question
stringlengths
37
38.8k
group_id
int64
0
74.5k
sentence_embeddings
sequencelengths
1.02k
1.02k
<p>I recently read a paper in which the authors claim that in order to compare the forecasting performance of two non-nested models, models A and B, a valid procedure is to fit models A and B on the same data set, and compare the average likelihood of the fitted models computed on the hold-out data set. All that is required is that models A and B are expressed as probability densities for the same variable. I am using the language of the paper: strictly speaking the quantities being compared are fitted models evaluated at data points, not likelihoods. Accepting this likelihood as the forecasting accuracy metric, this method for checking forecast accuracy has some intuitive appeal, although I have misgivings. Can these likelihoods be meaningfully compared without some sort of normalization? The out of sample probabilities will not add up to one. I'm not able to come up with a straightforward example in which this test would give a spurious result.</p> <p>update: I was able to produce a simple example in which direct comparison of out of sample likelihoods gave a misleading result: let the dependent variable y be a linear trend plus normally distributed error term, and let the explanatory variable x be a linear trend plus independent normally distributed error term. Generate 100 points for y and x. Model A is a linear regression, while for model B I used a regression with Student t-distributed errors (with two degrees of freedom). I trained on the first 50 points and tested on the second set of 50 points, and repeated with training and test sets interchanged. I repeated with three choices of variance for the data generating process. Model B gave higher average out of sample likelihoods in all cases. This example is a bit contrived but does illustrate my concern.</p>
74,016
[ -0.029233405366539955, -0.01680378057062626, -0.01179887168109417, -0.008211182430386543, 0.029288271442055702, 0.003489515045657754, -0.003102357964962721, 0.00430836109444499, 0.055781908333301544, -0.016781866550445557, 0.0023839755449444056, 0.03823729231953621, 0.06578650325536728, 0.005286222789436579, -0.009899559430778027, 0.01130794920027256, -0.025049902498722076, 0.025340085849165916, 0.005492219235748053, -0.04927985370159149, 0.010299813002347946, 0.023074043914675713, -0.002614343771710992, -0.02338704653084278, -0.010766806080937386, 0.019346661865711212, 0.0066113159991800785, -0.01944868452847004, -0.004273353610187769, 0.05104269087314606, -0.009710649028420448, -0.03081381879746914, 0.032595016062259674, 0.029516689479351044, 0.02007240243256092, 0.010975993238389492, 0.006946139968931675, -0.047491058707237244, -0.01619524508714676, 0.025542017072439194, -0.04053419455885887, -0.02113601379096508, 0.014432614669203758, 0.05431205406785011, -0.017434287816286087, 0.028254514560103416, -0.0018099076114594936, -0.027061114087700844, 0.021930983290076256, -0.019888224080204964, 0.061883095651865005, 0.005358919966965914, -0.014314661733806133, 0.05992883816361427, -0.028767874464392662, -0.02181982807815075, 0.030609363690018654, 0.046790070831775665, -0.010060753673315048, -0.03172174468636513, -0.016707105562090874, -0.051679763942956924, 0.005238312296569347, 0.0033797603100538254, -0.05008913576602936, 0.01276012510061264, -0.0018650664715096354, -0.017699798569083214, 0.044244349002838135, -0.06413158774375916, 0.0029337620362639427, 0.023094166070222855, 0.006786419544368982, 0.012876640073955059, 0.017359822988510132, -0.0029457027558237314, -0.0019800206646323204, 0.039591722190380096, 0.05560455843806267, 0.04359652101993561, 0.00474499212577939, 0.020311804488301277, 0.03408300504088402, 0.05109412968158722, 0.03268758952617645, -0.0016314690001308918, 0.10196087509393692, -0.04176529869437218, 0.006277994252741337, 0.006132009904831648, -0.0295773483812809, 0.006573363672941923, 0.06886802613735199, -0.027480151504278183, -0.05246146768331528, 0.041156865656375885, -0.014423739165067673, 0.01395519357174635, 0.004445693921297789, 0.018472053110599518, -0.027277369052171707, -0.04959676042199135, 0.02241578884422779, 0.045564621686935425, 0.04645054414868355, -0.04242647439241409, 0.007163375616073608, -0.027239199727773666, -0.022912347689270973, -0.03751208260655403, -0.02938486821949482, 0.03136863932013512, -0.012117603793740273, 0.029944339767098427, -0.005547483451664448, 0.023899409919977188, -0.010139204561710358, -0.024352462962269783, 0.049341846257448196, 0.02925438992679119, 0.04286651685833931, -0.01125507801771164, 0.02375398576259613, -0.05281534418463707, -0.0286968182772398, 0.0053202807903289795, -0.0072491103783249855, -0.023296089842915535, -0.09061506390571594, 0.053447283804416656, 0.015059678815305233, -0.013991555199027061, 0.00046976652811281383, -0.013587293215095997, 0.043362829834222794, 0.01043839193880558, -0.05900881811976433, -0.07534909248352051, 0.04308871924877167, 0.01140602957457304, 0.026370402425527573, -0.03286650776863098, -0.020493388175964355, 0.01976841688156128, 0.03807087615132332, 0.013135387562215328, 0.07738985121250153, -0.004559810739010572, 0.03699355199933052, -0.007317055482417345, -0.04841504991054535, -0.006512796506285667, -0.027820385992527008, -0.04554201290011406, -0.0366070531308651, -0.10246718674898148, 0.013698887079954147, 0.0018379613757133484, -0.030244087800383568, 0.001045449054799974, 0.03363563120365143, -0.006127681117504835, -0.02600216679275036, -0.01689983904361725, 0.04044133052229881, -0.03651973977684975, 0.04729178547859192, -0.02185995876789093, 0.0180071871727705, 0.01537614781409502, -0.028683163225650787, 0.0008175000548362732, 0.031560808420181274, 0.025292392820119858, 0.035689108073711395, -0.03173358738422394, 0.0029596704989671707, -0.036592353135347366, 0.0498880036175251, 0.01629440113902092, -0.04868241026997566, 0.02542916312813759, -0.005314788781106472, 0.02242959290742874, -0.0041150376200675964, 0.047505661845207214, -0.0056880321353673935, -0.02354303002357483, 0.024119524285197258, -0.05966023728251457, -0.013189245946705341, -0.04882346838712692, -0.008944841101765633, -0.025421906262636185, -0.0029601147398352623, 0.05333314090967178, -0.010849153622984886, 0.04907438904047012, -0.01172875240445137, -0.022551095113158226, -0.03202084079384804, -0.00956738367676735, 0.027612347155809402, -0.029416272416710854, 0.027283048257231712, 0.03708795830607414, 0.029285797849297523, 0.017280960455536842, -0.0026108932215720415, -0.03917425125837326, -0.031855545938014984, 0.012971863150596619, -0.026744859293103218, -0.0006351069314405322, 0.013062488287687302, -0.026459941640496254, 0.0001775554846972227, -0.016979264095425606, -0.011977174319326878, 0.05521593987941742, -0.05800348147749901, 0.006943153217434883, 0.06447532027959824, 0.01791444607079029, -0.02265843003988266, 0.01928607001900673, 0.007197048980742693, 0.02562355063855648, -0.01485374290496111, 0.01086835190653801, -0.047673922032117844, -0.0373326800763607, 0.02277824655175209, 0.021834678947925568, -0.006409851834177971, 0.023521149531006813, 0.08218604326248169, -0.004767529666423798, 0.014316942542791367, 0.06342761963605881, 0.015720920637249947, -0.04577647149562836, 0.017208941280841827, 0.008225408382713795, 0.048913974314928055, 0.009139123372733593, 0.025638079270720482, 0.0012372551718726754, 0.009015223011374474, 0.024568593129515648, 0.044166140258312225, 0.02749226614832878, -0.02310079336166382, 0.01499834656715393, -0.006539515685290098, 0.0168892964720726, 0.011120668612420559, -0.04601298272609711, -0.015189636498689651, 0.008299549110233784, -0.010089484974741936, 0.012768693268299103, -0.00826573371887207, 0.014589056372642517, 0.07927734404802322, 0.034911684691905975, 0.012267371639609337, 0.005162878427654505, 0.03428656607866287, -0.047887884080410004, -0.013240999542176723, -0.020915010944008827, -0.045239634811878204, -0.0173913836479187, 0.005210514180362225, 0.02133147604763508, 0.01598379947245121, 0.020083092153072357, -0.04178041219711304, -0.030142255127429962, 0.0030429617036134005, -0.006487542763352394, 0.010739869438111782, -0.019065633416175842, -0.025690702721476555, 0.010877982713282108, -0.013300183229148388, -0.037383586168289185, 0.038679685443639755, -0.02002428099513054, -0.00786268338561058, 0.014419157058000565, 0.0039861081168055534, -0.007512595038861036, -0.021184366196393967, -0.02742060273885727, -0.009143444709479809, -0.001026249025017023, -0.03910527750849724, 0.00927380658686161, -0.006440021563321352, -0.029942071065306664, 0.046850576996803284, -0.004397768992930651, -0.005682490300387144, -0.030597275123000145, 0.019502652809023857, -0.02576342411339283, 0.001639627036638558, 0.02829200215637684, 0.04299814626574516, -0.029812190681695938, -0.008868420496582985, -0.06573354452848434, -0.05494203791022301, 0.004534389823675156, -0.004468049854040146, 0.04120994731783867, 0.023589402437210083, -0.024466056376695633, 0.06857699155807495, 0.04549190029501915, -0.023441100493073463, -0.017921393737196922, -0.0025814874097704887, -0.051362134516239166, 0.013145064003765583, 0.026107260957360268, -0.007133433595299721, -0.011661193333566189, 0.04215119406580925, -0.005989332217723131, -0.0027194074355065823, 0.04264197126030922, -0.02060822583734989, 0.00906455423682928, 0.0022978391498327255, 0.042239896953105927, -0.0037860639858990908, 0.033167947083711624, 0.02251235395669937, -0.020812436938285828, 0.005072346422821283, 0.0111203258857131, 0.05466752499341965, 0.041031964123249054, -0.01657899282872677, 0.05512378364801407, 0.0002984589373227209, 0.0026430522557348013, -0.025742623955011368, 0.055625978857278824, 0.015669668093323708, -0.018588131293654442, -0.040134962648153305, 0.032361678779125214, 0.03565667197108269, 0.005455017555505037, 0.031224407255649567, 0.05740420147776604, 0.06108397617936134, -0.012986511923372746, -0.032044991850852966, 0.008433944545686245, -0.0012660952052101493, 0.02916363812983036, -0.011813457123935223, -0.0339076854288578, 0.047196164727211, 0.019510457292199135, 0.00005217198486207053, -0.011642285622656345, -0.031943950802087784, 0.014559481292963028, -0.05466923862695694, 0.02797734923660755, -0.04495754837989807, 0.0204788651317358, 0.021947354078292847, 0.013835912570357323, -0.03426390513777733, -0.026097944006323814, 0.005037966649979353, -0.022904418408870697, -0.045456886291503906, 0.029370585456490517, -0.003235368523746729, -0.017668571323156357, -0.010207771323621273, -0.02686932124197483, 0.01669580489397049, -0.04053246229887009, 0.02398349530994892, -0.0112319216132164, 0.03226338326931, -0.015025638043880463, 0.02761583961546421, -0.024834908545017242, -0.022228842601180077, -0.008596980944275856, -0.017668092623353004, 0.005345770623534918, -0.025892598554491997, 0.040591828525066376, 0.05054469406604767, -0.018327433615922928, -0.016485655680298805, -0.037209175527095795, 0.01670832373201847, 0.003197392215952277, 0.031178466975688934, 0.04862723499536514, 0.032841674983501434, -0.04526850953698158, 0.041128210723400116, 0.027796199545264244, 0.036848943680524826, 0.056402843445539474, -0.027229761704802513, -0.05268629640340805, -0.02674664929509163, -0.05302993953227997, 0.04821959510445595, -0.019560525193810463, 0.01756272464990616, -0.014493502676486969, 0.06272166222333908, 0.031591057777404785, -0.014833307825028896, 0.04106563329696655, 0.0524134635925293, -0.0027522125747054815, 0.030045317485928535, -0.0011670889798551798, 0.0038261772133409977, -0.013838819228112698, -0.014743500389158726, 0.023776596412062645, -0.0164258424192667, 0.030788470059633255, -0.032221730798482895, 0.042990125715732574, -0.039184264838695526, -0.031951386481523514, 0.006468184292316437, 0.01934041455388069, 0.02136259339749813, 0.016454041004180908, -0.03492135554552078, 0.05712561681866646, 0.04858137294650078, 0.04705780744552612, 0.06369807571172714, -0.004545398987829685, -0.08208967745304108, 0.017806023359298706, 0.053056154400110245, 0.007251217029988766, -0.03422154113650322, -0.013405879959464073, -0.0090649938210845, -0.026559563353657722, 0.0178070031106472, -0.016480538994073868, 0.025995556265115738, -0.01725422404706478, 0.033232249319553375, -0.02820250205695629, -0.026338541880249977, -0.061698827892541885, -0.03603415563702583, -0.03602156415581703, 0.026819350197911263, -0.023877551779150963, -0.025310078635811806, -0.031960196793079376, -0.014234566129744053, 0.020870380103588104, 0.04330619424581528, -0.008250975050032139, -0.0506446436047554, -0.0006158881005831063, 0.0028939966578036547, -0.008660552091896534, -0.061151497066020966, 0.003469571005553007, 0.04421192407608032, -0.02777165360748768, 0.026326723396778107, -0.004951488692313433, -0.043750617653131485, 0.020113592967391014, -0.019531531259417534, -0.032276399433612823, -0.0047846301458776, 0.017127927392721176, 0.009019696153700352, 0.036548931151628494, 0.025634849444031715, 0.052257344126701355, 0.040987368673086166, -0.00018290830485057086, -0.0027514430694282055, -0.025324039161205292, 0.0075874426402151585, -0.02161029726266861, -0.02957349456846714, -0.062098775058984756, -0.018132982775568962, -0.01506264228373766, 0.03482796251773834, 0.008714798837900162, 0.030254829674959183, -0.03949868679046631, 0.0005605550832115114, -0.01982668600976467, 0.04878109693527222, -0.02182072214782238, -0.03490593656897545, -0.01086078304797411, 0.023278627544641495, -0.010177859105169773, 0.0020399184431880713, 0.008599814027547836, -0.04833262041211128, 0.0071006156504154205, 0.03091309405863285, -0.04854772984981537, 0.0030375185888260603, -0.00927034392952919, 0.005839901976287365, 0.017624761909246445, 0.004098748322576284, 0.019031863659620285, 0.002249191515147686, 0.038686253130435944, -0.014494197443127632, -0.006855359300971031, 0.019088564440608025, 0.015527484938502312, 0.021922653540968895, 0.051760829985141754, -0.008121847175061703, 0.004743145313113928, -0.018786277621984482, -0.005954253952950239, -0.05584050342440605, 0.003845492610707879, 0.016441727057099342, 0.008868185803294182, -0.03671257570385933, -0.023905789479613304, 0.00045018576201982796, -0.014130473136901855, 0.012021361850202084, -0.06921052932739258, 0.0595824159681797, -0.03336404263973236, -0.042860738933086395, -0.019608573988080025, 0.011849689297378063, 0.104642353951931, -0.02863061986863613, -0.005359089933335781, -0.009030284360051155, 0.0036540082655847073, 0.000372035225154832, 0.022016888484358788, 0.02168913744390011, -0.03819899633526802, 0.022404823452234268, -0.010354332625865936, -0.022881893441081047, 0.03019998036324978, -0.03873302415013313, -0.041935477405786514, 0.07063533365726471, -0.015954503789544106, 0.02422553114593029, -0.008137499913573265, 0.003917037043720484, -0.05278420075774193, 0.0010043438524007797, -0.022745292633771896, 0.022490527480840683, 0.02465074695646763, -0.007002988364547491, 0.03866060823202133, -0.022544827312231064, -0.030877865850925446, 0.0016306423349305987, 0.1028735488653183, 0.021171126514673233, 0.005592236295342445, -0.01036800816655159, -0.022565709426999092, 0.05909230187535286, 0.03724759817123413, 0.024984924122691154, 0.016471462324261665, 0.03116229735314846, -0.012809064239263535, -0.02779209427535534, 0.0063276998698711395, 0.016130482777953148, 0.040399983525276184, -0.0241194199770689, 0.043698765337467194, 0.020121391862630844, -0.003268588799983263, -0.007183249108493328, -0.05781236290931702, 0.0018513344693928957, -0.016949471086263657, -0.015439527109265327, 0.04224877431988716, -0.02374211698770523, -0.013515337370336056, 0.030131541192531586, 0.008318718522787094, 0.019538514316082, 0.030410023406147957, -0.004348238464444876, 0.016469761729240417, 0.014642426744103432, 0.014123262837529182, -0.02533872053027153, 0.05463606119155884, -0.0249688308686018, -0.020292680710554123, -0.0360887385904789, -0.017325710505247116, 0.030792906880378723, 0.0227075032889843, -0.0011739778565242887, -0.01150896493345499, -0.025501566007733345, -0.09908051043748856, 0.015741081908345222, 0.026973916217684746, 0.00029271937091834843, 0.05116518214344978, 0.012415188364684582, 0.006580287590622902, 0.023615321144461632, 0.0024610748514533043, -0.062155332416296005, -0.06456298381090164, -0.05475515127182007, -0.029446924105286598, 0.003206853987649083, 0.0075151873752474785, -0.03257111832499504, -0.0015940724406391382, 0.04008067771792412, -0.020413003861904144, 0.03154700621962547, -0.02708207443356514, 0.01390948798507452, -0.02267087809741497, 0.05158115178346634, -0.027542298659682274, 0.014218435622751713, -0.04242107272148132, 0.007277787197381258, 0.11903958767652512, 0.053168028593063354, 0.04209451377391815, -0.05208383873105049, 0.01708933524787426, -0.029354320839047432, -0.014444884844124317, -0.0031235013157129288, -0.00531782628968358, 0.039321426302194595, -0.009037240408360958, 0.009898918680846691, 0.0536021888256073, -0.02123229019343853, -0.026349496096372604, 0.0312819629907608, -0.019175220280885696, 0.008094794116914272, 0.015581502579152584, 0.0027640981134027243, 0.017164111137390137, -0.029908437281847, -0.03488033264875412, -0.016414711251854897, -0.03990960493683815, 0.00888675358146429, 0.019123071804642677, -0.004165179096162319, -0.001095895771868527, 0.01053470466285944, -0.04039357975125313, 0.000899596547242254, 0.02678767777979374, 0.03510688990354538, 0.00320906238630414, 0.0037095556035637856, -0.017321916297078133, -0.014991150237619877, 0.009107325226068497, 0.058045659214258194, 0.01568782515823841, -0.008176266215741634, -0.008485564030706882, 0.000012837503163609654, -0.03689320757985115, -0.039027243852615356, -0.04238234460353851, 0.02134772762656212, -0.004065562505275011, -0.021197961643338203, -0.000060034417401766405, -0.012157293036580086, 0.008522565476596355, -0.011221283115446568, 0.0034858763683587313, 0.015828769654035568, -0.01032929215580225, -0.028410179540514946, -0.01282383780926466, -0.027001427486538887, 0.02663557417690754, 0.024010617285966873, 0.013128464110195637, 0.024589302018284798, -0.019939854741096497, 0.01044929213821888, 0.015213355422019958, 0.08850350230932236, -0.01853429526090622, 0.004003656562417746, -0.022822149097919464, -0.00006828253390267491, -0.04668829217553139, -0.02459777519106865, 0.01635807752609253, -0.019099103286862373, 0.0342625230550766, 0.010084627196192741, 0.02591961994767189, -0.022363992407917976, -0.055335186421871185, -0.008763454854488373, 0.0068809278309345245, 0.009832467883825302, -0.04048490151762962, 0.02113199792802334, 0.02332625351846218, -0.004048346541821957, 0.03370055556297302, 0.0030880961567163467, 0.01202650461345911, 0.0449833907186985, -0.00927459355443716, -0.0785689726471901, -0.022760385647416115, -0.03147498518228531, -0.0324435830116272, 0.01693311519920826, -0.00699955178424716, 0.04289161413908005, 0.01802704483270645, 0.045034755021333694, -0.016862554475665092, 0.06443998217582703, 0.020060673356056213, -0.021555373445153236, 0.010615588165819645, -0.016826920211315155, 0.007164039649069309, 0.05569306015968323, 0.005255737341940403, 0.001590187195688486, -0.02542385272681713, -0.05516505986452103, -0.04996046423912048, 0.02494535781443119, -0.01032835803925991, -0.04142791032791138, 0.0024424244184046984, 0.02253086306154728, 0.013113020919263363, -0.006862915586680174, 0.011651594191789627, 0.0006908941431902349, -0.027555789798498154, -0.0191288273781538, -0.03560242801904678, 0.016190804541110992, -0.0060787806287407875, -0.048827748745679855, -0.009347363375127316, 0.08525637537240982, 0.01047318335622549, -0.0003837917174678296, -0.04591638967394829, -0.0030586407519876957, 0.011877789162099361, 0.015458733774721622, -0.032828811556100845, -0.009252226911485195, 0.034103479236364365, -0.014875165186822414, -0.041204191744327545, 0.012417824938893318, 0.001792578143067658, 0.02813984639942646, -0.015557872131466866, 0.009783823974430561, -0.030887924134731293, 0.04650042578577995, -0.026342470198869705, 0.022187627851963043, -0.004933494143188, 0.008431214839220047, 0.02221411094069481, 0.005798571743071079, 0.02434839867055416, 0.01913449540734291, 0.033591363579034805, 0.017694350332021713, 0.037376344203948975, 0.0040577673353254795, 0.0034536197781562805, -0.022478193044662476, -0.021750517189502716, 0.015331928618252277, -0.05269159376621246, -0.013281408697366714, 0.013160447590053082, 0.08480749279260635, -0.024222642183303833, 0.002221387578174472, 0.011686060577630997, 0.01986655220389366, -0.10509120672941208, -0.02096056379377842, 0.015790846198797226, 0.019152268767356873, 0.0018226888496428728, -0.04597528651356697, -0.009329508990049362, 0.028059855103492737, -0.04481643810868263, 0.001953475410118699, -0.018048128113150597, -0.0041590784676373005, -0.060284990817308426, 0.0037482010666280985, -0.01576315052807331, -0.008432857692241669, 0.021509261801838875, 0.006079541053622961, 0.0016908172983676195, 0.032563481479883194, 0.01170539390295744, -0.019854910671710968, -0.021438749507069588, 0.018078386783599854, 0.0028596764896064997, -0.051473379135131836, 0.008104960434138775, -0.030377864837646484, -0.05611240118741989, 0.056279901415109634, -0.0078623341396451, 0.016521811485290527, -0.022104915231466293, 0.031682323664426804, 0.004507496953010559, 0.023594645783305168, 0.059055544435977936, 0.012751555070281029, -0.003415504703298211, 0.0059090591967105865, 0.015921588987112045, 0.001876163762062788, -0.041914403438568115, 0.0005732625722885132, -0.001602499047294259, -0.026190320029854774, -0.030127009376883507, 0.012301499024033546, -0.03803994134068489, 0.001087953569367528, -0.018152695149183273, 0.002897353144362569, -0.002343028550967574, -0.036203522235155106, 0.002600207692012191, -0.04218371957540512, 0.022556524723768234, 0.05294625833630562, 0.07529760897159576, -0.038222458213567734, 0.004873441997915506, -0.04834486544132233, -0.049149271100759506, -0.0029720894526690245, -0.002754553221166134, -0.014875206165015697, -0.04708978906273842, -0.00496680848300457, -0.012825235724449158, -0.01757504604756832, -0.034405581653118134, -0.020699016749858856, -0.049095917493104935, 0.05410149693489075, -0.025865968316793442, 0.05288352817296982, 0.043727826327085495, 0.02220981940627098, -0.013154548592865467, -0.0885368064045906, 0.0995369404554367, -0.018251696601510048, -0.020173747092485428, -0.02392931468784809, 0.01079563982784748, -0.023244155570864677, -0.004591117147356272, 0.038328856229782104, 0.03403952345252037, 0.029406478628516197, 0.023928875103592873, 0.02339945174753666, -0.024361371994018555, -0.015359614975750446, 0.03353587165474892, -0.01286933571100235, -0.007555841933935881, 0.014063178561627865, -0.03541860356926918, -0.00489434227347374, 0.01694358140230179, 0.03118143230676651, 0.0009467515628784895, 0.049350325018167496, 0.038945917040109634, 0.032767634838819504, 0.019747095182538033, 0.028829604387283325, -0.034762587398290634, 0.049817949533462524, 0.03319116309285164, 0.013766965828835964, 0.009846560657024384, -0.004867353942245245, -0.06349854171276093, 0.01744549162685871, -0.022717410698533058, 0.0036348074208945036, -0.0033459060359746218, 0.04512323439121246, -0.02311861142516136, -0.0417187474668026, -0.0098551195114851, 0.017626306042075157, -0.033020492643117905, 0.005187676753848791, 0.007887918502092361, 0.043001968413591385, 0.02476004883646965, -0.03685962036252022, 0.030275525525212288, 0.039836034178733826, -0.03185533732175827, 0.007659721653908491, 0.004958997014909983, 0.06956276297569275, 0.04185692220926285, -0.013312489725649357, 0.014308376237750053, -0.044221553951501846, 0.008484474383294582, -0.03677211329340935, 0.050409700721502304, -0.004216812551021576, -0.059580229222774506, 0.03614313527941704, -0.012872596271336079, -0.00808117724955082, -0.014648309908807278, -0.023106934502720833, 0.03708804398775101, -0.04182971268892288, -0.01965327374637127, -0.03333365172147751, 0.004674684721976519, 0.01814301498234272, 0.03005083277821541, -0.014064699411392212, 0.01914798654615879, 0.036416195333004, -0.00006590790144400671, -0.024989202618598938, -0.02555754967033863, 0.005801909137517214, 0.017164085060358047, -0.02034042775630951, -0.06494181603193283, -0.002092296490445733, -0.000979345291852951, -0.0246964693069458, -0.04972776398062706, -0.00017183678573928773, 0.015370221808552742, 0.014779121614992619, 0.04062553495168686, -0.059675995260477066, -0.029887044802308083, 0.01148903276771307, 0.03711913526058197, -0.05772071331739426, -0.009679299779236317, -0.053163301199674606, 0.018348045647144318, 0.004456120077520609, -0.07185240834951401 ]
<p>Which 2-tailed test is best to use to compare means/medians when one variable has a normal distribution and the other does not?</p>
39,451
[ -0.048386555165052414, 0.001171043491922319, -0.024296551942825317, 0.008621418848633766, 0.03325442969799042, 0.014566443860530853, 0.0349661149084568, -0.030514487996697426, 0.02869637869298458, -0.010810187086462975, 0.02458752691745758, 0.04209219291806221, 0.025925487279891968, 0.0023901560343801975, 0.043110720813274384, -0.009445932693779469, -0.03725147247314453, -0.0006623127264901996, -0.009111897088587284, 0.002847147174179554, -0.005894101224839687, -0.0034104189835488796, 0.05143972113728523, -0.012654971331357956, -0.02189130149781704, 0.03940725699067116, 0.006961311213672161, -0.023714929819107056, 0.007249576970934868, 0.055928610265254974, -0.06265362352132797, -0.04092356935143471, 0.0058541991747915745, 0.06788943707942963, -0.013948006555438042, -0.0035566757433116436, -0.005352244712412357, 0.0055134473368525505, -0.04107420891523361, 0.03591426461935043, -0.02208389900624752, -0.02332117035984993, 0.009114343672990799, -0.011344951577484608, -0.004217099864035845, 0.032947368919849396, -0.005985117983072996, -0.0534144751727581, 0.0357343964278698, -0.0546109639108181, 0.037781037390232086, 0.003905354766175151, 0.029304947704076767, 0.018483053892850876, 0.00362995732575655, -0.042899567633867264, 0.04265090823173523, 0.08609779924154282, -0.011075311340391636, -0.06741006672382355, -0.020679524168372154, -0.03474674001336098, -0.039891839027404785, -0.021558813750743866, -0.045596279203891754, 0.026976238936185837, 0.009598065167665482, -0.02762429229915142, 0.030961856245994568, 0.041531164199113846, -0.004828132688999176, 0.017903652042150497, 0.04938221350312233, -0.011012325994670391, 0.024056756868958473, -0.0032356716692447662, 0.025080157443881035, 0.017216917127370834, 0.027195272967219353, 0.06119049713015556, 0.045708492398262024, 0.0032672886736691, 0.004782816395163536, 0.06027941778302193, 0.021167203783988953, -0.011743062175810337, 0.07562657445669174, -0.00021584416390396655, -0.018160106614232063, 0.06257274746894836, -0.027991993352770805, -0.04495377466082573, 0.07337046414613724, 0.00276533467695117, -0.04927875101566315, 0.02313375286757946, -0.04545385017991066, 0.01350192166864872, 0.002568848431110382, 0.0018751021707430482, -0.00341636105440557, -0.052215442061424255, 0.03126334771513939, 0.06255396455526352, 0.005193044897168875, 0.013254860416054726, -0.021245701238512993, -0.0033280663192272186, -0.029017716646194458, 0.001799504505470395, -0.015874749049544334, 0.031059764325618744, -0.01755547523498535, 0.0217787716537714, 0.036416903138160706, 0.00789977889508009, -0.014423117972910404, -0.03769112750887871, 0.037070274353027344, 0.039098791778087616, 0.05202310532331467, 0.017585203051567078, -0.015143350698053837, -0.011005759239196777, 0.005110989324748516, 0.01651715859770775, 0.006721689831465483, -0.003804384730756283, -0.0449230894446373, 0.03188823163509369, -0.021894006058573723, -0.0009362567798234522, 0.0686873197555542, -0.008378684520721436, 0.04225835204124451, 0.015670664608478546, -0.08140212297439575, -0.03896968066692352, 0.029860742390155792, -0.01838400401175022, 0.01952582225203514, -0.05923690274357796, -0.006965877488255501, 0.04428734630346298, 0.02076358161866665, 0.025628013536334038, 0.05603412911295891, -0.02288779430091381, 0.02141234092414379, -0.015229621902108192, -0.005814366973936558, -0.03661682829260826, 0.01001688651740551, -0.02251279726624489, 0.02780677191913128, -0.07475659251213074, 0.002238346030935645, 0.00910582859069109, -0.015793250873684883, -0.007927250117063522, 0.03028840944170952, 0.0019698257092386484, 0.001376737025566399, -0.03452268987894058, 0.060792576521635056, -0.015827663242816925, 0.06587017327547073, 0.00925509911030531, 0.03997797891497612, -0.002916136523708701, -0.025253338739275932, 0.04068100452423096, 0.011218789033591747, 0.03511125594377518, 0.05032389611005783, -0.012221207842230797, 0.0015364044811576605, -0.038049787282943726, 0.04261832311749458, 0.044707126915454865, -0.019196730107069016, 0.018460022285580635, -0.0462767630815506, 0.004011448472738266, 0.007336202077567577, 0.04078712686896324, 0.0047571901232004166, -0.013575679622590542, 0.04891830310225487, -0.03558214753866196, -0.02279011346399784, -0.04524313658475876, 0.0004421049961820245, 0.029061980545520782, -0.054697033017873764, 0.045950282365083694, 0.03985969349741936, 0.04710664972662926, -0.029386963695287704, -0.010273641906678677, 0.009479579515755177, 0.003673840779811144, 0.054168395698070526, -0.042529039084911346, 0.039276979863643646, 0.07049807161092758, 0.06533433496952057, -0.018035298213362694, 0.005129157565534115, -0.04113716259598732, -0.04712199419736862, 0.010272241197526455, -0.022335881367325783, 0.03176100552082062, 0.015985120087862015, -0.010659311898052692, 0.018886635079979897, 0.014785470440983772, -0.02785337157547474, 0.01047532819211483, -0.057580817490816116, 0.058555711060762405, 0.05512697994709015, 0.0006284223636612296, 0.002688682870939374, -0.034318771213293076, 0.008418463170528412, 0.011367113329470158, -0.029865525662899017, -0.013080171309411526, -0.05302068218588829, -0.008477789349853992, 0.047591838985681534, 0.0038461301010102034, -0.049358122050762177, 0.037024546414613724, 0.038744352757930756, -0.016341902315616608, 0.013478511944413185, 0.041210807859897614, 0.0025007035583257675, -0.06563355773687363, -0.007438614033162594, 0.04635179415345192, 0.02993134595453739, 0.01227455772459507, 0.025149142369627953, 0.019595561549067497, 0.024054601788520813, 0.0211513452231884, -0.014244542457163334, 0.04384758695960045, 0.023258669301867485, 0.012922635301947594, -0.00945543497800827, -0.02856016717851162, 0.045843806117773056, -0.022546347230672836, -0.020576778799295425, 0.050609245896339417, 0.0014928595628589392, -0.003817359684035182, 0.020703375339508057, -0.024679159745573997, 0.0471842996776104, 0.009322256781160831, -0.021997034549713135, -0.009836776182055473, 0.05115387961268425, -0.025915585458278656, 0.0004997258656658232, -0.030491860583424568, -0.03436620160937309, -0.02375040017068386, 0.0025908625684678555, 0.04101408272981644, -0.01213887520134449, 0.028752662241458893, 0.014909056015312672, -0.012560377828776836, -0.0006296765059232712, -0.026654455810785294, -0.01756727136671543, -0.025917338207364082, -0.04100076109170914, 0.013565371744334698, -0.01293464470654726, 0.001495955279096961, 0.02304728515446186, -0.010827433317899704, 0.008593732491135597, 0.041946891695261, 0.02270929515361786, -0.059350378811359406, 0.0050108772702515125, -0.023183580487966537, 0.00338544650003314, -0.025532402098178864, -0.05475164204835892, 0.04489203169941902, 0.02262295037508011, -0.0606888011097908, 0.050429102033376694, -0.03286895900964737, -0.045565102249383926, -0.02814863622188568, 0.00039747098344378173, 0.019705835729837418, 0.002182713942602277, 0.010900971479713917, 0.012562503106892109, -0.03893899917602539, -0.0038038529455661774, -0.06157397851347923, -0.040821947157382965, 0.047371797263622284, -0.011001423932611942, 0.028757087886333466, -0.02378009632229805, -0.024852072820067406, 0.027766099199652672, 0.04782404378056526, -0.0020499317906796932, -0.00529548479244113, -0.008334053680300713, -0.03730592876672745, -0.026383189484477043, 0.006534237414598465, 0.007011673878878355, 0.026578662917017937, 0.005979225505143404, 0.007998276501893997, 0.022708814591169357, 0.043097808957099915, 0.01572299934923649, -0.03519895300269127, 0.0344727486371994, 0.038096994161605835, -0.017468756064772606, 0.0628470629453659, 0.03360309451818466, -0.02506665140390396, 0.0031043614726513624, 0.022740012034773827, 0.030860116705298424, -0.00006660012877546251, -0.031067010015249252, 0.04121699184179306, -0.03691285103559494, 0.005334303714334965, -0.03098384290933609, 0.012465677224099636, 0.04813479259610176, -0.004862024914473295, -0.018799861893057823, 0.012172744609415531, 0.011731820181012154, -0.036771830171346664, 0.03357529640197754, 0.05383579432964325, 0.042380962520837784, -0.0032256643753498793, -0.022307857871055603, -0.014531973749399185, -0.04355446994304657, 0.0287754125893116, -0.028456933796405792, -0.0168959591537714, 0.03814259544014931, 0.046553365886211395, 0.009930687956511974, 0.015747414901852608, -0.030461249873042107, -0.003446738002821803, -0.07435637712478638, 0.026864057406783104, -0.02506808377802372, 0.03485516458749771, 0.01043167244642973, 0.028133045881986618, 0.05851038172841072, 0.024341322481632233, -0.04174674674868584, -0.007853323593735695, -0.05532911792397499, 0.03573419898748398, -0.041279055178165436, 0.007058533374220133, -0.00024760200176388025, -0.03474126756191254, -0.008289861492812634, -0.008795186877250671, 0.05033739283680916, -0.011740420944988728, 0.028482316061854362, -0.029013605788350105, 0.012090311385691166, -0.031221572309732437, -0.02751687914133072, 0.013333853334188461, 0.017082298174500465, -0.012778171338140965, -0.028512751683592796, 0.017743108794093132, 0.04564960300922394, -0.011761073023080826, -0.019336266443133354, -0.007385649718344212, -0.00070455193053931, -0.009261318482458591, 0.05424993112683296, 0.017528047785162926, 0.013520361855626106, -0.04148123785853386, 0.015248511917889118, -0.00013113596651237458, 0.03450988605618477, 0.00661248154938221, -0.02459253929555416, -0.025207193568348885, -0.05558982118964195, -0.020357824862003326, -0.03880101069808006, 0.03563127666711807, -0.0024168130476027727, -0.013776002451777458, 0.030067110434174538, 0.010141403414309025, -0.03880208730697632, 0.004193530417978764, 0.056001998484134674, 0.02105875313282013, 0.00953776203095913, -0.01877637952566147, -0.016879599541425705, -0.03535765781998634, -0.033442482352256775, 0.054581597447395325, 0.014412489719688892, -0.01884797029197216, -0.0021606700029224157, 0.03763505443930626, 0.012049547396600246, -0.018107270821928978, 0.0059851985424757, 0.011197877116501331, 0.03133522719144821, 0.006547458935528994, -0.052547719329595566, 0.005954881198704243, 0.050227630883455276, 0.00645397137850523, 0.03654232993721962, 0.008584228344261646, -0.05170551314949989, 0.031124189496040344, 0.06332533061504364, 0.040440671145915985, -0.03788468986749649, -0.03955256938934326, -0.02148416079580784, 0.007684684358537197, 0.05366902053356171, -0.050861526280641556, 0.004560235887765884, -0.034344617277383804, -0.01573878340423107, -0.021479379385709763, -0.004825948271900415, -0.058183588087558746, 0.008537710644304752, 0.02780793234705925, -0.009940095245838165, 0.01133513730019331, -0.02933589369058609, -0.07434694468975067, -0.023437773808836937, 0.02048364467918873, 0.04798353463411331, -0.0003223333915229887, -0.008003427647054195, 0.01744963973760605, 0.013765833340585232, -0.03924998268485069, -0.031025247648358345, 0.014146458357572556, -0.0232771597802639, 0.010480535216629505, 0.03733990713953972, -0.008254309184849262, -0.04859942942857742, 0.029186557978391647, -0.044879354536533356, -0.03314359858632088, 0.007455300539731979, 0.02809680439531803, 0.02816300466656685, 0.04556708410382271, 0.004279287997633219, 0.06871358305215836, 0.015246200375258923, -0.018028395250439644, -0.00880604051053524, -0.04166402667760849, 0.0241771899163723, -0.03801998123526573, -0.044172972440719604, -0.044916845858097076, -0.04374886676669121, -0.03665623068809509, 0.007636388298124075, -0.01011786051094532, 0.02539493516087532, -0.003456403035670519, -0.01331863459199667, 0.008334528654813766, 0.010526612401008606, 0.025558369234204292, -0.010428943671286106, -0.008047401905059814, -0.0004404459032230079, 0.016800876706838608, -0.0035539029631763697, 0.05632765218615532, -0.03181197866797447, 0.004307931754738092, 0.009016098454594612, -0.06296433508396149, 0.021414613351225853, -0.04644371569156647, -0.03255651518702507, 0.01603393815457821, -0.025554928928613663, 0.013891479931771755, -0.014135325327515602, 0.012783953920006752, 0.03638651967048645, -0.03391900286078453, -0.023556362837553024, 0.05014486610889435, 0.0185245368629694, 0.04146324098110199, -0.038167864084243774, 0.06537003070116043, -0.01780710741877556, -0.01946883462369442, -0.06546434015035629, -0.04249974340200424, -0.019595634192228317, 0.023958774283528328, -0.01197727769613266, -0.03783363848924637, 0.03774413838982582, 0.0011008810251951218, -0.0019976107869297266, -0.031431980431079865, 0.07172585278749466, 0.01773073710501194, -0.02803019993007183, -0.028555026277899742, 0.023554086685180664, 0.08207099884748459, 0.000298431288683787, -0.015651654452085495, 0.017719890922307968, -0.024572966620326042, -0.020735375583171844, -0.013771540485322475, 0.012694941833615303, -0.029432101175189018, 0.009364779107272625, -0.020932292565703392, -0.011240019463002682, 0.015342540107667446, -0.00959860347211361, -0.034595515578985214, 0.019591402262449265, -0.004326313734054565, -0.0007884054211899638, -0.01704542152583599, 0.00010591347381705418, -0.029126539826393127, 0.0362231470644474, -0.020298272371292114, -0.015494775027036667, -0.014279264956712723, -0.014379861764609814, 0.024872679263353348, 0.03188232704997063, -0.031166866421699524, 0.019588755443692207, 0.07701361179351807, -0.01094685960561037, 0.023931942880153656, -0.027624929323792458, -0.030548613518476486, 0.0006583096110261977, -0.008391252718865871, -0.0038354359567165375, 0.016691410914063454, 0.050740789622068405, -0.022933052852749825, -0.005084531381726265, -0.032978903502225876, -0.01885838620364666, 0.04119125008583069, -0.00037184508983045816, 0.04078962281346321, 0.04480794072151184, 0.01426701433956623, 0.023820707574486732, -0.03981062024831772, -0.022682519629597664, -0.017501896247267723, 0.0010903700022026896, 0.0574587881565094, -0.011648546904325485, 0.027089793235063553, 0.041460342705249786, 0.007943830452859402, 0.018048880621790886, 0.040672190487384796, 0.021215634420514107, 0.02495664916932583, 0.042927972972393036, -0.038128796964883804, -0.0459580160677433, 0.03902881592512131, -0.030983923003077507, 0.04188399016857147, -0.0326172411441803, -0.0434577539563179, 0.03582404926419258, 0.019112562760710716, -0.03256935998797417, -0.052449971437454224, 0.0023742513731122017, -0.02644120715558529, -0.008819346316158772, -0.007561215199530125, -0.011621063575148582, 0.007707857061177492, 0.030170749872922897, 0.030859075486660004, -0.030669284984469414, 0.04362593591213226, -0.01050811167806387, -0.06107715144753456, -0.030829451978206635, 0.03722350671887398, -0.04546409472823143, 0.048841215670108795, -0.010321157053112984, -0.03207527846097946, 0.029904179275035858, -0.04490199685096741, -0.00504561560228467, -0.013554679229855537, 0.013700459152460098, -0.0195260439068079, 0.046086158603429794, -0.0006839240668341517, -0.0009230702999047935, -0.0048325699754059315, -0.022526465356349945, 0.09249888360500336, 0.04444752261042595, 0.04329279810190201, -0.08313948661088943, 0.04026247188448906, -0.0056099663488566875, 0.03748207911849022, -0.02893999218940735, 0.02303573675453663, 0.034237246960401535, 0.011645146645605564, 0.11321861296892166, 0.05318474769592285, 0.0010879063047468662, -0.025757044553756714, 0.0665435940027237, -0.016621440649032593, -0.047933924943208694, 0.009886190295219421, 0.014352541416883469, -0.005196681246161461, -0.020202213898301125, -0.021482165902853012, 0.04418051615357399, -0.007071650121361017, 0.022487713024020195, -0.018589474260807037, -0.01567027159035206, 0.007511323783546686, -0.0018113178666681051, -0.023002924397587776, 0.013778658583760262, 0.04569794982671738, -0.00041691336082294583, -0.03791184350848198, -0.04274584725499153, -0.0025465700309723616, -0.04652673006057739, 0.0073343790136277676, 0.02227194793522358, 0.012693320401012897, -0.007324225269258022, 0.01676788367331028, 0.001330840983428061, -0.04946888983249664, -0.007333454210311174, -0.022757986560463905, 0.0383879579603672, -0.0026826350949704647, 0.0061461846344172955, -0.005304320249706507, -0.007161957677453756, -0.02438785880804062, -0.025169620290398598, -0.01279147993773222, -0.01078683789819479, 0.03468767926096916, -0.02807886153459549, 0.003981262445449829, -0.044745851308107376, 0.05054144188761711, 0.024651678279042244, 0.05592983961105347, 0.03739830106496811, -0.01625206507742405, -0.021899694576859474, 0.0018209648551419377, 0.061871062964200974, 0.016039244830608368, -0.03706364706158638, 0.0001255139068234712, -0.029615869745612144, -0.020793532952666283, 0.014382201246917248, 0.023185359314084053, 0.005716049112379551, 0.05311194434762001, 0.00017887912690639496, -0.023997634649276733, -0.044977881014347076, -0.0005698278546333313, 0.02763563208281994, -0.029944099485874176, 0.022198708727955818, -0.05449630692601204, -0.022068791091442108, 0.03684793412685394, 0.027954699471592903, 0.04837127402424812, 0.031202463433146477, 0.00881960615515709, 0.05966709926724434, 0.022211996838450432, -0.0782998725771904, -0.008259827271103859, -0.03695673123002052, -0.027283310890197754, -0.014475577510893345, -0.05591236799955368, 0.014926292933523655, 0.026991531252861023, 0.021425779908895493, -0.006585486698895693, 0.004401539918035269, -0.02774644084274769, 0.01148607674986124, 0.015516838058829308, -0.06173228099942207, -0.01771119236946106, 0.03581400215625763, 0.013378412462770939, -0.010332951322197914, -0.015827825292944908, -0.029450146481394768, -0.03120315819978714, 0.02916642837226391, 0.001381622743792832, -0.029779233038425446, -0.02142966166138649, -0.011056884191930294, 0.048281725496053696, -0.0189425777643919, -0.017092565074563026, -0.044506072998046875, -0.02597435750067234, 0.0005838156794197857, 0.004480648320168257, -0.019559718668460846, 0.020579127594828606, -0.009835410863161087, -0.009334378875792027, 0.04529523104429245, 0.003738952800631523, 0.029597213491797447, 0.03705688565969467, 0.00008891793549992144, 0.015640540048480034, 0.04116114601492882, 0.011378539726138115, 0.014922654256224632, 0.05841898173093796, -0.016759583726525307, -0.015026448294520378, 0.00815677922219038, 0.02434844709932804, 0.026173477992415428, -0.011203430593013763, -0.010883327573537827, -0.021963560953736305, 0.03360959514975548, -0.027214599773287773, -0.05399535223841667, -0.027020908892154694, -0.015207987278699875, 0.043991830199956894, -0.004645489621907473, -0.011386571452021599, 0.004004430491477251, -0.02807699143886566, 0.0057448032312095165, 0.03250190243124962, -0.012906325981020927, 0.010818659327924252, 0.02270239219069481, 0.014208530075848103, 0.022145718336105347, 0.004107261076569557, -0.016455162316560745, 0.025262514129281044, 0.034862179309129715, -0.0174411628395319, 0.011059203185141087, -0.06221628189086914, -0.008082103915512562, -0.07040243595838547, -0.01892971061170101, 0.02273525856435299, 0.003190459916368127, 0.04574443772435188, -0.036333922296762466, -0.015727071091532707, 0.037980176508426666, -0.04508500173687935, 0.002966557629406452, -0.008192240260541439, -0.047934431582689285, -0.0322389230132103, -0.0076417019590735435, -0.006571943871676922, 0.031229274347424507, -0.00849109422415495, 0.016161514446139336, 0.024625983089208603, 0.022043712437152863, -0.009530696086585522, -0.011324976570904255, -0.000037383353628683835, 0.009448336437344551, 0.03339160978794098, -0.06652699410915375, 0.012191061861813068, -0.02496284432709217, -0.007883862592279911, 0.04364805296063423, 0.006436669267714024, 0.037639785557985306, -0.02236923575401306, 0.01815427653491497, 0.013927147723734379, 0.039441101253032684, 0.0345955528318882, 0.026025855913758278, -0.031457483768463135, -0.009493252262473106, -0.002479161601513624, 0.036496154963970184, -0.0251722801476717, -0.016365623101592064, 0.032338112592697144, -0.02640378288924694, -0.023681772872805595, 0.0220324844121933, -0.008998677134513855, -0.07061357796192169, -0.004424931015819311, -0.037509191781282425, 0.029328184202313423, 0.014249276369810104, 0.009255239740014076, -0.06442951411008835, -0.013625573366880417, 0.039791446179151535, 0.007060676347464323, -0.03261328116059303, 0.04058796539902687, 0.018338190391659737, -0.028923016041517258, 0.012225608341395855, -0.010508190840482712, 0.007229976821690798, -0.0380142442882061, -0.015857825055718422, -0.01750994473695755, 0.0442596897482872, -0.034762512892484665, -0.025600537657737732, -0.022242948412895203, 0.019411223009228706, 0.00035596484667621553, 0.014007926918566227, -0.0016938319895416498, 0.004189606290310621, 0.0173767302185297, -0.06035915017127991, 0.035463206470012665, 0.003682283218950033, -0.04948950558900833, -0.027803758159279823, 0.0016569503350183368, -0.04305465519428253, 0.00009917685383697972, 0.06598463654518127, 0.02159198932349682, -0.004261368419975042, -0.0032159762922674417, 0.016769740730524063, 0.016159329563379288, -0.07612138986587524, 0.014153415337204933, -0.02779427357017994, -0.04303118214011192, -0.025788206607103348, 0.012372435070574284, 0.0364874042570591, 0.0048928409814834595, 0.011920951306819916, 0.020289093255996704, 0.021728433668613434, 0.00032886076951399446, 0.010819976218044758, 0.031067674979567528, -0.009440850466489792, -0.01924922689795494, 0.03350919485092163, -0.023568544536828995, 0.02170860581099987, -0.0059964838437736034, -0.010206779465079308, -0.055292628705501556, 0.04580150172114372, -0.011660697869956493, -0.025475358590483665, -0.030359936878085136, 0.030672939494252205, -0.03528008610010147, -0.05962393060326576, -0.018461402505636215, -0.0033963853493332863, -0.020604142919182777, -0.01577586494386196, -0.008598348125815392, -0.0031862149480730295, 0.021922383457422256, 0.000970046385191381, 0.03314457833766937, 0.03300350159406662, -0.020253660157322884, -0.007286756299436092, -0.007437889464199543, 0.006804856471717358, 0.0060768998228013515, -0.02012917399406433, 0.03270944207906723, -0.05013642832636833, 0.05516672134399414, -0.02888215333223343, 0.034823548048734665, -0.010888159275054932, -0.044907890260219574, 0.03943297639489174, -0.008896274492144585, 0.03947397693991661, -0.010314307175576687, 0.009046370163559914, 0.049091536551713943, -0.04832559451460838, 0.0333651527762413, -0.03199998661875725, -0.013912776485085487, -0.041384901851415634, -0.010691998526453972, 0.012253841385245323, -0.018589964136481285, -0.027533916756510735, 0.014219222590327263, 0.025887859985232353, 0.009228354319930077, 0.006419181823730469, -0.017763465642929077, 0.04738171398639679, -0.016030382364988327, -0.011828812770545483, -0.06434112787246704, -0.015736475586891174, -0.08758561313152313, -0.018424617126584053, -0.004178667441010475, 0.05552150309085846, 0.012561963871121407, -0.01436614990234375, -0.009230834431946278, -0.0008689439855515957, 0.04132466018199921, -0.09552070498466492, -0.02176739275455475, -0.0364014133810997, 0.006354745011776686, 0.016147548332810402, -0.03523622080683708 ]
<p>Is there a difference between ANCOVA (as performed under the 'General Linear Model (GLM)') and Hierarchical Regression (as performed under 'Regression') in SPSS?</p> <p>I am testing the main effects and interaction of X1 (continuous) and X2 (categorical) on Y (continuous).</p> <p>I understand GLM incorporates regression and one of the main advantages of using GLM over the regression function is that GLM (factor) creates dummy coding. In regression, this must be done prior to inputting the categorical factor in the analysis box. The same also applies to the interaction product.</p> <p>I personally find GLM (ANCOVA) output easier to understand.</p>
74,017
[ -0.030660312622785568, 0.00899992324411869, 0.015140337869524956, 0.007935788482427597, 0.0272712092846632, 0.003773016156628728, 0.010968024842441082, -0.03520561382174492, 0.05968368425965309, -0.0013871858827769756, 0.018873970955610275, 0.008811538107693195, 0.0488324798643589, 0.029016591608524323, 0.03196333348751068, 0.019638027995824814, 0.01681642234325409, 0.006993407849222422, 0.02117661014199257, -0.003674326231703162, -0.041420385241508484, 0.014499844051897526, 0.03573911264538765, -0.022358346730470657, -0.013559283688664436, 0.03715471550822258, 0.02712598256766796, -0.04488436132669449, 0.033901941031217575, 0.026295257732272148, -0.021216852590441704, -0.0401780903339386, -0.04963510110974312, 0.022087203338742256, 0.019242025911808014, -0.005655650515109301, -0.008453691378235817, -0.04488478600978851, 0.00005982908623991534, 0.023815028369426727, -0.01139771193265915, -0.02260095812380314, -0.005454187747091055, 0.05673989653587341, -0.01343768835067749, 0.01517378818243742, -0.011912953108549118, 0.0076247104443609715, 0.017615918070077896, -0.0420372374355793, 0.012341841123998165, 0.0015935281990095973, 0.042905502021312714, 0.05728520452976227, -0.00153471645899117, -0.004739219322800636, 0.05088292062282562, 0.035517774522304535, -0.03118816763162613, -0.046795085072517395, 0.00912860780954361, -0.03656942769885063, 0.00847866851836443, -0.01619013026356697, -0.02699986845254898, 0.01674235425889492, -0.02194201387465, -0.031681664288043976, 0.03828509524464607, -0.023652510717511177, 0.03476646915078163, 0.03542017936706543, 0.0357000008225441, -0.006993723567575216, 0.04098985716700554, -0.03711077943444252, 0.021125463768839836, 0.0050481166690588, 0.06788524240255356, 0.0358426459133625, 0.023876797407865524, 0.015089712105691433, -0.0006104107014834881, 0.016776815056800842, -0.0016380491433665156, -0.0002843651454895735, 0.057454913854599, -0.051258500665426254, 0.01866556517779827, 0.022960608825087547, -0.017374355345964432, 0.007412855513393879, 0.04233086481690407, 0.044066332280635834, -0.05697379261255264, 0.02905319258570671, -0.02646060101687908, 0.005832802038639784, 0.039170924574136734, -0.012668810784816742, 0.014917036518454552, -0.017268121242523193, 0.014087928459048271, 0.024398846551775932, 0.0016184452688321471, 0.01868906058371067, -0.013762389309704304, -0.006754114292562008, -0.04019425809383392, -0.027302922680974007, -0.017566444352269173, 0.030869683250784874, -0.018589289858937263, 0.0018053438980132341, 0.0420861653983593, -0.0005418307846412063, 0.01723804883658886, 0.008484554477036, 0.04212525114417076, 0.033667974174022675, 0.04921850189566612, -0.04756734147667885, 0.002056131837889552, 0.0018740355735644698, -0.02409132942557335, -0.006750497967004776, 0.018261760473251343, -0.011896601878106594, -0.055933915078639984, 0.06926015019416809, -0.013880244456231594, -0.011244406923651695, -0.002242547692731023, 0.0026214064564555883, 0.010424790903925896, 0.017389658838510513, -0.10247432440519333, -0.07038196176290512, 0.028654327616095543, -0.004775461740791798, 0.04582539200782776, -0.0454053170979023, 0.0037372347433120012, 0.02972268871963024, 0.055704597383737564, 0.04703009873628616, 0.042158424854278564, 0.007608828134834766, 0.03735245764255524, 0.0200234092772007, -0.02941157855093479, -0.005409921519458294, 0.008101880550384521, -0.06763776391744614, -0.015426408499479294, -0.08962554484605789, 0.024475224316120148, 0.007890408858656883, -0.018871640786528587, -0.0069613209925591946, 0.016984015703201294, 0.0018871900392696261, -0.028499070554971695, 0.0508645623922348, 0.041937269270420074, -0.004092882387340069, 0.022810198366642, -0.016874490305781364, 0.07121806591749191, 0.07567828893661499, -0.006750503554940224, 0.04166274145245552, 0.014722375199198723, 0.06283558160066605, 0.011206544004380703, 0.0192358810454607, -0.018595634028315544, -0.031421907246112823, 0.011541726998984814, -0.00001333513228019001, -0.05498410388827324, -0.048771560192108154, -0.026216333732008934, -0.005389752332121134, 0.03620336949825287, 0.05201473832130432, 0.004713085014373064, -0.020428363233804703, 0.04370245710015297, -0.0218210332095623, -0.07722245156764984, -0.05017564818263054, 0.045830756425857544, 0.027281206101179123, -0.06452695280313492, 0.0340946801006794, -0.021880783140659332, 0.00011639831791399047, -0.03056035190820694, -0.019787508994340897, -0.009692220017313957, -0.007505394518375397, -0.003233577124774456, -0.037583138793706894, -0.014900344423949718, 0.03715166449546814, 0.022763581946492195, -0.03901543468236923, 0.027429288253188133, -0.056082744151353836, -0.029896922409534454, 0.023423541337251663, -0.008584719151258469, 0.029289063066244125, -0.021695688366889954, -0.018036922439932823, 0.02283245138823986, -0.0018758396618068218, -0.034952178597450256, 0.04100779816508293, -0.08478638529777527, 0.05007686838507652, 0.08384224772453308, 0.004017393104732037, 0.024532578885555267, 0.03942292928695679, -0.010878555476665497, -0.03504466637969017, -0.02094820886850357, 0.0056930407881736755, -0.04212550073862076, -0.0140624288469553, 0.032405924052000046, -0.04121426120400429, -0.031442150473594666, -0.007776198908686638, 0.040450479835271835, 0.006768030114471912, 0.0054431818425655365, 0.030186910182237625, -0.006808033678680658, 0.00228508235886693, 0.01256378274410963, 0.009045437909662724, 0.026719355955719948, 0.009508086368441582, 0.041835393756628036, 0.014640231616795063, 0.08125342428684235, 0.015007603913545609, -0.014921437948942184, 0.06344454735517502, -0.00209427741356194, 0.028482915833592415, -0.006025892216712236, -0.019525423645973206, 0.01012252178043127, -0.034191522747278214, -0.00468624010682106, 0.030780229717493057, 0.002728968858718872, -0.048966556787490845, 0.013439415954053402, -0.0005015888018533587, 0.027875440195202827, 0.02944348007440567, -0.05957909673452377, -0.027065061032772064, 0.015670185908675194, -0.007593526039272547, 0.03847683221101761, -0.008980686776340008, -0.02333381585776806, -0.06365509331226349, 0.002902454696595669, 0.026279618963599205, -0.03451060503721237, 0.04095952957868576, -0.020536603406071663, -0.020748505368828773, -0.004163686651736498, -0.038588158786296844, 0.04215899854898453, -0.020819885656237602, -0.05325073003768921, -0.02222231775522232, -0.041247785091400146, 0.001929266843944788, 0.020590608939528465, -0.026823727414011955, -0.019338153302669525, 0.017160387709736824, 0.004354038741439581, -0.056984007358551025, -0.034951645880937576, -0.01929757557809353, 0.01008034497499466, 0.045319899916648865, -0.02676604501903057, 0.02137821726500988, -0.023805074393749237, -0.040543004870414734, -0.01503633800894022, 0.010293812490999699, 0.016227731481194496, -0.03158331289887428, 0.03341951221227646, 0.0009533962002024055, 0.019564976915717125, -0.011436174623668194, 0.03010089509189129, -0.033211059868335724, -0.0037513738498091698, -0.051057375967502594, -0.050374921411275864, 0.03569721430540085, -0.015257519669830799, 0.04041994735598564, -0.02728213183581829, -0.02751961722970009, 0.0762588307261467, 0.02789050154387951, -0.013743347488343716, -0.05337563157081604, -0.028677040711045265, -0.028284326195716858, -0.012147773057222366, 0.0311540886759758, 0.0037223538383841515, 0.023477084934711456, 0.012458330020308495, -0.004085282329469919, 0.004365730565041304, 0.016419842839241028, 0.028665555641055107, 0.023189453408122063, 0.022875666618347168, -0.009040025994181633, -0.02007167786359787, -0.012658405117690563, -0.0033061366993933916, -0.031146081164479256, -0.017514146864414215, 0.010014385916292667, -0.003201712155714631, -0.03181370720267296, 0.0022704736329615116, 0.00890921801328659, -0.06610435992479324, 0.004484101664274931, -0.016227154061198235, 0.00572366826236248, 0.01521909050643444, -0.024274108931422234, -0.009559891186654568, 0.0381590761244297, 0.008100086823105812, -0.01803148351609707, -0.008708138018846512, 0.02638443559408188, 0.0882379338145256, -0.017938116565346718, 0.008344179019331932, -0.00786592811346054, -0.016619404777884483, 0.025112751871347427, -0.005180527456104755, 0.0011499639367684722, 0.06018243730068207, 0.034541234374046326, 0.013996167108416557, 0.02654062956571579, -0.052072230726480484, 0.014556217938661575, -0.10108175128698349, 0.030152717605233192, -0.036405641585588455, 0.028279615566134453, 0.009102318435907364, 0.03643418848514557, 0.009632888250052929, 0.008428269997239113, 0.015593468211591244, -0.005047256126999855, -0.060053061693906784, 0.020530156791210175, -0.015102517791092396, 0.004158892203122377, 0.036183372139930725, -0.02007175236940384, 0.03581728786230087, 0.01211883407086134, -0.012642910704016685, 0.019549496471881866, 0.02153763361275196, -0.00323441531509161, 0.0015976177528500557, -0.010824216529726982, -0.011188485659658909, -0.005894654430449009, -0.028632383793592453, -0.024440445005893707, -0.021339235827326775, 0.032822247594594955, 0.038580555468797684, -0.010668670758605003, 0.008120146580040455, -0.02633684128522873, -0.0009735801722854376, 0.0557849183678627, 0.033299341797828674, 0.06174032762646675, 0.035078540444374084, -0.038996659219264984, 0.033932968974113464, 0.007800733204931021, 0.03159752115607262, 0.0331525020301342, -0.008592446334660053, -0.02756761573255062, -0.05312681570649147, -0.009885474108159542, 0.014656977728009224, 0.010685577988624573, 0.009082137607038021, -0.005505713634192944, 0.023208077996969223, 0.027734247967600822, -0.0006552509148605168, 0.030990561470389366, 0.04916653409600258, -0.008632929064333439, -0.026412496343255043, -0.009041584096848965, 0.016555219888687134, -0.03294743597507477, -0.030469203367829323, 0.05965832248330116, 0.0015151876723393798, 0.016159938648343086, -0.024286950007081032, 0.04217943549156189, -0.020779959857463837, -0.02326003834605217, 0.027022670954465866, 0.04055226966738701, 0.03721656650304794, 0.0315999761223793, -0.05169062688946724, 0.00569025706499815, 0.048194631934165955, 0.031116772443056107, -0.008840112015604973, -0.03205760940909386, -0.08507626503705978, 0.0007615006761625409, 0.03390202671289444, 0.0324682854115963, -0.03874845430254936, -0.02637597545981407, 0.04222782328724861, -0.014393659308552742, 0.008755388669669628, -0.005380903370678425, 0.015524930320680141, -0.03411099314689636, 0.01187087781727314, -0.043462663888931274, -0.012735836207866669, -0.039265263825654984, 0.02847846783697605, -0.018075764179229736, -0.01312783919274807, 0.018069852143526077, -0.00805122684687376, -0.050889380276203156, -0.008161347359418869, -0.009832918643951416, 0.009486277587711811, -0.006967311259359121, -0.025729505345225334, 0.023220589384436607, 0.04924484342336655, 0.01142666582018137, -0.02880464866757393, 0.03928053751587868, -0.024860233068466187, -0.027493471279740334, 0.06917836517095566, 0.006283538416028023, -0.017554430291056633, -0.0024095012340694666, 0.013737578876316547, -0.012340959161520004, -0.007767411880195141, -0.020227795466780663, 0.03766309469938278, 0.005062614567577839, -0.013234362937510014, 0.052447907626628876, 0.024073339998722076, 0.0007482412038370967, -0.016234219074249268, 0.004946116823703051, -0.0000795812375145033, -0.0037673264741897583, -0.05346520617604256, -0.03769351541996002, 0.016940046101808548, -0.012534587644040585, 0.039511218667030334, 0.01707681082189083, 0.04087715595960617, -0.04312969744205475, -0.023570436984300613, 0.01834295317530632, 0.05407518520951271, 0.008537447080016136, -0.009595093317329884, -0.011103980243206024, 0.014131059870123863, 0.009702094830572605, -0.03567487373948097, -0.005303736310452223, 0.006060551851987839, 0.01082178857177496, 0.010579333640635014, -0.03216230869293213, 0.009734444320201874, -0.008686424233019352, -0.04038287326693535, 0.004911067895591259, -0.022049693390727043, 0.00031072262208908796, 0.0024909120984375477, 0.04181241989135742, 0.0010946969268843532, -0.08229056745767593, -0.0037740690167993307, 0.03691583499312401, -0.022097429260611534, 0.025609316304326057, -0.029802599921822548, 0.06454681605100632, -0.03327733650803566, -0.013371076434850693, -0.04421798884868622, -0.05492646247148514, -0.005984145682305098, -0.010496795177459717, 0.006958845071494579, 0.0027945598121732473, 0.0015248667914420366, -0.036851175129413605, 0.04563964903354645, -0.007494423538446426, 0.05424441024661064, -0.05040900036692619, 0.008284390904009342, -0.010338323190808296, 0.018180761486291885, 0.0413585864007473, 0.028141267597675323, 0.010456875897943974, 0.0011732662096619606, 0.02228691056370735, -0.0009924821788445115, 0.011881728656589985, 0.02031727321445942, -0.012323671951889992, -0.01237660925835371, -0.02587726153433323, -0.00028485149960033596, 0.03597059100866318, -0.0019784891046583652, 0.001729535055346787, 0.009865978732705116, 0.011400943621993065, 0.02773130126297474, -0.011776168830692768, -0.019686171784996986, -0.03287560120224953, -0.015836764127016068, -0.018497589975595474, -0.00936933048069477, -0.020976219326257706, -0.00027803677949123085, 0.04101532697677612, -0.007241505663841963, -0.027540242299437523, 0.004502690397202969, 0.06786093860864639, 0.011922311037778854, 0.028196925297379494, -0.012515056878328323, -0.008255936205387115, 0.057860102504491806, 0.006984715349972248, 0.003989481367170811, 0.008414075709879398, 0.04954203963279724, -0.010593443177640438, -0.003842306323349476, -0.027447491884231567, 0.0005455907084979117, 0.04106268659234047, -0.04313546419143677, 0.03756152465939522, 0.029599035158753395, -0.025823717936873436, -0.015537983737885952, -0.05889009311795235, -0.004522946663200855, -0.0045149303041398525, 0.0019206395372748375, 0.06528908759355545, -0.0019974003080278635, -0.008344655856490135, 0.02781892940402031, 0.0064128548838198185, -0.012456435710191727, 0.012395452708005905, -0.009601323865354061, 0.02627839334309101, 0.01754864864051342, -0.027326148003339767, -0.04041675105690956, 0.03743661195039749, -0.02924279496073723, -0.006705496460199356, -0.04060075059533119, -0.024987585842609406, 0.03264126926660538, 0.04955713450908661, 0.006416934542357922, -0.0905819907784462, -0.03545770049095154, -0.03909018263220787, 0.007320394739508629, 0.014174513518810272, -0.005961399059742689, -0.0059351809322834015, 0.017318719998002052, 0.010519515722990036, -0.00006860303255962208, -0.014436199329793453, -0.023732561618089676, -0.08258496224880219, -0.04985382407903671, -0.02648167498409748, -0.036948416382074356, 0.021227436140179634, -0.016060246154665947, -0.07089053839445114, 0.01168972160667181, -0.04864436015486717, -0.0213872492313385, 0.0026350743137300014, 0.012807006016373634, 0.004003416281193495, 0.037456829100847244, -0.014022049494087696, -0.006037443410605192, 0.01732656918466091, 0.01288312952965498, 0.08618887513875961, 0.05385853722691536, 0.041719961911439896, -0.08845612406730652, 0.007796778343617916, -0.03672117367386818, 0.01689363643527031, -0.007844885811209679, -0.031141681596636772, 0.03095990978181362, -0.03598892316222191, 0.059188976883888245, 0.05532338470220566, 0.03201543167233467, -0.004064516630023718, 0.07116290926933289, -0.03911598026752472, -0.009851637296378613, 0.00259689730592072, 0.0003470968222245574, -0.027020271867513657, 0.015350679866969585, -0.018321586772799492, 0.010283520445227623, 0.0018313834443688393, -0.003560036653652787, -0.02153059095144272, 0.015031018294394016, -0.005086148623377085, 0.020126042887568474, -0.052877914160490036, 0.017056375741958618, 0.0008037560619413853, 0.014380235224962234, -0.03345026820898056, -0.027707481756806374, 0.006729271728545427, -0.06378060579299927, -0.012061657384037971, 0.03484584018588066, -0.01130253542214632, -0.031263262033462524, 0.00603991374373436, -0.01997295208275318, -0.09102509170770645, -0.006787399295717478, 0.0007294288952834904, 0.004898929502815008, -0.013362139463424683, -0.03218270093202591, -0.05399418994784355, -0.0014282513875514269, -0.015401564538478851, -0.030240993946790695, -0.01980781927704811, 0.016282465308904648, 0.05536985024809837, 0.005390329752117395, -0.036111097782850266, -0.05324656516313553, 0.005985085386782885, -0.021420486271381378, 0.04844420403242111, 0.024141598492860794, -0.03738496080040932, 0.016858329996466637, -0.04761643707752228, 0.0183494221419096, 0.003612915286794305, -0.012367959134280682, 0.0364384651184082, 0.029324091970920563, -0.012423848733305931, -0.008653160184621811, -0.0046538980677723885, -0.00792976375669241, 0.007433148566633463, 0.0008350738207809627, -0.007092424668371677, -0.02307494729757309, -0.04967057704925537, -0.011048790067434311, -0.03116275742650032, 0.016750037670135498, -0.0526994913816452, -0.007033762522041798, 0.056511443108320236, 0.022259393706917763, 0.028387509286403656, 0.028737928718328476, 0.012067034840583801, 0.026487737894058228, 0.013641227968037128, -0.06832712143659592, -0.024925174191594124, 0.02315106987953186, -0.022515196353197098, -0.02161535806953907, -0.029928352683782578, 0.07652492076158524, 0.0006684928666800261, 0.029471557587385178, -0.017823975533246994, 0.02062292955815792, -0.010383150540292263, 0.03075801022350788, 0.00002906118970713578, -0.03154535964131355, 0.03023381344974041, 0.010517829097807407, 0.014700609259307384, -0.022699791938066483, -0.009233405813574791, -0.04364100843667984, -0.022027621045708656, 0.013073951005935669, -0.006993723567575216, 0.0017321084160357714, -0.005544785410165787, 0.009200132451951504, 0.03916909918189049, -0.04822125658392906, -0.00916591752320528, -0.05415738373994827, -0.005398223642259836, 0.029054226353764534, -0.045250046998262405, 0.049229491502046585, -0.004049601498991251, -0.027666229754686356, 0.03395581245422363, 0.04239184781908989, 0.021398555487394333, 0.01538111362606287, 0.018579678609967232, -0.01948508992791176, 0.007903676480054855, 0.03343508392572403, -0.016055351123213768, -0.03322029113769531, 0.002500004367902875, -0.02391309104859829, -0.036549702286720276, 0.02745872549712658, -0.011340858414769173, 0.03703897446393967, 0.040674205869436264, 0.017743509262800217, -0.042654357850551605, 0.08544941246509552, -0.027152251452207565, 0.015265566296875477, -0.03866173326969147, -0.03447340801358223, -0.04027950391173363, -0.027982285246253014, 0.00046654848847538233, 0.015918996185064316, -0.0171579048037529, 0.0630926787853241, 0.06895367801189423, -0.004840002860873938, -0.027229048311710358, 0.004271010402590036, -0.026993894949555397, 0.009739815257489681, 0.028697079047560692, -0.032235872000455856, 0.06717891246080399, 0.03331040218472481, -0.025324184447526932, 0.03534243628382683, 0.026862984523177147, 0.01978733204305172, -0.0889042317867279, -0.05990058183670044, -0.005729956552386284, 0.030129214748740196, 0.0033392442855983973, -0.05174490809440613, -0.021850336343050003, 0.012138932943344116, -0.031673185527324677, 0.0031431401148438454, 0.02685968205332756, -0.008782830089330673, -0.011241411790251732, 0.01073014922440052, -0.000020754332581418566, 0.003154441248625517, 0.028902849182486534, 0.00939058419317007, 0.017259113490581512, 0.022467028349637985, 0.020825378596782684, -0.02943473868072033, -0.01882588304579258, -0.023066692054271698, 0.008551523089408875, -0.06379231065511703, 0.016082370653748512, -0.03254460543394089, -0.00561764370650053, 0.0328151173889637, -0.025289831683039665, 0.019937973469495773, 0.050125665962696075, 0.0336507111787796, 0.029338199645280838, 0.016124555841088295, 0.020108796656131744, 0.02510954812169075, -0.01041475124657154, 0.03217384219169617, 0.033294543623924255, 0.05401139706373215, -0.014314305037260056, 0.02582881972193718, -0.00872447807341814, -0.006525858771055937, 0.0005738104227930307, 0.009879957884550095, -0.01499101985245943, -0.014346455223858356, -0.021882278844714165, -0.030339445918798447, 0.0394008606672287, 0.018541716039180756, -0.008359699510037899, -0.034226592630147934, 0.019801001995801926, 0.02161179855465889, 0.02924341894686222, -0.021794158965349197, -0.019080255180597305, 0.0013779673026874661, -0.011166036128997803, 0.013425846584141254, -0.006288105621933937, 0.025120990350842476, -0.055201344192028046, 0.0014316410524770617, 0.006162367295473814, -0.02591685578227043, 0.008426442742347717, -0.005041664931923151, -0.026236504316329956, 0.03824227675795555, -0.004944790154695511, -0.027538930997252464, 0.028523331508040428, -0.006895778700709343, 0.03486701846122742, -0.054220180958509445, 0.093934066593647, 0.020282410085201263, -0.03998441994190216, -0.05106335133314133, 0.015330214984714985, -0.039748504757881165, 0.004500553011894226, 0.045830097049474716, 0.021363960579037666, 0.007852396927773952, -0.01246919110417366, 0.07149671018123627, -0.02019183151423931, -0.013043167069554329, 0.05077548697590828, 0.027073917910456657, -0.05804826691746712, -0.01767716556787491, -0.012900294736027718, -0.020091069862246513, 0.030905304476618767, 0.02976357750594616, 0.0021735753398388624, 0.013959281146526337, 0.006634244695305824, 0.008595235645771027, 0.012068254873156548, 0.04513196647167206, -0.028218118473887444, 0.05080660432577133, -0.027282368391752243, -0.017122551798820496, 0.047795619815588, 0.0215435940772295, -0.029868461191654205, 0.020515000447630882, -0.019736705347895622, 0.024773191660642624, -0.0002734384033828974, 0.0030539645813405514, -0.03475993871688843, -0.03723161295056343, -0.005906891077756882, 0.03189057856798172, -0.05157366394996643, -0.02251981943845749, 0.02509387955069542, 0.030350325629115105, 0.0663616880774498, -0.04160374775528908, 0.010735327377915382, 0.03446713089942932, -0.012388255447149277, 0.05155811086297035, 0.06496673077344894, 0.051999252289533615, -0.011690033599734306, 0.015811294317245483, 0.03751829266548157, 0.0016078564804047346, 0.031249472871422768, 0.0014762342907488346, 0.05447429046034813, -0.008381622843444347, -0.006876038387417793, 0.00930176954716444, -0.023644505068659782, 0.0057224854826927185, 0.03485292196273804, -0.008865216746926308, 0.061798252165317535, -0.053855568170547485, -0.03830290213227272, -0.010677590034902096, 0.012268719263374805, -0.030278725549578667, -0.030875805765390396, 0.04728129878640175, 0.030648212879896164, 0.007323465310037136, -0.023670583963394165, 0.017674574628472328, -0.011380866169929504, 0.018670333549380302, 0.0010223842691630125, 0.007469346281141043, -0.051026809960603714, -0.00906115211546421, -0.0454748161137104, -0.03066374734044075, -0.03347843512892723, -0.056090667843818665, 0.06160009652376175, 0.041182853281497955, 0.011493454687297344, -0.027623282745480537, -0.03490117937326431, -0.016024531796574593, 0.039906252175569534, -0.08326858282089233, -0.00743210269138217, -0.01564166508615017, 0.014453784562647343, -0.01630767621099949, -0.04607570916414261 ]
<p>Can anyone tell me what exactly a cross-validation analysis gives as result? Is it just the average accuracy or does it give any model with parameters tuned? </p> <p>Because, I heard somewhere that cross-validation is used for parameter tuning.</p>
36,638
[ -0.029588956385850906, -0.003342600306496024, -0.03713073581457138, 0.0001202124185510911, 0.05390394479036331, 0.009257704950869083, -0.020881617441773415, -0.024726402014493942, 0.05135389044880867, -0.01942862570285797, 0.03428962454199791, 0.01837620884180069, 0.044538795948028564, 0.008900952525436878, -0.008031892590224743, 0.04272637143731117, -0.0058816829696297646, 0.016488483175635338, 0.0010160427773371339, 0.006567217875272036, 0.00011784375965362415, 0.014063555747270584, 0.010449510999023914, -0.03053550235927105, -0.004768886603415012, 0.028952471911907196, 0.06426137685775757, -0.03758906200528145, 0.04062163084745407, 0.03523989021778107, -0.04221512749791145, -0.024674318730831146, 0.005232470575720072, 0.06890130043029785, 0.012138042598962784, -0.000870579679030925, -0.007018656935542822, -0.049076054245233536, -0.017237626016139984, 0.04440018907189369, -0.012661231681704521, -0.034823816269636154, 0.003886957885697484, 0.0318274088203907, -0.008706933818757534, 0.00353785278275609, -0.03133116662502289, -0.0579567514359951, 0.006613246165215969, -0.06069781631231308, 0.07605692744255066, -0.023426754400134087, 0.025066988542675972, 0.029941851273179054, -0.005925366654992104, 0.0249553881585598, 0.08099488168954849, 0.02331766113638878, -0.008025567047297955, -0.08399558812379837, -0.01438918150961399, -0.008905739523470402, 0.020993083715438843, -0.00856670644134283, -0.01081791240721941, 0.03297151252627373, -0.006708031054586172, -0.011405865661799908, 0.017932770773768425, 0.021627774462103844, 0.015745308250188828, 0.03017629310488701, 0.03882359340786934, -0.018092025071382523, 0.002326831454411149, -0.025305354967713356, 0.01037230622023344, 0.04064574092626572, 0.04892551153898239, 0.044643376022577286, 0.001998485531657934, 0.006911855656653643, 0.006358169484883547, 0.011757634580135345, 0.011341440491378307, 0.00337027246132493, 0.07003042846918106, 0.002093459712341428, -0.003031460102647543, 0.004760213196277618, 0.009854022413492203, 0.026481086388230324, 0.026385746896266937, 0.006900709122419357, -0.019954031333327293, 0.0489954836666584, 0.007133956998586655, 0.034985654056072235, 0.031079374253749847, -0.04956846311688423, 0.03176787868142128, -0.017478186637163162, -0.004521127324551344, 0.027790838852524757, -0.018862558528780937, 0.00519694434478879, -0.008837904781103134, -0.01874525099992752, -0.003380173584446311, -0.021105224266648293, -0.007077042479068041, 0.01868731714785099, 0.031193803995847702, 0.00858702789992094, 0.021054713055491447, 0.03828035667538643, 0.014637717977166176, 0.0032384309452027082, 0.03889329731464386, 0.031246772035956383, 0.05141111835837364, -0.017797842621803284, 0.02023049257695675, 0.010402760468423367, -0.022574590519070625, -0.02195422723889351, -0.0012284311233088374, -0.0017410378204658628, -0.04788249358534813, 0.05418930575251579, -0.03963886946439743, -0.036546092480421066, 0.02344372868537903, 0.002223451854661107, 0.013438059948384762, 0.005481133237481117, -0.10089844465255737, -0.06589335948228836, 0.003697443986311555, 0.005497137550264597, 0.025451065972447395, -0.06223952770233154, 0.005010940600186586, 0.009907500818371773, 0.033766817301511765, 0.02291523851454258, 0.036664772778749466, 0.01800452172756195, -0.002257849322631955, -0.005723882000893354, -0.04290581867098808, -0.052929919213056564, 0.0032744258642196655, -0.002267220988869667, -0.02221756801009178, -0.07790984958410263, 0.006830296479165554, 0.008687552995979786, -0.03243599086999893, -0.03197168558835983, 0.009152054786682129, -0.017159733921289444, -0.04291393980383873, -0.004976350348442793, -0.006722119636833668, -0.01459325198084116, 0.04264416545629501, 0.011548143811523914, 0.023067710921168327, 0.03103504702448845, -0.01608489640057087, 0.02406879886984825, 0.06107495352625847, 0.023582827299833298, 0.01264421921223402, 0.04236004874110222, -0.002325088484212756, -0.03354774788022041, 0.031381648033857346, -0.005578856915235519, -0.05129411816596985, -0.022897571325302124, 0.00012890464859083295, 0.031210942193865776, -0.006572507321834564, 0.04192802309989929, 0.004288933239877224, -0.016602084040641785, 0.012464297004044056, -0.046014267951250076, -0.02162572182714939, -0.08366376906633377, 0.010032078251242638, -0.030820805579423904, -0.0005641261232085526, 0.008330323733389378, 0.0166301429271698, -0.0002877025108318776, -0.04732486978173256, -0.010892375372350216, -0.04433497041463852, 0.01749889738857746, 0.02860843390226364, -0.03943246230483055, 0.018917253240942955, 0.05370664224028587, -0.0023946838919073343, -0.03886403888463974, 0.054771482944488525, -0.03489048406481743, -0.06791720539331436, -0.011207603849470615, -0.04177618399262428, -0.01830570213496685, -0.04322995990514755, -0.0314432755112648, 0.023515479639172554, -0.018085123971104622, -0.02030598744750023, 0.018040653318166733, -0.06231503561139107, 0.0832202285528183, 0.042005542665719986, 0.00257269199937582, 0.017854399979114532, 0.0007703719893470407, 0.01166450697928667, 0.03742745518684387, -0.00476954597979784, -0.00980768259614706, -0.06541729718446732, -0.025867709890007973, 0.03149178624153137, 0.009178252890706062, -0.023508135229349136, -0.01708763651549816, 0.060400139540433884, 0.008705927059054375, 0.02412438578903675, 0.00044718579738400877, -0.0022047313395887613, 0.0036159211304038763, 0.005194546654820442, 0.03189677372574806, -0.006694328971207142, 0.012231426313519478, 0.01045354176312685, 0.014121278189122677, 0.03524480760097504, 0.009372584521770477, -0.006456454284489155, 0.08511604368686676, -0.008897450752556324, -0.007862954400479794, 0.008273863233625889, -0.026689274236559868, 0.02829800173640251, -0.01930188573896885, 0.01885669305920601, -0.018076177686452866, -0.0008813721360638738, 0.02017117477953434, -0.010213576257228851, 0.007834965363144875, 0.037112005054950714, 0.017515435814857483, -0.025527648627758026, 0.01825147680938244, 0.032097768038511276, -0.043414406478405, 0.018619973212480545, -0.041956957429647446, -0.0036934271920472383, -0.05352288484573364, -0.03052237443625927, 0.037479136139154434, 0.016166377812623978, 0.05160628259181976, -0.001330839586444199, -0.052890196442604065, -0.016165191307663918, -0.03287800773978233, 0.009234493598341942, -0.02720276452600956, -0.018196601420640945, -0.006574798375368118, -0.03285745903849602, 0.0032572203781455755, 0.05124016851186752, -0.040157172828912735, -0.01058083027601242, 0.04244273900985718, -0.004461122676730156, -0.03680812567472458, -0.036701641976833344, -0.03248748555779457, 0.030299944803118706, -0.012766705825924873, -0.009634308516979218, 0.02724858745932579, 0.0018171821720898151, -0.03835257142782211, 0.05432787537574768, -0.010965044610202312, -0.009098533540964127, -0.010774166323244572, -0.004064460285007954, 0.03207544982433319, -0.00523621030151844, 0.0343564972281456, 0.020955758169293404, -0.03307821601629257, 0.006926112808287144, -0.059922173619270325, -0.04854375496506691, 0.04552885890007019, -0.007465692702680826, 0.019089413806796074, -0.0011392462765797973, -0.03646067529916763, 0.08034542202949524, 0.014580420218408108, -0.05149921402335167, -0.02924933284521103, 0.028859276324510574, -0.03263638913631439, -0.023203987628221512, 0.009887918829917908, 0.028011765331029892, 0.022213462740182877, 0.05027240514755249, 0.009663005359470844, 0.023060742765665054, 0.045504454523324966, -0.006689134985208511, -0.004937352612614632, -0.007898968644440174, 0.01119146030396223, -0.013196964748203754, 0.026440296322107315, 0.012254029512405396, -0.010951654054224491, 0.025090673938393593, 0.031081587076187134, 0.030470265075564384, 0.027688702568411827, -0.014523674733936787, 0.028174875304102898, -0.023752298206090927, 0.01788690686225891, -0.024584628641605377, 0.024576444178819656, -0.01652037724852562, 0.00008610678924014792, -0.015139257535338402, 0.01705137826502323, 0.044873159378767014, 0.0025067301467061043, 0.00343477469868958, 0.026631316170096397, 0.04407023265957832, -0.03691880404949188, -0.00743496511131525, 0.0015814467333257198, 0.008170338347554207, -0.01223447360098362, 0.01088032592087984, -0.05270807072520256, 0.07531704753637314, 0.058576662093400955, 0.01660809852182865, -0.000799192872364074, -0.044264618307352066, -0.012788684107363224, -0.09817718714475632, 0.005247859749943018, -0.06238393485546112, 0.04591863974928856, 0.005539780016988516, 0.06602564454078674, 0.008336436934769154, -0.020728154107928276, 0.029444774612784386, -0.0037468099035322666, -0.06492045521736145, 0.04383675754070282, -0.018269890919327736, -0.026805510744452477, -0.028684522956609726, -0.039314523339271545, 0.010592551901936531, -0.027812490239739418, 0.014757147058844566, 0.00718492129817605, 0.025437241420149803, -0.0337204709649086, 0.002613734919577837, 0.0034821894951164722, 0.005006380379199982, -0.011998487636446953, 0.002556283725425601, 0.038158152252435684, 0.0017660813173279166, 0.008032141253352165, 0.03702344372868538, -0.020094310864806175, -0.03515477478504181, -0.033859118819236755, -0.0004910901770927012, 0.026780635118484497, 0.03780059516429901, 0.03307442367076874, 0.03777153417468071, -0.06331434845924377, 0.03966384753584862, -0.009356538765132427, 0.04858691990375519, 0.04493372142314911, 0.005519052967429161, -0.04767615720629692, -0.05672580748796463, -0.011049438267946243, 0.022919248789548874, -0.0160056222230196, -0.011973988264799118, 0.008455641567707062, 0.0409870371222496, 0.021525472402572632, -0.054713521152734756, 0.015358326025307178, 0.07172126322984695, 0.03392665088176727, 0.010362503118813038, -0.03334379568696022, -0.02379755489528179, -0.014784571714699268, -0.04085638374090195, 0.036945607513189316, -0.014856207184493542, -0.01405335497111082, 0.007861994206905365, 0.02749483473598957, -0.028366107493638992, -0.04629503935575485, -0.039646394550800323, 0.0304523017257452, 0.0398656465113163, -0.004034814890474081, -0.03164738044142723, 0.001460867584683001, 0.0656212866306305, 0.052584365010261536, 0.019799932837486267, -0.011188610456883907, -0.10020219534635544, 0.01497307326644659, 0.06126104295253754, 0.03292612358927727, -0.07909166812896729, -0.03358558192849159, -0.03439286723732948, 0.018382946029305458, 0.03225505352020264, -0.03495560213923454, 0.021838119253516197, 0.02407943457365036, 0.0244071576744318, -0.03714536130428314, 0.03692476451396942, -0.031003287062048912, 0.001190357143059373, -0.005023756995797157, 0.023814838379621506, -0.038711220026016235, -0.022131875157356262, -0.047119054943323135, 0.02900545857846737, 0.008403420448303223, 0.049457043409347534, -0.01740914024412632, 0.015784835442900658, -0.010132192634046078, 0.007313028909265995, 0.0015960880555212498, -0.07457716017961502, -0.029279937967658043, 0.009936981834471226, -0.02656681276857853, 0.015453387051820755, 0.008821147494018078, -0.04440252482891083, 0.02031484805047512, 0.017297731712460518, -0.02654341608285904, -0.02847820334136486, -0.01496745366603136, 0.01268409751355648, 0.02328331582248211, 0.02304905466735363, 0.06788700073957443, 0.0030889143235981464, 0.005407160148024559, -0.03274301812052727, -0.007043956313282251, 0.024775968864560127, -0.0030326603446155787, -0.03202898055315018, -0.026625867933034897, -0.03723849728703499, -0.03809794783592224, -0.004436453804373741, -0.006328812334686518, 0.03813948854804039, -0.03306153044104576, -0.029921768233180046, -0.024168051779270172, 0.029224323108792305, -0.026341285556554794, -0.01524435542523861, 0.023568416014313698, 0.0012531125685200095, 0.010357599705457687, -0.015294237062335014, 0.016324784606695175, 0.007035152055323124, 0.011193804442882538, 0.01628189906477928, -0.02446005307137966, -0.009417287074029446, -0.022644439712166786, -0.03229755908250809, 0.03761202469468117, -0.0033547189086675644, 0.04868190735578537, -0.007833626121282578, 0.01649487018585205, 0.00782554131001234, -0.06301267445087433, -0.016655750572681427, 0.02121286652982235, -0.0030723875388503075, 0.04239547625184059, -0.029042791575193405, 0.03143186494708061, -0.013592497445642948, -0.00655360147356987, -0.07701926678419113, -0.04136764258146286, 0.0395674966275692, -0.0010324354516342282, -0.03549790382385254, -0.01368990819901228, -0.002496897941455245, -0.025852935388684273, -0.021394528448581696, -0.015044298022985458, 0.03260320425033569, -0.008197925984859467, 0.00012404125300236046, 0.015164998359978199, -0.026665955781936646, 0.0514591708779335, 0.02670464664697647, 0.030451061204075813, -0.010021792724728584, -0.023150868713855743, -0.03239785507321358, 0.01890759915113449, 0.033701539039611816, -0.03875138610601425, 0.012658508494496346, -0.03240983933210373, 0.010434424504637718, 0.03195143863558769, -0.011624693870544434, -0.007073790300637484, -0.02442498318850994, 0.02619214542210102, 0.008548375219106674, -0.01708541251718998, 0.011575558222830296, -0.0031537662725895643, 0.005102997645735741, 0.009966500103473663, 0.002264211652800441, -0.038180723786354065, 0.003813318908214569, 0.011659965850412846, 0.0013766041956841946, -0.024210242554545403, 0.00795360840857029, 0.09569119662046432, -0.006251440849155188, 0.011162949725985527, -0.012912271544337273, -0.03898528218269348, 0.03207721188664436, 0.006856244057416916, 0.0032748784869909286, 0.030875137075781822, 0.034379202872514725, -0.03849479928612709, -0.036901041865348816, -0.02048170566558838, -0.026359040290117264, 0.04434841871261597, -0.0300183966755867, 0.05087039992213249, 0.05489647760987282, 0.013315821997821331, -0.028109228238463402, -0.044358015060424805, -0.02093498408794403, 0.007181777153164148, 0.007859155535697937, 0.039513442665338516, 0.024138182401657104, -0.0025532261934131384, 0.01398150809109211, -0.010290367528796196, 0.012571527622640133, 0.03947734087705612, 0.029987625777721405, 0.03781244158744812, -0.01723957061767578, -0.0108888428658247, -0.061286792159080505, 0.04833626374602318, -0.036753151565790176, -0.007753318175673485, -0.010671659372746944, 0.0034561355132609606, 0.03744308277964592, 0.03439496457576752, -0.015094573609530926, -0.031000392511487007, -0.0017602704465389252, -0.04002578556537628, 0.04367861524224281, 0.016631266102194786, -0.012266882695257664, 0.014515453949570656, 0.014026644639670849, 0.02104271575808525, -0.004655451979488134, 0.02384527213871479, -0.016737425699830055, -0.07263123989105225, -0.006008980795741081, -0.002871424425393343, -0.027865691110491753, 0.05181688442826271, 0.035687558352947235, -0.05937708169221878, 0.014211098663508892, -0.044715169817209244, 0.02674279548227787, -0.006585235241800547, 0.03047521412372589, -0.03789585828781128, 0.05927414819598198, -0.024396954104304314, -0.0002637575089465827, 0.027661480009555817, 0.02473626285791397, 0.12226250767707825, 0.08594857901334763, 0.018384873867034912, -0.06563491374254227, -0.0025291203055530787, -0.027659356594085693, -0.0017451156163588166, -0.028476838022470474, 0.0014765862142667174, 0.011600077152252197, 0.03146413713693619, 0.01959885098040104, 0.0003618293849285692, 0.01440679281949997, -0.00888172909617424, 0.059806086122989655, -0.009613873437047005, -0.032563310116529465, 0.04201030731201172, -0.0020722150802612305, -0.009594345465302467, -0.010700982995331287, -0.023247404024004936, 0.009907479397952557, -0.011818462051451206, -0.025435572490096092, -0.02518962323665619, -0.03726327791810036, 0.008236882276833057, -0.0064297993667423725, -0.028526874259114265, 0.008703263476490974, -0.011028368026018143, 0.020387813448905945, -0.07928360253572464, 0.015239747241139412, -0.02316642738878727, 0.010930655524134636, -0.011445463635027409, 0.04402812570333481, 0.020350266247987747, -0.02492939867079258, -0.013363252393901348, 0.02226024679839611, -0.048531074076890945, -0.022231992334127426, -0.04856890067458153, 0.003497001249343157, 0.009355362504720688, -0.02787465788424015, -0.014367091469466686, 0.031661149114370346, -0.008469689637422562, -0.032735344022512436, -0.0013476378517225385, 0.02843715064227581, 0.01596512459218502, -0.04083944857120514, -0.045452821999788284, -0.06585104763507843, 0.027756815776228905, -0.03265063092112541, 0.018403595313429832, 0.02362285554409027, -0.02809954434633255, -0.00021228485275059938, -0.021556703373789787, 0.06013612821698189, -0.006572781130671501, 0.002805850701406598, 0.0010630636243149638, -0.0003185630193911493, -0.048793770372867584, -0.008996783755719662, 0.030107242986559868, 0.022090649232268333, 0.03999142721295357, -0.00028940654010511935, -0.0069296397268772125, -0.013036206364631653, -0.06106182187795639, 0.008617297746241093, -0.0026031043380498886, 0.004804914817214012, -0.013458185829222202, 0.00962816271930933, 0.01616223156452179, 0.02910763956606388, 0.036763809621334076, 0.02690373733639717, -0.005514462944120169, 0.004355827812105417, 0.0070007252506911755, -0.05705287307500839, -0.012793423607945442, 0.016328860074281693, -0.02590702846646309, 0.022841347381472588, 0.008288673125207424, 0.05512642487883568, 0.01401517167687416, 0.029014021158218384, -0.03858914598822594, 0.028474582359194756, -0.02375085838139057, 0.01722748763859272, 0.009150966070592403, -0.04669543355703354, 0.003676688764244318, -0.0067039234563708305, 0.007763225585222244, -0.008097914047539234, 0.0009082644246518612, -0.02909909561276436, -0.049194782972335815, 0.048978064209222794, 0.009536927565932274, -0.02595786564052105, 0.02109907753765583, -0.00465853838250041, 0.045613229274749756, -0.037342023104429245, 0.009884998202323914, -0.039715901017189026, 0.011137672699987888, -0.018069367855787277, -0.03535183146595955, 0.03819737583398819, -0.02796647511422634, -0.011424783617258072, -0.005840786267071962, 0.05525040999054909, -0.007564086467027664, 0.020583132281899452, 0.013121825642883778, 0.009596511721611023, -0.0012192042777314782, 0.05435692146420479, -0.03744754195213318, -0.015897275879979134, 0.045937106013298035, -0.04855399951338768, -0.007688577752560377, 0.01723162829875946, -0.025868209078907967, 0.049524739384651184, 0.01311838161200285, -0.02234245464205742, 0.0014685887144878507, 0.05045142024755478, -0.028747979551553726, -0.031055452302098274, -0.0085146464407444, 0.009841765277087688, 0.046267759054899216, 0.028637297451496124, 0.009689286351203918, -0.007044172380119562, 0.003658940549939871, 0.033126670867204666, 0.04281110689043999, 0.00024161867622751743, -0.02842818573117256, 0.04310523718595505, -0.009819616563618183, 0.0066613685339689255, 0.025762924924492836, 0.012030947022140026, -0.007652704603970051, 0.06221575662493706, 0.031035088002681732, 0.01477665826678276, -0.00664967205375433, 0.010827171616256237, -0.09516669809818268, -0.004531062673777342, 0.0009795519290491939, 0.015933014452457428, 0.012833554297685623, -0.04747346416115761, 0.015186742879450321, 0.05221545323729515, -0.0406782291829586, 0.02794943004846573, -0.024410085752606392, -0.02675349824130535, -0.02375631406903267, 0.00517143402248621, -0.009450292214751244, 0.02149164117872715, 0.054261188954114914, -0.011199217289686203, 0.02317299321293831, 0.015552148222923279, -0.008930154144763947, -0.010446149855852127, -0.006783663295209408, 0.05815889313817024, 0.0010903846705332398, -0.03951265662908554, 0.010913246311247349, -0.010800404474139214, -0.06041766703128815, 0.027062969282269478, 0.008430243469774723, 0.02709888108074665, 0.013637895695865154, 0.02934773452579975, 0.024785220623016357, 0.010440587997436523, 0.02795802801847458, -0.004116289783269167, -0.02240140177309513, 0.040359627455472946, 0.0009732037433423102, 0.04594307020306587, -0.019688740372657776, 0.029748672619462013, -0.008444546721875668, -0.010502140037715435, -0.04919153079390526, 0.014853399246931076, -0.024088140577077866, -0.024602482095360756, -0.001351531594991684, -0.005308154504746199, -0.01663724146783352, -0.04304693266749382, -0.003578560659661889, -0.003564385697245598, 0.013384928926825523, 0.029294608160853386, 0.015801137313246727, -0.01919361762702465, 0.011783953756093979, -0.014241155236959457, -0.020933721214532852, 0.02804330736398697, 0.010189229622483253, -0.019404686987400055, -0.07592786848545074, -0.004581280052661896, 0.01101605873554945, -0.01329915039241314, -0.04136006534099579, -0.009939612820744514, -0.027062775567173958, 0.03910151124000549, 0.014274955727159977, -0.005045349709689617, 0.027535442262887955, -0.06535977870225906, -0.008206713944673538, -0.06835684180259705, 0.10982109606266022, 0.006990701425820589, -0.06743238866329193, -0.049598030745983124, -0.004838764667510986, -0.024624740704894066, -0.021071752533316612, 0.04511222243309021, 0.006325106602162123, 0.005462073255330324, -0.015568149276077747, 0.03301244601607323, -0.039990052580833435, -0.05788452923297882, 0.04563187062740326, -0.03313038870692253, -0.021730957552790642, -0.04226730391383171, -0.028075991198420525, -0.01081681065261364, 0.03629462793469429, -0.0019235869403928518, -0.030703699216246605, 0.06081949546933174, -0.020156051963567734, -0.01753603108227253, 0.04837825521826744, 0.01828162558376789, 0.011870653368532658, 0.07509845495223999, 0.03344590961933136, 0.029433028772473335, 0.02318006008863449, 0.011291843838989735, -0.026595788076519966, 0.025908691808581352, -0.024551939219236374, -0.004438673611730337, -0.028694678097963333, 0.05254168435931206, -0.016565164551138878, -0.03470355644822121, -0.00740752462297678, 0.05799218639731407, -0.046094369143247604, -0.009171645157039165, 0.05601782351732254, 0.05482262000441551, 0.011946949176490307, -0.028836386278271675, 0.015468055382370949, 0.022785015404224396, -0.010154008865356445, -0.015175559557974339, 0.023130379617214203, 0.02491636388003826, 0.0116809057071805, 0.017016422003507614, 0.021309582516551018, -0.004505825694650412, 0.010605806484818459, 0.014134086668491364, 0.06164152920246124, -0.06853564828634262, -0.005902307108044624, 0.000002368507693972788, -0.03845035657286644, 0.04239493981003761, -0.005717354826629162, -0.01583123952150345, 0.07157190889120102, -0.05189106985926628, -0.03351304680109024, -0.03508036583662033, -0.023879073560237885, 0.010329253040254116, -0.018947573378682137, 0.010861141607165337, 0.03096960484981537, 0.014749480411410332, 0.01354870107024908, -0.021420519798994064, 0.011503837071359158, 0.04601074755191803, 0.0003558664466254413, 0.027193501591682434, -0.0103685287758708, -0.011307706125080585, -0.040051594376564026, 0.018386514857411385, -0.02221115306019783, -0.0005176877020858228, 0.022902118042111397, 0.02993866242468357, 0.008882186375558376, 0.0038945628330111504, -0.01592755876481533, -0.004040011204779148, 0.0407584086060524, -0.09099163115024567, -0.030197877436876297, -0.04530734196305275, 0.02076191082596779, -0.004680396057665348, -0.011147169396281242 ]
<p>I am studying a population of individuals who all begin with a measureable score of interest (ranging from -2 to 2) [call it "old"], then they all undergo a change to a new score (also ranging from -2 to 2) ["new"]. Thus all the variation is in the change (which can be positive or negative), and there are also a variety of predictors that help to explain variation in the amount of change.</p> <p>My initial model is simply:</p> <pre><code>change = a + bx + e </code></pre> <p>where x is my vector of predictors.</p> <p>But now I'm concerned that some of these predictors could be correlated with the baseline (old) score. Is this, then, a better specification?</p> <pre><code>change = a + bx + old + e </code></pre> <p>Or perhaps</p> <pre><code>new = a + bx + old + e </code></pre> <p>Thanks!</p>
74,018
[ -0.05571361631155014, -0.0005952300853095949, -0.037092626094818115, 0.002017675433307886, 0.02503512054681778, -0.0013419139431789517, 0.016564320772886276, -0.0010070235002785921, 0.02623656764626503, -0.034806061536073685, 0.01930421032011509, 0.021673617884516716, 0.02940954826772213, 0.00024219612532760948, 0.03651341050863266, 0.039446115493774414, 0.009262979961931705, -0.009413384832441807, -0.003562921890988946, -0.03275274857878685, -0.0033092289231717587, -0.00950942374765873, 0.029095623642206192, -0.004912025760859251, -0.007043635472655296, 0.05296431854367256, 0.0537690706551075, -0.02537555806338787, 0.015011523850262165, 0.04517289623618126, -0.022979363799095154, -0.01325081568211317, -0.0022169840522110462, 0.03795035928487778, 0.052708644419908524, -0.013509734533727169, -0.021102992817759514, -0.048642538487911224, 0.018135104328393936, 0.03639435023069382, 0.007344633340835571, -0.000370914553059265, -0.012056580744683743, 0.03654254972934723, -0.006184284575283527, 0.01888657733798027, -0.014912023209035397, 0.004907353315502405, 0.033974528312683105, -0.016556955873966217, 0.08538368344306946, -0.03240405395627022, 0.06141786649823189, 0.023371247574687004, -0.059106968343257904, 0.009051748551428318, 0.07492749392986298, 0.08024580031633377, -0.005284711252897978, -0.04331779479980469, 0.019550833851099014, -0.023785514757037163, 0.022043274715542793, 0.0008635037811473012, -0.03907378762960434, 0.038887783885002136, -0.020300602540373802, -0.048026375472545624, 0.05387251824140549, -0.04371832311153412, 0.024670731276273727, 0.013470418751239777, 0.029144808650016785, -0.016006503254175186, 0.0343979112803936, -0.04132000356912613, 0.018317967653274536, 0.02630561962723732, 0.029357967898249626, 0.02988389879465103, -0.016158679500222206, -0.010925530456006527, 0.025723664090037346, 0.06258724629878998, 0.007292486261576414, -0.016617536544799805, 0.049859579652547836, -0.03389201685786247, 0.023507041856646538, 0.04253238067030907, 0.005004705861210823, 0.008462696336209774, 0.04807435721158981, -0.017966244369745255, -0.019660204648971558, 0.04172634705901146, -0.008696075528860092, 0.030422024428844452, 0.05336317792534828, 0.008341532200574875, -0.006600407417863607, -0.050186969339847565, 0.009125974960625172, 0.01699373684823513, -0.045941971242427826, -0.015697630122303963, -0.06655532866716385, -0.03347653150558472, -0.009016723372042179, -0.02536119520664215, -0.01943843439221382, 0.017973123118281364, -0.03168191388249397, -0.005300378426909447, 0.03454030305147171, -0.03669670224189758, -0.035074204206466675, 0.001274954411201179, 0.021109240129590034, 0.06356223672628403, 0.041464634239673615, -0.017251044511795044, 0.043627627193927765, 0.00443429546430707, -0.025211242958903313, 0.012604634277522564, 0.01794031262397766, -0.013667913153767586, -0.013417812064290047, 0.03891779109835625, -0.005974097643047571, -0.0211507398635149, 0.04070303216576576, 0.016376253217458725, 0.012437201105058193, 0.011696125380694866, -0.09939948469400406, -0.045808322727680206, 0.011686709709465504, -0.04920250177383423, -0.019786501303315163, -0.07714779675006866, -0.024087900295853615, 0.013442433439195156, 0.06925331801176071, 0.04068552702665329, 0.022977212443947792, 0.022516194730997086, 0.02605614811182022, 0.02821923978626728, -0.009891352616250515, -0.019977770745754242, -0.03661278262734413, -0.04263952001929283, -0.022878356277942657, -0.06667537987232208, -0.035798028111457825, 0.027803415432572365, -0.011572611518204212, 0.025972045958042145, 0.02341862954199314, -0.02194339781999588, -0.004597340244799852, -0.013824810273945332, 0.010004269890487194, -0.002675502561032772, 0.05746956914663315, 0.011673950590193272, 0.02100364863872528, 0.035044193267822266, 0.018245678395032883, 0.03761854022741318, -0.017047088593244553, 0.047770630568265915, 0.0764937549829483, 0.01509691122919321, -0.004454960580915213, -0.028667492792010307, 0.0013979687355458736, 0.018037615343928337, -0.057681769132614136, -0.06239454448223114, -0.0330975279211998, -0.026193559169769287, 0.027813389897346497, 0.03529856353998184, 0.021267587319016457, -0.014870996586978436, 0.04414624348282814, -0.03953377157449722, -0.042114101350307465, -0.08309967815876007, 0.030319975689053535, -0.008353088051080704, -0.023538250476121902, 0.015937436372041702, -0.006336214020848274, 0.059335459023714066, -0.02693387120962143, 0.0005623704055324197, -0.02751968987286091, 0.007535145618021488, 0.009070753119885921, -0.061438705772161484, -0.007888422347605228, 0.04966305196285248, 0.026185616850852966, -0.02870619110763073, 0.04892970994114876, -0.04855163022875786, -0.031846802681684494, 0.025374624878168106, -0.035881925374269485, 0.03598363324999809, -0.01288665272295475, -0.0209670253098011, 0.006599145475775003, 0.002685986692085862, -0.02389276772737503, 0.02446560561656952, -0.07615596055984497, 0.0792451873421669, 0.062399912625551224, -0.017033562064170837, 0.012490982189774513, 0.00632849894464016, 0.019756494089961052, 0.052959028631448746, -0.0441008023917675, -0.033052682876586914, -0.03440529853105545, -0.013518528081476688, 0.04005984589457512, 0.04341107979416847, -0.02929917350411415, 0.014633871614933014, 0.06923491507768631, -0.017787817865610123, -0.02391672134399414, 0.002928638132289052, 0.0280681774020195, -0.025206472724676132, 0.006215735338628292, -0.015112491324543953, 0.011331154964864254, 0.0009919279254972935, 0.01758045144379139, 0.006028858013451099, 0.05348876118659973, -0.010511304251849651, 0.0074375388212502, 0.022351285442709923, 0.04325205460190773, 0.015748120844364166, -0.018860049545764923, -0.03797899931669235, 0.008999676443636417, -0.03382951393723488, 0.023441821336746216, 0.027022533118724823, 0.017299801111221313, -0.023332510143518448, 0.01322722714394331, -0.03177596628665924, -0.003149367170408368, 0.06328319013118744, -0.0027493496891111135, -0.0035255434922873974, 0.007849539630115032, -0.030557848513126373, 0.026948057115077972, -0.02156911790370941, -0.03174412623047829, -0.05230436474084854, 0.020132143050432205, 0.038473568856716156, -0.008548651821911335, 0.02237647958099842, -0.027007795870304108, -0.05650612711906433, 0.008150885812938213, 0.009276704862713814, 0.016512397676706314, 0.007835005410015583, -0.053882256150245667, -0.0020724544301629066, -0.038970883935689926, -0.028740286827087402, 0.05088545009493828, -0.005557249300181866, -0.026818500831723213, 0.027583882212638855, -0.005401416681706905, -0.05980723351240158, -0.021854259073734283, -0.03676970675587654, 0.0063856919296085835, 0.035558976233005524, -0.06541019678115845, 0.07119881361722946, 0.017694395035505295, -0.04269087314605713, 0.02557334490120411, -0.0760895237326622, -0.015377096831798553, -0.018761655315756798, -0.00361368409357965, 0.020219244062900543, -0.0014763220679014921, 0.03981486335396767, 0.026517661288380623, -0.01723788119852543, -0.005862930789589882, -0.07699164748191833, -0.0679246112704277, 0.010491986759006977, -0.022157857194542885, 0.04725579917430878, -0.02504122443497181, -0.00363629637286067, 0.06050175055861473, 0.004609919618815184, -0.025521734729409218, -0.07108525186777115, 0.005583449732512236, -0.022234883159399033, -0.03923201188445091, 0.004606801085174084, 0.02775912918150425, 0.014235399663448334, 0.007045702543109655, -0.00475955568253994, 0.008535767905414104, 0.03259291499853134, 0.02944846823811531, -0.027984440326690674, 0.03457196056842804, 0.011581768281757832, -0.013507183641195297, 0.031147245317697525, 0.010821066796779633, -0.0020003316458314657, -0.002924696309491992, 0.0024081890005618334, 0.022902192547917366, 0.0045121354050934315, -0.0471075065433979, 0.028587626293301582, -0.0008843066170811653, 0.025248181074857712, -0.01753072813153267, 0.011366709135472775, -0.0025478096213191748, -0.027150524780154228, -0.0565510094165802, 0.02309722825884819, -0.011698119342327118, -0.0053128888830542564, -0.003990068566054106, 0.04988834634423256, 0.007330713327974081, -0.007554218638688326, 0.03173458203673363, -0.016224617138504982, 0.01703251339495182, 0.004428613465279341, -0.01100790686905384, -0.00789970625191927, 0.05218230187892914, 0.011063064448535442, 0.005045678932219744, 0.019747242331504822, -0.03724982962012291, 0.0036834203638136387, -0.061875686049461365, 0.011309175752103329, 0.007787341717630625, 0.055297352373600006, 0.007244516164064407, 0.029681537300348282, 0.009277798235416412, -0.020008912310004234, 0.029180271551012993, -0.009315281175076962, -0.07685437798500061, 0.012961333617568016, -0.002524069044739008, 0.013583066873252392, 0.008269625715911388, 0.004439630080014467, 0.008740818127989769, -0.04915936663746834, 0.007420807611197233, -0.005107779521495104, 0.03311542794108391, -0.03175755590200424, -0.008697401732206345, -0.03088841773569584, 0.0040761255659163, 0.023579128086566925, 0.009026320651173592, 0.046481095254421234, -0.02579781413078308, 0.013952484354376793, 0.035243116319179535, -0.005128565244376659, -0.017086884006857872, -0.02702585980296135, 0.002752866130322218, 0.0016599370865151286, 0.006729370914399624, 0.040535323321819305, 0.04759018123149872, -0.03866428881883621, 0.044412512332201004, -0.011543947272002697, 0.02828258089721203, 0.044472597539424896, 0.006511323153972626, 0.011104493401944637, -0.015287532471120358, -0.020433705300092697, -0.0001472960429964587, 0.024570804089307785, 0.04070526733994484, 0.0037103989161551, 0.031685106456279755, 0.044957224279642105, -0.03379659354686737, -0.006715776398777962, 0.07495176047086716, 0.03031954914331436, -0.0007625765865668654, -0.03573238104581833, 0.00980436336249113, 0.012248232029378414, -0.02140515297651291, 0.021958349272608757, 0.012897787615656853, 0.011535431258380413, -0.002652710070833564, 0.010371776297688484, -0.025692075490951538, -0.0433942973613739, 0.013309262692928314, -0.003634176217019558, 0.029530957341194153, 0.006721592508256435, -0.03634099289774895, 0.020302297547459602, 0.018841082230210304, 0.026799675077199936, 0.013352807611227036, 0.0030582528561353683, -0.11831177026033401, 0.010344878770411015, 0.04671766981482506, 0.057362884283065796, -0.02383982390165329, -0.04087724909186363, -0.041100893169641495, -0.025451552122831345, 0.04128348082304001, -0.03914957493543625, -0.0009070136584341526, 0.019997544586658478, -0.015047849155962467, -0.011587372049689293, -0.043103575706481934, -0.06112724915146828, 0.02418578788638115, -0.05204228684306145, 0.06049179285764694, 0.0049151647835969925, -0.0073239682242274284, -0.02424096316099167, 0.01241820678114891, -0.004500861745327711, 0.055796027183532715, -0.041057560592889786, -0.02602342888712883, 0.03118584118783474, 0.005426447372883558, 0.0019170010928064585, -0.05187838524580002, 0.018487347289919853, 0.01574692502617836, 0.008233513683080673, 0.027923157438635826, 0.017664991319179535, -0.014714368619024754, -0.028155596926808357, 0.034173306077718735, -0.01805795356631279, -0.003478370839729905, -0.022638780996203423, 0.07226910442113876, 0.041271984577178955, 0.013612359762191772, 0.05691033601760864, 0.023400165140628815, 0.03559436649084091, 0.009490188211202621, -0.02878664992749691, -0.011803927831351757, -0.016848944127559662, 0.004389888606965542, -0.05695919692516327, -0.004516220185905695, 0.004701471887528896, 0.06612074375152588, -0.005678014829754829, 0.021109318360686302, -0.042684417217969894, -0.011666909791529179, 0.02484685741364956, 0.017402049154043198, -0.03058016672730446, -0.026281513273715973, 0.01624000072479248, -0.0007245423039421439, -0.01130511425435543, -0.0015151615953072906, 0.04213651642203331, -0.02859085239470005, -0.003954323008656502, 0.03380562737584114, -0.03588338941335678, 0.009318089112639427, -0.019112344831228256, -0.024775652214884758, -0.0005961321876384318, -0.032047517597675323, 0.01242432277649641, 0.022241486236453056, 0.06118705868721008, 0.009316199459135532, -0.06295593827962875, -0.028553608804941177, 0.010120829567313194, -0.0053421687334775925, -0.003097731852903962, -0.03990873694419861, 0.04613916948437691, -0.03539643436670303, -0.02437787689268589, -0.050395477563142776, -0.06819774955511093, 0.02559184841811657, -0.04271966591477394, 0.014072849415242672, -0.0190958883613348, -0.03787217289209366, -0.027927381917834282, -0.0133156543597579, -0.011350737884640694, 0.02712184377014637, -0.0028415683191269636, -0.006857650354504585, 0.0450996533036232, 0.008597396314144135, 0.07511699944734573, 0.018205150961875916, 0.026241542771458626, 0.02937564253807068, -0.028048962354660034, -0.031387362629175186, -0.008891431614756584, 0.007229776121675968, -0.04442692920565605, -0.022784747183322906, -0.049726542085409164, 0.01906214840710163, 0.056921664625406265, -0.022734154015779495, -0.010582667775452137, -0.000738499453291297, 0.0040162368677556515, 0.03902395814657211, -0.05020521208643913, 0.008642788976430893, -0.06728904694318771, -0.04745106399059296, -0.01670197769999504, 0.00993376411497593, 0.014886668883264065, -0.014738238416612148, 0.024879559874534607, 0.0202760249376297, -0.022875677794218063, 0.0032940409146249294, 0.020861396566033363, -0.01605459675192833, -0.009201955050230026, 0.004925661254674196, -0.0555531308054924, 0.05962426960468292, 0.03814166784286499, -0.022461876273155212, 0.01528880838304758, 0.01549070980399847, -0.05610702931880951, -0.04066292569041252, -0.0251143965870142, 0.004288267344236374, 0.06267951428890228, 0.019791703671216965, 0.040802743285894394, 0.05299195647239685, 0.01909986138343811, 0.01495206356048584, -0.015507868491113186, 0.016532549634575844, -0.00567049952223897, -0.034047070890665054, 0.029490964487195015, -0.03725101053714752, -0.00032286939676851034, 0.020903663709759712, 0.01809164322912693, 0.0278758704662323, 0.04239697754383087, 0.007398189976811409, -0.002134463516995311, 0.0252841804176569, -0.008430139161646366, -0.050557270646095276, 0.038362808525562286, -0.043970171362161636, 0.0005385188851505518, -0.0558067224919796, -0.02273828536272049, 0.02629484236240387, 0.034764353185892105, 0.013013847172260284, -0.06161821633577347, -0.03798043355345726, -0.054686885327100754, -0.019666792824864388, 0.013975243084132671, -0.040996003895998, 0.04393107816576958, 0.024872731417417526, 0.050262074917554855, 0.011434941552579403, 0.010691069066524506, -0.04266805201768875, -0.0976308137178421, -0.02007715404033661, -0.01154513843357563, -0.01425890251994133, 0.015114917419850826, -0.0015912866219878197, -0.00045288100955076516, -0.0041549657471477985, -0.02558767795562744, -0.011751225218176842, -0.009110549464821815, 0.037347063422203064, -0.013024798594415188, 0.047455817461013794, -0.025367848575115204, -0.012169674970209599, -0.0004558695654850453, 0.0011508588213473558, 0.11525512486696243, 0.09153588861227036, 0.022780640050768852, -0.0418468602001667, 0.042170338332653046, 0.021066341549158096, -0.0010420503094792366, 0.011671759188175201, 0.0008340905769728124, -0.0003747924929484725, 0.0039299302734434605, 0.013567157089710236, 0.02184239588677883, 0.03328816220164299, -0.0194197129458189, 0.04374699667096138, -0.03221174702048302, -0.006087763700634241, 0.023014884442090988, -0.004857359454035759, 0.0040297480300068855, 0.024766892194747925, -0.018598094582557678, -0.005748681258410215, 0.02020104229450226, -0.02253156155347824, -0.02612983249127865, 0.024576762691140175, -0.035032376646995544, 0.04659086838364601, 0.006988089065998793, 0.014775354415178299, 0.002194551285356283, 0.017541436478495598, 0.003567360807210207, -0.004962497390806675, 0.004134898539632559, -0.018796300515532494, 0.026426570490002632, 0.01172802597284317, -0.014360941015183926, -0.033302001655101776, 0.004198554437607527, 0.004496945533901453, -0.04760223254561424, -0.026183361187577248, -0.05034472048282623, 0.047781843692064285, 0.007716646883636713, -0.018343593925237656, 0.021362263709306717, -0.01129967998713255, 0.027730677276849747, -0.048661187291145325, -0.04081634804606438, 0.0448116734623909, 0.009816590696573257, -0.026349779218435287, 0.0096401022747159, -0.01938522979617119, 0.02258554846048355, -0.01805439032614231, 0.007201783359050751, 0.037287596613168716, -0.04405874013900757, -0.014512150548398495, -0.05488104373216629, 0.0626848116517067, -0.009566226042807102, 0.003817492164671421, 0.025224991142749786, -0.0011152741499245167, -0.043103307485580444, -0.01763381063938141, 0.013850090093910694, 0.019310064613819122, 0.012390071526169777, -0.010265001095831394, -0.00400927197188139, -0.001797212171368301, -0.025920817628502846, -0.007865449413657188, 0.019626857712864876, 0.02086935192346573, -0.031261757016181946, 0.009968960657715797, 0.011385261081159115, 0.03869376704096794, -0.004981185309588909, 0.007173019926995039, 0.01100306585431099, 0.07935840636491776, 0.022415440529584885, -0.04553254693746567, -0.00015264075773302466, 0.025224721059203148, -0.023180266842246056, 0.013206010684370995, -0.050049714744091034, 0.05388552322983742, -0.010847611352801323, 0.011764121241867542, -0.021961821243166924, 0.05496064946055412, -0.03514714911580086, -0.001503528910689056, -0.004908462055027485, -0.028343677520751953, -0.0010313233360648155, -0.000584114866796881, -0.014768356457352638, 0.008802640251815319, -0.011732619255781174, -0.039818815886974335, -0.04057303071022034, -0.0009451994556002319, -0.034047678112983704, -0.04125392809510231, 0.04986530914902687, -0.02307325229048729, 0.005500386469066143, -0.038115739822387695, 0.0021334420889616013, -0.04206490144133568, 0.006963337771594524, 0.0006697168573737144, -0.02486470714211464, 0.014271842315793037, 0.007490705233067274, -0.03740649297833443, -0.015358413569629192, 0.035832054913043976, 0.019649283960461617, 0.01067263912409544, -0.006221235729753971, -0.0006853810627944767, -0.00015838407853152603, 0.03511764854192734, -0.02877792902290821, -0.04313914105296135, 0.021619539707899094, -0.04283389821648598, 0.013647743500769138, 0.013027879409492016, 0.041377175599336624, 0.027767539024353027, -0.02505703829228878, -0.007067837752401829, 0.01989937201142311, 0.04365074634552002, -0.01621069386601448, -0.017532898113131523, 0.0011586877517402172, -0.005028091836720705, -0.004513869062066078, -0.02007574401795864, 0.03272920846939087, 0.01633167639374733, -0.04407978057861328, 0.0024459282867610455, 0.04877803474664688, -0.008260691538453102, -0.028253115713596344, -0.013540975749492645, -0.01516181230545044, 0.023519299924373627, 0.020510511472821236, -0.006264370866119862, 0.0251495148986578, 0.01666175201535225, -0.024775927886366844, -0.007232436910271645, -0.02133326791226864, 0.007778179831802845, -0.08145061880350113, -0.02019507810473442, 0.027761265635490417, -0.004137147683650255, 0.04242352768778801, -0.07350838929414749, 0.021191930398344994, 0.01053531188517809, -0.03860700875520706, 0.008581330068409443, 0.020780079066753387, -0.013669491745531559, -0.006438195239752531, 0.005063192453235388, -0.043492935597896576, 0.026952259242534637, 0.04297872632741928, 0.04998255521059036, 0.030584324151277542, 0.016678251326084137, 0.025460297241806984, -0.04391003027558327, -0.03085126355290413, 0.007745466660708189, 0.006688406690955162, -0.04708179831504822, -0.008654837496578693, -0.04500631242990494, -0.04824591055512428, 0.014363820664584637, -0.018461989238858223, 0.035456955432891846, 0.03928728774189949, 0.03728247433900833, 0.03660513833165169, 0.06568136066198349, 0.03185894712805748, -0.0028055883012712, 0.006727276369929314, -0.023224717006087303, -0.030068380758166313, 0.013095567934215069, 0.013763729482889175, 0.030365779995918274, 0.01782682165503502, 0.013759547844529152, -0.034743472933769226, 0.0031877218279987574, -0.01711854711174965, -0.014138985425233841, -0.007910322397947311, 0.012199722230434418, 0.003969233483076096, -0.007479464169591665, -0.01807381771504879, -0.031456783413887024, -0.010293998755514622, 0.019853411242365837, 0.03722067177295685, -0.03746849298477173, 0.013299542479217052, -0.019155198708176613, -0.019809378311038017, 0.020153233781456947, -0.013016865588724613, 0.025857163593173027, -0.07148655503988266, -0.0383121520280838, 0.0037874500267207623, 0.007044441998004913, -0.058151718229055405, -0.0165222380310297, -0.028138775378465652, 0.013060539960861206, -0.02914852276444435, -0.00355813791975379, 0.021169893443584442, -0.0008212888496927917, 0.01887694001197815, -0.06369344890117645, 0.056613218039274216, 0.0012795451330021024, -0.00026021539815701544, -0.017641853541135788, -0.016353603452444077, -0.03796006739139557, 0.04781459644436836, 0.0796499028801918, -0.00774661498144269, 0.003372021485120058, -0.00813852809369564, 0.008584465831518173, 0.002894685138016939, -0.036685243248939514, 0.06517007946968079, 0.007403166964650154, 0.003334648907184601, 0.012990573421120644, 0.005316644441336393, 0.025132186710834503, 0.04150658845901489, 0.032890819013118744, -0.023539504036307335, 0.012737380340695381, 0.00762927858158946, -0.010368534363806248, 0.031140515580773354, 0.017027679830789566, -0.022503450512886047, 0.0396038256585598, -0.01247261743992567, 0.011562171392142773, 0.023467596620321274, 0.00039028539322316647, -0.03623037040233612, 0.04863116517663002, -0.044758331030607224, -0.03047134354710579, 0.021862855181097984, -0.009399056434631348, -0.017487339675426483, -0.03932876139879227, -0.008261793293058872, 0.02910936251282692, -0.03310535475611687, 0.0021201670169830322, 0.03282598778605461, 0.04887237399816513, 0.04384153336286545, -0.013802649453282356, -0.006883515510708094, 0.005366011522710323, 0.005723976995795965, 0.02224608324468136, -0.005899672396481037, 0.05394309014081955, 0.008791363798081875, 0.02786317840218544, 0.019763242453336716, -0.031916506588459015, 0.016744760796427727, -0.009376028552651405, 0.0058805025182664394, -0.03310096263885498, 0.02164551243185997, 0.007027851417660713, -0.0009067571954801679, 0.05834755301475525, 0.014504661783576012, -0.01901480183005333, 0.04692569002509117, -0.048395462334156036, -0.0364493764936924, -0.025543533265590668, 0.024791091680526733, -0.04421401396393776, -0.006625300273299217, 0.011717925779521465, 0.032191358506679535, 0.053966596722602844, -0.0080496184527874, -0.016575517132878304, -0.030817953869700432, -0.01252474170178175, -0.023850195109844208, 0.024551764130592346, -0.029003307223320007, -0.0016920476919040084, 0.03305478021502495, 0.010964414104819298, -0.03909188136458397, -0.005106855649501085, 0.0474938228726387, 0.05992298200726509, 0.03855545073747635, -0.013935280032455921, -0.026789136230945587, 0.00891977921128273, 0.025401636958122253, -0.06309846043586731, -0.0019652764312922955, -0.043909814208745956, -0.019796356558799744, 0.0014018260408192873, -0.030835850164294243 ]
<p>I ran a within subjects repeated measures experiment, where the independent variable had 3 levels. The dependent variable is a measure of correctness and is recorded as either correct / incorrect. Time taken to provide an answer was also recorded.</p> <p>A within subjects repeated measures ANOVA is used to establish whether there is significant differences in correctness (DV) between the 3 levels of the IV, there is significant. Now, I'd like to analyze whether there is significant differences in the time taken to provide the answers when the answers are 1) correct, and 2) incorrect.</p> <p>My problem is: Across the levels there are different numbers of correct / incorrect answers, e.g. level 1 has 67 correct answers, level 2 has 30, level 3 has 25. </p> <p>How can I compare the time take taken for all correct answers across the 3 levels? I think this means its unbalanced? Can I do 3 one way ANOVAS to do a pairwise comparison, while adjusting p downwards to account for each comparison?</p> <p>Thanks</p>
38,142
[ -0.049575075507164, 0.005023685283958912, -0.022454647347331047, 0.0061744702979922295, 0.05185479670763016, -0.00823917705565691, 0.015771886333823204, -0.013520915061235428, 0.018286511301994324, -0.016372937709093094, 0.010319588705897331, 0.02640151046216488, 0.05003930255770683, -0.010643552988767624, 0.02176499553024769, 0.02750784531235695, -0.005403430666774511, -0.0247807577252388, 0.009982951916754246, -0.02023245580494404, -0.0258338525891304, -0.0017381199868395925, 0.008791166357696056, -0.007902603596448898, -0.04528733715415001, 0.016721384599804878, 0.036905840039253235, -0.027992602437734604, 0.0016581438248977065, 0.024379828944802284, -0.02742985635995865, -0.043893538415431976, 0.028025493025779724, 0.04467310756444931, 0.025280628353357315, 0.026836300268769264, -0.016273541375994682, -0.023978494107723236, -0.01531722117215395, 0.03892241418361664, -0.02291068248450756, 0.01777774840593338, -0.023212745785713196, 0.037774473428726196, 0.014869417995214462, 0.038301192224025726, -0.034276317805051804, -0.0004978514043614268, 0.03735101968050003, -0.04315060377120972, 0.08502000570297241, -0.008371083997189999, 0.020155804231762886, 0.04693344607949257, -0.028952687978744507, -0.02930576540529728, 0.07901670038700104, 0.04684989154338837, 0.006283760070800781, -0.04702691733837128, -0.03249978646636009, -0.034176506102085114, 0.016510555520653725, 0.010446295142173767, -0.050437334924936295, 0.003965126350522041, -0.017842592671513557, 0.003789514536038041, 0.04910719767212868, -0.015301205217838287, 0.030435390770435333, 0.026197506114840508, 0.054790448397397995, 0.017593825235962868, 0.007089863996952772, -0.0451987199485302, 0.032507676631212234, 0.0018095532432198524, 0.047051314264535904, 0.04100613668560982, -0.03471957519650459, 0.007179436273872852, 0.0020629852078855038, 0.05126991495490074, 0.026137080043554306, 0.004652456380426884, 0.051038630306720734, -0.03583238273859024, -0.018044771626591682, 0.013207824900746346, -0.02281677909195423, 0.015295670367777348, 0.011805220507085323, 0.040484968572854996, -0.0003916348214261234, 0.011516595259308815, -0.012509472668170929, 0.031125400215387344, -0.01033203024417162, 0.036719247698783875, 0.03761264309287071, -0.04587966203689575, 0.013963030651211739, 0.035631585866212845, 0.0016453373245894909, 0.01947026513516903, -0.010448239743709564, 0.01679346337914467, 0.020269053056836128, -0.01439611054956913, -0.022399824112653732, 0.00976331066340208, -0.02798536978662014, 0.011430400423705578, -0.004638629965484142, -0.0309080109000206, -0.0291275791823864, -0.015046783722937107, 0.08870827406644821, 0.03790377080440521, 0.04464356601238251, -0.04862731695175171, 0.020807327702641487, -0.048936136066913605, -0.07149249315261841, 0.006823710631579161, 0.009083906188607216, -0.027778079733252525, -0.0314473919570446, 0.09155184030532837, 0.005857392679899931, -0.01635698974132538, 0.034194670617580414, -0.027768030762672424, 0.060495130717754364, 0.016521325334906578, -0.09000813961029053, -0.08082862943410873, -0.025020889937877655, -0.0034511813428252935, 0.002268562326207757, -0.06494805216789246, -0.016743537038564682, 0.015716904774308205, 0.030648093670606613, 0.00010600492532830685, 0.02343715913593769, 0.00337753864005208, 0.015616489574313164, 0.035111963748931885, -0.005211887415498495, 0.012849087826907635, -0.0032659461721777916, -0.019523825496435165, -0.005001532845199108, -0.07080772519111633, 0.04656228423118591, 0.02159833535552025, 0.02903307043015957, 0.013601848855614662, 0.009476290084421635, -0.00047590836766175926, -0.01735442318022251, -0.0034152031876146793, 0.016058683395385742, 0.018249429762363434, 0.06945900619029999, -0.029195936396718025, 0.03269787132740021, -0.014763238839805126, -0.031656548380851746, 0.03769638389348984, 0.006583825219422579, 0.005747007671743631, 0.04486100375652313, -0.03073524683713913, -0.0023054699413478374, 0.0024123897310346365, -0.00014660743181593716, 0.03817388042807579, -0.03153016045689583, -0.007228268310427666, -0.01670502871274948, -0.014889254234731197, 0.014612964354455471, 0.041936375200748444, -0.02595089189708233, 0.04214932397007942, 0.015612983144819736, -0.028086373582482338, -0.024999329820275307, -0.07880477607250214, 0.032978858798742294, 0.02387484349310398, -0.03546933829784393, 0.05430271476507187, -0.013926590792834759, 0.024813219904899597, -0.01930871419608593, -0.044288113713264465, -0.03612477332353592, -0.014819180592894554, 0.04456103593111038, -0.035481635481119156, 0.03497182950377464, 0.027217023074626923, 0.046302422881126404, -0.022146329283714294, 0.0524718277156353, -0.02595069445669651, -0.0038912631571292877, 0.014216396026313305, -0.02549440972507, 0.028479529544711113, -0.008181063458323479, -0.012637048028409481, 0.019516639411449432, 0.020114947110414505, -0.012752112932503223, 0.0341954343020916, -0.03959970921278, 0.0959339290857315, 0.07439497113227844, -0.0019984387326985598, -0.0023410278372466564, 0.010550914332270622, 0.012701368890702724, 0.02811243012547493, -0.012651422061026096, -0.051798731088638306, -0.060174327343702316, -0.03294448181986809, 0.007142649497836828, -0.004520399961620569, -0.025416487827897072, 0.02568202093243599, 0.06933978199958801, 0.018101200461387634, 0.010261254385113716, 0.024901125580072403, 0.030751090496778488, -0.02791588008403778, 0.031078414991497993, 0.05628607049584389, 0.0031515290029346943, 0.06278719007968903, 0.029533538967370987, -0.013486994430422783, 0.04653346166014671, 0.027331024408340454, 0.03496889770030975, 0.012736767530441284, 0.03395821899175644, 0.024085700511932373, -0.028778323903679848, -0.012679016217589378, 0.026615025475621223, -0.008015008643269539, 0.03173289820551872, 0.07453302294015884, 0.002337720012292266, 0.00015832923236303031, 0.029551152139902115, -0.022077234461903572, 0.07639442384243011, 0.03346928209066391, -0.034854162484407425, -0.013302931562066078, 0.02340097166597843, 0.003666945733129978, 0.01783435046672821, -0.037256818264722824, -0.012499270960688591, -0.02856561541557312, 0.003060931107029319, 0.001308458624407649, -0.016055317595601082, 0.0041045849211514, -0.03162744268774986, 0.021074702963232994, -0.012852702289819717, -0.017872627824544907, 0.029079677537083626, -0.02216929942369461, -0.06312274932861328, 0.021057112142443657, -0.007333871442824602, -0.049956001341342926, 0.0057885791175067425, -0.01395532488822937, 0.014203226193785667, 0.047221243381500244, -0.016355250030755997, -0.014678820967674255, -0.02468285523355007, -0.02280593290925026, 0.02908533625304699, -0.03375059366226196, -0.019505251199007034, 0.0298912413418293, 0.01679234765470028, -0.002635811921209097, 0.02454538457095623, -0.03760991990566254, 0.007843934930860996, 0.0009677505004219711, 0.00438039330765605, 0.023257121443748474, -0.012410852126777172, 0.01463585440069437, 0.01569715328514576, -0.011303561739623547, -0.019235625863075256, -0.06253955513238907, -0.09043315052986145, 0.0028071063570678234, 0.04476023092865944, 0.03831365704536438, -0.02289205603301525, -0.039301324635744095, 0.06444475054740906, 0.02332633174955845, -0.06022295355796814, -0.027732806280255318, -0.026567641645669937, -0.03911265730857849, -0.008023971691727638, 0.03611433133482933, 0.013846796937286854, -0.001123671536333859, 0.03204062208533287, -0.015487897209823132, 0.02088177390396595, 0.03238799422979355, 0.02106669917702675, -0.002169508021324873, 0.00486960681155324, 0.003985667135566473, -0.026710493490099907, -0.003074395703151822, 0.004177137278020382, -0.052509404718875885, -0.01690487377345562, 0.011707687750458717, 0.03753551095724106, -0.02955932728946209, -0.04286741092801094, 0.029667193070054054, -0.018550654873251915, -0.00487830163910985, -0.010344889014959335, 0.0029829186387360096, 0.0068738521076738834, -0.0008752617286518216, -0.008698537945747375, 0.03176522254943848, 0.04140258580446243, -0.015380491502583027, 0.033069852739572525, 0.0741334781050682, 0.05378563702106476, -0.007573637645691633, -0.02976294234395027, -0.007474173326045275, 0.00801579374819994, 0.02729455940425396, -0.0277231615036726, -0.049356576055288315, 0.05707880109548569, 0.017805490642786026, 0.005001714453101158, 0.02007273957133293, -0.029008733108639717, 0.0192366074770689, -0.06386352330446243, 0.02234428934752941, -0.03921482339501381, 0.05364803224802017, -0.02813982032239437, 0.05455771088600159, 0.005379852373152971, -0.026807064190506935, -0.03664831072092056, -0.0036766990087926388, -0.04815080761909485, 0.018711507320404053, -0.008728847838938236, -0.0005329286213964224, 0.020942501723766327, 0.006408510264009237, -0.01002469565719366, -0.053573641926050186, 0.04771146923303604, 0.001897282782010734, 0.022785624489188194, 0.004762173630297184, -0.013043205253779888, 0.0012996412115171552, 0.026090510189533234, -0.00857198890298605, 0.03437288478016853, 0.007210911251604557, -0.030451595783233643, 0.0138257946819067, -0.009760457091033459, -0.019369008019566536, 0.018739014863967896, -0.048737213015556335, -0.02243112586438656, 0.043092790991067886, 0.04148133471608162, 0.015583775006234646, 0.03541482612490654, -0.04192253202199936, 0.036806948482990265, -0.006084709893912077, 0.023310014978051186, 0.038815658539533615, -0.018569493666291237, -0.04877280816435814, -0.039721157401800156, -0.05308636650443077, 0.016464218497276306, 0.03402993828058243, 0.0028281775303184986, 0.015416695736348629, 0.02182799205183983, 0.0241305623203516, -0.06023021042346954, 0.03156483918428421, 0.06614692509174347, 0.003804972628131509, -0.010552704334259033, -0.06592849642038345, -0.021000413224101067, -0.005207818932831287, -0.01827975921332836, 0.030787454918026924, 0.04348786920309067, 0.021136760711669922, -0.008916782215237617, 0.049354080110788345, -0.01623699814081192, -0.04164569452404976, 0.008281848393380642, 0.017496224492788315, 0.015139398165047169, 0.03278925269842148, -0.008015667088329792, 0.024356018751859665, 0.050157055258750916, 0.03151839226484299, -0.005264692939817905, 0.009683441370725632, -0.07464287430047989, -0.00008559626439819112, 0.058095261454582214, 0.033240221440792084, -0.04118282347917557, -0.005104610696434975, 0.005462239496409893, 0.01997421868145466, 0.025626469403505325, -0.0532107800245285, 0.028716662898659706, -0.006299247033894062, -0.00388924079015851, -0.02371187135577202, -0.04554292932152748, -0.050486285239458084, 0.003606655402109027, -0.012436656281352043, 0.022147445008158684, -0.00224247295409441, -0.010601302608847618, -0.025729600340127945, -0.030715178698301315, 0.06355559080839157, 0.01755473203957081, 0.008989297784864902, 0.03869042918086052, 0.026219530031085014, 0.02534479647874832, -0.02865521050989628, -0.0625184029340744, 0.032643791288137436, -0.0243998896330595, -0.02352139540016651, 0.020830577239394188, -0.03443951532244682, -0.049318570643663406, 0.03233916684985161, 0.006209527142345905, 0.012007231824100018, -0.014062521979212761, -0.03815431147813797, 0.03899511694908142, 0.032249726355075836, 0.006887999828904867, 0.056163664907217026, -0.004350868985056877, 0.013968824408948421, -0.012707876972854137, -0.006481148302555084, 0.0052022915333509445, -0.014549550600349903, -0.021946581080555916, -0.005066221114248037, -0.030812710523605347, -0.015107451938092709, 0.05510914698243141, -0.003232654184103012, 0.038626160472631454, -0.04045840725302696, -0.007355635054409504, 0.014419106766581535, 0.0036700726486742496, 0.02584141492843628, 0.001796963275410235, -0.009938892908394337, -0.00929045770317316, 0.0157068632543087, -0.048650749027729034, 0.012892588041722775, -0.028659192845225334, 0.023951927199959755, 0.011353711597621441, -0.028708267956972122, 0.00019619110389612615, -0.025037484243512154, -0.05567234754562378, -0.009400404989719391, -0.041738152503967285, 0.021023951470851898, -0.014732594601809978, 0.03099195845425129, -0.02175408974289894, -0.03650287538766861, -0.00264439987950027, 0.041769854724407196, -0.026909239590168, 0.02087298408150673, -0.028887001797556877, 0.01093903835862875, -0.02018599584698677, 0.0059211417101323605, -0.05722203105688095, -0.03931637108325958, 0.0389319472014904, 0.033866554498672485, -0.005868683569133282, 0.00973618682473898, -0.00960605964064598, -0.03857206180691719, -0.0037303180433809757, -0.031696420162916183, 0.060737550258636475, -0.0006042261957190931, -0.034435294568538666, -0.01252988912165165, 0.027312975376844406, 0.051407504826784134, -0.028448397293686867, 0.00703229708597064, -0.0354037843644619, -0.025327298790216446, -0.02142505720257759, -0.009811842814087868, 0.00967651978135109, -0.01134102325886488, 0.0003531772526912391, -0.003865595208480954, 0.02152509242296219, 0.036859266459941864, -0.032728951424360275, -0.033908165991306305, -0.008339016698300838, -0.048647258430719376, -0.015332392416894436, -0.05636986345052719, 0.02474157325923443, 0.012592599727213383, -0.003636952955275774, -0.02560258097946644, 0.005203399807214737, -0.04329332709312439, -0.007593707647174597, 0.030827820301055908, 0.0019371674861758947, -0.05411403626203537, -0.0013366036582738161, 0.0818103775382042, -0.023698700591921806, 0.022994009777903557, 0.02184019796550274, -0.01819118857383728, 0.0330982580780983, 0.005176982376724482, -0.011879482306540012, 0.024371124804019928, 0.03928295150399208, -0.02295307070016861, -0.02647990733385086, -0.009320035576820374, -0.005869477987289429, 0.06697630137205124, 0.02083243429660797, 0.027175314724445343, 0.06017681211233139, 0.02830607071518898, 0.001638184068724513, -0.00012172434799140319, -0.009479430504143238, 0.007086189929395914, 0.036688853055238724, 0.03692299872636795, -0.011168012395501137, 0.0075842286460101604, -0.006265899632126093, 0.01697884313762188, 0.009746149182319641, 0.03605930134654045, 0.011342927813529968, -0.0014756720047444105, 0.027065854519605637, 0.01334341336041689, -0.03327831253409386, 0.04132798686623573, -0.04560729116201401, 0.006796986795961857, -0.055119916796684265, -0.02214200608432293, 0.030035050585865974, 0.030144814401865005, 0.00450369855388999, -0.036152951419353485, -0.020616531372070312, -0.11214685440063477, 0.030365634709596634, -0.0036616362631320953, -0.007212220691144466, 0.005047588609158993, 0.011800498701632023, 0.03892131149768829, -0.024718957021832466, 0.024482473731040955, -0.03818698972463608, -0.04973388463258743, -0.04212716594338417, -0.010021462105214596, -0.012834230437874794, 0.03593583032488823, -0.0038663512095808983, -0.03041008673608303, -0.012118133716285229, -0.019593236967921257, 0.037733882665634155, -0.016051387414336205, 0.03887389600276947, -0.04494688659906387, 0.051502618938684464, -0.01080716960132122, 0.04102618619799614, 0.017224399372935295, 0.03126047924160957, 0.07922696322202682, 0.07250204682350159, 0.03147047013044357, -0.07970095425844193, 0.030150756239891052, 0.00234621437266469, 0.005368811544030905, -0.015937283635139465, 0.002236493630334735, -0.005094196647405624, -0.0417538583278656, 0.039531052112579346, 0.05531168729066849, -0.0005878527881577611, 0.000282725173747167, 0.05912661924958229, -0.022414138540625572, -0.019326629117131233, 0.012538552284240723, 0.012994552962481976, 0.01337652001529932, -0.024566899985074997, -0.01906852051615715, 0.044746775180101395, 0.011855415999889374, 0.01559930108487606, 0.0060955192893743515, -0.009447254240512848, 0.01506881695240736, 0.004082590341567993, -0.012314354069530964, 0.02950334921479225, -0.023800671100616455, -0.019425950944423676, -0.06199466064572334, 0.04030465707182884, 0.005435609258711338, -0.03220460191369057, 0.024091990664601326, 0.07268374413251877, -0.020449023693799973, 0.006044347304850817, -0.018327990546822548, 0.000964987906627357, -0.038523588329553604, -0.03685212880373001, -0.028334544971585274, 0.01904870569705963, -0.020852118730545044, -0.05851574242115021, -0.017040608450770378, -0.007392226718366146, 0.007704793009907007, -0.04671821743249893, -0.03989963233470917, 0.023160673677921295, 0.01793176494538784, -0.03283241391181946, -0.01347969751805067, -0.015664266422390938, -0.00951895210891962, -0.01626810058951378, 0.007429921999573708, 0.01018296368420124, -0.02574383281171322, -0.0229682307690382, -0.042608242481946945, 0.030909322202205658, -0.03152187913656235, -0.007410809397697449, 0.008792427368462086, -0.0033718643244355917, -0.007275328505784273, 0.0259723998606205, 0.02401897683739662, 0.029081324115395546, -0.002261793939396739, 0.006315906997770071, -0.03020421229302883, -0.04161633923649788, -0.04394829273223877, -0.013576489873230457, 0.014920751564204693, -0.022142738103866577, -0.037689097225666046, -0.0023956377990543842, 0.03523659333586693, 0.016437210142612457, 0.03415456786751747, 0.028308643028140068, 0.003944222815334797, 0.05094056949019432, 0.0019322747830301523, -0.09607703983783722, -0.006731643341481686, -0.0032049918081611395, -0.048508282750844955, -0.039611030369997025, -0.022670801728963852, 0.07969585806131363, 0.015473254956305027, -0.024563387036323547, -0.00864112563431263, 0.04301750287413597, -0.007621472235769033, 0.00669518206268549, 0.02869226410984993, -0.05070163309574127, -0.011922360397875309, 0.025413552299141884, 0.006047488190233707, -0.00968770682811737, -0.023689836263656616, -0.058001335710287094, -0.0014643960166722536, 0.002263737842440605, -0.03217606619000435, 0.0007716268883086741, 0.00437577348202467, -0.027165845036506653, -0.024332895874977112, -0.01515461690723896, 0.026676220819354057, -0.045830801129341125, -0.005821858998388052, -0.0038703843019902706, 0.022143244743347168, 0.008461813442409039, 0.023089217022061348, -0.008167666383087635, -0.0015026889741420746, 0.05298265814781189, 0.0236269049346447, 0.04302751272916794, -0.022999687120318413, -0.0032757881563156843, 0.015211349353194237, 0.052142444998025894, -0.022670067846775055, -0.04156453534960747, 0.011186833493411541, -0.058507900685071945, -0.04127758368849754, 0.04504875838756561, 0.02371070347726345, 0.0036249696277081966, 0.019663415849208832, -0.023128967732191086, -0.023188939318060875, 0.0662456676363945, -0.02663120999932289, -0.026815980672836304, -0.00008493212226312608, -0.023781051859259605, -0.0076888189651072025, -0.00924687460064888, 0.026669111102819443, 0.0005944215226918459, -0.006948478519916534, 0.03605226054787636, 0.05874040350317955, -0.0044482676312327385, -0.03461164981126785, -0.025098826736211777, 0.02154463715851307, 0.04291854798793793, -0.00343945506028831, -0.02545017935335636, -0.0029799919575452805, 0.05657115578651428, -0.016673468053340912, 0.03694663569331169, -0.03138022497296333, -0.016074208542704582, -0.07925166189670563, -0.0006067248177714646, -0.023785719648003578, 0.03395404294133186, 0.024298451840877533, -0.05378296598792076, -0.0048712813295423985, 0.019992150366306305, -0.05576123297214508, 0.04236232116818428, -0.028272513300180435, -0.0339227095246315, -0.023786047473549843, 0.002276697428897023, -0.030055878683924675, -0.006350196432322264, -0.010882540605962276, 0.001582382945343852, 0.03983459994196892, 0.004944844637066126, 0.02454918809235096, -0.06034905090928078, 0.018645677715539932, 0.037261638790369034, 0.021825358271598816, -0.09555980563163757, 0.017630677670240402, -0.05093776807188988, -0.04861152544617653, 0.051586370915174484, -0.021622246131300926, 0.01108838152140379, 0.02684039995074272, 0.04781188443303108, 0.013488157652318478, 0.06053882837295532, 0.02555493824183941, 0.009735309518873692, 0.020076623186469078, 0.006782241631299257, -0.02412954345345497, 0.006321704480797052, -0.03549039363861084, 0.026714788749814034, 0.026076072826981544, 0.030415957793593407, -0.0011877052020281553, 0.008996601216495037, -0.003303024685010314, 0.013944614678621292, 0.010181126184761524, 0.009965137578547001, 0.019446102902293205, -0.04784196987748146, 0.003764410736039281, -0.043149225413799286, 0.012786184437572956, 0.03258410468697548, 0.04152838513255119, -0.056940414011478424, 0.024188127368688583, -0.033696822822093964, -0.02963804081082344, -0.023382360115647316, -0.01099440548568964, 0.004476012196391821, -0.024911673739552498, 0.020551951602101326, -0.002051732037216425, -0.009597956202924252, -0.030628876760601997, -0.022183557972311974, -0.005457163322716951, 0.04348541423678398, -0.057002704590559006, -0.02424127422273159, -0.024447627365589142, -0.00964002963155508, -0.02206512726843357, -0.07866553217172623, 0.05326415225863457, 0.012022635899484158, -0.035373758524656296, -0.026695014908909798, 0.03199372440576553, -0.03890850767493248, 0.019930314272642136, 0.056175537407398224, 0.0032546750735491514, -0.02342355251312256, 0.009813586249947548, -0.011354256421327591, 0.01965690404176712, -0.054470762610435486, 0.023340415209531784, 0.0010992740280926228, 0.010358364321291447, -0.003206698689609766, -0.009716267697513103, 0.001715815276838839, -0.026851201429963112, -0.0030859222169965506, -0.026165427640080452, -0.020383760333061218, -0.014750863425433636, 0.0015194481238722801, 0.0205292496830225, -0.033669549971818924, 0.0076421815901994705, 0.02324526384472847, 0.006862849462777376, -0.001450160052627325, 0.03792387619614601, 0.018888816237449646, -0.04395223781466484, 0.011980028823018074, -0.040615733712911606, 0.009964643977582455, 0.006044096779078245, -0.0036647533997893333, -0.009390449151396751, -0.06305041909217834, 0.006636124104261398, 0.011654761619865894, -0.03203556314110756, 0.001018677605316043, 0.043880660086870193, 0.023061592131853104, 0.011778222396969795, 0.009884965606033802, 0.02954195626080036, 0.016431985422968864, 0.004492681939154863, 0.025970496237277985, 0.06309043616056442, 0.05149555951356888, 0.018250446766614914, 0.029844488948583603, 0.011707067489624023, -0.020911315456032753, 0.06367212533950806, 0.009478003717958927, 0.034818798303604126, 0.014335211366415024, -0.0038230938371270895, 0.014822741970419884, -0.0032817067112773657, -0.014386431314051151, 0.004442859441041946, 0.000930172682274133, 0.016398070380091667, -0.04650766775012016, 0.0020648683421313763, -0.027305707335472107, 0.022524535655975342, -0.017013410106301308, -0.03903106227517128, 0.027834026142954826, 0.014321567490696907, -0.008533889427781105, -0.00120301463175565, -0.005705374758690596, -0.0067474995739758015, 0.006735714618116617, -0.016727393493056297, 0.02160048484802246, -0.004614981357008219, -0.0014510841574519873, -0.015628308057785034, -0.034256935119628906, -0.07133770734071732, -0.019058886915445328, 0.04772445186972618, 0.030350806191563606, 0.055026039481163025, -0.01054062508046627, -0.05528637394309044, 0.02682001143693924, 0.06038552522659302, -0.05684445798397064, -0.029329929500818253, -0.027536023408174515, 0.01705946773290634, -0.003925217781215906, -0.0054265824146568775 ]
<p>Based on the responses from the question <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/28086/how-to-draw-a-side-by-side-plot-mentioned-in-graphical-display-as-an-aid-to-ana">How to draw a side-by-side plot mentioned in &quot;Graphical Display as an Aid to Analysis&quot;</a>, I am considering implementing the function myself. The problem is that I don't know how to utilize the result of <code>aov()</code> function. I have to see how many factors there are, the names of factors, what are their main effects and interaction effects, etc. I can get residuals from <code>aov(y~x)$residuals</code>. I consulted the documentation for <code>aov()</code>, but I still have no clue how to do this. There must be some other way much complex than something like <code>t.test(x,y)$p.value</code>.</p> <p>Would you help me?</p>
41,740
