 0.053635917603969574, -0.03327592834830284, 0.013310667127370834, 0.04494296759366989, -0.04860231280326843, 0.00643957918509841, 0.004435093607753515, -0.02267148159444332, -0.019364168867468834, -0.021238304674625397, -0.01681157946586609, -0.011332141235470772, 0.05729856714606285, -0.02649676986038685, 0.001580790732987225, 0.01889161765575409, -0.037292029708623886, -0.007069312501698732, -0.030770516023039818, -0.03585510700941086, -0.04938723146915436, 0.008892458863556385, 0.026017215102910995, 0.002709699794650078, 0.016369273886084557, -0.0385877825319767, -0.012867119163274765, -0.0004533691972028464, -0.013113368302583694, -0.02821076475083828, 0.0016984327230602503, -0.034625064581632614, 0.012046324089169502, -0.022661255672574043, -0.018093958497047424, 0.023870792239904404, -0.021240586414933205, 0.012789127416908741, 0.03928768262267113, 0.045064445585012436, -0.00277309468947351, 0.00592540530487895, 0.02315092273056507, 0.041421640664339066, -0.02911876142024994, 0.0005231372197158635, -0.00607593497261405, -0.000730902305804193, -0.033646587282419205, 0.03122827783226967, -0.058059368282556534, -0.05542653799057007, -0.05296894162893295, -0.0003421581059228629, 0.025640171021223068, 0.00947421696037054, 0.013822074048221111, 0.021789757534861565, -0.049700088798999786, -0.03377358615398407, -0.0394648015499115, -0.047548215836286545, 0.05324326083064079, -0.0046781874261796474, 0.07506345212459564, -0.03207864984869957, -0.02258603647351265, 0.06228969991207123, 0.008213086053729057, -0.017998041585087776, -0.07051979750394821, -0.015062890946865082, -0.005057380069047213, 0.02081301063299179, 0.03244476020336151, 0.05177103728055954, -0.00035388709511607885, 0.006956738885492086, 0.008656776510179043, 0.02474273554980755, 0.008199104107916355, 0.005747049115598202, -0.0026223286986351013, 0.024340031668543816, -0.01254890114068985, -0.0011243587359786034, 0.04081055521965027, 0.0035897204652428627, -0.03961221128702164, 0.01471067313104868, 0.011247195303440094, 0.014954685233533382, 0.06888739764690399, -0.04676329717040062, 0.024260446429252625, 0.031156782060861588, -0.03387140855193138, -0.05800899863243103, 0.037111662328243256, -0.011078868061304092, 0.002790199127048254, -0.016073456034064293, -0.005444238428026438, 0.03440597653388977, 0.009075761772692204, -0.016097834333777428, 0.005251605063676834, 0.038819361478090286, -0.022981569170951843, -0.01874319650232792, -0.05561426281929016, 0.01745794340968132, -0.008408292196691036, 0.019589504227042198, -0.02467256598174572, 0.059922706335783005, 0.04054689034819603, 0.02348220720887184, -0.014015590772032738, -0.007838723249733448, 0.0034689835738390684, -0.06090892478823662, -0.02689175121486187, -0.03071025013923645, 0.04373893514275551, -0.004104232415556908, 0.014919640496373177, -0.010563523508608341, 0.019073238596320152, -0.01238385122269392, 0.016783075407147408, -0.020279446616768837, -0.008475663140416145, -0.0342596136033535, -0.030967293307185173, -0.004380516242235899, -0.03969775512814522, 0.02727048099040985, 0.0038754211273044348, 0.007136540487408638, -0.011284065432846546, 0.00011105005978606641, -0.03553017973899841, 0.01107723731547594, -0.009001126512885094, -0.015343910083174706, 0.036156632006168365, 0.012814771384000778, -0.0009764840942807496, -0.02863670140504837, 0.006674374919384718, 0.021886086091399193, 0.007556677330285311, -0.018448414281010628, -0.029038000851869583, 0.02422497235238552, 0.052121277898550034, 0.07364877313375473, -0.003548959270119667, 0.027020439505577087, -0.03334839642047882, 0.03212513029575348, -0.0063058603554964066, 0.01776023395359516, 0.022396286949515343, 0.009341400116682053, -0.03127523139119148, -0.023047124966979027, -0.012240953743457794, 0.024727636948227882, 0.016191648319363594, 0.006968535482883453, -0.012513568624854088, 0.05775252729654312, 0.029633795842528343, -0.017629779875278473, 0.01670202426612377, 0.03971856087446213, 0.006098057609051466, -0.007589335087686777, -0.03861641883850098, -0.022913269698619843, -0.00698850629851222, -0.019167941063642502, 0.026754718273878098, 0.015021825209259987, -0.010779629461467266, 0.03109985962510109, 0.05403953045606613, -0.017597276717424393, -0.07368995249271393, -0.02040364034473896, -0.007433481980115175, 0.05116299167275429, 0.0006108227535150945, -0.048375144600868225, 0.038172297179698944, 0.015907354652881622, 0.015172022394835949, 0.024999577552080154, -0.0009895807597786188, -0.10050999373197556, -0.0006089257076382637, 0.04889475926756859, -0.016189005225896835, -0.029170216992497444, -0.008959246799349785, -0.03788714483380318, -0.0031889579258859158, 0.048081714659929276, 0.01747984252870083, 0.013870786875486374, 0.005116468295454979, 0.013889368623495102, -0.014309979975223541, -0.03961724787950516, -0.03182545304298401, -0.010082281194627285, 0.030152803286910057, 0.021168580278754234, -0.033113110810518265, 0.013710850849747658, -0.05462392419576645, 0.03676043450832367, 0.05127574875950813, 0.053262583911418915, -0.003752422984689474, -0.0004451885470189154, -0.011480029672384262, 0.011298330500721931, -0.006900869309902191, -0.040635205805301666, 0.030620383098721504, 0.002399658551439643, -0.0013112578308209777, 0.028230058029294014, 0.009485207498073578, -0.024146491661667824, 0.004468149039894342, -0.009289538487792015, -0.06031575798988342, 0.017137156799435616, -0.016585517674684525, 0.06265025585889816, 0.03299947828054428, 0.025559749454259872, 0.016332687810063362, 0.022846519947052002, -0.015501629561185837, -0.0010996339842677116, -0.027340790256857872, 0.01412085723131895, -0.01753840781748295, -0.021639147773385048, -0.010236642323434353, -0.0430782213807106, 0.012021846137940884, -0.02558271586894989, 0.0000028963718250452075, 0.025638151913881302, -0.032904233783483505, 0.010931562632322311, -0.006560566369444132, -0.01718791574239731, 0.0058794752694666386, 0.014546092599630356, -0.0078094517812132835, 0.036057863384485245, 0.002272580750286579, -0.007554975338280201, 0.04888495057821274, 0.0011503687128424644, -0.01348184049129486, 0.011896788142621517, -0.042607493698596954, 0.0070293196476995945, -0.04750409722328186, -0.0038759317249059677, 0.025923486799001694, -0.03726706653833389, 0.036185797303915024, -0.016241392120718956, -0.009192541241645813, 0.03016384318470955, -0.05598238855600357, -0.007243203464895487, -0.0114071574062109, 0.012612064369022846, 0.03308196738362312, -0.02205534093081951, 0.03891492635011673, -0.02332792989909649, -0.01311974786221981, -0.06043031066656113, -0.03298914432525635, 0.03759879246354103, -0.015667106956243515, -0.004960904363542795, -0.028176434338092804, 0.005778856575489044, 0.005097364541143179, -0.010996408760547638, -0.009701601229608059, 0.05053834989666939, 0.003323462326079607, -0.010258246213197708, -0.017332997173070908, 0.023383906111121178, 0.05146946385502815, -0.029523711651563644, -0.009833122603595257, 0.036197174340486526, -0.01483156904578209, 0.0153697794303298, -0.01182430237531662, 0.0702710896730423, -0.03593989089131355, 0.017402106896042824, -0.03136489540338516, -0.01360049657523632, 0.009157774038612843, -0.03870324417948723, -0.013664746657013893, 0.027628637850284576, -0.015974635258316994, 0.031337350606918335, -0.03830381855368614, 0.00026410017744638026, 0.006901003886014223, 0.006160072050988674, -0.031071539968252182, 0.027696438133716583, 0.008944603614509106, -0.029345467686653137, 0.03777143359184265, 0.016612451523542404, -0.025669585913419724, 0.010087590664625168, 0.018494758754968643, -0.03353056684136391, 0.03151063248515129, 0.029971586540341377, -0.026546740904450417, 0.06323681771755219, -0.0025833395775407553, 0.001273362897336483, -0.009166909381747246, 0.020117994397878647, -0.031232576817274094, -0.02707044966518879, -0.03534720093011856, 0.0014627373311668634, 0.03334145247936249, -0.01655299961566925, 0.05788028612732887, 0.04290155693888664, -0.014920788817107677, 0.03150339424610138, -0.059359438717365265, 0.027253761887550354, 0.014855904504656792, 0.04335036128759384, 0.0393654964864254, -0.023818936198949814, -0.04270567372441292, 0.0949840322136879, 0.055937331169843674, 0.002825052011758089, 0.04676354303956032, 0.007044173311442137, 0.0030941821169108152, 0.02614304982125759, -0.04758555069565773, -0.026788290590047836, 0.07067552208900452, -0.05781058594584465, 0.0236964114010334, -0.03643594682216644, -0.027832938358187675, 0.050217967480421066, -0.008422545157372952, 0.015628496184945107, -0.053567346185445786, -0.03380899503827095, -0.01706412434577942, 0.017103951424360275, 0.030836107209324837, 0.04264046251773834, 0.04346834495663643, -0.02994060516357422, 0.025606680661439896, 0.0145955141633749, 0.01477394625544548, -0.01592157408595085, -0.09858164936304092, -0.006466670427471399, -0.031132085248827934, -0.08031781762838364, -0.0011157651897519827, -0.0009036390110850334, 0.003305822378024459, 0.0332643985748291, -0.040467698127031326, -0.019965212792158127, -0.011003222316503525, 0.03770819306373596, 0.004217519890516996, 0.08618413656949997, 0.03115619719028473, 0.024852752685546875, 0.005649049766361713, 0.006472169421613216, 0.12149950861930847, 0.05957088619470596, 0.00476992130279541, -0.02240280993282795, 0.04021211713552475, -0.005971340462565422, -0.020300332456827164, 0.01450954470783472, -0.020464353263378143, 0.0074096666648983955, -0.004047952126711607, 0.03410252556204796, 0.08883505314588547, -0.0019931187853217125, -0.05098716914653778, 0.06041260063648224, -0.032229311764240265, -0.03630880266427994, 0.029885387048125267, 0.026188833639025688, 0.008111870847642422, 0.02041994035243988, -0.00985004473477602, 0.0017843160312622786, 0.006033121142536402, -0.016316868364810944, 0.0021289498545229435, -0.004598293453454971, -0.004846374504268169, 0.018385689705610275, -0.04869756102561951, -0.010294584557414055, 0.04241229593753815, -0.023137832060456276, -0.03950485587120056, -0.03830346837639809, 0.01662171445786953, -0.04851594194769859, -0.008740420453250408, 0.008013756945729256, -0.019507819786667824, 0.027218762785196304, 0.0007069989806041121, -0.0006011961959302425, -0.037284404039382935, -0.026582013815641403, -0.008390121161937714, 0.03281636908650398, -0.025328144431114197, 0.026666875928640366, -0.02753426693379879, 0.040659017860889435, -0.014474202878773212, -0.012166830711066723, -0.005153839476406574, -0.016402561217546463, 0.015878409147262573, -0.010038081556558609, -0.02520117722451687, -0.00765252998098731, 0.029521292075514793, -0.017002517357468605, 0.028621982783079147, -0.0022671499755233526, -0.015993479639291763, -0.04600329324603081, -0.04995003342628479, 0.04548424482345581, -0.022647596895694733, -0.009901555255055428, -0.0011403700336813927, -0.007959814742207527, -0.0393219031393528, -0.004449489526450634, 0.007935799658298492, 0.04106423258781433, 0.04612143710255623, 0.007482110522687435, -0.011467931792140007, -0.03204645588994026, -0.05169173330068588, 0.021244490519165993, -0.01742102950811386, -0.013202768750488758, -0.044008977711200714, -0.02933201938867569, 0.01899074949324131, 0.03923002630472183, -0.017310330644249916, 0.025676138699054718, -0.007971219718456268, 0.039370279759168625, 0.021981632336974144, -0.028577005490660667, -0.0023850426077842712, -0.02990274503827095, -0.046665798872709274, -0.007866933941841125, -0.022756187245249748, 0.018348485231399536, 0.0040296027436852455, -0.009024777449667454, 0.025224391371011734, 0.08192760497331619, -0.015585404820740223, 0.009960459545254707, -0.000108933869341854, -0.0700317919254303, -0.051414839923381805, 0.023716989904642105, -0.0044875796884298325, -0.018386563286185265, -0.010155713185667992, -0.016819622367620468, -0.005593019537627697, 0.011401372961699963, -0.02017044834792614, -0.022436492145061493, 0.023664673790335655, 0.013159533962607384, 0.010069028474390507, -0.04888617992401123, -0.028720824047923088, -0.020477809011936188, -0.028635308146476746, -0.0023840200155973434, -0.011950623244047165, 0.013135717250406742, 0.015962036326527596, -0.03360309824347496, -0.007423225790262222, 0.01900949887931347, -0.022645117715001106, -0.03323518857359886, 0.027153773233294487, -0.00861507747322321, 0.01379676628857851, 0.04497555270791054, -0.043891873210668564, -0.03794755041599274, 0.057398583739995956, -0.041095197200775146, -0.04098393768072128, 0.019099412485957146, -0.01796376332640648, 0.05787695571780205, 0.0020785327069461346, 0.016907786950469017, -0.02596227452158928, 0.045142706483602524, -0.03169911727309227, 0.017270950600504875, -0.002678647404536605, 0.011245536617934704, 0.03562681004405022, 0.005880267359316349, -0.02455109730362892, 0.026058508083224297, 0.005461751017719507, 0.03565990924835205, 0.0522954985499382, -0.036751244217157364, 0.002458263421431184, 0.0065193562768399715, -0.01742342673242092, 0.004062869120389223, 0.008608830161392689, 0.015158513560891151, 0.016298959031701088, 0.041314747184515, -0.04322819784283638, 0.03675393387675285, -0.018106350675225258, -0.012979728169739246, -0.08321604877710342, -0.007986331358551979, 0.01834108680486679, -0.012416812591254711, 0.0432656891644001, -0.04766214266419411, 0.0009224517270922661, -0.03389860317111015, -0.08784454315900803, 0.02587316371500492, 0.004043882712721825, -0.04352090135216713, -0.05762789025902748, -0.024805258959531784, 0.01858925074338913, 0.07020783424377441, 0.004403447266668081, 0.037520237267017365, 0.04663662612438202, 0.03232552856206894, 0.010944552719593048, -0.031406234949827194, -0.021699197590351105, 0.020906949415802956, 0.03290174528956413, -0.004651535302400589, 0.038793161511421204, -0.06142519786953926, 0.004559538792818785, 0.054739419370889664, -0.03590134158730507, 0.05425131693482399, 0.00258355843834579, 0.02052685059607029, -0.005815587937831879, 0.019367048516869545, 0.02755242958664894, -0.01778280921280384, -0.012139713391661644, -0.015440421178936958, 0.014436615630984306, 0.020331572741270065, -0.029008863493800163, -0.011382849887013435, 0.02231764607131481, -0.022181762382388115, 0.013936854898929596, -0.017830032855272293, 0.015730276703834534, 0.0025152359157800674, 0.008265811018645763, -0.003389320569112897, 0.018937556073069572, 0.0038759750314056873, 0.0295665692538023, -0.030529672279953957, 0.0043957107700407505, 0.020352834835648537, 0.05782559514045715, -0.009270553477108479, 0.029136791825294495, -0.009663723409175873, -0.013175252825021744, -0.007793874945491552, -0.002361666178330779, -0.0016234932700172067, -0.05607592314481735, -0.01874011568725109, -0.009186030365526676, -0.0038509946316480637, -0.03853416442871094, -0.0062578353099524975, -0.03440277278423309, 0.01004063431173563, -0.009521694853901863, 0.01927049644291401, 0.038054075092077255, -0.01784350909292698, -0.03632405027747154, -0.07165274024009705, 0.03312547504901886, 0.008871697820723057, 0.008870009332895279, -0.018883930519223213, -0.023784806951880455, -0.01520710252225399, -0.01489135343581438, 0.043619394302368164, 0.014540772885084152, 0.015558670274913311, 0.000023567688913317397, 0.016207048669457436, -0.00554153136909008, -0.03681879863142967, 0.011656113900244236, -0.03986553102731705, -0.02186833880841732, -0.015604924410581589, -0.009875678457319736, 0.027589257806539536, -0.010692075826227665, -0.003990475554019213, -0.011070068925619125, -0.03805021941661835, 0.05800764262676239, -0.004496377892792225, 0.044611427932977676, -0.026495231315493584, -0.026607196778059006, 0.05639447644352913, -0.017990266904234886, 0.004984030034393072, 0.03288367763161659, -0.00309960450977087, -0.04786236211657524, 0.017888778820633888, 0.016973545774817467, -0.022688962519168854, -0.01188445184379816, -0.010066172108054161, 0.018616465851664543, -0.010365737602114677, 0.020561836659908295, 0.018576258793473244, -0.01651199348270893, 0.027749374508857727, 0.02605501189827919, 0.04669492691755295, 0.0329311341047287, -0.03795087710022926, 0.03014546073973179, 0.024268226698040962, -0.001825980725698173, -0.011543089523911476, 0.009266193024814129, 0.028581757098436356, -0.0005794130265712738, 0.03131880611181259, 0.04086433723568916, 0.01497506070882082, 0.019991382956504822, -0.024826280772686005, 0.025853466242551804, -0.05532347783446312, -0.022342339158058167, -0.01701302081346512, 0.03348930925130844, 0.022872576490044594, -0.006195288151502609, 0.0076220775954425335, 0.07529285550117493, 0.02198316529393196, -0.01454593800008297, -0.00548539636656642, -0.033185381442308426, -0.05435275658965111, 0.008697949349880219, 0.007906612008810043, -0.0019254706567153335, 0.009831896983087063, 0.01930486410856247, -0.006387791596353054, 0.018180834129452705, 0.030349010601639748, -0.017385248094797134, 0.0156389232724905, -0.04383087530732155, 0.01561401691287756, -0.03461366891860962, 0.0016838349401950836, -0.024916531518101692, 0.011559524573385715, 0.07392632961273193, 0.0468050092458725, 0.06093554571270943, 0.02504298835992813, -0.03800467029213905, -0.0017351838760077953, 0.03568599373102188, -0.05702034756541252, -0.04799453541636467, -0.07997040450572968, 0.01872081123292446, 0.01505692582577467, -0.023502439260482788 ]
<p>I'm doing a binary classification using SVM classfier, libsvm, where roughly 95% belongs to one class.</p> <p>The parameters C and gamma are to be set before the actual training takes place. I followed <a href="http://www.csie.ntu.edu.tw/~cjlin/libsvm/">the tutorial</a> but still can't get any good results.</p> <p>There is a script that comes with the library that is supposed to help with choosing the right values for parameters but what this script is doing is basically maximizing the accuracy metric (TP+TN)/ALL, so in my case it chooses the parameters to label all data with prevailing class label.</p> <p>I would like to choose parameters with recall and precision based metrics. How could I approach this problem. Accuracy is a meaningless metric for what I'm doing. Also I'm keen on changing the library libsvm to any other one that can help me with this problem as long as it takes data in the same format.</p> <p>1 1:0.3 2:0.4 ... -1 1.0.4 2:0.23 and so on</p> <p>Can anybody help?</p> <p>UPDATE: yes I did try both grid.py and easy.py but even though grid search uses logarithmic scale it is extremely slow.I mean even if I run it on just small chunk of my data it takes tens of hours to finish. Is this the most efficient way to use SVM?? Have also tried svmlight but it does exactly the same it labels all data with one label.</p> <p>UPDATE2: I reformed my question the better reflect what sort of issues I am facing</p>
6,882
[ -0.014565343037247658, -0.043999604880809784, -0.006853058002889156, 0.0101767648011446, 0.014366304501891136, -0.0025207740254700184, -0.032993756234645844, 0.004389094188809395, 0.03263717517256737, -0.015752719715237617, 0.01847655512392521, 0.06933785229921341, 0.05613118037581444, 0.02901431731879711, 0.021351369097828865, -0.02220982499420643, -0.004333457909524441, -0.02617008611559868, -0.023444997146725655, -0.038733672350645065, 0.012757730670273304, -0.005559862125664949, 0.040334466844797134, 0.007749007549136877, -0.01325859222561121, 0.03853342682123184, 0.017775803804397583, -0.007942482829093933, 0.0015874780947342515, 0.034486666321754456, -0.04714807868003845, -0.023427078500390053, 0.012950402684509754, -0.005598115269094706, 0.03823570907115936, 0.013069907203316689, -0.025858258828520775, -0.03106500580906868, -0.03891806676983833, 0.005699168425053358, -0.035610560327768326, -0.01775701716542244, -0.015147230587899685, 0.02800874412059784, 0.021068941801786423, 0.03030647337436676, 0.022284315899014473, 0.005912892520427704, 0.025404369458556175, -0.0358261913061142, 0.05123767629265785, 0.01155751384794712, 0.04091406241059303, 0.028079960495233536, -0.0011587388580664992, -0.033605627715587616, 0.030569063499569893, 0.0576634481549263, 0.012750433757901192, -0.02991064451634884, 0.020164893940091133, 0.006091192364692688, -0.0030407016165554523, -0.05965098366141319, 0.015566308982670307, 0.07383302599191666, 0.003628077683970332, 0.0024387934245169163, 0.023401645943522453, 0.01692640222609043, -0.005580599885433912, -0.006992693059146404, 0.03330622613430023, 0.0032149143517017365, 0.0249550212174654, -0.007770289201289415, -0.03350289911031723, 0.05364416912198067, 0.025936519727110863, 0.007823633961379528, 0.0018895991379395127, 0.035876017063856125, 0.035165417939424515, 0.016749270260334015, 0.0009098873706534505, 0.02054302580654621, 0.05624150112271309, -0.010818335227668285, 0.016902010887861252, 0.05708550661802292, -0.01283043622970581, 0.01591053418815136, 0.014790840446949005, 0.01676519587635994, -0.02517530508339405, 0.038456737995147705, -0.013534937053918839, 0.03617897629737854, 0.011519558727741241, -0.013229260221123695, -0.025945883244276047, -0.0018466588808223605, -0.01821807585656643, 0.08414214104413986, -0.07131324708461761, -0.004621431231498718, -0.041096221655607224, -0.03366788849234581, -0.014615871012210846, -0.02589748613536358, -0.015797417610883713, -0.015890883281826973, -0.01567556895315647, -0.03825649991631508, -0.009159213863313198, -0.04118093475699425, -0.025895897299051285, -0.03838634490966797, 0.044152647256851196, 0.048075783997774124, 0.0248214490711689, -0.030504507943987846, 0.02515624463558197, -0.010513000190258026, -0.06081902235746384, 0.001150575466454029, 0.058175332844257355, -0.03239121288061142, -0.015891123563051224, 0.0229260865598917, 0.008041993714869022, -0.030502939596772194, 0.055258456617593765, -0.01320859044790268, 0.01996530592441559, -0.03543402999639511, -0.06618887186050415, -0.08191002905368805, 0.024877935647964478, -0.02974502369761467, 0.02906164526939392, -0.07298910617828369, 0.015095874667167664, 0.01756082847714424, 0.032468073070049286, 0.015537885017693043, 0.00952227134257555, 0.04931321367621422, -0.0010574207408353686, -0.0195897426456213, -0.023391222581267357, -0.01482425071299076, -0.0571691133081913, -0.01305210217833519, -0.023776641115546227, -0.0291290245950222, 0.007198155391961336, -0.000685304228682071, -0.005822085775434971, 0.015173787251114845, 0.018592681735754013, -0.01528081949800253, 0.012887703254818916, 0.0025795644614845514, -0.009996414184570312, -0.025369513779878616, 0.04050968587398529, 0.021625204011797905, 0.05825090780854225, 0.004923542030155659, -0.020093653351068497, -0.013997170142829418, 0.06071200966835022, 0.003375984262675047, 0.03767448291182518, -0.010008479468524456, -0.024857820942997932, -0.030439117923378944, 0.03951427713036537, 0.017061516642570496, -0.025542940944433212, -0.04904975742101669, 0.0016358433058485389, 0.04041345417499542, -0.006774500943720341, 0.05671949312090874, 0.013013175688683987, -0.00941427145153284, 0.019544726237654686, -0.03530830517411232, -0.030949462205171585, -0.03488751873373985, -0.005968771874904633, -0.03394691273570061, 0.011722870171070099, 0.03725932165980339, -0.004618330392986536, 0.006572990212589502, 0.0327451154589653, 0.00412248820066452, -0.036449067294597626, -0.0009665106190368533, 0.04803020507097244, -0.05350760370492935, -0.0012525127967819571, 0.03035353682935238, 0.02034076489508152, -0.027942953631281853, 0.05968713387846947, -0.007015192415565252, -0.0394669771194458, -0.003803336527198553, -0.017766742035746574, -0.006046966649591923, -0.008983297273516655, -0.029878681525588036, 0.03150413557887077, 0.028308091685175896, 0.003539270255714655, -0.005861240904778242, -0.030855365097522736, 0.08052965998649597, 0.040453843772411346, 0.0290039274841547, -0.016694437712430954, 0.007935469970107079, -0.020373964682221413, 0.051281481981277466, -0.03234277293086052, 0.012996845878660679, -0.03162429481744766, -0.018592409789562225, 0.06653276085853577, 0.0207146555185318, -0.03532533720135689, 0.009786784648895264, 0.04454512149095535, 0.010605350136756897, 0.03154410421848297, 0.012878169305622578, -0.005984227638691664, -0.012250075116753578, 0.017421340569853783, 0.039441417902708054, -0.017555633559823036, -0.005862663500010967, 0.04337259382009506, -0.011228990741074085, 0.0534525029361248, -0.0021126135252416134, -0.008915722370147705, 0.021257882937788963, 0.004392839968204498, -0.012478702701628208, 0.003011837136000395, -0.02347666770219803, 0.04880185425281525, -0.004681249614804983, 0.003055637702345848, 0.02638889104127884, -0.015909945592284203, 0.019595792517066002, 0.0014413302997127175, -0.012071439065039158, 0.05600396916270256, 0.04865199699997902, -0.047920111566782, 0.004407518543303013, 0.014639915898442268, -0.07842142879962921, -0.0008026546565815806, 0.002868150593712926, -0.010943110100924969, -0.058560337871313095, 0.034428421407938004, 0.03113282471895218, -0.0035471064038574696, 0.029041707515716553, -0.006742760539054871, -0.0405416414141655, -0.01711316406726837, -0.003757692174986005, 0.04039952903985977, -0.004637337289750576, -0.03092886321246624, 0.0005917637026868761, 0.003255242481827736, -0.05769136920571327, 0.03366792947053909, 0.003345588454976678, -0.019768575206398964, -0.0023379847407341003, -0.0032259414438158274, -0.0467655211687088, -0.025918910279870033, -0.05441499501466751, 0.025970369577407837, -0.009016619995236397, 0.027729978784918785, 0.015531514771282673, 0.009070271626114845, -0.06996326148509979, 0.045658499002456665, -0.027628008276224136, -0.07153091579675674, -0.02243787795305252, -0.009888549335300922, 0.0012367322342470288, -0.02204653061926365, -0.02247847430408001, 0.04737931489944458, -0.007850760594010353, 0.015776483342051506, -0.04768471047282219, -0.019437380135059357, 0.012203002348542213, 0.02376050129532814, 0.024036280810832977, 0.006093178875744343, 0.014915578998625278, 0.10803605616092682, 0.045633718371391296, -0.018692802637815475, -0.038424935191869736, 0.0013080897042527795, -0.05244441330432892, -0.002203545533120632, 0.02294229157269001, 0.04052400961518288, -0.014757760800421238, 0.00789013784378767, 0.009050832130014896, 0.02551455609500408, 0.08610720932483673, -0.0000808543263701722, -0.009268374182283878, 0.028519177809357643, 0.001680250046774745, -0.06632689386606216, 0.015801064670085907, 0.04971287399530411, -0.02831743285059929, 0.007812971249222755, -0.02536098286509514, -0.030858227983117104, 0.00028512062272056937, -0.021524831652641296, 0.015764445066452026, -0.03326108679175377, 0.008995075710117817, -0.022070858627557755, -0.012263931334018707, 0.043180759996175766, -0.044345658272504807, 0.02451884187757969, 0.0303760077804327, 0.02116013877093792, -0.012121019884943962, -0.011980965733528137, 0.029320791363716125, 0.05243613198399544, -0.009875298477709293, -0.03885120153427124, 0.008711937814950943, -0.018789581954479218, -0.013851366937160492, 0.0003071255923714489, 0.009845489636063576, 0.02575148269534111, 0.04911499097943306, 0.018355464562773705, 0.010054456070065498, -0.058700934052467346, 0.0124040013179183, -0.09158429503440857, -0.029097169637680054, -0.013603417202830315, 0.05533210560679436, 0.027560826390981674, 0.02198403887450695, 0.04374305158853531, -0.014858034439384937, 0.050197113305330276, 0.030496956780552864, -0.030065540224313736, 0.03941495344042778, 0.003964695613831282, -0.013090829364955425, 0.028862789273262024, -0.02971874736249447, 0.01258950773626566, -0.02442323975265026, 0.013597001321613789, -0.0002280787448398769, 0.015775909647345543, -0.03547727316617966, -0.013599906116724014, 0.01685352250933647, 0.01724332571029663, -0.035136815160512924, 0.037707582116127014, 0.0018926053307950497, 0.005495513789355755, -0.001784701831638813, 0.028764571994543076, -0.00895186048001051, -0.045366063714027405, -0.009573248215019703, 0.0056585692800581455, -0.022155392915010452, 0.05445970222353935, 0.012856890447437763, 0.0580323301255703, -0.06633086502552032, -0.006893839221447706, -0.02534148469567299, 0.05590871721506119, 0.04092210903763771, 0.0034384834580123425, 0.00254982546903193, -0.04214745759963989, -0.023885296657681465, 0.02019759640097618, 0.031325507909059525, -0.002347715897485614, -0.006800861097872257, 0.044140178710222244, 0.0014931896002963185, -0.07372310757637024, 0.007971626706421375, 0.09100211411714554, -0.031904928386211395, -0.006125957705080509, -0.02672557532787323, -0.03464849293231964, 0.011665726080536842, -0.0224886704236269, 0.021371452137827873, 0.0433499850332737, -0.016438229009509087, -0.018404705449938774, 0.0365297868847847, -0.03816455975174904, -0.02714696153998375, -0.006643752567470074, 0.03046630322933197, 0.035799119621515274, -0.012761459685862064, -0.04077284783124924, -0.029449887573719025, 0.03863929212093353, 0.040013909339904785, 0.021222179755568504, -0.009961837902665138, -0.10726803541183472, -0.006318387109786272, 0.05408268794417381, 0.05189124122262001, -0.04844425618648529, -0.027525026351213455, -0.029496608301997185, -0.03633106127381325, 0.022649206221103668, -0.05339353531599045, 0.029101071879267693, 0.015781817957758904, 0.0009193183504976332, -0.02180357463657856, -0.03273884579539299, -0.042998306453228, 0.03804536908864975, -0.019557101652026176, 0.03086770698428154, -0.04183202236890793, -0.035172175616025925, -0.05206833779811859, 0.023684611544013023, -0.02236350253224373, 0.06782449036836624, -0.02452588640153408, -0.017752105370163918, 0.024800142273306847, -0.021151335909962654, -0.018468117341399193, -0.09030065685510635, 0.00549990963190794, -0.01484600268304348, 0.0010703576263040304, 0.02286180853843689, 0.0005821290542371571, -0.06524240970611572, 0.029527725651860237, 0.026172086596488953, -0.02912919782102108, -0.020131327211856842, -0.027343928813934326, 0.014126526191830635, 0.03048534132540226, 0.01583239622414112, 0.0331522598862648, 0.021537775173783302, 0.011010223999619484, 0.02037717029452324, -0.02629331313073635, -0.003568482818081975, 0.0009159903856925666, -0.013263914734125137, -0.02184613049030304, -0.020079614594578743, -0.020210672169923782, 0.03924446552991867, 0.03846808895468712, 0.05691235139966011, -0.01495063304901123, -0.005843278486281633, -0.016718193888664246, 0.032473377883434296, -0.0038012743461877108, -0.006436337251216173, 0.019822396337985992, 0.04969572275876999, -0.03301379457116127, -0.006270629353821278, -0.008946298621594906, -0.011949338018894196, 0.02087022364139557, 0.020311832427978516, -0.028107034042477608, -0.00346279121004045, -0.013231857679784298, -0.009781111031770706, -0.003752431133762002, -0.026374006643891335, 0.051149509847164154, -0.010709485039114952, 0.011834831908345222, 0.0051992833614349365, -0.04098756983876228, -0.03248363360762596, -0.0021385184954851866, 0.00928488839417696, 0.04585272818803787, -0.03226221725344658, 0.020743295550346375, 0.004765478428453207, 0.006395260337740183, -0.07104233652353287, -0.049432456493377686, 0.03101288713514805, -0.014841637574136257, -0.027387099340558052, -0.03365101292729378, 0.006050875876098871, -0.0029796939343214035, -0.034240130335092545, 0.009726803749799728, 0.05176733806729317, 0.040916599333286285, -0.006419948302209377, -0.007078352849930525, 0.038430556654930115, 0.033826980739831924, 0.004410339053720236, 0.0036985583137720823, 0.010569640435278416, -0.0006708510918542743, -0.030841510742902756, 0.04135525971651077, 0.04665455222129822, -0.03176498785614967, -0.0048378766514360905, -0.023869460448622704, 0.04215838015079498, 0.0255948044359684, 0.038534436374902725, 0.00819653831422329, 0.015066404826939106, -0.027086274698376656, 0.019696375355124474, -0.03654223680496216, 0.027727877721190453, 0.001500332378782332, -0.01841592974960804, -0.01247828546911478, -0.03265911340713501, -0.027524668723344803, -0.03867414593696594, 0.026094891130924225, 0.016320494934916496, -0.020936552435159683, 0.002379747573286295, 0.07119051367044449, 0.008128892630338669, 0.008304824121296406, -0.002235211431980133, -0.0006249292637221515, 0.017104361206293106, -0.015570510178804398, 0.006019211374223232, 0.004312814678996801, -0.010031869634985924, -0.004329437389969826, 0.03510935977101326, -0.0466829277575016, 0.002375931479036808, 0.06294981390237808, 0.028891535475850105, 0.07741539925336838, 0.0077967215329408646, 0.02355847880244255, 0.02014755643904209, -0.03127136453986168, -0.038059599697589874, -0.03982078284025192, 0.018050288781523705, 0.04874005168676376, 0.03255948796868324, 0.0009246680419892073, 0.026832347735762596, 0.0011917841620743275, 0.023358428850769997, 0.042959097772836685, 0.001562362420372665, 0.000616764067672193, 0.03875797614455223, -0.026344995945692062, 0.0017604886088520288, 0.02049337886273861, 0.006251970771700144, 0.03575943037867546, 0.006909740623086691, -0.02409522421658039, 0.010614905506372452, 0.02400689758360386, -0.03008589707314968, -0.008548607118427753, -0.011218488216400146, -0.07936898618936539, 0.018832745030522346, 0.06528304517269135, -0.04462870582938194, 0.014521711505949497, 0.03321700915694237, 0.00737652787938714, 0.005833369214087725, 0.03988762944936752, -0.02161283791065216, -0.061433710157871246, -0.029514869675040245, -0.04397682473063469, -0.042420487850904465, 0.04722246900200844, 0.04530671238899231, -0.03811362385749817, -0.0032369664404541254, -0.010747376829385757, 0.04469279944896698, 0.009528125636279583, 0.03368204087018967, -0.0017221281304955482, 0.053825777024030685, 0.020702295005321503, 0.00773291802033782, 0.014394359663128853, 0.004463899414986372, 0.14254508912563324, 0.09405659884214401, 0.02985888533294201, -0.05445355176925659, -0.01913651078939438, 0.026422154158353806, -0.0025364356115460396, -0.030884496867656708, 0.008093055337667465, -0.002421995857730508, -0.005978704430162907, 0.030560240149497986, -0.012222553603351116, 0.05060058459639549, 0.020148513838648796, 0.03394732624292374, 0.0005507705500349402, -0.009994872845709324, 0.015734298154711723, 0.010255108587443829, 0.031797684729099274, 0.009938248433172703, -0.05604925379157066, 0.03838391974568367, 0.013784178532660007, -0.04606584087014198, -0.017192436382174492, -0.05885167047381401, 0.014872883446514606, 0.0038949428126215935, -0.001594000612385571, -0.00737701915204525, -0.006055098958313465, 0.024926593527197838, 0.017709217965602875, 0.015204386785626411, -0.02376771904528141, 0.016732269898056984, 0.013381097465753555, 0.012956022284924984, 0.026550857350230217, -0.008962573483586311, -0.020337266847491264, -0.0077171968296170235, -0.033316053450107574, -0.046687960624694824, -0.050603561103343964, 0.06662033498287201, -0.0032627619802951813, -0.01690686121582985, 0.013567153364419937, 0.030769573524594307, 0.01204922329634428, -0.06971069425344467, -0.009720666334033012, 0.010799791663885117, 0.04044916853308678, -0.01148883905261755, -0.027289574965834618, -0.013799582608044147, 0.031202012673020363, -0.05903882905840874, -0.006004340946674347, 0.01055454183369875, -0.06835716217756271, -0.031000390648841858, -0.0381786972284317, 0.03775710612535477, 0.007156249135732651, 0.0026326230727136135, 0.04538723826408386, -0.012555929832160473, -0.023376189172267914, -0.00585054000839591, 0.014033079147338867, 0.022027557715773582, -0.0005352912703529, -0.04004286602139473, 0.008086820133030415, -0.03628511726856232, -0.044309914112091064, 0.006729239597916603, -0.011637550778687, 0.014081207104027271, -0.030112123116850853, 0.020439082756638527, 0.04376208409667015, -0.0023125936277210712, 0.029070906341075897, 0.006579369772225618, -0.02505629137158394, 0.019534390419721603, 0.024303510785102844, -0.03982696309685707, -0.008843843825161457, 0.005693526938557625, -0.05316569656133652, 0.03583703562617302, 0.01807304471731186, 0.04643315076828003, 0.00894071627408266, -0.000695869093760848, 0.014775973744690418, 0.013239042833447456, 0.022626681253314018, 0.006186852231621742, -0.009171999990940094, -0.05952012911438942, -0.015534527599811554, -0.016047043725848198, -0.04802142083644867, -0.01347933430224657, -0.04016655683517456, -0.07071366161108017, -0.01127649750560522, 0.005758162587881088, 0.003199205966666341, -0.06723541766405106, 0.017512628808617592, -0.03439922630786896, 0.009129175916314125, -0.03417322784662247, -0.027712717652320862, 0.016947807744145393, 0.022602176293730736, -0.06230127811431885, 0.0019605003762990236, 0.01223334763199091, -0.0007493534358218312, -0.035629671066999435, -0.015770111232995987, 0.03213382884860039, 0.020770667120814323, 0.040503159165382385, -0.01076799351722002, 0.01937040127813816, -0.02901642583310604, 0.024123361334204674, -0.033259522169828415, -0.010685130953788757, 0.02841217815876007, -0.06138692796230316, -0.05247227102518082, -0.003745641093701124, -0.023606792092323303, 0.029858743771910667, 0.021879825741052628, -0.03196428716182709, 0.003628701204434037, 0.06670540571212769, -0.02107434906065464, -0.018618745729327202, 0.0020197012927383184, 0.008056058548390865, 0.03203824162483215, 0.026063160970807076, 0.0018321204697713256, -0.03859783336520195, -0.026069149374961853, 0.02537648007273674, 0.01046218816190958, -0.018434086814522743, 0.02152969501912594, 0.01080609206110239, -0.004853426478803158, 0.011962158605456352, 0.028834473341703415, -0.0006403904990293086, 0.03891880437731743, 0.03646685928106308, -0.01243522297590971, 0.034475844353437424, -0.025278346613049507, 0.02160358615219593, -0.09322118014097214, -0.00923229195177555, -0.009917467832565308, 0.03355001285672188, 0.02852986566722393, -0.055585410445928574, 0.03356385603547096, 0.041705213487148285, -0.016005435958504677, -0.008878542110323906, -0.002957033459097147, 0.021232202649116516, -0.025665493682026863, -0.0002561750588938594, -0.0027543753385543823, -0.01105688139796257, 0.030078943818807602, -0.014060191810131073, 0.056887052953243256, 0.0040318104438483715, -0.026970360428094864, -0.034471165388822556, -0.016864420846104622, 0.04660695791244507, -0.01860262081027031, -0.026171142235398293, -0.01419288944453001, -0.030623218044638634, -0.0011969214538112283, 0.026138395071029663, -0.03159521520137787, 0.01559481117874384, 0.061185456812381744, 0.038094427436590195, -0.019735364243388176, 0.05281316861510277, 0.05271248519420624, -0.021873382851481438, -0.0485091470181942, 0.0018771510804072022, 0.015599195845425129, -0.002843164373189211, 0.005640282761305571, -0.0002628967631608248, 0.02299615740776062, 0.007472901605069637, -0.04483911395072937, 0.009193137288093567, -0.03409744054079056, -0.02185688726603985, -0.004484877455979586, -0.031526416540145874, 0.0161362886428833, -0.028349727392196655, 0.004059191327542067, -0.04025788977742195, -0.020910432562232018, 0.0016346285119652748, -0.005259386263787746, 0.008530247956514359, 0.0026949639432132244, -0.011144871823489666, -0.013762134127318859, -0.019957570359110832, 0.00994256790727377, -0.023470574989914894, 0.004430730827152729, 0.019218871369957924, 0.03938416764140129, -0.01706637628376484, -0.004152635112404823, -0.0005811058799736202, -0.01267283596098423, 0.0731269046664238, -0.030506795272231102, 0.04870122671127319, 0.002430456690490246, 0.0261983722448349, 0.0023200325667858124, -0.0937461331486702, 0.06893042474985123, 0.016771560534834862, -0.038382820785045624, -0.025543704628944397, 0.020887115970253944, -0.009717983193695545, 0.010801211930811405, 0.057508476078510284, -0.051108017563819885, 0.029902108013629913, -0.049259983003139496, 0.008058646693825722, 0.018053341656923294, -0.056060660630464554, 0.013865782879292965, -0.03404358774423599, -0.06977451592683792, 0.0065541514195501804, -0.007006696425378323, 0.008567011915147305, 0.0125734843313694, 0.02909354493021965, -0.02073637768626213, -0.01987040787935257, -0.0038219981361180544, -0.035737089812755585, 0.0023162695579230785, 0.015494431369006634, 0.024726860225200653, 0.05025430768728256, 0.009017455391585827, -0.017542630434036255, 0.0106253232806921, -0.007992105558514595, -0.04576125368475914, 0.05579642578959465, -0.005988620687276125, -0.035767458379268646, -0.006790827494114637, 0.033139124512672424, 0.014027174562215805, -0.0642353966832161, 0.011499444954097271, 0.012247011996805668, -0.03986993059515953, 0.01065661758184433, 0.008045239374041557, -0.022143812850117683, 0.02738703228533268, 0.023169290274381638, 0.02713092230260372, -0.0024972499813884497, -0.0028104912489652634, 0.0036037524696439505, 0.014466776512563229, 0.0003076359280385077, 0.016853822395205498, 0.03163246065378189, 0.026443634182214737, -0.0047120628878474236, 0.019048551097512245, -0.022685274481773376, 0.0445374995470047, -0.045174676924943924, 0.003647122997790575, -0.01187222171574831, 0.0056574176996946335, -0.0006534692947752774, 0.015510080382227898, -0.03465236350893974, 0.045798297971487045, -0.04495912790298462, -0.02870115451514721, -0.06370590627193451, -0.03552514314651489, -0.006755747366696596, -0.0011181313311681151, 0.01701408065855503, 0.044639311730861664, 0.015546147711575031, 0.037801411002874374, -0.010070784948766232, -0.012379011139273643, 0.052973490208387375, -0.04092508926987648, -0.002222958952188492, -0.0206526480615139, 0.02399401180446148, 0.02941037341952324, 0.018666477873921394, -0.034327421337366104, -0.03401544690132141, 0.009822321124374866, 0.036654967814683914, 0.003620757721364498, -0.016832122579216957, -0.028377126902341843, 0.017147475853562355, 0.02737211436033249, -0.05661087483167648, 0.0029920015949755907, -0.05244194343686104, 0.004398857709020376, -0.009920467622578144, 0.006865703966468573 ]
<p>I take vitamins in the morning, but one of them I only take a half tablet. </p> <p>So, I have an initial container with 100 full tablets, and every morning I take out a random tablet. If it's a full tablet, I break it in half, put half back, and take half. If it's a half tablet, I just take it. Given that, how many days must I do this before I get a $&gt; 50\%$ chance of getting a half tablet? (Or, what's the % chance I get a half tablet after $X$ days?)</p> <p><strong>NB</strong>: This isn't homework; it just occurred to me as I was doing my morning routine, and I really have no idea where to start on trying to solve this. Pointers welcome. It feels like something with an infinite series, but I'm not sure.</p>
36,476
[ -0.007057711016386747, -0.016095813363790512, 0.006364559754729271, 0.009311709553003311, 0.04170909523963928, -0.00821731798350811, -0.020947886630892754, -0.04835428297519684, 0.01795770600438118, 0.00208699400536716, 0.05395125597715378, 0.07707294821739197, 0.046333134174346924, 0.02461005002260208, 0.006416706833988428, 0.01762084849178791, -0.014987611211836338, -0.0454738549888134, -0.01656493730843067, 0.008695048280060291, 0.05274182930588722, 0.004468686878681183, 0.02419552206993103, -0.009506573900580406, -0.06315764039754868, 0.020716942846775055, 0.018248137086629868, -0.008915484882891178, 0.010591992177069187, 0.07334891706705093, -0.01639407128095627, -0.04319808632135391, 0.06828717142343521, 0.017797648906707764, 0.071957528591156, 0.005390970502048731, 0.0023583921138197184, -0.01590844988822937, -0.027331428602337837, 0.014868369325995445, -0.020822223275899887, 0.0014481137041002512, 0.00024353402841370553, 0.02449251525104046, -0.005162582732737064, 0.041429661214351654, 0.03335105627775192, -0.04161093384027481, 0.06289859116077423, -0.06346409767866135, 0.06742831319570541, 0.010078460909426212, 0.045052412897348404, 0.006720090750604868, -0.0004416498413775116, -0.02083481289446354, 0.009621970355510712, 0.03945355489850044, 0.00440171780064702, -0.019834134727716446, -0.01670515164732933, -0.04476539045572281, -0.018661044538021088, -0.02773294411599636, -0.05160019174218178, -0.026016658172011375, -0.040036655962467194, 0.011100154370069504, 0.02162194438278675, -0.037968527525663376, 0.007981473580002785, 0.03222956508398056, 0.038584738969802856, -0.02777135744690895, -0.037057045847177505, -0.0020215061958879232, 0.023745890706777573, 0.027008280158042908, 0.05545660853385925, 0.032942190766334534, 0.0041658771224319935, -0.01534950640052557, 0.031745024025440216, 0.02276950143277645, 0.03970276564359665, -0.038106177002191544, 0.06404698640108109, 0.013384412974119186, 0.02535063773393631, 0.02658628299832344, -0.021284718066453934, -0.009431266225874424, 0.0462782084941864, 0.021261639893054962, -0.04783191531896591, 0.0669216588139534, 0.012659355066716671, 0.014401392079889774, -0.005249534267932177, 0.003504816209897399, 0.03759821504354477, -0.030460543930530548, -0.0022292074281722307, 0.09772850573062897, -0.018615398555994034, -0.010207738727331161, 0.004178950563073158, 0.008095193654298782, 0.006812887731939554, -0.004882683977484703, 0.018161829560995102, 0.04501285403966904, 0.03950978443026543, 0.028056785464286804, 0.020605362951755524, -0.011195852421224117, -0.023409100249409676, -0.04195025935769081, 0.04248368367552757, 0.039235107600688934, 0.04632105305790901, -0.02065405622124672, 0.06332773715257645, -0.06025794520974159, -0.02317134290933609, 0.01620020717382431, 0.0006634354358538985, 0.004407297819852829, -0.020573880523443222, 0.013286220841109753, -0.010308814235031605, -0.05019322782754898, 0.025226395577192307, -0.011880380101501942, 0.031760040670633316, -0.0018562347395345569, -0.044946152716875076, -0.005309619940817356, 0.04450822249054909, -0.013260962441563606, -0.03953470662236214, -0.0505734458565712, 0.025497589260339737, 0.02124280110001564, 0.05090697109699249, 0.00416587945073843, 0.040097832679748535, 0.01809372380375862, 0.02784395031630993, 0.02835971489548683, -0.045131903141736984, -0.01703314110636711, -0.007088597863912582, -0.036260779947042465, 0.01765415258705616, -0.07217633724212646, 0.010244536213576794, 0.014709502458572388, 0.019975164905190468, -0.05518980696797371, 0.046316541731357574, -0.0045068576000630856, -0.03562237322330475, 0.017120549455285072, 0.029256317764520645, -0.05419866740703583, 0.07254619896411896, 0.029662087559700012, 0.008996197953820229, 0.0657728761434555, -0.005317633971571922, 0.03221603482961655, 0.018050596117973328, 0.022280769422650337, 0.04394310712814331, -0.009475507773458958, 0.004221446346491575, -0.01817731373012066, 0.0015903536695986986, 0.03163537010550499, -0.0005983407027088106, 0.009501999244093895, -0.023604921996593475, 0.020209670066833496, 0.03584690019488335, -0.02070147544145584, 0.014713778160512447, -0.007054627873003483, 0.002752328524366021, -0.06188797578215599, -0.022554248571395874, -0.05428608879446983, -0.01324391271919012, 0.007088057696819305, -0.04920731484889984, 0.03752034157514572, -0.028292037546634674, 0.016859523952007294, -0.009296061471104622, -0.042749177664518356, -0.014522840268909931, -0.0017177467234432697, 0.029449230059981346, -0.053251542150974274, 0.0015501660527661443, 0.07724638283252716, 0.027805227786302567, -0.014908602461218834, 0.025192324072122574, -0.045676905661821365, -0.014527649618685246, -0.029461398720741272, -0.009229402057826519, -0.015165232121944427, -0.062759168446064, -0.0018655868479982018, 0.017699502408504486, 0.022417232394218445, 0.03855659067630768, 0.019087979570031166, -0.05569459870457649, 0.04739107936620712, 0.08161261677742004, -0.008674470707774162, 0.027240198105573654, -0.03408277779817581, 0.029967859387397766, -0.014021269045770168, 0.0017731128027662635, -0.046203114092350006, -0.02551761269569397, -0.004125467035919428, -0.0030995220877230167, -0.003747121896594763, 0.030949050560593605, 0.01007472537457943, 0.06838300079107285, 0.01685713417828083, 0.024019185453653336, 0.05202041566371918, -0.021282877773046494, -0.0018977331928908825, -0.018305912613868713, -0.0031770800705999136, 0.0048499624244868755, 0.01594015210866928, -0.003243005136027932, -0.002053404226899147, -0.0039061331190168858, 0.03917837142944336, -0.03372877463698387, -0.010406925342977047, -0.011015847325325012, 0.02263355441391468, 0.008939540013670921, 0.012577719986438751, 0.04852237552404404, -0.023441646248102188, -0.05741433426737785, 0.04581420496106148, 0.0320621132850647, -0.011987581849098206, -0.028745371848344803, -0.021733900532126427, -0.02013501152396202, 0.041980136185884476, -0.03900230675935745, -0.025388380512595177, -0.006672088988125324, -0.006818892899900675, -0.004810743499547243, -0.0031894026324152946, 0.018620915710926056, -0.0010033957660198212, -0.00615166500210762, 0.024384276941418648, 0.011412400752305984, 0.0074537997134029865, -0.031785447150468826, -0.001745022600516677, 0.04618094861507416, -0.039022285491228104, 0.009350445121526718, -0.03023875504732132, -0.06172937899827957, 0.06483013927936554, -0.023663513362407684, -0.029638037085533142, 0.0448109470307827, 0.008786285296082497, 0.011098155751824379, 0.010517718270421028, 0.016885550692677498, -0.012365140952169895, -0.034348443150520325, -0.03911423310637474, 0.032664939761161804, -0.0794072076678276, 0.0034144457895308733, 0.02380301058292389, 0.03316963464021683, -0.056946080178022385, 0.01268134918063879, 0.0009318245574831963, -0.0030426024459302425, -0.03520706295967102, -0.006077820900827646, -0.007271790411323309, -0.03464822471141815, -0.012771724723279476, -0.00815071165561676, 0.02043452113866806, 0.017886925488710403, -0.08307177573442459, -0.09035267680883408, -0.018265975639224052, 0.007022963371127844, 0.014638299122452736, 0.03808650001883507, -0.011950978077948093, 0.04851749166846275, 0.027789892628788948, -0.029896212741732597, -0.00804813951253891, -0.003970817197114229, 0.004613825585693121, -0.01504518836736679, -0.01195117924362421, 0.002291123615577817, -0.018339527770876884, 0.04139035940170288, 0.029838047921657562, 0.04096846655011177, 0.047550495713949203, 0.027488868683576584, -0.013131228275597095, 0.024310218170285225, 0.025055523961782455, 0.009470799006521702, -0.010211561806499958, 0.014915017411112785, -0.047343797981739044, 0.027775326743721962, -0.02564837969839573, 0.02019818127155304, 0.010731845162808895, -0.05439786985516548, 0.018221108242869377, -0.026759816333651543, 0.0024174738209694624, -0.012343601323664188, 0.04832659289240837, -0.004535085055977106, 0.0039032376371324062, 0.01012678723782301, -0.008439993485808372, 0.07055318355560303, -0.05820687487721443, 0.02035633474588394, 0.05704880133271217, 0.03766130283474922, -0.015119772404432297, -0.06142396107316017, -0.03286799415946007, 0.04687601327896118, -0.024325598031282425, -0.04344399273395538, -0.026491643860936165, 0.026744509115815163, 0.035549480468034744, 0.03343809396028519, -0.020411591976881027, -0.012712270952761173, 0.0002853442565537989, -0.0753699541091919, -0.06623799353837967, 0.020259462296962738, 0.034805431962013245, -0.013926749117672443, 0.02301609143614769, -0.0068067223764956, -0.018218066543340683, -0.007355135399848223, 0.025941090658307076, -0.07386890798807144, 0.02951590158045292, 0.008996113203465939, -0.005896001122891903, -0.01578870788216591, 0.03999258205294609, 0.011026532389223576, -0.01805196888744831, -0.017687736079096794, -0.0020050129387527704, 0.0033080962020903826, -0.025460025295615196, 0.02671571634709835, -0.028488894924521446, -0.04212411120533943, -0.019483033567667007, 0.032170671969652176, 0.014058616943657398, 0.025106417015194893, 0.005146431270986795, 0.01105665136128664, -0.011956846341490746, 0.01508901733905077, 0.0023557355161756277, 0.008245797827839851, -0.008313203230500221, 0.011029491201043129, 0.022656884044408798, 0.014699306339025497, 0.004933552350848913, 0.007307825610041618, -0.026637239381670952, 0.05016223341226578, 0.02245742455124855, -0.002185833640396595, -0.008410485461354256, -0.037604920566082, 0.015343872830271721, -0.004535379819571972, -0.029107477515935898, -0.010119715705513954, 0.015475338324904442, 0.0779542401432991, 0.012902231886982918, -0.021797144785523415, 0.04192814230918884, 0.10059412568807602, -0.026761509478092194, -0.0605999231338501, -0.055786095559597015, -0.031076032668352127, -0.006367431487888098, 0.02181222476065159, 0.01717226207256317, -0.0138328168541193, 0.03981498256325722, 0.010371166281402111, 0.002997600706294179, 0.008702987805008888, 0.023202717304229736, -0.016443375498056412, -0.022835778072476387, 0.054981887340545654, 0.004410410765558481, -0.018219420686364174, -0.006697382777929306, 0.05368407443165779, 0.016352184116840363, 0.00755130173638463, -0.0025370423682034016, -0.03593239560723305, 0.023403286933898926, 0.028384093195199966, 0.07832787185907364, -0.05913183465600014, 0.03615345433354378, -0.05241132155060768, -0.016665320843458176, 0.06294891238212585, -0.041288211941719055, 0.001721989712677896, 0.016420982778072357, -0.01681852526962757, 0.012992328964173794, -0.032095979899168015, -0.040750112384557724, -0.029153790324926376, -0.024929499253630638, 0.026031242683529854, -0.005639364942908287, -0.014154245145618916, -0.03864884003996849, 0.03286260366439819, 0.02460380084812641, 0.05419671908020973, -0.06006460264325142, -0.004306728020310402, -0.021788792684674263, -0.003190754447132349, 0.005928019993007183, -0.07568925619125366, 0.009450649842619896, -0.01708940416574478, -0.03368410840630531, 0.010874547064304352, -0.03990130499005318, -0.059448327869176865, 0.05195236951112747, 0.027848150581121445, -0.022587882354855537, -0.0007305423496291041, -0.05911519005894661, 0.01780923642218113, 0.02045757696032524, 0.021036246791481972, 0.023004453629255295, 0.02586524188518524, 0.04205680266022682, -0.00823086779564619, -0.028435688465833664, 0.022860348224639893, -0.03459802642464638, 0.001363612711429596, -0.023095393553376198, -0.018286796286702156, -0.03727278485894203, 0.04378022253513336, -0.012492923997342587, -0.010212430730462074, 0.010413063690066338, -0.016307739540934563, -0.006381988059729338, 0.04992755502462387, 0.005082843825221062, -0.01510340254753828, -0.0031383181922137737, -0.003104162635281682, 0.017293114215135574, -0.022986672818660736, 0.007287396118044853, -0.03272649273276329, 0.02450842596590519, -0.00881623849272728, -0.03585272282361984, -0.01104693952947855, -0.03927335515618324, 0.0038519122172147036, 0.020553378388285637, -0.008380952291190624, 0.0015542267356067896, -0.030748825520277023, 0.0067297425121068954, -0.007461705710738897, -0.009234030731022358, -0.024428553879261017, 0.018027588725090027, -0.01863950490951538, 0.02873014658689499, -0.0415838398039341, 0.036237671971321106, 0.012094702571630478, 0.023678218945860863, -0.08722221106290817, -0.044159285724163055, 0.04138173162937164, 0.0005043238634243608, -0.038516197353601456, -0.040166474878787994, 0.031163427978754044, -0.04923855885863304, -0.00901092030107975, -0.03221331909298897, 0.04268980398774147, -0.02584938332438469, -0.010293112136423588, -0.009512425400316715, 0.011487789452075958, 0.03583532199263573, 0.004031368996948004, -0.044418126344680786, 0.016336379572749138, 0.008357961662113667, 0.0008593469392508268, 0.011151375249028206, -0.005416614934802055, -0.03283507004380226, -0.02123311720788479, -0.01639770343899727, -0.034879766404628754, 0.03899076581001282, -0.034230154007673264, -0.027385035529732704, 0.026212748140096664, 0.023375703021883965, 0.006680027116090059, -0.0434337742626667, 0.0030533510725945234, 0.059882648289203644, -0.020504401996731758, 0.029958274215459824, 0.004144701641052961, -0.019275173544883728, -0.018906360492110252, 0.018796434625983238, 0.0017124644946306944, -0.0315176397562027, -0.008581127971410751, 0.04114473611116409, -0.0242037121206522, -0.02096494473516941, 0.01928877644240856, -0.018564913421869278, 0.0034130322746932507, 0.030415959656238556, -0.020507153123617172, 0.0321870818734169, -0.029363730922341347, -0.04806617647409439, -0.02382221631705761, -0.03265056014060974, 0.010914983227849007, 0.05825147405266762, -0.022397326305508614, -0.009525387547910213, 0.042394328862428665, 0.03428492322564125, 0.022341934964060783, 0.016356278210878372, -0.0038037102203816175, -0.02051704004406929, -0.002069746144115925, 0.0359807051718235, -0.010404097847640514, -0.0041166627779603004, 0.04563790187239647, 0.019006090238690376, 0.004287342540919781, 0.03556469455361366, 0.012433219701051712, -0.007155990228056908, 0.03730921819806099, -0.0330529659986496, -0.0325559601187706, 0.003379716770723462, -0.02608666382730007, 0.03958706185221672, -0.03941052034497261, -0.03633062168955803, 0.07161585241556168, 0.03139412775635719, 0.003275302005931735, -0.043765947222709656, -0.030388841405510902, -0.026882337406277657, -0.04946443811058998, 0.053307026624679565, 0.00029104636632837355, 0.0382760614156723, -0.012861538678407669, 0.02135150134563446, 0.020209314301609993, 0.009885053150355816, -0.013775905594229698, -0.027971159666776657, -0.00786302424967289, 0.005623887293040752, -0.04181825742125511, 0.01774163544178009, 0.0254979245364666, -0.0038141044788062572, -0.018666023388504982, -0.025447988882660866, -0.001673128572292626, 0.025114141404628754, 0.05027500540018082, 0.020717088133096695, 0.08123605698347092, -0.0023478162474930286, 0.035703834146261215, -0.009561216458678246, -0.03429700434207916, 0.10512061417102814, 0.022813070565462112, 0.022866757586598396, -0.05176781862974167, 0.022853881120681763, -0.011846676468849182, 0.02060575969517231, 0.008470036089420319, 0.030561428517103195, 0.012968327850103378, 0.0019464172655716538, 0.07286012172698975, 0.06630076467990875, -0.017250707373023033, 0.03441571444272995, 0.04158885031938553, -0.038538239896297455, -0.04677543044090271, -0.016017207875847816, -0.029636282473802567, 0.015754597261548042, -0.01317417062819004, -0.04740189388394356, 0.05880088731646538, -0.011258363723754883, 0.001334498985670507, -0.02198369801044464, -0.011738172732293606, 0.029481690376996994, 0.0011661299504339695, -0.006604060996323824, -0.026973091065883636, -0.0013349564978852868, 0.0061660814099013805, 0.02520972304046154, 0.004464791156351566, 0.0558195523917675, -0.01944279670715332, 0.008851251564919949, 0.025122445076704025, 0.049774933606386185, 0.026534656062722206, 0.015968557447195053, 0.02417277731001377, -0.030636612325906754, -0.03673730790615082, -0.03502393513917923, 0.03450531139969826, -0.02838893048465252, -0.024406179785728455, -0.004432260524481535, 0.0021245977841317654, -0.011319330893456936, -0.07577519118785858, -0.028019936755299568, 0.050408508628606796, 0.03060307167470455, -0.01025009248405695, 0.008866391144692898, 0.024781333282589912, 0.034220367670059204, -0.006166970357298851, 0.034255802631378174, 0.015200609341263771, -0.026673972606658936, -0.013900239020586014, 0.017958343029022217, 0.02337796799838543, 0.0167064405977726, -0.006078104488551617, -0.01982976123690605, -0.010982217267155647, -0.03522057086229324, 0.039162229746580124, 0.006021577399224043, -0.013352349400520325, 0.06153080239892006, -0.04741654545068741, -0.023948093876242638, -0.0017231156816706061, -0.008967121131718159, 0.025657521560788155, 0.007874559611082077, 0.0001210495101986453, -0.043969329446554184, -0.008296080864965916, -0.0017551201162859797, 0.017636572942137718, -0.006468851584941149, 0.020730458199977875, -0.006138578522950411, 0.04465857148170471, -0.0300808846950531, -0.0215387511998415, 0.004415431525558233, -0.012336421757936478, -0.026348071172833443, 0.0177345909178257, -0.05785876885056496, 0.060217808932065964, 0.04158172383904457, 0.03419136628508568, 0.01199599914252758, 0.003441065549850464, -0.02587238699197769, 0.024603726342320442, -0.020194336771965027, -0.07181566208600998, -0.0037666282150894403, 0.0027249199338257313, -0.0044767833314836025, -0.0678224191069603, -0.022959034889936447, -0.030624132603406906, -0.01772625371813774, 0.0037148355040699244, 0.008411433547735214, -0.016988564282655716, 0.014923912473022938, -0.006486066617071629, 0.02000480890274048, 0.004392886999994516, -0.008678100071847439, -0.029720429331064224, 0.014701871201395988, 0.059370022267103195, -0.004386576823890209, -0.012247935868799686, 0.016743440181016922, -0.0004358182195574045, -0.019043460488319397, 0.041802555322647095, 0.01099819503724575, 0.021031977608799934, -0.03337124362587929, 0.02124371938407421, -0.009021916426718235, 0.033113181591033936, -0.0333222970366478, -0.03138555586338043, 0.04914180934429169, -0.012569042854011059, -0.03189407289028168, 0.024763526394963264, -0.005936493165791035, 0.03025086037814617, 0.04154627397656441, -0.02611205168068409, 0.01518072746694088, 0.058682557195425034, -0.024854741990566254, -0.012099562212824821, 0.00016979064093902707, 0.010688700713217258, 0.017841042950749397, 0.00232333829626441, -0.013294070027768612, 0.007344564888626337, -0.0361553430557251, 0.01341339759528637, 0.043536409735679626, 0.01315672229975462, 0.03239568695425987, 0.00045180079177953303, 0.004922737367451191, -0.013201942667365074, 0.008900281973183155, -0.017375951632857323, -0.002192875137552619, 0.04753643646836281, -0.009680508635938168, 0.03687198460102081, -0.02313724346458912, 0.003507652785629034, -0.08175109326839447, -0.03017139993607998, -0.019810521975159645, 0.0017055595526471734, 0.05145325884222984, -0.059787195175886154, -0.03505907580256462, 0.06059182435274124, -0.08207143098115921, 0.017325209453701973, -0.04814208298921585, -0.007905309088528156, -0.05150538682937622, 0.020671620965003967, -0.028982335701584816, 0.0008960189879871905, 0.05508096143603325, 0.031947072595357895, 0.053417183458805084, 0.03379276022315025, -0.0026912905741482973, -0.02840113826096058, 0.02423688769340515, 0.030826563015580177, 0.0026886879932135344, -0.03020724467933178, 0.025519447401165962, -0.016503579914569855, -0.029301734641194344, 0.0007866526721045375, -0.026097018271684647, 0.029294176027178764, -0.010769931599497795, 0.01547147985547781, -0.00225270027294755, 0.04934562370181084, -0.02661990374326706, 0.010274425148963928, -0.005496814381331205, -0.009383772499859333, 0.02023700810968876, 0.0367400087416172, -0.007657339796423912, 0.0033222376368939877, 0.053768835961818695, 0.0193150844424963, -0.051509883254766464, 0.039590273052453995, 0.059733398258686066, -0.008099526166915894, 0.010633942671120167, -0.01815825141966343, 0.0019652778282761574, -0.021834757179021835, 0.01019757054746151, -0.04724155366420746, 0.011073997244238853, 0.03871580585837364, -0.0066092293709516525, -0.021768875420093536, 0.005072277504950762, -0.05742106959223747, -0.049435049295425415, 0.0011598850833252072, -0.025503655895590782, 0.015447164885699749, -0.07586530596017838, 0.034554921090602875, -0.03294455632567406, 0.0128675177693367, 0.007642937358468771, -0.027992460876703262, -0.018154829740524292, 0.02107684127986431, 0.02155456505715847, 0.029744107276201248, -0.016654185950756073, -0.012725548818707466, -0.0076009174808859825, -0.0790829285979271, 0.046064916998147964, -0.02115142159163952, -0.01864948868751526, -0.056024517863988876, -0.02645399421453476, -0.04379839450120926, 0.028514351695775986, 0.04045400023460388, 0.026985425502061844, -0.003068438498303294, -0.01225657481700182, 0.02237682417035103, 0.010973439551889896, -0.07033675163984299, 0.019822875037789345, -0.02546863630414009, -0.01759486272931099, -0.033498406410217285, 0.030969299376010895, 0.012586255557835102, -0.027770988643169403, -0.0033878223039209843, -0.02357611060142517, 0.012164836749434471, 0.0016513224691152573, 0.022218341007828712, 0.013101761229336262, 0.00046650663716718554, 0.00334561406634748, 0.02239697054028511, 0.030368663370609283, 0.0034933106508105993, 0.027247678488492966, -0.028856121003627777, -0.06547469645738602, 0.010634662583470345, -0.023303665220737457, -0.01987685076892376, 0.0035173543728888035, -0.009948279708623886, -0.004628488328307867, -0.05449717119336128, -0.02265101857483387, 0.019970210269093513, -0.01661163568496704, 0.0258503220975399, 0.009649664163589478, 0.01975947804749012, 0.05533240735530853, 0.029865402728319168, 0.008133516646921635, 0.01339065283536911, 0.03165591508150101, 0.01480888295918703, -0.007736898493021727, 0.005497379694133997, -0.010229469276964664, 0.011301795952022076, 0.003917389549314976, 0.00440584821626544, 0.021973611786961555, 0.011965514160692692, 0.03804881498217583, -0.0074630132876336575, 0.006499204318970442, 0.008816788904368877, -0.03959020972251892, -0.017424698919057846, -0.001186816836707294, -0.01554767694324255, 0.047872550785541534, -0.0032725438941270113, 0.010015617124736309, -0.05424153804779053, -0.023315953090786934, 0.007339210249483585, 0.028756385669112206, 0.016665104776620865, -0.018121201545000076, -0.04413555935025215, -0.002918454585596919, -0.022035136818885803, 0.008170741610229015, 0.03734154626727104, -0.01753549464046955, 0.037019282579422, -0.01249877642840147, -0.014714367687702179, -0.04036085307598114, -0.018008442595601082, -0.03221236914396286, -0.08449585735797882, 0.002960332203656435, 0.03073352389037609, 0.015586365945637226, 0.015030398964881897, -0.03344174847006798, -0.011977055110037327, 0.09016548097133636, -0.0476020947098732, -0.013631453737616539, -0.032977793365716934, 0.031345367431640625, -0.0176689513027668, -0.037206944078207016 ]
<p>In a predictive linear regression model, does it make sense to combine binary and continuous data within a single scale?<br> Does it make statistical sense to convert binary data into a z score? </p> <p>I am wondering whether I could create a scale using a combination of binary and continuous items that I could convert into a Z score.</p>
36,479
[ -0.04228805750608444, -0.014932377263903618, -0.015014058910310268, 0.01940865069627762, 0.04831591621041298, -0.00033795463968999684, 0.005291955545544624, 0.005637655965983868, 0.02312585711479187, 0.014706994406878948, 0.03846817836165428, -0.0068615456111729145, 0.03175383806228638, -0.020488761365413666, -0.0008421520469710231, 0.044360291212797165, -0.012336096726357937, 0.02073550783097744, -0.0072911628521978855, 0.002206032630056143, -0.017029713839292526, 0.0039628189988434315, 0.040771037340164185, -0.001998323481529951, 0.0077577983029186726, 0.0665045827627182, 0.020142868161201477, -0.017741724848747253, 0.01563081704080105, 0.02769746445119381, 0.007862282916903496, -0.04339032247662544, 0.03560739755630493, 0.07043776661157608, 0.03075351193547249, -0.01646670326590538, -0.025131981819868088, -0.012874215841293335, -0.017950179055333138, 0.03634176403284073, -0.011182250455021858, -0.022480756044387817, -0.0053055123426020145, -0.00011837826605187729, -0.013403775170445442, 0.02469823881983757, -0.03276669606566429, -0.03756099194288254, 0.018859630450606346, -0.032305508852005005, 0.05327904596924782, -0.009377260692417622, 0.028518958017230034, 0.031415656208992004, -0.021479036659002304, 0.01210556086152792, 0.06197876110672951, 0.056651290506124496, -0.007225667592138052, -0.049364298582077026, -0.0027725992258638144, -0.01811426505446434, -0.001708919764496386, 0.027484958991408348, -0.015420516021549702, 0.036851152777671814, -0.012385034933686256, -0.015868203714489937, 0.022066166624426842, -0.0004295041726436466, 0.007561010308563709, 0.0073649766854941845, 0.011814112775027752, -0.01480860449373722, 0.03426201269030571, -0.030830198898911476, -0.008492052555084229, 0.03301122784614563, 0.061025429517030716, 0.04062584787607193, -0.0053573292680084705, -0.0015727973077446222, 0.01895264908671379, 0.0447181798517704, 0.021234184503555298, -0.033500514924526215, 0.07139565050601959, -0.032443005591630936, 0.030297469347715378, 0.02831636369228363, -0.0014268356608226895, 0.019854404032230377, 0.026956871151924133, 0.011841163970530033, -0.03926566243171692, 0.05917411670088768, -0.00935711245983839, 0.014864914119243622, 0.02438248321413994, -0.005408468656241894, -0.017046155408024788, -0.0013334194663912058, -0.006506879348307848, 0.038395319133996964, -0.018392182886600494, -0.00005917611633776687, -0.0169773381203413, -0.006284286268055439, 0.004002476576715708, -0.021693449467420578, 0.003419614862650633, -0.0066705611534416676, 0.013726110570132732, 0.011271602474153042, 0.02942201867699623, -0.007204645778983831, -0.01061208825558424, -0.03763960301876068, 0.05667385086417198, 0.024136077612638474, 0.024637047201395035, -0.03186715021729469, 0.01764615625143051, -0.012577473185956478, -0.04106304794549942, 0.00526744220405817, -0.00043696974171325564, 0.020962918177247047, -0.02115331031382084, 0.043794192373752594, -0.007084805518388748, -0.008632408455014229, 0.014809126034379005, -0.0014344349037855864, 0.0013493375154212117, 0.016216274350881577, -0.07562387734651566, -0.04980570822954178, -0.023641372099518776, -0.01900199055671692, 0.021022023633122444, -0.029545754194259644, 0.005473882891237736, 0.012741917744278908, 0.03060143254697323, 0.007896102033555508, 0.02974981814622879, 0.01875988394021988, 0.03504348546266556, 0.0023418632335960865, -0.030944885686039925, -0.027611903846263885, -0.035009726881980896, -0.051227036863565445, -0.005162441171705723, -0.0501602403819561, 0.0012598943430930376, 0.019229907542467117, -0.020894447341561317, -0.021176708862185478, 0.004725749138742685, -0.004167341161519289, -0.019563866779208183, 0.02564735896885395, 0.02923322282731533, -0.015183178707957268, 0.033353887498378754, -0.026584569364786148, 0.045644816011190414, 0.03038163110613823, -0.003558368654921651, -0.008580680936574936, 0.04157617315649986, 0.0288747176527977, 0.02805638127028942, 0.01329509075731039, -0.01977548934519291, -0.05377909913659096, 0.02688228338956833, -0.0006270644371397793, -0.06957117468118668, -0.05121061950922012, -0.05688938871026039, 0.0085937874391675, 0.019628038629889488, 0.04872617870569229, -0.017040004953742027, -0.028104225173592567, 0.04189243167638779, -0.052158281207084656, -0.00567607581615448, -0.06627003848552704, 0.014894862659275532, 0.012682344764471054, -0.013332447968423367, 0.019977020099759102, 0.016093015670776367, 0.0459735207259655, -0.01298104040324688, -0.015181046910583973, -0.04451248049736023, 0.01682462729513645, 0.024835258722305298, -0.030685076490044594, 0.024048270657658577, 0.08683069050312042, 0.030700262635946274, -0.03204714134335518, 0.03271874412894249, -0.0214365404099226, -0.07429774105548859, 0.0009313314221799374, -0.02907535247504711, 0.04308692738413811, -0.045709095895290375, 0.011192930862307549, 0.04612832888960838, -0.0025429476518183947, -0.022145627066493034, 0.03275727108120918, -0.061889734119176865, 0.07414548099040985, 0.06322558969259262, -0.036271244287490845, 0.00508439727127552, 0.02125779166817665, 0.024201568216085434, 0.01571143977344036, -0.01841137930750847, -0.03424421325325966, -0.07191073894500732, 0.014658525586128235, 0.027978334575891495, 0.027597734704613686, -0.07612109184265137, 0.03530338034033775, 0.037982817739248276, 0.032301392406225204, 0.020146304741501808, 0.011800432577729225, -0.012936105951666832, -0.022642912343144417, 0.028347186744213104, -0.005830677691847086, 0.019184034317731857, -0.0381285697221756, 0.01137456949800253, -0.002023909008130431, 0.04149703308939934, -0.031223060563206673, 0.03792623430490494, 0.03150603175163269, 0.01715143397450447, 0.013550312258303165, -0.027802716940641403, -0.03562691807746887, 0.05082329735159874, -0.038650304079055786, 0.014921189285814762, 0.032063692808151245, 0.0025991154834628105, -0.02071547321975231, 0.006098935380578041, -0.004909563343971968, -0.016070088371634483, 0.08397027850151062, -0.0465942919254303, 0.005827870219945908, 0.02083325758576393, -0.029447484761476517, 0.011804250068962574, 0.010790733620524406, -0.013661986216902733, -0.04732716456055641, -0.0023906382266432047, 0.03694938123226166, 0.0030338491778820753, 0.03370511531829834, -0.04586661234498024, -0.04536982625722885, 0.011178403161466122, 0.004650391638278961, -0.02042681910097599, -0.01008756272494793, -0.045186568051576614, -0.033861804753541946, -0.03261066973209381, -0.02785309962928295, 0.02991749532520771, 0.0008385740802623332, -0.014189593493938446, -0.0029706209897994995, -0.03922703489661217, -0.05523170530796051, -0.03768305480480194, -0.0154791921377182, 0.02219758741557598, 0.015637315809726715, -0.042707737535238266, 0.05082213506102562, -0.003345223143696785, -0.07668761163949966, 0.018804939463734627, -0.014390243217349052, 0.0018134701531380415, -0.014928358606994152, -0.004239162430167198, 0.005923054181039333, 0.018922554329037666, 0.03177421912550926, 0.011564090847969055, -0.06124104931950569, 0.02999669313430786, -0.061745744198560715, -0.055486440658569336, 0.034248240292072296, -0.03317778930068016, 0.0471646711230278, 0.024830222129821777, 0.015897508710622787, 0.06675387173891068, 0.027403229847550392, -0.016281986609101295, -0.089610256254673, 0.013775141909718513, -0.030490227043628693, -0.01558451447635889, 0.026470787823200226, 0.026905983686447144, 0.008445716463029385, -0.012292719446122646, -0.008174809627234936, 0.02502036653459072, 0.044561658054590225, 0.015753159299492836, 0.00955837219953537, 0.001568057225085795, 0.023449409753084183, -0.05094641074538231, -0.010670441202819347, 0.010875517502427101, -0.025765230879187584, -0.0037723456043750048, 0.0022461186163127422, 0.01046950463205576, 0.0032674826215952635, -0.05401259660720825, 0.02727658487856388, 0.01917560026049614, 0.019019924104213715, -0.03362255170941353, 0.017966557294130325, 0.03311102092266083, -0.03419245779514313, -0.004639311693608761, 0.00919815618544817, 0.052311986684799194, 0.014540893025696278, -0.011696424335241318, 0.038670141249895096, 0.06762098520994186, 0.001362474518828094, -0.005742351058870554, 0.039285678416490555, 0.033180639147758484, 0.04067361727356911, -0.021782362833619118, 0.023907434195280075, 0.05031726509332657, 0.022377438843250275, 0.00536512304097414, -0.0027350536547601223, -0.030381444841623306, -0.0022709285840392113, -0.07688631117343903, 0.003250437555834651, -0.04345560073852539, 0.034012023359537125, -0.006513261701911688, 0.04770428314805031, 0.022526409476995468, -0.03390400856733322, 0.026970434933900833, 0.020055947825312614, -0.06398040056228638, 0.028081011027097702, -0.016753321513533592, 0.03707325831055641, 0.013240178115665913, -0.03405788168311119, -0.008975219912827015, -0.03750382363796234, -0.008243058808147907, 0.008948272094130516, 0.026222318410873413, -0.0007008831016719341, -0.014404392801225185, 0.002011209726333618, -0.04566410928964615, 0.01443728618323803, -0.0037180755753070116, 0.010455988347530365, -0.024765096604824066, 0.027249475941061974, 0.015936000272631645, 0.05790796875953674, -0.0129888029769063, 0.0022236849181354046, 0.014285663142800331, -0.010510736145079136, 0.056365881115198135, -0.00017476761422585696, 0.019627990201115608, -0.0008222094038501382, 0.03248852491378784, 0.012163245119154453, 0.029995867982506752, 0.028270479291677475, -0.04483671113848686, -0.02540738694369793, -0.039717897772789, -0.018641788512468338, 0.0013246908783912659, 0.007644686847925186, 0.010747254826128483, 0.010808778926730156, 0.04631953313946724, -0.008490822277963161, -0.0439758263528347, 0.031949110329151154, 0.07772739976644516, 0.01193435862660408, -0.018999727442860603, -0.021740300580859184, -0.0025469493120908737, 0.008946970105171204, -0.02932536043226719, 0.034272097051143646, 0.024647438898682594, -0.008542275987565517, 0.014417082071304321, 0.04467829316854477, -0.00023831687576603144, -0.05776722729206085, -0.029082391411066055, 0.03327057510614395, 0.05678233876824379, -0.014235918410122395, -0.05322470888495445, 0.019878610968589783, 0.06287707388401031, 0.03886253759264946, 0.020649729296565056, -0.028466567397117615, -0.12495329976081848, 0.018535925075411797, 0.005665786098688841, 0.04073574021458626, -0.02378825470805168, -0.017124047502875328, -0.050986189395189285, -0.03679678216576576, 0.02083613909780979, -0.005992834456264973, 0.024400008842349052, -0.028439342975616455, 0.050846610218286514, -0.019525833427906036, -0.013901862315833569, -0.05964529886841774, 0.017951881512999535, -0.0285287294536829, 0.018425939604640007, 0.007290807086974382, -0.021194858476519585, -0.00631380220875144, 0.04605503007769585, 0.021176842972636223, 0.05947212874889374, -0.018670538440346718, -0.016857000067830086, 0.010752839036285877, -0.013079557567834854, -0.010715799406170845, -0.053995247930288315, 0.0030976450070738792, -0.008258504793047905, 0.014738248661160469, 0.044958025217056274, 0.017092416062951088, -0.037003178149461746, 0.0046391561627388, 0.02547713741660118, -0.005714672151952982, -0.0068868906237185, -0.045584168285131454, 0.046214111149311066, 0.04603158310055733, 0.025521691888570786, 0.040856149047613144, 0.019961360841989517, -0.0006684630643576384, -0.014332673512399197, -0.00534440390765667, 0.0159269031137228, -0.01191642601042986, -0.02825271524488926, -0.029812194406986237, -0.004363935440778732, -0.018621936440467834, 0.04553838446736336, 0.012031981721520424, 0.0004744117031805217, -0.038813136518001556, -0.033727746456861496, -0.015632759779691696, -0.0008613123209215701, 0.00031554666929878294, -0.0394064225256443, -0.018288737162947655, 0.002244669711217284, 0.006239322479814291, -0.04421818628907204, 0.030899450182914734, 0.0041769761592149734, 0.02602848783135414, 0.004804991651326418, -0.04874561354517937, 0.03086662106215954, 0.004154570400714874, -0.00918206013739109, 0.03345957398414612, -0.053379084914922714, 0.024652667343616486, -0.021224450320005417, 0.02898205816745758, 0.002182470401749015, -0.046198565512895584, 0.00821028184145689, 0.0021392120979726315, 0.030673831701278687, 0.02393047884106636, -0.036265574395656586, 0.0281244907528162, -0.015574372373521328, -0.03900405019521713, -0.04864124581217766, -0.0243280790746212, 0.00699785677716136, -0.02241128869354725, 0.017212027683854103, -0.02821463532745838, 0.041890986263751984, -0.027624689042568207, -0.022553322836756706, -0.04893104359507561, 0.04470403119921684, -0.032252103090286255, -0.027031339704990387, -0.015109658241271973, 0.004612132906913757, 0.064882293343544, 0.04105862230062485, -0.023587210103869438, 0.03589630872011185, -0.008230235427618027, -0.02556944079697132, -0.002755396068096161, 0.02158895693719387, -0.042852722108364105, -0.0246540829539299, -0.043521083891391754, -0.02306438609957695, 0.05661523714661598, 0.028153276070952415, -0.012621447443962097, 0.0026877010241150856, 0.009190786629915237, -0.003942857496440411, -0.015483993105590343, 0.01592840626835823, -0.0180689487606287, 0.007523240987211466, -0.047366101294755936, 0.018685052171349525, -0.025032343342900276, -0.00527539337053895, 0.034421224147081375, 0.003816034644842148, -0.05220533162355423, 0.034894008189439774, 0.07466796040534973, 0.019289912655949593, 0.004998345859348774, -0.030716214329004288, -0.03593701124191284, 0.04759206995368004, 0.011939307674765587, -0.015381339006125927, 0.04204218462109566, 0.020944997668266296, -0.02788355201482773, 0.011158931069076061, -0.02197675220668316, -0.03970591351389885, 0.03965158760547638, -0.01996222883462906, 0.03832510486245155, 0.05451521649956703, -0.005829745437949896, -0.0008248643134720623, -0.03115791082382202, 0.042098406702280045, -0.01201945636421442, 0.004175459034740925, 0.047536205500364304, -0.0301460400223732, -0.018822383135557175, -0.004423653706908226, -0.007873285561800003, 0.024083925411105156, 0.027694227173924446, 0.04546620324254036, 0.01572997123003006, -0.004831187892705202, -0.02710411138832569, -0.03531002625823021, 0.0462472140789032, -0.0458085797727108, -0.037423472851514816, -0.011700252071022987, -0.015672234818339348, 0.029885927215218544, 0.04733904451131821, -0.015910489484667778, -0.06810836493968964, -0.01927015744149685, -0.012275720946490765, 0.013364925980567932, 0.011691971682012081, -0.04122587665915489, 0.05530758947134018, -0.025109177455306053, 0.02944055385887623, 0.013619682751595974, 0.01392931304872036, -0.009675685316324234, -0.045127492398023605, -0.011756141670048237, -0.04527715593576431, -0.04485373944044113, 0.008794568479061127, 0.010288829915225506, -0.046401266008615494, 0.0071931094862520695, -0.05125637724995613, 0.032669633626937866, -0.02286936156451702, 0.023283004760742188, -0.010271725244820118, 0.0350477397441864, -0.01481708139181137, -0.028676306828856468, -0.015353923663496971, -0.0168102215975523, 0.12019966542720795, 0.10952837765216827, 0.03508788347244263, -0.04692889750003815, 0.07269541919231415, 0.012327163480222225, 0.019309544935822487, 0.004677401389926672, -0.003581142984330654, 0.0011142977746203542, -0.022290784865617752, 0.02613469399511814, 0.05065647512674332, 0.007883012294769287, 0.01087532751262188, 0.03245066851377487, -0.047182027250528336, 0.00793958455324173, 0.007597945164889097, 0.009617993608117104, 0.018502352759242058, -0.010925610549747944, -0.043496206402778625, -0.00021218326583039016, -0.014281163923442364, -0.04624880105257034, -0.01705038547515869, 0.0168285109102726, -0.0027882354333996773, 0.005321402568370104, -0.034478768706321716, 0.012882784940302372, 0.03266114369034767, 0.00672144303098321, 0.008415088057518005, -0.036618672311306, 0.024386147037148476, -0.003295788774266839, 0.003680262714624405, 0.03030594252049923, -0.01982051134109497, 0.014103705063462257, -0.024515779688954353, 0.004948705900460482, -0.08364967256784439, 0.0036776079796254635, -0.052421629428863525, 0.006691538263112307, 0.04177636653184891, -0.0294809490442276, 0.0010226777521893382, 0.018762238323688507, -0.017748378217220306, -0.00027746916748583317, -0.036131035536527634, 0.05823107808828354, 0.03054683469235897, -0.006137807387858629, -0.06412889808416367, -0.03030400350689888, 0.009854727424681187, 0.005745723377913237, 0.03112376295030117, 0.04070049151778221, -0.05031869560480118, -0.01716306433081627, -0.010943837463855743, 0.07704605162143707, 0.016283901408314705, -0.0004958937643095851, 0.04168481007218361, -0.0037472418043762445, -0.03264470398426056, -0.011753307655453682, -0.015638794749975204, 0.004522762261331081, -0.016206849366426468, -0.002371869282796979, 0.02118724212050438, -0.056450217962265015, -0.01951959915459156, 0.03205960988998413, 1.9245136684276076e-7, 0.0021697047632187605, -0.07060925662517548, 0.04042337089776993, 0.016512971371412277, 0.03891656547784805, -0.013872058130800724, -0.0033890404738485813, -0.013077884912490845, 0.04962914437055588, 0.01651519164443016, -0.01889188028872013, 0.021158751100301743, -0.0009290374582633376, -0.031011123210191727, 0.033011939376592636, -0.009542128071188927, 0.06356239318847656, 0.00969618372619152, 0.04178246855735779, -0.007961268536746502, 0.046804219484329224, -0.00048686368972994387, 0.01483888179063797, 0.01304421853274107, -0.06595788896083832, -0.0200063306838274, 0.023954547941684723, 0.006085261236876249, -0.012543718330562115, -0.027795419096946716, -0.04411960393190384, -0.041331660002470016, 0.017889592796564102, -0.04354581981897354, -0.041756775230169296, 0.018181467428803444, -0.011585365980863571, 0.02905511111021042, -0.0626128613948822, -0.03844931349158287, -0.028085386380553246, -0.010975182056427002, -0.026151401922106743, -0.02808324061334133, 0.029635779559612274, 0.019940771162509918, -0.028614480048418045, 0.012859431095421314, 0.03658944368362427, 0.015363815240561962, -0.007732061203569174, -0.021411430090665817, 0.015926798805594444, 0.029004927724599838, 0.027037374675273895, -0.019992848858237267, -0.013277885504066944, 0.026263292878866196, -0.04052186384797096, 0.011607066728174686, 0.04667415842413902, -0.019636955112218857, 0.020179476588964462, -0.01569710113108158, -0.016358861699700356, -0.004178091883659363, 0.026538396254181862, -0.013713371939957142, -0.024892836809158325, -0.034093886613845825, -0.007454963866621256, -0.015263577923178673, 0.017161812633275986, 0.00018977602303493768, 0.02524002641439438, -0.028104739263653755, 0.0147788617759943, 0.012010500766336918, 0.011523151770234108, -0.015567900612950325, 0.009501391090452671, -0.016679532825946808, 0.04089020565152168, 0.011658336967229843, -0.0220844354480505, 0.015666674822568893, 0.016538020223379135, -0.0231331679970026, 0.009795849211513996, 0.006057050544768572, 0.0009197038598358631, -0.0840989202260971, -0.03483689948916435, 0.021827563643455505, 0.01672031544148922, 0.017222188413143158, -0.04108858481049538, -0.021249692887067795, 0.0032802980858832598, -0.04676225408911705, 0.001674346742220223, 0.004863489884883165, -0.02217690274119377, -0.02866089716553688, -0.009867461398243904, -0.047243423759937286, 0.028981123119592667, 0.03935672715306282, 0.06088043749332428, 0.0019126811530441046, 0.017194928601384163, -0.027022628113627434, -0.026634640991687775, 0.01846291497349739, 0.0015877726254984736, 0.010260182432830334, -0.045865800231695175, 0.0611465685069561, -0.03519321233034134, -0.03292040899395943, 0.03434398025274277, 0.001830007415264845, 0.03824988007545471, 0.02934570051729679, 0.02553657814860344, 0.01748218573629856, 0.05315908044576645, 0.030635394155979156, 0.016930969431996346, -0.04146602749824524, 0.014102859422564507, 0.02062828838825226, 0.029815329238772392, -0.029104283079504967, 0.005044585559517145, 0.02087928168475628, 0.012451931834220886, -0.019409842789173126, 0.0037164578679949045, -0.03253655508160591, -0.015159367583692074, -0.019130947068333626, 0.049025893211364746, -0.014266162179410458, -0.04603416845202446, 0.007805403787642717, -0.04552661255002022, -0.02113950066268444, 0.03608774393796921, 0.023463506251573563, 0.005372436251491308, -0.013306836597621441, 0.0148403849452734, -0.04837168753147125, 0.012426672503352165, -0.003835535142570734, -0.008131351321935654, -0.033077213913202286, -0.008406490087509155, 0.027982743456959724, 0.004776462446898222, -0.042649514973163605, 0.008912689052522182, -0.010581376031041145, 0.06458286941051483, -0.060409143567085266, 0.011845346540212631, 0.02945699542760849, -0.016637148335576057, -0.014059565961360931, -0.0811600461602211, 0.08733239024877548, 0.015857385471463203, -0.005888740997761488, -0.028380032628774643, -0.034698911011219025, -0.03919430822134018, -0.002030937233939767, 0.0750088170170784, 0.004610054194927216, 0.016111794859170914, -0.018329009413719177, 0.016931872814893723, 0.001481562969274819, -0.03986058384180069, 0.011484418995678425, -0.02151111699640751, -0.02287791296839714, -0.03517412766814232, 0.0018309616716578603, 0.0010545979021117091, 0.001956717576831579, 0.05692072585225105, -0.016234923154115677, 0.012086800299584866, -0.010221157222986221, 0.009830737486481667, 0.03863610699772835, 0.024751557037234306, -0.022851618006825447, 0.051730383187532425, -0.012086869217455387, 0.04133198410272598, 0.025484437122941017, 0.008568800054490566, -0.061959896236658096, 0.025381654500961304, -0.030314534902572632, 0.0011615678668022156, -0.019881485030055046, 0.021099623292684555, -0.035930268466472626, -0.049519870430231094, 0.007510938216000795, 0.03219708427786827, -0.042529553174972534, 0.01052065845578909, 0.03160420060157776, 0.0003329381288494915, 0.06195129454135895, -0.02159678190946579, 0.0016717836260795593, 0.031719621270895004, -0.04480305314064026, 0.013031838461756706, 0.0029608523473143578, 0.07013767212629318, 0.014177265577018261, -0.002326689660549164, 0.028336193412542343, -0.01646438241004944, 0.01959911175072193, 0.0156850703060627, 0.061291735619306564, -0.02183404751121998, 0.01007428951561451, 0.020800676196813583, 0.028142591938376427, 0.035282354801893234, 0.03650704771280289, 0.0006551002152264118, 0.06319978088140488, -0.049365751445293427, -0.014915848150849342, -0.05419987812638283, -0.040070872753858566, -0.06238754093647003, 0.004984751343727112, 0.02440398372709751, 0.02966001257300377, 0.056180112063884735, 0.01548665203154087, -0.021438157185912132, -0.03628933057188988, 0.03742839768528938, -0.025650320574641228, 0.002165436279028654, -0.0212224293500185, -0.007682054303586483, 0.02867843024432659, 0.003941235598176718, -0.03193062171339989, -0.023488229140639305, 0.025919176638126373, 0.0176105834543705, 0.01895499788224697, -0.028709324076771736, -0.025683170184493065, -0.004131338093429804, 0.04049494117498398, -0.0686078742146492, -0.03539317473769188, -0.04836340621113777, 0.015853533521294594, 0.01152490358799696, -0.024213658645749092 ]
<p>I have gotten a student job in the management department of a chain of 50 grocery stores. The job includes gathering daily statistics on the economy of the stores.</p> <p>Every day a <strong>per-store revenue statistic</strong> is made, comparing the revenue to matching day last year (sunday/sunday, monday/monday) and an accumulated statistic for the month. </p> <p>Also a <strong>per-store gross margin percentage statistic</strong> is made.</p> <p>Now these are simple measures and I feel that there could be a lot more to be gained from the data, the data is specific down to the (cost price)/(sale price)/(number of sales)-level on every type of item.</p> <p>Furthermore no or very few graphics are made and the data from the previous years are not taken into use.</p> <p>Have any of you seen a similar problem? Do you have any ideas on how to proceed? Any easy-to-read, informative types of graphs you would want to share regarding these types of data?</p>
73,924
[ -0.01419538352638483, -0.03248212859034538, -0.020706800743937492, 0.03810833767056465, 0.05450771749019623, 0.02298889309167862, 0.045226696878671646, 0.006926593836396933, 0.017647266387939453, 0.018555231392383575, 0.014157574623823166, 0.046980034559965134, 0.053192347288131714, 0.03294796124100685, 0.010194116272032261, 0.0062404233030974865, -0.062262162566185, -0.007127112243324518, 0.011906846426427364, -0.006515522953122854, 0.007791285403072834, 0.018939729779958725, 0.022353796288371086, -0.016419338062405586, -0.020491860806941986, 0.02455016039311886, 0.007856137119233608, -0.0012484525796025991, -0.002252650447189808, 0.03375973179936409, -0.022779645398259163, -0.007953171618282795, 0.0067401002161204815, 0.03690027445554733, 0.03342658653855324, 0.03218282014131546, -0.03823528438806534, -0.03602059930562973, -0.01159665361046791, 0.025004791095852852, -0.04883376136422157, 0.02351830154657364, 0.001351795974187553, 0.025329789146780968, -0.023435641080141068, 0.0022518308833241463, -0.02582809142768383, -0.005180117674171925, 0.02697502262890339, -0.05210350826382637, 0.0600045882165432, 0.0027220044285058975, 0.05589092895388603, 0.033557333052158356, -0.028882082551717758, 0.018491121008992195, 0.01964951492846012, 0.047216594219207764, -0.03282623365521431, -0.03182901814579964, 0.013358984142541885, -0.02834746055305004, -0.010017680004239082, -0.03280121833086014, -0.03952313959598541, 0.04159275442361832, -0.021490134298801422, -0.01006390992552042, 0.054463498294353485, -0.003664252581074834, 0.01983293890953064, 0.04814453423023224, 0.03838426619768143, 0.004867244511842728, 0.017490552738308907, -0.052303582429885864, 0.02999686449766159, 0.01626044139266014, 0.04273533448576927, -0.010613912716507912, -0.012493954040110111, 0.016779063269495964, 0.03523213788866997, 0.0808287113904953, 0.01403252873569727, -0.031323954463005066, 0.0715833380818367, -0.07044737786054611, 0.013694674707949162, 0.006677727214992046, 0.01665009930729866, -0.010020153596997261, 0.025339730083942413, 0.028420692309737206, -0.04306234046816826, 0.006247039884328842, -0.038252636790275574, 0.037390973418951035, 0.0033997786231338978, -0.007460194639861584, -0.007645213045179844, -0.008136223070323467, 0.01628512144088745, 0.03586963191628456, -0.0010221156990155578, 0.00793564785271883, -0.025523724034428596, -0.012975256890058517, 0.02514819987118244, -0.016843970865011215, -0.02614131197333336, 0.008043630979955196, 0.02373441681265831, -0.013362006284296513, -0.005209288559854031, -0.044421009719371796, -0.030710600316524506, -0.012988084927201271, 0.032932598143815994, 0.04951932653784752, 0.022045252844691277, -0.04286278784275055, 0.02993031218647957, -0.056480519473552704, -0.06083216518163681, 0.030162163078784943, -0.0015903491294011474, -0.051698293536901474, -0.07693714648485184, 0.07126112282276154, 0.016052965074777603, 0.004732465837150812, 0.031136250123381615, -0.06184334307909012, 0.04566787928342819, -0.0031260703690350056, -0.060736462473869324, -0.05884241312742233, 0.059303801506757736, -0.02495475485920906, -0.011928170919418335, -0.03408981114625931, -0.023711243644356728, 0.020509330555796623, 0.01702837646007538, 0.014622801914811134, 0.04801646247506142, 0.010803692042827606, 0.018366768956184387, -0.007430423982441425, -0.018181325867772102, 0.015156247653067112, -0.027461949735879898, -0.04037676751613617, 0.019865872338414192, -0.05763693526387215, 0.0026248933281749487, 0.049021948128938675, -0.03484560549259186, -0.04579440876841545, 0.01981181465089321, 0.04480874165892601, -0.024446003139019012, 0.008708460256457329, 0.01185222901403904, -0.021561402827501297, 0.07954954355955124, -0.005840633064508438, 0.010186346247792244, 0.00991437491029501, -0.034083276987075806, 0.042203787714242935, 0.04213547706604004, 0.020893028005957603, 0.05393797159194946, 0.019881300628185272, 0.01483236439526081, 0.010889630764722824, 0.01591596007347107, 0.019782887771725655, -0.004722313489764929, -0.048259224742650986, -0.04299147427082062, 0.0017738527385517955, 0.009260195307433605, 0.02034730091691017, -0.015488969162106514, -0.03557548671960831, 0.03764840215444565, -0.08966334909200668, -0.05940600484609604, -0.084173284471035, 0.010757096111774445, -0.050100453197956085, -0.024015165865421295, 0.023158427327871323, -0.009750896133482456, -0.0059339506551623344, -0.016184428706765175, -0.060357775539159775, 0.0018052988452836871, -0.017129138112068176, 0.026440566405653954, -0.04965238645672798, -0.022169290110468864, 0.0004574884078465402, 0.028654877096414566, -0.045084353536367416, -0.0011402018135413527, -0.050292741507291794, -0.04812731221318245, -0.011514847166836262, -0.042309362441301346, 0.003216592827811837, 0.0002623322943691164, 0.004748351406306028, 0.012104641646146774, 0.02704380825161934, -0.029680341482162476, 0.04564737528562546, -0.052982479333877563, 0.03917007893323898, 0.08999475836753845, -0.01639537885785103, -0.00972933042794466, 0.00804151687771082, 0.04714963585138321, 0.02842795103788376, 0.005883142352104187, 0.016842685639858246, -0.05068373680114746, 0.02578369528055191, 0.013986465521156788, 0.001902471180073917, -0.020932311192154884, 0.00046299045789055526, 0.0872233510017395, 0.0024533558171242476, -0.007257689256221056, -0.002135156188160181, -0.027429742738604546, 0.013793453574180603, 0.002290457021445036, 0.005912288557738066, 0.020608603954315186, 0.021650904789566994, 0.018726620823144913, 0.034418266266584396, -0.013353999704122543, 0.02901916764676571, 0.04088154435157776, 0.04106375202536583, -0.009294688701629639, 0.027993284165859222, 0.01663190871477127, 0.005298514850437641, 0.07208652049303055, -0.03325513005256653, 0.006572324316948652, 0.06084994599223137, -0.01023789495229721, -0.009375681169331074, 0.015700766816735268, -0.03488880768418312, -0.019359953701496124, 0.042021237313747406, -0.03558297082781792, 0.008854416199028492, 0.035911478102207184, -0.03763619065284729, 0.020722875371575356, 0.008105473592877388, -0.047303877770900726, -0.05200396850705147, 0.012160313315689564, 0.02180914394557476, -0.0019737312104552984, 0.02939179353415966, -0.027783270925283432, -0.015567997470498085, 0.032503314316272736, -0.005646083038300276, 0.005501165520399809, -0.00021238080807961524, -0.028836576268076897, 0.019660772755742073, 0.0014219279401004314, 0.0019403869519010186, 0.03782781958580017, -0.0055438862182199955, 0.029949411749839783, 0.04208993539214134, 0.028399212285876274, -0.0005785315297544003, 0.003703606780618429, 0.006885127630084753, 0.050668228417634964, -0.06285431981086731, -0.028153620660305023, 0.05565955489873886, 0.003341827541589737, -0.011029461398720741, -0.02056187391281128, -0.037227194756269455, -0.029308157041668892, -0.025702176615595818, -0.00025438322336412966, -0.02608112432062626, -0.019881296902894974, -0.028856854885816574, 0.015250840224325657, -0.022766929119825363, -0.003734371392056346, -0.055895816534757614, -0.08775010704994202, -0.0053810435347259045, 0.018902886658906937, 0.032067473977804184, -0.003938996233046055, 0.000504738069139421, 0.05675637349486351, 0.005735975224524736, -0.030016815289855003, -0.06277185678482056, -0.04661494866013527, -0.024663986638188362, -0.02382146380841732, 0.007311883848160505, 0.031389955431222916, -0.015277629718184471, -0.01069182064384222, 0.0241358932107687, 0.028944196179509163, 0.061267197132110596, -0.006031322292983532, -0.053521476686000824, 0.00939888320863247, -0.01740764081478119, 0.020577795803546906, 0.004452286288142204, 0.0055806003510952, -0.08672495931386948, -0.015929605811834335, 0.004963643848896027, 0.020480679348111153, 0.0003334764624014497, -0.07539330422878265, 0.014462629333138466, -0.0030527992639690638, 0.008785749785602093, -0.017042027786374092, -0.003594841342419386, 0.0032898711506277323, -0.01248627807945013, -0.011143434792757034, -0.008073399774730206, 0.04096127301454544, -0.023170355707406998, -0.003367945784702897, 0.12165161967277527, 0.03253934532403946, -0.026600921526551247, -0.02379714883863926, -0.0035634099040180445, -0.0050128730945289135, 0.033874623477458954, -0.03215314820408821, 0.006447543855756521, 0.04750468581914902, 0.026783764362335205, 0.014264829456806183, 0.015018579550087452, -0.03716601803898811, -0.0034751303028315306, -0.08901931345462799, -0.015940586104989052, -0.03232748806476593, 0.06617894023656845, -0.020181600004434586, 0.02289951965212822, -0.013071096502244473, -0.027134818956255913, 0.03232407197356224, 0.0058579230681061745, -0.03353387489914894, 0.035760391503572464, 0.008089212700724602, 0.017087874934077263, 0.055614981800317764, -0.024260805919766426, 0.03376975655555725, -0.033216442912817, -0.020070234313607216, -0.024964530020952225, 0.016110869124531746, -0.016085604205727577, 0.0071628158912062645, -0.02023671381175518, 0.015123391523957253, -0.02834279090166092, -0.007656223140656948, 0.04930708557367325, -0.006445432547479868, 0.023531096056103706, 0.03615579009056091, 0.02635350450873375, -0.04671231657266617, -0.03881154954433441, -0.006455143913626671, 0.022430436685681343, 0.04649714007973671, -0.006658200640231371, 0.01993240788578987, -0.0034780302084982395, 0.03553598374128342, -0.004449332132935524, 0.017875507473945618, 0.00873283389955759, 0.013684685342013836, 0.005200170446187258, -0.02157556265592575, -0.02593781240284443, 0.01901669055223465, 0.013210260309278965, 0.0012693502940237522, -0.03830373287200928, 0.043841492384672165, 0.040066808462142944, -0.041186846792697906, 0.02971871756017208, 0.08266567438840866, 0.009058276191353798, -0.0023585655726492405, -0.0056389449164271355, -0.045899275690317154, -0.01237073726952076, -0.022873900830745697, 0.029071757569909096, 0.006129425019025803, 0.018863152712583542, 0.022324614226818085, 0.029094886034727097, 0.028972147032618523, -0.033918920904397964, 0.008724316023290157, 0.010540503077208996, 0.012856664136052132, -0.0032897726632654667, -0.04299866408109665, 0.054323695600032806, 0.0659719705581665, 0.022539258003234863, 0.028847303241491318, 0.005338896531611681, -0.08592122048139572, 0.020496319979429245, 0.017025725916028023, 0.03840387612581253, -0.00600780826061964, -0.01580411195755005, -0.01714000664651394, 0.006614010315388441, 0.015061253681778908, -0.031816791743040085, 0.05573725327849388, -0.01331393700093031, 0.0396139994263649, -0.038725823163986206, -0.018819916993379593, -0.00807181652635336, -0.007023724727332592, -0.04760341718792915, 0.010310029610991478, 0.002852870849892497, -0.0008615904371254146, -0.03858061507344246, 0.004032620228827, 0.015863632783293724, 0.03181871771812439, -0.008133305236697197, -0.05472909286618233, 0.012467545457184315, 0.015307501889765263, -0.025270000100135803, -0.06791143119335175, 0.020685739815235138, 0.005024315323680639, 0.00010581756941974163, 0.03179245442152023, -0.017119674012064934, -0.0032738884910941124, -0.018577370792627335, 0.01948738843202591, -0.006457076407968998, -0.033386923372745514, -0.05575573444366455, 0.02978389710187912, 0.03390509635210037, 0.019037721678614616, 0.03330589085817337, 0.03861744701862335, 0.016723180189728737, 0.01953994669020176, -0.018220076337456703, 0.02268795296549797, -0.02100144326686859, -0.017920419573783875, -0.015408775769174099, -0.0036070116329938173, -0.004371241200715303, 0.007197563070803881, 0.02301083691418171, 0.03948664292693138, -0.05691840127110481, -0.017406059429049492, -0.013816080056130886, 0.03200196102261543, -0.005692954640835524, -0.020038416609168053, -0.002169000217691064, -0.0014805671526119113, -0.03233826532959938, -0.05819965898990631, 0.00954771414399147, -0.011126064695417881, -0.016039008274674416, -0.007646101992577314, -0.010756513103842735, 0.01804160326719284, -0.052988406270742416, -0.039828892797231674, -0.011648423969745636, -0.050826381891965866, 0.02228078991174698, -0.021990260109305382, 0.05567791685461998, 0.028338061645627022, -0.029581474140286446, -0.020644797012209892, 0.059584032744169235, 0.013234959915280342, -0.006845530588179827, -0.029309328645467758, 0.03135761618614197, -0.023727241903543472, 0.0008230141829699278, -0.037586238235235214, -0.07980708032846451, 0.049656663089990616, 0.03132049739360809, -0.03765353932976723, -0.025367775931954384, 0.008164075203239918, 0.0017872368916869164, -0.002986649749800563, -0.022516604512929916, 0.01079467497766018, -0.013496424071490765, -0.039941608905792236, 0.007145486306399107, -0.012449894100427628, 0.10021887719631195, -0.008594662882387638, -0.019482025876641273, -0.019264789298176765, 0.006796947214752436, -0.013634152710437775, -0.03185898810625076, -0.009587615728378296, -0.015871508046984673, -0.05495309829711914, -0.07282885909080505, 0.004508522339165211, 0.030234042555093765, -0.041725557297468185, 0.045697614550590515, 0.014755552634596825, 0.035283852368593216, 0.0021837856620550156, -0.06722019612789154, 0.06013552471995354, -0.013718949630856514, -0.011455063708126545, -0.020139461383223534, -0.013181242160499096, -0.016491593793034554, -0.016528282314538956, 0.03556692600250244, 0.012336833402514458, -0.045389220118522644, 0.029980944469571114, 0.048909302800893784, 0.0058965482749044895, 0.0014669331721961498, -0.007724459283053875, -0.022724034264683723, 0.002132557099685073, -0.0010164373088628054, 0.01976274698972702, -0.012800569646060467, 0.054852742701768875, -0.040532954037189484, -0.03527935966849327, -0.01853153109550476, -0.00399510795250535, 0.05212189257144928, 0.010676692239940166, 0.027663320302963257, 0.06797449290752411, 0.0009534037089906633, -0.019045650959014893, -0.011247146874666214, -0.0011854947078973055, -0.0340687558054924, 0.01828058995306492, 0.06752920895814896, -0.0017182208830490708, -0.004761492367833853, 0.007188925985246897, 0.005319041199982166, 0.027814632281661034, -0.0035465972032397985, 0.024324286729097366, 0.007603478617966175, 0.027079172432422638, -0.028715429827570915, -0.0447586365044117, -0.005784494802355766, 0.00033759791404008865, 0.06614559143781662, -0.04472219944000244, -0.047820135951042175, 0.0374029316008091, 0.026923051103949547, -0.026561792939901352, -0.015889886766672134, 0.010714251548051834, -0.05537843331694603, -0.00017455073248129338, 0.02696938067674637, -0.019790707156062126, 0.02498764358460903, -0.00425263075158, 0.015329708345234394, 0.003485733876004815, 0.03341377153992653, -0.008050558157265186, -0.05629952251911163, -0.017907533794641495, -0.023334704339504242, -0.02274782955646515, 0.0475127138197422, -0.03231237828731537, 0.0032850373536348343, 0.004005974158644676, -0.008262727409601212, -0.003943189978599548, -0.012798730283975601, 0.019032347947359085, 0.012850981205701828, 0.06791362166404724, 0.03701750934123993, 0.0018405282171443105, 0.013027780689299107, -0.006659190636128187, 0.11077922582626343, 0.0703490749001503, 0.0059266407042741776, -0.01605738326907158, 0.026131005957722664, 0.008030478842556477, -0.009259195998311043, 0.007068552076816559, 0.04580548033118248, -0.008916223421692848, 0.01009176392108202, 0.026516646146774292, 0.06832660734653473, -0.0442005954682827, 0.031848106533288956, 0.05666812136769295, -0.004604921210557222, -0.000595778925344348, 0.0030887899920344353, 0.011351305991411209, 0.024718521162867546, 0.004505709279328585, -0.06136924773454666, 0.034927260130643845, 0.01085000578314066, -0.039567526429891586, 0.03194857016205788, -0.029192578047513962, 0.0303775854408741, 0.015840355306863785, -0.004996923729777336, 0.04057859256863594, 0.023991677910089493, 0.041184183210134506, -0.019721411168575287, -0.01437405589967966, 0.002774919383227825, -0.03971131145954132, -0.004001288674771786, 0.024181997403502464, -0.0030103535391390324, -0.02664680778980255, 0.01878940500319004, -0.002664504572749138, -0.021312447264790535, -0.017826389521360397, -0.030858902260661125, 0.03530978411436081, 0.02118590474128723, -0.009226341731846333, -0.03615222126245499, 0.020386943593621254, -0.005546893924474716, -0.025333408266305923, -0.002783184638246894, 0.01677894964814186, 0.03645780310034752, -0.05340193957090378, -0.007108270190656185, -0.01315571554005146, 0.0075646513141691685, -0.009991968050599098, 0.025008127093315125, 0.018309656530618668, -0.017619892954826355, -0.023538189008831978, -0.03251607343554497, 0.03551299870014191, 0.013544091023504734, -0.018350787460803986, 0.03660181164741516, 0.01490779034793377, -0.026828758418560028, -0.01409093663096428, -0.014552191831171513, -0.0009178860345855355, -0.012712930329144001, -0.007264305371791124, -0.00697633670642972, 0.030648713931441307, -0.01183459721505642, 0.016794925555586815, -0.017765024676918983, -0.02351428009569645, -0.059754177927970886, 0.005783949047327042, 0.029700230807065964, 0.027373235672712326, 0.03794803470373154, 0.009352116845548153, -0.015861496329307556, 0.06982976198196411, 0.020793728530406952, -0.015198723413050175, -0.019160453230142593, -0.003985569812357426, -0.06640765815973282, 0.002530698897317052, 0.012472138740122318, 0.06455133855342865, 0.014856642112135887, -0.0009031067020259798, 0.02001834288239479, 0.010100587271153927, 0.003776119090616703, 0.026878129690885544, 0.027525577694177628, -0.07514018565416336, 0.017488153651356697, 0.027679571881890297, -0.014420302584767342, -0.02893219329416752, -0.03898917883634567, -0.030389465391635895, -0.01090816967189312, -0.03568194434046745, 0.0354844406247139, -0.0021664933301508427, 0.019292227923870087, -0.023539265617728233, 0.034264881163835526, -0.024018917232751846, 0.003706126706674695, -0.03510164096951485, -0.036090441048145294, -0.02255617268383503, -0.012242122553288937, -0.02008255384862423, 0.023090578615665436, -0.013123874552547932, 0.03388557583093643, 0.04641883820295334, 0.05616855248808861, -0.012142293155193329, -0.02585544064640999, 0.04484187439084053, 0.0026632845401763916, 0.03032873012125492, -0.009986520744860172, -0.00032837336766533554, 0.04082615301012993, -0.027831127867102623, -0.007330321706831455, -0.01010385062545538, -0.017810305580496788, 0.035308051854372025, -0.01751025766134262, -0.02294258400797844, -0.028735416010022163, 0.029722075909376144, -0.026676755398511887, -0.009506087750196457, -0.02023601159453392, 0.0019684238359332085, 0.024649422615766525, 0.013066553510725498, -0.008864236995577812, 0.005350836552679539, -0.01268662977963686, 0.008442140184342861, 0.02012316696345806, -0.0048601627349853516, 0.006124179344624281, -0.014027752913534641, 0.02481994591653347, -0.014731586910784245, 0.01612124778330326, -0.020507236942648888, 0.051025476306676865, 0.03389270603656769, -0.0749533399939537, 0.015383458696305752, -0.0037668615113943815, -0.0020298080053180456, -0.03278050199151039, -0.024723855778574944, 0.027057917788624763, -0.0060284677892923355, 0.04488439857959747, -0.0505877323448658, 0.01995437778532505, 0.026072369888424873, -0.05726668983697891, 0.013951382599771023, -0.02368537150323391, -0.001063604955561459, -0.007446073926985264, -0.015010057017207146, 0.030742576345801353, -0.004911048337817192, 0.004326311871409416, 0.08965588361024857, 0.0038343744818121195, 0.02733633853495121, 0.026571249589323997, -0.0018268610583618283, -0.014541012234985828, 0.01550662238150835, -0.024942347779870033, -0.0318567268550396, 0.03317853435873985, -0.043500788509845734, -0.024651048704981804, 0.024305827915668488, -0.020932260900735855, 0.00980385486036539, 0.032906290143728256, -0.01771160028874874, -0.019256068393588066, 0.018918728455901146, 0.02487003244459629, -0.001924926764331758, -0.028509167954325676, -0.00725898053497076, 0.01473484467715025, 0.051890380680561066, 0.0198774766176939, 0.049029625952243805, 0.05560853332281113, -0.04695091396570206, -0.02278265170753002, -0.010955095291137695, 0.006521685514599085, -0.003979424014687538, 0.02438945509493351, 0.01504388265311718, 0.014678454026579857, -0.027260979637503624, 0.017567697912454605, -0.07958885282278061, 0.01035410538315773, 0.04557225480675697, -0.001997296931222081, 0.01045023649930954, 0.0023642154410481453, -0.005906508304178715, -0.029528459534049034, -0.013004121370613575, 0.001841969322413206, -0.00849219411611557, -0.07027014344930649, 0.013834163546562195, -0.005969225894659758, -0.02657971903681755, -0.007689198013395071, -0.008836359716951847, 0.008782805874943733, 0.04688100516796112, -0.029921097680926323, 0.017565399408340454, 0.02857346273958683, -0.003068595426157117, 0.05007333308458328, -0.07769068330526352, 0.060585714876651764, 0.051807258278131485, -0.0019012218108400702, -0.003609479172155261, -0.04506592079997063, -0.026472628116607666, 0.011118447408080101, 0.06304185837507248, -0.03707908093929291, 0.002009771531447768, -0.01047859899699688, -0.002322553424164653, -0.011837366037070751, -0.04427013173699379, 0.023886533454060555, -0.04173201695084572, -0.03629789501428604, 0.038175780326128006, -0.017665458843111992, 0.013451481238007545, -0.020769543945789337, -0.0006680836668238044, 0.009092322550714016, 0.00014328229008242488, 0.0072409166023135185, -0.03170935437083244, 0.026510998606681824, -0.013418077491223812, -0.023100240156054497, 0.04245844855904579, 0.0017855508485808969, 0.003243618179112673, 0.042728491127491, -0.04014825075864792, -0.07083887606859207, 0.08610112965106964, -0.037727970629930496, 0.004888927098363638, -0.006862908601760864, 0.0026459768414497375, 0.012975335121154785, -0.07098334282636642, -0.012348674237728119, 0.02326969802379608, 0.00014206150081008673, 0.025437310338020325, 0.018983466550707817, 0.019696569070219994, 0.006848637945950031, -0.015374978072941303, -0.011667019687592983, -0.02241562306880951, -0.005066900514066219, -0.01022156048566103, 0.016372734680771828, 0.019294140860438347, 0.029843036085367203, 0.015559698455035686, 0.058906927704811096, -0.010063983500003815, 0.005292531568557024, 0.025807812809944153, 0.035039547830820084, -0.03739997372031212, -0.012993806973099709, -0.011033592745661736, -0.0013737448025494814, -0.008855719119310379, 0.04128338396549225, 0.007203567307442427, 0.047965191304683685, -0.001693295780569315, 0.009775800630450249, -0.05422389134764671, -0.038675349205732346, -0.03679398447275162, -0.013611731119453907, 0.0029219877906143665, 0.026835868135094643, -0.015622698701918125, 0.05010754615068436, -0.009805207140743732, 0.03418801352381706, 0.03061983920633793, 0.024028804153203964, 0.03278033435344696, -0.01372444536536932, -0.01507076807320118, 0.0120429378002882, -0.03726941719651222, -0.004850207362323999, -0.0033086054027080536, 0.057716455310583115, 0.006940936204046011, -0.02477347105741501, -0.025463281199336052, -0.020563531666994095, 0.0025836112909018993, 0.040161971002817154, -0.06328637152910233, -0.02422594279050827, -0.06304540485143661, -0.019517486914992332, -0.027332520112395287, -0.03437713161110878 ]
<p>I am currently calculating reliability estimates for test-retest data.</p> <p>My question is regarding the difference between standard error of measurement (SEM) versus minimum detectable change (MDC) when seeking to determine if there is a 'real' difference between two measurements.</p> <p>Here is my thinking thus far:</p> <p>Each measurement has an error band about it. For two measurements, if error bands overlap then there is no 'real' difference between the measurements.</p> <ol> <li><p>For example, at 95% confidence, each measurement has an error band of $\pm 1.96 \times SEM$. So, two measurements would need to be more than $2 \times 1.96 \times SEM =3.92 \times SEM$ apart to avoid each measurement's confidence interval overlapping and for their to be a real difference between the two measurements.</p></li> <li><p>Another method for determining if two measurements are 'different' is to use MDC where </p></li> </ol> <p>$$MDC = 1.96 \times \sqrt{2} \times SEM =2.77 \times SEM$$</p> <p>[EDIT: for second formula see e.g. p. 238 of Weir, J. P. (2005). Quantifying test-retest reliability using the intraclass correlation coefficient and the SEM. Journal of strength and conditioning research / National Strength &amp; Conditioning Association, 19(1), 231–240. doi:10.1519/15184.1]</p> <p>If the difference between the two measurements is greater than MDC then there is a real difference between the measurements.</p> <p>Obviously the two formulas are different and would produce different results. So which formula is correct?</p>
73,925
[ -0.020936468616127968, -0.008925448171794415, -0.0289837084710598, -0.008977605029940605, 0.002502261893823743, 0.04075370728969574, -0.020837964490056038, -0.03645036369562149, 0.04225055128335953, 0.005141823086887598, 0.031446900218725204, 0.0018214946612715721, 0.044283427298069, 0.013986259698867798, 0.018703222274780273, -0.00019700049597304314, 0.004535268526524305, 0.009591315872967243, 0.035362858325242996, -0.019474009051918983, -0.016369549557566643, 0.004008503630757332, 0.03623406961560249, -0.0011410517618060112, -0.00571756437420845, 0.053736913949251175, 0.014918886125087738, -0.029448695480823517, -0.0012148255482316017, 0.047703295946121216, -0.03723160922527313, -0.019823454320430756, -0.008388631977140903, 0.028457004576921463, 0.028137942776083946, 0.011708036996424198, -0.0157083198428154, -0.041722383350133896, -0.008115457370877266, 0.04793880134820938, -0.03424644097685814, 0.009719752706587315, -0.005314542446285486, 0.05151311680674553, 0.007902279496192932, 0.018618717789649963, -0.04955879971385002, -0.011315072886645794, 0.03368356078863144, -0.016628507524728775, 0.0726572573184967, 0.00026580525445751846, 0.05896195396780968, 0.017151175066828728, -0.037709031254053116, -0.0012608853867277503, 0.04653196036815643, 0.068876713514328, 0.006890846882015467, -0.014049066230654716, -0.037733517587184906, -0.05044061690568924, -0.03072814829647541, -0.024527480825781822, -0.03448532521724701, 0.030973289161920547, -0.015458868816494942, -0.007729636039584875, 0.037689484655857086, -0.00047480352804996073, 0.0054296464659273624, 0.009623614139854908, 0.028733784332871437, -0.01392182894051075, 0.04432668164372444, -0.04983802139759064, 0.008348564617335796, 0.01780611462891102, 0.038435809314250946, 0.0637379065155983, -0.011124505661427975, -0.0012199011398479342, 0.04679805785417557, 0.04308399185538292, 0.031263016164302826, -0.05072484537959099, 0.08022631704807281, -0.009205223061144352, 0.015970798209309578, 0.020090384408831596, 0.0007684627780690789, 0.010564197786152363, 0.033948078751564026, -0.011391404084861279, -0.010701234452426434, 0.030408399179577827, -0.03190312907099724, 0.026963138952851295, -0.012304911389946938, -0.03077044151723385, 0.010558798909187317, -0.04020422324538231, 0.06406010687351227, 0.05824575945734978, 0.027279004454612732, -0.02317707985639572, 0.01147681474685669, 0.009507816284894943, 0.012882241047918797, -0.05830080062150955, 0.0006774342036806047, 0.012367232702672482, -0.01719680242240429, 0.03364257887005806, 0.038095783442258835, -0.011965101584792137, -0.022293277084827423, 0.006202046759426594, 0.051978811621665955, 0.055771563202142715, 0.0635034441947937, -0.029784945771098137, 0.0005310300621204078, -0.029982101172208786, -0.017904100939631462, 0.0348675362765789, 0.01384411659091711, -0.0021690872963517904, -0.02759421057999134, 0.02307470142841339, 0.022875316441059113, -0.0011581419967114925, 0.03265262767672539, 0.011517757549881935, -0.0003045410558115691, 0.02115212194621563, -0.09073559939861298, -0.036770619451999664, 0.0591006800532341, 0.001388957374729216, -0.0024728686548769474, -0.05716365575790405, -0.015520494431257248, 0.031223880127072334, 0.03105451539158821, 0.05156021565198898, 0.042182981967926025, -0.009489662945270538, 0.025272231549024582, 0.009534023702144623, -0.007591174449771643, -0.031722329556941986, -0.03154626488685608, -0.055990446358919144, -0.03331925347447395, -0.05794939026236534, -0.005556363612413406, 0.029144063591957092, -0.018440447747707367, -0.015107033774256706, 0.04913371056318283, -0.026311790570616722, -0.019814809784293175, -0.018532996997237206, 0.03329812362790108, 0.018771402537822723, 0.02889682911336422, -0.02116377279162407, -0.0012505508493632078, 0.01776791736483574, 0.01657247170805931, -0.03302028402686119, 0.03134305402636528, 0.0381949320435524, 0.04746692255139351, -0.002188724698498845, 0.000964854727499187, -0.014766170643270016, 0.014304849319159985, 0.02464168518781662, -0.06003159284591675, 0.008983311243355274, -0.02723560482263565, -0.016256431117653847, 0.047115784138441086, 0.052686918526887894, -0.011315836571156979, 0.011296187527477741, 0.030103053897619247, -0.008994616568088531, -0.038483645766973495, -0.05284206569194794, 0.046993814408779144, -0.008632346987724304, -0.018570618703961372, 0.029189473018050194, 0.004598864819854498, 0.03529443219304085, -0.018328774720430374, -0.031331829726696014, 0.0009766261791810393, 0.05370806157588959, 0.0307188481092453, -0.029244069010019302, 0.011674885638058186, 0.011530623771250248, 0.06511756032705307, -0.029519958421587944, 0.029391532763838768, -0.0411292165517807, -0.06111234053969383, 0.030416499823331833, -0.05092963948845863, 0.038530100136995316, -0.032555051147937775, -0.0407266728579998, 0.014313539490103722, -0.00783027708530426, -0.012346469797194004, 0.02919801138341427, -0.03214118257164955, 0.04291767627000809, 0.0199446864426136, 0.016301723197102547, 0.017669303342700005, 0.0019587045535445213, -0.012616780586540699, -0.0075332727283239365, -0.011301137506961823, -0.06065675616264343, -0.01475429255515337, -0.06087888777256012, 0.04270126298069954, 0.01557854562997818, -0.011052417568862438, 0.023610642179846764, 0.049690112471580505, -0.014339609071612358, -0.008095353841781616, 0.022388437762856483, 0.012706546112895012, -0.03618693724274635, 0.0031224836129695177, 0.0334489531815052, 0.003544782055541873, 0.014112801291048527, -0.02491595223546028, 0.027112288400530815, 0.04296531900763512, -0.009653429500758648, 0.046734679490327835, 0.03011450171470642, 0.004886945243924856, 0.022907204926013947, -0.005751614924520254, -0.027042392641305923, 0.06133589521050453, 0.018626563251018524, 0.008567947894334793, 0.06937143951654434, -0.006791326683014631, -0.009148956276476383, 0.008867898024618626, -0.017114661633968353, 0.03873724862933159, 0.01314966008067131, -0.009733526967465878, -0.02216196246445179, -0.0016692419303581119, -0.04802396148443222, 0.013345538638532162, -0.02681972086429596, -0.020717037841677666, -0.0017222686437889934, -0.014139787293970585, 0.03550805523991585, 0.028226472437381744, 0.0639522597193718, -0.03179340809583664, 0.004545983858406544, -0.007203391287475824, 0.0024947973433882, 0.06576193124055862, -0.032371554523706436, -0.031789667904376984, -0.009777774102985859, -0.03273100405931473, -0.030846554785966873, 0.0005840809899382293, -0.0005562073783949018, -0.027498558163642883, 0.03677763789892197, 0.0014247964136302471, -0.05895598232746124, -0.06116358935832977, -0.04130585491657257, -0.004997535143047571, 0.010565639473497868, -0.06766858696937561, 0.06137761101126671, -0.005986848380416632, -0.033020082861185074, 0.015608834102749825, 0.0035213150549679995, -0.024876875802874565, -0.010507225058972836, 0.013263651169836521, 0.01219747681170702, -0.045711830258369446, 0.012164284475147724, -0.002452746732160449, 0.0036529272329062223, 0.00024277952616102993, -0.08162019401788712, -0.06298820674419403, 0.004704230930656195, 0.004737718962132931, 0.026112064719200134, 0.009469905868172646, -0.002450682921335101, 0.07879486680030823, 0.026195015758275986, -0.005119230132550001, 0.003089267760515213, 0.028705380856990814, -0.004096774850040674, -0.03169691562652588, -0.00948276650160551, 0.0026147272437810898, 0.0015530947130173445, 0.0330510251224041, 0.006046926602721214, 0.00460267998278141, 0.07433031499385834, -0.006085609085857868, 0.04239660128951073, 0.019460733979940414, 0.03260999172925949, -0.050777923315763474, 0.050850994884967804, 0.006206884514540434, -0.03230264037847519, 0.0034211459569633007, 0.015099968761205673, -0.03128565102815628, -0.0071328976191580296, -0.05274219065904617, 0.03620973974466324, -0.009082192555069923, -0.007735166233032942, -0.019772255793213844, 0.02868093177676201, 0.04619540646672249, -0.056530583649873734, 0.0018772761104628444, 0.06490558385848999, 0.0003888504288624972, -0.017012346535921097, -0.010772139765322208, 0.06139875575900078, 0.052793409675359726, 0.021193617954850197, -0.04076283797621727, -0.026558181270956993, 0.015310845337808132, 0.03171351179480553, -0.028632264584302902, -0.04960274323821068, 0.026047026738524437, 0.030821247026324272, 0.012721126899123192, -0.020451337099075317, -0.019722260534763336, -0.03988417237997055, -0.0637827143073082, -0.024579934775829315, -0.015757912769913673, 0.054646093398332596, 0.023936321958899498, 0.01929968222975731, 0.0019699037075042725, -0.024208540096879005, 0.02670779451727867, 0.03376664221286774, -0.062287021428346634, 0.025080688297748566, -0.04495713487267494, -0.011198529042303562, 0.01481138076633215, -0.017663050442934036, 0.041333820670843124, -0.02190360613167286, 0.006315300706773996, -0.00014026353892404586, 0.03222290426492691, -0.02728349342942238, -0.007562567014247179, 0.002579387975856662, -0.010477917268872261, 0.027805110439658165, 0.02069198526442051, -0.0022502481006085873, -0.011391565203666687, 0.02122465893626213, 0.028937285766005516, -0.030035659670829773, 0.0018331329338252544, -0.064015693962574, 0.013165127485990524, -0.006711641326546669, 0.023711610585451126, 0.04335741326212883, 0.036175087094306946, -0.02085445076227188, 0.013815007172524929, 0.01324208453297615, 0.0006812086212448776, 0.03147687762975693, -0.03729990869760513, -0.024931173771619797, -0.03073681890964508, -0.018609296530485153, -0.009113763459026814, 0.053878407925367355, 0.027674240991473198, 0.016630588099360466, 0.05248698219656944, 0.003907397389411926, -0.05682260915637016, 0.0396064817905426, 0.029570413753390312, 0.004523922223597765, -0.004957688041031361, -0.060367994010448456, -0.028507262468338013, -0.01880752108991146, -0.030802519991993904, 0.058078352361917496, 0.021739710122346878, 0.04389912635087967, -0.03835250437259674, 0.03691627457737923, -0.012235711328685284, -0.02834463305771351, 0.02031611278653145, 0.010249334387481213, 0.01639224775135517, 0.01864679716527462, -0.014445026405155659, 0.005016856361180544, 0.029568184167146683, 0.06249724701046944, -0.01998717151582241, 0.01170716155320406, -0.06385616958141327, 0.0014844441320747137, 0.023233257234096527, 0.04775523021817207, -0.05941370502114296, -0.02112487703561783, -0.03850860893726349, -0.04203297197818756, 0.05073849856853485, -0.06681974232196808, 0.026026573032140732, 0.0055928099900484085, 0.014988771639764309, -0.04519304260611534, -0.0266089029610157, -0.06905903667211533, -0.0004751330998260528, -0.0023400690406560898, 0.024367447942495346, -0.006136226933449507, -0.009823104366660118, -0.025896824896335602, -0.024140378460288048, 0.0632198229432106, 0.06065317615866661, -0.05419651046395302, -0.005520347040146589, 0.014845105819404125, 0.01726456545293331, -0.02766423113644123, -0.06390444934368134, 0.007175640668720007, -0.008918709121644497, 0.0007638242095708847, 0.023619120940566063, 0.016981398686766624, -0.05408066138625145, 0.017424890771508217, 0.015541313216090202, -0.007512889336794615, -0.009222733788192272, 0.0064231320284307, 0.0780215933918953, 0.0558878630399704, 0.004759564064443111, 0.05025222525000572, -0.013885248452425003, 0.01730521395802498, 0.018263889476656914, -0.01962994784116745, 0.02554107829928398, -0.02373039908707142, -0.036716192960739136, -0.04903077706694603, 0.009494585916399956, -0.04674394056200981, 0.035663243383169174, -0.03495435044169426, 0.02722231112420559, -0.019844859838485718, -0.011936566792428493, -0.0006235559121705592, 0.012631140649318695, -0.020847881212830544, 0.0348726250231266, 0.028348783031105995, 0.022937634959816933, 0.010605190880596638, -0.003306084545329213, -0.004579334519803524, -0.029260123148560524, -0.015540610998868942, 0.009587780572474003, -0.0657518208026886, 0.022954192012548447, 0.002298729494214058, -0.01605658046901226, -0.015559187158942223, -0.006593022495508194, 0.002476205350831151, -0.022228673100471497, 0.016186334192752838, -0.014034639112651348, -0.040144383907318115, -0.020066583529114723, 0.007764667272567749, -0.0056662061251699924, 0.04220140725374222, -0.03773915022611618, 0.0007977391942404211, 0.020149560645222664, -0.012071232311427593, -0.07515320181846619, -0.05769410356879234, 0.01945146732032299, -0.0019610505551099777, 0.012983491644263268, -0.020788248628377914, 0.01897401735186577, 0.004441190045326948, -0.041547272354364395, -0.025203242897987366, 0.06367714703083038, -0.018231388181447983, -0.02554486133158207, -0.010496990755200386, 0.027844471856951714, 0.061554376035928726, -0.020372798666357994, 0.01156307477504015, -0.0033370566088706255, -0.017711693421006203, -0.03470122069120407, 0.03860204666852951, 0.01674913614988327, -0.023252926766872406, -0.015174993313848972, -0.04860232025384903, 0.005168830510228872, 0.06398159265518188, -0.011510672979056835, -0.007410612888634205, -0.01951626129448414, -0.007830759510397911, 0.022627901285886765, -0.017844244837760925, 0.042684465646743774, 0.018245423212647438, 0.040944576263427734, 0.008066431619226933, 0.028760267421603203, -0.028104035183787346, -0.0016862222691997886, 0.020137062296271324, -0.0026742310728877783, -0.041689757257699966, 0.007923205383121967, 0.08187215030193329, -0.018578970804810524, 0.0535527765750885, -0.008386999368667603, -0.04670783504843712, 0.03712278604507446, 0.020733576267957687, 0.028596021234989166, 0.0255393348634243, 0.011562839150428772, -0.05661318451166153, -0.021233053877949715, -0.027258340269327164, 0.022562118247151375, 0.06076622009277344, 0.011478382162749767, 0.04206589236855507, 0.039436224848032, 0.0008700252510607243, 0.03826073929667473, -0.009501626715064049, 0.007069953717291355, 0.005582546349614859, -0.018216675147414207, 0.07449620217084885, -0.055339712649583817, 0.0029527591541409492, 0.028427937999367714, 0.0017771886195987463, 0.003930441569536924, -0.022551925852894783, 0.0035662376321852207, 0.04362644627690315, 0.011109774932265282, -0.013241754844784737, -0.03799698129296303, 0.0340939499437809, -0.01199115626513958, -0.012022772803902626, -0.005138825625181198, 0.011521193198859692, 0.042878035455942154, 0.012897198088467121, -0.020999783650040627, -0.02096746861934662, -0.03611087426543236, -0.06968939304351807, -0.01978737860918045, -0.007756389211863279, -0.020503057166934013, -0.012800319120287895, -0.016963139176368713, 0.04187299683690071, -0.008336741477251053, 0.06307654082775116, -0.014649675227701664, -0.08350611478090286, -0.03676488995552063, -0.01063542254269123, -0.04504014179110527, 0.05534200370311737, -0.020330404862761497, -0.03055557981133461, 0.01628151163458824, -0.028841635212302208, 0.013174092397093773, 0.01942134089767933, 0.025308435782790184, -0.04041392728686333, 0.05803384631872177, -0.016477230936288834, 0.02809973806142807, -0.0022751784417778254, -0.02073482982814312, 0.08277077972888947, 0.03770065680146217, 0.04063022881746292, -0.03507755696773529, 0.030267424881458282, 0.014658564701676369, -0.000866649963427335, 0.0025999865029007196, 0.018875710666179657, 0.012342301197350025, -0.004550771322101355, 0.03477929159998894, 0.060916632413864136, 0.033910464495420456, -0.04103377088904381, 0.03804679214954376, -0.007689834572374821, -0.005855267867445946, 0.027367856353521347, 0.0031568054109811783, 0.03409051150083542, -0.03217455744743347, 0.029367297887802124, 0.02132531628012657, 0.0013519375352188945, -0.03320571780204773, -0.034622978419065475, -0.008173271082341671, 0.008716615848243237, -0.007181314751505852, -0.0406867191195488, 0.0069642565213143826, -0.017104612663388252, -0.0016277870163321495, -0.01695365644991398, 0.01447096187621355, -0.006654310040175915, -0.00555425975471735, 0.028099369257688522, 0.02538686990737915, 0.009608621709048748, -0.018036415800452232, 0.011331122368574142, 0.027687793597579002, -0.08298859000205994, -0.05791899561882019, -0.05603329837322235, 0.00701910862699151, -0.015218948014080524, -0.023829786106944084, -0.00000443344561062986, -0.05101035535335541, -0.01693800464272499, -0.0436253547668457, -0.03873312473297119, 0.024424225091934204, -0.005235368385910988, -0.045236121863126755, 0.0019269653130322695, -0.044971026480197906, 0.03321574628353119, 0.0005612517707049847, 0.013757314532995224, 0.025711005553603172, -0.017917843535542488, -0.0015046915505081415, 0.0006571430712938309, 0.04474165663123131, 0.015975646674633026, 0.011921918019652367, -0.019408080726861954, 0.004901269916445017, -0.05468432977795601, 0.013695663772523403, 0.005347511265426874, 0.010551819577813148, 0.04520207643508911, -0.0017195348627865314, -0.01743735745549202, -0.02606787346303463, -0.06770658493041992, -0.003982510417699814, -0.016824591904878616, 0.034439511597156525, -0.049605295062065125, -0.02003898099064827, 0.012524952180683613, -0.006352617871016264, 0.01637078821659088, 0.007452547550201416, 0.03733397275209427, 0.032450005412101746, 0.013484330847859383, -0.04141026735305786, 0.009199581108987331, 0.016391273587942123, -0.002756501315161586, -0.0004189607279840857, -0.002353489166125655, 0.053696710616350174, 0.02797061577439308, 0.026974650099873543, -0.010355857200920582, 0.013506096787750721, -0.0015934932744130492, -0.003130312543362379, 0.0075654760003089905, -0.027062706649303436, -0.014008533209562302, 0.013774052262306213, 0.024524908512830734, 0.000586933281738311, 0.009828165173530579, -0.051008742302656174, -0.03523027524352074, 0.007015247363597155, -0.019253775477409363, -0.03490620478987694, -0.039930183440446854, 0.00066133972723037, -0.020096048712730408, -0.029401199892163277, -0.030440794304013252, -0.025947773829102516, 0.015105320140719414, -0.006864230148494244, 0.016389744356274605, -0.02718585543334484, 0.03554660081863403, -0.04241297394037247, -0.019008388742804527, 0.06974466145038605, 0.004660183563828468, -0.019747737795114517, -0.01000005379319191, -0.016102252528071404, 0.034937936812639236, 0.02818959392607212, -0.003991809673607349, -0.02151966653764248, 0.0362706333398819, -0.025150587782263756, -0.02772679179906845, 0.05097294598817825, 0.00797213800251484, 0.00039465021109208465, 0.025178974494338036, -0.013379687443375587, 0.0030684098601341248, 0.01943114399909973, -0.014023675583302975, -0.028884638100862503, -0.022773737087845802, 0.019415654242038727, -0.0011468088487163186, -0.0051107038743793964, 0.03319256752729416, 0.005387740675359964, -0.015972495079040527, 0.03552916646003723, 0.032627660781145096, 0.013633452355861664, 0.008793382905423641, 0.014799879863858223, -0.01802823320031166, 0.012447641231119633, 0.034480981528759, -0.016053983941674232, 0.006180652882903814, 0.07990892976522446, -0.02476731687784195, -0.0012698700884357095, -0.008055937476456165, -0.010515004396438599, -0.06953386962413788, -0.03656468540430069, -0.011508670635521412, 0.04961521178483963, 0.027694758027791977, -0.055762600153684616, 0.010349172167479992, 0.009731482714414597, -0.0383625365793705, -0.01796891912817955, -0.05453255772590637, -0.00013089268759358674, -0.029200691729784012, 0.010075505822896957, -0.019847845658659935, 0.01877777650952339, 0.02782892994582653, 0.006936222780495882, -0.00923117808997631, 0.035549893975257874, -0.03195489943027496, -0.0016086602117866278, -0.025673966854810715, 0.022413676604628563, 0.03313367813825607, -0.07522311061620712, 0.02225610613822937, -0.006518812384456396, -0.04816114902496338, 0.041520293802022934, -0.03326348215341568, 0.02680095098912716, 0.021473975852131844, 0.03379392623901367, -0.017729241400957108, 0.02129041589796543, 0.014001679606735706, -0.04384542256593704, -0.04708811640739441, -0.0013265626039355993, 0.002617172198370099, 0.038676414638757706, -0.0433926023542881, -0.012460603378713131, 0.01334997545927763, -0.003630552440881729, -0.027714014053344727, 0.008701613172888756, -0.02842324785888195, -0.006969484034925699, -0.012068342417478561, -0.007786016911268234, 0.023077595978975296, -0.02046632207930088, 0.0007309764041565359, -0.05339273437857628, 0.013397028669714928, 0.053620096296072006, 0.04794028028845787, -0.03262802213430405, 0.03353255242109299, -0.0032956544309854507, -0.014131012372672558, 0.01865522749722004, -0.029589617624878883, -0.029206253588199615, -0.05725586786866188, -0.01182420551776886, -0.009221779182553291, -0.004815065301954746, -0.014601809903979301, -0.026304250583052635, -0.058303143829107285, 0.05317976325750351, -0.025253085419535637, 0.005401295144110918, 0.004135354422032833, -0.0005956538370810449, -0.017283102497458458, -0.1152162253856659, 0.0382671058177948, 0.027137182652950287, -0.0411372072994709, -0.028149439021945, -0.0008464943384751678, -0.01571075990796089, 0.007192751858383417, 0.0769079327583313, 0.030686018988490105, -0.0295135248452425, -0.0074675497598946095, 0.02492906153202057, 0.002411261200904846, -0.04712328314781189, 0.04886911064386368, -0.013837821781635284, -0.012350988574326038, 0.008740613237023354, 0.005697033833712339, 0.009318297728896141, 0.005127995740622282, 0.03019525669515133, -0.0372559055685997, 0.0459677055478096, -0.0034325814340263605, 0.01963711529970169, 0.026869475841522217, -0.011728682555258274, -0.024948203936219215, 0.054406531155109406, -0.02472108229994774, 0.028877418488264084, 0.022113369777798653, 0.005868405569344759, -0.04042091593146324, 0.01562061719596386, 0.006249162368476391, 0.0002466648875270039, 0.021263541653752327, 0.03182752802968025, -0.04117016866803169, -0.035487525165081024, 0.006144026294350624, 0.014111782424151897, -0.020135022699832916, -0.03279725834727287, 0.025859801098704338, 0.05096464976668358, 0.02404596097767353, 0.01744580827653408, 0.023690545931458473, 0.03387099876999855, -0.032566625624895096, 0.016990019008517265, 0.0064358096569776535, 0.039139147847890854, 0.011590773239731789, -0.012124473229050636, 0.048096708953380585, -0.03019237332046032, 0.0399564653635025, -0.004846935160458088, 0.06578981131315231, -0.024809550493955612, -0.03336005285382271, 0.04143518581986427, -0.04476519301533699, 0.02557803876698017, 0.029962336644530296, -0.012089742347598076, 0.06750833243131638, -0.039395105093717575, -0.012393388897180557, -0.019622892141342163, -0.014330346137285233, -0.023021986708045006, -0.019578974694013596, 0.056626301258802414, 0.014035612344741821, 0.019903041422367096, -0.01378227211534977, -0.018040768802165985, -0.013258203864097595, -0.005897187627851963, -0.023935234174132347, 0.016434671357274055, -0.01562844216823578, 0.0007293650414794683, -0.043274011462926865, -0.04806077852845192, -0.024996118620038033, -0.026947151869535446, 0.0006440135766752064, 0.0327073410153389, 0.05671924352645874, 0.012458397075533867, -0.04951724037528038, -0.022076481953263283, 0.06299742311239243, -0.07360479235649109, -0.017495131120085716, -0.03554312512278557, 0.017132243141531944, 0.01980006694793701, -0.014733053743839264 ]
<p>I need help in knowing which test to perform with this analysis. </p> <p>I have two groups (lets say group A and B). A study was performed with initial rates of heart failures in group A and B (i.e, baseline rates) were measured. After 6 months of follow up the heart failure rates in group A and B (i.e, re measurement rates) were measured again. By simple mathematics, I know that the improvement rate is better in group A as compared to group B. </p> <ul> <li>How do I test whether the difference in rates between the groups is statistically significant?</li> </ul> <p>I am using t-test for this but not sure how to go about it.</p>
73,926
[ -0.014375047758221626, -0.006834946572780609, -0.01426350325345993, -0.01861295849084854, 0.024498039856553078, 0.04317942634224892, 0.011601756326854229, -0.0175331924110651, 0.02037908509373665, 0.0018022848526015878, 0.06003018841147423, 0.01724342070519924, 0.03466461971402168, 0.0013948397245258093, -0.02057705819606781, -0.003747940296307206, -0.04695122316479683, -0.00698467344045639, -0.025294238701462746, 0.010701017454266548, 0.01308842096477747, -0.03518513962626457, -0.0029616497922688723, 0.013934929855167866, -0.028353918343782425, 0.03249495476484299, 0.040444642305374146, -0.032648470252752304, -0.008573520928621292, 0.0443064346909523, -0.04723932594060898, -0.021465938538312912, -0.0024493865203112364, -0.005600019823759794, 0.021863391622900963, 0.019556842744350433, -0.023743951693177223, -0.0049987053498625755, -0.0016911010025069118, 0.04891333729028702, -0.016062384471297264, -0.02574535273015499, -0.004948928486555815, 0.0452982522547245, -0.009316139854490757, 0.047115258872509, -0.022714409977197647, -0.022529371082782745, 0.011803564615547657, -0.035913754254579544, 0.040885135531425476, -0.01957578957080841, 0.0517895445227623, -0.00717265484854579, -0.015917273238301277, -0.052786167711019516, 0.03463420644402504, 0.06385397911071777, 0.008025662042200565, -0.026936283335089684, -0.014364534988999367, 0.00006698982178932056, -0.012776828370988369, -0.008231139741837978, -0.04951585829257965, 0.011752917431294918, -0.021197857335209846, -0.011507594957947731, 0.05330846458673477, -0.0002725324884522706, 0.00930281262844801, 0.007227522321045399, 0.039630256593227386, -0.026281213387846947, 0.03247753158211708, -0.03444364294409752, 0.005024717189371586, 0.011218092404305935, 0.05558547377586365, 0.04673250764608383, -0.009943201206624508, -0.023317845538258553, 0.03518844395875931, 0.07244132459163666, 0.02264721505343914, -0.026193754747509956, 0.026796145364642143, -0.013052893802523613, 0.02170497737824917, 0.02846033126115799, 0.003313327906653285, -0.010430287569761276, 0.040340982377529144, -0.007024099119007587, -0.050056152045726776, 0.0224304161965847, -0.009868702851235867, 0.04600090906023979, 0.025535695254802704, 0.0027557690627872944, -0.0019843527115881443, -0.09828696399927139, 0.03074081800878048, 0.04840688034892082, -0.0076688979752361774, 0.005701316520571709, -0.030963264405727386, -0.00382448872551322, -0.00006414904783014208, 0.014213754795491695, -0.052941955626010895, 0.001713131438009441, -0.003620537929236889, -0.019321508705615997, 0.019654126837849617, -0.01596982218325138, -0.025011533871293068, -0.017126942053437233, 0.0833931490778923, 0.04363454133272171, 0.06263575702905655, -0.016983160749077797, 0.016966024413704872, 0.0018894713139161468, -0.010732145048677921, 0.006348675116896629, 0.007039075717329979, -0.006567614618688822, -0.025746745988726616, 0.07128510624170303, 0.000053529969591181725, -0.0248605627566576, 0.030712556093931198, 0.018597373738884926, 0.03567524254322052, 0.00971516128629446, -0.08421285450458527, -0.04438532143831253, 0.060483209788799286, -0.007709473371505737, -0.0013760997680947185, -0.05412953346967697, 0.0018694818718358874, 0.022988472133874893, 0.0620027557015419, 0.03474276885390282, 0.02066863141953945, 0.017606167122721672, 0.029945503920316696, 0.026725199073553085, 0.0051582567393779755, -0.015892241150140762, -0.004943222273141146, -0.018100788816809654, 0.004034705460071564, -0.09381761401891708, -0.013241209089756012, -0.003000760218128562, -0.007923265919089317, -0.0066725644282996655, 0.03317047655582428, -0.007236367557197809, 0.002946644090116024, -0.018535293638706207, -0.0007918773335404694, 0.033918216824531555, 0.017822759225964546, -0.02110108733177185, -0.0019068146357312799, 0.025508856400847435, 0.0005071574705652893, 0.01566428877413273, 0.04705895856022835, 0.050077565014362335, 0.026942530646920204, -0.03420116752386093, 0.011890904046595097, -0.008255151100456715, 0.004988628439605236, 0.004361090715974569, -0.04767892509698868, -0.0431288406252861, -0.035117294639348984, 0.0008452086476609111, 0.04264511168003082, 0.03245711326599121, -0.006108382251113653, -0.003253050846979022, 0.05385061353445053, -0.02696990594267845, -0.04046856239438057, -0.07198140025138855, -0.004079168662428856, -0.006510300096124411, -0.044832028448581696, -0.014891044236719608, 0.004197302740067244, 0.03326338529586792, -0.030230974778532982, 0.010890998877584934, 0.005328116938471794, -0.011056371964514256, 0.018400805070996284, -0.04823923483490944, 0.02986317314207554, 0.03437420725822449, 0.06860581785440445, 0.008445441722869873, 0.04685990512371063, -0.0403728149831295, 0.0037334226071834564, -0.004159017466008663, -0.013368687592446804, 0.020867176353931427, 0.0038951414171606302, -0.03301844000816345, 0.020253464579582214, -0.012704686261713505, -0.036618687212467194, 0.007914552465081215, -0.07644503563642502, 0.09051045030355453, 0.035432178527116776, -0.01755422353744507, 0.025423536077141762, -0.017472321167588234, 0.013048743829131126, 0.03351174667477608, 0.0078427754342556, -0.001317668822593987, -0.050752587616443634, -0.013223495334386826, 0.04624737799167633, -0.00799697544425726, -0.013520170003175735, 0.03368787094950676, 0.07191820442676544, -0.034602656960487366, -0.004251806065440178, 0.049357589334249496, -0.012460106052458286, -0.047202929854393005, 0.006662556901574135, 0.049622077494859695, -0.0008680649916641414, -0.00857421476393938, 0.029307689517736435, -0.01897684670984745, 0.04304904490709305, -0.008529715240001678, 0.008889925666153431, 0.05017820745706558, 0.014611653983592987, 0.014976232312619686, -0.019702674821019173, -0.03620600700378418, 0.03127004951238632, -0.02345144934952259, 0.010733246803283691, 0.0040063695050776005, 0.017870768904685974, 0.012395475059747696, 0.0036028253380209208, -0.033954545855522156, 0.05822943150997162, 0.0014359981287270784, -0.0060026757419109344, 0.004291543271392584, 0.025523170828819275, -0.021799728274345398, -0.0001314877299591899, -0.03757143020629883, -0.029931092634797096, -0.029941432178020477, -0.046668168157339096, 0.026246463879942894, -0.00991382822394371, 0.04174784943461418, -0.014020907692611217, 0.002059407066553831, 0.017468586564064026, -0.0280897356569767, 0.04033542051911354, -0.007877524010837078, -0.005228726658970118, 0.005663590505719185, -0.010436651296913624, -0.02106543816626072, 0.007164451293647289, 0.007707667537033558, -0.01882321760058403, 0.05091569572687149, 0.04487035796046257, -0.07119356095790863, 0.0033492320217192173, -0.030199633911252022, 0.01945999078452587, -0.012053744867444038, -0.023006172850728035, 0.0533362552523613, -0.01965613104403019, -0.034961409866809845, 0.01820489950478077, -0.04177867993712425, 0.020362984389066696, -0.027543041855096817, -0.009665376506745815, 0.0022980589419603348, -0.008898510597646236, -0.00021080802252981812, -0.015384194441139698, -0.04986374452710152, -0.01055674534291029, -0.06300720572471619, -0.06288623809814453, 0.041902728378772736, -0.013321938924491405, 0.06079716980457306, -0.014079642482101917, -0.025699250400066376, 0.09468737244606018, 0.04769645631313324, 0.010419088415801525, -0.02913856878876686, 0.013343919068574905, -0.018648773431777954, -0.019100893288850784, 0.03524539992213249, 0.05564972385764122, -0.0029358905740082264, -0.01130814291536808, -0.01418107096105814, 0.020483676344156265, 0.07015575468540192, 0.018288929015398026, -0.01579882949590683, 0.018711907789111137, 0.040951721370220184, 0.020251940935850143, 0.05793400853872299, 0.01422839891165495, -0.03073955699801445, -0.007540026213973761, 0.00567963533103466, 0.008084715344011784, 0.0031105345115065575, -0.07083533704280853, 0.018898097798228264, 0.021310623735189438, -0.023350268602371216, -0.01887844130396843, 0.005850955378264189, 0.012713850475847721, -0.005210127215832472, 0.007872761227190495, 0.0028431392274796963, 0.017039287835359573, -0.007626883219927549, 0.011690107174217701, 0.038627613335847855, 0.045266058295965195, -0.013323361985385418, -0.017040802165865898, -0.04885217174887657, -0.008886465802788734, 0.03114362806081772, -0.03644249215722084, -0.038972269743680954, 0.010220106691122055, 0.03985761106014252, 0.04219641909003258, -0.0024725589901208878, -0.056905169039964676, -0.010765778832137585, -0.04161769896745682, -0.02700328268110752, -0.02483976073563099, 0.07411555200815201, -0.00519015546888113, 0.046616893261671066, 0.007307982537895441, -0.02026808261871338, -0.010915528982877731, -0.028930766507983208, -0.06559503078460693, 0.020355649292469025, -0.01695699617266655, -0.018370890989899635, 0.052691079676151276, -0.01406660582870245, -0.006556207779794931, -0.0033654426224529743, 0.014150705188512802, -0.0022107812110334635, 0.03165046498179436, -0.028082001954317093, 0.0028995696920901537, -0.028841538354754448, -0.0015400068368762732, -0.009731285274028778, -0.015951497480273247, 0.0050429655238986015, 0.009156306274235249, 0.029579097405076027, 0.03261832147836685, -0.004153389949351549, -0.004288054537028074, -0.01182621531188488, 0.00020537583623081446, 0.026948805898427963, 0.048604000359773636, 0.0378265306353569, 0.06247914209961891, -0.024533776566386223, 0.0035687508061528206, 0.024412190541625023, 0.014405288733541965, 0.023825135082006454, 0.01672685332596302, -0.018862202763557434, -0.018468137830495834, -0.026787424460053444, 0.006767965387552977, 0.03767002746462822, 0.015457801520824432, -0.035487182438373566, 0.008552078157663345, 0.01918671280145645, -0.03146698698401451, 0.00012081623572157696, 0.02903919480741024, 0.02373996376991272, -0.011486236937344074, -0.04498211666941643, -0.05800783261656761, -0.006340971682220697, -0.045318879187107086, 0.05063770338892937, 0.024738620966672897, -0.010686279274523258, -0.030464259907603264, 0.05970809981226921, 0.012756210751831532, -0.05834749713540077, -0.007369072642177343, -0.0076024834997951984, -0.009422493167221546, 0.035891093313694, -0.0353129617869854, 0.023551790043711662, 0.013422808609902859, 0.042941439896821976, 0.03659879416227341, 0.03314274922013283, -0.08382706344127655, -0.007527986541390419, 0.0477571114897728, 0.04310121014714241, -0.03509973734617233, -0.01477055810391903, -0.02599216066300869, 0.024348381906747818, 0.03488187864422798, -0.044954948127269745, -0.027115583419799805, -0.005575290881097317, 0.0012029209174215794, -0.050193190574645996, -0.029041318222880363, -0.041428253054618835, 0.02609529346227646, -0.007673077285289764, -0.0011491908226162195, 0.00968855805695057, -0.039991315454244614, -0.023268837481737137, -0.03256044164299965, 0.023322591558098793, 0.05033852532505989, -0.04396678879857063, -0.020358648151159286, 0.01814655214548111, 0.01240960881114006, -0.008326309733092785, -0.06321966648101807, 0.029517682269215584, -0.0027329104486852884, 0.035123519599437714, 0.02923898957669735, 0.003306812373921275, -0.05188862606883049, 0.030857816338539124, 0.014300975948572159, -0.04956243932247162, 0.0009142440394498408, -0.039931055158376694, 0.020582374185323715, 0.06237722560763359, 0.02137698419392109, 0.05290743708610535, 0.01471542939543724, 0.04855482652783394, 0.034445296972990036, -0.01125272735953331, 0.013740062713623047, -0.03405262902379036, -0.022703904658555984, -0.013349581509828568, -0.02823290228843689, 0.006084670778363943, 0.03294187784194946, 0.0032158938702195883, 0.0271979458630085, -0.00445776479318738, -0.00023606535978615284, 0.04643107205629349, -0.004271479789167643, -0.005254893098026514, 0.016155866906046867, 0.015993554145097733, -0.01947891339659691, 0.025954188778996468, -0.02007742039859295, 0.014327405020594597, -0.02833607792854309, 0.0141092324629426, 0.022321686148643494, -0.08142635971307755, -0.0028207851573824883, -0.03510475531220436, -0.03632192686200142, 0.006174765061587095, -0.011056109331548214, 0.029424404725432396, -0.03036399558186531, 0.046745941042900085, 0.00572566594928503, -0.006051213014870882, -0.015687434002757072, 0.038066476583480835, 0.017740657553076744, 0.0029675853438675404, -0.05282314494252205, 0.022625673562288284, 0.01930454559624195, -0.017524072900414467, -0.08310434967279434, -0.03427878022193909, 0.029182041063904762, 0.0019285886082798243, -0.01892143301665783, -0.035318609327077866, 0.02007671818137169, 0.0022163831163197756, -0.017898090183734894, -0.009570925496518612, 0.04916197061538696, -0.015715118497610092, -0.030135253444314003, -0.006691562011837959, 0.010045350529253483, 0.07669024914503098, -0.029260830953717232, -0.0019917611498385668, 0.011941647157073021, -0.015045658685266972, -0.020748626440763474, -0.026525704190135002, 0.010693447664380074, -0.048033636063337326, 0.012779352255165577, -0.03647272661328316, 0.015040014870464802, 0.036749646067619324, -0.02858605980873108, -0.027708932757377625, 0.027259593829512596, -0.04247059300541878, 0.03469480574131012, -0.04307526350021362, -0.01444660872220993, -0.02753099426627159, 0.02799997292459011, -0.02024894952774048, 0.013640849851071835, 0.023939935490489006, -0.02512545883655548, 0.009855284355580807, 0.03007143922150135, -0.029581774026155472, 0.005960074719041586, 0.06396595388650894, -0.007551198359578848, -0.008516822941601276, 0.00859568640589714, -0.03113015927374363, 0.0031759412959218025, 0.0029494797345250845, -0.01314065046608448, 0.013713383115828037, 0.004324179142713547, -0.04302285611629486, -0.021952256560325623, -0.03154357150197029, -0.014183279126882553, 0.04216829687356949, 0.0335562527179718, 0.041971076279878616, 0.06328412145376205, 0.01977361924946308, 0.016207678243517876, -0.009960361756384373, 0.018508723005652428, -0.024138636887073517, 0.010769320651888847, 0.035411372780799866, -0.004589886870235205, -0.005357842892408371, 0.05153002217411995, -0.0020868945866823196, 0.008851971477270126, 0.0547449104487896, 0.03173835948109627, 0.00677599897608161, 0.04876178875565529, -0.02519669383764267, -0.04507843777537346, 0.033526625484228134, -0.048928480595350266, 0.04186135157942772, -0.04938274249434471, -0.007650565821677446, 0.05295697599649429, 0.066403329372406, -0.02480260096490383, -0.03181760385632515, -0.011648041196167469, -0.08337006717920303, -0.014993027783930302, 0.02149146981537342, -0.02311774156987667, 0.05944061651825905, 0.04173864424228668, 0.033387284725904465, -0.012895442545413971, 0.036031324416399, -0.04590198025107384, -0.048631951212882996, -0.007491143885999918, 0.0065389275550842285, -0.031852465122938156, 0.02253604307770729, -0.009700908325612545, -0.051779575645923615, 0.0011103581637144089, -0.06877729296684265, 0.01412714459002018, 0.019236834719777107, 0.027375847101211548, -0.016801618039608, 0.08463940024375916, 0.02651195041835308, 0.032493624836206436, 0.04724863916635513, -0.004081874620169401, 0.09633520245552063, 0.045995380729436874, 0.030954809859395027, -0.05687449872493744, 0.04549844563007355, 0.01826746016740799, 0.026926470920443535, -0.017377197742462158, 0.0033765160478651524, 0.0001282515295315534, -0.015126102603971958, 0.06535971164703369, 0.03393285349011421, 0.013302290812134743, -0.024535831063985825, 0.05922535061836243, -0.025958744809031487, -0.026292936876416206, 0.019693661481142044, -0.02694484405219555, 0.0001416939339833334, -0.01652117632329464, -0.001704203663393855, 0.014406794682145119, 0.03085380047559738, -0.03345514088869095, -0.015103849582374096, 0.02382498048245907, -0.01901387609541416, 0.020302781835198402, -0.00539820734411478, 0.027662796899676323, -0.00807370524853468, 0.03034765087068081, -0.043640244752168655, -0.000617974903434515, -0.002614459488540888, -0.020595476031303406, 0.0048268516547977924, 0.025706354528665543, -0.0002353168383706361, -0.022438710555434227, 0.006508822087198496, 0.04460027068853378, -0.06808889657258987, -0.01904456876218319, -0.036730580031871796, 0.05250542238354683, -0.01829652301967144, -0.011331413872539997, -0.021996119990944862, 0.0029425579123198986, -0.001688129035755992, -0.0368923544883728, -0.004810177255421877, 0.012798851355910301, -0.02984512224793434, -0.031161950901150703, -0.0014811544679105282, -0.00981875415891409, 0.013129658065736294, -0.023790795356035233, 0.019489342346787453, 0.03839497268199921, -0.010561407543718815, -0.030760277062654495, -0.03145743906497955, 0.0009938221191987395, -0.004479626193642616, 0.016405660659074783, 0.021375222131609917, 0.00437487568706274, 0.005336180329322815, 0.016337284818291664, -0.011711543425917625, 0.03433776646852493, 0.023351196199655533, 0.03791717067360878, -0.024157682433724403, -0.006540501955896616, -0.050766754895448685, 0.03052089363336563, -0.013606286607682705, 0.0015197463799268007, -0.058630555868148804, -0.03180165961384773, 0.011037243530154228, 0.025979164987802505, 0.02928181365132332, 0.025634819641709328, 0.027560923248529434, 0.031445007771253586, 0.03414813429117203, -0.05292203649878502, -0.005898761563003063, -0.005536817945539951, -0.010053952224552631, -0.01794523186981678, -0.0400395505130291, 0.03599850833415985, 0.04539243131875992, 0.004135154653340578, -0.01302009355276823, 0.0035325561184436083, -0.027933185920119286, -0.0040489728562533855, -0.021300598978996277, -0.048644859343767166, -0.00584307499229908, -0.01487029530107975, 0.029972421005368233, 0.010996069759130478, 0.016113020479679108, -0.0006638871855102479, -0.0057611349038779736, 0.03601658344268799, -0.040602944791316986, 0.009136170148849487, -0.0011545709567144513, -0.011557385325431824, 0.019687367603182793, -0.048709601163864136, 0.006797244306653738, -0.03865441307425499, -0.048958227038383484, 0.01351912971585989, 0.03155239298939705, -0.04096242040395737, 0.02112743631005287, -0.004000771790742874, 0.0163874514400959, 0.0425286628305912, -0.01672264002263546, 0.023436393588781357, 0.024005120620131493, 0.02404118701815605, -0.01764676719903946, 0.040583785623311996, 0.00875807460397482, -0.017586687579751015, 0.04772695153951645, -0.034610725939273834, 0.013419781811535358, -0.005826924927532673, 0.030570145696401596, 0.006145384628325701, 0.007187054958194494, 0.0023160164710134268, -0.0003571758861653507, 0.04295072332024574, -0.04549415782094002, -0.05313858389854431, -0.041224271059036255, -0.022350629791617393, -0.0031016566790640354, -0.021536901593208313, 0.017359944060444832, -0.005333877168595791, 0.008408301509916782, -0.0010106581030413508, 0.032720502465963364, -0.022132841870188713, -0.015128940343856812, -0.004928938113152981, -0.00145942741073668, 0.013090332970023155, 0.0031959014013409615, -0.018660560250282288, 0.046205706894397736, 0.06114299222826958, 0.01219730731099844, -0.0004914854071103036, -0.04019888862967491, 0.007323506288230419, -0.08802742511034012, -0.024499356746673584, -0.023678643628954887, 0.009472097270190716, 0.04161950200796127, -0.049894094467163086, 0.0095840934664011, 0.028308548033237457, -0.027916384860873222, 0.04234629124403, 0.002515363972634077, -0.0024134605191648006, -0.054796140640974045, 0.03381475806236267, -0.008183855563402176, 0.016142388805747032, 0.00417064456269145, 0.03028346225619316, 0.015907444059848785, 0.06377139687538147, -0.008782380260527134, 0.00042923560249619186, 0.0014060750836506486, 0.018837520852684975, 0.019444987177848816, -0.06683734804391861, -0.0058105215430259705, -0.03957535699009895, -0.0461612343788147, 0.0030090869404375553, -0.0002999721618834883, 0.06252604722976685, 0.004936811979860067, 0.021024925634264946, 0.01640998013317585, 0.038713447749614716, 0.03376748040318489, -0.008462488651275635, -0.018484441563487053, -0.036574918776750565, 0.00990506261587143, 0.026752037927508354, -0.02227121964097023, -0.002605605171993375, 0.06684809923171997, -0.011952931992709637, -0.013540828600525856, -0.011202085763216019, -0.020573189482092857, -0.03592052683234215, 0.0201900415122509, -0.04456234350800514, 0.03710084781050682, -0.015438300557434559, -0.0330597460269928, -0.02014472335577011, 0.007383910473436117, 0.04783071205019951, 0.0059877135790884495, -0.054459862411022186, 0.02883080393075943, -0.026645176112651825, -0.01918879710137844, 0.014339854940772057, -0.015172163024544716, 0.0020640697330236435, -0.07623254507780075, -0.0010894933948293328, -0.0203403253108263, 0.015463917516171932, -0.0589183047413826, 0.0009044634643942118, -0.022838886827230453, 0.020484261214733124, 0.004021621309220791, 0.01776997372508049, 0.029951196163892746, 0.008705600164830685, 0.017617955803871155, -0.09780928492546082, 0.05854589119553566, 0.0019128257408738136, -0.025956138968467712, -0.02988320216536522, -0.019516203552484512, -0.07069258391857147, 0.021666504442691803, 0.07581998407840729, 0.030602531507611275, 0.02695324644446373, -0.017765959724783897, 0.02275131456553936, 0.029390592128038406, -0.05823320895433426, 0.0573449432849884, -0.015855984762310982, -0.03048071451485157, 0.005785970948636532, 0.01685166358947754, 0.021658100187778473, -0.01791340671479702, 0.0247186291962862, -0.03383038192987442, 0.016613321378827095, 0.011126106604933739, -0.027490774169564247, 0.024210480973124504, 0.012607025913894176, -0.056448694318532944, 0.05489129200577736, -0.015239298343658447, 0.040307365357875824, 0.034380536526441574, -0.01639091596007347, -0.04710380360484123, 0.06641948968172073, -0.03008822724223137, -0.010648127645254135, 0.01222002599388361, -0.020953385159373283, -0.02423213981091976, -0.07091313600540161, -0.003328720573335886, 0.008745907805860043, -0.04211179167032242, 0.033473677933216095, 0.05191908776760101, 0.028555050492286682, 0.011622321791946888, -0.048225387930870056, 0.017170196399092674, -0.0065587288700044155, -0.007262106519192457, -0.012647164054214954, -0.006778105162084103, -0.000833849364425987, -0.02000335603952408, 0.0037011723034083843, 0.008756283670663834, -0.038721926510334015, 0.025361696258187294, -0.008259212598204613, 0.004640243016183376, -0.04519087076187134, -0.00010691216448321939, 0.0002673375129234046, -0.029760878533124924, -0.00192641734611243, 0.03281937539577484, 0.01888168416917324, 0.06486879289150238, -0.04790021479129791, -0.004470676649361849, -0.014014020562171936, -0.005694132763892412, -0.05041266605257988, 0.013155719265341759, 0.056442566215991974, -0.0008496068767271936, 0.01443988736718893, 0.030049340799450874, -0.0060943737626075745, -0.018840104341506958, -0.015142792835831642, -0.01493599358946085, 0.06195112690329552, -0.03839835897088051, -0.044808343052864075, -0.024644246324896812, 0.0014670577365905046, -0.049399591982364655, -0.018495306372642517, 0.0018325743731111288, 0.042018432170152664, 0.0315561406314373, 0.007401448208838701, -0.023186612874269485, 0.024928690865635872, 0.03033110871911049, -0.051677390933036804, -0.03273683041334152, -0.0693308562040329, -0.020802706480026245, -0.009418576024472713, -0.03890286386013031 ]
<p>This is a more general treatment of the issue posed by <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/104875/question-about-standard-deviation-and-central-limit-theorem">this question</a>. After deriving the asymptotic distribution of the sample variance, we can apply the Delta method to arrive at the corresponding distribution for the standard deviation. </p> <p>Let a sample of size $n$ of i.i.d. <strong>non-normal</strong> random variables $\{X_i\},\;\; i=1,...,n$, with mean $\mu$ and variance $\sigma^2$. Set the sample mean and the sample variance as $$\bar x = \frac 1n \sum_{i=1}^nX_i,\;\;\; s^2 = \frac 1{n-1} \sum_{i=1}^n(X_i-\bar x)^2$$</p> <p>We know that $$E(s^2) = \sigma^2, \;\;\; \operatorname {Var}(s^2) = \frac{1}{n} \left(\mu_4 - \frac{n-3}{n-1}\sigma^4\right)$$</p> <p>where $\mu_4 = E(X_i -\mu)^4$, and we restrict our attention to distributions for which what moments need to exist and be finite, do exist and are finite.</p> <p>Does it hold that</p> <p>$$\sqrt n(s^2 - \sigma^2) \rightarrow_d N\left(0,\mu_4 - \sigma^4\right)\;\; ?$$</p>
73,927
[ -0.028528129681944847, -0.03221394866704941, 0.020059073343873024, -0.008639813400804996, 0.027025440707802773, 0.04004387557506561, -0.0024702022783458233, -0.02372008189558983, 0.01312301866710186, -0.03612888976931572, 0.038279514759778976, 0.012808033265173435, 0.07960569858551025, 0.0323234498500824, 0.022784337401390076, -0.008802901022136211, -0.025947846472263336, -0.016673410311341286, -0.02996654435992241, -0.027431871742010117, 0.015362427569925785, 0.02899455465376377, 0.0019312762888148427, -0.011152626946568489, -0.09263728559017181, -0.01853104494512081, 0.007306936662644148, -0.006979861296713352, -0.005476830061525106, 0.0722186341881752, -0.06301494687795639, -0.002852855483070016, 0.024552276358008385, 0.049552205950021744, -0.0032604625448584557, -0.00021833216305822134, -0.02192162163555622, -0.021020352840423584, 0.01564081571996212, 0.023369062691926956, -0.058432336896657944, 0.0009993243729695678, 0.006043187342584133, 0.0006670152652077377, -0.006737570744007826, 0.013400002382695675, -0.03012176975607872, -0.054081473499536514, 0.03736230731010437, -0.0403452068567276, 0.12047341465950012, -0.007547724060714245, 0.04063577950000763, 0.007974046282470226, -0.013030251488089561, -0.023818351328372955, 0.02494923770427704, 0.05958331376314163, 0.01648596115410328, -0.06650804728269577, -0.007546132430434227, -0.010624680668115616, 0.02981419488787651, -0.031110430136322975, -0.009226747788488865, -0.020255567505955696, 0.015677200630307198, -0.03430192917585373, 0.014833575114607811, -0.03979068994522095, 0.007181115914136171, 0.042294941842556, 0.030292382463812828, 0.04068516567349434, 0.004203153308480978, 0.019732171669602394, 0.005920985247939825, -0.002351430943235755, 0.05938594415783882, 0.029058050364255905, 0.0067986310459673405, 0.0010516883339732885, 0.043142303824424744, 0.02162185311317444, 0.01593213528394699, -0.011602263897657394, 0.07865042984485626, 0.0064712222665548325, 0.0397675521671772, 0.01468037161976099, -0.005724332295358181, -0.011879749596118927, 0.065363809466362, -0.05156606808304787, -0.06749969720840454, 0.05951042100787163, -0.028785236179828644, 0.048228707164525986, 0.0010195119539275765, 0.0024398420937359333, -0.011653021909296513, -0.048504289239645004, 0.037065472453832626, 0.038196202367544174, -0.01785319484770298, -0.009073387831449509, -0.035824526101350784, 0.03487423062324524, -0.011180820874869823, -0.0027322382666170597, -0.022426964715123177, 0.034118909388780594, -0.008569438010454178, -0.012851491570472717, 0.012453260831534863, -0.006671608425676823, -0.015966063365340233, 0.0008316098246723413, 0.022635942324995995, 0.05214604735374451, 0.014817130751907825, -0.011840146034955978, 0.012275888584554195, -0.03178480267524719, -0.04948427528142929, 0.04590366780757904, 0.025483788922429085, -0.016480308026075363, -0.05615830421447754, 0.02200671099126339, 0.001781682251021266, 0.02530856803059578, 0.01517561636865139, 0.035611025989055634, 0.012985095381736755, -0.0039822133257985115, -0.08453749120235443, -0.06825071573257446, 0.07116765528917313, -0.04258078336715698, -0.009309018962085247, -0.10257381945848465, 0.0024418572429567575, 0.051949307322502136, 0.03521062433719635, -0.008497575297951698, 0.05467021092772484, -0.0003084307536482811, 0.030386580154299736, 0.03971436619758606, -0.04749320447444916, 0.006100035738199949, -0.042350850999355316, -0.015753136947751045, -0.016671108081936836, -0.046905212104320526, 0.023362988606095314, 0.015807747840881348, 0.0069693829864263535, -0.008871018886566162, 0.026093672960996628, 0.011323188431560993, 0.011643458157777786, -0.017975766211748123, 0.03510699421167374, -0.02244734950363636, 0.06738775968551636, 0.034524060785770416, 0.017881764099001884, 0.008428669534623623, -0.008935960941016674, 0.00738557567819953, -0.023030949756503105, 0.0387442372739315, 0.049514755606651306, -0.04737046733498573, -0.02517300471663475, -0.034542668610811234, 0.007486727088689804, 0.008023344911634922, -0.04196497052907944, 0.03424844890832901, -0.02342827245593071, 0.0008750227862037718, 0.020357782021164894, 0.03608252480626106, 0.034174226224422455, -0.011828114278614521, 0.018163589760661125, -0.0555628277361393, -0.01551353745162487, -0.07669565826654434, 0.012996428646147251, 0.0031183953396975994, -0.05628969520330429, -0.00002863301597244572, -0.016050703823566437, 0.026559479534626007, -0.0055565726943314075, -0.02034568414092064, -0.011281713843345642, 0.026644304394721985, 0.036134444177150726, -0.03387868404388428, 0.0034317709505558014, 0.07176610827445984, 0.056107450276613235, -0.029003890231251717, 0.013500467874109745, -0.012207066640257835, -0.08999329805374146, -0.00022352066298481077, -0.029157575219869614, 0.034663207828998566, 0.02505609579384327, 0.0045383041724562645, 0.011483421549201012, -0.024784091860055923, 0.007334962487220764, 0.03791434317827225, -0.042869944125413895, 0.05950409546494484, 0.04778790473937988, 0.018841002136468887, 0.030902354046702385, 0.018288245424628258, 0.05295112729072571, -0.011159960180521011, -0.03789179027080536, 0.018291769549250603, -0.026075098663568497, 0.002505130134522915, 0.011264032684266567, 0.06969301402568817, -0.03467031940817833, 0.01110667735338211, 0.04090685769915581, 0.0183608029037714, 0.015105966478586197, -0.0027248477563261986, -0.003211844014003873, -0.02241891250014305, -0.028428051620721817, -0.020019255578517914, 0.015826594084501266, 0.0342780202627182, -0.03816220909357071, -0.0015320520615205169, 0.012874608859419823, 0.008804121054708958, 0.0054581924341619015, 0.045264165848493576, -0.018017245456576347, 0.002827864373102784, -0.013712933287024498, -0.011269580572843552, 0.031463030725717545, 0.0006322437548078597, -0.03773406147956848, 0.05345376208424568, -0.012949589639902115, 0.0009829759364947677, -0.00006544175266753882, -0.03930189087986946, 0.05158510431647301, -0.0005016612121835351, -0.009978477843105793, -0.0049034105613827705, 0.018559614196419716, -0.010026025585830212, 0.006296470761299133, -0.032987989485263824, -0.03165076673030853, 0.006585504859685898, 0.02165931649506092, 0.0005517661920748651, -0.01751534640789032, 0.0008903694688342512, 0.011074140667915344, -0.026537766680121422, 0.018384085968136787, 0.029000043869018555, -0.02138105221092701, 0.008177191019058228, -0.043225642293691635, -0.01805328205227852, -0.017953738570213318, -0.0025711534544825554, 0.027339864522218704, 0.018518028780817986, 0.008280294016003609, 0.047058697789907455, 0.01605890691280365, -0.013453223742544651, 0.008508351631462574, 0.003594442969188094, -0.016522040590643883, -0.025947950780391693, -0.03122393600642681, 0.03170168027281761, -0.021131135523319244, -0.010381210595369339, 0.05984757840633392, -0.03800436481833458, -0.06877098232507706, -0.045211099088191986, 0.035381946712732315, 0.07023553550243378, 0.002594425342977047, 0.028251010924577713, 0.0291631817817688, 0.01699645444750786, -0.019351767376065254, -0.04254838824272156, -0.05426555499434471, 0.007660556118935347, -0.022608311846852303, 0.020693620666861534, 0.011478555388748646, -0.05031409114599228, 0.07470361888408661, 0.014615606516599655, 0.0038106159772723913, 0.010321568697690964, -0.014234017580747604, -0.004529418423771858, -0.02918815426528454, 0.020562509074807167, -0.024481546133756638, -0.01433147955685854, 0.016471704468131065, 0.010843552649021149, 0.008844832889735699, 0.01961635798215866, 0.008574639447033405, -0.016898315399885178, 0.0014964317670091987, -0.025546465069055557, -0.007016239687800407, 0.04883183166384697, 0.01604018732905388, 0.010247319005429745, -0.016887569800019264, 0.03609541431069374, 0.041289668530225754, 0.008552639745175838, -0.03071080707013607, 0.030686531215906143, -0.0347597636282444, 0.013546117581427097, -0.03879670053720474, 0.07511516660451889, 0.020086267963051796, -0.058482516556978226, -0.014910302124917507, 0.00715896300971508, 0.017235226929187775, 0.008542225696146488, 0.03027106635272503, 0.059836018830537796, 0.03617822751402855, -0.01211472786962986, -0.025483952835202217, -0.029008671641349792, -0.009674650616943836, 0.013912987895309925, -0.046763040125370026, 0.0025412726681679487, 0.02996048703789711, 0.051080603152513504, 0.02485390566289425, -0.03740236535668373, -0.03462829068303108, -0.03152765706181526, -0.058122023940086365, 0.01961817964911461, -0.04844984412193298, 0.03510226681828499, 0.010996702127158642, 0.0540652722120285, 0.003623341675847769, -0.029642939567565918, 0.005531823728233576, -0.0048309084959328175, -0.06553905457258224, 0.0026645194739103317, -0.038543932139873505, -0.0024526603519916534, -0.015563110820949078, 0.0007638263050466776, 0.041753094643354416, 0.004236083477735519, 0.031053265556693077, -0.010480822995305061, -0.003409687429666519, -0.029844708740711212, -0.011446239426732063, -0.037984877824783325, -0.02853248082101345, -0.021260423585772514, 0.0501769594848156, 0.02170640043914318, -0.01919621229171753, -0.002464338904246688, 0.0352439247071743, -0.02204536274075508, -0.007391396444290876, -0.04000011086463928, 0.006384700071066618, -0.029195955023169518, 0.048062510788440704, 0.01551122311502695, -0.0029552835039794445, -0.034076835960149765, 0.0041281734593212605, 0.03659602627158165, 0.04257132112979889, 0.026010112836956978, 0.030118608847260475, -0.0011238917941227555, -0.03793598711490631, -0.010081854648888111, 0.014802252873778343, 0.02340414747595787, 0.019916465505957603, 0.013745685108006, 0.0637964978814125, 0.005983952898532152, -0.05467095226049423, 0.033605847507715225, 0.05345917120575905, 0.009115542285144329, -0.019350554794073105, -0.031977634876966476, -0.016884805634617805, -0.034240055829286575, -0.001149550313130021, 0.01466695312410593, 0.015983007848262787, 0.003816164331510663, 0.0015813324134796858, 0.03466574847698212, 0.025454752147197723, -0.00018060248112306, -0.0011660692980512977, 0.023604977875947952, 0.02541550062596798, -0.004756058566272259, -0.020838597789406776, 0.011305958032608032, 0.030380265787243843, 0.07527416944503784, -0.005013636313378811, -0.0102143045514822, -0.05402683466672897, 0.0024190638214349747, 0.03177982196211815, 0.058773841708898544, 0.0018957337597385049, 0.0036784184630960226, -0.013841617852449417, -0.008715418167412281, 0.0021938609424978495, -0.05134083330631256, 0.04126158356666565, -0.01911611109972, -0.0006740315584465861, -0.013120288029313087, -0.05836641415953636, -0.03832916542887688, 0.017663994804024696, 0.011715133674442768, 0.027255002409219742, -0.011670975014567375, -0.02338302880525589, -0.05927843227982521, -0.004973472561687231, 0.04760870337486267, 0.0837806835770607, -0.022664913907647133, -0.013825822621583939, -0.012807353399693966, 0.06277645379304886, -0.0375652089715004, -0.05327041819691658, 0.05060400068759918, -0.0025303438305854797, -0.04511663690209389, 0.019224535673856735, -0.04603603854775429, -0.07311239838600159, 0.027287496253848076, 0.009882915765047073, -0.037275031208992004, 0.010232575237751007, 0.01172496099025011, 0.01836627535521984, 0.03346511349081993, 0.04441147670149803, 0.08032482862472534, 0.022471047937870026, 0.005053929518908262, -0.011822838336229324, -0.041454464197158813, 0.001142541877925396, -0.005982847884297371, -0.02640458196401596, -0.014225862920284271, -0.01630304753780365, -0.012420880608260632, 0.027322053909301758, -0.010231215506792068, 0.054870616644620895, -0.03933148458600044, -0.02490534633398056, -0.003390800440683961, 0.023037675768136978, 0.034821271896362305, 0.004595687612891197, 0.006319544278085232, -0.004438512958586216, 0.032763563096523285, 0.0021920371800661087, 0.02717432752251625, -0.011549786664545536, 0.000900884042493999, 0.01569657400250435, -0.03519434481859207, 0.012748061679303646, -0.047136154025793076, -0.045143794268369675, -0.020182011649012566, -0.017017072066664696, 0.024961339309811592, 0.0016004872741177678, 0.02005511149764061, 0.03443930298089981, -0.021593241021037102, -0.010567906312644482, 0.021771760657429695, 0.010531243868172169, 0.023425228893756866, -0.03179655224084854, -0.0014494924107566476, 0.04289218410849571, 0.009054400026798248, -0.10108914971351624, -0.015886269509792328, -0.009109416045248508, 0.003046749858185649, 0.012493744492530823, -0.029146289452910423, -0.050365105271339417, -0.02287299558520317, -0.03357243537902832, -0.04005732759833336, 0.03658617287874222, 0.01513117365539074, -0.03850868344306946, -0.01634102314710617, 0.04502938687801361, 0.05753249675035477, -0.026701468974351883, -0.015315939672291279, 0.013655567541718483, -0.00024249422131106257, -0.003194366116076708, -0.011061291210353374, 0.029398009181022644, -0.028122002258896828, -0.0013008395908400416, 0.008059032261371613, -0.04555284231901169, 0.029491083696484566, -0.003872346831485629, -0.02533719129860401, 0.0081173712387681, 0.012734794057905674, 0.010537506081163883, -0.01755966991186142, -0.037246935069561005, 0.006724715232849121, 0.036342743784189224, -0.011979463510215282, -0.019604608416557312, -0.006009806413203478, 0.028947554528713226, 0.032334864139556885, 0.0059106298722326756, 0.011727336794137955, 0.0314454548060894, 0.07044778764247894, 0.014786183834075928, 0.00573207950219512, -0.01659650355577469, 0.021394528448581696, 0.029996216297149658, 0.0422121025621891, -0.0011511534685268998, -0.005015557166188955, -0.009307686239480972, -0.005262317135930061, -0.02908235974609852, -0.002827543532475829, 0.029462924227118492, 0.03985969349741936, -0.015950508415699005, -0.008173595182597637, 0.03207609802484512, 0.00264754774980247, -0.022530633956193924, -0.039135903120040894, 0.02093534544110298, -0.007979461923241615, -0.020192278549075127, 0.03509631007909775, -0.010862826369702816, -0.007284990977495909, 0.031080085784196854, 0.014551959000527859, -0.027643540874123573, 0.025469442829489708, 0.01779763400554657, -0.013050846755504608, 0.007485993672162294, -0.06606494635343552, -0.027617696672677994, 0.05561861768364906, -0.06391531974077225, 0.010412078350782394, -0.003865135833621025, -0.015191467478871346, 0.013928988948464394, 0.001654133666306734, 0.0028808224014937878, -0.027721760794520378, 0.016157152131199837, -0.01647523231804371, -0.011128745973110199, 0.02024815045297146, -0.029427194967865944, 0.014352497644722462, -0.00354195898398757, -0.007730478420853615, -0.015972303226590157, 0.04260655492544174, -0.05070235952734947, -0.07818909734487534, -0.013013094663619995, -0.006429014727473259, -0.048782315105199814, 0.07756532728672028, 0.0008179298602044582, -0.025021251291036606, -0.018669527024030685, -0.05351797863841057, 0.034742143005132675, -0.005529791582375765, 0.01455814391374588, -0.03654230013489723, 0.05603019520640373, 0.010921696200966835, 0.020660271868109703, -0.013605717569589615, 0.004347548820078373, 0.1130182147026062, 0.06824972480535507, 0.010131468065083027, -0.02778608724474907, 0.012229462154209614, -0.039067573845386505, 0.006309807766228914, 0.009881814941763878, -0.016885757446289062, -0.012182207778096199, -0.0056500681675970554, 0.005957358051091433, 0.06168998032808304, 0.012446734122931957, -0.003795338561758399, 0.020231885835528374, -0.029744815081357956, -0.017109205946326256, -0.020180080085992813, 0.016568664461374283, -0.02253919281065464, -0.023090245202183723, -0.05831379443407059, 0.02547498047351837, -0.00797671265900135, -0.0017543211579322815, -0.030029309913516045, 0.0027863781433552504, -0.0008343330700881779, -0.026650043204426765, -0.02763744629919529, -0.012788633815944195, 0.027093403041362762, -0.03450971096754074, -0.004344811197370291, -0.04083841294050217, 0.011412237770855427, -0.037955187261104584, 0.037449609488248825, 0.06508995592594147, -0.012654079124331474, 0.0010003591887652874, 0.052185479551553726, 0.03573649749159813, -0.03471773490309715, -0.050509609282016754, -0.023537520319223404, 0.02857350744307041, -0.02735402062535286, 0.00734160328283906, 0.015347211621701717, -0.020033039152622223, 0.001506550470367074, -0.01644454337656498, -0.01628868095576763, 0.0028793138917535543, 0.048955708742141724, -0.04429721087217331, -0.014837829396128654, -0.001290441257879138, 0.0276920348405838, -0.014042705297470093, 0.01890227198600769, -0.0010172080947086215, -0.022002851590514183, -0.05448396876454353, -0.0008412291062995791, 0.0072764805518090725, 0.014170723035931587, -0.003987045027315617, -0.0030347236897796392, -0.01957794278860092, -0.04204665869474411, 0.01749875582754612, 0.01455012708902359, -0.013179673813283443, 0.05080871656537056, -0.00925534125417471, 0.01803533174097538, 0.02006707154214382, -0.02573246695101261, -0.010480457916855812, -0.04018470272421837, 0.019772613421082497, -0.027992697432637215, -0.020302800461649895, 0.025305813178420067, 0.029592735692858696, -0.007863583043217659, -0.000956144358497113, 0.019917219877243042, 0.08851171284914017, 0.01520507875829935, -0.05252416431903839, -0.02942802757024765, 0.00417244341224432, -0.01176830567419529, 0.0285912174731493, -0.007052979897707701, 0.015696832910180092, 0.01578751765191555, 0.03941519930958748, 0.0002375401381868869, 0.05984767526388168, -0.02788710966706276, 0.013811192475259304, 0.056642383337020874, -0.05961286276578903, -0.015789300203323364, 0.05301210656762123, 0.018881918862462044, -0.010122025385499, -0.0148119255900383, -0.02358674630522728, -0.010786996223032475, -0.012251215986907482, -0.0039294008165597916, -0.04171835631132126, 0.0019374657422304153, -0.028895605355501175, -0.002958636963739991, -0.02469363994896412, -0.006678456906229258, 0.006976880598813295, 0.01309947483241558, -0.005797958932816982, 0.0031325381714850664, -0.005637914873659611, 0.015586258843541145, -0.007091793697327375, -0.01323351077735424, 0.02326788567006588, 0.009927008301019669, 0.00001687039366515819, -0.005112139508128166, -0.060861993581056595, 0.008387523703277111, 0.021406356245279312, 0.010049315169453621, -0.0023025970440357924, 0.05630064010620117, -0.06861460953950882, -0.05960117653012276, 0.005627423524856567, 0.02357393130660057, 0.019596362486481667, 0.01994720846414566, -0.01962573640048504, -0.021975073963403702, 0.022979281842708588, -0.05233673006296158, 0.01943461038172245, -0.03191032260656357, 0.009435699321329594, -0.005034825764596462, -0.005883391946554184, 0.02775285206735134, 0.024429304525256157, -0.00568862771615386, 0.01090148650109768, 0.04102909192442894, -0.029359718784689903, 0.011929131112992764, 0.0396224781870842, 0.003195910481736064, -0.042460981756448746, 0.02892891690135002, 0.040157951414585114, 0.019074033945798874, 0.06589760631322861, -0.03188062459230423, 0.025677921250462532, -0.07041686773300171, 0.007049278821796179, -0.09855678677558899, -0.008836912922561169, 0.03980869799852371, 0.035778339952230453, 0.01963483728468418, -0.05756877735257149, 0.009134838357567787, 0.031686171889305115, -0.07629060000181198, -0.006982024759054184, -0.02434144727885723, -0.03786224499344826, -0.033062905073165894, -0.010588354431092739, -0.015584724955260754, 0.03458530455827713, 0.0019368550274521112, 0.014353940263390541, 0.00633986946195364, 0.04339044913649559, -0.0011421890230849385, -0.011250078678131104, -0.007594139315187931, 0.019746985286474228, 0.03383461758494377, -0.05831334367394447, 0.00583674805238843, -0.03687410429120064, -0.007720509078353643, 0.023196814581751823, 0.03983776271343231, 0.006764402147382498, -0.011132887564599514, -0.004129611421376467, -0.01995735615491867, 0.04673298820853233, 0.014403360895812511, 0.019878536462783813, 0.02840285189449787, -0.0194382406771183, 0.012372060678899288, 0.03584377467632294, -0.03587985783815384, -0.03558114916086197, 0.023485252633690834, -0.0029867985285818577, -0.05614076554775238, 0.012917784042656422, -0.005264751613140106, -0.055238593369722366, -0.006182512268424034, -0.012198448181152344, -0.0025940388441085815, -0.04026802256703377, 0.06827496737241745, -0.040349360555410385, -0.02571791224181652, 0.031805962324142456, 0.041219256818294525, 0.01065212395042181, 0.02211776375770569, 0.01695227064192295, -0.03358402103185654, 0.007910408079624176, 0.007951251231133938, -0.0300679299980402, -0.05064031481742859, -0.0446438193321228, -0.0002279455802636221, 0.017909767106175423, 0.006989858113229275, -0.014608869329094887, -0.05730632692575455, 0.003453873097896576, 0.011678592301905155, 0.009395274333655834, -0.01822783052921295, 0.002568586962297559, 0.0006110759568400681, -0.10312280803918839, 0.05087429657578468, -0.012601977214217186, 0.04279465600848198, -0.039967481046915054, 0.017131632193922997, -0.06550587713718414, 0.009175153449177742, 0.05627020448446274, 0.0159615408629179, -0.015185629017651081, 0.02616535872220993, 0.03996586427092552, 0.033036455512046814, -0.05264382064342499, 0.0003265756240580231, -0.014529012143611908, 0.010571073740720749, -0.04103432595729828, -0.015405983664095402, 0.026984479278326035, -0.012073913589119911, -0.020831668749451637, -0.012930053286254406, 0.01364701334387064, 0.033794768154621124, 0.011902027763426304, 0.025975190103054047, 0.0005680471658706665, -0.03462030738592148, 0.05317741632461548, -0.004942654632031918, 0.003348353086039424, 0.053016021847724915, -0.009999643079936504, -0.018047906458377838, 0.01801738701760769, 0.004048739094287157, -0.034812454134225845, -0.04138713330030441, 0.02218055911362171, 0.027962576597929, -0.03808426484465599, -0.014609155245125294, 0.053514573723077774, -0.010545413009822369, -0.018986793234944344, 0.027946515008807182, 0.04051624983549118, 0.05111578106880188, 0.006944615393877029, -0.0343611016869545, -0.004056382924318314, 0.0029085089918226004, -0.0022613583132624626, 0.0021695776376873255, 0.01692621037364006, -0.012257557362318039, 0.014483945444226265, 0.022840242832899094, -0.027989821508526802, 0.007020286750048399, -0.012022776529192924, 0.011587669141590595, -0.019528625532984734, -0.0489642396569252, 0.045798834413290024, 0.010048368945717812, 0.021770792081952095, 0.002412815811112523, -0.018242791295051575, 0.06295210868120193, 0.004535228479653597, 0.0109573258087039, -0.02165270783007145, -0.006769152358174324, -0.013142835348844528, 0.0008714903960935771, -0.004782081115990877, 0.0010414785938337445, -0.0035929945297539234, -0.0050089992582798, -0.010402725078165531, -0.006206465885043144, 0.06467094272375107, -0.01720523089170456, 0.02458365261554718, -0.00900302454829216, 0.04296007379889488, -0.05342712253332138, -0.03173043206334114, -0.005876375362277031, -0.020708533003926277, 0.034386832267045975, 0.050457313656806946, 0.05248798802495003, -0.00087495002662763, -0.01751215010881424, 0.021877998486161232, 0.08318383246660233, -0.014851373620331287, -0.007498844526708126, -0.024299070239067078, -0.0014702202752232552, -0.007554783020168543, -0.03994133695960045 ]