[ -0.009120408445596695, 0.024714592844247818, 0.015006376430392265, 0.02906878851354122, 0.0429263636469841, -0.016430871561169624, -0.010421673767268658, -0.02503610961139202, 0.02870154194533825, -0.002614174969494343, 0.041602231562137604, 0.026587825268507004, 0.08388853818178177, 0.035761043429374695, 0.01020539365708828, -0.01251858752220869, -0.03051334246993065, -0.020694777369499207, 0.01688326708972454, -0.02799074724316597, -0.013238532468676567, -0.020845673978328705, 0.014262721873819828, -0.0125345503911376, 0.02775430493056774, 0.05407703295350075, 0.05701196566224098, -0.005470694042742252, 0.03023349680006504, 0.0297309048473835, -0.031779687851667404, -0.04126774147152901, 0.027285685762763023, 0.024555381387472153, 0.014745828695595264, -0.0004043187072966248, 0.01704268343746662, -0.02094934694468975, 0.00949071068316698, 0.030593641102313995, -0.0016300129937008023, -0.001928360085003078, -0.00016079422493930906, 0.03711019456386566, 0.00596204586327076, 0.019231848418712616, -0.034604884684085846, 0.005996553227305412, 0.04105081036686897, -0.04648419842123985, 0.056967172771692276, -0.005342245567589998, 0.059258297085762024, 0.01963026262819767, -0.026830490678548813, -0.013761300593614578, 0.054682657122612, 0.03273486718535423, 0.035160426050424576, -0.06263704597949982, 0.02480684593319893, -0.024358706548810005, -0.02175493910908699, -0.03330284729599953, -0.06895478814840317, 0.020445995032787323, 0.0202924981713295, -0.014194301329553127, 0.0010429213289171457, -0.04557740315794945, 0.010907596908509731, 0.029474707320332527, 0.014576319605112076, 0.0002961126738227904, 0.009028252214193344, 0.0025016667786985636, 0.05727514997124672, -0.057401519268751144, 0.035354599356651306, 0.03700830042362213, 0.023422226309776306, 0.04805433377623558, -0.01118540670722723, 0.013374490663409233, 0.023769604042172432, 0.016634928062558174, 0.0727880671620369, -0.019967233762145042, 0.006605858914554119, -0.008477275259792805, -0.0012688483111560345, 0.033515188843011856, 0.057875875383615494, 0.05050872266292572, -0.0708661824464798, 0.018676578998565674, -0.012773706577718258, 0.02235429547727108, 0.018133113160729408, -0.00009067435894394293, -0.007551789283752441, -0.03303465247154236, -0.001213014591485262, 0.022394049912691116, 0.0021124007180333138, -0.02806910127401352, -0.018968161195516586, -0.0068773007951676846, 0.003912352956831455, -0.038377419114112854, -0.027784593403339386, 0.022330164909362793, -0.02940952219069004, -0.008387679234147072, 0.017940882593393326, -0.01303953304886818, 0.021311365067958832, 0.04142530634999275, 0.08432227373123169, 0.012478061951696873, 0.06348458677530289, -0.019433842971920967, 0.027003757655620575, -0.01003476046025753, -0.055325139313936234, -0.01020340621471405, 0.01049818191677332, -0.006908032577484846, -0.02352319099009037, 0.06929977983236313, -0.018876006826758385, -0.040562327951192856, 0.02645224891602993, -0.00913330540060997, 0.007353002205491066, 0.006502089556306601, -0.08599132299423218, -0.07122991234064102, 0.02358243241906166, -0.04258665814995766, 0.010475028306245804, -0.008324665017426014, -0.023104438558220863, 0.026942063122987747, 0.017077237367630005, -0.00016314772074110806, 0.010791614651679993, -0.00887946505099535, 0.023812731727957726, 0.03338836878538132, -0.05837933346629143, 0.016569485887885094, -0.0252235047519207, 0.0017833266174420714, -0.03446584194898605, -0.0576033741235733, 0.0120413051918149, 0.03939306363463402, -0.016863981261849403, -0.011931591667234898, 0.0560947060585022, -0.006465170532464981, -0.007233971264213324, 0.008025789633393288, -0.0010556720662862062, -0.0693821907043457, 0.044362809509038925, -0.014283696189522743, 0.02708265744149685, 0.028809381648898125, -0.040553390979766846, 0.015002707950770855, 0.02490754798054695, 0.0129401795566082, 0.02396063506603241, 0.005673578474670649, -0.018262043595314026, -0.027236394584178925, -0.0038668052293360233, 0.027622435241937637, -0.04868195205926895, -0.05755124241113663, -0.05174313858151436, -0.016467584297060966, 0.028548981994390488, 0.02987758442759514, -0.033142101019620895, -0.02365792728960514, 0.043596960604190826, -0.06356159597635269, -0.056191716343164444, -0.0640195980668068, 0.009556012228131294, -0.01236790418624878, -0.026479491963982582, -0.016824694350361824, 0.000767361547332257, 0.03771112114191055, 0.031291842460632324, -0.025180557742714882, 0.010456107556819916, 0.03411714732646942, 0.07440128922462463, -0.023011349141597748, 0.00281044514849782, 0.013518176041543484, 0.07262290269136429, -0.02386384643614292, 0.01826408877968788, -0.03864859789609909, -0.01237258967012167, 0.0019219813402742147, -0.056319672614336014, 0.021395636722445488, 0.005568655673414469, -0.011665429919958115, 0.012551214545965195, 0.014364218339323997, 0.0008123955922201276, 0.009620347060263157, -0.03256542235612869, 0.04431385174393654, 0.07963676005601883, 0.006225785240530968, -0.0085066556930542, -0.026367835700511932, 0.03423162177205086, -0.0013966636033728719, -0.031663235276937485, 0.05918687954545021, -0.03828762099146843, -0.059146568179130554, 0.05873909965157509, 0.002698509953916073, -0.0011953915236517787, 0.03596920147538185, 0.02873172052204609, -0.02361169457435608, 0.012432669289410114, 0.03945159912109375, 0.015441163443028927, -0.015412014909088612, 0.005948252975940704, 0.047475915402173996, 0.014931649900972843, -0.02125898189842701, 0.038535404950380325, -0.013369321823120117, 0.05231141671538353, 0.027586989104747772, -0.011733540333807468, 0.06596070528030396, -0.006646386347711086, 0.009411252103745937, -0.03216847777366638, -0.013757869601249695, 0.0798916220664978, 0.004015746992081404, 0.011281847022473812, 0.023967359215021133, 0.0115882633253932, -0.015472358092665672, 0.03759625926613808, -0.019421851262450218, -0.01861107535660267, 0.017705487087368965, -0.015849387273192406, 0.011079146526753902, 0.003763162763789296, -0.020455604419112206, 0.048188433051109314, -0.024623168632388115, -0.02010277472436428, -0.04387308657169342, 0.002407046500593424, 0.02059515379369259, 0.0471513569355011, 0.0606401301920414, -0.0383312813937664, -0.03299175575375557, 0.02493964321911335, -0.006789518985897303, 0.01403594296425581, 0.015055916272103786, -0.046188849955797195, 0.01672946847975254, -0.07585440576076508, -0.01849624328315258, 0.019146688282489777, -0.0025110142305493355, -0.024264728650450706, 0.027176398783922195, -0.007503580767661333, -0.056664057075977325, -0.06764280050992966, -0.040727343410253525, 0.0010130350710824132, -0.08372051268815994, -0.03368748351931572, 0.01327388547360897, -0.03222759813070297, -0.026228589937090874, -0.007653138134628534, -0.006834178697317839, 0.007085450924932957, -0.0008903364650905132, 0.019248798489570618, 0.024371910840272903, 0.0017899514641612768, -0.008457289077341557, 0.03261562064290047, -0.019243542104959488, -0.02184140682220459, -0.0785973072052002, -0.026912596076726913, 0.0001696668186923489, 0.012779554352164268, -0.00227940920740366, -0.018069446086883545, -0.023205092176795006, 0.06361253559589386, 0.008969778195023537, -0.01342589221894741, -0.07267896085977554, 0.0013204347342252731, -0.042219243943691254, -0.03635816648602486, -0.0031172288581728935, 0.013713985681533813, 0.030417131260037422, 0.029416847974061966, -0.03079642541706562, 0.02976292371749878, 0.06320404261350632, 0.008689318783581257, 0.007013858761638403, 0.0006089751259423792, -0.017816796898841858, -0.011964332312345505, 0.018112972378730774, 0.018960371613502502, -0.01916523277759552, 0.0063458695076406, 0.01708313822746277, 0.011649982072412968, -0.018847458064556122, -0.04595251753926277, 0.003692804602906108, -0.031443532556295395, 0.0017279052408412099, -0.03252251073718071, 0.010288244113326073, 0.01722450740635395, -0.01192443910986185, -0.014167236164212227, 0.03931328281760216, 0.07108794152736664, -0.011280414648354053, 0.0039687249809503555, 0.0641479417681694, 0.043107300996780396, -0.03332846984267235, -0.007940882816910744, -0.013825132511556149, -0.014443432912230492, -0.0015044915489852428, -0.012348201125860214, 0.012344649992883205, 0.021588759496808052, 0.015734562650322914, 0.00443293759599328, 0.012254375033080578, -0.050761837512254715, 0.048562705516815186, -0.038710106164216995, 0.02324320189654827, -0.049249883741140366, 0.05104224011301994, 0.023532496765255928, 0.05671392008662224, 0.016175651922822, -0.006122080609202385, 0.01756472885608673, -0.04115050658583641, -0.05528808757662773, 0.03437987342476845, -0.0011008934816345572, -0.005587898660451174, 0.01101476326584816, 0.004249716177582741, 0.01476144976913929, 0.0013648583553731441, 0.016904618591070175, 0.0011090043699368834, 0.009974883869290352, 0.009157062508165836, 0.0005182239110581577, -0.02460412308573723, 0.007532052230089903, -0.03739289194345474, 0.012462573125958443, 0.029969217255711555, -0.006420754361897707, 0.034453146159648895, 0.07031227648258209, -0.03002641536295414, -0.014745966531336308, -0.04105176776647568, -0.005818530917167664, -0.010480988770723343, 0.021320294588804245, 0.06171146780252457, 0.0221652090549469, -0.006749821361154318, -0.0142905842512846, -0.01860678195953369, 0.03793478384613991, 0.018386563286185265, 0.011119295842945576, 0.005688040982931852, -0.0024456093087792397, -0.0366545170545578, -0.01931895688176155, 0.014246022328734398, -0.018755856901407242, 0.011590478010475636, 0.024523183703422546, 0.025164905935525894, -0.035455573350191116, 0.06136638671159744, 0.050365153700113297, 0.021283918991684914, 0.02974121831357479, -0.02987266331911087, -0.0029829873237758875, -0.023728491738438606, -0.006363522727042437, 0.05543842911720276, 0.013629363849759102, -0.005172158591449261, 0.01893942430615425, 0.026237623766064644, -0.016647497192025185, -0.02398689091205597, -0.005069426726549864, 0.008236312307417393, 0.04282502084970474, 0.0032492962200194597, -0.041340626776218414, -0.007862444967031479, 0.008638797327876091, 0.01591678336262703, 0.008690080605447292, -0.009433161467313766, -0.10184749960899353, 0.0019305059686303139, 0.026669450104236603, 0.012442498467862606, -0.011968608014285564, -0.0031322999857366085, -0.023993708193302155, -0.028254585340619087, 0.022617284208536148, -0.03381867706775665, 0.022680720314383507, -0.01918705739080906, 0.029703177511692047, -0.04201541468501091, 0.0027670138515532017, -0.07127492874860764, 0.03946390748023987, -0.05618013069033623, 0.0027031635399907827, -0.04500171169638634, -0.023559249937534332, -0.045854467898607254, 0.015432880260050297, -0.020913202315568924, 0.018242886289954185, -0.022522833198308945, -0.019264573231339455, -0.03241613507270813, 0.024599608033895493, -0.02447875216603279, -0.04470056667923927, 0.027190925553441048, 0.005482678301632404, -0.019208213314414024, 0.05408046394586563, 0.004549992270767689, 0.006002817302942276, 0.02101210691034794, 0.04112423211336136, 0.006984134204685688, -0.02471589669585228, -0.05345943197607994, 0.07132049649953842, 0.0204459335654974, -0.01918821781873703, 0.0817979946732521, 0.03257841244339943, 0.01075638085603714, 0.013673854060471058, -0.02908996492624283, 0.033075202256441116, 0.013280925340950489, -0.023945355787873268, -0.0350828655064106, -0.027536962181329727, 0.015781031921505928, 0.009769526310265064, -0.021730465814471245, 0.008430186659097672, -0.04499363154172897, -0.022191474214196205, 0.010618693195283413, 0.015115470625460148, 0.006830571684986353, -0.015146445482969284, 0.025515180081129074, -0.01760166697204113, -0.005276556592434645, -0.029246581718325615, -0.021158209070563316, -0.03577625751495361, -0.007209946401417255, -0.00392430555075407, -0.03403528407216072, -0.009001856669783592, -0.028767118230462074, -0.019788946956396103, -0.0025840741582214832, 0.014324711635708809, 0.02350856363773346, -0.015166728757321835, 0.052587173879146576, 0.01161560881882906, -0.026363546028733253, -0.028634002432227135, 0.07017336785793304, 0.014791066758334637, 0.0173802487552166, -0.0322711355984211, 0.07497227936983109, -0.02664245292544365, -0.004681080114096403, -0.023907572031021118, -0.024921366944909096, -0.013211829587817192, -0.0035032820887863636, -0.0315106101334095, -0.008300860412418842, -0.03555993735790253, -0.019870661199092865, 0.02467402070760727, -0.003384307725355029, 0.022108647972345352, -0.04714883863925934, -0.002562736626714468, -0.021266624331474304, -0.025919899344444275, 0.05793594568967819, -0.017824318259954453, 0.0063605718314647675, 0.005658826790750027, 0.013286835514008999, 0.022270360961556435, 0.009095684625208378, -0.02203746885061264, -0.034844666719436646, -0.014171279035508633, -0.04840156063437462, 0.03684217482805252, 0.0650329440832138, 0.0030181570909917355, 0.0008927949820645154, -0.03164280205965042, 0.0016754713142290711, -0.006335590500384569, -0.043153852224349976, 0.0073525067418813705, 0.013769243843853474, 0.0193219855427742, 0.009035971015691757, 0.00005006802894058637, -0.030396098271012306, 0.004749093670397997, 0.004111246671527624, -0.03539528325200081, -0.03080180659890175, 0.03182857856154442, 0.09216316789388657, 0.033370163291692734, 0.060060225427150726, -0.026950055733323097, -0.00024966575438156724, 0.062083955854177475, 0.013108707964420319, 0.02356491982936859, 0.0013833523262292147, -0.007956176064908504, -0.06624002754688263, -0.04382301867008209, -0.057261716574430466, -0.014198138378560543, 0.06354257464408875, -0.0582529716193676, 0.04602980986237526, 0.05870683118700981, 0.01263171061873436, -0.0016746334731578827, -0.025566913187503815, -0.03050062619149685, -0.03007657453417778, 0.024430422112345695, 0.06485337018966675, 0.0025638402439653873, -0.008969011716544628, 0.033086977899074554, 0.010911860503256321, 0.021705957129597664, 0.03887799009680748, -0.01216548029333353, -0.025573546066880226, 0.030493242666125298, -0.016960052773356438, -0.01613619364798069, -0.012062332592904568, -0.022505730390548706, 0.002084111561998725, -0.03604791685938835, -0.031965624541044235, 0.05685684457421303, 0.04912284016609192, -0.048709556460380554, -0.06008624657988548, -0.015287242829799652, -0.052244946360588074, -0.022427327930927277, 0.02035643719136715, -0.012090838514268398, 0.001783158048056066, 0.037172481417655945, 0.06505033373832703, -0.045260366052389145, 0.036400552839040756, -0.03444618359208107, -0.0696505531668663, -0.010091589763760567, -0.02760939486324787, -0.027839412912726402, 0.04932522028684616, -0.010212351568043232, -0.023433012887835503, 0.012269035913050175, -0.05328979343175888, 0.020001661032438278, -0.008835341781377792, 0.029281141236424446, -0.002421346493065357, 0.08856505900621414, -0.027045421302318573, 0.019539276137948036, 0.010425700806081295, 0.015550407581031322, 0.1267675757408142, 0.04031085968017578, 0.03669314086437225, -0.07605376839637756, 0.014061475172638893, 0.01128936093300581, -0.011303640902042389, -0.026886016130447388, -0.022226683795452118, 0.03314628824591637, 0.019341150298714638, 0.052877459675073624, 0.06620114296674728, 0.010037197731435299, 0.02133428119122982, 0.03851574286818504, -0.02859291434288025, -0.03547365963459015, -0.007603843230754137, 0.007457142695784569, -0.00977173913270235, -0.028975699096918106, -0.08020112663507462, 0.007984773255884647, 0.011233766563236713, 0.0009627339895814657, -0.009669380262494087, -0.02253171056509018, -0.0048336852341890335, -0.019695360213518143, -0.033130351454019547, 0.028201738372445107, 0.008860988542437553, 0.0365619920194149, -0.00715950271114707, -0.017490260303020477, 0.05158273130655289, -0.03380236029624939, 0.02850988879799843, 0.03866703063249588, 0.007560251280665398, -0.00745115801692009, -0.00003440640648477711, 0.015397002920508385, -0.010890249162912369, -0.04116102308034897, -0.0026370768900960684, 0.05749315768480301, -0.0082993870601058, -0.0025615182239562273, -0.03360610455274582, -0.008714305236935616, -0.03404596447944641, -0.021156881004571915, -0.021209411323070526, 0.02316977269947529, 0.03803772106766701, -0.023947004228830338, 0.019407136365771294, -0.012495697475969791, -0.015552067197859287, -0.019749263301491737, 0.04682960733771324, 0.024354612454771996, -0.006670176517218351, -0.00535446684807539, -0.04135344922542572, 0.06408216059207916, -0.0059424699284136295, -0.004552613478153944, -0.01168337743729353, -0.004621624946594238, -0.023500006645917892, -0.01573648303747177, 0.04370851442217827, 0.03580041229724884, -0.012455678544938564, 0.04640877991914749, -0.003258622484281659, -0.014536397531628609, -0.030717726796865463, 0.013378254137933254, -0.06814970076084137, -0.027653036639094353, -0.04914018511772156, 0.0052415793761610985, 0.05663556233048439, 0.025314947590231895, 0.019361527636647224, -0.012346961535513401, -0.002255456754937768, 0.05976537987589836, 0.00017985468730330467, -0.028076231479644775, -0.04803721606731415, 0.041659336537122726, -0.021920407190918922, -0.04021996259689331, -0.004804741591215134, 0.055134501308202744, 0.011977330781519413, -0.0030775030609220266, -0.022105371579527855, 0.027068667113780975, 0.0032373203430324793, -0.005631175823509693, 0.0223127119243145, -0.05278204381465912, -0.012971405871212482, -0.028492499142885208, 0.0074767861515283585, -0.061325449496507645, 0.0053051006980240345, -0.029719501733779907, -0.028934640809893608, 0.044831033796072006, 0.00006681072409264743, -0.018776632845401764, 0.023149147629737854, -0.008805513381958008, 0.036800846457481384, -0.04305064305663109, 0.0069265225902199745, -0.01753934845328331, -0.045854102820158005, -0.0020067289005964994, -0.015795139595866203, -0.023127034306526184, 0.05350973457098007, -0.0190131738781929, 0.021099168807268143, 0.022545520216226578, 0.04220844805240631, 0.020507361739873886, 0.004981882404536009, 0.004998976830393076, 0.01774941012263298, 0.0430227629840374, 0.025645878165960312, -0.019462382420897484, 0.00981072522699833, -0.005761750042438507, -0.00933622382581234, 0.008023770526051521, -0.027968814596533775, 0.055000778287649155, 0.007680412381887436, -0.005885236896574497, -0.008308143354952335, 0.03639204800128937, -0.0220138318836689, 0.022949939593672752, -0.01136175636202097, -0.01420561596751213, -0.016477610915899277, 0.011750833131372929, 0.018972087651491165, -0.0024632320273667574, 0.01350309792906046, 0.00643468601629138, 0.060437485575675964, -0.0035236526746302843, -0.014470777474343777, 0.002845081966370344, 0.007909415289759636, -0.015113460831344128, 0.012489689514040947, -0.0467279776930809, 0.040007736533880234, 0.04201044142246246, -0.029388437047600746, 0.04177031293511391, -0.013417001813650131, 0.038548678159713745, -0.09647829830646515, 0.01469773706048727, -0.013791246339678764, 0.018030859529972076, 0.02964659407734871, -0.031661469489336014, -0.0023659763392060995, 0.011008245870471, -0.018033936619758606, 0.036709293723106384, 0.026800591498613358, -0.0036445956211537123, -0.005549977999180555, 0.033117614686489105, 0.001266294508241117, 0.02825714461505413, 0.017747191712260246, 0.015559010207653046, 0.02078915387392044, 0.048059847205877304, 0.01805095188319683, -0.008711879141628742, -0.0008211450767703354, -0.002873111516237259, 0.02113405428826809, -0.043098051100969315, 0.04640590399503708, -0.021012865006923676, -0.02355319820344448, 0.017893457785248756, -0.0014895788626745343, 0.033462926745414734, 0.00045691855484619737, -0.005083744414150715, -0.017131207510828972, 0.05040846765041351, -0.031353335827589035, 0.005383527837693691, -0.02329118922352791, -0.0013662794372066855, 0.01850827783346176, -0.005858360789716244, 0.00454889889806509, 0.0327640064060688, 0.027990464121103287, 0.015294106677174568, -0.04043988138437271, 0.027676939964294434, 0.0047322832979261875, -0.03394991531968117, 0.007127950433641672, -0.015864482149481773, -0.0018599992617964745, -0.03292568773031235, -0.0008031285251490772, -0.021985236555337906, 0.01080461498349905, 0.03680212423205376, -0.02051001787185669, -0.0191507451236248, 0.008120215497910976, -0.03488488867878914, -0.07290179282426834, 0.02313992939889431, -0.0023252409882843494, 0.01596381887793541, -0.04727085307240486, 0.02861311286687851, -0.010139796882867813, -0.010163521394133568, 0.0019784856121987104, 0.007663076743483543, -0.03483811020851135, 0.010362913832068443, -0.026902638375759125, -0.002504047006368637, 0.0378844253718853, -0.03000093437731266, 0.030052294954657555, -0.09386168420314789, 0.05065979063510895, 0.03970517963171005, -0.027468468993902206, -0.03154361620545387, 0.024675386026501656, -0.02925517037510872, 0.006837258115410805, 0.004903985187411308, 0.0022483873181045055, -0.009265027940273285, -0.023497870191931725, 0.01965954899787903, -0.011139082722365856, -0.03208458423614502, 0.04447145387530327, -0.011701494455337524, -0.016098471358418465, -0.004199012648314238, 0.024643098935484886, 0.030796777456998825, 0.014037352986633778, 0.022419730201363564, -0.02131914347410202, -0.005194128956645727, -0.014430788345634937, -0.05707443878054619, 0.005447877570986748, 0.014962979592382908, -0.04411502555012703, 0.04569235071539879, 0.0007423994247801602, -0.0024884508457034826, 0.04047783091664314, 0.02965480461716652, -0.011229184456169605, 0.050145622342824936, -0.0190939549356699, 0.007648179307579994, -0.017359856516122818, 0.0023078524973243475, 0.029392946511507034, -0.07445405423641205, 0.017904456704854965, 0.022300461307168007, -0.008247253485023975, 0.007722966372966766, 0.014819364994764328, 0.043509937822818756, 0.004986755084246397, -0.015969008207321167, 0.009604014456272125, -0.0029237205162644386, -0.04437440261244774, -0.0023478481452912092, -0.011316658928990364, 0.02412392385303974, 0.01297028735280037, -0.01878792978823185, 0.021463461220264435, -0.014528922736644745, 0.005335231311619282, -0.009419984184205532, 0.046907030045986176, 0.023997927084565163, -0.00577675411477685, 0.012453717179596424, -0.016455594450235367, 0.02304951660335064, 0.019310617819428444, 0.0050118230283260345, 0.04743988439440727, -0.0643734484910965, 0.01037478819489479, -0.02388955093920231, -0.017915723845362663, -0.06393727660179138, 0.005178208462893963, 0.021921148523688316, 0.009089620783925056, -0.02740100771188736, 0.0012062033638358116, 0.01362669002264738, -0.014213033020496368, -0.02280990593135357, 0.0075800190679728985, 0.04652249813079834, -0.014258257113397121, -0.022369904443621635, -0.02048715576529503, -0.041194453835487366, -0.04829035699367523, -0.040336307138204575, 0.04501894488930702, 0.027495717629790306, 0.02078467421233654, -0.035688500851392746, -0.023424768820405006, 0.00559559091925621, 0.04358965903520584, -0.08007030934095383, -0.03371626138687134, -0.031012453138828278, 0.00733241206035018, 0.00914826337248087, 0.013130445964634418 ]
<p>Standard deck has 52 cards, 26 Red and 26 Black. A run is a maximum contiguous block of cards, which has the same color.</p> <p>Eg.</p> <ul> <li>(R,B,R,B,...,R,B) has 52 runs.</li> <li>(R,R,R,...,R,B,B,B,...,B) has 2 runs.</li> </ul> <p>What is the expected number of runs in a shuffled deck of cards?</p>
74,019
[ -0.03798166289925575, -0.048547785729169846, -0.01592393033206463, -0.008598731830716133, 0.03335712477564812, -0.026122942566871643, 0.035231899470090866, -0.022026751190423965, -0.00982693862169981, 0.01947994902729988, 0.06748907268047333, 0.0484444722533226, -0.002843787893652916, 0.029307721182703972, -0.003607867518439889, 0.013897190801799297, 0.010931498371064663, -0.045605845749378204, 0.004782770294696093, 0.020599573850631714, -0.012689785100519657, 0.02272717095911503, 0.03690063953399658, 0.01906154491007328, -0.049610771238803864, 0.008523071184754372, 0.07865937799215317, -0.01768920198082924, 0.042164817452430725, 0.05935141444206238, -0.05426594614982605, -0.025619149208068848, 0.030189497396349907, 0.05056624487042427, 0.04135636240243912, 0.03296132758259773, -0.022933393716812134, -0.04276338592171669, -0.0195483285933733, -0.013496292755007744, -0.019944483414292336, 0.0015868892660364509, -0.03316407650709152, 0.009833941236138344, -0.023089682683348656, 0.04477474093437195, -0.0039246887899935246, -0.023513849824666977, 0.0254898052662611, -0.04221557080745697, 0.08435102552175522, -0.017552025616168976, 0.04373329132795334, 0.003687930293381214, 0.015076624229550362, 0.012363898567855358, 0.040874168276786804, 0.0626257061958313, 0.0075368923135101795, -0.02563423663377762, 0.026050005108118057, -0.027382642030715942, -0.004351689014583826, -0.0179478507488966, -0.03570530191063881, 0.026692107319831848, 0.0013041136553511024, -0.020366337150335312, 0.033082254230976105, 0.0008459443342871964, -0.009996524080634117, 0.04604100063443184, 0.029258325695991516, -0.030878324061632156, 0.056613657623529434, -0.022428886964917183, -0.007925440557301044, 0.022192390635609627, -0.008340907283127308, 0.03281083703041077, 0.022334426641464233, 0.027474509552121162, 0.028638139367103577, 0.001367912394925952, 0.021479401737451553, -0.041935261338949203, 0.07552929222583771, 0.011850646696984768, 0.012384618632495403, -0.0187816359102726, 0.06748463958501816, -0.005373304709792137, 0.05826060101389885, -0.012092109769582748, -0.05412987619638443, 0.03422190994024277, -0.02364405430853367, 0.03441468998789787, -0.03224005177617073, -0.006776685360819101, -0.006401402875781059, -0.06144511327147484, 0.02901197411119938, 0.06664801388978958, -0.0019506452372297645, 0.0027369854506105185, -0.030575983226299286, 0.018091455101966858, 0.006628864444792271, -0.004269349854439497, 0.016598178073763847, 0.04488778114318848, -0.001512668444775045, 0.011524622328579426, -0.024189677089452744, -0.01904737949371338, 0.014766979031264782, 0.015118680894374847, 0.0052256048657000065, 0.06309668719768524, -0.0016760198632255197, -0.04592570662498474, -0.0029220711439847946, -0.03639212250709534, -0.07014988362789154, 0.013158619403839111, 0.028065873309969902, -0.03576882183551788, -0.05937151983380318, 0.0633372962474823, -0.03441954776644707, 0.009306265972554684, -0.010698194615542889, 0.015058777295053005, 0.034676097333431244, -0.02515474706888199, -0.07611682265996933, -0.07518050074577332, 0.01936066336929798, -0.011478662490844727, -0.041298188269138336, -0.019674599170684814, 0.0006592301069758832, -0.0017243241891264915, 0.020084436982870102, -0.03278405964374542, 0.047495774924755096, 0.029390158131718636, -0.006443951278924942, 0.00915632862597704, -0.018261365592479706, 0.01782899722456932, -0.003917846363037825, -0.02558920346200466, 0.01584484428167343, -0.06121225282549858, 0.00983260478824377, 0.015871930867433548, -0.03833187744021416, -0.014224628917872906, -0.011844497174024582, -0.005428796634078026, 0.0018342933617532253, -0.004559245891869068, -0.015190785750746727, -0.05620874837040901, 0.08268912136554718, 0.005863802973181009, 0.013030447997152805, 0.02739914134144783, -0.018313702195882797, -0.019567886367440224, 0.023994922637939453, 0.012141052633523941, 0.03972264751791954, -0.029213055968284607, -0.01828482747077942, 0.01627292111515999, -0.0027493059169501066, 0.003618622897192836, -0.05325709283351898, -0.01223920937627554, 0.021801887080073357, 0.015167023055255413, 0.04701510816812515, 0.01889653690159321, 0.010687141679227352, -0.007817353121936321, 0.007464027032256126, -0.0510181300342083, -0.005518779624253511, -0.08665343374013901, 0.010919421911239624, 0.02694745734333992, 0.008933071978390217, -0.04140795022249222, -0.02124953642487526, 0.053441375494003296, -0.017215117812156677, -0.009431925602257252, -0.011219695210456848, 0.0254703089594841, 0.0025190929882228374, -0.008600820787250996, -0.019038861617445946, 0.11522115021944046, 0.03863327205181122, -0.025537263602018356, 0.03024604544043541, -0.0576464980840683, -0.025391148403286934, -0.03701576218008995, -0.045783258974552155, 0.020977916195988655, 0.007131790276616812, -0.01333815697580576, 0.02754998579621315, 0.026462092995643616, 0.010708601213991642, 0.007971863262355328, -0.033513061702251434, 0.02488841861486435, 0.055115245282649994, 0.018018346279859543, 0.020811840891838074, -0.0005932445637881756, -0.001180992927402258, -0.011740968562662601, 0.014610462822020054, -0.0033734620083123446, -0.04176388680934906, -0.007248616777360439, 0.04316370189189911, 0.02912675403058529, -0.02890903316438198, 0.014205794781446457, 0.06909467279911041, 0.023474931716918945, -0.010141546837985516, 0.05423010513186455, -0.04942507669329643, 0.0037025685887783766, 0.014378988184034824, -0.017378853633999825, 0.006375265307724476, -0.010897467844188213, 0.017051612958312035, 0.013991786167025566, -0.0005141079891473055, -0.01624934747815132, -0.042882487177848816, 0.04065905138850212, 0.020670784637331963, 0.0021585943177342415, -0.012041943147778511, -0.03431254252791405, 0.04205486923456192, -0.015044400468468666, -0.026524867862462997, 0.03856135904788971, -0.0006892546662129462, 0.0009260136284865439, 0.003552085720002651, -0.026886364445090294, -0.0029218632262200117, 0.011668207123875618, 0.003496680874377489, -0.035138845443725586, 0.033947788178920746, 0.02664891630411148, 0.016187146306037903, -0.014292283914983273, -0.024590512737631798, -0.03688114881515503, 0.02810015343129635, 0.02521151676774025, -0.030970953404903412, 0.040461551398038864, -0.03953995183110237, 0.007422558031976223, -0.0016715703532099724, -0.015480635687708855, -0.001788669265806675, -0.03360763192176819, -0.06392931193113327, 0.013051965273916721, 0.01449781283736229, -0.04477960243821144, 0.009984773583710194, -0.01850695163011551, -0.01710749976336956, 0.06828617304563522, -0.001620457274839282, -0.017312785610556602, 0.003640102921053767, -0.02608099952340126, 0.026097478345036507, -0.051164694130420685, -0.005546515807509422, 0.08606114983558655, 0.011455107480287552, -0.05544517561793327, 0.03741679713129997, -0.05268622562289238, 0.011293421499431133, -0.027530228719115257, -0.0042787352576851845, 0.021073440089821815, -0.003545860294252634, -0.02062959410250187, -0.004127281717956066, -0.0014884107513353229, 0.0064517175778746605, -0.0660652369260788, -0.041292525827884674, -0.024457402527332306, -0.027830176055431366, 0.042782727628946304, 0.008005124516785145, -0.0036397783551365137, 0.060884665697813034, 0.027689145877957344, -0.00790906697511673, -0.006090973969548941, -0.0378112755715847, 0.010091896168887615, -0.05492820590734482, 0.032982371747493744, 0.03539473935961723, -0.03267126530408859, 0.01939990743994713, 0.014058670960366726, 0.03683096170425415, 0.027688393369317055, -0.033330947160720825, -0.01793668605387211, -0.003147340379655361, 0.018613047897815704, -0.022507531568408012, 0.05621543526649475, 0.004472984466701746, -0.043654054403305054, -0.005026055034250021, -0.001789152855053544, 0.02008427120745182, 0.014308291487395763, -0.04319942742586136, 0.05060810595750809, -0.010589619167149067, 0.012240231037139893, -0.011519377119839191, 0.04878837615251541, 0.005446736700832844, -0.02656339295208454, -0.013298548758029938, -0.013156356289982796, 0.04357919469475746, 0.01453430950641632, 0.007159512955695391, 0.05558821186423302, 0.04716802015900612, -0.04185022413730621, -0.021414760500192642, -0.015547561459243298, -0.015561435371637344, 0.020084703341126442, -0.03300295025110245, -0.02712569199502468, 0.032589804381132126, 0.01607847958803177, 0.015697844326496124, -0.0010178884258493781, -0.04148005694150925, -0.040927376598119736, -0.0822589322924614, 0.018096961081027985, -0.016441859304904938, 0.08524033427238464, 0.00832424871623516, 0.05029424652457237, -0.008679784834384918, -0.014954537153244019, 0.02373264916241169, 0.021610092371702194, -0.09349431097507477, -0.011389867402613163, -0.02379344217479229, -0.00928763672709465, -0.04497582092881203, -0.024100948125123978, 0.030901826918125153, -0.02104443684220314, -0.0029303161427378654, 0.01735760271549225, 0.011173474602401257, -0.02812439203262329, 0.03271627426147461, -0.013102805241942406, -0.04281226173043251, 0.02306191809475422, -0.003950584679841995, 0.003288908628746867, -0.014589146710932255, 0.04788055643439293, 0.026137566193938255, -0.03182617202401161, -0.009799866937100887, 0.012528751976788044, 0.00895986519753933, -0.0016197572695091367, 0.03339656814932823, 0.02788166143000126, 0.041714977473020554, -0.012661601416766644, -0.001803276827558875, -0.0069486056454479694, 0.038371313363313675, 0.02045419253408909, -0.031162558123469353, 0.022609608247876167, -0.07299549132585526, 0.009560666978359222, 0.009151844307780266, 0.00023448631691280752, -0.023585570976138115, 0.019193464890122414, 0.03925945609807968, 0.024540387094020844, -0.02771664597094059, 0.022663189098238945, 0.048139024525880814, -0.009463478811085224, -0.0303086806088686, -0.029214773327112198, 0.030846044421195984, -0.021607648581266403, -0.017095183953642845, -0.005301141180098057, -0.010951867327094078, 0.011645701713860035, 0.03975000977516174, 0.016893982887268066, -0.0032977827358990908, -0.036947160959243774, -0.008325685746967793, -0.00792606920003891, 0.04384029656648636, -0.017711183056235313, -0.003560254815965891, 0.00685009453445673, 0.020889488980174065, 0.010128874331712723, 0.026814943179488182, -0.03172348067164421, -0.020084811374545097, -0.006330263335257769, 0.05187893658876419, 0.0485987588763237, -0.04151851683855057, 0.020428676158189774, -0.026705827564001083, 0.03140206262469292, 0.015654565766453743, -0.017148174345493317, 0.024465201422572136, -0.023609885945916176, 0.014902686700224876, -0.06051585078239441, -0.052180737257003784, -0.031150588765740395, 0.01771017536520958, -0.026695385575294495, 0.028014222159981728, -0.016700444743037224, -0.001441473956219852, -0.034711629152297974, 0.012365601025521755, 0.05597345530986786, 0.060505472123622894, -0.06421656906604767, 0.01486029289662838, 0.012397311627864838, -0.002412360394373536, -0.0441390722990036, -0.07957629859447479, -0.001560200471431017, -0.00035943323746323586, 0.012869948521256447, 0.03224405273795128, -0.02796514704823494, -0.05865266174077988, -0.004734192509204149, -0.0072509124875068665, -0.024465521797537804, 0.024324430152773857, -0.045604389160871506, 0.038149282336235046, 0.02756301499903202, -0.014383492060005665, 0.04642567038536072, 0.037615831941366196, -0.010960676707327366, 0.007190083619207144, 0.006371659692376852, 0.017064986750483513, -0.0113253528252244, 0.0014456106582656503, -0.04218956455588341, -0.007808669935911894, -0.04235508665442467, 0.005691657308489084, -0.01928498037159443, 0.04722614586353302, 0.00659551564604044, -0.04044288769364357, -0.029357336461544037, 0.01310944464057684, 0.026029113680124283, 0.017930692061781883, -0.004032421857118607, -0.018928151577711105, -0.004491816274821758, -0.03621593862771988, 0.03282816708087921, 0.0032070090528577566, 0.01949610561132431, 0.027389278635382652, 0.00016310169303324074, 0.03211786970496178, -0.043122898787260056, -0.013266078196465969, -0.01406064908951521, -0.0245833620429039, 0.05035807192325592, -0.0034108879044651985, 0.025435108691453934, 0.014436887577176094, -0.0066562844440341, -0.015256626531481743, 0.005287165753543377, -0.027403583750128746, -0.0544692724943161, -0.024470647796988487, 0.05124467611312866, -0.00543708773329854, -0.03440476581454277, -0.06539376080036163, -0.022189555689692497, 0.020330749452114105, 0.012243798933923244, -0.0053544011898338795, -0.03705601766705513, -0.0026717728469520807, 0.023613275960087776, -0.006869684439152479, -0.03608289361000061, 0.030529767274856567, -0.022520946338772774, -0.0046875933185219765, -0.021876245737075806, -0.04822712019085884, 0.08956067264080048, 0.045022446662187576, -0.00904080830514431, -0.0023094741627573967, -0.040971558541059494, -0.044728461652994156, -0.02794795110821724, 0.03447597846388817, -0.026740550994873047, -0.01721499115228653, 0.02476264350116253, 0.024467116221785545, 0.057454731315374374, -0.010619175620377064, -0.031003553420305252, 0.011545625515282154, 0.02434646151959896, -0.03411448001861572, -0.0446854904294014, 0.006257815286517143, 0.0030910500790923834, 0.010817307978868484, 0.0013344347244128585, 0.013717243447899818, -0.012042741291224957, -0.01834127865731716, -0.017143327742815018, -0.009207992814481258, -0.01889318972826004, 0.014263687655329704, 0.065163254737854, -0.0006950542447157204, -0.02160581760108471, 0.006395475007593632, -0.04000687226653099, 0.029629414901137352, 0.02514016069471836, -0.006403698585927486, 0.022175390273332596, -0.015006312169134617, -0.0027444115839898586, -0.033586736768484116, -0.01855192333459854, -0.012264684773981571, 0.02469867281615734, -0.0074866157956421375, 0.03915233910083771, 0.03937917202711105, 0.007266449276357889, 0.03603486716747284, 0.0029604434967041016, 0.0076340786181390285, -0.008282102644443512, 0.03419730067253113, 0.03972054645419121, 0.006019968073815107, 0.03735480457544327, 0.009942627511918545, 0.040533822029829025, 0.02952580340206623, 0.020398132503032684, 0.020965777337551117, -0.025033950805664062, 0.00587279861792922, -0.03038492612540722, -0.04879540950059891, 0.030356567353010178, -0.06531896442174911, 0.01938706822693348, -0.022607827559113503, 0.0014960203552618623, 0.07737001031637192, 0.023990361019968987, -0.021238774061203003, -0.005781606771051884, 0.04267364367842674, -0.050897546112537384, 0.004606041591614485, 0.0013324307510629296, 0.02512376569211483, 0.000037857895222259685, -0.017428167164325714, 0.03307735547423363, -0.0008323794463649392, 0.06571725010871887, -0.031942449510097504, -0.07694685459136963, 0.015343118458986282, 0.006367685738950968, -0.05107448250055313, 0.027921417728066444, 0.020817650482058525, -0.008636931888759136, -0.0073232795111835, -0.02025715447962284, 0.04544385150074959, 0.02313769795000553, 0.04515243321657181, -0.036840952932834625, 0.07947441190481186, 0.016894381493330002, 0.01661071926355362, -0.020417826250195503, -0.0011640622979030013, 0.12121190875768661, 0.06314005702733994, 0.07872558385133743, -0.06891065090894699, 0.004166345577687025, -0.031997084617614746, 0.0048966375179588795, 0.014481538906693459, 0.0013039904879406095, 0.005228775553405285, 0.026622191071510315, 0.025193337351083755, 0.022114409133791924, -0.011366801336407661, 0.004447080194950104, 0.006220633629709482, -0.06027546152472496, -0.04113974794745445, -0.0007490650750696659, 0.014626458287239075, -0.016350993886590004, 0.028815092518925667, -0.08636104315519333, -0.0007801270694471896, 0.003412796650081873, -0.019043702632188797, -0.04275019094347954, -0.013240810483694077, 0.017164459452033043, 0.0016100641805678606, -0.016636252403259277, 0.025621546432375908, 0.04414611682295799, -0.011826000176370144, 0.0031296643428504467, 0.0014264743076637387, 0.011423073709011078, -0.012394587509334087, 0.010858123190701008, 0.04514331370592117, 0.01297664362937212, 0.018344996497035027, 0.010947938077151775, 0.021065492182970047, -0.05886334180831909, -0.03306801989674568, -0.035642676055431366, -0.008199055679142475, -0.04945111647248268, -0.012075427919626236, -0.02010512165725231, -0.012893203645944595, -0.032001130282878876, -0.05204816162586212, 0.012877542525529861, 0.01894827000796795, 0.014892988838255405, -0.05474122241139412, -0.0263198409229517, -0.04285554587841034, -0.0027535762637853622, -0.04892084747552872, 0.004350786097347736, 0.037246912717819214, -0.012999004684388638, -0.025823431089520454, -0.05031803995370865, 0.0533294714987278, -0.0009296819334849715, 0.007826518267393112, -0.025168832391500473, -0.006722653284668922, -0.04298793151974678, -0.007296689786016941, 0.0008545124437659979, 0.014545297250151634, 0.02713388204574585, 0.02993626520037651, -0.018806984648108482, 0.016977757215499878, -0.0341184101998806, 0.06857822090387344, -0.020809220150113106, -0.04119473323225975, -0.03974686190485954, 0.008719785138964653, 0.031658731400966644, -0.007712698075920343, 0.027735663577914238, 0.026869313791394234, 0.026852823793888092, 0.04235425218939781, -0.00449006725102663, -0.043871961534023285, -0.0047105103731155396, 0.009342568926513195, -0.04734514653682709, -0.027705034241080284, 0.018066763877868652, 0.06707427650690079, 0.03797457739710808, 0.001373797538690269, 0.004007911309599876, 0.011952162720263004, -0.010288573801517487, -0.002969425870105624, 0.006737526971846819, -0.05953031778335571, -0.0017039412632584572, 0.0276673324406147, -0.014464701525866985, -0.029124684631824493, 0.0026383730582892895, -0.0043943170458078384, -0.018395032733678818, 0.026222411543130875, -0.036204367876052856, -0.04249986633658409, -0.051535818725824356, -0.030458714812994003, 0.040972981601953506, -0.021363016217947006, -0.027952594682574272, -0.017582405358552933, -0.029427019879221916, -0.01364127453416586, 0.023173293098807335, -0.022073568776249886, 0.02500576339662075, 0.019971387460827827, -0.004047574009746313, 0.027490666136145592, 0.011678009293973446, 0.04001113772392273, 0.0276979710906744, 0.008387933485209942, -0.012689660303294659, 0.022155849263072014, -0.010927381925284863, -0.043255146592855453, 0.048916250467300415, -0.039699990302324295, 0.018204398453235626, -0.012038562446832657, -0.010561087168753147, 0.029131805524230003, 0.03451714292168617, -0.009760349988937378, -0.005048106424510479, 0.046577297151088715, -0.023175504058599472, -0.03714747354388237, -0.024158336222171783, -0.015183459036052227, 0.03808866813778877, 0.013334883376955986, -0.0009017151314765215, -0.014735790900886059, -0.0028863255865871906, 0.011264121159911156, 0.01738554798066616, -0.028829896822571754, 0.014737200923264027, 0.010017761029303074, 0.025167658925056458, 0.0007882826612330973, -0.02024565450847149, -0.019662952050566673, 0.011990724131464958, 0.019985387101769447, -0.0029196389950811863, 0.05096552520990372, -0.04005717486143112, -0.004868393298238516, -0.08344608545303345, 0.009690918028354645, -0.0075731598772108555, -0.014662984758615494, 0.040855180472135544, -0.034645091742277145, -0.040116384625434875, 0.02400905452668667, -0.011022903025150299, 0.01914393901824951, 0.028354542329907417, -0.00419986667111516, -0.029128212481737137, 0.046524133533239365, -0.029800884425640106, 0.005427862051874399, 0.02853710949420929, 0.028261825442314148, 0.056693289428949356, 0.035817570984363556, 0.0005742123466916382, -0.02853243798017502, 0.0006232863524928689, 0.012951071374118328, -0.0026476841885596514, 0.00479366397485137, -0.010792063549160957, 0.00658395467326045, 0.0016346173360943794, 0.006990240886807442, 0.006269985809922218, 0.031249500811100006, 0.0041598170064389706, 0.011627553030848503, 0.022087030112743378, 0.048172205686569214, 0.02066742815077305, 0.014734050258994102, -0.026942510157823563, -0.04248833283782005, -0.014120842330157757, 0.03804468363523483, -0.011810162104666233, 0.013852106407284737, 0.03372618183493614, -0.024552926421165466, -0.033769600093364716, 0.005808540154248476, -0.025785626843571663, -0.019197700545191765, -0.007888630032539368, 0.02431919425725937, 0.009804349392652512, -0.00126170355360955, 0.022641712799668312, 0.03851619362831116, 0.02236894890666008, 0.035279568284749985, 0.003401105524972081, -0.011405467987060547, -0.018947044387459755, 0.02048473246395588, -0.01471132691949606, -0.0074851433746516705, 0.0033572872634977102, -0.04060087725520134, -0.05164530128240585, -0.015641752630472183, 0.009675823152065277, 0.003573915222659707, -0.000540365232154727, -0.029942160472273827, -0.008944586850702763, 0.004484623204916716, 0.013619182631373405, 0.03068658523261547, 0.02640855498611927, 0.004466869402676821, 0.009203415364027023, -0.02668239176273346, 0.06735171377658844, 0.0032574234064668417, -0.00625248346477747, -0.06360986083745956, -0.0040185535326600075, 0.01095614954829216, 0.055449966341257095, 0.05523732304573059, 0.044701434671878815, -0.03298023343086243, 0.0012837420217692852, 0.02758757583796978, 0.058512914925813675, -0.03939191997051239, 0.02705174684524536, -0.05499991402029991, -0.005079883150756359, -0.017504394054412842, -0.04136704280972481, 0.014615755528211594, 0.028330164030194283, 0.024129807949066162, -0.018456950783729553, -0.007496228441596031, -0.010274958796799183, -0.003711182624101639, 0.01665622554719448, 0.03306983411312103, -0.03895656019449234, 0.05922945588827133, -0.015473724342882633, 0.03536370024085045, -0.007401270791888237, -0.009425252676010132, -0.03142230212688446, 0.07336628437042236, -0.07622101157903671, -0.009913780726492405, 0.006560519803315401, -0.006130686961114407, 0.04939722269773483, -0.04600749909877777, 0.006326703820377588, 0.015111041255295277, -0.04790952429175377, -0.014124562963843346, 0.0545031875371933, 0.021961001679301262, 0.055537205189466476, -0.043690744787454605, 0.013221719302237034, -0.01037539355456829, -0.06958863139152527, -0.027007531374692917, -0.0007605707505717874, 0.01352628879249096, -0.03299872204661369, 0.019360478967428207, 0.01414090022444725, -0.004958052653819323, 0.04474881291389465, 0.03857395425438881, 0.0020878559444099665, 0.008674788288772106, 0.014448211528360844, 0.018352096900343895, -0.02683483436703682, 0.013094468042254448, 0.018244970589876175, -0.012206352315843105, 0.06973328441381454, -0.0034688059240579605, 0.04883681237697601, -0.03986375778913498, -0.00888404343277216, -0.05566209927201271, -0.027872221544384956, 0.009568572044372559, -0.023962393403053284, 0.005981582682579756, 0.032359976321458817, -0.01490773819386959, 0.031148100271821022, 0.06150228530168533, -0.033753104507923126, 0.035795990377664566, 0.0013982612872496247, -0.019094757735729218, -0.0338745042681694, 0.021742766723036766, -0.021134356036782265, -0.02778337523341179, 0.04261333867907524, 0.03276403248310089, -0.012601974420249462, 0.007042491342872381, -0.007298977579921484, 0.03016859106719494, 0.06998346745967865, -0.05938122794032097, -0.0148096214979887, -0.07376446574926376, 0.01860591396689415, -0.04341491311788559, -0.011534953489899635 ]
<p>Following to the recent questions we had <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/1818/how-to-determine-the-sample-size-needed-for-repeated-measurement-anova/1823#1823">here</a>.</p> <p>I was hopping to know if anyone had come across or can share <strong>R code for performing a custom power analysis based on simulation for a linear model?</strong></p> <p>Later I would obviously like to extend it to more complex models, but lm seems to right place to start. Thanks.</p>
74,020
[ -0.032374706119298935, 0.012609319761395454, -0.01686200127005577, 0.0007528496789745986, 0.06881555169820786, 0.023969750851392746, -0.013222762383520603, -0.04613509774208069, 0.024428093805909157, -0.024909673258662224, 0.04199371114373207, 0.06609617173671722, 0.08390196412801743, -0.0017337709432467818, 0.025475619360804558, -0.0013897411990910769, -0.005997731816023588, -0.003560603130608797, -0.010229707695543766, -0.023049114271998405, -0.007280248217284679, 0.0063691833056509495, 0.013048901222646236, -0.01993696577847004, -0.044264089316129684, 0.05509383603930473, 0.03699641674757004, -0.022106869146227837, -0.0031055391300469637, 0.06249845772981644, -0.04777376726269722, -0.012909376062452793, 0.02142925001680851, 0.04149927571415901, -0.0007621952681802213, 0.0033140291925519705, -0.03193463385105133, -0.044908199459314346, 0.03583147004246712, 0.03833196312189102, -0.016630519181489944, 0.00855815876275301, -0.01316946279257536, 0.026976589113473892, 0.013008861802518368, 0.018616480752825737, -0.04523184522986412, -0.03662943094968796, 0.03073386289179325, -0.03339610621333122, 0.0870068222284317, 0.02460496872663498, 0.05780009925365448, 0.014701585285365582, 0.006026675458997488, -0.02264305017888546, 0.05590580403804779, 0.0462021566927433, 0.010690303519368172, -0.04651689529418945, -0.009607293643057346, -0.01269750390201807, 0.00979410856962204, -0.006254562642425299, -0.04253799095749855, -0.017205743119120598, 0.006988842505961657, -0.020833414047956467, 0.031128570437431335, -0.02289455197751522, 0.02595374546945095, 0.02950240857899189, 0.033528707921504974, -0.006546540651470423, -0.013650991022586823, -0.00561095867305994, 0.00013511840370483696, -0.018533699214458466, 0.033219944685697556, 0.05840558931231499, -0.01791093870997429, 0.0444086454808712, 0.0160986315459013, 0.02897905930876732, 0.0050201416015625, -0.02030041813850403, 0.06892940402030945, -0.002333645708858967, -0.02622375078499317, -0.007733621168881655, -0.03021841123700142, -0.020083868876099586, 0.032461944967508316, 0.024685144424438477, -0.03058497980237007, 0.010568437166512012, -0.010188073851168156, 0.07245568186044693, -0.0005566289182752371, 0.004179114941507578, 0.00042533778469078243, -0.022052455693483353, 0.008082033134996891, 0.03187735378742218, -0.007392076775431633, -0.023519428446888924, 0.011715957894921303, 0.0008465530117973685, -0.00684697600081563, -0.029764708131551743, 0.01174410991370678, 0.02933656983077526, 0.014983296394348145, -0.01591481827199459, 0.01830917038023472, -0.032459087669849396, 0.003051930572837591, 0.005895957816392183, 0.055564697831869125, 0.05999111011624336, 0.047881416976451874, -0.025405077263712883, 0.020982472226023674, -0.04996456950902939, -0.011757529340684414, 0.016975758597254753, -0.01919715292751789, -0.014468199573457241, -0.04320157319307327, 0.08717749267816544, 0.004691749811172485, -0.047435104846954346, 0.023509806022047997, -0.030542680993676186, 0.04384658485651016, 0.00345383258536458, -0.07116206735372543, -0.0512024387717247, 0.042973898351192474, -0.00559147959575057, -0.006551095750182867, -0.055038273334503174, -0.003047846956178546, 0.013004494830965996, 0.04223092272877693, 0.04912315681576729, 0.03320200741291046, -0.008164141327142715, 0.02159249410033226, 0.01970512606203556, -0.0383574441075325, 0.039723385125398636, -0.0453767329454422, -0.027920424938201904, -0.018185479566454887, -0.11216709017753601, 0.012026432901620865, 0.016558868810534477, -0.023812150582671165, -0.0029566374141722918, 0.03197682276368141, 0.018711591139435768, 0.017864014953374863, -0.016647135838866234, -0.011205500923097134, -0.0448603555560112, 0.06296776235103607, -0.040753915905952454, 0.01386273093521595, -0.009209580719470978, -0.024333050474524498, 0.009987978264689445, 0.01990651711821556, 0.01804274134337902, 0.04345232993364334, -0.004341230262070894, 0.01981297694146633, -0.02837967872619629, 0.025771934539079666, 0.034143682569265366, -0.04132106900215149, 0.002404688624665141, 0.011159089393913746, -0.015926912426948547, 0.022787997499108315, 0.012605990283191204, 0.0011199836153537035, -0.029364824295043945, 0.04049907252192497, -0.01913587376475334, -0.03824448212981224, -0.07942339032888412, 0.027146756649017334, -0.001635734224691987, -0.021503441035747528, -0.016107963398098946, 0.0009012347436510026, 0.04966117814183235, 0.005785733461380005, -0.028951311483979225, -0.000848517520353198, -0.011006776243448257, 0.04756589233875275, -0.023243572562932968, -0.011668622493743896, 0.03251836821436882, 0.06027529761195183, -0.04886576905846596, 0.02667233720421791, -0.021472418680787086, -0.0521712452173233, -0.0010821602772921324, -0.03645659238100052, -0.0005994949606247246, -0.024231187999248505, -0.02033895254135132, -0.004339322447776794, 0.010427236557006836, -0.015490936115384102, 0.0661732479929924, -0.028201110661029816, 0.06955315172672272, 0.08625304698944092, 0.04260723665356636, -0.0026091134641319513, 0.00845105666667223, 0.007575661409646273, -0.0004439717158675194, -0.0358949676156044, -0.005141901317983866, -0.037159696221351624, -0.0003028138307854533, 0.06285055726766586, -0.011335218325257301, -0.035878539085388184, -0.012939904816448689, 0.05221356451511383, -0.013322407379746437, 0.008144864812493324, 0.04059586673974991, -0.00992533564567566, -0.020611468702554703, -0.02666349895298481, 0.05413265526294708, 0.02852204069495201, 0.012616047635674477, -0.009462746791541576, 0.01133482065051794, 0.04878455772995949, 0.025169527158141136, -0.012057770043611526, 0.06063748523592949, -0.015827374532818794, -0.012176211923360825, -0.014006366021931171, -0.03287433087825775, 0.03951841592788696, -0.027422193437814713, -0.005853419657796621, 0.03974287211894989, 0.013536705635488033, 0.0033916588872671127, -0.016779953613877296, -0.03220798820257187, 0.006681382656097412, 0.00921745877712965, -0.020975856110453606, 0.02128508687019348, 0.012995504774153233, -0.00865961704403162, 0.03324609622359276, -0.040774472057819366, -0.022959258407354355, -0.03428143635392189, 0.007353968918323517, -0.015401351265609264, 0.02357533574104309, 0.02046218141913414, -0.024305572733283043, -0.022246677428483963, 0.0012711257440969348, -0.018393665552139282, 0.0054565235041081905, -0.0038179056718945503, -0.05887799337506294, -0.019755063578486443, -0.003855982795357704, 0.0048441579565405846, 0.01295672357082367, -0.004534658510237932, 0.007415321189910173, 0.0589216873049736, 0.012544959783554077, -0.07441359758377075, -0.005606402177363634, 0.008968624286353588, 0.016638023778796196, -0.004997780546545982, 0.010177371092140675, 0.032208338379859924, 0.017324568703770638, -0.061520934104919434, 0.02402493543922901, -0.015243897214531898, 0.011249858886003494, -0.003941450733691454, -0.009502304717898369, 0.017102377489209175, -0.006126627326011658, -0.008094018325209618, 0.010447715409100056, -0.050740256905555725, -0.018357593566179276, -0.05598733574151993, -0.018793126568198204, 0.010768892243504524, 0.020710567012429237, 0.049552492797374725, -0.009431172162294388, -0.012130164541304111, 0.09524250030517578, 0.024938691407442093, -0.015518993139266968, -0.051972102373838425, -0.008118472062051296, -0.028163637965917587, -0.04848867282271385, 0.0117933489382267, 0.0006101049948483706, -0.056354086846113205, 0.005253144074231386, -0.0035755096469074488, -0.005795700009912252, 0.05088764429092407, 0.03895356133580208, 0.01903296262025833, -0.009160022251307964, -0.016679901629686356, -0.000015056870324769989, 0.03726159781217575, -0.008532273583114147, -0.02753261663019657, 0.015473133884370327, 0.008507604710757732, 0.025569088757038116, -0.020173635333776474, -0.04973846673965454, -0.004662864375859499, -0.032058101147413254, 0.010167502798140049, -0.029481565579771996, 0.01924201287329197, -0.00973801501095295, -0.03452896699309349, 0.003959679044783115, 0.06292447447776794, 0.012856745161116123, -0.01812433823943138, -0.025157514959573746, 0.031198719516396523, 0.03843819722533226, -0.0069018262438476086, -0.008301869034767151, -0.006281827110797167, -0.015770914033055305, 0.007382837124168873, -0.016628999263048172, -0.00839606486260891, 0.04850258305668831, 0.05898306518793106, 0.015631863847374916, 0.015112606808543205, -0.023809542879462242, 0.002962931990623474, -0.05639990419149399, 0.03064960427582264, -0.0567907877266407, 0.03329593315720558, -0.0003605155798140913, 0.04599662125110626, 0.016622193157672882, -0.01886870339512825, 0.009349897503852844, -0.016741476953029633, -0.0629318505525589, 0.061297737061977386, -0.030166886746883392, -0.03396257385611534, 0.0177789106965065, 0.00478525273501873, 0.02895115129649639, 0.023317687213420868, 0.018074823543429375, -0.00475805951282382, 0.02362307906150818, -0.011035971343517303, -0.012288946658372879, -0.010679100640118122, -0.013141704723238945, 0.007296976633369923, 0.030450139194726944, 0.00009989085083361715, -0.01840556412935257, 0.008286960422992706, -0.001626672688871622, -0.03286472707986832, -0.028152771294116974, 0.009953676722943783, 0.028554514050483704, -0.010146944783627987, 0.034606702625751495, 0.019296888262033463, 0.020979847759008408, -0.042455196380615234, 0.03437117859721184, -0.011034892871975899, 0.01760656014084816, 0.04710644856095314, 0.01055990718305111, -0.00639490969479084, -0.042890120297670364, -0.0226299986243248, 0.03775559738278389, -0.008223441429436207, -0.007426777388900518, -0.012761538848280907, 0.04492038115859032, 0.039383888244628906, -0.07482617348432541, 0.038528550416231155, 0.06662744283676147, 0.021200159564614296, -0.012957573868334293, -0.05932467430830002, 0.0248117558658123, 0.003350541228428483, -0.0070422315038740635, 0.023265600204467773, 0.010613436810672283, 0.028320863842964172, 0.011388996616005898, 0.01643681339919567, -0.02277795784175396, -0.0014801147626712918, 0.006865373812615871, 0.0203904677182436, 0.05623292177915573, -0.0050035323947668076, -0.01966543309390545, -0.010649943724274635, 0.039049237966537476, -0.005585783626884222, 0.03140972927212715, 0.002284834859892726, -0.0770827904343605, 0.015959130600094795, 0.03034602291882038, 0.05653533339500427, -0.03815234452486038, -0.004855791572481394, 0.026981599628925323, -0.013418194837868214, 0.026065435260534286, -0.044615764170885086, 0.03659961745142937, -0.02130129188299179, 0.04158114269375801, -0.0552324540913105, 0.012683426961302757, -0.032327983528375626, 0.0016634747153148055, -0.026781566441059113, 0.011586615815758705, -0.01989113539457321, -0.021158665418624878, -0.047770898789167404, 0.03267237916588783, 0.027922771871089935, 0.054137252271175385, -0.05878215655684471, -0.019241133704781532, -0.0018767715664580464, 0.009507733397185802, -0.022047102451324463, -0.06767590343952179, 0.009202300570905209, 0.00862989854067564, -0.016599906608462334, 0.032491665333509445, -0.04543743282556534, -0.038178835064172745, 0.04455699771642685, 0.014202632941305637, 0.0014604475582018495, -0.045580312609672546, -0.03707249462604523, 0.055597200989723206, -0.00009216117905452847, -0.005402280483394861, 0.06595439463853836, 0.013876622542738914, -0.012283354997634888, 0.007332233712077141, -0.027263527736067772, 0.0005398804787546396, -0.022166846320033073, -0.05801253765821457, -0.06119287386536598, -0.024425126612186432, -0.03192828968167305, 0.0484967865049839, 0.006888265255838633, 0.020878605544567108, -0.0024050737265497446, -0.0094448272138834, 0.0077522131614387035, 0.017898444086313248, 0.015454086475074291, -0.010038472712039948, -0.003376262029632926, 0.03526942431926727, -0.011902429163455963, -0.0019549180287867785, 0.007949617691338062, -0.0010093731107190251, -0.02015571855008602, 0.009690260514616966, -0.03898610547184944, -0.00029801446362398565, 0.012457155622541904, -0.049011748284101486, 0.025980470702052116, -0.03703693300485611, 0.04936150461435318, -0.01122667919844389, 0.008912090212106705, -0.013228850439190865, -0.08199083060026169, 0.009136207401752472, 0.036201514303684235, -0.04548093304038048, 0.018635937944054604, -0.016179963946342468, 0.010421310551464558, -0.021877724677324295, -0.009724607691168785, -0.033345647156238556, -0.053567931056022644, 0.040867652744054794, -0.02134571596980095, 0.010166571475565434, -0.03588986396789551, -0.05533100664615631, -0.015702005475759506, -0.027706095948815346, -0.029937883839011192, 0.05243740603327751, -0.005387345794588327, 0.007915819063782692, -0.0178296510130167, -0.0027094653341919184, 0.06327460706233978, 0.008997179567813873, -0.011812734417617321, 0.02955782786011696, -0.03538445755839348, -0.038583654910326004, -0.004819882567971945, 0.0021719138603657484, -0.0274719949811697, 0.000015290141163859516, -0.03161634877324104, 0.0063106161542236805, 0.05528038367629051, -0.0211988165974617, -0.02320193313062191, 0.011397005058825016, -0.005043849349021912, 0.016054349020123482, -0.06315360218286514, 0.0032911542803049088, -0.0008327352697961032, 0.02976010926067829, -0.058033641427755356, 0.010774056427180767, -0.024253446608781815, 0.03270425274968147, 0.02454235963523388, 0.013995281420648098, 0.02612905763089657, 0.015367054380476475, 0.04656669497489929, 0.00825706496834755, 0.026582326740026474, -0.02455381117761135, -0.01714210957288742, 0.01766192726790905, 0.01254245825111866, -0.0169545728713274, 0.008017580024898052, -0.0105813629925251, -0.02017279341816902, -0.06258496642112732, -0.034786030650138855, -0.010163083672523499, 0.015679357573390007, 0.03470263257622719, 0.034546080976724625, 0.068007692694664, -0.012215422466397285, 0.003511078655719757, 0.027769532054662704, -0.016130482777953148, -0.004507893696427345, 0.039640236645936966, 0.0540965273976326, -0.017429372295737267, 0.002075925236567855, 0.03308618813753128, 0.00447847181931138, 0.03951861336827278, 0.04016619175672531, 0.020051652565598488, 0.0400056391954422, 0.046855367720127106, -0.009224928915500641, -0.03620115667581558, 0.010553800500929356, -0.027377961203455925, 0.01281837746500969, -0.04971662163734436, -0.0040071583352983, 0.031366266310214996, 0.05256519466638565, 0.013696447014808655, -0.05189653858542442, -0.008086161687970161, -0.0711640939116478, -0.023090828210115433, 0.03690623119473457, 0.011007887311279774, 0.02101399563252926, 0.009657717309892178, 0.01883895881474018, -0.030335061252117157, 0.03770696744322777, -0.010844786651432514, -0.06774339079856873, -0.02429250255227089, -0.011630542576313019, -0.03415549173951149, 0.05447867885231972, 0.0024135145358741283, 0.0031504647340625525, 0.013590839691460133, -0.04032239317893982, -0.0017740305047482252, -0.006364415865391493, 0.01836707442998886, 0.0007675845990888774, 0.07185018062591553, -0.035757679492235184, 0.014569432474672794, 0.007047540042549372, -0.006211054977029562, 0.10198931396007538, 0.072311170399189, 0.033135127276182175, -0.08445736765861511, 0.06365078687667847, 0.01047417800873518, 0.00829482264816761, -0.015409043990075588, 0.0005643769982270896, -0.015863856300711632, -0.02368415705859661, 0.01632663607597351, 0.07995973527431488, -0.013940047472715378, 0.017986105754971504, 0.05092667415738106, 0.010510038584470749, -0.008153414353728294, 0.03422141447663307, -0.008208096958696842, -0.03105301223695278, -0.05447354167699814, -0.03226693347096443, 0.029572928324341774, 0.016822628676891327, -0.043316811323165894, -0.03911497816443443, -0.029201261699199677, -0.025835895910859108, -0.054581720381975174, -0.01967936009168625, 0.0061477175913751125, -0.0045739891938865185, 0.01670452393591404, -0.0030291115399450064, -0.03221692144870758, 0.02276887185871601, -0.01496678777039051, -0.013076897710561752, 0.05126325041055679, -0.006701954640448093, 0.021759772673249245, -0.038395609706640244, 0.0043240077793598175, -0.04968351125717163, -0.03816460818052292, -0.00440967595204711, 0.03385801985859871, 0.01810607500374317, 0.0041179652325809, -0.009062469936907291, 0.0006574610015377402, -0.028714578598737717, -0.03337926045060158, 0.00596251804381609, 0.02229570597410202, 0.03615934029221535, -0.05245914310216904, -0.03633218631148338, -0.03162436559796333, 0.011959541589021683, -0.027924323454499245, 0.022301597520709038, 0.03893280774354935, -0.0007405420765280724, -0.0022500348277390003, -0.028187425807118416, 0.0384332500398159, 0.018255989998579025, -0.0011491681216284633, 0.001948850811459124, 0.01162640005350113, -0.025326456874608994, 0.011780884116888046, 0.026574084535241127, 0.017084604129195213, 0.05424145609140396, -0.009401286020874977, 0.008737711235880852, -0.04411933571100235, -0.05027475953102112, 0.010188998654484749, -0.034179504960775375, -0.015561915934085846, -0.002335806842893362, 0.017708219587802887, 0.04276028275489807, 0.052550602704286575, 0.025402231141924858, -0.03154249116778374, -0.011989149264991283, 0.0003035927948076278, 0.021990638226270676, -0.07718585431575775, 0.01368109043687582, 0.023153431713581085, -0.050686392933130264, -0.0005024734418839216, -0.009904894977807999, 0.04883556067943573, -0.020923729985952377, 0.01462042611092329, 0.001843394711613655, 0.004585975781083107, -0.033598337322473526, -0.003394933883100748, 0.000904680578969419, -0.06097003445029259, -0.00810677744448185, -0.010162158869206905, -0.023343753069639206, -0.012049611657857895, -0.006767211947590113, -0.054525960236787796, -0.05692232772707939, 0.009748638607561588, -0.008195525966584682, -0.023883070796728134, 0.006001526489853859, -0.004655004478991032, -0.018899457529187202, -0.03672843053936958, 0.009769156575202942, -0.026424424722790718, -0.013786199502646923, -0.011688019149005413, -0.009078886359930038, -0.02372189797461033, 0.021596482023596764, -0.00886840932071209, 0.003867292543873191, 0.0421769917011261, -0.0013855599099770188, 0.017030686140060425, -0.0013907927786931396, -0.0019401561003178358, 0.010981529019773006, 0.04303451254963875, -0.016783414408564568, -0.01158276479691267, 0.054512590169906616, -0.0403347983956337, -0.021673759445548058, 0.024265673011541367, -0.022573227062821388, 0.039771292358636856, 0.052023060619831085, -0.004834019113332033, -0.014669065363705158, 0.03392753377556801, 0.015479369089007378, -0.008220532909035683, -0.005825852043926716, 0.015341932885348797, 0.028572801500558853, 0.010464731603860855, 0.027376245707273483, -0.013962802477180958, 0.0009314138442277908, 0.03721406310796738, 0.07174351066350937, -0.003451205790042877, -0.018291445448994637, 0.018306907266378403, 0.019900698214769363, 0.035223715007305145, -0.01528098713606596, -0.02053297683596611, 0.05315278097987175, 0.03418698534369469, -0.0282828900963068, 0.027565866708755493, -0.03910420089960098, 0.009938627481460571, -0.10700482130050659, -0.006299699191004038, -0.047463104128837585, 0.031868770718574524, 0.04341072961688042, -0.07561410963535309, 0.012520556338131428, 0.00841627735644579, -0.05820966139435768, -0.01561805885285139, -0.0022874807473272085, 0.02147822454571724, -0.029774371534585953, 0.014515809714794159, -0.014077674597501755, -0.0051514757797122, -0.01340576633810997, -0.00045909557957202196, 0.04240468889474869, 0.05060385540127754, 0.020151659846305847, -0.028599675744771957, -0.004596839193254709, 0.015587899833917618, 0.01452544890344143, -0.06116028502583504, 0.014846180565655231, -0.01597527042031288, -0.024725044146180153, 0.01917184144258499, -0.03024694137275219, 0.03192611783742905, 0.02666684053838253, 0.0535886213183403, -0.010867111384868622, 0.08997704833745956, 0.04818670451641083, -0.012038364075124264, -0.012033293023705482, -0.022525019943714142, 0.008584873750805855, 0.023846270516514778, 0.00019869848620146513, 0.005678233224898577, 0.03807065635919571, 0.015069982968270779, 0.009687277488410473, 0.04011574015021324, -0.017872000113129616, -0.007643815595656633, 0.0017004008404910564, -0.026531660929322243, -0.017357228323817253, -0.03691204637289047, 0.008372782729566097, -0.034789446741342545, 0.0031340878922492266, 0.05466000363230705, 0.004475300200283527, -0.020052403211593628, 0.04625167325139046, -0.005138399079442024, -0.019400862976908684, 0.012038273736834526, -0.015873927623033524, -0.018018953502178192, -0.07688064128160477, 0.03228893131017685, 0.03165388107299805, -0.013462507165968418, -0.018872344866394997, -0.014103848487138748, -0.021415168419480324, 0.031225455924868584, -0.01664743572473526, 0.02106262370944023, 0.011870925314724445, -0.03366509824991226, 0.066368468105793, -0.08197135478258133, 0.0966414287686348, -0.006693869363516569, 0.00835377350449562, -0.04600807651877403, -0.010524905286729336, -0.01147380843758583, -0.009411631152033806, 0.05945185571908951, -0.008798777125775814, -0.016923366114497185, -0.012100858613848686, 0.052779536694288254, -0.006308389361947775, -0.04379541054368019, 0.01341161411255598, -0.038508251309394836, -0.013399570249021053, -0.010567047633230686, -0.024772431701421738, 0.010062995366752148, 0.008310711942613125, 0.008963358588516712, -0.01541778352111578, 0.00962732546031475, -0.025738801807165146, -0.01351581234484911, 0.039914198219776154, 0.03244223818182945, 0.010746852494776249, 0.041478708386421204, 0.008976520970463753, 0.0009768801974132657, 0.0407940112054348, 0.021586546674370766, -0.02498713880777359, 0.021423345431685448, -0.05634396895766258, -0.021041952073574066, 0.009182208217680454, 0.00376714626327157, 0.030448446050286293, -0.060661379247903824, 0.0010843260679394007, -0.01091081090271473, -0.0018883593147620559, -0.007867792621254921, 0.03526848182082176, 0.027409689500927925, 0.016178926452994347, 0.022498276084661484, 0.00605511199682951, 0.0027831224724650383, 0.018451565876603127, -0.03472407907247543, 0.01059720665216446, 0.02003990299999714, -0.02276177518069744, -0.02782461605966091, 0.03776707127690315, -0.00833271723240614, 0.03670156002044678, -0.0059075625613331795, 0.05482851713895798, -0.01668410189449787, -0.020397767424583435, 0.029704710468649864, -0.012791270390152931, 0.05596362054347992, 0.0025064568035304546, -0.03139640763401985, 0.06540629267692566, -0.04444175586104393, 0.03379744663834572, -0.01144313719123602, -0.017588777467608452, -0.024159008637070656, -0.006501671392470598, -0.0021337454672902822, 0.026789680123329163, 0.0032791101839393377, 0.02356497384607792, 0.01605445332825184, -0.023046443238854408, 0.03220472112298012, -0.032237011939287186, 0.05097265541553497, -0.0051023708656430244, 0.01024593785405159, -0.053023263812065125, -0.0361180417239666, -0.02212534286081791, -0.05298936367034912, 0.014750024303793907, 0.004853816702961922, 0.04090113192796707, -0.03257027640938759, -0.03537122532725334, 0.02350376546382904, 0.04414302855730057, -0.048174574971199036, -0.018762575462460518, -0.03849261254072189, 0.016822537407279015, -0.017244936898350716, -0.006099672056734562 ]
<p>What is the distribution of the following monomial? $$X^a \cdot Y^b$$ where $X$ and $Y$ are normal random variables and $a$ and $b$ are natural numbers.</p> <p>For example, when $X \sim N(0,1)$, $a=2$, and $b=0$ it is a Chi-squared distribution, which has a variance of 2.</p> <p>What if we have $n$ independent variables $X_1, X_2, \dots , X_n$, with $X_i \sim N(0,\sigma^2)$ and some natural numbers $p_1, p_2, \dots,p_n$. What can we say about the variance of the following r.v.?</p> <p>$$X_1^{p_1} \cdot X_2^{p_2} \cdots X_n^{p_n}$$</p>
74,021
[ -0.05181879177689552, -0.0030520004220306873, 0.02444043941795826, -0.02944348379969597, 0.04472017660737038, 0.013219970278441906, -0.009299803525209427, -0.02212826907634735, 0.015825530514121056, -0.04584932699799538, 0.06697673350572586, 0.016545072197914124, 0.05147117003798485, 0.04567505791783333, 0.023105032742023468, -0.007238283287733793, -0.03364402800798416, -0.013408967293798923, -0.0005216453573666513, 0.013379753567278385, 0.021055392920970917, 0.00747635867446661, 0.013993494212627411, -0.001838505151681602, -0.046659208834171295, 0.017349541187286377, -0.020422421395778656, -0.02174057438969612, 0.018188344314694405, 0.08612129092216492, -0.05563908442854881, 0.0007893724832683802, 0.037715137004852295, 0.03454984351992607, -0.017722511664032936, -0.0032690910156816244, -0.02918524295091629, -0.04833119362592697, 0.004044754430651665, -0.004901616368442774, -0.04490883648395538, -0.0436626560986042, 0.003415047889575362, -0.009459380991756916, -0.014539848081767559, 0.005739840213209391, -0.028788305819034576, -0.0478704497218132, 0.02755218930542469, -0.04507150873541832, 0.10891532897949219, 0.02184257283806801, 0.04035757854580879, 0.006136228330433369, -0.034996818751096725, -0.02237640880048275, 0.020206263288855553, 0.0433662012219429, -0.00416338536888361, -0.07464532554149628, -0.009087679907679558, -0.02213291823863983, -0.0034413475077599287, -0.04057248309254646, -0.057067617774009705, 0.014900660142302513, 0.010554744862020016, -0.008412144146859646, 0.010234416462481022, -0.011934760957956314, 0.02251509763300419, 0.06086070090532303, 0.027306392788887024, -0.02556922473013401, 0.0039030893240123987, -0.002103733830153942, 0.051853910088539124, -0.015088331885635853, 0.03865385055541992, 0.020790956914424896, 0.009701663628220558, 0.027889207005500793, -0.0041541364043951035, -0.004839670844376087, 0.005354114342480898, -0.001375376945361495, 0.06260719895362854, 0.0027757156640291214, 0.011646952480077744, -0.00692626042291522, -0.004375141113996506, -0.005296156741678715, 0.0565662644803524, -0.02485804818570614, -0.07537626475095749, 0.06033369526267052, -0.028757328167557716, 0.021721551194787025, 0.01960090547800064, -0.05465497821569443, -0.011983766220510006, -0.017642010003328323, 0.04504392668604851, 0.07508592307567596, -0.03542410209774971, -0.021856272593140602, -0.01505556795746088, 0.01798631064593792, -0.025449445471167564, -0.03008204512298107, -0.008244071155786514, 0.037782929837703705, 0.006250506266951561, 0.003893720917403698, 0.016444841399788857, -0.014995882287621498, 0.00710969977080822, -0.01714826002717018, 0.05430009961128235, 0.07840592414140701, 0.043388091027736664, -0.02143053337931633, 0.05441220849752426, -0.016957754269242287, -0.027146833017468452, 0.027715494856238365, 0.01407251600176096, 0.012123086489737034, -0.08191265165805817, 0.03293558955192566, 0.0008986852481029928, 0.009196712635457516, 0.02934584580361843, 0.004324825946241617, 0.010333736427128315, -0.014055275358259678, -0.11168693006038666, -0.04868857190012932, 0.00587594136595726, -0.017963988706469536, -0.02129506878554821, -0.07018105685710907, 0.022943953052163124, 0.07531607151031494, 0.056492794305086136, -0.028103630989789963, 0.054304733872413635, 0.011934168636798859, 0.046642549335956573, 0.02502366714179516, -0.02763504721224308, -0.004564220085740089, 0.006914271041750908, -0.05052131041884422, 0.011213704012334347, -0.05752456188201904, 0.02348814159631729, 0.0345633402466774, 0.0018261412624269724, -0.032457731664180756, 0.013851570896804333, 0.009981085546314716, 0.00213999068364501, -0.01860397309064865, 0.020877137780189514, -0.021517962217330933, 0.07638757675886154, 0.012364482507109642, 0.06153218448162079, 0.021356945857405663, -0.01595398597419262, 0.00869054440408945, 0.0033743777312338352, 0.058545663952827454, 0.04686180502176285, -0.002007708651944995, 0.0014666797360405326, -0.004626411944627762, 0.027961036190390587, 0.04267007112503052, -0.07461103796958923, 0.0013601044192910194, -0.016491597518324852, 0.002485359087586403, -0.008866168558597565, 0.027633169665932655, 0.005825791973620653, -0.01223201584070921, 0.018440909683704376, -0.05560775101184845, -0.02642030455172062, -0.06514281034469604, 0.01577671803534031, -0.014245369471609592, -0.01975589245557785, 0.026074301451444626, 0.032478392124176025, 0.014513086527585983, -0.00915030762553215, -0.008076821453869343, -0.020387116819620132, -0.00517464941367507, 0.03871473670005798, -0.0338699035346508, 0.004550629761070013, 0.04912063106894493, 0.02682293951511383, -0.0025576206389814615, 0.043052226305007935, -0.010151543654501438, -0.040850866585969925, -0.004511749837547541, -0.05151056498289108, 0.020578322932124138, -0.0011872703908011317, 0.017412854358553886, 0.01065065711736679, -0.016152841970324516, -0.013777866028249264, 0.03141952306032181, -0.05108517408370972, 0.018082905560731888, 0.049528080970048904, 0.035426102578639984, 0.0008039698586799204, -0.01825037971138954, 0.011138166300952435, 0.014940288849174976, 0.005439734552055597, -0.01765860803425312, -0.04008316248655319, 0.01050490327179432, 0.009870527312159538, 0.05098002031445503, -0.03176164627075195, 0.03204214200377464, 0.022532666102051735, 0.030608411878347397, 0.028210096061229706, 0.00737692229449749, -0.01390731893479824, -0.004142832010984421, 0.0009947228245437145, 0.014963825233280659, 0.02100830338895321, 0.027282096445560455, -0.0021834124345332384, -0.01782476156949997, 0.011124776676297188, 0.019312366843223572, -0.03307536244392395, 0.04446198046207428, -0.034868571907281876, 0.010431205853819847, -0.03843151032924652, -0.02221018634736538, 0.033356353640556335, 0.000808871875051409, 0.021403586491942406, 0.03187407925724983, 0.009203760884702206, -0.006663316395133734, 0.01644827239215374, -0.011624488048255444, 0.013002107851207256, 0.015099556185305119, -0.04695354402065277, -0.02531631849706173, 0.019221486523747444, -0.011993707157671452, 0.001375844469293952, -0.028779076412320137, -0.03898157179355621, -0.03011968731880188, 0.00282511068508029, -0.011049536988139153, -0.0068887281231582165, 0.030685700476169586, 0.0013523808447644114, -0.03464281186461449, -0.002574935555458069, -0.007190869189798832, 0.011930080130696297, -0.017494430765509605, -0.06705955415964127, -0.025916455313563347, -0.0076141818426549435, 0.019838396459817886, 0.026717673987150192, -0.015386831015348434, 0.008936328813433647, 0.04307660460472107, -0.002477570902556181, -0.03201651945710182, -0.016987144947052002, 0.01346578635275364, -0.01241040788590908, -0.035217076539993286, -0.022724086418747902, -0.008695154450833797, -0.030248304829001427, -0.029950149357318878, 0.0589713491499424, -0.04921748489141464, -0.04834733158349991, -0.016923578456044197, 0.01127257663756609, 0.04198133572936058, -0.03851763904094696, 0.033761199563741684, 0.029124902561306953, -0.0003532450064085424, 0.0037257052026689053, -0.0714842826128006, -0.04974578320980072, -0.0014409159775823355, -0.04055801406502724, 0.022662989795207977, -0.005928898695856333, -0.038180094212293625, 0.0815105065703392, 0.030754337087273598, -0.013268126174807549, -0.010479044169187546, -0.0057588135823607445, -0.027244040742516518, -0.06498118489980698, 0.04394567757844925, 0.027384808287024498, -0.012299749068915844, 0.04610788822174072, 0.02425156906247139, 0.008728456683456898, 0.03491244465112686, -0.02049454115331173, -0.030652327463030815, 0.008442258462309837, 0.020648425444960594, -0.013378963805735111, 0.0514589287340641, -0.01267759595066309, 0.0034288372844457626, 0.017278773710131645, 0.02227192558348179, 0.022379402071237564, -0.01073745358735323, -0.019690250977873802, 0.034568507224321365, -0.05066549405455589, 0.02208481915295124, -0.03278221935033798, 0.0664186030626297, 0.024195432662963867, -0.03326164931058884, -0.011556616052985191, 0.014928480610251427, -0.009607961401343346, -0.03894844651222229, 0.030230704694986343, 0.05331280454993248, 0.07446037977933884, -0.010402828454971313, -0.03835580125451088, -0.02115795947611332, 0.028401536867022514, 0.03787070885300636, -0.02538967691361904, -0.001179295708425343, 0.023476801812648773, 0.034076008945703506, 0.01581626385450363, -0.027409883216023445, -0.013028455898165703, 0.0077304719015955925, -0.019479090347886086, 0.030735908076167107, -0.05107545107603073, 0.037487879395484924, 0.012148579582571983, 0.08096634596586227, -0.0196865051984787, -0.006441500037908554, -0.008625859394669533, -0.0177360437810421, -0.04466177150607109, 0.010091648437082767, -0.03124842420220375, -0.010506976395845413, 0.002411833731457591, -0.014042648486793041, 0.05484967678785324, 0.02762581594288349, 0.013316546566784382, 0.006230639759451151, 0.0041223010048270226, -0.018294399604201317, -0.002272329293191433, -0.03994765877723694, -0.04607713222503662, -0.018398631364107132, 0.028434252366423607, -0.024743052199482918, -0.0023132096976041794, 0.04492519050836563, 0.015645336359739304, -0.01309942826628685, 0.003850317560136318, -0.0206033606082201, -0.009048879146575928, -0.014336801134049892, 0.022153666242957115, -0.0015312317991629243, 0.01406822632998228, -0.016934091225266457, 0.03266346827149391, -0.0025216196663677692, 0.04853776842355728, 0.03918216750025749, 0.0298396497964859, 0.03875650465488434, -0.0284234918653965, -0.019019795581698418, -0.010209552012383938, 0.0038172241766005754, 0.008264383301138878, -0.011758578009903431, 0.07364222407341003, 0.01894574984908104, -0.012979809194803238, 0.012061024084687233, 0.03252599015831947, 0.004457687493413687, 0.003057686146348715, 0.011192097328603268, -0.002176109701395035, -0.009001979604363441, -0.006605309899896383, -0.02126304991543293, -0.019406720995903015, -0.004968305584043264, -0.001809004694223404, 0.051987096667289734, 0.01781170256435871, -0.04733425751328468, -0.007319444790482521, 0.03171662241220474, 0.005388110410422087, 0.002311403164640069, -0.032030265778303146, 0.012108289636671543, 0.039179544895887375, 0.027273494750261307, 0.024379603564739227, -0.012334074825048447, -0.06125325709581375, 0.01691904105246067, -0.0034740138798952103, 0.03150126710534096, -0.007267430424690247, -0.020468594506382942, -0.012209981679916382, 0.010865278542041779, 0.0076512680388987064, -0.020641906186938286, 0.049156200140714645, -0.013009941205382347, 0.013597645796835423, -0.0020686842035502195, 0.012667627073824406, -0.06193225085735321, 0.022251944988965988, 0.00005304644218995236, 0.049385443329811096, -0.021113859489560127, -0.007976148277521133, -0.0411653108894825, 0.02375946007668972, 0.02523943781852722, 0.06402859836816788, -0.010732391849160194, 0.002848176984116435, 0.011606981046497822, 0.03924448415637016, -0.009820437990128994, -0.05423181131482124, 0.04991161450743675, 0.03445008024573326, -0.038990508764982224, 0.07610064744949341, -0.0278742928057909, -0.058668579906225204, -0.007865630090236664, -0.0170420054346323, -0.007006498984992504, 0.05920993536710739, 0.006777308415621519, 0.033943161368370056, 0.04408492147922516, 0.04382604733109474, 0.0685223713517189, 0.017204556614160538, -0.013581272214651108, -0.042769577354192734, -0.039383355528116226, 0.03822940215468407, 0.008878808468580246, -0.018930913880467415, -0.02987259440124035, -0.021646076813340187, -0.01761932112276554, 0.06364753842353821, -0.027829285711050034, 0.03139546886086464, -0.019414765760302544, -0.006909032817929983, -0.009339764714241028, 0.03415738418698311, 0.016455477103590965, -0.010432395152747631, 0.024309471249580383, 0.0168097373098135, 0.026901064440608025, -0.01763133890926838, 0.026356985792517662, 0.003474157303571701, 0.027078721672296524, -0.004342101980000734, -0.026786595582962036, 0.023491621017456055, -0.029961340129375458, -0.024959394708275795, -0.007767252624034882, -0.0073535810224711895, 0.055317699909210205, 0.014943764545023441, 0.0330800786614418, 0.015717117115855217, -0.061787962913513184, -0.021892651915550232, 0.029710937291383743, -0.0005892675835639238, 0.038649726659059525, -0.040119003504514694, 0.0024996167048811913, -0.008585279807448387, 0.0021230189595371485, -0.0695638433098793, -0.04250356927514076, -0.00733837578445673, 0.008180188946425915, 0.012895790860056877, -0.0018395611550658941, -0.004339390899986029, 0.02140512689948082, -0.04374222829937935, -0.014633314684033394, 0.04017211124300957, -0.020267924293875694, -0.02202392742037773, -0.004851422272622585, 0.010489843785762787, 0.07990171760320663, 0.012921624816954136, -0.047473397105932236, 0.021545518189668655, -0.017106033861637115, -0.007900157943367958, 0.022593917325139046, 0.00991645734757185, -0.024085329845547676, 0.00535191223025322, 0.018462805077433586, -0.019627660512924194, 0.05623815208673477, -0.05031440407037735, -0.045851971954107285, 0.005817328114062548, 0.005866604391485453, -0.008740709163248539, -0.023598801344633102, -0.018947288393974304, 0.010882474482059479, 0.016420267522335052, -0.01900704950094223, -0.04403086379170418, -0.036934442818164825, 0.003036790294572711, 0.020570499822497368, 0.00644295709207654, 0.006271997466683388, 0.022723549976944923, 0.0558963418006897, -0.0031186104752123356, -0.005742473527789116, -0.015092900022864342, -0.0010496237082406878, 0.03821071609854698, 0.03364640101790428, -0.011957126669585705, 0.014189399778842926, 0.02969585731625557, -0.006208907347172499, -0.008715370669960976, -0.020532066002488136, 0.017264077439904213, 0.05958839878439903, -0.010856008157134056, 0.01671283133327961, 0.05737930163741112, 0.014971289783716202, -0.00962353590875864, -0.026805207133293152, -0.008432915434241295, -0.026776134967803955, 0.041650425642728806, 0.0034969712141901255, -0.03402562811970711, 0.0034776837565004826, 0.05134957283735275, 0.023605169728398323, 0.007471759803593159, 0.020848920568823814, 0.028077760711312294, -0.0069862836971879005, 0.03355196863412857, -0.016011184081435204, -0.030536742880940437, 0.04207652062177658, -0.04084548354148865, 0.02531510405242443, -0.014736051671206951, -0.002612531650811434, 0.05006083473563194, 0.009194119833409786, 0.029662884771823883, -0.031419817358255386, -0.0317184254527092, -0.011366927064955235, -0.037806253880262375, 0.019669493660330772, 0.0013880777405574918, 0.007339763920754194, -0.02541239559650421, 0.020352547988295555, -0.028028180822730064, 0.05648962780833244, -0.006798853632062674, -0.10640574991703033, -0.03686497360467911, 0.012580635026097298, -0.039782702922821045, 0.037773896008729935, 0.015855953097343445, -0.033123161643743515, 0.0075843860395252705, -0.044422708451747894, 0.039615146815776825, 0.0019074755255132914, 0.028689298778772354, -0.017182257026433945, 0.06440207362174988, -0.004453527741134167, 0.01754060946404934, 0.00007241147250169888, -0.0018792505143210292, 0.09459571540355682, 0.04459112137556076, 0.03165807947516441, -0.06085173785686493, 0.0008147034677676857, -0.045099496841430664, -0.012848173268139362, -0.012060947716236115, -0.03530709818005562, 0.006069500464946032, 0.0028473420534282923, 0.03598420321941376, 0.04446609318256378, 0.00028493357240222394, -0.010187449865043163, 0.02209019660949707, -0.02744287997484207, -0.07028113305568695, -0.0036495975218713284, 0.01884211041033268, -0.0030073884408921003, 0.0018276292830705643, -0.05111570656299591, 0.007236789911985397, -0.0003671151353046298, -0.016743820160627365, -0.033977657556533813, -0.013223489746451378, 0.008122020401060581, -0.013647067360579967, -0.0263796616345644, -0.0008806251571513712, 0.07220775634050369, -0.018366612493991852, -0.007483163382858038, -0.026737572625279427, 0.008910119533538818, -0.030329495668411255, -0.0011768152471631765, 0.059247326105833054, 0.0005456307553686202, 0.013074657879769802, 0.06498200446367264, 0.009593195281922817, -0.05392144247889519, -0.045832064002752304, -0.02847452647984028, 0.03371183201670647, -0.021266093477606773, 0.010461783036589622, -0.04332464560866356, -0.008681192062795162, -0.02658768929541111, -0.004817032255232334, 0.001261438592337072, 0.03345894441008568, 0.015750683844089508, -0.04695756360888481, -0.028583144769072533, -0.007573397364467382, 0.010548229329288006, -0.015666842460632324, 0.03625670075416565, -0.0027117885183542967, -0.055440373718738556, -0.015546146780252457, -0.007588828913867474, 0.058132603764534, -0.048981670290231705, 0.004360970575362444, -0.047319892793893814, -0.054509952664375305, -0.010312206111848354, -0.003917656373232603, -0.011065936647355556, -0.013751285150647163, 0.03709784522652626, 0.020831609144806862, -0.00830482691526413, -0.01070478092879057, -0.027533357962965965, 0.003426474519073963, -0.03261931240558624, 0.018971282988786697, -0.02805384434759617, -0.006715681403875351, 0.03125463426113129, 0.008486653678119183, 0.00022206595167517662, -0.027272364124655724, 0.0025275966618210077, 0.06502798944711685, 0.03893473744392395, -0.03538930043578148, -0.006997980643063784, 0.035025838762521744, -0.02564895711839199, -0.03156119957566261, -0.0160842165350914, 0.0436941497027874, 0.05646830424666405, 0.02094772644340992, -0.007250238209962845, 0.045704618096351624, -0.018253864720463753, 0.012737651355564594, 0.04911525174975395, -0.07012693583965302, 0.012510628439486027, 0.02500154823064804, 0.0026505065616220236, -0.018363159149885178, -0.02768547646701336, -0.005868444684892893, -0.04478911682963371, 0.006238522008061409, -0.02317660115659237, -0.04770808294415474, -0.053648799657821655, -0.03250971809029579, 0.01780962385237217, -0.016134310513734818, -0.004925569519400597, 0.00551031157374382, 0.03472432866692543, 0.016343506053090096, -0.007834803313016891, -0.018023112788796425, 0.019498828798532486, -0.023291945457458496, -0.00841936469078064, 0.04178192839026451, 0.02131427638232708, 0.040567461401224136, -0.020564673468470573, -0.029095705598592758, 0.008592350408434868, 0.050276823341846466, -0.039619579911231995, -0.011239849030971527, 0.056119054555892944, -0.05028904229402542, -0.0035660085268318653, 0.03393875062465668, 0.015960946679115295, 0.050137925893068314, -0.008530699647963047, -0.022914346307516098, -0.014012875035405159, 0.019720735028386116, -0.032776668667793274, -0.003157145343720913, -0.02871263027191162, -0.015647534281015396, 0.009958243928849697, -0.04169280454516411, 0.011405994184315205, 0.012030286714434624, -0.0170864537358284, 0.027133112773299217, 0.060697972774505615, -0.015131398104131222, -0.003751282347366214, 0.019793368875980377, 0.007541586644947529, -0.012363352812826633, -0.01735677197575569, 0.0038277371786534786, 0.013180258683860302, 0.048393137753009796, -0.0490981824696064, 0.03857068717479706, -0.023457733914256096, 0.007071526721119881, -0.08967513591051102, -0.041151758283376694, 0.029858911409974098, 0.005001866724342108, 0.04848232865333557, -0.05277079716324806, -0.005472417920827866, 0.03287346661090851, -0.078037329018116, 0.033354002982378006, 0.0013432177947834134, -0.042419902980327606, -0.03850200027227402, 0.02414698339998722, -0.007263417821377516, 0.0658496618270874, -0.016650481149554253, 0.021319260820746422, 0.028000997379422188, 0.002659380668774247, -0.017277691513299942, -0.029677601531147957, 0.008515396155416965, -0.0016763856401666999, 0.008620166219770908, -0.05673597753047943, 0.036885444074869156, -0.012069067917764187, -0.02579515241086483, 0.029542967677116394, -0.028829781338572502, 0.03565596416592598, 0.03933730721473694, 0.015501148998737335, -0.0005034422501921654, 0.04756338521838188, 0.006261406000703573, 0.011389951221644878, -0.018557842820882797, 0.015609619207680225, 0.0527646467089653, 0.041539065539836884, -0.040285464376211166, -0.004320642910897732, 0.043936144560575485, 0.0006670510047115386, -0.006070851348340511, 0.029116850346326828, -0.010672378353774548, -0.024661673232913017, -0.02722637727856636, -0.03548175096511841, -0.0130712129175663, -0.019949832931160927, 0.05826569348573685, -0.040168583393096924, -0.019877249374985695, 0.01589316315948963, 0.0472000353038311, -0.009728403761982918, 0.02444702759385109, 0.015761610120534897, -0.044102732092142105, 0.02518729865550995, 0.0022167337592691183, 0.0038788970559835434, -0.028450453653931618, -0.02141890488564968, -0.012784542515873909, 0.02494126185774803, 0.016891803592443466, -0.034525856375694275, -0.029783183708786964, 0.008408873341977596, 0.01820613071322441, 0.007562263403087854, 0.015269067138433456, -0.024916740134358406, -0.004077955149114132, -0.06524846702814102, 0.03680716082453728, 0.03274737671017647, 0.00212534936144948, -0.04351360350847244, 0.03418780118227005, -0.04564369469881058, -0.025933578610420227, 0.04244621843099594, 0.03118746541440487, 0.025029761716723442, -0.005260717123746872, 0.06699112802743912, 0.00481311185285449, -0.036072488874197006, -0.009764903225004673, -0.02401966229081154, -0.038675177842378616, -0.0409541092813015, -0.002395726041868329, 0.03187095373868942, -0.010412200354039669, 0.025451531633734703, -0.014563383534550667, -0.012617049738764763, -0.007114325650036335, -0.024637743830680847, 0.021042615175247192, -0.0436001680791378, -0.04498260095715523, 0.026634762063622475, -0.004327939357608557, -0.027224618941545486, 0.01313798688352108, -0.00021238098270259798, -0.049213189631700516, 0.02334761805832386, -0.03491106629371643, -0.03003842569887638, -0.017912790179252625, 0.01682904176414013, 0.016651488840579987, -0.06716342270374298, 0.006191509775817394, 0.011291872709989548, -0.03065427392721176, -0.030794326215982437, 0.039881739765405655, 0.039012618362903595, 0.016211846843361855, 0.025020254775881767, -0.007786999456584454, -0.007259579841047525, -0.035747651010751724, 0.019968125969171524, 0.017907019704580307, 0.005398651584982872, -0.03231427073478699, 0.012179167941212654, 0.01970120705664158, -0.03377256542444229, 0.03564555570483208, 0.014185544103384018, 0.04610537365078926, -0.021591195836663246, -0.009457416832447052, 0.03663976490497589, -0.0195064228028059, 0.029313506558537483, -0.008428771048784256, -0.036837607622146606, 0.10427454113960266, -0.005356960464268923, 0.015259438194334507, -0.040769267827272415, -0.004227612633258104, -0.005467399023473263, -0.05376670882105827, 0.008865347132086754, 0.04034959524869919, -0.0008180058212019503, -0.004973899573087692, -0.035970330238342285, -0.016406329348683357, 0.025228753685951233, -0.021781127899885178, 0.01686667650938034, -0.024203328415751457, -0.0015476512489840388, -0.017013568431138992, -0.07202678173780441, -0.015436790883541107, -0.03706297278404236, 0.071686290204525, 0.04991455003619194, 0.03980015218257904, -0.008612802252173424, -0.013507449068129063, 0.012912987731397152, 0.06106501445174217, -0.02988619916141033, -0.018077563494443893, -0.05556102469563484, 0.03082461841404438, 0.012677651830017567, -0.004879273474216461 ]
<p>When studying time series, I once heard the statement that</p> <blockquote> <p>unit root test is less powerful.</p> </blockquote> <p>I hereby have two questions:</p> <ol> <li>What does it mean for a test to be powerful?</li> <li>What causes the unit root test to be less powerful?</li> </ol>
36,642
[ -0.012686391361057758, -0.026275375857949257, -0.001767727080732584, -0.022113071754574776, 0.05316649377346039, 0.01700783707201481, -0.023794744163751602, -0.040014371275901794, 0.025687629356980324, -0.0038383451756089926, 0.04248455911874771, 0.027157898992300034, 0.04188012704253197, -0.004260283429175615, 0.003974032122641802, 0.021793711930513382, -0.016570713371038437, 0.032651420682668686, -0.012399274855852127, -0.0063350871205329895, -0.021194448694586754, 0.026858733966946602, 0.018162939697504044, 0.005346996709704399, -0.0033701506908982992, 0.029932033270597458, 0.015377016738057137, 0.03407195955514908, 0.003663352457806468, 0.07612154632806778, -0.02017214335501194, -0.015331683680415154, 0.02110009267926216, 0.026508640497922897, 0.0011540316045284271, -0.015059385448694229, -0.0051305824890732765, -0.0016826478531584144, -0.016292110085487366, 0.055195435881614685, -0.03411275893449783, -0.03808992728590965, 0.008546216413378716, 0.019942590966820717, -0.03161853551864624, 0.046219877898693085, -0.014327040873467922, -0.016877146437764168, 0.006422931328415871, -0.041320424526929855, 0.0350174754858017, 0.005715703126043081, 0.02734256163239479, 0.02588619664311409, -0.00744438823312521, -0.022655770182609558, 0.06128464266657829, 0.04278692975640297, -0.067685566842556, -0.049046579748392105, -0.004360199440270662, -0.01072912011295557, 0.022160863503813744, -0.02902589738368988, -0.03394215926527977, 0.048402089625597, -0.009777015075087547, 0.009689293801784515, 0.041742950677871704, -0.026904135942459106, 0.030676662921905518, 0.023435188457369804, 0.0041471486911177635, 0.017274290323257446, -0.018011407926678658, -0.011966882273554802, -0.0020476800855249166, 0.03244917839765549, 0.07301337271928787, 0.06492356210947037, 0.0149065051227808, 0.04353296756744385, 0.04369727522134781, 0.026963431388139725, 0.05727245286107063, -0.014802366495132446, 0.06670776754617691, -0.0018995138816535473, -0.010294590145349503, 0.02695028856396675, -0.0029830976855009794, -0.02182677946984768, 0.03125897794961929, -0.003728594398126006, -0.03436018526554108, 0.006309564225375652, -0.0323629193007946, 0.02312902733683586, 0.011920292861759663, 0.004767068196088076, -0.013330289162695408, -0.04074833542108536, 0.03590131178498268, 0.02256249450147152, -0.005936375353485346, -0.0014254804700613022, -0.004752327222377062, -0.031581684947013855, -0.02040562406182289, -0.037868957966566086, -0.030642839148640633, 0.0225625392049551, -0.01090115588158369, -0.01085756253451109, 0.019901234656572342, 0.031297601759433746, -0.015992451459169388, -0.03282565250992775, 0.05682290717959404, 0.020902104675769806, 0.03969070687890053, -0.01613982580602169, -0.0008075407822616398, -0.023976527154445648, -0.03248196840286255, 0.03410133719444275, -0.010564112104475498, -0.013821647502481937, -0.04442911222577095, 0.06347698718309402, 0.0036947354674339294, -0.04267759621143341, 0.003489566734060645, -0.013470815494656563, 0.07768049836158752, 0.00779353640973568, -0.10514514148235321, -0.059536416083574295, 0.0915226861834526, 0.010642084293067455, -0.0006689756992273033, -0.0690772607922554, 0.025519708171486855, 0.004395161755383015, 0.054429471492767334, 0.005101475398987532, 0.056466951966285706, 0.03150990977883339, 0.00401989696547389, 0.03216591104865074, -0.020364752039313316, -0.03449084609746933, -0.01408039964735508, -0.016278164461255074, 0.00800313614308834, -0.06371321529150009, -0.0016043124487623572, 0.01822829805314541, -0.042929764837026596, -0.012807765044271946, 0.043810393661260605, 0.025701357051730156, -0.02097509428858757, 0.0163740161806345, -0.016309218481183052, -0.034404657781124115, 0.06835823506116867, 0.005581421311944723, 0.02704244665801525, 0.037997785955667496, -0.001276585040614009, 0.027238547801971436, 0.04453391209244728, 0.02756534330546856, 0.013931657187640667, -0.024646766483783722, -0.003610894549638033, -0.015320571139454842, -0.004081158433109522, -0.00039987234049476683, -0.05582530051469803, -0.02774178236722946, -0.009388729929924011, -0.017001988366246223, 0.020512748509645462, 0.07662313431501389, -0.0029594446532428265, -0.02668858878314495, 0.011013570241630077, -0.057050202041864395, -0.06732238829135895, -0.06784790754318237, 0.04002441465854645, 0.016523173078894615, -0.009547362104058266, 0.011721229180693626, -0.005740834400057793, 0.05125853046774864, -0.005671760533004999, -0.014465777203440666, -0.027917329221963882, 0.036801353096961975, 0.0027407612651586533, -0.02015269547700882, 0.044287387281656265, 0.028730224817991257, 0.047097355127334595, -0.0070015243254601955, 0.0014178443234413862, 0.007309816312044859, -0.051499441266059875, 0.02401072159409523, -0.0506698340177536, 0.0009557713638059795, -0.015294287353754044, -0.04355820268392563, 0.037896737456321716, -0.02173350192606449, -0.02537628449499607, 0.0750683918595314, -0.04534192755818367, 0.033194731920957565, 0.021216776221990585, 0.004912033211439848, 0.02312329225242138, 0.010772681795060635, 0.02099716104567051, -0.015561679378151894, -0.022013623267412186, 0.009336586110293865, -0.07929467409849167, 0.01570015214383602, 0.030101140961050987, 0.05050721392035484, -0.030010489746928215, 0.014900431036949158, 0.0729084387421608, 0.013499725610017776, -0.00708682369440794, 0.03830089420080185, 0.009794638492166996, -0.005210878327488899, 0.0022068405523896217, 0.003836939809843898, -0.001488643465563655, 0.011602208018302917, 0.03355839103460312, 0.014931819401681423, 0.024914663285017014, -0.0003832028596661985, -0.018456539139151573, 0.041781287640333176, 0.0016098871128633618, 0.00532478466629982, 0.006167776882648468, -0.0029672207310795784, -0.004255733452737331, -0.049915604293346405, -0.002758017275482416, 0.003994589205831289, 0.004611514043062925, 0.021612605080008507, -0.01355232298374176, -0.010738476179540157, 0.04205736517906189, 0.005292705725878477, -0.01300390437245369, -0.019793136045336723, 0.041950520128011703, -0.03630503639578819, 0.008359950967133045, -0.031012875959277153, -0.014608686789870262, -0.04309185966849327, 0.0011459079105407, 0.027954669669270515, 0.0032598809339106083, 0.028756912797689438, -0.003571116831153631, -0.02824852056801319, 0.0005282440106384456, -0.04329793155193329, -0.0013829718809574842, -0.0018911627121269703, -0.015089625492691994, 0.0078039951622486115, -0.010828300379216671, 0.00013571187446359545, 0.04391748830676079, -0.03277156874537468, 0.025798266753554344, 0.028612421825528145, 0.003062993520870805, -0.05533209815621376, -0.048057761043310165, -0.027986925095319748, 0.021448805928230286, -0.040432173758745193, -0.03663717955350876, 0.046942129731178284, -0.024909788742661476, -0.024690188467502594, 0.014244874007999897, -0.020000390708446503, -0.029006294906139374, -0.04608803614974022, -0.0015902456361800432, 0.0182390995323658, -0.04058605059981346, -0.003958895802497864, 0.00039065052988007665, -0.0662546381354332, -0.02496911585330963, -0.039675939828157425, -0.034919630736112595, 0.020258942618966103, -0.016460904851555824, 0.044127002358436584, -0.01099066250026226, -0.048005640506744385, 0.05055798962712288, 0.028794772922992706, -0.011494960635900497, -0.03371886909008026, -0.02903539128601551, -0.03326243534684181, -0.03883500024676323, 0.011647208593785763, 0.02465413697063923, 0.0045622000470757484, 0.0018138051964342594, 0.00028643867699429393, 0.02343362383544445, 0.04246807098388672, 0.03027447871863842, 0.0006817391840741038, -0.025509292259812355, -0.02672027051448822, -0.011818473227322102, 0.014166557230055332, 0.03181740269064903, -0.024463150650262833, 0.01620149426162243, 0.021185101941227913, 0.029990212991833687, 0.021345051005482674, -0.026843927800655365, 0.03800260275602341, -0.0058091250248253345, 0.02894485369324684, -0.058310989290475845, 0.03737024590373039, 0.013273979537189007, 0.0013923655496910214, -0.028498215600848198, 0.003909154329448938, -0.02782623842358589, 0.018958915024995804, -0.011085494421422482, 0.008386541157960892, 0.056012969464063644, -0.025548500940203667, -0.02321140468120575, -0.05068816989660263, -0.009489054791629314, 0.014631631784141064, 0.0013743326999247074, -0.025295013561844826, 0.034276291728019714, 0.04177252948284149, 0.025335092097520828, -0.014417771250009537, -0.026155121624469757, -0.03485260158777237, -0.03993586078286171, 0.006673980969935656, -0.02795274369418621, 0.07622840255498886, 0.0018040022114291787, 0.042319174855947495, 0.020016297698020935, 0.001752505893819034, 0.011649906635284424, -0.031013479456305504, -0.057813405990600586, 0.017598820850253105, -0.024727459996938705, -0.025757424533367157, 0.027261730283498764, -0.03153302147984505, 0.0068946825340390205, -0.035636864602565765, 0.014807038009166718, -0.02767888270318508, 0.028666339814662933, -0.030571233481168747, 0.03195203095674515, 0.022079959511756897, 0.004161111079156399, -0.01190230529755354, 0.0133131705224514, 0.029631420969963074, -0.002691600238904357, 0.039946768432855606, 0.05725954845547676, -0.012377561070024967, -0.00888072233647108, -0.00117028271779418, 0.00032859790371730924, 0.04256674274802208, 0.03756885603070259, 0.028432093560695648, 0.014907971024513245, -0.041313499212265015, 0.03516344353556633, 0.04839140549302101, 0.046110983937978745, 0.012239432893693447, -0.027179386466741562, -0.05524146929383278, -0.048846837133169174, -0.01675821654498577, 0.049738138914108276, 0.030547240749001503, 0.018702955916523933, -0.021032284945249557, 0.028608152642846107, 0.01766398549079895, -0.015261579304933548, 0.022670678794384003, 0.05409276485443115, 0.005503458436578512, 0.022899525240063667, -0.025193823501467705, -0.040334515273571014, -0.019167965278029442, -0.01303899846971035, 0.030145864933729172, -0.01713147759437561, -0.014353363774716854, -0.03217955306172371, 0.04749308153986931, -0.018266290426254272, -0.034376729279756546, -0.016464857384562492, 0.010665541514754295, 0.056964367628097534, 0.02474099211394787, -0.023967834189534187, 0.017940707504749298, 0.040928978472948074, 0.0080541567876935, 0.0439177080988884, 0.005136840045452118, -0.07392379641532898, 0.014439430087804794, 0.04617123678326607, 0.00723124947398901, -0.039669498801231384, -0.038275327533483505, -0.010487298481166363, -0.0034524814691394567, 0.034887757152318954, -0.05313482508063316, 0.04781803861260414, -0.03043266385793686, 0.012010767124593258, -0.0682341456413269, -0.02971484139561653, -0.0153675377368927, 0.03997111693024635, 0.01757057197391987, 0.032596733421087265, -0.00905954372137785, -0.02208264358341694, -0.028943432494997978, 0.005443040281534195, -0.010965503752231598, 0.04979686439037323, -0.03695353865623474, -0.012520468793809414, 0.0017069365130737424, 0.04971149191260338, -0.021869750693440437, -0.07824226468801498, 0.0008940520929172635, -0.02455599047243595, 0.006799288559705019, 0.02348320744931698, -0.01725679449737072, -0.0800672098994255, 0.01682906597852707, -0.02262217178940773, -0.004709718748927116, 0.0023533806670457125, -0.0359409935772419, 0.007658661808818579, 0.024983013048768044, 0.017297210171818733, 0.053903352469205856, 0.02350139245390892, 0.022844644263386726, 0.026267504319548607, 0.005424262955784798, 0.0010781718883663416, -0.0641239807009697, 0.0033654363360255957, -0.009484090842306614, 0.0021915938705205917, -0.046502310782670975, 0.043954044580459595, 0.034216370433568954, 0.03606325387954712, -0.04051881283521652, 0.02222132869064808, -0.019145721569657326, -0.0002989281783811748, 0.013885319232940674, -0.0233564805239439, -0.012115257792174816, 0.02079482562839985, -0.037220630794763565, -0.002713242545723915, 0.025554979220032692, 0.0007125750416889787, 0.003498736536130309, 0.016206806525588036, 0.002018104773014784, 0.02540585771203041, 0.0021559109445661306, -0.008259590715169907, 0.011776999570429325, -0.008915282785892487, 0.04317708685994148, -0.026332495734095573, -0.011405850760638714, 0.020327873528003693, -0.05387813597917557, -0.0017300592735409737, 0.026448136195540428, 0.006016704719513655, 0.05049537867307663, -0.03257875517010689, 0.03677336499094963, 0.01361726876348257, -0.016788294538855553, -0.06660553067922592, -0.039633430540561676, 0.014662052504718304, 0.007562069222331047, -0.001153139746747911, 0.004485012497752905, 0.009710254147648811, -0.0018371578771620989, -0.003117915475741029, -0.06876076012849808, 0.06556615978479385, 0.01401386596262455, -0.018373554572463036, -0.0018045707838609815, 0.006039927247911692, 0.091232068836689, -0.022515105083584785, -0.024052582681179047, 0.011171515099704266, -0.018861930817365646, -0.03321433439850807, -0.023124800994992256, 0.0502396784722805, -0.01778724417090416, -0.02174163982272148, -0.011019888333976269, -0.04448844492435455, 0.03401031717658043, -0.003954057116061449, -0.014606993645429611, 0.031365469098091125, -0.02275436371564865, -0.015260027721524239, -0.003866552608087659, 0.0289864931255579, -0.004580374341458082, 0.038821540772914886, 0.00209504715166986, 0.0013178623048588634, -0.033786386251449585, -0.04330574721097946, 0.010777367278933525, 0.025268355384469032, -0.03182501345872879, 0.01220162957906723, 0.04506451636552811, -0.04493255540728569, 0.015564980916678905, -0.026793409138917923, -0.010021187365055084, 0.03434150665998459, 0.017581308260560036, 0.020203646272420883, 0.005711715668439865, 0.01692517288029194, -0.06354982405900955, 0.00010562383249634877, 0.00978175736963749, -0.004475558176636696, 0.050338950008153915, 0.004922264255583286, 0.056170959025621414, 0.036456767469644547, -0.013122656382620335, 0.026109997183084488, -0.019496789202094078, -0.0032094649504870176, 0.006378924008458853, 0.010963736101984978, 0.020064545795321465, -0.013545122928917408, -0.0029407325200736523, 0.03694804385304451, -0.0017745493678376079, 0.03493213281035423, 0.011369843035936356, 0.023609809577465057, 0.027353152632713318, -0.011884651146829128, -0.021091032773256302, -0.01853576861321926, 0.039301395416259766, -0.037763405591249466, 0.007470331154763699, -0.037415605038404465, 0.03783721476793289, 0.048525333404541016, 0.012995554134249687, -0.03184504806995392, -0.03984122723340988, -0.014766966924071312, -0.07703965902328491, -0.015665879473090172, 0.01858183927834034, -0.014754332602024078, 0.016103949397802353, 0.013760782778263092, 0.030603302642703056, 0.0195490512996912, 0.02376684546470642, -0.01195420604199171, -0.05266173556447029, -0.029258741065859795, -0.023315347731113434, -0.022498343139886856, 0.04703450947999954, -0.0164778009057045, -0.04650788754224777, 0.04308700934052467, -0.06140286847949028, -0.011267304420471191, 0.0069949873723089695, 0.004958559293299913, -0.053574711084365845, 0.07577057182788849, 0.027503762394189835, 0.012882937677204609, 0.023645441979169846, -0.00714681064710021, 0.10420198738574982, 0.04428863525390625, 0.007225917186588049, -0.07182711362838745, 0.007804547902196646, -0.017641158774495125, 0.018711645156145096, -0.04304959997534752, 0.01165567897260189, -0.005847982596606016, 0.02127295546233654, 0.04251508414745331, 0.06730397790670395, -0.020428292453289032, 0.004007676616311073, 0.038183704018592834, -0.04512520134449005, 0.011526362970471382, 0.02148035168647766, 0.020726023241877556, 0.006198081187903881, -0.009152188897132874, -0.045379284769296646, -0.013334183022379875, -0.01411574985831976, -0.02642204426229, 0.016888011246919632, -0.013924376107752323, -0.002180666895583272, -0.022230571135878563, -0.045438334345817566, 0.013214915990829468, 0.04896420240402222, 0.026933640241622925, -0.0709037035703659, -0.017956819385290146, 0.0035749890375882387, -0.027677763253450394, 0.015008022077381611, 0.042578477412462234, -0.014146251603960991, -0.037214163690805435, 0.003265791805461049, 0.02181856334209442, -0.038563378155231476, -0.004929163958877325, -0.032677460461854935, 0.0259831752628088, 0.02437864989042282, 0.005854750517755747, -0.03241269290447235, 0.034731391817331314, -0.020519979298114777, -0.042420875281095505, -0.025264400988817215, 0.009214497171342373, 0.03181103616952896, -0.06232231855392456, -0.05776820331811905, -0.045578744262456894, 0.0072303656488657, -0.014748585410416126, 0.052566226571798325, -0.0023474337067455053, -0.039932508021593094, 0.013753380626440048, 0.00625563831999898, 0.0375872440636158, -0.006342804059386253, 0.006912711076438427, 0.018482426181435585, -0.0017134399386122823, -0.031615547835826874, 0.014726748690009117, 0.0363423191010952, -0.023987261578440666, 0.03212538734078407, 0.01723799668252468, 0.02279258705675602, -0.042481377720832825, -0.0443490706384182, 0.043663617223501205, -0.0363757349550724, -0.003208124777302146, -0.06050106883049011, 0.0026505030691623688, 0.0357021801173687, 0.02015627548098564, 0.03555567190051079, 0.022600598633289337, -0.013692686334252357, 0.01965206302702427, 0.055014364421367645, -0.061114367097616196, -0.010008583776652813, 0.0046012685634195805, -0.012729416601359844, -0.027841590344905853, -0.0177779458463192, 0.037084631621837616, 0.0481051504611969, 0.0020844030659645796, -0.02484869956970215, 0.01701696217060089, -0.03301119804382324, -0.00920672807842493, 0.028357598930597305, -0.04124519228935242, -0.046878986060619354, 0.044158704578876495, 0.00638002622872591, -0.030894340947270393, -0.03409956768155098, -0.041388146579265594, -0.0035191988572478294, 0.014484526589512825, 0.0012473514070734382, -0.021526606753468513, 0.008575395680963993, 0.0021526245400309563, 0.05039733648300171, -0.07046757638454437, 0.004318644758313894, -0.0498456135392189, -0.015338679775595665, 0.011712084524333477, -0.05871047452092171, 0.00043065749923698604, 0.02354178950190544, -0.013077886775135994, -0.007605717517435551, 0.05307776853442192, 0.016579406335949898, -0.0020975403022021055, -0.00514264078810811, 0.005002651829272509, -0.007645804900676012, 0.03661191090941429, -0.029689298942685127, -0.036641623824834824, 0.06568491458892822, -0.016324473544955254, -0.029659703373908997, 0.03447902575135231, -0.024816501885652542, 0.037871912121772766, 0.005588133353739977, 0.017185041680932045, -0.03443599119782448, -0.004640304017812014, -0.018522165715694427, 0.020084120333194733, -0.02018575556576252, -0.007865591906011105, -0.00660516694188118, 0.028948163613677025, -0.002720191143453121, -0.0011136984685435891, -0.016821380704641342, 0.052355386316776276, 0.04277318716049194, -0.009071935899555683, 0.017128344625234604, -0.0025568732526153326, -0.004264564253389835, 0.025585604831576347, 0.01710968278348446, -0.014802028425037861, 0.048441555351018906, 0.036241162568330765, -0.027794653549790382, -0.009534061886370182, -0.026939131319522858, 0.005034545436501503, -0.09750239551067352, -0.0073178852908313274, -0.020034432411193848, -0.017849929630756378, 0.046715736389160156, -0.0264839269220829, -0.00047718561836518347, 0.014760935679078102, -0.062163520604372025, 0.027815314009785652, -0.029785284772515297, -0.011819692328572273, -0.043519649654626846, -0.03610052168369293, -0.014751977287232876, 0.056799206882715225, 0.04333518445491791, 0.016621094197034836, 0.002322429558262229, 0.07428276538848877, 0.0328887403011322, -0.017747139558196068, -0.006528384517878294, 0.011288478970527649, -0.019486885517835617, -0.022380024194717407, 0.03779052570462227, -0.029467759653925896, 0.00029032406746409833, 0.01984432339668274, -0.04197708144783974, 0.03523065894842148, 0.006638051476329565, 0.030926121398806572, 0.00809185765683651, 0.026389582082629204, 0.04151130095124245, -0.038744520395994186, -0.05234229564666748, -0.003191604046151042, -0.00760736083611846, 0.02104252204298973, 0.009153041057288647, -0.02908669225871563, 0.000606230110861361, -0.022640792652964592, -0.0067573171108961105, -0.023079948499798775, 0.0025543400552123785, 0.0036967997439205647, 0.019258229061961174, -0.007128395605832338, 0.007622078061103821, 0.01043115183711052, 0.008689973503351212, -0.019955798983573914, 0.020371807739138603, 0.06692487746477127, 0.022662056609988213, -0.04217496141791344, -0.00018015869136434048, 0.003880585776641965, -0.007463793270289898, 0.04534698650240898, 0.01580853760242462, 0.011495738290250301, -0.0665661171078682, -0.0030506891198456287, 0.041549619287252426, -0.03175441548228264, -0.040466293692588806, -0.001246492494828999, -0.017338307574391365, 0.044459979981184006, 0.03465722128748894, -0.018760446459054947, 0.02936476655304432, -0.05271520838141441, -0.010753355920314789, -0.11891376227140427, 0.08108916133642197, -0.0011274542193859816, -0.015841763466596603, -0.031081173568964005, -0.015992192551493645, -0.03388334438204765, -0.014211727306246758, 0.0707637295126915, 0.002896260004490614, 0.02529072016477585, 0.008996795862913132, 0.007258867844939232, 0.006811186205595732, -0.022811787202954292, 0.026368845254182816, -0.027936682105064392, -0.009059340693056583, -0.019182205200195312, -0.02727590501308441, 0.009607065469026566, 0.013132070191204548, 0.016566455364227295, -0.016661962494254112, 0.0073644802905619144, -0.005685153882950544, 0.03379830718040466, 0.06522206217050552, 0.02082865871489048, -0.010768293403089046, 0.06472115218639374, 0.01533957663923502, 0.03323746845126152, -0.0032345245126634836, 0.008082360960543156, -0.07090345025062561, 0.01569674350321293, -0.01146387867629528, -0.006480544805526733, -0.011711370199918747, 0.03598388284444809, -0.006601162254810333, -0.01822965033352375, -0.0376804880797863, 0.03212060034275055, -0.047620996832847595, 0.030685825273394585, 0.024173475801944733, 0.025916580110788345, 0.03273959085345268, -0.012340948916971684, 0.024873508140444756, -0.009679438546299934, 0.015401924028992653, -0.010105370543897152, 0.025572439655661583, 0.034675806760787964, -0.02086164802312851, -0.0035948529839515686, 0.018859578296542168, -0.026201574131846428, 0.015585490502417088, -0.012918980792164803, 0.07525493949651718, -0.03192298486828804, -0.0453953854739666, -0.005094049498438835, -0.036940447986125946, 0.022019578143954277, 0.020494751632213593, -0.002493036212399602, 0.07984301447868347, -0.022806918248534203, -0.002190404338762164, -0.0025404265616089106, -0.032534293830394745, -0.02272140048444271, 0.016191886737942696, 0.04146772250533104, -0.009074985980987549, -0.019509626552462578, -0.004166462458670139, -0.006693679373711348, -0.02053506299853325, 0.018395233899354935, -0.00827021524310112, 0.001543873455375433, 0.015349590219557285, -0.01948346197605133, -0.03549855947494507, 0.003995375707745552, -0.0346713550388813, -0.010287517681717873, 0.036081280559301376, 0.019286079332232475, 0.03572741150856018, -0.004029777366667986, -0.04057111591100693, 0.029502402991056442, 0.03651392087340355, -0.0954384058713913, -0.0064735691994428635, -0.03840241581201553, 0.039989691227674484, 0.0004179723036941141, -0.0565795861184597 ]
<p>My lecturer just covered the <strong>Lindberg-Levy central limit theorem</strong> and the multivariate version, the <strong>Lindberg-fuller CLT</strong>. I understood the basic concept and I can derive it, etc. But it would help my understanding a lot if someone could explain how all this used in real life applications of <strong>econometric</strong> analysis?</p> <p>Ive read some claims that the CLT is nice only on a piece of paper.</p> <p>Some really cool industry applications or references would be appreciated.</p>
74,022
[ 0.005748308729380369, -0.018395690247416496, 0.033186402171850204, -0.02483201213181019, 0.043077412992715836, 0.01096387393772602, 0.018522756174206734, -0.01871352456510067, 0.011152669787406921, -0.0386577770113945, 0.02448413148522377, 0.045419398695230484, 0.03888266533613205, 0.011501799337565899, 0.03145171329379082, -0.013721199706196785, -0.0039035906083881855, -0.00546490540727973, -0.010762368328869343, -0.02356412634253502, 0.021231234073638916, 0.00820995680987835, 0.02161570079624653, -0.02874511294066906, -0.014188424684107304, 0.03675534203648567, 0.0011912938207387924, -0.0070682368241250515, 0.024440107867121696, 0.058462340384721756, -0.04903070256114006, -0.014250624924898148, -0.014693239703774452, 0.059210482984781265, -0.020367557182908058, 0.013201992958784103, -0.026861894875764847, -0.04538453370332718, 0.03831637278199196, 0.028933538123965263, -0.04622180014848709, -0.017488284036517143, 0.017749471589922905, 0.05003295838832855, 0.006649593356996775, -0.01433526910841465, -0.0025734466034919024, -0.07812785357236862, 0.05902756005525589, -0.06191948428750038, 0.06719585508108139, -0.006907939445227385, 0.006580232176929712, 0.01664746180176735, -0.015153016895055771, -0.008857090026140213, 0.04920520260930061, 0.04296823590993881, 0.0036236911546438932, -0.04124017059803009, -0.005284078419208527, 0.033169448375701904, -0.008348328061401844, -0.001440955325961113, -0.027584152296185493, 0.011055278591811657, 0.000547556031960994, -0.042613279074430466, 0.02706342190504074, -0.01718127354979515, 0.030420975759625435, 0.003400245448574424, 0.03824751451611519, -0.008543934673070908, -0.006523486692458391, 0.006163198966532946, 0.02039489336311817, 0.02701800875365734, 0.030610980466008186, 0.031630996614694595, 0.005261067766696215, 0.05194239318370819, -0.000686118844896555, 0.06142984330654144, 0.005051957909017801, -0.017403574660420418, 0.10028069466352463, -0.034608375281095505, 0.029449360445141792, -0.0029409802518785, -0.0022976708132773638, -0.028685307130217552, 0.04398506134748459, 0.018697263672947884, -0.06851105391979218, 0.03750479593873024, -0.006418986711651087, 0.011647514067590237, -0.002156972885131836, 0.013411260209977627, -0.01728738285601139, -0.025682223960757256, -0.00663426099345088, 0.044605553150177, -0.0062060607597231865, -0.04973607882857323, 0.00387108838185668, 0.006893814541399479, -0.014604460448026657, -0.01672038622200489, -0.0419171079993248, -0.011812002398073673, 0.036294035613536835, -0.026104707270860672, 0.004906516522169113, 0.031641583889722824, -0.012921499088406563, 0.011888286098837852, 0.0399341806769371, 0.06516443938016891, 0.04787761718034744, -0.013904914259910583, 0.012380200438201427, 0.015461132861673832, -0.05548530071973801, 0.040865711867809296, -0.012360475026071072, -0.02024490013718605, -0.056680675595998764, 0.08471561968326569, -0.008504658937454224, -0.007750956807285547, 0.012949971482157707, 0.019816182553768158, 0.05338098853826523, -0.008796206675469875, -0.11975519359111786, -0.04965654015541077, 0.07013937085866928, 0.015024286694824696, -0.010778091847896576, -0.037097688764333725, 0.01949934847652912, 0.035740926861763, 0.0647917240858078, 0.0009613186120986938, 0.039721887558698654, -0.026859136298298836, 0.023148609325289726, 0.02707619033753872, -0.04353000968694687, -0.029404835775494576, 0.020519517362117767, -0.028802208602428436, -0.006143190432339907, -0.1037384495139122, -0.012269995175302029, 0.03589130938053131, -0.03844590112566948, -0.05837314575910568, 0.037495192140340805, 0.004084425047039986, -0.048692312091588974, -0.03880401700735092, 0.005860971752554178, -0.04818008095026016, 0.057502057403326035, 0.0005602446035481989, -0.0006485129706561565, 0.005248596426099539, 0.013700456358492374, 0.028035884723067284, -0.01030147448182106, 0.05145559832453728, 0.03642099350690842, -0.007963192649185658, 0.02267996221780777, 0.01253955252468586, 0.01142407301813364, 0.02334240823984146, -0.041978150606155396, 0.007682336028665304, -0.023871375247836113, -0.016994794830679893, 0.009938927367329597, 0.05816153809428215, -0.0038080874364823103, -0.008114500902593136, 0.01195942796766758, -0.050259631127119064, -0.03511160984635353, -0.06610828638076782, 0.01329730823636055, -0.027546031400561333, -0.03447417542338371, 0.04923104867339134, 0.006900802254676819, 0.005152213852852583, -0.011201858520507812, -0.025002961978316307, -0.01686902716755867, -0.01322875265032053, 0.030210785567760468, -0.011261025443673134, 0.004447530955076218, 0.019330240786075592, 0.014862208627164364, 0.007105384953320026, -0.0005912943161092699, -0.04953668639063835, -0.029889890924096107, -0.0031300601549446583, -0.029181139543652534, 0.023101327940821648, -0.007958509959280491, -0.02484693005681038, 0.011879567056894302, -0.026063695549964905, -0.008459271863102913, 0.058797262609004974, -0.03880475088953972, 0.0479358471930027, 0.06080402806401253, -0.0037036132998764515, -0.017159296199679375, 0.04985739663243294, 0.0024405012372881174, -0.003921453841030598, 0.023345855996012688, -0.013437973335385323, -0.056776925921440125, 0.002797238063067198, 0.022371044382452965, 0.04783633351325989, -0.031145509332418442, 0.006263893563300371, 0.07215603440999985, 0.029512057080864906, 0.004101909697055817, 0.03274621069431305, -0.03346706181764603, -0.006289721000939608, 0.01588280498981476, -0.01570056565105915, 0.02544422447681427, -0.01891244202852249, 0.019512709230184555, 0.0059357513673603535, 0.0439981147646904, -0.005172806791961193, -0.041992511600255966, 0.03139006346464157, 0.01127768587321043, -0.027734141796827316, -0.024952251464128494, 0.00044697101111523807, 0.042766325175762177, -0.03663747385144234, 0.018706470727920532, 0.01904909498989582, -0.0015476207481697202, -0.005672242026776075, -0.032868411391973495, -0.039812762290239334, 0.009053638204932213, 0.005611729342490435, -0.03297001123428345, 0.04775935411453247, 0.024103661999106407, -0.054912302643060684, 0.008154013194143772, -0.01906069554388523, -0.021190917119383812, -0.016405407339334488, 0.02137088030576706, 0.04288158193230629, 0.015816550701856613, -0.005806670989841223, -0.014499743469059467, -0.0740402489900589, -0.029390908777713776, 0.0005766585236415267, 0.01515187881886959, -0.02325858362019062, -0.03576907142996788, 0.040456391870975494, -0.006518361158668995, -0.025863297283649445, 0.05088719725608826, -0.009587809443473816, 0.01953907497227192, 0.05150362476706505, -0.01584787108004093, -0.06960928440093994, -0.007193733472377062, 0.03737253323197365, 0.008066531270742416, -0.02752618119120598, -0.0427946038544178, 0.06547009199857712, -0.01346105057746172, 0.005029169376939535, 0.015472669154405594, -0.027890266850590706, -0.04175107181072235, -0.04271005839109421, -0.02579985372722149, -0.000548370648175478, -0.015224209055304527, 0.024569999426603317, -0.00015782073023729026, -0.02689441479742527, -0.011830760166049004, -0.06243226304650307, -0.049436647444963455, 0.0028603458777070045, -0.03484892472624779, 0.022835051640868187, -0.009552440606057644, -0.01875804364681244, 0.045363329350948334, 0.023897938430309296, -0.028312092646956444, -0.04765363782644272, 0.00260926759801805, -0.04267654940485954, 0.0041524870321154594, 0.0018836506642401218, 0.01622639410197735, -0.02829257771372795, 0.03581343963742256, 0.017037227749824524, 0.014666259288787842, 0.05006355792284012, 0.012934559024870396, -0.016793787479400635, 0.004025112371891737, -0.04072793945670128, 0.016631009057164192, 0.03076702356338501, 0.02034641243517399, -0.03907325118780136, 0.019921651110053062, -0.004374626558274031, -0.009768202900886536, 0.03182682767510414, -0.026171913370490074, 0.03394912928342819, 0.011219066567718983, -0.03264058381319046, -0.030025003477931023, -0.003844453487545252, 0.009169871918857098, -0.014728836715221405, -0.01567426137626171, 0.023115376010537148, 0.026050034910440445, -0.017715269699692726, 0.00529731810092926, 0.03137233480811119, 0.016636189073324203, -0.0009896483970806003, -0.03242822736501694, -0.014363255351781845, -0.006857921835035086, 0.013685286045074463, -0.0408201664686203, -0.021671444177627563, 0.015136460773646832, 0.0630117654800415, 0.012510827742516994, -0.029751472175121307, -0.041716866195201874, -0.006193678360432386, -0.04453268647193909, 0.004253203049302101, -0.0006524674245156348, 0.0398506261408329, 0.014262346550822258, 0.08967119455337524, -0.017157167196273804, 0.008184914477169514, 0.06689318269491196, -0.003688788041472435, -0.0667378231883049, 0.028358953073620796, -0.004805970937013626, -0.00396335031837225, -0.003947569988667965, 0.001992906676605344, 0.04011768102645874, -0.013436466455459595, -0.012124240398406982, -0.05581316724419594, 0.01940998062491417, -0.033514298498630524, -0.000553218531422317, -0.014876455068588257, -0.02841692417860031, -0.03146514296531677, -0.012781132012605667, 0.0131137166172266, 0.0016823456389829516, -0.002049746224656701, 0.05714757740497589, -0.05281584709882736, -0.029918255284428596, -0.005548444110900164, -0.02243196777999401, 0.01732291840016842, 0.043274641036987305, 0.026018116623163223, 0.019506612792611122, -0.048133499920368195, 0.047296956181526184, 0.04274876415729523, 0.0520266517996788, 0.03895377740263939, 0.0023448995780199766, 0.0041168564930558205, -0.057784583419561386, -0.022605115547776222, 0.0045510162599384785, -0.004664526786655188, 0.04591433331370354, 0.008875716477632523, 0.06362538039684296, 0.031091172248125076, -0.05024160444736481, -0.006837528198957443, 0.05500572919845581, 0.0013036936288699508, 0.004678487312048674, -0.003020958276465535, -0.02489454671740532, -0.004175703972578049, 0.004263090435415506, 0.04720824584364891, 0.01912790536880493, -0.025690957903862, 0.017019953578710556, 0.025576552376151085, 0.03431958705186844, -0.03755924850702286, -0.005501279141753912, 0.0009666283149272203, 0.01989988051354885, -0.0065255179069936275, -0.014884840697050095, -0.0008595296530984342, 0.03303041309118271, 0.020176908001303673, 0.052442945539951324, 0.014076889492571354, -0.08099707961082458, 0.03668069839477539, 0.02054300531744957, 0.025451531633734703, -0.04926037788391113, 0.015462337993085384, -0.030782796442508698, -0.021240942180156708, 0.02483566291630268, -0.029157232493162155, 0.029353903606534004, 0.0001303197641391307, 0.010130508802831173, -0.03517235070466995, 0.013561253435909748, 0.004900818224996328, 0.003568435087800026, -0.01829027570784092, 0.022203942760825157, -0.026198653504252434, -0.0021318900398910046, -0.047472815960645676, 0.0471380390226841, 0.03645240515470505, 0.05305739864706993, -0.016107728704810143, -0.063815638422966, -0.015075555071234703, 0.027219930663704872, -0.02006474696099758, -0.04544517770409584, -0.015402993187308311, 0.0025400875601917505, 0.006716631352901459, 0.060723062604665756, -0.025452090427279472, -0.03781728819012642, 0.0013160076923668385, 0.0026041315868496895, -0.04630845785140991, -0.0005288440734148026, -0.0036004723515361547, 0.007577103562653065, -0.003120161360129714, 0.00986676849424839, 0.04984140023589134, 0.03297726437449455, -0.02002527005970478, 0.006795049179345369, -0.002138525014743209, 0.030407831072807312, -0.018366796895861626, 0.016373764723539352, -0.016622846946120262, -0.022818489000201225, -0.029790127649903297, 0.005168008618056774, 0.0022320880088955164, 0.041129644960165024, -0.012478549033403397, -0.0038211855571717024, 0.002605969784781337, 0.044254276901483536, 0.004421991761773825, 0.010266873985528946, -0.032153334468603134, -0.0015716010238975286, -0.004788635298609734, -0.016466153785586357, 0.00020785116066690534, 0.005038323812186718, -0.010166122578084469, 0.016508493572473526, 0.010638809762895107, -0.01705937460064888, -0.021140621975064278, -0.006728790700435638, 0.028919024392962456, -0.009472045116126537, 0.046071089804172516, -0.000006658289748884272, 0.013841749168932438, 0.03341997042298317, -0.034970369189977646, -0.009053494781255722, 0.04771491140127182, -0.011875048279762268, 0.07876774668693542, -0.05381610244512558, 0.010236946865916252, -0.03252497315406799, -0.013009024783968925, -0.043363556265830994, -0.03954073041677475, 0.01608378067612648, 0.019723879173398018, -0.0014745427761226892, -0.043601274490356445, -0.0139913409948349, 0.022479064762592316, -0.027071865275502205, -0.014712690375745296, 0.04337795451283455, 0.01183159090578556, -0.02816321887075901, -0.022958427667617798, -0.024283837527036667, 0.0980382040143013, -0.012052712962031364, -0.011613426730036736, 0.03282780572772026, -0.012958895415067673, -0.01846536621451378, -0.023781003430485725, 0.018039073795080185, -0.027339978143572807, -0.016545021906495094, -0.0037761307321488857, 0.02488870359957218, -0.02145504765212536, -0.01717136986553669, -0.024793433025479317, 0.010668482631444931, 0.025018876418471336, -0.015919774770736694, -0.023056892678141594, -0.02394021488726139, -0.012138184159994125, 0.008829062804579735, -0.016896186396479607, 0.01919827051460743, -0.02474326640367508, -0.04243380203843117, 0.02164589986205101, 0.01144090574234724, 0.0028195769991725683, 0.04694294184446335, 0.0016000572359189391, 0.007624214515089989, -0.011887500993907452, 0.0018437171820551157, 0.0011578842531889677, 0.029754826799035072, -0.027662932872772217, 0.013294493779540062, -0.0012860283022746444, 0.028584666550159454, -0.037846267223358154, -0.05712740868330002, -0.025160977616906166, 0.019506419077515602, 0.051153071224689484, -0.020460572093725204, 0.050979502499103546, 0.043177004903554916, -0.024201728403568268, -0.03307243809103966, -0.01816348172724247, -0.03708766773343086, -0.0067178658209741116, -0.04877449944615364, 0.0373891219496727, 0.012750676833093166, -0.003691486781463027, 0.03337860479950905, 0.030643794685602188, -0.004022526554763317, 0.013583053834736347, 0.0065199630334973335, 0.038536615669727325, 0.0020056194625794888, 0.023092113435268402, -0.022966664284467697, 0.08493117243051529, -0.04650499299168587, 0.011698071844875813, -0.025025369599461555, -0.008920811116695404, 0.019707661122083664, 0.027666481211781502, -0.006618631072342396, -0.045033764094114304, -0.021982960402965546, -0.03274109587073326, 0.030338754877448082, 0.009645871818065643, -0.029470395296812057, 0.027023877948522568, -0.006700147874653339, 0.051744502037763596, 0.0138151990249753, 0.027541400864720345, -0.002512476872652769, -0.03534379601478577, -0.037776537239551544, -0.0048956298269331455, -0.01197610329836607, 0.019880669191479683, 0.01613590680062771, -0.02399488352239132, 0.0270842332392931, -0.0318143367767334, 0.01844439096748829, 0.01144495327025652, 0.03464260324835777, 0.005353196524083614, 0.07887747883796692, -0.014008249156177044, -0.005238787736743689, -0.024007190018892288, -0.016835147514939308, 0.11615375429391861, 0.04108801484107971, -0.01006404496729374, -0.07689788192510605, -0.008969494141638279, 0.002429029904305935, -0.0035985198337584734, -0.051983896642923355, -0.013040551915764809, -0.0031125331297516823, 0.044388603419065475, 0.0395280122756958, 0.032267991453409195, -0.003974403254687786, 0.008245112374424934, 0.0357656292617321, -0.01646238937973976, -0.03632066398859024, 0.020256061106920242, 0.016785932704806328, 0.0017948538297787309, 0.00982568971812725, -0.06811132282018661, 0.011054512113332748, -0.041205503046512604, -0.030297737568616867, -0.005629633087664843, -0.027804717421531677, 0.046800896525382996, -0.006800275761634111, -0.0031546272803097963, 0.02077614888548851, 0.05142681673169136, -0.0009980169124901295, -0.004780609626322985, -0.010351976379752159, 0.023385681211948395, -0.005645898170769215, 0.00045412289910018444, 0.030482228845357895, 0.016213389113545418, -0.013942440040409565, -0.014028578996658325, 0.032803092151880264, -0.01854129135608673, -0.02831784076988697, -0.024273861199617386, 0.019474109634757042, -0.007110717706382275, -0.0009706523269414902, -0.04058801382780075, 0.018608057871460915, 0.016525879502296448, 0.011700274422764778, -0.01149032637476921, 0.004105171654373407, 0.050387170165777206, -0.04089858755469322, -0.013168021105229855, -0.07282809168100357, -0.011767313815653324, -0.0036778035573661327, 0.014230581931769848, 0.0036609701346606016, -0.017351841554045677, 0.008165599778294563, -0.07065887004137039, 0.037781503051519394, -0.017529230564832687, -0.019969360902905464, -0.03839930519461632, 0.006597263738512993, -0.028279654681682587, 0.012821399606764317, 0.014272612519562244, -0.003256948897615075, 0.03572699800133705, -0.001623254269361496, -0.006378644611686468, -0.025832736864686012, -0.02830662950873375, 0.010055938735604286, -0.05188606679439545, -0.030897492542862892, -0.03376525267958641, -0.015214174054563046, 0.029926477000117302, 0.05117684230208397, 0.0253493320196867, -0.001717485603876412, -0.03122103027999401, 0.009925286285579205, 0.01418344583362341, -0.05394819751381874, -0.0022412047255784273, -0.039634820073843, -0.006777132861316204, -0.02001122757792473, -0.025125088170170784, 0.04073008894920349, 0.04301903024315834, -0.0024105552583932877, -0.0041704629547894, 0.006496400572359562, -0.03727050498127937, 0.006814717315137386, 0.05017812177538872, -0.06707767397165298, -0.00858808122575283, 0.041293688118457794, 0.018135813996195793, -0.019976677373051643, -0.01937057077884674, -0.03417763486504555, -0.015575677156448364, -0.014316709712147713, -0.003118261694908142, -0.03076828271150589, -0.00008069172326941043, 0.014901881106197834, 0.06741053611040115, -0.02280978299677372, 0.035912077873945236, -0.04610084742307663, 0.011840004473924637, -0.00020814315939787775, -0.019581831991672516, -0.0009234462631866336, -0.026139449328184128, 0.014172912575304508, 0.008671050891280174, 0.04006402939558029, 0.03426237031817436, 0.029513100162148476, -0.008706822991371155, 0.016661303117871284, -0.012427245266735554, 0.004663405474275351, -0.02729492262005806, -0.03566468879580498, 0.05558684840798378, -0.040294405072927475, -0.050599467009305954, -0.0016469573602080345, -0.02775975503027439, 0.027994902804493904, 0.017688220366835594, 0.026131045073270798, -0.03322569653391838, 0.016781562939286232, 0.0012792255729436874, -0.014029404148459435, 0.00041656833491288126, -0.009992755949497223, 0.012628168798983097, 0.024540456011891365, 0.02216840721666813, 0.014630207791924477, -0.0010458143660798669, 0.03688211739063263, 0.0429847314953804, 0.039344049990177155, 0.018472731113433838, 0.03610307350754738, -0.014518698677420616, -0.02549816109240055, -0.002844370435923338, -0.008457338437438011, 0.09059451520442963, 0.053939733654260635, -0.034998416900634766, 0.01720467396080494, -0.0020578494295477867, 0.02484327368438244, -0.09557406604290009, 0.004203387536108494, -0.0009691239101812243, -0.053233806043863297, 0.03244160860776901, -0.0012184327933937311, 0.010245302692055702, 0.016826892271637917, -0.03204430639743805, 0.005913906265050173, -0.05501975864171982, -0.020944703370332718, -0.0457354411482811, 0.006887777708470821, -0.0368599072098732, 0.033654578030109406, 0.010525123216211796, 0.008615007624030113, 0.05497012287378311, 0.06560832262039185, 0.04607565701007843, 0.01058177836239338, -0.02802404947578907, 0.03018752858042717, 0.03790665045380592, -0.02362627163529396, 0.06057747080922127, -0.0036667173262685537, -0.032086871564388275, 0.04256051033735275, -0.03522379696369171, -0.018204621970653534, -0.001412624609656632, -0.004212855827063322, 0.0033396498765796423, 0.06885045766830444, 0.04397287592291832, 0.00006359758117469028, -0.015775756910443306, 0.027929864823818207, 0.07763109356164932, 0.0007427830714732409, 0.0007387521327473223, 0.01559010986238718, 0.037918753921985626, -0.04004184901714325, -0.02186044678092003, 0.015676140785217285, 0.0374922901391983, 0.009854496456682682, 0.005286232568323612, -0.020194659009575844, 0.016634760424494743, 0.02883138507604599, 0.04294339939951897, -0.038030385971069336, -0.02538043074309826, 0.013484679162502289, 0.03601224347949028, -0.010389700531959534, 0.019096512347459793, -0.045186012983322144, -0.019945433363318443, 0.03882470726966858, 0.022640438750386238, -0.00718989921733737, -0.041523873805999756, -0.028805721551179886, 0.02498902939260006, -0.0190021563321352, -0.05718478560447693, 0.015403416007757187, -0.027152616530656815, 0.02409294992685318, -0.01156387198716402, 0.012448822148144245, 0.010841726325452328, -0.00889636855572462, -0.00899794977158308, -0.06964512914419174, 0.07526221871376038, -0.017043638974428177, 0.021273715421557426, -0.03577536717057228, -0.006320626474916935, -0.041614219546318054, -0.004131949041038752, 0.05823938548564911, -0.03787269815802574, -0.01803538203239441, -0.009078025817871094, 0.001811806345358491, -0.013715585693717003, -0.08048301935195923, 0.020535340532660484, -0.02451983094215393, -0.021577579900622368, -0.06292667239904404, -0.014788461849093437, -0.023357728496193886, 0.01501886360347271, 0.02444721944630146, 0.027222955599427223, 0.036466438323259354, -0.0011626306222751737, 0.008587589487433434, 0.022610114887356758, 0.02848336473107338, -0.02338949777185917, 0.0801384299993515, -0.00008886554860509932, 0.00020410721481312066, 0.0025528876576572657, -0.054363567382097244, -0.03750481829047203, 0.0604613833129406, -0.006426751147955656, -0.030135324224829674, -0.03184308484196663, 0.03376880660653114, -0.02478152886033058, -0.03409875929355621, -0.007735586259514093, 0.005765200592577457, -0.04283057153224945, 0.012506055645644665, 0.06739158183336258, 0.017831504344940186, 0.04282866790890694, 0.008289126679301262, 0.0013138640206307173, -0.011165839619934559, 0.01284116506576538, -0.03736397624015808, 0.014144200831651688, 0.0518631674349308, -0.007127417717128992, 0.03842733055353165, 0.026211732998490334, -0.03967762738466263, 0.011876781471073627, -0.03693109005689621, 0.03206976130604744, -0.055474553257226944, -0.03834965452551842, 0.01161008421331644, -0.023250337690114975, 0.03314110264182091, 0.011905071325600147, -0.007868592627346516, 0.10333827137947083, -0.030393032357096672, -0.007609858643263578, -0.0017131170025095344, -0.017061427235603333, -0.001007361919619143, 0.010589842684566975, -0.004145059268921614, 0.021976329386234283, 0.006790448911488056, 0.04347139224410057, -0.03862440213561058, 0.010116140358150005, 0.0533660352230072, 0.015732403844594955, 0.002343816915526986, 0.011497162282466888, -0.022994544357061386, 0.002792318584397435, -0.007553072180598974, -0.030385393649339676, -0.04376380145549774, -0.009361030533909798, 0.05066337436437607, 0.003908223006874323, 0.026114866137504578, -0.026217827573418617, 0.008393822237849236, 0.025878198444843292, -0.07427994161844254, 0.03058486245572567, -0.04063902050256729, -0.004290448501706123, -0.02223537676036358, -0.0027865900192409754 ]
<p>I tried to find some relation between these distance (loss) measures, but couldn't find any references. However, I think it must something like this: $$ \sqrt 2*D_{KL} &lt; L_1 &lt; L_2 $$ Is that right?</p>
36,644
[ -0.055124521255493164, -0.020360421389341354, -0.01238386519253254, -0.0019957630429416895, 0.03519784286618233, 0.035156212747097015, 0.024998297914862633, -0.01079366821795702, 0.018491845577955246, -0.010665715672075748, 0.02789054438471794, 0.005645585246384144, 0.05960946902632713, 0.0402730256319046, 0.0017289435490965843, -0.0059557403437793255, -0.057334382086992264, 0.013537228107452393, 0.029699888080358505, -0.05596517398953438, 0.05014265328645706, 0.030408047139644623, 0.044752880930900574, -0.02310565486550331, -0.04701505973935127, 0.06030634045600891, -0.004868424963206053, 0.0035060900263488293, -0.009634889662265778, 0.040882814675569534, 0.002381459577009082, -0.03292575851082802, 0.0014796208124607801, 0.03116977959871292, -0.001689380849711597, 0.022552836686372757, -0.05209638923406601, -0.026511184871196747, -0.03406120091676712, 0.014319396577775478, -0.04124578833580017, -0.043276213109493256, -0.02074429951608181, 0.03777037933468819, 0.019521329551935196, 0.014531617052853107, -0.03054061345756054, -0.07837008684873581, 0.0065826429054141045, -0.035591162741184235, 0.06477633863687515, -0.00020429077267181128, 0.005801813211292028, 0.005763915367424488, 0.01718633994460106, 0.017392227426171303, 0.04579770192503929, 0.10976935923099518, -0.019164515659213066, -0.03990056365728378, -0.0136197404935956, -0.0049197920598089695, 0.04256596788764, 0.018144357949495316, -0.008569254539906979, 0.06574223190546036, 0.002490886952728033, -0.019753508269786835, 0.025035150349140167, 0.014434476383030415, -0.03330336511135101, 0.023987241089344025, 0.030863706022500992, -0.004010641947388649, 0.042709749191999435, -0.00006091981413192116, -0.015884995460510254, 0.04351627081632614, 0.05881114304065704, 0.0309993177652359, -0.00596928084269166, -0.0038942922838032246, 0.01463244203478098, 0.017509212717413902, -0.006415992043912411, 0.01084247138351202, 0.048040635883808136, -0.03041066788136959, 0.0007473938749171793, 0.04292597249150276, 0.031450506299734116, -0.020417217165231705, 0.018896955996751785, -0.016545675694942474, -0.026113292202353477, -0.018887752667069435, -0.015416431240737438, 0.020990001037716866, 0.004913928918540478, -0.03001728653907776, -0.0013561142841354012, -0.034193575382232666, 0.018342312425374985, 0.06477543711662292, 0.006719627883285284, -0.024554695934057236, -0.03202255070209503, 0.011041632853448391, -0.03730800747871399, 0.020413566380739212, -0.016333509236574173, -0.002905146684497595, -0.008190997876226902, 0.012120349332690239, -0.010612992569804192, -0.03872344270348549, -0.01795954443514347, 0.018665531650185585, 0.023973660543560982, 0.08649005740880966, 0.051327090710401535, -0.016621876507997513, -0.0015685815596953034, -0.019964562729001045, -0.059116993099451065, 0.04505450651049614, 0.04550252482295036, -0.03727089986205101, -0.04029477387666702, 0.03577252849936485, -0.014642732217907906, -0.007348821498453617, 0.04253632202744484, 0.0024405387230217457, 0.01309104636311531, -0.01362843718379736, -0.06417632848024368, -0.03957071155309677, 0.03540199249982834, -0.013220458291471004, 0.04653787985444069, -0.06377412378787994, -0.008580985479056835, 0.03177709877490997, 0.05537501350045204, 0.052982304245233536, 0.0516948327422142, -0.0075492216274142265, 0.012227315455675125, -0.007848115637898445, -0.044326771050691605, -0.02335103042423725, -0.008488469757139683, 0.013050075620412827, -0.024722179397940636, -0.058747299015522, 0.0008616687846370041, 0.04625099524855614, -0.025938846170902252, -0.01733158528804779, 0.04895029217004776, 0.00832719262689352, -0.015197951346635818, 0.007762586697936058, 0.024162709712982178, -0.0030600535683333874, 0.07531297951936722, 0.016670258715748787, -0.008556892164051533, -0.003786321496590972, 0.008080174215137959, -0.021096723154187202, 0.04531404376029968, 0.018077565357089043, 0.07206527143716812, 0.018470337614417076, -0.017532464116811752, -0.06420747190713882, 0.0029221184086054564, 0.003886974649503827, -0.040419064462184906, -0.04941621050238609, -0.014740336686372757, 0.02500571683049202, -0.01641182228922844, 0.028147613629698753, -0.016579577699303627, -0.0007880041957832873, 0.051135074347257614, -0.012449989095330238, -0.03083018772304058, -0.004205451812595129, 0.02848348766565323, -0.0003913582186214626, -0.01649944856762886, 0.03244730085134506, 0.013532599434256554, 0.000023853906895965338, -0.0021048460621386766, 0.00021227063552942127, -0.00874172430485487, -0.018727654591202736, 0.006749042775481939, -0.019385261461138725, 0.015357756055891514, 0.06524880975484848, 0.04262244328856468, -0.0010456868913024664, 0.03239645063877106, -0.04187950864434242, -0.03517177328467369, -0.02418365702033043, -0.025810683146119118, 0.013852766714990139, -0.03920644521713257, -0.0013125044060871005, 0.010247969068586826, 0.0004123278777115047, -0.012187975458800793, -0.007600500714033842, -0.049130406230688095, 0.05852235108613968, 0.06548453867435455, 0.020246870815753937, -0.0050578066147863865, 0.02213398739695549, -0.01981465332210064, 0.03217445686459541, -0.039214398711919785, -0.03404588624835014, -0.04059233143925667, 0.02137468382716179, 0.05269618704915047, 0.03581200912594795, -0.05042870342731476, -0.0017416122136637568, 0.019602013751864433, 0.02474658004939556, -0.014236802235245705, -0.013536899350583553, -0.03723200783133507, -0.04438546672463417, 0.0013544196262955666, 0.04493531584739685, 0.009279819205403328, -0.002746100537478924, -0.005574353970587254, -0.001250912551768124, 0.01224427204579115, -0.02377454936504364, -0.015784719958901405, 0.039209332317113876, -0.013330777175724506, 0.013420640490949154, -0.03133668377995491, -0.018210558220744133, 0.04830236732959747, -0.01810736209154129, 0.024926168844103813, 0.04908016696572304, -0.004115356598049402, 0.004187958315014839, -0.0011305102379992604, -0.016965176910161972, 0.040772076696157455, 0.021423980593681335, -0.036655474454164505, 0.01021758746355772, 0.033431459218263626, -0.050049956887960434, 0.01854325272142887, 0.015479855239391327, -0.024161305278539658, -0.029155423864722252, -0.01444178819656372, 0.019915983080863953, -0.01710776425898075, 0.01321814488619566, -0.017814073711633682, -0.021543392911553383, 0.004161745775490999, -0.020395252853631973, 0.016510630026459694, -0.003765240777283907, -0.009256023913621902, 0.014292708598077297, -0.009566652588546276, -0.0012839138507843018, 0.016717202961444855, -0.026564085856080055, -0.015702946111559868, 0.02175484411418438, -0.03164948150515556, -0.04982215538620949, -0.04155045747756958, -0.0273961890488863, 0.05853838473558426, 0.005450588185340166, -0.004942332860082388, 0.03400446102023125, 0.002588908188045025, -0.0701369121670723, -0.009642334654927254, -0.03171423077583313, -0.03358764201402664, -0.05601152405142784, -0.006561181042343378, -0.011552060954272747, -0.04765503108501434, 0.009990476071834564, 0.04524506628513336, -0.05503296107053757, -0.017467573285102844, -0.07455932348966599, -0.05775883048772812, 0.04454942047595978, -0.002870913129299879, 0.029538210481405258, -0.007853737100958824, -0.022761987522244453, 0.09177771210670471, 0.03882020711898804, 0.0043593826703727245, -0.05142443627119064, -0.006013114005327225, -0.03804076835513115, -0.0419357493519783, -0.015439258888363838, 0.017132189124822617, 0.014478091150522232, 0.04161045327782631, -0.013356945477426052, 0.03445900231599808, 0.06285112351179123, -0.020345650613307953, -0.022732025012373924, 0.05625210702419281, 0.0010530480649322271, -0.011500230059027672, 0.06674367189407349, 0.029446270316839218, -0.04535182565450668, 0.026627713814377785, 0.01222430169582367, 0.02681938372552395, 0.0028572252485901117, -0.06943198293447495, -0.000009617192517907824, -0.0008012769394554198, -0.010459816083312035, -0.003740043379366398, 0.008969567716121674, 0.01724202185869217, -0.009372121654450893, -0.000651641224976629, 0.03928392007946968, 0.032766785472631454, -0.03922417387366295, 0.0020097317174077034, 0.04041161388158798, 0.04446398839354515, 0.00820455513894558, -0.021752947941422462, 0.0006439406424760818, 0.0011435088235884905, 0.016925454139709473, -0.0027678541373461485, -0.05106677860021591, -0.007581531070172787, 0.026513900607824326, -0.008422153070569038, 0.009166241623461246, -0.030909981578588486, 0.025862041860818863, -0.06770222634077072, -0.020402083173394203, -0.03137043118476868, 0.05870378762483597, 0.01990342326462269, 0.023292316123843193, 0.036188457161188126, -0.025140220299363136, -0.004348977468907833, 0.02908964268863201, -0.05713900551199913, -0.0060644252225756645, -0.056365717202425, -0.007000538054853678, 0.00734408525750041, -0.005021950230002403, 0.004390866030007601, -0.03251931071281433, -0.02875499613583088, -0.0034222009126096964, 0.023727890104055405, -0.05480354651808739, -0.00897265039384365, -0.009435802698135376, -0.012210577726364136, -0.011149443686008453, 0.03449118509888649, 0.006795619614422321, -0.04607565328478813, 0.037586748600006104, 0.04341476410627365, -0.021520689129829407, -0.014309871010482311, -0.01725318841636181, 0.027918655425310135, 0.034108638763427734, -0.002583802677690983, 0.02921375259757042, 0.017218058928847313, -0.022763747721910477, 0.008491262793540955, -0.012970439158380032, 0.021769845858216286, 0.017137331888079643, -0.0022427260410040617, -0.01925612799823284, -0.06311970204114914, -0.042416006326675415, -0.018519658595323563, 0.07329567521810532, -0.020876983180642128, -0.007322040852159262, 0.03993611037731171, 0.012618951499462128, -0.03654094785451889, -0.014619972556829453, 0.013711162842810154, -0.012414240278303623, -0.05810153856873512, -0.028057046234607697, -0.01988886669278145, 0.020221302285790443, -0.04609457403421402, 0.019695738330483437, -0.021629631519317627, -0.007146904245018959, -0.012724644504487514, 0.05146490037441254, 0.008630230091512203, -0.01438138261437416, -0.0033061408903449774, 0.019373241811990738, -0.014730376191437244, -0.03678928688168526, -0.012897852808237076, 0.017700476571917534, 0.047665685415267944, 0.060866519808769226, 0.055854711681604385, 0.0674658864736557, -0.06896847486495972, 0.011903857812285423, 0.004243199713528156, 0.016146674752235413, 0.016256680712103844, -0.011760484427213669, -0.032941680401563644, -0.033694975078105927, 0.009809435345232487, -0.012234156019985676, 0.06443609297275543, -0.002477314556017518, -0.026960521936416626, -0.019087783992290497, -0.019544297829270363, -0.0022764706518501043, 0.01944473385810852, 0.012129616923630238, 0.026032786816358566, -0.01211733277887106, 0.024385588243603706, -0.015611176379024982, 0.03060091659426689, 0.024177271872758865, 0.06212378665804863, -0.01740528829395771, -0.0327218696475029, -0.020338276401162148, 0.025451580062508583, -0.004525236785411835, -0.05506395176053047, 0.017032315954566002, 0.02461329475045204, -0.0012604346266016364, 0.031082870438694954, -0.047662992030382156, -0.009610223583877087, 0.0109222661703825, 0.038189198821783066, -0.013264312408864498, 0.03927595168352127, 0.023125242441892624, 0.044632598757743835, 0.06534063071012497, 0.016556089743971825, 0.03162050247192383, 0.0033491626381874084, 0.01864152029156685, 0.016792522743344307, 0.01805446855723858, 0.08117842674255371, -0.0426570288836956, -0.036656852811574936, -0.03836335241794586, -0.0305832140147686, -0.050384193658828735, 0.04112312197685242, -0.019625402987003326, 0.044379107654094696, -0.04056248441338539, -0.017380887642502785, -0.044218774884939194, 0.01704344153404236, 0.012079756706953049, -0.014349893666803837, 0.002367886248975992, 0.06977279484272003, 0.01850380003452301, -0.0012560599716380239, 0.023002363741397858, -0.01865813136100769, 0.003996684681624174, 0.03541167452931404, -0.01827664114534855, 0.018298357725143433, -0.05300593003630638, -0.00698854448273778, -0.0007323877653107047, -0.0009835134260356426, 0.0424918569624424, -0.034038711339235306, 0.0030320847872644663, 0.0034935935400426388, -0.008654005825519562, -0.0317377895116806, 0.009191768243908882, -0.009872726164758205, 0.03960185497999191, -0.06765781342983246, 0.006992072332650423, -0.008797445334494114, -0.02506580390036106, -0.07719328999519348, -0.004020380787551403, 0.018188579007983208, 0.023312456905841827, -0.029867934063076973, -0.031568706035614014, -0.004552959464490414, -0.014198211953043938, -0.0543237067759037, -0.0006695228512398899, 0.07658655941486359, -0.011411583051085472, -0.03826657310128212, -0.003472330514341593, -0.010086950846016407, 0.01908532902598381, 0.015547115355730057, 0.009142914786934853, -0.03161252290010452, 0.02393016591668129, 0.00685699051246047, 0.0050812712870538235, 0.05046440660953522, -0.03680428862571716, 0.00677504250779748, -0.06632291525602341, 0.005830079782754183, 0.00644621392711997, -0.03673728555440903, -0.02635057643055916, -0.03075997345149517, 0.0074028130620718, -0.014914686791598797, 0.005267736501991749, -0.01072263065725565, 0.0036409362219274044, 0.026435548439621925, -0.03546043485403061, -0.004595673177391291, 0.006751941051334143, 0.00466256495565176, -0.004968360532075167, 0.03550506383180618, 0.01591024361550808, -0.008202550932765007, 0.06123889237642288, 0.005406535696238279, -0.022303439676761627, 0.023186618462204933, -0.015630953013896942, 0.05023641511797905, -0.031745560467243195, 0.01747240126132965, 0.03929083049297333, 0.0731387734413147, -0.02481229417026043, -0.020656131207942963, -0.02822183258831501, 0.016182344406843185, 0.07838550955057144, -0.021634045988321304, 0.05739295855164528, 0.04443082585930824, -0.0020300287287682295, 0.018405428156256676, -0.03373190760612488, -0.022007659077644348, 0.002648464636877179, -0.0033568667713552713, 0.06567908823490143, -0.038379888981580734, -0.014468841254711151, 0.025158198550343513, 0.025335919111967087, -0.018813954666256905, -0.010032331570982933, -0.0070138126611709595, 0.02680620737373829, 0.009098292328417301, -0.037620335817337036, -0.01631498523056507, 0.03471393138170242, -0.044977057725191116, 0.005896531976759434, -0.011641534976661205, -0.001714215031825006, 0.06977808475494385, 0.01603315770626068, -0.00239391066133976, -0.04289044439792633, -0.05807904154062271, -0.05788448825478554, 0.018731115385890007, 0.03158211335539818, 0.005533676594495773, 0.024937013164162636, 0.004646374844014645, 0.037129972130060196, 0.007234262768179178, -0.023834992200136185, -0.008404761552810669, -0.04328927770256996, -0.030009211972355843, -0.02690930664539337, -0.05682756006717682, -0.028975794091820717, -0.011925109662115574, -0.038877684623003006, -0.022136935964226723, -0.014827949926257133, 0.007854776456952095, 0.017374828457832336, -0.019364215433597565, 0.02464122511446476, 0.05543319508433342, 0.027527188882231712, 0.01416447851806879, -0.006625926122069359, -0.026692567393183708, 0.1246718317270279, 0.045519549399614334, 0.029274819418787956, -0.07749571651220322, 0.018033314496278763, 0.02213655412197113, 0.02579648047685623, -0.05638037621974945, 0.03704367205500603, 0.00829438865184784, -0.008394645527005196, 0.029389193281531334, 0.04887530580163002, 0.017139798030257225, -0.04754984378814697, 0.055390793830156326, -0.019835766404867172, 0.011847938410937786, 0.062232546508312225, -0.000013648912499775179, 0.0015788795426487923, -0.0018167293164879084, -0.004168227780610323, 0.037861697375774384, 0.03799908235669136, 0.02036658115684986, -0.021475566551089287, -0.014741000719368458, 0.004995726048946381, -0.02706015110015869, 0.0033710626885294914, 0.00560768274590373, 0.039672330021858215, 0.04479070007801056, 0.00673962477594614, 0.010596820153295994, 0.022941196337342262, -0.020200153812766075, -0.009776421822607517, 0.008619819767773151, 0.028580879792571068, -0.00004741422162624076, 0.014126485213637352, 0.0022319559939205647, -0.03556232899427414, -0.04152398183941841, -0.05522594600915909, 0.0027018121909350157, -0.009235013276338577, 0.03167548030614853, 0.03490019589662552, -0.012701784260571003, 0.014944808557629585, -0.07177053391933441, -0.006333369296044111, 0.03270966187119484, 0.052753061056137085, 0.0024306378327310085, 0.0338677242398262, -0.009198484942317009, 0.030599242076277733, -0.010051232762634754, 0.002055667107924819, -0.024027593433856964, -0.019786236807703972, -0.023867430165410042, 0.030566491186618805, 0.043339285999536514, -0.007864524610340595, -0.004538390319794416, -0.015247284434735775, 0.022623660042881966, -0.021535193547606468, 0.0008198560099117458, -0.02099430188536644, 0.01029460784047842, 0.05035734549164772, 0.001507396693341434, -0.04720965400338173, -0.0062998500652611256, -0.0947531908750534, 0.0271148681640625, -0.0311684962362051, -0.023698745295405388, -0.03694615140557289, -0.0076409862376749516, 0.03176645562052727, 0.008725136518478394, 0.006416941527277231, 0.010423878207802773, 0.00542422803118825, 0.027455512434244156, 0.0018996319267898798, -0.042273133993148804, 0.02003094181418419, 0.024170612916350365, -0.04946760833263397, -0.021351614966988564, -0.008720086887478828, 0.03821761906147003, 0.04137812927365303, 0.009173331782221794, 0.002001022920012474, 0.0125225018709898, -0.030465545132756233, 0.02045387588441372, -0.008549506776034832, -0.04987061396241188, 0.025183983147144318, 0.008497956208884716, -0.023553946986794472, -0.007519217673689127, -0.021127626299858093, -0.03210391849279404, -0.02189725451171398, -0.008049567230045795, -0.001123136142268777, -0.01823597401380539, -0.019592082127928734, -0.004634442739188671, -0.006802179850637913, -0.031993716955184937, -0.013034922070801258, -0.016046393662691116, 0.004743911791592836, -0.043789707124233246, -0.015792235732078552, -0.004627815913408995, 0.01017883699387312, -0.013868546113371849, 0.016632946208119392, 0.024560218676924706, 0.019894858822226524, -0.030168266966938972, -0.012934579513967037, -0.02308238483965397, -0.030940964818000793, 0.04354469105601311, -0.055493444204330444, -0.0073758517391979694, 0.03370139002799988, -0.06241697445511818, -0.03690122440457344, 0.03919421136379242, -0.0018808315508067608, 0.0189074594527483, 0.005929155275225639, 0.03833877295255661, -0.03080347739160061, 0.051248159259557724, 0.012541033327579498, -0.024930153042078018, -0.02311333455145359, -0.04269397258758545, 0.012719282880425453, -0.03069998137652874, 0.0068185837008059025, -0.0014785098610445857, -0.0020234205294400454, 0.0026369094848632812, 0.02003416419029236, -0.038015492260456085, 0.02035033330321312, 0.007959305308759212, -0.01495518907904625, 0.03894858434796333, 0.012121202424168587, 0.018443474546074867, 0.053826332092285156, 0.020612213760614395, -0.018133457750082016, 0.004640256520360708, 0.04403169825673103, 0.013967931270599365, -0.09129217267036438, 0.022221382707357407, 0.021923884749412537, 0.01999470964074135, 0.03373303636908531, -0.10756323486566544, 0.043746206909418106, 0.00404540216550231, -0.06852725893259048, 0.028754521161317825, -0.039554987102746964, 0.02018130198121071, -0.04400716349482536, 0.004867488518357277, -0.02931721694767475, 0.03086017817258835, 0.00625588558614254, 0.029790306463837624, 0.028605854138731956, 0.040689464658498764, -0.027922766283154488, -0.011605121195316315, -0.017212258651852608, 0.009481046348810196, -0.020540751516819, -0.02883111499249935, 0.04545529931783676, -0.01590891368687153, -0.0003252914466429502, 0.03441264107823372, -0.023447809740900993, 0.017848292365670204, 0.011100443080067635, 0.022699303925037384, 0.041770607233047485, 0.006062333006411791, 0.010868784971535206, -0.031589098274707794, -0.000532223260961473, -0.036835599690675735, 0.020395921543240547, -0.02357078529894352, -0.014639008790254593, 0.0035046737175434828, 0.05645091459155083, -0.06195235997438431, -0.0017716893926262856, 0.043816130608320236, -0.010424858890473843, -0.020946361124515533, -0.017337555065751076, 0.00331873563118279, 0.03995167091488838, -0.05478481948375702, 0.018785322085022926, -0.03237712383270264, -0.04926181212067604, 0.028597429394721985, 0.0020995524246245623, 0.01266457885503769, 0.003508683294057846, -0.007968490943312645, -0.03563268482685089, 0.017495697364211082, 0.017683245241642, 0.001106332871131599, -0.03759640455245972, -0.020384294912219048, -0.022891541942954063, 0.015727825462818146, -0.027545634657144547, -0.045147113502025604, -0.04539967328310013, 0.039837032556533813, -0.044213391840457916, 0.03368648886680603, 0.01329768169671297, 0.02608966827392578, 0.003852386958897114, -0.09724631905555725, 0.047454237937927246, 0.008121125400066376, 0.01127245556563139, 0.00768611766397953, 0.02098555862903595, -0.018682722002267838, 0.009605787694454193, 0.059157487004995346, 0.03683079034090042, -0.011881434358656406, -0.00819258950650692, 0.007014403119683266, 0.009449485689401627, -0.01994134485721588, -0.02677670679986477, -0.041148118674755096, -0.010620645247399807, -0.05136345699429512, -0.010737285017967224, 0.005153035745024681, 0.005357485730201006, 0.02247532643377781, -0.024326223880052567, -0.005397486034780741, -0.019782695919275284, -0.012456917203962803, 0.013186033815145493, -0.012075729668140411, -0.0070417714305222034, 0.05496778339147568, 0.0007734890677966177, 0.0029662754386663437, -0.013404207304120064, -0.03776942938566208, -0.04113943129777908, 0.06295096129179001, 0.0003536007716320455, -0.027751237154006958, -0.0014133114600554109, 0.02567080780863762, 0.03031158819794655, -0.024161357432603836, -0.04015323147177696, 0.05535141006112099, -0.03624619171023369, -0.028055155649781227, 0.04013017192482948, 0.05487234145402908, 0.039000000804662704, -0.00507068308070302, 0.02330147847533226, 0.012944729067385197, 0.009168866090476513, 0.0270924624055624, 0.024175753816962242, 0.05928398296236992, 0.029440155252814293, -0.022147275507450104, 0.011531461961567402, -0.037507250905036926, 0.02670196257531643, -0.023786483332514763, 0.03595389053225517, -0.017729587852954865, -0.005150269716978073, 0.015507226809859276, 0.02057265304028988, -0.006589393597096205, 0.010644000954926014, -0.007418494671583176, 0.055648073554039, -0.028643839061260223, 0.02273104153573513, -0.04389801248908043, -0.026799267157912254, -0.0003517750301398337, -0.0037740529514849186, 0.02131730504333973, 0.008686216548085213, 0.011895750649273396, 0.02386537753045559, 0.00045677306479774415, -0.028920229524374008, 0.007014404516667128, -0.032681792974472046, 0.02977117709815502, 0.006998127326369286, 0.005629266612231731, 0.019451556727290154, -0.02428637258708477, 0.03063698671758175, 0.0017750993138179183, 0.02205607108771801, 0.03483152016997337, 0.04188567399978638, 0.011512420140206814, -0.017984671518206596, 0.04778403043746948, 0.03939368575811386, -0.048371803015470505, -0.03403043746948242, -0.024695292115211487, 0.021996542811393738, 0.021427342668175697, -0.011271565221250057 ]