<p>In my research I'm comparing the variance of a method and I would like to describe the overall variance between individuals and the variance of the replicates of these individuals. </p> <p>Things like 'comparing the intra-individual variance and between-individual variance' seems to get people confused. I would like to make a short brief notice of this without having to go to much in details about the experiment.</p> <p>What would be a way of describing this setting more clearly but still within if possible one sentence? </p> <p>To clarify: I have 10.000 measurements for 60 individuals. For each measurement I could calculate for example the standard deviation as a method of variance. I also have 5 replicate measurements per individual. I could calculate the standard deviation for each of the 10.000 measurement in the replicates. So now I have the variance of the measurement when looking in a population AND I have the variance when looking at replicates. When you would now have to describe these 2 types of variance in a single sentence how would you do that without going into to much details? </p>
73,928
[ -0.0518634207546711, -0.011199007742106915, -0.015569353476166725, -0.032234225422143936, 0.022472545504570007, 0.015874631702899933, 0.0031150057911872864, -0.01678326725959778, 0.011873186565935612, -0.019174015149474144, 0.040547728538513184, 0.02503165975213051, 0.04517814889550209, 0.012454651296138763, 0.020544609054923058, 0.004895583260804415, -0.03254595398902893, 0.002795587759464979, -0.009837191551923752, -0.018187392503023148, -0.017800098285079002, -0.02130746655166149, 0.008690725080668926, 0.008580890484154224, -0.029888132587075233, 0.060620300471782684, 0.0319359228014946, 0.0036352709867060184, 0.0003640253853518516, 0.023855192586779594, -0.030021371319890022, -0.030383432283997536, 0.022805331274867058, 0.017587702721357346, 0.03782791271805763, -0.01477751787751913, -0.0437965951859951, -0.02934354357421398, 0.00014499838289339095, 0.029748061671853065, -0.0368264876306057, 0.0007167089497670531, -0.01196519285440445, -0.0033115700352936983, -0.0235369261354208, 0.018407028168439865, -0.016485149040818214, 0.0009372966014780104, -0.015332796610891819, -0.055714454501867294, 0.06872179359197617, 0.008526493795216084, 0.07600448280572891, 0.051639292389154434, 0.006329065188765526, 0.037160664796829224, 0.027901720255613327, 0.046143896877765656, 0.0053229969926178455, -0.04191296920180321, -0.012906830757856369, -0.003780156373977661, 0.0313497893512249, -0.046398013830184937, -0.016553862020373344, 0.030039550736546516, 0.0026192760560661554, -0.03309440240263939, 0.037516999989748, -0.005290389060974121, 0.047172121703624725, 0.016206124797463417, 0.04359717294573784, 0.01296849176287651, -0.0037512173876166344, -0.04178681597113609, 0.01835375279188156, -0.004745957441627979, 0.04622046649456024, 0.041994381695985794, -0.00949903018772602, 0.013227373361587524, 0.0544363297522068, 0.0062590050511062145, -0.010992323979735374, -0.047249019145965576, 0.05203377082943916, 0.0017299152677878737, -0.011325825937092304, 0.04193064942955971, 0.02967158704996109, 0.02570805512368679, 0.054622866213321686, 0.031463854014873505, -0.06594718992710114, 0.010417803190648556, -0.0205350611358881, 0.05127597600221634, -0.027957240119576454, 0.013020366430282593, 0.01404627226293087, -0.042619939893484116, 0.042289383709430695, 0.050506990402936935, -0.018175072968006134, -0.047586292028427124, -0.016796935349702835, -0.005503406748175621, 0.002319600433111191, -0.02047504484653473, 0.01573311537504196, -0.017867542803287506, 0.006228094920516014, 0.02626822143793106, 0.02468811720609665, 0.008546284399926662, 0.0002719679905567318, 0.005933965556323528, 0.07234642654657364, 0.06014048680663109, 0.01934739574790001, -0.055505022406578064, 0.03326469287276268, -0.007727160584181547, -0.04594310000538826, 0.04646526277065277, 0.009546546265482903, -0.028306355699896812, -0.047334086149930954, 0.049097880721092224, 0.012960704043507576, -0.017929408699274063, 0.01156010851264, -0.020722609013319016, 0.019708456471562386, -0.017120584845542908, -0.11399579048156738, -0.05830283463001251, 0.03355773165822029, 0.0032378369942307472, 0.010523385368287563, -0.061967477202415466, 0.01581336371600628, 0.009398759342730045, -0.030879361554980278, 0.025372665375471115, 0.0320156067609787, 0.013939001597464085, 0.015148838981986046, 0.01628081128001213, -0.01268049143254757, -0.008297943510115147, 0.0024603402707725763, -0.011234269477427006, -0.004177882336080074, -0.05634670332074165, 0.012981807813048363, 0.04998327046632767, -0.017901349812746048, 0.0012811002088710666, 0.045744892209768295, -0.006031916942447424, 0.006368459202349186, 0.018626604229211807, 0.04386008903384209, -0.013372783549129963, 0.07536440342664719, 0.001717303181067109, 0.02619243413209915, 0.038204655051231384, 0.006344713270664215, -0.018037183210253716, 0.004650617949664593, 0.019191520288586617, 0.06386184692382812, -0.03132038190960884, 0.005860884673893452, 0.03941984847187996, -0.007236153353005648, 0.03975158929824829, -0.05657770484685898, -0.017246702685952187, 0.005859070923179388, 0.006862614303827286, 0.02642104960978031, 0.06902160495519638, -0.032574497163295746, 0.022369613870978355, 0.018763011321425438, -0.04844798520207405, -0.06901431828737259, -0.0721234679222107, 0.020796341821551323, -0.007518927101045847, -0.028651626780629158, 0.012612204067409039, -0.00025446867221035063, 0.02984452433884144, -0.003673780709505081, -0.022802406921982765, -0.05175861716270447, 0.013045761734247208, 0.058061424642801285, -0.020963823422789574, 0.011166095733642578, 0.03569362685084343, 0.037331633269786835, 0.013914689421653748, 0.035075753927230835, 0.011690919287502766, -0.017124982550740242, 0.0033583887852728367, -0.03533998876810074, 0.04767526686191559, 0.03590162470936775, -0.029209041967988014, 0.026299400255084038, -0.015883704647421837, -0.029345234856009483, 0.043414320796728134, 0.0024560026358813047, 0.058122359216213226, 0.06944272667169571, -0.01937611773610115, -0.015829140320420265, -0.01673911139369011, -0.0018132118275389075, 0.0050248391926288605, -0.018458470702171326, -0.02776152268052101, -0.025847768411040306, 0.01052319910377264, 0.033262405544519424, 0.03322595730423927, -0.03356578201055527, -0.0036749865394085646, 0.0357513427734375, 0.03444384038448334, 0.00934557057917118, 0.040160804986953735, -0.019325384870171547, -0.022768205031752586, 0.00226233946159482, 0.0467650406062603, 0.0008054991485551, 0.0376909077167511, 0.013741880655288696, -0.012700274586677551, 0.048900917172431946, 0.021762913092970848, 0.0448547899723053, 0.048685021698474884, 0.011943499557673931, 0.003950460813939571, -0.009932797402143478, -0.022628068923950195, 0.02920309640467167, -0.014047469012439251, 0.02276165410876274, 0.03742818906903267, -0.01401564758270979, -0.006433558184653521, -0.010213002562522888, -0.015026637353003025, 0.028584865853190422, 0.04847511649131775, -0.014981459826231003, -0.003085636766627431, 0.005058574955910444, -0.04375598207116127, 0.031194277107715607, -0.02570703811943531, -0.008400841616094112, -0.009901972487568855, -0.002847901312634349, 0.026251526549458504, -0.002997824689373374, 0.021284768357872963, -0.025189107283949852, -0.021322093904018402, -0.015300611034035683, -0.0056674303486943245, -0.001100146328099072, -0.039192888885736465, -0.06874314695596695, 0.012456076219677925, -0.015214319340884686, -0.0288825836032629, 0.031397316604852676, -0.019854489713907242, -0.01294904388487339, 0.015319920144975185, 0.0032798557076603174, -0.06994634121656418, 0.017515631392598152, -0.041727736592292786, 0.02111361362040043, 0.02849826030433178, -0.024621834978461266, 0.0565958209335804, 0.009645678102970123, -0.03497222438454628, 0.022539783269166946, -0.05499419569969177, -0.04079579561948776, -0.020942596718668938, -0.016487905755639076, 0.0394962802529335, -0.03374876827001572, -0.013088657520711422, 0.046572938561439514, -0.049823954701423645, -0.04667670279741287, -0.05832536518573761, -0.0674801841378212, 0.0030439889524132013, 0.02352682501077652, 0.03251253440976143, -0.025684334337711334, -0.03843647241592407, 0.09134548157453537, -0.005128609482198954, -0.03727656230330467, -0.049998361617326736, 0.02343389019370079, -0.02468384988605976, -0.0179954394698143, 0.03654757887125015, 0.002108014654368162, -0.020495548844337463, 0.019410530105233192, 0.012964329682290554, 0.0006564298528246582, 0.03160228952765465, 0.02001876011490822, -0.026267455890774727, -0.010016205720603466, -0.002852975158020854, -0.019460080191493034, 0.04747752845287323, 0.032549433410167694, -0.07075411826372147, 0.01787548139691353, -0.005106125492602587, 0.03357410058379173, -0.0018907822668552399, -0.04751455411314964, 0.03374410793185234, -0.011130750179290771, -0.03347529470920563, -0.04892269894480705, 0.01235046423971653, 0.016301972791552544, -0.007737533189356327, 0.017535455524921417, 0.00032607908360660076, -0.010625109076499939, -0.021719684824347496, -0.010169930756092072, 0.05658065155148506, 0.04563968628644943, -0.004555624444037676, -0.0350177064538002, 0.009600881487131119, 0.018898090347647667, 0.002756745321676135, 0.0067571778781712055, -0.03770776838064194, 0.03863123431801796, 0.03936614468693733, 0.037199717015028, -0.004013060592114925, -0.04568234831094742, 0.010941852815449238, -0.07173986732959747, -0.0004461657372303307, 0.0043005929328501225, 0.03203507140278816, -0.0016706726746633649, 0.027263935655355453, 0.02967650257050991, -0.008076389320194721, -0.014671684242784977, -0.015506666153669357, -0.04307718947529793, 0.019478973001241684, -0.015680750831961632, -0.012296654284000397, -0.0048673576675355434, -0.016333652660250664, 0.024913348257541656, -0.040229298174381256, 0.012851138599216938, 0.004781738854944706, 0.015390961430966854, -0.010683889500796795, 0.00859097857028246, 0.020053397864103317, -0.004305277951061726, -0.012820957228541374, 0.03257329389452934, 0.005491443909704685, -0.01754571869969368, 0.042259056121110916, 0.016867805272340775, 0.007729099597781897, -0.017162656411528587, -0.04013005644083023, -0.021153079345822334, 0.013078929856419563, 0.03714277595281601, 0.0040404354222118855, 0.017958516255021095, -0.02481069229543209, 0.05123940110206604, 0.012802556157112122, 0.041427720338106155, 0.019164342433214188, -0.013011960312724113, -0.03115268610417843, -0.017588626593351364, -0.00199116044677794, 0.010816961526870728, -0.01144084706902504, 0.01256138738244772, -0.022714175283908844, 0.05044258385896683, 0.04259448125958443, -0.036681097000837326, 0.051908645778894424, 0.0479329377412796, 0.006640516687184572, -0.014166973531246185, -0.027772225439548492, -0.025198403745889664, 0.009363310411572456, -0.002968106884509325, 0.012014534324407578, 0.03263303264975548, 0.025661800056695938, -0.006852662656456232, 0.060359980911016464, -0.052719227969646454, -0.0335950143635273, -0.004339618608355522, -0.037826862186193466, 0.03490561619400978, -0.00921278353780508, 0.0032604369334876537, 0.016530707478523254, 0.040865931659936905, 0.016182180494070053, 0.04683930426836014, -0.006756255403161049, -0.07601916790008545, -0.012585042975842953, 0.036741457879543304, 0.023849977180361748, -0.05121782422065735, 0.011710647493600845, -0.008621233515441418, -0.015911191701889038, 0.021428780630230904, -0.06783698499202728, 0.019679678604006767, -0.019758574664592743, -0.011487248353660107, 0.005367895122617483, -0.011022479273378849, -0.042213406413793564, 0.009103256277740002, -0.011262960731983185, 0.030379535630345345, -0.02511230669915676, 0.02408263459801674, -0.03599877655506134, -0.0034619190264493227, -0.005024679936468601, 0.06195944547653198, -0.011792310513556004, 0.004785500466823578, 0.02773367054760456, 0.05306001007556915, -0.017090026289224625, -0.08751653134822845, 0.03960113227367401, 0.03418727591633797, 0.017796412110328674, 0.037466589361429214, -0.021943489089608192, -0.06797721982002258, -0.012003494426608086, -0.013580039143562317, -0.00325020938180387, -0.02187853679060936, -0.015097878873348236, 0.03498972952365875, 0.04482579976320267, 0.005391597747802734, 0.09393057227134705, 0.004342940170317888, 0.004006003029644489, -0.006199860014021397, -0.0187324620783329, 0.03229011595249176, -0.020139146596193314, -0.05019970238208771, -0.043449874967336655, 0.007361732888966799, -0.0387289896607399, 0.05030501261353493, -0.03608130291104317, 0.045952435582876205, -0.048691075295209885, -0.035268571227788925, 0.010964957065880299, 0.03212234750390053, 0.009213987737894058, -0.020771833136677742, -0.00045025520375929773, 0.022629527375102043, 0.0014526789309456944, -0.03538746014237404, 0.015471654012799263, -0.013145176693797112, -0.01645907573401928, 0.00949897151440382, -0.0244465135037899, 0.004706705454736948, -0.05405024066567421, -0.048343729227781296, 0.0026788697578012943, -0.04238427057862282, 0.05346224084496498, -0.02142096310853958, 0.05327319726347923, -0.009987526573240757, -0.07838564366102219, -0.042312752455472946, 0.010241092182695866, 0.011320854537189007, 0.03533323481678963, -0.033348482102155685, 0.003036266192793846, -0.02419223263859749, -0.01434206124395132, -0.09096187353134155, -0.022848015651106834, 0.010360623709857464, 0.014460736885666847, 0.013511097058653831, -0.022018617019057274, -0.008567719720304012, 0.014500199817121029, -0.04514578357338905, -0.03429054841399193, 0.04134799540042877, -0.01567196659743786, 0.001611336600035429, -0.034091368317604065, 0.025473427027463913, 0.10303197056055069, -0.0097954785451293, -0.017564890906214714, -0.0067965565249323845, -0.018655061721801758, 0.02866695076227188, 0.028808411210775375, 0.0354461669921875, -0.015649182721972466, -0.025343162938952446, -0.037472281605005264, 0.02122911810874939, 0.019376704469323158, -0.02651270106434822, 0.019036920741200447, -0.005986104253679514, -0.016878031194210052, -0.0014661006862297654, -0.017635362222790718, 0.031281713396310806, -0.01334993727505207, 0.03209611773490906, -0.019575363025069237, 0.01905994676053524, -0.015589085407555103, -0.007918866351246834, 0.021506544202566147, 0.018336394801735878, -0.029607925564050674, 0.009045109152793884, 0.07655982673168182, -0.020529264584183693, 0.008040585555136204, 0.028274934738874435, -0.016701580956578255, 0.01992790587246418, -0.00548053253442049, 0.028151534497737885, 0.004802350420504808, 0.0013336817501112819, -0.01431489922106266, -0.0213185902684927, -0.014849531464278698, -0.02889614924788475, 0.053621795028448105, -0.012476625852286816, 0.04552515968680382, 0.08466267585754395, 0.026690807193517685, 0.03930448740720749, -0.02637392468750477, 0.02599046751856804, -0.008285298943519592, 0.04246274009346962, 0.09773685038089752, -0.026842055842280388, 0.005397176835685968, 0.045574385672807693, 0.0925934910774231, 0.01061951369047165, 0.03900347277522087, 0.005955828819423914, 0.020999792963266373, -0.03229927644133568, -0.010232023894786835, -0.05236131697893143, -0.004485170356929302, -0.05188211798667908, -0.00022828606597613543, -0.05652055889368057, 0.006047536619007587, 0.04288440942764282, 0.015430917032063007, 0.011681058444082737, -0.004324319772422314, -0.017178792506456375, -0.0779520720243454, 0.022838488221168518, 0.015781786292791367, -0.006971814204007387, -0.016927750781178474, -0.014801540412008762, 0.06030077114701271, -0.04132569208741188, 0.010940613225102425, -0.05808650702238083, -0.044027846306562424, -0.04445783421397209, -0.00016063600196503103, -0.02283102087676525, 0.02311394363641739, -0.01197862345725298, -0.03161492571234703, -0.005266973283141851, -0.004199367482215166, 0.012684325687587261, -0.0064940680749714375, 0.023461466655135155, -0.044524796307086945, 0.06020079553127289, 0.026853365823626518, 0.024528861045837402, -0.0007102256058715284, 0.007193378172814846, 0.08582039177417755, 0.020233575254678726, 0.0354948528110981, -0.04577817767858505, 0.023504892364144325, -0.005988209508359432, 0.015858598053455353, 0.021930381655693054, 0.012278144247829914, 0.02667599357664585, 0.02293497510254383, 0.04714614897966385, 0.03755134716629982, 0.03865349292755127, -0.005704652052372694, 0.05121326074004173, -0.027918532490730286, -0.0015583076747134328, 0.011141495779156685, 0.005893584340810776, -0.005492902360856533, -0.022751199081540108, -0.030165372416377068, 0.020040830597281456, 0.02108549140393734, -0.0007219391409307718, -0.031409237533807755, 0.011535780504345894, -0.0027630950789898634, 0.03365786373615265, -0.021207112818956375, 0.010059907101094723, -0.00611132150515914, 0.002245039213448763, -0.03563203662633896, -0.03164490684866905, 0.042481087148189545, -0.030262162908911705, 0.04563285782933235, 0.022360336035490036, -0.02767339162528515, 0.005376709159463644, 0.028144828975200653, 0.01979212835431099, -0.04843807965517044, -0.039689142256975174, -0.002749416511505842, 0.03326576203107834, -0.026095855981111526, -0.011216559447348118, -0.05334709212183952, -0.0010916019091382623, -0.024187570437788963, -0.05308525636792183, -0.01629367098212242, 0.02020256407558918, -0.001269742613658309, -0.04360900819301605, -0.005075512453913689, -0.026188958436250687, 0.017124079167842865, -0.06280241161584854, 0.011513885110616684, 0.008900927379727364, -0.0021698251366615295, -0.016255423426628113, -0.007914157584309578, -0.0170136671513319, -0.030599011108279228, 0.0004386508371680975, -0.026247836649417877, 0.0031198696233332157, -0.027997110038995743, 0.018741192296147346, 0.015409048646688461, -0.008135650306940079, 0.01380994450300932, -0.0003647641569841653, 0.004705994855612516, -0.016051292419433594, -0.008704314939677715, 0.03135978803038597, 0.03761448338627815, -0.01977282576262951, -0.019117768853902817, 0.007657715119421482, 0.028697112575173378, 0.018123822286725044, -0.01956804282963276, 0.04249132052063942, -0.0035194705706089735, 0.04162388667464256, 0.0016296182293444872, -0.03372923657298088, 0.0014778102049604058, 0.032794300466775894, -0.030126823112368584, -0.026810571551322937, -0.00834661815315485, 0.04901665821671486, 0.06473451852798462, -0.013033905997872353, 0.0005403977702371776, 0.047156788408756256, 0.01168142445385456, 0.004627636168152094, 0.016225621104240417, -0.046360038220882416, -0.006659261416643858, 0.028902942314743996, 0.009185783565044403, -0.01670551858842373, -0.013240119442343712, -0.0223147701472044, -0.04249933734536171, 0.01680023781955242, 0.012006090022623539, -0.01826762780547142, 0.026838162913918495, -0.02663322538137436, -0.012303047813475132, -0.01721516065299511, 0.023899540305137634, -0.06609050184488297, -0.004005139227956533, 0.01957322470843792, -0.011148049496114254, -0.006241731811314821, 0.018365448340773582, -0.0027954753022640944, -0.009558240883052349, 0.06211717426776886, 0.027250593528151512, 0.028655409812927246, 0.0036245982628315687, 0.006319190841168165, 0.016814103350043297, 0.06975553184747696, -0.01377012673765421, 0.0059752268716692924, 0.04936628416180611, -0.04472358524799347, -0.026492580771446228, 0.055908918380737305, -0.008491076529026031, 0.005150012671947479, 0.018086561933159828, -0.008865484967827797, -0.009089338593184948, 0.0386040024459362, -0.047686655074357986, -0.02811492048203945, -0.028135856613516808, 0.003938265144824982, -0.04101191461086273, -0.03682580590248108, 0.032209739089012146, -0.006213413085788488, -0.015918554738163948, 0.020431999117136, 0.050064150243997574, -0.006258251611143351, -0.025838281959295273, 0.010220399126410484, 0.015714943408966064, 0.02394862473011017, -0.014599057845771313, -0.004255188163369894, -0.011367079801857471, 0.05429255589842796, -0.07250844687223434, 0.006297572515904903, -0.03956782445311546, 0.013865017332136631, -0.0694880560040474, 0.004693825729191303, -0.01016540452837944, 0.019599398598074913, 0.006040058098733425, -0.0370342880487442, 0.0007465944509021938, 0.018869983032345772, -0.04243965446949005, -0.0013768902281299233, -0.03163573890924454, -0.03352872282266617, -0.0236502718180418, -0.0032393920700997114, -0.02337203361093998, 0.04420112445950508, -0.0011719827307388186, 0.02350890450179577, -0.005366568919271231, 0.015990380197763443, -0.004101122263818979, -0.0656111016869545, -0.023780273273587227, 0.01238977164030075, 0.012992710806429386, -0.04873347282409668, 0.042393915355205536, -0.0253177247941494, -0.05385831743478775, 0.051336947828531265, -0.03346357122063637, 0.02434704080224037, 0.0256651584059, 0.017435340210795403, -0.010560372844338417, 0.019371207803487778, -0.003227299079298973, 0.007703203242272139, -0.045049212872982025, 0.007344959769397974, 0.012600628659129143, 0.013479153625667095, 0.004295552149415016, 0.008513770997524261, 0.04733537882566452, 0.004331121686846018, -0.010014867410063744, 0.02641149051487446, -0.025990113615989685, -0.04189380258321762, -0.013617516495287418, 0.0061794607900083065, 0.051826439797878265, -0.03812377527356148, -0.0013110603904351592, -0.023014256730675697, -0.0010281129507347941, 0.049045585095882416, 0.018361372873187065, -0.031246671453118324, 0.003047668607905507, -0.01486129593104124, -0.023174483329057693, -0.009122814983129501, 0.007002285681664944, -0.03742806613445282, -0.06598164886236191, -0.04051009565591812, 0.0007271417998708785, -0.012472009286284447, -0.005490344949066639, -0.021389015018939972, -0.010680542327463627, 0.04668993130326271, -0.01759578473865986, 0.013285626657307148, -0.012054773978888988, 0.0032593877986073494, -0.03186396136879921, -0.025914400815963745, 0.0377328097820282, 0.02465640753507614, -0.00360917579382658, -0.04282635077834129, -0.01834847591817379, -0.0489690825343132, 0.04358962923288345, 0.05988437682390213, 0.009753014892339706, -0.021750302985310555, 0.007090748753398657, 0.04936542734503746, 0.021867096424102783, -0.06953563541173935, 0.05197342112660408, -0.012881643138825893, -0.029974643141031265, -0.013028932735323906, -0.03658609092235565, -0.012043694034218788, 0.012475247494876385, 0.01451940182596445, -0.0030049248598515987, 0.0013468314427882433, -0.01099834218621254, -0.01300826109945774, 0.039414457976818085, 0.01355630625039339, -0.03149256855249405, 0.00171637162566185, -0.017960458993911743, -0.00552588514983654, 0.04933447763323784, 0.03589978441596031, -0.03410846367478371, 0.013602306134998798, -0.04886713996529579, 0.0004993804614059627, 0.006970273796468973, -0.0094621442258358, -0.0032124670688062906, -0.039032988250255585, 0.00488572521135211, 0.011466770432889462, -0.06599187105894089, -0.003734002588316798, 0.05355045199394226, 0.060675084590911865, 0.01424909196794033, -0.0033598023001104593, -0.009992805309593678, -0.0029324530623853207, -0.021351413801312447, -0.03172067180275917, 0.028193246573209763, 0.019168157130479813, 0.030197277665138245, 0.02769489213824272, 0.03388380631804466, 0.015857208520174026, 0.06922925263643265, -0.0032355741132050753, 0.02250269614160061, -0.03271646797657013, -0.02274370938539505, -0.02854599431157112, -0.021665114909410477, -0.013889026828110218, 0.010969278402626514, -0.027634132653474808, 0.07062703371047974, -0.04250326380133629, -0.0071871280670166016, -0.042162247002124786, 0.0023398841731250286, -0.029257293790578842, -0.043075889348983765, 0.032108962535858154, 0.057428307831287384, -0.008288481272757053, -0.003053705208003521, -0.041625458747148514, 0.0053719584830105305, 0.021268406882882118, -0.037221718579530716, 0.05742897093296051, -0.031138205900788307, 0.0029468571301549673, -0.030501697212457657, -0.005649548023939133, -0.041781459003686905, 0.022729340940713882, 0.05954665690660477, 0.014368090778589249, 0.06955661624670029, 0.007966693490743637, -0.04853518679738045, 0.021907798945903778, 0.012857818976044655, -0.08396261185407639, -0.04694026708602905, -0.03035406582057476, 0.0311193335801363, -0.005122858099639416, -0.002034762641415 ]
<p>If somebody can tell me what R commands I need to use for a repeated measures ANOVA, I'd really appreciate it. I have trouble with the random term. I've seen <code>random=id</code>, <code>random=id/(treatment*group)</code> and others. </p> <p>Also can you please indicate to me what the formula for the Bonferroni adjusted intervals is?</p>
49,613
[ -0.022368373349308968, -0.006392807699739933, -0.02545315772294998, -0.0011268354719504714, 0.021961264312267303, 0.021803490817546844, -0.003347798017784953, -0.015688881278038025, 0.007028978317975998, -0.057941559702157974, 0.03845393657684326, 0.05714542046189308, 0.06178925558924675, 0.04375845938920975, 0.030979519709944725, -0.03137713298201561, 0.0014663838082924485, -0.022414932027459145, -0.009362101554870605, -0.0013753222301602364, -0.00019188846636097878, -0.005533064249902964, -0.011401680298149586, -0.017896782606840134, -0.013734748587012291, 0.05643465742468834, 0.05111606791615486, -0.008876360021531582, 0.018763883039355278, 0.057759370654821396, -0.06827542930841446, -0.04177358001470566, 0.0024648879189044237, 0.007835016585886478, 0.015018606558442116, 0.00707321148365736, -0.010394109413027763, -0.019504765048623085, -0.00023487559519708157, 0.004117756616324186, -0.017003381624817848, 0.0010548940626904368, 0.0016918781911954284, 0.034705087542533875, 0.016015997156500816, 0.0033752729650586843, -0.007314356509596109, 0.0005784900858998299, 0.04239863529801369, -0.04496099427342415, 0.08314874023199081, -0.0000794608931755647, 0.06127642095088959, 0.052736733108758926, -0.02503102831542492, 0.012470449320971966, 0.05854727700352669, 0.03671795129776001, 0.008727359585464, -0.06757038831710815, -0.004798282403498888, -0.03519991785287857, 0.0005104377632960677, 0.02530636079609394, -0.04299192503094673, -0.005508927162736654, 0.008318182080984116, -0.034451212733983994, 0.043799251317977905, 0.009516134858131409, 0.003732286160811782, 0.037394847720861435, 0.041695717722177505, -0.05348386988043785, 0.01586640067398548, -0.021283267065882683, 0.0383828803896904, -0.018990395590662956, 0.02763138711452484, 0.043709952384233475, -0.00005344161399989389, 0.015920031815767288, 0.014187749475240707, 0.020216407254338264, 0.0251294132322073, -0.013300200924277306, 0.03812776505947113, -0.011536580510437489, 0.023101620376110077, 0.0294321458786726, -0.023203887045383453, 0.031093956902623177, 0.024037696421146393, 0.04933447763323784, -0.03737146779894829, 0.04287182167172432, -0.0035577001981437206, 0.07031860202550888, -0.020168768242001534, -0.008093500509858131, 0.014525574631989002, -0.02938356250524521, 0.0143059017136693, 0.04930286481976509, -0.045233435928821564, -0.006978328339755535, -0.0377742163836956, 0.006400954443961382, 0.00245657772757113, -0.023936107754707336, 0.005552009679377079, 0.0069704377092421055, -0.04055861383676529, -0.027511416003108025, 0.021008329465985298, -0.041029687970876694, -0.02087954618036747, 0.029738837853074074, 0.06355032324790955, 0.07503454387187958, 0.04650454595685005, -0.02546919882297516, 0.028394971042871475, -0.05202824994921684, -0.03671212121844292, 0.0171507578343153, 0.01399900857359171, -0.004311190918087959, -0.013407286256551743, 0.07440828531980515, 0.00020337833848316222, -0.043372876942157745, 0.022025231271982193, -0.0018420186825096607, 0.04651150479912758, -0.01239322591573, -0.0727306455373764, -0.07734965533018112, 0.01845010183751583, -0.025520294904708862, 0.01486540399491787, -0.06432484835386276, -0.0038641628343611956, 0.017974257469177246, 0.045255087316036224, 0.02842559665441513, 0.02183246985077858, 0.0034549119882285595, 0.002115683862939477, 0.017110418528318405, -0.014062458649277687, -0.017469748854637146, -0.02039022371172905, -0.036653272807598114, -0.02231866866350174, -0.08353211730718613, 0.030895881354808807, 0.006289473734796047, -0.008922570385038853, -0.006019066087901592, 0.021366877481341362, -0.0038687961641699076, 0.0019076276803389192, 0.018879616633057594, 0.030177857726812363, -0.016794800758361816, 0.053223639726638794, -0.03215273097157478, 0.05318969488143921, 0.049468934535980225, -0.01935647800564766, 0.005768566392362118, -0.006877458654344082, 0.039046093821525574, 0.0790209025144577, -0.011967810802161694, 0.0023229143116623163, -0.014025215990841389, 0.020104363560676575, 0.08805660158395767, -0.042663272470235825, -0.006918047554790974, 0.006257680244743824, -0.03813811391592026, 0.023497149348258972, -0.012456201948225498, 0.01151367463171482, 0.0026665704790502787, 0.041989248245954514, -0.04147075489163399, -0.004860089626163244, -0.09546657651662827, -0.001717121689580381, -0.012690287083387375, -0.021973716095089912, -0.0016217399388551712, 0.013291792012751102, 0.02035837061703205, 0.02329377643764019, -0.02291031926870346, -0.03397643193602562, 0.00838548131287098, 0.05528672784566879, -0.03447245806455612, -0.004256070125848055, 0.02176930382847786, 0.05468713119626045, -0.04892014339566231, 0.06416372209787369, -0.018231704831123352, -0.025449883192777634, -0.004863905720412731, -0.03308549150824547, 0.0186817217618227, -0.02408813126385212, -0.019427020102739334, 0.015921398997306824, 0.016040852293372154, -0.020592357963323593, 0.03221258521080017, -0.06018301099538803, 0.038968924432992935, 0.09068161249160767, 0.06345616281032562, -0.0022829289082437754, 0.02187545783817768, 0.02084028720855713, 0.026426367461681366, -0.03391385078430176, -0.015524746850132942, -0.0414598286151886, -0.006473782006651163, 0.03014584444463253, -0.009837823919951916, -0.018653616309165955, 0.01970895752310753, 0.052355196326971054, 0.01585635542869568, 0.0126982182264328, 0.055309608578681946, -0.010489169508218765, -0.013772264122962952, -0.032038141041994095, 0.020484821870923042, 0.04432728886604309, 0.008843211457133293, 0.012292237021028996, -0.010875272564589977, 0.05413560941815376, 0.02862972766160965, 0.020642124116420746, 0.03967982158064842, 0.00027661662898026407, -0.0025812399107962847, -0.008528904058039188, -0.030158355832099915, 0.028515642508864403, -0.0260907132178545, 0.016959059983491898, 0.03266239911317825, 0.021629611030220985, -0.024782689288258553, 0.01605953648686409, -0.025406962260603905, 0.0025876217987388372, 0.01331394538283348, -0.030354110524058342, -0.022732669487595558, 0.018962347880005836, -0.007098737638443708, 0.0072359805926680565, -0.03557233512401581, -0.0023005201946944, -0.05988352745771408, 0.00780543964356184, -0.0001482579973526299, -0.004541024100035429, 0.002705636899918318, -0.02313242107629776, 0.015003406442701817, 0.027557050809264183, -0.025276582688093185, 0.020897727459669113, -0.001016576075926423, -0.020334918051958084, -0.00908653810620308, -0.03070496954023838, 0.011524933390319347, 0.01624605804681778, 0.0031771932262927294, -0.040430404245853424, 0.03519883006811142, 0.01347935851663351, -0.0295728612691164, -0.013701841235160828, -0.0067111109383404255, 0.03763401508331299, -0.011284858919680119, -0.008088002912700176, 0.0527770034968853, 0.04299784079194069, -0.013674238696694374, 0.03577525168657303, -0.06806390732526779, 0.023716378957033157, 0.005742407403886318, 0.02019241638481617, 0.031512320041656494, -0.007116407155990601, 0.02099471539258957, 0.030880006030201912, -0.015414159744977951, -0.03309708461165428, -0.05378977954387665, -0.04774128273129463, -0.01264286506921053, 0.017342576757073402, -0.013719765469431877, -0.020789319649338722, -0.01326738577336073, 0.08161213994026184, 0.03778684139251709, -0.03057633526623249, -0.05808180943131447, -0.020922016352415085, 0.006335289217531681, -0.03128323704004288, 0.02416725642979145, 0.0006436150288209319, -0.019592933356761932, 0.012648730538785458, 0.019077777862548828, 0.02877884730696678, 0.054840411990880966, 0.01626291126012802, 0.0025987764820456505, 0.006264273077249527, 0.029449645429849625, -0.03580549731850624, 0.04857536032795906, 0.010873699560761452, -0.019988996908068657, -0.013507616706192493, 0.015016731806099415, 0.025435809046030045, -0.010836396366357803, -0.04886326566338539, 0.012517610564827919, -0.04294171184301376, 0.020552298054099083, -0.03679355978965759, 0.020418936386704445, 0.02611469477415085, -0.02133185975253582, -0.0012499912409111857, 0.012676743790507317, 0.04264708235859871, -0.01535742450505495, 0.003561615012586117, 0.028733737766742706, 0.02289636991918087, -0.02373817376792431, -0.0039885942824184895, -0.014987035654485226, -0.022495776414871216, 0.019756266847252846, -0.057081036269664764, 0.006042766384780407, 0.024917026981711388, 0.0377667210996151, 0.001993566518649459, 0.0029237382113933563, -0.034001149237155914, 0.016820356249809265, -0.07906727492809296, 0.028293760493397713, -0.023355044424533844, 0.037723563611507416, 0.019270267337560654, 0.05422130227088928, 0.01229751668870449, -0.05413742735981941, 0.03797973319888115, -0.050580885261297226, -0.06289702653884888, 0.07917732745409012, 0.019264524802565575, -0.031371187418699265, 0.018766576424241066, -0.030909821391105652, 0.02440185844898224, 0.009334100410342216, -0.0023734914138913155, 0.0015919603174552321, 0.011837518773972988, 0.00033109664218500257, -0.0037933620624244213, -0.007516747340559959, 0.003824150189757347, -0.014246974140405655, 0.013406394049525261, 0.00455173384398222, -0.041728951036930084, 0.0005253308918327093, -0.0060120015405118465, 0.011888531967997551, -0.02780292183160782, 0.008830014616250992, -0.006403705570846796, 0.01564101316034794, 0.05884094536304474, 0.003901207586750388, 0.011921845376491547, -0.04378499463200569, 0.02086208015680313, -0.0027490872889757156, 0.039077028632164, 0.045325543731451035, 0.021850788965821266, -0.010188356041908264, -0.03334981948137283, -0.008607286028563976, 0.011108496226370335, -0.0011552841169759631, 0.0062499581836164, -0.002829279052093625, 0.038264449685811996, 0.02478315867483616, -0.05825434997677803, 0.0118196876719594, 0.05362130329012871, 0.006577447988092899, -0.00962172169238329, -0.026786278933286667, 0.026929156854748726, 0.0005954058724455535, -0.011917860247194767, 0.033118076622486115, 0.01836831122636795, -0.0106704356148839, 0.014118005521595478, 0.03909224644303322, -0.01334796566516161, -0.0028904073406010866, 0.0057793487794697285, 0.03247219696640968, 0.030163472518324852, 0.003838100703433156, -0.04490293934941292, -0.047046463936567307, 0.025943303480744362, 0.03467307612299919, 0.031268034130334854, -0.0235415268689394, -0.08719740808010101, 0.019109394401311874, 0.03733498603105545, 0.053420476615428925, -0.06394422054290771, 0.007722373586148024, -0.03149336576461792, -0.011120060458779335, 0.04332743585109711, -0.05336596444249153, -0.005769481882452965, -0.050219208002090454, -0.015266995877027512, -0.026652511209249496, -0.002190909581258893, -0.04672324284911156, 0.0023450697772204876, -0.011603150516748428, 0.03131260350346565, 0.015364502556622028, -0.0024788682349026203, -0.0531880147755146, 0.0023528202436864376, 0.013844117522239685, 0.04821280762553215, -0.0306661706417799, -0.006079494953155518, 0.05954713001847267, 0.01870441623032093, -0.0101131247356534, -0.03154309466481209, 0.00810872483998537, -0.00653695035725832, 0.018040908500552177, 0.03522124141454697, -0.021331194788217545, -0.01029009185731411, -0.00804981216788292, 0.03039601445198059, 0.0002946646127384156, -0.016139691695570946, -0.029263578355312347, 0.011438067071139812, 0.025405867025256157, 0.006661341525614262, 0.06775443255901337, 0.01660965196788311, 0.03441872075200081, 0.022669734433293343, -0.07062483578920364, 0.024494541808962822, -0.04050331190228462, -0.01746509037911892, -0.05840786173939705, -0.02394852042198181, -0.011545198038220406, 0.024905037134885788, 0.0032735613640397787, 0.029681427404284477, -0.04392445459961891, -0.025650693103671074, 0.02960442751646042, 0.04527689889073372, 0.011929063126444817, -0.02046261914074421, 0.04374471679329872, -0.010774604044854641, -0.013066514395177364, -0.04588964954018593, 0.003949697129428387, -0.025242440402507782, -0.018339168280363083, 0.012307967990636826, -0.062457211315631866, 0.01961718313395977, -0.005419563036412001, -0.04751775786280632, 0.006287702359259129, -0.05390419811010361, 0.022123318165540695, -0.006515862885862589, 0.012607717886567116, -0.017668921500444412, -0.05446041747927666, -0.02352140098810196, 0.027994459494948387, -0.028328098356723785, 0.021009277552366257, -0.035592805594205856, 0.05889537185430527, -0.020327288657426834, -0.0016116604674607515, -0.05711451917886734, -0.08199457824230194, 0.03620566055178642, -0.01343161053955555, 0.00269675487652421, -0.010869087651371956, -0.009638606570661068, -0.018631568178534508, 0.017325645312666893, -0.02572488598525524, 0.06525673717260361, -0.003169774543493986, 0.0018425480229780078, -0.015034301206469536, 0.036656614392995834, 0.07927390933036804, 0.0315832644701004, 0.010973147116601467, 0.015448058024048805, -0.040185485035181046, -0.027002530172467232, -0.01694549433887005, -0.013323655351996422, -0.04520603269338608, 0.013715038076043129, -0.035499293357133865, 0.03485289588570595, 0.03238697722554207, 0.012115145102143288, -0.01220165565609932, 0.01743890717625618, 0.019687024876475334, 0.00365022337064147, -0.09872718900442123, 0.008933092467486858, -0.014102489687502384, 0.0012925397604703903, -0.03764629364013672, -0.0023363621439784765, -0.05206860601902008, 0.039010126143693924, 0.015708077698946, -0.017826933413743973, 0.009598726406693459, 0.009911148808896542, 0.07576221227645874, 0.020603764802217484, 0.0004783580079674721, -0.009966302663087845, -0.021316343918442726, 0.018545953556895256, 0.01209426112473011, -0.0184441190212965, 0.002736608264967799, -0.010262401774525642, -0.02943475916981697, 0.01187828741967678, -0.04347424954175949, -0.022427257150411606, 0.06409949064254761, 0.01754683628678322, 0.05504556745290756, 0.07025342434644699, 0.00017059298988897353, 0.0015511171659454703, -0.008989990688860416, -0.003936216235160828, -0.010290255770087242, 0.03209822624921799, 0.05208198353648186, -0.002800100017338991, 0.007142095360904932, 0.004726625047624111, 0.0217591505497694, 0.03405006602406502, 0.05128881707787514, -0.0016543497331440449, 0.048214390873909, 0.01639735884964466, 0.010243874974548817, -0.04914794862270355, 0.03031843528151512, -0.021338459104299545, 0.03747320547699928, -0.05369799956679344, -0.03707580640912056, 0.034433189779520035, 0.042860232293605804, -0.02753441408276558, -0.01861555315554142, -0.0011242664186283946, -0.035132478922605515, 0.010617711581289768, 0.03137901425361633, -0.038836248219013214, 0.012695111334323883, 0.0055353580974042416, 0.03783494979143143, -0.02933214232325554, 0.019098443910479546, -0.037723831832408905, -0.07103775441646576, -0.0009459136635996401, -0.0031954485457390547, -0.04262584075331688, 0.0423261895775795, -0.01829545572400093, -0.01970711164176464, -0.00875316746532917, -0.02168705128133297, 0.013695968315005302, 0.0008284433279186487, 0.03714156895875931, 0.01097541581839323, 0.05282247066497803, -0.012614459730684757, -0.01145127136260271, -0.010647119022905827, -0.00027106719790026546, 0.09471628069877625, 0.07925093919038773, 0.03514029085636139, -0.08346213400363922, 0.023450959473848343, 0.01306851301342249, 0.024945860728621483, -0.0003689008590299636, 0.012425987981259823, 0.00630193529650569, -0.022837495431303978, 0.08330851793289185, 0.04822606220841408, 0.005779349710792303, 0.012079043313860893, 0.03983104228973389, -0.0007428486132994294, -0.041529394686222076, 0.007840839214622974, 0.009684879332780838, 0.008872310630977154, -0.03205723315477371, -0.04606021195650101, 0.020614411681890488, 0.00334740336984396, -0.003791112219914794, -0.03083571419119835, -0.044988781213760376, 0.006575433537364006, 0.0487765409052372, 0.004553038626909256, 0.017150918021798134, 0.006490663159638643, 0.018177146092057228, -0.00039041825220920146, -0.007629189640283585, 0.017417164519429207, -0.016778670251369476, 0.004644734784960747, 0.03267877548933029, 0.01900973543524742, 0.001262520207092166, -0.00849711149930954, 0.01906498335301876, -0.045358095318078995, -0.041463617235422134, 0.01751423254609108, 0.04179815948009491, -0.03519372269511223, -0.027148064225912094, -0.026610927656292915, 0.02676555886864662, -0.011080077849328518, -0.04857895150780678, -0.02272951230406761, 0.015257637947797775, 0.011349800042808056, -0.050344716757535934, -0.021286150440573692, -0.048814352601766586, -0.0081399567425251, -0.0401746965944767, 0.04176436364650726, 0.013019004836678505, -0.005928340367972851, -0.029320860281586647, -0.07936527580022812, 0.035934094339609146, -0.0009593698778189719, 0.002531321719288826, 0.0219256728887558, -0.02183731272816658, -0.01913991943001747, -0.006695370655506849, 0.014187620021402836, 0.037700753659009933, 0.03425008803606033, -0.02612733282148838, 0.029636720195412636, -0.003107197117060423, -0.026393912732601166, 0.020148705691099167, -0.03412535414099693, -0.019447891041636467, 0.001912388252094388, -0.008029794320464134, 0.029699906706809998, 0.043905291706323624, 0.00146836182102561, 0.008612984791398048, -0.017750049009919167, 0.014635886996984482, 0.010010507889091969, -0.05615296959877014, -9.998884706874378e-7, 0.020072894170880318, -0.0124333705753088, -0.04270212724804878, -0.018104709684848785, 0.03388539329171181, 0.03218007832765579, 0.01413336768746376, -0.019281433895230293, 0.025287367403507233, -0.018264302983880043, 0.007597544230520725, 0.012891574762761593, -0.059679388999938965, 0.02349366992712021, -0.03136887401342392, 0.010347092524170876, -0.044362325221300125, -0.026905475184321404, -0.04496137797832489, -0.024502092972397804, -0.018248749896883965, -0.009772761724889278, -0.033747460693120956, -0.009659850969910622, -0.007923930883407593, 0.0077547309920191765, 0.00013429592945612967, -0.006398952566087246, -0.05024272948503494, -0.005009437445551157, 0.016157377511262894, 0.009680722840130329, -0.03171929717063904, 0.024356596171855927, 0.011249641887843609, 0.008389504626393318, 0.031248290091753006, 0.0017921793041750789, 0.04241710901260376, -0.010261894203722477, -0.009331462904810905, -0.027364620938897133, 0.06394743174314499, 0.00727121951058507, -0.02898857556283474, 0.01708913780748844, -0.05800316855311394, -0.02065635845065117, -0.014909997582435608, 0.023103319108486176, 0.022225981578230858, 0.03467502444982529, -0.03013400360941887, -0.01810505986213684, 0.04704112187027931, -0.013454382307827473, -0.05223003774881363, -0.01191285066306591, -0.012067758478224277, 0.013295678421854973, 0.014165111817419529, 0.015191606245934963, 0.019559254869818687, -0.024244021624326706, 0.015827694907784462, 0.07037808746099472, 0.01761688105762005, -0.003790896153077483, 0.021275432780385017, 0.005967121571302414, 0.01589505933225155, 0.008511901833117008, 0.007346508093178272, 0.015537268482148647, 0.040776632726192474, -0.02850375697016716, 0.028852544724941254, -0.032025691121816635, 0.02468722127377987, -0.0853252038359642, -0.020388539880514145, -0.009936484508216381, -0.016339745372533798, 0.010526151396334171, -0.05092006176710129, -0.016516460105776787, 0.02294859290122986, -0.016697045415639877, -0.012767582200467587, -0.010357899591326714, -0.005529467482119799, 0.011724863201379776, 0.02502479776740074, 0.0021534995175898075, 0.0013462330680340528, 0.03515644371509552, 0.018249504268169403, 0.03474314883351326, -0.019990207627415657, -0.006059642881155014, -0.04546784609556198, 0.0012349295429885387, 0.030030466616153717, 0.054004184901714325, -0.08513360470533371, 0.006855911109596491, -0.007175196427851915, -0.02260405756533146, 0.01344496849924326, -0.02149452455341816, 0.04349377751350403, 0.044716399163007736, 0.028414640575647354, -0.005258792079985142, 0.06095355376601219, -0.005434890743345022, 0.013028514571487904, -0.01107028964906931, -0.03157941251993179, 0.028036197647452354, -0.0084467064589262, 0.01121998019516468, 0.01280656736344099, 0.030250759795308113, 0.005031028296798468, -0.03835197165608406, 0.05171951651573181, -0.026661545038223267, -0.04724155738949776, -0.024384059011936188, -0.034758180379867554, 0.01145966351032257, -0.0447862446308136, -0.012900516390800476, -0.014716489240527153, 0.03782828524708748, 0.028878461569547653, -0.02392718754708767, -0.005410813260823488, 0.04065224900841713, 0.017190957441926003, -0.022991174831986427, 0.006365000270307064, -0.010005591437220573, -0.04565821960568428, -0.07398200035095215, -0.01088717207312584, -0.012889149598777294, -0.008076115511357784, -0.00015607681416440755, 0.007751991041004658, 0.005340293515473604, 0.023324307054281235, -0.009334300644695759, -0.0004957969067618251, -0.011418716050684452, 0.0022775582037866116, 0.011625360697507858, -0.07362222671508789, 0.07613812386989594, 0.010572738014161587, -0.06516117602586746, -0.09176899492740631, 0.008938045240938663, -0.03379491716623306, 0.03285643830895424, 0.05917574092745781, 0.004339203238487244, -0.0016108143609017134, -0.002601233310997486, 0.06132205203175545, 0.019563807174563408, -0.06496692448854446, 0.04531955346465111, 0.014601675793528557, -0.016928328201174736, -0.02479368820786476, -0.024358578026294708, -0.017271636053919792, 0.025946563109755516, -0.02168368175625801, -0.031193772330880165, 0.02696603164076805, -0.011558794416487217, -0.011511968448758125, 0.00682529341429472, -0.008114713244140148, -0.022691823542118073, 0.04056182876229286, -0.028132159262895584, -0.03977614641189575, 0.051100824028253555, 0.012140239588916302, -0.009592718444764614, 0.026175661012530327, -0.05460545793175697, -0.01681780070066452, -0.007431690581142902, -0.010553826577961445, -0.0029898378998041153, -0.047993071377277374, 0.010462460108101368, 0.010427318513393402, -0.02462443709373474, -0.030908677726984024, 0.05877157673239708, 0.029299097135663033, 0.04448522999882698, 0.02235460840165615, 0.0070105926133692265, -0.013051099143922329, 0.025056233629584312, -0.009501240216195583, 0.023196766152977943, 0.01919555477797985, -0.014344497583806515, 0.006529613398015499, 0.004011714365333319, -0.017226338386535645, 0.028957543894648552, 0.006897344253957272, 0.06455176323652267, -0.029756389558315277, -0.013571512885391712, -0.020786698907613754, -0.039657481014728546, 0.021039623767137527, 0.00753016397356987, -0.02075938507914543, 0.04199869930744171, -0.06798513233661652, 0.027338728308677673, -0.02882334776222706, -0.014942402020096779, -0.02948034182190895, -0.012497296556830406, 0.022694800049066544, 0.02584892325103283, -0.0026169198099523783, 0.02244478091597557, -0.00949187483638525, -0.01247460674494505, 0.00599250104278326, -0.03172171115875244, 0.02421293966472149, -0.0012211344437673688, -0.0040117669850587845, -0.05640995875000954, -0.022471072152256966, -0.035207439213991165, -0.030286023393273354, 0.05201883241534233, 0.0015159591566771269, 0.01594339683651924, -0.027324151247739792, -0.012383241206407547, 0.024156084284186363, 0.058089062571525574, -0.05877993255853653, -0.018680160865187645, -0.027218565344810486, -0.00940013024955988, 0.010911115445196629, 0.007504590786993504 ]
<p>Suppose $X$ and $Y$ are two random samples (not necessarily iid, but one can make this assumption) and that $Z=X+Y$. If one computes the order statistics of $X$ and $Y$, what can be said about the relative order statistic of $Z$?</p> <p>To be more clear, let $\tilde{X}_{0.99}$ and $\tilde{Y}_{0.99}$ be the 0.99th quantiles of $X$ and $Y$, respectively, does it exist a relationship $f(\cdot)$ with $\tilde{Z}_{0.99}$ (i.e., the 0.99th quantile of $Z$) such that $\tilde{Z}_{0.99}=f(\tilde{X}_{0.99},\tilde{Y}_{0.99})$?</p> <p>Sorry for the possibly ill-posed question... I'm not a statistician.</p>
73,929
[ -0.00037168257404118776, -0.029711371287703514, 0.02434511110186577, -0.002046970184892416, 0.018535524606704712, 0.05718358978629112, -0.010599964298307896, 0.010361876338720322, 0.0293133445084095, -0.044127561151981354, 0.018646154552698135, 0.03161480277776718, 0.07149028033018112, 0.012707572430372238, 0.020504780113697052, 0.0016149923903867602, -0.04371030628681183, 0.02086408995091915, -0.0064775459468364716, -0.018728774040937424, -0.01377620454877615, 0.03291502594947815, 0.041792478412389755, 0.015850745141506195, -0.019672349095344543, 0.025688719004392624, 0.02234036661684513, -0.0030928198248147964, -0.010685059241950512, 0.06916410475969315, 0.007317650131881237, -0.03625383973121643, 0.009823538362979889, 0.054597966372966766, 0.0330682136118412, 0.0064830598421394825, -0.040146972984075546, -0.021631455048918724, 0.009512068703770638, 0.018192468211054802, -0.05090181529521942, -0.017829669639468193, 0.005425595678389072, 0.012451964430510998, -0.022978801280260086, -0.008078849874436855, -0.004733633249998093, -0.03497151657938957, 0.0594358965754509, -0.0349528044462204, 0.050299957394599915, 0.008885335177183151, 0.01265658251941204, 0.02740931697189808, 0.0018325718119740486, -0.003660084679722786, 0.02955690212547779, 0.07709570229053497, 0.0027973027899861336, -0.028063835576176643, -0.014254249632358551, -0.0381547175347805, -0.015196465887129307, -0.0027400110848248005, -0.012585333548486233, 0.028197932988405228, -0.03462013602256775, -0.026032917201519012, 0.02034786157310009, -0.0021248224657028913, 0.03429414704442024, 0.035784609615802765, 0.04050135985016823, -0.04184776917099953, -0.006767251994460821, -0.04029974713921547, 0.019573941826820374, 0.013322827406227589, 0.04965722933411598, 0.030303627252578735, -0.0031163343228399754, 0.002278599888086319, 0.02922680228948593, 0.04144915193319321, 0.016210200265049934, -0.031441740691661835, 0.07723096758127213, -0.056633614003658295, 0.03305814042687416, 0.0167889054864645, -0.002877980237826705, -0.01724107936024666, 0.020849183201789856, -0.015243606641888618, -0.041741326451301575, -0.011625741608440876, -0.010254171676933765, 0.013671680353581905, -0.016400672495365143, 0.0023641707375645638, 0.006160783115774393, -0.03960724174976349, -0.02449451945722103, 0.07530343532562256, -0.022350719198584557, -0.019591202959418297, -0.02509416826069355, 0.006208281964063644, -0.028793668374419212, -0.008282256312668324, 0.017756981775164604, 0.019429489970207214, 0.007534297648817301, -0.01606176234781742, 0.004645757842808962, 0.041703302413225174, 0.027500061318278313, -0.010157219134271145, 0.06257224828004837, 0.03280821070075035, 0.06347935646772385, 0.0011747947428375483, -0.02423190511763096, -0.00625883461907506, -0.012904580682516098, 0.026323841884732246, 0.02809479460120201, 0.014238288626074791, -0.043592989444732666, 0.05111972615122795, 0.006791997235268354, 0.009567984379827976, 0.0030105565674602985, -0.012638526037335396, 0.017416300252079964, 0.002497871872037649, -0.051941078156232834, -0.05033835768699646, 0.04753706231713295, 0.011252444237470627, 0.008569215424358845, -0.05426623672246933, -0.007623330224305391, 0.021075189113616943, 0.0035447152331471443, 0.04540926590561867, 0.053561732172966, -0.04372349753975868, 0.0025299591943621635, 0.0470208078622818, -0.026917321607470512, -0.027503790333867073, 0.010638023726642132, -0.058567773550748825, 0.016793176531791687, -0.04097617417573929, 0.0023468269500881433, -0.030612429603934288, -0.03544872999191284, -0.050942398607730865, 0.025734884664416313, 0.013183067552745342, -0.014380977489054203, -0.02928668074309826, 0.004387947730720043, -0.031623728573322296, 0.05215400829911232, -0.006482679396867752, 0.00648696580901742, -0.004604693036526442, 0.0024677449837327003, 0.02942531555891037, 0.03513260930776596, 0.04791242256760597, 0.05746417120099068, -0.03353948891162872, -0.004363594111055136, -0.06389303505420685, 0.008091299794614315, 0.045188166201114655, -0.04192270338535309, 0.0014730844413861632, -0.03184414654970169, -0.019125457853078842, -0.00872025266289711, 0.03408639505505562, -0.0008664686465635896, -0.02555505372583866, 0.04886435717344284, -0.043035656213760376, -0.040463224053382874, -0.046730902045965195, -0.013870935887098312, 0.02088548243045807, -0.0394095852971077, 0.02709273062646389, 0.03244785964488983, 0.02201775647699833, 0.011301347985863686, -0.023609206080436707, 0.008762447163462639, -0.015015264973044395, 0.025242475792765617, -0.041477397084236145, 0.04238187521696091, 0.017351772636175156, 0.0360214002430439, -0.0030819145031273365, 0.024526026099920273, -0.07045609503984451, -0.06265424191951752, 0.0010828253580257297, -0.005958264227956533, -0.006184861063957214, -0.0029959732200950384, -0.023557692766189575, 0.024059100076556206, -0.000008333331606991123, 0.0013274501543492079, 0.021526319906115532, -0.05597558245062828, 0.07049762457609177, 0.0806160718202591, -0.0008987215114757419, -0.03633469343185425, 0.03807550668716431, 0.04811374470591545, 0.004318492487072945, -0.025912867859005928, -0.059136491268873215, -0.02244618907570839, -0.009786167182028294, 0.05497566983103752, 0.050277046859264374, -0.0486266203224659, 0.018503719940781593, 0.07252056896686554, 0.0020923251286149025, 0.017136164009571075, 0.03444007784128189, -0.018315553665161133, -0.017060089856386185, -0.008169985376298428, 0.014375661499798298, 0.04459189996123314, 0.0027752374298870564, 0.01670563593506813, -0.00780863780528307, 0.023413442075252533, -0.014711926691234112, -0.032015975564718246, 0.005906879901885986, 0.0007115922053344548, 0.00421561487019062, 0.02764590084552765, 0.008828690275549889, 0.056398358196020126, -0.05126871168613434, -0.0012763806153088808, 0.033500298857688904, 0.013686291873455048, -0.005526058841496706, 0.04085305333137512, 0.01742182858288288, 0.01617938093841076, 0.027150234207510948, -0.0465533621609211, 0.025434449315071106, 0.02084404230117798, -0.0008675516583025455, -0.01184031181037426, -0.03493237495422363, -0.02035346068441868, -0.013464860618114471, -0.02256930246949196, 0.03498788923025131, 0.02758065238595009, 0.03291194885969162, -0.001656050211749971, -0.032217517495155334, -0.007882470265030861, -0.02359016053378582, 0.014205253683030605, 0.019498707726597786, -0.039941463619470596, 0.013189791701734066, 0.0009027506457641721, -0.01911914348602295, -0.014062338508665562, 0.00013379250594880432, 0.0026915587950497866, -0.017153114080429077, -0.02394310012459755, -0.06510110199451447, -0.0283800195902586, -0.060965731739997864, 0.025618474930524826, -0.041946277022361755, -0.006697327829897404, 0.031723931431770325, -0.010597125627100468, -0.03115716390311718, 0.008311768993735313, -0.007327432278543711, -0.03160005435347557, -0.02437104843556881, 0.05175696685910225, 0.002692026551812887, -0.007337425369769335, 0.012742471881210804, -0.0030305415857583284, 0.0005405062693171203, -0.022325975820422173, -0.019820982590317726, -0.08404219150543213, 0.006494901608675718, 0.004683429375290871, 0.03918261453509331, 0.026542773470282555, -0.02308471128344536, 0.06155097484588623, 0.034254349768161774, -0.02471470646560192, -0.03417985513806343, 0.005160425323992968, 0.011792177334427834, 0.022084742784500122, 0.018361536785960197, -0.0007200346444733441, -0.025563495233654976, 0.04261678829789162, 0.046992428600788116, 0.0216318741440773, 0.025938479229807854, -0.017037589102983475, 0.031937241554260254, -0.0003555951116140932, 0.05176546052098274, 0.0036144217010587454, 0.02270800992846489, 0.009496557526290417, -0.031535208225250244, 0.013109871186316013, 0.01876876689493656, 0.03709724545478821, 0.03705812990665436, -0.022645840421319008, 0.05514184385538101, -0.008926613256335258, -0.011893133632838726, -0.005999046843498945, 0.05322768911719322, 0.017924819141626358, -0.027107635512948036, -0.02347392775118351, 0.004072064068168402, 0.021280143409967422, -0.022190017625689507, 0.0359639935195446, 0.04599550738930702, 0.02845059148967266, -0.04420669749379158, 0.020583968609571457, -0.024493420496582985, -0.010503868572413921, 0.02743075229227543, -0.05661775544285774, -0.011236287653446198, -0.00964408740401268, 0.031006041914224625, -0.017381472513079643, -0.023842986673116684, -0.02889179438352585, 0.03102939762175083, -0.044629741460084915, -0.03419998288154602, -0.03178669512271881, 0.03759845718741417, 0.004666480235755444, 0.09364520013332367, 0.002245259704068303, -0.00036337494384497404, 0.0012950727250427008, 0.00449540326371789, -0.03893091529607773, 0.023259326815605164, -0.008452952839434147, 0.016242101788520813, -0.009888386353850365, -0.0134823527187109, 0.03831998258829117, -0.047139380127191544, 0.012331192381680012, -0.020971426740288734, -0.0009156170417554677, -0.010063905268907547, 0.004521383438259363, -0.03519587963819504, -0.0669233649969101, 0.03149184584617615, -0.00539401825517416, -0.02395382709801197, -0.07202401757240295, 0.05010466277599335, 0.0008229288505390286, -0.024885669350624084, -0.01854189671576023, -0.0497821643948555, 0.028941122815012932, 0.013453790917992592, 0.02096470631659031, -0.003304301993921399, 0.01233768556267023, -0.01807328127324581, 0.03281169384717941, -0.016425196081399918, 0.050806015729904175, 0.043546441942453384, -0.012172050774097443, -0.03364797681570053, -0.02492145448923111, -0.033182840794324875, 0.002738917013630271, 0.029049675911664963, 0.011305275373160839, -0.011552189476788044, 0.06486042588949203, 0.023465726524591446, -0.038527712225914, 0.02105017565190792, 0.054765485227108, 0.03179733455181122, 0.00584350386634469, -0.035759925842285156, 0.023865528404712677, -0.008632517419755459, -0.01827920414507389, 0.026991264894604683, 0.004704311490058899, 0.0057401093654334545, -0.014583822339773178, 0.031501732766628265, 0.014732368290424347, -0.026051590219140053, -0.028851864859461784, 0.006772244349122047, 0.03843913599848747, 0.006295656319707632, -0.04056845232844353, -0.024332506582140923, 0.003688384545966983, 0.04823746159672737, 0.028979282826185226, -0.0012125169159844518, -0.04779757931828499, 0.05565866827964783, 0.04638031870126724, 0.04796746000647545, -0.06661591678857803, 0.018047582358121872, -0.04632037505507469, -0.016209792345762253, 0.03253933787345886, -0.022455405443906784, 0.04238751903176308, -0.036075517535209656, -0.004384979140013456, 0.0019589182920753956, -0.03846225142478943, -0.05553170666098595, 0.017829522490501404, 0.00976813305169344, -0.015195661224424839, -0.011755875311791897, -0.028182124719023705, -0.05245880037546158, 0.029326217249035835, 0.0390290841460228, 0.03900919109582901, -0.014407186768949032, -0.01595619134604931, -0.02983560599386692, 0.010115298442542553, -0.000649583525955677, -0.0558614656329155, 0.03851050138473511, -0.00012958672596141696, 0.03865059092640877, 0.05734479799866676, -0.018677281215786934, -0.022321034222841263, 0.04341329261660576, 0.010118227452039719, -0.011996433138847351, 0.05543208122253418, 0.03102690353989601, 0.046853553503751755, 0.05190827324986458, 0.05448294058442116, 0.03542231395840645, 0.009847762994468212, 0.002096368232741952, -0.030436087399721146, 0.00658343406394124, 0.0411047488451004, -0.025349140167236328, 0.012410124763846397, -0.02495064213871956, 0.022255321964621544, -0.0474933497607708, 0.02199999988079071, -0.021322989836335182, 0.0381995365023613, -0.037897124886512756, 0.0007490786374546587, -0.024744926020503044, -0.0009954001288861036, -0.015071396715939045, -0.013964391313493252, -0.022960029542446136, 0.03139502927660942, -0.01571376621723175, 0.007942856289446354, 0.011510075069963932, -0.005329237785190344, -0.03921666368842125, 0.0005292948335409164, -0.04523793235421181, 0.057493772357702255, -0.02690044417977333, -0.009859561920166016, 0.024860186502337456, -0.015159540809690952, 0.0048644887283444405, -0.03728317841887474, -0.01992856152355671, 0.010056395083665848, -0.024577971547842026, -0.006391866598278284, 0.024387724697589874, 0.02586173452436924, 0.03831607848405838, -0.03013928420841694, 0.033369652926921844, 0.03611661493778229, -0.027404163032770157, -0.0958508774638176, -0.011344900354743004, 0.024201620370149612, 0.0017877836944535375, -0.01616840995848179, -0.04177163541316986, 0.03648872673511505, 0.007341325748711824, 0.004997494164854288, 0.00873001292347908, 0.060725901275873184, -0.03057284653186798, -0.033868059515953064, -0.007536747492849827, -0.0036464794538915157, 0.057640429586172104, -0.010566618293523788, -0.003602072363719344, 0.036534298211336136, -0.001919737085700035, -0.005482982844114304, 0.018872417509555817, 0.015880929306149483, -0.023502232506871223, 0.02194727212190628, -0.0320524238049984, -0.03926916792988777, 0.0470973439514637, -0.01591351255774498, -0.006710764952003956, 0.03446274250745773, 0.028936823830008507, 0.032134007662534714, -0.013809003867208958, -0.008593172766268253, 0.004443900194019079, 0.004726715851575136, -0.019047072157263756, -0.0042641484178602695, 0.02108572982251644, 0.006646179594099522, 0.006289634387940168, 0.012334042228758335, -0.02321009710431099, -0.0031011898536235094, 0.08606129884719849, -0.003414387349039316, -0.026153763756155968, -0.004053712822496891, -0.007779483683407307, 0.036472138017416, -0.02138209156692028, -0.017841165885329247, -0.013715856708586216, 0.020764388144016266, -0.0438261516392231, -0.030517956241965294, -0.015521389432251453, -0.0026867706328630447, 0.07445519417524338, 0.012393312528729439, 0.04526430368423462, 0.016358422115445137, -0.029725562781095505, -0.04299161955714226, -0.0039727408438920975, -0.007895688526332378, -0.0006815938395448029, -0.01576494611799717, 0.01826161891222, 0.0022305124439299107, -0.0049506546929478645, 0.016086742281913757, 0.010779494419693947, -0.0002504463482182473, 0.0456085279583931, -0.0005637925933115184, -0.007082543335855007, 0.05146632343530655, -0.031918469816446304, -0.026313647627830505, 0.059969522058963776, -0.008805532939732075, -0.005048308055847883, -0.03777282312512398, -0.028857985511422157, 0.057061877101659775, 0.026459934189915657, 0.015969278290867805, -0.05463193729519844, -0.06458841264247894, -0.07112596929073334, 0.0005147522897459567, -0.03121812455356121, 0.006425878964364529, 0.035727038979530334, -0.04378814250230789, -0.009596440009772778, 0.028825227171182632, 0.04469878226518631, -0.020754745230078697, -0.0776430293917656, 0.0023982746060937643, 0.0002713990688789636, -0.04085659980773926, 0.01843005046248436, -0.0030141673050820827, -0.012440582737326622, 0.03892812132835388, -0.05828900262713432, 0.003068041754886508, 0.002400120487436652, 0.022851981222629547, -0.00977341178804636, 0.0960322767496109, 0.05533565580844879, 0.052279066294431686, 0.02669893205165863, -0.03743879124522209, 0.10946189612150192, 0.023479603230953217, 0.029970930889248848, -0.044285159558057785, 0.028937481343746185, -0.005913786590099335, -0.03375765308737755, -0.01824459433555603, 0.02656078152358532, -0.003369525307789445, 0.028377022594213486, 0.055703774094581604, 0.05607486516237259, 0.020009132102131844, -0.044133108109235764, 0.05393180623650551, -0.02249876596033573, -0.007310522720217705, -0.00708296662196517, 0.03386731073260307, 0.0025499414186924696, -0.027839919552206993, -0.06950192153453827, -0.022448178380727768, -0.06005312129855156, 0.002032397547736764, -0.034509554505348206, -0.03406383842229843, -0.03745943307876587, 0.0034339139237999916, -0.03878822550177574, -0.014169717207551003, 0.04428381845355034, 0.0014963810099288821, -0.03468789905309677, 0.019832085818052292, 0.035048794001340866, -0.0002925595617853105, 0.024383405223488808, 0.05080238729715347, 0.03518655151128769, 0.017773590981960297, 0.01881471648812294, 0.014270567335188389, -0.07646892964839935, 0.019179271534085274, -0.042474403977394104, -0.004029217641800642, 0.0050681889988482, -0.00044705424807034433, -0.04265252500772476, -0.04563360661268234, 0.0080319968983531, -0.0021936874836683273, -0.025304118171334267, 0.035462431609630585, 0.009601658210158348, -0.014697191305458546, 0.012427703477442265, -0.007055017165839672, 0.013033177703619003, -0.01995115354657173, 0.03561697527766228, 0.04312700778245926, -0.06843243539333344, -0.025185290724039078, -0.014167463406920433, 0.06620743125677109, 0.01025712676346302, -0.023963674902915955, -0.026965362951159477, -0.028199205175042152, -0.026676032692193985, -0.005917543079704046, -0.04639706015586853, -0.02817760966718197, 0.04695044085383415, -0.0042930906638503075, -0.006590215023607016, -0.029843781143426895, -0.03327156603336334, 0.020860303193330765, -0.011404572054743767, 0.002650768728926778, -0.04536125063896179, 0.027641959488391876, 0.025435671210289, 0.019588826224207878, -0.00041200092528015375, 0.007534251548349857, -0.00059996492927894, 0.06056995317339897, 0.007590977940708399, -0.0641840249300003, -0.00263003702275455, -0.012365413829684258, -0.015058152377605438, -0.015385828912258148, -0.0058665149845182896, 0.055295221507549286, 0.025819966569542885, 0.03853708505630493, 0.009801038540899754, 0.01690252311527729, -0.04459406062960625, 0.029941145330667496, 0.03222322463989258, -0.05387922748923302, 0.0003556697047315538, 0.00011952070781262591, 0.015236151404678822, -0.03447510674595833, -0.014980177395045757, -0.018900427967309952, -0.006133521441370249, -0.018866734579205513, -0.0315508209168911, -0.029594406485557556, -0.06228433549404144, 0.004931872710585594, -0.019987454637885094, -0.01911214180290699, -0.0054044658318161964, -0.020559556782245636, -0.000900142767932266, 0.015634525567293167, 0.0027955900877714157, -0.027118539437651634, -0.0007850360707379878, -0.0065348707139492035, -0.018524082377552986, -0.005550528410822153, 0.017613675445318222, 0.018894106149673462, -0.01901932992041111, -0.004897837061434984, -0.01143250335007906, 0.04908308386802673, -0.04908916726708412, -0.01029769517481327, 0.040439020842313766, -0.0383622907102108, -0.0032749169040471315, 0.05024579539895058, -0.006621526554226875, 0.005483141168951988, 0.008843987248837948, 0.019202372059226036, -0.03386693075299263, 0.011838582344353199, -0.0025854005943983793, -0.016578353941440582, -0.005044614430516958, -0.01249056588858366, -0.008479217998683453, -0.01314200833439827, -0.006005097180604935, -0.011381632648408413, -0.0035189439076930285, 0.009786749258637428, 0.02142992988228798, -0.014505033381283283, 0.005282898899167776, 0.01698308438062668, 0.007610199972987175, 0.01943570375442505, 0.0015344800194725394, 0.022633686661720276, 0.06838402152061462, 0.043831728398799896, -0.03887639194726944, 0.01053482573479414, -0.01791229285299778, 0.012571511790156364, -0.07993197441101074, -0.028301632031798363, 0.012465381063520908, 0.016001736745238304, 0.004926756490021944, -0.020050548017024994, 0.005791609641164541, -0.02792753465473652, -0.06844260543584824, 0.05163818225264549, -0.01043742336332798, -0.02283105067908764, -0.06277317553758621, 0.01803927682340145, -0.01287606917321682, 0.021252918988466263, 0.022128958255052567, 0.033139798790216446, 0.07280192524194717, 0.03622701019048691, 0.004585739690810442, -0.009427888318896294, -0.04578801989555359, -0.011319009587168694, -0.006353944540023804, -0.05760056525468826, 0.059259481728076935, -0.03742304816842079, -0.04648664593696594, 0.02959904633462429, 0.003522024257108569, 0.016535747796297073, 0.007545975036919117, 0.04735111817717552, 0.01882939413189888, 0.03536925092339516, 0.007619926240295172, -0.0143880695104599, -0.053051963448524475, -0.03406357020139694, 0.04393848776817322, 0.02666701190173626, -0.025538865476846695, 0.02766220085322857, 0.029667029157280922, 0.001864936901256442, -0.025748301297426224, 0.012622551992535591, -0.020319359377026558, -0.03946267440915108, 0.030381837859749794, -0.0044350228272378445, 0.03682049736380577, -0.0262138694524765, 0.05802804231643677, -0.03680106997489929, -0.003600871888920665, 0.024494176730513573, 0.028468869626522064, 0.0015872186049818993, -0.011080400086939335, -0.016685230657458305, -0.05078943073749542, 0.006462883669883013, -0.002528611570596695, 0.02447296306490898, -0.08225414901971817, -0.019302314147353172, 0.0030697640031576157, -0.004844817332923412, -0.02196427993476391, -0.040141332894563675, -0.012771433219313622, 0.04822419211268425, -0.022493932396173477, 0.006494547240436077, 0.0002243248891318217, -0.002279020380228758, 0.011408881284296513, -0.08403932303190231, 0.05654788017272949, 0.024996396154165268, -0.010083363391458988, -0.019121168181300163, -0.034977372735738754, -0.004071994684636593, -0.017913641408085823, 0.044507335871458054, 0.015940610319375992, -0.016746828332543373, -0.02130567841231823, 0.03253554925322533, 0.018733438104391098, -0.04187243804335594, 0.0032658714335411787, -0.028508804738521576, 0.008603960275650024, -0.014905242249369621, -0.006382583640515804, -0.02398357354104519, 0.007846343331038952, 0.05010093003511429, 0.0060959928669035435, -0.013824029825627804, -0.010530979372560978, -0.011209082789719105, 0.04742041230201721, 0.0018396355444565415, 0.00457380386069417, 0.0683731883764267, 0.027365896850824356, 0.007794154807925224, -0.010935768485069275, -0.014674557372927666, -0.06445661932229996, 0.03222445026040077, -0.007821853272616863, 0.002949735149741173, -0.046291377395391464, 0.018326234072446823, 0.003158359555527568, -0.06846006214618683, -0.021004997193813324, 0.015024415217339993, -0.047533102333545685, 0.01636144332587719, 0.025914093479514122, 0.07659703493118286, 0.05045569688081741, 0.00427940534427762, 0.006387663073837757, -0.0017571841599419713, -0.05097177252173424, 0.006347802933305502, 0.019209884107112885, 0.017363261431455612, 0.016837691888213158, 0.025262413546442986, 0.017598746344447136, -0.011102376505732536, 0.0028550345450639725, -0.02398284338414669, 0.02129625529050827, 0.01743590645492077, 0.01392332836985588, 0.032218415290117264, -0.004881954751908779, 0.02393339015543461, 0.027728471904993057, 0.012635031715035439, 0.06975685805082321, -0.03073391504585743, 0.0110733387991786, -0.04142818972468376, 0.011976252309978008, -0.05570158734917641, 0.013658477924764156, -0.013185033574700356, -0.03474736958742142, -0.028029369190335274, 0.017853518947958946, 0.01965004950761795, -0.013258960098028183, 0.013604303821921349, 0.00197004247456789, -0.029688198119401932, -0.03305253013968468, -0.014264135621488094, 0.01256504375487566, -0.03559800982475281, -0.03495282679796219, -0.02289998158812523, 0.027445761486887932, 0.020468037575483322, 0.04556267336010933, 0.009532955475151539, -0.02228452078998089, -0.026850882917642593, 0.061609622091054916, -0.06009009853005409, -0.014809339307248592, -0.04907918721437454, 0.010643304325640202, 0.00885978527367115, -0.07242298126220703 ]
<p>I'm learning about boosting. I think I understand how adaptive boosting works for classification. I'm trying to get some intuition for regression boosting.</p> <p>At each iteration, adaptive boosting forces the next weak learner to focus more on incorrectly classified points. Intuitively, I can see why that should lead to a good classifier. I could be wrong, but L2 boosting doesn't seem to do anything like that. In L2 boosting, at each iteration, you're fitting a weak learner to the previous iteration's residuals. In a regression tree, when you're splitting a node, aren't you "fitting" the residuals from that node and that node's parents? In both cases, you're "fitting" unweighted residuals, so I don't understand why they're different.</p> <p>Maybe the the main advantage of L2 boosting over a single tree is that the former has many more regularization/bootstrap-ish options (e.g., randomly choosing subsets of features, the learning rate, the number of trees, individual tree depth, etc.)?</p>
36,488
[ -0.02592061273753643, 0.029972294345498085, -0.0389249287545681, -0.006017705425620079, 0.02049575187265873, 0.0001988891017390415, 0.021893978118896484, -0.03997596353292465, 0.0453384667634964, -0.009138977155089378, 0.026012808084487915, 0.02957131154835224, 0.05277223140001297, 0.010046962648630142, 0.011264493688941002, 0.025051873177289963, 0.014707837253808975, -0.005770422518253326, 0.014265576377511024, 0.009657103568315506, -0.022552575916051865, 0.02786070853471756, 0.020678792148828506, 0.017345447093248367, -0.023872993886470795, 0.0281977616250515, 0.023828448727726936, 0.015588869340717793, 0.03979682922363281, 0.031054595485329628, -0.020372169092297554, 0.004134920425713062, -0.017301922664046288, 0.04271627962589264, 0.03263460099697113, -0.023804208263754845, -0.02404044009745121, -0.016179265454411507, -0.011522151529788971, 0.032194871455430984, -0.0029246744234114885, -0.0394006185233593, -0.026778655126690865, 0.03484155982732773, -0.03119843639433384, 0.02339889481663704, -0.01646202988922596, -0.03664353862404823, 0.03581329807639122, -0.03504301607608795, 0.03832200542092323, -0.007796010933816433, 0.01629582978785038, 0.0681091696023941, -0.03109978884458542, -0.01590808480978012, 0.05154445022344589, 0.05841589346528053, -0.015724997967481613, -0.015555156394839287, -0.0047337268479168415, -0.019261840730905533, 0.02318761870265007, 0.04094522073864937, -0.03528479486703873, 0.05307360738515854, 0.0018253790913149714, -0.02956663817167282, 0.035524480044841766, 0.008954579010605812, 0.008399431593716145, 0.010810118168592453, 0.025607852265238762, -0.024975432083010674, 0.007525160908699036, -0.01092921569943428, -0.006384295877069235, 0.025037536397576332, 0.0656779557466507, 0.014738637022674084, 0.03305833414196968, 0.017401661723852158, 0.039895590394735336, 0.05226162075996399, 0.027432989329099655, 0.0029460093937814236, 0.0763448178768158, -0.021621735766530037, 0.0007211327902041376, 0.04424101486802101, 0.010011829435825348, 0.016471652314066887, 0.01925405114889145, -0.02466738224029541, -0.016308410093188286, 0.05391502007842064, 0.0020771422423422337, 0.00821241270750761, 0.06592737138271332, 0.023376381024718285, 0.009104378521442413, -0.0182730071246624, 0.00023628101916983724, 0.038471102714538574, -0.018282564356923103, -0.01911461539566517, -0.01780874654650688, 0.024666866287589073, 0.0016192358452826738, -0.0037303247954696417, -0.018666833639144897, 0.011929874308407307, -0.013983643613755703, -0.004852105397731066, 0.04501236975193024, -0.016886169090867043, -0.024434253573417664, 0.009163492359220982, 0.015215843915939331, 0.05461377650499344, 0.01021720189601183, -0.056718457490205765, 0.023003412410616875, 0.02325466275215149, -0.03717043623328209, 0.04534502699971199, 0.023193631321191788, -0.0434577614068985, -0.060533881187438965, 0.05850312486290932, -0.023885508999228477, -0.05496108904480934, 0.021318791434168816, 0.017749695107340813, 0.032262034714221954, -0.003135327948257327, -0.07431376725435257, -0.07420956343412399, 0.012669051066040993, -0.004829766694456339, 0.0236387737095356, -0.021007439121603966, -0.017626643180847168, 0.027844075113534927, 0.07269106805324554, 0.021324563771486282, 0.03207893669605255, 0.01645660027861595, 0.01657770946621895, 0.021548276767134666, -0.014310636557638645, -0.030150828883051872, -0.03769133239984512, -0.016100317239761353, -0.025828873738646507, -0.10741844773292542, 0.026739442721009254, 0.016728492453694344, -0.0349164642393589, -0.050794728100299835, 0.034297067672014236, -0.03400331363081932, -0.0044486382976174355, 0.0026089856401085854, -0.004832264501601458, 0.006143901962786913, 0.05642440915107727, 0.03023620694875717, 0.03885745629668236, 0.03890836238861084, -0.04976816847920418, -0.002800252055749297, 0.02523455023765564, 0.02992897853255272, 0.02610483579337597, -0.008697234094142914, -0.034872498363256454, -0.018793528899550438, 0.0282966960221529, -0.00590334739536047, -0.05865941196680069, -0.05259070545434952, -0.028103431686758995, -0.0022374852560460567, 0.0009478537831455469, 0.05328506976366043, 0.009920762851834297, -0.03750023990869522, 0.033680133521556854, -0.07870927453041077, -0.04777839034795761, -0.08573812991380692, -0.008773268200457096, -0.023245923221111298, 0.0017334347357973456, 0.037954073399305344, 0.027447791770100594, -0.0006783661665394902, -0.021712996065616608, 0.00204750569537282, -0.03427750617265701, 0.00856457743793726, 0.019082017242908478, -0.025037329643964767, 0.015579127706587315, 0.06040601804852486, -0.012102308683097363, 0.01777593046426773, 0.0709649920463562, -0.05343480780720711, -0.06759852170944214, 0.03688327223062515, -0.03124791756272316, 0.005228287074714899, -0.050181541591882706, -0.0069176931865513325, 0.019498491659760475, -0.01789981685578823, -0.026957185938954353, 0.019337238743901253, -0.06571631133556366, 0.08139317482709885, 0.07240504026412964, 0.0038561534602195024, -0.032943278551101685, -0.007153007201850414, -0.009354624897241592, -0.0005870453314855695, -0.025905169546604156, -0.0047134836204349995, -0.035587530583143234, -0.01905130036175251, 0.03539055958390236, 0.025472834706306458, -0.03376651182770729, -0.0072675482369959354, 0.053029514849185944, 0.03720260038971901, 0.002380082616582513, 0.038065411150455475, -0.03414430096745491, 0.004683866631239653, 0.013995129615068436, 0.011423158459365368, -0.012703200802206993, 0.004821227863430977, 0.040904346853494644, 0.0028753471560776234, 0.02330312319099903, 0.010406148619949818, -0.02759452350437641, 0.04091065004467964, 0.008015337400138378, -0.01069670356810093, -0.021164534613490105, -0.03972618654370308, 0.04013120383024216, -0.00894269347190857, 0.0304598119109869, 0.04602573439478874, -0.012965521775186062, -0.008115045726299286, -0.028077099472284317, -0.0027151291724294424, 0.047654978930950165, 0.010260808281600475, -0.007487246301025152, -0.001050966908223927, 0.016800401732325554, -0.010530234314501286, 0.030069975182414055, -0.047191277146339417, -0.003067990066483617, -0.05139227956533432, 0.027010083198547363, 0.015013417229056358, -0.007227533962577581, 0.03588881343603134, -0.005604885518550873, -0.013837064616382122, -0.02263345755636692, -0.039858099073171616, 0.053972963243722916, 0.0176713764667511, -0.04410206526517868, 0.002627481007948518, -0.02167288213968277, -0.03284807503223419, 0.051764391362667084, 0.013510025106370449, -0.01101479772478342, -0.010270931757986546, -0.021879348903894424, -0.0439886637032032, -0.05632992088794708, -0.05213848501443863, 0.0281646978110075, 0.004453365225344896, -0.012673855759203434, 0.04673798009753227, 0.0018109815428033471, -0.022291941568255424, 0.00986359640955925, -0.0608174093067646, -0.010261778719723225, -0.033054694533348083, -0.030143575742840767, -0.014168612658977509, 0.007569765672087669, 0.005910177249461412, 0.05342881381511688, -0.03585732355713844, 0.0014846886042505503, -0.04436586797237396, -0.02543240785598755, 0.020090963691473007, -0.0016947569092735648, 0.01958083175122738, 0.029078537598252296, -0.012703223153948784, 0.09790763258934021, 0.015258288942277431, -0.013054657727479935, -0.01980973593890667, 0.0012645958922803402, -0.0340237021446228, -0.003545670071616769, 0.01393204741179943, 0.005327073857188225, 0.03628408536314964, 0.03156876191496849, -0.013419480063021183, 0.02476317621767521, 0.07876718789339066, 0.005297044292092323, 0.005561131983995438, 0.012669339776039124, -0.0003028727078344673, -0.023189768195152283, -0.005277122836560011, 0.019176967442035675, -0.059446390718221664, 0.005363059230148792, 0.003797097597271204, 0.014092719182372093, 0.01308895368129015, -0.021966775879263878, 0.03699614480137825, -0.008130516856908798, 0.00923002790659666, -0.02778713032603264, 0.01870790868997574, 0.0004962303792126477, -0.023195462301373482, -0.011689300648868084, -0.0056307935155928135, 0.022374242544174194, -0.037361204624176025, -0.013632271438837051, 0.027725612744688988, 0.033602677285671234, 0.0014628613134846091, -0.022889388725161552, 0.005402610171586275, -0.01373913325369358, 0.030095335096120834, -0.027573633939027786, -0.002509582554921508, 0.03489375114440918, 0.04379686713218689, 0.003943290561437607, 0.024167822673916817, -0.053363531827926636, 0.04550027847290039, -0.04161468893289566, 0.02606748603284359, 0.0071251606568694115, 0.06070498377084732, -0.01642448827624321, 0.027180811390280724, -0.010264996439218521, -0.0037311024498194456, 0.026042401790618896, 0.022220902144908905, -0.09330938756465912, 0.012754061259329319, -0.007535689976066351, -0.03379955142736435, 0.004032600205391645, -0.005514403805136681, 0.019780630245804787, -0.05507948249578476, -0.012114849872887135, -0.033809877932071686, 0.026066729798913002, -0.004241515416651964, 0.004763119388371706, -0.02852991409599781, -0.0053155748173594475, -0.021641865372657776, 0.0003465874178800732, 0.00013552585733123124, 0.005127397365868092, 0.03134307637810707, 0.033781424164772034, 0.010688584297895432, 0.006208293605595827, -0.0465320460498333, 0.01939203590154648, 0.02661643736064434, 0.024296555668115616, 0.06714657694101334, 0.007546855602413416, -0.027028916403651237, 0.019462961703538895, 0.005505763925611973, 0.04386642947793007, 0.02512337826192379, -0.008847895078361034, -0.0011014592600986362, -0.05093450844287872, -0.042626459151506424, -0.0009486601920798421, 0.02397938072681427, 0.002641092985868454, -0.005636234767735004, 0.04638288915157318, 0.029318835586309433, -0.039517007768154144, 0.0013775221304968, 0.08535695821046829, -0.028877699747681618, -0.01769738458096981, -0.05839013680815697, 0.020429180935025215, 0.015478817746043205, 0.014998026192188263, 0.06126222014427185, -0.014509320259094238, -0.04336549714207649, -0.009508487768471241, 0.028683818876743317, -0.02565622515976429, -0.032926008105278015, -0.004353418480604887, 0.03281700238585472, 0.03962364047765732, 0.011467731557786465, -0.034501366317272186, -0.0029570774640887976, 0.05858952924609184, 0.03533059358596802, 0.024730753153562546, -0.0060318936593830585, -0.08317065984010696, -0.0220923013985157, 0.03698333725333214, 0.012647757306694984, -0.04792768135666847, -0.02305271476507187, -0.022571533918380737, -0.016689250245690346, 0.03004782274365425, -0.018455175682902336, -0.0015949079534038901, 0.017481766641139984, 0.019569065421819687, -0.01980912871658802, -0.01859118416905403, -0.013913130387663841, 0.029404114931821823, -0.021319067105650902, 0.035777851939201355, -0.040936242789030075, -0.03521228954195976, -0.04610739275813103, 0.0031007148791104555, -0.018149904906749725, 0.04660848528146744, -0.026756897568702698, -0.016369136050343513, 0.0028310709167271852, 0.06103900074958801, -0.0019238522509112954, -0.06581875681877136, -0.03454767167568207, 0.031733158975839615, -0.0365692600607872, 0.00789915956556797, -0.006600063759833574, -0.057168323546648026, 0.01368209719657898, 0.012325414456427097, -0.053262464702129364, -0.026887713000178337, -0.018676655367016792, -0.004469092469662428, 0.03529340401291847, 0.014424939639866352, 0.05399337783455849, 0.04237622022628784, -0.00897158682346344, -0.019013913348317146, -0.0320638082921505, 0.04364943504333496, -0.024513181298971176, -0.016954442486166954, -0.03310685232281685, -0.04117904230952263, -0.016463475301861763, 0.043240007013082504, 0.03128853067755699, 0.043153710663318634, 0.0004245676100254059, -0.026494760066270828, -0.01871013082563877, 0.02865726687014103, -0.011919859796762466, 0.005718945991247892, 0.016393344849348068, 0.05322938784956932, -0.014203079044818878, -0.014251558110117912, 0.004018889740109444, -0.017478611320257187, 0.030400371178984642, 0.026721686124801636, -0.004900453146547079, 0.02641131356358528, -0.00608587684109807, 0.005842690356075764, 0.0009395781671628356, 0.008613357320427895, 0.055523112416267395, 0.03278018906712532, 0.03476420417428017, -0.027641668915748596, -0.041887249797582626, -0.03388343006372452, 0.0010455509182065725, -0.01020246371626854, 0.029290983453392982, -0.07935445010662079, 0.042671725153923035, -0.012130842544138432, -0.019890518859028816, -0.04677456244826317, -0.015795182436704636, 0.01134323701262474, 0.008605850860476494, -0.017676541581749916, -0.010983183979988098, 0.02246403694152832, 0.007744542323052883, -0.027023132890462875, -0.006112491711974144, 0.05499142408370972, -0.02324613183736801, -0.025455350056290627, 0.024259399622678757, -0.014229051768779755, 0.0031250277534127235, 0.01567132957279682, 0.00723287696018815, -0.019204964861273766, -0.022142991423606873, -0.00982959009706974, 0.007299190852791071, 0.021763911470770836, -0.03010173887014389, 0.007115787360817194, -0.04052414000034332, 0.023132100701332092, 0.049045637249946594, -0.021815011277794838, -0.004435181617736816, -0.006570616737008095, 0.005070524290204048, 0.019734663888812065, -0.026002729311585426, 0.002466767095029354, -0.0003215629840269685, 0.026237495243549347, -0.003944801166653633, -0.011413215659558773, 0.036430586129426956, -0.010832713916897774, 0.00983709841966629, 0.023688720539212227, 0.016979780048131943, 0.024753758683800697, 0.031469713896512985, -0.051934435963630676, 0.0001519055658718571, -0.016976961866021156, -0.026815390214323997, 0.0611034519970417, 0.03478873521089554, 0.010374188423156738, 0.049210917204618454, 0.03818618506193161, -0.02633797749876976, -0.015015327371656895, -0.004484894685447216, 0.004333296790719032, 0.05694066733121872, -0.03133587911725044, 0.028512882068753242, 0.04490800201892853, 0.003217496909201145, 0.003744984045624733, -0.06853766739368439, -0.013252457603812218, -0.03953435644507408, -0.04344330355525017, 0.030089201405644417, 0.009032119065523148, -0.008213198743760586, 0.0603877529501915, -0.015958283096551895, 0.013312553986907005, 0.019528551027178764, 0.0005075117805972695, 0.041948478668928146, 0.014871765859425068, -0.006363037507981062, -0.025420380756258965, 0.043502774089574814, -0.03433821350336075, -0.01971592754125595, 0.02507888898253441, -0.015636879950761795, 0.07914825528860092, -0.0037586293183267117, 0.011233438737690449, -0.05424066260457039, -0.004460370168089867, -0.05726702883839607, 0.020678067579865456, -0.00682825455442071, -0.007352874614298344, 0.04735162854194641, -0.0039013023488223553, -0.014482094906270504, 0.01729893870651722, -0.0035658893175423145, -0.030256493017077446, -0.10207286477088928, -0.07873352617025375, -0.002660491270944476, -0.015113886445760727, 0.00928531214594841, -0.007772543467581272, -0.062347736209630966, 0.04750542342662811, -0.025448065251111984, 0.012891015037894249, 0.010205347090959549, 0.07551442831754684, -0.003866570768877864, 0.045611776411533356, 0.022160658612847328, 0.015229078009724617, -0.007139152381569147, -0.05706029012799263, 0.11669669300317764, 0.052578747272491455, 0.030572136864066124, -0.08011171221733093, 0.016343137249350548, -0.015112568624317646, -0.012295260094106197, -0.02521953172981739, 0.005065237637609243, 0.016076769679784775, 0.014545314945280552, -0.008373890072107315, 0.017202269285917282, -0.0027719635982066393, -0.041914910078048706, 0.05019374564290047, -0.0328117199242115, -0.0019046703819185495, 0.01804312691092491, 0.028071874752640724, 0.001374010113067925, 0.0008675498538650572, -0.024868721142411232, 0.01742282696068287, -0.0015721663367003202, 0.02034097909927368, -0.0006804992444813251, -0.007714762818068266, 0.020424937829375267, -0.0482296459376812, -0.018166271969676018, 0.010667475871741772, 0.005901027470827103, -0.018980082124471664, -0.01891656406223774, 0.04166793450713158, 0.010107988491654396, -0.02553989551961422, 0.029825452715158463, 0.01472082082182169, 0.03678807243704796, -0.002281135879456997, 0.02225659228861332, -0.00923837535083294, -0.027498286217451096, -0.03470016270875931, -0.051326096057891846, 0.051932234317064285, 0.0214385986328125, 0.01118430681526661, -0.0016966830007731915, 0.010684055276215076, 0.03162512928247452, -0.03657163307070732, 0.0016098699998110533, 0.029432836920022964, 0.040332455188035965, -0.012027612887322903, -0.010100992396473885, -0.014351193793118, 0.03416605293750763, -0.009216250851750374, 0.020037805661559105, -0.02022974193096161, -0.025617072358727455, -0.004939254838973284, -0.034702498465776443, -0.0029497607611119747, 0.024737142026424408, 0.002973990747705102, 0.015472798608243465, 0.020470498129725456, -0.028680643066763878, 0.01989644579589367, 0.019158557057380676, -0.011141305789351463, 0.06094209849834442, -0.009278981015086174, -0.01566472090780735, -0.03369135037064552, -0.051799528300762177, 0.037335753440856934, -0.039716411381959915, -0.007024907972663641, -0.024925338104367256, 0.004549185745418072, 0.008954459801316261, 0.05057889595627785, 0.02969050034880638, 0.000727363396435976, 0.008840390481054783, 0.02233794517815113, -0.01247947197407484, -0.05044897645711899, -0.05200711637735367, -0.012788084335625172, -0.030912091955542564, -0.0030174115672707558, -0.020653102546930313, 0.06975096464157104, 0.015271942131221294, 0.015236453153192997, -0.07123712450265884, 0.004638675134629011, 0.006614792626351118, 0.02143733948469162, 0.011338994838297367, -0.04600848630070686, -0.005405019503086805, 0.023209458217024803, -0.038858428597450256, -0.04140844568610191, -0.01975642889738083, -0.01987718790769577, -0.029343614354729652, -0.0045374492183327675, 0.008620687760412693, -0.030195321887731552, 0.028100954368710518, -0.01433463767170906, 0.05148246884346008, -0.01779928430914879, -0.016346294432878494, -0.035681966692209244, -0.014747307635843754, 0.010629219934344292, -0.05406602472066879, -0.004904508590698242, 0.01021658256649971, -0.013635865412652493, -0.016908518970012665, 0.04190301150083542, 0.009283795021474361, -0.00038847458199597895, -0.011085002683103085, 0.026817036792635918, -0.024251943454146385, 0.05692559853196144, -0.03607286140322685, -0.002262597903609276, 0.04267536476254463, -0.020376116037368774, -0.05736608803272247, 0.0538395531475544, -0.015712816268205643, 0.03071647137403488, -0.0002973732480313629, -0.013977888971567154, -0.06872500479221344, 0.04671570658683777, -0.021738940849900246, -0.02572060376405716, -0.029001887887716293, 0.004841517191380262, 0.007392520550638437, 0.007584730628877878, 0.020086925476789474, -0.013819526880979538, -0.005426245741546154, -0.017292559146881104, 0.02618587762117386, -0.021904805675148964, -0.014401533640921116, -0.021763108670711517, -0.021498380228877068, 0.04772978276014328, -0.026253536343574524, 0.00765597028657794, 0.031568821519613266, 0.04918589070439339, -0.0035252769012004137, 0.047085803002119064, 0.002971204463392496, 0.012845315970480442, -0.12007631361484528, -0.007927888073027134, 0.005463037174195051, -0.002507582539692521, -0.006016467697918415, -0.06105737015604973, 0.02704101800918579, 0.04246442764997482, -0.04475276917219162, -0.004089602269232273, -0.010811161249876022, 0.006050814408808947, -0.027757829055190086, -0.01341851893812418, -0.0362999252974987, -0.0002366094704484567, 0.06660892069339752, 0.018586071208119392, -0.012512443587183952, 0.004458722658455372, -0.0050394246354699135, -0.009088745340704918, -0.05327077955007553, 0.0068875704891979694, -0.01217416487634182, -0.046773314476013184, 0.01803475245833397, -0.013440916314721107, -0.00792125053703785, 0.00871847290545702, -0.022351866587996483, -0.009541397914290428, 0.06614969670772552, 0.028566598892211914, 0.03224325552582741, 0.00781744159758091, 0.006809632759541273, -0.02539311721920967, 0.025830205529928207, 0.011236114427447319, 0.0330544151365757, 0.001701440429314971, -0.018142249435186386, 0.024618733674287796, -0.03749067336320877, -0.014990964904427528, -0.013435435481369495, 0.03146900236606598, -0.00458136573433876, -0.014053131453692913, 0.00954348687082529, 0.01711864210665226, 0.011845679022371769, -0.01731567643582821, -0.028948867693543434, -0.01741553656756878, 0.015139847993850708, 0.03924690559506416, 0.031022707000374794, -0.009856130927801132, 0.011825584806501865, -0.031634293496608734, -0.032231405377388, -0.01433577574789524, 0.006601901259273291, -0.006324869114905596, -0.04584340378642082, 0.00840634573251009, 0.021333223208785057, -0.051633723080158234, -0.02201690524816513, -0.02407182939350605, -0.002883152337744832, 0.046063680201768875, -0.014544048346579075, 0.030495861545205116, 0.022627925500273705, -0.04184162616729736, -0.019812466576695442, -0.11474601924419403, 0.10157743096351624, 0.01857307180762291, -0.02367064170539379, -0.0415220782160759, 0.02403446100652218, -0.03929572552442551, 0.037640612572431564, 0.026658790186047554, -0.000888741749804467, 0.025344444438815117, -0.020208504050970078, 0.022898955270648003, 0.02797907590866089, 0.0017490517348051071, 0.03557448461651802, -0.0015608647372573614, -0.002343105850741267, -0.019354967400431633, -0.01125921867787838, 0.016398364678025246, 0.0233776792883873, 0.017849544063210487, 0.0030821007676422596, 0.024982016533613205, -0.006604644004255533, 0.024918977171182632, 0.04587185010313988, -0.0033507016487419605, 0.007447368465363979, 0.04180910438299179, -0.009592792019248009, 0.0099490350112319, 0.034839384257793427, -0.016640635207295418, -0.044014785438776016, 0.029967885464429855, 0.009890160523355007, -0.010345149785280228, -0.04999815672636032, -0.016556493937969208, -0.019640417769551277, -0.058236055076122284, 0.005379600450396538, 0.02125728502869606, -0.015315528959035873, 0.00570023013278842, 0.054579272866249084, 0.024164602160453796, 0.0373050831258297, 0.00018195489246863872, 0.02801036275923252, 0.01623290590941906, -0.01930573210120201, 0.011930035427212715, 0.010164815932512283, 0.021976089105010033, 0.019978702068328857, 0.06302790343761444, -0.002107797423377633, 0.0009503352339379489, 0.031067507341504097, -0.026490963995456696, 0.04956566542387009, -0.04111212119460106, -0.021704159677028656, -0.001478533842600882, -0.026975365355610847, 0.0354967825114727, 0.020220782607793808, -0.015545884147286415, 0.04326308146119118, -0.05265691503882408, -0.0244798231869936, -0.024277344346046448, -0.022682106122374535, 0.02023250423371792, 0.005496027879416943, 0.005706321448087692, 0.04505684971809387, 0.03965891897678375, 0.02066096104681492, -0.004196046851575375, 0.0009015973191708326, 0.040501829236745834, -0.011620227247476578, 0.03240498527884483, -0.017396243289113045, -0.030430389568209648, -0.02726486138999462, 0.0012894303072243929, -0.01151948980987072, -0.0601925253868103, -0.00714813033118844, 0.07169551402330399, 0.033091574907302856, -0.0031579111237078905, -0.04627610370516777, -0.009143250994384289, 0.01871601864695549, -0.08263099193572998, 0.004856452811509371, -0.05118429660797119, -0.015291810967028141, -0.005674750544130802, -0.04072536155581474 ]
<p>I am trying to analyse diagnostic plots of a spline object, I am using the package <strong>Fields</strong> from <strong>R</strong>.</p> <p>I am lost with the GCV function plot, since I can't find any guidelines of what to look for when comparing different models. Besides the value/degrees of freedom of the GCV function minimum for each model, can we also compare the GCV curve between models?</p> <p>This is an example of the different models and their correspondent diagnostic plots:</p> <p>(1)<strong>_________________________</strong>(2)<strong>__________________________</strong>(3)<strong>____________________</strong></p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/M8v7L.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>The summary of each fit:</p> <pre><code> (1) Number of Observations: 745 Number of unique points: 745 Number of parameters in the null space 21 Parameters for fixed spatial drift 21 Effective degrees of freedom: 116.4 Residual degrees of freedom: 628.6 MLE sigma 0.4153 GCV sigma 0.4269 MLE rho 0.02785 Smoothing parameter lambda 6.193 DETAILS ON SMOOTHING PARAMETER: Method used: GCV Cost: 1 lambda trA GCV GCV.one GCV.model shat 6.1932 116.4326 0.2160 0.2160 NA 0.4269 (2) Number of Observations: 734 Number of unique points: 734 Number of parameters in the null space 21 Parameters for fixed spatial drift 21 Effective degrees of freedom: 134.4 Residual degrees of freedom: 599.6 MLE sigma 0.2788 GCV sigma 0.2912 MLE rho 0.02166 Smoothing parameter lambda 3.589 DETAILS ON SMOOTHING PARAMETER: Method used: GCV Cost: 1 lambda trA GCV GCV.one GCV.model shat 3.5890 134.3993 0.1038 0.1038 NA 0.2912 (3) Number of Observations: 716 Number of unique points: 716 Number of parameters in the null space 21 Parameters for fixed spatial drift 21 Effective degrees of freedom: 680.2 Residual degrees of freedom: 35.8 MLE sigma 0.04486 GCV sigma 0.0766 MLE rho 11.6 Smoothing parameter lambda 0.0001734 DETAILS ON SMOOTHING PARAMETER: Method used: GCV Cost: 1 lambda trA GCV GCV.one GCV.model shat 1.734e-04 6.802e+02 1.173e-01 1.173e-01 NA 7.660e-02 </code></pre> <p>The lower values of lambda the smoother the surface (3), and the number of degrees of freedom is higher(3). Althought I know from the data that the observed values vary little for model (3), while for (1) and (2) I have a higher variation of observed values.</p>
73,930
[ -0.055894289165735245, 0.016296783462166786, -0.004356354475021362, 0.0058164638467133045, 0.025108549743890762, -0.006829463876783848, -0.008058229461312294, -0.05429203808307648, 0.0026800476480275393, -0.05561574548482895, 0.03761325776576996, 0.04056777060031891, 0.05367184057831764, 0.049549371004104614, 0.01066791731864214, 0.0007268371991813183, 0.0032876741606742144, 0.013346700929105282, 0.0014701554318889976, -0.0056100934743881226, -0.027083352208137512, -0.012132679112255573, 0.007965113036334515, 0.015410115011036396, -0.02816721424460411, 0.05222233384847641, 0.03847642242908478, -0.02356542833149433, -0.002834383165463805, 0.04581073671579361, -0.08360692113637924, -0.032156169414520264, -0.027894942089915276, 0.03882656618952751, 0.0031338126864284277, 0.002826478099450469, -0.006657925900071859, -0.011016192846000195, -0.027195343747735023, 0.05311226099729538, -0.031296294182538986, -0.011189669370651245, -0.01921074651181698, 0.048878081142902374, 0.006726056337356567, 0.008321881294250488, 0.0038552340120077133, 0.00005747774412157014, 0.06438500434160233, -0.011642061173915863, 0.06693937629461288, -0.011915222741663456, 0.018477963283658028, 0.04788823053240776, -0.0255010686814785, -0.04872997850179672, 0.032909709960222244, 0.047256048768758774, -0.027120579034090042, -0.06789463758468628, 0.006059155333787203, -0.019360557198524475, 0.036264315247535706, -0.004672586917877197, -0.01048649288713932, 0.021802322939038277, 0.00764151755720377, -0.04103884473443031, 0.05281004682183266, -0.0007913847803138196, 0.05072665587067604, 0.018653947860002518, 0.012573037296533585, -0.038656845688819885, 0.05768296867609024, 0.007839970290660858, 0.006765852682292461, 0.028767041862010956, 0.035981256514787674, 0.023900160565972328, -0.01322328019887209, 0.02872445620596409, -0.0006635320605710149, 0.010511394590139389, 0.012499313801527023, 0.02858494408428669, 0.05616486445069313, 0.005083861295133829, 0.02606799639761448, 0.01955362781882286, 0.00206577661447227, 0.023036940023303032, 0.05446157231926918, 0.03949759155511856, -0.03410446271300316, 0.04051882401108742, 0.008091595023870468, 0.010327907279133797, -0.00464192358776927, 0.01554582454264164, -0.04215275123715401, -0.059108395129442215, -0.0013212942285463214, 0.05811142176389694, -0.007283175364136696, -0.0020559942349791527, -0.01781810261309147, 0.00036855568760074675, -0.051453813910484314, -0.029773347079753876, -0.008075200952589512, -0.011746672913432121, 0.018138816580176353, -0.01926957257091999, -0.013864108361303806, 0.006656083278357983, -0.017277467995882034, 0.007080407813191414, 0.0300721637904644, 0.05508105829358101, 0.06675852090120316, -0.040213100612163544, -0.018812624737620354, -0.04215771332383156, -0.0718674287199974, -0.009400362148880959, 0.034209322184324265, -0.004349392373114824, -0.03497734293341637, 0.05297764763236046, 0.005822119768708944, -0.015592312440276146, 0.043805789202451706, -0.007888449355959892, 0.05569782853126526, -0.008446898311376572, -0.06481941789388657, -0.07572301477193832, 0.044519927352666855, -0.02471325546503067, 0.04380397871136665, -0.04727756604552269, -0.0267803855240345, 0.024038588628172874, 0.059414394199848175, -0.007211936637759209, 0.021065296605229378, -0.009068056009709835, 0.016279855743050575, -0.023616306483745575, -0.020069291815161705, -0.004446291830390692, -0.028125891461968422, -0.02277560532093048, -0.06926444917917252, -0.07859844714403152, -0.014077750034630299, 0.009318157099187374, -0.018840838223695755, 0.016153961420059204, 0.06132951006293297, 0.01215650700032711, 0.009888661094009876, -0.008123748935759068, -0.002747939433902502, -0.027909528464078903, 0.0374935008585453, 0.021669739857316017, 0.026773961260914803, 0.03432060405611992, -0.049239370971918106, 0.025348663330078125, -0.0059975930489599705, 0.033784184604883194, 0.047449029982089996, -0.029446423053741455, -0.010868526063859463, -0.016277769580483437, -0.0005209988448768854, 0.037218127399683, -0.06587778031826019, -0.015996301546692848, -0.024383163079619408, -0.027471765875816345, 0.02515983395278454, 0.05677039921283722, -0.017531052231788635, -0.027028130367398262, 0.013065294362604618, -0.04252779111266136, -0.06705787777900696, -0.014760502614080906, -0.019017722457647324, -0.005055760033428669, -0.04814799502491951, 0.035891905426979065, 0.019892947748303413, 0.023135343566536903, 0.034026678651571274, -0.030648358166217804, -0.015071837231516838, 0.0063272500410676, 0.027904026210308075, -0.0035196244716644287, 0.012726121582090855, 0.027560150250792503, 0.04498230293393135, -0.0016811968525871634, 0.048382874578237534, -0.027697790414094925, -0.010762205347418785, 0.056441113352775574, -0.03859275206923485, 0.024309130385518074, 0.012626591138541698, -0.019092174246907234, -0.005520289298146963, 0.026261895895004272, -0.023215441033244133, 0.008567670360207558, -0.05787224695086479, 0.035534437745809555, 0.08287400752305984, 0.02426142245531082, -0.021345939487218857, 0.014555091969668865, -0.0048158420249819756, 0.0508139505982399, -0.04002254083752632, -0.0019652554765343666, -0.026574114337563515, -0.0462767630815506, 0.04615545645356178, 0.02462470345199108, -0.028449110686779022, -0.021531982347369194, 0.050320520997047424, 0.011660597287118435, 0.0451011136174202, 0.029003800824284554, -0.006319190375506878, -0.030054880306124687, 0.028413444757461548, 0.02322211302816868, -0.011559851467609406, 0.0000589345654589124, 0.02137504704296589, 0.0072192358784377575, 0.044933076947927475, 0.006316193845123053, -0.020315850153565407, 0.05961760878562927, 0.015462130308151245, -0.01689760386943817, -0.02607789821922779, -0.00929554644972086, 0.07312293350696564, -0.00041397300083190203, 0.0026423893868923187, 0.06809453666210175, -0.010765998624265194, -0.031139452010393143, -0.006045808084309101, 0.023723052814602852, 0.023409927263855934, 0.028305450454354286, 0.013180729933083057, -0.02125050313770771, 0.01786019653081894, -0.03629564121365547, 0.04536767303943634, -0.024259302765130997, -0.013789460062980652, -0.04943224415183067, 0.031235110014677048, 0.04092751443386078, 0.007616332266479731, 0.02042725309729576, -0.01296116691082716, -0.01363346353173256, -0.012207051739096642, 0.0007146851858124137, 0.038380447775125504, 0.029676133766770363, -0.06099414825439453, -0.013795026578009129, -0.03742145001888275, -0.005896835587918758, 0.02301541343331337, -0.020743530243635178, -0.03857523575425148, 0.03689727559685707, -0.022195355966687202, -0.03283705562353134, -0.025893699377775192, 0.00018836262461263686, 0.03986004739999771, 0.0018530477536842227, -0.022827420383691788, 0.04319304972887039, -0.009448109194636345, -0.03701579570770264, 0.024216365069150925, -0.051277220249176025, 0.019135911017656326, 0.013389922678470612, 0.03981518745422363, 0.024103103205561638, 0.02321760356426239, 0.007019584998488426, 0.03236241266131401, -0.01866704598069191, -0.030928978696465492, -0.05682574585080147, 0.0004981543752364814, 0.03436601534485817, -0.022559406235814095, 0.04390016943216324, -0.05484598129987717, -0.022087041288614273, 0.07315646857023239, 0.07211627066135406, -0.028277302160859108, -0.04590749368071556, -0.0017591366777196527, -0.08051596581935883, -0.020646806806325912, 0.013842368498444557, 0.002296263352036476, 0.028390292078256607, 0.015070409514009953, -0.002866424387320876, 0.022674884647130966, 0.0444084107875824, 0.001252849237062037, -0.018584024161100388, 0.047238629311323166, 0.0006584197981283069, -0.04515732079744339, 0.05099192634224892, 0.0007197134546004236, -0.02906324714422226, -0.003093662904575467, 0.0033535303082317114, 0.0011073439382016659, 0.012980353087186813, -0.030058683827519417, 0.021787455305457115, 0.03406798467040062, -0.0041321637108922005, -0.04906950518488884, 0.010974335484206676, 0.03443627804517746, -0.05158335715532303, -0.03141817823052406, 0.011381409130990505, 0.045388270169496536, -0.017088480293750763, 0.0009580050245858729, 0.047507144510746, 0.01974201761186123, -0.009442432783544064, 0.036014311015605927, -0.029420185834169388, -0.019667260348796844, 0.000020214025425957516, -0.033976394683122635, -0.046344906091690063, 0.0477881021797657, 0.02573135867714882, 0.015871498733758926, -0.025324201211333275, -0.034788236021995544, -0.014240591786801815, -0.08099854737520218, 0.02926333248615265, -0.022631095722317696, 0.04370130971074104, 0.02267570048570633, 0.017316659912467003, 0.024967443197965622, -0.00005531683564186096, -0.007306813728064299, -0.01969524845480919, -0.0545482374727726, 0.031138310208916664, 0.03263528272509575, -0.003333764849230647, 0.025203702971339226, -0.03172611445188522, 0.014862335287034512, -0.025967448949813843, 0.03233378380537033, 0.029430769383907318, 0.013614598661661148, -0.03608289733529091, 0.012798686511814594, -0.017647424712777138, 0.012454311363399029, -0.013010045513510704, 0.04760945215821266, 0.02443057857453823, -0.028183242306113243, 0.04100603610277176, 0.009463070891797543, -0.019649654626846313, 0.005643656011670828, -0.018701763823628426, -0.01588127389550209, -0.01440687756985426, 0.030503759160637856, 0.02826482430100441, 0.0025599731598049402, -0.018644744530320168, 0.005684424191713333, 0.03617047145962715, 0.037834037095308304, 0.03835050389170647, -0.02412533201277256, -0.0206715427339077, -0.044824738055467606, 0.011441036127507687, -0.018553616479039192, 0.03931817412376404, 0.024728575721383095, -0.024842701852321625, 0.04484539106488228, 0.0006152559071779251, -0.02750156633555889, 0.06192636489868164, 0.04203847050666809, -0.0008247160003520548, -0.028589585795998573, -0.024813296273350716, -0.020152779296040535, 0.003312945133075118, 0.0014816710026934743, 0.048357997089624405, 0.010996921919286251, -0.03601641580462456, -0.015320390462875366, 0.03741076961159706, -0.03730368614196777, -0.06850232928991318, 0.0000639624340692535, 0.04420804604887962, 0.04682593792676926, 0.018715348094701767, -0.03197247534990311, -0.012033404782414436, 0.04971330985426903, 0.012410318478941917, 0.029672468081116676, 0.01661446876823902, -0.08450017124414444, -0.026106245815753937, 0.040259331464767456, -0.025965409353375435, 0.003089677542448044, -0.016353987157344818, -0.04364953562617302, -0.021843422204256058, 0.016926435753703117, -0.01793365553021431, -0.011134903877973557, 0.014666829258203506, 0.059494469314813614, -0.03368702158331871, -0.045548100024461746, -0.06087552756071091, 0.017129331827163696, -0.025377606973052025, 0.02263477072119713, -0.07108454406261444, -0.016919462010264397, -0.019680166617035866, -0.012586566619575024, -0.016682134941220284, 0.030729908496141434, 0.0022765358444303274, 0.00026075413916260004, 0.05943681672215462, 0.02994697540998459, -0.008428186178207397, -0.03135454282164574, 0.0054847924038767815, -0.004814122803509235, -0.01090929377824068, 0.07831846922636032, -0.016364632174372673, 0.009100602939724922, 0.018031131476163864, 0.01936914026737213, -0.02107921987771988, -0.0008061886765062809, -0.04576174542307854, 0.0457763597369194, 0.018135590478777885, 0.0035659524146467447, 0.04914645850658417, -0.001824326696805656, -0.020042020827531815, 0.004588218405842781, -0.04443935304880142, -0.004125055391341448, 0.015786314383149147, -0.017625154927372932, -0.06389125436544418, -0.03176560252904892, -0.01028468832373619, 0.04661889001727104, 0.0013167207362130284, 0.029586147516965866, -0.006215762346982956, -0.016830602660775185, 0.012114466167986393, 0.053050216287374496, 0.0007572431350126863, 0.0022095111198723316, 0.023134037852287292, 0.023366782814264297, 0.011711842380464077, -0.03942500427365303, 0.012240237556397915, -0.013217097148299217, -0.009102167561650276, 0.013684647157788277, -0.06181507185101509, 0.005203671287745237, -0.011701398529112339, 0.001964529510587454, 0.004033063538372517, -0.026995699852705002, -0.004366497043520212, 0.01219412125647068, 0.07996167242527008, 0.03307715430855751, -0.05122879520058632, -0.015028663910925388, 0.03757265582680702, -0.01102432981133461, 0.01590617746114731, -0.0022407073993235826, 0.02500702254474163, -0.0268312469124794, 0.026511307805776596, -0.039488039910793304, -0.019323889166116714, 0.020657774060964584, -0.008978642523288727, -0.040427420288324356, -0.02004634216427803, -0.008092251606285572, -0.005849313456565142, 0.001532061374746263, -0.019921038299798965, 0.023206526413559914, -0.019075538963079453, -0.003831350477412343, 0.0027139910962432623, 0.026187174022197723, 0.07214390486478806, -0.03396311774849892, 0.03485514968633652, 0.024229835718870163, -0.019461894407868385, -0.034033507108688354, 0.02361135371029377, 0.01618797704577446, -0.0449085608124733, -0.016711654141545296, -0.028969720005989075, 0.02021251618862152, 0.03275063633918762, -0.010001112706959248, -0.013555336743593216, 0.029509246349334717, 0.0029539966490119696, 0.018434809520840645, -0.010683432221412659, 0.004036142025142908, -0.03348209708929062, 0.008379345759749413, -0.03034188412129879, 0.023710444569587708, -0.02002524770796299, -0.01263618003576994, 0.022105960175395012, -0.01119933370500803, -0.03710278496146202, 0.04519004374742508, 0.06448182463645935, 0.015546059235930443, 0.022054584696888924, 0.0033014449290931225, 0.03262920677661896, 0.06221365928649902, 0.0047099837101995945, 0.02021094411611557, 0.02369026280939579, 0.03236852586269379, -0.01094219833612442, -0.0003378436085768044, -0.06079048290848732, 0.006257608998566866, 0.062312088906764984, 0.0021766640711575747, 0.029608087614178658, 0.06676719337701797, -0.04110422357916832, -0.008024214766919613, -0.03893940523266792, -0.018273839727044106, -0.008882662281394005, -0.0013083858648315072, 0.050629377365112305, -0.04163937643170357, -0.018566414713859558, 0.03273536264896393, 0.0005493021453730762, 0.005342986434698105, 0.02192881889641285, -0.044872257858514786, 0.019765660166740417, 0.037757016718387604, -0.004918334074318409, -0.03335830196738243, 0.0687754899263382, -0.003448416478931904, 0.0540585070848465, -0.009059295058250427, -0.01155907940119505, 0.02942458912730217, 0.058545585721731186, -0.014178404584527016, -0.032149020582437515, -0.02971448190510273, -0.0737110823392868, 0.007162697147578001, 0.04603969305753708, -0.05082610622048378, 0.030863435938954353, 0.039375439286231995, 0.057054657489061356, -0.014626427553594112, 0.027087176218628883, -0.04565751552581787, -0.06627926975488663, -0.0032640628051012754, 0.013760830275714397, -0.013961047865450382, 0.06357496231794357, -0.020615896210074425, -0.04516855627298355, 0.016553575173020363, -0.0659344345331192, 0.01917787827551365, 0.02923176996409893, 0.024413371458649635, 0.02601524256169796, 0.0512857548892498, -0.039036158472299576, -0.013513459824025631, -0.03980309143662453, -0.011341084726154804, 0.13490299880504608, 0.06386367231607437, 0.017669210210442543, -0.04566796123981476, 0.00027685583336278796, 0.021164989098906517, -0.00410792650654912, 0.019467294216156006, -0.004875969607383013, 0.03533967211842537, -0.02245715819299221, 0.05795270949602127, 0.023850830271840096, 0.021627511829137802, 0.002144163241609931, 0.013164193369448185, -0.02020283229649067, -0.018667666241526604, -0.02570362389087677, 0.01371795404702425, 0.022527290508151054, 0.007567026186734438, -0.013775074854493141, -0.005681771785020828, -0.019088158383965492, -0.03375978395342827, -0.024890128523111343, -0.005278578959405422, 0.004671686794608831, 0.005837598349899054, -0.02205202914774418, 0.04130532965064049, -0.009454268962144852, 0.003558364463970065, -0.006938796490430832, -0.0016552539309486747, 0.026377415284514427, -0.05596061423420906, 0.009341506287455559, 0.037032730877399445, -0.025695528835058212, -0.011902634985744953, 0.006720246281474829, 0.01494530774652958, -0.008100380189716816, -0.022359762340784073, -0.03789165988564491, 0.05400896444916725, 0.03138486295938492, -0.058175861835479736, 0.007723287679255009, 0.02166503667831421, 0.020493976771831512, -0.0498143695294857, -0.02907286025583744, -0.043688174337148666, -0.011553953401744366, -0.02304636873304844, -0.003549987683072686, -0.030530987307429314, 0.02054065652191639, 0.029876302927732468, 0.02498961240053177, 0.02838975377380848, -0.02148418314754963, -0.021523820236325264, -0.04583565518260002, 0.08199243992567062, -0.012985791079699993, 0.01571846753358841, 0.016196656972169876, -0.011261719278991222, -0.0007853522547520697, 0.0315496101975441, 0.005282214842736721, 0.04168262332677841, 0.018295645713806152, -0.014821924269199371, 0.019795263186097145, -0.0002441476099193096, -0.0837174728512764, 0.008851519785821438, -0.06025271490216255, -0.009537332691252232, -0.0274126585572958, -0.016840828582644463, 0.04495485872030258, 0.02042325958609581, 0.07032478600740433, 0.03318171203136444, 0.009436502121388912, 0.05478990823030472, -0.0022430396638810635, -0.06800679862499237, -0.056051675230264664, -0.004145769402384758, -0.0287513118237257, 0.0004512752057053149, -0.04876990243792534, 0.06689237803220749, 0.01155541930347681, 0.01891120709478855, 0.006406949833035469, 0.03384402021765709, -0.016061460599303246, -0.0035821963101625443, -0.004581093788146973, -0.030714139342308044, 0.023501519113779068, -0.00012219695781823248, -0.04217468574643135, -0.030557332560420036, 0.025870053097605705, -0.02419137954711914, -0.02313869632780552, 0.010269710794091225, -0.007805500645190477, -0.042570848017930984, 0.03359140455722809, 0.03493596985936165, -0.013274190947413445, -0.042802583426237106, 0.018072722479701042, -0.034392889589071274, -0.005770356394350529, -0.02351072058081627, -0.005916840396821499, -0.003740131389349699, 0.018935373052954674, -0.03261031582951546, 0.0023490632884204388, 0.027786502614617348, -0.023211322724819183, -0.01083248108625412, -0.011343452148139477, -0.0010073818266391754, 0.015615822747349739, 0.02261573076248169, 0.032267726957798004, 0.008428947068750858, -0.040214117616415024, -0.038777146488428116, -0.01570061780512333, 0.002748665167018771, -0.003819608362391591, 0.011226615868508816, 0.030940862372517586, 0.00204298528842628, -0.020588114857673645, 0.06878717243671417, -0.00971918273717165, -0.0008140161517076194, -0.02363731898367405, -0.002411514287814498, -0.026488158851861954, -0.045379750430583954, 0.04230494424700737, 0.0006689986912533641, -0.004438722040504217, -0.012666121125221252, 0.03445213660597801, -0.027116907760500908, -0.007208306808024645, -0.013216866180300713, -0.06034564971923828, -0.0037868013605475426, -0.010147811844944954, -0.00919727236032486, 0.057056643068790436, 0.058003656566143036, 0.0009658597991801798, -0.002338619204238057, 0.02365613356232643, 0.02310926839709282, -0.08859707415103912, -0.012630125507712364, 0.007391837425529957, 0.027876704931259155, 0.02177153155207634, -0.0500323660671711, 0.0070158373564481735, 0.042741499841213226, -0.0333327054977417, -0.007974434643983841, 0.002239486901089549, 0.039450109004974365, -0.05337382107973099, 0.007426381576806307, 0.00804890412837267, 0.009557230398058891, 0.02021389827132225, 0.03140424191951752, 0.05934816598892212, 0.02262900210916996, 0.016178295016288757, -0.023809222504496574, -0.030166860669851303, -0.0007781998720020056, 0.0045602149330079556, -0.042697973549366, 0.002247965894639492, -0.03216191381216049, -0.003530838992446661, -0.01798226125538349, -0.018388954922556877, 0.008516554720699787, -0.014665231108665466, 0.02031656727194786, 0.008833933621644974, 0.023034101352095604, 0.016481153666973114, -0.020729828625917435, -0.005410105921328068, -0.04509958252310753, -0.010644860565662384, -0.0014734650030732155, -0.008622950874269009, 0.029176916927099228, -0.004931841976940632, -0.04203415662050247, -0.018867485225200653, -0.013573293574154377, -0.019427543506026268, 0.005289461929351091, 0.01679833233356476, -0.00736190052703023, 0.0163642019033432, -0.022371018305420876, -0.006122188176959753, -0.04415939748287201, 0.047844383865594864, 0.015470701269805431, 0.00705382227897644, -0.01687725819647312, 0.009508995339274406, -0.03146509453654289, -0.014413541182875633, -0.009885964915156364, 0.00775885721668601, -0.012017869390547276, -0.0378057062625885, 0.0093834875151515, -0.009017462842166424, -0.03738746419548988, -0.021203039214015007, -0.007235565222799778, -0.026833320036530495, 0.028432615101337433, -0.02582157403230667, -0.009600184857845306, 0.01598416268825531, -0.008166101761162281, 0.03867562860250473, -0.07118265330791473, 0.004769803490489721, 0.012585286051034927, -0.04433673620223999, -0.050972070544958115, -0.022210178896784782, -0.021035823971033096, 0.043330997228622437, 0.023507555946707726, 0.00012873865489382297, 0.02046801894903183, 0.010671266354620457, 0.01934622786939144, 0.02472296915948391, -0.0366288460791111, 0.050458118319511414, -0.0017018577782437205, -0.025202715769410133, 0.010342089459300041, -0.007673931773751974, -0.004263203591108322, 0.02822682075202465, 0.04236547276377678, -0.005978702567517757, 0.02334853634238243, 0.006105098407715559, -0.04513624683022499, 0.018879802897572517, -0.0220186710357666, -0.04718867689371109, 0.04770638421177864, -0.034009821712970734, -0.019070278853178024, 0.0651598870754242, 0.014784575439989567, -0.005832378752529621, 0.016551408916711807, -0.004198210313916206, -0.025581302121281624, 0.010094629600644112, -0.009206265211105347, -0.01178338099271059, -0.053975626826286316, 0.014386001043021679, 0.001174057018943131, -0.043046098202466965, -0.013235025107860565, 0.0324602909386158, 0.023052604869008064, 0.015764346346259117, -0.017255527898669243, 0.014748715795576572, 0.02034923993051052, -0.0028398113790899515, 0.0277753584086895, 0.02980983443558216, 0.047111183404922485, 0.042693156749010086, -0.02563544362783432, 0.018055042251944542, -0.017734823748469353, 0.005840918980538845, -0.01770648919045925, 0.02253688871860504, -0.012488188222050667, 0.0010171725880354643, 0.015496850945055485, -0.005050011910498142, -0.0014696193393319845, -0.004426743369549513, -0.03874992951750755, 0.04391033202409744, -0.07429735362529755, -0.020454823970794678, -0.013245362788438797, -0.007926958613097668, -0.022236116230487823, 0.025859497487545013, 0.008216348476707935, 0.005042623728513718, 0.05203242972493172, 0.021324334666132927, -0.017410436645150185, -0.014800047501921654, 0.006546645890921354, -0.010661190375685692, 0.0002689309185370803, -0.006609663367271423, 0.01927880197763443, -0.028790194541215897, 0.0011696588480845094, 0.005240019876509905, -0.04394431784749031, 0.025350702926516533, 0.022464729845523834, -0.021405132487416267, -0.07048837840557098, -0.0330301858484745, -0.02415810339152813, 0.03812282159924507, -0.07901635020971298, -0.0394769161939621, -0.013344923965632915, -0.002726244740188122, -0.00216644536703825, -0.013259411789476871 ]
<p>I have a one dimensional List like this</p> <pre><code>public class Zeit_und_Eigenschaft { [Feature] public double Sekunden { get; set; } } //... List&lt;Zeit_und_Eigenschaft&gt; lzue = new List&lt;Zeit_und_Eigenschaft&gt;(); //fill lzue </code></pre> <p>lzue can be</p> <pre><code>lzue.Sekunden 1 2 3 4 8 9 10 22 55 ... </code></pre> <p>Goal is to find clusters in that list, ie elements that could form groups like f.i. in this example</p> <pre><code>lzue.Sekunden 1 2 3 4 8 9 10 22 55 </code></pre> <p>Which clustering algorithm is suitable(I don't know the number of clusters k)? GMM? PCA? Kmeans? Other?</p>
49,453
[ -0.007709521800279617, -0.027822958305478096, -0.01658281683921814, -0.02616957761347294, 0.037717629224061966, -0.002671549329534173, -0.0011567380279302597, -0.04325469210743904, 0.016456186771392822, -0.020494600757956505, 0.053072378039360046, 0.0045503308065235615, 0.08031290769577026, 0.03411038964986801, 0.034656915813684464, 0.0350458137691021, -0.022458212450146675, -0.03834451362490654, -0.017337940633296967, -0.008680805563926697, -0.03321683406829834, 0.002063735853880644, 0.018560968339443207, -0.02139771729707718, -0.04609213024377823, 0.01464612502604723, 0.0016870482359081507, 0.025338146835565567, 0.014936924912035465, 0.028653116896748543, -0.04474335536360741, -0.03818146884441376, 0.01817389391362667, 0.03214670717716217, 0.025078406557440758, -0.0011422152165323496, -0.015861177816987038, -0.02577907033264637, -0.033556435257196426, -0.0036136293783783913, 0.01551935076713562, -0.032349392771720886, -0.025714527815580368, 0.02725403755903244, 0.01781291887164116, 0.04663681983947754, -0.028680162504315376, -0.049952078610658646, 0.028601426631212234, -0.04844862222671509, 0.07932756096124649, -0.010386193171143532, 0.019536837935447693, 0.01055414229631424, 0.01172088272869587, -0.015715446323156357, 0.026003383100032806, 0.0525263212621212, 0.024515561759471893, -0.053390681743621826, -0.011591237969696522, 0.0015311150345951319, 0.022976214066147804, -0.028139175847172737, -0.04516422748565674, 0.008437881246209145, -0.04833725839853287, -0.02241862751543522, 0.05776505172252655, 0.003632742678746581, -0.025017818436026573, 0.02109665609896183, 0.049156226217746735, -0.03601403534412384, 0.02052217163145542, -0.028255680575966835, -0.026412704959511757, 0.021359190344810486, 0.0643787756562233, -0.0043960390612483025, -0.0008427879656665027, 0.002601624233648181, -0.008552432991564274, 0.015424449928104877, 0.0573449581861496, -0.032204363495111465, 0.03919520229101181, -0.025707371532917023, -0.015456336550414562, 0.039710644632577896, -0.0142910061404109, -0.008534461259841919, 0.011660519056022167, 0.020617622882127762, -0.01370156742632389, 0.04171814024448395, -0.001324402284808457, 0.013863671571016312, 0.02424797974526882, 0.01563958078622818, -0.007059915456920862, -0.049844104796648026, 0.0016267204191535711, 0.012384602800011635, -0.030251190066337585, 0.017941009253263474, -0.05429201200604439, -0.030697491019964218, 0.008670209906995296, 0.02720794454216957, 0.0197861660271883, 0.000992252491414547, 0.03966278210282326, -0.022832205519080162, 0.047055684030056, 0.0064491042867302895, -0.03686881065368652, 0.02551589347422123, 0.02479390799999237, 0.07505589723587036, 0.018827004358172417, -0.015853872522711754, 0.03238597512245178, -0.013250512070953846, -0.04354173690080643, 0.02055501565337181, 0.006682737730443478, -0.020266884937882423, -0.007251516450196505, 0.08069411665201187, -0.031002817675471306, -0.022706400603055954, 0.03409012407064438, -0.026437968015670776, 0.06034111604094505, 0.014065893366932869, -0.05263963341712952, -0.03818683326244354, 0.03711846098303795, -0.0031379361171275377, 0.03155869245529175, -0.05239144340157509, 0.012430856004357338, 0.01401486061513424, 0.043101388961076736, 0.048065174371004105, 0.043083205819129944, 0.014693480916321278, 0.04148541018366814, -0.0129860145971179, -0.03186780586838722, -0.04162280261516571, -0.04064878821372986, -0.02230978198349476, -0.015589063987135887, -0.015098346397280693, 0.011339793913066387, 0.015211362391710281, 0.003935850225389004, 0.021847762167453766, 0.0014003339456394315, 0.002330184681341052, 0.03154557943344116, 0.002055299235507846, -0.011611755937337875, -0.0063118282705545425, 0.06315085291862488, -0.007854590192437172, 0.0441933237016201, 0.02153104357421398, -0.021696286275982857, 0.01761685125529766, 0.03233490139245987, 0.004656846635043621, 0.034769799560308456, 0.02887851372361183, -0.018976693972945213, 0.02854103595018387, 0.043136660009622574, -0.004931180737912655, -0.01667727530002594, -0.056515827775001526, -0.0048845927231013775, 0.00930038932710886, 0.022708021104335785, 0.056005049496889114, 0.013365533202886581, -0.0062188091687858105, 0.05252625420689583, -0.038246039301157, -0.0033033830113708973, -0.03778978809714317, 0.03365270048379898, -0.026265401393175125, -0.02020477131009102, 0.015097687020897865, 0.027226632460951805, 0.01161331869661808, 0.007411114405840635, -0.025201989337801933, -0.06553187966346741, -0.004651978146284819, 0.016602132469415665, -0.07917661219835281, -0.009593985974788666, 0.04580267146229744, 0.01834612712264061, -0.06842868030071259, 0.06264641880989075, -0.018998339772224426, -0.009232952259480953, -0.034119557589292526, -0.03651740029454231, 0.0067929914221167564, -0.007816129364073277, -0.004358516074717045, 0.014783414080739021, 0.02011922188103199, -0.041383031755685806, 0.011966320686042309, -0.042500246316194534, 0.027012336999177933, 0.046651437878608704, -0.0033222639467567205, 0.020768310874700546, -0.014214512892067432, -0.0069770775735378265, 0.03734680265188217, 0.012894722633063793, -0.023401185870170593, -0.06322825700044632, -0.012874623760581017, 0.05122379586100578, 0.05598162114620209, -0.033958133310079575, -0.02159990184009075, 0.09086483716964722, 0.014078691601753235, 0.0120156891644001, 0.018079441040754318, -0.03259994462132454, -0.003897985676303506, 0.015105495229363441, 0.036257509142160416, 0.026849931105971336, -0.03094400092959404, 0.03969266265630722, 0.004052608273923397, 0.02504129335284233, 0.010340503416955471, 0.04739995300769806, 0.03108697384595871, -0.0013055161107331514, -0.016014959663152695, -0.0035123000852763653, -0.006885698530822992, 0.013883291743695736, 0.0029592036735266447, -0.005783796776086092, 0.036816149950027466, 0.004514761734753847, -0.0321040041744709, -0.01839056983590126, -0.038784127682447433, -0.028823550790548325, 0.027210984379053116, -0.03761232644319534, 0.010740653611719608, 0.016002153977751732, 0.00018180263577960432, 0.030651919543743134, -0.006702203769236803, -0.02225005254149437, -0.028229812160134315, 0.07678184658288956, 0.049514178186655045, -0.009087322279810905, -0.01493655052036047, 0.0034966173116117716, -0.019077833741903305, 0.018444133922457695, -0.002017066115513444, 0.005812473129481077, 0.0014290842227637768, -0.0489901527762413, 0.018389709293842316, 0.0019027936505153775, -0.0036262464709579945, 0.031567562371492386, 0.018518324941396713, -0.05755336582660675, 0.0398249626159668, -0.011269671842455864, -0.04125481843948364, -0.008049207739531994, -0.02092824876308441, 0.03142767399549484, 0.016435610130429268, 0.006983364466577768, 0.036498092114925385, 0.0016946244286373258, -0.05043670907616615, 0.023410599678754807, -0.03936624899506569, -0.02126249298453331, -0.07665996253490448, -0.050229936838150024, 0.027557509019970894, -0.004321671091020107, -0.03291977941989899, 0.05221736803650856, -0.02949439361691475, 0.01569245755672455, -0.0365927591919899, -0.08971911668777466, 0.015238478779792786, -0.018240274861454964, 0.04484857618808746, 0.026586493477225304, -0.036803293973207474, 0.022585513070225716, 0.011365528218448162, -0.04472330957651138, -0.07279744744300842, 0.012059939093887806, -0.020273838192224503, -0.0031312131322920322, 0.041777726262807846, 0.005979383829981089, 0.01949882321059704, -0.02956346608698368, 0.024581287056207657, 0.007769977208226919, 0.0928095281124115, -0.0049954066053032875, -0.012990024872124195, 0.008452469483017921, 0.020118720829486847, -0.014195661060512066, 0.038866348564624786, 0.02028128318488598, -0.05367359519004822, 0.017207885161042213, -0.006675738841295242, -0.02242523431777954, 0.04848805442452431, -0.03701988607645035, -0.015184379182755947, -0.0015794496284797788, 0.0015821265988051891, -0.005957211833447218, -0.029196729883551598, -0.008571035228669643, -0.027529696002602577, -0.007609640248119831, 0.07483601570129395, 0.027988474816083908, -0.01815962605178356, -0.029032744467258453, 0.06647710502147675, 0.039107199758291245, -0.029621882364153862, 0.015476156957447529, 0.014471742324531078, 0.01984471268951893, 0.0318608321249485, -0.026447748765349388, -0.027210671454668045, 0.013115040957927704, 0.053241923451423645, 0.029991012066602707, 0.045752909034490585, -0.01974128559231758, 0.0013018621830269694, -0.06545265763998032, 0.030934281647205353, -0.00749366357922554, 0.11188001185655594, -0.004720726981759071, 0.058570753782987595, 0.011296606622636318, -0.009062845259904861, 0.035703349858522415, -0.002743865130469203, -0.08875473588705063, 0.03056676872074604, -0.025201402604579926, 0.017971208319067955, -0.016100620850920677, 0.005809629801660776, -0.011765929870307446, -0.0011987631442025304, 0.043786078691482544, 0.0251331627368927, 0.030731048434972763, -0.06755601614713669, 0.022032352164387703, -0.020785758271813393, 0.028766095638275146, -0.04262658581137657, 0.023282358422875404, 0.0178832970559597, -0.013380097225308418, 0.07357523590326309, 0.027063464745879173, -0.013186396099627018, -0.021255116909742355, -0.007238576654344797, -0.008803480304777622, 0.003407712560147047, 0.04327927902340889, -0.005272852256894112, 0.03136797994375229, -0.020411940291523933, -0.002824083436280489, 0.0024456758983433247, 0.019942086189985275, 0.02684864029288292, 0.02032756805419922, 0.008065522648394108, -0.013182973489165306, 0.004620822612196207, -0.018094301223754883, 0.05481728911399841, -0.011173670180141926, 0.013531687669456005, -0.01038803905248642, -0.0029290218371897936, -0.04755913093686104, 0.018922576680779457, 0.09816920012235641, 0.02126818336546421, -0.04390161111950874, -0.041827838867902756, -0.0019240336259827018, 0.02431778982281685, 0.02069687470793724, 0.023034024983644485, 0.029293710365891457, 0.004334324970841408, -0.00033672829158604145, 0.01645304076373577, -0.01327611319720745, -0.03722671419382095, -0.026926523074507713, 0.0021457523107528687, 0.015302472747862339, -0.01599857769906521, -0.04104261472821236, 0.01912252977490425, 0.06328078359365463, 0.060482896864414215, 0.04533962532877922, -0.0014839989598840475, -0.09671174734830856, 0.01945478469133377, 0.04902154579758644, 0.04615376889705658, -0.053788382560014725, 0.016162149608135223, -0.028013288974761963, 0.003261548699811101, 0.02606390044093132, -0.05801493674516678, 0.03222372382879257, -0.016824036836624146, 0.01480372529476881, -0.005036544054746628, -0.01564171351492405, -0.056628964841365814, 0.020614556968212128, -0.013257689774036407, 0.047221630811691284, -0.020610081031918526, -0.03338885307312012, -0.016321826726198196, 0.026625793427228928, 0.007035026792436838, 0.026420028880238533, -0.030531829223036766, -0.010522052645683289, 0.007372947875410318, 0.03551558405160904, -0.017283260822296143, -0.056736838072538376, 0.03109855018556118, 0.03935328871011734, 0.011810355819761753, 0.05170123279094696, -0.009627385064959526, -0.03506893664598465, 0.004869484342634678, -0.002842765999957919, -0.03926488384604454, -0.04958254471421242, -0.035911254584789276, 0.0328863263130188, 0.05227348208427429, 0.02045617252588272, 0.017500635236501694, 0.023660143837332726, -0.014249543659389019, 0.008770457468926907, -0.06321168690919876, -0.02041262947022915, -0.009946372359991074, 0.023666366934776306, -0.03284216672182083, 0.021673962473869324, -0.05468476191163063, 0.016070643439888954, 0.002764933742582798, 0.028938420116901398, -0.028295187279582024, 0.015724021941423416, 0.00459311855956912, 0.029827648773789406, -0.017241043969988823, 0.0003121724585071206, -0.04081840068101883, 0.010369102470576763, -0.028480827808380127, -0.02709464356303215, 0.04911939054727554, -0.025597356259822845, -0.0255446620285511, 0.018468698486685753, -0.018325744196772575, 0.00518342200666666, -0.04449022188782692, -0.025640474632382393, 0.015043333172798157, -0.014184213243424892, 0.00866656843572855, -0.00643807090818882, 0.043125979602336884, 0.050186190754175186, -0.0422837920486927, -0.0021091934759169817, 0.007008261978626251, 0.00028356476104818285, -0.012121522799134254, -0.02054860256612301, 0.04156075417995453, 0.011465716175734997, -0.031204823404550552, -0.0679173618555069, -0.03655185177922249, -0.00798932183533907, -0.028690246865153313, -0.03141317516565323, -0.05054362863302231, -0.040488094091415405, -0.02635212428867817, 0.003069378435611725, -0.046748772263526917, 0.03906474635004997, 0.024150487035512924, -0.03197754919528961, 0.02444569766521454, 0.005289030726999044, 0.06721911579370499, 0.028382645919919014, 0.009402874857187271, 0.011304927058517933, 0.008236824534833431, -0.0037923078052699566, -0.005765461828559637, 0.0060387165285646915, -0.01467601116746664, 0.00788819044828415, -0.033723264932632446, 0.008519296534359455, 0.04548855125904083, -0.021130116656422615, 0.01526603102684021, -0.004264842253178358, 0.029168322682380676, -0.003364820731803775, -0.04778589680790901, -0.01131404098123312, -0.02149352990090847, -0.017953483387827873, -0.022450556978583336, 0.004456871654838324, -0.020477138459682465, -0.00959241297096014, 0.007826332934200764, 0.005663793534040451, -0.006842791568487883, 0.013214568607509136, 0.05440910533070564, -0.012747004628181458, 0.00011392840679036453, 0.02966417372226715, -0.026044059544801712, 0.04156597703695297, 0.02296176180243492, -0.00925477035343647, 0.041031528264284134, 0.05973571166396141, -0.0011266268556937575, -0.018480069935321808, 0.013191298581659794, 0.031440671533346176, 0.0568142868578434, 0.01754121109843254, 0.022925738245248795, 0.0679490938782692, 0.03436826542019844, -0.01800365373492241, -0.0007267774199135602, 0.042473237961530685, -0.0018258540658280253, 0.0038080194499343634, 0.03332776948809624, -0.04185301810503006, -0.00677619269117713, -0.00020825615501962602, 0.0312545970082283, -0.008444001898169518, 0.029199155047535896, 0.026454398408532143, 0.03417804837226868, 0.004627102520316839, -0.04065430164337158, -0.01729392819106579, -0.0012061912566423416, -0.03437776491045952, 0.033790167421102524, -0.011364576406776905, -0.014911085367202759, 0.018610795959830284, 0.05558520928025246, -0.012753425166010857, -0.026707002893090248, -0.021372832357883453, -0.018872445449233055, 0.04193887487053871, 0.023850634694099426, -0.034885190427303314, 0.026850104331970215, -0.011547112837433815, 0.007610540371388197, 0.05513758957386017, 0.016105785965919495, -0.01747056469321251, -0.042955636978149414, -0.016501571983098984, -0.04072239249944687, -0.05939435213804245, 0.026177935302257538, 0.011225377209484577, -0.06486291438341141, 0.03941701352596283, -0.026861578226089478, 0.011710546910762787, 0.014234586618840694, 0.03266829252243042, -0.007266744039952755, 0.05281190201640129, 0.012601087801158428, 0.018492229282855988, 0.015143274329602718, 0.016970347613096237, 0.09795184433460236, 0.10440428555011749, 0.032203372567892075, -0.03441980853676796, -0.003101551905274391, 0.010156344622373581, -0.06002280116081238, -0.0323818139731884, 0.022052831947803497, 0.007228533737361431, 0.018302354961633682, 0.015908604487776756, 0.03236250951886177, -0.001062600058503449, 0.035521671175956726, 0.0423925407230854, -0.04751196876168251, -0.021231673657894135, 0.02000817470252514, -0.03475850448012352, -0.012507994659245014, -0.0017481204122304916, -0.08460979908704758, 0.02495660074055195, 0.02485617622733116, -0.005704832263290882, -0.010857329703867435, -0.018206831067800522, 0.027272729203104973, -0.01733441837131977, -0.015474156476557255, 0.028761010617017746, -0.014696229249238968, 0.0033681157510727644, -0.0380203016102314, 0.006728445179760456, 0.007593429181724787, -0.01219590287655592, 0.02344837784767151, 0.033528488129377365, 0.020178968086838722, -0.011428197845816612, -0.05763661488890648, 0.003934788983315229, -0.01606902666389942, 0.0057949647307395935, -0.05566826090216637, 0.028067607432603836, 0.005303920246660709, 0.015527499839663506, -0.009307018481194973, 0.026314441114664078, 0.003820570185780525, -0.030938763171434402, -0.01956976391375065, 0.009216571226716042, 0.037990767508745193, -0.023839078843593597, -0.002126482781022787, -0.03787305951118469, -0.003014973597601056, -0.03574163094162941, -0.011721980758011341, 0.012980185449123383, 0.018534887582063675, 0.006699525285512209, -0.034977346658706665, 0.034056518226861954, -0.025349661707878113, -0.005207668524235487, -0.03543465584516525, -0.03879901394248009, -0.017091935500502586, -0.02747964672744274, 0.006111570168286562, -0.011420944705605507, 0.03495389223098755, -0.006842889357358217, -0.04387892782688141, -0.03508802875876427, 0.003915795590728521, 0.0008434970513917506, 0.011966084130108356, -0.027659542858600616, -0.013185275718569756, 0.002745134988799691, -0.011563346721231937, 0.05464307218790054, -0.015540864318609238, -0.0023993125651031733, 0.015077431686222553, 0.01531517505645752, 0.009684919379651546, -0.027056751772761345, -0.032215602695941925, -0.006249712314456701, -0.015721028670668602, 0.06306547671556473, -0.039163220673799515, 0.0502435602247715, 0.02514718286693096, -0.036339905112981796, -0.010680057108402252, 0.03211451321840286, -0.02531680278480053, 0.012844608165323734, -0.022074252367019653, -0.03413219377398491, -0.01687784120440483, 0.039423469454050064, 0.009980538859963417, -0.029110901057720184, -0.03923176974058151, -0.00332014262676239, -0.017144903540611267, 0.017812782898545265, 0.001712546101771295, -0.06115474924445152, 0.03992393985390663, -0.02815190888941288, 0.009635288268327713, -0.01677786186337471, 0.007410547696053982, -0.07167450338602066, 0.011728126555681229, -0.027230901643633842, -0.006301538553088903, -0.033206019550561905, 0.02000909298658371, 0.0022251964546740055, 0.032040681689977646, 0.0280417762696743, 0.013231894001364708, 0.04576842859387398, 0.03590495511889458, -0.005858750082552433, -0.03138263523578644, 0.025123395025730133, -0.002215044340118766, -0.02310279943048954, 0.02017829194664955, -0.06723183393478394, -0.043932557106018066, 0.011624516919255257, -0.0011997490655630827, 0.01967952959239483, 0.00629999628290534, 0.01596159301698208, -0.026326404884457588, 0.025006353855133057, 0.002981551457196474, -0.005342492368072271, -0.014528408646583557, 0.022587807849049568, -0.026030568405985832, -0.024455076083540916, -0.00609624246135354, -0.0015583598287776113, -0.013124684803187847, -0.042961347848176956, 0.05222337320446968, 0.026934577152132988, -0.06187495216727257, 0.018273118883371353, -0.018867189064621925, 0.009322095662355423, 0.005164488684386015, -0.02003154158592224, 0.02641977369785309, 0.04941374063491821, -0.033359695225954056, -0.015195818617939949, -0.03867214545607567, 0.02884926088154316, -0.051606036722660065, -0.016382453963160515, 0.0034538886975497007, -0.015808848664164543, 0.05027351155877113, -0.04095246270298958, -0.0230716485530138, 0.04024011641740799, -0.03475077450275421, 0.03621291369199753, 0.004210962448269129, -0.004179240204393864, -0.06535958498716354, 0.02628735639154911, -0.041676778346300125, 0.03001941181719303, 0.035107459872961044, 0.030424227938055992, 0.03927895054221153, 0.03191506117582321, 0.02409864030778408, -0.024268917739391327, 0.008485731668770313, 0.03147982805967331, -0.0004036944592371583, -0.04506443068385124, 0.021984675899147987, -0.06159820407629013, -0.04993733763694763, 0.007990051060914993, -0.00833328440785408, -0.007521029096096754, 0.06443209946155548, -0.010921339504420757, -0.015024467371404171, 0.03773633763194084, 0.07025473564863205, -0.03460931032896042, -0.010362405329942703, 0.007548753172159195, -0.005078330170363188, -0.005690034478902817, 0.020258372649550438, 0.0065306699834764, -0.002023071050643921, 0.013775416649878025, 0.008105143904685974, 0.02151360921561718, -0.002309519797563553, -0.010590741410851479, -0.011398999951779842, -0.009780860505998135, -0.03318887948989868, -0.018716761842370033, -0.028368445113301277, -0.022707292810082436, 0.02330014295876026, 0.006281283684074879, 0.005494234152138233, -0.025457661598920822, 0.0008327839314006269, -0.0065253060311079025, -0.0664953961968422, 0.018142178654670715, -0.035908475518226624, -0.022708823904395103, -0.07180505245923996, -0.021302668377757072, -0.0005693387938663363, -0.010958029888570309, -0.031371090561151505, -0.033514782786369324, -0.012427293695509434, 0.076935775578022, -0.0235525481402874, 0.005631324835121632, 0.004400540143251419, -0.0171493086963892, 0.026261616498231888, -0.05372025817632675, 0.0384969636797905, -0.03273189440369606, 0.003639094764366746, 0.0055512916296720505, -0.0023480395320802927, -0.02859995700418949, 0.03729931265115738, 0.0375119112432003, -0.007320907432585955, 0.01693119667470455, -0.035497650504112244, -0.0034220898523926735, 0.03219030052423477, -0.053874701261520386, 0.0383622832596302, -0.03221224620938301, -0.024465812370181084, -0.012292886152863503, -0.00688873790204525, 0.013269806280732155, -0.009294174611568451, 0.0558292381465435, -0.010971208103001118, -0.022707227617502213, -0.0193965844810009, -0.041252367198467255, -0.010263605043292046, 0.027190817520022392, 0.02616441249847412, 0.04020052030682564, -0.024494875222444534, 0.016655515879392624, 0.02865939401090145, 0.006685734260827303, -0.023890675976872444, 0.049757178872823715, -0.07723530381917953, -0.0007183229317888618, 0.041351646184921265, -0.007537985686212778, 0.00793785322457552, -0.08371714502573013, -0.005744640715420246, 0.014491894282400608, -0.05431895703077316, -0.01063731499016285, 0.03427281975746155, 0.009877619333565235, 0.0417693592607975, -0.011661025695502758, 0.03475569933652878, -0.017183443531394005, -0.01619620993733406, 0.01396174542605877, 0.03414980322122574, -0.008731812238693237, 0.013583118095993996, 0.009326627478003502, 0.013702303171157837, 0.008227658458054066, 0.04287876561284065, 0.003337191417813301, -0.003304487094283104, -0.01794390194118023, 0.0015868686605244875, 0.041523173451423645, -0.011714044958353043, 0.033633653074502945, 0.020050741732120514, 0.01350371167063713, 0.019821275025606155, -0.054662853479385376, 0.0055608926340937614, -0.07398717105388641, -0.04827344790101051, -0.046464476734399796, 0.00514500355347991, 0.021202022209763527, 0.042161550372838974, -0.006150874309241772, 0.04775368049740791, -0.0029558115638792515, 0.018417252227663994, 0.04585025832056999, -0.025784073397517204, 0.04140365123748779, -0.03515296429395676, -0.014716099947690964, 0.04356866702437401, 0.0005971546052023768, -0.047030266374349594, 0.00019866606453433633, 0.017311321571469307, 0.034980468451976776, 0.017252542078495026, -0.007414603140205145, -0.04540369659662247, -0.03687575086951256, 0.026832887902855873, -0.014166352339088917, -0.011980067007243633, -0.05411336570978165, 0.012180808931589127, -0.022970719262957573, 0.0004036413156427443 ]
<p>I am running a 2x2x5 mixed factorial ANCOVA, with one within-groups variable, and two between groups variable. I want to check for violation of homogeneity of regression slopes. My covatiate does not interact with my between groups variables. It does however interact with my within-groups variable. Is this still a violation of the assumption? </p>
73,931
[ -0.007025930564850569, 0.001980109605938196, -0.019216911867260933, 0.03050028160214424, 0.05057775229215622, 0.021697422489523888, -0.04474896565079689, 0.006991999689489603, 0.022496867924928665, -0.024261344224214554, 0.020768513903021812, 0.0037621455267071724, 0.077000193297863, 0.029700445011258125, 0.015544889494776726, 0.0006703927065245807, -0.0041104881092906, -0.000013185253010306042, 0.008245579898357391, 0.0023472721222788095, -0.019058188423514366, 0.01510711945593357, 0.009459423832595348, -0.044031403958797455, 0.0064427778124809265, 0.01384388655424118, 0.030810484662652016, -0.027039378881454468, 0.028146112337708473, 0.007356103975325823, -0.014112167060375214, -0.023205887526273727, -0.01796894706785679, 0.025446508079767227, 0.014996521174907684, -0.009459906257689, -0.023754611611366272, -0.037014927715063095, 0.0033505489118397236, 0.04392238333821297, -0.03999027982354164, -0.021062606945633888, 0.022510018199682236, 0.06567840278148651, -0.007204252760857344, 0.03745317459106445, 0.016906633973121643, 0.02009459026157856, 0.049295149743556976, -0.029747923836112022, 0.07699566334486008, 0.04150962457060814, 0.04230251535773277, 0.039973028004169464, -0.023014120757579803, -0.0031913083512336016, 0.05467827245593071, 0.030374843627214432, 0.01687312126159668, -0.03227642551064491, -0.023663565516471863, -0.03206057474017143, 0.011251319199800491, -0.003473366377875209, -0.06066291406750679, 0.009410928003489971, -0.02122332714498043, -0.041333913803100586, -0.0032833521254360676, -0.0018055654363706708, 0.00440912926569581, -0.02461862936615944, 0.04110990837216377, -0.012110250070691109, 0.035881951451301575, -0.02478718012571335, 0.04549839720129967, 0.030831485986709595, 0.015967614948749542, 0.021417172625660896, 0.005549968220293522, 0.018177447840571404, -0.0057921865954995155, 0.03556307777762413, -0.012572890147566795, -0.011765958741307259, 0.05641136318445206, -0.029950788244605064, 0.011174517683684826, 0.005536267068237066, -0.02973206155002117, -0.0008275103755295277, 0.062017206102609634, 0.015343377366662025, -0.036066628992557526, -0.0010812294203788042, -0.037340182811021805, 0.019895285367965698, -0.01708061434328556, 0.021261122077703476, -0.04214907065033913, -0.0016105478862300515, 0.0463409461081028, 0.034140609204769135, -0.003949829377233982, -0.016893228515982628, -0.036469027400016785, -0.005211533512920141, -0.0034108133986592293, -0.015544340014457703, -0.018884558230638504, 0.011408568359911442, -0.006222234107553959, -0.021894514560699463, 0.05087604746222496, 0.0009920868324115872, -0.026227587834000587, -0.023395834490656853, 0.085232675075531, 0.05452987924218178, 0.07679717987775803, -0.009195901453495026, 0.042800139635801315, -0.0014455736381933093, -0.0444151945412159, 0.013871321454644203, 0.02315443567931652, 0.010398723185062408, -0.0583965927362442, 0.039981819689273834, 0.010298222303390503, -0.004660114645957947, -0.012703495100140572, -0.021660078316926956, 0.03070788085460663, -0.026512131094932556, -0.09619594365358353, -0.057020917534828186, 0.016933156177401543, 0.016051754355430603, 0.033315710723400116, -0.05294362083077431, -0.01987181231379509, 0.024472257122397423, 0.06826642900705338, -0.028787417337298393, 0.054655175656080246, 0.00991947203874588, 0.0413927286863327, 0.009677478112280369, -0.019090278074145317, -0.018397526815533638, -0.06283783167600632, -0.029838724061846733, -0.014314272440969944, -0.10560259222984314, 0.022568343207240105, 0.029039878398180008, -0.02445986121892929, 0.012899879366159439, 0.03062395751476288, -0.010737594217061996, 0.011880423873662949, -0.00994113553315401, 0.02921774983406067, -0.013687626458704472, 0.04112030938267708, -0.04411076381802559, 0.0600212924182415, 0.033492326736450195, 0.0179938692599535, 0.04415445029735565, -0.027396423742175102, 0.07648476213216782, 0.0430232472717762, -0.01998380944132805, 0.014669244177639484, 2.1494106761110743e-7, 0.017162209376692772, 0.008500680327415466, -0.06253430992364883, -0.010100198909640312, -0.008033898659050465, -0.0019351911032572389, -0.0023487170692533255, 0.015351581387221813, 0.0205026026815176, -0.0004005589580629021, 0.02648538537323475, -0.02602536790072918, -0.040496453642845154, -0.03695621341466904, 0.001217631041072309, 0.024796705693006516, -0.02891070954501629, 0.03685509413480759, -0.004647425375878811, 0.0024138556327670813, -0.02370779775083065, -0.02502376027405262, -0.03906315192580223, 0.024165619164705276, 0.04643706604838371, -0.05329033359885216, 0.05922945216298103, -0.0010525539983063936, 0.06357162445783615, 0.014237220399081707, 0.02972157672047615, -0.018482012674212456, -0.018850555643439293, 0.03762636333703995, -0.013143870048224926, 0.021960850805044174, -0.04153301566839218, 0.02213633805513382, -0.017872435972094536, 0.017422214150428772, -0.02223539538681507, 0.07091353833675385, -0.06079619750380516, 0.03181266784667969, 0.08291854709386826, 0.012207139283418655, 0.01741574890911579, -0.003545887302607298, -0.013891059905290604, -0.01448107697069645, -0.05679643899202347, -0.024295039474964142, -0.03244335949420929, -0.0062376451678574085, 0.017491281032562256, 0.020077452063560486, -0.0066243670880794525, 0.020669903606176376, 0.04283676669001579, 0.01830151304602623, -0.007776039186865091, 0.022432783618569374, 0.022455338388681412, -0.028620263561606407, 0.011359491385519505, 0.038235899060964584, 0.04428013041615486, -0.008667819201946259, -0.011339988559484482, 0.013506955467164516, 0.04658013582229614, -0.011343945749104023, 0.02462412416934967, 0.0539538636803627, -0.0009107624646276236, 0.033965762704610825, -0.03760681301355362, -0.011542296037077904, 0.02899566851556301, -0.019194742664694786, 0.021607661619782448, 0.029544426128268242, 0.022263608872890472, -0.0706077292561531, -0.009311302565038204, -0.043739091604948044, 0.001776224235072732, 0.022382749244570732, -0.026794694364070892, 0.01099693775177002, 0.019613103941082954, -0.009550412185490131, -0.007067283149808645, -0.0271749384701252, 0.009377028793096542, 0.003811752423644066, 0.019309505820274353, 0.057351987808942795, -0.007533198222517967, 0.013661572709679604, -0.046226371079683304, 0.011768808588385582, -0.016904866322875023, -0.026105035096406937, 0.03505830466747284, -0.015713367611169815, -0.03755860775709152, 0.021697035059332848, -0.012604531832039356, 0.02092556469142437, 0.011217317543923855, -0.0041067046113312244, 0.007446662988513708, 0.06540616601705551, -0.019757797941565514, -0.05372278392314911, -0.01791170798242092, -0.0015074423281475902, -0.01955648697912693, -0.034602727741003036, -0.031200973317027092, 0.007848330773413181, -0.00010623387061059475, -0.02368600107729435, 0.04393497481942177, -0.02854606695473194, -0.011451137252151966, -0.014677123166620731, -0.03364177420735359, -0.016616826876997948, 0.010103315114974976, 0.0489153116941452, 0.03857241943478584, -0.014335882849991322, -0.013535293750464916, -0.07971853017807007, -0.08357734978199005, 0.035446647554636, -0.002365361899137497, -0.010119905695319176, -0.033443134278059006, -0.008339203894138336, 0.04638045281171799, 0.031119024381041527, -0.03707738593220711, -0.03561107814311981, -0.048836175352334976, -0.04173317551612854, -0.044818904250860214, 0.014690411277115345, -0.02049398608505726, 0.005756520666182041, 0.044419944286346436, -0.010597446002066135, 0.022355370223522186, 0.04523172229528427, 0.0015191127313300967, -0.02429858036339283, 0.029554441571235657, 0.05708123743534088, 0.006271783262491226, 0.03938499093055725, 0.01864270307123661, 0.0012381410924717784, -0.017192671075463295, 0.01210238691419363, 0.05091121420264244, -0.01043581124395132, -0.025565028190612793, 0.02634134143590927, -0.049789831042289734, 0.04176705330610275, -0.014044185169041157, 0.028592070564627647, 0.039474837481975555, -0.01787266507744789, 0.007907996885478497, 0.011559376493096352, 0.0180836021900177, -0.02725294791162014, 0.0219001155346632, 0.047622594982385635, 0.04305905103683472, -0.0029612863436341286, -0.02866256795823574, -0.02264460362493992, 0.014143794775009155, 0.024151165038347244, -0.015376710332930088, -0.014368158765137196, 0.01313633844256401, -0.009509154595434666, -0.003612659638747573, 0.022909050807356834, -0.034373100847005844, -0.005908633582293987, -0.0634576827287674, 0.008954966440796852, -0.025051817297935486, 0.007054424379020929, -0.017187172546982765, 0.015027342364192009, 0.008308565244078636, -0.01058571320027113, -0.04309772700071335, -0.019542284309864044, -0.08041925728321075, 0.04696781933307648, -0.021106820553541183, 0.0002121518482454121, 0.017264794558286667, -0.042202141135931015, 0.00633121095597744, -0.010420188307762146, 0.004577747080475092, 0.0017031098250299692, 0.03835801035165787, -0.006130545865744352, 0.010521477088332176, -0.030384721234440804, -0.034252699464559555, -0.013203137554228306, -0.018190328031778336, -0.015935301780700684, -0.026740767061710358, 0.022458136081695557, 0.015469033271074295, -0.01579376310110092, 0.008066773414611816, -0.009078292176127434, 0.02444356121122837, 0.025900861248373985, 0.050770197063684464, 0.0301981121301651, 0.036654241383075714, -0.018465209752321243, 0.03669475018978119, -0.04245889559388161, 0.059091247618198395, 0.03831163048744202, 0.004174134228378534, -0.023318994790315628, -0.02009008824825287, -0.05734078586101532, 0.023605067282915115, 0.026589492335915565, -0.04362316429615021, 0.0018612617859616876, 0.034084297716617584, 0.06351898610591888, -0.03955237567424774, 0.046001385897397995, 0.08941284567117691, 0.05091489478945732, -0.02136632613837719, -0.0331185907125473, -0.019399389624595642, 0.02146775647997856, -0.0180369820445776, 0.02362259104847908, -0.005891899578273296, 0.0032114714849740267, 0.00017804483650252223, 0.0584554597735405, 0.0010440791957080364, -0.018024291843175888, 0.05516369640827179, 0.0148087777197361, 0.015155325643718243, 0.01588399149477482, -0.02458464540541172, 0.016154004260897636, 0.02999279834330082, 0.00016889114340301603, 0.04726173356175423, -0.03918253257870674, -0.07943083345890045, 0.01852174662053585, 0.03814338892698288, 0.04490986093878746, -0.01174119208008051, -0.03490021824836731, -0.015607595443725586, 0.0024788067676126957, 0.023151196539402008, -0.006774114910513163, 0.05212891101837158, -0.02297627553343773, 0.016011212021112442, -0.02279547229409218, -0.01934364065527916, -0.02565724588930607, 0.026687810197472572, 0.02090388722717762, -0.0036861193366348743, -0.00417659105733037, -0.010320937260985374, -0.027499794960021973, 0.027046827599406242, 0.02119413949549198, 0.043011270463466644, -0.020858781412243843, -0.006679524201899767, 0.001896168920211494, 0.025452720001339912, -0.0092447055503726, -0.017498459666967392, 0.04147271811962128, 0.005084004253149033, 0.021308736875653267, 0.06668607890605927, 0.021225178614258766, 0.011183391325175762, 0.01083761639893055, -0.0018553381087258458, 0.031708694994449615, 0.004571415949612856, -0.04184649512171745, 0.06102585792541504, 0.007059128489345312, 0.003469825955107808, 0.05084909498691559, 0.008359850384294987, -0.006821551825851202, -0.006641446612775326, -0.047973211854696274, 0.03038564883172512, -0.02759632095694542, -0.02289034053683281, -0.04909398406744003, -0.027173589915037155, -0.0010748935164883733, 0.008709871210157871, 0.012578820809721947, 0.010671095922589302, -0.021261222660541534, -0.024077357724308968, 0.021727116778492928, -0.0012228040723130107, -0.023807087913155556, 0.013596031814813614, -0.012248694896697998, 0.005468201823532581, -0.03888503089547157, -0.03152652084827423, 0.024298042058944702, -0.03069613315165043, 0.010705271735787392, 0.030323119834065437, 0.008015851490199566, 0.0037894314154982567, -0.03426460549235344, -0.05035508796572685, -0.03129603713750839, -0.006401428021490574, 0.009687647223472595, -0.017971795052289963, 0.08192800730466843, -0.0375572144985199, -0.020591048523783684, 0.03671173006296158, 0.052253641188144684, -0.01967107318341732, 0.04699740931391716, 0.0019191575702279806, 0.0567750446498394, 0.008750100620090961, -0.004931672941893339, -0.09663861244916916, -0.04549907147884369, -0.0028359289281070232, 0.0007457602769136429, -0.03073255345225334, -0.013156963512301445, -0.04152316600084305, -0.048477791249752045, -0.02151949517428875, -0.045140620321035385, 0.052705612033605576, -0.023017926141619682, -0.024487195536494255, -0.00713154673576355, -0.014311457984149456, 0.09490344673395157, -0.004218533169478178, -0.012749537825584412, 0.0031734744552522898, -0.013367928564548492, 0.004729193169623613, 0.0042573087848722935, 0.010343060828745365, -0.029097719117999077, 0.020434008911252022, -0.04445949196815491, 0.008525894023478031, 0.050579220056533813, -0.008312797173857689, -0.01968458667397499, 0.01762537658214569, -0.04672401398420334, 0.0014552244683727622, -0.04128747433423996, 0.024142904207110405, -0.04092477634549141, -0.003920393530279398, -0.003666600910946727, 0.002498830435797572, 0.016615621745586395, 0.008794432505965233, -0.0006595862796530128, -0.005187818314880133, -0.044454425573349, 0.021019939333200455, 0.08422153443098068, 0.022674428299069405, -0.00109419459477067, 0.014725667424499989, -0.015970826148986816, 0.03584158048033714, -0.01807226613163948, -0.018341755494475365, -0.016589859500527382, 0.0191238634288311, -0.04853109270334244, -0.03197667375206947, -0.03307018056511879, 0.03200709819793701, 0.043637942522764206, -0.03405645862221718, 0.02126808650791645, 0.06304453313350677, 0.01001716684550047, -0.04659724980592728, -0.040597666054964066, 0.017984699457883835, -0.006843982730060816, -0.004045845940709114, 0.05260797217488289, -0.022004827857017517, -0.026577748358249664, 0.01813647150993347, 0.03814542293548584, 0.002285911701619625, 0.03129631653428078, -0.014111788012087345, 0.04809143766760826, 0.017371276393532753, 0.02371867746114731, -0.08512599021196365, 0.02340087667107582, -0.05485440045595169, -0.015571466647088528, -0.06820476800203323, -0.019204530864953995, 0.009361643344163895, 0.06374749541282654, 0.025398921221494675, -0.05785393342375755, -0.04484245926141739, -0.03449181094765663, 0.016511522233486176, -0.021334633231163025, 0.00225076824426651, 0.04850632697343826, -0.002940739970654249, 0.025410614907741547, 0.02461072988808155, 0.024596335366368294, -0.03914831206202507, -0.08361431211233139, -0.0012524083722382784, -0.019676458090543747, 0.004358424339443445, -0.016673272475600243, -0.007296336814761162, -0.05413641780614853, 0.03033660724759102, -0.033523041754961014, 0.008126229979097843, 0.0005546741303987801, 0.04113744571805, 0.034850772470235825, 0.042753249406814575, -0.01020097266882658, 0.025811107829213142, 0.018490822985768318, 0.015542013570666313, 0.10119982808828354, 0.0656077116727829, 0.01934986375272274, -0.0471622496843338, 0.03409098461270332, -0.023687483742833138, -0.0017699779709801078, -0.011882211081683636, -0.0047957138158380985, -0.024044310674071312, -0.037986062467098236, 0.05266112834215164, 0.04711788892745972, 0.014530668966472149, 0.016934184357523918, 0.03871701657772064, -0.05346061289310455, 0.015495055355131626, 0.01770043559372425, 0.01355426013469696, -0.025176657363772392, -0.0032834254670888186, 0.0018448347691446543, -0.015232246369123459, -0.0030232667922973633, -0.033957090228796005, 0.005706522148102522, 0.001766039291396737, 0.017200380563735962, 0.03294983133673668, -0.0463782362639904, 0.035154789686203, -0.009362565353512764, 0.007817169651389122, -0.051803845912218094, -0.04291536286473274, 0.016239743679761887, -0.05719636008143425, 0.01953640766441822, 0.010326573625206947, -0.024495014920830727, -0.00505051901564002, 0.04533134028315544, -0.012645340524613857, -0.026479749009013176, -0.0215996652841568, -0.010359065607190132, 0.04984111711382866, -0.002263844944536686, -0.03688080981373787, 0.0025933878496289253, 0.00042299809865653515, 0.045978836715221405, -0.0690532922744751, -0.021218739449977875, -0.009059684351086617, 0.004461698234081268, -0.00810560118407011, -0.018611596897244453, -0.023851633071899414, -0.0022934910375624895, 0.0020717040169984102, 0.03740191087126732, 0.02937905117869377, -0.03986523672938347, -0.00676021259278059, -0.021721303462982178, 0.04724171385169029, -0.011371728032827377, -0.012306786142289639, -0.0028686595614999533, -0.028926046565175056, -0.030253129079937935, -0.020617520436644554, 0.009493201971054077, 0.05347312241792679, 0.023329421877861023, 0.002353635849431157, -0.017390722408890724, -0.006379709113389254, -0.03115195594727993, -0.017833547666668892, -0.05228475108742714, -0.006831816863268614, -0.0460076667368412, -0.03834822028875351, 0.03062102384865284, 0.028781592845916748, -0.007227472495287657, -0.0011523914290592074, -0.014997710473835468, 0.06446181237697601, 0.0004683622973971069, -0.018597353249788284, -0.0005600613076239824, -0.016575245186686516, -0.06435885280370712, -0.02592908963561058, -0.039185862988233566, 0.054053064435720444, -0.023537786677479744, 0.010387244634330273, -0.014354373328387737, 0.012539738789200783, -0.0011948421597480774, 0.050393301993608475, 0.01504775881767273, -0.04548043757677078, 0.026375815272331238, -0.018830103799700737, -0.024590350687503815, -0.011213942430913448, -0.015130092389881611, -0.047295428812503815, -0.03388405591249466, 0.031913816928863525, -0.03758750110864639, -0.02027820236980915, -0.002397914882749319, -0.018984833732247353, 0.03478700667619705, -0.02817162126302719, -0.016666939482092857, -0.03224902227520943, -0.03068484738469124, 0.04384467750787735, -0.02583056129515171, -0.00726891215890646, 0.02169702760875225, -0.018598197028040886, 0.011046660132706165, 0.05036860704421997, 0.03536498174071312, 0.05260350927710533, -0.03537944331765175, 0.03357962146401405, 0.015660803765058517, 0.08252300322055817, 0.006507952697575092, -0.016123119741678238, 0.03394290804862976, -0.03892320394515991, -0.02873287722468376, 0.004133890848606825, -0.0031881786417216063, 0.02326875552535057, 0.019515646621584892, -0.012788650579750538, -0.027840329334139824, 0.06887830048799515, -0.01575157418847084, 0.018705755472183228, -0.013373707421123981, -0.0029833954758942127, 0.004543943330645561, -0.012366930954158306, -0.012502878904342651, 0.025093693286180496, 0.007011594250798225, 0.03288429602980614, 0.037975385785102844, 0.01754952035844326, -0.016800332814455032, -0.032741524279117584, 0.0015559729654341936, -0.0027044836897403, 0.015358634293079376, 0.0072061107493937016, 0.005824974272400141, 0.0435955710709095, -0.015244316309690475, -0.01813635416328907, -0.005504626780748367, 0.03654259443283081, -0.08054230362176895, -0.038550205528736115, 0.02173585630953312, 0.01868346519768238, 0.02763180620968342, -0.04308231547474861, 0.020092898979783058, 0.024502241984009743, -0.06076597794890404, -0.017778173089027405, 0.0004862054775003344, -0.016187993809580803, -0.07524129003286362, -0.023133179172873497, -0.019631637260317802, -0.016624148935079575, 0.01589626632630825, 0.02954462543129921, 0.04773367568850517, -0.0019091326976194978, -0.02751852199435234, -0.06418206542730331, 0.025453422218561172, -0.016840700060129166, -0.009033010341227055, -0.03458639979362488, 0.014516116119921207, 0.013133702799677849, -0.0494280643761158, -0.004009389318525791, -0.01629241742193699, -0.007116186898201704, 0.019113991409540176, 0.06188705191016197, 0.030795052647590637, 0.0438217930495739, 0.024815386161208153, 0.023224227130413055, 0.040639545768499374, -0.000551929057110101, -0.03192231059074402, 0.048524416983127594, -0.010382786393165588, 0.010894895531237125, 0.0172173622995615, -0.013811749406158924, -0.03163689002394676, 0.015405128709971905, -0.01744399033486843, -0.022532733157277107, -0.019904375076293945, -0.02553870528936386, 0.04338430240750313, -0.027698945254087448, 0.013408559374511242, -0.044489555060863495, -0.009000441059470177, 0.0481024831533432, 0.0426904559135437, -0.038372255861759186, -0.037218738347291946, 0.006542294751852751, -0.045113008469343185, 0.0023471040185540915, 0.009443028829991817, 0.000012631658137252089, -0.04727519676089287, -0.011051545850932598, -0.02076835185289383, -0.00879752915352583, -0.01738443598151207, -0.01711207814514637, -0.03205844387412071, 0.04066738486289978, -0.00730068888515234, -0.011503096669912338, -0.02334289625287056, 0.009974784217774868, 0.017659978941082954, -0.0640416368842125, 0.04169652983546257, -0.016536204144358635, -0.0023472411558032036, -0.02849387936294079, 0.007512271404266357, -0.05455530807375908, -0.0017267573857679963, 0.01075691170990467, 0.02220287173986435, 0.010565495118498802, 0.02825491689145565, 0.03621404245495796, -0.019745230674743652, -0.03402526676654816, 0.0778423547744751, 0.000851960270665586, -0.0117837805300951, -0.007488702889531851, 0.035277172923088074, -0.029168659821152687, 0.0011911721667274833, 0.009922209195792675, -0.005415691528469324, 0.027106085792183876, 0.025736337527632713, -0.007752123288810253, 0.005812505260109901, -0.020719438791275024, -0.013455339707434177, 0.047743529081344604, -0.02218136191368103, 0.013029651716351509, 0.025391804054379463, 0.031461890786886215, -0.03665193170309067, 0.038331687450408936, -0.011350085958838463, -0.010348698124289513, -0.019662197679281235, 0.01475223433226347, -0.0289485901594162, -0.0326070711016655, 0.03299635276198387, 0.018163004890084267, -0.04767223820090294, 0.009018694050610065, 0.010525967925786972, 0.027500588446855545, 0.04680364206433296, -0.0030359607189893723, 0.024037720635533333, 0.0101957768201828, -0.025860093533992767, 0.019717350602149963, 0.04350221902132034, 0.025342151522636414, 0.020466478541493416, -0.008831923827528954, 0.015695087611675262, -0.02987978607416153, 0.03402706980705261, -0.010545640252530575, 0.02631598524749279, 0.008755546063184738, -0.0025425648782402277, 0.005427056457847357, -0.03256583586335182, 0.033169936388731, -0.01415678858757019, 0.00987438764423132, 0.04873853921890259, -0.051986850798130035, 0.002946375170722604, -0.07036052644252777, 0.011569751426577568, 0.01079623308032751, 0.0303419791162014, 0.03298857435584068, 0.014177934266626835, 0.015763288363814354, 0.004905525129288435, 0.0021764119155704975, -0.03290540724992752, 0.01159929670393467, -0.01791389100253582, 0.029539717361330986, -0.026078589260578156, 0.00909875426441431, -0.02655770629644394, -0.02300550416111946, -0.0599001981317997, -0.03429447486996651, 0.011411886662244797, 0.022582754492759705, 0.02591635473072529, -0.030797792598605156, -0.011560489423573017, -0.00416994746774435, 0.04304935783147812, -0.06953903287649155, -0.031249571591615677, -0.007720613386482, 0.024751760065555573, 0.027156535536050797, 0.012790319509804249 ]
<p>Suppose we have a data set $X$. This data set consists of ordinal data (4 levels). To get estimates of the threshold coefficients and probit slope ($\beta_1, \dots, \beta_3$ and $\beta_4$ respectively), do most computational packages use maximum likelihood estimation? That is, given the data, MLE chooses the parameters that maximizes the probability of observing the data?</p>
73,932
[ -0.03390937298536301, -0.0018686738330870867, 0.010001015849411488, 0.029571179300546646, -0.006725453305989504, 0.07773996144533157, 0.008066317066550255, -0.009822053834795952, 0.03816020488739014, -0.009930882602930069, -0.0038496858906000853, 0.04033009707927704, 0.09065020829439163, 0.015690643340349197, 0.0665169432759285, 0.001477872603572905, -0.02318255975842476, 0.036153893917798996, -0.01710306666791439, -0.010012893006205559, -0.03949124738574028, 0.04723888635635376, 0.012900124303996563, 0.0031530268024653196, -0.02228955179452896, 0.018309837207198143, 0.028609266504645348, -0.03420896455645561, -0.023513032123446465, 0.039354488253593445, -0.027156246826052666, -0.02332918718457222, 0.013526168651878834, 0.04932817444205284, 0.0181141197681427, 0.009373911656439304, -0.028877627104520798, -0.02677645906805992, -0.008594143204391003, 0.0055305082350969315, -0.03609442338347435, -0.034937404096126556, 0.01865866594016552, 0.0022601676173508167, 0.004137387499213219, 0.011815699748694897, -0.008669535629451275, -0.005679850000888109, 0.01690961979329586, -0.018491143360733986, 0.05438416823744774, 0.006989320740103722, 0.017152145504951477, 0.02401054836809635, -0.02692682296037674, 0.002909792587161064, 0.030594686046242714, 0.0990525335073471, -0.016028311103582382, -0.049866948276758194, -0.03396335616707802, -0.01827855408191681, 0.018149301409721375, -0.011083418503403664, -0.03851839900016785, 0.0131467180326581, 0.011002506129443645, -0.01815900020301342, 0.04140638932585716, 0.014847815036773682, -0.013097819872200489, 0.015463185496628284, 0.0542568638920784, 0.01202954351902008, 0.0016026521334424615, -0.004386090207844973, 0.008292650803923607, 0.016328491270542145, 0.033175624907016754, 0.009129728190600872, 0.011182689107954502, -0.018986836075782776, 0.02520388923585415, 0.026740306988358498, -0.028959225863218307, 0.0007982315728440881, 0.0697007104754448, -0.04663408175110817, 0.03416340798139572, -0.022340990602970123, -0.020959606394171715, -0.013395655900239944, 0.02091938629746437, -0.016954340040683746, -0.022899677976965904, 0.018752455711364746, -0.021841736510396004, 0.013519484549760818, 0.04145481809973717, 0.007470151875168085, 0.007518307771533728, -0.022990671917796135, -0.054469604045152664, 0.05227268859744072, -0.0042168996296823025, 0.018090536817908287, -0.01809387095272541, -0.0027234102599322796, -0.019628264009952545, -0.017277857288718224, -0.022234465926885605, 0.0290556438267231, 0.01219941582530737, 0.0279480442404747, 0.013135481625795364, -0.0049358210526406765, 0.011996706947684288, -0.06149981915950775, 0.045586347579956055, 0.054746855050325394, 0.008786763995885849, -0.031954456120729446, 0.019500460475683212, -0.030203619971871376, -0.030005859211087227, 0.04219667240977287, -0.0000645957697997801, -0.019565653055906296, -0.0661078691482544, 0.02165576070547104, 0.0215921550989151, -0.005040924064815044, 0.060376882553100586, -0.0037983094807714224, -0.0023334946017712355, -0.0021444533485919237, -0.05332886055111885, -0.03322499245405197, 0.015601921826601028, -0.005906747188419104, 0.019234320148825645, -0.06830611079931259, -0.018116652965545654, 0.06348396837711334, 0.031117163598537445, 0.021378953009843826, 0.057186245918273926, 0.03955787047743797, 0.006801046431064606, -0.020417101681232452, -0.011875505559146404, -0.008417973294854164, -0.014202751219272614, -0.012840933166444302, -0.025535961613059044, -0.08740749955177307, -0.003885881043970585, 0.004906056448817253, 0.02431672252714634, -0.013578045181930065, 0.06251980364322662, 0.03730235993862152, -0.0253932923078537, -0.021131224930286407, 0.022819584235548973, -0.0005635457346215844, 0.05144466087222099, -0.014172929339110851, 0.06508269906044006, 0.032276902347803116, 0.01786588877439499, 0.055589672178030014, -0.005604193080216646, 0.0434236153960228, 0.05661221966147423, -0.037970032542943954, -0.025102250277996063, -0.03538498654961586, 0.048494696617126465, -0.011501380242407322, -0.022682109847664833, 0.004776098299771547, 0.025668123736977577, -0.04768989607691765, 0.03140414133667946, 0.03623965010046959, 0.010255686938762665, -0.04024151712656021, 0.03279967978596687, -0.04947960004210472, -0.03836842626333237, -0.048784952610731125, -0.006259347777813673, -0.026615319773554802, -0.02140284888446331, 0.03624315559864044, -0.008982270024716854, -0.017863977700471878, -0.022543050348758698, 0.03164507448673248, -0.05061550810933113, -0.019073359668254852, 0.014208418317139149, -0.04165491834282875, 0.008999143727123737, 0.042502325028181076, 0.054926395416259766, 0.0027846430893987417, 0.031028158962726593, -0.049341831356287, -0.05262236297130585, 0.028215689584612846, -0.03190765157341957, -0.0012532919645309448, -0.007252066396176815, -0.046005308628082275, -0.004275124985724688, 0.000007094496140780393, -0.034485943615436554, 0.04052084684371948, -0.06163562089204788, 0.06035757064819336, 0.04763837531208992, 0.020353028550744057, -0.0027585001662373543, 0.0019829589873552322, -0.009736903011798859, 0.008580908179283142, -0.002204036107286811, -0.021419614553451538, -0.06055726855993271, -0.025660481303930283, 0.025341438129544258, 0.019122416153550148, -0.06096227094531059, 0.07421915978193283, 0.05391658470034599, -0.004890721291303635, 0.033761266618967056, 0.01177823357284069, 0.00969020463526249, -0.023600850254297256, 0.01840311288833618, 0.0005598908755928278, -0.0005770911811850965, 0.04984131082892418, 0.028327355161309242, 0.04139922931790352, 0.028947746381163597, -0.0014125648885965347, 0.036662209779024124, 0.03103134036064148, -0.00406699487939477, 0.007549275644123554, -0.03278026357293129, -0.015374487265944481, 0.06713326275348663, -0.035671040415763855, 0.01229182630777359, 0.006725530605763197, 0.016481585800647736, 0.0016314317472279072, 0.017688173800706863, 0.004776661284267902, 0.038528189063072205, 0.044217340648174286, -0.05881603807210922, 0.0034207762219011784, 0.04027975723147392, -0.03121703304350376, 0.05532974377274513, -0.034975815564394, -0.050929512828588486, -0.009568135254085064, 0.026356197893619537, 0.032836928963661194, -0.03958209976553917, 0.03511277958750725, -0.0150449825450778, -0.03183170408010483, -0.0019128706771880388, -0.016108810901641846, 0.030639400705695152, 0.024173041805624962, -0.019971614703536034, -0.019678587093949318, -0.03663576766848564, -0.040603362023830414, 0.016566600650548935, -0.007905622944235802, 0.0012540359748527408, 0.0031775289680808783, 0.0030100620351731777, -0.0457540899515152, -0.026570197194814682, -0.007860339246690273, -0.010701441206037998, -0.0061803883872926235, -0.01116996817290783, -0.002806507283821702, -0.004011331591755152, 0.017496468499302864, 0.01717425510287285, -0.06185263767838478, -0.03672461211681366, -0.036219142377376556, 0.012787881307303905, 0.0093952976167202, 0.026899520307779312, 0.010833938606083393, 0.02885233424603939, -0.009362805634737015, -0.021766886115074158, -0.06744210422039032, -0.055735670030117035, 0.03093278408050537, -0.05213097482919693, 0.024037882685661316, 0.00706908293068409, -0.03191279619932175, 0.05886580049991608, 0.05786668509244919, -0.054374661296606064, -0.02114974334836006, -0.011126467026770115, -0.037934038788080215, -0.00804642029106617, 0.01330503262579441, 0.003712935373187065, 0.031935423612594604, 0.032424602657556534, -0.018134810030460358, -0.013439299538731575, 0.021393174305558205, 0.005384111776947975, 0.016990799456834793, 0.011910266242921352, 0.0319378525018692, -0.06380486488342285, 0.02255728840827942, 0.0008048856980167329, 0.0017610875656828284, 0.034426115453243256, 0.0013285033637657762, -0.004026803653687239, 0.02262996882200241, 0.009325763210654259, 0.029152587056159973, -0.043382201343774796, -0.017838621512055397, -0.045690130442380905, 0.058978162705898285, 0.04106910154223442, -0.014944672584533691, -0.0026085618883371353, 0.020556461066007614, 0.004361296538263559, -0.05046035349369049, 0.00025295489467680454, 0.012706520035862923, -0.011417878791689873, -0.03958848863840103, 0.015171139501035213, 0.008543260395526886, -0.008652906864881516, 0.011736923828721046, -0.023915667086839676, -0.02420457825064659, 0.02519453689455986, 0.03396233543753624, -0.018834959715604782, 0.019389169290661812, -0.025620628148317337, -0.029750891029834747, -0.06140227988362312, -0.0031665703281760216, -0.024819891899824142, 0.04627808555960655, -0.007928255014121532, 0.0301677193492651, -0.010633377358317375, 0.008984788320958614, 0.016305774450302124, 0.00451579038053751, -0.07127659022808075, 0.0010620515095070004, -0.030159737914800644, 0.02115015685558319, -0.00875094160437584, -0.042690422385931015, 0.04681433364748955, -0.021696696057915688, 0.010890397243201733, 0.004618234001100063, 0.001244949409738183, -0.011273417621850967, -0.004820921458303928, 0.013300472870469093, -0.018905159085989, 0.024330317974090576, 0.022612323984503746, -0.008001287467777729, -0.036460623145103455, 0.020288890227675438, 0.043149031698703766, -0.020863011479377747, -0.028403133153915405, -0.0432603545486927, -0.0031255586072802544, -0.02340015023946762, 0.02698938362300396, 0.009407131001353264, 0.0021808610763400793, -0.08207225054502487, 0.04119769111275673, 0.008820323273539543, 0.09476925432682037, 0.037345658987760544, -0.0027601439505815506, -0.014179062098264694, -0.013518521562218666, -0.009354274719953537, 0.03566589951515198, -0.005541742313653231, 0.004268721677362919, 0.005316718481481075, 0.07330644875764847, 0.01486772671341896, -0.06534110009670258, 0.02473454922437668, 0.05829648673534393, 0.007841338403522968, 0.0013581158127635717, -0.02070968598127365, -0.013310843147337437, -0.026172123849391937, -0.007568294648081064, 0.0010517790215089917, 0.002815402578562498, -0.01843166910111904, 0.016357751563191414, 0.03267848119139671, 0.03022339753806591, -0.022601984441280365, 0.01699901930987835, 0.044236455112695694, 0.026473887264728546, 0.005153820849955082, -0.024142591282725334, 0.012129862792789936, 0.053142983466386795, 0.04164927452802658, -0.011806500144302845, -0.007694864179939032, -0.08399362862110138, 0.022058993577957153, 0.025482578203082085, 0.042455803602933884, -0.05985356122255325, 0.005872688721865416, -0.06897584348917007, 0.022015869617462158, 0.006984222214668989, 0.004029775504022837, 0.008585721254348755, -0.03481055796146393, 0.001038378686644137, -0.019026249647140503, -0.00155529601033777, -0.037475019693374634, -0.022474559023976326, 0.03415441885590553, 0.017428750172257423, 0.00532733928412199, 0.018169237300753593, -0.0247899629175663, 0.026013396680355072, 0.0035880603827536106, 0.061028383672237396, -0.003351678606122732, -0.02001922018826008, 0.03339771181344986, -0.015242013148963451, -0.0465303398668766, -0.0325942188501358, -0.003416581079363823, 0.010880755260586739, 0.014667016454041004, 0.027798272669315338, 0.02593180537223816, -0.04911890625953674, 0.010315443389117718, 0.018669072538614273, -0.008932728320360184, 0.005630078259855509, -0.003240020014345646, 0.04071016609668732, 0.025990169495344162, 0.03435099869966507, 0.06291927397251129, 0.04117831587791443, 0.015971895307302475, -0.012472723610699177, -0.009426070377230644, 0.0015778306405991316, -0.028767095878720284, -0.0202126894146204, -0.017221292480826378, -0.0013119380455464125, -0.0058747148141264915, 0.033356890082359314, 0.007889124564826488, 0.04699903726577759, -0.025142347440123558, -0.014162026345729828, -0.03262116760015488, 0.04337717592716217, 0.005023008678108454, -0.016338035464286804, 0.011634386144578457, 0.012130176648497581, 0.0004035698948428035, -0.015147319063544273, 0.0124747846275568, -0.03724358230829239, 0.010118053294718266, 0.016294602304697037, -0.036745525896549225, 0.014712842181324959, -0.05641523748636246, -0.04643796384334564, 0.01318309549242258, -0.025259757414460182, -0.006215842440724373, 0.01868443377315998, 0.029114432632923126, 0.005072589032351971, -0.05339597538113594, -0.029954127967357635, 0.0150612136349082, -0.0016339769354090095, 0.008393450640141964, -0.0316118523478508, 0.04269760474562645, -0.034488242119550705, 0.008814387954771519, -0.07245786488056183, -0.030113354325294495, 0.008087251335382462, 0.013578074052929878, -0.017555173486471176, -0.0020047780126333237, 0.021486636251211166, -0.0029732154216617346, -0.032360874116420746, 0.014706539921462536, 0.07343257963657379, 0.0069009726867079735, 0.0035158463288098574, -0.03681068494915962, 0.0360509529709816, 0.0558420866727829, 0.022879811003804207, 0.014459212310612202, 0.027034955099225044, -0.00872969999909401, 0.01249685138463974, -0.004251742735505104, 0.010014420375227928, -0.010466648265719414, -0.0032162521965801716, -0.02802698314189911, 0.005022035911679268, 0.05625239759683609, -0.015484752133488655, -0.019359435886144638, 0.07339651137590408, 0.020895831286907196, -0.015403215773403645, -0.02286464162170887, -0.015628891065716743, -0.040026430040597916, 0.005178556777536869, 0.007469430565834045, 0.012010389007627964, -0.01595296896994114, 0.0011265050852671266, 0.07311874628067017, 0.025590350851416588, -0.0033954093232750893, -0.0017561533022671938, 0.08811379224061966, -0.008506672456860542, 0.006956034805625677, 0.0003110375255346298, -0.012540934607386589, 0.05141168832778931, -0.005229067523032427, -0.0031039011664688587, 0.019641607999801636, 0.05785953626036644, -0.025662563741207123, -0.03539609536528587, -0.028985928744077682, 0.042728573083877563, 0.03490791097283363, -0.009714983403682709, 0.019964193925261497, 0.03286401554942131, -0.032103996723890305, -0.035382095724344254, -0.05267007648944855, -0.01935741677880287, 0.04266512766480446, -0.022089848294854164, 0.05258379504084587, -0.03506651520729065, 0.0014290055260062218, 0.006520254071801901, -0.008437844924628735, -0.005020183511078358, 0.0209736879914999, 0.025421632453799248, 0.023463046178221703, 0.0017417026683688164, -0.04873160272836685, -0.005534654948860407, 0.03867502883076668, -0.06128087267279625, 0.03162453696131706, -0.05758306384086609, -0.06331551820039749, 0.024274731054902077, -0.005082930438220501, 0.04907634109258652, -0.0794609785079956, -0.00006758524250471964, -0.053105708211660385, 0.01174714881926775, 0.02966385893523693, -0.006602502427995205, 0.056594494730234146, 0.02926694042980671, 0.013665842823684216, -0.018516583368182182, 0.018093321472406387, -0.014804604463279247, -0.11449939012527466, -0.03960175812244415, 0.040080998092889786, -0.07435191422700882, 0.01979285664856434, 0.013646064326167107, -0.018497303128242493, 0.03169136866927147, -0.06855259090662003, 0.031236745417118073, 0.017103541642427444, 0.0654403567314148, -0.012881970033049583, 0.046953339129686356, -0.01761048473417759, -0.011087557300925255, -0.0076978555880486965, 0.0007352600223384798, 0.13920381665229797, 0.11181764304637909, 0.044212471693754196, -0.09000099450349808, 0.015099705196917057, -0.009962162002921104, -0.00696058664470911, -0.012958867475390434, -0.003759333398193121, -0.0013403329066932201, -0.010417439043521881, 0.030940793454647064, 0.060830008238554, 0.00571145536378026, 0.014376894570887089, 0.06366503983736038, -0.029718562960624695, -0.015546899288892746, 0.0290150698274374, 0.011448810808360577, 0.002473865170031786, 0.000297566584777087, -0.026026373729109764, -0.01425953023135662, 0.020519642159342766, -0.01888992451131344, -0.016178365796804428, -0.013017234392464161, 0.00007495638419641182, 0.0014296387089416385, -0.03822390362620354, -0.019013047218322754, 0.006406668107956648, -0.0048455442301929, -0.008507831953465939, -0.009207632392644882, -0.027413394302129745, -0.038240812718868256, 0.029578493908047676, 0.024937987327575684, 0.002852599136531353, -0.014212032780051231, -0.003912237007170916, 0.01694977842271328, -0.03687858581542969, -0.02414637804031372, -0.03224528208374977, 0.016225138679146767, -0.04330822080373764, 0.009732918813824654, 0.0184777844697237, 0.007736218627542257, -0.01668710447847843, -0.03414991870522499, -0.0034378007985651493, 0.006375397555530071, 0.02814071998000145, -0.010466029867529869, 0.009744568727910519, -0.030098577961325645, 0.01685783453285694, -0.02097843401134014, 0.006351059768348932, 0.02403077483177185, -0.06213302165269852, -0.020439252257347107, -0.01251373253762722, 0.022160546854138374, 0.0002457990194670856, -0.020986590534448624, -0.011806657537817955, -0.03222174197435379, -0.0018988060764968395, -0.0265957098454237, 0.011868768371641636, -0.013158222660422325, -0.008959205821156502, 0.006284305360168219, -0.016535304486751556, -0.021588698029518127, -0.01596640981733799, -0.006785789504647255, -0.02058347687125206, -0.0007322716992348433, -0.03716656193137169, -0.018243353813886642, 0.017041977494955063, -0.0005496430094353855, 0.03189292922616005, 0.004464536439627409, 0.0031790994107723236, 0.028658101335167885, -0.015498972497880459, -0.06940995156764984, -0.0023643001914024353, -0.01831965148448944, -0.03320595994591713, 0.038135915994644165, -0.034454211592674255, 0.06397797912359238, -0.026830734685063362, 0.036616310477256775, 0.0013371789827942848, 0.032085999846458435, 0.0048422073014080524, 0.024684935808181763, 0.007119407411664724, -0.0435524582862854, 0.02871672622859478, -0.014796493574976921, -0.0035387512762099504, 0.0014243023470044136, -0.04086103290319443, -0.047430578619241714, 0.00017265260976273566, 0.015055299736559391, -0.04732707142829895, -0.038010530173778534, 0.04371820017695427, -0.008652258664369583, 0.005356617737561464, 0.012846721336245537, -0.010908647440373898, 0.008568845689296722, -0.012547445483505726, 0.027085844427347183, -0.005087766330689192, -0.00953906774520874, -0.01590467058122158, -0.014968900009989738, -0.03165362775325775, -0.008083049207925797, 0.02464275248348713, -0.005845580715686083, 0.02469779923558235, 0.0014852258609607816, 0.006043743807822466, 0.03676467388868332, -0.003609153674915433, -0.03060639090836048, 0.013104951940476894, -0.060170140117406845, -0.041261255741119385, 0.0266531053930521, 0.0030728732235729694, 0.002858610125258565, 0.022930964827537537, 0.021821916103363037, -0.03494105860590935, 0.03543659672141075, -0.06407120078802109, -0.023645272478461266, -0.003890730207785964, 0.04371880367398262, 0.016771577298641205, -0.012125616893172264, -0.011720028705894947, 0.0037048968952149153, -0.022675609216094017, -0.0018574250862002373, -0.002871720353141427, 0.0010901626665145159, -0.018930356949567795, 0.05214936286211014, -0.029847022145986557, 0.03772775083780289, 0.024164823815226555, 0.005101451650261879, 0.015288928523659706, 0.05083892494440079, -0.05017085373401642, 0.05820145457983017, 0.032682981342077255, -0.0004142124962527305, -0.11515694856643677, -0.04841167852282524, 0.02893555723130703, 0.021082906052470207, -0.008275358006358147, -0.0719863772392273, 0.03189230337738991, 0.035189155489206314, -0.03790750727057457, 0.009986327029764652, 0.02075670287013054, 0.001890283660031855, -0.035621412098407745, 0.004919588565826416, 0.0051960754208266735, -0.00018401563283987343, 0.036834582686424255, -0.0020632175728678703, 0.06466321647167206, -0.006083269603550434, 0.022369617596268654, -0.02895021066069603, 0.003390885889530182, 0.0388658232986927, 0.01680365949869156, -0.09784294664859772, 0.03645097464323044, -0.07197965681552887, -0.04199623316526413, 0.04778054729104042, 0.036373842507600784, -0.00623037526383996, 0.022061780095100403, 0.014095584861934185, -0.02429266832768917, 0.057861071079969406, 0.03235844150185585, -0.005792456679046154, 0.01478517148643732, 0.04658178612589836, -0.008975492790341377, 0.02197398990392685, -0.03105718083679676, -0.00994644034653902, 0.04144622012972832, 0.005849570967257023, -0.03237847238779068, -0.0006707452121190727, -0.003937026485800743, -0.044184327125549316, -0.03285052999854088, -0.003765800269320607, -0.024706730619072914, -0.04505360499024391, 0.015572788193821907, -0.047108881175518036, 0.01866508275270462, -0.0068236482329666615, 0.04678472876548767, -0.009120584465563297, 0.00617428682744503, -0.01905820704996586, 0.00021788608864881098, 0.009543673135340214, 0.025381682440638542, -0.01831929385662079, -0.05959146097302437, 0.007202918641269207, 0.005351105239242315, -0.017445338889956474, 0.0007951812003739178, -0.015471014194190502, -0.022197777405381203, 0.022558564320206642, -0.04281546175479889, 0.025999166071414948, 0.017030147835612297, -0.01340851653367281, 0.0024083987809717655, -0.07745233923196793, 0.08290895819664001, -0.0001913828164106235, 0.02176925167441368, -0.01867786794900894, 0.011671139858663082, -0.042399708181619644, 0.002857285551726818, 0.053379807621240616, 0.02527012676000595, -0.0036783581599593163, 0.013800478540360928, 0.05249113589525223, 0.028408803045749664, -0.019689420238137245, 0.017401542514562607, -0.013239176943898201, -0.027476534247398376, -0.015398728661239147, -0.0019094200106337667, 0.02692493610084057, 0.017074914649128914, -0.0013934513553977013, 0.02333350107073784, 0.03447173535823822, -0.026861531659960747, 0.042818568646907806, 0.031710147857666016, 0.022842442616820335, -0.017299985513091087, 0.049483902752399445, 0.0005700470646843314, 0.008194532245397568, 0.006900154985487461, -0.011876565404236317, -0.03460175544023514, 0.01949772611260414, 0.007719127461314201, -0.03687473386526108, 0.0012148900423198938, 0.02327042631804943, -0.05557448789477348, -0.02962282858788967, -0.013480228371918201, 0.016546357423067093, -0.013688204810023308, -0.012697849422693253, 0.013601688668131828, 0.005482676904648542, 0.025333736091852188, -0.0034839308355003595, 0.031799159944057465, 0.03551746904850006, -0.009518605656921864, 0.03479519858956337, 0.026772938668727875, 0.03734615445137024, 0.0039033738430589437, 0.009872958064079285, 0.020485959947109222, 0.008067315444350243, 0.016049211844801903, -0.025458063930273056, 0.03459237143397331, 0.015485096722841263, -0.05449100211262703, 0.025805741548538208, 0.00024319002113770694, -0.013143764808773994, -0.05016568303108215, -0.0011938593816012144, 0.0679847002029419, -0.022617043927311897, -0.008921374566853046, -0.0516839325428009, -0.010819626040756702, -0.019951391965150833, -0.009637943468987942, -0.005064795259386301, -0.0043284473940730095, 0.013832774944603443, -0.005494201090186834, -0.0021205851808190346, 0.0284971185028553, 0.055533405393362045, -0.022308526560664177, 0.00024788634618744254, -0.0054587735794484615, -0.03048238530755043, -0.00227030529640615, -0.01315777376294136, -0.037501778453588486, -0.046297863125801086, 0.018797127529978752, 0.01199262123554945, 0.02029562182724476, 0.001225603511556983, -0.02368566207587719, -0.014101418666541576, 0.029742436483502388, -0.04574580490589142, -0.013002750463783741, -0.01859983801841736, -0.016468938440084457, 0.001150356838479638, -0.020260291174054146 ]
<p>In Chemical industrial, samples are often analyzed multiple times, e.g. 5 samples and each was analyzed 2 times with 10 data points in total. What would be the confidence interval for the mean estimated from these data? The degrees of freedom is somewhere from 4 to 10 depending on the correlation between repeats.</p>
36,495
[ -0.03250731900334358, -0.008070982992649078, 0.0013399202143773437, 0.02949546091258526, 0.05191965773701668, 0.009090125560760498, -0.011986336670815945, -0.010605200193822384, -0.0019580405205488205, -0.02911286987364292, 0.07161926478147507, 0.03932803124189377, 0.015066483058035374, -0.005222448613494635, -0.009020958095788956, 0.039668936282396317, -0.017839061096310616, 0.018826771527528763, -0.00561135821044445, -0.020970935001969337, 0.0027444304432719946, 0.009937243536114693, -0.024841776117682457, -0.01007486879825592, -0.038686603307724, 0.027852598577737808, 0.04932812601327896, -0.040100447833538055, 0.058715060353279114, 0.033688243478536606, -0.05429765582084656, -0.058166004717350006, 0.04321885481476784, 0.048495691269636154, 0.016137687489390373, -0.012584482319653034, -0.024561332538723946, -0.04823283478617668, 0.017247797921299934, 0.058935511857271194, -0.06256058812141418, 0.005045465659350157, -0.012851376086473465, -0.000994828762486577, 0.005212836433202028, -0.023774897679686546, -0.009799025021493435, -0.055774521082639694, 0.034866150468587875, -0.023573409765958786, 0.11403456330299377, -0.02773137018084526, 0.026135260239243507, 0.007928187027573586, -0.02285107597708702, 0.012514709495007992, 0.009853113442659378, 0.017610954120755196, -0.016797257587313652, -0.0632457584142685, 0.00011248559894738719, -0.016057996079325676, 0.010274299420416355, 0.015611937269568443, -0.04678453132510185, -0.021494537591934204, -0.012639318592846394, 0.004009451251477003, 0.006390927359461784, -0.000825233175419271, 0.031944889575242996, 0.02731039747595787, 0.07971663773059845, -0.011799035593867302, 0.005888524930924177, -0.015282873995602131, 0.02416485920548439, 0.013604657724499702, 0.04987358674407005, 0.04028310626745224, 0.009503810666501522, 0.016320833936333656, 0.033175818622112274, 0.0056274221278727055, 0.024236632511019707, -0.03141656517982483, 0.07569897174835205, -0.014572993852198124, 0.03654762730002403, 0.04337943345308304, -0.006910040974617004, -0.005366886034607887, 0.061184756457805634, 0.049284428358078, -0.04659726098179817, 0.017922965809702873, -0.026099901646375656, 0.05760426074266434, -0.004032229073345661, 0.027609705924987793, 0.023721180856227875, -0.03997684270143509, 0.034066058695316315, 0.08919285237789154, -0.018766365945339203, 0.015797410160303116, -0.010365205816924572, -0.011421430855989456, -0.020848410204052925, -0.01548854075372219, 0.033206019550561905, 0.0169791579246521, 0.04535980522632599, 0.00979815237224102, 0.03671949729323387, 0.04502260312438011, 0.0007976903580129147, 0.007121376693248749, 0.04372566565871239, 0.05328459292650223, 0.010871815495193005, -0.03453553095459938, 0.0010043162619695067, 0.0045519033446908, -0.015895895659923553, 0.013995842076838017, 0.011462806724011898, -0.012766172178089619, -0.04472677409648895, 0.051752593368291855, -0.0024539416190236807, 0.001209433889016509, 0.026907190680503845, -0.002605144400149584, 0.027340637519955635, -0.011406601406633854, -0.0872887372970581, -0.06713806837797165, 0.006574808619916439, -0.04863842949271202, -0.018547527492046356, -0.06326613575220108, 0.05500714108347893, 0.020946860313415527, 0.04218689352273941, -0.008646456524729729, 0.017678268253803253, -0.0005943603464402258, 0.038705598562955856, -0.004452649969607592, -0.006451792549341917, -0.001581320189870894, -0.018429864197969437, -0.0030181207694113255, -0.008197859860956669, -0.061618681997060776, 0.03243379294872284, 0.015918320044875145, -0.024153249338269234, -0.021716158837080002, -0.026549527421593666, 0.0060638198629021645, -0.012067536823451519, -0.008667370304465294, 0.03237306699156761, -0.03575977310538292, 0.044556040316820145, -0.013479968532919884, 0.025557424873113632, -0.0009236323530785739, 0.010229498147964478, 0.0031621363013982773, -0.0021004981826990843, 0.03979989141225815, 0.08124382048845291, -0.01080249436199665, 0.03522713854908943, -0.0035397415049374104, 0.025078769773244858, 0.021071674302220345, -0.04219679906964302, -0.005864298436790705, 0.0016834150301292539, 0.013492166064679623, 0.03435025364160538, 0.0007911751163192093, -0.016888730227947235, -0.04564007744193077, -0.03224456310272217, -0.02698693238198757, 0.0008486796286888421, -0.08533383160829544, 0.004396751988679171, -0.030200934037566185, -0.028329258784651756, -0.0002677769516594708, 0.019675934687256813, 0.01300326082855463, -0.019610276445746422, -0.04648668318986893, -0.02686161734163761, -0.012461408041417599, 0.07856233417987823, -0.05188574269413948, 0.006686256732791662, 0.05293703451752663, 0.036744315177202225, -0.0010484576923772693, 0.06554490327835083, -0.025374174118041992, -0.03635924309492111, -0.02466585673391819, -0.02979348599910736, -0.006319489795714617, 0.019770901650190353, -0.012257646769285202, 0.00322418799623847, 0.023862987756729126, -0.0337497815489769, 0.03475256264209747, -0.025071797892451286, 0.07040313631296158, 0.0599832646548748, 0.011428716592490673, -0.010844886302947998, -0.018604662269353867, 0.027662426233291626, 0.019572017714381218, -0.022874725982546806, -0.07076440006494522, -0.06231914088129997, -0.0003937394649256021, 0.0035374758299440145, 0.036374326795339584, -0.018963875249028206, -0.010838104411959648, 0.09443182498216629, 0.036992330104112625, 0.002086926717311144, 0.020421983674168587, -0.00888737291097641, -0.014344293624162674, 0.00032413555891253054, 0.015419521369040012, 0.02375689148902893, -0.0007377429865300655, -0.011987032368779182, 0.023405684158205986, 0.05060393735766411, 0.03572187200188637, 0.030674317851662636, 0.02268192358314991, 0.016109025105834007, -0.01729687862098217, 0.005278675351291895, -0.007560048718005419, 0.03580693155527115, -0.007188855204731226, -0.011036568321287632, 0.04245833307504654, 0.010788770392537117, 0.01551287155598402, 0.020153362303972244, -0.011927691288292408, 0.00008887382864486426, 0.027320362627506256, -0.04246550798416138, -0.008504717610776424, 0.022918540984392166, -0.019217049703001976, -0.012296061962842941, -0.06270720064640045, 0.00894816406071186, 0.029039960354566574, -0.020950419828295708, 0.02570010907948017, -0.013456698507070541, 0.04314357414841652, -0.02161618508398533, 0.002538928994908929, -0.03341167792677879, -0.02032582275569439, 0.003915572538971901, -0.020286301150918007, -0.06482282280921936, -0.01467769593000412, 0.02319938689470291, -0.017265304923057556, 0.010323493741452694, 0.0014760204358026385, -0.020570646971464157, 0.036434952169656754, -0.005282706581056118, -0.0661843791604042, -0.00797463022172451, 0.009483246132731438, 0.022789204493165016, -0.03204233944416046, -0.021758293733000755, 0.04764069244265556, -0.002730317646637559, -0.03902541473507881, 0.058788999915122986, -0.05086987465620041, -0.015675434842705727, -0.02316095679998398, 0.008285554125905037, 0.007451433222740889, -0.005087472964078188, -0.011982801370322704, 0.0029991359915584326, 0.031385935842990875, -0.02577138878405094, -0.04125642031431198, -0.07176607102155685, -0.0026533622294664383, -0.031800057739019394, 0.05343570187687874, 0.011075926013290882, -0.014772902242839336, 0.08212985843420029, 0.013527114875614643, -0.036337513476610184, 0.006824368145316839, 0.01289369910955429, -0.003767244517803192, -0.015024387277662754, 0.029802968725562096, 0.009473979473114014, -0.005341034382581711, 0.0029054584447294474, 0.012589508667588234, 0.021305108442902565, 0.05090013146400452, -0.035599831491708755, 0.004788162186741829, 0.012368445284664631, 0.019045671448111534, -0.01918857730925083, 0.034991562366485596, 0.029062585905194283, -0.026517614722251892, 0.021962199360132217, -0.00980960950255394, 0.03672235831618309, 0.020298069342970848, -0.06322348117828369, 0.020643223077058792, -0.036628082394599915, -0.0005262280465103686, -0.029457202181220055, 0.0251929834485054, 0.018932251259684563, -0.02024797722697258, -0.019709890708327293, 0.028964219614863396, 0.04618605971336365, -0.0128040025010705, -0.01266530528664589, 0.04195509850978851, 0.0355040542781353, 0.017495935782790184, -0.005749447736889124, -0.0008163083693943918, -0.011781472712755203, 0.012564701028168201, -0.03905937448143959, -0.07055472582578659, 0.023715903982520103, 0.062072575092315674, -0.0019595534540712833, -0.00019410939421504736, -0.045708563178777695, 0.009657700546085835, -0.07245296239852905, -0.0011971467174589634, -0.01797371543943882, 0.037090856581926346, -0.014687679708003998, 0.04366084560751915, 0.03408672660589218, -0.029493052512407303, -0.0012248214334249496, 0.009353015571832657, -0.06119878590106964, 0.026822956278920174, -0.009646100923418999, -0.013763516210019588, -0.017532750964164734, -0.014579232782125473, 0.050544023513793945, -0.008770369924604893, 0.01935337670147419, 0.014135465957224369, 0.03658103197813034, -0.04279659315943718, 0.027584366500377655, -0.019704289734363556, 0.03355550393462181, 0.008078373968601227, 0.04516194760799408, 0.021441703662276268, 0.011624179780483246, 0.04747914522886276, 0.0013319114223122597, -0.022953098639845848, 0.01136066671460867, 0.002388397930189967, 0.002559681423008442, 0.003985835704952478, 0.0329163558781147, 0.0248170867562294, 0.014779230579733849, -0.016713907942175865, 0.016498224809765816, -0.04002901911735535, 0.06188688054680824, 0.05421711876988411, -0.0015717350179329515, -0.030970368534326553, -0.04588506743311882, 0.015325375832617283, 0.004284370690584183, -0.00782532524317503, -0.010519459843635559, 0.012093734927475452, 0.03170691803097725, 0.03779531642794609, -0.10860804468393326, 0.010730305686593056, 0.03000420145690441, 0.03443289175629616, 0.020623741671442986, -0.04267722740769386, -0.00020290828251745552, 0.011030497029423714, -0.025065306574106216, 0.007223131135106087, 0.009412476792931557, -0.020714687183499336, 0.0019093664595857263, 0.033255498856306076, 0.003842714475467801, -0.06967079639434814, 0.03864066302776337, 0.0031698185484856367, 0.06828185170888901, -0.015964850783348083, -0.042656268924474716, 0.00641029654070735, 0.0024660902563482523, 0.024608546867966652, 0.015939896926283836, -0.002891676500439644, -0.07378971576690674, 0.029163161292672157, 0.03565598651766777, 0.032776184380054474, -0.036474231630563736, 0.031045839190483093, -0.01609683968126774, 0.012990664690732956, 0.03161776438355446, -0.04235084727406502, 0.0035009151324629784, -0.023230765014886856, 0.012013285420835018, -0.01311741303652525, -0.005934590008109808, -0.04062102362513542, -0.016140056774020195, -0.02243330143392086, 0.00010736776312114671, -0.036435820162296295, -0.03269228711724281, -0.02088957466185093, 0.018707919865846634, 0.042536716908216476, 0.0692543238401413, -0.013837084174156189, -0.007766319904476404, 0.013387057930231094, 0.022621329873800278, -0.01671046018600464, -0.04617458954453468, 0.005358213558793068, -0.005370027851313353, 0.0020007772836834192, 0.010738134384155273, -0.05151915177702904, -0.04618095979094505, 0.016567762941122055, -0.0022653723135590553, 0.0005182177992537618, -0.035674482583999634, 0.0028126263059675694, 0.03436566889286041, 0.050162173807621, 0.01713070645928383, 0.07607113569974899, -0.019119758158922195, -0.01827668584883213, 0.014746326953172684, -0.03430098667740822, 0.04122810438275337, -0.03818071633577347, 0.0032150812912732363, -0.020660819485783577, 0.02145712450146675, -0.030350705608725548, 0.014622321352362633, -0.026371844112873077, 0.018091419711709023, 0.006734109483659267, -0.007139850873500109, 0.0269533209502697, -0.007543035317212343, 0.011935467831790447, -0.004726801533252001, -0.0035446351394057274, 0.037652600556612015, -0.005061735399067402, -0.03448422998189926, -0.022702615708112717, -0.012453095987439156, -0.011486019939184189, -0.01317998580634594, -0.04046519845724106, -0.021684404462575912, -0.06715963780879974, -0.0336630642414093, 0.019794268533587456, -0.0527515709400177, 0.03550439327955246, -0.04384993761777878, 0.02147887833416462, -0.0015328200533986092, -0.025500938296318054, -0.000897391582839191, 0.01702936179935932, -0.019440989941358566, 0.03396683558821678, -0.04949991777539253, 0.04553258791565895, -0.032208383083343506, 0.016863854601979256, -0.08556266874074936, -0.057347994297742844, 0.052118781954050064, 0.0536135658621788, -0.012598039582371712, -0.03146747499704361, -0.029599351808428764, 0.0076034353114664555, -0.05353526398539543, -0.03300284594297409, 0.04088921099901199, 0.004690580070018768, -0.04929132014513016, 0.004502981901168823, 0.03356437757611275, 0.06703007221221924, -0.00037985050585120916, 0.0066199894063174725, 0.03609675541520119, -0.04157983511686325, -0.032390281558036804, -0.02922125719487667, -0.0066511561162769794, -0.034628428518772125, 0.0006062811589799821, -0.03506601229310036, 0.01823265478014946, 0.02993546426296234, -0.03299795091152191, -0.011377844959497452, 0.0037197142373770475, 0.027362409979104996, 0.02342820167541504, -0.029594793915748596, -0.004927160684019327, -0.04066629707813263, 0.029651613906025887, 0.0068240598775446415, -0.0010387664660811424, -0.01525319367647171, -0.005551561713218689, 0.015007668174803257, 0.03050699457526207, -0.030641116201877594, 0.023255035281181335, 0.05828681215643883, -0.0034800039138644934, -0.0017486107535660267, -0.028964586555957794, -0.031612690538167953, 0.011022948659956455, -0.00683573866263032, -0.02482457645237446, 0.03943083807826042, -0.0066383914090693, -0.06113564595580101, -0.024679068475961685, -0.02906656265258789, -0.0036192822735756636, 0.05694635212421417, -0.015104479156434536, 0.0361461266875267, 0.054653413593769073, 0.026977386325597763, 0.01149126049131155, -0.0035400085616856813, -0.0061377836391329765, 0.000998175353743136, 0.030284082517027855, 0.05628534406423569, 0.01838482916355133, -0.022523026913404465, 0.010637123137712479, 0.035167694091796875, 0.017878025770187378, 0.052373580634593964, 0.01602611318230629, 0.008428850211203098, -0.013454580679535866, 0.00018245888350065798, -0.03208315372467041, 0.0013593574985861778, -0.04483466222882271, 0.028505807742476463, -0.008246978744864464, -0.0002514832594897598, 0.017373058944940567, 0.030183009803295135, 0.02780451439321041, -0.01201996672898531, -0.027680981904268265, -0.05544506385922432, 0.024038225412368774, 0.005044217221438885, 0.004376113414764404, 0.01862046867609024, 0.00926683098077774, 0.01134589035063982, -0.005824596621096134, -0.001411530189216137, -0.04668561741709709, -0.03920400142669678, -0.0028893204871565104, 0.01694609224796295, -0.05372767895460129, 0.03523179888725281, 0.014042388647794724, -0.04232551530003548, 0.00994504801928997, -0.00630359398201108, 0.004109509289264679, -0.02617587149143219, 0.07056073844432831, -0.028965121135115623, 0.09802115708589554, 0.025694016367197037, 0.042055893689394, -0.007188701070845127, -0.0016473636496812105, 0.11029842495918274, 0.07381083816289902, 0.00488239387050271, -0.04877787083387375, 0.007813563570380211, 0.02156912535429001, -0.012974202632904053, -0.01799846440553665, 0.03715485334396362, 0.020976638421416283, 0.031291671097278595, 0.03667305037379265, 0.033515412360429764, -0.0006865346804261208, 0.0047765085473656654, 0.0406738743185997, -0.0009892513044178486, -0.024870311841368675, -0.02324710786342621, 0.00015029906353447586, -0.026980381458997726, -0.019990572705864906, -0.03084453195333481, 0.026063088327646255, -0.007506183348596096, -0.012047899886965752, -0.025729600340127945, -0.036314960569143295, -0.002106394385918975, 0.018642790615558624, -0.0011741344351321459, 0.032195694744586945, 0.012765731662511826, -0.004406413063406944, -0.05482715368270874, -0.02726408652961254, 0.0192952249199152, -0.006997121963649988, -0.0017376735340803862, 0.03667324781417847, -0.007014870643615723, -0.010349438525736332, -0.011223338544368744, 0.004477150738239288, -0.021124359220266342, -0.031323570758104324, -0.026069527491927147, 0.02956327423453331, -0.024627838283777237, -0.026105821132659912, -0.015300756320357323, -0.023716604337096214, -0.01692742295563221, -0.04084376245737076, -0.00432917894795537, 0.01419858168810606, 0.023488951846957207, -0.05917295068502426, -0.03108344040811062, -0.05590112879872322, 0.022508671507239342, -0.013793914578855038, 0.027726227417588234, 0.04998524487018585, 0.007810358889400959, -0.011944378726184368, -0.01746903359889984, 0.051003556698560715, 0.0006791016785427928, 0.002903954591602087, -0.008007382042706013, -0.02291017398238182, -0.045850515365600586, 0.004805495962500572, 0.0242784284055233, 0.0021688214037567377, 0.07153171300888062, 0.006859243381768465, -0.007340564858168364, -0.0013570365263149142, -0.019382813945412636, -0.006790835410356522, 0.010087492875754833, 0.004684209357947111, -0.012642367742955685, 0.0022884211502969265, 0.01735605113208294, 0.04159245267510414, -0.02998136170208454, 0.021754451096057892, -0.021512657403945923, 0.000669748114887625, 0.040723275393247604, -0.04802817851305008, 0.0191537793725729, -0.015954893082380295, -0.03690747916698456, -0.03219650685787201, -0.01700437255203724, 0.08983773738145828, 0.0023474215995520353, 0.0009757495136000216, 0.02698855847120285, -0.0007878360338509083, -0.0007499029743485153, 0.01781557872891426, 0.008400638587772846, -0.05455396696925163, 0.010904627852141857, 0.03219124674797058, 0.00032258813735097647, -0.03385661542415619, -0.020426668226718903, -0.030157653614878654, -0.040298011153936386, 0.032291051000356674, -0.008136850781738758, -0.031679462641477585, 0.012560910545289516, 0.007687765173614025, -0.00156878971029073, 0.017944935709238052, 0.02344844862818718, -0.05680285766720772, -0.000675816205330193, 0.003037250367924571, 0.02123415842652321, 0.00014640968583989888, -0.01671149954199791, -0.020811190828680992, 0.008183698169887066, 0.06912669539451599, 0.020850997418165207, 0.0456085130572319, -0.024152042344212532, 0.0012421132996678352, -0.012690415605902672, 0.05262735113501549, -0.05728793144226074, -0.007662524469196796, 0.0616397000849247, -0.03876575082540512, 0.003652677172794938, 0.01952052116394043, 0.0032801043707877398, 0.035788681358098984, 0.01725832000374794, 0.022838342934846878, -0.008582849986851215, -0.023884054273366928, -0.05964428558945656, -0.03071271814405918, -0.00003569039472495206, -0.006915566511452198, 0.025392459705471992, 0.006386940833181143, 0.028767535462975502, 0.040228232741355896, 0.006019653286784887, 0.003411295358091593, 0.039137765765190125, 0.0003261943347752094, 0.005888567306101322, 0.01393881719559431, -0.008075522258877754, 0.04266263172030449, 0.008757728151977062, 0.012512561865150928, -0.0012453533709049225, 0.05144510045647621, -0.03583451732993126, 0.020061079412698746, -0.03419917821884155, -0.009691894985735416, -0.08727864176034927, -0.04769980162382126, -0.010597540065646172, 0.028637269511818886, 0.009668285958468914, -0.018102793022990227, -0.02638406679034233, 0.0492912158370018, -0.05466035008430481, 0.014314197935163975, -0.017972270026803017, -0.04085731506347656, -0.02081269770860672, -0.030756765976548195, -0.014484445564448833, 0.021363640204072, 0.03752482682466507, 0.039264000952243805, 0.03908611461520195, 0.0006968265515752137, -0.009107401594519615, -0.012420370243489742, -0.004624336492270231, 0.017396526411175728, 0.010789729654788971, -0.033677857369184494, 0.0008621186716482043, -0.02984972856938839, -0.0261214766651392, 0.0391143299639225, -0.015184127725660801, 0.05027279630303383, 0.003519355319440365, 0.0017423090757802129, -0.023732855916023254, 0.07477835565805435, 0.02640695497393608, -0.002996643539518118, -0.028506003320217133, -0.009309088811278343, 0.003074018284678459, 0.006709255278110504, -0.003972297068685293, 0.005351807922124863, 0.02814675122499466, 0.0030034813098609447, -0.024059101939201355, 0.0478348545730114, 0.00614504050463438, -0.0004091469163540751, 0.013495184481143951, -0.012775910086929798, -0.018332485109567642, -0.030518293380737305, 0.028254961594939232, -0.01688624918460846, 0.007078248076140881, 0.04384331777691841, 0.030517248436808586, -0.04038064926862717, 0.005516769830137491, -0.0069749560207128525, -0.02378552034497261, -0.015061706304550171, -0.016548840329051018, -0.04683380201458931, -0.0841171145439148, 0.0038558405358344316, 0.006745487917214632, 0.008876209147274494, -0.029972033575177193, -0.02663015015423298, -0.025356998667120934, 0.06276937574148178, -0.00630609504878521, 0.011219598352909088, 0.018844520673155785, -0.027719683945178986, -0.01881002075970173, -0.07877365499734879, 0.06910237669944763, 0.007266610395163298, 0.002024612622335553, -0.039194609969854355, -0.022509654983878136, 0.01058200839906931, -0.0006736225914210081, 0.040055081248283386, 0.05999450385570526, -0.004025763366371393, -0.014406661503016949, 0.05120984464883804, 0.013809256255626678, -0.06079066917300224, 0.01762111485004425, -0.03153057023882866, 0.0038040908984839916, -0.029727471992373466, -0.04103793203830719, 0.019041312858462334, -0.021219614893198013, -0.0035849525593221188, -0.015631532296538353, 0.05764485150575638, 0.01799389347434044, -0.002785660093650222, 0.0011158237466588616, 0.020204031839966774, 0.006761839613318443, 0.042279426008462906, -0.00400124117732048, 0.009540109895169735, 0.0282947588711977, 0.018205776810646057, -0.04573478549718857, 0.01911630481481552, -0.015282010659575462, -0.03031371533870697, -0.02663019672036171, 0.00031857891008257866, 0.005608813837170601, -0.09689746797084808, 0.011488156393170357, 0.0063605778850615025, -0.05872105434536934, -0.02095162495970726, 0.04233097657561302, 0.009668217971920967, 0.022626278921961784, -0.010478676296770573, 0.019060874357819557, 0.011831238865852356, -0.007169258315116167, -0.000057451670727459714, -0.02528611198067665, 0.01899087242782116, -0.007902715355157852, 0.0056033628061413765, 0.030891602858901024, -0.03529277816414833, 0.03004600666463375, -0.012251358479261398, 0.006818732712417841, -0.043715618550777435, -0.035293098539114, 0.033607903867959976, -0.032954759895801544, 0.031816333532333374, 0.0017213044920936227, -0.013731874525547028, 0.07091324031352997, -0.023011628538370132, -0.007041501812636852, -0.042958423495292664, -0.025249242782592773, -0.031318411231040955, -0.01710033416748047, 0.03439883515238762, 0.03985293582081795, 0.04564588516950607, 0.022731320932507515, -0.017739014700055122, 0.012486127205193043, 0.05072226747870445, -0.03980575129389763, 0.0336078517138958, -0.0252138189971447, 0.0004881863424088806, -0.041463304311037064, -0.024607889354228973, -0.0489671565592289, -0.04664510861039162, 0.0071039688773453236, 0.01680591143667698, 0.0032903640531003475, 0.028347566723823547, -0.022943764925003052, 0.003120150649920106, 0.040211357176303864, -0.047638580203056335, -0.03302471339702606, -0.045653969049453735, 0.007456665858626366, 0.0017012333264574409, -0.027714362367987633 ]
<p>I have some data I'm studying where functional data analysis seems like a promising approach. But having never tackled FDA before, I'm having trouble wrapping my head around it.</p> <p>For background, I have Ramsay and Silverman's "Functional Data Analysis" and Ramsay, Hooker, and Graves "Functional Data Analysis with R and Matlab" but only got them recently, and am still very much the newbie with FDA. I am using R with package fda as the analysis software.</p> <p>My data are a sample of hundreds of young adult subjects, each of whom were measured annually by performing a task with a binary outcome over some number of trials. The outcome of interest is the success rate on the task. I'll include a short sample of data at the end of my question.</p> <p>Several parameters were collected on each subject, including height, weight, education level, amount of prior training on the task, and the results of an aptitude pre-test. </p> <p>The year-to-year change in success rate over time is the curve I'd like to model with FDA. There is significant variation across subjects in overall performance, but I am mostly interested in how a subject's success rate evolves over time rather than a subject's actual performance. </p> <p>The subjects generally follow a pattern of starting off with a low success rate, improving yearly until reaching a personal maximum, then declining with age. The typical subject enters the study at age 20 with a low success rate, improves until age 25, then declines until age 30, at which point no further data is collected. One of the goals is to characterize the "canonical" development curve for the population. FDA seems like a good fit for this aspect of the problem.</p> <p>Some of my challenges are:</p> <ul> <li><p>Subjects may reach their maximum success rate at different ages, and may improve/decline faster than others, so both phase variation and amplitude variation are potentially present. So it seems like curve registration will be an important part of the analysis. </p></li> <li><p>The number of trials in the test is relatively small each year, so the outcome data is noisy, and registering the data properly seems daunting since the noise in one subject can obscure the landmarks in the data. </p></li> <li><p>I am also interested in whether the other variables predict the registration characteristics of the subject's curve. i.e. Do college-educated subjects reach their maximum performance at an earlier age than others (phase), or do particularly tall subjects sustain their peak performance longer than short subjects do (amplitude)?</p></li> <li><p>We would like to be able to produce a customized curve for a subject. e.g. If we observed the tests through age 23, we would be able to predict how much improvement to expect, at what age the maximum performance would be reached, and how sharp the decline phase would be through age 30. </p></li> </ul> <p>My questions include:</p> <ol> <li><p>Is FDA an appropriate method for this problem?</p></li> <li><p>Are there techniques in FDA for predicting a subject's phase and amplitude variation using other variables? What I've read so far seems to treat registration as a correction for noise rather than as containing features worth examination on its own.</p></li> <li><p>What are some good ways to handle registration where the individual curves have a lot of noise?</p></li> <li><p>Should I be able to produce individualized forecast curves that include subject-specific predicted phase/amplitude variation? What difficulties should I anticipate?</p></li> </ol> <p>Thank you for any and all suggestions.</p> <p>Sample data </p> <pre><code>Subject Education Ht Wt Training Aptitude A College 72 200 0 Medium B High School 77 250 100 High C High School 68 160 50 Low Subject Age Trials Success Success% A 20 15 3 20% A 21 18 5 28% A 22 30 7 23% A 23 28 8 29% A 24 32 13 41% A 25 8 2 25% A 26 20 8 40% A 27 40 11 28% A 28 33 10 30% A 29 18 5 28% A 30 10 2 20% B 20 24 4 17% B 21 27 5 19% B 22 30 8 27% B 23 33 2 6% B 24 41 8 20% B 25 39 5 13% B 26 39 5 13% C 24 13 4 31% C 25 19 6 32% C 26 18 5 28% C 27 23 6 26% C 28 16 6 38% C 29 9 3 33% </code></pre>
37,510
[ -0.021319283172488213, -0.013393747620284557, 0.010740615427494049, -0.025588372722268105, 0.04820763319730759, -0.018164537847042084, -0.033497292548418045, -0.04351292550563812, 0.007952158339321613, -0.030511969700455666, 0.019064810127019882, 0.007507888600230217, 0.05638745799660683, -0.015052152797579765, 0.0026905860286206007, 0.006571945734322071, 0.001419899403117597, 0.0002776278997771442, -0.04881121963262558, 0.01007808092981577, 0.016637388616800308, 0.01846642978489399, -0.00518640223890543, -0.01858341321349144, -0.02732323482632637, 0.0505053885281086, -0.0022967886179685593, -0.06269601732492447, -0.05923027917742729, 0.07284440845251083, -0.065670907497406, -0.033635463565588, -0.02174212597310543, 0.025919288396835327, 0.052993807941675186, 0.027789708226919174, -0.04532874748110771, -0.02908138744533062, -0.013995199464261532, 0.05660172924399376, -0.04813525080680847, -0.01717080920934677, 0.006686382927000523, 0.0582510270178318, -0.012204007245600224, 0.02291698008775711, -0.03104032389819622, 0.005472780670970678, 0.06062682345509529, 0.00441953307017684, 0.0628100037574768, -0.009355029091238976, 0.028384586796164513, 0.03172643855214119, -0.02237812988460064, -0.05164185166358948, 0.07078947871923447, 0.026470495387911797, 0.0544637069106102, -0.057196106761693954, 0.0006424181628972292, -0.06736525148153305, -0.05871616676449776, 0.0051462892442941666, -0.021246375516057014, 0.010829067789018154, 0.009095556102693081, -0.003887245897203684, 0.025387456640601158, -0.03580323979258537, 0.016959266737103462, 0.06617441773414612, 0.03665689378976822, -0.004836881533265114, 0.009845000691711903, -0.0017790324054658413, 0.0016850853571668267, -0.0006479895673692226, 0.03973103687167168, 0.030945437029004097, -0.030092282220721245, 0.002264629816636443, 0.014853313565254211, 0.026228532195091248, -0.00733689172193408, -0.005888911429792643, 0.06516218930482864, -0.022062961012125015, 0.0023954291827976704, 0.009132090955972672, -0.0014017450157552958, 0.00029223834280855954, 0.05406910926103592, -0.018712233752012253, -0.034067440778017044, 0.019009875133633614, 0.015163732692599297, 0.02704276330769062, 0.014854222536087036, -0.008296345360577106, -0.015948230400681496, -0.06307392567396164, -0.030104342848062515, 0.0726790651679039, -0.025003664195537567, -0.005098740104585886, -0.005399954505264759, -0.02622794173657894, -0.04302939027547836, -0.05281885713338852, -0.01321212388575077, 0.03245927765965462, 0.017963696271181107, 0.02300015278160572, 0.014818299561738968, -0.030079593881964684, -0.006752277258783579, -0.004103548359125853, 0.07806849479675293, 0.035774484276771545, -0.0031207739375531673, -0.023111514747142792, 0.030404385179281235, 0.010080510750412941, -0.031601015478372574, 0.01361210085451603, 0.013463092967867851, 0.0030120941810309887, -0.015309173613786697, 0.03664671629667282, -0.0023460625670850277, -0.011736663989722729, 0.057258471846580505, -0.0016832707915455103, -0.0060013895854353905, 0.024006089195609093, -0.07684093713760376, -0.012139721773564816, 0.020176293328404427, 0.004190599545836449, 0.019510578364133835, -0.04114542156457901, -0.0077394298277795315, 0.011578528210520744, 0.054909564554691315, -0.0022102282382547855, 0.01012894231826067, 0.029597492888569832, 0.023772135376930237, 0.030194319784641266, 0.0003610935527831316, -0.0014050627360120416, -0.016136445105075836, 0.011639104224741459, -0.03678075224161148, -0.08577827364206314, 0.02437562681734562, 0.007418261840939522, 0.007783679757267237, -0.03580348566174507, 0.0457373708486557, 0.011165148578584194, -0.0011417034547775984, -0.03682224079966545, 0.0402800552546978, -0.013139708898961544, 0.070894256234169, 0.034073155373334885, 0.043230827897787094, 0.03238889202475548, 0.003520731348544359, 0.027507081627845764, 0.013447127304971218, 0.031692396849393845, 0.058451853692531586, -0.024449698626995087, 0.025952881202101707, -0.018317295238375664, -0.04213723912835121, 0.014207025989890099, -0.03165942803025246, -0.040025096386671066, -0.07783553004264832, -0.0393606461584568, 0.029916103929281235, 0.02689412608742714, -0.01622302643954754, 0.03645168989896774, 0.04810764640569687, -0.02276725322008133, -0.03178056702017784, -0.08878954499959946, 0.011627938598394394, -0.030719991773366928, -0.0637313723564148, 0.025532182306051254, -0.019096650183200836, 0.029187269508838654, -0.019758015871047974, -0.033748917281627655, -0.013349170796573162, -0.015705494210124016, 0.03588669002056122, -0.03720011189579964, 0.030618352815508842, 0.04899007827043533, 0.030827084556221962, -0.011504756286740303, 0.05994754657149315, -0.05502920225262642, 0.003393255639821291, -0.0030877881217747927, -0.02725481614470482, 0.05101188272237778, 0.01471196860074997, 0.015874097123742104, -0.008948421105742455, -0.016651106998324394, -0.039366818964481354, -0.002111902693286538, -0.044211894273757935, 0.08474545180797577, 0.0670412927865982, -0.04113917797803879, -0.008283225819468498, 0.02811604179441929, 0.007355335168540478, 0.044131115078926086, -0.0028510706033557653, 0.012470711953938007, -0.03454556316137314, -0.034984905272722244, 0.01549760065972805, 0.041303850710392, -0.00913217756897211, 0.013954145833849907, 0.05536669120192528, 0.018109865486621857, 0.0006776437512598932, 0.011269338428974152, 0.011228308081626892, -0.049560364335775375, 0.0032975804060697556, 0.009593273513019085, 0.007503489963710308, 0.01970151625573635, 0.015369086526334286, 0.008527006953954697, 0.019410936161875725, 0.012412451207637787, 0.005196107551455498, 0.00978753063827753, 0.01807454042136669, -0.012037158012390137, -0.0180539321154356, 0.006945406086742878, 0.028015591204166412, -0.006602994166314602, -0.01315235160291195, 0.0594748817384243, -0.014987817965447903, -0.014754087664186954, 0.0004464013909455389, -0.0030953804962337017, 0.018808513879776, 0.01396604161709547, 0.009694959037005901, -0.02463987097144127, 0.021195273846387863, 0.004873130936175585, -0.00931818038225174, -0.042112547904253006, -0.043331559747457504, -0.006118066143244505, -0.012901290319859982, 0.025255944579839706, 0.018621234223246574, 0.031458958983421326, -0.030669638887047768, 0.011601528152823448, 0.01995650678873062, 0.008144166320562363, 0.08674918860197067, -0.0007441559573635459, -0.03672681748867035, -0.010179904289543629, 0.001690404606051743, 0.005930606741458178, 0.058059852570295334, 0.002760307164862752, -0.004575222264975309, 0.017469342797994614, 0.01290147379040718, -0.05875491723418236, -0.04523945227265358, -0.020427267998456955, -0.024039091542363167, -0.03625549376010895, 0.02028525434434414, 0.04008254036307335, 0.01090171467512846, -0.031109197065234184, 0.0378694161772728, -0.011553273536264896, -0.009502353146672249, -0.0004971714224666357, 0.012976383790373802, 0.0030612193513661623, 0.021209891885519028, 0.006231650710105896, 0.019303208217024803, -0.0062163411639630795, -0.015919411554932594, -0.09507669508457184, -0.05809900537133217, 0.0025523502845317125, -0.022982213646173477, 0.03447594493627548, -0.015715546905994415, 0.028615811839699745, 0.07024849951267242, 0.027150465175509453, -0.027192700654268265, -0.06000576168298721, 0.020293371751904488, -0.004292019177228212, -0.004195089917629957, 0.05092724785208702, 0.049855414777994156, -0.014993526041507721, 0.01787617988884449, -0.06657274812459946, 0.009456989355385303, 0.04406944289803505, 0.007523487322032452, 0.0014171956572681665, 0.04056527093052864, 0.018005317077040672, 0.0012992951087653637, 0.011402730830013752, 0.01383285503834486, -0.02469082921743393, 0.028361055999994278, -0.000004406229891174007, 0.0022587236016988754, 0.008605853654444218, -0.05703159421682358, 0.012955594807863235, -0.037062790244817734, -0.031340092420578, 0.0063326070085167885, -0.036201924085617065, -0.04346929490566254, -0.03168939799070358, -0.03122141771018505, 0.02316633053123951, 0.024703430011868477, 0.005829578265547752, 0.011361400596797466, 0.017942918464541435, 0.003007418941706419, 0.006457049865275621, 0.00486366031691432, -0.04202184081077576, -0.012428568676114082, -0.01292723510414362, -0.031394604593515396, -0.02867698110640049, 0.025566017255187035, 0.00019052327843382955, 0.0016151330200955272, 0.02798623964190483, -0.050314974039793015, -0.0099161546677351, -0.05514032766222954, -0.0021127427462488413, -0.03517654538154602, 0.040523454546928406, 0.009212545119225979, 0.011329435743391514, -0.026897720992565155, -0.001842169207520783, -0.035418618470430374, 0.00353203690610826, -0.09196417778730392, 0.004235095344483852, -0.007859661243855953, -0.011017688550055027, 0.03498134762048721, -0.017972098663449287, 0.044128067791461945, -0.015496545471251011, -0.004305265843868256, -0.0033607762306928635, 0.04060572758316994, -0.02263827435672283, -0.011657468974590302, -0.01038322038948536, -0.022783944383263588, -0.013357043266296387, -0.0017455217894166708, 0.01622583530843258, 0.012044448405504227, 0.011304090730845928, 0.012533726170659065, 0.044201578944921494, -0.021182261407375336, -0.03161298483610153, 0.0003178513434249908, 0.04116484522819519, 0.02246103435754776, -0.008718163706362247, 0.029278501868247986, -0.03032068908214569, 0.05062270909547806, -0.0220791045576334, 0.03247975558042526, 0.092718206346035, 0.01604570262134075, -0.031031563878059387, -0.04686325788497925, -0.0196091141551733, 0.03550305962562561, -0.001330596162006259, 0.004810079000890255, -0.009346595034003258, 0.03002561256289482, 0.029343539848923683, -0.03083575703203678, -0.00001731660267978441, 0.046783242374658585, -0.002713065827265382, 0.002422967692837119, -0.04523884877562523, -0.05419749394059181, -0.017179738730192184, 0.010376445017755032, 0.021497510373592377, 0.02301054075360298, -0.004841100890189409, 0.006367678754031658, 0.061277929693460464, 0.006147222593426704, -0.048945795744657516, 0.010755723342299461, 0.0021480058785527945, 0.031146779656410217, 0.003108552424237132, -0.02700924314558506, 0.026361802592873573, 0.02150525338947773, 0.06785225123167038, -0.002777728484943509, 0.041600845754146576, -0.06464570015668869, -0.03072657249867916, 0.02889735996723175, 0.05202289670705795, -0.019785353913903236, -0.02144857682287693, -0.039328914135694504, -0.04337170720100403, 0.047136757522821426, -0.022518200799822807, 0.018625909462571144, 0.031343068927526474, 0.025421317666769028, -0.05962478742003441, -0.05897562950849533, -0.05449829623103142, -0.036663517355918884, -0.007274501491338015, -0.014015903696417809, 0.001512984512373805, -0.014489232562482357, -0.03294806182384491, 0.014625201933085918, -0.04390387609601021, 0.025126120075583458, -0.011049875989556313, -0.022804174572229385, 0.029826877638697624, -0.01544943917542696, -0.025648266077041626, -0.05507126823067665, 0.035761509090662, 0.03318169340491295, 0.016393033787608147, 0.04074972867965698, 0.008641339838504791, -0.02129545994102955, 0.003304426558315754, 0.007638631388545036, -0.02120143733918667, 0.018147725611925125, -0.010242913849651814, 0.060554247349500656, 0.024730291217565536, 0.04912714287638664, 0.04294774681329727, -0.0025056875310838223, -0.010962365195155144, 0.009641870856285095, 0.016782965511083603, 0.02034800313413143, 0.020940134301781654, -0.016686134040355682, -0.057143040001392365, 0.00837108213454485, 0.008469177410006523, 0.034904737025499344, -0.009708083234727383, 0.044264160096645355, -0.043963007628917694, 0.011711128056049347, 0.016761651262640953, 0.02746575139462948, 0.005600611679255962, -0.00827757827937603, 0.0442873015999794, 0.019565075635910034, 0.020563660189509392, 0.01104650180786848, 0.0047856527380645275, -0.0313493087887764, -0.015489267185330391, 0.005055660381913185, -0.014862188138067722, -0.0016771082300692797, 0.002784182783216238, -0.056801456958055496, 0.007504668552428484, 0.0025121457874774933, 0.02764308825135231, -0.015576883219182491, 0.026614360511302948, 0.019915753975510597, -0.017462315037846565, 0.0013791389064863324, 0.01973538286983967, 0.01463241782039404, 0.0243400726467371, -0.013050283305346966, -0.006652088835835457, -0.013547196984291077, 0.031020069494843483, -0.05828676000237465, -0.06800321489572525, 0.030090803280472755, -0.006459631025791168, -0.022567497566342354, 0.004339425824582577, 0.047292836010456085, 0.02201008051633835, -0.023226406425237656, 0.014511214569211006, 0.06084609404206276, -0.04483593627810478, 0.030848292633891106, 0.014918711967766285, -0.0000746530931792222, 0.053099922835826874, 0.012247688136994839, 0.007545124273747206, 0.015115414746105671, -0.01577211171388626, 0.00009616131137590855, -0.017166471108794212, 0.01693570986390114, -0.034829843789339066, 0.01595606654882431, -0.06513304263353348, -0.0028779124841094017, 0.07171311229467392, -0.015218124724924564, -0.05490073561668396, -0.0089780418202281, -0.049714215099811554, 0.016065476462244987, -0.05198455601930618, -0.006988723296672106, -0.008058905601501465, -0.03047119453549385, 0.017965730279684067, 0.006034620106220245, -0.011571814306080341, -0.01689591258764267, 0.013164417818188667, 0.024612965062260628, -0.04359352961182594, 0.023435430601239204, 0.032193269580602646, -0.02882068231701851, -0.009055566042661667, -0.0017871377058327198, -0.04483519122004509, 0.0430457666516304, 0.03231256455183029, 0.009309024550020695, 0.012975293211638927, -0.01381540298461914, -0.023711761459708214, -0.04775775596499443, -0.06195956468582153, 0.006410534027963877, 0.09078129380941391, 0.014017310924828053, 0.04095129296183586, 0.055317025631666183, -0.006248460616916418, -0.002364465733990073, -0.028996722772717476, -0.0010929238051176071, 0.019257066771388054, -0.026104945689439774, 0.0429142601788044, 0.008053797297179699, -0.038503214716911316, 0.05551552027463913, 0.007796837482601404, -0.0006950789247639477, 0.04129529371857643, 0.01685931347310543, 0.0029627270996570587, 0.04767172783613205, -0.058679573237895966, -0.05093364417552948, 0.03705773875117302, -0.028828214854002, 0.04757312312722206, -0.018512235954403877, 0.018151478841900826, 0.01701807975769043, 0.06593222916126251, 0.01143613550812006, -0.03504813089966774, -0.02926412783563137, -0.03611684590578079, -0.012872623279690742, 0.04577767103910446, -0.036798495799303055, 0.06808091700077057, -0.024642430245876312, 0.02170744352042675, 0.0031234861817210913, 0.020807545632123947, -0.018872929736971855, -0.02672567218542099, 0.015378782525658607, -0.0025878138840198517, -0.04745861887931824, 0.06765580922365189, 0.0007435359875671566, -0.004247305914759636, -0.012131641618907452, -0.027382144704461098, -0.02170691266655922, 0.025583792477846146, 0.013970859348773956, -0.006398599594831467, 0.05646062269806862, -0.016917740926146507, -0.0020567479077726603, -0.00954232458025217, 0.006060295272618532, 0.1415662169456482, 0.08216937631368637, 0.023087643086910248, -0.028360361233353615, 0.010270961560308933, 0.012699886225163937, -0.016864605247974396, 0.0058689662255346775, 0.003909324295818806, 0.008997678756713867, -0.04595169797539711, 0.057819902896881104, 0.01286568958312273, 0.03244054317474365, -0.023205755278468132, 0.05527934432029724, -0.01899968646466732, -0.012688460759818554, 0.027163606137037277, -0.00978932436555624, 0.004407256375998259, 0.019613580778241158, 0.004413743037730455, 0.021244343370199203, -0.0036699024494737387, -0.028164135292172432, -0.0267728790640831, -0.01159365102648735, 0.02103642374277115, -0.03276024013757706, -0.016260279342532158, 0.00614166958257556, -0.01763792335987091, 0.020980937406420708, 0.004113133531063795, -0.0007281940779648721, -0.04051738604903221, -0.03740604966878891, 0.012030476704239845, 0.06556571274995804, 0.022678939625620842, 0.012825880199670792, -0.021552208811044693, -0.019245704635977745, -0.01815585419535637, -0.05540246143937111, -0.0401950366795063, 0.024806737899780273, -0.046208832412958145, -0.03261154517531395, -0.017661752179265022, 0.019192665815353394, 0.0019628540612757206, -0.057542115449905396, -0.02565181627869606, 0.024446086958050728, 0.03095238469541073, -0.008558404631912708, 0.01457140315324068, -0.010523050092160702, -0.03764307498931885, 0.015710921958088875, -0.01975817047059536, 0.0174114853143692, -0.03483380004763603, -0.028081154450774193, -0.05518517643213272, 0.04547305777668953, 0.04208831861615181, -0.0056924764066934586, 0.002429201267659664, 0.010540365241467953, -0.01735321804881096, 0.013251972384750843, 0.006611999124288559, -0.002569642849266529, 0.04427407309412956, 0.023020436987280846, -0.05157080292701721, -0.02967928722500801, -0.02999993972480297, 0.021694280207157135, -0.0078515550121665, 0.04021485522389412, -0.05429461598396301, -0.00712553458288312, -0.0007172449841164052, 0.02936767227947712, 0.022658267989754677, 0.05293048173189163, -0.02437160164117813, 0.044063590466976166, 0.03025677800178528, -0.018001358956098557, -0.033737484365701675, -0.009233380667865276, -0.033279549330472946, -0.005983315408229828, -0.023783136159181595, 0.06947822123765945, -0.021655522286891937, -0.016679810360074043, -0.021958494558930397, 0.036601584404706955, -0.016269739717245102, -0.0044243428856134415, 0.010311205871403217, -0.040922995656728745, 0.008369142189621925, -0.03871608152985573, -0.012445959262549877, -0.029357023537158966, 0.0007576818461529911, -0.04475545510649681, -0.0128043657168746, -0.04248906672000885, -0.01343543455004692, 0.023027945309877396, 0.021756138652563095, -0.0013685754965990782, 0.0012815941590815783, -0.005313042085617781, 0.027465349063277245, -0.01842556707561016, 0.026328615844249725, -0.0015285892877727747, 0.02333713322877884, -0.014499781653285027, 0.02007027342915535, 0.012133843265473843, -0.02469620853662491, -0.01999831572175026, 0.006080643739551306, -0.005203327164053917, -0.0011196534615010023, 0.024299515411257744, 0.014218364842236042, 0.0344141460955143, 0.013238498009741306, -0.02562275528907776, 0.03256124630570412, -0.03378026559948921, -0.03607243299484253, 0.02271922677755356, -0.022163599729537964, 0.02569674141705036, -0.019847191870212555, 0.0018205521628260612, 0.025137128308415413, -0.0027030070777982473, -0.009241325780749321, -0.02867261692881584, -0.022468416020274162, 0.012516999617218971, 0.022235741838812828, 0.04767179861664772, 0.027887608855962753, 0.0082273343577981, -0.0025913661811500788, -0.0011466792784631252, 0.030234074220061302, -0.0344199575483799, 0.01668655127286911, 0.010176051408052444, -0.06159299239516258, -0.010709132067859173, -0.008812490850687027, -0.0022204932756721973, 0.060033489018678665, 0.04506838694214821, 0.009929670952260494, 0.018885843455791473, -0.027818547561764717, 0.0240397397428751, -0.09078878164291382, -0.004805650096386671, 0.0036952518858015537, 0.02350013703107834, 0.04240434616804123, -0.07168444246053696, -0.07326120138168335, 0.0004654359945561737, -0.040750421583652496, 0.053380683064460754, -0.0004704870516434312, -0.004807280842214823, -0.04306129366159439, 0.012391192838549614, -0.01638745702803135, 0.03090483881533146, 0.002248745644465089, 0.0456538051366806, 0.03987670689821243, 0.03173285350203514, -0.015926914289593697, 0.011374239809811115, -0.02937922812998295, -0.005985417868942022, 0.01835552789270878, -0.028048573061823845, 0.01747235842049122, -0.0757589191198349, -0.030118007212877274, 0.030581902712583542, -0.032270029187202454, 0.03512345254421234, 0.008787183091044426, 0.010629828087985516, 0.0042986152693629265, 0.06320006400346756, 0.011354696936905384, -0.021639209240674973, 0.011965620331466198, 0.0008232539985328913, -0.011440472677350044, 0.0670386254787445, -0.07929659634828568, 0.017305253073573112, 0.03390198200941086, 0.0009644728270359337, -0.04477453604340553, 0.018589366227388382, 0.01225766446441412, 0.012636307626962662, -0.010063123889267445, -0.03697216883301735, -0.012912839651107788, 0.0009908247739076614, 0.00006544922507600859, -0.024232923984527588, -0.02357720583677292, 0.026350289583206177, 0.015215456485748291, -0.01542535237967968, 0.015009582042694092, -0.03387116640806198, -0.022918635979294777, 0.00470485957339406, -0.0003611832216847688, -0.027164500206708908, -0.008619848638772964, -0.011966235004365444, -0.032384783029556274, -0.012722901999950409, -0.019999662414193153, -0.001667284988798201, 0.004325647372752428, 0.019467463716864586, -0.00013533451419789344, 0.01142747700214386, 0.006167684681713581, -0.03432668745517731, 0.021684294566512108, -0.08043508231639862, 0.055033497512340546, -0.007903623394668102, -0.02604389749467373, -0.035255953669548035, -0.017462274059653282, 0.0014766170643270016, 0.016824176535010338, -0.003629388753324747, -0.0129481740295887, -0.010995724238455296, -0.021558010950684547, 0.007931368425488472, -0.004218457266688347, -0.041395917534828186, 0.0801716297864914, -0.02205389365553856, 0.006974044721573591, -0.014943915419280529, 0.02278873138129711, 0.003061776515096426, -0.0239586029201746, 0.02691948600113392, -0.025646774098277092, 0.014130664989352226, 0.01390867494046688, -0.0016431580297648907, 0.009267960675060749, 0.03336566314101219, -0.02331767976284027, 0.001198569661937654, 0.005551740527153015, -0.00845100823789835, 0.024720149114727974, -0.018089313060045242, -0.06413926929235458, 0.03638910874724388, 0.0004098505596630275, -0.003220879239961505, 0.001806659041903913, 0.025819726288318634, -0.04020732268691063, -0.03159694746136665, -0.021518457680940628, 0.019498102366924286, -0.017937323078513145, -0.033470116555690765, 0.05788136273622513, 0.037638429552316666, 0.028553584590554237, 0.004651072435081005, 0.019171468913555145, -0.009153865277767181, 0.003793321782723069, -0.011085688136518002, 0.01124553196132183, 0.04614569991827011, 0.0090230293571949, 0.014017694629728794, 0.025711361318826675, -0.04764309152960777, 0.030641213059425354, -0.009154977276921272, 0.058149512857198715, -0.06847133487462997, 0.016602201387286186, 0.02546883374452591, 0.01968280039727688, -0.01766957901418209, 0.010563661344349384, -0.002044391119852662, 0.06286407262086868, -0.009136302396655083, -0.024614036083221436, 0.004684168379753828, -0.022047773003578186, -0.062154628336429596, -0.005542899016290903, 0.0785503089427948, 0.050124481320381165, -0.03655988723039627, 0.009638328105211258, -0.021115930750966072, 0.014342552050948143, 0.04103893041610718, 0.020274585112929344, 0.028573108837008476, 0.004041789565235376, -0.01482446026057005, 0.002324608387425542, 0.012663829140365124, -0.06217318773269653, -0.049389325082302094, 0.02574136108160019, -0.0014514653012156487, 0.03009866736829281, -0.02060864120721817, 0.02559247612953186, 0.0017319266917183995, 0.01800638623535633, -0.031714122742414474, -0.02112329937517643, -0.037796713411808014, 0.03876345977187157, 0.009622074663639069, 0.021331865340471268 ]
<p>The question is from a typical example for E-M algorithm. </p> <p>Let's say $(y_1,y_2,y_3)$ $\sim$ $\text{multinomial}(n;p_1,p_2,p_3)$, where $p_1+p_2+p_3=1$. </p> <p>How can we derive the conditional distribution of $y_2$ given $y_2+y_3=n$?</p> <p>The answer is $y_2|y_2+y_3 \sim \text{binomial}(n, p_2/(p_2+p_3)$). </p> <p>Any idea on how to derive this rigorously? </p>
73,933
[ 0.0010972002055495977, -0.03633582219481468, -0.02012135274708271, -0.019001811742782593, 0.02122368849813938, 0.012626174837350845, 0.013657488860189915, 0.008836857043206692, 0.029915716499090195, -0.031027209013700485, 0.0548568069934845, 0.029391556978225708, 0.04879363626241684, -0.0033848523162305355, 0.03077062778174877, 0.02507293038070202, 0.0021869244519621134, 0.009280802682042122, 0.021966658532619476, -0.012349084950983524, -0.006239684298634529, 0.00981026329100132, 0.001342900563031435, -0.05473843216896057, -0.05085095763206482, 0.012124218046665192, 0.04041272774338722, -0.016480939462780952, 0.025486912578344345, 0.0721188634634018, -0.04276449978351593, -0.041572313755750656, 0.04965696856379509, 0.060177430510520935, -0.014727473258972168, -0.00894512701779604, -0.039640162140131, -0.008813388645648956, 0.006859562825411558, -0.00436742277815938, -0.04512365534901619, -0.03707844391465187, -0.02468215860426426, 0.0011187943164259195, -0.02345592901110649, 0.020765574648976326, -0.01962251216173172, -0.02548193745315075, 0.027324682101607323, -0.06854860484600067, 0.10994017869234085, -0.000672322406899184, 0.02911185845732689, 0.028316471725702286, -0.02329649031162262, 0.0005711104604415596, 0.05201469734311104, 0.0744299441576004, 0.03441017121076584, -0.0029166415333747864, -0.018198687583208084, -0.020166784524917603, 0.010152919217944145, -0.04726124927401543, -0.040620457381010056, -0.001423808396793902, 0.022956710308790207, -0.0072272163815796375, 0.03808838874101639, -0.011285287328064442, -0.0020894291810691357, 0.018153319135308266, 0.05549691990017891, -0.024092458188533783, 0.020682942122220993, 0.03461093083024025, 0.026223130524158478, 0.0008128653280436993, 0.020135553553700447, 0.0013805485796183348, 0.004630929324775934, 0.02331145480275154, 0.024761606007814407, 0.05030122771859169, -0.021728839725255966, -0.053214531391859055, 0.045219626277685165, -0.010836099274456501, 0.009972410276532173, -0.003096190746873617, -0.022831741720438004, 0.004257256630808115, 0.040450386703014374, -0.03959312662482262, -0.053292352706193924, 0.057221200317144394, -0.0021793318446725607, 0.007246764842420816, 0.038366202265024185, -0.004045478068292141, -0.006359647959470749, -0.03564338758587837, -0.005059210117906332, 0.046637535095214844, -0.07367165386676788, 0.01662633568048477, -0.03900676965713501, 0.041803278028964996, 0.010874438099563122, 0.002677313284948468, -0.005450109019875526, 0.050145816057920456, 0.007034114561975002, -0.0017270256066694856, 0.0312856025993824, -0.004212545230984688, 0.00697829807177186, -0.015384319238364697, 0.030877169221639633, 0.06340892612934113, 0.031047221273183823, -0.01309595350176096, 0.02842237986624241, -0.022350486367940903, -0.03493426740169525, 0.005561642348766327, -0.0026533878408372402, 0.00028546369867399335, -0.015092713758349419, 0.05001286417245865, -0.021538229659199715, -0.046549566090106964, 0.010133478790521622, 0.012576347216963768, -0.010287326760590076, -0.01157936081290245, -0.06624612212181091, -0.029231833294034004, 0.01682662032544613, -0.03874991089105606, 0.006824310403317213, -0.045993924140930176, -0.006639289204031229, 0.07102826237678528, 0.02905995212495327, 0.012825270183384418, 0.07136663794517517, -0.020233485847711563, 0.036508627235889435, 0.03844785317778587, -0.051858704537153244, -0.029426760971546173, -0.053998854011297226, 0.0009961930336430669, 0.00039407986332662404, -0.10554622858762741, 0.029815124347805977, 0.05407130718231201, 0.007962335832417011, -0.017727386206388474, 0.02986874245107174, 0.007081672549247742, -0.012014594860374928, -0.016658246517181396, 0.00008820066432235762, -0.020878339186310768, 0.07252407819032669, 0.018752874806523323, 0.04984638839960098, 0.04325666278600693, 0.004539556335657835, 0.033397313207387924, 0.01526511088013649, 0.03598557040095329, 0.0664462298154831, -0.056772444397211075, -0.01146660652011633, -0.0113803306594491, 0.021443726494908333, 0.01724003627896309, -0.0023692836984992027, -0.01583121158182621, -0.005678174551576376, -0.008727803826332092, 0.03051985241472721, 0.034124165773391724, 0.0034660587552934885, -0.005973655264824629, 0.03323479741811752, -0.024688880890607834, -0.05583571270108223, -0.07761357724666595, 0.005915586370974779, 0.008160761557519436, -0.04200304299592972, 0.04923970624804497, -0.008709395304322243, 0.0016347829950973392, -0.010958196595311165, -0.007743289228528738, -0.018222052603960037, -0.013717354275286198, 0.03293624147772789, -0.021596210077404976, -0.01854173094034195, 0.04309877008199692, 0.03521924838423729, -0.0015554195269942284, 0.03813781216740608, -0.0322435162961483, -0.04579682648181915, -0.02506956458091736, -0.032824426889419556, 0.027742063626646996, 0.001568555599078536, -0.02630184404551983, 0.00937072653323412, -0.027274876832962036, 0.00652266014367342, 0.024176286533474922, -0.06530270725488663, 0.04531458020210266, 0.06096789613366127, 0.027705222368240356, 0.02621684968471527, -0.025106435641646385, 0.016389550641179085, -0.012664886191487312, 0.038303423672914505, -0.015254325233399868, -0.03400798141956329, -0.02421649545431137, 0.005382105708122253, 0.018127184361219406, -0.043626654893159866, 0.03619970753788948, 0.06124359741806984, 0.024778487160801888, 0.005320691037923098, 0.05147404223680496, -0.002480471273884177, 0.038841068744659424, 0.03588191047310829, 0.048187509179115295, -0.017269430682063103, 0.01631539687514305, -0.017165714874863625, -0.013910964131355286, 0.005871349945664406, -0.0010418868623673916, -0.033581484109163284, 0.03390127420425415, -0.010385090485215187, -0.01062398124486208, -0.03533346205949783, -0.017991967499256134, 0.012935414910316467, -0.02421434409916401, -0.004714178387075663, 0.006399881560355425, 0.0011146839242428541, -0.015510253608226776, 0.004679610952734947, -0.045879822224378586, 0.0021905547473579645, 0.03916775435209274, -0.032939519733190536, -0.01494479551911354, 0.024489296600222588, -0.009233690798282623, 0.046390749514102936, -0.018350252881646156, -0.05303613096475601, -0.010605082847177982, 0.018334409222006798, 0.023987924680113792, -0.02371382713317871, -0.0039055331144481897, -0.049986716359853745, -0.03746999427676201, -0.0289568193256855, -0.002500477945432067, 0.024148976430296898, -0.02900298871099949, -0.07427898049354553, 0.003634494263678789, -0.015378435142338276, -0.029722997918725014, 0.03946181386709213, -0.009414447471499443, -0.021254565566778183, -0.004037765320390463, 0.011479075066745281, -0.0024429329205304384, -0.009547288529574871, -0.01302541233599186, -0.002502985065802932, -0.04806189611554146, -0.04125130549073219, 0.038808658719062805, 0.016616569831967354, -0.035114824771881104, 0.008687935769557953, -0.07113267481327057, -0.02107830159366131, -0.025726940482854843, -0.028857730329036713, 0.016414085403084755, -0.03670596703886986, 0.03949292376637459, 0.011799529194831848, 0.019386427477002144, -0.004268476739525795, -0.08984196186065674, -0.07122895121574402, 0.03985016047954559, -0.01926867477595806, 0.009147756733000278, 0.009943204931914806, -0.06938590109348297, 0.07673226296901703, 0.03156892955303192, -0.02336362935602665, -0.004962621256709099, 0.024302994832396507, -0.007857389748096466, -0.02147248201072216, 0.025490008294582367, 0.031609438359737396, -0.014362639747560024, 0.05406863987445831, 0.012418259866535664, -0.021527554839849472, 0.04636277258396149, -0.026331428438425064, 0.0011774144368246198, 0.009550321847200394, -0.01783355511724949, 0.004801767412573099, 0.05495551601052284, 0.008903502486646175, -0.02401163801550865, 0.007947448641061783, -0.00019675324438139796, 0.027201315388083458, -0.017824241891503334, -0.0075179231353104115, 0.002308913040906191, -0.04616222158074379, 0.0033928907942026854, -0.031332653015851974, 0.07085958123207092, 0.028227509930729866, -0.031744156032800674, 0.03789551183581352, 0.013531315140426159, 0.020269185304641724, -0.05293749272823334, 0.016549818217754364, 0.06679679453372955, 0.04454488307237625, -0.05646952986717224, -0.04593830928206444, -0.02628466486930847, -0.008817438036203384, 0.034238770604133606, -0.019829044118523598, -0.028345538303256035, 0.0395033098757267, 0.018226435407996178, 0.02733820676803589, 0.008805771358311176, -0.01547094527631998, -0.009392721578478813, -0.05633130297064781, -0.01822265051305294, -0.005273007322102785, 0.02403898537158966, 0.0018869685009121895, 0.06835738569498062, -0.014511930756270885, -0.014734026975929737, 0.014872467145323753, 0.03951568901538849, -0.0626380518078804, -0.007024357095360756, -0.005250220187008381, -0.029378890991210938, -0.009288080036640167, 0.01787521503865719, 0.04746444523334503, -0.018294092267751694, 0.005228366237133741, 0.0071220300160348415, 0.007518647704273462, -0.020258355885744095, -0.0026648654602468014, -0.024086464196443558, -0.004156795796006918, 0.0005972393555566669, 0.01977495290338993, 0.01389989722520113, 0.005380142480134964, 0.0008365539833903313, 0.027330996468663216, -0.02144656516611576, -0.014192878268659115, -0.009590771980583668, 0.027384430170059204, -0.0018314406042918563, 0.014609786681830883, 0.021120429039001465, 0.08043335378170013, -0.021465467289090157, -0.0001654701045481488, 0.005535348318517208, 0.044704124331474304, 0.023029038682579994, -0.021809609606862068, -0.011066637001931667, -0.034647971391677856, -0.026045629754662514, 0.03613852709531784, 0.013846234418451786, 0.020487377420067787, 0.019703837111592293, 0.05463079735636711, 0.038402970880270004, -0.08187917619943619, 0.014401060529053211, 0.056946996599435806, 0.022187616676092148, 0.0018428104231134057, -0.05340659245848656, 0.03267795965075493, -0.008054710924625397, -0.0009544685599394143, 0.016799474135041237, 0.013348801992833614, 0.003380035748705268, -0.014608791097998619, 0.04335327818989754, -0.037461113184690475, 0.01164618507027626, 0.03651605546474457, 0.02304983139038086, 0.034298501908779144, 0.02930060401558876, -0.01757914572954178, 0.011274506337940693, 0.03479372709989548, -0.009220021776854992, 0.0007515641045756638, -0.03537379950284958, -0.026492098346352577, 0.008178728632628918, 0.0716390535235405, 0.03476136550307274, -0.07091353088617325, 0.01461632177233696, -0.06163863092660904, -0.006398617289960384, 0.004171283449977636, -0.013474266044795513, 0.012966213747859001, 0.024478942155838013, 0.019781403243541718, 0.0037527959793806076, -0.0031666578724980354, -0.07079730927944183, 0.021701067686080933, 0.0007805401110090315, 0.04002205282449722, -0.0290236659348011, -0.026389246806502342, -0.044660285115242004, -0.015338263474404812, 0.0659017488360405, 0.08081071078777313, -0.013882790692150593, -0.019895194098353386, 0.002715117996558547, 0.011572234332561493, 0.004016177263110876, -0.08974304050207138, 0.03229731693863869, 0.005520745646208525, -0.006189224775880575, 0.03997654840350151, -0.05258769169449806, -0.03245573118329048, 0.0016792292008176446, 0.015688924118876457, -0.009770992211997509, 0.008328795433044434, 0.010173694230616093, 0.040662944316864014, 0.04064307361841202, -0.012826002202928066, 0.04836677014827728, -0.006728943437337875, -0.01152941957116127, -0.0243826974183321, -0.03789262846112251, 0.010974740609526634, -0.04225866496562958, 0.013866204768419266, -0.012706550769507885, 0.007455788552761078, 0.007634281646460295, 0.022287683561444283, -0.006785382051020861, 0.023674920201301575, 0.004582295659929514, -0.03742385283112526, -0.05472441390156746, 0.01608947291970253, -0.004292959813028574, 0.006720365025103092, 0.011875512078404427, 0.003818351775407791, 0.013766942545771599, -0.013013225048780441, 0.06521628051996231, -0.0463227815926075, 0.008589837700128555, -0.0016270325286313891, -0.018015600740909576, 0.007626846432685852, -0.024590589106082916, -0.017861321568489075, -0.006741595920175314, -0.004675331991165876, 0.03617018461227417, -0.023822853341698647, 0.06362960487604141, 0.02213912457227707, -0.04548421502113342, -0.018709076568484306, 0.01781734637916088, -0.02935664914548397, 0.022661661729216576, -0.039993591606616974, -0.009214699268341064, 0.007003507576882839, 0.0018616467714309692, -0.05213399603962898, -0.047949545085430145, 0.02250906080007553, 0.009936959482729435, 0.011355401016771793, -0.051500383764505386, -0.047958262264728546, -0.0217925775796175, -0.04671798273921013, 0.018736669793725014, 0.06354407221078873, -0.03360946103930473, -0.0322246253490448, -0.018449150025844574, -0.007091674488037825, 0.07567410171031952, 0.004504750482738018, 0.0020023153629153967, 0.01846439205110073, -0.02803654596209526, -0.022569287568330765, 0.023190490901470184, 0.012690099887549877, -0.020966699346899986, -0.016327306628227234, -0.0056222272105515, 0.037027757614851, 0.05727405846118927, -0.07102935761213303, -0.0213596411049366, 0.004403980448842049, -0.002345849759876728, 0.005128025077283382, -0.005437116138637066, -0.00848151370882988, -0.00015611242270097136, 0.038607072085142136, -0.043895822018384933, -0.023889126256108284, 0.0033233794383704662, 0.010690468363463879, 0.061614491045475006, 0.025414273142814636, -0.0015583580825477839, 0.006540178786963224, 0.081149160861969, -0.013355609029531479, -0.017799492925405502, 0.0038379847537726164, 0.012989435344934464, 0.03324189782142639, 0.004828459583222866, -0.006936194375157356, 0.012248062528669834, 0.0026386897079646587, -0.0377722904086113, 0.007914623245596886, -0.04618856683373451, 0.02726748213171959, 0.04121130332350731, -0.02875271812081337, 0.04144993796944618, 0.034633226692676544, 0.020876817405223846, -0.024879813194274902, -0.02218797244131565, 0.008850407786667347, 0.0011434172047302127, -0.010164414532482624, 0.021632587537169456, -0.037027157843112946, -0.004727718885987997, 0.053844597190618515, 0.02709134854376316, -0.0005404663970693946, 0.005316213238984346, 0.0027939709834754467, 0.010008640587329865, 0.06537982076406479, -0.01596829853951931, -0.03068729303777218, 0.04093284532427788, -0.07070812582969666, -0.007637042552232742, -0.02716178447008133, -0.02989860251545906, 0.048583801835775375, 0.01748024672269821, -0.0028061727061867714, -0.03294692933559418, -0.022766074165701866, -0.016161907464265823, -0.004323793575167656, 0.034040242433547974, -0.03387292101979256, 0.04044944792985916, 0.007450059521943331, 0.043306514620780945, -0.028582755476236343, 0.013483208604156971, 0.0286372322589159, -0.07072493433952332, -0.049439601600170135, -0.026061346754431725, -0.007400189526379108, -0.011199360713362694, 0.0338868647813797, 0.005204153247177601, -0.00515746371820569, 0.007784684654325247, 0.025059089064598083, 0.0350271500647068, 0.06587299704551697, -0.028305690735578537, 0.08916788548231125, 0.02289261668920517, 0.05133884400129318, -0.004602169618010521, -0.02234218455851078, 0.08933621644973755, 0.04347662627696991, 0.06144891679286957, -0.0918574407696724, 0.04192192107439041, -0.0003242016537114978, -0.019177259877324104, -0.033952224999666214, 0.017621522769331932, 0.03863111510872841, 0.027542227879166603, 0.029959309846162796, 0.04632991924881935, -0.0026955518405884504, -0.0005329794366843998, 0.037212077528238297, -0.021067922934889793, -0.04207165539264679, 0.016587257385253906, 0.01932424120604992, -0.014344509690999985, -0.04272996261715889, -0.058620765805244446, -0.000527647091075778, 0.032695844769477844, -0.04590087756514549, -0.02376154251396656, -0.03473525494337082, 0.013927522115409374, 0.014156938530504704, -0.003827880835160613, -0.012136838398873806, 0.012308148667216301, -0.002586205955594778, -0.017641263082623482, 0.0017336627934128046, -0.005126815289258957, -0.04292362183332443, 0.01629233919084072, 0.021697914227843285, 0.02224011905491352, 0.006873995531350374, 0.004759321920573711, 0.011007236316800117, -0.050789687782526016, -0.017596513032913208, -0.03363195061683655, 0.020246854051947594, -0.023566441610455513, -0.014559379778802395, -0.0006968739326111972, -0.020472584292292595, 0.0026515061035752296, -0.0607842355966568, 0.02184295281767845, 0.02655952237546444, -0.014336496591567993, -0.03731883689761162, -0.021660761907696724, -0.01239206176251173, 0.015954025089740753, 0.0007188352174125612, 0.00901914294809103, 0.012154211290180683, -0.021774373948574066, -0.018918674439191818, -0.027952976524829865, 0.01022402010858059, 0.032672587782144547, -0.032732393592596054, -0.03244234621524811, -0.045101508498191833, -0.012225973419845104, 0.001791685470379889, -0.0010860958136618137, -0.021760201081633568, -0.004248728975653648, 0.012699359096586704, -0.019934093579649925, 0.011917863972485065, -0.015178375877439976, -0.02721923030912876, -0.025085322558879852, 0.001116590341553092, -0.012279752641916275, -0.01922033354640007, 0.008619613014161587, 0.051500577479600906, 0.006696621421724558, -0.0014555947855114937, 0.005566628649830818, 0.061104968190193176, 0.004127247259020805, -0.038920409977436066, -0.009433852508664131, -0.02250315062701702, -0.03356514126062393, -0.00281738443300128, -0.0030423253774642944, 0.03046402707695961, 0.00032352376729249954, 0.03594066575169563, -0.0048998091369867325, -0.006949090864509344, 0.004098942037671804, 0.014404494315385818, -0.020497770980000496, -0.037197310477495193, 0.0017500551184639335, 0.014385245740413666, -0.015767652541399002, -0.03672902658581734, 0.01584082655608654, -0.0037849450018256903, -0.026536904275417328, 0.06697539985179901, -0.05602700263261795, -0.02563110552728176, -0.01628682017326355, 0.0001590829051565379, 0.01797456666827202, -0.012786317616701126, 0.009914366528391838, 0.02362358756363392, -0.014575288631021976, -0.010992464609444141, 0.000917180092073977, -0.016512257978320122, -0.02372322417795658, -0.012836147099733353, 0.013232867233455181, 0.04851043224334717, 0.009223125874996185, 0.017000112682580948, -0.01600869558751583, 0.02060578390955925, 0.015381993725895882, 0.06331019103527069, -0.02352515608072281, -0.021161841228604317, 0.07722452282905579, -0.052011653780937195, -0.006739548407495022, -0.0035033170133829117, 0.014826858416199684, 0.06246010586619377, 0.0113215995952487, -0.01814320683479309, -0.022854860872030258, -0.0008076811791397631, -0.038404881954193115, -0.022301996126770973, 0.020305553451180458, 0.02446577325463295, 0.017871402204036713, -0.008556228131055832, -0.022583691403269768, -0.006105753593146801, -0.019387617707252502, 0.037340689450502396, 0.0521615631878376, -0.022886550053954124, -0.026266086846590042, 0.031892888247966766, 0.02115461975336075, 0.013870049268007278, 0.02022702246904373, -0.004545398056507111, 0.03222910687327385, 0.06352835148572922, 0.007665403187274933, 0.039497893303632736, -0.0033770264126360416, -0.029860911890864372, -0.07220806181430817, -0.041473668068647385, 0.030287401750683784, -0.009616966359317303, 0.06633660942316055, -0.042225077748298645, 0.009156589396297932, 0.026185208931565285, -0.04547283053398132, -0.005761048290878534, 0.02018589898943901, -0.03136446326971054, -0.04955312982201576, 0.05408809706568718, -0.021317755803465843, 0.024587217718362808, -0.005192738492041826, 0.018381081521511078, 0.0375499427318573, 0.015896441414952278, 0.015480873174965382, -0.021713875234127045, -0.022494344040751457, -0.007081382442265749, 0.03073527291417122, -0.02858148142695427, 0.0430128239095211, -0.03818744421005249, -0.03918229416012764, 0.023624135181307793, 0.014689767733216286, 0.004925693850964308, 0.022757459431886673, 0.018460387364029884, 0.022977419197559357, 0.03829782456159592, 0.005966564640402794, -0.0008345091482624412, 0.01785595528781414, 0.015362890437245369, 0.03937067463994026, 0.01877969317138195, -0.027035100385546684, -0.014536434784531593, 0.043298617005348206, -0.00741884671151638, -0.03574928268790245, 0.032804567366838455, 0.010547402314841747, -0.04973096400499344, 0.0004471211286727339, -0.02649884670972824, 0.016455087810754776, -0.06061781197786331, 0.062055233865976334, -0.051048643887043, -0.01076514832675457, 0.03494703024625778, 0.059782855212688446, 0.004405238199979067, 0.01195527520030737, -0.012305090203881264, -0.05380108579993248, 0.012134949676692486, 0.02451721951365471, -0.027270926162600517, -0.03843332454562187, 0.0198739692568779, 0.006989851128309965, 0.01077481172978878, -0.02240583673119545, -0.04791920632123947, -0.03938925638794899, 0.018423080444335938, 0.00667310506105423, 0.00814526341855526, 0.041666850447654724, -0.0027455950621515512, 0.01565106213092804, -0.06211875006556511, 0.029772847890853882, 0.046371616423130035, 0.005691881291568279, -0.04323309287428856, -0.003091772086918354, -0.05554291233420372, -0.0005201997119002044, 0.050370071083307266, 0.006653760559856892, -0.0042707123793661594, -0.01085526030510664, 0.033017970621585846, 0.007262141443789005, -0.06512337177991867, 0.012094725854694843, -0.03389497473835945, -0.0049979290924966335, -0.04551564157009125, -0.029847461730241776, 0.0429033599793911, 0.0002557107072789222, -0.02286979742348194, 0.023464584723114967, -0.004025465343147516, -0.010599133558571339, 0.013363066129386425, 0.023976203054189682, 0.012351326644420624, -0.011898867785930634, 0.026377705857157707, -0.038451798260211945, -0.0036011775955557823, 0.017276713624596596, -0.007517881225794554, -0.08073468506336212, 0.007070279214531183, -0.06775843352079391, -0.0019578493665903807, -0.006282133515924215, -0.003468678565695882, 0.0015339819947257638, -0.05731866508722305, -0.0054197306744754314, -0.005797895602881908, -0.052320510149002075, 0.00547540420666337, 0.026637591421604156, 0.018119368702173233, 0.061974722892045975, -0.014271557331085205, 0.011062116362154484, 0.012701028026640415, -0.022830402478575706, 0.022874286398291588, 0.018923651427030563, -0.006384218577295542, -0.03429105132818222, 0.02150798961520195, 0.00561731681227684, -0.007473805919289589, 0.019675789400935173, 0.023535313084721565, 0.02240638993680477, 0.010886230506002903, -0.020831072703003883, 0.05145922303199768, -0.026302644982933998, 0.01865397021174431, -0.01782350055873394, 0.00018549375818111002, 0.07960060238838196, -0.0039028956089168787, 0.03310249373316765, -0.013763065449893475, 0.008479073643684387, -0.013512209057807922, -0.00020433121244423091, 0.013893023133277893, 0.017758967354893684, 0.013909613713622093, -0.002252597827464342, 0.01524087879806757, -0.019304098561406136, 0.015204898081719875, 0.016596022993326187, 0.02173720672726631, -0.0005198231665417552, -0.019653569906949997, -0.007115267217159271, -0.049475327134132385, -0.005934933200478554, -0.015484130941331387, -0.005312654655426741, 0.03627821430563927, 0.03957873582839966, 0.0034646601416170597, -0.000304399844026193, -0.02016782946884632, 0.04997043311595917, -0.03593003749847412, -0.03275549039244652, -0.07474878430366516, 0.007764878682792187, 0.02539895288646221, -0.02347816340625286 ]
<p>I do not know why testing homogeneity of variance is so important. What are the examples that require homogeneity of variance?</p>
36,497
[ -0.05415123328566551, 0.011944600380957127, -0.013887469656765461, -0.031547266989946365, 0.06068100780248642, -0.00212631537579, -0.0012542353942990303, -0.01432915311306715, 0.004955087322741747, 0.005211284849792719, 0.047504670917987823, 0.006535541731864214, 0.042079199105501175, 0.012722662650048733, 0.022178998216986656, 0.006604307796806097, -0.004762027878314257, -0.03563954681158066, -0.01976597309112549, 0.0189904123544693, 0.0026409602724015713, 0.0056214602664113045, 0.012673020362854004, -0.029406506568193436, 0.0017709650564938784, 0.0033806602004915476, 0.02962329238653183, -0.01041207741945982, 0.050971098244190216, 0.07372653484344482, -0.049937061965465546, 0.009357747621834278, 0.01344378013163805, 0.082373708486557, 0.005518206860870123, -0.004317884799093008, 0.0017601734725758433, -0.029076501727104187, -0.006975800264626741, 0.04331182315945625, -0.02011929266154766, -0.013244334608316422, -0.01983928494155407, 0.02458544448018074, -0.01826569251716137, 0.0429711677134037, 0.008822285570204258, -0.049779824912548065, 0.03357915207743645, -0.06446094810962677, 0.07085578888654709, 0.0015555690042674541, 0.04270225018262863, 0.024005593731999397, 0.0166955403983593, -0.013305433094501495, 0.056255485862493515, 0.037677567452192307, -0.026596544310450554, -0.058941856026649475, -0.03603735566139221, -0.015975335612893105, 0.010781916789710522, -0.018752658739686012, -0.02509308233857155, 0.0345948226749897, 0.01088288240134716, -0.04351139813661575, 0.04179073125123978, -0.012802796438336372, 0.006664011161774397, 0.011692242696881294, 0.02826174534857273, 0.016121383756399155, -0.0033931254874914885, 0.02659108303487301, 0.006334448233246803, -0.003537209006026387, 0.027211079373955727, 0.03126024454832077, -0.012325762771070004, -0.00843073520809412, 0.024698052555322647, 0.002596937119960785, 0.036825839430093765, -0.02392285130918026, 0.05001665651798248, -0.015113608911633492, -0.0021638120524585247, 0.009503544308245182, -0.016092829406261444, -0.014001892879605293, 0.05995767563581467, 0.020994704216718674, -0.053246770054101944, 0.005569489672780037, -0.04031199589371681, 0.011420853435993195, 0.004563449881970882, -0.009224982000887394, -0.019452570006251335, -0.05503510311245918, 0.07340805232524872, 0.04904839023947716, -0.0009982783813029528, -0.04187347739934921, -0.02802436053752899, 0.015648003667593002, 0.013310953043401241, -0.010433073155581951, 0.0007147804135456681, 0.02684229239821434, -0.021600065752863884, 0.01122907642275095, 0.036770425736904144, 0.01023972686380148, -0.0013554781908169389, -0.022326041013002396, 0.07378271222114563, 0.07993367314338684, 0.04866767302155495, 0.0032677764538675547, 0.013784687966108322, -0.012875846587121487, -0.050416119396686554, 0.028414394706487656, 0.03467121347784996, 0.0024708255659788847, -0.05916455760598183, 0.07538872957229614, -0.008650114759802818, -0.04182686656713486, -0.003666020929813385, -0.00793719943612814, 0.02429240196943283, -0.02844722382724285, -0.1201896071434021, -0.06958688050508499, 0.05643399804830551, 0.003656338667497039, -0.022779924795031548, -0.061194635927677155, 0.019723689183592796, 0.006348618306219578, 0.037757035344839096, -0.008960044011473656, 0.03568124771118164, -0.005606357473880053, 0.0275986660271883, 0.029641168192029, -0.036095425486564636, -0.021583719179034233, -0.0029912760946899652, -0.02806827239692211, 0.03204775229096413, -0.0794176235795021, -0.0110529949888587, 0.0125121483579278, -0.017381520941853523, -0.015814902260899544, -0.0024936820846050978, 0.00909597147256136, -0.008805235847830772, -0.014985117129981518, 0.00019390741363167763, -0.00794259924441576, 0.059804756194353104, -0.035579461604356766, 0.01649525761604309, 0.026273218914866447, 0.001115203252993524, 0.01694604754447937, 0.016574842855334282, 0.05403243750333786, 0.0062622195109725, 0.016201116144657135, -0.0031202982645481825, 0.00866943970322609, 0.032927993685007095, -0.0009429212077520788, -0.044550277292728424, 0.029031354933977127, 0.019278449937701225, 0.0067186495289206505, 0.0070181856863200665, 0.040063876658678055, -0.013714841566979885, -0.017902133986353874, 0.075034961104393, -0.055706657469272614, -0.04095663130283356, -0.05228852480649948, 0.018282324075698853, -0.02039998397231102, -0.020944111049175262, 0.028024189174175262, 0.036371342837810516, 0.027915719896554947, -0.03316061198711395, -0.04876115918159485, -0.037004224956035614, 0.002269385615363717, 0.03893013671040535, -0.05365852266550064, 0.02284359559416771, 0.030761126428842545, 0.026396486908197403, -0.019382400438189507, 0.06551558524370193, -0.01990259811282158, -0.034860387444496155, 0.026223041117191315, -0.05236847698688507, 0.014807246625423431, -0.014909385703504086, -0.012180338613688946, 0.004929065238684416, 0.0017633881652727723, -0.02637973427772522, 0.07033630460500717, -0.050385043025016785, 0.07248541712760925, 0.05089821293950081, -0.010511189699172974, 0.017140457406640053, -0.014011186547577381, 0.016990363597869873, -0.011930789798498154, -0.015141237527132034, -0.0035329386591911316, -0.05255545303225517, -0.009359226562082767, 0.03209904581308365, 0.017589522525668144, -0.04453219845890999, 0.007597367279231548, 0.034969814121723175, 0.054569732397794724, 0.0014640174340456724, 0.04007967188954353, 0.006989734712988138, -0.050263483077287674, 0.015206936746835709, 0.022591734305024147, 0.03189048916101456, 0.0029905589763075113, 0.01330163050442934, 0.02589225582778454, 0.006788724102079868, 0.011195565573871136, 0.00033493415685370564, 0.0619354285299778, -0.010564204305410385, 0.0008232336840592325, -0.0147062037140131, -0.025916198268532753, 0.017453161999583244, -0.02241366356611252, 0.04764774441719055, 0.04373214766383171, 0.0025504720397293568, 0.01061537116765976, 0.0036377180367708206, -0.05357423052191734, 0.041968442499637604, 0.004051420837640762, -0.015540697611868382, 0.011927745305001736, 0.05182608217000961, -0.03670850396156311, -0.026425793766975403, -0.05773784592747688, 0.004639949183911085, -0.027398213744163513, -0.0026429954450577497, 0.05727488920092583, -0.008474943228065968, 0.012171167880296707, 0.004509629216045141, -0.0000043058394112449605, -0.014540978707373142, -0.011175998486578465, 0.004326287191361189, -0.01744907535612583, -0.028254305943846703, 0.0035281190648674965, -0.0063632396049797535, 0.011074027046561241, 0.03056204319000244, -0.0022957150358706713, -0.017957884818315506, 0.05717458203434944, 0.009594721719622612, -0.02787029556930065, -0.010181669145822525, -0.037245653569698334, -0.003801763290539384, -0.0296966340392828, -0.03746149688959122, 0.0449204258620739, -0.03458409383893013, -0.03705614060163498, 0.041934456676244736, -0.02617577649652958, -0.03577994927763939, -0.028572672978043556, -0.0010958630591630936, 0.01578235626220703, -0.025081580504775047, 0.0207902230322361, 0.03520505130290985, -0.08105631172657013, -0.021970653906464577, -0.03890686109662056, -0.049497105181217194, 0.016761764883995056, -0.0025408901274204254, 0.05520278215408325, -0.013707064092159271, -0.04429037123918533, 0.043950390070676804, 0.027341991662979126, -0.023442013189196587, -0.027286984026432037, 0.004097019787877798, -0.03309592977166176, -0.040957462042570114, 0.04124666750431061, 0.001166373724117875, -0.013649391010403633, 0.034259602427482605, 0.03721790388226509, 0.040983039885759354, 0.02049925923347473, -0.004831838421523571, -0.0065747895278036594, 0.018514111638069153, 0.006926864385604858, -0.008009808138012886, 0.019443141296505928, 0.009057863615453243, -0.019344616681337357, -0.023299559950828552, 0.028924578800797462, 0.036965738981962204, -0.016174351796507835, -0.018015878275036812, 0.036771856248378754, -0.030225932598114014, 0.030459191650152206, -0.04133214056491852, 0.034369632601737976, -0.012810896150767803, 0.01810491643846035, 0.00507836090400815, 0.014238322153687477, 0.00655269343405962, -0.019301703199744225, -0.002393012633547187, 0.02140984870493412, 0.04024839773774147, -0.023922059684991837, 0.01432708278298378, -0.017657466232776642, -0.01534168142825365, 0.03012836165726185, -0.023524342104792595, 0.003970455378293991, 0.03855095058679581, 0.053558349609375, 0.027820777148008347, -0.036992114037275314, -0.053321171551942825, -0.007423711474984884, -0.024931469932198524, 0.015609254129230976, -0.03944242000579834, -0.0002460789983160794, -0.012655597180128098, 0.05641525238752365, 0.04326367378234863, -0.006334320176392794, -0.023621734231710434, -0.04060372710227966, -0.050186436623334885, 0.009140128269791603, -0.03972136601805687, 0.021053532138466835, -0.00661816168576479, -0.0459701269865036, 0.02560233511030674, -0.007796380668878555, 0.039818838238716125, -0.001775888493284583, 0.03256084397435188, -0.02943631075322628, 0.019330309703946114, 0.00771381426602602, -0.03201737254858017, -0.022641770541667938, 0.023422857746481895, 0.0035540414974093437, -0.0133589468896389, 0.02730974555015564, 0.025394661352038383, -0.005535466130822897, -0.040262240916490555, -0.0311938114464283, 0.02674739807844162, -0.0031065908260643482, 0.05892699211835861, 0.03426286578178406, 0.011207678355276585, -0.028100615367293358, 0.04515718296170235, 0.0070725479163229465, 0.05638129264116287, 0.01825985684990883, 0.024759454652667046, -0.024947980418801308, -0.028303859755396843, -0.049460116773843765, 0.00004410788096720353, 0.01660727709531784, 0.00233806692995131, -0.0048894318751990795, 0.052260491997003555, 0.04027516022324562, -0.0394497774541378, 0.03762324899435043, 0.040422894060611725, 0.016506243497133255, 0.0048749675042927265, -0.01985420472919941, -0.04080639034509659, -0.021356068551540375, -0.03046673908829689, 0.00944499671459198, 0.00218580593355, -0.019985070452094078, 0.022418268024921417, 0.02673252485692501, -0.013122795149683952, -0.03405985236167908, -0.008791097439825535, 0.011248158290982246, 0.03222110494971275, 0.0033096002880483866, -0.04874361306428909, 0.02166621945798397, 0.0357394702732563, 0.03084391914308071, 0.02746177464723587, -0.031337887048721313, -0.08280406147241592, 0.023823413997888565, 0.03956093266606331, 0.028843749314546585, -0.042538292706012726, 0.003160004038363695, -0.01016854215413332, 0.004547427408397198, 0.042560335248708725, -0.03814857825636864, 0.015486945398151875, -0.04302374646067619, 0.0034195557236671448, -0.04181787744164467, -0.027506135404109955, -0.030077774077653885, 0.024906422942876816, 0.027989134192466736, 0.017513291910290718, -0.03319927304983139, -0.004259749315679073, -0.023648984730243683, -0.00024280529760289937, 0.016490694135427475, 0.05785760655999184, -0.013367613777518272, 0.0011402531526982784, 0.018880965188145638, 0.050538722425699234, -0.03218569979071617, -0.05684177950024605, 0.02013254165649414, 0.005001962650567293, 0.022850362583994865, 0.05623014643788338, -0.019105644896626472, -0.05425894260406494, 0.02247711457312107, -0.02511080913245678, -0.04460347443819046, 0.011531894095242023, -0.0051938011310994625, 0.020753243938088417, 0.027940763160586357, 0.051856618374586105, 0.0718202143907547, 0.0007811676478013396, -0.016994399949908257, -0.005195169243961573, -0.008575069718062878, 0.016411615535616875, -0.06076600030064583, -0.029624290764331818, -0.052708741277456284, -0.033968668431043625, -0.022452307865023613, 0.03303179517388344, 0.012848391197621822, 0.004760357551276684, 0.025008603930473328, -0.004130091518163681, 0.005125917494297028, 0.0016093618469312787, 0.019375087693333626, -0.04502946510910988, -0.004120570607483387, 0.00817936286330223, 0.00426293583586812, -0.007279710844159126, 0.03149985149502754, 0.010119629092514515, 0.002563491929322481, 0.017644457519054413, 0.002860919339582324, -0.006196530535817146, -0.05529242008924484, -0.032795246690511703, 0.0034259085077792406, -0.01432772260159254, 0.03330649435520172, -0.009489954449236393, 0.03714499995112419, -0.008884407579898834, -0.06571988761425018, 0.015890860930085182, 0.023343700915575027, -0.016500605270266533, 0.05595790594816208, -0.012949224561452866, 0.01640371046960354, -0.04233204200863838, 0.00899102259427309, -0.09615054726600647, -0.01990557089447975, 0.006364802829921246, 0.03317056968808174, 0.013477443717420101, -0.0313478522002697, -0.008464536629617214, 0.009638230316340923, -0.038397446274757385, -0.023970581591129303, 0.05829699710011482, -0.015193474479019642, -0.01382437627762556, -0.03554292768239975, 0.02188718691468239, 0.11667928844690323, 0.013232868164777756, 0.0016075177118182182, 0.027214929461479187, -0.03703911602497101, -0.005847783759236336, -0.005002311896532774, 0.014435390941798687, -0.03828510269522667, 0.015122678130865097, -0.010384034365415573, -0.025743477046489716, 0.013276802375912666, -0.04461690038442612, -0.05384190380573273, 0.02274920418858528, -0.016626853495836258, -0.018751902505755424, -0.0333537720143795, 0.042231593281030655, -0.04100674390792847, 0.033786289393901825, -0.027771320194005966, 0.006981855258345604, -0.007814938202500343, -0.016182221472263336, 0.039461396634578705, 0.011463377624750137, 0.007093540392816067, 0.030055010691285133, 0.07070645689964294, -0.00835428573191166, -0.012507095001637936, 0.016368795186281204, -0.016076447442173958, 0.004461520817130804, 0.010361184366047382, 0.01831449568271637, -0.00031112891156226397, 0.050223153084516525, -0.03661792352795601, -0.01892232894897461, -0.008512094616889954, 0.012243623845279217, 0.04882718622684479, 0.000020590252461261116, 0.05461809039115906, 0.06310049444437027, -0.0023899395018815994, -0.015125672332942486, -0.02009357511997223, 0.00047309292131103575, -0.006414813455194235, 0.008331168442964554, 0.033752307295799255, 0.02996501699090004, -0.005309096071869135, 0.044594038277864456, 0.02203785628080368, 0.021770549938082695, 0.0037254453636705875, 0.01748255454003811, 0.030307123437523842, 0.029461899772286415, -0.020031124353408813, -0.06561003625392914, 0.059860169887542725, -0.049266520887613297, 0.012102368287742138, -0.054143909364938736, 0.00640904949977994, 0.04180620238184929, 0.021557532250881195, -0.013918768614530563, -0.05546094477176666, -0.026827827095985413, -0.03439481928944588, 0.02753683738410473, 0.005420819856226444, -0.02092733420431614, 0.012245632708072662, 0.021762888878583908, 0.04346907138824463, -0.03348319232463837, 0.00630186777561903, -0.031224066391587257, -0.1152721643447876, -0.053585294634103775, 0.02409859001636505, -0.007868466898798943, 0.04675137624144554, 0.0007742089801467955, -0.037634801119565964, -0.0008700019679963589, -0.02567180059850216, 0.002593262353911996, -0.04190625622868538, 0.0363626666367054, -0.023265575990080833, 0.06121502444148064, 0.03398936241865158, 0.03727003559470177, 0.00810027215629816, 0.002149290405213833, 0.1024455800652504, 0.07187913358211517, 0.02724594995379448, -0.05620269849896431, 0.030012834817171097, -0.03864191845059395, 0.011287053115665913, -0.007330568972975016, 0.013888937421143055, 0.0070482478477060795, 0.04196366295218468, 0.013729309663176537, 0.04290018603205681, 0.02426680363714695, -0.02227240800857544, 0.06344868987798691, -0.061159901320934296, -0.028348900377750397, -0.011848153546452522, 0.01171865314245224, -0.02043277397751808, 0.004006408620625734, -0.020906012505292892, 0.0027034941595047712, 0.01608377881348133, -0.02974420040845871, 0.004267048090696335, -0.029358478263020515, -0.0027728371787816286, 0.017570221796631813, -0.030124319717288017, -0.0028318811673671007, -0.005967707373201847, -0.006484965793788433, -0.06770925968885422, -0.028695285320281982, 0.011165469884872437, -0.028289245441555977, 0.003600797848775983, 0.028399672359228134, -0.014888250268995762, -0.013354751281440258, 0.012353834696114063, 0.0018303388496860862, -0.02556532993912697, -0.010046390816569328, -0.02741401270031929, 0.0546005554497242, -0.01100634504109621, 0.00449357507750392, -0.017217954620718956, 0.017977364361286163, -0.021457789465785027, -0.03623943775892258, -0.0007671351195313036, 0.014233775436878204, 0.005265772342681885, -0.03996222838759422, -0.015599210746586323, -0.04686722904443741, 0.019554466009140015, -0.015021711587905884, 0.06137556955218315, 0.03968461975455284, -0.05088106170296669, -0.01688229665160179, -0.03550967201590538, 0.051946837455034256, 0.005220768507570028, -0.03620072454214096, 0.0010863145580515265, 0.00024203448265325278, -0.018152588978409767, 0.005269946530461311, -0.0010117298224940896, 0.016564730554819107, 0.01748010329902172, 0.011822120286524296, -0.01716432347893715, 0.01835792325437069, -0.04845055192708969, 0.022594982758164406, -0.041395340114831924, -0.02944435179233551, -0.06747132539749146, 0.007726032752543688, 0.05202702805399895, 0.03044121339917183, 0.02557840570807457, 0.024214109405875206, -0.025945590808987617, 0.05458499863743782, 0.01934572122991085, -0.021112637594342232, -0.016221025958657265, -0.012414967641234398, -0.029034992679953575, -0.01918146014213562, -0.023673513904213905, 0.02454989030957222, 0.0427478663623333, 0.0362686961889267, -0.020265059545636177, 0.0029163260478526354, -0.0044591426849365234, 0.03225095197558403, 0.0205070823431015, -0.06520535051822662, -0.011375701986253262, 0.005391555838286877, 0.014477689750492573, -0.012104222550988197, -0.030815372243523598, -0.05190005898475647, -0.010702284052968025, 0.026595117524266243, -0.04535702243447304, -0.024483921006321907, -0.006047546397894621, -0.013796054758131504, 0.07056598365306854, -0.05456168204545975, 0.01696503721177578, -0.009845050983130932, -0.028459157794713974, 0.016388876363635063, -0.030819717794656754, 0.03016095608472824, 0.0009189858101308346, 0.010492098517715931, 0.008140809834003448, 0.047234293073415756, 0.03559541329741478, 0.03425902500748634, 0.024624647572636604, 0.024797169491648674, 0.01798916608095169, 0.03624102100729942, -0.015896670520305634, -0.013086074963212013, 0.04926516115665436, -0.04488550126552582, -0.019537800922989845, -0.0004989217850379646, -0.011909306980669498, 0.020296700298786163, 0.00400282209739089, -0.023945875465869904, -0.023161504417657852, 0.015019990503787994, -0.01428865548223257, 0.007311180233955383, -0.008528187870979309, -0.00929234828799963, 0.02500523440539837, 0.0011871939059346914, 0.014438990503549576, -0.005291004199534655, -0.014301415532827377, 0.03330502659082413, 0.027117833495140076, 0.01451578363776207, -0.0129816560074687, 0.028101079165935516, 0.011252752505242825, 0.008972270414233208, 0.023846488445997238, -0.0063603161834180355, 0.017643745988607407, 0.08226184546947479, -0.03323807567358017, -0.003415638580918312, -0.03574533760547638, -0.00647883303463459, -0.09352482855319977, -0.010419508442282677, 0.02275902032852173, 0.014994839206337929, 0.012378978542983532, -0.05639791861176491, 0.03195933997631073, 0.0460459403693676, -0.0561833418905735, 0.021255789324641228, -0.014255613088607788, -0.017145365476608276, -0.041603974997997284, -0.05037253350019455, -0.015441102907061577, 0.019626734778285027, 0.0018422780558466911, 0.01917710155248642, 0.025591924786567688, 0.027559125795960426, 0.005657486617565155, -0.019458502531051636, 0.028835298493504524, -0.006180314347147942, -0.027066979557275772, -0.06047256663441658, 0.01541113294661045, 0.011070574633777142, -0.0480305515229702, 0.011172723956406116, 0.0008914823993109167, 0.014689493924379349, 0.008233343251049519, 0.03681449964642525, -0.014255358837544918, 0.028385717421770096, 0.019357498735189438, 0.021502431482076645, -0.022868134081363678, 0.015374666079878807, -0.003906190861016512, 0.039270173758268356, -0.020350754261016846, 0.022188007831573486, 0.017583854496479034, -0.021645037457346916, -0.017225725576281548, -0.003198478603735566, -0.03396429866552353, -0.060939762741327286, 0.010912665165960789, -0.016129303723573685, 0.033532142639160156, 0.0031467112712562084, 0.017529455944895744, -0.03770921006798744, -0.02933344617486, 0.024198485538363457, 0.06724101305007935, -0.018455835059285164, -0.00322609581053257, -0.020196188241243362, -0.016129931434988976, 0.026833757758140564, 0.012876863591372967, -0.025361452251672745, -0.061930879950523376, -0.020618468523025513, -0.01666475459933281, 0.027109574526548386, -0.021826529875397682, -0.010833523236215115, -0.008218182250857353, 0.020893044769763947, -0.01712271198630333, 0.01419887412339449, -0.005953439511358738, -0.018673140555620193, 0.011951275169849396, -0.062276970595121384, 0.07933378219604492, -0.016423286870121956, -0.03297745808959007, -0.03586817532777786, 0.016367962583899498, -0.04751252755522728, 0.009718070738017559, 0.023129718378186226, 0.009878400713205338, 0.00753809092566371, 0.001919279107823968, 0.030336692929267883, -0.032928112894296646, -0.06408598273992538, 0.07905414700508118, -0.026628652587532997, -0.021443292498588562, 0.004948370158672333, 0.0024359922390431166, 0.015468783676624298, 0.0003369827172718942, 0.007941358722746372, -0.008788688108325005, 0.022511424496769905, -0.006189767271280289, -0.005262333434075117, 0.05451186001300812, -0.0158572755753994, -0.036160022020339966, 0.031696636229753494, -0.013306435197591782, 0.0015375912189483643, 0.022448629140853882, 0.0039605447091162205, -0.05790003016591072, 0.039332740008831024, -0.020645394921302795, -0.018582645803689957, -0.016108430922031403, 0.048756618052721024, 0.011359969154000282, -0.047452714294195175, 0.01142781600356102, 0.024286948144435883, -0.03769776225090027, -0.005387994460761547, 0.023570986464619637, 0.06470027565956116, 0.03216535225510597, -0.008964041247963905, -0.00564565509557724, 0.0061522843316197395, -0.016526754945516586, -0.0011580854188650846, 0.019246350973844528, 0.04004389047622681, -0.006980357225984335, 0.0051367017440497875, 0.017519352957606316, -0.03952445462346077, 0.024146297946572304, 0.019468780606985092, 0.056859664618968964, -0.05394600331783295, -0.008463303558528423, -0.0010034323204308748, -0.02339274436235428, 0.04182213544845581, 0.009546380490064621, -0.02616284228861332, 0.06466349214315414, -0.017934078350663185, -0.018282674252986908, -0.026346003636717796, -0.006063222885131836, 0.001296588103286922, -0.0025599875953048468, 0.024534795433282852, 0.037364661693573, -0.010046844370663166, 0.010121898725628853, -0.014361710287630558, -0.00234719249419868, 0.019256021827459335, -0.020879080519080162, 0.03138376399874687, -0.019696766510605812, -0.0011173203820362687, -0.03479759767651558, 0.01181778684258461, -0.03791967034339905, -0.017075911164283752, 0.006552640814334154, 0.0389985553920269, 0.03038071095943451, -0.02764221467077732, -0.03548731282353401, 0.01989717222750187, 0.045105721801519394, -0.07507481426000595, -0.00566044170409441, -0.07097731530666351, -0.006579344626516104, -0.01614110916852951, 0.008097102865576744 ]
<p>I am running a structural Panel vector autoregressive model on a panel of 13 countries over the period 1970-2012. I'm having problems in implementing the model. Does anyone have estimation programs (from Matlab, Eviews, RATS or any time series package tool) so that I can use them to estimate my model? Thanks in advance.</p>
21,562
[ -0.03125970438122749, 0.004209591541439295, 0.007684210781008005, 0.021449608728289604, 0.056102462112903595, 0.008406265638768673, -0.03993920981884003, -0.010484890080988407, 0.026271091774106026, -0.04641645774245262, 0.018790097907185555, 0.06739387661218643, 0.059013497084379196, -0.0024855080991983414, 0.010857224464416504, -0.014401082880795002, -0.004896226804703474, 0.03440257906913757, -0.002906693844124675, -0.0027550174854695797, -0.0068583074025809765, 0.048121675848960876, -0.008642720058560371, -0.005512681324034929, 0.013749949634075165, 0.05639779567718506, 0.032769739627838135, 0.004486626945436001, 0.011389637365937233, 0.058945462107658386, -0.04925044625997543, -0.024392344057559967, -0.0045070955529809, 0.006267528515309095, -0.016601242125034332, -0.017913654446601868, 0.00932761374861002, -0.05070875212550163, -0.0009603648213669658, 0.02759183943271637, -0.03100796788930893, 0.02249108999967575, -0.022387810051441193, 0.02109430730342865, -0.01631806790828705, 0.017784154042601585, 0.018858900293707848, -0.03410087153315544, 0.03325109928846359, -0.003794766729697585, 0.08980485796928406, 0.01841118186712265, 0.026700863614678383, 0.021628890186548233, -0.026217080652713776, 0.015277895145118237, 0.020096462219953537, 0.04239484667778015, 0.017878660932183266, -0.0390629805624485, 0.00022399357112590224, -0.007369144819676876, 0.0026469917502254248, -0.049610406160354614, -0.023882055655121803, 0.04312693327665329, -0.03936322405934334, -0.010070474818348885, 0.04885254055261612, -0.014971566386520863, 0.008682342246174812, 0.013966728933155537, -0.0021763844415545464, -0.012372118420898914, -0.02525271661579609, -0.03758757561445236, 0.0034647504799067974, 0.024660691618919373, 0.03785199299454689, 0.022190475836396217, 0.013281762599945068, 0.026673149317502975, 0.03135833889245987, 0.05324146896600723, 0.03821854293346405, -0.006327662151306868, 0.0815824419260025, -0.03374749794602394, 0.023262865841388702, 0.0068316082470119, -0.08377181738615036, -0.004792301915585995, 0.04857777804136276, 0.04240460693836212, -0.03622918576002121, 0.0007833714480511844, -0.0005962415598332882, 0.08168566972017288, 0.01920139417052269, -0.012759032659232616, 0.008465559221804142, 0.003551318310201168, -0.011417321860790253, 0.043612509965896606, -0.009007751010358334, -0.009008224122226238, -0.015738172456622124, -0.033754706382751465, -0.004542620852589607, -0.050501178950071335, -0.031541381031274796, 0.02880876511335373, -0.018963830545544624, -0.01476374827325344, 0.03539819270372391, 0.017200926318764687, -0.006358421873301268, -0.03517633303999901, 0.040187347680330276, 0.09347771108150482, 0.03269915282726288, -0.049034930765628815, 0.020000850781798363, -0.03589710220694542, -0.09208036959171295, 0.022954661399126053, 0.0013061099452897906, -0.03688105195760727, -0.05066947266459465, 0.03439897298812866, 0.020638357847929, -0.05601031705737114, 0.06282366812229156, -0.04792921617627144, 0.06988642364740372, 0.013753853738307953, -0.03632206842303276, -0.07360196858644485, 0.03127140551805496, -0.01656421832740307, -0.0022698815446347, -0.051723770797252655, 0.011364958249032497, -0.016748301684856415, 0.07360327988862991, 0.01095758005976677, 0.07427754253149033, 0.05431494489312172, 0.03809820115566254, -0.0067318398505449295, -0.053985949605703354, -0.016195818781852722, -0.0343795008957386, -0.00925226230174303, 0.0002779626229312271, -0.06460582464933395, 0.03434859216213226, 0.005882818251848221, -0.04358547553420067, 0.0125122694298625, 0.026528948917984962, 0.052437178790569305, -0.05155447870492935, -0.020284200087189674, 0.011514808982610703, -0.023172400891780853, 0.01826365664601326, -0.03030056320130825, 0.009638217277824879, 0.0008449975284747779, -0.032460521906614304, -0.02808539941906929, 0.031117010861635208, 0.03548312932252884, 0.051200948655605316, 0.007971949875354767, -0.005492528434842825, 0.012843885459005833, 0.004032089374959469, 0.01232621818780899, -0.029874112457036972, -0.05078645423054695, 0.013704643584787846, 0.0023829336278140545, 0.030740518122911453, 0.04941374808549881, 0.004033643286675215, -0.032951291650533676, 0.008144233375787735, -0.05005475506186485, -0.045347776263952255, -0.05192684009671211, 0.012911477126181126, -0.029746266081929207, 0.015153167769312859, -0.0004375606367830187, -0.0105070685967803, 0.011470100842416286, 0.016388779506087303, -0.04641003534197807, -0.025824984535574913, -0.017054874449968338, 0.023500777781009674, -0.013435527682304382, -0.00023790064733475447, 0.013109516352415085, 0.08216583728790283, -0.029209237545728683, 0.0627179741859436, -0.03953799232840538, -0.030698953196406364, 0.02444498986005783, -0.05635805428028107, 0.003974029328674078, 0.014004409313201904, -0.011088124476373196, -0.016361471265554428, -0.00030863730353303254, -0.0070188092067837715, 0.029944848269224167, -0.00321751506999135, 0.028237249702215195, 0.07377209514379501, 0.014818331226706505, -0.020652420818805695, 0.025593673810362816, 0.032112088054418564, 0.020195938646793365, -0.050930529832839966, -0.004400832578539848, -0.052041612565517426, 0.001898270333185792, 0.055297575891017914, 0.008531968109309673, -0.06087211146950722, 0.043146148324012756, 0.03962593898177147, 0.005994320847094059, 0.018503280356526375, 0.01626683957874775, -0.004518156871199608, -0.012542341835796833, 0.000042311701690778136, 0.006263117305934429, -0.014176023192703724, -0.00007162862311815843, 0.00024912049411796033, 0.02451312728226185, 0.007995551452040672, -0.00646206084638834, -0.013041730970144272, 0.03647128865122795, -0.022236481308937073, 0.006569262128323317, -0.02813129499554634, -0.02359749563038349, 0.04576431214809418, -0.014064528048038483, 0.004936995916068554, 0.004036430735141039, 0.003120436565950513, 0.011205743998289108, 0.04126746952533722, -0.02250778302550316, 0.010485732927918434, 0.04029473662376404, -0.008532389998435974, -0.012945285066962242, 0.030580788850784302, -0.009681461378932, 0.02634010836482048, -0.03609131649136543, 0.0020669742953032255, -0.03349973261356354, 0.024620339274406433, 0.043621838092803955, -0.020147932693362236, 0.0042429170571267605, -0.015856025740504265, 0.010989808477461338, 0.056341227144002914, -0.0354718454182148, 0.02549418807029724, 0.01994466409087181, -0.023826807737350464, 0.025891844183206558, -0.021519538015127182, -0.015317839570343494, 0.038115985691547394, 0.001883027027361095, -0.017078347504138947, 0.05273430794477463, -0.029890114441514015, -0.060877300798892975, -0.019448211416602135, -0.013999360613524914, 0.02244299277663231, -0.030024385079741478, 0.0007713759550824761, -0.008744709193706512, 0.010872662998735905, -0.0007341702003031969, 0.0519104078412056, -0.07058439403772354, -0.002447666134685278, -0.03627486899495125, 0.0059920116327703, -0.027775244787335396, -0.029739558696746826, 0.00508261239156127, 0.04092390090227127, -0.005807883571833372, 0.007124295923858881, -0.056734200567007065, -0.0361487902700901, -0.009550096467137337, 0.02575850300490856, 0.008006087504327297, 0.049608856439590454, -0.01899617165327072, 0.04549491032958031, 0.004742573946714401, -0.034342315047979355, -0.032064761966466904, -0.02203570120036602, 0.010809250175952911, -0.04073317348957062, 0.04858970642089844, 0.020111557096242905, 0.011444482021033764, 0.016527516767382622, -0.03823084756731987, -0.010941999033093452, 0.05286945402622223, 0.005908578168600798, -0.004528059624135494, 0.020011231303215027, -0.01183429267257452, -0.00042912125354632735, 0.037927769124507904, -0.01889127306640148, -0.0019320605788379908, -0.01940678432583809, -0.00019752913794945925, 0.022703969851136208, 0.02440052106976509, -0.027648689225316048, 0.030878912657499313, -0.027403252199292183, -0.03355395048856735, -0.06281404197216034, 0.0071180094964802265, 0.023779084905982018, 0.0010799502488225698, -0.017032407224178314, -0.013812987133860588, -0.0021480615250766277, 0.0030700743664056063, 0.014936305582523346, 0.021597152575850487, -0.020543312653899193, -0.01125287264585495, -0.00804411992430687, -0.042785804718732834, -0.00976279005408287, 0.023638902232050896, 0.004243230912834406, -0.028823958709836006, 0.06687615066766739, 0.04176241159439087, 0.02990441769361496, -0.0047700898721814156, -0.04681392014026642, 0.002010685857385397, -0.08242829144001007, 0.01522727869451046, -0.03402460366487503, 0.06424281001091003, 0.004615652374923229, 0.0006759363459423184, 0.011424657888710499, 0.011794324964284897, 0.03324154391884804, -0.026737894862890244, -0.05292791500687599, 0.013289812952280045, -0.023895610123872757, -0.015707744285464287, 0.00819876603782177, -0.02004452422261238, 0.015604478307068348, -0.012346304021775723, -0.015826599672436714, -0.03018060326576233, 0.003817685879766941, -0.05284125730395317, -0.0046128095127642155, -0.023830775171518326, 0.01547950692474842, 0.042567431926727295, -0.011340422555804253, 0.02797483466565609, -0.059381481260061264, 0.013781783170998096, 0.0404396615922451, -0.011241413652896881, 0.008107648231089115, -0.023518921807408333, 0.015578792430460453, 0.016434283927083015, 0.0289955735206604, 0.07360420376062393, 0.01597246155142784, -0.07620058953762054, 0.013678201474249363, 0.005201939959079027, 0.049630943685770035, 0.05058233439922333, 0.00937191303819418, -0.020218821242451668, -0.02999299392104149, -0.008385790511965752, 0.009069892577826977, -0.0038674280513077974, 0.020508479326963425, 0.033764347434043884, 0.0444958321750164, 0.025648081675171852, -0.05540230870246887, -0.007338876836001873, 0.06194504722952843, 0.017868522554636, 0.008586373180150986, -0.020172860473394394, -0.010303257033228874, -0.008486023172736168, -0.016509460285305977, 0.018176723271608353, -0.009298713877797127, -0.007430925499647856, 0.042737994343042374, 0.02304883860051632, -0.016154086217284203, -0.009100958704948425, 0.03397583216428757, 0.05819174274802208, 0.051331568509340286, 0.018919972702860832, -0.04119289666414261, 0.02529388852417469, 0.04956838861107826, 0.03741864114999771, 0.04332396388053894, 0.0028573779854923487, -0.10681122541427612, 0.05114803835749626, 0.038948215544223785, 0.016149574890732765, -0.06657726317644119, -0.016096532344818115, -0.05130654200911522, -0.037758488208055496, 0.04586617648601532, -0.019940126687288284, 0.014616930857300758, -0.02558264695107937, 0.007909591309726238, -0.03259279951453209, -0.02108778804540634, -0.002704052021726966, -0.015054737217724323, -0.00800842884927988, 0.056413132697343826, -0.002281943103298545, -0.0077326372265815735, -0.026136554777622223, 0.025331629440188408, 0.0662967711687088, 0.03523240238428116, 0.00494682602584362, 0.0009605559753254056, 0.04028122127056122, 0.02701929211616516, -0.057124730199575424, -0.06169002130627632, -0.0021405271254479885, 0.015040351077914238, -0.0018266509287059307, 0.04919441044330597, 0.0048448736779391766, -0.026471830904483795, 0.018779559060931206, 0.004427484702318907, 0.015469559468328953, -0.020835524424910545, -0.029627138748764992, 0.034037571400403976, 0.006411862559616566, -0.0019058346515521407, 0.03938860818743706, 0.04169026389718056, -0.017312582582235336, 0.03055441565811634, -0.02424422651529312, 0.00979922991245985, -0.044731758534908295, -0.019460054114460945, -0.03059682995080948, -0.023844731971621513, -0.0021502976305782795, 0.00783885084092617, 0.01931515336036682, 0.044441644102334976, -0.0556672029197216, 0.008170993067324162, -0.018231144174933434, 0.04583605006337166, -0.019322574138641357, -0.0031651025637984276, -0.0006727012805640697, 0.03400189429521561, -0.017048146575689316, -0.037754692137241364, -0.004684558603912592, -0.030743172392249107, -0.039959270507097244, -0.003133626189082861, -0.02339961938560009, 0.004743274301290512, -0.029525941237807274, -0.04449915140867233, 0.038784269243478775, -0.025741908699274063, 0.057316794991493225, -0.058900754898786545, -0.0002331293362658471, -0.0010556469205766916, -0.05571603402495384, -0.009868647903203964, 0.03288372978568077, 0.00241551804356277, 0.03458430990576744, -0.012836876325309277, 0.035041142255067825, -0.010766717605292797, -0.040686678141355515, -0.06756621599197388, -0.05028364807367325, 0.03108672797679901, 0.006730618420988321, -0.05866285413503647, -0.028274565935134888, 0.044987790286540985, -0.021329032257199287, 0.006515352055430412, -0.02158335968852043, 0.020076848566532135, -0.009839586913585663, 0.002076720353215933, -0.02182047627866268, 0.030026553198695183, 0.022638030350208282, 0.012698384933173656, 0.010631932877004147, 0.03055649623274803, -0.04903857782483101, -0.03835535794496536, -0.03934980183839798, 0.0005768985720351338, -0.02322869561612606, 0.025919996201992035, -0.022819900885224342, 0.0027422928251326084, 0.03167542442679405, -0.012122509069740772, 0.03606519103050232, 0.052756041288375854, -0.005984336603432894, -0.019145075231790543, -0.03933238238096237, 0.03182782232761383, -0.031799569725990295, -0.027674267068505287, -0.016389479860663414, 0.0011806389084085822, -0.03334973379969597, -0.006220993120223284, 0.060536473989486694, -0.0369204543530941, -0.028189750388264656, 0.01353746373206377, 0.04708344489336014, 0.009209641255438328, 0.0026908039581030607, 0.008822406642138958, 0.001178136095404625, 0.03200407326221466, -0.014358232729136944, 0.003022328484803438, -0.004954949487000704, 0.018119217827916145, -0.02452763170003891, -0.050174616277217865, -0.028434906154870987, 0.01318489108234644, 0.06194189190864563, -0.006845081690698862, 0.04103570058941841, 0.027311282232403755, 0.021582700312137604, -0.002351734321564436, -0.03708174079656601, -0.030672239139676094, 0.024800751358270645, -0.00373506685718894, 0.0631537139415741, -0.0234919935464859, -0.0035689875949174166, 0.0016479359474033117, 0.03211832791566849, 0.0344715379178524, 0.06768401712179184, 0.014593316242098808, 0.05355648696422577, 0.001365747768431902, -0.03526347130537033, -0.043424274772405624, 0.003277279669418931, -0.004921501036733389, 0.025196965783834457, -0.0616365447640419, -0.03821420297026634, 0.013674421235918999, 0.04895094409584999, 0.016709523275494576, -0.04930659383535385, -0.007243211846798658, -0.02170672081410885, 0.015640070661902428, 0.025706538930535316, -0.006758623290807009, 0.0031674515921622515, 0.0366695262491703, 0.03220418095588684, 0.014416049234569073, 0.0569390133023262, -0.02781934291124344, -0.0846635028719902, -0.017522141337394714, -0.038078200072050095, -0.020314199849963188, 0.04370247200131416, 0.010100523009896278, -0.023645585402846336, 0.01553498487919569, -0.0196726955473423, -0.010997511446475983, -0.017539922147989273, 0.04119560867547989, 0.013280881568789482, 0.07287845015525818, -0.030390983447432518, 0.030568761751055717, -0.001182634849101305, 0.002506530610844493, 0.11444201320409775, 0.07742933183908463, 0.03734046220779419, -0.06917749345302582, 0.013515605591237545, 0.0033406303264200687, -0.024803422391414642, -0.03645888343453407, 0.014495136216282845, -0.000754857319407165, -0.038049813359975815, 0.019926801323890686, 0.07761787623167038, 0.016831031069159508, 0.029877863824367523, 0.024183161556720734, -0.024360155686736107, -0.01229281909763813, -0.006874771788716316, 0.03856336325407028, 0.017955143004655838, -0.004304494708776474, -0.0737372487783432, 0.019994506612420082, -0.023104624822735786, -0.04902834817767143, -0.021251114085316658, -0.026182884350419044, 0.02182743139564991, -0.01367444172501564, -0.03200692683458328, 0.007731741759926081, 0.025558315217494965, 0.035137902945280075, -0.001475103897973895, -0.0038727798964828253, 0.0050987000577151775, -0.0194708202034235, 0.04418792575597763, 0.011017021723091602, -0.005196991842240095, -0.0022373246029019356, -0.012891444377601147, -0.024228431284427643, -0.06091770529747009, -0.02922661416232586, -0.01730668544769287, 0.040694158524274826, 0.02616472728550434, -0.010080534033477306, -0.009269068017601967, 0.023189404979348183, 0.015364665538072586, -0.020045533776283264, -0.01269947923719883, -0.028151769191026688, 0.013029289431869984, -0.04586637392640114, 0.01579892449080944, -0.03938308358192444, -0.01993652619421482, -0.02130737714469433, 0.029745765030384064, 0.012268566526472569, -0.06619250774383545, 0.017387937754392624, -0.01974727027118206, 0.04912007600069046, -0.02646023966372013, -0.043945904821157455, 0.020168738439679146, -0.020653437823057175, -0.011906282976269722, -0.03475189954042435, 0.04556002840399742, 0.046036798506975174, 0.011673210188746452, -0.02409704215824604, 0.029184777289628983, -0.0005526714958250523, -0.04763617739081383, 0.01472074817866087, -0.0596107579767704, -0.022216584533452988, -0.01738131418824196, 0.017097214236855507, 0.047996148467063904, 0.01944967359304428, -0.015187413431704044, 0.019075822085142136, -0.02681446075439453, 0.017514027655124664, 0.001421652385033667, -0.06832310557365417, 0.0007825231296010315, -0.0342753529548645, -0.025904078036546707, 0.010234192945063114, -0.0179731547832489, 0.03060639090836048, 0.029506536200642586, -0.004633511882275343, -0.0214654840528965, 0.04708049073815346, -0.008185778744518757, -0.00640946114435792, -0.0009251984301954508, -0.08589981496334076, -0.0006390513735823333, -0.024956481531262398, -0.0007365364581346512, -0.04803304001688957, -0.001233398332260549, -0.025290563702583313, -0.00008054284262470901, -0.013597722165286541, -0.019516531378030777, -0.06406563520431519, 0.027263661846518517, -0.016638558357954025, 0.03144456073641777, -0.03735979646444321, 0.01637091487646103, -0.01518768910318613, 0.002391587244346738, -0.020133277401328087, 0.010905412025749683, -0.037384986877441406, 0.01898794434964657, -0.03286610171198845, 0.0118065495043993, 0.02382574789226055, 0.022418512031435966, 0.025714069604873657, 0.015982188284397125, 0.01444066409021616, -0.02239563874900341, 0.0739162340760231, -0.007840149104595184, -0.050448037683963776, 0.0016099571948871017, -0.03783081844449043, -0.020144343376159668, 0.01611286774277687, 0.0064573693089187145, 0.038730476051568985, 0.02688535302877426, -0.004606197122484446, -0.015457726083695889, 0.04249024763703346, -0.013291878625750542, 0.013939973898231983, 0.00019475186127237976, 0.03692738711833954, -0.012367529794573784, 0.02288658730685711, 0.007113213185220957, 0.047533608973026276, -0.032158445566892624, 0.04050988331437111, 0.05975991114974022, -0.013979937881231308, -0.0071671511977910995, 0.011666919104754925, 0.0005662703770212829, 0.023395609110593796, 0.008201345801353455, -0.007131931371986866, 0.03426722064614296, 0.013327660039067268, 0.00032060351804830134, 0.013087798841297626, 0.0023642887827008963, 0.022398481145501137, -0.020902780815958977, 0.01717572659254074, -0.025780057534575462, 0.0027859250549227, 0.04206416755914688, -0.05001676082611084, 0.016636313870549202, 0.020982518792152405, -0.053235456347465515, 0.0074109709821641445, -0.004833629820495844, -0.011489304713904858, -0.029174042865633965, 0.0030043600127100945, 0.012489967979490757, 0.03731703385710716, 0.01884732022881508, -0.001178503385744989, 0.03684043139219284, 0.03226673603057861, 0.01166731771081686, -0.04847314953804016, -0.016337817534804344, -0.008713491261005402, 0.046555910259485245, -0.04854384437203407, 0.0187467522919178, -0.04702375456690788, -0.04113581031560898, 0.018872186541557312, -0.020534906536340714, 0.04153979569673538, 0.026148268952965736, 0.014299972914159298, -0.023359639570116997, 0.07458347082138062, 0.018284177407622337, 0.004159186966717243, 0.04105322062969208, -0.02547120489180088, -0.020734397694468498, -0.004239035304635763, -0.009967312216758728, 0.05001338571310043, -0.01490865834057331, 0.01841936632990837, 0.0026641106233000755, -0.025608409196138382, 0.00013256714737508446, -0.0021800901740789413, -0.010334883816540241, -0.021593306213617325, 0.009090052917599678, -0.0033568129874765873, 0.03397830203175545, -0.026769418269395828, 0.00974496640264988, 0.022458544000983238, 0.00804203562438488, -0.021203655749559402, 0.007585376035422087, 0.0010053942678496242, -0.01297813281416893, 0.019927090033888817, -0.0001327806239714846, -0.001413178164511919, -0.050190508365631104, -0.026716165244579315, 0.034827008843421936, -0.016212400048971176, -0.047509949654340744, 0.01811336725950241, -0.005252373870462179, 0.04401654377579689, -0.019246911630034447, -0.007120208349078894, 0.026098450645804405, -0.017230136319994926, 0.03760039433836937, -0.0467040054500103, 0.04659372568130493, -0.005237847566604614, -0.027395805343985558, 0.016898659989237785, -0.006594900041818619, -0.008064652793109417, -0.012221756391227245, 0.017652474343776703, -0.03817444667220116, 0.016719697043299675, 0.010320787318050861, 0.016120582818984985, 0.020722609013319016, -0.016088416799902916, 0.07313203066587448, -0.02292182669043541, -0.04643075540661812, 0.008906714618206024, -0.021124217659235, 0.009272732771933079, -0.012213358655571938, 0.026432543992996216, -0.02455437369644642, -0.03301205113530159, 0.025799322873353958, -0.018545793369412422, 0.0020426963455975056, 0.0197110828012228, 0.001359553774818778, 0.0642610490322113, -0.020308949053287506, 0.003306223079562187, 0.03212730959057808, 0.013416199013590813, -0.026259895414114, 0.022121792659163475, -0.03399885073304176, -0.024932878091931343, -0.0008623281610198319, -0.01285354420542717, -0.0034270258620381355, -0.07279373705387115, -0.0117808161303401, 0.00849587470293045, -0.01728587970137596, 0.003226332366466522, 0.07051250338554382, 0.001961552770808339, 0.01416176650673151, -0.002020494546741247, 0.03638868033885956, 0.018946601077914238, 0.04763925075531006, 0.007530593778938055, 0.03469189628958702, 0.043131958693265915, 0.029015975072979927, 0.01488420832902193, 0.023926375433802605, -0.03479563817381859, 0.03770090639591217, -0.039382919669151306, 0.013415491208434105, -0.034982889890670776, -0.05112232267856598, 0.008159271441400051, 0.008903859183192253, 0.018706900998950005, 0.010289323516190052, -0.020215241238474846, 0.07940896600484848, -0.03458913043141365, 0.0014913503546267748, -0.00771642429754138, -0.017114942893385887, -0.04406418651342392, 0.0036338719073683023, -0.006922846660017967, -0.0018013289663940668, -0.015110885724425316, 0.027169568464159966, -0.006641087122261524, -0.017730096355080605, 0.01567268557846546, -0.03804440051317215, -0.0030737838242202997, -0.01927272602915764, 0.0032647624611854553, -0.01810217648744583, -0.02449965476989746, -0.026280265301465988, 0.015450509265065193, 0.05814187973737717, 0.03819417208433151, 0.005678500048816204, -0.06478066742420197, -0.006559760309755802, -0.0004904086235910654, 0.020490998402237892, -0.06106758490204811, -0.017420483753085136, -0.019411247223615646, -0.009898464195430279, -0.029125740751624107, 0.022374361753463745 ]
<p>When analyzing data, using MLE or Bayesian methods, one needs to assume a distribution for the data. For continuous data the are a number of distributions that are often considered, for example, the normal distribution, the t-distribution, the log-normal, etc.</p> <p><strong>When analyzing the distribution of the SDs of a number of groups (or participants) what distributions could be appropriate?</strong> Of course this is dependent on the data, and varies from case to case, but what could be some reasonable distributions to try?</p>
42,522
[ -0.029605044052004814, -0.009657461196184158, 0.02286464534699917, -0.04467812553048134, 0.043303217738866806, 0.041944731026887894, 0.004206922370940447, -0.03162919729948044, 0.0034012733958661556, -0.04526355490088463, 0.05380241572856903, 0.025486990809440613, 0.027403388172388077, 0.002662057988345623, 0.04608801752328873, -0.024095647037029266, 0.01694481447339058, -0.007831496186554432, -0.038565900176763535, 0.008098992519080639, 0.0226758923381567, 0.008774527348577976, 0.00033106133923865855, -0.027912143617868423, -0.06412147730588913, 0.034911878407001495, 0.013011833652853966, -0.008699781261384487, 0.011361057870090008, 0.06612854450941086, -0.054986171424388885, -0.0011825551046058536, -0.034436047077178955, 0.03221593424677849, -0.02298167534172535, -0.02458077110350132, -0.05277976393699646, -0.04112814739346504, -0.025198781862854958, 0.049308981746435165, -0.04683304205536842, 0.032969601452350616, 0.016398688778281212, 0.023393047973513603, -0.044984716922044754, 0.016289139166474342, 0.01003822311758995, -0.06846239417791367, 0.0023923334665596485, -0.04167259857058525, 0.06289179623126984, -0.010289080440998077, 0.02001533843576908, 0.031135356053709984, -0.05145149677991867, -0.012843250297009945, 0.03006930649280548, 0.06568388640880585, 0.015605027787387371, -0.056066907942295074, 0.003865915583446622, -0.009103410877287388, 0.006805173121392727, -0.03741069883108139, 0.012976519763469696, 0.042874351143836975, -0.02285521849989891, -0.015272596850991249, 0.023814184591174126, 0.0016970305005088449, 0.04539221152663231, 0.03130752220749855, 0.021724140271544456, 0.02111242711544037, 0.028347235172986984, 0.0013319039717316628, 0.026623891666531563, 0.042041171342134476, 0.0592525377869606, 0.04046006500720978, 0.01078245509415865, -0.00877787172794342, 0.039485543966293335, 0.01671360246837139, -0.0014702901244163513, -0.04362005740404129, 0.07445864379405975, -0.018378300592303276, 0.0011489837197586894, -0.021212201565504074, -0.03318877890706062, 0.01958324760198593, 0.02503616362810135, -0.005723211914300919, -0.05171267315745354, 0.03578709438443184, -0.02277577668428421, 0.03674422949552536, -0.017157429829239845, -0.018024172633886337, -0.0043936120346188545, -0.03627932444214821, 0.0026503154076635838, 0.04663555696606636, -0.03899073600769043, 0.00684064207598567, -0.03716355934739113, 0.011165428906679153, -0.024489546194672585, -0.03635820746421814, -0.011229573749005795, 0.036543361842632294, 0.01628280058503151, 0.027617596089839935, 0.03267263248562813, 0.004309033043682575, -0.005064220167696476, -0.01905873604118824, 0.056863345205783844, 0.04607414826750755, 0.031922198832035065, -0.020709972828626633, 0.020453205332159996, 0.012839666567742825, -0.030278611928224564, 0.04127461090683937, 0.009252847172319889, 0.005857717711478472, -0.05517377704381943, 0.03678911179304123, 0.002909519709646702, -0.031084202229976654, 0.059293415397405624, -0.02089419960975647, -0.011018767021596432, -0.009410284459590912, -0.05491448566317558, -0.05262342095375061, 0.022374777123332024, -0.023872224614024162, -0.0066427490673959255, -0.034233491867780685, -0.04305308312177658, 0.030470218509435654, 0.016246113926172256, -0.03808962553739548, 0.056199949234724045, -0.0022735637612640858, 0.04355670139193535, -0.024721313267946243, -0.02471139468252659, -0.009444055147469044, -0.0464140921831131, 0.010528516955673695, -0.007871044799685478, -0.08398306369781494, 0.030236922204494476, 0.015645405277609825, 0.015075934119522572, 0.0042975228279829025, 0.02371050976216793, -0.013096346519887447, -0.021801156923174858, -0.01009068451821804, 0.04220115393400192, 0.0035279844887554646, 0.0478215254843235, 0.026818718761205673, 0.04517457261681557, 0.024844449013471603, 0.0030065805185586214, 0.04148106649518013, -0.0050224787555634975, 0.07411119341850281, 0.04226059094071388, -0.02779219299554825, 0.006161896977573633, 0.01945403777062893, 0.02299741841852665, 0.010140733793377876, -0.03413521870970726, -0.01578367128968239, -0.025475217029452324, -0.014688150957226753, -0.005153141915798187, 0.03162110596895218, 0.03347007557749748, -0.01996099203824997, 0.00898259598761797, -0.06137600168585777, -0.0686287209391594, -0.0749666690826416, 0.016563456505537033, -0.017670534551143646, -0.02074756659567356, 0.05857802554965019, 0.02148822881281376, 0.014842640608549118, -0.030999120324850082, -0.009585139341652393, -0.02330312691628933, -0.016479548066854477, 0.02168963849544525, -0.0356571227312088, -0.012990335933864117, 0.0710633397102356, 0.024449048563838005, -0.03103780560195446, 0.015193002298474312, -0.018569793552160263, -0.05699534714221954, -0.01883041299879551, -0.048927418887615204, 0.04021136835217476, 0.014668824151158333, -0.021757490932941437, 0.0017182924784719944, -0.004701294470578432, -0.036132536828517914, 0.00691404240205884, -0.060933295637369156, 0.04153480753302574, 0.06830793619155884, -0.020199259743094444, -0.020257802680134773, 0.05040690675377846, 0.001351004815660417, -0.019301237538456917, -0.010145879350602627, 0.010400226339697838, -0.07077842205762863, 0.00228094682097435, 0.045145731419324875, 0.013718399219214916, -0.04494040459394455, 0.010378190316259861, 0.047038257122039795, 0.044278185814619064, 0.012322482652962208, -0.011712963692843914, -0.030511347576975822, -0.043615084141492844, 0.010954140685498714, -0.03023943118751049, 0.0182564165443182, -0.0069500841200351715, -0.0016134707257151604, 0.004891830030828714, 0.002748446073383093, -0.017270881682634354, 0.0009026851039379835, 0.026903409510850906, -0.0028138644993305206, 0.010225403122603893, -0.018363749608397484, -0.038990285247564316, 0.022956915199756622, -0.02148616872727871, 0.018502172082662582, 0.008537630550563335, 0.011247457005083561, -0.018799059092998505, 0.016759401187300682, -0.032743681222200394, -0.003991908393800259, 0.04339451715350151, 0.011071496643126011, 0.007703455630689859, 0.021647589281201363, -0.04450537636876106, -0.0014893668703734875, -0.004973192233592272, -0.06342343986034393, -0.018374120816588402, 0.03273414820432663, 0.028652746230363846, -0.0051534222438931465, 0.012007397599518299, -0.005029619205743074, -0.03344348073005676, 0.0024581640027463436, 0.011674660257995129, 0.009897799231112003, 0.023240316659212112, -0.06475875526666641, -0.0176595076918602, -0.022997306659817696, -0.06070723012089729, 0.0226872768253088, 0.0025449369568377733, -0.01569010317325592, 0.012783617712557316, -0.006601852364838123, -0.04472356662154198, -0.025170424953103065, -0.00581844849511981, -0.0005961649585515261, -0.021028032526373863, -0.02863864228129387, 0.05397237092256546, 0.00006489630322903395, -0.006477304268628359, 0.03232649713754654, -0.0421626903116703, -0.04178095981478691, -0.029068682342767715, 0.010354798287153244, 0.004361006431281567, 0.04360911250114441, 0.03264852613210678, 0.029070112854242325, -0.02855863980948925, -0.009955464862287045, -0.07721291482448578, -0.06127115711569786, 0.014849599450826645, -0.008280623704195023, 0.02999599277973175, 0.01313682273030281, -0.013496864587068558, 0.07760193943977356, 0.028705889359116554, 0.0005797752528451383, 0.021535567939281464, -0.012302527204155922, -0.03740464895963669, -0.00638476200401783, 0.04747285321354866, 0.0011415354674682021, -0.010278687812387943, 0.03390051797032356, -0.01789327710866928, 0.01641409657895565, 0.058891747146844864, -0.03414110094308853, -0.03318014740943909, 0.030864479020237923, 0.0009707892895676196, -0.02083524502813816, 0.022468771785497665, 0.010448629967868328, -0.012903166934847832, 0.024040162563323975, -0.007632540073245764, 0.01921619102358818, 0.021644525229930878, -0.05715775489807129, 0.012396830134093761, -0.008013920858502388, 0.004037218168377876, -0.05968856066465378, 0.03315367549657822, 0.022616541013121605, -0.040838226675987244, 0.020631665363907814, 0.016236718744039536, -0.012024607509374619, -0.0233242679387331, 0.01857663318514824, 0.023388996720314026, 0.06028531491756439, -0.0005591382505372167, -0.08322520554065704, -0.04517185315489769, -0.011490663513541222, 0.014893175102770329, -0.016131967306137085, -0.010016120038926601, 0.006924035493284464, 0.030157528817653656, 0.032017335295677185, -0.03689972311258316, -0.046168867498636246, 0.0016714704688638449, -0.10868532210588455, 0.01799512840807438, -0.006339272949844599, 0.06022924557328224, -0.01465112715959549, 0.019835565239191055, 0.02533009462058544, 0.0039206077344715595, 0.023431846871972084, 0.006817101500928402, -0.05021614581346512, 0.03274838998913765, 0.011488917283713818, 0.023574456572532654, 0.0064648473635315895, -0.01943437196314335, 0.0749533623456955, -0.02579108253121376, 0.021862134337425232, -0.0003841098223347217, 0.03217395767569542, -0.008599096909165382, -0.03320430964231491, -0.017868250608444214, -0.04557700455188751, 0.011919341050088406, 0.0024852652568370104, -0.006600142456591129, 0.0006014813552610576, 0.018466459587216377, 0.054905619472265244, 0.0021971387322992086, -0.012285512872040272, -0.023605354130268097, 0.002786212367936969, 0.0006136095034889877, 0.048959895968437195, 0.004397904500365257, 0.010332941077649593, -0.018710436299443245, 0.040287356823682785, -0.018214797601103783, 0.08170914649963379, 0.06528767198324203, -0.019183378666639328, 0.005381184630095959, -0.06213033199310303, -0.0075234523974359035, 0.004842023365199566, 0.004488509614020586, 0.001507835928350687, -0.02584002912044525, 0.04412277415394783, 0.03851781412959099, -0.07362107187509537, 0.030745457857847214, 0.04281388968229294, 0.017289139330387115, -0.03998300060629845, -0.0009133592830039561, 0.00992592889815569, -0.012509350664913654, -0.0013450260739773512, 0.0033768003340810537, 0.030253823846578598, -0.009691194631159306, 0.03524333983659744, 0.05062960833311081, -0.015212357975542545, -0.06917301565408707, 0.000056849759857868776, 0.004379705525934696, 0.02297738380730152, 0.04653589427471161, -0.029869306832551956, 0.028299683704972267, 0.022320780903100967, 0.030858758836984634, 0.0373007170855999, 0.0026296426076442003, -0.07085943967103958, 0.02515724115073681, 0.06174599006772041, 0.04132094234228134, -0.030470235273241997, 0.01168516743928194, -0.035103823989629745, 0.025993816554546356, 0.03844146803021431, -0.036000385880470276, -0.007986838929355145, 0.0005672230618074536, 0.020355138927698135, -0.021974189206957817, -0.02417599782347679, -0.0446125827729702, 0.004460495430976152, 0.013217853382229805, 0.043130356818437576, -0.01915753073990345, 0.011642182245850563, -0.04843681678175926, 0.015095865353941917, 0.011748227290809155, 0.05641718581318855, -0.00612500449642539, -0.030115827918052673, 0.008830159902572632, 0.037785355001688004, -0.00896589457988739, -0.0655902624130249, 0.030201591551303864, 0.011418202891945839, 0.0036800887901335955, 0.05351634323596954, -0.012616047635674477, -0.05917222425341606, 0.004135328810662031, -0.0007385502103716135, 0.004114515148103237, -0.0007430138066411018, -0.024568362161517143, 0.026906238868832588, 0.040367886424064636, 0.02675352804362774, 0.031838688999414444, 0.0037248735316097736, 0.014432131312787533, 0.00517250644043088, -0.04338451847434044, 0.005771127063781023, -0.04568749666213989, -0.00015493419778067619, -0.033627353608608246, -0.024318374693393707, -0.005531627219170332, 0.009839814156293869, 0.011862458661198616, 0.041516996920108795, 0.008182061836123466, -0.04698050022125244, 0.013210409320890903, 0.0058425553143024445, 0.026990611106157303, 0.023809587582945824, 0.013879816047847271, 0.02187451720237732, -0.004845999646931887, 0.0012407803442329168, 0.03410777077078819, -0.009157445281744003, 0.024426093325018883, -0.009236049838364124, -0.049404170364141464, 0.006137963384389877, -0.033250536769628525, -0.02239498868584633, 0.048213113099336624, -0.03598067909479141, 0.05414942279458046, 0.017526470124721527, 0.06263994425535202, 0.00434429757297039, -0.013690761290490627, -0.018299201503396034, 0.030350403860211372, -0.015231966972351074, 0.056221213191747665, -0.057702917605638504, 0.051263436675071716, -0.010483479127287865, 0.013924118131399155, -0.08898882567882538, -0.023162802681326866, 0.01827327348291874, 0.01403457298874855, -0.02873578853905201, -0.0492488257586956, 0.06166660413146019, -0.030096491798758507, -0.018169941380620003, -0.013837888836860657, 0.0664886012673378, 0.008841144852340221, -0.033508576452732086, -0.029630055651068687, 0.0005786237306892872, 0.11239934712648392, -0.01637716218829155, -0.007741405628621578, 0.04473758488893509, -0.025734489783644676, -0.006512567866593599, -0.023348039016127586, 0.011089909821748734, -0.02522529661655426, -0.006643560715019703, -0.014439262449741364, 0.026082240045070648, 0.03744371607899666, -0.039306074380874634, 0.004754253197461367, 0.035370130091905594, 0.006616279017180204, -0.013711577281355858, 0.0024604271166026592, 0.045531466603279114, -0.03894827887415886, -0.023812204599380493, -0.027214277535676956, -0.002770937280729413, 0.003402185859158635, 0.016405653208494186, 0.04009938985109329, 0.0028347871266305447, -0.0543317012488842, 0.04114039987325668, 0.05700667202472687, -0.023881306871771812, -0.007387851364910603, -0.0011943642748519778, 0.0013208460295572877, 0.08411473780870438, -0.018688883632421494, -0.016781693324446678, 0.016808006912469864, 0.023518988862633705, -0.019480643793940544, -0.023328207433223724, -0.022426461800932884, -0.01612117514014244, 0.01608826406300068, -0.00888058077543974, 0.019354326650500298, 0.056625425815582275, -0.01817275956273079, -0.004246511496603489, -0.04075396806001663, 0.013511152938008308, -0.028879914432764053, -0.0078002531081438065, 0.02890944480895996, -0.01630583219230175, 0.015691321343183517, -0.0033135488629341125, -0.0034594491589814425, 0.00598057871684432, 0.020078161731362343, -0.016584841534495354, 0.0014454048359766603, 0.049408040940761566, -0.051376815885305405, -0.05481667071580887, 0.05184169486165047, -0.05320106819272041, 0.015737587586045265, -0.042363304644823074, -0.023901179432868958, 0.05550919473171234, 0.005941929295659065, 0.03311460092663765, -0.0011037577642127872, 0.026687387377023697, -0.015477209351956844, 0.013222761452198029, 0.04170842096209526, 0.007285821717232466, 0.038064952939748764, -0.01917358674108982, 0.05696787312626839, -0.019345415756106377, 0.040470611304044724, -0.02128547430038452, -0.07594824582338333, -0.046183787286281586, -0.018891122192144394, -0.03223970904946327, 0.00541049987077713, -0.013353150337934494, -0.00009440375288249925, -0.011021535843610764, -0.0538257472217083, 0.01968713477253914, 0.02901589311659336, 0.027563374489545822, 0.008645636960864067, 0.08069340139627457, -0.01768246479332447, 0.035169873386621475, -0.02117297239601612, -0.038661617785692215, 0.11224682629108429, 0.08560427278280258, 0.04201585799455643, -0.04474784806370735, 0.010861781425774097, -0.009193986654281616, -0.012843340635299683, 0.01066516526043415, 0.009110357612371445, 0.003387199714779854, 0.0247283186763525, 0.006401726510375738, 0.030097365379333496, -0.004425358958542347, -0.011997202411293983, 0.051036953926086426, -0.025609640404582024, -0.019029531627893448, 0.03919956460595131, 0.013607937842607498, -0.015851803123950958, -0.0029419907368719578, -0.05382538586854935, 0.01655079983174801, 0.03533904254436493, -0.011980386450886726, -0.004819510970264673, -0.029732663184404373, -0.019665993750095367, 0.008345422334969044, 0.007863684557378292, -0.02450239099562168, 0.05328002944588661, 0.010024413466453552, -0.006853977218270302, -0.04157976061105728, -0.0159761905670166, -0.06866853684186935, 0.018578391522169113, 0.04467957466840744, -0.004231472034007311, -0.023708174005150795, -0.008420838043093681, 0.013872519135475159, -0.026212699711322784, -0.03891182690858841, -0.02264438383281231, 0.0322829969227314, -0.012569704093039036, -0.005582776851952076, -0.03222045302391052, 0.03351598232984543, 0.0030881164129823446, -0.04120790213346481, 0.006667491514235735, 0.004652153700590134, 0.04960786551237106, -0.03130204975605011, -0.03527318313717842, -0.03793824091553688, 0.016176488250494003, -0.014140095561742783, 0.009288305416703224, 0.019278904423117638, -0.024397360160946846, -0.051170919090509415, -0.015008894726634026, 0.04202713072299957, -0.010212475433945656, 0.001275806687772274, -0.005653143860399723, -0.009445575065910816, -0.029493825510144234, 0.04837847501039505, 0.005414591636508703, 0.008712299168109894, 0.012914973311126232, -0.003744932822883129, 0.025389384478330612, -0.028020022436976433, -0.05322840437293053, 0.03642510250210762, -0.05700308457016945, -0.004934465512633324, -0.030217424035072327, 0.004933674354106188, 0.006447548512369394, 0.03897276893258095, 0.022391026839613914, 0.013413325883448124, -0.005682098679244518, 0.033530429005622864, 0.01323420275002718, -0.03802475705742836, -0.009316515177488327, -0.027583135291934013, -0.02263917215168476, -0.007669810205698013, 0.0035022469237446785, 0.06032277271151543, 0.008273102343082428, 0.0021022388245910406, -0.020561348646879196, 0.0066492208279669285, 0.03275229036808014, -0.011055462062358856, -0.007038949057459831, -0.060424692928791046, -0.018328096717596054, 0.022233085706830025, -0.022677583619952202, -0.026725048199295998, 0.008992207236588001, -0.0199904665350914, -0.007730135228484869, 0.0008267048397101462, -0.004724164493381977, -0.026896851137280464, 0.021827707067131996, -0.02284720540046692, 0.01698721945285797, 0.01987285725772381, 0.009202029556035995, 0.006155879236757755, -0.022792324423789978, -0.03411401808261871, 0.000239767789025791, -0.02950461022555828, 0.0049751210026443005, 0.0016547059640288353, -0.008855613879859447, 0.01971898414194584, -0.02241002395749092, 0.03753695264458656, -0.00453063054010272, 0.004391973838210106, -0.025092408061027527, 0.020652972161769867, 0.018473824486136436, -0.012510258704423904, 0.037267278879880905, -0.02952319011092186, -0.01743929646909237, 0.0014105790760368109, 0.004244760610163212, 0.035437993705272675, 0.003580253105610609, 0.028970180079340935, -0.011850999668240547, 0.004372323397547007, -0.06261292845010757, -0.013427047058939934, 0.011328685097396374, -0.006582141853868961, 0.018486715853214264, 0.001613181782886386, 0.027206983417272568, 0.03639600798487663, -0.020844900980591774, 0.01011913362890482, -0.003672810271382332, -0.011820128187537193, 0.006471405737102032, 0.014080205000936985, -0.01963801309466362, 0.02371697872877121, -0.011683839373290539, 0.0014355153543874621, 0.0561017245054245, 0.049528710544109344, -0.012737394310534, 0.005585172679275274, -0.0014922599075362086, -0.0051901028491556644, -0.07265884429216385, -0.032215554267168045, 0.0626557320356369, -0.002706303494051099, 0.030562879517674446, -0.06592677533626556, -0.017691440880298615, 0.061650119721889496, -0.05805378407239914, 0.01597084291279316, -0.019051970914006233, -0.014180295169353485, -0.037806861102581024, 0.024489751085639, -0.02689460851252079, 0.056086547672748566, -0.010942494496703148, 0.027721144258975983, 0.02552042528986931, 0.0166777390986681, 0.03717506304383278, 0.0020849858410656452, -0.02407274767756462, 0.023453719913959503, 0.03642347455024719, -0.04560733214020729, 0.019938325509428978, -0.06264056265354156, -0.03521296754479408, 0.04689175635576248, 0.03536491096019745, 0.045573316514492035, 0.023237576708197594, 0.01650199107825756, 0.007214507088065147, 0.05302707850933075, 0.03730599954724312, -0.024649426341056824, -0.02560712955892086, 0.010646717622876167, 0.016120335087180138, 0.053295381367206573, -0.008268850855529308, -0.0034106015227735043, 0.03567853197455406, -0.03227092698216438, 0.0077423169277608395, 0.03787437453866005, 0.003410589648410678, -0.06347107142210007, -0.0014278859598562121, -0.033622678369283676, 0.03206920996308327, -0.007111715618520975, 0.02273671142756939, -0.0517846904695034, 0.013274790719151497, 0.024668114259839058, -0.01387395802885294, -0.013615786097943783, 0.02841724082827568, -0.0367855541408062, -0.035483717918395996, 0.008223267272114754, -0.017459552735090256, -0.02384035661816597, -0.04004811495542526, 0.028301073238253593, -0.02719852328300476, -0.009957047179341316, -0.05358041077852249, 0.01915889047086239, -0.014532158151268959, 0.032251473516225815, -0.01631273701786995, 0.02076874114573002, 0.012448690831661224, -0.031974948942661285, 0.0021696153562515974, -0.060703929513692856, 0.05212544649839401, 0.014944126829504967, -0.029211707413196564, -0.024225052446126938, -0.007362118922173977, -0.02441227249801159, -0.0014127051690593362, 0.03621614724397659, 0.03409203141927719, 0.016783082857728004, 0.014677130617201328, 0.01645437441766262, 0.01011157687753439, -0.05173484981060028, 0.017517397180199623, -0.0026741065084934235, -0.025242572650313377, -0.048294324427843094, 0.010171927511692047, 0.022963782772421837, -0.01373120117932558, 0.004923474974930286, -0.03474852442741394, 0.026224490255117416, 0.027025124058127403, 0.02034715563058853, 0.03308985009789467, 0.005566002801060677, -0.03186609596014023, 0.007760326378047466, -0.02777785435318947, -0.0007408784003928304, -0.01153192762285471, -0.006710454355925322, -0.04493570327758789, 0.0000376778953068424, -0.0009807046735659242, -0.08486353605985641, 0.024989450350403786, 0.014965335838496685, -0.017490440979599953, -0.0597522035241127, -0.016979297623038292, 0.02494303323328495, -0.041310008615255356, 0.044321030378341675, 0.015621187165379524, 0.02568555250763893, 0.04985925182700157, 0.01085155550390482, 0.01658034697175026, 0.02886533923447132, 0.00970786064863205, 0.01981748268008232, 0.005495553370565176, 0.049242064356803894, 0.00876657199114561, 0.017375117167830467, 0.007529661059379578, -0.029155133292078972, 0.030244596302509308, -0.0017182239098474383, 0.026509994640946388, -0.05166812986135483, 0.024707360193133354, 0.015853289514780045, -0.004711617715656757, 0.022156288847327232, -0.008313556201756, 0.001507458626292646, 0.08207520097494125, -0.01153694186359644, -0.016722576692700386, -0.050593141466379166, -0.01762806810438633, -0.028662361204624176, 0.0056845396757125854, 0.011179819703102112, 0.0343918576836586, 0.003081468865275383, 0.030593736097216606, 0.007685704622417688, 0.019576163962483406, 0.052361853420734406, -0.027686556801199913, 0.029445242136716843, -0.00016238776152022183, -0.004290366545319557, 0.0015037818811833858, -0.014757831580936909, 0.00009337568917544559, -0.013399715535342693, 0.0011027364525943995, 0.05883476883172989, 0.03096660040318966, -0.019092099741101265, -0.017191141843795776, -0.002516738837584853, -0.00851379707455635, -0.04606344923377037, -0.0046388995833694935, -0.05876147001981735, 0.0029391879215836525, -0.008478070609271526, -0.020020324736833572 ]
<p>I have a binary outcome (success \ failure). I have 20 subjects, half of them gave 2 samples, the others just one, so I have 30 data points.</p> <p>All data points without any exceptions were success (1). So my point estimate of the success rate is clearly 100%. Now I want to calculate a CI for the success rate, mainly to see what the lower limit is, I want to be able to say that with 95% confidence the success rate is higher than....(80%, 85%, whatever comes up).</p> <p>The problem is, as you can see, is the clustering, I can't use n = 30 because I then ignore the correlation, I feel it is a waste to use n = 20. Is there a way to calculate the variance of a single sample proportion while taking into account the cluster ?</p> <p>Thanks !</p>
31,914
[ -0.04428480565547943, 0.012038744986057281, -0.014452177099883556, -0.00044423737563192844, 0.024053676053881645, -0.0027940853033214808, -0.023881996050477028, -0.01681993529200554, -0.0010346786584705114, -0.020074205473065376, 0.03136605769395828, 0.04554203897714615, 0.06487032771110535, 0.04448734223842621, -0.012369725853204727, 0.008764768950641155, -0.03705917298793793, 0.005276691168546677, -0.0034442199394106865, -0.015965407714247704, -0.01484566181898117, -0.0012155271833762527, -0.005881014280021191, 0.010075618512928486, -0.0343346931040287, 0.014063644222915173, 0.03190220147371292, -0.021928925067186356, 0.002082264283671975, 0.050536055117845535, -0.0572025403380394, -0.05808491259813309, 0.026298832148313522, 0.026065988466143608, 0.02136976458132267, -0.011065958999097347, -0.03987455368041992, -0.0328323133289814, -0.003058559726923704, 0.008669105358421803, -0.05647120997309685, -0.016295205801725388, -0.013306708075106144, 0.008471115492284298, 0.016798369586467743, 0.022184548899531364, 0.01939551904797554, -0.03461054712533951, 0.02177322283387184, -0.019995497539639473, 0.10640684515237808, 0.006984304171055555, 0.03266517072916031, 0.0033789649605751038, 0.0005960995913483202, -0.01185278594493866, 0.06652465462684631, 0.017089780420064926, 0.013675271533429623, -0.015291943214833736, -0.027321409434080124, -0.027053190395236015, 0.01114625670015812, -0.032031603157520294, -0.013986371457576752, 0.008720948360860348, -0.01834142580628395, -0.02365235984325409, 0.016893086954951286, 0.01520582102239132, 0.04395933449268341, 0.007678074762225151, 0.047797173261642456, -0.02804756350815296, -0.004381322767585516, -0.03939403221011162, 0.013008832931518555, -0.013775200583040714, 0.030948663130402565, 0.04631052911281586, -0.001233621034771204, 0.01849534921348095, 0.026472242549061775, 0.019388532266020775, 0.04448412358760834, -0.022084495052695274, 0.07383854687213898, -0.02631431445479393, 0.01485999021679163, 0.039678215980529785, -0.034533023834228516, -0.030987104400992393, 0.04620141535997391, 0.019788481295108795, -0.06946147233247757, 0.0129444794729352, -0.02109624445438385, 0.051705941557884216, 0.0009844712913036346, 0.03487085923552513, -0.0497121587395668, -0.00425462843850255, -0.0058596087619662285, 0.05990386754274368, -0.00956425815820694, -0.003200351260602474, -0.019333189353346825, -0.029074635356664658, -0.007662103045731783, -0.011423980817198753, 0.004464855883270502, -0.002285693772137165, 0.018286505714058876, 0.02270919643342495, 0.025183413177728653, -0.020545614883303642, -0.008116201497614384, -0.010854541324079037, 0.06401726603507996, 0.0432167574763298, 0.025836750864982605, -0.014452515169978142, 0.017269035801291466, -0.016817914322018623, -0.01960141398012638, 0.010028624907135963, 0.03212427347898483, -0.01684088632464409, -0.028729554265737534, 0.039303578436374664, 0.01751619018614292, 0.0054917423985898495, 0.030779488384723663, -0.012454340234398842, 0.0009205781971104443, -0.020019080489873886, -0.08024069666862488, -0.03576095402240753, 0.0023904384579509497, -0.018250908702611923, 0.037357959896326065, -0.05900479853153229, 0.021877000108361244, 0.025523537769913673, 0.07797116041183472, 0.006658890750259161, 0.01940048299729824, -0.03807257488369942, 0.04703683778643608, 0.021464694291353226, 0.0017602210864424706, 0.007760514505207539, -0.01094815507531166, -0.019113805145025253, -0.031475167721509933, -0.06397940218448639, 0.04739409312605858, 0.005959650501608849, 0.005445307586342096, -0.03858678415417671, 0.000568419462069869, -0.0057623302564024925, -0.004028785042464733, -0.019034096971154213, 0.030230671167373657, -0.0024372879415750504, 0.07139910757541656, 0.007570276968181133, 0.02050759829580784, 0.016308695077896118, -0.01072418037801981, 0.0002497680252417922, 0.027001090347766876, 0.011178837157785892, 0.06018749251961708, -0.05431832745671272, 0.00930862221866846, -0.029815083369612694, 0.01893431507050991, 0.019434519112110138, -0.020201794803142548, -0.0006194378365762532, -0.017312342301011086, 0.011212234385311604, 0.005562577862292528, 0.006582216359674931, -0.05227745696902275, -0.00842202641069889, 0.014422299340367317, -0.01783236861228943, -0.015204120427370071, -0.07397183775901794, -0.0034550016280263662, 0.010478610172867775, -0.02352863922715187, 0.016795681789517403, 0.002189117483794689, 0.030941253527998924, -0.007842755876481533, -0.03136701136827469, -0.03634447976946831, -0.027161752805113792, 0.04680756479501724, -0.03052525222301483, 0.016854409128427505, 0.01652619056403637, 0.027577567845582962, 0.0034666701685637236, 0.08855635672807693, -0.02733686752617359, -0.03758405148983002, -0.017044605687260628, 0.0014097423991188407, -0.009124957956373692, 0.013410737738013268, 0.00888808909803629, 0.04644661396741867, 0.00022514761076308787, -0.037473540753126144, 0.01438822690397501, -0.01970139890909195, 0.10384424775838852, 0.08801780641078949, 0.031536251306533813, -0.011995870620012283, 0.01341320388019085, -0.009363182820379734, 0.006162481382489204, -0.02239397168159485, -0.022580523043870926, -0.039090946316719055, -0.00027903291629627347, 0.006531066261231899, 0.03093632496893406, -0.037272267043590546, 0.003581312717869878, 0.05142746865749359, -0.00799185037612915, 0.02019304782152176, 0.042160116136074066, 0.0009590194677002728, -0.022104917094111443, 0.002998361364006996, 0.033191680908203125, 0.003380643669515848, -0.0021010017953813076, -0.002512592589482665, -0.0025851507671177387, 0.041275735944509506, -0.010505720973014832, -0.00969158299267292, 0.016773009672760963, 0.02750832960009575, -0.032106269150972366, 0.0044134859926998615, -0.013208376243710518, 0.023337235674262047, -0.016307080164551735, 0.01808442547917366, 0.04257071763277054, 0.034079987555742264, -0.004163878969848156, 0.00424839137122035, -0.030461512506008148, 0.05357048287987709, 0.03560706973075867, -0.038931332528591156, 0.031911808997392654, -0.00464143930003047, -0.02576381340622902, 0.006827606353908777, -0.011793713085353374, -0.019641777500510216, -0.03248826786875725, 0.008321340195834637, 0.015539630316197872, 0.016798662021756172, 0.03515130281448364, -0.0032995184883475304, -0.022040104493498802, -0.0018208784749731421, 0.040774811059236526, -0.0009943722980096936, 0.011092327535152435, -0.04168009012937546, -0.006591767072677612, 0.004178253468126059, -0.009592941962182522, -0.01699288934469223, -0.00006556678999913856, -0.019400760531425476, 0.0011832232121378183, 0.0007895186427049339, -0.04037880524992943, 0.01608489267528057, -0.010807441547513008, 0.028459543362259865, -0.020650891587138176, -0.020573480054736137, 0.024120206013321877, 0.014682047069072723, -0.07325663417577744, 0.05022875592112541, -0.0058217886835336685, 0.0006918891449458897, -0.030485427007079124, 0.027110399678349495, 0.03051723539829254, -0.021862594410777092, -0.004178543575108051, 0.031772974878549576, -0.0044335960410535336, 0.002968898508697748, -0.07744968682527542, -0.09176236391067505, -0.03634156286716461, 0.006166398525238037, 0.023818211629986763, 0.0010446951491758227, -0.004194575361907482, 0.08363372087478638, 0.045200325548648834, -0.022357812151312828, -0.03258777782320976, -0.009312317706644535, -0.015355320647358894, 0.0027496060356497765, 0.027609724551439285, 0.019457362592220306, -0.01789283938705921, 0.002051709219813347, -0.029719175770878792, 0.01989481784403324, 0.07437160611152649, -0.010407496243715286, 0.03663747385144234, -0.00022483222710434347, 0.011689117178320885, -0.03771183639764786, 0.040807560086250305, 0.023710181936621666, -0.04022389277815819, 0.002618280705064535, -0.009911024011671543, 0.015906576067209244, 0.01931915618479252, -0.04995255544781685, -0.033039260655641556, -0.011714650318026543, 0.02586193010210991, -0.06258338689804077, 0.013074404560029507, 0.020356435328722, -0.022152945399284363, 0.026329785585403442, 0.0254745502024889, 0.0448538102209568, -0.015130408108234406, -0.030508462339639664, 0.06377409398555756, 0.0575123056769371, 0.005354391876608133, -0.051203083246946335, 0.015157106332480907, -0.01020639855414629, -0.006595304701477289, -0.02539055049419403, -0.0063104769214987755, 0.019294315949082375, 0.01926150731742382, 0.03684491291642189, -0.021994760259985924, -0.03940127044916153, 0.034395936876535416, -0.0212590079754591, 0.018029935657978058, -0.04174690321087837, 0.05608305335044861, -0.01749400608241558, 0.040309060364961624, -0.0017857748316600919, -0.010902179405093193, 0.02036934159696102, 0.004211762920022011, -0.061439622193574905, 0.03357645869255066, -0.0012544066412374377, -0.015774458646774292, 0.0019346361514180899, -0.0511430948972702, 0.01537757646292448, -0.009524800814688206, 0.028193414211273193, 0.009206786751747131, 0.05039539188146591, 0.008137393742799759, 0.02111888863146305, -0.014351471327245235, 0.00331912306137383, 0.020237606018781662, 0.03326811641454697, -0.0036676349118351936, 0.007706474978476763, 0.028751924633979797, 0.040203481912612915, 0.027422137558460236, -0.030265655368566513, -0.005918614100664854, 0.015829280018806458, 0.00013695299276150763, 0.04078878462314606, 0.0010927645489573479, 0.02937864512205124, -0.04811576008796692, -0.009822523221373558, 0.011633847840130329, 0.045485321432352066, 0.05833893641829491, -0.008846628479659557, 0.023964736610651016, -0.0016955931205302477, -0.033561766147613525, -0.000950545072555542, 0.004898711573332548, 0.0007484781090170145, -0.009367072954773903, 0.04228787496685982, 0.03380613401532173, -0.07059388607740402, 0.007484856061637402, 0.05549924820661545, 0.04126746580004692, 0.007512934971600771, -0.05088837072253227, -0.02453828603029251, 0.0334637276828289, -0.014075497165322304, -0.003291144734248519, 0.0321492925286293, -0.00440455274656415, 0.01058096531778574, 0.07178545743227005, -0.012360628694295883, -0.059313639998435974, -0.0021721275988966227, -0.011218025349080563, 0.05672229453921318, 0.00017845211550593376, -0.03971247002482414, 0.01943974383175373, 0.008353549987077713, 0.03348224610090256, 0.059694789350032806, -0.016071151942014694, -0.05928264930844307, -0.033703550696372986, 0.019888564944267273, 0.02574317529797554, -0.02473044954240322, 0.0054961987771093845, -0.03631667047739029, -0.013900833204388618, 0.013301289640367031, -0.05678872391581535, 0.0027247238904237747, -0.0025729890912771225, 0.005955560598522425, -0.021700575947761536, -0.010996815748512745, -0.06982721388339996, 0.0076934536918997765, -0.015263681299984455, 0.03303714841604233, -0.019902292639017105, -0.026723841205239296, -0.04759709909558296, 0.023758964613080025, 0.041526854038238525, 0.06550736725330353, -0.027933306992053986, -0.010537412017583847, -0.007441555615514517, 0.03169553726911545, 0.0028715343214571476, -0.07130270451307297, 0.033770639449357986, 0.012533559463918209, 0.0026460292283445597, 0.051195260137319565, -0.007762962952256203, -0.0430520623922348, 0.03078204020857811, 0.008675686083734035, -0.03560631722211838, -0.014494744129478931, -0.05918367579579353, 0.04688374698162079, 0.01001750212162733, 0.028139295056462288, 0.05033288896083832, 0.012687280774116516, 0.003421932691708207, 0.012127609923481941, -0.0422457717359066, 0.00614512013271451, -0.017520256340503693, -0.010506933555006981, -0.031353361904621124, 0.004036187659949064, -0.020771292969584465, 0.008789239451289177, -0.005884555168449879, 0.05273936688899994, -0.013145583681762218, -0.009207615628838539, 0.04225657880306244, -0.002173586515709758, 0.0041238684207201, 0.02538556046783924, 0.006928416900336742, -0.007719133980572224, 0.008529605343937874, -0.016671955585479736, 0.027406707406044006, -0.029092945158481598, -0.028940251097083092, -0.002361525548622012, -0.04363594204187393, -0.033754605799913406, -0.04228393733501434, -0.032201290130615234, 0.011822200380265713, -0.019263718277215958, 0.019638586789369583, -0.024148831143975258, 0.049967121332883835, -0.05118711665272713, -0.008370304480195045, -0.016335736960172653, 0.016358133405447006, -0.012284772470593452, 0.027253564447164536, -0.04021449759602547, 0.015587720088660717, -0.010424165055155754, 0.013198829255998135, -0.08696441352367401, -0.01703532412648201, -0.0014426849083974957, 0.00712771387770772, -0.03211371228098869, -0.06342150270938873, -0.0044881259091198444, 0.02743941731750965, -0.0486033670604229, -0.022466452792286873, 0.04277200624346733, 0.018668754026293755, -0.03237546235322952, -0.01887812465429306, 0.0028342369478195906, 0.07645510137081146, -0.021180856972932816, -0.042822156101465225, 0.03367970883846283, -0.01689072884619236, -0.0241901483386755, 0.046987950801849365, -0.007390233222395182, -0.025058114901185036, -0.006925093475729227, -0.045813899487257004, 0.0006321456166915596, 0.04137794300913811, -0.00485020037740469, -0.02447568066418171, 0.007410646881908178, 0.03532268851995468, 0.00530063034966588, -0.04516337439417839, -0.0030432059429585934, 0.008116597309708595, 0.008808630518615246, -0.02107837423682213, 0.017580095678567886, -0.034341830760240555, -0.0109041016548872, 0.044879063963890076, 0.034554895013570786, -0.020316289737820625, 0.013474500738084316, 0.05687084421515465, -0.007973679341375828, -0.04690960422158241, -0.0028102267533540726, -0.04872884228825569, 0.01380694005638361, 0.04003791883587837, -0.010757112875580788, 0.033546846359968185, 0.0186814833432436, -0.02547393925487995, -0.021412145346403122, -0.044775765389204025, 0.04456385597586632, 0.06898992508649826, -0.011267564259469509, 0.042426761239767075, 0.05661072954535484, 0.019287312403321266, -0.009279473684728146, -0.021162113174796104, 0.014551193453371525, 0.0046953544951975346, 0.018169257789850235, 0.04765838757157326, 0.00005318397961673327, -0.041213639080524445, 0.01338637713342905, 0.04111739248037338, 0.004455174319446087, 0.05069394037127495, 0.01737736351788044, 0.0031699188984930515, 0.014478271827101707, -0.02411211095750332, -0.021662922576069832, 0.01637503132224083, -0.05927656963467598, 0.03775531053543091, -0.05424799025058746, -0.04002495855093002, 0.006383812054991722, 0.05642302334308624, -0.0006409287452697754, -0.00918154139071703, -0.04636134207248688, -0.02691194787621498, 0.00022481077758129686, 0.02183903194963932, -0.03196004033088684, 0.035125911235809326, 0.00252650398761034, 0.026316121220588684, -0.022659888491034508, 0.033216942101716995, -0.012346513569355011, -0.04992479830980301, -0.04661809653043747, -0.036445122212171555, -0.031819187104701996, 0.037162311375141144, 0.0059843165799975395, -0.022738469764590263, 0.04047493264079094, -0.01807614602148533, 0.02445387840270996, -0.012723268941044807, 0.042690202593803406, 0.017412155866622925, 0.06958821415901184, 0.03628173843026161, 0.02618129551410675, 0.018305914476513863, 0.005110102705657482, 0.13319265842437744, 0.08856842666864395, 0.01649744249880314, -0.053699083626270294, 0.046719424426555634, 0.002527381991967559, -0.011759256012737751, -0.0189457256346941, 0.009480767883360386, 0.01364417839795351, -0.010783419013023376, 0.06446605920791626, 0.039430975914001465, 0.045857761055231094, -0.002365076681599021, 0.06462176144123077, -0.02290351502597332, -0.057255517691373825, 0.012131118215620518, 0.011193869635462761, -0.03530203178524971, -0.053896475583314896, -0.015366731211543083, 0.02793511003255844, 0.006805093958973885, -0.0256227757781744, -0.021734153851866722, 0.016665950417518616, 0.0035707878414541483, -0.01725146174430847, -0.024207692593336105, -0.031869467347860336, 0.015481174923479557, -0.015886031091213226, -0.032403815537691116, -0.044530052691698074, 0.018925974145531654, -0.002682820428162813, 0.0004222453571856022, 0.02030150033533573, -0.0051408070139586926, 0.005247307475656271, -0.02561938390135765, -0.0007102220552042127, -0.033539529889822006, -0.041832029819488525, -0.03261960297822952, 0.02821749448776245, -0.007402712944895029, 0.010655206628143787, -0.015399380587041378, 0.011061172001063824, 0.01348653994500637, -0.02066757157444954, 0.015555527061223984, 0.020652929320931435, 0.03496493771672249, -0.02603337913751602, -0.05214521661400795, -0.05882229283452034, -0.007139682304114103, 0.003505455097183585, 0.006910932715982199, 0.02216322161257267, -0.029808392748236656, -0.026654453948140144, -0.022147759795188904, 0.06092701479792595, 0.0200358796864748, -0.005634834058582783, 0.013559225015342236, -0.0228131040930748, -0.022827422246336937, 0.02693694829940796, -0.0118852024897933, -0.021607546135783195, 0.03207273781299591, 0.00891323946416378, -0.004180314484983683, -0.009762919507920742, -0.02986597828567028, -0.0028157527558505535, -0.01384949404746294, -0.01719132997095585, -0.019589630886912346, 0.02800571173429489, 0.004609986674040556, 0.06952688097953796, 0.005916786380112171, 0.01343909278512001, -0.02722882479429245, 0.04380611702799797, 0.006403051782399416, -0.03374873474240303, -0.028932498767971992, -0.02725735865533352, -0.04805601015686989, -0.011839163489639759, -0.02110941894352436, 0.06997913122177124, 0.01791171357035637, 0.0002949620829895139, 0.0029632244259119034, 0.020811598747968674, -0.00329108745791018, -0.005873591173440218, 0.00427015358582139, -0.05551688000559807, -0.0031909230165183544, 0.018270326778292656, 0.022033369168639183, -0.005341255106031895, -0.008800189010798931, -0.01624426431953907, -0.07608796656131744, 0.0019345389446243644, -0.035006333142519, -0.043155137449502945, -0.02617025189101696, -0.015252862125635147, -0.018750032410025597, -0.02783641591668129, 0.004569132812321186, -0.02109799161553383, -0.007496044505387545, -0.007560163736343384, 0.004876019898802042, -0.032427333295345306, 0.009045431390404701, 0.00327437580563128, 0.020850323140621185, 0.05035225674510002, 0.018168937414884567, 0.04031442105770111, -0.009805268608033657, -0.011246776208281517, 0.019116166979074478, 0.032439425587654114, -0.04827333986759186, 0.02558361552655697, 0.07040084153413773, -0.04220117628574371, -0.07299865782260895, 0.033735550940036774, -0.0014510758919641376, 0.04723567143082619, 0.00341301248408854, 0.002074595307931304, -0.03791803494095802, 0.04167376831173897, -0.052312642335891724, -0.05177941918373108, -0.015197969041764736, 0.021729394793510437, -0.0005060764960944653, -0.0016377816209569573, -0.01953289657831192, 0.01053174864500761, -0.008798954077064991, -0.003374149790033698, 0.04926571249961853, 0.010952099226415157, -0.004337414167821407, 0.021979790180921555, -0.0047112819738686085, 0.030643897131085396, 0.0013887559762224555, -0.02110164612531662, -0.007222871761769056, 0.06207125261425972, -0.050060853362083435, 0.002403984311968088, -0.029413092881441116, 0.05122610554099083, -0.08258580416440964, -0.05247046425938606, 0.00047244332381524146, 0.052726179361343384, 0.048840660601854324, -0.04987195506691933, 0.006023923866450787, 0.018563583493232727, -0.0036706046666949987, 0.04430866613984108, -0.01015481073409319, -0.015163556672632694, -0.05664621666073799, 0.04281776770949364, -0.032835137099027634, 0.03650820627808571, 0.02801075577735901, 0.03256266564130783, 0.034546222537755966, 0.026905657723546028, 0.010229578241705894, -0.0023319008760154247, -0.01467150542885065, -0.0334123931825161, 0.03554222360253334, -0.05915078520774841, 0.038211431354284286, -0.02896738052368164, -0.04638652876019478, 0.02371908538043499, -0.035831063985824585, 0.0014955948572605848, 0.056838858872652054, 0.024486104026436806, -0.029960697516798973, 0.04127931222319603, 0.02476312778890133, -0.02618955448269844, 0.001156794955022633, 0.006426991429179907, 0.0037529615219682455, 0.010754037648439407, -0.03896164521574974, 0.0009393692598678172, 0.05904177948832512, 0.028023138642311096, -0.030322816222906113, 0.020514683797955513, -0.026096539571881294, -0.019579732790589333, -0.01372642070055008, -0.01438734121620655, -0.01055228617042303, -0.02928561344742775, 0.03539876639842987, -0.04726949706673622, -0.01450363639742136, 0.07791121304035187, 0.014265993610024452, -0.004686374682933092, -0.0053038704209029675, -0.0028745722956955433, -0.038698628544807434, -0.023345697671175003, -0.007212532684206963, -0.028378285467624664, -0.04227318614721298, 0.008828769437968731, 0.0017813523299992085, 0.007734713610261679, 0.018628528341650963, 0.0056263599544763565, 0.005365859251469374, 0.06710760295391083, -0.04817808046936989, -0.008260758593678474, 0.03376895561814308, -0.0019152609165757895, 0.022172261029481888, -0.09300455451011658, 0.0341380275785923, -0.008898957632482052, 0.014532679691910744, -0.045620113611221313, -0.014213460497558117, -0.02681490033864975, -0.00520235113799572, 0.05083860829472542, 0.002716120332479477, 0.015979085117578506, 0.013552428223192692, 0.05151229724287987, 0.01621285080909729, -0.034362517297267914, 0.04944973811507225, -0.02829574979841709, -0.007301459554582834, -0.013832038268446922, -0.021399641409516335, -0.0098680779337883, -0.02074292302131653, 0.0030544460751116276, 0.0005228859372437, 0.008182575926184654, -0.0013407254591584206, -0.004199655260890722, 0.025986183434724808, -0.004092910327017307, 0.009205823764204979, 0.04044032841920853, 0.00033185837673954666, -0.02026650309562683, 0.030598241835832596, 0.013121400959789753, -0.07908207178115845, 0.031468238681554794, -0.022588340565562248, -0.05936885252594948, 0.01853240467607975, 0.023666629567742348, -0.03566550463438034, -0.0771133154630661, 0.021651476621627808, -0.006442571058869362, -0.04920344054698944, -0.0017540850676596165, 0.017305975779891014, -0.004226713441312313, 0.019769921898841858, -0.010350092314183712, -0.0016934205777943134, 0.016327349469065666, -0.02069695293903351, 0.02544218860566616, 0.004971710033714771, 0.03033057413995266, -0.009341591037809849, -0.003958498127758503, 0.008963706903159618, 0.02122395858168602, 0.037653423845767975, 0.004118444863706827, 0.02214641124010086, -0.011190543882548809, -0.014452457427978516, 0.04237320274114609, -0.020852725952863693, 0.03686433285474777, 0.007050515152513981, 0.017844412475824356, 0.04120182245969772, -0.03660128265619278, 0.02547209896147251, -0.0336972177028656, -0.029372958466410637, -0.043566130101680756, -0.001838524709455669, 0.03027682565152645, 0.08580006659030914, 0.017812363803386688, 0.032435815781354904, -0.009195415303111076, -0.028309982270002365, 0.045154932886362076, -0.037383925169706345, 0.03329741209745407, -0.02100607194006443, -0.006467069964855909, -0.027950871735811234, -0.01010828372091055, -0.07062557339668274, -0.030032571405172348, -0.010013283230364323, 0.023094885051250458, 0.03246022388339043, 0.026929514482617378, -0.056504011154174805, 0.029904363676905632, 0.036786194890737534, -0.03545651212334633, -0.012275418266654015, -0.04386851191520691, 0.023890240117907524, -0.03803310543298721, -0.013468717224895954 ]
<p>I'm new to Stata and didn't find the answer in the help, navigating the menus, or online so far. I would just like to know how to access the quantile function of a distribution. For example in R, if I want to know the 0.95 point of the $\chi^2(1)$ distribution, I do:</p> <pre><code>&gt; qchisq(0.95,1) [1] 3.841459 </code></pre> <p>Is there an equivalent command in Stata ?</p>
48,119