<p>Which correlation coefficient is the most appropriate to compare 2 time series? I want to compare the variation of one variable for 2 regions, have regional data for the last 30 years. Is Pearson correlation ok or should I rely on Kendall's tau b or Spearman's rho and why? I tried to google it and analyse what I found, but I'm still not sure.</p>
74,023
[ -0.0257816594094038, -0.01601579040288925, -0.04763396829366684, 0.0078019509091973305, 0.022782625630497932, 0.015819789841771126, 0.028859395533800125, -0.004174178931862116, 0.02443862333893776, -0.022672927007079124, 0.017620157450437546, 0.019067108631134033, 0.03726660832762718, 0.017252104356884956, 0.03228699043393135, 0.0016652252525091171, -0.015205328352749348, -0.009943190962076187, -0.017852235585451126, 0.009890166111290455, -0.014310953207314014, -0.01609930582344532, 0.027915511280298233, -0.0007849230896681547, -0.027862124145030975, 0.06550300121307373, 0.02496679686009884, 0.0009791135089471936, 0.014975577592849731, 0.017374515533447266, -0.03603394329547882, -0.043775249272584915, 0.0004918394261039793, 0.05571344867348671, 0.007923305034637451, -0.004954325966536999, -0.035463158041238785, -0.029164103791117668, -0.040489181876182556, 0.04724651202559471, -0.06311538070440292, -0.06359817087650299, -0.010572457686066628, 0.04368709772825241, -0.027955476194620132, 0.05114717036485672, 0.009170630015432835, 0.0024902618024498224, 0.02759338729083538, -0.022705024108290672, 0.0644076019525528, -0.0022076850291341543, 0.01454172469675541, 0.04194645583629608, 0.0017595242243260145, -0.016135236248373985, 0.07000769674777985, 0.030141543596982956, -0.013560815714299679, -0.06927600502967834, -0.015243531204760075, 0.009477999061346054, 0.001120153465308249, -0.023953083902597427, -0.047606371343135834, 0.004104006104171276, -0.009816151112318039, 0.01877628266811371, 0.04326876252889633, -0.03642582148313522, 0.025972850620746613, 0.02113214321434498, 0.04482034966349602, -0.005688509438186884, -0.00136662763543427, -0.04528909921646118, 0.01641959883272648, 0.02335638366639614, 0.06525614857673645, 0.036828361451625824, 0.0009887897176668048, -0.01925227791070938, 0.050064943730831146, 0.026081770658493042, 0.06554638594388962, 0.006138963624835014, 0.07794156670570374, -0.049803268164396286, -0.009772447869181633, 0.016177542507648468, -0.02900548093020916, 0.01589898392558098, 0.04654001444578171, 0.010693049058318138, -0.02879950776696205, -0.001607720972970128, -0.03461957350373268, 0.018883058801293373, 0.02812148630619049, -0.006633132696151733, -0.009965072385966778, -0.032533157616853714, -0.0026625487953424454, 0.04199911281466484, -0.005073042120784521, -0.0014818652998656034, -0.022552404552698135, -0.01930440403521061, 0.0085377749055624, -0.044509224593639374, -0.05842601880431175, 0.016179770231246948, -0.04701562970876694, 0.026035917922854424, 0.03660289943218231, -0.009729520417749882, 0.029708782210946083, 0.025682976469397545, 0.07211136817932129, 0.08292344957590103, 0.04892410710453987, -0.00801068264991045, 0.0079747773706913, -0.020689455792307854, -0.031686972826719284, 0.03451927751302719, 0.011124614626169205, -0.06698063015937805, -0.04511167109012604, 0.06197511777281761, 0.004211358726024628, -0.04047306254506111, -0.001438781851902604, -0.05095239356160164, 0.05282953009009361, 0.017946112900972366, -0.06512638926506042, -0.033489201217889786, 0.030891569331288338, 0.001994380494579673, -0.009176422841846943, -0.03308828920125961, 0.018957411870360374, -0.0030054079834371805, 0.0556451715528965, 0.03062627464532852, 0.030817953869700432, 0.006052868440747261, 0.05949458107352257, -0.023958217352628708, -0.0808597207069397, -0.008836938068270683, -0.005740099120885134, 0.0037131477147340775, -0.0006366859888657928, -0.06258729100227356, -0.04802486300468445, 0.013621220365166664, 0.015859907492995262, 0.011475546285510063, 0.05241058021783829, 0.018580693751573563, -0.0064623234793543816, 0.03517550230026245, -0.008329618722200394, -0.01219367329031229, 0.07461100816726685, -0.004295102786272764, 0.04536561295390129, -0.010247340425848961, 0.017797481268644333, -0.002236331347376108, 0.034013502299785614, 0.019858468323946, 0.04841760918498039, -0.03153274208307266, 0.017779715359210968, 0.017808180302381516, -0.0010827945079654455, -0.009903919883072376, -0.07502900063991547, -0.024309813976287842, -0.051400166004896164, -0.04033944755792618, 0.0062428852543234825, 0.02757074497640133, -0.029371965676546097, -0.012510440312325954, 0.03164920210838318, -0.02056027390062809, -0.04575888812541962, -0.024554159492254257, 0.00523611344397068, -0.02076922357082367, -0.03427928686141968, 0.05343054607510567, 0.0031547145918011665, 0.030584122985601425, -0.04144109785556793, -0.016019770875573158, -0.03383968397974968, 0.014830161817371845, -0.005661859177052975, -0.034010909497737885, 0.027690034359693527, 0.0022419311571866274, 0.05845102295279503, -0.00899185985326767, 0.042211614549160004, -0.03169456124305725, -0.049152519553899765, 0.011025876738131046, -0.01371257659047842, 0.025495702400803566, -0.03794107586145401, -0.03073965199291706, 0.010898818261921406, -0.012101647444069386, -0.06202255189418793, -0.01601123809814453, -0.04819732904434204, 0.07026627659797668, 0.034330565482378006, 0.010286431759595871, 0.00042338049388490617, -0.0008806498371995986, 0.017576346173882484, 0.005604927893728018, -0.02098436839878559, -0.03491735830903053, -0.04825571924448013, 0.03272219002246857, 0.03944062441587448, 0.02454948052763939, -0.05356360226869583, 0.026536133140325546, 0.07342476397752762, 0.00994571577757597, -0.0359753742814064, 0.041191115975379944, -0.007500060368329287, -0.029230963438749313, -0.0016122087836265564, 0.01843537762761116, -0.000049573834985494614, 0.017750343307852745, 0.017395982518792152, -0.02149798534810543, 0.03656934201717377, 0.004687600769102573, -0.03594028577208519, 0.03163306415081024, -0.006602998822927475, -0.009636891074478626, 0.00042814415064640343, -0.010313080623745918, 0.014048381708562374, -0.025787850841879845, 0.018094055354595184, -0.0020294850692152977, 0.004992498084902763, 0.00880188774317503, 0.020503822714090347, -0.023898471146821976, 0.0226002037525177, 0.026079697534441948, 0.004746316932141781, 0.00026305727078579366, 0.024562226608395576, -0.02644188143312931, 0.021173208951950073, -0.049242254346609116, -0.015512113459408283, -0.03237602859735489, -0.014715440571308136, 0.060415007174015045, 0.023885412141680717, 0.02979327365756035, -0.008974351920187473, -0.018437203019857407, -0.015471849590539932, -0.009930149652063847, 0.013383363373577595, -0.0007055595051497221, -0.08604027330875397, 0.0314418189227581, 0.0035597775131464005, -0.011594056151807308, 0.029107728973031044, -0.03585798665881157, -0.015170642174780369, 0.0460556298494339, 0.03197339177131653, -0.06065070256590843, -0.022890467196702957, -0.010238846763968468, -0.0010605674469843507, -0.006015249993652105, -0.023418273776769638, 0.043108027428388596, -0.026240084320306778, -0.02250051684677601, 0.01149212196469307, -0.054000526666641235, -0.029592016711831093, -0.0064188530668616295, 0.011149943806231022, 0.00537152262404561, -0.013332986272871494, -0.008323373273015022, 0.03565092384815216, -0.048208583146333694, -0.026902545243501663, -0.02449404075741768, -0.03214682638645172, 0.07641495019197464, 0.008732616901397705, 0.036869410425424576, -0.007459515705704689, -0.06674093008041382, 0.03474866971373558, 0.02883576974272728, -0.010907802730798721, -0.03418246656656265, 0.005268725100904703, -0.03201666101813316, -0.010952516458928585, 0.028490668162703514, 0.02233041822910309, 0.023293908685445786, 0.002955546136945486, 0.003285778686404228, 0.025447677820920944, 0.06213226541876793, 0.0027046562172472477, 0.02106376923620701, 0.04750284180045128, 0.007126484997570515, -0.014143036678433418, 0.04681747779250145, 0.005083934869617224, -0.06400510668754578, 0.007366884499788284, -0.007789511699229479, -0.009369037114083767, 0.009464111179113388, -0.02940048836171627, 0.022805137559771538, -0.025030096992850304, 0.008500642143189907, -0.040907569229602814, -0.015454797074198723, -0.0034078331664204597, 0.006898645311594009, -0.030864661559462547, 0.05437050387263298, 0.0004591458127833903, -0.005961524322628975, -0.009387625381350517, 0.05532674118876457, 0.03773083910346031, 0.029937466606497765, -0.009677434340119362, -0.000467158475657925, 0.0036568946670740843, 0.051120370626449585, -0.039296627044677734, -0.025969043374061584, 0.052705299109220505, 0.007471770513802767, 0.01120635773986578, 0.00018152354459743947, -0.05835679918527603, -0.0007857352029532194, -0.06470906734466553, 0.020811349153518677, -0.03248593583703041, 0.04492030292749405, 0.016000565141439438, 0.020061496645212173, 0.04089647904038429, -0.004559757653623819, 0.023997990414500237, -0.0027700781356543303, -0.0508509986102581, 0.04762154817581177, -0.04197530075907707, -0.0007772283279336989, 0.019027862697839737, -0.03544820100069046, 0.016636718064546585, -0.012625615112483501, 0.03993865102529526, 0.00013237564417067915, 0.024237753823399544, -0.02032412961125374, 0.011713583953678608, -0.039322394877672195, -0.010263965465128422, 0.012497693300247192, 0.01677865907549858, -0.007521129213273525, -0.006228133570402861, 0.08945959061384201, 0.0661216601729393, -0.005347724538296461, 0.012981768697500229, 0.0037480697501450777, 0.02135287970304489, 0.008363466709852219, 0.006213672459125519, 0.025076309219002724, -0.0019769039936363697, -0.025660637766122818, 0.02529049664735794, 0.03978228569030762, 0.03017852082848549, 0.0012440178543329239, -0.0662330761551857, -0.027568228542804718, 0.003834871808066964, -0.005901325028389692, -0.0264920461922884, 0.03315740451216698, 0.0437680259346962, -0.010464278981089592, 0.024106299504637718, 0.03135492652654648, -0.04990745708346367, 0.017059583216905594, 0.056366655975580215, 0.010090370662510395, -0.0036952062509953976, -0.01592252403497696, -0.023886945098638535, 0.025859110057353973, -0.0007249215850606561, 0.03272596746683121, 0.002730979584157467, -0.02889193594455719, -0.005702700931578875, 0.04643229767680168, -0.004246557131409645, -0.06816211342811584, 0.021641353145241737, 0.048421699553728104, 0.03727863356471062, -0.015050830319523811, -0.04442289471626282, 0.01697513833642006, 0.006581069435924292, 0.05029883608222008, 0.03619174659252167, 0.027544189244508743, -0.04084574803709984, -0.025123827159404755, 0.051919348537921906, -0.0020927474834024906, -0.037150025367736816, -0.042996373027563095, -0.0448191873729229, -0.0025195942725986242, 0.038882311433553696, -0.02453487180173397, 0.0071622151881456375, 0.006302121561020613, -0.009402774274349213, -0.026798190549016, -0.032450903207063675, -0.014454483054578304, 0.036935511976480484, 0.05145832523703575, 0.028398532420396805, -0.01210822258144617, -0.008778125047683716, -0.0388692244887352, -0.0019897844176739454, 0.00026731984689831734, 0.04452309384942055, -0.019180746749043465, -0.020877346396446228, 0.016366668045520782, 0.044794514775276184, 0.01741689257323742, -0.06184328719973564, 0.009574922733008862, -0.006074255332350731, -0.01129060983657837, 0.03385595232248306, 0.0036338400095701218, -0.04661612585186958, 0.01772521249949932, -0.016010727733373642, -0.018827926367521286, 0.022784680128097534, 0.019067266955971718, 0.073215551674366, 0.0041417935863137245, -0.0033979511354118586, 0.0751194953918457, 0.029621820896863937, -0.007493705488741398, -0.012055395171046257, -0.039629675447940826, 0.01577448658645153, -0.033257562667131424, -0.042033277451992035, -0.03447158262133598, -0.031793247908353806, -0.036224115639925, 0.03644511476159096, -0.007237176410853863, 0.031472913920879364, -0.04231433570384979, 0.016688114032149315, 0.006644493900239468, 0.051758188754320145, -0.04139122739434242, -0.013423302210867405, 0.028819946572184563, 0.0025084789376705885, 0.0000802170907263644, -0.048577819019556046, 0.0019388545770198107, -0.0055394829250872135, -0.015164866112172604, 0.025356339290738106, -0.051456257700920105, 0.03586595505475998, -0.016305584460496902, -0.020041191950440407, -0.03624769300222397, 0.013743873685598373, 0.025733182206749916, 0.03378447890281677, 0.020901987329125404, 0.015507744625210762, -0.042338691651821136, -0.002019063802435994, 0.016478795558214188, -0.006975003983825445, 0.0639282613992691, -0.04128742218017578, 0.040417127311229706, -0.029674505814909935, 0.0024690988939255476, -0.07240920513868332, -0.0452735461294651, 0.040328700095415115, -0.0010535315377637744, -0.01015519630163908, -0.03349427133798599, 0.04787544906139374, -0.009052491746842861, -0.019735243171453476, -0.01036329846829176, 0.06981756538152695, -0.0015118180308490992, -0.004350591450929642, -0.021509088575839996, 0.028142010793089867, 0.04205306991934776, -0.010605663992464542, 0.02679114229977131, -0.00012451113434508443, -0.015473304316401482, -0.018499979749321938, 0.002993691712617874, 0.0501486100256443, 0.0076767210848629475, 0.00449306471273303, -0.0456852912902832, -0.009930284693837166, 0.029728038236498833, -0.01730559766292572, -0.023113662376999855, 0.01801004633307457, -0.01043681800365448, -0.0035890494473278522, -0.02892453595995903, 0.02719704806804657, -0.0394899956882, 0.010552460327744484, -0.03934314474463463, -0.039420004934072495, -0.03068772330880165, -0.020466888323426247, 0.021013053134083748, 0.003923776559531689, -0.03535284847021103, 0.024342576041817665, 0.04746728390455246, 0.00002267835589009337, -0.0062112282030284405, -0.03157544136047363, -0.020400632172822952, 0.017512960359454155, -0.016761111095547676, 0.011734366416931152, 0.044568706303834915, 0.01999816857278347, -0.041030943393707275, -0.040105655789375305, -0.03105984255671501, 0.01198082510381937, 0.0774901881814003, 0.012086424976587296, 0.06041623651981354, 0.052115585654973984, 0.0027188449166715145, 0.011296391487121582, -0.027080927044153214, -0.022438371554017067, 0.01370803639292717, 0.006977119483053684, 0.03120480477809906, -0.034840237349271774, 0.0064558773301541805, 0.02553964965045452, 0.018866034224629402, -0.02845420502126217, 0.051190368831157684, 0.026256481185555458, 0.05215727537870407, 0.015901250764727592, 0.009745441377162933, -0.043334975838661194, 0.0005847797729074955, -0.0230419859290123, 0.0027242302894592285, -0.03599531203508377, -0.03118181601166725, 0.017746180295944214, 0.07136330753564835, -0.019068149849772453, -0.05490417033433914, -0.02485733851790428, -0.043495044112205505, -0.005008917301893234, 0.012298868969082832, -0.03515322878956795, 0.026725735515356064, 0.012470676563680172, 0.030139725655317307, 0.0026037911884486675, 0.055011339485645294, -0.036783818155527115, -0.06624628603458405, -0.0267268568277359, -0.021436648443341255, -0.022958168759942055, 0.02997007966041565, 0.0005448819720186293, -0.02810729667544365, 0.02125096507370472, -0.030742432922124863, -0.02148551680147648, -0.007551543414592743, 0.0010235103545710444, -0.0016414396231994033, 0.05524791032075882, -0.019347677007317543, 0.016817651689052582, -0.005160392727702856, -0.0007472913130186498, 0.09653321653604507, 0.038271714001894, 0.019747456535696983, -0.06042525917291641, 0.05031602457165718, -0.003933197818696499, -0.008875188417732716, -0.07237110286951065, 0.03598399460315704, 0.03610306978225708, -0.010421426966786385, 0.08016055077314377, 0.03252164646983147, 0.054162025451660156, -0.025502653792500496, 0.07152939587831497, -0.0035412595607340336, -0.026768358424305916, -0.004403265658766031, 0.024701310321688652, 0.016876038163900375, -0.02186065912246704, -0.008951365947723389, -0.007889882661402225, -0.01931721903383732, 0.0034941239282488823, -0.017840668559074402, -0.012178267352283001, 0.005057414527982473, -0.0020861427765339613, -0.0213161613792181, 0.028020305559039116, 0.027065323665738106, 0.03414124622941017, -0.016232365742325783, 0.0038900026120245457, -0.0031535536982119083, -0.01962945982813835, -0.01122330967336893, -0.017323985695838928, -0.0028052208945155144, -0.009894799441099167, 0.016056669875979424, -0.019439466297626495, -0.02517518401145935, 0.016733909025788307, -0.047284774482250214, -0.009512992575764656, 0.008702648803591728, 0.023997187614440918, 0.014377889223396778, 0.04523855075240135, -0.006737423595041037, -0.016420893371105194, -0.016274379566311836, -0.012851211242377758, 0.0431048609316349, -0.04127708077430725, 0.002020960906520486, -0.0376213863492012, -0.0028876273427158594, -0.015824193134903908, 0.05441625416278839, 0.04834091290831566, -0.03580312430858612, 0.006230113096535206, 0.007305298000574112, 0.06221635639667511, -0.024859409779310226, 0.0034249513410031796, 0.02575720101594925, 0.03071516379714012, -0.05067037418484688, -0.013402441516518593, -0.0002952618233393878, 0.013605949468910694, 0.026739003136754036, -0.004839281551539898, -0.010461722500622272, -0.026344483718276024, -0.04501289129257202, 0.010484345257282257, -0.009930836968123913, -0.001895081833936274, -0.029969530180096626, -0.020092060789465904, 0.041746269911527634, 0.016579026356339455, 0.012362646870315075, 0.03397363796830177, -0.022338664159178734, 0.046571314334869385, 0.03672598674893379, -0.06742957979440689, -0.007771349512040615, -0.01549161784350872, -0.07325058430433273, -0.03736070170998573, -0.03975675255060196, 0.026215601712465286, 0.055675726383924484, 0.02684149332344532, -0.025939246639609337, -0.004738215822726488, -0.022434387356042862, 0.003280384698882699, -0.0011153548257425427, -0.042948994785547256, -0.018913641571998596, 0.01851503737270832, -0.010950982570648193, -0.04661157354712486, -0.003579874988645315, -0.02677391655743122, -0.0015874351374804974, -0.012184479273855686, 0.0035616490058600903, -0.048092830926179886, -0.009240166284143925, -0.007032493595033884, 0.00892600230872631, -0.04060734435915947, 0.01236636657267809, -0.06362703442573547, 0.03825033828616142, -0.008864244446158409, 0.01650233194231987, -0.03507984057068825, 0.029393987730145454, 0.01046825386583805, 0.019579794257879257, 0.06439725309610367, -0.001020696945488453, 0.02441880851984024, -0.014752921648323536, -0.01065904926508665, 0.00785764493048191, 0.07037831097841263, -0.014864291995763779, -0.01721092313528061, 0.0416397899389267, -0.015133644454181194, -0.03459162637591362, 0.015336456708610058, 0.023387784138321877, -0.013092623092234135, -0.017626063898205757, 0.01865915209054947, 0.00023660327133256942, 0.046073414385318756, 0.0036097068805247545, -0.01457124762237072, -0.02268599532544613, -0.00011028002336388454, 0.0213469285517931, -0.017909174785017967, 0.013728382997214794, 0.011053700000047684, -0.014984951354563236, 0.023402879014611244, 0.04742889478802681, -0.025382177904248238, -0.021703939884901047, -0.0052708531729876995, -0.03321235999464989, 0.01547867339104414, 0.002303873188793659, -0.019446779042482376, 0.04215581342577934, 0.07050010561943054, -0.03231922909617424, -0.0420907586812973, 0.011610128916800022, 0.003226123284548521, -0.043381527066230774, -0.01961609162390232, 0.018939023837447166, -0.024038204923272133, 0.036323148757219315, -0.038999415934085846, -0.00003670147998491302, 0.03958159312605858, -0.04998891428112984, 0.043617382645606995, 0.010456754826009274, 0.016942234709858894, -0.0179095808416605, 0.002846359508112073, 0.022191228345036507, 0.04633798450231552, 0.004211560357362032, 0.01509871706366539, 0.012792923487722874, 0.03417649492621422, 0.004875390324741602, -0.0021698016207665205, -0.011997368186712265, 0.001321333460509777, 0.024169189855456352, -0.04824484512209892, 0.018861044198274612, -0.041852325201034546, -0.046153001487255096, 0.022228503599762917, -0.03195738047361374, 0.0318782813847065, 0.00420632166787982, 0.029444659128785133, 0.004683700390160084, 0.0556020513176918, 0.045930977910757065, -0.05877414718270302, -0.03470486029982567, 0.0022282316349446774, 0.01106991060078144, 0.026633987203240395, -0.04680992662906647, 0.013544721528887749, -0.030178964138031006, -0.02077368274331093, -0.042361460626125336, -0.019663257524371147, -0.015200820751488209, -0.024026254191994667, -0.0025676132645457983, -0.008532465435564518, 0.009821544401347637, 0.03138796240091324, 0.003227363573387265, -0.04006878286600113, -0.026376759633421898, 0.03967919573187828, 0.04088843613862991, -0.031186198815703392, -0.02190157026052475, -0.030822550877928734, -0.03779510781168938, 0.004302400164306164, -0.01042856089770794, -0.003110354533419013, -0.039190858602523804, -0.007499281782656908, -0.01742120087146759, -0.020511731505393982, -0.047513242810964584, -0.014779703691601753, -0.03963937237858772, 0.04535619169473648, 0.013779888860881329, 0.014414005912840366, 0.03934633359313011, -0.007384458091109991, 0.012601781636476517, -0.03799154981970787, 0.04372049495577812, -0.013909501023590565, -0.028483476489782333, -0.03412345424294472, -0.019827602431178093, -0.04982772469520569, -0.017555873841047287, 0.059868037700653076, -0.0013293713564053178, 0.018494892865419388, -0.009720993228256702, 0.030241983011364937, 0.042021848261356354, -0.031919971108436584, 0.04882204905152321, -0.0305818822234869, -0.009252025745809078, 0.023990603163838387, 0.0005720191984437406, 0.0383586548268795, -0.008512911386787891, -0.02775590866804123, -0.04109131172299385, 0.034993112087249756, 0.02406877465546131, -0.006573847495019436, 0.04332553595304489, 0.003601792035624385, -0.02702172100543976, 0.0322517529129982, -0.004472588654607534, 0.035306237637996674, 0.03258116915822029, 0.009987510740756989, -0.009658917784690857, 0.05859283730387688, -0.01848698779940605, -0.05380154401063919, 0.03180782124400139, 0.0473160594701767, -0.024438077583909035, -0.04697032272815704, -0.03277403488755226, 0.04406944289803505, -0.047360725700855255, 0.014111217111349106, 0.01082131639122963, -0.009245587512850761, 0.03541530668735504, 0.002271131845191121, 0.024884440004825592, 0.020054955035448074, -0.01378418505191803, -0.008409942500293255, -0.014773044735193253, 0.05605558305978775, 0.024823324754834175, 0.01782919280230999, 0.02200448326766491, -0.03229450061917305, 0.01750314235687256, -0.05457593873143196, 0.03284478932619095, -0.020864790305495262, -0.047644391655921936, 0.045011650770902634, -0.015796886757016182, 0.021251631900668144, 0.03247473016381264, -0.0036849365569651127, 0.05535484477877617, -0.06932852417230606, 0.0072417473420500755, -0.017347093671560287, -0.013781371526420116, -0.03356919065117836, 0.01454656571149826, 0.02887456864118576, -0.01128595694899559, -0.0010209453757852316, 0.0026222297456115484, -0.018015611916780472, -0.028370985761284828, 0.02138170599937439, -0.042871732264757156, 0.027909593656659126, 0.011000216007232666, 0.011204213835299015, -0.014991440810263157, 0.011357426643371582, -0.05276600643992424, -0.04306870326399803, 0.008768866769969463, 0.06120476499199867, 0.01941082440316677, 0.0011749520199373364, -0.039003368467092514, -0.018540166318416595, 0.026640912517905235, -0.06921496242284775, -0.011851134710013866, -0.03629610687494278, 0.019474534317851067, 0.010448375716805458, 0.04135512188076973 ]
<p>I have learnt the definition of AIC for parametric model. But, what I want to know is that is there a semi-parametric version of AIC? Have you heard about it? And if you know, please show me a link, so I can have a look. </p>
41,742
[ -0.03267904743552208, -0.018109779804944992, 0.015723727643489838, -0.020542485639452934, 0.028964446857571602, 0.021830355748534203, -0.007219364866614342, -0.004868734162300825, 0.011141849681735039, -0.030424900352954865, 0.015997735783457756, 0.028917590156197548, 0.05436882749199867, 0.026602307334542274, 0.0010854109423235059, 0.003613022156059742, -0.019216397777199745, 0.004367516376078129, -0.013171574100852013, -0.043965261429548264, 0.016482114791870117, 0.0007473532459698617, -0.002398042008280754, -0.014725591987371445, 0.010228177532553673, 0.010673614218831062, -0.006541030947118998, -0.013850243762135506, 0.006445641629397869, 0.059843759983778, -0.04041023552417755, 0.02443423680961132, -0.01801462657749653, 0.0259536262601614, 0.04061079025268555, 0.019913313910365105, 0.00695959385484457, -0.028941087424755096, 0.00006433266389649361, 0.012479504570364952, -0.015156710520386696, -0.04082163795828819, 0.0010141062084585428, 0.01857559196650982, 0.0030899543780833483, 0.027664383873343468, -0.019389651715755463, -0.03715542331337929, 0.02039189264178276, -0.06710921227931976, 0.07805651426315308, -0.012119049206376076, 0.010302862152457237, 0.05208950862288475, -0.01959756761789322, 0.033838313072919846, 0.04152180254459381, 0.05529050529003143, -0.04710071161389351, -0.03403546288609505, -0.022638896480202675, -0.03070462867617607, 0.013938333839178085, -0.021450946107506752, -0.0801510214805603, 0.026280762627720833, 0.0015826981980353594, -0.01990124210715294, 0.01250312477350235, 0.0018441177671775222, -0.028383485972881317, -0.021447105333209038, 0.03379698842763901, -0.005229892209172249, 0.01493797730654478, 0.002226474229246378, 0.011601696722209454, -0.01735837385058403, 0.051654715090990067, 0.020100338384509087, 0.0009973342530429363, 0.037196531891822815, -0.025185808539390564, 0.007162238471210003, 0.006523865275084972, 0.008033683523535728, 0.0663800910115242, -0.042574457824230194, -0.0051190899685025215, 0.03004695661365986, -0.05418325960636139, -0.017071474343538284, 0.04507087916135788, 0.001752589363604784, -0.054259855300188065, 0.03516578674316406, -0.008452099747955799, 0.05449746176600456, -0.01036891620606184, -0.024377239868044853, -0.008104711771011353, -0.037406615912914276, -0.02137496881186962, 0.02704712562263012, -0.013866485096514225, -0.011470885016024113, 0.016032468527555466, -0.003713995683938265, 0.017723437398672104, 0.008731508627533913, -0.020944762974977493, 0.02872699871659279, 0.044532425701618195, 0.015562274493277073, 0.02446582168340683, 0.001955642830580473, 0.0007771165110170841, -0.03523361310362816, 0.016437169164419174, 0.10327450186014175, 0.04733600839972496, -0.027896739542484283, 0.04454709589481354, -0.022505419328808784, -0.05539519712328911, 0.017665866762399673, 0.004411672241985798, -0.04297671467065811, -0.05486556515097618, 0.05763751268386841, 0.010990486480295658, 0.0010676116216927767, 0.022979488596320152, 0.002910266863182187, 0.025183159857988358, -0.012889436446130276, -0.03504880890250206, -0.04244052618741989, -0.006564652547240257, 0.0019826851785182953, 0.049549590796232224, -0.04161972180008888, 0.05012917146086693, 0.041737981140613556, 0.05252261087298393, 0.0536276176571846, 0.03723169490695, 0.009858428500592709, -0.025898996740579605, 0.021851258352398872, -0.030265556648373604, -0.026600535959005356, 0.01246950775384903, -0.025523139163851738, -0.0077751860953867435, -0.10002519190311432, 0.018159570172429085, 0.014881697483360767, -0.014923124574124813, -0.001392942969687283, 0.039239175617694855, 0.002091850619763136, -0.048657581210136414, 0.00129914830904454, -0.01610170304775238, -0.006151428446173668, 0.05270778387784958, -0.004918418824672699, -0.019064312800765038, 0.009168998338282108, -0.0006313464837148786, 0.03588838502764702, -0.0009252732270397246, 0.02893681637942791, 0.06219097226858139, -0.011563664302229881, -0.04236143082380295, -0.02747606299817562, 0.017905699089169502, 0.06678912043571472, -0.022419489920139313, -0.0036698635667562485, -0.04011879488825798, 0.04458038508892059, 0.0072992476634681225, 0.00659904582425952, -0.00837844330817461, -0.013212018646299839, 0.06671462953090668, -0.0464509092271328, -0.01176844909787178, -0.04191461205482483, 0.020299768075346947, 0.009477266110479832, 0.014543360099196434, -0.0003122426860500127, 0.011687954887747765, -0.013388694263994694, 0.004953337367624044, -0.009229560382664204, -0.05428677424788475, -0.0055313874036073685, 0.047549936920404434, -0.058914605528116226, 0.020359432324767113, 0.015351425856351852, -0.0010412326082587242, -0.03293309360742569, 0.06478146463632584, -0.04613891988992691, -0.038577497005462646, 0.008296485990285873, -0.039824601262807846, 0.0031762155704200268, 0.00592136150225997, -0.0052116126753389835, 0.00382614997215569, -0.013492044992744923, -0.03702482581138611, 0.0315856896340847, -0.044786203652620316, 0.07988519221544266, 0.050715312361717224, 0.034328021109104156, 0.007375662215054035, 0.03498712182044983, 0.007670656777918339, 0.015584256500005722, -0.021613555029034615, -0.010757346637547016, -0.02252849191427231, -0.015106976963579655, 0.03658374026417732, 0.011845138855278492, -0.04397595301270485, 0.015938714146614075, 0.04625016078352928, 0.03065229207277298, 0.026706956326961517, 0.023416178300976753, -0.011541951447725296, 0.014328599907457829, 0.019714899361133575, 0.026519786566495895, 0.02816912904381752, -0.008654664270579815, -0.00045914307702332735, -0.030021999031305313, 0.02622382342815399, -0.03615996614098549, -0.02911335788667202, 0.04740801453590393, -0.009886981919407845, -0.012124540284276009, -0.02951100468635559, -0.02157989889383316, 0.03491787612438202, -0.0401131808757782, 0.02165035344660282, 0.04217774048447609, -0.008221309632062912, -0.020071255043148994, 0.022684847936034203, 0.008865678682923317, 0.0195634625852108, 0.008761189877986908, -0.040051184594631195, -0.013432791456580162, 0.026270180940628052, -0.021435296162962914, 0.007847989909350872, -0.01133086159825325, -0.017873404547572136, -0.06328602135181427, -0.0017018310027197003, 0.030208595097064972, 0.01093103177845478, 0.03175942227244377, -0.02187461219727993, -0.010832981206476688, 0.010746527463197708, -0.027929086238145828, 0.04831908270716667, 0.012431932613253593, -0.09334901720285416, 0.02451690286397934, -0.01450065802782774, -0.056246303021907806, 0.05484906584024429, -0.03927966207265854, -0.010529393330216408, 0.015449557453393936, -0.03284416347742081, -0.030154643580317497, -0.0006256469641812146, -0.029238726943731308, -0.007721095345914364, -0.05254673585295677, -0.007837517186999321, -0.0030518786516040564, 0.0027660659980028868, -0.06608595699071884, 0.0280397180467844, -0.025282979011535645, -0.010335853323340416, -0.03880615532398224, 0.010925347916781902, 0.01576433889567852, -0.016515009105205536, 0.05062910541892052, 0.046373460441827774, -0.03445951268076897, 0.00457305321469903, -0.07342740893363953, -0.05488846078515053, 0.00841041374951601, 0.008356492035090923, 0.021352624520659447, 0.02080100029706955, -0.021372657269239426, 0.022473977878689766, 0.04465296491980553, -0.04808516055345535, -0.0638163685798645, 0.034248195588588715, 0.000007393450232484611, -0.016329467296600342, -0.004055381286889315, 0.004394465126097202, -0.007703382056206465, 0.018405118957161903, 0.00734282610937953, 0.007881569676101208, 0.04922734200954437, 0.019749170169234276, -0.00816277228295803, 0.017780425027012825, 0.006185343489050865, -0.0027356466744095087, 0.013574681244790554, 0.04134386405348778, -0.04758072644472122, 0.005697552114725113, -0.023595033213496208, 0.01882724091410637, 0.018269004300236702, 0.005915973335504532, 0.030795220285654068, -0.007891647517681122, -0.007062793709337711, -0.02734481170773506, 0.018184171989560127, 0.0039831893518567085, -0.02124294824898243, 0.003036811016499996, 0.058393314480781555, -0.0025051028933376074, 0.0035801061894744635, -0.00015655138122383505, 0.0459604412317276, 0.04231679067015648, -0.043700359761714935, 0.024741798639297485, -0.02205883152782917, -0.00987178459763527, 0.011940086260437965, -0.018145186826586723, -0.02441270835697651, 0.02509932965040207, 0.01898680441081524, 0.034316323697566986, 0.001072715618647635, -0.017210228368639946, 0.028659487143158913, -0.06842518597841263, 0.0004984865663573146, -0.035900309681892395, 0.03584703430533409, 0.010806398466229439, -0.006375826429575682, 0.014874332584440708, 0.023004889488220215, 0.02487933076918125, 0.022156599909067154, -0.06266900151968002, -0.005944012198597193, -0.03279852867126465, -0.009756105951964855, 0.004503720905631781, 0.02043008990585804, 0.041378121823072433, -0.02214124985039234, -0.025307655334472656, -0.0176357701420784, 0.019512854516506195, -0.04413491487503052, 0.0016338099958375096, -0.04342298582196236, -0.02094622515141964, -0.0015488914214074612, -0.00713106244802475, 0.034054845571517944, -0.006546133663505316, 0.020054969936609268, 0.04148510843515396, -0.0007226063753478229, -0.006603260524570942, -0.009760424494743347, 0.016567455604672432, 0.016626784577965736, 0.02924131602048874, 0.041046466678380966, 0.06395092606544495, -0.04080457612872124, 0.021165091544389725, 0.011079340241849422, 0.031539320945739746, 0.04899391904473305, -0.03048604354262352, -0.026157310232520103, -0.058360304683446884, -0.03595605492591858, 0.022653095424175262, 0.029505407437682152, -0.011310224421322346, -0.004799763206392527, 0.03492214158177376, 0.008947547525167465, -0.07666676491498947, 0.023530416190624237, 0.024510718882083893, -0.012188443914055824, -0.013528183102607727, -0.03058629110455513, 0.00896860845386982, 0.0094213942065835, 0.005415626335889101, 0.035200558602809906, 0.017341308295726776, -0.00998250488191843, 0.05436594411730766, 0.03684854134917259, -0.01304552610963583, -0.032879285514354706, -0.010263204574584961, 0.008385504595935345, -0.0071678427048027515, 0.012800406664609909, -0.046359699219465256, -0.019670745357871056, 0.04757056012749672, 0.013744487427175045, 0.05898965150117874, 0.007217037957161665, -0.0937075987458229, 0.017915090546011925, 0.03857862576842308, -0.000538505322765559, -0.034769926220178604, 0.00012774708739016205, -0.005625284742563963, -0.05152611434459686, 0.018411407247185707, 0.019877305254340172, 0.02346586249768734, -0.02779063954949379, -0.02288946323096752, 0.0022288996260613203, -0.017286375164985657, -0.028873829171061516, 0.015017734840512276, -0.012374752201139927, -0.005252022296190262, -0.02356138825416565, -0.034159716218709946, -0.054238203912973404, 0.001278277370147407, -0.021074119955301285, 0.051260411739349365, -0.023758625611662865, -0.028530683368444443, 0.003541130805388093, 0.04686497151851654, -0.028333263471722603, -0.016940966248512268, 0.0116066699847579, 0.02074308507144451, -0.031762465834617615, 0.010701711289584637, -0.01712837442755699, -0.00397837907075882, 0.04150225967168808, 0.005451209843158722, -0.02208821102976799, 0.018586013466119766, -0.0013852432603016496, 0.050471775233745575, 0.02991562895476818, -0.011268500238656998, 0.025664718821644783, 0.025973651558160782, -0.05310419201850891, -0.029389891773462296, -0.020280590280890465, -0.005942037329077721, -0.045076753944158554, -0.042380623519420624, -0.04869366064667702, -0.008189857937395573, -0.039424244314432144, 0.01737399958074093, 0.000880065665114671, 0.020007673650979996, -0.054513804614543915, -0.0114818774163723, -0.001388902892358601, -0.009385485202074051, -0.007370258215814829, -0.02349734865128994, -0.02098858542740345, 0.01615109108388424, 0.02840196155011654, -0.031188253313302994, -0.025891924276947975, -0.0489715151488781, -0.016171978786587715, 0.015308104455471039, 0.0024008655454963446, 0.020113585516810417, -0.036610689014196396, -0.050056323409080505, 0.02662830613553524, -0.0007873086724430323, 0.007721997797489166, -0.03126509487628937, 0.010943282395601273, 0.0313199944794178, -0.08353783190250397, -0.0035358548630028963, 0.02964388020336628, -0.045685358345508575, 0.02895607054233551, -0.021618613973259926, 0.007826048880815506, -0.01808662712574005, -0.01281723938882351, -0.0784854143857956, -0.040768399834632874, 0.057952363044023514, -0.055169299244880676, -0.06553518027067184, 0.00012851129577029496, -0.035598888993263245, -0.024420615285634995, -0.04732276499271393, 0.050927307456731796, 0.026082385331392288, -0.03053758107125759, 0.004683708306401968, -0.006360506638884544, -0.025853851810097694, 0.005424519069492817, 0.041322506964206696, -0.019777772948145866, -0.003351941704750061, -0.02052488550543785, -0.015472080558538437, 0.0321161262691021, 0.048806332051754, -0.029864754527807236, 0.04441405460238457, -0.034707095474004745, -0.04094871133565903, 0.02279757894575596, -0.0009812384378165007, 0.0019462262280285358, 0.00368324457667768, 0.013358954340219498, -0.012321536429226398, -0.027762671932578087, -0.011292305774986744, -0.00705754803493619, 0.013712082989513874, -0.022584956139326096, -0.001207036548294127, 0.00729821203276515, -0.005450904369354248, 0.029238102957606316, 0.01571485586464405, -0.011691984720528126, 0.02375224605202675, 0.05163702741265297, 0.0019122548401355743, 0.0052742608822882175, -0.0017635979456827044, 0.008475003764033318, -0.008836286142468452, -0.015112703666090965, 0.04770898073911667, -0.0035143569111824036, 0.013841081410646439, -0.009671157225966454, -0.007565943989902735, -0.011274963617324829, 0.03374897688627243, 0.05166013911366463, -0.03159872442483902, 0.09310578554868698, 0.0724911242723465, 0.025381598621606827, -0.021417684853076935, -0.025728240609169006, -0.03467918932437897, 0.02964426763355732, 0.016246913000941277, 0.09921266883611679, -0.036621786653995514, -0.005822427570819855, 0.02875438518822193, 0.014590184204280376, -0.003193128388375044, 0.0634269118309021, -0.007023826707154512, 0.03712045028805733, 0.0009404108859598637, -0.0013422452611848712, -0.052626922726631165, 0.06641282141208649, -0.003910276107490063, 0.03845427930355072, -0.0017047696746885777, -0.03275987133383751, 0.017089348286390305, 0.04742680490016937, 0.020408058539032936, -0.07418612390756607, -0.04228396341204643, -0.044079240411520004, 0.011134305968880653, 0.017148835584521294, 0.023121776059269905, 0.0027260836213827133, 0.0072438460774719715, 0.009184618480503559, -0.012101738713681698, 0.04768180102109909, 0.011705621145665646, -0.08051817119121552, -0.056133631616830826, -0.04115289822220802, 0.011424376629292965, 0.008245152421295643, 0.03616795316338539, 0.0009454627288505435, -0.022544654086232185, 0.012490850873291492, -0.01594555750489235, 0.008261657319962978, 0.0345945842564106, 0.01929214596748352, 0.07958775758743286, -0.022368548437952995, 0.04450511932373047, -0.027315830811858177, -0.0052327960729599, 0.11722919344902039, 0.06290023028850555, 0.018815062940120697, -0.06619863957166672, 0.0206903163343668, -0.0164052564650774, -0.03599545359611511, 0.006209076847881079, 0.002906110370531678, 0.023139791563153267, -0.006857685744762421, 0.0462271086871624, 0.04751049354672432, -0.028194855898618698, 0.016320114955306053, 0.059470996260643005, -0.05167911946773529, -0.02470524236559868, 0.018992969766259193, -0.022442229092121124, 0.022480374202132225, -0.008923525922000408, -0.03350207582116127, -0.007929409854114056, 0.03612051159143448, -0.0056321630254387856, -0.03762012720108032, -0.03754222020506859, 0.009187980554997921, 0.03068540059030056, -0.023670416325330734, 0.006765061058104038, 0.023156723007559776, -0.0006033334066160023, 0.017810095101594925, 0.010776983574032784, -0.01334992703050375, 0.00901301670819521, -0.022156838327646255, 0.08080271631479263, 0.04111652076244354, -0.043877918273210526, -0.019231081008911133, -0.007460653781890869, -0.0011609538923949003, -0.030773304402828217, -0.01728871278464794, 0.00286783161573112, 0.019132385030388832, -0.011877776123583317, -0.01972009800374508, -0.016227267682552338, 0.016382625326514244, -0.01476989220827818, -0.034492943435907364, 0.01796807162463665, 0.05342739075422287, -0.049661267548799515, -0.006850942503660917, -0.0032760242465883493, -0.029405036941170692, -0.010004926472902298, 0.024379225447773933, -0.0161274541169405, -0.07003096491098404, -0.01628079265356064, -0.014804219827055931, 0.08071237802505493, 0.003799932776018977, -0.020816396921873093, 0.022945482283830643, -0.010835830122232437, -0.032582420855760574, -0.058343306183815, 0.004870788659900427, 0.0068945433013141155, 0.029854636639356613, -0.00521856127306819, -0.009362177923321724, -0.008309808559715748, -0.01940195821225643, 0.015643548220396042, -0.01610349677503109, 0.029388487339019775, -0.04237412288784981, -0.023029819130897522, 0.05511103570461273, 0.034377653151750565, -0.010158187709748745, 0.010792742483317852, -0.03437758982181549, 0.03914983198046684, 0.001950675155967474, -0.057978782802820206, -0.023239918053150177, 0.005228665191680193, -0.028774918988347054, 0.011625569313764572, 0.017480717971920967, 0.029793400317430496, 0.04277091473340988, -0.005244287196546793, -0.03716230019927025, 0.019435087218880653, -0.005922441836446524, 0.029657065868377686, -0.008015318773686886, -0.04693329706788063, -0.0009887553751468658, -0.0003933952539227903, 0.047773946076631546, -0.06320128589868546, 0.02537890151143074, -0.022404950112104416, -0.0228700153529644, 0.038282837718725204, 0.033129241317510605, -0.022175533697009087, 0.04086839035153389, -0.004200662486255169, 0.00788414292037487, -0.053554799407720566, 0.01507131103426218, -0.006170636508613825, 0.01175325084477663, -0.006741057615727186, 0.005843839142471552, 0.0023836614564061165, 0.011558073572814465, -0.02702474035322666, -0.01310040894895792, 0.0600200779736042, 0.01625785045325756, -0.04204313084483147, 0.009425356052815914, 0.00877822283655405, -0.0007972916937433183, 0.05126691237092018, -0.03813795745372772, -0.006966039538383484, 0.030262038111686707, -0.06899193674325943, -0.03436177223920822, 0.013806496746838093, -0.03334452584385872, 0.007877910509705544, 0.03810964524745941, 0.017603984102606773, 0.0003418641572352499, 0.02272610552608967, -0.004643639549612999, -0.01544211246073246, -0.004848069977015257, -0.0037509449757635593, -0.008708161301910877, -0.007933299988508224, -0.005879505537450314, -0.0017955368384718895, -0.0482509545981884, 0.044258780777454376, 0.035831518471241, 0.018389325588941574, -0.02876412868499756, 0.07523272186517715, 0.00041650712955743074, -0.004988391883671284, 0.019579919055104256, -0.0056564887054264545, 0.01879572682082653, 0.0018300395458936691, 0.020983807742595673, 0.041623279452323914, 0.012497923336923122, 0.006612531840801239, -0.08022242784500122, 0.006259298883378506, -0.020907314494252205, 0.013011510483920574, 0.035192664712667465, -0.03237660601735115, 0.023422375321388245, 0.018367497250437737, -0.09416414797306061, 0.004814988933503628, -0.008552104234695435, -0.020219337195158005, -0.04297942668199539, 0.015221224166452885, -0.036086879670619965, 0.0720786303281784, 0.004060165025293827, 0.019954297691583633, 0.038364775478839874, 0.0070998878218233585, -0.018890757113695145, 0.006589139811694622, -0.018260221928358078, -0.01751004531979561, 0.030635152012109756, -0.018535198643803596, 0.07090408354997635, -0.032316695898771286, -0.014874236658215523, 0.03862164542078972, 0.01868886500597, 0.00011101873678853735, 0.004424145445227623, 0.020674409344792366, 0.01826835237443447, 0.02858259156346321, 0.000491649319883436, 0.012251004576683044, 0.010779251344501972, 0.0124069107696414, -0.004622723441570997, 0.06455870717763901, -0.013588840141892433, 0.013693160377442837, -0.009030334651470184, 0.022422760725021362, 0.003545677987858653, 0.014886659570038319, 0.03147129714488983, -0.05236731469631195, -0.0022537040058523417, -0.045574139803647995, -0.027362089604139328, -0.017819510772824287, 0.010668533854186535, -0.01975325122475624, 0.004793307278305292, 0.022355658933520317, 0.01422572135925293, 0.008243594318628311, 0.00890293437987566, -0.07168867439031601, -0.05515940114855766, 0.04828409105539322, 0.04654160887002945, -0.017853813245892525, -0.011039643548429012, -0.0075688413344323635, 0.02481560781598091, -0.0068902368657290936, -0.00775208929553628, 0.01415114663541317, -0.03886931389570236, 0.015563157387077808, -0.0347176119685173, -0.012471642345190048, 0.04386235773563385, -0.012981784529983997, 0.004698712378740311, -0.07971679419279099, 0.08799394220113754, 0.01207252312451601, 0.010359733365476131, -0.013286051340401173, 0.0050966148264706135, 0.01947774551808834, 0.0004799696907866746, 0.04321576654911041, -0.02422552928328514, 0.011689522303640842, -0.02358998730778694, 0.00473029725253582, -0.024025626480579376, 0.010507669299840927, 0.009982780553400517, 0.003088329453021288, 0.0026977176312357187, -0.026392659172415733, -0.02391888201236725, 0.03268323093652725, 0.020699141547083855, 0.02301526814699173, -0.02880508080124855, 0.02956635132431984, 0.014863730408251286, -0.05107782408595085, -0.010045327246189117, -0.006059959530830383, -0.01278501283377409, 0.08856502175331116, -0.004301180597394705, 0.004440202843397856, 0.0005674940184690058, 0.03316635265946388, -0.02697192132472992, 0.024016818031668663, -0.02404463104903698, -0.009024085476994514, -0.0023235175758600235, 0.0010536171030253172, -0.006282192654907703, -0.02531960979104042, -0.021705716848373413, 0.03508567065000534, -0.042676445096731186, -0.01950407400727272, 0.03013494797050953, 0.018924877047538757, 0.06647193431854248, -0.02244480699300766, 0.033021826297044754, 0.0032942406833171844, -0.0055173649452626705, 0.020874233916401863, 0.015418539755046368, 0.029801173135638237, -0.0012661287328228354, -0.005794708151370287, 0.02470850758254528, -0.020951496437191963, 0.041869159787893295, 0.008485388942062855, 0.05024697259068489, -0.010973343625664711, -0.01601487770676613, 0.02998591586947441, -0.01113926898688078, 0.054498717188835144, 0.02827298641204834, -0.029583273455500603, 0.1040608286857605, -0.02930598147213459, -0.010643040761351585, -0.02843783050775528, 0.02692112885415554, -0.05463050678372383, -0.019892750307917595, 0.012776684947311878, 0.022204114124178886, 0.028379222378134727, -0.00761684775352478, -0.0036525577306747437, 0.005311057902872562, 0.0035146845038980246, -0.023600855842232704, 0.026151038706302643, 0.004191058687865734, 0.009511628188192844, -0.018410321325063705, -0.0017496546497568488, -0.023095963522791862, -0.02743644081056118, 0.044634126126766205, 0.016983715817332268, 0.06714832782745361, 0.004085499327629805, -0.05162134766578674, -0.011535568162798882, 0.05514891818165779, -0.09262633323669434, -0.026976028457283974, 0.01411800179630518, 0.017319805920124054, 0.0053281281143426895, -0.018957512453198433 ]
<p>Here is the problem: I am making a machine learning algorithm that takes the inputs and outputs of some software I've written, and I don't know how many datalines to produce to get results that are a 'good' fit. I realize the answer is 'the more the better' but I'm looking for any sort of minimum requirement. I also realize that the greater the number of variables the greater the number of datalines required. </p> <p>So I'm looking for a rule of thumb for number of variables to number of datalines. </p>
74,024
[ -0.03139329329133034, 0.021741444244980812, -0.026535851880908012, 0.0030477959662675858, 0.027583574876189232, 0.020013395696878433, -0.011653280816972256, -0.05038904771208763, 0.03122139535844326, 0.025128427892923355, 0.045496221631765366, 0.023890256881713867, 0.02240762859582901, -0.0022426603827625513, -0.0028151387814432383, 0.005772939417511225, -0.01744917593896389, 0.0020718241576105356, 0.03219267725944519, 0.0026907066348940134, -0.015749860554933548, 0.010209371335804462, 0.04701980948448181, -0.0006302472320385277, -0.022496508434414864, 0.04280403256416321, 0.043348394334316254, 0.010802313685417175, 0.018839692696928978, 0.03167692571878433, -0.008836845867335796, -0.0447770431637764, 0.03597322106361389, 0.08362879604101181, 0.04402310773730278, 0.0051125031895935535, -0.02746228501200676, -0.009838216006755829, 0.00048223193152807653, 0.025808263570070267, -0.017098713666200638, -0.003422540845349431, 0.025190100073814392, -0.002224588068202138, 0.003778215730562806, 0.004975413903594017, 0.005029712338000536, -0.03115147538483143, 0.0013436096487566829, -0.06589258462190628, 0.08425720781087875, -0.005627649370580912, 0.054761048406362534, 0.023398524150252342, -0.018772203475236893, -0.010249141603708267, 0.06685610860586166, 0.06262939423322678, 0.0028665687423199415, -0.056078340858221054, -0.004096649121493101, -0.022349869832396507, 0.0058727506548166275, -0.009440033696591854, -0.03176054731011391, 0.04380388557910919, -0.019826622679829597, 0.02581174112856388, 0.023725882172584534, -0.02597513049840927, 0.021730143576860428, 0.008434123359620571, 0.0493444949388504, -0.006256064400076866, -0.0216961856931448, 0.01116726640611887, 0.03281167894601822, 0.025334447622299194, 0.038367196917533875, 0.03302815183997154, -0.0060555399395525455, 0.011945754289627075, 0.01904011331498623, 0.018646258860826492, 0.023960145190358162, 0.008266035467386246, 0.08825276792049408, -0.02629707381129265, 0.014123816974461079, 0.0224528219550848, -0.013136039488017559, 0.01662920042872429, 0.0608157254755497, 0.02193017490208149, -0.018712777644395828, 0.0001742213062243536, -0.01190242450684309, 0.0357135608792305, 0.002561695408076048, -0.023748110979795456, -0.008040818385779858, -0.030088497325778008, 0.0006710723973810673, 0.06413621455430984, -0.016968825832009315, 0.02807527780532837, -0.006552426144480705, -0.008409411646425724, 0.0004949734429828823, -0.0077870311215519905, 0.014085543341934681, 0.016712449491024017, -0.011031110771000385, -0.007012784946709871, -0.01424854900687933, -0.007434432860463858, -0.004280126187950373, -0.007883705198764801, 0.06534877419471741, 0.08947665989398956, 0.028750503435730934, -0.049233853816986084, 0.05566024035215378, -0.0012121808249503374, -0.04435253143310547, 0.03566429018974304, 0.0015158547321334481, -0.020878488197922707, -0.03256211802363396, 0.028924889862537384, -0.03274067863821983, -0.01463684905320406, 0.04345623403787613, -0.005502264015376568, 0.013818434439599514, -0.004604842979460955, -0.07107283920049667, -0.07509862631559372, 0.015602445229887962, -0.030499273911118507, 0.021779745817184448, -0.050391070544719696, 0.03663191199302673, 0.00859095063060522, 0.06901257485151291, -0.005279765464365482, 0.058103229850530624, 0.02979288063943386, 0.015473526902496815, -0.03775506094098091, -0.047691456973552704, -0.005155458115041256, -0.03808911144733429, -0.021450521424412727, 0.0013726049801334739, -0.03924259543418884, 0.029879875481128693, 0.06395585834980011, 0.0023447799030691385, 0.011127431876957417, -0.011868512257933617, -0.015745192766189575, 0.009453844279050827, -0.013040849007666111, 0.009817428886890411, -0.0438600592315197, 0.037522561848163605, 0.009436650201678276, 0.047656524926424026, 0.05492962524294853, -0.003767092479392886, 0.00489058718085289, -0.0006079758168198168, 0.020827261731028557, 0.06650199741125107, 0.005724532064050436, 0.0012448948109522462, -0.01226702518761158, 0.011756877414882183, 0.04283416271209717, -0.010254640132188797, -0.05859861522912979, 0.010969044640660286, 0.03360975161194801, 0.016752347350120544, 0.03258281201124191, 0.012453905306756496, -0.019251734018325806, 0.03387822210788727, -0.019529689103364944, -0.021977417171001434, -0.04239824786782265, 0.024899816140532494, -0.038115814328193665, -0.025149652734398842, -0.012716773897409439, 0.021047793328762054, -0.00272273737937212, -0.024988509714603424, -0.03131084516644478, -0.019369274377822876, -0.006626191083341837, 0.026301691308617592, -0.031791090965270996, 0.00784935150295496, 0.078859344124794, 0.031363148242235184, -0.02483321540057659, 0.04169369488954544, -0.03946363925933838, -0.01626349426805973, -0.015922773629426956, -0.02305690199136734, -0.009781263768672943, -0.020962977781891823, -0.009090653620660305, 0.029351919889450073, 0.021832400932908058, -0.009847154840826988, 0.02192266471683979, -0.04785821586847305, 0.09221968054771423, 0.06286971271038055, 0.03992903605103493, -0.013718105852603912, -0.01372631173580885, 0.012234521098434925, -0.0111557487398386, -0.012765043415129185, 0.023579951375722885, -0.06670650094747543, 0.01078409980982542, 0.011406052857637405, 0.01604035496711731, -0.04649677500128746, -0.0009199882624670863, 0.06832488626241684, 0.04545549303293228, 0.02111300826072693, 0.03666580840945244, -0.04975523799657822, -0.00026618994888849556, -0.0018991829128935933, -0.0004935381002724171, -0.011082325130701065, 0.012469722889363766, 0.008653693832457066, 0.058880891650915146, 0.0005718228057958186, 0.02148917131125927, -0.014849024824798107, 0.02120985835790634, -0.021272936835885048, -0.0006915781414136291, 0.0007421279442496598, -0.03106202557682991, 0.04832770675420761, -0.05406608060002327, -0.002952135168015957, 0.03963156044483185, 0.011813409626483917, 0.013378472998738289, 0.0015902519226074219, -0.030549606308341026, 0.012389364652335644, 0.01987576298415661, -0.029044630005955696, -0.012548577040433884, 0.02611541375517845, -0.05568898841738701, 0.006386531982570887, -0.0024342576507478952, -0.036776985973119736, -0.0628800019621849, 0.03061201050877571, 0.02211330458521843, -0.02088754065334797, 0.057560671120882034, -0.009049908258020878, -0.004437226336449385, 0.008155100978910923, -0.041261326521635056, 0.022731229662895203, -0.03511710837483406, -0.03814006596803665, -0.03854895010590553, 0.0036412167828530073, -0.024250326678156853, 0.05701279640197754, -0.022591160610318184, -0.009701211005449295, 0.03107822872698307, -0.012937256135046482, -0.03670189529657364, -0.03415984660387039, -0.013755145482718945, 0.003591721411794424, 0.006272187456488609, -0.03060508519411087, 0.014466791413724422, 0.013686958700418472, -0.06737910956144333, -0.0035343244671821594, -0.04223901405930519, -0.036457229405641556, -0.04907316341996193, -0.01168327871710062, 0.02977222390472889, 0.0024043889716267586, -0.002521030604839325, 0.0175058301538229, -0.05586574226617813, 0.012974870391190052, -0.04989784583449364, -0.07363206893205643, 0.0371159203350544, 0.013831538148224354, 0.047841090708971024, 0.007800292689353228, -0.025466950610280037, 0.06087896600365639, -0.004505945835262537, -0.04703725874423981, -0.038552187383174896, -0.016911474987864494, -0.014414044097065926, -0.007630307227373123, 0.0194834116846323, 0.008298649452626705, 0.007949575781822205, 0.006890001241117716, 0.010732089169323444, 0.025458578020334244, 0.03855706751346588, -0.005708279553800821, 0.015641601756215096, 0.019830575212836266, 0.008036734536290169, -0.007054425310343504, 0.022788362577557564, 0.027335625141859055, -0.04172666743397713, 0.020331332460045815, -0.02292473427951336, 0.006767391227185726, -0.014035151340067387, -0.009433034807443619, 0.007818269543349743, -0.030419325456023216, 0.03962666168808937, -0.02051682211458683, -0.022466352209448814, -0.0003042480966541916, -0.025233132764697075, -0.013823142275214195, 0.03697977587580681, 0.0348614826798439, -0.05650443956255913, -0.03084762580692768, 0.04662084951996803, 0.010924416594207287, -0.004826504271477461, -0.007581331767141819, -0.015761714428663254, -0.030927494168281555, -0.004357157275080681, -0.011559541337192059, -0.009122714400291443, 0.029481420293450356, 0.038168516010046005, 0.04022872820496559, 0.012531109154224396, -0.03618570789694786, 0.02232053130865097, -0.08259811252355576, 0.006137587130069733, -0.027871565893292427, 0.07826466858386993, -0.0007338262512348592, 0.04600813239812851, 0.012641356326639652, -0.049879129976034164, 0.03483768180012703, -0.009106220677495003, -0.05856987461447716, 0.020285742357373238, -0.03691225126385689, 0.0030526183545589447, 0.026646768674254417, -0.015620111487805843, 0.029222358018159866, -0.05138080194592476, 0.017269082367420197, 0.008462293073534966, 0.029992448166012764, -0.04517607018351555, 0.024036649614572525, -0.037093985825777054, -0.003351049730554223, -0.004604110959917307, 0.008369403891265392, 0.004594575613737106, 0.017659222707152367, 0.012412269599735737, 0.04151774197816849, -0.002452682936564088, -0.04861079528927803, -0.011464681476354599, -0.00028234024648554623, -0.015953555703163147, 0.05629885941743851, 0.025865228846669197, 0.02531209960579872, -0.039918508380651474, 0.01477135345339775, -0.041446503251791, 0.007063241209834814, 0.04783241078257561, -0.039277780801057816, -0.01587040163576603, -0.04116830974817276, -0.013151824474334717, 0.022781215608119965, 0.01955447532236576, 0.02150283008813858, 0.0011587482877075672, 0.03478413075208664, -0.021407222375273705, -0.05505834147334099, 0.01632239669561386, 0.10035621374845505, -0.006642663385719061, -0.010049748234450817, -0.017656465992331505, -0.01844247244298458, -0.008127103559672832, -0.0036519605200737715, -0.005303975660353899, 0.014502502977848053, -0.007721416652202606, -0.024329693987965584, -0.0016549847787246108, -0.04031531512737274, -0.026689643040299416, 0.00774325942620635, 0.04442445933818817, 0.04935756325721741, -0.012243302538990974, -0.029913507401943207, 0.018194230273365974, 0.07599799335002899, 0.01987200416624546, 0.03180234506726265, 0.005266902502626181, -0.09721900522708893, 0.0043662781827151775, 0.05957340821623802, 0.04446804150938988, -0.041613154113292694, -0.018086520954966545, -0.022928742691874504, 0.008216692134737968, 0.04294858127832413, -0.0363476499915123, 0.03093179315328598, -0.013650926761329174, -0.014409513212740421, -0.025798102840781212, -0.03802013024687767, -0.027899429202079773, -0.010280020534992218, -0.011670654639601707, 0.08408822119235992, 0.004179404582828283, -0.017650486901402473, -0.02333032712340355, 0.018333127722144127, 0.006750988308340311, 0.04719219356775284, 0.009044792503118515, -0.049170415848493576, 0.009585559368133545, 0.012807733379304409, -0.0216391459107399, -0.055097952485084534, -0.009618940763175488, 0.008705426938831806, 0.010583634488284588, 0.007369404658675194, -0.014373105950653553, -0.040492646396160126, 0.010208675637841225, 0.014602668583393097, -0.02767217345535755, -0.025403888896107674, -0.04581861197948456, 0.007771479431539774, 0.009637072682380676, 0.042316142469644547, 0.04921005293726921, -0.006860838737338781, 0.008850958198308945, 0.025742292404174805, -0.024633364751935005, 0.020322920754551888, -0.03584056347608566, -0.03823726251721382, -0.03119228407740593, -0.022316791117191315, -0.023000821471214294, 0.010397113859653473, -0.01339287031441927, 0.014901258982717991, -0.04479535296559334, -0.03867020085453987, -0.010383755899965763, 0.04878292232751846, 0.02688416838645935, -0.031800735741853714, 0.0252614077180624, 0.010051479563117027, 0.007527132052928209, -0.002242304850369692, 0.030900422483682632, -0.019866257905960083, 0.010631856508553028, 0.021497396752238274, -0.02636508271098137, -0.012210709042847157, -0.0483015775680542, -0.0315423458814621, -0.009933708235621452, -0.019828395918011665, 0.024386996403336525, 0.009103052318096161, 0.039829809218645096, -0.0048500122502446175, -0.0589265301823616, 0.020076308399438858, 0.042456913739442825, -0.006787218153476715, 0.030681537464261055, -0.049602530896663666, 0.02741525135934353, -0.0811983272433281, 0.015834901481866837, -0.04380473122000694, -0.06790521740913391, 0.012307098135352135, 0.014362765476107597, -0.010458923876285553, -0.013968409039080143, 0.017085377126932144, -0.017544792965054512, -0.022920062765479088, -0.03362023085355759, 0.02899184077978134, -0.030760062858462334, -0.024199049919843674, 0.004839172121137381, 0.01391314622014761, 0.06327471137046814, 0.0317545086145401, 0.008572508580982685, 0.015695704147219658, -0.03445380553603172, -0.0012345280265435576, -0.019168002530932426, 0.0019930265843868256, -0.032216839492321014, -0.02430717833340168, -0.03643845021724701, -0.00541852368041873, 0.04117899015545845, -0.026748618111014366, 0.05882492661476135, -0.013545166701078415, -0.023579692468047142, -0.033498115837574005, -0.03618162125349045, 0.023180348798632622, -0.04413897171616554, -0.005386296194046736, -0.005028332583606243, -0.005744062829762697, 0.010140793398022652, 0.01871427148580551, -0.010099798440933228, 0.039821211248636246, -0.00006132516864454374, 0.014272673055529594, 0.050043366849422455, 0.026283204555511475, -0.01647065207362175, -0.023862222209572792, -0.02674107998609543, 0.04514286667108536, 0.022390112280845642, 0.012190270237624645, 0.00442990567535162, 0.03239459916949272, -0.03294003754854202, -0.04808492586016655, -0.01616991125047207, -0.03989493474364281, 0.05864887684583664, 0.024689041078090668, 0.04842980206012726, 0.05922368913888931, 0.039524562656879425, 0.008697613142430782, -0.02073568105697632, -0.013016534969210625, -0.006740238983184099, 0.033066149801015854, 0.05796351283788681, 0.009522036649286747, -0.02864181622862816, 0.022258011624217033, 0.0030243713408708572, 0.03934750333428383, 0.020430589094758034, -0.012620948255062103, -0.004661440849304199, 0.014110558666288853, -0.058690592646598816, -0.06007850915193558, 0.0115390345454216, -0.027966244146227837, 0.02134612947702408, -0.0030605620704591274, -0.02308787778019905, 0.030661163851618767, 0.029813673347234726, 0.012597707100212574, -0.013197955675423145, -0.029826240614056587, -0.013384629972279072, -0.0036243705544620752, 0.020835814997553825, -0.03902482986450195, 0.0058886040933430195, 0.005589506588876247, 0.003190414048731327, 0.015541384927928448, 0.04357440024614334, -0.029056787490844727, -0.05700166895985603, -0.04662642627954483, -0.030018549412488937, -0.060237154364585876, 0.050092242658138275, 0.031087378039956093, -0.04306846112012863, -0.019948361441493034, 0.0006864487077109516, 0.01371472142636776, -0.017041964456439018, 0.03666408360004425, -0.011568035930395126, 0.056272607296705246, -0.002157761948183179, -0.004134617280215025, -0.0027246212121099234, 0.008268197998404503, 0.09069057554006577, 0.12947680056095123, 0.053430069237947464, -0.06565682590007782, 0.04219236597418785, -0.03898060694336891, -0.03887973353266716, -0.016188176348805428, 0.03189624845981598, -0.01910778507590294, 0.005920449271798134, 0.03601616621017456, -0.017153140157461166, 0.0011641255114227533, 0.02338768169283867, 0.06694334745407104, -0.03713670372962952, -0.016564225777983665, 0.008542287163436413, 0.01326837483793497, 0.009929199703037739, -0.00012658783816732466, -0.02640184760093689, -0.014873624779284, 0.0003398111439310014, -0.05287742242217064, 0.0194467194378376, -0.00855084415525198, 0.03600388392806053, -0.0016783025348559022, -0.011815453879535198, -0.005848539061844349, 0.001976050902158022, 0.02230096235871315, -0.02999771013855934, -0.011959141120314598, 0.010362452827394009, -0.045722924172878265, -0.02987818978726864, 0.018645357340574265, -0.0036518226843327284, 0.00005502804560819641, -0.004633672069758177, -0.010724266059696674, -0.03502936661243439, -0.022557364776730537, -0.016276558861136436, 0.02676682360470295, 0.017166754230856895, -0.010531970299780369, 0.005533989053219557, 0.045354489237070084, 0.04073811322450638, -0.05724501237273216, 0.00818618107587099, 0.034677743911743164, 0.04693584516644478, -0.04059198126196861, -0.001828426611609757, -0.009822479449212551, 0.0348515659570694, -0.016035860404372215, -0.00009973308624466881, 0.03191250190138817, -0.01185715664178133, -0.0072957309894263744, -0.02262357994914055, 0.0627828985452652, -0.01072776224464178, 0.0045135109685361385, -0.013778389431536198, -0.016211198642849922, -0.007423874456435442, -0.005653263069689274, 0.028377767652273178, 0.017963368445634842, -0.02998296171426773, -0.02468106336891651, -0.012052163481712341, -0.020973550155758858, -0.022142067551612854, 0.024838564917445183, 0.010922596789896488, -0.004659151658415794, -0.03244524076581001, 0.015664881095290184, -0.006177231203764677, 0.029164927080273628, 0.042312752455472946, 0.045149482786655426, -0.0050229355692863464, 0.03006078489124775, 0.022641994059085846, -0.03437608852982521, 0.015284821391105652, -0.016648991033434868, -0.052107073366642, -0.0007245169836096466, -0.02238781936466694, 0.07012881338596344, 0.01653849147260189, 0.03053700551390648, 0.0028771283105015755, 0.053041066974401474, -0.013574818149209023, 0.004137213341891766, -0.005812914110720158, -0.06735797971487045, 0.009705648757517338, -0.004098163917660713, 0.0035555714275687933, -0.05277054384350777, -0.010063113644719124, -0.0461358018219471, -0.03800075873732567, 0.02476430870592594, -0.019190559163689613, -0.05121009424328804, 0.05301893875002861, 0.009390872903168201, 0.014767682179808617, -0.026507634669542313, 0.0174538753926754, -0.04195890575647354, 0.0020743103232234716, 0.008116945624351501, -0.019631551578640938, 0.006158190313726664, -0.016163986176252365, -0.007434820756316185, 0.015319540165364742, 0.05187459662556648, 0.02814636006951332, 0.025856517255306244, -0.009157681837677956, 0.019641250371932983, 0.0021636439487338066, 0.057883016765117645, -0.08177664130926132, -0.017429107800126076, 0.036830734461545944, -0.07034473866224289, -0.0008075190708041191, 0.023571111261844635, -0.018367083743214607, 0.038734741508960724, 0.01609068736433983, -0.03985892981290817, -0.04285154119133949, 0.06435126811265945, 0.010694553144276142, -0.006631676573306322, 0.010012831538915634, 0.008626743219792843, 0.02751266397535801, -0.0028469653334468603, 0.014306816272437572, -0.01290493831038475, 0.0064591034315526485, -0.014096401631832123, 0.025371339172124863, 0.027411548420786858, -0.015620972029864788, 0.012031124904751778, 0.024148710072040558, 0.024950463324785233, 0.027420882135629654, -0.01722765527665615, 0.045783642679452896, 0.019049838185310364, -0.03722485899925232, -0.0039215413853526115, 0.035101816058158875, 0.05096181109547615, -0.08346696197986603, -0.009316015988588333, -0.0037186688277870417, 0.026774698868393898, 0.009392959997057915, -0.04515692591667175, 0.02209075726568699, 0.03509325534105301, -0.027324512600898743, -0.001616181107237935, -0.01964687556028366, -0.004621502943336964, -0.028169114142656326, 0.0022159137297421694, 0.006804773584008217, 0.006806172896176577, 0.02184203639626503, 0.03859756514430046, 0.03793724253773689, 0.014689459465444088, -0.025190439075231552, -0.05781644955277443, -0.01640443317592144, 0.04160599038004875, -0.026149164885282516, -0.046481721103191376, -0.015723921358585358, -0.009930003434419632, -0.03375392407178879, 0.03462492302060127, -0.0024767343420535326, 0.06900177150964737, 0.028792578727006912, 0.055117953568696976, 0.039750706404447556, 0.058525294065475464, 0.013802334666252136, -0.005391930695623159, 0.003151881042867899, -0.02864708937704563, -0.024320771917700768, 0.024803558364510536, -0.020347468554973602, 0.02564389258623123, 0.030268263071775436, -0.03033595345914364, -0.04394388943910599, 0.02221035771071911, -0.006892014294862747, -0.026558617129921913, -0.004333094228059053, 0.007852098904550076, 0.010911691933870316, -0.03033052571117878, 0.014485840685665607, -0.037427593022584915, -0.014323174953460693, 0.026305576786398888, 0.00628562830388546, -0.01649048924446106, 0.005740790627896786, -0.026467377319931984, -0.024620233103632927, -0.010718614794313908, -0.015494822524487972, -0.010181249119341373, -0.06183980032801628, 0.010421201586723328, 0.0024236305616796017, -0.016155017539858818, -0.030564019456505775, -0.045694030821323395, -0.03436196967959404, 0.030039489269256592, -0.021755199879407883, 0.01088504958897829, 0.025868268683552742, -0.03580817952752113, 0.008623938076198101, -0.08184224367141724, 0.05532452464103699, 0.007506242953240871, 0.02997167408466339, -0.0442560650408268, -0.0092934500426054, -0.012786731123924255, 0.004342805594205856, 0.04793050140142441, 0.00033998567960225046, -0.0005171953234821558, -0.05049769952893257, 0.013100175186991692, -0.006995638832449913, -0.054174307733774185, 0.034717608243227005, -0.027835339307785034, -0.03068942204117775, -0.02866092324256897, -0.04781275987625122, 0.030799198895692825, -0.015956779941916466, 0.011735699139535427, 0.005142533220350742, 0.022344116121530533, 0.007736772298812866, -0.024584591388702393, 0.012669093906879425, 0.010436308570206165, -0.005831148009747267, 0.020498644560575485, -0.02096078172326088, 0.011897960677742958, 0.05660264566540718, -0.007742385379970074, -0.06445213407278061, 0.01737121120095253, -0.0291441660374403, 0.003877461887896061, -0.027194084599614143, -0.00026581744896247983, 0.01692536100745201, -0.055813755840063095, 0.041038740426301956, 0.035676393657922745, -0.018203403800725937, 0.005983700975775719, 0.04619026929140091, 0.037373136729002, 0.04485631734132767, -0.017900312319397926, 0.03018205612897873, 0.018473973497748375, -0.03342742472887039, 0.0001444152876501903, -0.009848634712398052, 0.019661007449030876, 0.025380490347743034, 0.011471997015178204, 0.03588840737938881, -0.015358584001660347, 0.05032575875520706, 0.010117222554981709, 0.00307124643586576, -0.033302776515483856, 0.0025489311665296555, -0.030167551711201668, -0.010899440385401249, -0.002837932901456952, -0.0002995941031258553, -0.026208046823740005, 0.05989820882678032, -0.06324896216392517, 0.008038416504859924, -0.059180133044719696, -0.0207033921033144, -0.025299474596977234, 0.010153042152523994, -0.020527582615613937, 0.08863861858844757, -0.0033367115538567305, 0.0333666056394577, 0.008729809895157814, -0.009941749274730682, 0.045688267797231674, -0.034044232219457626, 0.030315900221467018, -0.017243238165974617, 0.005096488166600466, -0.02348172292113304, 0.011521883308887482, -0.034663788974285126, 0.0070457723923027515, 0.05095352977514267, 0.050324857234954834, 0.014982481487095356, -0.023582816123962402, -0.019423453137278557, 0.007891171611845493, 0.011761369183659554, -0.04611299932003021, -0.023654652759432793, -0.07004716247320175, 0.008810370229184628, -0.0004740662407130003, -0.013194441795349121 ]
<p>I have implemented a three-way anova with type III sum of squares in c++. Since some of my experiments (observations) are more important (more informative), I want to give them a higher weight in my analysis. For example, an experiment which is very important has a weight of 10, and a relatively important one has a weight of 5, and so on. To implement it, I repeat such observations in respect to its corresponding weight, 10 times, 5 times, ...<br> I used the same concept in 2way anova, but there I used the conventional formulas of Sum of Squares, because my design was balanced. So there I just multiplied the value of each observation and the number of times I have seen that to the weight.<br> Here, repeating the items makes the design matrix so big and increase the computational complexity. Now the problem is that what if I don't want to repeat them, but use a weight matrix? and what if the weights are not integer values (so I really can't repeat one item 0.3 times)?<br> I found this formula <a href="http://www.stat.umn.edu/pub/macanova/docs/manual/manchp03.pdf" rel="nofollow">here</a>: </p> <pre><code>H^=X(X'WX)-1XW </code></pre> <p>So I put my weights into W matrix and used this formula. To check if it works, I used the conventional method and repeated observations as often as the weight value, and gave it to MATLAB. But I got different SS values.</p> <p>Could you please kindly tell me how I should change this formula? </p> <p>Thanks,</p>
74,025
[ -0.037479232996702194, -0.002728494815528393, -0.010069625452160835, -0.008052018471062183, 0.05985332280397415, 0.03344029188156128, -0.025904718786478043, -0.02204040251672268, 0.027511760592460632, -0.03320147842168808, 0.011728910729289055, 0.015248576179146767, 0.04374893754720688, 0.018796376883983612, 0.03840308263897896, -0.013361331075429916, -0.025371043011546135, -0.015446257777512074, 0.011545754969120026, -0.014404397457838058, -0.01562140416353941, 0.024879958480596542, -0.022415660321712494, -0.0040141218341887, -0.031085774302482605, 0.04091604799032211, 0.01062075886875391, -0.04618018493056297, 0.07099421322345734, 0.04701988771557808, -0.029131537303328514, -0.01705329306423664, 0.033386994153261185, 0.00002746673817455303, 0.04899042472243309, 0.010797393508255482, -0.0044289277866482735, 0.008021974004805088, -0.0075384825468063354, 0.012870918959379196, -0.02886117808520794, 0.025210896506905556, -0.015693584457039833, 0.012179255485534668, 0.022551890462636948, 0.019018812105059624, -0.033242110162973404, -0.05135050415992737, 0.045368894934654236, -0.09187234938144684, 0.08754515647888184, 0.025264296680688858, 0.04022675380110741, 0.03552613407373428, -0.03437589481472969, -0.00881105661392212, 0.036042001098394394, 0.011844854801893234, 0.030827848240733147, -0.01561744511127472, 0.019053682684898376, -0.003740179119631648, 0.02960275486111641, -0.012442132458090782, -0.02684953063726425, 0.005660638213157654, -0.021204302087426186, -0.02916567400097847, 0.03660556301474571, -0.047916922718286514, 0.01615522988140583, 0.015262731350958347, 0.047788262367248535, -0.04120010510087013, -0.006042962893843651, -0.022591374814510345, 0.009360363706946373, -0.0029693066608160734, 0.08980588614940643, 0.025416305288672447, -0.021767007187008858, 0.05614856630563736, 0.005694607738405466, 0.05261790007352829, 0.011970173567533493, -0.01056129951030016, 0.03980083018541336, -0.01369507610797882, 0.01488642767071724, 0.028687620535492897, -0.019307229667901993, -0.004720519762486219, 0.05147426575422287, 0.022276513278484344, -0.002820746274664998, -0.009447026066482067, 0.0006318448577076197, 0.024442674592137337, -0.0026429365389049053, 0.021163707599043846, -0.0262605007737875, -0.05096092075109482, -0.030223365873098373, 0.038610514253377914, -0.03004162758588791, -0.0027742439415305853, -0.00535375252366066, 0.02758958376944065, -0.007467980030924082, -0.03362033888697624, 0.013540629297494888, 0.01771538332104683, -0.005532144568860531, -0.019019318744540215, -0.0017044885316863656, -0.014236964285373688, -0.009432393126189709, 0.012772751040756702, 0.02626369521021843, 0.07458693534135818, 0.031931765377521515, -0.049132250249385834, 0.049339231103658676, -0.052019961178302765, -0.031180081889033318, 0.02093612775206566, -0.01541505940258503, -0.008219469338655472, -0.02099354937672615, 0.07516483217477798, 0.02989010699093342, -0.03468440845608711, 0.04061082378029823, -0.018985312432050705, -0.023004526272416115, -0.01107074599713087, -0.09232042729854584, -0.06871727854013443, 0.029732050374150276, -0.004533102735877037, -0.030829129740595818, -0.04270957410335541, 0.02371593564748764, 0.04993447661399841, 0.09284353256225586, 0.03886933624744415, 0.022142091765999794, 0.03002801164984703, 0.03842296078801155, 0.02310982346534729, 0.0019000853644683957, -0.023414598777890205, -0.03839760273694992, -0.030362607911229134, 0.0006842483999207616, -0.07367099076509476, 0.02941483072936535, -0.002996073802933097, -0.003702824702486396, 0.0002525433083064854, 0.031135443598031998, 0.011242982931435108, -0.009217983111739159, 0.00008008616714505479, -0.04020221158862114, -0.013221904635429382, 0.04871682822704315, -0.021645566448569298, 0.04142902418971062, -0.004865223076194525, -0.018958372995257378, -0.017549820244312286, -0.02293592505156994, 0.06179126352071762, 0.05914714187383652, 0.012236700393259525, 0.014485666528344154, -0.04881945624947548, 0.02143264375627041, 0.035088758915662766, -0.00877019576728344, -0.04360098019242287, 0.006075965240597725, -0.014751521870493889, 0.04763203114271164, 0.02924123965203762, -0.011692799627780914, 0.01670677401125431, 0.05441969633102417, -0.025965839624404907, -0.047513481229543686, -0.06660213321447372, 0.01356764230877161, 0.0072463806718587875, -0.03820868209004402, 0.00786765106022358, -0.014349501579999924, 0.0016224690480157733, 0.02772190235555172, -0.011896701529622078, -0.01546619925647974, 0.02821493148803711, 0.06184294447302818, -0.032300226390361786, -0.008384239859879017, 0.010846134275197983, 0.04955839738249779, -0.02555261366069317, 0.06386162340641022, -0.04402227699756622, -0.01937623880803585, -0.00017406322876922786, -0.020462870597839355, -0.020121876150369644, 0.0023438388016074896, -0.03172896057367325, 0.0016299494309350848, 0.019497280940413475, -0.011639993637800217, 0.04229161515831947, -0.059906646609306335, 0.08185173571109772, 0.09239614754915237, 0.010702650062739849, 0.016257338225841522, 0.04560171067714691, 0.006737825460731983, 0.019288992509245872, -0.02412468194961548, -0.024300752207636833, -0.0056098466739058495, -0.001589987426996231, 0.0016365706687793136, 0.010588104836642742, -0.04066324234008789, 0.01001646462827921, 0.05188864842057228, 0.01172630861401558, 0.02069527842104435, 0.060944076627492905, 0.021774955093860626, -0.006772338412702084, -0.0057105254381895065, 0.014169358648359776, 0.04132217913866043, 0.022490011528134346, -0.00872240774333477, 0.044796064496040344, 0.014019455760717392, 0.0070539843291044235, -0.0007514459430240095, 0.035212598741054535, 0.0032875328324735165, 0.02424820140004158, -0.035728514194488525, -0.004850422497838736, 0.025687139481306076, -0.025537988170981407, 0.0008225603960454464, 0.043768107891082764, -0.014781875535845757, 0.01522000040858984, -0.013566230423748493, -0.03584727272391319, -0.011253979057073593, -0.012811011634767056, -0.00235556298866868, 0.01858387142419815, 0.022756187245249748, 0.009019797667860985, 0.03593785688281059, -0.03745760768651962, 0.015216270461678505, -0.0046126204542815685, 0.026160746812820435, 0.005253090523183346, 0.002519626636058092, -0.007048220839351416, -0.02861659601330757, -0.04053093120455742, -0.016194434836506844, -0.015869662165641785, -0.010047460906207561, 0.005111973732709885, -0.06599494069814682, -0.027367444708943367, -0.026241406798362732, -0.011330521665513515, 0.036455459892749786, -0.005284180864691734, -0.005056018941104412, 0.055856671184301376, 0.014235547743737698, -0.011289921589195728, -0.027178233489394188, -0.012630215846002102, -0.004258836153894663, 0.004878147970885038, -0.0034268151503056288, 0.032731927931308746, 0.036015525460243225, -0.06688227504491806, 0.048364076763391495, -0.02969246916472912, -0.022960606962442398, -0.02304190956056118, 0.00045117505942471325, -0.002028962131589651, -0.014747889712452888, 0.03289072960615158, 0.02317187935113907, -0.024893950670957565, -0.027265990152955055, -0.0401788167655468, -0.03740997239947319, -0.013552875258028507, 0.017937518656253815, 0.039028141647577286, 0.0077592781744897366, -0.0033213726710528135, 0.07892093807458878, 0.035742223262786865, -0.01766500063240528, -0.031455714255571365, -0.003627025056630373, -0.0004821046022698283, -0.03984499350190163, 0.05505416914820671, -0.004335061646997929, -0.03667649254202843, -0.026871968060731888, -0.01385758351534605, -0.015797529369592667, 0.06817495822906494, 0.02392907440662384, -0.0031554955057799816, 0.014463163912296295, 0.01107698678970337, -0.05135265365242958, 0.04344607889652252, -0.024480098858475685, 0.0010520763462409377, -0.014359869062900543, 0.04510771483182907, -0.01000749971717596, -0.012905504554510117, -0.04201478511095047, 0.0012421238934621215, -0.035648684948682785, 0.06113804876804352, -0.02904563955962658, 0.040631480515003204, 0.011561479419469833, -0.020619837567210197, -0.001273931236937642, -0.0015855852980166674, 0.03433283418416977, -0.020303091034293175, -0.007686632219702005, 0.004719233140349388, 0.051242679357528687, -0.00967186689376831, -0.021620329469442368, -0.024874767288565636, -0.0057095433585345745, 0.01682991348206997, -0.031466636806726456, -0.004988590721040964, 0.007711778860539198, 0.03578145429491997, -0.005835480522364378, 0.017143655568361282, -0.01425324846059084, -0.015008294954895973, -0.049386728554964066, -0.0315740704536438, -0.05016113445162773, 0.062290582805871964, -0.014138330705463886, 0.032309744507074356, 0.011953389272093773, -0.018557492643594742, 0.013581184670329094, -0.0709376335144043, -0.07077119499444962, 0.02570289559662342, 0.053083669394254684, -0.016844244673848152, 0.06649978458881378, -0.046059370040893555, 0.010691391304135323, -0.039357252418994904, 0.017617566511034966, 0.008026393130421638, 0.021496668457984924, -0.028156166896224022, 0.022260889410972595, 0.00235847570002079, 0.00848905835300684, -0.02790161594748497, 0.03278110548853874, 0.02484079636633396, -0.02991297096014023, 0.0008883660193532705, -0.01270996779203415, -0.07841049879789352, 0.0007198969251476228, -0.013275150209665298, 0.01309134066104889, 0.015578088350594044, 0.03672448918223381, -0.004385077860206366, 0.0676206648349762, -0.07193925976753235, 0.009929443709552288, 0.007024544291198254, 0.016989650204777718, 0.014124755747616291, 0.04288354888558388, -0.018092187121510506, -0.022913362830877304, -0.004300341010093689, 0.007383415475487709, 0.02292715571820736, -0.008829916827380657, 0.021656116470694542, 0.03894057869911194, -0.028853219002485275, -0.09342845529317856, 0.0023031095042824745, 0.06382536888122559, 0.014732141979038715, 0.008574387058615685, -0.03138674795627594, 0.036328043788671494, -0.018856339156627655, -0.022232661023736, 0.0018119701417163014, -0.0007606135914102197, 0.0013210508041083813, -0.020380893722176552, 0.0317913219332695, -0.008560612797737122, -0.002600405365228653, 0.01447972934693098, 0.031903963536024094, 0.04925879091024399, -0.0018682203954085708, -0.039536114782094955, -0.017886891961097717, 0.005996758583933115, 0.053596172481775284, 0.008079198189079762, -0.013259819708764553, -0.0605749636888504, -0.016505789011716843, 0.03338996693491936, 0.06621690839529037, -0.020297987386584282, 0.0229683518409729, -0.00989724975079298, -0.004935046657919884, 0.01120139379054308, -0.047439657151699066, 0.046817682683467865, -0.03223225101828575, 0.01986664906144142, -0.05732002854347229, 0.005592463072389364, -0.04466656967997551, 0.02106354758143425, -0.05295007675886154, 0.03718351200222969, -0.00012341119872871786, -0.020921187475323677, -0.048342831432819366, 0.008630737662315369, 0.03989075869321823, 0.021324744448065758, -0.04216223582625389, -0.018230510875582695, 0.012980770319700241, 0.026809819042682648, -0.04086250066757202, -0.07208709418773651, -0.0075742932967841625, 0.0021530247759073973, 0.007273199502378702, 0.03899892047047615, -0.01150688249617815, -0.03923269361257553, 0.003392424900084734, 0.004217245616018772, 0.000978092080913484, -0.030594073235988617, 0.0017065908759832382, 0.037542592734098434, 0.01754707843065262, 0.0010293942177668214, 0.06283202767372131, 0.038764696568250656, 0.005639899987727404, 0.016918489709496498, -0.027610424906015396, 0.007514184340834618, -0.015958527103066444, -0.017598005011677742, -0.05822813883423805, -0.00015503419854212552, -0.015227038413286209, 0.025768300518393517, 0.030987391248345375, 0.032476626336574554, -0.026899704709649086, -0.025329049676656723, -0.0031544368248432875, -0.00031965787638910115, 0.02081269957125187, -0.024957925081253052, 0.007969449274241924, 0.0506276898086071, 0.008843442425131798, -0.03949347510933876, 0.010959247127175331, -0.011426340788602829, -0.026278097182512283, 0.0029142226558178663, -0.004385179374366999, 0.006247607059776783, -0.0385601781308651, -0.015775363892316818, 0.006426061037927866, -0.03420673683285713, 0.046637773513793945, -0.02050255425274372, 0.017987390980124474, -0.003802324179559946, -0.06665289402008057, 0.025417406111955643, 0.015235275961458683, -0.0115816006436944, -0.00910973735153675, -0.03396700322628021, 0.029499460011720657, -0.0032644332386553288, 0.0026879389770329, -0.08357446640729904, -0.035418447107076645, 0.03151572868227959, 0.03908853232860565, 0.014701206237077713, 0.01473193522542715, -0.01061483658850193, -0.013342322781682014, -0.04820307716727257, -0.04911468178033829, 0.043835513293743134, -0.01639341376721859, -0.007577680982649326, 0.009218964725732803, 0.05851417034864426, 0.07783094793558121, -0.011610432527959347, -0.006770579144358635, -0.0045478614047169685, -0.04645707085728645, -0.008010984398424625, -0.00223484355956316, -0.03712109848856926, -0.048355963081121445, -0.006516949273645878, -0.019476767629384995, -0.019793644547462463, 0.0397687591612339, -0.008015425875782967, -0.011975301429629326, -0.004879834596067667, -0.006025872193276882, -0.002147400751709938, -0.040868181735277176, 0.013446585275232792, -0.015565849840641022, 0.021666619926691055, 0.0011008037254214287, 0.005761926528066397, -0.04750925675034523, 0.016300713643431664, 0.00846924539655447, -0.006197874899953604, -0.036886781454086304, -0.029972238466143608, 0.03600429370999336, 0.009050157852470875, -0.006461252458393574, -0.009987696073949337, -0.021835925057530403, 0.021388530731201172, 0.019825389608740807, -0.01594720594584942, 0.011801235377788544, 0.01731085032224655, -0.014193912968039513, -0.002446646336466074, -0.07449039816856384, 0.036030177026987076, 0.06682153791189194, -0.020609373226761818, 0.03271486610174179, 0.06771907955408096, 0.011843282729387283, -0.013836484402418137, -0.0011354752350598574, -0.01615229621529579, -0.007861686870455742, 0.03209559619426727, 0.06850830465555191, 0.0163333211094141, -0.0064385151490569115, 0.018539518117904663, 0.04321209341287613, 0.027706855908036232, 0.013230979442596436, -0.00363173964433372, 0.02597452886402607, -0.007924539968371391, -0.010206885635852814, -0.04165157303214073, 0.024967290461063385, -0.009897167794406414, 0.025352369993925095, -0.01216221321374178, -0.024206077679991722, 0.03369423374533653, 0.03349563106894493, 0.01061677560210228, -0.04452047497034073, -0.05129285901784897, -0.04968083277344704, -0.008868183009326458, 0.027109168469905853, -0.05031002685427666, 0.015691464766860008, 0.051594700664281845, 0.028799250721931458, 0.018811162561178207, 0.0028797511477023363, -0.03479824587702751, -0.07354056090116501, -0.032012470066547394, -0.026956254616379738, -0.03793266788125038, 0.03756130859255791, 0.02513473480939865, -0.045723266899585724, -0.005345780868083239, -0.0023279497399926186, 0.0305224247276783, -0.0017192622181028128, 0.04600737243890762, 0.014138804748654366, 0.023709431290626526, -0.015975646674633026, 0.02876700647175312, 0.018808141350746155, 0.02427886240184307, 0.11767171323299408, 0.04738558828830719, 0.06970137357711792, -0.02783369831740856, 0.07690208405256271, -0.024441851302981377, 0.01548962201923132, -0.025523241609334946, 0.011228390038013458, -0.0036497479304671288, -0.024597937241196632, 0.00795629620552063, 0.03188202157616615, -0.006480411160737276, 0.03902594372630119, 0.03352324292063713, -0.029302138835191727, -0.03786094859242439, 0.019130930304527283, 0.015791136771440506, 0.004114833660423756, -0.006974685937166214, -0.03419380262494087, 0.03455917537212372, -0.013051166199147701, -0.013223843649029732, 0.00606841966509819, -0.027191581204533577, -0.006289822980761528, -0.028082985430955887, 0.011952259577810764, 0.025896448642015457, -0.007989754900336266, 0.021752245724201202, -0.034018389880657196, 0.021832507103681564, 0.04002713784575462, -0.0197587963193655, 0.01948566734790802, 0.023767469450831413, 0.009052515961229801, -0.007634923793375492, -0.028067631646990776, 0.033541787415742874, -0.05185844376683235, -0.024388998746871948, -0.013091177679598331, 0.04695170000195503, -0.006630550604313612, -0.04789721220731735, 0.009399556554853916, 0.00371279357932508, 0.017973804846405983, -0.07185734063386917, -0.005106878466904163, 0.028636464849114418, 0.028804179280996323, -0.04049481824040413, -0.036221299320459366, -0.008697893470525742, -0.020680734887719154, -0.01560577005147934, 0.009191883727908134, 0.05562233179807663, -0.04248614236712456, -0.008405580185353756, -0.014517546631395817, 0.04467654600739479, -0.009581450372934341, -0.0429888591170311, -0.008285237476229668, -0.011388219892978668, 0.003267312189564109, -0.05136328935623169, -0.019880980253219604, -0.002609125105664134, 0.0020442686509341, -0.03208688646554947, -0.006256341468542814, -0.0467403382062912, -0.0582854337990284, -0.016462475061416626, -0.028339361771941185, 0.015319149009883404, -0.03811326622962952, 0.02428145334124565, 0.021152183413505554, 0.05071704834699631, -0.013558916747570038, -0.021483678370714188, 0.01611963100731373, 0.02159307524561882, 0.015249600633978844, -0.060727693140506744, 0.004198446869850159, 0.031251195818185806, 0.0003192431468050927, -0.0015159912873059511, -0.0032801725901663303, 0.062069568783044815, 0.034727923572063446, 0.03167625144124031, -0.010118752717971802, 0.04814474284648895, -0.014924390241503716, 0.007165252696722746, 0.018726862967014313, -0.05693983659148216, 0.0003489587106741965, -0.0040318346582353115, 0.010232989676296711, -0.00604971032589674, -0.04998962953686714, -0.07639095187187195, -0.034769654273986816, -0.03325324505567551, 0.007049748674035072, -0.020406095311045647, 0.014461945742368698, -0.02801959402859211, 0.028451930731534958, -0.02504008077085018, 0.012650111690163612, -0.034285254776477814, 0.011392696760594845, -0.04313087835907936, -0.009667408652603626, -0.031048646196722984, 0.013244718313217163, -0.03149275481700897, 0.034433651715517044, 0.021098937839269638, -0.010085215792059898, 0.016202624887228012, -0.012955705635249615, 0.007285646628588438, -0.011222954839468002, 0.06444025784730911, -0.0005919467657804489, -0.009420929476618767, 0.031168309971690178, -0.05197775736451149, -0.009495235979557037, 0.035266660153865814, -0.0536673367023468, 0.025449972599744797, 0.022958291694521904, -0.01628175377845764, 0.014693736098706722, 0.029439818114042282, -0.012125113047659397, -0.01652887649834156, 0.010187688283622265, -0.02266582101583481, 0.015882164239883423, -0.015628965571522713, 0.040579088032245636, 0.029405178502202034, -0.01386058609932661, 0.04109012335538864, 0.04040125757455826, -0.0034066904336214066, -0.014692061580717564, 0.008163845166563988, 0.004343078006058931, 0.042841482907533646, -0.0035728795919567347, -0.0236427653580904, 0.018451493233442307, 0.05558793991804123, -0.04031495749950409, 0.01838524080812931, -0.05178392305970192, 0.041911084204912186, -0.0630543902516365, -0.03205769136548042, -0.01379603985697031, -0.0016041203634813428, 0.04420386999845505, -0.03287933021783829, 0.015407075174152851, 0.021359028294682503, -0.068391352891922, 0.025486106052994728, -0.003483517561107874, -0.005209928844124079, -0.014083013869822025, -0.01670534722507, -0.026704108342528343, 0.020053798332810402, 0.00406440906226635, -0.020588595420122147, 0.05596264451742172, 0.045282360166311264, -0.004237758461385965, -0.05276463180780411, -0.008551145903766155, 0.021242676302790642, 0.026184670627117157, -0.06541059911251068, 0.019647661596536636, -0.008300834335386753, -0.05182793363928795, 0.03271086886525154, -0.021398648619651794, 0.017979081720113754, 0.004277401603758335, 0.06148108094930649, -0.009576160460710526, 0.06551441550254822, -0.0030211617704480886, 0.0044423434883356094, 0.03618427366018295, -0.017827335745096207, 0.003551660105586052, -0.00611664867028594, 0.003086827928200364, 0.053330305963754654, 0.02658543735742569, 0.0016852349508553743, -0.0034884021151810884, -0.0028850140515714884, -0.011813548393547535, 0.002050067065283656, -0.01739235781133175, -0.021156368777155876, 0.008246191777288914, -0.025711655616760254, 0.016108965501189232, 0.00026989204343408346, 0.026537016034126282, 0.02161312848329544, -0.0016237415838986635, -0.012389285489916801, 0.021729080006480217, -0.0059327553026378155, -0.03077886439859867, 0.02537969872355461, -0.010260147973895073, -0.031832899898290634, -0.060653205960989, -0.021864915266633034, 0.018190454691648483, -0.00794707890599966, -0.03388160467147827, -0.00841189082711935, -0.0401485338807106, 0.056624848395586014, -0.02825097367167473, -0.006978652905672789, -0.006211070343852043, 0.001249088323675096, 0.016538619995117188, -0.11251426488161087, 0.053746894001960754, 0.03657514974474907, -0.023129913955926895, -0.02815086767077446, -0.003991040866822004, -0.006182268261909485, 0.053392451256513596, 0.05959577485918999, 0.008820769377052784, -0.002546053845435381, -0.029540816321969032, 0.025368209928274155, 0.0005350110004656017, -0.041293203830718994, 0.04487647861242294, 0.0050927759148180485, -0.0010790438391268253, -0.0008105366141535342, -0.0008358713239431381, 0.04138266667723656, 0.0014440647792071104, 0.00936575885862112, -0.013398013077676296, -0.018543152138590813, 0.011704771779477596, -0.007495878264307976, 0.004323551431298256, 0.007964663207530975, -0.03899656981229782, 0.042224425822496414, -0.03399865701794624, 0.007191777694970369, 0.035160910338163376, -0.0065736365504562855, -0.026372475549578667, 0.01720874197781086, -0.03588666021823883, 0.011025944724678993, 0.026655837893486023, -0.009453989565372467, 0.049188967794179916, -0.08545073121786118, -0.00971426721662283, 0.010697285644710064, -0.03426911681890488, -0.020769303664565086, 0.06070576608181, 0.049352265894412994, 0.026056014001369476, 0.04707375168800354, 0.015603287145495415, -0.024002760648727417, 0.018444640561938286, -0.01299796812236309, 0.02535061724483967, 0.013094632886350155, -0.0032475704792886972, 0.004736211616545916, 0.03382212668657303, -0.012467815540730953, 0.0389835387468338, -0.0037621725350618362, 0.033129092305898666, -0.012803109362721443, -0.0017630010843276978, -0.014766895212233067, -0.03189387172460556, 0.0019511108985170722, -0.000637628196272999, -0.040318120270967484, 0.05920301377773285, -0.015519841574132442, -0.009592095389962196, -0.03320766240358353, 0.020271016284823418, -0.031103121116757393, -0.02386288344860077, 0.021350927650928497, 0.08206629008054733, 0.0142372390255332, -0.006639034487307072, -0.005166023038327694, -0.022076111286878586, 0.017948148772120476, -0.007593993563205004, 0.037225689738988876, 0.0024252792354673147, 0.012764672748744488, -0.035608675330877304, -0.02713426575064659, -0.05431487411260605, 0.007938460446894169, 0.03917693719267845, 0.03010430932044983, 0.031505465507507324, -0.002709690947085619, -0.051011115312576294, -0.00011962864664383233, 0.016800114884972572, -0.04541080445051193, -0.014541799202561378, -0.024887027218937874, 0.03716340288519859, -0.0072090765461325645, -0.003429372562095523 ]
<p>I iterated my 10-fold cross validation 100 times for several methods. Now I want to use a t-test to test if the results are significant. However, I'm not sure what the sample size is. Is the sample size the original amount of samples, or is it the original amount of samples x 100?</p> <h2>edit:</h2> <p>For university we need to classify 3 cancer types and give an estimation of how well our model will perform. We received a dataset with 100 samples. We split the data up into a training and test set using stratified sampling with a ratio of 0.3 and 0.7. The resulting training set consists of 69 samples, and the test set out of 31 samples.</p> <p>We used repeated cross validation because of this paper: <a href="http://www.cse.iitb.ac.in/~tarung/smt/papers_ppt/ency-cross-validation.pdf" rel="nofollow">http://www.cse.iitb.ac.in/~tarung/smt/papers_ppt/ency-cross-validation.pdf</a></p> <p>The repeated cross-validation is done on the same training set, but with the folds are randomly chosen every time, so they should be different every time.</p> <p>The significance we want to test is if the accuracy of one model is significantly better than the accuracy of a different model. </p>
46,718
[ -0.03356162831187248, -0.014127245172858238, 0.0037848104257136583, 0.0075288200750947, 0.04390483349561691, 0.025163322687149048, 0.0014238763833418489, -0.021363267675042152, 0.04145479574799538, -0.00607667863368988, 0.06777383387088776, 0.013533457182347775, 0.03262230381369591, -0.01399304810911417, 0.004501885734498501, 0.005288651213049889, -0.04785186052322388, 0.013767324388027191, -0.000054610471124760807, 0.008113819174468517, -0.002288727555423975, -0.0120918657630682, 0.022522136569023132, -0.021502966061234474, -0.01584716886281967, 0.04653461277484894, 0.030859127640724182, -0.03376774862408638, 0.05156577751040459, 0.034243881702423096, -0.027090314775705338, -0.009012448601424694, 0.018257448449730873, 0.04681352898478508, 0.0059097688645124435, -0.0017695908900350332, -0.008412077091634274, -0.03269687294960022, 0.013060473836958408, -0.002526647411286831, 0.004510596860200167, -0.013900780119001865, -0.00880003534257412, 0.04212310165166855, -0.02054079808294773, 0.02521461248397827, -0.05274175852537155, -0.05344291031360626, 0.03220372647047043, -0.017764754593372345, 0.08275753259658813, 0.008318611420691013, 0.036813464015722275, 0.0011872657341882586, -0.00884875189512968, -0.028477760031819344, 0.010152679868042469, 0.029887918382883072, -0.027788452804088593, -0.02185099944472313, -0.02192571572959423, -0.032182727009058, -0.006245335564017296, -0.027751050889492035, -0.03957393020391464, 0.015049951151013374, -0.020046545192599297, -0.0009169253171421587, 0.03233979269862175, -0.005421641748398542, 0.043303318321704865, 0.003970752935856581, 0.03214556351304054, -0.03836829215288162, -0.028964214026927948, -0.02031995728611946, 0.00399320712313056, 0.05569776892662048, 0.06714034825563431, 0.051614634692668915, 0.013199822045862675, 0.016274865716695786, 0.006522977724671364, 0.017118437215685844, 0.03516785427927971, -0.025556741282343864, 0.07361267507076263, 0.0059348950162529945, 0.02959432452917099, 0.008944048546254635, 0.005241019651293755, 0.002409272827208042, 0.0861416757106781, -0.006166910286992788, -0.00679839588701725, 0.01478281244635582, -0.01855500042438507, 0.03534215688705444, -0.004292435944080353, 0.0315885916352272, -0.003566374536603689, -0.05871274322271347, 0.03379593417048454, 0.05860498175024986, -0.032882362604141235, 0.01136600598692894, -0.016080426052212715, -0.017263242974877357, -0.03970101848244667, -0.0006960642640478909, 0.006328968331217766, -0.002193834399804473, 0.024091936647892, 0.012154503725469112, 0.018011171370744705, 0.02228226698935032, -0.0033589161466807127, -0.0024607146624475718, 0.04023251309990883, 0.05815231800079346, 0.03483011573553085, -0.027340874075889587, 0.04940005764365196, -0.04186570644378662, -0.036374274641275406, 0.008804336190223694, -0.017630690708756447, 0.0012872148072347045, -0.02366221882402897, 0.0667036697268486, -0.01805858314037323, -0.0336596742272377, 0.0018317910144105554, -0.01790557987987995, 0.011798949912190437, 0.00039588066283613443, -0.06333032250404358, -0.05953263118863106, 0.03352401405572891, -0.0029248739592731, 0.01969759911298752, -0.04633926972746849, 0.004157115239650011, 0.0032295987475663424, 0.03237588331103325, 0.03176093474030495, 0.043815068900585175, 0.01717335544526577, 0.04560761898756027, 0.0017770325066521764, -0.03649153932929039, -0.02433384209871292, -0.03232994303107262, 0.013901415280997753, -0.044047314673662186, -0.10443323850631714, 0.020328035578131676, 0.008540600538253784, 0.0025198454968631268, -0.017693597823381424, 0.006642639171332121, -0.010671149007976055, -0.0001698109699646011, -0.028573649004101753, 0.004817507229745388, -0.03294162452220917, 0.05967270955443382, -0.008758856914937496, 0.022441469132900238, -0.0017148986225947738, -0.013939425349235535, -0.03130364790558815, 0.0420047827064991, 0.004068910144269466, 0.005831520538777113, 0.004724245984107256, 0.04462027922272682, -0.035468876361846924, 0.02009810321033001, 0.06319579482078552, -0.01668451353907585, -0.016280656680464745, -0.010280082002282143, 0.0024530114606022835, 0.012134724296629429, 0.033344052731990814, 0.0029133064672350883, -0.018234627321362495, 0.009451189078390598, -0.024042095988988876, -0.06638454645872116, -0.07628897577524185, 0.02374880388379097, -0.012927227653563023, -0.010371572338044643, -0.02236964739859104, -0.007500492036342621, 0.01584210805594921, 0.011369404383003712, -0.018466392531991005, -0.012813122011721134, 0.0023116387892514467, 0.021822158247232437, -0.03153194487094879, 0.017793970182538033, 0.0374000146985054, -0.005133629776537418, -0.03964638710021973, 0.07218557596206665, -0.006918798666447401, -0.028885753825306892, 0.021884365007281303, -0.027853837236762047, -0.0243837870657444, -0.04234255850315094, -0.03313124179840088, 0.004336040932685137, 0.01805754005908966, -0.025484487414360046, 0.07072553783655167, -0.06004106625914574, 0.071817547082901, 0.06762092560529709, -0.02367103099822998, 0.02020532451570034, -0.015402214601635933, -0.012040494941174984, 0.036006249487400055, -0.006759308744221926, -0.029375430196523666, -0.07582319527864456, -0.042830564081668854, 0.05159696936607361, 0.02659432590007782, -0.030597226694226265, 0.007907475344836712, 0.05223575979471207, -0.003450921503826976, 0.028650572523474693, 0.01165764220058918, 0.02939092367887497, -0.03351772576570511, -0.0030818588566035032, 0.0415937565267086, 0.017031166702508926, -0.004736525006592274, -0.004707212559878826, -0.008813895285129547, 0.06044759228825569, 0.029697896912693977, -0.012674126774072647, 0.04079993814229965, -0.016276990994811058, 0.0013043951475992799, -0.0221197959035635, -0.0016813288675621152, 0.03828202188014984, -0.019463131204247475, -0.02358834818005562, 0.0031352376099675894, -0.0058679054491221905, 0.012974720448255539, 0.00042492678039707243, -0.005178041290491819, 0.03209013491868973, 0.025276105850934982, -0.009026133455336094, -0.02651788666844368, 0.013783164322376251, -0.054954782128334045, -0.010794276371598244, -0.009439637884497643, -0.02757939323782921, -0.03557947650551796, 0.012631205841898918, 0.024667534977197647, 0.0013511651195585728, 0.04424325004220009, -0.03099455125629902, -0.028375467285513878, -0.0003748447052203119, -0.03898774832487106, 0.023452596738934517, -0.014994521625339985, -0.03935978561639786, 0.027154365554451942, -0.0033268893603235483, -0.01689041592180729, 0.03323369473218918, -0.004535761661827564, -0.030974026769399643, 0.02073260024189949, 0.023690618574619293, -0.045443471521139145, -0.02181311324238777, -0.05504363030195236, 0.023605015128850937, 0.019951418042182922, -0.02156129851937294, 0.055141549557447433, 0.022817986086010933, -0.023029698058962822, 0.05127020925283432, 0.005803151987493038, -0.019146833568811417, -0.0035672509111464024, -0.004002705682069063, -0.009682386182248592, -0.01463959738612175, -0.00919781532138586, 0.019413309171795845, 0.003296568524092436, -0.021852552890777588, -0.06774234026670456, -0.07758805900812149, 0.002690898487344384, -0.0037465482018887997, 0.04262663051486015, 0.00350277591496706, -0.01877342164516449, 0.09345640242099762, 0.04537977650761604, -0.017976932227611542, -0.020325521007180214, 0.02283259853720665, -0.037714697420597076, -0.0179208442568779, 0.02693140134215355, -0.010927695780992508, 0.002367237117141485, -0.01028454303741455, -0.017733758315443993, 0.018845146521925926, 0.046285733580589294, -0.02442382276058197, -0.002163942437618971, 0.012530707754194736, 0.03485365957021713, -0.004892200697213411, 0.03155767545104027, 0.01292843371629715, -0.02454044297337532, 0.032506901770830154, -0.004467572085559368, 0.014982648193836212, 0.007421520072966814, -0.03474368155002594, 0.022625841200351715, -0.0014115553349256516, -0.009702551178634167, -0.024583600461483, 0.021194742992520332, -0.005209893453866243, -0.028259532526135445, -0.01889156363904476, 0.03889736905694008, 0.0493677593767643, -0.03463537618517876, 0.004135941155254841, 0.026245377957820892, 0.038211748003959656, -0.009441674686968327, 0.002389751374721527, -0.03881242871284485, -0.0024524189066141844, 0.014857582747936249, 0.003257041098549962, -0.04518047347664833, 0.04196937754750252, 0.05719141289591789, 0.03827783465385437, -0.024964144453406334, -0.0419217124581337, 0.021059691905975342, -0.05849604308605194, -0.007363473996520042, -0.04202474653720856, 0.05724630877375603, 0.007778890430927277, 0.01063729077577591, 0.009692899882793427, -0.022254014387726784, 0.0045228940434753895, 0.0057372129522264, -0.05167403444647789, 0.05941705405712128, -0.007627089507877827, -0.006849693134427071, -0.008431175723671913, -0.007648495025932789, 0.020945362746715546, -0.004221088718622923, 0.022984541952610016, 0.03351227566599846, 0.016740305349230766, -0.013014020398259163, 0.025363100692629814, -0.03423375263810158, -0.011913868598639965, 0.0041783940978348255, 0.05613580718636513, -0.0011701168259605765, 0.013573804870247841, 0.012882569804787636, 0.014044889248907566, -0.014778601005673409, -0.03660181537270546, -0.01759417913854122, 0.03873787820339203, -0.01598230004310608, 0.03844412788748741, 0.03974281996488571, 0.06092728674411774, -0.07774709165096283, 0.02721366472542286, -0.018583282828330994, 0.019707610830664635, 0.031007902696728706, 0.012968948110938072, -0.02129559963941574, -0.06633364409208298, -0.0171651653945446, 0.018658995628356934, -0.014801444485783577, 0.006337796337902546, -0.025811096653342247, 0.05021112039685249, 0.025444606319069862, -0.06114741787314415, 0.026034589856863022, 0.054099198430776596, 0.008703265339136124, 0.010028376244008541, -0.08324267715215683, 0.02474937029182911, 0.01390098873525858, -0.020895278081297874, 0.042216476052999496, 0.026005441322922707, -0.025858426466584206, -0.016121361404657364, 0.019386937841773033, -0.057125773280858994, -0.050750087946653366, 0.014272833243012428, 0.009990362450480461, 0.017112210392951965, 0.022910377010703087, -0.03311433643102646, 0.004974667448550463, 0.04137473925948143, 0.0469454787671566, 0.022828342393040657, 0.010070200078189373, -0.06468626111745834, -0.02346022240817547, 0.01703951135277748, 0.05695078894495964, -0.08339116722345352, -0.009385231882333755, -0.04195033013820648, -0.010880893096327782, 0.02834630012512207, -0.06652937084436417, -0.015695784240961075, -0.016264284029603004, 0.023041436448693275, -0.03788920119404793, 0.007284921128302813, -0.05074216425418854, -0.00996340811252594, -0.055703818798065186, 0.010167992673814297, -0.03331174701452255, -0.02089105360209942, -0.02677369862794876, 0.022451236844062805, 0.004256622865796089, 0.045686036348342896, -0.0786421075463295, -0.01056965533643961, 0.010649715550243855, -0.017040418460965157, -0.0001492753071943298, -0.06705041229724884, -0.005445938091725111, 0.0001866461825557053, -0.012878909707069397, 0.009271716699004173, 0.0119402464479208, -0.027460729703307152, 0.029102856293320656, 0.03727767989039421, -0.031126799061894417, -0.019965073093771935, -0.02114136517047882, 0.034062083810567856, 0.04172566160559654, 0.019418029114603996, 0.07609374821186066, 0.006562988739460707, 0.05340362340211868, 0.01531698927283287, -0.006712533533573151, 0.020048130303621292, -0.04914506524801254, -0.014090562239289284, -0.044500529766082764, 0.0066666919738054276, -0.05472234636545181, 0.03987409174442291, -0.008414779789745808, 0.0391865000128746, -0.021252261474728584, -0.03651811555027962, 0.016804533079266548, 0.03332585096359253, 0.010842487215995789, -0.019524643197655678, 0.03714842349290848, 0.06133908033370972, -0.01749701052904129, -0.004421209450811148, -0.03557978570461273, -0.011175896041095257, 0.006563096307218075, 0.009707076475024223, -0.023622699081897736, 0.013384873047471046, -0.02572210133075714, -0.0011335288872942328, 0.027632946148514748, -0.030529893934726715, 0.009551938623189926, -0.011407426558434963, 0.0202279444783926, -0.011008400470018387, -0.017105385661125183, -0.009755092673003674, 0.029806900769472122, 0.0351879745721817, 0.01830591820180416, -0.07013118267059326, 0.03483611345291138, -0.012291178107261658, -0.010075860656797886, -0.08319981396198273, -0.04367784783244133, 0.023603463545441628, 0.026889093220233917, -0.026299264281988144, -0.011648117564618587, 0.0073471772484481335, 0.008180022239685059, 0.013248709961771965, -0.031261689960956573, 0.035022083669900894, 0.004908089525997639, -0.011660571210086346, -0.01182190328836441, 0.005961169023066759, 0.04808942228555679, -0.02667095698416233, 0.03954773023724556, -0.03123570792376995, -0.012281198985874653, -0.043916136026382446, 0.01675204373896122, 0.01534497831016779, -0.025345390662550926, -0.016715722158551216, -0.02431979402899742, -0.012037125416100025, 0.017571154981851578, -0.019951902329921722, -0.05082041770219803, 0.010410369373857975, -0.01824927143752575, 0.020644381642341614, -0.01112424023449421, -0.019486676901578903, 0.013438496738672256, 0.017558205872774124, -0.024621181190013885, 0.003744288580492139, 0.01604585349559784, -0.027309918776154518, -0.00027528766077011824, 0.015033303759992123, -0.03878423571586609, 0.03365262225270271, 0.07746578752994537, -0.010588770732283592, 0.028965521603822708, -0.03814177215099335, -0.05240190774202347, 0.04127064719796181, 0.02198067493736744, -0.020273331552743912, 0.0028522261418402195, 0.021838273853063583, -0.005442527588456869, -0.014487233012914658, 0.0011354009620845318, 0.014805527403950691, 0.04349534958600998, 0.02838863618671894, 0.036118101328611374, 0.06922081112861633, 0.002160367788746953, 0.02019255794584751, -0.03837547078728676, -0.008200142532587051, -0.0037009823136031628, 0.03912841156125069, 0.05189353972673416, -0.010929273441433907, -0.04115400090813637, 0.08990471065044403, 0.007299015298485756, 0.03136977180838585, 0.04988893121480942, 0.029337141662836075, 0.022384990006685257, 0.021700246259570122, -0.04562618210911751, -0.03203685209155083, 0.01664343662559986, -0.027979932725429535, 0.03476441651582718, -0.02710811235010624, 0.009128917939960957, 0.024097848683595657, 0.05777939036488533, 0.02028447948396206, -0.012087277136743069, 0.0016372354002669454, -0.07700711488723755, 0.002686896361410618, 0.028846051543951035, -0.010664897039532661, 0.019496498629450798, 0.010373271070420742, 0.017840281128883362, 0.01147547923028469, 0.04858993738889694, -0.03895905986428261, -0.06167967990040779, -0.02949298359453678, -0.005203479900956154, -0.022371890023350716, 0.02103535830974579, 0.005061518866568804, -0.04107794538140297, 0.004341588355600834, -0.04163719341158867, 0.04694904014468193, -0.0010751158697530627, 0.04745950177311897, -0.014681334607303143, 0.05764227733016014, -0.0016077265609055758, 0.03940829262137413, 0.025133291259407997, -0.0027259206399321556, 0.1281251162290573, 0.09051187336444855, -0.012727604247629642, -0.03526311740279198, 0.014968041330575943, 0.002847464056685567, -0.031334295868873596, 0.0009797640377655625, 0.003342179348692298, 0.03487815707921982, 0.0025819740258157253, 0.024352511391043663, 0.043014489114284515, 0.006750136148184538, -0.03676941245794296, 0.030880456790328026, -0.026004644110798836, -0.014064829796552658, 0.052058059722185135, 0.000911006354726851, 0.01891743205487728, -0.04158524051308632, -0.04222264140844345, 0.00395621731877327, -0.038046713918447495, 0.004060389474034309, -0.023322226479649544, -0.020936759188771248, -0.013958079740405083, -0.008449493907392025, 0.02089500240981579, -0.008313557133078575, -0.030576514080166817, 0.003473315155133605, -0.06223710998892784, 0.00018782976258080453, -0.014404783956706524, -0.007189501076936722, 0.02132350206375122, 0.07509365677833557, -0.002009126590564847, -0.0013350684894248843, -0.03152468055486679, 0.025829996913671494, -0.05156516283750534, -0.04259765148162842, -0.051067955791950226, 0.041127726435661316, -0.0247308649122715, 0.003909923601895571, -0.00853810179978609, -0.008037270046770573, 0.008313254453241825, -0.03293279930949211, 0.00364116788841784, 0.04590325430035591, 0.004545446950942278, -0.03361371532082558, -0.020366938784718513, -0.04765724763274193, 0.006309095770120621, -0.009955178014934063, 0.015739306807518005, 0.01888655126094818, 0.010813950560986996, -0.03476646542549133, -0.026900943368673325, 0.019132237881422043, 0.014861639589071274, 0.02351645566523075, 0.03296395763754845, -0.06617636233568192, -0.03225284814834595, 0.002638990990817547, 0.00968589261174202, 0.026194900274276733, 0.04297136142849922, -0.005229054018855095, -0.01350042037665844, -0.04128874093294144, -0.01369955763220787, -0.01582045666873455, 0.02304694801568985, 0.00496288575232029, -0.014635682106018066, -0.002607326954603195, -0.01915200985968113, 0.024800606071949005, 0.02659776248037815, 0.019283993169665337, 0.05040358379483223, -0.01600220799446106, 0.007661002222448587, -0.04973709583282471, -0.010934358462691307, 0.018601028248667717, -0.019112402573227882, -0.011806193739175797, -0.023062383756041527, 0.03613406419754028, 0.0101240249350667, 0.018283311277627945, -0.028044505044817924, 0.0214411448687315, -0.0023669591173529625, 0.0020286960061639547, -0.007133313920348883, -0.044363826513290405, 0.00019848138617817312, 0.002249734243378043, -0.005981778260320425, -0.04700632765889168, -0.007576469797641039, -0.04919194057583809, -0.029161741957068443, 0.03856504708528519, 0.02036171592772007, -0.04081347957253456, 0.016714053228497505, -0.002886066446080804, 0.05750080570578575, -0.01598369888961315, 0.006581761408597231, -0.0425850972533226, 0.007848086766898632, 0.016083043068647385, -0.002915749792009592, 0.0011378182098269463, 0.01406331267207861, -0.02760477177798748, -0.034261953085660934, 0.05386052280664444, -0.005521533545106649, 0.008522930555045605, -0.00971896480768919, -0.0018048358615487814, 0.00934177078306675, 0.053505148738622665, -0.03698471933603287, 0.010004577226936817, 0.0657908171415329, -0.07322932034730911, -0.002211396349593997, 0.043464627116918564, -0.025548230856657028, 0.042976804077625275, 0.04798179119825363, -0.0353756882250309, 0.029608184471726418, 0.04594458267092705, -0.016865484416484833, -0.019066840410232544, -0.01737275905907154, 0.009121526964008808, 0.04388748109340668, 0.022324448451399803, 0.005666389595717192, 0.026977166533470154, 0.02933892048895359, 0.01678890362381935, 0.03876025602221489, -0.004237757530063391, -0.003138046944513917, -0.010722680948674679, 0.0011025617131963372, -0.012911362573504448, -0.00312293809838593, 0.003383571282029152, 0.02434033714234829, 0.08895621448755264, -0.018916385248303413, 0.030256401747465134, -0.003470031078904867, 0.024243909865617752, -0.10062955319881439, -0.00727331405505538, -0.011607348918914795, 0.028031451627612114, 0.01037707831710577, -0.032090041786432266, -0.005920329596847296, 0.026299849152565002, -0.019209524616599083, 0.03947247564792633, -0.04197178781032562, 0.014012431725859642, -0.04523145407438278, 0.012553703971207142, -0.04325203225016594, 0.01630484312772751, 0.055810000747442245, 0.014202874153852463, 0.02909473329782486, 0.04108772799372673, -0.012096291407942772, -0.01745837740600109, -0.018451910465955734, 0.04020412266254425, -0.019182583317160606, -0.05965664982795715, -0.002823336748406291, -0.009231168776750565, -0.055801574140787125, 0.007722227834165096, -0.014232585206627846, -0.0030323988758027554, 0.014065880328416824, 0.023792769759893417, 0.03944665193557739, 0.03819018602371216, 0.04624401777982712, -0.01983523927628994, -0.004183908924460411, 0.02641458250582218, 0.014180423691868782, -0.0038887353148311377, 0.021304365247488022, 0.013288985006511211, 0.02402816154062748, 0.005329777020961046, 0.008250590413808823, 0.02857603318989277, -0.045712027698755264, -0.025546997785568237, -0.012854701839387417, -0.01362011581659317, -0.019980762153863907, -0.017193503677845, -0.015123692341148853, -0.013525599613785744, -0.004862927366048098, 0.036819737404584885, 0.033300939947366714, -0.03220872953534126, 0.011426533572375774, -0.02001749351620674, -0.037506911903619766, 0.00021026245667599142, -0.014630675315856934, -0.04121211916208267, -0.039714425802230835, 0.014321822673082352, 0.026947664096951485, 0.012827129103243351, -0.027564266696572304, -0.017045307904481888, -0.05468281731009483, 0.04736471548676491, -0.004638159181922674, 0.011401389725506306, 0.026847170665860176, -0.01977556012570858, 0.002390633337199688, -0.0843406394124031, 0.03756261244416237, 0.0132905263453722, -0.056573621928691864, -0.04570884257555008, -0.026870552450418472, -0.029465513303875923, 0.024432044476270676, 0.05157029256224632, 0.03938834369182587, -0.006323993671685457, -0.010218941606581211, 0.019751695916056633, 0.006328861694782972, -0.0850757285952568, 0.05069930478930473, -0.04497653990983963, -0.02211599610745907, -0.011659320443868637, 0.026871686801314354, 0.01808677427470684, 0.010731094516813755, 0.025245262309908867, -0.01036197692155838, 0.048925768584012985, -0.02036653645336628, 0.003983819391578436, 0.032484401017427444, 0.01090278197079897, -0.0026289995294064283, 0.05559787526726723, 0.010832633823156357, 0.01490304060280323, -0.006746970117092133, 0.017776528373360634, -0.04108735918998718, 0.0051123290322721004, -0.04008335992693901, 0.00021430187916848809, 0.007368010934442282, 0.04707835987210274, 0.017622392624616623, -0.04273705929517746, 0.0029939622618258, 0.004196580499410629, -0.011301994323730469, -0.018717097118496895, 0.048029616475105286, 0.05226318910717964, 0.004728886764496565, -0.022665683180093765, 0.018663503229618073, 0.0038517594803124666, -0.017857886850833893, -0.009597336873412132, 0.00567845581099391, -0.029321342706680298, 0.013206065632402897, 0.03546953573822975, -0.0006258104112930596, -0.03249689191579819, -0.0058310991153120995, 0.007285335101187229, 0.060998108237981796, -0.040668144822120667, -0.03333452343940735, 0.03659416362643242, -0.0029416484758257866, 0.011968862265348434, -0.018582774326205254, -0.005916422698646784, 0.06500057876110077, -0.03403594717383385, -0.004886908922344446, -0.01080439891666174, -0.019938619807362556, -0.04092133790254593, 0.011343905702233315, 0.01784464344382286, 0.03143954649567604, 0.01402627769857645, 0.012235788628458977, -0.016237972304224968, -0.015758352354168892, 0.049464598298072815, -0.04215444251894951, 0.03197412192821503, 0.010643872432410717, -0.029790692031383514, -0.02859642170369625, -0.014342056587338448, -0.040549442172050476, -0.02375641092658043, -0.00311480020172894, 0.03360894322395325, 0.023497940972447395, -0.025278229266405106, -0.046460337936878204, 0.02871868945658207, 0.04132867977023125, -0.06594298034906387, -0.012060988694429398, -0.07078007608652115, 0.015365500934422016, -0.00039333655149675906, -0.031538836658000946 ]
<p>I have a collection of $n$ datapoints $(y_i,\bf{x}_i)$ in $\mathbb{R}^{p+1}$ and would like to estimate the following model in <code>R</code>:</p> <p>$$\underset{\bf{b}\in\mathbb{R}^{p}}{\arg.\min}\;\sum_{i=1}^n(y_i-\bf{x}_i'\bf{b})^2$$ </p> <p>$$u.c.\;\;\;0\leq \bf{x}_i'\bf{b}\leq 1\;\;\;\forall i$$</p> <p>anybody has a pointer to an efficient way of doing this? is there a re-parametrization of the OLS problem that would allow for this? </p>
74,026
[ -0.044119078665971756, 0.0006638991762883961, 0.017479507252573967, 0.01446536835283041, 0.005190133582800627, 0.01588183455169201, -0.024823501706123352, -0.011182596907019615, 0.0328647680580616, -0.051419492810964584, 0.050521738827228546, 0.04702674597501755, 0.04709154739975929, -0.03186945989727974, 0.026568053290247917, -0.024642230942845345, -0.019533390179276466, 0.021352749317884445, -0.02406434156000614, -0.030448146164417267, 0.011645635589957237, 0.026266470551490784, 0.020176652818918228, -0.001254766946658492, -0.01915038749575615, 0.043617673218250275, 0.045075900852680206, -0.022577716037631035, -0.02648397721350193, 0.08932938426733017, 0.002929818583652377, -0.006623381748795509, 0.020131602883338928, 0.029302366077899933, 0.057867612689733505, 0.006473237182945013, -0.030987584963440895, -0.05423889309167862, 0.01997765526175499, 0.026755623519420624, -0.025043021887540817, -0.04067688435316086, 0.017196305096149445, 0.016411857679486275, 0.012985635548830032, 0.01190898660570383, 0.03330628201365471, -0.023708786815404892, 0.006375669967383146, -0.04128030315041542, 0.10914736241102219, 0.0040289899334311485, 0.0073361643590033054, 0.012367687188088894, -0.023487450554966927, 0.0022812271490693092, 0.0418136827647686, 0.10947054624557495, 0.0012587696546688676, -0.05160136520862579, -0.008883858099579811, 0.0020429305732250214, 0.031064871698617935, -0.0193877425044775, -0.07083877921104431, 0.03813799470663071, -0.008624758571386337, 0.0012685767142102122, 0.0025612390600144863, -0.061432015150785446, 0.01667121611535549, -0.0002859917876776308, 0.016413774341344833, -0.008406431414186954, -0.003181744832545519, -0.0037118010222911835, 0.006672020070254803, 0.033977046608924866, 0.04229869320988655, 0.02713996358215809, 0.006561753340065479, 0.026436125859618187, 0.03894752264022827, 0.02939639799296856, -0.002121228026226163, 0.01092476211488247, 0.054180167615413666, -0.01778995618224144, 0.03840094804763794, 0.023452801629900932, 0.004019946791231632, 0.029354169964790344, 0.04826967418193817, 0.01180731039494276, -0.0569537878036499, 0.04214733839035034, -0.012354777194559574, 0.03421017900109291, 0.005786977708339691, -0.015880879014730453, -0.010117219761013985, -0.058833371847867966, -0.03732214495539665, 0.05917643755674362, -0.013512210920453072, -0.03434550762176514, -0.004650180693715811, 0.002618391066789627, 0.02438434585928917, -0.029365509748458862, -0.013583192601799965, 0.05878191441297531, -0.015951205044984818, -0.006026865914463997, 0.03992635756731033, -0.05159369856119156, -0.023067785426974297, -0.020363081246614456, 0.0066796219907701015, 0.05386008322238922, 0.049546126276254654, -0.01393476128578186, 0.024310700595378876, -0.019677452743053436, -0.042550258338451385, -0.008563803508877754, 0.019351761788129807, -0.030081599950790405, -0.05949419364333153, 0.03946017846465111, 0.029179109260439873, -0.039526425302028656, 0.04375707730650902, -0.005629227962344885, 0.02878286875784397, 0.01004806999117136, -0.06887997686862946, -0.07759362459182739, 0.018078405410051346, -0.05761941894888878, 0.022205684334039688, -0.03714874014258385, -0.0264809001237154, -0.0013023177161812782, 0.059236329048871994, -0.007516554091125727, 0.042491357773542404, 0.03249979019165039, 0.01927308365702629, 0.008522354066371918, -0.012164962477982044, -0.025779036805033684, -0.02273246832191944, -0.004011646378785372, 0.01168484054505825, -0.08722250908613205, 0.020781071856617928, 0.004803886637091637, -0.04819730669260025, 0.0035284901969134808, 0.06708160042762756, 0.023346606642007828, -0.022221989929676056, -0.018923619762063026, -0.0022724815644323826, -0.006194474641233683, 0.02237880975008011, 0.01069263368844986, 0.022355856373906136, 0.00034544410300441086, -0.012432982213795185, 0.011631947942078114, 0.02503202296793461, 0.02585878036916256, 0.07269345223903656, -0.012931757606565952, -0.004827519878745079, -0.015032703056931496, 0.021049408242106438, 0.04719690978527069, -0.05509854853153229, -0.023439830169081688, -0.014854351989924908, -0.01308676227927208, 0.0381011962890625, 0.025399602949619293, -0.014816136099398136, -0.023111747577786446, 0.0032644406892359257, -0.039564959704875946, -0.0037624379619956017, -0.07992006093263626, -0.008459201082587242, 0.01897382363677025, -0.006571323610842228, 0.04250315949320793, 0.002935313154011965, 0.005235909949988127, -0.01566901244223118, -0.027382712811231613, -0.029426706954836845, 0.020664650946855545, 0.07335758209228516, -0.041662510484457016, -0.008951588533818722, 0.039198681712150574, 0.06278960406780243, -0.01792134903371334, 0.058138977736234665, -0.04432303458452225, -0.03237122297286987, -0.01863253302872181, -0.04419773444533348, 0.009786956012248993, -0.012873291037976742, -0.01896676793694496, -0.007284556049853563, -0.03568505123257637, -0.01039446983486414, 0.008453182876110077, -0.08949834108352661, 0.03057842329144478, 0.07548089325428009, 0.06380138546228409, 0.000776166096329689, 0.007221395615488291, 0.05824369564652443, 0.03646429255604744, -0.0313386432826519, 0.02598741091787815, -0.008062731474637985, 0.012715212069451809, 0.009367140009999275, 0.03413917496800423, -0.03784449025988579, -0.013939660973846912, 0.04721623659133911, 0.031654953956604004, -0.0021128884982317686, 0.021770277991890907, -0.01940702088177204, -0.03244827315211296, 0.016695676371455193, -0.028475966304540634, 0.026179345324635506, 0.016805747523903847, -0.015191685408353806, -0.002900968538597226, 0.031158417463302612, -0.03728153184056282, -0.00013021790073253214, 0.014158245176076889, 0.05230443924665451, -0.015317882411181927, -0.016924377530813217, -0.017854275181889534, 0.024209674447774887, -0.01200073678046465, -0.013589514419436455, 0.0039499495178461075, 0.007532299496233463, 0.012962296605110168, 0.005529148504137993, -0.006575671024620533, 0.031177636235952377, -0.006409960333257914, -0.04086386784911156, 0.016216062009334564, 0.030393332242965698, -0.04863058403134346, 0.00766769191250205, -0.008473372086882591, -0.03044787049293518, -0.03624795749783516, 0.0026772741694003344, 0.034601811319589615, 0.027650490403175354, -0.015305589884519577, -0.012450668960809708, 0.006285881157964468, 0.010713629424571991, -0.014588460326194763, 0.06663282215595245, -0.010064599104225636, -0.02114097774028778, 0.013435989618301392, -0.03703172877430916, 0.018641717731952667, 0.010640888474881649, -0.009326523169875145, -0.029666824266314507, 0.02714867703616619, -0.007872002199292183, -0.030050259083509445, -0.029259251430630684, 0.007151056081056595, 0.023298297077417374, -0.032086700201034546, -0.016440652310848236, 0.005073845386505127, 0.01246784720569849, -0.022403085604310036, -0.002947569126263261, -0.05204281210899353, 0.002161974087357521, -0.022894274443387985, -0.0029045171104371548, 0.011933845467865467, 0.036610186100006104, 0.020421458408236504, 0.019084297120571136, -0.021293530240654945, -0.01963122747838497, -0.07770807296037674, -0.0707111731171608, -0.01562479604035616, 0.016244806349277496, 0.008303412236273289, 0.005443131551146507, -0.027522122487425804, 0.09670929610729218, 0.06193693354725838, -0.016574084758758545, -0.044171445071697235, 0.013826536945998669, 0.012205759063363075, -0.037907663732767105, 0.021084437146782875, 0.013403421267867088, 0.013634058646857738, 0.03174262493848801, -0.023417353630065918, 0.015603366307914257, 0.05163858085870743, 0.004417926073074341, 0.0429462194442749, 0.00047904267557896674, -0.045107193291187286, 0.004854668863117695, 0.004399801138788462, 0.031040530651807785, 0.004134050570428371, 0.004571577068418264, 0.023092499002814293, 0.011229244992136955, 0.006807935889810324, -0.049320854246616364, 0.00012467223859857768, -0.009909802116453648, 0.027111632749438286, 0.01878375932574272, 0.04226718842983246, -0.001657921471633017, -0.029491053894162178, -0.03739865496754646, 0.027700522914528847, 0.02403905801475048, 0.004963874351233244, 0.0032021566294133663, 0.016003938391804695, 0.01733391359448433, 0.001680272282101214, 0.02499881014227867, -0.009293640963733196, 0.0028230922762304544, 0.0334298238158226, -0.00671466113999486, -0.024823585525155067, 0.020815573632717133, 0.0262463241815567, -0.005204563494771719, 0.014910307712852955, -0.018158603459596634, 0.004186141770333052, -0.0603473037481308, -0.0026248928625136614, -0.030164016410708427, 0.08613839000463486, 0.01589161902666092, 0.006139607168734074, -0.024541527032852173, -0.027352789416909218, 0.02158590964972973, 0.018105728551745415, -0.0678282305598259, 0.04255388304591179, 0.0016844198107719421, 0.009693772532045841, 0.005480710417032242, 0.0096732871606946, 0.05441037937998772, -0.03762327879667282, 0.03771001845598221, 0.003629154758527875, 0.03802544251084328, -0.021740693598985672, -0.000022938973415875807, -0.013198748230934143, 0.005248998291790485, 0.008552580140531063, 0.008575293235480785, 0.0051682861521840096, -0.03968583419919014, 0.009037673473358154, 0.01800176501274109, -0.007185302209109068, -0.006748936604708433, -0.05180157721042633, 0.012551560997962952, 0.005630206316709518, 0.05597073212265968, -0.003830320667475462, 0.03671431913971901, -0.027947884052991867, 0.017428142949938774, -0.00811129342764616, 0.025841765105724335, 0.07704942673444748, -0.0035313391126692295, 0.0017304039793089032, -0.036797311156988144, -0.006318262778222561, 0.04344647377729416, 0.04307566210627556, 0.0010876511223614216, -0.00995618849992752, 0.04777273163199425, 0.03811102360486984, -0.05563661828637123, -0.00005619364674203098, 0.08317353576421738, 0.03147588297724724, 0.03007197380065918, -0.03144058212637901, -0.0029951431788504124, -0.0057272533886134624, 0.03453562781214714, 0.00918247178196907, -0.017208678647875786, 0.005561624653637409, -0.025638900697231293, 0.055881619453430176, -0.008119573816657066, -0.022498195990920067, -0.004395273048430681, 0.026679832488298416, 0.042539581656455994, -0.0033621741458773613, -0.056812938302755356, 0.026081867516040802, 0.03552066534757614, 0.05419173091650009, 0.03990425914525986, 0.04326387494802475, -0.055704087018966675, -0.01943296566605568, 0.0038152022752910852, 0.022812899202108383, -0.004290105774998665, 0.006529377773404121, -0.0240531787276268, -0.015539448708295822, 0.053537070751190186, 0.012005584314465523, 0.01635296829044819, 0.018177159130573273, 0.01865740865468979, -0.013519861735403538, -0.04218211770057678, -0.07340891659259796, -0.0015112456167116761, -0.03727082163095474, 0.022326285019516945, -0.017165852710604668, -0.013530444353818893, -0.03427973389625549, 0.025501085445284843, 0.007041445001959801, 0.07240407168865204, -0.027514057233929634, -0.01658891886472702, 0.04391380399465561, 0.026971202343702316, -0.021806063130497932, -0.017284976318478584, 0.017596129328012466, 0.033538948744535446, -0.04886900261044502, 0.02721508778631687, -0.003211589762941003, -0.06062183901667595, 0.038479678332805634, 0.004354614764451981, -0.015754852443933487, -0.01221015676856041, -0.01790965162217617, 0.05406127870082855, 0.0523810051381588, 0.009956138208508492, 0.07274862378835678, 0.030467428267002106, -0.00011893634655280039, 0.013285256922245026, -0.02667132578790188, -0.021058809012174606, -0.010055601596832275, -0.06412158161401749, -0.03733154386281967, -0.016244200989603996, 0.023252803832292557, 0.019180409610271454, 0.007748735137283802, 0.01651323214173317, -0.03869682177901268, -0.027923116460442543, -0.016970321536064148, 0.038288671523332596, -0.022302843630313873, -0.029175281524658203, 0.020003939047455788, 0.04217745363712311, 0.04030359163880348, -0.011111903004348278, 0.01142027322202921, -0.03371492028236389, 0.011930971406400204, 0.035770196467638016, -0.04556611180305481, 0.017204251140356064, -0.035699471831321716, -0.00812863651663065, -0.035402487963438034, -0.022673947736620903, -0.001344993943348527, -0.0079650292173028, 0.025362467393279076, 0.02216625027358532, -0.03300504386425018, -0.0007175930077210069, -0.017026307061314583, -0.01818491704761982, 0.013254848308861256, -0.06214378774166107, 0.01275124866515398, -0.01827068068087101, -0.00831856019794941, -0.04975184053182602, -0.026028774678707123, 0.06468060612678528, -0.019302742555737495, -0.03000006452202797, -0.04463549330830574, -0.005395988002419472, -0.02777983620762825, -0.0005149299395270646, -0.03770216181874275, 0.09092274308204651, -0.0463159903883934, -0.00874315109103918, -0.030163012444972992, 0.019849399104714394, 0.022021856158971786, -0.012986117042601109, -0.0052610659040510654, 0.05620280280709267, -0.037985771894454956, -0.04492918774485588, -0.018042171373963356, 0.0416293740272522, -0.02136659249663353, 0.016220858320593834, -0.047841720283031464, -0.004732336383312941, 0.02022317424416542, -0.008669903501868248, -0.021795332431793213, 0.010401359759271145, 0.005150181706994772, -0.025740347802639008, -0.025644036009907722, -0.030008457601070404, -0.008856306783854961, -0.013093452900648117, -0.04081318527460098, 0.00039922280120663345, -0.0025014083366841078, -0.019720546901226044, 0.03326079621911049, 0.0019018559250980616, -0.009304211474955082, 0.0004298938438296318, 0.05595911294221878, 0.008220617659389973, -0.007500653620809317, 0.009981588460505009, -0.033039309084415436, 0.04851385951042175, 0.0212734155356884, -0.015675561502575874, 0.015124120749533176, 0.040464844554662704, -0.06720674782991409, -0.015555846504867077, -0.029982931911945343, 0.02169274166226387, 0.029296373948454857, 0.003704603062942624, 0.04254211485385895, 0.06339018046855927, 0.012236258946359158, 0.010265122167766094, -0.0315951444208622, -0.0005993963568471372, 0.020672013983130455, -0.007435976527631283, 0.0646648034453392, 0.0015735154738649726, -0.029361197724938393, 0.035161375999450684, -0.016238272190093994, 0.030816517770290375, 0.05315382778644562, -0.006643838714808226, 0.02411079593002796, 0.01991334743797779, -0.046613659709692, -0.07214745134115219, 0.031572893261909485, -0.04579123109579086, -0.03433499112725258, -0.021964168176054955, -0.06992913037538528, 0.037155602127313614, 0.015871547162532806, 0.04753906652331352, -0.022892840206623077, -0.04964378848671913, -0.03573036938905716, 0.012644259259104729, 0.02520011179149151, -0.024297740310430527, 0.03101000376045704, 0.01776118017733097, -0.007926485501229763, -0.012927891686558723, 0.04210870712995529, -0.009065821766853333, -0.0856856256723404, -0.02092188037931919, -0.026508202776312828, -0.04751446098089218, 0.012815927155315876, 0.021890031173825264, 0.024219783022999763, 0.02538320980966091, -0.008311904035508633, 0.008540721610188484, -0.00732666440308094, 0.0337606817483902, 0.02502015233039856, 0.06337080895900726, 0.0024050548672676086, -0.008528047241270542, -0.02043280377984047, -0.031214958056807518, 0.10402271151542664, 0.06667452305555344, 0.043981220573186874, -0.05826009437441826, -0.0000023693769435340073, 0.006698091048747301, -0.06036682426929474, -0.053290095180273056, -0.005620613228529692, 0.0009198422776535153, -0.007784400600939989, 0.008886881172657013, 0.07301736623048782, 0.0067491354420781136, -0.0352478064596653, 0.04961754381656647, -0.05336424335837364, -0.00870293378829956, 0.034757960587739944, -0.012561503797769547, 0.009230461902916431, -0.04204034060239792, -0.05725540220737457, 0.016232086345553398, 0.029386665672063828, -0.0702030211687088, -0.04227568209171295, -0.020886199548840523, -0.005810729693621397, -0.00888726394623518, -0.006134260445833206, 0.014658954925835133, 0.0069905053824186325, 0.01741914264857769, -0.005174113903194666, 0.011232417076826096, 0.006088316906243563, -0.01533597707748413, 0.01817641593515873, 0.020869731903076172, 0.024529673159122467, 0.02153283730149269, -0.009312435984611511, 0.00024621677584946156, -0.0015631800051778555, -0.02623584307730198, -0.04474706947803497, 0.03421479091048241, -0.01700471341609955, -0.00007922967779450119, -0.025763634592294693, 0.026294631883502007, 0.020722290500998497, -0.05358332395553589, -0.0043193441815674305, 0.022651460021734238, 0.03856681287288666, -0.019938567653298378, -0.006696587428450584, 0.011028911918401718, -0.007201119791716337, 0.022900233045220375, 0.007208891678601503, 0.0009589892579242587, -0.02373225800693035, -0.018028946593403816, -0.004327230155467987, 0.06422142684459686, -0.002836132189258933, 0.0017215744592249393, 0.013066109269857407, -0.01077674888074398, 0.001702345092780888, -0.01765606738626957, 0.04308094456791878, -0.01896325685083866, 0.020455384626984596, -0.007858227007091045, -0.025379670783877373, -0.03196985274553299, -0.023448439314961433, -0.026102101430296898, -0.04043525457382202, 0.010911379009485245, -0.025784984230995178, -0.019422221928834915, 0.005663970485329628, 0.019138675183057785, 0.0025307389441877604, -0.04305289685726166, -0.01002182625234127, 0.0666690394282341, -0.0035956695210188627, -0.016570594161748886, -0.025238769128918648, -0.010855619795620441, -0.004864468704909086, 0.012705002911388874, 0.02616443671286106, 0.03921230509877205, 0.014769460074603558, 0.015321067534387112, -0.03651178628206253, 0.05706530436873436, -0.05538918823003769, 0.020371945574879646, -0.013626929372549057, -0.053625307977199554, 0.02558921091258526, 0.02671201527118683, 0.02143026702105999, -0.033976033329963684, 0.027137380093336105, -0.020967304706573486, -0.02971556782722473, -0.002276980085298419, -0.028779970481991768, -0.0317319892346859, 0.006024760659784079, -0.003324311226606369, -0.008404486812651157, -0.014231008477509022, 0.016018331050872803, -0.018994677811861038, 0.029489707201719284, -0.02639816515147686, -0.013199901208281517, -0.016237253323197365, 0.023273149505257607, -0.026295103132724762, -0.028915410861372948, 0.03882087394595146, 0.001345719676464796, 0.016630029305815697, 0.012814627960324287, -0.011623287573456764, -0.005944910459220409, 0.04315192997455597, 0.0021068360656499863, -0.039575617760419846, 0.03025222197175026, -0.04590799659490585, -0.035307932645082474, 0.030670659616589546, -0.024515798315405846, 0.03022790141403675, 0.007377101574093103, -0.0044534411281347275, -0.0642787516117096, 0.010001747868955135, 0.005758887622505426, 0.02268621139228344, 0.01170821487903595, 0.03122050128877163, 0.02053133025765419, -0.0029260702431201935, 0.020381242036819458, 0.004621059168130159, -0.02216484397649765, 0.006278771907091141, 0.016391081735491753, -0.03759411349892616, -0.026742056012153625, 0.0062643117271363735, -0.020649204030632973, 0.0004826220392715186, -0.03460123389959335, -0.0014882421819493175, 0.01291497889906168, 0.015717793256044388, -0.04331628978252411, 0.030650276690721512, -0.008646734990179539, -0.0034118180628865957, -0.1073455661535263, -0.046130843460559845, -0.006055604666471481, 0.020424477756023407, 0.045432403683662415, -0.07353077083826065, 0.028124012053012848, 0.00958169437944889, -0.035133104771375656, 0.021595900878310204, -0.011961250565946102, -0.005940837785601616, 0.005906207486987114, -0.0028160912916064262, -0.06837760657072067, 0.00341864675283432, -0.003222794272005558, 0.058551184833049774, 0.052674371749162674, 0.005978353321552277, -0.00522829033434391, -0.04427013918757439, 0.01309487596154213, 0.001818150863982737, 0.020641744136810303, -0.07590646296739578, 0.01865653321146965, -0.021368874236941338, 0.01881006546318531, 0.013356324285268784, -0.0172195415943861, 0.0149879464879632, 0.0035355305299162865, 0.019719326868653297, 0.007245684042572975, 0.0729583129286766, 0.02020922861993313, 0.015369672328233719, 0.033276572823524475, -0.02011571265757084, 0.0205488633364439, 0.017859069630503654, -0.039517730474472046, 0.034448619931936264, 0.01259323488920927, 0.0583525113761425, -0.0261636134237051, -0.00911237858235836, -0.010403950698673725, 0.0049310592003166676, -0.0004796482971869409, -0.006117594428360462, -0.030605891719460487, -0.0543658472597599, 0.020422304049134254, -0.010346261784434319, -0.002425020793452859, 0.02880220115184784, 0.014604389667510986, -0.047335926443338394, 0.012331956066191196, -0.011756299063563347, -0.05310071259737015, -0.007389586418867111, 0.026669980958104134, -0.011297083459794521, -0.06648344546556473, -0.017560265958309174, 0.015792090445756912, -0.020768502727150917, -0.03889131918549538, -0.006974088493734598, -0.037844665348529816, 0.05371846631169319, -0.007665995974093676, -0.020481720566749573, 0.019657127559185028, 0.017165089026093483, -0.007185470312833786, -0.09901665896177292, 0.07569249719381332, 0.03539051115512848, 0.006606749724596739, 0.046076662838459015, 0.0034110897686332464, 0.0035318350419402122, -0.014077934436500072, 0.0708724707365036, 0.01195552572607994, 0.020322849974036217, 0.023363446816802025, 0.02271832711994648, 0.004502065945416689, -0.014069232158362865, 0.04449046775698662, 0.001656667678616941, -0.015346527099609375, -0.0330413393676281, -0.011183985508978367, 0.01193139236420393, -0.016138529404997826, -0.00752614950761199, 0.015429522842168808, -0.009874285198748112, 0.03290066123008728, -0.004225691314786673, 0.010192208923399448, -0.0008633973775431514, -0.0029855568427592516, 0.021732941269874573, 0.030687501654028893, 0.02537023276090622, 0.022330574691295624, -0.00335733056999743, -0.05750679969787598, 0.008834839798510075, -0.021930137649178505, -0.03711646795272827, -0.011525583453476429, 0.017177294939756393, -0.025476926937699318, -0.034775763750076294, 0.02108580432832241, -0.006555368658155203, -0.043520063161849976, -0.006907671689987183, 0.03728020191192627, -0.005971475038677454, 0.046174123883247375, 0.01733599416911602, 0.02664925716817379, -0.0012072756653651595, 0.026843594387173653, 0.025104647502303123, -0.011755667626857758, 0.031911760568618774, 0.0022782054729759693, 0.011266887187957764, 0.02259758673608303, -0.01701919175684452, 0.04543878138065338, 0.000019990156943094917, 0.030876196920871735, -0.015379419550299644, -0.03077206015586853, 0.06587128341197968, -0.0250423401594162, 0.00781360361725092, -0.0021306185517460108, -0.02526598423719406, 0.0756726786494255, -0.04659218341112137, -0.01574975624680519, -0.01383826695382595, 0.001225780346430838, -0.020098745822906494, 0.002840333618223667, -0.008956078439950943, -0.003716398263350129, 0.021831216290593147, 0.015638284385204315, -0.001989692682400346, -0.020469190552830696, 0.002137280534952879, -0.02072879858314991, 0.013643117621541023, 0.024297934025526047, 0.00003879805080941878, -0.003932065796107054, -0.014653180725872517, -0.020870523527264595, 0.007375113666057587, 0.007392761297523975, 0.029140852391719818, 0.028712963685393333, -0.02814583107829094, -0.0047640930861234665, 0.01647212915122509, 0.03823593631386757, -0.07165353745222092, -0.014659952372312546, -0.03695892170071602, -0.041413143277168274, -0.03522709012031555, -0.02883208729326725 ]
<p>Let's assume we have predictors x1-x5 and dependent variables y1-y9 in one dataset. We have a certain hypothesis about x1: it should have differently strong effects on our 9 dependent variables y1-y9. </p> <p>We perform 9 regressions, and find that x1 significantly predicts all y with p&lt;.001. Now we want to find out whether these (highly significant) effects are different from each other (just because they are significant effects does not mean they are equally strong). Two questions: </p> <p>(1) What information that a regression provides us with would give us insight into this question? Unstandardized beta? Standardized beta? t?</p> <p>(2) Is there a statistical test we can perform to find out whether the strengths of predictions are different between (y1 ON x1) and (y2 ON x1) and (y3 ON x1)? </p> <p>Software I can use is R and SPSS; field is psychology/medicine. </p>
36,649