[ 0.013770150020718575, 0.005680046044290066, 0.014582745730876923, 0.006812737789005041, 0.013466640375554562, 0.021324560046195984, -0.0014250986278057098, 0.000628309091553092, 0.018156103789806366, -0.027915019541978836, 0.03540164604783058, 0.04329855740070343, 0.08257954567670822, 0.006918405648320913, 0.02547363191843033, 0.009772242978215218, -0.04473090171813965, 0.005624477285891771, -0.03383895754814148, 0.010201173834502697, -0.007288982626050711, 0.03698479384183884, -0.012646932154893875, -0.01360996626317501, 0.003928093239665031, 0.05635906383395195, 0.030575519427657127, 0.00297142774797976, -0.0031895460560917854, 0.10188569128513336, -0.011776216328144073, -0.05797813832759857, 0.017233388498425484, 0.011141502298414707, 0.01939018815755844, -0.0006806079763919115, -0.01623419113457203, -0.032091859728097916, -0.013522164896130562, 0.03207247331738472, -0.065825916826725, 0.022689148783683777, 0.005732303950935602, 0.00562326842918992, -0.019116636365652084, 0.022315001115202904, 0.015856897458434105, -0.03499845787882805, 0.018697811290621758, -0.04773100093007088, 0.036303821951150894, 0.01906358264386654, 0.007207599934190512, 0.03510233014822006, 0.002769999671727419, -0.0016340879956260324, 0.029527727514505386, 0.03794252499938011, 0.0023168183397501707, -0.06649447232484818, -0.02137209102511406, -0.025755269452929497, 0.0030769705772399902, -0.05235530808568001, -0.05264495685696602, 0.021962707862257957, -0.012677780352532864, -0.002926285844296217, 0.041025806218385696, -0.021510016173124313, -0.0028307961765676737, 0.049909479916095734, 0.029492637142539024, 0.008807413280010223, -0.00810313131660223, -0.03372559696435928, 0.02076476812362671, -0.026126757264137268, 0.05518696457147598, 0.019684500992298126, 0.031844206154346466, 0.007218870334327221, -0.01331560593098402, 0.029668696224689484, 0.00939344335347414, -0.019835157319903374, 0.05845283344388008, -0.01298854872584343, 0.009721874259412289, 0.01715848781168461, -0.04618571698665619, -0.00862045306712389, 0.03186434879899025, -0.026129350066184998, -0.022194141522049904, 0.055607493966817856, -0.019741538912057877, 0.02004382759332657, -0.017012635245919228, -0.027084315195679665, 0.003960954491049051, -0.05336293950676918, 0.041010648012161255, 0.014932298101484776, -0.04748762398958206, 0.00970496702939272, 0.0016005372162908316, -0.03405555710196495, -0.010644710622727871, -0.016745230183005333, -0.027241889387369156, 0.01378338411450386, 0.019898371770977974, -0.008709749206900597, 0.005490806885063648, 0.016841551288962364, -0.01936945505440235, 0.00806377548724413, 0.020423367619514465, 0.029317861422896385, 0.028526537120342255, -0.024394815787672997, 0.003804720239713788, -0.040089428424835205, -0.028586383908987045, 0.03813277557492256, 0.01271077711135149, -0.009563647210597992, -0.03823041170835495, 0.011466708965599537, -0.006420820951461792, -0.017675982788205147, 0.06162888556718826, 0.019356491044163704, 0.0029509488958865404, -0.02708582393825054, -0.02355639636516571, -0.07635032385587692, 0.007442346308380365, 0.0534951388835907, 0.010470709763467312, -0.042887307703495026, 0.015308900736272335, 0.030317969620227814, 0.02026282623410225, 0.02990695834159851, 0.0665164589881897, 0.02078411355614662, -0.0025027040392160416, -0.004519124515354633, -0.05912803113460541, -0.021045304834842682, -0.01947169005870819, -0.0272426325827837, 0.021853014826774597, -0.029935607686638832, 0.02714887447655201, -0.01677943393588066, -0.023458333685994148, -0.038960233330726624, 0.04945971444249153, 0.012047774158418179, -0.015158395282924175, -0.010048485361039639, -0.021800031885504723, -0.04677939414978027, 0.09482286125421524, -0.0017359884222969413, -0.0032948350999504328, -0.01853742077946663, -0.029350116848945618, -0.04470304399728775, -0.016914550215005875, 0.04596422240138054, 0.061984650790691376, -0.01889933831989765, -0.010237805545330048, -0.03683982416987419, 0.0432412214577198, 0.012543120421469212, -0.05617116019129753, 0.013963104225695133, 0.02583831176161766, -0.01440910343080759, 0.01723662205040455, 0.0003147921815980226, -0.00660050380975008, -0.017422573640942574, 0.0332116074860096, -0.05079064890742302, -0.05008004233241081, -0.016222361475229263, -0.019057156518101692, 0.022926904261112213, -0.027728084474802017, 0.010612486861646175, 0.045849792659282684, 0.01896795816719532, 0.013616073876619339, 0.014816959388554096, -0.004473636392503977, -0.0059212190099060535, 0.03416721150279045, -0.04808082431554794, 0.0036613058764487505, 0.018418483436107635, 0.05709629878401756, -0.023263832554221153, 0.04696383699774742, -0.024906115606427193, -0.021860722452402115, 0.02388245053589344, -0.01379057951271534, 0.05106068402528763, -0.0315144844353199, -0.004165559075772762, -0.0044835531152784824, 0.0043252757750451565, -0.040392324328422546, -0.00024444243172183633, -0.06405449658632278, 0.0458986833691597, 0.09140094369649887, 0.02036834880709648, -0.012392490170896053, -0.009199359454214573, 0.0010686949826776981, 0.046917304396629333, -0.010171297006309032, -0.028698228299617767, -0.017585348337888718, -0.007559570018202066, 0.03266570344567299, 0.01927388831973076, -0.0311049185693264, -0.019236018881201744, 0.08077282458543777, -0.055767375975847244, 0.011707054451107979, 0.028526946902275085, -0.03957461565732956, -0.003252299502491951, 0.00017627966008149087, -0.014171861112117767, 0.020585039630532265, -0.00603859918192029, 0.024018196389079094, 0.031546346843242645, 0.057415541261434555, 0.02295355126261711, 0.0011615486582741141, 0.08521135151386261, -0.023077383637428284, 0.010239185765385628, -0.009151208214461803, 0.003809086512774229, 0.08256643265485764, -0.0003397385880816728, 0.010826497338712215, 0.025166859850287437, -0.014272787608206272, -0.011819754727184772, 0.04021262004971504, -0.014408888295292854, 0.03061177022755146, 0.0509527325630188, -0.0463411882519722, -0.000619195110630244, 0.0035890929866582155, -0.006040459033101797, 0.020421311259269714, -0.033483557403087616, -0.02757634036242962, -0.019177395850419998, -0.0035626208409667015, 0.057304419577121735, 0.011534898541867733, -0.016837693750858307, -0.018197091296315193, -0.036786407232284546, 0.007258117198944092, -0.00326718483120203, 0.03573036193847656, 0.017507921904325485, -0.0308842733502388, -0.038495469838380814, -0.0033865622244775295, -0.038234565407037735, -0.0030258838087320328, -0.0022498280741274357, -0.038087476044893265, -0.005660782102495432, -0.019631454721093178, -0.01964639127254486, -0.0037113477010279894, -0.020063474774360657, -0.00863105058670044, -0.053095828741788864, 0.01907588727772236, 0.0032848124392330647, -0.012254399247467518, -0.02075616642832756, 0.020841024816036224, -0.06310107558965683, -0.02554474025964737, -0.0422762855887413, 0.05156591534614563, 0.031568560749292374, 0.014047046191990376, 0.00351098645478487, -0.0006059552542865276, 0.0032817297615110874, -0.011257842183113098, -0.04420982673764229, -0.014291317202150822, -0.00893282052129507, 0.03671823814511299, 0.025801721960306168, 0.016713730990886688, -0.013639395125210285, 0.07290691137313843, -0.00536726089194417, -0.05184468626976013, -0.04073604568839073, -0.0069990623742341995, -0.009545444510877132, 0.002010174561291933, 0.010473332367837429, -0.0009136270964518189, -0.020198054611682892, -0.004692277871072292, 0.007019842974841595, 0.06503945589065552, 0.061674173921346664, -0.008971060626208782, -0.017276154831051826, 0.02473730593919754, -0.036872245371341705, -0.017678018659353256, 0.034086354076862335, 0.02039121650159359, -0.015080106444656849, 0.023885933682322502, -0.025660440325737, 0.018076274544000626, -0.004212873987853527, -0.005658787675201893, 0.018454037606716156, 0.010626471601426601, -0.00044691929360851645, -0.08122846484184265, 0.03641810268163681, 0.024202998727560043, -0.01282456424087286, 0.030213451012969017, 0.0015734387561678886, 0.01566082052886486, -0.04379349574446678, 0.014599275775253773, 0.005451149307191372, -0.0002481426054146141, -0.012871705926954746, 0.01788555271923542, -0.014597699977457523, -0.019664129242300987, -0.003130982629954815, -0.03718861937522888, -0.014867556281387806, 0.02266017161309719, 0.06854774057865143, 0.0455404669046402, 0.01821056567132473, -0.034325651824474335, 0.024925725534558296, -0.0389348641037941, -0.03682387247681618, 0.016196785494685173, 0.0599820651113987, 0.04020213708281517, 0.03747604414820671, 0.020681768655776978, 0.0038247439078986645, -0.016919197514653206, -0.004223993048071861, -0.05571320280432701, 0.028827816247940063, 0.02371169999241829, -0.012766493484377861, -0.020087825134396553, -0.003369441721588373, 0.036651138216257095, -0.019266178831458092, -0.014728494919836521, -0.004331061616539955, -0.01054761279374361, -0.027474738657474518, 0.02917299047112465, -0.008339432068169117, -0.016816306859254837, -0.035646405071020126, 0.021477991715073586, -0.02475348673760891, -0.04047773405909538, 0.017003562301397324, 0.02641361579298973, -0.03167534992098808, 0.026267915964126587, -0.007026920095086098, 0.011195488274097443, -0.01052058208733797, 0.046371862292289734, 0.007892366498708725, 0.021848304197192192, -0.04514060914516449, 0.020360860973596573, 0.001538746990263462, 0.0782405212521553, 0.07387927919626236, -0.019889533519744873, -0.011521664448082447, -0.02869584411382675, 0.013564184308052063, -0.03771861642599106, -0.008418981917202473, -0.013946527615189552, 0.0033760506194084883, 0.05422717705368996, 0.01334434375166893, -0.0662962794303894, 0.033034976571798325, 0.08426967263221741, 0.03021029755473137, -0.005842805374413729, -0.0206727534532547, -0.01029959972947836, -0.002875863341614604, 0.03439102694392204, 0.008754073642194271, 0.019351430237293243, 0.019858988001942635, 0.01270691491663456, 0.019460100680589676, -0.024290697649121284, -0.01597435399889946, -0.043463896960020065, 0.06776594370603561, 0.0377311073243618, 0.011174041777849197, -0.054934047162532806, 0.010702094994485378, 0.019109312444925308, 0.006161640398204327, 0.00028231280157342553, 0.023241283372044563, -0.09524863213300705, -0.009352556429803371, 0.04843168705701828, -0.00556564936414361, -0.03612707927823067, -0.05925727263092995, -0.05130145698785782, -0.011276251636445522, 0.04237687215209007, -0.04572029784321785, 0.009996437467634678, -0.012807212769985199, 0.02995125763118267, 0.0032392386347055435, 0.01050281897187233, -0.031673677265644073, 0.03729793801903725, -0.00880641769617796, -0.008876917883753777, -0.038004323840141296, -0.018076980486512184, -0.06747829914093018, 0.015517924912273884, -0.02330060489475727, 0.057304561138153076, 0.0009992617415264249, -0.011657176539301872, -0.006385968532413244, 0.020932326093316078, -0.028772853314876556, -0.033766407519578934, -0.00011967169120907784, -0.024606900289654732, 0.03194662928581238, 0.039512407034635544, -0.006201126147061586, -0.010920918546617031, -0.003951115999370813, 0.029312703758478165, -0.030234873294830322, 0.03519604355096817, -0.01652362197637558, 0.038303013890981674, 0.0023441710509359837, 0.02086401917040348, 0.05481208860874176, 0.019434116780757904, -0.013385303318500519, -0.0008820362272672355, -0.05266101658344269, 0.021031973883509636, 0.0007117817876860499, -0.05021030083298683, -0.04830910265445709, -0.006851231213659048, 0.004565736744552851, -0.01210795994848013, 0.004045543726533651, 0.03838623687624931, -0.01975388266146183, 0.014224931597709656, -0.001600188435986638, 0.04023337364196777, 0.009230217896401882, -0.029506372287869453, 0.011384566314518452, 0.0429774671792984, -0.0010739945573732257, -0.0007957145571708679, 0.036178428679704666, -0.01952296681702137, -0.021279146894812584, -0.011318438686430454, -0.046402253210544586, 0.02334796078503132, -0.03392726182937622, -0.026733405888080597, -0.004654424265027046, 0.011565815657377243, 0.00021429787739180028, -0.02781076915562153, -0.007461992092430592, -0.02007894404232502, -0.02723161317408085, -0.017827654257416725, 0.02174796722829342, 0.007314691785722971, 0.01151262316852808, -0.04036283493041992, 0.0782572478055954, -0.005222535226494074, 0.00842836033552885, -0.07626181095838547, -0.00782978255301714, 0.013874276541173458, -0.01847843825817108, -0.058634255081415176, -0.02612239494919777, 0.00901762768626213, 0.023273201659321785, 0.004504750482738018, 0.027326293289661407, 0.022984864190220833, -0.01305390428751707, 0.03062526509165764, -0.02410438284277916, 0.04649149253964424, 0.03464769572019577, -0.04911181703209877, 0.009328148327767849, 0.028440890833735466, 0.027297649532556534, -0.020190058276057243, 0.006307018920779228, 0.004586148075759411, -0.031273119151592255, 0.017642490565776825, -0.0028645566198974848, -0.027411259710788727, -0.0026241883169859648, -0.0019924966618418694, 0.004373676143586636, -0.0330035537481308, -0.007252118084579706, 0.026443960145115852, -0.03252585232257843, -0.018921609967947006, -0.02355904132127762, 0.013981982134282589, -0.050516147166490555, -0.0026953110937029123, -0.014909631572663784, 0.044678524136543274, 0.047698553651571274, -0.014945518225431442, 0.014090728014707565, 0.000012831046660721768, 0.08013170957565308, -0.01734013296663761, 0.012218131683766842, 0.008429360575973988, -0.0015648232074454427, 0.0212485883384943, 0.02969200909137726, -0.03245958313345909, 0.006649492308497429, -0.012577161192893982, -0.017033927142620087, -0.0015714872861281037, -0.04755149036645889, -0.01358033251017332, 0.05582865700125694, 0.017942314967513084, 0.03664291277527809, 0.024175120517611504, 0.007725149858742952, 0.005143207963556051, -0.03519918769598007, -0.003034102264791727, -0.016793258488178253, 0.036195628345012665, 0.04857505485415459, 0.01635988987982273, 0.01912299543619156, 0.04202884063124657, 0.03895460069179535, -0.04012437164783478, 0.07147058844566345, 0.009113890118896961, 0.03929252550005913, 0.04350123181939125, -0.02786889113485813, -0.013674657791852951, 0.0086490698158741, -0.011377655901014805, 0.02438678964972496, -0.044716887176036835, -0.04030820354819298, 0.006708377972245216, 0.018517371267080307, 0.002302221953868866, -0.05447433888912201, -0.004177953582257032, -0.027991952374577522, 0.0072095985524356365, -0.003293533343821764, -0.03111409768462181, 0.03904545307159424, 0.025401653721928596, 0.03316018730401993, 0.002633772324770689, 0.016843529418110847, -0.0009378021350130439, -0.04846920073032379, -0.01047305017709732, -0.022486800327897072, -0.03890717029571533, 0.0061128814704716206, 0.0007542570238001645, -0.05896284058690071, 0.03986739367246628, -0.04431522265076637, 0.03261628746986389, 0.011233330704271793, 0.010115038603544235, 0.00969404075294733, 0.10883031785488129, -0.0048544444143772125, 0.02274339459836483, -0.006693193688988686, 0.005320832598954439, 0.11653724312782288, 0.09613336622714996, 0.028551260009407997, -0.08781073987483978, -0.011990295723080635, 0.03502468392252922, 0.004936189390718937, -0.015442411415278912, -0.01688997633755207, 0.027291102334856987, -0.022288061678409576, 0.05711384862661362, 0.09193236380815506, 0.020540732890367508, 0.008503829129040241, 0.03169775381684303, -0.00009768164454726502, -0.038475096225738525, -0.00014131695206742734, 0.03348781168460846, -0.005396883003413677, 0.00114112114533782, -0.08974896371364594, 0.0226250272244215, 0.014248812571167946, 0.009133460000157356, -0.06421782821416855, -0.032000891864299774, -0.05045003071427345, 0.017832428216934204, -0.03162356838583946, -0.021543577313423157, 0.044935084879398346, 0.024599025025963783, -0.017557749524712563, -0.017516685649752617, 0.008965378627181053, 0.00717453146353364, 0.002868494251742959, 0.036348577588796616, -0.01645185612142086, 0.054200273007154465, -0.011595943942666054, 0.03330593928694725, -0.019161459058523178, -0.04014426842331886, -0.027414051815867424, 0.005031310021877289, -0.03173008933663368, -0.009449616074562073, -0.024435991421341896, -0.004167253617197275, -0.013349240645766258, -0.013462255708873272, -0.008827398531138897, -0.00913209281861782, 0.004164820071309805, -0.028624024242162704, -0.018838219344615936, -0.027090996503829956, 0.010468186810612679, -0.048677172511816025, 0.04880213364958763, -0.02850075624883175, -0.04916614294052124, 0.011953948065638542, -0.014970988966524601, 0.02260712906718254, -0.02587066777050495, -0.02123064361512661, 0.024683088064193726, -0.026026908308267593, -0.022911066189408302, -0.03114866092801094, -0.0012948280200362206, -0.0072158332914114, 0.03226508945226669, -0.017529208213090897, -0.002159412717446685, -0.05353220924735069, -0.03458689898252487, 0.02597402036190033, -0.04090086370706558, -0.02052164077758789, -0.0062241144478321075, -0.009629940614104271, 0.023639418184757233, 0.03427485004067421, 0.00040313942008651793, 0.011940467171370983, -0.019377293065190315, 0.03691874071955681, 0.0160946287214756, -0.07983165234327316, 0.03325049579143524, 0.014632250182330608, -0.026911107823252678, 0.00411788048222661, -0.044512201100587845, 0.030692052096128464, 0.023726964369416237, 0.03629563748836517, -0.02410586178302765, 0.012075357139110565, -0.04059944674372673, 0.031417593359947205, 0.019382357597351074, -0.04254043474793434, 0.009149856865406036, -0.014418848790228367, 0.005556819494813681, -0.042813703417778015, 0.003606292651966214, -0.029663028195500374, -0.05905488133430481, 0.017880314961075783, -0.013795362785458565, -0.04761834815144539, 0.014448823407292366, -0.02419978752732277, -0.02390207350254059, -0.009423183277249336, 0.00360356317833066, 0.019676269963383675, -0.002018736442551017, 0.005582890007644892, -0.04313512146472931, 0.001020813942886889, -0.014745338819921017, -0.010088455863296986, 0.009652648121118546, -0.0007546744309365749, 0.0013384063495323062, 0.03225967660546303, 0.009945648722350597, 0.03547175973653793, 0.039606187492609024, 0.05457416549324989, -0.029803326353430748, 0.021429680287837982, 0.04921719804406166, -0.04557693749666214, -0.0361047089099884, 0.043530482798814774, -0.006887338124215603, 0.04778606817126274, 0.039968036115169525, 0.008461076766252518, -0.021204886958003044, 0.029338376596570015, -0.02268684096634388, -0.003867739113047719, 0.00043104050564579666, -0.009682911448180676, 0.004034322686493397, 0.011383334174752235, -0.048981133848428726, -0.004884836729615927, 0.00413142517209053, 0.02729780599474907, 0.05568322911858559, 0.003169253934174776, 0.00847172737121582, 0.030497193336486816, -0.03707171604037285, 0.030478931963443756, 0.05085974931716919, -0.013989252038300037, 0.0355956107378006, 0.04681927338242531, -0.02151036262512207, 0.02395215816795826, -0.045912083238363266, 0.026712168008089066, -0.09708252549171448, -0.026273809373378754, 0.007105649448931217, -0.006499510258436203, 0.03751834109425545, -0.04035240411758423, 0.005930297076702118, 0.03226173296570778, -0.03222179412841797, 0.030690165236592293, -0.0022112627048045397, -0.006705408915877342, -0.046134576201438904, 0.008685966953635216, -0.024820536375045776, 0.05471009388566017, 0.044937290251255035, -0.005085200071334839, 0.06977371871471405, 0.020313022658228874, -0.0008875034982338548, -0.012395109049975872, -0.0003911954117938876, 0.022156132385134697, 0.009841524995863438, -0.07087543606758118, 0.03575185686349869, -0.0437350794672966, -0.022476011887192726, 0.03369125723838806, -0.031698018312454224, 0.035861555486917496, 0.023927299305796623, 0.009486394934356213, -0.0034703968558460474, 0.05272732302546501, 0.04738275706768036, 0.017857136204838753, -0.024942154064774513, -0.01149750966578722, 0.019710995256900787, 0.00791167188435793, -0.03512529656291008, 0.034695155918598175, 0.03994199261069298, -0.00861561018973589, -0.052985794842243195, 0.0524170845746994, -0.015832023695111275, -0.01818486861884594, -0.019721856340765953, -0.024000318720936775, 0.0023131701163947582, -0.04288485273718834, 0.05507680028676987, -0.042342640459537506, 0.01174233015626669, 0.028304221108555794, 0.016527077183127403, 0.023465733975172043, -0.006716421339660883, 0.008570363745093346, -0.06156742200255394, 0.051747340708971024, 0.018370065838098526, -0.010208004154264927, -0.06382004916667938, -0.014544576406478882, -0.01512015052139759, 0.02411632053554058, -0.027708174660801888, -0.0032178880646824837, -0.006972937844693661, 0.02907549776136875, -0.011200630106031895, -0.017404234036803246, 0.007786154747009277, 0.03308246657252312, 0.024911241605877876, -0.11219502240419388, 0.04020266607403755, 0.008375510573387146, -0.02823842689394951, -0.039011724293231964, -0.009557384997606277, -0.0519668385386467, -0.013957446441054344, 0.015476777218282223, 0.004190382082015276, -0.0008582673617638648, -0.013445890508592129, 0.04523690044879913, 0.03963783383369446, -0.027213813737034798, 0.007156052626669407, -0.0063409944996237755, -0.0029140745755285025, -0.04986431077122688, 0.01408806536346674, -0.015459302812814713, 0.03890297934412956, 0.0077972253784537315, 0.018017658963799477, -0.0006620096391998231, 0.00908257532864809, -0.04237481579184532, 0.027555111795663834, 0.03153542801737785, 0.0157280582934618, 0.031475890427827835, 0.004783019423484802, -0.025884125381708145, 0.06738545745611191, -0.00031709240283817053, -0.018430108204483986, 0.028463713824748993, 0.0058008888736367226, -0.054680630564689636, -0.012668062001466751, 0.02158609963953495, 0.0032855102326720953, -0.04802931472659111, 0.006815064232796431, 0.010889454744756222, -0.043346282094717026, -0.0014659821754321456, -0.005452290643006563, 0.034330736845731735, 0.07026755809783936, 0.017958562821149826, 0.0012392811477184296, -0.0050865523517131805, -0.019312066957354546, 0.0198511965572834, 0.017145950347185135, 0.03693639114499092, -0.01856435090303421, 0.005408921279013157, 0.0419425293803215, -0.036486465483903885, 0.012842520140111446, -0.03688553720712662, 0.04960018768906593, -0.012862775474786758, -0.04054420813918114, -0.004060034640133381, 0.011592811904847622, 0.03384591266512871, 0.033815767616033554, -0.045185599476099014, 0.0444764643907547, -0.027785176411271095, 0.012833227403461933, -0.04879189282655716, -0.025751644745469093, -0.05426885932683945, -0.04052463918924332, -0.015766508877277374, 0.017705293372273445, -0.024818502366542816, 0.02844964526593685, 0.03603554889559746, 0.001738165388815105, 0.012096264399588108, -0.018821941688656807, 0.008290393278002739, 0.009226839058101177, 0.04457036405801773, -0.014617862179875374, -0.03963727876543999, 0.021777817979454994, 0.019918808713555336, 0.010015085339546204, 0.009278548881411552, 0.04476059228181839, -0.006506292149424553, -0.05684809014201164, 0.004770413972437382, 0.03446647897362709, -0.024666426703333855, 0.004389540757983923, -0.015118589624762535, -0.004912900272756815, -0.04106346145272255, -0.015192215330898762 ]
<p>Let's say, we have simple "yes/no" question that we want to know answer to. And there are N people "voting" for correct answer. Every voter has a history - list of 1's and 0's, showing whether they were right or wrong about this kind of questions in the past. If we assume history as a binomial distribution, we can find voters' mean performance on such questions, their variation, CI and any other kind of confidence metrics. </p> <p>Basically, my question is: how to incorporate <strong>confidence information</strong> into <strong>voting system</strong>? </p> <p>For example, if we consider only mean performance of each voter, then we can construct simple weighted voting system: </p> <p>$$result = sign(\sum_{v \in voters}\mu_v \times (-1)^{1-vote})$$</p> <p>That is, we can just sum voters' weights multiplied either by $+1$ (for "yes") or by $-1$ (for "no"). It makes sense: if voter 1 has average of correct answers equal to $.9$, and voter 2 has only $.8$, than, probably, 1st person's vote should be considered as more important. On other hand, if 1st person have answered only 10 questions of this kind, and 2nd person have answered 1000 such questions, we are much more confident about 2nd person's skill level than about those of the 1st - it's just possible that 1st person was lucky, and after 10 relatively successful answers he will continue with much worse results. </p> <p>So, more precise question may sound like this: is there statistical metric that incorporates both - <strong>strength</strong> and <strong>confidence</strong> about some parameter? </p>
36,500
[ -0.023379087448120117, -0.0664617121219635, -0.0007310862420126796, -0.039266187697649, 0.015629054978489876, 0.0016733275260776281, 0.020646510645747185, -0.02463621459901333, 0.01440773531794548, -0.02481631562113762, 0.02464042417705059, 0.017369050532579422, 0.062339771538972855, 0.03098820336163044, -0.0060593970119953156, 0.009419748559594154, -0.01713395304977894, 0.01172611117362976, -0.03865622356534004, 0.006468095351010561, -0.007797522470355034, 0.01228584349155426, 0.01719571277499199, 0.00940315518528223, -0.007207763381302357, 0.0026166548486799, 0.001441428903490305, -0.024311674758791924, 0.0008524242439307272, 0.07262521237134933, -0.022445203736424446, 0.007631581276655197, 0.02417769469320774, 0.035649411380290985, -0.023504316806793213, -0.011288636364042759, -0.03920171037316322, 0.008621386252343655, -0.0050798747688531876, 0.012855776585638523, -0.03338969126343727, -0.01162059884518385, 0.001669841120019555, 0.0021148736122995615, -0.000036999415897298604, -0.005662119947373867, -0.01376444473862648, -0.0398971252143383, 0.009924177080392838, -0.05779660493135452, 0.0681067556142807, -0.023341381922364235, 0.04161640256643295, 0.03611430153250694, 0.0005137507687322795, -0.04301641136407852, 0.066838838160038, 0.05580256134271622, 0.0013653190108016133, -0.05030202865600586, -0.014038477092981339, -0.030110705643892288, 0.02073889970779419, 0.015829287469387054, -0.027160553261637688, 0.019052697345614433, -0.0341494157910347, -0.019166983664035797, 0.0718006044626236, -0.013969912193715572, -0.03185263276100159, 0.04503839835524559, 0.03334425017237663, 0.019458962604403496, 0.009288233704864979, -0.015144492499530315, 0.00950350146740675, 0.017374347895383835, 0.061706479638814926, 0.03101828321814537, -0.013709647580981255, 0.018192462623119354, 0.023216404020786285, 0.06362079083919525, 0.00847201980650425, 0.003504266729578376, 0.041052501648664474, -0.06784608960151672, 0.02893972210586071, 0.02636885829269886, -0.0020670711528509855, -0.02233319729566574, -0.004976860247552395, -0.0223582461476326, -0.05916113033890724, 0.0035315765999257565, -0.025323636829853058, 0.025659484788775444, 0.05557805299758911, -0.005848669912666082, -0.020324669778347015, -0.061811186373233795, 0.02053127996623516, 0.049122944474220276, -0.023401804268360138, -0.0004784713964909315, 0.01362268254160881, -0.025886593386530876, -0.04405539482831955, -0.030379582196474075, -0.012482092715799809, 0.007463136687874794, 0.00848474446684122, 0.0193034540861845, 0.010177548974752426, -0.01879284530878067, 0.009468337520956993, -0.000033093991078203544, 0.08895903080701828, 0.039070647209882736, 0.03586454316973686, 0.005008876323699951, 0.01665830984711647, -0.03386266902089119, -0.06182217597961426, 0.018656738102436066, 0.04799491539597511, -0.027610179036855698, -0.06052006781101227, 0.040786951780319214, -0.0008071985212154686, -0.016241371631622314, 0.02606886252760887, -0.0040732561610639095, 0.037771426141262054, 0.018232649192214012, -0.06345165520906448, -0.047176294028759, 0.012247650884091854, -0.028089841827750206, -0.019462211057543755, -0.06197609007358551, 0.004601447843015194, 0.039060115814208984, 0.039035387337207794, 0.05436091125011444, 0.06901789456605911, 0.026104610413312912, 0.058515384793281555, 0.04791613295674324, -0.013874669559299946, -0.015675731003284454, -0.020470980554819107, 0.015079407021403313, -0.03180309757590294, -0.06665752083063126, 0.056694697588682175, 0.026230912655591965, -0.03394988551735878, -0.012011879123747349, 0.0031782835721969604, 0.0037055278662592173, 0.004379977937787771, -0.02512366510927677, 0.02646988444030285, -0.014032806269824505, 0.07103979587554932, 0.04488198831677437, 0.030574269592761993, -0.019808759912848473, 0.0018097254214808345, 0.004861048888415098, 0.05718628317117691, 0.02132366970181465, 0.04922720044851303, -0.03215767815709114, -0.022662049159407616, -0.019905341789126396, -0.034561894834041595, 0.009566880762577057, 0.007937530986964703, -0.037419699132442474, -0.04170631989836693, 0.020457372069358826, -0.0004083092790096998, 0.030566439032554626, -0.009260871447622776, -0.04315473884344101, 0.008201279677450657, -0.03780825063586235, -0.0055363597348332405, -0.07299081981182098, -0.02710864692926407, 0.017572443932294846, -0.02357240952551365, 0.0433955043554306, -0.028997337445616722, 0.018600374460220337, -0.002449800493195653, 0.0012366315349936485, -0.020628107711672783, 0.010146953165531158, 0.047017525881528854, -0.04917951300740242, 0.010954499244689941, 0.016247203573584557, 0.02123226225376129, -0.04355374723672867, 0.06815492361783981, -0.014331765472888947, -0.08431154489517212, -0.0033222835045307875, -0.05968818441033363, 0.020158404484391212, 0.03283502534031868, -0.02373534068465233, 0.01760266348719597, -0.02208537608385086, -0.007513222750276327, 0.006913567893207073, -0.0481409877538681, 0.07786649465560913, 0.0778035894036293, -0.039889950305223465, 0.02090868167579174, 0.033736299723386765, 0.018884506076574326, 0.011750583536922932, -0.009248902089893818, -0.03580547869205475, -0.05383582040667534, 0.007545295171439648, 0.0006282146787270904, 0.043895136564970016, -0.04309020936489105, -0.002797316061332822, 0.060707807540893555, 0.02070034109055996, 0.005661328788846731, 0.017193511128425598, -0.03479699790477753, 0.017890799790620804, 0.04370690882205963, 0.04175494983792305, -0.0018943812465295196, 0.053170595318078995, -0.015773048624396324, 0.023408815264701843, -0.02004827745258808, 0.021292801946401596, 0.023745357990264893, 0.029532188549637794, 0.024237042292952538, 0.0009268323774449527, -0.021523848176002502, 0.0018322766991332173, 0.05023031681776047, -0.025202708318829536, 0.003202693071216345, 0.014278633520007133, 0.009116986766457558, 0.015922877937555313, 0.005920891184359789, -0.04070628061890602, 0.023907657712697983, 0.04497165232896805, -0.031024398282170296, 0.007427277974784374, 0.03216535598039627, -0.0012066008057445288, 0.022313350811600685, -0.007020596880465746, -0.007372889667749405, 0.004582215566188097, 0.004327627830207348, 0.02961554192006588, -0.002083403989672661, -0.02661856636404991, -0.020417630672454834, -0.046849895268678665, -0.029517438262701035, 0.0036687368992716074, 0.016774455085396767, 0.00005963144576526247, -0.07180583477020264, -0.02787032723426819, -0.003409553086385131, -0.015575775876641273, 0.031078362837433815, -0.007759475149214268, -0.0035799082834273577, -0.008064201101660728, 0.01041355263441801, -0.0296935997903347, -0.036977969110012054, -0.043561071157455444, 0.005743448156863451, -0.028619352728128433, -0.0058619314804673195, 0.06219341233372688, 0.010664470493793488, -0.04768964648246765, 0.030870288610458374, -0.030086291953921318, -0.05843031033873558, -0.029274364933371544, -0.017149172723293304, 0.007250854279845953, -0.02461005561053753, 0.018939796835184097, 0.04856561869382858, -0.015069827437400818, -0.05025105178356171, -0.08838832378387451, -0.04141388088464737, 0.04477923363447189, -0.021696774289011955, 0.0503171943128109, 0.018125761300325394, -0.03245484083890915, 0.09259316325187683, 0.020849717780947685, -0.02716476283967495, -0.03391548991203308, 0.013440779410302639, -0.02956226095557213, 0.003875999478623271, -0.028835631906986237, -0.00010489066335139796, 0.003184158354997635, 0.03743212670087814, 0.038906171917915344, 0.007900474593043327, 0.01049074437469244, 0.012099321000277996, -0.031259648501873016, 0.0023399419151246548, -0.01798730529844761, -0.0027330226730555296, 0.00378055009059608, 0.017244646325707436, -0.03130989894270897, 0.02154349349439144, -0.011646086350083351, 0.026383336633443832, 0.002459434326738119, -0.02109597437083721, 0.015369138680398464, -0.0027588834054768085, 0.0011762354988604784, -0.02872820943593979, 0.03475164249539375, -0.029290033504366875, 0.017502501606941223, 0.00555195240303874, 0.029176605865359306, 0.019743792712688446, -0.021685779094696045, 0.015465620905160904, 0.018652094528079033, 0.0460139736533165, -0.006873766425997019, -0.010650091804564, -0.024770919233560562, -0.009985852055251598, 0.0029869067948311567, -0.054048050194978714, -0.009645234793424606, 0.005993994418531656, 0.04921116679906845, -0.011360946111381054, 0.0032914343755692244, -0.04785905405879021, 0.0024045584723353386, -0.04409496486186981, -0.01329897902905941, -0.01476717833429575, 0.05698313191533089, -0.010027422569692135, 0.044830892235040665, 0.03686666861176491, -0.02168215438723564, 0.003244162304326892, -0.026850122958421707, -0.04725298658013344, 0.02654120698571205, -0.007881119847297668, -0.030528344213962555, 0.005885756574571133, -0.003098102519288659, 0.03863099217414856, -0.026413781568408012, -0.02529517002403736, -0.018561527132987976, 0.056800954043865204, -0.04162965342402458, 0.02738098055124283, -0.05143003910779953, -0.03767702728509903, -0.011634374968707561, 0.03817829117178917, 0.01937662623822689, -0.011380927637219429, 0.06269829720258713, 0.02278004214167595, 0.0009232557495124638, 0.01715008169412613, -0.043715160340070724, -0.008832273073494434, 0.015912426635622978, 0.020024331286549568, 0.034463997930288315, 0.0379844605922699, -0.007352999411523342, 0.04668614640831947, 0.028229862451553345, 0.06790239363908768, 0.059664927423000336, -0.011587810702621937, 0.003482137806713581, -0.05593101680278778, -0.036691442131996155, 0.0019864030182361603, 0.008689036592841148, -0.002107605803757906, 0.015127265825867653, 0.03322911635041237, 0.0013881009072065353, -0.0745059922337532, 0.014375119470059872, 0.03236236050724983, -0.009178434498608112, -0.009274783544242382, -0.03757976368069649, 0.037799935787916183, 0.005902543198317289, -0.015191338025033474, -0.0065050204284489155, 0.042074237018823624, 0.023734137415885925, -0.006370177026838064, 0.029932308942079544, -0.009856618009507656, -0.06146718189120293, 0.008090227842330933, 0.025932861492037773, 0.022476091980934143, 0.02443920262157917, -0.02708343230187893, 0.032545410096645355, 0.03846273571252823, 0.017657214775681496, 0.007739961612969637, 0.0010879315668717027, -0.07954341173171997, -0.015217671170830727, 0.04490841552615166, 0.04385768249630928, -0.026142438873648643, -0.025645224377512932, -0.01586289145052433, -0.019846772775053978, 0.053867485374212265, -0.0036023538559675217, 0.0374470092356205, -0.026109643280506134, -0.0004620841646101326, -0.024845371022820473, -0.007669743616133928, -0.03523566201329231, 0.04476534202694893, 0.010379382409155369, 0.03903726115822792, -0.025822017341852188, 0.020265931263566017, -0.03646281361579895, 0.026841113343834877, -0.0006541110924445093, 0.07141371071338654, -0.01525125652551651, -0.004611677024513483, -0.003796201664954424, 0.022519633173942566, -0.015310398302972317, -0.051049817353487015, 0.013116268441081047, -0.019937291741371155, -0.006418184377253056, 0.02142452448606491, -0.01777775026857853, -0.04402218386530876, 0.05384282395243645, -0.005935819819569588, 0.0011962531134486198, 0.021540455520153046, -0.007025171536952257, 0.031191905960440636, 0.018307534977793694, 0.005913058761507273, 0.01949159987270832, 0.02354941889643669, -0.02908322401344776, 0.030993791297078133, -0.007438961882144213, -0.04375713691115379, -0.02053401991724968, 0.006420898251235485, -0.010284124873578548, 0.019884565845131874, -0.032892707735300064, 0.025000764057040215, 0.03951325640082359, 0.012242401018738747, -0.011274493299424648, 0.0018707097042351961, -0.03607235103845596, 0.0019669404719024897, 0.013369891792535782, -0.0197917353361845, 0.021247079595923424, 0.007272546645253897, -0.0018477848498150706, 0.006343875080347061, 0.004339759703725576, -0.022548172622919083, 0.004613686818629503, 0.003234313102439046, -0.031018400564789772, 0.021522797644138336, -0.04277737811207771, 0.00816437415778637, 0.020603030920028687, -0.012241674587130547, 0.05316619947552681, 0.026122430339455605, 0.02973102778196335, -0.0272664874792099, -0.042951758950948715, -0.0004633375210687518, 0.018111947923898697, -0.008552879095077515, -0.0013397797010838985, -0.03413519263267517, 0.0014065982541069388, 0.013568449765443802, -0.016941890120506287, -0.04642713814973831, 0.00841143261641264, 0.009504405781626701, 0.010912962257862091, -0.014541554264724255, -0.023512985557317734, 0.005005806218832731, 0.00020795299496967345, -0.00011457622895250097, -0.0046509988605976105, 0.04773710295557976, 0.003991617355495691, -0.021712765097618103, 0.03461296483874321, 0.017834912985563278, 0.02731897123157978, -0.016966594383120537, -0.014243838377296925, -0.00186673435382545, -0.026576919481158257, -0.02684572897851467, 0.009981827810406685, -0.019922086969017982, -0.053915850818157196, -0.0136902229860425, -0.014243419282138348, 0.007839920930564404, 0.028443047776818275, -0.01220260001718998, 0.0064447131007909775, 0.0012161429040133953, -0.013323191553354263, -0.022823449224233627, 0.008617585524916649, -0.005784175358712673, -0.031630948185920715, 0.029028097167611122, -0.03638544678688049, 0.005988915450870991, -0.006123117171227932, 0.014142212457954884, 0.06330983340740204, 0.01127528678625822, -0.050445377826690674, -0.014281303621828556, 0.009667731821537018, -0.014091580174863338, -0.011959424242377281, -0.010428574867546558, 0.01842227764427662, 0.05057318136096001, 0.00016316914116032422, -0.02541709691286087, 0.05290175601840019, 0.02848614752292633, -0.02788976952433586, -0.010492480359971523, -0.0166019219905138, -0.016225317493081093, 0.0596599318087101, -0.020551461726427078, 0.06029214337468147, 0.017354298382997513, 0.0013342660386115313, -0.008267269469797611, 0.012782975099980831, -0.028425144031643867, -0.0184764564037323, 0.0020608610939234495, -0.00002648009467520751, -0.02262076921761036, 0.022769898176193237, 0.015906067565083504, 0.03771550953388214, 0.029226984828710556, -0.006284557748585939, -0.029321979731321335, 0.01966380886733532, 0.031125113368034363, -0.03207877278327942, -0.025093767791986465, 0.07359982281923294, -0.06390855461359024, -0.031380847096443176, 0.009868445806205273, -0.04503674432635307, 0.021913474425673485, 0.0029051280580461025, -0.001470131566748023, -0.01751760020852089, -0.02558898739516735, -0.08061037957668304, 0.012311208993196487, 0.005599884781986475, 0.01333703100681305, 0.029242096468806267, 0.0070827375166118145, 0.02231956273317337, 0.01651044562458992, 0.00604987470433116, -0.032153885811567307, -0.07292722910642624, -0.02483592927455902, -0.032129134982824326, -0.05868994817137718, -0.0016391014214605093, 0.028615588322281837, -0.036651674658060074, 0.05628802627325058, -0.026179460808634758, 0.02269023470580578, 0.012265595607459545, 0.012028568424284458, -0.03140769153833389, 0.0940694659948349, 0.04595007002353668, 0.06623508036136627, -0.0007329433574341238, 0.00775441899895668, 0.13500623404979706, 0.07813045382499695, 0.017848165705800056, -0.04841631278395653, -0.001082495553418994, 0.0361790657043457, -0.004123499151319265, -0.034906208515167236, 0.010471118614077568, 0.06179681792855263, 0.0010404560016468167, 0.00917078834027052, 0.005288297776132822, 0.006895516067743301, 0.015064693987369537, 0.04186028614640236, -0.0065069738775491714, -0.02444509044289589, 0.007206788752228022, 0.0298052616417408, -0.02605356276035309, -0.040467970073223114, -0.03156455233693123, 0.011327742598950863, 0.0042104050517082214, 0.007140017114579678, 0.02646218240261078, -0.0031193941831588745, -0.019406942650675774, -0.015547706745564938, 0.00427818251773715, 0.02079140953719616, 0.0007447475218214095, 0.001562934834510088, -0.03429751098155975, 0.003669142723083496, 0.012614536099135876, 0.0005701027112081647, 0.031227407976984978, 0.004883908666670322, -0.035425446927547455, 0.00614336971193552, -0.001196014927700162, -0.0023829746060073376, -0.04242022708058357, -0.040382739156484604, -0.05814050883054733, 0.009015222080051899, -0.013739845715463161, 0.01425079070031643, -0.0044141970574855804, -0.0442243367433548, 0.024570131674408913, -0.005865155719220638, -0.01701502688229084, 0.04697415232658386, 0.03732407093048096, -0.059017229825258255, -0.030815914273262024, -0.015626700595021248, 0.015726711601018906, -0.013168992474675179, 0.017110401764512062, 0.02300172671675682, -0.059911951422691345, -0.06600862741470337, -0.034692831337451935, 0.014680461958050728, -0.004667496774345636, -0.02233794704079628, 0.0024836394004523754, -0.044491879642009735, -0.047567401081323624, 0.01719667762517929, -0.01100744865834713, -0.005857836455106735, 0.033805739134550095, 0.027087267488241196, 0.0062844944186508656, 0.016108961775898933, -0.02519145980477333, 0.015271631069481373, -0.024219147861003876, 0.00196852907538414, 0.00403399346396327, -0.019327187910676003, 0.008095895871520042, 0.005068398080766201, -0.001186257228255272, -0.010185937397181988, -0.0038876717444509268, 0.017389675602316856, 0.02670285291969776, -0.060334961861371994, -0.004194414708763361, -0.0051451376639306545, -0.06395148485898972, -0.0046852221712470055, -0.01659037359058857, 0.04108884930610657, -0.0020510489121079445, 0.017193833366036415, -0.028758136555552483, 0.009752395562827587, 0.004606262780725956, 0.0089179128408432, 0.015977200120687485, -0.08735067397356033, -0.013081654906272888, -0.007486882619559765, 0.007175460923463106, -0.023473000153899193, -0.01679554209113121, -0.04128638654947281, -0.0017626623157411814, 0.025107135996222496, -0.03178602084517479, -0.03289824724197388, 0.0013804907212033868, -0.009682362899184227, 0.009901151061058044, 0.0027949295472353697, 0.012862755917012691, -0.020517710596323013, -0.004942672792822123, -0.026222482323646545, 0.005969765596091747, 0.03734142333269119, 0.023915186524391174, 0.025829892605543137, -0.017555104568600655, -0.006461193319410086, -0.0002897251397371292, 0.01178601011633873, 0.00012699072249233723, -0.007974402979016304, 0.015060609206557274, 0.0537545308470726, -0.046335574239492416, -0.018891090527176857, 0.05455411598086357, -0.03508858382701874, -0.040739577263593674, 0.01991797424852848, 0.01803932897746563, 0.04659976065158844, 0.024010421708226204, -0.0353890098631382, 0.00423648115247488, 0.006646713241934776, -0.05286049470305443, -0.010653844103217125, 0.01898328587412834, -0.0037068836390972137, 0.006330322474241257, 0.011350269429385662, 0.0007960484945215285, 0.00981096364557743, 0.02434431202709675, -0.01700051687657833, 0.05089760571718216, -0.005327367689460516, -0.018429704010486603, 0.03209212049841881, 0.00924277026206255, 0.039056651294231415, -0.019108664244413376, 0.002577292500063777, 0.027410099282860756, 0.042793046683073044, -0.01942148059606552, 0.031573228538036346, -0.017197340726852417, 0.006894939113408327, -0.07608809322118759, -0.006440651137381792, 0.03510405868291855, 0.03423691540956497, 0.04460853338241577, -0.06510479003190994, 0.0472540445625782, 0.0136443255469203, -0.018421156331896782, 0.012086107395589352, -0.017765870317816734, 0.019027894362807274, -0.010000963695347309, 0.03717741742730141, -0.03855587914586067, 0.03884134441614151, 0.011095547117292881, 0.02467527613043785, 0.024452408775687218, 0.025710243731737137, 0.02115822769701481, -0.023453041911125183, -0.07614944130182266, -0.006525504868477583, -0.01763535849750042, -0.04157422482967377, 0.02769838646054268, -0.04362386092543602, -0.059971943497657776, 0.0414309948682785, 0.010813617147505283, 0.032459162175655365, -0.0016313858795911074, 0.059499237686395645, 0.01635168492794037, 0.03153352066874504, 0.009434742853045464, -0.06113499775528908, -0.02836175262928009, -0.0157626960426569, 0.03207217901945114, 0.014338215813040733, -0.017765596508979797, 0.04732007160782814, 0.04548106715083122, -0.005521512124687433, -0.00791244488209486, 0.05436870828270912, -0.019972631707787514, -0.03342915326356888, 0.03965914621949196, -0.04311293363571167, 0.02038196474313736, -0.043870147317647934, 0.02394966408610344, -0.029661543667316437, 0.009286795742809772, 0.019174814224243164, 0.003290182678028941, -0.006939345970749855, -0.007374241948127747, -0.01445737574249506, -0.05742524191737175, 0.015587910078465939, -0.003933318890631199, -0.002823550719767809, -0.03571112081408501, 0.019961051642894745, -0.0007668798789381981, 0.032752957195043564, -0.0355101116001606, -0.004815536085516214, -0.044450659304857254, 0.06008737161755562, -0.029041757807135582, 0.019910046830773354, -0.0028262471314519644, -0.036146726459264755, 0.002007151488214731, -0.10339614003896713, 0.02981492131948471, 0.06741919368505478, 0.016803346574306488, -0.005485227331519127, 0.01789569854736328, -0.025283530354499817, -0.027747849002480507, 0.02542111650109291, 0.019617758691310883, -0.018360212445259094, 0.014881426468491554, -0.023189693689346313, 0.016789235174655914, -0.049371249973773956, 0.02575104869902134, -0.04044066369533539, 0.011571560986340046, -0.03038659691810608, -0.0020484940614551306, 0.011175472289323807, 0.020350610837340355, 0.02428038790822029, -0.022647378966212273, -0.04404967278242111, -0.026857290416955948, -0.00944635458290577, 0.05036470293998718, 0.037395041435956955, -0.005944750737398863, 0.023295588791370392, 0.009696438908576965, 0.018074484542012215, 0.02237306907773018, 0.037181075662374496, -0.024700213223695755, 0.04321718588471413, -0.02151072397828102, -0.07193072885274887, 0.018694382160902023, 0.009680009447038174, -0.010972928255796432, -0.09994129836559296, -0.05025831237435341, 0.046778395771980286, -0.05791058763861656, 0.010504331439733505, 0.04239377751946449, 0.006610115058720112, 0.028327576816082, 0.024601854383945465, 0.024789810180664062, 0.027991782873868942, -0.019007084891200066, -0.020685069262981415, 0.0288139246404171, 0.07161687314510345, 0.008649292401969433, 0.03057890571653843, -0.002732126973569393, -0.0017389347776770592, 0.05427930876612663, 0.0013294342206791043, 0.06683050096035004, -0.027888955548405647, -0.003148485906422138, 0.029433969408273697, 0.0017740370240062475, 0.0021605701185762882, 0.008048943243920803, -0.012139164842665195, 0.0627574473619461, -0.02473274990916252, 0.004908428527414799, -0.0531175471842289, 0.008772284723818302, -0.0285724475979805, -0.022514156997203827, 0.013083248399198055, 0.04902949929237366, 0.03736399859189987, 0.016700267791748047, -0.005428111180663109, 0.012754414230585098, 0.0036243407521396875, -0.03905363753437996, 0.053298693150281906, 0.0040812380611896515, 0.006032138597220182, 0.01725332997739315, -0.04630956053733826, -0.03404431417584419, -0.004943939857184887, -0.003816151525825262, 0.025880496948957443, 0.07221372425556183, -0.011142750270664692, -0.052657272666692734, -0.0016072636935859919, 0.04432085156440735, -0.05582406371831894, 0.0018404264701530337, -0.07373955845832825, 0.012703493237495422, 0.0009510935051366687, -0.021894747391343117 ]
<p>the following problem came up recently while analyzing data. If the random variable X follows a normal distribution and Y follows a $\chi^2_n$ distribution (with n dof), how is $Z = X^2 + Y^2$ distributed? Up to now I came up with the pdf of $Y^2$: \begin{eqnarray} \psi^2_n(x) &amp;=&amp; \frac{\partial F(\sqrt{x})}{\partial x} \\ &amp;=&amp; \left( \int_0^{\sqrt{x}} \frac{t^{n/2-1}\cdot e^{-t/2}}{2^{n/2}\Gamma(n/2)} \mathrm{d}t \right)^\prime_x \\ &amp;=&amp; \frac{1}{2^{n/2}\Gamma(n/2)} \cdot \left( \sqrt{x} \right)^{n/2-1} \cdot e^{-\sqrt{x}/2} \cdot \left( \sqrt{x} \right)^\prime_x \\ &amp;=&amp; \frac{1}{2^{n/2-1}\Gamma(n/2)} \cdot x^{n/4-1} \cdot e^{-\sqrt{x}/2} \end{eqnarray}</p> <p>as well as some simplifications for the convolution integral ($X^2$ has the pdf $\chi^2_m$ with m dof):</p> <p>\begin{eqnarray} K_{mn}(t) &amp;:=&amp; ( \chi^2_m \ast \psi^2_n )(t) \\ &amp;=&amp; \int_0^t \chi^2_m(x) \cdot \psi^2_n(t-x) \mathrm{d}x \\ &amp;=&amp; \left( 2^{\frac{(n+m)}{2}+1} \Gamma(\frac{m}{2}) \Gamma(\frac{n}{2}) \right)^{-1} \cdot \int_0^t (t-x)^{\frac{n}{4}-1} \cdot x^{\frac{m}{2}-1} \cdot \exp(-(\sqrt{t-x}+x)/2) \mathrm{d}x \end{eqnarray}</p> <p>Does someone see a good way of calculating this integral for any real t or does it have to be computed numerically? Or am I missing a much simpler solution?</p> <p>Thanks!</p>
73,934
[ 0.039317041635513306, -0.036364391446113586, 0.031131330877542496, -0.038189828395843506, 0.03519516438245773, -0.0012887658085674047, 0.023575637489557266, -0.07965684682130814, 0.020489977672696114, -0.046368084847927094, 0.08040077984333038, 0.007029690779745579, 0.04294465109705925, 0.027596715837717056, 0.02377364970743656, 0.0037949203979223967, -0.04658140614628792, -0.010332789272069931, -0.00897342897951603, -0.031774699687957764, -0.016162196174263954, 0.03711862489581108, -0.01760794222354889, -0.0018774239579215646, -0.07010480016469955, 0.04676954448223114, -0.01973569579422474, 0.0008962057763710618, -0.000752009975258261, 0.06544621288776398, -0.055704470723867416, -0.0206304918974638, 0.03331216052174568, 0.061987731605768204, -0.020047161728143692, 0.0008481772383674979, -0.040628522634506226, -0.06438393145799637, -0.0010162589605897665, 0.031534940004348755, -0.05719559267163277, -0.013466655276715755, -0.030533721670508385, 0.006692694500088692, -0.01213689986616373, 0.014019892551004887, 0.004903168883174658, -0.03416215255856514, 0.02718513272702694, -0.029056942090392113, 0.08338996022939682, 0.0487871989607811, 0.008181165903806686, 0.03207378461956978, -0.006500163581222296, -0.021231088787317276, 0.03445333242416382, 0.07761508226394653, 0.013521268963813782, -0.05047127231955528, -0.014471116475760937, -0.03282129019498825, -0.0050654360093176365, -0.05472602695226669, 0.0030006568413227797, -0.01187833771109581, 0.023892192170023918, -0.031529638916254044, -0.02872380055487156, -0.04683757200837135, 0.02695709839463234, 0.03742160275578499, 0.023762524127960205, -0.010914902202785015, -0.0240767914801836, 0.008592884056270123, 0.0063238609582185745, -0.005437110085040331, 0.018886443227529526, -0.025437569245696068, 0.012990260496735573, 0.013431517407298088, 0.009588969871401787, 0.010854396037757397, -0.0019932501018047333, 0.01515810377895832, 0.08620895445346832, -0.023464301601052284, 0.022013776004314423, 0.021274829283356667, -0.001427041250281036, 0.013168109580874443, 0.07670034468173981, -0.05830678343772888, -0.01597423106431961, 0.040841784328222275, -0.03866706043481827, 0.028199797496199608, -0.013837833888828754, 0.005981573835015297, -0.027267111465334892, -0.04098537936806679, 0.014887383207678795, 0.08673788607120514, -0.010522029362618923, -0.025092098861932755, -0.003815388074144721, 0.0072676087729632854, -0.02690272592008114, -0.015458025969564915, -0.022471990436315536, 0.03897218406200409, -0.026590734720230103, 0.02070370502769947, 0.009386636316776276, -0.017025701701641083, -0.009910178370773792, -0.032752905040979385, 0.05894167348742485, 0.052147988229990005, 0.03415714576840401, -0.02481965161859989, 0.018660329282283783, -0.029742257669568062, -0.040847569704055786, 0.03299419581890106, 0.01782924495637417, 0.007646126206964254, -0.06136586517095566, 0.015023657120764256, 0.02185235545039177, -0.0027137426659464836, 0.016996337100863457, 0.026682090014219284, 0.002526606433093548, -0.015682781115174294, -0.06287240236997604, -0.03605007752776146, 0.04884412884712219, -0.010658490471541882, 0.03657985106110573, -0.0813712626695633, -0.007912276312708855, 0.03645990788936615, 0.0835452601313591, -0.028572211042046547, 0.0489480197429657, -0.0022746494505554438, 0.01854691095650196, 0.026339948177337646, -0.019706398248672485, -0.03797229751944542, -0.02456865832209587, -0.039846271276474, 0.03947883099317551, -0.02218397706747055, 0.04141068086028099, 0.01174178346991539, -0.007752050645649433, -0.02650574781000614, 0.05801134184002876, -0.007841992191970348, -0.005331462249159813, 0.004795768763870001, 0.055082935839891434, -0.03668335825204849, 0.061600908637046814, 0.03138282895088196, 0.014736779034137726, 0.01799466647207737, -0.014816795475780964, 0.01320089865475893, -0.010109126567840576, 0.05237181484699249, -0.003932447638362646, -0.06625775247812271, -0.01853753812611103, -0.04230918735265732, 0.008143991231918335, 0.015530386939644814, -0.020622216165065765, -0.006828518118709326, -0.036691077053546906, 0.012082631699740887, 0.033997565507888794, 0.029046224430203438, 0.037791844457387924, 0.004946037195622921, -0.0051119523122906685, -0.03498861938714981, -0.048081476241350174, -0.030793307349085808, 0.002430605236440897, -0.008482763543725014, -0.058186307549476624, 0.007141852285712957, -0.025836000218987465, 0.0339946411550045, 0.012343652546405792, -0.01245889626443386, -0.004040122032165527, 0.015644267201423645, 0.01447397843003273, -0.01704583503305912, 0.02195054106414318, 0.013011351227760315, 0.02299153059720993, 0.011706061661243439, 0.0366702638566494, -0.03984367102384567, -0.04087495431303978, -0.015542123466730118, -0.031239600852131844, 0.047093819826841354, -0.0033124128822237253, -0.04030812904238701, -0.0095018045976758, -0.043312814086675644, -0.039211951196193695, 0.015889843925833702, -0.053725067526102066, 0.023723607882857323, 0.03485046327114105, -0.005366290453821421, -0.0022751297801733017, 0.014241705648601055, -0.004538173787295818, 0.017326166853308678, -0.026854759082198143, -0.003960643894970417, -0.05491658300161362, -0.03150545805692673, 0.061489325016736984, 0.06775884330272675, -0.049945130944252014, 0.011832955293357372, 0.0196219552308321, 0.008264769800007343, 0.03902290388941765, -0.0198396947234869, 0.009132842533290386, -0.05960649996995926, 0.005327251739799976, 0.010186934843659401, 0.011329803615808487, 0.02609368972480297, 0.03445310518145561, -0.0054147434420883656, 0.01860017329454422, 0.02140389382839203, -0.041466981172561646, 0.028231395408511162, -0.02639288455247879, 0.0323420874774456, -0.041112545877695084, 0.014578486792743206, 0.02394789643585682, 0.008916017599403858, -0.011282207444310188, 0.04564668983221054, 0.010345074348151684, 0.0014813384041190147, 0.0006074607954360545, -0.026493871584534645, 0.05168568715453148, -0.0012152333511039615, -0.0319194570183754, -0.020337022840976715, -0.00027204977232031524, 0.011675383895635605, -0.022270575165748596, -0.019511807709932327, -0.05581691116094589, 0.0007790721138007939, 0.02974400855600834, 0.031155474483966827, -0.011166173033416271, -0.004674417432397604, -0.0019086831016466022, -0.03848043829202652, 0.02296329289674759, 0.026378653943538666, 0.022360194474458694, 0.0010095176985487342, -0.05835344269871712, -0.043735604733228683, -0.036430489271879196, 0.008055158890783787, 0.027442628517746925, -0.011709384620189667, 0.03505883365869522, 0.008468739688396454, -0.021392889320850372, -0.017037956044077873, -0.02165917679667473, -0.011780106462538242, -0.030422713607549667, -0.05347764492034912, -0.036795809864997864, 0.055552657693624496, 0.027691854164004326, -0.017203686758875847, 0.0428089015185833, -0.025869255885481834, -0.05282941460609436, -0.03474825248122215, -0.015045306645333767, 0.058593109250068665, -0.040046047419309616, 0.04968956857919693, 0.0159453172236681, 0.01794138178229332, 0.013293626718223095, -0.07283633202314377, -0.03161011263728142, 0.009643330238759518, -0.011590140871703625, 0.0055292509496212006, 0.02457389235496521, -0.027455605566501617, 0.08407792448997498, 0.002122037811204791, 0.009999840520322323, 0.01703481376171112, 0.02503451704978943, -0.01949971169233322, -0.0410853736102581, 0.025880116969347, 0.01923884078860283, -0.03654477000236511, 0.054424043744802475, -0.01854179985821247, -0.008007646538317204, 0.047692157328128815, -0.040440455079078674, -0.017547139897942543, 0.04151342809200287, 0.005928833968937397, 0.0016081981593742967, 0.021255573257803917, 0.007716102059930563, -0.019393377006053925, 0.02492770366370678, 0.02333172783255577, -0.019226843491196632, 0.006046833470463753, -0.026446053758263588, 0.032925598323345184, -0.055001989006996155, -0.00116017647087574, -0.03085773065686226, 0.058765750378370285, 0.05217774584889412, -0.06126343831419945, -0.03288894519209862, 0.03168261796236038, 0.028664451092481613, -0.016648072749376297, 0.01881062053143978, 0.0482448972761631, 0.027435481548309326, 0.019723737612366676, -0.003671646350994706, -0.0271099004894495, 0.011744298972189426, 0.04104464873671532, -0.018086211755871773, 0.00518164923414588, 0.007841804064810276, 0.0372028611600399, -0.003857809817418456, -0.04732193425297737, 0.0057256887666881084, -0.009631807915866375, -0.04211137443780899, -0.010846220888197422, -0.05746404454112053, 0.04094527289271355, 0.0180981308221817, 0.041372671723365784, -0.013602139428257942, -0.010477572679519653, -0.026554832234978676, 0.04153226688504219, -0.058340247720479965, -0.0007254877127707005, -0.02001236379146576, -0.013066289015114307, -0.021129289641976357, 0.006976630073040724, 0.043138567358255386, 0.022117936983704567, 0.009136971086263657, 0.0011106617748737335, -0.023868482559919357, -0.027690516784787178, 0.01895887963473797, -0.026049884036183357, 0.009152264334261417, -0.0302719883620739, 0.04914099723100662, 0.0032919624354690313, -0.020430391654372215, -0.011732134036719799, 0.01810416765511036, -0.012165717780590057, 0.008498752489686012, -0.04881851375102997, -0.0009300102246925235, 0.017090918496251106, 0.030989957973361015, -0.024769186973571777, 0.0006123596103861928, -0.003203969681635499, -0.001147720031440258, -0.01965917833149433, 0.055528756231069565, 0.04159035161137581, -0.012531952001154423, 0.0019785785116255283, -0.009207536466419697, -0.014312009327113628, 0.010703657753765583, 0.053202588111162186, 0.027845703065395355, 0.027316642925143242, 0.039412032812833786, -0.006580672226846218, 0.012137392535805702, -0.009346778504550457, 0.02576722390949726, -0.031246475875377655, 0.00039063513395376503, -0.03417152911424637, 0.03477705270051956, -0.0029291941318660975, -0.00027756195049732924, -0.008696042001247406, -0.013058517128229141, -0.044328805059194565, -0.012804597616195679, 0.021765798330307007, 0.03583613783121109, 0.01069795060902834, -0.0009687876445241272, 0.05887695029377937, 0.028122389689087868, 0.036164965480566025, -0.023990241810679436, 0.04297040402889252, 0.031071104109287262, 0.009248809888958931, 0.0077500720508396626, -0.03676886111497879, -0.05967818573117256, 0.004716681782156229, 0.07040069997310638, 0.03825996816158295, -0.010144361294806004, -0.01743292063474655, -0.059084437787532806, -0.022622518241405487, -0.0014910121681168675, -0.005044459365308285, 0.019322657957673073, 0.000619240163359791, 0.00920211710035801, 0.014065353199839592, -0.05148734897375107, -0.07984849810600281, 0.004747603554278612, 0.009926504455506802, 0.003146491479128599, -0.05058582127094269, -0.0329696349799633, -0.07242989540100098, -0.012887906283140182, 0.015582075342535973, 0.04652458801865578, -0.023406950756907463, -0.036084145307540894, -0.016910644248127937, 0.026846008375287056, -0.005091528873890638, -0.058649692684412, 0.022459199652075768, -0.004801715724170208, -0.008054036647081375, 0.032664403319358826, -0.006691459100693464, -0.055557072162628174, 0.040278468281030655, 0.018294833600521088, -0.013547985814511776, 0.0565665103495121, -0.006468744482845068, 0.05278334394097328, 0.051546718925237656, 0.04206474870443344, 0.06729324162006378, 0.0471213236451149, -0.0133713623508811, -0.008670619688928127, -0.03577643260359764, 0.03482259064912796, -0.03631586953997612, -0.001615681336261332, -0.022319111973047256, -0.04601244255900383, -0.007795942947268486, 0.03739017993211746, -0.010776805691421032, 0.03142785280942917, 0.003160052699968219, -0.014353948645293713, 0.011182133108377457, 0.002536589978262782, 0.004670079797506332, 0.018354501575231552, -0.01892935298383236, -0.001571528846397996, 0.029408035799860954, -0.027438418939709663, 0.02534235268831253, -0.0056859408505260944, -0.008333479054272175, 0.03444946929812431, -0.021168749779462814, -0.01378401555120945, -0.03347359597682953, -0.03638268634676933, 0.010976739227771759, 0.006315005477517843, 0.018356144428253174, 0.01927606761455536, 0.02068745717406273, 0.022409699857234955, -0.033507589250802994, -0.025033412501215935, 0.011479784734547138, -0.012791935354471207, 0.0034058536402881145, -0.015732064843177795, 0.0030633602291345596, 0.05145176872611046, 0.008249561302363873, -0.09083516150712967, 0.0028762808069586754, -0.0018195138545706868, -0.044441238045692444, 0.027955984696745872, -0.03300000727176666, -0.0264559555798769, -0.005594443064182997, -0.04619884118437767, 0.0055586108937859535, 0.07033880054950714, -0.008257321082055569, -0.023899197578430176, -0.018155204132199287, 0.03955647349357605, 0.048594336956739426, -0.022670496255159378, -0.024258850142359734, 0.02063833922147751, -0.02780064567923546, -0.04695890098810196, 0.01801549829542637, 0.031946130096912384, -0.009547711350023746, 0.012288607656955719, 0.013117698021233082, -0.01486817467957735, 0.036268725991249084, -0.05428463593125343, -0.0644177496433258, 0.03328171744942665, 0.00861395988613367, 0.018176041543483734, -0.016681870445609093, -0.05142504349350929, 0.04577121511101723, 0.020751848816871643, -0.028075316920876503, -0.05614915117621422, -0.004392467439174652, -0.046455495059490204, 0.02089719846844673, -0.004153435118496418, -0.018450943753123283, 0.002522681374102831, 0.04861554875969887, -0.015433366410434246, -0.020531361922621727, -0.028574327006936073, 0.015572941862046719, 0.016527729108929634, 0.031329356133937836, -0.008374262601137161, 0.017951535061001778, -0.008771644905209541, -0.02536144107580185, 0.01152122300118208, -0.0414544939994812, 0.000793496030382812, 0.07219886779785156, 0.0025980512145906687, 0.04166550561785698, -0.02277059108018875, -0.013800453394651413, -0.012148038484156132, -0.02729116939008236, 0.011599889025092125, 0.023048633709549904, -0.028243111446499825, 0.04026209935545921, -0.012877004221081734, -0.017190052196383476, 0.012329493649303913, -0.024514351040124893, -0.005389612168073654, 0.022287700325250626, 0.008209451101720333, 0.03853808343410492, 0.01967342011630535, -0.02450263686478138, -0.03109324909746647, 0.03674102947115898, -0.039669714868068695, 0.021404076367616653, -0.008892209269106388, 0.0010424248175695539, 0.047980211675167084, 0.035824570804834366, -0.014843806624412537, -0.021621745079755783, -0.004749161656945944, -0.011239903047680855, -0.01660103350877762, 0.041273608803749084, -0.02298527956008911, 0.03723863139748573, 0.007331355940550566, 0.02940557524561882, -0.013339170254766941, 0.01571575738489628, -0.010382532142102718, -0.05431385710835457, 0.006001387257128954, 0.004775842651724815, -0.03521712124347687, 0.010263847187161446, -0.01582713983952999, -0.022370176389813423, 0.009888282977044582, -0.03033248707652092, 0.009923904202878475, 0.012207521125674248, 0.004769764840602875, -0.030748063698410988, 0.07963836938142776, 0.018325231969356537, 0.006534834858030081, -0.0338420569896698, 0.0028625363484025, 0.12946893274784088, 0.055215489119291306, 0.018992014229297638, -0.04483884200453758, -0.021714812144637108, -0.040833406150341034, 0.03610921651124954, -0.0308097954839468, -0.01966151036322117, -0.008413849398493767, -0.025706060230731964, 0.03693050891160965, 0.062321268022060394, 0.02748742140829563, -0.030655434355139732, 0.02572665549814701, 0.008714207448065281, -0.025821952149271965, 0.006798081565648317, 0.03887540102005005, -0.024599280208349228, 0.002414921298623085, -0.03225211799144745, 0.013649458065629005, -0.012686087749898434, 0.029656313359737396, -0.040979836136102676, -0.03049156814813614, -0.020407533273100853, -0.04509517922997475, -0.03968307375907898, -0.007797071244567633, 0.04711804538965225, -0.020350871607661247, 0.013866388238966465, 0.0009034568211063743, 0.020359031856060028, -0.020054887980222702, 0.049037180840969086, 0.033311109989881516, 0.011358765885233879, -0.005665389820933342, 0.04907713457942009, 0.01775580458343029, -0.03520480915904045, -0.0418047271668911, -0.021894730627536774, 0.056799158453941345, 0.018127938732504845, -0.009241937659680843, -0.0009212240111082792, -0.004404769279062748, -0.01449759304523468, 0.005865525454282761, 0.012415111996233463, 0.029560038819909096, 0.01816519908607006, -0.023988910019397736, 0.0038200041744858027, 0.006977316457778215, 0.03131593391299248, 0.02681482955813408, 0.01860315352678299, 0.02085324376821518, -0.01889040879905224, -0.01536859292536974, 0.00757391145452857, 0.0078665129840374, -0.010465921834111214, -0.03694038465619087, -0.021163787692785263, -0.011857807636260986, -0.03836962208151817, -0.027950655668973923, 0.018904022872447968, -0.04247865453362465, 0.0431244932115078, 0.005350517574697733, -0.014859146438539028, -0.03123028762638569, -0.04987294599413872, 0.03849831223487854, 0.012373974546790123, 0.017115628346800804, -0.024415111169219017, -0.01657852903008461, 0.02105972357094288, 0.020119069144129753, -0.010273140855133533, -0.013832122087478638, 0.008039348758757114, 0.07732488960027695, 0.023642776533961296, -0.028928278014063835, -0.0066050756722688675, 0.03139205276966095, -0.01980895921587944, -0.014968116767704487, -0.009064880199730396, -0.00029347208328545094, 0.01595565862953663, 0.05065162107348442, -0.015079461969435215, 0.03957569599151611, -0.020623767748475075, 0.014347575604915619, -0.01391963753849268, -0.05015650391578674, 0.01449969969689846, 0.009270387701690197, 0.027563801035284996, -0.017007136717438698, -0.016985062509775162, 0.0001699911372270435, -0.02113875187933445, -0.021780498325824738, -0.003977883607149124, -0.017582276836037636, -0.03401819244027138, -0.03137630224227905, -0.010811127722263336, 0.025486964732408524, 0.013779379427433014, -0.00875524990260601, -0.005733567755669355, -0.025682492181658745, -0.012180172838270664, -0.0080135902389884, 0.04472872242331505, 0.014322246424853802, 0.004616478458046913, 0.023723749443888664, 0.027316702529788017, -0.02484155260026455, -0.013325793668627739, -0.0010720419231802225, -0.011608152650296688, 0.00949886068701744, 0.04116060957312584, -0.005116621498018503, 0.045458029955625534, -0.02216433174908161, -0.03633103892207146, 0.02006266452372074, 0.0056913369335234165, 0.0076996153220534325, 0.024670684710144997, 0.026932071894407272, -0.043043918907642365, 0.02798030897974968, -0.0365651473402977, -0.024043895304203033, -0.00050252495566383, -0.025757497176527977, 0.012717314064502716, -0.022339265793561935, 0.025088828057050705, -0.014041397720575333, 0.01085256040096283, 0.03433539718389511, 0.032244760543107986, -0.007322716526687145, 0.008212730288505554, 0.020779665559530258, -0.03884914889931679, 0.028671758249402046, 0.005939651280641556, 0.009621825069189072, 0.05298119783401489, 0.04399880766868591, -0.019965292885899544, 0.012273449450731277, -0.04075777158141136, -0.0022177593782544136, -0.090737484395504, -0.03359520062804222, 0.03469158709049225, 0.03599618747830391, 0.08070698380470276, -0.05231379717588425, -0.0006440112483687699, 0.01611972786486149, -0.043327536433935165, -0.008216810412704945, -0.028220850974321365, -0.02012876234948635, -0.02778574265539646, -0.008343745954334736, 0.00787639245390892, 0.04174226522445679, 0.03500280901789665, 0.02115136943757534, 0.05281724035739899, 0.020580442622303963, -0.010408761911094189, 0.040405165404081345, 0.004342405591160059, 0.0009111605468206108, 0.007888431660830975, -0.006544658448547125, 0.08103717863559723, -0.022531962022185326, 0.0004610978648997843, 0.054512035101652145, 0.003969118464738131, 0.015313168056309223, -0.050096139311790466, 0.021430758759379387, 0.02978329546749592, 0.01388510037213564, 0.02153070643544197, 0.009214780293405056, 0.04078762233257294, -0.02150770090520382, 0.0656910389661789, 0.0029134706128388643, -0.03296578675508499, -0.011708976700901985, 0.02631141059100628, 0.001832031412050128, -0.02187664806842804, 0.046544432640075684, 0.014819971285760403, -0.03594787418842316, 0.010808238759636879, -0.027334237471222878, 0.029426515102386475, 0.007039199583232403, 0.0671665146946907, -0.05862573906779289, -0.016662463545799255, 0.007634976878762245, 0.04495387151837349, 0.006610147189348936, 0.007478988729417324, -0.006061013787984848, -0.06479701399803162, 0.05897582694888115, 0.011514616198837757, 0.000752326799556613, -0.05491481348872185, -0.03379729762673378, -0.03549477458000183, 0.024932969361543655, 0.027680471539497375, -0.002081016544252634, -0.053107623010873795, 0.01837138831615448, -0.009063106030225754, 0.03255457803606987, -0.015711333602666855, 0.003076971508562565, 0.010673971846699715, -0.08228078484535217, 0.03261006996035576, -0.009705787524580956, -0.037880897521972656, 0.002419816330075264, 0.031095385551452637, -0.011310038156807423, -0.008739184588193893, 0.06983933597803116, 0.012038633227348328, 0.019223565235733986, -0.006817306857556105, 0.033093202859163284, 0.04244040325284004, -0.07636623829603195, -0.010144460014998913, -0.004104750230908394, 0.0058388845063745975, -0.039903558790683746, 0.02503487467765808, 0.0068970913998782635, 0.037611350417137146, 0.014018946327269077, 0.0037936759181320667, 0.014415694400668144, 0.010421295650303364, -0.015476145781576633, 0.022521043196320534, -0.016186831519007683, -0.036881398409605026, 0.04372668266296387, -0.037961412221193314, -0.0038705524057149887, 0.033456966280937195, -0.019461961463093758, -0.05001593381166458, 0.002357764635235071, -0.011821821331977844, -0.03422403335571289, 0.01579352281987667, 0.02560530975461006, 0.02337382733821869, -0.04602362960577011, -0.038666147738695145, 0.02947189100086689, -0.045690104365348816, -0.038245789706707, 0.03636983036994934, 0.05935506522655487, 0.016644125804305077, 0.03209501504898071, 0.004602721426635981, 0.0009901869343593717, 0.002342620864510536, 0.04285219684243202, -0.03186760097742081, -0.012640382163226604, -0.013162432238459587, -0.008076874539256096, -0.017444279044866562, -0.03300849348306656, 0.03252866864204407, -0.0160168819129467, 0.011551517061889172, -0.03935444727540016, -0.005681643262505531, 0.07889104634523392, -0.01766582392156124, 0.027899090200662613, -0.0013133232714608312, -0.027492903172969818, 0.06302287429571152, -0.0013246076414361596, 0.030373306944966316, -0.04143507033586502, -0.009066618047654629, -0.006100931670516729, 0.020227618515491486, 0.06351149827241898, 0.027139440178871155, 0.007905930280685425, 0.0234769769012928, -0.012660137377679348, -0.0026696310378611088, 0.013248657807707787, -0.036912016570568085, 0.01765291765332222, -0.02661914937198162, -0.027880260720849037, -0.011417663656175137, -0.06949619203805923, -0.005949980579316616, -0.029463129118084908, 0.022800255566835403, 0.03127346560359001, 0.020300686359405518, 0.019269991666078568, -0.022223351523280144, -0.009624629281461239, 0.06488392502069473, -0.07963844388723373, -0.006089902948588133, -0.01051398366689682, -0.0026339879259467125, 0.0392850786447525, -0.023501424118876457 ]
<p>In hypothesis testing, one must decide between two probability distributions $P_1(x)$ and $P_2(x)$ on a finite set $X$, after observing $n$ i.i.d. samples $x_1,...,x_n$ drawn from the unknown distribution. Let $A_n\subseteq X^n$ denote the chosen acceptance region for $P_1$. The error probabilities of type I and II can be expressed thus</p> <p>$$ \alpha_n = P^n_1(A^c_n)$$ $$ \beta_n = P^n_2(A_n)$$</p> <p>(Cover &amp; Thomas, Ch. 11 is an excellent reference for the definitions and facts mentioned in this post). </p> <p>Assume we have chosen the acceptance regions $A_n$'s ($n\geq 1$), so that both error probabilities approach zero as the number of observations grows: $\alpha_n\rightarrow 0$ and $\beta_n\rightarrow 0$ as $n\rightarrow \infty$. Stein's Lemma tells us that the maximum rate of deacrease of both error probabilities is determined, to the first order of the exponent, by the the KL-distance between the given distributions. More precisely</p> <p>$$ -\frac 1 n \log \alpha_n \rightarrow D(P_2||P_1)\tag{1}$$ $$ -\frac 1 n \log \beta_n \rightarrow D(P_1||P_2)\tag{2}$$</p> <p>Now, consider the Bayesian version of the hypothesis testing problem. In this case, $P_1$ and $P_2$ are given prior probabilities $\pi_1$ and $\pi_2$, respectively, and the error probability is obtained by weighting $\alpha_n$ and $\beta_n$:</p> <p>$$ e_n = \pi_1\alpha_n + \pi_2\beta_n.\tag{3}$$</p> <p>In this case, the optimal exponent for $e_n$ is given by Chernoff distance between the given distributions:</p> <p>$$ -\frac 1 n \log e_n \rightarrow C(P_1,P_2).$$</p> <p><strong>Question</strong>: what is wrong in the reasoning below? (Disclaimer: I'm <em>not</em> trying to be fully formal/detailed here).</p> <p>By (3), the decrease rate of $e_n$ is the minimum deacrease rate of $\alpha_n$ and $\beta_n$:</p> <p>$$ \lim -\frac 1 n \log e_n = \min\{\lim -\frac 1 n \log \alpha_n, \lim -\frac 1 n \log \beta_n\}$$.</p> <p>Since $e_n\rightarrow 0$, one must have both $\alpha_n\rightarrow 0$ and $\beta_n\rightarrow 0$ as $n\rightarrow \infty$. So, by the previous considerations on Stein's Lemma, and (1) and (2), one would get </p> <p>$$ \lim -\frac 1 n \log e_n = \min\{D(P_1||P_2), \,\,D(P_2||P_1)\}$$</p> <p>which is quite different from $C(P_1,P_2)$.</p> <p><strong>EDIT</strong>: I realize that now that (1) and (2) cannot hold simultaneously, for the same regions $A_n$'s, so this must be the bug in the reasoning.</p> <p>What one can infer through a similar reasoning is just, I think, </p> <p>$$C(P_1,P_2)\leq \min\{D(P_1||P_2), \,\,D(P_2||P_1)\}.$$</p>
73,935
[ -0.012771038338541985, -0.0015939074801281095, 0.02075774222612381, -0.027790917083621025, 0.018403150141239166, 0.04524378105998039, 0.006799641065299511, -0.029503801837563515, 0.0071655623614788055, -0.010792024433612823, 0.05165683105587959, 0.0003711736935656518, 0.06142714247107506, 0.04102316126227379, 0.019531887024641037, 0.031395480036735535, -0.04561840370297432, 0.01724957302212715, -0.01165662333369255, -0.012124690227210522, 0.026372896507382393, 0.03652388975024223, 0.009396919049322605, 0.005969873629510403, -0.04479388892650604, 0.012040919624269009, 0.02932947874069214, -0.06033618003129959, -0.008106631226837635, 0.08171457052230835, -0.03823539614677429, 0.006442300509661436, -0.008501107804477215, 0.023623274639248848, 0.031414397060871124, -0.01050132978707552, 0.007254992611706257, -0.008489548228681087, -0.004295260179787874, 0.030833950266242027, -0.06846406310796738, -0.0034647376742213964, 0.024142451584339142, -0.011690606363117695, 0.003446317045018077, 0.015177588909864426, -0.024195389822125435, -0.07012095302343369, -0.00864217709749937, -0.028982946649193764, 0.04088561236858368, -0.01528414897620678, -0.017925677821040154, 0.00917766336351633, -0.00612031202763319, -0.03453822061419487, 0.0322018638253212, 0.07167140394449234, -0.004428855609148741, -0.05808030441403389, -0.03330179303884506, -0.03792357072234154, 0.007703772746026516, 0.006354115903377533, -0.05103957653045654, 0.014154992066323757, -0.017680581659078598, -0.015689754858613014, -0.014546666294336319, -0.0037883776240050793, -0.028081325814127922, 0.02614719606935978, -0.017641963437199593, -0.006485066842287779, 0.028405705466866493, 0.015224582515656948, -0.02002902701497078, 0.03666786476969719, 0.03485611453652382, 0.017207840457558632, 0.027219388633966446, 0.0031919085886329412, 0.04357291758060455, 0.03682908043265343, 0.03282995894551277, -0.021064475178718567, 0.07935699075460434, -0.021769501268863678, 0.0001550051965750754, -0.013720417395234108, 0.005800375249236822, 0.025475623086094856, 0.026486610993742943, -0.05790824070572853, -0.013907166197896004, 0.03309532254934311, -0.0365321971476078, 0.02545442245900631, -0.041056711226701736, -0.02414042130112648, -0.014374513179063797, -0.04616937413811684, -0.004004560876637697, 0.047248661518096924, 0.012709006667137146, -0.022179773077368736, 0.008172430098056793, 0.01614309847354889, -0.057320304214954376, -0.041924942284822464, -0.029578519985079765, 0.05954534932971001, 0.0074754925444722176, 0.04496796429157257, -0.010005625896155834, -0.013312813825905323, -0.01313828770071268, -0.0281529538333416, 0.054743487387895584, 0.048874642699956894, 0.06795549392700195, 0.0027582268230617046, 0.014776673167943954, -0.009507743641734123, -0.05710284784436226, 0.009888739325106144, 0.014940603636205196, -0.04857135936617851, -0.031713712960481644, 0.04636915773153305, -0.0010281202849000692, -0.014493780210614204, 0.026011686772108078, 0.02330142818391323, -0.012322381138801575, -0.011581335216760635, -0.06111963093280792, -0.03424982726573944, 0.06508798897266388, 0.02510092593729496, 0.0042495024390518665, -0.039621416479349136, -0.013712321408092976, 0.08654000610113144, 0.04482170566916466, 0.010999515652656555, 0.04315197467803955, -0.00006270533049246296, 0.01724928244948387, 0.003098258748650551, -0.02376989647746086, -0.024641703814268112, -0.017566252499818802, 0.02893874980509281, -0.05945466458797455, -0.09189143031835556, 0.02211080864071846, 0.009903171099722385, -0.010847244411706924, -0.009627723135054111, 0.03177277371287346, -0.01983105204999447, -0.04363594204187393, -0.04342196136713028, -0.01252626720815897, 0.01774359494447708, 0.07428620755672455, 0.0537274032831192, 0.04868662729859352, 0.023831607773900032, -0.0001833112328313291, 0.04466076195240021, 0.0026151968631893396, 0.0438757985830307, 0.0591185986995697, -0.054656337946653366, -0.035238854587078094, -0.028173908591270447, 0.02188878506422043, 0.029869941994547844, 0.008196786046028137, 0.021191012114286423, -0.025382990017533302, 0.0031828104984015226, -0.002499275142326951, -0.00658866623416543, 0.020780324935913086, 0.03022886998951435, 0.024417199194431305, -0.04199877753853798, -0.030658230185508728, -0.03684364631772041, -0.021527474746108055, -0.014552936889231205, -0.06226922571659088, 0.0655691921710968, -0.0003066444769501686, -0.016048314049839973, -0.0231140349060297, -0.019473548978567123, -0.05040682107210159, -0.021755948662757874, 0.018184732645750046, -0.04786936566233635, 0.005936275701969862, 0.04942150413990021, 0.034210991114377975, -0.020942678675055504, 0.05858614668250084, -0.03439540043473244, -0.025432568043470383, 0.0021497602574527264, -0.021827207878232002, -0.02184426598250866, -0.004496564157307148, -0.034816157072782516, 0.003918167669326067, -0.02111070789396763, -0.03368184342980385, 0.03689659386873245, -0.08023518323898315, 0.05377001315355301, 0.09468866139650345, 0.0002752479340415448, 0.02340191975235939, -0.021990783512592316, -0.02437656559050083, 0.0011584399035200477, -0.03484689071774483, -0.02127053588628769, -0.05161791294813156, -0.04502182453870773, 0.01230780128389597, 0.057467393577098846, -0.011516943573951721, 0.004568752367049456, 0.012846231460571289, 0.015225502662360668, 0.007931345142424107, 0.012268166057765484, -0.008594568818807602, -0.039133187383413315, 0.004075242672115564, 0.014159535057842731, 0.012084288522601128, 0.013868145644664764, 0.034839652478694916, -0.013299643993377686, 0.034269075840711594, -0.008528273552656174, 0.0009716530912555754, 0.0045475950464606285, -0.023922935128211975, 0.0015555204590782523, -0.0015302165411412716, 0.01140030287206173, 0.0013436268782243133, -0.016042642295360565, -0.018846599385142326, -0.008837070316076279, 0.01145064365118742, 0.014310934580862522, -0.0028273884672671556, 0.018120406195521355, 0.06488919258117676, 0.016695430502295494, 0.003009787295013666, -0.021236786618828773, 0.043302811682224274, -0.0610465370118618, -0.006093065720051527, -0.009903130121529102, -0.07062800228595734, 0.025360943749547005, 0.008530083112418652, -0.0024354143533855677, -0.0036330875009298325, -0.0069798012264072895, -0.019883399829268456, 0.005638299509882927, -0.01295427605509758, -0.025722134858369827, 0.047777313739061356, 0.006565730553120375, -0.024596551433205605, 0.00020327458332758397, -0.012066335417330265, 0.006496634799987078, 0.009408587589859962, -0.021781818941235542, -0.009939692914485931, 0.006612308789044619, 0.03559689223766327, -0.03149743750691414, -0.05890112742781639, -0.04899340495467186, -0.019708069041371346, -0.06215301528573036, -0.0064493087120354176, 0.02259146049618721, 0.0407363660633564, -0.03248561918735504, 0.03386753797531128, -0.02190554141998291, -0.02745070308446884, -0.047756344079971313, -0.028857260942459106, -0.0310850627720356, -0.003106876742094755, -0.00004490375067689456, 0.02356688678264618, -0.012746098451316357, -0.01413548830896616, -0.05820959806442261, -0.053780242800712585, 0.02748466469347477, -0.005267029628157616, 0.029965266585350037, -0.02974175661802292, -0.026338549330830574, 0.08084918558597565, 0.023511415347456932, -0.00484100915491581, 0.002490314422175288, 0.03798293694853783, -0.035485245287418365, 0.010920559987425804, -0.004982734564691782, -0.004041144624352455, -0.015317943878471851, 0.04345802217721939, -0.020298752933740616, 0.011956410482525826, 0.006978601682931185, -0.034276630729436874, 0.03679368272423744, 0.06096950173377991, 0.0033888693433254957, -0.013757149688899517, 0.0031563544180244207, 0.030730528756976128, 0.010265347547829151, 0.022550027817487717, 0.023847296833992004, -0.008406877517700195, 0.03832918405532837, -0.01842670887708664, -0.008885529823601246, -0.008676380850374699, 0.028800521045923233, -0.0009493344114162028, 0.030137354508042336, 0.05176180228590965, -0.051877837628126144, 0.00993326772004366, 0.02447420172393322, 0.018444180488586426, -0.018420221284031868, 0.000527116353623569, 0.010885179974138737, 0.06502003967761993, -0.014469007030129433, -0.05775627866387367, -0.03813888505101204, 0.003937995992600918, 0.0298608411103487, -0.026648404076695442, -0.01791161671280861, 0.03783925250172615, 0.028988216072320938, 0.0000881371961440891, -0.02049543894827366, 0.00824548676609993, -0.019819673150777817, -0.025740239769220352, -0.005242009647190571, -0.0032827274408191442, 0.049792539328336716, 0.009711386635899544, 0.006427392363548279, 0.032241467386484146, -0.013762403279542923, -0.0012699593789875507, 0.022970564663410187, -0.05770554766058922, -0.0016938906628638506, -0.0032519223168492317, -0.02826339565217495, 0.04226751998066902, -0.04689173772931099, 0.07473171502351761, -0.050166115164756775, 0.009751394391059875, -0.0017548957839608192, 0.05541684478521347, -0.05334832891821861, 0.025733109563589096, -0.02506411075592041, -0.03959481418132782, -0.017058854922652245, 0.057633060961961746, 0.032051749527454376, 0.0014494110364466906, 0.032847810536623, 0.046252522617578506, 0.003481230465695262, 0.0006905645714141428, -0.00015570316463708878, 0.03964304178953171, 0.03042355366051197, 0.03932461887598038, 0.027070723474025726, 0.04793699458241463, -0.012045901268720627, 0.026540346443653107, -0.004993034992367029, 0.038844648748636246, 0.05499357357621193, -0.01593543402850628, 0.03141648322343826, -0.022324174642562866, -0.013185140676796436, -0.018816325813531876, 0.04348158463835716, 0.00590027729049325, -0.04438639059662819, 0.025011636316776276, 0.0253774281591177, -0.0097186379134655, 0.02387619949877262, 0.016864705830812454, -0.006833173334598541, 0.012011118233203888, 0.01650102064013481, -0.06226272135972977, -0.008111828938126564, 0.01815221644937992, 0.03228555619716644, -0.002322627231478691, 0.01287771761417389, -0.019371461123228073, 0.03703107684850693, -0.003309783758595586, -0.038039568811655045, -0.01363500114530325, 0.03798800706863403, -0.012712493538856506, 0.011112714186310768, -0.02268785797059536, 0.051898982375860214, -0.0023387297987937927, 0.0495159775018692, 0.0032056665513664484, 0.03919205442070961, -0.04777432233095169, 0.008314232341945171, 0.0264570452272892, 0.0075991214253008366, -0.022223584353923798, 0.045932117849588394, -0.04198726266622543, 0.004403629805892706, 0.012604244984686375, 0.004226876422762871, 0.04429978132247925, -0.008656534366309643, 0.011425212025642395, -0.03541912883520126, -0.0432196706533432, -0.0318993516266346, 0.00021738036593887955, 0.009440764784812927, 0.007811755407601595, -0.02464468963444233, 0.02034648507833481, -0.043441418558359146, -0.03974684327840805, -0.015869295224547386, 0.10346256196498871, -0.018953675404191017, -0.028771188110113144, -0.015500765293836594, -0.011538797058165073, -0.0025970644783228636, -0.05103965848684311, 0.0672193244099617, -0.005157432984560728, -0.038438860327005386, 0.028636496514081955, -0.016257984563708305, -0.03859550878405571, 0.04104301333427429, -0.011629360727965832, -0.05702256038784981, 0.0413016751408577, 0.00460811285302043, 0.05013149976730347, 0.03402658924460411, 0.053192172199487686, 0.05989072471857071, -0.0041779219172894955, 0.01673620007932186, 0.01919933222234249, -0.009370951913297176, 0.011203845031559467, -0.034114234149456024, -0.0007575043709948659, -0.026464302092790604, 0.025866147130727768, -0.015537707135081291, 0.0304404366761446, 0.002987590618431568, 0.03294821456074715, 0.015333674848079681, -0.04081249237060547, 0.014189302921295166, 0.03665762394666672, -0.005159514024853706, 0.007189265452325344, -0.03382178768515587, 0.04117623344063759, -0.026791352778673172, 0.015733281150460243, 0.030533747747540474, -0.02189718745648861, 0.04260805621743202, 0.005945294629782438, -0.03233427181839943, 0.022040056064724922, -0.05460318922996521, -0.01940838247537613, 0.022171443328261375, -0.007365100085735321, 0.02074562758207321, 0.020517906174063683, 0.010546654462814331, 0.0016464991495013237, 0.0013562642270699143, -0.011146286502480507, 0.026348700746893883, -0.0005946495803073049, 0.04188138246536255, -0.010494659654796124, -0.0048379674553871155, -0.006026415154337883, -0.011217264458537102, -0.06104552745819092, 0.045386865735054016, 0.0036205926444381475, 0.0061972904950380325, 0.008105120621621609, -0.029696544632315636, 0.0034674915950745344, 0.0264657624065876, -0.00047923735110089183, -0.03393944725394249, 0.07253517955541611, 0.028356099501252174, -0.011679506860673428, -0.0077569205313920975, 0.04132356867194176, 0.05605561286211014, -0.018394121900200844, 0.027487849816679955, 0.0007017427124083042, -0.03307656571269035, -0.0019435443682596087, 0.019978199154138565, 0.015529508702456951, -0.014693662524223328, 0.0006068662041798234, -0.025409987196326256, -0.008070331066846848, 0.013110311701893806, 0.01280972920358181, -0.07511720061302185, 0.014931711368262768, 0.027057357132434845, -0.033178430050611496, 0.005021991673856974, -0.0660579577088356, -0.0019820956513285637, 0.024957815185189247, -0.013147988356649876, -0.01908629573881626, 0.03770775720477104, -0.002373012015596032, 0.0046574086882174015, 0.009383659809827805, -0.014532654546201229, 0.04082206264138222, 0.04988687112927437, -0.04243149608373642, 0.014755398966372013, -0.01735585555434227, -0.0100403456017375, 0.01919540762901306, -0.01581781543791294, 0.022691478952765465, 0.025929639115929604, -0.005889195948839188, -0.02422032132744789, -0.003019351279363036, -0.03536437079310417, 0.03395251929759979, 0.07300955802202225, 0.00355484033934772, 0.040193866938352585, -0.015856940299272537, 0.00045257009332999587, 0.01589111052453518, -0.036866817623376846, -0.008241166360676289, -0.03691266104578972, 0.004087257664650679, 0.02438955195248127, -0.03486913442611694, -0.04199162870645523, 0.06335227936506271, -0.03372396528720856, 0.015061345882713795, -0.012287545949220657, -0.010701493360102177, 0.055134743452072144, 0.020147567614912987, -0.09443099796772003, -0.0059669907204806805, 0.03738151118159294, -0.057681236416101456, 0.00870312750339508, -0.004713719245046377, -0.012608823366463184, 0.024132469668984413, 0.02811630629003048, 0.01386329997330904, -0.07359668612480164, -0.036326535046100616, -0.06300988793373108, 0.015550896525382996, 0.015688762068748474, -0.0010690806666389108, 0.04302220419049263, -0.02148955874145031, 0.02079147659242153, -0.01145048625767231, 0.034663937985897064, 0.007126218639314175, -0.06806128472089767, -0.026056285947561264, 0.007510322146117687, -0.030932888388633728, -0.0009553091367706656, 0.0038800283800810575, -0.029514463618397713, 0.01474789809435606, -0.03762277960777283, 0.045761968940496445, 0.06724262237548828, 0.019474850967526436, -0.023522498086094856, 0.01686611771583557, -0.022086573764681816, 0.03013691119849682, -0.007351841311901808, -0.042759183794260025, 0.14421355724334717, 0.0786801353096962, 0.012989240698516369, -0.03416942059993744, 0.02330169826745987, 0.0070019434206187725, -0.005606913939118385, -0.026810504496097565, 0.011322787031531334, 0.011315695010125637, -0.041055355221033096, -0.001340963295660913, 0.05506257712841034, 0.009354707784950733, -0.024844875559210777, 0.017838316038250923, -0.02690909057855606, -0.010591496713459492, 0.034091781824827194, 0.02632666379213333, -0.012783681973814964, -0.0076643177308142185, -0.0038785096257925034, -0.007498514838516712, 0.00935745146125555, 0.0059781260788440704, -0.012700674124062061, 0.005387203302234411, -0.009508667513728142, -0.014486979693174362, -0.008538437075912952, -0.02026960626244545, 0.024270856752991676, -0.0365898571908474, -0.0028657568618655205, -0.0025609212461858988, -0.027255989611148834, -0.038647640496492386, 0.00577703770250082, 0.025771310552954674, 0.02776362933218479, 0.0010559186339378357, 0.009656096808612347, 0.008359085768461227, -0.027337921783328056, -0.06922224909067154, -0.010935813188552856, 0.05614082142710686, -0.05378906801342964, -0.016551131382584572, 0.0035972511395812035, -0.04622828960418701, 0.0043553938157856464, -0.00134154106490314, -0.008821211755275726, 0.031907010823488235, 0.02053871378302574, -0.031156286597251892, 0.008802702650427818, -0.018645457923412323, 0.05845632031559944, 0.012211826629936695, 0.025339601561427116, 0.007490916643291712, -0.02915938012301922, -0.029850369319319725, 0.009515015408396721, 0.03294692188501358, 0.04701811075210571, 0.0010981374653056264, -0.010842058807611465, 0.009064674377441406, -0.036796361207962036, -0.002846034476533532, -0.02024114690721035, -0.03300388157367706, 0.04499993845820427, 0.013210847973823547, -0.01676865667104721, -0.04806391894817352, -0.027739476412534714, -0.014675113372504711, -0.050190288573503494, -0.0026904030237346888, -0.03517914190888405, -0.024099158123135567, 0.028065945953130722, 0.023495661094784737, 0.05648130550980568, -0.023968985304236412, 0.006277807056903839, 0.07829198986291885, -0.0029572497587651014, -0.05176396667957306, -0.017084216699004173, -0.01937880367040634, -0.0202353335916996, 0.01617942936718464, 0.008272490464150906, 0.04209175705909729, 0.02719866670668125, 0.052861910313367844, -0.00813678652048111, -0.011956985108554363, -0.021689463406801224, -0.020981719717383385, 0.008833518251776695, -0.022745760157704353, -0.0062727234326303005, 0.03520090505480766, 0.011704938486218452, -0.03457065299153328, 0.005947075318545103, -0.063222736120224, -0.016435272991657257, -0.0008093004580587149, -0.025542093440890312, -0.01268537063151598, -0.00946727767586708, 0.0019140848889946938, 0.024634476751089096, -0.0032465721014887094, -0.01600966788828373, 0.04664929583668709, -0.01965889148414135, -0.05736435204744339, 0.04819991812109947, -0.013221652247011662, 0.015702510252594948, -0.028019707649946213, -0.0154012031853199, 0.02949935756623745, 0.0014937602682039142, 0.015781454741954803, 0.006991222966462374, 0.0005118238623254001, 0.017071563750505447, 0.02182997576892376, -0.0030194700229912996, 0.00010197017400059849, 0.045201465487480164, -0.05616823583841324, -0.03747330233454704, 0.02210910990834236, 0.025935305282473564, 0.021401245146989822, 0.000019357530618435703, 0.03190644457936287, -0.055412791669368744, 0.023503502830863, -0.04118730500340462, -0.015705905854701996, -0.01977195218205452, -0.00005810186485177837, -0.023132244125008583, -0.005605191458016634, 0.03425874933600426, 0.008567014709115028, 0.030090603977441788, -0.0032067273277789354, 0.012779531069099903, 0.0050819916650652885, 0.003259924938902259, 0.0030227326788008213, -0.0371040478348732, 0.019132863730192184, 0.001492704264819622, -0.0364682637155056, 0.018811963498592377, 0.056474264711141586, -0.001848252839408815, 0.01960667595267296, 0.013653614558279514, -0.015511928126215935, -0.107512928545475, -0.038359418511390686, 0.02077636495232582, 0.045746564865112305, 0.042969606816768646, -0.05377315357327461, 0.0035312927793711424, 0.07527155429124832, -0.03800236061215401, 0.037544917315244675, -0.028388570994138718, 0.04053047299385071, -0.049988094717264175, 0.004625134635716677, -0.05241786316037178, 0.0419185496866703, 0.02205830253660679, 0.0011660517193377018, 0.021799234673380852, 0.05099809914827347, 0.006441405974328518, 0.007293241564184427, 0.006126038264483213, 0.02994314581155777, -0.009312269277870655, -0.06733300536870956, 0.027475479990243912, -0.03962794691324234, 0.020508207380771637, 0.01631186716258526, 0.023921817541122437, 0.00633540004491806, -0.0026080422103405, 0.033385224640369415, 0.021869147196412086, 0.019286885857582092, 0.012566843070089817, -0.014437487348914146, -0.024085115641355515, 0.017168553546071053, 0.014994757249951363, 0.007008989807218313, -0.0009610640699975193, -0.01324960496276617, 0.029847458004951477, -0.010192842222750187, -0.02893988974392414, 0.01206644345074892, 0.04098987951874733, -0.011954416520893574, 0.028732692822813988, -0.004601870663464069, -0.01587994582951069, 0.0008711816626600921, -0.010008398443460464, -0.025770479813218117, -0.024729497730731964, 0.015013535507023335, 0.020160969346761703, -0.05704793706536293, 0.031525712460279465, -0.03190053626894951, -0.036861125379800797, 0.02205521985888481, -0.00660398555919528, 0.000589675095397979, -0.06918928027153015, -0.005752569064497948, -0.035853929817676544, -0.026695217937231064, -0.018164662644267082, -0.011658056639134884, -0.0692007839679718, 0.019659023731946945, -0.023480957373976707, 0.0039048444014042616, -0.0214310921728611, 0.014792484231293201, -0.007032607216387987, -0.10543563961982727, 0.08815047889947891, -0.018891656771302223, 0.0047843484207987785, -0.028166186064481735, -0.0009520165040157735, -0.022599486634135246, 0.003954190760850906, 0.050413236021995544, 0.0364113450050354, 0.006735661998391151, -0.021692603826522827, 0.03357680141925812, 0.012667066417634487, -0.06514044851064682, 0.010354823432862759, -0.029843829572200775, -0.01622099243104458, -0.0121840238571167, 0.008852116763591766, 0.03074593096971512, 0.0005410925368778408, 0.044728901237249374, -0.01801292411983013, 0.006882372312247753, 0.008665177039802074, 0.02017045021057129, 0.015121015720069408, -0.015459051355719566, 0.03377191722393036, 0.030458632856607437, -0.028009407222270966, 0.03097567707300186, -0.019405031576752663, -0.0005491950432769954, -0.09519777446985245, 0.01613789238035679, -0.04260188341140747, -0.023718170821666718, 0.005236741155385971, 0.00901084579527378, -0.039728157222270966, -0.004988816101104021, -0.011605816893279552, 0.018702460452914238, -0.03299419954419136, -0.01966981589794159, -0.013615291565656662, 0.009263727813959122, 0.055905986577272415, 0.03748186677694321, 0.04187411442399025, -0.003967526834458113, -0.014344719238579273, 0.031632035970687866, -0.012151714414358139, 0.016336139291524887, -0.00683065690100193, 0.015797076746821404, 0.016614167019724846, -0.04427637159824371, 0.0175643153488636, -0.004847726318985224, 0.06245493143796921, -0.004079950042068958, -0.018387895077466965, 0.020236127078533173, 0.0093980822712183, -0.022424058988690376, -0.019823454320430756, 0.015772346407175064, 0.053706590086221695, -0.00968231726437807, 0.015179987996816635, -0.02576439455151558, -0.0016284151934087276, 0.007210398092865944, -0.00023400808277074248, -0.0041518365032970905, -0.007662743795663118, -0.020965052768588066, 0.006048878189176321, 0.01169476006180048, 0.002412906615063548, 0.01799267716705799, -0.022310473024845123, 0.0312058012932539, 0.07017867267131805, -0.017750615254044533, -0.002931812545284629, -0.022812234237790108, -0.035224996507167816, -0.040663495659828186, -0.02349834516644478, 0.045742426067590714, 0.013583998195827007, 0.015568855218589306, -0.018299128860235214, 0.014210173860192299, 0.03577861934900284, -0.031769201159477234, 0.023334961384534836, -0.04805750027298927, 0.01484107319265604, 0.007572812493890524, 0.009646480903029442 ]
<p>Conceptually, what is the reason why the correlation between growth rates of A and B would be different from correlation between actual A and B? Under what circumstances would the growth rate correlation be higher? How about lower? How about equal? Thanks.</p>
73,936
[ -0.02912415750324726, -0.025799734517931938, 0.0057772123254835606, 0.015920184552669525, 0.03886551782488823, -0.0003998781321570277, 0.01716427505016327, -0.018035801127552986, 0.03580080345273018, -0.01695886068046093, 0.02604723908007145, 0.03150251880288124, 0.04829568415880203, 0.049825519323349, -0.009108715690672398, 0.01201424840837717, -0.008397359400987625, -0.0016591117018833756, 0.00604561623185873, 0.023597432300448418, 0.016925211995840073, 0.029186518862843513, 0.046390097588300705, 0.005996244493871927, -0.02678484469652176, 0.06135847792029381, 0.0061132656410336494, -0.024720441550016403, 0.014817829243838787, 0.05104002729058266, -0.02706039883196354, -0.02128409408032894, 0.03758864104747772, 0.07697713375091553, 0.03693436458706856, -0.024497436359524727, -0.0320182628929615, -0.056838784366846085, -0.020888807252049446, 0.018543720245361328, -0.0501667819917202, -0.030034590512514114, -0.0009299622033722699, 0.021856967359781265, -0.012258275412023067, 0.012652071192860603, -0.008949554525315762, -0.03615541383624077, 0.0637674331665039, -0.024913126602768898, 0.07834633439779282, 0.010204530321061611, 0.0022643248084932566, 0.050094250589609146, -0.0030561299063265324, -0.0017521136905997992, 0.09784039855003357, 0.03394144028425217, -0.02536405809223652, -0.039859674870967865, -0.029020102694630623, 0.0017640701262280345, -0.013752412982285023, -0.0017479169182479382, -0.012943018227815628, 0.028965016826987267, -0.023530540987849236, -0.033167701214551926, 0.05827619135379791, 0.0022485870867967606, 0.021500658243894577, 0.007952998392283916, 0.0528608113527298, -0.03540064021945, 0.028818240389227867, -0.025187918916344643, 0.007671060506254435, 0.034330014139413834, 0.04551403969526291, 0.06329851597547531, -0.006359347607940435, 0.023525269702076912, 0.05442073941230774, 0.024442218244075775, 0.024367472156882286, 0.005052614491432905, 0.051993463188409805, -0.019943512976169586, -0.006901999469846487, 0.02916625328361988, -0.042686671018600464, -0.014341606758534908, 0.0740889310836792, -0.01747644692659378, -0.03246592730283737, 0.02939855121076107, -0.01768922619521618, 0.03717620298266411, 0.011191270314157009, -0.013573702424764633, -0.0019783154129981995, -0.037975769490003586, 0.02579614147543907, 0.043290965259075165, -0.0047420933842659, -0.01823391206562519, -0.02888050675392151, 0.024579010903835297, -0.013496787287294865, 0.0011638380819931626, -0.022123580798506737, -0.012757684104144573, 0.02463369071483612, 0.02533705346286297, 0.02972380816936493, -0.0008299424662254751, 0.011289055459201336, -0.002930218121036887, 0.08005169034004211, 0.04569876566529274, 0.027601243928074837, -0.03130137547850609, 0.037734463810920715, 0.031077949330210686, -0.02342061884701252, 0.026107724756002426, 0.00591800082474947, -0.009996289387345314, -0.04283185675740242, 0.059151336550712585, -0.013382203876972198, -0.01625746861100197, -0.007853787392377853, -0.032590921968221664, 0.05862615630030632, 0.0129366684705019, -0.10249722748994827, -0.05515306070446968, 0.07325121760368347, -0.02143075317144394, -0.014236720278859138, -0.051599714905023575, 0.030242551118135452, 0.00538518326357007, 0.08546139299869537, 0.014245852828025818, -0.0032989780884236097, -0.009124781005084515, 0.035927675664424896, 0.0332389697432518, -0.014448491856455803, -0.002282975008711219, 0.017336679622530937, -0.036160990595817566, 0.01375906728208065, -0.07698924839496613, 0.0008038663072511554, 0.01971922628581524, -0.009471222758293152, -0.04829049110412598, 0.034629937261343, -0.000843148969579488, -0.03031042590737343, -0.006083810236304998, 0.028037073090672493, -0.015431415289640427, 0.049218788743019104, 0.002631629118695855, -0.02391568198800087, 0.03749493137001991, -0.002880544401705265, 0.024405738338828087, 0.022372126579284668, 0.05320979282259941, 0.04580012336373329, 0.0011798928026109934, -0.014853443019092083, 0.011033698916435242, -0.013208053074777126, -0.002006764756515622, -0.03073730506002903, -0.057617973536252975, -0.03929297626018524, -0.0015611242270097136, 0.022921079769730568, 0.04860616847872734, -0.014585111290216446, -0.010836940258741379, -0.008437950164079666, -0.034648530185222626, -0.029282663017511368, -0.1230536475777626, 0.02028595842421055, -0.0034026463981717825, -0.03430335596203804, 0.03494824096560478, 0.026497861370444298, -0.004745239857584238, -0.031512677669525146, -0.037779539823532104, -0.01579613983631134, -0.006893271114677191, -0.0002870619064196944, -0.029618561267852783, 0.043688446283340454, 0.051077619194984436, 0.02358085662126541, 0.012011042796075344, 0.015524729155004025, -0.029386229813098907, -0.029234960675239563, 0.027563005685806274, -0.018994033336639404, 0.011311927810311317, -0.014868514612317085, -0.011334842070937157, -0.0005073123029433191, -0.008883983828127384, -0.04441788047552109, 0.03772212564945221, -0.04542984440922737, 0.06981619447469711, 0.04571966826915741, 0.013198045082390308, -0.028937701135873795, 0.029337463900446892, 0.010165632702410221, 0.015855377539992332, -0.021548805758357048, -0.0465923473238945, -0.031133610755205154, 0.017693860456347466, -0.0032386493403464556, 0.0251438207924366, -0.04895045608282089, 0.03145883232355118, 0.04109654948115349, 0.00798917468637228, -0.004373053554445505, 0.02933122217655182, -0.01233699731528759, -0.02789343148469925, -0.0034077835734933615, 0.04087284207344055, 0.002390816807746887, -0.01653905212879181, 0.0005077284877188504, -0.014148597605526447, 0.02889942191541195, 0.0010734910611063242, -0.022302722558379173, 0.010382240638136864, 0.012654973194003105, 0.03819410130381584, -0.006573948543518782, 0.007739761844277382, 0.007438153959810734, -0.040322039276361465, 0.007398845627903938, 0.024222418665885925, 0.007536457385867834, -0.0044342633336782455, -0.00791079644113779, -0.04523966461420059, 0.02359148859977722, 0.023866457864642143, -0.01940874569118023, -0.0403163768351078, 0.012302527204155922, 0.01345671247690916, -0.004448397550731897, -0.022482233121991158, -0.014687740243971348, -0.04158078879117966, -0.01876695826649666, 0.026036996394395828, 0.0025834860280156136, 0.07111292332410812, -0.012086400762200356, -0.021260859444737434, -0.009893689304590225, -0.013961582444608212, 0.004281700123101473, -0.036356836557388306, -0.040405575186014175, 0.01707303337752819, 0.026795001700520515, -0.02298465184867382, 0.03195672482252121, -0.02806091122329235, 0.020239129662513733, 0.03341212123632431, 0.011677002534270287, -0.031195003539323807, 0.011560481041669846, -0.026701243594288826, -0.010759977623820305, 0.013867123052477837, -0.010857866145670414, 0.04461997002363205, -0.05020803213119507, -0.0582684688270092, 0.02883569523692131, -0.045386072248220444, -0.027313681319355965, -0.01478620059788227, -0.026027239859104156, -0.02971021831035614, -0.02375469170510769, 0.0007868426037020981, -0.004962745122611523, -0.035283301025629044, -0.007388042751699686, -0.04273084178566933, -0.055226098746061325, 0.010310766287147999, -0.017072273418307304, 0.05529744178056717, -0.05016964301466942, -0.02314762771129608, 0.030665487051010132, 0.014432650059461594, -0.02310149185359478, -0.03258980065584183, 0.00012045403855154291, -0.0012297825887799263, -0.02056303434073925, 0.03729100897908211, 0.05447928607463837, 0.007811324205249548, 0.030848795548081398, 0.06965116411447525, 0.061852239072322845, 0.06130530312657356, -0.000828459276817739, 0.0011056549847126007, 0.0075224037282168865, 0.029211368411779404, 0.03431113809347153, 0.02031836099922657, 0.02019105665385723, -0.04707522317767143, 0.02415682002902031, 0.019281120970845222, 0.005865864921361208, 0.009376371279358864, -0.04376629367470741, 0.020115351304411888, -0.009080787189304829, 0.005334379151463509, -0.06642208993434906, -0.008459868840873241, 0.0025295703671872616, 0.011503109708428383, -0.0038302482571452856, -0.0025361122097820044, 0.03939032927155495, -0.01900457590818405, -0.01976616494357586, 0.031222986057400703, 0.03502168878912926, -0.03475717082619667, -0.009935051202774048, -0.007946725003421307, -0.003911222796887159, 0.03191881254315376, 0.0011284488718956709, -0.0006254542386159301, 0.08539280295372009, 0.01645667292177677, 0.0032666423358023167, -0.00047541927779093385, -0.03086167760193348, -0.025680501013994217, -0.05737800523638725, -0.004431932233273983, -0.02313939854502678, 0.04480258747935295, -0.01832914724946022, 0.05406087636947632, 0.023769017308950424, 0.01814698800444603, 0.01969408430159092, 0.011434175074100494, -0.07097924500703812, 0.02347324788570404, -0.062347836792469025, -0.015348318964242935, 0.008942149579524994, -0.022626109421253204, -0.003216723445802927, -0.038156431168317795, -0.01646854542195797, -0.013951070606708527, 0.03095201775431633, -0.009724199771881104, -0.009606575593352318, -0.03305431082844734, -0.04137573391199112, -0.03770240396261215, -0.015639323741197586, -0.013028438203036785, -0.014610910788178444, 0.07808177918195724, 0.06120987609028816, 0.022692810744047165, -0.007643490564078093, -0.015351387672126293, 0.00579658942297101, 0.029438365250825882, 0.010436885990202427, 0.051716528832912445, 0.01843920722603798, -0.03162165358662605, 0.009020009078085423, 0.03164403513073921, 0.030021803453564644, 0.04284026846289635, 0.008294409140944481, -0.02891768515110016, -0.016160590574145317, -0.02566012740135193, -0.016886185854673386, 0.015544925816357136, 0.0015276280464604497, -0.012420762330293655, 0.028987446799874306, 0.01269525196403265, 0.01285693608224392, 0.03277917578816414, 0.08374736458063126, 0.004579646047204733, -0.006756700109690428, -0.001846135943196714, -0.04173053801059723, -0.0023699442390352488, -0.022215962409973145, 0.028587471693754196, -0.006010586861521006, -0.0038200095295906067, -0.0014959777472540736, 0.03204099461436272, -0.003205421846359968, -0.03879544138908386, 0.00646760081872344, -0.015400002710521221, 0.023840077221393585, 0.009249425493180752, -0.04692092910408974, 0.006118680816143751, 0.04032469540834427, 0.032894257456064224, 0.03186760097742081, 0.00819080788642168, -0.06938567757606506, -0.02297104150056839, 0.018164366483688354, -0.012184124439954758, -0.043151311576366425, 0.004418992903083563, -0.03535982966423035, -0.027889862656593323, 0.030608506873250008, -0.010400139726698399, 0.03539963811635971, -0.01803874783217907, 0.015609674155712128, -0.02243131585419178, -0.012738035060465336, -0.025959216058254242, 0.0009020203724503517, 0.002044701250270009, 0.012987765483558178, 0.015357904136180878, 0.006868056021630764, -0.011596722528338432, -0.021554091945290565, 0.02955041639506817, 0.0611446350812912, -0.04158776253461838, 0.0045832437463104725, 0.01928437501192093, 0.032475367188453674, 0.018317921087145805, -0.06783883273601532, 0.04313544183969498, 0.0012519028969109058, -0.018813887611031532, 0.03954383358359337, -0.01544984057545662, -0.04178552329540253, 0.020691106095910072, -0.033967677503824234, -0.020082639530301094, -0.032274384051561356, -0.02668081782758236, 0.06836099177598953, 0.03927334025502205, 0.011513032019138336, 0.029054325073957443, 0.019376253709197044, -0.003938389476388693, -0.044825490564107895, -0.04773758351802826, 0.03301606699824333, -0.0442708320915699, -0.010421578772366047, -0.03292645886540413, 0.01908927597105503, -0.0202142596244812, 0.062108736485242844, 0.019131086766719818, -0.008057561703026295, -0.047555480152368546, -0.024570509791374207, 0.02698453888297081, 0.006290963385254145, -0.017350761219859123, -0.0029600521083921194, 0.025414753705263138, 0.01223330944776535, 0.016129447147250175, -0.024900317192077637, 0.020085029304027557, -0.03425564989447594, -0.03873100131750107, 0.011333663016557693, -0.037350110709667206, -0.008156177587807178, -0.0033118482679128647, -0.0015696303453296423, 0.02802308090031147, -0.026561865583062172, 0.03695586323738098, -0.0019107261905446649, 0.009482242166996002, 0.02350175566971302, -0.047862567007541656, -0.004584773909300566, 0.034496575593948364, -0.013115198351442814, 0.05990098789334297, -0.0599689707159996, 0.036005862057209015, -0.0364801362156868, -0.014087158255279064, -0.09542760252952576, -0.04475090652704239, 0.0030360801611095667, 0.018957944586873055, 0.010240018367767334, -0.0284266397356987, -0.02518005110323429, -0.0090892119333148, -0.03329741209745407, -0.021947406232357025, 0.05829766392707825, -0.0050569940358400345, -0.029822638258337975, 0.002070211572572589, 0.03330426290631294, 0.06450556218624115, -0.03890850767493248, -0.021182958036661148, -0.005080658942461014, -0.0021420568227767944, -0.022338183596730232, 0.02540111355483532, 0.04302962124347687, -0.040722642093896866, 0.008411729708313942, -0.005477840080857277, -0.029370134696364403, 0.043240174651145935, -0.05390072241425514, -0.02820669114589691, 0.0032824925146996975, 0.015613912604749203, 0.03273786976933479, -0.004823376890271902, 0.008333160541951656, 0.000402275676606223, 0.024160929024219513, 0.0036935550160706043, -0.023082097992300987, -0.02472706511616707, -0.028975313529372215, 0.025657011196017265, 0.01733636111021042, -0.021315759047865868, 0.036501914262771606, 0.059737011790275574, -0.04268190264701843, -0.019650723785161972, 0.013666695915162563, -0.032606322318315506, 0.013185550458729267, -0.02844259701669216, 0.012566433288156986, 0.046721041202545166, 0.005268311593681574, -0.03896855562925339, -0.02182367444038391, -0.03469356149435043, 0.008104567416012287, 0.06783849000930786, -0.016655895859003067, 0.06049073114991188, 0.02345900982618332, 0.0026652365922927856, 0.014213486574590206, -0.025177733972668648, -0.009577210992574692, -0.004825478419661522, -0.00655511487275362, 0.009786282666027546, -0.04198213666677475, -0.019312987104058266, 0.03622700646519661, 0.029554570093750954, -0.011442996561527252, 0.018512671813368797, 0.031904399394989014, 0.024735279381275177, 0.0072125461883842945, -0.0030594575218856335, -0.06637092679738998, 0.06694686412811279, -0.01749546080827713, 0.04128658026456833, -0.038088176399469376, -0.011890214867889881, 0.06567304581403732, 0.034245625138282776, -0.029398813843727112, -0.06428747624158859, -0.050224419683218, -0.04489742964506149, -0.02565586380660534, 0.014078892767429352, -0.02440761588513851, 0.0666569396853447, 0.02051493152976036, -0.006180337630212307, -0.03314454108476639, 0.012188517488539219, -0.02439425326883793, -0.06064870208501816, -0.04675518348813057, -0.038843393325805664, -0.04308626428246498, 0.017831312492489815, -0.012925625778734684, -0.034483570605516434, 0.020213522017002106, -0.008425249718129635, -0.024782385677099228, -0.023126455023884773, 0.009970027022063732, -0.020160801708698273, 0.0731842890381813, 0.031184224411845207, 0.020937157794833183, -0.014402889646589756, 0.011161287315189838, 0.08647339046001434, 0.05693850293755531, -0.0011494043283164501, -0.07038341462612152, 0.045590534806251526, 0.0029185477178543806, 0.024611039087176323, -0.02930407226085663, 0.020503707230091095, 0.03025241754949093, 0.008591449819505215, 0.023825375363230705, 0.029334884136915207, 0.03523320332169533, -0.01962236501276493, 0.06070517748594284, -0.00798340979963541, -0.05061611905694008, 0.008588934317231178, 0.02494349144399166, 0.004128545057028532, 0.01799141801893711, -0.022656001150608063, -0.01701311580836773, -0.016668368130922318, -0.02041415125131607, -0.02308633364737034, -0.018123488873243332, 0.011191670782864094, -0.0135450204834342, -0.045584142208099365, 0.017102647572755814, 0.04785369709134102, -0.024481244385242462, -0.050315991044044495, -0.03014385886490345, -0.009969079867005348, -0.026728594675660133, 0.005800170823931694, 0.022227244451642036, 0.02818971499800682, 0.004323086701333523, -0.020878732204437256, 0.00797075591981411, -0.04934762418270111, -0.008761739358305931, -0.014583815820515156, 0.03433745354413986, -0.0006855672691017389, 0.007580951321870089, -0.003904345678165555, 0.014085067436099052, -0.02004815638065338, -0.008564019575715065, -0.02136833779513836, -0.006103065330535173, 0.018486155197024345, -0.022523894906044006, -0.02273564226925373, -0.017830492928624153, 0.007894530892372131, -0.04305190220475197, 0.06066358461976051, 0.020617902278900146, -0.021685395389795303, 0.03478145971894264, -0.06657420843839645, 0.03490787371993065, -0.014666442759335041, 0.0009438011911697686, 0.0011169464560225606, 0.017234761267900467, -0.02095961570739746, 0.010814055800437927, -0.01012485846877098, 0.029381610453128815, 0.06680011004209518, 0.014450080692768097, -0.02855844981968403, -0.0014802342047914863, 0.010555805638432503, 0.03295525163412094, 0.009296144358813763, -0.01648424193263054, -0.07150736451148987, 0.017592379823327065, 0.04522142931818962, 0.0317293182015419, -0.01197704765945673, 0.0074680037796497345, -0.041319433599710464, 0.00770823797211051, 0.05055978521704674, -0.04976829141378403, 0.0014439007500186563, 0.03176667541265488, -0.028380563482642174, -0.04322829842567444, -0.0052505056373775005, 0.016919657588005066, 0.010889093391597271, -0.00030297887860797346, 0.012504547834396362, 0.003350065555423498, -0.01136978343129158, 0.011823724955320358, -0.0009684199467301369, -0.017111824825406075, 0.003412688849493861, 0.029222272336483, -0.0354454442858696, -0.013882718048989773, -0.015075896866619587, 0.0023616456892341375, -0.011936754919588566, 0.01934775337576866, -0.002270831959322095, -0.017093904316425323, 0.00576440105214715, -0.03315029665827751, -0.0025666127912700176, -0.040719471871852875, -0.01896304450929165, -0.07748718559741974, 0.004935386124998331, 0.029472405090928078, 0.013271094299852848, -0.013417437672615051, 0.05897532403469086, -0.019595198333263397, -0.01019456796348095, 0.04340624436736107, 0.01947498694062233, -0.00830138847231865, -0.01497446745634079, -0.0052281576208770275, -0.008779492229223251, 0.04111918434500694, -0.012128944508731365, -0.04735659435391426, 0.027686621993780136, -0.03776777535676956, -0.01758638024330139, 0.020233454182744026, 0.007428557146340609, 0.028477435931563377, -0.016145814210176468, -0.005193783435970545, -0.02945207990705967, 0.051050443202257156, -0.026596250012516975, 0.0123829310759902, -0.04079267382621765, -0.003455146448686719, -0.015473999083042145, -0.009907972998917103, -0.022646645084023476, 0.026018638163805008, 0.006610450800508261, -0.005559242330491543, 0.04759115353226662, -0.033511485904455185, -0.012313764542341232, -0.0011939296964555979, -0.010930851101875305, 0.01410155463963747, 0.003942801151424646, -0.00824646558612585, 0.0385376513004303, 0.07214061915874481, -0.006940202321857214, 0.016664061695337296, 0.03210746869444847, 0.004173660650849342, -0.05639271065592766, 0.017076177522540092, 0.003911002539098263, -0.007944385521113873, 0.018414702266454697, -0.02514331415295601, -0.022500302642583847, 0.01749807596206665, -0.07714486122131348, 0.018556617200374603, -0.017167607322335243, -0.023121798411011696, -0.03860580921173096, -0.03675660863518715, -0.003930243197828531, 0.0671493411064148, 0.0333230160176754, 0.050678595900535583, 0.015786942094564438, -0.00748341204598546, -0.01380158867686987, -0.0172870010137558, -0.011463792994618416, 0.005939099472016096, 0.006982531864196062, -0.01684466376900673, 0.0453774556517601, -0.03456946089863777, -0.016540393233299255, 0.04918922111392021, -0.03123120591044426, 0.013649999164044857, 0.048612818121910095, 0.05516096577048302, 0.017361270263791084, 0.014010279439389706, 0.014818184077739716, -0.008803963661193848, -0.0223735012114048, -0.01430085115134716, 0.020859867334365845, 0.021776417270302773, -0.032520588487386703, 0.034734632819890976, 0.009877635166049004, 0.005388493184000254, -0.000984211335889995, -0.010576670058071613, -0.010947253555059433, -0.018624940887093544, 0.03466241806745529, -0.022676726803183556, 0.009481759741902351, 0.013245278969407082, 0.008545094169676304, -0.021365320309996605, -0.016271203756332397, 0.028428636491298676, 0.04438251256942749, -0.04710704833269119, -0.00222818017937243, -0.02179684489965439, -0.007679659407585859, -0.015412911772727966, 0.02135307341814041, 0.00198072730563581, -0.041910771280527115, -0.01129359845072031, -0.026456141844391823, -0.006016677711158991, -0.04090878367424011, -0.03507562354207039, -0.05529384687542915, 0.053096503019332886, -0.011397294700145721, 0.029209135100245476, 0.020731735974550247, -0.03177710250020027, -0.02163763716816902, -0.07627969235181808, 0.06843661516904831, -0.01887575350701809, -0.007480376400053501, -0.06090981513261795, -0.014183162711560726, -0.027458148077130318, 0.010352177545428276, 0.04828225448727608, -0.011432847939431667, 0.009664629586040974, 0.007314067333936691, 0.03534673899412155, 0.009999140165746212, -0.04621103033423424, 0.03994259238243103, -0.0030947488266974688, -0.01772204041481018, 0.03391946852207184, -0.014036434702575207, 0.006206202320754528, -0.009755310602486134, -0.006172387860715389, -0.02342185750603676, 0.008210116997361183, 0.03823068365454674, 0.003976813983172178, 0.05333156883716583, -0.0006439813878387213, -0.008582713082432747, 0.08093409985303879, 0.020312568172812462, 0.008382457308471203, 0.03415099158883095, 0.009637654758989811, -0.06389272212982178, 0.052911628037691116, -0.0008944461005739868, 0.003741635475307703, 0.0030874107033014297, -0.02741371840238571, 0.020756743848323822, -0.050636176019907, -0.03495055064558983, 0.028032241389155388, -0.016952553763985634, 0.010950434021651745, 0.031215673312544823, 0.02338913083076477, 0.025617022067308426, -0.034607112407684326, 0.01074767392128706, -0.009561545215547085, -0.01515534520149231, -0.014398249797523022, 0.02430860698223114, 0.03819415345788002, -0.017497170716524124, 0.03561745956540108, 0.03975645825266838, 0.010035760700702667, 0.011984501034021378, -0.03833472728729248, 0.03149356320500374, -0.055570658296346664, -0.0410752147436142, 0.019149601459503174, -0.028560208156704903, 0.059491727501153946, 0.04129786789417267, 0.005479326006025076, 0.06582079082727432, -0.04277236387133598, 0.021535709500312805, 0.02082081511616707, -0.009296402335166931, -0.0600079745054245, -0.04475327953696251, 0.031153270974755287, 0.014072716236114502, 0.02844994328916073, -0.010127538815140724, -0.002099036006256938, 0.003823971375823021, 0.013966411352157593, -0.0005616505513899028, 0.0311181228607893, 0.0017954538343474269, -0.04000180959701538, -0.025093792006373405, 0.026413414627313614, -0.044971875846385956, -0.03439166024327278, 0.07480970025062561, 0.059801407158374786, 0.0013620042009279132, 0.022870348766446114, -0.030185144394636154, 0.014200897887349129, 0.056949786841869354, -0.05385000258684158, -0.045958906412124634, -0.048180777579545975, 0.004634248558431864, 0.018751665949821472, -0.033003900200128555 ]
<p>I have produced a model using the <code>ctree</code> function in R, and want to know whether this tree is actually explaining my data well. </p> <p>I am trying to explain the presence or absence of landscape disturbances using environmental factors. <code>rpart</code> gives an $R^2$ value, but since my data are not well-balanced (PRESENCE contains a relatively small number of 1s), I believe the <code>ctree</code> model will work better. A (simplified) version of my model is: </p> <pre><code>fit &lt;- ctree (PRESENCE ~ A + B + C + D + E + F, data=dat); </code></pre> <p>where PRESENCE is a factor containing values of (0,1), five of the independent variables (denoted by the letters A-F) are numerical values (environmental data), and the remaining variable is categorical.</p> <p>I believe there is a way to make an $R^2$ value using the <code>predict</code> function (as in <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/23772/getting-r-square-value-from-ctree">Getting R square value from ctree</a>), but I'm fairly new to R and haven't had any success trying to code this.</p> <p>Any help would be much appreciated.</p>
36,504
[ -0.03372417762875557, -0.023344360291957855, 0.014002225361764431, 0.032200202345848083, 0.005396588705480099, 0.0010632046032696962, -0.008692464791238308, -0.0019524699309840798, 0.05295800045132637, -0.04435375705361366, 0.03582654148340225, 0.018180154263973236, 0.03528054058551788, 0.015895714983344078, 0.028929170221090317, 0.01986146904528141, -0.009111837483942509, -0.013462094590067863, -0.0069341277703642845, -0.020301392301917076, -0.013294684700667858, 0.016655925661325455, 0.015925781801342964, 0.004887055139988661, -0.00646560825407505, 0.08084333688020706, 0.0391242578625679, 0.032216958701610565, 0.013475229032337666, 0.018197108060121536, -0.04462582617998123, -0.01174034085124731, 0.004352159332484007, 0.024995002895593643, 0.01249493658542633, 0.010217053815722466, 0.005985081661492586, 0.0028613745234906673, 0.011367537081241608, 0.021051080897450447, -0.0006174384034238756, -0.03221352770924568, 0.03235262259840965, 0.07784498482942581, -0.0007362259784713387, 0.006808026693761349, -0.011270035989582539, -0.0017805570969358087, 0.06733465939760208, -0.03538989648222923, 0.09603272378444672, 0.0034408022183924913, 0.041387006640434265, 0.017571546137332916, -0.02864517830312252, -0.010398966260254383, 0.0726504996418953, 0.03202362358570099, -0.03157377615571022, -0.05013563483953476, -0.020523516461253166, -0.033805426210165024, 0.006336031015962362, 0.01132543571293354, -0.04350657761096954, 0.012994076125323772, 0.005710751749575138, -0.0075186677277088165, 0.05087507888674736, -0.02444029413163662, 0.028161773458123207, 0.002475104993209243, 0.023115022107958794, 0.003360169939696789, 0.03386801853775978, -0.029455706477165222, 0.03275144472718239, 0.01839802972972393, 0.024988101795315742, -0.0015105570200830698, 0.00018047630146611482, 0.02802523970603943, 0.03234492242336273, 0.018097057938575745, 0.006513634696602821, 0.0076199364848434925, 0.046129435300827026, -0.02012273296713829, 0.0007491813157685101, 0.0068613397888839245, 0.011634737253189087, 0.008873092010617256, 0.07842107862234116, -0.022341500967741013, -0.04425409436225891, 0.013313375413417816, -0.01364207174628973, 0.039818402379751205, 0.01565449684858322, 0.021151626482605934, -0.034425441175699234, -0.02843676134943962, 0.01852325163781643, 0.04615628346800804, -0.05798234045505524, 0.00046571617713198066, -0.05318876728415489, -0.005752723664045334, 0.01659405790269375, -0.014220121316611767, -0.01776321604847908, 0.02513706125319004, 0.011724081821739674, -0.05740104988217354, 0.01694183051586151, -0.03365278244018555, -0.015521935187280178, 0.013884895481169224, 0.05401052534580231, 0.044162921607494354, 0.0655008852481842, -0.06398633122444153, 0.033601824194192886, 0.006081215105950832, -0.043237827718257904, 0.003605468198657036, 0.00897539034485817, 0.0017784038791432977, -0.0375811904668808, 0.04427347332239151, -0.021451259031891823, -0.016754789277911186, 0.03587053343653679, 0.0035330206155776978, 0.027645425871014595, 0.02140907011926174, -0.09699045866727829, -0.08999864012002945, 0.012284365482628345, -0.01716119609773159, 0.007134974468499422, -0.047259651124477386, -0.00465597677975893, 0.03648773953318596, 0.04912425950169563, -0.0017776928143575788, 0.02423790842294693, 0.015307052992284298, 0.02100115455687046, 0.028644386678934097, -0.05202673003077507, -0.0022674929350614548, -0.013296776451170444, -0.031300295144319534, -0.01250377856194973, -0.05769412964582443, 0.03699076920747757, 0.00416041212156415, -0.011097142472863197, 0.007016131188720465, 0.04364677146077156, -0.0010814397828653455, -0.003247904358431697, 0.022022753953933716, -0.0018167601665481925, -0.007809913717210293, 0.06593353301286697, -0.015450287610292435, 0.042452674359083176, 0.029320642352104187, 0.002558675827458501, 0.01591886579990387, 0.04874637350440025, 0.04557333514094353, 0.05064871907234192, -0.002227777848020196, -0.00303965643979609, -0.0007305230246856809, 0.007180735468864441, 0.0030456671956926584, -0.04796306788921356, -0.024396231397986412, -0.013344905339181423, 0.013269582763314247, 0.004700616467744112, 0.03887702524662018, -0.03155994042754173, -0.011655719950795174, 0.062122080475091934, -0.05997718870639801, -0.029373038560152054, -0.057300906628370285, -0.021787818521261215, 0.001999601721763611, -0.007237320765852928, -0.008737619034945965, 0.018121829256415367, 0.030027419328689575, 0.009737344458699226, 0.016312159597873688, -0.030619274824857712, 0.009407928213477135, 0.04957038536667824, -0.005811746697872877, 0.01538823451846838, 0.04795052111148834, 0.052637532353401184, 0.017066296190023422, 0.05386340618133545, -0.025538219138979912, -0.04816979914903641, -0.010499806143343449, -0.043287575244903564, 0.021266356110572815, -0.015534224919974804, -0.013306588865816593, 0.005764393601566553, 0.025315511971712112, -0.015920229256153107, 0.036705709993839264, -0.05512754246592522, 0.051220882683992386, 0.08689562231302261, 0.06028630957007408, 0.010769263841211796, 0.012774611823260784, -0.01850256510078907, -0.0004582726105581969, -0.06015742942690849, -0.015189085155725479, -0.029748285189270973, 0.0007101181545294821, 0.014673843048512936, 0.00539257051423192, 0.0021913819946348667, 0.014019153080880642, 0.049775004386901855, -0.02047940157353878, 0.008583590388298035, 0.03662889450788498, -0.018061144277453423, 0.008978708647191525, 0.013435478322207928, -0.012779561802744865, 0.026596494019031525, -0.014495433308184147, 0.019002800807356834, 0.01773764193058014, 0.028895681723952293, -0.015740226954221725, 0.00025362573796883225, 0.04206002131104469, -0.01960746757686138, 0.004695084411650896, -0.005198405124247074, -0.018660087138414383, 0.049930132925510406, -0.009717946872115135, -0.041024718433618546, 0.05470658093690872, 0.003230527276173234, -0.02297063358128071, -0.01987016387283802, -0.02535944990813732, 0.01396267581731081, 0.06963056325912476, -0.01486978493630886, 0.014152401126921177, 0.003772848518565297, -0.04337668791413307, 0.029012544080615044, 0.006469430401921272, -0.05124411731958389, -0.053560368716716766, 0.01668154075741768, 0.007123397197574377, 0.02959495410323143, 0.0052071004174649715, -0.028023192659020424, 0.0077397143468260765, -0.01740313693881035, -0.041065119206905365, 0.01832224801182747, -0.01649291254580021, -0.02766234427690506, -0.021298270672559738, -0.020874273031949997, -0.004092937335371971, -0.001998839434236288, -0.016317171975970268, -0.05777573585510254, 0.023681126534938812, -0.021296489983797073, -0.021546365693211555, -0.03509246185421944, -0.04401043802499771, 0.027537807822227478, -0.02696589194238186, -0.04856472834944725, 0.0009141791379079223, -0.009493930265307426, -0.009622258134186268, 0.008736228570342064, -0.08071089535951614, -0.011712726205587387, -0.03069576621055603, -0.017593814060091972, 0.01124436967074871, 0.006848757620900869, 0.026882493868470192, 0.015438379719853401, -0.037456464022397995, 0.003029152052477002, -0.06061049923300743, -0.06901521980762482, 0.0009203950758092105, 0.035454753786325455, 0.03671292960643768, -0.020028628408908844, 0.00031611512531526387, 0.07509034872055054, -0.006338892970234156, -0.035015180706977844, -0.08041876554489136, -0.02114279195666313, -0.024793023243546486, -0.017463674768805504, -0.0013014348223805428, 0.02337462455034256, 0.027623655274510384, 0.007761376444250345, -0.033720385283231735, 0.03909650444984436, 0.011484581045806408, 0.0044816480949521065, -0.05653468519449234, 0.03378506377339363, -0.006765273399651051, -0.016433700919151306, 0.0503079891204834, 0.003767079906538129, -0.008845127187669277, 0.04025449976325035, -0.04910431429743767, -0.001312860636971891, 0.010130522772669792, -0.03485908731818199, -0.007942918688058853, -0.01429729349911213, 0.04579078033566475, -0.023659255355596542, 0.02598550356924534, -0.031195376068353653, -0.06453955173492432, -0.016226204112172127, -0.025928184390068054, 0.052074115723371506, 0.017286963760852814, -0.049846917390823364, 0.03902294859290123, 0.02047003246843815, 0.0017012403113767505, 0.027584441006183624, -0.02794557996094227, 0.009380454197525978, 0.030186111107468605, -0.020103879272937775, -0.014241975732147694, 0.05667893961071968, 0.04906007647514343, 0.025776775553822517, 0.008686522953212261, -0.030655067414045334, 0.016000958159565926, 0.008647740818560123, 0.011122367344796658, -0.0385807640850544, 0.04796863719820976, 0.011220816522836685, 0.04267340525984764, 0.011296464130282402, -0.03400319814682007, 0.0522950179874897, 0.013115940615534782, -0.04253007471561432, 0.011690786108374596, 0.016356397420167923, -0.0057172393426299095, -0.02205837331712246, -0.009268113411962986, -0.0048880805261433125, 0.008601964451372623, 0.012206509709358215, 0.03812629356980324, 0.0011882728431373835, -0.008765952661633492, -0.02642185054719448, -0.005417011212557554, 0.00181880546733737, -0.029924798756837845, 0.0179308969527483, 0.04882083833217621, -0.02511259727180004, 0.013189716264605522, 0.049315083771944046, -0.018421970307826996, 0.02418147772550583, -0.05022597685456276, -0.04749104380607605, 0.05661560222506523, 0.0018115997081622481, 0.046810586005449295, 0.012771157547831535, 0.006485985592007637, 0.0026138725224882364, -0.012757275253534317, 0.044605109840631485, 0.018452486023306847, 0.0383632630109787, 0.027965301647782326, -0.014275779016315937, 0.01022608857601881, -0.02367197722196579, -0.012260648421943188, -0.029157783836126328, -0.012025083415210247, 0.04285060614347458, 0.03395456448197365, -0.03704529628157616, 0.04158751666545868, 0.041786015033721924, 0.012423052452504635, -0.033691637217998505, -0.03445889428257942, 0.008655037730932236, 0.011167256161570549, -0.022024132311344147, 0.03566576912999153, 0.008044525049626827, 0.002644764492288232, -0.004308410454541445, 0.02375107631087303, -0.03450067341327667, -0.039171669632196426, 0.0068061817437410355, 0.006600012071430683, 0.04097442701458931, -0.06668038666248322, -0.028936564922332764, 0.0045434823259711266, 0.024979567155241966, -0.011211931705474854, -0.009418451227247715, -0.006619991734623909, -0.08905179798603058, -0.0020348927937448025, 0.014516936615109444, 0.057834524661302567, 0.026628194376826286, -0.04879634454846382, -0.04843810573220253, -0.01785076968371868, -0.0006587662501260638, -0.022230716422200203, 0.011710282415151596, -0.013427306897938251, 0.02728535421192646, -0.0038454034365713596, -0.025983691215515137, -0.03221489489078522, 0.00021339886006899178, -0.0367964543402195, 0.044944461435079575, 0.00023824798699934036, -0.020962435752153397, -0.048932988196611404, -0.0006590946577489376, -0.004695688374340534, 0.055755387991666794, -0.01890295371413231, -0.017922380939126015, -0.000034619926736922935, 0.006414094474166632, -0.01429061684757471, -0.04431755095720291, -0.004174205008894205, 0.0010327076306566596, -0.009991050697863102, 0.04749966040253639, -0.008090909570455551, -0.019034432247281075, 0.006984473671764135, 0.03398176655173302, -0.024941233918070793, -0.006776028778403997, -0.020888905972242355, 0.06003797426819801, 0.006743291858583689, -0.015261445194482803, 0.0833311602473259, 0.0780804455280304, -0.01711880974471569, 0.03201613202691078, -0.03676733374595642, 0.02934066578745842, 0.021028582006692886, -0.023725131526589394, -0.05612587556242943, -0.018969833850860596, -0.01285039447247982, -0.030231473967432976, -0.012410778552293777, 0.046379849314689636, -0.056035105139017105, 0.0013627364533022046, 0.027370009571313858, 0.040179427713155746, -0.0038964496925473213, 0.019716901704669, -0.010867231525480747, 0.014528272673487663, -0.003145724767819047, -0.0290759839117527, 0.0011127121979370713, -0.026810819283127785, 0.008976041339337826, 0.014010543935000896, 0.0005765202222391963, 0.03876412659883499, -0.028563769534230232, -0.03287913650274277, 0.006099289283156395, -0.02599436230957508, 0.04047252610325813, -0.023343252018094063, 0.03627229109406471, -0.019162660464644432, -0.06933177262544632, 0.0022971136495471, 0.02778567746281624, 0.0008507168968208134, 0.006946245674043894, -0.028927385807037354, 0.027179595082998276, -0.021953590214252472, -0.008840967901051044, -0.04606734961271286, -0.03207137808203697, 0.0012686863774433732, 0.0059225899167358875, -0.03973114490509033, -0.021170200780034065, -0.019890042021870613, -0.011206090450286865, -0.002295366721227765, -0.024688100442290306, 0.06095072627067566, -0.029980860650539398, 0.021812552586197853, 0.014638712629675865, 0.010883331298828125, 0.0658499002456665, 0.02375030890107155, -0.001735368394292891, 0.018590372055768967, 0.0007357078138738871, -0.036536309868097305, 0.041674207895994186, -0.009170522913336754, -0.04433855414390564, 0.026484904810786247, -0.022516481578350067, 0.04482932388782501, 0.024873055517673492, 0.03531170263886452, -0.00034912125556729734, -0.013601367361843586, 0.015135146677494049, 0.004842860158532858, -0.050777751952409744, 0.015397980809211731, -0.021969396620988846, -0.0055688731372356415, -0.021431293338537216, -0.005319057032465935, -0.003692563157528639, -0.0019829883240163326, -0.016688469797372818, -0.024457965046167374, 0.012046909891068935, 0.020496491342782974, 0.06902983784675598, 0.003693499369546771, 0.03269679471850395, -0.0035386718809604645, -0.011081774719059467, 0.03849015757441521, -0.00045271546696312726, -0.002064881380647421, 0.01178235188126564, 0.0404789075255394, -0.03173112869262695, -0.0237266905605793, 0.0010395077988505363, 0.027561413124203682, 0.07141167670488358, -0.04262516275048256, 0.06108425557613373, 0.04194161295890808, 0.0053787087090313435, 0.021900556981563568, -0.03883427381515503, -0.008432844653725624, -0.020105259492993355, 0.035322897136211395, 0.04094179719686508, -0.004740557167679071, 0.01653430610895157, 0.026743784546852112, 0.01110947597771883, 0.01892695762217045, 0.03822930157184601, 0.019425194710493088, 0.010745069943368435, 0.013180031441152096, -0.017133958637714386, -0.04331711307168007, 0.009417247958481312, -0.04287266731262207, 0.0070053571835160255, -0.014869858510792255, -0.02084266021847725, 0.05822623148560524, 0.007497688289731741, 0.005338029935956001, -0.034142009913921356, -0.039834700524806976, -0.056083161383867264, 0.009269000962376595, -0.009769788011908531, 0.004763341508805752, 0.029685068875551224, -0.0022862753830850124, -0.008611679077148438, -0.006161740515381098, 0.017946695908904076, -0.05440123379230499, -0.10536456853151321, -0.007056484930217266, -0.03583275154232979, -0.03322489559650421, 0.03357500210404396, 0.033421535044908524, -0.02032768912613392, 0.031064018607139587, -0.06208407133817673, 0.016207195818424225, 0.00959404744207859, 0.03958988934755325, -0.027619769796729088, 0.050046827644109726, -0.010149208828806877, -0.015916232019662857, -0.02735232748091221, 0.010738222859799862, 0.11478099972009659, 0.08942475914955139, 0.013302636332809925, -0.039588190615177155, 0.023169847205281258, -0.004683051723986864, 0.011112921871244907, -0.02617831528186798, -0.03237535059452057, -0.008466791361570358, -0.00023174710804596543, 0.055680740624666214, 0.025904301553964615, 0.032816555351018906, 0.002864275826141238, 0.006492775399237871, -0.018105575814843178, -0.05524558946490288, 0.0039749364368617535, 0.0004039057530462742, -0.01367255300283432, -0.013530367985367775, -0.02643638849258423, 0.010507791303098202, -0.012021981179714203, -0.01966082490980625, -0.021005667746067047, 0.009455106221139431, 0.0052597722969949245, 0.00857414398342371, -0.041810065507888794, 0.03260211646556854, 0.03042643517255783, 0.013756399042904377, -0.016620516777038574, 0.016114190220832825, 0.030245667323470116, -0.011844145134091377, 0.013178260996937752, -0.0017484021373093128, -0.03756415843963623, -0.02528061717748642, 0.004832667764276266, 0.05190287157893181, -0.03575313091278076, -0.04296009615063667, -0.06068315729498863, 0.07202403247356415, 0.011093145236372948, -0.0014770339475944638, -0.000596403784584254, -0.00538735231384635, 0.0025709872134029865, -0.06027631089091301, 0.016729453578591347, 0.0018077179556712508, 0.060425084084272385, -0.021354399621486664, -0.023809261620044708, -0.021199092268943787, 0.024669284000992775, -0.027881598100066185, -0.031594887375831604, 0.027656665071845055, -0.03976273536682129, 0.006731914356350899, -0.05618725344538689, 0.049975309520959854, -0.0268392376601696, 0.0071595096960663795, -0.00890596304088831, 0.012284536845982075, -0.033162206411361694, 0.008500466123223305, 0.020156899467110634, 0.033725082874298096, 0.028406018391251564, -0.023481251671910286, -0.004999152384698391, -0.013382663950324059, -0.07832637429237366, -0.0028930765110999346, -0.04815953969955444, -0.012734861113131046, -0.06504090130329132, -0.0026215342804789543, 0.029963726177811623, 0.043487731367349625, -0.009226435795426369, 0.012522883713245392, -0.02638532966375351, 0.04832753166556358, 0.013166598975658417, -0.045835141092538834, -0.046052485704422, 0.022719480097293854, -0.014940023422241211, -0.006357547827064991, -0.0032103939447551966, 0.07967052608728409, 0.010823576711118221, -0.004686850123107433, -0.018361829221248627, 0.026768337935209274, 0.010238426737487316, 0.012590734288096428, 0.013122775591909885, -0.04969382658600807, 0.01248355582356453, -0.005642123520374298, 0.009203535504639149, -0.044255129992961884, -0.029303215444087982, -0.03243265300989151, -0.05292988568544388, -0.011687655001878738, 0.003169623902067542, -0.05008978396654129, 0.03287791088223457, -0.03541553020477295, 0.0016972975572571158, -0.03692862018942833, -0.019777599722146988, -0.0340961217880249, -0.007576744072139263, -0.013125883415341377, -0.06199902668595314, -0.017765328288078308, 0.02230582758784294, -0.024432336911559105, 0.016834160313010216, 0.010894683189690113, -0.008033820427954197, 0.02020883373916149, 0.006649413146078587, -0.006879664957523346, 0.00829176977276802, 0.07297253608703613, -0.018779773265123367, -0.010379517450928688, 0.03637663275003433, -0.04103019833564758, -0.038201954215765, 0.009239906445145607, -0.011129678227007389, 0.06346818804740906, -0.03238416090607643, 0.01387708354741335, -0.037914954125881195, 0.07719245553016663, -0.014192255213856697, 0.018702492117881775, 0.003940075635910034, -0.008080999366939068, 0.020023232325911522, -0.03726945444941521, -0.0062414598651230335, 0.0002547714102547616, -0.020979419350624084, 0.0035958935040980577, 0.0511971078813076, 0.014603124931454659, 0.006497840862721205, -0.014597286470234394, -0.0467672273516655, 0.007320128846913576, -0.02420484460890293, 0.003954506479203701, 0.029280610382556915, 0.03609167039394379, -0.04377456381917, 0.04875029996037483, -0.018422679975628853, 0.02428865246474743, -0.057452648878097534, -0.029690004885196686, 0.024455949664115906, 0.02779620885848999, 0.02753113955259323, -0.03574252128601074, 0.007349800784140825, 0.04723966494202614, -0.021374262869358063, -0.005956258159130812, -0.0028823106549680233, -0.010084188543260098, -0.01909622550010681, -0.014629878103733063, -0.03339000791311264, -0.023615527898073196, 0.042999036610126495, 0.03682968392968178, 0.027195751667022705, 0.023840539157390594, 0.003947603516280651, -0.011864963918924332, -0.007846692577004433, 0.013385619036853313, 0.011680769734084606, -0.05963020771741867, -0.004758099094033241, 0.012837323360145092, -0.00027713325107470155, 0.022429928183555603, -0.049727194011211395, 0.018383493646979332, 0.05160893499851227, 0.03398560732603073, 0.047382574528455734, 0.06289862096309662, 0.03293871134519577, -0.03823922574520111, -0.020168425515294075, -0.030919644981622696, -0.003884045174345374, -0.0052573117427527905, 0.013315611518919468, 0.01620412804186344, 0.01723395101726055, 0.01597820222377777, -0.01112420205026865, 0.01378113403916359, -0.011075872927904129, 0.01170929241925478, -0.019118700176477432, -0.03086576797068119, -0.021458825096488, -0.03464866057038307, -0.01250453945249319, -0.04001503065228462, 0.031891755759716034, 0.03746422752737999, 0.006007940508425236, -0.023902954533696175, -0.00186641002073884, -0.017780331894755363, -0.04988871142268181, 0.007440725341439247, 0.015551132149994373, -0.02002321556210518, -0.029115896672010422, -0.040869902819395065, -0.004971399903297424, -0.008494501933455467, 0.0008342118817381561, -0.014456711709499359, -0.02809428796172142, 0.050677306950092316, -0.006141965277493, -0.02367064356803894, 0.0324629470705986, -0.01963035762310028, 0.036816611886024475, -0.10480069369077682, 0.10429023951292038, 0.031389690935611725, 0.007017290219664574, -0.022186515852808952, 0.022815676406025887, 0.0053825112991034985, 0.015172608196735382, 0.004625618923455477, -0.00775689585134387, 0.021593928337097168, 0.012731241062283516, 0.050273165106773376, 0.03021770529448986, -0.057351551949977875, 0.028484370559453964, 0.014392276294529438, -0.005222199950367212, -0.022925695404410362, -0.022278377786278725, 0.04184624180197716, 0.0011215230915695429, 0.017600208520889282, -0.01170722022652626, 0.032998837530612946, -0.02026662789285183, -0.054636869579553604, 0.04880038648843765, -0.0499364398419857, -0.03450435772538185, 0.05556407570838928, -0.03140360489487648, -0.010287552140653133, 0.03791703283786774, 0.0028080567717552185, -0.0008954581571742892, 0.03727315366268158, -0.013013102114200592, -0.016481241211295128, 0.02348683774471283, -0.022273385897278786, 0.008397073484957218, -0.07112325727939606, -0.007615798618644476, 0.03667726740241051, -0.011763344518840313, 0.025321194902062416, 0.07370969653129578, 0.017783930525183678, 0.07752140611410141, 0.017692629247903824, 0.0013139405054971576, 0.0011472137412056327, -0.01779422163963318, 0.015206588432192802, -0.018376944586634636, 0.0003003283927682787, 0.002484517404809594, 0.012871049344539642, 0.03512001037597656, -0.036441463977098465, -0.01470151823014021, -0.01092907227575779, 0.0324229933321476, 0.016231732442975044, -0.02681650035083294, 0.006127837114036083, 0.001773262396454811, 0.04256407916545868, 0.014386369846761227, -0.031214522197842598, 0.042082007974386215, -0.05620139464735985, 0.004043993540108204, -0.03289482370018959, -0.03825460001826286, -0.038632385432720184, 0.0044906362891197205, 0.026446910575032234, 0.029456228017807007, 0.012356391176581383, 0.033057309687137604, -0.005037132650613785, -0.018230900168418884, 0.03365441784262657, -0.0177263543009758, -0.008732154034078121, -0.024913674220442772, 0.013763092458248138, 0.004695036448538303, 0.010386740788817406, -0.0054072430357337, -0.04582885280251503, 0.04676681384444237, 0.03420192003250122, 0.02825409173965454, -0.054249849170446396, -0.007275443058460951, 0.04423089697957039, 0.031239738687872887, -0.05661512166261673, -0.004922783933579922, -0.011463413946330547, 0.002854161197319627, -0.026061156764626503, -0.01390385627746582 ]
<p>Based on the lack of responses to <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/78593/centralization-measures-in-weighted-graphs">my previous network question</a>, perhaps this is not quite the place to ask this question, but I'll give it a try.</p> <p>I am planning a series of studies that involve small groups of people. In a typical study, the participants will meet in groups of 4 to have a discussion about a particular topic. As a group, the (student) participants will reach a decision about the topic (e.g., whether to support or oppose a proposed change in university policy). The discussion will be videotaped, and we will use transcripts of the discussion to obtain information about who is talking to whom about what topics. In addition, the participants will complete ratings of themselves and each other (e.g., What is your opinion about the proposed change? What do you think is this person's opinion of the proposed change?). I will also have a variety of data about the individual characteristics of all the participants. Thus, each group from each study will give me a 4-node network with directed, valued edges and a variety of attributes about each node. In a typical study, I might have 20 - 30 of these small groups (i.e., small, 4-node networks).</p> <p>In all the studies, I will be interested in group-level, relationship-level, and individual-level outcomes. I have provided below a sampling of the kinds of questions I would want to ask from these data: </p> <ol> <li>Which groups express the most agreement in their discussions? Which groups express the most disagreement? Is group composition related to agreement / disagreement and to the final decision outcome?</li> <li>Which pairs of people like each other during the discussion? Which pairs of people dislike each other? How are the pairwise patterns of liking related to the final decision outcome?</li> <li>Who has the most influence on the course of the discussion? Who has influence over the final decision of each group? Are there any individual difference characteristics that are related to influence over the discussion and / or final decision?</li> </ol> <p>And so on. What I am looking is the proper statistical model to use to investigate samples of networks, rather than individual networks.</p> <p>I have read a bit about single-network methods (like <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exponential_random_graph_models" rel="nofollow">exponential random graph models</a>, for which there is <a href="http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/ergm/index.html" rel="nofollow">a nice R package available</a>), but these methods do not seem appropriate, since I am dealing with a set of independent networks, rather than a single network. In addition, a plain linear mixed model does not seem appropriate because I am collecting explicitly relational data. Finally, although a method like the <a href="http://davidakenny.net/srm/soremo.htm" rel="nofollow">social relations model</a> seems appropriate for this situation at first blush, the social relations model seems to only partition the variance in round-robin ratings into perceiver, target, and relationship sources rather than allowing me to, for example, relate the patterns within a set of networks to overall network outcomes.</p> <p>Could anyone offer some advice about which statistical model might be appropriate for my situation? Any readings suggestions and / or software recommendations would be greatly appreciated. (FYI, I am a proficient R user, so R package recommendations would be especially appreciated).</p> <hr> <p><strong>Edit:</strong></p> <p>At the request of Alex Williams, I have posted some example data <a href="http://pastebin.com/t2Z00k7K" rel="nofollow">here</a> in csv format to give everyone a concrete example of the type of data I'm working with. In the sample data, participants, identified by <code>participant_id</code>, are each in 4-person groups, identified by <code>group_id</code>. The participants discuss a proposal and decide as a group whether the support or oppose the proposal. <code>group_decision</code> is the result of the group discussion. The participants also rate their own attitude toward the proposal (<code>pers_att</code>), their perceptions of the attitudes of the other group members (<code>p1_att</code> through <code>p4_att</code>; <code>person_id</code> tracks who <code>p1</code> through <code>p4</code> are within each group), and their own enjoyment of the discussion.</p> <p>In the sample data, I might be interested in the following sorts of questions:</p> <ol> <li>Are personal attitudes related to group-level decisions?</li> <li>Are personal attitudes related to personal enjoyment of the group discussion?</li> <li>Were people accurate in their ratings of other peoples' attitudes?</li> <li>Were the ratings of others related to others' enjoyment of the discussion?</li> <li>Does disagreement within a group (quantified, for example, by the difference between the minimum and maximum attitude ratings) relate to group-level decisions?</li> <li>Does disagreement within a group cause people to enjoy the discussion less?</li> <li>Did people who enjoyed the discussion more have more influence over the outcome?</li> </ol>
73,937
[ -0.038130708038806915, -0.034710247069597244, 0.006965077016502619, -0.03158676624298096, 0.028428416699171066, 0.022396676242351532, -0.019116247072815895, -0.04841122776269913, 0.03176671266555786, -0.04313726723194122, 0.017984095960855484, 0.03569505736231804, 0.032109156250953674, 0.032845400273799896, -0.031748801469802856, 0.01644434593617916, -0.030937479808926582, 0.024851076304912567, -0.01284850388765335, 0.014928094111382961, 0.01971736177802086, -0.0018628330435603857, 0.005409570410847664, -0.0025433998089283705, -0.040166400372982025, 0.03657059371471405, -0.0032870324794203043, -0.041199419647455215, -0.012798874638974667, 0.04563324153423309, -0.03688385337591171, -0.0060163261368870735, -0.005273891147226095, 0.006787571124732494, -0.011814786121249199, 0.009591716341674328, -0.012840691022574902, 0.0015466534532606602, -0.026708558201789856, 0.04107331484556198, -0.011967934668064117, 0.0075389244593679905, -0.016114944592118263, -0.0029716449789702892, -0.047166336327791214, -0.0141180120408535, 0.0343436636030674, -0.011473704129457474, 0.02013566717505455, -0.04271829128265381, 0.07488270848989487, 0.0013308890629559755, 0.020203683525323868, 0.021431386470794678, -0.01951429806649685, -0.020300261676311493, 0.04685474559664726, 0.061082445085048676, 0.01562582701444626, -0.04316249117255211, -0.010558639653027058, 0.0007759055006317794, 0.011805190704762936, -0.03296845406293869, -0.06570783257484436, 0.029868749901652336, 0.0012245363323017955, -0.0067178127355873585, 0.031620241701602936, -0.024883955717086792, -0.020428277552127838, 0.022792864590883255, 0.03908161073923111, 0.026932530105113983, -0.014227311126887798, 0.0034104029182344675, 0.026472236961126328, 0.004816881380975246, 0.06333330273628235, 0.06093493103981018, -0.01276028249412775, 0.010894903913140297, -0.013578490354120731, 0.021554967388510704, -0.0010698935948312283, -0.022698691114783287, 0.07740664482116699, -0.031787123531103134, -0.00964022520929575, 0.0034834998659789562, -0.023437192663550377, -0.014887862838804722, -0.020231667906045914, -0.016583800315856934, -0.02079562470316887, 0.014095420949161053, -0.018638918176293373, 0.030161725357174873, -0.00618703430518508, -0.008401335217058659, -0.016586903482675552, -0.006016244180500507, -0.02442173659801483, 0.03416723385453224, 0.011193926446139812, -0.0487678125500679, -0.05721999332308769, -0.0036620995961129665, -0.017513660714030266, -0.03158168867230415, -0.0014215465635061264, 0.004373189993202686, 0.0018316460773348808, 0.0028603021055459976, 0.0067998310551047325, -0.017013410106301308, 0.001959505258128047, -0.03161124140024185, 0.05860064923763275, 0.0468926839530468, 0.013547085225582123, 0.005378222092986107, 0.027107195928692818, -0.02542932517826557, -0.04858754202723503, -0.0023239480797201395, 0.022080369293689728, -0.009220833890140057, -0.006105029955506325, 0.055129241198301315, -0.01159550342708826, 0.018474945798516273, 0.004493067041039467, -0.0013783181784674525, 0.018025485798716545, 0.040072064846754074, -0.09109453856945038, -0.04193417727947235, 0.06795190274715424, -0.007315131835639477, 0.019472848623991013, -0.058212656527757645, -0.034933459013700485, 0.017996177077293396, 0.025193650275468826, -0.03979295864701271, 0.049299441277980804, 0.03364964947104454, 0.03244606405496597, 0.04629135504364967, -0.0006751698674634099, 0.029301296919584274, -0.0545666366815567, 0.009453333914279938, -0.011000134982168674, -0.06317147612571716, 0.027631958946585655, 0.0173572339117527, -0.015229524113237858, 0.02839416265487671, 0.016063811257481575, 0.01550029031932354, -0.018985189497470856, 0.0007269668276421726, 0.01417872216552496, 0.022625021636486053, 0.028640758246183395, -0.006381476763635874, -0.007428821176290512, -0.0041493261232972145, 0.019095810130238533, -0.002105595776811242, -0.02685326524078846, 0.04690022021532059, 0.04267175495624542, 0.01648668758571148, -0.0007925694226287305, 0.012554621323943138, -0.014340522699058056, -0.021399619057774544, -0.03608810529112816, -0.014643138274550438, -0.022925367578864098, 0.003414635080844164, 0.004591927397996187, 0.08471035212278366, 0.012953424826264381, -0.006185951177030802, 0.021271388977766037, -0.04875091835856438, -0.05350949987769127, -0.05896344780921936, 0.0013092698063701391, -0.039196766912937164, -0.027550866827368736, 0.011896256357431412, -0.01156153716146946, -0.01566651277244091, 0.007481734734028578, -0.03500746190547943, -0.022897357121109962, 0.026560263708233833, 0.07518918812274933, 0.009585749357938766, 0.01770428568124771, 0.04035937786102295, 0.03404182940721512, -0.04334861412644386, 0.018586957827210426, -0.025220975279808044, -0.05881929397583008, 0.016619810834527016, -0.03907785192131996, 0.05716228112578392, -0.01448378898203373, -0.010589458048343658, 0.023667816072702408, 0.03957638144493103, -0.022475434467196465, 0.009465375915169716, -0.09064208716154099, 0.09995424002408981, 0.04961954802274704, -0.005649484694004059, 0.019680729135870934, 0.045350074768066406, 0.023143185302615166, 0.0019012953853234649, -0.007393687032163143, 0.016051024198532104, -0.07180269807577133, -0.02652117609977722, 0.02040104568004608, 0.016989197582006454, -0.04095553979277611, 0.030879314988851547, 0.014241524040699005, 0.044823821634054184, -0.006548822857439518, -0.014122814871370792, 0.003555803094059229, -0.032399483025074005, 0.006307912524789572, 0.020721035078167915, 0.00016679747204761952, 0.019993320107460022, -0.017255019396543503, 0.03112637624144554, 0.06694797426462173, 0.008087275549769402, -0.001164330169558525, 0.05941241979598999, 0.033621132373809814, 0.018843555822968483, 0.01732161082327366, -0.0007877033785916865, 0.031234947964549065, -0.003550211898982525, -0.03684527426958084, 0.031590357422828674, 0.02658918872475624, 0.025185471400618553, 0.02052597887814045, -0.02919858507812023, 0.02396569401025772, 0.05637561157345772, -0.005322355777025223, 0.032905057072639465, 0.010266980156302452, -0.038586001843214035, 0.05030002072453499, -0.04827180877327919, -0.018020926043391228, -0.030876141041517258, 0.021472999826073647, 0.03412695974111557, 0.001409814110957086, -0.003660202492028475, -0.025905095040798187, -0.010871406644582748, 0.004075281322002411, -0.0019532134756445885, 0.01957758143544197, 0.03532152622938156, -0.05848626792430878, -0.01653708703815937, -0.021240174770355225, 0.0027069891802966595, -0.006856823805719614, -0.0005141720757819712, -0.006381362676620483, 0.04464738816022873, 0.015776699408888817, -0.07167405635118484, -0.0270707830786705, 0.0020996369421482086, 0.02341299317777157, -0.026587720960378647, -0.0069235567934811115, 0.034833576530218124, 0.03648044168949127, -0.010458355769515038, 0.020309913903474808, -0.020683497190475464, -0.029459534212946892, 0.0007984483381733298, -0.01316326204687357, 0.02789035066962242, 0.011308225803077221, -0.004493303131312132, 0.011236927472054958, 0.0006640363717451692, -0.04051588848233223, -0.09376535564661026, -0.04977789521217346, 0.0323936827480793, 0.015022790059447289, 0.04577755928039551, -0.002386855660006404, -0.0011120779672637582, 0.06664592027664185, 0.007429573219269514, -0.051252275705337524, -0.034067898988723755, 0.0017650615191087127, -0.05097515881061554, 0.008143540471792221, 0.07429390400648117, 0.022939112037420273, 0.000019790299120359123, -0.01603129506111145, 0.022384818643331528, 0.04440784826874733, 0.04489455372095108, -0.020380627363920212, 0.020227370783686638, 0.04351925849914551, 0.0035948336590081453, -0.016368845477700233, 0.045324329286813736, 0.028435543179512024, -0.04379851371049881, -0.006838448345661163, 0.00017252861289307475, -0.009840836748480797, -0.0021762277465313673, -0.09265884757041931, 0.003425192553550005, 0.009277349337935448, -0.030184373259544373, -0.03453533351421356, 0.03392493724822998, 0.008189216256141663, -0.0324387289583683, 0.004411960951983929, 0.023804953321814537, 0.04740467667579651, 0.006911373697221279, 0.004886643495410681, 0.06716936826705933, 0.05021124705672264, -0.02378941886126995, -0.00637985672801733, 0.009619534015655518, 0.005875884555280209, 0.005388925317674875, -0.0304794292896986, -0.012287234887480736, 0.00933900661766529, 0.06846808642148972, 0.02238575927913189, 0.012317569926381111, -0.04636400565505028, -0.0031195185147225857, -0.049880314618349075, 0.010759460739791393, -0.06439322978258133, 0.07858091592788696, -0.02587522193789482, 0.05858621001243591, -0.007039569318294525, 0.008816510438919067, -0.01177101582288742, -0.010672041215002537, -0.03970357030630112, 0.00910776387900114, -0.030591445043683052, 0.027985017746686935, 0.049967434257268906, 0.021467236801981926, 0.05821560323238373, 0.020738353952765465, 0.004570063669234514, -0.033027514815330505, 0.055259283632040024, 0.013099298812448978, -0.01611247844994068, -0.04071076586842537, -0.0017592118820175529, 0.015165758319199085, 0.0365171954035759, 0.046511225402355194, -0.03240049257874489, 0.015173915773630142, -0.0022069960832595825, 0.013413363136351109, -0.006537903565913439, -0.024200862273573875, -0.021365946158766747, 0.029466846957802773, 0.06394606083631516, 0.0051138736307621, 0.02003014087677002, 0.005039842799305916, 0.02406773529946804, 0.0329367034137249, 0.043987516313791275, 0.037107545882463455, -0.008777253329753876, -0.005247125867754221, -0.015361426398158073, -0.0027325712144374847, 0.0024366811849176884, 0.04280998930335045, -0.011921157129108906, -0.04433022439479828, 0.04158584401011467, 0.017085161060094833, -0.03307925909757614, 0.025644514709711075, 0.016396407037973404, 0.03857731819152832, -0.010408296249806881, -0.02017836831510067, 0.007775419391691685, 0.014891193248331547, -0.00014332962746266276, 0.027332229539752007, -0.003464643144980073, 0.0011843749089166522, -0.014234338887035847, 0.026067856699228287, 0.03695697337388992, -0.08428240567445755, 0.015619456768035889, -0.0217270627617836, 0.030979223549365997, 0.004365209955722094, -0.0032967955339699984, -0.0333016961812973, 0.036458928138017654, 0.06399945914745331, 0.016214877367019653, -0.008020862005650997, -0.0800957977771759, -0.00816301628947258, 0.04265347868204117, 0.07607226818799973, -0.04235535115003586, -0.04558899626135826, -0.01297373790293932, -0.013878490775823593, 0.022736605256795883, -0.012752754613757133, 0.04690692946314812, -0.021964916959404945, 0.03032052330672741, -0.048950135707855225, -0.048910219222307205, -0.017138490453362465, -0.0157880000770092, -0.018956132233142853, 0.014720112085342407, -0.018332654610276222, -0.01708129793405533, -0.0416778139770031, -0.003048171754926443, 0.033550817519426346, 0.0518590547144413, -0.022256219759583473, -0.009985401295125484, 0.023320024833083153, 0.005369461141526699, -0.023795854300260544, -0.05370016396045685, 0.042319051921367645, 0.052956629544496536, -0.015233345329761505, 0.06826900690793991, -0.0016316520050168037, -0.013080432079732418, 0.0017708170926198363, 0.008616145700216293, -0.02518530935049057, 0.0035942276008427143, -0.02935730293393135, 0.06597989052534103, 0.02491690404713154, -0.03431044891476631, 0.0569133423268795, 0.05407390743494034, -0.0339726097881794, -0.003050474217161536, -0.0362064354121685, -0.006541787646710873, -0.01689705066382885, -0.011203967034816742, 0.025246113538742065, -0.012464018538594246, -0.007378817535936832, -0.0014090632321313024, 0.0005474175559356809, 0.029817255213856697, -0.03298748657107353, -0.01980956830084324, 0.0006100417231209576, 0.003422265639528632, 0.026367057114839554, 0.020298751071095467, 0.010524032637476921, 0.01620178297162056, 0.02879277989268303, -0.01335282251238823, 0.03355588763952255, -0.05768727883696556, 0.023000532761216164, 0.0355471633374691, -0.057869382202625275, -0.042967382818460464, -0.05425984784960747, -0.03468133509159088, -0.011471792124211788, -0.028272097930312157, 0.053934939205646515, 0.0032462473027408123, 0.02062559686601162, 0.045393381267786026, -0.011875788681209087, -0.03421909362077713, 0.010006624273955822, -0.0009129124809987843, 0.029640156775712967, 0.011985380202531815, 0.004693839233368635, -0.021807124838232994, -0.009609457105398178, -0.05685862526297569, -0.019360482692718506, 0.02103360928595066, 0.0016519192140549421, -0.03679179772734642, -0.03396071493625641, -0.013721241615712643, 0.01060642208904028, -0.01610761135816574, -0.021414687857031822, 0.0610833466053009, -0.029154960066080093, 0.010278417728841305, -0.0189849641174078, 0.016930410638451576, 0.08873389661312103, 0.018034618347883224, -0.014775657095015049, -0.002289696130901575, -0.018063966184854507, -0.0010874790605157614, -0.020254941657185555, 0.007072939537465572, -0.03321181610226631, -0.027883457019925117, -0.03866086155176163, 0.013770313933491707, 0.04735073447227478, -0.03687117248773575, 0.004614385776221752, 0.016826685518026352, -0.016190454363822937, -0.034629106521606445, -0.009657290764153004, -0.004847139120101929, -0.008469563908874989, -0.0030209615360945463, -0.024280689656734467, 0.033192165195941925, 0.010492837056517601, -0.011544039472937584, 0.011207787320017815, -0.00535988062620163, -0.042256634682416916, 0.005571567919105291, 0.036974839866161346, 0.023054730147123337, 0.015959924086928368, 0.022972580045461655, -0.06293337792158127, 0.047631219029426575, -0.041803255677223206, -0.007804259192198515, 0.007392868399620056, 0.04388844221830368, -0.023731237277388573, -0.03536921739578247, -0.020226458087563515, -0.0086587592959404, 0.05496346950531006, 0.017275864258408546, 0.020320920273661613, 0.07483315467834473, -0.03918524459004402, 0.006781758740544319, -0.015178698115050793, 0.03548076003789902, -0.010852926410734653, 0.013998934999108315, 0.013381374068558216, -0.03862005099654198, -0.02432042919099331, 0.017896993085741997, 0.02013895846903324, 0.004341154359281063, 0.00889578741043806, 0.03398243710398674, -0.004650273360311985, 0.044551584869623184, -0.056753236800432205, -0.04808957129716873, 0.020884228870272636, -0.0834473967552185, 0.012203452177345753, -0.04012538492679596, -0.05534651130437851, 0.03436414897441864, 0.038877811282873154, 0.01979001611471176, -0.02555241622030735, 0.011921349912881851, -0.06383367627859116, 0.0029401190113276243, -0.0007175336359068751, -0.013653211295604706, -0.016606148332357407, 0.009858524426817894, 0.027510356158018112, -0.02326011285185814, 0.024249467998743057, -0.02710888348519802, -0.09040606021881104, -0.04100411385297775, 0.025096921250224113, -0.06825659424066544, 0.026578431949019432, 0.024219566956162453, -0.02898627519607544, 0.02062973938882351, -0.05067985877394676, 0.019504062831401825, 0.034812577068805695, 0.013904045335948467, -0.03965757414698601, 0.00976986438035965, 0.0011912521440535784, 0.03283600136637688, 0.004120603669434786, -0.036355338990688324, 0.1356017291545868, 0.06303856521844864, 0.018676012754440308, -0.03266999125480652, 0.041579097509384155, 0.028449442237615585, -0.01730513386428356, -0.035492315888404846, 0.007495659403502941, 0.019963059574365616, -0.002933503594249487, 0.03994622826576233, 0.02927609346807003, 0.009158224798738956, -0.007221462205052376, 0.09127384424209595, -0.0016241117846220732, -0.04019979387521744, 0.017051517963409424, -0.01399999763816595, -0.008199756033718586, -0.019591091200709343, -0.048962995409965515, 0.016034139320254326, -0.0017954644281417131, -0.002775364788249135, -0.015649447217583656, -0.020493803545832634, 0.03967093303799629, -0.029602494090795517, 0.00340484781190753, 0.0023268067743629217, 0.02551235444843769, 0.0178562980145216, -0.04381120949983597, -0.0163146760314703, 0.02079065889120102, -0.04687635600566864, 0.033002834767103195, 0.049694985151290894, -0.03271026909351349, -0.011185743845999241, -0.01723589561879635, 0.024087294936180115, -0.050200846046209335, -0.06045202538371086, -0.014457072131335735, 0.03140584006905556, 0.030850548297166824, -0.009171395562589169, -0.008162236772477627, 0.004301170352846384, 0.004444860853254795, -0.01939992606639862, 0.0031379449646919966, 0.0025809849612414837, 0.06712812185287476, -0.021789362654089928, -0.037784989923238754, -0.018223093822598457, 0.0248856358230114, -0.025532318279147148, -0.012440657243132591, 0.02312750741839409, -0.032345663756132126, -0.07037234306335449, -0.029389625415205956, -0.012412636540830135, 0.01785603165626526, 0.022782616317272186, -0.016931472346186638, -0.021262234076857567, 0.003493137424811721, 0.013390831649303436, -0.02725587971508503, 0.01055939868092537, 0.0535358302295208, 0.029034452512860298, 0.005587918683886528, -0.011073252186179161, -0.0019398271106183529, -0.007122362032532692, -0.04779989644885063, -0.010229656472802162, -0.014122110791504383, 0.011798139661550522, 0.009221617132425308, 0.009150473400950432, 0.010247468017041683, -0.006269143428653479, 0.035667531192302704, 0.034597478806972504, 0.012087089940905571, -0.026143278926610947, -0.02960911951959133, -0.012748762965202332, -0.05286116525530815, -0.010549529455602169, 0.01195583026856184, 0.09209343045949936, -0.015537593513727188, -0.03134089708328247, 0.008719517849385738, 0.020029010251164436, 0.009813767857849598, 0.00799572467803955, 0.05941582843661308, -0.08087380230426788, -0.03073553368449211, 0.015087848529219627, -0.021096572279930115, -0.0532829649746418, -0.014178206212818623, -0.051914114505052567, -0.009529724717140198, 0.030815431848168373, -0.02656104974448681, -0.024769768118858337, 0.003084341296926141, -0.014927195385098457, 0.05911816284060478, 0.011259512975811958, -0.01601029373705387, -0.02287326008081436, -0.04599536955356598, -0.020920051261782646, 0.02108304388821125, -0.010844126343727112, 0.014856552705168724, 0.034833874553442, 0.003814106108620763, 0.018001407384872437, -0.022475475445389748, 0.002632695948705077, -0.020836884155869484, -0.0018380280816927552, 0.01894780434668064, 0.04221317172050476, 0.012423863634467125, -0.04904601722955704, 0.03866932913661003, -0.02464810572564602, -0.03360858932137489, 0.026504743844270706, -0.0031470246613025665, 0.03121831640601158, 0.007916045375168324, -0.04802316799759865, 0.010463211685419083, 0.023272356018424034, -0.037236761301755905, -0.019920920953154564, -0.02234644815325737, 0.01781814731657505, 0.024456437677145004, -0.007320004981011152, -0.005813817493617535, 0.00479772686958313, 0.010663118213415146, 0.01066674292087555, 0.033334601670503616, -0.010870439931750298, -0.017644334584474564, -0.057188212871551514, -0.008519678376615047, 0.0028163727838546038, -0.023009633645415306, 0.0032912753522396088, -0.002095946343615651, 0.038611412048339844, -0.04459500312805176, 0.018068816512823105, 0.02597789466381073, 0.01097673736512661, -0.08142295479774475, -0.018367907032370567, -0.009166540578007698, 0.011652527377009392, 0.015193894505500793, -0.04054218903183937, -0.000801520305685699, 0.02597527951002121, -0.06281379610300064, 0.04059037193655968, 0.010371170938014984, 0.009832598268985748, -0.007300302851945162, -0.0062664165161550045, -0.04837443307042122, 0.026995737105607986, -0.022754715755581856, 0.05576149746775627, 0.0014072750927880406, 0.009734170511364937, 0.0043333712965250015, 0.014150376431643963, -0.02951253578066826, 0.00619381433352828, -0.0037244842387735844, -0.03772716969251633, 0.004711331333965063, -0.05198751389980316, -0.04266425967216492, 0.028697852045297623, 0.019785158336162567, 0.016662249341607094, 0.016783582046628, 0.009896465577185154, -0.01503828912973404, 0.042509086430072784, 0.04283040016889572, 0.003669171128422022, 0.00335087557323277, -0.00625851983204484, -0.011604400351643562, 0.015497096814215183, 0.035255491733551025, 0.0025564697571098804, 0.048189740628004074, -0.006660306826233864, 0.024258621037006378, 0.0355374701321125, -0.018227072432637215, -0.02188149467110634, -0.006737014278769493, -0.012938292697072029, 0.004925721324980259, -0.014216548763215542, -0.016507118940353394, -0.051965951919555664, -0.0231956597417593, 0.007683259434998035, 0.012983059510588646, 0.006463836878538132, 0.017606684938073158, 0.030133534222841263, -0.020962612703442574, 0.006742373108863831, -0.03719601780176163, -0.019853228703141212, -0.07231106609106064, -0.02660193108022213, -0.02596159279346466, -0.014309512451291084, -0.0007707331096753478, 0.013688946142792702, -0.013645941391587257, 0.038669850677251816, -0.05652347952127457, -0.001658730790950358, -0.023772256448864937, -0.043387070298194885, 0.032389283180236816, -0.09590861946344376, 0.02800016850233078, 0.03005572035908699, 0.011974350549280643, -0.03642909973859787, 0.0015280115185305476, -0.017445482313632965, 0.006074904929846525, 0.053612202405929565, 0.02933761104941368, 0.008153746835887432, -0.014830016531050205, 0.007779288105666637, 0.034989356994628906, -0.0379316471517086, 0.03805149719119072, -0.026056820526719093, 0.04929545894265175, -0.018510306254029274, -0.012912595644593239, -0.0014544931473210454, -0.014150727540254593, 0.032180894166231155, -0.016397366300225258, -0.019235149025917053, -0.01974860392510891, 0.011491076089441776, 0.023567022755742073, -0.018591945990920067, -0.016806377097964287, 0.030905237421393394, 0.007957573980093002, -0.008718173019587994, 0.02997555211186409, 0.00257544731721282, -0.029689213261008263, 0.025906281545758247, -0.029335640370845795, -0.04638701304793358, 0.01256336085498333, 0.012760487385094166, 0.06492814421653748, -0.08686782419681549, -0.015596520155668259, 0.02336490899324417, -0.018655957654118538, 0.008663810789585114, 0.04530356079339981, 0.05077076330780983, -0.00722849415615201, 0.018140770494937897, 0.03387947753071785, -0.032121896743774414, -0.02892211452126503, 0.013538802973926067, -0.001528457854874432, 0.030742892995476723, 0.009147525765001774, -0.015945931896567345, -0.0061014448292553425, -0.021112406626343727, 0.05610288679599762, -0.017269810661673546, 0.013961877673864365, -0.024670330807566643, -0.007091328501701355, 0.0472770594060421, 0.0061710914596915245, 0.03185749053955078, 0.032394181936979294, 0.019736627116799355, 0.07181669026613235, -0.010163359344005585, -0.009505550377070904, -0.030064528807997704, -0.01370301004499197, -0.03413823992013931, 0.018082542344927788, 0.02634851261973381, 0.04645032808184624, -0.01700018346309662, 0.015372422523796558, -0.028037700802087784, -0.01458761841058731, 0.02063126116991043, -0.009833453223109245, 0.02112497016787529, -0.009477362968027592, 0.010959802195429802, -0.003465372370555997, -0.01822064071893692, -0.015865350142121315, 0.017947891727089882, 0.012742812745273113, 0.03067069500684738, 0.02760648913681507, 0.023912686854600906, 0.007722343318164349, 0.007389495614916086, 0.04531324654817581, -0.020274827256798744, -0.028865918517112732, -0.07597389817237854, 0.02378474362194538, 0.015830988064408302, -0.00558070745319128 ]
<p>Can data sparseness appear due to either high sample size or high dimension? How different are the situations in the two cases? Thanks!</p>
73,938
[ -0.036046337336301804, 0.01328018493950367, 0.03770016133785248, -0.020209545269608498, 0.057783663272857666, 0.01273864321410656, -0.01838863082230091, -0.027363179251551628, 0.031192420050501823, -0.047587454319000244, 0.01430222112685442, -0.0041722869500517845, 0.03337550535798073, 0.021715689450502396, 0.00791569147258997, -0.008291898295283318, -0.01936289109289646, 0.014028648845851421, 0.009791441261768341, 0.017554253339767456, 0.024273067712783813, 0.032093461602926254, 0.04096762090921402, -0.009209374897181988, -0.05788864195346832, 0.0452791228890419, 0.04029051586985588, 0.033801525831222534, 0.02686873823404312, 0.027760762721300125, -0.03612624108791351, 0.012556091882288456, -0.007265571504831314, 0.06427089869976044, 0.01436727773398161, -0.023957552388310432, -0.034614838659763336, -0.023304766044020653, 0.030104657635092735, 0.03535538911819458, -0.0008700886974111199, -0.02995648793876171, 0.019541794434189796, 0.03236879035830498, -0.034026071429252625, 0.030108649283647537, 0.011914806440472603, -0.06489980220794678, 0.02416868507862091, -0.05602749064564705, 0.07501086592674255, -0.011401279829442501, 0.05389288440346718, 0.009475245140492916, -0.011366135440766811, -0.005433280952274799, 0.041142016649246216, 0.06518230587244034, -0.020325982943177223, -0.04250707849860191, -0.002905320143327117, -0.019665686413645744, 0.0014976637903600931, -0.026655130088329315, -0.05319922789931297, 0.0735359936952591, -0.024615095928311348, -0.03595100715756416, 0.035177022218704224, 0.014093958772718906, -0.0004188265011180192, -0.0007745048496872187, 0.03970176354050636, -0.02131282351911068, 0.009121876209974289, -0.002218463458120823, 0.005338647868484259, 0.02193731628358364, 0.05273975804448128, 0.02565426006913185, 0.016586247831583023, 0.01656063087284565, 0.03195599094033241, -0.01257745549082756, 0.030245374888181686, -0.019432364031672478, 0.04735076054930687, -0.04121505841612816, 0.0064274403266608715, 0.011176313273608685, -0.012815071269869804, 0.0022201177198439837, 0.06046155467629433, -0.021119508892297745, -0.026101019233465195, 0.014167825691401958, 0.007130214013159275, 0.06097177043557167, 0.01788036711513996, -0.01693890057504177, -0.006169739179313183, -0.028396422043442726, 0.02318279817700386, 0.05142129212617874, -0.026973536238074303, -0.018915902823209763, -0.024954592809081078, 0.025083381682634354, -0.0307744350284338, -0.009685060009360313, -0.007173818536102772, 0.012799627147614956, 0.012259792536497116, 0.007647452875971794, 0.05522000789642334, 0.012531802989542484, 0.004087038803845644, -0.03242283686995506, 0.058800049126148224, 0.1190183162689209, 0.008711257018148899, -0.038859374821186066, 0.027277633547782898, -0.03299432992935181, -0.044485725462436676, 0.007382816169410944, 0.023508012294769287, -0.012517913244664669, -0.041254673153162, 0.06153502315282822, -0.020293500274419785, -0.02786950021982193, 0.048016250133514404, -0.018113598227500916, 0.03045654483139515, 0.007188666611909866, -0.08894165605306625, -0.022600771859288216, 0.06964024901390076, -0.014620945788919926, -0.01043388620018959, -0.05186069756746292, 0.014817385002970695, 0.031281985342502594, 0.029599327594041824, -0.010913324542343616, 0.04747072979807854, 0.04977159574627876, 0.035706762224435806, 0.029240736737847328, -0.030438585206866264, -0.0166579931974411, 0.005574554670602083, -0.011740968562662601, 0.020191509276628494, -0.077639140188694, -0.011446082033216953, 0.023917628452181816, -0.0010315406834706664, -0.014438673853874207, -0.0015480751171708107, 0.001802691025659442, -0.02310805954039097, 0.012315405532717705, 0.03083956614136696, -0.01678117923438549, 0.050491295754909515, 0.005745227448642254, 0.062021706253290176, 0.050920724868774414, -0.0008877241634763777, -0.006001438479870558, 0.048281703144311905, 0.06311354786157608, 0.038651272654533386, 0.012606877833604813, -0.028760526329278946, -0.014954949729144573, 0.020338891074061394, 0.006455010734498501, -0.06725477427244186, -0.035522978752851486, -0.02079097181558609, 0.01583253964781761, 0.018017582595348358, 0.06797383725643158, 0.025508075952529907, -0.07885967195034027, 0.02396625280380249, -0.047140009701251984, -0.050383664667606354, -0.0491439588367939, -0.003719903761520982, -0.013244114816188812, -0.031577013432979584, 0.034595176577568054, 0.029108339920639992, -0.0018992413533851504, -0.035538092255592346, -0.020947154611349106, -0.014328142628073692, -0.02323724515736103, 0.0029254129622131586, -0.02009665220975876, -0.006450165994465351, 0.027441998943686485, 0.008910072036087513, -0.021413907408714294, 0.034239258617162704, 0.009089753031730652, -0.06541568040847778, 0.003133749356493354, -0.011769132688641548, 0.03399525582790375, -0.04005146771669388, -0.025238368660211563, 0.008429793640971184, -0.026056984439492226, -0.040231987833976746, 0.06482013314962387, -0.025517651811242104, 0.07698395103216171, 0.05406951159238815, 0.02145497314631939, -0.0010269958293065429, -0.009497196413576603, -0.006189296487718821, -0.04339710250496864, -0.016017448157072067, -0.0020755804143846035, -0.049482084810733795, -0.0192397590726614, 0.03707720339298248, 0.04113204777240753, -0.044951993972063065, 0.018116727471351624, 0.053637973964214325, 0.04956430941820145, 0.025500480085611343, 0.04282484948635101, -0.017160505056381226, -0.033717039972543716, -0.006107320077717304, 0.024315902963280678, 0.007551201619207859, -0.03192870691418648, -0.02262135222554207, 0.011725513264536858, 0.05488536134362221, -0.020698538050055504, 0.007799186743795872, 0.03797515109181404, -0.025800518691539764, -0.015210806392133236, -0.00786983035504818, -0.020979389548301697, 0.010376963764429092, -0.030055075883865356, -0.015544654801487923, 0.017412494868040085, -0.0043642716482281685, 0.02852707728743553, -0.02316296473145485, -0.00946851447224617, 0.01561325415968895, -0.0061935861594974995, -0.008113901130855083, -0.015231529250741005, 0.043222177773714066, -0.03746096044778824, 0.004918140824884176, -0.02720472775399685, -0.023139670491218567, -0.03904809430241585, 0.00763003621250391, 0.06955268979072571, -0.0250563845038414, 0.04387562349438667, 0.0006126085063442588, -0.024346143007278442, -0.00570053793489933, -0.044280435889959335, 0.01879609376192093, -0.004136706702411175, -0.04184286296367645, 0.0008333564619533718, -0.03615691885352135, 0.005649950820952654, 0.013824370689690113, -0.024939192458987236, 0.026142174378037453, 0.005163396708667278, -0.012441531755030155, -0.04924885556101799, 0.000687386142089963, -0.028854845091700554, 0.059918150305747986, 0.012110545299947262, -0.002550557954236865, 0.0380232073366642, -0.012226964347064495, -0.028487026691436768, -0.010091337375342846, 0.008379921317100525, -0.05270073190331459, -0.05580813065171242, -0.017636695876717567, -0.006602879613637924, -0.006493085063993931, -0.02145366743206978, 0.053088799118995667, -0.03116052970290184, -0.0030827841255813837, -0.06117435544729233, -0.045296765863895416, 0.027176305651664734, -0.028265664353966713, 0.04520678520202637, -0.017036139965057373, -0.03721078112721443, 0.05706777051091194, 0.022806907072663307, -0.011105728335678577, -0.02070506475865841, -0.03943100944161415, -0.04542040452361107, -0.00819415133446455, 0.02538340725004673, -0.013400417752563953, 0.0076283239759504795, 0.01189510989934206, 0.0009836130775511265, 0.03088480792939663, 0.025476252660155296, 0.018740063533186913, -0.020536402240395546, 0.03139501065015793, 0.013162968680262566, 0.008932207711040974, -0.002879310166463256, 0.017813170328736305, -0.058762144297361374, 0.007031925953924656, -0.017709089443087578, 0.038556285202503204, 0.00213560345582664, -0.024751737713813782, -0.011637509800493717, -0.004647322464734316, 0.05716162547469139, -0.03979995474219322, -0.0061301663517951965, 0.02075696550309658, -0.0051166038028895855, -0.011942433193325996, 0.034924328327178955, 0.03257102519273758, -0.034801263362169266, 0.007984618656337261, 0.060821402817964554, 0.0194669421762228, -0.02865932695567608, 0.022046389058232307, 0.012796787545084953, -0.013447964563965797, 0.040835388004779816, -0.03802984207868576, -0.009378205984830856, 0.053503409028053284, 0.028732553124427795, 0.03556748852133751, -0.010936399921774864, -0.04104696586728096, 0.028934473171830177, -0.08565769344568253, -0.011879084631800652, 0.009074150584638119, 0.05010341480374336, -0.014283268712460995, 0.03921676427125931, 0.01876233145594597, 0.008443395607173443, -0.01911134459078312, -0.004416578449308872, -0.054829422384500504, -0.003533212933689356, -0.053148284554481506, 0.020894920453429222, 0.011349707841873169, -0.028879018500447273, 0.028044451028108597, -0.020389936864376068, 0.008956111036241055, -0.0014689639210700989, 0.045715928077697754, -0.053341951221227646, 0.014386394061148167, -0.01411678921431303, 0.020244086161255836, -0.022651880979537964, 0.026165151968598366, 0.03461874648928642, 0.003173013450577855, 0.035887233912944794, 0.04099053889513016, -0.0006949743838049471, -0.008198807947337627, -0.0014819827629253268, 0.04894758760929108, 0.003089561825618148, 0.04538683220744133, 0.005841883365064859, 0.029168380424380302, -0.030523162335157394, 0.026487169787287712, 0.017520811408758163, 0.07756233960390091, -0.0008149743662215769, 0.002793304855003953, -0.01207588892430067, -0.05577397719025612, -0.03214171156287193, 0.011682683601975441, 0.02956671267747879, 0.000245207134867087, -0.002332547679543495, 0.03469806909561157, 0.01881559193134308, -0.05171368271112442, 0.032321278005838394, 0.04016134887933731, 0.0200083889067173, 0.020337071269750595, -0.0462278388440609, 0.0037581096403300762, -0.010183168575167656, 0.01763017289340496, 0.052542585879564285, 0.00605837581679225, -0.013313590548932552, -0.016724728047847748, 0.02603023499250412, -0.020221270620822906, -0.04662679508328438, 0.012434232980012894, 0.0339423343539238, 0.021117504686117172, -0.011674334295094013, -0.017138225957751274, 0.00914753694087267, 0.022601008415222168, 0.05589096248149872, 0.056666385382413864, 0.0034285904839634895, -0.07744410634040833, -0.023448016494512558, 0.020835356786847115, 0.015077492222189903, -0.01643115095794201, 0.014305760152637959, -0.050744764506816864, -0.02299574762582779, 0.05666466802358627, -0.02826664410531521, 0.023436015471816063, -0.007624182850122452, 0.01929358020424843, -0.018082793802022934, -0.015263128094375134, -0.017890689894557, -0.008216620422899723, -0.008307619951665401, 0.03240622952580452, -0.004093850031495094, -0.042894404381513596, -0.05399263650178909, 0.024657869711518288, 0.012124525383114815, 0.036248672753572464, 0.016929470002651215, -0.014489781111478806, -0.009125622920691967, 0.03150828555226326, -0.01826663315296173, -0.07211872190237045, 0.04233502224087715, 0.013243338093161583, -0.012357573956251144, 0.06703175604343414, -0.007608500774949789, -0.04651183262467384, 0.011612292379140854, 0.01192342210561037, -0.024578560143709183, 0.0013971485896036029, -0.016154659911990166, 0.030949139967560768, 0.024844445288181305, 0.0058656721375882626, 0.05793408676981926, 0.0027378001250326633, 0.02918504737317562, -0.010651368647813797, -0.02239149995148182, 0.03483930975198746, -0.04878474771976471, -0.013141484931111336, -0.04471877962350845, 0.0027743412647396326, -0.030668964609503746, 0.03155340626835823, 0.017685802653431892, 0.04707428440451622, -0.001978135434910655, -0.021185042336583138, -0.001355089363642037, 0.041033655405044556, 0.02603139542043209, -0.024837708100676537, 0.016946369782090187, 0.04230949282646179, -0.019702570512890816, -0.006633967626839876, 0.01565367542207241, -0.00020371931896079332, -0.015019618906080723, 0.000928316090721637, -0.013665445148944855, -0.006043620407581329, -0.023893317207694054, -0.013221708126366138, 0.031379032880067825, 0.010437441989779472, 0.05088825151324272, -0.04368989169597626, 0.02226032130420208, -0.01953984424471855, -0.09091018885374069, 0.021950213238596916, 0.01262838114053011, 0.00004648240428650752, 0.058552879840135574, -0.05455075949430466, 0.04398559033870697, -0.02022111415863037, -0.011282629333436489, -0.08799869567155838, -0.04945353791117668, 0.020672140643000603, 0.033919669687747955, -0.010167364962399006, -0.010087587870657444, -0.011305229738354683, -0.025994736701250076, -0.015238817781209946, -0.018035171553492546, 0.038149040192365646, -0.017079131677746773, -0.03870387375354767, 0.011520479805767536, 0.004317710176110268, 0.05737246200442314, -0.016547389328479767, 0.0020175809040665627, -0.0009717173525132239, 0.002076952252537012, 0.026866603642702103, -0.021844588220119476, 0.04509764164686203, -0.02719266340136528, -0.016957160085439682, -0.04939017817378044, -0.032614950090646744, 0.029583072289824486, -0.03138028830289841, -0.019728071987628937, 0.021022500470280647, -0.008500300347805023, 0.030834294855594635, -0.014021450653672218, 0.012123159132897854, 0.0033504758030176163, -0.0011337515898048878, -0.017904644832015038, -0.03548891097307205, -0.0033605291973799467, -0.02923606149852276, 0.013826494105160236, 0.016676587983965874, -0.010333416983485222, 0.017459889873862267, 0.008939388208091259, -0.030160313472151756, -0.0074388119392097, -0.02046770416200161, -0.02588779665529728, 0.027676880359649658, -0.023473380133509636, -0.003168783150613308, 0.0010966213885694742, 0.04396488517522812, -0.04534098505973816, -0.033538416028022766, -0.011991621926426888, 0.023294342681765556, 0.06192775070667267, -0.002885866677388549, 0.016671696677803993, 0.06805788725614548, -0.043258149176836014, 0.003663263050839305, -0.041869595646858215, -0.014073443599045277, 0.0066027832217514515, 0.006185551639646292, 0.042443446815013885, 0.01224951446056366, -0.014761622063815594, 0.04835231974720955, -0.00011493408237583935, -0.0009132829145528376, 0.03696014732122421, 0.021081814542412758, 0.007407430559396744, 0.020203324034810066, -0.04010672867298126, -0.0569385327398777, 0.006815419532358646, -0.01824958808720112, 0.03691864013671875, -0.007139353081583977, 0.005894823465496302, 0.04992828518152237, 0.04322009161114693, 0.030200038105249405, -0.03686904534697533, -0.01127562951296568, -0.022227277979254723, -0.002007540548220277, 0.020486926659941673, 0.02466743439435959, 0.004321208689361811, -0.009493817575275898, 0.01724739372730255, -0.007369540631771088, -0.0020888429135084152, 0.0151365352794528, -0.07074981927871704, -0.05487481504678726, -0.012149964459240437, -0.024753447622060776, 0.012979510240256786, 0.007891444489359856, -0.047175321727991104, 0.017017627134919167, -0.06252265721559525, 0.027857353910803795, 0.028483180329203606, 0.032925356179475784, -0.001604427583515644, 0.02930234558880329, 0.029642637819051743, 0.0006115954020060599, -0.01840953901410103, 0.02089724875986576, 0.10108757019042969, 0.10910607874393463, 0.0352034717798233, -0.05630997568368912, 0.029219014570116997, -0.00382808200083673, -0.03170867636799812, -0.031043441966176033, 0.013775153085589409, -0.005532546434551477, 0.004607729613780975, 0.03819773718714714, 0.03658725693821907, 0.004990039858967066, -0.005976786371320486, 0.0245475135743618, -0.04234980419278145, -0.03491244465112686, -0.007264535408467054, 0.010093513876199722, 0.005521117709577084, 0.009737436659634113, -0.041924040764570236, 0.01196248922497034, 0.0067912680096924305, -0.039175163954496384, -0.0118941655382514, 0.021045256406068802, 0.007059190887957811, -0.021247247233986855, -0.041965045034885406, -0.01761854626238346, 0.031937528401613235, 0.014544988051056862, -0.059210777282714844, 0.010564750991761684, 0.012606658972799778, -0.032164983451366425, -0.024738743901252747, 0.01806320622563362, -0.02348153665661812, -0.01208651065826416, -0.014004162512719631, -0.0004029026604257524, -0.053351372480392456, -0.027901995927095413, -0.006751688662916422, 0.05776143819093704, 0.01864980347454548, 0.03526676073670387, -0.006899186875671148, 0.02907473035156727, 0.01048225536942482, -0.044692933559417725, 0.003357748966664076, 0.024501509964466095, 0.029674280434846878, -0.05785663053393364, -0.0316372849047184, -0.01902303844690323, 0.009354069828987122, -0.021032068878412247, 0.02707880176603794, 0.0056195855140686035, -0.028777308762073517, 0.003832749091088772, -0.007919490337371826, 0.025423288345336914, 0.017107825726270676, 0.03324667736887932, -0.03317968174815178, 0.007932204753160477, -0.007385370787233114, -0.03151746839284897, 0.010389241389930248, 0.009307065047323704, 0.011729923076927662, -0.01684681512415409, -0.032687824219465256, -0.031373292207717896, -0.03154078871011734, 0.02865057997405529, -0.036589037626981735, -0.026508159935474396, -0.04757002368569374, -0.009026475250720978, -0.002137364586815238, 0.049600888043642044, 0.010136697441339493, 0.004037451930344105, -0.014983518049120903, 0.038378629833459854, 0.008153527975082397, -0.05419064685702324, -0.0007653372013010085, -0.02091124840080738, -0.04582742601633072, 0.012600158341228962, 0.022293543443083763, 0.04368586838245392, 0.009967965073883533, 0.007226297166198492, -0.002165460027754307, 0.03228393569588661, -0.013408008962869644, -0.01455768570303917, 0.022704031318426132, -0.04606739431619644, 0.018217559903860092, 0.022214878350496292, 0.0006355619407258928, -0.052800778299570084, -0.04079008474946022, -0.040844108909368515, -0.007365839555859566, -0.018670057877898216, 0.019157767295837402, 0.0032161041162908077, 0.0031438590958714485, 0.0014121531276032329, 0.05568589270114899, -0.015343092381954193, -0.02925781160593033, -0.03254587948322296, 0.004262794274836779, 0.02543029375374317, -0.024497147649526596, 0.005344725213944912, -0.001592805958352983, -0.02234315685927868, -0.0007200050167739391, 0.013566258363425732, 0.013420021161437035, 0.014838306233286858, -0.0017251959070563316, 0.01111514400690794, -0.012065439485013485, 0.05355582758784294, -0.034528929740190506, -0.025952564552426338, 0.045501235872507095, -0.0666419193148613, -0.04514803737401962, 0.024367546662688255, -0.06552132219076157, 0.02028258889913559, 0.05660654231905937, 0.009875775314867496, -0.04773806035518646, 0.04558251425623894, -0.02738535776734352, -0.014440180733799934, 0.016360972076654434, 0.01907411776483059, -0.018139436841011047, -0.007120157591998577, 0.0009835032979026437, 0.0004541059024631977, -0.012227768078446388, 0.007677488029003143, 0.041321855038404465, 0.04583048075437546, -0.024693090468645096, 0.014737475663423538, -0.008395963348448277, 0.0333348885178566, 0.02351638861000538, -0.021060200408101082, 0.04654284566640854, 0.0722542405128479, -0.06298705190420151, 0.02909970097243786, 0.03186151757836342, 0.04082785174250603, -0.1084802895784378, -0.019511623308062553, 0.02452370710670948, 0.0025740021374076605, 0.022368958219885826, -0.06010587513446808, -0.013687345199286938, 0.04809162765741348, -0.07883704453706741, -0.00036627473309636116, -0.01829310692846775, 0.007162531837821007, -0.05723246559500694, 0.001042807474732399, -0.012055554427206516, 0.0011549181072041392, 0.048010796308517456, 0.031520240008831024, 0.020803138613700867, 0.022387761622667313, -0.014178951270878315, 0.01627502590417862, -0.030903639271855354, 0.022274145856499672, -0.03477631136775017, -0.04651529714465141, 0.028558528050780296, -0.028401216492056847, -0.03400150313973427, 0.008659088052809238, 0.002332559321075678, 0.001682174508459866, 0.046655893325805664, -0.011457364074885845, 0.01601603627204895, 0.023296544328331947, 0.0258841123431921, -0.029503382742404938, -0.012400580570101738, 0.002986690029501915, -0.023371925577521324, 0.03320222347974777, 0.04323197528719902, 0.03508424013853073, 0.025204820558428764, -0.034626636654138565, 0.04040379822254181, 0.015034937299787998, -0.00024160821340046823, -0.02957172878086567, -0.004816093947738409, 0.006931339390575886, 0.01809980534017086, -0.015330799855291843, 0.05677296966314316, -0.05214276164770126, -0.023980004712939262, 0.013585438020527363, 0.015644360333681107, -0.022946732118725777, 0.03869565576314926, 0.008571895770728588, -0.0570644736289978, 0.00803769938647747, -0.009117845445871353, -0.01581139862537384, -0.06643584370613098, -0.018433310091495514, -0.004013630095869303, 0.007306927349418402, -0.009130495600402355, -0.02370091900229454, -0.03632647544145584, 0.055712904781103134, 0.0048483628779649734, 0.020930292084813118, 0.004754700232297182, -0.05121482163667679, -0.03580303117632866, -0.09960070997476578, 0.06340193003416061, -0.01309961173683405, 0.006097458302974701, -0.03603068366646767, 0.0014208168722689152, -0.0421823188662529, 0.011508580297231674, 0.048015303909778595, 0.005744280759245157, 0.017239311710000038, -0.0009562179329805076, 0.012389732524752617, 0.006145400460809469, -0.03295919671654701, 0.03235697001218796, -0.006505027413368225, -0.022191833704710007, 0.001961695495992899, -0.04396451264619827, 0.03337948024272919, 0.006322671193629503, 0.028097519651055336, -0.004181943833827972, 0.03881978988647461, -0.006494792643934488, 0.0001205058943014592, 0.0677424743771553, 0.005577570758759975, -0.003271942725405097, 0.047376599162817, -0.019100364297628403, 0.025646155700087547, 0.015910876914858818, -0.005360134411603212, -0.04724700003862381, 0.010694599710404873, -0.023541530594229698, -0.024854110553860664, 0.028617585077881813, 0.028991807252168655, 0.010786958038806915, -0.053350988775491714, 0.0008391092414967716, 0.03313950076699257, -0.030705222859978676, 0.004237261600792408, 0.03674251586198807, 0.0307184848934412, 0.012542354874312878, -0.020963754504919052, -0.0125255286693573, 0.029273705556988716, 0.006872856989502907, -0.011533147655427456, 0.03087732195854187, -0.008732902817428112, 0.0036502645816653967, 0.01372272428125143, -0.007171453442424536, -0.016779331490397453, 0.0015463578747585416, -0.014936167746782303, 0.031171297654509544, -0.05337130278348923, -0.041286006569862366, 0.0049074562266469, -0.017520401626825333, 0.022258013486862183, -0.0032132435590028763, -0.014638126827776432, 0.089109405875206, -0.018834415823221207, -0.021240567788481712, -0.04560810327529907, -0.03485552594065666, -0.024494308978319168, 0.01376289501786232, -0.00008428939327131957, 0.03756216540932655, -0.010816740803420544, -0.005198493599891663, -0.009286630898714066, 0.012515651062130928, 0.036088380962610245, -0.04031895846128464, 0.015787141397595406, 0.007204736582934856, -0.014626111835241318, -0.006081775296479464, 0.0049980818293988705, -0.0007799536688253284, -0.011334177106618881, 0.02718122862279415, 0.02317034639418125, 0.026470422744750977, -0.029950343072414398, -0.008085228502750397, -0.015450716949999332, 0.05548465624451637, -0.05987288057804108, 0.012696853838860989, -0.0567866750061512, 0.02184872142970562, -0.01815093122422695, -0.0041924165561795235 ]