[ -0.047749295830726624, 0.01519766729325056, -0.024089477956295013, 0.007508386857807636, 0.03924161195755005, 0.031985677778720856, 0.01829073205590248, -0.020395027473568916, 0.06088853254914284, -0.03131833299994469, 0.043796077370643616, 0.031250908970832825, 0.06662819534540176, -0.01749713532626629, 0.022848257794976234, -0.0031590270809829235, -0.0058268033899366856, 0.02576534077525139, -0.00019488006364554167, 0.011091787368059158, -0.012081134133040905, 0.027564430609345436, 0.006059302017092705, 0.025250375270843506, -0.0264789666980505, 0.06532697379589081, 0.036838386207818985, -0.016963200643658638, -0.005947788245975971, 0.014498569071292877, -0.008610837161540985, -0.018460530787706375, 0.00982374232262373, 0.0683547630906105, -0.005404760129749775, -0.01725704036653042, -0.0018801339901983738, -0.01902594231069088, 0.00339887710288167, 0.041200730949640274, -0.01837383210659027, -0.05264393240213394, -0.02873767353594303, 0.03558287024497986, -0.03348926827311516, -0.0073120007291436195, -0.00846985075622797, -0.02928389050066471, 0.028855305165052414, -0.022012043744325638, 0.0852968767285347, 0.00043207171256653965, 0.061215683817863464, 0.052927415817976, -0.012888574972748756, -0.0055852304212749004, 0.03840850293636322, 0.05745694786310196, -0.02132433094084263, -0.05566416308283806, -0.029425740242004395, -0.006365584209561348, 0.014380318112671375, -0.00032632212969474494, -0.048543184995651245, 0.03332109376788139, -0.002060355618596077, -0.017169585451483727, 0.06135774403810501, -0.006694944575428963, 0.018075931817293167, 0.03045731410384178, 0.04829893261194229, 0.023417407646775246, -0.023723989725112915, -0.019072145223617554, 0.01817970909178257, 0.01992132142186165, 0.0508185476064682, 0.03865012153983116, 0.0003229702706448734, 0.009520670399069786, 0.01592479832470417, 0.04833127558231354, 0.015197833068668842, -0.003720223205164075, 0.049167174845933914, -0.04453194886445999, 0.029035823419690132, 0.04639458283782005, -0.01960132271051407, -0.027955137193202972, 0.05165519937872887, 0.021489443257451057, -0.038758307695388794, 0.0037186727859079838, -0.01102517731487751, 0.010995742864906788, 0.00910349003970623, 0.03283053636550903, 0.02140754647552967, -0.05290238931775093, 0.009396273642778397, 0.04028457775712013, 0.008568866178393364, -0.008026402443647385, -0.025349734351038933, -0.001758302329108119, 0.007012293208390474, -0.01618225872516632, 0.001428784104064107, 0.017903519794344902, -0.00868514645844698, -0.0207954291254282, 0.022440150380134583, -0.007532036397606134, 0.005044018384069204, -0.045654889196157455, 0.05581222474575043, 0.05326511338353157, 0.032493989914655685, -0.0409097857773304, -0.0028383515309542418, 0.007118612062186003, -0.008231904357671738, 0.0046243020333349705, 0.03200582414865494, -0.047158047556877136, -0.03447060286998749, 0.06089702993631363, 0.00399576872587204, 0.0008260643808171153, 0.01704307831823826, 0.007310791406780481, 0.015887482091784477, 0.0242775771766901, -0.07820213586091995, -0.06643280386924744, 0.01936483569443226, -0.003413806203752756, -0.000865460024215281, -0.02968594990670681, -0.018890680745244026, 0.027925563976168633, 0.07096149027347565, 0.0047069089487195015, 0.02970486506819725, 0.009717466309666634, 0.00928625836968422, 0.03202985227108002, -0.047547224909067154, 0.02364814281463623, -0.026631131768226624, -0.03133387118577957, -0.03519819304347038, -0.09287022054195404, -0.009290234185755253, 0.005623607896268368, -0.03509986028075218, -0.019856620579957962, 0.006745159160345793, 0.000618302496150136, 0.0012677403865382075, -0.018778465688228607, 0.026334062218666077, -0.001911492901854217, 0.05086194723844528, -0.015363105572760105, 0.005311029497534037, 0.02162698470056057, -0.022132230922579765, 0.03580182045698166, 0.029058188199996948, 0.06373364478349686, 0.02658531256020069, -0.008029977791011333, 0.016187191009521484, -0.03492320701479912, 0.005780118517577648, -0.003715015249326825, -0.033604737371206284, -0.026072433218359947, -0.07109715044498444, -0.016108857467770576, -0.003970406949520111, 0.08500301092863083, -0.027865897864103317, -0.025959832593798637, 0.04442692548036575, -0.029586289077997208, -0.07049700617790222, -0.0603741817176342, 0.02836720272898674, -0.005284298676997423, -0.03730761259794235, 0.04872545972466469, 0.01134918350726366, 0.03475497290492058, -0.016345610842108727, 0.009765471331775188, -0.030271217226982117, 0.006247444078326225, 0.03550538048148155, -0.0068886918015778065, 0.023651134222745895, 0.0321216955780983, 0.04171711951494217, -0.04388491064310074, 0.043106190860271454, -0.07724027335643768, -0.03476693853735924, 0.04462464153766632, -0.06213510408997536, -0.016610009595751762, -0.014801442623138428, -0.020450303331017494, 0.004655615892261267, -0.044010598212480545, -0.029939984902739525, 0.03608886897563934, -0.05388392508029938, 0.06989303231239319, 0.029061658307909966, -0.006026789080351591, -0.015344399958848953, -0.009213869459927082, 0.012030286714434624, -0.008734412491321564, -0.04204634577035904, -0.00029210696811787784, -0.05787258222699165, -0.00621070945635438, 0.022133177146315575, 0.016062352806329727, -0.056154780089855194, 0.01648360677063465, 0.02787635289132595, 0.0025221933610737324, 0.008467880077660084, 0.042803067713975906, -0.013409522362053394, -0.004281847272068262, -0.01806764304637909, 0.032326824963092804, 0.02533787675201893, 0.009078466333448887, 0.032751474529504776, 0.04982323944568634, 0.061471398919820786, -0.0005504733417183161, 0.0004607118899002671, 0.03731174021959305, 0.00028082585777156055, -0.0037824399769306183, -0.019595004618167877, -0.001193059142678976, 0.06746040284633636, -0.003433338599279523, 0.020878152921795845, 0.01802261732518673, 0.01558599341660738, 0.009353773668408394, 0.014545232988893986, -0.007041487377136946, 0.06544102728366852, 0.03448624536395073, -0.025900056585669518, 0.025688666850328445, 0.01823173463344574, -0.03775512054562569, 0.050022054463624954, -0.009504904970526695, -0.010023712180554867, -0.021461673080921173, 0.026402007788419724, 0.027428066357970238, -0.010777696035802364, 0.021597353741526604, -0.019675320014357567, -0.02684169076383114, -0.004571603145450354, -0.03348158672451973, 0.032410118728876114, -0.006241207476705313, -0.06702487915754318, 0.004198756068944931, -0.02342117577791214, -0.01280487235635519, 0.006358205806463957, -0.032537225633859634, -0.027996204793453217, 0.03240318223834038, -0.03413453698158264, -0.08881449699401855, -0.0404786616563797, -0.05013778433203697, 0.03349864482879639, -0.016842268407344818, -0.03934139758348465, 0.02519763633608818, 0.0003786775341723114, -0.039871856570243835, 0.021499449387192726, 0.01163550280034542, -0.008140480145812035, 0.002939945552498102, -0.009452822618186474, -0.0017766613746061921, -0.00037065890501253307, 0.014398418366909027, 0.026883918792009354, -0.021094873547554016, -0.027288267388939857, -0.04973021149635315, -0.042069897055625916, 0.039898581802845, -0.0002633991534821689, 0.05499083176255226, -0.0039289891719818115, -0.030494701117277145, 0.07982563972473145, 0.018205342814326286, -0.019860154017806053, -0.06268633157014847, 0.029757754877209663, -0.03443824127316475, -0.01655864156782627, 0.022193579003214836, 0.0036717092152684927, 0.055916398763656616, 0.02378653548657894, 0.027332507073879242, 0.021472733467817307, 0.017092429101467133, 0.004010418895632029, -0.0019892817363142967, 0.024561915546655655, 0.00709178950637579, 0.016231318935751915, 0.006025712005794048, 0.03476664051413536, -0.039419449865818024, 0.013451977632939816, 0.014968647621572018, 0.018086332827806473, -0.0022711241617798805, -0.045119646936655045, 0.00980427023023367, 0.01491385418921709, -0.0055955140851438046, -0.03357641398906708, 0.0007513200398534536, 0.003072267398238182, -0.02953844703733921, -0.017480598762631416, 0.036484841257333755, 0.00782737135887146, -0.010690448805689812, -0.01346816960722208, 0.028795216232538223, 0.018028758466243744, -0.009454159997403622, -0.005055287387222052, -0.04681049659848213, -0.01791255548596382, 0.017385492101311684, -0.014249167405068874, -0.017264898866415024, 0.0454452708363533, -0.0014045470161363482, 0.014248418621718884, 0.001596605172380805, -0.05411289259791374, 0.017526384443044662, -0.0329364538192749, 0.0071927704848349094, -0.008245054632425308, 0.0438808798789978, 0.008834118023514748, 0.046344149857759476, 0.012514553032815456, -0.030648378655314445, 0.009864152409136295, -0.006698922254145145, -0.05052046477794647, 0.039474714547395706, -0.03633086010813713, 0.01049411203712225, 0.01881513185799122, 0.0027286915574222803, 0.019365040585398674, -0.041186146438121796, 0.0399547703564167, -0.007707410492002964, 0.01719086244702339, -0.046853747218847275, -0.02429298311471939, -0.026360340416431427, -0.03174814581871033, -0.014191593043506145, 0.02801966480910778, -0.02446419931948185, -0.031568869948387146, 0.043344974517822266, 0.014227952808141708, -0.039375804364681244, 0.01321137510240078, -0.069800965487957, 0.019907506182789803, 0.03437002748250961, 0.04662485793232918, 0.04209933057427406, 0.014632578939199448, -0.01582695171236992, 0.011266284622251987, 0.00011409520084271207, 0.01903003267943859, 0.0576864518225193, -0.0021638106554746628, -0.045656684786081314, -0.03444409370422363, 0.004379552323371172, 0.0010007258970290422, 0.015599805861711502, 0.023824527859687805, 0.007659631781280041, 0.051314763724803925, 0.04874549061059952, -0.0641268789768219, 0.026923131197690964, 0.06400018185377121, -0.0036867926828563213, -0.005823343526571989, -0.01953563652932644, 0.0037042212206870317, -0.002732747234404087, -0.005187549628317356, -0.019056502729654312, 0.014707119204103947, -0.007942499592900276, -0.01602473482489586, 0.0031753871589899063, -0.03197406232357025, -0.0509457103908062, -0.006899906322360039, 0.012048108503222466, 0.06798437982797623, 0.00896221399307251, -0.052481431514024734, 0.016496052965521812, 0.02794637717306614, 0.014537529088556767, 0.023585546761751175, 0.0022932409774512053, -0.06515157967805862, 0.0147800762206316, 0.05789058655500412, 0.0334952175617218, -0.010836445726454258, -0.02315010316669941, 0.011953717097640038, -0.0024223653599619865, 0.057840023189783096, -0.02186729572713375, -0.0036400307435542345, 0.014718951657414436, 0.0038875758182257414, -0.02785073034465313, -0.007840389385819435, -0.0746617317199707, 0.03286520764231682, -0.03162110224366188, 0.05028621107339859, -0.009697750210762024, -0.04757275804877281, -0.02928771637380123, 0.011669320054352283, 0.012636158615350723, 0.03839612379670143, -0.01597082056105137, -0.015525434166193008, 0.004098325967788696, 0.025935083627700806, -0.011979777365922928, -0.05073801800608635, 0.01701826974749565, 0.03140585497021675, -0.028456110507249832, 0.0740397498011589, -0.014049445278942585, -0.039558783173561096, 0.025241831317543983, 0.0007553703617304564, -0.008565927855670452, 0.014240846037864685, -0.0004601759428624064, 0.04387452080845833, 0.05664989724755287, 0.0025549884885549545, 0.06143311783671379, 0.015913445502519608, 0.0028083890210837126, -0.0161353200674057, 0.0075368392281234264, -0.005604296922683716, -0.025782110169529915, -0.040003497153520584, -0.04696427285671234, -0.010290122590959072, -0.014050181955099106, 0.010292628780007362, -0.011719096451997757, 0.005770648829638958, 0.008271905593574047, 0.005115056410431862, -0.01584024168550968, 0.01847033202648163, -0.009373358450829983, 0.026725100353360176, 0.0015679426724091172, -0.007192443590611219, -0.016001597046852112, -0.01211254857480526, 0.004162720404565334, 0.012787017971277237, -0.004962952341884375, -0.004669668152928352, -0.06979256123304367, 0.013975130394101143, -0.019237248227000237, -0.018442705273628235, 0.011597374454140663, -0.015982767567038536, 0.04439619183540344, -0.0013214951613917947, 0.018801914528012276, -0.010442331433296204, -0.03087994083762169, -0.025541109964251518, 0.06860240548849106, -0.00038561373366974294, 0.03302296623587608, -0.023624612018465996, 0.038918063044548035, -0.03629693016409874, -0.026244129985570908, -0.05403057485818863, -0.01838391087949276, 0.04158922657370567, 0.04829595610499382, 0.006949169095605612, -0.013904707506299019, 0.01275608129799366, -0.017883263528347015, 0.006828863639384508, -0.03283534571528435, 0.048937585204839706, -0.011804801411926746, -0.01028470415621996, -0.002116680145263672, -0.01649351790547371, 0.04383581876754761, -0.02162155695259571, -0.014001034200191498, -0.01327334064990282, 0.013120547868311405, -0.008185535669326782, -0.009665102697908878, -0.0157883670181036, -0.024355055764317513, -0.013288305141031742, -0.04343346878886223, 0.0013445669319480658, 0.04063345491886139, -0.046846065670251846, -0.004069428890943527, 0.005787584464997053, -0.01895325817167759, 0.019630052149295807, -0.012147011235356331, -0.016659962013363838, -0.031071364879608154, -0.019372718408703804, -0.008219871670007706, 0.01468968391418457, 0.005789204966276884, -0.025053828954696655, 0.03837692737579346, 0.033319953829050064, -0.03413235396146774, 0.008328537456691265, 0.061653561890125275, 0.027587464079260826, 0.015059294179081917, -0.03230942785739899, 0.005872298497706652, 0.047124505043029785, 0.007258224301040173, 0.002491353778168559, -0.0036698426119983196, 0.037290237843990326, -0.055797964334487915, -0.032814230769872665, -0.049597058445215225, -0.0017967317253351212, 0.05226488783955574, -0.02192731760442257, -0.004704026971012354, 0.08596903085708618, -0.02297135815024376, -0.021298399195075035, -0.033877309411764145, -0.024255454540252686, 0.010432446375489235, -0.026013974100351334, 0.049994371831417084, 0.017584167420864105, 0.010799490846693516, 0.0329061858355999, 0.015148081816732883, -0.005119865760207176, 0.03559762239456177, 0.014564876444637775, 0.029222164303064346, 0.042468514293432236, -0.04124237969517708, -0.033452246338129044, 0.04848429560661316, -0.05152801796793938, -0.030227359384298325, -0.03544403985142708, -0.0020192391239106655, 0.04555255174636841, 0.056659433990716934, 0.017851348966360092, -0.07451488077640533, -0.04377317428588867, -0.0643954873085022, 0.029202604666352272, 0.031474996358156204, 0.0004813078267034143, 0.03878890722990036, 0.01178672444075346, 0.025838680565357208, 0.024456027895212173, 0.02487003058195114, -0.06329261511564255, -0.09984776377677917, -0.02370135486125946, -0.023720378056168556, -0.005334616173058748, 0.0276340302079916, -0.011003300547599792, -0.04617995768785477, 0.041302476078271866, -0.05306486040353775, 0.006716092582792044, 0.016417929902672768, 0.030872168019413948, 0.0028109741397202015, 0.05761121213436127, -0.006833255756646395, 0.021224338561296463, 0.022980403155088425, -0.026677541434764862, 0.09336737543344498, 0.08715518563985825, 0.03689582645893097, -0.07303231209516525, 0.01791214942932129, 0.000980149838142097, -0.020535867661237717, -0.010141372680664062, 0.010321435518562794, 0.02794140949845314, -0.001238612225279212, 0.03317604213953018, 0.07367177307605743, 0.026292333379387856, 0.006314218044281006, 0.07089601457118988, -0.024603262543678284, 0.012589198537170887, 0.023152202367782593, 0.02021155133843422, 0.008014373481273651, -0.0562950074672699, -0.03055654466152191, 0.011588345281779766, -0.01720445789396763, -0.02892245166003704, -0.009126297198235989, 0.020048106089234352, 0.04110633209347725, -0.006174338050186634, -0.001872433815151453, -0.0028333705849945545, -0.008150642737746239, 0.016611777245998383, -0.06320277601480484, -0.002035322366282344, 0.038403451442718506, -0.04427434876561165, 0.02275831624865532, 0.014114726334810257, -0.017106663435697556, -0.0012722340179607272, -0.00596404867246747, 0.006234414875507355, -0.039472322911024094, -0.0335998497903347, -0.046306777745485306, 0.0322328545153141, -0.0056726522743701935, -0.03927839919924736, -0.004369794856756926, 0.02397005259990692, -0.0006974999560043216, -0.02435486577451229, -0.0529479905962944, 0.02317240461707115, 0.020922424271702766, -0.037965282797813416, 0.022636065259575844, -0.02416144497692585, 0.006802287418395281, -0.009935788810253143, 0.032072849571704865, 0.0014346654061228037, -0.0452544204890728, -0.0058475942350924015, -0.010569392703473568, 0.03531154990196228, 0.0050361123867332935, -0.017967533320188522, 0.02818901091814041, -0.006889067590236664, -0.01088934950530529, -0.0004326905182097107, 0.020232470706105232, 0.0007760845473967493, -0.015709318220615387, 0.005760659463703632, -0.0018975978018715978, -0.03410164639353752, 0.030163930729031563, 0.004113615024834871, -0.07001391798257828, 0.008448721840977669, -0.05562448874115944, -0.02375240996479988, 0.04186061769723892, 0.030242236331105232, 0.04041006788611412, -0.0009959334274753928, -0.019667401909828186, 0.01525561697781086, 0.02909950539469719, -0.09828773885965347, -0.028239386156201363, -0.002920729573816061, -0.043595727533102036, -0.02315327152609825, 0.0007567593129351735, 0.08075301349163055, 0.01576921157538891, 0.018096018582582474, 0.004321042913943529, 0.03146880492568016, -0.03227483108639717, 0.00855238363146782, -0.01491408422589302, -0.06210814416408539, -0.01153814047574997, -0.0006737900548614562, -0.005320986267179251, -0.002722611650824547, -0.007573373150080442, -0.03514019027352333, -0.021491825580596924, 0.03354557603597641, -0.027757341042160988, -0.001221265411004424, 0.015875397250056267, 0.029189206659793854, 0.025873340666294098, -0.0324377678334713, -0.008028062991797924, -0.042525120079517365, -0.019179442897439003, 0.03461789712309837, -0.028610670939087868, 0.01208595559000969, 0.0033452585339546204, -0.006342753767967224, 0.003912142477929592, 0.02623811550438404, 0.0094329584389925, 0.027626095339655876, -0.00015809491742402315, -0.00981700886040926, -0.01272042840719223, 0.03309240937232971, -0.04197204113006592, -0.03755049780011177, 0.024388710036873817, -0.03573005273938179, -0.03954838588833809, 0.048380736261606216, -0.03971261903643608, 0.029296379536390305, 0.03498034179210663, 0.01415881048887968, -0.030244169756770134, 0.05075551196932793, -0.006459026597440243, -0.0034031274262815714, 0.002354205586016178, 0.03271104022860527, -0.011217662133276463, 0.005503218155354261, 0.03206082433462143, 0.0027409198228269815, -0.030644956976175308, 0.04799434170126915, 0.03737656772136688, 0.027097877115011215, -0.006368877366185188, 0.010573172010481358, 0.02394290268421173, 0.023973731324076653, 0.011463724076747894, -0.015102293342351913, 0.049397263675928116, 0.03359342738986015, -0.053076937794685364, 0.04639830440282822, 0.023694084957242012, 0.027148274704813957, -0.09695648401975632, -0.017493126913905144, -0.028600990772247314, 0.007005996536463499, 0.02305409125983715, -0.06981199234724045, 0.05317787081003189, 0.02309976890683174, -0.02649201638996601, -0.013416281901299953, -0.015053552575409412, -0.008701501414179802, -0.019703272730112076, 0.026189057156443596, 0.0008618136635050178, 0.03454286977648735, 0.03216269239783287, 0.018392113968729973, 0.006059002596884966, 0.051897600293159485, 0.0033884409349411726, -0.027089040726423264, -0.012015553191304207, -0.020916782319545746, 0.016578778624534607, -0.09304177016019821, 0.0041031925939023495, -0.05531882494688034, -0.044813599437475204, 0.035008665174245834, 0.0018194301519542933, 0.03764878213405609, 0.024314766749739647, 0.02290741540491581, 0.01783120259642601, 0.03557705506682396, 0.02726990357041359, -0.024731844663619995, -0.035617608577013016, -0.026531321927905083, -0.0011262749321758747, 0.036567166447639465, -0.017690179869532585, 0.025727147236466408, 0.024293139576911926, 0.008573981001973152, -0.0010306036565452814, -0.015268770977854729, -0.01260603778064251, -0.04266749694943428, -0.02170051448047161, -0.010894845239818096, -0.00465467618778348, -0.00533381849527359, 0.006202499847859144, -0.07350923866033554, -0.004945546854287386, 0.02765539102256298, 0.07108605653047562, -0.029612593352794647, 0.015539131127297878, -0.03296622633934021, -0.03657829761505127, 0.005243092775344849, -0.0020272217225283384, 0.025082901120185852, -0.06852520257234573, 0.00034331169445067644, 0.004042658489197493, -0.024970393627882004, -0.04867832362651825, -0.016272149980068207, -0.02572212554514408, 0.03801112622022629, -0.013667376711964607, -0.0010287095792591572, 0.020458543673157692, -0.04493137449026108, 0.03598577156662941, -0.06474315375089645, 0.06261380016803741, 0.027853621169924736, -0.004803012125194073, -0.036905862390995026, 0.018826952204108238, -0.03578563779592514, -0.016150789335370064, 0.017996950075030327, -0.001337982015684247, 0.004907925613224506, 0.010793193243443966, 0.01729123666882515, -0.02020425722002983, -0.04481969773769379, 0.025598568841814995, -0.0024333407636731863, -0.021717209368944168, -0.048171572387218475, -0.003895843168720603, 0.041444458067417145, 0.011257737874984741, 0.016892636194825172, -0.003745797323063016, -0.014140813611447811, 0.00925663486123085, 0.020779801532626152, 0.0484275259077549, 0.007116511929780245, -0.0034178232308477163, 0.048384591937065125, 0.024546729400753975, 0.044825054705142975, 0.021511998027563095, -0.007097873371094465, -0.015424462035298347, 0.03966487944126129, -0.016542533412575722, -0.019962050020694733, -0.0019578207284212112, -0.013805982656776905, -0.02400466986000538, -0.057118095457553864, -0.01565936580300331, 0.007242003455758095, -0.025165900588035583, 0.018588896840810776, 0.03737734258174896, 0.040253646671772, 0.024735314771533012, -0.02341490611433983, -0.008519681170582771, 0.009978503920137882, -0.026047183200716972, 0.00964287482202053, 0.013615565374493599, 0.044028185307979584, 0.03158225491642952, 0.012911047786474228, 0.013730153441429138, -0.017606347799301147, 0.026547159999608994, -0.00803980603814125, 0.03179686516523361, -0.0033220993354916573, -0.015281694941222668, 0.0066232639364898205, -0.00904758833348751, 0.028881940990686417, -0.020028945058584213, 0.02344731241464615, 0.04712921008467674, -0.06385751068592072, -0.015650533139705658, -0.023280637338757515, -0.013350915163755417, -0.01218845322728157, 0.012657089158892632, 0.020529860630631447, -0.004037436563521624, 0.017886582762002945, 0.010294687002897263, 0.014373712241649628, -0.015021285973489285, 0.02179831825196743, 0.012213248759508133, -0.024339618161320686, -0.029050860553979874, -0.03646219149231911, -0.011556613259017467, -0.021966559812426567, -0.042381469160318375, -0.012341107241809368, 0.028225205838680267, 0.02940705418586731, 0.052192557603120804, -0.02638864889740944, -0.05223339423537254, 0.005577379837632179, 0.05108482763171196, -0.0689675584435463, -0.009230886586010456, -0.04450703039765358, 0.015474102459847927, -0.015053006820380688, -0.021183492615818977 ]
<p>I'm trying to program impulse response functions for a VAR model using Cholesky decomposition. The thing is I do not completely understand how I should do this when I read in the literature. Suppose I have:</p> <p>$$ \begin{bmatrix}x_t\\y_t\\z_t\end{bmatrix}=\begin{bmatrix}\alpha_1\\\alpha_2\\\alpha_3\end{bmatrix}+\begin{bmatrix}b_{11}&amp;b_{12}&amp;b_{13}\\b_{21}&amp;b_{22}&amp;b_{23}\\b_{31}&amp;b_{32}&amp;b_{33}\end{bmatrix}\begin{bmatrix}x_{t-1}\\y_{t-1}\\z_{t-1}\end{bmatrix}+\begin{bmatrix}u_{1t}\\ u_{2t}\\ u_{3t}\end{bmatrix} $$ which we can write as $$ \mathbf{x}_t=\mathbf{a}+\mathbf{B}\mathbf{x}_{t-1}+\mathbf{u}_t. $$</p> <p>Further, suppose the covariance matrix of $\mathbf{u}_t$ is $$ Cov(\mathbf{u}_t)=\Sigma_u=PP^\prime. $$</p> <p>Now, let's say I want the impulse responses to a unit shock in $u_{1t}$. I want the effects then on say $\mathbf{x}_t, \, \mathbf{x}_{t+1}, \, \mathbf{x}_{t+2}$ and $\mathbf{x}_{t+3}$. As I understand it, the orthogonalization is done by multiplying the error vector with $P$. Let's call the responses in period $t$ to the shock $\mathbf{x}_t^*$. Would what I am interested in then be (assume unit shock in $u_{1t}$ such that $\mathbf{u}_t^*=\begin{bmatrix}1&amp;0&amp;0\end{bmatrix}^\prime$):</p> <p>$$ \mathbf{x}_t^*=P\mathbf{u}^*_t=P\begin{bmatrix}1\\0\\0\end{bmatrix}\\ \mathbf{x}_{t+1}^*=\mathbf{B}\mathbf{x}^*_t=\mathbf{B}P\mathbf{u}^*_t\\ \mathbf{x}_{t+2}^*=\mathbf{B}\mathbf{x}^*_{t+1}=\mathbf{B}\mathbf{B}P\mathbf{u}^*_t\\ \mathbf{x}_{t+3}^*=\mathbf{B}\mathbf{x}^*_{t+2}=\mathbf{B}\mathbf{B}\mathbf{B}P\mathbf{u}^*_t $$</p> <p>Now, extend this to include more lags (for example 4). The model is then $$ \mathbf{x}_t=\mathbf{a}+\sum_{k=1}^4\mathbf{B}_k\mathbf{x}_{t-k}+\mathbf{u}_t. $$</p> <p>Thus the impulses are:</p> <p>$$ \mathbf{x}_t^*=P\mathbf{u}^*_t=P\begin{bmatrix}1\\0\\0\end{bmatrix}\\ \mathbf{x}_{t+1}^*=\mathbf{B}_1\mathbf{x}^*_t=\mathbf{B}_1P\mathbf{u}^*_t\\ \mathbf{x}_{t+2}^*=\mathbf{B}_1\mathbf{x}^*_{t+1}+\mathbf{B}_2\mathbf{x}^*_t=\mathbf{B}_1\mathbf{B}_1P\mathbf{u}^*_t + \mathbf{B}_2P\mathbf{u}^*_t\\ \mathbf{x}_{t+3}^*=\mathbf{B}_1\mathbf{x}^*_{t+2}+\mathbf{B}_2\mathbf{x}^*_{t+1}+\mathbf{B}_3\mathbf{x}^*_{t}=\mathbf{B}_1\mathbf{B}_1\mathbf{B}_1P\mathbf{u}^*_t + \mathbf{B}_1\mathbf{B}_2P\mathbf{u}^*_t+\mathbf{B}_2\mathbf{B}_1P\mathbf{u}^*_t+\mathbf{B}_3P\mathbf{u}^*_t $$</p> <p>Is this line of thinking correct? If so, then this simple R code should be fine:</p> <pre><code>library(vars) set.seed(1) x &lt;- rnorm(100) set.seed(2) y &lt;- rnorm(100) set.seed(3) z &lt;- rnorm(100) data &lt;- cbind(x, y, z) model &lt;- VAR(data, p=4, type = "const") u &lt;- matrix(c(1, 0, 0), ncol=1) P &lt;- chol(cov(residuals(model))) B1 &lt;- Acoef(model)[[1]] B2 &lt;- Acoef(model)[[2]] B3 &lt;- Acoef(model)[[3]] B4 &lt;- Acoef(model)[[4]] xt &lt;- P %*% u xt1 &lt;- B1 %*% xt xt2 &lt;- B1 %*% xt1 + B2 %*% xt xt3 &lt;- B1 %*% xt2 + B2 %*% xt1 + B1 %*% xt </code></pre> <p>Any input would be very much appreciated!</p>
36,651
[ 0.023612426593899727, -0.013302582316100597, -0.019108964130282402, -0.04998563975095749, 0.04158250242471695, 0.011701083742082119, -0.0263771191239357, -0.034980833530426025, 0.057853810489177704, -0.04532736912369728, -0.0043883416801691055, 0.0411255843937397, 0.03442814573645592, -0.005284742917865515, 0.015630869194865227, 0.02100519649684429, -0.0018023602897301316, 0.011455405503511429, 0.012337854132056236, 0.006496361456811428, 0.00019910121045541018, -0.0019208269659429789, -0.023574702441692352, -0.0016850311076268554, -0.0035427911207079887, 0.058192797005176544, 0.03008420392870903, -0.021177193149924278, 0.03632780537009239, 0.023688826709985733, -0.02009863220155239, -0.028575407341122627, 0.03364564850926399, 0.042035847902297974, 0.02981240302324295, 0.04874272271990776, -0.0064711193554103374, -0.03811223432421684, -0.006399139296263456, 0.005315393675118685, -0.03905223682522774, 0.009723005816340446, -0.01583300530910492, 0.03378617763519287, 0.0010194632923230529, 0.031812310218811035, -0.026499833911657333, 0.012796713039278984, -0.004711909685283899, -0.018763281404972076, 0.08611346781253815, 0.02117314748466015, 0.034718725830316544, 0.025749580934643745, -0.046059396117925644, -0.016993621364235878, 0.06669017672538757, 0.061989523470401764, 0.008167242631316185, -0.019957635551691055, 0.008293653838336468, -0.000202388662728481, -0.02082364447414875, -0.01088522095233202, -0.01618875190615654, 0.021716026589274406, 0.02197159454226494, -0.01218565646559, -0.005703470204025507, -0.04499858617782593, 0.0379398874938488, -0.03370156139135361, -0.005111677572131157, -0.061006102710962296, -0.016338201239705086, -0.041483551263809204, 0.008671186864376068, 0.015426132827997208, 0.017294777557253838, -0.013254527933895588, 0.009292256087064743, 0.027760513126850128, 0.022875413298606873, 0.03404323011636734, 0.012942003086209297, 0.02124052122235298, 0.05956941097974777, -0.053743425756692886, 0.07043281197547913, -0.0054364693351089954, -0.043487317860126495, -0.0016325890319421887, 0.0475887767970562, -0.03921079263091087, -0.03929027169942856, 0.032685890793800354, 0.004639867227524519, 0.03825121745467186, 0.003551441477611661, -0.00711783766746521, -0.011099996976554394, -0.042632095515728, 0.0035120584070682526, 0.031910404562950134, 0.006539869122207165, 0.012496961280703545, -0.0017709811218082905, 0.008931105956435204, 0.007947529666125774, -0.0850985050201416, -0.05035734549164772, 0.051037341356277466, -0.05262959748506546, -0.013034001924097538, 0.021061519160866737, -0.02041901834309101, -0.01549590565264225, 0.00505105359479785, 0.01458399835973978, 0.06689265370368958, 0.07366334646940231, -0.02237265184521675, 0.0037633285392075777, -0.019386030733585358, -0.08868671953678131, 0.0015519646694883704, 0.004811383783817291, -0.006784684024751186, -0.05676517263054848, 0.05749925225973129, 0.036711256951093674, -0.051145367324352264, 0.04481054097414017, 0.025825899094343185, 0.0005538192926906049, -0.008374499157071114, -0.11621344834566116, -0.012452492490410805, 0.02718312479555607, 0.004876596387475729, -0.019267039373517036, -0.08225419372320175, 0.009721212089061737, 0.02226460538804531, 0.0635601356625557, -0.012763286009430885, 0.03941955044865608, 0.04147808998823166, 0.04035614803433418, 0.03470122814178467, -0.0068700797855854034, 0.020534729585051537, -0.04448757320642471, 0.017994794994592667, 0.038978446274995804, -0.038833342492580414, 0.00044557242654263973, 0.016332929953932762, -0.001971531892195344, 0.015189667232334614, 0.05517232418060303, 0.016591286286711693, -0.0345199890434742, 0.00038729881634935737, 0.01583707518875599, -0.039544764906167984, 0.022729575634002686, -0.021318521350622177, 0.005703633185476065, 0.018651610240340233, -0.018045801669359207, -0.03798360750079155, -0.014363636262714863, 0.05985257029533386, 0.04317425563931465, -0.05982109531760216, -0.010438305325806141, 0.0009842411382123828, -0.040152568370103836, 0.034839168190956116, -0.02623315155506134, -0.06393272429704666, -0.029690660536289215, -0.009178959764540195, 0.01981927640736103, 0.027676057070493698, 0.03400988131761551, 0.031140262261033058, 0.03716404363512993, -0.051823683083057404, -0.011978529393672943, -0.0428389236330986, -0.003416304709389806, -0.0008492055931128561, -0.02279011532664299, 0.044388510286808014, -0.04111345857381821, 0.011577523313462734, 0.042978882789611816, -0.03252697363495827, -0.018293756991624832, 0.02699602209031582, 0.028530986979603767, -0.027307288721203804, 0.02751677669584751, -0.00634775822982192, 0.0387284979224205, 0.015479516237974167, 0.046401023864746094, -0.010917526669800282, 0.020908696576952934, 0.0023127535823732615, -0.022794527933001518, 0.009859997779130936, -0.022092347964644432, -0.018821075558662415, 0.026796672493219376, -0.03925744444131851, -0.0026601203717291355, 0.0307018980383873, -0.030656225979328156, 0.02657274715602398, 0.1300022155046463, 0.006341585423797369, -0.0019605252891778946, 0.02798144705593586, -0.004932945594191551, 0.06508645415306091, -0.0025822878815233707, -0.0010361336171627045, -0.03397882729768753, 0.009910681284964085, 0.04478026181459427, 0.04727225750684738, -0.0305943563580513, -0.007210466079413891, 0.04342453554272652, -0.007224275264889002, 0.028697073459625244, 0.0600832924246788, 0.00817659217864275, 0.0009050005464814603, 0.040167186409235, -0.01701951213181019, 0.018948979675769806, 0.006625586189329624, -0.0015632439171895385, -0.02779589779675007, 0.049048274755477905, -0.012090915814042091, -0.010750897228717804, 0.027028603479266167, 0.009511065669357777, 0.007682683411985636, -0.0443548746407032, -0.006332344375550747, 0.02394801378250122, 0.0020804479718208313, 0.022285310551524162, 0.02833389677107334, -0.0023978909011930227, -0.002397088333964348, 0.01568993553519249, -0.03803762421011925, -0.014122978784143925, 0.007629835046827793, -0.020790111273527145, -0.023119568824768066, 0.018262434750795364, -0.01585855334997177, -0.00010155076597584412, 0.011690578423440456, -0.03346296027302742, -0.013989970088005066, -0.009951615706086159, 0.05750637874007225, 0.024295013397932053, 0.004751645959913731, -0.008679263293743134, 0.019296251237392426, 0.0017371557187289, -0.006142389960587025, 0.04242054373025894, -0.002720619784668088, -0.04229944944381714, 0.023882342502474785, -0.03688265383243561, -0.0018868454499170184, 0.005395994987338781, 0.01284619141370058, -0.0024466561153531075, 0.02285691164433956, -0.017768044024705887, -0.04338430240750313, -0.0436004102230072, -0.010290763340890408, 0.007596559822559357, -0.01402437686920166, -0.022286856546998024, 0.06277924031019211, 0.027253886684775352, -0.023267270997166634, -0.04421699419617653, -0.023975985124707222, 0.014870359562337399, -0.019428983330726624, -0.03851954638957977, -0.03024424985051155, -0.01231150422245264, 0.06308187544345856, 0.008389175869524479, -0.008119797334074974, 0.004838846158236265, -0.06385810673236847, -0.02991153486073017, -0.03510772064328194, 0.06532883644104004, 0.05595719441771507, 0.02554970607161522, 0.0013066795654594898, 0.07342615723609924, -0.0230245441198349, -0.0014370258431881666, -0.005179081577807665, 0.01539648324251175, 0.01923576183617115, -0.061471886932849884, 0.03436650335788727, 0.019069265574216843, 0.0009045229526236653, -0.0017870700685307384, -0.017902815714478493, 0.028597937896847725, 0.06509541720151901, -0.02291724644601345, 0.019833320751786232, 0.009142477996647358, -0.030728427693247795, 0.02958592213690281, 0.006624083966016769, -0.012726915068924427, 0.030299682170152664, 0.004411012399941683, 0.014284001663327217, -0.00007668248872505501, 0.056677673012018204, -0.03201344981789589, -0.004773747641593218, -0.006061547435820103, 0.0021304937545210123, -0.043088216334581375, 0.02568204700946808, 0.0017651221714913845, -0.03136591240763664, -0.05008992552757263, 0.01889640837907791, 0.008773716166615486, -0.015912683680653572, -0.0066818795166909695, 0.059992898255586624, 0.024370040744543076, -0.017564745619893074, -0.006522143259644508, 0.01548092346638441, -0.012413236312568188, 0.051989827305078506, -0.026528961956501007, 0.023513106629252434, 0.009765167720615864, 0.031305670738220215, 0.02041490003466606, -0.03119230642914772, -0.018713735044002533, -0.011452476494014263, -0.043069224804639816, 0.027157649397850037, -0.04742683842778206, 0.05187734588980675, 0.023288508877158165, 0.060753364115953445, -0.002976312069222331, -0.00840773805975914, 0.0011322185164317489, -0.0201653353869915, -0.055178962647914886, 0.031930286437273026, 0.004569737706333399, -0.0125123281031847, -0.022922992706298828, -0.0213968213647604, 0.023169999942183495, -0.016333352774381638, -0.00624671159312129, -0.010792176239192486, -0.006615247577428818, -0.029277104884386063, -0.004922446794807911, -0.016188226640224457, 0.01560775376856327, -0.016896571964025497, 0.01604483276605606, 0.052395936101675034, -0.06186683475971222, 0.0233017485588789, 0.028338544070720673, 0.0007062748773023486, -0.002681237645447254, -0.023602090775966644, 0.04804534092545509, 0.06653006374835968, 0.03917066752910614, -0.020185012370347977, 0.00820684153586626, -0.005898839328438044, 0.045650679618120193, 0.021819505840539932, 0.020349545404314995, 0.04166139289736748, -0.005215127486735582, -0.0321555957198143, -0.015015258453786373, 0.017245501279830933, 0.03863092511892319, 0.023466693237423897, 0.06253300607204437, -0.009264776483178139, 0.06954307854175568, 0.012609407305717468, -0.010418642312288284, 0.010532492771744728, 0.0545925535261631, -0.013179393485188484, 0.02220883034169674, -0.0456734336912632, 0.021991897374391556, -0.006876250263303518, -0.008082141168415546, 0.03040391020476818, -0.0017062360420823097, 0.0020507180597633123, -0.0022218746598809958, 0.03887341916561127, 0.011784269474446774, -0.004933016374707222, 0.02500743977725506, 0.047408975660800934, 0.009254910051822662, 0.031100474298000336, -0.04224551096558571, -0.0043313223868608475, 0.031191818416118622, 0.041955359280109406, 0.039316460490226746, 0.047196485102176666, -0.06647676229476929, 0.027938123792409897, -0.02136332169175148, 0.01996428146958351, -0.03194469213485718, -0.01489206962287426, -0.04252030700445175, -0.016703877598047256, 0.04243353009223938, -0.013096281327307224, 0.05061035975813866, -0.021421434357762337, 0.010554597713053226, -0.028604449704289436, -0.04616643115878105, -0.02608342096209526, 0.008960405364632607, -0.0141373286023736, 0.04134414345026016, 0.0029927478171885014, -0.038408637046813965, -0.02128123864531517, 0.010846691206097603, 0.024141274392604828, 0.023524679243564606, -0.055407777428627014, -0.03292151540517807, -0.019432712346315384, 0.04390735179185867, -0.027905777096748352, -0.05908411368727684, -0.010397532023489475, 0.004704486578702927, -0.011373131535947323, 0.02600320614874363, 0.022885728627443314, -0.00595912104472518, 0.04583513364195824, 0.012653527781367302, 0.04983947426080704, -0.01600588858127594, 0.0049432311207056046, 0.0782904326915741, -0.0033232097048312426, -0.03734138235449791, 0.07573864609003067, 0.034947026520967484, -0.01530647836625576, -0.001856530550867319, -0.04595445841550827, -0.006148588843643665, -0.04366190358996391, 0.000044706539483740926, -0.05129656568169594, 0.01367783173918724, 0.013366419821977615, 0.048330873250961304, -0.0302203968167305, 0.022877849638462067, -0.03874717652797699, 0.0026460562366992235, 0.027878504246473312, 0.054129958152770996, -0.04991421476006508, 0.0063876500353217125, 0.009233461692929268, 0.027176804840564728, -0.026839716359972954, -0.015556300058960915, -0.004216401372104883, -0.03256095200777054, 0.021869074553251266, 0.015534656122326851, -0.04160737618803978, 0.005170766264200211, 0.031580422073602676, -0.012452635914087296, -0.032806072384119034, -0.01799326203763485, 0.04077710956335068, -0.00510573573410511, -0.0047863018698990345, 0.025235341861844063, -0.022308893501758575, 0.04763919487595558, 0.029456358402967453, 0.01795334368944168, 0.056419167667627335, -0.044712167233228683, 0.016575507819652557, 0.0012718188809230924, 0.029317153617739677, -0.05468493700027466, -0.046690281480550766, 0.035459477454423904, -0.02047562599182129, -0.04737519100308418, -0.03689945489168167, 0.013796868734061718, -0.024881280958652496, -0.04204898327589035, -0.010853306390345097, 0.05004795268177986, -0.015781505033373833, -0.013796846382319927, -0.022519033402204514, 0.039693232625722885, 0.062010686844587326, 0.015916064381599426, 0.002398430835455656, 0.00405038520693779, -0.033659301698207855, -0.023360058665275574, -0.03477216511964798, 0.0009473317768424749, -0.011770008131861687, 0.03413793444633484, 0.01686134748160839, -0.03143954649567604, 0.03168898820877075, -0.025431178510189056, -0.021080447360873222, 0.0036284690722823143, -0.0014016906498000026, 0.0012073121033608913, -0.04051860049366951, -0.0423649325966835, -0.02103666588664055, 0.000494720705319196, -0.02829115465283394, -0.03219344839453697, -0.024609781801700592, -0.014528644271194935, -0.002706666477024555, -0.004780075047165155, 0.003659855807200074, 0.017771072685718536, 0.030480509623885155, 0.014900383539497852, 0.016353271901607513, 0.024093514308333397, -0.008034692145884037, 0.05432121455669403, 0.03201597183942795, 0.008370887488126755, 0.0024609239771962166, -0.026233315467834473, -0.03024032898247242, -0.03978026285767555, -0.059020448476076126, 0.04117684066295624, 0.0835898220539093, -0.025932475924491882, 0.023683810606598854, 0.05370577052235603, 0.0005182823515497148, -0.017505548894405365, -0.03849731758236885, -0.005840781144797802, -0.010259142145514488, -0.04392710328102112, 0.051135219633579254, -0.03308635205030441, -0.040660545229911804, 0.011270752176642418, 0.013505106791853905, 0.020378272980451584, 0.014319395646452904, -0.018737230449914932, 0.016271794214844704, 0.002807811601087451, -0.026526471599936485, -0.045824084430933, 0.026276182383298874, -0.021436797454953194, -0.010452318005263805, -0.023688070476055145, -0.004812703933566809, 0.023823007941246033, 0.04679815098643303, 0.0010448945686221123, -0.04172167927026749, -0.015076391398906708, -0.06040530279278755, 0.013775232248008251, 0.028252722695469856, -0.02245137467980385, 0.018001537770032883, 0.045381054282188416, 0.07173805683851242, 0.0018606436206027865, 0.023646097630262375, -0.022527510300278664, -0.07195442169904709, -0.017555302008986473, -0.048201508820056915, -0.03357638046145439, 0.03348509594798088, -0.012563394382596016, -0.011800005100667477, -0.003110596677288413, -0.006596945691853762, 0.03660891205072403, -0.023033374920487404, 0.04317604377865791, -0.007079451810568571, 0.08008609712123871, -0.042487937957048416, 0.016194701194763184, -0.012289507314562798, 0.005056648049503565, 0.13656584918498993, 0.054231274873018265, 0.029584534466266632, -0.03883461281657219, -0.02513864077627659, -0.012103881686925888, -0.023511359468102455, -0.04970681667327881, 0.025141580030322075, 0.01752854511141777, -0.05483509600162506, -0.004236213862895966, 0.041868001222610474, -0.0031159783247858286, -0.03792036324739456, 0.011326110921800137, -0.015038507990539074, -0.014527185820043087, -0.016942493617534637, 0.010220441967248917, -0.012379562482237816, 0.008016949519515038, -0.0353190042078495, 0.005083922762423754, -0.006301914341747761, -0.03267258405685425, -0.0517180971801281, 0.003906072350218892, -0.010487237013876438, -0.04735056683421135, -0.0032970490865409374, 0.03782249614596367, 0.016150174662470818, 0.03290373831987381, -0.020004412159323692, 0.033174220472574234, -0.011259560473263264, -0.03966088965535164, 0.04355120286345482, 0.00883870106190443, -0.006003762595355511, 0.02783157490193844, -0.011167210526764393, 0.015928104519844055, -0.019692692905664444, -0.021098455414175987, -0.03700860217213631, 0.062486432492733, -0.012248927727341652, -0.03244422376155853, -0.05874167010188103, 0.05341525748372078, 0.01854865998029709, -0.03943295031785965, 0.006011013872921467, 0.023733187466859818, 0.027456186711788177, -0.04547758772969246, -0.0009303251281380653, -0.009267475455999374, -0.028570670634508133, 0.01993689499795437, 0.016849156469106674, 0.019252365455031395, -0.061676736921072006, 0.025962060317397118, -0.022086534649133682, 0.0318165086209774, -0.015244620852172375, 0.0003679030924104154, 0.024184469133615494, 0.03543422743678093, -0.013936290517449379, -0.0632658302783966, 0.01858908124268055, 0.002437831135466695, 0.007378575392067432, -0.005206939298659563, -0.004017690196633339, -0.04879762604832649, -0.062132492661476135, 0.01749112643301487, -0.009280912578105927, -0.03276978060603142, -0.00143262033816427, -0.014845126308500767, 0.018435852602124214, 0.04053333029150963, -0.017314741387963295, 0.008131121285259724, -0.004899562802165747, 0.08507406711578369, 0.017068933695554733, -0.05294502526521683, -0.016785355284810066, 0.03207611292600632, 0.006535986438393593, -0.004343661945313215, 0.021792486310005188, 0.06502002477645874, 0.02751913107931614, 0.028546910732984543, -0.05209207162261009, 0.0357758104801178, -0.041978590190410614, -0.012386182323098183, 0.03726709634065628, -0.03181639313697815, 0.032702166587114334, 0.02342529222369194, 0.02017473615705967, -0.03620520979166031, 0.004257115535438061, -0.005360485054552555, -0.025768356397747993, -0.030429508537054062, -0.038755737245082855, -0.007915175519883633, -0.019045494496822357, -0.055844780057668686, 0.007449625991284847, -0.014819987118244171, 0.008050735108554363, 0.0037969136610627174, 0.01609717682003975, -0.011775236576795578, -0.028729282319545746, -0.036522552371025085, -0.017579277977347374, -0.049299221485853195, -0.00559282535687089, 0.034459181129932404, 0.04010101407766342, 0.01764678955078125, -0.0023261182941496372, 0.020361507311463356, 0.0019276350503787398, 0.06721808761358261, 0.05342443287372589, -0.014745990745723248, 0.02410714700818062, -0.0517098493874073, -0.03890184313058853, 0.02681865356862545, 0.02459787018597126, 0.04225612431764603, 0.010947399772703648, 0.011578258126974106, -0.05376838147640228, 0.06294842064380646, 0.016287673264741898, 0.031654998660087585, -0.022759972140192986, -0.017453612759709358, -0.005571063607931137, -0.02981618419289589, 0.012572266161441803, -0.021391620859503746, -0.004552262369543314, 0.004427018109709024, 0.015190908685326576, -0.03342679142951965, 0.02138792909681797, -0.0004160359385423362, -0.016924984753131866, 0.0007408353849314153, -0.02049776166677475, -0.011819036677479744, 0.037934012711048126, 0.0527188666164875, -0.00015505720512010157, -0.011281467974185944, 0.00889170914888382, -0.0005138185806572437, -0.07122201472520828, -0.020148001611232758, 0.004049570299685001, -0.012393235228955746, 0.023212717846035957, -0.009460785426199436, 0.030122580006718636, -0.003675169311463833, -0.011283930391073227, 0.012482669204473495, -0.03574075549840927, -0.013239508494734764, -0.03204164281487465, 0.015329713001847267, -0.0044746994972229, 0.01665421575307846, 0.03146505355834961, -0.01541106216609478, 0.0014644796028733253, 0.027801744639873505, 0.0029561712872236967, -0.03501536324620247, 0.013416464440524578, 0.01809445396065712, 0.008651546202600002, -0.047553278505802155, 0.04557683318853378, -0.03295101970434189, -0.007121868431568146, 0.006924516521394253, 0.0011569923954084516, -0.015538442879915237, -0.010812169872224331, 0.055890005081892014, 0.0065409280359745026, 0.05229092761874199, 0.042212024331092834, -0.014412971213459969, 0.05245031788945198, 0.011956238187849522, 0.010690219700336456, -0.0037454389967024326, -0.015248650684952736, 0.012232096865773201, 0.01342444121837616, 0.003159431740641594, -0.03698482736945152, -0.04926704987883568, 0.01805899105966091, -0.04699467867612839, -0.00424289470538497, -0.051152169704437256, 0.0025976584292948246, -0.026875250041484833, 0.012262333184480667, -0.028526026755571365, -0.02891402132809162, 0.019679496064782143, -0.019237425178289413, -0.005548099521547556, -0.0037967602256685495, -0.05254628136754036, -0.03474587947130203, 0.02928858995437622, 0.01368335448205471, 0.0035195949021726847, -0.05446712300181389, -0.040027961134910583, 0.03995829075574875, -0.02501903660595417, -0.07308342307806015, -0.009004561230540276, -0.009253582917153835, 0.04087803512811661, 0.009867105633020401, -0.020965488627552986, 0.0014101099222898483, 0.00858687050640583, 0.004146564286202192, -0.058188796043395996, 0.04195960983633995, 0.0009404424345120788, -0.045037396252155304, -0.0019466206431388855, -0.017452064901590347, -0.0063838595524430275, 0.03771543502807617, 0.05955330282449722, -0.01779578998684883, 0.02368071861565113, 0.02197994291782379, 0.04319712892174721, 0.02588711306452751, -0.032629746943712234, 0.055761370807886124, 0.013027967885136604, 0.004501829389482737, -0.016829147934913635, -0.019668765366077423, 0.00858005415648222, 0.013440282084047794, -0.013718228787183762, 0.017963001504540443, -0.009586513042449951, -0.020434867590665817, -0.051391709595918655, 0.006478147115558386, 0.012287028133869171, -0.02666507661342621, 0.025248844176530838, -0.004180933814495802, 0.016998425126075745, 0.008075117133557796, -0.015790008008480072, -0.06293758749961853, -0.03319672495126724, -0.05564417690038681, 0.004481093492358923, -0.04282424971461296, -0.0008981236605904996, 0.015731090679764748, -0.062076766043901443, -0.0203863475471735, 0.02894267626106739, -0.03428264707326889, -0.021159537136554718, 0.04750437289476395, -0.024096552282571793, -0.0020772581920027733, 0.02162298373878002, 0.024250458925962448, 0.015118258073925972, -0.051802173256874084, 0.024255968630313873, 0.021590005606412888, 0.027795247733592987, -0.0020862191449850798, -0.019413204863667488, -0.01025433000177145, -0.01669652760028839, -0.0017222660826519132, 0.015750011429190636, 0.0045605977065861225, -0.012244670651853085, -0.020867466926574707, 0.02306460589170456, -0.021417954936623573, 0.00560325663536787, 0.02434595488011837, -0.02242266573011875, 0.04370734468102455, -0.04035938158631325, -0.018698982894420624, 0.014762049540877342, 0.011963249184191227, -0.00013911700807511806, 0.018403252586722374, 0.0054502831771969795, 0.02113417722284794, -0.027576563879847527, 0.008735349401831627, -0.01861199550330639, -0.035264041274785995, 0.014022122137248516, -0.05995249003171921, 0.0017915667267516255, 0.04375382512807846, -0.000050496899348217994, 0.005458507686853409, -0.02197142131626606, -0.05728754773736, -0.041371118277311325, 0.04017467051744461, 0.025433087721467018, -0.016507355496287346, -0.03245774656534195, 0.024883374571800232, -0.01373849157243967, 0.040892601013183594, -0.04056345298886299, -0.01774677447974682, 0.010274670086801052, -0.002001699060201645, -0.0070624565705657005, 0.046967651695013046 ]
<p>I estimated a Partial Least Squares model where the X matrix had normalized columns. Now I want to predict the value for a new instance (which is a frequency vector summing to one.) I assume that if I just use the raw frequency values, the predicted value won't be on the same scale as the scenario where my 'new' instance was taken from the normalized X matrix. (i.e. Comparing the fitted values of the model with predicted value of new instance.)</p> <p>I was thinking of adding the new instance as the bottom row of the original non-normalized X matrix, normalizing, and then using the values from this new bottom row to predict.</p> <p>Alternatively, I could standardize by using the column means and standard deviations from the original non-normalized X. </p> <p>Is one method preferred to the other? Is there a better way?</p>
50
[ -0.04587368294596672, 0.0016067768447101116, -0.02156616933643818, 0.0021029491908848286, 0.0075925737619400024, 0.00950507540255785, -0.003082528244704008, -0.00013136786583345383, 0.04424817115068436, -0.033787041902542114, 0.013051292859017849, 0.0659283995628357, 0.0504816435277462, 0.04588356241583824, 0.015998179093003273, 0.023432236164808273, -0.044877681881189346, -0.018511302769184113, -0.024972306564450264, -0.008125108666718006, 0.00010491097782505676, 0.0065150996670126915, 0.021928735077381134, -0.018440790474414825, 0.013996141031384468, 0.05779348313808441, 0.03460119664669037, -0.04041026160120964, 0.036771271377801895, 0.058866485953330994, 0.004016705323010683, -0.025166070088744164, 0.008115261793136597, 0.032821182161569595, 0.039401523768901825, 0.027901696041226387, -0.023091644048690796, -0.013208947144448757, -0.01726272515952587, 0.04405979439616203, 0.0003870262880809605, -0.0029551757033914328, 0.01651371270418167, 0.02290005423128605, -0.003357615554705262, 0.04657953605055809, -0.025606876239180565, -0.018209196627140045, 0.020079324021935463, -0.03805796802043915, 0.08127979189157486, 0.0026828725822269917, 0.004896878730505705, 0.04634518176317215, -0.03989841043949127, 0.007839924655854702, 0.0656886100769043, 0.025861572474241257, 0.0008241691975854337, -0.06360635906457901, -0.008400380611419678, -0.034798651933670044, -0.014422422274947166, -0.015860555693507195, -0.014576230198144913, 0.012860952876508236, -0.02757561020553112, -0.021681498736143112, 0.03416009619832039, -0.039005059748888016, 0.014517170377075672, 0.029960904270410538, 0.04766424372792244, -0.01810137741267681, 0.027462806552648544, -0.041939351707696915, 0.022555677220225334, 0.044644422829151154, 0.04283694922924042, 0.02982962131500244, 0.04853291064500809, 0.0016970467986539006, 0.013347646221518517, 0.045934755355119705, 0.012800524942576885, -0.021381083875894547, 0.03414326161146164, 0.007019302807748318, 0.007742132991552353, 0.06329035013914108, 0.015370541252195835, 0.0029446061234921217, 0.07891353219747543, -0.036774251610040665, -0.014021661132574081, 0.025173621252179146, -0.01851239614188671, 0.017990807071328163, -0.003900649957358837, -0.008257811889052391, -0.010366213507950306, -0.008221635594964027, -0.01952071115374565, 0.03450826182961464, -0.016243571415543556, -0.00024764746194705367, -0.013010942377150059, -0.01606013998389244, 0.006250141654163599, -0.03848063573241234, -0.013514294289052486, -0.0030307965353131294, -0.00916067510843277, -0.006314408499747515, 0.016417192295193672, -0.0032705848570913076, -0.02085563726723194, -0.023123249411582947, 0.061716385185718536, 0.08374565094709396, 0.009159485809504986, -0.020247332751750946, 0.008479754440486431, -0.030277492478489876, -0.02050744742155075, 0.05052846297621727, -0.0050790621899068356, -0.009208301082253456, -0.06804218888282776, 0.052482251077890396, -0.011883411556482315, -0.020460164174437523, 0.03511398285627365, -0.008739217184484005, -0.006245491560548544, 0.008063805289566517, -0.08250636607408524, -0.022953161969780922, 0.017357485368847847, -0.02899935655295849, 0.003973279148340225, -0.04437311738729477, -0.010605135932564735, 0.02211586758494377, 0.07000214606523514, 0.0532100573182106, 0.008699205704033375, 0.0062436009757220745, 0.05200687050819397, 0.0016712115611881018, 0.00578519981354475, -0.021229257807135582, -0.038492221385240555, -0.06431855261325836, -0.04688972234725952, -0.053078897297382355, 0.002958844415843487, 0.037882983684539795, -0.01761508174240589, 0.006303433328866959, 0.02398778311908245, 0.006094960495829582, -0.008377986028790474, -0.0047260164283216, -0.006321029271930456, -0.044938698410987854, 0.026137471199035645, -0.048040423542261124, 0.018555140122771263, 0.0339851975440979, -0.0074041155166924, -0.005211099982261658, -0.002987631130963564, 0.02889907732605934, 0.023977069184184074, 0.017011044546961784, 0.011466866359114647, -0.042219389230012894, 0.03401055932044983, -0.01718629151582718, -0.03054807521402836, -0.034872379153966904, -0.007468576077371836, 0.01486795861274004, 0.014744405634701252, 0.049578599631786346, 0.005989489611238241, -0.0363975465297699, 0.042337965220212936, -0.053534675389528275, -0.03895040601491928, -0.09085913747549057, 0.017140429466962814, -0.0010385935893282294, -0.022890714928507805, 0.041076790541410446, -0.025555042549967766, 0.022065604105591774, 0.013643342070281506, -0.005530045833438635, -0.03373686969280243, 0.01103264931589365, 0.03780415281653404, -0.09904681146144867, 0.025304675102233887, 0.07577033340930939, 0.039727214723825455, -0.01591459847986698, 0.06162438914179802, -0.03952702879905701, -0.044832926243543625, 0.0014780281344428658, -0.03090767189860344, -0.001436389982700348, -0.006244031712412834, -0.0031480558682233095, 0.03349015489220619, 0.005779955070465803, 0.0009898138232529163, -0.007061828393489122, -0.06302817910909653, 0.07249313592910767, 0.051753729581832886, -0.012767301872372627, 0.020744746550917625, -0.012142203748226166, 0.02436634711921215, 0.023753957822918892, -0.021249011158943176, -0.01091389823704958, -0.026010051369667053, 0.016575418412685394, 0.03458869829773903, 0.03244909644126892, -0.022168666124343872, -0.008467455394566059, 0.07088474184274673, -0.012874389067292213, 0.03079216182231903, 0.02784065157175064, 0.021870121359825134, -0.021720923483371735, 0.04270949214696884, 0.005106733180582523, 0.009028315544128418, -0.021050255745649338, -0.004230366554111242, 0.0009723571711219847, 0.019155001267790794, 0.017875362187623978, 0.009943671524524689, 0.025030218064785004, 0.014877410605549812, 0.0026985539589077234, -0.05285964906215668, -0.03385695442557335, 0.004020929802209139, -0.017773296684026718, 0.018490100279450417, 0.014264710247516632, -0.025550400838255882, -0.0239118579775095, -0.010749992914497852, -0.02913045324385166, 0.017972460016608238, 0.03258458152413368, -0.04250706732273102, 0.04242643341422081, 0.01319151371717453, -0.03933434188365936, 0.022786999121308327, -0.01047400664538145, -0.019399192184209824, -0.03307566046714783, -0.0013998684007674456, 0.04189286753535271, -0.0007082957308739424, 0.03240974247455597, -0.0050079249776899815, 0.0016039930051192641, 0.0040050228126347065, 0.017558999359607697, -0.0011930025648325682, 0.046468961983919144, -0.027300259098410606, -0.005306457635015249, -0.036002591252326965, -0.05092019587755203, 0.033320195972919464, 0.02627887763082981, -0.0016292090294882655, 0.03208887577056885, -0.01819026842713356, -0.03508710861206055, -0.012537009082734585, -0.025475313887000084, 0.00017198181012645364, 0.01801036298274994, -0.004486642312258482, 0.02830526977777481, 0.0113481180742383, -0.09383764117956161, 0.026201078668236732, -0.004978044889867306, -0.011134309694170952, -0.04196038097143173, -0.04604341462254524, 0.001499853446148336, -0.026088105514645576, 0.033559415489435196, -0.010676419362425804, -0.02347654104232788, 0.034545473754405975, -0.04754668474197388, -0.03885333612561226, 0.020001886412501335, -0.022852525115013123, 0.05380413308739662, 0.011080095544457436, 0.019337935373187065, 0.07257865369319916, 0.029882997274398804, 0.006751528009772301, -0.052054326981306076, 0.035677701234817505, -0.027264825999736786, -0.053900230675935745, 0.025926291942596436, 0.018615486100316048, 0.004744982346892357, -0.017387013882398605, -0.001660668640397489, 0.03462028130888939, 0.06622130423784256, 0.03234722465276718, 0.005527531262487173, 0.01990501955151558, -0.005563400685787201, -0.011361848562955856, 0.04767689108848572, -0.01824500970542431, 0.012846129946410656, -0.013562112115323544, -0.00985808577388525, 0.004097932018339634, 0.0156150097027421, -0.0441889762878418, -0.010913193225860596, -0.023944925516843796, 0.02175254374742508, -0.015869736671447754, 0.05903049185872078, -0.006033029872924089, -0.035813841968774796, -0.016177086159586906, 0.023213094100356102, 0.00740085868164897, -0.020305898040533066, 0.002328319940716028, 0.058701787143945694, 0.04828659072518349, -0.012112807482481003, 0.015261655673384666, 0.00159043341409415, 0.01515879575163126, 0.028222523629665375, -0.037573739886283875, -0.03557077795267105, 0.029315920546650887, 0.022268159314990044, 0.04854867234826088, 0.025252094492316246, -0.02239435538649559, 0.002928592264652252, -0.07309609651565552, -0.002545936033129692, -0.001829248620197177, 0.05310056358575821, 0.026532936841249466, 0.030301902443170547, 0.026830339804291725, -0.016936136409640312, 0.020088031888008118, 0.01953093335032463, -0.06917469948530197, 0.04223218187689781, 0.03431406244635582, -0.014975566416978836, -0.013610998168587685, -0.005703264847397804, -0.0002743013028521091, -0.02307569421827793, 0.02348269708454609, 0.024075742810964584, 0.0055591450072824955, -0.06603232026100159, -0.0013560979859903455, -0.011724702082574368, 0.005176253151148558, -0.0032896308694034815, 0.011835881508886814, 0.017506955191493034, -0.020484885200858116, 0.01299242116510868, 0.007107273675501347, -0.032835010439157486, 0.011296464130282402, 0.004181897733360529, 0.02119024656713009, 0.02719585970044136, 0.026843171566724777, 0.013670009560883045, 0.0465996116399765, -0.08193053305149078, 0.046667441725730896, 0.013966040685772896, 0.049826350063085556, 0.039541855454444885, -0.011394888162612915, 0.004266597330570221, -0.013252985663712025, -0.02275856025516987, 0.018918609246611595, 0.05073361471295357, -0.021182313561439514, -0.01219031773507595, 0.042147357016801834, 0.011613762006163597, -0.04620937258005142, 0.014426891691982746, 0.08935686945915222, 0.01660972274839878, -0.011020987294614315, -0.04339516907930374, 0.017406852915883064, -0.0052443030290305614, -0.02163706161081791, 0.041757892817258835, -0.005789845250546932, 0.03925548121333122, -0.01585760898888111, 0.028078099712729454, -0.007530824281275272, -0.01838667318224907, -0.03406823053956032, 0.01134686078876257, 0.04077298939228058, -0.029289256781339645, -0.035898562520742416, -0.013064759783446789, 0.051618073135614395, 0.04754547029733658, 0.027352996170520782, -0.007031706627458334, -0.11077206581830978, -0.027704710140824318, 0.028556980192661285, 0.024000365287065506, -0.006163825746625662, -0.03559563681483269, -0.015217718668282032, -0.026222428306937218, 0.02079334855079651, -0.023371713235974312, 0.03279687091708183, 0.007625562604516745, -0.00858231820166111, -0.054170019924640656, -0.0005414251354523003, -0.05371222645044327, 0.0024617661256343126, -0.051522646099328995, 0.09595004469156265, -0.011504200287163258, -0.04385850578546524, -0.06696322560310364, 0.015840813517570496, -0.019703390076756477, 0.03150748461484909, -0.017856091260910034, -0.049130406230688095, 0.0059853773564100266, 0.019576776772737503, 0.0038407479878515005, -0.04839044809341431, 0.025536488741636276, 0.027066437527537346, -0.017406795173883438, 0.014906063675880432, -0.002684299135580659, -0.032038845121860504, 0.020282989367842674, -0.022334439679980278, -0.02954830415546894, -0.015856586396694183, 0.0023331386037170887, 0.031876951456069946, -0.016918154433369637, 0.01876027323305607, 0.06490475684404373, 0.03048953041434288, 0.03395260125398636, -0.0012065295595675707, -0.01840565726161003, -0.004494759254157543, -0.04141979664564133, -0.039916981011629105, -0.03747810795903206, 0.013150710612535477, 0.004328698385506868, 0.051710356026887894, 0.01693408004939556, 0.05005119368433952, -0.03198489919304848, -0.03565078228712082, 0.006746006663888693, 0.04658636823296547, -0.020436454564332962, -0.02941560186445713, 0.01044490560889244, 0.008544087409973145, -0.0423150472342968, -0.026761336252093315, 0.012814348563551903, -0.02034042589366436, 0.01594412326812744, 0.01149720698595047, -0.03646426275372505, 0.007662911433726549, -0.021331600844860077, -0.03264082968235016, 0.020793726667761803, -0.030402056872844696, 0.026122024282813072, -0.004185331054031849, 0.06980540603399277, 0.0005716320592910051, -0.039103034883737564, 0.00857968907803297, 0.018334442749619484, -0.023578200489282608, 0.027225013822317123, -0.0717889592051506, 0.03729094937443733, -0.027896670624613762, -0.00546336779370904, -0.04206934943795204, -0.052300792187452316, 0.022769736126065254, 0.01872040145099163, -0.015202626585960388, -0.03553225100040436, 0.0041100881062448025, -0.03169983625411987, -0.02401536889374256, -0.05907006189227104, 0.006576067302376032, -0.03942713513970375, -0.00505929347127676, 0.00036302092485129833, 0.008245320059359074, 0.06418202817440033, -0.02208622917532921, -0.011137831956148148, 0.028867758810520172, -0.009899232536554337, 0.007847204804420471, -0.03330403193831444, 0.0032297309953719378, -0.0493323914706707, -0.0016509788110852242, -0.05629445239901543, -0.02081192657351494, 0.053186558187007904, -0.023058317601680756, 0.0010678544640541077, 0.03342084959149361, -0.012554850429296494, 0.018076978623867035, -0.036586519330739975, -0.00659535126760602, -0.005990306846797466, -0.008340275846421719, -0.0015608064131811261, 0.014533007517457008, 0.03838393837213516, 0.012775293551385403, 0.015562661923468113, 0.01561677549034357, -0.006951966322958469, 0.009776725433766842, 0.06036492437124252, 0.01571042276918888, 0.01813061162829399, -0.013522760942578316, -0.04608207941055298, 0.05586361512541771, 0.03491564840078354, 0.028645366430282593, 0.01988728903234005, 0.05172041803598404, -0.00551080796867609, -0.009323333390057087, -0.045707881450653076, -0.02766021341085434, 0.048026517033576965, -0.009821419604122639, 0.04641764238476753, 0.04849082976579666, 0.030020903795957565, -0.04916823282837868, -0.03657258674502373, -0.0254123006016016, -0.001694678096100688, -0.004684122279286385, 0.05920469015836716, -0.025662805885076523, -0.008012289181351662, 0.020268959924578667, 0.00748017430305481, 0.016785377636551857, 0.06926647573709488, 0.02252805233001709, 0.03938612341880798, 0.028247231617569923, 0.005259041674435139, -0.055096182972192764, 0.025502435863018036, -0.03657364472746849, -0.009347358718514442, -0.03815290331840515, -0.006786096375435591, 0.04315843805670738, 0.046426333487033844, -0.006702163256704807, -0.04985933005809784, -0.013420896604657173, -0.03698043152689934, -0.030482081696391106, -0.010221391916275024, -0.004492661915719509, 0.03468884900212288, -0.01118217408657074, 0.029251430183649063, -0.001560715027153492, 0.012517567723989487, -0.04257040470838547, -0.07788144052028656, -0.02435031346976757, -0.0006871805526316166, -0.0008459052769467235, 0.02286168932914734, 0.014789280481636524, 0.002104257233440876, 0.016192307695746422, -0.0576372891664505, 0.019621361047029495, -0.029674028977751732, 0.050721023231744766, -0.005770499352365732, 0.042714666575193405, -0.021955477073788643, -0.03253142908215523, -0.0012277907226234674, 0.006152754183858633, 0.10099690407514572, 0.08121580630540848, 0.06453230232000351, -0.03002731129527092, 0.01564236730337143, 0.004884956404566765, 0.029758207499980927, -0.023583311587572098, -0.030184928327798843, -0.004019818268716335, 0.0026753759011626244, 0.029705233871936798, 0.06924425065517426, -0.0029258220456540585, -0.015485372394323349, 0.03454652056097984, -0.023044809699058533, 0.002905959030613303, 0.015098673291504383, 0.01293125282973051, 0.016701357439160347, -0.0039253924041986465, -0.03639631345868111, 0.022069014608860016, 0.008335057646036148, 0.0009979670867323875, -0.013052013702690601, 0.03473619371652603, -0.01955895870923996, 0.026095159351825714, -0.015482683666050434, 0.02138270065188408, 0.01959136873483658, 0.01952180452644825, -0.0015907988417893648, 0.014888935722410679, 0.008941537700593472, -0.025480439886450768, 0.0069373296573758125, 0.02411714568734169, -0.011243673972785473, -0.0029325690120458603, -0.0003812656505033374, 0.005125971976667643, -0.08708314597606659, -0.01731022819876671, -0.05469023436307907, 0.03158776834607124, -0.019400088116526604, -0.026417173445224762, 0.029099006205797195, 0.0014864997938275337, 0.017238261178135872, -0.03839561343193054, 0.009645428508520126, 0.04852357879281044, 0.029354248195886612, 0.017855452373623848, 0.0005474346107803285, 0.009464175440371037, 0.02999141998589039, 0.0008147536427713931, 0.008509195409715176, 0.04105062037706375, -0.03602156043052673, -0.043522316962480545, 0.0031257227528840303, 0.08200930804014206, -0.009387173689901829, 0.0035816130694001913, 0.012680751271545887, -0.012179973535239697, -0.017743051052093506, -0.02333729900419712, 0.03141756355762482, 0.0017038192600011826, 0.05588293448090553, -0.04016922414302826, 0.015000891871750355, -0.05556882545351982, -0.0459543876349926, -0.00020016304915770888, 0.0265489649027586, 0.013364450074732304, -0.04107164591550827, 0.015298040583729744, 0.0005571636138483882, 0.042850274592638016, -0.002834904473274946, 0.009166166186332703, 0.014652842655777931, 0.033601656556129456, 0.011319512501358986, -0.049710530787706375, -0.022067725658416748, -0.005155859049409628, -0.0027122285682708025, 0.006128543522208929, -0.012281699106097221, 0.03700583055615425, 0.013552512973546982, 0.006589914672076702, -0.024199776351451874, 0.04717656597495079, -0.0007262510480359197, 0.03315001726150513, -0.02348732016980648, -0.05110461264848709, 0.0010230897460132837, 0.018648769706487656, 0.01138948556035757, -0.014476059004664421, -0.021226711571216583, -0.043748512864112854, -0.04502210393548012, 0.021637409925460815, 0.027800068259239197, -0.01493699848651886, 0.03248712047934532, -0.013814789243042469, 0.049524422734975815, -0.029181882739067078, -0.048246514052152634, -0.0436965674161911, -0.0007135727792046964, -0.016765037551522255, -0.05089849233627319, -0.003593594068661332, 0.0035165727604180574, -0.0630786269903183, 0.010272669605910778, 0.03271276503801346, 0.02283737249672413, -0.00654247123748064, -0.04668330028653145, -0.05508606508374214, -0.021485909819602966, 0.05402102321386337, -0.02265261858701706, -0.01035704929381609, 0.021105187013745308, -0.03671884164214134, -0.004467902239412069, 0.021028941497206688, 0.003873642301186919, 0.06748251616954803, 0.01674782484769821, -0.01606905460357666, -0.03168434649705887, 0.04279074817895889, -0.03463980183005333, -0.023495053872466087, -0.008575068786740303, 0.012593073770403862, -0.012156344950199127, 0.0500069186091423, 0.031563300639390945, 0.0004560084198601544, -0.026499643921852112, 0.046166129410266876, 0.03415288031101227, -0.01714981161057949, -0.009875322692096233, 0.01899278722703457, -0.027320489287376404, 0.029555946588516235, 0.015885042026638985, -0.014539186842739582, 0.029589775949716568, 0.03300299122929573, -0.027821123600006104, -0.0033257578033953905, -0.02939613349735737, -0.01741332933306694, -0.05893668532371521, -0.0454365573823452, 0.011947629041969776, -0.01994512975215912, 0.0012830289779230952, -0.05310351401567459, -0.014949962496757507, 0.017598917707800865, -0.07591871172189713, 0.0015292938333004713, 0.023208381608128548, -0.04532928019762039, -0.02871944196522236, 0.01884332112967968, -0.0059758080169558525, 0.008568508550524712, 0.041383806616067886, 0.011732161045074463, 0.008730840869247913, 0.013560027815401554, -0.001895866822451353, -0.06041818857192993, -0.013007231056690216, 0.022034289315342903, 0.025509728118777275, -0.036516014486551285, 0.014471333473920822, -0.06824833899736404, -0.011363348923623562, 0.04498862102627754, -0.02780035138130188, 0.03165644779801369, 0.016594456508755684, 0.02947874739766121, -0.0006989770336076617, 0.03846929222345352, -0.003750875359401107, -0.027360929176211357, 0.03569558635354042, 0.025188744068145752, 0.008971551433205605, 0.03704332560300827, -0.033049438148736954, -0.008474924601614475, 0.05045296624302864, -0.0222391989082098, -0.031515803188085556, -0.014552714303135872, -0.023937607184052467, -0.008438036777079105, -0.041377048939466476, 0.015355264768004417, -0.0055197542533278465, -0.022471783682703972, 0.004263839218765497, -0.01953856833279133, 0.010697340592741966, 0.04745158180594444, 0.003992617130279541, -0.020675277337431908, 0.03856739401817322, -0.008150019682943821, -0.04126809537410736, 0.004434237256646156, -0.0199327003210783, 0.01697288267314434, -0.054139506071805954, -0.04584508016705513, 0.029650069773197174, -0.01390650775283575, -0.02717500925064087, -0.0222539771348238, -0.04250543192028999, 0.036078229546546936, -0.03824847191572189, 0.02805669605731964, 0.014904284849762917, -0.003072187537327409, 0.003800902748480439, -0.06890027225017548, 0.034217339009046555, 0.015650447458028793, -0.058262236416339874, -0.0010552412131801248, -0.003912026062607765, -0.037166960537433624, 0.036019302904605865, 0.06349227577447891, 0.011317649856209755, 0.027307389304041862, -0.031877465546131134, 0.031553879380226135, 0.013929438777267933, -0.0346999354660511, 0.040674347430467606, -0.002582478802651167, -0.03917437791824341, -0.013204910792410374, -0.0012720522936433554, 0.02274591661989689, 0.025979408994317055, 0.012459071353077888, -0.027448950335383415, 0.019147390499711037, 0.010299228131771088, -0.027975894510746002, 0.01912645995616913, 0.02880813367664814, -0.00445742579177022, 0.025800999253988266, 0.015174374915659428, -0.0012798592215403914, 0.030213646590709686, -0.0038025411777198315, -0.044463373720645905, 0.01615007221698761, -0.07208274304866791, -0.005732246674597263, 0.042448751628398895, 0.023613469675183296, -0.006687800865620375, -0.04571160674095154, 0.010806461796164513, 0.02843800187110901, -0.04427405819296837, 0.01911463774740696, 0.03644169867038727, 0.020576976239681244, 0.029231147840619087, 0.013131941668689251, 0.033587075769901276, 0.007360185030847788, -0.010040568187832832, -0.010182094760239124, -0.010207928717136383, 0.036445531994104385, 0.0011344905942678452, -0.0002875053323805332, 0.021564487367868423, -0.028320331126451492, 0.009925205260515213, -0.018286531791090965, 0.04119163379073143, -0.03060583584010601, -0.010241977870464325, 0.03802120313048363, -0.024093005806207657, 0.04605155810713768, -0.004702459089457989, -0.007333406247198582, 0.028674235567450523, -0.05855604261159897, -0.039151981472969055, -0.07256456464529037, -0.030197089537978172, -0.0009772053454071283, 0.000504329102113843, -0.022951429709792137, 0.052395835518836975, 0.00952503364533186, -0.021474845707416534, -0.01140868104994297, -0.03754545375704765, 0.01990862376987934, -0.027914784848690033, 0.01606191135942936, -0.056178897619247437, 0.035149604082107544, -0.012711546383798122, -0.004012878052890301, -0.040821995586156845, 0.010480784811079502, 0.03988298401236534, 0.029515612870454788, 0.03745097294449806, 0.0019978724885731936, -0.022729458287358284, 0.025056010112166405, 0.003110928926616907, -0.028466228395700455, -0.03266177698969841, -0.031393323093652725, 0.008291983045637608, 0.01715647615492344, -0.03295637294650078 ]
<p>My work involves building statistical / econometric models using R, SPSS modeler. I am also doing my PhD (part time) in econometrics. In order to do more advanced data / model visualisation I am thinking about to pick up another programming language. Any suggestion will be much appreciated. </p>
74,027
[ -0.04094703495502472, -0.004128751344978809, -0.01300103310495615, 0.007221641018986702, 0.01641053892672062, 0.030772918835282326, 0.020333928987383842, -0.016196122393012047, 0.002519297879189253, -0.033214353024959564, 0.027786388993263245, 0.04892336577177048, 0.03763599321246147, 0.0051190960220992565, 0.015825288370251656, -0.006311048287898302, 0.004845753777772188, -0.03215424716472626, -0.014586768113076687, 0.043177906423807144, -0.004800561349838972, 0.019498903304338455, -0.002879709703847766, 0.021366961300373077, -0.021192822605371475, 0.06228883937001228, 0.03512931242585182, -0.02053496055305004, -0.013008274137973785, 0.03307303786277771, -0.012792112305760384, -0.0164980236440897, -0.012401333078742027, 0.056601304560899734, 0.06659907847642899, -0.005783088970929384, -0.02981426939368248, -0.03069751150906086, -0.0032214601524174213, 0.023446332663297653, -0.041981421411037445, -0.0006183524965308607, -0.012124339118599892, 0.03617383912205696, 0.01748254895210266, 0.02667693793773651, -0.020067229866981506, -0.0033106801565736532, 0.042756177484989166, -0.023562593385577202, 0.07529313117265701, 0.01867225207388401, 0.042428452521562576, 0.03352997452020645, -0.014637495391070843, 0.03198839724063873, 0.03708901256322861, 0.09259098768234253, -0.0005557418335229158, -0.06814798712730408, 0.016749508678913116, -0.006640386302024126, 0.014252165332436562, -0.029023153707385063, -0.05239805579185486, 0.02564539946615696, -0.01949659176170826, -0.0033065981697291136, 0.012133419513702393, 0.010170522145926952, 0.012910849414765835, 0.01429775357246399, 0.01828726939857006, -0.005003075581043959, 0.027713406831026077, -0.04059646278619766, 0.005318659823387861, -0.008057055063545704, 0.03824140131473541, 0.04210453853011131, 0.0044313520193099976, 0.009895210154354572, -0.007535858079791069, 0.014975701458752155, 0.015752051025629044, -0.016438009217381477, 0.06892997026443481, -0.02764461562037468, -0.022679481655359268, 0.06131381168961525, -0.03792175278067589, -0.0062284767627716064, 0.0656917542219162, 0.029384855180978775, -0.021232109516859055, -0.002176722278818488, -0.03133349120616913, 0.045401282608509064, 0.03025491163134575, 0.01931193098425865, -0.01460153516381979, -0.00974836852401495, -0.008505627512931824, 0.035360515117645264, -0.009564802050590515, -0.007457400672137737, -0.015245839953422546, -0.03725047409534454, -0.022592006251215935, -0.04662901163101196, -0.03757239505648613, -0.0006202638032846153, 0.0020509795285761356, -0.020887533202767372, 0.006176308263093233, -0.030497822910547256, -0.006649661343544722, -0.01482973899692297, 0.031670719385147095, 0.10601354390382767, 0.017352474853396416, -0.04475751519203186, 0.05652009695768356, -0.03541499376296997, -0.08657604455947876, -0.013092299923300743, 0.02185485139489174, -0.07165607064962387, -0.03394149988889694, 0.052423328161239624, -0.01930898241698742, -0.009991448372602463, 0.052481576800346375, -0.003018022747710347, 0.04606431722640991, -0.018735401332378387, -0.07266194373369217, -0.09567688405513763, 0.05079939216375351, -0.010100490413606167, 0.03404920548200607, -0.022995317354798317, 0.007655398454517126, -0.0002817708009388298, 0.053637463599443436, 0.013803647831082344, 0.04306377097964287, 0.016633445397019386, 0.03351953253149986, -0.031186692416667938, -0.025809509679675102, -0.010919101536273956, -0.01374257355928421, -0.0021187537349760532, 0.026289766654372215, -0.07459475845098495, -0.010287931188941002, 0.016606518998742104, -0.006279665511101484, 0.009217740036547184, 0.028365977108478546, 0.002324354602023959, 0.009663429111242294, 0.02270342968404293, 0.011084962636232376, -0.02146926149725914, 0.06282126158475876, -0.016906531527638435, 0.06329112499952316, 0.026485640555620193, 0.000564156158361584, 0.01946987584233284, 0.02887343056499958, 0.015493074432015419, 0.04481767490506172, -0.042829032987356186, -0.016574133187532425, 0.009288221597671509, -0.04391942918300629, 0.0005790857831016183, -0.04123503714799881, -0.05160651355981827, -0.00555488932877779, -0.02940385974943638, 0.014047525823116302, 0.033309441059827805, 0.010639660060405731, -0.04028845578432083, 0.04670942947268486, -0.049830418080091476, -0.055145107209682465, -0.05474601313471794, 0.017030702903866768, -0.020775344222784042, 0.0010819034650921822, 0.007070095278322697, 0.0307686198502779, 0.029178723692893982, -0.013839691877365112, -0.009934622794389725, -0.036977920681238174, 0.008956223726272583, 0.03850960731506348, -0.025629548355937004, -0.023167289793491364, 0.06582508236169815, 0.026226984336972237, -0.0393989123404026, 0.0255510862916708, -0.04550441727042198, -0.04065914452075958, -0.0068147387355566025, -0.009330222383141518, 0.0067256297916173935, -0.015501255169510841, -0.021311035379767418, 0.02276115119457245, 0.03703608736395836, -0.024878740310668945, 0.015501067042350769, -0.00870097428560257, 0.048740681260824203, 0.03712112829089165, 0.02365872450172901, 0.0171632319688797, 0.009255096316337585, 0.02584991045296192, 0.02480936422944069, -0.009745796211063862, 0.027444738894701004, -0.016289226710796356, 0.027192916721105576, 0.04765414819121361, 0.03380858153104782, -0.04476701840758324, 0.013875671662390232, 0.05817921459674835, -0.0038051872979849577, 0.017075635492801666, 0.01428279373794794, -0.030867604538798332, -0.0052347383461892605, -0.0005706544034183025, 0.006393680348992348, 0.04107612743973732, 0.012019583955407143, 0.036076657474040985, 0.015971597284078598, 0.02837245725095272, -0.0004206022131256759, -0.04309753701090813, 0.03164068982005119, 0.004454160574823618, -0.004650356713682413, 0.02704778127372265, -0.005462161730974913, 0.03789179399609566, -0.04787324741482735, -0.01774333044886589, 0.010360886342823505, -0.007341368589550257, -0.008472923189401627, 0.031104957684874535, -0.03513149172067642, -0.011712229810655117, 0.02632693015038967, -0.006546227261424065, 0.0011233317200094461, 0.03436752036213875, -0.051508497446775436, 0.0172223299741745, -0.02145848236978054, -0.028017528355121613, -0.07245032489299774, 0.04194071516394615, 0.016569986939430237, 0.0002725548401940614, 0.015529748983681202, 0.009063944220542908, -0.010370121337473392, 0.03607769310474396, -0.018251359462738037, 0.043673187494277954, -0.020956024527549744, -0.06927486509084702, 0.020024031400680542, -0.023654796183109283, -0.030456915497779846, 0.046597011387348175, -0.013794244267046452, 0.013141065835952759, 0.015208994038403034, 0.0054745119996368885, -0.056762661784887314, -0.02834957465529442, -0.008279352448880672, 0.03726068139076233, -0.01581358164548874, -0.020714087411761284, -0.009865401312708855, -0.036505747586488724, -0.0042540268041193485, 0.029351303353905678, -0.047547657042741776, -0.01946455053985119, -0.040982987731695175, 0.04708247259259224, -0.022707266733050346, 0.010949013754725456, -0.017772704362869263, 0.03871160373091698, -0.05291696637868881, 0.0043526217341423035, -0.05175832286477089, -0.04670481011271477, 0.022496819496154785, 0.012537652626633644, 0.012825064361095428, -0.028223345056176186, -0.00762362452223897, 0.06044822931289673, 0.020532920956611633, -0.01899574138224125, -0.04787364974617958, -0.03557811677455902, -0.0103450333699584, -0.032663457095623016, 0.05150206387042999, -0.011951208114624023, -0.014693339355289936, -0.00725763663649559, -0.015253265388309956, 0.017572367563843727, 0.03480498492717743, 0.016674010083079338, 0.018781106919050217, 0.025370672345161438, -0.037248432636260986, 0.0001595270587131381, 0.02869839034974575, -0.003982776775956154, -0.038610439747571945, 0.02537563070654869, -0.02602110430598259, -0.00033170057577081025, 0.03025263547897339, -0.011267509311437607, 0.009288221597671509, 0.00364948739297688, 0.004329304210841656, -0.03709343448281288, -0.009087535552680492, 0.0072972518391907215, -0.02345697581768036, -0.006251714192330837, 0.009284887462854385, 0.023606767877936363, -0.01847788877785206, -0.03005806915462017, 0.021896112710237503, 0.015791267156600952, -0.022105131298303604, 0.005366378929466009, -0.038368795067071915, -0.009598967619240284, 0.029621832072734833, 0.004532444756478071, -0.0038415445014834404, 0.07408882677555084, 0.025844460353255272, 0.0261534433811903, 0.02549402415752411, -0.057572588324546814, 0.0028781061992049217, -0.08324681222438812, 0.028798522427678108, -0.02710874006152153, 0.0775114968419075, 0.015927106142044067, 0.032022323459386826, 0.016226664185523987, -0.011193516664206982, -0.0009746266878210008, -0.01743803545832634, -0.06804317235946655, 0.0015462980372831225, -0.02472742274403572, 0.01970246620476246, 0.030703634023666382, -0.019735129550099373, -0.009384548291563988, -0.0007079293136484921, -0.002184554236009717, -0.013160532340407372, -0.005105393473058939, -0.0382295660674572, 0.025291280820965767, -0.030319584533572197, 0.004393451847136021, 0.00636722007766366, 0.00996113009750843, -0.0036335079930722713, -0.018213581293821335, 0.04705888777971268, 0.02824927307665348, -0.007361241150647402, -0.04028809443116188, -0.007209929171949625, 0.018825095146894455, 0.014191608875989914, 0.037996698170900345, 0.021856220439076424, 0.031506672501564026, -0.04995354264974594, 0.0353766493499279, -0.010847938247025013, 0.011978089809417725, 0.0113741559907794, 0.01687971130013466, 0.02146119251847267, -0.07132034003734589, 0.0076135736890137196, 0.01151822879910469, 0.041582804173231125, 0.003750955918803811, 0.030668482184410095, 0.03202488645911217, 0.010077117942273617, -0.08551082760095596, -0.01076896395534277, 0.06528179347515106, 0.014006556011736393, -0.01902836747467518, -0.0011053262278437614, -0.01174074411392212, -0.019917970523238182, -0.016545366495847702, 0.02292456664144993, 0.023999067023396492, -0.021641355007886887, 0.036442507058382034, 0.04474242776632309, -0.008991594426333904, -0.0385381318628788, -0.027775978669524193, 0.018838772550225258, 0.05575038120150566, 0.005395448300987482, -0.015461432747542858, 0.009706123732030392, 0.03570812940597534, -0.010942031629383564, 0.013527327217161655, 0.017749764025211334, -0.11283311247825623, -0.006069391034543514, 0.0765591636300087, 0.029508445411920547, -0.03151853010058403, -0.010327445343136787, -0.019734280183911324, -0.028636984527111053, 0.039729293435811996, -0.05169057846069336, 0.02385399304330349, -0.005081717856228352, -0.01483143586665392, -0.019165799021720886, -0.015853742137551308, -0.03354809433221817, 0.024293651804327965, -0.019121043384075165, 0.05716918036341667, 0.004466622602194548, 0.004661891609430313, -0.053731657564640045, 0.03869990259408951, 0.003271019086241722, 0.015585352666676044, 0.0332784540951252, -0.02410084195435047, 0.02132275514304638, 0.02392793446779251, -0.011113902553915977, -0.05229084938764572, 0.0213716309517622, 0.03395909070968628, -0.009577097371220589, 0.024991968646645546, -0.0135480472818017, -0.02849767543375492, -0.019403880462050438, -0.019207006320357323, -0.015282347798347473, -0.007296962663531303, 0.023335013538599014, 0.02876855991780758, 0.027109604328870773, -0.023983946070075035, 0.05104085057973862, 0.00001877075555967167, 0.027680950239300728, 0.034790392965078354, -0.013643452897667885, 0.009892280213534832, -0.00686472887173295, -0.019648468121886253, -0.04886450618505478, -0.04854903742671013, -0.033829815685749054, 0.00817127525806427, 0.0044919452629983425, 0.024868478998541832, -0.05333230271935463, 0.017338108271360397, -0.008686268702149391, 0.04349956288933754, 0.02277771197259426, -0.04448983445763588, -0.0017114138463512063, -0.03417573496699333, -0.01859687827527523, -0.0474112331867218, 0.030491340905427933, -0.036391731351614, -0.027705000713467598, -0.007804548367857933, -0.05088084936141968, 0.003921127412468195, -0.03562101721763611, -0.043592169880867004, 0.02007382921874523, -0.029399249702692032, 0.017879484221339226, 0.00041223311563953757, 0.057695381343364716, 0.037493620067834854, -0.047231126576662064, -0.01872858591377735, 0.028599560260772705, 0.01003954280167818, -0.006696635857224464, -0.05727441981434822, 0.049353718757629395, -0.06374037265777588, -0.03537583351135254, -0.04645673558115959, -0.08679014444351196, 0.026035964488983154, -0.014061348512768745, -0.03674841299653053, -0.00908458698540926, 0.00024089809448923916, -0.012870949693024158, 0.016040625050663948, -0.01966431736946106, 0.02698071300983429, -0.03312963992357254, 0.003142881439998746, 0.009473870508372784, 0.001073941821232438, 0.052265048027038574, 0.0063421232625842094, -0.0036279717460274696, 0.014856839552521706, 0.03044840134680271, -0.016958076506853104, -0.009616006165742874, 0.04344819486141205, -0.019181177020072937, 0.004153361078351736, -0.04984521493315697, 0.004187923390418291, 0.060384489595890045, -0.028721962124109268, 0.0435367189347744, 0.043513547629117966, 0.003016330534592271, -0.006882697343826294, -0.025001270696520805, 0.015409694984555244, -0.03551716357469559, -0.01183492224663496, -0.03896690532565117, -0.006771462969481945, 0.003711929079145193, -0.004113956820219755, 0.02623906545341015, -0.016381176188588142, -0.008217589929699898, 0.0004820962785743177, 0.04377240687608719, 0.03242909163236618, 0.018060151487588882, -0.0007448428659699857, -0.022961007431149483, -0.003988735377788544, -0.01648963801562786, 0.001963229151442647, -0.0019381511956453323, 0.042949505150318146, -0.062237516045570374, -0.05572093650698662, 0.010635973885655403, -0.033553168177604675, 0.04531044512987137, -0.013010811060667038, 0.032309312373399734, 0.042501624673604965, 0.0017266658833250403, -0.014050135388970375, -0.045669421553611755, -0.062318526208400726, -0.019531624391674995, 0.021326785907149315, 0.06619785726070404, 0.02734450064599514, 0.002524868817999959, 0.06475129723548889, 0.041073642671108246, 0.022398782894015312, 0.05886651203036308, -0.00214964896440506, 0.010360835120081902, 0.0034483836498111486, -0.05622131749987602, -0.07046481966972351, 0.016930876299738884, -0.06813498586416245, 0.06680987775325775, -0.021889423951506615, -0.0510617233812809, 0.024432415142655373, 0.031818170100450516, 0.009337685070931911, -0.03620237484574318, 0.024182992056012154, -0.021043336018919945, 0.01949775032699108, 0.021996330469846725, -0.01401770580559969, 0.011844217777252197, 0.008140390738844872, 0.0363115593791008, 0.0007301013101823628, 0.02278296649456024, -0.017157291993498802, -0.07977590709924698, 0.0015483092283830047, -0.015832703560590744, -0.036150481551885605, 0.059385623782873154, -0.005873479880392551, -0.01155009027570486, 0.0006623254157602787, -0.013413636013865471, -0.015956832095980644, -0.015361735597252846, 0.03552393615245819, 0.029956888407468796, 0.06651712954044342, -0.039900168776512146, -0.02200957015156746, -0.042964257299900055, -0.007060686592012644, 0.1152571588754654, 0.07612615823745728, 0.04987639933824539, -0.06354903429746628, 0.03644222021102905, -0.006742214784026146, 0.014633692800998688, -0.021777039393782616, 0.02946232073009014, 0.00456574559211731, 0.001967532793059945, 0.031764060258865356, 0.0487065464258194, -0.00023920308740343899, 0.019354118034243584, 0.07590685039758682, -0.014668052084743977, -0.019210487604141235, -0.03922645375132561, -0.009070085361599922, 0.024824507534503937, -0.020233390852808952, -0.08013880997896194, 0.00853258278220892, -0.020623747259378433, -0.0482768714427948, -0.03543497249484062, -0.03128941357135773, 0.0417315699160099, -0.004319075960665941, -0.04627145826816559, -0.019748829305171967, -0.009312361478805542, 0.01627117581665516, -0.02674994431436062, -0.026555677875876427, 0.02661762945353985, -0.03897390514612198, 0.012664435431361198, 0.028488218784332275, 0.0058444347232580185, 0.002731296932324767, -0.012142959050834179, 0.01003153994679451, -0.03181611746549606, 0.004162950441241264, 0.0028902629856020212, 0.019081436097621918, -0.00038872676668688655, 0.003549982560798526, -0.019251812249422073, 0.029193541035056114, 0.022753914818167686, -0.037102408707141876, -0.01932491734623909, 0.024213852360844612, 0.032613642513751984, -0.008628439158201218, 0.012866257689893246, -0.015926172956824303, 0.008996373973786831, -0.010001955553889275, 0.0210218895226717, -0.0065082283690571785, -0.05946365371346474, -0.017057383432984352, -0.030863048508763313, 0.034323111176490784, -0.03433697670698166, -0.01007587369531393, 0.02095692791044712, 0.01773044653236866, -0.01630055531859398, 0.014086615294218063, 0.026791423559188843, 0.02705313079059124, 0.013129263184964657, -0.05179460719227791, -0.008734608069062233, -0.047041915357112885, -0.006641334388405085, 0.0034887371584773064, -0.025415433570742607, 0.020496537908911705, -0.015077149495482445, 0.02007453888654709, 0.05388271436095238, 0.017926407977938652, 0.02654888853430748, 0.004702179692685604, 0.00307713751681149, 0.0007585640996694565, 0.009541334584355354, -0.05882042273879051, -0.019575417041778564, -0.01233475562185049, -0.05285745486617088, 0.011415541172027588, -0.05001087859272957, 0.03107074461877346, 0.009236885234713554, 0.0027097822166979313, -0.03686745837330818, 0.05383390933275223, -0.015331353060901165, 0.030529579147696495, -0.015368727035820484, -0.07654555886983871, -0.017587848007678986, -0.015798885375261307, 0.004026692360639572, -0.02933797985315323, 0.010894827544689178, -0.025339828804135323, -0.011374343186616898, -0.00555521110072732, -0.0029074158519506454, -0.03327763080596924, 0.058374542742967606, 0.021009985357522964, 0.043573714792728424, -0.0400901734828949, 0.012374330312013626, -0.04817861318588257, -0.015326249413192272, 0.00013188226148486137, -0.033095475286245346, 0.012443634681403637, 0.004203255288302898, -0.007707064971327782, 0.022462649270892143, 0.020055407658219337, 0.024650665000081062, 0.02406427077949047, 0.016336636617779732, 0.03925948217511177, 0.0032085482962429523, 0.039004746824502945, -0.02681075781583786, -0.027199210599064827, 0.043414462357759476, -0.00009184230293612927, -0.046546146273612976, 0.013810052536427975, 0.013268383219838142, 0.021996181458234787, 0.00991048477590084, 0.020904770120978355, -0.0443723164498806, 0.06810663640499115, 0.022683531045913696, -0.027313489466905594, -0.02021215856075287, 0.007372717373073101, 0.024694394320249557, 0.005729591008275747, 0.011583728715777397, -0.01835613325238228, -0.028858225792646408, 0.03702794760465622, 0.04824624955654144, -0.0035965379793196917, -0.013461694121360779, 0.01677030511200428, -0.00445912079885602, -0.00026430521393194795, 0.017129380255937576, -0.032738231122493744, 0.04859410226345062, -0.01452297531068325, -0.03479853272438049, 0.020344315096735954, 0.015529777854681015, 0.0118505097925663, -0.054208170622587204, -0.023564035072922707, 0.032968390733003616, -0.0010629952885210514, 0.04918089136481285, -0.061747800558805466, 0.03568305820226669, 0.025818979367613792, -0.03602176904678345, 0.01091193500906229, -0.012048665434122086, -0.033436331897974014, 0.005125763826072216, -0.009292329661548138, -0.003177299629896879, 0.03304128348827362, 0.0018424036679789424, 0.03261774405837059, 0.05206500366330147, 0.02570539526641369, 0.03304380178451538, -0.025107936933636665, -0.022726625204086304, 0.007070219609886408, -0.0028597782365977764, -0.036769263446331024, 0.02132687345147133, -0.06325408071279526, -0.00755234993994236, 0.037482328712940216, 0.019871069118380547, 0.04218627139925957, 0.021380340680480003, 0.020720385015010834, 0.016338180750608444, 0.061604078859090805, 0.04873672500252724, -0.014174837619066238, -0.0254552960395813, -0.03152242675423622, 0.007592563051730394, 0.03847329691052437, 0.0017514587379992008, 0.045966703444719315, -0.02829516865313053, -0.04013575613498688, -0.00843886286020279, 0.022734882310032845, 0.01902875490486622, -0.00016166700515896082, 0.009995990432798862, -0.010151376016438007, 0.007755333557724953, -0.0042288051918148994, 0.013494164682924747, -0.03632677346467972, -0.004131416790187359, 0.025713762268424034, 0.007906096987426281, -0.025561748072504997, 0.024106904864311218, 0.004264907445758581, -0.030222920700907707, -0.007961097173392773, 0.009993745014071465, 0.0070425719022750854, -0.039788126945495605, -0.007366628851741552, 0.02668488398194313, 0.005296832881867886, 0.005366872530430555, -0.008641114458441734, -0.001978489337489009, 0.05122068524360657, -0.049154769629240036, 0.009805524721741676, 0.042678602039813995, -0.014340675435960293, 0.02133101224899292, -0.08678614348173141, 0.0914815217256546, 0.0004181230324320495, 0.0064984471537172794, -0.010322604328393936, -0.009937967173755169, -0.03988136723637581, 0.009274384006857872, 0.052928172051906586, -0.015743983909487724, 0.018837440758943558, -0.03341022506356239, 0.002521451096981764, 0.02336573414504528, -0.025587119162082672, 0.025607891380786896, -0.010565591976046562, -0.038192301988601685, -0.010338738560676575, -0.03416401520371437, -0.014184667728841305, 0.014373138546943665, 0.039303455501794815, 0.02292877435684204, 0.017635708674788475, 0.005464752204716206, -0.04846161603927612, 0.011410475708544254, 0.022939268499612808, -0.05591249838471413, 0.03873150423169136, -0.010431361384689808, -0.022196004167199135, 0.017137307673692703, -0.013049357570707798, 0.01146683283150196, 0.04307423532009125, -0.03608468919992447, -0.019212134182453156, -0.049766529351472855, -0.02496224455535412, -0.01744789630174637, -0.05955145135521889, 0.018718495965003967, 0.02730461396276951, -0.035611841827631, 0.021761944517493248, 0.024835141375660896, 0.007054600398987532, 0.03425734490156174, 0.004600930958986282, 0.019573282450437546, 0.01720498874783516, 0.003191140480339527, 0.015924477949738503, -0.0168793685734272, 0.031226079910993576, 0.018007352948188782, 0.009356386959552765, 0.03133558854460716, 0.010186775587499142, 0.02302551455795765, 0.0019951113499701023, 0.043644849210977554, -0.05745712295174599, -0.0256272554397583, 0.028950463980436325, 0.009275556541979313, 0.029172899201512337, 0.018428776413202286, -0.027848321944475174, 0.05607399344444275, -0.035512927919626236, -0.00796507764607668, -0.023734603077173233, -0.009588214568793774, -0.04674440249800682, -0.02457667700946331, -0.016195023432374, 0.017128754407167435, -0.006337812636047602, 0.04776841029524803, 0.014639513567090034, 0.0037795889656990767, 0.06816326081752777, -0.016750164330005646, 0.00362096237950027, 0.004101472906768322, -0.015940304845571518, -0.03944672644138336, 0.006641618441790342, -0.03574243187904358, -0.004359630402177572, 0.08142192661762238, 0.034166958183050156, 0.004433882422745228, -0.0150251230224967, -0.022076334804296494, 0.014349011704325676, 0.017938999459147453, -0.04406942427158356, -0.025761974975466728, -0.02532193809747696, -0.01817426271736622, -0.0028741860296577215, 0.018596630543470383 ]
<p>A treatment was given to one hand of a subject, and a single outcome metric is measured for both hands, twice pre and several times post treatment. </p> <p>What is best practice for assessing effectiveness of treatment? </p> <p>Treated and Untreated "groups" really are paired.</p>
74,028
[ -0.010300418362021446, -0.03928472474217415, -0.029533198103308678, -0.04392863065004349, 0.010220132768154144, 0.009192537516355515, -0.03971221297979355, -0.0221088957041502, 0.024762632325291634, 0.01527799479663372, 0.052929483354091644, 0.014934485778212547, 0.0304675605148077, 0.04265304654836655, -0.037268687039613724, -0.018634403124451637, -0.0007077421178109944, 0.0063255224376916885, 0.0037943036295473576, 0.01115450356155634, 0.00021372509945649654, -0.003252814756706357, -0.0107096116989851, 0.009225254878401756, 0.005779903382062912, 0.029322432354092598, 0.010206863284111023, -0.026303531602025032, 0.02460717037320137, 0.016330409795045853, -0.046243663877248764, -0.044070374220609665, -0.00827685184776783, -0.020160531625151634, -0.004706656094640493, 0.00694599375128746, -0.032912302762269974, -0.01775919273495674, -0.03792838007211685, 0.04091966897249222, 0.004757396411150694, -0.019611045718193054, 0.0027602820191532373, 0.029842782765626907, -0.03777823597192764, 0.03176461160182953, -0.0454498827457428, -0.011485232040286064, 0.019777363166213036, -0.027747754007577896, 0.04554193094372749, 0.013955952599644661, 0.05692732334136963, -0.0029968267772346735, -0.02363629639148712, 0.0033392326440662146, 0.06969200074672699, 0.02150001749396324, 0.0452718548476696, -0.036353323608636856, -0.0848659798502922, -0.01069313008338213, 0.035706862807273865, -0.008378126658499241, -0.019250832498073578, 0.07112547010183334, 0.02433609962463379, -0.011326109990477562, 0.019944937899708748, 0.024158574640750885, -0.009424945339560509, 0.02101234160363674, 0.04987054690718651, 0.014570314437150955, 0.032631296664476395, -0.0003286998544353992, 0.00012653862359002233, 0.04951433092355728, 0.0272901002317667, 0.0414021797478199, -0.013058660551905632, 0.007543027400970459, 0.014684837311506271, 0.080023393034935, 0.02537619322538376, -0.005298576783388853, 0.050612449645996094, -0.002013599965721369, 0.016444971784949303, -0.003990250639617443, 0.029996685683727264, 0.009093919768929482, 0.031929247081279755, -0.022565098479390144, -0.05382443219423294, 0.000481164752272889, -0.015024658292531967, 0.044583916664123535, -0.009829393588006496, 0.005338871851563454, -0.004200020805001259, -0.013004672713577747, -0.024413786828517914, 0.019385941326618195, -0.0011104836594313383, -0.0016858733724802732, -0.00820406898856163, 0.009304014965891838, 0.016358347609639168, 0.002786315744742751, -0.03528696671128273, -0.0019379337318241596, 0.0019966212566941977, 0.027354592457413673, 0.03820977360010147, 0.022193942219018936, -0.020228249952197075, 0.016429763287305832, 0.07550996541976929, 0.035026926547288895, 0.03874293714761734, -0.04943573847413063, 0.00890191737562418, -0.024833669885993004, -0.04277362301945686, -0.007201195228844881, 0.007831348106265068, -0.007569169159978628, -0.05290984734892845, 0.03465724363923073, 0.0431462861597538, -0.01841571182012558, 0.012465146370232105, -0.011790219694375992, 0.0049326010048389435, -0.012154262512922287, -0.049907103180885315, -0.07215610891580582, 0.0414612777531147, 0.017747581005096436, 0.0058897449634969234, -0.02025105245411396, -0.0035892848391085863, 0.020887697115540504, 0.04463671147823334, -0.01816505938768387, -0.011179435066878796, 0.0119044603779912, 0.05729881301522255, 0.0018055889522656798, -0.009757313877344131, -0.03324265033006668, -0.008808726444840431, -0.04036221653223038, -0.03372952714562416, -0.0840403363108635, 0.048082541674375534, 0.025524113327264786, -0.020324287936091423, 0.0013503022491931915, 0.04636979103088379, -0.003280250122770667, 0.02474060282111168, -0.012972277589142323, -0.020932268351316452, 0.014974460005760193, 0.038683947175741196, -0.007499977480620146, 0.025828666985034943, 0.054486826062202454, -0.004988358821719885, 0.04508340358734131, 0.03919021412730217, 0.04214619845151901, 0.012918462976813316, -0.011134766973555088, 0.023409223183989525, 0.008625857532024384, -0.023576028645038605, -0.025934800505638123, -0.02652999572455883, -0.02076639048755169, -0.019684890285134315, 0.00804129708558321, 0.01955152489244938, 0.03921571001410484, -0.010247472673654556, 0.014262446202337742, 0.009398329071700573, -0.010888062417507172, -0.055968549102544785, -0.09889039397239685, -0.00242769718170166, 0.03048120066523552, -0.04231513291597366, -0.004637102596461773, -0.023636633530259132, 0.022903218865394592, -0.022717732936143875, -0.03784485161304474, -0.0009574193973094225, -0.001527416636236012, 0.05968628078699112, 0.0293028112500906, 0.03992035984992981, 0.08438891917467117, 0.05647807940840721, 0.004379697609692812, 0.01585141010582447, -0.0330471470952034, -0.07878515869379044, -0.013641600497066975, -0.012686528265476227, 0.030362103134393692, 0.043545596301555634, -0.02646622620522976, 0.018457477912306786, -0.03773176670074463, -0.03664910048246384, 0.01592411659657955, -0.020652731880545616, 0.05492020770907402, 0.07170174270868301, -0.02162131294608116, 0.018646113574504852, -0.02020086720585823, -0.025911720469594002, -0.02246146649122238, -0.00495363911613822, -0.0372229740023613, -0.06926289200782776, -0.01030675508081913, 0.010475901886820793, 0.01914306730031967, -0.022972526028752327, 0.03340030461549759, 0.014305288903415203, 0.02824302203953266, 0.002610123250633478, 0.027646126225590706, 0.014156236313283443, -0.0267720315605402, 0.02412271685898304, 0.04330221936106682, 0.008646202273666859, -0.009324687533080578, 0.036090463399887085, -0.010504664853215218, -0.012454500421881676, 0.05787014216184616, 0.0026634330861270428, 0.046639781445264816, 0.02126706950366497, 0.006764586549252272, -0.006106085143983364, -0.03976212441921234, 0.02373417094349861, -0.0361800342798233, 0.009938153438270092, 0.023433854803442955, 0.012660386972129345, -0.018123840913176537, -0.0013061674544587731, -0.020037028938531876, 0.015803972259163857, 0.017942272126674652, 0.012142389081418514, -0.00744766416028142, 0.044354259967803955, -0.04250524938106537, 0.012839091010391712, -0.03873593360185623, -0.021107688546180725, -0.04263598471879959, -0.0006411827052943408, 0.014640082605183125, 0.01900344341993332, 0.04362231492996216, -0.0517684631049633, 0.0016601474490016699, -0.019455421715974808, -0.000641973689198494, 0.02455816976726055, 0.023674819618463516, -0.05909101292490959, -0.008727825246751308, -0.04221562296152115, -0.00320948613807559, 0.03130902349948883, 0.00945333018898964, -0.03765043243765831, 0.018204787746071815, 0.03064502589404583, -0.026024477556347847, -0.023492153733968735, -0.03704426437616348, 0.022970881313085556, -0.005202404223382473, 0.01589994691312313, 0.03602161630988121, 0.004217538051307201, -0.05763312429189682, 0.015813883394002914, -0.025538044050335884, -0.011668168008327484, 0.043124984949827194, 0.0012165488442406058, 0.020688554272055626, 0.003902546362951398, -0.007117514964193106, 0.021935485303401947, -0.0398925356566906, -0.03900064155459404, -0.10427781194448471, -0.038596998900175095, -0.006278181914240122, -0.00869910791516304, 0.024100342765450478, 0.008864505216479301, -0.0004297864797990769, 0.07027389109134674, 0.013041689060628414, 0.011096411384642124, -0.037199560552835464, 0.0007937883492559195, -0.035808928310871124, 0.02102227509021759, 0.013601511716842651, 0.035019949078559875, 0.0070521230809390545, 0.024856705218553543, -0.01220698095858097, 0.047412995249032974, 0.06696175783872604, 0.037064895033836365, -0.038232047110795975, -0.004338343162089586, 0.032581474632024765, -0.022524628788232803, -0.017647406086325645, 0.022480640560388565, -0.025063546374440193, 0.004521852359175682, 0.021963266655802727, 0.009618486277759075, 0.0031980457715690136, -0.06976287811994553, 0.033763352781534195, -0.010516616515815258, 0.01092634629458189, 0.0208906177431345, 0.032964009791612625, 0.013004284352064133, -0.02013092115521431, -0.019245022907853127, 0.03687552735209465, 0.032901547849178314, -0.0169276911765337, 0.016039971262216568, 0.05281837657094002, 0.042989544570446014, 0.0009047425701282918, -0.0767616406083107, -0.0036701462231576443, 0.013384801335632801, 0.00008502782293362543, -0.01271425187587738, -0.022449426352977753, -0.01151131559163332, 0.01460737083107233, 0.01481639314442873, 0.027043936774134636, -0.017665395513176918, -0.015042063780128956, -0.06216007471084595, 0.012673115357756615, -0.05421462282538414, 0.0074765002354979515, 0.023507650941610336, 0.007833186537027359, -0.011020299047231674, -0.009192993864417076, -0.054054535925388336, 0.012878187000751495, -0.07200465351343155, 0.025550803169608116, 0.0010902828071266413, 0.009453260339796543, 0.022876963019371033, 0.0014080964028835297, 0.009906445629894733, -0.003968344070017338, -0.0003368000325281173, -0.02553883194923401, 0.04808041825890541, 0.014219134114682674, -0.006659990176558495, -0.003457921789959073, -0.040973491966724396, -0.017528744414448738, 0.001470130984671414, 0.017369642853736877, -0.011520490981638432, 0.020335551351308823, 0.029024804010987282, 0.02770685963332653, -0.005073354113847017, -0.023105716332793236, -0.007452423218637705, -0.005562441889196634, 0.04046616703271866, -0.0024738977663218975, 0.034871503710746765, -0.06054878979921341, 0.02598840557038784, 0.01479265931993723, 0.031430698931217194, 0.023592457175254822, -0.04747488349676132, -0.009837744757533073, -0.05382043868303299, -0.025308026000857353, 0.010608565993607044, 0.03988831490278244, 0.046643853187561035, -0.001296070870012045, 0.04704905301332474, 0.041577812284231186, -0.046207595616579056, 0.01386012602597475, 0.05223279818892479, -0.009458080865442753, -0.037469297647476196, -0.05737429857254028, -0.043168142437934875, 0.04955386742949486, -0.011486747302114964, 0.04441824182868004, 0.00035814131842926145, -0.005388499237596989, -0.038820236921310425, 0.037401121109724045, 0.02596631832420826, -0.04936815798282623, 0.02747514471411705, -0.021701473742723465, 0.0011506931623443961, -0.00020897071226499975, -0.011462388560175896, 0.03860918805003166, 0.07743429392576218, 0.015203487128019333, 0.029168903827667236, -0.03993196412920952, -0.07318431884050369, -0.0008907910669222474, 0.029348306357860565, 0.056011222302913666, -0.021904658526182175, -0.008188525214791298, 0.01403600163757801, 0.014266178011894226, -0.004918231163173914, -0.04857877641916275, 0.04598958417773247, -0.03136344626545906, 0.0305430106818676, -0.03551824390888214, -0.02131134644150734, -0.05603460222482681, 0.03327595815062523, -0.0079740509390831, -0.020463675260543823, 0.03449069708585739, -0.020106591284275055, -0.013943768106400967, -0.008561939932405949, -0.004433766473084688, 0.011763999238610268, -0.027407480403780937, 0.0014729081885889173, 0.010029555298388004, -0.012813309207558632, -0.019848298281431198, -0.054694533348083496, 0.001609679195098579, 0.036425668746232986, -0.016281219199299812, 0.06947414577007294, -0.0345974862575531, -0.05316263437271118, 0.034177787601947784, -0.00194360944442451, -0.028017273172736168, 0.011863404884934425, -0.013919614255428314, 0.011512549594044685, 0.026342198252677917, 0.004737716168165207, 0.07497108727693558, 0.03394357115030289, -0.02376198023557663, -0.022902974858880043, -0.03615914657711983, 0.019174275919795036, 0.010329010896384716, 0.03243540599942207, -0.019830061122775078, 0.01760368049144745, 0.0010546118719503284, 0.05126475170254707, -0.017477093264460564, 0.056703586131334305, 0.001023829448968172, -0.009660727344453335, -0.012160375714302063, 0.008079923689365387, 0.013035707175731659, -0.006090231239795685, 0.02064463309943676, -0.017227187752723694, -0.019231019541621208, -0.01772465743124485, 0.01302486564964056, -0.029785282909870148, 0.040311671793460846, 0.020936762914061546, -0.05150656774640083, 0.014125511050224304, -0.0006105158245190978, -0.02179458737373352, -0.014087717980146408, -0.031473223119974136, 0.01805172674357891, -0.017071306705474854, 0.034561533480882645, -0.013688911683857441, -0.01678706705570221, -0.012947321869432926, 0.019574839621782303, 0.023337703198194504, 0.014687522314488888, -0.021654924377799034, 0.0036868860479444265, 0.032367147505283356, -0.003600700292736292, -0.018725506961345673, -0.030707402154803276, 0.01302688755095005, 0.0027625916991382837, 0.00003985287912655622, -0.00338357943110168, -0.0024175841826945543, 0.019119802862405777, -0.022588225081562996, -0.022175578400492668, 0.07749533653259277, 0.0029386833775788546, -0.029521789401769638, -0.015346105210483074, 0.011883002705872059, 0.05430092662572861, 0.0017006698762997985, -0.052583009004592896, 0.0006027885829098523, -0.00734289176762104, -0.019755225628614426, 0.0018753993790596724, -0.03556155413389206, -0.054961513727903366, 0.0003486648784019053, -0.05527309328317642, 0.022191449999809265, 0.023672020062804222, 0.011349009349942207, -0.0001493876479798928, 0.014474470168352127, -0.019564775750041008, -0.03234757483005524, -0.043032385408878326, 0.011548956856131554, -0.020220870152115822, 0.02666904777288437, 0.0004486394173000008, 0.008781762793660164, 0.0083055654540658, -0.02835765853524208, -0.007668941747397184, 0.032761428505182266, -0.07601667195558548, 0.006384916603565216, 0.027936233207583427, 0.019063778221607208, 0.004382191225886345, 0.029583530500531197, -0.044064201414585114, 0.026881009340286255, -0.013531156815588474, 0.017116377130150795, -0.003060858463868499, 0.015838589519262314, -0.05993672460317612, -0.010268541052937508, 0.006696136202663183, -0.010833336971700191, 0.08159808814525604, 0.009141532704234123, 0.05720805376768112, 0.07025929540395737, -0.030029822140932083, 0.0034960072953253984, -0.03872460126876831, 0.03436494618654251, -0.03066059574484825, 0.004817210603505373, 0.048809394240379333, -0.002939701545983553, -0.0123629504814744, 0.07381770014762878, 0.006355435587465763, -0.001837457879446447, 0.026130886748433113, 0.0034773999359458685, 0.016543807461857796, 0.03953228145837784, -0.06858882308006287, -0.03764435648918152, 0.030468646436929703, -0.09068948775529861, -0.0191513542085886, -0.043715085834264755, -0.03156256303191185, 0.008355917409062386, 0.02444612979888916, 0.00044824788346886635, -0.0334509052336216, 0.008306257426738739, -0.04149368777871132, -0.005257266107946634, -0.005921859759837389, -0.0007091125007718801, 0.04805061221122742, -0.01481649000197649, 0.055523116141557693, 0.010467255488038063, 0.0297088660299778, -0.02134663425385952, -0.06367621570825577, -0.002584971021860838, -0.016532115638256073, -0.014785007573664188, 0.035535670816898346, -0.0007804587366990745, -0.0071489536203444, 0.023050086572766304, -0.02691817283630371, -0.007040477357804775, -0.015202412381768227, 0.010059249587357044, -0.04676109179854393, 0.06570933759212494, 0.0384380929172039, 0.055610623210668564, 0.014186160638928413, 0.007554472424089909, 0.13082852959632874, 0.047380588948726654, 0.033180128782987595, -0.020204976201057434, 0.06941033154726028, -0.0040956418961286545, 0.00817691907286644, -0.001169571653008461, 0.028173163533210754, -0.004294044803828001, 0.004224205855280161, 0.07084302604198456, 0.026720697060227394, 0.05105442553758621, -0.014638070948421955, 0.03786064684391022, -0.022100169211626053, -0.025213174521923065, 0.04357496649026871, -0.02840149961411953, 0.0074509261175990105, -0.017750663682818413, -0.020407315343618393, -0.015806492418050766, 0.05223746597766876, -0.006173672620207071, 0.024475358426570892, 0.03200788050889969, 0.03325855731964111, 0.01967046409845352, 0.034861546009778976, 0.005595594644546509, -0.015297959558665752, -0.005825405474752188, -0.03579331561923027, 0.0057253846898674965, 0.026448074728250504, -0.034450750797986984, 0.005661312956362963, 0.02631050907075405, -0.023012133315205574, 0.023826036602258682, 0.023769564926624298, -0.017225703224539757, -0.05286473408341408, -0.03657779097557068, -0.008791618049144745, 0.05359749123454094, 0.002417190931737423, 0.004050694406032562, -0.02759028598666191, 0.005379354115575552, -0.012423055246472359, -0.044127125293016434, -0.05990159139037132, 0.019353143870830536, 0.01651935651898384, -0.03854448348283768, -0.03759336471557617, 0.006675234530121088, -0.001941606169566512, -0.029153218492865562, 0.03998309746384621, 0.0033409830648452044, -0.004212390165776014, -0.02399030514061451, -0.038471005856990814, 0.0403292290866375, 0.04772011190652847, 0.0015414963709190488, -0.016589416190981865, -0.00543938810005784, -0.007194883655756712, 0.0018669333076104522, -0.023938383907079697, 0.012338271364569664, 0.0475093238055706, -0.004133898764848709, -0.018971938639879227, -0.05340646207332611, -0.03391440212726593, 0.03014560416340828, -0.06186872720718384, -0.011136815883219242, -0.014733700081706047, -0.025356484577059746, 0.040659207850694656, 0.03776831179857254, -0.04061990603804588, -0.025577159598469734, -0.0187258068472147, 0.011581328697502613, 0.023583658039569855, -0.014801917597651482, -0.03880373388528824, -0.0077110095880925655, -0.035720646381378174, -0.012353439815342426, -0.028128210455179214, 0.03746270760893822, 0.008492670953273773, -0.00702971126884222, -0.009026779793202877, 0.009740252047777176, -0.007017162628471851, -0.01335185393691063, 0.025921227410435677, -0.06659996509552002, -0.00933907087892294, -0.018573088571429253, -0.03044545091688633, -0.040564339607954025, -0.011006329208612442, -0.03290762007236481, -0.023431045934557915, 0.016938835382461548, -0.0069757006131112576, -0.033459972590208054, -0.016691571101546288, -0.024084264412522316, 0.05527228116989136, -0.02743278257548809, -0.018560515716671944, -0.03421705216169357, -0.033782679587602615, -0.032876696437597275, -0.00011648840882116929, 0.0009335726499557495, 0.02886005863547325, -0.007062992546707392, 0.019394395872950554, 0.02648192271590233, -0.01761193759739399, -0.006908676587045193, 0.03558660298585892, 0.005470237694680691, -0.01701289787888527, 0.04903745278716087, 0.03175325691699982, -0.0263338815420866, 0.030839892104268074, -0.04646272957324982, -0.024033397436141968, 0.003544025355949998, -0.0010314423125237226, 0.04058627784252167, 0.015493305400013924, 0.01955389603972435, -0.013178534805774689, -0.0008556533139199018, -0.05906163528561592, -0.06085335835814476, 0.005753571633249521, -0.02586297132074833, -0.022280974313616753, -0.0002260373585158959, -0.001061234506778419, 0.02060893550515175, -0.0322478823363781, 0.01242719404399395, 0.00353258172981441, 0.06132776662707329, -0.009971254505217075, 0.01589120551943779, 0.009041239507496357, 0.03212567791342735, -0.010320045985281467, -0.009500944055616856, 0.005513943266123533, 0.05712738260626793, -0.009174357168376446, 0.026562819257378578, -0.036147020757198334, 0.027614790946245193, -0.07052350044250488, -0.00640940573066473, -0.03469666838645935, 0.015029791742563248, 0.034833986312150955, -0.05112135410308838, 0.022073345258831978, -0.0034129132982343435, -0.0152135593816638, 0.042265634983778, 0.007498665247112513, -0.012018026784062386, -0.04808388277888298, 0.03948948159813881, -0.03244331479072571, 0.02028723806142807, 0.0030376093927770853, 0.04209541901946068, -0.03898295387625694, 0.011427526362240314, 0.02091253362596035, 0.030534394085407257, -0.006106076296418905, 0.021778572350740433, 0.007606176193803549, -0.01116353552788496, 0.03244419023394585, -0.009379704482853413, -0.029942711815238, 0.03592001646757126, -0.037581589072942734, 0.03907369077205658, 0.005211125127971172, 0.06250934302806854, -0.021794382482767105, 0.02875687927007675, 0.003167587798088789, -0.04070102795958519, -0.051023174077272415, -0.049095433205366135, 0.00313737103715539, 0.018515832722187042, -0.04195728898048401, 0.02710190787911415, 0.06462297588586807, 0.024828001856803894, -0.0034182362724095583, 0.012905334122478962, -0.012839260511100292, -0.05378051847219467, -0.012741982005536556, -0.0033520290162414312, 0.034008052200078964, -0.010844086296856403, 0.013174446299672127, -0.018951524049043655, -0.00783728901296854, 0.06342515349388123, -0.02765313722193241, -0.006282549351453781, 0.03351834416389465, -0.004268627148121595, 0.017824331298470497, 0.023020874708890915, -0.01082785427570343, 0.013761102221906185, -0.0738975778222084, -0.010982091538608074, 0.00887475349009037, 0.001617705449461937, -0.0298761073499918, -0.0023486679419875145, 0.0017536870436742902, 0.01771305315196514, -0.024274080991744995, 0.04625264182686806, 0.01728654094040394, 0.0023110797628760338, 0.008694510906934738, -0.048332579433918, 0.0702144205570221, 0.03826393932104111, -0.03314908593893051, -0.07192166149616241, -0.03540481626987457, -0.0054576583206653595, -0.01887364685535431, 0.06927762180566788, 0.06056676432490349, -0.03108426183462143, -0.015135086141526699, 0.030014676973223686, -0.014145554974675179, -0.04598085954785347, 0.04607246443629265, -0.0224636010825634, 0.009088209830224514, -0.03438916802406311, -0.025163890793919563, -0.036768194288015366, -0.002033025026321411, 0.05501663312315941, -0.0484560988843441, 0.00666763773187995, -0.007332867011427879, -0.003114689840003848, 0.047741275280714035, 0.029839644208550453, -0.03604190796613693, 0.04400487616658211, 0.0008233464322984219, 0.03581457957625389, -0.012742413207888603, -0.03209301829338074, -0.06990642845630646, 0.03449229523539543, -0.031088318675756454, 0.023844929412007332, -0.02105417475104332, 0.027131270617246628, 0.004207952879369259, -0.0443246103823185, 0.008932513184845448, 0.012876954860985279, -0.021160166710615158, 0.02710871770977974, 0.06130969896912575, 0.02575058490037918, -0.0013507544063031673, -0.03326813504099846, -0.018837368115782738, 0.03528846055269241, 0.008767413906753063, -0.013912459835410118, 0.03906705975532532, 0.008901461958885193, 0.022349920123815536, -0.020119545981287956, 0.011166268959641457, -0.04193009436130524, 0.052052997052669525, 0.03356347978115082, 0.034667134284973145, 0.005995995365083218, 0.009099476970732212, -0.014545271173119545, -0.02999921515583992, 0.001028347876854241, 0.012031896971166134, -0.004841673653572798, 0.03310048207640648, -0.012552757747471333, -0.029046280309557915, -0.04679698869585991, -0.02839534915983677, -0.018088793382048607, -0.007073500193655491, 0.040608517825603485, 0.06678389012813568, -0.023946229368448257, -0.0005198850994929671, -0.02887006103992462, -0.019295699894428253, 0.012101476080715656, -0.004930462222546339, 0.060621317476034164, -0.011750355362892151, -0.000023977474484127015, -0.006281889975070953, -0.025431182235479355, -0.04467163234949112, -0.057531628757715225, 0.04642162099480629, 0.03145422786474228, 0.027386648580431938, -0.005836791358888149, -0.02115672267973423, 0.0066527980379760265, 0.032156627625226974, -0.10058410465717316, -0.04210638254880905, -0.04553704336285591, 0.02338450774550438, 0.04333501681685448, 0.008071538992226124 ]
<p>I have to design an experiment where tool wear is a factor (not a response). I'm not trying to study tool wear minimizing. I'm trying to study the effect of tool wear along with 3 other factors on the number of a certain defect type.</p> <p>What kind of design should I use? I considered dividing the tool wear into 3 conditions (low, med, high) and then running each treatment within the conditions. But I'm not sure that is a correct method. Tool wear is considered to be a highly significant contributor to the defect rate. Interactions are also important here.</p> <p>This is a forging operation. The other factors are billet temp, spotting location and pancake height. I have plenty of replication opportunities and plan at least 10 parts for each treatment.</p> <p>Many Thanks - Kelly</p>
36,653
[ -0.0027444411534816027, -0.05382467061281204, -0.008463487029075623, -0.022080404683947563, 0.03905392810702324, -0.0011367276310920715, -0.026688257232308388, -0.0064718835055828094, 0.032961662858724594, 0.0044433181174099445, 0.007563912309706211, 0.019391736015677452, 0.015650495886802673, 0.02482387237250805, 0.014544302597641945, -0.0061071282252669334, -0.0129076037555933, -0.052693821489810944, -0.0037630032747983932, -0.03183835372328758, -0.005894815549254417, -0.023479171097278595, -0.0005571317742578685, 0.012704393826425076, -0.039399389177560806, 0.01497163251042366, 0.025078430771827698, -0.053259678184986115, 0.026723669841885567, 0.014819770120084286, -0.03584546595811844, -0.0341210700571537, 0.000613524520304054, 0.036196645349264145, -0.01444604154676199, -0.017818894237279892, -0.012206798419356346, -0.006879535503685474, -0.026073617860674858, 0.021483205258846283, -0.020825142040848732, 0.013326559215784073, 0.014519713819026947, -0.007216508034616709, 0.019712887704372406, -0.022511905059218407, 0.0096386494114995, -0.039467666298151016, 0.027584541589021683, -0.046494897454977036, 0.030800875276327133, -0.02439451590180397, 0.029877200722694397, 0.04362591728568077, -0.005197628401219845, -0.02347612753510475, 0.07906410098075867, 0.06066209822893143, 0.030994104221463203, -0.03558867424726486, -0.014048624783754349, -0.026293907314538956, 0.016903012990951538, -0.010015303269028664, -0.03295551985502243, 0.015515337698161602, -0.015189907513558865, -0.02681802585721016, 0.02762596867978573, 0.004106102045625448, 0.036294132471084595, -0.02317071706056595, 0.033890288323163986, -0.008250103332102299, 0.0027218235190957785, -0.00041747582145035267, 0.017660286277532578, 0.044178325682878494, 0.021174827590584755, 0.05764466151595116, -0.021320411935448647, 0.04000202938914299, -0.03879735618829727, 0.04101954400539398, -0.010273371823132038, -0.03410869464278221, 0.08159390836954117, 0.007954656146466732, 0.04516798257827759, 0.02908952534198761, -0.011385658755898476, -0.0009068866493180394, 0.03921128064393997, 0.03295288607478142, -0.030378432944417, 0.0008197440183721483, -0.021081214770674706, 0.03407678008079529, -0.010907499119639397, 0.0030484411399811506, -0.01707187108695507, -0.04348183795809746, -0.012967990711331367, 0.048490010201931, 0.012215252965688705, 0.022462572902441025, -0.009438821114599705, 0.03456263616681099, -0.007994226180016994, -0.03455173224210739, -0.006436438299715519, -0.0013681815471500158, -0.02139582298696041, -0.013042201288044453, 0.009244267828762531, -0.00955187063664198, -0.002384764142334461, -0.006690714042633772, 0.05332823842763901, 0.03340104967355728, 0.008707933127880096, -0.04938202723860741, 0.014068865217268467, -0.010287672281265259, -0.053610172122716904, -0.00046883668983355165, 0.05260537937283516, -0.02501121535897255, 0.023137802258133888, 0.032206375151872635, 0.013104152865707874, -0.021537862718105316, 0.04041675850749016, -0.008482057601213455, 0.004058789927512407, 0.00969894789159298, -0.07510595768690109, -0.0759095624089241, 0.039043132215738297, 0.014992395415902138, -0.010843371972441673, -0.04360824078321457, -0.019628053531050682, 0.042009178549051285, 0.0443364754319191, 0.03810007870197296, -0.04142679274082184, -0.0014962777495384216, 0.020326664671301842, 0.020087311044335365, -0.011328864842653275, -0.013565585017204285, 0.01659443788230419, -0.02007243223488331, -0.02833409607410431, -0.06439468264579773, 0.031539708375930786, 0.013086788356304169, -0.01610752008855343, -0.028292188420891762, 0.03519255667924881, 0.0050799050368368626, -0.012826013378798962, -0.003322701435536146, 0.032914601266384125, -0.025966208428144455, 0.06926077604293823, -0.016977811232209206, 0.04854859411716461, 0.015167757868766785, 0.017062392085790634, 0.007915002293884754, -0.016998622566461563, 0.05760421231389046, 0.06410559266805649, -0.014394146390259266, 0.030125737190246582, 0.023767590522766113, -0.010736352764070034, 0.01595122180879116, -0.022390831261873245, -0.03483733907341957, -0.019558457657694817, -0.0016434754943475127, 0.0156397745013237, 0.04667269065976143, 0.020078690722584724, 0.013402479700744152, 0.07605265080928802, -0.031951889395713806, -0.023360082879662514, -0.06459879130125046, 0.012034169398248196, -0.016759734600782394, -0.05277351289987564, -0.02417634055018425, -0.028226714581251144, 0.003527913009747863, -0.007094851695001125, -0.04507700353860855, -0.006561384070664644, -0.0004549302102532238, 0.031140170991420746, -0.028380224481225014, 0.0006862456211820245, 0.0363578237593174, 0.021806038916110992, -0.041958779096603394, 0.03351277858018875, -0.017598388716578484, -0.01091071218252182, 0.00641092611476779, -0.033291760832071304, 0.001769022666849196, 0.008676232770085335, -0.02926027402281761, 0.0533151812851429, 0.011712772771716118, -0.03037082403898239, 0.03915191814303398, -0.04811388626694679, 0.05121656134724617, 0.05629948899149895, -0.008618989028036594, -0.0009942302713170648, 0.005040181800723076, -0.029359815642237663, 0.07750904560089111, -0.012860387563705444, 0.0003686971322167665, -0.028088880702853203, -0.006815621163696051, 0.007672903593629599, -0.01571272313594818, -0.01498932484537363, 0.04810746759176254, 0.05218232423067093, 0.032854288816452026, 0.016592279076576233, 0.04683951660990715, 0.05652260780334473, 0.0035695843398571014, 0.014567457139492035, 0.03542047739028931, 0.027607034891843796, 0.01762172020971775, 0.018379101529717445, 0.04197436198592186, 0.052124205976724625, -0.023601343855261803, 0.018647681921720505, 0.06312873214483261, 0.01578139141201973, 0.014829869382083416, -0.006031163036823273, 0.018796147778630257, 0.024861209094524384, -0.023461943492293358, 0.003134976141154766, 0.025780126452445984, 0.026222772896289825, 0.012447056360542774, 0.019999222829937935, -0.04218572378158569, 0.03464239835739136, 0.02835889905691147, 0.01880604214966297, 0.0056908223778009415, 0.003887095721438527, -0.04124096408486366, -0.011143624782562256, -0.02162143774330616, -0.03008183464407921, -0.02017149329185486, 0.021055303514003754, 0.023576023057103157, 0.02520546317100525, -0.0030431468039751053, 0.003907658159732819, -0.030584627762436867, -0.028385033831000328, -0.014479179866611958, 0.002517210552468896, -0.01159802544862032, -0.06414028257131577, -0.022533651441335678, -0.00789948832243681, -0.026267705485224724, 0.009384107775986195, 0.0035164596047252417, -0.028771361336112022, 0.04239928722381592, -0.015380575321614742, -0.024625331163406372, -0.02813434600830078, -0.03185189515352249, 0.015488174743950367, 0.008342297747731209, -0.0034837888088077307, 0.07541583478450775, 0.019040919840335846, -0.012694700621068478, 0.007788105867803097, -0.047695230692625046, -0.013911282643675804, -0.033172864466905594, -0.03416793420910835, -0.0039882175624370575, -0.009342147037386894, 0.01042154710739851, 0.04415550082921982, -0.02593684010207653, 0.0005232373368926346, -0.04401759058237076, -0.04597486928105354, 0.004972934257239103, -0.032153837382793427, 0.03992568328976631, -0.03553006798028946, -0.004082974977791309, 0.06234307587146759, 0.045363955199718475, -0.02910507656633854, -0.035667598247528076, -0.0005959861446171999, -0.026020100340247154, -0.03131473809480667, 0.033934324979782104, 0.009609250351786613, -0.02244999259710312, 0.023838091641664505, -0.048664554953575134, 0.02940022014081478, 0.034371476620435715, 0.028973780572414398, -0.024886660277843475, -0.03599313274025917, 0.015737386420369148, -0.020995015278458595, 0.013144717551767826, 0.0297356266528368, 0.016677750274538994, 0.011467387899756432, -0.024282552301883698, 0.02751372940838337, 0.01873285509645939, -0.06574338674545288, -0.004978617187589407, -0.03414318710565567, 0.018043121322989464, -0.01053354050964117, -0.00021890045900363475, 0.010367493145167828, -0.039820604026317596, 0.015410205349326134, 0.018430616706609726, 0.03661251440644264, -0.007662798278033733, 0.014867027290165424, 0.03165111318230629, 0.005736621096730232, 0.010528291575610638, -0.004305572248995304, -0.01712128147482872, -0.04843712970614433, 0.00829286314547062, -0.03677719086408615, 0.0482444129884243, 0.014067965559661388, 0.009373970329761505, 0.027581382542848587, -0.008591088466346264, -0.06386010348796844, -0.007728469092398882, -0.08522596210241318, -0.021609585732221603, -0.005918325390666723, 0.06683121621608734, 0.012198170647025108, 0.011365429498255253, 0.01931246742606163, -0.03213028237223625, 0.01924733817577362, -0.048504672944545746, -0.09729861468076706, 0.08118691295385361, 0.013259339146316051, -0.025006277486681938, 0.024783873930573463, 0.006394846830517054, 0.020994016900658607, -0.030293965712189674, 0.004000570625066757, 0.008537334389984608, 0.04349435493350029, -0.01476273499429226, 0.0021440014243125916, -0.04323698952794075, -0.02259073592722416, -0.03225911408662796, 0.032937321811914444, 0.03584882244467735, -0.011533565819263458, 0.03544173762202263, -0.01766531728208065, -0.013832337222993374, -0.04685305804014206, -0.003986899740993977, -0.01122130174189806, 0.021697379648685455, 0.06540616601705551, -0.014422787353396416, 0.023282958194613457, -0.032020583748817444, 0.053472984582185745, 0.02421041764318943, 0.05981191620230675, 0.026885785162448883, 0.005287510808557272, -0.009740418754518032, -0.029816368594765663, -0.022849438712000847, 0.0460459403693676, 0.052339259535074234, -0.009256514720618725, -0.009824304841458797, 0.03795601427555084, -0.007800190709531307, -0.06842219829559326, -0.011237384751439095, 0.041580092161893845, 0.04104688763618469, -0.004324115812778473, -0.02391083352267742, -0.01896863430738449, 0.006067515350878239, 0.010344764217734337, 0.030739188194274902, 0.0429287813603878, -0.015391115099191666, -0.0035031060688197613, 0.0369175560772419, -0.00816525612026453, -0.026996297761797905, 0.03905287757515907, 0.010151919908821583, 0.03728072717785835, 0.0078255794942379, -0.019203966483473778, 0.045929208397865295, 0.04195459932088852, 0.022921904921531677, 0.02078964374959469, -0.032562825828790665, -0.07149665802717209, 0.0021540590096265078, 0.0663694441318512, 0.03943236917257309, -0.030072227120399475, 0.014485376887023449, -0.023899246007204056, -0.052447088062763214, 0.02308771386742592, -0.06395941227674484, 0.011852335184812546, -0.03720671683549881, 0.016679560765624046, -0.043764110654592514, -0.03339329734444618, -0.08122123032808304, 0.043406892567873, -0.0036657999735325575, 0.018372245132923126, -0.007058682851493359, -0.013285400345921516, -0.0027093205135315657, -0.003081132424995303, 0.036221690475940704, 0.0612819530069828, -0.0017944646533578634, 0.003909471910446882, 0.005033003631979227, 0.0016907230019569397, -0.02398112043738365, -0.044168829917907715, 0.004483136814087629, 0.008469718508422375, 0.019351348280906677, 0.021699151024222374, -0.0005539394915103912, -0.030278371647000313, 0.03144214302301407, -0.01408884022384882, -0.03718492388725281, -0.01878170482814312, -0.026698049157857895, 0.04785899445414543, 0.03676877170801163, -0.039702072739601135, 0.03555900231003761, 0.010011004284024239, -0.03856099024415016, -0.02391299232840538, 0.004700508434325457, -0.006814804393798113, -0.018986308947205544, 0.030597040429711342, -0.052922721952199936, -0.0038016685284674168, 0.006059537176042795, -0.0031343710143119097, -0.02506699413061142, 0.017267432063817978, -0.03262995183467865, -0.028594881296157837, 0.012560744769871235, 0.0105788204818964, 0.029189033433794975, -0.017867648974061012, 0.01156004797667265, 0.011527452617883682, -0.01005395594984293, -0.009996055625379086, 0.010288892313838005, -0.004380407743155956, -0.015238597989082336, 0.0012904308969154954, -0.032755736261606216, -0.0000978833922999911, -0.05179755389690399, -0.014677139930427074, -0.021073780953884125, 0.009411999024450779, 0.054019562900066376, -0.013011096976697445, 0.04607491195201874, -0.007719250395894051, -0.02745037153363228, 0.032457929104566574, 0.024095255881547928, 0.015764689072966576, 0.04550105333328247, -0.04126245155930519, 0.07127763330936432, -0.023973757401108742, 0.024413667619228363, -0.07779870927333832, -0.06369630992412567, 0.025140702724456787, 0.004155056085437536, -0.01047480758279562, 0.0322999507188797, -0.025571295991539955, -0.02701633609831333, -0.06771250814199448, 0.003485127119347453, 0.09105366468429565, -0.04530993476510048, -0.00900584738701582, 0.05605238303542137, 0.06960586458444595, 0.08148191124200821, 0.011452107690274715, -0.030785420909523964, 0.004047888331115246, -0.03965265676379204, -0.024744383990764618, 0.004954042844474316, -0.06083669513463974, -0.028673380613327026, 0.0120557751506567, -0.012024556286633015, 0.021147191524505615, 0.03823624923825264, -0.02470455691218376, 0.016368767246603966, 0.010556936264038086, 0.04595043882727623, 0.010339104570448399, -0.04295656085014343, 0.038429781794548035, 0.02864767238497734, 0.017832808196544647, -0.01232843566685915, -0.01179733406752348, -0.03402113914489746, 0.0009897188283503056, -0.013899787329137325, 0.011477289721369743, -0.030073553323745728, 0.039206430315971375, 0.06554162502288818, -0.027063550427556038, 0.023753149434924126, 0.002202003262937069, -0.02314002253115177, 0.05251505970954895, -0.011173096485435963, -0.00033441674895584583, -0.019417250528931618, -0.00957375206053257, 0.0077615478076040745, -0.009384995326399803, -0.016471633687615395, -0.022938165813684464, 0.07513677328824997, -0.028727315366268158, 0.06306015700101852, 0.03802555426955223, -0.02031906321644783, -0.010743808932602406, -0.016241205856204033, 0.009918583557009697, 0.007432833779603243, -0.020903293043375015, 0.03376472741365433, 0.009380403906106949, -0.013704601675271988, 0.02217249758541584, 0.015414600260555744, 0.023962538689374924, 0.03928269073367119, -0.0032511090394109488, 0.017029957845807076, -0.006454857066273689, -0.045180000364780426, -0.05192570015788078, 0.02892032079398632, -0.0712168887257576, 0.06113163009285927, -0.026403015479445457, -0.0019968687556684017, 0.0718941017985344, 0.06508508324623108, 0.013182333670556545, -0.01977912336587906, -0.0028020006138831377, -0.03531073406338692, 0.010124564170837402, 0.024694979190826416, -0.05631885305047035, 0.03386861830949783, 0.04607037082314491, 0.029140643775463104, -0.016241062432527542, 0.0003940626047551632, -0.030571818351745605, -0.041206154972314835, -0.018538454547524452, -0.008742486126720905, -0.0039061063434928656, 0.039551254361867905, 0.008885955438017845, -0.032418977469205856, 0.016489552333950996, -0.023922575637698174, 0.02759406715631485, 0.02236083149909973, 0.02876625768840313, -0.02492537908256054, 0.03076346032321453, 0.002321939915418625, 0.016690252348780632, 0.0403948649764061, 0.025087561458349228, 0.11844998598098755, 0.07394642382860184, 0.04416368901729584, -0.061996061354875565, 0.06228112056851387, -0.03466087207198143, -0.0023840414360165596, -0.018088631331920624, 0.024072950705885887, 0.013395815156400204, 0.023644613102078438, 0.05445875972509384, 0.018091561272740364, -0.02454610913991928, 0.0400499626994133, 0.06266196072101593, -0.029026739299297333, -0.04208560287952423, -0.002633888740092516, 0.013728819787502289, -0.0007630541222169995, 0.007948948070406914, -0.018401620909571648, 0.05283521115779877, 0.008165363222360611, -0.05633905529975891, 0.009433462284505367, -0.029822243377566338, 0.0031672099139541388, 0.002618510043248534, 0.024534594267606735, 0.0011987491743639112, 0.010386827401816845, -0.022555842995643616, -0.053531091660261154, -0.009036255069077015, -0.0016796793788671494, -0.04431666061282158, 0.011948241852223873, 0.02062995359301567, -0.005555257201194763, -0.036839600652456284, 0.002881771419197321, 0.00723329046741128, -0.06452134251594543, -0.03178032487630844, -0.015730084851384163, 0.06615909188985825, -0.017617996782064438, -0.03586720675230026, -0.016132736578583717, -0.008316733874380589, 0.025489911437034607, -0.023456554859876633, -0.018008938059210777, 0.014331857673823833, 0.02513820305466652, -0.0433146171271801, -0.02349342219531536, -0.00860428437590599, 0.027229968458414078, 0.006086691282689571, 0.0015433573862537742, 0.04685479775071144, -0.044619593769311905, -0.004398726858198643, -0.008649734780192375, 0.03972961753606796, 0.029282234609127045, -0.002598176011815667, -0.03933500498533249, -0.01290957909077406, 0.009009885601699352, 0.030026517808437347, 0.01526764314621687, 0.018253671005368233, 0.03198224678635597, -0.019563963636755943, -0.030153224244713783, -0.013922564685344696, -0.04156091436743736, 0.01725657656788826, -0.01620466075837612, -0.02561025321483612, -0.0329996794462204, 0.013095870614051819, 0.020285924896597862, 0.07285094261169434, -0.013622164726257324, -0.020446162670850754, 0.009610551409423351, 0.036779820919036865, 0.06725501269102097, -0.053238045424222946, -0.016205094754695892, 0.005021748133003712, -0.048595868051052094, -0.008356287144124508, -0.021362338215112686, 0.06923069804906845, -0.02448527328670025, -0.01649358868598938, 0.01988096348941326, 0.040003977715969086, -0.018725132569670677, 0.007868367247283459, 0.04183689132332802, -0.0414874441921711, 0.011292148381471634, 0.00031542108627036214, 0.0187677014619112, -0.052732665091753006, -0.04120924323797226, -0.015482424758374691, -0.0145416846498847, -0.032145410776138306, -0.006799308583140373, -0.0209221038967371, 0.03757959231734276, -0.03334427252411842, 0.021588297560811043, -0.022163530811667442, 0.008764476515352726, -0.04177842661738396, -0.05947105959057808, 0.015178894624114037, 0.012572885490953922, -0.007813411764800549, -0.0020868685096502304, -0.007729988545179367, 0.026327472180128098, -0.006443176418542862, 0.020384032279253006, 0.03987787291407585, -0.0010945808608084917, 0.004377530887722969, -0.021196184679865837, 0.022424744442105293, -0.02513265796005726, -0.012515871785581112, 0.04912829026579857, -0.04993327334523201, -0.013136106543242931, -0.0038898319471627474, -0.03242381289601326, 0.020242761820554733, -0.023442406207323074, 0.010815045796334743, -0.002847139025107026, 0.04501085728406906, -0.013570518232882023, -0.02964949794113636, 0.003344058757647872, 0.004686668049544096, 0.01218822505325079, -0.005115997977554798, -0.002089547924697399, -0.0020186209585517645, 0.01800711080431938, 0.023759301751852036, 0.028655167669057846, 0.024838821962475777, -0.031043509021401405, -0.006425173953175545, -0.005676018539816141, 0.01190091110765934, -0.006464927922934294, -0.010299555025994778, 0.020356563851237297, 0.03651228919625282, -0.022974945604801178, 0.04653596505522728, -0.019181765615940094, -0.029716208577156067, -0.09866871684789658, -0.04366052523255348, -0.005011461209505796, 0.05565991625189781, 0.024985868483781815, -0.036051955074071884, -0.00872667133808136, 0.00796656683087349, -0.00869057048112154, 0.04170671105384827, -0.00880335457623005, 0.0030178341548889875, -0.034539930522441864, -0.04659835994243622, 0.0056115188635885715, -0.01932532526552677, -0.001706190756522119, 0.015886306762695312, 0.01943366602063179, 0.03662075102329254, -0.00839957594871521, -0.044939007610082626, -0.01732488162815571, 0.011564304120838642, 0.02579391561448574, -0.026209093630313873, 0.012803938239812851, -0.024390246719121933, -0.02441670559346676, 0.00300474651157856, -0.022384358569979668, 0.02426827885210514, 0.026841169223189354, 0.0260156262665987, -0.03664088621735573, 0.05074035003781319, 0.023374145850539207, -0.029434844851493835, 0.024329710751771927, -0.03421878069639206, 0.009558113291859627, -0.013500064611434937, -0.01624258980154991, 0.0285659059882164, 0.060327719897031784, -0.02098143845796585, -0.0021531858947128057, 0.013901956379413605, -0.014217095449566841, -0.052450019866228104, 0.008563799783587456, 0.03202027454972267, 0.039176151156425476, -0.019382840022444725, -0.03774615377187729, -0.015998905524611473, 0.01146736927330494, 0.023791858926415443, 0.023725198581814766, -0.001235912088304758, 0.00487241568043828, -0.03164752572774887, -0.024296995252370834, 0.012241873890161514, -0.019128821790218353, -0.01673273555934429, -0.03517052158713341, 0.006440204568207264, -0.012735877186059952, 0.005914212204515934, -0.06138988211750984, -0.008506863377988338, 0.0008703061612322927, 0.052632708102464676, -0.0324806310236454, 0.0037319250404834747, 0.006911772303283215, -0.012070423923432827, 0.018555674701929092, -0.0581510104238987, 0.05941254273056984, -0.03050074353814125, -0.02991083450615406, -0.03184781223535538, -0.020062562078237534, -0.047599684447050095, -0.006362940184772015, 0.033925607800483704, -0.010900534689426422, -0.009812995791435242, -0.014910509809851646, 0.008704870007932186, 0.004534145817160606, -0.051791124045848846, 0.08596035838127136, -0.026801735162734985, -0.023429077118635178, -0.04810279980301857, -0.02619204670190811, -0.013973311521112919, -0.002409327309578657, 0.034480080008506775, -0.016676565632224083, 0.028369812294840813, 0.022720513865351677, -0.00928368978202343, 0.0015112713444977999, -0.009906225837767124, -0.011484512127935886, 0.06335025280714035, -0.009953162632882595, 0.006524641066789627, 0.008879294618964195, 0.010579822584986687, -0.0853678360581398, 0.034205928444862366, -0.0414944626390934, 0.013609293848276138, 0.014622299931943417, -0.01650065742433071, 0.013407733291387558, -0.08296644687652588, 0.00006608550756936893, -0.0029903315007686615, -0.02936943992972374, -0.048042986541986465, 0.018071619793772697, 0.058263812214136124, 0.03358542546629906, -0.05496800318360329, 0.024157600477337837, -0.013326196931302547, 0.02340330369770527, -0.010885819792747498, 0.0330132357776165, -0.008351845666766167, 0.021209709346294403, -0.000029319851819309406, 0.0368184894323349, -0.025544805452227592, 0.027192795649170876, -0.024218512699007988, 0.025326602160930634, 0.00010534837929299101, -0.0019389266381040215, 0.00970261450856924, -0.013091382570564747, -0.021450914442539215, -0.019824571907520294, -0.013912007212638855, 0.04850879684090614, -0.01571270078420639, -0.000019776947738137096, -0.05599326640367508, 0.0011112141655758023, -0.04169430583715439, 0.027969829738140106, 0.01336123887449503, 0.08452486246824265, -0.011785135604441166, 0.028031907975673676, 0.006970967166125774, 0.04868995025753975, 0.0284581258893013, 0.004112794529646635, 0.013710422441363335, -0.0024836338125169277, -0.030097302049398422, -0.020154137164354324, 0.023195162415504456, -0.03237786889076233, -0.035282980650663376, 0.048886995762586594, 0.04067641869187355, 0.0051238806918263435, -0.00866621546447277, 0.0011300141923129559, 0.022816522046923637, 0.02008715271949768, -0.058976635336875916, -0.04255193844437599, -0.05048992484807968, 0.050282564014196396, 0.012869670987129211, 0.01983581855893135 ]
<p>What is a good loss function for a predictive model used by gamblers?</p> <p>I've been reading a bit about loss functions recently. I've always just went with MSE (e.g., for a couple of neural network projects) and didn't ask questions. I didn't realize exactly how arbitrary MSE actually is. And speaking of this, could somebody explain a simple practical situation where MSE can be derived as the "correct" loss function?</p> <p>Anyway, I came across Log-Loss (which is the same as cross entropy) and am interested because I'm curious about some probabilistic models. I understand how one derives this loss function from information theory, but when we talk about probabilities, we're often involved in some form of gambling on an outcome. It's not clear to me that efficient transmission of information translates to the type of utility one is usually looking for in a predictive/probabilistic model.</p> <p>If, for example, I had a model that was meant to predict the winner of the 2012 US presidential election, and I had used this to move money around on a future's market like Intrade, how might I determine a loss function for my prediction - assuming I'm able to continue making bets as the market fluctuates? Same type of thing should apply for any market where I am able to make handicapped bets on the occurrence of some event.</p> <p>Or is this really regret, and is regret completely different than a loss function?</p>
36,654