<p>I have UMVUE $$\tilde\theta = \frac{(n-1)(U-n)}{(U-1)(U-2)}$$ for $P(Y=2)=\theta(1-\theta)$ where $U=\sum_{i=1}^n Y_i$</p> <p>$Y_i \sim \text{geometric} (\theta)$ I am using delta method to find the variance of $\tilde\theta$</p> <p>So far, I have defined: $$g(y)=\frac{(n-1)(y-n)}{(y-1)(y-2)}$$</p> <p>$$g'(y) = \frac{(n-1)[n(2y-3)-y^2+2]}{(y-2)^2(y-1)}$$</p> <p>Replacing $y$ with $\theta$ for $g'(\theta)$</p> <p>Since $\tilde \theta$ is unbiased estimator, $E[\tilde \theta] = \theta$</p> <p>$Var(\sum Y_i)=n^2(1-\theta)/\theta^2 $ [ This is the step where I am confused, do I have to take the variance of one of the $Y_i$'s or sum of $Y_i'$s</p> <p>So, $Var(\tilde \theta) = [g'(\theta)]^2Var (\sum Y_i)$</p> <p>Is this approach is correct? Any pointers would be helpful.</p>
73,939
[ -0.035573750734329224, -0.024470683187246323, 0.020654134452342987, -0.009765264578163624, 0.02650310844182968, -0.0013922047801315784, -0.009368333034217358, -0.07875744253396988, 0.05109838396310806, -0.04685371741652489, 0.018421536311507225, 0.022106733173131943, 0.09240508079528809, 0.03538373112678528, 0.04089760780334473, 0.009437451139092445, -0.035847947001457214, -0.009280098602175713, -0.023285716772079468, -0.02248050831258297, 0.007184523623436689, 0.038944829255342484, 0.004021753557026386, -0.05748682841658592, -0.052516985684633255, 0.025113295763731003, 0.031203890219330788, -0.011502575129270554, 0.006294101011008024, 0.08387532085180283, -0.06627705693244934, -0.015947522595524788, 0.010364432819187641, 0.03720684349536896, 0.016552317887544632, -0.0011462908005341887, -0.05547568202018738, -0.026484845206141472, 0.0030810432508587837, 0.00007355029083555564, -0.03266353905200958, -0.032309118658304214, -0.03464757651090622, 0.00957171805202961, 0.0029374370351433754, 0.0007441769121214747, -0.018811875954270363, -0.004506368190050125, 0.02227517031133175, -0.059099264442920685, 0.1055619865655899, -0.01430291123688221, 0.02134469524025917, 0.010561390779912472, 0.003548175562173128, 0.0079231858253479, 0.04013742879033089, 0.03787902742624283, -0.027200764045119286, -0.01151025015860796, 0.020038427785038948, -0.030060680583119392, 0.04094972833991051, -0.01894150674343109, -0.033334072679281235, -0.002859915839508176, 0.01894485577940941, -0.03198831528425217, 0.027640115469694138, -0.011887644417583942, 0.04645775258541107, 0.005515102297067642, -0.00883413664996624, 0.01717546209692955, 0.022797780111432076, -0.01417660340666771, 0.005987606942653656, 0.03540101647377014, 0.01584787108004093, 0.024630390107631683, 0.004309332463890314, 0.01604791358113289, 0.034922897815704346, 0.006073720753192902, 0.004424149636179209, 0.006231236271560192, 0.059926774352788925, -0.019497189670801163, 0.0382625013589859, 0.04520559310913086, 0.00042426944128237665, 0.01215638779103756, 0.05394010618329048, -0.025859791785478592, -0.05945504456758499, 0.029055316001176834, -0.01395832933485508, 0.01399671658873558, 0.011805512011051178, 0.007783951237797737, -0.01341679785400629, -0.05363280698657036, 0.005446384195238352, 0.05061574652791023, -0.026900069788098335, -0.01635156199336052, -0.008742266334593296, 0.0011788330739364028, 0.027059223502874374, -0.03291711583733559, -0.032105881720781326, 0.04680098220705986, -0.02372763492166996, -0.040516529232263565, 0.028889764100313187, 0.006358854006975889, -0.02471262402832508, 0.029412994161248207, 0.007285458035767078, 0.04652503505349159, 0.04176291450858116, -0.0002885121793951839, 0.02910499833524227, -0.025204258039593697, -0.06833174079656601, 0.024591950699687004, 0.060948990285396576, -0.021538177505135536, -0.041496798396110535, 0.028187653049826622, 0.012244800105690956, -0.019858073443174362, 0.024061288684606552, 0.034547340124845505, 0.008744853548705578, 0.033146776258945465, -0.11267878860235214, -0.08238929510116577, 0.027347523719072342, -0.05019654333591461, 0.07293375581502914, -0.04451559856534004, 0.02040667086839676, 0.029080385342240334, 0.017795337364077568, 0.0010597242508083582, 0.059344418346881866, 0.008547994308173656, 0.010127484798431396, 0.008237047120928764, -0.03162804991006851, -0.006227170117199421, -0.006115240510553122, -0.03804413974285126, -0.02520495094358921, -0.06932446360588074, 0.047493334859609604, 0.04338898882269859, 0.0019926060922443867, -0.029165877029299736, 0.07468580454587936, 0.025710007175803185, 0.016947399824857712, -0.018462104722857475, 0.020504055544734, -0.023256564512848854, 0.08498034626245499, 0.032147105783224106, 0.00745765445753932, 0.02500019036233425, -0.022233175113797188, 0.009946775622665882, 0.000801329966634512, 0.02578166499733925, 0.03862297534942627, -0.016331814229488373, -0.019316894933581352, -0.05460406467318535, -0.0059772818349301815, 0.02093307115137577, -0.043467383831739426, -0.016703225672245026, -0.020106783136725426, -0.012375876307487488, 0.013772843405604362, 0.014942402020096779, 0.011926120147109032, 0.0019398439908400178, 0.028375405818223953, -0.03405984491109848, -0.012818874791264534, -0.037991903722286224, -0.012707514688372612, -0.0022650836035609245, -0.014969156123697758, -0.00025779777206480503, -0.0031403813045471907, 0.020201388746500015, -0.005393410101532936, -0.01970929652452469, -0.00766126299276948, 0.020947838202118874, 0.025405969470739365, -0.026006728410720825, 0.020562492311000824, 0.04766996577382088, 0.05355203151702881, 0.020763978362083435, 0.034236516803503036, -0.02679360844194889, -0.005788735114037991, -0.02326720766723156, -0.021675944328308105, 0.004776498302817345, 0.0077921124175190926, -0.022176271304488182, 0.012585661374032497, -0.018880480900406837, 0.005405644420534372, 0.036725472658872604, -0.10132802277803421, 0.0720381960272789, 0.08576089143753052, 0.008996594697237015, 0.038678571581840515, 0.017900725826621056, 0.04054317623376846, 0.017079846933484077, -0.014917761087417603, 0.013807050883769989, -0.04633296653628349, -0.005442277528345585, 0.028090234845876694, 0.026375440880656242, -0.029402799904346466, -0.01545034535229206, 0.11355411261320114, 0.010136919096112251, 0.01350698433816433, 0.008192453533411026, -0.01344226486980915, -0.028680089861154556, 0.016802463680505753, 0.022704126313328743, 0.005510825198143721, 0.017981717362999916, -0.009560446254909039, 0.01554187387228012, 0.022230561822652817, -0.009337651543319225, -0.015019742771983147, 0.062136027961969376, 0.010527250356972218, 0.004257229156792164, -0.026898136362433434, 0.0028124582022428513, 0.03340311720967293, -0.004803751595318317, 0.0014789886772632599, 0.044260166585445404, 0.013586491346359253, -0.00604394031688571, -0.019476989284157753, -0.019402816891670227, 0.05496605485677719, 0.004730425775051117, -0.015631521120667458, 0.014633211307227612, 0.026431439444422722, 0.0021839833352714777, 0.009191273711621761, -0.04869989678263664, -0.05661847069859505, -0.010122143663465977, 0.008257596753537655, 0.018384987488389015, 0.010369610972702503, -0.004060001578181982, -0.014257067814469337, -0.030757753178477287, -0.015192574821412563, 0.028506947681307793, 0.01169721782207489, 0.007862667553126812, -0.07955925911664963, -0.00936366431415081, -0.014438813552260399, 0.03761327639222145, 0.024943416938185692, -0.0029223733581602573, 0.00237808539532125, 0.03231398016214371, -0.002715753624215722, -0.025039780884981155, -0.010136987082660198, -0.004124748520553112, 0.014126060530543327, -0.01427456270903349, -0.050459858030080795, -0.0031003316398710012, 0.003721978049725294, -0.016463587060570717, 0.06402168422937393, -0.06795354187488556, -0.019495179876685143, -0.028259651735424995, 0.02671416662633419, 0.05191953480243683, -0.024657944217324257, 0.032833486795425415, 0.015882907435297966, -0.012008853256702423, -0.013426709920167923, -0.062452282756567, -0.06432995200157166, 0.014138918370008469, 0.020051825791597366, 0.002496193628758192, 0.006413735914975405, -0.05019097402691841, 0.0728793665766716, 0.014453359879553318, -0.037836525589227676, -0.0030004840809851885, 0.01770135946571827, -0.0038424315862357616, -0.050301287323236465, 0.004357177764177322, -0.004375501535832882, 0.0016460976330563426, 0.021432500332593918, -0.003683728165924549, -0.008167716674506664, 0.07107165455818176, -0.019422590732574463, -0.019595300778746605, 0.012402490712702274, -0.013266218826174736, 0.00405784510076046, 0.07104562222957611, 0.041069187223911285, -0.006504323333501816, 0.0013918090844526887, 0.02753402851521969, 0.02328464202582836, -0.003392989980056882, -0.04558396711945534, 0.03036189265549183, -0.03522555157542229, 0.015591864474117756, -0.02388026751577854, 0.06623202562332153, -0.0038944173138588667, -0.026880592107772827, -0.031080633401870728, 0.0009091850370168686, 0.04485011845827103, 0.0032476589549332857, 0.0014537787064909935, 0.06290565431118011, 0.04235180467367172, 0.0011958039831370115, -0.02087336778640747, -0.008856897242367268, -0.030407074838876724, 0.02068614400923252, -0.025444595143198967, 0.01340534444898367, 0.00825740210711956, 0.046990491449832916, 0.003969457931816578, 0.003629631595686078, -0.018059391528367996, -0.02550632506608963, -0.07093965262174606, 0.04748503118753433, -0.050876911729574203, 0.06579048186540604, -0.01268548984080553, 0.012929907999932766, 0.009937364608049393, -0.007394370622932911, 0.0311575960367918, -0.0026788562536239624, -0.08482082188129425, 0.02497623860836029, -0.004546425770968199, -0.0060095335356891155, -0.0026471707969903946, 0.017784016206860542, 0.019602173939347267, -0.025699933990836143, 0.04412006959319115, 0.0052946885116398335, -0.016663771122694016, -0.034426767379045486, 0.02764042466878891, -0.00852243509143591, 0.005773516837507486, -0.02745996043086052, 0.039186395704746246, 0.01845085248351097, -0.043269187211990356, 0.011192189529538155, 0.04166490584611893, -0.011167451739311218, 0.013163704425096512, -0.014339958317577839, -0.006774751469492912, 0.005550120025873184, 0.03471977263689041, 0.003118390217423439, 0.040609173476696014, -0.0012367519084364176, 0.003779726568609476, -0.0007578416261821985, 0.026896048337221146, 0.05773531645536423, 0.00925583764910698, -0.028923839330673218, -0.03135437145829201, -0.015232782810926437, 0.02632075361907482, 0.018337955698370934, 0.02167702652513981, 0.020940566435456276, 0.06517481058835983, 0.0029992188792675734, -0.045070305466651917, 0.004798646550625563, 0.05858774110674858, -0.03415966033935547, -0.002327921334654093, -0.038334984332323074, -0.008984885178506374, -0.016162442043423653, -0.011821453459560871, 0.019862821325659752, 0.027791008353233337, -0.05585398152470589, -0.017680015414953232, 0.06146840378642082, -0.0031129352282732725, 0.0009200693457387388, -0.02135225385427475, 0.039757780730724335, 0.04841534420847893, 0.019276197999715805, -0.0657416507601738, 0.012901907786726952, 0.03505939990282059, 0.012860518880188465, 0.029383858665823936, -0.046448249369859695, -0.03294547647237778, 0.007568962872028351, 0.0306622963398695, 0.04485219717025757, -0.015090273693203926, 0.02269456535577774, -0.026377620175480843, -0.022707566618919373, 0.0023186837788671255, -0.018515534698963165, 0.0578032024204731, -0.044286079704761505, -0.055383164435625076, 0.015215758234262466, -0.046608589589595795, -0.056723788380622864, -0.013585114851593971, -0.03652465343475342, 0.05104075372219086, -0.04511554166674614, -0.0395195372402668, -0.033172357827425, -0.02330704592168331, 0.00561120780184865, 0.06905966997146606, -0.04009592905640602, -0.019473589956760406, 0.011887862347066402, 0.04404560104012489, -0.02124948240816593, -0.05065363273024559, 0.04884742572903633, 0.029470359906554222, 0.0021116395946592093, 0.019715270027518272, -0.02613917551934719, -0.08706840127706528, 0.01848960854113102, 0.0016644125571474433, 0.014013766311109066, 0.005578245036303997, 0.006715383380651474, 0.052608639001846313, 0.056350622326135635, 0.002211029175668955, 0.06840771436691284, -0.007529272232204676, 0.01869536191225052, -0.003560006385669112, -0.042802222073078156, -0.007747749797999859, -0.027942851185798645, -0.03877456858754158, -0.02142845280468464, 0.00003873735840898007, -0.001529440050944686, 0.008738246746361256, 0.004077744670212269, 0.037554096430540085, -0.045930732041597366, -0.017225198447704315, -0.01906711980700493, 0.014687645249068737, 0.04678478091955185, -0.001025525270961225, -0.007698776666074991, -0.025560962036252022, 0.04912703484296799, 0.004095472861081362, 0.021178940311074257, -0.050684329122304916, 0.006280240602791309, 0.007536165416240692, -0.006922518834471703, -0.02463879995048046, -0.03556033596396446, -0.034158751368522644, 0.010242192074656487, -0.02573801577091217, 0.04373263940215111, -0.02291892096400261, 0.03564176335930824, 0.014396018348634243, -0.012987853959202766, -0.018540363758802414, -0.0015897839330136776, -0.02251831442117691, 0.02856866642832756, -0.04804638773202896, 0.020692924037575722, 0.009396201930940151, 0.024495350196957588, -0.08363872021436691, -0.0028668823651969433, 0.005926994606852531, 0.00647943839430809, 0.0007294235983863473, -0.022275200113654137, -0.007907702587544918, -0.00511236721649766, -0.022974221035838127, -0.02511514350771904, 0.02217382937669754, -0.019706524908542633, -0.020786227658391, -0.03459761664271355, 0.054532621055841446, 0.09213115274906158, -0.019262848421931267, -0.005839349236339331, 0.03744800016283989, -0.03197050467133522, -0.02507549338042736, -0.006224190816283226, 0.02586124651134014, -0.035895053297281265, 0.017898520454764366, 0.012937966734170914, -0.008154086768627167, 0.021776406094431877, -0.009102572686970234, -0.06224926933646202, 0.010848426260054111, -0.00578923849388957, 0.002067352645099163, -0.02227039262652397, -0.02525395154953003, -0.007696717511862516, 0.0003179973573423922, -0.028830911964178085, -0.005363244563341141, -0.009673099964857101, 0.0263782050460577, 0.03572152554988861, -0.01885833777487278, 0.004751041065901518, 0.020866742357611656, 0.07985502481460571, -0.006942439824342728, -0.04591761901974678, 0.015732765197753906, -0.024360768496990204, 0.02685450203716755, 0.05650641769170761, -0.0002454793138895184, 0.0237747635692358, -0.005783356726169586, -0.037924155592918396, -0.012809072621166706, -0.020833278074860573, 0.01601618528366089, 0.11391578614711761, -0.011813102290034294, 0.029655884951353073, 0.0589701272547245, 0.02870134450495243, -0.02312774956226349, -0.05990496650338173, -0.016012316569685936, -0.008588999509811401, -0.017513006925582886, 0.014782863669097424, 0.0024333447217941284, -0.009978720918297768, 0.011707157827913761, -0.007158834952861071, 0.028574513271450996, 0.04190860316157341, -0.00792151689529419, 0.02025829255580902, 0.030369818210601807, -0.022978555411100388, -0.023010578006505966, 0.013088107109069824, -0.044752996414899826, 0.017261993139982224, -0.058844562619924545, -0.012252784334123135, 0.035315871238708496, 0.040680356323719025, 0.007484037894755602, -0.030003009364008904, 0.0017257448052987456, -0.03297017142176628, -0.025146225467324257, 0.035773634910583496, -0.014347630552947521, 0.005379948765039444, 0.01601254940032959, 0.028257232159376144, -0.01900753192603588, 0.02796248160302639, -0.02469806559383869, -0.07137104868888855, -0.0018481091829016805, -0.014513757079839706, -0.0316753052175045, 0.027734624221920967, -0.0028792459052056074, 0.002572088036686182, -0.022971486672759056, 0.017713120207190514, -0.02390800230205059, 0.0026359991170465946, 0.05471663177013397, -0.02753400430083275, 0.07202854752540588, 0.011588964611291885, 0.02873562090098858, -0.022953202947974205, -0.0051890346221625805, 0.09423268586397171, 0.02762378379702568, 0.03253190964460373, -0.03424418345093727, 0.025490857660770416, -0.014470834285020828, -0.009475155733525753, -0.01866990327835083, -0.010894331149756908, 0.02794823795557022, -0.009247835725545883, 0.022587738931179047, 0.041343800723552704, 0.0021577223669737577, -0.023385977372527122, 0.04456213116645813, -0.03748594969511032, -0.04199971258640289, 0.00635879160836339, -0.013038590550422668, -0.012486549094319344, 0.02114393562078476, -0.030924499034881592, 0.011974325403571129, -0.00550592876970768, -0.0030595643911510706, -0.03263473883271217, -0.0006837028195150197, 0.01458067912608385, 0.027670150622725487, -0.02263447642326355, 0.018022576346993446, -0.013549268245697021, -0.00729158753529191, -0.018480198457837105, -0.0014539336552843451, 0.017479876056313515, -0.043033260852098465, 0.027778951451182365, 0.03610696271061897, -0.00182376429438591, -0.003479929640889168, 0.031287018209695816, -0.011253098957240582, -0.037199508398771286, -0.027106288820505142, 0.0060254307463765144, 0.04667385667562485, -0.021712491288781166, -0.00428101746365428, -0.017176955938339233, -0.022854696959257126, -0.0018069796497002244, -0.05316324159502983, 0.009361921809613705, 0.013316836208105087, 0.017644982784986496, -0.04711369797587395, -0.03209266811609268, -0.007152756210416555, -0.009951083920896053, 0.02099401317536831, 0.03415701910853386, 0.028165195137262344, -0.026358185335993767, -0.015209236182272434, -0.025103863328695297, 0.03197303041815758, 0.0333627425134182, 0.0027567045763134956, -0.03631377965211868, -0.024767305701971054, -0.03694213554263115, 0.006477682385593653, -0.011864341795444489, -0.026712866500020027, 0.034478262066841125, -0.020014716312289238, -0.004058216232806444, -0.01681843213737011, -0.03744633123278618, 0.018817272037267685, -0.030521081760525703, 0.00021197140449658036, -0.06074104830622673, -0.021289750933647156, 0.030452851206064224, 0.0016943735536187887, 0.008758753538131714, 0.015965277329087257, -0.009277726523578167, 0.04042527452111244, 0.018504738807678223, -0.02505919709801674, -0.05732095614075661, -0.026766840368509293, -0.030620524659752846, -0.01313533540815115, -0.017950130626559258, 0.04350990802049637, 0.06252995133399963, 0.03241324424743652, -0.0028807625640183687, 0.04141900688409805, -0.05254903435707092, 0.04128348082304001, -0.01753445528447628, -0.06604090332984924, 0.02294868417084217, 0.02143503911793232, 0.01929459348320961, 0.008700746111571789, 0.01693662814795971, -0.006291928701102734, -0.045523613691329956, 0.018711358308792114, -0.027645180001854897, -0.0280284620821476, 0.007268487010151148, -0.013867358677089214, 0.02331860363483429, -0.021583465859293938, 0.025847403332591057, 0.02167588844895363, -0.006763542536646128, -0.010203259997069836, 0.02007373608648777, -0.032420627772808075, -0.006317096762359142, -0.013180036097764969, -0.02976350300014019, 0.042550936341285706, 0.04422072693705559, 0.036050572991371155, -0.02131209336221218, 0.011131065897643566, -0.01297353208065033, 0.056790791451931, -0.010544929653406143, -0.009035260416567326, 0.04874405637383461, -0.03459492698311806, -0.01275342795997858, 0.016430512070655823, 0.022150106728076935, 0.04046989232301712, 0.01800443045794964, 0.0003341759729664773, -0.019383160397410393, 0.011917331255972385, -0.04426144063472748, 0.00886398646980524, -0.04242880642414093, -0.007954451255500317, -0.0023577024694532156, -0.05032724887132645, 0.021557530388236046, 0.0005433472106233239, 0.013583116233348846, 0.05027249455451965, -0.0022201172541826963, 0.012435609474778175, -0.010237001813948154, 0.021059494465589523, -0.009159423410892487, -0.022615335881710052, 0.009920552372932434, -0.013322889804840088, 0.025410166010260582, 0.04365476965904236, -0.027082053944468498, 0.029768891632556915, -0.0676194354891777, 0.004590237513184547, -0.06100397929549217, -0.04261458292603493, 0.02561885677278042, 0.020325710996985435, 0.03768196329474449, -0.07950684428215027, 0.015290437266230583, 0.031907398253679276, -0.035049114376306534, 0.01671976037323475, 0.012072485871613026, -0.033431459218263626, -0.02814578451216221, 0.01673068106174469, -0.03191562741994858, -0.005569991189986467, -0.008626753464341164, 0.04701867699623108, 0.030167344957590103, 0.015109661966562271, -0.003122376510873437, -0.04924999549984932, -0.0037404641043394804, -0.004001704044640064, 0.014535867609083652, -0.07678839564323425, 0.03758106380701065, -0.02984677068889141, -0.002222605748102069, 0.04785611480474472, -0.005097909830510616, 0.024440865963697433, -0.021704351529479027, 0.02175573818385601, 0.0054678902961313725, 0.0054261754266917706, 0.04739575833082199, 0.0031664406415075064, 0.03831202909350395, -0.027560824528336525, 0.01355401799082756, 0.04281610623002052, -0.02054915949702263, -0.015212029218673706, 0.01740400306880474, 0.03708364814519882, -0.04606710746884346, 0.00735525181517005, -0.01273724902421236, -0.01987081579864025, 0.013196512125432491, -0.0031762924045324326, -0.017190802842378616, -0.06953748315572739, 0.04778800904750824, -0.0486256405711174, -0.018183039501309395, 0.07013287395238876, 0.014566238038241863, 0.01384255476295948, -0.033373042941093445, -0.008143696002662182, -0.0498524084687233, 0.00727213267236948, -0.03483033925294876, -0.004043228458613157, -0.031986579298973083, 0.0062795220874249935, 0.00719114113599062, 0.008660530671477318, 0.03624763339757919, -0.008336392231285572, -0.02816077135503292, 0.008820587769150734, 0.008693086914718151, -0.03526831790804863, -0.020953752100467682, -0.00016366968338843435, 0.0006401622085832059, -0.04929739981889725, 0.059395842254161835, 0.0005673401756212115, -0.019521839916706085, -0.013759844936430454, 0.0006696432246826589, -0.044370509684085846, 0.036746010184288025, 0.06332626193761826, 0.0004009315453004092, 0.01411536056548357, 0.03286725655198097, 0.004422713536769152, 0.028752125799655914, -0.05453934520483017, 0.025135047733783722, -0.031485240906476974, -0.004548988770693541, -0.015040253289043903, -0.003798017743974924, 0.02812192775309086, 0.00848364643752575, 0.002100430428981781, -0.0022142475936561823, 0.014392509125173092, 0.006973865441977978, 0.0005327537655830383, -0.01816515251994133, -0.024021189659833908, -0.020110508427023888, 0.051087528467178345, 0.005938361398875713, 0.011210696771740913, 0.012794152833521366, -0.0017387765692546964, -0.06510639935731888, 0.0060149603523314, -0.0055666458792984486, -0.012218749150633812, -0.044333700090646744, -0.028272029012441635, 0.04296119138598442, -0.04383188486099243, -0.02746625430881977, 0.030400350689888, -0.05087695270776749, 0.00971907377243042, 0.030330048874020576, 0.005005728919059038, 0.027319200336933136, 0.018401483073830605, 0.01840052381157875, 0.027124684303998947, -0.018402099609375, 0.02370823360979557, 0.055071715265512466, 0.027541372925043106, -0.008537235669791698, 0.005562865175306797, 0.04429290443658829, -0.010034007951617241, 0.019495327025651932, 0.025676270946860313, 0.020158912986516953, -0.009353372268378735, -0.013953747227787971, 0.038020387291908264, -0.011199408210814, -0.020053375512361526, 0.02047407627105713, -0.03918224945664406, 0.031166154891252518, -0.03853209316730499, -0.00013453411520458758, -0.015311185270547867, -0.02207327075302601, -0.02886488474905491, -0.045029640197753906, -0.010893107391893864, 0.033250462263822556, 0.010210467502474785, 0.01032937690615654, -0.006880031432956457, -0.010378853417932987, 0.02247762493789196, -0.0048574963584542274, 0.04258652776479721, -0.012789004482328892, 0.027425101026892662, -0.002745309378951788, -0.036427900195121765, -0.04891102761030197, -0.04145897179841995, 0.03014957718551159, 0.035627927631139755, 0.05410044640302658, -0.01573178544640541, -0.047909822314977646, 0.003809477435424924, 0.06492874771356583, -0.03575225546956062, -0.010800485499203205, -0.008250033482909203, -0.021696787327528, 0.006972045637667179, -0.04859236255288124 ]
<p>(I'm asking this question for a friend, honest...)</p> <blockquote> <p>Is there an easy way to convert from an SPSS file to a SAS file, which preserves the formats AND labels? Saving as a POR file gets me the labels (I think) but not the POR file. I tried to save to a SAS7dat file but it didn't work. Thanks,</p> </blockquote>
36,505
[ -0.03175380453467369, 0.0253791194409132, -0.013275569304823875, 0.0010550889419391751, 0.005081288982182741, 0.013864793814718723, 0.020258812233805656, -0.013492729514837265, 0.04637293517589569, -0.054621197283267975, 0.015480991452932358, 0.03356345370411873, 0.00907125137746334, 0.04098625108599663, -0.00012276774214114994, -0.03487500548362732, -0.010167987085878849, -0.0042266459204256535, -0.030478056520223618, 0.03487738221883774, 0.005921401083469391, 0.007199840620160103, -0.012133905664086342, -0.01682620495557785, 0.018013829365372658, 0.03471382334828377, 0.019180886447429657, -0.02355075441300869, 0.012613742612302303, 0.05277065187692642, 0.0025880676694214344, -0.02277066558599472, 0.024556847289204597, 0.021888751536607742, 0.02890760265290737, -0.04113573953509331, -0.017119286581873894, -0.019287224858999252, -0.021220121532678604, 0.0010963095119222999, -0.031758666038513184, 0.0026600747369229794, 0.03368094936013222, 0.05687475949525833, 0.002344422275200486, -0.006930168718099594, -0.009101283736526966, 0.004321333020925522, 0.00998255517333746, -0.03178444877266884, 0.038040369749069214, -0.01655023917555809, 0.028289223089814186, 0.06544701009988785, 0.0010918735060840845, 0.037111300975084305, 0.05184009298682213, 0.047715526074171066, -0.0034180982038378716, -0.023778926581144333, 0.0035551334731280804, 0.008131977170705795, 0.012974213808774948, -0.008589529432356358, -0.07199761271476746, -0.010735566727817059, -0.020520010963082314, -0.007819109596312046, 0.0644230991601944, 0.012339841574430466, 0.002762759104371071, 0.00544469291344285, 0.045382700860500336, 0.0004337973368819803, 0.007208302151411772, -0.020068572834134102, 0.029451657086610794, -0.014226945117115974, 0.04537099227309227, 0.05203430354595184, 0.04659176617860794, 0.05093031004071236, 0.008617525920271873, -0.0004395121359266341, -0.005489604081958532, 0.0033338225912302732, 0.05099204182624817, -0.00892652478069067, 0.00786458607763052, 0.054203812032938004, 0.036395225673913956, -0.010457323864102364, 0.05477382615208626, 0.016010675579309464, 0.01834833435714245, 0.043910570442676544, 0.003452450502663851, 0.053987663239240646, 0.018829600885510445, -0.008208408020436764, 0.008878895081579685, 0.0029632910154759884, 0.030263559892773628, 0.02159227803349495, -0.02233985811471939, -0.011271133087575436, 0.0018392914207652211, -0.016258953139185905, -0.007611982990056276, -0.03561985120177269, -0.004946231842041016, -0.001972448080778122, 0.010178912431001663, -0.010547078214585781, 0.018973780795931816, -0.037899162620306015, -0.013901722617447376, -0.007738277781754732, 0.05277164280414581, 0.0561487041413784, 0.04151846840977669, -0.030641518533229828, 0.05315035954117775, -0.019621146842837334, -0.059113167226314545, -0.024431925266981125, -0.033686038106679916, -0.001878736075013876, -0.055453479290008545, 0.04056161269545555, -0.01929604262113571, -0.006323163863271475, 0.0668950229883194, -0.03594745323061943, 0.019270511344075203, -0.003907236736267805, -0.07191593199968338, -0.06430597603321075, -0.005136741790920496, -0.007877121679484844, 0.02353697642683983, -0.08403503894805908, -0.006068722810596228, -0.01689939573407173, 0.012085999362170696, -0.0008466357830911875, 0.017531586810946465, 0.0530802421271801, 0.013222702778875828, 0.01402935292571783, 0.010270299389958382, -0.00025594138423912227, -0.019763384014368057, -0.08190485835075378, 0.030043991282582283, -0.061087097972631454, -0.028763998299837112, 0.022575045004487038, -0.034662045538425446, -0.052775148302316666, 0.018195750191807747, -0.002200528047978878, 0.00031937280436977744, -0.010782484896481037, -0.017802271991968155, -0.012400046922266483, 0.06257396191358566, 0.004306156653910875, -0.008540371432900429, 0.021471749991178513, -0.009535310789942741, 0.001051637576892972, -0.006939352490007877, 0.02662992849946022, 0.03445088863372803, -0.01774393953382969, -0.03676940128207207, 0.01737399585545063, 0.009213317185640335, -0.008648611605167389, -0.01383325457572937, 0.0032082523684948683, -0.01410609856247902, 0.012081848457455635, 0.026654846966266632, 0.058281056582927704, 0.0379641093313694, -0.015154191292822361, 0.02224067598581314, -0.045910101383924484, -0.06280666589736938, -0.06353088468313217, 0.05161476507782936, -0.01667875610291958, -0.013722553849220276, 0.0033003841526806355, 0.051189616322517395, 0.0027990692760795355, 0.011914413422346115, -0.04725828021764755, -0.01815425418317318, -0.02154715731739998, 0.03904420882463455, -0.07341857999563217, -0.0013787810457870364, 0.06674398481845856, 0.04627394303679466, -0.05316244810819626, 0.025527143850922585, -0.0234997421503067, 0.008131198585033417, 0.011423151940107346, -0.022041041404008865, 0.0035089231096208096, -0.037404414266347885, -0.010242195799946785, 0.008905293419957161, 0.010882756672799587, -0.023347079753875732, 0.026654450222849846, -0.03339438885450363, 0.024051884189248085, 0.03998629003763199, 0.0021072018425911665, 0.0012911137891933322, -0.017410503700375557, 0.03666291385889053, 0.015520975925028324, 0.01710747741162777, -0.01597662828862667, 0.0063211130909621716, 0.005898250732570887, 0.0386221744120121, 0.02154947631061077, -0.05489538609981537, 0.014942997135221958, 0.04554000869393349, 0.016408096998929977, 0.020342905074357986, 0.02967526763677597, -0.02247278019785881, 0.010202527977526188, -0.0017539029940962791, -0.020982638001441956, 0.011611735448241234, 0.018606839701533318, -0.006855358369648457, 0.052185434848070145, 0.0501837395131588, 0.031392116099596024, -0.0061560217291116714, 0.03387586772441864, 0.019444210454821587, 0.0014754112344235182, 0.03209063783288002, -0.045123882591724396, 0.05314479395747185, -0.03568887338042259, 0.019312415271997452, 0.021784193813800812, 0.019032729789614677, 0.0002176310372306034, 0.043008316308259964, 0.0180265661329031, 0.0075372569262981415, 0.03346138447523117, -0.01939569227397442, -0.002193520776927471, -0.0006098982412368059, -0.07700807601213455, 0.018580777570605278, 0.0005741617060266435, 0.004395267926156521, -0.04050030559301376, 0.01752667874097824, 0.0243087001144886, -0.027466388419270515, 0.02465847320854664, -0.01902034319937229, -0.03072698973119259, 0.019414927810430527, -0.011833587661385536, 0.015253190882503986, 0.0073079913854599, -0.04530438035726547, -0.005721325520426035, -0.023555785417556763, -0.0034871415700763464, 0.026506567373871803, -0.042903006076812744, -0.0384490080177784, 0.05824287608265877, -0.014087174087762833, -0.05378756672143936, -0.021500958129763603, -0.0274150762706995, -0.01550544984638691, -0.010374526493251324, -0.021072961390018463, 0.02161487005650997, 0.020633216947317123, -0.03273206949234009, -0.01791667751967907, -0.04500964656472206, -0.024317262694239616, -0.03691011667251587, 0.024325154721736908, 0.0249268040060997, -0.006076379679143429, 0.020078424364328384, 0.0044177258387207985, -0.04658939689397812, 0.0007759264553897083, -0.025394873693585396, -0.03146352618932724, 0.049619290977716446, 0.04121483117341995, -0.0073677366599440575, -0.005503341555595398, -0.0009974412387236953, 0.04316447675228119, 0.012576884590089321, -0.06668132543563843, -0.026859190315008163, -0.0027068599592894316, -0.022133128717541695, -0.01062264759093523, 0.0010075552854686975, -0.012736325152218342, 0.009079528041183949, 0.001947695855051279, -0.019206475466489792, -0.002846503397449851, 0.053261131048202515, 0.008247296325862408, -0.002898314269259572, -0.009346062317490578, -0.019285108894109726, -0.007562581449747086, 0.010124865919351578, 0.02863449603319168, -0.05220263451337814, 0.004916452802717686, -0.004605579189956188, 0.02185838669538498, -0.002553260885179043, -0.038895245641469955, 0.005869937129318714, -0.0013762784656137228, 0.03186360001564026, -0.07612358778715134, -0.00091353221796453, 0.031076565384864807, 0.0015100175514817238, 0.0034545590169727802, 0.021708738058805466, 0.02121456153690815, -0.026854172348976135, -0.02755648083984852, 0.04392688721418381, 0.04057183489203453, 0.015999015420675278, -0.001545705716125667, -0.00021669936541002244, -0.01863786391913891, 0.010617750696837902, 0.010018834844231606, -0.019587179645895958, 0.058446869254112244, 0.039282020181417465, 0.03491310775279999, -0.020828383043408394, -0.04067467898130417, 0.04757203534245491, -0.07271412760019302, 0.008785059675574303, -0.0025633492041379213, 0.054857008159160614, 0.03691750019788742, 0.06749331206083298, 0.024587728083133698, -0.01567011885344982, -0.02506919763982296, -0.0003860000870190561, -0.02901097759604454, 0.009853292256593704, -0.01982417330145836, 0.007041286677122116, 0.024569252505898476, 0.003516783006489277, 0.010011049918830395, -0.03375716879963875, -0.0003549433604348451, 0.004938798490911722, 0.010972381569445133, -0.030716845765709877, -0.0281654242426157, 0.00474601611495018, 0.004636882804334164, -0.03275872394442558, 0.029841871932148933, -0.0016807486535981297, -0.010890204459428787, 0.007760908920317888, 0.03717993572354317, -0.01903005689382553, -0.028783349320292473, -0.04021008312702179, 0.01865110918879509, 0.0011569742346182466, 0.05359836295247078, 0.03442678600549698, 0.04364534467458725, -0.008286167867481709, 0.029525883495807648, 0.0032042681705206633, 0.03423435613512993, -0.006490617990493774, 0.008607814088463783, -0.05372568219900131, -0.020613130182027817, -0.008339433930814266, 0.019573230296373367, 0.03402167931199074, -0.013078787364065647, 0.014893969520926476, 0.020255761221051216, 0.00009864500316325575, -0.09537076205015182, 0.02352834865450859, 0.08077516406774521, 0.03200685605406761, 0.006086194422096014, -0.029355056583881378, -0.018484558910131454, -0.029638376086950302, -0.007558545097708702, 0.01387311052531004, 0.031937673687934875, 0.0016660435358062387, 0.016370121389627457, 0.011989309452474117, -0.021560413762927055, 0.006077783182263374, 0.01458948664367199, 0.011958208866417408, 0.05197196826338768, 0.021448034793138504, -0.0168252382427454, 0.015798373147845268, 0.045195307582616806, 0.050674960017204285, 0.034442201256752014, -0.0010102622909471393, -0.06884720921516418, 0.011438598856329918, 0.02371436357498169, 0.04618099704384804, -0.023656263947486877, 0.016402335837483406, -0.03379315137863159, -0.04817713052034378, 0.06992394477128983, -0.04907427728176117, 0.04328412190079689, -0.040447670966386795, 0.0088233333081007, -0.025564737617969513, -0.019127391278743744, 0.0011622780002653599, -0.018102914094924927, -0.018827494233846664, 0.028080929070711136, -0.009203927591443062, 0.007985208183526993, -0.03220997378230095, -0.012566976249217987, -0.008813749998807907, 0.06176435574889183, -0.005452429410070181, -0.03208630159497261, 0.02229469269514084, 0.022662131115794182, -0.054458629339933395, -0.04746805876493454, 0.004593748599290848, 0.011839116923511028, -0.015214923769235611, 0.05278198421001434, -0.028192544355988503, -0.04440632835030556, 0.0038531613536179066, -0.007984177209436893, -0.025686711072921753, 0.0027694327291101217, -0.018165849149227142, 0.010902614332735538, 0.012234696187078953, 0.0007303525926545262, 0.053969308733940125, 0.03623153269290924, 0.022474925965070724, -0.0028347407933324575, -0.06854594498872757, 0.020802505314350128, -0.054189179092645645, -0.0447896346449852, -0.07284905761480331, 0.04712409898638725, -0.0075979046523571014, 0.00453373696655035, -0.004390480928122997, 0.005299150478094816, -0.026468662545084953, 0.008298821747303009, 0.003976219799369574, 0.044941727072000504, -0.0014732067938894033, 0.0046388874761760235, 0.01113726943731308, 0.029628915712237358, -0.03563433885574341, -0.06819764524698257, 0.02514876052737236, -0.011979052796959877, -0.03569243475794792, 0.01251972559839487, -0.034776657819747925, 0.03733009472489357, -0.03649916127324104, -0.04040203243494034, -0.0048364028334617615, -0.0444953516125679, 0.014756996184587479, -0.03555874899029732, 0.042954739183187485, 0.015983624383807182, -0.082054004073143, -0.01171327754855156, 0.05761978402733803, -0.01259475015103817, -0.00485157361254096, -0.058453842997550964, 0.05961993336677551, -0.009966137818992138, -0.03844433277845383, -0.07373899221420288, -0.0913148894906044, 0.01100134663283825, 0.026967395097017288, -0.01215370837599039, -0.025668209418654442, 0.02220139279961586, -0.0192909874022007, -0.011011363007128239, -0.031754881143569946, 0.05559639260172844, -0.03996088728308678, -0.0034209827426820993, -0.011936827562749386, 0.01320093497633934, 0.06682725995779037, -0.0047485968098044395, 0.01924184523522854, -0.011031459085643291, 0.010858669877052307, -0.0487433485686779, -0.0006667798152193427, 0.021718168631196022, -0.007914234884083271, -0.029812730848789215, -0.03141675516963005, -0.0006543447379954159, 0.03637750446796417, 0.017498204484581947, 0.022070815786719322, -0.01685766689479351, -0.020587677136063576, -0.015380547381937504, -0.007175757549703121, -0.008801769465208054, -0.020899003371596336, 0.037805382162332535, -0.06844346225261688, 0.00435352697968483, -0.03493636101484299, 0.05219654366374016, -0.03523869439959526, 0.0118434838950634, 0.019225601106882095, 0.029822714626789093, 0.0739591121673584, 0.005605785176157951, 0.013099602423608303, 0.009365357458591461, -0.019070351496338844, 0.028111426159739494, 0.04466455802321434, 0.04215550795197487, -0.016444753855466843, 0.021195756271481514, -0.034735195338726044, 0.00893888995051384, -0.018577590584754944, -0.06670521944761276, 0.042774587869644165, -0.01114895660430193, 0.016461245715618134, 0.025726212188601494, -0.04142197594046593, -0.045491769909858704, -0.06079823896288872, -0.02246016636490822, 0.0273132286965847, 0.023177525028586388, 0.06962714344263077, 0.028866810724139214, -0.01400831900537014, -0.011909674853086472, 0.021853605285286903, 0.035683535039424896, 0.07332121580839157, 0.03562239184975624, 0.012988821603357792, 0.0010994707699865103, -0.035378146916627884, -0.06436621397733688, -0.006827196571975946, -0.012835877947509289, 0.019888026639819145, -0.012392757460474968, -0.06677734851837158, 0.050750408321619034, 0.015486497431993484, -0.005677667912095785, -0.0284310020506382, -0.006292133592069149, -0.05577728897333145, 0.03368177264928818, -0.0322907418012619, -0.025878554210066795, 0.018584076315164566, -0.01967698708176613, 0.04422471299767494, -0.039118919521570206, 0.033501822501420975, -0.023902863264083862, -0.060660168528556824, -0.03214019536972046, -0.030613308772444725, -0.020325960591435432, 0.07112479954957962, -0.006691718474030495, -0.0057176994159817696, -0.008779104799032211, -0.031206125393509865, -0.009238380007445812, -0.01444677822291851, 0.04351062327623367, -0.011105590499937534, 0.059814903885126114, 0.006881574634462595, -0.00399387301877141, -0.005994177423417568, -0.005708971526473761, 0.138764888048172, 0.07065099477767944, 0.04311934858560562, -0.0656227320432663, 0.013581742532551289, 0.0020227236673235893, 0.02186208963394165, -0.005664454773068428, -0.00006141354970168322, 0.016473129391670227, -0.006445391569286585, 0.01903316006064415, 0.09908578544855118, 0.027134926989674568, 0.0339239239692688, 0.05639994516968727, -0.045334767550230026, 0.0019642363768070936, -0.011316696181893349, 0.007301419507712126, -0.025481699034571648, -0.008537051267921925, -0.0628974512219429, -0.02951202541589737, 0.015609060414135456, -0.03896266967058182, -0.04057024419307709, -0.005900499410927296, 0.012571298517286777, 0.014726195484399796, -0.012638506479561329, -0.03528345748782158, 0.04360794275999069, 0.028804751113057137, -0.041042011231184006, -0.024205690249800682, 0.028860950842499733, -0.05157628282904625, -0.02020196244120598, 0.013219966553151608, 0.019640721380710602, 0.019929533824324608, -0.013543975539505482, -0.02686244435608387, -0.04172865301370621, 0.011802887544035912, -0.02025774121284485, 0.0059816581197083, -0.003267630934715271, -0.004459157586097717, -0.00828851293772459, 0.02419811673462391, 0.02362871542572975, -0.054030660539865494, -0.02644224464893341, 0.025306660681962967, 0.018537672236561775, 0.021896131336688995, -0.015449605882167816, -0.03463321924209595, -0.008127540349960327, -0.04903304576873779, 0.02256346307694912, 0.014582029543817043, -0.05932820960879326, -0.007551127579063177, -0.022412585094571114, 0.020487111061811447, -0.02309645712375641, 0.020366784185171127, 0.0016121400985866785, 0.005386544857174158, -0.021535607054829597, -0.026506340131163597, 0.01273980364203453, 0.038518667221069336, -0.0033374580089002848, -0.011099224910140038, -0.005636022891849279, -0.042669571936130524, -0.05518988147377968, 0.027530619874596596, -0.03771229460835457, -0.018944889307022095, -0.022141849622130394, 0.025522997602820396, 0.060842663049697876, 0.042779795825481415, 0.022225819528102875, 0.043108753859996796, -0.008236733265221119, 0.022337552160024643, 0.04884972795844078, -0.05848746374249458, -0.005965257994830608, 0.02542574517428875, -0.02956392429769039, 0.02190478891134262, -0.02239355817437172, 0.0614338219165802, 0.021975263953208923, 0.058451130986213684, -0.025998704135417938, 0.019803589209914207, 0.014432166703045368, 0.025842847302556038, -0.02222445234656334, -0.038469426333904266, 0.01242852583527565, -0.01793401688337326, 0.02688916027545929, -0.03778240084648132, -0.02906591072678566, -0.04500527307391167, -0.026122922077775, 0.015627676621079445, -0.03389834240078926, -0.06166743487119675, 0.029174335300922394, -0.0079303914681077, 0.029527779668569565, -0.00766243739053607, -0.021171774715185165, -0.02695498988032341, -0.038686614483594894, -0.013519259169697762, -0.022167982533574104, -0.01597636006772518, 0.025061549618840218, -0.00844728946685791, 0.02631651796400547, 0.04970095306634903, 0.02501106448471546, -0.005496247671544552, -0.0025402489118278027, 0.00890444591641426, 0.006315201986581087, 0.07066678255796432, -0.04658100754022598, -0.004208542872220278, 0.02378249168395996, -0.06315040588378906, -0.04455846920609474, 0.006168636493384838, -0.04740050062537193, 0.02066905051469803, 0.02488512359559536, -0.0017529228935018182, 0.007579298689961433, 0.08530102670192719, -0.010116751305758953, -0.03298361971974373, -0.016745299100875854, 0.015867404639720917, -0.00997411273419857, 0.027128499001264572, 0.02075662836432457, 0.021314872428774834, -0.05013015866279602, 0.054381657391786575, 0.0046965028159320354, 0.013137713074684143, 0.010235597379505634, -0.022033395245671272, -0.007470664568245411, 0.003844283986836672, 0.025530757382512093, 0.003983791917562485, 0.008897662162780762, 0.03931629657745361, -0.01592956855893135, 0.009334510192275047, 0.01051223836839199, -0.006690152920782566, -0.07066605240106583, 0.001286614453420043, -0.002203160198405385, 0.009851514361798763, 0.021356429904699326, -0.044929832220077515, 0.05116783082485199, 0.02658940851688385, -0.052502453327178955, -0.0172662902623415, 0.004750038962811232, -0.00405370257794857, -0.01528369914740324, 0.036884110420942307, -0.041654206812381744, 0.02263638749718666, 0.03917115554213524, 0.027626950293779373, 0.005451584234833717, 0.023123620077967644, 0.0032847884576767683, -0.0035518486984074116, -0.020941896364092827, 0.0014085123548284173, 0.015538986772298813, -0.02783508226275444, 0.03847838193178177, -0.03250553458929062, -0.020172784104943275, 0.018710467964410782, 0.007879565469920635, 0.023813750594854355, 0.015159569680690765, -0.00444111879914999, -0.015156866982579231, -0.0016624241834506392, -0.016093380749225616, -0.002208889462053776, -0.04090579226613045, 0.010071536526083946, -0.009317180141806602, 0.008759967051446438, -0.013069363310933113, 0.01098661869764328, 0.009298047050833702, -0.03961585834622383, -0.02444496378302574, 0.022060245275497437, -0.050879720598459244, -0.0344679094851017, -0.016022130846977234, -0.028989583253860474, 0.05655086785554886, -0.014274267479777336, 0.0053208149038255215, -0.032230082899332047, 0.027725448831915855, 0.04350587725639343, 0.011776051484048367, 0.019297761842608452, 0.00405234657227993, -0.0009523488697595894, -0.0397191122174263, 0.013585287146270275, 0.028373178094625473, -0.01358688436448574, -0.035765141248703, -0.031321197748184204, 0.024317950010299683, -0.01905268430709839, -0.010000246576964855, 0.04217356815934181, 0.004417795222252607, 0.06976574659347534, -0.005679498426616192, 0.015878645703196526, 0.056421373039484024, -0.02623354084789753, 0.02038384974002838, -0.04678734391927719, 0.007395632099360228, 0.033801909536123276, -0.014117076061666012, -0.0527908131480217, 0.011153261177241802, -0.02683238871395588, 0.030531292781233788, 0.057837825268507004, -0.030511433258652687, 0.02625999227166176, -0.0417289212346077, 0.033333756029605865, 0.018007703125476837, -0.056569118052721024, 0.0551307238638401, 0.05981847643852234, -0.015931446105241776, -0.0070204478688538074, -0.038941919803619385, -0.028993355110287666, 0.015180468559265137, 0.02828771248459816, -0.022282114252448082, 0.006070930976420641, 0.02111048810184002, -0.006842684466391802, 0.007010933943092823, 0.006479689851403236, -0.0389455109834671, 0.03590565174818039, 0.012353927828371525, -0.03808096796274185, 0.05616340786218643, 0.017262661829590797, -0.0034590698778629303, 0.003715980565175414, -0.06922295689582825, 0.023203592747449875, 0.005945539101958275, 0.013544047251343727, -0.0007265404565259814, -0.05005292594432831, 0.04454052448272705, 0.017171354964375496, -0.028013166040182114, -0.0012271339073777199, 0.019799159839749336, 0.013190660625696182, 0.026516735553741455, -0.00814330205321312, 0.03062896803021431, -0.016885142773389816, 0.00011018620716640726, 0.05928603187203407, 0.03227473795413971, 0.017002495005726814, 0.011958732269704342, 0.010643428191542625, 0.007491063326597214, -0.008815255016088486, 0.01264679804444313, -0.01367126777768135, 0.03822138532996178, -0.015210465528070927, -0.018547723069787025, 0.008847164921462536, -0.033209048211574554, 0.023648258298635483, 0.013842380605638027, -0.032392457127571106, 0.04546242207288742, -0.024195201694965363, 0.02843078039586544, -0.044483084231615067, 0.03277164697647095, -0.049762334674596786, 0.01817420683801174, 0.021500423550605774, 0.022121423855423927, -0.030143724754452705, 0.016607817262411118, -0.014599330723285675, -0.0009168284013867378, 0.04919636622071266, 0.0006836197571828961, -0.004333897028118372, -0.011634516529738903, 0.012500287964940071, -0.031739864498376846, 0.007846389897167683, -0.018325451761484146, 0.030824748799204826, 0.023916183039546013, -0.002902850043028593, -0.007541321683675051, -0.01532750204205513, -0.03494611755013466, 0.03552369773387909, 0.051485709846019745, -0.060484688729047775, -0.029100950807332993, -0.012429596856236458, -0.030229410156607628, -0.048002276569604874, 0.0022558069322258234 ]
<p>I have animals, that could be virgin or mated (reproductive state is the fixed factor), which I've stimulated sequentially with 4 different doses of an odour (doses are the repeated measures, the same animal was blown with 4 increasing doses of the same odorant). Then, I measure the neuronal response (variable: number of spikes) of each animal to each dose of the odorant. This might be a typical case or repeated measures, however I have some missing values for the doses, I have not all the doses completed for some animals. For example, for animal 1, I missed recording 1 out of the 4 doses. what can I do? I have two statistical packages: SPSS 16 or Statistical. thanks for your help!</p>
73,940
[ -0.03135346993803978, -0.0037825482431799173, 0.01460869051516056, 0.04295209050178528, 0.0030951728112995625, 0.021685749292373657, -0.009374462999403477, -0.03558537736535072, 0.026826443150639534, 0.013161811046302319, 0.03900928050279617, 0.04889119789004326, 0.020961130037903786, 0.0208280049264431, -0.006758740171790123, -0.047032251954078674, -0.024559931829571724, 0.0036813695915043354, 0.0021826992742717266, -0.006200714036822319, -0.024923671036958694, 0.05151466280221939, -0.03868253529071808, -0.033820103853940964, -0.01631084457039833, 0.05354691296815872, 0.028116855770349503, -0.005138049833476543, 0.000730217550881207, 0.022948190569877625, -0.07323914021253586, -0.062117863446474075, -0.010135173797607422, 0.025156527757644653, 0.030659833922982216, -0.009528079070150852, -0.04374033212661743, -0.007796190213412046, -0.011554894037544727, 0.026460543274879456, -0.02653365768492222, 0.0020465622656047344, -0.011669272556900978, 0.02944839373230934, -0.003715166822075844, 0.004498669411987066, -0.01514541544020176, -0.012562394142150879, 0.03295397013425827, -0.029616953805088997, 0.07345899194478989, 0.018333325162529945, 0.022786473855376244, 0.026101864874362946, -0.0011807051487267017, 0.018252192065119743, 0.07683195173740387, 0.04160438850522041, 0.010946459136903286, -0.05265534296631813, 0.006245598196983337, -0.04136466234922409, 0.016743550077080727, -0.014706981368362904, -0.030069034546613693, -0.00757182901725173, -0.001262045232579112, -0.03739118576049805, 0.03759056702256203, -0.050264108926057816, 0.04775814712047577, -0.008127219043672085, 0.023827465251088142, 0.017826946452260017, 0.0016882027266547084, -0.015196806751191616, 0.022518444806337357, 0.036053452640771866, 0.0626777708530426, 0.019187726080417633, -0.0016135753830894828, 0.00308308657258749, 0.018203318119049072, 0.029789920896291733, -0.004177676513791084, -0.055325526744127274, 0.04571717604994774, -0.03328779712319374, 0.02204110659658909, 0.023884626105427742, -0.01387183926999569, -0.01305929385125637, 0.06465964764356613, 0.04091653972864151, -0.04666485637426376, -0.008552659302949905, -0.00040952482959255576, 0.05487392842769623, 0.01202886737883091, 0.004720783792436123, 0.017001019790768623, -0.02288946881890297, 0.027379270642995834, 0.06642170995473862, -0.08147570490837097, -0.006017576903104782, -0.002864171052351594, -0.00845291931182146, -0.009827577508985996, -0.009867800399661064, -0.018252525478601456, 0.016682034358382225, 0.04527626559138298, 0.007821531035006046, 0.03354813531041145, 0.0203118696808815, -0.04659457877278328, -0.007695726118981838, 0.025808127596974373, 0.06683090329170227, 0.027926554903388023, -0.03252605348825455, 0.017752476036548615, -0.027218319475650787, -0.0740259662270546, -0.008797165006399155, 0.039133135229349136, -0.05001359060406685, -0.006252009887248278, 0.05171271786093712, 0.004547588061541319, 0.0020739492028951645, 0.05379244312644005, -0.021630700677633286, 0.03648445010185242, -0.0029863903764635324, -0.05613049492239952, -0.04164928197860718, 0.005746886134147644, -0.08127332478761673, 0.01282317191362381, -0.05875241383910179, -0.02383808046579361, 0.026630518957972527, 0.036634571850299835, 0.00873616524040699, 0.0064233653247356415, 0.003443100955337286, 0.023314090445637703, 0.05951759219169617, 0.02085493877530098, -0.016982566565275192, -0.010824275203049183, -0.03514036908745766, -0.04540865868330002, -0.05113392695784569, 0.042155832052230835, 0.00422997260466218, 0.017056118696928024, -0.01232142560184002, 0.005081474781036377, 0.006770995445549488, -0.0010329516371712089, 0.018691284582018852, 0.04547087475657463, -0.009007810615003109, 0.0553780235350132, -0.027282096445560455, 0.04859742522239685, 0.007452786900103092, -0.03187953308224678, 0.00982262659817934, -0.0304146446287632, 0.03116222657263279, 0.056177496910095215, -0.008838300593197346, -0.029522597789764404, 0.0007877643802203238, -0.016192272305488586, 0.046030472964048386, -0.024187475442886353, -0.030691709369421005, -0.01659499853849411, 0.022584320977330208, 0.021231412887573242, -0.0044922539964318275, 0.02863268554210663, -0.041793495416641235, 0.002574404701590538, -0.03631220757961273, -0.052620552480220795, -0.09237287193536758, 0.018387364223599434, -0.0042589809745550156, -0.05469883233308792, 0.043663959950208664, -0.017940310761332512, 0.005617279559373856, -0.016317978501319885, -0.047461919486522675, -0.03858004882931709, -0.0031710444018244743, 0.03582989424467087, -0.026789994910359383, -0.010984642431139946, 0.06237123906612396, 0.011763800866901875, -0.0047831786796450615, 0.055121392011642456, -0.03190409764647484, -0.025249764323234558, -0.020023783668875694, -0.005327935330569744, 0.007450561039149761, -0.028465865179896355, -0.021967800334095955, -0.003588547697290778, 0.01380745880305767, -0.05209700018167496, 0.036352239549160004, -0.06715844571590424, 0.051893725991249084, 0.08907970786094666, -0.0030226961243897676, -0.010087117552757263, 0.009456009604036808, 0.03477569669485092, 0.024703120812773705, -0.026084113866090775, -0.03927801921963692, -0.026722624897956848, 0.009041366167366505, 0.024772923439741135, -0.025251153856515884, -0.04127314314246178, 0.018516669049859047, 0.03821394219994545, 0.005097799468785524, 0.011620069853961468, 0.03793526068329811, -0.0034193650353699923, 0.001055514090694487, 0.015471593476831913, -0.0058089252561330795, 0.015973225235939026, 0.028499122709035873, 0.017899727448821068, -0.0034925665240734816, 0.03568344935774803, 0.029038652777671814, 0.0011509958421811461, 0.030361447483301163, -0.05383756011724472, 0.003282825695350766, -0.021385883912444115, -0.024618858471512794, 0.04231661558151245, -0.027845146134495735, 0.045426178723573685, 0.05456405133008957, 0.03661759942770004, -0.030570002272725105, 0.03867001086473465, -0.013444166630506516, 0.013157753273844719, 0.020132875069975853, -0.031325798481702805, -0.031216511502861977, 0.01832587458193302, -0.053445782512426376, 0.0031437852885574102, -0.020629364997148514, -0.035161592066287994, -0.04048600420355797, 0.025266055017709732, 0.05921390652656555, -0.010788009501993656, 0.031583476811647415, -0.012005331926047802, 0.012604977935552597, -0.024166638031601906, 0.005424203351140022, 0.04880933463573456, 0.022057199850678444, -0.05623183771967888, -0.026042424142360687, 0.009048579260706902, 0.005462252534925938, 0.016583088785409927, -0.006180865690112114, -0.008624249137938023, 0.04932340234518051, -0.00658141216263175, -0.010829975828528404, -0.042196232825517654, -0.03999054804444313, 0.031349893659353256, 0.008333243429660797, 0.006844715680927038, 0.028172394260764122, 0.039722733199596405, -0.02909063547849655, 0.0132131427526474, -0.05439490079879761, 0.030849706381559372, -0.01712329499423504, 0.007788962684571743, -0.008439878933131695, 0.007540297228842974, -0.02616157941520214, -0.0054762158542871475, -0.007095434702932835, -0.010536673478782177, -0.07231343537569046, -0.07085128128528595, -0.014863925985991955, 0.01755002699792385, 0.019244659692049026, 0.01845141127705574, 0.006458025425672531, 0.07072564214468002, 0.004173127934336662, -0.05013984441757202, -0.025770213454961777, -0.006640166509896517, -0.00405696127563715, -0.006917078513652086, 0.040582578629255295, -0.006629650946706533, 0.03102327696979046, 0.023692021146416664, -0.008587893098592758, 0.0325813814997673, 0.060187969356775284, 0.022420426830649376, -0.0016265754820778966, 0.02265910804271698, 0.027628758922219276, -0.046398475766181946, 0.008677627891302109, 0.04622935876250267, -0.030466975644230843, 0.015712494030594826, -0.017522990703582764, 0.0036958358250558376, 0.02574191428720951, -0.03986026346683502, -0.0026428524870425463, -0.020066674798727036, 0.0013506399700418115, -0.0035888557322323322, 0.01572542078793049, 0.021236376836895943, -0.028309909626841545, -0.05311316251754761, 0.03898809105157852, 0.028923477977514267, -0.02752547711133957, -0.030019128695130348, 0.06493960320949554, 0.026370687410235405, -0.01116923801600933, -0.014899570494890213, -0.042898520827293396, 0.012682642787694931, 0.0419059656560421, 0.03451688587665558, -0.02803168259561062, 0.023965291678905487, 0.029029982164502144, 0.026244254782795906, 0.00680868374183774, -0.01783398538827896, 0.004984183702617884, -0.06360770761966705, 0.013783276081085205, -0.04108476638793945, 0.03270155191421509, 0.00021387387823779136, 0.05473511666059494, 0.02074296399950981, -0.0067268856801092625, -0.012977570295333862, 0.023981820791959763, -0.045655686408281326, -0.004514030646532774, 0.03710241988301277, -0.012437786906957626, 0.03048548474907875, -0.006842188071459532, 0.023298989981412888, -0.040277983993291855, -0.006293180864304304, 0.019675832241773605, 0.00520775793120265, -0.06108668074011803, -0.025711284950375557, -0.012221571058034897, 0.02727559022605419, -0.02877771109342575, 0.010905655100941658, 0.00939889531582594, -0.025987520813941956, 0.023822104558348656, 0.011825312860310078, 0.019610648974776268, 0.0006423014565370977, -0.04373534768819809, 0.006240295246243477, -0.01085733063519001, 0.06548196822404861, 0.018975939601659775, 0.046041619032621384, -0.0688420906662941, 0.028551951050758362, -0.016883039847016335, 0.06163473799824715, 0.05707339942455292, 0.05381904914975166, -0.0559292808175087, -0.04990539699792862, -0.013810976408421993, -0.014020424336194992, 0.05259103700518608, 0.0334928072988987, 0.03712661936879158, -0.002758926246315241, 0.019538817927241325, -0.059585701674222946, -0.016771575435996056, 0.04245730862021446, 0.01594555377960205, 0.0020401969086378813, -0.0029958118684589863, -0.0059959059581160545, -0.006468977313488722, 0.010510616935789585, 0.02437354251742363, 0.02195555344223976, 0.014928233809769154, -0.019259395077824593, 0.0326395109295845, 0.011833266355097294, -0.027716420590877533, 0.003979145549237728, 0.006591573357582092, 0.04455531761050224, -0.018910208716988564, 0.005049218889325857, -0.013471568934619427, 0.03205644711852074, 0.044356558471918106, 0.011543389409780502, -0.03364606201648712, -0.05378350988030434, -0.019886111840605736, 0.042175933718681335, 0.0021951422095298767, -0.0201508067548275, 0.02365594357252121, -0.014203612692654133, -0.021309806033968925, 0.02218611352145672, -0.036012522876262665, 0.00718153640627861, -0.002918461337685585, 0.019393572583794594, -0.02501695230603218, -0.046976346522569656, -0.035668715834617615, 0.02870158478617668, -0.019263654947280884, 0.06486426293849945, 0.002751374151557684, -0.016551297158002853, -0.013423078693449497, 0.00709183607250452, 0.046826306730508804, 0.10166209191083908, 0.030468622222542763, -0.02621937170624733, 0.04520157352089882, 0.006233148742467165, -0.019648544490337372, -0.019914675503969193, 0.006852681282907724, -0.023942731320858, -0.019475406035780907, 0.05794236809015274, -0.0005492508644238114, -0.009348533116281033, 0.036766793578863144, 0.010623399168252945, -0.019425522536039352, -0.03571580722928047, -0.03502756729722023, 0.04219072312116623, 0.04981742426753044, 0.020831089466810226, 0.04330055043101311, -0.02120552584528923, 0.026660148054361343, 0.047348666936159134, -0.027267372235655785, 0.025373170152306557, -0.010614276863634586, -0.017174910753965378, -0.053995925933122635, 0.00989422295242548, 0.017555080354213715, 0.05081385746598244, -0.006436116062104702, 0.02613825909793377, -0.0492607019841671, -0.00599302351474762, 0.04854021966457367, 0.025377821177244186, -0.0029997036326676607, 0.005242232698947191, 0.008531947620213032, 0.015562071464955807, -0.030140068382024765, -0.012412194162607193, -0.01599598117172718, -0.02900453470647335, -0.02212732471525669, 0.013662224635481834, -0.04655960947275162, -0.000948068278376013, -0.03449290245771408, -0.024131588637828827, 0.048541370779275894, -0.047358304262161255, -0.0050689042545855045, -0.04784662649035454, 0.024662375450134277, -0.006423105485737324, -0.015985755249857903, -0.028638357296586037, 0.021087247878313065, 0.00913829542696476, 0.034137655049562454, -0.06612768024206161, 0.0458032451570034, -0.05889597907662392, 0.014629550278186798, -0.06842760741710663, -0.05326807126402855, 0.05082548409700394, 0.016750846058130264, -0.04859485477209091, -0.02908366359770298, -0.0189522672444582, -0.01658015325665474, -0.02968522533774376, -0.02259223908185959, 0.02797286957502365, -0.030476344749331474, -0.021822599694132805, 0.008712627924978733, 0.03825787827372551, 0.02954315021634102, 0.009215127676725388, 0.003621931653469801, 0.02599477581679821, -0.01367088034749031, -0.06078389286994934, 0.004084996413439512, -0.029256798326969147, -0.03647415712475777, -0.03430650010704994, -0.019370537251234055, -0.005463623441755772, 0.024272039532661438, -0.05356300622224808, -0.012279501184821129, 0.04465000331401825, 0.008989602327346802, -0.023688625544309616, -0.04771093279123306, 0.004060947801917791, -0.03646043315529823, -0.004526116419583559, -0.009563134051859379, 0.011184195056557655, -0.013249796815216541, 0.005698943976312876, 0.0004885789239779115, 0.036385465413331985, -0.028009600937366486, 0.017080087214708328, 0.05756004527211189, -0.005675692576915026, -0.016232602298259735, 0.010564998723566532, 0.024194814264774323, 0.029945582151412964, 0.03820795565843582, 0.030681481584906578, -0.013393918983638287, 0.015232413075864315, -0.06771902740001678, -0.01168717723339796, -0.033436719328165054, -0.026561303064227104, 0.07417869567871094, 0.014107100665569305, -0.0073279449716210365, 0.01920642890036106, 0.011425000615417957, -0.018059775233268738, -0.032081618905067444, 0.0034545273520052433, 0.017176605761051178, 0.020643195137381554, 0.02066763862967491, 0.0038622745778411627, 0.0021326958667486906, -0.007302096579223871, 0.06073886901140213, 0.009691430255770683, 0.034879036247730255, -0.0003153115976601839, 0.022626101970672607, 0.013516809791326523, -0.038301482796669006, -0.05429411679506302, 0.015062314458191395, -0.04351852461695671, 0.022595662623643875, -0.01446221861988306, -0.010674821212887764, 0.04847343638539314, 0.04838775470852852, -0.0027820905670523643, -0.04421824589371681, -0.05205664411187172, -0.05265918746590614, 0.003309349063783884, 0.004452297929674387, -0.027026262134313583, -0.0000013070715567664593, 0.013788426294922829, 0.06646101921796799, -0.019090643152594566, 0.04481169581413269, -0.03820031136274338, -0.05989009141921997, -0.02743983082473278, 0.014409035444259644, -0.01786438748240471, 0.05056107044219971, -0.008389332331717014, -0.0035206428728997707, 0.009815159253776073, -0.0038112092297524214, 0.026742585003376007, -0.022015582770109177, 0.06337540596723557, 0.006720867473632097, 0.03511429950594902, 0.02335861511528492, -0.02286325953900814, -0.014004966244101524, 0.02359057031571865, 0.11546140909194946, 0.07150902599096298, 0.028241196647286415, -0.06345211714506149, 0.005607989616692066, -0.0007321115117520094, 0.02402646653354168, 0.002708949614316225, -0.007366882637143135, 0.027235740795731544, -0.016669459640979767, 0.020298706367611885, 0.028361033648252487, 0.04873953387141228, 0.01886606402695179, 0.07651402801275253, -0.01084707397967577, -0.013209734112024307, -0.009249228052794933, 0.020811930298805237, 0.043917763978242874, -0.006619896274060011, -0.02373102866113186, -0.004380827769637108, 0.02090594917535782, -0.022813132032752037, -0.03500917926430702, 0.010423216037452221, -0.009414388798177242, 0.0021223961375653744, -0.007060741074383259, -0.0021193930879235268, 0.017125464975833893, 0.047308120876550674, -0.02842964604496956, 0.0018713590689003468, 0.013021253980696201, -0.049147266894578934, 0.01986704394221306, 0.026680080220103264, 0.006341106723994017, -0.003940912429243326, 0.032456811517477036, 0.011949578300118446, -0.006902479100972414, -0.029921935871243477, 0.0035237439442425966, 0.056624796241521835, -0.027921533212065697, -0.0163597222417593, -0.008780683390796185, 0.018161911517381668, 0.013112028129398823, -0.06845368444919586, -0.051884569227695465, 0.03454053774476051, 0.011582321487367153, -0.017442921176552773, 0.00878927018493414, -0.01872039958834648, 0.0025706307496875525, 0.007703882176429033, 0.013290077447891235, 0.022817809134721756, 0.0031203629914671183, -0.035089220851659775, -0.04973192140460014, 0.03055906854569912, 0.00819031335413456, -0.006261808332055807, 0.008119916543364525, -0.029091302305459976, -0.0025004050694406033, 0.015385962091386318, 0.013110192492604256, 0.009284029714763165, 0.015066806226968765, -0.02035032957792282, -0.04940701276063919, 0.019645527005195618, -0.05052193999290466, -0.012639722786843777, -0.012704757042229176, -0.0023536905646324158, -0.030300414189696312, -0.001636998145841062, 0.02195724844932556, 0.0323905348777771, 0.026863960549235344, -0.010837024077773094, 0.008907824754714966, 0.05526752397418022, 0.05769659951329231, -0.07028388977050781, -0.019244028255343437, 0.008502774871885777, -0.01773606240749359, -0.011133615858852863, -0.034717898815870285, 0.06799973547458649, -0.007228804286569357, 0.03342742845416069, -0.04126477241516113, 0.0015620416961610317, 0.011891718953847885, -0.005096460226923227, 0.009348498657345772, -0.050880927592515945, -0.028520291671156883, -0.011851878836750984, 0.013383896090090275, -0.04625236615538597, -0.03988363593816757, -0.038062259554862976, -0.003548156935721636, 0.01384811196476221, -0.04215843603014946, -0.030783558264374733, -0.017021140083670616, 0.031073397025465965, 0.005106793250888586, 0.03326667100191116, 0.02156696282327175, -0.03157821297645569, -0.028502052649855614, -0.007174636237323284, -0.0008993734954856336, -0.014897646382451057, 0.014722615480422974, -0.01888403296470642, 0.00300445850007236, 0.020476801320910454, -0.014022043906152248, 0.04431728646159172, -0.022774001583456993, -0.016513030976057053, 0.005660217255353928, 0.06364092230796814, 0.00022525322856381536, -0.021633628755807877, 0.012061852030456066, -0.05275050923228264, -0.013752613216638565, 0.017058920115232468, 0.0038103205151855946, 0.011303797364234924, 0.056417182087898254, 0.03719169646501541, -0.02738920785486698, 0.05925293639302254, -0.0511297881603241, 0.014648368582129478, -0.011915023438632488, 0.024924766272306442, 0.004982763435691595, 0.027867039665579796, -0.010887380689382553, 0.048853613436222076, -0.00871586985886097, 0.027708305045962334, 0.0375710055232048, 0.02018786035478115, 0.023738203570246696, 0.018503950908780098, -0.014008178375661373, 0.020308716222643852, -0.012749725952744484, -0.020543336868286133, 0.018923988565802574, 0.041169874370098114, -0.0030912263318896294, 0.0007165568531490862, 0.004227661993354559, 0.006588729098439217, -0.03929706662893295, -0.0276564359664917, 0.010344074107706547, 0.02506382204592228, 0.019586240872740746, -0.036863625049591064, 0.024918099865317345, 0.0009291013702750206, -0.06530823558568954, -0.007356963586062193, 0.014818932861089706, -0.028380677103996277, -0.0016734832897782326, 0.014753641560673714, 0.007483191788196564, -0.0030860090628266335, 0.016468128189444542, -0.013180004432797432, 0.02109481208026409, -0.009008956141769886, 0.02576846443116665, -0.05796784535050392, -0.035088177770376205, 0.013871973380446434, 0.06815041601657867, -0.09144489467144012, 0.03899780288338661, -0.05421819910407066, -0.02696400135755539, 0.024525810033082962, -0.00722228130325675, -0.0016986568225547671, 0.03458544611930847, 0.029417507350444794, -0.028201185166835785, 0.08800768107175827, -0.018881814554333687, 0.016725752502679825, 0.01797669194638729, -0.023262949660420418, 0.01307964138686657, -0.018584173172712326, -0.062761090695858, 0.03286336362361908, 0.036993030458688736, 0.010320914909243584, -0.04021991416811943, -0.00849760603159666, 0.009719294495880604, -0.031012268736958504, 0.027176741510629654, 0.030448129400610924, 0.06457851827144623, -0.014498497359454632, -0.03904068470001221, -0.04288586229085922, 0.03552182391285896, 0.03173689916729927, 0.012550415471196175, -0.0211531613022089, -0.009502316825091839, -0.03061019442975521, -0.019401971250772476, -0.019593551754951477, 0.006668187212198973, -0.00649690069258213, -0.05382223799824715, -0.007008072454482317, -0.02876870706677437, -0.009668015874922276, 0.0017604080494493246, -0.006909291259944439, -0.010230682790279388, 0.06983903050422668, -0.015742359682917595, -0.011295432224869728, -0.008372360840439796, 0.009343383833765984, 0.011011150665581226, -0.07677127420902252, 0.04242975264787674, 0.004320930689573288, -0.005762179382145405, -0.018097110092639923, -0.0222164299339056, -0.017850361764431, 0.044392943382263184, 0.03929100185632706, -0.01390878763049841, -0.009852574206888676, 0.007846951484680176, 0.030859846621751785, 0.005003591068089008, -0.04226693883538246, 0.057910140603780746, 0.02359754964709282, 0.012678267434239388, -0.049693599343299866, 0.008047410286962986, -0.02484971098601818, -0.008648674003779888, 0.004808308556675911, 0.019831376150250435, 0.006379659287631512, -0.016507042571902275, 0.009345069527626038, 0.021886365488171577, 0.009217184968292713, -0.01490254607051611, 0.020816072821617126, -0.017452936619520187, -0.0023773787543177605, 0.0262904092669487, 0.01611507683992386, -0.06971943378448486, 0.031573787331581116, -0.055971983820199966, -0.03434518724679947, -0.03013733960688114, 0.020218366757035255, 0.0050468407571315765, -0.10221775621175766, -0.013975248672068119, 0.004111143294721842, -0.014539840631186962, 0.022264791652560234, 0.02507368102669716, 0.012199816294014454, 0.027651041746139526, -0.04524480924010277, 0.01593445986509323, 0.005017363931983709, 0.017902931198477745, 0.010642537847161293, 0.06439058482646942, 0.004102942068129778, 0.02148141898214817, -0.024109138175845146, 0.015261482447385788, -0.03673475235700607, 0.024248111993074417, -0.002506047021597624, 0.008663604035973549, -0.016406698152422905, -0.003109615296125412, 0.036973193287849426, -0.004158276133239269, 0.00588582968339324, -0.02097209356725216, 0.00044565656571649015, 0.05276620015501976, -0.03956686332821846, -0.00496492488309741, -0.07767310738563538, 0.0006845110910944641, -0.020253513008356094, -0.0144991185516119, -0.002668917179107666, 0.03286903724074364, 0.006067659240216017, 0.03047502227127552, -0.005599683616310358, -0.007635198999196291, 0.03948983922600746, -0.04333079233765602, -0.008922492153942585, -0.019741764292120934, -0.007402919232845306, -0.0011083754943683743, -0.03116157464683056, -0.03238175809383392, 0.008475223556160927, 0.040421321988105774, 0.041896089911460876, 0.013562554493546486, -0.051314424723386765, -0.026896491646766663, -0.02778848633170128, 0.024604639038443565, -0.026171432808041573, -0.04065624624490738, -0.010522739961743355, 0.007673508487641811, -0.008449547924101353, -0.007169633638113737 ]
<p>Obviously events A and B are independent iff Pr$(A\cap B)$ = Pr$(A)$Pr$(B)$. Let's define a related quantity Q:</p> <p>$Q\equiv\frac{\mathrm{Pr}(A\cap B)}{\mathrm{Pr}(A)\mathrm{Pr}(B)}$</p> <p>So A and B are independent iff Q = 1 (assuming the denominator is nonzero). Does Q actually have a name though? I feel like it refers to some elementary concept that is escaping me right now and that I will feel quite silly for even asking this.</p>
49,547
[ 0.010389125905930996, -0.01475843321532011, -0.020869987085461617, -0.006603558547794819, 0.04171016812324524, 0.014790643937885761, -0.013252896256744862, 0.030304554849863052, 0.005946075078099966, -0.010479000397026539, 0.026542337611317635, 0.021486954763531685, 0.05869564786553383, -0.0001870284031610936, 0.0025863307528197765, 0.042217738926410675, 0.03198856860399246, -0.006157521158456802, -0.025673145428299904, -0.04895548149943352, 0.005533742252737284, 0.017579833045601845, 0.0635635107755661, 0.004750804975628853, -0.0026437502820044756, 0.05954209715127945, -0.014970023185014725, -0.008657838217914104, 0.001701083150692284, 0.04809939116239548, -0.019649533554911613, -0.0602378286421299, 0.02353723905980587, 0.008292723447084427, 0.017466789111495018, -0.006713119801133871, -0.008903305046260357, -0.03825382888317108, -0.006825709715485573, -0.0006260740337893367, -0.05716375261545181, -0.032964762300252914, -0.02222638577222824, 0.026398953050374985, -0.04908420890569687, -0.00249857478775084, 0.020400244742631912, -0.07762952893972397, 0.028018660843372345, -0.03127570077776909, 0.06282196193933487, -0.002112274058163166, 0.061487819999456406, 0.014602121897041798, -0.010802341625094414, -0.012417052872478962, 0.05080057680606842, 0.05337924882769585, -0.017659485340118408, -0.03142163157463074, -0.02967969700694084, -0.011473040096461773, 0.014941575936973095, -0.012885507196187973, -0.020589597523212433, 0.006951283663511276, -0.0004861229390371591, 0.002794892992824316, 0.039752792567014694, 0.0015381162520498037, 0.007486366666853428, 0.04262496158480644, 0.06323553621768951, -0.019149966537952423, 0.031248509883880615, -0.015802429988980293, 0.036929305642843246, -0.014448663219809532, 0.028008854016661644, 0.018512632697820663, 0.025393512099981308, 0.0036294455640017986, 0.026421472430229187, -0.014969736337661743, -0.0019292323850095272, -0.015273901633918285, 0.059349026530981064, -0.009180476889014244, -0.003097826847806573, 0.018262242898344994, -0.05174114182591438, 0.021765805780887604, 0.004408546723425388, -0.019111599773168564, -0.048868898302316666, 0.036112718284130096, -0.022705724462866783, 0.010958226397633553, 0.018208827823400497, -0.00904016848653555, -0.015593933872878551, -0.07333433628082275, 0.02123170904815197, 0.08332379162311554, -0.03144271671772003, -0.023587506264448166, -0.02268937975168228, 0.03462212160229683, -0.03809092938899994, -0.0072990842163562775, -0.030765442177653313, 0.0016645051073282957, 0.025209710001945496, 0.04943245276808739, -0.0033219221513718367, -0.02830887772142887, -0.0027764930855482817, 0.0387830026447773, 0.04304775968194008, 0.04391690343618393, 0.0599663108587265, -0.03732811287045479, 0.020957669243216515, -0.006007737945765257, -0.050996098667383194, 0.034306444227695465, 0.027911487966775894, -0.01241433434188366, -0.04783589020371437, 0.052213314920663834, -0.00008258993329945952, -0.021152468398213387, 0.005461203400045633, 0.01815560832619667, -0.00503110745921731, -0.026462802663445473, -0.05808854103088379, -0.055088527500629425, 0.0575992651283741, -0.0013029519468545914, -0.04011755436658859, -0.05425278842449188, 0.025295140221714973, 0.07111778855323792, 0.0714302808046341, -0.013640178367495537, 0.05178080499172211, 0.00008174513641279191, -0.022743631154298782, 0.013266943395137787, -0.0439215749502182, -0.03753752261400223, 0.01723889447748661, -0.0056311520747840405, 0.025204790756106377, -0.041027069091796875, 0.020934855565428734, 0.04763881862163544, -0.008399820886552334, 0.01147195789963007, 0.07104841619729996, -0.005320291500538588, 0.012244426645338535, 0.03988669067621231, 0.005301169119775295, -0.0483689084649086, 0.08874708414077759, 0.012038794346153736, -0.012751635164022446, 0.02762531489133835, 0.043540485203266144, -0.007472257129848003, 0.03581712767481804, 0.041280049830675125, 0.033785004168748856, -0.03907832130789757, -0.05234227329492569, -0.02758948691189289, 0.017186777666211128, 0.006834740750491619, -0.04803198575973511, -0.02475903555750847, -0.038451049476861954, 0.008585937321186066, -0.009274840354919434, 0.008533766493201256, 0.00022760359570384026, -0.020624857395887375, 0.04150806739926338, 0.025447554886341095, -0.03132985159754753, -0.04716005548834801, 0.018146367743611336, -0.0012087341165170074, -0.013267191126942635, 0.01712646707892418, 0.004175378475338221, -0.0014261052710935473, -0.03616064786911011, -0.01850956678390503, -0.0345071405172348, 0.0019772546365857124, 0.0007546409033238888, -0.04913341999053955, 0.024018120020627975, 0.046151429414749146, 0.03023499622941017, 0.0025282870046794415, 0.03431529551744461, -0.029155537486076355, -0.03663099557161331, -0.0358269102871418, -0.020744383335113525, 0.049487147480249405, -0.04610855132341385, -0.04508742690086365, 0.013185190036892891, -0.00755162863060832, -0.0067419870756566525, 0.01568397507071495, -0.060882702469825745, 0.034014638513326645, 0.01516666915267706, 0.03172092139720917, -0.027662979438900948, 0.004603039938956499, 0.06283843517303467, -0.003903210163116455, -0.007371118292212486, -0.009743607603013515, -0.03333798423409462, 0.01185620203614235, 0.043606072664260864, 0.014497966505587101, 0.01002052053809166, 0.004825087264180183, 0.044100016355514526, 0.028646143153309822, 0.008427540771663189, 0.019703568890690804, -0.015538476407527924, -0.002870306372642517, -0.0007420745096169412, 0.01848040521144867, 0.03502822294831276, 0.009676645509898663, 0.014357388019561768, -0.009873911738395691, 0.03516051173210144, -0.035266414284706116, -0.047042738646268845, 0.00820294301956892, 0.018239764496684074, -0.01635352149605751, -0.005584742873907089, -0.050133876502513885, 0.046549104154109955, -0.04704185202717781, 0.05047726258635521, 0.002123675076290965, 0.042416732758283615, -0.021171385422348976, -0.017497869208455086, -0.029232053086161613, -0.009697235189378262, 0.0010779175208881497, -0.045187003910541534, 0.006650018505752087, 0.020054196938872337, -0.003499007783830166, 0.010768851265311241, -0.023432869464159012, -0.0552198700606823, -0.0028182684909552336, -0.045539189130067825, 0.017900042235851288, 0.022324498742818832, 0.04456624388694763, -0.04498739540576935, -0.05010125786066055, 0.014462115243077278, -0.025464871898293495, 0.02848387509584427, 0.018129967153072357, -0.03286236524581909, 0.004635069519281387, -0.008802947588264942, -0.03587629273533821, 0.04520442709326744, -0.013822364620864391, -0.013000736944377422, -0.027016228064894676, -0.013235765509307384, -0.04015759751200676, -0.0015549359377473593, -0.06847943365573883, -0.011475801467895508, -0.05063008889555931, -0.005703503731638193, 0.06171884387731552, -0.0265219584107399, -0.04976317286491394, 0.00273033045232296, -0.0705280676484108, -0.0021264723036438227, -0.047652196139097214, -0.001320235780440271, 0.046209488064050674, -0.014341234229505062, -0.016587823629379272, 0.046481069177389145, -0.010596045292913914, -0.02373463287949562, -0.0683932825922966, -0.10222472995519638, 0.01920570805668831, -0.021720848977565765, 0.03602540120482445, 0.018410170450806618, -0.023111402988433838, 0.07298599183559418, 0.030761243775486946, -0.010737798176705837, -0.00613631634041667, 0.0016892523271963, 0.008192560635507107, -0.026663998141884804, 0.012374085374176502, 0.00010506069520488381, -0.0050448523834347725, 0.028977423906326294, 0.028203820809721947, 0.025895101949572563, 0.03321308642625809, -0.022868415340781212, 0.0002820390509441495, 0.02947261556982994, 0.007214191369712353, -0.023783840239048004, 0.03978994861245155, 0.04859727621078491, -0.033570319414138794, 0.007693963591009378, -0.0009130073594860733, 0.06597594916820526, 0.0039413850754499435, -0.04566733539104462, 0.037280842661857605, 0.016598941758275032, 0.00800123531371355, -0.028874795883893967, 0.04962260276079178, -0.029156744480133057, 0.008254675194621086, -0.011008096858859062, 0.022053850814700127, 0.00980748888105154, -0.031645603477954865, 0.041962604969739914, 0.03362138196825981, 0.0398702435195446, -0.035248469561338425, -0.026600323617458344, -0.021967492997646332, -0.004162412602454424, 0.018272416666150093, -0.01549290120601654, -0.02291569486260414, 0.04842423275113106, 0.006355573423206806, 0.019368194043636322, 0.008184962905943394, -0.060867466032505035, -0.015534242615103722, -0.05830421298742294, 0.0011337177129462361, 0.001125229406170547, 0.0005588863277807832, 0.01406847033649683, 0.08696597069501877, 0.006258219946175814, 0.0108157554641366, 0.030286213383078575, 0.03591426834464073, -0.0777101069688797, 0.008943945169448853, -0.04251042753458023, -0.05002470314502716, -0.005833457224071026, -0.00011777183681260794, 0.026531493291258812, -0.01849590614438057, -0.047866079956293106, -0.008764422498643398, -0.007306337356567383, -0.04718147590756416, -0.00881112925708294, -0.030020039528608322, -0.05565207824110985, 0.029651198536157608, -0.006182124372571707, 0.02936430089175701, -0.002675687661394477, 0.056349728256464005, 0.04292356222867966, -0.006891961675137281, -0.012500216253101826, 0.010353402234613895, -0.008106998167932034, 0.00345768965780735, -0.004792073275893927, -0.005597923882305622, 0.03312059864401817, -0.01940065808594227, 0.04426121339201927, 0.03841588273644447, 0.04187391325831413, 0.02769441530108452, -0.021832356229424477, -0.009106449782848358, -0.06391620635986328, -0.0010589108569547534, -0.019558949396014214, -0.00013712956570088863, 0.012430177070200443, 0.002515191212296486, 0.03218536823987961, 0.02921372838318348, -0.02360510639846325, 0.010418812744319439, 0.06970781832933426, 0.018543142825365067, -0.022669678553938866, -0.0012682679807767272, 0.02248113788664341, -0.004538486711680889, -0.005728253163397312, -0.032815441489219666, 0.028558731079101562, -0.001383214141242206, 0.02774396352469921, 0.01156486477702856, 0.0027560293674468994, 0.02014973573386669, -0.021953029558062553, -0.019462499767541885, 0.000804420153144747, -0.008504175581037998, -0.03912988305091858, 0.01645732671022415, 0.0015869515482336283, -0.013728984631597996, 0.06033632904291153, -0.0005744299851357937, -0.05625644698739052, 0.05384024605154991, 0.02788609266281128, 0.007485271897166967, -0.024502942338585854, -0.031293950974941254, -0.023998267948627472, -0.04549982398748398, 0.043146658688783646, -0.01538973581045866, 0.01730022393167019, -0.008821054361760616, -0.004683327861130238, -0.005195298232138157, -0.007969199679791927, 0.00020440058142412454, 0.03497105464339256, 0.019329722970724106, 0.026232406497001648, 0.007942701689898968, -0.006122882012277842, -0.01814093440771103, 0.02154717780649662, 0.028958674520254135, 0.03637384623289108, -0.010691140778362751, -0.006065543740987778, -0.01318690087646246, 0.025856008753180504, -0.01655864529311657, -0.08966983109712601, -0.002916398225352168, -0.004370851442217827, 0.016544464975595474, 0.016652463003993034, -0.031103502959012985, -0.061236992478370667, 0.012101718224585056, -0.003290156600996852, -0.022044556215405464, 0.04198768734931946, -0.019382746890187263, 0.06300602853298187, 0.03767668455839157, 0.02464357577264309, 0.02363329753279686, 0.03135141730308533, -0.023569602519273758, -0.027826635167002678, 0.012711203657090664, 0.05144469439983368, -0.0342574417591095, -0.017187733203172684, -0.05124072730541229, 0.0004980054218322039, -0.0655808299779892, 0.01685962826013565, 0.015098185278475285, -0.003454274730756879, -0.04450724273920059, -0.026484128087759018, -0.048324208706617355, -0.00277626421302557, 0.03903578221797943, -0.008298956789076328, -0.03777056932449341, 0.012728381901979446, -0.0012526798527687788, -0.0066739944741129875, 0.012985526584088802, -0.013093516230583191, -0.0062163276597857475, 0.005836050491780043, 0.015937699005007744, 0.015026876702904701, -0.04234560206532478, -0.029176881536841393, 0.03872930258512497, -0.007398837711662054, 0.046917445957660675, 0.0031616773921996355, 0.021369121968746185, 0.009258393198251724, -0.07279491424560547, -0.06627645343542099, 0.01776636205613613, -0.00820161309093237, 0.016031119972467422, -0.06915034353733063, -0.0029948295559734106, -0.018750077113509178, -0.008506214246153831, -0.06152541562914848, -0.02805257961153984, 0.024441249668598175, 0.0032385524827986956, -0.010524041019380093, -0.0053026932291686535, 0.009471374563872814, 0.010786633938550949, -0.05113867297768593, 0.026837171986699104, 0.0567881315946579, -0.015004933811724186, -0.011653522029519081, -0.0021214711014181376, 0.02611965872347355, 0.012267262674868107, 0.030708113685250282, 0.0033366826828569174, -0.019729580730199814, 0.0067565967328846455, -0.007079009432345629, 0.0463094562292099, 0.043920520693063736, -0.016920180991292, -0.012222828343510628, -0.05036922171711922, -0.017487287521362305, 0.009302166290581226, -0.025674091652035713, -0.008498958311975002, 0.004970384296029806, 0.026692800223827362, -0.004092902410775423, 0.0003683516988530755, -0.00036973593523725867, 0.028481503948569298, 0.003477667924016714, -0.0034970410633832216, -0.019730405882000923, 0.0009028095519170165, -0.0021801081020385027, 0.019712727516889572, -0.009366968646645546, -0.026271646842360497, 0.0026401979848742485, 0.0321965329349041, -0.0011256535071879625, -0.01337977685034275, 0.010468116030097008, 0.004650452174246311, 0.020678333938121796, -0.019814372062683105, -0.025634489953517914, 0.01856686919927597, -0.02014118619263172, -0.01773526519536972, -0.03325612097978592, -0.037621356546878815, 0.014785310253500938, 0.03411165624856949, -0.039808955043554306, 0.0654224157333374, 0.02794584259390831, 0.0018063136376440525, -0.00040368392365053296, -0.03140512853860855, -0.013556492514908314, -0.014639703556895256, 0.013993666507303715, 0.0192326121032238, -0.03847559541463852, 0.027654927223920822, 0.0247320719063282, 0.05801143869757652, -0.03294612094759941, 0.003078508423641324, 0.018106358125805855, 0.028397299349308014, 0.03755054995417595, 0.0005222569452598691, -0.025419490411877632, 0.03334527835249901, -0.055644646286964417, -0.0113369757309556, -0.04428271949291229, -0.032133426517248154, 0.055952880531549454, 0.018182219937443733, -0.03327666595578194, -0.03939716890454292, -0.009210867807269096, -0.03661491349339485, 0.025824425742030144, 0.018325187265872955, 0.03778071328997612, 0.043748509138822556, -0.05038995295763016, 0.0053177629597485065, -0.00590662332251668, 0.016729407012462616, -0.002214853884652257, -0.07037730515003204, -0.018441254273056984, -0.05752641335129738, -0.052264221012592316, 0.030662842094898224, -0.04260614886879921, -0.025646641850471497, 0.004346748348325491, -0.04444511607289314, 0.025865769013762474, 0.022771785035729408, 0.024508433416485786, -0.023359792307019234, 0.07843025028705597, 0.013357515446841717, 0.024136189371347427, -0.015456351451575756, 0.009325578808784485, 0.1039913147687912, 0.03819714114069939, 0.014941263012588024, -0.049550704658031464, -0.010605083778500557, 0.018516570329666138, 0.024775473400950432, -0.003157101571559906, -0.0009696920751594007, 0.003694550832733512, 0.010748119093477726, 0.04074382781982422, 0.053795941174030304, 0.049191080033779144, -0.028257189318537712, 0.05878077819943428, -0.005548414308577776, -0.04107404500246048, -0.007716668304055929, 0.03283335641026497, -0.03174297884106636, -0.0031271367333829403, -0.03252408280968666, -0.004206534940749407, 0.016400188207626343, -0.008493880741298199, -0.020986264571547508, 0.0060192737728357315, 0.01613401621580124, 0.04202621430158615, 0.012953625060617924, 0.016817370429635048, 0.06825492531061172, 0.009015174582600594, -0.007923777215182781, 0.04237358644604683, 0.019884664565324783, -0.030980560928583145, 0.015488557517528534, 0.023745475336909294, 0.021259855479002, -0.013673531822860241, 0.011809604242444038, -0.02676389180123806, -0.05167662724852562, -0.027358420193195343, -0.022201210260391235, 0.0309684406965971, -0.032162267714738846, 0.05566117540001869, -0.05626364424824715, -0.015472132712602615, 0.01850801333785057, -0.04778052866458893, 0.008502506650984287, -0.012519625015556812, -0.010985836386680603, -0.03470062464475632, 0.030361277982592583, -0.031376976519823074, 0.02524672821164131, -0.010332576930522919, 0.010245285928249359, 0.020489567890763283, -0.02573288418352604, 0.01125828642398119, -0.024987133219838142, 0.03324265778064728, -0.027580758556723595, 0.006334192585200071, 0.0011749167460948229, -0.004365628119558096, -0.04079566150903702, -0.034713760018348694, -0.028426170349121094, 0.006956732831895351, 0.030137863010168076, 0.00289355730637908, 0.0016276176320388913, -0.0028223968110978603, 0.005221500527113676, 0.04441467672586441, -0.030363043770194054, -0.015555639751255512, -0.02175862528383732, -0.014441345818340778, 0.010517466813325882, 0.05841238051652908, -0.018153997138142586, 0.004447042476385832, -0.00724010867998004, 0.02580864541232586, 0.008823765441775322, -0.03872780501842499, 0.010233486071228981, 0.02925053797662258, -0.021994465962052345, 0.00955374538898468, -0.01020770613104105, 0.05786978825926781, 0.01414465345442295, 0.025050977244973183, -0.024072956293821335, -0.012758499011397362, -0.011705955490469933, 0.027074500918388367, -0.011242461390793324, -0.019623972475528717, -0.0021581300534307957, 0.017028003931045532, 0.03233218938112259, 0.008178041316568851, -0.02815908193588257, 0.013780763372778893, 0.03565400838851929, -0.011047020554542542, 0.0016545150429010391, -0.06327079981565475, 0.0023085460998117924, -0.017445527017116547, 0.04246405512094498, -0.00894885417073965, 0.01287790760397911, -0.05150787532329559, -0.020984306931495667, 0.01800074614584446, -0.003992204088717699, -0.019185395911335945, 0.03895067796111107, 0.014327204786241055, -0.00784533005207777, -0.011806806549429893, 0.007309084292501211, -0.007786852773278952, -0.011096470057964325, 0.03495357185602188, 0.026446590200066566, 0.0418887659907341, -0.04214058443903923, 0.00087791308760643, 0.03636913374066353, -0.0365590862929821, -0.040668223053216934, 0.019895905628800392, 0.026543891057372093, 0.052709467709064484, 0.05747189000248909, -0.003896343754604459, -0.01931180991232395, -0.0047363960184156895, -0.01745615340769291, -0.027042405679821968, -0.011680969037115574, -0.02875376306474209, -0.01930808834731579, -0.02896866388618946, -0.012285621836781502, 0.022080466151237488, -0.005329820327460766, 0.009005069732666016, 0.036884307861328125, -0.007426277734339237, 0.004552972968667746, 0.05138593539595604, 0.030699603259563446, 0.002415438648313284, 0.006057466845959425, 0.010670905001461506, 0.01239025592803955, 0.02091137133538723, -0.024346301332116127, 0.015206284821033478, 0.003135465318337083, 0.029347434639930725, -0.08697547018527985, -0.014080650173127651, 0.01898052915930748, 0.017681295052170753, 0.053037263453006744, -0.04382485896348953, 0.020519226789474487, 0.007809580769389868, -0.07672256976366043, 0.03620048239827156, -0.01392214186489582, -0.02545391581952572, -0.027195388451218605, 0.05136924237012863, 0.012016844935715199, 0.06844347715377808, 0.017514845356345177, -0.01606106199324131, 0.06743435561656952, 0.033850327134132385, 0.011125637218356133, -0.025578981265425682, -0.015249260701239109, -0.03954986110329628, -0.017836449667811394, 0.000499979592859745, 0.0445595346391201, -0.05860863998532295, 0.005869297310709953, 0.04701414331793785, -0.020266972482204437, 0.0066137779504060745, 0.004949955735355616, 0.03375912830233574, 0.02768588252365589, 0.001900160568766296, 0.01887890137732029, -0.024993831291794777, -0.013643773272633553, -0.008339151740074158, 0.04347001016139984, 0.05722827464342117, 0.03452083468437195, -0.054443083703517914, 0.015299751423299313, -0.05150692164897919, -0.0708591565489769, -0.0007057356997393072, -0.0033601082395762205, -0.010797872208058834, 0.0145725654438138, -0.019335661083459854, -0.008795307017862797, -0.011014610528945923, 0.04036717116832733, -0.033113911747932434, -0.008793001994490623, 0.04771258309483528, -0.01773785799741745, -0.008887866511940956, -0.03521526977419853, -0.005065875593572855, -0.032356731593608856, 0.05530604347586632, 0.030774906277656555, -0.025875749066472054, -0.052801307290792465, -0.028183089569211006, -0.015757795423269272, 0.018261149525642395, 0.013763594441115856, -0.036004919558763504, -0.02707693539559841, 0.002388596534729004, -0.031178772449493408, -0.010120593011379242, 0.00359946652315557, 0.00965041946619749, 0.007907804101705551, -0.06981216371059418, 0.07349980622529984, 0.031509533524513245, 0.0179432462900877, -0.04443296417593956, -0.03229068964719772, -0.019036253914237022, -0.021881332620978355, 0.07273554801940918, 0.03431355580687523, -0.006834125146269798, 0.030390800908207893, 0.001373820356093347, 0.030964242294430733, -0.021380208432674408, -0.010565010830760002, -0.01293216086924076, 0.010747935622930527, -0.031846582889556885, -0.007456094957888126, 0.006857980974018574, -0.013389527797698975, 0.01933179423213005, 0.022223981097340584, -0.017579227685928345, -0.0274181067943573, -0.024976301938295364, 0.06617128849029541, -0.018870985135436058, -0.01577359437942505, 0.05163697898387909, 0.010440386831760406, 0.01783984899520874, 0.010494030080735683, -0.043649930506944656, -0.06698289513587952, 0.050918638706207275, -0.011609675362706184, -0.03697499632835388, 0.004367194138467312, 0.03066788800060749, 0.012631474994122982, -0.043851763010025024, -0.045148637145757675, 0.014924295246601105, -0.06278396397829056, -0.0029479123186320066, 0.02365860901772976, 0.015672815963625908, 0.053896255791187286, -0.023077284917235374, -0.003051056293770671, -0.0008292220300063491, -0.04278753325343132, 0.04294176772236824, 0.04104410484433174, 0.06621549278497696, 0.01448022946715355, 0.02905907854437828, 0.04300926253199577, 0.0000311494804918766, 0.0007254956290125847, 0.036430131644010544, -0.013384872116148472, -0.004755104426294565, -0.01199848111718893, 0.014403844252228737, -0.0005037855007685721, 0.049093786627054214, 0.03214007988572121, -0.016795773059129715, 0.05731457844376564, 0.020355060696601868, 0.025953181087970734, -0.020978983491659164, 0.05771830305457115, -0.030536703765392303, -0.05242813751101494, 0.020582593977451324, 0.011492288671433926, -0.023111578077077866, -0.028367530554533005, 0.01210186816751957, -0.01579810306429863, -0.013705102726817131, -0.054548513144254684, 0.03727075830101967, 0.009171076118946075, 0.013961760327219963, -0.006825634278357029, 0.0015674708411097527, 0.009994959458708763, -0.029291415587067604, 0.04523158445954323, 0.06543807685375214, 0.039685145020484924, 0.0216422937810421, -0.04865504056215286, 0.0024022290017455816, 0.05340536683797836, -0.07469836622476578, 0.0032506673596799374, -0.039851441979408264, 0.04958457499742508, 0.01384744979441166, -0.012185189872980118 ]
<p>As the title says, I'd like to calculate the percentage difference for two sets of points. For example, suppose I have $S_{1}=\{(1,x_{1}),(2,x_{2}),(3,x_{3})\}$ and $S_{2}=\{(1,y_{1}),(2,y_{2}),(3,y_{3})\}$. How can I know the difference in percentage between both sets of data. What is the correct way to do that? Is that kind of assessment meaningful to establish to which degree of precision a set of data is preferred over the other?</p> <p>In my particular case, $S_{1}$ is simply a set of numerical results obtained by <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_simulation_Monte_Carlo" rel="nofollow">DSMC</a> and $S_{2}$ was obtained by a theoretical result. I'd like to quantify how much difference exist between each other in order to establish when it is convenient to use one or the other.</p> <p>By "difference in percentage" I mean <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Percent_difference" rel="nofollow">percent difference</a>. Hopefully that clarifies a bit the question.</p> <p><strong>UPDATE:</strong></p> <p>Another way to formulate my question would be: How can I arrive to conclusions such as "The results from experiment A are inaccurate by 10% with respect to experiment B", when experiment A and B are a set of values.</p>
73,941
[ 0.008242800831794739, -0.02467450499534607, -0.016694895923137665, -0.028053492307662964, -0.004823156166821718, 0.025519348680973053, 0.011513955891132355, -0.05786168575286865, 0.028527868911623955, 0.009795092046260834, 0.03849472105503082, 0.03734085336327553, 0.03070732206106186, 0.013684730045497417, 0.02062535472214222, 0.0005998141132295132, -0.007954277098178864, 0.008977377787232399, 0.024063443765044212, -0.0216305460780859, 0.03453827649354935, -0.006572114769369364, -0.01988556794822216, -0.0039930641651153564, -0.023802923038601875, 0.029913749545812607, 0.02367926575243473, -0.012444110587239265, -0.022859113290905952, 0.03066621907055378, -0.030696099624037743, -0.05711768567562103, 0.017358049750328064, 0.030902229249477386, 0.010583438910543919, 0.004353326745331287, -0.02803504839539528, -0.02746480517089367, 0.004015475977212191, 0.02760322019457817, -0.06139610335230827, -0.0004697652766481042, -0.02399531938135624, 0.03524782136082649, -0.007771104574203491, -0.015060888603329659, 0.01640220731496811, -0.05127694830298424, 0.01902848854660988, -0.047907788306474686, 0.028694722801446915, -0.01455970760434866, 0.04052296653389931, 0.058152567595243454, 0.0003883161989506334, 0.0027896249666810036, 0.040582235902547836, 0.056674160063266754, -0.035708241164684296, -0.047176260501146317, -0.027335014194250107, -0.01619001477956772, 0.0246898103505373, -0.019183862954378128, -0.04644158482551575, 0.030532700940966606, -0.041734565049409866, -0.03584083914756775, 0.024638278409838676, -0.03543337807059288, 0.009038713760674, 0.04137297347187996, 0.019949784502387047, -0.027152951806783676, 0.02686537802219391, -0.04784476384520531, -0.006735434755682945, 0.021472163498401642, 0.04070330411195755, 0.050106123089790344, -0.020995112136006355, 0.01538222748786211, 0.05620704963803291, 0.03890031948685646, 0.010944726876914501, -0.02802021987736225, 0.0373409166932106, -0.02474205382168293, -0.007316332310438156, 0.02534520998597145, -0.014237708412110806, -0.015436998568475246, 0.04742571339011192, -0.017340853810310364, -0.03008718602359295, 0.015285939909517765, -0.02197246253490448, 0.037171538919210434, 0.003768960712477565, -0.02362312376499176, -0.007665687240660191, -0.0419035367667675, 0.050818875432014465, 0.07180332392454147, -0.027110805734992027, -0.03775475546717644, 0.02503865398466587, -0.01216792780905962, -0.028023898601531982, -0.03930048644542694, 0.01800389215350151, 0.05755503848195076, 0.016385408118367195, 0.031607646495103836, 0.025255659595131874, -0.024428891018033028, 0.007414083927869797, -0.015986401587724686, 0.09648053348064423, 0.028300147503614426, 0.05268070846796036, -0.001930381404235959, 0.025918131694197655, -0.019053025171160698, -0.037907399237155914, -0.0036421518307179213, 0.04664206877350807, -0.003700525499880314, -0.05445915833115578, 0.026762904599308968, -0.02093435637652874, -0.0035907558631151915, 0.02536497637629509, -0.019565487280488014, 0.00021433286019600928, -0.0029846306424587965, -0.06891310214996338, -0.042659033089876175, 0.05409068614244461, 0.012435014359652996, 0.025090953335165977, -0.06682014465332031, 0.017518091946840286, 0.026180120185017586, 0.050270307809114456, 0.029542604461312294, -0.0009457432315684855, -0.0060108620673418045, 0.0637112408876419, 0.014154771342873573, -0.008704441599547863, 0.021890053525567055, 0.021950067952275276, -0.03031568042933941, -0.05727329105138779, -0.07730743288993835, 0.02322952076792717, 0.03553922474384308, -0.020061125978827477, -0.011019456200301647, 0.035518839955329895, 0.006387555506080389, -0.017414672300219536, 0.0146584277972579, 0.0524943508207798, -0.015100324526429176, 0.06647764891386032, 0.008724212646484375, 0.002900943160057068, 0.017738396301865578, -0.023434393107891083, 0.01884877309203148, 0.0051881857216358185, 0.021043900400400162, 0.07343895733356476, -0.019636103883385658, 0.014025981537997723, -0.012333606369793415, -0.007937307469546795, -0.0022588332649320364, -0.041770193725824356, 0.009573756717145443, -0.01515976246446371, -0.00916595570743084, 0.024792687967419624, 0.06153789907693863, -0.013275891542434692, 0.004308725707232952, 0.015307119116187096, -0.009391150437295437, -0.0368061289191246, -0.0756063386797905, -0.02945653721690178, -0.0007914337329566479, -0.034479640424251556, 0.02104433998465538, -0.0016980228247120976, -0.017891380935907364, -0.017052454873919487, -0.024110479280352592, 0.02897834964096546, -0.01066451147198677, 0.047991834580898285, -0.05016927048563957, 0.00969643797725439, 0.03476385772228241, 0.06334532797336578, -0.029097728431224823, 0.034493185579776764, -0.02433815598487854, -0.030910871922969818, -0.0008322349167428911, -0.04118560999631882, -0.00821311678737402, 0.01640825718641281, -0.03982321545481682, 0.010147182270884514, 0.0003084958589170128, -0.020864393562078476, 0.032183095812797546, -0.0483042374253273, 0.0696554034948349, 0.10330294817686081, 0.0159493125975132, 0.008616531267762184, -0.011629801243543625, -0.011974024586379528, 0.03526689484715462, 0.023885240778326988, -0.03133713826537132, -0.08961332589387894, -0.013548574410378933, 0.030818549916148186, -0.0020586790051311255, -0.056283507496118546, -0.004697511903941631, 0.0395469069480896, -0.02129664644598961, 0.030895350500941277, 0.05225421115756035, -0.0020817553158849478, -0.03763080760836601, 0.040778644382953644, 0.026847895234823227, 0.000754437583964318, 0.0374327227473259, -0.013961858116090298, 0.023805150762200356, 0.04585710167884827, 0.01610342413187027, 0.022787321358919144, 0.04069758951663971, 0.006884572561830282, -0.024814553558826447, 0.008014637976884842, 0.030767271295189857, 0.04260982200503349, 0.007085343357175589, -0.002295148093253374, -0.0017129358602687716, -0.018703360110521317, -0.017412403598427773, 0.0028451241087168455, -0.016157304868102074, 0.026573846116662025, 0.06157767027616501, -0.040351130068302155, 0.016931816935539246, -0.0005112452781759202, -0.032585110515356064, -0.010151045396924019, -0.05034396052360535, -0.01825723610818386, -0.0286190714687109, -0.009729522280395031, 0.03140293434262276, 0.00883547030389309, 0.028930215165019035, -0.02569044567644596, -0.0039992136880755424, -0.02494586631655693, -0.033030346035957336, 0.00953574851155281, -0.010527988895773888, -0.06776589900255203, 0.004727174527943134, -0.008260898292064667, -0.026129938662052155, 0.013318161480128765, -0.019360944628715515, -0.002523764967918396, 0.023768650367856026, 0.03836815804243088, -0.0532807856798172, -0.002284739399328828, -0.006515683606266975, 0.022714169695973396, -0.012523370794951916, -0.027600795030593872, 0.011885535903275013, -0.0005887411534786224, -0.043771810829639435, 0.04118945077061653, -0.0072305514477193356, -0.02747204713523388, -0.037210214883089066, 0.016150634735822678, 0.01798073947429657, -0.016435610130429268, -0.0165309626609087, 0.0367472842335701, -0.012705289758741856, -0.026576338335871696, -0.06949824839830399, -0.07224203646183014, 0.020436234772205353, -0.018521025776863098, 0.014224170707166195, -0.01844087429344654, -0.032735832035541534, 0.08444586396217346, 0.031111393123865128, -0.0466252826154232, 0.01302957534790039, 0.014889701269567013, -0.03636610135436058, 0.022098593413829803, -0.012922538444399834, -0.010367942973971367, 0.011952714994549751, 0.01161864772439003, 0.0064520882442593575, 0.02282916195690632, 0.054496195167303085, -0.006317392457276583, 0.006525371689349413, 0.008120795711874962, 0.022780636325478554, 0.0070533715188503265, 0.0482991598546505, -0.009725278243422508, -0.04882624372839928, 0.02241954579949379, -0.0198306106030941, 0.01567697525024414, 0.02833578549325466, -0.06563885509967804, 0.026786765083670616, -0.012166385538876057, -0.015651842579245567, -0.014929731376469135, 0.03511904925107956, 0.009350793436169624, -0.012842840515077114, 0.02106904610991478, 0.052051469683647156, 0.028538215905427933, -0.018061641603708267, -0.009205136448144913, 0.06288067996501923, 0.06786411255598068, -0.028750678524374962, -0.04208952188491821, -0.015092430636286736, -0.022296808660030365, -0.0011774193262681365, -0.03184671700000763, -0.0522197000682354, 0.03619237244129181, 0.051741134375333786, 0.011806662194430828, -0.013932578265666962, -0.015913648530840874, 0.008378067053854465, -0.0868624672293663, -0.010907785966992378, -0.020338978618383408, 0.06684789061546326, -0.0005721087218262255, 0.04592888429760933, 0.014944440685212612, 0.007932137697935104, -0.006592677906155586, -0.022206688299775124, -0.04003652185201645, 0.055461909621953964, -0.015315167605876923, -0.04128748178482056, -0.017897706478834152, -0.02203681692481041, 0.023224355652928352, -0.00775093212723732, -0.004466857761144638, -0.015018273144960403, 0.04603101313114166, -0.013272174634039402, 0.005476837977766991, -0.06268784403800964, -0.012045948766171932, -0.01965128257870674, 0.05223700776696205, -0.016747750341892242, -0.03729788586497307, 0.02217925526201725, 0.017264364287257195, -0.013402629643678665, -0.013277996331453323, -0.037361692637205124, 0.0207379087805748, 0.018956100568175316, 0.03583686053752899, 0.0618039146065712, 0.07089637964963913, -0.036727484315633774, 0.061888739466667175, 0.020407794043421745, 0.06326697021722794, 0.028965706005692482, -0.023840146139264107, -0.045316752046346664, -0.0384022481739521, 0.0068700374104082584, 0.004750984255224466, 0.01714622788131237, -0.019223157316446304, -0.01615733467042446, 0.0325908288359642, 0.027030302211642265, -0.037857700139284134, 0.027937697246670723, 0.004066170193254948, -0.01861228235065937, 0.032484736293554306, -0.0559624582529068, 0.00599195109680295, -0.009877174161374569, -0.024742111563682556, 0.061708588153123856, 0.05836479738354683, -0.0038146909791976213, -0.019529327750205994, 0.036681897938251495, 0.022284898906946182, -0.05258621647953987, 0.05296245962381363, 0.008549466729164124, 0.021158089861273766, 0.017183342948555946, -0.023922817781567574, 0.013873004354536533, 0.013806737959384918, 0.05417096987366676, 0.009273113682866096, 0.03305298089981079, -0.05720709636807442, -0.014555995352566242, 0.015782194212079048, 0.04470520094037056, -0.05839381366968155, -0.04604408144950867, -0.020796721801161766, -0.001785770640708506, 0.026119761168956757, -0.03614387661218643, 0.029950274154543877, -0.009211326949298382, 0.03977362811565399, -0.050251785665750504, -0.0005627439823001623, -0.05760272219777107, 0.0339529849588871, -0.0249754898250103, 0.027738215401768684, -0.024840956553816795, -0.019897285848855972, -0.013577585108578205, -0.0026851636357605457, 0.04948783293366432, 0.09280169755220413, -0.02957075834274292, -0.01592644304037094, -0.006755724083632231, 0.004261051770299673, -0.004063740838319063, -0.04848878085613251, 0.018331557512283325, -0.0020865220576524734, -0.025271587073802948, 0.03353234753012657, -0.026663554832339287, -0.011862747371196747, 0.05282680317759514, 0.011895147152245045, -0.006743442267179489, 0.009185191243886948, -0.007637337781488895, 0.025927122682332993, 0.06185869872570038, -0.01825118437409401, 0.06857329607009888, 0.015957755967974663, -0.029663674533367157, 0.012115079909563065, -0.016598133370280266, 0.012768750078976154, -0.010244779288768768, -0.0003754629287868738, -0.04382854327559471, 0.003924839198589325, -0.01501227542757988, 0.017892174422740936, 0.009995857253670692, 0.02983800694346428, -0.02115488238632679, -0.021087603643536568, -0.009057469666004181, -0.005673481151461601, -0.006055946461856365, 0.022076988592743874, -0.014550053514540195, 0.023514095693826675, 0.0025747299659997225, -0.02765691466629505, -0.00831209123134613, -0.018216639757156372, -0.03188095986843109, -0.019327383488416672, -0.06767302006483078, 0.02866586297750473, -0.06076516583561897, -0.023873258382081985, 0.012041750364005566, -0.012600497342646122, 0.04492410644888878, 0.0016634650528430939, 0.013635754585266113, -0.017078550532460213, -0.06720401346683502, -0.004938294645398855, 0.01863088831305504, 0.05331911891698837, 0.036559753119945526, -0.10041272640228271, -0.026020482182502747, -0.011947150342166424, 0.03475691005587578, -0.05639401823282242, -0.024989137426018715, 0.013567446731030941, 0.01964433677494526, -0.01852049119770527, -0.04300936684012413, -0.0300942063331604, -0.005900174379348755, -0.021640222519636154, -0.003651642706245184, 0.05958405137062073, -0.03514844551682472, -0.04430112615227699, 0.0007438426255248487, 0.012419704347848892, 0.0614871010184288, -0.04535209760069847, -0.01063054334372282, -0.015908313915133476, 0.0019681553822010756, -0.005488217808306217, 0.022833893075585365, 0.020955203101038933, -0.0242603812366724, 0.00021683999511878937, -0.016308356076478958, -0.006620034575462341, 0.05676891654729843, -0.04562690481543541, -0.009894044138491154, 0.014689624309539795, 0.019130846485495567, 0.03758014738559723, -0.019324863329529762, -0.011101962998509407, -0.04270439222455025, 0.00981857255101204, -0.035643044859170914, 0.002051320858299732, 0.011118916794657707, 0.0006539511377923191, 0.012163632549345493, 0.014571400359272957, -0.0376444011926651, -0.0010580868693068624, 0.08121474832296371, -0.02940550073981285, 0.01643538661301136, 0.03241020068526268, -0.023653080686926842, 0.03253736346960068, -0.01513515692204237, 0.03816547244787216, 0.023441007360816002, 0.03958940505981445, 0.0030633057467639446, -0.007197643630206585, -0.0328340120613575, 0.011687652207911015, 0.07572893798351288, -0.026187898591160774, 0.06081875413656235, 0.0596623532474041, -0.002998212119564414, -0.004344177432358265, -0.023309076204895973, -0.021305672824382782, -0.014440051279962063, 0.006298680789768696, 0.049995094537734985, -0.03795955702662468, -0.02768109366297722, 0.04927479103207588, 0.033307768404483795, -0.01860255002975464, 0.030449427664279938, 0.0009290974121540785, 0.034988731145858765, 0.02780088596045971, -0.027253182604908943, -0.0375254824757576, 0.029788460582494736, -0.04193173348903656, 0.03382784128189087, -0.017803989350795746, -0.018743807449936867, 0.03844664990901947, 0.02538350410759449, 0.02022790163755417, -0.03476879373192787, -0.019974980503320694, -0.06570059061050415, 0.005579187069088221, -0.0004472574219107628, 0.0012916030827909708, 0.014818140305578709, 0.014808109030127525, 0.02263827994465828, -0.034193556755781174, 0.016548559069633484, -0.01693924330174923, -0.062485143542289734, -0.010719766840338707, -0.040518030524253845, -0.03582630679011345, 0.034585531800985336, 0.004776973742991686, -0.048829685896635056, 0.03712237626314163, -0.01839674822986126, 0.025284543633461, 0.03161522001028061, 0.01376551017165184, -0.02991858310997486, 0.050716981291770935, 0.0023476167116314173, 0.03395688533782959, 0.005999784450978041, -0.015146230347454548, 0.10075855255126953, 0.04612937569618225, 0.03362983465194702, -0.041193749755620956, 0.038567543029785156, -0.0022285806480795145, 0.014849405735731125, 0.0010634202044457197, -0.007470530923455954, 0.04649750143289566, 0.00311064044944942, 0.006392656359821558, 0.04830549657344818, 0.009939789772033691, 0.0030096706468611956, 0.05897726118564606, -0.03927559778094292, -0.019239461049437523, 0.02347908914089203, -0.006852983497083187, 0.008973798714578152, -0.04155299812555313, -0.032615482807159424, 0.0017814163584262133, -0.007224136497825384, 0.0012531073298305273, -0.01077274139970541, 0.0060065994039177895, 0.00920427218079567, -0.00931594893336296, -0.03226855769753456, 0.021884718909859657, 0.012358472682535648, 0.039881493896245956, -0.04728880897164345, 0.016006164252758026, 0.05648479610681534, -0.04996524751186371, 0.00025979906786233187, 0.029224928468465805, 0.023363396525382996, -0.002538900589570403, -0.017431208863854408, 0.02574842795729637, -0.049313291907310486, -0.03266254812479019, -0.06414863467216492, 0.029491670429706573, -0.014059554785490036, -0.017331093549728394, -0.005327627062797546, -0.002629251452162862, -0.03119784966111183, -0.03685219958424568, -0.022151311859488487, 0.026450155302882195, -0.001100222929380834, 0.004244634415954351, -0.028681587427854538, -0.028869908303022385, 0.027559764683246613, -0.03748927265405655, 0.0106967743486166, 0.058308400213718414, -0.0476890429854393, -0.02890094928443432, 0.04343657195568085, 0.04147138446569443, -0.005306139588356018, -0.019392596557736397, -0.02462063543498516, -0.017903165891766548, -0.004643599037081003, 0.015548736788332462, -0.0561116486787796, 0.01289305742830038, 0.022426500916481018, 0.006312000565230846, 0.021867044270038605, 0.02068905718624592, -0.03746645525097847, 0.0282119270414114, -0.019044170156121254, 0.017161507159471512, -0.014202023856341839, -0.016798637807369232, 0.04410776495933533, 0.01086458470672369, -0.0016981821972876787, -0.0068818056024611, 0.014145433902740479, 0.01247335970401764, 0.04144968464970589, -0.04948698729276657, -0.012285090982913971, 0.015690717846155167, -0.046927280724048615, 0.006424144376069307, -0.01758878491818905, 0.060309916734695435, 0.019422372803092003, 0.007897117175161839, 0.019986851140856743, 0.002075695199891925, -0.010232566855847836, 0.03045414388179779, -0.0006216628244146705, -0.04357892647385597, -0.02537725679576397, 0.024935156106948853, -0.01197553426027298, -0.03509632125496864, 0.028542572632431984, -0.022440068423748016, -0.0074259438551962376, 0.040930964052677155, -0.032775506377220154, -0.001706959679722786, -0.022127846255898476, -0.006050494033843279, -0.028042489662766457, -0.00735152792185545, -0.002024970483034849, -0.017149798572063446, -0.04009716585278511, 0.008849134668707848, 0.02805139869451523, -0.023573776707053185, 0.008986849337816238, -0.005045607686042786, 0.005239290185272694, 0.05917114391922951, -0.004935075994580984, 0.02582252398133278, -0.004895150661468506, 0.007138935849070549, 0.018430547788739204, 0.045171912759542465, -0.033322278410196304, -0.016073711216449738, 0.018179431557655334, -0.05997346714138985, -0.06599303334951401, 0.04530874639749527, -0.008937756530940533, 0.016701312735676765, 0.005616202484816313, 0.0007094023749232292, -0.004709417931735516, 0.05821845307946205, -0.018057281151413918, -0.018934277817606926, -0.021364718675613403, 0.0032760147005319595, -0.008408316411077976, -0.018032200634479523, 0.04080578312277794, 0.007942176423966885, 0.023807592689990997, 0.049182210117578506, 0.023289788514375687, -0.02643754333257675, -0.0026514106430113316, -0.025372177362442017, -0.014720977284014225, 0.0006761374534107745, 0.00854464154690504, -0.026652993634343147, 0.042867451906204224, 0.06312888115644455, -0.04057738557457924, -0.009167831391096115, -0.011537175625562668, 0.0006297510117292404, -0.07841667532920837, -0.010409606620669365, 0.002256104489788413, 0.03375294804573059, -0.0001607347949175164, -0.03567277640104294, 0.04199521988630295, 0.02725432999432087, -0.02250862866640091, 0.025246450677514076, -0.012085632421076298, 0.010091442614793777, -0.04035887494683266, -0.026150913909077644, -0.03051787242293358, 0.019460361450910568, 0.02045442909002304, 0.02595197968184948, 0.01825316622853279, 0.018494341522455215, 0.004863804671913385, -0.0024447902105748653, -0.0017918936209753156, 0.027055446058511734, 0.01329749170690775, -0.08921043574810028, 0.017252996563911438, -0.028328683227300644, -0.032279420644044876, 0.02268027886748314, -0.0065574683248996735, 0.0116423349827528, -0.03440181538462639, 0.045938991010189056, -0.02860867790877819, 0.02315186709165573, 0.018909292295575142, 0.0121588334441185, -0.015327750705182552, -0.023188509047031403, 0.021423205733299255, 0.00809919647872448, -0.016469106078147888, 0.01592898927628994, 0.05580325797200203, 0.0015508480137214065, -0.023720256984233856, -0.0012373009230941534, 0.008164250291883945, -0.027854926884174347, -0.0327676460146904, 0.00007635236397618428, 0.035241544246673584, -0.04884360358119011, 0.013149412348866463, -0.03883396461606026, -0.005123399663716555, 0.035716596990823746, 0.001370345475152135, -0.03438293933868408, 0.000005960655016679084, -0.011513812467455864, -0.03256497159600258, 0.006739941891282797, -0.010605469346046448, 0.0075310226529836655, -0.0897439643740654, -0.00390929589048028, 0.010403255932033062, -0.010568208061158657, -0.023744860664010048, -0.019507741555571556, -0.03177764266729355, 0.062272947281599045, -0.005282439757138491, -0.016550786793231964, 0.011667179875075817, 0.026912972331047058, 0.03444854915142059, -0.09870303422212601, 0.032322756946086884, 0.036566030234098434, -0.034538302570581436, -0.053609635680913925, 0.04339051991701126, -0.03474297747015953, 0.028217792510986328, 0.03151505067944527, 0.051209937781095505, -0.014273973181843758, 0.0030389369931071997, 0.031579773873090744, 0.02861752361059189, -0.05030732974410057, 0.026904193684458733, -0.0426892451941967, -0.01599319465458393, -0.003548411652445793, -0.024974016472697258, 0.0011310498230159283, 0.042473454028367996, 0.03304306045174599, 0.002691187197342515, 0.01592758484184742, -0.006321429740637541, 0.020638663321733475, 0.023808568716049194, -0.006083136424422264, -0.02444927580654621, 0.02806156314909458, -0.01149978768080473, 0.013420871458947659, 0.007485661190003157, 0.011936979368329048, -0.0476299412548542, 0.030291948467493057, -0.023826798424124718, -0.02442770078778267, 0.014952295459806919, -0.04824366420507431, -0.007562454789876938, -0.061762791126966476, -0.014657103456556797, 0.01786717027425766, -0.02238648384809494, 0.000336718832841143, 0.019495191052556038, 0.028887540102005005, 0.02656087838113308, 0.023030253127217293, 0.05269745737314224, 0.011685797944664955, -0.007414666935801506, -0.005658417474478483, 0.017676537856459618, 0.052512817084789276, 0.01343847531825304, 0.022293778136372566, 0.031122952699661255, -0.01582159474492073, -0.011613993905484676, 0.02310473658144474, 0.03701494261622429, 0.021854670718312263, -0.018948422744870186, 0.015469271689653397, -0.02590258978307247, -0.0015416302485391498, 0.0029018211644142866, -0.00931650772690773, 0.06560666859149933, -0.02875082939863205, -0.011329617351293564, -0.0313098281621933, 0.01156932208687067, -0.007055444642901421, -0.015641100704669952, 0.013964330777525902, 0.021089769899845123, 0.02864566631615162, -0.0043909684754908085, 0.01695067249238491, -0.007058336865156889, 0.03519992530345917, -0.0003851609362754971, 0.04985048994421959, -0.01796349696815014, 0.00985089410096407, -0.008704841136932373, -0.016819743439555168, -0.014756478369235992, -0.02214331552386284, 0.06612563133239746, 0.02843453921377659, 0.0038163019344210625, -0.01212690956890583, -0.04409527778625488, -0.006572649348527193, 0.029110699892044067, -0.039533115923404694, -0.041505131870508194, -0.02042272686958313, 0.011710867285728455, -0.02255500666797161, -0.03639133647084236 ]
<p>Alright, hopefully third time is the charm. I'm basically trying to build a predictive model with R and gbm. For various reasons, I can't explicitly state exactly what I'm doing. </p> <p>Basically I have a response variable that averages around zero. It has high volatility, is right skewed, and has very high kurtosis. I have a bunch of predictors I think contain information about the response. Some of them are numerical, others factors. I have partitioned available data into three sets 1, 2, 3. What I've done is trained gbm on set 1 with parameters as follows: interaction depth of 10, shrinkage of .001, 3 fold cross validation, about 200000 iterations (maybe overkill), out of bag estimation 50%, and training % at 80%. I've then tested how well the model predicts the responses in set 2 and it's significantly better than chance. The predictors are distributed similarly to the response (similar averages), but the responses have a higher stdev and kurtosis. I then proceed to update the model by training on set 1 + set 2 with the same parameters. I then test on set 3. The predictors now are extremely different from the actual responses (average of 25 for the predictor versus close to 0 for responses). I'm not sure what's causing this. I haven't changed anything so my initial thought was the data in set 2, where the range of the response variable is larger than set 1. How do I narrow down what might be causing this discrepancy with the predictions for set 3?</p> <h2>I realize this is somewhat open-ended, so please let me know what other information would be helpful in answering this question. I'm not sure what exactly you guys might find useful.</h2> <p>answers to comments the data is a time series so just took three time period of about 2 years, 1 year, and 3 months.</p>
31,217
[ -0.00803572777658701, 0.007207633461803198, -0.03300134837627411, 0.016789469867944717, 0.010934471152722836, -0.033050041645765305, -0.010671631433069706, -0.050648096948862076, 0.0498945377767086, -0.02006593346595764, 0.02559405192732811, 0.002900371327996254, 0.051580168306827545, -0.02078041434288025, 0.024728110060095787, -0.027423353865742683, 0.002853084821254015, -0.014195339754223824, 0.035233963280916214, 0.0019235878717154264, -0.010393126867711544, 0.041567232459783554, 0.01770157553255558, -0.023417368531227112, -0.024334469810128212, 0.04254958778619766, 0.02677696943283081, -0.027871374040842056, 0.003777473233640194, 0.0212074127048254, -0.05945165455341339, -0.030178792774677277, -0.012458112090826035, 0.01799255795776844, 0.027438903227448463, -0.005704645533114672, -0.00006733360351063311, -0.05157862976193428, -0.030841941013932228, 0.035626865923404694, -0.0330168642103672, -0.023103732615709305, -0.000189770755241625, 0.04743199422955513, -0.0071293930523097515, -0.03835630416870117, -0.024683360010385513, -0.00033096401602961123, 0.06630317121744156, -0.046941693872213364, 0.06068416312336922, 0.009937570430338383, 0.029149672016501427, 0.0752897709608078, -0.017310624942183495, -0.007342554163187742, 0.049268364906311035, 0.09549030661582947, -0.003364707576110959, -0.028027594089508057, -0.02018742263317108, -0.025527123361825943, -0.010756195522844791, 0.03431520238518715, -0.020331744104623795, 0.03346188738942146, 0.017704514786601067, -0.03690652176737785, 0.017122846096754074, -0.016324535012245178, 0.028122857213020325, 0.02337970770895481, 0.03797675669193268, -0.0013534327736124396, 0.03064718097448349, -0.010255323722958565, -0.03574457764625549, 0.019986964762210846, 0.05720148980617523, 0.016056418418884277, -0.01740710809826851, 0.00670176325365901, -0.0006211792933754623, 0.031055454164743423, 0.017621507868170738, 0.0012140972539782524, 0.057505615055561066, -0.03518125042319298, 0.021295998245477676, 0.039101969450712204, -0.04530169442296028, 0.043844304978847504, 0.05449036881327629, 0.010369215160608292, -0.03844187408685684, 0.05690755322575569, -0.005967667791992426, 0.02972160279750824, -0.006831085309386253, 0.01669532060623169, -0.0052920375019311905, -0.03380937501788139, 0.0404839925467968, 0.046009257435798645, -0.030928274616599083, -0.030345195904374123, -0.040829189121723175, -0.03057130053639412, -0.013696468435227871, -0.03615180402994156, 0.0007422583294101059, 0.06762740015983582, -0.021635329350829124, -0.009572643786668777, 0.018371116369962692, -0.00630338815972209, -0.03592732921242714, -0.028635215014219284, 0.03592682257294655, 0.055525850504636765, 0.012958277948200703, -0.03416034206748009, 0.026085639372467995, -0.034076280891895294, -0.03289243206381798, 0.0013312877854332328, 0.03793734312057495, -0.0506741888821125, -0.014932280406355858, 0.06617003679275513, 0.033847782760858536, -0.019633891060948372, 0.022564267739653587, -0.025804955512285233, 0.0014656089479103684, -0.002523125382140279, -0.07905316352844238, -0.034893300384283066, 0.022746041417121887, -0.018171709030866623, -0.005846619140356779, -0.07207254320383072, -0.03995320573449135, 0.011237145401537418, 0.056285612285137177, -0.0010802942560985684, 0.015324350446462631, 0.014808330684900284, 0.04094961658120155, 0.031105883419513702, -0.01627131924033165, -0.015278592705726624, -0.03329285606741905, 0.02107236348092556, -0.03303930535912514, -0.06320834159851074, 0.021614542230963707, 0.02087540365755558, -0.01239832304418087, -0.004613283555954695, 0.01487269438803196, 0.0005151349469088018, 0.008630345575511456, -0.015453395433723927, 0.04626856744289398, -0.006560118868947029, 0.06584646552801132, 0.04751460626721382, 0.023559588938951492, 0.0440487265586853, 0.011466328985989094, -0.019922349601984024, 0.031460341066122055, 0.04707258939743042, 0.050083961337804794, -0.014192823320627213, 0.04441406950354576, -0.047282516956329346, -0.011782529763877392, -0.0027973849792033434, 0.01512127835303545, 0.007100026123225689, -0.006979058496654034, -0.0337146632373333, 0.002039689105004072, 0.01407722570002079, -0.0076737855561077595, -0.032959531992673874, 0.043503955006599426, -0.03982270881533623, -0.03790467232465744, -0.05835845693945885, -0.025636624544858932, -0.0005845432751812041, -0.01250077411532402, 0.015509911812841892, 0.010448707267642021, 0.040539372712373734, 0.009995270520448685, -0.002696300158277154, -0.01717706397175789, -0.0016632435144856572, 0.02945997752249241, -0.03625354543328285, 0.017888108268380165, 0.06414105743169785, 0.016436027362942696, -0.04535453021526337, 0.03369183465838432, -0.024575117975473404, -0.06056198477745056, 0.0431239977478981, -0.00747338030487299, 0.03988918662071228, -0.040971435606479645, -0.04811832681298256, 0.01485371869057417, -0.015297087840735912, -0.009603315964341164, 0.042211033403873444, -0.06816056370735168, 0.05006392300128937, 0.06843124330043793, -0.026698971167206764, -0.0022437998559325933, -0.0027182926423847675, -0.01476320344954729, 0.04529407247900963, -0.050725169479846954, -0.015412898734211922, -0.05870538577437401, -0.036138031631708145, 0.035672664642333984, -0.0011889206944033504, 0.01437265146523714, 0.04154740646481514, 0.05652172118425369, 0.010910628363490105, 0.0012693213066086173, 0.016344744712114334, 0.029054805636405945, 0.004679462872445583, 0.03616146743297577, 0.010738329030573368, 0.01525556668639183, -0.005675462074577808, 0.030926909297704697, -0.008430366404354572, 0.031878646463155746, 0.0051605976186692715, 0.005226410925388336, 0.04169215261936188, 0.025368371978402138, -0.011221557855606079, -0.05560683459043503, 0.020630212500691414, 0.03782353550195694, -0.013154339045286179, -0.007151831407099962, 0.06279917061328888, 0.027993692085146904, -0.016981206834316254, -0.0024389876052737236, -0.024607447907328606, 0.02117324434220791, 0.028696797788143158, -0.025386132299900055, 0.012850315310060978, 0.01314000878483057, -0.059445299208164215, 0.004773180931806564, -0.002824855735525489, -0.012291647493839264, -0.050692662596702576, 0.004478774964809418, 0.020691024139523506, 0.007196403574198484, 0.05687619745731354, -0.04336199536919594, -0.010384788736701012, 0.023069998249411583, -0.000015264407920767553, 0.05177265778183937, -0.009893320500850677, -0.054531075060367584, 0.02098933793604374, 0.00007811120303813368, 0.025813961401581764, 0.01369823794811964, 0.003769733477383852, -0.020413510501384735, 0.01591511443257332, -0.00010956655023619533, -0.054406654089689255, -0.016524706035852432, -0.06060541421175003, 0.020959587767720222, 0.0009089357336051762, -0.019314495846629143, 0.051237739622592926, 0.016572464257478714, -0.013898898847401142, 0.036823879927396774, 0.001849562395364046, 0.023261068388819695, -0.04362432286143303, -0.0001792835828382522, 0.023116353899240494, -0.012411440722644329, 0.0035633728839457035, 0.019307272508740425, -0.0040995050221681595, -0.01436559297144413, -0.06650198996067047, -0.06497593969106674, 0.010382457636296749, 0.017085913568735123, 0.0021267561241984367, -0.022139674052596092, 0.01192558091133833, 0.057425033301115036, 0.03758133947849274, 0.0001995934289880097, -0.025761913508176804, -0.020212024450302124, -0.024892548099160194, -0.03783676028251648, 0.03010598011314869, 0.0176850575953722, 0.03978234529495239, 0.03964515030384064, -0.003239400452002883, 0.024346185848116875, 0.03483683243393898, -0.012947903014719486, -0.0402681864798069, 0.03398970142006874, 0.003723442554473877, 0.0035237432457506657, 0.030332596972584724, -0.005747905466705561, -0.0031746209133416414, -0.009329346008598804, 0.007278775796294212, 0.012535358779132366, 0.002045355038717389, -0.05770188942551613, 0.01650424487888813, -0.007239411119371653, 0.03768002614378929, -0.008886572904884815, 0.016018647700548172, 0.0112064303830266, -0.0564211905002594, -0.03252774477005005, 0.029596561565995216, 0.06491398066282272, -0.010434609837830067, 0.027332352474331856, 0.05678557977080345, -0.012759204022586346, -0.0388219878077507, -0.008420990779995918, -0.0006628058617934585, -0.03541715815663338, 0.01779812201857567, -0.005547943525016308, 0.005063892807811499, 0.04155953973531723, 0.028889397159218788, 0.015834998339414597, -0.03617612272500992, -0.049293145537376404, 0.015849128365516663, -0.07846897840499878, 0.027368471026420593, -0.03186682239174843, 0.040883034467697144, 0.008693063631653786, 0.01662532053887844, 0.0421321801841259, -0.014824115671217442, 0.010353941470384598, 0.009845316410064697, -0.07267583906650543, 0.062422607094049454, 0.017369592562317848, -0.010124541819095612, -0.01847601868212223, -0.041390273720026016, 0.04638134315609932, 0.006840779446065426, -0.0021880283020436764, -0.01000168826431036, 0.02427419275045395, -0.06290784478187561, -0.009865100495517254, -0.05287623032927513, 0.0063624330796301365, 0.0037356731481850147, 0.02045675367116928, -0.010558940470218658, -0.004334770608693361, 0.03872805833816528, 0.06953570991754532, 0.006614476442337036, -0.009025823324918747, -0.02988881804049015, 0.038689978420734406, 0.028072116896510124, 0.05919227749109268, 0.05048888176679611, 0.011981097050011158, -0.06844662129878998, 0.04349549859762192, 0.036784086376428604, 0.02501915581524372, 0.05386732891201973, -0.0001918806810863316, -0.008474673144519329, -0.03952408209443092, -0.04305262863636017, 0.053531114012002945, -0.010897397063672543, 0.026946183294057846, 0.016544580459594727, 0.04907041788101196, 0.024360764771699905, -0.04483597353100777, 0.005775693338364363, 0.04271179437637329, 0.007495324593037367, 0.007149549666792154, -0.04515465721487999, -0.015078149735927582, 0.008976954966783524, -0.025345126166939735, 0.059321071952581406, -0.023516874760389328, -0.0018064031610265374, -0.0057642594911158085, 0.0457732118666172, -0.03597293794155121, -0.023389635607600212, -0.011509230360388756, 0.03178352117538452, 0.0310811847448349, 0.012426711618900299, 0.00039108519558794796, -0.009174049831926823, 0.03138124942779541, 0.04801381379365921, 0.005211774725466967, 0.01999080367386341, -0.08728918433189392, -0.0220321174710989, 0.03423572704195976, 0.011128450743854046, -0.06408783793449402, -0.02859661355614662, -0.050357840955257416, -0.013557245954871178, -0.015390346758067608, -0.043311648070812225, 0.01754075475037098, 0.0038706737104803324, 0.01511156652122736, -0.017183158546686172, -0.03837450593709946, -0.05029350146651268, -0.0017054973868653178, -0.050930287688970566, 0.045235536992549896, 0.013370517641305923, -0.030119428411126137, -0.01485657412558794, 0.013072502799332142, 0.02263401634991169, 0.07767048478126526, -0.027267739176750183, -0.013195808045566082, 0.019372981041669846, 0.011683780699968338, 0.022913821041584015, -0.04775578901171684, 0.02781941369175911, -0.023108644410967827, -0.02171860635280609, 0.06100374460220337, -0.032820090651512146, -0.05351103097200394, 0.021728865802288055, 0.042528100311756134, -0.020590761676430702, -0.0505867563188076, -0.004784010350704193, 0.020190393552184105, 0.03575371205806732, -0.007472270168364048, 0.07366761565208435, 0.014430740848183632, -0.003965205047279596, 0.004521683789789677, -0.05281024053692818, 0.024799557402729988, -0.040696028620004654, -0.027741095051169395, -0.01505523081868887, -0.034111861139535904, -0.019635526463389397, 0.035022933036088943, 0.02195596508681774, 0.03851243481040001, -0.04038771241903305, -0.014257857576012611, 0.029631828889250755, 0.008355222642421722, -0.01819603517651558, 0.010376622900366783, 0.017172932624816895, -0.0007531089941039681, -0.013527787290513515, 0.0222274549305439, 0.01808193325996399, -0.0291240643709898, -0.011809173971414566, 0.02934628166258335, -0.04017728567123413, 0.016755634918808937, -0.014149140566587448, -0.0002506292948964983, -0.0064693414606153965, -0.02003619819879532, 0.03127048537135124, 0.004096397198736668, 0.02743169292807579, 0.01567935384809971, -0.01737077906727791, 0.010670053772628307, -0.015850961208343506, -0.007206421345472336, 0.03539546579122543, -0.015411102212965488, -0.008226248435676098, -0.010438446886837482, 0.026561027392745018, -0.06771418452262878, -0.053279049694538116, 0.036187537014484406, 0.011470641009509563, -0.011728408746421337, -0.019269568845629692, 0.005231375806033611, -0.010575000196695328, 0.00427999859675765, -0.010331227444112301, 0.046008963137865067, 0.0007521758088842034, -0.02274148538708687, 0.013247888535261154, 0.04142818972468376, 0.06021427735686302, -0.023582998663187027, -0.0011683814227581024, 0.036482471972703934, 0.010839030146598816, -0.0580098032951355, -0.009028108790516853, 0.015399823896586895, -0.04394090548157692, -0.01938244141638279, 0.01905653066933155, 0.01549475733190775, 0.060049645602703094, -0.0245289895683527, -0.03664780408143997, 0.0031463075429201126, -0.03045056201517582, 0.05594741180539131, -0.005204458720982075, 0.00039131828816607594, -0.003330795094370842, -0.018960274755954742, -0.035945143550634384, 0.001094076200388372, -0.03130147233605385, -0.02011585235595703, 0.025248272344470024, 0.0036322148516774178, -0.03581595793366432, 0.02814057469367981, 0.08106622099876404, 0.03439098596572876, -0.003261695383116603, 0.00391128845512867, -0.03842150792479515, 0.05005130171775818, 0.007914557121694088, 0.01504615880548954, 0.010991296730935574, 0.045831046998500824, -0.0631982833147049, -0.026487618684768677, -0.0026819014456123114, 0.0009446924668736756, 0.09569685161113739, -0.05093592405319214, 0.046826720237731934, 0.012194167822599411, -0.021647334098815918, 0.0017036584904417396, -0.05346217378973961, 0.005039421375840902, -0.025457844138145447, -0.012035265564918518, 0.052350446581840515, -0.025722356513142586, 0.018845966085791588, 0.02514607645571232, -0.006377835292369127, 0.01635560765862465, 0.014588681980967522, 0.011239632964134216, 0.011221421882510185, 0.03802875801920891, -0.03225138783454895, -0.045813821256160736, 0.02356499806046486, -0.00846888031810522, 0.0001838897733250633, -0.019959527999162674, 0.012187059968709946, 0.037120476365089417, 0.05873402580618858, -0.002577617997303605, -0.039710283279418945, -0.025518007576465607, -0.04286346584558487, 0.016381897032260895, 0.035889770835638046, -0.03474820405244827, 0.03305662423372269, -0.0025196103379130363, 0.01520994771271944, 0.03272085264325142, 0.02165580913424492, -0.018816381692886353, -0.08846130222082138, -0.0056000156328082085, -0.032775383442640305, -0.018571021035313606, 0.029426664113998413, -0.0066230264492332935, -0.011122935451567173, 0.0269345510751009, -0.038561731576919556, 0.0006915356498211622, -0.00546648632735014, -0.024534525349736214, -0.016783976927399635, 0.05923127755522728, 0.012792807072401047, 0.007191631011664867, -0.0047019110061228275, -0.01688869670033455, 0.11501163989305496, 0.04378586262464523, 0.039362214505672455, -0.06446376442909241, -0.007325255777686834, 0.015625646337866783, -0.02244068682193756, -0.02068917453289032, -0.001415979815647006, 0.008674073964357376, -0.017727522179484367, -0.007093249354511499, 0.03684036433696747, 0.009873639792203903, 0.013535819947719574, 0.050314031541347504, -0.03664257377386093, 0.005293132737278938, 0.02440783381462097, 0.01910487376153469, 0.026815958321094513, -0.05792952701449394, -0.04615166410803795, 0.021809570491313934, -0.0161104965955019, 0.01576266624033451, -0.008581886067986488, -0.011682793498039246, -0.01218741200864315, 0.023124827072024345, -0.013646215200424194, 0.016850890591740608, -0.016844311729073524, 0.009440229274332523, 0.01540803536772728, 0.024457817897200584, 0.015575943514704704, -0.013175996020436287, 0.01256139948964119, -0.009039847180247307, -0.016716118901968002, 0.012264808639883995, 0.008784716948866844, 0.006717358250170946, -0.04583721607923508, -0.04109692573547363, -0.02597767300903797, 0.057341065257787704, 0.004123206250369549, -0.03576832264661789, 0.009043042548000813, -0.0055888039059937, -0.002129307249560952, -0.03922998160123825, -0.010779092088341713, 0.048994507640600204, 0.0026302619371563196, -0.05675720050930977, -0.04336950182914734, 0.0014111538184806705, 0.028545886278152466, -0.017572572454810143, 0.05468963831663132, -0.008056795224547386, -0.01643112674355507, 0.009901192039251328, -0.015371176414191723, 0.058579228818416595, 0.024523302912712097, 0.003009821055456996, 0.021170981228351593, -0.03761076182126999, -0.031636133790016174, -0.018251949921250343, 0.005339632276445627, -0.004668197128921747, 0.007579721510410309, -0.04498588666319847, -0.014684638939797878, -0.028806164860725403, -0.04907141625881195, 0.007763843517750502, -0.04096731171011925, 0.0217637587338686, -0.05200839415192604, -0.04045422747731209, -0.0016963263042271137, 0.03118068166077137, 0.03791379556059837, 0.03125648573040962, -0.020803356543183327, 0.05460480973124504, 0.0060344901867210865, -0.06312467157840729, -0.02399565652012825, 0.012564605101943016, -0.05385490506887436, -0.007067972794175148, 0.0012069068616256118, 0.058670587837696075, -0.024446025490760803, 0.014004885219037533, -0.007170373108237982, 0.02950378693640232, -0.02097921073436737, 0.020695967599749565, 0.018405884504318237, -0.03464406728744507, 0.011536050587892532, 0.01121030654758215, -0.020246310159564018, -0.020424893125891685, -0.029206860810518265, -0.01806335523724556, -0.040659189224243164, 0.019226517528295517, -0.013394295237958431, -0.024968115612864494, -0.006527322810143232, -0.009675508365035057, 0.019986815750598907, -0.004546113312244415, -0.02417133003473282, -0.05936148017644882, 0.0007579860975965858, -0.03292310610413551, -0.03437337651848793, 0.016521835699677467, 0.00653846887871623, -0.023016473278403282, -0.029737602919340134, 0.0307353213429451, -0.005923593882471323, 0.023762447759509087, 0.002262513618916273, 0.004478110931813717, 0.013222265988588333, 0.04280282184481621, -0.02262229658663273, -0.04914530739188194, 0.054554760456085205, -0.02072715200483799, -0.056040775030851364, 0.018677877262234688, 0.001106548123061657, 0.03585178405046463, -0.007200748194009066, -0.005859308876097202, -0.03463456407189369, 0.08253695070743561, -0.016111185774207115, 0.0014810824068263173, -0.003774910233914852, 0.027929099276661873, -0.0028031684923917055, 0.0037402957677841187, 0.004351126961410046, 0.022192703559994698, 0.030067482963204384, 0.00312131829559803, 0.021184762939810753, 0.01577731966972351, 0.0013635989744216204, 0.005320654716342688, -0.0429198332130909, 0.011515644378960133, 0.005939023569226265, 0.009835981763899326, 0.00899405125528574, 0.06667577475309372, -0.03676687180995941, 0.0531000979244709, -0.02540764771401882, 0.02543492801487446, -0.06295176595449448, -0.016020769253373146, -0.012950785458087921, -0.010028594173491001, 0.013663782738149166, -0.04940275475382805, 0.017959166318178177, 0.013521842658519745, -0.030133118852972984, 0.02533501759171486, -0.011663143523037434, -0.015821445733308792, -0.029912028461694717, -0.01353935431689024, -0.015076292678713799, -0.017392151057720184, 0.03357744589447975, -0.0018582522170618176, 0.053108811378479004, 0.02870776318013668, -0.0320340059697628, -0.017130054533481598, -0.018227936699986458, 0.031211916357278824, -0.0004858443862758577, -0.04223395884037018, -0.0018538471776992083, -0.022502576932311058, -0.02841290645301342, 0.008732759393751621, -0.024286527186632156, -0.012115883640944958, 0.028046315535902977, -0.003676404245197773, 0.022617939859628677, 0.05358375236392021, 0.049791887402534485, -0.013750551268458366, 0.024491479620337486, -0.011014964431524277, 0.004819110501557589, 0.013481445610523224, -0.024131493642926216, 0.011452911421656609, 0.006647439673542976, -0.011765573173761368, 0.0076210652478039265, 0.002263852395117283, -0.0296492800116539, -0.017396990209817886, -0.0021823833230882883, 0.05083560571074486, 0.0008119349367916584, -0.0554732121527195, 0.02283497340977192, -0.0630507543683052, -0.030261633917689323, 0.03327925130724907, 0.0283709354698658, -0.02372310310602188, 0.023546015843749046, -0.04287460446357727, -0.0106359226629138, -0.014311238192021847, 0.018397891893982887, 0.01595967635512352, -0.0271578598767519, -0.038483627140522, -0.0012390996562317014, 0.009775860235095024, -0.03598839044570923, -0.008173007518053055, -0.07028542459011078, 0.05649863928556442, -0.02803127095103264, 0.026794318109750748, 0.01947624608874321, -0.005164095666259527, -0.010681365616619587, -0.09688970446586609, 0.07605291903018951, -0.001027270220220089, -0.03794058412313461, -0.01235194131731987, -0.01661001332104206, -0.04761272668838501, -0.01101747341454029, 0.03784787654876709, -0.010173602029681206, -0.002250448800623417, -0.004007038660347462, 0.02548055723309517, 0.002196436282247305, -0.02482711523771286, 0.05875436216592789, 0.006174280308187008, -0.022400572896003723, -0.0020391365978866816, -0.025272604078054428, 0.02523876167833805, 0.007293718867003918, 0.003810273250564933, -0.03006487898528576, 0.025251729413866997, -0.0024727110285311937, 0.002096109790727496, 0.041569050401449203, -0.008510463871061802, 0.013575483113527298, 0.047582563012838364, -0.01487403642386198, 0.02951010689139366, 0.014196256175637245, 0.01962512917816639, -0.07264126092195511, 0.04405940696597099, -0.027747182175517082, -0.019623251631855965, -0.030226971954107285, 0.036950889974832535, 0.017278533428907394, -0.04337865114212036, 0.008793485350906849, 0.01723635010421276, -0.0058331661857664585, 0.035193540155887604, 0.05318652093410492, 0.005956558510661125, 0.0012476186966523528, 0.0014452836476266384, 0.015876641497015953, -0.01772727072238922, -0.0007729827193543315, -0.014772321097552776, 0.010785326361656189, 0.025463392958045006, 0.03540407866239548, 0.01939353160560131, 0.048578500747680664, -0.05179845541715622, 0.008758611977100372, 0.00010596025094855577, 0.030336780473589897, -0.022061189636588097, 0.00388534227386117, 0.008282486349344254, -0.0019341455772519112, -0.020976150408387184, -0.02813410758972168, 0.02102823741734028, 0.035501521080732346, -0.04466165229678154, -0.03003764897584915, -0.016586679965257645, -0.01175007876008749, 0.01857517659664154, 0.03251784294843674, 0.030606940388679504, 0.004389914218336344, 0.04535173997282982, 0.01849629543721676, 0.0017876647179946303, -0.0024422563146799803, 0.023844672366976738, 0.0006285683484748006, -0.02547394298017025, 0.00549370376393199, 0.021579518914222717, -0.03955238685011864, -0.051216647028923035, -0.015028540045022964, -0.04755490645766258, 0.01497666910290718, 0.03946573659777641, 0.0055631608702242374, -0.07912376523017883, -0.0006716958014294505, -0.02221560850739479, 0.058813754469156265, -0.05255480483174324, 0.024926437065005302, -0.055582303553819656, 0.01573886349797249, 0.021043702960014343, -0.012813928537070751 ]
<p>I read in <a href="http://www2.sas.com/proceedings/sugi30/203-30.pdf" rel="nofollow">this paper</a> (page 3) comparing pca to factor analysis that both methods need a number of observations about 5 times the number of variables. Why? and how would you reduce the number of variables if you have few observations only? </p>
73,942
[ -0.037333447486162186, 0.030097950249910355, -0.002397482981905341, -0.009396656416356564, 0.05713549628853798, -0.005144615191966295, -0.017851410433650017, -0.023787472397089005, 0.029974084347486496, -0.024520182982087135, 0.006960337981581688, 0.029640674591064453, 0.02700585499405861, 0.03112945519387722, -0.00476212939247489, 0.011224023066461086, -0.0035367412492632866, 0.04083261638879776, -0.011844851076602936, 0.022128218784928322, -0.006851044483482838, 0.03351638838648796, 0.01863565854728222, -0.039776112884283066, 0.009860818274319172, 0.050751082599163055, 0.017429249361157417, -0.021705256775021553, 0.039082854986190796, 0.03200199082493782, -0.0029545631259679794, 0.004059161525219679, 0.005776182748377323, 0.04537009820342064, 0.018462078645825386, -0.03379342332482338, -0.015392021276056767, -0.01328172069042921, 0.022428616881370544, 0.05062760040163994, -0.028912799432873726, -0.02759268879890442, 0.003694068407639861, 0.003748454852029681, -0.019483858719468117, 0.02222515270113945, 0.007396616041660309, -0.04175271466374397, 0.0181872621178627, -0.05295689404010773, 0.08145131170749664, 0.02284739725291729, 0.03818802535533905, 0.023026010021567345, -0.023124635219573975, 0.0118976766243577, 0.054930612444877625, 0.0598105750977993, -0.030011290684342384, -0.06484869867563248, -0.014320331625640392, -0.0007046489045023918, -0.007250106427818537, -0.02847173810005188, -0.041637733578681946, 0.010955419391393661, -0.007862009108066559, -0.027421025559306145, 0.0051397220231592655, 0.012183650396764278, 0.04233090206980705, -0.03583167865872383, 0.052669256925582886, -0.012505722232162952, -0.02505592443048954, -0.017209619283676147, 0.010006576776504517, -0.008196558803319931, 0.038824521005153656, 0.04083038866519928, 0.010493798181414604, 0.013510286808013916, 0.013611935079097748, 0.0015170800033956766, 0.002761014737188816, -0.008379432372748852, 0.0625104084610939, -0.04201217368245125, -0.004407108761370182, 0.00249976827763021, -0.02093280665576458, 0.025285299867391586, 0.05625050887465477, 0.013883871957659721, -0.026468511670827866, 0.01982256956398487, 0.002692457288503647, 0.03707089275121689, 0.018381617963314056, -0.0044252448715269566, -0.01098041981458664, -0.03130163624882698, 0.015217287465929985, 0.04739648476243019, -0.029776915907859802, 0.00565686309710145, -0.021952413022518158, 0.02200590819120407, -0.006440105848014355, -0.02204013802111149, -0.010582329705357552, 0.0063560097478330135, 0.009319846518337727, -0.001214082702063024, 0.014154281467199326, 0.008691534399986267, 0.002028945367783308, 0.005242417100816965, 0.06925030797719955, 0.09117904305458069, 0.03174518421292305, -0.03744545206427574, -0.02464345283806324, -0.0063332258723676205, -0.03930750489234924, -0.007283526938408613, -0.007024525199085474, -0.005702694412320852, -0.034176602959632874, 0.05172458291053772, -0.0065512992441654205, -0.005024071782827377, 0.06958063691854477, 0.0035898499190807343, -0.005581794772297144, 0.011268960312008858, -0.11486716568470001, -0.01856510154902935, 0.03675851598381996, -0.03234948590397835, 0.014560109935700893, -0.07201025635004044, 0.02668638527393341, 0.004061852116137743, 0.05645950138568878, -0.023853465914726257, 0.02910378947854042, 0.0390385165810585, 0.04743616282939911, 0.010173930786550045, -0.042576901614665985, -0.015571077354252338, -0.04037608206272125, -0.03330408036708832, -0.03834160417318344, -0.07350900769233704, 0.03459542617201805, 0.033658262342214584, -0.0014816353796049953, -0.003840377787128091, 0.0008592835511080921, 0.005882589146494865, -0.02891938015818596, -0.01992122270166874, 0.011373305693268776, -0.011842123232781887, 0.02356830984354019, -0.028160735964775085, 0.03324957937002182, 0.04983282834291458, -0.0192412119358778, 0.022991178557276726, 0.009737756103277206, 0.0505031980574131, 0.038389209657907486, 0.011120564304292202, -0.03610343858599663, 0.02643703483045101, 0.019895706325769424, 0.017751937732100487, -0.06426984816789627, -0.02281968481838703, 0.021904584020376205, 0.0195512305945158, 0.03809204697608948, 0.07594949007034302, -0.0018374125938862562, -0.028750257566571236, 0.02821844071149826, -0.03459608554840088, -0.0638100877404213, -0.08328425884246826, 0.017476273700594902, -0.0010137043427675962, -0.011387865990400314, 0.029907826334238052, 0.0201504398137331, -0.027141867205500603, 0.012484943494200706, -0.03927503526210785, -0.026882797479629517, -0.02039712481200695, 0.041371848434209824, -0.07513639330863953, -0.011216782964766026, 0.02281877212226391, 0.0423862598836422, -0.0022682170383632183, 0.05074536055326462, -0.03890136629343033, -0.0470232255756855, 0.030964484438300133, -0.034937355667352676, 0.025532882660627365, -0.019030457362532616, -0.01840253546833992, 0.022231027483940125, 0.008369125425815582, -0.04477821663022041, 0.05976470559835434, -0.041499413549900055, 0.057619359344244, 0.0534704364836216, -0.0033793977927416563, 0.01592588610947132, -0.011880327016115189, 0.018419280648231506, 0.003402798669412732, -0.006469784304499626, -0.007210801355540752, -0.04622388258576393, -0.0016543808160349727, 0.055464211851358414, 0.014317968860268593, -0.049665868282318115, 0.002979379380121827, 0.06407856196165085, 0.06360998749732971, 0.008200487121939659, 0.03380146250128746, 0.0032002355437725782, -0.021891864016652107, 0.005266040563583374, 0.0582319013774395, -0.015809083357453346, 0.011879421770572662, -0.006154526956379414, 0.0019370010122656822, 0.02894272282719612, 0.028556406497955322, -0.017098654061555862, 0.0702836886048317, -0.00573727348819375, 0.027002790942788124, 0.011054901406168938, 0.003637125249952078, 0.046722661703825, -0.031726304441690445, 0.017691774293780327, 0.04181276634335518, 0.021520910784602165, -0.00041131177567876875, -0.0009909694781526923, -0.011585243046283722, -0.0016742456937208772, 0.03222488611936569, -0.056758951395750046, 0.009083637967705727, 0.000506215903442353, -0.0463520772755146, -0.027278795838356018, -0.05437936261296272, -0.00834605097770691, -0.0351702943444252, 0.02070668712258339, 0.031384337693452835, -0.0029801225755363703, 0.0597630999982357, -0.022764863446354866, -0.024551253765821457, 0.01930377632379532, -0.015146667137742043, 0.013091862201690674, 0.0015708087012171745, -0.05407025292515755, 0.004104401916265488, -0.016180401667952538, 0.007640608586370945, 0.03555507957935333, -0.04691309854388237, 0.0020545097067952156, 0.013821160420775414, -0.025717444717884064, -0.05590856075286865, -0.01707625202834606, 0.006690992042422295, 0.03226281702518463, -0.005764841567724943, -0.034274086356163025, 0.018175490200519562, 0.021674035117030144, -0.03143301606178284, -0.04819098114967346, -0.034268464893102646, -0.032389190047979355, -0.035943880677223206, -0.015660414472222328, 0.010422787629067898, -0.01653236150741577, -0.01174756046384573, 0.05434103682637215, -0.02156049758195877, 0.00791536271572113, -0.04235347360372543, -0.06063328683376312, 0.012195993214845657, 0.024260204285383224, 0.04335549846291542, -0.008046211674809456, -0.009840225800871849, 0.0716414675116539, -0.010443968698382378, -0.029965007677674294, -0.0524614118039608, -0.007055758498609066, -0.05708201602101326, -0.003149778349325061, -0.0022601408418267965, 0.026540350168943405, 0.01625732146203518, 0.03427371010184288, -0.0327579528093338, -0.021115103736519814, 0.08364637941122055, 0.026601841673254967, 0.008278096094727516, -0.007876602001488209, 0.020833570510149002, -0.007004891987890005, 0.018242040649056435, 0.023466240614652634, -0.054546814411878586, -0.0071235354989767075, 0.016693631187081337, 0.013404357247054577, -0.0032950760796666145, 0.000933371891733259, -0.010357268154621124, -0.05443741753697395, 0.03322077542543411, -0.038199909031391144, -0.03975345566868782, 0.0017211934318765998, -0.015213506296277046, 0.009710608050227165, 0.028102774173021317, 0.04353614151477814, -0.06816502660512924, -0.03079298511147499, 0.03504776209592819, 0.019050126895308495, 0.002411650260910392, 0.012171415612101555, -0.004111550282686949, -0.016612429171800613, 0.019523853436112404, 0.016714541241526604, 0.00799337774515152, 0.05124680697917938, 0.03459089249372482, 0.034699589014053345, 0.015756193548440933, -0.03767196834087372, 0.02547893114387989, -0.07475653290748596, 0.018209990113973618, -0.022567126899957657, 0.05419879034161568, 0.0037007310893386602, 0.05122509226202965, 0.0008185574552044272, -0.022699715569615364, -0.03685848042368889, -0.013752998784184456, -0.08362351357936859, -0.043765027076005936, -0.03158853203058243, 0.02516232430934906, 0.011863294057548046, -0.007344046141952276, 0.04206160083413124, -0.0019734471570700407, 0.008361764252185822, -0.021509720012545586, 0.03233001008629799, -0.040761951357126236, 0.0069724745117127895, -0.012264778837561607, 0.036091890186071396, -0.008331391029059887, 0.010039291344583035, 0.05220318213105202, -0.03133614361286163, 0.04322439432144165, 0.01812148652970791, -0.0330347865819931, -0.029014630243182182, -0.03824394568800926, -0.005646882113069296, 0.028316760435700417, 0.045385971665382385, -0.026585068553686142, 0.04808000475168228, -0.0045245056971907616, 0.020271625369787216, -0.00718813668936491, 0.02802935242652893, 0.021097712218761444, -0.009304859675467014, -0.015416553243994713, -0.029392367228865623, -0.016569696366786957, -0.00041982074617408216, 0.017664484679698944, -0.02689814195036888, 0.0021543249022215605, 0.01941058039665222, -0.0026727220974862576, -0.028689447790384293, 0.008726154454052448, 0.057624660432338715, 0.029418397694826126, 0.008616862818598747, -0.03346606343984604, -0.0031329321209341288, -0.00041419779881834984, -0.029758697375655174, 0.044577330350875854, 0.00588202802464366, -0.00026933482149615884, -0.032108355313539505, 0.0511629693210125, -0.04796247184276581, -0.023565685376524925, 0.019740769639611244, 0.036373112350702286, 0.033392541110515594, 0.0016878293827176094, -0.009229259565472603, 0.019483720883727074, 0.06605713069438934, 0.041539594531059265, 0.019118834286928177, -0.009137443266808987, -0.058718398213386536, -0.007575378753244877, 0.02193203940987587, 0.03888886794447899, -0.050205398350954056, 0.024886105209589005, -0.042036041617393494, 0.005903369747102261, 0.023714272305369377, -0.053247835487127304, 0.03636614978313446, -0.0264664925634861, 0.031032545492053032, -0.026447195559740067, -0.02761487476527691, -0.03621111810207367, -0.011413510888814926, -0.0005762895452789962, 0.0363488532602787, -0.007963082753121853, -0.03519732132554054, -0.03828904405236244, -0.0034919241443276405, 0.019589001312851906, 0.06351987272500992, 0.005566172301769257, -0.01717580296099186, 0.011516080237925053, 0.04468519985675812, -0.02854040637612343, -0.057408541440963745, 0.028047986328601837, 0.005376086570322514, -0.003236151998862624, 0.0672464445233345, -0.031630486249923706, -0.07275225967168808, -0.021731950342655182, 0.0022559522185474634, -0.003679538145661354, -0.012833407148718834, -0.02941420115530491, 0.04438396915793419, 0.018014132976531982, 0.0037310002371668816, 0.09316308051347733, -0.007705075666308403, -0.011125490069389343, 0.004608520772308111, -0.020710689947009087, 0.008187218569219112, -0.041532013565301895, -0.02390703186392784, -0.02784181945025921, 0.0003694043552968651, -0.0015573608689010143, 0.032894764095544815, 0.0039921957068145275, 0.033063556998968124, -0.01622605323791504, -0.025634991005063057, -0.0012050995137542486, 0.023309500887989998, 0.006657001096755266, 0.030323723331093788, -0.022538529708981514, 0.03155974671244621, 0.007579382508993149, -0.03181897848844528, 0.03496687114238739, -0.005331879481673241, -0.004192279186099768, 0.014216846786439419, 0.009021558798849583, -0.018010593950748444, -0.038180749863386154, -0.058841072022914886, -0.0003270848246756941, -0.014943677932024002, 0.046689242124557495, -0.0423554889857769, 0.0510106198489666, 0.0347399078309536, -0.07277478277683258, 0.010441186837852001, 0.024042541161179543, -0.009942619130015373, 0.015303052961826324, -0.04624076187610626, 0.05582782253623009, -0.047063250094652176, -0.033819589763879776, -0.06055937334895134, -0.06285516172647476, 0.009477237239480019, 0.003653612919151783, -0.0187296811491251, -0.038889482617378235, 0.0011582043953239918, -0.02270613983273506, -0.041050881147384644, -0.027239860966801643, 0.041298653930425644, -0.06369881331920624, -0.028345977887511253, 0.022653792053461075, 0.025001130998134613, 0.05117371678352356, 0.007653701119124889, -0.02020743303000927, 0.0033936563413590193, -0.03233279287815094, -0.001807977445423603, -0.009873953647911549, -0.000606438668910414, -0.021007739007472992, -0.021853197365999222, -0.029004918411374092, -0.01801265962421894, 0.011624894104897976, -0.003999378066509962, 0.013088020496070385, -0.01193537563085556, -0.020528988912701607, -0.000387286941986531, -0.018537333235144615, -0.0030768699944019318, -0.010151169262826443, 0.020675795152783394, -0.02101714536547661, 0.011792972683906555, -0.02410060353577137, 0.02230072394013405, 0.007757880724966526, 0.014683704823255539, 0.0022279308177530766, 0.041152071207761765, 0.047335099428892136, -0.014659484848380089, 0.0453437939286232, -0.016184864565730095, 0.0020577821414917707, 0.03493542969226837, 0.03509657084941864, 0.026335643604397774, 0.009650553576648235, 0.011967579834163189, -0.02625378407537937, -0.04429544135928154, -0.02289603464305401, -0.0014459382509812713, 0.04200950264930725, 0.0205977875739336, 0.036660853773355484, 0.061037078499794006, -0.02993091195821762, -0.006488753017038107, -0.03998999670147896, 0.007886193692684174, 0.013662426732480526, 0.011352547444403172, 0.06409872323274612, -0.023412857204675674, -0.035914670675992966, 0.04029104858636856, 0.03134196251630783, 0.037427689880132675, 0.04965481162071228, 0.014433508738875389, 0.036059994250535965, -0.007677108980715275, -0.03860284015536308, -0.060124121606349945, 0.01955125853419304, -0.027320653200149536, 0.012793069705367088, -0.010574180632829666, -0.031210800632834435, 0.04503900930285454, 0.015893766656517982, -0.009419882670044899, -0.07986033707857132, -0.018497275188565254, -0.03017766773700714, -0.009286061860620975, 0.013766548596322536, -0.005258279852569103, 0.016229454427957535, -0.0532875619828701, 0.00905048381537199, 0.022567657753825188, 0.044905416667461395, -0.00042071533971466124, -0.04339587315917015, -0.061074744910001755, 0.003750378964468837, -0.015140454284846783, 0.04171910881996155, -0.022250840440392494, -0.043773751705884933, 0.026331312954425812, -0.04677538946270943, 0.02118409238755703, -0.024033086374402046, 0.03033674880862236, -0.00631110742688179, 0.056416649371385574, 0.017928868532180786, 0.0065589784644544125, -0.00200295471586287, 0.025845035910606384, 0.1169002503156662, 0.09315118193626404, 0.03717131167650223, -0.024373294785618782, 0.04502507671713829, -0.0004716707917395979, 0.026409581303596497, -0.015133616514503956, 0.02489914558827877, -0.003707349766045809, 0.005418169312179089, 0.01856500469148159, 0.0460999421775341, -0.0034368878696113825, -0.020135637372732162, 0.030645880848169327, -0.0434865802526474, -0.028842590749263763, -0.013417243026196957, -0.008287040516734123, -0.024365736171603203, -0.017271915450692177, 0.007919072173535824, 0.005570479668676853, 0.007313124369829893, -0.06656067818403244, -0.0025719893164932728, 0.002109761582687497, -0.0247220229357481, -0.01959981583058834, -0.040145136415958405, 0.010384279303252697, 0.036254145205020905, 0.00043250503949820995, -0.02722921222448349, 0.027987858280539513, 0.0033304872922599316, -0.04774874076247215, -0.01739460602402687, 0.0332886166870594, -0.01653311774134636, -0.023402832448482513, 0.03455910086631775, 0.02717103622853756, -0.047725848853588104, -0.023822246119379997, -0.01510019600391388, 0.06456273049116135, -0.01513107679784298, 0.027347661554813385, -0.020388247445225716, 0.0025254811625927687, 0.0021004287991672754, -0.03921207785606384, 0.024071896448731422, 0.030721111223101616, 0.03232608735561371, -0.023561162874102592, -0.02014179155230522, -0.04654499143362045, 0.0014728393871337175, -0.024874776601791382, 0.04771889001131058, 0.047221824526786804, -0.018852103501558304, -0.012062461115419865, -0.0034341090358793736, 0.04048899933695793, -0.016313616186380386, 0.012209300883114338, -0.01478278823196888, 0.03553635999560356, -0.03523734584450722, -0.022703468799591064, 0.03232162818312645, 0.006352189462631941, 0.03770844265818596, -0.007469594944268465, -0.010278336703777313, -0.023130452260375023, -0.03102162666618824, -0.0031986490357667208, -0.014780299738049507, -0.02406875044107437, -0.025341179221868515, 0.02099504880607128, 0.005479850806295872, 0.04224930331110954, -0.009221822023391724, 0.008428377099335194, -0.014641477726399899, 0.01779920607805252, 0.012244354002177715, -0.037301138043403625, 0.01286567933857441, -0.010917874053120613, -0.01676214300096035, 0.022671906277537346, 0.004275300074368715, 0.06545611470937729, 0.03078252077102661, 0.011379828676581383, 0.004902681801468134, 0.05720236524939537, -0.01875370554625988, -0.012632192112505436, 0.014770423993468285, -0.04035205394029617, 0.048291269689798355, 0.0018608112586662173, 0.013887050561606884, -0.04381653293967247, -0.039183128625154495, -0.03699498251080513, 0.0014417896745726466, -0.016157180070877075, -0.012600885704159737, -0.01985894702374935, -0.003449911018833518, -0.009592588059604168, 0.04171011224389076, -0.0314512625336647, 0.004940249025821686, -0.043203968554735184, 0.0255629550665617, -0.01168003398925066, -0.008195494301617146, -0.011031245812773705, 0.0020394970197230577, -0.006073064170777798, 0.004929855931550264, 0.060402728617191315, 0.005375652574002743, 0.026234427466988564, -0.017544642090797424, 0.022501837462186813, -0.012654542922973633, 0.022546889260411263, -0.0651613101363182, -0.015353318303823471, 0.04601844400167465, -0.0780649334192276, -0.029830055311322212, 0.016123780980706215, 0.0062878369353711605, 0.06255783140659332, 0.020948661491274834, 0.019374174997210503, -0.034809280186891556, 0.034612853080034256, -0.017176678404211998, -0.02509153261780739, -0.006865428760647774, 0.04014517366886139, 0.001273788744583726, -0.017329849302768707, -0.01725373975932598, 0.0014540432021021843, -0.026802634820342064, 0.057330917567014694, 0.03369275853037834, 0.005558249074965715, -0.023177795112133026, 0.014529249630868435, -0.014328948222100735, 0.01405965443700552, -0.0072678495198488235, 0.014772946946322918, 0.05113079771399498, 0.015642032027244568, -0.028750767931342125, 0.036529459059238434, -0.02195180207490921, 0.040281981229782104, -0.08455350995063782, -0.012084387242794037, -0.011871998198330402, 0.00790106039494276, 0.027085023000836372, -0.04159703850746155, 0.02745506539940834, 0.030736181885004044, -0.06075156852602959, 0.0026177556719630957, 0.005475729703903198, 0.003559560514986515, -0.035896074026823044, -0.006940810941159725, -0.023517349734902382, 0.01682337187230587, 0.025447256863117218, -0.006407708395272493, 0.034855689853429794, 0.02517184242606163, 0.004510102327913046, -0.03300035744905472, -0.022371012717485428, 0.01728953793644905, -0.042711041867733, -0.0602705292403698, 0.05854662507772446, -0.04566211625933647, -0.02688545547425747, 0.007581712212413549, -0.0031794162932783365, 0.032273244112730026, 0.05445461720228195, 0.009569845162332058, 0.0045542544685304165, 0.02070792205631733, 0.04185112938284874, -0.0379476472735405, -0.02264133282005787, -0.010997611097991467, -0.022946752607822418, 0.016061844304203987, 0.020061589777469635, 0.02958991564810276, 0.03765542060136795, -0.015963446348905563, -0.018795736134052277, -0.04324290528893471, -0.0035305095370858908, -0.012003708630800247, -0.0008933219942264259, -0.021420445293188095, -0.008491606451570988, -0.0019400871824473143, 0.03626112639904022, -0.035111356526613235, -0.006411134731024504, 0.024997349828481674, 0.0000369333392882254, -0.04280657693743706, 0.018712539225816727, -0.000023276421416085213, -0.04682259261608124, 0.008673131465911865, 0.007645227015018463, 0.012076664716005325, -0.08427082747220993, -0.01128285750746727, 0.04522262513637543, -0.0551115982234478, -0.0494999922811985, -0.01287666242569685, -0.05489115044474602, 0.016758205369114876, -0.022229263558983803, 0.017967427149415016, 0.023003889247775078, -0.014156951569020748, 0.005662931129336357, -0.08609248697757721, 0.07430039346218109, 0.0036570013035088778, -0.00913633406162262, -0.011584579944610596, -0.027563020586967468, -0.03776627779006958, -0.0007546667475253344, 0.0372830294072628, -0.0033804168924689293, 0.0028330085333436728, -0.036332499235868454, 0.044316794723272324, -0.000989480409771204, -0.045087724924087524, 0.06035449355840683, -0.00036384063423611224, -0.014213073067367077, -0.022808745503425598, -0.06598371267318726, 0.025055143982172012, -0.017001478001475334, 0.014298679307103157, -0.012812389992177486, 0.0018092866521328688, -0.002353417221456766, -0.013961504213511944, 0.03482479974627495, 0.016809813678264618, -0.008054873906075954, 0.022543512284755707, 0.004923114087432623, 0.059918567538261414, 0.03841007128357887, 0.0017267469083890319, -0.02717752940952778, 0.020580492913722992, -0.019956914708018303, 0.004406052641570568, 0.029974397271871567, 0.014952671714127064, 0.004626329522579908, -0.05064164847135544, 0.016687294468283653, 0.025841280817985535, -0.05889312922954559, -0.00787101686000824, 0.013625022023916245, 0.03610783442854881, 0.020556479692459106, -0.006343205459415913, 0.033814359456300735, 0.02828342467546463, -0.019058533012866974, -0.012926590628921986, 0.017383383587002754, 0.009390722960233688, 0.02860580012202263, 0.015349474735558033, 0.048217155039310455, 0.012111041694879532, 0.001953703351318836, -0.0138566754758358, 0.03283557668328285, -0.012848399579524994, -0.006859016604721546, -0.02561677061021328, -0.002218992682173848, 0.04586867243051529, -0.011437688954174519, -0.03868047893047333, 0.08665203303098679, -0.016334963962435722, -0.02793652005493641, -0.03871763497591019, 0.02541137859225273, -0.010649769566953182, -0.014885894022881985, 0.0058851949870586395, 0.050408486276865005, 0.011862295679748058, 0.017629943788051605, -0.007725202478468418, -0.025781024247407913, 0.02015601471066475, -0.010799374431371689, 0.0029392922297120094, -0.009979150258004665, 0.011981343850493431, -0.023049989715218544, -0.022638728842139244, -0.016147369518876076, 0.0017180098220705986, 0.05306870862841606, 0.04294635355472565, 0.01682671345770359, -0.004489297978579998, -0.026584863662719727, 0.01959163509309292, 0.05064722150564194, -0.03689252957701683, -0.0050492356531322, -0.027954066172242165, -0.010710581205785275, -0.009269223548471928, 0.024306513369083405 ]
<p>I am trying to get upto speed in Bayesian Statistics. I have a little bit of stats background (STAT 101) but not too much - I think I can understand prior, posterior, and likelihood :D. </p> <p>I don't want to read a Bayesian textbook just yet. I'd prefer to read from a source (website preferred) that will ramp me up quickly. Something like <a href="http://www.stat.washington.edu/raftery/Research/PDF/bayescourse.pdf">this</a>, but that has more details.</p> <p>Any advice?</p>
73,943