[ -0.03503449261188507, -0.022639328613877296, -0.02999267354607582, -0.008967534638941288, 0.027246413752436638, 0.04768861457705498, -0.016336338594555855, 0.019245518371462822, 0.03431372344493866, -0.00492883799597621, 0.019017836079001427, 0.027244554832577705, 0.04687635600566864, 0.017144478857517242, 0.010394129902124405, -0.0042503708973526955, -0.011120821349322796, 0.0038627784233540297, -0.02668149396777153, -0.005470535717904568, 0.004040614701807499, 0.025271624326705933, 0.02373216487467289, 0.006799204740673304, -0.01759488321840763, 0.028550880029797554, 0.036092065274715424, 0.007552366238087416, 0.0013762726448476315, 0.064780592918396, 0.008847037330269814, -0.03239322081208229, -0.04174337908625603, 0.05888066068291664, 0.019478727132081985, 0.008898154832422733, -0.029107416048645973, -0.039919883012771606, -0.027328602969646454, -0.008673395961523056, -0.015050401911139488, -0.023040898144245148, 0.00312665943056345, 0.021251119673252106, -0.005968323443084955, 0.012323732487857342, -0.03440817818045616, -0.04912706837058067, 0.01062540803104639, -0.04025468975305557, 0.028297152370214462, -0.03403256833553314, 0.022432547062635422, 0.004027525894343853, 0.008179345168173313, -0.0015819136751815677, 0.06920438259840012, 0.09300108253955841, -0.0036151243839412928, -0.04922741651535034, 0.008964967913925648, 0.030400827527046204, 0.02128012850880623, -0.029127087444067, -0.026275359094142914, 0.005023727659136057, -0.01831328310072422, -0.01982039026916027, 0.04580254480242729, -0.036797285079956055, 0.006668065208941698, 0.006631044205278158, 0.020988894626498222, 0.042215730994939804, 0.048781003803014755, -0.012585804797708988, 0.027120590209960938, 0.010764344595372677, 0.054060086607933044, 0.0526055172085762, 0.008970832452178001, -0.005581787321716547, 0.020883377641439438, 0.028958449140191078, 0.041822124272584915, 0.007195462938398123, 0.0497494675219059, -0.04712987691164017, 0.035933949053287506, 0.051631759852170944, -0.02431105077266693, -0.02646055817604065, 0.0029137239325791597, -0.042958274483680725, -0.05663921684026718, 0.0059963311068713665, -0.030226485803723335, 0.006436201278120279, 0.04120764136314392, -0.0377328060567379, -0.03977202996611595, -0.03773524984717369, -0.008035250008106232, 0.04953872412443161, -0.0259711854159832, -0.012565494515001774, -0.013414202257990837, -0.0005320103373378515, 0.019233332946896553, -0.048717767000198364, -0.01238191407173872, 0.0306971687823534, -0.0045419721864163876, 0.02390194498002529, -0.002392004244029522, -0.025172678753733635, -0.005819452460855246, -0.0014605401083827019, 0.008140316233038902, 0.07829669862985611, 0.04084238037467003, 0.003667288227006793, 0.030485277995467186, -0.03266707807779312, -0.04473420977592468, -0.014310530386865139, 0.04944296181201935, -0.03177017718553543, -0.05213477090001106, 0.018271340057253838, -0.0075494879856705666, -0.039000436663627625, 0.020848426967859268, 0.009351901710033417, 0.011319548822939396, -0.02185922861099243, -0.0895434096455574, -0.03567621111869812, 0.04879993572831154, -0.005459914915263653, -0.018684152513742447, -0.06085986644029617, -0.05097696930170059, 0.0343373566865921, 0.049766797572374344, 0.02398081310093403, 0.06606107950210571, 0.010967806912958622, 0.06098540127277374, 0.02806060202419758, -0.03329203650355339, 0.0024122127797454596, -0.0431230254471302, 0.03370620682835579, -0.019906479865312576, -0.01909325271844864, 0.020734703168272972, 0.0438394658267498, -0.024465415626764297, -0.022278353571891785, 0.036314956843853, -0.005302020348608494, -0.04884939268231392, 0.014632262289524078, -0.019678572192788124, -0.054461754858493805, 0.08632069081068039, 0.02688674069941044, 0.05398259311914444, -0.0003725627902895212, 0.03919804468750954, -0.011838520877063274, 0.024976618587970734, 0.028277290984988213, 0.03361346945166588, -0.022431744262576103, -0.012998356483876705, -0.01801602728664875, -0.010547936893999577, 0.007786785718053579, -0.026778560131788254, 0.010897857137024403, -0.0013942471705377102, -0.03517681360244751, -0.011174257844686508, -0.007787602953612804, 0.01632769964635372, -0.00720043433830142, 0.0533304400742054, -0.03412387892603874, -0.05851725861430168, -0.03774343430995941, -0.00958016887307167, -0.01950371265411377, 0.03076315112411976, 0.05458907410502434, 0.0027987812645733356, 0.011008361354470253, -0.016611790284514427, -0.051181916147470474, -0.018234947696328163, 0.03698112815618515, 0.047463659197092056, -0.027507156133651733, -0.010358226485550404, 0.05448243394494057, -0.019718969240784645, -0.005075489170849323, -0.0025871810503304005, -0.04669243469834328, -0.04529675096273422, 0.007933120243251324, -0.01375200692564249, 0.015753479674458504, -0.013710429891943932, -0.015239574946463108, 0.042658597230911255, -0.022769859060645103, 0.007696491666138172, 0.005536927841603756, -0.042855728417634964, 0.06747929751873016, 0.05282296985387802, 0.017711037769913673, -0.011529217474162579, 0.03721840679645538, 0.013465258292853832, 0.035303257405757904, -0.06398218125104904, -0.02733316272497177, -0.047297582030296326, -0.017227282747626305, 0.02970331721007824, 0.04697524756193161, -0.004336148966103792, 0.0235432218760252, 0.05834547057747841, -0.01779184676706791, 0.016013972461223602, 0.022269869223237038, 0.014729000627994537, -0.004186378791928291, 0.005965751595795155, 0.0107535095885396, 0.015018506906926632, 0.02251393347978592, 0.035045038908720016, -0.027281315997242928, -0.016335904598236084, -0.03022577054798603, -0.024207472801208496, 0.059196874499320984, 0.005128837190568447, 0.006382866762578487, -0.026027126237750053, -0.03397698327898979, 0.06279496848583221, -0.03032664954662323, 0.0029201661236584187, 0.010562232695519924, 0.009142058901488781, 0.01906612701714039, 0.010071777738630772, -0.00019149386207573116, 0.026265857741236687, 0.024719471111893654, -0.006515772547572851, 0.012140280567109585, 0.028316378593444824, -0.02970440499484539, 0.007299040909856558, 0.009877709671854973, 0.009651640430092812, -0.016274865716695786, 0.011091231368482113, 0.024133257567882538, -0.04110272601246834, -0.002061394276097417, -0.01987156830728054, -0.0553438626229763, 0.003531506983563304, -0.013481170870363712, 0.022023320198059082, 0.01579720340669155, -0.0680440217256546, 0.002868000650778413, -0.03830396756529808, -0.04463595524430275, 0.03254037722945213, -0.000486421980895102, -0.00004807519871974364, -0.030224408954381943, -0.010597161017358303, -0.05653470382094383, -0.033312149345874786, -0.06035642698407173, 0.007141126785427332, -0.03195827081799507, -0.0243625920265913, 0.08655557036399841, -0.01823212020099163, -0.045041292905807495, 0.01878572627902031, -0.032270219177007675, -0.014171124435961246, -0.0136598851531744, -0.0002526401949580759, -0.010558037087321281, -0.02582998387515545, 0.002186492318287492, 0.052976228296756744, -0.013099053874611855, -0.025831013917922974, -0.09601227194070816, -0.09902695566415787, 0.0480823777616024, -0.014497974887490273, -0.005499879363924265, 0.019478019326925278, -0.02429339475929737, 0.05496826767921448, 0.034378811717033386, 0.005061318166553974, -0.04856539145112038, 0.013086237013339996, 0.01311422884464264, -0.04464827850461006, 0.0014737278688699007, 0.0018537899013608694, -0.009333547204732895, 0.060507070273160934, 0.01566127873957157, 0.014197173528373241, 0.019936412572860718, -0.000010762253623397555, -0.00971790961921215, 0.022106025367975235, -0.011402151547372341, -0.009813671931624413, 0.024365529417991638, 0.018145283684134483, -0.005501984618604183, 0.041797202080488205, 0.010358202271163464, 0.007350634317845106, -0.000608028145506978, -0.03077428601682186, 0.04617083817720413, 0.009033636189997196, 0.008932303637266159, -0.016291292384266853, 0.02653096802532673, -0.01913858763873577, -0.0061777569353580475, 0.00916444044560194, -0.00899646244943142, 0.019975870847702026, 0.02101745828986168, 0.02319101057946682, 0.019063910469412804, 0.05072350800037384, -0.007008700631558895, -0.033840835094451904, -0.03859243541955948, 0.031951434910297394, -0.026013236492872238, 0.0013283640146255493, -0.0035253551322966814, 0.009639362804591656, 0.032778192311525345, 0.001537778414785862, -0.011448923498392105, -0.04769880697131157, -0.02232159674167633, -0.034808702766895294, -0.0069581288844347, -0.0673758015036583, 0.04224906861782074, 0.020596597343683243, 0.010332311503589153, 0.01305483654141426, -0.01976369135081768, -0.005117764696478844, 0.0367036797106266, -0.05559865012764931, 0.0650220513343811, 0.010215241461992264, 0.019418388605117798, -0.018562374636530876, -0.0030696745961904526, 0.06447608768939972, -0.03554835543036461, -0.025649849325418472, 0.020961694419384003, 0.004955120850354433, -0.05293755605816841, 0.004217611625790596, -0.01860557310283184, -0.030947377905249596, -0.020189303904771805, 0.014064381830394268, 0.024456331506371498, 0.008055606856942177, 0.040373869240283966, 0.04959164187312126, -0.007726343814283609, -0.02107805386185646, 0.005593855399638414, 0.019116265699267387, -0.005991785787045956, 0.02896452136337757, 0.027636349201202393, -0.004581755958497524, -0.031437985599040985, 0.030097907409071922, 0.00023164124286267906, 0.037220459431409836, 0.02340012975037098, -0.014650206081569195, -0.03524250164628029, -0.07870253920555115, -0.02643951214849949, 0.017084643244743347, -0.00754728727042675, 0.001552608679048717, 0.027576258406043053, 0.056890908628702164, 0.017798731103539467, -0.06341760605573654, 0.011860771104693413, 0.05452010780572891, 0.002251791302114725, -0.005791096948087215, -0.012326646596193314, 0.007675039116293192, -0.006134974770247936, -0.003801652230322361, 0.002622902160510421, -0.0012592775747179985, -0.02755151130259037, -0.02619367651641369, 0.014801657758653164, -0.02721133455634117, -0.0244002602994442, -0.020387733355164528, 0.004936411511152983, 0.05531008541584015, 0.02196265198290348, -0.00985680427402258, 0.012035682797431946, 0.02306698076426983, 0.029568416997790337, 0.06264103204011917, 0.012555684894323349, -0.0867542177438736, -0.004373850766569376, 0.018566111102700233, 0.03878365457057953, 0.0011716734152287245, -0.020728498697280884, -0.04911581426858902, -0.002163186203688383, -0.007427622098475695, -0.016506610438227654, 0.01744263432919979, -0.0145654221996665, 0.016169598326086998, -0.024990975856781006, -0.01768864504992962, -0.030266139656305313, 0.02027398720383644, 0.0009194563026539981, 0.04101802781224251, -0.017142806202173233, 0.00399502320215106, -0.054803770035505295, -0.013512646779417992, 0.014124804176390171, 0.06373384594917297, -0.039022479206323624, -0.018492328003048897, 0.012946922332048416, 0.02925054542720318, -0.011301230639219284, -0.10391762107610703, -0.0065703741274774075, -0.016942838206887245, -0.0024053556844592094, 0.009236379526555538, 0.001436259364709258, -0.05381658673286438, 0.021300604566931725, 0.014487659558653831, -0.04902924969792366, 0.05204635486006737, -0.03913770243525505, 0.028193607926368713, 0.012628989294171333, 0.02462281472980976, 0.07458627223968506, 0.014682978391647339, 0.014559667557477951, 0.04768170416355133, 0.0004231743805576116, 0.03165378421545029, 0.0005463239504024386, 0.015786949545145035, -0.02412998303771019, -0.05181046947836876, -0.0262235626578331, 0.013899821788072586, 0.028832213953137398, 0.056933969259262085, -0.010108775459229946, -0.04441162198781967, -0.06326830387115479, -0.012722421437501907, 0.011945072561502457, -0.032581694424152374, 0.013522560708224773, 0.03144551441073418, -0.010644487105309963, 0.002023058943450451, 0.015097931027412415, -0.0021670255810022354, 0.020563846454024315, 0.05709896981716156, -0.04700839892029762, 0.0154047179967165, -0.05410217493772507, -0.03587858006358147, 0.010221128351986408, 0.006490212399512529, 0.057541996240615845, 0.0017936681397259235, 0.02208603173494339, 0.00806514173746109, -0.016310393810272217, -0.0007782163447700441, -0.01561572216451168, -0.005519587080925703, 0.017717497423291206, -0.028972378000617027, -0.02074643410742283, -0.0367010273039341, -0.020469168201088905, -0.07591760158538818, -0.0006607159739360213, 0.029726464301347733, 0.02648259699344635, -0.0647023394703865, 0.00698420824483037, 0.023995961993932724, -0.024120301008224487, -0.017468515783548355, -0.00046641661901958287, 0.028276335448026657, -0.02350311540067196, 0.006230244878679514, 0.025777878239750862, 0.0033676899038255215, 0.07527385652065277, -0.024794630706310272, -0.0018890463979914784, 0.021074026823043823, -0.00562756322324276, 0.009015745483338833, -0.017672929912805557, 0.04000184312462807, -0.03851683810353279, 0.0018227174878120422, 0.015826363116502762, -0.020184870809316635, 0.023305006325244904, -0.014371683821082115, -0.005137998145073652, 0.0158142801374197, 0.008056758902966976, -0.009632077999413013, 0.034317076206207275, 0.026316866278648376, -0.021459629759192467, 0.051061928272247314, -0.033929161727428436, -0.0007156776846386492, -0.014807838015258312, -0.014584606513381004, 0.044651564210653305, 0.011092107743024826, 0.022977344691753387, 0.0061923484317958355, 0.034594353288412094, -0.01396987959742546, -0.009149995632469654, 0.0208414439111948, -0.0008611070807091892, 0.06471434235572815, -0.014361806213855743, 0.030960015952587128, -0.0032640425488352776, 0.020098477602005005, -0.04254864156246185, -0.07653786242008209, -0.038975175470113754, 0.021567102521657944, 0.05846384912729263, -0.0352570042014122, 0.006763434037566185, 0.017389453947544098, -0.0052663846872746944, -0.017960969358682632, -0.03112279623746872, -0.009172932244837284, 0.01887289248406887, 0.018014371395111084, 0.019471144303679466, -0.010482193902134895, 0.0038577017839998007, 0.017552368342876434, -0.0020797071047127247, -0.00241362233646214, 0.05004098266363144, -0.006853660102933645, 0.02126212790608406, 0.02807074598968029, -0.059393830597400665, -0.03808799758553505, 0.01429325807839632, -0.05031374469399452, 0.008319340646266937, -0.0702691376209259, -0.01270986720919609, 0.05077832564711571, 0.017176859080791473, -0.01250664982944727, -0.02922877110540867, -0.029371468350291252, -0.04554622992873192, -0.026112839579582214, 0.03706129640340805, -0.00789590086787939, 0.04672197625041008, -0.013735576532781124, 0.02537543699145317, -0.013856176286935806, 0.009594514966011047, -0.021980280056595802, -0.08769147843122482, -0.017815222963690758, -0.012702800333499908, -0.0692915990948677, -0.013371296226978302, 0.04269428178668022, -0.0171043761074543, 0.007019258104264736, -0.012396236881613731, 0.026512468233704567, 0.006348304450511932, 0.01993325725197792, 0.0023706217762082815, 0.0757104679942131, 0.011728473007678986, 0.028447696939110756, -0.015999270603060722, 0.006232164334505796, 0.13209129869937897, 0.07778695970773697, 0.03962947055697441, -0.07904655486345291, 0.02173728495836258, -0.03341455012559891, 0.020969515666365623, -0.011945495381951332, 0.034329887479543686, 0.013102855533361435, 0.010161935351788998, 0.0297146774828434, 0.03894679620862007, -0.006108438596129417, -0.034928396344184875, 0.041538551449775696, -0.0625683143734932, 0.013979274779558182, 0.03982878476381302, -0.008933192119002342, 0.0034043705090880394, -0.014302030205726624, -0.01720757596194744, 0.00797700323164463, -0.0012782583944499493, 0.00570786464959383, 0.001991711324080825, -0.033053405582904816, 0.0024762453977018595, -0.01257062703371048, 0.018245931714773178, -0.007421992719173431, 0.017078077420592308, 0.017013773322105408, -0.008989145047962666, 0.021345116198062897, 0.036794185638427734, -0.0018819340039044619, 0.016049033030867577, -0.0022482164204120636, -0.01593257673084736, 0.00814876239746809, 0.019708232954144478, -0.00836911704391241, -0.0420156791806221, -0.04485483840107918, -0.04073537886142731, 0.0166306272149086, -0.02909243479371071, 0.00031732756178826094, -0.009186550974845886, -0.009002557024359703, 0.004717041738331318, -0.00703446613624692, -0.026424843817949295, 0.03595226630568504, 0.019754137843847275, -0.04035414382815361, -0.022109178826212883, -0.013133333064615726, 0.05090715363621712, -0.006026053335517645, 0.03836667910218239, 0.010495944879949093, -0.048234179615974426, -0.037050727754831314, -0.015394828282296658, 0.0059010423719882965, 0.05101439356803894, -0.010186754167079926, -0.0027607642114162445, -0.013422727584838867, -0.059327349066734314, -0.04693925753235817, -0.031136028468608856, -0.016969799995422363, 0.0032491011079400778, -0.0007012828718870878, -0.006306835450232029, -0.016052501276135445, -0.03247419744729996, 0.0368209183216095, -0.03337058052420616, -0.019981572404503822, -0.032464031130075455, 0.014657079242169857, 0.020410584285855293, 0.01808066852390766, 0.031070027500391006, 0.01353806909173727, 0.013906974345445633, 0.00818748027086258, 0.018273722380399704, -0.046425268054008484, -0.0032424808014184237, 0.0038681200239807367, -0.049233801662921906, 0.018020832911133766, -0.01981380581855774, 0.06269055604934692, 0.03938451409339905, 0.020971139892935753, -0.019486645236611366, -0.005201982334256172, -0.0035116702783852816, 0.021151002496480942, 0.0016600160161033273, -0.07964254915714264, -0.009879454039037228, 0.009684558026492596, 0.031210441142320633, 0.0046147629618644714, -0.03300730884075165, -0.043040450662374496, -0.006286295596510172, 0.03498655930161476, -0.012822173535823822, -0.012969338335096836, 0.02235747128725052, 0.006006921175867319, 0.05977046489715576, -0.007716332096606493, -0.0017092222115024924, -0.010891549289226532, 0.01636120304465294, -0.031409941613674164, -0.03614567220211029, 0.027747200801968575, 0.005819767247885466, -0.01142718642950058, -0.04541166126728058, 0.02625696174800396, 0.005209578201174736, 0.008615466766059399, -0.010403444990515709, 0.01855062134563923, 0.010347512550652027, 0.05497187003493309, -0.010074951685965061, -0.034088898450136185, 0.0310785174369812, -0.030248595401644707, -0.0273886825889349, 0.02082650549709797, -0.004646087531000376, 0.05800652876496315, 0.007333587855100632, 0.016214631497859955, -0.03556128963828087, 0.03981146216392517, -0.012802219949662685, -0.004502320662140846, 0.0008704464416950941, -0.006090066861361265, 0.02676619589328766, -0.007104399614036083, 0.00984073244035244, 0.00027942584711126983, 0.010525855235755444, 0.013818018138408661, 0.0007606756407767534, 0.006900942884385586, -0.0040323068387806416, 0.019910216331481934, -0.014369473792612553, 0.014113795012235641, -0.008395735174417496, 0.012426557950675488, 0.02195253036916256, 0.0253238957375288, -0.0052354298532009125, 0.011354872025549412, 0.032930888235569, 0.028172384947538376, -0.08829544484615326, -0.002701857825741172, 0.05764324963092804, 0.026831110939383507, 0.04493390768766403, -0.046669140458106995, 0.029578883200883865, 0.00812724232673645, -0.034880880266427994, 0.030988294631242752, 0.005119635723531246, 0.0002513861109036952, -0.005114391911774874, 0.01050856988877058, -0.049456704407930374, 0.015284769237041473, 0.023653356358408928, 0.002757095266133547, 0.045145269483327866, 0.003571688663214445, -0.007695495150983334, -0.02524634636938572, -0.030977191403508186, 0.028702430427074432, -0.04696867614984512, -0.01941106468439102, 0.0738958939909935, -0.055496830493211746, -0.043763525784015656, 0.05638412758708, 0.007422627881169319, 0.00898739043623209, 0.013217195868492126, -0.0019131401786580682, 0.011549827642738819, 0.017503654584288597, 0.034636788070201874, -0.04521554708480835, 0.02532661147415638, 0.03105136752128601, 0.02576865255832672, 0.01058740634471178, -0.011260795406997204, 0.03303523734211922, 0.0038711675442755222, -0.013111411593854427, -0.02973538264632225, -0.0041186632588505745, -0.05119854956865311, -0.01783102937042713, -0.013389738276600838, -0.01841636374592781, 0.03181314840912819, -0.036233846098184586, 0.02815084718167782, 0.002577326726168394, -0.0088180061429739, 0.055930960923433304, 0.0048276931047439575, 0.01022325735539198, -0.006758235860615969, -0.02925398014485836, -0.0638618990778923, 0.02136281691491604, 0.006088169291615486, -0.02258867770433426, -0.04001787304878235, 0.013607988134026527, 0.01362553145736456, -0.00633000023663044, -0.02023325487971306, -0.017967306077480316, -0.04992448911070824, 0.018844135105609894, -0.03214498981833458, 0.044127047061920166, 0.04271761327981949, -0.02460489422082901, 0.01587868295609951, -0.10133098065853119, 0.0438212975859642, -0.004482712130993605, 0.0026126792654395103, -0.0023643476888537407, -0.03459453210234642, -0.012161193415522575, -0.0115182651206851, 0.08111388981342316, -0.028171291574835777, -0.004018648061901331, 0.012868843972682953, 0.029396045953035355, 0.004655557218939066, -0.02236086316406727, 0.016456065699458122, -0.07430645823478699, -0.0025648532900959253, -0.046061061322689056, 0.007252838928252459, -0.005987519398331642, -0.00240142154507339, 0.008166341111063957, -0.013887660577893257, -0.002154868096113205, -0.014174550771713257, -0.01714777760207653, 0.04230509325861931, 0.02411218173801899, -0.02484544739127159, 0.034472860395908356, 0.01575510762631893, 0.004841230809688568, -0.0009257548954337835, -0.020165959373116493, -0.04291646555066109, 0.06967093050479889, -0.032844625413417816, -0.052096035331487656, -0.007167026866227388, 0.02188083529472351, 0.017040038481354713, -0.018519185483455658, -0.050215043127536774, 0.07416284829378128, -0.023736724629998207, -0.00564340827986598, 0.06561530381441116, 0.01721794344484806, 0.02514594793319702, 0.02266053482890129, 0.04133225232362747, 0.011146442964673042, -0.012242289260029793, 0.0061249202117323875, -0.002337873913347721, 0.05131884291768074, 0.016602234914898872, 0.010014691390097141, 0.004336896352469921, -0.03547642007470131, 0.038431357592344284, 0.002965799532830715, 0.06232622638344765, -0.04886960983276367, -0.022572867572307587, 0.00994950532913208, 0.022373221814632416, -0.020961057394742966, -0.0035810701083391905, -0.01996498927474022, 0.05358035862445831, 0.017264943569898605, 0.017768986523151398, -0.03533492609858513, -0.016897065564990044, -0.04137277975678444, -0.022089939564466476, -0.02084587700664997, 0.028085043653845787, 0.040968507528305054, 0.023591890931129456, 0.00498597975820303, 0.014273515902459621, 0.04737398773431778, -0.03857048228383064, 0.026915431022644043, 0.02371096797287464, -0.020806243643164635, -0.013661106117069721, -0.042704734951257706, -0.01839401014149189, -0.007043773774057627, 0.01618053764104843, 0.05151588097214699, 0.02462715469300747, 0.030780265107750893, -0.04031970724463463, 0.0022010020911693573, 0.06331178545951843, -0.07535678893327713, 0.014305590651929379, -0.053785111755132675, 0.025752093642950058, 0.02339005097746849, 0.008205115795135498 ]
<p>I have hourly utility bills for two years. The first year's data are from before a retrofit was performed on a home and the second year is after the retrofit was performed. </p> <p>How do I compare the two time series statistically to make claims of demand savings during a specific time period of the day. Can this be done in R, if so how?</p>
48,321
[ -0.003449578071013093, -0.03627598658204079, -0.025423916056752205, 0.016670087352395058, 0.010689645074307919, -0.0028624420519918203, -0.012534208595752716, -0.0121396379545331, 0.04800209403038025, -0.021475331857800484, 0.03009819984436035, 0.05869907885789871, 0.022578110918402672, 0.03333737701177597, 0.04055759683251381, -0.00543781416490674, -0.03042794205248356, -0.009460166096687317, 0.005426127463579178, 0.02001858688890934, -0.003221741411834955, -0.00955180637538433, 0.00040898675797507167, 0.014524843543767929, -0.037238046526908875, 0.046265047043561935, 0.0297709833830595, -0.023471446707844734, -0.03161076828837395, 0.042047061026096344, -0.01771659590303898, -0.02582046575844288, -0.011590959504246712, 0.04537968337535858, 0.03483569622039795, 0.006518503185361624, -0.05715683475136757, -0.04406401142477989, 0.02447773702442646, 0.04181423410773277, -0.01165490411221981, -0.013309626840054989, 0.020833587273955345, 0.032818831503391266, -0.01715044490993023, 0.005111809354275465, -0.0007804973283782601, 0.006310324650257826, 0.02313566580414772, -0.043668605387210846, 0.05472623556852341, -0.041252050548791885, 0.03611563891172409, 0.031120767816901207, -0.03406856209039688, 0.015022805891931057, 0.019313065335154533, 0.08194688707590103, 0.006520638708025217, -0.04677389934659004, -0.031895481050014496, 0.02339298091828823, -0.03409182280302048, -0.03103496879339218, -0.043232981115579605, 0.0001762503234203905, -0.013793903402984142, -0.017077062278985977, 0.012857135385274887, -0.028111856430768967, 0.022204725071787834, 0.004863417707383633, 0.02387598343193531, -0.0064402977004647255, 0.01463568676263094, -0.006347118876874447, 0.016826048493385315, -0.0016821464523673058, 0.03127007931470871, 0.045988500118255615, 0.008955230005085468, 0.0023010866716504097, 0.0630093440413475, 0.05665874853730202, 0.021325794979929924, -0.007721480913460255, 0.06076357886195183, -0.012927662581205368, 0.03986620530486107, 0.010773816145956516, 0.030124356970191002, 0.005525023676455021, 0.04254920408129692, 0.036198899149894714, -0.012668957933783531, -0.018569713458418846, -0.02966536395251751, 0.022617222741246223, -0.0019926035311073065, -0.00270690000616014, 0.008130883798003197, -0.027391577139496803, 0.04215150326490402, 0.024263037368655205, -0.015525782480835915, -0.01301706675440073, -0.019588636234402657, -0.015985192731022835, -0.0178957711905241, -0.01261606439948082, -0.07316575944423676, 0.015676358714699745, -0.0016186782158911228, -0.00918719545006752, 0.033647436648607254, -0.027238469570875168, -0.014773120172321796, -0.01068459078669548, 0.06532527506351471, 0.07056692242622375, 0.04468342289328575, -0.002781379735097289, 0.02815164066851139, -0.0341353677213192, -0.036796800792217255, 0.008159332908689976, -0.00804171897470951, -0.01689687930047512, -0.055997975170612335, 0.06497297435998917, -0.020787907764315605, -0.06629906594753265, 0.019030064344406128, -0.03928203135728836, 0.06010669842362404, 0.016883067786693573, -0.09760042279958725, -0.03294043615460396, 0.01984901912510395, -0.02953176386654377, 0.0013336478732526302, -0.04753686487674713, 0.030940281227231026, -0.017130475491285324, 0.04179269075393677, 0.04644094780087471, 0.03670762851834297, 0.035745833069086075, 0.022473106160759926, 0.015988880768418312, -0.03476822003722191, -0.032560233026742935, 0.03026261180639267, -0.008036132901906967, 0.013639461249113083, -0.0719676986336708, 0.009921444579958916, 0.01650064066052437, -0.02328626811504364, 0.008806691505014896, 0.044652584940195084, 0.04197827726602554, -0.018351947888731956, -0.011816391721367836, 0.006603298708796501, -0.0344284325838089, 0.06566846370697021, -0.007029588799923658, -0.02083904668688774, -0.01398532371968031, -0.02918853983283043, -0.00288575142621994, 0.0012687318958342075, 0.03420288488268852, 0.019056648015975952, 0.01284113246947527, 0.011795289814472198, 0.01423807442188263, 0.007003882434219122, 0.02872515842318535, -0.0201003048568964, -0.006810662802308798, -0.0006815113592892885, -0.0798378586769104, 0.013252221047878265, 0.02271418645977974, 0.0043793935328722, -0.05044545978307724, 0.005068961065262556, -0.042249660938978195, -0.06307743489742279, -0.06585825979709625, 0.006965705193579197, -0.02687673084437847, -0.021682268008589745, -0.021391870453953743, 0.0020392632577568293, 0.05161421746015549, -0.022611359134316444, -0.022642025724053383, 0.004658366087824106, -0.01678558997809887, 0.024273598566651344, -0.03481733426451683, -0.004669638350605965, 0.005033987108618021, 0.10770385712385178, -0.04381595924496651, 0.014805321581661701, -0.04749573394656181, -0.03070436604321003, 0.009478465653955936, -0.03816854953765869, 0.004608712159097195, 0.007227446883916855, -0.005189341027289629, 0.05042799189686775, -0.00012106270150979981, -0.004735540132969618, 0.03534524515271187, -0.04303167387843132, 0.014321847818791866, 0.07436733692884445, 0.004460155498236418, -0.026021428406238556, -0.014661405235528946, 0.0034116413444280624, 0.035482656210660934, -0.006229968275874853, -0.0018537110881879926, -0.04488973692059517, 0.005604199133813381, 0.07313331216573715, 0.04216993972659111, -0.026694627478718758, 0.005492217838764191, 0.08753784745931625, -0.025000326335430145, 0.014741552993655205, 0.019222047179937363, 0.025032145902514458, -0.023353932425379753, 0.019344814121723175, 0.025714335963129997, 0.017049625515937805, 0.008764454163610935, 0.03420310840010643, -0.010936399921774864, 0.06428017467260361, -0.009281886741518974, -0.01500842534005642, 0.04967457056045532, -0.013885381631553173, 0.04459621384739876, 0.008154100738465786, -0.043899182230234146, 0.057118963450193405, -0.026571953669190407, 0.008708326146006584, 0.02866903506219387, 0.010866237804293633, 0.02883693389594555, 0.03411482274532318, -0.0039173299446702, 0.0355893149971962, 0.0029230848886072636, -0.016800908371806145, -0.014627810567617416, 0.03286752849817276, -0.03489428758621216, 0.03314158320426941, -0.034314364194869995, -0.03508605808019638, -0.029972407966852188, -0.021637985482811928, 0.026766857132315636, -0.011882874183356762, 0.010862350463867188, -0.030087174847722054, -0.043891843408346176, 0.03059198334813118, -0.022582465782761574, 0.009764840826392174, -0.009626099839806557, -0.007968508638441563, 0.034300778061151505, -0.0006916805286891758, -0.0168259646743536, 0.03968590125441551, -0.0012532563414424658, 0.013648169115185738, 0.038887232542037964, 0.008211659267544746, -0.054601527750492096, 0.0006219107308425009, -0.021827902644872665, 0.006915811914950609, -0.040547050535678864, -0.023039162158966064, 0.03259626403450966, 0.0038395128212869167, -0.04923897981643677, -0.023410210385918617, -0.049010928720235825, 0.01240798644721508, -0.020699629560112953, -0.012821649201214314, 0.009051873348653316, -0.021091768518090248, 0.0076674968004226685, 0.007099492475390434, -0.048252254724502563, -0.022863727062940598, -0.0465676449239254, -0.06452009081840515, 0.01917199045419693, 0.0057577816769480705, 0.020062875002622604, -0.005092657171189785, -0.03514168784022331, 0.024299612268805504, 0.03282471001148224, -0.0017878786893561482, -0.028998250141739845, -0.017804116010665894, -0.004011897835880518, -0.02593155950307846, 0.03790133073925972, 0.04516027867794037, -0.02865375578403473, 0.013266321271657944, 0.016557840630412102, 0.030415453016757965, 0.0679614394903183, 0.01499036606401205, -0.004562608432024717, -0.010125069878995419, 0.006146945059299469, 0.013838673010468483, 0.018086444586515427, -0.03462439775466919, -0.02532101981341839, 0.028487488627433777, -0.022099118679761887, 0.010691882111132145, -0.009319768287241459, -0.051123056560754776, 0.016986962407827377, -0.019604751840233803, 0.011616956442594528, -0.05971385911107063, 0.041846178472042084, 0.003609246574342251, -0.023082735016942024, -0.014589405618607998, -0.00846060924232006, -0.0009746675495989621, -0.012262387201189995, 0.021579554304480553, 0.004995420575141907, 0.044786009937524796, -0.00702708400785923, 0.01097874529659748, -0.022443940863013268, -0.02037101238965988, 0.021563589572906494, -0.037928324192762375, -0.03298533335328102, 0.058750253170728683, 0.026759373024106026, 0.03195338323712349, 0.011113332584500313, -0.04367005079984665, 0.00045560451690107584, -0.06827669590711594, -0.0032553612254559994, -0.037548620253801346, 0.08738240599632263, -0.0029731488320976496, 0.021735895425081253, 0.018378570675849915, -0.016303816810250282, 0.01840432733297348, -0.055977437645196915, -0.05655457824468613, 0.04920148476958275, 0.019060328602790833, 0.032015975564718246, -0.0006350519834086299, -0.02718588523566723, -0.024344781413674355, -0.0412202924489975, 0.009683476760983467, 0.000005129964847583324, 0.0058708409778773785, -0.032348182052373886, -0.004244854208081961, -0.0031120702624320984, -0.010547188110649586, 0.0075881206430494785, -0.005306967068463564, 0.04126141592860222, -0.045635052025318146, 0.038827527314424515, 0.051197685301303864, 0.016519207507371902, -0.015648338943719864, -0.017447734251618385, 0.0420122966170311, 0.006838687229901552, 0.027664951980113983, 0.040504373610019684, 0.03933515027165413, -0.010541427880525589, 0.033572155982255936, 0.03257661312818527, 0.009329602122306824, 0.04166664183139801, -0.025346539914608, -0.04514457285404205, -0.022771785035729408, -0.026171252131462097, 0.0018438486149534583, 0.028398090973496437, 0.015249510295689106, -0.025586141273379326, 0.005590253975242376, 0.05353834480047226, -0.010999373160302639, 0.0013530332362279296, 0.0761215090751648, 0.008823897689580917, -0.0002186810306739062, -0.0383136086165905, -0.02932496927678585, -0.0008857213542796671, -0.005226271227002144, 0.043440282344818115, -0.00267764157615602, -0.0255197174847126, -0.0006072872783988714, 0.014860972762107849, -0.015221752226352692, -0.007730037439614534, 0.042338598519563675, 0.035274308174848557, 0.012260282412171364, 0.029612204059958458, -0.033949512988328934, 0.009850576519966125, 0.046229321509599686, 0.03996020555496216, 0.012105698697268963, 0.015555559657514095, -0.10667036473751068, -0.012239836156368256, 0.05758571997284889, 0.07139809429645538, -0.016879016533493996, -0.042230453342199326, -0.04009374603629112, -0.009128921665251255, 0.04452089965343475, -0.03173254430294037, 0.02454560063779354, -0.01083220075815916, 0.016513343900442123, -0.03674157336354256, -0.04669316112995148, -0.01711437664926052, 0.024233976379036903, -0.022189870476722717, 0.046768832951784134, 0.030911730602383614, -0.05294545739889145, -0.06398826837539673, -0.0018677220214158297, 0.027268677949905396, 0.049501072615385056, -0.04791555181145668, 0.019691018387675285, 0.006128270179033279, 0.003483760869130492, -0.024819230660796165, -0.03993511572480202, 0.03144167736172676, -0.017614038661122322, -0.002253968734294176, 0.06200799718499184, 0.01756979152560234, 0.008694763295352459, -0.012909973040223122, 0.021536704152822495, -0.026382284238934517, 0.004953105002641678, -0.010526887141168118, 0.02074742503464222, 0.03076655976474285, 0.00474866246804595, 0.07249213010072708, 0.021971354261040688, 0.035415567457675934, 0.028556177392601967, 0.012738320045173168, 0.036503661423921585, -0.01744270697236061, -0.026588454842567444, -0.0225684754550457, -0.0324622243642807, -0.005959519650787115, 0.018353721126914024, -0.0073031410574913025, 0.057041388005018234, -0.03982970863580704, 0.023874087259173393, 0.020956488326191902, 0.025758469477295876, -0.030992403626441956, -0.031647827476263046, -0.016094431281089783, 0.00820242241024971, -0.0107989851385355, -0.02967921458184719, -0.003039692295715213, -0.01570321060717106, -0.001607232610695064, 0.01955963671207428, -0.031221933662891388, 0.04655589163303375, -0.01749912090599537, -0.027823064476251602, 0.01272857841104269, 0.003866391722112894, 0.026767222210764885, 0.007492475677281618, 0.03851434960961342, 0.0016356115229427814, -0.024817682802677155, 0.02084437943994999, 0.03142113611102104, 0.031722307205200195, -0.001290821353904903, -0.05027582496404648, 0.05777129530906677, 0.017322011291980743, -0.019208243116736412, -0.060881029814481735, -0.03864525258541107, 0.0052329255267977715, 0.03694288432598114, -0.03768537938594818, -0.04207238927483559, -0.005731937475502491, 0.0010288383346050978, 0.00337815610691905, -0.04136035591363907, 0.03705862909555435, -0.019437778741121292, 0.03092017024755478, 0.0036713876761496067, 0.015661463141441345, 0.06982079893350601, -0.020622851327061653, 0.006133244372904301, -0.005702542141079903, -0.04567048326134682, -0.04312736541032791, -0.03493896871805191, 0.005218235310167074, -0.027558809146285057, -0.0006340013933368027, -0.03367220610380173, -0.017907757312059402, 0.049345459789037704, -0.02888067252933979, -0.018159277737140656, 0.04574216157197952, -0.012792468070983887, 0.0052020554430782795, -0.052701931446790695, 0.026615265756845474, -0.027970382943749428, 0.03513876348733902, -0.03327152132987976, -0.03725935518741608, -0.0024240987841039896, -0.005029541440308094, 0.001877400791272521, -0.002223121002316475, -0.018148234114050865, 0.031061450019478798, 0.08559653162956238, -0.03769431635737419, -0.005771222524344921, 0.026510894298553467, -0.0022127532865852118, 0.0018979167798534036, -0.011193410493433475, -0.010293243452906609, -0.0015886169858276844, -0.027563469484448433, -0.04347820580005646, -0.028872359544038773, -0.024835949763655663, -0.03155598044395447, 0.057199496775865555, -0.012359322048723698, 0.06697329133749008, 0.04992560297250748, -0.011873068287968636, 0.02441999688744545, -0.05007422715425491, -0.0023915537167340517, -0.0023104718420654535, -0.01917921006679535, 0.04889698699116707, -0.009746671654284, -0.02263026311993599, 0.0410526841878891, -0.020737288519740105, 0.01731162890791893, 0.06497412919998169, 0.005014447495341301, 0.011786782182753086, 0.04033787548542023, -0.03558383136987686, -0.012745642103254795, -0.011651072651147842, -0.04565123841166496, -0.0035710143856704235, -0.05756119638681412, 0.008291895501315594, 0.04606638103723526, 0.014438724145293236, -0.02709032967686653, -0.04859786480665207, -0.03153441101312637, -0.1082836464047432, 0.005583255551755428, 0.05808286368846893, -0.005362206604331732, 0.04451006278395653, 0.05444895476102829, 0.06909333169460297, -0.010030968114733696, 0.035672493278980255, -0.005222095176577568, -0.03813640773296356, 0.02214844338595867, -0.005804876796901226, -0.03980284929275513, 0.038014236837625504, -0.004929085727781057, 0.007322831079363823, 0.028021708130836487, -0.01917431876063347, -0.03845645859837532, 0.004718989599496126, 0.032804492861032486, 0.043018847703933716, 0.0723305195569992, -0.019143538549542427, 0.01919054239988327, -0.0055306218564510345, -0.011723963543772697, 0.13314907252788544, 0.05578065663576126, 0.027456684038043022, -0.06278102099895477, 0.0145291518419981, 0.03473605588078499, -0.004167996812611818, -0.036660511046648026, 0.009739949367940426, 0.0022597627248615026, -0.01486015785485506, 0.09252224117517471, 0.05033159255981445, 0.006469915620982647, -0.013366058468818665, 0.05490490421652794, -0.005520409904420376, 0.030272461473941803, 0.013253026641905308, 0.04292887821793556, 0.004961587954312563, 0.005799651611596346, -0.051890794187784195, 0.02429817058146, -0.00790219847112894, -0.01820683293044567, -0.009618766605854034, -0.03326395899057388, 0.024807743728160858, -0.010112582705914974, -0.01356249675154686, 0.04231959581375122, 0.023801498115062714, 0.029417933896183968, 0.0028471890836954117, -0.02356690727174282, 0.03417395055294037, -0.03400756046175957, 0.0026811810676008463, 0.023327866569161415, 0.03177747502923012, -0.034962691366672516, -0.014251716434955597, 0.021390603855252266, -0.07332149893045425, -0.007166261784732342, -0.06614598631858826, 0.0013758647255599499, 0.013696338050067425, -0.02548186108469963, -0.006826062221080065, -0.0004954423056915402, 0.0035459748469293118, -0.05480565130710602, -0.030319374054670334, 0.03155769035220146, 0.021619098260998726, -0.03176548331975937, 0.02179383672773838, -0.05836111679673195, 0.008620016276836395, 0.017269643023610115, 0.06152934581041336, 0.019396688789129257, -0.020742211490869522, 0.01379344891756773, -0.030102748423814774, 0.023422541096806526, -0.02978014573454857, -0.0012695377226918936, 0.01653292588889599, 0.0015927724307402968, -0.004343750886619091, -0.015272097662091255, 0.0329253189265728, -0.0013256388483569026, 0.016359541565179825, 0.0008938746759667993, -0.017921481281518936, -0.005676546599715948, -0.05982057750225067, 0.01831667684018612, 0.010085784830152988, -0.002741681644693017, -0.018770970404148102, -0.009805405512452126, 0.0711895227432251, 0.015944814309477806, 0.028922170400619507, -0.010934680700302124, 0.004434638191014528, 0.05047118663787842, 0.030862145125865936, -0.04175360128283501, -0.027417458593845367, -0.03569196164608002, -0.026610422879457474, -0.026982523500919342, -0.047143202275037766, 0.032219093292951584, 0.01965692825615406, -0.0415056049823761, -0.011709339916706085, 0.008758658543229103, -0.051643334329128265, 0.006277800537645817, 0.01874292455613613, -0.049567222595214844, -0.007870426401495934, -0.01610783487558365, 0.006521506235003471, 0.013759972527623177, -0.020055150613188744, -0.034007612615823746, 0.008197201415896416, -0.00021217562607489526, -0.02284313179552555, -0.036664314568042755, 0.03131064400076866, -0.006280310917645693, 0.024494323879480362, -0.01814289763569832, -0.018451543524861336, -0.029619408771395683, -0.03805213421583176, -0.007552584167569876, -0.034268368035554886, -0.003089224686846137, 0.035864077508449554, -0.04692073166370392, -0.023527756333351135, 0.03207199648022652, 0.0015127918450161815, 0.00560190062969923, -0.004448759835213423, 0.014644374139606953, -0.026618484407663345, 0.05050884187221527, -0.007865569554269314, -0.03189276158809662, 0.05379162356257439, -0.021488143131136894, 0.011482729576528072, 0.01111902017146349, 0.003644360927864909, 0.016202187165617943, -0.001732913893647492, -0.0022407504729926586, 0.009618505835533142, 0.0517379492521286, -0.0383329913020134, 0.01185857504606247, -0.0034102171193808317, 0.022399259731173515, 0.035672467201948166, 0.019693737849593163, 0.02894669771194458, -0.014636618085205555, -0.004349345341324806, 0.002814795123413205, 0.030071616172790527, 0.009278383105993271, -0.022594520822167397, -0.024872852489352226, -0.033115994185209274, 0.021856436505913734, 0.012197542004287243, 0.0013756353873759508, 0.038606908172369, 0.04541090503334999, -0.041275832802057266, 0.0140603082254529, -0.03459812328219414, -0.02226448804140091, -0.08450555056333542, 0.029054895043373108, -0.004591819830238819, -0.03371965512633324, 0.018498221412301064, -0.04379863291978836, 0.031598106026649475, 0.008174577727913857, -0.004541055765002966, 0.03303571790456772, 0.01193493977189064, 0.01196278166025877, -0.013984018005430698, 0.025529442355036736, -0.022227583453059196, -0.004055464174598455, 0.033954448997974396, 0.030335325747728348, 0.015836669132113457, 0.02680336683988571, 0.019993219524621964, -0.011271079070866108, -0.0035353954881429672, 0.0021403469145298004, 0.013139438815414906, -0.04022868722677231, 0.022327544167637825, -0.05598072707653046, -0.0031579232309013605, 0.01125094760209322, -0.013818002305924892, 0.03981291130185127, -0.009533917531371117, -0.016510989516973495, -0.00965155754238367, 0.03360076993703842, 0.0636015310883522, -0.0237683467566967, -0.0148234898224473, -0.03848758712410927, 0.013496432453393936, 0.002746209967881441, -0.004361861385405064, -0.00335141783580184, 0.03308766335248947, 0.00444372184574604, -0.02886832505464554, 0.024110490456223488, 0.005260090343654156, -0.026916027069091797, 0.03057103231549263, -0.020950058475136757, 0.030146338045597076, 0.023837311193346977, 0.0003517446748446673, -0.034907907247543335, -0.01419336162507534, 0.08167825639247894, 0.007395635358989239, -0.024629896506667137, 0.0027022126596421003, -0.009596265852451324, -0.06779743731021881, 0.031611960381269455, 0.004385577514767647, -0.03327948972582817, -0.04276600107550621, -0.007871764712035656, -0.019813286140561104, 0.018256111070513725, -0.06506044417619705, -0.012934403494000435, -0.01943056657910347, 0.022807467728853226, -0.005521658342331648, -0.010845367796719074, 0.0433303639292717, -0.011748742312192917, 0.0023125852458178997, -0.08247380703687668, 0.06262990832328796, -0.002416520845144987, -0.02950253337621689, -0.03418829292058945, -0.019534606486558914, -0.04998401924967766, 0.00495891971513629, 0.0546659454703331, 0.011252417229115963, 0.007276023272424936, -0.016057346016168594, 0.0061083100736141205, 0.040206220000982285, -0.05576026812195778, 0.06487859785556793, -0.0006412359653040767, -0.0452641099691391, 0.009807170368731022, -0.0045480867847800255, 0.008406490087509155, 0.003954431973397732, 0.0029133257921785116, -0.011426362209022045, 0.006291489582508802, -0.0002355433680349961, -0.01595408283174038, 0.014240133576095104, 0.008753926493227482, -0.018438609316945076, 0.03054291568696499, -0.018748793751001358, 0.012192696332931519, 0.013226140290498734, -0.006522896699607372, -0.05440967157483101, 0.02837013639509678, -0.036161474883556366, -0.003640157403424382, 0.015515008009970188, -0.01052536629140377, -0.030503714457154274, -0.04618777707219124, -0.03285275399684906, 0.01043685432523489, 0.004682072438299656, 0.020512200891971588, 0.040538638830184937, 0.019302260130643845, 0.030254734680056572, -0.018112260848283768, 0.036718156188726425, -0.02208043821156025, 0.010458025150001049, -0.005010534077882767, 0.020069550722837448, 0.0162810068577528, -0.019006211310625076, 0.0007980401860550046, 0.039192624390125275, 0.019401758909225464, 0.008329139091074467, -0.0444800928235054, 0.032784461975097656, -0.007963012903928757, -0.036283452063798904, 0.013885052874684334, 0.018080227077007294, -0.03381215035915375, 0.0223495252430439, 0.00013588397996500134, 0.018826015293598175, -0.019155800342559814, 0.016712838783860207, -0.022183306515216827, -0.02632526308298111, -0.05767637491226196, -0.0036342565435916185, 0.030104979872703552, 0.015753502026200294, -0.005037473049014807, 0.01388100441545248, -0.00021420714620035142, -0.003919410519301891, 0.008698887191712856, -0.0026193091180175543, 0.014932842925190926, -0.0014143864391371608, -0.004156788811087608, -0.01924046128988266, -0.010340618900954723, -0.007995136082172394, -0.01262610498815775, 0.015414797700941563, 0.04708631709218025, 0.036339689046144485, -0.015307707712054253, -0.02842085249722004, 0.010487370193004608, 0.022339509800076485, -0.11862348020076752, -0.026148617267608643, -0.02277831919491291, 0.0003997966123279184, 0.01171763427555561, -0.03240235149860382 ]
<p>My first and I think naive question here.</p> <p>I am trying to model a certain business, and the simplest model I am willing to test is: 1. there is a bag of differently biased coins. 2. every step, a single coin is chosen with equal probability. 3. the chosen coin is flipped and returned to the bag.</p> <p>The business goal is to predict the rate of heads in future trials (probably using Bayesian inference).</p> <p>This got me thinking - am I not over-complicating things? Isn't this process (observationally) equivalent to a single biased coin?</p> <p>Thanks in advance!</p>
74,029
[ -0.06018751114606857, -0.04999435693025589, -0.00568053824827075, -0.016097869724035263, 0.01296719815582037, -0.002568779978901148, 0.011606360785663128, 0.010687721893191338, -0.009587402455508709, 0.006352802738547325, 0.04938710853457451, 0.047021541744470596, 0.050676796585321426, 0.02595459669828415, 0.013719500973820686, 0.027117852121591568, -0.007509530987590551, -0.003548102453351021, 0.015693768858909607, -0.014389218762516975, 0.006587082985788584, 0.03825132176280022, 0.009767190553247929, -0.022824542596936226, -0.032908834517002106, -0.0011819673236459494, 0.036376774311065674, -0.027540596202015877, 0.021376879885792732, 0.02288220450282097, -0.027011049911379814, -0.026627803221344948, 0.051966696977615356, 0.0699048861861229, 0.06189492344856262, 0.001832599751651287, -0.005764194298535585, -0.03506540134549141, -0.012472678907215595, 0.036678653210401535, -0.03240562975406647, 0.02660493738949299, -0.006104073487222195, 0.017836784943938255, -0.012870010919868946, -0.022813351824879646, -0.032437361776828766, -0.013661119155585766, 0.025954509153962135, -0.05648873373866081, 0.06820674240589142, -0.004193134140223265, 0.03136179968714714, 0.03386257588863373, 0.025957785546779633, -0.021106787025928497, 0.04301166906952858, 0.05703774467110634, -0.020935148000717163, -0.004749521147459745, -0.03343697264790535, 0.005250976420938969, 0.02521035075187683, -0.01778712309896946, -0.03904426470398903, 0.030371278524398804, -0.007295245770365, -0.0615059994161129, 0.04271028935909271, -0.00956951268017292, 0.04954875260591507, 0.025683775544166565, 0.03393210098147392, 0.00883434060961008, -0.007001506630331278, -0.006541133392602205, 0.0321861170232296, 0.013708987273275852, 0.03685881197452545, 0.018404653295874596, -0.0058275675401091576, -0.0260306429117918, -0.003467382164672017, 0.06331764906644821, 0.031904492527246475, -0.02783907577395439, 0.046247031539678574, -0.057338517159223557, 0.041762955486774445, 0.02802974544465542, -0.03636615723371506, 0.0015090792439877987, 0.03594463691115379, 0.005632967688143253, -0.07979094982147217, 0.050607986748218536, -0.02374221384525299, 0.05215400457382202, -0.012437739409506321, 0.01271541602909565, -0.02942517213523388, -0.044967103749513626, -0.002068266738206148, 0.06438793241977692, -0.039722416549921036, -0.03322681412100792, -0.020121360197663307, 0.028262833133339882, -0.0493447370827198, -0.002733818953856826, -0.029836049303412437, 0.012865359894931316, 0.0011360442731529474, -0.0026965204160660505, 0.0019036951707676053, 0.006231445353478193, -0.053010184317827225, -0.025640198960900307, 0.03705349937081337, 0.05289118364453316, 0.050852347165346146, -0.032821208238601685, 0.018945839256048203, -0.031398434191942215, -0.03881596028804779, -0.004470388870686293, 0.03247485309839249, -0.055902838706970215, -0.0366918183863163, 0.060853417962789536, 0.03589657321572304, -0.01439205463975668, 0.043138157576322556, 0.018728960305452347, 0.012837009504437447, -0.038094840943813324, -0.08892832696437836, -0.030514683574438095, 0.02664119377732277, -0.023239757865667343, -0.00008650981908431277, -0.06228645145893097, -0.006598762236535549, 0.05237529054284096, 0.052658360451459885, -0.027248894795775414, 0.025576625019311905, 0.009832050651311874, 0.051988087594509125, 0.04700561985373497, -0.035156574100255966, 0.020559949800372124, 0.00090453727170825, 0.015506361611187458, -0.03281218931078911, -0.05601189285516739, 0.0014706895453855395, 0.001033265725709498, -0.012854253873229027, -0.04054749384522438, -0.0026432231534272432, 0.006155961658805609, 0.004353269003331661, -0.015913717448711395, -0.0005061745760031044, -0.01242463756352663, 0.08329736441373825, 0.016006838530302048, 0.02267240360379219, -0.004604343790560961, 0.012069393880665302, -0.0051247053779661655, -0.015656543895602226, 0.04440263286232948, 0.045975591987371445, -0.045473530888557434, 0.02554883435368538, -0.0470617413520813, 0.032124944031238556, 0.00033837961382232606, -0.012280497699975967, -0.007913987152278423, 0.014079520478844643, -0.008709383197128773, -0.033963967114686966, 0.0015443400479853153, -0.005436505191028118, -0.024840936064720154, 0.013083669357001781, -0.051517609506845474, -0.0347282737493515, -0.07478870451450348, -0.04568308964371681, -0.04521176964044571, -0.03282663971185684, 0.03246614336967468, -0.0023435400798916817, 0.03236817941069603, -0.02750534750521183, -0.06048841401934624, -0.018657030537724495, 0.006150910165160894, 0.027605798095464706, -0.05019079148769379, -0.0002447656006552279, 0.06925638765096664, -0.003880283096805215, -0.01664871908724308, 0.02729325369000435, -0.014666161499917507, -0.006984914653003216, -0.014933356083929539, -0.024026459082961082, -0.010904612950980663, -0.0023342471104115248, 0.018730299547314644, 0.05437585711479187, -0.014202145859599113, 0.009053023532032967, 0.05136296898126602, -0.04539664462208748, 0.07305152714252472, 0.05020088329911232, -0.017726900056004524, 0.0034195957705378532, -0.014605234377086163, 0.023654330521821976, 0.012604394927620888, -0.00725415488705039, -0.026143871247768402, -0.030498463660478592, 0.006580134388059378, -0.003602229990065098, 0.024051077663898468, -0.01085576694458723, 0.01497073657810688, 0.043286602944135666, 0.025797802954912186, 0.015372328460216522, 0.029778214171528816, 0.014145162887871265, 0.013711296021938324, 0.004768770188093185, 0.024110298603773117, 0.01701689325273037, 0.021038126200437546, 0.025965692475438118, -0.022559264674782753, -0.0027234023436903954, 0.003541777143254876, -0.0365876704454422, 0.029521213844418526, 0.01812317781150341, 0.00023137862444855273, -0.027781037613749504, -0.0273822620511055, 0.02755342423915863, -0.020383641123771667, 0.0105111263692379, 0.043905969709157944, 0.03267780691385269, -0.03865722939372063, -0.01827312260866165, -0.0408756248652935, -0.009845200926065445, 0.06403054296970367, -0.033139780163764954, 0.022492749616503716, 0.044973619282245636, -0.00885848794132471, 0.016785098239779472, 0.0006937182042747736, 0.008399893529713154, -0.02959374152123928, 0.048618171364068985, 0.0022879389580339193, 0.015444253571331501, 0.027957310900092125, -0.03895583003759384, -0.02811235748231411, -0.005404398310929537, 0.032898738980293274, 0.036072175949811935, 0.010041155852377415, -0.09488610178232193, 0.01816546730697155, 0.0072952862828969955, -0.04027508199214935, 0.020406678318977356, -0.00968986190855503, -0.012389043346047401, 0.02962387539446354, 0.005618033930659294, -0.04150858148932457, -0.0005956353852525353, -0.016698278486728668, 0.020516613498330116, -0.03315964713692665, -0.02223040536046028, 0.04971293359994888, 0.04713129624724388, -0.05667310953140259, 0.0066514150239527225, -0.03392091020941734, -0.033536091446876526, -0.014642260037362576, -0.04675520583987236, 0.0176052525639534, -0.00898714642971754, 0.01295022014528513, 0.05668826401233673, -0.006664446089416742, -0.023104151710867882, -0.05956464260816574, -0.09361416846513748, 0.027362875640392303, -0.010662340559065342, 0.02421470172703266, -0.00019486383826006204, 0.032804958522319794, 0.07362189888954163, 0.028927933424711227, -0.038382720202207565, -0.01668217033147812, -0.003931706305593252, -0.029348216950893402, -0.04405805096030235, 0.007355339825153351, 0.030849553644657135, -0.03922126069664955, 0.011887384578585625, -0.002729912521317601, 0.026379957795143127, 0.008908258751034737, -0.013925610110163689, -0.005828306544572115, 0.04379774257540703, 0.001441614469513297, -0.009883344173431396, -0.024475302547216415, 0.030162611976265907, -0.015295316465198994, -0.011505228467285633, 0.0008981576538644731, 0.03371315076947212, 0.03028900921344757, -0.01983487419784069, 0.05906541645526886, -0.00801465567201376, 0.0016447899397462606, 0.022306060418486595, 0.021022992208600044, -0.04206506907939911, -0.024734465405344963, -0.020434513688087463, -0.01460408978164196, 0.04893853887915611, 0.0005180013831704855, 0.017642954364418983, 0.05495610460639, 0.0013933690497651696, -0.024423416703939438, -0.054934125393629074, -0.024481328204274178, -0.0016891404520720243, 0.010331829078495502, -0.015224226750433445, -0.024497177451848984, 0.000970357155892998, 0.054433804005384445, 0.06550998985767365, -0.031000636518001556, -0.03923621028661728, -0.0011944572906941175, -0.07484293729066849, 0.027555033564567566, -0.015433061867952347, 0.01554710604250431, -0.000057175559049937874, 0.04408122971653938, -0.014029808342456818, -0.02388693392276764, 0.01509128324687481, 0.01606423780322075, -0.05481502413749695, 0.02888430841267109, -0.01912890002131462, -0.00408241618424654, -0.016152413561940193, -0.030985835939645767, 0.025403158739209175, -0.05488166585564613, 0.01266804151237011, 0.02328026294708252, -0.02052292786538601, -0.022671399638056755, 0.02101193182170391, -0.056548841297626495, -0.015711860731244087, 0.04871867224574089, 0.03885708004236221, 0.03618650138378143, -0.01187869906425476, 0.05648867413401604, -0.006455244962126017, -0.03431386500597, 0.004150450229644775, -0.015293885953724384, 0.012748975306749344, 0.027733275666832924, 0.04795101284980774, 0.04338239133358002, 0.023149514570832253, -0.07756208628416061, 0.041245944797992706, 0.023674219846725464, 0.03669019415974617, 0.047088075429201126, -0.03859690949320793, -0.025349318981170654, -0.05466765910387039, -0.05314233899116516, 0.025121500715613365, 0.02875509299337864, 0.0566311739385128, -0.011640891432762146, 0.05348967760801315, 0.010454723611474037, -0.02199575863778591, -0.0388013981282711, 0.07554642111063004, 0.001736742677167058, -0.006082012318074703, -0.011157387867569923, 0.01592947542667389, 0.006146338768303394, -0.01375376246869564, 0.010994384996592999, 0.006457881070673466, -0.005950435996055603, 0.017564566805958748, 0.006453895475715399, 0.001115776365622878, -0.010684827342629433, 0.03314700350165367, -0.007922738790512085, 0.06385444849729538, 0.024584868922829628, -0.043401170521974564, 0.03558478504419327, 0.0597207136452198, 0.0013079375494271517, 0.06451873481273651, -0.003547636093571782, -0.06258779764175415, 0.03100217692553997, 0.03275064378976822, 0.01135935913771391, -0.07002278417348862, 0.03384777158498764, -0.024347800761461258, 0.003011989174410701, 0.056193020194768906, -0.026295360177755356, -0.0017946239095181227, 0.006927854381501675, -0.00724151823669672, -0.00492158904671669, -0.008403916843235493, -0.05533834174275398, 0.051939576864242554, -0.03933999314904213, 0.006188776344060898, -0.02116360515356064, -0.03080850839614868, 0.010879737325012684, 0.00547680864110589, 0.03313922509551048, 0.03302595391869545, -0.027903588488698006, -0.005238107405602932, 0.013792788609862328, 0.04297836124897003, -0.010615012608468533, -0.09329576790332794, 0.007046214770525694, -0.0003809419577009976, -0.015651840716600418, 0.021372893825173378, -0.03078078292310238, -0.04665913060307503, 0.01679573580622673, 0.007564834784716368, -0.016559205949306488, 0.03105008788406849, -0.04523894563317299, 0.0180052500218153, 0.0031013735570013523, -0.002440198790282011, 0.04356512799859047, 0.00641470355913043, 0.014892692677676678, -0.014878051355481148, -0.004734493792057037, 0.005348711274564266, -0.001090757199563086, 0.012566495686769485, -0.04531272128224373, -0.020118162035942078, -0.03620787709951401, 0.030491197481751442, 0.03663748875260353, 0.027039101347327232, 0.022019434720277786, -0.00930039118975401, -0.0134669728577137, 0.02260744757950306, 0.015448035672307014, 0.0042248014360666275, -0.03170069307088852, 0.004869570955634117, -0.03836597129702568, -0.022074801847338676, -0.033638566732406616, -0.030498795211315155, 0.0003443553578108549, -0.013258151710033417, -0.03038024716079235, -0.0005228468216955662, -0.03752680867910385, -0.026334131136536598, 0.02191946655511856, -0.018976135179400444, 0.03766733035445213, -0.020001741126179695, 0.06244804710149765, 0.025483690202236176, -0.04387325793504715, -0.0035407464019954205, 0.03862748667597771, -0.007706045638769865, 0.0013945645187050104, -0.030613791197538376, 0.00607630331069231, -0.007638209033757448, -0.012790590524673462, -0.052252378314733505, -0.03433174267411232, 0.011034583672881126, -0.038066565990448, -0.012971937656402588, -0.039137788116931915, 0.007838948629796505, -0.002728646621108055, -0.05217156559228897, -0.03899659961462021, 0.023647965863347054, -0.004242661874741316, -0.008859029971063137, -0.005138294771313667, 0.004487177357077599, 0.06363037973642349, 0.01967637427151203, -0.02358431927859783, 0.0038932855241000652, -0.020242974162101746, -0.007449284195899963, 0.005548825487494469, -0.00425713462755084, -0.03159167990088463, -0.007817188277840614, -0.030712474137544632, -0.007849043235182762, 0.04639950767159462, -0.08128990978002548, -0.0013958652270957828, -0.005784489680081606, -0.017361817881464958, 0.00525378342717886, -0.013308999128639698, -0.0422106608748436, -0.013633158057928085, 0.008982563391327858, -0.04508554935455322, 0.01257376465946436, 0.03304232284426689, -0.03754023462533951, 0.04742756113409996, 0.02595309354364872, -0.029680296778678894, 0.049510657787323, 0.026020390912890434, 0.002430459950119257, -0.006282358895987272, -0.027141094207763672, -0.03409896790981293, 0.018978189677000046, -0.022418053820729256, -0.019183706492185593, -0.0021487835329025984, 0.016453251242637634, -0.03339628502726555, -0.020098119974136353, -0.019419841468334198, 0.012163369916379452, 0.05807028338313103, 0.002741225529462099, 0.03954167664051056, 0.023895664140582085, 0.0360553003847599, -0.02633925899863243, -0.01616511680185795, 0.006230212282389402, -0.022224238142371178, -0.00033359843655489385, 0.04018706455826759, 0.005681451875716448, 0.03542652353644371, 0.040220752358436584, 0.018465768545866013, 0.023821311071515083, 0.03357132524251938, 0.03889533132314682, 0.006814873311668634, 0.03750234842300415, 0.00988906528800726, -0.0021625813096761703, 0.03950823098421097, -0.04916498810052872, 0.01123111229389906, -0.06243737414479256, -0.03224834427237511, 0.06394767016172409, 0.026477474719285965, -0.0052021341398358345, -0.054982926696538925, -0.0275481715798378, -0.055647872388362885, -0.0006066347123123705, -0.020387524738907814, 0.0066574085503816605, 0.01999055966734886, 0.00879492424428463, 0.03538168966770172, 0.004102032165974379, 0.009129712358117104, -0.03322456032037735, -0.10884517431259155, -0.029193641617894173, -0.022586718201637268, -0.02584485150873661, 0.03372107073664665, 0.02672691084444523, -0.01695835031569004, 0.014447560533881187, -0.0383550263941288, 0.02620437555015087, 0.01168614812195301, 0.026616279035806656, 0.003379488131031394, 0.06134084239602089, 0.0315144918859005, 0.03646411746740341, -0.018806826323270798, -0.0159042626619339, 0.11192916333675385, 0.055030904710292816, 0.040302518755197525, -0.028824271634221077, 0.00782717950642109, -0.01814868114888668, -0.0026238549035042524, 0.0043996344320476055, 0.043756674975156784, 0.009551302529871464, 0.029631532728672028, 0.011515465565025806, 0.03444685786962509, 0.02548258565366268, -0.007464995142072439, 0.04082624986767769, -0.037792909890413284, -0.032235726714134216, -0.0013784626498818398, 0.031406354159116745, 0.016173670068383217, -0.04132114723324776, -0.04235795512795448, 0.030219312757253647, 0.007033521309494972, -0.031222516670823097, 0.04907963424921036, -0.013380895368754864, -0.01571027562022209, 0.049265120178461075, 0.02657400444149971, -0.019650980830192566, 0.020802557468414307, -0.051508188247680664, -0.028597507625818253, -0.00047778585576452315, 0.013927728869020939, -0.04628912732005119, 0.017968980595469475, -0.005564675200730562, 0.012178413569927216, 0.0055616130121052265, 0.021931268274784088, 0.014541191048920155, -0.03703929856419563, -0.027446173131465912, -0.02351287007331848, 0.031082848086953163, -0.025533000007271767, 0.02178994193673134, -0.016589350998401642, -0.02308950014412403, 0.03312748670578003, -0.07296595722436905, 0.004853269085288048, 0.04200832545757294, -0.012377441860735416, -0.023762505501508713, -0.02590489760041237, -0.026118986308574677, 0.022531632333993912, -0.02277889847755432, 0.02181851677596569, -0.010689884424209595, -0.040608786046504974, -0.03319506347179413, -0.03167936950922012, 0.031499892473220825, 0.02779426798224449, -0.038464970886707306, 0.023918643593788147, -0.023383615538477898, -0.05472131446003914, 0.02659759670495987, -0.017904553562402725, -0.02534932643175125, 0.009938766248524189, -0.029679767787456512, -0.01477301400154829, 0.02029361017048359, 0.005590852815657854, -0.004029515199363232, -0.010537788271903992, -0.0178644061088562, -0.02713620476424694, -0.025620024651288986, 0.0132771460339427, 0.01143236830830574, 0.032996851950883865, 0.0031503087375313044, -0.009006096981465816, 0.04197997599840164, 0.005896895192563534, -0.0637962818145752, 0.0022793752141296864, 0.0057876743376255035, -0.05004540830850601, 0.027568459510803223, -0.02685428410768509, 0.10085524618625641, 0.000455172237707302, 0.025056805461645126, -0.03552404046058655, 0.017721202224493027, 0.00496229063719511, 0.044876668602228165, -0.0058642164804041386, -0.0357653871178627, 0.0008483536075800657, 0.031268566846847534, -0.012877953238785267, -0.05701270326972008, -0.06835739314556122, -0.03761374577879906, 0.019769083708524704, -0.017174042761325836, -0.05592367798089981, -0.04509936645627022, 0.010466476902365685, -0.007326999679207802, 0.05905810371041298, 0.004061492159962654, 0.02493833377957344, -0.018556417897343636, -0.016628865152597427, 0.014032128266990185, 0.01857498474419117, 0.04871581122279167, 0.0017655467381700873, 0.006629026494920254, -0.010363802313804626, 0.0303342267870903, -0.014577602036297321, 0.004909055307507515, 0.01142085250467062, 0.028012771159410477, 0.009007234126329422, 0.02177487686276436, -0.023972058668732643, -0.04251280426979065, 0.056521423161029816, -0.014712294563651085, -0.00023329289979301393, 0.014532195404171944, 0.07161878049373627, 0.05247342959046364, 0.04336218908429146, -0.01078857947140932, -0.02325761877000332, 0.011003619059920311, -0.042758289724588394, -0.02368992194533348, 0.01801535114645958, -0.013190087862312794, -0.00042397406650707126, -0.020107993856072426, 0.04160608723759651, 0.016267169266939163, -0.009399396367371082, 0.03814199939370155, 0.01756754331290722, 0.03534573316574097, -0.02584437094628811, -0.01578853279352188, -0.0036652192939072847, -0.003092654515057802, -0.006148169282823801, 0.000028195023332955316, 0.014988577924668789, 0.03691914677619934, -0.018826382234692574, 0.052966006100177765, 0.02006821520626545, 0.005276382900774479, -0.07621771842241287, -0.020272593945264816, 0.036446407437324524, -0.0030460061971098185, 0.005587915424257517, -0.046866148710250854, 0.019864097237586975, 0.00485153729096055, -0.04463723301887512, 0.006943781394511461, 0.024566616863012314, -0.016014978289604187, -0.05348355695605278, 0.013458894565701485, -0.025088006630539894, -0.0011856922646984458, 0.0022328109480440617, -0.004569882992655039, 0.038835398852825165, -0.0008450163877569139, 0.01570582389831543, -0.008888689801096916, -0.000047004596126498654, 0.03375230357050896, -0.01827455498278141, -0.01686159521341324, 0.025635849684476852, -0.03084014728665352, -0.019753700122237206, 0.05700979009270668, 0.015691472217440605, 0.012688301503658295, 0.01672097109258175, 0.02298138104379177, -0.01782192476093769, 0.0031165932305157185, 0.04343901202082634, -0.01110503263771534, 0.00995431374758482, 0.026441816240549088, 0.04011645168066025, 0.045256149023771286, 0.007981596514582634, 0.004591417033225298, 0.035867854952812195, -0.010435509495437145, -0.002925780601799488, -0.018537962809205055, -0.008974178694188595, 0.009141628630459309, -0.0020214845426380634, 0.017771610990166664, 0.010656184516847134, 0.013102605938911438, 0.03284892812371254, -0.027097012847661972, 0.024662962183356285, 0.031200191006064415, -0.02342316508293152, -0.04671766608953476, -0.020732512697577477, -0.03529149293899536, -0.029592065140604973, 0.01158917136490345, 0.012465283274650574, -0.0024240247439593077, -0.05075715854763985, -0.022700928151607513, 0.03223268687725067, -0.0007829662645235658, -0.016604412347078323, -0.042282503098249435, -0.015011335723102093, 0.03801506385207176, -0.029762357473373413, 0.0293850339949131, 0.03975221887230873, 0.018181895837187767, 0.004384902305901051, -0.08042672276496887, 0.07590964436531067, -0.018137384206056595, -0.0022653350606560707, -0.014192292466759682, -0.021287214010953903, -0.020591674372553825, 0.019446413964033127, 0.07377585023641586, 0.010935736820101738, -0.004569008480757475, 0.029562683776021004, 0.003882582765072584, 0.01360746007412672, -0.04988712817430496, 0.019648892804980278, -0.018750738352537155, 0.015996010974049568, 0.0011304866056889296, -0.04017265886068344, -0.0004534286563284695, -0.01850031316280365, 0.02095179818570614, -0.012342968955636024, 0.01517596747726202, 0.00020914241031277925, -0.02377059869468212, 0.04694591090083122, -0.006444316357374191, 0.004771446343511343, 0.045284055173397064, 0.009448395110666752, -0.006259240210056305, 0.009633577428758144, -0.030638722702860832, -0.06434933096170425, 0.060881320387125015, -0.008382786996662617, -0.019012868404388428, 0.004685530439019203, 0.019401568919420242, -0.007370352279394865, -0.05122978240251541, -0.034779321402311325, 0.0049713351763784885, -0.06552576273679733, 0.013991151936352253, -0.005413108039647341, 0.012849903665482998, 0.007228539325296879, -0.051346659660339355, -0.011356769129633904, 0.0014417419442906976, 0.0038217143155634403, 0.0317196361720562, 0.010988532565534115, 0.04080969840288162, 0.03516451269388199, 0.04420476779341698, 0.02303534932434559, -0.02809622325003147, 0.0000861980952322483, -0.003797569079324603, 0.01417967863380909, -0.032037463039159775, -0.002397534204646945, -0.011966303922235966, 0.004013474564999342, 0.027627242729067802, -0.010597295127809048, 0.035798609256744385, 0.06130595505237579, -0.011240008287131786, 0.020557746291160583, -0.017760269343852997, 0.043416377156972885, 0.01309872418642044, 0.006303845904767513, 0.0037410189397633076, 0.02152884192764759, 0.011509407311677933, -0.047257885336875916, -0.005971791222691536, 0.03730161860585213, 0.022438373416662216, -0.023126821964979172, 0.01799541711807251, 0.002213360508903861, -0.006637902930378914, -0.03362761810421944, -0.020873168483376503, -0.030781492590904236, -0.03870879486203194, 0.009798823855817318, 0.028771841898560524, 0.051513880491256714, 0.012458117678761482, -0.030942630022764206, -0.0062112752348184586, 0.07325290143489838, -0.050971031188964844, -0.02348882146179676, -0.058353241533041, 0.020881587639451027, -0.01906879059970379, 0.010770685039460659 ]
<p>I want to study relations between sites categories and species abundances through PCoA or CAP using vegan::capscale. For doing so, I overlay species scores on my ordination. However, I am getting confused with the different scaling options and their interpretation. From what I understood: With scaling=1, arrow shows the direction from the origin for which sites have larger abundances for this species. With scaling=2, we want to analyze the correlations among species. Species that have a small angle between their arrows are expected to be strongly positively correlated. With scaling=-2, const = sqrt(nrow(dune)-1), we get correlations between species and axes. This comes from <a href="https://stat.ethz.ch/pipermail/r-sig-ecology/2010-August/001448.html" rel="nofollow">Jari Oksanen</a>.</p> <p>I did compare the 3 different options (see codes below), differences seem to be only a matter of arrow length. Hence, by considering that the most important are the relative length of arrows (relative to each other), am I allowed to use scaling=-2 (species axes correlations) for both analyzing site-species associations and species-species correlations? One more questions, is there a well admitted threshold in the value of species-axes correlations, below which we consider that species are not correlated (I mean species don't differ in abundance across the sites, excluding the cases of non linear relationships). If yes, do this threshold change depending on the scaling method used and on either the ordination is constrained or not. Morover, if I want to overlay a vector for a quantitative environnemental variable, may I use also scaling=-2, from which correlation threshold?</p> <pre><code>library(vegan) library(ggplot2) library(grid) data(dune) data(dune.env) dune=sqrt(dune) mcap=capscale(dune~1,dist="bray") #PCoA #sites scores dims=c(1,2) site=scores(mcap,display="wa",choices=dims) site.env=cbind(site,dune.env) #spider for management levels dev.new();plot(mcap);coord_spider=with(dune.env,ordispider(mcap,Management,col="blue",label=F,choices=dims));dev.off() coord_spider=as.data.frame(cbind(coord_spider[,],site.env)) names(coord_spider)[1:4]=c("MDS1","MDS2","MDS1end","MDS2end") #species scores #scaling1 cor.min=0.6 #below this threshold, arrows will be not plotted because correlation is considered too much week cor_sp=as.data.frame(scores(mcap, dis="sp", scaling=1,choices=dims)) cor_sp$cor=with(cor_sp,sqrt(MDS1^2+MDS2^2)) cor_sp$sup=FALSE;cor_sp$sup[cor_sp$cor&gt;=cor.min]&lt;-TRUE cor_sp$lab=row.names(cor_sp) cor_sp=cor_sp[cor_sp$sup==TRUE,] cor_sp_s1=cor_sp #scaling2 cor.min=0.6 #below this threshold, arrows will be not plotted because correlation is considered too much week cor_sp=as.data.frame(scores(mcap, dis="sp", scaling=2,choices=dims)) cor_sp$cor=with(cor_sp,sqrt(MDS1^2+MDS2^2)) cor_sp$sup=FALSE;cor_sp$sup[cor_sp$cor&gt;=cor.min]&lt;-TRUE cor_sp$lab=row.names(cor_sp) cor_sp=cor_sp[cor_sp$sup==TRUE,] cor_sp_s2=cor_sp #scaling -2, correlations between species and axes #from Jari Oksanen at https://stat.ethz.ch/pipermail/r-sig-ecology/2010-August/001448.html cor.min=0.6 #below this threshold, arrows will be not plotted because correlation is considered too much week cor_sp=as.data.frame(scores(mcap, dis="sp", scaling=-2, const = sqrt(nrow(dune)-1),choices=dims)) cor_sp$cor=with(cor_sp,sqrt(MDS1^2+MDS2^2)) cor_sp$sup=FALSE;cor_sp$sup[cor_sp$cor&gt;=cor.min]&lt;-TRUE cor_sp$lab=row.names(cor_sp) cor_sp=cor_sp[cor_sp$sup==TRUE,] cor_sp_s3=cor_sp #plot mon.plot1=ggplot(data=site.env)+theme_bw()+ geom_point(aes(x=MDS1,y=MDS2,color=Management))# les sites #add spider mon.plot2=mon.plot1+ geom_segment(data=coord_spider,aes(x=MDS1,y=MDS2,xend=MDS1end,yend=MDS2end,colour=Management),lwd=0.5,alpha=1/3)+ geom_point(data=coord_spider,aes(x=MDS1,y=MDS2,colour=Management),cex=3,shape=19) #add species scores as vector #scaling1 mon.plot_s1=mon.plot2+ggtitle("Scaling 1")+ geom_point(aes(x=0,y=0),shape=21,fill="black",color="black",size=3)+#central point geom_segment(data=cor_sp_s1,aes(x=0,y=0,xend=MDS1,yend=MDS2),arrow = arrow(length = unit(0.3,"cm")))+#arrows geom_text(data = cor_sp_s1, aes(x = MDS1, y = MDS2, label = lab), size = 3)#labels #scaling2 mon.plot_s2=mon.plot2+ggtitle("Scaling 2")+ geom_point(aes(x=0,y=0),shape=21,fill="black",color="black",size=3)+#central point geom_segment(data=cor_sp_s2,aes(x=0,y=0,xend=MDS1,yend=MDS2),arrow = arrow(length = unit(0.3,"cm")))+#arrows geom_text(data = cor_sp_s2, aes(x = MDS1, y = MDS2, label = lab), size = 3)#labels #scaling -2, correlations between species and axes mon.plot_s3=mon.plot2+ggtitle("Scaling -2")+ geom_point(aes(x=0,y=0),shape=21,fill="black",color="black",size=3)+#central point geom_segment(data=cor_sp_s3,aes(x=0,y=0,xend=MDS1,yend=MDS2),arrow = arrow(length = unit(0.3,"cm")))+#arrows geom_text(data = cor_sp_s3, aes(x = MDS1, y = MDS2, label = lab), size = 3)#labels #plot everything grid.newpage() pushViewport(viewport(layout = grid.layout(2, 2))) print(mon.plot_s1,vp=viewport(layout.pos.row = 1, layout.pos.col = 1)) print(mon.plot_s2,vp=viewport(layout.pos.row = 2, layout.pos.col = 1)) print(mon.plot_s3,vp=viewport(layout.pos.row = 1, layout.pos.col = 2)) </code></pre>
74,030
[ -0.04347651079297066, -0.016634399071335793, 0.005350376944988966, 0.00822876300662756, 0.01009166520088911, 0.041638921946287155, -0.02885919250547886, 0.0032913032919168472, 0.011145330965518951, -0.04246888682246208, 0.01835218071937561, 0.011915739625692368, 0.03437938541173935, 0.03062734380364418, 0.030990606173872948, 0.018219387158751488, -0.026351744309067726, 0.007529810070991516, 0.006703629624098539, -0.02445187419652939, 0.005845492705702782, 0.020789243280887604, 0.01457400806248188, 0.004053035285323858, -0.006871083751320839, 0.05814073234796524, 0.021393902599811554, -0.0013679178664460778, 0.003420524997636676, 0.036101922392845154, -0.05511175096035004, -0.028094783425331116, 0.050670772790908813, 0.03706257417798042, 0.02001187577843666, -0.015316850505769253, 0.017736155539751053, -0.013069244101643562, 0.022878898307681084, 0.026280589401721954, -0.01398598775267601, -0.020605219528079033, -0.01137150265276432, 0.00995514914393425, -0.02469124086201191, 0.031219694763422012, 0.013260066509246826, -0.020059704780578613, 0.03675231337547302, -0.013987633399665356, 0.0710485577583313, -0.010706726461648941, -0.017078690230846405, 0.03484766557812691, -0.005310035310685635, -0.011327916756272316, 0.07296101003885269, 0.028162715956568718, -0.017949914559721947, -0.049715638160705566, -0.05899027734994888, -0.015584103763103485, 0.005979515146464109, 0.02888830192387104, -0.02410726249217987, 0.013681421987712383, 0.027480248361825943, -0.0029088500887155533, 0.04127541556954384, -0.017376309260725975, -0.008566366508603096, -0.003278574673458934, 0.010191092267632484, -0.008579712361097336, 0.03618742898106575, -0.03125784918665886, 0.009423952549695969, 0.01652871072292328, 0.041353218257427216, 0.045977890491485596, 0.013023965992033482, 0.055566076189279556, 0.02461198903620243, 0.011423783376812935, 0.05341624841094017, -0.021274792030453682, 0.04843062907457352, -0.05076976493000984, 0.02426505647599697, 0.025335397571325302, 0.003022419521585107, 0.022029921412467957, 0.05659174546599388, -0.01331967581063509, -0.01775088906288147, 0.02620302140712738, -0.0031105251982808113, -0.006274371407926083, -0.015471654012799263, -0.005113805178552866, -0.060705751180648804, -0.060640159994363785, -0.014761085622012615, 0.04752855375409126, -0.014652310870587826, 0.025609180331230164, -0.06615130603313446, 0.004501858726143837, -0.042309846729040146, -0.028494207188487053, -0.011667686514556408, 0.014102432876825333, 0.003964979667216539, -0.0017144153825938702, 0.03585522994399071, -0.045580074191093445, 0.012470759451389313, 0.023914504796266556, 0.09788322448730469, 0.02871871553361416, 0.05421238765120506, -0.004585233982652426, 0.01322920247912407, -0.011741387657821178, -0.05696626007556915, 0.02768760360777378, 0.03779467195272446, 0.011302446946501732, 0.0010320873698219657, 0.02656354010105133, 0.01697094552218914, -0.02928105741739273, 0.009020105935633183, -0.022349635139107704, 0.029195306822657585, 0.022519413381814957, -0.08555572479963303, -0.027952110394835472, 0.03828757628798485, 0.0010477066971361637, 0.01625075750052929, -0.03580313175916672, -0.014449487440288067, 0.0011365392711013556, 0.043686989694833755, 0.0027795289643108845, 0.03591927886009216, -0.01454571820795536, 0.0015569977695122361, -0.011482183821499348, -0.057478200644254684, -0.014626091346144676, -0.04363350570201874, -0.06553711742162704, -0.02726965770125389, -0.07971766591072083, 0.046646323055028915, 0.0023883997928351164, 0.027124442160129547, 0.02073211409151554, 0.10130515694618225, -0.01234683208167553, 0.007117776665836573, -0.012048549950122833, -0.012893714010715485, 0.007113480009138584, 0.051983632147312164, -0.02685275860130787, 0.0055722566321492195, 0.010833361186087132, -0.018754933029413223, 0.005179210100322962, -0.0005920555558986962, 0.05112089961767197, 0.059945832937955856, 0.001264768885448575, -0.008506587706506252, -0.03902653232216835, -0.005480673164129257, 0.03329743444919586, -0.08029502630233765, -0.03280118107795715, -0.02270578406751156, -0.011490333825349808, 0.06048298254609108, 0.04743707552552223, -0.0023027146235108376, -0.04297719895839691, 0.04425738379359245, -0.04975003004074097, -0.02077404409646988, -0.06421992182731628, -0.021380774676799774, 0.017983611673116684, -0.04921205714344978, 0.03150623291730881, 0.0027421920094639063, 0.009921986609697342, 0.01750275492668152, 0.005639845039695501, -0.01500893384218216, 0.029479729011654854, 0.07393284142017365, -0.05138242989778519, 0.007565601263195276, 0.04807199910283089, 0.04573719576001167, -0.003848521737381816, 0.023402754217386246, -0.04938743636012077, -0.05285422131419182, 0.022582046687602997, -0.016014020889997482, -0.00946338102221489, 0.034038200974464417, -0.026323821395635605, -0.002208580495789647, 0.010830148123204708, -0.06995386630296707, 0.03571096062660217, -0.05768119916319847, 0.06653052568435669, 0.05508336424827576, -0.0013206173898652196, 0.0012521541211754084, 0.03013933263719082, -0.004209311679005623, 0.02320689521729946, -0.0719776600599289, 0.014239519834518433, -0.07690533250570297, 0.0004315518890507519, 0.0640123188495636, 0.025851203128695488, -0.02890278398990631, -0.013155926950275898, 0.04374878108501434, 0.003262641839683056, -0.003340725786983967, 0.042725153267383575, 0.031054334715008736, -0.017566964030265808, -0.016184791922569275, 0.006854045204818249, 0.027471473440527916, -0.00341697852127254, 0.019803669303655624, -0.014253093861043453, 0.05283472314476967, -0.007247332017868757, -0.02362784370779991, 0.029196472838521004, -0.013000395148992538, 0.0018108211224898696, -0.014485785737633705, 0.01590944081544876, 0.039772551506757736, -0.020368540659546852, 0.016766583546996117, 0.06916087120771408, 0.024757293984293938, -0.017748095095157623, 0.028090156614780426, 0.016921671107411385, 0.000740056682843715, 0.05811886116862297, -0.04329879954457283, -0.027389315888285637, 0.00988262239843607, -0.007599989417940378, 0.00416909996420145, -0.03651760146021843, -0.06413296610116959, -0.04011974856257439, -0.007049883715808392, 0.07517939805984497, 0.005991515703499317, 0.04010774940252304, -0.055215638130903244, -0.022518649697303772, -0.02071254327893257, 0.0016061338828876615, 0.0237677451223135, -0.0036786841228604317, -0.005240228492766619, -0.010551335290074348, -0.026683973148465157, 0.0038749759551137686, 0.006935731507837772, -0.028158552944660187, -0.031571026891469955, -0.002732733963057399, 0.020283496007323265, -0.04924460127949715, -0.03370525315403938, -0.0025356828700751066, 0.0119817228987813, -0.036471396684646606, -0.07976707071065903, 0.039058975875377655, -0.006128545850515366, -0.061782918870449066, 0.039908189326524734, -0.014427753165364265, -0.019245510920882225, 0.005613184534013271, -0.00011470208846731111, 0.007698926609009504, 0.012706009671092033, -0.011253521777689457, 0.017964154481887817, -0.028458749875426292, -0.0438583567738533, -0.017049649730324745, -0.04129055142402649, 0.009560225531458855, -0.02103932574391365, 0.0028361687436699867, -0.02077772654592991, -0.01303265430033207, 0.05802280828356743, 0.03261110931634903, 0.014691057614982128, -0.051360975950956345, -0.01765495352447033, -0.037643954157829285, 0.011115741916000843, 0.008984738029539585, -0.002094354247674346, 0.05793150141835213, 0.0351700559258461, -0.004909304901957512, 0.0446767695248127, 0.02085741050541401, -0.0035079100634902716, 0.006301505956798792, 0.03945392370223999, -0.003238063305616379, -0.031783174723386765, 0.025193452835083008, 0.048836272209882736, -0.042080968618392944, 0.048491742461919785, -0.011402237229049206, -0.013003378175199032, -0.005035263951867819, -0.03478556498885155, 0.007780341897159815, 0.0029927559662610292, 0.039496611803770065, -0.027512041851878166, 0.0048601701855659485, 0.04099557176232338, -0.020937101915478706, -0.019089585170149803, -0.020504457876086235, 0.062485694885253906, -0.03752325847744942, -0.033929239958524704, 0.031585484743118286, 0.03226762264966965, -0.005474729463458061, 0.05303172394633293, -0.005025952588766813, 0.008959473110735416, 0.01976037584245205, -0.03521238639950752, -0.00870953593403101, 0.029342636466026306, 0.020651139318943024, -0.028147608041763306, 0.017424797639250755, -0.03484613075852394, 0.032950300723314285, -0.06700417399406433, 0.028240755200386047, -0.07128029316663742, 0.017969321459531784, -0.000991775537841022, 0.016387827694416046, 0.013483571819961071, 0.011114748194813728, -0.014061525464057922, -0.0010105636902153492, -0.04062478616833687, 0.029140060767531395, -0.008106875233352184, 0.020111937075853348, -0.003598166396841407, -0.008782892487943172, -0.0025952677242457867, 0.008008277975022793, 0.010221612639725208, 0.005316092167049646, 0.025830112397670746, -0.022600730881094933, 0.021773379296064377, -0.008364885114133358, -0.0015950619708746672, -0.0010997391073033214, 0.006345509085804224, 0.020903103053569794, -0.033563148230314255, 0.06608528643846512, 0.03332097828388214, -0.00010517271584831178, -0.005993492901325226, 0.00021462504810187966, 0.0103759178891778, 0.046372104436159134, 0.03761739283800125, 0.012798560783267021, 0.0055897049605846405, -0.025780148804187775, 0.013716776855289936, 0.011467589996755123, 0.05719912797212601, 0.03148942068219185, -0.009606970474123955, 0.028373824432492256, -0.032925304025411606, -0.018937669694423676, -0.014649823307991028, 0.017101917415857315, -0.0026304812636226416, -0.0053563304245471954, 0.037137050181627274, 0.004643863067030907, -0.0329044833779335, 0.006463480647653341, 0.030866367742419243, 0.03410964459180832, 0.01200677640736103, -0.054875556379556656, -0.04675529524683952, -0.004097529221326113, 0.004344209562987089, 0.009492555633187294, -0.0003977319283876568, 0.0022654940839856863, 0.008821659721434116, 0.02376348339021206, -0.01157911866903305, -0.032621730118989944, -0.01146682444959879, 0.011771435849368572, 0.048079196363687515, -0.05239322781562805, -0.018354004248976707, -0.008818384259939194, -0.008796095848083496, 0.02779289148747921, 0.009182055480778217, 0.017989562824368477, -0.06327251344919205, -0.026019467040896416, 0.02523070015013218, 0.03392330929636955, -0.01013241708278656, -0.018182020634412766, -0.03917444869875908, -0.03319315239787102, 0.013717759400606155, -0.03942209109663963, 0.014629285782575607, -0.01432948186993599, 0.033692918717861176, -0.02278812602162361, -0.03913012146949768, -0.06428873538970947, 0.0029448922723531723, -0.019333599135279655, -0.006373174488544464, -0.00896499678492546, -0.03177936375141144, -0.02319815568625927, 0.015511961653828621, 0.003073521889746189, 0.03953496739268303, -0.02069634385406971, -0.016235006973147392, 0.026508737355470657, -0.002168324775993824, 0.014407671056687832, -0.03658236935734749, 0.035431019961833954, 0.015210794284939766, 0.015696927905082703, 0.05559004470705986, 0.037192150950431824, 0.03576404228806496, 0.015600299462676048, 0.0240950807929039, -0.009290137328207493, -0.003885948332026601, 0.0067825703881680965, 0.0686536654829979, 0.04178563877940178, -0.021646803244948387, 0.07325718551874161, 0.02392766997218132, -0.012898935936391354, -0.0003304383426439017, -0.07153171300888062, 0.034898217767477036, -0.021912841126322746, -0.005312170833349228, -0.06357299536466599, -0.007767544128000736, -0.018323997035622597, 0.034150030463933945, -0.0024069850333034992, 0.03572389483451843, -0.04735790193080902, -0.009940298274159431, 0.03725650906562805, 0.03710208460688591, 0.017428535968065262, 0.00785244069993496, 0.014089046977460384, 0.007774575147777796, 0.03594124689698219, -0.024264730513095856, 0.013522742316126823, -0.025934429839253426, -0.03151528537273407, -0.00029101347899995744, -0.043448735028505325, -0.02169625833630562, -0.011335376650094986, -0.01864640600979328, 0.0105142742395401, -0.049195561558008194, 0.035675324499607086, -0.004219250753521919, 0.01126724574714899, 0.015329623594880104, -0.0240304134786129, -0.02149874158203602, 0.034270286560058594, -0.023666532710194588, -0.019853796809911728, -0.01744292862713337, 0.026037927716970444, -0.012659210711717606, -0.01281573623418808, -0.02028239332139492, -0.004040660336613655, -0.033318035304546356, 0.0227810125797987, -0.01816810481250286, -0.02610706351697445, -0.03333636745810509, -0.008420714177191257, -0.009335755370557308, -0.03880474716424942, 0.04479413479566574, -0.02921515330672264, 0.00010855999425984919, -0.03539752587676048, 0.0067948647774755955, 0.07235261052846909, -0.03132141754031181, -0.01983928307890892, 0.028150135651230812, 0.0007551166345365345, -0.025629792362451553, -0.002445142949000001, -0.010143505409359932, -0.043827787041664124, -0.007430137135088444, -0.036117006093263626, 0.0011900827521458268, 0.029699357226490974, -0.012603909708559513, -0.04543675109744072, -0.02102021500468254, 0.012424393557012081, 0.011972456239163876, 0.0016370402881875634, -0.00015352974878624082, 0.0017583617009222507, -0.012603426352143288, -0.025227723643183708, -0.019392281770706177, 0.001920446171425283, -0.02321707084774971, -0.007344807498157024, 0.012968027964234352, 0.014338113367557526, 0.020897241309285164, 0.06744861602783203, 0.010602330788969994, 0.023675108328461647, -0.01960737816989422, -0.0462992824614048, 0.02900794707238674, 0.010366979986429214, -0.004652549512684345, 0.0036760701332241297, 0.03217451274394989, -0.031823404133319855, -0.019158361479640007, -0.02922624535858631, 0.018908407539129257, 0.05808350443840027, 0.04495495557785034, 0.02786916308104992, 0.025745166465640068, -0.024042867124080658, -0.0004791281826328486, -0.06239330768585205, -0.006179182790219784, 0.008945216424763203, 0.03145565092563629, 0.0504179447889328, -0.06578493863344193, -0.022108787670731544, 0.035123907029628754, 0.0021881579887121916, 0.027938729152083397, 0.03632529452443123, 0.02068132534623146, 0.027092164382338524, 0.01438465341925621, -0.04956116899847984, -0.0707211047410965, 0.04681822285056114, -0.011090419255197048, 0.006980638485401869, -0.01560724712908268, -0.03136444836854935, 0.016514616087079048, 0.05895404517650604, -0.014092421159148216, -0.07021442800760269, -0.03594473376870155, -0.017114223912358284, 0.010412069037556648, 0.02519710175693035, -0.03496602550148964, 0.010653852485120296, 0.010818948969244957, 0.0636957511305809, -0.03519676998257637, 0.03187589719891548, -0.021398039534687996, -0.053955476731061935, -0.00870361365377903, -0.03149406984448433, -0.03511912748217583, 0.02159322425723076, -0.00194253318477422, -0.032183147966861725, 0.03468810021877289, -0.06251750886440277, -0.022631652653217316, -0.01448874268680811, 0.041231416165828705, -0.009525532834231853, 0.03002963215112686, -0.00991455465555191, -0.003913842141628265, -0.007702579256147146, -0.030248984694480896, 0.15415169298648834, 0.06826171278953552, -0.026331067085266113, -0.05935132876038551, 0.02980184741318226, 0.028324345126748085, 0.016907770186662674, -0.01887902058660984, -0.03790319710969925, 0.00136846664827317, -0.01761959120631218, 0.04575398191809654, 0.05041942000389099, 0.04112183302640915, -0.030916858464479446, 0.058120619505643845, -0.005005235318094492, -0.034206192940473557, -0.004187704995274544, 0.03982071205973625, -0.04657777398824692, 0.010902916081249714, -0.028674153611063957, 0.0019479175098240376, 0.025951780378818512, -0.0007041242788545787, -0.026912715286016464, -0.022333281114697456, 0.01635858044028282, 0.0032233111560344696, -0.026749620214104652, -0.005170750897377729, 0.02174689620733261, -0.029655173420906067, 0.005774914287030697, -0.02344076707959175, 0.010119793005287647, -0.037150975316762924, -0.00619379011914134, 0.04592031612992287, -0.06498924642801285, 0.005143939983099699, -0.0022542416118085384, 0.03521415591239929, -0.02875692769885063, -0.0263660978525877, -0.041967280209064484, 0.04995155707001686, 0.002986659063026309, -0.000775422842707485, 0.0039138756692409515, 0.014813111163675785, 0.0371837243437767, -0.043834373354911804, -0.013639627024531364, 0.003956738859415054, 0.020652299746870995, -0.0005110371275804937, 0.015452699735760689, -0.0462762825191021, 0.013903794810175896, 0.016611281782388687, -0.0026002381928265095, 0.049222446978092194, -0.006970875430852175, -0.006296134553849697, -0.033938221633434296, 0.055357806384563446, 0.015342269092798233, 0.001061430899426341, 0.01782456412911415, 0.030730323866009712, -0.03762049227952957, -0.004815424792468548, 0.005695217754691839, 0.0067040943540632725, 0.060325801372528076, 0.018102088943123817, -0.041452668607234955, -0.06216003745794296, -0.04421878606081009, 0.0257867518812418, -0.044836580753326416, -0.02197408676147461, -0.04927480220794678, 0.03170366957783699, 0.02114017866551876, 0.016341596841812134, 0.06620188802480698, 0.004242399707436562, -0.05191768333315849, 0.028230486437678337, 0.028856024146080017, 0.0011483104899525642, -0.050643082708120346, 0.003578317817300558, -0.04486934468150139, -0.015680326148867607, -0.00801552552729845, 0.039492249488830566, 0.011914334259927273, -0.003286204533651471, -0.019435686990618706, 0.034042976796627045, 0.015394928865134716, -0.012103150598704815, 0.029183443635702133, -0.00816864613443613, 0.04992665350437164, -0.013601739890873432, -0.022417422384023666, -0.03442254289984703, -0.02027430199086666, -0.026930946856737137, -0.04006607085466385, -0.0008170176879502833, -0.013228539377450943, -0.038244880735874176, 0.015972165390849113, -0.0018701925873756409, 0.026917031034827232, -0.029526274651288986, -0.05565962567925453, -0.05096118524670601, -0.01697068102657795, 0.001984276110306382, -0.0037352479994297028, 0.03786712512373924, -0.007602765690535307, -0.041741300374269485, 0.02346878871321678, 0.021098094061017036, 0.015531240962445736, -0.0006539369351230562, -0.05996851995587349, -0.02571682073175907, 0.017989739775657654, 0.056850630789995193, 0.03664397448301315, -0.016133906319737434, 0.0069882567040622234, -0.03331528604030609, -0.03284229338169098, -0.014892276376485825, 0.015126021578907967, 0.04219695180654526, -0.009856689721345901, 0.010676747187972069, -0.048188455402851105, 0.05217215418815613, -0.025653745979070663, -0.03237296640872955, -0.02772878110408783, 0.007787344045937061, -0.004275992512702942, -0.00522724399343133, 0.017692076042294502, -0.007195670157670975, 0.01251270342618227, 0.03077191300690174, 0.034590981900691986, -0.021841274574398994, -0.02391136810183525, 0.01559692807495594, -0.0804370567202568, 0.00792522169649601, -0.011429923586547375, -0.02849099598824978, 0.026618048548698425, 0.07323956489562988, -0.0038586347363889217, 0.05619293078780174, 0.016869857907295227, 0.01843675971031189, -0.05598977208137512, -0.011122360825538635, 0.03146982192993164, 0.017700398340821266, 0.03670878708362579, -0.04080507531762123, -0.0038291956298053265, 0.005199710372835398, -0.04332585632801056, 0.023758674040436745, -0.0013960690703243017, -0.033294614404439926, -0.021341025829315186, 0.009763210080564022, -0.017881155014038086, -0.0002920837723650038, 0.034749794751405716, 0.027691226452589035, 0.009333580732345581, 0.031607188284397125, -0.02702360600233078, -0.05745130032300949, 0.00659998320043087, 0.02110246941447258, -0.01615934632718563, -0.0817984789609909, 0.049866873770952225, -0.0012386237503960729, -0.014678283594548702, 0.010020740330219269, -0.03179590776562691, 0.034023914486169815, 0.044366829097270966, 0.03817351162433624, 0.014214101247489452, 0.06029480695724487, 0.02682454138994217, -0.013969242572784424, -0.034407444298267365, -0.03657912090420723, 0.01001475565135479, 0.012414948083460331, -0.008626481518149376, 0.020344005897641182, 0.022246651351451874, -0.005792433395981789, 0.006557171698659658, 0.035633839666843414, -0.058034539222717285, -0.014137218706309795, -0.016251038759946823, -0.008734230883419514, -0.017682870849967003, 0.002772687003016472, -0.0009389774058945477, -0.029406122863292694, 0.00733322324231267, 0.030257701873779297, 0.030063318088650703, -0.003804887644946575, 0.007515998557209969, -0.006671267561614513, -0.04628623649477959, 0.009008214809000492, 0.0003950249229092151, 0.01918061077594757, -0.04898756742477417, -0.04037421941757202, -0.04530695080757141, 0.010677853599190712, 0.0026028749998658895, 0.02546779066324234, -0.0328214168548584, 0.04587828740477562, -0.020185647532343864, 0.022777285426855087, -0.00036848513991571963, -0.031548209488391876, 0.04446585476398468, -0.05323854088783264, 0.055522896349430084, -0.00038653178489767015, 0.0015745236305519938, -0.037040844559669495, -0.03653908520936966, -0.008193261921405792, 0.026641473174095154, 0.030668992549180984, 0.013282355852425098, 0.02686980739235878, -0.03570762276649475, 0.005779629573225975, -0.01118527539074421, -0.027824383229017258, 0.033569663763046265, 0.038679733872413635, 0.0017515039071440697, 0.015629444271326065, -0.0021285819821059704, 0.016988275572657585, 0.01907912828028202, 0.024792451411485672, -0.019339272752404213, 0.03187763690948486, 0.011828014627099037, -0.0009892827365547419, 0.04430101811885834, -0.04674858599901199, 0.010584539733827114, 0.019421279430389404, 0.025595391169190407, 0.05202846601605415, 0.05014198273420334, 0.0029788189567625523, -0.0052221002988517284, 0.04742544889450073, -0.027470452710986137, -0.029084334149956703, 0.050757355988025665, 0.02280461974442005, -0.006888634525239468, -0.061862654983997345, 0.01711970940232277, -0.0025312567595392466, -0.012936562299728394, -0.018882928416132927, 0.038300156593322754, -0.02069380320608616, 0.04155166074633598, -0.06706590950489044, 0.03310225531458855, 0.022322406992316246, -0.009730580262839794, 0.04034028574824333, 0.02647988498210907, 0.0032978220842778683, 0.04230553284287453, -0.006380942650139332, 0.03116237185895443, -0.004229532089084387, 0.015441535040736198, -0.015764491632580757, 0.033718954771757126, -0.016827860847115517, -0.01541566289961338, 0.031385764479637146, -0.022734319791197777, 0.036014292389154434, 0.028413839638233185, 0.007930422201752663, 0.019836099818348885, -0.05743511766195297, 0.007897714152932167, -0.010968220420181751, -0.014275317080318928, -0.08195669203996658, 0.008344030007719994, -0.06204031780362129, -0.005663775838911533, 0.006455020047724247, 0.018035417422652245, 0.026657022535800934, -0.0026404501404613256, 0.033743225038051605, -0.019107526168227196, 0.03572729229927063, 0.015396861359477043, 0.009470831602811813, 0.031260717660188675, 0.022854937240481377, -0.027363264933228493, -0.03166158124804497, 0.03870384395122528, -0.01718089170753956, 0.00448068231344223, -0.008025877177715302, 0.021590277552604675, 0.021825747564435005, 0.004652354866266251, -0.057357460260391235, -0.05275903642177582, -0.015161635354161263, 0.014960546046495438, 0.018828939646482468, -0.012480034492909908 ]
<p>This is probably going to sound extremely stupid, but it's part of a larger question, about sample distribution of means, that I'm having problems understanding, so please bear with me.</p> <p>If I record the time between planes landing, and have 250 observations, are those 250 observations my "population", or does the term "population" refer to all the values, i.e. if I had sat there till the end of time recording?</p> <p>I'm assuming its the latter but just want to double check.</p>
74,031
[ -0.02246953919529915, -0.028507625684142113, -0.007497165817767382, -0.020693043246865273, 0.004157737363129854, 0.009990965016186237, -0.012022634968161583, -0.011916739866137505, -0.013484019786119461, -0.024156391620635986, 0.039875369518995285, 0.058214522898197174, 0.012244099751114845, 0.0030978089198470116, -0.0022374563850462437, 0.011960657313466072, -0.04719945043325424, 0.01981024257838726, 0.0005005346611142159, -0.01850065030157566, 0.011906866915524006, 0.039028726518154144, 0.01997467689216137, -0.049560293555259705, -0.06631192564964294, 0.04036317765712738, 0.02264171466231346, -0.03447564318776131, 0.007973804138600826, 0.051018912345170975, -0.06656641513109207, -0.03823097422719002, 0.022145753726363182, 0.05852297320961952, 0.03472457081079483, 0.015882661566138268, -0.02872988022863865, -0.02034544013440609, 0.01511358842253685, 0.016338320448994637, -0.025723304599523544, -0.00969709176570177, 0.021888552233576775, -0.02929370105266571, -0.014496233314275742, 0.011711726896464825, 0.019058044999837875, -0.01935351826250553, 0.027131125330924988, -0.045353639870882034, 0.09468836337327957, -0.002516410779207945, 0.023086022585630417, 0.028294311836361885, 0.005532655864953995, 0.008271797560155392, 0.04284840449690819, 0.023206349462270737, 0.00635560741648078, -0.017254170030355453, 0.018955977633595467, -0.03069330006837845, -0.02072114311158657, -0.003796981181949377, -0.005016474053263664, 0.014038278721272945, -0.0013667689636349678, -0.005224637221544981, 0.03991219028830528, 0.003697763429954648, -0.017450926825404167, -0.0038331481628119946, 0.026558028534054756, -0.00033839602838270366, 0.034020718187093735, -0.015064980834722519, 0.04243983328342438, 0.012454407289624214, 0.04173554852604866, 0.05312411114573479, 0.025446658954024315, 0.01658371277153492, 0.010545052587985992, 0.011812259443104267, 0.03930569067597389, -0.032990530133247375, 0.0959627777338028, -0.018996916711330414, 0.017724357545375824, 0.02079477347433567, 0.024306217208504677, -0.005952815525233746, 0.02815329097211361, -0.012173112481832504, -0.04199431464076042, 0.03150546923279762, -0.017208002507686615, 0.0412413515150547, -0.0005884466809220612, 0.012341246008872986, -0.007688744459301233, -0.06982209533452988, 0.038269393146038055, 0.05840061232447624, -0.04886110499501228, 0.02383335493505001, -0.07831823825836182, -0.013852089643478394, -0.000947037129662931, -0.0012078600702807307, -0.02029581181704998, 0.026710787788033485, 0.025563698261976242, -0.017608437687158585, -0.003094133222475648, 0.030041297897696495, 0.04424022138118744, -0.013090734370052814, 0.05176769942045212, 0.03167782723903656, 0.05706558749079704, -0.04737313836812973, -0.010001462884247303, -0.002110507804900408, -0.0520000196993351, 0.0056153228506445885, -0.004292100202292204, -0.01935947686433792, -0.03930266201496124, 0.027339257299900055, -0.0000928287990973331, -0.03440142050385475, 0.03778908774256706, 0.01426149532198906, 0.033045444637537, 0.01248024683445692, -0.09713123738765717, -0.04826870560646057, 0.023233473300933838, 0.010631350800395012, 0.005215947981923819, -0.0605304017663002, 0.03917909786105156, 0.012440315447747707, 0.009864699095487595, 0.01084811333566904, 0.04491891711950302, 0.002066667191684246, 0.027289707213640213, 0.017701856791973114, -0.009792097844183445, -0.005318851210176945, 0.016351550817489624, -0.040563520044088364, -0.008578535169363022, -0.07535022497177124, 0.012026656419038773, -0.000677254400216043, 0.02014407515525818, 0.0025434482377022505, 0.01980079896748066, -0.009441792964935303, 0.009716649539768696, -0.016059957444667816, 0.03178779035806656, -0.046699799597263336, 0.06283272057771683, -0.009720548056066036, 0.03097180835902691, 0.009919385425746441, 0.0013425665674731135, 0.03311442211270332, -0.013935691677033901, 0.0541825070977211, 0.05764708295464516, -0.019196396693587303, -0.011650851927697659, -0.004662571474909782, -0.013404017314314842, 0.006948642898350954, -0.045382238924503326, -0.021832196041941643, -0.003128262236714363, 0.023872852325439453, 0.03880881890654564, 0.03578482195734978, 0.014110556803643703, -0.022933004423975945, 0.021740755066275597, -0.05096516013145447, -0.008233658969402313, -0.06867031008005142, -0.007871738635003567, -0.026631440967321396, -0.03377186134457588, -0.005293966270983219, -0.016879137605428696, -0.004260812886059284, -0.058207958936691284, -0.029069850221276283, -0.014184552244842052, -0.01725088432431221, 0.052404217422008514, -0.07197289168834686, -0.013872146606445312, 0.06538005918264389, -0.0016140809748321772, 0.012891299091279507, 0.050901491194963455, -0.006182499695569277, -0.0252434853464365, -0.000662203470710665, -0.014980786480009556, 0.006694807671010494, -0.011694028973579407, -0.0006666685803793371, 0.004781704396009445, 0.020298883318901062, -0.016555866226553917, 0.037967681884765625, -0.05748330429196358, 0.06184155121445656, 0.05986656993627548, -0.00878851767629385, 0.01538178138434887, -0.008363976143300533, 0.004616946447640657, 0.006276254076510668, -0.00842974241822958, 0.006957505363970995, -0.0684615820646286, -0.0069960858672857285, 0.022067241370677948, -0.0332576259970665, -0.02208660915493965, 0.01444901991635561, 0.054975103586912155, 0.021169966086745262, 0.029251521453261375, -0.014985138550400734, 0.04574347659945488, -0.020050063729286194, 0.009415651671588421, 0.010597387328743935, 0.01156972162425518, -0.00191274203825742, 0.04700397700071335, -0.009545833803713322, 0.029567332938313484, -0.00959811732172966, 0.002872919663786888, 0.017095953226089478, 0.016392746940255165, 0.02660677582025528, -0.032929450273513794, 0.006926044821739197, 0.01311113778501749, -0.007122797891497612, -0.011994227766990662, 0.03271138295531273, 0.017800631001591682, -0.02087755873799324, 0.024244491010904312, -0.05238661915063858, -0.004756857641041279, 0.04951934516429901, -0.038001686334609985, -0.017851801589131355, 0.018387969583272934, -0.022808484733104706, 0.021629832684993744, -0.015379364602267742, -0.05674475431442261, -0.016409264877438545, 0.012861358933150768, 0.0477263517677784, -0.012517526745796204, 0.035980939865112305, -0.02860495075583458, -0.007386217825114727, -0.019250448793172836, -0.02498968504369259, 0.005776542704552412, -0.008875560015439987, -0.07277505099773407, 0.0061348918825387955, 0.004066196270287037, -0.03640228882431984, 0.005208796821534634, -0.01007248368114233, -0.016796449199318886, 0.033290401101112366, -0.05035269260406494, -0.031096460297703743, -0.023214222863316536, -0.029600851237773895, -0.020582422614097595, -0.02777979150414467, -0.014900312758982182, 0.05441181734204292, 0.005501870531588793, -0.009567196480929852, 0.05537604168057442, -0.08402025699615479, -0.03929980844259262, -0.0342811681330204, 0.002672620350494981, 0.027378501370549202, -0.041819605976343155, 0.0056639621034264565, 0.01277516782283783, 0.009700199589133263, -0.034779760986566544, -0.04674452170729637, -0.03909222036600113, 0.006505866069346666, -0.006330542266368866, 0.037658073008060455, 0.013501261360943317, -0.002112683141604066, 0.06712107360363007, 0.040737394243478775, -0.005389292258769274, 0.0064179375767707825, -0.000017055355783668347, 0.00791205558925867, -0.0022225629072636366, 0.05036299303174019, 0.0009184652590192854, -0.017675774171948433, -0.009850947186350822, 0.008120954968035221, 0.009840566664934158, 0.030809525400400162, 0.00524277426302433, 0.007470708340406418, -0.003910309635102749, 0.008327045477926731, 0.027322107926011086, 0.07052125036716461, 0.04985813423991203, -0.051932718604803085, 0.006034227553755045, -0.014961633831262589, 0.04975332319736481, 0.026568863540887833, -0.05891718342900276, 0.02308798022568226, -0.02400335669517517, 0.004404627252370119, -0.007074679248034954, 0.039578478783369064, -0.010427831672132015, -0.058390628546476364, -0.02734612300992012, 0.01592477597296238, 0.016988391056656837, -0.01580633781850338, -0.027979161590337753, 0.029879461973905563, 0.033128395676612854, -0.05853533372282982, -0.018139192834496498, -0.0035114216152578592, -0.011480431072413921, 0.012146775610744953, -0.0039664157666265965, -0.015487901866436005, 0.023912634700536728, 0.0444868728518486, -0.019188452512025833, -0.0006910684169270098, -0.040466852486133575, -0.011150801554322243, -0.08319252729415894, 0.008486898615956306, 0.006063767708837986, 0.05514839291572571, -0.015534985810518265, 0.06362149119377136, -0.0026183368172496557, 0.0009399830014444888, 0.004539091140031815, 0.024753395467996597, -0.043169401586055756, 0.0020648776553571224, -0.0062927198596298695, -0.046165235340595245, -0.032696954905986786, -0.05805836245417595, 0.051182035356760025, -0.010987890884280205, 0.020775122568011284, -0.009983307681977749, 0.013960265554487705, -0.01664283126592636, 0.008493011817336082, -0.025205040350556374, -0.05257026478648186, -0.002279988257214427, 0.03480197861790657, 0.008991709910333157, -0.0010501279029995203, 0.043354280292987823, 0.01052895188331604, 0.004504953511059284, -0.02974582649767399, -0.0054607391357421875, -0.034890733659267426, 0.004722481593489647, 0.03167809918522835, 0.01365188043564558, 0.006212727632373571, -0.07495275884866714, 0.049659088253974915, 0.007461983244866133, 0.04000423103570938, 0.02053387090563774, -0.025122137740254402, -0.013861538842320442, -0.029459651559591293, -0.023978738114237785, 0.03175950422883034, 0.00994070339947939, -0.012042611837387085, -0.03272160887718201, 0.012715854682028294, 0.001200107391923666, -0.03125305101275444, 0.024866178631782532, 0.0041517224162817, -0.016883892938494682, 0.022258855402469635, -0.033304449170827866, 0.014679595828056335, -0.023840945214033127, 0.008020002394914627, -0.0036692353896796703, 0.0008976910030469298, 0.01752248778939247, -0.0032846468966454268, 0.03012765757739544, 0.009133181534707546, -0.04167705029249191, 0.036860231310129166, 0.01945500448346138, 0.0029084032867103815, -0.0170309878885746, -0.0053701987490057945, 0.02869212068617344, 0.05067714303731918, 0.007883601821959019, 0.04260457679629326, 0.006440107244998217, -0.07903137803077698, 0.0033806755673140287, 0.02890821173787117, 0.01346521731466055, -0.043007202446460724, -0.0033221577759832144, -0.04278234764933586, -0.0007380652823485434, -0.009280010126531124, 0.001252288930118084, 0.03245270252227783, -0.02393212355673313, 0.010486648418009281, 0.0029511384200304747, -0.030394479632377625, -0.03304092586040497, -0.0012998889433220029, -0.005383032374083996, 0.012761333957314491, 0.014654763974249363, 0.00016608524310868233, -0.02211611159145832, 0.00829168688505888, 0.0449201874434948, 0.060909271240234375, -0.023256666958332062, 0.018279867246747017, 0.008749798871576786, 0.007989763282239437, -0.017308739945292473, -0.05003280192613602, 0.018004190176725388, -0.002064841566607356, 0.027260219678282738, 0.04083775728940964, 0.021765699610114098, -0.04812858626246452, 0.009446587413549423, 0.027147730812430382, 0.011339874938130379, -0.035011958330869675, -0.03546258807182312, 0.043377988040447235, 0.039718084037303925, 0.012621761299669743, 0.032305922359228134, 0.03884567692875862, 0.020829999819397926, 0.010605921968817711, -0.01320895366370678, 0.036719124764204025, -0.05119810253381729, -0.0231374129652977, -0.031201092526316643, -0.012138471938669682, -0.035926152020692825, 0.020331835374236107, -0.0008217779686674476, -0.006810010876506567, -0.0485154464840889, -0.05514313280582428, 0.01966831274330616, 0.00803106464445591, 0.040785837918519974, 0.03185325860977173, -0.03484705090522766, 0.018040794879198074, 0.019483178853988647, -0.037014223635196686, 0.00924775842577219, -0.014142145402729511, 0.005737085826694965, 0.010374742560088634, -0.020256847143173218, -0.00867652241140604, -0.050080325454473495, -0.028199980035424232, 0.0308389812707901, -0.023830056190490723, 0.03157199174165726, -0.016712861135601997, 0.030929990112781525, 0.03374543786048889, -0.0429583378136158, -0.03482329472899437, 0.006316054612398148, -0.019799139350652695, 0.022588910534977913, -0.0572173185646534, 0.04298422485589981, -0.0045278025791049, 0.032648131251335144, -0.09549278020858765, -0.05396091192960739, 0.022005543112754822, -0.000006518770533148199, -0.01838688552379608, -0.048956822603940964, 0.0035372357815504074, 0.0006737224757671356, -0.03276009112596512, -0.026424793526530266, 0.046924907714128494, -0.042961686849594116, -0.01618640124797821, -0.018988704308867455, 0.012606952339410782, 0.10590571165084839, -0.002384446794167161, -0.03617893159389496, 0.021865179762244225, 0.014155124314129353, -0.020469646900892258, -0.026005754247307777, 0.00580606609582901, -0.02392597869038582, 0.012997171841561794, 0.015298466198146343, -0.013410256244242191, 0.01636316068470478, -0.028325771912932396, -0.000052415842219488695, 0.015036419034004211, -0.018906379118561745, 0.014157786965370178, -0.02280512824654579, -0.002201358089223504, 0.010082771070301533, -0.017131894826889038, -0.047853630036115646, 0.021367423236370087, 0.048093196004629135, 0.004254494793713093, 0.04845527186989784, 0.032262612134218216, -0.014154886826872826, 0.025254515931010246, 0.07532938569784164, 0.01120374258607626, -0.011913029477000237, -0.02059379778802395, -0.02734864316880703, 0.022372493520379066, 0.013045057654380798, -0.03768964111804962, 0.03617987036705017, 0.004448664840310812, -0.016896793618798256, 0.01089475303888321, -0.03812700882554054, -0.006110304035246372, 0.05255114287137985, 0.0385633260011673, 0.028293121606111526, 0.045551616698503494, 0.021365517750382423, 0.04932837933301926, -0.0287269726395607, 0.008068934082984924, -0.0018291727174073458, 0.009254887700080872, 0.030820418149232864, -0.0031319744884967804, -0.0064704823307693005, -0.008816021494567394, 0.016981614753603935, 0.04035622254014015, 0.029193593189120293, 0.030817145481705666, 0.002347364788874984, 0.01179188396781683, -0.015020729042589664, -0.055384665727615356, 0.0236602034419775, -0.0254732146859169, -0.00012888890341855586, -0.027364885434508324, -0.003200702602043748, 0.042522039264440536, 0.0362401157617569, 0.02859569899737835, -0.05894080176949501, 0.005415747407823801, -0.020497344434261322, -0.026845736429095268, 0.006887330673635006, 0.018756521865725517, 0.024779440835118294, -0.033016644418239594, 0.039162736386060715, -0.013966669328510761, -0.022784126922488213, 0.01317508239299059, -0.01779247634112835, -0.0208212211728096, -0.02659471705555916, -0.07001303136348724, 0.026420915499329567, -0.018342802301049232, -0.015290291048586369, -0.0078064436092972755, -0.009951882064342499, -0.006124842446297407, 0.0005279362085275352, 0.017567044124007225, -0.029311593621969223, 0.04170394688844681, 0.04263013228774071, 0.017932696267962456, -0.041256293654441833, -0.01881415583193302, 0.12335469573736191, 0.037364501506090164, 0.025455940514802933, -0.008360777981579304, 0.000544260605238378, -0.008784877136349678, 0.041799720376729965, -0.020434269681572914, -0.026595262810587883, -0.025363314896821976, 0.01730920560657978, 0.07937969267368317, 0.024576308205723763, 0.012083298526704311, -0.0025245677679777145, 0.05460407957434654, 0.010890965349972248, 0.0030043944716453552, -0.01008677389472723, 0.006064310669898987, -0.019079454243183136, 0.022312605753540993, -0.033685337752103806, 0.047003891319036484, 0.004946253728121519, -0.007371255196630955, -0.04337183013558388, -0.030252881348133087, -0.029692955315113068, 0.018808139488101006, -0.042139049619436264, 0.01462335605174303, 0.033039722591638565, -0.014957473613321781, -0.02452157996594906, -0.008635356090962887, -0.0063246749341487885, -0.03824556991457939, -0.0054088616743683815, 0.04340697079896927, -0.03426424786448479, 0.0190155990421772, -0.026530589908361435, 0.011899212375283241, -0.059790462255477905, 0.003109879791736603, -0.02551235817372799, 0.04787961021065712, 0.0027991312090307474, 0.003443884663283825, -0.018749184906482697, -0.020318767055869102, -0.007582508027553558, -0.0427587628364563, -0.005933049600571394, 0.029042184352874756, -0.005986516363918781, -0.004835375584661961, -0.06546137481927872, -0.02073085680603981, 0.005577614065259695, 0.0019315178506076336, -0.056112129241228104, 0.033552926033735275, -0.0107429726049304, -0.010458920150995255, -0.04514522850513458, -0.000009005333595268894, -0.011145167052745819, -0.0010498522315174341, -0.028897175565361977, -0.016688933596014977, -0.06408201903104782, -0.005877106450498104, 0.04242977872490883, 0.011077042669057846, 0.02559133805334568, 0.005824443884193897, -0.03810245171189308, -0.04255174845457077, -0.0165927242487669, 0.04460080340504646, -0.0029562131967395544, -0.023394504562020302, -0.03371122479438782, -0.018846707418560982, 0.0018828711472451687, 0.06489960104227066, 0.01917368359863758, 0.026976129040122032, 0.005519427824765444, 0.06791246682405472, -0.01816084049642086, -0.03916521742939949, 0.005806172266602516, 0.04830778017640114, -0.04277339577674866, 0.014419720508158207, -0.008088433183729649, 0.05938848480582237, 0.02242063172161579, -0.005566628649830818, 0.01966605894267559, 0.03001393750309944, 0.015194431878626347, 0.03754836693406105, -0.01309952326118946, -0.044922832399606705, 0.033414412289857864, 0.045803867280483246, 0.019758766517043114, -0.02633368968963623, -0.02809888869524002, -0.03479957953095436, 0.026104377582669258, -0.005633671302348375, -0.031134676188230515, 0.027595719322562218, 0.03155536577105522, -0.005995855201035738, 0.016432469710707664, 0.03749518468976021, -0.01894933544099331, -0.04827989265322685, -0.016150619834661484, -0.01765402965247631, 0.002339777769520879, -0.029005125164985657, -0.02796337939798832, 0.02379068359732628, 0.006857749540358782, 0.025964047759771347, 0.0015346254222095013, -0.01957692578434944, -0.008111592382192612, 0.012913975864648819, 0.013104229234158993, 0.014224973507225513, -0.012089907191693783, 0.005510310176759958, 0.048582930117845535, -0.02045631967484951, -0.035230934619903564, 0.04169972613453865, 0.0691627562046051, 0.03976845368742943, 0.043840814381837845, 0.016124172136187553, -0.00481996638700366, 0.035969529300928116, -0.02244679257273674, -0.04967672377824783, -0.04996807500720024, -0.011427192017436028, 0.024365533143281937, 0.011748215183615685, 0.013066752813756466, 0.01247606985270977, -0.006226351950317621, 0.014503346756100655, 0.03275873512029648, -0.0146035086363554, -0.0028200491797178984, -0.014514170587062836, 0.01546213123947382, 0.012934781610965729, 0.006514973472803831, 0.015063691884279251, 0.0516071617603302, 0.028136130422353745, -0.042505621910095215, 0.012878365814685822, -0.005017796065658331, 0.0036147376522421837, -0.08817567676305771, -0.03002804145216942, 0.013068453408777714, 0.013570120558142662, 0.04852694272994995, -0.02156693860888481, -0.05774391070008278, 0.05249297618865967, -0.07371882349252701, 0.012719954364001751, 0.007735803723335266, -0.007972588762640953, -0.04835767671465874, 0.045576151460409164, -0.006252232473343611, 0.03575648367404938, -0.009587639011442661, 0.043787725269794464, 0.03452889621257782, 0.03490234538912773, 0.017552753910422325, -0.025361865758895874, 0.0062431879341602325, 0.013596751727163792, 0.036040112376213074, -0.04253353923559189, 0.033499013632535934, -0.06064650043845177, -0.00740297045558691, 0.05679844319820404, 0.008762129582464695, 0.03204898163676262, 0.013374008238315582, 0.02561141364276409, 0.026816481724381447, 0.022261153906583786, 0.024748319759964943, -0.004658333491533995, 0.002944768639281392, 0.021936042234301567, 0.011045579798519611, 0.039628855884075165, -0.012144247069954872, -0.03441441059112549, 0.0505465567111969, -0.01702822744846344, -0.0325913168489933, 0.04341629147529602, 0.011590098030865192, -0.007457659114152193, 0.012164996936917305, 0.006145295687019825, -0.03435279056429863, -0.011255436576902866, 0.03996530920267105, -0.04007953405380249, 0.0536261685192585, 0.04936347156763077, -0.018925681710243225, -0.03657875582575798, 0.02106446400284767, 0.007359619252383709, -0.022627055644989014, -0.01863747462630272, 0.001612912630662322, 0.003028168808668852, -0.03026772104203701, -0.04157065600156784, -0.013039193116128445, -0.017638999968767166, 0.0028207171708345413, 0.021363457664847374, -0.06342039257287979, -0.01721133477985859, 0.024839580059051514, 0.011922952719032764, 0.002381980651989579, -0.03495638817548752, -0.0003938768641091883, -0.08258020132780075, 0.0875692144036293, 0.023790771141648293, 0.027872208505868912, -0.09588416665792465, -0.04049330949783325, -0.03214406967163086, 0.02104584500193596, 0.056707289069890976, 0.05788758397102356, 0.024947047233581543, -0.0014955552760511637, -0.009254601784050465, 0.04533615708351135, -0.05310012772679329, 0.033646102994680405, -0.006052522454410791, -0.06000340357422829, -0.03261275589466095, -0.02604159712791443, -0.018309585750102997, -0.024713117629289627, 0.03559396043419838, -0.0210895836353302, 0.029319508001208305, -0.03514999896287918, -0.008232937194406986, 0.06354771554470062, 0.032741978764534, 0.0029158906545490026, 0.02650308609008789, -0.02889871783554554, -0.007538548205047846, 0.05037746578454971, -0.030051521956920624, -0.0666191428899765, 0.025500547140836716, -0.015114267356693745, -0.0030616074800491333, 0.01347743347287178, 0.016522882506251335, 0.0013900244375690818, 0.0011200207518413663, 0.028431570157408714, 0.0056991176679730415, -0.0542927160859108, -0.003779588732868433, 0.0579356774687767, 0.01309796143323183, 0.045681312680244446, -0.06937646865844727, 0.039113759994506836, -0.01562873274087906, -0.058532703667879105, 0.021512910723686218, 0.013557936064898968, 0.007866984233260155, -0.011266435496509075, 0.017039567232131958, 0.014410595409572124, 0.008071674033999443, 0.028955398127436638, 0.021122407168149948, 0.03413725644350052, -0.01265106163918972, -0.0018619195325300097, 0.013312563300132751, 0.0029020884539932013, 0.021356182172894478, 0.035832203924655914, -0.014680875465273857, 0.07477816939353943, -0.00484258821234107, 0.014005397446453571, -0.0614955835044384, -0.03269249573349953, -0.04315991699695587, -0.049265168607234955, 0.006108250934630632, 0.03232128918170929, -0.013766337186098099, -0.003394261235371232, -0.033486079424619675, 0.02368372119963169, 0.011485566385090351, -0.05667483061552048, 0.050829268991947174, -0.010231289081275463, 0.041212234646081924, -0.03993960842490196, -0.017437024042010307, 0.0038824512157589197, -0.0030863238498568535, 0.054854586720466614, 0.022769523784518242, 0.0002530100173316896, -0.0011552008800208569, 0.0042054178193211555, -0.041142940521240234, 0.011874305084347725, -0.06860026717185974, -0.045737046748399734, -0.04831550642848015, 0.03865017741918564, 0.006271527148783207, -0.03177027404308319 ]
<p>I don't know a lot about sampling methods. </p> <p>I have a large population of size 2,000,000. I used one of those sample size calculators. It says that I need sample size of approximately 10,000.</p> <p>I am trying to find the probability <strong>p</strong> of success for the population. It is not feasible for me to test all 2,000,000 members of the population. That is why I am sampling.</p> <p>I assume that the sample size calculator means a simple random sample without replacement. I have read that a simple random sample with replacement ensures that the covariance between two variables is 0<strike>, i.e., independent</strike>. </p> <p>When should one choose with replacement instead of without replacement?</p> <p>If we sample with replacement, then we are simply performing Bernoulli trials. I suppose this makes applying statistical tools (which?) easier.</p> <p>Again, sampling ignoramus here.</p>
74,032
[ -0.011772174388170242, -0.044305361807346344, 0.018221598118543625, -0.02067440003156662, 0.06759544461965561, -0.03226730599999428, -0.01711154542863369, -0.051532816141843796, 0.004349878989160061, -0.02567479945719242, 0.03864544630050659, 0.0490402914583683, 0.06066371873021126, 0.010059747844934464, 0.028030388057231903, 0.02316095679998398, -0.024436431005597115, -0.0070917545817792416, -0.007325474638491869, -0.0003490092058200389, -0.009711731225252151, -0.003245154395699501, 0.03267206996679306, -0.003924897871911526, -0.03663522005081177, 0.028158044442534447, 0.015354077331721783, -0.014829843305051327, 0.014550616964697838, 0.0627206563949585, -0.07713218778371811, -0.03246830403804779, 0.005658261943608522, 0.0675133764743805, 0.04138101264834404, 0.0036309370771050453, -0.023932524025440216, -0.05640857294201851, 0.0023181820288300514, 0.03100302629172802, -0.04210737720131874, 0.003493481781333685, 0.02694791369140148, 0.004200228489935398, -0.013422844931483269, 0.01771528460085392, -0.01704132929444313, -0.06641995906829834, 0.015821563079953194, -0.037675440311431885, 0.039317574352025986, 0.0028905505314469337, 0.035909075289964676, 0.021472714841365814, -0.018825924023985863, -0.05334959551692009, 0.051733724772930145, 0.04289381206035614, -0.036241307854652405, -0.003927063196897507, 0.025436291471123695, -0.014099590480327606, -0.0023001532536000013, -0.017490403726696968, -0.03848433494567871, 0.021807832643389702, -0.015626415610313416, -0.00658524502068758, 0.033943090587854385, 0.00010446579108247533, 0.03409840166568756, 0.019207432866096497, 0.011724866926670074, -0.020869120955467224, 0.0199351254850626, -0.02303558588027954, 0.029865823686122894, 0.0351237878203392, 0.027763914316892624, 0.07190454751253128, 0.0077043077908456326, 0.012922870926558971, 0.043062154203653336, 0.024775197729468346, 0.01795182377099991, -0.037433940917253494, 0.039353907108306885, -0.030488405376672745, 0.025833528488874435, -0.017152220010757446, 0.002344964537769556, -0.01583431474864483, 0.05119859799742699, 0.004675689153373241, -0.014039755798876286, 0.026508809998631477, -0.03294708579778671, 0.05928415432572365, -0.013237384147942066, 0.012615397572517395, -0.017032440751791, -0.06331027299165726, 0.02326739951968193, 0.051449790596961975, -0.021038934588432312, -0.0012119050370529294, 0.010862991213798523, -0.01203230582177639, -0.02535148523747921, -0.04867493361234665, -0.026744505390524864, 0.035376548767089844, 0.00046233038301579654, 0.01321730762720108, 0.04380843788385391, -0.012392295524477959, -0.00606257189065218, 0.004830475430935621, 0.0655975267291069, 0.05521760880947113, 0.029209604486823082, -0.005948065780103207, 0.02168421447277069, -0.0300117339938879, -0.036255672574043274, 0.03566338121891022, 0.011433917097747326, -0.0032086053397506475, -0.04454398527741432, 0.03063538856804371, -0.015350742265582085, -0.021332349628210068, 0.03198564052581787, 0.025693019852042198, 0.0276941005140543, -0.011521188542246819, -0.07564449310302734, -0.015720665454864502, 0.03356161713600159, -0.02660582773387432, -0.01866445131599903, -0.09757664799690247, 0.0416579432785511, 0.0005786116234958172, 0.030862729996442795, -0.007639565039426088, 0.06063639000058174, -0.01957659423351288, 0.017780661582946777, 0.02044392190873623, -0.027572378516197205, -0.003444080473855138, -0.04362732172012329, -0.009496357291936874, -0.021187057718634605, -0.08094105869531631, 0.027091342955827713, 0.004310364834964275, -0.001145675778388977, -0.02944338321685791, 0.0019012675620615482, 0.0014748838730156422, -0.012585164979100227, -0.020257525146007538, 0.024921702221035957, -0.02305585891008377, 0.07725538313388824, 0.010142658837139606, 0.01893451437354088, 0.012583201751112938, 0.011534239165484905, 0.038458485156297684, 0.015865091234445572, -0.002063195686787367, 0.03136158362030983, -0.02293870970606804, 0.0004759757430292666, -0.008329027332365513, 0.007025182247161865, 0.043110962957143784, -0.044337280094623566, -0.03348323330283165, -0.019323550164699554, -0.005918165668845177, 0.011871414259076118, 0.06096763536334038, 0.055395908653736115, 0.003179025836288929, 0.023618238046765327, -0.03167125955224037, -0.09173154085874557, -0.10000679641962051, 0.01771635189652443, -0.0013581033563241363, -0.030878784134984016, 0.015250246040523052, 0.0021794941276311874, 0.028408095240592957, -0.011271893978118896, -0.0014433993492275476, -0.0420280359685421, -0.015870166942477226, 0.029918184503912926, -0.04158275946974754, 0.0020556177478283644, 0.07035885751247406, 0.03109828196465969, -0.030043326318264008, 0.06592417508363724, -0.024187825620174408, -0.024137478321790695, -0.023854464292526245, -0.025381948798894882, -0.0008562454604543746, 0.014662503264844418, -0.053338728845119476, 0.022326594218611717, 0.018297014757990837, -0.002359675243496895, 0.06934890896081924, -0.05139969289302826, 0.0679086223244667, 0.06953117996454239, 0.005320717114955187, -0.00425393832847476, 0.027639899402856827, 0.01293590385466814, -0.0184798464179039, 0.0029177586548030376, -0.00265557412058115, -0.08890865743160248, 0.03089885227382183, 0.04201747104525566, -0.013623427599668503, -0.02519024908542633, -0.010980786755681038, 0.058733806014060974, 0.008079670369625092, -0.004746878519654274, 0.023268792778253555, 0.006858297158032656, -0.029063943773508072, 0.0020370925776660442, 0.031462885439395905, 0.017879992723464966, 0.006760606542229652, -0.0029915799386799335, 0.014884303323924541, 0.05741133913397789, 0.004685420077294111, -0.02548903413116932, 0.028615299612283707, -0.029338708147406578, 0.01727757230401039, -0.012292840518057346, -0.023906445130705833, 0.028972197324037552, 0.0032006686087697744, 0.029472971335053444, 0.0501110777258873, 0.041131410747766495, 0.006672619841992855, -0.016071569174528122, -0.024782197549939156, 0.019592085853219032, 0.0015664241509512067, -0.020826134830713272, -0.007580445148050785, 0.01776258461177349, -0.03230241313576698, -0.010336138308048248, 0.006841321941465139, -0.03448969125747681, -0.029246417805552483, -0.006048502400517464, 0.0067655593156814575, 0.0188220776617527, 0.027264423668384552, -0.008601115085184574, -0.03422533720731735, 0.01216977834701538, 0.00037345124292187393, -0.022392580285668373, 0.023732243105769157, -0.0688476487994194, -0.030944764614105225, -0.035373032093048096, -0.020761746913194656, 0.04314305633306503, 0.018992409110069275, -0.0020709887612611055, 0.02048027515411377, 0.0036681354977190495, -0.04921198636293411, -0.0067373220808804035, -0.020525824278593063, -0.0003293841436970979, -0.042729515582323074, -0.024248996749520302, 0.08988867700099945, 0.052209965884685516, -0.04046579450368881, 0.029915140941739082, -0.05620652437210083, -0.042087506502866745, -0.03574583679437637, -0.012760495766997337, 0.020529264584183693, -0.03829960152506828, -0.011068714782595634, 0.030741356313228607, 0.01130762416869402, -0.005502423737198114, -0.047000277787446976, -0.07569988071918488, -0.013635401614010334, 0.022504400461912155, 0.03271399065852165, -0.0007248639594763517, -0.030521079897880554, 0.06821917742490768, 0.037768442183732986, -0.012588301673531532, -0.00565261859446764, 0.010517627000808716, -0.020345717668533325, -0.008739126846194267, 0.005645317491143942, 0.0011309041874483228, -0.032266490161418915, -0.024201730266213417, -0.00928608700633049, 0.03713887557387352, 0.034240271896123886, 0.017572863027453423, 0.003431163262575865, -0.007533822674304247, 0.011120336130261421, 0.02484012208878994, 0.036980681121349335, 0.00031010949169285595, -0.05416857451200485, 0.029895903542637825, 0.008439240977168083, 0.025754312053322792, 0.02840975672006607, -0.04976847395300865, 0.014922398142516613, -0.028489690274000168, 0.009830593131482601, -0.029345249757170677, 0.038858894258737564, 0.019710280001163483, -0.06600528210401535, 0.019972601905465126, -0.002747020684182644, 0.034874118864536285, -0.023820918053388596, -0.01192077249288559, 0.02999616041779518, 0.025903724133968353, -0.005524276290088892, -0.009027448482811451, -0.04488404840230942, -0.01910417713224888, -0.011235170997679234, 0.002112223533913493, 0.006895743310451508, 0.02982000820338726, 0.08794789761304855, 0.029072513803839684, -0.0028018273878842592, -0.009548819623887539, 0.0181508120149374, -0.04667872563004494, 0.0005161060835234821, -0.020221352577209473, 0.05787793919444084, -0.03135381266474724, 0.045788150280714035, 0.020299965515732765, -0.00610171677544713, 0.007921057753264904, 0.03158767521381378, -0.04776398837566376, 0.054064031690359116, -0.03146485611796379, -0.04647063836455345, 0.04293302074074745, -0.013819053769111633, 0.01638226956129074, 0.027010248973965645, 0.013862218707799911, -0.02311726287007332, 0.029104821383953094, -0.029136385768651962, 0.0037458434235304594, -0.010358241386711597, 0.022382715716958046, 0.016280576586723328, 0.0478181466460228, 0.023411335423588753, 0.006473212037235498, 0.01895764097571373, 0.054566871374845505, -0.00526594091206789, 0.005652799271047115, -0.01502954214811325, 0.030600380152463913, 0.03077489323914051, 0.05588248372077942, 0.02901742048561573, 0.05078569054603577, -0.029625356197357178, -0.0018317268695682287, -0.012020688503980637, 0.037682536989450455, 0.034492116421461105, 0.025942351669073105, -0.013744628988206387, -0.07203381508588791, -0.007767453324049711, 0.010191046632826328, 0.012186167761683464, -0.006834352854639292, -0.028606977313756943, 0.08373341709375381, 0.00735241686925292, -0.022704999893903732, 0.013880343176424503, 0.0800468921661377, 0.0018762461841106415, 0.007499567233026028, -0.008983594365417957, 0.0018543130718171597, -0.010540725663304329, 0.001518100150860846, 0.012025179341435432, 0.03276317939162254, -0.03340468555688858, -0.013343585655093193, 0.033558327704668045, -0.010920358821749687, -0.03251112625002861, 0.03519069030880928, -0.023898979648947716, 0.019121315330266953, 0.007080733776092529, -0.05095716938376427, 0.02819078043103218, -0.00819061417132616, 0.0067855073139071465, 0.018266545608639717, -0.0034422397147864103, -0.03979696333408356, 0.024683203548192978, 0.05332794412970543, 0.057506028562784195, -0.0629153922200203, 0.004072610288858414, -0.033510901033878326, -0.03921099752187729, 0.022533006966114044, -0.06410049647092819, -0.023140359669923782, -0.015537616796791553, -0.0008076148224063218, -0.03794160485267639, -0.034768469631671906, -0.026573840528726578, 0.030394336208701134, -0.03514895960688591, 0.026603661477565765, -0.010223493911325932, -0.005563210695981979, -0.005734764505177736, -0.01573239639401436, 0.013498939573764801, 0.06937357783317566, -0.054328132420778275, -0.014761112630367279, 0.02287079393863678, -0.0057632881216704845, -0.020587392151355743, -0.06467480957508087, -0.0010809184750542045, -0.025403643026947975, -0.020325016230344772, 0.0235704705119133, -0.01880425214767456, -0.058661479502916336, 0.03927244246006012, -0.00043301115510985255, 0.01017201691865921, 0.0046065133064985275, -0.053579118102788925, -0.00010651619959389791, 0.0174117274582386, 0.027958756312727928, 0.06909943372011185, 0.00778419803828001, -0.009725292213261127, 0.0003596773894969374, -0.001062876544892788, -0.01772013120353222, -0.022390145808458328, -0.024444833397865295, -0.073360376060009, 0.0033635643776506186, -0.008738675154745579, 0.026630232110619545, 0.00760608958080411, 0.006183390039950609, -0.03626029193401337, -0.038608368486166, 0.011055531911551952, 0.028874753043055534, 0.007808243855834007, 0.03851770982146263, -0.034818634390830994, 0.05687860772013664, -0.030072247609496117, 0.008494915440678596, 0.033592794090509415, -0.00245686830021441, -0.006332317367196083, 0.007619072683155537, -0.024442365393042564, -0.002617807127535343, -0.088241808116436, -0.0262686125934124, 0.03649766370654106, -0.06198706477880478, 0.0595465824007988, -0.0027175378054380417, 0.06301721930503845, -0.011687389574944973, -0.05580124631524086, -0.041291244328022, 0.030123787000775337, 0.01279685739427805, 0.030947700142860413, -0.04158812016248703, 0.029220255091786385, -0.009980968199670315, 0.011173252947628498, -0.057308923453092575, -0.08115879446268082, 0.02071932889521122, 0.029397819191217422, 0.0027543457690626383, -0.003448356641456485, -0.038945652544498444, 0.00765613466501236, -0.02016357146203518, -0.03721080720424652, 0.028164613991975784, 0.020854275673627853, -0.014234861359000206, 0.004589073359966278, 0.006088274531066418, 0.07514481246471405, -0.011352703906595707, -0.0004571937315631658, 0.029184630140662193, -0.050177816301584244, -0.003951904829591513, -0.012115142308175564, 0.00942294206470251, -0.02272503264248371, -0.03805246204137802, -0.029094809666275978, 0.0012195189483463764, 0.03396223485469818, -0.030995085835456848, -0.03163302317261696, 0.0028369566425681114, -0.03271870315074921, -0.0055693574249744415, -0.024212153628468513, -0.008244420401751995, 0.016778171062469482, 0.044303882867097855, -0.04228590428829193, 0.009825114160776138, 0.005399276968091726, -0.004244155716150999, 0.03642456606030464, 0.02471776492893696, -0.01940280571579933, 0.03295627608895302, 0.027246873825788498, -0.023611459881067276, 0.03817679360508919, 0.0014911926118656993, -0.03769798204302788, 0.03744244575500488, 0.014729028567671776, -0.030726246535778046, -0.0019823729526251554, 0.00285937893204391, -0.021434133872389793, -0.03959834948182106, -0.026732346042990685, 0.023401526734232903, 0.05196380615234375, -0.02426564320921898, 0.014513988047838211, 0.01670464128255844, -0.0030326098203659058, 0.0452561154961586, -0.009295839816331863, -0.00479825958609581, -0.04917434975504875, 0.0015747076831758022, 0.026805700734257698, 0.009855573996901512, -0.0015549826202914119, 0.0757957324385643, 0.03408182039856911, 0.029462117701768875, 0.022176844999194145, 0.040824975818395615, 0.0036420493852347136, -0.0015488405479118228, -0.02666715532541275, -0.015701524913311005, 0.010716049931943417, -0.07334994524717331, 0.0005507732857950032, -0.027743861079216003, -0.019271479919552803, 0.058332379907369614, 0.02927253767848015, 0.01870678924024105, 0.005371151491999626, -0.013538382016122341, -0.02987663447856903, -0.006777829024940729, 0.005441679153591394, 0.008028367534279823, 0.022435173392295837, -0.004237836692482233, 0.02390947937965393, -0.009762270376086235, 0.04872264713048935, -0.012727200984954834, -0.04885732755064964, -0.05338679254055023, -0.0016599057707935572, -0.054015640169382095, 0.022417334839701653, -0.0032649249769747257, -0.00892286840826273, 0.018376335501670837, -0.020952139049768448, 0.01766284368932247, 0.013736564666032791, 0.04270036146044731, -0.03186829388141632, 0.08188465237617493, 0.05165144428610802, 0.013725432567298412, -0.0004918549675494432, 0.021626031026244164, 0.1279672384262085, 0.04983644559979439, 0.035520561039447784, -0.06109778210520744, 0.01734715886414051, -0.022470518946647644, -0.009061958640813828, -0.012274390086531639, 0.010741300880908966, 0.023273123428225517, -0.012934427708387375, 0.046928755939006805, 0.01476836483925581, -0.005961480550467968, -0.016081951558589935, 0.04517778381705284, -0.0351044237613678, -0.061406880617141724, 0.013696988113224506, 0.0019103529630228877, -0.02853482775390148, -0.026235997676849365, -0.006122427526861429, 0.0023620417341589928, -0.011471381410956383, -0.036480918526649475, 0.0003673557366710156, -0.008031715638935566, -0.009693216532468796, 0.019331086426973343, -0.00672562513500452, 0.013178739696741104, 0.017154144123196602, -0.005880668293684721, -0.011980357579886913, -0.018320700153708458, 0.00031100126216188073, -0.026314614340662956, 0.023777635768055916, 0.026264457032084465, -0.03501226752996445, 0.0025172976311296225, 0.0020193164236843586, 0.03222103789448738, -0.03173469379544258, -0.032817672938108444, -0.023629963397979736, 0.03550053760409355, -0.007598351687192917, 0.024101614952087402, -0.040964774787425995, -0.014259561896324158, 0.015272186137735844, -0.06114884093403816, 0.028760550543665886, 0.04563700035214424, 0.006975542288273573, -0.034598346799612045, -0.044178590178489685, -0.013214951381087303, 0.013093740679323673, -0.015289454720914364, -0.00938150379806757, 0.03545229882001877, -0.024605033919215202, -0.02003871090710163, -0.007684584707021713, -0.004006640054285526, 0.03901218622922897, -0.00047794420970603824, 0.012784810736775398, -0.03563521057367325, -0.06167862191796303, -0.0031330750789493322, 0.005871602799743414, 0.016025997698307037, 0.0381862036883831, -0.004803266376256943, 0.0028756619431078434, -0.02893015556037426, -0.01083702128380537, 0.02994845062494278, 0.0006030841032043099, 0.004845154006034136, -0.007440980989485979, -0.002724194200709462, -0.015177070163190365, 0.006876461673527956, 0.01145077869296074, -0.01206189300864935, 0.006204129662364721, 0.032044753432273865, -0.0074430713430047035, -0.041457176208496094, -0.026211069896817207, -0.0064993673004209995, -0.04259882867336273, -0.010387290269136429, -0.014828331768512726, 0.023936493322253227, 0.01810266822576523, 0.02312305197119713, 0.027547325938940048, 0.005642442032694817, -0.005181209184229374, 0.017342640087008476, 0.0008727255044505, -0.05137619748711586, -0.016811508685350418, 0.015517553314566612, -0.021437929943203926, -0.031593549996614456, -0.009959269315004349, -0.03776891902089119, 0.0028916101437062025, -0.009006546810269356, -0.017314907163381577, -0.04471353068947792, 0.006998868193477392, -0.03851364552974701, 0.0017376616597175598, -0.018049106001853943, 0.030655309557914734, -0.02615506574511528, -0.031814999878406525, -0.017900554463267326, 0.012073764577507973, -0.015476841479539871, -0.00685366615653038, -0.0008190374355763197, -0.018397875130176544, 0.04806940257549286, -0.00458899699151516, 0.003594383131712675, 0.025538401678204536, 0.0060865445993840694, 0.0033235345035791397, 0.007183837238699198, -0.0850459411740303, 0.02724030613899231, 0.062301162630319595, -0.04515950009226799, -0.0316573791205883, 0.04160257428884506, -0.006620599888265133, 0.04101533815264702, 0.024996791034936905, -0.023622572422027588, -0.021121079102158546, 0.045377470552921295, -0.0498451367020607, -0.01387633103877306, -0.018763933330774307, 0.015052255243062973, 0.029078233987092972, -0.0011154714738950133, 0.024812066927552223, 0.009616080671548843, 0.023139994591474533, 0.04929381608963013, 0.04221082478761673, 0.012036729604005814, 0.005095078609883785, 0.0009976064320653677, 0.02710721455514431, 0.01424543559551239, 0.03195340558886528, -0.024254396557807922, -0.001077377120964229, 0.07829160243272781, -0.001589702325873077, 0.035314660519361496, -0.03744622319936752, -0.014361738227307796, -0.10282450169324875, -0.012397877871990204, -0.0014900245005264878, 0.02569941058754921, 0.06576838344335556, -0.05057408660650253, -0.012111363001167774, 0.020587507635354996, -0.058577314019203186, -0.010878912173211575, -0.027601484209299088, 0.009061255492269993, -0.023310165852308273, 0.015816375613212585, -0.03438811004161835, 0.047530870884656906, 0.042338524013757706, 0.027390647679567337, 0.0406159833073616, 0.042066965252161026, -0.003967985510826111, -0.03373913839459419, 0.011401652358472347, 0.025885028764605522, -0.035770174115896225, -0.04081140458583832, 0.006596491672098637, -0.006960587110370398, -0.037572674453258514, 0.030826294794678688, 0.0029687397181987762, 0.047904111444950104, 0.027134455740451813, 0.0316576324403286, 0.003387837903574109, 0.03425261750817299, 0.0429786816239357, -0.0013496174942702055, -0.01308933924883604, 0.02328694425523281, 0.023194430395960808, 0.028379572555422783, 0.011694530956447124, 0.012316325679421425, 0.04069269075989723, -0.006729238200932741, 0.002346048131585121, 0.013682184740900993, -0.01928321272134781, -0.021441832184791565, 0.021769113838672638, 0.01926274225115776, 0.0008244146010838449, 0.007160247769206762, 0.024219758808612823, -0.014383367262780666, -0.007961736992001534, 0.04507308080792427, -0.0022670761682093143, -0.0029396754689514637, -0.006818163674324751, -0.03177464008331299, -0.04694274067878723, 0.008260357193648815, -0.008830470032989979, -0.0156648438423872, -0.06587793678045273, -0.01588314026594162, 0.011424832977354527, -0.006954864598810673, 0.00665937690064311, 0.012173748575150967, -0.05158010125160217, 0.043258149176836014, -0.019635457545518875, -0.001852398389019072, -0.026872452348470688, 0.002694224240258336, 0.05436254292726517, -0.037585727870464325, 0.07473479956388474, -0.002690698951482773, -0.0094535443931818, -0.07297611236572266, -0.039778467267751694, 0.004652144853025675, 0.03604039549827576, 0.021973058581352234, -0.02210436388850212, 0.03823167458176613, 0.0011253139236941934, -0.0008663504268042743, -0.0015140300383791327, -0.023384084925055504, 0.04679124429821968, -0.021524859592318535, -0.043080735951662064, -0.00220409850589931, -0.016085175797343254, 0.04339088872075081, 0.016655057668685913, 0.02555996924638748, -0.03060990571975708, 0.0373019240796566, 0.005158312618732452, -0.01808147132396698, 0.03411710634827614, 0.01247829757630825, 0.014721439220011234, 0.025199884548783302, -0.0040597617626190186, 0.05353179946541786, 0.00160867883823812, -0.013350694440305233, -0.055158816277980804, 0.03303078934550285, -0.07312745600938797, -0.026353934779763222, -0.004630653653293848, -0.015675483271479607, 0.010120375081896782, -0.022450055927038193, 0.009594988077878952, 0.013390997424721718, -0.031982265412807465, -0.011148357763886452, 0.0036522881127893925, 0.04005812853574753, 0.043770644813776016, -0.01025601290166378, 0.010299448855221272, -0.015187172219157219, -0.005633776541799307, 0.003368998412042856, -0.006651350297033787, -0.028096843510866165, -0.0148130739107728, 0.017793362960219383, 0.03827651962637901, 0.013625143095850945, 0.007212354801595211, 0.02676611952483654, 0.04208146035671234, -0.025901777669787407, -0.025270408019423485, 0.010624147951602936, -0.017229333519935608, 0.010719873011112213, -0.0011113927466794848, -0.016842031851410866, 0.08521554619073868, -0.007253178860992193, 0.03386012464761734, -0.014960587956011295, -0.008874964900314808, -0.035252645611763, -0.02159317024052143, -0.00828795786947012, -0.0011800139909610152, -0.033082157373428345, 0.0009659756324253976, 0.0014448926085606217, 0.0353882759809494, 0.04786311089992523, -0.05798580124974251, 0.03244488313794136, -0.0047471784055233, -0.012472289614379406, -0.04167491942644119, 0.0018456069519743323, -0.02660166285932064, 0.013143391348421574, 0.0011430352460592985, 0.009426649659872055, -0.0018893169471994042, 0.01650117337703705, -0.014725404791533947, -0.003250239184126258, 0.023302549496293068, -0.060033004730939865, 0.015635216608643532, -0.09407228231430054, -0.0035544189158827066, -0.0033398978412151337, 0.01594199426472187 ]
<p>I am trying to estimate the price elasticity of supply for small scale farmers in Malawi and I have time series data for 34 years. I have two problems: First, the prices are very low such that when I take their logs am getting negative values, as a remedy i added 1 to each value and i got positive logs but i don't know how to interprete the result with the 1 that I added. Second i want to find out the specific way of estimating the model in <code>Stata</code>, I just used regress. I will appreciate your help</p>
74,033
[ 0.00976006593555212, -0.037324365228414536, -0.02694394439458847, 0.011099194176495075, 0.02160191908478737, 0.02765517681837082, -0.025700300931930542, 0.025231214240193367, 0.037070389837026596, -0.02428581193089485, 0.0234058927744627, 0.043601859360933304, 0.026945797726511955, 0.02906339429318905, 0.044281136244535446, 0.019338082522153854, 0.007971809245646, -0.008908858522772789, -0.016560664400458336, 0.008271044120192528, 0.015530828386545181, 0.021956024691462517, -0.02852640673518181, 0.06073450669646263, -0.007397685199975967, 0.05730645731091499, 0.054714567959308624, -0.016359150409698486, 0.014454871416091919, 0.10788692533969879, 0.01836840808391571, -0.026959199458360672, -0.03609598055481911, 0.01745937019586563, 0.060798585414886475, 0.022710280492901802, -0.061385028064250946, -0.03788423165678978, 0.04475077614188194, 0.03786993399262428, -0.01572580263018608, 0.0029850101564079523, 0.006706528831273317, 0.008124206215143204, -0.01896490715444088, 0.04330729320645332, 0.02163076587021351, -0.019982239231467247, 0.07722310721874237, -0.033081382513046265, 0.04708090052008629, 0.007089472841471434, 0.014863848686218262, 0.03674018755555153, -0.006099474150687456, -0.028549233451485634, 0.0542275495827198, 0.04425358772277832, -0.010639005340635777, -0.03912771865725517, 0.005045650061219931, -0.019168144091963768, 0.0008822995005175471, -0.06535671651363373, -0.010944843292236328, -0.0033609753008931875, 0.00881577655673027, 0.02539055049419403, 0.05113638564944267, -0.007396654691547155, 0.013210959732532501, -0.0004122266254853457, 0.015851309522986412, -0.006038025952875614, -0.009738045744597912, -0.029128748923540115, -0.01648026704788208, 0.02352735958993435, 0.042278140783309937, 0.04687865450978279, 0.021536285057663918, -0.006443690042942762, 0.02114882320165634, 0.04867103695869446, 0.00038283845060504973, -0.007769573014229536, 0.0705694705247879, -0.010722612030804157, 0.05592801794409752, 0.02046012319624424, -0.029171576723456383, 0.0221643578261137, 0.04847303777933121, -0.004473913926631212, -0.009416145272552967, 0.028652751818299294, -0.009057353250682354, 0.04961584508419037, -0.0017112408531829715, -0.04000154510140419, -0.045304492115974426, -0.010813887231051922, 0.006391282659024, 0.033089566975831985, -0.04996972158551216, 0.008746308274567127, -0.011962606571614742, -0.025229275226593018, -0.010524450801312923, -0.0396009162068367, -0.01618519052863121, 0.011703353375196457, 0.032053474336862564, -0.014866667799651623, -0.009608727879822254, -0.017007309943437576, -0.053935762494802475, -0.022327052429318428, 0.04203563556075096, 0.023379262536764145, 0.02633221074938774, -0.05211630463600159, 0.030664930120110512, -0.015596440061926842, -0.06391073763370514, 0.018892483785748482, -0.008333839476108551, -0.048024363815784454, -0.05563550442457199, 0.01079250406473875, 0.050703804939985275, -0.07089971005916595, 0.011668615974485874, -0.01137817557901144, 0.02646961435675621, -0.004231213591992855, -0.04324210062623024, -0.07951075583696365, 0.03641486167907715, 0.005004815757274628, 0.020487625151872635, -0.05142844840884209, -0.006208179518580437, -0.002679213648661971, 0.06635061651468277, -0.01950058899819851, 0.05977763235569, 0.06153933331370354, -0.01786387898027897, -0.003444465110078454, -0.03295248746871948, -0.03168636932969093, -0.03964179754257202, -0.012309964746236801, 0.015342896804213524, -0.061500053852796555, -0.03548247367143631, -0.00815163366496563, -0.05493893846869469, -0.012915696948766708, 0.04017987102270126, 0.019612012431025505, -0.022348256781697273, 0.0010441112099215388, -0.038562312722206116, -0.06206035241484642, 0.07646951079368591, -0.027164196595549583, 0.03358067572116852, 0.026259610429406166, -0.023574398830533028, -0.011257501319050789, -0.0283048152923584, 0.05679532513022423, 0.03627004474401474, 0.0011900104582309723, -0.0037268120795488358, -0.005350135266780853, 0.029024425894021988, 0.012134225107729435, -0.04774332791566849, -0.020419633015990257, 0.03349682316184044, -0.009426429867744446, 0.03850320354104042, -0.004226406570523977, 0.007920597679913044, -0.024010363966226578, 0.007446840405464172, -0.04991789162158966, -0.038860198110342026, -0.05037855729460716, 0.005498761311173439, 0.01106966007500887, 0.020985664799809456, -0.002195401582866907, 0.014424009248614311, 0.0074918330647051334, -0.013844947330653667, 0.012200853787362576, 0.0028061436023563147, -0.002933410694822669, 0.016682777553796768, -0.014893071725964546, -0.005463721230626106, 0.05742129310965538, 0.04212037846446037, -0.05563938617706299, 0.034285422414541245, -0.044924549758434296, -0.0016940170899033546, 0.038921378552913666, -0.017631560564041138, 0.035979531705379486, -0.014969687908887863, 0.027567068114876747, 0.0011772048892453313, 0.007947533391416073, -0.029169995337724686, 0.008763291873037815, -0.04988742992281914, 0.039472781121730804, 0.026049314066767693, 0.0021230431739240885, -0.001597764203324914, -0.012507456354796886, 0.008887444622814655, 0.04335357993841171, -0.02314361371099949, -0.019004151225090027, -0.034840039908885956, -0.01803990639746189, 0.01665562391281128, 0.060638878494501114, 0.0020745794754475355, -0.0150038106366992, 0.08731351792812347, -0.01726178266108036, -0.003817474003881216, 0.00795351155102253, -0.023530272766947746, -0.004424096085131168, 0.005156782455742359, -0.006972637493163347, 0.013854664750397205, 0.018940212205052376, -0.005018140189349651, -0.02520660310983658, 0.060602303594350815, 0.012862324714660645, 0.02474779263138771, 0.03173296898603439, -0.006108926609158516, 0.06615731120109558, 0.022432565689086914, 0.01982930116355419, 0.04014617204666138, -0.01382050197571516, 0.023754533380270004, -0.00684800511226058, 0.009359301067888737, 0.021552877500653267, 0.0019107452826574445, -0.004748096223920584, 0.027296913787722588, 0.039534155279397964, -0.003745706519111991, -0.005941248964518309, 0.01759670488536358, -0.03340206295251846, 0.01025248784571886, -0.0077824098989367485, -0.03100723773241043, -0.021964838728308678, -0.008511088788509369, 0.034196656197309494, 0.015578588470816612, 0.030048109591007233, -0.06187719106674194, -0.003295905189588666, 0.019976060837507248, -0.02775127999484539, 0.04073503986001015, 0.004629895556718111, -0.002688651904463768, -0.030058957636356354, -0.017697365954518318, -0.006608881521970034, 0.018936067819595337, 0.0012897615088149905, -0.01711856946349144, 0.05065044015645981, -0.03510255366563797, -0.04176637902855873, -0.056078165769577026, -0.021455882117152214, 0.01754569076001644, -0.0031346092000603676, -0.009033803828060627, 0.06378709524869919, 0.0037773929070681334, -0.023866934701800346, -0.0031067340169101954, -0.0726393386721611, 0.0007827281951904297, -0.036669518798589706, -0.0019778995774686337, -0.04633154720067978, -0.010711266659200191, 0.044618669897317886, -0.03096664510667324, -0.001036255736835301, -0.020388726145029068, -0.0673903301358223, -0.034271035343408585, 0.007791174575686455, -0.00792786106467247, 0.02945268154144287, -0.0004064641834702343, -0.020669223740696907, 0.05287431553006172, 0.016831519082188606, -0.004430705681443214, -0.05045386031270027, -0.02747362293303013, -0.011981384828686714, -0.052420537918806076, 0.04176447167992592, 0.027945661917328835, -0.0210796557366848, 0.046630945056676865, 0.015698252245783806, 0.0738934576511383, 0.03468809649348259, 0.0283281821757555, -0.028885947540402412, 0.03896365687251091, -0.039038706570863724, -0.03201485425233841, 0.006621082313358784, 0.03474229946732521, -0.009121257811784744, 0.020265020430088043, -0.022802414372563362, 0.0055563198402523994, 0.0074022128246724606, -0.047542229294776917, -0.012313074432313442, -0.005847014021128416, -0.023816127330064774, -0.05083691328763962, 0.0057432991452515125, 0.0470016710460186, -0.0074994368478655815, -0.0025680046528577805, -0.012323767878115177, -0.013401323929429054, -0.022050127387046814, -0.016489475965499878, 0.01718125492334366, 0.0419376976788044, 0.01476160530000925, 0.013687435537576675, -0.014432176947593689, -0.02455400675535202, 0.0002960065030492842, -0.017759671434760094, 0.015966977924108505, 0.043024998158216476, 0.0855076014995575, -0.008199313655495644, -0.0136411739513278, -0.06995733082294464, -0.0035919456277042627, -0.05417726933956146, -0.009168742224574089, -0.0034003693144768476, 0.054196860641241074, -0.0022174962796270847, -0.006916197016835213, 0.0018627418903633952, 0.004446524661034346, 0.033379971981048584, 0.0049818954430520535, -0.08673615008592606, 0.04439355060458183, 0.04433459788560867, 0.012317804619669914, 0.019854078069329262, -0.0009346218430437148, 0.011819576844573021, -0.054542817175388336, -0.0005297375028021634, -0.024411015212535858, 0.01656939648091793, -0.012075807899236679, 0.010670141316950321, 0.027783842757344246, -0.021094435825943947, -0.015515558421611786, -0.011322696693241596, 0.007502526510506868, 0.013459645211696625, 0.012511655688285828, 0.028175579383969307, 0.009703248739242554, -0.021541841328144073, -0.018538596108555794, 0.01717079058289528, 0.045698657631874084, 0.048158299177885056, 0.007646898739039898, 0.017704995349049568, -0.06326243281364441, 0.04785122722387314, 0.024045925587415695, 0.07719441503286362, 0.05547359958291054, 0.016354572027921677, -0.00786912813782692, -0.022360065951943398, 0.02280139923095703, 0.016349907964468002, 0.010976845398545265, 0.005685369949787855, -0.0033622418995946646, 0.060827553272247314, 0.014295417815446854, -0.028214354068040848, -0.007126155309379101, 0.07679229229688644, -0.005320200230926275, -0.01183750294148922, -0.02726839669048786, -0.009289794601500034, -0.001783721032552421, 0.03416513651609421, 0.01646742969751358, -0.012373330071568489, 0.015548212453722954, -0.028537632897496223, 0.0573410764336586, -0.015553457662463188, -0.01807263121008873, 0.002349090063944459, 0.03119805082678795, 0.031431179493665695, 0.006255039479583502, -0.06435126811265945, 0.04661642387509346, 0.04669267311692238, 0.006230704020708799, 0.02877259999513626, 0.031537603586912155, -0.0902482345700264, -0.03828056529164314, 0.012460737489163876, 0.0017486453289166093, -0.026275387033820152, -0.010587044060230255, -0.05301015079021454, -0.028701644390821457, 0.012832854874432087, -0.07692038267850876, 0.029052283614873886, 0.004181587137281895, 0.04233863577246666, -0.01767018623650074, -0.007095970679074526, -0.044220879673957825, 0.014316955581307411, 0.02940516732633114, 0.03689943626523018, -0.02562805265188217, -0.018806688487529755, -0.03377388417720795, 0.028939375653862953, 0.004540855996310711, 0.01991098001599312, -0.01612202264368534, 0.004149915184825659, 0.0158998966217041, 0.04889114201068878, -0.027406783774495125, -0.07286456227302551, 0.025488466024398804, -0.029406802728772163, 0.008606002666056156, 0.0391613245010376, 0.020245445892214775, 0.007156918756663799, -0.005479623097926378, 0.022708149626851082, 0.0035544452257454395, -0.02794676460325718, -0.04067106544971466, -0.00012245586549397558, 0.008240186609327793, -0.0008109889458864927, 0.02135281451046467, 0.058067623525857925, -0.0425432026386261, 0.0008292367565445602, -0.027625905349850655, -0.017290426418185234, -0.0408664233982563, 0.005181540735065937, -0.027287743985652924, 0.02002660371363163, -0.009849986992776394, 0.010510437190532684, 0.022707270458340645, 0.030781671404838562, -0.05430145934224129, 0.005266233347356319, 0.004790520295500755, 0.046876098960638046, -0.0001266421313630417, -0.005439178552478552, 0.00444788858294487, 0.025823885574936867, -0.030790388584136963, -0.06364354491233826, 0.019043391570448875, -0.006298013962805271, -0.017692603170871735, -0.031392425298690796, -0.044971685856580734, 0.006369929760694504, 0.005243037827312946, -0.0302343238145113, -0.0017585668247193098, -0.040480971336364746, 0.04313458502292633, 0.021666349843144417, 0.0280649121850729, -0.010513627901673317, 0.001156917423941195, 0.024949193000793457, 0.03809220716357231, -0.008642267435789108, 0.0581369511783123, -0.017907096073031425, 0.04751228168606758, 0.009279400110244751, -0.012197299860417843, -0.04360613226890564, -0.01904679834842682, 0.03677933290600777, -0.034513361752033234, -0.04932789504528046, -0.01931825652718544, -0.03815590590238571, 0.008321879431605339, -0.015729516744613647, 0.005716599989682436, 0.0575098991394043, -0.021735094487667084, 0.0016189261805266142, 0.0029475076589733362, 0.0491461381316185, 0.05391926318407059, -0.012444430030882359, -0.014945471659302711, 0.03568227216601372, -0.03962348774075508, -0.07426407933235168, -0.026056185364723206, 0.0048193843103945255, -0.02886240929365158, -0.04547226056456566, -0.0484691746532917, -0.0009651084546931088, -0.012325054034590721, -0.01612376794219017, 0.00008321163477376103, -0.014309262856841087, 0.008732951246201992, 0.016924740746617317, -0.012945855967700481, 0.002245004288852215, 0.009419966489076614, 0.024961190298199654, -0.02804143913090229, -0.034600142389535904, -0.030513687059283257, 0.001600188435986638, 0.022169334813952446, -0.007162173744291067, -0.01596790924668312, 0.007993686944246292, 0.06732454150915146, 0.02220666967332363, -0.010379526764154434, 0.02791958674788475, -0.006667725741863251, 0.012777472846210003, 0.00909300334751606, -0.01584278605878353, -0.018997089937329292, 0.01394775602966547, -0.014771041460335255, -0.030339574441313744, -0.0239665936678648, -0.004394468851387501, 0.07034539431333542, 0.027474962174892426, 0.008374595083296299, 0.013199273496866226, 0.015680186450481415, -0.01685747131705284, -0.009539179503917694, -0.011859451420605183, -0.024405980482697487, 0.007445189636200666, 0.052732277661561966, -0.027204837650060654, 0.005191627889871597, 0.04337546229362488, -0.00036533112870529294, 0.011214171536266804, 0.03867250308394432, -0.002878215629607439, -0.016611594706773758, 0.006666615605354309, -0.0037821969017386436, -0.0836988016963005, 0.013662656769156456, -0.001518953824415803, 0.04671294614672661, -0.0168631412088871, 0.009713609702885151, 0.053045760840177536, 0.03588610887527466, -0.018373824656009674, -0.06004905328154564, 0.019657138735055923, -0.0638795867562294, -0.02951645478606224, 0.018930375576019287, -0.05777990445494652, 0.05611129850149155, 0.023670842871069908, 0.024358877912163734, -0.018126105889678, 0.017590908333659172, -0.033461254090070724, -0.06908582895994186, -0.0108431251719594, -0.011479220353066921, -0.013352867215871811, 0.025682633742690086, -0.015451875515282154, -0.02014918066561222, 0.022385723888874054, -0.0277169868350029, -0.000026689813239499927, 0.0033867405727505684, 0.014261484146118164, 0.0027595730498433113, 0.0400981679558754, 0.008273272775113583, -0.007224402390420437, -0.03815898299217224, 0.011059346608817577, 0.12498871237039566, 0.07236532121896744, 0.002017081016674638, -0.07423407584428787, 0.005065138451755047, -0.019075710326433182, -0.002694415394216776, -0.004076740238815546, -0.01559969037771225, -0.01252198126167059, -0.025661593303084373, 0.04552011936903, 0.047501467168331146, -0.0211107786744833, 0.012717112898826599, 0.0301550030708313, -0.03281934931874275, -0.025813555344939232, -0.009138571098446846, -0.0027877502143383026, 0.002382720820605755, 0.04262617230415344, -0.05810000002384186, 0.04035213962197304, -0.000249567354330793, -0.013263600878417492, -0.029323168098926544, -0.03521175682544708, 0.011748313903808594, -0.006513853091746569, -0.013661042787134647, 0.006944564171135426, 0.032934363931417465, 0.018019746989011765, -0.018058964982628822, 0.0015170149272307754, 0.009796363301575184, 0.003961536101996899, -0.0025337086990475655, 0.03799347206950188, -0.012050923891365528, 0.00921834260225296, 0.025853591039776802, 0.007882555015385151, -0.040516603738069534, -0.017741894349455833, -0.028165917843580246, 0.03684144467115402, 0.02724459581077099, -0.01666192151606083, -0.044159237295389175, -0.002789280842989683, -0.005912900902330875, -0.0335882194340229, -0.028369370847940445, 0.016957953572273254, 0.03306789696216583, -0.053292132914066315, -0.054823193699121475, -0.008698402903974056, -0.026828784495592117, -0.03320513293147087, 0.018324119970202446, -0.002204864751547575, -0.02819494903087616, 0.011865869164466858, -0.023187685757875443, 0.04540369659662247, -0.03499376028776169, 0.003918339032679796, 0.03054838627576828, -0.0043872264213860035, -0.01948441006243229, -0.0316220223903656, -0.002296190708875656, 0.005045898724347353, 0.01429632119834423, 0.014079567976295948, 0.018180960789322853, -0.048465240746736526, -0.06204322353005409, 0.0021237386390566826, -0.05353059992194176, -0.00395691953599453, -0.05383582040667534, -0.00920091476291418, 0.009246407076716423, 0.03615421801805496, 0.02525167167186737, -0.015273685567080975, -0.0005499830585904419, 0.033862221986055374, 0.054811250418424606, -0.042418621480464935, -0.028586218133568764, 0.016410641372203827, -0.0638640895485878, -0.03691631555557251, -0.05599936097860336, 0.08603052794933319, 0.0004610485921148211, 0.027018588036298752, -0.005648962687700987, 0.012619467452168465, -0.012194445356726646, 0.0009749389137141407, 0.021376587450504303, -0.0411355122923851, 0.004870404954999685, 0.009340516291558743, 0.018288157880306244, -0.007069126237183809, 0.0031207066494971514, -0.006616378668695688, -0.028248002752661705, 0.030274678021669388, 0.014980974607169628, -0.040399618446826935, 0.054757144302129745, -0.022527547553181648, 0.01982969418168068, -0.012160100042819977, 0.026147037744522095, -0.02883114479482174, -0.004997525364160538, -0.008053429424762726, -0.019705867394804955, -0.009175542742013931, 0.020543096587061882, -0.023570789024233818, 0.03368967026472092, 0.05061526596546173, -0.0014366678660735488, 0.03174501284956932, -0.045983199030160904, 0.051166027784347534, 0.003519257763400674, 0.024828536435961723, -0.005893085617572069, -0.06453057378530502, 0.031135374680161476, -0.0405229888856411, -0.026044659316539764, 0.007440024521201849, 0.004566853865981102, 0.05716400966048241, 0.021380271762609482, 0.004823084454983473, -0.04669515788555145, 0.039923910051584244, -0.015884997323155403, 0.011938528157770634, -0.01315020676702261, -0.007800382561981678, 0.04241383820772171, 0.0032831858843564987, -0.024319656193256378, -0.0008019599481485784, -0.032008096575737, -0.013089542277157307, 0.03339975327253342, -0.02386108972132206, -0.02073103003203869, 0.010908875614404678, 0.022412091493606567, 0.009025135077536106, -0.015628065913915634, -0.0475129559636116, 0.012678492814302444, 0.03292792662978172, 0.00796737615019083, 0.016120171174407005, -0.03104390576481819, -0.0022105821408331394, -0.016406884416937828, 0.003958430141210556, -0.016767947003245354, 0.01829632744193077, 0.019961487501859665, -0.04038681462407112, 0.005103289149701595, 0.01405640970915556, 0.015784556046128273, -0.01611977070569992, -0.0254790261387825, 0.013338442891836166, -0.04160575941205025, -0.021840516477823257, -0.01710321009159088, 0.037091560661792755, 0.023396655917167664, 0.03730880096554756, 0.04029010981321335, -0.004922218155115843, 0.00020674704865086824, -0.017453346401453018, -0.015866685658693314, 0.006462624296545982, 0.005020058248192072, -0.04048458859324455, 0.0426248274743557, -0.07179983705282211, -0.00042903475696220994, 0.06853948533535004, -0.021661214530467987, 0.05532049760222435, 0.043977249413728714, 0.02253519929945469, -0.01235007680952549, 0.08936008810997009, 0.023574404418468475, 0.0020117575768381357, -0.004756058566272259, -0.024923497810959816, 0.002843589521944523, -0.008901922032237053, -0.027996715158224106, 0.04320983961224556, 0.0062223318964242935, -0.0440816693007946, 0.018094917759299278, -0.023564651608467102, 0.002446698723360896, -0.024719534441828728, 0.004778677597641945, -0.017918270081281662, 0.021312136203050613, -0.024776456877589226, 0.04046865552663803, 0.0044608889147639275, 0.014346376061439514, 0.08365216106176376, 0.06057766079902649, -0.034302547574043274, 0.021438701078295708, -0.0031241741962730885, -0.038025129586458206, 0.04691190645098686, -0.0071680000983178616, -0.0303080715239048, -0.012086376547813416, -0.019825587049126625, -0.005752059631049633, -0.0015945715131238103, -0.058027591556310654, 0.04847395420074463, -0.020115306600928307, 0.029690764844417572, -0.03966430574655533, -0.00956688728183508, 0.009882721118628979, -0.03393954783678055, 0.061149295419454575, -0.08762839436531067, 0.05713077634572983, -0.0023612549994140863, -0.010362277738749981, -0.015807894989848137, -0.051477979868650436, -0.03901123255491257, -0.00219515198841691, 0.06501063704490662, 0.005245072301477194, -0.031414639204740524, 0.0010918003972619772, 0.0320519357919693, 0.02023165114223957, 0.0016260587144643068, 0.04110167920589447, 0.03519703075289726, -0.013123304583132267, 0.02720644883811474, -0.02726501040160656, -0.01702977530658245, 0.029722774401307106, 0.01215603668242693, -0.014327581971883774, -0.0269912239164114, 0.018494974821805954, -0.030751749873161316, -0.001558214775286615, 0.011794410645961761, -0.01674477569758892, 0.06196540594100952, 0.0019415828865021467, 0.013822905719280243, 0.03369849920272827, -0.015423447825014591, -0.04984258487820625, 0.014502260833978653, -0.019651025533676147, -0.024974027648568153, 0.02247915044426918, 0.007324441336095333, 0.008170496672391891, -0.05303363874554634, -0.04345831647515297, 0.034431342035532, 0.004334447905421257, 0.009543580934405327, 0.04181564599275589, 0.048800140619277954, 0.05352378264069557, 0.021823687478899956, 0.03321032598614693, -0.005152092315256596, 0.00890621729195118, 0.012812045402824879, 0.055076565593481064, 0.03981141746044159, -0.011058507487177849, -0.013124095275998116, -0.0069903419353067875, -0.014904276467859745, 0.03968660905957222, -0.03218483179807663, 0.052006542682647705, -0.02944163978099823, -0.025805439800024033, -0.00913598109036684, 0.018628133460879326, -0.011813837103545666, 0.037954576313495636, 0.0016903490759432316, 0.05173558369278908, -0.019412903115153313, -0.008378664031624794, -0.03993461653590202, 0.01291667204350233, -0.0220500361174345, 0.002723681041970849, -0.013793138787150383, -0.007231973577290773, -0.0021978209260851145, 0.017907103523612022, 0.021825173869729042, -0.01633014716207981, 0.020482389256358147, -0.027867883443832397, -0.027799665927886963, -0.0016595936613157392, -0.009271956980228424, -0.00857629906386137, -0.01983438991010189, -0.009853234514594078, 0.012101277709007263, 0.039270784705877304, 0.01070389710366726, 0.006810879334807396, -0.022562917321920395, -0.06254088133573532, -0.0017766173696145415, 0.05661496892571449, -0.0508732832968235, -0.015645714476704597, -0.004383523017168045, -0.04247285798192024, -0.026915356516838074, -0.04292774945497513 ]