[ -0.03195749223232269, -0.05210914835333824, 0.031112130731344223, -0.032569848001003265, 0.04956481605768204, 0.019522620365023613, 0.037345971912145615, -0.019794896245002747, 0.013728605583310127, -0.0484948456287384, 0.024322645738720894, 0.07356921583414078, 0.04466012120246887, 0.017907390370965004, 0.01498345099389553, 0.01660809852182865, -0.004580404609441757, -0.024661540985107422, -0.02823776751756668, -0.010993324220180511, 0.005501316860318184, -0.0005262583727017045, 0.02832644432783127, 0.0061875018291175365, -0.0191813874989748, 0.024919651448726654, 0.04120344668626785, -0.0056729502975940704, -0.0035792163107544184, 0.09046559035778046, -0.03811647742986679, -0.016390228644013405, -0.01084168627858162, 0.04155850410461426, -0.004588671959936619, -0.028576930984854698, 0.003924600780010223, -0.018252737820148468, -0.009107636287808418, 0.03888682276010513, -0.0013264628360047936, -0.023205997422337532, -0.0102979876101017, 0.037197720259428024, -0.03540273383259773, -0.013751683756709099, 0.006297511048614979, -0.04608384892344475, 0.018536189571022987, -0.07021240144968033, 0.04442688822746277, 0.0030005774460732937, 0.039404019713401794, 0.04508858919143677, 0.005713340826332569, -0.018172314390540123, 0.049445800483226776, 0.08148306608200073, -0.016958052292466164, -0.061594847589731216, -0.019360138103365898, -0.04032427445054054, 0.009958709590137005, -0.04743339121341705, -0.04066020995378494, 0.041544754058122635, -0.03719174861907959, -0.02844701148569584, 0.029417896643280983, 0.002169417915865779, 0.01482333429157734, 0.029292764142155647, 0.04890134930610657, -0.001241502002812922, 0.008746960200369358, -0.031307023018598557, 0.007114667445421219, 0.036928996443748474, 0.020939383655786514, 0.0633147582411766, -0.004713569302111864, -0.0007268645567819476, 0.025548242032527924, 0.05530085414648056, -0.0027124625630676746, -0.026811761781573296, 0.08876839280128479, -0.02388361282646656, -0.035743407905101776, -0.01574651338160038, -0.04949640855193138, -0.0022592428140342236, 0.004162775818258524, -0.018282437697052956, -0.04270147159695625, 0.04597701504826546, -0.032121069729328156, 0.07765620946884155, 0.01606670208275318, -0.02353726141154766, 0.0012124833883717656, -0.005089341662824154, 0.01976679638028145, 0.049223244190216064, -0.04224181920289993, -0.029206646606326103, -0.04400484636425972, 0.02650628797709942, -0.032316263765096664, -0.021916501224040985, -0.04031195491552353, 0.048271309584379196, 0.00278937048278749, 0.0008455520146526396, -0.013435286469757557, -0.028444543480873108, 0.023906175047159195, -0.014820131473243237, 0.06462362408638, 0.04768941178917885, 0.051154978573322296, -0.03595314919948578, 0.058061324059963226, -0.02199077047407627, -0.057069119065999985, 0.001026030397042632, -0.0037084072828292847, -0.029919883236289024, -0.008386912755668163, 0.07573635876178741, -0.03194519132375717, -0.02310975454747677, 0.04633137956261635, 0.016543162986636162, 0.029671110212802887, 0.016759607940912247, -0.07789609581232071, -0.03637443855404854, 0.05973600223660469, -0.004221292212605476, -0.008869155310094357, -0.0701027661561966, 0.014646068215370178, 0.03365934267640114, 0.021303050220012665, -0.002022502711042762, 0.023768948391079903, -0.011145677417516708, 0.01673520728945732, -0.03159818425774574, -0.037802331149578094, -0.042399678379297256, -0.0051663583144545555, 0.007947889156639576, -0.0047722854651510715, -0.08785442262887955, 0.01838093064725399, 0.012649589218199253, 0.021974746137857437, -0.041598573327064514, 0.048481352627277374, -0.009357338771224022, -0.020673491060733795, -0.015634607523679733, -0.00812994409352541, 0.0025238448288291693, 0.0941321924328804, 0.008020387031137943, -0.0033617366570979357, 0.04254840314388275, 0.009333138354122639, 0.026849064975976944, 0.003793184645473957, 0.040883637964725494, 0.04678305983543396, -0.04506836459040642, -0.019935622811317444, 0.00841937493532896, 0.01501295156776905, -0.0027984536718577147, 0.00021251430734992027, 0.007576616480946541, -0.008306187577545643, -0.006464344449341297, -0.009175649844110012, 0.017114493995904922, 0.02061518281698227, -0.013600482605397701, 0.019710585474967957, -0.04975927993655205, -0.05182477459311485, -0.07240000367164612, -0.006162473000586033, -0.03461388871073723, -0.01460812333971262, 0.05888265371322632, 0.028544900938868523, 0.032770562916994095, -0.03451119363307953, -0.022635741159319878, -0.043925561010837555, -0.020811954513192177, 0.021082960069179535, -0.03141069784760475, 0.012999546714127064, 0.06654491275548935, 0.03892592713236809, -0.01873224787414074, 0.017701799049973488, -0.034158118069171906, -0.04548974707722664, -0.004074072930961847, -0.010513359680771828, 0.007313048467040062, -0.0243367962539196, -0.007314648479223251, 0.005449547898024321, -0.011076180264353752, -0.009313085116446018, -0.0027167906519025564, -0.056565385311841965, 0.0529014952480793, 0.05240827798843384, 0.02876102365553379, -0.016295816749334335, 0.024257870391011238, 0.013483413495123386, 0.0023645004257559776, -0.015452750027179718, 0.014966960065066814, -0.02924164943397045, 0.009533518925309181, 0.04877503588795662, -0.019997062161564827, -0.015069241635501385, 0.019530750811100006, 0.023395363241434097, 0.030738862231373787, 0.019767772406339645, 0.041600484400987625, -0.011447807773947716, -0.04213196411728859, -0.02146461233496666, 0.0038381183985620737, -0.007611512206494808, 0.01036203932017088, 0.043818630278110504, 0.029216408729553223, 0.03024979680776596, -0.00016439940372947603, -0.034490883350372314, 0.01185663416981697, -0.028468893840909004, 0.011990593746304512, -0.020885810256004333, -0.032079607248306274, 0.03449195995926857, -0.04592787101864815, -0.0023602379951626062, -0.010571117512881756, 0.013788583688437939, 0.013059277087450027, 0.0022286386229097843, -0.018425770103931427, 0.020229626446962357, 0.02865740656852722, -0.026953957974910736, 0.027099791914224625, 0.02287624590098858, -0.04612131416797638, 0.03295712545514107, -0.015040718019008636, -0.033590167760849, -0.042290784418582916, 0.00651227030903101, -0.009265565313398838, 0.009869303554296494, 0.029894083738327026, -0.026971524581313133, -0.04567166417837143, -0.017822779715061188, -0.03521392494440079, 0.021548457443714142, -0.004875526763498783, -0.06140332669019699, 0.010072180069983006, -0.02722938358783722, -0.0450616218149662, 0.034339308738708496, -0.007201375439763069, -0.03490644693374634, 0.004106221254914999, 0.013754606246948242, -0.046447042375802994, -0.016914639621973038, -0.003677555127069354, 0.005286154802888632, -0.02398918755352497, -0.013752995058894157, 0.017404651269316673, -0.0042680599726736546, 0.019466189667582512, 0.026886170729994774, -0.052045825868844986, -0.02355489507317543, -0.03839559108018875, 0.013471268117427826, -0.002860622713342309, 0.007011438719928265, 0.01076547335833311, 0.03173845633864403, -0.056916285306215286, 0.03017488680779934, -0.020285123959183693, -0.08142547309398651, 0.019492540508508682, 0.03127831593155861, 0.027545584365725517, -0.019393227994441986, -0.016697345301508904, 0.053781066089868546, 0.011654552072286606, -0.03363333269953728, 0.0061512175016105175, 0.01851329766213894, -0.020563708618283272, -0.00014923617709428072, 0.03025851957499981, 0.008334686979651451, -0.01944349892437458, 0.020603002980351448, -0.006580083165317774, 0.023168280720710754, 0.038761913776397705, 0.02984580211341381, 0.02336695045232773, 0.029862789437174797, -0.012655786238610744, 0.008117260411381721, 0.0042747026309370995, 0.014171847142279148, -0.03734137490391731, -0.0008566838805563748, -0.034757163375616074, 0.03800315782427788, 0.013115840964019299, -0.01900513470172882, 0.02362549491226673, 0.006065284367650747, -0.015252422541379929, -0.05967389792203903, 0.05212930962443352, -0.004840807523578405, -0.023585164919495583, 0.028492147102952003, 0.0029945960268378258, 0.024672407656908035, -0.007313584443181753, 0.012997420504689217, 0.03865611180663109, 0.026195241138339043, -0.058828502893447876, -0.029241345822811127, -0.020791374146938324, -0.006639047060161829, 0.011105605401098728, -0.00812995433807373, -0.004435994196683168, 0.05315360054373741, 0.033329810947179794, 0.026951638981699944, -0.029731515794992447, -0.04461643844842911, 0.01932067982852459, -0.08574111759662628, 0.007091062143445015, -0.00909755751490593, 0.008796732872724533, 0.003569311462342739, 0.05108940228819847, -0.002811918267980218, 0.009442933835089207, 0.023158589377999306, 0.004044022411108017, -0.08125890046358109, 0.011317997239530087, -0.03693687543272972, -0.012223650701344013, -0.006773545406758785, 0.0037348235491663218, 0.03139827400445938, -0.026694148778915405, -0.013599895872175694, -0.03450295701622963, 0.005815469194203615, -0.03180556371808052, 0.010113714262843132, -0.05915062874555588, 0.0006011939258314669, 0.014787218533456326, -0.008006274700164795, 0.009328584186732769, -0.016147105023264885, 0.02186158113181591, 0.05221517011523247, -0.016047174111008644, -0.020558243617415428, 0.018007079139351845, 0.022127477452158928, 0.0166990514844656, 0.009878791868686676, 0.03550873324275017, 0.046449534595012665, -0.028370413929224014, 0.039095524698495865, -0.013959071598947048, 0.05428318679332733, 0.029104486107826233, -0.05112357810139656, -0.006701190955936909, -0.02143770083785057, -0.013659530319273472, -0.013454440981149673, 0.016628772020339966, 0.014592491090297699, 0.01259917113929987, 0.06911777704954147, 0.007034126669168472, -0.0706518143415451, 0.044120050966739655, 0.060132529586553574, -0.02288360521197319, 0.0010580040980130434, -0.018034428358078003, -0.004224888514727354, -0.04339691996574402, 0.0028580590151250362, 0.0393587201833725, 0.019824160262942314, -0.03298568353056908, 0.00596532691270113, 0.030537864193320274, -0.04407191276550293, -0.008843403309583664, -0.04012482240796089, -0.002494264394044876, 0.018610166385769844, 0.031471408903598785, -0.0539189837872982, 0.030140627175569534, 0.019550809636712074, 0.029013341292738914, 0.01152765192091465, -0.0013816036516800523, -0.09601105004549026, 0.004141402896493673, 0.04935717210173607, 0.04440819099545479, -0.0540553480386734, 0.0422515943646431, -0.05854538083076477, -0.03283572942018509, 0.0747021734714508, -0.028410403057932854, -0.0009076923597604036, -0.03466477245092392, -0.024349963292479515, -0.00046317893429659307, -0.014108100906014442, -0.03957514464855194, 0.006250473670661449, -0.007231530267745256, 0.03760674595832825, -0.00011709576938301325, 0.01972697488963604, -0.04845055192708969, 0.002437338698655367, 0.03844423219561577, 0.062928706407547, -0.01486013364046812, -0.025674864649772644, 0.0110746119171381, 0.009997505694627762, -0.004076303914189339, -0.05031987652182579, 0.022981157526373863, -0.013964098878204823, -0.007525601424276829, 0.03276124224066734, -0.018727805465459824, -0.03760925680398941, 0.030993245542049408, 0.015361654572188854, -0.07093387097120285, -0.008264323696494102, -0.018828487023711205, 0.014267534017562866, 0.005405012518167496, 0.0022048496175557375, 0.06252085417509079, -0.021583540365099907, -0.02760232426226139, 0.0036727995611727238, -0.04102931544184685, 0.056080736219882965, -0.03767528384923935, 0.02982911467552185, -0.03836102783679962, -0.028245223686099052, -0.03038393333554268, 0.048370111733675, -0.0038174365181475878, 0.008839542046189308, -0.03071008436381817, -0.01361242774873972, 0.01196232158690691, 0.035812072455883026, 0.018247952684760094, 0.018971629440784454, 0.0005668553640134633, 0.01037619635462761, 0.006496687885373831, -0.0059156883507966995, 0.05478246882557869, -0.009345443919301033, 0.02135983482003212, -0.02094533108174801, -0.03973517194390297, 0.02748296968638897, -0.06475513428449631, -0.057511135935783386, 0.03436094522476196, -0.06700053066015244, 0.06540170311927795, 0.021215049549937248, 0.031811561435461044, 0.01769600249826908, -0.06073947623372078, -0.05140721797943115, -0.004410203546285629, 0.006041792221367359, 0.058265529572963715, -0.05451039597392082, 0.04547286033630371, -0.03911610692739487, 0.011879834346473217, -0.03847958520054817, -0.041912440210580826, 0.013506663031876087, -0.005903305020183325, -0.036453377455472946, -0.0636180117726326, 0.04934747517108917, -0.022374816238880157, -0.015428825281560421, -0.02812851592898369, 0.028993146494030952, -0.006261499132961035, -0.004761746618896723, 0.014218040741980076, 0.012645651586353779, 0.08306307345628738, 0.027731657028198242, -0.03227830305695534, 0.029048742726445198, 0.00024695234606042504, 0.0017289454117417336, -0.017758408561348915, 0.03469303250312805, -0.032541509717702866, 0.010031448677182198, -0.01090214028954506, 0.034438759088516235, 0.055995047092437744, -0.045735061168670654, 0.0062081292271614075, 0.030210938304662704, 0.03288615122437477, -0.005679781548678875, -0.036185745149850845, -0.032441891729831696, -0.0031783778686076403, -0.00719508808106184, -0.03950265794992447, -0.014079205691814423, 0.008092010393738747, -0.014841322787106037, 0.03397149220108986, -0.009380193427205086, 0.009082627482712269, 0.007744997274130583, 0.046976640820503235, -0.0038057153578847647, 0.033981725573539734, 0.01278409268707037, 0.002140988828614354, -0.00019145278201904148, 0.015068921260535717, -0.0036505162715911865, 0.02349492534995079, -0.012973830103874207, -0.03540285676717758, -0.002257796237245202, -0.05879467725753784, -0.010240327566862106, 0.04548013210296631, 0.0009493667748756707, 0.06696852296590805, 0.022977294400334358, 0.015144577249884605, 0.002270796336233616, -0.02373526245355606, -0.02993909828364849, -0.016198569908738136, 0.04161720722913742, 0.009555493481457233, -0.04383408650755882, 0.014117080718278885, 0.03357328101992607, -0.002282083034515381, 0.013812875375151634, 0.019960258156061172, 0.026531707495450974, 0.0320211686193943, 0.059976764023303986, -0.026017693802714348, -0.05073075741529465, 0.05054731294512749, -0.03729955479502678, 0.0320245698094368, -0.04127497225999832, -0.03454431891441345, 0.07125221192836761, 0.03090050257742405, -0.006596577353775501, -0.03288812190294266, -0.020163364708423615, -0.03294086828827858, 0.033331625163555145, 0.020960038527846336, 0.016524240374565125, 0.022688239812850952, -0.005255918018519878, 0.03635411709547043, -0.007778871338814497, 0.03788245841860771, -0.01673857867717743, -0.08538404852151871, -0.0667266771197319, 0.008649585768580437, -0.015603023581206799, 0.010025751776993275, 0.021170642226934433, -0.025362884625792503, -0.004590717609971762, -0.04340584576129913, 0.021920623257756233, 0.004105309955775738, 0.04012276604771614, -0.029561620205640793, 0.08519373089075089, -0.024260960519313812, 0.01143985241651535, -0.015568807721138, -0.013492219150066376, 0.10311771929264069, 0.06284212321043015, 0.024541661143302917, -0.08158385008573532, 0.03253038227558136, 0.005409306846559048, 0.01879945956170559, -0.0433206669986248, 0.020130803808569908, 0.015805644914507866, -0.006805607583373785, 0.014811298809945583, 0.05026113986968994, 0.014240310527384281, -0.0004156981594860554, 0.07483720779418945, -0.03898495063185692, -0.03861437737941742, -0.0075189280323684216, 0.013300103135406971, -0.023748695850372314, -0.000922915933188051, -0.04636230319738388, 0.005702521186321974, -0.012949349358677864, -0.03169199079275131, -0.03340142220258713, -0.010350502096116543, -0.01953744702041149, 0.016901526600122452, 0.01646830514073372, -0.03768191114068031, -0.0019692941568791866, -0.02867303602397442, 0.00016058811161201447, 0.0045636664144694805, 0.02485654130578041, -0.006186667829751968, 0.014593906700611115, 0.027809159830212593, -0.009477646090090275, -0.002318734535947442, 0.011454466730356216, 0.008054764941334724, -0.03777219355106354, -0.024519553408026695, -0.013444858603179455, 0.055752288550138474, -0.025365075096488, 0.008741693571209908, -0.020844651386141777, 0.01251349039375782, 0.008907495997846127, -0.03253544121980667, 0.018984904512763023, 0.03535590320825577, 0.01590554788708687, -0.032549530267715454, -0.01536411140114069, -0.017735697329044342, 0.036792829632759094, -0.02322978712618351, 0.03346969932317734, 0.03772479668259621, -0.014552026987075806, -0.03853129968047142, -0.045806169509887695, 0.002952579176053405, -0.0014734253054484725, -0.015244338661432266, 0.005795315373688936, 0.02694815583527088, -0.03718098625540733, 0.00036565816844813526, 0.033453769981861115, -0.01935763657093048, 0.007542699575424194, -0.019204773008823395, -0.019217774271965027, 0.020147189497947693, -0.03217443823814392, 0.012636550702154636, -0.037852831184864044, -0.04033832997083664, -0.021664906293153763, 0.017707079648971558, 0.06191386282444, 0.027580879628658295, 0.03324170783162117, 0.04138247296214104, -0.026884958148002625, 0.018312808126211166, 0.038795579224824905, -0.04898085445165634, -0.0007747315103188157, 0.00023927718575578183, -0.005227979738265276, -0.013004444539546967, -0.007526955101639032, 0.04006107524037361, 0.041846081614494324, 0.013871763832867146, 0.007233339361846447, 0.005775169935077429, -0.008004223927855492, 0.019267834722995758, -0.01392195001244545, -0.07361732423305511, -0.0052307103760540485, 0.011293251067399979, 0.02259310707449913, -0.00409972807392478, -0.044171884655952454, -0.004421866033226252, 0.015135491266846657, 0.007025032304227352, -0.00975782796740532, -0.049015551805496216, 0.038863249123096466, 0.029405703768134117, 0.021581565961241722, -0.024995559826493263, 0.006732263136655092, -0.0059509179554879665, -0.0061885216273367405, -0.007552727125585079, 0.02430359274148941, -0.011469189077615738, 0.03200405836105347, -0.03265179321169853, -0.02347966469824314, 0.02297511138021946, -0.014441365376114845, 0.03267262876033783, -0.0025268536992371082, 0.03552216291427612, -0.030624117702245712, 0.05717262253165245, -0.02107388712465763, -0.004732320550829172, 0.03084961324930191, -0.04309174045920372, -0.03244324401021004, 0.013090377673506737, 0.025380097329616547, 0.01988617330789566, 0.0049368650652468204, -0.005679813679307699, -0.027097268030047417, 0.051392216235399246, -0.012244649231433868, -0.010498854331672192, 0.010930294170975685, 0.00019262736896052957, -0.006687950808554888, -0.002292142016813159, 0.011091571301221848, 0.010094030760228634, -0.0006062422762624919, 0.025559671223163605, 0.03264164552092552, 0.011512208729982376, 0.01928751729428768, -0.0032733019907027483, -0.0027427999302744865, 0.007803963031619787, -0.02082221210002899, -0.02811466157436371, 0.04009539261460304, 0.05644695460796356, -0.013778090476989746, 0.06576437503099442, 0.007389589678496122, 0.004066670313477516, -0.10081542283296585, 0.002250039018690586, -0.000470405095256865, 0.017203964293003082, 0.041602861136198044, -0.05349447578191757, 0.010079826228320599, 0.051796264946460724, -0.03866201639175415, 0.03325019031763077, 0.012316702865064144, -0.022900132462382317, -0.03038630075752735, -0.017885029315948486, 0.004337694961577654, 0.062167637050151825, 0.014601395465433598, 0.030366649851202965, 0.041623834520578384, 0.011201324872672558, 0.007971974089741707, -0.02227483130991459, 0.0007331374217756093, 0.0620000883936882, 0.023128997534513474, -0.05722366273403168, 0.03656452149152756, -0.024851271882653236, -0.031737662851810455, 0.02397962659597397, 0.027132496237754822, 0.03065383806824684, 0.009493321180343628, 0.03271644935011864, -0.008619188331067562, 0.0408950001001358, 0.04744584858417511, 0.006030690390616655, 0.023691486567258835, 0.011595728807151318, 0.014420855790376663, 0.04761505499482155, -0.01060409750789404, 0.009557006880640984, 0.0149909732863307, -0.028047338128089905, -0.03651478886604309, 0.030913207679986954, -0.0004961976665072143, -0.01093882042914629, 0.023269468918442726, 0.00010393161937827244, 0.007985478267073631, -0.007666059769690037, 0.030862413346767426, -0.053610965609550476, -0.011879978701472282, 0.03555586189031601, -0.015267997980117798, 0.0014200685545802116, 0.02661558799445629, -0.019012613222002983, -0.010030352510511875, 0.015483309514820576, -0.006150826811790466, 0.003981103654950857, -0.05480886995792389, 0.008937864564359188, 0.0037810872308909893, -0.0020529720932245255, -0.015868203714489937, -0.023510348051786423, -0.03557560220360756, 0.005454180296510458, -0.0017297323793172836, -0.012236770242452621, 0.006950363051146269, 0.025356097146868706, -0.0029707830399274826, -0.04141722992062569, 0.08362536132335663, 0.0015803759451955557, -0.025758959352970123, -0.05025799944996834, 0.004383516032248735, -0.003656771732494235, -0.018253987655043602, 0.037820231169462204, -0.009964518249034882, 0.013694371096789837, -0.022184167057275772, 0.010813301429152489, 0.031862035393714905, -0.0303769763559103, 0.036089904606342316, 0.00032192133949138224, -0.052706778049468994, -0.019886095076799393, -0.004884509835392237, 0.026513034477829933, 0.019657127559185028, 0.003957244101911783, 0.008585445582866669, 0.02428886666893959, -0.02040572091937065, -0.00660726660862565, 0.03411341831088066, 0.010340542532503605, -0.004410742782056332, 0.04311370849609375, -0.04799983650445938, 0.025186238810420036, 0.026466192677617073, -0.0032009705901145935, -0.045059867203235626, 0.029156461358070374, -0.030084947124123573, -0.008901478722691536, 0.014478989876806736, -0.026432884857058525, -0.023505892604589462, -0.05584512650966644, 0.012080410495400429, 0.0227435864508152, -0.043603766709566116, 0.030769867822527885, 0.03079861029982567, 0.008173303678631783, 0.06775623559951782, 0.009112994186580181, -0.0015406734310090542, 0.026905588805675507, 0.004321974236518145, -0.009460767731070518, 0.007382540497928858, 0.04151025786995888, -0.004426175728440285, 0.04210010543465614, 0.05059301108121872, 0.0003955216088797897, 0.019598625600337982, -0.0034588584676384926, 0.03322051092982292, -0.04243282601237297, -0.009860897436738014, -0.022634955123066902, -0.02162220887839794, 0.000356880365870893, 0.014677288942039013, -0.015144702047109604, 0.04996582493185997, -0.03880828991532326, -0.005209399852901697, -0.002895655808970332, 0.027111994102597237, -0.05485425144433975, -0.026567192748188972, -0.005544354673475027, 0.016745807603001595, 0.010170919820666313, 0.003828915301710367, -0.004453934263437986, -0.004299391061067581, 0.023219486698508263, -0.047717414796352386, 0.027249636128544807, -0.0016428790986537933, -0.010633190162479877, -0.016599692404270172, 0.008349847979843616, -0.003480154788121581, -0.01457356009632349, -0.013166538439691067, 0.04359937086701393, -0.008432288654148579, -0.04122568294405937, -0.022072680294513702, -0.015634533017873764, 0.029565533623099327, -0.06542328000068665, 0.025940721854567528, -0.07500623911619186, 0.0025938730686903, -0.015689438208937645, -0.010547024197876453 ]
<p>I have two tables (matrix) of same dimensions, one contains correlation coefficients and other with p values. I want to combine them into one table. For example let's say I have correlation coefficient between variable A1 and A2 of 0.75 in table 1 and p value of 0.045 in table 2. Now in my combined table 3, I want to use:</p> <p>condition1 for table 1: if a coefficient value in a cell of table 1 is less than 0.4 then "+", 0.4 &lt;= coefficient &lt;0.7 then "++" else "+++",</p> <p>condition2 for table 2: if a pvalue in a cell of table 2 is less than 0.01 then "+++", 0.01 &lt;= pvalue &lt; .05 then "++" else "+".</p> <p>Thus corresponding cell value for A1 and A2 in table 3 should look like: +++/++ where "+++" correspond to table 1 value of 0.75 and ++ correspond to table 2 p value of 0.045 and "/" is just a separator.</p> <p>I would like to do this either is SAS or R. Thanks in advance.</p>
73,944
[ -0.035365842282772064, 0.0052786762826144695, -0.009414460510015488, 0.019503837451338768, -0.001583295175805688, 0.03057323396205902, 0.02111721783876419, 0.006817767862230539, 0.0672941505908966, -0.013262113556265831, 0.028544677421450615, 0.03064676746726036, 0.026335759088397026, 0.009881536476314068, 0.009468519128859043, 0.02304868958890438, 0.019084123894572258, 0.020357144996523857, -0.019181275740265846, -0.004018052946776152, -0.019886258989572525, -0.019279642030596733, 0.01640780083835125, -0.010207872837781906, 0.028224296867847443, 0.06531540304422379, 0.01750331185758114, -0.04433027282357216, -0.0022895701695233583, 0.08362656831741333, -0.01176968589425087, -0.044220536947250366, 0.04540516808629036, 0.02716946229338646, 0.047404758632183075, -0.004819189663976431, -0.018275368958711624, 0.010434208437800407, -0.02346809208393097, 0.01703697443008423, -0.03260573744773865, -0.010185770690441132, 0.04563695564866066, 0.022375717759132385, -0.011282348074018955, -0.008152960799634457, 0.009292845614254475, 0.015999268740415573, 0.007471153978258371, -0.03822855278849602, 0.04140684753656387, -0.008714155294001102, 0.07370482385158539, 0.03120061196386814, -0.011819056235253811, 0.013713158667087555, 0.034859247505664825, 0.047111403197050095, 0.04233916476368904, -0.041124217212200165, 0.01926160603761673, -0.014950333163142204, 0.011416716501116753, 0.008290550671517849, -0.06717673689126968, -0.010787456296384335, -0.028944851830601692, -0.03864092007279396, 0.025606922805309296, -0.025815539062023163, -0.015729624778032303, -0.0005668572266586125, 0.039919164031744, -0.03487129136919975, 0.01510707288980484, -0.02083909884095192, 0.011500961147248745, -0.008982948027551174, 0.028949324041604996, 0.03543184697628021, 0.016880737617611885, 0.01734800636768341, 0.02455875463783741, 0.011555883102118969, 0.028842080384492874, -0.0005565524916164577, 0.06735784560441971, -0.0710095539689064, -0.015205145813524723, 0.027734538540244102, -0.008335395716130733, -0.0019067897228524089, 0.029643265530467033, 0.06556880474090576, -0.0009375819936394691, 0.01960749737918377, -0.0018498854478821158, 0.047907505184412, 0.01022674236446619, 0.027362966910004616, -0.009734349325299263, -0.020394183695316315, -0.0016042867209762335, 0.03184957057237625, -0.04698554798960686, -0.012942900881171227, -0.005887763109058142, 0.0002159865398425609, -0.0030052729416638613, -0.004269703291356564, -0.0010387003421783447, 0.006594926118850708, 0.02797684259712696, -0.0017650867812335491, 0.020532064139842987, -0.06665940582752228, -0.011098322458565235, 0.00028318571276031435, 0.045470140874385834, 0.05042286589741707, 0.05574312433600426, -0.012573239393532276, 0.006445141509175301, -0.012864002026617527, -0.0731031596660614, 0.010177924297749996, -0.02873418480157852, -0.017055384814739227, -0.03390943631529808, 0.06111358478665352, -0.008073586970567703, -0.05735137313604355, 0.0818033367395401, -0.011077841743826866, 0.028283949941396713, 0.014686386100947857, -0.05174629017710686, -0.014695489779114723, 0.004044505767524242, -0.03832495957612991, 0.03118709847331047, -0.049012213945388794, -0.007290416397154331, 0.030243780463933945, 0.08529453724622726, 0.002297378145158291, 0.023599758744239807, 0.026950301602482796, -0.0016394697595387697, 0.01681574434041977, -0.020988838747143745, -0.04553872346878052, -0.05008944123983383, -0.010245789773762226, 0.009032955393195152, -0.061116769909858704, 0.01103909220546484, 0.005270884372293949, -0.019436124712228775, 0.002480727154761553, 0.006995887495577335, -0.008048283867537975, 0.020332826301455498, -0.02000182494521141, 0.025785861536860466, -0.008448564447462559, 0.02235141023993492, -0.002840754808858037, -0.019536303356289864, 0.02158881165087223, 0.003640905022621155, -0.0003302045806776732, -0.011509855277836323, 0.034047335386276245, 0.06653071194887161, -0.028361259028315544, 0.007199370302259922, 0.015439774841070175, 0.017368881031870842, 0.01083375047892332, -0.03269925341010094, -0.01683937944471836, -0.022648705169558525, -0.05183210223913193, 0.0702718123793602, 0.040466707199811935, 0.017430303618311882, -0.027259651571512222, 0.035555433481931686, -0.010965324006974697, -0.01639307662844658, -0.06975644826889038, -0.025826940312981606, 0.0022070889826864004, -0.05665795877575874, 0.023902272805571556, 0.012180444784462452, -0.005139281507581472, 0.027525894343852997, -0.044371798634529114, -0.0687909722328186, -0.0024903796147555113, 0.036239996552467346, -0.05788786709308624, -0.008871479891240597, 0.03823697566986084, 0.05019097402691841, -0.03987116366624832, 0.02310189977288246, -0.022147703915834427, -0.009091028943657875, 0.030708733946084976, -0.018612271174788475, 0.0027830658946186304, 0.020619209855794907, -0.02522461488842964, -0.013393223285675049, 0.028120150789618492, -0.006018014159053564, 0.033718425780534744, -0.037372201681137085, 0.0548006147146225, 0.06704972684383392, 0.05071160942316055, 0.02827615663409233, -0.014312667772173882, 0.013829651288688183, 0.030049417167901993, -0.04063907265663147, -0.034596677869558334, -0.0186083372682333, 0.024691468104720116, 0.004205614794045687, 0.02682504802942276, -0.04243706166744232, 0.013358385302126408, 0.041213490068912506, -0.03533339872956276, 0.004371458198875189, 0.08726879954338074, -0.0006909219082444906, 0.03690975904464722, -0.005449511110782623, -0.01078670285642147, 0.029741086065769196, 0.019876830279827118, -0.011930644512176514, 0.044941894710063934, 0.07602454721927643, 0.015035903081297874, -0.013114815577864647, 0.007359004579484463, 0.021415693685412407, 0.007356007117778063, -0.021322917193174362, 0.004252792801707983, 0.042568888515233994, -0.0023392534349113703, 0.020388534292578697, 0.010922632180154324, 0.015923015773296356, -0.037820663303136826, 0.02014997787773609, -0.018676694482564926, -0.019813155755400658, 0.0514901727437973, -0.016793973743915558, -0.0019275560043752193, 0.01768324337899685, -0.061726585030555725, 0.02171696349978447, -0.0011731499107554555, 0.02336559072136879, -0.06951554119586945, 0.01878526620566845, 0.05483514815568924, 0.007509835995733738, 0.05001378804445267, -0.0321735218167305, -0.029080530628561974, -0.006920806132256985, -0.03507169336080551, 0.01043044775724411, -0.016772054135799408, -0.04543318971991539, -0.017516348510980606, -0.0061833541840314865, -0.022796183824539185, 0.0452788807451725, 0.007942348718643188, -0.012952196411788464, 0.020855102688074112, -0.013244177214801311, -0.07534550875425339, -0.029978211969137192, -0.04124585911631584, 0.0039420537650585175, -0.020508358255028725, -0.024936271831393242, -0.006729190703481436, -0.004138072486966848, -0.03799626976251602, -0.013162079267203808, -0.07540160417556763, -0.018737252801656723, -0.02513616345822811, -0.016836732625961304, 0.006856190972030163, 0.0033663008362054825, 0.026460375636816025, 0.05017701908946037, -0.011446511372923851, -0.014102925546467304, -0.04990442097187042, -0.02450079284608364, 0.01475907489657402, -0.005766019690781832, 0.014908579178154469, 0.0167975015938282, -0.03185845538973808, 0.03405964374542236, 0.026592906564474106, -0.037014417350292206, -0.05854896828532219, -0.015108332969248295, -0.026596378535032272, -0.043542563915252686, 0.03610219061374664, -0.011501812376081944, 0.025712311267852783, 0.01957038976252079, 0.002852420322597027, 0.039445679634809494, 0.03490768000483513, -0.0006133608403615654, 0.006618322804570198, -0.005221990868449211, -0.015657464042305946, -0.059013087302446365, 0.03988638520240784, 0.031091710552573204, -0.026255136355757713, 0.015411922708153725, -0.013489377684891224, -0.003280044300481677, -0.015448909252882004, -0.0059699974954128265, -0.04317428171634674, 0.005718661937862635, 0.04234793782234192, -0.02615458145737648, -0.005115763284265995, 0.021291183307766914, -0.0017478637164458632, -0.020934704691171646, 0.06057854741811752, 0.021824367344379425, -0.0038182244170457125, -0.012557734735310078, 0.04000747203826904, 0.015885816887021065, -0.028063366189599037, 0.017262490466237068, 0.02047092840075493, 0.0018828731263056397, 0.015585534274578094, -0.014023276045918465, -0.00782082974910736, 0.047154758125543594, 0.007241333834826946, 0.013898291625082493, 0.030522774904966354, -0.014378153719007969, 0.017552468925714493, -0.045736610889434814, -0.000002331579707970377, -0.022567979991436005, 0.08056691288948059, 0.007948685437440872, 0.06906675547361374, 0.02768058329820633, -0.018457703292369843, 0.06813172250986099, -0.0362401008605957, -0.06230156868696213, 0.0210717860609293, 0.03054889850318432, -0.018781039863824844, 0.02159035950899124, -0.00575617840513587, -0.0032362225465476513, -0.049229420721530914, 0.005517284385859966, 0.025362852960824966, 0.010293595492839813, -0.045241035521030426, 0.005136223044246435, -0.04600245878100395, 0.02501971647143364, -0.010368848219513893, -0.0031266354490071535, 0.040598418563604355, -0.017320428043603897, 0.02310173027217388, 0.03453399986028671, -0.00855514407157898, -0.006777290720492601, -0.015301587991416454, 0.024820387363433838, 0.04877423867583275, 0.05140291899442673, 0.023669933900237083, 0.050534769892692566, -0.021085919812321663, 0.029014987871050835, -0.026307661086320877, 0.02497239224612713, 0.04392935335636139, 0.0071246810257434845, -0.016115108504891396, -0.008894036523997784, -0.0004860592307522893, -0.02085445635020733, 0.03177417814731598, -0.001119682565331459, 0.006719476077705622, 0.01413742359727621, 0.005105894058942795, -0.06247429922223091, 0.018229730427265167, 0.09675587713718414, 0.027744553983211517, -0.025914955884218216, -0.028225909918546677, -0.009564727544784546, 0.009952090680599213, -0.04234791919589043, 0.012657820247113705, 0.030437113717198372, -0.011331548914313316, -0.010565766133368015, 0.017787106335163116, -0.03762734681367874, -0.007108588702976704, 0.015539579093456268, 0.04004690423607826, 0.04559660702943802, 0.0033892549108713865, -0.04310740530490875, -0.012843340635299683, 0.03310532122850418, -0.011232280172407627, 0.04044051468372345, 0.013390499167144299, -0.07704471051692963, 0.01923607848584652, 0.05563731491565704, 0.061429884284734726, -0.03397466614842415, -0.01265602558851242, -0.03441706672310829, -0.054546989500522614, 0.03370597958564758, -0.02232997864484787, 0.03120298497378826, -0.006782675161957741, -0.011156265623867512, -0.008708327077329159, -0.007322615012526512, -0.033628422766923904, 0.014867017976939678, -0.029660791158676147, 0.023958392441272736, 0.000057088505855062976, -0.04374818131327629, -0.024332044646143913, 0.011251554824411869, 0.00649995356798172, 0.032177530229091644, -0.04489699751138687, -0.022831501439213753, -0.007694656029343605, 0.017470406368374825, -0.019969500601291656, -0.026640335097908974, 0.01797730103135109, 0.010725815780460835, 0.009668468497693539, 0.06133706495165825, -0.0026198173873126507, 0.02049843594431877, -0.01705986075103283, 0.005827911198139191, 0.0002621356106828898, -0.0004191686457488686, 0.04651530086994171, 0.0713517963886261, 0.011475146748125553, -0.013161307200789452, 0.07029388844966888, 0.03462767228484154, -0.03680239990353584, -0.0105127627030015, -0.07424766570329666, -0.0006293187034316361, -0.012069745920598507, 0.0060249073430895805, -0.07794618606567383, 0.009831930510699749, -0.02801194228231907, -0.00667284382507205, -0.0016765805194154382, 0.023053208366036415, -0.045226845890283585, 0.02332027070224285, 0.016767751425504684, 0.052118994295597076, -0.028398320078849792, -0.01159413531422615, 0.01996360905468464, 0.010293114930391312, 0.005378748755902052, -0.04164296016097069, 0.03050585836172104, -0.04660674184560776, -0.03351221978664398, -0.01769646629691124, -0.0534699410200119, 0.007275838870555162, 0.012441094033420086, -0.009798307903110981, -0.027381565421819687, -0.04822519049048424, 0.03262177109718323, -0.022987036034464836, 0.0656750351190567, 0.01429821364581585, -0.02178226038813591, -0.002769701648503542, 0.05118280276656151, -0.023055434226989746, 0.027828510850667953, -0.05208953842520714, 0.09020169824361801, -0.06900208443403244, -0.019065827131271362, -0.047001373022794724, -0.0766347348690033, 0.015146773308515549, 0.00950690545141697, -0.020060677081346512, -0.028860190883278847, -0.014340206049382687, -0.02585761435329914, 0.019210461527109146, -0.03257499262690544, 0.040639545768499374, -0.03934185206890106, -0.013174118474125862, 0.05121442675590515, 0.012935533188283443, 0.041475314646959305, 0.01989675685763359, 0.029620880261063576, -0.00010213839414063841, -0.0038905651308596134, -0.03759776055812836, -0.0014333464205265045, -0.03371995687484741, -0.02422197163105011, -0.02628844976425171, -0.03684840723872185, -0.004526570904999971, 0.05463062971830368, -0.013025506399571896, 0.04474451765418053, -0.04933176189661026, 0.010387944057583809, 0.01333291083574295, -0.029754873365163803, 0.008412308990955353, -0.03149324283003807, -0.00016164875705726445, -0.020564768463373184, 0.03145650029182434, -0.031484611332416534, 0.024786116555333138, -0.02015865035355091, 0.014480147510766983, -0.028753582388162613, 0.0015191977145150304, 0.06035066395998001, 0.03781856223940849, 0.014658542349934578, -0.013364232145249844, 0.02619510143995285, 0.08857235312461853, 0.027226092293858528, -0.009907184168696404, -0.009834043681621552, 0.03057721257209778, -0.021577253937721252, -0.008411983959376812, -0.005224532447755337, -0.01062504481524229, 0.05205713212490082, -0.0424342043697834, 0.037407830357551575, 0.055653199553489685, -0.0058123269118368626, -0.02842678874731064, -0.036021728068590164, 0.00404658867046237, 0.035144176334142685, 0.004469708073884249, 0.06438248604536057, 0.009502531960606575, -0.032997120171785355, 0.004837288986891508, 0.003097966080531478, 0.020125269889831543, 0.04876750707626343, -0.040824152529239655, -0.01344019453972578, 0.02370740845799446, -0.018141798675060272, -0.006368969567120075, 0.022473644465208054, -0.019470037892460823, -0.0034574209712445736, -0.05199455842375755, -0.08034446090459824, -0.004737042356282473, 0.03169017285108566, -0.031464505940675735, -0.05869659408926964, -0.043765030801296234, -0.03659621998667717, 0.0018741008825600147, -0.007452981546521187, -0.05766578018665314, 0.013869584538042545, -0.01829775795340538, -0.009722137823700905, 0.01218356378376484, 0.029469523578882217, -0.03390907123684883, -0.05418037250638008, -0.024230947718024254, -0.06482745707035065, -0.006086238659918308, 0.04239712655544281, 0.037960633635520935, -0.03779207542538643, 0.015895957127213478, -0.014079632237553596, 0.007664515171200037, 0.023070214316248894, 0.06993516534566879, -0.0022348426282405853, 0.07331683486700058, -0.01240535918623209, 0.041686903685331345, -0.025544390082359314, -0.02409481070935726, 0.11727645248174667, 0.04141100496053696, 0.03299066796898842, -0.08511792123317719, 0.0515095517039299, 0.03230273723602295, -0.014941205270588398, -0.05244022607803345, 0.04282987117767334, 0.01871350035071373, 0.029555341228842735, 0.0330607034265995, 0.08232885599136353, 0.009248153306543827, 0.019702602177858353, 0.05239954590797424, -0.027096832171082497, -0.036816276609897614, -0.01607666164636612, 0.013918763026595116, 0.0053945137187838554, -0.022042132914066315, -0.03819996863603592, -0.027209118008613586, 0.0018659341149032116, -0.03914806991815567, -0.04860648512840271, 0.010874330066144466, 0.03259929269552231, -0.001857632421888411, -0.049768686294555664, 0.004963848739862442, 0.04791780561208725, 0.03967203199863434, 0.0016311299987137318, -0.008121756836771965, 0.045736949890851974, -0.04734552651643753, -0.01543118990957737, 0.02620086446404457, 0.02195913717150688, -0.026442402973771095, -0.013011163100600243, -0.004926310386508703, -0.03018522448837757, 0.027074486017227173, -0.020672213286161423, 0.006809969432651997, -0.03277453035116196, -0.03194760903716087, 0.007024921476840973, 0.0064573767594993114, 0.024967921897768974, -0.04324914142489433, -0.02478882297873497, 0.005918070673942566, 0.0313851572573185, 0.000039990180084714666, 0.008978132158517838, -0.024517592042684555, 0.028264550492167473, -0.02339153178036213, 0.034071918576955795, -0.00916779600083828, -0.03377007693052292, 0.007003702223300934, -0.05371332913637161, 0.06737712770700455, -0.04033118486404419, 0.01940193399786949, 0.021431688219308853, -0.008399988524615765, -0.05349309369921684, -0.036938559263944626, -0.007085126359015703, 0.0325707383453846, -0.004769966006278992, -0.013143443502485752, 0.00854360219091177, -0.008709851652383804, -0.04445568844676018, 0.02419900894165039, -0.028568407520651817, -0.011776288971304893, -0.03172958642244339, -0.013006145134568214, 0.06329203397035599, 0.0074880970641970634, -0.031736232340335846, -0.017793886363506317, -0.024048039689660072, 0.04900750517845154, 0.006740347947925329, -0.05204889550805092, -0.034517884254455566, -0.0035888205748051405, -0.017762061208486557, 0.01582404598593712, -0.01100904494524002, 0.04137019068002701, 0.00511896051466465, -0.0017725029028952122, -0.020761793479323387, 0.025569017976522446, -0.006175797898322344, -0.0030439042020589113, 0.039109449833631516, -0.012770269997417927, 0.019388997927308083, -0.0068820477463305, 0.01907714083790779, -0.022348398342728615, 0.006974211893975735, -0.0418018214404583, -0.0030640612822026014, -0.01579885743558407, -0.02673201449215412, -0.010131512768566608, 0.010499722324311733, -0.026459185406565666, -0.008063537068665028, -0.022234374657273293, 0.05639924481511116, -0.0443672239780426, -0.010421949438750744, 0.01993325725197792, -0.002698722993955016, -0.018081912770867348, 0.016381802037358284, -0.05091961845755577, 0.008253091014921665, 0.048808690160512924, 0.06222547963261604, 0.03508530184626579, -0.014347764663398266, -0.011234796606004238, 0.014748407527804375, 0.06280000507831573, -0.03557918965816498, -0.018268583342432976, 0.02407374233007431, -0.05736757442355156, -0.036542683839797974, -0.010046846233308315, -0.0018832245841622353, 0.014747818000614643, -0.00864854734390974, 0.010617009364068508, -0.025111518800258636, 0.04706374928355217, -0.02216823771595955, -0.03976273164153099, -0.01884130947291851, 0.006989551242440939, -0.012510141357779503, 0.02195076458156109, 0.013637569732964039, -0.013790717348456383, -0.032513175159692764, 0.007293311413377523, 0.05578588321805, -0.007097081281244755, -0.001402009278535843, 0.004029976204037666, -0.021372303366661072, 0.02216988056898117, 0.021742813289165497, -0.016529319807887077, 0.02686060033738613, 0.04156767576932907, -0.018383663147687912, 0.0034123181831091642, 0.02542233094573021, 0.022648552432656288, -0.08061114698648453, -0.014627971686422825, 0.010028274729847908, 0.0045553939417004585, 0.021496444940567017, -0.03544653207063675, 0.017997439950704575, 0.018969230353832245, -0.017410092055797577, 0.011051202192902565, 0.011162200011312962, 0.007925988174974918, -0.0021108733490109444, 0.033972714096307755, -0.006396056618541479, 0.029316507279872894, 0.025330007076263428, 0.01734926365315914, 0.048328399658203125, 0.008908377960324287, 0.003332704771310091, -0.007666740566492081, -0.04607178270816803, -0.04042498767375946, 0.00419401191174984, -0.030064096674323082, 0.011832287535071373, -0.04778637737035751, -0.033137209713459015, -0.005726533010601997, -0.0500294491648674, 0.00950536411255598, 0.016742615029215813, 0.041458312422037125, 0.0007111856248229742, 0.0580907016992569, -0.009781723842024803, -0.005250162910670042, -0.0032520287204533815, -0.013900776393711567, 0.039637792855501175, -0.0001071562510333024, -0.03317473828792572, 0.035772278904914856, 0.03287150338292122, -0.0036342942621558905, -0.018668003380298615, 0.01266710739582777, -0.02839900180697441, 0.01240064762532711, -0.052343226969242096, 0.01552050281316042, 0.044889599084854126, -0.037288498133420944, -0.015257438644766808, -0.022199660539627075, 0.019377602264285088, 0.0022645005956292152, 0.02628478780388832, 0.007744597736746073, 0.0034718953538686037, 0.01125449687242508, -0.008830216713249683, 0.01338303741067648, 0.011541574262082577, 0.02082916907966137, -0.03111865743994713, -0.016751568764448166, 0.006820271257311106, -0.01219921838492155, 0.005837287753820419, 0.0027666818350553513, -0.03138304501771927, 0.049088720232248306, -0.038402002304792404, 0.028085561469197273, 0.05932142585515976, -0.014956834726035595, 0.025192739441990852, -0.07259207218885422, 0.034590426832437515, 0.03212721645832062, 0.006287009455263615, -0.02644321136176586, -0.023077627643942833, -0.051416728645563126, 0.05736856162548065, 0.014494637958705425, 0.0036164172925055027, 0.018286295235157013, -0.04353037476539612, -0.002764680190011859, -0.004169688560068607, -0.0321064256131649, 0.06173716485500336, 0.0024387864395976067, -0.013346745632588863, -0.025701746344566345, 0.0035545630380511284, 0.04829536750912666, -0.014816226437687874, -0.018647776916623116, -0.0034899578895419836, -0.013668817467987537, -0.005413293372839689, -0.061776675283908844, 0.006101246923208237, 0.003294531023129821, -0.03428985923528671, 0.05022872984409332, -0.03992220386862755, 0.004218610934913158, 0.027730070054531097, 0.007130831480026245, -0.0032434791792184114, 0.02095014415681362, -0.03072494827210903, -0.03005027025938034, -0.004987399559468031, -0.002975494833663106, -0.020689254626631737, -0.05787237733602524, 0.016439536586403847, 0.004479460883885622, -0.04578821733593941, -0.015736587345600128, 0.013377548195421696, 0.030299806967377663, 0.06392518430948257, -0.0389762781560421, 0.03533150255680084, -0.02956838719546795, -0.014656804502010345, 0.005437309853732586, 0.02811487764120102, 0.02683231420814991, -0.019564321264624596, -0.003223283449187875, 0.030047399923205376, 0.003289412707090378, 0.005775045603513718, -0.03028532676398754, 0.02484213374555111, 0.020182650536298752, 0.006225499324500561, 0.02895507775247097, -0.016972588375210762, 0.046619828790426254, -0.0051132626831531525, 0.00036323038511909544, 0.03848138079047203, -0.0373687744140625, 0.01934635080397129, -0.010705770924687386, 0.006657187361270189, -0.009156824089586735, 0.010574986226856709, -0.02534579485654831, 0.010022994130849838, -0.031184829771518707, 0.001055696397088468, 0.0072530535981059074, -0.04587757959961891, -0.018681226298213005, -0.004979104269295931, -0.00626489007845521, -0.039507173001766205, -0.00626874016597867, 0.034319449216127396, -0.010848631151020527, -0.03486030548810959, 0.008761595003306866, 0.040727898478507996, 0.022532625123858452, -0.00814977940171957, -0.03409676253795624, 0.0062220655381679535, 0.012722046114504337, 0.033674221485853195, -0.037007275968790054, -0.025899959728121758, -0.013592513278126717, 0.011747825890779495, -0.03391150012612343, 0.013552405871450901 ]
<p>I know this is a fairly specific <code>R</code> question, but I may be thinking about proportion variance explained, $R^2$, incorrectly. Here goes.</p> <p>I'm trying to use the <code>R</code> package <code>randomForest</code>. I have some training data and testing data. When I fit a random forest model, the <code>randomForest</code> function allows you to input new testing data to test. It then tells you the percentage of variance explained in this new data. When I look at this, I get one number.</p> <p>When I use the <code>predict()</code> function to predict the outcome value of the testing data based on the model fit from the training data, and I take the squared correlation coefficient between these values and the <em>actual</em> outcome values for the testing data, I get a different number. <em>These values don't match up</em>. </p> <p>Here's some <code>R</code> code to demonstrate the problem.</p> <pre><code># use the built in iris data data(iris) #load the randomForest library library(randomForest) # split the data into training and testing sets index &lt;- 1:nrow(iris) trainindex &lt;- sample(index, trunc(length(index)/2)) trainset &lt;- iris[trainindex, ] testset &lt;- iris[-trainindex, ] # fit a model to the training set (column 1, Sepal.Length, will be the outcome) set.seed(42) model &lt;- randomForest(x=trainset[ ,-1],y=trainset[ ,1]) # predict values for the testing set (the first column is the outcome, leave it out) predicted &lt;- predict(model, testset[ ,-1]) # what's the squared correlation coefficient between predicted and actual values? cor(predicted, testset[, 1])^2 # now, refit the model using built-in x.test and y.test set.seed(42) randomForest(x=trainset[ ,-1], y=trainset[ ,1], xtest=testset[ ,-1], ytest=testset[ ,1]) </code></pre> <p>Thanks for any help you might be willing to lend.</p>
73,945
[ -0.023809079080820084, -0.023884868249297142, -0.007317225448787212, -0.003358925227075815, 0.03805668652057648, 0.01493989210575819, -0.03284914419054985, -0.047955192625522614, 0.026259807869791985, -0.00003946122160414234, 0.06098366528749466, 0.05354004725813866, 0.033545080572366714, 0.05206911638379097, 0.024929342791438103, 0.004465229343622923, -0.01706164889037609, 0.01622183807194233, 0.010374345816671848, -0.020949173718690872, -0.041391175240278244, 0.022198734804987907, 0.01207589078694582, -0.0062581258825957775, -0.04319700226187706, 0.0470038503408432, 0.023175187408924103, -0.027929645031690598, 0.011481386609375477, 0.028580129146575928, -0.0823332816362381, -0.049496959894895554, 0.020892243832349777, 0.01626339927315712, 0.040697090327739716, 0.011782144196331501, 0.027087951079010963, -0.02309371531009674, -0.015477537177503109, 0.016954921185970306, 0.01297737192362547, 0.01949595846235752, -0.009074085392057896, 0.06770588457584381, 0.0023899527732282877, 0.028638634830713272, -0.0028611887246370316, 0.0061920820735394955, 0.05299379676580429, -0.025324910879135132, 0.0581376850605011, -0.015070541761815548, 0.02636071853339672, 0.04181838780641556, -0.006361030507832766, -0.0201659444719553, 0.07866610586643219, 0.05872473865747452, -0.028001802042126656, -0.05676233395934105, -0.017625533044338226, -0.03889227285981178, -0.024315601214766502, 0.02253674902021885, -0.04603604972362518, -0.00436108885332942, 0.015697263181209564, -0.014260071329772472, 0.04627079516649246, -0.038290977478027344, 0.0693449079990387, 0.0496462881565094, 0.023348934948444366, -0.006912888493388891, 0.03342335298657417, -0.014490080066025257, 0.027873888611793518, 0.013436060398817062, 0.018299860879778862, 0.021440742537379265, 0.00231571844778955, 0.006494069006294012, 0.006591565907001495, 0.003673900617286563, 0.03806711733341217, -0.02253733202815056, 0.04032747447490692, 0.010003226809203625, 0.0277615524828434, 0.012261413969099522, -0.004123305901885033, 0.0041447230614721775, 0.06307578831911087, -0.004313220269978046, -0.02226753532886505, 0.06524976342916489, -0.02797301858663559, 0.026870595291256905, 0.013078958727419376, 0.015796003863215446, -0.05234604701399803, -0.05778123065829277, 0.01860734075307846, 0.06195363402366638, -0.07189075648784637, -0.05510147288441658, -0.017430640757083893, -0.031397439539432526, 0.005059983115643263, -0.013333417475223541, -0.012104704976081848, 0.006859155371785164, -0.006462888326495886, -0.0028591493610292673, 0.052422896027565, -0.04014214500784874, -0.010580748319625854, 0.0015930732479318976, 0.06227034330368042, 0.06392728537321091, 0.053920943289995193, -0.010575647465884686, 0.0032076158095151186, -0.030016837641596794, -0.023596249520778656, 0.019997257739305496, 0.008546659722924232, -0.035603560507297516, -0.017864704132080078, 0.00953690242022276, -0.009825821965932846, -0.009625321254134178, 0.019833913072943687, 0.0040709334425628185, 0.03216130658984184, -0.0031885073985904455, -0.0961737111210823, -0.06467075645923615, 0.011926255188882351, -0.026122882962226868, 0.008997946977615356, -0.03521014004945755, -0.005511593073606491, 0.00008742132922634482, 0.08542744815349579, -0.006998211611062288, 0.05107609182596207, -0.013153711333870888, -0.003578372998163104, 0.006427641026675701, -0.007105017080903053, 0.009052854962646961, -0.0017556764651089907, -0.020723896101117134, -0.03373750299215317, -0.03617018833756447, 0.021732382476329803, 0.02459467016160488, -0.03440103307366371, -0.014606376178562641, -0.00960288941860199, -0.03306502476334572, 0.0034031602554023266, -0.010990223847329617, -0.03494975343346596, -0.021496836096048355, 0.07604296505451202, 0.022301189601421356, 0.03789035230875015, -0.0024594904389232397, -0.033203985542058945, -0.011923620477318764, 0.026332702487707138, 0.02343807928264141, 0.055214788764715195, -0.016386883333325386, -0.002187935635447502, -0.03583703562617302, 0.010319290682673454, -0.010747008956968784, -0.03432423993945122, -0.04781857505440712, -0.009879079647362232, -0.020901888608932495, 0.029557710513472557, 0.002052196767181158, 0.009144516661763191, -0.005598137155175209, 0.06015486642718315, -0.0635182335972786, -0.0390922874212265, -0.0636545941233635, 0.012303141877055168, -0.03288451209664345, -0.030024047940969467, -0.02444976568222046, -0.00022650713799521327, 0.05465579032897949, 0.012578482739627361, -0.014222963713109493, -0.05211956799030304, 0.02394743636250496, 0.03762129321694374, -0.009206470102071762, 0.01544343214482069, 0.05592039227485657, 0.03487614169716835, -0.011326175183057785, 0.03126494213938713, -0.03515268862247467, -0.05260910466313362, 0.015367873013019562, -0.0351235568523407, -0.01635841093957424, -0.028684871271252632, -0.040571752935647964, 0.0144501943141222, 0.029541203752160072, -0.03286236152052879, 0.012759213335812092, -0.032414935529232025, 0.03572502359747887, 0.06092588230967522, 0.013204412534832954, 0.011853744275867939, -0.007871001027524471, -0.036053966730833054, 0.03104441799223423, -0.04081980511546135, -0.02050667256116867, -0.02568325400352478, -0.047242529690265656, 0.04185683652758598, 0.005933655891567469, 0.006596656050533056, -0.022914068773388863, 0.06902576237916946, -0.01308947242796421, 0.011873706243932247, 0.03286246955394745, 0.015048139728605747, -0.03195056691765785, 0.020717225968837738, -0.0011688577942550182, 0.018718747422099113, 0.0252618957310915, 0.013498956337571144, -0.01250558253377676, 0.034183721989393234, 0.00987859908491373, -0.014805924147367477, 0.031070297583937645, 0.010122168809175491, -0.006792592350393534, -0.033487118780612946, -0.021864917129278183, -0.022362856194376945, 0.001398959313519299, -0.025956451892852783, 0.022069154307246208, 0.045559003949165344, -0.0035187876783311367, -0.033835191279649734, -0.030904516577720642, 0.04728682339191437, 0.04953514784574509, -0.024892399087548256, 0.008170134387910366, 0.0139527078717947, -0.03036578558385372, 0.0077724759466946125, 0.01404657494276762, -0.02361910231411457, -0.08127101510763168, 0.039348069578409195, 0.03218020871281624, 0.012654905207455158, 0.013264278881251812, -0.017091790214180946, 0.018700188025832176, 0.002796716522425413, -0.0294550321996212, 0.016966018825769424, -0.04310915619134903, -0.03980099409818649, -0.020362218841910362, -0.02956727147102356, -0.0011021317914128304, 0.003640206065028906, 0.00037319373222999275, -0.04890807345509529, 0.0363629087805748, -0.020606838166713715, -0.043918341398239136, -0.0016502473736181855, -0.043641336262226105, 0.025488609448075294, -0.02155456878244877, -0.03541550412774086, 0.040315549820661545, -0.0126392412930727, -0.058696288615465164, 0.025217553600668907, -0.01741943694651127, 0.047079019248485565, -0.022256191819906235, -0.04580528289079666, 0.019027600064873695, 0.009017830714583397, 0.00942361168563366, 0.04137066751718521, 0.013291518203914165, -0.0332881361246109, -0.0446602962911129, -0.0314708948135376, -0.018631866201758385, 0.024570532143115997, 0.00035190407652407885, 0.0021511847153306007, 0.02357218787074089, 0.038669977337121964, 0.016167638823390007, -0.0037103877402842045, -0.03952116519212723, 0.025693504139780998, -0.028976136818528175, -0.03362809121608734, 0.014301941730082035, 0.026326017454266548, 0.0237957164645195, 0.00948413647711277, -0.02198142558336258, 0.04666006565093994, 0.03684264048933983, -0.004299729131162167, 0.007171275559812784, 0.019056573510169983, 0.021587787196040154, -0.03198472037911415, 0.04879321530461311, 0.0273923147469759, -0.01617959327995777, 0.0318538136780262, -0.01380098145455122, -0.004596480634063482, 0.0009718064684420824, -0.0472160167992115, 0.018735438585281372, -0.020455943420529366, 0.06251814216375351, -0.026634763926267624, 0.01656334288418293, -0.020579954609274864, -0.03901361674070358, -0.04321596026420593, -0.01204365398734808, 0.06243447586894035, 0.01504433061927557, -0.01946306601166725, 0.024653540924191475, 0.003291358472779393, -0.02497616969048977, 0.0038733500987291336, -0.044741079211235046, -0.036416877061128616, 0.02034471556544304, -0.01440656092017889, 0.0014956301311030984, 0.06327398121356964, 0.033294592052698135, 0.018876323476433754, -0.006371738389134407, -0.022300975397229195, 0.013960117474198341, -0.005818051286041737, 0.020447812974452972, -0.059386253356933594, 0.04061952605843544, 0.025807933881878853, 0.06534777581691742, 0.014583960175514221, -0.0194612517952919, 0.029221460223197937, 0.025371059775352478, -0.03990083932876587, 0.02524561621248722, 0.0468023456633091, -0.04205508157610893, -0.027679722756147385, -0.024206172674894333, 0.012238643132150173, -0.0037076722364872694, 0.01731528528034687, 0.006676402874290943, -0.003151550656184554, 0.0008569298661313951, 0.049899447709321976, 0.0031069964170455933, 0.009787951596081257, 0.0036391958128660917, 0.03416170924901962, 0.033685751259326935, -0.023834198713302612, 0.003770046168938279, 0.0003987625241279602, -0.01040829811245203, -0.00030394448549486697, -0.04375895485281944, -0.026727735996246338, 0.055476799607276917, 0.05678553134202957, 0.05423528328537941, -0.02685151994228363, -0.04668738320469856, 0.019089244306087494, -0.017696738243103027, 0.01905043236911297, 0.0694742277264595, -0.0033832653425633907, -0.002351160626858473, 0.01220407709479332, -0.011801250278949738, 0.009301196783781052, -0.012226726859807968, 0.013733607716858387, -0.0049337344244122505, 0.04268353804945946, 0.05904757231473923, -0.006989028304815292, -0.010063987225294113, 0.03812292590737343, -0.023698056116700172, 0.003995534032583237, -0.016283145174384117, -0.004740727599710226, -0.0004333831602707505, -0.01800519973039627, 0.011828087270259857, 0.01256506983190775, -0.019862167537212372, 0.008238300681114197, 0.03329960256814957, -0.046473294496536255, -0.015194297768175602, 0.014540628530085087, 0.014780811034142971, 0.046821918338537216, -0.03308017551898956, -0.02155989222228527, -0.0234974417835474, 0.04853014647960663, -0.0002018543891608715, 0.01957830972969532, 0.014164648950099945, -0.051671888679265976, 0.0024811711627990007, 0.05276000127196312, 0.02602643147110939, -0.03599859029054642, -0.008712430484592915, -0.04558747634291649, -0.003969692159444094, 0.02206599898636341, -0.0388629212975502, -0.0001770769158611074, -0.0051551866345107555, 0.011858531273901463, -0.00630234507843852, -0.03135368600487709, -0.07462646067142487, 0.004100834485143423, -0.058505620807409286, 0.03505780175328255, -0.013095978647470474, -0.05548117309808731, -0.017068330198526382, -0.018437329679727554, 0.002439559902995825, 0.07297736406326294, -0.05838549882173538, -0.008576001040637493, -0.0022481591440737247, 0.003933263942599297, 0.008774599060416222, -0.05936865881085396, 0.004839231260120869, 0.0010555919725447893, 0.01053321547806263, 0.031264759600162506, -0.0252989474684, -0.016056805849075317, 0.028962157666683197, 0.01653146557509899, -0.03283986076712608, -0.00818697176873684, -0.045709311962127686, 0.046039145439863205, 0.039596810936927795, 0.012244715355336666, 0.058584682643413544, 0.022394191473722458, 0.007154777646064758, 0.02450147084891796, -0.06364226341247559, 0.00716042798012495, -0.008571290411055088, -0.026452142745256424, -0.04920177534222603, -0.012743094936013222, -0.014008347876369953, 0.009145130403339863, -0.006632496137171984, 0.03658507019281387, -0.07363782823085785, 0.013188951648771763, 0.002238141605630517, 0.030415473505854607, -0.03923023119568825, -0.00013576680794358253, 0.018634043633937836, 0.0005435915663838387, -0.022107228636741638, 0.016529271379113197, 0.010603172704577446, -0.006098768208175898, 0.0112365847453475, 0.017023863270878792, -0.041769612580537796, 0.007150636985898018, -0.028676863759756088, 0.006713496055454016, 0.014009291306138039, -0.017742440104484558, 0.00490168109536171, 0.0125821428373456, 0.036974284797906876, 0.008682427927851677, -0.004330560099333525, -0.020680278539657593, 0.029173169285058975, -0.004621659871190786, -0.004118031356483698, -0.008546123281121254, -0.026241593062877655, 0.003682417096570134, -0.024037940427660942, -0.046269748359918594, -0.012677126564085484, 0.0008714044815860689, -0.042238593101501465, -0.011042002588510513, -0.06605350971221924, -0.05002160370349884, 0.005644085351377726, -0.01166133675724268, -0.01458517275750637, 0.03929438441991806, -0.039511553943157196, 0.01467191893607378, -0.05495529621839523, -0.016165686771273613, 0.06952626258134842, -0.0214829258620739, 0.0006794228684157133, 0.025896189734339714, -0.013503826223313808, -0.03306189551949501, 0.04641130566596985, -0.0008449839078821242, -0.02352493442595005, 0.002209913218393922, -0.023148490116000175, 0.017253786325454712, 0.05567827820777893, 0.041031867265701294, -0.03732063248753548, -0.023768791928887367, 0.013691594824194908, 0.019521569833159447, -0.042391058057546616, -0.006214851979166269, 0.03210403025150299, -0.006546013988554478, -0.017056189477443695, 0.0036777188070118427, -0.03921828418970108, -0.008547860197722912, 0.02083144336938858, -0.018673844635486603, 0.026362592354416847, 0.01735500432550907, 0.1049799993634224, -0.03357986733317375, 0.016710732132196426, -0.011834274977445602, -0.02794831432402134, 0.027451451867818832, 0.02306569181382656, 0.01739583909511566, -0.011865870095789433, 0.05172388255596161, -0.036577921360731125, 0.016993260011076927, -0.019863983616232872, -0.014547181315720081, 0.0701860785484314, -0.0005548007320612669, 0.06210651248693466, 0.06683354079723358, -0.018806377425789833, 0.02582760713994503, -0.05487476661801338, -0.008634970523416996, -0.020261816680431366, 0.04002419114112854, 0.046758756041526794, 0.026343928650021553, 0.0037903431802988052, 0.034715235233306885, 0.04571447893977165, 0.0289912112057209, 0.054510314017534256, 0.0049272808246314526, 0.0007414465653710067, 0.009853571653366089, -0.026410115882754326, -0.05439988896250725, 0.04026767984032631, 0.007697401102632284, -0.006404774729162455, -0.009520722553133965, 0.005679082125425339, 0.07018948346376419, 0.039749354124069214, -0.022377634420990944, -0.011561381630599499, -0.02659538760781288, -0.0489090271294117, -0.023990487679839134, -0.0037199456710368395, -0.06254863739013672, 0.006270471960306168, 0.011718722060322762, 0.011596151627600193, -0.03360414132475853, 0.02254389598965645, -0.054832808673381805, -0.08889245986938477, -0.04183557257056236, -0.019177714362740517, -0.009759815409779549, 0.022754119709134102, 0.004421190824359655, -0.0005503523861989379, -0.012575539760291576, -0.044152144342660904, 0.03617328405380249, 0.012762688100337982, 0.023508884012699127, -0.0238431915640831, 0.019719505682587624, -0.00005506663001142442, 0.0018096010899171233, -0.017482498660683632, -0.02508225478231907, 0.1560605764389038, 0.060230135917663574, 0.04652896523475647, -0.04776514694094658, -0.003461083397269249, -0.006662085186690092, -0.013005339540541172, -0.00824586022645235, -0.023375390097498894, 0.019913408905267715, -0.0059015778824687, 0.05559537187218666, 0.008415760472416878, 0.05344156175851822, -0.037872277200222015, -0.0016403382178395987, -0.005577250849455595, -0.02812092937529087, -0.004772210493683815, 0.007874468341469765, -0.02221696265041828, -0.025219354778528214, -0.051979295909404755, -0.011669485829770565, 0.014230921864509583, 0.015498199500143528, -0.0263375211507082, 0.00015350487956311554, -0.0040620965883135796, 0.005078519228845835, -0.0072920420207083225, -0.008067685179412365, -0.007457916624844074, 0.011353657580912113, 0.01964222453534603, 0.00011443760013207793, 0.02479570172727108, 0.01225193403661251, -0.019057605415582657, 0.009374069981276989, 0.006639366503804922, -0.010328421369194984, -0.022781960666179657, 0.04810947924852371, -0.058355409651994705, -0.025501811876893044, -0.039017193019390106, 0.05404357239603996, 0.011213533580303192, -0.07117196172475815, 0.006447547115385532, 0.001607534708455205, 0.029701001942157745, -0.04231274500489235, 0.010504672303795815, 0.037750326097011566, 0.023251885548233986, -0.020385026931762695, 0.017242830246686935, 0.01924750953912735, 0.028960933908820152, -0.018485916778445244, 0.021268505603075027, 0.022572971880435944, 0.000702455872669816, -0.02052685059607029, -0.06838393211364746, 0.028610989451408386, 0.013492993079125881, 0.04487227275967598, 0.013393728993833065, -0.021438565105199814, 0.005432644858956337, -0.0028149865102022886, 0.02887343429028988, 0.030047379434108734, 0.020888676866889, -0.035628270357847214, 0.004812241066247225, -0.021157102659344673, -0.016417400911450386, 0.006116650998592377, -0.01429551001638174, -0.00691682193428278, -0.039790455251932144, 0.00364315090700984, 0.009945112280547619, 0.03005831502377987, 0.058086175471544266, 0.01610894314944744, -0.020652268081903458, 0.04202885553240776, 0.0003957881417591125, -0.021355969831347466, -0.039068497717380524, 0.017086463049054146, -0.02837498113512993, -0.010285301133990288, 0.016882121562957764, 0.06456854194402695, 0.052801456302404404, 0.05484768748283386, -0.03975461795926094, 0.00004976285345037468, 0.007695215288549662, -0.006994232535362244, 0.02220691367983818, -0.012456807307898998, -0.005399760324507952, 0.018366996198892593, 0.023875918239355087, -0.04024806618690491, -0.01809193752706051, -0.040941957384347916, -0.07097185403108597, 0.023767992854118347, 0.012549988925457, -0.05703475698828697, 0.0014868867583572865, 0.0008015188504941761, 0.018239635974168777, -0.05100274085998535, -0.038047194480895996, -0.037481505423784256, -0.024699535220861435, -0.014159094542264938, -0.0535113699734211, -0.011106980964541435, 0.012386930175125599, -0.009593063034117222, 0.011438029818236828, 0.03620283305644989, -0.006390518043190241, 0.01274645235389471, 0.0010534102329984307, 0.0035271490924060345, 0.016494251787662506, 0.01849127560853958, 0.0022948412224650383, -0.0043618218041956425, 0.04212435334920883, -0.05763598904013634, -0.0362996943295002, 0.03153134137392044, 0.000587775488384068, 0.05541424825787544, -0.021564049646258354, -0.003163510700687766, -0.030359644442796707, 0.05975341796875, -0.02061554230749607, -0.02000919170677662, -0.03609462454915047, 0.018595008179545403, 0.04769326373934746, 0.008766737766563892, 0.019373111426830292, -0.0199664868414402, 0.017880501225590706, 0.02085038088262081, 0.02696395479142666, 0.004976012744009495, -0.006933942437171936, 0.020046288147568703, -0.04928803816437721, 0.00296658743172884, 0.01514307502657175, -0.015472590923309326, -0.027943680062890053, 0.03600294515490532, -0.03026632033288479, 0.05669228732585907, -0.00760556710883975, 0.010678370483219624, -0.10202838480472565, -0.046059057116508484, 0.006954316049814224, 0.05319130793213844, 0.011248394846916199, -0.017448199912905693, -0.03476979583501816, 0.012830881401896477, -0.05231281369924545, 0.034990403801202774, 0.00791124813258648, -0.020478881895542145, -0.03011905960738659, 0.021990323439240456, -0.0488346666097641, -0.0002700616605579853, 0.04626758024096489, 0.027277952060103416, 0.032062631100416183, 0.009213507175445557, 0.00870111770927906, -0.03600569814443588, -0.02278802916407585, 0.02780700847506523, -0.0013339824508875608, -0.04355708882212639, 0.02761073410511017, -0.00447069201618433, -0.008091502822935581, 0.02082695998251438, 0.002222587587311864, 0.013387241400778294, 0.044073767960071564, 0.04509415477514267, 0.03444087132811546, 0.050995681434869766, 0.023881586268544197, -0.004864746704697609, 0.00512358732521534, -0.026037907227873802, 0.01547685544937849, -0.0023879227228462696, -0.015304495580494404, 0.021693265065550804, 0.011873253621160984, 0.01937832683324814, -0.0007164418348111212, 0.06871390342712402, -0.05174768716096878, -0.020998062565922737, -0.017057247459888458, 0.010535276494920254, -0.011388772167265415, -0.04504653811454773, 0.0028293977957218885, -0.03827260062098503, 0.030902033671736717, 0.059026625007390976, 0.023500703275203705, -0.0004757962597068399, 0.007137424778193235, 0.0033316013868898153, -0.0031185888219624758, -0.007884065620601177, 0.023089805617928505, 0.014609549194574356, -0.0407230369746685, -0.03521613031625748, -0.012610895559191704, -0.02009950578212738, -0.0030631457921117544, 0.002494134707376361, -0.018267245963215828, 0.03205716237425804, 0.009141065180301666, -0.00033820810494944453, 0.0077753448858857155, -0.021311867982149124, 0.009469440206885338, -0.10773668438196182, 0.04799928888678551, -0.013381656259298325, -0.0402255617082119, -0.032126590609550476, 0.04005790501832962, -0.041784074157476425, 0.051764413714408875, 0.020851798355579376, 0.0253777913749218, 0.014296221546828747, -0.008035872131586075, 0.028109049424529076, 0.03083154745399952, -0.07722644507884979, 0.03454522043466568, 0.004706638865172863, -0.012999391183257103, -0.03582044690847397, -0.031082088127732277, 0.018055591732263565, 0.0181206613779068, -0.008084077388048172, -0.014981122687458992, 0.004635425750166178, 0.004702432081103325, -0.01960933208465576, 0.04594090208411217, -0.0007929591229185462, 0.007143107708543539, 0.043908145278692245, -0.008353264071047306, 0.010523291304707527, 0.06469949334859848, 0.006502658594399691, -0.01880836673080921, -0.00897234957665205, -0.04744851216673851, -0.016671165823936462, 0.011054285801947117, 0.030459722504019737, 0.03151288628578186, -0.030818844214081764, 0.007762670051306486, 0.0322534553706646, -0.015942560508847237, -0.010974272154271603, 0.04699406400322914, 0.006297278683632612, 0.028685418888926506, 0.02634539268910885, 0.01597379706799984, -0.001937712193466723, -0.038802992552518845, 0.001484078005887568, -0.013166221790015697, 0.029131580144166946, -0.02432401478290558, -0.023748978972434998, 0.03285829350352287, -0.03743797540664673, -0.0010742922313511372, -0.05050283297896385, 0.05507350713014603, -0.03247138485312462, -0.0015198725741356611, -0.010491541586816311, -0.03242890536785126, 0.03139558061957359, -0.0008280680049210787, 0.00277331261895597, 0.018374353647232056, -0.0611245334148407, 0.031244928017258644, -0.04447721689939499, -0.03355719894170761, -0.005028606858104467, 0.012992938980460167, 0.030104614794254303, 0.04305031895637512, 0.026688016951084137, 0.03564491868019104, 0.022728944197297096, -0.02054678276181221, 0.05216890200972557, -0.018161555752158165, 0.004495211411267519, -0.0032745113130658865, -0.01864783838391304, 0.00778990751132369, 0.0020487173460423946, -0.030027231201529503, -0.03719153255224228, 0.029400749132037163, 0.03218080848455429, -0.009013322181999683, -0.032658908516168594, 0.00014775498129893094, 0.042497508227825165, 0.0424627922475338, -0.03586522117257118, -0.014786738902330399, -0.027972886338829994, 0.031401004642248154, 0.01247705053538084, -0.04050286114215851 ]
<p>I found the following posts interesting and I was wondering if any of you guys know of good academic papers that describe methods/relationships of exogenous variables in VECM models. If so could you kindly point them out to me as I am very interested in learning. Thank you.</p> <p><a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/4030/finding-coefficients-for-vecm-exogenous-variables">Finding coefficients for VECM + exogenous variables</a></p> <p><a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/6487/lagged-exogenous-variables-in-vecm-with-r">Lagged Exogenous Variables in VECM with R</a></p>
48,143
[ -0.020172521471977234, -0.050392650067806244, 0.007357705384492874, 0.01826690137386322, 0.02482215128839016, 0.0268482007086277, -0.01673622988164425, -0.001519950688816607, 0.04897680506110191, -0.04956953227519989, -0.01071778405457735, 0.04371058940887451, 0.04486500099301338, 0.02070300653576851, 0.03201396018266678, 0.006790804676711559, -0.0012837954564020038, 0.0020659719593822956, 0.019779935479164124, 0.02840198390185833, -0.025472400709986687, 0.0078026228584349155, 0.03663789853453636, -0.00024051930813584477, -0.02912793681025505, 0.032998841255903244, -0.0037867454811930656, 0.01736980862915516, -0.04660400003194809, 0.03901267051696777, 0.0344555638730526, 0.016297081485390663, -0.040377967059612274, 0.02705300599336624, -0.011655007489025593, 0.012602278962731361, -0.027926618233323097, -0.03045228123664856, 0.04371209070086479, 0.03540308400988579, -0.04158883914351463, -0.008701740764081478, -0.001400982029736042, 0.0456961914896965, -0.007729798089712858, -0.0023822723887860775, 0.034002285450696945, -0.021920926868915558, 0.030283445492386818, -0.019732076674699783, 0.08586086332798004, 0.009928135201334953, 0.02848239615559578, 0.05606355145573616, 0.0150051424279809, 0.014081963337957859, 0.029898682609200478, 0.043455593287944794, 0.02669496089220047, -0.011733989231288433, -0.005966972094029188, -0.038595620542764664, -0.02081582136452198, -0.015496799722313881, -0.06284869462251663, 0.05410096421837807, 0.009062445722520351, -0.012184830382466316, 0.06664157658815384, 0.01244888361543417, 0.04084986448287964, -0.011444390751421452, 0.030730849131941795, -0.0010660577099770308, -0.0030739300418645144, 0.005244836676865816, -0.020499175414443016, -0.004867845214903355, 0.02025081403553486, 0.04132983833551407, -0.006616934668272734, 0.01303719263523817, 0.03052341565489769, 0.058005861937999725, 0.004583881702274084, 0.0050552296452224255, 0.0659492090344429, -0.04802253097295761, 0.01712934859097004, 0.05057393014431, -0.0278529804199934, 0.015835022553801537, 0.03417449817061424, 0.040586769580841064, -0.07176712155342102, 0.029984718188643456, -0.007676556706428528, 0.03628385439515114, 0.0548875592648983, -0.0005074097425676882, -0.03753038868308067, -0.03800543025135994, -0.009048587642610073, 0.055731598287820816, -0.03460192307829857, -0.013442177325487137, -0.017803141847252846, 0.028995411470532417, -0.04829397052526474, -0.040470853447914124, -0.022451745346188545, 0.006133961025625467, 0.012095075100660324, 0.013900251127779484, 0.02413264848291874, -0.018491720780730247, 0.0176321342587471, -0.04410121962428093, 0.04537810757756233, 0.05777990445494652, 0.05846638232469559, -0.02681889757514, 0.040551234036684036, -0.03161471709609032, -0.09593134373426437, -0.008042487315833569, 0.033151786774396896, -0.01767340488731861, -0.018766196444630623, 0.05737457796931267, 0.026186656206846237, -0.01615438237786293, 0.013318737037479877, -0.004474058747291565, 0.04641258344054222, 0.004339081700891256, -0.05273689329624176, -0.06020793691277504, 0.06666017323732376, -0.017813272774219513, 0.037143729627132416, -0.029596557840704918, -0.023220345377922058, 0.0057909502647817135, 0.043870922178030014, 0.0206085704267025, -0.018769312649965286, -0.022574935108423233, 0.03828226774930954, 0.010946004651486874, -0.03731301426887512, -0.029139237478375435, 0.022670289501547813, -0.001638968475162983, -0.01390896551311016, -0.09820778667926788, 0.014485355466604233, 0.04610806703567505, 0.0030444273725152016, 0.006511267274618149, 0.06975488364696503, 0.030480269342660904, -0.029833059757947922, -0.0194997638463974, -0.0022002612240612507, -0.005209500901401043, 0.025966651737689972, -0.019514143466949463, 0.028018997982144356, -0.011978644877672195, 0.04020267724990845, 0.03701891750097275, 0.022848336026072502, 0.02721024490892887, 0.03575736656785011, -0.04677619785070419, 0.007655396591871977, 0.015657417476177216, 0.020332975313067436, 0.02585524693131447, -0.03024939075112343, -0.060929328203201294, -0.005569285247474909, 0.0012656365288421512, 0.0003086626238655299, 0.04991106316447258, -0.017185062170028687, 0.0057322802022099495, 0.030400408431887627, -0.06323931366205215, -0.04070327803492546, -0.04447504132986069, 0.025232749059796333, 0.0031812796369194984, -0.018275300040841103, 0.045381225645542145, -0.015768105164170265, 0.026890382170677185, -0.001435593469068408, -0.03272412344813347, -0.012269803322851658, -0.011599563993513584, 0.058158744126558304, 0.012061933986842632, -0.010654977522790432, -0.025247573852539062, 0.035176005214452744, 0.0025477444287389517, 0.01913464441895485, -0.030592987313866615, -0.05616505816578865, 0.017505817115306854, -0.0319894440472126, 0.05938888341188431, -0.013800828717648983, -0.010041959583759308, 0.006704248487949371, 0.0076206764206290245, -0.00537945656105876, 0.058517102152109146, -0.06342725455760956, 0.03688982129096985, 0.08893072605133057, 0.03362539783120155, -0.025445761159062386, 0.038064032793045044, 0.024928685277700424, 0.04066787287592888, -0.02350585348904133, -0.021285738795995712, -0.030711648985743523, -0.034567564725875854, 0.04450714588165283, -0.020571265369653702, -0.032557521015405655, 0.02501237951219082, 0.035002317279577255, 0.04516952857375145, 0.02564767189323902, 0.02263815887272358, 0.003544016508385539, -0.009006334468722343, -0.015475918538868427, 0.06545073539018631, 0.0012582145864143968, 0.030899761244654655, 0.0017571131465956569, 0.020002223551273346, 0.03728579357266426, -0.004696655087172985, -0.019204039126634598, 0.05472167953848839, 0.016638170927762985, -0.014610802754759789, -0.0070634037256240845, -0.020018218085169792, 0.07152068614959717, -0.04308639094233513, 0.011239181272685528, 0.027379265055060387, 0.04346977546811104, 0.0068245865404605865, -0.01984281837940216, -0.007496897131204605, 0.035484228283166885, 0.0296531580388546, -0.045771997421979904, 0.02446679212152958, 0.014535650610923767, -0.025834426283836365, 0.015050712041556835, -0.023172464221715927, -0.03353915736079216, -0.06634797155857086, -0.012763461098074913, 0.0026920409873127937, 0.005607388913631439, 0.015155784785747528, -0.006841487251222134, -0.013303803279995918, 0.019252175465226173, 0.004094030242413282, -0.019436582922935486, 0.010849417187273502, -0.02199583686888218, 0.03986891731619835, -0.028776444494724274, -0.006069929338991642, 0.029814792796969414, -0.0192335844039917, -0.0471019521355629, 0.035749081522226334, -0.008797326125204563, -0.062009286135435104, -0.026896493509411812, 0.021756978705525398, 0.008494696579873562, 0.004667662084102631, -0.0017845883267000318, -0.019128896296024323, 0.002011772245168686, -0.03647243231534958, 0.02748434990644455, -0.061757247895002365, -0.018106764182448387, -0.012932011857628822, -0.016233248636126518, 0.004432487301528454, -0.029018178582191467, 0.04643953964114189, 0.023887859657406807, -0.03556373715400696, -0.01552801113575697, -0.09410422295331955, -0.07237554341554642, 0.013863956555724144, -0.006534940097481012, 0.03719651699066162, 0.006879507098346949, -0.05754673108458519, 0.06328225135803223, 0.027538297697901726, -0.03285255283117294, -0.0245578121393919, -0.0033226937521249056, -0.02163786068558693, 0.008355502970516682, 0.021240359172225, 0.032016776502132416, -0.006936653982847929, 0.0071038673631846905, 0.00224508810788393, 0.015120179392397404, 0.039490848779678345, -0.00687436806038022, 0.03977542743086815, 0.013383890502154827, -0.013898545876145363, -0.013240743428468704, 0.04155000299215317, 0.038892075419425964, -0.02421504072844982, 0.024946847930550575, 0.023871131241321564, 0.053670141845941544, 0.019384926185011864, -0.033978141844272614, -0.0011250078678131104, 0.013594847172498703, -0.03544672206044197, -0.05568021163344383, 0.018671158701181412, 0.025494705885648727, 0.0005762669024989009, -0.005419875495135784, 0.0069464510306715965, 0.013529444113373756, 0.0011112559586763382, -0.011249569244682789, 0.04244186729192734, 0.03902662545442581, -0.03481009230017662, -0.023011911660432816, -0.025815140455961227, -0.0044603245332837105, 0.022200539708137512, -0.04772627726197243, 0.021800082176923752, 0.06496648490428925, 0.014091401360929012, -0.016128621995449066, -0.05750938132405281, -0.041476476937532425, 0.02289803884923458, -0.08446072041988373, 0.007428259588778019, -0.02936985157430172, 0.020578814670443535, 0.011037579737603664, 0.04024415463209152, -0.04459888115525246, -0.008538652211427689, 0.03733689710497856, -0.0038145240396261215, -0.04764000326395035, -0.003175164572894573, -0.04405410587787628, -0.006399177946150303, 0.013395809568464756, 0.001340349204838276, 0.06011408194899559, -0.0008191366214305162, -0.044942568987607956, -0.011112102307379246, 0.009180571883916855, -0.015018544159829617, 0.007753787562251091, -0.03302328288555145, -0.05719568952918053, 0.006003717426210642, -0.020225737243890762, 0.03002738207578659, -0.046321138739585876, 0.0202438086271286, 0.07078487426042557, -0.014174421317875385, -0.033066004514694214, -0.030563103035092354, -0.0060775806196033955, 0.03210090473294258, 0.03560696542263031, 0.03173540532588959, -0.01810220070183277, -0.032900482416152954, 0.05586640164256096, -0.012076337821781635, 0.019731709733605385, 0.03005862422287464, -0.011311986483633518, -0.06391575932502747, -0.0336102731525898, -0.021458560600876808, 0.010613144375383854, 0.0019038055324926972, 0.03573659807443619, 0.012506622821092606, 0.06459765136241913, 0.01924610137939453, -0.021230850368738174, 0.009969795122742653, 0.02594814822077751, 0.0032605149317532778, 0.028017962351441383, -0.04367710277438164, 0.007433637045323849, 0.024951990693807602, 0.009521130472421646, 0.0158209390938282, 0.01391622144728899, -0.010121630504727364, -0.0009785250294953585, 0.02171305939555168, -0.005399724002927542, 0.003940301481634378, 0.020499039441347122, 0.0195865910500288, 0.035004060715436935, -0.024212919175624847, -0.07968582212924957, 0.028334401547908783, 0.05883265659213066, 0.0385110080242157, -0.009462479501962662, -0.0020974199287593365, -0.0961192324757576, 0.005447836127132177, 0.0519191138446331, 0.026926446706056595, -0.07285059243440628, 0.017316313460469246, -0.05911435931921005, -0.0032468391582369804, 0.03365762531757355, -0.030973926186561584, -0.00002017140832322184, -0.025395208969712257, -0.002994437702000141, -0.007615149952471256, -0.04079480096697807, -0.03288143500685692, -0.00265873852185905, -0.0059251743368804455, 0.02512051910161972, -0.02648431807756424, -0.031564146280288696, -0.01132153533399105, 0.03192797303199768, 0.03171776980161667, 0.02854411117732525, -0.0000055350515140162315, -0.016712572425603867, 0.015711143612861633, 0.03296397626399994, -0.04302776977419853, -0.0390179306268692, 0.019998902454972267, 0.017971722409129143, -0.00899999774992466, 0.05745626240968704, -0.007871853187680244, -0.02344101294875145, 0.019707344472408295, -0.00983000174164772, -0.05578070506453514, -0.024104904383420944, -0.04874700307846069, 0.05508292838931084, 0.031158871948719025, -0.014521092176437378, 0.04943130165338516, 0.06390506029129028, -0.011023283936083317, 0.0022636444773525, -0.0025301522109657526, 0.01640390418469906, -0.021992571651935577, -0.016518233343958855, -0.05249376967549324, -0.03773006424307823, -0.014082172885537148, 0.005192236974835396, -0.01112062856554985, 0.030253853648900986, -0.04142171889543533, -0.012497471645474434, -0.007085574325174093, 0.033731214702129364, -0.0010528985876590014, -0.02874569222331047, -0.006174334790557623, 0.01569342240691185, 0.011577241122722626, -0.006679882295429707, 0.029742371290922165, -0.031407810747623444, -0.016787337139248848, -0.01671750098466873, -0.04256010055541992, -0.020323166623711586, -0.023503033444285393, 0.006238824687898159, 0.022039342671632767, -0.04375327751040459, 0.010594026185572147, -0.010344448499381542, 0.002116800518706441, -0.014698502607643604, -0.04385068267583847, -0.03609872981905937, -0.0005669203819707036, 0.007672923617064953, 0.016534456983208656, -0.009741825051605701, -0.010337268002331257, -0.0065007018856704235, -0.00825709942728281, -0.05137019604444504, -0.05647823214530945, -0.017794553190469742, -0.05977149307727814, 0.0018374758074060082, -0.051173340529203415, 0.054368894547224045, -0.03696433827280998, -0.02904571406543255, 0.0015180155169218779, 0.060992639511823654, -0.034230612218379974, 0.010646287351846695, -0.021897627040743828, 0.042128901928663254, 0.03889083117246628, -0.009724545292556286, -0.0014408256392925978, 0.02716122381389141, 0.0037529459223151207, -0.008043142966926098, 0.012460917234420776, 0.01065028551965952, 0.0034157277550548315, 0.011374402791261673, -0.0010025453520938754, -0.006911089178174734, 0.03883584961295128, -0.013573337346315384, -0.01607309654355049, 0.05747336894273758, -0.0032829362899065018, 0.016220862045884132, -0.05153539404273033, 0.019201813265681267, 0.0027656806632876396, 0.016113534569740295, -0.0015706605045124888, 0.016028493642807007, 0.0019612666219472885, -0.021925030276179314, 0.05633701756596565, -0.02286411263048649, -0.02380928210914135, 0.03200378268957138, 0.0724630206823349, -0.029612017795443535, 0.02261856570839882, 0.048558179289102554, 0.0027081749867647886, 0.020139623433351517, -0.032696448266506195, 0.02373218536376953, -0.006770727690309286, 0.012931683100759983, -0.05627685412764549, -0.04985891282558441, -0.02125464379787445, 0.024434691295027733, 0.07069537043571472, 0.026340462267398834, 0.05077840015292168, 0.04520943760871887, -0.03522409126162529, -0.014826740138232708, -0.04006970301270485, -0.008656325750052929, 0.04731477051973343, -0.021958736702799797, 0.04880568012595177, -0.055178429931402206, 0.016174692660570145, 0.02523256652057171, 0.03725021705031395, -0.004174171481281519, 0.008859207853674889, -0.018493596464395523, 0.018403535708785057, 0.029818646609783173, -0.028117096051573753, -0.014220130629837513, 0.02336256578564644, -0.033363983035087585, 0.02774924412369728, -0.0429392084479332, -0.015405985526740551, 0.04491559416055679, 0.03671922907233238, 0.003084221389144659, -0.0651276633143425, -0.04985331743955612, -0.054424893110990524, 0.029447654262185097, 0.02465338073670864, -0.016125323250889778, 0.028502652421593666, 0.0153152821585536, 0.056978851556777954, -0.027655789628624916, 0.021577170118689537, -0.03956722095608711, -0.09346877783536911, -0.004793825093656778, -0.004807846155017614, -0.01640954054892063, 0.031313780695199966, -0.003413414116948843, -0.027049431577324867, 0.01089954562485218, -0.05550363287329674, -0.013940433971583843, -0.002984873717650771, 0.009147175587713718, 0.0006551935221068561, 0.09182140976190567, -0.04752040281891823, 0.0011790671851485968, -0.020001811906695366, -0.005195076577365398, 0.10685727745294571, 0.03867913410067558, 0.017474407330155373, -0.07266842573881149, 0.03192597255110741, 0.042844146490097046, 0.009057785384356976, -0.05168787017464638, 0.011503864079713821, 0.0017350416164845228, 0.017096418887376785, 0.0255722776055336, 0.05997511371970177, 0.013954528607428074, 0.028834475204348564, 0.04728839546442032, -0.006750559899955988, -0.020260611549019814, -0.02900109253823757, -0.020953083410859108, -0.009195581078529358, 0.01336886640638113, -0.015894819051027298, 0.02797883190214634, -0.010226385667920113, -0.03379736840724945, -0.036738257855176926, -0.008092522621154785, 0.04264417290687561, -0.02630726620554924, 0.0047515868209302425, -0.012076283805072308, 0.009312433190643787, 0.036591801792383194, 0.015251986682415009, -0.03417466953396797, 0.023249447345733643, -0.022230802103877068, 0.030689306557178497, 0.02087400294840336, -0.008023330010473728, -0.014884546399116516, 0.006426229607313871, -0.010171831585466862, -0.03780139610171318, -0.0018387478776276112, -0.04020066559314728, 0.05293997377157211, -0.023896392434835434, -0.016740964725613594, -0.004705611150711775, 0.00851843785494566, 0.0010423073545098305, 0.0038929651491343975, -0.046338047832250595, 0.04249018430709839, 0.007890567183494568, -0.0743163526058197, 0.008142272010445595, -0.04202495887875557, 0.012083841487765312, 0.002172650769352913, 0.03517366945743561, 0.028549987822771072, -0.05915692076086998, -0.005235934164375067, -0.0392451286315918, 0.028920462355017662, -0.013510304503142834, -0.04192438721656799, 0.030987927690148354, 0.014608640223741531, -0.01610264740884304, -0.004705292638391256, -0.014352671802043915, 0.0015921443700790405, 0.012337913736701012, -0.009599869139492512, -0.0070765670388937, 0.002840690314769745, -0.04768507555127144, -0.007282615639269352, -0.02659597061574459, -0.013158060610294342, -0.038622453808784485, 0.050856202840805054, 0.01427142322063446, 0.016757287085056305, 0.03410162031650543, 0.004425490275025368, -0.004416744224727154, 0.042594242841005325, -0.03355604037642479, -0.0244132187217474, -0.030985312536358833, -0.05825235694646835, -0.060546278953552246, -0.01241089403629303, -0.0038578552193939686, 0.04422305151820183, 0.008909632451832294, 0.020698973909020424, -0.01606708951294422, 0.0022855480201542377, 0.007310389541089535, 0.009557642973959446, 0.045542214065790176, -0.026041612029075623, -0.011462551541626453, 0.0023122853599488735, 0.017736081033945084, -0.014621843583881855, 0.02582114189863205, -0.019629474729299545, -0.006387189030647278, -0.02947930619120598, -0.00471107754856348, -0.05987626314163208, 0.0385654978454113, -0.023837294429540634, 0.05602002888917923, -0.03263668343424797, -0.002181170042604208, -0.03579194098711014, -0.034610021859407425, -0.013605672866106033, -0.013529986143112183, 0.007037348113954067, -0.0027617260348051786, -0.0064478712156414986, 0.005438543856143951, 0.02835664711892605, 0.005495981313288212, 0.004545267205685377, -0.00954734068363905, 0.02244379371404648, 0.004576006438583136, 0.048952143639326096, -0.022421877831220627, -0.034306496381759644, 0.01394753810018301, -0.013503910042345524, -0.033151037991046906, 0.004401796963065863, 0.003315967507660389, 0.02903570979833603, -0.008726201020181179, -0.03425249084830284, 0.006437133532017469, 0.029655281454324722, -0.004163580946624279, 0.02904430963099003, -0.00033988000359386206, -0.03137757256627083, 0.009889448992908001, 0.019032930955290794, 0.01076824776828289, -0.0007472339202649891, 0.008467751555144787, 0.012032744474709034, 0.05971809849143028, 0.018607359379529953, -0.02985144779086113, 0.03202379122376442, -0.0013314068783074617, 0.005898835137486458, 0.00023794548178557307, -0.004006346687674522, 0.04455922544002533, 0.023542573675513268, -0.007518487982451916, 0.03816782683134079, 0.0099020479246974, 0.0037186068948358297, -0.06824365258216858, -0.009683971293270588, 0.014088956639170647, 0.06601614505052567, 0.029278401285409927, -0.06364898383617401, -0.025685831904411316, 0.012322204187512398, -0.039595846086740494, 0.011778686195611954, 0.008660199120640755, -0.007042351644486189, -0.0354725606739521, -0.03615174442529678, 0.004640581551939249, 0.027801513671875, 0.027076201513409615, 0.022829696536064148, -0.000630937225650996, 0.029316574335098267, -0.005195196717977524, -0.05868977680802345, 0.0005075788358226418, -0.0030174776911735535, 0.018222391605377197, -0.05082219839096069, 0.05304403975605965, -0.03353988379240036, 0.006652530282735825, 0.00032694326364435256, -0.02485678903758526, -0.002666303189471364, 0.017822522670030594, 0.022624867036938667, -0.012471063062548637, 0.036551594734191895, 0.021532317623496056, 0.02763931080698967, -0.0005916788359172642, -0.05024801567196846, 0.011996825225651264, 0.0011942196870222688, 0.009496880695223808, 0.014076951891183853, 0.022959988564252853, 0.02725670300424099, -0.005691009107977152, 0.022727524861693382, -0.045017801225185394, -0.03469469025731087, -0.010656646452844143, -0.02550237439572811, 0.0015932833775877953, 0.009030391462147236, 0.030701758340001106, -0.053621381521224976, -0.04428018257021904, 0.03362076357007027, 0.014033004641532898, -0.007809091359376907, -0.011384615674614906, 0.0025136584881693125, 0.008882438763976097, -0.004170293919742107, 0.00879944209009409, 0.026397574692964554, -0.039179153740406036, 0.01157612819224596, -0.01515705231577158, -0.029429445043206215, -0.06811568140983582, 0.008310195989906788, -0.036868613213300705, 0.05657064914703369, 0.006224008277058601, -0.006650018971413374, -0.018011214211583138, -0.0016978922067210078, 0.04320339858531952, -0.019907044246792793, 0.04034419357776642, 0.017752686515450478, -0.024093274027109146, -0.015504511073231697, -0.012335104867815971, -0.010764308273792267, -0.025500645861029625, 0.03999787196516991, -0.05259290337562561, -0.005066771991550922, 0.00916476920247078, 0.030438140034675598, -0.017267350107431412, -0.026468755677342415, 0.05693842098116875, 0.004608300514519215, 0.004488125443458557, 0.023698657751083374, -0.00899823009967804, 0.021853044629096985, -0.02423216961324215, 0.025844231247901917, 0.0004440050106495619, 0.002272167010232806, 0.00026286154752597213, -0.012930194847285748, 0.008378691039979458, 0.012671108357608318, 0.0038872850127518177, 0.04220367968082428, -0.020157422870397568, 0.026623336598277092, -0.0023588156327605247, 0.008400240913033485, -0.04122043401002884, 0.001054751337505877, -0.04311259835958481, 0.0017551585333421826, -0.0032199337147176266, -0.029799537733197212, 0.009809617884457111, -0.06793726235628128, -0.00557602196931839, 0.025024494156241417, -0.029975218698382378, 0.005555136129260063, 0.05070902407169342, 0.030627645552158356, 0.013614147901535034, -0.02067880518734455, 0.059558022767305374, 0.022097352892160416, -0.01840761862695217, 0.012076306156814098, 0.030214566737413406, 0.06290864199399948, 0.04091302677989006, -0.0018026778707280755, 0.026135781779885292, -0.005839630030095577, 0.04323726147413254, -0.0278181079775095, -0.002441276330500841, -0.02442353218793869, -0.03054930828511715, -0.008176527917385101, 0.048093292862176895, -0.012146868743002415, 0.009786561131477356, -0.0016407585935667157, 0.052766475826501846, -0.05266871675848961, -0.0036782189272344112, -0.012810079380869865, 0.0005240031168796122, -0.049502041190862656, -0.0037361783906817436, -0.019384942948818207, 0.01830187998712063, 0.023378247395157814, 0.008806214667856693, 0.025065768510103226, -0.033027201890945435, 0.008829876780509949, -0.006338109262287617, 0.015364752151072025, -0.004742479883134365, -0.03287872299551964, 0.012908211909234524, -0.03829974681138992, -0.001631647115573287, -0.01801910251379013, 0.05235183984041214, 0.04874603822827339, 0.0014333738945424557, -0.050737328827381134, -0.032217174768447876, 0.006676407065242529, 0.06700743734836578, -0.0718071460723877, -0.0037811489310115576, -0.02907186560332775, -0.005860332865267992, -0.033204976469278336, -0.027942566201090813 ]
<p>I've got a particular MCMC algorithm which I would like to port to C/C++. Much of the expensive computation is in C already via Cython, but I want to have the whole sampler written in a compiled language so that I can just write wrappers for Python/R/Matlab/whatever.</p> <p>After poking around I'm leaning towards C++. A couple of relevant libraries I know of are Armadillo (http://arma.sourceforge.net/) and Scythe (http://scythe.wustl.edu/). Both try to emulate some aspects of R/Matlab to ease the learning curve, which I like a lot. Scythe squares a little better with what I want to do I think. In particular, its RNG includes a lot of distributions where Armadillo only has uniform/normal, which is inconvenient. Armadillo seems to be under pretty active development while Scythe saw its last release in 2007.</p> <p>So what I'm wondering is if anyone has experience with these libraries -- or others I have almost surely missed -- and if so, whether there is anything to recommend one over the others for a statistician very familiar with Python/R/Matlab but less so with compiled languages (not completely ignorant, but not exactly proficient...).</p>
61
[ -0.02195240557193756, -0.006946149747818708, -0.0020889276638627052, -0.023932019248604774, 0.04319646209478378, 0.03960021957755089, -0.009636486880481243, -0.017376232892274857, 0.030552608892321587, -0.034444887191057205, 0.04002402722835541, 0.03096828982234001, 0.06385762244462967, 0.026009846478700638, 0.012655072845518589, -0.03175519406795502, -0.0037988850381225348, -0.047076933085918427, -0.022971687838435173, -0.03567627817392349, 0.012322320602834225, 0.031105322763323784, 0.03839123621582985, -0.025415685027837753, -0.04368598386645317, 0.028519069775938988, 0.05224735662341118, -0.01149736251682043, -0.0014608765486627817, 0.07732109725475311, -0.060221631079912186, -0.04432659223675728, -0.009411493316292763, 0.05991284176707268, 0.03553997352719307, 0.01269934605807066, -0.03195784240961075, 0.002284451387822628, -0.017086882144212723, 0.026140587404370308, -0.054731108248233795, -0.0012823002180084586, -0.024506116285920143, -0.003833247348666191, 0.028269432485103607, 0.004798858426511288, -0.010552606545388699, -0.019026855006814003, 0.02538662776350975, -0.03898897394537926, 0.05656721442937851, -0.0007829006062820554, -0.01516679860651493, -0.002254398074001074, 0.016439709812402725, 0.00582471489906311, 0.05960677191615105, 0.028171580284833908, 0.019572539255023003, -0.055747728794813156, 0.05518585070967674, 0.016696782782673836, 0.027019154280424118, 0.005533171817660332, -0.0413169302046299, 0.031189844012260437, -0.010578550398349762, -0.02588517963886261, 0.005236497614532709, -0.004788095131516457, 0.01792212575674057, 0.006989895366132259, 0.02358393929898739, -0.024061914533376694, 0.029394792392849922, -0.022837115451693535, -0.02099495381116867, 0.0042610811069607735, 0.033101294189691544, -0.0013330734800547361, 0.009447322227060795, 0.03961368277668953, 0.013171032071113586, 0.010337593033909798, 0.01587674766778946, -0.023954857140779495, 0.04762554541230202, -0.03730940818786621, -0.02107762172818184, 0.04409908503293991, 0.004920489154756069, -0.03910653665661812, 0.05563287064433098, 0.014931956306099892, -0.058393094688653946, -0.004391050897538662, -0.0013648105086758733, 0.04107212647795677, -0.013968187384307384, -0.014535710215568542, -0.029602428898215294, -0.007364735007286072, -0.023305192589759827, 0.032066766172647476, -0.042830370366573334, -0.000854461919516325, -0.02649185061454773, -0.029945285990834236, -0.03980499133467674, 0.0024852261412888765, -0.0364488884806633, 0.011931362561881542, -0.007288957946002483, -0.024967961013317108, 0.038576118648052216, -0.0158416535705328, -0.010481844656169415, 0.004652651026844978, 0.005951539147645235, 0.09577476233243942, 0.03858856484293938, 0.0012067595962435007, 0.03799262270331383, -0.05059678852558136, -0.0955725684762001, 0.0332055389881134, -0.0005319547490216792, -0.040400709956884384, -0.047453735023736954, 0.06721637398004532, -0.006933556403964758, 0.006481674034148455, 0.04468056932091713, -0.0025818664580583572, 0.002211027080193162, -0.01640940271317959, -0.08863192051649094, -0.07695534080266953, 0.04760302975773811, -0.033337995409965515, 0.007142531219869852, -0.033100299537181854, 0.03508933633565903, 0.00262791127897799, 0.062235984951257706, -0.004349070135504007, 0.05403158441185951, 0.009612896479666233, 0.07877638936042786, -0.032139852643013, -0.0430450364947319, -0.03309483453631401, -0.03274083882570267, 0.012421054765582085, 0.008859907276928425, -0.07611770927906036, 0.04938599094748497, -0.0065557388588786125, -0.011329930275678635, -0.0008967741741798818, 0.04138793796300888, 0.04185248166322708, -0.002964232349768281, -0.01910793036222458, -0.00029864482348784804, -0.02603057399392128, 0.06356815993785858, 0.021817579865455627, 0.04450862854719162, 0.003943673335015774, -0.0540616437792778, -0.0030581632163375616, 0.018564224243164062, -0.00427259411662817, 0.05848534032702446, -0.03269609436392784, -0.020366709679365158, 0.022482898086309433, 0.016757173463702202, 0.029846886172890663, -0.02499767579138279, -0.01558602787554264, 0.026291711255908012, -0.038029301911592484, 0.015240299515426159, 0.04839671775698662, 0.0016860777977854013, 0.00975780002772808, 0.05681220069527626, -0.05675852298736572, -0.039144206792116165, -0.027334347367286682, -0.01453624852001667, 0.008656449615955353, -0.017401758581399918, 0.03664570674300194, 0.010087034665048122, 0.018378719687461853, 0.030285997316241264, -0.017459142953157425, -0.02575751766562462, -0.0008678407757543027, 0.034572966396808624, -0.014304487966001034, -0.01993776485323906, 0.06680728495121002, 0.028763137757778168, -0.03353549912571907, 0.04933939501643181, -0.04955730959773064, -0.06825356930494308, -0.04621487483382225, -0.02253377065062523, -0.01988156884908676, 0.014513831585645676, -0.01959432289004326, 0.005215267185121775, 0.0017912028124555945, 0.007754944264888763, 0.01042005605995655, -0.040676627308130264, 0.04739081487059593, 0.036479875445365906, 0.016843648627400398, 0.01354794017970562, 0.029834991320967674, 0.008911235257983208, -0.007223567459732294, -0.025721628218889236, 0.019731931388378143, -0.0011165785836055875, 0.017796387895941734, 0.0443444661796093, 0.0476282574236393, -0.04535220190882683, -0.022687392309308052, 0.06449762731790543, -0.00015645507664885372, -0.00587398512288928, 0.027474137023091316, 0.009961905889213085, -0.00415238318964839, -0.007827912457287312, 0.0073379105888307095, 0.026453183963894844, -0.016078930348157883, -0.021882297471165657, 0.01663016714155674, 0.005803471896797419, 0.007458271458745003, -0.04880543053150177, 0.035779524594545364, 0.01972074992954731, -0.01520458236336708, 0.00023532455088570714, -0.023515716195106506, 0.022283772006630898, -0.023250190541148186, -0.03274296969175339, 0.00929307285696268, -0.026759590953588486, -0.008510544896125793, -0.01731131784617901, -0.04284453019499779, -0.0066312081180512905, 0.033124715089797974, -0.010289928875863552, -0.007395114749670029, 0.017704030498862267, -0.015462523326277733, 0.01056746393442154, -0.014980434440076351, -0.021817393600940704, -0.040234073996543884, 0.030376121401786804, 0.010856712237000465, -0.004038139712065458, 0.038110725581645966, -0.04110372066497803, 0.012253557331860065, 0.024947654455900192, -0.011721492744982243, 0.011727796867489815, 0.022354915738105774, -0.05811843276023865, 0.06016114726662636, -0.015326209366321564, 0.016703788191080093, 0.018510079011321068, 0.0010762078454717994, -0.04859624803066254, 0.04264536499977112, 0.040791161358356476, -0.050827257335186005, 0.005510103423148394, 0.004403314087539911, -0.01214110478758812, -0.02190367877483368, -0.012945545837283134, 0.03673619404435158, -0.0069948835298419, -0.06736621260643005, 0.039809901267290115, -0.03925439715385437, 0.004068321548402309, -0.05667414516210556, -0.030161099508404732, 0.00012204567610751837, 0.003701360197737813, -0.004227190278470516, 0.03971010074019432, -0.07197295129299164, 0.0005780589999631047, -0.019654130563139915, -0.042897097766399384, 0.018867777660489082, 0.029051916673779488, 0.008039388805627823, 0.022993439808487892, 0.05968736857175827, 0.07968463003635406, 0.025573618710041046, -0.04190002754330635, -0.04197489097714424, 0.009274076670408249, 0.023852605372667313, -0.01179615966975689, 0.02842923067510128, 0.006347012240439653, -0.016392985358834267, -0.013255411759018898, -0.05942574888467789, 0.01693243719637394, 0.042111318558454514, -0.013783369213342667, 0.025546608492732048, 0.042269960045814514, -0.0028721278067678213, -0.004371520597487688, 0.06759059429168701, 0.015290860086679459, -0.00047302647726610303, 0.008342782035470009, -0.039203472435474396, -0.001650728052482009, -0.0007381197065114975, -0.03965562954545021, 0.003999656066298485, -0.0372498482465744, 0.014534457586705685, -0.03695778176188469, -0.019882282242178917, -0.04216928035020828, -0.06175728887319565, 0.015252535231411457, 0.02586054615676403, 0.034810621291399, -0.009292492642998695, 0.011942144483327866, 0.02689443714916706, 0.023982902988791466, -0.027755029499530792, 0.022509736940264702, 0.0017542140558362007, -0.020348936319351196, 0.01560880709439516, -0.0305539071559906, 0.01310752984136343, 0.047246966511011124, 0.03348146751523018, 0.023392990231513977, 0.003151271492242813, -0.03942130506038666, 0.009472829289734364, -0.042210452258586884, 0.021158481016755104, -0.0536978542804718, 0.06987501680850983, 0.013289869762957096, 0.08230429887771606, 0.006917503196746111, -0.03153282031416893, -0.008650789968669415, -0.020525259897112846, -0.08145779371261597, -0.003346845740452409, -0.01087973453104496, -0.021588394418358803, -0.001338756293989718, -0.004205203615128994, 0.0051199449226260185, 0.026248399168252945, 0.000638586760032922, -0.003569019725546241, -0.014026196673512459, -0.023297404870390892, 0.040684428066015244, -0.034767407923936844, -0.035730816423892975, 0.012815642170608044, 0.021446870639920235, 0.010441934689879417, -0.045798566192388535, 0.0067789130844175816, 0.010514305904507637, -0.05272403731942177, -0.012847654521465302, -0.012755979783833027, 0.02467765100300312, 0.017854368314146996, 0.026821548119187355, 0.009844431653618813, 0.05472537875175476, -0.03969648480415344, -0.022343875840306282, 0.031030382961034775, 0.03846050798892975, 0.024787988513708115, -0.010538509115576744, 0.016304606571793556, -0.05418622866272926, -0.019734283909201622, 0.033745940774679184, -0.005467272363603115, -0.016244109719991684, 0.015448219142854214, 0.015218847431242466, 0.012953052297234535, -0.07797660678625107, -0.0059657408855855465, 0.05661704018712044, -0.011266272515058517, 0.025375498458743095, -0.01090795174241066, -0.03255057707428932, -0.012962038628757, 0.01128838025033474, 0.012929610908031464, 0.022162461653351784, 0.001101969974115491, 0.010231349617242813, 0.011001529172062874, -0.025689739733934402, -0.02933834306895733, -0.011150416918098927, 0.03409235551953316, 0.037007369101047516, -0.04499747231602669, 0.020058294758200645, -0.01031523011624813, 0.00990534108132124, -0.008155766874551773, 0.02165994606912136, 0.0010565236443653703, -0.06191970035433769, 0.029575804248452187, 0.042365189641714096, 0.09262990951538086, -0.029823224991559982, -0.024263925850391388, -0.048201221972703934, 0.00927723478525877, 0.05495251715183258, 0.0003022768651135266, 0.017996184527873993, -0.0055376384407281876, -0.027783678844571114, -0.026529209688305855, -0.010550987906754017, -0.041916534304618835, 0.0012798378011211753, -0.009135552681982517, 0.00777035066857934, -0.00805612187832594, -0.02113574743270874, -0.05064180865883827, 0.017483282834291458, 0.026318848133087158, 0.051959674805402756, -0.02212490327656269, -0.017577502876520157, -0.0025128915440291166, 0.020598167553544044, 0.01811443641781807, -0.026524508371949196, -0.011330479755997658, 0.02980286069214344, 0.026881322264671326, 0.05905824899673462, -0.02352752909064293, -0.04598795250058174, 0.033398501574993134, -0.020571038126945496, -0.04892144724726677, -0.005278339143842459, 0.008063285611569881, 0.020336836576461792, 0.02727574110031128, -0.04070582985877991, 0.015886932611465454, 0.05072486773133278, -0.00002712979585339781, 0.015521947294473648, -0.01938513293862343, -0.007934016175568104, -0.005997356027364731, -0.0037894328124821186, -0.0701291412115097, -0.0451241135597229, -0.007573320064693689, -0.003999067470431328, 0.0016961325891315937, 0.07572926580905914, -0.046436600387096405, 0.023262660950422287, -0.01839483343064785, 0.06312431395053864, -0.03108900971710682, -0.009523725137114525, 0.007943361066281796, -0.01279432699084282, -0.028601527214050293, -0.010510112158954144, 0.047989558428525925, -0.01833403669297695, -0.011683488264679909, 0.013688760809600353, -0.08372539281845093, 0.002770391060039401, -0.03994512930512428, -0.02150527387857437, 0.026832224801182747, -0.03639283403754234, 0.04025030881166458, -0.0043891980312764645, 0.046282850205898285, 0.012393631041049957, -0.05038069188594818, 0.004251891281455755, 0.029051247984170914, -0.027907054871320724, 0.015405349433422089, -0.03183988854289055, 0.03663770854473114, -0.04977775737643242, 0.007750913500785828, -0.07975717633962631, -0.04916340857744217, -0.014333990402519703, -0.037437427788972855, -0.024694159626960754, -0.03065565787255764, 0.008465060964226723, 0.006271453108638525, 0.008437026292085648, 0.009102221578359604, 0.022480817511677742, -0.00463636452332139, -0.00790620967745781, -0.0036319373175501823, -0.0027360767126083374, 0.0605737678706646, -0.01342769991606474, 0.014479925855994225, 0.019526295363903046, 0.006695386487990618, -0.00513482466340065, -0.009506111033260822, 0.05103575065732002, -0.009089557453989983, 0.0285508930683136, 0.007137799169868231, 0.009001747705042362, 0.043648529797792435, -0.026879621669650078, 0.04379193112254143, 0.04224368557333946, -0.018189355731010437, -0.005827248562127352, -0.05246575176715851, 0.0016765542095527053, -0.033045172691345215, 0.0014204325852915645, -0.03928355872631073, -0.05273010581731796, 0.017722219228744507, 0.011644648388028145, 0.028418706730008125, 0.035584285855293274, 0.01846800185739994, 0.010453564114868641, 0.019117632880806923, -0.006324469111859798, -0.012232811190187931, 0.0004859316977672279, -0.025888383388519287, -0.006758395116776228, -0.033113934099674225, 0.02907930687069893, -0.037537895143032074, 0.025830848142504692, 0.003039477625861764, -0.03322127088904381, -0.0436154380440712, 0.013993417844176292, 0.030151046812534332, 0.02011328563094139, 0.02555158920586109, 0.03571540117263794, -0.008263901807367802, -0.013534823432564735, -0.026142209768295288, -0.015687884762883186, 0.0014067016309127212, 0.0004996031639166176, 0.07494588196277618, 0.03429964557290077, -0.0034099644981324673, 0.02090214006602764, 0.01937197893857956, 0.024019062519073486, 0.049822017550468445, 0.013282354921102524, 0.013591846451163292, 0.010311434045433998, -0.02077515795826912, -0.05017136409878731, 0.03011685609817505, -0.05745294317603111, 0.051210638135671616, -0.018777798861265182, -0.03835476189851761, 0.02749071829020977, -0.005996581632643938, 0.010168064385652542, -0.05238798260688782, -0.008084818720817566, -0.0339864045381546, 0.017612269148230553, 0.008539491333067417, -0.021038584411144257, 0.024498021230101585, 0.008474762551486492, 0.012611453421413898, 0.006647248286753893, 0.054983124136924744, -0.011095435358583927, -0.08646591007709503, -0.02398240938782692, -0.03582096844911575, -0.06758861243724823, 0.047813594341278076, 0.053798187524080276, -0.00905069150030613, 0.008642291650176048, -0.02571866661310196, 0.03898409754037857, -0.002432763809338212, 0.041543148458004, 0.00674811564385891, 0.08061741292476654, -0.023228710517287254, -0.004586429800838232, -0.039116594940423965, -0.04340164363384247, 0.11507163196802139, 0.010302625596523285, 0.06326331198215485, -0.061717402189970016, 0.03428327664732933, -0.03563230112195015, 0.013783561065793037, 0.001259109121747315, 0.011742840521037579, -0.019945135340094566, -0.0064810775220394135, 0.011939826421439648, 0.03720604255795479, 0.024445965886116028, 0.018097884953022003, 0.02086699940264225, -0.0011939126998186111, -0.021619142964482307, -0.006327662151306868, 0.027089344337582588, 0.004906089510768652, 0.002675544936209917, -0.045738495886325836, 0.014530962333083153, -0.015041925944387913, -0.049282100051641464, -0.039513349533081055, -0.031997039914131165, 0.025478996336460114, 0.005572409834712744, -0.029641395434737206, -0.0014416812919080257, 0.02464843913912773, -0.010671901516616344, 0.0407225526869297, -0.01103957835584879, 0.036029618233442307, -0.054659124463796616, 0.016452522948384285, 0.024904342368245125, 0.024116776883602142, -0.0291276928037405, 0.0011231974931433797, 0.012273842468857765, -0.02910676971077919, -0.02641250565648079, -0.01751428097486496, 0.03836524859070778, -0.04711729288101196, -0.025358406826853752, 0.0053121657110750675, -0.000880116771440953, 0.040300555527210236, -0.05125594139099121, 0.0007230697083286941, -0.0030228495597839355, 0.029848212376236916, -0.021493516862392426, 0.022072581574320793, 0.004287992604076862, 0.010676946491003036, -0.03141739219427109, 0.003571935463696718, -0.010230855084955692, -0.03244777396321297, -0.054391730576753616, -0.031203974038362503, 0.021693915128707886, -0.015377284958958626, -0.020506130531430244, 0.005957019980996847, 0.002797162625938654, 0.0065984283573925495, -0.002212828490883112, 0.006546841003000736, -0.0017599286511540413, 0.042007580399513245, -0.04651015251874924, -0.03360063582658768, -0.03635415807366371, -0.026992494240403175, -0.0008536110981367528, -0.0505778007209301, 0.01993529126048088, -0.004383901134133339, -0.02035783790051937, 0.06074894964694977, 0.023295722901821136, 0.00517194764688611, 0.0041868798434734344, -0.02780064009130001, 0.0022146564442664385, 0.038883451372385025, -0.005087804980576038, 0.013573885895311832, 0.00005283570499159396, -0.031570374965667725, 0.003672258462756872, -0.03756310045719147, 0.03634168207645416, 0.03083072416484356, 0.010992629453539848, 0.007034344132989645, 0.025033636018633842, -0.009296843782067299, -0.001153618679381907, 0.0035077484790235758, -0.048875242471694946, -0.03569729998707771, -0.02853500097990036, 0.014638416469097137, -0.06944094598293304, 0.013321388512849808, -0.03946266323328018, -0.01686854660511017, -0.03623947501182556, -0.009497782215476036, -0.023445991799235344, 0.014123775064945221, -0.03948584198951721, 0.03446340933442116, -0.00611237995326519, 0.028519820421934128, 0.014790407381951809, 0.02633059397339821, -0.008640788495540619, -0.009257285855710506, -0.006292153149843216, -0.024142088368535042, -0.0014967435272410512, 0.025811990723013878, 0.014559428207576275, 0.015125459991395473, 0.046202152967453, 0.044311609119176865, 0.021497217938303947, 0.022277286276221275, 0.03013797290623188, -0.02839256078004837, 0.03241224214434624, 0.04116484895348549, -0.06169234961271286, -0.020006230100989342, 0.01976144127547741, -0.009558727964758873, 0.012174037285149097, 0.007667859084904194, -0.0146521320566535, -0.01645486429333687, 0.06884115189313889, -0.005464465823024511, -0.012429285794496536, -0.027106517925858498, 0.019094014540314674, 0.03583734109997749, 0.014343883842229843, 0.02760104089975357, 0.005961696617305279, -0.015524527058005333, 0.045474521815776825, 0.024456342682242393, -0.012604216113686562, 0.03257811442017555, 0.01346662174910307, 0.01124115101993084, -0.02310674823820591, -0.007120766211301088, -0.013919420540332794, 0.07061809301376343, -0.008236374706029892, -0.03177974745631218, 0.05660503730177879, 0.010495156049728394, 0.06070639193058014, -0.060618311166763306, -0.023233870044350624, 0.011172223836183548, -0.033068619668483734, 0.05559176579117775, -0.06783975660800934, -0.03353821858763695, 0.030924607068300247, -0.0740332081913948, -0.017132766544818878, 0.007785603404045105, -0.05859525501728058, -0.017691655084490776, 0.05089561268687248, -0.003420215332880616, 0.0063904509879648685, -0.010127590969204903, -0.022323569282889366, 0.06416353583335876, 0.027733735740184784, 0.005026660859584808, 0.011639413423836231, -0.0073348465375602245, 0.017095211893320084, 0.02778821624815464, -0.007826292887330055, 0.05851968377828598, -0.042432401329278946, -0.020976681262254715, 0.03248950093984604, 0.011250931769609451, 0.026868881657719612, 0.011589901521801949, 0.04082208871841431, -0.017165932804346085, 0.032130468636751175, 0.018390856683254242, 0.0016212399350479245, 0.04538523778319359, -0.014983231201767921, 0.028399376198649406, 0.02641347609460354, -0.02830362133681774, 0.016976725310087204, 0.02342202328145504, -0.01958630606532097, 0.015360898338258266, 0.013666989281773567, 0.017990870401263237, -0.009649055078625679, -0.014568801037967205, 0.006121980957686901, 0.012373951263725758, -0.015559658408164978, 0.0368635393679142, -0.04708050936460495, -0.0020398630294948816, 0.033796124160289764, -0.014152823947370052, -0.020916538313031197, 0.015735819935798645, -0.01700667291879654, -0.021327339112758636, -0.023494955152273178, -0.016852425411343575, -0.00008637412247480825, -0.029916688799858093, -0.006085712928324938, 0.0033697050530463457, 0.02115497551858425, -0.012450043112039566, -0.029826365411281586, -0.0010888029355555773, 0.05899515748023987, 0.0044014304876327515, 0.016743896529078484, 0.012992710806429386, 0.0434698760509491, 0.028973206877708435, -0.06513901799917221, 0.06848219782114029, 0.002400689758360386, 0.002455993089824915, -0.01538262702524662, 0.023005276918411255, 0.0012405866291373968, -0.0069150556810200214, 0.028977731242775917, -0.0004610988835338503, 0.02495698072016239, -0.049434930086135864, 0.015208078548312187, 0.0059837414883077145, -0.0391707606613636, 0.044616855680942535, -0.030235961079597473, -0.026769015938043594, -0.025844139978289604, -0.025952089577913284, 0.00037003293982706964, -0.005451797973364592, -0.0019465087680146098, -0.039007630199193954, -0.0400562658905983, -0.00458191242069006, -0.043472714722156525, 0.04436198249459267, 0.010614275932312012, -0.029057281091809273, 0.047416504472494125, 0.002843700349330902, 0.01622815430164337, 0.0011640414595603943, -0.00328055745922029, -0.012058721855282784, 0.04378238320350647, -0.00927142146974802, -0.008836979046463966, -0.003796109464019537, -0.006403656210750341, -0.001719521009363234, -0.03495430946350098, -0.001962760230526328, 0.017127756029367447, -0.005648892838507891, 0.0035860398784279823, 0.058459874242544174, -0.017153792083263397, 0.03979151323437691, -0.003221123246476054, 0.042988184839487076, 0.011147409677505493, 0.04652518033981323, -0.02918265387415886, -0.009647209197282791, 0.035013746470212936, 0.013043149374425411, 0.0019442546181380749, 0.04228377714753151, -0.028179727494716644, 0.010735453106462955, 0.007691339589655399, 0.057241011410951614, -0.03816782310605049, -0.012037602253258228, 0.031594883650541306, -0.03331216424703598, 0.018208982422947884, 0.002537883585318923, -0.03488990291953087, 0.0668821781873703, -0.03564027324318886, 0.004935245495289564, -0.0350259430706501, 0.006698110606521368, -0.002372956136241555, 0.005734001751989126, -0.055281203240156174, 0.010830041021108627, 0.003591595683246851, 0.03143009543418884, 0.0056273904629051685, 0.003191213821992278, 0.09897760301828384, -0.0384114645421505, 0.003811880247667432, -0.021264538168907166, 0.047404929995536804, 0.002937639132142067, 0.0002921817358583212, 0.0023405090905725956, -0.007635598536580801, 0.03941313177347183, 0.08816884458065033, 0.006703115534037352, -0.030184274539351463, -0.035392578691244125, 0.012876399792730808, 0.02041999064385891, -0.03678062930703163, 0.01314716786146164, -0.019739460200071335, 0.02099653333425522, -0.010835169814527035, 0.021968575194478035 ]
<p>I have a set of samples in which I assume there are 2 definite subsets in it. I plotted their values in a histogram and found that there are two distinct modes as shown in the figure below.</p> <p>My question is how do I differentiate two groups. i.e how do I choose a value that differentiates the two subsets? </p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/wbIvt.png" alt="enter image description here"></p>
36,512
[ -0.024394754320383072, -0.0115482984110713, 0.023665349930524826, -0.0123261958360672, 0.014138550497591496, 0.01838207058608532, -0.004352834075689316, -0.03919128701090813, 0.030016060918569565, 0.019591471180319786, 0.02596125192940235, 0.02767782285809517, 0.047127582132816315, 0.030483458191156387, 0.020217830315232277, -0.0094675337895751, -0.0017861229134723544, -0.025254568085074425, -0.005516663659363985, -0.005534874740988016, -0.02191431075334549, 0.0006192509899847209, 0.026490673422813416, -0.012457309290766716, -0.04341645538806915, 0.0754612386226654, 0.03295546770095825, 0.005571400746703148, 0.002615923061966896, 0.05145015940070152, -0.04287203773856163, -0.03199003264307976, 0.015825053676962852, 0.026336638256907463, 0.017794648185372353, -0.03186028450727463, -0.0040321652777493, -0.0025493460707366467, -0.008889416232705116, 0.013752863742411137, -0.07231884449720383, -0.018678491935133934, -0.011916088871657848, 0.05289134755730629, -0.016061492264270782, 0.019147155806422234, 0.019061818718910217, -0.06195550039410591, 0.026248332113027573, -0.04090256616473198, 0.07522916048765182, 0.044522691518068314, 0.038040950894355774, 0.042497728019952774, -0.024361494928598404, 0.00816488079726696, 0.02858593873679638, 0.10139696300029755, -0.0014518315438181162, -0.05833688750863075, 0.010116481222212315, -0.038250818848609924, -0.014398615807294846, -0.013735800981521606, -0.05426473915576935, 0.037479933351278305, 0.002563763177022338, -0.04648176580667496, 0.002494996413588524, -0.000817545282188803, 0.02070624567568302, 0.004456432070583105, 0.025524944067001343, -0.034577056765556335, 0.023057660087943077, -0.03936954215168953, 0.02204391546547413, 0.03074902482330799, 0.05830487236380577, -0.030375801026821136, 0.04772817716002464, 0.027826674282550812, 0.022592909634113312, 0.015587660484015942, 0.012599805369973183, -0.02268482930958271, 0.06927064061164856, -0.02800917625427246, 0.014452670700848103, 0.02014196664094925, -0.016885949298739433, 0.0016858623130246997, 0.04515490680932999, 0.00739991245791316, -0.004349293652921915, 0.036203380674123764, -0.030776744708418846, 0.004577879793941975, -0.012328458949923515, -0.020366456359624863, 0.005916138179600239, -0.041698817163705826, 0.04818941280245781, 0.07123897969722748, -0.005599441006779671, 0.03796805813908577, -0.01499004103243351, -0.006866714917123318, -0.02765079028904438, 0.005698513705283403, 0.00276964926160872, 0.028067870065569878, -0.00011900284152943641, -0.024529192596673965, 0.031180163845419884, 0.03984082117676735, -0.01880926825106144, -0.036336373537778854, 0.052136704325675964, 0.0603795126080513, 0.06996414065361023, -0.03254026547074318, 0.007043106015771627, -0.025988372042775154, -0.06704705953598022, -0.011632897891104221, 0.013644718565046787, 0.04801931604743004, -0.003524480387568474, 0.04591164365410805, -0.008526593446731567, -0.020827919244766235, 0.0326334610581398, -0.01512596383690834, -0.0029972416814416647, 0.01011671032756567, -0.07333236932754517, -0.02381596714258194, 0.02327328361570835, -0.013918760232627392, -0.015562518499791622, -0.04307573661208153, -0.009203835390508175, 0.06876575946807861, 0.026011353358626366, 0.04366789385676384, 0.025661276653409004, -0.008915511891245842, 0.02084570936858654, 0.02829684317111969, -0.011681626550853252, 0.012388392351567745, -0.02818123996257782, -0.017443319782614708, 0.011019975878298283, -0.027125850319862366, -0.020752009004354477, 0.014114622958004475, -0.012248390354216099, 0.013315428979694843, 0.007813585922122002, 0.013902961276471615, -0.03896504268050194, 0.0163374412804842, 0.03320317342877388, -0.0038617614191025496, 0.06643571704626083, -0.005738686770200729, 0.0063245962373912334, 0.016143305227160454, -0.004070601891726255, 0.05947252735495567, 0.030489061027765274, 0.037234947085380554, 0.015018749982118607, -0.008680542930960655, -0.01802992820739746, -0.047223083674907684, 0.006383900996297598, 0.00700349872931838, 0.011203301139175892, -0.033494576811790466, -0.022308504208922386, 0.0012396590318530798, 0.05862913653254509, 0.03765418753027916, 0.01804840750992298, -0.0020843972451984882, 0.015985917299985886, -0.042929958552122116, -0.052243124693632126, -0.06857936829328537, 0.009052389301359653, -0.009953511878848076, -0.06983236223459244, 0.02067619562149048, 0.042714741080999374, 0.006222723051905632, -0.017067043110728264, -0.03540363907814026, -0.037348464131355286, -0.025546850636601448, 0.038733672350645065, -0.01918259635567665, -0.005666051991283894, 0.04613340646028519, 0.049916818737983704, 0.004631073214113712, 0.040478456765413284, -0.019430914893746376, -0.026067622005939484, 0.027615217491984367, -0.025637682527303696, 0.00985731091350317, -0.02546987496316433, -0.006694018840789795, -0.005810433998703957, 0.004311918746680021, -0.04293413087725639, 0.037333860993385315, -0.04412670060992241, 0.049095604568719864, 0.06846009194850922, -0.004664908163249493, -0.009052198380231857, -0.023051176220178604, -0.01538034901022911, 0.0277495589107275, -0.05091622844338417, 0.002809481928125024, -0.04853561520576477, 0.000697374576702714, 0.05437192693352699, 0.01848248951137066, -0.027396902441978455, 0.015235275030136108, 0.05054363235831261, -0.0053351279348134995, 0.022607414051890373, 0.00799554493278265, 0.017942138016223907, -0.002048959257081151, 0.0179277490824461, 0.03536263853311539, 0.03203989192843437, 0.008602291345596313, 0.06502485275268555, -0.026154380291700363, 0.034374527633190155, -0.032114043831825256, 0.009625384584069252, 0.06281298398971558, 0.004190416075289249, 0.004613333847373724, -0.009999961592257023, -0.001193967298604548, 0.014810874126851559, -0.011011862196028233, -0.029970837756991386, 0.014359213411808014, 0.0007029165280982852, -0.03545035049319267, 0.025523753836750984, -0.0017555017257109284, 0.02581370435655117, 0.046269491314888, -0.013565318658947945, 0.007928173057734966, 0.016402358189225197, -0.05178175866603851, 0.0010062319925054908, 0.00998170766979456, -0.03708731010556221, -0.027795417234301567, -0.026130111888051033, 0.055694129317998886, 0.019294092431664467, 0.0024911637883633375, -0.026379112154245377, -0.016201570630073547, -0.007567137945443392, -0.019091598689556122, -0.011935999616980553, 0.013815768994390965, -0.05622151866555214, 0.01080491952598095, -0.03529181331396103, -0.00903031975030899, 0.005891850218176842, 0.019257420673966408, -0.030272310599684715, 0.01706661842763424, 0.013392938300967216, -0.05513463541865349, 0.0005786588881164789, -0.046533551067113876, 0.04082515090703964, -0.02907366119325161, -0.017765337601304054, 0.0253666490316391, 0.029519587755203247, -0.03375914320349693, -0.010928836651146412, -0.04999266564846039, -0.03397762030363083, -0.03748825192451477, 0.026271823793649673, 0.046461042016744614, 0.03353128582239151, -0.03874017670750618, 0.02632114291191101, 0.009508241899311543, 0.024891072884202003, -0.06242114678025246, -0.04604766145348549, 0.007704572286456823, -0.008063387125730515, 0.03382299467921257, 0.016323139891028404, -0.016115594655275345, 0.07306399941444397, 0.04757627844810486, -0.01253686286509037, -0.017058612778782845, -0.011546698398888111, -0.06754578649997711, -0.003883058438077569, 0.03933555260300636, 0.012559058144688606, 0.03551428020000458, 0.030611546710133553, 0.025211365893483162, 0.014645541086792946, 0.07632075250148773, -0.009641269221901894, -0.025523340329527855, 0.02776838093996048, 0.01745927520096302, -0.026201216503977776, 0.05764441564679146, 0.029277736321091652, -0.04804075509309769, 0.008173799142241478, 0.0009585171355865896, 0.019501449540257454, 0.007268145680427551, -0.029408026486635208, 0.011506074108183384, 0.013577738776803017, 0.008000106550753117, -0.027977963909506798, 0.03021201118826866, 0.01805594563484192, -0.016774294897913933, -0.009450914338231087, -0.003497116733342409, 0.027743881568312645, -0.047963112592697144, -0.008470799773931503, 0.08807364106178284, -0.0035964820999652147, -0.004059945698827505, -0.008186360821127892, -0.017181802541017532, -0.013909294269979, 0.031115852296352386, -0.025481807067990303, -0.020126305520534515, 0.010073927231132984, 0.01718905009329319, 0.011497031897306442, 0.008686726912856102, -0.0017133277142420411, -0.00954834371805191, -0.05342569202184677, 0.032442495226860046, 0.011983399279415607, 0.06940922141075134, 0.007973101921379566, 0.08180365711450577, 0.027883246541023254, -0.010249142535030842, -0.02819840796291828, -0.018794631585478783, -0.03862956166267395, 0.06381021440029144, 0.014288978651165962, -0.010817896574735641, 0.01782875321805477, -0.055744413286447525, 0.03820982947945595, -0.048445139080286026, 0.001987229334190488, 0.0015256659826263785, 0.026537390425801277, -0.0205560103058815, 0.014165298081934452, -0.021168245002627373, 0.002672976814210415, -0.042944904416799545, 0.041557349264621735, 0.023332368582487106, 0.011812424287199974, 0.035790592432022095, 0.02990998513996601, 0.008432325907051563, 0.025100771337747574, -0.013542193919420242, -0.0038779228925704956, 0.034805651754140854, 0.018360020592808723, 0.009489946067333221, 0.04986647143959999, -0.005806841421872377, 0.01907440833747387, -0.010398371145129204, 0.07789520919322968, 0.02744702249765396, -0.028855791315436363, -0.01663893461227417, 0.010185496881604195, -0.021380625665187836, -0.03386132791638374, 0.04248896241188049, -0.027268320322036743, -0.012659775093197823, -0.007470136974006891, 0.023061996325850487, -0.07101019471883774, 0.009633410722017288, -0.009216655045747757, 0.04160572588443756, -0.013645486906170845, -0.04610553756356239, 0.018252961337566376, -0.025213539600372314, -0.021938886493444443, -0.0042266263626515865, 0.02031301148235798, 0.002402469515800476, 0.01103303860872984, 0.04547261819243431, 0.013636321760714054, -0.03423960879445076, 0.03298831731081009, -0.009872598573565483, 0.016977259889245033, -0.024004850536584854, -0.036336738616228104, 0.01589013822376728, 0.04820218309760094, 0.030621090903878212, -0.008150455541908741, 0.020505782216787338, -0.06264281272888184, -0.0022074070293456316, 0.05018703266978264, 0.02661743015050888, -0.04240760952234268, -0.014946268871426582, -0.04658110812306404, 0.005212321877479553, 0.015224510803818703, -0.045361630618572235, 0.04952564090490341, -0.026798686012625694, 0.022341014817357063, -0.05514226853847504, -0.029351703822612762, -0.043752994388341904, 0.0432768315076828, -0.00968257337808609, 0.0037586104590445757, -0.014384019188582897, -0.05388513579964638, -0.04288237541913986, 0.04095705598592758, 0.011131064966320992, 0.051169779151678085, -0.033694349229335785, -0.01787278987467289, 0.011383014731109142, -0.0004065317043568939, 0.0032257377170026302, -0.04592292383313179, 0.022095516324043274, 0.01176407840102911, 0.014336872845888138, 0.07141304016113281, -0.034528911113739014, -0.06533162295818329, 0.008954577147960663, 0.0014142309082672, 0.016538521274924278, 0.02456805296242237, -0.03538293391466141, 0.045038800686597824, 0.048392154276371, 0.028605762869119644, 0.04408564791083336, 0.040169037878513336, -0.008426647633314133, -0.010277854278683662, -0.050233349204063416, 0.02350071631371975, -0.041306931525468826, -0.03909888118505478, -0.05146804079413414, -0.0164179727435112, -0.03494240716099739, 0.023226941004395485, 0.0029718419536948204, 0.08651846647262573, 0.0008565901662223041, -0.034377407282590866, 0.004239191766828299, 0.031747814267873764, 0.024106362834572792, 0.02888592518866062, -0.024095775559544563, 0.008626069873571396, -0.028967266902327538, 0.012263311073184013, 0.026574913412332535, -0.04328243434429169, -0.0030202288180589676, 0.014313198626041412, -0.049224112182855606, 0.040267106145620346, -0.04580065980553627, -0.037630338221788406, -0.00551532581448555, -0.048907555639743805, 0.022760916501283646, -0.002771776169538498, 0.026725230738520622, 0.030931653454899788, -0.02711905539035797, -0.023548809811472893, 0.029057445004582405, 0.025068268179893494, 0.02163609489798546, -0.047041937708854675, 0.04969405755400658, 0.00872816052287817, -0.03710297867655754, -0.06975816935300827, -0.01050745602697134, 0.012617555446922779, 0.019834937527775764, -0.006618076004087925, -0.05296562612056732, 0.02175043523311615, 0.024724123999476433, -0.016884032636880875, 0.012098168022930622, 0.0505947545170784, 0.026462078094482422, -0.014998199418187141, -0.008197484537959099, 0.016182273626327515, 0.08564209192991257, -0.009493554942309856, 0.0111418217420578, 0.0033898877445608377, -0.042484305799007416, -0.022883344441652298, 0.0230251494795084, 0.0008688109228387475, -0.013855365104973316, -0.002265299204736948, -0.015304048545658588, 0.034536100924015045, 0.04593193158507347, -0.007968633435666561, -0.0017261188477277756, -0.0250540841370821, -0.012711715884506702, -0.022481238469481468, -0.047144077718257904, -0.03751474618911743, -0.02907480113208294, -0.015077309682965279, -0.014128738082945347, 0.02235056646168232, -0.025483420118689537, -0.032423410564661026, 0.01441110484302044, -0.008429892361164093, -0.002221715869382024, -0.003721964079886675, 0.04093928635120392, -0.033753085881471634, 0.007320909760892391, -0.007453560829162598, -0.01376488246023655, 0.04377680644392967, -0.05011891946196556, -0.010687598958611488, 0.0035471816081553698, 0.03328138217329979, -0.046955469995737076, 0.026250280439853668, -0.046864286065101624, -0.0057428316213190556, 0.029142364859580994, 0.009193599224090576, 0.06433439999818802, 0.09203999489545822, -0.04047081992030144, -0.004578479565680027, -0.02080717869102955, 0.010439769364893436, -0.034043729305267334, -0.019318144768476486, 0.06463854759931564, -0.012268293648958206, 0.005959534551948309, 0.013272956013679504, -0.021910566836595535, 0.013562582433223724, 0.029810132458806038, 0.002414008369669318, 0.03244471549987793, 0.013141144067049026, -0.028952166438102722, -0.004634481389075518, -0.024121155962347984, -0.02906276285648346, 0.03324830159544945, 0.004512119572609663, -0.010939488187432289, -0.004887518938630819, 0.07721657305955887, -0.021967599168419838, -0.04750555753707886, -0.0008883735281415284, -0.06426273286342621, 0.011074281297624111, 0.05658033490180969, -0.003419608809053898, 0.036833230406045914, 0.07269611954689026, 0.03710159659385681, 0.004570133052766323, 0.0230808537453413, -0.00046912915422581136, -0.036188166588544846, 0.015928545966744423, -0.03312254324555397, -0.04733961075544357, 0.008828255347907543, -0.0265340693295002, -0.022105565294623375, 0.035951633006334305, -0.02766835130751133, 0.020824456587433815, 0.008260111324489117, 0.017781101167201996, -0.0299984160810709, 0.05183963105082512, 0.005024392623454332, 0.021732913330197334, 0.02525479905307293, -0.011083131656050682, 0.11730355024337769, 0.04171561822295189, 0.030085353180766106, -0.049760036170482635, 0.011399448849260807, -0.00912698544561863, -0.004518021829426289, -0.02109750732779503, 0.025476040318608284, 0.005217749159783125, 0.038371045142412186, 0.021364737302064896, 0.01966087333858013, 0.0037667916622012854, 0.021080072969198227, 0.05665821209549904, -0.016626231372356415, 0.008959861472249031, -0.0087273009121418, 0.05396789684891701, -0.004327433183789253, 0.000014299393114924897, -0.029931357130408287, 0.012234865687787533, 0.01914159394800663, -0.013826875947415829, -0.037808291614055634, -0.047678906470537186, 0.01635221764445305, -0.014072740450501442, -0.000861884793266654, 0.005212749820202589, 0.04701213166117668, 0.01342724822461605, 0.005590986460447311, -0.003928918391466141, 0.0010871007107198238, -0.0792786255478859, 0.02036970667541027, 0.005505645181983709, 0.001656802836805582, -0.02571772411465645, -0.0024335733614861965, 0.009104263037443161, -0.03858664631843567, 0.0054113673977553844, -0.05699307844042778, 0.05474682152271271, 0.014437484554946423, -0.03389224037528038, -0.01033919770270586, 0.07556465268135071, 0.020582688972353935, -0.06159995123744011, -0.035384442657232285, -0.0021004837471991777, 0.01093123760074377, -0.04712319374084473, -0.026600057259202003, -0.032940443605184555, -0.011304561048746109, -0.021396994590759277, 0.02128256857395172, -0.015685157850384712, -0.033971961587667465, -0.034744780510663986, -0.024575764313340187, 0.01837286166846752, 0.01641215942800045, -0.036201994866132736, -0.02759682945907116, -0.05928133800625801, -0.010203611105680466, 0.013153519481420517, -0.013794869184494019, 0.05374142900109291, 0.03959664702415466, 0.001545931096188724, -0.02996341697871685, -0.030235935002565384, -0.04227929189801216, -0.006747103296220303, -0.01146426796913147, 0.028951358050107956, 0.006023619789630175, 0.0029173227958381176, -0.0028808384668082, 0.05328845605254173, -0.018520042300224304, 0.0218134094029665, 0.035297658294439316, 0.032141394913196564, 0.017837347462773323, -0.054434698075056076, 0.009289229288697243, 0.03449707850813866, -0.009198845364153385, 0.0134058753028512, -0.011848699301481247, 0.08942258358001709, 0.00005779038110631518, -0.0051414938643574715, -0.005639051552861929, 0.026796890422701836, -0.023083096370100975, 0.012968783266842365, -0.007607554085552692, -0.0571783185005188, -0.002106290776282549, 0.030335402116179466, -0.01687755063176155, -0.03781735897064209, -0.04015551134943962, -0.028758084401488304, -0.03005465865135193, 0.01622377522289753, -0.0018544637132436037, 0.004984124097973108, -0.026045802980661392, -0.012065952643752098, 0.01679479517042637, -0.007432535290718079, -0.001976495375856757, -0.03211734816431999, -0.020984262228012085, -0.014103095978498459, 0.0016999832587316632, -0.02908485010266304, 0.021957572549581528, 0.012675122357904911, 0.004164142068475485, 0.05692259967327118, 0.008951647207140923, 0.050968773663043976, -0.013042869046330452, 0.030299099162220955, 0.00094012072077021, 0.06436627358198166, 0.04432249814271927, 0.012422872707247734, 0.019471261650323868, -0.03956988453865051, 0.00239764922298491, 0.01598624512553215, 0.021829623728990555, 0.016105972230434418, 0.013656379655003548, -0.0026728869415819645, 0.03768666833639145, 0.02677464485168457, -0.03609571233391762, -0.043402593582868576, -0.023013660684227943, 0.019146839156746864, -0.006482916418462992, -0.016422249376773834, 0.008355369791388512, 0.00642825523391366, -0.05048627033829689, 0.01841013878583908, -0.006791286636143923, 0.00014952468336559832, -0.05714396759867668, -0.03979340195655823, -0.03056502155959606, 0.01369220670312643, -0.013682996854186058, -0.004561390727758408, 0.056236378848552704, 0.030795788392424583, -0.019774634391069412, -0.013165067881345749, -0.0033971057273447514, -0.016547633334994316, -0.059369925409555435, -0.026843858882784843, 0.01861400529742241, -0.012416078709065914, 0.07659103721380234, -0.037308044731616974, 0.01437375694513321, 0.05191640183329582, -0.021574316546320915, 0.021243654191493988, -0.006494150497019291, 0.032598040997982025, -0.051511071622371674, -0.008775308728218079, -0.052131567150354385, 0.013375782407820225, -0.017907947301864624, 0.017842350527644157, 0.06271769106388092, 0.024179181084036827, -0.03480570763349533, -0.021763091906905174, -0.008763698861002922, -0.012203732505440712, 0.029027851298451424, -0.05946033447980881, 0.01145133189857006, -0.03398413956165314, -0.019849471747875214, 0.015737704932689667, -0.04059062525629997, -0.015109656378626823, 0.02504991739988327, 0.009859194979071617, 0.02688589133322239, 0.013429579325020313, 0.026218736544251442, 0.0012284881668165326, -0.009041179902851582, -0.024407703429460526, 0.004097117111086845, 0.0022299301344901323, 0.002180539071559906, -0.03172290697693825, 0.028219975531101227, -0.014112940989434719, -0.020302044227719307, 0.014412907883524895, -0.013346725143492222, -0.04631317779421806, -0.0007275976240634918, -0.01024666614830494, 0.012449415400624275, -0.012923026457428932, -0.005887151230126619, -0.024591226130723953, -0.012199298478662968, 0.0169591773301363, -0.0133536197245121, -0.02010580711066723, 0.005992161575704813, -0.024099843576550484, -0.07410722225904465, 0.02484808675944805, 0.03750747814774513, -0.01718597486615181, -0.04746965318918228, -0.001664508250541985, -0.011430442333221436, 0.0026349592953920364, -0.02992340177297592, -0.0011523696593940258, -0.029444504529237747, 0.04138725996017456, -0.03700042515993118, 0.006799986120313406, -0.03921252489089966, -0.029172610491514206, -0.01989440992474556, -0.09366357326507568, 0.03310122713446617, 0.04504965990781784, -0.04067598283290863, -0.04786849394440651, -0.005276077426970005, -0.07821053266525269, 0.053908027708530426, 0.057375580072402954, 0.030557435005903244, 0.026002248749136925, -0.020364707335829735, 0.008961771614849567, 0.04209727793931961, -0.024240370839834213, 0.008233503438532352, -0.033140286803245544, -0.03040671907365322, 0.017983360216021538, 0.012682858854532242, 0.0155479209497571, 0.03783624619245529, 0.021169262006878853, -0.010569713078439236, -0.003177728969603777, 0.01001179963350296, -0.028176194056868553, 0.018923457711935043, -0.02191157639026642, -0.01596383936703205, 0.021002663299441338, -0.017793353646993637, -0.01587398536503315, -0.019004955887794495, -0.03418605402112007, -0.05531252548098564, 0.010111087001860142, -0.04897013679146767, -0.02120400406420231, -0.00690472824499011, -0.010010919533669949, 0.020040588453412056, -0.03568845987319946, 0.000014823856872681063, 0.0029164794832468033, -0.04120851308107376, 0.00759839778766036, -0.00653776666149497, -0.001580850686877966, 0.02210596390068531, 0.0055305371060967445, 0.05480607599020004, -0.05352804809808731, -0.04484984651207924, 0.015469187870621681, -0.005900680553168058, 0.0034871932584792376, 0.009868591092526913, -0.0025186350103467703, 0.019053999334573746, -0.007813374511897564, 0.014450568705797195, -0.017593611031770706, 0.03466612845659256, 0.0044562495313584805, 0.0076688965782523155, 0.016816889867186546, -0.0018362492555752397, -0.01692083291709423, 0.023880651220679283, -0.007903467863798141, 0.05200896039605141, 0.006805329583585262, -0.01361139491200447, -0.021530166268348694, -0.00808633677661419, -0.039418693631887436, 0.041570715606212616, 0.0752149447798729, -0.009870226494967937, 0.0009896362898871303, 0.03791908919811249, -0.006477785762399435, -0.015007306821644306, 0.0058075725100934505, -0.026594068855047226, 0.058634866029024124, 0.018972380086779594, -0.016758248209953308, -0.004600117914378643, -0.013192426413297653, -0.022737160325050354, -0.033940501511096954, 0.046903111040592194, 0.035709988325834274, 0.02320276014506817, -0.01060574222356081, -0.03862544894218445, 0.007135321386158466, 0.028044484555721283, -0.0550917349755764, -0.03159211948513985, -0.020781533792614937, 0.011697926558554173, -0.039369966834783554, -0.0032560285180807114 ]
<p>I am currently trying to do the following in R:</p> <p>I have thousands of <strong>measured spectra</strong> (x,y; see below). Each spectra has one or two peaks. Also I have sets of <strong>"training" spectra</strong> obtained in more controlled conditions and I would like to know which of my training spectra has the closest match to the measured spectra!? </p> <p>I was thinking that some sort of pattern recognition would be useful but I know too little to make an informed choice as this is a bit outside of my usual work-area</p> <ul> <li>What is the most promising way/function in R to do this kind of pattern recognition I want?</li> <li>In case pattern recognition (like PCA) is not the most promising way, what other options are there?</li> </ul> <p>I am looking for sample bits of code or literature dealing with this kind of data analysis. </p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/5mpqU.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p><strong>EDIT</strong> The peak position will most probably always be the same, however the laser used to record the spectra is temperature controlled and slight variations are possible. The intensity will change depending on experimental conditions. The two peaks sould be treated as independet peaks.</p>
73,946
[ -0.0002682881022337824, -0.017750509083271027, -0.001770846894942224, -0.02779810130596161, 0.01574084348976612, 0.007174179423600435, -0.014104061760008335, -0.03868532553315163, 0.045677550137043, -0.03965814784169197, 0.050471823662519455, 0.05296773836016655, 0.022909466177225113, 0.04011518880724907, 0.011553636752068996, -0.0041845389641821384, -0.004399394616484642, -0.004968625959008932, -0.03144482523202896, -0.006631585769355297, -0.024387776851654053, 0.017720405012369156, -0.011775909923017025, 0.020429830998182297, -0.054465677589178085, 0.0654219537973404, 0.005766978487372398, 0.00897868163883686, -0.0029227114282548428, 0.05727607011795044, -0.05316951498389244, -0.03209549933671951, -0.0014775608433410525, 0.04412897676229477, 0.043663810938596725, 0.0021297906059771776, -0.015681125223636627, -0.04862520843744278, -0.002923703985288739, 0.039265990257263184, -0.0401834174990654, -0.027267122641205788, -0.0076475017704069614, 0.03943634778261185, -0.019977297633886337, 0.01248928252607584, -0.004790873266756535, -0.03013618476688862, 0.03058719076216221, -0.031038451939821243, 0.08018524199724197, 0.0010835868306457996, 0.01566876284778118, 0.04838090017437935, -0.0295554231852293, 0.017962954938411713, 0.05597277358174324, 0.06491072475910187, -0.014020014554262161, -0.05971738323569298, -0.02563498727977276, -0.03490067273378372, 0.0051533435471355915, 0.014803465455770493, -0.040703337639570236, 0.0150369331240654, 0.00218969932757318, -0.012109559029340744, 0.017839495092630386, 0.0019122814992442727, 0.015339357778429985, 0.0260629840195179, 0.04208176210522652, -0.049664344638586044, -0.017748236656188965, -0.033368125557899475, -0.012013539671897888, 0.03900715708732605, 0.03723116219043732, 0.023246122524142265, 0.017862878739833832, 0.004740124102681875, 0.005723273381590843, 0.009620732627809048, 0.01662835106253624, -0.021790334954857826, 0.078126460313797, -0.016077879816293716, 0.014052944257855415, 0.01244641188532114, 0.028278440237045288, 0.03284187614917755, 0.059843238443136215, 0.04128948226571083, -0.021966176107525826, -0.0035521958488970995, 0.023118965327739716, 0.042400699108839035, -0.021207619458436966, -0.010851962491869926, 0.028165211901068687, -0.019194716587662697, 0.00385355856269598, 0.075083427131176, -0.02917240373790264, -0.025621945038437843, -0.011346904560923576, -0.024592280387878418, -0.002828948898240924, -0.00017073398339562118, -0.014725688844919205, 0.031809452921152115, 0.00252774846740067, -0.036680668592453, 0.00901710707694292, -0.0034025395289063454, 0.002381119644269347, -0.010086791589856148, 0.05749843642115593, 0.09130734950304031, 0.017907895147800446, -0.04152246192097664, -0.0011339643970131874, -0.01652618683874607, -0.03274340182542801, 0.007725866045802832, 0.049686823040246964, -0.00554188946262002, -0.06150352209806442, 0.03553856909275055, -0.04138222336769104, -0.0052133481949567795, 0.021242843940854073, -0.02675292082130909, 0.010965163819491863, -0.0025192636530846357, -0.10177464783191681, -0.0335598923265934, 0.018428487703204155, -0.014849056489765644, -0.02225615456700325, -0.05267878249287605, 0.004373510368168354, 0.0249177198857069, 0.07394302636384964, 0.001957821426913142, 0.035405367612838745, 0.026033254340291023, 0.01197894662618637, 0.0033128801733255386, -0.013371305540204048, -0.020241666585206985, 0.006806686986237764, -0.03502707555890083, -0.021134106442332268, -0.049370404332876205, -0.006994480267167091, 0.012888330034911633, -0.027849309146404266, 0.01862783543765545, 0.005073074251413345, -0.016923442482948303, 0.005638894159346819, 0.015168086625635624, 0.0452888160943985, 0.01966039277613163, 0.09830740839242935, -0.01436423696577549, 0.011988912709057331, 0.0008248292724601924, -0.03329457715153694, 0.018412213772535324, 0.018243664875626564, 0.013593309558928013, 0.04408415034413338, -0.02657405100762844, 0.010153398849070072, 0.00489619979634881, 0.0027017558459192514, 0.03841223195195198, -0.050505492836236954, -0.02320168726146221, -0.0012487091589719057, -0.016213493421673775, 0.03320557251572609, 0.04428059235215187, 0.024439731612801552, -0.04647821933031082, 0.040196649730205536, -0.03886915370821953, -0.010438371449708939, -0.07928890734910965, 0.004138912074267864, -0.030234728008508682, -0.03584260120987892, 0.006372679024934769, 0.029987497255206108, 0.031279306858778, -0.0013288253685459495, -0.038193561136722565, 0.015154289081692696, -0.0026388606056571007, 0.035975608974695206, -0.020909959450364113, -0.010007835924625397, 0.0349314883351326, 0.020009774714708328, -0.013979973271489143, 0.04878310114145279, -0.05382689833641052, -0.03932833671569824, -0.0041167582385241985, -0.06460961699485779, 0.018297549337148666, 0.00009281760867452249, 0.004952264949679375, -0.004251259844750166, 0.005615213420242071, -0.03858732804656029, 0.011715349741280079, -0.048237044364213943, 0.06061688810586929, 0.026278385892510414, -0.0038011635188013315, 0.0006474136025644839, -0.01547549944370985, 0.013361155055463314, 0.05667939409613609, -0.05467308312654495, -0.05623961612582207, -0.07242755591869354, -0.01098248828202486, 0.013568672351539135, 0.06093785911798477, -0.045753397047519684, 0.019272595643997192, 0.04149913787841797, 0.0130075104534626, 0.026403577998280525, 0.009245451539754868, -0.01441657729446888, -0.02487824857234955, 0.031294919550418854, 0.01689733751118183, 0.003354635089635849, 0.014565535821020603, 0.009952319785952568, 0.022137794643640518, 0.06495397537946701, -0.00469103641808033, -0.011807572096586227, 0.0606323704123497, -0.026278626173734665, 0.014955543912947178, -0.0018883888842538, -0.02893020026385784, 0.06306466460227966, -0.014185476116836071, 0.043999116867780685, 0.040199749171733856, -0.002999088494107127, 0.009571058675646782, 0.013792498037219048, -0.0048226360231637955, -0.0067481379956007, 0.040031421929597855, -0.03634708374738693, 0.010808739811182022, 0.006935035809874535, -0.047268860042095184, 0.039231788367033005, -0.01834934949874878, -0.023030677810311317, -0.025123611092567444, 0.018438534811139107, 0.052443500608205795, 0.029680727049708366, 0.0207227673381567, -0.061750415712594986, -0.03553580120205879, -0.00014298254973255098, -0.037418704479932785, 0.045454416424036026, 0.0010704146698117256, -0.04378153011202812, -0.039535295218229294, -0.01873956061899662, -0.01409187912940979, 0.000039914477383717895, -0.007373469416052103, -0.017302196472883224, 0.014211993664503098, -0.00885543879121542, -0.07761244475841522, -0.017034433782100677, -0.0026750864926725626, 0.03144815191626549, -0.02051650546491146, -0.014338167384266853, 0.030870236456394196, -0.0014505945146083832, -0.03604860231280327, 0.005778361111879349, -0.012106872163712978, 0.002765440382063389, -0.014882612973451614, 0.011670146137475967, 0.015380870550870895, 0.0073066516779363155, -0.011878379620611668, 0.047960564494132996, 0.004505181219428778, -0.019258735701441765, -0.08011137694120407, -0.02597842738032341, 0.0023354303557425737, 0.0049300966784358025, 0.029587093740701675, 0.0034404643811285496, 0.0312587134540081, 0.051722101867198944, 0.033244285732507706, -0.027246734127402306, -0.04572112485766411, 0.009163205511868, -0.037809818983078, -0.0226608756929636, 0.030772700905799866, 0.01249685324728489, 0.006315418053418398, -0.005325370468199253, 0.006648258771747351, 0.0069489870220422745, 0.06805755943059921, 0.024050842970609665, -0.02470511756837368, 0.027288060635328293, -0.017635663971304893, -0.00936813186854124, 0.05005454272031784, 0.034299321472644806, -0.033783525228500366, 0.01937641017138958, -0.015606231987476349, -0.02201102115213871, 0.02370140142738819, -0.04601772874593735, -0.0023350678384304047, 0.004830102901905775, 0.015806470066308975, -0.04603590816259384, 0.013216933235526085, 0.008947371505200863, -0.012793941423296928, -0.0009317674557678401, 0.03805357217788696, 0.025278866291046143, 0.0020465063862502575, -0.01520993560552597, 0.01849004067480564, 0.024053262546658516, 0.012955044396221638, 0.013506481423974037, 0.0038153992500156164, -0.03617948293685913, -0.003740261774510145, -0.022002872079610825, -0.03839423879981041, 0.04152658209204674, 0.012629536911845207, 0.04048512503504753, 0.012301917187869549, -0.01605086773633957, 0.033726468682289124, -0.046089351177215576, 0.0004614278441295028, -0.014006871730089188, 0.05225544795393944, 0.015058482997119427, 0.04856907203793526, 0.049513548612594604, 0.007223236840218306, 0.0499701164662838, -0.015072375535964966, -0.10065365582704544, 0.017043529078364372, -0.001550143351778388, 0.018813978880643845, -0.021136052906513214, -0.009241201914846897, -0.0037047157529741526, -0.03266529738903046, 0.013909222558140755, 0.024471623823046684, 0.01714710146188736, -0.042454250156879425, -0.015595685690641403, -0.023432014510035515, 0.0035397675819694996, -0.044419724494218826, 0.021497895941138268, 0.038838762789964676, -0.003527954686433077, 0.024923410266637802, 0.01073015108704567, -0.01576600782573223, 0.004292725119739771, 0.004400741308927536, -0.020915791392326355, 0.027901096269488335, 0.06611236184835434, -0.009001150727272034, 0.04608505591750145, -0.01435840968042612, 0.028969470411539078, -0.01777440682053566, 0.03368136286735535, 0.041030991822481155, -0.026134289801120758, -0.018976839259266853, -0.019802428781986237, 0.008205204270780087, 0.019805626943707466, 0.050968777388334274, -0.0033259086776524782, -0.040753744542598724, 0.003923278767615557, 0.0049334256909787655, -0.06600020080804825, -0.01235943753272295, 0.039632052183151245, 0.05031581595540047, 0.009546386078000069, -0.01706230267882347, -0.016349373385310173, -0.009230020456016064, 0.00963092502206564, 0.01864529401063919, -0.005972815677523613, -0.0060208942741155624, 0.022650960832834244, 0.037406470626592636, 0.02677515149116516, -0.030968720093369484, -0.0338565893471241, -0.013347875326871872, 0.04742595553398132, -0.04380933195352554, -0.0374467708170414, -0.021753976121544838, 0.02649718150496483, 0.055261608213186264, -0.03699902817606926, 0.007109816651791334, -0.10001501441001892, 0.006802753545343876, 0.05331098660826683, 0.043266747146844864, -0.012479222379624844, -0.03891715407371521, -0.03102417103946209, -0.025126436725258827, 0.035371121019124985, -0.06272834539413452, 0.03712104633450508, 0.003249028930440545, -0.01203129906207323, -0.00247777346521616, -0.014156192541122437, -0.038371965289115906, -0.007310918532311916, -0.008484299294650555, 0.03200605884194374, -0.024048179388046265, -0.05874420329928398, -0.025161417201161385, 0.010654732584953308, 0.022835316136479378, 0.028669916093349457, -0.030482839792966843, -0.012544074095785618, 0.023174308240413666, 0.0019790232181549072, -0.02022436447441578, -0.0576121062040329, -0.012475050054490566, 0.01322981994599104, -0.0008627019706182182, 0.04580456390976906, -0.022055841982364655, -0.0700259730219841, 0.009932579472661018, 0.04196081683039665, 0.0021956556010991335, -0.012090004980564117, -0.0054959626868367195, 0.014815273694694042, 0.06719954311847687, 0.013388840481638908, 0.09387852996587753, 0.027259601280093193, -0.008033176884055138, 0.0083465576171875, -0.020288586616516113, 0.038805413991212845, -0.0234906617552042, -0.05713029205799103, -0.043965745717287064, 0.009029275737702847, -0.034178800880908966, 0.03519282117486, -0.02612900920212269, 0.03278914466500282, -0.009142937138676643, 0.0044784643687307835, 0.021524224430322647, 0.04052489623427391, -0.036240506917238235, -0.015328748151659966, -0.014961116015911102, 0.07320138812065125, -0.0004594572528731078, -0.007243746891617775, 0.004600870423018932, 0.006420827936381102, -0.01774437725543976, 0.021457595750689507, -0.04502520710229874, 0.0315466970205307, -0.061381228268146515, 0.006948747672140598, 0.033962432295084, -0.0249621644616127, 0.02562037482857704, -0.017865300178527832, 0.04757234454154968, 0.04275822639465332, -0.01764022745192051, -0.001424337038770318, 0.004202555399388075, 0.003034943249076605, 0.018950700759887695, -0.01580073870718479, 0.05083569884300232, -0.04493025690317154, 0.002554688835516572, -0.04907708615064621, -0.05905991792678833, -0.009491527453064919, 0.019738130271434784, -0.016480904072523117, -0.059771519154310226, -0.00040815435932017863, -0.012536472640931606, 0.0018626629607751966, -0.019991111010313034, 0.040923524647951126, -0.01478477194905281, 0.002346610650420189, 0.01687365397810936, 0.0028128891717642546, 0.05901098996400833, -0.003837621072307229, 0.015167267993092537, 0.02579658292233944, -0.0018941301386803389, -0.023386383429169655, 0.009957686997950077, 0.017514334991574287, -0.04236917942762375, -0.043437112122774124, -0.04025896638631821, 0.0462183840572834, 0.029904410243034363, -0.013897217810153961, -0.017848772928118706, 0.006616387981921434, 0.021545082330703735, -0.018834508955478668, -0.062382299453020096, 0.006046708207577467, -0.02393370307981968, -0.030729584395885468, -0.021711360663175583, -0.011405897326767445, 0.01586015522480011, -0.027337681502103806, 0.004991660825908184, 0.011766252107918262, -0.022892072796821594, 0.03397902846336365, 0.04555395990610123, -0.029242927208542824, 0.01799379289150238, -0.019093435257673264, -0.039881687611341476, 0.024934930726885796, -0.03781430423259735, 0.03347223997116089, -0.011948776431381702, 0.01784701459109783, -0.032734181731939316, -0.06267773360013962, -0.036798473447561264, -0.022194594144821167, 0.07058074325323105, 0.04935484379529953, 0.06887704133987427, 0.07108841836452484, 0.0020207532215863466, 0.025361791253089905, -0.025896968320012093, -0.022002143785357475, -0.0022119663190096617, 0.02898772619664669, 0.03337036445736885, 0.012847460806369781, -0.027417918667197227, 0.04603723809123039, 0.018038619309663773, 0.008500942960381508, 0.060175057500600815, 0.00917647872120142, 0.03454655781388283, 0.00820668414235115, -0.03354871645569801, -0.03356223553419113, 0.010860267095267773, -0.029068518429994583, 0.018858719617128372, 0.008306987583637238, -0.012887293472886086, 0.01828181743621826, 0.022075552493333817, 0.01909266784787178, -0.05017350986599922, -0.014038420282304287, -0.0830005407333374, 0.03420049697160721, 0.05182097479701042, 0.011788710951805115, 0.04817068576812744, 0.054366350173950195, 0.013944070786237717, -0.0016236406518146396, 0.013085251674056053, -0.030874919146299362, -0.05245470255613327, -0.0075838202610611916, -0.004439326003193855, -0.06238457188010216, 0.054137229919433594, -0.004490707069635391, -0.04784836247563362, 0.03252825886011124, -0.012442960403859615, -0.00671752355992794, 0.020276019349694252, 0.06658763438463211, 0.004902858752757311, 0.020558783784508705, 0.002306648064404726, -0.008042417466640472, 0.016339540481567383, 0.01977834291756153, 0.13264109194278717, 0.08092834800481796, 0.03427809104323387, -0.061273958534002304, 0.0067709144204854965, 0.013412661850452423, -0.04828336834907532, -0.013770838268101215, -0.0026159121189266443, 0.007426409516483545, 0.013352045789361, 0.02571360394358635, 0.031053323298692703, 0.010280169546604156, 0.005184187088161707, 0.036947235465049744, 0.0006562352646142244, 0.00830473005771637, 0.038258492946624756, 0.00811145082116127, 0.010200864635407925, 0.00929491501301527, -0.026187177747488022, 0.044049330055713654, -0.013817112892866135, -0.019091764464974403, -0.047099679708480835, -0.042699702084064484, 0.04044096916913986, -0.0026430143043398857, -0.03189225122332573, -0.01054300181567669, 0.0035765711218118668, 0.003119872882962227, -0.0015215142630040646, 0.02851404994726181, 0.005989735014736652, -0.02174329198896885, -0.007735074497759342, 0.004962545819580555, 0.02367786318063736, -0.02240956388413906, -0.001731078838929534, -0.0012654957827180624, -0.012086130678653717, -0.05161473527550697, -0.06042957305908203, 0.038096439093351364, 0.0036215689033269882, -0.008781570009887218, 0.014727032743394375, 0.0006089892121963203, 0.017721550539135933, -0.04004434868693352, 0.00034531645360402763, 0.025003666058182716, 0.06147522106766701, -0.04619581997394562, 0.017568059265613556, -0.0701051577925682, 0.0026403875090181828, -0.002410301472991705, 0.020227724686264992, 0.006739016156643629, -0.01509652566164732, -0.011965490877628326, -0.02766881324350834, 0.048221655189991, 0.004436937626451254, 0.0102235721424222, 0.0009095788118429482, -0.020183304324746132, -0.0026781174819916487, -0.041755806654691696, 0.0049246191047132015, 0.019464178010821342, 0.015064437873661518, 0.010447637178003788, -0.04690952226519585, 0.001664789393544197, -0.06518097221851349, 0.010915077291429043, -0.02571655623614788, 0.00721478508785367, 0.02393040433526039, -0.0077596548944711685, 0.06752333045005798, 0.011926486156880856, 0.03675130382180214, 0.010048283264040947, -0.0066071245819330215, 0.011765140108764172, 0.0439000278711319, -0.06629863381385803, -0.03525634482502937, -0.018584633246064186, -0.04727735370397568, 0.020066937431693077, 0.01911248080432415, 0.05561043694615364, 0.013445859774947166, -0.014362583868205547, 0.023858286440372467, 0.015089386142790318, -0.0646262913942337, -0.006717282347381115, 0.00626727007329464, -0.026578517630696297, 0.012147589586675167, -0.027950016781687737, -0.023600712418556213, -0.04510238766670227, -0.022344177588820457, -0.02204783819615841, -0.025377562269568443, -0.0015005649765953422, 0.011953568086028099, -0.023206796497106552, 0.035758066922426224, 0.03455495834350586, -0.0022137437481433153, -0.0035652972292155027, -0.006224587559700012, -0.035393547266721725, -0.018706249073147774, -0.02145650051534176, -0.02092176489531994, -0.007285354193300009, 0.001071274047717452, -0.02303272671997547, -0.017914168536663055, 0.03023989126086235, 0.013247966766357422, 0.03353848680853844, -0.000019849570890073664, -0.007173890247941017, -0.015446102246642113, 0.04675111174583435, -0.01391538605093956, -0.01760071888566017, -0.0011507952585816383, -0.05792524665594101, -0.026205170899629593, 0.005291388835757971, -0.040516942739486694, 0.0051075792871415615, 0.03553127869963646, 0.007356663700193167, -0.00002317510370630771, 0.02436455339193344, 0.017944607883691788, -0.03610772639513016, 0.0124692777171731, 0.025846561416983604, 0.019921213388442993, 0.04610975831747055, 0.0492626316845417, 0.01627073995769024, -0.031187495216727257, 0.01292448304593563, 0.024728240445256233, 0.010174617171287537, -0.011811650358140469, 0.0018380454275757074, -0.03825908899307251, 0.0024264943785965443, -0.005813307128846645, 0.014985021203756332, 0.048036277294158936, 0.03200274333357811, -0.031136196106672287, 0.019460367038846016, -0.029910966753959656, 0.02654120698571205, -0.11354941129684448, -0.00023314077407121658, 0.012317455373704433, 0.0026760397013276815, 0.005429967772215605, -0.06592618674039841, 0.006168541498482227, 0.0357576385140419, -0.039807021617889404, -0.012922636233270168, -0.011204316280782223, -0.007546412758529186, 0.009863990359008312, 0.053420260548591614, -0.050231028348207474, -0.0004940845537930727, 0.03927747160196304, 0.03829403594136238, 0.05388565734028816, 0.02688160538673401, 0.01990935020148754, 0.0032159017864614725, -0.0025346525944769382, 0.01527077704668045, 0.029081810265779495, -0.05243358016014099, 0.03009948879480362, -0.019218359142541885, -0.005087788682430983, 0.0038950785528868437, -0.04652952775359154, 0.030001752078533173, 0.03109884262084961, 0.016461193561553955, -0.01742648333311081, 0.06127516180276871, -0.012034633196890354, -0.02141125127673149, -0.021280787885189056, -0.020416229963302612, 0.012109304778277874, 0.020736869424581528, -0.0065007321536540985, 0.012794576585292816, 0.024726025760173798, -0.019537178799510002, -0.01296924240887165, 0.04331471025943756, -0.017255345359444618, -0.007416847161948681, -0.008645415306091309, 0.02634340524673462, -0.0070397816598415375, -0.02402743697166443, -0.011424737051129341, -0.04479391872882843, 0.02200964093208313, 0.030986297875642776, 0.037917036563158035, 0.007452969904989004, -0.021384576335549355, -0.016635745763778687, -0.04935907572507858, 0.009042173624038696, 0.0010360660962760448, -0.04221739619970322, -0.038611505180597305, 0.013407805003225803, 0.009127563796937466, -0.026152681559324265, -0.03305306285619736, 0.009087920188903809, -0.029564328491687775, 0.04500594735145569, -0.02290283516049385, 0.015381567180156708, 0.00647913571447134, -0.016816508024930954, -0.010426335036754608, -0.10037156939506531, 0.036786701530218124, -0.02860139310359955, -0.01352686807513237, -0.0458393357694149, -0.032452862709760666, -0.012286262586712837, 0.025361116975545883, 0.023466553539037704, 0.014951393008232117, -0.005327026825398207, 0.010881374590098858, -0.0024844834115356207, 0.0040504951030015945, -0.04292265325784683, 0.02966887131333351, -0.011903478763997555, 0.0025967538822442293, -0.004875092767179012, -0.007293172180652618, -0.003537182928994298, 0.04139583930373192, 0.030732786282896996, -0.01393364742398262, 0.004729531239718199, 0.004535399843007326, 0.00645861541852355, 0.04453444480895996, -0.03467046469449997, -0.03233391046524048, 0.035376109182834625, 0.02287261374294758, -0.012043708935379982, 0.04429582133889198, -0.02250761166214943, -0.05135974660515785, 0.043327633291482925, -0.036563970148563385, -0.03287256136536598, 0.03472654148936272, 0.019944097846746445, 0.02588704228401184, -0.05075935274362564, 0.018394820392131805, -0.023523660376667976, -0.030779672786593437, -0.01431630551815033, 0.03471515327692032, -0.011687268503010273, 0.010199709795415401, -0.008386796340346336, 0.04542932286858559, 0.0031517778988927603, 0.0078819515183568, -0.016747476533055305, 0.0016612909967079759, 0.05483229458332062, -0.004226654767990112, 0.049173321574926376, 0.011654544621706009, 0.005175526719540358, -0.027331463992595673, -0.030050406232476234, 0.025465257465839386, -0.020719308406114578, -0.009935840964317322, 0.03328615427017212, -0.02941444143652916, 0.022193141281604767, 0.0014461672399193048, -0.009887894615530968, 0.04432474449276924, -0.047046512365341187, -0.016529981046915054, -0.042355068027973175, -0.056109555065631866, 0.003663702867925167, 0.011997707188129425, 0.002659738529473543, 0.019188551232218742, 0.01945708505809307, 0.049291547387838364, -0.0017568552866578102, 0.02006475068628788, 0.030630361288785934, -0.05323762819170952, 0.025026490911841393, -0.016673104837536812, -0.0027507804334163666, -0.0007951873703859746, -0.010527489706873894, -0.036751534789800644, -0.012981768697500229, 0.010132981464266777, 0.03793821483850479, 0.022405488416552544, -0.007688854355365038, -0.013169929385185242, -0.013570771552622318, 0.04627828299999237, -0.08134418725967407, -0.01309695839881897, -0.03404590114951134, 0.011859633959829807, -0.022108543664216995, -0.034205902367830276 ]
<p>I am trying to understand standard error "clustering" and how to execute in R (it is trivial in Stata). In R I have been unsuccessful using either <code>plm</code> or writing my own function. I'll use the <code>diamonds</code> data from the <code>ggplot2</code> package.</p> <p>I can do fixed effects with either dummy variables</p> <pre><code>&gt; library(plyr) &gt; library(ggplot2) &gt; library(lmtest) &gt; library(sandwich) &gt; # with dummies to create fixed effects &gt; fe.lsdv &lt;- lm(price ~ carat + factor(cut) + 0, data = diamonds) &gt; ct.lsdv &lt;- coeftest(fe.lsdv, vcov. = vcovHC) &gt; ct.lsdv t test of coefficients: Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(&gt;|t|) carat 7871.082 24.892 316.207 &lt; 2.2e-16 *** factor(cut)Fair -3875.470 51.190 -75.707 &lt; 2.2e-16 *** factor(cut)Good -2755.138 26.570 -103.692 &lt; 2.2e-16 *** factor(cut)Very Good -2365.334 20.548 -115.111 &lt; 2.2e-16 *** factor(cut)Premium -2436.393 21.172 -115.075 &lt; 2.2e-16 *** factor(cut)Ideal -2074.546 16.092 -128.920 &lt; 2.2e-16 *** --- Signif. codes: 0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1 </code></pre> <p>or by de-meaning both left- and right-hand sides (no time invariant regressors here) and correcting degrees of freedom.</p> <pre><code>&gt; # by demeaning with degrees of freedom correction &gt; diamonds &lt;- ddply(diamonds, .(cut), transform, price.dm = price - mean(price), carat.dm = carat .... [TRUNCATED] &gt; fe.dm &lt;- lm(price.dm ~ carat.dm + 0, data = diamonds) &gt; ct.dm &lt;- coeftest(fe.dm, vcov. = vcovHC, df = nrow(diamonds) - 1 - 5) &gt; ct.dm t test of coefficients: Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(&gt;|t|) carat.dm 7871.082 24.888 316.26 &lt; 2.2e-16 *** --- Signif. codes: 0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1 </code></pre> <p>I can't replicate these results with <code>plm</code>, because I don't have a "time" index (i.e., this isn't really a panel, just clusters that could have a common bias in their error terms).</p> <pre><code>&gt; plm.temp &lt;- plm(price ~ carat, data = diamonds, index = "cut") duplicate couples (time-id) Error in pdim.default(index[[1]], index[[2]]) : </code></pre> <p>I also tried to code my own covariance matrix with clustered standard error using Stata's explanation of their <code>cluster</code> option (<a href="http://www.stata.com/support/faqs/stat/cluster.html">explained here</a>), which is to solve $$\hat V_{cluster} = (X&#39;X)^{-1} \left( \sum_{j=1}^{n_c} u_j&#39;u_j \right) (X&#39;X)^{-1}$$ where $u_j = \sum_{cluster~j} e_i * x_i$, $n_c$ si the number of clusters, $e_i$ is the residual for the $i^{th}$ observation and $x_i$ is the row vector of predictors, including the constant (this also appears as equation (7.22) in Wooldridge's <em>Cross Section and Panel Data</em>). But the following code gives very large covariance matrices. Are these very large values given the small number of clusters I have? Given that I can't get <code>plm</code> to do clusters on one factor, I'm not sure how to benchmark my code.</p> <pre><code>&gt; # with cluster robust se &gt; lm.temp &lt;- lm(price ~ carat + factor(cut) + 0, data = diamonds) &gt; &gt; # using the model that Stata uses &gt; stata.clustering &lt;- function(x, clu, res) { + x &lt;- as.matrix(x) + clu &lt;- as.vector(clu) + res &lt;- as.vector(res) + fac &lt;- unique(clu) + num.fac &lt;- length(fac) + num.reg &lt;- ncol(x) + u &lt;- matrix(NA, nrow = num.fac, ncol = num.reg) + meat &lt;- matrix(NA, nrow = num.reg, ncol = num.reg) + + # outer terms (X'X)^-1 + outer &lt;- solve(t(x) %*% x) + + # inner term sum_j u_j'u_j where u_j = sum_i e_i * x_i + for (i in seq(num.fac)) { + index.loop &lt;- clu == fac[i] + res.loop &lt;- res[index.loop] + x.loop &lt;- x[clu == fac[i], ] + u[i, ] &lt;- as.vector(colSums(res.loop * x.loop)) + } + inner &lt;- t(u) %*% u + + # + V &lt;- outer %*% inner %*% outer + return(V) + } &gt; x.temp &lt;- data.frame(const = 1, diamonds[, "carat"]) &gt; summary(lm.temp) Call: lm(formula = price ~ carat + factor(cut) + 0, data = diamonds) Residuals: Min 1Q Median 3Q Max -17540.7 -791.6 -37.6 522.1 12721.4 Coefficients: Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(&gt;|t|) carat 7871.08 13.98 563.0 &lt;2e-16 *** factor(cut)Fair -3875.47 40.41 -95.9 &lt;2e-16 *** factor(cut)Good -2755.14 24.63 -111.9 &lt;2e-16 *** factor(cut)Very Good -2365.33 17.78 -133.0 &lt;2e-16 *** factor(cut)Premium -2436.39 17.92 -136.0 &lt;2e-16 *** factor(cut)Ideal -2074.55 14.23 -145.8 &lt;2e-16 *** --- Signif. codes: 0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1 Residual standard error: 1511 on 53934 degrees of freedom Multiple R-squared: 0.9272, Adjusted R-squared: 0.9272 F-statistic: 1.145e+05 on 6 and 53934 DF, p-value: &lt; 2.2e-16 &gt; stata.clustering(x = x.temp, clu = diamonds$cut, res = lm.temp$residuals) const diamonds....carat.. const 11352.64 -14227.44 diamonds....carat.. -14227.44 17830.22 </code></pre> <p>Can this be done in R? It is a fairly common technique in econometrics (there's a brief tutorial in <a href="http://sekhon.berkeley.edu/causalinf/sp2010/section/week7.pdf">this lecture</a>), but I can't figure it out in R. Thanks!</p>
48,146
[ -0.00007010444824118167, -0.012878821231424809, -0.017318960279226303, 0.004838517867028713, 0.035762280225753784, 0.005492242984473705, 0.007571057416498661, -0.01602339744567871, 0.03604249656200409, -0.055749088525772095, 0.03387104347348213, 0.035861194133758545, 0.04754611477255821, 0.07293100655078888, -0.007423066068440676, -0.01113506406545639, -0.0010441537015140057, -0.023792847990989685, 0.018779205158352852, 0.03089679218828678, -0.005022663157433271, 0.009332085028290749, -0.029881861060857773, -0.01462890300899744, -0.016532832756638527, 0.04216981306672096, 0.0008554317755624652, -0.03510287031531334, -0.016174474731087685, 0.03673391416668892, -0.04068407788872719, -0.0419754832983017, 0.033896222710609436, -0.02829364500939846, 0.006227816920727491, 0.05737273395061493, 0.010180850513279438, -0.01574779488146305, -0.03561015799641609, 0.02741575799882412, -0.03465602919459343, 0.030282801017165184, -0.03820297494530678, 0.033967118710279465, 0.05558701232075691, 0.04419160261750221, 0.0009179802145808935, -0.019712159410119057, 0.052124809473752975, 0.0036551530938595533, 0.038700688630342484, 0.006790360901504755, -0.022457987070083618, -0.018596947193145752, -0.03657131642103195, -0.022105230018496513, 0.02774866670370102, 0.06408260017633438, 0.008034318685531616, -0.03097398392856121, -0.01352349016815424, -0.03768032416701317, 0.061494145542383194, -0.01920350082218647, 0.014026501215994358, -0.007605274207890034, 0.02597697637975216, -0.006432455498725176, 0.033132992684841156, -0.019688522443175316, -0.002031297655776143, 0.00014973912038840353, -0.012044182978570461, 0.012598962523043156, 0.0391080379486084, -0.022913245484232903, 0.01571146585047245, -0.012885984033346176, -0.004920864012092352, 0.030557962134480476, 0.00793102104216814, 0.027656299993395805, -0.016953138634562492, 0.05407790094614029, -0.0013044166844338179, 0.02501186728477478, 0.05403069034218788, -0.04225988686084747, 0.01613709330558777, 0.041317347437143326, -0.003976280335336924, -0.009027172811329365, 0.05911579728126526, 0.006821152754127979, -0.01661612093448639, 0.032271116971969604, -0.0031112174037843943, 0.006837314926087856, 0.009663590230047703, -0.025683976709842682, -0.043508294969797134, -0.05682777240872383, -0.004323210567235947, 0.05843672156333923, -0.02150190807878971, -0.023204978555440903, -0.02234654873609543, -0.03599411994218826, 0.003997165244072676, -0.04464589059352875, -0.00585540384054184, 0.021583067253232002, 0.0042108697816729546, -0.005255657248198986, -0.030232956632971764, -0.027951134368777275, 0.013560914434492588, 0.009657653979957104, 0.08158402889966965, 0.019052764400839806, 0.09445386379957199, -0.03196229040622711, 0.005453839898109436, -0.007733440957963467, -0.06047801300883293, 0.03303547576069832, 0.04343453422188759, -0.008252162486314774, 0.0020588203333318233, 0.009820659644901752, 0.06195860728621483, -0.05375684052705765, 0.01434332225471735, 0.013164895586669445, 0.009488455951213837, -0.000015431360225193202, -0.07697895914316177, -0.03836502879858017, -0.005192052107304335, -0.007327273953706026, -0.018505332991480827, -0.05480245500802994, -0.02155793458223343, -0.017587341368198395, 0.03673580661416054, -0.005685151554644108, 0.05644054338335991, 0.02891387790441513, 0.020727984607219696, 0.03708009794354439, -0.0473330095410347, -0.017109902575612068, -0.04813404753804207, -0.0027896787505596876, -0.029738398268818855, -0.04255615174770355, 0.025703344494104385, -0.010244614444673061, -0.03177645057439804, 0.019967973232269287, 0.035393062978982925, -0.005893363151699305, -0.02427280694246292, -0.0024423825088888407, -0.036244187504053116, -0.03005041554570198, 0.04518260434269905, 0.003420000895857811, 0.0176226869225502, 0.032812297344207764, -0.06448139250278473, 0.015702441334724426, -0.025973744690418243, 0.035837385803461075, 0.00903837475925684, 0.000558341562282294, 0.04669622704386711, -0.034459080547094345, 0.030304957181215286, 0.010060073807835579, -0.04371977597475052, -0.02235652320086956, 0.009488709270954132, -0.009643417783081532, 0.012354298494756222, 0.045107096433639526, -0.006801203358918428, 0.014181016944348812, 0.04446222633123398, -0.0815923810005188, -0.06783304363489151, -0.02308424562215805, -0.008178291842341423, -0.00826900452375412, -0.042997878044843674, 0.0053686341270804405, 0.009220769628882408, 0.014028457924723625, 0.020984211936593056, 0.0014552978100255132, -0.024263571947813034, 0.027829157188534737, 0.07012574374675751, -0.04824085161089897, -0.01557634212076664, 0.042975615710020065, 0.055936142802238464, 0.025383153930306435, 0.045591142028570175, -0.019339334219694138, -0.00819228496402502, 0.04366574436426163, -0.021745365113019943, 0.02960323914885521, -0.00007372224354185164, -0.013720578514039516, 0.010195532813668251, -0.01938876509666443, -0.037418510764837265, 0.055955614894628525, -0.06336970627307892, 0.011164339259266853, 0.07081137597560883, -0.026195039972662926, 0.00006473143002949655, -0.003109009237959981, -0.03200317546725273, 0.07540594041347504, -0.03275279700756073, -0.01545016560703516, -0.030523503199219704, -0.026726078242063522, 0.04275902733206749, 0.017006244510412216, -0.04573589190840721, 0.007067299447953701, 0.06823465973138809, -0.0173428226262331, 0.016021670773625374, 0.027339806780219078, -0.0003418206761125475, -0.01598319783806801, 0.04237394779920578, 0.01057903841137886, 0.044226545840501785, 0.010305085219442844, 0.007370391860604286, 0.009736759588122368, 0.015288109891116619, 0.004220583476126194, 0.025439396500587463, 0.11057540774345398, 0.018578480929136276, -0.019320931285619736, -0.01791958510875702, -0.0043216790072619915, 0.0523935928940773, 0.005160647444427013, 0.030261138454079628, 0.04560871422290802, 0.0057397508062422276, -0.02812720648944378, -0.012453570030629635, 0.004775096196681261, 0.0017054451163858175, 0.05141795426607132, -0.01967102289199829, 0.012526500970125198, 0.010985997505486012, 0.002785635180771351, 0.016709133982658386, -0.007317391689866781, -0.011133409105241299, -0.03794976696372032, -0.000029143004212528467, 0.004702676087617874, 0.010493977926671505, -0.038785260170698166, -0.0036847509909421206, 0.02500145509839058, -0.024232231080532074, 0.004113894421607256, 0.06060372292995453, -0.007686801720410585, -0.04282989725470543, -0.003948166035115719, -0.01702296920120716, 0.021898409351706505, 0.02886144071817398, 0.03357544168829918, -0.057169701904058456, 0.04313475266098976, 0.01615493930876255, -0.0013928012922406197, 0.01472733449190855, 0.007669434417039156, -0.03825912997126579, -0.046689294278621674, -0.0502399206161499, 0.05690323933959007, -0.01697305589914322, -0.032411813735961914, 0.010041330941021442, -0.035758599638938904, -0.005359210539609194, -0.02141783945262432, -0.01830214075744152, -0.03813391551375389, 0.007511076983064413, 0.007028717547655106, -0.00513153150677681, -0.002326913643628359, 0.039772991091012955, -0.0651918426156044, -0.04111412167549133, -0.0005802480736747384, 0.012926624156534672, -0.00816535297781229, -0.006977524608373642, -0.017954515293240547, 0.038705796003341675, 0.015561082400381565, -0.013720192015171051, -0.062445349991321564, -0.021416090428829193, -0.012706714682281017, -0.019506776705384254, 0.04654933139681816, 0.019479917362332344, 0.0003018608258571476, 0.018749572336673737, -0.035816047340631485, 0.02999074012041092, 0.05373033508658409, -0.008688632398843765, 0.013334915973246098, 0.03515242412686348, -0.017232606187462807, -0.03451167047023773, 0.04419199377298355, 0.0574822798371315, -0.00805469136685133, -0.008828862570226192, 0.016506122425198555, -0.015400717966258526, -0.0239399466663599, -0.034967657178640366, -0.007228677626699209, -0.01869882084429264, -0.008748914115130901, -0.016009913757443428, -0.003697678679600358, 0.014109437353909016, -0.054865457117557526, 0.0072820368222892284, -0.053267206996679306, 0.0036081522703170776, -0.018693221732974052, 0.006426317151635885, 0.020041881129145622, 0.004710501059889793, 0.04340198636054993, -5.86396083690488e-7, -0.0030457775574177504, -0.011439304798841476, 0.004204996395856142, -0.01730046607553959, -0.00657365657389164, 0.06028580665588379, 0.0679352730512619, 0.01863533817231655, 0.016888361424207687, -0.029719403013586998, 0.005392332095652819, -0.049971289932727814, 0.02035972848534584, -0.06875889748334885, 0.06255487352609634, 0.028371892869472504, 0.05108833312988281, 0.015702666714787483, -0.00044085635454393923, -0.03128912299871445, -0.007797832600772381, -0.04993848875164986, -0.003132572630420327, 0.021951759234070778, -0.001406815368682146, -0.018895786255598068, -0.003591808257624507, 0.019339414313435555, -0.01489848643541336, 0.007220586761832237, -0.028697511181235313, 0.00826823990792036, -0.02835565246641636, 0.008838583715260029, 0.0028463781345635653, 0.010363456793129444, -0.021352581679821014, 0.01236351765692234, 0.03147006407380104, -0.006772334687411785, 0.021412160247564316, 0.047979217022657394, -0.013620470650494099, 0.021355826407670975, -0.024177279323339462, 0.0019866202492266893, 0.007054720539599657, 0.048145171254873276, 0.03616166487336159, -0.010683313943445683, -0.02534070797264576, 0.014571592211723328, 0.03175349533557892, 0.03778425231575966, 0.027509113773703575, -0.012186594307422638, -0.016062622889876366, 0.015940643846988678, 0.00244433106854558, -0.00026880967197939754, 0.002323002088814974, -0.01575729064643383, 0.007987265475094318, 0.07050611823797226, 0.050320856273174286, -0.030708540230989456, 0.018156491219997406, 0.07082366943359375, 0.012582181952893734, -0.002984990831464529, -0.05553418770432472, -0.02516394481062889, 0.014394115656614304, 0.0008866426069289446, 0.030008463189005852, 0.002741387579590082, 0.02405542880296707, 0.01990555226802826, 0.03774306923151016, 0.007813634350895882, -0.03671618551015854, 0.015330898575484753, 0.038201335817575455, 0.022778766229748726, -0.01870036870241165, -0.02234293706715107, -0.0016812742687761784, 0.015854358673095703, 0.01131736021488905, 0.024864042177796364, 0.007171063683927059, -0.1003195270895958, 0.010088859125971794, 0.015200537629425526, 0.03569919243454933, -0.0356878787279129, -0.02208520658314228, -0.0467306450009346, 0.011624152772128582, -0.0076314122416079044, -0.03949529305100441, 0.010351437143981457, -0.021190552040934563, 0.04718891903758049, -0.042064979672431946, -0.03266849368810654, -0.08064404129981995, 0.0022350759245455265, 0.00950170960277319, 0.019416730850934982, -0.041443582624197006, -0.029880333691835403, -0.025242451578378677, 0.029660003259778023, 0.022103527560830116, 0.03294511139392853, -0.04827806353569031, -0.029996175318956375, -0.00738615682348609, 0.002234081970527768, -0.025360073894262314, -0.06562545150518417, 0.012855377979576588, -0.0001917967019835487, 0.050266627222299576, 0.05815185606479645, 0.018510114401578903, -0.020458735525608063, 0.017204057425260544, 0.015987781807780266, 0.008546256460249424, 0.007572670932859182, -0.025870436802506447, 0.0542757511138916, 0.006674849893897772, 0.00955160427838564, 0.05326174572110176, 0.0031146083492785692, 0.004395221825689077, 0.04093699902296066, -0.06168265640735626, 0.03563492372632027, -0.009757768362760544, 0.012564843520522118, -0.05195142701268196, -0.023482147604227066, 0.016111021861433983, -0.015629936009645462, -0.014005430974066257, 0.02832801081240177, -0.06132065877318382, 0.025712257251143456, 0.040737085044384, 0.03591306507587433, -0.033677492290735245, -0.04320185258984566, 0.025323454290628433, 0.026944298297166824, 0.029774259775877, -0.0075204502791166306, -0.00286845862865448, -0.04734146222472191, -0.002344187581911683, -0.011058772914111614, -0.05005564168095589, -0.035406142473220825, -0.007922904565930367, -0.04191214218735695, -0.006948405876755714, -0.05708126351237297, 0.04273676127195358, -0.006052147131413221, 0.06502605229616165, -0.013956251554191113, 0.009680413641035557, -0.015314236283302307, 0.015359175391495228, 0.008841262198984623, -0.00351691828109324, -0.021184829995036125, 0.028606517240405083, 0.005853583104908466, -0.014701912179589272, -0.06816630065441132, -0.028315585106611252, -0.003958904650062323, -0.02934517152607441, -0.04817042127251625, -0.005104392301291227, -0.007699998561292887, 0.043173447251319885, -0.03227604180574417, -0.012381340377032757, 0.06893740594387054, -0.004689483437687159, -0.007249369751662016, -0.02143196016550064, 0.015980008989572525, 0.07830899953842163, -0.016860926523804665, 0.007232733070850372, -0.004435885697603226, -0.001432177028618753, -0.032697826623916626, 0.021572517231106758, -0.006813262589275837, -0.03520014137029648, -0.00279174093157053, -0.0492730475962162, -0.002086837310343981, 0.020238885655999184, -0.02762141078710556, 0.005417429376393557, -0.05856676772236824, 0.007588817737996578, 0.017301203683018684, -0.047236375510692596, -0.043691035360097885, -0.027752526104450226, 0.0004564184055197984, -0.02475707046687603, -0.012021747417747974, -0.0236882995814085, 0.014959217980504036, 0.024502074345946312, -0.03108983486890793, -0.010190460830926895, -0.017448436468839645, 0.05969277024269104, 0.012796434573829174, 0.012708882801234722, -0.001489046378992498, -0.012678636237978935, 0.04171167314052582, 0.02049698308110237, -0.008898995816707611, 0.03181343153119087, -0.00455953786149621, -0.03128605708479881, -0.03358536586165428, -0.054518308490514755, 0.024571863934397697, 0.06473971903324127, 0.011372982524335384, 0.02147374302148819, 0.05712008848786354, -0.03934464231133461, 0.02205604314804077, -0.054443880915641785, -0.013229159638285637, 0.016671422868967056, 0.01579028181731701, 0.03934603929519653, -0.006006200797855854, -0.0076754107140004635, 0.06406180560588837, 0.0076523274183273315, -0.0058465744368731976, 0.019086437299847603, 0.0029381313361227512, 0.03525111451745033, -0.006212475243955851, -0.05436546355485916, -0.012841414660215378, 0.02348717674612999, -0.029048345983028412, 0.06263113021850586, -0.05983077362179756, -0.029011307284235954, 0.026337880641222, 0.04581132158637047, -0.007399559952318668, -0.07452857494354248, -0.038767267018556595, -0.060173310339450836, -0.024120287969708443, 0.0518445186316967, -0.07005641609430313, 0.05634576454758644, 0.01851920783519745, 0.04052387923002243, -0.04273872822523117, 0.04829028248786926, -0.025201238691806793, -0.07430845499038696, -0.001311774249188602, 0.020920421928167343, 0.0009765159920789301, 0.034141603857278824, -0.011857826262712479, -0.03549684211611748, 0.03389163315296173, -0.01744452491402626, -0.004982369020581245, 0.018407367169857025, 0.023186955600976944, 0.021814676001667976, 0.03940139338374138, -0.02386651560664177, 0.02540283091366291, -0.045560549944639206, -0.03853091597557068, 0.17535626888275146, 0.06938820332288742, 0.010279177688062191, -0.057855114340782166, -0.0038077004719525576, 0.04603707790374756, 0.027427002787590027, 0.00857226736843586, -0.009975524619221687, 0.009785220958292484, -0.0082893967628479, 0.035182852298021317, 0.06551804393529892, 0.01587541028857231, -0.03329746052622795, 0.03410284221172333, -0.03194046765565872, -0.0038598759565502405, -0.014338811859488487, 0.07187842577695847, -0.026023270562291145, -0.024500984698534012, -0.03351987525820732, 0.008898600935935974, 0.0056831385008990765, 0.005245645996183157, -0.03354734554886818, -0.005499254446476698, -0.03884363919496536, 0.02101331762969494, -0.0016642569098621607, 0.006339109968394041, 0.020171519368886948, 0.013775319792330265, 0.011667062528431416, -0.023391569033265114, 0.03342482075095177, -0.033732056617736816, 0.03163820505142212, 0.04701632633805275, 0.002407028339803219, 0.01251999195665121, 0.014216268435120583, 0.03766552731394768, -0.045383717864751816, -0.05239556357264519, -0.03697611764073372, 0.03430896997451782, -0.021039089187979698, -0.005691507365554571, 0.011748379096388817, -0.006863846909254789, 0.012664944864809513, -0.007563925813883543, 0.019317328929901123, 0.023664012551307678, -0.01440359279513359, 0.007129130885004997, -0.004703078884631395, -0.022709639742970467, 0.009491094388067722, -0.024048903957009315, 0.008069057948887348, 0.014012869447469711, -0.011933095753192902, -0.011192076839506626, -0.01567184180021286, 0.04221701622009277, 0.017652327194809914, -0.00020969535398762673, 0.007624983321875334, -0.0026370463892817497, -0.0074195945635437965, 0.020379628986120224, -0.013113582506775856, 0.00397289777174592, 0.04206430912017822, -0.004720322322100401, -0.0359855554997921, -0.04960298165678978, -0.012328044511377811, 0.029806893318891525, -0.04581977054476738, -0.062240809202194214, -0.03516174107789993, -0.006645545829087496, 0.015331731177866459, 0.025885848328471184, 0.013979047536849976, 0.03272382542490959, 0.028218843042850494, 0.07863333076238632, 0.01496982853859663, -0.029685862362384796, -0.026897812262177467, 0.026375463232398033, -0.01888948120176792, -0.009577441960573196, -0.003650197060778737, 0.07190022617578506, 0.006288176402449608, -0.011216038838028908, -0.023010507225990295, 0.003497079713270068, -0.006467216182500124, 0.03062671795487404, 0.05526942387223244, -0.05789416283369064, -0.010116593912243843, 0.0077525037340819836, -0.011218447238206863, -0.025032751262187958, 0.021024048328399658, -0.028572972863912582, -0.06012019142508507, -0.02770298346877098, -0.0441533625125885, -0.036108002066612244, 0.014804890379309654, 0.0023747736122459173, -0.014236262999475002, -0.02737104333937168, 0.002171176252886653, -0.002845000708475709, -0.02104252204298973, -0.027442729100584984, -0.015692051500082016, -0.005560384131968021, 0.014121629297733307, -0.03673546761274338, 0.030492132529616356, 0.006349022034555674, -0.00989650096744299, -0.0013059170451015234, -0.027341129258275032, 0.02216147817671299, 0.04346581548452377, 0.036019496619701385, 0.02397114410996437, -0.004253816325217485, -0.01692955195903778, -0.007722788490355015, -0.05284658446907997, 0.008376885205507278, 0.021876536309719086, 0.04210421070456505, -0.011527888476848602, 0.038143813610076904, -0.007774777244776487, 0.053539812564849854, -0.02290266752243042, -0.0007582121761515737, -0.015391563065350056, -0.03907036781311035, 0.021914245560765266, -0.02556208148598671, -0.008342673070728779, 0.013735455460846424, -0.01402771845459938, 0.03939996287226677, 0.011878748424351215, -0.008243638090789318, -0.009073065593838692, 0.013053487055003643, -0.0444805771112442, -0.008359950967133045, 0.02205622009932995, 0.003650799859315157, 0.018043646588921547, 0.008778299205005169, 0.01273706741631031, 0.032734956592321396, -0.021207118406891823, 0.03562743961811066, -0.07604994624853134, 0.003072582883760333, -0.004818937741219997, 0.015435157343745232, 0.04251520335674286, -0.028029868379235268, 0.03267144411802292, 0.01927792653441429, -0.01936131902039051, 0.0121489018201828, 0.01637476123869419, 0.019336095079779625, -0.035656750202178955, 0.024009862914681435, -0.0431111715734005, 0.008309358730912209, 0.03796431049704552, -0.021128030493855476, 0.06072450429201126, 0.021909095346927643, 0.02210884913802147, -0.0039679622277617455, -0.021278701722621918, -0.040977951139211655, 0.009682901203632355, -0.054465390741825104, 0.025551943108439445, -0.03084716759622097, 0.024730537086725235, -0.0014248017687350512, -0.039417192339897156, 0.04650500416755676, 0.03097439743578434, 0.015016194432973862, 0.0005979671259410679, 0.052215512841939926, 0.013149251230061054, 0.03492040932178497, -0.0133868008852005, -0.02444998174905777, 0.00942799262702465, 0.0003749313182197511, -0.016222544014453888, 0.029788566753268242, -0.015313109382987022, 0.00746498629450798, -0.0444859154522419, -0.002440966432914138, -0.013028169050812721, 0.0020735717844218016, -0.011830229312181473, -0.008587466552853584, 0.009732386097311974, -0.012961644679307938, 0.01876138150691986, -0.032055847346782684, 0.0002922849671449512, 0.05103887617588043, 0.08021518588066101, -0.028885221108794212, 0.0184768233448267, -0.039221856743097305, -0.050895724445581436, -0.010939894244074821, 0.02396148443222046, -0.019650153815746307, -0.01470869965851307, -0.02212967351078987, 0.007536476012319326, -0.008068612776696682, -0.027470551431179047, 0.050375573337078094, -0.025822414085268974, 0.03315543383359909, -0.005509806796908379, -0.000025258370442315936, 0.001058440189808607, -0.000021074600226711482, 0.062027331441640854, -0.07009060680866241, 0.04727324843406677, -0.027697980403900146, 0.0007508060079999268, -0.012981059029698372, -0.04540529102087021, -0.038498759269714355, 0.04257247969508171, 0.022879861295223236, -0.0017399373464286327, 0.01805947534739971, -0.0244318675249815, 0.0061342753469944, 0.02674000896513462, -0.06285305321216583, 0.038209233433008194, -0.005033413413912058, 0.02243274636566639, 0.01578797586262226, 0.0033101446460932493, 0.0018540782621130347, 0.020973725244402885, 0.02941465750336647, -0.003955412656068802, 0.0018099662847816944, 0.008526299148797989, -0.03477289155125618, -0.0018887954065576196, -0.008648963645100594, -0.009610036388039589, 0.029654523357748985, -0.028108129277825356, 0.029442133381962776, 0.03234158828854561, -0.029289603233337402, -0.05444648116827011, 0.04138828441500664, -0.008731906302273273, -0.012316497042775154, -0.032539770007133484, -0.052543167024850845, -0.021741773933172226, -0.05302819609642029, 0.011731917969882488, 0.0037573117297142744, -0.02464018203318119, -0.031752850860357285, 0.004668248351663351, 0.004619725979864597, 0.008092132396996021, -0.00016134654288180172, -0.003198523074388504, -0.03036881797015667, -0.0006629058625549078, 0.047030992805957794, 0.0012746708234772086, 0.06540936976671219, -0.011499137617647648, 0.006926216185092926, 0.01962132751941681, -0.043175745755434036, 0.017441343516111374, 0.002943527651950717, 0.05368829146027565, 0.012508717365562916, -0.03601710870862007, 0.04179094731807709, 0.007057064678519964, 0.04117897152900696, 0.002812940627336502, 0.005276528187096119, 0.008799226954579353, -0.009180281311273575, 0.01862933486700058, -0.0211502555757761, 0.010393552482128143, -0.05472905933856964, -0.017046833410859108, -0.019206373021006584, 0.010238016955554485, -0.023215996101498604, 0.012820059433579445, -0.007895219139754772, 0.0017330985283479095, -0.004329781513661146, 0.026636460795998573, 0.026568077504634857, 0.03515824303030968, -0.014141188934445381, -0.002590636257082224, -0.007413540966808796, -0.007635215297341347, -0.057662483304739, 0.011725973337888718, 0.023125475272536278, -0.033704373985528946, -0.02469687908887863, -0.0017383780796080828, 0.030653754249215126, 0.05679889768362045, -0.06068713963031769, -0.03997064009308815, -0.0016026257071644068, -0.01739870198071003, -0.02099907211959362, 0.021443849429488182 ]
<p>I have a Poisson regression where I regress a counts variable (called $H(x)$) on one covariate (called $x$) and one factor (categorical) variable (called $s$), which can take one of three values recoded to integers 1 through 3. I am including an offset variable called $P(x)$ and an intercept called $B_0$. I am trying to write the regression equation. </p> <p>I believe I have correctly expressed the dependent, offset, intercept, and $B_1$ terms, but am not sure about how to express the categorical variable (the $s$) term. Since it's a categorical variable that takes an integer value in the range 1 through 3, I would like to know if can I write it like this (in bold below):</p> <p>$$\log H(x) = \log P(x) + B0 + B1 \cdot x + B2\cdot s$$</p> <p>or if instead I should express each possible value in the equation (since the regression results give one beta parameter estimate for each of the three values) like this:</p> <p>$$\log H(x) = \log P(x) + B0 + B1 \cdot x + B2 \cdot 1 + B3 \cdot 2 + B4 \cdot 3$$ </p> <p>The value for this categorical factor coded as "3" is the reference variable and so the parameter estimate is set by the regression procedure in SPSS to 0.</p>
73,947
[ -0.037952031940221786, -0.009032351896166801, 0.011408094316720963, 0.04037405923008919, 0.0041093784384429455, 0.009718385525047779, 0.014976190403103828, 0.020167576149106026, 0.039186008274555206, -0.029106391593813896, 0.03818254917860031, 0.05294329300522804, 0.04506799578666687, 0.0033680787310004234, 0.05443957448005676, 0.003465894144028425, -0.008782342076301575, 0.04341293126344681, -0.02385067567229271, 0.009081698954105377, -0.0011414500186219811, 0.028229165822267532, 0.006289682351052761, 0.027671493589878082, 0.031596001237630844, 0.05546766519546509, 0.0403754785656929, -0.018501468002796173, 0.005897450726479292, 0.005020557902753353, -0.0126589210703969, -0.007781622931361198, 0.007146710064262152, 0.02435821108520031, 0.012787210755050182, 0.010406914167106152, -0.023368755355477333, -0.03906311094760895, -0.009974769316613674, 0.008527114056050777, -0.02736124023795128, 0.03244185075163841, 0.02387421764433384, 0.016586635261774063, -0.014762694016098976, -0.003587879706174135, -0.013184593990445137, -0.01087338849902153, -0.006308006588369608, -0.026130249723792076, 0.07587732374668121, -0.006496167276054621, 0.05395655333995819, 0.051231663674116135, -0.035167962312698364, -0.014637673273682594, 0.03570947423577309, 0.07190816849470139, 0.006002598907798529, -0.0260726697742939, -0.010599568486213684, -0.03775477781891823, 0.025274649262428284, -0.03984644636511803, -0.021122241392731667, -0.0035018424969166517, 0.006711382418870926, -0.025035163387656212, 0.05966218560934067, -0.025176312774419785, 0.04251823574304581, -0.00616904953494668, 0.06287350505590439, -0.014538338407874107, 0.027866750955581665, -0.04626374691724777, -0.0007287191692739725, 0.01845361478626728, 0.047357022762298584, 0.017515379935503006, -0.0017744640354067087, 0.007839095778763294, 0.002549618948251009, 0.030284199863672256, 0.0012771391775459051, -0.009438849054276943, 0.04521545395255089, -0.024824701249599457, 0.02485133334994316, 0.022979550063610077, -0.0074031176045536995, 0.024114910513162613, 0.05039209499955177, 0.003920932300388813, -0.0031551264692097902, 0.04038402438163757, -0.004227892961353064, 0.026972515508532524, 0.002381469588726759, 0.05586845055222511, 0.011833230964839458, -0.05569492653012276, 0.006216052453964949, 0.0489860363304615, -0.017710022628307343, 0.03092813305556774, -0.02261267602443695, -0.010478328913450241, -0.006030098535120487, -0.0680914893746376, 0.0008692324627190828, 0.005225290544331074, 0.007874731905758381, -0.008589733392000198, -0.0069434260949492455, -0.05453592538833618, -0.009864465333521366, -0.024397704750299454, 0.04039406776428223, 0.02963588759303093, -0.011969253420829773, -0.013069069012999535, 0.026205573230981827, 0.02803497575223446, -0.03508821502327919, 0.02839810773730278, 0.006012897938489914, 0.002001892076805234, -0.05439013987779617, 0.0570773184299469, 0.018395965918898582, -0.037133000791072845, 0.058952197432518005, 0.02698361501097679, 0.0023920671083033085, -0.008417457342147827, -0.06767763942480087, -0.03472878783941269, -0.007783995009958744, 0.013271265663206577, 0.018087273463606834, -0.04686413332819939, 0.00212382385507226, 0.06762687861919403, 0.05926884710788727, 0.010076712816953659, 0.00611232640221715, 0.022755799815058708, 0.02762167900800705, 0.02082853950560093, -0.011477552354335785, -0.008647903800010681, -0.06279801577329636, -0.04244377836585045, -0.04523502662777901, -0.03779124468564987, 0.02757011353969574, 0.024027979001402855, -0.014608056284487247, 0.0032970868051052094, 0.07549042999744415, 0.005611589178442955, -0.011468570679426193, 0.025555020198225975, -0.02430662140250206, -0.005518907215446234, 0.03190593793988228, -0.016069388017058372, 0.033027589321136475, 0.019602036103606224, 0.022289564833045006, 0.0063524432480335236, -0.026067424565553665, 0.06732851266860962, 0.042902398854494095, -0.02219870314002037, -0.007850753143429756, -0.019557179883122444, 0.0026174343656748533, 0.02675042487680912, -0.059114720672369, -0.03180360049009323, -0.008804425597190857, 0.011123714968562126, 0.018651016056537628, 0.012978639453649521, 0.007952139712870121, -0.009503140114247799, 0.05632847175002098, -0.013875092379748821, -0.0661887526512146, -0.0718003585934639, 0.0066045476123690605, -0.0016580321826040745, 0.014464913867413998, 0.04232947900891304, -0.007970045320689678, -0.012890768237411976, 0.02063284069299698, -0.0029699455481022596, 0.01250857301056385, 0.0042641907930374146, 0.05308235064148903, -0.028828756883740425, 0.0006553155253641307, 0.05944913998246193, 0.0326734222471714, -0.0039017663802951574, 0.04129882529377937, -0.01938813552260399, 0.005118170753121376, 0.027048440650105476, -0.02838614024221897, 0.024211443960666656, -0.003997663035988808, 0.008974737487733364, 0.03428628668189049, 0.000012893149687442929, -0.004432438872754574, 0.019364066421985626, -0.059329546988010406, 0.03494982048869133, 0.0756293386220932, 0.06182410195469856, 0.0024345044512301683, -0.00961589440703392, -0.019723592326045036, 0.01585126668214798, -0.02795805223286152, -0.03492350876331329, -0.030793743208050728, 0.009009292349219322, 0.019947843626141548, 0.004712101072072983, -0.008190426975488663, -0.024686506018042564, 0.02942414954304695, 0.004892939701676369, 0.014077380299568176, 0.033932823687791824, -0.0020043791737407446, 0.032809093594551086, 0.013056965544819832, -0.015470395796000957, 0.014745574444532394, 0.018069257959723473, 0.029683377593755722, 0.012457288801670074, 0.0744071751832962, -0.012167057022452354, 0.01284556183964014, 0.024769887328147888, -0.0006778017268516123, 0.009742599911987782, -0.03245089575648308, -0.0019233704078942537, 0.049130797386169434, -0.033172912895679474, 0.023532109335064888, 0.03951943665742874, 0.021384619176387787, -0.020313061773777008, 0.021195461973547935, 0.004928752314299345, -0.008520049974322319, 0.06215040385723114, -0.024127617478370667, -0.01778697781264782, 0.010318909771740437, -0.0517696738243103, 0.024089176207780838, -0.038073886185884476, -0.019818205386400223, -0.04889986291527748, 0.0015471238875761628, 0.005527290049940348, 0.011947260238230228, 0.0038681537844240665, -0.009144616313278675, -0.05214032530784607, -0.028891179710626602, -0.0037501465994864702, 0.07215835154056549, -0.007233751472085714, -0.06774631887674332, -0.038240570574998856, -0.031262416392564774, -0.022304775193333626, 0.003055546898394823, -0.012918684631586075, -0.03968893364071846, 0.007018519099801779, -0.05926886945962906, -0.07342727482318878, -0.02728760987520218, -0.02250324934720993, 0.009160738438367844, -0.03303511068224907, -0.026859089732170105, 0.048554010689258575, 0.0357644222676754, -0.023100098595023155, -0.01293847244232893, -0.04148215055465698, -0.05006687343120575, -0.03037058375775814, -0.013344748876988888, -0.0018993985140696168, 0.005067839752882719, 0.042798712849617004, 0.021277736872434616, -0.0011475778883323073, -0.009144538082182407, -0.09563492983579636, -0.07148664444684982, -0.01580655388534069, 0.010695491917431355, 0.04816572740674019, -0.027708157896995544, 0.01949109137058258, 0.09959620982408524, 0.03135604038834572, 0.019082220271229744, -0.03176802769303322, 0.0059064882807433605, -0.021420108154416084, -0.05845622718334198, 0.03643927350640297, 0.0034076739102602005, 0.0419783741235733, 0.009444081224501133, -0.05570726469159126, 0.03687254711985588, 0.011087564751505852, 0.016817014664411545, -0.02047966606914997, 0.016556618735194206, -0.002653378527611494, -0.0005169091746211052, 0.0404888279736042, 0.04114867374300957, 0.009659522213041782, 0.032500747591257095, -0.005558964796364307, 0.014217118732631207, 0.01377541571855545, -0.060432400554418564, 0.0210075955837965, 0.009880001656711102, -0.0026092168409377337, -0.004365655593574047, 0.050942420959472656, 0.05107688903808594, -0.06276325136423111, -0.01570800505578518, 0.031117910519242287, 0.019217632710933685, -0.047611888498067856, -0.017583748325705528, 0.045207004994153976, 0.0352802537381649, -0.006951641757041216, -0.03695017471909523, -0.023111026734113693, -0.02363250032067299, 0.015412211418151855, -0.00996930617839098, -0.013117492198944092, 0.024532359093427658, 0.03489113599061966, 0.03375868499279022, -0.008712159469723701, -0.04741254448890686, -0.0036362232640385628, -0.06785956770181656, -0.0427035428583622, 0.021587712690234184, 0.03553706780076027, 0.0003530074027366936, 0.02871040441095829, 0.012471482157707214, -0.029770154505968094, 0.03982772305607796, 0.03913336619734764, -0.034376490861177444, 0.008396109566092491, -0.002199445152655244, 0.006076483521610498, 0.017280220985412598, -0.006795706693083048, 0.03655128553509712, -0.04695192351937294, -0.015589932911098003, 0.013887799344956875, -0.0025616935454308987, 0.011188169941306114, 0.007413723971694708, 0.0008045285358093679, -0.012464819476008415, 0.02434893138706684, 0.010772104375064373, 0.0024556254502385855, -0.021857665851712227, 0.004962793085724115, 0.04474325478076935, -0.005638745613396168, 0.004009319469332695, -0.06739695370197296, 0.0026931134052574635, 0.0011543706059455872, 0.06849327683448792, 0.020950451493263245, 0.015696825459599495, 0.01406156551092863, 0.0248921699821949, -0.017323682084679604, 0.021138150244951248, 0.04477913677692413, 0.022023459896445274, -0.007156024686992168, -0.026760531589388847, 0.002165405312553048, -0.019580654799938202, 0.03397448733448982, -0.003453507786616683, 0.024225806817412376, 0.08894563466310501, 0.046144455671310425, -0.048350024968385696, 0.04899228364229202, 0.048364587128162384, 0.028245627880096436, -0.016545133665204048, -0.02736903727054596, 0.036364972591400146, -0.026889711618423462, 0.017444012686610222, -0.024967866018414497, -0.010141081176698208, -0.024658283218741417, -0.0006165012018755078, 0.02966894954442978, 0.009069519117474556, -0.007356397341936827, 0.03547120839357376, 0.023652106523513794, 0.03839690610766411, 0.015238096937537193, -0.04579164832830429, 0.010629372671246529, 0.03970097005367279, -0.011728408746421337, -0.0007793636759743094, -0.01825072430074215, -0.08653757721185684, 0.00558773847296834, 0.006311394274234772, 0.03169933706521988, -0.04911202937364578, -0.024256370961666107, -0.02934878133237362, 0.0016849742969498038, 0.010929414071142673, -0.035309042781591415, -0.003982490859925747, -0.037419643253088, 0.037170976400375366, 0.01989794708788395, -0.025088826194405556, -0.06479620188474655, 0.029649930074810982, -0.006054264027625322, 0.020522482693195343, -0.003934097476303577, 0.01019559521228075, -0.019723007455468178, 0.012828872539103031, 0.004550488665699959, 0.05860922485589981, -0.028583241626620293, -0.02061307616531849, 0.013870607130229473, 0.02264244295656681, -0.01564639061689377, -0.08831187337636948, 0.014068146236240864, 0.029230624437332153, 0.016162311658263206, 0.03345433250069618, -0.012332441285252571, -0.03319818526506424, -0.0007694700034335256, 0.009089089930057526, 0.009249894879758358, -0.007247373461723328, -0.031140342354774475, 0.05184541270136833, 0.019995488226413727, -0.014377366751432419, 0.09985815733671188, 0.07089976966381073, 0.00392164196819067, 0.021952597424387932, -0.03464218229055405, -0.005278029013425112, 0.017924638465046883, -0.007612229790538549, -0.05936677008867264, 0.045665450394153595, 0.007355893030762672, 0.014123504050076008, -0.0016515827737748623, 0.01914343237876892, -0.03087581694126129, -0.03413659706711769, -0.0003469236253295094, 0.02462867833673954, -0.003313851309940219, 0.017763711512088776, -0.004113273695111275, 0.009805538691580296, -0.005073264241218567, -0.04924826696515083, 0.0071603539399802685, -0.049549367278814316, 0.009956968948245049, 0.0002725883387029171, -0.01472258660942316, 0.0024227111134678125, -0.0182632002979517, -0.018206238746643066, -0.005938269663602114, -0.06924028694629669, -0.0016737050609663129, -0.019335180521011353, 0.02553289383649826, -0.01829378865659237, -0.017614353448152542, -0.017450163140892982, -0.011260190978646278, 0.017921483144164085, 0.012682310305535793, -0.06526967138051987, 0.00959089770913124, -0.011174308136105537, -0.022854596376419067, -0.07355675101280212, -0.06938672065734863, 0.017506776377558708, -0.0038921816740185022, -0.028868822380900383, -0.010535364039242268, -0.02914188615977764, -0.013999266549944878, -0.05080143362283707, 0.0021867319010198116, 0.018226899206638336, -0.032345835119485855, -0.017755648121237755, -0.005801577121019363, 0.040317047387361526, 0.04819861799478531, 0.021545423194766045, -0.00033184580388478935, -0.010215976275503635, 0.012927556410431862, 0.0003482069878373295, 0.016322243958711624, -0.0244055837392807, 0.004992783535271883, -0.04088757932186127, -0.024477628991007805, -0.011308299377560616, -0.01870831474661827, -0.014466634951531887, -0.03655692934989929, 0.00029771338449791074, 0.0010353414108976722, 0.017734955996274948, -0.010869151912629604, 0.0009822777938097715, 0.005739039741456509, 0.0009806454181671143, -0.016504019498825073, 0.008128991350531578, -0.020078038796782494, 0.016725018620491028, 0.02675580605864525, 0.020847829058766365, -0.0322541780769825, -0.0012406917521730065, 0.07609038054943085, 0.04645238444209099, 0.0388626866042614, 0.01366521418094635, 0.011781311593949795, 0.07513920962810516, 0.014710831455886364, -0.007843054831027985, -0.000318259175401181, 0.03000710718333721, -0.022145623341202736, -0.0062471539713442326, -0.05216558650135994, 0.007994987070560455, 0.043504927307367325, -0.047373250126838684, 0.01075481716543436, 0.0016901857452467084, -0.01920066773891449, 0.013404354453086853, -0.023416586220264435, -0.013978282921016216, -0.0003707124851644039, 0.004275317769497633, 0.046730536967515945, -0.0035672958474606276, -0.013452786020934582, 0.0032901072409003973, 0.029077431187033653, -0.013477275148034096, 0.04777970165014267, -0.0150552773848176, -0.015431828796863556, -0.010117336176335812, -0.038388121873140335, -0.04401670768857002, 0.01564278081059456, -0.013995708897709846, 0.0004677476827055216, -0.04019129276275635, -0.09788264334201813, 0.0513477623462677, -0.01056960504502058, 0.022380750626325607, -0.08250304311513901, -0.05032125487923622, -0.061141084879636765, 0.008199376054108143, 0.0007691956707276404, 0.012145230546593666, 0.027076220139861107, -0.01898687332868576, 0.011044619604945183, 0.01712184026837349, 0.016528360545635223, -0.05487954616546631, -0.0725785419344902, -0.02524334006011486, -0.017728429287672043, -0.020726753398776054, 0.03540721535682678, -0.016872432082891464, -0.01572052203118801, 0.021004708483815193, -0.044082898646593094, 0.03898932784795761, 0.02415645681321621, 0.04056210070848465, 0.017502283677458763, 0.06371508538722992, 0.00786768738180399, -0.039227500557899475, -0.0046658762730658054, -0.0071561019867658615, 0.11959218978881836, 0.08625126630067825, 0.053936850279569626, -0.09854395687580109, -0.010928064584732056, -0.021041927859187126, 0.008732023648917675, -0.026253793388605118, 0.008868241682648659, -0.0029739970341324806, -0.005433638114482164, 0.022038184106349945, 0.07156702876091003, 0.013247072696685791, 0.008310507982969284, 0.032500192523002625, 0.000459949515061453, 0.0044058533385396, 0.010908304713666439, 0.0036933445371687412, 0.008058164268732071, -0.005954524502158165, -0.019837668165564537, -0.013221669010818005, 0.019625626504421234, -0.026673004031181335, -0.020566482096910477, -0.003929526079446077, -0.022999471053481102, 0.01956002600491047, -0.030176905915141106, 0.015214868821203709, 0.018251143395900726, -0.0027493129018694162, -0.004947436973452568, -0.01528154592961073, 0.00931488536298275, -0.03494025766849518, 0.041367143392562866, 0.010693207383155823, -0.032799117267131805, 0.013805181719362736, 0.036037955433130264, -0.023473018780350685, -0.041288506239652634, -0.03566396236419678, -0.016760673373937607, 0.037148814648389816, -0.020062444731593132, -0.03945372998714447, -0.02164369449019432, 0.01375686563551426, 0.00964086689054966, -0.0507020577788353, -0.002615142846480012, 0.011079125106334686, 0.019690385088324547, -0.04268624633550644, -0.03452472761273384, 0.00037645187694579363, -0.005201729480177164, -0.010347104631364346, 0.019474990665912628, 0.013263165019452572, -0.05047047138214111, 0.028919991105794907, -0.024967530742287636, 0.027446463704109192, 0.0013415574794635177, -0.018999792635440826, 0.016877437010407448, 0.01678132824599743, -0.04345555976033211, -0.028846971690654755, 0.026561152189970016, 0.014993197284638882, -0.007083801086992025, -0.014408436603844166, 0.0036083837039768696, -0.029148396104574203, -0.02182478830218315, 0.031407780945301056, -0.014700775034725666, 0.01943233795464039, -0.059157274663448334, -0.0028982069343328476, 0.032638922333717346, 0.0672551617026329, -0.013408377766609192, 0.014922704547643661, -0.0008518882095813751, 0.06045025587081909, 0.01068210881203413, -0.0763666182756424, -0.02517702430486679, 0.0679951086640358, -0.059328027069568634, -0.01624930091202259, -0.0019133153837174177, 0.04354695603251457, 0.005609624087810516, 0.03902773559093475, -0.02790078893303871, 0.02542940154671669, 0.020874859765172005, 0.013066739775240421, -0.005240746773779392, -0.010355984792113304, 0.01448439434170723, 0.04796561598777771, 0.020014731213450432, -0.0037731241900473833, -0.04245655983686447, -0.06240283325314522, -0.0038311597891151905, -0.014092506840825081, -0.025135302916169167, -0.06124653294682503, 0.032773494720458984, -0.020475119352340698, -0.007039083167910576, 0.005707571282982826, 0.04672718048095703, -0.028387989848852158, 0.011934256181120872, 0.022378848865628242, -0.02809712663292885, 0.011227106675505638, 0.013682594522833824, -0.028591947630047798, 0.013484089635312557, 0.04970250651240349, 0.019935181364417076, 0.04437125474214554, 0.008154458366334438, 0.007909001782536507, -0.020172683522105217, 0.037730369716882706, -0.03446977585554123, -0.008895638398826122, 0.0031404667533934116, -0.022904517129063606, -0.010024948045611382, 0.013354535214602947, 0.0012222618097439408, 0.03575766831636429, 0.047458913177251816, 0.029374340549111366, -0.03519059717655182, 0.043037351220846176, -0.017742356285452843, 0.006467718165367842, 0.003842428093776107, -0.012794872745871544, -0.01150666456669569, 0.0003689953591674566, -0.0036973576061427593, 0.036606315523386, -0.01554372999817133, 0.006687618792057037, 0.0393330343067646, -0.015330621972680092, 0.028414905071258545, -0.015462087467312813, -0.004084540531039238, -0.007453954312950373, -0.009259561076760292, -0.02551444247364998, 0.011533965356647968, 0.05182603374123573, -0.01819438859820366, 0.0429968386888504, 0.02352503314614296, 0.04797230288386345, -0.08726143091917038, -0.02479620836675167, 0.014377351850271225, 0.030355477705597878, 0.0227778572589159, -0.014713472686707973, 0.020186830312013626, -0.01645435206592083, 0.0004283673770260066, -0.0031626035925000906, -0.007547327317297459, -0.012054198421537876, -0.013742122799158096, 0.002067595487460494, 0.02286580763757229, -0.0032338344026356936, 0.05311970040202141, 0.002650798996910453, 0.0013187055010348558, 0.035372499376535416, -0.0001485065877204761, -0.05329715833067894, 0.00894740130752325, -0.014201498590409756, 0.022031884640455246, -0.0824873074889183, 0.03845598176121712, -0.0513351708650589, -0.036855217069387436, 0.038256920874118805, 0.016502685844898224, -0.014160907827317715, 0.05215006321668625, 0.02901754155755043, -0.019339406862854958, 0.07202386856079102, 0.04174511879682541, -0.010979412123560905, -0.0214876476675272, 0.019023114815354347, -0.009010898880660534, 0.03095891699194908, -0.018179956823587418, -0.004991683177649975, 0.013413731940090656, -0.020627804100513458, -0.0777970626950264, -0.0008854246116243303, 0.010013156570494175, -0.003878540825098753, -0.028706079348921776, -0.01419396884739399, 0.024618597701191902, -0.014777613803744316, 0.010584838688373566, -0.08271443098783493, 0.009640042670071125, 0.031571321189403534, -0.031425267457962036, -0.05079907178878784, -0.004255296662449837, -0.0353451706469059, -0.030269401147961617, -0.013067532330751419, -0.004641981795430183, -0.014691309072077274, -0.057440392673015594, -0.010067817755043507, 0.006266871001571417, -0.011281503364443779, -0.04837581142783165, 0.01586662419140339, -0.011392047628760338, 0.06527556478977203, -0.025791456922888756, -0.004111704416573048, 0.026888975873589516, -0.024964893236756325, 0.013440774753689766, -0.04308510571718216, 0.04033620283007622, 0.04331251606345177, 0.0029363043140619993, -0.03701651468873024, -0.004342669155448675, -0.05937587097287178, 0.03199634328484535, 0.03659505024552345, -0.024490604177117348, -0.016802646219730377, -0.008240221068263054, 0.09374783933162689, 0.015501773916184902, -0.0033594740089029074, 0.012148497626185417, 0.04769114777445793, -0.03145759925246239, -0.04603046178817749, 0.0018594535067677498, -0.03752082213759422, -0.0021293871104717255, 0.0081730205565691, -0.0022363292519003153, 0.019115660339593887, -0.009831029921770096, -0.05707075446844101, -0.01746324822306633, 0.020664632320404053, -0.025382332503795624, 0.06197156757116318, 0.012560627423226833, -0.008941777981817722, 0.0464789979159832, 0.010984472930431366, -0.04641169682145119, 0.015183506533503532, -0.016595546156167984, -0.03841699659824371, -0.013646125793457031, 0.014238452538847923, 0.011962266638875008, -0.03209853172302246, 0.04047846794128418, -0.014212774112820625, -0.017230557277798653, -0.01001665461808443, 0.014480766840279102, 0.016893431544303894, 0.06194305419921875, -0.018185114488005638, -0.02872449718415737, 0.04169587790966034, -0.03257633000612259, 0.05262678861618042, 0.0192013718187809, 0.020908912643790245, -0.010389456525444984, 0.012281733565032482, 0.012900257483124733, 0.014286682941019535, 0.011948916129767895, 0.03119216486811638, 0.000969530432485044, -0.004381704609841108, 0.0032536466605961323, 0.03444243222475052, 0.00004593457924784161, 0.036806218326091766, -0.010696160607039928, -0.005952479783445597, 0.04897184297442436, -0.016897084191441536, 0.018587935715913773, -0.037272073328495026, 0.028633613139390945, -0.00601724348962307, 0.005466114263981581, -0.009811099618673325, 0.02468731440603733, -0.03246122971177101, -0.030612817034125328, 0.0075376988388597965, -0.01863580197095871, 0.0005345714162103832, -0.047575101256370544, -0.031064551323652267, -0.007862397469580173, -0.02138940431177616, -0.023232830688357353, -0.05943544954061508, -0.013691757805645466, 0.012730594724416733, 0.035040922462940216, 0.007670527324080467, -0.00972880981862545, -0.04343360662460327, -0.01854953169822693, -0.019733620807528496, 0.051306597888469696, -0.056357160210609436, -0.03711386397480965, -0.024100959300994873, -0.00891201663762331, 0.005330885760486126, -0.033093053847551346 ]
<p>I'm using R to calculate the median absolute deviation for a few distributions, but some of the values I'm calculating do not seem realistic at all. I have the following distribution:</p> <pre><code>x &lt;- [1] NA NA NA -0.003 -0.009 0.004 -0.001 -0.001 -0.003 0.001 -0.002 0.000 -0.003 0.000 0.006 -0.011 -0.003 [18] 0.002 -0.007 -0.002 0.006 -0.005 0.000 0.008 0.001 0.009 -0.002 0.001 0.001 0.002 0.003 NA NA 0.001 [35] NA 0.005 -0.002 0.003 0.016 0.007 -0.003 -0.017 0.000 -0.013 0.000 0.002 0.002 0.000 NA 0.000 0.000 [52] 0.000 0.000 0.004 -0.001 0.000 -0.002 -0.003 -0.007 -0.001 -0.001 0.000 -0.002 0.001 0.003 0.000 -0.011 -0.002 [69] -0.003 0.004 -0.007 NA -0.009 0.005 -0.001 0.001 -0.001 0.001 -0.001 0.006 0.002 -0.006 0.002 -0.002 0.004 [86] 0.006 0.001 0.000 0.002 -0.002 0.007 0.004 0.003 0.004 0.005 -0.005 0.003 -0.003 0.002 0.004 0.003 -0.002 [103] -0.002 0.001 0.002 0.000 0.000 0.003 -0.001 0.004 0.001 0.001 0.005 -0.001 NA -0.005 0.000 -0.002 -0.004 [120] 0.004 NA 0.007 0.000 0.002 0.003 -0.006 -0.002 0.000 -0.002 -0.001 -0.001 -0.001 -0.006 -0.001 -0.001 -0.008 [137] 0.000 0.003 0.001 0.001 -0.001 0.000 0.011 -0.017 NA NA NA </code></pre> <p>Then I used the following code to generate my MAD value:</p> <pre><code>MADx &lt;- mad(x, center = median(x, na.rm = TRUE), constant = (1/(quantile(x, probs=0.75, na.rm = TRUE, names = FALSE, type = 1))), na.rm = TRUE, low = FALSE, high = FALSE) </code></pre> <p>I get a value of 1 when doing this, which seems unrealistic because the values I have are much less than 1.</p> <p>I used the quantile function to get the 75th quantile of the distribution.</p>
114
[ -0.02881116420030594, 0.02047036960721016, -0.0071183377876877785, -0.04308002442121506, 0.02044752612709999, 0.03431427851319313, -0.008616515435278416, -0.024918412789702415, 0.012868212535977364, -0.040763553231954575, 0.0286669060587883, 0.07044287770986557, 0.02027755044400692, 0.016296541318297386, 0.03391178324818611, -0.007276778109371662, -0.03669031336903572, -0.00037272111512720585, 0.02056903950870037, -0.02979213185608387, 0.022219616919755936, -0.013489444740116596, 0.0239231176674366, -0.02471034601330757, -0.029359281063079834, 0.036331504583358765, 0.028400298207998276, -0.011569075286388397, 0.012189985252916813, 0.06768213212490082, -0.049614883959293365, -0.01869356632232666, 0.020431511104106903, -0.0017305940855294466, 0.008504029363393784, 0.016479426994919777, 0.017640430480241776, -0.006510498002171516, -0.04748982936143875, 0.0672280490398407, -0.04057445377111435, -0.012158484198153019, -0.014039355330169201, -0.005660178605467081, -0.011926021426916122, -0.006103899795562029, 0.005909549538046122, -0.009440108202397823, 0.04072292149066925, 0.0020140742417424917, 0.0698951780796051, 0.0016234390204772353, 0.04023832082748413, 0.019993651658296585, -0.03657088428735733, -0.015485559590160847, 0.03711174428462982, 0.0805414542555809, 0.0015693355817347765, -0.05862335115671158, 0.032267581671476364, -0.052452452480793, -0.017126118764281273, -0.033637579530477524, 0.007701677270233631, -0.004185961559414864, -0.008312899619340897, -0.032659854739904404, 0.024081440642476082, -0.012266113422811031, 0.03848263621330261, -0.001576828071847558, -0.022078845649957657, -0.02958490699529648, 0.004195933695882559, 0.0012307495344430208, 0.02991117350757122, -0.006254010368138552, 0.041771549731492996, 0.022596335038542747, 0.003955076448619366, 0.03191237524151802, 0.01710345409810543, 0.04352102428674698, 0.01820109225809574, -0.03575024753808975, 0.10566753894090652, -0.028446542099118233, -0.0037388750351965427, 0.007458439562469721, -0.006386753637343645, 0.011490997858345509, 0.0682038813829422, 0.018589114770293236, -0.012003890238702297, 0.03942234814167023, 0.012978003360331059, 0.037191275507211685, -0.0159126166254282, -0.02303360216319561, 0.00227746763266623, -0.032004464417696, 0.0002433624758850783, 0.021227354183793068, -0.02677081897854805, -0.041904520243406296, -0.03992971032857895, -0.0041466630063951015, -0.0131234647706151, -0.028478367254137993, -0.00457393191754818, 0.05417168140411377, -0.021424653008580208, -0.024606231600046158, 0.03356160968542099, -0.0671631246805191, 0.005442850757390261, -0.03841567784547806, 0.01068240124732256, 0.036469947546720505, 0.034779373556375504, -0.012995188124477863, 0.02560701221227646, 0.004326818510890007, -0.04882213845849037, -0.0045963856391608715, 0.002175198867917061, 0.03312482312321663, -0.005463554058223963, 0.018401389941573143, -0.018326610326766968, -0.027675094082951546, 0.10665540397167206, -0.008221760392189026, 0.024270888417959213, -0.010894477367401123, -0.07134345918893814, -0.03192603588104248, 0.03478934243321419, -0.03511885553598404, 0.0018137604929506779, -0.06547880172729492, -0.0072390069253742695, 0.0222524031996727, 0.007046785671263933, 0.03331167995929718, 0.028458865359425545, 0.010656308382749557, -0.01198561955243349, 0.009239044040441513, -0.029752938076853752, -0.010236062109470367, -0.010623308829963207, -0.006538780871778727, 0.008966585621237755, -0.04533329978585243, -0.003066495293751359, -0.002261038403958082, -0.030985167250037193, 0.003673842642456293, -0.006755416747182608, 0.010847494006156921, -0.0012469090288504958, -0.02984163537621498, -0.0036246497184038162, -0.007197586819529533, 0.06753279268741608, -0.009943665005266666, -0.010176263749599457, 0.015530803240835667, -0.034062206745147705, 0.01119094155728817, -0.012418849393725395, 0.033352822065353394, 0.051988791674375534, -0.004732734989374876, 0.046262819319963455, -0.04634293541312218, 0.02215576171875, 0.051409270614385605, -0.053967852145433426, 0.0046341209672391415, -0.025465117767453194, -0.03548276424407959, 0.048453327268362045, 0.03603047505021095, 0.013432572595775127, -0.03713399916887283, 0.07770641893148422, -0.03491733595728874, -0.018928537145256996, -0.06921993941068649, -0.02362745627760887, 0.014053703285753727, -0.03730035200715065, 0.015308670699596405, 0.02002394013106823, 0.0206803809851408, -0.002787737874314189, -0.013085796497762203, -0.049811430275440216, -0.0010646687587723136, 0.03853479400277138, -0.04005395621061325, 0.028103411197662354, 0.07084107398986816, 0.07301430404186249, -0.030633412301540375, 0.039426691830158234, -0.004237051121890545, -0.02949048951268196, 0.009067018516361713, -0.03788945823907852, -0.004949074704200029, 0.019686609506607056, -0.008112466894090176, -0.014185294508934021, 0.025720342993736267, -0.00973088201135397, 0.018832558766007423, -0.0562732107937336, 0.03609007969498634, 0.04080376401543617, 0.0037769360933452845, 0.014876231551170349, -0.01641380786895752, -0.025689085945487022, 0.008437351323664188, -0.01147544663399458, -0.016406627371907234, -0.027799813076853752, 0.012828562408685684, 0.04966611787676811, 0.046612098813056946, -0.017793750390410423, 0.010846191085875034, 0.0021298802457749844, -0.02799167111515999, 0.060779884457588196, 0.05249698832631111, 0.01922791264951229, -0.04432821646332741, 0.0030487405601888895, -0.016507761552929878, 0.010369653813540936, 0.0031813867390155792, 0.026130761951208115, 0.030431365594267845, 0.0409366749227047, -0.03779977187514305, -0.009553663432598114, 0.02634495124220848, 0.00027866571326740086, -0.0037905164062976837, -0.004041579086333513, 0.011343775317072868, 0.04519101604819298, -0.009601082652807236, -0.007574090268462896, 0.09018988162279129, 0.017269782721996307, 0.021079229190945625, 0.01800977997481823, -0.05844323709607124, 0.006087174639105797, 0.07208511233329773, -0.02165140211582184, 0.006632638163864613, -0.0161055326461792, -0.02683306857943535, 0.022115522995591164, -0.0648321732878685, -0.02782456949353218, -0.03047069162130356, -0.006902571301907301, 0.04380076378583908, 0.046424828469753265, 0.006241180468350649, -0.008360425010323524, -0.01610199734568596, 0.003041893243789673, -0.003826484549790621, 0.014237815514206886, 0.0253836028277874, -0.049916692078113556, -0.011552369222044945, -0.01509228628128767, -0.013021822087466717, 0.025454077869653702, -0.00431582797318697, -0.05080247297883034, 0.03560493141412735, -0.018431002274155617, -0.029578518122434616, 0.004478110000491142, -0.012715230695903301, -0.00545273395255208, -0.030271081253886223, -0.00889593642205, 0.037960320711135864, -0.029566287994384766, -0.05473751202225685, 0.025932809337973595, -0.0518040731549263, -0.0573701411485672, -0.049399249255657196, 0.001812734524719417, 0.002190833445638418, 0.029805539175868034, -0.0032176922541111708, 0.02923058159649372, 0.024349860846996307, 0.006700028199702501, -0.04021729901432991, -0.02462940104305744, 0.0008108252659440041, -0.011789037846028805, 0.0023319402243942022, 0.015513386577367783, -0.0023866964038461447, 0.10904669016599655, 0.019509656354784966, -0.033497050404548645, -0.007984708063304424, -0.00598624162375927, -0.038456134498119354, 0.00720250466838479, 0.02506059594452381, 0.03525650501251221, 0.040121614933013916, 0.012213489972054958, 0.013381837867200375, 0.05700519680976868, -0.0010902207577601075, -0.021486865356564522, 0.016704091802239418, 0.02376309037208557, -0.008467922918498516, -0.020938461646437645, 0.03301520645618439, 0.014901898801326752, 0.008407216519117355, -0.0017461710376664996, 0.024826530367136, 0.025183502584695816, -0.027256043627858162, -0.02283468097448349, 0.011356258764863014, -0.03774004429578781, 0.02928956411778927, -0.035731226205825806, 0.039954833686351776, 0.011815649457275867, -0.0279153510928154, 0.0039043857250362635, -0.03536383435130119, 0.047519829124212265, -0.0499233715236187, 0.03171718493103981, 0.07634445279836655, 0.02624477818608284, -0.02301880717277527, 0.04228004068136215, -0.005579143762588501, -0.03614114597439766, 0.008579406887292862, -0.04832494631409645, -0.015084896236658096, 0.03312011808156967, 0.05320674926042557, 0.03705426678061485, 0.006166025996208191, -0.011421906761825085, 0.02718060091137886, -0.025614431127905846, 0.022245697677135468, -0.04069291800260544, -0.0033147844951599836, -0.0023867993149906397, 0.03522136062383652, 0.004321396816521883, -0.006714766379445791, -0.009106033481657505, -0.028627770021557808, 0.00666830176487565, 0.04989062622189522, -0.037250589579343796, -0.006939759943634272, -0.04760844632983208, -0.047012992203235626, -0.00013728706107940525, -0.05773203447461128, 0.02386900782585144, 0.010999998077750206, 0.027754345908761024, -0.014872908592224121, -0.002610559808090329, 0.02523215115070343, 0.015195479616522789, -0.029442671686410904, 0.00413769856095314, 0.026143910363316536, -0.010648498311638832, 0.042320434004068375, -0.002395221032202244, -0.014357984066009521, 0.004367126617580652, -0.05458643287420273, 0.007811048999428749, 0.03681818023324013, 0.03014780580997467, 0.03227607533335686, -0.005286198575049639, -0.0006541403708979487, 0.0036253086291253567, 0.0015056353295221925, 0.03121737577021122, 0.059865839779376984, -0.029640275985002518, -0.010529869236052036, -0.038795001804828644, -0.016924496740102768, -0.019454816356301308, 0.0005128449411131442, 0.012138147838413715, 0.008456817828118801, 0.0367560014128685, 0.02315591834485531, -0.02293914370238781, 0.028719311580061913, 0.06753946095705032, 0.019648998975753784, 0.02478005178272724, -0.06195085123181343, -0.007208277937024832, -0.02737380564212799, -0.005821174010634422, 0.03337480127811432, -0.012109644711017609, 0.040161047130823135, -0.032049428671598434, 0.032038528472185135, 0.005341402254998684, -0.04188705235719681, -0.024846451357007027, 0.02874043770134449, 0.017200276255607605, 0.004996075294911861, -0.009660034440457821, -0.01433852594345808, 0.03069392964243889, 0.006253500003367662, -0.011014794930815697, 0.02839951403439045, -0.08959593623876572, -0.008599617518484592, 0.05998195335268974, 0.02936633862555027, -0.03425278887152672, -0.013060099445283413, -0.051318369805812836, -0.014508712105453014, 0.016271863132715225, -0.03221021220088005, 0.04949653893709183, -0.028574837371706963, -0.023518232628703117, -0.008947163820266724, -0.007501340936869383, -0.04770243167877197, 0.014491413719952106, -0.01696270890533924, 0.016751712188124657, -0.041320785880088806, -0.019294684752821922, -0.038629621267318726, 0.005305017344653606, -0.018888087943196297, 0.05800216645002365, -0.03054143488407135, -0.01485305093228817, 0.022186243906617165, -0.0023277904838323593, 0.015480061993002892, -0.018468346446752548, 0.03677835315465927, 0.012366952374577522, 0.008229518309235573, 0.0772099569439888, 0.001545823528431356, -0.0025349489878863096, 0.025184940546751022, 0.0053275697864592075, 0.009828993119299412, -0.022762266919016838, 0.014770402573049068, 0.030311517417430878, 0.05308228358626366, 0.0010252640349790454, 0.05886896699666977, 0.00273917056620121, -0.02388335019350052, 0.004837160464376211, -0.06832581758499146, 0.013069752603769302, 0.006521434523165226, -0.046124331653118134, -0.07004182040691376, -0.008034550584852695, 0.010692390613257885, 0.031787529587745667, -0.04106125235557556, 0.023398375138640404, 0.028764856979250908, 0.0459187887609005, 0.030012916773557663, -0.0002806394186336547, 0.0001572892942931503, -0.028640111908316612, -0.007927509024739265, -0.0014676471473649144, -0.015057047829031944, 0.000989596825093031, 0.024313732981681824, 0.003937109373509884, -0.004875482060015202, 0.0446365587413311, -0.05980570241808891, -0.022026916965842247, -0.0024891430512070656, -0.02688213624060154, -0.003524646395817399, -0.0070352028124034405, 0.000681765959598124, 0.013811590149998665, 0.013098720461130142, 0.06108841672539711, -0.026343267410993576, -0.03650997579097748, 0.03208867087960243, -0.016345437616109848, 0.07587676495313644, -0.002079975325614214, 0.044587794691324234, -0.022766955196857452, -0.007248054724186659, -0.08318203687667847, -0.040674421936273575, 0.03545574098825455, 0.0019339590799063444, -0.07015936076641083, -0.053476255387067795, -0.01197652518749237, 0.03586193919181824, 0.029624052345752716, -0.0041968608275055885, 0.011965706944465637, -0.06262680143117905, 0.0017628106288611889, -0.02666771598160267, 0.01095582451671362, 0.09057575464248657, -0.0532502755522728, -0.0007535357144661248, 0.04677954316139221, -0.0059533994644880295, -0.02150416560471058, 0.02676798403263092, -0.024334769695997238, -0.03281817585229874, -0.015684064477682114, -0.004765997640788555, 0.013264870271086693, 0.047164373099803925, -0.00516207329928875, -0.029556190595030785, -0.038901496678590775, 0.01806703582406044, 0.04854352027177811, 0.003780653700232506, 0.013877565041184425, -0.013060279190540314, -0.008843199349939823, -0.006331405136734247, 0.006477874703705311, -0.003961436450481415, -0.0027586601208895445, 0.01925143413245678, -0.006829685531556606, -0.05057894065976143, 0.04432728886604309, 0.06223687529563904, -0.023979132995009422, 0.0038340280298143625, 0.010751601308584213, -0.01941472664475441, 0.03978065773844719, 0.017240449786186218, -0.010699539445340633, -0.019522294402122498, 0.002321335719898343, -0.008296171203255653, -0.023263778537511826, -0.050571851432323456, 0.007278157398104668, 0.050524625927209854, -0.004171786829829216, 0.04621003195643425, 0.009261407889425755, 0.033946577459573746, -0.012180693447589874, -0.019372737035155296, -0.01245101261883974, 0.016161495819687843, 0.021977338939905167, 0.04684129357337952, -0.017107365652918816, -0.009389941580593586, 0.030565952882170677, -0.01546591054648161, 0.010014589875936508, 0.058216534554958344, -0.029493864625692368, -0.04013403505086899, 0.010533480904996395, -0.002044935477897525, -0.034744903445243835, 0.023147359490394592, -0.022870855405926704, 0.00625327043235302, -0.031332287937402725, -0.04912344738841057, 0.027645695954561234, -0.03619995340704918, -0.0019054050790145993, -0.04209837689995766, -0.03703718259930611, 0.001143706263974309, -0.014712292701005936, 0.008721007034182549, -0.03437911346554756, 0.046509742736816406, 0.0025883482303470373, 0.024359583854675293, -0.008099202066659927, 0.056573327630758286, -0.029508236795663834, -0.06384924054145813, -0.03913915529847145, -0.017286650836467743, -0.06067674979567528, 0.06691788882017136, 0.020542040467262268, -0.023733040317893028, 0.014413425698876381, -0.04595394805073738, 0.03759166970849037, 0.016798442229628563, 0.020638298243284225, -0.0147068090736866, 0.07764282077550888, 0.0015072638634592295, 0.024351272732019424, 0.0006478301947936416, -0.04518586024641991, 0.13345809280872345, 0.03170587122440338, 0.03408728539943695, -0.05474252998828888, -0.028322938829660416, 0.0028850878588855267, -0.01484458427876234, -0.004467108752578497, -0.011266821064054966, 0.02898649126291275, -0.01999897137284279, 0.05087738856673241, 0.04992843419313431, 0.030209749937057495, -0.015402971766889095, 0.013262244872748852, -0.015255003236234188, -0.023570487275719643, 0.013127912767231464, 0.018137069419026375, 0.005083490163087845, -0.015576626174151897, -0.07052239775657654, 0.026932405307888985, 0.016172491014003754, 0.0033766785636544228, -0.05728743597865105, 0.024743642657995224, -0.012198274955153465, 0.007617016322910786, -0.032107140868902206, -0.01442424301058054, 0.016894713044166565, 0.003645832184702158, -0.0081148287281394, -0.037831488996744156, 0.018038194626569748, -0.06482164561748505, -0.001579604926519096, 0.007309806067496538, 0.01809346117079258, 0.03834432736039162, 0.001433378434740007, 0.03422120213508606, -0.05339810252189636, -0.007959295995533466, -0.032879538834095, 0.023066971451044083, 0.022704243659973145, 0.009731043130159378, 0.012905384413897991, -0.007666528224945068, 0.0024273511953651905, -0.03541344031691551, -0.0002390307345194742, 0.006785224657505751, 0.01637534238398075, 0.013006705790758133, -0.005369814578443766, 0.022961052134633064, 0.02680293098092079, -0.002281136577948928, 0.02840774692595005, 0.011534035205841064, -0.008133519440889359, -0.0445014126598835, -0.054928429424762726, 0.060016144067049026, 0.022745609283447266, 0.010612309910356998, 0.009583739563822746, -0.008564343675971031, -0.011601172387599945, 0.01418792549520731, 0.027106009423732758, -0.005555625539273024, 0.03806367143988609, 0.00927711557596922, -0.02308778464794159, 0.0023356545716524124, -0.01653851941227913, 0.025597957894206047, -0.027755258604884148, 0.011463368311524391, -0.051020488142967224, -0.002426601480692625, 0.026358287781476974, 0.049990344792604446, 0.031149648129940033, 0.049026649445295334, -0.021984325721859932, 0.08498585969209671, 0.019466789439320564, -0.041793838143348694, 0.008290721103549004, 0.0019603974651545286, -0.008646064437925816, -0.0029219756834208965, -0.011720736511051655, 0.04618744179606438, 0.0036641955375671387, 0.023325828835368156, 0.02051386423408985, 0.024763014167547226, -0.014192875474691391, -0.022120695561170578, 0.007282183971256018, -0.01252441294491291, -0.001448656665161252, 0.011926759965717793, -0.024215219542384148, -0.039582863450050354, 0.005128750577569008, -0.01682061143219471, -0.06756164133548737, -0.019906409084796906, 0.0033813659101724625, -0.03112206794321537, -0.022572819143533707, -0.007052303291857243, -0.04595361649990082, 0.008595417253673077, -0.0008243773481808603, -0.013451647944748402, 0.029987609013915062, -0.06847775727510452, -0.021037308499217033, -0.0016136004123836756, -0.009944244287908077, -0.012464750558137894, -0.0065843490883708, 0.05629217252135277, 0.00822193268686533, 0.03556254133582115, -0.011857300065457821, 0.03188518434762955, 0.007307037245482206, 0.0567958764731884, -0.006613009609282017, 0.007323095574975014, 0.04607979580760002, -0.06652987003326416, -0.02939577028155327, -0.009761538356542587, 0.02144988812506199, 0.01684156060218811, -0.009565640240907669, -0.025486260652542114, -0.03262460231781006, 0.06211831793189049, -0.04004402458667755, -0.003281546523794532, -0.03595505282282829, 0.00556352362036705, -0.00834969338029623, 0.0015780621906742454, -0.0018681742949411273, -0.02066519483923912, -0.031438447535037994, 0.00932726077735424, 0.04012678191065788, -0.026682181283831596, -0.0007754992111586034, 0.0038391726557165384, -0.03767876327037811, -0.03258981555700302, 0.039842840284109116, 0.0030039544217288494, 0.027614710852503777, 0.022549303248524666, -0.0285260621458292, 0.04905245825648308, -0.014767230488359928, 0.04149826988577843, -0.0989873856306076, -0.029422104358673096, -0.0005628535873256624, 0.034989096224308014, 0.047580406069755554, -0.04494957998394966, -0.016994671896100044, 0.027164185419678688, -0.04061450436711311, 0.046933405101299286, -0.004593822173774242, 0.006898385938256979, -0.016574954614043236, 0.00872258935123682, -0.04184139519929886, 0.004896463360637426, 0.015231252647936344, 0.013791464269161224, 0.06262001395225525, 0.014680339023470879, -0.003202897496521473, -0.007014508359134197, -0.028620505705475807, 0.006587128154933453, 0.019874656572937965, -0.02756262570619583, 0.006678481586277485, -0.041445087641477585, -0.01899360492825508, 0.034624118357896805, -0.0056915986351668835, 0.00410059466958046, 0.017276369035243988, 0.05793476477265358, 0.02671939879655838, 0.04388223960995674, 0.02087043784558773, 0.035282522439956665, 0.000986047787591815, -0.015430362895131111, 0.03074416145682335, -0.002246462507173419, -0.029625864699482918, 0.035584114491939545, 0.03469187766313553, 0.0018272007582709193, -0.03250797837972641, -0.014094792306423187, 0.008696387521922588, -0.03783417493104935, -0.039518751204013824, 0.04467899352312088, 0.020236356183886528, -0.014357835985720158, 0.024823680520057678, -0.019212165847420692, 0.0208272784948349, 0.03930167853832245, 0.05528108403086662, -0.022216586396098137, 0.0495760440826416, -0.0035909712314605713, -0.040156979113817215, -0.02636292576789856, -0.021482480689883232, 0.010877596214413643, -0.063017837703228, -0.023803608492016792, 0.005008227191865444, 0.011224063113331795, 0.008178811520338058, -0.01580125465989113, -0.06755204498767853, -0.00286933034658432, -0.01509054098278284, -0.0026437556371092796, 0.027381502091884613, -0.003451572498306632, 0.011917360126972198, -0.13268394768238068, 0.03664694353938103, -0.002925833920016885, 0.014214261434972286, -0.041023530066013336, -0.0020172675140202045, -0.06535450369119644, 0.06522615998983383, 0.038929425179958344, 0.04025379195809364, -0.019123276695609093, -0.004288392141461372, 0.002306391252204776, 0.02013316936790943, -0.030965754762291908, 0.037376534193754196, 0.019286641851067543, -0.026946457102894783, -0.0028952518478035927, 0.014451374299824238, 0.022256871685385704, 0.01409580186009407, -0.03153765946626663, 0.02196217142045498, -0.018286311998963356, -0.0013851297553628683, -0.0068664997816085815, 0.05004339665174484, -0.001980171538889408, -0.030486730858683586, 0.018394293263554573, -0.005163983441889286, -0.004098168108612299, 0.05550578236579895, 0.03816012293100357, -0.061439309269189835, -0.010536208748817444, 0.016086816787719727, -0.02689373679459095, 0.006403000093996525, 0.004742284771054983, 0.006417584139853716, -0.07038894295692444, 0.013880543410778046, 0.002648883732035756, -0.047272369265556335, -0.01507891807705164, -0.031907882541418076, 0.015391048043966293, 0.016961177811026573, 0.002793779829517007, 0.023873746395111084, -0.009134652093052864, -0.006302810274064541, 0.04072701185941696, 0.0016073711449280381, 0.016545653343200684, -0.04037436470389366, 0.012586383149027824, -0.0032434402965009212, -0.021048054099082947, 0.0032990355975925922, -0.018540041521191597, 0.08542315661907196, -0.004988133441656828, -0.0022128247655928135, 0.04901183769106865, 0.00243001407943666, 0.0076626380905508995, -0.021353749558329582, -0.02044062130153179, 0.03966796025633812, -0.0008744170190766454, 0.026678619906306267, 0.011373966000974178, -0.04933520779013634, 0.00725692231208086, 0.006745532155036926, -0.02983357012271881, 0.008307707495987415, -0.06173041835427284, 0.00791165791451931, 0.015143468976020813, -0.005893040914088488, -0.0011327116517350078, -0.035956427454948425, 0.0018178841564804316, -0.026721807196736336, 0.017927158623933792, -0.022193534299731255, -0.016556568443775177, -0.01786096580326557, -0.01605559140443802, 0.0037970412522554398, 0.027362314984202385, 0.020868053659796715, -0.030827540904283524, -0.024588357657194138, -0.012853330001235008, 0.023417878895998, -0.00947724748402834, -0.023165559396147728, -0.02294056862592697, 0.019653329625725746, -0.006265122443437576, -0.04936898872256279 ]
<p>So, it seems to me that the weights function in lm gives observations more weight the larger the associated observation's 'weight' value, while the lme function in lme does precisely the opposite. This can be verified with a simple simulation. </p> <pre><code>#make 3 vectors- c is used as an uninformative random effect for the lme model a&lt;-c(1:10) b&lt;-c(2,4,6,8,10,100,14,16,18,20) c&lt;-c(1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1) </code></pre> <p>If you were now to run a model where you weight the observations based on the inverse of the dependent variable in lm, you can only generate the exact same result in nlme if you weight by just the dependent variable, without taking the inverse.</p> <pre><code>summary(lm(b~a,weights=1/b)) summary(lme(b~a,random=~1|c,weights=~b)) </code></pre> <p>You can flip this and see the converse is true- specifying weights=b in lm requires weights=1/b to get a matching lme result. </p> <p>So, I understand this much, I just want validation on one thing and to ask a question about another.</p> <ol> <li>If I want to weight my data based on the inverse of the dependent variable, is it fine to just code weights=~(dependent variable) within lme?</li> <li>Why is lme written to handle weights completely differently than lm? What is the purpose of this other than to generate confusion? </li> </ol> <p>Any insight would be appreciated!</p>
73,948
[ -0.0466792955994606, 0.007252365350723267, -0.0172637440264225, -0.015154805034399033, 0.02088789828121662, 0.025409597903490067, 0.0006749977474100888, -0.014166747219860554, 0.06420277059078217, -0.03367426618933678, 0.019177274778485298, 0.07256946712732315, 0.08763215690851212, 0.004691148176789284, 0.06917520612478256, 0.008311064913868904, 0.0039814491756260395, 0.00010570981976343319, 0.007710250094532967, -0.037467945367097855, -0.014661355875432491, 0.024475496262311935, 0.04867209866642952, -0.00913566630333662, -0.014154339209198952, 0.03172004222869873, 0.03287912905216217, -0.026583587750792503, 0.034219905734062195, 0.04696683958172798, -0.01994490996003151, -0.035762958228588104, 0.019072391092777252, 0.017370091751217842, 0.008439866825938225, -0.008919562213122845, -0.02290794998407364, 0.009223992936313152, -0.0192551352083683, 0.017309658229351044, -0.03984488546848297, 0.00769581226631999, -0.0203007273375988, 0.03838380426168442, 0.011579065583646297, 0.012098112143576145, -0.015091676265001297, -0.011007566936314106, 0.041134677827358246, -0.05383627116680145, 0.0749778151512146, 0.004400952253490686, 0.009551586583256721, 0.0427827388048172, -0.009455879218876362, -0.034839190542697906, 0.0806109756231308, 0.0820382833480835, 0.01922430470585823, -0.051055897027254105, 0.0011342691723257303, -0.011752324178814888, 0.005882316268980503, 0.016341829672455788, -0.029445838183164597, 0.0016849125968292356, 0.021026961505413055, -0.00392412394285202, 0.07369568943977356, -0.03421132639050484, 0.02552381530404091, 0.037000320851802826, 0.030873045325279236, 0.011130403727293015, 0.017062455415725708, -0.025997774675488472, -0.0004873289435636252, -0.029065145179629326, 0.049838557839393616, 0.039008066058158875, -0.0009405538439750671, 0.025262070819735527, 0.0054532624781131744, 0.05952488258481026, -0.014955569989979267, -0.03057308867573738, 0.05491344630718231, -0.0069343834184110165, 0.024465365335345268, -0.0016872367123141885, -0.038119979202747345, 0.027011491358280182, 0.02270708978176117, 0.011667651124298573, -0.015190478414297104, 0.03809627890586853, -0.033206548541784286, -0.0028223798144608736, 0.019865278154611588, -0.010241261683404446, -0.03367716073989868, -0.06176707148551941, 0.005121094640344381, 0.03392008692026138, -0.01541018858551979, -0.011984608136117458, -0.015268698334693909, 0.01767611876130104, 0.0014077227097004652, -0.01878347061574459, 0.020949041470885277, 0.03036734275519848, -0.022758247330784798, -0.01847483217716217, 0.025431042537093163, -0.050217363983392715, 0.012926352210342884, -0.007758890278637409, 0.033093493431806564, 0.05980362743139267, 0.030942624434828758, 0.0024266503751277924, -0.011502332985401154, -0.04215537756681442, -0.016916945576667786, -0.003040681127458811, 0.024154487997293472, -0.017358288168907166, -0.027189571410417557, 0.05071575567126274, 0.01193181797862053, -0.05794217064976692, 0.05219490826129913, -0.008353717625141144, 0.0005278806202113628, -0.007080611307173967, -0.09620174020528793, -0.060778845101594925, 0.041770052164793015, -0.053941238671541214, 0.010046836920082569, -0.03574772924184799, -0.00037740147672593594, 0.036971013993024826, 0.04798712953925133, 0.050728052854537964, 0.0580705963075161, 0.02597339078783989, 0.01137111522257328, 0.014677982777357101, -0.020887374877929688, 0.0008290240657515824, -0.011241760104894638, -0.04347097501158714, 0.007488328963518143, -0.08401466906070709, -0.0025358879938721657, 0.015277824364602566, -0.038259733468294144, 0.001436319318599999, 0.04987509176135063, -0.016822753474116325, 0.0019185837591066957, 0.010546344332396984, 0.010868430137634277, -0.008356338366866112, 0.05148141086101532, 0.013439239002764225, 0.037303391844034195, 0.015979142859578133, -0.02472340688109398, 0.031962063163518906, 0.00626339390873909, 0.033424872905015945, 0.0419701412320137, -0.025224333629012108, 0.01572740450501442, -0.04263491556048393, 0.01876671053469181, 0.01748579740524292, -0.06153785437345505, 0.0022286095190793276, 0.003711674129590392, -0.032765716314315796, 0.029857074841856956, 0.017513802275061607, -0.0034383872989565134, -0.006976105272769928, 0.05446985363960266, -0.01128390058875084, -0.02899410016834736, -0.06369153410196304, 0.00008566099859308451, 0.02130933478474617, -0.03957848623394966, 0.019817231222987175, -0.0033058389090001583, 0.03085394762456417, 0.00954813975840807, 0.016441497951745987, -0.034790217876434326, 0.0027009951882064342, 0.023165157064795494, -0.017407145351171494, 0.015308343805372715, 0.042188145220279694, 0.05362361669540405, -0.019323376938700676, 0.0039078970439732075, -0.030119342729449272, -0.03267093747854233, 0.04012023285031319, -0.020436204969882965, -0.02085656113922596, -0.011983821168541908, -0.0345597118139267, 0.020796896889805794, -0.009656901471316814, -0.0360848531126976, 0.069785475730896, -0.06649927794933319, 0.0596068799495697, 0.08545999974012375, -0.011217826046049595, -0.015482906252145767, 0.025654777884483337, 0.021000174805521965, 0.036452267318964005, -0.040079813450574875, 0.0203817430883646, -0.05395354703068733, -0.019134601578116417, 0.052724286913871765, 0.00462800357490778, -0.029391687363386154, 0.019111016765236855, 0.035203006118535995, -0.005177625454962254, 0.016265137121081352, 0.03722671419382095, -0.01031198538839817, -0.020499808713793755, 0.039758410304784775, 0.01500757411122322, 0.04797423258423805, 0.013275263831019402, 0.0069872173480689526, -0.0009297276264987886, 0.020261423662304878, 0.0010779362637549639, -0.022541329264640808, 0.07240290939807892, -0.002612397540360689, -0.015437426045536995, -0.011651772074401379, -0.01934276521205902, 0.03454507887363434, -0.028458522632718086, 0.011050092056393623, 0.04624113067984581, -0.010497073642909527, -0.037985388189554214, -0.006408163346350193, -0.013823255896568298, 0.0051005007699131966, 0.02055288478732109, -0.023828139528632164, -0.0017985455924645066, 0.01817147620022297, -0.034076202660799026, 0.002321817446500063, -0.005655914079397917, -0.019687162712216377, -0.074175164103508, 0.02517533116042614, -0.0023992981296032667, -0.009131679311394691, 0.0038410464767366648, -0.027621813118457794, -0.0353161096572876, -0.006296209059655666, 0.008960339240729809, 0.013136765919625759, -0.004726711194962263, -0.050062067806720734, 0.00844332855194807, -0.03095313347876072, -0.03412133455276489, 0.031144440174102783, -0.011212040670216084, 0.0064025879837572575, 0.004671006463468075, 0.008878669701516628, -0.043136656284332275, -0.017236461862921715, -0.020275946706533432, 0.013373506255447865, 0.024314293637871742, -0.03706458956003189, 0.06435203552246094, 0.00970203336328268, -0.04590428248047829, 0.025954358279705048, -0.05564427748322487, -0.02504112385213375, -0.046592600643634796, 0.006127446889877319, -0.0069713350385427475, -0.007085107266902924, 0.004326766822487116, 0.022201957181096077, -0.05429418385028839, -0.02397029660642147, -0.056773990392684937, -0.032064832746982574, 0.01623276062309742, 0.04133698344230652, -0.0009066545753739774, 0.049798861145973206, -0.02147817797958851, 0.09528293460607529, 0.04892302304506302, -0.04500426724553108, -0.06400779634714127, 0.006287397816777229, -0.01491997204720974, -0.033331748098134995, 0.023715324699878693, -0.026765257120132446, -0.012058085761964321, 0.028605682775378227, 0.003376615699380636, 0.007227583788335323, 0.025167925283312798, 0.022221015766263008, -0.0029123208951205015, 0.011128825135529041, -0.001742580789141357, -0.03365040570497513, 0.041666723787784576, 0.007393433712422848, -0.01551306527107954, 0.006524448748677969, 0.02470434457063675, 0.020416192710399628, -0.03548302873969078, -0.05018632113933563, 0.004707289859652519, -0.011164315044879913, 0.0505487322807312, -0.042838964611291885, 0.031228113919496536, -0.009311934933066368, -0.015117269940674305, 0.015158901922404766, 0.00008588260971009731, 0.032846249639987946, -0.048540759831666946, -0.029638685286045074, 0.02741578407585621, 0.03619227558374405, -0.02629176527261734, 0.0006744515849277377, 0.010225359350442886, -0.021270940080285072, 0.019655868411064148, -0.036866337060928345, 0.0008706822409294546, 0.05734257400035858, 0.027178851887583733, 0.011956402100622654, -0.009144688956439495, -0.053286559879779816, 0.016582554206252098, -0.06190226227045059, 0.02411450445652008, 0.003802647814154625, 0.0585140585899353, 0.01075291633605957, 0.06995052844285965, 0.028878720477223396, -0.008754020556807518, 0.0015366636216640472, -0.003908182960003614, -0.07343994081020355, 0.046134769916534424, 0.004562046844512224, 0.011888539418578148, 0.012103053741157055, -0.014169166795909405, 0.002792719518765807, -0.04405206814408302, -0.015750519931316376, -0.010468672029674053, 0.008702442049980164, -0.011538028717041016, 0.012490903027355671, -0.03409552201628685, -0.004352763295173645, -0.016889985650777817, 0.0056845503859221935, 0.0011327123502269387, -0.03747443109750748, 0.028314849361777306, 0.06724127382040024, -0.033461883664131165, -0.018657105043530464, -0.03626789152622223, 0.005052820313721895, 0.01712779887020588, 0.05128604918718338, 0.00429273908957839, 0.007583053316920996, -0.0315094068646431, 0.03011706843972206, 0.03740755096077919, 0.009372533299028873, 0.05115024000406265, 0.0034247967414557934, -0.049414925277233124, -0.02975546009838581, -0.033001918345689774, 0.014969813637435436, -0.008558329194784164, 0.002103380160406232, 0.003364321542903781, 0.0587947741150856, -0.002932085655629635, -0.04190943017601967, 0.029668211936950684, 0.053248997777700424, 0.020256059244275093, -0.01802912726998329, -0.041338954120874405, 0.015300342813134193, -0.012409204617142677, -0.03823787346482277, 0.05898359417915344, 0.004675612784922123, 0.022113794460892677, -0.005756830796599388, 0.03693234547972679, -0.022442689165472984, 0.0027936308179050684, 0.013083310797810555, 0.04026804864406586, 0.018550794571638107, -0.012096896767616272, -0.05268865078687668, -0.023081809282302856, 0.0303855761885643, 0.05124105140566826, 0.01230981107801199, -0.015121201053261757, -0.082698754966259, 0.023260565474629402, 0.03707364946603775, 0.05447446182370186, -0.03902167081832886, 0.016131604090332985, 0.00472481781616807, -0.022649498656392097, 0.010181182064116001, -0.07306423038244247, 0.01889968290925026, -0.02838715724647045, 0.027971096336841583, -0.011246612295508385, -0.02737467549741268, -0.02458743005990982, 0.04560978710651398, -0.036222346127033234, 0.021494688466191292, -0.017191698774695396, -0.04094785451889038, -0.020260551944375038, 0.02534577064216137, 0.02215992659330368, 0.056044090539216995, -0.07107274234294891, -0.032296936959028244, -0.0045593734830617905, 0.05084215849637985, -0.006859682034701109, -0.03848666697740555, -0.03072950430214405, -0.007803732994943857, 0.00263699097558856, 0.053570106625556946, -0.01159414742141962, -0.07449834793806076, 0.019888341426849365, 0.035913191735744476, 0.005702102556824684, -0.02335796318948269, -0.007565257605165243, 0.05064799264073372, 0.008706417866051197, -0.005292525049299002, 0.04105926305055618, 0.0024708209093660116, -0.003100104397162795, -0.0250860508531332, -0.03801582753658295, 0.005696800537407398, -0.025715583935379982, -0.0397457592189312, -0.05071133002638817, -0.0025840341113507748, -0.004861531779170036, 0.04068802669644356, 0.02700413018465042, 0.011922899633646011, -0.03893028944730759, -0.030846664682030678, -0.007571954745799303, 0.026743371039628983, 0.00577966682612896, -0.01241430826485157, -0.0090846698731184, 0.013308316469192505, 0.005803259089589119, -0.013928184285759926, -0.0005632281536236405, 0.002509143203496933, -0.019270407035946846, 0.004066907800734043, -0.035120341926813126, 0.024272436276078224, -0.008921679109334946, 0.007907858118414879, 0.055392973124980927, -0.014441716484725475, 0.030121246352791786, 0.02431761473417282, 0.02689630724489689, -0.024436242878437042, -0.07225659489631653, 0.011237322352826595, 0.014683418907225132, -0.037021469324827194, 0.00979499239474535, -0.04118943586945534, 0.013362663798034191, 0.015170346945524216, -0.002970104804262519, -0.06638451665639877, -0.03845281898975372, -0.007095946930348873, -0.02941354736685753, 0.009007885120809078, -0.017382359132170677, -0.03096419759094715, -0.024735793471336365, -0.03072628378868103, -0.022880153730511665, 0.08399020880460739, -0.03103739023208618, -0.011385749094188213, 0.01743120327591896, 0.017010176554322243, 0.04470956698060036, 0.011657795868813992, -0.011206496506929398, 0.0052652363665401936, -0.019498877227306366, -0.025979826226830482, 0.022334741428494453, 0.0001511248992756009, -0.045701976865530014, 0.016856737434864044, -0.024730941280722618, -0.006947593297809362, 0.06683371961116791, -0.01974589005112648, -0.03071782924234867, 0.029465215280652046, -0.017770543694496155, 0.000997046590782702, -0.02338782697916031, -0.0005383624229580164, -0.03391449898481369, 0.04113411158323288, -0.007457229774445295, 0.008729414083063602, -0.019723234698176384, -0.0025576739571988583, 0.051363639533519745, -0.015578879974782467, -0.01667696423828602, -0.009503452107310295, 0.09096910059452057, -0.008895453996956348, 0.028919128701090813, -0.03582409396767616, -0.037778422236442566, 0.03562008962035179, -0.0037461533211171627, 0.002940658014267683, 0.026233477517962456, 0.030310753732919693, -0.0323551706969738, -0.021868616342544556, -0.022956231608986855, 0.005022080149501562, 0.045977283269166946, -0.004599340725690126, 0.017926232889294624, 0.039559658616781235, -0.016153810545802116, -0.009568958543241024, -0.0449286550283432, -0.013382382690906525, 0.001024747733026743, -0.0034916617441922426, 0.07373413443565369, -0.007910002022981644, -0.004536528140306473, 0.054492175579071045, 0.0018849808257073164, 0.045754119753837585, 0.0004843946371693164, 0.0071622999384999275, 0.02797684259712696, 0.022954998537898064, -0.004977099131792784, -0.03483681380748749, 0.048444852232933044, -0.02046959102153778, 0.0038755827117711306, -0.03376410901546478, -0.053220368921756744, 0.051799748092889786, 0.0067549836821854115, -0.018565546721220016, -0.05756191536784172, -0.03748403489589691, -0.03836396709084511, 0.03246896713972092, 0.02593817561864853, -0.006213245913386345, 0.018944241106510162, 0.025791121646761894, 0.025720244273543358, 0.006297902204096317, 0.011082347482442856, -0.030062181875109673, -0.10446920990943909, -0.06387168169021606, -0.01937943883240223, -0.025254974141716957, 0.019609875977039337, 0.002896901685744524, -0.00694337859749794, 0.03551463037729263, -0.05946988984942436, 0.029575824737548828, 0.005684662610292435, 0.03288640081882477, -0.004509366117417812, 0.06177947297692299, 0.0003454402321949601, 0.01982930488884449, -0.00003961532638641074, -0.018101710826158524, 0.11959847807884216, 0.05302237346768379, 0.05613798648118973, -0.09570547938346863, 0.044561974704265594, 0.007484629284590483, 0.0036562648601830006, 0.00920089054852724, -0.0002895559591706842, 0.003125322051346302, 0.03136782720685005, 0.009288391098380089, 0.02001863345503807, 0.006603652145713568, -0.0018013096414506435, 0.032578010112047195, -0.03725234419107437, -0.012354015372693539, 0.014075098559260368, 0.01766366884112358, -0.010699843056499958, -0.052915800362825394, -0.05811338499188423, -0.007046298123896122, 0.03481253236532211, -0.002310995478183031, -0.04271365702152252, -0.022334489971399307, -0.019124643877148628, -0.014161499217152596, 0.0005784875247627497, 0.005821261089295149, -0.010986370034515858, 0.009447325021028519, 0.005828401539474726, 0.018566211685538292, 0.023885659873485565, -0.03881138935685158, 0.01691773533821106, 0.022992679849267006, -0.000931817339733243, 0.02206936478614807, -0.027388913556933403, 0.02708369493484497, -0.03676418587565422, -0.011827359907329082, -0.03993849456310272, 0.05800844356417656, -0.02305482141673565, 0.011458016000688076, 0.015710406005382538, -0.007571361027657986, 0.022080430760979652, -0.04170779511332512, -0.009816641919314861, 0.025374937802553177, 0.009387842379510403, -0.009988806210458279, -0.01031882967799902, -0.03142254427075386, 0.025582030415534973, -0.016487523913383484, 0.049128297716379166, 0.04822093993425369, -0.06127182021737099, 0.00274787750095129, -0.01435050182044506, 0.04906008765101433, -0.005517957266420126, 0.02263382449746132, -0.01087254099547863, -0.018539566546678543, -0.016413910314440727, -0.016767095774412155, 0.015977781265974045, -0.0012322082184255123, 0.035441260784864426, -0.052705440670251846, -0.004279479384422302, -0.038946423679590225, -0.04431190341711044, 0.01258288323879242, -0.009331499226391315, -0.01041249930858612, -0.015714989975094795, 0.0254068523645401, 0.03035137802362442, 0.02145400643348694, 0.01135731115937233, -0.019837530329823494, -0.0021227672696113586, 0.006176218390464783, -0.029628513380885124, -0.06329737603664398, -0.0075219785794615746, 0.044641923159360886, -0.012435346841812134, 0.01730608381330967, 0.022764166817069054, 0.057911258190870285, 0.014262661337852478, 0.03153160586953163, -0.032879263162612915, 0.0490197092294693, -0.019641747698187828, -0.007036956958472729, 0.004537975415587425, -0.011840671300888062, 0.004376235418021679, 0.001436352962628007, -0.010910199023783207, -0.01930859312415123, -0.012746088206768036, -0.07583148777484894, -0.04977710172533989, -0.003846528474241495, -0.03499607369303703, -0.04535198584198952, -0.0009021700243465602, 0.004287930205464363, 0.006990625057369471, -0.008100924082100391, -0.0051216790452599525, -0.023753510788083076, -0.05064183101058006, 0.005352761130779982, -0.06956681609153748, -0.01598419062793255, 0.024546708911657333, -0.008330932818353176, -0.024307195097208023, 0.007414091844111681, 0.0005976703832857311, 0.018466198816895485, -0.02339407056570053, 0.012954432517290115, -0.00406999746337533, 0.03104006126523018, -0.008481144905090332, -0.040771257132291794, 0.054689113050699234, -0.020604969933629036, -0.026757419109344482, 0.041198913007974625, -0.02798532322049141, 0.03463222458958626, 0.029342997819185257, 0.021880071610212326, -0.004523425828665495, 0.02952275611460209, -0.01600826345384121, -0.0016199633246287704, -0.014924711547791958, -0.029993616044521332, 0.013887010514736176, 0.005647347774356604, 0.025564342737197876, -0.014071268029510975, -0.007006470579653978, 0.015437649562954903, 0.04687466099858284, -0.028097933158278465, -0.026400985196232796, 0.011810366064310074, 0.019884398207068443, 0.0778423398733139, -0.0023150909692049026, 0.008708618581295013, 0.024966660887002945, 0.019518569111824036, -0.04864111542701721, 0.06349238008260727, -0.03525746986269951, 0.011764620430767536, -0.0866706520318985, -0.017566945403814316, 0.002764824777841568, 0.0010363069595769048, 0.01626356691122055, -0.048177193850278854, 0.014046299271285534, 0.005836622789502144, -0.04585213214159012, 0.026370016857981682, 0.021465083584189415, -0.012243476696312428, -0.010415395721793175, 0.019513489678502083, -0.035977594554424286, 0.0018042126903310418, -0.0173901729285717, -0.018472105264663696, 0.0525832362473011, -0.001361359260044992, 0.012421134859323502, -0.012344478629529476, -0.039932724088430405, 0.016057433560490608, 0.01972001977264881, -0.024951884523034096, 0.02765372209250927, -0.006467906758189201, -0.03592870011925697, 0.03664394095540047, -0.004175384528934956, 0.0312996506690979, 0.0044155423529446125, 0.021519893780350685, 0.014254829846322536, 0.04960911348462105, 0.027424411848187447, -0.01490428764373064, -0.003630233695730567, 0.012361557222902775, 0.05817481875419617, 0.025901872664690018, -0.014763569459319115, 0.01870228722691536, -0.004279574379324913, -0.002291362965479493, -0.006224829703569412, 0.04419068992137909, -0.01924332045018673, -0.013404224067926407, -0.04139582812786102, -0.00956707913428545, 0.010752132162451744, -0.05692833662033081, 0.03300097584724426, -0.03537503629922867, -0.021905018016695976, 0.054311636835336685, 0.005226332228630781, -0.01420478243380785, 0.032459765672683716, -0.003757121507078409, -0.029211532324552536, -0.0016612743493169546, -0.009912431240081787, -0.016094466671347618, -0.049808256328105927, 0.010132422670722008, 0.01996788941323757, -0.011152061633765697, -0.03129032626748085, -0.016672685742378235, -0.06154962256550789, 0.05099877715110779, -0.01780468039214611, 0.030057469382882118, 0.014385504648089409, -0.000014789728083997034, 0.025278721004724503, -0.12157464027404785, 0.0868762880563736, 0.003865382866933942, -0.01954970322549343, -0.07644415646791458, -0.011946930550038815, -0.005750069860368967, 0.001941275899298489, 0.047322724014520645, 0.030702074989676476, -0.011626030318439007, -0.005815551150590181, 0.03050246089696884, -0.007689889520406723, -0.03248301148414612, 0.016536861658096313, -0.002349664457142353, -0.011869573965668678, -0.009211251512169838, -0.009382393211126328, -0.005636569578200579, 0.011416800320148468, 0.013886594213545322, -0.01211133785545826, -0.006678077392280102, -0.0016446032095700502, 0.002818908542394638, 0.03371872752904892, -0.010861671529710293, 0.007220834493637085, 0.029060354456305504, 0.02084106020629406, 0.03120368905365467, 0.023165298625826836, 0.002463548444211483, -0.049098361283540726, 0.05661389231681824, -0.035250335931777954, 0.0038758066948503256, 0.007794308476150036, 0.010905939154326916, 0.02085384912788868, -0.0620124414563179, -0.02461695298552513, 0.005840434692800045, -0.010005428455770016, -0.007655033841729164, -0.0022673222701996565, 0.019114693626761436, 0.02469593659043312, 0.006681879051029682, 0.01280306838452816, -0.0010214024223387241, 0.004909991752356291, -0.0025906970258802176, 0.012911172583699226, 0.035455964505672455, -0.0013057456817477942, -0.01479803491383791, 0.05220048874616623, -0.008111495524644852, 0.020919276401400566, -0.023223476484417915, 0.07139932364225388, -0.02153651975095272, -0.014979209750890732, 0.024505551904439926, 0.0039931102655828, 0.05227503925561905, -0.005894339643418789, -0.02256879024207592, 0.029974108561873436, -0.06016942486166954, 0.03699663653969765, 0.000535310129635036, -0.0032654276583343744, -0.0023883820977061987, -0.028629761189222336, 0.03343687579035759, 0.042123328894376755, 0.030866451561450958, -0.009868348948657513, -0.010639417916536331, -0.03715536743402481, 0.006234060041606426, -0.01645093411207199, 0.003016524249687791, -0.02799091301858425, 0.019337713718414307, -0.016409369185566902, -0.02195371687412262, -0.017914416268467903, -0.027847079560160637, 0.010294316336512566, 0.05828200653195381, 0.050720687955617905, -0.006834971718490124, -0.014601602219045162, 0.014791250228881836, 0.03698541224002838, -0.03707540035247803, -0.01376807689666748, -0.04052230715751648, 0.020745502784848213, 0.009878410957753658, -0.011166539043188095 ]
<p>I am working with an investigator planning a study to validate a device to measure blood pressure (BP). The investigator states a difference within +/- 5 mmHg, when the two devices are used by the same participant, as "similar". I obtained the following summary statistics (slightly modified) from a similar study which used the ANSI/AAMI SP10A-2002 protocol:</p> <p>n = 100 participants<br> mean +/- SD systolic BP = -0.70 +/- 5.00<br> mean difference +/- diastolic BP = 0.20 +/- 5.20</p> <p>How many participants would the investigator need to recruit to validate the device considering the typical 80% power and alpha level of 0.05? I am using R (specifically power.t.test). I assume I want to focus on diastolic BP due to the greater variation.</p> <p>I defined the null and alternative hypotheses as follows: Null Hypothesis: The average difference between the two measurements is 5 mmHg. Alternative Hypothesis: The average difference between the two measurements are no greater than 5 mmHg (one-sided hypothesis).</p> <p>But apparently my thinking is off... is there a piece of information I am lacking? Thank you in advance!</p>
73,949
[ -0.02139895223081112, -0.017820144072175026, -0.014316808432340622, -0.010678761638700962, 0.0568249449133873, 0.005361724644899368, 0.010371798649430275, -0.031279414892196655, 0.008867975324392319, 0.005680485162883997, 0.04230356961488724, 0.022877318784594536, 0.03550383076071739, 0.0005901360418647528, 0.016665775328874588, 0.009249965660274029, -0.027015557512640953, 0.004225021693855524, -0.0004059930215589702, -0.041230425238609314, 0.015723001211881638, -0.025004403665661812, 0.0020824687089771032, -0.005076502915471792, -0.03428485989570618, 0.04341138154268265, 0.02173566445708275, -0.042908232659101486, -0.027080917730927467, 0.06154531240463257, -0.060355283319950104, -0.014670317061245441, 0.013231995515525341, 0.03313980996608734, 0.05468372628092766, 0.011726047843694687, -0.032155778259038925, -0.03718630596995354, -0.03862972557544708, 0.05209680274128914, -0.022425642237067223, -0.002856411272659898, 0.01112067885696888, -0.0010010648984462023, -0.03345426544547081, 0.008210268802940845, 0.027149353176355362, -0.042851466685533524, 0.018242651596665382, -0.04571171849966049, 0.0698636844754219, -0.0007221431005746126, 0.08401653170585632, 0.053952474147081375, 0.009370844811201096, -0.028604520484805107, 0.026793912053108215, 0.05651787295937538, 0.004004314076155424, -0.04210371524095535, -0.005670145619660616, -0.005320054944604635, -0.008737140335142612, -0.0006681545055471361, -0.03984205052256584, -0.02011893503367901, -0.018105773255228996, -0.016881804913282394, 0.050568949431180954, -0.0005615937407128513, 0.06152411922812462, 0.04434632509946823, 0.050935499370098114, -0.0155994463711977, 0.005360277369618416, -0.02320663444697857, 0.0030261268839240074, -0.011830978095531464, 0.036827802658081055, 0.038358934223651886, 0.003448458155617118, -0.01020028255879879, 0.04018748924136162, 0.05993175134062767, 0.010514931753277779, -0.039916131645441055, 0.04857728257775307, -0.027299799025058746, 0.005815030075609684, -0.0015007317997515202, -0.04677131772041321, -0.005597395822405815, 0.03881267085671425, 0.021847233176231384, -0.03597525134682655, 0.02585558407008648, -0.022594057023525238, 0.06792814284563065, 0.008456330746412277, 0.022023482248187065, -0.03757226839661598, -0.059556301683187485, 0.053923334926366806, 0.01457128394395113, 0.008261037059128284, -0.028408732265233994, -0.02376253716647625, -0.001805282081477344, 0.007050971034914255, 0.017531080171465874, 0.014593517407774925, 0.007991292513906956, 0.020947258919477463, -0.016128750517964363, 0.004311086609959602, -0.013429314829409122, 0.0006002274458296597, -0.010284760035574436, 0.09044424444437027, 0.0157727412879467, 0.046253107488155365, 0.04175996780395508, 0.00928344577550888, -0.016466539353132248, -0.023525439202785492, 0.017737742513418198, -0.023351596668362617, -0.00603722408413887, -0.02337496727705002, 0.042861197143793106, 0.026630735024809837, -0.004069529939442873, 0.03871782869100571, -0.004052777774631977, 0.044670067727565765, -0.007708796765655279, -0.10184973478317261, -0.05836382135748863, 0.047180455178022385, -0.017355220392346382, 0.015032920986413956, -0.07105286419391632, -0.01935616135597229, 0.02292817458510399, 0.04816834256052971, -0.0007748172502033412, 0.04163289815187454, 0.0068125915713608265, 0.016780409961938858, 0.035773176699876785, -0.02486616186797619, -0.015473537147045135, -0.05880149081349373, -0.016674360260367393, -0.046778563410043716, -0.11205969005823135, -0.027360377833247185, -0.006438154261559248, -0.052275869995355606, -0.011522878892719746, -0.003705037059262395, 0.008915424346923828, -0.008679690770804882, 0.0007290468201972544, 0.03811460733413696, -0.012645076960325241, 0.0814841166138649, -0.02571045607328415, -0.03411189839243889, 0.015340320765972137, -0.0036907540634274483, 0.023732095956802368, -0.0022706722375005484, 0.028434010222554207, 0.049072809517383575, -0.01424260251224041, 0.023882625624537468, -0.022151829674839973, 0.03170114755630493, 0.02021641843020916, 0.0003745791909750551, 0.007338257506489754, -0.03243650868535042, -0.03685580939054489, -0.007272809743881226, 0.022026842460036278, 0.017782015725970268, -0.021382750943303108, 0.04174576327204704, -0.03597639501094818, -0.046694956719875336, -0.03632123023271561, -0.003906662110239267, -0.00741609325632453, -0.02608325146138668, 0.02322697453200817, 0.01002747006714344, 0.04242663085460663, 0.01108360756188631, 0.0015139045426622033, 0.0114360973238945, -0.038614463061094284, 0.07340259850025177, -0.02752150408923626, 0.021419810131192207, 0.03584904223680496, 0.05458219349384308, -0.02376502938568592, 0.02427428774535656, -0.04263778775930405, -0.024554848670959473, 0.0006129703833721578, -0.04576948657631874, -0.002062814775854349, 0.03610270097851753, -0.03558887541294098, -0.005620032548904419, -0.004655376076698303, -0.009744185023009777, 0.05296613276004791, -0.06477144360542297, 0.06335465610027313, 0.05809924378991127, -0.020037943497300148, 0.0050107319839298725, 0.008897814899682999, 0.023618081584572792, 0.020510230213403702, -0.014510542154312134, -0.02154432237148285, -0.06829950958490372, 0.0010973797179758549, 0.041396599262952805, -0.008766143582761288, -0.024201661348342896, 0.008694776333868504, 0.04699091985821724, -0.0005669919773936272, 0.016071956604719162, 0.021532433107495308, 0.042857009917497635, -0.014117199927568436, -0.004526637960225344, 0.06991975009441376, -0.0019326758338138461, -0.005753297824412584, 0.013957277871668339, -0.02604191191494465, 0.058917101472616196, 0.011695952154695988, 0.0020328108221292496, 0.028772922232747078, 0.030548131093382835, 0.05548511818051338, -0.022389579564332962, 0.014378517866134644, 0.027811413630843163, 0.00011887589062098414, -0.007377065252512693, 0.05351531133055687, -0.008702126331627369, -0.03371039032936096, -0.008827922865748405, -0.02044738084077835, -0.004174345172941685, 0.029317693784832954, -0.013536452315747738, -0.010811379179358482, -0.007820573635399342, -0.05766628682613373, -0.011760782450437546, -0.04498454928398132, -0.003751451848074794, -0.011157126165926456, -0.018091021105647087, 0.03375426307320595, 0.022380713373422623, 0.067721888422966, -0.03885236009955406, -0.04044896364212036, 0.0005965956952422857, -0.02163921482861042, 0.020478276535868645, -0.0022866607178002596, -0.0569775365293026, -0.009631406515836716, -0.04602298140525818, -0.020301934331655502, 0.0331607386469841, -0.049957435578107834, -0.015383141115307808, 0.022343629971146584, 0.010305684059858322, -0.03638853132724762, -0.041663363575935364, -0.0154971182346344, -0.007963684387505054, -0.03300773352384567, -0.03039419837296009, 0.02486571855843067, 0.04357325658202171, -0.054212991148233414, 0.023074688389897346, -0.032841671258211136, -0.0036483800504356623, -0.021889979019761086, -0.010613903403282166, 0.034246597439050674, -0.0162933561950922, 0.02083400823175907, 0.03478230908513069, -0.04090070351958275, 0.02601989358663559, -0.03905347362160683, -0.06934021413326263, 0.006075137294828892, 0.017681419849395752, 0.018315831199288368, -0.013901070691645145, -0.01778971031308174, 0.10171441733837128, 0.03839370608329773, -0.03540601581335068, -0.03390806168317795, 0.031246516853570938, -0.029014827683568, -0.03251267969608307, 0.016354000195860863, 0.08955220878124237, -0.021565726026892662, 0.04109002277255058, 0.035089775919914246, 0.021558433771133423, 0.0423395037651062, 0.01725775934755802, -0.00530266622081399, 0.025005174800753593, 0.01933147758245468, 0.002257992047816515, 0.04292497783899307, 0.009323697537183762, -0.030757471919059753, 0.03115643560886383, -0.012835446745157242, 0.019548537209630013, -0.012367255054414272, -0.035971883684396744, 0.013070558197796345, -0.009347397834062576, -0.018212005496025085, -0.04388528689742088, -0.005525726824998856, 0.002755555557087064, -0.036306846886873245, -0.013610666617751122, 0.0462903194129467, 0.013467595912516117, -0.047573626041412354, -0.0054864101111888885, 0.056206993758678436, 0.03857644274830818, -0.018815604969859123, -0.03504343703389168, -0.028265681117773056, 0.0038729810621589422, -0.0117727005854249, -0.029990950599312782, -0.061073966324329376, 0.04783410578966141, 0.014353817328810692, 0.030200116336345673, 0.013228824362158775, -0.023915814235806465, 0.026696644723415375, -0.07592667639255524, -0.013920551165938377, -0.02331656590104103, 0.04406586289405823, -0.01920357160270214, 0.020256077870726585, 0.0020854466129094362, -0.0023398965131491423, 0.01301497407257557, -0.005949302110821009, -0.02561492659151554, 0.04441181570291519, -0.026754839345812798, -0.01906653679907322, 0.02522670291364193, -0.003424576949328184, 0.04268069565296173, -0.026374895125627518, 0.016514481976628304, 0.01063165720552206, 0.057560503482818604, -0.04687678813934326, 0.03195063769817352, -0.001908288337290287, -0.03152339160442352, 0.0007056460599415004, 0.01733280159533024, 0.01088491640985012, -0.000698285351973027, 0.03246036544442177, -0.024253815412521362, 0.028649460524320602, -0.020125439390540123, -0.01808302104473114, 0.03990866243839264, 0.03618209436535835, 0.054107416421175, 0.042003702372312546, 0.03263707086443901, -0.03307179734110832, 0.006533429026603699, 0.010601475834846497, 0.01732536219060421, 0.03923329338431358, 0.03283097222447395, -0.038544684648513794, -0.03729577735066414, -0.03010541945695877, -0.01857735402882099, 0.00898456759750843, 0.024257991462945938, -0.01203752402216196, 0.023046936839818954, 0.010521464049816132, -0.03619899973273277, 0.028380904346704483, 0.05917869508266449, 0.025997966527938843, -0.001893012085929513, -0.06284651905298233, -0.01562626101076603, -0.043903328478336334, -0.014810258522629738, 0.028357772156596184, 0.034064024686813354, -0.01590822823345661, 0.008465289138257504, 0.043119657784700394, -0.016360927373170853, -0.0115258963778615, 0.01663823053240776, -0.00268482300452888, 0.03255962207913399, 0.034391410648822784, -0.03247120976448059, 0.015531115233898163, 0.012246152386069298, 0.008216475136578083, 0.006987497676163912, -0.004339517559856176, -0.07212323695421219, 0.015937861055135727, 0.02298666350543499, 0.04042234271764755, -0.03410281613469124, 0.013199787586927414, -0.017927849665284157, 0.027463143691420555, 0.03709150105714798, -0.05794630944728851, -0.004963612649589777, 0.013058873824775219, 0.019678378477692604, -0.0003942236362490803, -0.010194224305450916, -0.06561189889907837, -0.010391343384981155, -0.022190606221556664, 0.00595947215333581, 0.00802282989025116, -0.05001801624894142, -0.01427093893289566, -0.011105066165328026, 0.0306968055665493, 0.07386775314807892, -0.05664309114217758, -0.008025877177715302, 0.019838400185108185, 0.013954922556877136, 0.0014983980217948556, -0.04615221917629242, 0.03011433035135269, -0.0072022355161607265, 0.006101127248257399, 0.04686925932765007, -0.024733522906899452, -0.020651578903198242, 0.01570192724466324, 0.029606860131025314, -0.03402508795261383, -0.0044906167313456535, -0.047976113855838776, 0.04127693921327591, 0.06521917879581451, -0.0036380074452608824, 0.06468313187360764, -0.03607756644487381, -0.018505780026316643, 0.016384445130825043, -0.03931669890880585, 0.010836651548743248, -0.018750013783574104, 0.0006797949317842722, -0.04103166610002518, 0.013659418560564518, -0.013365131802856922, 0.04704414680600166, -0.02598961628973484, 0.025901347398757935, 0.0033846248406916857, -0.016029810532927513, 0.01514789555221796, 0.0151600930839777, 0.009295323863625526, -0.021318767219781876, 0.041488051414489746, 0.036748651415109634, 0.02054458111524582, -0.02168731577694416, 0.015161209739744663, -0.043959956616163254, -0.010719764046370983, -0.017702123150229454, -0.046881165355443954, -0.009259765967726707, -0.002863229252398014, -0.021758219227194786, 0.020425191149115562, -0.026577509939670563, -0.011012389324605465, -0.03887002542614937, 0.057340290397405624, 0.00748657388612628, -0.02855086326599121, -0.028147034347057343, 0.020180881023406982, -0.010366290807723999, 0.015256800688803196, -0.06236470490694046, 0.04622410982847214, -0.023515649139881134, -0.003768735332414508, -0.0879938155412674, -0.025890275835990906, 0.008652694523334503, -0.025497309863567352, 0.0005586971528828144, -0.012349484488368034, -0.03128573298454285, -0.024153605103492737, -0.03092590905725956, -0.030868612229824066, 0.023610297590494156, 0.012362074106931686, -0.03082118183374405, -0.028639554977416992, 0.0031120963394641876, 0.06155214458703995, -0.0008435153285972774, -0.014764299616217613, -0.0024174638092517853, 0.002504243515431881, -0.012124110944569111, -0.0093734385445714, 0.007446885574609041, -0.03659617900848389, 0.002236928092315793, -0.05079836770892143, -0.011026717722415924, 0.01890730671584606, -0.0073879435658454895, 0.015182577073574066, -0.012455962598323822, -0.024953555315732956, 0.014897012151777744, -0.03494846820831299, -0.0073442524299025536, -0.020646095275878906, 0.011173740960657597, -0.005286219995468855, 0.013079150579869747, -0.023151595145463943, -0.022476881742477417, 0.05215459316968918, 0.025914721190929413, -0.004001761320978403, 0.004432188346982002, 0.08961568772792816, 0.00039626925718039274, 0.04871627688407898, -0.0005660519236698747, -0.022646905854344368, 0.04595306143164635, 0.02558225207030773, -0.01942574791610241, -0.007605087943375111, -0.003034949069842696, -0.07705908268690109, -0.03804697096347809, -0.03251101076602936, 0.03989318385720253, 0.03138148784637451, 0.024990953505039215, 0.059838779270648956, 0.06052185595035553, -0.008646871894598007, 0.002563560614362359, -0.02911381796002388, 0.017147144302725792, -0.011089637875556946, 0.007812496740370989, 0.07743409276008606, -0.029236622154712677, 0.011393098160624504, 0.049427568912506104, 0.04848269000649452, 0.044956859201192856, 0.03289426863193512, 0.019828595221042633, 0.05979926139116287, 0.03966841474175453, -0.005998340900987387, -0.042992278933525085, 0.006331677082926035, -0.01728913001716137, 0.018245764076709747, -0.033510565757751465, -0.0013335306430235505, 0.03207479044795036, 0.017380474135279655, 0.0026209629140794277, -0.07381100952625275, -0.01865655742585659, -0.03115934506058693, 0.0014662683242931962, 0.03655541315674782, -0.009106570854783058, 0.029720956459641457, 0.012589567340910435, 0.0046337866224348545, 0.01897392049431801, 0.007672639563679695, -0.04396030306816101, -0.057978834956884384, -0.027280684560537338, -0.02401157096028328, -0.03748209774494171, 0.05478857085108757, -0.027804182842373848, -0.02893519401550293, -0.004796597640961409, -0.024319931864738464, -0.012732688337564468, -0.007781386841088533, 0.006169936154037714, 0.012497130781412125, 0.08437121659517288, 0.009338940493762493, 0.04138430207967758, -0.01155182160437107, -0.013981875963509083, 0.11797134578227997, 0.08667760342359543, 0.026540623977780342, -0.033288706094026566, 0.029191352427005768, 0.028123125433921814, 0.03415888920426369, -0.001958848675712943, 0.04052960127592087, 0.013921800069510937, -0.00185344647616148, 0.04787812754511833, 0.08349499851465225, 0.037982288748025894, -0.02919990010559559, 0.05743727087974548, -0.027927326038479805, 0.01768367737531662, 0.0397532694041729, 0.0014474388444796205, -0.017887970432639122, -0.0369868129491806, 0.011718204244971275, 0.03802688419818878, -0.019930928945541382, -0.019064536318182945, -0.04083961993455887, -0.0073405541479587555, 0.006914008408784866, 0.02137250266969204, 0.013581981882452965, 0.009535232558846474, -0.019028732553124428, 0.015236379578709602, -0.021858027204871178, -0.020993530750274658, 0.025063887238502502, -0.048515476286411285, -0.01835002563893795, 0.040531646460294724, 0.024385927245020866, -0.017180319875478745, 0.010577832348644733, 0.01497756876051426, -0.04318922013044357, -0.021556785330176353, -0.03336087241768837, 0.03691662475466728, -0.0057319640181958675, -0.020269881933927536, -0.010690378956496716, -0.008289859630167484, -0.022698326036334038, -0.04388235881924629, -0.0306477602571249, -0.041992273181676865, 0.01828787289559841, -0.01149335689842701, -0.0028965428937226534, -0.014610848389565945, 0.034970179200172424, 0.013607373461127281, 0.04524962231516838, 0.024108340963721275, -0.011679138988256454, -0.0364038310945034, -0.004638948477804661, 0.024551818147301674, -0.037183742970228195, -0.022552616894245148, -0.006273023784160614, 0.029684990644454956, -0.042926814407110214, 0.0024934508837759495, -0.0013676144881173968, 0.004556819796562195, 0.05161350220441818, -0.010577289387583733, 0.013192311860620975, 0.00172001076862216, -0.023134419694542885, 0.0029930463060736656, -0.012162202969193459, -0.02436407096683979, 0.008304895833134651, -0.035539574921131134, 0.02804676443338394, 0.04888926073908806, -0.027915509417653084, -0.008548731915652752, 0.00566362589597702, 0.03982122242450714, 0.014444082044064999, -0.062127090990543365, -0.018423518165946007, 0.007340860087424517, -0.06835488229990005, 0.008498945273458958, -0.029515311121940613, 0.046521008014678955, 0.016333524137735367, 0.02819780819118023, -0.00835941918194294, 0.0220996905118227, -0.030244817957282066, -0.02101057581603527, -0.05919241905212402, -0.05906642973423004, -0.004880494903773069, -0.004175660200417042, -0.008496486581861973, -0.015897316858172417, -0.013305380940437317, -0.04890534281730652, -0.013534718193113804, 0.04903218895196915, -0.00659779692068696, -0.009498625993728638, 0.001303688739426434, 0.004200962372124195, -0.034736067056655884, -0.020357361063361168, 0.041490472853183746, -0.03607529401779175, -0.011097037233412266, 0.016143137589097023, -0.0124281644821167, 0.0011410583974793553, 0.002195770386606455, -0.021537302061915398, -0.022783545777201653, 0.02938096411526203, -0.0033568304497748613, 0.022223014384508133, 0.02415338344871998, -0.004160740412771702, 0.012963894754648209, 0.026953527703881264, -0.02220979705452919, -0.00429561035707593, 0.0548195019364357, -0.047235604375600815, -0.030038857832551003, 0.06544209271669388, 0.012414393946528435, 0.013658902607858181, 0.0023493303451687098, 0.005968101788312197, 0.005423538386821747, 0.04184359684586525, -0.05084160342812538, -0.0413527674973011, -0.029281536117196083, -0.019635779783129692, -0.009124182164669037, -0.000353410403477028, 0.005727142561227083, 0.019317274913191795, -0.0008101803250610828, 0.05533779785037041, 0.05869394168257713, -0.00027014248189516366, -0.00198994018137455, -0.030592365190386772, 0.02549549750983715, 0.023293351754546165, -0.0022865801583975554, -0.01532836351543665, 0.020536158233880997, 0.06617899239063263, -0.044474851340055466, 0.010832062922418118, -0.04401716962456703, 0.03492189571261406, -0.07468156516551971, -0.009178731590509415, -0.009755013510584831, 0.037283193320035934, -0.002612384734675288, -0.05784240737557411, 0.003930952399969101, 0.028713852167129517, -0.05930117145180702, -0.008863121271133423, -0.024895552545785904, -0.012469977140426636, -0.048187192529439926, 0.002446305938065052, -0.011117079295217991, 0.004132770001888275, 0.0009675411274656653, 0.0011053404305130243, -0.000044069805881008506, 0.024552758783102036, 0.005785169079899788, -0.021781573072075844, -0.04341324418783188, 0.02977941371500492, 0.015537365339696407, -0.05312945693731308, 0.02641294151544571, -0.015867218375205994, -0.05239088460803032, 0.007520441897213459, -0.04505879431962967, 0.013701209798455238, 0.0019705737940967083, 0.02828225865960121, 0.007746818475425243, 0.033105578273534775, 0.00967373140156269, -0.01569889858365059, -0.012982669286429882, -0.00461224652826786, 0.009414487518370152, 0.041504718363285065, -0.020700907334685326, 0.014510351233184338, 0.02773447148501873, -0.01503533124923706, -0.015101962722837925, -0.0027521930169314146, -0.02970515377819538, -0.04333817586302757, 0.0027788584120571613, -0.0376160703599453, 0.03325255215167999, -0.02653622440993786, -0.006782658863812685, -0.010038299486041069, -0.025764113292098045, 0.05417013168334961, 0.03022157773375511, -0.020349005237221718, 0.004867439158260822, -0.026672156527638435, -0.04035978391766548, 0.03794135898351669, -0.013991494663059711, -0.0029206499457359314, -0.06766127049922943, 0.00554467411711812, -0.055125780403614044, 0.0010336788836866617, 0.0035136190708726645, -0.006571728270500898, 0.0037427032366394997, 0.023397967219352722, -0.003933019936084747, 0.017319412901997566, 0.0014123687287792563, -0.013812882825732231, 0.0018114754930138588, -0.09937255829572678, 0.07186917215585709, -0.0016937927575781941, 0.020769484341144562, -0.03986216336488724, -0.0032561342231929302, -0.040041323751211166, 0.024561885744333267, 0.03604854643344879, 0.05025617033243179, 0.002013307297602296, 0.009498565457761288, 0.0005068444879725575, -0.01803012751042843, -0.03164301812648773, 0.036206942051649094, 0.04848584160208702, -0.021858632564544678, 0.00452131824567914, -0.011440962553024292, 0.04948801547288895, -0.003298529190942645, -0.011156605556607246, -0.026974687352776527, 0.016969189047813416, 0.0021225009113550186, 0.006741937715560198, -0.003243292449042201, 0.018910575658082962, -0.009209814481437206, 0.044701606035232544, -0.005706180352717638, -0.01835378259420395, 0.020249387249350548, 0.012171479873359203, -0.04772380739450455, 0.03323150426149368, -0.015240512788295746, 0.009102318435907364, 0.023468907922506332, 0.03383495286107063, -0.003162470180541277, -0.04594232141971588, -0.013731159269809723, 0.01603080704808235, -0.0193630363792181, -0.011326760984957218, 0.049860358238220215, 0.04711977019906044, 0.01055130548775196, -0.03855406865477562, 0.013138099573552608, -0.017398880794644356, -0.004375937394797802, 0.02349521778523922, -0.011357774026691914, 0.019825264811515808, 0.034846384078264236, 0.0009601219207979739, 0.03232605755329132, -0.02420859970152378, 0.03141041100025177, -0.017270928248763084, 0.035815536975860596, -0.010269011370837688, -0.03286631032824516, -0.00010317379201296717, 0.015259324572980404, 0.012844451703131199, 0.015840357169508934, 0.01189738791435957, 0.04985244199633598, -0.025576548650860786, -0.0060980250127613544, -0.020676925778388977, -0.007414364721626043, 0.02251206710934639, 0.01499524712562561, 0.027828799560666084, 0.028544073924422264, 0.014025585725903511, 0.005418037995696068, 0.012304470874369144, -0.013736034743487835, 0.0014221054734662175, -0.025757823139429092, 0.010113008320331573, -0.031066417694091797, -0.00821441225707531, 0.003738022642210126, -0.012675099074840546, -0.019611435011029243, 0.037398453801870346, 0.0187382772564888, 0.03299141302704811, 0.03348039835691452, -0.018235590308904648, -0.04913773387670517, 0.024164974689483643, 0.03196578845381737, -0.05034862458705902, -0.027123205363750458, -0.04610442370176315, -0.006323710083961487, 0.02925184741616249, -0.008075111545622349 ]
<p>So I am given the following question</p> <blockquote> <p>Data set sample5.txt has a 20-dimensional input $x$ in $\mathbb{R}^{20}$ but we suspect that many of these are actually irrelevant. Could you model the function $y = f(x)$ while - at the same time - figuring which dimensions contribute to the output?</p> </blockquote> <p>So it is a feature selection task - I understand that. But I'm sort of confused by the </p> <blockquote> <p>at the same time</p> </blockquote> <p>part. I know many feature selection algorithms but they do not actually produce models for the data, they just produce decisions regarding which features are important and which are not. Conversely, a model (alone) doesn't really give much information regarding which features are important and which are not.</p> <p>Perhaps you could do simple linear regression and then select features based on the weights (but I have never heard of anyone doing this). Or do you think that I am over-analyzing the question and what I should do is simply do feature selection first, then create the model? </p>
36,518
[ -0.024445675313472748, 0.005576767027378082, 0.014281104318797588, 0.0036244108341634274, 0.04129372164607048, -0.012900019995868206, -0.02990894205868244, -0.01650838926434517, 0.03220648318529129, -0.01162764336913824, -0.0017249470110982656, 0.01719869300723076, 0.06569505482912064, 0.015151482075452805, 0.01808776706457138, 0.012766256928443909, -0.014730346389114857, -0.0157527644187212, -0.0007223120192065835, 0.010112455114722252, -0.021887904033064842, 0.042741984128952026, 0.03231118991971016, -0.02548990398645401, -0.02592439018189907, 0.07837372273206711, 0.009467635303735733, 0.0033080652356147766, 0.022044813260436058, 0.012529177591204643, -0.02794935554265976, -0.0016914228908717632, 0.008035605773329735, 0.06296106427907944, 0.03983667492866516, -0.018093574792146683, -0.01339660119265318, -0.026750368997454643, 0.016875971108675003, 0.0291217602789402, -0.022472918033599854, -0.027301769703626633, 0.026672987267374992, 0.01239038910716772, -0.0034431677777320147, 0.03308878839015961, -0.0003081168106291443, -0.01145439688116312, 0.02439170889556408, -0.05670781433582306, 0.0987386554479599, 0.02112461067736149, 0.03302742540836334, 0.06189649924635887, 0.0219720508903265, 0.005052884109318256, 0.04082192853093147, 0.09682169556617737, -0.005189472809433937, -0.04098765179514885, -0.017552269622683525, 0.0046119075268507, 0.00413968600332737, -0.009258782491087914, -0.04615013301372528, 0.03695732355117798, -0.0005597475101239979, -0.007790414150804281, 0.04597249999642372, -0.028634047135710716, -0.0041329809464514256, -0.0018654230516403913, 0.013157904148101807, -0.013524052686989307, -0.009502050466835499, -0.004120643716305494, -0.00020279882301110774, 0.007996814325451851, 0.03092465177178383, 0.016651716083288193, 0.007399657275527716, 0.0002696065348573029, 0.0077808452770113945, 0.028923379257321358, 0.02124728634953499, 0.009043307043612003, 0.06010384112596512, -0.02655099518597126, 0.04877733439207077, -0.011762453243136406, -0.013739013113081455, -0.007002661004662514, 0.034453216940164566, 0.008689168840646744, -0.010515646077692509, 0.037541698664426804, 0.0031758886761963367, 0.004671085625886917, 0.02811412140727043, -0.016849521547555923, -0.018165215849876404, -0.035803113132715225, -0.0023154551163315773, 0.038562752306461334, -0.03156560659408569, 0.009462520480155945, -0.01705637387931347, -0.01654670760035515, -0.0159634817391634, -0.0185093991458416, -0.02558024600148201, 0.04126624017953873, -0.009372820146381855, -0.03224429860711098, 0.04818503186106682, 0.016710897907614708, 0.022939415648579597, -0.013189888559281826, 0.05549471825361252, 0.09091833233833313, -0.0015422602882608771, -0.050183944404125214, 0.029659390449523926, -0.024616461247205734, -0.03134452551603317, -0.017499050125479698, -0.0038628624752163887, -0.030264800414443016, -0.01670914515852928, 0.05064311996102333, 0.0036674649454653263, -0.02206859551370144, 0.023029984906315804, 0.010782717727124691, 0.03488253057003021, 0.012374300509691238, -0.09006735682487488, -0.05489003285765648, 0.058685705065727234, -0.06734925508499146, 0.007962079718708992, -0.028055274859070778, -0.026261158287525177, 0.014072136953473091, 0.06274440884590149, 0.026347175240516663, 0.047236207872629166, 0.03901148587465286, 0.02700454369187355, -0.009902852587401867, 0.004185615107417107, -0.01182286161929369, -0.025953494012355804, -0.015366433188319206, 0.006375730503350496, -0.085773766040802, -0.006920651067048311, 0.017094630748033524, -0.01020090188831091, 0.00684501463547349, -0.0038287900388240814, 0.023630291223526, -0.01757834665477276, 0.0389409065246582, 0.004349788185209036, -0.0397631898522377, 0.06983283162117004, 0.02170642279088497, 0.06893014162778854, 0.015351059846580029, 0.013481687754392624, -0.00010125202243216336, 0.019441578537225723, 0.056923314929008484, 0.04031520336866379, 0.024085216224193573, -0.019990742206573486, -0.008085093460977077, 0.015420304611325264, -0.0027058871928602457, -0.023708518594503403, -0.057289909571409225, 0.0004917078767903149, -0.0043458957225084305, 0.017239905893802643, 0.05269357189536095, 0.021702826023101807, -0.03609156236052513, 0.031827643513679504, -0.04694756120443344, -0.040360499173402786, -0.02652047574520111, 0.012973678298294544, -0.041638538241386414, 0.0074396925047039986, 0.0022961555514484644, -0.015413647517561913, 0.00748410215601325, -0.00821033027023077, -0.02681347355246544, -0.013576269149780273, -0.00026781370979733765, 0.032758940011262894, -0.013353620655834675, -0.014379105530679226, 0.02176319994032383, 0.05284040793776512, -0.030878402292728424, 0.03757529705762863, -0.048386089503765106, -0.06338415294885635, 0.007625495083630085, -0.024208873510360718, 0.007966208271682262, -0.04086216539144516, -0.032419510185718536, 0.013453657738864422, -0.007857613265514374, -0.0363943874835968, 0.02517339214682579, -0.05684914067387581, 0.08611702173948288, 0.0607963390648365, 0.012135045602917671, 0.003755725221708417, 0.022065473720431328, 0.04344364255666733, 0.048428718000650406, 0.013961589895188808, -0.026879392564296722, -0.041341111063957214, -0.009640536271035671, 0.03747805580496788, 0.014811142347753048, -0.040206070989370346, 0.017374392598867416, 0.0629279837012291, 0.03454768285155296, 0.0016035308362916112, 0.01950082555413246, -0.012765028513967991, 0.020443156361579895, 0.02214539609849453, 0.001692049903795123, 0.008453989401459694, -0.0034849706571549177, 0.004534379579126835, 0.01625742018222809, 0.04128309711813927, -0.006384017877280712, 0.0027964746113866568, 0.06986547261476517, -0.009602381847798824, 0.005592194385826588, -0.017892416566610336, -0.013235950842499733, 0.032368600368499756, -0.04037833958864212, -0.006627361290156841, 0.030744776129722595, 0.010812276974320412, 0.006043122615665197, 0.011164571158587933, -0.004504199139773846, -0.0070778923109173775, 0.004998007323592901, -0.027162032201886177, 0.02001125179231167, 0.030062751844525337, -0.05780617892742157, 0.009231838397681713, 0.005497728008776903, -0.016976373270154, -0.029897987842559814, 0.03482929617166519, 0.07690081000328064, 0.001009780098684132, 0.02179745025932789, -0.020707720890641212, -0.04963066428899765, 0.006530847400426865, -0.04120868444442749, 0.019184963777661324, 0.007326948922127485, -0.0544302724301815, 0.003257604781538248, -0.080476313829422, -0.004914045799523592, 0.03779909014701843, -0.05612250417470932, 0.007279997691512108, 0.003560618031769991, 0.015064818784594536, -0.021066585555672646, -0.03482959419488907, -0.05353797227144241, 0.06800690293312073, 0.007535585667937994, -0.037050437182188034, 0.014171802438795567, -0.006409547757357359, -0.0501532256603241, 0.019199464470148087, -0.03831063210964203, -0.06406538933515549, -0.025032026693224907, 0.010509682819247246, -0.013776609674096107, -0.006168595049530268, -0.007774478290230036, 0.04781216382980347, -0.034876249730587006, -0.003212583251297474, -0.06570446491241455, -0.042679786682128906, 0.0034840665757656097, -0.017836622893810272, 0.018877578899264336, 0.018734486773610115, 0.009951687417924404, 0.05749228224158287, 0.051533959805965424, -0.06355193257331848, -0.05060426518321037, 0.017990415915846825, -0.05782507732510567, -0.03248806670308113, 0.0055040293373167515, 0.021020634099841118, 0.01985950954258442, 0.0005960850394330919, 0.005894738249480724, -0.008393978700041771, 0.056175120174884796, -0.003807350993156433, 0.008249221369624138, 0.017873715609312057, 0.001696276944130659, -0.009530247189104557, -0.015188869088888168, 0.02082250826060772, -0.0034621325321495533, 0.0025807837955653667, -0.031959984451532364, 0.0188754852861166, 0.03190845251083374, -0.04042874649167061, 0.00538702541962266, -0.02337721362709999, 0.020176300778985023, -0.02269721031188965, -0.005497338250279427, -0.012096441350877285, -0.0058400374837219715, 0.00466048251837492, 0.02966509759426117, 0.03793693333864212, -0.0326615534722805, -0.018453406170010567, 0.032050054520368576, 0.02664799802005291, -0.022240787744522095, 0.02300002984702587, -0.022197352722287178, -0.013378562405705452, 0.0091886967420578, 0.01093021035194397, -0.0196714885532856, 0.03683720529079437, 0.04910309612751007, 0.016669662669301033, 0.0035815048031508923, -0.06287738680839539, 0.022871768102049828, -0.05082446709275246, 0.007595062721520662, 0.012105518020689487, 0.07024151086807251, 0.01802108809351921, 0.027782540768384933, -0.004083066247403622, -0.006873948033899069, -0.004683620296418667, -0.021718259900808334, -0.058539509773254395, 0.03643601015210152, -0.021193325519561768, 0.03815421462059021, 0.008567067794501781, -0.021862056106328964, 0.04738848656415939, -0.02676488645374775, -0.0004637849924620241, -0.011866690590977669, 0.038760047405958176, -0.052669744938611984, 0.037703145295381546, -0.0347149595618248, -0.01850954256951809, -0.022733792662620544, 0.03199077397584915, 0.03989497944712639, -0.032226886600255966, 0.018348349258303642, 0.025525176897644997, -0.011908140033483505, -0.0013901698403060436, -0.012188034132122993, 0.00603059958666563, 0.019913015887141228, 0.0545416995882988, -0.009843707084655762, 0.03323834389448166, -0.029467083513736725, 0.03599627688527107, -0.0043217879720032215, 0.04316147044301033, 0.00865743588656187, -0.016715779900550842, 0.0027840454131364822, -0.05241233855485916, -0.0029836054891347885, -0.008304168470203876, 0.013692228123545647, -0.007231434807181358, -0.01830482855439186, 0.06626798957586288, -0.004140765871852636, -0.04290511831641197, -0.006314151920378208, 0.061351656913757324, 0.05196520686149597, -0.024058805778622627, -0.022035107016563416, 0.006849144119769335, -0.01019833143800497, -0.010142332874238491, 0.01814079098403454, -0.010053384117782116, -0.013209403492510319, -0.008734348230063915, 0.021270977333188057, -0.031526047736406326, -0.03114391677081585, -0.002198093803599477, 0.0025479712057858706, 0.06750847399234772, -0.010300391353666782, -0.03343939036130905, 0.012590628117322922, 0.035920724272727966, 0.02872161753475666, 0.022717924788594246, 0.005002222023904324, -0.09101613610982895, -0.012079780921339989, 0.012974519282579422, 0.04414582997560501, -0.045208171010017395, -0.006013238336890936, -0.01574034057557583, -0.019034655764698982, 0.06038818508386612, -0.01067427359521389, 0.04057468846440315, -0.026829680427908897, 0.0120848985388875, -0.015873050317168236, -0.004031256306916475, -0.03442081809043884, -0.007403824012726545, -0.017007574439048767, 0.042439915239810944, -0.026226796209812164, -0.03611144796013832, -0.04967138543725014, 0.020792361348867416, -0.011211645789444447, 0.04337991774082184, -0.01804520934820175, -0.017888596281409264, 0.00021695629402529448, 0.02672869898378849, 0.009044635109603405, -0.07428643852472305, -0.01924086920917034, 0.03267216309905052, -0.023202108219265938, 0.0410330630838871, -0.005656183697283268, -0.0865476131439209, 0.026307111606001854, 0.026491623371839523, -0.012938795611262321, -0.0022981353104114532, -0.016845660284161568, 0.02718711458146572, 0.03193933144211769, 0.021186819300055504, 0.054722610861063004, 0.04041029140353203, -0.01702486164867878, 0.00013920165656600147, -0.022778602316975594, 0.01113449689000845, -0.011091338470578194, -0.02276299148797989, -0.047626107931137085, -0.004107317421585321, -0.037142232060432434, 0.019745662808418274, 0.019788557663559914, 0.02299042046070099, 0.0028251127805560827, 0.00510035827755928, -0.007951721549034119, 0.020261824131011963, -0.019979488104581833, -0.058549683541059494, 0.0014103970024734735, 0.026918858289718628, -0.03546703979372978, 0.006013062316924334, -0.00650267256423831, 0.024003006517887115, 0.015994440764188766, 0.009338323958218098, 0.006793387234210968, -0.009663636796176434, -0.03451006859540939, -0.004209896549582481, 0.011914190836250782, -0.03830385580658913, 0.03822696581482887, 0.004327343311160803, 0.02174861915409565, 0.0009801583364605904, -0.07913435250520706, 0.016061602160334587, -0.0028287561144679785, 0.038068778812885284, -0.008504622615873814, -0.021760202944278717, 0.04629898816347122, -0.054308634251356125, 0.0056837378069758415, -0.06816128641366959, -0.0341285839676857, -0.0055727409198880196, 0.0024874904192984104, -0.022255072370171547, -0.05191134288907051, 0.034939493983983994, -0.04355614632368088, -0.031801044940948486, -0.010484367609024048, 0.038728997111320496, -0.02153419889509678, -0.009735574945807457, 0.033256854861974716, 0.018365683034062386, 0.06473040580749512, 0.0037885846104472876, -0.019278906285762787, 0.029695812612771988, -0.005055392626672983, 0.026776941493153572, 0.0029750114772468805, 0.006233741529285908, -0.03984144330024719, 0.005998899694532156, -0.061385318636894226, 0.017208820208907127, 0.024754757061600685, -0.0007307688356377184, 0.00015197070024441928, 0.0339621976017952, -0.014879847876727581, -0.008828437887132168, -0.024194497615098953, 0.016038944944739342, -0.010324390605092049, -0.01030152477324009, -0.010007175616919994, 0.00949237309396267, -0.00090992875630036, -0.029205238446593285, 0.04776648059487343, -0.010479932650923729, 0.007795083336532116, 0.029709352180361748, 0.04387848824262619, 0.005592467729002237, 0.024980129674077034, -0.023848213255405426, -0.024416225031018257, 0.04153810441493988, -0.031383272260427475, 0.0007365511264652014, 0.01110414881259203, 0.04467357322573662, -0.04305942729115486, -0.03989141061902046, -0.044325243681669235, 0.019949842244386673, 0.06383763998746872, -0.04096882790327072, 0.07483012229204178, 0.052656423300504684, -0.02921598218381405, 0.007167885545641184, -0.03923055902123451, -0.02867613546550274, -0.02893589437007904, 0.0057310075499117374, 0.06979624181985855, 0.03349253907799721, -0.018033431842923164, 0.043402619659900665, -0.010897938162088394, 0.03449371084570885, 0.05049068480730057, -0.0037074293941259384, 0.004303627647459507, 0.02594023197889328, -0.033185895532369614, -0.05993269383907318, -0.006577631924301386, -0.036007657647132874, -0.000026874387913267128, 0.003829154884442687, -0.03417956456542015, 0.043278951197862625, 0.035701870918273926, 0.017009248957037926, -0.05383475124835968, -0.010727747343480587, -0.036747414618730545, 0.003712743055075407, 0.038485389202833176, -0.010578961111605167, 0.016350679099559784, 0.021568547934293747, -0.0010180294048041105, 0.002742848824709654, 0.007869377732276917, -0.021056391298770905, -0.08299652487039566, -0.0399971604347229, -0.038234464824199677, -0.05032346770167351, 0.05044642835855484, 0.002518212655559182, -0.019168803468346596, 0.02799469791352749, -0.053056057542562485, 0.0228126160800457, 0.004625947214663029, 0.05588319152593613, -0.024092938750982285, 0.044698767364025116, -0.004932025447487831, -0.011632842943072319, 0.0069291917607188225, 0.02149191126227379, 0.1054600179195404, 0.11391966044902802, 0.040890883654356, -0.06948138028383255, 0.0036309794522821903, -0.02086770161986351, -0.033473409712314606, -0.016907138749957085, 0.008412966504693031, -0.012598841451108456, 0.002662219339981675, 0.015046347863972187, 0.04217424988746643, 0.01515205204486847, -0.0082493145018816, 0.042640578001737595, -0.06982670724391937, -0.0332174189388752, -0.009341918863356113, -0.01753172278404236, 0.00452739093452692, -0.009653983637690544, -0.04548824578523636, 0.023691948503255844, -0.0026744131464511156, -0.013351697474718094, -0.00256228051148355, -0.015236581675708294, -0.023128589615225792, -0.025023294612765312, -0.022249724715948105, -0.0009074274566955864, 0.018093304708600044, 0.017547285184264183, -0.014320787973701954, 0.061009909957647324, -0.00006950407259864733, -0.03086104802787304, -0.012638297863304615, 0.00856977328658104, -0.017586208879947662, -0.0077093360014259815, -0.010505769401788712, 0.016100041568279266, -0.045263830572366714, -0.03337280452251434, -0.052299294620752335, 0.017750337719917297, 0.008304370567202568, 0.005211996380239725, -0.006661133375018835, 0.030788958072662354, 0.024145420640707016, -0.03986562788486481, -0.02167988196015358, 0.00032600315171293914, 0.05394257232546806, -0.003407691838219762, -0.013393816538155079, -0.0014889411395415664, 0.028728339821100235, 0.009569303132593632, 0.04443947225809097, 0.050880953669548035, -0.048825666308403015, -0.009766113013029099, 0.013171005062758923, 0.060572199523448944, 0.007314467802643776, 0.03420790657401085, -0.03562069311738014, 0.0008832615567371249, -0.029864491894841194, -0.01683320850133896, 0.04691721126437187, 0.001242306549102068, 0.022446079179644585, -0.038124553859233856, -0.03311774134635925, -0.013550820760428905, -0.04051573574542999, 0.01267498079687357, -0.0002811450103763491, 0.008868994191288948, -0.06893741339445114, 0.021457010880112648, -0.011184502393007278, 0.06157379597425461, 0.04411322996020317, -0.026944484561681747, 0.01864536479115486, 0.021013425663113594, -0.010741941630840302, -0.034687209874391556, -0.011073661968111992, -0.009308833628892899, -0.02316908910870552, 0.0362459234893322, -0.00203226157464087, 0.05460089072585106, 0.03740254044532776, 0.025059519335627556, -0.03680852800607681, 0.07623922824859619, -0.03419727832078934, 0.007133880630135536, -0.003567999228835106, -0.03427895903587341, 0.014967639930546284, 0.008487126789987087, -0.01213102601468563, -0.06140368804335594, -0.038059551268815994, -0.02449716068804264, -0.04256603121757507, 0.042415279895067215, -0.00847097858786583, -0.03516950085759163, 0.026805032044649124, 0.004532579332590103, 0.02065056562423706, -0.045018985867500305, 0.0025184268597513437, -0.054545462131500244, 0.017702613025903702, 0.022976234555244446, -0.03709781914949417, -0.007947776466608047, -0.01038738340139389, -0.024102646857500076, 0.007683113217353821, -0.016745999455451965, -0.0018969494849443436, -0.0034305849112570286, -0.006499637383967638, 0.018053840845823288, 0.0002652119437698275, 0.04587124288082123, -0.01344222854822874, 0.0018659933703020215, 0.015684334561228752, -0.04930834844708443, 0.0010412137489765882, 0.03735136613249779, -0.05186513066291809, 0.04204694926738739, 0.02631571516394615, 0.002639136044308543, -0.0007543376996181905, 0.04451657459139824, -0.008253765292465687, -0.0015534160193055868, -0.005908064544200897, 0.011286386288702488, -0.022834310308098793, -0.002324007684364915, 0.008286884054541588, -0.011433478444814682, -0.027547013014554977, 0.009087692946195602, 0.027410946786403656, 0.01630365662276745, -0.050641924142837524, 0.021058524027466774, 0.013593406416475773, 0.029781457036733627, -0.012159130536019802, -0.022097643464803696, 0.023294178768992424, 0.01807902380824089, -0.04423203319311142, 0.04433099925518036, 0.030893094837665558, 0.013979393057525158, -0.1116403117775917, -0.02866430953145027, 0.027200711891055107, 0.01737068220973015, 0.02581150457262993, -0.07952958345413208, 0.006925986614078283, 0.01776633970439434, -0.06228005513548851, 0.006468513514846563, 0.013946733437478542, 0.010079669766128063, -0.009118996560573578, 0.02296195924282074, -0.04164448752999306, -0.016807066276669502, 0.0240275077521801, 0.030202915892004967, 0.03723413124680519, 0.03943382203578949, 0.01948179304599762, 0.001960107823833823, -0.006434331648051739, 0.024670029059052467, -0.012117537669837475, -0.03726277872920036, 0.06333427876234055, -0.01734250970184803, -0.034057747572660446, 0.016198134049773216, 0.0024071098305284977, 0.016485827043652534, 0.011295744217932224, 0.006181614473462105, 0.024267390370368958, 0.05093730613589287, 0.05980915576219559, -0.03876557573676109, 0.012654743157327175, 0.019316302612423897, 0.0033936367835849524, -0.013048723340034485, -0.018424948677420616, 0.027106355875730515, 0.01624351553618908, -0.021424464881420135, -0.0019046362722292542, -0.005224690772593021, -0.006837304215878248, -0.012203811667859554, 0.014388070441782475, -0.016905363649129868, -0.003427745308727026, -0.032052524387836456, 0.019151581451296806, -0.057558540254831314, -0.012704112567007542, -0.002421356737613678, 0.0009738400694914162, -0.02797897346317768, -0.0007515700999647379, -0.009740779176354408, -0.0778915211558342, 0.0011716311564669013, 0.019084857776761055, -0.026571746915578842, -0.05987488105893135, 0.0002726007951423526, 0.03873133286833763, -0.01892164908349514, -0.017916182056069374, -0.014484863728284836, -0.052618302404880524, 0.05310263857245445, -0.016687633469700813, 0.050139836966991425, 0.012213196605443954, -0.07657387852668762, 0.017765406519174576, -0.10059107840061188, 0.060640670359134674, 0.033083271235227585, -0.004791087005287409, 0.011618386022746563, -0.004318234510719776, -0.027119947597384453, -0.0067045115865767, 0.04234617203474045, 0.002777768997475505, 0.01983814314007759, -0.024723967537283897, 0.0272798091173172, 0.015967275947332382, -0.029174569994211197, 0.027914436534047127, 0.001595007604919374, -0.015357901342213154, -0.023752136155962944, -0.02060699835419655, 0.025818759575486183, 0.0017602171283215284, 0.031189089640975, 0.013213926926255226, -0.0276723001152277, 0.0217121709138155, 0.0015532239340245724, 0.05290515720844269, 0.031239544972777367, -0.0038670047651976347, 0.03782281652092934, 0.011313925497233868, 0.022272976115345955, 0.023125452920794487, 0.021701619029045105, -0.044707078486680984, 0.013491853140294552, -0.045182764530181885, -0.01144057884812355, 0.022166110575199127, 0.02193376235663891, 0.002522636903449893, -0.051330193877220154, 0.004883936606347561, 0.031920868903398514, -0.010302084498107433, -0.002755814464762807, -0.010078134015202522, 0.019851496443152428, 0.02358982339501381, 0.0011008080327883363, 0.004198235459625721, 0.005435782950371504, -0.027122143656015396, -0.029828209429979324, -0.018988514319062233, 0.05245428904891014, 0.015883661806583405, 0.019287968054413795, 0.031155366450548172, -0.007838253863155842, 0.02472931519150734, -0.023403899744153023, 0.03201791271567345, -0.055944718420505524, -0.0344686321914196, 0.005869546439498663, 0.005920385476201773, -0.014679080806672573, -0.03556673973798752, -0.034046586602926254, 0.0728217139840126, -0.01337366458028555, -0.01692287065088749, -0.04412047564983368, -0.03040512464940548, -0.004961754661053419, 0.012128796428442001, 0.014133522287011147, 0.03507111966609955, 0.014794660732150078, 0.02448422461748123, -0.05401960387825966, -0.0068435268476605415, 0.030733060091733932, -0.03310728445649147, 0.02130848728120327, -0.002111387439072132, -0.008142729289829731, 0.0178631953895092, 0.0010066450340673327, -0.023475412279367447, 0.008819150738418102, 0.030670180916786194, 0.048435382544994354, 0.027974480763077736, -0.03284149989485741, 0.0009222874650731683, -0.025440720841288567, 0.036312200129032135, -0.049970343708992004, -0.001987961120903492, -0.024337351322174072, -0.012006744742393494, 0.0063507952727377415, -0.006904710549861193 ]
<p>So I realize this has been asked before: e.g. <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/48425/what-are-the-use-cases-related-to-cluster-analysis-of-different-distance-metrics">What are the use cases related to cluster analysis of different distance metrics?</a> but I've found the answers somewhat contradictory to what is suggested should be possible in the literature. </p> <p>Recently I have read two papers that have mention using the kmeans algorithm with other metrics, for example edit distance between strings and the "Earth Mover Distance" between distributions. Given that these papers mention using kmeans with other metrics without specifying <em>how</em>, particularly when it comes to computing the mean of set of points, suggests to me that maybe there is some "standard" method to dealing with this that I'm just not picking up on.</p> <p>Take for example this <a href="http://machinelearning.wustl.edu/mlpapers/paper_files/icml2003_Elkan03.pdf" rel="nofollow">paper</a>, which gives a faster implementation of the k-means algorithm. Quoting from paragraph 4 in the intro the author says his algorithm "can be used with any black box distance metric", and in the next paragraph he mentions edit distance as a specific example. His algorithm however still computes the mean of a set of points and doesn't mention how this might affect results with other metrics (I'm especially perplexed as to how mean would work with edit distance).</p> <p>This other <a href="http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~sganzfri/PotentialAware_AAAI14.pdf" rel="nofollow">paper</a> describes using k-means to cluster poker hands for a texas hold-em abstraction. If you jump to page 2 bottom of lefthand column the author's write "and then k-means is used to compute an abstraction with the desired number of clusters using the Earth Mover Distance between each pair of histograms as the distance metric".</p> <p>I'm not really looking for someone to explain these papers to me, but am I missing some standard method for using k-means with other metrics? Standard averaging with the earth mover distance seems like it could work heuristically, but edit distance seems to not fit the mold at all. I appreciate any insight someone could give.</p> <p><strong>(edit)</strong>: I went ahead and tried k-means on distribution histograms using the earth mover distance (similar to what is in the poker paper) and it seemed to have worked fine, the clusters it output looked pretty good for my use case. For averaging I just treated the histograms as vectors and averaged in the normal way. The one thing that I noticed is the sum over all points of the distances to the means did not always decrease in a monotone manner. In practice though, it would settle on a local min within 10 iterations despite monotone issues. I'm going to assume that this is what they did in the second paper, the only question that remains then is, how the heck would you average when using something like edit distance?</p>
49,393
[ -0.05061928927898407, -0.009628839790821075, 0.010140590369701385, -0.021846270188689232, 0.015644891187548637, 0.03311095014214516, 0.014585853554308414, -0.022034497931599617, -0.039219629019498825, -0.016106467694044113, 0.039700932800769806, 0.027871936559677124, 0.05447078123688698, 0.038740918040275574, 0.01717684417963028, -0.03547000139951706, -0.004086360801011324, 0.013347134925425053, 0.009681283496320248, -0.026358110830187798, 0.032374802976846695, 0.016850706189870834, 0.00938743818551302, -0.018640177324414253, -0.005750818178057671, 0.003431613789871335, -0.0023658843711018562, -0.04119903966784477, 0.0026767882518470287, 0.01694761961698532, -0.0227382592856884, -0.020519092679023743, 0.036800604313611984, 0.010145206935703754, -0.012851046398282051, 0.007302831392735243, -0.011813042685389519, -0.04719608277082443, -0.016661511734128, 0.005443253088742495, -0.05545562505722046, 0.008626185357570648, -0.005708320531994104, 0.03646257147192955, -0.03642984852194786, 0.039027873426675797, -0.0414884053170681, -0.04914809390902519, -0.027487292885780334, -0.013402136042714119, 0.08209279924631119, -0.00743417302146554, -0.01636277511715889, 0.021310463547706604, -0.033586304634809494, 0.004090769682079554, 0.04687276855111122, 0.06472395360469818, 0.007859674282371998, -0.06424426287412643, 0.0019958550110459328, -0.018823299556970596, 0.00870036706328392, -0.027702808380126953, -0.007308632135391235, 0.016009386628866196, -0.00048828008584678173, -0.020647350698709488, 0.03043055161833763, -0.028790602460503578, 0.00615261634811759, 0.008684140630066395, 0.013761031441390514, -0.005117017775774002, 0.028580542653799057, -0.01883186586201191, -0.020864689722657204, 0.02449921891093254, 0.0580139234662056, 0.04265748709440231, 0.020154088735580444, -0.012277316302061081, 0.04732881858944893, 0.0016461018240079284, 0.012985724955797195, 0.029143862426280975, 0.09117486327886581, -0.02781013585627079, 0.011006813496351242, 0.03831658884882927, -0.0072813136503100395, -0.03174489736557007, 0.024937696754932404, -0.010188445448875427, -0.027911998331546783, 0.023576948791742325, -0.021168699488043785, 0.04067007079720497, -0.008893406018614769, -0.02110905759036541, -0.004808126017451286, -0.04762409254908562, 0.014457548037171364, 0.028838714584708214, 0.024059472605586052, -0.010923605412244797, -0.03823060542345047, 0.007470787037163973, -0.049115560948848724, 0.00388948991894722, -0.01453948300331831, 0.0203617624938488, 0.011779666878283024, -0.008871915750205517, 0.0003537299344316125, -0.012817601673305035, 0.010020232759416103, 0.015956314280629158, 0.026222264394164085, 0.05625664442777634, 0.017990199849009514, -0.049483347684144974, 0.015553995966911316, -0.024729352444410324, -0.03556885942816734, 0.015999790281057358, 0.03737805783748627, -0.01572467014193535, -0.026971079409122467, 0.03682733327150345, -0.013055720366537571, 0.011924232356250286, 0.02261781319975853, 0.005736636929214001, 0.023854756727814674, 0.021056313067674637, -0.0950695127248764, -0.04068847373127937, 0.06210928410291672, 0.017090391367673874, 0.04332392290234566, -0.025493372231721878, -0.04040777310729027, -0.00351753830909729, 0.01309515256434679, 0.027739644050598145, -0.0034295048099011183, -0.0033901508431881666, 0.026256855577230453, 0.013010378926992416, -0.027905376628041267, -0.028918342664837837, -0.04862825199961662, -0.018231157213449478, -0.011288835667073727, -0.06281296163797379, 0.03126567602157593, 0.04266106337308884, -0.026130640879273415, 0.01414406020194292, 0.022539502009749413, 0.03435163199901581, 0.0012364644790068269, 0.007215602323412895, -0.015944866463541985, 0.00020390648569446057, 0.07378829270601273, 0.01814958266913891, 0.026656709611415863, -0.022398900240659714, -0.028351351618766785, 0.033752430230379105, -0.003011023160070181, -0.00946895033121109, 0.041388045996427536, -0.012054366059601307, -0.010950724594295025, -0.027075722813606262, 0.01611500233411789, 0.018163461238145828, -0.0100620798766613, -0.04478692635893822, 0.01332376804202795, -0.009114529937505722, 0.04680493846535683, 0.01799377053976059, -0.004936934914439917, 0.02139013260602951, 0.021733103320002556, -0.03339888155460358, -0.036348871886730194, -0.05969001725316048, 0.03506025671958923, -0.008145944215357304, 0.0070050726644694805, 0.0372597873210907, -0.03451961278915405, 0.013907218351960182, -0.00218258798122406, -0.02073318138718605, 0.002261809539049864, -0.03742910549044609, 0.024030394852161407, -0.040794532746076584, -0.029058506712317467, 0.08219832926988602, 0.039342254400253296, 0.009626544080674648, 0.019096864387392998, -0.06615076959133148, -0.07652547955513, -0.01884113810956478, -0.027270158752799034, -0.0033416575752198696, 0.012843075208365917, 0.008156000636518002, 0.022797301411628723, 0.015558847226202488, -0.057605400681495667, -0.025756945833563805, -0.057799916714429855, 0.06740737706422806, 0.04638109728693962, 0.006443618331104517, 0.022173546254634857, 0.01734078675508499, 0.009200735948979855, 0.017407748848199844, 0.01196748111397028, -0.00873694196343422, -0.04844021797180176, -0.04458720609545708, 0.05275990441441536, 0.019000105559825897, -0.04199957475066185, -0.01128978468477726, 0.04451669380068779, 0.06453417986631393, -0.0286099910736084, -0.0012492636451497674, -0.014269145205616951, -0.010768010281026363, 0.046362753957509995, 0.025910887867212296, 0.01224157027900219, -0.014766096137464046, 0.02645888552069664, -0.031584881246089935, 0.007443752605468035, -0.004716264083981514, -0.0017691882094368339, 0.035109661519527435, 0.0334462895989418, 0.01271673385053873, -0.008186066523194313, -0.0008409885922446847, 0.03560023754835129, -0.020335746929049492, -0.0006645594839937985, 0.03095848858356476, 0.01817554049193859, 0.022687004879117012, 0.0035968248266726732, -0.043772805482149124, 0.003565929364413023, 0.040274422615766525, -0.01581430621445179, 0.012072891928255558, 0.010905434377491474, -0.030426880344748497, 0.052295081317424774, -0.0059202201664447784, -0.03663181886076927, -0.02616472728550434, 0.008490486070513725, -0.0026893827598541975, 0.013596877455711365, -0.003389081684872508, -0.045921824872493744, 0.015892749652266502, -0.012707321904599667, 0.0103893568739295, -0.004870033357292414, -0.0067106857895851135, -0.048739612102508545, 0.004566332325339317, -0.03603491559624672, -0.004427650477737188, -0.009975278750061989, -0.016544679179787636, -0.023437337949872017, 0.005797605495899916, 0.025100883096456528, -0.039630498737096786, -0.0005723852082155645, 0.010112404823303223, 0.03198336437344551, -0.033080000430345535, -0.028196295723319054, 0.04563440755009651, 0.040143586695194244, -0.06750708818435669, 0.02745060808956623, -0.001666623167693615, -0.04594103619456291, -0.050540756434202194, -0.02403327077627182, 0.031119564548134804, -0.02738068997859955, -0.011807374656200409, 0.024286044761538506, -0.028317319229245186, -0.00486309127882123, -0.07021980732679367, -0.07971371710300446, 0.031952716410160065, -0.03342875465750694, 0.06063338741660118, -0.007826044224202633, -0.042127739638090134, 0.07546868175268173, 0.021437814459204674, -0.010833408683538437, -0.048629280179739, 0.004030050244182348, -0.032444603741168976, 0.005960584152489901, 0.012496475130319595, 0.004316410515457392, -0.013642728328704834, -0.009183171205222607, 0.013091188855469227, 0.04704846441745758, 0.08827725052833557, -0.02349943108856678, -0.023981621488928795, -0.0089784050360322, -0.017155373468995094, -0.011623035185039043, 0.05364616587758064, 0.0054653724655508995, -0.036878861486911774, 0.013226088136434555, 0.024267928674817085, 0.0007297208067029715, 0.011788489297032356, -0.053084515035152435, 0.026476547122001648, -0.0016397124854847789, -0.0012953178957104683, -0.030559919774532318, 0.026715893298387527, 0.002794410102069378, -0.051901184022426605, 0.005611720960587263, 0.019819527864456177, 0.03594160079956055, -0.011714363470673561, -0.011429100297391415, 0.03905652090907097, 0.036498311907052994, -0.019517557695508003, 0.008438531309366226, -0.005093986634165049, -0.028717856854200363, 0.00958937220275402, -0.0323747843503952, 0.0026271753013134003, 0.008777347393333912, 0.04909105598926544, -0.021843653172254562, 0.015501566231250763, -0.04847992956638336, -0.003124306444078684, -0.06626513600349426, 0.013349066488444805, -0.06578581780195236, 0.030584128573536873, -0.019811125472187996, 0.01357781607657671, -0.0022001906763762236, -0.029866019263863564, -0.03291073441505432, -0.0029791370034217834, -0.04604656994342804, -0.023512836545705795, -0.055260468274354935, -0.0031295442022383213, 0.012018055655062199, -0.05217491835355759, 0.033218782395124435, 0.016606025397777557, 0.019225196912884712, -0.013871661387383938, 0.023455854505300522, -0.04437904804944992, 0.0006285856943577528, -0.02520548738539219, -0.03318595141172409, -0.0013915058225393295, -0.013740555383265018, 0.048561155796051025, -0.012201921083033085, 0.043240293860435486, -0.001567208208143711, 0.003506934968754649, -0.04255133122205734, -0.00693378085270524, 0.02657764032483101, 0.032614611089229584, -0.003025254001840949, -0.029969511553645134, 0.016607876867055893, -0.0068439943715929985, 0.03209191933274269, 0.02184044010937214, 0.039020054042339325, 0.025499094277620316, -0.04616500064730644, 0.0019102816004306078, -0.035860490053892136, -0.047284215688705444, 0.007389730773866177, 0.04573787376284599, -0.026460489258170128, 0.0014635203406214714, 0.01713964156806469, 0.04353533312678337, -0.04757143557071686, -0.006910101976245642, 0.04022595286369324, 0.03835747018456459, -0.03183921054005623, -0.07523445039987564, -0.027138881385326385, 0.019428066909313202, -0.020159224048256874, 0.001415383885614574, 0.013412531465291977, 0.01670852303504944, 0.010334388352930546, 0.05218653008341789, -0.021963173523545265, -0.04012778773903847, -0.009357994422316551, 0.034437090158462524, -0.012914766557514668, -0.04552282392978668, 0.0055553545244038105, 0.03445827215909958, 0.05427149683237076, 0.061949294060468674, -0.003173695644363761, 0.024247433990240097, -0.0823625847697258, -0.006330379284918308, 0.05118956416845322, 0.039533212780952454, 0.019723672419786453, 0.033912982791662216, -0.03211527690291405, 0.0034882042091339827, 0.008544664829969406, -0.021674958989024162, 0.07905834168195724, -0.0323149748146534, 0.004278329201042652, -0.028472984209656715, -0.02687782421708107, -0.04935072734951973, 0.013062448240816593, 0.008230430074036121, 0.04920393228530884, -0.023603104054927826, 0.003417982952669263, -0.02697419933974743, 0.025647884234786034, 0.026564467698335648, 0.04688628017902374, -0.027629228308796883, -0.000583567307330668, 0.018675779923796654, -0.003482657019048929, -0.028781114146113396, -0.08461479097604752, 0.020657991990447044, 0.02024337649345398, 0.006035732105374336, 0.04225194826722145, -0.003037631046026945, -0.05406493693590164, 0.03609437867999077, 0.023484954610466957, -0.01716451160609722, -0.014784581959247589, -0.025213100016117096, 0.05195889249444008, 0.08947048336267471, 0.00440353574231267, 0.0609821155667305, 0.009456817060709, -0.008620996959507465, 0.05650565028190613, -0.05387488380074501, 0.007214859127998352, -0.021854432299733162, -0.003302628407254815, -0.03796486556529999, -0.020221665501594543, -0.0503002405166626, 0.016160832718014717, -0.0410391241312027, 0.04809979721903801, -0.03504951670765877, -0.012413880787789822, -0.014843028970062733, -0.01070683915168047, -0.01073318999260664, -0.00015709639410488307, -0.004174073692411184, 0.05290708318352699, 0.015564631670713425, 0.0007315193652175367, 0.047439511865377426, 0.016530806198716164, 0.02440395951271057, 0.010844988748431206, -0.005076493602246046, -0.035666573792696, -0.04934457316994667, -0.006124360021203756, 0.04491237923502922, 0.002127773826941848, 0.06410866975784302, -0.030112456530332565, 0.01732911728322506, 0.05019530653953552, -0.015470256097614765, -0.011742944829165936, -0.028455480933189392, -0.04272649064660072, 0.00025925133377313614, -0.022622739896178246, 0.01290088053792715, 0.016954733058810234, -0.0027283497620373964, -0.05823568254709244, -0.008294434286653996, -0.007593752350658178, -0.043222732841968536, -0.007550176698714495, -0.053369857370853424, 0.009937371127307415, 0.028319615870714188, -0.040887393057346344, -0.01133816596120596, 0.06752488017082214, -0.001772074494510889, -0.023061485961079597, 0.011266583576798439, 0.0353870652616024, 0.06026773527264595, 0.022588742896914482, 0.0006291205645538867, 0.03311963751912117, 0.010525312274694443, -0.015767760574817657, 0.011505099944770336, 0.044380348175764084, -0.023713216185569763, -0.0007429734687320888, -0.031711578369140625, 0.010395007207989693, 0.019131559878587723, -0.03532892465591431, -0.009434585459530354, -0.003949903417378664, 0.01123255304992199, 0.028394687920808792, -0.03505758196115494, -0.016762658953666687, 0.010480720549821854, 0.005126835312694311, -0.030130654573440552, -0.00483036320656538, 0.018201062455773354, 0.011005282402038574, 0.020325416699051857, -0.006559234112501144, -0.006856953259557486, -0.016268623992800713, 0.07996270060539246, -0.007779258769005537, -0.020285656675696373, 0.015567729249596596, -0.04680353403091431, 0.06713782995939255, -0.03359905257821083, -0.016099829226732254, 0.0017903243424370885, 0.02403632365167141, -0.012999100610613823, -0.01878863386809826, -0.01185879111289978, -0.007240639999508858, 0.059625718742609024, 0.05401795357465744, 0.03536533564329147, 0.0450315997004509, -0.05085943639278412, 0.016594525426626205, -0.03896592929959297, 0.004828761797398329, -0.03919706493616104, -0.0028992323204874992, 0.07751787453889847, 0.015725869685411453, 0.01148082036525011, 0.036587852984666824, 0.012547475285828114, -0.020605280995368958, 0.013711253181099892, 0.026615768671035767, 0.05025335028767586, -0.00034965600934810936, -0.05204102769494057, -0.01627996563911438, 0.050835270434617996, -0.06811277568340302, 0.022325605154037476, -0.01895698346197605, -0.023324308916926384, 0.03419928997755051, 0.05123012140393257, -0.0034976915922015905, -0.024913106113672256, -0.020158113911747932, -0.06425878405570984, 0.020211942493915558, -0.022269409149885178, -0.013538233004510403, 0.0772588923573494, -0.019611136987805367, 0.034808624535799026, 0.003170321462675929, -0.008958647027611732, -0.04778647422790527, -0.03372064605355263, -0.009356425143778324, -0.026970256119966507, -0.05649992451071739, 0.009773277677595615, 0.026308167725801468, -0.0478527657687664, 0.03805848956108093, -0.009749354794621468, 0.04341501370072365, -0.0157763734459877, -0.008348584175109863, -0.02469753287732601, 0.07310711592435837, 0.009342271834611893, 0.04222143068909645, -0.011659801006317139, -0.0239239651709795, 0.1321902573108673, 0.05821286886930466, 0.03096824884414673, -0.04201429337263107, 0.04062924161553383, -0.0019334339303895831, 0.0228276327252388, -0.03239905834197998, -0.01238769106566906, -0.0009257970959879458, 0.006217179354280233, -0.005482750944793224, 0.027553392574191093, 0.009358607232570648, -0.021961759775877, 0.04266081377863884, -0.04429411515593529, -0.025116052478551865, 0.02035229653120041, 0.00713561475276947, -0.0015305652050301433, -0.02275797165930271, -0.0733828917145729, 0.038332391530275345, 0.02683779038488865, -0.0068753985688090324, -0.0075940280221402645, -0.01657797209918499, -0.005066098645329475, 0.003167590359225869, 0.028962938115000725, -0.005405460949987173, -0.0018779572565108538, -0.06320877373218536, 0.0011202526511624455, -0.00956042855978012, 0.03837628290057182, -0.04143502563238144, 0.03197859600186348, 0.03447146713733673, 0.00937731098383665, -0.009059194475412369, -0.0017493185587227345, 0.009162254631519318, -0.04627775400876999, -0.005473277997225523, -0.06123974919319153, 0.03482430428266525, -0.0011634886031970382, 0.03843121603131294, -0.004520879127085209, -0.010084806010127068, 0.029872136190533638, -0.03490382060408592, 0.01892697438597679, -0.0025901792105287313, 0.037651192396879196, 0.02447902038693428, -0.012025146745145321, -0.025262095034122467, 0.01794392801821232, 0.008273670449852943, 0.01903870515525341, 0.014521545730531216, -0.00020805574604310095, -0.04208412393927574, -0.015668483451008797, 0.013162125833332539, -0.007980813272297382, -0.040024496614933014, -0.08429383486509323, 0.009841003455221653, -0.0002527564356569201, 0.002622063737362623, -0.0005932751810178161, -0.010390891693532467, 0.06143882870674133, 0.011769306845963001, -0.002333301119506359, -0.0276351198554039, -0.055982280522584915, 0.026736948639154434, -0.021997300907969475, -0.012851034291088581, -0.03404198959469795, -0.024007746949791908, 0.03389192372560501, 0.05336569622159004, 0.043328456580638885, 0.03296805918216705, 0.020180389285087585, 0.03754341974854469, 0.012251888401806355, -0.007068872917443514, -0.0028303691651672125, 0.002293715486302972, -0.05604076385498047, 0.00476835947483778, -0.023224467411637306, 0.06122609227895737, 0.025840675458312035, -0.010082758031785488, 0.005739555694162846, 0.02602027915418148, -0.006669597700238228, 0.021845955401659012, -0.004157110583037138, -0.03489679843187332, -0.003268500091508031, 0.002850142540410161, -0.01870397850871086, -0.013992861844599247, -0.004543066956102848, 0.008013571612536907, -0.060730382800102234, 0.023667430505156517, -0.020536581054329872, -0.04583289846777916, -0.004068145994096994, -0.03070065565407276, 0.0028390251100063324, -0.04073115438222885, -0.007631882559508085, -0.010531466454267502, -0.007854530587792397, -0.05789172649383545, 0.007144126109778881, -0.007350051775574684, 0.027713743969798088, -0.0013127068523317575, 0.06202542036771774, 0.05250084400177002, 0.01533076073974371, 0.036892492324113846, 0.002116688061505556, -0.030262604355812073, -0.024170758202672005, 0.031076950952410698, -0.039232220500707626, -0.01519002765417099, 0.05367936193943024, -0.0648263543844223, -0.004281490575522184, 0.027861448004841805, 0.0017062819097191095, 0.020995579659938812, 0.0005053866771049798, -0.0022293489892035723, -0.03269185498356819, 0.025518100708723068, -0.015467183664441109, -0.02269277162849903, -0.026994675397872925, -0.01244649663567543, 0.029267482459545135, 0.001233768300153315, 0.012503238394856453, 0.02499854937195778, -0.0313471183180809, -0.018621603026986122, -0.006945302244275808, -0.005867382511496544, -0.018611088395118713, 0.009553009644150734, -0.004790446255356073, -0.007994255051016808, -0.030806411057710648, -0.006366384215652943, 0.06625457853078842, 0.031812798231840134, -0.006038281600922346, 0.046496376395225525, -0.026938872411847115, -0.0017145954770967364, -0.050896238535642624, 0.013113655149936676, 0.010027335025370121, 0.03364992514252663, 0.06974370777606964, -0.0742945745587349, 0.02143412083387375, 0.01032967958599329, -0.07496767491102219, 0.036580272018909454, -0.013414940796792507, -0.007179077714681625, -0.0732957199215889, 0.02154598943889141, 0.0032828187104314566, 0.010900106281042099, 0.0282916110008955, 0.018919026479125023, 0.009297332726418972, 0.010647827759385109, -0.023456132039427757, -0.024293329566717148, -0.016105497255921364, 0.022320406511425972, 0.029776789247989655, -0.023059701547026634, 0.02844797447323799, -0.04887588694691658, -0.011920907534658909, -0.005957574117928743, -0.021862005814909935, 0.0027740150690078735, 0.029433459043502808, 0.014578953385353088, 0.020064113661646843, 0.04000766575336456, 0.03121941164135933, -0.023583175614476204, 0.03937119245529175, -0.02868608944118023, -0.007962660863995552, 0.03208106383681297, 0.0019601467065513134, 0.008145194500684738, 0.03460968658328056, -0.022807709872722626, -0.012243334203958511, 0.002403878141194582, -0.04826504364609718, -0.04185023531317711, 0.0160833653062582, 0.027232129126787186, 0.014463444240391254, -0.0010004331124946475, 0.012883665971457958, 0.0021414016373455524, -0.030167194083333015, 0.066850446164608, 0.04216478392481804, -0.0155827971175313, 0.03013702481985092, -0.010450847446918488, -0.059671200811862946, 0.017760133370757103, -0.012190258130431175, -0.008979573845863342, -0.05020315945148468, 0.0005773675511591136, -0.007100880146026611, 0.021075531840324402, -0.03079739212989807, 0.011010422371327877, 0.005610110703855753, 0.01806480810046196, -0.026087064296007156, 0.020311998203396797, 0.016690397635102272, 0.010423784144222736, 0.019295306876301765, -0.07623207569122314, 0.05421300604939461, 0.007229930721223354, -0.016255993396043777, -0.009595886804163456, -0.009671212173998356, -0.01057602558284998, -0.009498891420662403, 0.04579376429319382, 0.024492938071489334, -0.0002638784353621304, 0.0005865455605089664, -0.0036167309153825045, 0.020963186398148537, -0.06979271024465561, 0.03969461843371391, -0.03343653306365013, -0.007203470449894667, 0.024261029437184334, -0.012741346843540668, -0.004294916521757841, 0.019247081130743027, 0.04393831640481949, -0.024812590330839157, -0.00592037895694375, 0.01335461251437664, -0.024851350113749504, 0.03542178124189377, 0.021894967183470726, -0.030076773837208748, 0.0040986137464642525, 0.0059005930088460445, -0.0110835712403059, 0.02917829528450966, -0.03561108186841011, -0.017162291333079338, 0.0404260978102684, -0.047483958303928375, -0.030605297535657883, 0.02570950984954834, 0.004299623426049948, 0.027095288038253784, -0.028120284900069237, -0.03847546502947807, 0.03877141326665878, 0.007123883813619614, -0.008348469622433186, 0.044790077954530716, 0.027038967236876488, 0.02258201129734516, 0.03259256109595299, 0.0391540601849556, 0.009947825223207474, -0.03822283819317818, 0.014264807105064392, 0.008046478033065796, 0.027972236275672913, 0.02699284255504608, -0.021607454866170883, -0.00013617947115562856, 0.012935733422636986, 0.05768268182873726, 0.002378435805439949, 0.04400172829627991, 0.015517575666308403, 0.01292008999735117, 0.011510970070958138, 0.014445890672504902, 0.006841936148703098, 0.031446147710084915, -0.012452878057956696, 0.0803905576467514, 0.0013959581265226007, -0.025743214413523674, -0.011962275952100754, -0.01742992363870144, -0.005089171230792999, -0.004977671429514885, 0.014349514618515968, -0.005363406613469124, 0.009764187969267368, 0.006200452335178852, -0.020208917558193207, 0.039743900299072266, 0.03864891082048416, -0.03725052997469902, 0.056629423052072525, -0.022089404985308647, 0.023332519456744194, 0.04873708263039589, -0.052862171083688736, 0.008096097968518734, 0.000009570188922225498, 0.02470482513308525, 0.03797091916203499, 0.02747855708003044, 0.007862558588385582, -0.01596379466354847, -0.01890641637146473, 0.06663651019334793, -0.08181643486022949, -0.02554233931005001, -0.06125352159142494, 0.0048995730467140675, -0.0059000286273658276, -0.007070557214319706 ]
<p>In a representative sample of country population I have very few missing data, around 3%. But when I checked the missing data among communities, I found that one of them has almost 30% of data lost. That's consistent in all ages.</p> <p>Should I try to impute the data, remove that community from the analysis, or keep all the communities but warn the reader about this possible bias?</p>
73,950
[ -0.08317723870277405, -0.0015202945796772838, -0.013465270400047302, -0.0037359516136348248, 0.04234767705202103, 0.009508813731372356, -0.03000730462372303, -0.007565021980553865, 0.012453692965209484, -0.017523663118481636, 0.02817470207810402, 0.0430452935397625, 0.03359001874923706, 0.004626649431884289, -0.0019450464751571417, 0.03165627643465996, -0.01717868633568287, 0.022380195558071136, -0.0038249006029218435, -0.01781565323472023, -0.016330646350979805, 0.014726242981851101, -0.0000297809747280553, -0.015474960207939148, -0.05248634144663811, 0.01266747247427702, 0.031692419201135635, -0.007410628721117973, 0.009081071242690086, 0.011639482341706753, -0.028872530907392502, -0.031041927635669708, -0.006727753672748804, 0.015209134668111801, 0.024544179439544678, 0.024483956396579742, -0.037879422307014465, -0.023746972903609276, 0.013024596497416496, 0.047068364918231964, -0.030867960304021835, -0.012705093249678612, 0.009314055554568768, 0.008324612863361835, -0.02677830122411251, 0.03423132002353668, 0.008419742807745934, -0.010202721692621708, 0.005223652347922325, 0.01653662696480751, 0.023498360067605972, -0.0042533851228654385, 0.02702508494257927, 0.0141927944496274, -0.02312360890209675, -0.016620133072137833, 0.05248662456870079, 0.05217661336064339, 0.030202386900782585, -0.054111938923597336, -0.022752178832888603, -0.010646078735589981, -0.01832561008632183, -0.003361252835020423, -0.01625734195113182, 0.041655104607343674, 0.0009126461227424443, -0.01295529305934906, 0.046032387763261795, -0.012236510403454304, 0.02410731092095375, 0.02748464047908783, 0.0051635331474244595, 0.010691552422940731, 0.027606016024947166, -0.025353720411658287, -0.012138829566538334, 0.04436426982283592, 0.02044856734573841, 0.015913769602775574, 0.014389985240995884, -0.013963436707854271, 0.0573774091899395, 0.029406385496258736, 0.006180328316986561, -0.023617055267095566, 0.08811827749013901, -0.02624446339905262, -0.01751486025750637, 0.01034245640039444, 0.0008094027871266007, -0.020140206441283226, -0.0010551700834184885, 0.0013556800549849868, -0.037102267146110535, 0.03067513182759285, -0.04155818745493889, 0.052516136318445206, -0.002964526182040572, -0.0038725356571376324, -0.0018935184925794601, -0.0012528980150818825, 0.027178147807717323, 0.03927575796842575, -0.02324371226131916, 0.018399342894554138, -0.04368788003921509, -0.012722708284854889, -0.05505780130624771, -0.017356839030981064, -0.022435158491134644, 0.011751449666917324, 0.005573723465204239, 0.02380933240056038, 0.053372517228126526, 0.008405499160289764, 0.028192933648824692, -0.01363795343786478, 0.05094539001584053, 0.05317619815468788, 0.04054499417543411, -0.005303310230374336, 0.017211591824889183, -0.02138722687959671, -0.050725843757390976, 0.020434590056538582, 0.019619163125753403, -0.053402129560709, -0.05658784508705139, 0.01649554632604122, 0.018387705087661743, -0.0030142045579850674, 0.04150472953915596, -0.026467304676771164, 0.0526578463613987, 0.027584362775087357, -0.10728105902671814, -0.045697130262851715, 0.006349898409098387, -0.0017591688083484769, 0.011117568239569664, -0.03811029717326164, -0.017394226044416428, 0.00006084044434828684, 0.05357595160603523, -0.011694611050188541, 0.020219063386321068, 0.044631946831941605, 0.06240710988640785, -0.001244943356141448, -0.007103006821125746, -0.0065367817878723145, -0.02992565743625164, -0.0057492926716804504, -0.0245229322463274, -0.05622948333621025, 0.050141602754592896, 0.06599839776754379, 0.0011055170325562358, -0.00188056833576411, 0.02707696333527565, 0.00770671246573329, -0.02460447885096073, 0.0050481571815907955, 0.013721220195293427, -0.02405437082052231, 0.06609946489334106, -0.009595739655196667, 0.0308596920222044, 0.012550367042422295, 0.008729001507163048, 0.07663827389478683, 0.04157079756259918, 0.03089888021349907, 0.04688123241066933, -0.024701515212655067, 0.01665864698588848, 0.022120987996459007, -0.021014397963881493, 0.026976503431797028, -0.08049346506595612, -0.04904022440314293, 0.03489520028233528, 0.007717058062553406, 0.0316811241209507, 0.023061342537403107, 0.011941347271203995, -0.03393632546067238, 0.07799611240625381, -0.045054394751787186, -0.047484140843153, -0.055605314671993256, 0.01520664431154728, 0.010695049539208412, -0.014527730643749237, 0.01881861500442028, 0.00352653325535357, 0.011331746354699135, -0.05317651852965355, -0.025103460997343063, -0.008345616981387138, -0.0370674692094326, 0.04760127142071724, -0.03326203674077988, -0.019150136038661003, 0.024750562384724617, 0.00743972510099411, 0.004470216576009989, 0.037479549646377563, -0.005208995658904314, -0.03807029128074646, 0.011943561024963856, -0.022443220019340515, 0.0359385721385479, -0.0391937792301178, -0.0040154536254704, -0.022835852578282356, -0.003787353867664933, -0.03416484221816063, 0.024655232205986977, -0.025349069386720657, 0.060399480164051056, 0.016696549952030182, -0.02590123936533928, -0.04039511829614639, -0.0006615492748096585, -0.01391812413930893, 0.026137830689549446, -0.03029930405318737, -0.005330867134034634, -0.09826023131608963, -0.009651225060224533, 0.018313219770789146, -0.003967478405684233, -0.041997477412223816, 0.008814273402094841, 0.03450353443622589, 0.020831825211644173, -0.0174896027892828, -0.012618138454854488, -0.003743773093447089, -0.05799934267997742, 0.007555285934358835, -0.00524403341114521, 0.00691034784540534, 0.03819311410188675, 0.0009118065354414284, -0.01940043270587921, -0.026212744414806366, -0.02072935551404953, 0.011194461956620216, 0.04517591372132301, 0.003952110186219215, 0.015534170903265476, -0.018178675323724747, -0.017582014203071594, 0.0021301470696926117, -0.055245425552129745, 0.03072316199541092, 0.006701075937598944, -0.03309216350317001, -0.01283595897257328, 0.006619365885853767, -0.003146957606077194, -0.01029633916914463, 0.03455137461423874, -0.04326219484210014, 0.01579022780060768, 0.03397709131240845, -0.03357304632663727, -0.01942414976656437, -0.029010970145463943, -0.050191480666399, -0.047174494713544846, 0.03555239737033844, 0.05424953252077103, 0.007607836741954088, 0.002548179356381297, -0.019747570157051086, -0.03493654355406761, -0.0075659905560314655, 0.029875576496124268, 0.0038713449612259865, 0.04231207072734833, -0.0443241223692894, -0.012373484671115875, -0.005812263116240501, 0.013026469387114048, 0.04324214905500412, 0.011526825837790966, -0.0035795108415186405, 0.026153186336159706, 0.039361290633678436, -0.03366079181432724, -0.03318382799625397, 0.006613160949200392, 0.02142498269677162, 0.010730613023042679, -0.017841346561908722, 0.02582823485136032, 0.024812927469611168, -0.02073442004621029, 0.0034589674323797226, -0.029931139200925827, -0.05014807730913162, -0.005785404238849878, -0.005283363629132509, 0.011567777022719383, -0.0015718108043074608, -0.02372109703719616, -0.0016734631499275565, -0.01721605658531189, 0.0030939762946218252, -0.07192014157772064, -0.10866528004407883, 0.05662212893366814, -0.016389019787311554, 0.04370447248220444, 0.005165246315300465, 0.027950003743171692, 0.09071926772594452, 0.04567180946469307, -0.018871517851948738, -0.011775974184274673, -0.05205577239394188, -0.012860127724707127, -0.014861357398331165, 0.0035996921360492706, 0.02369528077542782, 0.024920722469687462, -0.02590099349617958, -0.023811155930161476, 0.05232326313853264, 0.05443624034523964, -0.0003234972828067839, 0.013263383880257607, 0.001558683579787612, -0.00528810266405344, -0.021303704008460045, 0.027631210163235664, 0.041044387966394424, -0.021524174138903618, -0.024358918890357018, -0.05658089742064476, 0.0720813199877739, 0.013077596202492714, -0.06911556422710419, -0.018218912184238434, -0.05460198596119881, 0.03219415992498398, -0.03723910078406334, 0.01847855933010578, 0.0429152175784111, -0.0004861757915932685, 0.00793981272727251, 0.01253487914800644, 0.04003521800041199, -0.008617039769887924, -0.015393577516078949, 0.07662377506494522, 0.03181201592087746, 0.035866398364305496, 0.001734997727908194, 0.000016424095520051196, 0.014683892019093037, 0.03942665457725525, 0.020772362127900124, 0.0016699242405593395, 0.02141692116856575, 0.046097129583358765, 0.020137332379817963, -0.036045707762241364, -0.06142120808362961, 0.03271928429603577, -0.07889170944690704, 0.03858458623290062, -0.003914015833288431, 0.04824003577232361, -0.028164392337203026, -0.0012785395374521613, -0.010617191903293133, 0.030663343146443367, -0.03813990205526352, 0.02362532913684845, -0.062126100063323975, -0.024396782740950584, -0.006761821918189526, 0.02913036197423935, -0.03929217904806137, 0.00036327829002402723, 0.04987293481826782, 0.027419229969382286, -0.0121995210647583, -0.024585209786891937, 0.00905429944396019, -0.03234143555164337, 0.038861244916915894, -0.011797377839684486, 0.0017281225882470608, 0.00909513421356678, -0.005438488908112049, 0.045722413808107376, 0.004098107572644949, 0.03135121241211891, 0.055319853127002716, 0.03920536860823631, -0.06581196188926697, -0.04689650982618332, 0.00827300176024437, 0.023409677669405937, 0.027555691078305244, 0.014988986775279045, 0.010688160546123981, -0.06737875193357468, 0.008471202105283737, -0.01622379571199417, -0.002571035409346223, 0.010602186433970928, 0.0026169470511376858, -0.006084560416638851, -0.018434418365359306, -0.02110864222049713, 0.0013519097119569778, 0.02072311006486416, -0.006734512280672789, 0.008927782066166401, 0.02637137845158577, 0.04257325828075409, -0.06629521399736404, 0.02189483307301998, 0.02163105271756649, 0.033865202218294144, 0.013987540267407894, -0.02253940887749195, 0.0070698936469852924, -0.01508419495075941, 0.0024648236576467752, 0.003717297688126564, 0.000789811194408685, -0.0036257777828723192, -0.02890034392476082, 0.058955658227205276, 0.014857579953968525, -0.0294942706823349, 0.021632680669426918, 0.011337258853018284, 0.030081667006015778, 0.006723862607032061, -0.02322547324001789, 0.05427203327417374, 0.040251534432172775, 0.02904360555112362, 0.05577383190393448, -0.02037792094051838, -0.09807215631008148, 0.014878371730446815, 0.034444600343704224, 0.03143332153558731, -0.00040471518877893686, 0.005414303857833147, -0.06952456384897232, 0.01626076176762581, 0.012762586586177349, -0.004664589650928974, 0.011216742917895317, -0.002245232928544283, 0.00009631054126657546, -0.018143601715564728, -0.05637410283088684, 0.030046949163079262, -0.014967011287808418, -0.0010966744739562273, 0.03508749604225159, -0.016206324100494385, -0.009164335206151009, -0.032249849289655685, 0.06177574023604393, 0.008056326769292355, 0.07863273471593857, 0.0023311993572860956, -0.001738966559059918, -0.011491643264889717, 0.051687270402908325, -0.02307708002626896, -0.0646754577755928, 0.01276423130184412, -0.022094063460826874, 0.0026374049484729767, 0.057820238173007965, -0.01863711141049862, -0.0689311996102333, -0.00003813181319856085, 0.005326217506080866, -0.05292923003435135, -0.002721982542425394, -0.049199704080820084, 0.03552279993891716, -0.025355154648423195, 0.005246005952358246, 0.040273744612932205, 0.06838736683130264, -0.011848348192870617, -0.002682151971384883, -0.03967666253447533, -0.0036003824789077044, -0.04024398699402809, 0.02304249443113804, -0.03390124812722206, -0.04169084504246712, -0.00801448617130518, -0.009846672415733337, 0.012451636604964733, 0.027861978858709335, -0.00040434321272186935, -0.021072452887892723, 0.011716624721884727, -0.027478504925966263, -0.021163146942853928, 0.04341923072934151, -0.01695019006729126, -0.006972647737711668, -0.015929486602544785, 0.00015122274635359645, 0.06300800293684006, 0.004847184754908085, 0.027402054518461227, 0.00829884223639965, -0.04568127170205116, 0.007260594516992569, -0.06224937364459038, -0.053939782083034515, 0.022167040035128593, -0.02352936565876007, 0.008782150223851204, 0.013763805851340294, 0.06141719967126846, -0.01504137646406889, -0.027041606605052948, -0.010309716686606407, 0.01005709357559681, 0.009267645888030529, 0.06615395098924637, -0.015057453885674477, 0.02724604494869709, -0.01579015515744686, 0.03760598227381706, -0.07044418901205063, -0.0633564442396164, 0.022458449006080627, 0.03562559932470322, -0.033686574548482895, -0.018323494121432304, 0.03473731875419617, -0.0026063877157866955, -0.037042807787656784, 0.013852623291313648, 0.05649915710091591, 0.005848431959748268, -0.028561685234308243, -0.014214360155165195, 0.005758308805525303, 0.09792309254407883, -0.014445521868765354, 0.011465134099125862, 0.012892837636172771, -0.031817078590393066, 0.024639371782541275, -0.05210001394152641, 0.024988384917378426, 0.0048590791411697865, -0.030438557267189026, -0.048451896756887436, 0.011448482051491737, -0.00911661982536316, -0.02037954330444336, -0.02323210798203945, -0.00010160770762013271, -0.02320205233991146, -0.017259618267416954, -0.02235085889697075, 0.017313895747065544, -0.039221737533807755, 0.0016737818950787187, -0.034134820103645325, 0.044558119028806686, -0.005822986364364624, 0.013163887895643711, 0.02738349884748459, 0.0035858191549777985, -0.05716574937105179, 0.02489422634243965, 0.05119128152728081, -0.028750482946634293, 0.0182234738022089, -0.006552976090461016, -0.027069974690675735, 0.048138078302145004, 0.011533129960298538, 0.0007440861081704497, -0.017992867156863213, 0.03914106264710426, -0.022592347115278244, -0.022489462047815323, -0.017417054623365402, 0.009009059518575668, 0.040094442665576935, -0.0018905345350503922, 0.02013331465423107, 0.06490293145179749, 0.00026952108601108193, 0.023158425465226173, 0.0008698789752088487, 0.00200890121050179, 0.01993124932050705, -0.024174390360713005, 0.025872161611914635, 0.0009940669406205416, 0.009771020151674747, 0.03375629335641861, 0.012079841457307339, 0.015096377581357956, 0.039907343685626984, 0.003952378872781992, 0.01050075888633728, -0.015552281402051449, -0.03465360775589943, -0.03434884175658226, -0.027988117188215256, -0.05008074268698692, 0.026405086740851402, -0.025209523737430573, -0.03708856180310249, 0.059912096709012985, 0.006805918179452419, 0.04289250075817108, -0.007637742441147566, -0.003539205528795719, -0.02571783773601055, -0.033920176327228546, -0.004506675526499748, 0.04304061457514763, 0.017132893204689026, -0.021380389109253883, 0.04678688943386078, -0.024141479283571243, 0.027513401582837105, -0.024767087772488594, -0.04747401922941208, -0.0634918138384819, -0.012733068317174911, -0.0023389423731714487, 0.029714342206716537, 0.0061529045924544334, -0.029721634462475777, 0.01756923831999302, 0.006892903242260218, 0.0028544068336486816, 0.008399594575166702, 0.04315005987882614, -0.03677712753415108, 0.028178943321108818, 0.009924017824232578, -0.004167179577052593, 0.006192295346409082, 0.009252423420548439, 0.13302282989025116, 0.06996060907840729, 0.0689544826745987, -0.07801618427038193, 0.036704614758491516, 0.007720187306404114, -0.003772624069824815, 0.013882645405828953, -0.013846815563738346, -0.018239255994558334, -0.011392643675208092, 0.0645812377333641, 0.029088111594319344, 0.033661291003227234, -0.003168265800923109, 0.04264025762677193, -0.06636583805084229, -0.026102745905518532, 0.015359927900135517, -0.000162342912517488, 0.03597903624176979, -0.03820405527949333, -0.04353070259094238, 0.009798780083656311, 0.058418478816747665, -0.018275270238518715, -0.0236713457852602, -0.019195448607206345, -0.013132652267813683, -0.014421055093407631, -0.026813924312591553, 0.01184158120304346, 0.030021758750081062, 0.028657741844654083, -0.010935436002910137, -0.04862075299024582, -0.021969163790345192, -0.03096393309533596, 0.00022236895165406168, 0.010858241468667984, -0.02098456397652626, 0.009876216761767864, 0.014971477910876274, 0.02785172127187252, -0.02309507504105568, -0.03541436418890953, 0.009302332997322083, 0.023154251277446747, -0.02050904370844364, 0.004209683742374182, -0.03632251173257828, -0.007628542371094227, 0.012704395689070225, -0.03970683738589287, -0.03765163570642471, 0.03540145233273506, 0.010558480396866798, 0.0027630950789898634, -0.038397252559661865, 0.018044935539364815, -0.007691593840718269, -0.006414444651454687, -0.0021789749152958393, 0.020795661956071854, -0.010177910327911377, -0.0377354770898819, -0.01498619094491005, 0.017119867727160454, 0.0032882769592106342, 0.041263431310653687, -0.002989723812788725, -0.027963414788246155, -0.010914425365626812, -0.0038033686578273773, -0.008694327436387539, 0.019334638491272926, 0.058187007904052734, -0.018844041973352432, -0.01744684763252735, -0.03544047847390175, -0.06213976815342903, 0.021981967613101006, 0.007297208532691002, -0.002742624143138528, -0.026108376681804657, -0.008621127344667912, -0.015005713328719139, 0.024658162146806717, 0.012492630630731583, 0.025883715599775314, 0.013218495063483715, 0.0658382698893547, -0.021971771493554115, -0.041686367243528366, -0.0028002881444990635, -0.03679615259170532, -0.0845256969332695, 0.017759187147021294, -0.03214585781097412, 0.06590710580348969, -0.005338215734809637, -0.009310777299106121, 0.04653742536902428, 0.04400501772761345, 0.018291648477315903, -0.0017794921295717359, 0.0189611054956913, -0.08116090297698975, 0.002904109191149473, 0.02089345082640648, 0.03095373325049877, -0.045574285089969635, 0.005361596588045359, -0.0056969099678099155, -0.022615177556872368, 0.032197948545217514, -0.00901410449296236, -0.03847651183605194, 0.0526091605424881, -0.00968108233064413, 0.01474720612168312, -0.028944004327058792, -0.010338849388062954, -0.07228299230337143, -0.0517210029065609, -0.015183630399405956, -0.03405878692865372, 0.007145533338189125, -0.01924176700413227, -0.002676725387573242, 0.03968818858265877, 0.005202575121074915, -0.06069136783480644, -0.016331134364008904, 0.02928466536104679, -0.002157597802579403, 0.013658232055604458, 0.048288799822330475, -0.026652280241250992, -0.04428672045469284, 0.027677936479449272, -0.012145362794399261, -0.054952990263700485, 0.01045729499310255, -0.007843307219445705, 0.05231596156954765, -0.009243165142834187, 0.0021479495335370302, -0.0024877479299902916, 0.051406823098659515, -0.02487783133983612, -0.016498761251568794, -0.000771382066886872, 0.03284091874957085, 0.018325701355934143, -0.00010326837218599394, -0.03894522786140442, 0.02851550094783306, -0.02161305956542492, 0.044213760644197464, 0.07959875464439392, 0.020302310585975647, -0.0182754285633564, 0.01354915089905262, 0.005005395971238613, 0.021370982751250267, -0.019951950758695602, 0.010657261125743389, 0.04006413370370865, 0.021629374474287033, -0.02718348428606987, -0.0037932884879410267, 0.007349187973886728, -0.006531002931296825, -0.09648653119802475, -0.0248469989746809, 0.02118533104658127, 0.037751875817775726, -0.001819018041715026, -0.023770306259393692, 0.030304500833153725, 0.020958077162504196, -0.04474065825343132, 0.0353144071996212, 0.019572237506508827, 0.022333882749080658, -0.05186948552727699, 0.029120702296495438, -0.01876283995807171, 0.004348629619926214, 0.027686679735779762, 0.037446971982717514, 0.02529265359044075, 0.04617765173316002, 0.01814088597893715, -0.04801509156823158, -0.044057853519916534, 0.015136666595935822, -0.007106245495378971, -0.016634559258818626, 0.0014449676964432001, -0.013244317844510078, -0.014137379825115204, 0.01782778464257717, -0.015412244014441967, 0.024598078802227974, 0.024055546149611473, 0.018962780013680458, -0.005583886988461018, 0.031328413635492325, 0.040833525359630585, -0.025028347969055176, -0.019344082102179527, 0.01014635618776083, 0.01649521104991436, 0.041298758238554, -0.032618261873722076, 0.03625226020812988, 0.015552648343145847, -0.034354642033576965, 0.007895441725850105, -0.0085070189088583, 0.007951566949486732, 0.022743264213204384, 0.007399715483188629, -0.021577656269073486, 0.0017638602294027805, 0.001338185160420835, -0.020371511578559875, -0.01508816983550787, -0.017342036589980125, 0.06315462291240692, 0.020301563665270805, 0.008278371766209602, 0.01917911134660244, -0.051225464791059494, -0.017126260325312614, -0.005827754735946655, 0.007896150462329388, -0.00733173917979002, -0.024790622293949127, 0.0023085963912308216, 0.01243981346487999, 0.0033103132154792547, -0.030461542308330536, -0.021197615191340446, -0.04835600405931473, 0.02979096584022045, -0.0027930131182074547, -0.03440951183438301, 0.0017890851013362408, -0.036428894847631454, 0.028152506798505783, -0.05067163333296776, 0.04193110764026642, -0.008598871529102325, -0.008342316374182701, -0.03508592024445534, -0.006010627374053001, -0.0036489625927060843, 0.03537057340145111, 0.05361060053110123, -0.03193390369415283, 0.016368072479963303, -0.006831287406384945, 0.0017339932965114713, -0.012589739635586739, -0.022138874977827072, 0.070017509162426, 0.008085887879133224, 0.026972370222210884, 0.0035448535345494747, -0.02146216295659542, -0.021034937351942062, -0.002258158288896084, 0.0185784250497818, 0.004876909777522087, 0.010832875967025757, 0.036385901272296906, 0.03787136450409889, 0.04048570245504379, 0.018085328862071037, -0.025034302845597267, 0.007671091239899397, -0.0029924320988357067, -0.007831940427422523, 0.03177463263273239, -0.016093730926513672, -0.05418767035007477, -0.00012370840704534203, -0.007536436431109905, -0.03526265546679497, 0.020595138892531395, 0.004562667105346918, -0.004217158537358046, -0.022996438667178154, -0.009203804656863213, 0.030191101133823395, -0.00755263539031148, 0.0034184325486421585, 0.0027850624173879623, 0.0001421640336047858, 0.0403398759663105, -0.011102631688117981, 0.014880980364978313, 0.007064989302307367, -0.02325003407895565, 0.016219357028603554, 0.017612937837839127, -0.0029422699008136988, 0.015437589026987553, 0.011245076544582844, 0.014877437613904476, 0.009721068665385246, 0.01433240994811058, -0.009854895994067192, 0.05960628762841225, -0.051677100360393524, -0.003838885109871626, -0.014325612224638462, 0.00474237184971571, 0.010026230476796627, -0.01071077585220337, 0.01107016485184431, 0.036264434456825256, 0.016828134655952454, 0.0009286344284191728, -0.04685753583908081, -0.03799867257475853, -0.019360702484846115, 0.016615740954875946, -0.012465528212487698, 0.023641590029001236, 0.007650021929293871, -0.03226436302065849, -0.03919379040598869, -0.0053328294306993484, 0.03575747832655907, -0.020041562616825104, 0.02773945778608322, -0.01459136325865984, 0.013923447579145432, -0.00029322714544832706, -0.021112389862537384, -0.009832209907472134, -0.0028900704346597195, 0.06487443298101425, 0.047095634043216705, 0.028557486832141876, -0.07101739197969437, -0.048084475100040436, -0.0441790334880352, 0.019215045496821404, -0.045800358057022095, -0.024861276149749756, -0.03812519460916519, 0.023439258337020874, 0.00930298212915659, -0.028949672356247902 ]
<p>I'm new here and have a question regarding ANOVA in R. </p> <p>I have an ANOVA table like this from running <code>anova(model)</code> in R, where <code>model</code> is a multiple linear regression model built with the <code>lm</code> command:</p> <pre><code>Analysis of Variance Table Response: log(price) Df Sum Sq Mean Sq F value Pr(&gt;F) mileage.residual 1 10.79 10.79 733.329 &lt; 2.2e-16 *** model 5 138.31 27.66 1880.427 &lt; 2.2e-16 *** body_type 4 108.87 27.22 1850.269 &lt; 2.2e-16 *** age 1 654.08 654.08 44463.584 &lt; 2.2e-16 *** transmission 1 3.87 3.87 263.416 &lt; 2.2e-16 *** four_wd 1 0.86 0.86 58.718 2.353e-14 *** nav 1 1.41 1.41 96.168 &lt; 2.2e-16 *** fuel 2 2.35 1.17 79.809 &lt; 2.2e-16 *** age:transmission 1 0.79 0.79 53.827 2.719e-13 *** Residuals 3429 50.44 0.01 --- Signif. codes: 0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1 </code></pre> <p>From reading this I have three questions:<br/></p> <ol> <li><p>How is the the model for MS(Model) chosen when calculating the different F-values for the independent variables? Is it the model with only that variable? This leads to the second question.<br/></p></li> <li><p>Are the different F-values comparable? Does it make sense to draw the conclusion that <code>age</code> is by far the strongest predictor among the considered covariates and that <code>model</code> and <code>body_type</code> are of about the same strength? <br/></p></li> <li><p>If I train a new model, but with different data (in this case representing a different car model), does it make sense to compare the Mean Sq(Residuals) as a measure across different R-models of how well the model describes the different car models. That is, if this R-model is first trained with car model A's data and has a MSE of 0.01 (as in the table) and the same R-model is then trained with car model B's data and then has a MSE of 0.1, can I conclude that the R-model is a much better fit for model A than B?</p></li> </ol> <p>This all seems like reasonable things, but I just want to be sure to not jump to any unjustified conclusions.</p> <p>For completeness a summary of the model is shown below:</p> <pre><code>Call: lm(formula = log(price) ~ mileage.residual + model + body_type + age * transmission + four_wd + nav + fuel, data = sample.data) Residuals: Min 1Q Median 3Q Max -0.74556 -0.07250 0.00126 0.07135 0.46688 Coefficients: Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(&gt;|t|) (Intercept) 12.5718774 0.0104270 1205.710 &lt; 2e-16 *** mileage.residual -0.0318929 0.0006863 -46.471 &lt; 2e-16 *** model320 0.0827985 0.0063347 13.071 &lt; 2e-16 *** model325 0.2139785 0.0088962 24.053 &lt; 2e-16 *** model328 0.2689928 0.0137284 19.594 &lt; 2e-16 *** model330 0.2956210 0.0105510 28.018 &lt; 2e-16 *** model335 0.4724337 0.0114792 41.156 &lt; 2e-16 *** body_typecab 0.3254419 0.0102776 31.665 &lt; 2e-16 *** body_typecoupe 0.1200356 0.0087123 13.778 &lt; 2e-16 *** body_typehatchback 0.1082495 0.0096499 11.218 &lt; 2e-16 *** body_typestation_wagon 0.0165039 0.0054116 3.050 0.00231 ** age -0.1588759 0.0013296 -119.491 &lt; 2e-16 *** transmissionautomatic 0.1061707 0.0076932 13.801 &lt; 2e-16 *** four_wdTRUE 0.0478496 0.0067139 7.127 1.25e-12 *** navTRUE 0.0567863 0.0061501 9.233 &lt; 2e-16 *** fueldiesel 0.0910481 0.0067196 13.550 &lt; 2e-16 *** fuelelectric 0.0309334 0.0471583 0.656 0.51190 age:transmissionautomatic -0.0113273 0.0015439 -7.337 2.72e-13 *** --- Signif. codes: 0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1 Residual standard error: 0.1213 on 3429 degrees of freedom Multiple R-squared: 0.9481, Adjusted R-squared: 0.9478 F-statistic: 3684 on 17 and 3429 DF, p-value: &lt; 2.2e-16 </code></pre> <p>Thank you very much!</p>
73,951