<p>In the English Championship division, there are 24 teams, 8 of which have names starting with the letter B (e.g.Bolton) Tonight, (5th March 2013) all 24 teams in this division are playing each other. By a coincidence, the 8 teams starting with B are playing each other, i.e. 4 of the games involve these 8 teams (there are 2 teams per game!) What is the probability of this happening ?</p>
74,034
[ -0.03790530562400818, -0.05232065171003342, -0.03273584321141243, -0.002414512913674116, 0.05320750176906586, 0.04002346470952034, 0.018130024895071983, 0.001043629483319819, 0.004934448748826981, -0.0005134379607625306, -0.004739782772958279, 0.033784061670303345, 0.006615135818719864, 0.01623319834470749, 0.016641179099678993, 0.0034293895587325096, -0.011596099473536015, 0.03605874255299568, -0.0008861634996719658, 0.0021504764445126057, 0.023605210706591606, 0.006428380962461233, 0.022204183042049408, 0.014655478298664093, -0.02636546455323696, 0.040093228220939636, -0.026819143444299698, -0.0459308959543705, -0.009755540639162064, 0.04508690908551216, -0.0019749943166971207, -0.03382521867752075, 0.05234101414680481, 0.052654676139354706, 0.011095632798969746, -0.005579983815550804, 0.003471739124506712, -0.04165003076195717, -0.010501901619136333, 0.022562671452760696, -0.02604985050857067, -0.052182722836732864, -0.03481703996658325, 0.06507135182619095, -0.010678929276764393, -0.007783183362334967, -0.014716465957462788, -0.04177628830075264, 0.015136740170419216, -0.012412316165864468, 0.06945522129535675, -0.009581197053194046, 0.04231301322579384, -0.010434607043862343, -0.009851772338151932, -0.002715500071644783, 0.02587345615029335, 0.07968802750110626, -0.011639303527772427, -0.04224719852209091, -0.030806826427578926, -0.023582130670547485, -0.015993263572454453, -0.016932489350438118, -0.04519755765795708, -0.0035080877132713795, -0.0016183495754376054, -0.022737829014658928, 0.04342125356197357, 0.0029816541355103254, -0.013999396935105324, 0.07647155225276947, 0.07333410531282425, -0.03305751085281372, 0.01857774145901203, -0.013755428604781628, 0.047872576862573624, 0.023195594549179077, 0.04041452705860138, 0.010663405992090702, -0.01531432569026947, -0.010096285492181778, 0.0067990669049322605, 0.04383710026741028, 0.08660009503364563, 0.013927345164120197, 0.00426400825381279, -0.020677298307418823, 0.01735384203493595, -0.01924576237797737, -0.022253787145018578, -0.01747165434062481, 0.03537699207663536, 0.02965301275253296, -0.07445860654115677, 0.0582280233502388, -0.01636587642133236, 0.0273335799574852, 0.0013062095968052745, -0.02960643358528614, 0.0013106163823977113, -0.04015078395605087, 0.02803495153784752, 0.05950915440917015, -0.00779022928327322, -0.014549501240253448, -0.07095160335302353, 0.018759846687316895, -0.020383113995194435, 0.018941588699817657, -0.0260833278298378, 0.048984866589307785, 0.014153669588267803, 0.0013690433697775006, -0.0004875348531641066, -0.05265600234270096, -0.05105823650956154, 0.009007367305457592, 0.006849413737654686, 0.0610230378806591, 0.04373408481478691, -0.028681376948952675, 0.03877735137939453, -0.02503577433526516, -0.03831641748547554, 0.036078616976737976, 0.0026094492059201, -0.0435837097465992, 0.006850127130746841, 0.04987284168601036, -0.013986405916512012, -0.05071407929062843, 0.019158581271767616, -0.02012202888727188, 0.04473442584276199, -0.02574758790433407, -0.08338519185781479, -0.015096780844032764, 0.0673971101641655, -0.031086787581443787, -0.05635726451873779, -0.08654103428125381, -0.009814918972551823, 0.00854011345654726, 0.07169079035520554, -0.00987271312624216, 0.01677311398088932, 0.015862425789237022, 0.03040786273777485, 0.04288502410054207, 0.006122036371380091, 0.01542734820395708, -0.004460000433027744, -0.007730458397418261, 0.03672263026237488, -0.06716141849756241, -0.008061328902840614, 0.0037734564393758774, -0.001874224399216473, -0.03454887121915817, 0.036830175668001175, 0.0006409622728824615, -0.026397705078125, 0.012859798036515713, 0.026298880577087402, -0.02142455242574215, 0.04887382686138153, 0.06600277125835419, 0.012497215531766415, -0.0040545170195400715, 0.00020890073210466653, 0.03096570074558258, 0.03751346096396446, 0.054525554180145264, 0.036351971328258514, -0.0398455448448658, 0.02639712579548359, 0.004957243334501982, 0.039950091391801834, -0.0272358525544405, -0.02737223356962204, -0.009766588918864727, -0.012928090058267117, -0.011819657869637012, 0.013232385739684105, 0.03489900380373001, 0.031038636341691017, 0.008559951558709145, 0.03181327506899834, -0.024189524352550507, -0.037351325154304504, -0.10238273441791534, -0.01723814196884632, -0.01071610115468502, -0.017874648794531822, -0.027272405102849007, 0.00463501363992691, 0.013863885775208473, -0.038715243339538574, 0.006251531653106213, -0.025126509368419647, 0.007543324492871761, -0.0016769191715866327, -0.04405537620186806, -0.010897536762058735, 0.06036309152841568, 0.02549430914223194, -0.008808731101453304, 0.05152531713247299, -0.04927777126431465, -0.025617850944399834, 0.010559096932411194, 0.025657737627625465, 0.03629601001739502, -0.04715730994939804, -0.014513474889099598, 0.019309470430016518, 0.04628865048289299, 0.032690998166799545, 0.026157254353165627, -0.06458059698343277, 0.016179854050278664, 0.0007231894414871931, 0.01484726369380951, 0.01682860217988491, 0.02899061143398285, 0.058262113481760025, 0.03866078704595566, 0.0283330287784338, -0.03549680858850479, -0.008684838190674782, 0.02419314533472061, 0.03928064554929733, 0.012507977895438671, 0.0055101728066802025, 0.009401396848261356, 0.051954422146081924, -0.0017564947484061122, -0.015919342637062073, 0.02457396313548088, -0.021132471039891243, -0.006054552737623453, 0.0009444660972803831, 0.0058930786326527596, 0.0036753893364220858, -0.0016845319187268615, -0.03172360733151436, 0.0015891342191025615, 0.03912578895688057, -0.015605035237967968, -0.038284409791231155, -0.006560162175446749, 0.006490975618362427, 0.030866200104355812, -0.02034156396985054, -0.03934343531727791, 0.06439194083213806, -0.014056691899895668, -0.026817001402378082, 0.016224103048443794, 0.04625754803419113, 0.007476685103029013, -0.0027576989959925413, -0.03315134346485138, 0.039029061794281006, 0.01833895966410637, -0.05281325429677963, -0.02253577671945095, 0.019616268575191498, -0.016505582258105278, 0.02798241563141346, 0.008127061650156975, -0.001401224173605442, 0.03276210278272629, -0.007263461127877235, 0.028833208605647087, -0.010241014882922173, 0.06269022077322006, -0.008574510924518108, -0.020207654684782028, -0.026139207184314728, -0.017002468928694725, 0.007948626764118671, -0.014118877239525318, -0.07129556685686111, 0.038992930203676224, -0.0032923887483775616, -0.022178592160344124, 0.02286839485168457, -0.02349860407412052, 0.005776543170213699, 0.02658134326338768, -0.026362596079707146, 0.008103203028440475, -0.011708841659128666, 0.0008664646302349865, 0.03135428950190544, -0.04381470009684563, 0.013822582550346851, 0.011993330903351307, 0.02713492140173912, -0.0318494476377964, 0.03153577074408531, -0.024190140888094902, -0.03361012041568756, -0.002534252591431141, -0.017502613365650177, 0.021733488887548447, -0.02315921150147915, 0.015499059110879898, -0.02571442723274231, -0.02244400978088379, -0.009429305791854858, -0.057615071535110474, -0.08132843673229218, 0.012711333110928535, 0.0033620779868215322, 0.06948384642601013, -0.035810187458992004, -0.02874326892197132, 0.02590077929198742, 0.039082206785678864, 0.030188286677002907, 0.011751496233046055, 0.0022409618832170963, -0.02687728963792324, -0.027993207797408104, 0.024757923558354378, 0.041621994227170944, -0.03076898120343685, 0.024009831249713898, 0.015880124643445015, 0.034559257328510284, 0.06568008661270142, -0.011028110980987549, -0.031696807593107224, 0.008819526061415672, -0.023048868402838707, 0.013702109456062317, 0.010844416916370392, -0.0009200210915878415, -0.017635757103562355, -0.0021134940907359123, -0.005594721529632807, -0.03792504221200943, 0.033465318381786346, -0.05283679813146591, 0.013874311000108719, -0.010899200104176998, -0.00005637050708173774, -0.03231802210211754, 0.043917037546634674, 0.02740197628736496, 0.008046246133744717, 0.014592221938073635, 0.01595231518149376, 0.07046874612569809, -0.022706836462020874, 0.013896215707063675, 0.0515047162771225, -0.022479481995105743, -0.027971163392066956, -0.04568390175700188, -0.002255405765026808, 0.01778670959174633, 0.005442454479634762, -0.03407000005245209, -0.008697963319718838, 0.01757635921239853, 0.012012417428195477, 0.004700393881648779, 0.008385088294744492, -0.04853321239352226, -0.03729863837361336, -0.03803608566522598, -0.03618016839027405, -0.01461851131170988, -0.023877160623669624, -0.01064221654087305, 0.023718494921922684, -0.030202949419617653, -0.011061817407608032, -0.015486730262637138, 0.018106956034898758, -0.06228332221508026, 0.023027842864394188, -0.011239430867135525, 0.02104564756155014, -0.020051579922437668, -0.029810447245836258, 0.004639666993170977, 0.006022640969604254, -0.01799607276916504, 0.011454378254711628, -0.015216792933642864, -0.05672428011894226, 0.00842510350048542, -0.03867252916097641, -0.02334904484450817, 0.012526639737188816, 0.009301960468292236, 0.027967263013124466, 0.01863132417201996, 0.0472358837723732, 0.03380875661969185, -0.006644236855208874, -0.0355452336370945, -0.00006440557626774535, 0.0009796853410080075, 0.03694528341293335, 0.0003719389205798507, 0.022554896771907806, 0.04217814281582832, -0.044919420033693314, -0.036430761218070984, -0.01674843579530716, 0.05249066278338432, 0.027805447578430176, 0.0027933786623179913, 0.004009012132883072, -0.05657994747161865, -0.008431687951087952, 0.03340392932295799, 0.007394234649837017, -0.021305734291672707, 0.06002696976065636, 0.06647726148366928, 0.029565606266260147, -0.03631041571497917, 0.01785791665315628, 0.06700515002012253, 0.003979853354394436, -0.015412584878504276, -0.04286743700504303, -0.002450808184221387, 0.026121970266103745, 0.022630764171481133, 0.004694459959864616, 0.004558832850307226, 0.01979953609406948, -0.023000722751021385, 0.068364717066288, 0.04527170583605766, -0.008297030813992023, 0.035640157759189606, -0.029759090393781662, -0.005189893767237663, 0.022519787773489952, 0.00965121854096651, -0.014248990453779697, 0.031447239220142365, 0.0015962428878992796, 0.024673761799931526, -0.03084407187998295, -0.03126894682645798, -0.004934868309646845, 0.031744323670864105, 0.058609701693058014, -0.013274026103317738, 0.008927437476813793, -0.0443609319627285, -0.029950033873319626, 0.060425978153944016, -0.05024547129869461, 0.032013069838285446, -0.023661091923713684, 0.011686895973980427, 0.007364328019320965, -0.04070783406496048, -0.002963976003229618, 0.02646447904407978, 0.040381986647844315, 0.036519426852464676, 0.017095815390348434, -0.03123781643807888, -0.006027424708008766, 0.0013762225862592459, 0.06007984280586243, 0.03198796138167381, -0.044067371636629105, -0.024089783430099487, -0.006837930530309677, 0.008397812023758888, -0.0382283590734005, -0.04831279069185257, 0.000821260386146605, -0.022304601967334747, -0.03722357004880905, 0.04043951630592346, -0.05275893956422806, -0.016793355345726013, -0.0002414254704490304, -0.0036923219449818134, 0.003195969620719552, -0.004286249168217182, -0.02584693767130375, 0.031656935811042786, 0.02766653709113598, -0.030802149325609207, 0.0379122719168663, -0.031249061226844788, -0.006768008694052696, -0.018510282039642334, 0.004101570695638657, -0.0032704207114875317, 0.027479076758027077, 0.008015131577849388, 0.009398199617862701, -0.019899951294064522, -0.02615746669471264, 0.04111477732658386, -0.010087094269692898, -0.005512496922165155, 0.001461840933188796, -0.018606562167406082, -0.062052298337221146, 0.0018880642019212246, -0.018617544323205948, 0.011450800113379955, -0.01222980860620737, 0.009593321941792965, 0.0044517056085169315, -0.008347484283149242, 0.0038201219867914915, -0.06323207914829254, 0.029618775472044945, -0.011415070854127407, -0.028731629252433777, 0.026675384491682053, -0.034677185118198395, 0.007533435244113207, 0.0005949854385107756, -0.068502277135849, 0.01742956042289734, 0.0018229855922982097, -0.004892914090305567, -0.005849199835211039, -0.04934565722942352, -0.053722236305475235, -0.0007646423182450235, 0.0007394419517368078, 0.047799285501241684, -0.019038772210478783, 0.02181515097618103, -0.0007413498824462295, -0.02489824779331684, -0.04659786447882652, -0.04381772503256798, 0.05191142484545708, 0.01997990347445011, -0.031079042702913284, -0.043375954031944275, -0.03531551733613014, 0.024365771561861038, -0.04125829041004181, 0.005819936748594046, 0.04398516193032265, -0.03618457913398743, -0.016429176554083824, 0.007259295787662268, 0.00028069785912521183, 0.06319638341665268, 0.02181946486234665, -0.011480736546218395, 0.04294257238507271, -0.013227156363427639, -0.03279440104961395, -0.023432929068803787, 0.03985605388879776, -0.02156863547861576, -0.016128603368997574, 0.00612284429371357, 0.027165833860635757, 0.04703982174396515, -0.01795007847249508, 0.0027197019662708044, 0.006488960701972246, 0.03453682363033295, -0.0010040798224508762, -0.03179244324564934, 0.02859734743833542, 0.013419630005955696, -0.0038958785589784384, -0.0026657069101929665, -0.008184477686882019, 0.021206729114055634, -0.016353650018572807, -0.007057058159261942, 0.02137867361307144, 0.0033808224834501743, 0.004264249932020903, 0.06185978651046753, -0.0058732773177325726, -0.047353845089673996, 0.009308317676186562, -0.005010658409446478, 0.052665840834379196, 0.03516380116343498, -0.031857799738645554, -0.016963843256235123, 0.005834709852933884, -0.015848074108362198, -0.014824486337602139, -0.01427688729017973, 0.026977714151144028, 0.04775241017341614, -0.011443151161074638, 0.042320676147937775, 0.03656645491719246, 0.05683886632323265, 0.03508596867322922, 0.028156133368611336, 0.03134952113032341, 0.025898005813360214, 0.019518384709954262, 0.0051080696284770966, -0.03422462195158005, 0.0298121590167284, 0.04251139983534813, 0.011998970061540604, 0.03236569091677666, 0.03619126230478287, 0.06905734539031982, -0.0032368781976401806, 0.036902546882629395, 0.010082649998366833, -0.05449435114860535, 0.030084818601608276, -0.049160782247781754, 0.016358695924282074, -0.025559954345226288, -0.022631388157606125, 0.05862516909837723, -0.006330323871225119, 0.005939393304288387, -0.009391442872583866, -0.051413342356681824, -0.01902114599943161, 0.008487838320434093, 0.02185237780213356, 0.0177836362272501, 0.04186597093939781, 0.0055771805346012115, 0.014940673485398293, -0.022504227235913277, 0.008756512776017189, -0.024930143728852272, -0.05363033711910248, 0.02429795451462269, -0.008753171190619469, -0.05335164815187454, 0.03743724524974823, 0.04014823958277702, 0.00470759067684412, -0.017831286415457726, -0.014737145975232124, 0.026034310460090637, 0.013225425966084003, 0.041756223887205124, -0.021018093451857567, 0.08526715636253357, 0.009281337261199951, 0.0011071385815739632, -0.021821001544594765, -0.024678166955709457, 0.08958607167005539, 0.04007284715771675, 0.04285415634512901, -0.07435847818851471, -0.02373482845723629, 0.03731805086135864, -0.022719884291291237, -0.05145185440778732, 0.03110993653535843, 0.026723910123109818, -0.0034970445558428764, 0.025009548291563988, 0.05525624006986618, 0.019539861008524895, -0.012895572930574417, 0.03181300684809685, 0.003266330109909177, -0.057375065982341766, -0.018029291182756424, 0.020821908488869667, 0.042512960731983185, -0.0010024794610217214, -0.06957744061946869, -0.006360052619129419, 0.007474077399820089, -0.03682964667677879, -0.048807524144649506, -0.0270139928907156, -0.02009844407439232, 0.019907645881175995, 0.004511942621320486, 0.008047533221542835, 0.019607186317443848, -0.033360209316015244, -0.026281146332621574, 0.007611763663589954, 0.023766325786709785, -0.04112451896071434, 0.029376422986388206, -0.004401340615004301, -0.0212863776832819, 0.007436863612383604, -0.020018113777041435, 0.01650167815387249, -0.006157933734357357, -0.004476537462323904, -0.03969979286193848, 0.01270693726837635, -0.022914398461580276, 0.0022393441759049892, -0.010853751562535763, -0.021884527057409286, 0.006859630346298218, -0.019766831770539284, -0.00014416968042496592, 0.007535309996455908, 0.030431590974330902, -0.053755022585392, -0.0846305713057518, -0.006382632069289684, 0.01589183509349823, -0.021809082478284836, -0.002248525619506836, 0.040697671473026276, 0.008222734555602074, -0.004904451780021191, -0.048777539283037186, 0.036052558571100235, 0.04891997203230858, 0.0008798548369668424, -0.007440077140927315, 0.01623760722577572, -0.03529568389058113, -0.0298148263245821, -0.027208935469388962, 0.03383003547787666, 0.022312939167022705, 0.0036071832291781902, -0.025036217644810677, 0.004458089359104633, -0.00621781637892127, -0.011694609187543392, -0.013460868038237095, -0.0013229175237938762, -0.015077107585966587, 0.0033869873732328415, 0.006425030995160341, 0.008308576419949532, -0.04963606968522072, 0.011675719171762466, -0.01062377542257309, 0.026735519990324974, 0.02676049806177616, -0.038693543523550034, -0.011896547861397266, -0.028765028342604637, -0.025447145104408264, -0.018096452578902245, 0.012578527443110943, 0.04372609406709671, -0.000017247752111870795, -0.002640702063217759, 0.06050910800695419, -0.007044370751827955, -0.03802813962101936, 0.029942309483885765, -0.03089740499854088, -0.0375264510512352, -0.026848455891013145, 0.023874670267105103, -0.03987564519047737, -0.03720968961715698, -0.04955446720123291, 0.01863427646458149, 0.021109791472554207, 0.004578348249197006, -0.03599102795124054, -0.07624636590480804, -0.041078560054302216, -0.003599987830966711, 0.006806688848882914, 0.017763037234544754, 0.009416062384843826, -0.007854186929762363, 0.017761707305908203, 0.01820860058069229, 0.01214626431465149, -0.03610053285956383, 0.008526328019797802, 0.003121379530057311, 0.007364824879914522, 0.023180358111858368, 0.008187021128833294, 0.05078064650297165, -0.01143624633550644, 0.01406036876142025, -0.04271648824214935, 0.018830033019185066, 0.0013267649337649345, -0.02351442724466324, 0.08142182976007462, -0.03266575559973717, -0.053834591060876846, 0.031047185882925987, 0.005661511328071356, 0.027860961854457855, 0.003586176782846451, -0.009398049674928188, -0.007949783466756344, 0.06205550953745842, -0.029063312336802483, 0.009357635863125324, 0.01836293563246727, 0.03692666068673134, 0.022692954167723656, 0.02687668986618519, -0.006746774539351463, 0.005855116993188858, -0.01995171420276165, -0.041973892599344254, 0.04956242814660072, -0.020599959418177605, -0.02047809027135372, 0.0029723220504820347, 0.026228323578834534, 0.0038113053888082504, -0.015247076749801636, -0.01188222412019968, 0.038385190069675446, 0.028555532917380333, 0.025921102613210678, 0.04862748831510544, 0.012897862121462822, -0.037146005779504776, -0.08446094393730164, -0.05572056770324707, 0.025783134624361992, -0.005693218670785427, 0.05750473588705063, -0.02597299963235855, 0.008056131191551685, 0.03636103868484497, -0.06477811932563782, -0.0005593624664470553, 0.009925799444317818, -0.037154149264097214, -0.06417089700698853, 0.004440909251570702, 0.003985879011452198, 0.05408046022057533, 0.00994098000228405, 0.03935099393129349, 0.04617582634091377, -0.024657761678099632, -0.04734347388148308, -0.037203092128038406, 0.010602334514260292, 0.04283204674720764, 0.005992315709590912, -0.04862256348133087, 0.017527392134070396, -0.03581424057483673, -0.05147537589073181, 0.029295435175299644, -0.028765037655830383, -0.03889981284737587, -0.019054220989346504, -0.008575296960771084, 0.007928202860057354, 0.07201799750328064, 0.017265576869249344, 0.017100075259804726, 0.0315958671271801, 0.008896984159946442, 0.021028729155659676, 0.0642414316534996, -0.020951367914676666, -0.022174285724759102, 0.022055139765143394, -0.013091844506561756, -0.05186638608574867, 0.01472663413733244, 0.03218350559473038, 0.023793336004018784, 0.0030668769031763077, -0.014118270948529243, -0.008629187010228634, -0.044708047062158585, 0.01998082920908928, -0.01193615235388279, 0.030764462426304817, 0.05371895805001259, 0.03845721110701561, -0.008593471720814705, 0.027997979894280434, -0.0063638039864599705, -0.014594679698348045, -0.054043933749198914, -0.016593150794506073, -0.03744766116142273, -0.010974403470754623, 0.05045214667916298, 0.0373997762799263, -0.006264446768909693, -0.003729849820956588, -0.03460865840315819, -0.0485953651368618, -0.00828520767390728, 0.014462212100625038, 0.03517008200287819, -0.02898644283413887, -0.0019108325941488147, -0.03550471365451813, -0.06696948409080505, 0.0325099378824234, -0.0065371147356927395, -0.0030580172315239906, -0.025127150118350983, 0.014908017590641975, -0.027265220880508423, -0.03417884558439255, 0.042604099959135056, -0.007236303761601448, 0.01209360919892788, -0.005453363060951233, 0.02378552407026291, 0.015054927207529545, -0.024880601093173027, -0.000030039278499316424, -0.009290479123592377, 0.0015611849958077073, -0.015915604308247566, 0.009178528562188148, -0.018902704119682312, -0.026920471340417862, -0.020971355959773064, -0.053038161247968674, 0.015463784337043762, -0.006347094662487507, -0.01840359903872013, 0.05514155700802803, 0.00577996950596571, -0.015891091898083687, 0.019615426659584045, 0.04456915706396103, -0.045665182173252106, 0.0031443240586668253, -0.00895723421126604, -0.03334364295005798, 0.0620851069688797, -0.041059527546167374, -0.011273288168013096, -0.012171833775937557, 0.008380354382097721, -0.0031011532992124557, -0.07733533531427383, 0.013246254995465279, 0.00909221637994051, -0.015165727585554123, 0.003789491020143032, 0.025068506598472595, 0.0015354949282482266, 0.029025321826338768, -0.009287270717322826, -0.01048579066991806, -0.0408034473657608, -0.00012890489597339183, 0.009634020738303661, -0.025984950363636017, 0.008792254142463207, 0.006695881485939026, 0.014359588734805584, 0.02719455026090145, -0.02784327231347561, 0.05937540903687477, 0.0171455480158329, 0.008927607908844948, -0.02589927427470684, 0.02277246117591858, 0.03735659271478653, -0.009313258342444897, 0.02534925565123558, 0.03144725412130356, -0.021864386275410652, 0.10024717450141907, 0.008782128803431988, 0.04887714609503746, -0.03180421516299248, 0.004518205299973488, -0.02466212585568428, -0.03392788767814636, 0.060659319162368774, -0.025453360751271248, -0.01944742165505886, -0.02064095437526703, -0.021700339391827583, 0.02120082825422287, 0.05270441994071007, -0.05058794096112251, 0.035552531480789185, -0.02020702138543129, 0.010692663490772247, -0.030314141884446144, 0.003886389546096325, -0.016537979245185852, 0.0054667177610099316, -0.027263781055808067, 0.08211018890142441, -0.012107591144740582, 0.013549888506531715, -0.00908646360039711, 0.007005821913480759, 0.05851425230503082, -0.013003536500036716, -0.009386609308421612, -0.0521012507379055, 0.054949723184108734, -0.03998275846242905, 0.002484062220901251 ]
<p>I performed principal components analysis on continuous variables describing 16 languages. Using the first two axes, which explain 76% of variance, I need to calculate the distance between each pair of languages as appeared on the first two axes; to test in a Mantel test the correlation between distances in linguistic variables and geographic distances. Could anyone help me: how can I do that?</p> <p>cheers</p>
74,035
[ -0.043932244181632996, 0.015068146400153637, -0.030650828033685684, 0.014311539940536022, 0.05990005284547806, 0.014814258553087711, 0.0037337334360927343, -0.010216854512691498, 0.020673751831054688, -0.0016584864351898432, 0.00515283877030015, 0.03687000274658203, 0.06934414803981781, 0.03173708915710449, 0.017903853207826614, 0.000429401668952778, -0.018825648352503777, 0.007661907467991114, 0.017255885526537895, -0.017453216016292572, 0.03504427522420883, 0.03319469839334488, 0.02779553271830082, -0.010739263147115707, 0.010673344135284424, 0.07193450629711151, 0.019333407282829285, -0.042125679552555084, 0.02707618661224842, 0.05043141171336174, -0.027750935405492783, -0.029478972777724266, 0.026942633092403412, 0.03513990342617035, 0.016017822548747063, 0.03158406540751457, -0.016367582604289055, -0.010280948132276535, -0.0354260578751564, 0.04558752477169037, -0.05846527963876724, -0.03449249640107155, 0.02009749598801136, 0.054797716438770294, -0.004429308697581291, 0.012179025448858738, 0.004914322402328253, -0.038796018809080124, 0.007899018935859203, -0.03648984804749489, 0.11276265233755112, -0.0152362622320652, 0.034008342772722244, 0.010355032049119473, 0.006394474301487207, 0.016025060787796974, 0.060532890260219574, 0.045449502766132355, -0.016922198235988617, -0.04901575669646263, -0.02058490738272667, -0.027686160057783127, 0.008859499357640743, -0.0024714518804103136, -0.017389846965670586, 0.026588769629597664, -0.04193396493792534, -0.012997793033719063, 0.05572690814733505, -0.011614791117608547, 0.038780611008405685, 0.020761270076036453, 0.05388348177075386, -0.043226953595876694, 0.005678105168044567, -0.021003229543566704, 0.027272725477814674, 0.03802143409848213, 0.01933865062892437, 0.016364676877856255, 0.00409243069589138, 0.005461195949465036, 0.006394946947693825, -0.015656307339668274, 0.03928276151418686, -0.00691108126193285, 0.06579254567623138, -0.036030009388923645, -0.011210630647838116, 0.02707456611096859, 0.025845550000667572, -0.01989041641354561, 0.025492027401924133, 0.06930408626794815, -0.03908377140760422, 0.02468116581439972, 0.010610230267047882, 0.047995515167713165, -0.027047550305724144, -0.005928158760070801, 0.00034294347278773785, -0.03168896585702896, 0.032907936722040176, 0.016483699902892113, -0.013583351857960224, 0.01349588017910719, -0.01939956471323967, -0.0017659030854701996, -0.019200481474399567, 0.02155565842986107, -0.000039467468013754115, 0.024845320731401443, 0.00961721409112215, -0.04493309557437897, 0.027921024709939957, 0.0029538830276578665, -0.031774524599313736, -0.013100708834826946, 0.031309209764003754, 0.07927904278039932, 0.025923952460289, -0.03219697251915932, 0.05002179741859436, -0.00876798015087843, -0.05820634588599205, 0.03460400179028511, 0.0007267036708071828, -0.016984639689326286, -0.012308248318731785, 0.05619823560118675, -0.016960499808192253, -0.026693150401115417, 0.01357682328671217, -0.01133333146572113, 0.019406316801905632, 0.008890122175216675, -0.08967821300029755, -0.05743690952658653, 0.030448395758867264, -0.039476122707128525, 0.021086696535348892, -0.061952732503414154, 0.004434687085449696, -0.0024752411991357803, 0.06255289912223816, -0.009063324891030788, 0.019358694553375244, 0.006334297358989716, 0.0060751005075871944, 0.009219862520694733, -0.04358377307653427, -0.03100123442709446, -0.013448159210383892, -0.03649100288748741, -0.01306124683469534, -0.08949605375528336, -0.005039198789745569, 0.014248305931687355, -0.006586529780179262, -0.023999342694878578, 0.03637486323714256, 0.03472788631916046, -0.030758609995245934, -0.03590213507413864, 0.012909125536680222, -0.0126190772280097, 0.07162364572286606, 0.01036723144352436, -0.015651719644665718, 0.015275178477168083, -0.010523037053644657, -0.01778952218592167, 0.00762256421148777, 0.03411458805203438, 0.06499022990465164, 0.010962747037410736, 0.003037151414901018, 0.041667208075523376, -0.023257574066519737, 0.013218866661190987, -0.025508157908916473, -0.04090272635221481, -0.014292125590145588, 0.012511609122157097, 0.05431918427348137, 0.030319128185510635, -0.005934238899499178, -0.03454197570681572, 0.033487603068351746, -0.037189170718193054, -0.027553869411349297, -0.05036887899041176, 0.015717532485723495, 0.010237225331366062, -0.03820383921265602, 0.011648460291326046, 0.01643591932952404, 0.009733001701533794, -0.03199229761958122, -0.034905124455690384, -0.058233898133039474, -0.03006169945001602, 0.04074685648083687, -0.021330248564481735, -0.02792305126786232, 0.07044254243373871, 0.056576233357191086, -0.005441918037831783, 0.05419112741947174, 0.0019108600681647658, -0.03363560885190964, 0.00007310826185857877, -0.041075848042964935, 0.008405947126448154, -0.009682118892669678, -0.0042371298186481, -0.01552661694586277, 0.03026428259909153, -0.012952311895787716, 0.013496032916009426, -0.02028760500252247, 0.07567916810512543, 0.05161869153380394, 0.017093390226364136, -0.0025535202585160732, -0.014001352712512016, -0.0012756449868902564, 0.008880081586539745, -0.011909371241927147, -0.03941386193037033, -0.04789729043841362, -0.04200367256999016, 0.03868343308568001, 0.023441342636942863, -0.052893076092004776, -0.0037330379709601402, 0.059540316462516785, 0.07842747867107391, 0.0011480855755507946, 0.0280010923743248, 0.011832966469228268, -0.017321569845080376, -0.015920504927635193, -0.013989998027682304, -0.020492002367973328, 0.008510126732289791, 0.027674786746501923, 0.006278317421674728, 0.05103631317615509, 0.006788705475628376, -0.022787701338529587, 0.04989834874868393, 0.029852205887436867, 0.051083412021398544, -0.030101550742983818, -0.012007465586066246, 0.04298900440335274, -0.009004369378089905, 0.021246287971735, 0.05124620348215103, 0.004111370071768761, -0.004956425633281469, 0.02683449164032936, -0.0018616379238665104, 0.005691445432603359, 0.041446566581726074, -0.04912860319018364, 0.027519354596734047, 0.015039358288049698, -0.0849207416176796, 0.017431600019335747, -0.02629552036523819, -0.042140357196331024, -0.018932059407234192, 0.0412762425839901, 0.059346895664930344, 0.035364534705877304, 0.024569427594542503, 0.01078935619443655, -0.0014669019728899002, 0.023386511951684952, -0.009456912986934185, -0.0006151431589387357, -0.001661463174968958, -0.05965447798371315, 0.021675273776054382, 0.0004924853565171361, 0.043663959950208664, -0.011342777870595455, -0.0059961420483887196, -0.020115336403250694, 0.08334529399871826, -0.01741945557296276, -0.058766454458236694, -0.01181062962859869, -0.04092142730951309, 0.030336769297719002, -0.012751667760312557, 0.02119247242808342, -0.01096552424132824, 0.02116570994257927, -0.010252854786813259, -0.0038339048624038696, -0.02433694340288639, -0.01737978309392929, -0.03836049884557724, 0.009378260932862759, 0.0002603558241389692, -0.006578254979103804, -0.010998551733791828, -0.003766868729144335, -0.045471809804439545, -0.031375620514154434, -0.03455387055873871, -0.05717010796070099, 0.04417263716459274, 0.025129130110144615, 0.01210766565054655, -0.019569752737879753, -0.027430864050984383, 0.07946973294019699, 0.013265293091535568, -0.08748220652341843, -0.05832648649811745, -0.025780437514185905, -0.06172487884759903, -0.008357075043022633, 0.02610095404088497, -0.016086293384432793, 0.004456169903278351, 0.020889559760689735, -0.0029436699114739895, 0.038297008723020554, 0.07664048671722412, -0.02786756493151188, -0.0003959489113185555, 0.028624599799513817, -0.010774340480566025, -0.024988962337374687, 0.029438579455018044, 0.03446492552757263, -0.03326413035392761, 0.041547976434230804, 0.00778799457475543, -0.0016899763140827417, 0.013296275399625301, -0.04036317020654678, -0.006958329118788242, -0.01254202239215374, -0.00661633163690567, -0.06649743765592575, 0.002191519131883979, -0.003316020593047142, 0.0026512222830206156, 0.02589970827102661, 0.021484168246388435, 0.044974178075790405, -0.027716439217329025, -0.016069980338215828, 0.0386955551803112, 0.04802299663424492, 0.015980903059244156, -0.02120744064450264, -0.007542417384684086, 0.0017486129654571414, 0.02369089610874653, -0.018255271017551422, -0.009869925677776337, 0.03085516206920147, 0.03662782907485962, 0.026802703738212585, 0.004082545172423124, -0.03147004544734955, 0.04461070895195007, -0.03971623256802559, 0.06033553183078766, 0.011391907930374146, 0.03213882818818092, -0.008024119772017002, 0.06322784721851349, 0.01923546940088272, -0.011186300776898861, -0.00524130929261446, -0.020215481519699097, -0.07694996893405914, 0.009922077879309654, -0.029478905722498894, -0.020783839747309685, 0.013987990096211433, -0.044831279665231705, 0.0374663844704628, 0.008873715996742249, -0.016458293423056602, -0.012735027819871902, 0.008799086324870586, -0.03464536741375923, -0.0017636894481256604, -0.015387182123959064, -0.02690473198890686, -0.009751354344189167, 0.02166096493601799, 0.028883159160614014, -0.028395315632224083, 0.03114735335111618, 0.017082076519727707, -0.01732604391872883, -0.03751809895038605, -0.017070014029741287, -0.010112656280398369, 0.04900456964969635, 0.038860682398080826, -0.0002583939640317112, 0.027106622233986855, -0.05259779095649719, 0.04105063155293465, -0.029891887679696083, 0.0572844073176384, 0.036757100373506546, 0.020962756127119064, -0.001114510465413332, -0.02741684764623642, -0.015351327136158943, 0.003202679567039013, 0.025435684248805046, -0.030589956790208817, -0.00022620447271037847, 0.03268750384449959, 0.03345296159386635, -0.07674726098775864, 0.020485352724790573, 0.04884248971939087, 0.041328947991132736, -0.013893341645598412, 0.021580785512924194, -0.020891448482871056, 0.015551285818219185, -0.01487497054040432, 0.02345322072505951, 0.008812803775072098, -0.0023379239719361067, -0.028706001117825508, 0.05316602811217308, -0.0010845890501514077, -0.03089248575270176, -0.019366540014743805, 0.008972174488008022, 0.006795757450163364, -0.01747223734855652, -0.012265078723430634, -0.013640613295137882, 0.047164712101221085, 0.03851214423775673, 0.010595808736979961, 0.012045405805110931, -0.07503918558359146, -0.00042043987195938826, 0.019233256578445435, 0.030228501185774803, -0.03387826681137085, -0.01905561424791813, -0.034357741475105286, -0.0018169215181842446, 0.04730580747127533, -0.03340885788202286, 0.06080834940075874, -0.002161962678655982, 0.018069835379719734, -0.018626710399985313, 0.008018615655601025, -0.030457163229584694, 0.010243875905871391, 0.006049548741430044, 0.03127433732151985, -0.010259918868541718, -0.0160335935652256, -0.05864378809928894, 0.017692778259515762, 0.019145434722304344, 0.04499766603112221, 0.016454465687274933, -0.017054596915841103, 0.022702395915985107, 0.0012072303798049688, -0.016951879486441612, -0.03184648975729942, 0.030982008203864098, 0.011238930746912956, -0.019381990656256676, 0.04851590096950531, -0.02829567715525627, -0.023438220843672752, 0.005577890668064356, 0.004308183211833239, 0.004218723624944687, -0.021009651944041252, 0.009610326960682869, 0.03604134917259216, 0.05459889397025108, -0.007769386749714613, 0.04654781520366669, 0.0037867692299187183, 0.004132955335080624, 0.009339690208435059, -0.046816952526569366, 0.010790159925818443, -0.017118167132139206, -0.041579779237508774, -0.021176496520638466, -0.015244660899043083, 0.01166830025613308, 0.00431490084156394, -0.018279271200299263, 0.03647460415959358, -0.031198453158140182, 0.006418818607926369, -0.02806173451244831, 0.024496007710695267, -0.01783100515604019, 0.011811692267656326, 0.02485903725028038, 0.029467454180121422, -0.006895433645695448, -0.018622620031237602, 0.06541415303945541, -0.008171048015356064, 0.005871593952178955, -0.025980981066823006, -0.005177261773496866, 0.0004948924761265516, -0.021807126700878143, -0.020159529522061348, -0.010499414056539536, -0.028612405061721802, 0.031111840158700943, -0.020774738863110542, 0.037246789783239365, 0.05157449468970299, -0.04639475792646408, -0.0335732027888298, 0.01946563459932804, 0.027074629440903664, 0.05291295424103737, -0.04168196767568588, 0.01534303929656744, -0.045258279889822006, -0.010959330014884472, -0.058019381016492844, -0.06160827353596687, 0.017496950924396515, 0.030270850285887718, -0.028403185307979584, -0.08630050718784332, -0.05577878654003143, 0.02341429516673088, 0.016575288027524948, -0.007275284267961979, 0.0726594552397728, -0.009670417755842209, 0.006369165610522032, -0.011330398730933666, 0.011419435031712055, 0.04947143420577049, 0.006023035384714603, 0.005501204635947943, 0.016074564307928085, -0.016188016161322594, -0.001113183214329183, -0.011090656742453575, 0.02734583616256714, -0.029031522572040558, 0.006461575161665678, -0.03552759438753128, 0.015776999294757843, 0.011764733120799065, -0.021138794720172882, -0.007044515572488308, -0.032658711075782776, -0.0018598289461806417, 0.005941726732999086, -0.027190692722797394, 0.012770543806254864, -0.019836340099573135, 0.003692630212754011, -0.06746790558099747, 0.02511722408235073, -0.04431985691189766, 0.007044035475701094, -0.010890001431107521, -0.0003803725412581116, -0.0002917716628871858, 0.01102218497544527, 0.04013691842556, -0.02856125682592392, 0.03356415778398514, 0.024113528430461884, 0.007629082538187504, 0.005801518447697163, 0.048650991171598434, 0.011863750405609608, 0.006261416710913181, 0.02474913001060486, -0.011426040902733803, -0.013160116039216518, -0.015272760763764381, -0.026683857664465904, 0.09855910390615463, -0.010785032995045185, 0.058737367391586304, 0.07608360052108765, 0.009538826532661915, 0.026304615661501884, -0.004342390689998865, -0.036211706697940826, 0.004631970077753067, 0.026006652042269707, 0.05194248631596565, -0.0064237238839268684, -0.000651848444249481, 0.02696220576763153, 0.07036982476711273, 0.002192116342484951, 0.06184093654155731, 0.000853662088047713, 0.012156489305198193, -0.005885933991521597, -0.025471750646829605, -0.04135163128376007, -0.005106087774038315, -0.035264067351818085, -0.00733844842761755, -0.013402098789811134, 0.0017916535725817084, 0.04572296887636185, 0.03851660341024399, -0.030432138592004776, -0.013152006082236767, -0.02125530317425728, -0.018644874915480614, 0.016964007169008255, 0.00598892942070961, 0.010304510593414307, 0.009423451498150826, 0.011233977973461151, 0.05471651256084442, -0.014095649123191833, 0.04485325142741203, -0.034045327454805374, -0.05900775268673897, -0.014747546054422855, -0.0053097871132195, -0.035757023841142654, 0.04348073899745941, -0.025052422657608986, -0.050399016588926315, 0.019455982372164726, -0.002461034106090665, -0.015555009245872498, -0.014579434879124165, 0.008770371787250042, -0.012369338423013687, 0.07901556044816971, 0.01612034998834133, 0.004630437586456537, -0.0017886451678350568, -0.008957043290138245, 0.10415564477443695, 0.059778496623039246, 0.029013270512223244, -0.10572154074907303, 0.03897304832935333, -0.013493463397026062, -0.019185524433851242, -0.048723917454481125, 0.01089747715741396, -0.016589734703302383, 0.0049080876633524895, 0.032177336513996124, 0.037587184458971024, 0.004615016747266054, -0.006264091469347477, 0.052701931446790695, -0.019681882113218307, -0.04303111508488655, 0.015470259822905064, 0.010291706770658493, -0.02658461406826973, -0.029906651005148888, -0.02117067016661167, 0.027966994792222977, -0.015904948115348816, 0.003882819786667824, -0.032189127057790756, -0.024733608588576317, 0.024829450994729996, -0.008123752661049366, -0.045020002871751785, 0.027711231261491776, 0.048210203647613525, 0.024275340139865875, -0.027171218767762184, -0.03013051301240921, 0.06073516979813576, -0.028550855815410614, 0.0020941374823451042, -0.005784901324659586, -0.032644424587488174, 0.02045411430299282, 0.00896797701716423, -0.0121634965762496, -0.04262358322739601, -0.043408893048763275, -0.04413282871246338, 0.022881628945469856, 0.021411985158920288, 0.0038955053314566612, -0.009527708403766155, 0.03880772367119789, -0.014009959995746613, -0.04454869031906128, 0.007949354127049446, 0.019387682899832726, 0.016202984377741814, 0.005933374632149935, -0.019059687852859497, 0.00010042537178378552, 0.01913352683186531, -0.01422432903200388, 0.0063318065367639065, -0.006010476499795914, -0.0021203968208283186, -0.008649797178804874, -0.05322140455245972, 0.05407309532165527, -0.010048854164779186, -0.034892428666353226, -0.00693749962374568, -0.026465199887752533, -0.03302011266350746, 0.021294621750712395, 0.008601072244346142, 0.01812499761581421, 0.012602041475474834, 0.013904486782848835, -0.05529474839568138, -0.017158905044198036, -0.024216419085860252, 0.008248258382081985, -0.04103117063641548, -0.027538442984223366, -0.029061036184430122, 0.01005344744771719, 0.041628651320934296, 0.036823708564043045, 0.026055190712213516, 0.0009470380027778447, -0.010001128539443016, 0.013666199520230293, -0.0032811493147164583, -0.04748710244894028, -0.013592150993645191, -0.023128336295485497, -0.04982146620750427, -0.024574998766183853, -0.03108912892639637, 0.05371462181210518, 0.05450773984193802, -0.01803317666053772, 0.007432982791215181, 0.03682730346918106, -0.025967517867684364, 0.018048042431473732, 0.015439820475876331, -0.06398241966962814, 0.018673306331038475, 0.013429923914372921, -0.004546415992081165, -0.05733849108219147, -0.019325248897075653, -0.015994397923350334, -0.028480378910899162, 0.014953072182834148, -0.01939276233315468, -0.049560703337192535, -0.008877657353878021, 0.013171255588531494, 0.007182592060416937, -0.07076413929462433, -0.01705242693424225, -0.03639005497097969, 0.00047654678928665817, -0.039629869163036346, 0.013483557850122452, 0.0015280894003808498, -0.008312767371535301, -0.02329838275909424, 0.012507247738540173, 0.06977944076061249, 0.03143635392189026, 0.02869940735399723, -0.021814502775669098, 0.02939142845571041, 0.008912547491490841, 0.033578988164663315, -0.02618393301963806, -0.011712725274264812, 0.018855083733797073, -0.05484350398182869, -0.041515011340379715, 0.025709938257932663, -0.014164261519908905, 0.04181961342692375, 0.005193461664021015, 0.013454255647957325, -0.035893514752388, 0.0663098618388176, 0.005094849970191717, -0.027164792641997337, -0.04906807839870453, 0.0470006950199604, 0.003971620462834835, 0.020742066204547882, 0.023611819371581078, 0.013919652439653873, -0.0219549760222435, 0.03283021226525307, 0.05687405914068222, -0.016132937744259834, 0.022039305418729782, 0.0003079781017731875, -0.027027742937207222, -0.027602514252066612, 0.013090314343571663, -0.06250320374965668, 0.04107948765158653, 0.02415025793015957, -0.01040769275277853, 0.008933893404901028, -0.0014912982005625963, 0.004004884976893663, -0.05253946781158447, -0.0008801348158158362, -0.03072393126785755, 0.004969480913132429, 0.06272245198488235, -0.08808215707540512, 0.020765936002135277, 0.05538665130734444, -0.04322925955057144, 0.014511163346469402, -0.003280115546658635, -0.020784178748726845, -0.024273095652461052, 0.014740422368049622, 0.03065340965986252, 0.06985592097043991, -0.0005456274375319481, 0.030242454260587692, 0.03984125703573227, 0.04429462179541588, -0.02174120768904686, -0.04556591436266899, -0.01966239884495735, -0.025001758709549904, 0.020147958770394325, -0.04518617317080498, 0.03666984662413597, -0.021063731983304024, -0.034641291946172714, 0.010931096039712429, -0.044044166803359985, 0.017256228253245354, 0.033334508538246155, 0.013643172569572926, 0.015995752066373825, 0.02504441700875759, -0.016164014115929604, -0.014288432896137238, 0.02149156667292118, -0.029687609523534775, -0.006236337125301361, 0.03064035065472126, -0.038044337183237076, 0.0004572327306959778, 0.015593739226460457, 0.000318184174830094, -0.022117195650935173, -0.011830083094537258, -0.0184905044734478, -0.007728195283561945, 0.010696401819586754, 0.025121867656707764, 0.0024321696255356073, -0.03776584938168526, -0.0013145692646503448, -0.03986816853284836, 0.02066836692392826, 0.046955425292253494, 0.00945519469678402, -0.04530634731054306, 0.013722289353609085, 0.007338172290474176, -0.04055162891745567, 0.0099818529561162, -0.0227473434060812, 0.02573607861995697, -0.04603096470236778, -0.03587901592254639, 0.02306666597723961, -0.02190374955534935, -0.004103062674403191, -0.013653757981956005, -0.00890217162668705, 0.031984228640794754, -0.01561889797449112, -0.015356977470219135, 0.02742771990597248, -0.010979886166751385, 0.01516185887157917, -0.03550214320421219, 0.03302525356411934, -0.0028088586404919624, -0.021316712722182274, -0.03516974672675133, -0.0042451368644833565, -0.06017852574586868, 0.02821919322013855, 0.03917080909013748, 0.011458516120910645, 0.019487082958221436, -0.04865515977144241, 0.023016920313239098, 0.002653507050126791, -0.03830995038151741, 0.0653589516878128, -0.00799572840332985, -0.029695142060518265, -0.0020846643019467592, -0.03288736939430237, -0.006470466032624245, 0.022523989900946617, -0.0016139802755787969, -0.024803996086120605, 0.010327686555683613, 0.016688905656337738, -0.007360491901636124, 0.020627496764063835, -0.03311280533671379, -0.014621415175497532, 0.01566402241587639, 0.0031003840267658234, -0.028603345155715942, 0.03304297849535942, 0.0102918092161417, -0.04702343791723251, 0.023364193737506866, -0.0298306904733181, -0.02153954468667507, 0.015769295394420624, 0.0214361771941185, 0.03061431087553501, -0.05428840592503548, 0.03269345313310623, 0.032538462430238724, -0.022420722991228104, 0.006722490768879652, 0.025051826611161232, 0.037328146398067474, 0.005485306028276682, -0.012769242748618126, 0.02984635718166828, -0.00387965957634151, -0.007236897945404053, 0.03053111955523491, 0.005213819444179535, 0.03514169529080391, -0.003797991434112191, -0.00043097298475913703, -0.027655409649014473, -0.025709856301546097, 0.026685798540711403, -0.006350082810968161, 0.027164971455931664, -0.027736658230423927, 0.007429346442222595, 0.0024759715888649225, -0.006537767592817545, 0.012774181552231312, -0.0006666589761152864, -0.016739487648010254, 0.06031255051493645, -0.026689670979976654, 0.008371559903025627, -0.07165396958589554, -0.002992841647937894, -0.04212907329201698, -0.022640179842710495, -0.001760034472681582, -0.013225692324340343, -0.011123011820018291, 0.04192766174674034, -0.01246720552444458, -0.022669818252325058, 0.021511686965823174, -0.018399512395262718, 0.021744415163993835, 0.0003560880431905389, 0.025032594799995422, -0.01817469671368599, -0.004795720335096121, -0.05152077600359917, -0.004911831114441156, 0.0433320514857769, 0.04432369023561478, 0.007425298448652029, -0.03392646834254265, -0.03389349207282066, -0.013203655369579792, 0.02388015016913414, -0.05748039484024048, -0.04532487690448761, -0.03496171534061432, 0.01832812838256359, -0.01939561404287815, 0.030663546174764633 ]
<p>I have time series data for a set of cities that goes back for about 10 years. I also have the data at the state level for almost 30 years. There was an event that occurred about 20 years ago, that is captured in the longer, state level data, but not the city data, that I would like to investigate at the city level. </p> <p>What I think might be useful is to create some kind of ARIMA model that regresses the state data as an exogenous variable. If I were to do this, how do I use the model to backfill the city data such that it ends at the same point as where the actual city data starts? Is there already a canonical method of doing something like this? Thanks for any help you can give (literature references, R libraries, etc.)</p>
36,659
[ -0.0055501386523246765, -0.009879696182906628, 0.007968666963279247, 0.021652601659297943, 0.0134276133030653, -0.016644306480884552, -0.007263595703989267, -0.0004397110315039754, 0.03326039016246796, -0.04646329954266548, 0.006681857630610466, 0.042617544531822205, 0.022887442260980606, 0.013583947904407978, 0.04775677248835564, -0.002231837483122945, -0.01014766190201044, -0.009705309756100178, -0.016714297235012054, -0.012176435440778732, -0.0001131096578319557, -0.011397411115467548, -0.038474190980196, -0.0005218998994678259, -0.01135070901364088, 0.011103146709501743, 0.040324922651052475, -0.0006696101627312601, -0.008743174374103546, 0.06737648695707321, 0.012624346651136875, -0.017918279394507408, -0.015269391238689423, 0.041107792407274246, 0.022783489897847176, 0.00027508795028552413, -0.022049302235245705, -0.04158652946352959, 0.009204470552504063, 0.04424850270152092, -0.044589631259441376, -0.011707047000527382, 0.007510012481361628, 0.04587278887629509, -0.009999801404774189, 0.022714762017130852, 0.010500202886760235, 0.009943044744431973, 0.03737667202949524, -0.022624531760811806, 0.07858514040708542, -0.039970967918634415, 0.024430355057120323, 0.038127634674310684, -0.01988297700881958, -0.0003045227495022118, 0.07449126243591309, 0.06222080811858177, 0.011449740268290043, -0.033601392060518265, -0.02967548370361328, -0.004274066537618637, -0.03358399495482445, -0.028677374124526978, -0.052904073148965836, -0.005986772011965513, -0.012290682643651962, -0.009085563942790031, 0.016778340563178062, -0.07362513244152069, -0.007382656913250685, -0.011741101741790771, 0.06233704835176468, -0.018363172188401222, 0.005824042018502951, -0.04047790542244911, 0.023228224366903305, -0.03036828339099884, 0.030019864439964294, 0.02047414891421795, 0.018432745710015297, 0.0006608635885640979, 0.05424769967794418, 0.06246476247906685, 0.002728966996073723, 0.021180981770157814, 0.05465245991945267, -0.056396644562482834, 0.0035845483653247356, 0.06596778333187103, -0.040904104709625244, -0.0012645344249904156, 0.043079398572444916, 0.005133780650794506, -0.05690114200115204, 0.027041131630539894, -0.023012228310108185, 0.05600890889763832, -0.010515300557017326, 0.026476290076971054, -0.011937407776713371, -0.0350787527859211, -0.00975157879292965, 0.020661331713199615, -0.03932209312915802, 0.009489508345723152, -0.004302019253373146, -0.024432001635432243, -0.03205444663763046, -0.02871023863554001, -0.06073080003261566, 0.012173065915703773, -0.0069709960371255875, -0.013130434788763523, 0.016126709058880806, 0.0017224717885255814, -0.02374468930065632, -0.027614472433924675, 0.047017306089401245, 0.06598333269357681, 0.03822224959731102, -0.028995566070079803, 0.0018511016387492418, -0.04070928692817688, -0.04284766688942909, 0.01191750168800354, -0.02246907539665699, -0.02807137928903103, -0.04178664833307266, 0.06467866152524948, 0.012844271957874298, -0.040652912110090256, 0.02274485118687153, -0.038613371551036835, 0.08824510127305984, -0.009033489041030407, -0.08023137599229813, -0.010601039044559002, 0.032851193100214005, 0.0015271594747900963, 0.024114176630973816, -0.058013446629047394, 0.02135644294321537, -0.016215892508625984, 0.08484009653329849, 0.03966369107365608, 0.008647473528981209, 0.05434565246105194, 0.018377669155597687, -0.024923037737607956, 0.00234692869707942, -0.016354583203792572, -0.004199211951345205, 0.009968118742108345, -0.01849587820470333, -0.09102657437324524, 0.008599002845585346, 0.0327170267701149, -0.019021447747945786, 0.018159525468945503, 0.07010955363512039, 0.02494264580309391, -0.019072305411100388, 0.028081417083740234, -0.03399210050702095, -0.021017204970121384, 0.09218724817037582, 0.020133085548877716, -0.03282584622502327, -0.008099023252725601, -0.003688212251290679, 0.013777979649603367, 0.01204581931233406, 0.04087340086698532, 0.02488163858652115, -0.021510247141122818, -0.004004648886620998, -0.006267214193940163, -0.039120152592659, 0.02067776396870613, 0.00006692147871945053, -0.0009504531626589596, 0.011026964522898197, -0.043969571590423584, 0.013692831620573997, -0.004119629506021738, -0.03352532535791397, -0.021319342777132988, 0.04594013839960098, -0.05781999230384827, 0.007856194861233234, -0.055017754435539246, 0.01826179027557373, -0.027653316035866737, 0.017395690083503723, 0.02254517562687397, -0.01581324264407158, 0.05854132026433945, -0.007483190391212702, -0.02908114343881607, -0.010986030101776123, -0.030472764745354652, 0.01675863191485405, -0.04896596819162369, 0.0048299143090844154, 0.03560424968600273, 0.05400213971734047, -0.015161796472966671, 0.03322005644440651, -0.049123652279376984, -0.020258909091353416, -0.018010174855589867, -0.029041865840554237, -0.008035101927816868, -0.03883490711450577, 0.0018281597876921296, 0.022331083193421364, -0.006315594073385, 0.008702279068529606, 0.005524598527699709, -0.0629042461514473, 0.039815545082092285, 0.06554415822029114, 0.02293999493122101, -0.012615696527063847, 0.005495300050824881, 0.0336172990500927, 0.04370206966996193, -0.02549082413315773, -0.040588900446891785, -0.04456140473484993, -0.018506726250052452, 0.017517851665616035, 0.00012241180229466408, -0.018175767734646797, 0.018502874299883842, 0.0730513408780098, 0.033346641808748245, 0.010142569430172443, 0.05453624948859215, 0.003662443021312356, 0.019997743889689445, 0.002602787921205163, 0.0004587900184560567, -0.006582873873412609, 0.012163343839347363, 0.028274694457650185, -0.007205251604318619, 0.008853781037032604, 0.018148837611079216, -0.00848685298115015, 0.015225999057292938, 0.012880390509963036, 0.034097909927368164, 0.00274173473007977, -0.053979892283678055, 0.05496862903237343, -0.025082778185606003, 0.005716376472264528, 0.005407310090959072, 0.015570958144962788, 0.02203507348895073, -0.010156863369047642, 0.0012646769173443317, 0.01275804452598095, 0.04273687303066254, -0.025111204013228416, 0.022564267739653587, 0.009138735011219978, -0.01743164099752903, 0.020726582035422325, -0.021663935855031013, -0.013248845003545284, -0.07846623659133911, -0.003786189015954733, 0.036872297525405884, 0.035023145377635956, 0.003737040562555194, -0.008744718506932259, -0.03304243087768555, 0.0055735427886247635, -0.03432732820510864, -0.007271203678101301, 0.023652460426092148, -0.012027986347675323, 0.04920264706015587, 0.009922402910888195, 0.010479212738573551, 0.027337701991200447, 0.02963826060295105, 0.009644700214266777, 0.03001965768635273, 0.012959021143615246, -0.019976487383246422, -0.012765927240252495, -0.03658555448055267, -0.005298050586134195, -0.010658001527190208, 0.006046542897820473, 0.04394649341702461, 0.04896234720945358, -0.05130281671881676, 0.006035858299583197, -0.07064100354909897, 0.007581617217510939, -0.01662641018629074, 0.0013909898698329926, 0.022985033690929413, -0.0004166395519860089, 0.02964659221470356, 0.020854029804468155, -0.04622379690408707, -0.007313903886824846, -0.08064910024404526, -0.06091104447841644, 0.0197527427226305, -0.0014209006913006306, 0.008952483534812927, 0.010040114633738995, 0.005584549158811569, 0.02739677205681801, 0.02724441885948181, -0.0047279889695346355, -0.051381394267082214, -0.018079550936818123, 0.012204107828438282, -0.026151344180107117, -0.0045241788029670715, 0.043655820190906525, -0.01539574284106493, 0.014831616543233395, 0.002412732457742095, 0.05588237941265106, 0.039979707449674606, 0.001305298414081335, 0.01734805852174759, 0.002713422756642103, 0.0017015031771734357, 0.017680136486887932, 0.03467106446623802, -0.01974024809896946, -0.018421417102217674, 0.005338187795132399, -0.02706928551197052, 0.02689278870820999, 0.004438762087374926, -0.021360794082283974, -0.006639543920755386, -0.04189261049032211, -0.038921695202589035, -0.03301553055644035, 0.02885906957089901, -0.005926600191742182, -0.009403683245182037, -0.011920043267309666, 0.03220352157950401, 0.04838477075099945, -0.011854426935315132, 0.004069328308105469, 0.019764220342040062, 0.0463733971118927, -0.042224232107400894, -0.022154279053211212, -0.010931964963674545, -0.013316475786268711, 0.017825575545430183, -0.0180735494941473, -0.0008641040767543018, 0.03411659970879555, 0.01287288311868906, 0.01635582745075226, -0.01945282518863678, -0.0362311415374279, 0.0236427653580904, -0.07655883580446243, 0.03300902619957924, 0.0005358096677809954, 0.04837818443775177, 0.021412506699562073, 0.02400284819304943, 0.016209347173571587, 0.006968323606997728, 0.0353655070066452, -0.006697551812976599, -0.05569353699684143, 0.03523389995098114, 0.012487410567700863, -0.0014420630177482963, 0.008380545303225517, -0.027039237320423126, 0.029319996014237404, -0.017793452367186546, 0.015147894620895386, 0.007507901638746262, -0.021533042192459106, -0.04870389401912689, 0.007637580391019583, -0.03262246400117874, -0.00970005989074707, -0.0010026698000729084, -0.016790635883808136, 0.05641507729887962, -0.020211955532431602, 0.024523695930838585, 0.03396628424525261, 0.024875538423657417, -0.02191128395497799, -0.05446724593639374, 0.005446362774819136, 0.04430297017097473, 0.04746929556131363, 0.05874152109026909, 0.022753646597266197, -0.07988151162862778, 0.0451786071062088, 0.010251853615045547, 0.020447667688131332, 0.029256166890263557, -0.00842671561986208, -0.05322841554880142, -0.017955556511878967, -0.012496024370193481, 0.0073439572006464005, 0.020075704902410507, 0.02488626353442669, 0.02229824662208557, 0.042863570153713226, 0.04773009940981865, -0.0602983720600605, 0.018397768959403038, 0.07504763454198837, 0.022987544536590576, 0.028999989852309227, -0.04471532627940178, -0.032063476741313934, 0.019440291449427605, 0.016891328617930412, 0.01681312918663025, -0.04339802637696266, -0.022981544956564903, 0.0025555191095918417, 0.05972684919834137, 0.008025907911360264, -0.019973149523139, 0.010287384502589703, 0.03476404398679733, 0.06895575672388077, 0.024134032428264618, -0.0499466173350811, 0.026086322963237762, 0.02831828035414219, 0.04550023376941681, 0.054552946239709854, 0.04627348110079765, -0.11809120327234268, -0.0028366660699248314, 0.03865443542599678, 0.0018190125701949, -0.02270839735865593, -0.034255173057317734, -0.06351500004529953, -0.03478081524372101, 0.03805665671825409, -0.008559231646358967, 0.022735847160220146, -0.0018689456628635526, 0.004864299204200506, -0.015196274034678936, -0.059026703238487244, -0.019829334691166878, 0.026763038709759712, -0.040733665227890015, 0.05680287256836891, -0.028341908007860184, -0.038029033690690994, -0.05636490136384964, -0.005199790000915527, -0.006282031536102295, 0.01907333731651306, -0.007389036472886801, -0.027040692046284676, 0.016687147319316864, 0.02576504275202751, -0.016018114984035492, -0.03558656573295593, 0.004153395537286997, -0.0028750342316925526, -0.015522727742791176, 0.04680933430790901, 0.017731279134750366, -0.001786529552191496, 0.006247849203646183, -0.0019353341776877642, -0.011917206458747387, 0.012310354970395565, -0.009525776840746403, 0.06400511413812637, -0.0021739634685218334, 0.004543175920844078, 0.07176565378904343, 0.03450006619095802, 0.03774743154644966, -0.028649695217609406, -0.0015014742966741323, 0.03181543946266174, -0.023908479139208794, -0.008936121128499508, -0.020206740126013756, -0.011662107892334461, -0.021161597222089767, 0.00713109178468585, 0.02145462855696678, 0.012453606352210045, -0.02534860372543335, 0.0012032819213345647, 0.02546931989490986, 0.06709547340869904, -0.03656112030148506, -0.03382182866334915, -0.0037710678298026323, 0.028927139937877655, -0.04572663456201553, -0.01126912236213684, -0.015981335192918777, 0.0021144638303667307, -0.007524993736296892, 0.003679534187540412, -0.04192241653800011, 0.030961979180574417, -0.013461065478622913, -0.06176610291004181, 0.028915246948599815, -0.02471977099776268, 0.014001486822962761, -0.017176248133182526, 0.014359699562191963, 0.010029824450612068, -0.03350572660565376, 0.035498082637786865, 0.02288471907377243, -0.011902322992682457, 0.0011424330295994878, -0.05852704867720604, 0.03640991449356079, 0.023815492168068886, 0.040890712291002274, -0.08280237764120102, -0.04505959898233414, 0.04013323038816452, -0.014102385379374027, -0.04602949321269989, -0.05428996682167053, 0.018734902143478394, -0.034881591796875, -0.026184014976024628, -0.043719254434108734, 0.03989209234714508, -0.030457064509391785, 0.002540125511586666, 0.02140803635120392, 0.023291371762752533, 0.05664186179637909, -0.02449684590101242, -0.01964247040450573, 0.014888286590576172, -0.013666074723005295, -0.017119185999035835, -0.016881508752703667, 0.029329387471079826, -0.015802429988980293, 0.03148123249411583, -0.02833895944058895, -0.00030985698685981333, 0.03955541178584099, -0.030341988429427147, -0.027919847518205643, 0.03310545161366463, -0.011022407561540604, 0.029589461162686348, -0.03832031413912773, -0.0036301552318036556, -0.024412091821432114, -0.028005536645650864, -0.010636769235134125, -0.005810822360217571, -0.00016995616897474974, -0.004994736053049564, 0.03388465195894241, 0.0021874115336686373, -0.00022226286819204688, 0.015618016943335533, 0.053247321397066116, -0.003966251853853464, -0.02275371365249157, -0.014502491801977158, 0.00814732350409031, 0.03217126056551933, -0.019038241356611252, -0.015926677733659744, 0.014896190725266933, -0.007659293245524168, -0.06978496164083481, -0.03551311418414116, -0.014544742181897163, 0.004464073572307825, 0.06147675961256027, -0.014503685757517815, 0.027886999770998955, 0.0274429302662611, 0.048161689192056656, 0.022292081266641617, -0.04944971203804016, -0.004286366049200296, 0.023614201694726944, -0.014676031656563282, 0.06332627683877945, -0.026897339150309563, 0.010651477612555027, -0.01047312282025814, 0.034215863794088364, -0.012906673364341259, 0.059086285531520844, 0.028456084430217743, 0.017010103911161423, 0.04160280153155327, -0.013648326508700848, -0.021471260115504265, -0.014130471274256706, -0.03321615979075432, 0.027542535215616226, -0.02251947671175003, -0.023042291402816772, 0.048216670751571655, 0.06595370918512344, 0.0179609302431345, -0.03330594301223755, -0.026566093787550926, -0.06369772553443909, -0.014634229242801666, 0.013859129510819912, 0.001553701120428741, 0.02763126790523529, 0.03654162958264351, 0.06489452719688416, 0.004771979991346598, 0.00010261243733111769, -0.03302450850605965, -0.07371166348457336, -0.010202092118561268, -0.051847197115421295, -0.03642459213733673, 0.027269335463643074, -0.005108820740133524, -0.008491616696119308, 0.03106050193309784, -0.016532529145479202, -0.010691513307392597, -0.03402107208967209, 0.00474550761282444, 0.029099291190505028, 0.08810906857252121, 0.007626852486282587, 0.0026316754519939423, -0.020749010145664215, 0.008135196752846241, 0.10947573184967041, 0.09167270362377167, 0.014030209742486477, -0.10194092243909836, -0.006730040535330772, 0.027221346274018288, 0.009375748224556446, -0.04338458180427551, 0.010179500095546246, 0.01408839225769043, -0.02229006588459015, 0.04992685467004776, 0.04009918496012688, -0.008475598879158497, -0.02365919016301632, 0.07224064320325851, -0.057030268013477325, -0.00827278383076191, -0.00041107163997367024, 0.009663078002631664, -0.021243134513497353, -0.009301378391683102, -0.05669618770480156, 0.0006979077588766813, -0.008953146636486053, -0.03457765653729439, -0.007928171195089817, -0.007968343794345856, -0.008358027786016464, 0.0010403721826151013, -0.0050422861240804195, 0.032674964517354965, -0.008257605135440826, 0.028218382969498634, -0.022706706076860428, -0.019341586157679558, -0.020267633721232414, -0.02005242556333542, 0.009995806962251663, 0.014996103011071682, 0.026266874745488167, 0.010295342653989792, -0.020943358540534973, -0.02475113980472088, -0.04186851531267166, 0.0007841523038223386, -0.046952489763498306, 0.038803718984127045, -0.03463283181190491, 0.0034194241743534803, -0.013070794753730297, 0.03285080939531326, 0.007518565747886896, -0.00420761713758111, -0.03159186989068985, 0.020379748195409775, 0.03662034869194031, -0.033425889909267426, -0.007715834770351648, -0.01282078679651022, 0.009054313413798809, 0.0042030601762235165, 0.05028342455625534, 0.03641234710812569, -0.019404664635658264, 0.017482737079262733, -0.04576841741800308, 0.04467996582388878, -0.03363034874200821, -0.01707753911614418, 0.00452935416251421, 0.018605859950184822, -0.02735491842031479, -0.0031274009961634874, 0.042657628655433655, -0.027202166616916656, 0.006201053969562054, -0.010574180632829666, 0.00672743609175086, -0.03519956022500992, 0.0394594669342041, 0.011628670617938042, -0.02411787398159504, -0.00029417453333735466, -0.02633599564433098, 0.005174950696527958, 0.028816204518079758, 0.04388730973005295, 0.0031786661129444838, 0.0004654947842936963, -0.020155105739831924, 0.05129680037498474, 0.02541486546397209, -0.02840624563395977, -0.012339468114078045, -0.026479635387659073, -0.04397359862923622, 0.028674118220806122, -0.010366834700107574, 0.04691554605960846, 0.021969633176922798, 0.00863636750727892, -0.03098743036389351, 0.03158382326364517, -0.005846931133419275, 0.006478350143879652, 0.0264454185962677, -0.06645795702934265, 0.010119149461388588, -0.007429258897900581, 0.012327145785093307, -0.04219547286629677, -0.01989915408194065, 0.012559037655591965, -0.023687046021223068, 0.017081184312701225, -0.001683984650298953, -0.04654242470860481, 0.06489430367946625, -0.04209167882800102, 0.027146026492118835, -0.03552662581205368, 0.0029903205577284098, -0.06672810763120651, -0.020717885345220566, -0.038460515439510345, -0.0601358525454998, -0.015913894400000572, 0.01745479553937912, -0.009160012938082218, 0.005006453953683376, 0.03626398369669914, 0.01477066706866026, 0.012042392045259476, 0.014166422188282013, 0.0206857081502676, 0.009059282951056957, 0.03878802806138992, -0.03356507420539856, -0.03122604265809059, -0.004562849178910255, -0.046581581234931946, -0.036568671464920044, 0.01954793557524681, -0.008267832919955254, 0.044956713914871216, 0.018522029742598534, -0.012604206800460815, 0.023098889738321304, 0.028519563376903534, 0.01196063868701458, -0.015492228791117668, 0.017750604078173637, 0.012374955229461193, 0.02922281250357628, 0.015710100531578064, 0.03951834514737129, 0.015449385158717632, -0.004270763136446476, -0.008129405789077282, 0.04286479577422142, 0.00000348927937920962, -0.0033451642375439405, 0.018319586291909218, -0.01382110733538866, -0.029528971761465073, -0.02592281624674797, -0.028389979153871536, 0.045995213091373444, 0.048304926604032516, -0.028251346200704575, 0.0028940315824002028, 0.004189164377748966, -0.017244283109903336, -0.03328898549079895, 0.005340083967894316, 0.02965162880718708, -0.022261517122387886, 0.016627226024866104, -0.028017757460474968, 0.037919167429208755, 0.0034505128860473633, -0.036555420607328415, 0.004276657477021217, 0.010158497840166092, 0.032314930111169815, -0.006552672479301691, -0.0020769794937223196, -0.012548706494271755, 0.03653625771403313, 0.03320585936307907, 0.029972223564982414, 0.011666623875498772, 0.025159871205687523, 0.00685080885887146, -0.013872643932700157, -0.01883218251168728, 0.0008539286209270358, 0.03418256714940071, -0.03275436535477638, 0.05354539677500725, -0.06530199944972992, -0.012439068406820297, 0.011864524334669113, -0.036676179617643356, 0.0337570458650589, 0.0005177156999707222, 0.004402273800224066, -0.02546697109937668, 0.02127724513411522, 0.02303224988281727, -0.011662155389785767, 0.0019958631601184607, -0.003614051267504692, 0.014468284323811531, 0.05260009691119194, -0.06094708293676376, -0.020202452316880226, 0.011946175247430801, -0.011856394819915295, -0.028645796701312065, -0.00919091235846281, 0.006582522299140692, -0.0029655795078724623, 0.030478084459900856, -0.014379577711224556, -0.01660374365746975, 0.012400995008647442, 0.015983328223228455, 0.0012836595997214317, -0.045936670154333115, 0.06165379285812378, -0.011045017279684544, -0.04934411123394966, 0.005640980787575245, -0.011334529146552086, -0.07966744154691696, 0.012579088099300861, 0.002287397626787424, -0.03413514792919159, -0.033265598118305206, 0.011376939713954926, -0.010902093723416328, -0.029257027432322502, -0.08126255124807358, 0.01881565898656845, -0.02187386341392994, 0.029584430158138275, 0.002496495842933655, 0.017723780125379562, 0.05646531283855438, -0.028140245005488396, 0.0005624606274068356, -0.07686223834753036, 0.05648775026202202, 0.023239528760313988, -0.0049913558177649975, 0.012779789045453072, -0.02301732823252678, 0.004497459623962641, -0.012785651721060276, 0.072329580783844, -0.008819558657705784, 0.014945468865334988, -0.0023597138933837414, 0.053234875202178955, 0.01437230221927166, -0.01283408422023058, 0.024927401915192604, -0.0020238435827195644, -0.0045051719062030315, 0.01734258607029915, -0.031180890277028084, -0.008288473822176456, -0.0015154300490394235, -0.011242988519370556, 0.01989574171602726, -0.02857024222612381, -0.011602655053138733, 0.011348402127623558, -0.013176539912819862, -0.0025692780036479235, -0.007142859976738691, 0.03871040418744087, 0.0433097742497921, -0.006944696884602308, 0.038170330226421356, -0.0019547564443200827, -0.054934073239564896, 0.04793667793273926, -0.05120180547237396, -0.031090762466192245, -0.0057884701527655125, -0.0016174947377294302, 0.0022315895184874535, -0.04007471725344658, -0.007912934757769108, 0.0070764790289103985, -0.04406622424721718, 0.04901581630110741, 0.03826981782913208, -0.013483766466379166, 0.018689943477511406, 0.00566913653165102, 0.012998481281101704, 0.008343166671693325, 0.002348023233935237, 0.007337342947721481, 0.01003990788012743, 0.014516972936689854, -0.0021396055817604065, -0.02217833697795868, 0.0425824411213398, 0.009093225933611393, 0.005155408754944801, -0.04685895889997482, 0.04089653864502907, -0.01077927928417921, -0.041863251477479935, 0.020202701911330223, 0.027205146849155426, 0.04454689845442772, 0.0023150015622377396, -0.03082939051091671, 0.034070856869220734, -0.0016237859381362796, 0.014566337689757347, -0.014270782470703125, -0.033529285341501236, -0.022712215781211853, 0.007031428627669811, -0.020604588091373444, 0.0245619248598814, -0.005095297936350107, -0.00462752440944314, 0.02531612664461136, -0.0027230342384427786, 0.02573326602578163, -0.006019264925271273, 0.012875639833509922, -0.006911002565175295, -0.0006474022520706058, -0.015478948131203651, -0.019849929958581924, -0.06370565295219421, -0.04331158846616745, 0.01414860412478447, 0.046791501343250275, 0.025584720075130463, 0.01577107235789299, -0.014574287459254265, 0.004535800311714411, 0.019314758479595184, -0.09794740378856659, -0.0391964390873909, -0.025255579501390457, 0.004065889865159988, -0.022745033726096153, -0.01916481740772724 ]
<p>What is the best out-of-the-box 2-class classifier? Yes, I guess that's the million dollar question, and yes, I'm aware of the <a href="http://www.no-free-lunch.org/">no free lunch theorem</a>, and I've also read the previous questions:</p> <ul> <li><a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/258/poll-what-is-the-best-out-of-the-box-2-class-classifier-for-your-application">Poll: What is the best out-of-the-box 2-class classifier for your application?</a></li> <li>and <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/5987/worst-classifier">Worst classifier</a></li> </ul> <p>Still, I'm interested in reading more on the subject.</p> <p>What is a good source of information that includes a general comparison of the characteristics, advantage, and features of different classifiers?</p>
48,332
[ -0.027249835431575775, -0.0524880550801754, 0.0076597388833761215, -0.0134718157351017, 0.012631735764443874, -0.019047079607844353, 0.017483854666352272, -0.03316110372543335, 0.0379495844244957, -0.016936764121055603, 0.04565516859292984, 0.049412939697504044, 0.023953396826982498, 0.06121450662612915, -0.021825771778821945, -0.01326333824545145, -0.008718647062778473, 0.006182789336889982, 0.0034377274569123983, 0.006343803368508816, -0.02156117744743824, -0.005433409940451384, 0.03555057570338249, 0.00008294350845972076, -0.05314119532704353, 0.054827552288770676, 0.0036245803348720074, -0.02758723683655262, -0.001991917844861746, 0.06472568213939667, -0.07048642635345459, 0.008541170507669449, -0.004722178913652897, 0.04733775183558464, 0.04425447806715965, 0.022140877321362495, -0.002832992235198617, -0.04261964187026024, -0.01702878624200821, 0.007290426176041365, -0.004866475705057383, -0.031206900253891945, 0.010466719046235085, 0.03276877850294113, -0.009939607232809067, 0.015544550493359566, -0.04007018730044365, -0.025740567594766617, -0.01181078888475895, -0.06695041805505753, 0.05004417151212692, -0.009348719380795956, 0.025180073454976082, 0.04683052375912666, -0.022337371483445168, -0.06114668771624565, 0.02129393443465233, 0.08553232997655869, -0.026470569893717766, -0.044266227632761, 0.005924994591623545, 0.007158117834478617, -0.006796864327043295, -0.019575132057070732, -0.03912912681698799, 0.045200131833553314, 0.011004977859556675, -0.026926599442958832, 0.01717325858771801, -0.013587693683803082, 0.02651464007794857, -0.043171320110559464, 0.0202912800014019, 0.015627261251211166, 0.020357778295874596, -0.0324871763586998, -0.00014201189333107322, 0.045212794095277786, 0.034143492579460144, 0.0482470877468586, -0.0066695366986095905, -0.014060386456549168, 0.038841888308525085, 0.02711343578994274, 0.039302460849285126, -0.0188455693423748, 0.09536626935005188, -0.0006288511212915182, -0.007033568806946278, 0.024657465517520905, 0.010961047373712063, -0.00675320066511631, 0.055174533277750015, -0.013119954615831375, -0.03218412399291992, 0.022397585213184357, -0.02305017039179802, 0.02202591672539711, 0.03175796940922737, -0.045828677713871, 0.008752374909818172, -0.017920101061463356, 0.011965814046561718, 0.07564522325992584, -0.02834775112569332, -0.009545175358653069, -0.028301771730184555, -0.026865815743803978, -0.044368546456098557, 0.004652719013392925, -0.013932294212281704, 0.024389300495386124, -0.01838020235300064, 0.017652073875069618, 0.03148600086569786, -0.025665434077382088, 0.006808432750403881, 0.006659424863755703, 0.0021781029645353556, 0.06769300997257233, 0.04315381124615669, -0.038975320756435394, 0.002067712601274252, -0.043452195823192596, -0.015390899032354355, 0.01598428748548031, 0.025845825672149658, -0.001883571152575314, -0.04515306279063225, 0.03643262758851051, -0.016570735722780228, -0.01205033715814352, 0.011057540774345398, 0.00682061817497015, -0.02576608955860138, 0.012625733390450478, -0.10402944684028625, -0.059366583824157715, 0.03509782999753952, -0.023433515802025795, -0.005952989216893911, -0.07169802486896515, -0.020893365144729614, 0.03331197053194046, 0.03006349876523018, 0.028395971283316612, 0.036976754665374756, 0.027439754456281662, 0.034350309520959854, -0.014697444625198841, -0.04257746413350105, 0.013498181477189064, -0.01668310910463333, -0.00687542324885726, -0.013266928493976593, -0.04861150309443474, 0.015558835119009018, -0.0009165803785435855, -0.009860355406999588, -0.008353237994015217, 0.020577093586325645, 0.02640681155025959, -0.012993804179131985, -0.027262551710009575, 0.0007787845097482204, 0.01577680930495262, 0.07666824758052826, 0.026411166414618492, 0.05504327639937401, 0.013981318101286888, -0.032128751277923584, 0.035028308629989624, 0.041295140981674194, 0.021218255162239075, 0.023542100563645363, -0.006769925355911255, -0.03601350262761116, -0.04705990478396416, 0.028245050460100174, -0.019464125856757164, -0.02383238635957241, -0.033481940627098083, -0.026122137904167175, -0.007315272465348244, -0.0076738325878977776, 0.06093824282288551, 0.02280893363058567, -0.011292374692857265, 0.051996465772390366, -0.04119665548205376, -0.05015164986252785, -0.07009435445070267, 0.005946626421064138, -0.003988899290561676, -0.018628573045134544, 0.03951585665345192, 0.02402782253921032, -0.017369523644447327, -0.019150283187627792, -0.01097871083766222, -0.05541529506444931, 0.04394295811653137, 0.03733331710100174, -0.03375759720802307, 0.0100804902613163, 0.052515916526317596, 0.01687190681695938, -0.035390838980674744, 0.0002515246451366693, -0.046460092067718506, -0.09454613924026489, 0.009253231808543205, -0.023053178563714027, 0.0198817141354084, -0.025106336921453476, -0.010268595069646835, 0.018586521968245506, 0.014722517691552639, -0.042154476046562195, 0.006131804548203945, -0.05188373848795891, 0.044045574963092804, 0.03571188077330589, 0.018896734341979027, 0.022242100909352303, -0.0026964296121150255, -0.01817544363439083, 0.025392061099410057, -0.010516108945012093, 0.0409543551504612, -0.054338209331035614, -0.01411337498575449, 0.07189355045557022, 0.025081709027290344, -0.03456229344010353, 0.04405088722705841, 0.0029690179508179426, 0.019101742655038834, -0.024522967636585236, 0.015018877573311329, -0.027724752202630043, -0.012480553239583969, 0.01650368422269821, 0.029941145330667496, 0.007514352444559336, -0.00596297811716795, 0.028095543384552002, 0.0017744284123182297, 0.017152495682239532, 0.03653660789132118, -0.006082888226956129, 0.07665083557367325, 0.01754525676369667, -0.04162878915667534, -0.016177687793970108, -0.022232789546251297, 0.01546915341168642, -0.015472471714019775, 0.0008395054610446095, 0.0544368214905262, 0.02689443714916706, -0.0004078547062817961, -0.002916438039392233, -0.03240962699055672, 0.017909223213791847, 0.04257271811366081, -0.009942094795405865, 0.015626361593604088, 0.03839913383126259, -0.04936491325497627, 0.019859563559293747, -0.004582361783832312, -0.0126111451536417, -0.06397661566734314, 0.019401442259550095, 0.010610108263790607, -0.0060891942121088505, 0.007173581980168819, 0.007936397567391396, -0.011301822029054165, 0.016819294542074203, -0.025120653212070465, 0.017680803313851357, -0.001822225982323289, -0.05203831568360329, -0.0006757483351975679, -0.015623816289007664, -0.016195937991142273, 0.06475595384836197, 0.03266335278749466, -0.0019673339556902647, 0.015264722518622875, 0.0019335452234372497, -0.0704108253121376, -0.04506497457623482, -0.040609825402498245, 0.033697083592414856, -0.025191064924001694, -0.05817098543047905, 0.006054283585399389, -0.020946141332387924, -0.0547339990735054, 0.01611950621008873, -0.02448137477040291, -0.03791589289903641, -0.0139140784740448, 0.004375657066702843, 0.046853773295879364, -0.004461521748453379, -0.044890228658914566, 0.037432711571455, 0.01095533650368452, 0.03132286295294762, -0.07330941408872604, -0.07658663392066956, 0.013108821585774422, -0.015863599255681038, 0.018404869362711906, 0.004807972349226475, -0.013325029984116554, 0.045212272554636, 0.034791622310876846, -0.03313342109322548, -0.027523895725607872, -0.021962320432066917, -0.006230946630239487, -0.04953347519040108, 0.01064821146428585, 0.00567593751475215, 0.005181730259209871, 0.003365131327882409, -0.018648002296686172, 0.027405474334955215, 0.05177771672606468, -0.010177385061979294, 0.0026824516244232655, 0.012930733151733875, 0.002000712091103196, -0.027665043249726295, 0.054393451660871506, 0.05385212600231171, -0.047538407146930695, 0.03921470418572426, -0.020397989079356194, 0.004234847612679005, 0.015553134493529797, -0.04146822914481163, 0.004003817215561867, 0.001610901323147118, 0.011737393215298653, -0.03501756116747856, 0.028234515339136124, 0.0014422731474041939, -0.03937724605202675, -0.03200430050492287, -0.0010071652941405773, 0.03408612310886383, -0.019263461232185364, -0.0033092861995100975, 0.056589074432849884, 0.06938610225915909, 0.008250628598034382, 0.012994017452001572, -0.01895716041326523, 0.0050811320543289185, 0.017722798511385918, 0.0004477509355638176, 0.01919388771057129, 0.031326014548540115, 0.0327644869685173, 0.026708267629146576, 0.04117194190621376, -0.03734677657485008, 0.005649952217936516, -0.07695824652910233, -0.010280854068696499, -0.07666764408349991, 0.07242340594530106, -0.008760852739214897, -0.0058659715577960014, -0.01862700656056404, -0.0027493301313370466, 0.01179203949868679, 0.009692370891571045, -0.05908215790987015, 0.01740354485809803, -0.03160848841071129, 0.016404323279857635, -0.012868011370301247, -0.002736999886110425, 0.015181629918515682, -0.026880940422415733, 0.022082805633544922, -0.03209611028432846, 0.03079989179968834, -0.032150231301784515, 0.018254581838846207, -0.02477903477847576, 0.01822091080248356, 0.0017765846569091082, 0.0015441736904904246, -0.02235237881541252, -0.006029399577528238, 0.036278218030929565, 0.0212235264480114, -0.01161995716392994, -0.008739477954804897, 0.040519580245018005, -0.00011790150892920792, -0.030474774539470673, 0.015128839761018753, -0.006662418600171804, 0.012160753831267357, -0.03147274628281593, 0.03302045539021492, 0.00011071520566474646, 0.0389668308198452, -0.0004037657054141164, 0.004865897353738546, -0.023237071931362152, -0.03412206470966339, -0.03771641105413437, -0.004751772619783878, 0.03436138480901718, 0.010436435230076313, 0.0008879808592610061, 0.055292196571826935, 0.035833947360515594, -0.03643738105893135, 0.01789853163063526, 0.07601433247327805, -0.0230354443192482, 0.0091164605692029, 0.004500513896346092, -0.005073574837297201, 0.0037747786846011877, -0.010198818519711494, 0.01790374144911766, 0.012669983319938183, -0.011902255937457085, -0.014401544816792011, 0.012412519194185734, -0.032051246613264084, -0.03192320838570595, 0.011084675788879395, -0.0212982390075922, 0.028132768347859383, 0.00142294866964221, 0.0011571783106774092, -0.028022807091474533, 0.048889659345149994, 0.06327211856842041, 0.02079693414270878, -0.0078482860699296, -0.07459750026464462, -0.016618160530924797, 0.06483142077922821, 0.05168928578495979, -0.03601284697651863, -0.020264461636543274, -0.03611691668629646, -0.027637116611003876, 0.013886073604226112, -0.03152528405189514, 0.04227183759212494, -0.012994358316063881, -0.014008904807269573, -0.03335892781615257, 0.009924021549522877, -0.03560579568147659, 0.0013450992992147803, -0.00834894459694624, 0.0393105186522007, -0.009858152829110622, -0.010376833379268646, -0.05109770968556404, 0.02931719459593296, 0.02133827842772007, 0.08353207260370255, -0.052836738526821136, -0.006399696692824364, 0.004859863314777613, 0.007368418388068676, -0.03358236327767372, -0.043638020753860474, -0.014983066357672215, 0.014591694809496403, -0.048467837274074554, 0.016194039955735207, -0.022238612174987793, -0.050198353826999664, 0.01783999428153038, 0.0033554602414369583, -0.025833433493971825, -0.007244776003062725, -0.01633458212018013, -0.011087627150118351, 0.056743744760751724, 0.050688885152339935, 0.032969601452350616, 0.04275660961866379, 0.011480034328997135, 0.022542139515280724, -0.03292930871248245, 0.023164598271250725, -0.022801894694566727, -0.03244885057210922, -0.027119411155581474, -0.024803481996059418, -0.06816563010215759, 0.0025769418571144342, 0.02619950845837593, 0.060053881257772446, -0.0341031439602375, -0.048487596213817596, -0.01006824616342783, 0.0200604647397995, 0.004839457105845213, -0.007966756820678711, -0.012894406914710999, 0.02352571114897728, -0.0016523018712177873, 0.0018839475233107805, 0.03045954369008541, -0.026950828731060028, 0.02513018436729908, 0.055405136197805405, -0.04876105859875679, 0.026793938130140305, -0.0540350116789341, 0.01243263017386198, 0.0016026918310672045, -0.007834771648049355, 0.08233185112476349, 0.026957010850310326, 0.03485793247818947, 0.020740367472171783, -0.03708692267537117, -0.036133065819740295, 0.022689208388328552, 0.02546071819961071, 0.03775928169488907, -0.020734110847115517, 0.054020948708057404, 0.0008525939774699509, -0.026814540848135948, -0.051682211458683014, -0.019171420484781265, 0.0030019099358469248, 0.005257521290332079, -0.02655717171728611, -0.024556729942560196, 0.04750576242804527, -0.012877104803919792, -0.018923159688711166, -0.025160718709230423, 0.057139333337545395, -0.0029665203765034676, -0.035397641360759735, 0.022493703290820122, 0.018579626455903053, 0.06971803307533264, 0.04028169438242912, -0.017627350986003876, 0.007216185797005892, 0.004370978567749262, -0.020715784281492233, 0.018974872305989265, 0.06059662997722626, -0.030621711164712906, -0.020592018961906433, -0.008907263167202473, 0.0033647974487394094, 0.023365337401628494, -0.004142262041568756, 0.005754597019404173, 0.027434656396508217, -0.01899935118854046, -0.01635688915848732, -0.009029348380863667, -0.0036927792243659496, -0.018030857667326927, 0.004293348174542189, -0.004308204632252455, 0.014079352840781212, -0.020536553114652634, -0.02775641344487667, -0.020048130303621292, 0.00607423298060894, -0.009841224178671837, 0.004654822871088982, 0.016628354787826538, -0.043413762003183365, 0.028298020362854004, 0.031459614634513855, -0.06827706098556519, 0.03965480998158455, 0.030369523912668228, 0.02574331685900688, 0.0030392117332667112, 0.04278186708688736, -0.0258047915995121, -0.01917465217411518, -0.02518431283533573, -0.019356925040483475, 0.05124073475599289, -0.012885631062090397, 0.04011130332946777, 0.036911483854055405, 0.02720755897462368, -0.009993162006139755, -0.025409094989299774, 0.0021946781780570745, -0.011367014609277248, 0.021343329921364784, 0.03646479919552803, 0.0045306263491511345, 0.022237282246351242, 0.040847115218639374, -0.00048599191359244287, 0.04082532599568367, -0.010109582915902138, 0.026427537202835083, 0.036901816725730896, 0.04137623682618141, -0.0582573227584362, -0.05369117856025696, 0.021276749670505524, -0.04509318619966507, -0.008861388079822063, 0.021039368584752083, -0.04393940418958664, 0.03683885186910629, 0.0023328668903559446, -0.0028700826223939657, -0.032490115612745285, 0.02730150893330574, -0.05813775956630707, 0.029775923117995262, 0.015959611162543297, -0.03243991360068321, 0.017006998881697655, -0.005487627815455198, 0.03161666914820671, -0.007483868394047022, 0.0230092890560627, -0.021453749388456345, -0.10629506409168243, -0.013843185268342495, -0.007974635809659958, -0.06757906079292297, -0.0007628480670973659, 0.027855515480041504, -0.034572891891002655, 0.029214855283498764, -0.016643129289150238, -0.003275900613516569, 0.026202542707324028, 0.048003990203142166, -0.024363381788134575, 0.05126268044114113, -0.03822711855173111, 0.0052312142215669155, -0.003844568971544504, -0.04033590853214264, 0.13971197605133057, 0.02896525338292122, 0.04492988809943199, -0.06142621114850044, 0.030530409887433052, 0.016139769926667213, 0.01331678219139576, -0.03984496742486954, 0.004604491870850325, 0.030174046754837036, 0.006561000365763903, 0.030528556555509567, -0.00853133387863636, 0.023552557453513145, -0.021751802414655685, 0.027420401573181152, -0.02483535185456276, -0.014270889572799206, 0.03691480681300163, 0.03496082127094269, 0.004877390805631876, -0.012427859008312225, -0.027140537276864052, 0.014096537604928017, 0.0023682352621108294, 0.02731577306985855, -0.0034931290429085493, -0.044849198311567307, 0.021651409566402435, -0.007868346758186817, -0.02967097796499729, -0.03590049594640732, 0.0035694201942533255, -0.012382952496409416, 0.009411325678229332, 0.00040638414793647826, 0.004482314921915531, -0.039045948535203934, 0.018670162186026573, 0.03452286869287491, 0.056813061237335205, -0.030751226469874382, 0.023029323667287827, 0.00789656862616539, -0.08033663034439087, 0.01818796433508396, -0.05284016206860542, 0.026543857529759407, -0.010767334140837193, -0.003467338625341654, -0.026227688416838646, -0.01497656386345625, -0.00442303204908967, -0.03721889480948448, -0.027752317488193512, 0.01890517584979534, 0.040336329489946365, -0.013969183899462223, -0.039714962244033813, -0.04129574075341225, 0.06559929996728897, -0.026357723399996758, 0.014633151702582836, -0.012363968417048454, -0.01452779583632946, -0.013510864228010178, 0.018029391765594482, 0.018405981361865997, 0.03513899818062782, 0.043400928378105164, 0.004682966973632574, -0.04615379124879837, -0.07376431673765182, -0.011170406825840473, -0.0022401995956897736, 0.013967660255730152, 0.04038693383336067, 0.00006996618321863934, -0.01090152096003294, -0.023693831637501717, -0.036907464265823364, -0.01216314546763897, -0.03574925288558006, 0.053378406912088394, -0.04219283536076546, -0.01534564420580864, -0.001799173653125763, -0.013250741176307201, 0.058069683611392975, 0.05702747404575348, 0.02452077530324459, 0.02487381361424923, -0.008160974830389023, -0.056104037910699844, 0.0017188795609399676, 0.002848060568794608, -0.01987900398671627, 0.0021674102172255516, -0.0012685961555689573, 0.05699948966503143, 0.007226945366710424, 0.050065841525793076, 0.0014680459862574935, -0.007447387557476759, -0.004402691498398781, 0.009883144870400429, 0.03629137948155403, -0.028537558391690254, -0.03375362977385521, 0.006029728800058365, 0.010060898959636688, -0.02423466555774212, -0.03607132285833359, -0.03149212896823883, -0.03554258123040199, 0.032753270119428635, 0.027955928817391396, -0.044259581714868546, -0.002617819467559457, -0.0336962454020977, 0.03199043124914169, -0.023704998195171356, -0.006013969890773296, -0.039424747228622437, -0.03467704728245735, -0.03199988231062889, -0.025722686201334, 0.009574871510267258, 0.03785553574562073, -0.012325526215136051, -0.008763144724071026, 0.04944584146142006, 0.01175770629197359, -0.0110328895971179, 0.04054061323404312, -0.004498273134231567, -0.029228143393993378, 0.048884157091379166, -0.04444757103919983, 0.018451927229762077, 0.05707070603966713, -0.03468415141105652, 0.004107556771486998, 0.016233311966061592, -0.033458411693573, 0.0011741669150069356, 0.015654059126973152, -0.022147079929709435, 0.021625010296702385, 0.025100531056523323, -0.048566803336143494, -0.02147221565246582, -0.02166658453643322, 0.014758052304387093, 0.017550772055983543, 0.010162487626075745, 0.0022994279861450195, -0.015395566821098328, -0.040657319128513336, 0.0387917160987854, 0.02407301589846611, 0.02021276019513607, -0.02214481122791767, 0.004626301117241383, 0.0057931821793317795, 0.01641574688255787, -0.015233046375215054, 0.018330276012420654, 0.024242224171757698, 0.025865914300084114, -0.02683229371905327, 0.041302118450403214, -0.02429799735546112, 0.004282946232706308, -0.08186947554349899, -0.0004559429653454572, 0.007758178748190403, 0.02772822044789791, 0.0387585423886776, -0.04690536856651306, 0.01588798128068447, 0.03876367211341858, -0.03215768188238144, 0.023051884025335312, 0.011425319127738476, -0.005556232761591673, -0.019060641527175903, -0.006208194885402918, -0.031935982406139374, 0.003679896704852581, 0.013940943405032158, -0.0034804565366357565, 0.019713228568434715, 0.04080624133348465, -0.035459764301776886, -0.02668852172791958, 0.0002662699844222516, 0.016041187569499016, -0.031146664172410965, -0.03895892947912216, 0.006666144356131554, -0.008118205703794956, -0.0038959078956395388, 0.04290377348661423, 0.011601769365370274, 0.03353596106171608, 0.04925532639026642, -0.004064582288265228, -0.002408751519396901, 0.01758667826652527, 0.05000296235084534, -0.027515478432178497, -0.038254112005233765, 0.02436845377087593, 0.0043714698404073715, 0.041946373879909515, 0.007310662418603897, 0.03218851238489151, 0.0028204566333442926, 0.024807564914226532, -0.03803538158535957, 0.027347223833203316, -0.05167023092508316, 0.0025735509116202593, 0.005918517708778381, -0.025707898661494255, 0.005813427735120058, 0.01935420371592045, -0.012106616050004959, -0.003137174528092146, 0.00625596335157752, 0.03756975382566452, 0.005561287049204111, -0.02269323356449604, 0.026146529242396355, -0.030874600633978844, -0.029518049210309982, -0.0019033373100683093, -0.004752877168357372, 0.007143490016460419, -0.035309188067913055, -0.0040153865702450275, 0.02226107381284237, 0.004594543948769569, -0.015753602609038353, -0.02619675174355507, 0.005680943839251995, 0.034294549375772476, -0.010717115364968777, 0.014364057220518589, 0.04081494361162186, 0.011501884087920189, -0.00265995180234313, -0.07224253565073013, 0.056019656360149384, 0.020335175096988678, 0.001818923861719668, -0.0067102909088134766, -0.005656046327203512, -0.0394633486866951, 0.0015162797644734383, 0.05765741318464279, -0.008847406134009361, 0.029506003484129906, -0.050141591578722, 0.0237602386623621, 0.010593228042125702, -0.03411264345049858, 0.03408055007457733, -0.0012837144313380122, -0.044495146721601486, -0.012635352090001106, -0.009725837036967278, -0.005075014196336269, 0.010470308363437653, 0.05502146854996681, 0.00010564125113887712, 0.017665714025497437, 0.020786885172128677, 0.0017174443928524852, 0.037338439375162125, -0.026123184710741043, 0.022690050303936005, 0.05805006995797157, -0.025243572890758514, 0.028650779277086258, 0.01463653240352869, -0.012267730198800564, -0.0018652558792382479, 0.028908979147672653, -0.020677782595157623, -0.030814001336693764, -0.048478446900844574, 0.011701829731464386, 0.0016122511588037014, -0.07446245849132538, 0.010254639200866222, 0.029133833944797516, 0.018741179257631302, -0.0014253502013161778, 0.03133542835712433, 0.021147293969988823, 0.031122220680117607, 0.015547766350209713, 0.05397972837090492, -0.011459283530712128, -0.014666017144918442, 0.00021318304061423987, -0.0047227079048752785, 0.025288479402661324, 0.0043031396344304085, 0.022609278559684753, 0.050028350204229355, -0.001068343291990459, 0.036451417952775955, -0.020874634385108948, 0.024015599861741066, -0.042549025267362595, -0.03325406461954117, 0.021842271089553833, 0.00028621600358746946, 0.013725466094911098, 0.011711630038917065, -0.020442286506295204, 0.06036180630326271, -0.01718878746032715, -0.014564725570380688, -0.030900273472070694, -0.0023936862125992775, -0.023149199783802032, -0.03673939034342766, -0.004797914065420628, 0.029769334942102432, 0.02656758390367031, 0.02721388079226017, 0.011701877228915691, 0.014398948289453983, 0.03503849729895592, -0.02457490749657154, 0.05316702648997307, -0.012691044248640537, 0.008981783874332905, -0.03845028206706047, -0.002147085266187787, -0.015946701169013977, -0.029060568660497665, -0.017743194475769997, 0.07575737684965134, 0.019370103254914284, -0.030376214534044266, -0.006182914599776268, -0.004341817926615477, 0.023378340527415276, -0.051047854125499725, 0.019023317843675613, -0.08881611377000809, 0.0076127429492771626, 0.013739070855081081, -0.033181868493556976 ]
<p>When estimating the confidence interval of mean, I think both the bootstrap t method and the nonparametric bootstrap method can apply, but the former requires a little more computation. </p> <p>I wonder what the advantages and disadvantages of bootstrap t over the normal nonparametric bootstrap are? Why? </p> <p>Are there some references for explaining this?</p>
74,036
[ -0.006165835075080395, -0.01712324284017086, 0.0038175664376467466, -0.014589161612093449, 0.0215117409825325, 0.02337389625608921, -0.00013478289474733174, -0.018539542332291603, 0.02470419928431511, -0.004607781767845154, 0.03371176868677139, 0.042827945202589035, 0.010542255826294422, 0.02884361706674099, -0.01255270466208458, -0.014463845640420914, -0.0084354467689991, -0.02342092990875244, -0.013222306966781616, -0.007536976598203182, -0.01577676460146904, 0.05971963331103325, -0.022842491045594215, -0.03677309304475784, 0.013730861246585846, 0.026363827288150787, 0.010041986592113972, 0.005404084920883179, 0.01232018880546093, 0.09061399102210999, -0.06250618398189545, -0.025253988802433014, -0.003947050776332617, 0.0702306255698204, -0.021720480173826218, -0.02928192913532257, -0.043431252241134644, -0.05302425101399422, 0.006474139168858528, 0.024498527869582176, -0.05781402438879013, -0.009688641875982285, -0.006511859130114317, 0.02154134400188923, 0.01595429889857769, 0.05209602788090706, -0.01844264566898346, -0.05432739853858948, 0.012668348848819733, -0.03525521978735924, 0.03203602507710457, -0.005693887360394001, 0.023107856512069702, 0.022481471300125122, -0.015902848914265633, 0.00979763362556696, 0.004615004640072584, 0.04712705314159393, -0.018191326409578323, -0.0649925246834755, 0.012678603641688824, -0.04468782991170883, 0.02813558094203472, -0.013153833337128162, -0.016966452822089195, 0.023800397291779518, 0.0026163370348513126, -0.006804640404880047, 0.013485250994563103, -0.001483779400587082, 0.022374475374817848, 0.006493739318102598, 0.0455368235707283, -0.008682792074978352, -0.00822437833994627, -0.03751986101269722, 0.011935265734791756, 0.0013857966987416148, 0.08195431530475616, 0.06202666461467743, 0.03845351189374924, 0.00989171676337719, 0.04853295534849167, 0.03427280858159065, 0.010325641371309757, -0.0032793330028653145, 0.05832448601722717, -0.017693154513835907, 0.013734180480241776, 0.06011802703142166, -0.03586892783641815, -0.006969434209167957, 0.04793918505311012, -0.02160143479704857, -0.033110231161117554, 0.048180315643548965, -0.007926428690552711, 0.02678864076733589, 0.016991881653666496, -0.009237794205546379, 0.0089229391887784, -0.012266364879906178, 0.05278359726071358, 0.06813289225101471, 0.015828967094421387, -0.013667765073478222, -0.05242881923913956, -0.0002887228038161993, 0.0024355717469006777, -0.015272448770701885, -0.02846192754805088, 0.010342555120587349, 0.005694752559065819, 0.021958688274025917, 0.04916675388813019, 0.015382389537990093, 0.011812577955424786, -0.03641495853662491, 0.04173716902732849, 0.043504491448402405, 0.02572965808212757, -0.011225205846130848, 0.0040068794041872025, -0.026440473273396492, -0.04451336711645126, 0.02435045689344406, 0.025335561484098434, -0.008501908741891384, -0.006261435337364674, 0.044250961393117905, -0.009897087700664997, -0.01954982802271843, 0.04707731306552887, 0.01585402712225914, 0.03149084001779556, -0.023687507957220078, -0.06859534978866577, -0.07179073989391327, 0.028184175491333008, 0.012874354608356953, 0.00967963133007288, -0.0381561741232872, 0.002382155740633607, 0.028806382790207863, 0.015632404014468193, 0.01859724521636963, 0.028314528986811638, 0.0007089014397934079, 0.03912131488323212, 0.0054215192794799805, -0.05421874299645424, -0.018396848812699318, 0.018212752416729927, 0.003441946115344763, 0.004071083851158619, -0.0957733541727066, 0.03934434801340103, 0.001075630309060216, -0.005233784671872854, -0.030191075056791306, 0.024673977866768837, -0.007544907741248608, -0.0193648561835289, -0.004809512756764889, 0.01769666001200676, 0.0024705331306904554, 0.06259413808584213, -0.03172449767589569, 0.041676152497529984, -0.015780134126544, -0.003941070754081011, 0.026951290667057037, 0.022230299189686775, 0.022498834878206253, 0.05733202397823334, -0.04805970937013626, -0.03920372575521469, -0.02229790762066841, 0.015375622548162937, -0.01320593897253275, -0.014572003856301308, 0.014383695088326931, -0.010065515525639057, 0.017854180186986923, 0.01588428020477295, 0.02280937135219574, 0.022346628829836845, -0.01387083437293768, 0.049000486731529236, -0.03433884680271149, -0.02392485924065113, -0.0794588252902031, 0.0036246166564524174, -0.01005337480455637, -0.005957190413028002, 0.020113520324230194, 0.0052757239900529385, 0.0020299034658819437, -0.012002982199192047, -0.013699602335691452, 0.0005887873703613877, -0.00649498775601387, 0.02698688767850399, -0.07510369271039963, 0.029734022915363312, 0.05506069213151932, 0.0482713021337986, -0.02809789963066578, 0.035913001745939255, -0.04391036182641983, -0.060391589999198914, -0.005819749087095261, -0.04545266926288605, -0.0041908277198672295, -0.022490432485938072, -0.03640219569206238, 0.01527111791074276, -0.004130934365093708, -0.044643502682447433, 0.033977948129177094, -0.047669339925050735, 0.04651274159550667, 0.04204913228750229, 0.030211161822080612, -0.027908291667699814, -0.003318128641694784, 0.02534474804997444, 0.0018754244083538651, -0.009481752291321754, 0.007271377369761467, -0.058761075139045715, -0.015872875228524208, 0.02865409106016159, 0.02924252301454544, -0.039187293499708176, 0.02496482990682125, 0.06829483062028885, -0.004118018783628941, 0.005484156776219606, 0.018004950135946274, 0.0023294135462492704, -0.039064086973667145, 0.0065063959918916225, 0.048619672656059265, 0.046172793954610825, -0.014652320183813572, 0.006531659979373217, 0.00601881043985486, 0.03387519344687462, 0.0292073842138052, -0.023399248719215393, 0.02860628440976143, 0.014427698217332363, -0.011578695848584175, 0.0007713650702498853, -0.057646241039037704, 0.046304021030664444, -0.06373166292905807, -0.002601193031296134, 0.02152281627058983, -0.020876802504062653, 0.02423379383981228, 0.0077655017375946045, -0.011589039117097855, 0.040573857724666595, 0.047650326043367386, -0.02026481367647648, 0.01078417431563139, 0.021357929334044456, -0.011384776793420315, -0.01019616425037384, -0.0397329218685627, -0.033731404691934586, -0.04660060256719589, -0.014865926466882229, 0.0036549351643770933, -0.04354545846581459, 0.05001425743103027, -0.011548341251909733, -0.007218390237540007, -0.004830519203096628, -0.021839739754796028, -0.004993426147848368, -0.0025993678718805313, -0.05517572537064552, -0.010048776865005493, -0.002903120592236519, -0.03851519897580147, 0.012037333101034164, -0.013342835940420628, -0.0006291560712270439, -0.005660303868353367, 0.0031401629094034433, -0.03747127950191498, -0.01190363708883524, -0.005829615984112024, 0.006478616036474705, -0.013463173061609268, -0.02439763769507408, 0.03452783077955246, 0.01640581153333187, -0.049837417900562286, 0.06408389657735825, -0.03604207932949066, -0.04956309124827385, -0.06063714623451233, 0.05097297206521034, 0.0011583659797906876, -0.005609452724456787, 0.0008717459859326482, -0.0014523382997140288, -0.03592707961797714, 0.022728994488716125, -0.06692171096801758, -0.016430910676717758, 0.028558671474456787, -0.011554265394806862, 0.03967738896608353, -0.03138817101716995, -0.007694292347878218, 0.07982920110225677, 0.04901992902159691, -0.011027928441762924, -0.0322139672935009, -0.010383935645222664, -0.026997020468115807, 0.04736156016588211, -0.006958618760108948, 0.01440755557268858, 0.02271883934736252, 0.02635348029434681, -0.015723103657364845, 0.010612265206873417, 0.06283386796712875, 0.02684895135462284, 0.008337422274053097, -0.002029460621997714, 0.005451584234833717, -0.025926781818270683, 0.055343855172395706, 0.012626651674509048, -0.020142145454883575, -0.005670065060257912, -0.002303502755239606, 0.029515711590647697, 0.014952398836612701, -0.04820378124713898, 0.020112166181206703, -0.043725110590457916, -0.023396102711558342, -0.06627051532268524, 0.015757082030177116, 0.009185555391013622, 0.02385183796286583, 0.008709059096872807, 0.014802801422774792, -0.002505847718566656, -0.027184246107935905, 0.013063652440905571, 0.01782994158565998, 0.05441468954086304, 0.0004874209116678685, -0.0038177829701453447, -0.02609688974916935, -0.02687987871468067, 0.022420216351747513, -0.023502273485064507, -0.017941251397132874, 0.005182297900319099, 0.1008252203464508, 0.003789673326537013, 0.001715459511615336, -0.03144821524620056, -0.011602077633142471, -0.042838141322135925, 0.03248361870646477, -0.01974952407181263, 0.035885829478502274, -0.0016204476123675704, 0.05930512771010399, 0.05304283648729324, -0.00372272334061563, 0.0011924812570214272, -0.003989303484559059, -0.08331061154603958, 0.016610244289040565, -0.04913127422332764, -0.029570169746875763, 0.02028951421380043, -0.019051117822527885, 0.021345380693674088, 0.0011957347160205245, 0.022813234478235245, -0.02805204689502716, 0.034757424145936966, -0.020248357206583023, 0.044268179684877396, -0.015526005998253822, -0.002567153424024582, -0.02511570416390896, -0.0017459288937970996, 0.012266675941646099, -0.005986232776194811, 0.01867806725203991, 0.038025036454200745, 0.010756482370197773, -0.019071588292717934, 0.01840963028371334, 0.019329270347952843, 0.022974049672484398, 0.016216354444622993, 0.043795254081487656, 0.02796274423599243, -0.04042275995016098, 0.031376130878925323, -0.01312534511089325, 0.08279161900281906, 0.030600404366850853, -0.03641379997134209, -0.0019825417548418045, -0.03499108552932739, 0.0040035671554505825, -0.0034488188102841377, 0.005068701226264238, -0.028001828119158745, -0.010815706104040146, 0.06271971017122269, 0.0009703469695523381, -0.06545747071504593, -0.010994348675012589, 0.028263358399271965, 0.033501122146844864, -0.01874222420156002, -0.062129028141498566, 0.013664556667208672, -0.022780723869800568, -0.01377974171191454, 0.020697759464383125, 0.012074457481503487, 0.00018026077304966748, 0.02931596152484417, 0.07741532474756241, -0.019957920536398888, -0.02326590195298195, 0.00821240060031414, 0.04394877329468727, 0.03705238178372383, 0.028616176918148994, -0.02754836156964302, 0.03645174205303192, 0.005985690280795097, 0.008357157930731773, -0.00207963096909225, 0.006183042656630278, -0.0830295979976654, 0.012170880101621151, 0.06900455057621002, 0.029755838215351105, -0.03400658816099167, -0.02708800882101059, -0.03326685354113579, 0.02107998915016651, 0.05629894137382507, -0.03557620942592621, 0.013022862374782562, -0.02496013045310974, -0.038998235017061234, -0.03551284223794937, -0.005789023358374834, -0.036532506346702576, 0.014151139184832573, -0.008900424465537071, -0.0060326638631522655, -0.032698966562747955, -0.012621438130736351, -0.031091228127479553, -0.020709536969661713, 0.034604497253894806, 0.06985856592655182, -0.030771344900131226, -0.017068084329366684, 0.01155153103172779, 0.03491579741239548, -0.036296188831329346, -0.04663868620991707, -0.00773720582947135, 0.02227672189474106, -0.00046107012894935906, 0.024760760366916656, -0.013726918958127499, -0.06622101366519928, 0.029795542359352112, 0.0058053163811564445, -0.048491690307855606, -0.0017528228927403688, 0.0007334446418099105, 0.016514567658305168, 0.024235926568508148, 0.003997008316218853, 0.08698264509439468, -0.004951486364006996, 0.0010468485997989774, 0.0009210723801515996, -0.03022543340921402, 0.01021965965628624, -0.05226064845919609, 0.014358754269778728, -0.03707179054617882, -0.016612524166703224, -0.04941853508353233, 0.032653406262397766, -0.0024881039280444384, 0.021320143714547157, -0.010568041354417801, 0.01529348362237215, 0.012645036913454533, 0.013896926306188107, 0.0228465273976326, 0.018782272934913635, -0.002844755770638585, 0.019396888092160225, 0.014415462501347065, -0.020772861316800117, 0.006889003328979015, 0.006156387273222208, 0.009528675116598606, -0.006832696031779051, -0.035230524837970734, 0.016359100118279457, -0.04350997135043144, -0.05652650073170662, 0.040525734424591064, -0.027865109965205193, 0.02358674257993698, -0.004811808001250029, 0.011049279943108559, -0.004528288263827562, -0.04533353075385094, -0.0031015968415886164, 0.029323307797312737, -0.016793716698884964, 0.04887007921934128, -0.057962071150541306, 0.05529328063130379, 0.015736199915409088, -0.008693358860909939, -0.068800188601017, -0.05285987630486488, 0.05334612727165222, 0.007207154296338558, -0.015249820426106453, 0.0001082679009414278, 0.03122006542980671, -0.019176917150616646, -0.053721122443675995, -0.014828859828412533, 0.056822072714567184, 0.010652401484549046, -0.014697887934744358, -0.004883859306573868, 0.021657003089785576, 0.05903566628694534, 0.009603654034435749, -0.0020063547417521477, -0.001307161059230566, -0.01326912920922041, -0.02846035733819008, 0.03143273666501045, 0.028268340975046158, -0.03507450968027115, -0.016049569472670555, -0.02299663797020912, -0.0012907228665426373, 0.020820600911974907, 0.007887117564678192, -0.030754556879401207, 0.03622667118906975, 0.0015729768201708794, -0.026564640924334526, -0.017900921404361725, -0.02877453900873661, -0.014758724719285965, 0.03541513532400131, -0.011138441041111946, 0.0009274348267354071, 0.010092463344335556, 0.011225152760744095, 0.0280262753367424, -0.012403056025505066, 0.0017947815358638763, -0.01764533855021, 0.04551900550723076, -0.02244408056139946, 0.008190195076167583, -0.01651126705110073, -0.029734013602137566, 0.01742432452738285, 0.004247878212481737, 0.008388176560401917, 0.040583040565252304, -0.01732151210308075, -0.049377210438251495, -0.01992064341902733, -0.011677895672619343, -0.014597446657717228, 0.03543649986386299, 0.024271909147500992, 0.06466958671808243, 0.029930097982287407, 0.0009622567449696362, -0.009252889081835747, 0.004977421369403601, -0.009766134433448315, -0.016611527651548386, 0.01268624048680067, 0.04526888579130173, 0.014212238602340221, -0.01408291980624199, 0.05310649797320366, -0.016331356018781662, 0.02715952694416046, 0.06893131881952286, 0.016211943700909615, -0.0038561008404940367, 0.008979400619864464, -0.005693892482668161, -0.035394132137298584, 0.04226910322904587, -0.05247264727950096, 0.007181546185165644, -0.01313596311956644, 0.011525426991283894, 0.014318378642201424, 0.003097649198025465, 0.007022831588983536, -0.013279932551085949, 0.003902757540345192, -0.0263840239495039, 0.007679026108235121, -0.0019453427521511912, -0.019246302545070648, 0.0317479744553566, 0.008082392625510693, 0.0023256749846041203, -0.03689222410321236, 0.01870463788509369, -0.05186512693762779, -0.07199806720018387, -0.0034192129969596863, -0.02102000266313553, -0.09040015935897827, 0.03308207541704178, -0.01845424436032772, -0.03500178083777428, 0.01380324549973011, -0.03602096065878868, 0.0033489002380520105, -0.009992321021854877, 0.030563395470380783, -0.02200634405016899, 0.08604849129915237, 0.019026106223464012, 0.027477528899908066, 0.003854889189824462, -0.011969760060310364, 0.12126393616199493, 0.08114294707775116, 0.020094143226742744, -0.06399358808994293, 0.02555706351995468, -0.013694213703274727, 0.03106427565217018, -0.04348521679639816, 0.011399862356483936, 0.03471990302205086, -0.0069860778748989105, 0.03290408477187157, 0.02806723490357399, 0.002387408399954438, -0.03058033064007759, 0.05079888179898262, -0.0414544939994812, -0.026747144758701324, 0.005689024925231934, -0.0033113467507064342, -0.02562648430466652, -0.0035625931341201067, -0.03885501250624657, 0.02617720514535904, -0.03277052566409111, 0.010038087144494057, -0.015869813039898872, -0.046159252524375916, -0.024432582780718803, 0.008959327824413776, -0.03466082364320755, -0.018228808417916298, 0.01945742405951023, -0.03106420859694481, -0.03914312645792961, -0.006068558432161808, -0.02369629591703415, -0.025204531848430634, 0.02083433046936989, 0.05580511689186096, 0.024806877598166466, -0.030972272157669067, -0.0016315345419570804, 0.01455778069794178, -0.03730057552456856, -0.01121537946164608, -0.021615425124764442, 0.033192891627550125, -0.004402956925332546, 0.031893059611320496, -0.023546019569039345, 0.0010822182521224022, -0.013301827013492584, -0.01825902983546257, -0.010954208672046661, -0.0016894806176424026, 0.014509113505482674, -0.03468906879425049, -0.02023487538099289, -0.04707274213433266, 0.014651193283498287, -0.012210557237267494, 0.026034237816929817, 0.018852660432457924, 0.0007819563616067171, -0.031178053468465805, -0.003634663065895438, 0.010814285837113857, -0.02460647001862526, -0.02864600345492363, -0.012819848954677582, 0.01576315611600876, -0.06673984974622726, -0.007118242792785168, 0.03620406985282898, -0.02563430741429329, 0.07415333390235901, -0.011128093115985394, 0.012202993966639042, -0.008207513019442558, -0.04113570973277092, 0.0185945276170969, -0.0173666812479496, -0.0014502722769975662, -0.04459788277745247, 0.009531392715871334, 0.026826152577996254, 0.015121031552553177, -0.01294597890228033, 0.019526053220033646, -0.011676564812660217, 0.018728721886873245, 0.044656042009592056, -0.05218623951077461, -0.030389511957764626, -0.036964401602745056, -0.029392283409833908, -0.01972774975001812, -0.025731097906827927, 0.011524260975420475, 0.036380767822265625, 0.02678830921649933, -0.017834605649113655, -0.0033431684132665396, 0.028232391923666, 0.02949235774576664, 0.0014778049662709236, -0.05057033896446228, -0.02579745650291443, 0.020945807918906212, 0.012045844458043575, -0.005078623536974192, -0.0009121443144977093, -0.022262413054704666, -0.02819737419486046, 0.024210086092352867, -0.013197362422943115, -0.03174009174108505, 0.004632859490811825, 0.001706197508610785, 0.020889824256300926, -0.010862494818866253, -0.024920929223299026, -0.037021491676568985, 0.00622656149789691, -0.02270750142633915, 0.017484458163380623, 0.0015854116063565016, 0.029772045090794563, -0.015641167759895325, 0.033568985760211945, 0.0437670573592186, 0.013830520212650299, 0.009609375149011612, 0.009197942912578583, 0.0025691234041005373, -0.0035182710271328688, 0.05005954951047897, -0.023816317319869995, 0.02463383786380291, 0.05583503469824791, -0.036569561809301376, -0.03215385973453522, -0.0044173430651426315, 0.0085254842415452, 0.01046784594655037, 0.00006524157652165741, -0.016136983409523964, -0.03222014755010605, 0.0070225391536951065, -0.064312644302845, -0.02622787281870842, -0.019075704738497734, -0.03387763351202011, 0.01351289451122284, 0.022587742656469345, -0.0020751995034515858, 0.00963645614683628, -0.031771522015333176, 0.024095285683870316, 0.03560519963502884, -0.004463333636522293, 0.013296849094331264, 0.033518433570861816, 0.006253204308450222, 0.03187327831983566, -0.007185766473412514, 0.004329652525484562, 0.05553492531180382, 0.0749581828713417, -0.04682557284832001, 0.04810114949941635, -0.0256970077753067, 0.0012921328889206052, -0.05327926203608513, 0.0005702119669876993, 0.0012517188442870975, -0.00044335235725156963, 0.03560149297118187, -0.012530111707746983, 0.0008188306819647551, 0.03816225379705429, -0.04000105708837509, 0.02095254510641098, -0.0276200994849205, -0.027815569192171097, -0.030937563627958298, -0.02078436128795147, -0.011972122825682163, 0.042734626680612564, 0.038928598165512085, -0.004322979599237442, 0.00605993065983057, 0.03845572844147682, -0.016151312738656998, 0.006754165980964899, -0.02847951091825962, 0.02405463345348835, 0.01741308718919754, -0.08957932144403458, 0.031228724867105484, -0.015280176885426044, -0.030508453026413918, 0.048908062279224396, 0.02252272702753544, 0.034167367964982986, -0.0025590029545128345, 0.037847843021154404, 0.007573030423372984, 0.05492717772722244, 0.024968871846795082, 0.021045170724391937, -0.01455593854188919, 0.010106055065989494, 0.026292167603969574, 0.017728853970766068, -0.004911683965474367, -0.0004342544998507947, -0.002298523671925068, -0.023933934047818184, -0.03729407861828804, 0.02284502051770687, -0.013189221732318401, -0.05015077814459801, -0.01627323590219021, -0.020230405032634735, -0.014457272365689278, -0.006656345911324024, 0.025166766718029976, -0.021625125780701637, 0.0013256591046229005, 0.039439067244529724, 0.04538198560476303, -0.017521731555461884, 0.008868596516549587, 0.0002558821579441428, -0.0466686449944973, 0.02213503234088421, 0.005486898124217987, -0.017631862312555313, -0.029918035492300987, 0.020874084904789925, 0.005122821312397718, 0.03435060754418373, 0.006642100866883993, -0.008902044035494328, -0.012835265137255192, 0.04202045872807503, -0.050662554800510406, 0.006954141892492771, 0.0010536719346418977, -0.004040542058646679, -0.004103099461644888, -0.10488682240247726, 0.09707827121019363, -0.016911430284380913, -0.025090381503105164, -0.029769349843263626, -0.002787436591461301, -0.02276228554546833, -0.02121899463236332, 0.06947851181030273, 0.047022175043821335, -0.006248020101338625, 0.010754736140370369, 0.04529442638158798, 0.001373543869704008, -0.061468079686164856, -0.00229322025552392, 0.0051665459759533405, -0.002305951900780201, -0.02664654701948166, -0.02099449932575226, 0.025312602519989014, 0.02094537392258644, 0.020017588511109352, -0.016664331778883934, 0.04148733615875244, 0.0371251218020916, 0.031155431643128395, 0.030808553099632263, 0.02474476769566536, -0.033322446048259735, 0.07921495288610458, -0.012554747052490711, 0.002624962478876114, 0.028589164838194847, -0.010103070177137852, -0.03692261874675751, 0.02350570820271969, -0.0015407322207465768, -0.05432012304663658, -0.039051543921232224, -0.0022542511578649282, -0.025454463437199593, -0.06011039763689041, -0.02343820594251156, 0.0449439212679863, -0.04603090137243271, 0.048854656517505646, 0.04957270622253418, 0.03522878512740135, 0.04460364207625389, 0.0024465967435389757, 0.013230746611952782, 0.007972227409482002, -0.012825519777834415, 0.013119781389832497, 0.0026925220154225826, 0.031762342900037766, -0.005034163128584623, 0.03188852220773697, 0.024632485583424568, -0.04581820219755173, 0.040210481733083725, -0.01285947859287262, 0.06050104647874832, -0.005729333031922579, -0.08036140352487564, 0.03865767642855644, -0.012451700866222382, 0.043288297951221466, 0.04069208353757858, -0.031070847064256668, 0.04946976527571678, -0.029202261939644814, 0.017161564901471138, -0.010585966520011425, -0.010958398692309856, -0.0552964024245739, -0.009249533526599407, 0.02342168614268303, -0.005682703573256731, 0.02734946645796299, 0.019079318270087242, 0.02872803434729576, 0.011120056733489037, 0.013654842041432858, -0.03580065071582794, 0.014194237068295479, -0.01712542399764061, 0.009740177541971207, -0.03555672615766525, -0.02968762069940567, -0.04858597368001938, -0.043498847633600235, 0.021842677146196365, 0.038873739540576935, 0.04286768287420273, 0.01387348584830761, -0.06324246525764465, 0.021984700113534927, 0.05822141841053963, -0.07160458713769913, -0.02330411970615387, -0.03379696235060692, -0.009184908121824265, -0.0016945097595453262, -0.0352192185819149 ]
<p>I have a total population of 31, of these I have a treatment finishing population of 20.</p> <p>I want to run a test on SPSS to identify if there are any significant differences between the 20 individuals that completed the treatment and the group as a whole.</p> <p>The variables I am trying to compare are age, weight, height and BMI.</p> <p>I have run descriptives for both the entire population and the sub group seperatley, I can see there is little difference between the groups but would like to know the statistical significance</p>
74,037
[ -0.08381617814302444, -0.01772230491042137, -0.030879061669111252, 0.015965541824698448, 0.03428215906023979, 0.0009819070110097528, -0.015293601900339127, -0.06856594979763031, 0.01304881926625967, -0.011554291471838951, 0.025407128036022186, 0.024625880643725395, 0.03493911400437355, 0.015642981976270676, 0.024053946137428284, 0.02062278613448143, -0.029258042573928833, -0.006785667967051268, 0.001922017545439303, 0.04132407158613205, -0.002217172645032406, 0.0050051892176270485, 0.003230051835998893, -0.04009104520082474, -0.03084157593548298, 0.03805521875619888, 0.0398981086909771, -0.04790906235575676, -0.007932533510029316, 0.044802263379096985, -0.06246093660593033, -0.042042192071676254, -0.003599293064326048, 0.02835971675813198, 0.022752853110432625, -0.002457559574395418, -0.039171602576971054, -0.01891343481838703, 0.011465984396636486, 0.024071762338280678, -0.03337157890200615, -0.011242520995438099, 0.01359788328409195, 0.02316572330892086, -0.025698572397232056, 0.019552109763026237, -0.013991757296025753, -0.0049228360876441, 0.015273724682629108, -0.009120591916143894, 0.06481875479221344, 0.01788979396224022, 0.03206761181354523, 0.0015683092642575502, -0.010138293728232384, 0.016204115003347397, 0.014521090313792229, 0.05249542370438576, 0.01535156648606062, -0.053139522671699524, -0.007054466288536787, -0.04195143282413483, 0.011943956837058067, -0.03013063222169876, -0.041808322072029114, 0.019298695027828217, -0.017397716641426086, -0.005108750890940428, 0.0534144788980484, 0.012316505424678326, 0.03738628700375557, 0.01486306544393301, 0.03421332687139511, 0.015883279964327812, 0.00980087835341692, -0.016154853627085686, 0.03462817147374153, -0.005414815153926611, 0.033127039670944214, 0.037893783301115036, 0.02968471497297287, 0.013138677924871445, 0.0010997429490089417, 0.051623959094285965, 0.009609472937881947, -0.01407194696366787, 0.03729075938463211, -0.00016110343858599663, 0.014869350008666515, 0.027635639533400536, -0.010563607327640057, 0.001839940552599728, 0.03484061732888222, 0.06474953889846802, -0.030324766412377357, 0.0001404937356710434, -0.030150143429636955, 0.058599069714546204, -0.006519791670143604, 0.004534997511655092, 0.040901441127061844, -0.024341266602277756, 0.04527829587459564, 0.023502741008996964, -0.03726819530129433, 0.011912577785551548, -0.0375579372048378, -0.04105790704488754, -0.011093003675341606, -0.01681305281817913, 0.0007418773020617664, 0.00220872787758708, -0.018059363588690758, -0.007155214436352253, 0.0095016248524189, -0.0041850898414850235, -0.03119724988937378, -0.008371977135539055, 0.06799048185348511, 0.036296334117650986, 0.03291995823383331, -0.005179743282496929, 0.011514757759869099, -0.014921783469617367, -0.030396420508623123, 0.01635584980249405, 0.015393480658531189, -0.04198603332042694, -0.05217649042606354, 0.061920445412397385, -0.00016911717830225825, 0.02420085482299328, 0.04734387248754501, -0.017443964257836342, 0.012252860702574253, -0.0030274835880845785, -0.05008184537291527, -0.05880139395594597, 0.02672317437827587, -0.0020016024354845285, 0.010454120114445686, -0.029876500368118286, -0.008357544429600239, -0.013817393220961094, 0.014143597334623337, 0.02097894437611103, 0.03551485016942024, 0.02007189579308033, 0.023392457515001297, 0.02451850287616253, 0.019404945895075798, 0.011959724128246307, -0.018419235944747925, -0.019142968580126762, -0.00045959866838529706, -0.1027594804763794, -0.0036800776142627, 0.027263641357421875, -0.011805753223598003, 0.0004384282510727644, 0.009105958975851536, -0.003792770206928253, 0.00030574656557291746, 0.006131894886493683, 0.02723701484501362, 0.01144655141979456, 0.05547572672367096, 0.000102656202216167, -0.005152479279786348, 0.018967103213071823, -0.003980780486017466, 0.028773462399840355, 0.018582187592983246, 0.04071607068181038, 0.012180522084236145, -0.011927471496164799, 0.013848730362951756, -0.011865385808050632, -0.008914114907383919, 0.0030031907372176647, -0.06850194931030273, -0.023566028103232384, -0.02843596413731575, 0.00020401683286763728, 0.01832491159439087, 0.04717211425304413, 0.016092125326395035, 0.013729028403759003, 0.048388779163360596, -0.04192819446325302, -0.0480317585170269, -0.08248437941074371, 0.025205006822943687, 0.02389559894800186, -0.05257519707083702, -0.03676237165927887, 0.013098135590553284, 0.03254269063472748, 0.009029113687574863, -0.010296836495399475, -0.023191291838884354, -0.02378854900598526, 0.016669759526848793, -0.02428952418267727, 0.019276944920420647, 0.03331330046057701, 0.06351257860660553, -0.04980107396841049, 0.028263457119464874, -0.031758539378643036, -0.022234657779335976, 0.009600224904716015, -0.03153471648693085, -0.015389850363135338, 0.01675032265484333, -0.007131059654057026, 0.016985999420285225, 0.03352726250886917, -0.031031960621476173, 0.06845638900995255, -0.046477120369672775, 0.10300924628973007, 0.07963159680366516, 0.002866004826501012, 0.0006688029388897121, -0.03221987560391426, 0.055267199873924255, 0.03172643110156059, -0.008161863312125206, -0.006039115134626627, -0.03412945196032524, -0.012725712731480598, 0.020192410796880722, -0.007989875972270966, -0.04488746449351311, -0.020944250747561455, 0.08491837233304977, -0.025652717798948288, 0.004990893416106701, 0.0184796042740345, 0.027847837656736374, -0.02844921313226223, 0.024363325908780098, 0.02768532559275627, 0.010508662089705467, 0.025060122832655907, 0.0076460386626422405, 0.022349931299686432, 0.029358023777604103, 0.020735954865813255, 0.012498260475695133, 0.049100156873464584, -0.0030115062836557627, 0.024356381967663765, -0.04582759737968445, -0.0400858074426651, 0.03250807151198387, -0.036353785544633865, -0.019422778859734535, 0.0502130351960659, 0.020737895742058754, -0.01974930427968502, -0.0070741488598287106, -0.032794881612062454, 0.04415036737918854, 0.06524060666561127, -0.025082364678382874, -0.012777370400726795, 0.008047614246606827, -0.05258890613913536, 0.0184490829706192, -0.014490173198282719, -0.03901834785938263, -0.04891884699463844, 0.03668791428208351, 0.07303019613027573, 0.0019980580545961857, 0.03200045973062515, -0.022162824869155884, -0.009843869134783745, -0.010263888165354729, -0.02259713225066662, 0.036781150847673416, -0.025118302553892136, -0.08295333385467529, -0.005146084353327751, -0.018967747688293457, -0.03511441498994827, 0.03833382576704025, -0.017589107155799866, -0.012430124916136265, 0.028583403676748276, 0.006308766547590494, -0.01838686875998974, -0.013580775819718838, -0.02903049625456333, 0.015209677629172802, -0.012242080643773079, -0.013213594444096088, 0.043395694345235825, 0.024727974086999893, -0.04194936156272888, 0.02727685309946537, -0.04000803455710411, 0.0013781802263110876, -0.013512814417481422, 0.0028525369707494974, 0.005096734035760164, 0.009956996887922287, 0.0003186241665389389, 0.02153981663286686, -0.01890227571129799, -0.028908245265483856, -0.07407578080892563, -0.07121124863624573, 0.031906384974718094, 0.04911202937364578, 0.057985372841358185, -0.05711186304688454, 0.00017083114653360099, 0.06100490689277649, -0.00435444014146924, -0.05334186181426048, -0.04253571480512619, -0.0060252295807003975, -0.042919181287288666, 0.0027164274360984564, 0.055318545550107956, 0.024291440844535828, -0.010001965798437595, 0.01951788365840912, 0.010647699236869812, 0.04247429966926575, 0.042068686336278915, 0.017203668132424355, -0.02280528098344803, 0.011671301908791065, 0.02431424893438816, -0.015527913346886635, 0.01820438541471958, 0.012504280544817448, -0.0762944296002388, -0.009755524806678295, -0.001100905705243349, 0.023953570052981377, 0.0010238417889922857, -0.04596062749624252, 0.019501306116580963, 0.0016449644463136792, 0.01735769212245941, -0.0056315260007977486, 0.031210942193865776, 0.012539595365524292, -0.022415341809391975, -0.03082425519824028, 0.019107632339000702, 0.021195754408836365, -0.02968567982316017, -0.00938032753765583, 0.06994999200105667, 0.026543106883764267, -0.022388886660337448, -0.016101742163300514, -0.002453563269227743, -0.045571133494377136, -0.025209469720721245, 0.0070198820903897285, -0.060294799506664276, 0.009450324811041355, 0.05625586956739426, 0.046992380172014236, 0.004882155917584896, -0.04823881387710571, 0.006661099847406149, -0.09811918437480927, 0.010855356231331825, -0.0360516682267189, 0.06561243534088135, -0.0007902168435975909, 0.044745590537786484, 0.0195075161755085, -0.00928746722638607, -0.01972886361181736, -0.0029861684888601303, -0.025069313123822212, 0.0623469352722168, -0.007193050812929869, 0.008729766122996807, 0.06466083228588104, -0.016123097389936447, 0.03237582743167877, -0.0048548318445682526, 0.027699382975697517, 0.007084606681019068, 0.052756328135728836, -0.02974221296608448, -0.015580019913613796, -0.005108439829200506, 0.014280530624091625, 0.0090019591152668, 0.01044788770377636, -0.013793197460472584, -0.01722821220755577, -0.004938703961670399, 0.029398979619145393, 0.003980716690421104, -0.023223180323839188, -0.035242412239313126, 0.001784572028554976, 0.012100331485271454, 0.07415875792503357, 0.020576460286974907, 0.03665885329246521, -0.06155264005064964, 0.03438149020075798, -0.020450295880436897, 0.04010029509663582, 0.013976389542222023, 0.004499811679124832, -0.020619317889213562, -0.00965625699609518, -0.0016692469362169504, 0.011354283429682255, 0.023240428417921066, 0.004838801454752684, -0.039677053689956665, 0.023989640176296234, 0.020230676978826523, -0.03460239991545677, 0.033113691955804825, 0.07549752295017242, 0.017624318599700928, -0.024791035801172256, -0.0506601445376873, -0.007506831549108028, -0.011401084251701832, -0.0231592059135437, 0.02226445823907852, 0.0068460195325315, 0.017165500670671463, -0.0008100983686745167, 0.0763145387172699, -0.004683765582740307, -0.06492646783590317, 0.013529197312891483, -0.035674139857292175, 0.066966712474823, 0.01616639643907547, -0.032958973199129105, 0.021868405863642693, 0.03535683825612068, 0.004300953820347786, 0.017489900812506676, -0.012114512734115124, -0.050764020532369614, -0.0009958349401131272, 0.048575639724731445, 0.04905889555811882, -0.06512915343046188, -0.008309141732752323, 0.002376783173531294, 0.014669839292764664, 0.08133675158023834, -0.022585859522223473, 0.015326895751059055, -0.004577585496008396, 0.01649785414338112, -0.019717056304216385, -0.0109293507412076, -0.04451023414731026, 0.0030800371896475554, -0.021119335666298866, 0.004005701746791601, -0.00991923175752163, -0.003094832180067897, -0.043387074023485184, -0.00919665489345789, 0.014448205940425396, 0.055085647851228714, -0.026908785104751587, -0.030627911910414696, 0.02367720566689968, 0.03177078068256378, 0.01117039006203413, -0.041851695626974106, 0.008978351019322872, 0.00020480211242102087, -0.0015967113431543112, 0.05935484543442726, -0.03381834551692009, -0.03246244415640831, 0.0012575172586366534, 0.0012428183108568192, -0.03371213749051094, -0.02896735817193985, -0.0533602312207222, 0.039478328078985214, -0.0015480458969250321, -0.02162826620042324, 0.0612160749733448, -0.016181590035557747, -0.011747604236006737, -0.0052030752412974834, -0.013048208318650723, -0.007514829747378826, -0.007134093903005123, -0.005466228350996971, -0.05718809738755226, -0.005522582214325666, 0.0005464019486680627, 0.04108961299061775, -0.010011550970375538, 0.025624314323067665, -0.03546145558357239, 0.00791915599256754, 0.026334306225180626, 0.036533791571855545, 0.014095112681388855, 0.009742127731442451, 0.010978862643241882, -0.006564703304320574, -0.011711172759532928, -0.04760822281241417, 0.04222346097230911, -0.02230588160455227, 0.012944231741130352, 0.007928450591862202, -0.0416107214987278, -0.00037050366518087685, -0.024466561153531075, -0.05970320105552673, 0.013371809385716915, -0.05517767742276192, -0.007049812935292721, -0.033897191286087036, 0.049071475863456726, -0.009561325423419476, -0.03477100282907486, -0.004039605148136616, 0.022391973063349724, -0.003756976220756769, 0.027547482401132584, -0.014847670681774616, 0.058439139276742935, -0.02277284860610962, -0.004600358661264181, -0.08031654357910156, -0.0586831159889698, 0.020950065925717354, 0.045386552810668945, -0.014038598164916039, -0.025082740932703018, 0.01767640933394432, -0.024269411340355873, -0.018399730324745178, 0.00512769864872098, 0.04650714993476868, -0.0014150916831567883, 0.0004713131347671151, -0.022192982956767082, 0.003659298410639167, 0.08459211885929108, 0.009809802286326885, -0.010794713161885738, 0.004626869224011898, 0.02793988026678562, -0.04370430111885071, -0.020056720823049545, -0.004644359461963177, -0.01746249943971634, -0.037205856293439865, -0.05490536615252495, 0.02245570905506611, 0.03316827863454819, -0.022818487137556076, -0.0051933578215539455, -0.003010180778801441, -0.034858640283346176, 0.016892628744244576, -0.03991937264800072, 0.00745785515755415, -0.022245200350880623, 0.002595557365566492, -0.04095166176557541, 0.006462450604885817, -0.016596857458353043, -0.014357635751366615, 0.0067952158860862255, 0.010520749725401402, -0.04778709262609482, 0.019542770460247993, 0.07564682513475418, 0.006980259902775288, 0.01643870770931244, -0.016730617731809616, -0.019200239330530167, -0.002913437085226178, 0.005537922028452158, -0.0031401400920003653, -0.018380790948867798, 0.05689263716340065, -0.005840817932039499, 0.025589656084775925, -0.025441568344831467, -0.006939810700714588, 0.06763339787721634, 0.024633923545479774, 0.04245534911751747, 0.06621487438678741, -0.026168260723352432, 0.0017230334924533963, -0.032357729971408844, 0.01842966116964817, 0.0008664419292472303, 0.018927691504359245, 0.05173857510089874, 0.0179101824760437, -0.036222849041223526, 0.0641900971531868, 0.018022723495960236, 0.02512606792151928, 0.06137355417013168, 0.03394388407468796, -0.009006425738334656, 0.025197384878993034, -0.04927816614508629, -0.05184800550341606, -0.005583259742707014, -0.03369927033782005, 0.016382083296775818, -0.0579712800681591, 0.0013284437591210008, 0.036225803196430206, 0.05049596354365349, 0.014127261936664581, -0.020615827292203903, -0.0021293258760124445, -0.03274596482515335, 0.011064784601330757, 0.016224317252635956, -0.004033923614770174, 0.006180915981531143, 0.0167961698025465, 0.029019998386502266, -0.011019045487046242, 0.02960391342639923, -0.043861377984285355, -0.06701865792274475, -0.0196602251380682, -0.023740142583847046, -0.061551857739686966, 0.03938634693622589, -0.027069341391324997, 0.005719792563468218, -0.022543132305145264, -0.021954083815217018, 0.005482485983520746, 0.02056688629090786, 0.01842120662331581, 0.012461013160645962, 0.04463229328393936, 0.014686443842947483, 0.007595579605549574, 0.06552929431200027, 0.005506716202944517, 0.1169012114405632, 0.054523009806871414, 0.026691734790802002, -0.04160366579890251, 0.030765287578105927, 0.009012448601424694, -0.005793181248009205, 0.011524488218128681, 0.000245373958023265, 0.01693767122924328, -0.018406281247735023, 0.06066471338272095, 0.05685625225305557, 0.013340141624212265, -0.017582900822162628, 0.05964077264070511, -0.02556304819881916, -0.052567094564437866, 0.038923416286706924, -0.01866144873201847, -0.013617959804832935, -0.010944126173853874, -0.03094196505844593, 0.008630254305899143, 0.010200374759733677, -0.014117498882114887, -0.043574944138526917, 0.014607680961489677, -0.000020087132725166157, 0.011646900326013565, -0.0057470849715173244, -0.03634481877088547, -0.003469378687441349, -0.004562159068882465, -0.09370231628417969, -0.03716558963060379, 0.001544986036606133, -0.06877955794334412, 0.0002786589611787349, 0.05484919622540474, -0.016818085685372353, -0.00787558127194643, -0.024083927273750305, 0.022893091663718224, -0.044733092188835144, -0.017280638217926025, -0.027811219915747643, 0.051798611879348755, -0.017101682722568512, -0.04628648981451988, -0.00830102525651455, 0.015887461602687836, -0.016369104385375977, -0.06608887016773224, -0.011425578035414219, -0.002814308274537325, 0.00455270754173398, -0.030361095443367958, -0.02243162877857685, -0.04470176249742508, -0.013929220847785473, -0.009302274323999882, 0.016818616539239883, 0.024933792650699615, -0.026856934651732445, -0.046512141823768616, -0.024715352803468704, 0.0057433173060417175, -0.0011332465801388025, 0.003125557443127036, 0.0175753403455019, -0.010824068449437618, -0.0001898114278446883, 0.04431675001978874, 0.02327079139649868, 0.03210682049393654, 0.041819099336862564, 0.004869634751230478, -0.03579311445355415, -0.03229214623570442, -0.02924208901822567, 0.03282224014401436, -0.02665141597390175, 0.01931905932724476, -0.014748256653547287, 0.020758166909217834, 0.03396152704954147, 0.04898899421095848, 0.023923328146338463, 0.035462863743305206, 0.0050255837850272655, 0.05915270373225212, 0.010879225097596645, -0.06790102273225784, -0.043581970036029816, 0.01282252836972475, -0.03579016402363777, 0.00651036761701107, -0.07449303567409515, 0.043749187141656876, 0.02530038170516491, 0.011636976152658463, -0.0268381517380476, 0.031154753640294075, -0.004526060540229082, 0.026424139738082886, -0.011546586640179157, -0.05212206766009331, 0.008872506208717823, 0.009073184803128242, -0.00749778188765049, -0.004875575192272663, -0.027333348989486694, -0.023727376013994217, -0.027492623776197433, 0.008336689323186874, -0.03248655050992966, -0.0029744531493633986, 0.00019265942682977766, -0.01868799328804016, -0.012083517387509346, -0.020908815786242485, 0.005823531653732061, -0.06369485706090927, -0.01619494892656803, 0.026774249970912933, 0.004515289794653654, -0.00004886426904704422, -0.004927368834614754, -0.024127421900629997, -0.018192889168858528, 0.03771514818072319, -0.01429054792970419, 0.018530936911702156, 0.018579881638288498, -0.0005253629060462117, 0.009400525130331516, 0.049510303884744644, 0.02050529420375824, -0.01314468402415514, 0.048449233174324036, -0.04166693985462189, -0.01985584758222103, 0.013847414404153824, -0.016006143763661385, 0.03564944490790367, 0.01423379871994257, -0.011779103428125381, -0.0016223067650571465, 0.06976508349180222, -0.021781571209430695, -0.030285386368632317, -0.030901974067091942, -0.005691966041922569, -0.0030010452028363943, 0.014463383704423904, -0.004446817561984062, 0.016285734251141548, -0.052962470799684525, 0.05635662376880646, 0.030428802594542503, -0.016185594722628593, -0.03217850252985954, -0.013482716865837574, -0.013053111732006073, 0.002690742490813136, 0.0018254119204357266, -0.005191026255488396, 0.04042618349194527, 0.03475054353475571, -0.01347134169191122, -0.0007047472172416747, -0.039424970746040344, -0.0063952491618692875, -0.09010440111160278, -0.037622302770614624, -0.024205798283219337, 0.018737049773335457, 0.007495599333196878, -0.03942231088876724, 0.02809211052954197, 0.01048923097550869, -0.0172733087092638, 0.015976300463080406, -0.004058152437210083, -0.011249568313360214, -0.018832284957170486, 0.024391278624534607, -0.0014214980183169246, 0.014917596243321896, 0.023901911452412605, 0.059545744210481644, 0.05438327044248581, 0.03853800147771835, 0.012669363059103489, -0.021607547998428345, -0.0063447956927120686, 0.02432648278772831, 0.016953080892562866, -0.05267387256026268, -0.0010075055761262774, -0.023504558950662613, -0.026935873553156853, 0.03866105526685715, -0.013517381623387337, 0.026589153334498405, 0.020652562379837036, 0.029056740924715996, 0.003621176118031144, 0.05307534337043762, 0.049977533519268036, 0.017770342528820038, -0.016894740983843803, 0.03843291476368904, -0.019209038466215134, 0.04039176180958748, -0.053991883993148804, 0.016715219244360924, 0.04535505548119545, -0.01880531571805477, 0.003249481553211808, 0.02610594592988491, -0.004620254971086979, -0.031421732157468796, -0.01271576713770628, -0.027377817779779434, 0.03423726186156273, -0.01870528608560562, 0.012751903384923935, -0.038723282516002655, -0.01756024733185768, 0.013029242865741253, -0.01239147037267685, -0.04998283460736275, 0.020802754908800125, 0.0023746993392705917, -0.02853108011186123, -0.016794010996818542, -0.018380872905254364, -0.007550778333097696, -0.057066429406404495, -0.005210597068071365, -0.018674150109291077, -0.0035201970022171736, -0.040491968393325806, -0.0003573951544240117, -0.011390093713998795, 0.0411624014377594, -0.028412451967597008, -0.021598270162940025, 0.021080251783132553, 0.021868480369448662, 0.016390463337302208, -0.05960099771618843, 0.03687546029686928, 0.004684287589043379, -0.03024759329855442, -0.04353291168808937, -0.012430778704583645, -0.03325289487838745, 0.0021447064355015755, 0.055494509637355804, -0.0019954906310886145, 0.016120802611112595, -0.004753476940095425, 0.025436032563447952, -0.023470010608434677, -0.03213416785001755, 0.06454142928123474, 0.011289367452263832, -0.05032389611005783, -0.05463730916380882, 0.030693231150507927, 0.026238849386572838, 0.0034511913545429707, 0.03476221486926079, -0.041971489787101746, -0.0018614125438034534, 0.014800893142819405, 0.006537465378642082, 0.03534829244017601, -0.001338726026006043, -0.023887217044830322, 0.01814538985490799, -0.001165562542155385, -0.015066539868712425, 0.05035367235541344, 0.009447677992284298, -0.03217824921011925, 0.03230778127908707, -0.013503356836736202, 0.003916833084076643, 0.0044558183290064335, 0.01826656609773636, -0.06188230961561203, -0.04140192270278931, 0.018791669979691505, 0.006115274969488382, -0.034165725111961365, 0.01374194398522377, -0.0015550187090411782, 0.056665003299713135, 0.006513642147183418, -0.024553075432777405, -0.00974282156676054, 0.0003727746370714158, -0.004778524860739708, 0.02744203619658947, 0.03355271369218826, 0.010454429313540459, 0.013205552473664284, 0.0037931425031274557, 0.016501925885677338, -0.010329323820769787, 0.04553554952144623, 0.023366300389170647, 0.004557837266474962, -0.01770090125501156, -0.0033947674091905355, -0.007611231878399849, -0.010335850529372692, 0.04657831788063049, -0.00030524484463967383, -0.01594327948987484, 0.027765607461333275, 0.006134656723588705, 0.0032786012161523104, -0.01809839718043804, 0.004387685563415289, -0.039813823997974396, -0.014469877816736698, 0.05531763657927513, 0.007230021059513092, -0.013759186491370201, -0.011728529818356037, 0.01232302375137806, -0.011391597799956799, 0.043393924832344055, -0.012684297747910023, 0.0263496283441782, -0.026034196838736534, 0.008297541178762913, -0.029539594426751137, -0.020305989310145378, -0.05033903941512108, 0.00956826750189066, 0.05554109066724777, 0.03970850259065628, 0.03436289727687836, -0.018595770001411438, -0.023644814267754555, 0.026810849085450172, 0.048830099403858185, -0.039135951548814774, -0.044724904000759125, -0.04379433020949364, 0.0038614373188465834, 0.008895388804376125, 0.004959927871823311 ]
<p>(Possibly related to <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/17342/is-there-a-nonparametric-equivalent-of-tukey-hsd">Is there a nonparametric equivalent of Tukey HSD?</a>)</p> <p>Given a set of several exponentially distributed variables (representing data which is modeled this way), I'd like to check whether one of them has a significantly higher mean than the others. If the variables were normally distributed, I would have used Tukey's test; however, this is not the case, and I'm looking for as simple alternative as possible. </p> <p><strong>Some background on the data</strong> </p> <p>Alternative methods and markets from which we buy goods are compared every day. Data is aggregated on a daily basis (i.e. I only have prices and number of transactions per day, which translate to a mean). The distribution of funds for the next day is based on previous' day analysis: best method gets most of the funds, and the other methods share the rest. Typically, 5-10 alternative methods are compared, with 10,000 and more transactions per method per day.</p> <p><strong>Current Alternatives</strong></p> <p>Based on my limited knowledge, I came up with two possible ways of comparing methods:</p> <ol> <li><p>Based on the referenced question above, a nonparametric versions of Tukey's test can be used.</p></li> <li><p>Since only the highest-mean variable is compared to the rest of the variables, I think it can be compared to the second highest with <em>bonferroni correction</em>. i.e. use effective alpha = 0.05 / number of variables. This might be very conservative, but since the numbers are high, the results are usable (i.e. most days have significent results).</p></li> </ol> <p><strong>My questions</strong></p> <ol> <li><p>Do the methods above make sense as solutions to the presented case? specifically, method (2) is simple and yields usable results, but I'm not sure it's statistically sound.</p></li> <li><p>I'm interested in any other suggestions for performing this analysis. As noted, I'm more interested in simplicity and generalization, and less on getting the best significance values.</p></li> </ol>
74,038