[ -0.019856253638863564, -0.0007503125816583633, -0.02025553025305271, 0.030621647834777832, 0.025603441521525383, 0.0029360654298216105, 0.008168159984052181, -0.03064444288611412, 0.05109943449497223, -0.011772877536714077, 0.02632182650268078, 0.02165721356868744, 0.0347343385219574, -0.013437030836939812, 0.07922720164060593, 0.008627720177173615, 0.021408703178167343, -0.005767583381384611, 0.0207738745957613, -0.003949946723878384, -0.020968234166502953, -0.012629050761461258, 0.026389552280306816, -0.03264936804771423, -0.05125609412789345, 0.05387800559401512, 0.027853351086378098, -0.034910231828689575, 0.011718055233359337, 0.009786179289221764, -0.01792866177856922, -0.02878321334719658, -0.01747964508831501, 0.023280931636691093, 0.009791596792638302, 0.049937862902879715, -0.0119542321190238, 0.0017567657632753253, 0.023767901584506035, 0.02714402787387371, -0.01838160678744316, -0.013438192196190357, 0.007061352953314781, 0.04018270596861839, 0.042087286710739136, 0.02256445214152336, 0.002367277629673481, 0.01637427695095539, 0.04687269777059555, -0.02525496482849121, 0.07192990928888321, -0.01845310628414154, 0.01743452064692974, 0.05956263840198517, -0.014409869909286499, -0.007789371535181999, 0.058602474629879, 0.04653234779834747, 0.004978547338396311, -0.08427926152944565, -0.007638025097548962, -0.022183792665600777, 0.02545412816107273, 0.02144131064414978, -0.015044564381241798, -0.01073551457375288, -0.007133976090699434, -0.051734860986471176, 0.06059134751558304, -0.019984016194939613, 0.03675435483455658, -0.0019705777522176504, 0.00775539968162775, -0.001416207174770534, 0.03927060216665268, 0.015859253704547882, 0.02851855754852295, -0.027316521853208542, 0.013572145253419876, 0.03543528541922569, -0.011212071403861046, -0.002750381827354431, 0.0007997850188985467, 0.02289583720266819, -0.014586493372917175, -0.006993464659899473, 0.04931509867310524, -0.02571158856153488, 0.023045409470796585, 0.019577478989958763, -0.011546781286597252, 0.012504947371780872, 0.05408145859837532, 0.03244366869330406, 0.005475437268614769, 0.06256620585918427, -0.01646527275443077, -0.005071864929050207, 0.028300907462835312, -0.017160268500447273, -0.009240908548235893, -0.05350475758314133, -0.007672962266951799, 0.027096308767795563, -0.017284775152802467, -0.024623356759548187, -0.012343408539891243, -0.0031276687514036894, -0.03213895484805107, -0.026193935424089432, -0.02252023294568062, 0.039239831268787384, -0.00610679667443037, 0.0060670808888971806, 0.023232735693454742, -0.04016290605068207, -0.014996437355875969, 0.0006003421149216592, 0.06326990574598312, 0.03724939376115799, 0.03103450872004032, -0.03403552249073982, -0.01320725865662098, 0.008815598674118519, -0.02216259576380253, 0.017031418159604073, 0.0059029958210885525, 0.009335672482848167, 0.0009189827833324671, 0.029587218537926674, -0.007772854063659906, -0.03618495911359787, 0.02858552895486355, 0.03798298537731171, 0.01195214781910181, -0.01611199416220188, -0.07841500639915466, -0.07054615765810013, 0.03230335935950279, -0.0491807796061039, 0.016032295301556587, -0.054093584418296814, -0.02128005214035511, 0.018623962998390198, 0.037949174642562866, -0.009122772142291069, 0.03978126496076584, 0.00849565863609314, 0.024562405422329903, 0.034290339797735214, -0.0004963910905644298, 0.011349203065037727, -0.03633607551455498, -0.02536039426922798, 0.017523596063256264, -0.0941629484295845, -0.019656814634799957, 0.015716364607214928, -0.010152543894946575, -0.004072190262377262, 0.051979273557662964, -0.0012607716489583254, -0.02470141462981701, 0.03316362202167511, -0.01759510114789009, -0.021157655864953995, 0.039694610983133316, -0.020870011299848557, 0.007611916866153479, 0.054471705108881, -0.027405399829149246, 0.02396322786808014, -0.06009925901889801, 0.02478122152388096, 0.03373236581683159, -0.007747594267129898, -0.005785028450191021, -0.042319368571043015, -0.0015323369298130274, 0.0314021073281765, -0.07767108827829361, -0.038550328463315964, -0.0276174433529377, -0.029782766476273537, 0.028369933366775513, 0.015022710897028446, 0.007646281272172928, 0.0001730462972773239, 0.0708049088716507, -0.044187773019075394, -0.05574709549546242, -0.0345434732735157, -0.022126292809844017, -0.013713213615119457, -0.04350873827934265, 0.0003915928245987743, -0.005048330407589674, -0.00158991280477494, 0.000023253927793120965, -0.008485469035804272, -0.05609531328082085, 0.022669717669487, 0.03897404670715332, -0.02645391784608364, 0.0033994889818131924, 0.022169603034853935, 0.04829767346382141, -0.014915217645466328, 0.016770806163549423, -0.021051298826932907, -0.029431132599711418, 0.023655161261558533, -0.026874087750911713, -0.0018208883702754974, -0.028702164068818092, -0.0311896912753582, 0.016537979245185852, 0.011440230533480644, -0.009689181111752987, 0.061115819960832596, -0.0794687494635582, 0.04196132346987724, 0.08107056468725204, -0.0011051736073568463, -0.0278834979981184, 0.0028242701664566994, 0.0069984556175768375, 0.0875665545463562, -0.07512874901294708, 0.01618487946689129, -0.06828830391168594, -0.05287902057170868, 0.024701960384845734, -0.016582144424319267, -0.008610863238573074, 0.006767125800251961, 0.07383359223604202, 0.005149013828486204, 0.03769427537918091, 0.017396654933691025, -0.017505547031760216, -0.013983559794723988, 0.008719382807612419, 0.035719458013772964, 0.0343916192650795, 0.036697808653116226, 0.03126806765794754, 0.015106704086065292, 0.039236392825841904, -0.024176890030503273, 0.03403179720044136, 0.0448564812541008, -0.019822699949145317, -0.03391031548380852, -0.033165257424116135, 0.024478144943714142, 0.026074569672346115, -0.03568611666560173, 0.006493765860795975, 0.06322798877954483, 0.020120840519666672, -0.0025150387082248926, -0.013058589771389961, -0.015986843034625053, 0.008511552587151527, 0.038063179701566696, -0.026178566738963127, -0.013767795637249947, 0.001843626145273447, -0.0027546489145606756, 0.044848814606666565, -0.0517788827419281, -0.05288365110754967, -0.00661828787997365, 0.013976783491671085, 0.04180435091257095, -0.017398949712514877, -0.015608124434947968, -0.01716790534555912, 0.009599486365914345, -0.01654343493282795, -0.014794440940022469, 0.024988126009702682, -0.005557892844080925, -0.053159069269895554, -0.03664608672261238, -0.03608987107872963, 0.013715744949877262, 0.06001778319478035, 0.01983794942498207, -0.012408689595758915, 0.01106687169522047, 0.01590828225016594, -0.03704425320029259, -0.03712853789329529, -0.005403971299529076, 0.008902210742235184, -0.0013362927129492164, 0.01428211759775877, 0.04757416993379593, 0.015610986389219761, -0.050427310168743134, -0.022024141624569893, -0.08846673369407654, 0.0062525407411158085, 0.026646699756383896, -0.03260214254260063, 0.0025294353254139423, 0.03103055991232395, 0.013516710139811039, 0.013558195903897285, -0.03903202340006828, -0.008034458383917809, -0.05759135261178017, -0.03316453844308853, 0.017170974984765053, -0.003182806773111224, 0.022922717034816742, -0.024112174287438393, 0.000007584939339722041, 0.018742719665169716, 0.043137844651937485, -0.03178301453590393, -0.04004789888858795, 0.009164640679955482, -0.05465877056121826, -0.05892495810985565, 0.0029985106084495783, 0.016917839646339417, 0.0370166040956974, 0.026277706027030945, -0.010399945080280304, 0.050357405096292496, 0.047630999237298965, -0.015007594600319862, 0.03858665004372597, 0.02652115561068058, 0.005474776960909367, -0.030789034441113472, 0.04069570079445839, 0.030619489029049873, -0.014000139199197292, 0.042854320257902145, 0.011367063969373703, 0.046670760959386826, -0.01701376959681511, -0.044645920395851135, 0.045032091438770294, -0.006013537757098675, 0.0031826235353946686, -0.0199684239923954, 0.007469979114830494, 0.026407510042190552, 0.002928811125457287, -0.03405865281820297, -0.0213306974619627, 0.025527046993374825, -0.01632768288254738, 0.014678683131933212, 0.0572534017264843, 0.03303486108779907, 0.004760729148983955, -0.00925458874553442, -0.0030919229611754417, -0.01931679993867874, -0.024410543963313103, -0.024030033499002457, -0.00811693724244833, 0.03016752004623413, 0.050389207899570465, 0.025234444066882133, 0.008339233696460724, -0.024422159418463707, 0.0028090113773941994, -0.055742163211107254, 0.000511009304318577, -0.04121372103691101, 0.010557721368968487, 0.001120768953114748, 0.031472790986299515, -0.03527466580271721, -0.019930122420191765, -0.05170777812600136, -0.046568453311920166, -0.01700197160243988, 0.022562922909855843, 0.03767741844058037, -0.02704654633998871, 0.020578837022185326, -0.03736221790313721, 0.003848159220069647, -0.07102150470018387, 0.012482534162700176, 0.0052900156006217, 0.016204072162508965, 0.014984124340116978, -0.022902971133589745, 0.00027693642186932266, -0.0030824148561805487, -0.01894339732825756, 0.013087577186524868, 0.03004416637122631, 0.00986932497471571, -0.011048049665987492, 0.03481348231434822, 0.009860275313258171, -0.03272746875882149, -0.034876931458711624, 0.03182758763432503, 0.021868735551834106, 0.01942390948534012, 0.051438797265291214, -0.004638714715838432, -0.06155875325202942, 0.020467719063162804, 0.022354958578944206, 0.003227488836273551, 0.04170849174261093, 0.0021001382265239954, -0.05124643072485924, -0.0033418035600334406, -0.03237909823656082, -0.006237545050680637, -0.008893132209777832, 0.015538400039076805, 0.011403924785554409, 0.04377266764640808, 0.029727375134825706, -0.029500098899006844, 0.046153027564287186, 0.060988906770944595, -0.03233741968870163, -0.03133469820022583, -0.035945672541856766, -0.008656557649374008, -0.00625563831999898, 0.025840183719992638, 0.04962235316634178, 0.03498343005776405, 0.011598433367908001, -0.01536291278898716, 0.034724704921245575, 0.01658967137336731, -0.04069390147924423, 0.012352623045444489, 0.016478778794407845, 0.00013117764319758862, -0.00781804509460926, -0.04920237138867378, -0.03204250708222389, 0.021812930703163147, 0.015368678607046604, 0.020464114844799042, 0.008915329352021217, -0.10103560239076614, -0.005692184437066317, -0.02906409278512001, 0.018435409292578697, -0.02777833491563797, 0.0004951941664330661, -0.004635821096599102, -0.03073054552078247, -0.014163374900817871, -0.016382792964577675, 0.07149955630302429, -0.02636217512190342, 0.03451932966709137, -0.0311256293207407, -0.04129219055175781, -0.035803329199552536, -0.011103416793048382, -0.0048078750260174274, -0.02576993778347969, -0.009343796409666538, -0.04151368886232376, -0.05278932303190231, 0.006681676488369703, -0.009365245699882507, 0.023641791194677353, -0.04374932125210762, -0.030935386195778847, -0.0024582440964877605, 0.04058860242366791, -0.008499367162585258, -0.03934415057301521, 0.03817451745271683, -0.020232245326042175, -0.02395191416144371, 0.019702142104506493, -0.003915189299732447, -0.019645845517516136, 0.04356484115123749, 0.028014810755848885, 0.004298023879528046, -0.001430972944945097, -0.04381956160068512, 0.03848420828580856, 0.015619863756000996, 0.007290676236152649, 0.045443855226039886, 0.04304974526166916, -0.011048019863665104, 0.04780847951769829, -0.07735618948936462, 0.02155187726020813, -0.012453680858016014, -0.061709851026535034, -0.033072568476200104, -0.009309609420597553, 0.009262322448194027, 0.01688663847744465, 0.026435334235429764, 0.05082595348358154, -0.0545155368745327, -0.0011588388588279486, 0.029823051765561104, 0.028284944593906403, 0.01242881827056408, -0.007225348614156246, 0.01767890341579914, 0.01441320963203907, -0.029780466109514236, -0.0429525300860405, 0.020309939980506897, 0.0030431258492171764, -0.0002642102772369981, 0.012566511519253254, -0.04197481647133827, -0.0023863264359533787, -0.003258100710809231, -0.050746213644742966, 0.024229228496551514, -0.016186818480491638, 0.008081433363258839, 0.03559403866529465, 0.018173905089497566, -0.0032632737420499325, -0.06908747553825378, -0.02132864110171795, 0.04640237241983414, 0.0070818145759403706, 0.036189548671245575, 0.012598743662238121, 0.02916537970304489, -0.010107657872140408, -0.03634245693683624, -0.05110963433980942, 0.009869911707937717, 0.02357669547200203, 0.015299235470592976, -0.04556424543261528, -0.0022761437576264143, -0.04558975622057915, -0.0011838256614282727, -0.015919428318738937, -0.04343621805310249, 0.07161217927932739, -0.05251215025782585, -0.014941004104912281, 0.002697525778785348, 0.02990851365029812, 0.05120733007788658, -0.0033240641932934523, 0.0005735896993428469, 0.011898286640644073, -0.039492420852184296, -0.02414182387292385, 0.008045201189815998, 0.009464088827371597, -0.02576422691345215, -0.00019694109505508095, -0.03696576505899429, -0.00606783339753747, 0.04669127240777016, 0.006578694563359022, -0.01275450550019741, -0.00705135939642787, -0.004794090520590544, 0.027748795226216316, -0.034856166690588, -0.0006699900841340423, -0.013634447008371353, 0.029980139806866646, -0.0051682558842003345, 0.025791825726628304, -0.016444480046629906, 0.004914960358291864, 0.03687601536512375, -0.05781731754541397, 0.004065181128680706, 0.02003583312034607, 0.054136261343955994, 0.001587294857017696, 0.01822015643119812, -0.01668158918619156, -0.014466879889369011, 0.032972194254398346, 0.007457491010427475, 0.019423633813858032, 0.0024039638228714466, 0.019526991993188858, -0.03427974507212639, -0.026698371395468712, -0.025728721171617508, -0.012560763396322727, 0.05987981706857681, -0.009380247443914413, 0.037777889519929886, 0.05574706569314003, -0.00831624399870634, 0.03181090205907822, -0.03961159288883209, -0.031456299126148224, 0.019603228196501732, 0.00677691912278533, 0.05360943451523781, -0.0254693441092968, -0.03635942563414574, 0.04397188872098923, -0.007486176211386919, 0.02857073023915291, 0.007984069176018238, 0.03582637384533882, -0.005528139881789684, -0.012542284093797207, 0.017686685547232628, -0.029368961229920387, 0.023140234872698784, -0.025891687721014023, 0.016227921470999718, -0.07399788498878479, 0.01136994268745184, 0.056609392166137695, 0.05719153955578804, 0.018092229962348938, -0.08313324302434921, -0.017676709219813347, -0.0897597149014473, 0.005785486660897732, 0.02503451146185398, -0.040588755160570145, -0.004260526970028877, 0.015003289096057415, 0.03008156083524227, -0.05384286120533943, 0.03163699060678482, -0.02741771563887596, -0.04418644681572914, -0.017772603780031204, 0.0236788559705019, -0.007521475199609995, 0.09468813985586166, -0.004904820583760738, -0.022220730781555176, -0.01646866276860237, -0.05485283583402634, 0.007058836054056883, 0.006627555470913649, 0.026347776874899864, -0.009848151355981827, 0.04067220538854599, -0.025170743465423584, -0.005662191659212112, -0.015947269275784492, -0.018433520570397377, 0.1175880879163742, 0.06401880830526352, 0.029113471508026123, -0.04793199151754379, 0.006606068927794695, 0.016560222953557968, 0.0059040747582912445, 0.003922882955521345, -0.03877097740769386, 0.0069627403281629086, 0.0021907025948166847, 0.07027576118707657, 0.024556294083595276, 0.01740269362926483, -0.028597913682460785, 0.017959967255592346, -0.012604119256138802, -0.0009439876885153353, -0.018681900575757027, 0.060333188623189926, -0.008337200619280338, 0.024396736174821854, -0.04182574898004532, -0.043184418231248856, 0.04676895961165428, 0.012586700730025768, -0.02268970012664795, -0.014197642914950848, 0.015254241414368153, -0.034988418221473694, -0.023632820695638657, 0.012877351604402065, -0.01758088544011116, 0.010640297085046768, -0.013427739962935448, 0.018112070858478546, 0.015406685881316662, -0.036687664687633514, -0.015302930027246475, 0.0016267200699076056, -0.0035153033677488565, -0.0028168940916657448, -0.026531782001256943, 0.021316830068826675, -0.05396962910890579, -0.013401344418525696, -0.024342719465494156, 0.03847353160381317, 0.012089097872376442, -0.0269936453551054, -0.01617547683417797, 0.016243817284703255, -0.019939083606004715, -0.0360235832631588, -0.003184926463291049, 0.018812313675880432, 0.026555810123682022, -0.0022042281925678253, -0.015790481120347977, -0.03617702051997185, 0.015347465872764587, 0.0026147228199988604, -0.015058141201734543, 0.03694230318069458, 0.0073472801595926285, -0.022370360791683197, -0.07317589968442917, 0.03914502263069153, 0.017083091661334038, 0.01917385496199131, 0.002955844858661294, -0.013296592980623245, -0.01795477420091629, -0.003489184658974409, 0.012259767390787601, 0.03118833154439926, 0.030433835461735725, -0.00993848592042923, 0.010135207325220108, -0.034543950110673904, -0.061260394752025604, 0.05160894617438316, -0.019609149545431137, 0.014576002955436707, -0.028149167075753212, -0.009722850285470486, 0.014556726440787315, 0.024746118113398552, -0.011604445055127144, 0.012527200393378735, -0.015008094720542431, 0.059279825538396835, -0.012497549876570702, -0.08180316537618637, -0.04176163300871849, 0.05576279014348984, -0.02619762159883976, 0.0013679111143574119, -0.05746244266629219, 0.06405068188905716, -0.0033793237525969744, 0.019301168620586395, -0.010814924724400043, 0.005868361331522465, 0.016055116429924965, -0.023543864488601685, 0.020075052976608276, -0.04344001039862633, 0.019415557384490967, 0.014982461929321289, -0.0049680666998028755, 0.017305951565504074, -0.010682978667318821, -0.005536547861993313, -0.07747216522693634, -0.00993791501969099, -0.01740325056016445, -0.0172109454870224, 0.035255592316389084, -0.02878296934068203, -0.015392436645925045, -0.0323074571788311, 0.016508080065250397, -0.045557890087366104, 0.021109845489263535, -0.014131245203316212, -0.03625626116991043, 0.0017276814905926585, -0.001901526004076004, -0.027252381667494774, 0.030125947669148445, 0.030026737600564957, 0.006894975434988737, 0.053898606449365616, -0.0318700447678566, 0.023415235802531242, 0.0189390666782856, 0.03704948350787163, 0.042225513607263565, -0.004014975391328335, 0.015613710507750511, -0.014227221719920635, -0.029242103919386864, 0.02386218123137951, 0.01351558230817318, 0.04508985951542854, -0.0060533941723406315, 0.035172220319509506, -0.023333949968218803, 0.08388814330101013, -0.025730835273861885, -0.013320934027433395, -0.010461043566465378, -0.029274284839630127, 0.017301522195339203, -0.036017175763845444, 0.008362376131117344, 0.011377627961337566, 0.002798909554257989, 0.042612217366695404, 0.04559028521180153, -0.02663697674870491, -0.016191361472010612, -0.0049498132430016994, -0.030122732743620872, 0.03555374965071678, 0.014277610927820206, 0.019077206030488014, 0.043625608086586, 0.03519251570105553, 0.01792122796177864, 0.06039811298251152, -0.017408953979611397, 0.011627919971942902, -0.07241033017635345, -0.03907857835292816, 0.027013620361685753, 0.05703377723693848, 0.05751923471689224, -0.04196523502469063, -0.015264434739947319, 0.011411155574023724, -0.05408405140042305, -0.008222530595958233, 0.016514141112565994, 0.011786670424044132, -0.03849393129348755, -0.004471675492823124, -0.036616697907447815, 0.011495614424347878, 0.008551273494958878, 0.03140180557966232, 0.050109148025512695, 0.0033068929333239794, 0.006984574720263481, -0.043549712747335434, 0.00016115808102767915, 0.04193555936217308, 0.024917736649513245, -0.07564450800418854, 0.00754842022433877, -0.0203497763723135, 0.015834910795092583, -0.007405712269246578, 0.014091195538640022, 0.028393570333719254, 0.012165810912847519, 0.004592048469930887, 0.030652908608317375, 0.0420464351773262, 0.01664573699235916, 0.020703306421637535, -0.0192963145673275, -0.0019629548769444227, -0.0017909487942233682, 0.005716348998248577, -0.028312869369983673, -0.004125043749809265, 0.0035986301954835653, -0.010877704247832298, -0.015157177112996578, 0.001963387243449688, -0.014707429334521294, -0.02026411145925522, 0.005739152897149324, 0.007798282895237207, 0.003961027134209871, -0.029442833736538887, -0.009589988738298416, -0.04197211191058159, 0.011882355436682701, 0.03716869652271271, 0.04278413578867912, 0.0223610308021307, 0.02862917259335518, -0.027344495058059692, -0.03216896578669548, 0.007176767569035292, 0.0017558360705152154, -0.002366861328482628, -0.032641515135765076, -0.0035624918527901173, 0.01638420671224594, -0.0324409194290638, -0.01898092031478882, 0.008126049302518368, -0.03402536362409592, 0.008145280182361603, -0.010332739911973476, -0.02848563902080059, 0.008003836497664452, 0.005111826583743095, 0.03345396742224693, -0.10450448840856552, 0.049463506788015366, 0.018808623775839806, -0.014653157442808151, -0.056493088603019714, -0.0058274720795452595, -0.04592478275299072, 0.07655292004346848, 0.0562172457575798, 0.022655054926872253, -0.004858503583818674, -0.010122925974428654, 0.029808295890688896, -0.0000849500866024755, -0.02219128981232643, 0.07199757546186447, 0.0037855759728699923, 0.012559741735458374, -0.0028863740153610706, 0.03625454381108284, -0.017024166882038116, 0.019218508154153824, 0.021862221881747246, 0.005113436374813318, -0.008463140577077866, -0.010916804894804955, -0.011860660277307034, 0.017773907631635666, 0.01422534417361021, -0.03874536231160164, 0.0017038544174283743, 0.016315776854753494, 0.0031210745219141245, 0.06776376813650131, 0.02090008370578289, -0.04490004852414131, 0.027955323457717896, -0.005135257728397846, -0.0004685254243668169, 0.015791215002536774, -0.004453595727682114, 0.017481138929724693, -0.051366016268730164, 0.015996290370821953, 0.03068358823657036, -0.013286537490785122, -0.03848902881145477, 0.009711637161672115, 0.07997200638055801, 0.011398816481232643, 0.01994357816874981, 0.021208535879850388, -0.016616178676486015, -0.028299476951360703, 0.02660592831671238, 0.015888411551713943, 0.05204324424266815, -0.014701361767947674, -0.005611531902104616, 0.03653380274772644, -0.000725998601410538, 0.01159672811627388, -0.022710170596837997, 0.021919067949056625, 0.011530834250152111, 0.005257077049463987, 0.01578192599117756, 0.03335936367511749, 0.005206902977079153, 0.02144317887723446, -0.017985180020332336, 0.0379021018743515, -0.04909730702638626, -0.00016527483239769936, 0.0276481993496418, 0.017559625208377838, -0.040711574256420135, -0.012678735889494419, -0.005224436987191439, 0.012674456462264061, 0.0031582284718751907, 0.029813937842845917, 0.016688207164406776, -0.014962718822062016, 0.01515834778547287, -0.00847549643367529, 0.025898337364196777, 0.012293035164475441, -0.02148699201643467, -0.038032352924346924, -0.025396190583705902, -0.03398985415697098, -0.0387403778731823, 0.014305966906249523, 0.0324498750269413, -0.029699401929974556, -0.06326703727245331, -0.0449230819940567, 0.011397512629628181, 0.08228065073490143, -0.04063932225108147, -0.04347298666834831, 0.0014634998515248299, 0.019972417503595352, 0.017188189551234245, -0.007443768437951803 ]
<p>I have an interesting question that I think has not been asked yet here.</p> <p>I am building an AI that has as goal to predict how wrong a standard based-on-history model is. This is done based on Natural Language Processing(NLP), so from an external source (yes I have thousands of articles timed by the minute to do this!!).</p> <p>I come to point where I need to select my original model. The most simple way is linear regression from bars 0-40 (where 40 is 'now') and compare it to bars 5-45. Compare the difference of value 40 and 45 and voila we have the 'difference' in our model we can attempt predict/classify using news articles. </p> <p>Ofcourse, using linear regression is not suitable for this kind of task but what is? And even better are there libraries in .NET(C#) that can do that, since my math-to-code skills are not that great.</p> <p>I have been looking at polynomial regression but find that the difference can be out of proportion big. Also been looking at GARCH but I cannot seem to find a library(so not in R) that can do this without paying a part of my body. What also seems interesting is AR(i)MA but there I stopped and decided to get some advice on my problem.</p> <p>What would be suited for such a 'supervisor'? Would I need very complex regression or would linear even be good enough? Or in this case just use a neural network(already made a pretty good one for this once)?</p> <p>Greets</p>
28,680
[ 0.0002742145152296871, -0.014662153087556362, -0.025547917932271957, -0.031162967905402184, 0.04021364450454712, 0.0023892803583294153, -0.019411219283938408, 0.017444204539060593, 0.039131034165620804, -0.006476526148617268, 0.013069802895188332, 0.017487552016973495, 0.05919962748885155, 0.03161996975541115, 0.026085440069437027, 0.0027172518894076347, -0.018228929489850998, -0.0067700729705393314, -0.002628087066113949, -0.013522970490157604, 0.006263064220547676, -0.011535163037478924, -0.035706453025341034, 0.011131924577057362, -0.02253851108253002, 0.038663145154714584, 0.025609465315937996, 0.019200092181563377, -0.056119006127119064, 0.07746147364377975, -0.033887073397636414, -0.021602101624011993, 0.022431861609220505, 0.031660594046115875, 0.04509635269641876, 0.021611690521240234, 0.015782620757818222, -0.056671541184186935, -0.034651197493076324, 0.06269228458404541, -0.018656481057405472, -0.0029125662986189127, 0.015873784199357033, 0.04310188442468643, -0.004586352501064539, 0.026592226698994637, -0.04477190971374512, -0.01779816672205925, 0.018923934549093246, -0.017210155725479126, 0.0814753919839859, -0.0095287524163723, 0.049067750573158264, 0.05507096275687218, -0.005256641656160355, -0.011899457313120365, 0.0662829577922821, 0.05236952006816864, 0.0005403139512054622, -0.04704827070236206, -0.025464922189712524, 0.01739487051963806, 0.004439530894160271, -0.036950863897800446, -0.025091350078582764, -0.007938511669635773, -0.001962814712896943, 0.0072745103389024734, 0.03268253430724144, -0.025055821985006332, 0.004211954306811094, 0.004170548636466265, 0.039905522018671036, 0.018404129892587662, 0.00778582226485014, -0.0256961677223444, -0.014668582007288933, 0.015159768983721733, 0.03282748907804489, -0.011854888871312141, -0.003722954308614135, -0.010183303616940975, 0.03220531344413757, 0.07481400668621063, 0.01696174405515194, -0.005449880380183458, 0.06223912164568901, -0.033536236733198166, 0.059282779693603516, 0.051608867943286896, -0.011484101414680481, 0.0018233814043924212, 0.03598712012171745, 0.03670066222548485, -0.055813614279031754, 0.009976418688893318, 0.020081564784049988, 0.02426445484161377, 0.03297389671206474, 0.02750195935368538, -0.00845494493842125, -0.0567820779979229, -0.027073370292782784, 0.05202769115567207, 0.013569025322794914, 0.0020491613540798426, 0.0165095217525959, -0.05392633005976677, -0.01638323813676834, -0.00855033379048109, -0.07106734812259674, 0.009669815190136433, -0.005263129714876413, -0.02595716156065464, 0.03625522553920746, -0.026649784296751022, -0.02450607530772686, -0.03691880404949188, 0.0626656636595726, 0.0621308758854866, 0.000012112685908505227, -0.01701669953763485, 0.037582267075777054, -0.03168230131268501, -0.02671596221625805, 0.00048675091238692403, 0.03834015503525734, -0.03821459040045738, -0.020192435011267662, 0.07995294779539108, 0.0035125489812344313, -0.006832473445683718, 0.004270863253623247, -0.02106376923620701, 0.054430969059467316, 0.0056755030527710915, -0.10442519187927246, -0.0551799014210701, 0.023867236450314522, -0.022071626037359238, 0.030972842127084732, -0.07412713766098022, -0.025216566398739815, 0.015937112271785736, 0.07722528278827667, 0.0426480807363987, 0.04487255960702896, 0.04315185546875, 0.0021087750792503357, -0.006987689528614283, -0.04361027479171753, -0.002986347768455744, -0.027914119884371758, 0.02143915556371212, -0.024323923513293266, -0.06197436898946762, -0.00759775610640645, 0.016243258491158485, -0.01906718499958515, 0.033826906234025955, 0.004575353115797043, 0.0015606515808030963, -0.01882391795516014, 0.015840789303183556, -0.003910946659743786, -0.03131529688835144, 0.12092781811952591, 0.016236450523138046, -0.0029893505852669477, -0.006726795341819525, 0.018087374046444893, 0.008494359441101551, 0.03849645331501961, 0.01976299099624157, 0.0895836353302002, 0.012266980484127998, -0.013050364330410957, -0.01937892474234104, -0.015158851630985737, 0.023484814912080765, -0.01604187861084938, -0.055680301040410995, -0.03267887979745865, -0.027120305225253105, -0.05058278888463974, 0.04801912605762482, -0.017329733818769455, 0.00873411912471056, 0.034539248794317245, -0.03639126569032669, -0.01671869307756424, -0.029327064752578735, 0.01891418546438217, -0.0382833369076252, 0.007203441113233566, 0.00879308208823204, -0.0241816695779562, 0.0026069972664117813, -0.00009026937914313748, -0.027498001232743263, 0.033948253840208054, 0.013407586142420769, 0.0485185869038105, -0.014860488474369049, -0.008179968222975731, 0.008998733013868332, 0.001063462346792221, -0.007823299616575241, 0.0460909903049469, -0.05240499973297119, -0.05764415115118027, 0.013569367118179798, -0.0058508203364908695, 0.01959356665611267, -0.0001964601397048682, -0.024192549288272858, 0.028663495555520058, 0.0026535941287875175, -0.015497039072215557, -0.006134406663477421, -0.02153577283024788, 0.04511947184801102, 0.056870412081480026, 0.03288319334387779, 0.0047994256019592285, 0.007250041700899601, 0.00470237759873271, 0.01926085352897644, -0.055706270039081573, -0.0366179458796978, -0.04569020867347717, -0.033518433570861816, 0.028176914900541306, 0.025513267144560814, -0.003137878840789199, 0.05240432918071747, 0.06160598620772362, 0.04641285538673401, -0.0020393754821270704, 0.019729482010006905, -0.012999150902032852, -0.001211299211718142, 0.0375664159655571, -0.03201676160097122, 0.024611640721559525, -0.0135547686368227, 0.03157413378357887, 0.022043589502573013, 0.07934713363647461, -0.009262063540518284, -0.00026663619792088866, 0.05725400149822235, 0.01883184164762497, 0.012039967812597752, -0.01565995253622532, -0.04935537278652191, 0.05895971134305, -0.03481188416481018, -0.014492131769657135, 0.014222165569663048, 0.01490374282002449, -0.01504079345613718, 0.014352189376950264, 0.00044657569378614426, -0.004360257647931576, 0.015957387164235115, -0.030337870121002197, 0.0020758926402777433, 0.0052881063893437386, -0.02343110367655754, 0.03180638328194618, -0.006218821741640568, 0.006262950133532286, -0.056707367300987244, 0.04130998253822327, 0.022875428199768066, 0.02320569008588791, 0.02988678216934204, 0.007511552423238754, -0.030058452859520912, 0.024680422618985176, -0.008017994463443756, 0.02327956259250641, 0.010196451097726822, -0.021777398884296417, 0.03641239553689957, -0.007866493426263332, -0.004272507503628731, 0.02227061241865158, 0.02736322395503521, 0.023097151890397072, 0.016660504043102264, -0.008245401084423065, -0.057168230414390564, -0.03770523890852928, -0.03268371894955635, 0.016367975622415543, -0.006465389858931303, -0.04833252727985382, 0.01334328018128872, -0.0015664908569306135, -0.06885097920894623, 0.005282798781991005, -0.04693490266799927, 0.001192034687846899, -0.041029445827007294, 0.0035731352400034666, -0.005577743519097567, 0.007379645481705666, 0.008902447298169136, 0.03773622214794159, 0.03169052302837372, -0.011381925083696842, -0.07337914407253265, -0.04868413507938385, 0.004379664547741413, 0.0020664692856371403, -0.019753845408558846, 0.021775126457214355, -0.006929402239620686, 0.0443914495408535, 0.040907423943281174, -0.02786446176469326, -0.036403778940439224, 0.029378589242696762, -0.012676101177930832, -0.04435521364212036, 0.019166115671396255, 0.018740277737379074, 0.02336747571825981, 0.012521819211542606, -0.014337393455207348, -0.009999039582908154, 0.03813179209828377, 0.0002520900161471218, -0.007594137452542782, 0.01685584895312786, -0.048371605575084686, 0.012713821604847908, 0.020606469362974167, 0.02043524757027626, -0.012784282676875591, 0.0399775393307209, 0.0019257219973951578, 0.008132599294185638, 0.005947892088443041, -0.04722069576382637, 0.010781091637909412, -0.018429206684231758, -0.04489978402853012, -0.01802367903292179, 0.0032187344040721655, -0.024611234664916992, -0.037184469401836395, -0.007925213314592838, -0.003990945406258106, 0.03760041669011116, -0.014183053746819496, 0.026544788852334023, 0.03937114030122757, 0.04852008819580078, 0.007857847027480602, -0.0035643165465444326, -0.035098493099212646, 0.002003108849748969, -0.003116922453045845, -0.02004201151430607, 0.004703707993030548, 0.05284819379448891, 0.021459711715579033, 0.009952814318239689, 0.01572195626795292, -0.02877950854599476, -0.0006190158892422915, -0.043263331055641174, 0.027970122173428535, -0.016859672963619232, 0.08827482908964157, 0.02530154585838318, 0.021107492968440056, 0.02126987650990486, -0.011626875028014183, 0.0520179383456707, -0.01495873648673296, -0.09542694687843323, 0.06810051947832108, -0.016710815951228142, -0.010252594016492367, 0.024073276668787003, -0.018885139375925064, 0.016647711396217346, -0.02414526417851448, -0.0029136782977730036, -0.006586120463907719, -0.011138901114463806, -0.03581510856747627, 0.02183074876666069, -0.032063305377960205, 0.002449377439916134, 0.01541818492114544, -0.03760030120611191, 0.013992620632052422, -0.03093971684575081, 0.04230951890349388, 0.014144781976938248, 0.0296163409948349, -0.01698126830160618, -0.028218558058142662, 0.03295048698782921, 0.030267750844359398, 0.0648382231593132, 0.034377600997686386, -0.0014413213357329369, -0.044874124228954315, 0.039228323847055435, 0.016127074137330055, 0.010210545733571053, 0.03157631680369377, 0.013028344139456749, -0.03274359554052353, -0.03881154954433441, -0.02565671131014824, 0.0023241667076945305, 0.019776243716478348, 0.008788501843810081, -0.004540184047073126, 0.0359879732131958, 0.025078922510147095, -0.07585395872592926, -0.004919403698295355, 0.07540372014045715, 0.02172721177339554, 0.009177637286484241, -0.026391983032226562, -0.03207368776202202, 0.04637560993432999, 0.002017984166741371, 0.023905793204903603, 0.009203770197927952, -0.011482053436338902, -0.026777833700180054, 0.054490745067596436, -0.021359648555517197, -0.03016309253871441, -0.011052125133574009, 0.045785482972860336, 0.05323502793908119, -0.011109014973044395, -0.0371587909758091, -0.01633528061211109, 0.04152039811015129, 0.07722143828868866, 0.019816482439637184, 0.022023797035217285, -0.11126058548688889, 0.019801929593086243, 0.029904427006840706, 0.03195575252175331, -0.042896561324596405, -0.05808762088418007, -0.0392320342361927, -0.056940652430057526, 0.03511402755975723, 0.005926794372498989, 0.008518796414136887, -0.01667291298508644, 0.009731576777994633, 0.007517922203987837, -0.046067867428064346, -0.039146821945905685, 0.03126101195812225, -0.011904697865247726, 0.055628109723329544, -0.015198550187051296, -0.05443776026368141, -0.060802388936281204, -0.0043476782739162445, 0.020071765407919884, 0.00900487881153822, 0.01055089384317398, -0.009789125993847847, 0.013263195753097534, 0.028867442160844803, -0.02484901435673237, -0.05584293603897095, -0.007377377711236477, 0.003614244982600212, -0.016795868054032326, 0.026088964194059372, 0.006301881279796362, -0.027044130489230156, 0.01685122400522232, 0.014199182391166687, 0.0002793367311824113, -0.029530096799135208, -0.02603788673877716, 0.025596093386411667, 0.025181487202644348, 0.030484512448310852, 0.047444794327020645, 0.009610026143491268, 0.00966801866889, 0.0045862155966460705, -0.008427435532212257, 0.02111165225505829, 0.0056051709689199924, -0.02043047919869423, -0.03708207979798317, -0.011031147092580795, -0.021125903353095055, 0.03303270414471626, -0.00467171985656023, 0.033705972135066986, 0.0014160755090415478, -0.006355917081236839, 0.014601688832044601, 0.013331206515431404, -0.038511306047439575, -0.04065947234630585, 0.005095199216157198, 0.0010308847995474935, -0.061589017510414124, 0.006177575793117285, -0.005947653669863939, -0.02751210145652294, 0.0028944597579538822, 0.03631591796875, -0.04826077073812485, -0.010128706693649292, -0.018751200288534164, -0.0016726719914004207, -0.009648931212723255, 0.009437432512640953, 0.03162139281630516, 0.00896341074258089, 0.050471045076847076, 0.023537147790193558, -0.031136836856603622, -0.018939930945634842, 0.008608395233750343, -0.007611147128045559, -0.006597679108381271, -0.04677311331033707, 0.008576281368732452, -0.02674003504216671, -0.027494266629219055, -0.027107948437333107, -0.05031449347734451, 0.02499137818813324, -0.004059147089719772, -0.06676610559225082, -0.024825314059853554, 0.012875943444669247, -0.044190458953380585, -0.01683122105896473, -0.01723962277173996, 0.0642126277089119, 0.000695455470122397, -0.011339182034134865, 0.0024967382196336985, -0.002539654029533267, 0.06150062754750252, -0.0069407024420797825, 0.0006398232653737068, -0.011566977947950363, -0.014773434959352016, -0.012335737235844135, -0.002625607419759035, 0.059716831892728806, -0.033795081079006195, 0.013540836051106453, -0.0524466373026371, -0.013970481231808662, 0.04468415305018425, -0.002478798385709524, 0.027272159233689308, 0.012134536169469357, -0.03059604950249195, 0.03427690267562866, -0.01339251734316349, 0.019072018563747406, -0.015709595754742622, -0.02181517705321312, -0.026136552914977074, -0.03847401216626167, 0.000889006070792675, -0.022248048335313797, 0.03769201412796974, 0.004404173232614994, -0.025398556143045425, 0.05615178868174553, 0.04734024405479431, -0.020170127972960472, 0.017927134409546852, -0.0035041430965065956, 0.01062185037881136, 0.029166528955101967, -0.003797698998823762, 0.0071278708055615425, -0.010451286099851131, -0.0005020610406063497, -0.06935495883226395, -0.04349422827363014, -0.01908007822930813, 0.010769249871373177, 0.05661597102880478, 0.002107907785102725, 0.06756550818681717, 0.04306964576244354, 0.05718781799077988, -0.04263349622488022, -0.018005000427365303, -0.02247382514178753, 0.0012324724812060595, -0.021388154476881027, 0.019745109602808952, -0.012533587403595448, 0.003723869798704982, 0.002746541053056717, -0.009275980293750763, 0.023134607821702957, 0.05675312504172325, -0.004052410833537579, 0.039023663848638535, 0.03099648654460907, -0.03801200911402702, -0.009636925533413887, 0.019192392006516457, -0.03421362116932869, 0.019565870985388756, -0.025244107469916344, -0.022419888526201248, 0.040180835872888565, 0.05509538576006889, 0.010387328453361988, -0.04268224909901619, -0.03530922532081604, -0.07288425415754318, 0.00028953657601960003, 0.06428346782922745, -0.047020215541124344, 0.025308677926659584, 0.036365807056427, 0.015195881947875023, -0.005623629316687584, 0.053686026483774185, -0.026485461741685867, -0.09727833420038223, -0.0007961162482388318, -0.06274097412824631, -0.026081249117851257, 0.06666754186153412, 0.008284458890557289, -0.04641816392540932, 0.00024472607765346766, -0.03428327292203903, 0.01508491300046444, 0.03650780767202377, 0.0017499603563919663, 0.01612398400902748, 0.07507025450468063, -0.034056223928928375, -0.0005080244736745954, 0.023931721225380898, 0.020369360223412514, 0.13755284249782562, 0.10043337196111679, 0.023784881457686424, -0.041629280894994736, 0.0148035092279315, 0.01964881829917431, 0.002659726422280073, -0.00859781727194786, 0.008395737037062645, 0.0028623510152101517, -0.011936062946915627, 0.009161644615232944, 0.034631360322237015, 0.019328676164150238, -0.023596448823809624, 0.04105839505791664, -0.03213090822100639, 0.0012281356612220407, 0.0020699109882116318, -0.0013713677180930972, 0.022981487214565277, -0.03677859529852867, -0.03361428529024124, 0.03173169866204262, -0.002612212672829628, -0.0024627563543617725, -0.002190107014030218, -0.0328047014772892, 0.011426977813243866, 0.012136808596551418, -0.014094434678554535, -0.0001171889525721781, -0.015231135301291943, 0.04413139075040817, 0.022585824131965637, 0.012762192636728287, 0.015998145565390587, -0.0011918222298845649, 0.008522075600922108, 0.0020145224407315254, 0.039053067564964294, -0.016568223014473915, 0.006321517284959555, -0.01669877953827381, -0.015223273076117039, -0.03820907324552536, -0.07439770549535751, 0.02550250105559826, -0.00519380671903491, -0.018380405381321907, 0.014029033482074738, -0.013740058057010174, 0.006286287214607, -0.031446829438209534, -0.027960753068327904, 0.05965707078576088, 0.04370855167508125, -0.010515248402953148, -0.004766876809298992, -0.023806657642126083, 0.012976774014532566, 0.024914750829339027, 0.03483501076698303, 0.0025289307814091444, -0.05983993783593178, -0.02813747525215149, -0.019639605656266212, 0.05188165232539177, -0.04232245311141014, -0.023155691102147102, -0.0018335941713303328, -0.006652869284152985, -0.04329496622085571, 0.0029893291648477316, 0.01853291504085064, 0.007501222193241119, -0.014070933684706688, -0.026615571230649948, -0.02844562940299511, 0.0005557028925977647, 0.017228418961167336, -0.005828166846185923, -0.00897096749395132, 0.02728159725666046, -0.03518363833427429, -0.03487592935562134, 0.030306966975331306, 0.040991101413965225, 0.026904018595814705, 0.011400843970477581, 0.0026259669102728367, 0.009878383949398994, 0.021602971479296684, -0.036778032779693604, -0.004293055739253759, 0.004634703043848276, -0.04333822801709175, 0.018723957240581512, -0.01977645233273506, 0.056539200246334076, 0.022271351888775826, -0.01580045372247696, -0.01321512833237648, 0.04106077924370766, -0.031704336404800415, -0.020590949803590775, 0.036190930753946304, -0.051895346492528915, -0.015998195856809616, -0.00555992079898715, -0.004509649705141783, -0.06979650259017944, -0.01583598554134369, -0.01631692424416542, -0.009906762279570103, 0.006012048106640577, -0.024781063199043274, -0.013800274580717087, 0.044605206698179245, -0.005257049575448036, 0.01158168539404869, -0.04734119772911072, 0.011079882271587849, -0.02134578675031662, -0.0011099694529548287, -0.019995473325252533, -0.03011755645275116, -0.027572151273489, 0.013653717935085297, -0.016723234206438065, -0.017714569345116615, -0.003884263336658478, -0.008565320633351803, -0.002530628815293312, -0.007550489157438278, 0.0018234950257465243, -0.006752397399395704, 0.025805072858929634, -0.026104189455509186, -0.0409027636051178, 0.017204929143190384, -0.004760634619742632, -0.014220094308257103, 0.019518237560987473, 0.017898039892315865, 0.03984261304140091, 0.006430868990719318, -0.01211882010102272, -0.001880950410850346, 0.06288129836320877, -0.02349664457142353, 0.004753511399030685, -0.00795566663146019, 0.038899317383766174, -0.019506331533193588, 0.010309879668056965, 0.01641351357102394, 0.00612223893404007, -0.020717071369290352, -0.007143632508814335, 0.04092825576663017, 0.005761361680924892, 0.007527973037213087, 0.004725458100438118, -0.016042200848460197, -0.028101110830903053, 0.009816018864512444, -0.00008146060281433165, 0.007680304814130068, 0.012098003178834915, -0.023155396804213524, 0.0005085041630081832, -0.0005330399144440889, 0.03628277778625488, -0.0675540640950203, 0.013789552263915539, 0.037435535341501236, 0.002397830132395029, 0.04287654161453247, -0.07107754796743393, -0.00302084325812757, 0.02453942410647869, -0.04405263066291809, -0.010119075886905193, -0.00016436155419796705, -0.0012614878360182047, 0.008227451704442501, 0.010170393623411655, -0.02315778099000454, 0.02979990467429161, 0.010913217440247536, 0.03071432374417782, 0.05483532324433327, -0.00019233679631724954, 0.022323207929730415, -0.032250069081783295, -0.012844066135585308, 0.028103163465857506, 0.0003594533773139119, -0.007542826700955629, 0.03933338075876236, -0.07442466914653778, -0.041427820920944214, 0.0588344968855381, -0.024862172082066536, 0.011279475875198841, 0.004047958180308342, 0.028334280475974083, -0.0036431066691875458, 0.04260283336043358, 0.010320822708308697, -0.019325727596879005, 0.01100994274020195, 0.00845266878604889, 0.01547944825142622, 0.01181394886225462, -0.03138706833124161, 0.03022167459130287, 0.01262580044567585, -0.04030655696988106, 0.011252469383180141, -0.02420143224298954, -0.009420045651495457, 0.008114846423268318, 0.022886598482728004, -0.02228776179254055, -0.001141121843829751, -0.0226576030254364, -0.010655851103365421, 0.004252247512340546, 0.007737889885902405, -0.0006897907005622983, 0.04178190603852272, -0.03377862274646759, 0.0018454017117619514, -0.04647159203886986, -0.07753679901361465, 0.012335357256233692, -0.03550161048769951, -0.028169119730591774, -0.06010456383228302, -0.009606488980352879, 0.010648651979863644, -0.011943948455154896, -0.04506272077560425, -0.008775174617767334, 0.0035576876252889633, 0.0394103042781353, -0.03251473605632782, -0.0023715540301054716, 0.029328307136893272, -0.026138128712773323, 0.030927198007702827, -0.07667452096939087, 0.05316680669784546, 0.02216566726565361, 0.01614236831665039, 0.007726323790848255, -0.01863425225019455, -0.05113399028778076, -0.019700391218066216, 0.04848632216453552, -0.020376134663820267, 0.008073682896792889, 0.0025014213752001524, -0.033448606729507446, -0.025694072246551514, -0.02937130071222782, 0.04977131262421608, -0.015362553298473358, -0.02170315757393837, -0.03102429397404194, 0.004860415123403072, -0.003987646196037531, 0.0019328708294779062, 0.013822545297443867, 0.02414313703775406, -0.044485848397016525, 0.012025673873722553, 0.0027122374158352613, 0.0022961499635130167, -0.006214357912540436, 0.017120543867349625, 0.03617680445313454, 0.028031939640641212, -0.016027972102165222, 0.049876246601343155, 0.04632643237709999, -0.062009841203689575, 0.049120791256427765, 0.009199301712214947, -0.018230875954031944, 0.0022894798312336206, 0.028317412361502647, -0.006018256302922964, -0.06171406805515289, -0.009651335887610912, 0.027403870597481728, 0.019887400791049004, 0.015538480132818222, -0.00015773824998177588, -0.02131452038884163, 0.013465648517012596, -0.012567662633955479, 0.00668916804715991, 0.014489095658063889, 0.03446899726986885, -0.00937381386756897, -0.02923261933028698, 0.034945763647556305, 0.013171075843274593, 0.02221582643687725, 0.022643929347395897, -0.046540722250938416, 0.05348319560289383, -0.022732598707079887, 0.020785747095942497, -0.06697943061590195, -0.017361069098114967, 0.024339385330677032, 0.010415240190923214, -0.007600375916808844, 0.007018771953880787, 0.004852688405662775, 0.044573377817869186, -0.02018335461616516, -0.013424874283373356, -0.0396653413772583, 0.016392124816775322, -0.006904840935021639, 0.023468324914574623, -0.03212697058916092, -0.0009411692153662443, -0.008425911888480186, 0.023618139326572418, 0.014434617012739182, -0.009592415764927864, 0.03771144896745682, -0.024936789646744728, -0.0023334319703280926, -0.0007766180206090212, -0.008898656815290451, -0.014413809403777122, -0.027112402021884918, -0.06762734800577164, -0.011463973671197891, 0.04643659293651581, 0.03144281357526779, 0.04600777477025986, -0.012214943766593933, -0.021709736436605453, -0.026667295023798943, 0.048719748854637146, -0.0670349970459938, -0.0065235900692641735, -0.02487037144601345, -0.010614082217216492, -0.014870583079755306, -0.026584122329950333 ]
<p><strong>Context:</strong> I'm reading up on sampling in <a href="http://cis.temple.edu/~latecki/Courses/RobotFall07/PapersFall07/andrieu03introduction.pdf" rel="nofollow">MCMC for Machine Learning</a>. On page 5, it mentions rejection sampling:</p> <pre><code>repeat sample xi ~ q(x) and u ~ U(0,1) if uMq(xi) &lt; p(xi): accept xi until enough samples </code></pre> <p>(where $M$ is chosen such that $p(x) \le Mq(x)$ for all $x$)</p> <p><strong>Question:</strong> In the analysis, the paper says that it may work bad for high-dimensional settings. While I can see that, the paper gives a reason that I don't understand: $P(x \text{ accepted}) = P \left(u &lt; \frac{p(x)}{Mq(x)} \right) = \frac{1}{M}$. This doesn't make sense to me. If the probability were constant, why even bother to evaluate $p(x)$? Should this be a "at most $\frac{1}{M}$? Or am I just misinterpreting the statement? </p>
36,531
[ 0.013367865234613419, -0.03366096317768097, 0.03937365859746933, -0.02949482388794422, 0.02673063986003399, 0.029772460460662842, -0.011786465533077717, -0.04887503758072853, 0.016349520534276962, -0.03817213699221611, 0.046641092747449875, 0.0630052238702774, 0.07091373950242996, 0.026562511920928955, 0.02053028531372547, 0.02967025339603424, 0.007437629159539938, -0.012141923420131207, -0.0032365485094487667, 0.012359166517853737, -0.0018416469683870673, 0.07368239760398865, 0.027721326798200607, -0.010440001264214516, -0.04889126121997833, 0.00806318037211895, 0.018563877791166306, -0.009557039476931095, 0.0231177918612957, 0.06449718028306961, -0.06265368312597275, -0.014207838103175163, 0.011387334205210209, 0.035625770688056946, -0.00899041909724474, 0.010137778706848621, -0.05446150153875351, -0.06637215614318848, -0.0033347432035952806, 0.031215567141771317, -0.014501065947115421, -0.007279502227902412, -0.0007997477659955621, 0.007743166293948889, -0.020667288452386856, 0.016200490295886993, 0.028159644454717636, -0.04637543857097626, 0.03532383590936661, -0.023715846240520477, 0.04827028512954712, 0.020906656980514526, 0.010532105341553688, 0.03999723494052887, -0.008990060538053513, -0.021476222202181816, 0.05858972668647766, 0.052139267325401306, 0.007797376252710819, -0.03767827898263931, -0.009263260290026665, -0.04020501673221588, 0.0021042057778686285, -0.006249635014683008, -0.03258739411830902, 0.052522096782922745, 0.002058962360024452, -0.016618546098470688, 0.036056410521268845, -0.030090272426605225, 0.03341778740286827, 0.049878593534231186, -0.004481935407966375, -0.03571747615933418, 0.024513861164450645, 0.027076322585344315, -0.006171807646751404, 0.041447460651397705, 0.02631482109427452, 0.048684220761060715, 0.013933088630437851, 0.007965926080942154, 0.027659974992275238, 0.04450223594903946, -0.0008352691656909883, -0.01373197976499796, 0.049316126853227615, -0.018934469670057297, 0.02456432394683361, 0.0016745352186262608, -0.006757109891623259, 0.003555349074304104, 0.018060728907585144, -0.0011709034442901611, -0.05656398460268974, 0.047622326761484146, -0.010884767398238182, 0.03477131947875023, -0.010707559064030647, -0.03725043684244156, -0.046770043671131134, -0.05682826042175293, 0.03242688998579979, 0.005573455709964037, -0.010856842622160912, -0.016393398866057396, -0.01591912843286991, -0.0008777750190347433, -0.010888069868087769, -0.03027082048356533, -0.02330269291996956, 0.01050836592912674, 0.016603713855147362, -0.004933071322739124, -0.0011714727152138948, 0.009714862331748009, -0.0009783543646335602, -0.020638925954699516, 0.04330917447805405, 0.07336662709712982, 0.025327282026410103, 0.004217265173792839, 0.04685959219932556, -0.03452509269118309, -0.06676837801933289, 0.022184841334819794, 0.04040472209453583, -0.012359865009784698, -0.06677281856536865, 0.048283662647008896, -0.02046338841319084, 0.015581520274281502, 0.0421893447637558, 0.025160759687423706, 0.03885115310549736, -0.009446087293326855, -0.08720255643129349, -0.03438742458820343, 0.040164411067962646, -0.008470935747027397, -0.0005854538176208735, -0.04646054282784462, 0.04116310179233551, 0.06441430747509003, 0.05360323563218117, 0.0027247515972703695, 0.06801970303058624, -0.007506073452532291, 0.016779521480202675, 0.030121825635433197, -0.057591527700424194, -0.01684909500181675, -0.02837413176894188, -0.0037832707166671753, -0.03746460750699043, -0.08097708225250244, 0.010934997349977493, 0.021885959431529045, 0.007589819375425577, -0.03423361852765083, 0.01870298758149147, -0.023646852001547813, -0.01264489721506834, -0.03445008397102356, -0.029113078489899635, -0.02663044072687626, 0.07143805176019669, 0.033035799860954285, 0.06268139183521271, -0.016030652448534966, -0.02114221267402172, 0.0036717690527439117, 0.005158433225005865, 0.01981300488114357, 0.033642932772636414, -0.03534611687064171, 0.0431857593357563, -0.0013124928809702396, 0.02584920823574066, 0.015165706165134907, -0.023554159328341484, -0.013362499885261059, -0.029100041836500168, -0.01010151021182537, -0.016796119511127472, -0.018583033233880997, -0.014508238062262535, 0.018268637359142303, 0.007154084276407957, -0.04629531875252724, -0.05486010015010834, -0.07038191705942154, 0.01656975969672203, 0.0076821777038276196, -0.01688537746667862, 0.023376991972327232, -0.01036873273551464, -0.005104506853967905, -0.020892100408673286, -0.020577426999807358, -0.0018202535575255752, -0.028951115906238556, 0.020696653053164482, -0.041538577526807785, -0.020983582362532616, 0.03722592815756798, -0.003465282032266259, 0.02077747881412506, 0.03596852347254753, -0.014712793752551079, -0.049457352608442307, 0.002663068473339081, -0.0058896285481750965, 0.02030215412378311, -0.032578255981206894, -0.04477743059396744, 0.03225567936897278, -0.012542064301669598, -0.02715880237519741, 0.010960686951875687, -0.058477144688367844, 0.07591524720191956, 0.0750420019030571, 0.004852043464779854, -0.0222481582313776, 0.02551397867500782, 0.009557942859828472, -0.0029803505167365074, -0.02465592510998249, -0.02264563925564289, -0.04435893893241882, -0.018136145547032356, 0.02288128435611725, 0.019881799817085266, -0.02127128653228283, 0.042097464203834534, 0.046295780688524246, 0.04335753992199898, 0.02396123670041561, 0.02168869972229004, 0.0018043452873826027, -0.043859630823135376, 0.036751944571733475, 0.04709377512335777, 0.02777717635035515, -0.0025149520952254534, -0.017342856153845787, -0.0024071545340120792, 0.026046043261885643, 0.00840772595256567, 0.01314463373273611, 0.036112409085035324, -0.054683804512023926, 0.006032104138284922, -0.009884735569357872, 0.009349866770207882, -0.005821847822517157, 0.009760200046002865, 0.0013158959336578846, 0.04168402776122093, 0.023954713717103004, 0.0037671260070055723, -0.027085289359092712, -0.04002394527196884, 0.009771266020834446, 0.014256538823246956, -0.014759058132767677, -0.002099586185067892, 0.017131997272372246, -0.005231936927884817, 0.01679890602827072, -0.049293648451566696, -0.008971821516752243, -0.025824300944805145, 0.02340027131140232, 0.015384207479655743, 0.00831139087677002, 0.0018410986522212625, -0.035486944019794464, -0.02454337105154991, 0.013448796235024929, 0.00815747119486332, 0.00955851748585701, -0.014886797405779362, -0.04408916085958481, 0.011623946018517017, -0.03555861487984657, -0.006001447327435017, 0.06773196905851364, -0.0003490642411634326, -0.021438218653202057, -0.014309994876384735, 0.006237333174794912, -0.05559647083282471, -0.03249581530690193, -0.02265317365527153, 0.0071394676342606544, 0.0057739149779081345, -0.044616296887397766, 0.039308737963438034, 0.017494402825832367, -0.03592851758003235, 0.023918919265270233, 0.0014068507589399815, -0.012319070287048817, -0.02452845312654972, 0.003721400164067745, 0.0032545102294534445, -0.020713886246085167, 0.015816936269402504, 0.03378154709935188, -0.030354764312505722, -0.0050816768780350685, -0.05365094169974327, -0.048852961510419846, 0.023038817569613457, -0.007019971963018179, 0.022793425247073174, 0.04165727645158768, -0.014010753482580185, 0.07752620428800583, 0.025882357731461525, -0.00758623331785202, -0.009769011288881302, 0.014852827414870262, -0.00870063528418541, 0.0028508256655186415, -0.04671913757920265, 0.007823005318641663, -0.01277356967329979, 0.004022371489554644, -0.015409855172038078, 0.025600850582122803, 0.06036617234349251, -0.022423233836889267, 0.0029363431967794895, 0.02452482469379902, -0.0016734080854803324, 0.005064220633357763, 0.019990721717476845, 0.02603870816528797, 0.0019319826969876885, 0.014689224772155285, 0.02229599840939045, 0.0030908561311662197, -0.012751788832247257, -0.01978345774114132, 0.0189005509018898, -0.03140721097588539, 0.012351209297776222, -0.04588336870074272, 0.04379326477646828, -0.007174707483500242, -0.06499332189559937, 0.005571696907281876, 0.02311604656279087, 0.024679360911250114, -0.042146921157836914, -0.008455689065158367, 0.03194264695048332, 0.014748973771929741, -0.027972038835287094, -0.002293737605214119, -0.018384529277682304, -0.009240041486918926, 0.02032487839460373, -0.06102527305483818, -0.02142411470413208, 0.034759219735860825, 0.047975536435842514, 0.03925834596157074, 0.0050241583958268166, -0.03572887182235718, -0.01264574658125639, -0.055717144161462784, 0.02693815901875496, -0.02029436267912388, 0.06184610351920128, 0.002794065047055483, 0.033516984432935715, 0.02744593471288681, 0.004053278360515833, -0.006564082577824593, 0.020741980522871017, -0.09531915187835693, -0.0007993087056092918, -0.016678674146533012, -0.020830556750297546, 0.013525499030947685, -0.020423226058483124, 0.04839228093624115, 0.020343707874417305, 0.006354044657200575, 0.00222217314876616, 0.0009326555300503969, -0.036524105817079544, 0.03245497867465019, -0.0351889505982399, -0.009220270439982414, -0.023107215762138367, -0.008041228167712688, 0.01050697360187769, -0.03401891887187958, 0.03326413780450821, 0.03484499827027321, -0.06140756979584694, -0.005534807685762644, 0.0037695979699492455, 0.01077238004654646, 0.02021043747663498, 0.009180016815662384, 0.018917351961135864, 0.051069438457489014, -0.030336035415530205, 0.00968476478010416, 0.03390984609723091, 0.08279839158058167, 0.05819988250732422, -0.044101081788539886, -0.011615739203989506, -0.04543306306004524, -0.026107946410775185, 0.052935730665922165, 0.0045511070638895035, -0.0051917945966124535, -0.00983726792037487, 0.07385332882404327, 0.023152772337198257, -0.07991757243871689, 0.03248361125588417, 0.054202791303396225, -0.01110885851085186, 0.013086382299661636, -0.03909555450081825, -0.0028140684589743614, -0.014490535482764244, 0.001495030359365046, 0.04892503842711449, -0.011188258416950703, -0.019980404525995255, -0.02402433194220066, -0.011532762087881565, -0.007912262342870235, -0.041927073150873184, 0.00025233131600543857, 0.02948434092104435, 0.0030547231435775757, 0.004474898334592581, -0.03998687118291855, 0.00722044100984931, 0.0491660013794899, 0.044613029807806015, 0.027422940358519554, -0.03128037601709366, -0.06327633559703827, -0.014521385543048382, 0.04955710843205452, 0.04782161861658096, -0.02843555435538292, 0.020822471007704735, -0.05199303850531578, -0.021554576233029366, 0.023320836946368217, -0.004956180229783058, 0.03316914290189743, -0.005222962237894535, -0.0077952672727406025, -0.012333083897829056, -0.0015029130736365914, -0.04695865139365196, -0.023793498054146767, -0.011931615881621838, 0.03393762186169624, -0.0032298231963068247, -0.03823326528072357, -0.06704081594944, 0.0014891945756971836, -0.023706527426838875, 0.04195389151573181, -0.04359718784689903, -0.01291546132415533, -0.00943209882825613, -0.0007177027291618288, -0.013628371991217136, -0.07001840323209763, 0.014728751964867115, -0.018890483304858208, 0.002472644904628396, 0.04395666718482971, -0.02816186100244522, -0.05819476768374443, 0.08552737534046173, 0.020264331251382828, -0.0002862572146113962, -0.02493811957538128, -0.0298015084117651, 0.022111739963293076, 0.030418625101447105, 0.0002226535725640133, 0.04258346185088158, -0.0030814027413725853, 0.01818658411502838, 0.01108565740287304, -0.011286351829767227, 0.018634824082255363, -0.03980041667819023, 0.009100276976823807, -0.029448388144373894, 0.0006438685231842101, -0.06627090275287628, 0.049223072826862335, 0.017734955996274948, 0.01274237409234047, -0.036001190543174744, -0.04630999639630318, 0.02188144437968731, 0.05459879711270332, -0.02874820865690708, 0.007425593212246895, -0.011359984055161476, 0.02360263280570507, -0.03305554389953613, 0.01562776044011116, 0.003142661415040493, -0.04142480343580246, 0.035373784601688385, 0.029860788956284523, -0.030716506764292717, -0.012451797723770142, -0.009592666290700436, -0.021378522738814354, 0.011326066218316555, -0.02044890820980072, 0.036750972270965576, 0.00582272419705987, 0.04056699946522713, -0.0013401488540694118, -0.05864938348531723, -0.0004391746479086578, 0.01811394654214382, -0.015776701271533966, 0.013675716705620289, -0.02873508632183075, 0.05213638022542, -0.019675932824611664, 0.028660796582698822, -0.06982681155204773, -0.04939818009734154, -0.002815825631842017, 0.0009458738495595753, -0.04781634360551834, -0.023194462060928345, 0.0002970487985294312, 0.01078670285642147, -0.02710878849029541, -0.02341192215681076, 0.04476035386323929, -0.010602593421936035, -0.029621142894029617, 0.0019514515297487378, 0.03404625132679939, 0.0467182956635952, -0.014202839694917202, 0.031253632158041, 0.042839258909225464, -0.03200950101017952, -0.0029201821889728308, 0.004552519414573908, 0.029144354164600372, -0.04805009812116623, -0.042840562760829926, -0.03140631690621376, -0.002808624180033803, 0.04445786401629448, -0.018279721960425377, -0.034571997821331024, 0.027736112475395203, -0.001364157535135746, 0.006744928192347288, -0.016733236610889435, -0.019045352935791016, -0.013835283927619457, 0.020977335050702095, -0.00019230879843235016, -0.016670426353812218, -0.007964994758367538, 0.018677787855267525, 0.09170565754175186, 0.017208438366651535, -0.018036359921097755, 0.04623175784945488, 0.08698292076587677, -0.04665130004286766, 0.020673805847764015, -0.026815932244062424, -0.038600049912929535, 0.0109543576836586, 0.031619951128959656, -0.0021050707437098026, 0.02820969931781292, -0.010515025816857815, -0.006801236420869827, -0.028231767937541008, -0.07260529696941376, 0.023230427876114845, 0.0005359962815418839, 0.01755603961646557, 0.028511911630630493, 0.03478146344423294, -0.015769099816679955, -0.016107724979519844, -0.014092471450567245, -0.0225738026201725, -0.03811254724860191, 0.0032136032823473215, 0.03146842494606972, 0.01202706340700388, -0.0017947775777429342, 0.042507804930210114, 0.008510765619575977, 0.02370286174118519, 0.007775519043207169, 0.02621990628540516, 0.03558950126171112, 0.030752647668123245, -0.016960807144641876, -0.01172682736068964, 0.04325011372566223, -0.026151860132813454, 0.018766120076179504, -0.013416970148682594, -0.025968391448259354, 0.04234490543603897, 0.03978383168578148, 0.00023803432122804224, -0.046111296862363815, -0.014913571998476982, -0.07388724386692047, 0.0033734089229255915, 0.04151999205350876, 0.03818835690617561, 0.047315459698438644, -0.0011132728541269898, 0.0024997862055897713, 0.006675361189991236, 0.019981570541858673, 0.001242255326360464, -0.04302158206701279, -0.06654199212789536, -0.012882653623819351, -0.022530503571033478, 0.016104532405734062, 0.020367348566651344, -0.004313796758651733, 0.0306444950401783, -0.05882735550403595, 0.05043645203113556, -0.004736245609819889, 0.040043942630290985, -0.04112660884857178, 0.05236005038022995, -0.011632144451141357, 0.009621704928576946, -0.0037564262747764587, -0.029416872188448906, 0.13961046934127808, 0.052446745336055756, 0.05437377840280533, -0.07704193890094757, 0.028859173879027367, -0.02131468430161476, -0.025306960567831993, -0.027391530573368073, -0.020244374871253967, 0.026108641177415848, 0.00195767218247056, 0.014354735612869263, 0.0016050897538661957, 0.010968816466629505, 0.02337000146508217, 0.03234482929110527, -0.030762499198317528, -0.013017366640269756, 0.021672870963811874, -0.0017686812207102776, -0.011586089618504047, -0.03895244002342224, -0.01395831536501646, 0.0136689692735672, 0.01939663663506508, -0.02580464631319046, -0.011547090485692024, -0.0037206297274678946, -0.004814570304006338, -0.016429834067821503, 0.03357410803437233, -0.015576080419123173, -0.015867887064814568, -0.006323755718767643, 0.019100410863757133, -0.00236882409080863, 0.02424592711031437, -0.03157132863998413, -0.00020527958986349404, 0.06381545960903168, 0.00864992942661047, 0.005233248230069876, -0.012034958228468895, 0.009545940905809402, -0.0074261329136788845, -0.035654108971357346, -0.021896518766880035, 0.04934655502438545, -0.004578468855470419, -0.013247866183519363, 0.01227062102407217, 0.0045026130974292755, -0.012686191126704216, -0.028577739372849464, 0.013983288779854774, 0.02158016338944435, 0.029406456276774406, -0.026077251881361008, -0.005708328913897276, 0.0025697469245642424, 0.014291632920503616, -0.005284383427351713, 0.020288165658712387, 0.006914246827363968, -0.04380092769861221, -0.009021302685141563, -0.020513838157057762, 0.005646007135510445, -0.0014839894138276577, 0.018047552555799484, -0.021638456732034683, 0.007213602773845196, -0.0458865649998188, -0.009985750541090965, -0.018622003495693207, -0.03265926614403725, 0.04224403202533722, -0.02532110922038555, -0.00010877639579121023, -0.014877459034323692, -0.05067163705825806, 0.027330700308084488, -0.03347103297710419, 0.028956135734915733, -0.034867044538259506, -0.028686154633760452, -0.012841650284826756, 0.03469071537256241, 0.02657550387084484, -0.000891508418135345, 0.007271171547472477, 0.04209356755018234, -0.009428789839148521, -0.01583307795226574, 0.003213150193914771, -0.020370373502373695, -0.04470377787947655, 0.026664678007364273, 0.017761295661330223, 0.03709609806537628, -0.0012213689042255282, 0.004518498200923204, -0.019025443121790886, -0.01193158607929945, -0.008403804153203964, -0.016378402709960938, 0.033152025192976, -0.05014599487185478, -0.011287757195532322, 0.03878142684698105, -0.008376643992960453, -0.03056183084845543, -0.017117705196142197, -0.03358550742268562, -0.0149734728038311, -0.001629215432330966, -0.0125328553840518, -0.06676123291254044, -0.008844699710607529, 0.030357414856553078, 0.02584904246032238, 0.004850698634982109, -0.017528342083096504, 0.007506791967898607, -0.017296893522143364, -0.00797711219638586, -0.009675380773842335, -0.011488400399684906, -0.0033694058656692505, -0.01909516379237175, 0.030341537669301033, 0.023990636691451073, -0.0277087464928627, 0.00006299413507804275, 0.03364761918783188, 0.031056910753250122, 0.016325296834111214, 0.021335801109671593, -0.08056631684303284, 0.003921918570995331, 0.04183390364050865, -0.08696584403514862, -0.013475070707499981, 0.03859546035528183, -0.008281880989670753, 0.03718755021691322, 0.01262673083692789, 0.007323126308619976, -0.004375339485704899, -0.012875474989414215, -0.017717968672513962, -0.012826311402022839, 0.015499277971684933, 0.02094404213130474, 0.006003416609019041, -0.004848991986364126, 0.005956337321549654, -0.024652494117617607, 0.04132023826241493, 0.0334412083029747, 0.08024784177541733, 0.014491990208625793, -0.02349047176539898, 0.01763213239610195, 0.0014011352322995663, 0.034852493554353714, 0.03433195501565933, 0.018137067556381226, 0.03090832382440567, 0.04137447476387024, -0.0072847106494009495, 0.02355964295566082, -0.03700895980000496, 0.004136153496801853, -0.14143219590187073, -0.024427421391010284, 0.0041145747527480125, 0.008766714483499527, 0.03809386491775513, -0.06208903342485428, 0.0013822977198287845, 0.033005207777023315, -0.05226876586675644, -0.007662512827664614, -0.014741508290171623, -0.009331262670457363, -0.02716010808944702, 0.010458244010806084, -0.022410785779356956, 0.023841436952352524, 0.042717304080724716, -0.011588742956519127, 0.060021769255399704, 0.004899254068732262, -0.004910992458462715, -0.013796873390674591, 0.006678151898086071, 0.061025068163871765, -0.025989456102252007, -0.04253261908888817, 0.044608186930418015, -0.03025646135210991, -0.04605383425951004, 0.04520155116915703, 0.008081805892288685, 0.0014517318923026323, 0.04513368755578995, 0.03004290908575058, 0.010274950414896011, 0.016820650547742844, 0.055484339594841, 0.006497033406049013, 0.02761846035718918, -0.006870209705084562, 0.023203037679195404, 0.026611387729644775, -0.0006034368998371065, 0.027257025241851807, 0.030435919761657715, -0.014671608805656433, -0.024622708559036255, 0.030490295961499214, -0.0022355506662279367, -0.025389915332198143, 0.017150238156318665, 0.00832973513752222, -0.005953314248472452, -0.043850596994161606, 0.0473695732653141, -0.018139827996492386, -0.001802405808120966, 0.045692890882492065, 0.03310418501496315, -0.005678233690559864, 0.0037119267508387566, -0.048552006483078, -0.03459182754158974, 0.029484190046787262, -0.017492977902293205, -0.020728839561343193, -0.0654551088809967, 0.012117389589548111, 0.01999012939631939, 0.01853969879448414, -0.023042211309075356, -0.00868310872465372, -0.042528003454208374, 0.008112027309834957, -0.005388111807405949, 0.017374377697706223, -0.007728217635303736, 0.006587586831301451, 0.0029768645763397217, -0.09596136212348938, 0.06007704138755798, -0.02007642760872841, -0.023938041180372238, -0.017972461879253387, -0.008070309646427631, -0.040045365691185, -0.008747326210141182, 0.03790668025612831, 0.02003527618944645, -0.0192986149340868, 0.015828566625714302, 0.0396704375743866, 0.0026724939234554768, -0.03810020536184311, 0.022319329902529716, -0.04069506376981735, 0.029522400349378586, -0.040741004049777985, -0.005844081752002239, 0.02044171839952469, 0.019881771877408028, 0.02284364216029644, -0.03438977524638176, 0.01627780869603157, 0.019487598910927773, 0.007566686253994703, 0.001960622612386942, 0.0006299075321294367, 0.014668533578515053, 0.024729257449507713, 0.004517362918704748, 0.037231218069791794, -0.0007037842296995223, 0.01754883863031864, -0.08512479066848755, 0.01976092904806137, -0.04960934445261955, -0.044382281601428986, 0.008880732581019402, 0.021050279960036278, 0.00745543884113431, -0.0634118914604187, -0.0341431200504303, 0.012707915157079697, -0.05024823173880577, -0.023163488134741783, 0.02300502173602581, 0.04003499820828438, 0.039565421640872955, 0.027797088027000427, 0.0034234344493597746, 0.012545161880552769, -0.0075793182477355, -0.03742792829871178, 0.015142570249736309, 0.031769752502441406, -0.013514230959117413, 0.03778687119483948, 0.02144271694123745, -0.031160863116383553, 0.014364143833518028, 0.023998912423849106, 0.05705663934350014, -0.03583988919854164, -0.010297867469489574, 0.007963295094668865, -0.021434299647808075, 0.004798065405339003, -0.014379763044416904, 0.0005960075068287551, 0.07071470469236374, -0.010188233107328415, 0.021817289292812347, -0.026657799258828163, -0.023064885288476944, -0.0209632758051157, 0.012977383099496365, -0.00817542802542448, 0.07012386620044708, 0.007072382140904665, 0.005915055051445961, 0.004795452579855919, 0.02917916141450405, 0.04757507145404816, -0.03295382112264633, 0.021889323368668556, 0.019905276596546173, 0.010300518944859505, -0.03858795762062073, -0.03365623950958252, 0.02482314221560955, -0.0031121845822781324, -0.005579792894423008, 0.031569890677928925, 0.025506749749183655, -0.012052175588905811, -0.017148327082395554, -0.011943905614316463, 0.06528236716985703, -0.040994979441165924, 0.015030782669782639, -0.05777668580412865, -0.01634146273136139, -0.018886305391788483, -0.008588752709329128 ]
<p>I asked a group of subjects to make a series of 12 binary choices regarding preferences. </p> <p>Let's say for arguments sake, these were between ugly (<code>ug</code>), attractive (<code>att</code>), and neutral (<code>neut</code>) faces. Hence, we have 4 <code>ug</code> vs <code>att</code>, 4 <code>ug</code> vs <code>neut</code> and 4 <code>att</code> vs <code>neut</code> choices. For each subject I summed the number of times each face was chosen. Hence, I have a 3 column table comprising a score (max 8) for <code>Att</code>, <code>Ug</code> and <code>Neut</code> for each subject. Each row sums to 12 hence the variables are negatively correlated.</p> <p>My questions:</p> <ul> <li>Are attractive faces preferred to ugly and if so:</li> <li>Is this driven by an attraction to <code>att</code> or an aversion to <code>ug</code> or both? - this is why we have choices with the neutral faces.</li> </ul> <p>I originally thought to do a repeated measures ANOVA followed by <em>post hoc</em> tests to look for differences in ratings but i'm wondering if the fact that the DVs all sum to a constant is problematic because in essence the third variable - say $neut = 12-(ug+att)$. If so, is MANOVA the way to go, or how about chi-square?</p>
36,534
[ -0.05363202467560768, -0.01913311518728733, 0.009351834654808044, 0.023956885561347008, 0.051703937351703644, 0.04574155434966087, -0.015623237937688828, 0.011719286441802979, 0.021450670436024666, -0.026567738503217697, -0.006718687247484922, 0.018651658669114113, 0.031221818178892136, 0.017329784110188484, -0.008932380937039852, 0.0028644672129303217, -0.04270065203309059, -0.010256035253405571, 0.01209330651909113, 0.008058225736021996, -0.006113351322710514, 0.06209087371826172, 0.02101234160363674, -0.039571329951286316, -0.022383157163858414, 0.05822873115539551, -0.01420542597770691, -0.07079680263996124, 0.035189855843782425, 0.031971778720617294, 0.0013860237086191773, -0.03893392160534859, -0.0005293895956128836, 0.02711329236626625, 0.017264459282159805, 0.011652939021587372, 0.014521170407533646, -0.0014328458346426487, 0.0016373761463910341, 0.018720369786024094, -0.025304635986685753, -0.01858869008719921, -0.014854155480861664, 0.02872876264154911, -0.01996372640132904, -0.01944587007164955, -0.022455111145973206, -0.03152737393975258, -0.0024041261058300734, -0.07856517285108566, 0.06480463594198227, 0.0025999913923442364, 0.04216143861413002, 0.055336181074380875, 0.011298710480332375, -0.032945021986961365, 0.02257302589714527, 0.04331817850470543, -0.0003689813893288374, -0.05409163981676102, 0.008422954939305782, -0.030619744211435318, 0.009052404202520847, -0.0016993902390822768, -0.020700853317975998, 0.06473574042320251, -0.008527365513145924, -0.013699072413146496, 0.026231950148940086, -0.02674845978617668, 0.02703850343823433, 0.04189162701368332, 0.022108037024736404, 0.007381518837064505, 0.01445538830012083, 0.0014754622243344784, 0.03388272598385811, 0.015080885030329227, 0.04641113430261612, 0.06006338819861412, -0.0026710424572229385, 0.02118552289903164, 0.003558318130671978, 0.05588657036423683, 0.029261430725455284, 0.009336667135357857, 0.04671049118041992, -0.058870937675237656, 0.0063973041251301765, 0.05116533488035202, -0.0030966391786932945, -0.020259438082575798, 0.03240695595741272, 0.044880982488393784, -0.07151756435632706, 0.036239560693502426, -0.027955835685133934, 0.03831210732460022, 0.0015154011780396104, -0.020592516288161278, -0.0328424870967865, 0.02451144903898239, 0.014327244833111763, 0.055509522557258606, -0.026609258726239204, -0.004081356339156628, -0.03729214146733284, 0.02660825476050377, 0.028269410133361816, -0.04815371707081795, -0.038018662482500076, 0.015446558594703674, -0.036928098648786545, -0.012306260876357555, 0.0012637048494070768, -0.03897637873888016, -0.03558199107646942, -0.04268362745642662, 0.05301593244075775, 0.05027611553668976, 0.0209959764033556, -0.03448028117418289, 0.044127099215984344, -0.023515908047556877, -0.03999479487538338, 0.03595719486474991, 0.03134242445230484, -0.0038662035949528217, -0.025850018486380577, 0.06467871367931366, -0.023921845480799675, 0.015493675135076046, 0.028189081698656082, 0.009506702423095703, -0.005214422009885311, 0.003138132393360138, -0.07718747109174728, -0.07573896646499634, 0.006423820275813341, -0.032582711428403854, -0.03383477404713631, -0.08012078702449799, -0.011342925950884819, 0.04238518327474594, 0.05969813093543053, -0.03560000658035278, 0.012130566872656345, 0.012279530055820942, 0.03522687405347824, 0.04673780873417854, -0.017511654645204544, -0.0004532791208475828, -0.04544887691736221, -0.049850691109895706, -0.011333961971104145, -0.08946593850851059, 0.026483433321118355, 0.043729253113269806, 0.012269263155758381, -0.015830369666218758, 0.041616931557655334, 0.023805201053619385, -0.03604070097208023, 0.009392306208610535, 0.010021979920566082, -0.028501465916633606, 0.04723140969872475, -0.021142249926924706, 0.03077187016606331, 0.005748786963522434, 0.006083858199417591, 0.03643496334552765, 0.009585944935679436, 0.04673115164041519, 0.03476578742265701, -0.005687644239515066, 0.0012658891500905156, -0.008109845221042633, -0.007647973019629717, 0.005024468991905451, -0.027106288820505142, -0.046914808452129364, -0.0441286526620388, -0.02073110267519951, 0.04542839154601097, 0.04272838681936264, -0.013052941299974918, -0.009641572833061218, 0.05817968398332596, -0.05589322745800018, -0.041699137538671494, -0.1071821078658104, 0.013022933155298233, 0.015799090266227722, -0.04802710935473442, 0.020641876384615898, -0.006956018973141909, -0.015704575926065445, 0.024751709774136543, -0.008816612884402275, -0.0025415057316422462, 0.019007131457328796, 0.08479510247707367, -0.0312037393450737, 0.0062739048153162, 0.058146364986896515, 0.015492518432438374, -0.028148135170340538, 0.03110463358461857, -0.029928255826234818, -0.041034895926713943, -0.019396724179387093, -0.02670256420969963, 0.04098997265100479, -0.027739256620407104, -0.005796334706246853, 0.017986714839935303, 0.008557625114917755, -0.03091229498386383, 0.07207530736923218, -0.06079981103539467, 0.0678044781088829, 0.05519432574510574, -0.029511891305446625, 0.012466385960578918, 0.02388870157301426, 0.020295249298214912, 0.04665873572230339, -0.05086558312177658, 0.00374094070866704, -0.058277517557144165, 0.00205332157202065, 0.04384898766875267, 0.021542811766266823, -0.027971280738711357, 0.02303594909608364, 0.03460730239748955, 0.01995943672955036, 0.015527162700891495, 0.04176726192235947, 0.017551356926560402, -0.027403270825743675, 0.011448973789811134, 0.02328355237841606, 0.03390501067042351, 0.005853790789842606, -0.011482398957014084, -0.01629815436899662, 0.003385029034689069, 0.02945505455136299, -0.0072828056290745735, 0.04334498569369316, 0.017460249364376068, 0.016993505880236626, -0.06848452240228653, 0.004934418480843306, 0.04297864809632301, -0.012014908716082573, 0.004841349553316832, 0.03645222634077072, 0.03162794187664986, -0.03696471452713013, -0.008547959849238396, -0.03706306219100952, 0.006489947438240051, 0.03641912341117859, -0.011559830978512764, -0.003110352670773864, 0.0012024784227833152, -0.008938311599195004, 0.044573958963155746, -0.015480222180485725, -0.00626467727124691, -0.01677853614091873, 0.019775716587901115, 0.014877940528094769, 0.025812258943915367, 0.012996071949601173, -0.04464280977845192, -0.013304159045219421, 0.003354722401127219, -0.006072051823139191, -0.0005948691978119314, 0.036590609699487686, -0.058492135256528854, -0.05088480934500694, -0.02978195808827877, -0.019499629735946655, 0.03969213366508484, 0.00294283963739872, 0.006588519550859928, 0.05226074159145355, 0.024342436343431473, -0.026216063648462296, -0.037610046565532684, -0.0030718641355633736, 0.02505735121667385, -0.026266172528266907, -0.036201994866132736, 0.012850063852965832, 0.008452581241726875, -0.024372518062591553, 0.04022267833352089, -0.026950394734740257, -0.04374217987060547, 0.031535543501377106, -0.010076163336634636, 0.002716449787840247, -0.023625515401363373, -0.005647522863000631, 0.0093583008274436, -0.004571526776999235, -0.01752081699669361, -0.09274765104055405, -0.04434286803007126, 0.049850430339574814, -0.0029408144764602184, 0.02716171182692051, 0.021079502999782562, -0.035680655390024185, 0.08631139248609543, 0.06758137047290802, -0.027536951005458832, -0.06141732633113861, -0.032951291650533676, -0.043390028178691864, -0.030740704387426376, 0.026694035157561302, 0.033533766865730286, -0.0038788665551692247, 0.040101245045661926, 0.003888770006597042, 0.031214581802487373, 0.02689962647855282, 0.01331042405217886, -0.014540143311023712, 0.01761852391064167, 0.0017282527405768633, -0.03650719299912453, 0.01749911904335022, 0.03152761608362198, -0.015935927629470825, 0.00395390996709466, 0.035647451877593994, 0.013152716681361198, -0.004619027953594923, -0.048153046518564224, 0.022940339520573616, -0.030116021633148193, 0.0070454212836921215, -0.01636558212339878, 0.027534373104572296, 0.011923529207706451, -0.020128007978200912, -0.02477138675749302, 0.008499455638229847, 0.06355197727680206, -0.03951088711619377, 0.019662214443087578, 0.04886860027909279, 0.03218691423535347, 0.003782226238399744, -0.026285305619239807, 0.013637405820190907, 0.018193403258919716, 0.035344094038009644, -0.01510708685964346, 0.026031872257590294, 0.018060952425003052, 0.052693597972393036, 0.019883841276168823, 0.018134742975234985, -0.053447820246219635, 0.009256408549845219, -0.06379105895757675, 0.0005124727031216025, -0.061708979308605194, 0.031447313725948334, 0.0055576288141310215, 0.035266727209091187, -0.013255062513053417, -0.008902784436941147, -0.023299777880311012, -0.01533210463821888, -0.06044425815343857, 0.035562776029109955, 0.006565575022250414, 0.010347705334424973, 0.01746678724884987, 0.007524993270635605, 0.008887513540685177, -0.04080504924058914, 0.008337900042533875, -0.03373749554157257, 0.03252144902944565, 0.0029465453699231148, 0.005202048923820257, -0.029033970087766647, -0.017139442265033722, -0.0023854312021285295, 0.028096243739128113, 0.002657433971762657, -0.054384324699640274, 0.004571959841996431, 0.014779074117541313, -0.016374927014112473, -0.0035099652595818043, -0.01639537140727043, 0.0210951566696167, 0.02153516374528408, 0.05757984146475792, 0.014048450626432896, 0.03072826936841011, -0.014609762467443943, 0.04164111986756325, -0.00970066711306572, 0.023460019379854202, 0.013699925504624844, -0.004940961953252554, -0.02204328589141369, -0.08100377768278122, -0.056344036012887955, -0.024061081930994987, 0.009499629959464073, 0.036736637353897095, -0.016928505152463913, 0.04871291667222977, 0.02908056043088436, -0.031398601830005646, 0.0052790092304348946, 0.025655187666416168, 0.018072135746479034, -0.03129039332270622, -0.04073038324713707, 0.005549001041799784, 0.00820449460297823, 0.022821780294179916, 0.08426836133003235, 0.039139557629823685, -0.007325850427150726, -0.018133513629436493, 0.017105715349316597, -0.011415277607738972, -0.03258892893791199, -0.013788996264338493, 0.03051041066646576, 0.05596110597252846, 0.010786869563162327, -0.02160528674721718, 0.01138988696038723, 0.0579959899187088, 0.03592507541179657, 0.028219087049365044, -0.04404535889625549, -0.08750656992197037, 0.00865471176803112, 0.035552605986595154, 0.03797759860754013, -0.048809852451086044, 0.00176956073846668, 0.006670290604233742, 0.002107783453539014, 0.011870115995407104, -0.010388141497969627, 0.04854458570480347, -0.005460334941744804, 0.008595465682446957, -0.026390258222818375, -0.037132393568754196, -0.034300897270441055, 0.005536634474992752, -0.013619930483400822, 0.01946745626628399, 0.01962004043161869, -0.054547205567359924, -0.028719736263155937, 0.025762300938367844, 0.0086970878764987, 0.04385415464639664, -0.02827220968902111, -0.018034888431429863, 0.049342118203639984, -0.018252285197377205, -0.01473468728363514, -0.03768704831600189, -0.007080497685819864, 0.010609731078147888, -0.018894018605351448, 0.0864681527018547, -0.030774487182497978, -0.008847923018038273, -0.03691265359520912, -0.012789375148713589, 0.008072979748249054, 0.028655515983700752, -0.019572041928768158, 0.03662682697176933, 0.019486382603645325, -0.01019836775958538, 0.0479653999209404, 0.012040521018207073, -0.01345351617783308, 0.01940377801656723, -0.034710843116045, 0.020136035978794098, 0.0026969476602971554, -0.03812573105096817, -0.025564854964613914, -0.03205709531903267, -0.00825418159365654, 0.016007959842681885, 0.014705676585435867, 0.03960332274436951, -0.02326120063662529, -0.041174858808517456, -0.01952734962105751, -0.0013511445140466094, 0.019443068653345108, 0.0074340347200632095, 0.03243902325630188, -0.005828622728586197, 0.02472439594566822, -0.019957521930336952, -0.005299570504575968, -0.04174476116895676, 0.011799822561442852, 0.006772757042199373, -0.04226923733949661, 0.005209462717175484, -0.026145709678530693, -0.016544250771403313, -0.004902801942080259, -0.0271480493247509, 0.04573424160480499, -0.013392346911132336, 0.022081783041357994, 0.01568707637488842, -0.031653858721256256, 0.005977783817797899, -0.0024728053249418736, 0.0062659624963998795, 0.052409201860427856, -0.023718206211924553, 0.05071504786610603, -0.01964985951781273, 0.027860267087817192, -0.05197605490684509, 0.0031780540011823177, -0.00024322091485373676, 0.0064253294840455055, -0.036689430475234985, 0.00855580996721983, -0.014134867116808891, -0.0023479305673390627, -0.010372641496360302, -0.02823767624795437, 0.0749380812048912, -0.010212332010269165, -0.01987983100116253, 0.006838745437562466, 0.06069201976060867, 0.061443030834198, 0.0010818548034876585, -0.030640987679362297, 0.001179062994197011, -0.023694822564721107, -0.015380685217678547, 0.012703954242169857, 0.01000643614679575, -0.04265178367495537, -0.00551257748156786, 0.00512779550626874, -0.017118625342845917, 0.03329680860042572, -0.003463020781055093, -0.009811907075345516, 0.000016734078599256463, 0.006767183542251587, -0.020604122430086136, -0.04445923864841461, 0.0276506170630455, -0.020059732720255852, 0.03588095307350159, -0.020398622378706932, 0.0033398736268281937, -0.02565825544297695, 0.011345872655510902, 0.034360505640506744, 0.018488610163331032, -0.03096899949014187, -0.005751838441938162, 0.04438019543886185, 0.022223256528377533, -0.0005096530076116323, 0.008641812019050121, -0.013242936693131924, 0.05551806837320328, 0.004032644908875227, 0.0082619683817029, 0.01851859875023365, 0.054632723331451416, 0.007303605321794748, -0.011768071912229061, -0.05208023637533188, 0.014928427524864674, 0.0539642870426178, -0.034721579402685165, 0.06201552227139473, 0.04539322853088379, 0.0211002379655838, -0.009633582085371017, -0.0638415664434433, 0.0017640205333009362, -0.015813415870070457, 0.01790102943778038, 0.06856466084718704, 0.015788299962878227, 0.007956421002745628, 0.02670898474752903, -0.019214345142245293, 0.008305652067065239, 0.057801567018032074, 0.004158316645771265, 0.010502510704100132, 0.012078795582056046, -0.014705151319503784, -0.02101871930062771, 0.031977713108062744, -0.08515197783708572, 0.015404813922941685, -0.048136912286281586, -0.03450537100434303, 0.027389591559767723, 0.03864789009094238, -0.003669655416160822, -0.06223754212260246, -0.05339134857058525, -0.033729590475559235, 0.0005732525605708361, 0.022852597758173943, -0.017498651519417763, -0.017041489481925964, 0.011696314439177513, 0.02780306711792946, -0.02201489359140396, 0.006723642349243164, -0.03339727967977524, -0.08563948422670364, -0.01650199480354786, 0.0007058714400045574, -0.018503455445170403, 0.026629788801074028, -0.0044676088728010654, -0.010272974148392677, -0.03998871147632599, -0.07702741026878357, -0.006260330323129892, -0.013876748271286488, 0.035041965544223785, -0.010285868309438229, 0.04764971882104874, -0.011000039987266064, 0.03164846450090408, 0.024928024038672447, 0.0029451993759721518, 0.11467418074607849, 0.06274177879095078, 0.034244995564222336, -0.06226673722267151, 0.0539710596203804, 0.005564240738749504, -0.010612367652356625, -0.04252861440181732, 0.02755887061357498, 0.012316156178712845, 0.0077659012749791145, 0.04354703426361084, 0.05210651084780693, 0.01965724676847458, -0.030286064371466637, 0.07594380527734756, -0.02232304774224758, -0.03074188157916069, 0.038840193301439285, -0.0003138655156362802, 0.036143913865089417, -0.006962114945054054, -0.012102389708161354, -0.013349966146051884, 0.03128500655293465, -0.001601044787093997, -0.0169419776648283, -0.019149698317050934, 0.010937373153865337, -0.020186293870210648, 0.0014676472637802362, -0.0057533844374120235, 0.015934228897094727, 0.009321464225649834, -0.01469514798372984, -0.008395293727517128, 0.018429402261972427, -0.035442933440208435, 0.028522511944174767, 0.046471793204545975, -0.014166935347020626, -0.005550585687160492, 0.018368173390626907, 0.02226288616657257, -0.0393107607960701, -0.016949331387877464, -0.019168859347701073, 0.04310063645243645, -0.018745984882116318, -0.041833583265542984, -0.01654326543211937, 0.017542552202939987, 0.015349826775491238, -0.045561160892248154, -0.0326448529958725, 0.022654809057712555, 0.059590987861156464, -0.017252499237656593, -0.04445867985486984, -0.004092860501259565, -0.0006906401831656694, 0.01438521035015583, 0.03061087429523468, 0.02665043994784355, -0.015578457154333591, -0.03174125775694847, -0.04035123437643051, 0.043326422572135925, 0.03091561608016491, -0.01171750109642744, -0.02774708718061447, -0.018237967044115067, -0.025620440021157265, -0.009244869463145733, -0.024112867191433907, 0.009138098917901516, 0.020492371171712875, 0.0045448835007846355, 0.003489651484414935, -0.0006426108884625137, -0.03684191033244133, 0.0043615964241325855, -0.04149225354194641, -0.001329585094936192, -0.03433294966816902, -0.0038664801977574825, 0.029202444478869438, 0.020374400541186333, 0.0026225748006254435, -0.02180311270058155, 0.02280930057168007, 0.05332460254430771, -0.025658976286649704, -0.018108535557985306, -0.007606040220707655, -0.03007921390235424, -0.026020413264632225, 0.0058966935612261295, -0.01909624971449375, 0.017617834731936455, -0.016585253179073334, 0.01267613098025322, 0.005035662092268467, 0.015930743888020515, 0.0019070246489718556, 0.028105691075325012, 0.05961146950721741, -0.06262063980102539, 0.013091796077787876, 0.0052434965036809444, -0.023559490218758583, -0.027868052944540977, -0.048152629286050797, -0.05458580330014229, -0.037681590765714645, -0.0008847698918543756, -0.04079905152320862, -0.029489688575267792, 0.002917809411883354, -0.022333955392241478, 0.021634520962834358, -0.0404222309589386, -0.05170188099145889, -0.04337701201438904, 0.0027764763217419386, 0.0012780383694916964, -0.003220603335648775, 0.02915249578654766, -0.00046558736357837915, -0.008111625909805298, -0.014185803942382336, 0.02795056812465191, 0.021112700924277306, 0.014588696882128716, -0.01497936062514782, 0.0004503604141063988, -0.010546493344008923, 0.03687242418527603, -0.00005451880133477971, -0.06358511000871658, 0.021930653601884842, -0.06494056433439255, 0.003596568712964654, 0.03465932607650757, 0.017053967341780663, 0.03166830539703369, -0.00526436697691679, 0.007813203148543835, -0.00855216197669506, 0.020398005843162537, -0.001431346987374127, -0.03306710347533226, -0.0013216105289757252, -0.010275117121636868, 0.007246306166052818, -0.008368442766368389, 0.00609520124271512, 0.0028659787494689226, -0.0002492550411261618, 0.038666464388370514, 0.031161757186055183, -0.004642586689442396, 0.007439263164997101, -0.03573980927467346, -0.012011755257844925, 0.012621100060641766, -0.018354831263422966, 0.015210947953164577, 0.009518464095890522, 0.029262825846672058, -0.00382912321947515, 0.03326541930437088, -0.024259023368358612, -0.014287001453340054, -0.05767426639795303, -0.003647256875410676, 0.0161418616771698, 0.022915765643119812, 0.03496536239981651, -0.0839778408408165, 0.04602401331067085, 0.002281904686242342, -0.044130511581897736, 0.022093724459409714, 0.011173318140208721, -0.000942426617257297, -0.04226190969347954, -0.030455555766820908, -0.036173272877931595, 0.014052990823984146, 0.006472079548984766, 0.01263751182705164, 0.03383275493979454, -0.004929427057504654, 0.013274735771119595, -0.011619625613093376, 0.035988304764032364, 0.03423868119716644, -0.010182186029851437, -0.07012037187814713, 0.04473226144909859, 0.003515960182994604, -0.06990297138690948, 0.04845719411969185, -0.007356506306678057, -0.0023632363881915808, 0.0326676182448864, 0.026576893404126167, 0.016981905326247215, 0.043500375002622604, 0.016435975208878517, 0.03850070759654045, 0.009785478003323078, 0.0050025153905153275, 0.020663268864154816, 0.025766009464859962, -0.009086872451007366, 0.022019609808921814, 0.025256479158997536, -0.018535660579800606, -0.009504458867013454, 0.025781070813536644, -0.022686265408992767, -0.022695008665323257, -0.00894695334136486, -0.005591116845607758, 0.04379042610526085, -0.02550073340535164, 0.014417317695915699, -0.059874068945646286, -0.0213070847094059, 0.013413414359092712, 0.014219708740711212, 0.05132802203297615, -0.005566234700381756, -0.01250963844358921, -0.028950445353984833, 0.013982469215989113, 0.012210301123559475, 0.041779760271310806, -0.031333692371845245, 0.0024519425351172686, 0.005238267593085766, 0.017319176346063614, -0.0025308465119451284, -0.01303132064640522, -0.03930281475186348, 0.03936242312192917, -0.05245625600218773, 0.01406282652169466, -0.0011207887437194586, -0.028441082686185837, -0.012870409525930882, -0.08179497718811035, 0.034356068819761276, 0.005736773833632469, -0.027760522440075874, -0.02418387308716774, 0.020704561844468117, -0.05609983205795288, 0.008639554493129253, 0.062024928629398346, -0.017287984490394592, -0.008334996178746223, 0.01136175449937582, 0.009387890808284283, -0.024841465055942535, -0.040434371680021286, 0.03954348340630531, -0.0038983041886240244, 0.0502774603664875, -0.02138184942305088, 0.019030150026082993, 0.01831854321062565, -0.01713750883936882, 0.010593962855637074, -0.03759688138961792, 0.00887153297662735, -0.004236223176121712, -0.008337507024407387, 0.04428797587752342, 0.0062309931963682175, -0.032975856214761734, 0.021942920982837677, -0.003178630257025361, 0.01795211061835289, -0.014103162102401257, -0.022846486419439316, -0.0398542545735836, 0.033433206379413605, 0.00020982135902158916, -0.02609916962683201, -0.05428867042064667, 0.008523193188011646, 0.022429410368204117, -0.07185812294483185, -0.011113711632788181, 0.009434637613594532, -0.03907771408557892, -0.018449710682034492, 0.04360325634479523, 0.03209514170885086, 0.009796889498829842, 0.005259685218334198, 0.039385829120874405, -0.022850828245282173, -0.009328493848443031, -0.009764562360942364, 0.021021194756031036, 0.03280656412243843, 0.017433565109968185, -0.039159342646598816, 0.036942578852176666, -0.03144107758998871, 0.05280116945505142, 0.0028472773265093565, -0.004358737729489803, -0.0028534773737192154, -0.0059411232359707355, 0.024995941668748856, 0.022624274715781212, 0.005242054350674152, -0.0030887878965586424, -0.004245731048285961, 0.06273284554481506, -0.02105874940752983, -0.03085138276219368, -0.018021687865257263, -0.012190684676170349, -0.04255370423197746, 0.012370442971587181, 0.005024249199777842, 0.07099486887454987, 0.01660679467022419, 0.008150004781782627, -0.011252079159021378, -0.014646457508206367, 0.011575172655284405, -0.015509629622101784, 0.002566098002716899, 0.005161673296242952, -0.046555645763874054, 0.008544345386326313, -0.027637677267193794, -0.03457383066415787, -0.02574029751121998, 0.039335545152425766, 0.020291000604629517, 0.025314638391137123, -0.018192410469055176, -0.029325192794203758, 0.002869663992896676, 0.07571639120578766, -0.035269733518362045, -0.06134423241019249, -0.006299364380538464, 0.01547109242528677, 0.00828209426254034, 0.013515855185687542 ]
<p>Assuming I have a data set with $d$ dimensions (e.g. $d=20$) so that each dimension is i.i.d. $X_i \sim U[0;1]$ (alternatively, each dimension $X_i \sim \mathcal N[0;1]$) and independent of each other.</p> <p>Now I draw a random object from this dataset and take the $k=3\cdot d$ nearest neighbors and compute PCA on this set. In contrast to what one might expect, the eigenvalues aren't all the same. In 20 dimensions uniform, a typical result looks like this:</p> <pre><code>0.11952316626613427, 0.1151758808663646, 0.11170020254046743, 0.1019390988585198, 0.0924502502204256, 0.08716272453538032, 0.0782945015348525, 0.06965903935713605, 0.06346159593226684, 0.054527131148532824, 0.05346303562884964, 0.04348400728546128, 0.042304834600062985, 0.03229641081461124, 0.031532033468325706, 0.0266801529298156, 0.020332085835946957, 0.01825531821510237, 0.01483790669963606, 0.0068195084468626625 </code></pre> <p>For normal distributed data, the results appear to be very similar, at least when rescaling them to a total sum of $1$ (the $\mathcal N[0;1]^d$ distribution clearly has a higher variance in the first place).</p> <p>I wonder if there is any result that predicts this behavior? I'm looking for a test if the series of eigenvalues is somewhat regular, and how many of the eigenvalues are as expected and which ones significantly differ from the expected values.</p> <p>For a given (small) sample size $k$, is there a result if a correlation coefficient for two variables is significant? Even i.i.d. variables will have a non-0 result occasionally for low $k$.</p>
73,952
[ -0.04100554436445236, 0.00675129285082221, 0.009378420189023018, -0.03863232955336571, 0.05356355011463165, 0.001833263668231666, -0.03608965128660202, -0.05021176487207413, 0.013538459315896034, -0.0940776914358139, 0.05416751652956009, 0.002012257231399417, 0.0419979989528656, 0.08273956179618835, 0.01023037452250719, 0.003995900042355061, -0.03407514840364456, -0.007065347861498594, -0.0023935127537697554, -0.04472488909959793, 0.03797014802694321, 0.04506704583764076, 0.0186920128762722, -0.032449401915073395, -0.022210121154785156, 0.05675685033202171, -0.0032089692540466785, -0.03874222934246063, 0.0013948350679129362, 0.05242782458662987, -0.059134840965270996, -0.004620510619133711, -0.009652847424149513, 0.039945609867572784, 0.02996252290904522, 0.008589162491261959, 0.000922052247915417, -0.02371363714337349, 0.007174778264015913, 0.05138286575675011, -0.00761211896315217, -0.03019583784043789, -0.0029025764670222998, 0.033080942928791046, 0.023614875972270966, 0.03154778108000755, 0.01861225813627243, -0.04014091193675995, 0.027268197387456894, -0.028929661959409714, 0.11752679944038391, 0.0166064091026783, -0.001100063556805253, 0.00410439120605588, -0.05259937420487404, -0.03360358253121376, 0.019562551751732826, 0.07547754049301147, 0.0015110124368220568, -0.05721684545278549, 0.02754976414144039, -0.021911276504397392, 0.006700402591377497, -0.009371872060000896, -0.041964564472436905, 0.04675595834851265, -0.018684662878513336, -0.017328793182969093, -0.008679850958287716, -0.0566704235970974, 0.028771501034498215, 0.033460475504398346, 0.025836335495114326, -0.008657013066112995, -0.02095252089202404, 0.03722035884857178, -0.000477493362268433, 0.027935601770877838, 0.04669984430074692, 0.0069663948379457, 0.015436495654284954, -0.0051759774796664715, 0.0031063633505254984, -0.00336323375813663, 0.015006433241069317, 0.010092725977301598, 0.06854813545942307, -0.026884175837039948, 0.02668120339512825, 0.006177249364554882, 0.011257622390985489, 0.009962627664208412, 0.05093447491526604, 0.0047008683905005455, -0.04550621286034584, 0.03557772561907768, 0.006349816918373108, 0.02380123920738697, -0.0012941744644194841, -0.025759505107998848, -0.022749964147806168, -0.033128127455711365, 0.0021608308888971806, 0.0339973084628582, -0.01673239842057228, -0.03450828790664673, -0.03560139238834381, 0.010564555414021015, -0.05368576943874359, -0.029490329325199127, -0.001514966832473874, 0.030662667006254196, -0.012945977039635181, 0.011750751174986362, 0.012888962402939796, 0.010121137835085392, 0.012004027143120766, 0.008575369603931904, 0.03587203472852707, 0.060826752334833145, 0.014649086631834507, -0.015751678496599197, -0.009587028995156288, -0.05182972177863121, -0.015392349101603031, 0.036593399941921234, 0.015732882544398308, 0.014512909576296806, -0.033744607120752335, 0.04405742883682251, -0.02518852800130844, 0.0006006646435707808, 0.028602667152881622, -0.013263230212032795, 0.06434059888124466, 0.005540834739804268, -0.09776879101991653, -0.030823860317468643, 0.07024641335010529, -0.027304397895932198, 0.0033852956257760525, -0.04527441784739494, -0.015005480498075485, 0.03652920573949814, 0.02203887514770031, -0.024681538343429565, 0.04623711481690407, 0.02306659147143364, 0.06199636310338974, 0.026940956711769104, -0.026499871164560318, -0.043571360409259796, -0.015309380367398262, -0.02132410928606987, -0.02266155555844307, -0.03296726197004318, -0.009702039882540703, 0.028972968459129333, 0.010207729414105415, 0.02021370641887188, 0.015497320331633091, 0.027233203873038292, 0.014905644580721855, -0.0032982134725898504, -0.024844342842698097, -0.0181202944368124, 0.03148803114891052, 0.04301266744732857, 0.03691950812935829, 0.007285531144589186, -0.017293691635131836, -0.0006134912837296724, 0.0103551484644413, 0.05626829341053963, 0.03199566528201103, -0.0007093243184499443, 0.013317880220711231, -0.01855706050992012, 0.02366780675947666, 0.023154446855187416, -0.07432933896780014, -0.006282517220824957, -0.025850821286439896, -0.01095009408891201, 0.013607632368803024, 0.01705380529165268, 0.005487660877406597, -0.041405271738767624, 0.03372965380549431, -0.04904257506132126, -0.04183812439441681, -0.03652630373835564, 0.019523078575730324, -0.0029153807554394007, -0.04642084613442421, 0.03209982067346573, 0.0014145821332931519, 0.028571654111146927, 0.028360961005091667, -0.030946984887123108, -0.01577635668218136, -0.009412918239831924, 0.051274172961711884, -0.05584130808711052, -0.010540356859564781, 0.03822131082415581, 0.06493337452411652, -0.01329457014799118, 0.07418165355920792, 0.003370092948898673, -0.038485944271087646, 0.017645277082920074, -0.0546208955347538, 0.0036311792209744453, -0.013110504485666752, 0.021425312384963036, 0.02510387822985649, -0.001864237361587584, -0.021934950724244118, 0.002796712564304471, -0.045554518699645996, 0.02821955271065235, 0.05619735270738602, 0.0033385560382157564, -0.01249874010682106, 0.010601550340652466, 0.01175651140511036, 0.022156286984682083, -0.014548215083777905, 0.004434640519320965, -0.04242619127035141, -0.013149043545126915, 0.0370200015604496, 0.09267015755176544, -0.06871237605810165, -0.008205528371036053, 0.08008015900850296, 0.05067424476146698, 0.030634384602308273, 0.008283914066851139, -0.010376744903624058, -0.057929590344429016, 0.013368153013288975, 0.014180503785610199, 0.002991356886923313, -0.043946217745542526, -0.02471454255282879, 0.015075484290719032, 0.036645177751779556, -0.028836356475949287, 0.007538550533354282, 0.0012034688843414187, -0.04231703281402588, 0.013998354785144329, -0.04754607751965523, -0.02030409872531891, 0.04038112983107567, 0.011003164574503899, -0.013471742160618305, 0.021292559802532196, 0.0013663480058312416, 0.0003411283250898123, -0.03335949778556824, -0.0388752818107605, 0.017626512795686722, 0.03315135836601257, -0.0500628687441349, -0.02130713313817978, 0.008160923607647419, -0.00024237792240455747, 0.006264891475439072, -0.06073968857526779, -0.026934457942843437, -0.0352247953414917, 0.019504085183143616, 0.08335770666599274, -0.00022925986559130251, 0.010189687833189964, -0.03245675563812256, 0.014218299649655819, -0.000059663751017069444, 0.02679661475121975, 0.018551582470536232, 0.011641785502433777, -0.06439583003520966, 0.021149856969714165, -0.014728951267898083, 0.021877264603972435, -0.012697777710855007, -0.016682002693414688, -0.00041429410339333117, 0.06145887449383736, 0.0035409415140748024, -0.023494450375437737, -0.0002474821812938899, -0.005323417019098997, 0.01948624663054943, -0.03713277727365494, -0.016469277441501617, 0.01922968029975891, -0.004304183181375265, -0.05397989600896835, 0.0014382541412487626, -0.020807206630706787, -0.00355345755815506, -0.01739073544740677, -0.020408695563673973, -0.001037349458783865, -0.03485909476876259, 0.01616077497601509, 0.013904085382819176, -0.02274451218545437, -0.02170705795288086, -0.04867273196578026, -0.06303271651268005, 0.022053854539990425, -0.02432122640311718, 0.06460787355899811, 0.00470611872151494, -0.017446530982851982, 0.05656715855002403, 0.029464129358530045, -0.012508708983659744, -0.03045342117547989, 0.014659707434475422, -0.048517949879169464, -0.036928366869688034, 0.04465833306312561, 0.024767616763710976, -0.0031712381169199944, 0.024165192618966103, -0.017306270077824593, 0.0351158082485199, 0.06045994535088539, -0.03678544983267784, 0.005288966465741396, 0.047147590667009354, 0.01183283980935812, -0.010341218672692776, 0.03316137567162514, -0.00215653283521533, -0.02191968262195587, -0.015829041600227356, 0.025043660774827003, 0.008990599773824215, 0.031700171530246735, -0.05615166202187538, 0.02156241051852703, -0.030988819897174835, 0.027594730257987976, -0.05569029226899147, 0.014112357050180435, 0.0007643533172085881, -0.041522301733493805, -0.04725513607263565, 0.026594839990139008, 0.03902742266654968, -0.002385317115113139, 0.023044779896736145, 0.05059685930609703, 0.04616633057594299, 0.02428055927157402, 0.014363040216267109, 0.012866342440247536, -0.018636193126440048, 0.01809290237724781, -0.046754106879234314, -0.0076584592461586, 0.05100798234343529, 0.02705306187272072, 0.043064504861831665, -0.004581255838274956, -0.04395871236920357, 0.02183852717280388, -0.06003258377313614, 0.010200189426541328, -0.0737106129527092, 0.027168553322553635, 0.016937866806983948, 0.032207269221544266, 0.00042094936361536384, -0.01445099338889122, -0.01865573413670063, -0.0201982744038105, -0.06655888259410858, -0.0071726590394973755, -0.011882944963872433, 0.004617983940988779, -0.016107195988297462, -0.039782289415597916, 0.012963520362973213, 0.02184162475168705, 0.032331883907318115, 0.05292220786213875, 0.028409995138645172, -0.06194325163960457, 0.043386224657297134, 0.006293144077062607, 0.0036969350185245275, -0.01858394406735897, 0.019982926547527313, 0.032403603196144104, -0.012064870446920395, 0.012133161537349224, 0.0010716411052271724, -0.012815624475479126, 0.00142869190312922, 0.0033425800502300262, 0.019230622798204422, 0.021588431671261787, 0.028298338875174522, -0.011761492118239403, -0.004648362286388874, -0.019254401326179504, 0.034151751548051834, -0.00569702684879303, 0.038889575749635696, 0.01455079298466444, -0.028873231261968613, 0.006512805819511414, -0.052562061697244644, -0.018606195226311684, 0.01932498812675476, 0.034262508153915405, -0.005707796663045883, 0.005456758663058281, 0.036575403064489365, 0.02691618725657463, -0.044734906405210495, 0.018006986007094383, 0.05073085054755211, 0.007404100615531206, -0.009512498043477535, -0.05314656347036362, -0.024347946047782898, 0.001766401925124228, 0.006802968215197325, 0.02581857144832611, -0.042337339371442795, 0.0021822999697178602, 0.006112684495747089, 0.04878409579396248, -0.028875749558210373, -0.024717651307582855, -0.018519053235650063, 0.029740363359451294, 0.039924539625644684, -0.012066919356584549, -0.025557363405823708, 0.0027717123739421368, 0.011352155357599258, 0.0581473708152771, 0.04814358428120613, 0.0013242211425676942, -0.03716610372066498, 0.007658028043806553, 0.04748013988137245, 0.021914038807153702, -0.03167442977428436, 0.0037912316620349884, -0.06641212850809097, -0.004587864503264427, 0.05196549370884895, -0.004820828326046467, 0.021634472534060478, 0.04376929998397827, 0.00333588058128953, -0.028602005913853645, -0.026230566203594208, -0.049504540860652924, -0.028563255444169044, -0.004957167897373438, 0.04280182719230652, -0.06218205392360687, -0.056401923298835754, -0.036128513514995575, 0.032524432986974716, 0.022651564329862595, 0.057648953050374985, -0.004755060654133558, -0.005909949075430632, -0.009883162565529346, -0.0031156253535300493, 0.010814365930855274, -0.06567542254924774, 0.053103428333997726, 0.05783470347523689, 0.014515689574182034, 0.03598862513899803, -0.02824605628848076, -0.0149712935090065, 0.039803944528102875, -0.011072969064116478, 0.010296515189111233, 0.011496730148792267, 0.01643662340939045, 0.09573407471179962, 0.03542027249932289, -0.018370259553194046, 0.04072023928165436, -0.014570586383342743, 0.019217774271965027, -0.013427456840872765, -0.03765798732638359, 0.021047450602054596, -0.04617609828710556, -0.003205149434506893, -0.04176102206110954, 0.006553308572620153, 0.012525174766778946, 0.04050668329000473, -0.0022924847435206175, 0.022262386977672577, 0.004234536550939083, 0.009567627683281898, -0.0038807601667940617, 0.04593938961625099, -0.02178693749010563, -0.012384763918817043, 0.018093138933181763, 0.022636108100414276, 0.0030767428688704967, 0.027451708912849426, 0.016797494143247604, -0.005235312040895224, 0.0012172259157523513, 0.03479037061333656, -0.030651619657874107, -0.010326153598725796, -0.022012479603290558, 0.0070461491122841835, -0.0026175405364483595, -0.026569316163659096, 0.0002022705302806571, 0.003424763446673751, 0.046710189431905746, 0.0331495925784111, -0.03546909987926483, 0.036668721586465836, -0.0059356121346354485, -0.0063476115465164185, 0.06262246519327164, -0.03239601477980614, 0.02068883553147316, -0.04509400948882103, 0.022127976641058922, -0.0870417058467865, -0.0012041701702401042, 0.02998690865933895, 0.00944663304835558, -0.015503752045333385, -0.05645809322595596, -0.022220073267817497, 0.008470367640256882, -0.024724766612052917, 0.0028749671764671803, 0.029368087649345398, -0.031069261953234673, -0.010304894298315048, 0.0038209978956729174, 0.028960518538951874, 0.07376617193222046, -0.049520332366228104, -0.0014636089326813817, 0.014035027474164963, -0.050038013607263565, -0.021202581003308296, 0.0036071958020329475, 0.027977729216217995, -0.036420825868844986, 0.0013629019958898425, -0.06709039956331253, -0.0019064749358221889, 0.05981912091374397, -0.0343564935028553, -0.06250607967376709, 0.020129011943936348, -0.026844939216971397, 0.048436447978019714, -0.021263252943754196, -0.00560151319950819, -0.025147974491119385, -0.008048659190535545, -0.005370871629565954, -0.02183295600116253, -0.008274652063846588, 0.0031965721864253283, 0.012206283397972584, 0.004815356340259314, -0.03437196835875511, 0.019725093618035316, 0.02473611943423748, -0.007180050015449524, -0.014177552424371243, -0.030343899503350258, -0.019921373575925827, 0.01881592720746994, -0.006569420453161001, 0.02897604927420616, 0.005887022241950035, 0.02932043932378292, -0.01778363063931465, -0.04079558327794075, -0.04303087666630745, 0.035346098244190216, 0.04510440677404404, 0.023034991696476936, 0.05118653550744057, 0.0590641088783741, -0.014345460571348667, 0.01104642916470766, -0.04267963021993637, 0.006642667576670647, 0.02233956754207611, -0.0005986899486742914, 0.02823135070502758, -0.01217906828969717, -0.04660581424832344, 0.010704069398343563, 0.040742337703704834, 0.01868259720504284, 0.040012210607528687, 0.01623574085533619, -0.02991406060755253, 0.038406409323215485, -0.04833994805812836, -0.0549064576625824, 0.01812613755464554, -0.05267323926091194, 0.02138025127351284, 0.004143392667174339, -0.009995813481509686, 0.033542532473802567, 0.06438487023115158, 0.015633996576070786, -0.013730023987591267, -0.0449492484331131, -0.05024489015340805, -0.012873830273747444, 0.031598228961229324, 0.007718482054769993, 0.011329781264066696, -0.017091190442442894, 0.029828134924173355, -0.005795016419142485, 0.027041709050536156, -0.01945626735687256, -0.06471685320138931, -0.03590671718120575, 0.00520353764295578, -0.027950724586844444, 0.04696211963891983, -0.019251490011811256, -0.02272532694041729, 0.015003489330410957, -0.0465417355298996, 0.03509312495589256, 0.027625739574432373, 0.0012996948789805174, 0.029658345505595207, 0.02421346865594387, 0.023072345182299614, 0.023616140708327293, -0.01053999736905098, -0.03897403925657272, 0.11473199725151062, 0.04694806784391403, 0.04712120071053505, -0.03981366381049156, 0.016948748379945755, 0.03284763917326927, -0.010660955682396889, -0.030750440433621407, -0.014313613064587116, 0.022092685103416443, -0.01955595426261425, 0.02751595340669155, 0.027613256126642227, -0.001990033546462655, -0.0401463583111763, 0.0367576889693737, -0.05276917293667793, -0.025953451171517372, 0.013904174789786339, 0.010721043683588505, -0.01741495355963707, -0.016046324744820595, -0.013939270749688148, 0.02165461890399456, -0.014060093089938164, -0.023230882361531258, -0.03762023150920868, 0.01967298425734043, -0.0068681854754686356, -0.0023623935412615538, -0.03361626714468002, -0.0035244510509073734, 0.018130362033843994, 0.0005502607091329992, -0.01933581754565239, 0.019014587625861168, 0.009011532180011272, -0.03647522255778313, 0.012424727901816368, 0.026169193908572197, -0.023143373429775238, 0.01741066202521324, 0.011424095369875431, 0.02754749171435833, -0.012859631329774857, -0.04097592085599899, -0.028224265202879906, 0.03957579284906387, -0.006133774761110544, -0.015839707106351852, -0.0006582766072824597, 0.020223844796419144, -0.02874482050538063, -0.06750956177711487, 0.0016509623965248466, -0.008370738476514816, 0.022792672738432884, -0.009161212481558323, 0.007215573918074369, 0.022989127784967422, 0.01987324096262455, 0.0010491437278687954, 0.05256488174200058, 0.011757967993617058, -0.009911519475281239, -0.03910905495285988, -0.02160586230456829, 0.08078362047672272, -0.0005175096448510885, 0.03591262549161911, -0.004945514723658562, -0.02689329721033573, -0.0035570680629462004, -0.04005403444170952, -0.0335737019777298, -0.011850366368889809, 0.07249137759208679, 0.0174910556524992, -0.016093634068965912, -0.014540078118443489, -0.04383913055062294, 0.012050717137753963, -0.040165986865758896, 0.03885263949632645, -0.05548318102955818, 0.009015530347824097, 0.01903627999126911, 0.0188576839864254, 0.04260794073343277, -0.0007947896956466138, 0.0006385278538800776, 0.08208387345075607, -0.027894675731658936, -0.017185987904667854, -0.030977487564086914, -0.03151369467377663, -0.022330325096845627, 0.041553303599357605, 0.0004487326950766146, 0.007987936958670616, 0.028312239795923233, -0.014693811535835266, -0.017173735424876213, 0.03724728524684906, -0.03654846176505089, 0.0008037372026592493, -0.013813693076372147, -0.04807916283607483, 0.03584888204932213, 0.02747197076678276, -0.03549841791391373, -0.015184297226369381, 0.00955575704574585, -0.02619991824030876, -0.052518684417009354, -0.0331839919090271, -0.010181060060858727, -0.01893332600593567, 0.0013519127387553453, 0.010052462108433247, 0.010027073323726654, -0.01619040220975876, -0.034645479172468185, -0.018764404579997063, 0.006835846230387688, -0.038829702883958817, 0.0014713769778609276, -0.007282854989171028, 0.0012200307101011276, -0.033100929111242294, 0.00922556221485138, 0.060428135097026825, 0.01025465689599514, 0.018676219508051872, -0.03122706338763237, -0.0008942236891016364, 0.012450478971004486, 0.04182124510407448, -0.0019242701819166541, -0.04554692283272743, 0.05389945209026337, -0.056111179292201996, -0.018043672665953636, 0.013032438233494759, -0.033395133912563324, 0.022870689630508423, -0.010716512799263, 0.033291906118392944, -0.03748108819127083, 0.031569115817546844, -0.020058853551745415, -0.009779922664165497, -0.006675045471638441, 0.011326423846185207, 0.005761250853538513, 0.009839587844908237, 0.029048070311546326, -0.011372052133083344, 0.005345512647181749, 0.009841380640864372, 0.02337801456451416, -0.040091559290885925, -0.025055821985006332, 0.05140247941017151, -0.04596826061606407, 0.0017166315810754895, 0.01825840212404728, 0.027715621516108513, 0.0178177822381258, 0.04196886345744133, -0.038337573409080505, 0.0006239626673050225, -0.027145739644765854, -0.01563885249197483, -0.11278928816318512, -0.02405116893351078, -0.0011164037277922034, 0.007455991115421057, 0.013201842084527016, -0.0626031681895256, -0.037341464310884476, 0.002700062468647957, -0.04677915573120117, 0.06825122982263565, 0.0041107055731117725, 0.01054983027279377, -0.06526269763708115, 0.03162939473986626, -0.005175152327865362, 0.0016187388682737947, 0.021105701103806496, 0.0572064071893692, 0.0456416979432106, 0.05576901510357857, 0.0017037849174812436, -0.0004382783663459122, -0.0030443884897977114, 0.02452334389090538, -0.007808892522007227, -0.05627872049808502, 0.0410187691450119, -0.023699017241597176, -0.007812660187482834, 0.017596503719687462, 0.018864156678318977, -0.0016008748207241297, -0.019890625029802322, -0.0013874249998480082, 0.0018705865368247032, 0.04197756201028824, 0.022560173645615578, 0.021404901519417763, 0.016506899148225784, -0.014570278115570545, 0.036653533577919006, -0.0004955510376021266, -0.030988061800599098, 0.02107635885477066, 0.018902843818068504, -0.0034363558515906334, -0.015855010598897934, -0.010902185924351215, 0.0018247442785650492, -0.011970477178692818, -0.020976576954126358, -0.0043782684952020645, -0.008545656688511372, -0.02355877496302128, 0.026380853727459908, -0.03466730937361717, -0.028740590438246727, -0.0018773998599499464, 0.05069000646471977, -0.005551264155656099, 0.031949661672115326, 0.012370837852358818, -0.03278210386633873, -0.0071233599446713924, -0.0026890116278082132, 0.010351411998271942, -0.04733406752347946, -0.0374409519135952, 0.021585144102573395, 0.00455578463152051, -0.007181970402598381, -0.05962589383125305, -0.025512536987662315, 0.03388591110706329, 0.006275500170886517, -0.0021347622387111187, -0.004058415535837412, -0.03871474415063858, -0.01026186067610979, -0.08568968623876572, 0.0035709103103727102, -0.00618026265874505, -0.03298570588231087, -0.0010354609694331884, 0.007297791540622711, -0.03089987300336361, 0.04592356085777283, 0.006489430088549852, 0.040229883044958115, -0.002160074422135949, -0.013035386800765991, 0.00595289608463645, 0.03410391882061958, -0.06373348832130432, 0.03354823589324951, -0.021064549684524536, -0.03218437731266022, -0.009836768731474876, -0.025340018793940544, 0.052783701568841934, -0.0014821889344602823, 0.019076401367783546, -0.01655653305351734, -0.045463260263204575, 0.010507790371775627, -0.0038832449354231358, 0.043628741055727005, -0.013838437385857105, 0.0066082049161195755, 0.02889365702867508, 0.020786797627806664, 0.005298058968037367, 0.0036958844866603613, 0.0028203572146594524, -0.023402052000164986, 0.010348212905228138, -0.02387743815779686, -0.018512235954403877, 0.009436547756195068, 0.038474369794130325, 0.007124520838260651, -0.03475575894117355, -0.018716799095273018, 0.02063145488500595, -0.04271108657121658, -0.026375887915492058, 0.009662657976150513, 0.035647954791784286, 0.008631640113890171, 0.048175785690546036, 0.01647782325744629, 0.0392964705824852, -0.004063894506543875, 0.029135454446077347, 0.007945907302200794, 0.04396558925509453, -0.007045476697385311, -0.032614823430776596, -0.018983520567417145, -0.03317239508032799, 0.020995086058974266, -0.048536621034145355, 0.042144183069467545, -0.03253864869475365, -0.010051430203020573, 0.04750771448016167, 0.005189837422221899, 0.005013297777622938, 0.014095432125031948, -0.03214534744620323, 0.06823676079511642, -0.0013097074115648866, -0.0006583885988220572, -0.011816165409982204, -0.00906671117991209, 0.03706059232354164, 0.00583503395318985, 0.018200470134615898, 0.03614058718085289, -0.013630193658173084, 0.024611767381429672, -0.01886989362537861, -0.015449796803295612, 0.03709029406309128, -0.022152503952383995, 0.00687813526019454, 0.01073104701936245, 0.05382348597049713, 0.014203308150172234, 0.015074193477630615, -0.02071784809231758, -0.051420871168375015, 0.03043992817401886, -0.010173092596232891, 0.00999100599437952, -0.022323576733469963, -0.02244124375283718, 0.012899406254291534, 0.03794856369495392, -0.03566133230924606, -0.02791895717382431, -0.029762132093310356, 0.013643404468894005, 0.017315957695245743, 0.007298764307051897 ]
<p>I know that widget X has a population of N_x. However, widget Y has an unknown population that I'd like to estimate. </p> <p>Both widgets appear with a differential frequency over time as I sample them.</p> <p>Time ... X counts .... Y counts<br> 1 .......... 120 ............... 2<br> 2 .......... 212 ............... 3<br> 3 .......... 321 ............... 5<br> 4 .......... 149 ............... 0<br> 5 .......... 321 ............... 1 </p> <p>What is the total population of Y? With what confidence? I'm particularly interested in any special considerations that I many need to make when Widget Y is much rarer than the reference Widget X.</p> <p>Best,</p> <p>Paul</p>
48,181
[ -0.042768556624650955, -0.053745072335004807, 0.0353575274348259, -0.007536991033703089, 0.013007329776883125, -0.027177084237337112, -0.006561850197613239, -0.009939679875969887, 0.01145218312740326, 0.0013094563037157059, 0.03005870245397091, 0.07656456530094147, 0.09711948782205582, 0.0354745052754879, -0.01409402396529913, 0.02690693736076355, -0.007426903583109379, 0.017381247133016586, 0.011160533875226974, -0.04253576323390007, -0.018030844628810883, 0.01207059621810913, 0.03278680145740509, -0.02874896302819252, -0.07129223644733429, 0.038808491080999374, 0.013299240730702877, -0.05454201623797417, 0.014045896008610725, 0.07657097280025482, -0.07552769035100937, -0.02140343189239502, 0.01672976277768612, 0.05915877968072891, 0.012027814984321594, 0.021179720759391785, -0.02342117577791214, -0.028649860993027687, -0.004634227138012648, -0.0023734960705041885, -0.06492415815591812, -0.003345886478200555, 0.005653788801282644, -0.007373183034360409, 0.00724107725545764, 0.0333603136241436, 0.027862733229994774, -0.03770061954855919, 0.04987705498933792, -0.025083614513278008, 0.09031444042921066, -0.005647349637001753, 0.019554417580366135, 0.0030547776259481907, -0.03703229874372482, 0.0265659149736166, 0.03397473320364952, 0.012092645280063152, 0.00404056953266263, -0.037523943930864334, -0.019733205437660217, -0.015396162867546082, -0.007834899239242077, -0.014062152244150639, -0.026720361784100533, 0.037141699343919754, -0.04773186519742012, -0.02962181158363819, 0.025935130193829536, -0.037298060953617096, -0.0041560642421245575, 0.017114533111453056, 0.05640105903148651, -0.03819045051932335, 0.009560965932905674, -0.044958341866731644, 0.0048269364051520824, 0.0345926396548748, 0.025407427921891212, 0.021639250218868256, -0.01953037828207016, 0.02743859402835369, 0.02988564968109131, 0.019428309053182602, 0.01533079706132412, -0.009340502321720123, 0.056716304272413254, -0.035867467522621155, 0.0182260200381279, 0.04505673050880432, 0.006065991707146168, -0.01228894293308258, 0.045829709619283676, -0.0019194037886336446, -0.028484048321843147, 0.012965221889317036, -0.014188501052558422, 0.008421794511377811, -0.026691826060414314, -0.03526290878653526, -0.008299353532493114, -0.042584408074617386, 0.01692512445151806, 0.058603763580322266, -0.016432804986834526, -0.03047523833811283, -0.015617809258401394, -0.021891804412007332, -0.03650447726249695, -0.019755568355321884, -0.007971556857228279, 0.004590345546603203, -0.02242019772529602, -0.0204041488468647, 0.008112873882055283, 0.00042672615381889045, 0.027540231123566628, 0.01970832049846649, 0.0859428346157074, 0.07134616374969482, 0.04101499915122986, -0.02028074860572815, 0.012109886854887009, -0.02471230924129486, -0.06320098787546158, 0.021719152107834816, 0.00023380128550343215, -0.0030123265460133553, -0.06181108206510544, 0.05273422226309776, -0.016059894114732742, 0.007632814347743988, 0.04792246222496033, -0.03657792508602142, 0.017585961148142815, 0.007433502469211817, -0.04016571119427681, -0.05491948127746582, 0.040587976574897766, -0.01775733008980751, -0.0011151452781632543, -0.047230228781700134, 0.015843091532588005, 0.04278954118490219, 0.04605802148580551, -0.006343848537653685, 0.004820006433874369, -0.021565383300185204, 0.006615033373236656, 0.03008607029914856, -0.02870095893740654, -0.0160171240568161, 0.015341500751674175, 0.0024567125365138054, -0.03382522612810135, -0.05534156411886215, 0.026430873200297356, 0.013749942183494568, -0.01305804867297411, -0.0436449758708477, 0.014390449970960617, 0.030625691637396812, -0.01714201085269451, -0.004125723149627447, 0.0399097241461277, -0.05919672176241875, 0.06978140026330948, 0.028446389362215996, 0.018809573724865913, 0.016756584867835045, -0.020040227100253105, 0.0478079579770565, 0.019162964075803757, -0.026398995891213417, 0.0424228273332119, -0.004773230291903019, -0.008818243630230427, 0.00787594635039568, -0.0016397706931456923, 0.00986707303673029, -0.013795668259263039, -0.038238491863012314, -0.04149837791919708, -0.006148690823465586, 0.04460311681032181, 0.00844475906342268, -0.02634158730506897, -0.020804110914468765, -0.016054769977927208, -0.06692805141210556, -0.04043075814843178, -0.06798044592142105, -0.047251760959625244, 0.02626844123005867, -0.02374897338449955, -0.0051877060905098915, -0.013044548220932484, -0.008192336186766624, 0.013507258147001266, -0.022302990779280663, -0.042438019067049026, -0.029605058953166008, 0.043215733021497726, -0.060721103101968765, -0.04039118438959122, 0.055640995502471924, 0.04038059338927269, -0.03434441238641739, 0.054963063448667526, -0.044984519481658936, -0.04560102894902229, -0.03677812218666077, -0.03944441303610802, 0.013715351931750774, -0.001907600206322968, -0.031195100396871567, 0.023732341825962067, -0.011440310627222061, -0.009026898071169853, 0.03427090495824814, -0.05185621604323387, 0.04683108255267143, 0.060077980160713196, 0.004798985086381435, 0.009619109332561493, -0.022374875843524933, -0.003814971772953868, 0.025994500145316124, 0.010774870403110981, -0.02947322465479374, -0.0911957249045372, 0.019857170060276985, -0.028556572273373604, 0.01266033761203289, -0.019483987241983414, 0.031927600502967834, 0.06285493820905685, 0.0011272195260971785, 0.003743482753634453, 0.024697890505194664, 0.015075956471264362, 0.0038982622791081667, 0.026905396953225136, 0.04499225318431854, 0.059507519006729126, -0.01786728762090206, 0.021657999604940414, -0.0016362834721803665, 0.004827790427953005, 0.03795852139592171, -0.005350079853087664, 0.04122919589281082, -0.007429663557559252, 0.009819221682846546, -0.02054804377257824, -0.008600854314863682, 0.036581020802259445, -0.009195956401526928, -0.04031749069690704, 0.05824742466211319, -0.021488996222615242, -0.008855213411152363, 0.03550386056303978, -0.02617737092077732, 0.028889847919344902, 0.0249418206512928, -0.02582203783094883, -0.009115262888371944, 0.009466540068387985, -0.01683199778199196, 0.027575096115469933, 0.002892878372222185, -0.04238869249820709, -0.014049495570361614, 0.010409040376543999, 0.00780150480568409, 0.025778021663427353, 0.027561422437429428, -0.0099564827978611, -0.0037078482564538717, 0.0008316660532727838, -0.03767824172973633, -0.019680889323353767, 0.028330320492386818, -0.06797420978546143, -0.00736095430329442, 0.024603568017482758, -0.04018044099211693, 0.04209962114691734, 0.01186501793563366, -0.04905153810977936, 0.015145589597523212, -0.03404026851058006, -0.042630769312381744, -0.0201950091868639, -0.03774227201938629, 0.00986907072365284, -0.03791690245270729, -0.011433327570557594, 0.02335968427360058, 0.0017902322579175234, -0.03264150023460388, 0.040500715374946594, -0.030200643464922905, -0.04902999848127365, -0.03677542135119438, 0.02215425670146942, 0.028637133538722992, 0.010322599671781063, -0.022942760959267616, 0.030772382393479347, 0.007341655436903238, -0.005421102978289127, -0.06694529950618744, -0.05237364023923874, 0.01899036392569542, 0.008450341410934925, 0.039381545037031174, 0.030315110459923744, 0.009067099541425705, 0.08974256366491318, 0.025525201112031937, 0.016147611662745476, -0.028671640902757645, -0.04775414988398552, -0.014567184261977673, -0.0064907316118478775, 0.00687055941671133, 0.014788632281124592, -0.02438078448176384, 0.005444059614092112, 0.021354878321290016, 0.04328305274248123, 0.02011908032000065, -0.02195660211145878, 0.006728049833327532, 0.024196533486247063, 0.03186866268515587, 0.0029857908375561237, 0.05323050916194916, 0.022799436002969742, -0.019642263650894165, -0.010667077265679836, -0.010377681814134121, 0.005741323344409466, 0.0016886626835912466, -0.02874838188290596, 0.006971447728574276, -0.04200918972492218, -0.017526116222143173, -0.012124673463404179, 0.03807739168405533, 0.006221570074558258, -0.020223941653966904, -0.024624980986118317, 0.0024586718063801527, 0.0686541348695755, 0.003719972912222147, -0.00570207554847002, 0.056730855256319046, 0.04351270943880081, -0.0021922339219599962, -0.02117079123854637, -0.0320601724088192, -0.0007895487360656261, 0.0005249975947663188, -0.05341120809316635, -0.01347990520298481, -0.010690338909626007, 0.04965147003531456, -0.003450463991612196, -0.015772154554724693, -0.007997177541255951, 0.01045580767095089, -0.09564147144556046, -0.010826419107615948, -0.025555456057190895, 0.0613255575299263, 0.001491725561209023, 0.04737786576151848, 0.022987835109233856, -0.004804171156138182, -0.009716778993606567, -0.017014633864164352, -0.07774115353822708, 0.040678806602954865, 0.0034029760863631964, 0.00795868132263422, 0.016958730295300484, -0.032117683440446854, 0.04226541891694069, -0.0035580992698669434, 0.0010283448500558734, -0.004039517138153315, 0.008615515194833279, -0.04472622647881508, 0.0036236385349184275, -0.025294208899140358, -0.014279801398515701, 0.0008908467716537416, 0.015041765756905079, -0.021645398810505867, -0.021373171359300613, 0.024734796956181526, 0.022795788943767548, -0.002494565909728408, 0.0014692796394228935, -0.017753195017576218, -0.03363614156842232, 0.013650045730173588, 0.007580887526273727, 0.015000851824879646, 0.04439104348421097, -0.058065127581357956, 0.021205607801675797, 0.02886251173913479, 0.06606331467628479, 0.04545651003718376, 0.009830653667449951, 0.009026484563946724, -0.01471211388707161, -0.011584491468966007, 0.03072064369916916, 0.03326691687107086, -0.02880781702697277, 0.0011364183155819774, 0.06581717729568481, 0.025874679908156395, -0.025460250675678253, 0.003112486796453595, 0.020133303478360176, -0.02284405194222927, 0.03671759366989136, -0.0322350449860096, 0.05285008251667023, 0.017529206350445747, 0.04901530221104622, 0.012445084750652313, 0.025333166122436523, 0.006283008027821779, 0.0014767709653824568, 0.04157686606049538, 0.05929752439260483, -0.05618783459067345, 0.03652419522404671, 0.016201619058847427, 0.0319061316549778, -0.05713227763772011, 0.003036520443856716, -0.00025575567269697785, 0.03284025192260742, 0.05455124005675316, 0.010365437716245651, -0.018445441499352455, -0.10487223416566849, -0.018130650743842125, 0.08101378381252289, 0.05987193062901497, -0.03018844500184059, -0.003691299818456173, -0.054100971668958664, 0.01552585233002901, 0.014234742149710655, -0.000704200123436749, 0.005836729891598225, -0.0025426989886909723, -0.026844244450330734, -0.004320938605815172, -0.017818743363022804, -0.021038344129920006, 0.00030851035262458026, -0.037858352065086365, 0.04800524562597275, 0.0017364441882818937, -0.04659945145249367, -0.021454736590385437, 0.04673822224140167, 0.032911088317632675, 0.023757249116897583, -0.017080336809158325, -0.012716205790638924, 0.0004601936088874936, -0.0021684812381863594, -0.021924223750829697, -0.04828266426920891, 0.04468649998307228, 0.013832383789122105, -0.016075007617473602, 0.0582699216902256, 0.004775344394147396, -0.026752060279250145, 0.012439481914043427, -0.009744568727910519, -0.03087284415960312, 0.0074736857786774635, -0.006123073864728212, 0.010004745796322823, 0.029821809381246567, 0.029858093708753586, 0.008889689110219479, 0.015081650577485561, 0.021482568234205246, 0.0012606341624632478, -0.002061658538877964, -0.009707548655569553, -0.04003037139773369, 0.05397310107946396, -0.0380619578063488, -0.017136167734861374, -0.019508495926856995, 0.02420942485332489, 0.0007805204950273037, 0.024857325479388237, -0.01987331733107567, -0.04346809908747673, 0.016479836776852608, 0.027326617389917374, 0.008852241560816765, 0.01707194559276104, -0.0050344583578407764, -0.0022132261656224728, 0.011446499265730381, -0.007740652654320002, 0.0054152715019881725, -0.007948729209601879, 0.022878792136907578, -0.00011190925579285249, -0.04825941473245621, 0.03797425702214241, -0.032774921506643295, -0.005680902395397425, 0.055530864745378494, -0.016586607322096825, 0.002959477948024869, -0.006840807851403952, 0.06534643471240997, 0.03883570805191994, -0.037972453981637955, 0.028391066938638687, 0.011751677840948105, 0.007399276364594698, 0.03179856017231941, -0.04292706772685051, 0.05419182777404785, 0.0028531085699796677, -0.004699618089944124, -0.07194442301988602, -0.012435538694262505, 0.03349151089787483, 0.02102113887667656, -0.02410069666802883, -0.03954077139496803, -0.000629175454378128, 0.009186847135424614, -0.01925749145448208, -0.008468558080494404, -0.0004148143925704062, 0.0037517850287258625, -0.019837377592921257, -0.04036673903465271, 0.033569078892469406, 0.05558421090245247, -0.026926156133413315, -0.013184678740799427, -0.013252319768071175, 0.018994508311152458, 0.004586668685078621, -0.023151377215981483, -0.00009197106555802748, -0.012016957625746727, -0.009728778153657913, 0.004191701300442219, -0.0002771928848233074, 0.06654766947031021, -0.044863827526569366, 0.014323445968329906, 0.0435401052236557, 0.03332790359854698, 0.00004923025335301645, -0.014354999177157879, -0.02279888093471527, -0.04278486594557762, 0.020368842408061028, -0.03536561504006386, 0.02146242931485176, -0.007183526176959276, 0.011850601993501186, 0.0481574609875679, 0.0036907163448631763, -0.027704117819666862, -0.019020451232790947, 0.062160905450582504, -0.023111723363399506, -0.005878438241779804, 0.016256261616945267, -0.05485210940241814, 0.05810186266899109, 0.01067170687019825, -0.02002558670938015, 0.014392933808267117, 0.019097331911325455, -0.0019389307126402855, -0.030535520985722542, -0.056222349405288696, 0.005625036545097828, 0.03567029535770416, -0.006201344076544046, 0.03466669097542763, 0.007146132178604603, -0.015719564631581306, -0.007184040267020464, -0.011146528646349907, -0.023457294330000877, -0.05148866027593613, -0.012514916248619556, 0.023282654583454132, 0.04097232222557068, -0.026278886944055557, 0.03329666331410408, 0.03991353511810303, 0.03771592676639557, 0.029238637536764145, 0.021306252107024193, 0.00035050747101195157, 0.01659456454217434, -0.03621325269341469, -0.03242788463830948, 0.021104292944073677, -0.03297664225101471, 0.020870400592684746, -0.04380534589290619, -0.02004704624414444, 0.0312215443700552, 0.01113292295485735, -0.004979392513632774, -0.026631956920027733, -0.05947624891996384, -0.055076710879802704, -0.011335090734064579, -0.001191586023196578, 0.012659101746976376, 0.019782207906246185, 0.04772820696234703, 0.028890877962112427, 0.010191424749791622, 0.013977778144180775, -0.07209301739931107, -0.050208065658807755, -0.020676223561167717, -0.028780490159988403, -0.04930130019783974, 0.021840153262019157, -0.017203301191329956, -0.009720319882035255, 0.04058118164539337, 0.005154382437467575, 0.011120724491775036, -0.022472284734249115, 0.07675506919622421, -0.005869515705853701, 0.0538039393723011, 0.03917643055319786, 0.022061718627810478, -0.03309321403503418, 0.022856462746858597, 0.15777656435966492, 0.03601837903261185, 0.024002043530344963, -0.0629461482167244, 0.006283553317189217, 0.014544174075126648, -0.014600006863474846, -0.018378060311079025, -0.03798322007060051, 0.010104411281645298, -0.012171231210231781, 0.058296725153923035, 0.012490171939134598, 0.02268676832318306, 0.01140273455530405, 0.03197437897324562, -0.00530608044937253, -0.00754491938278079, -0.023994792252779007, 0.014985213056206703, -0.003294573863968253, -0.004414852242916822, -0.11077643185853958, 0.019970711320638657, 0.01911960169672966, -0.005858940072357655, -0.010676344856619835, -0.04996027052402496, -0.019012441858649254, -0.02056189626455307, 0.009949740953743458, 0.04309863597154617, 0.02104450762271881, -0.006614512298256159, 0.005797105375677347, -0.015224752947688103, -0.0008198115392588079, -0.031747836619615555, 0.02285212092101574, 0.05755763128399849, 0.039287269115448, 0.004475656896829605, -0.03358853980898857, 0.02119285985827446, -0.04034734144806862, 0.0267025139182806, -0.019111378118395805, 0.011529836803674698, -0.023092977702617645, -0.041235603392124176, -0.000021812718841829337, 0.01943378895521164, -0.009152790531516075, 0.008240262977778912, -0.026132144033908844, 0.0388028547167778, 0.01720426045358181, -0.016417434439063072, -0.022820277139544487, -0.0007539151119999588, 0.02570239081978798, -0.01901843212544918, 0.025820786133408546, 0.03689011558890343, -0.020078668370842934, 0.005957370158284903, 0.01140829361975193, 0.027814267203211784, -0.02498481795191765, 0.02290373668074608, 0.011970692314207554, -0.018717041239142418, -0.010186046361923218, -0.025266051292419434, 0.0022096489556133747, 0.00787939690053463, 0.028473014011979103, -0.015803609043359756, -0.010836408473551273, -0.001701006549410522, -0.024314576759934425, 0.0042723482474684715, -0.0243344958871603, -0.006167376413941383, -0.016186194494366646, 0.012190619483590126, 0.023791251704096794, 0.03215367719531059, -0.009899510070681572, 0.0266251303255558, -0.009165506809949875, 0.036676086485385895, 0.013883046805858612, -0.030576011165976524, 0.0013044776860624552, -0.010589273646473885, -0.02979522943496704, -0.027559157460927963, -0.02892756089568138, 0.028118042275309563, 0.021398887038230896, -0.009790386073291302, 0.04350884631276131, 0.011089826934039593, -0.02701067551970482, 0.026793301105499268, 0.0005629900842905045, -0.11344379186630249, 0.002385250758379698, 0.013086616061627865, -0.023539818823337555, -0.03031713329255581, -0.046470873057842255, -0.05208821967244148, 0.0009675787878222764, -0.019869456067681313, 0.015061053447425365, -0.0385151170194149, -0.00084020133363083, -0.0016712055075913668, -0.019061904400587082, -0.00046934495912864804, -0.0015462615992873907, -0.033817220479249954, -0.0047031547874212265, -0.017555436119437218, 0.013595410622656345, 0.021083015948534012, -0.005007751286029816, -0.020965544506907463, 0.01742868311703205, 0.008837364614009857, 0.0053774151019752026, -0.010593382641673088, 0.019104070961475372, 0.02559352107346058, -0.01126658171415329, 0.01706305518746376, -0.002175196073949337, 0.03528086096048355, 0.046384017914533615, -0.044878698885440826, -0.027997909113764763, 0.030986834317445755, -0.025399774312973022, 0.03520241007208824, 0.023317255079746246, -0.022996723651885986, 0.023372242227196693, 0.027779504656791687, -0.04554601013660431, -0.024852346628904343, -0.03186265379190445, 0.0062343706376850605, 0.027512943372130394, -0.014701641164720058, -0.014337075874209404, 0.009077847003936768, 0.007021441590040922, 0.048988789319992065, 0.012948735617101192, -0.02397206798195839, -0.008719295263290405, 0.03850707411766052, 0.024372771382331848, 0.02340148761868477, -0.032835785299539566, 0.0016886088997125626, 0.04117732122540474, 0.07264255732297897, -0.06073395162820816, 0.006656117737293243, -0.045570552349090576, -0.003398524597287178, -0.07235024869441986, -0.021988997235894203, 0.005557968281209469, 0.004634080454707146, 0.010887389071285725, -0.03647458180785179, 0.021831946447491646, 0.01997479237616062, -0.04736413434147835, 0.005960588343441486, 0.005711734294891357, 0.014005069620907307, -0.018207276239991188, 0.04434999078512192, -0.02848496474325657, 0.01289315614849329, 0.054471347481012344, 0.008420244790613651, 0.019679613411426544, 0.053005702793598175, 0.005158302374184132, -0.052373528480529785, -0.017602022737264633, -0.0033914013765752316, 0.016276996582746506, -0.07601691037416458, 0.024018608033657074, -0.02133704349398613, 0.0239514522254467, 0.0641130581498146, -0.003555083414539695, 0.02474171295762062, 0.02852405421435833, 0.046712398529052734, -0.021721748635172844, 0.029920540750026703, 0.019202062860131264, 0.02798115648329258, 0.015359199605882168, -0.00886810664087534, -0.0037544129882007837, 0.03593097999691963, -0.018049124628305435, 0.010569008998572826, 0.03325548768043518, 0.016396714374423027, -0.0030257790349423885, 0.018403099849820137, -0.002365982159972191, 0.004332924261689186, 0.04327158257365227, 0.01430834922939539, 0.018428141251206398, -0.0015634797746315598, 0.03581835702061653, 0.0036252285353839397, 0.03945495933294296, 0.027837203815579414, -0.008162775076925755, -0.0441470742225647, 0.015079564414918423, -0.04493190348148346, -0.05496760085225105, -0.0034825496841222048, 0.012664999812841415, 0.030058961361646652, -0.01181978452950716, 0.00021095537522342056, -0.03125391900539398, 0.031969159841537476, 0.01271092426031828, 0.0199887715280056, -0.06755444407463074, 0.030498594045639038, -0.02412007562816143, -0.04109327867627144, 0.025120126083493233, 0.02890511229634285, 0.0015699780778959394, -0.08616276830434799, 0.060603201389312744, 0.027444733306765556, -0.020134469494223595, -0.03929804638028145, 0.003862515091896057, -0.010046993382275105, 0.030242396518588066, 0.03401349112391472, 0.002395692514255643, -0.005665660835802555, -0.01955375447869301, 0.029450764879584312, -0.00876336544752121, -0.032118793576955795, 0.042856741696596146, -0.025056350976228714, -0.039004161953926086, -0.011557070538401604, -0.02388378046452999, 0.0013796113198623061, 0.0011697032023221254, 0.009596929885447025, -0.005689541809260845, -0.0007013820577412844, -0.01917501911520958, -0.006687968038022518, 0.04456930235028267, -0.008293782360851765, 0.0028935957234352827, 0.03494155406951904, 0.0022681986447423697, 0.0058983308263123035, 0.02450859174132347, 0.01029989030212164, -0.0931229218840599, 0.031503498554229736, -0.0393546000123024, -0.025551842525601387, 0.01966828666627407, -0.018343595787882805, 0.020017122849822044, -0.04863160848617554, -0.01086223591119051, -0.03177880123257637, -0.028361983597278595, -0.006739733275026083, 0.036204684525728226, 0.029869750142097473, 0.059590283781290054, -0.008711849339306355, -0.00033426491427235305, -0.007774501573294401, -0.010426390916109085, -0.015672914683818817, 0.005204665940254927, -0.029271505773067474, -0.0023515718057751656, 0.037518467754125595, 0.018612626940011978, 0.008523425087332726, 0.04837051033973694, -0.020556559786200523, 0.029322465881705284, -0.019012276083230972, -0.03277925029397011, 0.026559382677078247, 0.004873149562627077, 0.029584446921944618, 0.04701912775635719, -0.018865592777729034, 0.07110932469367981, -0.023163089528679848, 0.033586591482162476, -0.04172375798225403, -0.02733471989631653, -0.02048526331782341, -0.008272409439086914, -0.006382552441209555, 0.023939820006489754, -0.0027409701142460108, 0.009060919284820557, -0.020917702466249466, -0.031823743134737015, 0.012709783390164375, -0.04550132527947426, 0.018903901800513268, -0.022035041823983192, 0.015511591918766499, -0.027046948671340942, 0.024687733501195908, -0.01813763566315174, -0.0032137047965079546, 0.012050776742398739, 0.022506430745124817, 0.025776732712984085, -0.01367388479411602, -0.02233283594250679, 0.004959065467119217, 0.03765050694346428, -0.026906419545412064, -0.045729056000709534, -0.05946815013885498, 0.010819496586918831, 0.03087075985968113, -0.05290314927697182 ]
<p>A new virus breaks out on a cruise ship. I want to test the hypothesis that males and females are equally likely to contract the virus.</p> <p>I am going to test 100 men and 100 women. Presumably if I find 87 women infected and 89 men I cannot safely reject the null. If on the other hand I find 11 men are affected and 20 women this would seem a reasonable basis on which to reject the null. </p> <p>So before running the test I want to define a rejection region. The rejection region is to be defined so that the probability of rejecting the null given that it is true is <em>at most</em> 5%. Since this is a composite null – the probability of getting the disease can range from 0 to 1 – this condition must hold for each and every member of the null.</p> <p>How do I construct such a region?</p>
37,289
[ -0.0003825924650300294, -0.022799411788582802, 0.0009268462308682501, 0.002357969293370843, 0.0436985045671463, 0.02425479143857956, 0.0002051362971542403, -0.00712188147008419, 0.023041684180498123, 0.011748307384550571, 0.10333957523107529, 0.05116882547736168, 0.07073020190000534, 0.013971560634672642, -0.02192339301109314, 0.007341416087001562, -0.0008729497203603387, -0.01214923057705164, -0.04331239312887192, -0.009478909894824028, 0.02722141146659851, -0.03615288436412811, 0.02239692397415638, -0.0236860029399395, -0.0023980115074664354, 0.024548465386033058, 0.04602847248315811, -0.049698974937200546, 0.010857758112251759, 0.05627208203077316, -0.060698796063661575, -0.03661360964179039, 0.02512006089091301, 0.01850513182580471, 0.012951095588505268, 0.0403292216360569, -0.0026693716645240784, 0.011443113908171654, -0.028798023238778114, 0.018351418897509575, -0.024408351629972458, 0.02203555218875408, 0.001941153546795249, 0.032339245080947876, -0.03425286337733269, -0.00394637743011117, 0.017370225861668587, 0.0010238578543066978, 0.0024861276615411043, -0.08142878115177155, 0.039193056523799896, 0.044339876621961594, 0.05787424370646477, 0.0018844726728275418, 0.002551464596763253, -0.051061782985925674, 0.05581483244895935, 0.05010274052619934, -0.004759661853313446, -0.024658501148223877, 0.022048478946089745, -0.046895112842321396, -0.006955618504434824, -0.0352732352912426, -0.01286480575799942, 0.003786835353821516, 0.001644885167479515, -0.016758007928729057, -0.007511140778660774, -0.03479200601577759, -0.0003880486765410751, 0.02742012031376362, 0.010970131494104862, -0.030191298574209213, 0.008987783454358578, -0.03268206864595413, 0.04429209604859352, 0.01834160089492798, 0.03462265804409981, 0.005256351549178362, 0.006051977630704641, 0.01911553367972374, 0.037868600338697433, 0.01001458615064621, 0.006071016192436218, -0.028337011113762856, 0.07554450631141663, 0.006488395854830742, 0.018259644508361816, 0.0055481549352407455, -0.004044714383780956, -0.013653934001922607, 0.0075409081764519215, -0.007668768521398306, -0.04744570329785347, 0.0045720250345766544, -0.021189600229263306, 0.02795361541211605, 0.026830872520804405, 0.011786350049078465, -0.03597693517804146, -0.012460505589842796, 0.027150247246026993, 0.06172715127468109, 0.004662315361201763, 0.03213462606072426, -0.05665622279047966, -0.023795917630195618, -0.028570296242833138, 0.014382252469658852, -0.041489217430353165, 0.045228127390146255, 0.03131425380706787, 0.019655117765069008, 0.03638989478349686, 0.010438918136060238, -0.04270080104470253, -0.03858108073472977, 0.05322830751538277, 0.026410497725009918, 0.04270738735795021, 0.010211305692791939, 0.0563480369746685, -0.031110629439353943, -0.05693058297038078, 0.03809262812137604, -0.036669258028268814, 0.0042202770709991455, 0.013109301216900349, 0.06874649226665497, 0.005188800860196352, -0.003167971968650818, 0.03242068737745285, 0.01583329401910305, 0.02134261280298233, 0.0010114569449797273, -0.08063554018735886, -0.0872173011302948, 0.01663675531744957, -0.00037827735650353134, 0.005715839099138975, -0.05984021723270416, -0.009565767832100391, 0.07171378284692764, 0.06561024487018585, -0.016111770644783974, 0.03032657876610756, -0.0050964332185685635, -0.009426095522940159, -0.00018264436221215874, -0.01775229722261429, -0.015615856274962425, -0.055602505803108215, 0.028226852416992188, -0.04013415798544884, -0.07762719690799713, 0.02901444397866726, 0.012447472661733627, -0.02751343697309494, -0.022710168734192848, 0.02653541974723339, -0.04926478862762451, -0.029589742422103882, -0.017000338062644005, -0.041403353214263916, -0.01691199652850628, 0.10439341515302658, 0.019997721537947655, -0.021240198984742165, 0.04343760758638382, -0.012702804990112782, 0.006308701355010271, 0.0058151837438344955, 0.026762045919895172, 0.03245360031723976, -0.019590012729167938, 0.011151186190545559, -0.005496309604495764, 0.0608520433306694, 0.004293929319828749, -0.020373191684484482, -0.005860072560608387, -0.01857665926218033, 0.014411376789212227, -0.010236190631985664, 0.012960857711732388, 0.018747670575976372, -0.015048887580633163, 0.025199010968208313, -0.04877883195877075, -0.06245545297861099, -0.04679394140839577, -0.011256610974669456, 0.005585516337305307, -0.04727399721741676, 0.013069083914160728, -0.015085740014910698, 0.007466375827789307, -0.018709832802414894, -0.048763763159513474, -0.022407716140151024, -0.01012741681188345, 0.01412199903279543, -0.04016242176294327, -0.008676881901919842, 0.055466171354055405, 0.045280855149030685, 0.020911095663905144, 0.016899434849619865, -0.0345161072909832, -0.05174170434474945, -0.017757661640644073, -0.02929501421749592, 0.018207332119345665, 0.008306621573865414, -0.0018764015985652804, 0.023239556699991226, 0.010666976682841778, 0.01738458313047886, -0.0038912822492420673, -0.05654400959610939, 0.05804666876792908, 0.07343544811010361, -0.009251316078007221, 0.009953223168849945, -0.034206267446279526, 0.030982019379734993, -0.009998946450650692, 0.038718730211257935, -0.014456120319664478, -0.05559440702199936, 0.009625580161809921, 0.01274358294904232, -0.04198601841926575, -0.002500625792890787, 0.011310881935060024, 0.030300738289952278, -0.0009846193715929985, 0.02431812696158886, 0.026591628789901733, -0.003829866647720337, -0.012008529156446457, 0.010407383553683758, 0.023493871092796326, 0.016531554982066154, 0.025727346539497375, 0.03246162086725235, 0.0038225946482270956, 0.022075798362493515, 0.0019102183869108558, -0.00331809651106596, 0.019181273877620697, 0.022594550624489784, 0.00913440715521574, -0.018969353288412094, 0.02056954801082611, 0.040274396538734436, -0.014105335809290409, 0.008583111688494682, -0.0028676281217485666, -0.01294476818293333, -0.0032441499643027782, -0.014596758410334587, -0.01961466111242771, -0.012040741741657257, 0.02114211581647396, 0.016736846417188644, 0.02814333327114582, 0.027670862153172493, -0.02955019660294056, -0.015866558998823166, -0.014126746915280819, -0.01578446291387081, -0.04616998881101608, -0.03195154294371605, 0.04299606382846832, 0.031244447454810143, 0.04807058721780777, -0.025682834908366203, -0.004777681082487106, -0.024210823699831963, -0.016508182510733604, 0.03385237231850624, 0.03518955036997795, -0.03176572546362877, -0.020665070042014122, -0.023831743746995926, -0.011477349326014519, 0.011165156029164791, -0.028240973129868507, -0.014302100986242294, 0.0028628690633922815, -0.004512534476816654, -0.020314281806349754, -0.017679857090115547, -0.020557217299938202, -0.01392916776239872, -0.041188281029462814, -0.013558021746575832, 0.0771951973438263, 0.0415908619761467, -0.017404397949576378, 0.037650369107723236, -0.028978439047932625, 0.027036156505346298, -0.015905432403087616, -0.028016433119773865, 0.0010441845515742898, -0.021280109882354736, -0.005053795874118805, 0.044349346309900284, 0.0020858768839389086, 0.05899922549724579, -0.05764596164226532, -0.06488658487796783, -0.012907487340271473, -0.009879481047391891, 0.007946554571390152, -0.020433755591511726, 0.005835306365042925, 0.07669632136821747, 0.035359665751457214, 0.022157566621899605, -0.028938619419932365, 0.028422534465789795, -0.03489045426249504, -0.05276026204228401, 0.05794467031955719, 0.02739795297384262, -0.018534280359745026, 0.012210703454911709, 0.01724996231496334, 0.0239303857088089, 0.06909669935703278, 0.0031901246402412653, -0.016858847811818123, 0.023377584293484688, -0.014781743288040161, -0.014508446678519249, 0.04639570042490959, 0.012106908485293388, -0.010858665220439434, 0.021523531526327133, -0.04905211552977562, 0.013496752828359604, 0.02525644563138485, -0.0353865809738636, 0.008630526252090931, -0.03687133267521858, -0.0003546249645296484, -0.013626269064843655, 0.06014300137758255, -0.021533124148845673, -0.018749747425317764, 0.01647121272981167, 0.0004964789841324091, 0.04123825579881668, -0.038630411028862, 0.006031404715031385, 0.06460929661989212, 0.05691206082701683, -0.006990894675254822, -0.01627933979034424, -0.011880984529852867, 0.03984271362423897, 0.025280339643359184, -0.012677794322371483, -0.007408694829791784, 0.01927977055311203, 0.05135299637913704, 0.013304893858730793, -0.015868820250034332, -0.04937164485454559, -0.02801460027694702, -0.019041331484913826, -0.024424055591225624, 0.009622669778764248, 0.06590390205383301, 0.008954612538218498, 0.01646011881530285, 0.038575928658246994, -0.009450618177652359, -0.004425765480846167, 0.016391897574067116, -0.06628739833831787, -0.019490903243422508, 0.01020387839525938, 0.005439810920506716, -0.008089643903076649, -0.02141551300883293, 0.023161614313721657, 0.001201901468448341, -0.021336276084184647, -0.004527104552835226, 0.06360147148370743, -0.054252590984106064, 0.03264004364609718, 0.021513547748327255, -0.006616522092372179, 0.015650490298867226, 0.025326116010546684, 0.014918828383088112, 0.0021276006009429693, 0.01635616272687912, 0.017362359911203384, -0.0072059896774590015, 0.0029516967479139566, -0.005197747144848108, 0.033534854650497437, 0.00879584439098835, 0.052845317870378494, 0.012029998935759068, 0.03214513882994652, -0.06865067034959793, -0.040897879749536514, 0.0002642783510964364, 0.02402179315686226, 0.045048654079437256, 0.05119007080793381, -0.018646180629730225, -0.00336800841614604, -0.019794313237071037, -0.027846522629261017, 0.0032764903735369444, -0.003202343126758933, -0.01756484992802143, 0.04571402445435524, 0.05858461186289787, -0.040057044476270676, 0.012098235078155994, 0.06260917335748672, 0.03236965462565422, 0.0037703600246459246, -0.01616775244474411, -0.033556655049324036, -0.02233045920729637, -0.01865566521883011, -0.0024379703681916, 0.016678016632795334, 0.005399825517088175, -0.011789833195507526, 0.07494362443685532, -0.02794652245938778, -0.04210413619875908, 0.024508126080036163, -0.013843441382050514, 0.06450188159942627, -0.016789516434073448, 0.01057851780205965, 0.05028066039085388, -0.004070368595421314, -0.0003025806799996644, 0.05214645713567734, -0.0445244163274765, -0.04971449077129364, 0.0010387052316218615, 0.01999439112842083, 0.010426828637719154, -0.006765552330762148, -0.012061288580298424, -0.033058974891901016, 0.05085695534944534, 0.060006629675626755, -0.02459360659122467, -0.0003073652333114296, -0.004164098761975765, -0.003959787078201771, -0.044493354856967926, -0.03925791755318642, -0.00850880891084671, 0.03562440723180771, -0.05066537857055664, 0.022613059729337692, -0.026097813621163368, -0.03210862725973129, -0.05622756481170654, 0.022337961941957474, -0.001987982774153352, 0.053423602133989334, -0.010006808675825596, -0.015806179493665695, -0.021386995911598206, 0.002394983312115073, -0.023145370185375214, -0.06268695741891861, -0.021596619859337807, 0.04889625310897827, 0.0047471108846366405, 0.06575331836938858, -0.0312829427421093, 0.008137920871376991, -0.0034735670778900385, 0.004633662290871143, -0.0466543585062027, 0.0452287457883358, -0.04043220728635788, 0.02871975302696228, 0.004968535155057907, 0.03254926577210426, 0.05418453738093376, -0.03635062277317047, -0.006115796975791454, -0.0024113424587994814, -0.04468580335378647, -0.0011116882087662816, -0.03555763512849808, 0.010908307507634163, -0.026242688298225403, -0.001908228499814868, -0.011402339674532413, 0.03036820888519287, -0.009172298014163971, -0.006082920357584953, -0.020798334851861, -0.05194510146975517, -0.029642179608345032, 0.01979997381567955, -0.011051909066736698, 0.0061238608323037624, -0.029606226831674576, 0.03535902127623558, -0.019152401015162468, -0.012333848513662815, 0.05460050702095032, -0.008705822750926018, 0.03098001889884472, -0.025203784927725792, -0.0389714390039444, 0.010850340127944946, -0.04811437800526619, -0.03322744742035866, -0.004067473579198122, -0.01713806577026844, 0.056963201612234116, -0.02949342131614685, 0.0038215985987335443, 0.010161499492824078, -0.037897370755672455, -0.011765682138502598, 0.05057200416922569, 0.03296130150556564, 0.0395466573536396, -0.028910953551530838, 0.04740189388394356, 0.006591088604182005, 0.048950906842947006, -0.09152810275554657, -0.015040994621813297, 0.00043459859443828464, 0.000402087316615507, -0.008671055547893047, -0.018993059173226357, -0.006584509275853634, -0.01857476681470871, -0.03474672511219978, -0.0034303427673876286, 0.04199768230319023, 0.0012718801153823733, 0.003389960154891014, -0.035321783274412155, 0.00037194773904047906, 0.09735675156116486, 0.01735733263194561, 0.005373802967369556, 0.015978805720806122, -0.0397300161421299, 0.03202659264206886, -0.03590500354766846, 0.01734081842005253, -0.04587389528751373, -0.03965083137154579, -0.037862423807382584, -0.0011705729411914945, -0.0034473473206162453, 0.021590394899249077, -0.009998793713748455, -0.02333630621433258, -0.04144062474370003, -0.028546761721372604, -0.021948017179965973, -0.014574847184121609, -0.0050216661766171455, 0.002625122433528304, -0.008229880593717098, 0.02975224331021309, -0.022403787821531296, 0.023912115022540092, 0.052984680980443954, 0.0022119334898889065, -0.025496575981378555, 0.009609619155526161, 0.08725340664386749, 0.004946211818605661, 0.020519180223345757, 0.003971979953348637, 0.014572134241461754, 0.049902014434337616, 0.0276084803044796, -0.034703902900218964, 0.009248007088899612, 0.006422035396099091, -0.06486756354570389, 0.000888765265699476, -0.04305654764175415, 0.030071035027503967, 0.023500466719269753, -0.05937333032488823, 0.026660745963454247, 0.020527951419353485, 0.0147408964112401, -0.01223752275109291, -0.03584351763129234, -0.002410927088931203, -0.03246656805276871, 0.023558035492897034, 0.03459693863987923, -0.007710116449743509, 0.011189224198460579, 0.06532643735408783, 0.034186020493507385, 0.02784055843949318, 0.03285859525203705, 0.006364138331264257, 0.053380101919174194, 0.02951815351843834, -0.013173047453165054, 0.009302147664129734, 0.016596680507063866, -0.0031700110994279385, 0.04287014529109001, -0.025321153923869133, 0.03708972781896591, 0.01669398508965969, 0.04712726175785065, -0.005255357827991247, -0.026750916615128517, -0.03693319484591484, -0.03042643517255783, 0.04338923469185829, 0.06494607031345367, -0.05390290543437004, 0.019060296937823296, 0.007181372959166765, 0.04642966017127037, -0.017385441809892654, -0.015603159554302692, -0.01768002100288868, -0.04071113467216492, -0.018876181915402412, -0.03795255348086357, -0.044933684170246124, 0.007973830215632915, -0.0016998664941638708, -0.0002292185672558844, 0.023809783160686493, -0.03143710643053055, 0.018842989578843117, -0.013344966806471348, 0.017141660675406456, -0.006604040041565895, 0.05792112275958061, -0.0017871793825179338, 0.026007216423749924, -0.04133246839046478, 0.021062714979052544, 0.1264823079109192, 0.05928508937358856, 0.008404594846069813, -0.050427667796611786, 0.018770432099699974, 0.007955393753945827, -0.01940104365348816, 0.009515476413071156, 0.013106479309499264, 0.036017388105392456, -0.02003006637096405, 0.04201981797814369, 0.016747498884797096, -0.017689906060695648, 0.0342320092022419, 0.040604230016469955, -0.06464516371488571, -0.013437672518193722, -0.01421794481575489, 0.013522371649742126, -0.004337029531598091, -0.019704995676875114, -0.047731779515743256, -0.009096106514334679, 0.022636059671640396, -0.03924086317420006, -0.02768714353442192, 0.006250991951674223, 0.040289320051670074, -0.011648688465356827, 0.0075036329217255116, -0.004377075936645269, 0.017525019124150276, 0.031633537262678146, -0.01597491279244423, -0.04318581521511078, -0.015737297013401985, -0.035971201956272125, 0.020152658224105835, 0.015237190760672092, 0.00046078392188064754, -0.009052594192326069, -0.007336401380598545, -0.0004966852720826864, -0.018338212743401527, -0.04406476393342018, -0.03706459701061249, 0.04946638271212578, -0.001571760163642466, -0.022261880338191986, -0.015193850733339787, 0.04304041340947151, 0.026898516342043877, -0.03028588369488716, -0.031890735030174255, 0.008539599366486073, 0.018428195267915726, 0.013779128901660442, 0.01782294362783432, -0.04505045711994171, 0.03698064759373665, -0.005700873211026192, 0.0058821155689656734, 0.020957082509994507, -0.007820446975529194, -0.06084015220403671, -0.02266657166182995, 0.04253644123673439, 0.000408052554121241, -0.015374138951301575, -0.04079480096697807, -0.008977983146905899, -0.04047446325421333, 0.017445798963308334, -0.011043032631278038, -0.016663195565342903, -0.0026505349669605494, 0.011258373968303204, -0.008769795298576355, 0.007975845597684383, -0.037515923380851746, -0.024845629930496216, -0.07302786409854889, -0.025365855544805527, -0.0014993097865954041, -0.031526222825050354, 0.003830960253253579, 0.04722282662987709, 0.0016814146656543016, -0.023226385936141014, 0.003109377110376954, 0.04058658704161644, 0.014871438965201378, -0.043350737541913986, -0.04393654689192772, 0.00009419707203051075, -0.007028080057352781, 0.011958346702158451, -0.011781193315982819, 0.07821857184171677, 0.008957781828939915, 0.038455601781606674, 0.029014088213443756, 0.007559660822153091, -0.02702404372394085, -0.017226241528987885, 0.034772973507642746, -0.08297105878591537, -0.04801761731505394, 0.025864850729703903, 0.008796137757599354, -0.04499662294983864, -0.019323695451021194, -0.023120371624827385, -0.043965041637420654, 0.02018219605088234, -0.02255973033607006, 0.002269565127789974, 0.006304015405476093, -0.00817022379487753, 0.03847726434469223, -0.06656575202941895, -0.003345553297549486, -0.027106700465083122, -0.012963092885911465, 0.010473337955772877, -0.023419324308633804, -0.02415562979876995, -0.02608710154891014, -0.010500824078917503, 0.03635066747665405, 0.02370319329202175, 0.014366572722792625, 0.026020701974630356, 0.013056670315563679, 0.00936397910118103, 0.029331251978874207, 0.04027089476585388, -0.022326426580548286, -0.011093022301793098, 0.03315751627087593, -0.04700062423944473, -0.014161482453346252, 0.0295424684882164, 0.014846909791231155, 0.047460295259952545, -0.012280233204364777, 0.03140312433242798, 0.014081649482250214, 0.030813464894890785, -0.002651376184076071, -0.03734372556209564, -0.036351483315229416, 0.019281405955553055, 0.07125595211982727, 0.0060010929591953754, -0.010505212470889091, 0.007047492545098066, 0.029298337176442146, 0.026789335533976555, 0.03112328052520752, 0.01597018726170063, 0.00683706346899271, -0.019950781017541885, 0.02950637973845005, 0.05241023004055023, -0.00823286548256874, -0.039881981909275055, 0.01608382724225521, 0.0426989383995533, -0.03541255742311478, 0.018666177988052368, -0.0005598545540124178, 0.007030590903013945, -0.09319117665290833, -0.027098050341010094, 0.021272720769047737, -0.028953874483704567, 0.021849438548088074, -0.02946402132511139, -0.002638468286022544, 0.07512334734201431, -0.07823307812213898, 0.02075032703578472, 0.010194802656769753, 0.017707427963614464, -0.08410881459712982, -0.015762323513627052, -0.03752601146697998, 0.03062913753092289, -0.00960955023765564, -0.03687762841582298, 0.004761442542076111, 0.02859254740178585, 0.0027607043739408255, -0.04186560958623886, 0.011977020651102066, 0.021532196551561356, -0.021032020449638367, -0.04522823169827461, 0.04681529849767685, -0.011961383745074272, -0.028855960816144943, 0.020386021584272385, -0.021891174837946892, 0.0007302105077542365, 0.007711437996476889, 0.0015477410051971674, 0.0028272243216633797, 0.013860764913260937, 0.03574728965759277, 0.01535511389374733, 0.016963858157396317, -0.015283280052244663, -0.0033254928421229124, 0.019289787858724594, -0.02842189557850361, -0.026814982295036316, 0.05600866302847862, -0.05024097487330437, -0.03818868473172188, -0.000279449624940753, 0.010220079682767391, -0.0003494582779239863, 0.008657621219754219, -0.017436742782592773, 0.0015910506481304765, -0.003465003799647093, 0.005818175617605448, -0.018229616805911064, 0.006961314473301172, 0.03936007246375084, 0.013119525276124477, -0.009491541422903538, 0.017089147120714188, -0.007863064296543598, -0.05845821276307106, -0.005638168193399906, 0.01827004924416542, -0.014163301326334476, -0.03832560405135155, 0.03323948755860329, -0.028603175655007362, -0.019610319286584854, -0.015951644629240036, -0.0032478671055287123, -0.004543422721326351, 0.0010105302790179849, -0.056078191846609116, 0.011700572445988655, -0.015141071751713753, -0.00723285460844636, 0.0033840362448245287, -0.068611279129982, 0.03860776871442795, 0.017406610772013664, -0.05585489422082901, -0.0254070945084095, -0.013478516601026058, -0.03265601024031639, 0.0056750881485641, 0.010101615451276302, 0.031167320907115936, 0.0030076513066887856, -0.03391682356595993, 0.020535577088594437, -0.01594851352274418, -0.03927350789308548, 0.06294935941696167, -0.055048320442438126, -0.06927551329135895, -0.01024904940277338, 0.014147908426821232, 0.04081109166145325, -0.015117072500288486, 0.017789969220757484, 0.0023105344735085964, 0.018260542303323746, -0.02412831038236618, -0.029002096503973007, -0.011663609184324741, 0.020469224080443382, -0.00017910874157678336, 0.0015100989257916808, 0.0009075204143300653, 0.020765244960784912, -0.008012017235159874, 0.005550646223127842, -0.05996624007821083, 0.030577173456549644, -0.06469804048538208, 0.0012394655495882034, 0.006054211407899857, 0.04187066853046417, -0.005774241406470537, -0.04330679401755333, 0.02812957763671875, 0.024367276579141617, -0.0142822852358222, 0.008293014019727707, 0.008624269627034664, 0.03354029729962349, 0.02596500888466835, -0.017860660329461098, 0.004473570268601179, -0.006216323468834162, -0.020442336797714233, -0.010183474980294704, 0.007793413009494543, 0.0015358581440523267, -0.0008429345907643437, 0.009798021055758, 0.04167307913303375, -0.018839430063962936, 0.054440297186374664, 0.019456032663583755, 0.02600025199353695, 0.011686811223626137, 0.012714770622551441, 0.017071682959794998, -0.010837001726031303, -0.006252348888665438, 0.007775821723043919, 0.00431106286123395, 0.06488283723592758, -0.0005166345508769155, -0.007332415319979191, -0.05894431099295616, -0.028950659558176994, -0.015102802775800228, 0.014000815339386463, 0.08065205067396164, 0.033495523035526276, -0.026819894090294838, -0.01587125100195408, -0.019733959808945656, 0.004723381716758013, 0.045527469366788864, -0.0012036985717713833, 0.047568295150995255, -0.006420176010578871, 0.007722013629972935, -0.0036342069506645203, -0.029304945841431618, -0.007173621561378241, -0.017665212973952293, -0.009042289108037949, 0.03754069283604622, 0.022113222628831863, 0.024661146104335785, -0.023549102246761322, -0.003505280939862132, 0.013675064779818058, -0.028681321069598198, -0.04654920846223831, -0.04084140062332153, 0.05224914848804474, 0.02022213488817215, 0.023564254865050316 ]
<p>We often average models together to create an aggregate prediction model. Some recent research suggests that simple model averages perform as well or better than model averages weighted by functions of information criterion scores. Weighted or simple, model averaging often (but not always) performs better than choosing the model with the best score. Many information criterion scores can be seen as approximations to different cross-validation schemes. Even though one model performs worse in cross-validation than another, it is still informative. I argue that an average model with weights as functions of cross-validation scores makes sense. Yet most people who do cross-validation to tune hyperparameters just choose the value of the hyperparameter that minimizes cross-validation error. In what circumstances might we expect a cross-validation-error-weighted average model to perform better than a single "best" model? I would love it if someone could point me to the most relevant research on this. Thank you.</p>
37,290
[ -0.05324588716030121, 0.00844333041459322, -0.024063406512141228, -0.025613874197006226, 0.04371749609708786, -0.002559999469667673, -0.03067564032971859, -0.0009516614954918623, 0.0439256988465786, -0.027098117396235466, 0.02380448579788208, 0.03171003609895706, 0.08274098485708237, -0.006349809467792511, 0.004030129406601191, 0.00847332552075386, -0.0031539916526526213, -0.0076886387541890144, -0.02447710558772087, 0.006243748124688864, -0.011909816414117813, 0.0268336683511734, 0.013316039927303791, -0.03447689488530159, -0.012001718394458294, 0.019193248823285103, 0.04454216733574867, -0.026753555983304977, 0.040776386857032776, 0.03471803292632103, 0.008702936582267284, 0.022861121222376823, 0.006664913147687912, 0.08364742994308472, 0.011400669813156128, -0.03501866012811661, 0.015565070323646069, -0.013694079592823982, -0.047384168952703476, 0.021368732675909996, -0.015000034123659134, -0.03055104799568653, -0.014274685643613338, 0.011489460244774818, -0.010110408999025822, 0.020038757473230362, -0.01863565295934677, -0.027990156784653664, 0.01155630312860012, -0.04953351616859436, 0.03143470361828804, -0.001494340947829187, 0.0035001682117581367, 0.07010874897241592, -0.016736887395381927, 0.03285246714949608, 0.04624618962407112, 0.055114928632974625, -0.0032336569856852293, -0.04470378905534744, -0.040226761251688004, -0.03383202105760574, 0.01632341556251049, 0.009951947256922722, -0.020182808861136436, 0.051235415041446686, -0.004493778105825186, -0.020880049094557762, 0.02228054404258728, 0.003068935126066208, -0.006139724515378475, 0.020653853192925453, 0.029533734545111656, 0.008489124476909637, -0.005672038998454809, 0.0007654569926671684, 0.032383617013692856, 0.027830321341753006, 0.06065133213996887, 0.05219300836324692, 0.013988832011818886, 0.006733190268278122, 0.02101142704486847, 0.0220645759254694, -0.006862270645797253, 0.015672123059630394, 0.07238730788230896, -0.008079307153820992, -0.006107252556830645, 0.008748410269618034, -0.005586767569184303, 0.00857570581138134, 0.023072144016623497, -0.005152591038495302, -0.020522234961390495, 0.05451655387878418, 0.007841269485652447, 0.002382531063631177, 0.008961581625044346, -0.04402772709727287, -0.014857040718197823, -0.03955454006791115, -0.00769349979236722, 0.05061587318778038, -0.01297534629702568, -0.017991207540035248, -0.03514963388442993, -0.02332693710923195, -0.017374422401189804, -0.0379205159842968, 0.00783488992601633, 0.016053898259997368, -0.006963593419641256, -0.0055143446661531925, -0.0020102630369365215, 0.025856148451566696, 0.012692244723439217, -0.02475188672542572, 0.04072242230176926, 0.04292650520801544, 0.07042689621448517, -0.04800589382648468, 0.020994428545236588, -0.024164646863937378, -0.013002031482756138, -0.01775996759533882, 0.00477740541100502, -0.011132260784506798, -0.05553450062870979, 0.04877173528075218, 0.009070884436368942, -0.0381520539522171, 0.03230523318052292, 0.0006409303168766201, -0.003389690537005663, 0.01662411540746689, -0.07401683181524277, -0.05948076769709587, 0.018704960122704506, 0.012811251915991306, 0.002295434707775712, -0.051114995032548904, -0.04200108349323273, 0.022226322442293167, 0.07586197555065155, 0.03374809771776199, 0.041715919971466064, 0.0194699764251709, 0.03150429576635361, 0.02678206004202366, -0.027528226375579834, -0.06768526881933212, -0.01412324607372284, 0.009206355549395084, -0.02389550395309925, -0.08596663922071457, 0.002720337826758623, -0.0015755208441987634, -0.02949322946369648, -0.002785238204523921, 0.028738686814904213, -0.008863378316164017, -0.03192359209060669, -0.020111706107854843, 0.026963545009493828, -0.012715593911707401, 0.0319361537694931, 0.005413088947534561, 0.050502266734838486, 0.020505759865045547, -0.003221584716811776, 0.00878980103880167, 0.04309100657701492, 0.0374470055103302, 0.00799906998872757, 0.014613592065870762, 0.009132450446486473, -0.033344291150569916, 0.010830488987267017, 0.011664743535220623, -0.0307422187179327, -0.03392218053340912, -0.021030498668551445, -0.014892243780195713, -0.013508645817637444, 0.03194405138492584, -0.016816671937704086, -0.05391630902886391, 0.019317619502544403, -0.033914268016815186, -0.04807364568114281, -0.060617364943027496, -0.02148924395442009, -0.020049087703227997, 0.011837947182357311, 0.04913550242781639, -0.013645307160913944, 0.04429673030972481, 0.00219160970300436, -0.004036553669720888, -0.035879671573638916, -0.0012046985793858767, 0.04932355135679245, -0.03940794989466667, 0.022488033398985863, 0.02808764949440956, -0.006798019167035818, -0.05785464495420456, 0.01090253796428442, -0.056064873933792114, -0.09790923446416855, 0.020686333999037743, -0.05872979760169983, -0.0012277610367164016, -0.021157367154955864, -0.021448299288749695, 0.004484416916966438, -0.028001727536320686, -0.01541157253086567, 0.01635284721851349, -0.058398354798555374, 0.08760318160057068, 0.041606925427913666, -0.020690370351076126, 0.0068343812599778175, 0.04639773815870285, 0.005536145996302366, 0.022587522864341736, -0.017364073544740677, -0.01950148120522499, -0.043015897274017334, -0.004174496978521347, 0.03861313685774803, 0.019156159833073616, -0.03729986399412155, 0.02939174510538578, 0.026001261547207832, 0.016658397391438484, 0.008969602175056934, 0.019940165802836418, 0.02146306075155735, -0.0039694784209132195, 0.025907736271619797, 0.02135690674185753, 0.011378415860235691, -0.0029594756197184324, 0.006154656410217285, -0.005444268696010113, -0.004496488254517317, 0.00828359741717577, -0.011881588958203793, 0.0401611328125, 0.00234843953512609, -0.00577563839033246, -0.01711651310324669, -0.024334685876965523, 0.03382875770330429, -0.049374163150787354, -0.0011369920102879405, 0.011063015088438988, 0.0047164843417704105, 0.02418023720383644, 0.010187124833464622, -0.0001971033780137077, 0.02460261434316635, -0.004319125320762396, -0.03708354011178017, 0.009451545774936676, 0.014504714868962765, -0.027649080380797386, 0.011613791808485985, -0.02747287042438984, -0.01701182872056961, -0.020920665934681892, 0.0013115063775330782, 0.036798324435949326, -0.0026794131845235825, 0.017711151391267776, -0.021127643063664436, -0.024858105927705765, -0.02782910317182541, -0.02634657733142376, 0.01824774406850338, 0.0016138736391440034, -0.014450944028794765, -0.004775562323629856, -0.0500318817794323, -0.018314266577363014, 0.08320672065019608, -0.04238760098814964, -0.037701718509197235, -0.005021177232265472, 0.03881634399294853, -0.0496482253074646, -0.04326721280813217, -0.03276371955871582, -0.004777862690389156, -0.017403505742549896, -0.031187942251563072, 0.03190995007753372, 0.008960356935858727, -0.03255771845579147, 0.07106692343950272, 0.016334012150764465, -0.03228418156504631, 0.0031720236875116825, 0.0071418797597289085, 0.025606496259570122, -0.006701427046209574, 0.04158167168498039, 0.033951155841350555, -0.03914960101246834, -0.03646016865968704, -0.08415649831295013, -0.04592045769095421, 0.042643867433071136, -0.034152716398239136, 0.03645087778568268, 0.0339161641895771, -0.01924780011177063, 0.06662079691886902, 0.006325302179902792, -0.021952351555228233, -0.05755012854933739, 0.011545520275831223, -0.01733880676329136, 0.009584150277078152, 0.010324954986572266, 0.04254549369215965, 0.006261161994189024, 0.04931093379855156, 0.003941114991903305, -0.005742801818996668, 0.021278783679008484, 0.0026008770801126957, 0.02511049248278141, 0.004232183564454317, -0.0008232825202867389, -0.024684373289346695, -0.017148582264780998, 0.01689627766609192, 0.012589829973876476, 0.01866832934319973, 0.03918019309639931, 0.03761168569326401, 0.007091263774782419, -0.02648717537522316, 0.04223715141415596, -0.021116236224770546, 0.022780781611800194, -0.03134459629654884, 0.011505680158734322, -0.008843024261295795, -0.0017993963556364179, -0.02170507423579693, 0.041841212660074234, 0.02806951105594635, -0.018514685332775116, 0.031511805951595306, 0.026114342734217644, 0.03908958286046982, -0.012746250256896019, -0.0073647573590278625, -0.012553311884403229, -0.003259439719840884, 0.022182675078511238, 0.009052292443811893, -0.014004606753587723, 0.042245492339134216, 0.05827929824590683, -0.018659483641386032, -0.03326019272208214, -0.050214484333992004, 0.025747748091816902, -0.09235996007919312, -0.010226689279079437, -0.03429367020726204, 0.03014455735683441, 0.0379536934196949, 0.01844659447669983, 0.023584915325045586, -0.021710330620408058, 0.004229700192809105, 0.00390779459849, -0.04461473971605301, 0.015899555757641792, 0.013959570787847042, 0.019639892503619194, -0.003368917852640152, -0.027033241465687752, 0.024449288845062256, -0.014328193850815296, 0.0128175662830472, -0.021885089576244354, 0.062051039189100266, -0.0270722433924675, 0.001912999781779945, -0.011598043143749237, -0.007898925803601742, -0.032092999666929245, 0.013844885863363743, 0.03199883922934532, 0.009344936348497868, 0.0183155108243227, 0.019860802218317986, -0.008329846896231174, -0.03448385372757912, -0.04548501968383789, 0.025605948641896248, -0.0005466504371725023, 0.031434331089258194, 0.01615830324590206, 0.026913562789559364, -0.04015110805630684, 0.03898990526795387, -0.018911782652139664, 0.019853251054883003, 0.016021793708205223, -0.048264164477586746, -0.029173944145441055, -0.0436602458357811, -0.011247984133660793, 0.009596584364771843, 0.020426470786333084, 0.004792502149939537, 0.01157465297728777, 0.03832811489701271, -0.006448327098041773, -0.01253513153642416, -0.001258369768038392, 0.07261572778224945, 0.02217489294707775, 0.015996478497982025, -0.03869475796818733, -0.005448714829981327, -0.011065714061260223, -0.0330376997590065, 0.056661445647478104, -0.023755179718136787, 0.017164774239063263, -0.01740259677171707, 0.018095476552844048, -0.03669387847185135, -0.03374253958463669, -0.04060567542910576, 0.04067831486463547, 0.0377383790910244, 0.010076483711600304, -0.05084335431456566, -0.006728207226842642, 0.08960491418838501, 0.05913081765174866, 0.006972296163439751, -0.023605000227689743, -0.082391157746315, 0.0029521966353058815, 0.05022888258099556, 0.012291115708649158, -0.03721801936626434, -0.020285239443182945, -0.02390621043741703, 0.0031914538703858852, 0.03578638657927513, -0.0006312350160442293, -0.01139167882502079, 0.024960070848464966, -0.01956777647137642, -0.008129732683300972, 0.0011179039720445871, -0.028860028833150864, 0.009495813399553299, -0.0005157235427759588, 0.05544646829366684, -0.0039048250764608383, -0.02758008800446987, -0.04047374799847603, 0.04936636611819267, 0.0019253104692324996, 0.019601069390773773, -0.014003189280629158, -0.00624321773648262, 0.003862980753183365, 0.011091018095612526, -0.02373364381492138, -0.07077869772911072, -0.029656434431672096, -0.019795110449194908, -0.028994260355830193, 0.02695140801370144, 0.0033733053132891655, -0.03904243931174278, 0.002571891061961651, 0.016880469396710396, -0.0488564595580101, -0.020545748993754387, 0.0033359492663294077, 0.009191115386784077, 0.027382683008909225, 0.03028249368071556, 0.08068957179784775, -0.00021902238950133324, 0.006105039734393358, -0.022336721420288086, -0.02691359631717205, 0.005029564723372459, -0.018610462546348572, -0.03786207363009453, -0.020411796867847443, -0.042538225650787354, -0.0034197550266981125, 0.01336028054356575, -0.014498796314001083, 0.05840683728456497, -0.03245892375707626, -0.021966543048620224, -0.019066862761974335, -0.00216751080006361, -0.006082452833652496, -0.016459520906209946, -0.0008090838673524559, 0.021983226761221886, -0.005431048106402159, 0.011222369968891144, 0.01729976013302803, -0.024542061612010002, 0.002057089237496257, 0.027458233758807182, -0.05706128105521202, 0.018178941681981087, -0.024507464841008186, -0.005838928744196892, 0.0409548357129097, 0.0012362132547423244, 0.06211650371551514, 0.0038453012239187956, 0.02017880417406559, 0.011859230697154999, -0.03493199497461319, -0.013145668432116508, -0.012352376244962215, -0.00004247252218192443, 0.061962325125932693, -0.030048007145524025, 0.04237499088048935, -0.03341018408536911, -0.010341175831854343, -0.06774929910898209, -0.03223109617829323, 0.040629275143146515, -0.0020187473855912685, -0.02565869688987732, -0.007419264875352383, 0.041388168931007385, -0.05949147045612335, -0.019282082095742226, -0.0015015930403023958, 0.06981515884399414, -0.006595463491976261, -0.010574418120086193, 0.01098712533712387, 0.03014330565929413, 0.07589060813188553, -0.005487991962581873, 0.043984465301036835, 0.02028481289744377, -0.03691175952553749, -0.030335649847984314, 0.016262637451291084, 0.022070685401558876, -0.06543263792991638, -0.01697889342904091, -0.010709023103117943, -0.01947932504117489, 0.06579404324293137, -0.02095869369804859, 0.003869958221912384, 0.031090350821614265, -0.018997760489583015, -0.013764306902885437, 0.013468281365931034, 0.01226496696472168, -0.03713347762823105, 0.003794645657762885, -0.00922572985291481, 0.020747940987348557, -0.023778872564435005, -0.021776072680950165, 0.02571823075413704, -0.0099689532071352, -0.03577820584177971, 0.005598374642431736, 0.06141190975904465, 0.009079573675990105, 0.02452458254992962, -0.004412681329995394, -0.06517500430345535, 0.06284643709659576, -0.013246175833046436, 0.0172308087348938, 0.038746997714042664, 0.036724332720041275, -0.04989591985940933, -0.04995447397232056, -0.030294381082057953, -0.009631956927478313, 0.04950549826025963, -0.041395388543605804, 0.07477636635303497, 0.030002696439623833, 0.009970110841095448, -0.020452830940485, -0.06327196210622787, -0.023645779117941856, -0.024289559572935104, 0.005611147731542587, 0.04371185973286629, 0.014836565591394901, -0.020352821797132492, 0.025195106863975525, -0.0014965824084356427, 0.02299552969634533, 0.026594027876853943, 0.014781268313527107, 0.03786700591444969, 0.0032204894814640284, -0.04265480116009712, -0.03880244866013527, 0.042289502918720245, -0.04714588075876236, -0.023506129160523415, -0.001403867150656879, -0.031679216772317886, 0.023907918483018875, 0.022403301671147346, -0.030684849247336388, -0.0404500849545002, -0.024958698078989983, -0.02332465536892414, 0.017191581428050995, -0.008259281516075134, -0.038866229355335236, 0.050846077501773834, 0.021316660568118095, 0.010680894367396832, 0.014026195742189884, 0.00606731791049242, -0.029551425948739052, -0.089104063808918, -0.02020922489464283, 0.005892981309443712, -0.040525082498788834, 0.026011956855654716, 0.04818036034703255, -0.04571490362286568, 0.023248767480254173, -0.026252564042806625, 0.018555207177996635, -0.0034812220837920904, 0.016113001853227615, -0.03250596299767494, 0.04938345029950142, -0.033735740929841995, -0.0077607776038348675, 0.014117958955466747, 0.01962379179894924, 0.14260175824165344, 0.09099258482456207, 0.026712127029895782, -0.047431182116270065, 0.021706458181142807, 0.02215898036956787, -0.009193246252834797, -0.009736242704093456, -0.010539456270635128, 0.03431404381990433, 0.01186202373355627, 0.00815384741872549, 0.043270960450172424, 0.023165345191955566, -0.027233310043811798, 0.04504961892962456, -0.014827905222773552, 0.028545452281832695, 0.044585198163986206, 0.029198436066508293, 0.045226212590932846, -0.04187309369444847, -0.017704062163829803, 0.018790436908602715, 0.01692933775484562, 0.019963616505265236, -0.0034554200246930122, -0.04519385099411011, -0.010550362057983875, 0.002893033204600215, 0.020071424543857574, 0.014650886878371239, 0.01068920735269785, -0.0003764105204027146, -0.028117110952734947, 0.03437664732336998, -0.018864592537283897, -0.023199623450636864, 0.004423858597874641, 0.00675646448507905, -0.00002432009750918951, -0.013613076880574226, 0.008730393834412098, 0.04598537087440491, -0.045660991221666336, -0.034961946308612823, -0.041128356009721756, 0.0033171745017170906, -0.002319699851796031, -0.00828163418918848, -0.015698734670877457, 0.005597641225904226, 0.010146141983568668, -0.024984875693917274, -0.022038064897060394, 0.003926427103579044, 0.06340301036834717, -0.01424857322126627, -0.030095797032117844, -0.03321431577205658, 0.03190349042415619, 0.011089764535427094, 0.01687219925224781, 0.02163020148873329, -0.039996374398469925, -0.04524952918291092, -0.014550729654729366, 0.0629478394985199, 0.01562478207051754, -0.009405694901943207, -0.0005405463743954897, 0.0037428720388561487, -0.054524339735507965, -0.030143197625875473, 0.022004764527082443, -0.015825403854250908, 0.07345938682556152, 0.01211761124432087, 0.0004262884031049907, -0.016520818695425987, -0.0589652881026268, -0.005582610610872507, 0.003934141714125872, -0.01662886142730713, -0.031830158084630966, 0.022911638021469116, -0.013752756640315056, 0.011853124015033245, 0.02579028345644474, 0.0023417221382260323, 0.004827403929084539, 0.00676835048943758, -0.015050684101879597, -0.020900294184684753, 0.031360138207674026, 0.01249941997230053, 0.003897982183843851, 0.018909545615315437, 0.015451472252607346, 0.06566738337278366, 0.0019208065932616591, 0.02703036367893219, -0.03516712784767151, 0.04711655154824257, -0.002835253020748496, 0.012504355981945992, -0.007800006773322821, -0.06162505969405174, -0.002887713722884655, -0.025787875056266785, 0.003045380348339677, -0.04676658287644386, 0.0032828394323587418, -0.04254554957151413, -0.05345715209841728, 0.03288858383893967, -0.006340320222079754, -0.037248823791742325, 0.027700010687112808, -0.013159037567675114, 0.05690009519457817, -0.0213011521846056, 0.006144343875348568, -0.035060979425907135, 0.03290478512644768, -0.04134305566549301, -0.03077087178826332, 0.015215837396681309, 0.005469499155879021, -0.008050883188843727, -0.020204827189445496, 0.05507436394691467, -0.005172431468963623, -0.0012228988343849778, 0.017889706417918205, -0.005866120103746653, -0.014481953345239162, 0.06670332700014114, -0.0451805517077446, -0.022072046995162964, 0.05342605710029602, -0.018812740221619606, -0.013547039590775967, -0.014294120483100414, -0.019147643819451332, 0.01341492310166359, 0.033608727157115936, -0.030958937481045723, -0.025393672287464142, 0.05639394372701645, -0.032874226570129395, -0.008959357626736164, -0.01309991255402565, 0.01640438847243786, 0.02772260643541813, 0.028131520375609398, 0.024291284382343292, 0.026063228026032448, -0.010403077118098736, 0.011552449315786362, 0.0220646895468235, -0.015111243352293968, -0.01395406760275364, 0.008586040697991848, -0.018748007714748383, 0.03072226047515869, -0.018586501479148865, 0.015565483830869198, -0.002165354322642088, 0.05687794089317322, -0.01789133995771408, 0.030433550477027893, -0.003292905865237117, -0.00810976792126894, -0.0741361454129219, -0.007200163323432207, 0.02403067797422409, 0.026164529845118523, -0.002575239399448037, -0.03457317501306534, 0.038831088691949844, 0.050052303820848465, -0.05157347023487091, 0.00522422231733799, -0.0227830670773983, -0.04480791091918945, -0.022742029279470444, 0.0021635054145008326, -0.04211623594164848, -0.013300947844982147, 0.03426247462630272, -0.007157685235142708, 0.01430296991020441, 0.0032522552646696568, 0.011456083506345749, 0.0051271566189825535, -0.04216879606246948, 0.045727916061878204, -0.0009374003857374191, -0.008867225609719753, 0.055068857967853546, 0.0023797079920768738, -0.06289970129728317, 0.04650774225592613, 0.0035434518940746784, 0.006822913885116577, -0.00024610813125036657, 0.022458581253886223, 0.03998086228966713, 0.028676344081759453, 0.03435184434056282, -0.0410383976995945, -0.019886713474988937, 0.04613196477293968, 0.014338101260364056, 0.01623213291168213, -0.015789052471518517, 0.04436912760138512, -0.006217688322067261, 0.015343381091952324, -0.060795482248067856, -0.006741632707417011, -0.005155750084668398, -0.04229458048939705, -0.015802018344402313, 0.0013454413274303079, 0.008607182651758194, -0.007815803401172161, 0.017574260011315346, -0.004930737894028425, 0.0013981368392705917, 0.02926066145300865, -0.0016141162486746907, -0.011847252957522869, 0.03648897260427475, -0.010687456466257572, -0.03628091886639595, -0.00309205474331975, 0.008820685558021069, -0.006822334136813879, -0.0163906030356884, -0.014307796023786068, 0.009531316347420216, 0.014883041381835938, -0.05198641121387482, -0.01955731213092804, -0.028450487181544304, 0.05897960066795349, -0.016736377030611038, 0.049185242503881454, 0.004593633580952883, -0.06485582888126373, 0.002618578728288412, -0.09690409153699875, 0.07763782888650894, 0.006047163158655167, -0.028612948954105377, -0.00235379277728498, -0.022088689729571342, 0.011777330189943314, -0.0327129140496254, 0.07454392313957214, 0.024538999423384666, 0.014543760567903519, -0.01769109070301056, 0.0146369319409132, -0.04950859025120735, -0.03009093552827835, 0.04840240254998207, -0.017330633476376534, -0.0017896791687235236, -0.030144788324832916, -0.005212070886045694, -0.0035333139821887016, 0.014873446896672249, 0.01761477440595627, -0.04570774361491203, 0.033294644206762314, 0.004379115998744965, 0.021456068381667137, 0.0711360052227974, 0.023071106523275375, -0.010941235348582268, 0.05358121544122696, 0.014284285716712475, 0.0370478630065918, -0.011369012296199799, -0.01763068698346615, -0.01701285131275654, 0.04028148204088211, -0.022670671343803406, -0.024804985150694847, -0.011274829506874084, 0.05648219585418701, -0.021206587553024292, -0.032923731952905655, 0.016490735113620758, 0.05409001186490059, -0.038225479423999786, -0.019932983443140984, 0.052550286054611206, 0.04548775404691696, 0.03477919474244118, 0.04679638892412186, 0.019508102908730507, 0.018453707918524742, 0.0009966681245714426, 0.004246534779667854, 0.011252730153501034, 0.057238269597291946, 0.03514885529875755, 0.012251708656549454, 0.019274286925792694, -0.023693399503827095, 0.03284865990281105, -0.017537491396069527, 0.04540954530239105, -0.04873710498213768, -0.03863423317670822, 0.021663326770067215, -0.0205408725887537, 0.005751210730522871, -0.02984403632581234, -0.018399320542812347, 0.06424221396446228, -0.028529932722449303, -0.030120834708213806, -0.041944049298763275, -0.025321563705801964, 0.007846985943615437, -0.011598479934036732, -0.022604063153266907, 0.03480822220444679, 0.02881287969648838, -0.0013376004062592983, -0.018545763567090034, -0.0043417541310191154, 0.011476391926407814, 0.012195128947496414, 0.019395066425204277, -0.014333314262330532, -0.006963874213397503, -0.02373931184411049, -0.021613677963614464, -0.025394292548298836, 0.014260688796639442, 0.0162806436419487, 0.03658492490649223, 0.03219488263130188, 0.010145312175154686, -0.022296251729130745, 0.010891820304095745, 0.052058055996894836, -0.08758054673671722, -0.0215702373534441, -0.05360277742147446, -0.004487915430217981, 0.02491590939462185, -0.015646768733859062 ]