[ -0.01495097391307354, 0.014384434558451176, 0.01265499833971262, -0.015134715475142002, 0.034269437193870544, -0.014788052998483181, 0.02170223370194435, -0.025100640952587128, 0.020967237651348114, -0.01652049832046032, 0.032760217785835266, 0.026591017842292786, 0.047607872635126114, 0.039771415293216705, -0.0040970658883452415, -0.014656780287623405, -0.013950293883681297, 0.013976672664284706, 0.012786977924406528, -0.02038281038403511, -0.022281091660261154, -0.012220834381878376, 0.020263303071260452, -0.03244589641690254, -0.05480834096670151, 0.03093012608587742, -0.014521731063723564, -0.022509176284074783, -0.028452230617403984, 0.04997759312391281, -0.05095295235514641, -0.03138960152864456, -0.011627067811787128, 0.021510226652026176, -0.01138203963637352, 0.025687038898468018, -0.0016401439206674695, -0.018727729097008705, -0.024520110338926315, 0.033797815442085266, -0.018623584881424904, -0.022200316190719604, 0.006599718239158392, -0.001985440496355295, 0.023125415667891502, 0.02146405726671219, 0.002250006189569831, -0.0357777364552021, 0.026420366019010544, -0.05026938393712044, 0.05536903440952301, 0.004285579081624746, 0.004280198831111193, -0.0021384945139288902, -0.0383128747344017, -0.05973575636744499, 0.024920515716075897, 0.050401777029037476, 0.00656611192971468, -0.06205857917666435, 0.017924858257174492, 0.010058819316327572, -0.0032304469496011734, -0.020467525348067284, -0.03762456774711609, 0.05355050414800644, 0.002616969868540764, 0.006587636191397905, 0.030191656202077866, -0.012184699065983295, 0.016886848956346512, -0.00046138028847053647, 0.025465693324804306, 0.027950365096330643, -0.025015167891979218, 0.015736088156700134, -0.005228968802839518, 0.030695641413331032, 0.059968966990709305, 0.038905344903469086, -0.013283963315188885, 0.001307763042859733, 0.00765467993915081, 0.05428845062851906, 0.0442793034017086, -0.029911037534475327, 0.07951968908309937, -0.02411113679409027, -0.016933415085077286, 0.03423454985022545, 0.017363067716360092, -0.032588884234428406, 0.06590777635574341, 0.0075641474686563015, -0.028194651007652283, 0.01660284586250782, -0.019306493923068047, -0.013719468377530575, -0.03280293941497803, 0.02972675859928131, -0.008259909227490425, -0.07163318991661072, 0.02169732190668583, 0.019554991275072098, 0.015536335296928883, 0.0006945183267816901, -0.012888667173683643, -0.01868046075105667, -0.02777295745909214, 0.004223554860800505, -0.03262733295559883, 0.019827838987112045, -0.010729320347309113, 0.015364957973361015, 0.003154042409732938, -0.026341380551457405, -0.03307763859629631, -0.039355311542749405, 0.029305078089237213, 0.05091182142496109, 0.039020270109176636, -0.011056811548769474, 0.01728285290300846, -0.041209928691387177, -0.042550135403871536, -0.0000601144929532893, -0.031227853149175644, 0.009897506795823574, -0.045896150171756744, 0.06619936972856522, 0.015222091227769852, -0.012516279704868793, 0.04597672075033188, -0.018346907570958138, 0.013517072424292564, 0.01913445070385933, -0.06411280483007431, -0.07644261419773102, 0.05775155499577522, 0.008334312587976456, 0.018912816420197487, -0.04897924140095711, -0.013562588021159172, 0.045831479132175446, 0.008155856281518936, 0.020418116822838783, 0.055201124399900436, 0.036838676780462265, 0.03494361788034439, 0.027927201241254807, -0.03367963060736656, -0.008999631740152836, -0.009460894390940666, -0.019362447783350945, 0.001738492283038795, -0.05471713840961456, -0.003245673608034849, -0.0019281492568552494, -0.012613020837306976, 0.03153463825583458, 0.036164380609989166, 0.020549915730953217, -0.04364343360066414, -0.00021778829977847636, 0.02676270343363285, 0.0054093655198812485, 0.05282020941376686, 0.03212684765458107, 0.026647882536053658, -0.028597930446267128, -0.05059068650007248, 0.03408943861722946, -0.015108474530279636, 0.010836551897227764, 0.03337676450610161, -0.012409904040396214, 0.0067659723572432995, -0.06999325752258301, 0.026543354615569115, 0.036861445754766464, -0.03847460076212883, 0.030734354630112648, -0.04389778897166252, -0.028746016323566437, 0.0074480618350207806, 0.039222121238708496, -0.0042785340920090675, -0.010722075589001179, 0.003729180432856083, -0.08394656330347061, -0.06769899278879166, -0.030580759048461914, -0.015763098374009132, -0.0014598702546209097, -0.03131081908941269, 0.0583784393966198, -0.011417638510465622, 0.0213051438331604, 0.01762322336435318, 0.015450287610292435, 0.025006579235196114, -0.016374792903661728, 0.06955569237470627, -0.06154242902994156, -0.005838057026267052, 0.02567613124847412, 0.04646569490432739, -0.0429547093808651, 0.01068593468517065, -0.03670118376612663, -0.04835296422243118, 0.018568962812423706, -0.06365732848644257, 0.0210530087351799, 0.0050721801817417145, -0.010529538616538048, 0.06061527505517006, -0.01227960828691721, -0.029877085238695145, 0.04170713946223259, -0.06750470399856567, 0.031909044831991196, 0.04139912128448486, 0.017846057191491127, 0.0018943535396829247, 0.02018154226243496, -0.026084469631314278, 0.03511815890669823, -0.02207583747804165, 0.006801690440624952, -0.03577834367752075, -0.0040199668146669865, 0.02722652442753315, 0.00145336810965091, -0.04953010380268097, 0.04321727529168129, 0.10234879702329636, 0.03380424901843071, -0.028057968243956566, 0.046942707151174545, -0.005550947971642017, -0.021083787083625793, 0.00408798037096858, 0.04318259656429291, 0.06444401293992996, 0.03908929601311684, 0.02960320934653282, -0.004641932435333729, 0.018524285405874252, 0.048873014748096466, 0.026355205103754997, -0.005268574226647615, 0.006948455702513456, 0.001296831527724862, -0.015125991776585579, -0.027764873579144478, 0.028632301837205887, -0.006717571057379246, -0.01908585987985134, 0.03828885406255722, -0.02671167068183422, -0.0018230180721729994, -0.00954891461879015, -0.019118117168545723, 0.04556914418935776, 0.02112209051847458, -0.012960631400346756, 0.02216036058962345, 0.042829953134059906, -0.04160681739449501, -0.006380726583302021, -0.05652279034256935, -0.01648019254207611, -0.011202148161828518, -0.020154908299446106, 0.005869599059224129, 0.00044667781912721694, 0.004214580170810223, -0.033249013125896454, 0.0038273315876722336, -0.03162387013435364, -0.005791040603071451, 0.01742522232234478, -0.03719065710902214, -0.09001175314188004, -0.016487933695316315, -0.047176141291856766, -0.008852098137140274, 0.030779412016272545, 0.007139191962778568, -0.016299566254019737, 0.06402122229337692, 0.05161092057824135, -0.04074496030807495, 0.009464709088206291, 0.0032551472540944815, 0.003136474173516035, -0.05025206133723259, -0.0019424168858677149, 0.036669351160526276, 0.02506292797625065, -0.0446743443608284, 0.016768628731369972, -0.028169739991426468, -0.031516291201114655, -0.030117228627204895, -0.020262859761714935, -0.038750048726797104, -0.011266144923865795, -0.0027242398355156183, 0.02282741107046604, 0.006937805563211441, -0.016765030100941658, -0.07066836953163147, -0.05038020387291908, -0.005261322949081659, -0.006308059673756361, 0.025702660903334618, 0.003773338394239545, -0.037113871425390244, 0.06783614307641983, 0.017529943957924843, -0.05137840285897255, -0.040169857442379, 0.02957908809185028, -0.01360135618597269, 0.005403927993029356, 0.017355330288410187, 0.03828946128487587, 0.007987862452864647, -0.011927658692002296, -0.01675037480890751, 0.011325113475322723, 0.05099433287978172, 0.0362960621714592, -0.0010085089597851038, 0.035978663712739944, 0.015621783211827278, -0.005935012362897396, 0.0313112847507, 0.014812713488936424, -0.045677460730075836, 0.007297576870769262, 0.02889600582420826, 0.019850872457027435, 0.004042668733745813, -0.04522907733917236, 0.02895110473036766, 0.02069137617945671, -0.018042903393507004, -0.009636868722736835, -0.0311465784907341, 0.005605537910014391, -0.045209743082523346, -0.03085441142320633, -0.005011476576328278, 0.030254581943154335, 0.012393415905535221, 0.04428035020828247, 0.051729876548051834, 0.08871439844369888, -0.025276677682995796, -0.0068068308755755424, -0.05100448057055473, -0.007529188878834248, -0.009395662695169449, -0.020145317539572716, -0.02292747236788273, -0.006924574729055166, 0.05243634060025215, 0.005803362932056189, -0.002060868078842759, -0.04699430614709854, -0.000584363762754947, -0.0809355154633522, 0.01060682162642479, -0.04196514934301376, 0.0602337084710598, 0.026736589148640633, 0.024457955732941628, 0.008459270000457764, -0.0067306999117136, -0.011143774725496769, -0.004820721223950386, -0.07227965444326401, 0.02178964577615261, 0.0015179443871602416, -0.0006484109908342361, 0.004491790197789669, -0.03494412824511528, 0.010378382168710232, 0.00810643658041954, 0.042992692440748215, -0.010244670324027538, 0.01786389946937561, -0.03860466554760933, -0.0011442507384344935, -0.009137311019003391, -0.01860354281961918, -0.05955720692873001, 0.011107390746474266, 0.035961564630270004, 0.0076077482663095, 0.02994758076965809, -0.004628175403922796, 0.0007737634005025029, 0.005526556633412838, 0.011892113834619522, 0.06296710669994354, 0.009331479668617249, 0.02947533130645752, -0.017082614824175835, 0.04171297699213028, -0.03264090046286583, 0.03137940913438797, 0.01675533689558506, 0.03322893753647804, 0.032727744430303574, -0.04320156201720238, -0.031590454280376434, 0.016451654955744743, 0.012990660965442657, 0.02720803953707218, -0.006341803818941116, 0.021536724641919136, 0.0037073625717312098, 0.06303703784942627, 0.06254395097494125, 0.013869543559849262, -0.001948501798324287, 0.04255078360438347, 0.0020328129176050425, 0.005190364085137844, -0.01141307782381773, -0.041317183524370193, -0.017274556681513786, 0.02418721653521061, 0.01730428636074066, 0.031177522614598274, 0.04088291525840759, 0.001758403843268752, 0.012122208252549171, 0.015088880434632301, -0.020108278840780258, -0.006724497769027948, 0.012675086967647076, 0.006501825526356697, -0.0000902226529433392, -0.04656985029578209, 0.027622099965810776, 0.057499323040246964, 0.02952367067337036, 0.04752412810921669, 0.03508744388818741, -0.08516921103000641, 0.02148623578250408, 0.025765199214220047, 0.026441054418683052, -0.028682930395007133, -0.01988539658486843, -0.03041367419064045, -0.002522003138437867, 0.028354914858937263, -0.030655205249786377, 0.02793092466890812, -0.0185015257447958, 0.021002700552344322, -0.03430097922682762, -0.04199826344847679, -0.05205889418721199, -0.020722532644867897, -0.009571453556418419, 0.0034752460196614265, 0.00991464126855135, -0.010682810097932816, -0.0437927208840847, 0.01258356124162674, 0.024277163669466972, 0.03752647712826729, -0.01833956316113472, -0.01608950085937977, 0.01969817839562893, 0.026397084817290306, -0.046722590923309326, -0.049226775765419006, 0.04414837062358856, -0.02138492837548256, -0.030605942010879517, 0.03362384811043739, -0.014586848206818104, -0.027695000171661377, 0.013397229835391045, -0.027372445911169052, -0.03646526485681534, 0.04130839183926582, -0.022542450577020645, 0.022336989641189575, 0.044344156980514526, 0.045414842665195465, 0.07897302508354187, 0.04315271973609924, -0.017472928389906883, -0.0026001862715929747, -0.03561469539999962, -0.03495537117123604, -0.012867752462625504, 0.00463804230093956, -0.03105938248336315, -0.03217463940382004, -0.03004118613898754, 0.021152107045054436, -0.004967068322002888, 0.04197423532605171, -0.01872118003666401, 0.023570669814944267, 0.03510153666138649, 0.022091617807745934, -0.019542699679732323, -0.028463082388043404, -0.02171783521771431, 0.016212381422519684, -0.008413026109337807, 0.0010531630832701921, 0.03134501725435257, -0.02517455257475376, 0.006274475250393152, 0.006617658771574497, -0.040092118084430695, -0.014473875984549522, -0.027810920029878616, 0.00885250885039568, -0.015771903097629547, 0.01915576122701168, 0.031087899580597878, 0.003654283471405506, 0.016863783821463585, 0.00400168402120471, -0.009549420326948166, 0.005844218656420708, 0.07787501811981201, -0.014412594959139824, 0.03986644372344017, 0.0011000304948538542, 0.0461953841149807, 0.01007660198956728, -0.03465154021978378, -0.056430526077747345, -0.04470963403582573, 0.06118429824709892, 0.05246749892830849, -0.012158706784248352, -0.023751504719257355, -0.0003644869721028954, -0.020351611077785492, -0.006267085671424866, -0.02394811064004898, 0.01897105574607849, 0.0003549022367224097, -0.03427334502339363, -0.012493878602981567, 0.0020155985839664936, 0.058869823813438416, -0.02476910501718521, -0.005914995446801186, 0.02437562309205532, 0.01942380703985691, 0.0025830729864537716, -0.011096692644059658, -0.0023686462081968784, -0.05951916426420212, -0.006699258927255869, -0.01800685003399849, -0.02795548178255558, 0.0297388918697834, 0.021215708926320076, -0.04222863167524338, 0.04710003733634949, -0.025377104058861732, -0.03068164549767971, -0.008266523480415344, 0.007597725838422775, 0.0127240139991045, 0.012576443143188953, -0.01582689955830574, -0.0104698920622468, -0.02161930315196514, -0.017946036532521248, -0.012358252890408039, -0.012790354900062084, -0.041263777762651443, 0.03145430609583855, 0.03946525603532791, -0.007429031655192375, 0.02399863675236702, -0.012666181661188602, -0.014338037930428982, 0.03744417056441307, -0.0052366252057254314, 0.03768228366971016, -0.005800069309771061, 0.024717768654227257, -0.0011051404289901257, -0.05142371729016304, -0.01750432327389717, -0.0015982643235474825, 0.048917852342128754, 0.014575270004570484, 0.024438753724098206, 0.02232898212969303, 0.037933602929115295, 0.022482581436634064, -0.012803459540009499, -0.00384759483858943, -0.005699499510228634, 0.019714154303073883, 0.049705564975738525, -0.02094096690416336, -0.0035216344986110926, 0.0981377437710762, 0.017395183444023132, 0.038956351578235626, 0.04204309731721878, 0.0004049025592394173, 0.0017728552920743823, 0.034803252667188644, -0.08045852929353714, -0.032084133476018906, 0.0052251690067350864, -0.05732100456953049, 0.053591083735227585, -0.04702488332986832, -0.036071907728910446, 0.007482654880732298, -0.0009716078639030457, -0.025360064581036568, -0.037273552268743515, -0.03764118254184723, -0.07800675183534622, -0.00011176778934895992, 0.007719854358583689, -0.00018226998508907855, 0.04665680229663849, -0.0028844091575592756, 0.03692055121064186, -0.007980499416589737, 0.024224240332841873, -0.009622091427445412, -0.05816320329904556, 0.008053990080952644, 0.018951211124658585, -0.046271342784166336, 0.035429295152425766, -0.020561188459396362, -0.02972693182528019, 0.019416186958551407, -0.047822751104831696, -0.0007376583525910974, -0.0018200093181803823, 0.00930442288517952, 0.03697160258889198, 0.0723150297999382, -0.023035775870084763, 0.023665912449359894, -0.041541874408721924, -0.030665714293718338, 0.11682726442813873, 0.080239437520504, 0.05404966324567795, -0.010161957703530788, 0.0013798066647723317, 0.003895942121744156, 0.0037986363749951124, -0.025621997192502022, 0.00824022851884365, 0.03429904952645302, -0.017119958996772766, 0.04745708405971527, 0.08416138589382172, -0.04570799320936203, -0.026779327541589737, 0.04712783917784691, -0.04489698261022568, 0.006214558612555265, 0.0560750737786293, 0.03713545575737953, 0.04222612455487251, -0.039531558752059937, -0.05026538670063019, 0.058621518313884735, -0.009224656037986279, -0.0022056882735341787, -0.0073268599808216095, -0.017644107341766357, 0.003655623644590378, -0.010153978131711483, -0.00623038737103343, 0.003967895172536373, 0.010975233279168606, -0.028785856440663338, 0.008878620341420174, -0.009145492687821388, 0.042232297360897064, -0.0691632628440857, 0.03287101164460182, 0.06479128450155258, -0.014082829467952251, -0.0207988228648901, 0.006892423611134291, 0.018606018275022507, -0.0497760996222496, 0.0271189883351326, -0.05021295323967934, 0.01645093411207199, -0.01876405067741871, -0.02356104366481304, -0.048226431012153625, -0.0017725753132253885, -0.0033639194443821907, -0.009194016456604004, -0.03954077512025833, 0.022023487836122513, 0.04677824303507805, -0.023693693801760674, -0.02003910019993782, -0.02475367672741413, 0.010377855040133, 0.03497397154569626, 0.010519130155444145, -0.0017090445617213845, -0.03119107522070408, -0.03511172905564308, -0.021496782079339027, 0.03845647722482681, 0.020740650594234467, -0.022693060338497162, -0.026173371821641922, -0.0005537315155379474, -0.018154768273234367, 0.009239415638148785, -0.01869300939142704, 0.001449858769774437, 0.039184652268886566, -0.0014751867856830359, 0.005170386750251055, -0.02854565531015396, -0.03149431198835373, 0.02210623025894165, -0.023014487698674202, -0.004998601973056793, -0.03238175809383392, -0.008763049729168415, 0.007031868677586317, -0.00012759561650454998, 0.05907082557678223, 0.01960662193596363, -0.013974358327686787, 0.07583925873041153, 0.005159328691661358, -0.048122528940439224, -0.03704299032688141, -0.04414413124322891, -0.0037702638655900955, -0.01748667098581791, -0.02220599539577961, 0.0335603766143322, 0.04781677946448326, -0.02597806043922901, 0.021777819842100143, -0.0101874815300107, -0.008603633381426334, 0.010551556013524532, 0.042608946561813354, -0.06523790955543518, -0.017023500055074692, 0.03373969346284866, 0.02050234004855156, -0.0005291066481731832, -0.0035686104092746973, -0.045668136328458786, -0.005259500816464424, 0.01502256840467453, -0.011990000493824482, -0.01611565425992012, 0.03429539129137993, 0.017475595697760582, 0.06885625422000885, 0.03006729483604431, 0.01709040068089962, -0.050179194658994675, 0.011509716510772705, -0.031686797738075256, -0.009923434816300869, -0.003748175222426653, 0.04795801639556885, 0.0025454259011894464, 0.01623607613146305, 0.07390734553337097, 0.034736085683107376, 0.011847488582134247, -0.04251953586935997, -0.01571182906627655, 0.01127525046467781, 0.016753746196627617, -0.005431182216852903, -0.015252936631441116, 0.02967950701713562, -0.016245171427726746, -0.0014760479098185897, 0.02872360125184059, 0.027103422209620476, -0.010701158083975315, 0.003118195105344057, -0.021541031077504158, -0.02733469195663929, 0.006512755993753672, -0.058803725987672806, -0.028300171718001366, -0.0004771339881699532, -0.01645876094698906, 0.017729531973600388, 0.010844851844012737, -0.012085555121302605, 0.03526834771037102, -0.0414571613073349, 0.03841947764158249, 0.03500538691878319, 0.05091238021850586, 0.023896748200058937, 0.01844458095729351, -0.022194726392626762, 0.0011257020523771644, 0.009753698483109474, -0.027434706687927246, 0.03294047340750694, 0.07619927078485489, -0.04475538805127144, -0.0033391728065907955, -0.0416717566549778, 0.0047727408818900585, -0.03840089216828346, -0.007881004363298416, 0.010171477682888508, -0.020194748416543007, 0.0603649765253067, 0.006533362437039614, 0.018977291882038116, 0.030783358961343765, -0.052454736083745956, 0.04931560903787613, -0.01723945140838623, -0.00471653463318944, -0.05511811748147011, -0.005830923095345497, -0.003193079959601164, 0.016435977071523666, -0.005331371910870075, 0.029660053551197052, 0.017960483208298683, 0.047777511179447174, -0.008043386973440647, -0.020198605954647064, -0.033921029418706894, -0.004693578463047743, 0.004882020875811577, -0.0640815868973732, 0.022918932139873505, -0.019754683598876, -0.01678590290248394, 0.022752728313207626, -0.018565243110060692, 0.015623965300619602, -0.03447646275162697, -0.01018260233104229, -0.014169743284583092, 0.03367757052183151, 0.03569692000746727, 0.016959939152002335, -0.03707251697778702, -0.013736254535615444, 0.0174818467348814, 0.025719743221998215, 0.019582562148571014, 0.0023665246553719044, 0.024759961292147636, -0.00990019179880619, -0.0014167620101943612, 0.00230785203166306, 0.017062826082110405, -0.007150496821850538, -0.012372753582894802, -0.02143709361553192, 0.05170362442731857, -0.0011730478145182133, -0.028491007164120674, -0.00886288657784462, 0.02906166948378086, 0.02310941554605961, 0.011512717232108116, -0.05642589181661606, -0.008851439692080021, -0.008100299164652824, -0.0342194102704525, -0.006237128283828497, 0.015135753899812698, 0.034430526196956635, -0.02394910342991352, -0.026381833478808403, -0.03102046623826027, -0.01378586608916521, -0.015476499684154987, -0.019979864358901978, -0.01842474564909935, 0.0006416990072466433, -0.04660306125879288, 0.03139733150601387, -0.006394707132130861, 0.007129632402211428, 0.023986930027604103, -0.07485882192850113, 0.04179578647017479, -0.006738780532032251, 0.006938914302736521, -0.016181914135813713, -0.010523930191993713, -0.049177367240190506, -0.004183686804026365, 0.08669866621494293, -0.009187854826450348, -0.012881624512374401, 0.01763654500246048, -0.0010929559357464314, 0.0005513663636520505, -0.07106422632932663, 0.02541806362569332, 0.008782153017818928, -0.010954882018268108, -0.018087444826960564, -0.010278909467160702, 0.012922875583171844, -0.006880136672407389, 0.02578359842300415, -0.021607816219329834, 0.0009037155541591346, -0.01006521936506033, 0.02787785604596138, 0.026675457134842873, 0.008097739890217781, -0.03494705259799957, 0.027801861986517906, 0.012990443035960197, -0.0025299217086285353, 0.017485104501247406, -0.04038754105567932, -0.058902498334646225, 0.028967777267098427, -0.044030431658029556, -0.003521737176924944, -0.014101964421570301, 0.006752596236765385, -0.010949288494884968, -0.030645333230495453, 0.0027413014322519302, 0.031937647610902786, -0.0064614517614245415, -0.0046892617829144, 0.013071009889245033, 0.013758714310824871, 0.028079180046916008, 0.02793102338910103, 0.04923216253519058, -0.0019934421870857477, -0.007768690586090088, -0.019634319469332695, -0.0087105268612504, 0.03449435159564018, -0.0006597288302145898, -0.008992559276521206, 0.02922254428267479, -0.029767613857984543, 0.03934178128838539, -0.018139343708753586, 0.01249754149466753, 0.011793035082519054, -0.04186072200536728, -0.002853507874533534, 0.020312169566750526, 0.001838608062826097, 0.011636821553111076, -0.01626880094408989, 0.06662893295288086, -0.0451691634953022, 0.023767678067088127, -0.022247089073061943, 0.013791602104902267, 0.02595011331140995, -0.00986948236823082, -0.0026605708990246058, -0.0016106339171528816, -0.02960365265607834, 0.024771399796009064, -0.007139646913856268, 0.05579247325658798, -0.017401788383722305, -0.01812581531703472, 0.02443666197359562, -0.016908299177885056, 0.023827752098441124, -0.002321619773283601, -0.07428662478923798, -0.03795095905661583, -0.06525105983018875, 0.006370983086526394, 0.028469564393162727, 0.024220405146479607, -0.010596091859042645, -0.03605147823691368, 0.012577537447214127, 0.06570721417665482, -0.05441012978553772, -0.00826569925993681, -0.04448096081614494, 0.015085929073393345, 0.013061797246336937, -0.012603827752172947 ]
<p>In the following problem, check that it is appropriate to use the normal approximation to the binomial. Then use the normal distribution to estimate the requested probabilities.</p> <p>It is known that 85% of all new products introduced in grocery stores fail (are taken off the market) within 2 years. If a grocery store chain introduces 68 new products, find the following probabilities. (Round your answers to four decimal places.)</p> <p>(a) within 2 years 47 or more fail</p> <p>(b) within 2 years 58 or fewer fail . </p> <p>(c) within 2 years 15 or more succeed . </p> <p>(d) within 2 years fewer than 10 succeed</p>
36,663
[ -0.04385129734873772, -0.0662960559129715, -0.0012890375219285488, 0.019791362807154655, 0.011367782019078732, -0.042960602790117264, -0.007799056358635426, 0.004091781098395586, 0.0333799310028553, -0.004903001245111227, 0.014805597253143787, 0.048779550939798355, -0.0036081934813410044, 0.04264998435974121, 0.020837070420384407, 0.02859337441623211, -0.05721866339445114, -0.01768556796014309, -0.0018863299628719687, 0.005854320712387562, 0.03892148658633232, -0.01353022176772356, 0.01927511766552925, -0.004372456576675177, -0.0355006568133831, 0.026914890855550766, 0.009050729684531689, -0.015620806254446507, 0.023716719821095467, 0.06419099122285843, -0.030899276956915855, -0.023523323237895966, -0.0005968191544525325, 0.03195181116461754, 0.04716041684150696, 0.012897057458758354, -0.03636582940816879, -0.02738798037171364, -0.04827570542693138, -0.030595222488045692, -0.05101945996284485, 0.03150198981165886, 0.0011867514112964272, 0.01551976427435875, -0.02265607938170433, -0.0013007459929212928, -0.024714408442378044, -0.06001179292798042, 0.038452859967947006, -0.038093846291303635, 0.08400023728609085, -0.006249483674764633, 0.027928462252020836, 0.01916145160794258, -0.023772574961185455, -0.0459030345082283, 0.03657294809818268, 0.05236482247710228, -0.05137544125318527, -0.06609461456537247, 0.0015686698025092483, -0.04106007143855095, -0.027965068817138672, 0.005414753220975399, -0.052455395460128784, -0.00785316713154316, -0.02157030813395977, -0.05341688543558121, 0.06337334960699081, -0.0193882305175066, 0.03944186866283417, 0.036338843405246735, 0.043971993029117584, -0.007250692695379257, 0.05867588520050049, -0.02770010381937027, 0.02554030530154705, 0.018963631242513657, 0.017036689445376396, 0.04746922478079796, -0.005582205019891262, -0.008935458026826382, 0.0451284758746624, 0.04338771104812622, 0.03061079978942871, -0.04318908601999283, 0.07890457659959793, -0.015860391780734062, 0.014551844447851181, 0.03982432186603546, 0.0037774196825921535, 0.007870365865528584, 0.07663756608963013, -0.0010749527718871832, -0.034565843641757965, 0.058768704533576965, -0.018534529954195023, 0.0816115066409111, -0.00801281351596117, -0.019575245678424835, -0.002112406073138118, -0.042277611792087555, 0.01572367548942566, 0.07576117664575577, -0.021157467737793922, -0.015209444798529148, -0.05386894568800926, 0.006748809013515711, -0.006009165197610855, 0.00342988851480186, 0.015625817701220512, 0.0195840485394001, 0.021947136148810387, -0.0046372190117836, 0.018897702917456627, -0.008731038309633732, -0.05437050014734268, -0.007721638772636652, 0.03305094316601753, 0.040294013917446136, 0.040084268897771835, -0.000904661719687283, 0.05202336609363556, 0.0014606444165110588, -0.04506324976682663, 0.027529781684279442, 0.006211114581674337, -0.016453919932246208, -0.048218175768852234, 0.02854583039879799, -0.008158651180565357, -0.004308521747589111, 0.016688086092472076, -0.017181923612952232, 0.045437995344400406, -0.0030950428918004036, -0.08441770821809769, -0.0684368684887886, 0.015292913652956486, -0.04802289232611656, 0.013288738206028938, -0.04612978175282478, 0.014973555691540241, 0.018598107621073723, 0.029256200417876244, -0.013023650273680687, 0.019020406529307365, -0.01955200545489788, 0.03092365153133869, 0.019993359223008156, -0.022226842120289803, -0.008962665684521198, 0.014488196931779385, -0.03152511641383171, 0.0004946037661284208, -0.11258848756551743, 0.04887363314628601, 0.016474485397338867, 0.011139324866235256, -0.05327994376420975, 0.022068778052926064, -0.020571863278746605, -0.013310353271663189, -0.03232838585972786, 0.005301249213516712, -0.01900205761194229, 0.06522884964942932, 0.009892485104501247, 0.0185882356017828, 0.06697120517492294, -0.019328821450471878, 0.029111070558428764, -0.0036394030321389437, -0.0002410599117865786, 0.05108766257762909, -0.04681699350476265, -0.0024630983825773, 0.011294540017843246, 0.023710213601589203, 0.028698742389678955, -0.019022440537810326, 0.014519513584673405, 0.0020354799926280975, 0.004748925566673279, 0.017288818955421448, 0.017181089147925377, 0.00436736736446619, -0.014034907333552837, 0.029390498995780945, -0.01878087967634201, -0.033841267228126526, -0.08407124876976013, -0.0009526374633423984, 0.009463842026889324, -0.009827548637986183, 0.014780942350625992, -0.006997594144195318, 0.019467821344733238, -0.01585366576910019, 0.023661235347390175, -0.015416440553963184, -0.010468566790223122, 0.013901060447096825, -0.07564904540777206, -0.018135543912649155, 0.07038455456495285, 0.06880449503660202, -0.016593538224697113, 0.05111560598015785, -0.062406741082668304, -0.018114035949110985, -0.006520611699670553, 0.0023457538336515427, 0.010052612982690334, 0.002178564900532365, -0.017495250329375267, 0.009142385795712471, 0.0074843852780759335, -0.01845351979136467, 0.06201039254665375, -0.07058720290660858, 0.038014765828847885, 0.09231151640415192, 0.019073238596320152, -0.00480294693261385, -0.021187802776694298, 0.02539408951997757, 0.013466160744428635, 0.01988852769136429, -0.03817824646830559, -0.04256092756986618, -0.006406491622328758, -0.000619030324742198, -0.0042538768611848354, -0.03520725294947624, 0.028628652915358543, 0.06936072558164597, -0.030045634135603905, 0.008276975713670254, 0.03193728253245354, -0.0027649221010506153, 0.012766921892762184, -0.013806960545480251, 0.04077935963869095, -0.030182158574461937, -0.005607910454273224, 0.008566254749894142, 0.022901419550180435, 0.026015453040599823, 0.0010908193653449416, -0.0016752314986661077, 0.02945779822766781, 0.00924886018037796, 0.03580503165721893, -0.00856604240834713, -0.009154457598924637, 0.06184770539402962, -0.008687027730047703, -0.047905437648296356, 0.029670000076293945, 0.007179324049502611, 0.019666381180286407, -0.019593847915530205, -0.041907984763383865, -0.018870042636990547, 0.04381784051656723, -0.06644655019044876, -0.030265338718891144, 0.023937715217471123, -0.021194318309426308, -0.0026477640494704247, 0.0021980770397931337, -0.015168136917054653, -0.01976013369858265, 0.004122570157051086, 0.039368145167827606, 0.001575057627633214, 0.06165972724556923, -0.007305821403861046, -0.025422751903533936, -0.01459495723247528, 0.00021822474082000554, -0.016027966514229774, -0.027293195948004723, -0.05839414522051811, 0.0020556552335619926, 0.012894636951386929, -0.0156556349247694, 0.006291110534220934, 0.000672905589453876, -0.0023604303132742643, 0.036437902599573135, 0.024273160845041275, 0.009841830469667912, -0.003091786988079548, -0.013601009733974934, 0.04213465005159378, -0.03747343271970749, -0.0313958078622818, 0.05604448541998863, 0.05712352693080902, 0.00014716006990056485, 0.024169154465198517, -0.06315742433071136, -0.03594000265002251, -0.0323752723634243, -0.009163113310933113, 0.004482726566493511, -0.006485100835561752, -0.008076325058937073, -0.021846024319529533, -0.010802216827869415, 0.04820171743631363, -0.09368450939655304, -0.09038681536912918, -0.04062032327055931, -0.02287743054330349, 0.01767612062394619, -0.014173810370266438, 0.01443847268819809, 0.059818897396326065, 0.04116811975836754, -0.02851470187306404, 0.0008195361006073654, -0.007884704507887363, -0.015913700684905052, -0.028874916955828667, 0.037817396223545074, 0.01688511110842228, -0.03939053416252136, -0.011399024166166782, 0.03144429996609688, 0.03651264309883118, 0.04649730026721954, -0.03213588148355484, -0.012308966368436813, 0.025251513347029686, 0.042653314769268036, -0.019186845049262047, 0.013736150227487087, -0.008858802728354931, -0.04411963000893593, 0.013570995070040226, -0.026386255398392677, 0.03130430728197098, 0.007954076863825321, -0.038620322942733765, 0.005880019627511501, -0.05160722881555557, 0.009117592126131058, -0.005901876371353865, 0.018873216584324837, 0.008684602566063404, -0.029961688444018364, 0.020975587889552116, -0.029547197744250298, 0.052028145641088486, -0.04667181149125099, -0.007097071968019009, 0.03193847835063934, 0.06300891935825348, -0.0002718029136303812, -0.02284766174852848, 0.023588795214891434, -0.002937730634585023, 0.023927772417664528, 0.0038460525684058666, -0.00005726767631131224, 0.03249119222164154, 0.0700492113828659, 0.03682808578014374, 0.0017830173019319773, 0.0002988410124089569, 0.0014204132603481412, -0.08371561765670776, 0.0038988757878541946, -0.006443484220653772, 0.017701392993330956, -0.024379882961511612, 0.02619055099785328, 0.03277482092380524, -0.03591929003596306, 0.0324561633169651, 0.024095451459288597, -0.07325230538845062, 0.06090676411986351, -0.0033528103958815336, -0.015026751905679703, 0.01069330982863903, -0.015035382471978664, 0.011955375783145428, 0.013655133545398712, 0.020435446873307228, 0.014557743445038795, 0.030517255887389183, -0.04307989403605461, -0.03808002546429634, 0.004248158540576696, -0.00495240930467844, 0.03618708625435829, -0.04290926083922386, -0.019300170242786407, 0.014074725098907948, 0.0028047997038811445, 0.06904494017362595, -0.01013861782848835, -0.005966944620013237, -0.02481437288224697, -0.024524807929992676, 0.004282467532902956, 0.06484588980674744, 0.03515166416764259, 0.04301416501402855, -0.03159071505069733, 0.0123373381793499, 0.04032399505376816, 0.03913424536585808, 0.032505933195352554, 0.021409833803772926, -0.03760151192545891, -0.06064328923821449, -0.021768618375062943, -0.006243753246963024, -0.010369081981480122, -0.0032153225038200617, 0.004585261456668377, 0.06944899260997772, -0.005691241472959518, -0.016726963222026825, 0.011797547340393066, 0.07682014256715775, -0.014064569026231766, -0.0011391916777938604, -0.015667935833334923, -0.020389122888445854, -0.017125990241765976, -0.022459710016846657, 0.01860891655087471, 0.01781964860856533, 0.006930709350854158, 0.030269604176282883, 0.05899719521403313, 0.022309940308332443, -0.06328153610229492, 0.04626396670937538, 0.022359328344464302, 0.0033586095087230206, 0.01012562308460474, -0.02975264936685562, 0.03822268545627594, 0.01287370640784502, 0.04684043303132057, 0.012550449930131435, 0.011297166347503662, -0.05118319019675255, 0.028915833681821823, 0.04565700888633728, 0.04552226513624191, -0.028805840760469437, -0.018781788647174835, -0.04903325065970421, 0.0025470275431871414, 0.026068462058901787, -0.055587153881788254, 0.0031411577947437763, -0.0018311585299670696, 0.04336158558726311, -0.012061629444360733, -0.007928607985377312, -0.0184397641569376, -0.017795821651816368, -0.01677575521171093, -0.02002357877790928, 0.0032856392208486795, -0.001617889036424458, -0.05370154231786728, 0.003132631303742528, 0.0438554510474205, 0.09484542161226273, -0.011210914701223373, -0.014062859117984772, -0.0018121699104085565, -0.018604570999741554, -0.009134075604379177, -0.025662099942564964, 0.032801393419504166, -0.004449081141501665, -0.0345240943133831, 0.029343249276280403, -0.019444501027464867, -0.01359215285629034, 0.03409932553768158, -0.000514838146045804, -0.04492078721523285, -0.023957666009664536, -0.04377762973308563, 0.002078623976558447, 0.0374002680182457, 0.010298501700162888, 0.00458933413028717, 0.0331626757979393, 0.001783515908755362, 0.02781812660396099, -0.03754802793264389, -0.02074538730084896, 0.014552074484527111, 0.002338009886443615, -0.024019399657845497, 0.0053411610424518585, 0.017965935170650482, 0.032371606677770615, -0.0038858226034790277, 0.009593576192855835, -0.07369843125343323, -0.014891366474330425, 0.003758248407393694, 0.043323855847120285, -0.0004315411497373134, 0.025083018466830254, 0.00667200330644846, 0.007951711304485798, -0.003170099575072527, 0.0064208172261714935, 0.012375274673104286, -0.02357274293899536, 0.02727673202753067, -0.014798371121287346, -0.02497519738972187, 0.0176036786288023, -0.027466123923659325, -0.07771589607000351, 0.013879840262234211, -0.04536501318216324, 0.01880226470530033, 0.003567366860806942, 0.02984328754246235, 0.008443458937108517, -0.04822857677936554, -0.04912646859884262, 0.03185448795557022, 0.020967017859220505, 0.06547989696264267, -0.024818098172545433, 0.027217978611588478, -0.004672652576118708, 0.011500942520797253, -0.06674211472272873, -0.021527431905269623, 0.014261285774409771, 0.0330621562898159, -0.017100749537348747, -0.0042102341540157795, 0.008836704306304455, -0.01147371344268322, -0.027925437316298485, -0.048960767686367035, 0.037710487842559814, 0.0075200460851192474, -0.020721688866615295, -0.017576780170202255, 0.004318797495216131, 0.07090694457292557, 0.03179758042097092, 0.007356748450547457, -0.01797690987586975, -0.023114828392863274, -0.025562193244695663, -0.002592564793303609, -0.01470907125622034, -0.036713771522045135, -0.017194150015711784, -0.014295952394604683, -0.00817063543945551, 0.033694129437208176, -0.04525524005293846, -0.023787686601281166, 0.011653047055006027, 0.047343701124191284, -0.009216970764100552, -0.047212716192007065, 0.004338124766945839, -0.008945493958890438, 0.0072825998067855835, -0.0027443033177405596, 0.0246538445353508, 0.014454496093094349, 0.011118026450276375, 0.002658881014212966, -0.021322252228856087, -0.03149358555674553, 0.027069594711065292, 0.036715131253004074, -0.01761729270219803, 0.021175745874643326, -0.007950366474688053, -0.01232160348445177, 0.02801596000790596, 0.03968481346964836, -0.030565666034817696, 0.03212657943367958, 0.008061767555773258, -0.00652896286919713, -0.016536934301257133, -0.03070397488772869, 0.024034667760133743, 0.02855277806520462, -0.016125258058309555, 0.017031587660312653, 0.001948834047652781, 0.02061057649552822, -0.01859515905380249, -0.009818661026656628, -0.013161315582692623, 0.01889021322131157, 0.029156526550650597, 0.03749467432498932, -0.014302810654044151, 0.0062851677648723125, 0.05165766179561615, -0.017340967431664467, 0.03318851813673973, 0.03422027826309204, -0.0006977940211072564, 0.00841328501701355, 0.015185194090008736, -0.02798209711909294, -0.022821124643087387, 0.017370572313666344, -0.024238362908363342, 0.030459381639957428, -0.03922070190310478, -0.01344924047589302, 0.02513723075389862, -0.0033975974656641483, -0.019342010840773582, -0.008409879170358181, -0.03311079740524292, -0.016363520175218582, -0.010451520793139935, 0.013808722607791424, -0.000044629396143136546, 0.019838789477944374, -0.0045129987411201, -0.012761837802827358, 0.01640484854578972, 0.06469788402318954, 0.019007917493581772, -0.04391944780945778, -0.04798990488052368, -0.012889545410871506, -0.041671473532915115, 0.019876832142472267, 0.001015259767882526, 0.0100279925391078, -0.007844364270567894, -0.01921703666448593, 0.014476021751761436, 0.02771308645606041, 0.003955570049583912, 0.018448010087013245, 0.05994027853012085, 0.01944613829255104, 0.037598636001348495, 0.018423693254590034, -0.012670510448515415, 0.10277669876813889, 0.04949558526277542, -0.009193295612931252, -0.061990078538656235, 0.023543160408735275, -0.011077633127570152, 0.016779322177171707, -0.010491187684237957, 0.007772751152515411, 0.024644022807478905, -0.0036126193590462208, 0.0550113171339035, 0.026583820581436157, -0.017244519665837288, 0.04415874183177948, 0.011703414842486382, -0.04714393615722656, -0.041846297681331635, -0.012568479403853416, 0.017957918345928192, -0.0024310555309057236, -0.009783804416656494, -0.012704646214842796, 0.03209931030869484, -0.008008393459022045, -0.012247934006154537, -0.037373028695583344, 0.011224435642361641, 0.02665417641401291, 0.013739421032369137, -0.000028607999411178753, 0.014843533746898174, 0.04639795795083046, -0.0037978310137987137, -0.01856769435107708, -0.010684131644666195, 0.009478254243731499, -0.03262295946478844, 0.026789290830492973, 0.018480516970157623, -0.0042495401576161385, -0.015840156003832817, 0.014248023740947247, 0.02355879917740822, -0.05038177967071533, -0.004813142120838165, -0.03727050870656967, 0.022771775722503662, -0.025960475206375122, -0.00590774230659008, -0.005284032318741083, -0.0004889211268164217, -0.010278183966875076, -0.03957159072160721, -0.017568081617355347, 0.03300337493419647, 0.00508110411465168, -0.031215239316225052, -0.03865284100174904, -0.010963060893118382, 0.011385408230125904, -0.01553092896938324, 0.045508772134780884, 0.015563479624688625, 0.0029135113582015038, -0.03374958783388138, -0.05084119364619255, 0.025501132011413574, -0.057656023651361465, -0.00497912522405386, 0.005167727824300528, 0.01122942753136158, -0.05648760870099068, 0.017632724717259407, -0.007364765740931034, -0.011661114171147346, 0.03753392770886421, 0.01329482439905405, 0.022647986188530922, -0.004547421354800463, -0.011018105782568455, 0.011450272984802723, 0.0008639258448965847, 0.02468271367251873, -0.05544695630669594, 0.00030441462877206504, 0.0062867868691682816, 0.0389845110476017, -0.00999488402158022, 0.03333870694041252, 0.028568530455231667, 0.05516650900244713, -0.009229859337210655, -0.024737877771258354, 0.003435408929362893, -0.03250756114721298, -0.08415152877569199, -0.03575621172785759, -0.02877834439277649, 0.0754740834236145, -0.0011851248564198613, 0.027233177796006203, 0.03555039316415787, -0.003111066296696663, -0.019122611731290817, 0.016327600926160812, 0.006225804332643747, -0.0721621960401535, -0.013498435728251934, 0.03747062012553215, -0.002796334680169821, -0.031914375722408295, -0.019025132060050964, 0.018453508615493774, -0.01136127207428217, 0.01359707023948431, 0.00212170765735209, -0.030438853427767754, -0.007685914169996977, -0.009444770403206348, 0.012257103808224201, -0.021780721843242645, -0.010279125533998013, -0.01140577532351017, -0.03945794329047203, 0.00046761910198256373, 0.02497134730219841, -0.015557016246020794, 0.04107083007693291, -0.01346690021455288, 0.027375198900699615, 0.040719594806432724, 0.060815371572971344, 0.021103108301758766, -0.0372212789952755, -0.003351944964379072, 0.023086246103048325, 0.0072270710952579975, -0.023277174681425095, -0.012292243540287018, 0.041978299617767334, -0.05692888796329498, -0.023142674937844276, 0.005756664089858532, 0.00042731015128083527, 0.04337403550744057, 0.021981902420520782, 0.005111947190016508, -0.02269160747528076, 0.07012084871530533, -0.053667448461055756, -0.023084476590156555, -0.006999922450631857, 0.01819290593266487, 0.040246184915304184, 0.008812714368104935, -0.03176366537809372, 0.03657596930861473, -0.013490437529981136, -0.014274257235229015, 0.05839835852384567, 0.013499738648533821, 0.009653069078922272, -0.0053376019932329655, 0.02083168551325798, -0.003591194748878479, 0.003230082569643855, -0.026920219883322716, 0.011287459172308445, 0.029603617265820503, 0.004225417505949736, 0.015674704685807228, -0.023776812478899956, -0.030108194798231125, -0.0758274719119072, -0.020450441166758537, 0.034053679555654526, -0.017460273578763008, 0.04001028835773468, -0.036987751722335815, -0.0029683648608624935, 0.0490635447204113, -0.026021910831332207, 0.00898425467312336, -0.00177662109490484, -0.009185869246721268, -0.03350205719470978, 0.06084439530968666, 0.000683237100020051, 0.054766424000263214, 0.015094214119017124, 0.025566253811120987, 0.041427887976169586, -0.02949066273868084, 0.004580583423376083, -0.03835079073905945, 0.018205152824521065, 0.017054656520485878, -0.008755754679441452, -0.04529022425413132, 0.017937470227479935, -0.0349726639688015, -0.017950888723134995, 0.010229065082967281, 0.001950261415913701, 0.034590959548950195, 0.00981798768043518, -0.029495012015104294, 0.015856822952628136, 0.027137910947203636, 0.030515162274241447, 0.009407475590705872, -0.002214904874563217, -0.0009205011301673949, 0.018952349200844765, -0.0026558879762887955, -0.017359640449285507, 0.004097340628504753, 0.04731721431016922, 0.010679746977984905, -0.0802142471075058, -0.011643623001873493, 0.013250778429210186, 0.0003094240964855999, 0.0068627167493104935, 0.026278505101799965, -0.02985273487865925, -0.02296377345919609, -0.017474835738539696, -0.045828063040971756, -0.002709660679101944, 0.04292469471693039, -0.009942393749952316, -0.03659522905945778, 0.016024868935346603, -0.005393892526626587, -0.022056689485907555, -0.004669192247092724, -0.02639627270400524, -0.020127449184656143, -0.022189946845173836, 0.018106991425156593, -0.013330081477761269, 0.01805877685546875, -0.02388112246990204, -0.0240144282579422, -0.05503177270293236, 0.024468189105391502, -0.03427781164646149, 0.013990703970193863, 0.008607795462012291, 0.00967251043766737, 0.013593314215540886, -0.08412335067987442, 0.06975970417261124, -0.013392379507422447, -0.01872536912560463, -0.03914022445678711, 0.0025564339011907578, -0.041805289685726166, 0.0226255115121603, 0.05537095665931702, 0.003268952015787363, 0.000873458746355027, -0.009013422764837742, 0.030463064089417458, 0.02412857860326767, -0.0729377493262291, 0.04797092825174332, -0.037188127636909485, -0.05920877680182457, -0.01954296976327896, 0.012963672168552876, 0.03725540637969971, -0.01179435197263956, -0.021172255277633667, 0.03824719414114952, 0.004308753181248903, 0.02860492654144764, -0.005997521337121725, 0.01819625124335289, -0.011456689797341824, 0.005648179445415735, 0.04020434245467186, -0.04135071858763695, 0.03466738387942314, 0.014939320273697376, -0.014728406444191933, -0.055850621312856674, 0.057967666536569595, -0.02843623049557209, -0.03479566052556038, -0.024440599605441093, -0.00829703826457262, -0.01683720387518406, -0.03590565547347069, -0.0006325470167212188, 0.049829840660095215, 0.0003619871858973056, 0.0037605350371450186, 0.011389893479645252, 0.021494079381227493, 0.05549280717968941, -0.009570624679327011, -0.0001350120728602633, 0.008307264186441898, 0.001802308252081275, -0.02455166168510914, -0.016623038798570633, 0.03233962878584862, -0.025256188586354256, 0.035679351538419724, -0.014805651269853115, -0.028288301080465317, 0.005471287295222282, 0.005143832415342331, 0.021753953769803047, -0.03335210680961609, -0.0031288927420973778, 0.03500819206237793, -0.0021737515926361084, -0.0017845325637608767, 0.035998035222291946, -0.0012351832119747996, 0.04551250860095024, 0.0035713145043700933, 0.04696433246135712, -0.034717705100774765, 0.008228305727243423, -0.062319230288267136, -0.037017568945884705, -0.006624487694352865, 0.011036107316613197, 0.00727308914065361, 0.02494257129728794, 0.02465279959142208, 0.029719775542616844, 0.05699918791651726, 0.014980100095272064, 0.007287159096449614, -0.042554821819067, -0.04818076267838478, -0.07617837935686111, 0.01632549613714218, -0.02549014426767826, -0.01719999499619007, 0.01065152045339346, 0.04121950641274452, -0.0008651692769490182, 0.024292178452014923, -0.013829795643687248, 0.06081956624984741, 0.05375950410962105, -0.0183927733451128, -0.0037291492335498333, -0.060622453689575195, -0.0389094240963459, -0.05028366670012474, -0.024529816582798958 ]
<p>I am trying to grasp what exactly is "estimated" in the E-step of the algorithm. </p> <p>According to all definitions, in E-step the "conditional expectation values , or posterior probabilities of the hidden variables" are computed, using the Bayes formula ( posterior probability=prior( or marginal prob.) x likelihood/probability of evidence). Now, my question is, are these posterior probabilities, that I "estimate" or "compute", actually numbers or are they functions with respect to the current iteration's parameters ( and they are the ones I need to plug into M-step)? Where the probability of evidence would be likelihood, calculated with the previous argmax , calculated in previous M-step. </p>
36,664
[ 0.00036952775553800166, -0.03263920173048973, 0.00888073444366455, -0.042219508439302444, 0.03849552571773529, 0.013338156044483185, 0.00960689689964056, -0.02647566795349121, -0.005426038056612015, -0.0068514239974319935, 0.030182190239429474, 0.03221724554896355, 0.04664738476276398, 0.012028563767671585, 0.01598348654806614, 0.02552780508995056, -0.0011004583211615682, -0.000029474347684299573, 0.006084362044930458, -0.02322443202137947, 0.008794627152383327, 0.03284062445163727, -0.001643129624426365, -0.026164954528212547, -0.03495865315198898, 0.0384056493639946, 0.04067157581448555, -0.011027809232473373, 0.029462695121765137, 0.06410879641771317, -0.028699593618512154, -0.039925865828990936, 0.03361271694302559, 0.033365633338689804, -0.0009890656219795346, -0.003434389131143689, -0.050493910908699036, -0.01700226403772831, -0.04698590934276581, 0.03450819104909897, -0.00902029499411583, -0.01624218560755253, -0.04958241432905197, 0.04504423961043358, -0.012479602359235287, 0.004265885334461927, -0.020016953349113464, 0.009262144565582275, 0.026041695848107338, -0.03404657170176506, 0.08845190703868866, 0.007652022410184145, 0.01725415326654911, 0.004259523935616016, -0.03381369262933731, -0.034852202981710434, 0.0630800724029541, 0.05001378804445267, 0.0041976310312747955, -0.0433407798409462, -0.049488432705402374, -0.03875129669904709, 0.02732013911008835, -0.03475256636738777, -0.02617233246564865, 0.01941329799592495, 0.016618359833955765, -0.015414832159876823, 0.0403522253036499, 0.005495263729244471, 0.02063278667628765, 0.0019564535468816757, 0.03681754693388939, -0.017586059868335724, 0.02757261134684086, -0.015621399506926537, 0.022128859534859657, 0.020422697067260742, 0.006793015170842409, 0.020704416558146477, 0.013775898143649101, -0.025436190888285637, 0.007848565466701984, 0.04806361719965935, -0.01759149692952633, -0.004371206276118755, 0.05145854875445366, -0.009537825360894203, 0.02294725552201271, -0.013617020100355148, -0.03872833773493767, 0.03525324538350105, 0.02138044312596321, -0.008996306918561459, -0.027774758636951447, 0.045861467719078064, -0.003474478842690587, 0.043534111231565475, -0.007922985590994358, 0.009712040424346924, 0.01852051541209221, -0.015476902015507221, 0.015008612535893917, 0.012614748440682888, -0.057392995804548264, -0.002165472600609064, -0.03251183405518532, 0.03170574828982353, -0.015385118313133717, -0.027373064309358597, -0.02118672803044319, 0.04711693525314331, -0.012708279304206371, 0.025356372818350792, 0.018480680882930756, -0.033265553414821625, -0.013219318352639675, -0.011970493011176586, 0.0566413588821888, 0.05130678415298462, 0.038322869688272476, -0.043883852660655975, 0.040180306881666183, -0.024085206910967827, -0.07965601235628128, 0.0010946117108687758, 0.01281020324677229, -0.017269518226385117, -0.023420413956046104, 0.052761346101760864, 0.0013998504728078842, -0.05526246502995491, 0.07163790613412857, 0.03750525414943695, -0.002221847651526332, 0.0012656968319788575, -0.0735217034816742, -0.061043888330459595, 0.02843952737748623, -0.04836418479681015, 0.02011263370513916, -0.06060909852385521, -0.007327475119382143, 0.059334106743335724, 0.041887037456035614, -0.002304003806784749, 0.046536702662706375, 0.0077155460603535175, 0.024600772187113762, 0.00953162182122469, -0.05655704811215401, -0.014826121740043163, -0.07465912401676178, 0.007354146800935268, -0.05625449866056442, -0.05754243582487106, 0.05831558629870415, 0.045965708792209625, -0.005892581772059202, -0.023380832746624947, 0.03441273421049118, 0.011787843890488148, -0.03299166262149811, 0.0011196165578439832, 0.00592500064522028, -0.041571926325559616, 0.07184203714132309, 0.031019696965813637, 0.014328064396977425, 0.050097886472940445, -0.025210415944457054, -0.0014857669593766332, -0.010023180395364761, 0.017969710752367973, 0.068785659968853, -0.02704673446714878, -0.05470188707113266, -0.035560496151447296, 0.010661750100553036, 0.007975460961461067, 0.031101683154702187, -0.039395201951265335, -0.011695959605276585, -0.027663741260766983, 0.021325813606381416, 0.0066894907504320145, 0.007313586305826902, -0.004866553470492363, 0.022118084132671356, -0.051301270723342896, -0.04285692051053047, -0.060314301401376724, 0.005963793955743313, -0.024407772347331047, 0.007383815478533506, 0.01764349825680256, -0.01887284778058529, 0.03568127751350403, -0.00649438239634037, -0.03699028864502907, -0.04179127886891365, 0.0002802315866574645, 0.018489517271518707, -0.014045999385416508, -0.010170551016926765, 0.06677374988794327, 0.018998615443706512, 0.007953817956149578, 0.05696785822510719, -0.03785504400730133, -0.04995250329375267, -0.007578193210065365, -0.043310340493917465, -0.0032842718064785004, 0.012415948323905468, -0.027817970141768456, -0.021659469231963158, -0.024727365002036095, 0.0161037165671587, -0.019759168848395348, -0.06895723938941956, 0.0595071017742157, 0.07162650674581528, 0.022034229710698128, -0.0027257660403847694, 0.03804405406117439, 0.018811872228980064, 0.01758795604109764, 0.013172666542232037, 0.0183696486055851, -0.02678621932864189, -0.05467258766293526, 0.02584175579249859, 0.012905826792120934, -0.030637849122285843, 0.0003063465701416135, 0.03084961324930191, 0.011990108527243137, 0.006822103168815374, 0.058232635259628296, 0.0007268192712217569, 0.003539596451446414, 0.035608015954494476, 0.011411436833441257, -0.011267414316534996, -0.01664930209517479, 0.014834225177764893, 0.02833874151110649, 0.03221463784575462, -0.0014430333394557238, -0.022163640707731247, 0.013963866978883743, -0.030170556157827377, 0.017691589891910553, -0.07927025854587555, -0.008531229570508003, 0.037578172981739044, -0.032283056527376175, 0.020842688158154488, 0.011035162955522537, -0.029985321685671806, -0.024570727720856667, 0.00799145083874464, -0.04331502318382263, 0.022917956113815308, 0.029834292829036713, -0.03172219544649124, -0.004929960705339909, 0.017116369679570198, -0.025486838072538376, 0.027603046968579292, -0.010175323113799095, -0.0170533899217844, -0.03563306853175163, 0.07167258113622665, 0.005497484467923641, -0.023647496476769447, 0.012459861114621162, -0.06003040075302124, -0.052806127816438675, 0.005160062108188868, -0.007650534622371197, 0.042658496648073196, 0.03304661065340042, -0.07013880461454391, 0.01737165078520775, -0.023800134658813477, -0.033946581184864044, 0.04274611920118332, -0.007543702609837055, -0.05346515029668808, 0.03342611715197563, -0.0074106240645051, -0.01953841932117939, -0.0020462237298488617, -0.0426148846745491, -0.01637396588921547, -0.01166309043765068, -0.01964908093214035, 0.006173549685627222, 0.006899712141603231, 0.0251317135989666, 0.023624634370207787, -0.058178432285785675, -0.0001298196439165622, -0.04019634798169136, -0.020067140460014343, -0.015489081852138042, -0.018110666424036026, 0.04070403426885605, 0.02273324318230152, -0.004885287955403328, 0.035667601972818375, -0.04266747832298279, -0.06010837107896805, 0.02608628198504448, 0.03445925563573837, -0.009620310738682747, -0.0064377509988844395, -0.001271554734557867, 0.08954930305480957, 0.020470185205340385, -0.08357945084571838, 0.005988178309053183, 0.009296290576457977, -0.01307020615786314, 0.013613843359053135, 0.0014164017047733068, 0.017751473933458328, -0.0017691035754978657, 0.03590790182352066, -0.03550853207707405, 0.014814137481153011, 0.05093984678387642, -0.0065564243122935295, 0.03359102085232735, 0.05902334675192833, -0.007124891970306635, -0.005873341113328934, 0.07035234570503235, 0.014161484315991402, -0.019052110612392426, 0.01254407037049532, -0.01630415767431259, 0.007113215979188681, 0.015431585721671581, -0.018973009660840034, 0.0493629015982151, -0.013898082077503204, 0.0016231960617005825, -0.05259900167584419, 0.06192388758063316, 0.01041484996676445, -0.016665520146489143, 0.005196761339902878, -0.003104602452367544, 0.025141479447484016, -0.031603552401065826, 0.010361296124756336, 0.02247016504406929, 0.03257909044623375, -0.011783099733293056, -0.004023998975753784, -0.022434785962104797, -0.017870169132947922, 0.023013345897197723, -0.00894332118332386, -0.046324875205755234, 0.06505420058965683, 0.042469821870326996, 0.026767661795020103, 0.014035062864422798, -0.035473622381687164, -0.007841695100069046, -0.044394101947546005, -0.0229866374284029, -0.008771181106567383, 0.025141116231679916, 0.010599938221275806, 0.046695150434970856, -0.00883119460195303, 0.01856795884668827, 0.01517278328537941, 0.01142911147326231, -0.07707124203443527, -0.013133392669260502, -0.01616372913122177, -0.022380689159035683, -0.025532806292176247, -0.02728171832859516, 0.027351737022399902, -0.04635895416140556, -0.017418017610907555, 0.017234357073903084, 0.0081161605194211, -0.03452929109334946, 0.01851094700396061, -0.044567517936229706, 0.01824023760855198, -0.013849652372300625, -0.008010772056877613, 0.047275371849536896, 0.002357840072363615, 0.022174354642629623, 0.029618065804243088, -0.02612147107720375, 0.002872610464692116, 0.013014543801546097, 0.0071523371152579784, 0.01416700053960085, 0.03144167363643646, 0.056121375411748886, 0.05413233861327171, -0.05035211518406868, 0.03690304234623909, 0.04021041840314865, 0.06836305558681488, 0.03668787330389023, -0.025443192571401596, 0.0005775551544502378, -0.019873162731528282, -0.04759034886956215, 0.014592827297747135, 0.04162408784031868, -0.009809155948460102, 0.03083525225520134, 0.051042068749666214, 0.01721421629190445, -0.03955887258052826, 0.009003246203064919, 0.06856808066368103, 0.003415281418710947, 0.005731229204684496, -0.055084824562072754, 0.027891546487808228, -0.024329423904418945, 0.003922613337635994, 0.024267150089144707, -0.006358566228300333, 0.003073770320042968, 0.021899614483118057, 0.017315028235316277, -0.017857516184449196, -0.0005229247035458684, 0.003750878619030118, 0.016810152679681778, 0.012721974402666092, 0.008359504863619804, 0.011517846956849098, 0.04443390294909477, 0.03616851568222046, 0.010518970899283886, -0.0017187190242111683, -0.006535982713103294, -0.09150288999080658, -0.007867740467190742, 0.05313348025083542, 0.04765349626541138, -0.06050105765461922, 0.00020697280706372112, -0.06607553362846375, -0.03443315252661705, 0.04128570854663849, 0.010334189049899578, -0.01637536659836769, 0.0045575667172670364, 0.019005224108695984, -0.02441517822444439, -0.022738775238394737, -0.022149598225951195, -0.001764683285728097, -0.025120992213487625, 0.01501071359962225, -0.04450443387031555, -0.013960498385131359, -0.04737193137407303, -0.004924738314002752, 0.04496293142437935, 0.06533452123403549, -0.023560218513011932, 0.004884528461843729, -0.014181860722601414, -0.0003308420709799975, -0.0033091155346482992, -0.04336410388350487, 0.006348541006445885, -0.022617129608988762, -0.021263225004076958, 0.03616520017385483, -0.037375643849372864, -0.012064085341989994, 0.039220377802848816, 0.020867737010121346, -0.009335831739008427, -0.023671844974160194, -0.014095108024775982, 0.046379733830690384, 0.028938494622707367, -0.011260894127190113, 0.05510628968477249, 0.004998276941478252, 0.008735322393476963, 0.010792553424835205, -0.018801849335432053, 0.015625230967998505, -0.03059682995080948, 0.0340089425444603, -0.02674388885498047, 0.006462718825787306, -0.010928359813988209, 0.046771515160799026, 0.03696460276842117, 0.013019884005188942, -0.0410747267305851, -0.010182765312492847, -0.0259364303201437, 0.04239833727478981, -0.0036015482619404793, -0.0028736961539834738, 0.023801011964678764, 0.015060384757816792, -0.004997020587325096, -0.010912899859249592, 0.013223079964518547, -0.04116276651620865, 0.008321784436702728, -0.01913820579648018, -0.019671376794576645, 0.017493484541773796, -0.007678918074816465, 0.001492189010605216, 0.06793609261512756, -0.021937765181064606, 0.017554298043251038, -0.03262196108698845, 0.013038715347647667, -0.009670981205999851, -0.04015752300620079, -0.030853429809212685, -0.025555456057190895, -0.004500093404203653, 0.03780541941523552, -0.035203151404857635, 0.03523346036672592, -0.02635873481631279, 0.014357607811689377, -0.023301105946302414, -0.022939564660191536, -0.002001051092520356, 0.02641959674656391, -0.06289134174585342, -0.035899773240089417, -0.016758227720856667, -0.019290396943688393, -0.009279410354793072, -0.012826027348637581, 0.043001554906368256, -0.019007433205842972, 0.008488865569233894, -0.0013927014078944921, 0.022523578256368637, 0.014755601063370705, 0.02150522544980049, 0.014604819007217884, 0.017174504697322845, -0.0014469155576080084, 0.008732705377042294, 0.03300361707806587, 0.0046936809085309505, -0.006102711893618107, -0.01393655315041542, -0.011012506671249866, 0.053078025579452515, 0.046964287757873535, -0.035196103155612946, -0.0025894769933074713, 0.0327705554664135, 0.01814396120607853, 0.02025592140853405, 0.007306926418095827, -0.031940557062625885, -0.025600487366318703, 0.02886619232594967, -0.0015597953461110592, -0.017472760751843452, 0.00437257019802928, 0.013175124302506447, 0.055714067071676254, -0.019537121057510376, 0.008181451819837093, -0.004515473730862141, 0.05642471835017204, -0.010665129870176315, 0.0033464618027210236, 0.006146843079477549, -0.01044006459414959, 0.02246035821735859, 0.009563983418047428, 0.03478304296731949, 0.010032466612756252, 0.00687206769362092, -0.054659634828567505, -0.01013796217739582, -0.06180502474308014, 0.003779937280341983, 0.04028318449854851, -0.01248912326991558, 0.040318116545677185, 0.011228428222239017, 0.015478143468499184, 0.01814463548362255, -0.03156045824289322, -0.03520695120096207, 0.008623752743005753, 0.03526961803436279, 0.01513857115060091, -0.02889736369252205, -0.02228929102420807, 0.024634949862957, -0.007069074083119631, 0.02352316863834858, 0.016394132748246193, 0.02501779794692993, 0.02895691618323326, 0.027491480112075806, -0.01632448099553585, -0.03700043261051178, 0.03700710088014603, -0.04501282051205635, 0.014484495855867863, -0.01317881140857935, 0.003968964796513319, 0.06763879209756851, 0.0353829562664032, 0.012605487369000912, -0.041834697127342224, -0.013552839867770672, -0.05016142874956131, 0.0024657035246491432, -0.010271956212818623, -0.010832349769771099, 0.02078578807413578, -0.018922394141554832, 0.0036398633383214474, -0.012625585310161114, 0.02691776491701603, -0.011936540715396404, -0.08398973196744919, -0.06027596816420555, -0.030867166817188263, -0.04435249790549278, 0.03125382587313652, 0.00497006718069315, -0.006624915637075901, -0.020024562254548073, -0.012850834056735039, 0.04672788083553314, -0.0007762694149278104, 0.0595240518450737, -0.05827134847640991, 0.07525281608104706, 0.010633517056703568, 0.04965144395828247, -0.03708116337656975, -0.025383304804563522, 0.1345812976360321, 0.06412764638662338, 0.0279433224350214, -0.05887933820486069, -0.007711844984441996, -0.02343444898724556, 0.005802723579108715, -0.0036603277549147606, 0.001643092604354024, 0.03131699562072754, -0.0018709207652136683, -0.005872682668268681, 0.02292674034833908, 0.02484825812280178, 0.004413303453475237, 0.03633991628885269, -0.05186842754483223, -0.05078394338488579, 0.03369150310754776, 0.039707764983177185, -0.0268899817019701, -0.01848570443689823, -0.018064534291625023, -0.02404865249991417, -0.004046259447932243, -0.0233396515250206, -0.0006339782266877592, -0.039281342178583145, -0.009549844078719616, 0.013643770478665829, -0.03023805283010006, 0.022269338369369507, -0.0008889281307347119, -0.002241321839392185, 0.013190069235861301, 0.03153879567980766, 0.03503567725419998, 0.00043040490709245205, 0.013383333571255207, 0.04377226158976555, 0.03905588015913963, 0.0040125008672475815, -0.020623773336410522, 0.0069390758872032166, -0.03696207329630852, -0.0355384461581707, -0.02971712499856949, 0.07370695471763611, -0.009385796263813972, -0.0033429530449211597, 0.0008494815556332469, -0.031248874962329865, -0.005614949390292168, -0.08168581128120422, 0.020987670868635178, -0.001436480670236051, -0.00808099377900362, 0.00962741393595934, -0.03836868330836296, -0.03296560049057007, 0.013747522607445717, -0.010568330995738506, 0.01272558607161045, 0.03258255496621132, -0.009922378696501255, -0.012552074156701565, -0.03903951495885849, 0.045533061027526855, -0.012059452943503857, -0.020601334050297737, -0.019425397738814354, -0.0314507782459259, -0.03923916816711426, -0.01202404499053955, -0.003071465063840151, -0.011512809433043003, 0.004151566885411739, -0.023815298452973366, -0.0028769292403012514, -0.005560100544244051, -0.04496801272034645, -0.012653086334466934, -0.03582639619708061, -0.013799106702208519, -0.04958731681108475, 0.009374259039759636, 0.03723079711198807, 0.05700928717851639, 0.021620215848088264, 0.017526855692267418, 0.010689778253436089, 0.013034139759838581, -0.015119549818336964, -0.05072035267949104, -0.024916166439652443, -0.0034440536983311176, -0.025792555883526802, -0.010978622362017632, -0.0011551406932994723, 0.05754808709025383, 0.017158498987555504, 0.025166749954223633, -0.043104927986860275, 0.021831855177879333, 0.010434876196086407, -0.006191292777657509, -0.04744682461023331, -0.03470684960484505, -0.008093715645372868, -0.030128005892038345, -0.010883251205086708, -0.05970320105552673, 0.0035652327351272106, -0.04189956188201904, 0.002729270374402404, 0.04642561078071594, -0.01742727868258953, -0.03813224285840988, 0.03250803425908089, 0.014289883896708488, -0.0029874914325773716, -0.014756601303815842, 0.00805436447262764, 0.04962775111198425, 0.009802189655601978, -0.019000815227627754, -0.003317467402666807, -0.009266347624361515, -0.0044883666560053825, 0.0013837115839123726, -0.040748126804828644, 0.0013172777835279703, 0.00976098794490099, 0.007337065413594246, -0.028804127126932144, 0.03219006955623627, -0.006446911487728357, 0.054890815168619156, -0.0047648269683122635, -0.02430536039173603, 0.023522190749645233, -0.04927055165171623, -0.03406643122434616, 0.04975361377000809, 0.03695143759250641, 0.03108634613454342, 0.061956390738487244, 0.004566586576402187, 0.002228503581136465, 0.01292566116899252, -0.03602605313062668, -0.022344784811139107, 0.0076047214679419994, -0.004332865588366985, -0.023789070546627045, -0.01530989445745945, 0.007028170395642519, 0.025636078789830208, 0.012320680543780327, 0.027681240811944008, 0.020142676308751106, -0.002635649172589183, -0.0024507876951247454, 0.022364722564816475, -0.009966140612959862, 0.011524555273354053, 0.05028776079416275, -0.01166964415460825, 0.015660861507058144, 0.060147639364004135, 0.012374804355204105, 0.053501203656196594, 0.034219060093164444, -0.017346002161502838, -0.07615617662668228, 0.007932476699352264, 0.012036539614200592, -0.011389377526938915, 0.05226096510887146, -0.06579465419054031, 0.004529743921011686, 0.047023944556713104, -0.039788972586393356, 0.015622878447175026, -0.014266487210988998, 0.020133662968873978, -0.031156571581959724, 0.03750620782375336, -0.012798530049622059, 0.03160162270069122, 0.04456454515457153, 0.02695670910179615, 0.04947115480899811, -0.03439318388700485, 0.0045670573599636555, -0.03959084302186966, -0.019420767202973366, 0.05209510400891304, 0.024277962744235992, -0.0405670665204525, 0.04427678510546684, -0.0546104721724987, -0.06102881208062172, 0.04679648578166962, 0.02918398194015026, 0.025735603645443916, 0.0028912536799907684, 0.045789796859025955, 0.02914005145430565, 0.023075291886925697, 0.03848946467041969, 0.009088133461773396, 0.024005712941288948, 0.019830800592899323, -0.007293547037988901, 0.012090742588043213, -0.020221348851919174, 0.02917836606502533, 0.005737014580518007, -0.030525708571076393, -0.028758779168128967, 0.04321373254060745, -0.0025531614664942026, 0.008061472326517105, -0.01565115712583065, -0.020125029608607292, -0.028791438788175583, -0.0416710190474987, 0.04064088687300682, -0.028127972036600113, 0.039026178419589996, 0.03362412005662918, 0.03397614508867264, -0.033498432487249374, -0.010182177647948265, 0.0030605716165155172, -0.056890737265348434, 0.032012056559324265, -0.005354517605155706, -0.016801565885543823, -0.06119044870138168, 0.03449992835521698, 0.019183628261089325, -0.006960633676499128, 0.0006167783867567778, -0.00981880072504282, -0.05479840934276581, -0.001533057540655136, 0.0040945252403616905, -0.024215368553996086, 0.019825376570224762, -0.01739751175045967, -0.02904757484793663, -0.08508941531181335, 0.0723656490445137, 0.009002285078167915, -0.04279651865363121, -0.05015410855412483, 0.007525559980422258, -0.006952651776373386, 0.014111879281699657, 0.01740046590566635, -0.016171470284461975, -0.005375456530600786, -0.004199693910777569, 0.014779005199670792, 0.045914940536022186, -0.03687233850359917, 0.011305492371320724, -0.02899409644305706, -0.019768351688981056, -0.03874113783240318, -0.002771104918792844, 0.016185598447918892, 0.03166728839278221, 0.0036745909601449966, -0.008031468838453293, 0.006480069365352392, -0.0376117080450058, -0.012943597510457039, 0.032989103347063065, -0.021804513409733772, 0.0014171954244375229, 0.010209151543676853, -0.007156349718570709, -0.00632986007258296, 0.0354587659239769, -0.012926231138408184, -0.05737407132983208, 0.030309388414025307, 0.014640482142567635, -0.029565544798970222, 0.06689926236867905, -0.005671642255038023, 0.04749814420938492, -0.048908885568380356, -0.030513886362314224, 0.04538554698228836, -0.04333564266562462, 0.006767559796571732, 0.0447375550866127, -0.0033736592158675194, 0.030607808381319046, 0.0018062440212816, 0.009986165910959244, 0.041194986552000046, -0.0024582436308264732, 0.012305429205298424, 0.036060430109500885, 0.034349072724580765, -0.04938292130827904, 0.036025602370500565, 0.00011166967306053266, -0.04846979305148125, 0.03133334964513779, -0.013787226751446724, 0.0322694405913353, -0.04442357271909714, -0.012545561417937279, 0.015728836879134178, -0.005627183243632317, -0.009620511904358864, 0.004187405109405518, -0.033771924674510956, 0.08002737164497375, -0.04285036399960518, 0.017528435215353966, -0.024237962439656258, 0.0431772917509079, -0.028699565678834915, -0.023503702133893967, -0.0016298656119033694, 0.0130226481705904, 0.023347632959485054, -0.005061178933829069, 0.009510229341685772, 0.015050100162625313, 0.038015201687812805, -0.06188669055700302, 0.0009068545186892152, -0.006996487732976675, -0.022411268204450607, -0.015275555662810802, -0.011639942415058613, -0.03931223228573799, 0.015044604428112507, 0.010829134844243526, 0.027159927412867546, 0.030097439885139465, -0.022617986425757408, -0.036949243396520615, -0.011091627180576324, 0.03302956745028496, -0.03328792005777359, 0.012513815425336361, -0.03517613932490349, 0.02590908482670784, 0.01347692497074604, -0.02115734852850437 ]
<p>I like to set up a 2 way repeated measures anova. I compare 4 models with 4 ages and see if the results differ, this should result in around 16 groups, since 4*4=16 (so far so good)</p> <p>However from some groups I don't have the data so I still have 2 factors to test for but not longer 16 groups but 15-14.</p> <p>This is not due to mistakes but due to the fact that the groups under this condition are just bad and don't meet standard recommondations. </p> <p>If however I'll try to do 2 way repeated measurments including my missing groups, I can't execute it.</p> <p>Is there a way to handle this missing groups?</p> <p>Greetings </p>
36,665
[ -0.017405804246664047, -0.0024731624871492386, -0.011919667944312096, 0.030889714136719704, 0.05207425355911255, -0.004501029849052429, 0.0006439853459596634, -0.04112638905644417, 0.027913209050893784, 0.005421190056949854, 0.024191109463572502, -0.010047009214758873, 0.051437847316265106, 0.012434007599949837, 0.004267432726919651, -0.0072777667082846165, -0.03145595267415047, -0.03784111142158508, 0.02004273608326912, 0.0013299132697284222, -0.026489198207855225, 0.01981787197291851, -0.018933888524770737, -0.011165708303451538, -0.014716774225234985, 0.013588984496891499, 0.051672689616680145, -0.041922323405742645, 0.028265221044421196, 0.026097392663359642, -0.04678051918745041, -0.061545271426439285, -0.008387318812310696, 0.04142509400844574, 0.005647655110806227, 0.0017315410077571869, -0.0124845951795578, 0.0076686665415763855, -0.004803059622645378, 0.01059692818671465, -0.05418553948402405, 0.017268309369683266, -0.015296020545065403, 0.0441235676407814, 0.016546817496418953, 0.027407387271523476, -0.004869256634265184, -0.0026655776891857386, 0.033370986580848694, -0.0573136992752552, 0.08673892915248871, -0.0006506865029223263, 0.0347285196185112, 0.020305538550019264, -0.015059410594403744, -0.024258878082036972, 0.05847369506955147, 0.07014801353216171, 0.00011945564619963989, -0.056969378143548965, -0.0016713341465219855, -0.012745517306029797, 0.011649969033896923, 0.0051557584665715694, -0.034867431968450546, 0.00321030942723155, -0.018354209139943123, -0.031551264226436615, 0.03920089080929756, -0.014471878297626972, 0.040937572717666626, -0.0029596081003546715, 0.05715590715408325, -0.01568695902824402, 0.02669522352516651, -0.007704277988523245, 0.043613336980342865, -0.017096903175115585, 0.04092211648821831, 0.048422448337078094, -0.010057490319013596, 0.03077569045126438, 0.02006424404680729, 0.015266687609255314, 0.005889028776437044, -0.0342203713953495, 0.029255224391818047, -0.046892695128917694, -0.014390994794666767, 0.018030161038041115, -0.01358039304614067, -0.030992189422249794, 0.0707247406244278, 0.03495515510439873, -0.0223239678889513, -0.00013651732297148556, -0.008784597739577293, 0.023497164249420166, -0.020597774535417557, 0.02793678641319275, -0.00669869314879179, 0.0012537480797618628, 0.03510069102048874, 0.0633455216884613, -0.03140392526984215, 0.007499523460865021, -0.013747832737863064, 0.006912111770361662, -0.01114095002412796, 0.013535108417272568, 0.011171539314091206, 0.018254956230521202, -0.010756819508969784, -0.03234241157770157, 0.03025062382221222, 0.003527460154145956, -0.05523844063282013, -0.014520418830215931, 0.03984827548265457, 0.05515946447849274, 0.05405211076140404, -0.036157671362161636, 0.03311425819993019, -0.008059983141720295, -0.03595561161637306, -0.013236574828624725, 0.006541954353451729, -0.023961568251252174, -0.02172037586569786, 0.08589600026607513, 0.0034318696707487106, -0.00609631696715951, 0.0335141196846962, -0.015299324877560139, 0.060541316866874695, -0.02876441180706024, -0.0755285918712616, -0.05784356966614723, 0.011720046401023865, -0.07142914831638336, -0.01313936896622181, -0.07128915935754776, 0.021866953000426292, 0.01590527966618538, 0.06540653109550476, 0.025628121569752693, 0.02053532935678959, -0.008341780863702297, 0.024613773450255394, 0.031503669917583466, 0.04036476090550423, 0.008273039944469929, -0.040733955800533295, -0.022950511425733566, -0.005489418748766184, -0.07898621261119843, 0.05129399523139, 0.015771841630339622, 0.009637849405407906, 0.007181231863796711, 0.019222911447286606, 0.0021735590416938066, -0.03314134478569031, 0.02032056450843811, 0.035944513976573944, -0.008093548007309437, 0.03992132470011711, -0.00704537658020854, 0.004944941028952599, 0.020946210250258446, -0.021808037534356117, -0.005928677041083574, -0.026402119547128677, 0.041766200214624405, 0.03960620239377022, 0.02604500576853752, -0.03154018521308899, 0.0014704461209475994, 0.026225293055176735, 0.06515348702669144, -0.019972924143075943, -0.02211032621562481, -0.050017911940813065, 0.01622096076607704, 0.03678989037871361, -0.002651265123859048, 0.024144958704710007, 0.007884291000664234, 0.05787771940231323, -0.04875236749649048, -0.03638081252574921, -0.08226223289966583, 0.021457472816109657, 0.019261501729488373, -0.020848538726568222, 0.035882093012332916, 0.012319964356720448, -0.010347384959459305, -0.010679715313017368, -0.056510698050260544, -0.025141969323158264, -0.027531523257493973, 0.009333870373666286, -0.04755040630698204, -0.009782515466213226, 0.015912365168333054, 0.06094098463654518, -0.03188974782824516, 0.09247292578220367, -0.03198980167508125, -0.050892263650894165, -0.018588285893201828, -0.02973313443362713, 0.009693647734820843, -0.014051171950995922, -0.0069518182426691055, -0.008433328941464424, 0.0128176249563694, -0.014565630815923214, 0.0705532431602478, -0.07308832556009293, 0.06436840444803238, 0.0763932317495346, 0.006955503951758146, -0.017350461333990097, 0.01261156052350998, 0.04237059876322746, 0.035168103873729706, -0.06268994510173798, -0.029764436185359955, -0.04429487884044647, 0.0013091053115203977, 0.015775389969348907, -0.017218569293618202, -0.04738890752196312, 0.03279692679643631, 0.06528936326503754, 0.01978059858083725, -0.010546906851232052, 0.040644846856594086, 0.046552106738090515, -0.0024127799551934004, 0.03873088210821152, 0.041143037378787994, 0.04318881779909134, 0.033179447054862976, 0.0018774975324049592, -0.004590605851262808, 0.014770162291824818, 0.02683420479297638, 0.0032169034238904715, 0.05330779403448105, 0.010473791509866714, -0.012553215958178043, -0.025724785402417183, -0.027786338701844215, 0.040638405829668045, 0.0031077919993549585, 0.03952064737677574, 0.055160049349069595, 0.0411839634180069, -0.019204530864953995, 0.02442169561982155, -0.01782173290848732, 0.019390052184462547, 0.03179604932665825, -0.029998810961842537, -0.04302855208516121, 0.008289236575365067, -0.009927230887115002, -0.019164497032761574, -0.0013069140259176493, -0.02059416100382805, -0.03528008982539177, 0.017388101667165756, 0.021104352548718452, -0.011667213402688503, 0.03450993075966835, -0.0018719660583883524, 0.0013244420988485217, -0.00927362684160471, -0.006422053091228008, 0.010909372009336948, 0.013674908317625523, -0.020131977275013924, 0.002887414302676916, -0.0013089082203805447, 0.024955982342362404, 0.030216841027140617, -0.017904072999954224, 0.030070597305893898, 0.025356508791446686, 0.0011744563234969974, -0.013459822162985802, -0.04293787106871605, -0.0428624153137207, 0.005075958091765642, -0.017789479345083237, -0.005355961620807648, 0.04553207382559776, 0.06234978884458542, -0.04118277132511139, -0.024685153737664223, -0.046151190996170044, 0.01950538530945778, -0.014468444511294365, -0.008159891702234745, 0.006927468813955784, -0.01351553201675415, 0.003072367049753666, 0.02841007523238659, -0.005930386949330568, 0.011240394786000252, -0.06203704699873924, -0.08222169429063797, -0.00222559436224401, 0.028338724747300148, -0.0004552528844214976, 0.0034748802427202463, 0.012872738763689995, 0.07580854743719101, 0.026757119223475456, -0.016001615673303604, -0.07021794468164444, -0.037004098296165466, -0.01947670616209507, -0.04975348711013794, 0.023081056773662567, -0.020168228074908257, -0.004977760370820761, 0.023292934522032738, -0.013126706704497337, -0.004857114981859922, 0.07743220776319504, 0.012098048813641071, -0.00346737215295434, 0.016772469505667686, 0.0530419759452343, -0.02978583052754402, 0.036000806838274, -0.002965186256915331, -0.02958332560956478, -0.03202563524246216, -0.002101482357829809, 0.0602494515478611, 0.01931479014456272, -0.04782823100686073, -0.002779970411211252, -0.04753347486257553, 0.015984589233994484, -0.02037421241402626, 0.016039080917835236, 0.03656645119190216, -0.009000913240015507, 0.013866464607417583, 0.024732865393161774, 0.04942566528916359, -0.026819953694939613, -0.006835921201854944, 0.05409839004278183, 0.020655713975429535, -0.0011827375274151564, -0.007007263600826263, -0.005236444063484669, -0.002130043227225542, 0.040166981518268585, 0.012826172634959221, 0.004782542120665312, 0.022649196907877922, 0.0346883125603199, 0.000129271560581401, 0.018737906590104103, -0.054963141679763794, 0.001276196911931038, -0.09583159536123276, 0.02255275659263134, -0.06642138212919235, 0.04493416100740433, 0.009752926416695118, 0.010253241285681725, 0.007128175813704729, 0.004513489548116922, -0.03358350694179535, -0.02745233289897442, -0.057145848870277405, 0.022068025544285774, 0.0050583453848958015, -0.0033016998786479235, 0.031503621488809586, -0.011601874604821205, 0.007280668709427118, -0.011493108235299587, 0.00606070552021265, -0.0028438984882086515, 0.02937978319823742, -0.017247691750526428, -0.02943890169262886, -0.013135520741343498, 0.0018932572565972805, -0.003000046592205763, -0.00557758379727602, 0.019423210993409157, -0.031662922352552414, 0.024658802896738052, 0.040624793618917465, -0.007679410744458437, -0.04295959696173668, -0.02726377360522747, 0.0060792225413024426, -0.00007933579763630405, 0.045320380479097366, 0.006125924177467823, 0.0476100780069828, -0.0746549665927887, -0.010744122788310051, -0.005731739569455385, 0.01486250851303339, 0.02432899922132492, 0.06797157227993011, -0.024443522095680237, -0.015420806594192982, -0.05876044183969498, -0.013588489964604378, 0.03227370232343674, 0.005386810749769211, -0.0008427570573985577, -0.021337183192372322, 0.019164511933922768, -0.0666821300983429, -0.00011977161193499342, 0.04658332094550133, 0.018022846430540085, -0.02368786372244358, -0.027918515726923943, -0.014847452752292156, -0.01703934371471405, -0.014131699688732624, -0.0054995594546198845, 0.0031606145203113556, -0.011586970649659634, -0.010825278237462044, 0.03474373742938042, -0.007290554698556662, -0.02366425096988678, 0.04529654607176781, 0.0060860211960971355, 0.013693826273083687, 0.003974195569753647, -0.007866712287068367, 0.01116285752505064, 0.038501057773828506, 0.01931295171380043, 0.040987949818372726, -0.016792913898825645, -0.07139094173908234, -0.011126995086669922, 0.061719655990600586, 0.04449858516454697, -0.0004698979901149869, -0.016193736344575882, -0.0001350271631963551, -0.025425642728805542, 0.013277183286845684, -0.032899994403123856, 0.048846468329429626, -0.030575808137655258, 0.019699469208717346, -0.030924372375011444, -0.06955917179584503, -0.0036484040319919586, 0.024885809049010277, -0.0018875476671382785, 0.010644806548953056, 0.02518203668296337, -0.02778511494398117, -0.03678358346223831, -0.005309986416250467, 0.017000265419483185, 0.05953783914446831, -0.00875650905072689, 0.002508029341697693, 0.04435017704963684, 0.022780751809477806, -0.0405159629881382, -0.03485977649688721, 0.02142619527876377, -0.031899817287921906, -0.017816755920648575, 0.0475822351872921, -0.02256946824491024, -0.025844231247901917, 0.015002149157226086, -0.024895522743463516, 0.019968826323747635, -0.01638551987707615, -0.035094015300273895, 0.02271970547735691, 0.019137922674417496, 0.012955095618963242, 0.055659983307123184, 0.05567310005426407, 0.02206513099372387, 0.032374776899814606, -0.03855201601982117, -0.012223572470247746, -0.04507552459836006, -0.04126875102519989, -0.05760081112384796, -0.05926249548792839, -0.010706664063036442, 0.03276768699288368, -0.0061258310452103615, 0.04390645772218704, -0.02973971888422966, -0.04133688285946846, 0.03689922019839287, 0.021913617849349976, 0.04340527951717377, 0.002547407988458872, -0.0009470300283282995, 0.012748084962368011, -0.022118346765637398, -0.02261742390692234, 0.045355673879384995, 0.0028077063616365194, 0.004616689868271351, 0.018990756943821907, -0.025417665019631386, 0.0023782348725944757, -0.01655975542962551, -0.03650812432169914, 0.007537635043263435, -0.032181523740291595, 0.011168158613145351, -0.027532853186130524, 0.0467483326792717, -0.043342944234609604, -0.014825482852756977, 0.022225715219974518, 0.03297336399555206, -0.04350888729095459, 0.009978560730814934, -0.013567131944000721, 0.06491386145353317, -0.000678125477861613, -0.013058078475296497, -0.09402842819690704, -0.046369459480047226, 0.01765182614326477, 0.01697484776377678, -0.012685702182352543, -0.019619807600975037, -0.02933085896074772, -0.0071119158528745174, 0.012562155723571777, -0.042046837508678436, 0.08080822974443436, 0.007146133109927177, 0.005293366499245167, 0.02121563069522381, 0.04847971722483635, 0.06282827258110046, 0.01675531454384327, -0.008549205958843231, 0.02018175646662712, -0.05109906941652298, -0.05587721988558769, -0.014969934709370136, -0.014191921800374985, -0.04120085760951042, -0.015955612063407898, -0.019722342491149902, 0.02972363866865635, 0.018772052600979805, -0.03483903780579567, -0.011302889324724674, 0.013034200295805931, -0.024847349151968956, 0.013500857166945934, -0.08668357133865356, 0.005645384546369314, -0.026631949469447136, -0.011252590455114841, -0.026034224778413773, -0.011082283221185207, -0.012544726952910423, 0.0024003717117011547, 0.008032585494220257, 0.0003504294145386666, 0.008069529198110104, 0.003169781994074583, 0.05963222309947014, -0.02096555382013321, -0.00943690910935402, 0.018195608630776405, 0.005667075980454683, 0.02776945009827614, 0.007705974858254194, -0.001049716491252184, -0.015265719033777714, 0.013658487237989902, -0.062062449753284454, -0.01830286905169487, -0.010809153318405151, -0.014260279946029186, 0.04669731855392456, 0.004378298297524452, 0.04258719086647034, 0.03776652365922928, 0.00791025348007679, -0.014570346102118492, -0.003179548541083932, -0.0005374656757339835, 0.01425028033554554, 0.003124239156022668, 0.07040296494960785, -0.00132154137827456, 0.04318030923604965, -0.009030507877469063, 0.021724233403801918, 0.04284562170505524, 0.03908746317028999, 0.0029169395565986633, 0.024057537317276, 0.010968032293021679, 0.017504142597317696, -0.03244669735431671, 0.002815300365909934, -0.035821281373500824, 0.0014893327606841922, -0.05262292921543121, -0.007024215068668127, 0.03152704983949661, 0.04370463266968727, 0.007999899797141552, -0.024328717961907387, -0.04923344776034355, -0.04841861501336098, 0.00009423487790627405, 0.034439437091350555, -0.027539245784282684, 0.02259337343275547, 0.02181495912373066, 0.06168467178940773, -0.011838212609291077, 0.029992593452334404, -0.03464615345001221, -0.0690491646528244, -0.04223688691854477, -0.0054918015375733376, -0.0033854986540973186, 0.05830156430602074, 0.006619058549404144, 0.017698446288704872, -0.010243003256618977, 0.007655701600015163, 0.01036086305975914, -0.012297773733735085, 0.04278081655502319, -0.0301086213439703, 0.011580921709537506, 0.03732896223664284, 0.007860601879656315, -0.010734176263213158, 0.04464884102344513, 0.11645115166902542, 0.05422024428844452, 0.02527228370308876, -0.07004949450492859, 0.03461166098713875, -0.005098743364214897, -0.005669464357197285, -0.005590767599642277, 0.01950371079146862, -0.025661444291472435, -0.014209489338099957, 0.04749736934900284, 0.07008510082960129, -0.0176644716411829, 0.027075130492448807, 0.046921130269765854, -0.008196679875254631, 0.0013437727466225624, -0.01341477781534195, 0.03957194834947586, 0.015442844480276108, -0.01301356591284275, -0.03817778453230858, 0.028032567352056503, 0.00847362820059061, 0.01629243977367878, -0.02455107681453228, -0.02247641794383526, -0.012181796133518219, -0.001963710179552436, -0.01526334322988987, 0.05983325466513634, 0.022954251617193222, 0.018261026591062546, -0.02007308416068554, -0.0054291305132210255, 0.00981278344988823, -0.034410830587148666, 0.03003220446407795, 0.025870805606245995, -0.0027399826794862747, -0.031308308243751526, -0.007844885811209679, 0.017410412430763245, -0.00962008535861969, -0.03887702524662018, 0.008582075126469135, 0.04992999508976936, -0.035423677414655685, -0.021324295550584793, -0.023017391562461853, -0.0012274229666218162, -0.008501979522407055, -0.05361296609044075, -0.03491302579641342, 0.017708487808704376, 0.03480610251426697, -0.031884387135505676, -0.03978760913014412, 0.005275555420666933, -0.0034670026507228613, 0.015749230980873108, 0.03155146911740303, 0.027628518640995026, -0.0031174554023891687, -0.007384614087641239, -0.09114236384630203, 0.04140609875321388, 0.017480505630373955, -0.02012680470943451, 0.004882113076746464, -0.013676800765097141, -0.008135618641972542, -0.0006814736407250166, 0.015479367226362228, 0.050309497863054276, 0.029698139056563377, -0.01373188104480505, -0.0458272323012352, -0.03812071681022644, -0.034516409039497375, -0.010364317335188389, -0.03325415775179863, -0.03875749558210373, 0.011722669936716557, -0.013267694041132927, 0.009527405723929405, 0.04687970504164696, 0.01718333549797535, -0.022046033293008804, 0.005730878561735153, 0.05568128079175949, 0.024208147078752518, -0.06840116530656815, -0.030728943645954132, -0.020411917939782143, -0.04616645351052284, -0.014049861580133438, -0.007916959002614021, 0.051378410309553146, -0.0026748671662062407, -0.012700231745839119, -0.0011597891571000218, 0.02594652958214283, -0.024300148710608482, 0.0012793692294508219, 0.0395875982940197, -0.09694857150316238, 0.008076103404164314, -0.005734534002840519, 0.023330839350819588, -0.020650720223784447, -0.0238507017493248, -0.029568107798695564, -0.04364398494362831, 0.04094841703772545, -0.04575793817639351, -0.03585726395249367, -0.011363603174686432, -0.03200748190283775, 0.013014044612646103, -0.02446831203997135, 0.016316283494234085, -0.06163094565272331, -0.015421351417899132, -0.013637101277709007, -0.01818968541920185, -0.021422749385237694, 0.023853715509176254, -0.025427082553505898, 0.026467029005289078, 0.03800969198346138, 0.0252417903393507, 0.02222425676882267, 0.007745738141238689, -0.0186329148709774, -0.007452609483152628, 0.026840656995773315, 0.013467023149132729, -0.026101047173142433, 0.022504759952425957, -0.06336379796266556, -0.025477591902017593, 0.03547632321715355, 0.011631759814918041, 0.059444326907396317, 0.03439217805862427, 0.000756927125621587, -0.03979242220520973, 0.07388987392187119, -0.025176094844937325, -0.03459765017032623, -0.006688679102808237, 0.026478402316570282, 0.009206111542880535, 0.016993524506688118, -0.007376819849014282, 0.025515053421258926, -0.03322833403944969, 0.020058345049619675, 0.054700251668691635, 0.034214895218610764, -0.05883171409368515, 0.001295853522606194, 0.031581345945596695, 0.04316987842321396, 0.004045404959470034, 0.012129010632634163, 0.02436969056725502, 0.017183318734169006, -0.009882842190563679, 0.0021928006317466497, -0.0232175812125206, 0.014117971993982792, -0.05573546513915062, -0.034391138702631, 0.005103534087538719, 0.024026602506637573, 0.02561172842979431, -0.036002837121486664, 0.01355831790715456, 0.022932980209589005, -0.054890137165784836, 0.015225361101329327, -0.0006877757259644568, -0.011145235039293766, -0.016021519899368286, 0.01430465467274189, -0.015370659530162811, 0.02349063754081726, 0.007463269867002964, 0.022261423990130424, -0.004302981775254011, -0.0018120115855708718, -0.009092879481613636, -0.08032211661338806, 0.002292684046551585, -0.007308104541152716, 0.04537997767329216, -0.0727606788277626, 0.02593844011425972, -0.0022938488982617855, -0.03405369445681572, 0.020897455513477325, -0.039102956652641296, 0.030368678271770477, 0.024116048589348793, 0.022951588034629822, -0.005137302912771702, 0.05465768650174141, 0.010989654809236526, 0.0022176848724484444, 0.029976963996887207, -0.012277480214834213, -0.039165038615465164, -0.012827858328819275, -0.0049616144970059395, 0.01724962145090103, 0.04312562197446823, -0.015097377821803093, -0.0059564076364040375, 0.019897202029824257, 0.007649269886314869, -0.013228163123130798, 0.03334234282374382, -0.010603845119476318, 0.030207352712750435, -0.01695113256573677, -0.03776820749044418, -0.0008123414008878171, 0.008934982120990753, 0.02727765403687954, 0.0040537710301578045, -0.026487428694963455, 0.02285933680832386, -0.02671932615339756, -0.032350827008485794, 0.01335045788437128, -0.0038192388601601124, -0.020890291780233383, -0.04300418868660927, 0.0032969992607831955, 0.017674744129180908, -0.030130581930279732, -0.007197000086307526, -0.003953674808144569, -0.019483204931020737, 0.05513574182987213, -0.02610507234930992, 0.01858155056834221, -0.030470915138721466, -0.004293315578252077, -0.008476047776639462, -0.062419258058071136, 0.04101135581731796, 0.010410974733531475, -0.011341995559632778, -0.04018426686525345, 0.009149623103439808, -0.015376490540802479, 0.00841442309319973, 0.05322880297899246, -0.005375043489038944, 0.029206855222582817, 0.003657631343230605, 0.00502760149538517, 0.0006919585866853595, -0.06466222554445267, 0.05447527393698692, 0.005541432648897171, 0.009828243404626846, -0.0004656164674088359, 0.028315717354416847, -0.025876332074403763, -0.016019804403185844, 0.013737776316702366, -0.0350186787545681, 0.003879257943481207, 0.011571829207241535, 0.01263212226331234, 0.01177225261926651, 0.004861950874328613, -0.008231723681092262, 0.015064921230077744, -0.004319904837757349, -0.011631819419562817, 0.021131161600351334, 0.026448553428053856, -0.058076661080121994, 0.05231009051203728, -0.04849771037697792, -0.012364933267235756, -0.012496392242610455, -0.007895124144852161, 0.003425316186621785, -0.03613637760281563, -0.017944950610399246, 0.05444297567009926, -0.023502599447965622, -0.005851758178323507, 0.0310653168708086, 0.04770201817154884, 0.008306163363158703, -0.01191534660756588, 0.024234386160969734, 0.006391419097781181, -0.010562525130808353, 0.01905592530965805, 0.009396255947649479, -0.013998618349432945, 0.004389910958707333, -0.020115386694669724, 0.016988884657621384, -0.004599915351718664, 0.007575598079711199, -0.007753713056445122, 0.0382937528192997, 0.003348161932080984, 0.010989096015691757, 0.001404859940521419, -0.015597102232277393, 0.046646613627672195, 0.011383605189621449, -0.00735130812972784, 0.04857907071709633, -0.05094080790877342, 0.034251291304826736, -0.03861742094159126, -0.0012602137867361307, -0.027273841202259064, 0.010289622470736504, 0.0026956619694828987, 0.03056083619594574, -0.0036031093914061785, 0.00831606611609459, -0.014118456281721592, -0.03197404742240906, 0.02703084796667099, -0.027729405090212822, 0.04130307212471962, -0.017208749428391457, -0.014520121738314629, -0.01559870969504118, -0.01285223476588726, -0.05864919349551201, -0.04262673109769821, 0.01757250726222992, 0.04265015199780464, 0.014099904336035252, -0.031154658645391464, -0.03647160530090332, 0.016928382217884064, 0.011961860582232475, -0.06413249671459198, -0.028974438086152077, -0.028260137885808945, 0.007777940481901169, -0.019503381103277206, 0.00043673114851117134 ]
<p>I have a textual classification problem that consists of two categories- zero an one. Up until now I tried solving it by creating a Document Term Matrix, and to run it through SVM (using RTextTools package). Here's a code snippet: (R)</p> <pre><code>models &lt;- train_models(container, algorithms=c("SVM")) results &lt;- classify_models(container, models) analytics &lt;- create_analytics(container, results) View(summary(analytics)) &gt;&gt;ALGORITHM PERFORMANCE &gt;&gt;SVM_PRECISION SVM_RECALL SVM_FSCORE &gt;&gt; 0.64 0.63 0.63 </code></pre> <p>My questions are as follows:</p> <ol> <li><p>Why are all the predicted values in the result matrix between 0.5-1? isn't it supposed to be 0-1? </p></li> <li><p>How can I see (in R) under which <strong><em>threshold</em></strong> are these precision and recall values being calculated? How can I change this threshold to get different values?</p></li> <li>How exactly are the recall/precision scores being calculated? I mean, supposed we have <em>theta</em> to separate that all scores above it are of class 1, and the rest are 0. Are these output scores just a simple mean of the two classes precision/recall? Is it a weighted average?</li> <li>How can I create in R two different thresholds values for each class (with what's left in between labeled as "unidentified")? </li> </ol>
74,039
[ -0.026233648881316185, -0.009460238739848137, 0.0026603899896144867, -0.008579029701650143, 0.01669875904917717, 0.008820531889796257, -0.026617828756570816, -0.011179700493812561, 0.03693113103508949, 0.0014405243564397097, 0.039497021585702896, 0.03411352261900902, 0.0704721063375473, 0.030966686084866524, 0.034467652440071106, 0.008639647625386715, 0.0021049792412668467, -0.003712395904585719, 0.018705038353800774, 0.02557472139596939, -0.005728476215153933, 0.021738562732934952, 0.014391192235052586, -0.0037083541974425316, -0.0035775129217654467, 0.05443079024553299, 0.022963788360357285, -0.013129724189639091, -0.011677645146846771, 0.03529881685972214, -0.028488976880908012, -0.018192442134022713, 0.009456843137741089, -0.015751829370856285, 0.00430486211553216, 0.005650979932397604, -0.026987586170434952, 0.007026138715445995, -0.012174924835562706, 0.019067931920289993, -0.0051038870587944984, -0.02409503422677517, -0.02319728210568428, 0.0600886344909668, -0.019173793494701385, -0.017069820314645767, -0.015577387996017933, 0.006358555983752012, 0.04564333334565163, -0.032737161964178085, 0.03366051986813545, -0.014991804957389832, 0.041085630655288696, 0.06067374721169472, 0.0015138568123802543, 0.012178655713796616, 0.05846434086561203, 0.06990110129117966, 0.03470081835985184, -0.06543970108032227, -0.015319650061428547, -0.02557162195444107, -0.002864755457267165, -0.010686177760362625, -0.03677402064204216, 0.04788294807076454, 0.005010517779737711, -0.04054105281829834, 0.06262996792793274, -0.00965022947639227, -0.005387511570006609, 0.020894421264529228, -0.025357352569699287, -0.0018119808519259095, 0.04590914398431778, -0.0197074506431818, 0.007245400454849005, 0.020629137754440308, 0.06725800037384033, 0.037706371396780014, 0.013212827034294605, 0.04488019645214081, 0.03664642944931984, 0.02902119606733322, -0.01375175453722477, 0.014591524377465248, 0.05857480689883232, -0.019450940191745758, 0.013456102460622787, 0.03739674389362335, 0.027099240571260452, 0.022073455154895782, 0.0330265611410141, -0.0006726261344738305, -0.009445229545235634, 0.07297564297914505, 0.003695898689329624, 0.02205364778637886, 0.023653464391827583, -0.022133730351924896, -0.0022843615151941776, -0.04812171682715416, 0.012292244471609592, 0.054652608931064606, -0.05413692817091942, 0.005395879969000816, -0.048293568193912506, -0.04544062539935112, -0.008992146700620651, -0.023125816136598587, 0.0038051768206059933, 0.01847129315137863, -0.019001493230462074, -0.03524653613567352, -0.024294834583997726, -0.013411135412752628, -0.02288517914712429, -0.01883266679942608, 0.04384135454893112, 0.02519352175295353, 0.04900530353188515, 0.0132647305727005, 0.014790746383368969, -0.025521107017993927, -0.055535513907670975, -0.0061420719139277935, 0.028069565072655678, -0.029487257823348045, -0.0508585050702095, 0.040531087666749954, -0.021365297958254814, -0.0010272235376760364, 0.03108697012066841, -0.0020120928529649973, 0.018445540219545364, -0.00003208843554602936, -0.036871571093797684, -0.053912095725536346, 0.014132422395050526, -0.008773108944296837, -0.017355425283312798, -0.04637214168906212, -0.018965672701597214, 0.018654940649867058, 0.046152498573064804, 0.04854823648929596, 0.049505919218063354, 0.04509595036506653, -0.012483148835599422, 0.0237717442214489, -0.0340542308986187, 0.025086209177970886, -0.05918054282665253, 0.006668879184871912, -0.03340057656168938, -0.03803080692887306, 0.0023967118468135595, -0.00009987360681407154, -0.027300190180540085, 0.005410433281213045, 0.005172520875930786, -0.02316828817129135, 0.01719779148697853, 0.02672192081809044, 0.0113593814894557, -0.009883975610136986, 0.05150493606925011, 0.03754652291536331, 0.05348292738199234, 0.0235732514411211, -0.0170182753354311, 0.010767178609967232, 0.03910818323493004, 0.041195664554834366, 0.019275950267910957, 0.0183698907494545, 0.004304870031774044, -0.0317784920334816, 0.035192396491765976, 0.01371808908879757, -0.07501333951950073, -0.047423627227544785, -0.017503749579191208, 0.007012540474534035, 0.010848402045667171, 0.0330856554210186, -0.030125483870506287, -0.01689676195383072, 0.024994105100631714, -0.018788577988743782, -0.025936760008335114, -0.07147266715765, -0.007627241779118776, -0.04538799822330475, -0.026545856148004532, 0.019500181078910828, -0.015098812058568, 0.024628378450870514, 0.012795059941709042, 0.01040552370250225, -0.04480429366230965, 0.03541213646531105, 0.0383591391146183, -0.03466954454779625, 0.016719209030270576, 0.05710926279425621, 0.015832260251045227, -0.039846207946538925, 0.005128834396600723, -0.014201471582055092, -0.06709536910057068, -0.02121448703110218, -0.03832067921757698, 0.051048316061496735, -0.025706801563501358, -0.036995287984609604, 0.0061738211661577225, 0.0004875553131569177, -0.02683650702238083, 0.020982639864087105, -0.06087661162018776, 0.0630251094698906, 0.07293747365474701, 0.03462144732475281, -0.019968675449490547, -0.0063402787782251835, -0.02994915470480919, 0.023585164919495583, -0.022684890776872635, 0.0035152274649590254, -0.038851547986269, -0.011516768485307693, 0.07112197577953339, 0.03139635920524597, -0.01210798230022192, -0.005881274119019508, 0.05243368074297905, 0.020209232345223427, -0.008337294682860374, 0.010199014097452164, 0.0009711437742225826, 0.01364273764193058, 0.02595295011997223, 0.024720218032598495, 0.005585185252130032, 0.007698743604123592, 0.017113355919718742, -0.013009010814130306, 0.05117969214916229, 0.005074500571936369, -0.0009507468203082681, 0.06394048035144806, -0.015022452920675278, -0.016939854249358177, -0.028934264555573463, 0.02124343067407608, 0.0602569505572319, -0.0011713422136381269, -0.006195852532982826, 0.06587588042020798, 0.017823712900280952, 0.008516917005181313, 0.018014652654528618, 0.01694243773818016, 0.028574032709002495, 0.037251126021146774, -0.020093154162168503, -0.012112071737647057, 0.007852358743548393, -0.025471027940511703, 0.03755684569478035, -0.010906267911195755, -0.022120021283626556, -0.032257355749607086, 0.03087756037712097, 0.05991882085800171, -0.02384353242814541, 0.00808173418045044, -0.02863992191851139, -0.004515062086284161, -0.009323230013251305, -0.023123105987906456, 0.023438410833477974, -0.005613450426608324, -0.07861749827861786, 0.010702989064157009, -0.05324700102210045, -0.023029645904898643, 0.02726275846362114, 0.014568825252354145, -0.048418283462524414, 0.0070733968168497086, -0.020981380715966225, -0.07304947823286057, -0.06404613703489304, -0.03811958432197571, 0.009169481694698334, -0.03322887420654297, -0.011235063895583153, 0.0044111101888120174, -0.012261969968676567, -0.03903227299451828, 0.020741280168294907, -0.02512245438992977, -0.03312288224697113, -0.02443513832986355, 0.0048923310823738575, -0.001422262517735362, -0.02099710702896118, 0.018903395161032677, 0.03494871035218239, -0.038191281259059906, -0.03259488567709923, -0.07761958986520767, 0.000729323539417237, 0.017012353986501694, -0.042058076709508896, -0.015711858868598938, 0.009913381189107895, -0.0046068173833191395, 0.09402762353420258, 0.02698131464421749, -0.03572255000472069, -0.054868895560503006, 0.010103642009198666, -0.041838452219963074, -0.04054011404514313, -0.019178416579961777, 0.02178432233631611, 0.02465042844414711, -0.022295517846941948, -0.0033059651032090187, 0.010564273223280907, 0.04830832779407501, -0.008375503122806549, -0.030385322868824005, 0.025780612602829933, -0.02832399681210518, -0.02926928736269474, 0.015695935115218163, 0.03978772833943367, 0.01044247392565012, 0.02122941054403782, 0.0005607646889984608, 0.05021887645125389, 0.0006294945487752557, -0.016211973503232002, -0.0018019990529865026, -0.012185241095721722, 0.008579248562455177, -0.012666791677474976, 0.024070730432868004, 0.005210566334426403, -0.027099722996354103, -0.023035584017634392, 0.01100890338420868, 0.025650229305028915, -0.06846775114536285, -0.03608398884534836, 0.02616669237613678, 0.04694443941116333, -0.045647334307432175, -0.009580807760357857, -0.03615020215511322, 0.01300108153373003, -0.006900106091052294, -0.0305708646774292, 0.004052537959069014, 0.05881461873650551, 0.03588363528251648, 0.009763101115822792, 0.020903272554278374, -0.017308630049228668, 0.004161925055086613, -0.08941905200481415, 0.009219374507665634, -0.026271728798747063, 0.044048063457012177, 0.019170712679624557, 0.025646502152085304, 0.003472911659628153, -0.015578413382172585, 0.04195217415690422, -0.016454031690955162, -0.05352325364947319, 0.014210497960448265, -0.01410662941634655, -0.037832338362932205, 0.031671080738306046, -0.007149828132241964, 0.02201240323483944, -0.028483206406235695, -0.00018147849186789244, -0.018418485298752785, 0.00940579455345869, -0.0366368405520916, 0.014607860706746578, 0.05456361919641495, 0.019127188250422478, -0.045156825333833694, 0.01071564294397831, 0.03257433697581291, -0.017859842628240585, 0.050214819610118866, 0.04051775857806206, -0.005391473416239023, 0.004976082593202591, -0.04507991299033165, 0.011519880965352058, 0.03087160736322403, 0.033121414482593536, 0.0761399120092392, 0.038507137447595596, -0.05075465887784958, 0.04701818898320198, 0.006099935155361891, 0.07885906100273132, 0.05358119308948517, -0.0010544774122536182, -0.045466773211956024, -0.05596780404448509, -0.03964126110076904, 0.03380410373210907, 0.018276188522577286, -0.01006791740655899, 0.007428501266986132, 0.03408436104655266, 0.01945418119430542, -0.0675620511174202, 0.015419138595461845, 0.06200752034783363, -0.014275743626058102, -0.004258269909769297, -0.029528383165597916, -0.015527934767305851, -0.022542694583535194, 0.013868497684597969, 0.04926075041294098, -0.006376785691827536, 0.02109561674296856, -0.019947975873947144, 0.009886249899864197, -0.06195494160056114, -0.06353205442428589, -0.008169976063072681, 0.032603584229946136, -0.000046605709940195084, -0.02620699070394039, -0.03426916524767876, -0.0046143559738993645, 0.03551285341382027, 0.05738133564591408, -0.010044903494417667, 0.01351961400359869, -0.09332134574651718, -0.0002839565568137914, 0.030575770884752274, 0.07653329521417618, -0.025920048356056213, -0.027862144634127617, -0.03245743364095688, -0.018422283232212067, 0.015142222866415977, -0.021246928721666336, 0.05031163990497589, 0.003215162781998515, 0.001375186606310308, -0.005051744170486927, 0.006759162992238998, -0.029225200414657593, 0.02719845436513424, -0.024215681478381157, 0.06618934869766235, 0.0023857203777879477, -0.012384281493723392, -0.025061579421162605, 0.01315796934068203, -0.015288294292986393, 0.00991432648152113, -0.0390956848859787, -0.0289472546428442, 0.015266257338225842, -0.0015415744855999947, -0.0025420193560421467, -0.050439365208148956, -0.018421830609440804, -0.015849411487579346, -0.014949358068406582, 0.04071350395679474, -0.0204776581376791, -0.021007269620895386, 0.05796847864985466, 0.039097338914871216, -0.007987823337316513, -0.024190189316868782, -0.021870849654078484, 0.03966192901134491, 0.061168085783720016, -0.02284814417362213, 0.06113126128911972, 0.02662002481520176, 0.03132861852645874, 0.02594906836748123, -0.05686338245868683, 0.00445984210819006, 0.013932472094893456, -0.02510174922645092, -0.06379535794258118, 0.01372265163809061, -0.00010201666009379551, 0.027570180594921112, 0.038408175110816956, 0.03977656364440918, -0.029593875631690025, 0.005725509487092495, -0.017251307144761086, 0.05216286703944206, -0.016103392466902733, -0.022436682134866714, 0.05012039840221405, 0.02507762238383293, -0.03592482581734657, 0.007889557629823685, 0.015307191759347916, -0.03755916655063629, 0.023728715255856514, 0.010671081952750683, -0.03382735326886177, 0.00959570799022913, 0.010543841868638992, -0.010988893918693066, 0.016344258561730385, -0.02024093084037304, 0.0670803114771843, -0.03651615232229233, 0.04827030003070831, 0.004017861094325781, -0.024342898279428482, -0.032554179430007935, 0.01366029866039753, 0.015818601474165916, 0.012717043049633503, -0.025427961722016335, 0.05110911652445793, 0.004107414744794369, -0.02908848412334919, -0.023298729211091995, -0.01922854222357273, 0.006079218816012144, -0.013418896123766899, -0.05397314205765724, -0.02020002342760563, 0.007782903965562582, -0.016035841777920723, -0.02921907790005207, -0.013157046400010586, 0.07399505376815796, -0.030355865135788918, -0.04478505253791809, -0.0001455743913538754, 0.016813527792692184, 0.08147698640823364, -0.013287208043038845, 0.009539254941046238, 0.036787088960409164, 0.012027457356452942, -0.018034247681498528, 0.013089118525385857, 0.02534167282283306, -0.05796447768807411, -0.03650436922907829, -0.0525471568107605, 0.036138150840997696, 0.03975595906376839, 0.012714109383523464, 0.025653313845396042, -0.0035684676840901375, -0.007496414706110954, 0.04079853743314743, -0.036471638828516006, 0.011644002050161362, 0.014861861243844032, 0.0008408697904087603, -0.030830595642328262, -0.009959263727068901, -0.04006670042872429, -0.000034542568755568936, 0.014909244142472744, -0.029941905289888382, 0.01146561000496149, -0.013747221790254116, 0.0918167233467102, 0.002627541543915868, 0.045530207455158234, -0.010044283233582973, -0.002592594362795353, 0.034099090844392776, 0.012058687396347523, 0.002594597637653351, 0.014440187253057957, 0.005668882746249437, -0.045070428401231766, -0.0004137180221732706, -0.04344363510608673, -0.011501667089760303, 0.05909891054034233, -0.0070790862664580345, 0.024683335795998573, 0.007250303868204355, -0.017606431618332863, -0.0066131544299423695, -0.05945567414164543, -0.029048195108771324, -0.023393113166093826, -0.00002741930256888736, 0.03288345783948898, -0.037254784256219864, -0.018892187625169754, 0.03191475197672844, 0.00819433480501175, 0.0008727897657081485, 0.0028383878525346518, 0.021103547886013985, -0.014222519472241402, 0.029821405187249184, -0.023837292566895485, -0.004989082925021648, 0.02359498105943203, 0.0069944607093930244, -0.009541692212224007, 0.01577521488070488, 0.00017836864572018385, 0.04576066508889198, 0.014674223028123379, 0.008690656162798405, -0.050231173634529114, -0.007386237848550081, -0.05759162828326225, 0.01913231797516346, 0.03800763189792633, -0.04856649413704872, 0.009929425083100796, 0.013799129985272884, 0.011328128166496754, 0.010249112732708454, 0.03814410790801048, -0.011159144341945648, -0.0761808305978775, -0.04109299182891846, -0.021325308829545975, -0.03785434737801552, 0.022446615621447563, 0.012180894613265991, -0.02565740793943405, 0.04406684264540672, -0.07164731621742249, 0.045245781540870667, 0.02803998440504074, 0.040407001972198486, -0.0167797040194273, 0.016131404787302017, -0.012633170001208782, 0.03480929136276245, 0.01619473285973072, -0.024732742458581924, 0.13711291551589966, 0.09488511830568314, 0.0427396260201931, -0.06555129587650299, -0.0011661496246233582, 0.018866438418626785, 0.021063733845949173, -0.04286899045109749, 0.011143786832690239, -0.0058675906620919704, -0.007275337353348732, 0.02927280403673649, 0.02336372621357441, 0.03659631311893463, -0.0013677640818059444, 0.022133463993668556, -0.031213194131851196, -0.023701567202806473, -0.02280730940401554, 0.016223285347223282, 0.009759730659425259, -0.017936864867806435, -0.06505453586578369, -0.0034699265379458666, 0.02396267279982567, -0.025732150301337242, -0.024111945182085037, -0.016705328598618507, 0.010435394011437893, -0.011893432587385178, -0.006333433091640472, 0.01623455621302128, -0.015065964311361313, 0.0571819506585598, 0.01888829655945301, 0.023766586557030678, 0.0131013048812747, 0.002832846948876977, -0.0008273414568975568, 0.03603687137365341, -0.013227093033492565, 0.0045539909042418, 0.014354564249515533, 0.04540417715907097, -0.04558844864368439, -0.027857936918735504, -0.04087409749627113, 0.06969442963600159, -0.0019740459974855185, -0.02550414577126503, 0.0027738476637750864, 0.007580431178212166, -0.011472741141915321, -0.023640666157007217, -0.017931830137968063, 0.033499572426080704, 0.013502562418580055, -0.013292286545038223, 0.0040663364343345165, -0.03357976675033569, 0.05132525414228439, -0.01203231792896986, 0.030098866671323776, -0.0032097462099045515, -0.03620193526148796, -0.003822135739028454, -0.050438109785318375, 0.05057787895202637, 0.019955040886998177, 0.019628651440143585, 0.01609024591743946, -0.009300295263528824, -0.012647025287151337, -0.021731460466980934, -0.019112542271614075, 0.0054494235664606094, 0.007504516746848822, -0.0019538472406566143, 0.004737076349556446, -0.030244749039411545, -0.04554731026291847, 0.004737649112939835, -0.019997546449303627, 0.008375720120966434, -0.05915350839495659, -0.004148692823946476, 0.016314974054694176, 0.004091240465641022, 0.03211037814617157, 0.030688613653182983, 0.027761854231357574, 0.01769864186644554, 0.03158583119511604, -0.028851207345724106, -0.0193034615367651, 0.009730271063745022, -0.008689725771546364, -0.005186666268855333, 0.025816939771175385, 0.07335022836923599, 0.015256449580192566, -0.003662011818960309, -0.026652364060282707, 0.0010242749704048038, 0.0060108378529548645, -0.016803106293082237, -0.0014535000082105398, -0.033134106546640396, 0.026117980480194092, 0.01665964536368847, -0.009524136781692505, -0.030225878581404686, -0.03930606693029404, -0.05399522930383682, -0.034849390387535095, 0.0023652189411222935, 0.0024762677494436502, -0.05642938241362572, 0.013762847520411015, -0.013285779394209385, 0.03468787670135498, -0.008751899935305119, -0.02205486409366131, 0.010139187797904015, 0.009870283305644989, -0.04858054220676422, -0.04920728877186775, 0.018690407276153564, 0.017649929970502853, -0.03563101589679718, 0.00919691938906908, 0.009941968135535717, 0.00037866245838813484, -0.0023740814067423344, -0.02919941395521164, 0.0009850624483078718, -0.03514692932367325, 0.024526748806238174, -0.004768332000821829, -0.04036160185933113, 0.04629303887486458, -0.037736792117357254, -0.03886422514915466, -0.0008764973026700318, -0.029652932658791542, 0.04226509854197502, 0.01392405480146408, -0.03358139470219612, -0.00035572441993281245, 0.08091741800308228, -0.049349259585142136, -0.016006872057914734, 0.0042928848415613174, 0.01773799955844879, 0.0014341690111905336, 0.04200691729784012, 0.034306347370147705, 0.002958868630230427, -0.001933423220179975, -0.004204460419714451, 0.02911348268389702, -0.006391605362296104, -0.024079948663711548, 0.012877282686531544, -0.04117511212825775, 0.03419013321399689, 0.018106408417224884, -0.003332801628857851, 0.01119367778301239, 0.016023889183998108, -0.004307672381401062, 0.01928309164941311, -0.01989530771970749, 0.028181517496705055, -0.08548072725534439, 0.007095256820321083, -0.007643294520676136, -0.006451066583395004, 0.032631415873765945, -0.061458658427000046, 0.014279547147452831, 0.03073190338909626, -0.04336313158273697, 0.009752552956342697, 0.026833519339561462, -0.01194577943533659, -0.02430086024105549, 0.03242539241909981, -0.03823534771800041, -0.00008572694059694186, 0.04751364886760712, 0.010168544948101044, 0.02761108987033367, 0.007841796614229679, -0.02902153693139553, -0.0460006520152092, -0.04043349251151085, 0.03070708177983761, -0.011618560180068016, -0.016394829377532005, 0.030348140746355057, -0.04832952097058296, -0.03470778837800026, -0.001417140825651586, -0.024657461792230606, 0.0011198732536286116, 0.08316663652658463, 0.006555138621479273, 0.006003414746373892, 0.04920066520571709, 0.01847054250538349, 0.016881823539733887, -0.007646733429282904, 0.009470715187489986, 0.00741285877302289, 0.017173530533909798, -0.021431464701890945, 0.0015269016148522496, 0.04449840635061264, -0.004871532320976257, -0.030172711238265038, 0.044260263442993164, -0.03595280647277832, -0.04117856174707413, -0.028234483674168587, 0.03502792865037918, -0.010943854227662086, -0.06252056360244751, 0.006450607907027006, -0.04259961098432541, -0.01833048276603222, 0.0023769887629896402, 0.00484964344650507, -0.007040527183562517, 0.009860679507255554, -0.024108463898301125, -0.03053516522049904, 0.022161973640322685, -0.024488648399710655, -0.03943434730172157, -0.027525315061211586, -0.016499489545822144, 0.013908468186855316, -0.01692066714167595, -0.016095487400889397, 0.007353878580033779, -0.024410750716924667, 0.0650693029165268, -0.013726446777582169, 0.02257404290139675, 0.030415108427405357, 0.00980588048696518, 0.0068305968306958675, -0.09512130171060562, 0.06440234929323196, -0.0179465189576149, 0.0030661195050925016, -0.038189757615327835, 0.0029647003393620253, -0.049308013170957565, 0.043569207191467285, 0.04407168924808502, 0.0073617431335151196, 0.0005126453470438719, -0.02226070873439312, 0.00796107854694128, -0.012275952845811844, -0.040958989411592484, 0.03632853552699089, 0.003995970357209444, -0.029481586068868637, -0.025587141513824463, -0.024784579873085022, 0.019594918936491013, 0.021913887932896614, 0.01488400436937809, -0.04840496927499771, 0.00015552293916698545, -0.011293357238173485, 0.003212140640243888, 0.029824864119291306, 0.014909797348082066, 0.03103022836148739, 0.058176904916763306, 0.02299734577536583, -0.0066795009188354015, 0.04743324592709541, 0.007598100695759058, -0.013474524952471256, 0.046294204890728, -0.03222312778234482, -0.02365471050143242, -0.014782525599002838, 0.01466583926230669, 0.01169915683567524, -0.06150663271546364, -0.021613702178001404, 0.02985290437936783, 0.003859149059280753, 0.016039574518799782, 0.047934941947460175, 0.008126598782837391, 0.05509026348590851, 0.018591688945889473, 0.017771542072296143, -0.014315355569124222, -0.01172089483588934, 0.03391759470105171, 0.020692041143774986, 0.031350474804639816, 0.0111905038356781, 0.03275573253631592, 0.005391986109316349, -0.02507481537759304, 0.019044766202569008, -0.012476090341806412, 0.05762219801545143, -0.029495401307940483, -0.0038324007764458656, 0.0008060534601099789, -0.012508993037045002, -0.0040222955867648125, 0.014010346494615078, 0.002734573557972908, 0.045677751302719116, -0.04007017984986305, -0.008174451068043709, -0.05313520506024361, -0.026009904220700264, -0.022753484547138214, 0.00972207635641098, 0.005184612236917019, 0.04737624526023865, 0.004481015261262655, -0.0014313803985714912, -0.005531640257686377, -0.016439378261566162, 0.016617994755506516, -0.026302073150873184, 0.018584128469228745, 0.0042972867377102375, -0.01563018001616001, -0.016271281987428665, -0.005863876547664404, -0.01958044059574604, -0.015428412705659866, 0.014286335557699203, 0.019537916406989098, 0.002691522240638733, -0.038222234696149826, -0.024944446980953217, -0.0014139799168333411, 0.014602068811655045, -0.051020700484514236, 0.005366180092096329, -0.032274115830659866, 0.011611204594373703, -0.017492812126874924, -0.0508749820291996 ]
<p>If I would like to fit random intercept and slope and if I write it as (color|writer) compared to (1+color|writer), are they the same?</p>
74,040
[ -0.03991149365901947, -0.029872572049498558, -0.01010398380458355, 0.006443274673074484, 0.019680503755807877, 0.027138328179717064, 0.022235926240682602, -0.005246730986982584, 0.013922447338700294, -0.017451871186494827, 0.027384033426642418, 0.023618293926119804, 0.04202507436275482, 0.022526586428284645, 0.043225016444921494, 0.052909817546606064, -0.004492470063269138, 0.044718172401189804, 0.0007678422261960804, 0.022043626755475998, -0.0008692336268723011, 0.011773113161325455, 0.046350155025720596, -0.009522894397377968, -0.0033020717091858387, 0.03480660170316696, 0.03924314305186272, -0.04656172916293144, 0.010591096244752407, 0.034524060785770416, -0.016512220725417137, -0.01894542947411537, 0.021008692681789398, 0.05231161788105965, 0.03510013967752457, -0.010016641579568386, 0.010690529830753803, -0.03732281178236008, -0.026560619473457336, 0.0018312250031158328, 0.0028303773142397404, -0.017295125871896744, 0.013084993697702885, 0.008100580424070358, -0.026386819779872894, 0.01923668570816517, -0.010249012149870396, -0.044805724173784256, 0.03783680871129036, -0.043778371065855026, 0.07141280919313431, -0.020652012899518013, 0.04456542432308197, 0.04954339563846588, -0.03931345418095589, 0.007061243988573551, 0.0841870829463005, 0.05008634552359581, 0.006231141742318869, -0.023381944745779037, 0.02986088953912258, -0.011791885830461979, 0.00976313091814518, 0.01691722683608532, -0.017781078815460205, 0.01153869740664959, 0.02482188493013382, -0.0070185535587370396, 0.04772399738430977, 0.0018461813451722264, -0.020658493041992188, 0.019949305802583694, 0.07280337810516357, -0.022057615220546722, 0.02312951721251011, -0.056548964232206345, 0.046096667647361755, 0.0471709780395031, 0.037886060774326324, 0.0006268626893870533, -0.01963622495532036, 0.023359637707471848, 0.06600169837474823, 0.020602241158485413, 0.007403793279081583, 0.01735564135015011, 0.04113752394914627, -0.024482211098074913, 0.027127929031848907, 0.027754444628953934, 0.019690264016389847, 0.04348442330956459, 0.05176069587469101, 0.01725578121840954, -0.036490101367235184, 0.021653790026903152, -0.010084954090416431, 0.00772120663896203, 0.03119778446853161, 0.01838076487183571, -0.024849461391568184, -0.03687603026628494, -0.007472734898328781, 0.05027744546532631, -0.008669628761708736, -0.003654679050669074, 0.012584647163748741, 0.058211006224155426, -0.021743010729551315, -0.015742452815175056, -0.0015679181087762117, -0.003067958867177367, 0.006233474239706993, 0.007767020724713802, 0.0384967140853405, -0.03020378388464451, 0.008408384397625923, -0.003411892568692565, 0.08229793608188629, 0.05261089652776718, 0.01007886417210102, -0.05533294752240181, 0.023492837324738503, -0.030903393402695656, 0.005919042509049177, 0.012958979234099388, -0.008622465655207634, -0.014948839321732521, -0.04241405799984932, 0.034772615879774094, -0.029057219624519348, -0.036177460104227066, 0.014835218898952007, 0.0297380480915308, 0.0021488890051841736, 0.001511964714154601, -0.05448728799819946, -0.03634924814105034, -0.012857893481850624, -0.035422053188085556, 0.010090784169733524, -0.039294492453336716, -0.012205001898109913, 0.015079306438565254, 0.027810905128717422, 0.021654725074768066, 0.0608123354613781, 0.0019621497485786676, 0.008378209546208382, 0.0015206326497718692, -0.030015109106898308, -0.039256539195775986, 0.009635097347199917, -0.05797342583537102, 0.03058936446905136, -0.05969693139195442, 0.04015093296766281, 0.027375323697924614, -0.008289842866361141, -0.02404019609093666, 0.041244350373744965, -0.026092639192938805, 0.002304090652614832, 0.01744925044476986, 0.025135602802038193, -0.03864366188645363, 0.08239928632974625, -0.011125553399324417, 0.013823194429278374, 0.009885581210255623, 0.012717360630631447, 0.004258911591023207, 0.028184043243527412, 0.03517606481909752, 0.07237714529037476, 0.006079116370528936, -0.016438070684671402, -0.012066194787621498, 0.03465087339282036, 0.013058273121714592, -0.05074562132358551, -0.05144818499684334, -0.022788647562265396, -0.016958631575107574, 0.012562903575599194, 0.04981684312224388, 0.029347317293286324, 0.011048074811697006, 0.04056189954280853, -0.0033391742035746574, 0.012339944951236248, -0.03686259314417839, 0.01990257017314434, 0.033169955015182495, 0.011456703767180443, 0.04121243581175804, 0.018083740025758743, -0.0034125710371881723, -0.011149217374622822, -0.024654140695929527, -0.01342935860157013, 0.007016799878329039, 0.004497842397540808, -0.03379904106259346, -0.0211565513163805, 0.07256443798542023, 0.025315329432487488, -0.010988387279212475, 0.04711830988526344, -0.050799015909433365, -0.05240932106971741, 0.0027791280299425125, -0.04329398274421692, 0.01853742077946663, 0.0050376406870782375, 0.008689123205840588, 0.027294810861349106, 0.035423751920461655, -0.007518860045820475, 0.048701684921979904, -0.02579156681895256, 0.05552835389971733, 0.026996420696377754, 0.03244201838970184, -0.030342761427164078, 0.04849669337272644, 0.019858909770846367, -0.004037169273942709, -0.002787507139146328, -0.012407486326992512, -0.005406317301094532, 0.009273169562220573, 0.01097724586725235, 0.005731799639761448, -0.046709563583135605, 0.006982880178838968, 0.07355247437953949, 0.02383105456829071, 0.03892829641699791, 0.03575292229652405, 0.01025475189089775, -0.0057524037547409534, -0.013355639763176441, 0.03392805904150009, 0.0152171915397048, -0.004490764811635017, 0.005664769094437361, -0.01588565669953823, 0.03580137714743614, 0.00785879883915186, -0.022983327507972717, 0.001183565123938024, 0.023615974932909012, 0.0017030835151672363, -0.021778058260679245, -0.010266284458339214, 0.039396099746227264, -0.04886264726519585, 0.018564848229289055, 0.032839350402355194, -0.010130736976861954, -0.044356413185596466, -0.007058302406221628, -0.008303334005177021, -0.004479550756514072, 0.028269024565815926, -0.018858538940548897, -0.05806076154112816, 0.04434175044298172, -0.010977827943861485, 0.04727376252412796, -0.05471211299300194, -0.028406500816345215, -0.07098419964313507, 0.010233021341264248, 0.009589217603206635, -0.01029968075454235, 0.01550410408526659, -0.05703279748558998, -0.01054401881992817, -0.0004971043672412634, -0.005629513878375292, 0.015239400789141655, -0.027345936745405197, -0.04711233824491501, 0.013503572903573513, -0.07146725058555603, -0.023883486166596413, -0.007605044636875391, -0.023112427443265915, -0.008766938000917435, 0.009545066393911839, -0.05925443395972252, -0.04877009987831116, -0.02790844440460205, -0.02682710997760296, 0.0055093481205403805, -0.028973758220672607, -0.04573140665888786, 0.04042304307222366, -0.017290811985731125, -0.049502819776535034, -0.004423616454005241, -0.030212994664907455, -0.014100429601967335, -0.057587698101997375, -0.006185626611113548, 0.007636226713657379, 0.004780097398906946, 0.02654366008937359, 0.06473322212696075, -0.02573961578309536, -0.00346605503000319, -0.10362054407596588, -0.052119605243206024, 0.018996963277459145, -0.0029652470257133245, 0.03538902848958969, -0.009801726788282394, 0.014874649234116077, 0.022849885746836662, 0.03748047724366188, -0.027972178533673286, -0.04679735377430916, 0.02297421172261238, -0.018957030028104782, -0.04445062577724457, 0.023075232282280922, 0.030917102470993996, 0.018025800585746765, 0.02523193694651127, -0.013005265966057777, 0.028487250208854675, 0.06402727216482162, 0.02049211412668228, 0.03789814934134483, 0.009812043979763985, -0.0023429561406373978, -0.028939491137862206, 0.05939869210124016, 0.019359121099114418, -0.03136078640818596, 0.03433343023061752, -0.0012790834298357368, 0.055825844407081604, 0.019546575844287872, -0.00045790564035996795, 0.024818072095513344, -0.008379805833101273, 0.044382426887750626, -0.03190009668469429, 0.053087834268808365, 0.0008083002176135778, -0.016852224245667458, 0.0030202376656234264, 0.008227587677538395, 0.06487869471311569, -0.026818983256816864, 0.024891158565878868, 0.05452711135149002, 0.04835495725274086, -0.02415735274553299, 0.004717606119811535, 0.0019026673398911953, 0.01229518000036478, 0.002168387407436967, -0.03172621876001358, -0.0022963506635278463, 0.05169149488210678, 0.03676838427782059, -0.006304456386715174, 0.029433652758598328, -0.02543480321764946, -0.001109092845581472, -0.08744212239980698, -0.012447452172636986, 0.008649904280900955, 0.04619136452674866, -0.00915941596031189, 0.08687351644039154, -0.01489123236387968, -0.004263197537511587, 0.018898680806159973, 0.0022950798738747835, -0.06986596435308456, -0.0029143712017685175, -0.02869894728064537, -0.04640127718448639, -0.019472366198897362, -0.02791174128651619, 0.005978462286293507, -0.05433949828147888, -0.018932905048131943, 0.05933376029133797, -0.009309791028499603, -0.005153793375939131, 0.05360430106520653, -0.03001761995255947, -0.05833231285214424, 0.02095119282603264, 0.004617753904312849, 0.006546730175614357, -0.05973955988883972, 0.02560039982199669, 0.04294409602880478, 0.02248901128768921, -0.03398584946990013, -0.02140692248940468, 0.04043738543987274, 0.03354163095355034, 0.024298498407006264, 0.06244605407118797, 0.02541184052824974, -0.012697054073214531, 0.014703278429806232, 0.04135002940893173, 0.03977137804031372, 0.00699631916359067, -0.030003927648067474, -0.035406604409217834, -0.07311075925827026, 0.000918238190934062, -0.017503496259450912, 0.0001446664537070319, -0.03800637647509575, 0.01804209128022194, 0.04381852224469185, 0.018439076840877533, -0.012776673771440983, 0.01729745976626873, 0.07418663799762726, -0.023701954632997513, -0.019040990620851517, -0.04281101003289223, 0.011048286221921444, 0.003867663675919175, -0.00023172952933236957, -0.00497276708483696, 0.0174334067851305, -0.00910205952823162, -0.0002932223433163017, 0.03675366938114166, -0.01944008842110634, -0.03357753902673721, -0.015227559953927994, -0.021633921191096306, 0.007441494148224592, -0.019297517836093903, -0.019791921600699425, -0.0094993207603693, 0.07781203836202621, -0.016394222155213356, 0.011448734439909458, -0.03657890111207962, -0.05792033672332764, 0.017643561586737633, 0.03780443221330643, 0.04077775031328201, -0.07234577089548111, 0.008362933062016964, -0.05685361847281456, -0.003051405306905508, 0.023530956357717514, 0.015446363016963005, 0.0178927443921566, -0.012613007798790932, 0.004285738337785006, -0.018908793106675148, -0.014804410748183727, -0.06860936433076859, 0.04488394781947136, 0.014051076024770737, 0.019374750554561615, -0.01627085544168949, -0.020359011366963387, -0.031245645135641098, 0.03890804946422577, 0.020695460960268974, 0.03488098457455635, -0.07027395814657211, 0.005706511903554201, -0.005154106300324202, 0.014446791261434555, -0.0010075327008962631, -0.06592943519353867, 0.005055516492575407, -0.004139246419072151, -0.00007848967652535066, 0.03275294974446297, 0.019035447388887405, 0.004467471037060022, 0.013452505692839622, -0.0046346066519618034, -0.01757388934493065, 0.00442053796723485, -0.03671559318900108, 0.0738072320818901, 0.02720848098397255, -0.015106952749192715, 0.027441028505563736, 0.02931138500571251, 0.003883187659084797, -0.018478814512491226, -0.044366318732500076, 0.01931753195822239, -0.026780180633068085, -0.04190472885966301, -0.03445834293961525, -0.025009825825691223, -0.039052169770002365, -0.006955004297196865, 0.011781135573983192, 0.03606443852186203, -0.042728353291749954, -0.0344189815223217, -0.025268863886594772, 0.028428051620721817, 0.0069029624573886395, 0.026150373741984367, 0.031658705323934555, 0.004040074069052935, -0.013139716349542141, -0.04805465042591095, 0.010793712921440601, -0.03243289515376091, 0.014143324457108974, 0.028864914551377296, 0.0004871289129368961, 0.02491973154246807, -0.01803462766110897, 0.019293950870633125, 0.00440843915566802, -0.03470775857567787, 0.03728508576750755, -0.007403261959552765, 0.04294939339160919, -0.028664996847510338, -0.03762434050440788, -0.01977926306426525, 0.016991889104247093, -0.041677989065647125, 0.007096488494426012, -0.05155559629201889, 0.07775517553091049, -0.029338229447603226, -0.03527383878827095, -0.06297101080417633, -0.06567146629095078, -0.041688866913318634, -0.00128304457757622, -0.0015516186831519008, -0.0008451894391328096, -0.003611248219385743, -0.007105213589966297, 0.01517373975366354, -0.007831849157810211, 0.02574959583580494, -0.017580479383468628, -0.02381092496216297, -0.03508279100060463, 0.0005673094419762492, 0.05994117632508278, 0.019720112904906273, -0.02027233876287937, 0.030086394399404526, -0.04604791849851608, 0.0032448635902255774, 0.005848556291311979, 0.010110810399055481, -0.039983998984098434, 0.012674067169427872, -0.017622698098421097, 0.008691624738276005, 0.03947969898581505, -0.0011251561809331179, 0.011442686431109905, 0.019308868795633316, 0.013173074461519718, 0.010998157784342766, -0.01360009703785181, -0.021474072709679604, 0.01926138624548912, -0.015213346108794212, -0.0031686818692833185, -0.002976339776068926, 0.007465803530067205, 0.030902128666639328, 0.02417183294892311, 0.011931205168366432, -0.027198176831007004, 0.02400732971727848, 0.10203616321086884, 0.01802201010286808, -0.02858196198940277, 0.0011249707313254476, -0.00040430703666061163, 0.04000850394368172, -0.02839205414056778, -0.014228416606783867, 0.024015437811613083, 0.008890712633728981, -0.0416368804872036, -0.027046985924243927, -0.016391774639487267, -0.005922070238739252, 0.05324691906571388, 0.0012312432518228889, 0.03495778515934944, 0.031807493418455124, -0.0035134160425513983, -0.0008918889798223972, -0.04148618131875992, 0.0026360866613686085, -0.02981736697256565, -0.04186094552278519, 0.07437387853860855, -0.008820880204439163, 0.0005695248255506158, 0.003820151323452592, 0.02175166644155979, -0.002347160829231143, 0.002025978872552514, -0.007290366571396589, -0.004912193864583969, 0.046525437384843826, 0.008616920560598373, -0.029670746996998787, 0.024587882682681084, -0.0344584584236145, -0.008998800069093704, -0.028213243931531906, -0.06506644189357758, 0.05865408852696419, 0.041373781859874725, -0.02382746711373329, -0.05998242273926735, -0.008354807272553444, -0.03648418188095093, -0.0025056309532374144, -0.016269484534859657, 0.027166927233338356, -0.0040187411941587925, -0.01295178197324276, 0.028460422530770302, -0.002311798743903637, 0.019177470356225967, -0.05654344707727432, -0.10571634024381638, -0.008808813989162445, -0.028207629919052124, -0.04562670737504959, 0.014211942441761494, 0.015098433010280132, -0.014214178547263145, 0.0318230502307415, -0.040822651237249374, 0.012730497866868973, -0.006530605256557465, 0.009520720690488815, -0.01060840580612421, 0.02729925699532032, 0.012728375382721424, 0.02130255289375782, -0.025972871109843254, -0.004391186870634556, 0.1067962720990181, 0.09504454582929611, 0.026671040803194046, -0.06840655207633972, 0.0052715749479830265, -0.037491247057914734, 0.0051211160607635975, -0.019736945629119873, 0.013454238884150982, 0.014929019846022129, -0.019544918090105057, 0.05529988184571266, 0.015919556841254234, -0.00479384558275342, -0.01585298590362072, 0.02946452423930168, -0.03918102756142616, -0.03186537325382233, -0.00026835608878172934, 0.008937569335103035, 0.014640828594565392, 0.03028382919728756, -0.04833405464887619, -0.004560018423944712, -0.009813414886593819, -0.021040691062808037, -0.01982683129608631, -0.025910677388310432, 0.026312533766031265, 0.039853036403656006, -0.029043639078736305, 0.021306203678250313, 0.029836369678378105, 0.02199280820786953, -0.00742381252348423, 0.02062375098466873, 0.03634043037891388, -0.030949009582400322, 0.004376010037958622, 0.0377933494746685, 0.00833802204579115, -0.0009648303966969252, 0.004511058796197176, -0.052460890263319016, -0.034937866032123566, -0.0002623776672407985, -0.05581711605191231, 0.004017116967588663, 0.0011147453915327787, 0.005204792134463787, 0.030465474352240562, -0.009334036149084568, 0.015419485978782177, -0.049974534660577774, -0.0071157049387693405, 0.029737578704953194, 0.032558340579271317, 0.02104916237294674, 0.002361443592235446, -0.02369115874171257, 0.02025667391717434, -0.017548786476254463, 0.0028549605049192905, 0.07458638399839401, -0.013674888759851456, 0.025105681270360947, -0.023638200014829636, 0.07114224880933762, 0.04156549647450447, -0.05172431096434593, 0.025881187990307808, -0.03826357424259186, -0.027645250782370567, -0.051747847348451614, -0.00698666088283062, 0.02522255666553974, 0.007708546705543995, -0.005066151265054941, 0.022710103541612625, -0.01311686635017395, -0.022654777392745018, 0.029854556545615196, -0.001794583280570805, -0.0060611567460000515, -0.03650930896401405, -0.0077934423461556435, 0.0496562235057354, 0.021054478362202644, 0.007996813394129276, 0.003026692196726799, -0.011584191583096981, 0.06662021577358246, 0.0028908257372677326, -0.04300530627369881, -0.0209113210439682, -0.006672126241028309, -0.04187830910086632, -0.00737816421315074, -0.023761291056871414, 0.04154646769165993, 0.014817984774708748, 0.04218136519193649, -0.024794310331344604, 0.006950893439352512, -0.0013290573842823505, -0.006819574628025293, 0.007716585416346788, -0.07740972191095352, 0.03901819884777069, 0.01676933281123638, -0.030822159722447395, -0.02322201430797577, -0.022296050563454628, -0.04511144757270813, 0.010561276227235794, -0.022530248388648033, -0.029630960896611214, -0.055631596595048904, -0.0030296265613287687, -0.027925174683332443, 0.022207893431186676, -0.0067648752592504025, -0.01983741857111454, -0.03158765658736229, -0.02467517741024494, 0.02450273558497429, -0.04145277664065361, 0.02177031897008419, 0.0321015827357769, 0.006572025362402201, 0.020492209121584892, 0.029134826734662056, 0.03457007557153702, 0.003649528604000807, -0.02175242267549038, 0.02236700989305973, -0.013428635895252228, 0.08385423570871353, -0.05865982547402382, -0.059508971869945526, 0.03579441457986832, -0.03632444515824318, -0.004844505339860916, 0.03139311447739601, -0.016261480748653412, 0.045305270701646805, 0.005267363041639328, -0.015589727088809013, -0.010388108901679516, 0.06233793869614601, -0.01357569545507431, -0.01208522729575634, -0.004785912577062845, -0.03861404210329056, 0.0033172215335071087, -0.007424476556479931, -0.01677533984184265, 0.0183495432138443, 0.028976013883948326, 0.0213483814150095, 0.034875720739364624, 0.0030754581093788147, 0.012711137533187866, 0.03847276419401169, 0.023047855123877525, 0.016510048881173134, 0.027623992413282394, -0.04072941094636917, -0.027113014832139015, 0.006622119341045618, -0.020582493394613266, 0.04649646580219269, 0.025418907403945923, 0.015044795349240303, -0.09772647172212601, -0.006289476528763771, 0.03829158842563629, -0.010604136623442173, 0.0030225550290197134, -0.05026448518037796, -0.03567579761147499, 0.0038560256361961365, -0.054947156459093094, -0.040852777659893036, -0.008659709244966507, -0.005669044330716133, -0.03311467543244362, 0.036777205765247345, 0.02763591706752777, -0.008239812217652798, 0.05426163598895073, 0.04185480996966362, 0.018279582262039185, 0.007892773486673832, -0.02685544081032276, -0.018384750932455063, -0.02154560573399067, -0.011455656029284, 0.01963604800403118, -0.04081214219331741, 0.030589910224080086, -0.03801833838224411, -0.0057372404262423515, 0.009051351808011532, -0.0013825817732140422, 0.02162044309079647, -0.008912861347198486, 0.03454471752047539, 0.01420311164110899, 0.027179904282093048, 0.013005878776311874, 0.007201885338872671, -0.035214975476264954, -0.043867360800504684, 0.017103174701333046, 0.05165325105190277, -0.0072984532453119755, 0.026229005306959152, -0.029038414359092712, -0.026078956201672554, -0.028473936021327972, 0.023097388446331024, -0.015127111226320267, -0.045629363507032394, 0.010211695916950703, 0.02388346754014492, 0.01634601503610611, -0.014182530343532562, 0.032872941344976425, -0.05979974940419197, 0.005427572876214981, -0.004693621303886175, 0.007690769620239735, -0.006946498993784189, -0.012950608506798744, 0.03649438917636871, -0.0020026364363729954, -0.03209871053695679, 0.01181752048432827, -0.014506565406918526, -0.035060521215200424, -0.0057785166427493095, 0.008265986107289791, 0.013032815419137478, 0.0005000346573069692, -0.025377890095114708, -0.0032944181002676487, 0.00929520558565855, -0.009050136432051659, -0.012118412181735039, 0.03008037805557251, -0.02202022075653076, -0.007016475312411785, -0.04519100859761238, 0.07300499081611633, 0.014359161257743835, -0.01966124214231968, -0.08246855437755585, 0.0025313154328614473, -0.026331525295972824, 0.014522631652653217, 0.0336310938000679, -0.013178431428968906, -0.012703501619398594, -0.005231217946857214, 0.02414548397064209, 0.037940915673971176, -0.02483370527625084, 0.028980743139982224, 0.006728035397827625, 0.004677380435168743, 0.0009577127639204264, -0.0037558339536190033, 0.013086234219372272, 0.012401213869452477, 0.007269067224115133, -0.031883057206869125, -0.028583966195583344, -0.000016377469364670105, -0.041539739817380905, 0.007079587783664465, 0.04766949266195297, -0.019428618252277374, 0.0743715837597847, 0.003549140179529786, 0.013458367437124252, 0.006139661185443401, -0.0008929141913540661, -0.05608198791742325, 0.052542779594659805, -0.011181451380252838, -0.01604379527270794, 0.018186550587415695, -0.006081792991608381, -0.01779838837683201, -0.06136375665664673, -0.008082536980509758, 0.046603523194789886, -0.0300478283315897, -0.026728924363851547, 0.030007651075720787, 0.02034924179315567, 0.02111200802028179, -0.02314559370279312, 0.0068437401205301285, 0.004263324197381735, -0.030671510845422745, 0.015329379588365555, -0.01970498263835907, -0.0043464661575853825, -0.013648621737957, 0.015089004300534725, 0.03578221797943115, 0.002370215719565749, 0.03345771133899689, 0.01857469417154789, 0.04052918031811714, 0.014065590687096119, 0.013696838170289993, 0.00379605102352798, 0.003613817971199751, 0.021818285807967186, 0.015478750690817833, -0.014339126646518707, 0.03250559791922569, -0.03635530173778534, 0.0007774941041134298, -0.05140696465969086, 0.008312307298183441, -0.016033165156841278, -0.04665447771549225, -0.0013719386188313365, -0.04396667703986168, 0.014242575503885746, -0.03859325498342514, -0.01888231188058853, -0.003220170736312866, 0.04237302765250206, -0.06799597293138504, -0.0022560313809663057, -0.018864305689930916, -0.0015531568787992, -0.04491148144006729, -0.001775417709723115, -0.019760720431804657, -0.01837282069027424, 0.024232979863882065, 0.013770506717264652, -0.003742318833246827, -0.0017266025533899665, -0.008414915762841702, -0.019623279571533203, 0.04561550170183182, -0.06371378898620605, -0.03276300057768822, -0.02093253657221794, 0.054830197244882584, 0.022569311782717705, -0.018534863367676735 ]
<p>For example, the lists can be something like: $$\{1.123213, 5.154543, 2.134121, 7.34534, 12.223432, 8.16571, 100.45645, 222.423\}$$ I want to remove $\{100.45645, 222.423\}$.</p> <p>$$\{232.123213, 323.154543, 232.134121, 123.34534, 222.223432, 8545.16571,\\ 4335.45645, 1222.423\}$$ I want to remove $\{8545.16571, 4335.45645, 1222.423\}$.</p> <p>The size is not fixed, and the range may vary. Are there any ways to remove these "abnormally large" values from my lists?</p>
36,666
[ 0.004820670932531357, -0.011041109450161457, 0.02097111940383911, 0.01569414511322975, -0.009081294760107994, 0.0006864801980555058, -0.013617788441479206, -0.03112407773733139, -0.02390061691403389, -0.009962935000658035, 0.06223984807729721, 0.049360524863004684, 0.04794878140091896, 0.026844533160328865, 0.01147522684186697, 0.018166836351156235, -0.019408516585826874, -0.006560976151376963, 0.005792435724288225, -0.04804527759552002, 0.002241759793832898, 0.012782529927790165, 0.03720693662762642, -0.028692929074168205, -0.014056365936994553, 0.020047388970851898, 0.038460925221443176, 0.011567387729883194, 0.0029646686743944883, 0.04180676490068436, -0.0387796051800251, -0.0231084655970335, 0.05088646709918976, 0.001215844415128231, -0.0016244349535554647, 0.007615534123033285, -0.03853805363178253, -0.023342130705714226, -0.01815001852810383, 0.010173014365136623, -0.045224301517009735, -0.017198655754327774, 0.0005440143286250532, 0.018656820058822632, 0.010729562491178513, 0.036322902888059616, -0.026357052847743034, -0.016663530841469765, 0.007215532939881086, -0.031074821949005127, 0.06001818925142288, 0.025382723659276962, 0.020299838855862617, 0.01603328436613083, -0.015645138919353485, -0.0267934650182724, 0.01005721278488636, 0.07022435963153839, -0.04171060770750046, -0.06642570346593857, -0.01628558151423931, -0.017683373764157295, 0.013360712677240372, -0.020715098828077316, -0.027760758996009827, 0.02279762364923954, -0.009815934114158154, -0.0025097387842833996, -0.04034876450896263, 0.0018332907930016518, -0.021712496876716614, -0.007938657887279987, 0.019076114520430565, -0.01851481944322586, 0.028901780024170876, -0.02053774707019329, 0.011481402441859245, 0.022072121500968933, 0.05674953758716583, 0.05465257540345192, -0.004488528240472078, 0.029369914904236794, -0.003368193516507745, -0.020123500376939774, 0.01659693755209446, -0.016576532274484634, 0.05079079419374466, -0.011814450845122337, 0.03795613721013069, 0.019677715376019478, 0.017927633598446846, -0.016015533357858658, 0.04705948010087013, 0.0029838979244232178, -0.01653851754963398, 0.026040051132440567, -0.011948647908866405, 0.034764613956213, -0.013311240822076797, 0.004415823146700859, -0.019771380349993706, -0.05371192842721939, 0.017173342406749725, 0.03931256756186485, -0.03282298892736435, 0.021060844883322716, -0.022203125059604645, 0.00969274714589119, -0.020315637812018394, 0.017766699194908142, -0.02546326257288456, -0.004581165499985218, 0.008424730971455574, -0.004768410697579384, 0.026872146874666214, -0.003693684469908476, -0.00511937914416194, -0.023023955523967743, 0.009586408734321594, 0.07686913758516312, 0.03282202035188675, -0.02455376833677292, 0.06069816276431084, -0.048887621611356735, -0.07603850215673447, 0.013486480340361595, 0.03904959186911583, -0.002440509619191289, -0.05249033868312836, 0.04185109958052635, -0.022537140175700188, -0.029658794403076172, 0.043845321983098984, -0.03618750348687172, 0.07007107138633728, -0.011615270748734474, -0.04497591406106949, -0.027538741007447243, 0.03884677588939667, 0.012409146875143051, -0.010450642555952072, -0.04352516680955887, -0.009691284969449043, 0.018270399421453476, 0.019301926717162132, 0.04169362783432007, -0.001661863410845399, 0.04278596118092537, 0.019433729350566864, -0.002375720301643014, -0.024725105613470078, 0.0067749228328466415, -0.008170883171260357, -0.0416797436773777, -0.0064749387092888355, -0.027964778244495392, 0.04345238581299782, 0.046597037464380264, 0.006410451605916023, -0.003640479175373912, -0.0008773499866947532, -0.01207657065242529, 0.022221924737095833, -0.03439522534608841, 0.016129668802022934, 0.006712865550071001, 0.07633110135793686, 0.03805505856871605, 0.004882136359810829, 0.04089838266372681, 0.005335362162441015, 0.04517888277769089, 0.022539829835295677, 0.0025320276618003845, 0.04742737114429474, -0.005502026993781328, -0.028771674260497093, -0.047441449016332626, 0.008637486957013607, 0.0313950814306736, -0.009657006710767746, -0.01651482842862606, 0.006217911373823881, 0.024983391165733337, 0.04111337289214134, 0.05386560782790184, 0.021923251450061798, -0.0393066368997097, 0.02959437668323517, -0.06217442452907562, 0.002872604178264737, -0.07452981173992157, 0.03401637077331543, 0.020704174414277077, -0.01487707532942295, 0.04569193720817566, -0.005721517372876406, -0.03623408079147339, -0.009527248330414295, 0.0060979509726166725, -0.015082200989127159, 0.011869028210639954, 0.040092021226882935, -0.057850681245326996, -0.023206597194075584, 0.07823417335748672, 0.02845418080687523, -0.028712892904877663, 0.04084598645567894, -0.0426214262843132, -0.01518633496016264, -0.0059992410242557526, -0.04766656085848808, -0.021960048004984856, -0.01818828471004963, -0.03259315341711044, 0.004303550347685814, 0.00044820530456490815, -0.005532688461244106, -0.016690364107489586, -0.019574621692299843, 0.06011347472667694, 0.08559003472328186, 0.020102670416235924, 0.002666901098564267, -0.0030213985592126846, -0.001546202227473259, 0.024563018232584, 0.00016780463920440525, -0.03737760707736015, -0.07833300530910492, -0.008790722116827965, 0.01667186990380287, 0.04280790686607361, -0.03176445513963699, 0.028141075745224953, 0.040718529373407364, 0.03105592168867588, 0.030203942209482193, 0.011349768377840519, -0.03610043600201607, 0.02848423644900322, 0.03276292607188225, 0.0006967279477976263, 0.04497150704264641, -0.016431326046586037, 0.0007514632306993008, 0.016185680404305458, 0.020237166434526443, 0.026877662166953087, 0.004417513031512499, -0.020686475560069084, 0.02963409014046192, -0.004164357669651508, -0.0029774506110697985, -0.02365555614233017, 0.02832646854221821, -0.008951721712946892, -0.008524244651198387, 0.018491875380277634, 0.0015690881991758943, 0.0016329024219885468, -0.032043345272541046, -0.02942741848528385, 0.0017604557797312737, 0.03251517564058304, -0.05120597407221794, -0.017854614183306694, 0.020454084500670433, -0.049827151000499725, -0.004149810876697302, -0.00007344930781982839, -0.016290899366140366, -0.049390777945518494, 0.04203882813453674, 0.045329779386520386, 0.00762801943346858, 0.005289225373417139, -0.030596381053328514, -0.003006870159879327, -0.012788391672074795, -0.03728596493601799, -0.008614719845354557, -0.002908622846007347, -0.01604783721268177, 0.02497733011841774, 0.0062083653174340725, -0.04551888257265091, 0.04467056691646576, -0.00094102683942765, 0.02595820091664791, 0.013600504957139492, -0.009275847114622593, -0.01732446812093258, -0.013248918578028679, -0.05305853113532066, 0.03451669216156006, -0.015247474424540997, 0.00037783506559208035, 0.06432772427797318, 0.01198434829711914, -0.07384587824344635, 0.020663876086473465, -0.04059219732880592, 0.008316528983414173, -0.045438073575496674, -0.030786359682679176, 0.0003038936119992286, 0.005333323497325182, -0.026438383385539055, 0.007969575934112072, -0.00744285061955452, 0.027185309678316116, -0.0797189325094223, -0.02848806604743004, -0.0266941636800766, 0.008772856555879116, 0.04159015044569969, 0.011405754834413528, -0.03927185386419296, 0.06635469943284988, 0.02031468041241169, -0.039252519607543945, -0.016047794371843338, -0.03875564783811569, 0.016365032643079758, -0.012125103734433651, -0.024275466799736023, 0.02957584336400032, 0.006874986924231052, 0.0031011137180030346, 0.05211523175239563, 0.03206431865692139, 0.02396254986524582, 0.031035950407385826, -0.03916264325380325, 0.01201202068477869, -0.015180250629782677, -0.03578995540738106, 0.02477388083934784, -0.0026995877269655466, 0.007496723905205727, 0.001637454959563911, -0.00645989878103137, -0.0006700975936837494, 0.018965087831020355, -0.03187582269310951, 0.0038180022966116667, 0.022530345246195793, 0.02522767335176468, 0.006482633762061596, 0.033908549696207047, 0.020711494609713554, -0.039012350142002106, -0.020701901987195015, 0.03321665897965431, 0.05430635064840317, -0.03456314280629158, 0.04310760274529457, 0.03227408975362778, 0.07330203056335449, -0.0626942366361618, -0.002360867103561759, 0.0034672836773097515, -0.0057655218988657, 0.024829452857375145, -0.01175749208778143, -0.04199664294719696, 0.02010193094611168, 0.020138831809163094, -0.014208905398845673, -0.007814214564859867, -0.021316133439540863, 0.008772511966526508, -0.07773774862289429, -0.0010158997029066086, -0.036201853305101395, 0.07914431393146515, 0.007649464998394251, 0.011097190901637077, 0.028118334710597992, 0.0044034370221197605, 0.008557582274079323, 0.05185997486114502, -0.047553520649671555, 0.024518880993127823, -0.0034101305063813925, -0.005364342126995325, -0.02488061599433422, -0.02823716029524803, 0.045808110386133194, 0.006580312270671129, 0.042689431458711624, -0.02541748620569706, 0.0034409593790769577, -0.059000413864851, -0.005952839739620686, -0.05272609740495682, -0.012246369384229183, -0.017496397718787193, 0.03311563655734062, 0.021160872653126717, -0.06476118415594101, 0.03682619705796242, 0.010857494547963142, -0.04851740971207619, -0.03008735552430153, -0.015424796380102634, 0.03236692398786545, -0.026984507218003273, 0.018599441275000572, 0.015963371843099594, 0.039457663893699646, -0.008526550605893135, 0.008511056192219257, -0.04437928646802902, 0.0633445605635643, 0.013890998438000679, 0.022562973201274872, -0.00872429832816124, -0.04120074585080147, 0.007886487059295177, -0.0008217415888793766, 0.05615631863474846, -0.029066521674394608, 0.008013016544282436, 0.03522954508662224, 0.0003238277859054506, -0.0385160930454731, 0.06968969106674194, 0.06135968491435051, 0.03908473625779152, -0.00275688455440104, -0.005297142546623945, 0.015812451019883156, 0.017242101952433586, -0.020280923694372177, 0.010277947410941124, 0.011108767241239548, 0.008030422031879425, 0.011757233180105686, 0.00797239039093256, 0.009334361180663109, -0.03845861926674843, -0.0026358875911682844, 0.011332939378917217, 0.04143093526363373, -0.046177614480257034, 0.05049552768468857, 0.06287016719579697, -0.012287436984479427, 0.03875012323260307, -0.002234553685411811, 0.019826838746666908, -0.09792916476726532, 0.008293360471725464, 0.05987134948372841, 0.03770462051033974, -0.030176455155014992, 0.01712939515709877, -0.038799948990345, -0.002034176839515567, 0.08759915828704834, -0.03694845363497734, 0.027415698394179344, -0.006619240622967482, 0.018563929945230484, -0.0413818396627903, -0.02958386205136776, -0.01975204609334469, 0.0014228319050744176, -0.045002397149801254, 0.03159429877996445, -0.02004348672926426, -0.020830467343330383, -0.044680532068014145, -0.013460743241012096, 0.00010995352204190567, 0.0672960951924324, 0.01147859264165163, -0.026857921853661537, 0.03487195074558258, -0.012809696607291698, -0.016377931460738182, -0.02615833468735218, 0.004425723571330309, 0.03676772490143776, 0.0157771073281765, 0.06108807027339935, -0.030441192910075188, -0.02348056621849537, 0.02499043010175228, 0.02518734335899353, 0.018626710399985313, 0.00891084037721157, -0.010678035207092762, 0.017089951783418655, 0.04887069761753082, -0.0030982682947069407, 0.026842355728149414, 0.029202379286289215, 0.014331324957311153, 0.0034824407193809748, -0.029639514163136482, 0.015087222680449486, -0.04231401905417442, -0.006372513249516487, -0.07530240714550018, 0.0009484661859460175, -0.0599052794277668, 0.0540088415145874, -0.005875198170542717, -0.005193253513425589, -0.021662037819623947, -0.008387007750570774, -0.010369719937443733, 0.05158689618110657, 0.02978477068245411, 0.002045727800577879, -0.017616378143429756, 0.049232929944992065, -0.051298584789037704, -0.027619559317827225, 0.029490813612937927, -0.003138978034257889, 0.01501459814608097, 0.0038991940673440695, -0.014075406827032566, 0.03625139221549034, -0.048749566078186035, 0.021254681050777435, -0.006067190784960985, -0.013678479008376598, 0.03582108020782471, 0.010533133521676064, 0.02741001732647419, 0.020855437964200974, -0.030252207070589066, -0.002980761229991913, 0.024382419884204865, -0.014077611267566681, -0.013994638808071613, -0.05300286412239075, 0.06591538339853287, -0.004208576865494251, 0.005818984471261501, -0.06869269907474518, -0.05526868253946304, 0.020830443128943443, 0.027754701673984528, -0.021227112039923668, -0.04091032221913338, -0.03408481553196907, -0.022006552666425705, 0.0062413024716079235, -0.03051767311990261, 0.021634088829159737, -0.009321394376456738, -0.014745624735951424, 0.014192117378115654, 0.014393431134521961, 0.0975775197148323, 0.0011957392562180758, 0.02273046411573887, -0.021290238946676254, -0.016551198437809944, -0.020668720826506615, -0.006407393142580986, 0.009829371236264706, -0.02389490231871605, -0.028767209500074387, 0.010994368232786655, -0.03392016887664795, -0.004842678550630808, -0.02628471702337265, -0.011780652217566967, 0.004785011988133192, 0.011154387146234512, 0.009922770783305168, -0.00617099367082119, -0.0158099252730608, -0.035864491015672684, 0.01023772731423378, -0.023823268711566925, 0.010874314233660698, 0.014863063581287861, -0.03851830214262009, 0.018530799075961113, 0.031566113233566284, -0.018835967406630516, -0.012799471616744995, 0.04363337159156799, -0.045316603034734726, 0.03694343566894531, 0.00002166375270462595, -0.03355887159705162, 0.05743908882141113, 0.012494071386754513, -0.033908456563949585, 0.03297106549143791, -0.004085280001163483, -0.0423879474401474, -0.056587401777505875, -0.05585186555981636, -0.017782220616936684, 0.010238132439553738, -0.013917979784309864, 0.04082408919930458, 0.04056756570935249, 0.015624981373548508, 0.03061937354505062, -0.023310016840696335, -0.01055952813476324, -0.011641373857855797, 0.012421739287674427, 0.01754518784582615, -0.003545081242918968, 0.022081872448325157, 0.04194861650466919, -0.007108743768185377, 0.02473626472055912, -0.003997212275862694, -0.007392349187284708, 0.041945796459913254, 0.02095368131995201, -0.04906696826219559, -0.014698739163577557, -0.011612605303525925, -0.0693952664732933, -0.0049780202098190784, 0.015828367322683334, -0.024015942588448524, 0.02805645763874054, 0.05552348122000694, 0.0004588992160279304, -0.007776268292218447, -0.028148280456662178, -0.04709571972489357, -0.013696222566068172, 0.015565291047096252, -0.02233790047466755, 0.008802195079624653, -0.013566255569458008, 0.01570582017302513, 0.008393569849431515, 0.007881264202296734, -0.022986022755503654, -0.05305417254567146, -0.043815404176712036, -0.03976012393832207, -0.06245050206780434, 0.0259668231010437, -0.01637899875640869, -0.014519765041768551, 0.03606324642896652, -0.03443509712815285, 0.017850592732429504, 0.018141809850931168, 0.02050420083105564, -0.016258563846349716, 0.04038313776254654, -0.0030252933502197266, -0.0036275710444897413, -0.002042420208454132, 0.011675473302602768, 0.11716138571500778, 0.09182158857584, 0.026852574199438095, -0.07806338369846344, -0.004449453204870224, 0.0075909350998699665, -0.030566399917006493, -0.030852913856506348, -0.015153281390666962, -0.008682564832270145, 0.028550509363412857, 0.03114437311887741, 0.04946877062320709, -0.009398219175636768, 0.0386548712849617, 0.058516208082437515, -0.048377811908721924, 0.007053959183394909, 0.0472031906247139, 0.02056569792330265, -0.02896212413907051, 0.028231607750058174, -0.09134943783283234, 0.01985035091638565, -0.005781651008874178, 0.00012602699280250818, -0.06742165237665176, -0.033284228295087814, 0.00685185007750988, 0.03625553846359253, 0.008799604140222073, -0.0011321858037263155, 0.017288153991103172, -0.022242069244384766, -0.017048489302396774, 0.02926003187894821, 0.005293556489050388, -0.015208927914500237, -0.013332512229681015, 0.06434906274080276, 0.014609421603381634, 0.0035514039918780327, 0.008784018456935883, 0.029263053089380264, -0.034879330545663834, -0.04312113672494888, -0.019368788227438927, 0.028928242623806, -0.045003779232501984, 0.00691670086234808, -0.0078809829428792, 0.008565414696931839, -0.0032995110377669334, -0.06781929731369019, 0.008652209304273129, 0.008933527395129204, 0.01738760806620121, 0.00045806472189724445, 0.024065840989351273, -0.01593802310526371, 0.014560889452695847, -0.02367684803903103, 0.005114695522934198, -0.0015322454273700714, -0.06853699684143066, -0.011549904011189938, 0.011012447066605091, 0.013295438140630722, 0.011501246131956577, 0.027575217187404633, -0.02960299141705036, -0.010581188835203648, -0.00712871178984642, -0.006431885063648224, 0.003016130765900016, 0.025260059162974358, 0.03705473244190216, -0.0041498662903904915, 0.0020541271660476923, -0.029192708432674408, -0.06145932525396347, 0.03864999860525131, -0.05063996836543083, -0.022461969405412674, -0.032393526285886765, -0.050672389566898346, -0.022883770987391472, 0.02253110706806183, 0.06016680225729942, -0.01688576303422451, -0.038332123309373856, 0.06576864421367645, 0.008020971901714802, -0.029490988701581955, -0.020109564065933228, 0.0014236874412745237, -0.03864666447043419, 0.06381714344024658, 0.026630086824297905, 0.06987585872411728, 0.04021156206727028, -0.020445721223950386, 0.008878235705196857, 0.05111923813819885, 0.003063580486923456, -0.002128664869815111, 0.0025647690054029226, -0.03542632609605789, 0.004895045887678862, 0.028220320120453835, -0.03594579920172691, -0.042187776416540146, -0.002044487511739135, -0.030887292698025703, -0.02554742805659771, 0.04693373292684555, 0.037284523248672485, -0.017949344590306282, 0.022613264620304108, -0.03502653166651726, -0.035344198346138, -0.03317858278751373, -0.03859827667474747, -0.055969078093767166, -0.030593223869800568, 0.002442494034767151, 0.026596322655677795, -0.03514894098043442, -0.009248582646250725, -0.03367552161216736, -0.026779333129525185, 0.04029485210776329, 0.011695203371345997, -0.007095230743288994, 0.028686726465821266, 0.0006120369653217494, 0.01426913682371378, 0.047481514513492584, -0.035520654171705246, -0.025045625865459442, 0.04945242777466774, -0.026336323469877243, -0.013830384239554405, -0.019783547148108482, -0.002265641000121832, 0.04483142867684364, 0.043542757630348206, -0.0012940013548359275, -0.035677578300237656, 0.06704334914684296, -0.007497090846300125, -0.002236629370599985, -0.010571101680397987, 0.016270775347948074, -0.002117716707289219, 0.005984671413898468, -0.016947835683822632, -0.04820530116558075, 0.0010123869869858027, -0.006022574845701456, 0.04588551074266434, 0.011896161362528801, 0.0015840192791074514, 0.026598792523145676, 0.021826276555657387, 0.011431093327701092, -0.01777982898056507, 0.013299313373863697, 0.026901675388216972, 0.03391891345381737, -0.04131689667701721, 0.023896804079413414, -0.0005920948460698128, 0.004488782491534948, -0.09760120511054993, 0.006449523847550154, 0.007453973405063152, -0.03482221066951752, 0.014455024152994156, -0.0376129150390625, 0.014414369128644466, 0.027050012722611427, -0.02472669444978237, 0.02066309191286564, -0.08752983808517456, 0.03050318732857704, -0.019972415640950203, -0.003049096092581749, -0.04709511250257492, 0.02822994999587536, 0.04068714752793312, 0.05704103037714958, 0.03765102103352547, -0.00439070351421833, -0.0008857083739712834, -0.029641754925251007, 0.029616007581353188, 0.008772565983235836, -0.02055138722062111, -0.04068352282047272, 0.009876069612801075, -0.03148050606250763, 0.0087581817060709, 0.035924170166254044, -0.023560838773846626, -0.03945476561784744, -0.024546759203076363, 0.021138738840818405, 0.002515486441552639, 0.0696653425693512, 0.027665184810757637, 0.04077977314591408, -0.05150797963142395, -0.022839322686195374, -0.0455375500023365, -0.0004953329917043447, -0.009304150007665157, 0.02675158716738224, 0.026358893141150475, -0.03274015709757805, 0.0016135595506057143, 0.04801720008254051, -0.02377159707248211, 0.016780024394392967, 0.01479957066476345, 0.023307114839553833, 0.006606664974242449, -0.0451461486518383, 0.007630529813468456, 0.023352397605776787, 0.003313829656690359, 0.02541559562087059, -0.01958991214632988, -0.004570269491523504, 0.03432418778538704, 0.004001876339316368, -0.052244871854782104, -0.01061034481972456, 0.03182394802570343, 0.006354297045618296, -0.08755265176296234, -0.007904639467597008, -0.011059156619012356, -0.015278982929885387, -0.021718844771385193, -0.008882966823875904, -0.07827194035053253, 0.03970085456967354, -0.021467329934239388, 0.017612343654036522, -0.03176282346248627, 0.009269909001886845, -0.0012179601471871138, -0.05693496763706207, 0.00961789395660162, 0.0034316680394113064, 0.01979188621044159, -0.026766518130898476, -0.013822286389768124, 0.01689673215150833, 0.06396935135126114, 0.026130197569727898, -0.002665316453203559, -0.020808201283216476, -0.020802052691578865, 0.018092364072799683, 0.030339963734149933, -0.04986569657921791, 0.02849154733121395, 0.018549401313066483, -0.00808415561914444, 0.017670990899205208, -0.011452843435108662, 0.031026367098093033, 0.014870645478367805, 0.013335511088371277, 0.025023529306054115, -0.030754998326301575, 0.017535747960209846, -0.04813092574477196, 0.03945918008685112, 0.016665419563651085, 0.02802133560180664, 0.05389747396111488, 0.005228538066148758, 0.03150685131549835, 0.036873746663331985, -0.005445441231131554, -0.046873580664396286, 0.03650693595409393, -0.07998128980398178, -0.02016981691122055, -0.01297749113291502, 0.022207384929060936, 0.0013710306957364082, -0.01666257344186306, 0.04013403132557869, 0.01175269577652216, -0.03231195732951164, -0.014920847490429878, 0.02872590720653534, 0.0015410053310915828, 0.04860987141728401, 0.006454496644437313, 0.03666869178414345, 0.015787377953529358, -0.03908221796154976, 0.025180025026202202, 0.0369189977645874, -0.018887650221586227, -0.008781787008047104, 0.02027234062552452, 0.013577794656157494, 0.02696012146770954, 0.026904871687293053, 0.04561285302042961, 0.05232058838009834, -0.016513410955667496, -0.03897315636277199, -0.0010428928071632981, -0.015395253896713257, 0.0026322791818529367, -0.013103888370096684, -0.013096253387629986, 0.05287530645728111, -0.006946643814444542, -0.003921932075172663, -0.0570550337433815, -0.02313828282058239, -0.009138306602835655, 0.011384060606360435, -0.01806899718940258, -0.005030915141105652, -0.016089817509055138, -0.006136130541563034, 0.015069073997437954, 0.04469094052910805, -0.015164811164140701, -0.00002239570858364459, 0.013203415088355541, 0.0042879595421254635, 0.008024431765079498, 0.0019462225027382374, -0.03027242049574852, -0.011828827671706676, -0.003844523336738348, 0.022872917354106903, 0.04591778293251991, 0.02092059515416622, 0.013244947418570518, -0.003014456946402788, -0.021297818049788475, -0.00044689010246656835, -0.0699404925107956, -0.012631828896701336, -0.02668769657611847, 0.004024216905236244, 0.00505191832780838, -0.0161988977342844 ]
<p>Let's say that I have a picture like the one in figure. This look like an histogram, but actually is not, in the sense that I did not produce the figure starting from a dataset of values. In fact, I only have the probability (the y axis) for each bar. I also have the center point of each bin, and the bin width of each bin. Notice that the graph is normalized such that the area under the bins is equal to one. </p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/CQWGd.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>What I want to do now, is to calculate the reciprocal of this probabilities. Usually I would use this formula: </p> <p>$g(y) = \frac{ 1 }{ y^2 } f\left( \frac{ 1 }{ y } \right) $</p> <p>But I cannot do that now, since I do not want to assume any f(x). Having an histogram, I would just plot the (1./dataset) to get the reciprocal (in histogram form), and then I would normalize (assuming that the original dataset was not already normalized like the one in the example), so to have a good approximation of the rate distribution. However, in this case, I don't have the dataset. I only have the y points (the p(x), actually) and the x (bin center for each bin).</p> <p>I have been adviced to use the following formula (in MATLAB): plot(1./x, y) And this will give me a function with the same shape as the reciprocal function, but not normalized. I <em>think</em> I could take this result and normalize it, and that should work fine. However, I wonder if there is another method that uses only the x and the p(x) in order to get the reciprocal values.</p> <p>Thank you. </p>
74,041
[ -0.03002362698316574, 0.003188379341736436, 0.052342403680086136, 0.007847020402550697, 0.03235520422458649, -0.01341480202972889, -0.031087126582860947, 0.009128204546868801, 0.012130025774240494, -0.005667961668223143, 0.02471451461315155, 0.03664394095540047, 0.06373250484466553, 0.06971822679042816, 0.022978482767939568, -0.00688835559412837, -0.017528200522065163, 0.0032580136321485043, -0.03230642154812813, -0.045090753585100174, 0.03080315887928009, 0.008861218579113483, 0.021014247089624405, -0.0037652121391147375, -0.016026007011532784, 0.034341733902692795, 0.0020428956486284733, -0.020977267995476723, 0.019050944596529007, 0.1047079935669899, -0.05205042287707329, -0.04654253274202347, 0.036016277968883514, 0.03736557066440582, 0.04522639885544777, 0.012099332176148891, -0.044443488121032715, -0.03752921521663666, -0.019346820190548897, 0.0035985689610242844, -0.005850812420248985, 0.01322993729263544, 0.04028197377920151, 0.04334179311990738, -0.0027629798278212547, 0.006451274733990431, 0.015702277421951294, -0.044520024210214615, 0.05905098468065262, -0.057376883924007416, 0.08131713420152664, 0.0058720046654343605, 0.04808899015188217, 0.0354527123272419, -0.012486941181123257, 0.0028403231408447027, 0.04714345559477806, 0.08270702511072159, 0.0018761848332360387, -0.05742625892162323, 0.008809712715446949, -0.03371002525091171, -0.02310335449874401, -0.021132078021764755, -0.010170063003897667, 0.008753196336328983, -0.02016911655664444, -0.05221499130129814, 0.03208779916167259, -0.027122246101498604, 0.026958858594298363, 0.0415666289627552, 0.0536002553999424, -0.05768171325325966, 0.02298751100897789, -0.012569316662847996, 0.03205874562263489, 0.005664804019033909, 0.028680263087153435, 0.03029586374759674, -0.027155177667737007, 0.020456966012716293, 0.017737137153744698, 0.023707641288638115, 0.02618497610092163, -0.008940890431404114, 0.07521791011095047, -0.006516873370856047, 0.03347856178879738, 0.030318185687065125, -0.028264576569199562, 0.00007729534263489768, 0.0531885139644146, -0.014404783956706524, -0.0657435953617096, 0.051830608397722244, 0.00037086507654748857, 0.02972780354321003, 0.011096920818090439, -0.05615580826997757, -0.020502643659710884, -0.045079607516527176, -0.015245208516716957, 0.029636304825544357, -0.004982168320566416, -0.00045157375279814005, -0.0363929308950901, -0.024897702038288116, -0.006714468821883202, -0.014342337846755981, -0.021865420043468475, 0.010679829865694046, 0.026505552232265472, 0.00744594307616353, 0.03438040241599083, 0.006618409883230925, -0.030521763488650322, 0.018800070509314537, 0.07371528446674347, 0.04092845693230629, 0.046987876296043396, -0.019553374499082565, 0.016164148226380348, 0.016196217387914658, -0.03072049655020237, 0.02132515236735344, 0.021310994401574135, 0.006330504082143307, -0.027464035898447037, 0.06028694659471512, -0.008911523036658764, -0.04792097955942154, 0.06863228976726532, 0.013722141273319721, 0.048135943710803986, -0.016688823699951172, -0.06244708225131035, -0.04607308655977249, 0.0040918635204434395, -0.007359552197158337, 0.007338023744523525, -0.03855343163013458, -0.014903298579156399, 0.06251466274261475, 0.039314135909080505, 0.019689807668328285, 0.017805537208914757, -0.03412242606282234, 0.0389396958053112, 0.04437148943543434, 0.000026938316295854747, -0.0022705686278641224, -0.019580043852329254, -0.03639209270477295, -0.03516155481338501, -0.045230284333229065, 0.012011323124170303, 0.004675193224102259, -0.012504266574978828, -0.0192746352404356, 0.072614885866642, -0.02381156198680401, -0.02065630815923214, -0.011635461822152138, -0.03909123316407204, -0.02654035948216915, 0.1025405079126358, -0.010877616703510284, -0.004613271914422512, -0.004407597240060568, -0.016135113313794136, -0.006501257419586182, 0.0025718528777360916, -0.0045811510644853115, 0.06852628290653229, -0.033064261078834534, -0.008171834982931614, -0.024533338844776154, 0.04464147612452507, 0.022010058164596558, 0.021530168130993843, -0.027651775628328323, -0.015554971992969513, -0.0024828724563121796, 0.055490437895059586, 0.04461418464779854, 0.01792890764772892, -0.04827268049120903, 0.04595484584569931, -0.04459776729345322, -0.027038875967264175, -0.03959701582789421, 0.02649548277258873, -0.015969332307577133, -0.016749463975429535, -0.010669349692761898, 0.02294924110174179, 0.0019797380082309246, 0.043578822165727615, -0.021934781223535538, -0.014663377776741982, -0.02314635179936886, 0.045035965740680695, -0.028270753100514412, -0.012916324660182, 0.05160406976938248, 0.03858115151524544, -0.005257854703813791, 0.045080363750457764, -0.04850201681256294, -0.019906165078282356, 0.015754884108901024, -0.054082658141851425, 0.020223384723067284, -0.009041449055075645, -0.037397634238004684, -0.033515725284814835, -0.012852326035499573, -0.023662418127059937, 0.001983217429369688, -0.024114390835165977, 0.052806396037340164, 0.06278670579195023, -0.008952665142714977, -0.010932411067187786, -0.011304306797683239, 0.032045260071754456, 0.022259095683693886, -0.012374275363981724, -0.03336639702320099, -0.052586764097213745, 0.03792149946093559, 0.04933784902095795, 0.014105189591646194, -0.022397957742214203, -0.007665784563869238, 0.06659930944442749, -0.006953727919608355, 0.01452956348657608, 0.028038926422595978, -0.0005441269022412598, -0.004917773883789778, 0.00826015044003725, 0.05574820190668106, 0.03533300757408142, -0.01609852723777294, 0.010768149979412556, 0.005478873383253813, 0.028654174879193306, 0.0210659708827734, -0.02255602553486824, 0.00945337861776352, -0.003309693420305848, 0.008951803669333458, -0.022502465173602104, -0.0011348309926688671, 0.017910540103912354, -0.010003315284848213, -0.021217772737145424, 0.04095301404595375, -0.007185615133494139, 0.00005864403647137806, 0.03484254330396652, -0.015343397855758667, 0.03046588785946369, 0.039326488971710205, -0.04562994837760925, -0.007273939438164234, 0.02194891683757305, -0.033211223781108856, 0.007058598566800356, -0.01576513797044754, -0.03124394454061985, -0.03311280906200409, -0.01610170677304268, 0.01802041567862034, 0.05363382771611214, -0.007174593396484852, -0.017785800620913506, -0.03276856616139412, 0.024717412889003754, -0.003238468896597624, 0.007291177287697792, -0.010394725948572159, -0.029992137104272842, -0.00026863120729103684, -0.001394389197230339, -0.0051323543302714825, -0.04215798154473305, 0.013906382955610752, -0.029835794121026993, -0.022511528804898262, -0.008013150654733181, -0.03397923707962036, -0.0071718040853738785, -0.03419315814971924, 0.024731528013944626, -0.023288605734705925, -0.019262613728642464, 0.05127987265586853, -0.008654739707708359, -0.039955247193574905, 0.020307814702391624, -0.02993256039917469, -0.033312637358903885, -0.067779041826725, 0.02205241657793522, 0.06456845253705978, 0.03560199216008186, 0.006383971776813269, 0.006527099292725325, -0.033849433064460754, -0.014322292059659958, -0.05012877658009529, -0.049121636897325516, -0.00548178656026721, 0.005633171647787094, -0.009675446897745132, 0.029913702979683876, -0.025502068921923637, 0.04844534397125244, 0.053222741931676865, -0.015596935525536537, -0.031109383329749107, 0.002551718382164836, -0.021250955760478973, -0.001081604976207018, 0.0001429165859008208, -0.026157360523939133, -0.009321767836809158, -0.0005205412744544446, -0.023444868624210358, 0.016528749838471413, 0.06725488603115082, 0.015119637362658978, -0.0010158242657780647, 0.02758404053747654, -0.007211217191070318, -0.0048915366642177105, 0.05723940581083298, 0.04033338651061058, 0.005258341785520315, 0.029009543359279633, -0.0005996141699142754, 0.01687847264111042, 0.023544158786535263, -0.07050254195928574, -0.016529159620404243, -0.002476852387189865, 0.007384621072560549, -0.020172975957393646, 0.008421093225479126, 0.0212465301156044, -0.04274991527199745, 0.021024653688073158, 0.02709473855793476, 0.04432934522628784, 0.0006503236945718527, 0.010892453603446484, 0.008317606523633003, 0.03733448311686516, 0.0010482333600521088, -0.03041832335293293, -0.003364233998581767, -0.03365982696413994, 0.019213993102312088, -0.025501852855086327, 0.016849437728524208, 0.035520195960998535, 0.03496600314974785, 0.03234006464481354, -0.011530864983797073, -0.04198099300265312, 0.012117377482354641, -0.04839766398072243, -0.005485870409756899, -0.02405327744781971, 0.03922642394900322, 0.026013532653450966, 0.05226476863026619, 0.005090686026960611, -0.008063259534537792, 0.01567211002111435, 0.010854925960302353, -0.09219427406787872, 0.046121057122945786, 0.018266038969159126, 0.019525296986103058, -0.0078737186267972, -0.01047162152826786, 0.03524329513311386, -0.03317553177475929, -0.015362326987087727, 0.0002526250609662384, -0.009355154819786549, -0.04160938784480095, -0.029997307807207108, -0.0038335134740918875, -0.011105004698038101, -0.02432798407971859, 0.01008843258023262, -0.005496916361153126, -0.010671605356037617, 0.017173314467072487, 0.04018034413456917, 0.015576486475765705, -0.00012702180538326502, -0.028889520093798637, 0.016196072101593018, 0.031237250193953514, 0.04320115968585014, 0.016775351017713547, 0.030498893931508064, -0.025405386462807655, 0.009203293360769749, 0.012810466811060905, 0.06103327497839928, 0.0342601016163826, -0.008633177727460861, -0.00003494378688628785, -0.033761825412511826, -0.003558554919436574, -0.014060269109904766, 0.014240083284676075, -0.035037316381931305, 0.009258804842829704, 0.044547729194164276, 0.026826199144124985, -0.0216885507106781, 0.016304370015859604, 0.0752202719449997, -0.0173573549836874, -0.021360475569963455, -0.0263195987790823, -0.006482149474322796, -0.0057583339512348175, -0.01875213347375393, 0.005603621248155832, 0.029871298000216484, -0.0013420532923191786, 0.009432724677026272, 0.06331007182598114, 0.03898170217871666, 0.041362714022397995, -0.025987409055233, -0.008674790151417255, 0.05051098391413689, 0.008941574022173882, -0.046997521072626114, 0.006648910231888294, 0.007093437481671572, 0.05533299967646599, -0.0003778497048188001, -0.05068667605519295, -0.07882852852344513, 0.016252703964710236, 0.023511815816164017, 0.03820809721946716, -0.0023409121204167604, -0.002013126388192177, -0.014856601133942604, -0.04952329397201538, 0.05216694995760918, -0.03998254984617233, 0.005948839709162712, -0.02169499173760414, 0.01913551613688469, 0.012455250136554241, -0.021006934344768524, -0.07144897431135178, 0.001292831264436245, -0.036155205219984055, 0.001396787236444652, -0.03551589325070381, -0.010073469020426273, -0.06772124767303467, 0.004240179900079966, -0.004235008265823126, 0.07183364033699036, -0.006551010068506002, -0.03321054205298424, 0.002620941260829568, 0.005368612240999937, -0.021681010723114014, -0.07423538714647293, 0.00871572270989418, -0.01351709384471178, 0.004484113305807114, 0.05541331321001053, 0.01016378402709961, -0.04258275032043457, 0.04357611760497093, 0.0021859456319361925, -0.029209258034825325, 0.017694754526019096, -0.029727457091212273, 0.00879410095512867, 0.04416920617222786, 0.06593680381774902, 0.035890378057956696, 0.07772321999073029, 0.019949542358517647, -0.027355894446372986, -0.02646285854279995, 0.010363169945776463, -0.008951257914304733, -0.028632497414946556, -0.035283565521240234, 0.027556903660297394, -0.02035035751760006, -0.012511606328189373, -0.01983453519642353, 0.02359381504356861, -0.05088372901082039, -0.026176920160651207, 0.018089668825268745, 0.021879971027374268, -0.027162378653883934, 0.025651443749666214, 0.004634693264961243, 0.024937499314546585, -0.022724665701389313, 0.0071011693216860294, -0.016375377774238586, -0.010228101164102554, -0.0203708466142416, 0.01609816402196884, -0.02420947514474392, 0.008624215610325336, -0.042366091161966324, -0.007643919438123703, -0.015368003398180008, -0.0597732737660408, 0.026268329471349716, -0.014488745480775833, 0.04487358406186104, 0.03149653598666191, -0.040386125445365906, 0.0043446761555969715, 0.0045869844034314156, 0.0022556507028639317, 0.04349827021360397, -0.0629359558224678, 0.022321609780192375, -0.03930014744400978, 0.009946505539119244, -0.07388381659984589, -0.05860484391450882, -0.000763643707614392, 0.01081206277012825, -0.03934231027960777, -0.05250608175992966, -0.020863668993115425, -0.007434581406414509, -0.00617403257638216, -0.00881845410913229, 0.021607881411910057, -0.007565590087324381, 0.0068848636001348495, -0.006068453658372164, -0.03285365551710129, 0.07421126216650009, -0.022792458534240723, -0.011624246835708618, 0.03736100345849991, 0.009698038920760155, -0.04046569764614105, 0.006083748769015074, 0.00971502996981144, -0.03133745864033699, -0.002270020777359605, -0.016592003405094147, -0.006112975999712944, 0.03709883242845535, -0.02237122878432274, -0.009533748961985111, -0.00716801080852747, 0.023063672706484795, 0.005350308958441019, 0.0005250434624031186, -0.016995983198285103, -0.0122750299051404, -0.0019757079426199198, -0.022905688732862473, -0.022257480770349503, -0.06499078124761581, 0.021160922944545746, 0.027934351935982704, 0.029753269627690315, -0.009299813769757748, 0.019925760105252266, 0.09702248126268387, -0.014096814207732677, -0.0017014134209603071, -0.03156665712594986, -0.032874781638383865, 0.0424756221473217, 0.00032229552743956447, 0.01680591143667698, 0.010179554112255573, 0.002600316423922777, 0.009730726480484009, 0.012081828899681568, -0.06416759639978409, -0.0205696914345026, 0.050632718950510025, -0.028678318485617638, 0.05365500599145889, 0.006958083249628544, 0.012845377437770367, 0.030144307762384415, -0.003935324028134346, -0.03894535452127457, -0.005274886731058359, 0.018117409199476242, 0.04414336383342743, -0.016053665429353714, -0.02575436420738697, 0.012546840123832226, 0.01760650984942913, -0.004758706782013178, 0.049020424485206604, -0.024487677961587906, -0.0013987604761496186, 0.04670890048146248, 0.014388877898454666, -0.012850569561123848, 0.015704117715358734, 0.0016519686905667186, 0.049078065901994705, -0.01758023351430893, -0.061475250869989395, 0.05793194845318794, 0.0374927818775177, -0.0005594161339104176, -0.039930347353219986, -0.032642096281051636, -0.027883389964699745, 0.020117182284593582, 0.015438576228916645, 0.003052404150366783, 0.009428594261407852, -0.0043547628447413445, -0.014385996386408806, -0.010835942812263966, 0.0227354746311903, -0.014797878451645374, -0.053432587534189224, -0.016842931509017944, -0.05185295641422272, -0.05407542735338211, 0.01648705080151558, 0.0240505151450634, -0.03603842109441757, 0.006357178557664156, -0.024981245398521423, 0.03005995973944664, -0.021084502339363098, 0.012745634652674198, 0.025180082768201828, 0.09286972135305405, 0.008763108402490616, 0.0049160197377204895, 0.026652948930859566, -0.0059594702906906605, 0.11317356675863266, 0.04412305727601051, 0.03291235491633415, -0.07330203801393509, -0.013423340395092964, -0.032073210924863815, -0.007849198766052723, -0.007888752967119217, 0.019975604489445686, 0.03713875636458397, 0.009654481895267963, 0.039425384253263474, 0.04716348275542259, -0.023577021434903145, 0.025904478505253792, 0.0648534744977951, -0.015147224999964237, -0.00047396268928423524, 0.016804100945591927, 0.016301441937685013, -0.006120265461504459, 0.017451167106628418, -0.07418648153543472, -0.011524192057549953, 0.01003962755203247, 0.00963988620787859, -0.05109129846096039, -0.0413544625043869, 0.006115789525210857, 0.008874306455254555, -0.016360390931367874, -0.0013199413660913706, 0.04057246819138527, -0.010366293601691723, 0.011892232112586498, -0.03778607398271561, 0.058343060314655304, -0.02279667556285858, -0.003173604840412736, 0.04749657213687897, -0.0004784906923305243, 0.025411419570446014, 0.01931941509246826, -0.017510268837213516, -0.03116290457546711, -0.02531293034553528, -0.034285273402929306, 0.03394462913274765, -0.012572424486279488, 0.006029912736266851, 0.019310543313622475, 0.01877865567803383, 0.007557241711765528, -0.04203840717673302, -0.003402035217732191, 0.004675878211855888, -0.010423028841614723, 0.011303909122943878, 0.0045875427313148975, -0.027271049097180367, 0.020529724657535553, -0.005796124693006277, 0.04974159598350525, -0.02149795927107334, -0.007678569760173559, -0.024030478671193123, -0.019358279183506966, 0.052534401416778564, -0.020109187811613083, -0.060080643743276596, -0.0070580895990133286, -0.03602266684174538, 0.013416266068816185, 0.002910271054133773, 0.019166601821780205, -0.018236063420772552, 0.03858252987265587, 0.017068253830075264, -0.009189103730022907, 0.015687746927142143, -0.04105819761753082, 0.02647538110613823, 0.006258517969399691, 0.002279761014506221, -0.01372453011572361, -0.011280211620032787, 0.009965570643544197, 0.04575913026928902, -0.020320888608694077, -0.007265768479555845, -0.007008975837379694, 0.03955710679292679, 0.03416386991739273, -0.045255713164806366, -0.052171897143125534, 0.02545798569917679, -0.024360228329896927, 0.016035517677664757, -0.03462596237659454, 0.08152637630701065, -0.006669909227639437, 0.03993314877152443, -0.007033291272819042, -0.0041703153401613235, -0.00864575244486332, 0.04422985389828682, -0.034407902508974075, -0.0483071431517601, 0.00922657735645771, -0.012757007963955402, -0.004289175383746624, -0.04031548276543617, 0.0024789224844425917, -0.00185426976531744, -0.016162680462002754, 0.0011921729892492294, 0.018287137150764465, -0.030534863471984863, -0.010082717053592205, -0.012270434759557247, -0.0016242058482021093, -0.0033092121593654156, -0.022098001092672348, -0.04500260949134827, -0.032648682594299316, -0.008145509287714958, 0.006450760178267956, -0.008642208762466908, 0.0019099212950095534, 0.009517990984022617, 0.020517632365226746, 0.03412561118602753, 0.052100565284490585, 0.03624866157770157, 0.0074606360867619514, 0.017454273998737335, 0.03134317323565483, 0.057433146983385086, -0.03347570449113846, 0.016356389969587326, 0.04411746934056282, -0.04509606212377548, -0.0028817441780120134, 0.00213252124376595, 0.017161957919597626, 0.01838570088148117, -0.010263917036354542, -0.014664504677057266, -0.03470173105597496, 0.023479215800762177, -0.006138120777904987, -0.016166850924491882, -0.00674098078161478, 0.010117826983332634, 0.018500126898288727, 0.04346799850463867, 0.006289110518991947, 0.00740865059196949, -0.011021796613931656, 0.03155932202935219, 0.03379819169640541, -0.020184943452477455, 0.021546833217144012, 0.01270274631679058, -0.027104143053293228, 0.007390505634248257, -0.022877167910337448, -0.02428990602493286, 0.06532885879278183, 0.030890801921486855, -0.03297751396894455, 0.010174970142543316, -0.030761243775486946, 0.00438700383529067, -0.1015620082616806, -0.00943533144891262, 0.00942588783800602, -0.008159559220075607, 0.01791771873831749, -0.06781955808401108, 0.008168037980794907, 0.009526563808321953, -0.0416429378092289, 0.00802787858992815, -0.0007477326435036957, -0.05696960538625717, -0.03242875263094902, 0.016452915966510773, -0.0025987408589571714, 0.03413518890738487, 0.02284093387424946, 0.0582134984433651, 0.05492179095745087, -0.007543005980551243, 0.004938895348459482, -0.02326926775276661, -0.01134673785418272, -0.019835105165839195, 0.022567231208086014, -0.05278709530830383, 0.040433596819639206, -0.04878130927681923, -0.04742211848497391, 0.03335144743323326, -0.03747657313942909, -0.009349885396659374, 0.010868038050830364, 0.008683248423039913, -0.01664523035287857, 0.05848417058587074, 0.029111260548233986, -0.028576696291565895, 0.01065109670162201, -0.009145118296146393, 0.06222933903336525, 0.01270299218595028, -0.042337074875831604, 0.013582530431449413, 0.06366429477930069, -0.00590953603386879, -0.024282120168209076, 0.019899914041161537, -0.03070252016186714, -0.05774861201643944, -0.00578374182805419, -0.020682403817772865, 0.016275446861982346, -0.015014994889497757, 0.03643186762928963, -0.044444490224123, 0.018230486661195755, 0.02355167083442211, -0.011711337603628635, 0.013650876469910145, 0.006459001451730728, -0.011623748578131199, -0.07031205296516418, -0.006601171102374792, 0.011774027720093727, -0.031920865178108215, -0.0187520869076252, -0.016314031556248665, 0.025821268558502197, -0.008244283497333527, 0.018675547093153, -0.03013249672949314, 0.002715993905439973, 0.016634978353977203, -0.030281327664852142, 0.00348891643807292, 0.03127181902527809, -0.005945699289441109, 0.009900922887027264, -0.09836852550506592, 0.015797074884176254, -0.0033171435352414846, -0.04590070992708206, -0.028658922761678696, -0.011222894303500652, -0.054540809243917465, -0.0013182592811062932, 0.08069374412298203, 0.01540212333202362, 0.021077632904052734, -0.04009326919913292, 0.0032719988375902176, 0.00957996305078268, -0.06708674132823944, -0.009928081184625626, -0.01894192397594452, -0.03127319738268852, 0.009753198362886906, 0.0025481381453573704, 0.0017208161298185587, 0.017409956082701683, 0.010170742869377136, 0.022636134177446365, -0.010508890263736248, 0.032137125730514526, -0.03019523248076439, 0.01655523106455803, 0.012918073683977127, -0.03143996372818947, 0.0007648697355762124, 0.009935234673321247, -0.024166204035282135, 0.02510029450058937, 0.006237466353923082, -0.07659833133220673, 0.01756826601922512, -0.03886432573199272, -0.0486481599509716, 0.013891859911382198, 0.013825340196490288, -0.0036329205613583326, -0.09667004644870758, -0.007178676314651966, 0.005215241573750973, -0.048244409263134, -0.02471681870520115, 0.011994359083473682, -0.0018262697849422693, 0.04125865548849106, -0.026452520862221718, 0.019807759672403336, 0.01069938950240612, 0.013764981180429459, -0.00872330367565155, -0.001201901352033019, -0.016933314502239227, -0.011966655030846596, -0.01221812330186367, 0.015136797912418842, -0.013934943825006485, 0.021359683945775032, 0.006405213847756386, 0.03729662671685219, -0.00789558794349432, 0.0026743076741695404, 0.030561940744519234, -0.04427846893668175, 0.0011692085536196828, 0.011090151965618134, 0.0030643504578620195, 0.05955146625638008, 0.014895729720592499, 0.0182728823274374, -0.02709905430674553, -0.024280745536088943, -0.023465696722269058, 0.03305814415216446, 0.03599002584815025, 0.027415798977017403, 0.015239272266626358, -0.007608878891915083, -0.011974929831922054, 0.00017921559629030526, 0.05143333226442337, -0.005574548151344061, 0.032675497233867645, -0.00860499870032072, -0.00289325718767941, 0.0031048001255840063, -0.014744965359568596, -0.01094091311097145, 0.006389138754457235, 0.008341860957443714, 0.028887081891298294, 0.04543766751885414, 0.0019632666371762753, 0.02299697883427143, 0.009525763802230358, 0.05297049507498741, -0.0820435881614685, -0.04302513226866722, -0.026343589648604393, -0.00506834639236331, 0.027656223624944687, -0.03517322242259979 ]
<p>Im newbie in Image Processing field, and I got many term that wierd. There are :</p> <ol> <li><p>Moments</p></li> <li><p>Local and global characteristic</p></li> <li><p>Energy of Image</p></li> <li><p>Color Temperature</p></li> </ol> <p>What each of them represent in Image??</p>
36,670
[ -0.030409079045057297, -0.04524815082550049, 0.00946046318858862, 0.013255935162305832, 0.03414791822433472, 0.011821889318525791, -0.06290242820978165, -0.027211135253310204, 0.005214466713368893, -0.03542913496494293, 0.04052864760160446, 0.05012274533510208, 0.014114472083747387, 0.043045949190855026, -0.006961874198168516, 0.01771930791437626, -0.025420743972063065, 0.009735740721225739, -0.03500368818640709, -0.0016352522652596235, -0.008192002773284912, 0.004093899857252836, 0.04131448268890381, 0.028055567294359207, -0.037938088178634644, 0.02129616215825081, 0.02198542281985283, -0.0024008085019886494, 0.05051155760884285, 0.0462830513715744, -0.030704263597726822, -0.03759559616446495, -0.01868247427046299, -0.013950672931969166, -0.02075442299246788, -0.012777280993759632, -0.01680944859981537, -0.029189521446824074, 0.011447270400822163, 0.016739066690206528, -0.00898263044655323, -0.014636962674558163, 0.02630035951733589, 0.01311502791941166, -0.019696509465575218, 0.005627183709293604, -0.021423161029815674, -0.028949782252311707, 0.01029899064451456, -0.04448322951793671, 0.06685628741979599, -0.02716069482266903, 0.021860403940081596, 0.035477135330438614, 0.007468270603567362, 0.05756354331970215, 0.015302412211894989, 0.06264105439186096, -0.033009085804224014, -0.03565888851881027, 0.007314094342291355, 0.006682815030217171, 0.04651791974902153, -0.01637188158929348, -0.01523983757942915, 0.03543724864721298, 0.01704048551619053, -0.02908175066113472, 0.0531577505171299, 0.05832827463746071, 0.014119705185294151, 0.01284008752554655, 0.0536380298435688, -0.05141526833176613, -0.001120729255490005, -0.036378517746925354, -0.01843411847949028, 0.010554500855505466, 0.043715767562389374, 0.0072192298248410225, 0.007381513249129057, 0.046108800917863846, -0.033759403973817825, -0.022407321259379387, 0.04849020764231682, -0.005831262096762657, 0.08863598853349686, 0.005781563930213451, 0.02082507684826851, -0.01372976042330265, 0.00556377274915576, 0.011963355354964733, 0.03693770244717598, -0.018931157886981964, -0.03601548820734024, 0.03983116149902344, 0.028719056397676468, 0.031015753746032715, -0.010810044594109058, -0.0008009636658243835, 0.01926414482295513, -0.036786999553442, 0.010367749258875847, 0.06856756657361984, -0.046329207718372345, -0.02352198213338852, -0.0541369765996933, -0.005763334222137928, 0.03627858683466911, 0.037703972309827805, -0.018370138481259346, 0.002957860939204693, 0.021253271028399467, 0.00749253248795867, 0.020348140969872475, 0.00825522094964981, 0.03486400097608566, 0.04032290726900101, 0.01705869473516941, 0.03436826914548874, 0.02348569966852665, -0.05835791304707527, 0.0081612728536129, 0.001346935285255313, -0.08397798985242844, 0.0428200326859951, 0.04351073130965233, 0.0006687257555313408, -0.02196604385972023, 0.03986243158578873, -0.014899584464728832, -0.04656780883669853, 0.008816665038466454, 0.0018950249068439007, 0.02556806616485119, -0.011918232776224613, -0.06462915986776352, -0.025751862674951553, 0.014455159194767475, -0.03978968411684036, -0.013406747952103615, -0.0653090626001358, -0.010427623055875301, 0.024002568796277046, 0.040412671864032745, -0.008285424672067165, 0.00571658369153738, 0.000724637066014111, 0.01589757762849331, -0.016347821801900864, -0.015948884189128876, -0.00155319191981107, -0.00069144566077739, 0.0039164479821920395, 0.010355686768889427, -0.044313691556453705, 0.004253685008734465, 0.030860062688589096, -0.03937871381640434, -0.037929512560367584, 0.03603286296129227, -0.02697926200926304, -0.0008774814195930958, 0.01984620839357376, 0.011570759117603302, -0.03656700253486633, 0.06306829303503036, 0.0068089766427874565, 0.03716960549354553, 0.02942560985684395, 0.005464254412800074, 0.02240394428372383, -0.024135738611221313, 0.017211373895406723, 0.05888567119836807, 0.0034698578529059887, 0.0036450137849897146, -0.03391005098819733, 0.024330001324415207, 0.011184859089553356, -0.05807090923190117, -0.06264355778694153, 0.03874213993549347, 0.013965618796646595, 0.01781013421714306, 0.055092617869377136, 0.02295798808336258, -0.0312558151781559, 0.030783800408244133, -0.007437819615006447, -0.014431034214794636, -0.062179531902074814, 0.03554476797580719, -0.03520083427429199, -0.04138564318418503, 0.013305895030498505, 0.02793487347662449, -0.01095836516469717, -0.015188104473054409, -0.023523468524217606, -0.022638728842139244, 0.00697521585971117, 0.014966785907745361, -0.03157595172524452, 0.007392171770334244, 0.04193119332194328, 0.028414146974682808, -0.016512485221028328, 0.01753482036292553, -0.03623609617352486, -0.019413180649280548, 0.012872109189629555, -0.028317220509052277, 0.017528386786580086, -0.02961793728172779, -0.03149769455194473, 0.00010011232370743528, 0.03521566092967987, -0.02793383225798607, -0.01197056844830513, 0.0014343131333589554, 0.04576120525598526, 0.006977809127420187, 0.01053435169160366, 0.021403435617685318, 0.028657345101237297, 0.029473591595888138, 0.02888481691479683, -0.0228276364505291, -0.029714159667491913, -0.03236545994877815, -0.018200967460870743, 0.040098220109939575, 0.03604718670248985, -0.057604264467954636, 0.004597368184477091, 0.039925746619701385, 0.026278948411345482, 0.07056356966495514, -0.0010486048413440585, -0.02865765057504177, -0.00972425751388073, -0.011418340727686882, 0.010744353756308556, -0.0033677720930427313, 0.022046729922294617, 0.013990720734000206, 0.042050592601299286, 0.07525627315044403, -0.011783662252128124, -0.01527289766818285, 0.08245684951543808, -0.015167666599154472, 0.01790275052189827, -0.03045760840177536, -0.012870607897639275, 0.037048790603876114, -0.03014538623392582, 0.006352709606289864, 0.024074768647551537, -0.02223340794444084, 0.010918397456407547, -0.024853933602571487, -0.007004042621701956, -0.02304230071604252, 0.010826556012034416, -0.009729462675750256, -0.007050692569464445, 0.011394307017326355, -0.006880294065922499, 0.045311857014894485, 0.010956640355288982, -0.0031910960096865892, -0.057122331112623215, 0.020039977505803108, 0.05332082509994507, 0.0020407745614647865, 0.03158113360404968, -0.019467759877443314, -0.04011223092675209, -0.0012384416768327355, -0.029272183775901794, 0.020243942737579346, -0.014501161873340607, -0.05066613107919693, 0.021341437473893166, -0.05130491778254509, -0.01769794337451458, 0.051793940365314484, -0.010131058283150196, -0.011179658584296703, 0.010060990229249, -0.014844462275505066, -0.039217542856931686, 0.0025028823874890804, 0.002965377876535058, 0.04598129168152809, -0.009249101392924786, -0.019099418073892593, 0.051709916442632675, -0.03368343412876129, -0.006067261565476656, 0.020828401669859886, -0.032504674047231674, -0.02639075368642807, -0.05118376761674881, 0.025464700534939766, 0.07446763664484024, -0.006056900601834059, 0.04173220694065094, 0.053311195224523544, -0.051436953246593475, -0.0007925842655822635, -0.02489642985165119, -0.027350738644599915, 0.008695989847183228, 0.01310619805008173, 0.029285011813044548, -0.026676729321479797, 0.0027839101385325193, 0.057907503098249435, 0.03263252228498459, -0.0446232371032238, -0.04166029766201973, -0.013422545045614243, -0.0710543841123581, -0.02060360461473465, -0.00976652093231678, -0.015202661044895649, 0.02178930677473545, -0.002071371767669916, 0.0013490873388946056, 0.022372515872120857, 0.06341969221830368, 0.004003935027867556, -0.022872108966112137, 0.037124570459127426, -0.014368313364684582, -0.0385754331946373, 0.06581461429595947, 0.032240524888038635, -0.03271372243762016, 0.024442698806524277, 0.007554302923381329, 0.03168881684541702, 0.029323028400540352, -0.02466227486729622, 0.03352006897330284, -0.006571648642420769, 0.006578360218554735, -0.03231009468436241, 0.056040309369564056, 0.015970304608345032, -0.017816968262195587, -0.021815843880176544, 0.02118578553199768, 0.04160825535655022, 0.013410236686468124, -0.0005062538548372686, 0.027092693373560905, 0.033278852701187134, -0.0432443730533123, -0.0007586905849166214, -0.006980269681662321, -0.018221741542220116, 0.024930942803621292, -0.034795548766851425, -0.049231451004743576, 0.04476790502667427, 0.03412052243947983, 0.021851105615496635, 0.029126329347491264, -0.03409242630004883, -0.039796702563762665, -0.06108606979250908, -0.001995986560359597, 0.019599996507167816, 0.0849943533539772, 0.004999668337404728, 0.09030447900295258, 0.058341193944215775, 0.026353221386671066, 0.015702461823821068, 0.023608297109603882, -0.06752024590969086, 0.04085119441151619, 0.03511800244450569, -0.016193188726902008, -0.009332312270998955, -0.009844040498137474, 0.037679653614759445, -0.0531579963862896, -0.022758355364203453, 0.048490650951862335, 0.0051369620487093925, -0.025617511942982674, 0.009855140931904316, -0.026452692225575447, 0.011066020466387272, -0.0068979389034211636, 0.041004668921232224, 0.0011701672337949276, -0.011461417190730572, 0.0013508895644918084, 0.04969165846705437, -0.01138062309473753, -0.015779869630932808, -0.013262983411550522, -0.020559560507535934, 0.03898811340332031, 0.04534140229225159, 0.028704166412353516, 0.03005303256213665, -0.029920941218733788, 0.011074095964431763, 0.035037312656641006, 0.07070057839155197, -0.003488717367872596, -0.024333583191037178, -0.03433584049344063, -0.055509548634290695, 0.010957960970699787, 0.006718148943036795, 0.02059832401573658, -0.028439564630389214, -0.030078601092100143, 0.0240396149456501, -0.012519310228526592, -0.01399415172636509, 0.050431132316589355, 0.034462153911590576, 0.04358240216970444, -0.031343672424554825, -0.037622783333063126, 0.005890171974897385, -0.0065333959646523, -0.010473684407770634, 0.029907310381531715, 0.021427398547530174, -0.019963685423135757, 0.01769365929067135, 0.012121506035327911, -0.0506877675652504, -0.02180083654820919, -0.04094618186354637, 0.017733648419380188, 0.00619161082431674, -0.0119777275249362, -0.024547679349780083, -0.016943247988820076, 0.020311664789915085, 0.052957501262426376, 0.0059565594419837, -0.019062630832195282, -0.07139860093593597, 0.00397605262696743, 0.07360359281301498, 0.03889220952987671, -0.022918952628970146, -0.04464128613471985, -0.043600231409072876, 0.0032456759363412857, 0.033260881900787354, -0.03242983669042587, 0.02614702098071575, -0.018799955025315285, -0.008129711262881756, -0.0030236386228352785, -0.01427446398884058, -0.007912790402770042, 0.03309642896056175, -0.0019066972890868783, 0.021384347230196, -0.08184290677309036, -0.01224359031766653, -0.01775960437953472, 0.018428390845656395, -0.0008264739881269634, 0.03573494777083397, -0.022334011271595955, 0.031031502410769463, 0.002939569065347314, 0.02876846306025982, -0.009408076293766499, -0.04681029170751572, 0.024238890036940575, 0.015849167481064796, -0.019104553386569023, 0.052140552550554276, -0.021132100373506546, -0.030343445017933846, 0.018887188285589218, 0.018956368789076805, -0.04961077496409416, -0.015572509728372097, -0.024534016847610474, 0.032501157373189926, 0.035202860832214355, 0.03120596706867218, 0.04287276044487953, 0.01590918004512787, -0.020498568192124367, -0.01181995403021574, -0.03354058414697647, 0.06943894177675247, -0.014988181181252003, -0.012362489476799965, -0.06164136528968811, -0.015236939303576946, -0.07057258486747742, 0.052708860486745834, -0.02234789915382862, 0.0013152329484000802, -0.032043106853961945, -0.026890628039836884, -0.0017404869431629777, 0.02630426734685898, -0.00941529031842947, -0.03690853342413902, 0.007966691628098488, 0.014581764116883278, -0.018532028421759605, 0.0007452948484569788, 0.026342464610934258, 0.01216206420212984, 0.0037168902345001698, 0.02408844791352749, -0.0029038640204817057, 0.011654888279736042, -0.03715900331735611, -0.0009162910864688456, 0.0034757729154080153, -0.030994486063718796, 0.027333548292517662, 0.01263626292347908, 0.03364371135830879, 0.04596349596977234, -0.0844978392124176, -0.02739568054676056, 0.013119356706738472, -0.02769283391535282, 0.024129077792167664, -0.04145519807934761, 0.05057857930660248, 0.041009943932294846, 0.008109141141176224, -0.030045712366700172, -0.041876472532749176, -0.003640629816800356, 0.023889366537332535, -0.02771955169737339, -0.03213733807206154, -0.012650593183934689, -0.0065657454542815685, -0.03717917948961258, 0.010069534182548523, 0.01522155199199915, 0.02829696424305439, -0.0016609971644356847, 0.026707928627729416, 0.016421061009168625, 0.08349739015102386, 0.02106441557407379, 0.009511923417448997, 0.014989870600402355, 0.015366964973509312, -0.023719480261206627, 0.033930711448192596, 0.0439840629696846, -0.020952723920345306, 0.018098263069987297, -0.010015021078288555, 0.008380542509257793, 0.01149455551058054, 0.02588386833667755, 0.011719880625605583, -0.005662900861352682, 0.05573505535721779, -0.02760608308017254, -0.004930217284709215, 0.026112867519259453, 0.013729761354625225, 0.02581975795328617, 0.008308587595820427, -0.0004184477438684553, 0.0025950344279408455, -0.039848148822784424, 0.021039562299847603, -0.0014619705034419894, 0.018695173785090446, 0.037992194294929504, 0.02833886444568634, -0.037738773971796036, 0.039397288113832474, 0.006292019970715046, -0.034109652042388916, 0.027163825929164886, -0.028961878269910812, 0.012094304896891117, 0.010412642732262611, 0.03930315375328064, -0.013722540810704231, 0.018072940409183502, -0.04909975826740265, -0.01044260524213314, 0.05674932524561882, -0.01657758839428425, 0.07554484903812408, 0.04638216644525528, -0.027619868516921997, 0.01320321299135685, -0.030839327722787857, -0.019883599132299423, 0.014165249653160572, -0.0015430653002113104, 0.06348352134227753, -0.019800769165158272, -0.04731179401278496, -0.01211635209619999, 0.02246984653174877, -0.008606381714344025, 0.03402285277843475, -0.0017790385754778981, 0.040974706411361694, -0.00730494549497962, -0.03705226257443428, -0.04112504795193672, 0.03912096470594406, -0.01674015447497368, 0.028573274612426758, 0.015741242095828056, 0.007098759990185499, 0.055719394236803055, 0.0384308286011219, -0.011064836755394936, -0.04384160414338112, 0.003169009694829583, -0.06855504959821701, 0.008342491462826729, 0.009333162568509579, -0.011840399354696274, -0.03996888920664787, -0.007035548333078623, 0.01868845894932747, -0.00877102930098772, 0.0370793491601944, -0.009056949988007545, -0.06298845261335373, -0.004393233917653561, -0.05398980528116226, -0.05845871567726135, 0.03341313451528549, -0.0048482404090464115, -0.019075101241469383, -0.024012789130210876, -0.04861025884747505, 0.016862349584698677, 0.04187142103910446, 0.03778461366891861, -0.033350106328725815, 0.03505345433950424, 0.025225376710295677, -0.0006186739192344248, 0.022854415699839592, -0.010849007405340672, 0.09791847318410873, 0.08164388686418533, -0.015910618007183075, -0.0537639781832695, -0.022858917713165283, -0.03197620064020157, -0.009914529509842396, -0.001212723203934729, 0.0016433252021670341, -0.032261040061712265, 0.0160402562469244, 0.030115174129605293, -0.004576594568789005, 0.0308673195540905, -0.003944190684705973, 0.0026903836987912655, -0.05188681185245514, -0.057260673493146896, 0.003095827763900161, -0.007896365597844124, -0.0334789976477623, 0.06380338221788406, -0.09445347636938095, 0.021073488518595695, 0.016998687759041786, 0.012301717884838581, -0.01332027930766344, -0.03973374143242836, 0.06572151184082031, 0.03833276778459549, -0.008191855624318123, -0.0050498442724347115, 0.009594717994332314, -0.01297244243323803, -0.019172854721546173, 0.00038060007500462234, 0.03086559846997261, -0.011176114901900291, 0.0038053328171372414, 0.005129448603838682, -0.007532741408795118, -0.041699863970279694, -0.010366784408688545, -0.008992861956357956, -0.019572582095861435, -0.032732196152210236, -0.019901728257536888, 0.01614132709801197, 0.022620342671871185, 0.016364481300115585, -0.004750806838274002, 0.015120435506105423, -0.026662515476346016, -0.05739803612232208, -0.008858603425323963, -0.0014532250352203846, 0.008653241209685802, -0.017148956656455994, -0.02975102886557579, -0.0844542384147644, 0.03559501841664314, -0.019783858209848404, 0.05663343891501427, 0.018287042155861855, -0.017900940030813217, 0.016167810186743736, -0.03482438996434212, 0.05871446058154106, 0.00026790687115862966, 0.00875856913626194, -0.0000035174987260688795, -0.032606884837150574, -0.001463638269342482, -0.04055044800043106, -0.0026812241412699223, 0.016300292685627937, -0.005852606147527695, 0.007934639230370522, -0.007626374717801809, -0.013640759512782097, -0.047062139958143234, 0.026157351210713387, -0.009828400798141956, -0.016088325530290604, -0.025982845574617386, 0.001689079450443387, 0.049523547291755676, 0.02288144640624523, 0.013149423524737358, -0.008114976808428764, -0.0010270531056448817, 0.027077671140432358, 0.021754516288638115, -0.047925204038619995, -0.012290144339203835, 0.06235330551862717, -0.010423332452774048, 0.009108291938900948, -0.00010556676716078073, 0.07480746507644653, 0.021847505122423172, -0.02418685331940651, 0.01742326281964779, 0.033081185072660446, -0.023887459188699722, -0.019435804337263107, -0.00932355597615242, -0.0135152917355299, 0.010251877829432487, 0.009887420572340488, -0.0427292063832283, -0.049074914306402206, -0.005997637286782265, 0.008158156648278236, 0.013325700536370277, -0.013311989605426788, 0.035889796912670135, -0.024620482698082924, -0.004770453087985516, -0.025234879925847054, 0.0694858580827713, -0.0021670919377356768, -0.03237687796354294, -0.05430751293897629, 0.03247877582907677, 0.004757257644087076, -0.036330170929431915, -0.026771945878863335, 0.024844778701663017, -0.01627528667449951, -0.04244177043437958, 0.021763384342193604, 0.013558742590248585, 0.03484448045492172, 0.017187049612402916, -0.028760189190506935, -0.030806032940745354, 0.05686021223664284, 0.00018007458129432052, 0.004796963185071945, 0.016163740307092667, -0.03311330825090408, -0.02896769531071186, 0.026654409244656563, -0.015749314799904823, 0.002792445942759514, 0.068097785115242, 0.005689817480742931, -0.01527392864227295, 0.0369320809841156, 0.002797624794766307, -0.027394311502575874, -0.03091548942029476, -0.028164109215140343, -0.04784924164414406, -0.0007961784140206873, 0.019597865641117096, -0.03351190313696861, -0.027829227969050407, 0.004186382982879877, -0.007184217683970928, -0.011971456930041313, -0.03004717268049717, 0.004149564541876316, -0.01636194810271263, 0.02325574681162834, -0.005598181392997503, 0.0028778063133358955, 0.02948780730366707, 0.01919654570519924, -0.05115089192986488, 0.02274264395236969, -0.02631467953324318, -0.008624210022389889, -0.09287763386964798, -0.022257495671510696, 0.024744708091020584, -0.02624170482158661, 0.04661909490823746, -0.07304970920085907, 0.01224586647003889, 0.023500610142946243, -0.04341466352343559, -0.003912621643394232, -0.012885432690382004, -0.02652083709836006, -0.03135048970580101, 0.03492773696780205, 0.013580769300460815, 0.024736331775784492, 0.0016925876261666417, 0.007268697954714298, 0.024140728637576103, 0.03648268058896065, -0.01883479580283165, 0.013167881406843662, -0.027872368693351746, 0.03802817687392235, -0.013324249535799026, -0.05163319781422615, 0.037083256989717484, -0.008622384630143642, -0.023308945819735527, -0.0026940107345581055, -0.03299440070986748, -0.02781238593161106, 0.021694054827094078, 0.009907407686114311, -0.011147614568471909, 0.014514928683638573, 0.016653908416628838, -0.026543932035565376, -0.03962690755724907, -0.007741183042526245, 0.014540028758347034, 0.05164872482419014, 0.030080048367381096, 0.005149255972355604, -0.008499884977936745, -0.031205326318740845, -0.0016495411982759833, 0.03070453554391861, -0.023642346262931824, -0.06839516758918762, 0.03010038658976555, -0.012779048644006252, -0.003060891292989254, -0.05347984656691551, 0.02759268321096897, -0.03801323473453522, -0.0014191484078764915, -0.0022457705345004797, -0.024144606664776802, 0.011241830885410309, 0.015216277912259102, 0.020630963146686554, -0.03157215192914009, 0.020080704241991043, 0.026023302227258682, -0.013770807534456253, -0.015161161310970783, 0.010111764073371887, 0.06743399053812027, -0.013326052576303482, -0.008321217261254787, -0.03383094444870949, -0.051275502890348434, 0.016018597409129143, 0.00738284969702363, -0.01755056530237198, -0.013067438267171383, -0.009766259230673313, -0.039180491119623184, -0.07432171702384949, 0.024566808715462685, -0.03412425145506859, -0.018651288002729416, -0.055577293038368225, 0.01905790902674198, -0.009254135191440582, 0.050440073013305664, 0.0502287894487381, 0.028943369165062904, 0.0006036423146724701, 0.0028375505935400724, 0.017985660582780838, 0.02669818140566349, -0.04863970726728439, -0.00982481986284256, -0.008879676461219788, -0.026137201115489006, -0.0031268156599253416, -0.029269428923726082, 0.020111294463276863, 0.028322888538241386, 0.034379586577415466, -0.033593229949474335, -0.009541355073451996, -0.01837676204741001, -0.010897522792220116, 0.048293810337781906, -0.006392735056579113, -0.016987768933176994, 0.06621351838111877, -0.026200629770755768, -0.00963541865348816, 0.003339285496622324, -0.014514305628836155, -0.018170595169067383, -0.01971268653869629, -0.015413410030305386, -0.03740614280104637, 0.0025725027080625296, -0.02829756774008274, 0.045588910579681396, -0.06096896529197693, -0.008919816464185715, 0.00833051186054945, -0.024620044976472855, 0.004294089041650295, 0.05798802897334099, 0.04361651465296745, 0.03177236393094063, 0.004282345063984394, -0.0025511765852570534, -0.004485663026571274, -0.02750008925795555, -0.03616981953382492, 0.038364943116903305, -0.013439523987472057, -0.0027474805247038603, 0.046086717396974564, -0.014369742013514042, 0.04316489025950432, -0.00486918305978179, 0.00656061340123415, 0.019404340535402298, -0.04517565667629242, -0.027671795338392258, -0.009918717667460442, 0.0056410981342196465, 0.008637461811304092, 0.0046355025842785835, -0.0177803672850132, 0.06515292078256607, -0.029938634485006332, -0.02506815269589424, -0.03725438192486763, 0.012367891147732735, -0.0381486676633358, -0.006918594241142273, 0.02818298526108265, 0.029695356264710426, 0.0019789619836956263, 0.015978015959262848, -0.033564526587724686, 0.002467515878379345, 0.04823978617787361, -0.05107152834534645, 0.0691155344247818, -0.020477311685681343, -0.011218962259590626, 0.018197091296315193, 0.015979081392288208, -0.0075176251120865345, 0.008810657076537609, 0.026083869859576225, 0.034271690994501114, 0.03330886736512184, 0.023158960044384003, -0.04415220767259598, 0.008782852441072464, 0.05467123165726662, -0.10170412808656693, -0.013541075401008129, -0.0028045487124472857, 0.017920073121786118, 0.01655341498553753, -0.021678553894162178 ]
<p>Particles are suspended in a liquid medium at a concentration of 4 particles per mL. A large amount of the suspension is thoroughly agitated, and then 3 mL are withdrawn . Let $X$ be the number of the particles in the 3 mL. Answer the following:</p> <p>a- The distribution of X is a Poisson distribution, what is its parameter ($\lambda$)?</p> <p>b- Find the probability that no particle is withdrawn from the 3 mL.</p> <p>c- Find the probability that one particle is withdrawn from the 3 mL.</p>
74,042
[ -0.0100275669246912, -0.012258204631507397, 0.016664983704686165, -0.031063895672559738, 0.02113947458565235, -0.002842001151293516, 0.007886840030550957, 0.02229720540344715, 0.009272521361708641, -0.011852996423840523, 0.040615394711494446, 0.0868711769580841, 0.08600904047489166, 0.020834477618336678, 0.029316898435354233, 0.03310054913163185, 0.00017240263696294278, 0.007557923439890146, 0.021824289113283157, -0.001143364585004747, -0.014377477578818798, -0.011846105568110943, -0.015849633142352104, -0.0035764200147241354, -0.026012107729911804, 0.023364584892988205, 0.03542374074459076, -0.010208857245743275, 0.00761380372568965, 0.07037679851055145, -0.04207621514797211, -0.008971618488430977, 0.007901747711002827, 0.021990569308400154, 0.010878041386604309, 0.01968919299542904, -0.01730545423924923, -0.059646617621183395, -0.017498629167675972, 0.04848078265786171, -0.05363905802369118, -0.00999259203672409, 0.029445121064782143, 0.03332129493355751, -0.013033251278102398, 0.010936615988612175, 0.005132578779011965, -0.04854724928736687, 0.0252815131098032, -0.04164177179336548, 0.040020354092121124, 0.01617373153567314, 0.03653565049171448, 0.010870798490941525, 0.02321719564497471, -0.04225027933716774, 0.03550652414560318, 0.06362612545490265, -0.0197321567684412, -0.06264643371105194, 0.003212263574823737, -0.005882727913558483, -0.011908511631190777, -0.026594627648591995, -0.04875188320875168, -0.013927672058343887, -0.01946689933538437, -0.04203017055988312, 0.05429054796695709, 0.0017362755024805665, 0.021544290706515312, 0.007197353057563305, 0.02995283529162407, -0.03704537823796272, 0.01780524291098118, -0.006535555701702833, 0.00762140890583396, 0.0069780368357896805, 0.008968817070126534, 0.02159211039543152, -0.008231113664805889, 0.007744366768747568, 0.014226024970412254, 0.029217064380645752, -0.0009290556772612035, -0.03933365270495415, 0.06064135581254959, 0.033773165196180344, 0.015582002699375153, -0.0024946345947682858, -0.020127134397625923, 0.026384077966213226, 0.05432061851024628, 0.006598138250410557, -0.020052626729011536, 0.046292997896671295, -0.036959461867809296, 0.05404936149716377, 0.023255668580532074, -0.0198103915899992, -0.016501644626259804, -0.02225452847778797, 0.01537804864346981, 0.10556389391422272, -0.04014041647315025, 0.015642333775758743, -0.01859159953892231, 0.005321155302226543, -0.05248039960861206, -0.01982629857957363, -0.022247837856411934, 0.01222943514585495, 0.007565464358776808, -0.008093149401247501, -0.011360363103449345, 0.010075357742607594, 0.004095394629985094, -0.05249524116516113, 0.055673860013484955, 0.07718168944120407, 0.019626613706350327, 0.008548887446522713, 0.01796429231762886, 0.0043973615393042564, -0.044225603342056274, 0.010273121297359467, 0.020860254764556885, 0.0033758520148694515, -0.04171159863471985, 0.08730243891477585, 0.012486039660871029, 0.006073553580790758, 0.015528327785432339, 0.020681768655776978, 0.020343603566288948, -0.021175820380449295, -0.06413830071687698, -0.05573491007089615, 0.04180808737874031, -0.033293467015028, -0.03005247563123703, -0.0763029232621193, 0.012397026643157005, 0.06216515228152275, 0.056023772805929184, -0.0006649202550761402, -0.0022004409693181515, -0.024215251207351685, 0.012997470796108246, -0.0028515364974737167, -0.0059158680960536, 0.02293841540813446, -0.034100309014320374, -0.008500058203935623, -0.0051762112416327, -0.05019243806600571, -0.005277097690850496, -0.013045641593635082, 0.027509326115250587, -0.04311370849609375, 0.032526299357414246, -0.02449299395084381, -0.008075353689491749, -0.005292981863021851, 0.014131658710539341, -0.028950238600373268, 0.07139191776514053, 0.008836353197693825, 0.04126376286149025, -0.0076927863992750645, 0.0030127486679702997, 0.06616084277629852, 0.0034075374715030193, 0.01864115707576275, 0.02862825058400631, -0.013906166888773441, -0.026990776881575584, -0.018254974856972694, 0.026195557788014412, 0.04080045595765114, -0.028063377365469933, -0.008934730663895607, -0.014695967547595501, 0.010476316325366497, 0.01993696019053459, 0.015862124040722847, 0.037572406232357025, -0.00947226770222187, -0.0177028588950634, -0.003106931922957301, -0.02359605021774769, -0.06409452855587006, 0.024534212425351143, 0.010124310851097107, -0.020228242501616478, 0.02604968100786209, 0.013378895819187164, -0.015266158618032932, -0.003009881591424346, 0.03383469581604004, -0.04378147050738335, 0.007142552640289068, 0.007838797755539417, -0.021501297131180763, 0.007910950109362602, 0.061706315726041794, 0.04731524735689163, -0.02247573435306549, 0.03246155381202698, 0.01407194696366787, -0.0014140903949737549, -0.034822285175323486, -0.035884201526641846, -0.005329669453203678, -0.025510845705866814, -0.026006145402789116, 0.02602267451584339, 0.028569400310516357, 0.004027726594358683, 0.03478769585490227, -0.0523315891623497, 0.06517438590526581, 0.04726599156856537, 0.03666657209396362, 0.017848949879407883, -0.015130027197301388, -0.026186779141426086, 0.006268288474529982, 0.004285826813429594, -0.02050686441361904, -0.006599348969757557, -0.01104432437568903, 0.010800875723361969, 0.020316578447818756, -0.006707631517201662, 0.03401517495512962, 0.05121579021215439, -0.019620677456259727, 0.05494887754321098, 0.014314391650259495, -0.00310574215836823, -0.01743113249540329, 0.03325429558753967, 0.032348718494176865, -0.018882179632782936, 0.019059637561440468, 0.011108782142400742, -0.005293180700391531, 0.04343070834875107, -0.026673322543501854, 0.012035204097628593, -0.010754604823887348, 0.019004231318831444, 0.011651282198727131, -0.04445908963680267, 0.0005871508619748056, 0.04578758776187897, 0.014802669174969196, 0.0010640008840709925, 0.037717945873737335, 0.0012340424582362175, 0.010952428914606571, 0.02574528381228447, -0.029062867164611816, 0.0012771179899573326, 0.01016812864691019, -0.06326141208410263, -0.045205701142549515, 0.017093878239393234, -0.040325094014406204, 0.014989162795245647, -0.03280642628669739, -0.0015647837426513433, -0.03669825941324234, 0.0405864454805851, 0.014163920655846596, 0.012550153769552708, 0.02541903778910637, -0.005828759167343378, -0.03845784440636635, -0.012955074198544025, -0.0017339258920401335, -0.010356323793530464, 0.011357265524566174, -0.05380897596478462, 0.011238479986786842, -0.013651502318680286, -0.07279551774263382, 0.014712643809616566, -0.013019014149904251, 0.007941476069390774, 0.0077864327467978, -0.022686023265123367, -0.06269676983356476, 0.0028897265437990427, 0.026844725012779236, 0.01223679818212986, -0.03887468948960304, -0.00733595434576273, 0.04514015465974808, -0.0007650040788576007, -0.010818595066666603, -0.0005829664878547192, -0.078768290579319, -0.06712851673364639, -0.0370347686111927, 0.011595993302762508, 0.034100811928510666, 0.0028707836754620075, 0.01131978165358305, 0.0010428607929497957, 0.02933625690639019, 0.01852523721754551, -0.07149001210927963, -0.09095535427331924, -0.0010316205443814397, -0.03967101871967316, 0.05577845126390457, -0.05253789946436882, -0.022359518334269524, 0.06413289159536362, 0.03051389940083027, -0.04566037654876709, 0.04492931813001633, -0.008510569110512733, -0.04794270172715187, -0.0019550889264792204, 0.04742969945073128, 0.00650396104902029, -0.00801806803792715, 0.024790192022919655, -0.014520293101668358, 0.04325462877750397, -0.01263150293380022, 0.02593829855322838, -0.009629735723137856, 0.041423067450523376, 0.03803086653351784, -0.019696494564414024, 0.05470319837331772, -0.0006593382568098605, -0.04626237601041794, 0.030124006792902946, -0.04206608235836029, -0.002083506202325225, 0.004819967783987522, -0.04338980093598366, 0.03746911138296127, -0.0052182371728122234, 0.002601620042696595, 0.022306349128484726, 0.0572141595184803, 0.0358055904507637, -0.027472930029034615, 0.02736487053334713, 0.011032561771571636, 0.03119749389588833, -0.02508300170302391, -0.004965838510543108, 0.04375361651182175, 0.05299707129597664, -0.05572405457496643, -0.02135038748383522, -0.029109785333275795, -0.031392600387334824, 0.005319572985172272, -0.017373457551002502, -0.027408229187130928, 0.015313408337533474, 0.033330123871564865, 0.012255828827619553, 0.007701044902205467, -0.015539458021521568, -0.025674330070614815, -0.05913673713803291, -0.013933618552982807, 0.037227898836135864, 0.03721772879362106, -0.011101716198027134, 0.044761355966329575, 0.03423721343278885, -0.013979433104395866, -0.010260033421218395, 0.02425375021994114, -0.06144218519330025, 0.018030544742941856, 0.010011169128119946, -0.005154326558113098, -0.027398288249969482, -0.013036883436143398, 0.035171594470739365, -0.011975692585110664, 0.014196445234119892, 0.0031280932016670704, 0.005377581343054771, -0.052102282643318176, 0.012931729666888714, 0.01743299327790737, -0.009433732368052006, 0.004983901511877775, 0.017522692680358887, -0.015344878658652306, -0.0053401305340230465, 0.02054583467543125, 0.04505952075123787, -0.03230596333742142, -0.011670299805700779, 0.015608097426593304, -0.03421204164624214, 0.02560446970164776, 0.020017562434077263, 0.02115805819630623, 0.047259584069252014, -0.010120710358023643, 0.010668331757187843, 0.02592489682137966, 0.05913214758038521, 0.009573644027113914, 0.026199517771601677, -0.020721925422549248, -0.07459598034620285, 0.0060774520970880985, -0.003599763149395585, 0.0045270067639648914, 0.016821090131998062, 0.005420373287051916, 0.03450767323374748, -0.007956676185131073, -0.03797929361462593, 0.04675360023975372, 0.04928859695792198, 0.0028427578508853912, -0.01179689820855856, -0.02405059151351452, 0.038665611296892166, 0.009455505758523941, 0.014819088391959667, 0.033112380653619766, 0.030789241194725037, -0.0036948425695300102, -0.00045455931103788316, 0.034938231110572815, 0.031175220385193825, -0.04632442444562912, -0.011526172049343586, -0.003625615267083049, 0.0075742523185908794, 0.005017371848225594, -0.017391720786690712, -0.009565701708197594, 0.01661067083477974, 0.040996771305799484, 0.007250393740832806, -0.021517599001526833, -0.06182122603058815, -0.02766537107527256, 0.027547447010874748, 0.043599873781204224, -0.06130356341600418, -0.0021244457457214594, -0.05065770819783211, -0.04257061332464218, 0.03294103592634201, -0.05663984268903732, -0.013853423297405243, -0.048775795847177505, 0.03276479244232178, 0.03411053866147995, -0.03721463307738304, -0.06653044372797012, -0.013905703090131283, 0.0023227937053889036, 0.009154800325632095, -0.04312264919281006, -0.01897207275032997, -0.020169522613286972, -0.002341262297704816, 0.02366575039923191, 0.03999482840299606, 0.006515572778880596, -0.03436307981610298, -0.0037112352438271046, 0.005092502571642399, -0.00474052969366312, -0.05378786474466324, 0.029750660061836243, -0.015199347399175167, 0.0016898191533982754, 0.03600719943642616, -0.04324282705783844, -0.050446655601263046, -0.0038303539622575045, 0.03005893900990486, -0.01128939725458622, -0.002799239009618759, -0.034154217690229416, -0.0033968398347496986, -0.009296687319874763, 0.0032902860548347235, 0.06995345652103424, 0.03834666684269905, -0.0026026680134236813, -0.008631706237792969, -0.04329342022538185, -0.011808658950030804, -0.026991771534085274, 0.006171849090605974, -0.03862237185239792, 0.03004051372408867, -0.010430779308080673, 0.07180735468864441, 0.0033456403762102127, -0.01537507027387619, -0.017081720754504204, -0.011779043823480606, 0.025452451780438423, 0.016091248020529747, 0.04917222633957863, 0.02011640928685665, -0.018089503049850464, -0.016282403841614723, -0.012208378873765469, -0.0041135381907224655, 0.02864914759993553, -0.026659462600946426, 0.01764392852783203, 0.01576177403330803, -0.02676037885248661, 0.0272761732339859, 0.00432706531137228, -0.002862895606085658, -0.0004217592068016529, -0.0663188174366951, 0.02831602655351162, -0.006532036699354649, 0.048558931797742844, 0.0046562436036765575, -0.04793870449066162, -0.05511927977204323, 0.002542155096307397, -0.029022017493844032, 0.07683232426643372, -0.05698000267148018, 0.048098087310791016, -0.024418853223323822, 0.035925645381212234, -0.0809650793671608, -0.05824977159500122, -0.0015835909871384501, 0.018685009330511093, -0.02384263090789318, -0.02172865718603134, -0.0221940279006958, -0.006030935328453779, -0.03457295894622803, 0.0012650121934711933, 0.03009532205760479, -0.014613178558647633, -0.008023402653634548, 0.013081233948469162, 0.02791120484471321, 0.05958535149693489, 0.029581906273961067, 0.004233022686094046, 0.0058603351935744286, -0.020015710964798927, -0.04988425597548485, 0.006479634437710047, 0.014938270673155785, -0.01035093329846859, -0.009072598069906235, 0.01858782023191452, -0.004070180468261242, 0.023587673902511597, -0.03353019058704376, -0.062152400612831116, -0.002128654159605503, 0.02617037110030651, -0.03367907926440239, -0.019869329407811165, 0.00737409433349967, 0.005699592176824808, 0.03799593076109886, 0.021599991247057915, 0.003788487520068884, -0.025796769186854362, -0.02071058750152588, 0.03966531902551651, -0.010515136644244194, 0.004478557966649532, 0.025758706033229828, 0.0735243633389473, 0.004927558358758688, 0.016683431342244148, 0.003629148006439209, 0.058446209877729416, 0.015021775849163532, -0.043958645313978195, -0.0038369079120457172, 0.01812862604856491, 0.019254475831985474, -0.0017518977401778102, -0.011097339913249016, -0.06146583333611488, 0.02472119964659214, 0.04260086268186569, -0.022105233743786812, 0.04758871719241142, 0.024033570662140846, 0.03391566500067711, 0.008439794182777405, 0.0062737977132201195, 0.017048755660653114, 0.008801248855888844, -0.004362425301223993, 0.0408102311193943, -0.036092471331357956, -0.016214588657021523, 0.0216862540692091, 0.0262158066034317, -0.01133583951741457, 0.004596611484885216, -0.0022733008954674006, -0.00757205905392766, 0.005408769939094782, -0.0208126287907362, -0.037609562277793884, 0.04255680739879608, -0.03485754877328873, 0.029104962944984436, 0.006033165846019983, -0.09475405514240265, 0.03520620986819267, -0.0026398315094411373, -0.01635601371526718, -0.046165697276592255, 0.002427875529974699, -0.05945857986807823, 0.02474117837846279, 0.009078786708414555, 0.018355946987867355, 0.004716519266366959, -0.0018281199736520648, 0.036876827478408813, 0.013620554469525814, 0.05813795328140259, -0.0220603346824646, -0.08907806873321533, -0.019158031791448593, -0.0038559690583497286, -0.036459434777498245, 0.026772715151309967, -0.02052842266857624, -0.041765958070755005, -0.011962199583649635, -0.046753767877817154, 0.05695280432701111, -0.0049605160020291805, 0.027502737939357758, -0.05143318697810173, 0.06158290430903435, -0.022968431934714317, 0.004524662159383297, 0.004687147680670023, 0.046107351779937744, 0.1002466231584549, 0.06980312615633011, 0.017642227932810783, -0.07750756293535233, -0.020652681589126587, 0.004452540073543787, 0.012098348699510098, -0.04888240993022919, 0.0127977030351758, 0.030098548159003258, 0.026745755225419998, 0.02487914264202118, 0.0543823167681694, -0.014887084253132343, 0.0035946760326623917, 0.011037896387279034, 0.006397247780114412, -0.0836009606719017, -0.02557305060327053, 0.021799685433506966, 0.0010378146544098854, 0.013106639496982098, -0.06480076164007187, 0.020572727546095848, 0.03061690181493759, -0.011494620703160763, -0.05473146587610245, -0.0012073322432115674, -0.03128954395651817, -0.009697231464087963, -0.006434990558773279, -0.01657797582447529, 0.0015162966446951032, -0.011862054467201233, -0.025083020329475403, 0.01210528239607811, -0.012629399076104164, -0.04119493067264557, 0.016747595742344856, 0.05025738105177879, 0.0007098101195879281, 0.008106485940515995, 0.02567891590297222, 0.04367293044924736, -0.046202391386032104, -0.007810317445546389, -0.02218611165881157, 0.0238445233553648, -0.013199081644415855, -0.0016311579383909702, 0.0032408006954938173, -0.018836911767721176, -0.025803644210100174, -0.03856915980577469, -0.010857687331736088, 0.0007843718631193042, 0.009040402248501778, -0.030950970947742462, -0.04999672248959541, -0.023359840735793114, -0.004629385191947222, -0.023543408140540123, 0.018495742231607437, 0.035721201449632645, -0.04422527924180031, -0.03495342656970024, -0.017613636329770088, 0.0016506500542163849, 0.019053075462579727, 0.008638839237391949, -0.033541399985551834, -0.029083847999572754, -0.002109409775584936, 0.03101337142288685, -0.0009170653065666556, 0.00785594992339611, 0.02816023863852024, -0.005285728722810745, 0.009553744457662106, 0.008022066205739975, -0.062183041125535965, 0.016165170818567276, 0.008232147432863712, 0.047917574644088745, -0.031610555946826935, -0.007848012261092663, -0.03216762840747833, 0.04516468197107315, 0.007331240456551313, -0.035965241491794586, 0.0440748929977417, 0.031221069395542145, 0.02642335742712021, -0.04333657771348953, 0.00565419951453805, -0.0014053143095225096, -0.023968929424881935, -0.015947731211781502, -0.026357153430581093, 0.07385706901550293, -0.008013851009309292, 0.03166446089744568, 0.021608153358101845, -0.0005656647845171392, -0.007049871142953634, 0.010347275994718075, 0.02974630519747734, -0.03940129652619362, -0.044057514518499374, 0.06930787861347198, -0.013175174593925476, -0.03602400794625282, -0.030481066554784775, -0.018780728802084923, 0.0037643632385879755, 0.005402456037700176, 0.0021783544216305017, -0.09744805842638016, -0.03333583474159241, -0.0036418726667761803, 0.03392120078206062, 0.0005829727742820978, 0.015770792961120605, -0.013228422030806541, -0.02333085611462593, 0.019428562372922897, 0.007257032673805952, -0.0053293751552701, -0.007797034922987223, -0.0110698277130723, -0.003990809433162212, -0.024827741086483, -0.0051156156696379185, 0.03483850881457329, -0.0073868222534656525, 0.018326839432120323, 0.015139522030949593, 0.027996547520160675, -0.025807298719882965, -0.021213999018073082, 0.07620967924594879, -0.07308044284582138, -0.0033866851590573788, -0.008527363650500774, 0.004488603211939335, 0.02841048501431942, 0.04615825042128563, -0.005168691277503967, -0.014091466553509235, 0.03829801455140114, -0.02363463304936886, 0.005504930391907692, -0.05356711521744728, -0.021886825561523438, 0.008851457387208939, -0.0031105780508369207, -0.017856422811746597, 0.04164509102702141, -0.012959026731550694, -0.0009330116445198655, 0.06472882628440857, 0.006499525159597397, 0.0066338758915662766, 0.026836607605218887, -0.010536596179008484, 0.012141832150518894, 0.025729743763804436, 0.0012965305941179395, 0.0014628395438194275, 0.06798650324344635, -0.024831615388393402, 0.02963327057659626, 0.0038396120071411133, -0.019521748647093773, -0.12932229042053223, -0.031951043754816055, -0.0045831045135855675, 0.008535061031579971, 0.010531269013881683, -0.023923499509692192, 0.022153208032250404, 0.05775579810142517, -0.03615616261959076, -0.0023026710841804743, -0.03219550848007202, -0.01646423526108265, -0.036378540098667145, 0.005122410133481026, 0.015532618388533592, 0.07035867869853973, 0.017105838283896446, -0.022055529057979584, 0.04994393512606621, 0.017617646604776382, -0.001306628924794495, -0.05298834294080734, 0.04547968879342079, 0.03520241007208824, -0.002626223722472787, -0.04407428950071335, 0.007129970006644726, -0.037882249802351, -0.01311985682696104, 0.03541195020079613, 0.01103410217911005, 0.010178006254136562, 0.00843809638172388, -0.013740556314587593, -0.016551103442907333, 0.0494658499956131, 0.01471224520355463, 0.004095022566616535, 0.01701430231332779, 0.042598117142915726, -0.005487085785716772, 0.02897685393691063, -0.007456414867192507, 0.00253228098154068, 0.07255133986473083, -0.003354283981025219, -0.031474966555833817, 0.006586622446775436, 0.011022784747183323, -0.014939216896891594, 0.029123838990926743, -0.0049795047380030155, 0.0030579734593629837, -0.03409725800156593, 0.04742659255862236, -0.04118078947067261, 0.004823746625334024, 0.033837512135505676, 0.032207947224378586, -0.04856202378869057, -0.010318647138774395, 0.009240388870239258, -0.008589990437030792, -0.039557281881570816, -0.028604257851839066, -0.014961222186684608, -0.022979693487286568, 0.013761290349066257, -0.007146196439862251, 0.006394978147000074, -0.03441771864891052, -0.0332980677485466, -0.03602713719010353, 0.031770236790180206, -0.008213485591113567, -0.0031598254572600126, 0.025012310594320297, 0.030928960070014, -0.010432007722556591, -0.08053137362003326, 0.0006277721840888262, 0.007401336450129747, -0.04514370858669281, -0.04244248941540718, 0.0009228756534866989, -0.027653636410832405, 0.04774928092956543, 0.022826937958598137, 0.031048869714140892, -0.011964309960603714, 0.017151998355984688, 0.021300509572029114, 0.02671421878039837, -0.03805306553840637, 0.02256942354142666, -0.02093655616044998, 0.002807960379868746, -0.040862925350666046, 0.026768449693918228, 0.015526640228927135, -0.0014794656308367848, 0.003581172553822398, 0.018371127545833588, 0.02258845418691635, -0.0005184219917282462, -0.023757703602313995, -0.019798722118139267, 0.02160545438528061, 0.008550499565899372, 0.06808629631996155, -0.002702365629374981, 0.020395567640662193, 0.007351495325565338, 0.011772438883781433, -0.030374906957149506, 0.0180070623755455, -0.0004290714568924159, -0.027763662859797478, 0.013095168396830559, 0.009847927838563919, -0.020286552608013153, -0.08850515633821487, 0.012607605196535587, -0.011742266826331615, -0.056352123618125916, -0.0067631457932293415, -0.028089743107557297, 0.04599293693900108, 0.07406123727560043, 0.0070524197071790695, -0.026272041723132133, -0.010217913426458836, -0.0037629720754921436, 0.0014726216904819012, 0.052866388112306595, 0.024430710822343826, -0.005040732678025961, 0.028366833925247192, 0.010465044528245926, -0.007541867438703775, 0.020250564441084862, 0.029111947864294052, -0.0020970741752535105, -0.00826557632535696, 0.007376424968242645, 0.009762141853570938, -0.016000408679246902, 0.04160747304558754, 0.023731611669063568, 0.03825199604034424, 0.07045664638280869, -0.05359477177262306, 0.024689866229891777, -0.014041428454220295, -0.008177529089152813, -0.014202040620148182, 0.012350104749202728, 0.030628513544797897, 0.020159918814897537, -0.011822683736681938, -0.042169202119112015, -0.03201969712972641, -0.004880376160144806, 0.01990749128162861, -0.03041103109717369, 0.008046543225646019, -0.006103686522692442, 0.00630096485838294, -0.05417775362730026, -0.020322604104876518, -0.005354501772671938, -0.03692099079489708, 0.010447824373841286, 0.0576181523501873, 0.02008158154785633, -0.004312160890549421, -0.007709794212132692, -0.005709470249712467, 0.056270357221364975, -0.0060196006670594215, -0.027293847873806953, -0.014803173951804638, -0.007834886200726032, 0.0064365495927631855, -0.0036771518643945456 ]
<p>I noticed that in the Normal distribution, the probability $P(x=c)$ equals zero, while for the Poisson distribution, it will not equal zero when $c$ is a non-negative integer.</p> <p>My question is: Does the probability of any constant in the normal distribution equal zero because it represents the area under any curve? Or it is just only a rule to memorize? </p>
36,675
[ -0.022893063724040985, -0.036681439727544785, -0.0012892435770481825, -0.025867829099297523, 0.016336334869265556, 0.02548779547214508, -0.0015410667983815074, -0.03544936701655388, -0.0025403713807463646, -0.04175550490617752, -0.00757897412404418, 0.010865462012588978, 0.0395546481013298, 0.013422410935163498, 0.030577829107642174, -0.0035695545375347137, -0.02874501422047615, 0.021035563200712204, -0.020779279991984367, -0.0011084646685048938, -0.009842039085924625, 0.0423150509595871, 0.026153825223445892, -0.014777486212551594, 0.019181085750460625, 0.05724445357918739, -0.007636716589331627, -0.007890881970524788, 0.0003363594296388328, 0.0956650972366333, -0.038420695811510086, 0.003974578808993101, 0.010706176050007343, 0.08279231935739517, 0.017216837033629417, 0.01369873620569706, -0.014149338938295841, -0.01898401789367199, -0.026189910247921944, 0.022183649241924286, -0.02054506726562977, -0.031061314046382904, 0.018490007147192955, 0.03532223775982857, -0.03840578347444534, 0.02272968925535679, -0.0018130068201571703, -0.057844020426273346, 0.015882989391684532, -0.04322957247495651, 0.021492717787623405, -0.020033670589327812, 0.05259954556822777, 0.06364761292934418, 0.04998702555894852, -0.032012857496738434, 0.054731983691453934, 0.040284253656864166, -0.04011741653084755, -0.08008476346731186, -0.017886964604258537, -0.024316253140568733, -0.02472187578678131, -0.03359055146574974, -0.018837057054042816, 0.008993963710963726, -0.011263553984463215, -0.03440926969051361, 0.03707924857735634, 0.0021900231949985027, 0.004745597951114178, 0.07358090579509735, 0.024379394948482513, -0.046854451298713684, 0.009263758547604084, -0.0046446421183645725, 0.03877464681863785, 0.0031320073176175356, 0.005926508456468582, 0.06650670617818832, 0.02890842594206333, -0.006331536453217268, 0.04787743091583252, 0.017653530463576317, 0.0244574137032032, -0.008446622639894485, 0.05702206492424011, 0.010797178372740746, 0.03548189997673035, 0.02923407033085823, 0.021609965711832047, 0.0004395082069095224, 0.02681679092347622, -0.05080462619662285, -0.034703027456998825, 0.05018095299601555, -0.022064806893467903, 0.01503813173621893, 0.020209696143865585, -0.005501457490026951, 0.0021589917596429586, -0.03831789270043373, 0.03105272352695465, 0.05837411805987358, -0.014039017260074615, 0.008883485570549965, -0.03153197839856148, 0.0011886819265782833, 0.009923011995851994, -0.0023164949379861355, -0.04105425998568535, 0.014281495474278927, 0.030865726992487907, -0.006581772118806839, 0.015812654048204422, 0.00670000072568655, 0.0017158767441287637, -0.018964748829603195, 0.06371141225099564, 0.024870969355106354, 0.02169705554842949, -0.020719517022371292, 0.027083348482847214, -0.007646886631846428, -0.055219616740942, -0.0054189045913517475, 0.015887273475527763, 0.03429190069437027, -0.06146577373147011, 0.05170669034123421, -0.010429533198475838, -0.00046219571959227324, 0.036395832896232605, 0.03704487904906273, 0.060699064284563065, 0.011326562613248825, -0.06686358153820038, -0.034818537533283234, 0.008854017592966557, -0.018560251221060753, -0.011292851530015469, -0.03923022001981735, 0.001174801029264927, 0.037540003657341, 0.03206862136721611, -0.017479805275797844, 0.008932417258620262, -0.029404155910015106, 0.013999156653881073, 0.022629952058196068, -0.015950724482536316, -0.009034925140440464, 0.0015546020586043596, -0.04350833594799042, -0.03220858424901962, -0.09447630494832993, 0.046061914414167404, 0.03749793767929077, 0.01859457977116108, -0.05532630905508995, 0.0026237540878355503, -0.05501439794898033, 0.01807164028286934, -0.029568461701273918, -0.014024386182427406, -0.03880831599235535, 0.08454097807407379, 0.015374010428786278, 0.02007443830370903, -0.005844340659677982, 0.024789324030280113, 0.05215068161487579, 0.017337480559945107, 0.03044590726494789, 0.0669856071472168, -0.04722505435347557, -0.028202872723340988, -0.03292984142899513, 0.022646455094218254, 0.03112034499645233, -0.025477197021245956, 0.017753079533576965, -0.012091550044715405, 0.010609639808535576, 0.004586095921695232, 0.032467618584632874, 0.004104521591216326, 0.015536434017121792, 0.0015986700309440494, -0.030045118182897568, -0.00997938308864832, -0.08320322632789612, 0.031923823058605194, 0.013828156515955925, -0.022510426118969917, 0.03589098900556564, 0.03825586289167404, -0.003673882456496358, -0.04613958299160004, -0.006836655084043741, -0.0026085032150149345, -0.0006009707576595247, -0.0033877987880259752, -0.10614091157913208, 0.018925592303276062, 0.03408137336373329, 0.034463070333004, 0.0035955174826085567, 0.029845526441931725, -0.03547025844454765, -0.03646574914455414, 0.029324328526854515, -0.05283556506037712, 0.03434581309556961, -0.017364712432026863, 0.02172677405178547, 0.01917387545108795, 0.008518031798303127, -0.02163265272974968, 0.052662402391433716, -0.05542796850204468, 0.029244231060147285, 0.04269377887248993, 0.0031982557848095894, 0.002373417839407921, 0.011627311818301678, 0.006257215980440378, -0.012085015885531902, -0.005617766175419092, -0.028977742418646812, -0.05913327634334564, 0.0026816772297024727, 0.034135203808546066, 0.03349149972200394, -0.027821339666843414, 0.006559024099260569, 0.049752309918403625, 0.022424563765525818, 0.03675282001495361, 0.01802571676671505, 0.005084889009594917, -0.0507047213613987, -0.01705203950405121, 0.05012555047869682, 0.04056674242019653, 0.02494983747601509, 0.01813730224967003, 0.006861513946205378, 0.03116644360125065, 0.004101958125829697, -0.029999131336808205, 0.05644659698009491, -0.023771466687321663, 0.04721442610025406, -0.013991741463541985, 0.013013721443712711, 0.038990043103694916, -0.022338956594467163, 0.021033253520727158, 0.02106638438999653, 0.00989518966525793, -0.03299304470419884, -0.009929530322551727, -0.025614066049456596, 0.005168053321540356, 0.0037483389023691416, -0.04871091991662979, -0.00865286123007536, 0.03309660404920578, -0.011788911186158657, -0.006091790273785591, -0.016533449292182922, -0.012738951481878757, -0.03396904096007347, 0.02572173811495304, 0.015583005733788013, 0.01206840667873621, 0.030577627941966057, -0.056675516068935394, -0.04272304102778435, -0.0036145567428320646, -0.017326809465885162, 0.0157384742051363, -0.0015022732550278306, -0.04250941425561905, 0.0010164661798626184, -0.005612412467598915, -0.03145120292901993, 0.030535589903593063, -0.03560784459114075, 0.03327300027012825, 0.028782596811652184, -0.034039951860904694, -0.025602959096431732, 0.006215918809175491, -0.03677275404334068, 0.016013678163290024, -0.04552822932600975, -0.019414182752370834, 0.023874569684267044, 0.003991869743913412, -0.03504127636551857, 0.005286209750920534, -0.011175832711160183, -0.061276379972696304, -0.04383362457156181, -0.013501562178134918, 0.044284164905548096, -0.03253904730081558, 0.020714879035949707, 0.02240070328116417, -0.05201685428619385, -0.00017325989028904587, -0.023089872673153877, -0.05225450545549393, 0.014349900186061859, -0.03318749740719795, 0.03224813565611839, -0.011599377728998661, -0.009921042248606682, 0.08115909993648529, 0.023574011400341988, -0.02196252904832363, 0.00015915125550236553, 0.006095409393310547, -0.03155849501490593, -0.012902329675853252, -0.015103517100214958, -0.0034361497964709997, 0.0010658369865268469, 0.017843617126345634, -0.0034796250984072685, 0.040356915444135666, 0.03345043957233429, 0.018667321652173996, -0.013264515437185764, 0.03269412741065025, 0.005353995598852634, -0.0016402537003159523, 0.06022585183382034, 0.02820136584341526, 0.00923844799399376, -0.005603552330285311, 0.011812460608780384, 0.025701668113470078, 0.015461412258446217, -0.04160778224468231, 0.05797233060002327, -0.019946452230215073, 0.047845520079135895, -0.04677844047546387, 0.026658251881599426, -0.027942977845668793, -0.011480930261313915, 0.014764868654310703, 0.010126518085598946, 0.03341970592737198, -0.05113137513399124, -0.0034339663106948137, 0.009283787570893764, 0.01764109544456005, -0.03246475011110306, -0.04947926849126816, -0.019171275198459625, 0.013908391818404198, 0.0011343639343976974, -0.012515990994870663, -0.04878072813153267, 0.0411531962454319, 0.05902015045285225, 0.02206851728260517, 0.0035928913857787848, -0.05559369921684265, 0.019030524417757988, -0.02322738990187645, -0.046619389206171036, 0.014216101728379726, 0.007538047153502703, 0.017933636903762817, 0.03632138669490814, -0.0003256833297200501, 0.010473654605448246, 0.005345690064132214, 0.01673050783574581, -0.11979836225509644, 0.020991314202547073, -0.051963333040475845, -0.021370409056544304, -0.02133561670780182, -0.03831252455711365, 0.03758103400468826, 0.004643805790692568, 0.017327632755041122, -0.00042914474033750594, 0.0038699882570654154, -0.032756298780441284, -0.0016274433583021164, -0.005967588629573584, -0.04107324033975601, -0.04681696370244026, 0.013901823200285435, -0.026782335713505745, 0.017846209928393364, 0.0463789626955986, 0.029925305396318436, 0.011500983498990536, -0.029107270762324333, -0.022082362323999405, -0.021767642349004745, 0.01700638420879841, 0.0260180551558733, 0.040377575904130936, 0.015780676156282425, 0.008923908695578575, -0.000931840855628252, 0.0023260721936821938, 0.059826649725437164, 0.015324571169912815, -0.003713736543431878, -0.005696061998605728, -0.07387205213308334, -0.03558175265789032, -0.03814999386668205, 0.029381759464740753, -0.005007970612496138, 0.022034786641597748, 0.04111272096633911, 0.011319353245198727, -0.011992559768259525, 0.007559030782431364, 0.05074354261159897, 0.030003922060132027, -0.011044589802622795, -0.026205502450466156, 0.01856306940317154, -0.05764838680624962, 0.022292379289865494, -0.01280023530125618, -0.01647992804646492, -0.03545390069484711, -0.011138935573399067, 0.03460228815674782, 0.024798717349767685, -0.01600991003215313, -0.03100735880434513, -0.0006568013341166079, 0.020996522158384323, 0.0010847762459889054, -0.034426022320985794, 0.058486200869083405, 0.00797731988132, 0.0018612411804497242, 0.017309855669736862, -0.044049184769392014, -0.050944603979587555, -0.02970167063176632, 0.008254516869783401, 0.04756522551178932, 0.006547968368977308, 0.004756887909024954, -0.04847266152501106, -0.01849343441426754, 0.05136344954371452, -0.019363773986697197, -0.00883719976991415, -0.07473967224359512, 0.01255855243653059, 0.008703307248651981, -0.00721393246203661, -0.06075036898255348, 0.006794283166527748, 0.013402966782450676, 0.02854575775563717, -0.03351406380534172, 0.02969406731426716, -0.05354008823633194, 0.018504561856389046, -0.010387868620455265, 0.05973820760846138, 0.0000695852140779607, 0.003651960985735059, -0.011212293058633804, 0.026615550741553307, 0.009554349817335606, -0.09206487983465195, -0.02076714113354683, 0.013307185843586922, 0.049000099301338196, 0.04697009548544884, -0.013103372417390347, -0.06866039335727692, 0.00753967696800828, -0.0037058067973703146, -0.041937801986932755, 0.02546880766749382, -0.0034365912433713675, 0.032107725739479065, 0.015050521120429039, -0.013926592655479908, 0.030984750017523766, 0.02754497155547142, -0.0003344381111674011, -0.025035111233592033, -0.037092115730047226, 0.04043952748179436, -0.017742697149515152, -0.014100578613579273, -0.06939376890659332, 0.011682199314236641, 0.0014687528600916266, 0.004369771108031273, 0.0035675198305398226, 0.003275003284215927, -0.016170818358659744, -0.0350918248295784, -0.0021468636114150286, 0.02493392676115036, 0.04455011710524559, 0.034880686551332474, -0.031411804258823395, -0.026594117283821106, -0.008686632849276066, -0.030836503952741623, 0.009507637470960617, -0.01825290359556675, 0.0005430883029475808, 0.02128531038761139, -0.0024656045716255903, 0.016062216833233833, -0.0040520476177334785, -0.03572973981499672, 0.018853146582841873, -0.057070352137088776, 0.0005884243873879313, 0.022992871701717377, 0.005723243113607168, 0.009992794133722782, -0.04605823755264282, -0.025156619027256966, -0.022541571408510208, -0.006424210499972105, 0.04989098757505417, -0.06770055741071701, 0.060113608837127686, -0.0011762825306504965, 0.0155718345195055, -0.08548057079315186, -0.0636885017156601, -0.017345109954476357, 0.016167227178812027, -0.028344247490167618, -0.027049709111452103, 0.014650662429630756, 0.013063710182905197, -0.029009854421019554, 0.004179914481937885, 0.04011372849345207, -0.006357710342854261, -0.019242536276578903, 0.010942679829895496, 0.009204898029565811, 0.09317699819803238, -0.001526092761196196, -0.009046068415045738, 0.0042629484087228775, -0.0324380025267601, -0.0050972155295312405, 0.0011764256050810218, 0.056339461356401443, -0.021858148276805878, -0.017063619568943977, 0.01863536424934864, -0.04837547615170479, 0.032796863466501236, -0.01897025667130947, -0.048683732748031616, -0.00758018484339118, 0.03070027567446232, -0.017538242042064667, 0.00014776243187952787, -0.020230691879987717, -0.014078162610530853, 0.022342538461089134, 0.005434447433799505, -0.0044917878694832325, -0.03246968239545822, 0.010688905604183674, 0.03136506676673889, 0.00971553660929203, 0.025717556476593018, 0.024011652916669846, 0.08002373576164246, -0.015929214656352997, -0.040861763060092926, -0.03811544179916382, -0.025104906409978867, 0.0282982736825943, -0.0032869908027350903, 0.005045539233833551, 0.01724538393318653, 0.008080840110778809, -0.02771332859992981, -0.002069569192826748, -0.05006980523467064, 0.013818911276757717, 0.02666357345879078, -0.008492828346788883, 0.06912160664796829, 0.03182442858815193, -0.004640586674213409, -0.006085562985390425, -0.01719554141163826, -0.01715700514614582, -0.007657731417566538, 0.005482679232954979, 0.024336230009794235, -0.024923229590058327, 0.017986396327614784, 0.054694872349500656, 0.012854261323809624, -0.009197789244353771, 0.015292959287762642, -0.011421124450862408, 0.028845928609371185, 0.017947664484381676, 0.00727803586050868, -0.015947315841913223, 0.05029661953449249, -0.005932403728365898, 0.033618006855249405, -0.002205314813181758, -0.058306705206632614, 0.04778022691607475, -0.011924025602638721, 0.0029803391080349684, -0.05430590733885765, -0.02313225343823433, -0.006815833039581776, 0.038914989680051804, 0.013951843604445457, 0.03641233220696449, -0.0069044046103954315, 0.011250057257711887, 0.0002491224149707705, -0.0224089864641428, 0.010079490020871162, 0.008848712779581547, -0.062459807842969894, -0.02450093999505043, -0.0329781174659729, -0.027108987793326378, 0.013879680074751377, -0.0005196653073653579, -0.012113180942833424, 0.026769835501909256, -0.04963798448443413, 0.03450467437505722, 0.018109029158949852, 0.010084575042128563, -0.009726633317768574, 0.06860202550888062, 0.0264617707580328, 0.0035523937549442053, -0.03451424837112427, 0.014062423259019852, 0.13322888314723969, 0.05906374379992485, 0.010400451719760895, -0.07537917792797089, -0.010790931060910225, -0.0014013027539476752, -0.007155048195272684, -0.027284421026706696, 0.019314546138048172, 0.03968646749854088, -0.004081042483448982, 0.03224664553999901, 0.05731562525033951, -0.01632423885166645, -0.02149205096065998, 0.051479462534189224, -0.0031934992875903845, -0.027750490233302116, -0.01919892430305481, 0.04194695129990578, -0.008644619956612587, 0.0003134096332360059, -0.028122976422309875, 0.026696329936385155, -0.009150093421339989, 0.04002336040139198, -0.010960962623357773, -0.0047271158546209335, 0.0005116888787597418, -0.027279358357191086, -0.05964228883385658, -0.023967847228050232, 0.054688625037670135, -0.020378025248646736, -0.036353129893541336, -0.007394150365144014, 0.009351490996778011, -0.027321752160787582, -0.015791958197951317, 0.025655124336481094, 0.0034457400906831026, 0.01610824279487133, 0.028084715828299522, -0.022176949307322502, -0.05123044177889824, -0.03227628394961357, -0.03963736072182655, 0.01978628896176815, -0.029641836881637573, 0.01039190124720335, 0.024385496973991394, -0.008504020050168037, -0.007965689525008202, -0.02228217013180256, -0.02375066466629505, -0.007227540947496891, 0.02180751971900463, -0.011796164326369762, 0.00535981310531497, -0.02444012090563774, 0.012309800833463669, 0.016555866226553917, 0.029552731662988663, 0.0239724088460207, -0.03943599388003349, -0.014726237393915653, -0.01933106780052185, 0.05525226891040802, -0.00696068350225687, -0.006615879479795694, -0.003874102607369423, -0.05547789856791496, -0.04643791913986206, -0.013788528740406036, -0.021084818989038467, -0.013828030787408352, 0.05563338100910187, 0.020886365324258804, -0.014059833250939846, 0.046916525810956955, -0.0386052168905735, 0.03281830623745918, -0.0187113955616951, 0.028023187071084976, -0.028295615687966347, -0.007623523008078337, 0.007727595511823893, 0.05076701194047928, 0.007545655593276024, 0.015910128131508827, 0.020279815420508385, 0.045221876353025436, -0.015864595770835876, -0.015573049895465374, 0.004444698803126812, 0.006423264276236296, -0.04399622604250908, 0.04268015921115875, -0.016467714682221413, 0.013410602696239948, -0.0017676540883257985, 0.08448410779237747, -0.034515559673309326, 0.023074816912412643, -0.03049313835799694, 0.02034398354589939, -0.007405338808894157, -0.0487259179353714, 0.027838842943310738, 0.04279671236872673, 0.05173055827617645, -0.049810729920864105, -0.03691207990050316, -0.01000430341809988, 0.0169298704713583, -0.0064346035942435265, -0.007436717394739389, -0.025455454364418983, 0.002476009540259838, 0.018327735364437103, 0.013035484589636326, 0.019670244306325912, -0.009849609807133675, -0.0124426931142807, 0.030942726880311966, 0.07423793524503708, -0.010447670705616474, -0.009759407490491867, -0.002844237955287099, 0.04757188260555267, -0.012733666226267815, 0.0006933107506483793, 0.01767590641975403, 0.003800911596044898, 0.0008761711069382727, 0.05512383207678795, 0.012410953640937805, 0.029187418520450592, -0.04052026942372322, -0.018019096925854683, 0.06206567957997322, -0.019685417413711548, -0.03123944252729416, 0.032760780304670334, 0.0238331351429224, 0.01839050091803074, -0.0003491693641990423, 0.02682594582438469, 0.004911423660814762, 0.036764200776815414, -0.029134713113307953, 0.011875231750309467, -0.03210299462080002, -0.011357000097632408, 0.0002497875248081982, 0.009063459001481533, -0.009024009108543396, 0.025696096941828728, -0.001110742101445794, 0.004007332026958466, 0.01929713785648346, -0.0043230196461081505, 0.003807998960837722, 0.04374294355511665, -0.03389374539256096, -0.0028905344661325216, 0.03483732417225838, 0.014704503118991852, 0.03952568769454956, 0.04076407849788666, -0.003376173321157694, 0.04698529839515686, -0.03463742509484291, 0.004267258103936911, -0.09547029435634613, -0.010945728048682213, 0.05137886479496956, -0.00284370849840343, 0.03263913840055466, -0.009933852590620518, -0.030244382098317146, 0.0249004028737545, -0.050387248396873474, -0.019049976021051407, -0.00008265012729680166, -0.0366092287003994, -0.03039989247918129, 0.004877821542322636, -0.021185848861932755, 0.03924890607595444, 0.04922584816813469, 0.022950224578380585, 0.023743176832795143, 0.010348876006901264, -0.015472985804080963, -0.005531990434974432, -0.024586645886301994, 0.023354914039373398, -0.010845953598618507, -0.065998375415802, 0.048560675233602524, -0.027554335072636604, -0.017922349274158478, 0.007987407967448235, -0.018718933686614037, -0.027348950505256653, 0.008820909075438976, 0.010810556821525097, -0.016049059107899666, 0.05479728803038597, 0.03626549616456032, 0.006891684606671333, -0.02163941040635109, 0.004130588844418526, 0.023899920284748077, 0.024676021188497543, -0.024010462686419487, -0.01624143496155739, 0.04088115692138672, -0.044210538268089294, -0.06812835484743118, 0.03362404927611351, 0.015172300860285759, -0.03316891938447952, 0.013683189637959003, 0.012617477215826511, -0.008412877097725868, -0.01188501063734293, 0.03808470070362091, -0.06306838989257812, 0.02207694947719574, 0.04026579111814499, 0.02753427065908909, -0.0027517846319824457, -0.014640914276242256, 0.006648425478488207, -0.04763025790452957, 0.03825167566537857, 0.019508693367242813, -0.02167535573244095, -0.048966750502586365, 0.03384990990161896, -0.021127713844180107, 0.0007399562164209783, 0.011583991348743439, -0.030579175800085068, -0.06001432240009308, 0.00015084663755260408, 0.017815081402659416, 0.0021618104074150324, -0.02615402638912201, -0.027737781405448914, -0.004737961106002331, -0.06817492097616196, 0.038647882640361786, -0.01664387434720993, -0.02452700212597847, -0.07168760895729065, 0.0049344515427947044, -0.07017701119184494, -0.010794704779982567, 0.01355726644396782, -0.014141043648123741, 0.0024648569524288177, -0.020886316895484924, 0.03138040006160736, 0.04846227914094925, -0.033301059156656265, 0.013042813166975975, -0.030959472060203552, -0.046633727848529816, -0.026779495179653168, 0.007493244018405676, 0.01602203957736492, 0.027923142537474632, -0.0011675507994368672, -0.017144586890935898, 0.0220295712351799, -0.027083512395620346, 0.0036011843476444483, 0.03953659534454346, 0.02858351171016693, -0.032673172652721405, 0.06824711710214615, 0.011168334633111954, 0.03155519813299179, 0.008792787790298462, 0.024419713765382767, -0.03941795602440834, 0.032887354493141174, -0.016346901655197144, -0.027611298486590385, -0.01135935541242361, 0.04949108511209488, 0.032106831669807434, -0.05159187689423561, -0.0017589024500921369, 0.04584873840212822, -0.024823695421218872, -0.03270920366048813, 0.008111986331641674, 0.0011678506853058934, 0.023263853043317795, 0.01639389991760254, -0.00599777651950717, 0.014885219745337963, 0.023390527814626694, 0.024374591186642647, 0.004052250646054745, 0.03151397779583931, -0.03676547482609749, 0.006943342741578817, 0.027372386306524277, -0.012690340168774128, 0.03355206549167633, 0.009593792259693146, 0.05269483104348183, -0.03495343029499054, -0.00815474335104227, -0.0034459144808351994, -0.012697326019406319, 0.03336728736758232, 0.010519432835280895, 0.002455004258081317, 0.05622294172644615, -0.0140884043648839, 0.0263662226498127, -0.01113622635602951, -0.008936116471886635, -0.022998126223683357, -0.026666879653930664, 0.025462530553340912, 0.02861795388162136, -0.009356776252388954, -0.020284704864025116, -0.0022304821759462357, 0.010448049753904343, 0.062423307448625565, -0.039133019745349884, 0.025383178144693375, 0.023401273414492607, -0.0010856324806809425, -0.032236456871032715, -0.010290085338056087, -0.020475680008530617, -0.019426478073000908, 0.013855567201972008, 0.027104927226901054, 0.025541730225086212, 0.016551686450839043, -0.007232022006064653, -0.004567342810332775, 0.06478266417980194, -0.05699549615383148, -0.024789825081825256, -0.003923559561371803, 0.016124406829476357, 0.015968050807714462, -0.05076882615685463 ]
<p>I've studied machine learning and statistics only very briefly. I've used linear regression to solve problems with fixed sets of variables, but I'm not sure how to approach the following problem.</p> <p>Given a bunch of tagged photos, I'd like to use the tags to estimate the probability that a specific object is contained within the photo. </p> <p>I have access to a wealth of data which has already been classified as either containing the objects we're looking for or not (however note that this is not a classification problem; the probabilities are being used to rank photos).</p> <p>For example. If a photo is tagged with <em>coke</em> and <em>drink</em>, there is a high probability it contains coca-cola. However if a photo is tagged with <em>coke</em> and <em>crack</em>, there is a high probability it does not contain coca-cola. If a photo is tagged with either <em>crack</em> or <em>drink</em> separately, that doesn't tell us much about what might be in the photo.</p> <p>How would one go about building a hypothesis formula for this problem?</p>
74,043
[ -0.01438666507601738, -0.0291141327470541, 0.012417168356478214, 0.005190227180719376, -0.004113767761737108, -0.012982585467398167, -0.04386929050087929, -0.009391091763973236, 0.029054904356598854, -0.023920366540551186, 0.03176772966980934, 0.05232444405555725, 0.03799637779593468, 0.034357234835624695, 0.009876401163637638, 0.029223384335637093, 0.004371107090264559, -0.0040016938000917435, -0.019819825887680054, 0.0009981769835576415, 0.015224052593111992, 0.021310722455382347, -0.008497446775436401, 0.00553834019228816, -0.03317047283053398, 0.030729610472917557, 0.03662775456905365, -0.03601188585162163, 0.050440769642591476, 0.03140551969408989, -0.018281051889061928, -0.062211792916059494, 0.0283968485891819, 0.024734580889344215, 0.017764262855052948, 0.012528663501143456, -0.025777043774724007, -0.04151317849755287, 0.0008414059411734343, 0.03042701445519924, -0.01462802104651928, -0.028877072036266327, 0.021638477221131325, 0.03389039635658264, -0.04497803375124931, 0.023722024634480476, -0.038347166031599045, -0.026163501664996147, 0.019033975899219513, -0.04329419508576393, 0.06364154070615768, -0.003914612345397472, 0.054900653660297394, 0.0666525661945343, -0.018993522971868515, 0.02518502064049244, 0.028396911919116974, 0.0596030130982399, 0.0022889773827046156, -0.05785275623202324, -0.017715344205498695, -0.02138604409992695, -0.02996709942817688, -0.017537686973810196, 0.006338106002658606, -0.012785478495061398, -0.015722783282399178, -0.006868189200758934, 0.05990130826830864, 0.009326006285846233, 0.03392694890499115, -0.008805226534605026, 0.04193323105573654, -0.015886830165982246, -0.015217049978673458, -0.008330261334776878, 0.0015743693802505732, 0.03051283210515976, 0.022915072739124298, 0.004260447807610035, 0.018289778381586075, 0.005974995903670788, -0.019107816740870476, 0.04377862066030502, 0.036564216017723083, -0.03794803470373154, 0.033426012843847275, -0.02127128466963768, 0.0354708731174469, -0.005453514866530895, -0.016179116442799568, -0.011041870340704918, 0.0330420546233654, 0.0003795707307290286, -0.041438326239585876, 0.0442705899477005, -0.016031252220273018, 0.025913281366229057, 0.03521258383989334, 0.004771101754158735, -0.005227182526141405, -0.02179964818060398, -0.011687923222780228, 0.05757477879524231, -0.018459448590874672, -0.010563774965703487, -0.037090834230184555, 0.002010979922488332, 0.018703868612647057, -0.002652069553732872, -0.024018412455916405, 0.04149209335446358, 0.03881518542766571, -0.006624886300414801, 0.009273714385926723, -0.02011350728571415, -0.02247837372124195, -0.031119853258132935, 0.058126531541347504, 0.06900732219219208, 0.04228171706199646, -0.048300836235284805, 0.024947350844740868, -0.03282518312335014, -0.04014565795660019, 0.017462952062487602, 0.0041684047318995, 0.00325522618368268, -0.043176647275686264, 0.05312994867563248, -0.011976275593042374, -0.03433799743652344, 0.006337430793792009, -0.03418891504406929, 0.010409507900476456, -0.007080220617353916, -0.06589438021183014, -0.023952769115567207, 0.007417695131152868, -0.007057852111756802, -0.036652930080890656, -0.03337334096431732, -0.00918886810541153, 0.020812012255191803, 0.054919250309467316, -0.02131403423845768, 0.032553669065237045, 0.015325307846069336, 0.018027693033218384, 0.006563566625118256, -0.013386600650846958, -0.048954688012599945, -0.033809732645750046, 0.0181695818901062, -0.026010140776634216, -0.10315784811973572, 0.03132228925824165, -0.0006382432184182107, -0.01140670944005251, 0.006811294239014387, 0.029983054846525192, -0.0014117603423073888, -0.017560843378305435, 0.012919439002871513, 0.0468914732336998, -0.042307429015636444, 0.08521712571382523, 0.004770857747644186, 0.05726972967386246, 0.016826769337058067, -0.004800533875823021, 0.017073867842555046, 0.03134240210056305, 0.01740524359047413, 0.028916627168655396, 0.011323027312755585, 0.005567680113017559, 0.0008696623262949288, 0.025432640686631203, -0.009017007425427437, -0.0033247368410229683, -0.023604685440659523, -0.022444548085331917, 0.007961743511259556, 0.051217492669820786, 0.015148181468248367, 0.03137148916721344, -0.04189232364296913, 0.03083464689552784, -0.03256896138191223, -0.028818627819418907, -0.07965260744094849, -0.009214557707309723, -0.055625393986701965, -0.006063410546630621, 0.04941095784306526, 0.009690224193036556, -0.021592864766716957, -0.01622009091079235, -0.014846709556877613, 0.012221942655742168, -0.005873411428183317, 0.03239407017827034, -0.025310920551419258, -0.025784464552998543, 0.04788556322455406, 0.026123668998479843, -0.02926936186850071, 0.02894916571676731, -0.0389380156993866, -0.021866928786039352, 0.021106235682964325, -0.04479047656059265, -0.011211303062736988, -0.026323994621634483, -0.012608352117240429, 0.0052536106668412685, -0.008225984871387482, -0.006366870366036892, 0.015119241550564766, -0.014444380067288876, 0.0504986010491848, 0.05956536903977394, 0.0026145277079194784, 0.016123903915286064, -0.01268171425908804, 0.029773497954010963, 0.006551042199134827, -0.02651839144527912, -0.05619311332702637, -0.07398727536201477, -0.01338410098105669, 0.023746732622385025, 0.030502334237098694, -0.027481839060783386, 0.008129098452627659, 0.07324358820915222, 0.042790818959474564, 0.01348209660500288, 0.019726015627384186, -0.04404838755726814, 0.01329084113240242, 0.007713018450886011, -0.005180302541702986, 0.02760041505098343, -0.0014018095098435879, -0.030419424176216125, 0.005257266573607922, 0.028165338560938835, -0.00693836435675621, -0.015480373054742813, 0.026486031711101532, 0.022544536739587784, 0.02105608396232128, -0.009371943771839142, -0.0133962482213974, 0.03182387724518776, -0.019492197781801224, -0.010659027844667435, 0.03105872869491577, -0.0027190791442990303, 0.0003404442686587572, 0.004976906813681126, -0.025914883241057396, 0.0037088540848344564, 0.04216604679822922, -0.05981901288032532, 0.04390858858823776, 0.0067823780700564384, -0.020169883966445923, 0.043974459171295166, 0.029444485902786255, -0.03207724168896675, -0.0104674082249403, 0.02338295988738537, 0.028480984270572662, -0.025893522426486015, 0.037693608552217484, -0.02573053352534771, -0.004468246828764677, -0.010986708104610443, -0.03228209167718887, -0.01916414313018322, -0.004998368211090565, -0.04279932379722595, -0.01618110202252865, -0.03639838472008705, -0.03835480287671089, 0.013121804222464561, 0.014552492648363113, -0.03346032276749611, 0.003706082934513688, -0.009107201360166073, -0.0496961809694767, -0.04044333100318909, -0.006903192028403282, 0.009898875840008259, -0.0484737902879715, -0.040691718459129333, 0.024409476667642593, 0.02136191911995411, -0.04433333873748779, 0.02212785929441452, -0.016788965091109276, -0.02404874376952648, -0.04384205490350723, 0.001883491757325828, 0.0076715340837836266, -0.009123292751610279, 0.010037713684141636, 0.026553792878985405, 0.01889164187014103, 0.015062027610838413, -0.07675881683826447, -0.08987190574407578, 0.04100913926959038, 0.017124531790614128, 0.0030540674924850464, 0.01658722013235092, -0.01694253273308277, 0.08134592324495316, 0.06260672211647034, -0.03770964965224266, -0.036015577614307404, -0.021950826048851013, -0.002651400398463011, 0.00845385156571865, 0.0011501021217554808, 0.015586256980895996, 0.0034620757214725018, 0.03378625214099884, -0.002325968584045768, 0.0034334883093833923, 0.052552592009305954, -0.002963378094136715, 0.010481296107172966, 0.00767124630510807, 0.018293464556336403, -0.00920055154711008, 0.06048895791172981, 0.03903906047344208, -0.02769942209124565, 0.02174174040555954, -0.02167753502726555, -0.006185744423419237, 0.0069409203715622425, -0.040997397154569626, -0.02071360871195793, -0.030944116413593292, -0.006423372775316238, -0.007601494435220957, 0.048834290355443954, 0.008945491164922714, -0.03282899409532547, 0.03885148838162422, 0.008494569920003414, 0.031108999624848366, 0.0029165816958993673, 0.03980966657400131, 0.04122291877865791, 0.05770041421055794, -0.07870133221149445, -0.04467514529824257, -0.04615006968379021, -0.02971339039504528, 0.004437875468283892, -0.01955336518585682, -0.010248995386064053, 0.05377620458602905, 0.017533818259835243, 0.014470560476183891, 0.011960910633206367, -0.02620616741478443, -0.016080334782600403, -0.043504443019628525, -0.02093563787639141, 0.014299312606453896, 0.0405614897608757, -0.001903652329929173, 0.05503440275788307, -0.002943317871540785, -0.024515198543667793, 0.011986255645751953, 0.04084322601556778, -0.06480134278535843, 0.028701085597276688, 0.017201483249664307, 0.006340003572404385, 0.0007385002099908888, -0.05760107934474945, 0.055773600935935974, -0.017862310633063316, 0.008942835032939911, -0.013251694850623608, 0.04841920733451843, -0.05606716126203537, 0.01383948139846325, -0.020938707515597343, 0.002733436645939946, -0.01726587861776352, -0.0028885933570563793, 0.027935603633522987, 0.008018185384571552, 0.010912866331636906, 0.021815892308950424, -0.0329238697886467, -0.014925150200724602, -0.018777238205075264, -0.001213188050314784, 0.03611498326063156, 0.030062256380915642, -0.00181140739005059, 0.0066129546612501144, -0.03091263771057129, -0.00031829762156121433, 0.008013786748051643, 0.048794642090797424, 0.02273351512849331, -0.006840046029537916, -0.021863404661417007, -0.06661098450422287, -0.02384193055331707, -0.013431549072265625, 0.015813063830137253, -0.03545602411031723, 0.010623276233673096, 0.06809962540864944, 0.003908892162144184, -0.04426531866192818, 0.04187505319714546, 0.08315538614988327, 0.03558512032032013, -0.0023916312493383884, -0.053593117743730545, -0.013828963041305542, 0.013131854124367237, -0.0021376945078372955, 0.030072076246142387, 0.03945612162351608, 0.012031936086714268, -0.019157644361257553, 0.04217807203531265, -0.005787525791674852, -0.07857771217823029, -0.010902264155447483, -0.026740223169326782, 0.016610465943813324, -0.019048091024160385, -0.049475520849227905, 0.013331198133528233, 0.032079678028821945, 0.061911892145872116, 0.012714159674942493, 0.0062460084445774555, -0.08652003854513168, 0.00020431568555068225, 0.06171000003814697, 0.08329851925373077, -0.04026326909661293, -0.02650904282927513, -0.02393416129052639, -0.002702454337850213, 0.03860364854335785, -0.028136640787124634, 0.017840169370174408, 0.025197695940732956, 0.009323643520474434, 0.021697627380490303, -0.03728483244776726, -0.04014287143945694, 0.007146899588406086, -0.050298165529966354, 0.018712280318140984, -0.03549030423164368, -0.04224139451980591, -0.03216290473937988, 0.018525755032896996, 0.04269290715456009, 0.0493534617125988, 0.008607732132077217, -0.015461345203220844, 0.005169149953871965, 0.010934471152722836, -0.008444997482001781, -0.029497947543859482, -0.006697689648717642, -0.032218676060438156, -0.021305572241544724, 0.057456906884908676, 0.014727657660841942, -0.03406981751322746, -0.011543824337422848, -0.011882689781486988, -0.07437275350093842, -0.014846112579107285, -0.015822090208530426, 0.0017639757134020329, 0.054000988602638245, 0.017695847898721695, 0.02297036536037922, 0.016087926924228668, 0.008330581709742546, -0.004493986256420612, -0.018066775053739548, 0.008662354201078415, 0.010551546700298786, 0.012374301441013813, -0.01723029650747776, 0.0000160049839905696, -0.054726291447877884, 0.00464768148958683, -0.014977182261645794, 0.018257511779665947, -0.01155098620802164, -0.020835552364587784, -0.0007626762380823493, 0.015153234824538231, -0.014716774225234985, -0.0020103114657104015, 0.00902093667536974, 0.009728449396789074, 0.023350121453404427, 0.016380732879042625, 0.008898275904357433, -0.0032802943605929613, 0.019382737576961517, -0.002941662212833762, -0.02844611369073391, 0.03006206825375557, -0.0448821559548378, -0.001078781089745462, 0.005195961333811283, -0.013775238767266273, 0.04169869422912598, 0.027952607721090317, 0.02724480628967285, -0.034752629697322845, -0.02716211974620819, -0.026901686564087868, 0.006316907703876495, 0.011185476556420326, 0.044164448976516724, -0.01965893618762493, 0.04726039990782738, -0.0394357405602932, -0.019148001447319984, -0.047346342355012894, -0.03308390825986862, 0.0017110822955146432, 0.045803431421518326, -0.0368645004928112, -0.049254510551691055, 0.04768329858779907, 0.005479970946907997, -0.010008815675973892, -0.011249725706875324, 0.086719810962677, -0.029865257441997528, -0.009452955797314644, 0.012596732005476952, -0.014759223908185959, 0.07044420391321182, 0.005961855407804251, -0.014225474558770657, 0.03390993922948837, 0.028097081929445267, 0.019868599250912666, 0.010743382386863232, -0.020861288532614708, -0.037800077348947525, -0.043184544891119, -0.058473359793424606, 0.0521363690495491, 0.052329301834106445, -0.043597735464572906, 0.00549030676484108, -0.023366611450910568, 0.03798993304371834, 0.019608130678534508, -0.018851635977625847, 0.026175551116466522, 0.012380722910165787, -0.025703422725200653, -0.009984002448618412, 0.025783998891711235, -0.022585010156035423, -0.018462006002664566, 0.013595868833363056, -0.005685399752110243, 0.01567661389708519, 0.0049374401569366455, 0.07227476686239243, -0.02133137173950672, 0.044336382299661636, -0.0027387975715100765, -0.015836376696825027, 0.059430934488773346, 0.03206281736493111, -0.016318142414093018, 0.0399150475859642, 0.010880708694458008, -0.059750739485025406, 0.003177870763465762, -0.04368963465094566, -0.04075392335653305, 0.07098927348852158, -0.03776191920042038, 0.02744496986269951, 0.04142970219254494, -0.023495852947235107, 0.02126290090382099, -0.02617720700800419, 0.012762680649757385, 0.01070777140557766, -0.02111431583762169, 0.03295333683490753, 0.014035719446837902, -0.013456556014716625, 0.07590057700872421, -0.011966198682785034, 0.03268519788980484, 0.03996720537543297, 0.03689419478178024, 0.04819045215845108, 0.03371458500623703, -0.04450759291648865, -0.026510650292038918, 0.016691429540514946, -0.0715675875544548, 0.0017971833003684878, -0.0004306166374590248, -0.046702656894922256, 0.055948544293642044, 0.041137855499982834, 0.0184613224118948, -0.028393922373652458, -0.04182637110352516, -0.08251453191041946, 0.04783017933368683, 0.025931017473340034, -0.012828596867620945, 0.004105798900127411, -0.000203455172595568, -0.008086320012807846, 0.00199771486222744, 0.024463100358843803, -0.00854169949889183, -0.042682111263275146, -0.012780971825122833, -0.024159032851457596, -0.023813921958208084, -0.016393473371863365, 0.011294830590486526, -0.02405225671827793, 0.00024930707877501845, -0.05332737788558006, 0.014489958994090557, 0.03475242853164673, 0.07205593585968018, -0.011751496233046055, 0.04787002503871918, 0.009154869243502617, 0.0240229070186615, 0.011901848018169403, 0.0021860115230083466, 0.10690310597419739, 0.08475371450185776, 0.05264279618859291, -0.04097002372145653, -0.005981578957289457, 0.012503094971179962, -0.04163767024874687, -0.049237173050642014, 0.015142875723540783, 0.015365560539066792, 0.01200003270059824, -0.008754481561481953, 0.032732043415308, 0.008504301309585571, -0.04141994193196297, 0.034920141100883484, -0.08253489434719086, 0.014785121195018291, 0.034041423350572586, 0.004644047934561968, -0.010607920587062836, -0.020299600437283516, -0.0640910267829895, 0.0016786071937531233, 0.00040751919732429087, -0.0009363464778289199, -0.013440979644656181, -0.02863447554409504, -0.016604840755462646, -0.016222594305872917, 0.011940669268369675, -0.013870944269001484, 0.0024878066033124924, -0.003795051481574774, 0.005719118285924196, 0.016032014042139053, 0.04801678657531738, -0.014688273891806602, -0.00799634587019682, -0.01358471903949976, 0.03278467804193497, -0.025353427976369858, -0.006535131484270096, -0.006843242794275284, -0.029557688161730766, -0.0072067915461957455, -0.02894618734717369, 0.06051989272236824, -0.017269417643547058, -0.014523623511195183, 0.0166876669973135, -0.016895068809390068, -0.020824121311306953, -0.018008342012763023, -0.009966172277927399, 0.022312646731734276, 0.018002420663833618, 0.005299368407577276, -0.037872541695833206, -0.042559828609228134, 0.04471684247255325, -0.010748161002993584, 0.04534962773323059, 0.042790189385414124, 0.012394323013722897, -0.034680478274822235, -0.024780863896012306, 0.05252574756741524, 0.006148560903966427, 0.00432279147207737, -0.011105246841907501, -0.05242959037423134, -0.027910619974136353, -0.015408010222017765, 0.0016724677989259362, 0.008068757131695747, 0.009006681852042675, 0.002702937228605151, -0.02035352773964405, -0.004218272864818573, -0.03212475776672363, -0.019525853917002678, -0.019729038700461388, -0.016149459406733513, -0.03850479796528816, 0.03206761181354523, 0.0342162624001503, 0.03541366010904312, 0.007492559030652046, 0.011374945752322674, 0.03944506496191025, 0.06305583566427231, 0.013980014249682426, -0.048869453370571136, -0.004914766643196344, -0.023015636950731277, -0.0101739801466465, 0.002864639973267913, -0.008019600063562393, 0.06342018395662308, 0.004178159404546022, 0.013417874462902546, 0.005278674885630608, -0.005171460099518299, -0.02764245867729187, 0.028038090094923973, 0.00452034268528223, -0.03522232919931412, -0.05033368244767189, 0.0037454755511134863, -0.01352682150900364, -0.03770117834210396, -0.03433402255177498, 0.0029326442163437605, -0.0005093306535854936, 0.017325198277831078, -0.028351258486509323, -0.02234012633562088, -0.0495135597884655, 0.00935249961912632, 0.027688737958669662, -0.0022282719146460295, -0.035590529441833496, -0.01662769541144371, 0.014197515323758125, 0.005392369348555803, -0.028167055919766426, -0.042752787470817566, 0.013622484169900417, -0.0016033437568694353, -0.015313859097659588, 0.012399528175592422, 0.003862318117171526, 0.0025050663389265537, -0.01267122384160757, 0.013363020494580269, -0.03127521649003029, 0.07745900005102158, -0.017176203429698944, 0.0156251173466444, 0.03954143449664116, -0.019028518348932266, -0.009785966947674751, 0.0012749803718179464, 0.00045684020733460784, 0.03829842805862427, 0.039534635841846466, -0.008518638089299202, -0.021029798313975334, 0.03793001174926758, -0.02951972745358944, -0.044608429074287415, 0.00002207267789344769, 0.01044365856796503, -0.02176119014620781, -0.009413584135472775, 0.04384195804595947, 0.023827610537409782, -0.012596892192959785, -0.02018764801323414, 0.010665833950042725, 0.009473814629018307, -0.0016739985439926386, -0.006006807088851929, -0.028291989117860794, 0.026799941435456276, -0.01559445820748806, 0.024078087881207466, 0.02693529799580574, 0.06082246080040932, -0.023740338161587715, 0.05035929009318352, 0.022601505741477013, 0.008896520361304283, -0.08215419948101044, -0.042090028524398804, 0.03137749433517456, -0.009540800005197525, 0.06323922425508499, -0.09512212872505188, 0.019253328442573547, 0.05478490889072418, -0.03844844177365303, -0.03257808834314346, 0.0001890704152174294, 0.0004372209950815886, -0.01797064021229744, 0.05306359380483627, -0.028649238869547844, 0.022700641304254532, 0.013477635569870472, 0.04549584165215492, 0.06782862544059753, 0.034260645508766174, 0.0038547394797205925, -0.0028957673348486423, -0.03241550922393799, 0.015616853721439838, 0.019751904532313347, -0.032403599470853806, 0.03871558606624603, -0.011801584623754025, -0.02678084746003151, 0.02731388621032238, -0.042056694626808167, -0.002749443519860506, 0.0411858893930912, -0.012525917030870914, -0.03098694048821926, 0.021299198269844055, 0.021903375163674355, -0.003747224109247327, 0.0334479995071888, 0.019505731761455536, 0.015719430521130562, 0.023186564445495605, 0.007971440441906452, 0.008376818150281906, -0.008393784053623676, -0.007328583858907223, -0.02132320962846279, 0.04456872493028641, 0.010097689926624298, 0.0038555506616830826, 0.03591041639447212, 0.011243303306400776, 0.022905319929122925, -0.04118204489350319, 0.023860542103648186, -0.04666484147310257, 0.029492869973182678, 0.01655379682779312, 0.018894726410508156, -0.00944425631314516, -0.00899686198681593, -0.03529883548617363, -0.04737496376037598, 0.008370999246835709, 0.0076222228817641735, -0.033127330243587494, -0.05907457694411278, 0.016078762710094452, 0.03877097740769386, -0.018012141808867455, 0.006469240877777338, -0.015420482493937016, -0.03535408526659012, 0.05066410452127457, 0.009686734527349472, 0.053169988095760345, 0.04349721595644951, -0.00999907311052084, -0.0073153371922671795, -0.10767357051372528, 0.037235379219055176, -0.006722152233123779, -0.003933071158826351, -0.03028041124343872, 0.000008490214895573445, -0.04180767759680748, -0.00917532667517662, 0.043442294001579285, -0.03227009251713753, 0.012382102198898792, -0.03994819521903992, -0.012729084119200706, -0.014879819937050343, -0.029195692390203476, 0.005558643490076065, -0.028388291597366333, -0.007357467897236347, -0.012400475330650806, 0.00450053159147501, 0.010507297702133656, -0.003605062607675791, 0.01569119468331337, 0.009952248074114323, 0.011497135274112225, 0.04392881691455841, 0.016637910157442093, 0.02582605369389057, 0.018177978694438934, -0.002760002389550209, 0.039597027003765106, 0.018247554078698158, 0.005868649575859308, 0.024298561736941338, 0.022458449006080627, -0.05285162851214409, 0.05239706486463547, -0.02618304453790188, -0.06508199125528336, 0.01467101275920868, 0.011997940950095654, -0.013973859138786793, -0.07465231418609619, 0.01136129628866911, -0.0020407801494002342, -0.021937482059001923, 0.0014624816831201315, 0.01646900363266468, 0.013181876391172409, 0.07617200911045074, -0.005788202863186598, 0.028151441365480423, -0.01427230890840292, -0.003446115180850029, 0.007234841585159302, -0.0013603265397250652, -0.013032806105911732, -0.0043760850094258785, 0.04974885657429695, 0.03207605332136154, 0.023394055664539337, 0.034128233790397644, -0.004426132421940565, 0.009886550717055798, -0.01460306253284216, 0.01075048092752695, -0.011637149378657341, 0.029383672401309013, 0.028438085690140724, -0.0074932449497282505, 0.007535790093243122, 0.037506673485040665, -0.007660780102014542, -0.03399796411395073, -0.06878840178251266, 0.01921939104795456, -0.0030508970376104116, 0.017252301797270775, -0.003910829778760672, 0.014522342942655087, -0.0019449349492788315, 0.02033025026321411, 0.017624281346797943, 0.016593217849731445, 0.04662664607167244, 0.01937471330165863, -0.0008479157695546746, -0.03018309734761715, -0.05944440886378288, -0.01997148059308529, -0.004864085931330919, -0.004088970832526684, -0.007439290173351765, -0.01502882968634367, 0.05426906794309616, -0.0010285918833687901, -0.003618265502154827, -0.010993687435984612, -0.03646489605307579, 0.03881818428635597, -0.04914429038763046, 0.002072700532153249, -0.08458377420902252, 0.005674915853887796, -0.01969480700790882, -0.059559084475040436 ]
<p>There is quite some content online interpreting odds in a logistic model with a dichotomous predictor. My problem is understanding coefficients when there are more than 2 levels for a categorical variable. How do you <em>define the odds</em> then?</p> <pre><code>Data: X is a single categorical predictor with 4 levels: teenager, adult, mature, senior. Y: 1=smoking, 0=non smoking. LR: We use n-1 dummy variables. I chose adult as the reference bin as it had the highest concentration. (ok??) ________ | Intercepts | p adult | -4.3801 | 0 teenager | -0.32456 | 0 mature | 1.45119 | 0 old | -0.9891 | 0 </code></pre> <p><strong>Interpreting the coefficients</strong></p> <p>Teenager: Teen is less likely to smoke (w.r.t adult?). In fact, a teen is 28% (exp-0.32456 -1) less likely to smoke THAN AN ADULT. Is odds of teenager smoking always mentioned against the reference group?</p> <p>Mature: Matures is more to smoke (w.r.t adult?). In fact, a mature is 326% more likely to smoke THAN AN ADULT. Is odds of mature smoking always mentioned against the reference group? </p>
33,684
[ -0.040021903812885284, 0.002893513534218073, 0.00928723718971014, 0.004903984721750021, 0.032193828374147415, 0.013929104432463646, 0.021413234993815422, -0.0492040254175663, 0.04268746078014374, -0.035547636449337006, 0.0348476767539978, 0.06319420039653778, 0.045677490532398224, 0.01410814467817545, 0.028564363718032837, 0.02791651524603367, 0.008129962719976902, 0.01999663934111595, 0.0013790610246360302, 0.0063591767102479935, -0.03383231535553932, 0.012144693173468113, 0.012006448581814766, 0.008803286589682102, 0.026754675433039665, 0.06838148087263107, 0.007165437564253807, -0.03508777916431427, -0.0010648728348314762, -0.002700719516724348, -0.0051873959600925446, -0.061253149062395096, 0.011514374986290932, -0.022403830662369728, 0.025010108947753906, 0.024329228326678276, 0.009019154123961926, -0.007434492465108633, -0.022688187658786774, 0.02610829286277294, -0.04368574917316437, -0.027630090713500977, -0.016807787120342255, 0.0137332146987319, -0.027690861374139786, 0.0547928661108017, -0.004875893238931894, -0.023451905697584152, 0.054000373929739, -0.03770787641406059, 0.05662044510245323, -0.005205188412219286, 0.031991131603717804, 0.06537006795406342, -0.03202854096889496, 0.0047137015499174595, 0.05813313275575638, 0.05788369104266167, -0.020720286294817924, -0.027468981221318245, -0.03969455882906914, -0.030878162011504173, 0.01232896838337183, 0.01046075951308012, -0.04014354571700096, -0.0005534188239835203, 0.0032141776755452156, -0.04337485134601593, 0.031995151191949844, -0.02639041095972061, 0.04049328714609146, 0.023416610434651375, 0.03725028410553932, 0.002271328354254365, -0.014040805399417877, -0.016505006700754166, 0.013522556982934475, 0.004197307396680117, 0.01361763197928667, 0.025875825434923172, -0.009384378790855408, 0.021318625658750534, 0.0037244921550154686, 0.01573784463107586, 0.006380822975188494, -0.017673982307314873, 0.0746782049536705, -0.02276759408414364, 0.01278852391988039, 0.00812356173992157, -0.03146306425333023, -0.003459997707977891, 0.037448033690452576, 0.026540853083133698, -0.035762980580329895, 0.03669550642371178, -0.02515224739909172, 0.017185648903250694, 0.013747802935540676, 0.0424574613571167, 0.000529664393980056, -0.03773943707346916, 0.03307778388261795, 0.04232809320092201, -0.03377499431371689, -0.027545388787984848, -0.06795306503772736, -0.0006834980449639261, 0.011302351020276546, -0.044041749089956284, 0.0011431523598730564, 0.025277215987443924, -0.027881866320967674, -0.02321695163846016, 0.015261716209352016, -0.009363900870084763, -0.00001662546674197074, -0.004036814905703068, 0.035014137625694275, 0.02231067605316639, 0.03738650307059288, -0.02313309535384178, 0.019218258559703827, -0.0008194553083740175, -0.02994026429951191, 0.0042775156907737255, 0.029433781281113625, 0.003410556586459279, -0.026573359966278076, 0.0373893678188324, -0.008542729541659355, -0.006256106309592724, 0.02470533549785614, 0.05113104358315468, 0.038417112082242966, 0.004208707716315985, -0.06164686381816864, -0.061561886221170425, 0.023005640134215355, -0.005680329632014036, -0.0034280044492334127, -0.0855414941906929, -0.001211300608702004, 0.058167602866888046, 0.052453331649303436, -0.01639755815267563, 0.04250941053032875, 0.006798126734793186, 0.016489306464791298, 0.03703739866614342, -0.016714520752429962, 0.013199570588767529, -0.04189259931445122, -0.017372651025652885, -0.019165150821208954, -0.0780021995306015, 0.04197687283158302, 0.026421017944812775, -0.0044068885035812855, -0.0044451188296079636, 0.026226572692394257, -0.01995887979865074, -0.04085782915353775, 0.041592035442590714, -0.007201399654150009, -0.017687156796455383, 0.0772060751914978, -0.021654807031154633, 0.015979614108800888, 0.036949239671230316, 0.011737961322069168, 0.039724186062812805, 0.024058811366558075, 0.05834915116429329, 0.036013003438711166, 0.016267426311969757, -0.04242051765322685, -0.012275462970137596, 0.026063868775963783, 0.018526125699281693, -0.0693942978978157, -0.019739117473363876, -0.00896721612662077, -0.013040647841989994, 0.038941580802202225, 0.002032011980190873, -0.019146552309393883, -0.0292280912399292, 0.0512409582734108, -0.02015361189842224, -0.046641383320093155, -0.06437357515096664, 0.030740218237042427, -0.015821950510144234, -0.006646360736340284, -0.00033156792051158845, -0.010015767067670822, 0.0142705999314785, -0.025966044515371323, 0.039752453565597534, -0.016689972952008247, -0.008297816850244999, 0.03342393785715103, -0.0493556410074234, 0.00510967243462801, 0.026628609746694565, 0.02547328919172287, -0.023194506764411926, 0.03912514075636864, -0.05968106910586357, -0.06164111569523811, 0.015920544043183327, -0.014041099697351456, 0.010953829623758793, -0.015473079867661, -0.022136718034744263, -0.004901079460978508, -0.013126395642757416, -0.05281513184309006, 0.06183391064405441, -0.10230652242898941, 0.05981893464922905, 0.04462514445185661, 0.007641176227480173, -0.03196738287806511, 0.0030484215822070837, 0.0006598916952498257, 0.02960318699479103, -0.01341265719383955, -0.04477683827280998, -0.039243001490831375, -0.018915893509984016, 0.02835785411298275, -0.0016488482942804694, -0.048769909888505936, 0.026696033775806427, 0.040882501751184464, 0.027454709634184837, -0.015600239858031273, 0.03140030801296234, 0.016024312004446983, -0.01361799519509077, -0.016803426668047905, 0.006642690394073725, -0.009698492474853992, 0.022003790363669395, 0.032456863671541214, 0.04331393539905548, -0.018458401784300804, 0.03055047057569027, -0.03268076106905937, 0.08181830495595932, -0.009944894351065159, 0.01800190843641758, 0.005232651252299547, -0.015363050624728203, 0.09014921635389328, -0.03378208726644516, 0.03562634438276291, 0.038804393261671066, 0.01732061430811882, -0.0159287191927433, 0.019378384575247765, 0.01527476217597723, 0.0010142959654331207, 0.07929163426160812, -0.06311551481485367, -0.00467441463842988, 0.007456750608980656, -0.03766229748725891, 0.008515003137290478, -0.01455566007643938, -0.03443681821227074, -0.000026525522116571665, -0.00700412830337882, 0.027448225766420364, -0.009924850426614285, 0.0004390570684336126, -0.018575968220829964, -0.021015357226133347, -0.04089823365211487, 0.005242088809609413, 0.012382379733026028, -0.01115531288087368, -0.0338958315551281, -0.046003442257642746, -0.04222888872027397, 0.0005983414012007415, 0.03765755891799927, 0.00021350373572204262, -0.07047118246555328, -0.0010454144794493914, -0.014840146526694298, -0.055305011570453644, -0.01426786184310913, 0.003991724457591772, -0.03794026002287865, -0.013151840306818485, -0.024425184354186058, 0.007314127869904041, 0.0015317233046516776, -0.0037137658800929785, 0.020808465778827667, -0.028756937012076378, -0.04369579628109932, 0.006492654327303171, 0.0007496834150515497, 0.030621850863099098, 0.025588003918528557, 0.0009592032874934375, 0.010491902008652687, -0.02183181792497635, 0.02828964777290821, -0.09415536373853683, -0.07326541095972061, 0.03770139813423157, 0.026677828282117844, 0.016746144741773605, 0.012151915580034256, -0.008530514314770699, 0.03892532363533974, 0.028041694313287735, -0.014496146701276302, -0.06611377000808716, -0.009498747065663338, -0.05470738187432289, -0.013885894790291786, 0.02426285296678543, 0.03204939141869545, 0.05343487113714218, 0.03591221198439598, -0.03435777127742767, 0.0018023260636255145, 0.041178103536367416, 0.010699614882469177, 0.020516926422715187, 0.03156404569745064, 0.01415780559182167, -0.019369062036275864, 0.02929961495101452, 0.03925725072622299, -0.025423265993595123, 0.020379407331347466, -0.023859135806560516, 0.06320059299468994, -0.008192818611860275, -0.03019026108086109, 0.02248542197048664, 0.003987571224570274, -0.021843383088707924, -0.026753172278404236, 0.05136910080909729, 0.03324110060930252, -0.025926001369953156, -0.007455131970345974, 0.006179770454764366, 0.010115575976669788, -0.012554732151329517, 0.005784306209534407, 0.03882506117224693, 0.015452306717634201, -0.04511578381061554, 0.011272696778178215, 0.026710184291005135, -0.01946248859167099, 0.03318750485777855, -0.04437439888715744, -0.012387487106025219, 0.03715187683701515, 0.049376990646123886, -0.024369757622480392, -0.026145871728658676, -0.06605622917413712, 0.0551464781165123, -0.0664091557264328, -0.023389901965856552, -0.00479118013754487, 0.026880186051130295, -0.013775327242910862, 0.023362237960100174, -0.012859567068517208, -0.016540372744202614, 0.018580477684736252, 0.004008610732853413, -0.04510274901986122, 0.018041187897324562, 0.024442017078399658, 0.010074748657643795, 0.00472766300663352, -0.048178527504205704, 0.07026110589504242, -0.015580407343804836, -0.032659489661455154, 0.019078150391578674, 0.01628609374165535, -0.0025543321389704943, 0.02553677372634411, 0.0008791493019089103, -0.006070420145988464, 0.004526915960013866, 0.01564914546906948, 0.009987860918045044, 0.002587363589555025, 0.02673732303082943, 0.042771968990564346, -0.027758024632930756, -0.01720011979341507, -0.048944853246212006, 0.019923197105526924, 0.046897418797016144, 0.007587066385895014, 0.021320322528481483, 0.006826560478657484, -0.03612753003835678, 0.014995208010077477, -0.01379493810236454, 0.04900183528661728, 0.05461680889129639, -0.016828296706080437, -0.04304267838597298, -0.0220032911747694, -0.01022123172879219, -0.011067241430282593, -0.007007332984358072, -0.02084534615278244, 0.02291015535593033, 0.06228441745042801, 0.02470594272017479, -0.09021978080272675, 0.03629796952009201, 0.03838517516851425, 0.02654806524515152, -0.009610462933778763, -0.05367151275277138, -0.017942434176802635, -0.007008044980466366, 0.012239581905305386, 0.049000825732946396, -0.01037628948688507, -0.01342654787003994, -0.019563334062695503, 0.06958132982254028, 0.000357832876034081, -0.06857747584581375, 0.036077894270420074, 0.00017450404993724078, 0.015395589172840118, 0.0002205831988248974, -0.0779019370675087, -0.003950681071728468, 0.053515370935201645, 0.03949771076440811, -0.004604971967637539, -0.018881257623434067, -0.06421958655118942, -0.006027526222169399, 0.01591537334024906, 0.056884344667196274, -0.05391458794474602, -0.02394690550863743, 0.0192920733243227, 0.01061275415122509, 0.005194298457354307, -0.025927912443876266, -0.016222653910517693, -0.04539357125759125, 0.030699441209435463, 0.006762998178601265, -0.0395374521613121, -0.03351829573512077, 0.01632155291736126, -0.0036210149992257357, 0.013312983326613903, -0.0008160229190252721, -0.012759490869939327, -0.04161224514245987, 0.005693581886589527, 0.017847567796707153, 0.04371338710188866, -0.021897831931710243, -0.03476398438215256, 0.0062120952643454075, 0.00027458995464257896, -0.007161176763474941, -0.05536084994673729, 0.008506660349667072, -0.0031719093676656485, 0.001324086799286306, 0.0704672560095787, -0.012895524501800537, -0.02633524127304554, -0.019551856443285942, 0.02843404933810234, -0.031061844900250435, 0.017510822042822838, -0.044814519584178925, 0.04033544659614563, 0.010981632396578789, 0.004641291219741106, 0.058753304183483124, 0.039157748222351074, 0.0006918738945387304, 0.04174885153770447, -0.06582531332969666, 0.004012760706245899, -0.005940336734056473, -0.01962330937385559, -0.04055667296051979, -0.023988889530301094, 0.011674393899738789, 0.03166668489575386, -0.014399898238480091, 0.007026705890893936, -0.01346142403781414, -0.028453495353460312, 0.042829666286706924, 0.02586359530687332, -0.002228909870609641, -0.01986711658537388, 0.014551065862178802, 0.021335428580641747, -0.0014803230296820402, -0.024550074711441994, 0.0292165819555521, -0.033481910824775696, 0.02814859338104725, 0.023044748231768608, -0.016032272949814796, 0.001973704667761922, -0.0020227632485330105, -0.037913743406534195, -0.0018309853039681911, 0.010586241260170937, 0.01452627219259739, 0.0010562101379036903, 0.03590551018714905, 0.009064207784831524, -0.02041199617087841, -0.028144268319010735, 0.008090931922197342, -0.028689878061413765, 0.022608378902077675, -0.014960934408009052, 0.04712459072470665, -0.0016576709458604455, -0.016615791246294975, -0.03879275918006897, -0.05035005137324333, 0.01432088389992714, 0.012975243851542473, -0.03830532357096672, -0.034696657210588455, 0.01849636249244213, -0.02328486554324627, -0.0074279289692640305, -0.00547165097668767, 0.05455033481121063, -0.01605852134525776, -0.011544576846063137, 0.017433781176805496, 0.023641768842935562, 0.06584105640649796, -0.008982454426586628, 0.002875815611332655, 0.013744196854531765, -0.008695255033671856, -0.01923583634197712, -0.0050073894672095776, -0.03180847689509392, -0.01654299721121788, -0.030892977491021156, -0.022140823304653168, -0.01302152406424284, 0.02590310573577881, -0.01751859299838543, -0.04917416349053383, 0.01381894014775753, -0.018384000286459923, 0.03332851082086563, -0.026945946738123894, 0.008412682451307774, 0.00016031684936024249, 0.010958503931760788, -0.025606852024793625, 0.02605719491839409, -0.03487692028284073, 0.00005420333764050156, 0.025819825008511543, 0.014264777302742004, -0.012234237045049667, 0.03655127435922623, 0.0661083459854126, -0.008385851979255676, 0.05804302543401718, -0.01085940096527338, -0.003694141749292612, 0.06430786103010178, 0.017410803586244583, -0.005697269923985004, 0.023748990148305893, 0.02172922156751156, -0.0074144029058516026, -0.00857427529990673, -0.037277817726135254, 0.04241505265235901, 0.04003512114286423, -0.0230748038738966, 0.04947790503501892, 0.02845221757888794, -0.033611200749874115, 0.0066927410662174225, -0.0462859608232975, 0.011670161969959736, 0.0016861926997080445, -0.039997898042201996, 0.03564124554395676, -0.05041275545954704, -0.016349229961633682, 0.06093115359544754, 0.017184162512421608, 0.020733412355184555, 0.03246159479022026, 0.04533805325627327, -0.02145269699394703, 0.00015662852092646062, 0.00590592622756958, -0.005393896717578173, 0.030479324981570244, -0.05306299775838852, 0.011110855266451836, -0.0775824710726738, -0.0032493476755917072, 0.040455836802721024, 0.011141604743897915, 0.01912490837275982, -0.05806177482008934, -0.0246412493288517, -0.03098827786743641, -0.003608708269894123, 0.01837538182735443, 0.013285253196954727, 0.047297220677137375, -0.037209365516901016, 0.02816787175834179, -0.011957544833421707, 0.005761689972132444, -0.031916387379169464, -0.09515339881181717, -0.036316677927970886, 0.02479732595384121, -0.04600641131401062, 0.00658587459474802, -0.002464275574311614, -0.036068711429834366, 0.02294875867664814, -0.07216909527778625, 0.007855880074203014, 0.004746309947222471, 0.015872517600655556, 0.024002177640795708, 0.06652775406837463, 0.026836521923542023, -0.010747391730546951, -0.010179843753576279, 0.009961691685020924, 0.12515999376773834, 0.0869707316160202, 0.02935565449297428, -0.08986040949821472, 0.020374327898025513, 0.03070029616355896, -0.0017155775567516685, -0.001760608865879476, -0.031288255006074905, -0.002781449118629098, -0.00955804344266653, 0.04814014583826065, 0.038951851427555084, 0.041859354823827744, 0.009643969126045704, 0.048815224319696426, -0.05059267580509186, -0.021896304562687874, 0.01597849279642105, -0.011094188317656517, 0.011476139537990093, -0.004631604999303818, -0.010457002557814121, -0.033459316939115524, 0.06238628551363945, -0.019191665574908257, -0.020759860053658485, -0.027997644618153572, 0.02292921207845211, -0.002815927378833294, -0.03661833703517914, 0.007013522554188967, 0.01759728603065014, 0.0008601362933404744, -0.0063173286616802216, -0.032692547887563705, 0.037772975862026215, -0.023275334388017654, -0.017036516219377518, 0.036282017827034, -0.03533151373267174, -0.014860152266919613, 0.0140469865873456, 0.0432552732527256, -0.021539438515901566, -0.027364162728190422, -0.007705423980951309, 0.022562384605407715, -0.02933877892792225, -0.018357964232563972, -0.018883157521486282, 0.005231313407421112, -0.029066169634461403, -0.02537616714835167, -0.04372934252023697, 0.04893878102302551, 0.02408931404352188, -0.015131735242903233, -0.030759165063500404, -0.03779358044266701, 0.01553559023886919, -0.015310942195355892, 0.009565027430653572, 0.02778933010995388, -0.03548829257488251, -0.013618411496281624, -0.0783720538020134, 0.034671202301979065, 0.016591357067227364, 0.015722546726465225, 0.010863840579986572, 0.02532770112156868, 0.0006777537055313587, -0.019495414569973946, 0.013577508740127087, -0.01585416868329048, 0.025659894570708275, -0.01578967273235321, -0.014766675420105457, -0.03480863571166992, -0.031439412385225296, 0.015155093744397163, -0.002550724195316434, -0.018184009939432144, -0.04441419616341591, -0.002137221861630678, -0.016429763287305832, 0.04310019314289093, -0.006407890003174543, 0.053883638232946396, 0.005385784897953272, 0.017466412857174873, -0.023943763226270676, -0.07995304465293884, -0.037926655262708664, 0.010590478777885437, -0.032716237008571625, -0.01692204549908638, -0.015590548515319824, 0.052380625158548355, -0.022003237158060074, 0.02079758234322071, 0.02425440400838852, 0.012297206558287144, 0.017060616984963417, 0.008143818937242031, 0.023700807243585587, -0.022974196821451187, -0.017059119418263435, 0.027188241481781006, 0.00640888512134552, -0.02005087025463581, -0.010625127702951431, -0.060895293951034546, -0.04543563723564148, 0.006590752396732569, -0.0346810407936573, -0.02076439931988716, 0.01942339912056923, -0.028217820450663567, -0.0346122607588768, -0.009196544997394085, -0.032062795013189316, -0.046008747071027756, 0.02862018719315529, 0.008434128947556019, -0.022372117266058922, -0.010963339358568192, 0.018974334001541138, 0.0009785142028704286, 0.0030357171781361103, 0.012651786208152771, 0.0134451724588871, 0.044552989304065704, -0.001683887210674584, 0.03181488811969757, 0.006018863990902901, 0.01723599247634411, -0.023757703602313995, -0.04808882996439934, -0.008218594826757908, -0.005791597533971071, -0.00278808013536036, 0.0023192749358713627, -0.01983535848557949, 0.017604362219572067, 0.026320844888687134, 0.040955014526844025, -0.007924344390630722, 0.05054841935634613, -0.018859032541513443, -0.03604654595255852, -0.0007101210067048669, -0.004975003655999899, 0.003955028019845486, -0.01755278930068016, -0.021701529622077942, 0.044527165591716766, -0.027687186375260353, 0.01887156069278717, 0.04929806664586067, 0.020687472075223923, 0.018423553556203842, -0.0009248122805729508, -0.003973172511905432, 0.01652337796986103, -0.0005642477772198617, 0.004961326252669096, 0.051519908010959625, 0.05331147089600563, -0.026750918477773666, 0.06501902639865875, 0.022658387199044228, 0.0038993132766336203, -0.09674487262964249, -0.056727129966020584, 0.05108160153031349, 0.012584725394845009, 0.04615873470902443, -0.04624548554420471, -0.021521976217627525, 0.00799920130521059, -0.04737994074821472, -0.032808903604745865, 0.027864838019013405, 0.0030138741713017225, -0.012030993588268757, -0.0011488678865134716, -0.011401360854506493, 0.038533374667167664, 0.023318372666835785, 0.026341570541262627, 0.020268583670258522, -0.002438168739899993, 0.004139294847846031, -0.041529733687639236, -0.011361891403794289, -0.000013223164387454744, 0.023452239111065865, -0.047428857535123825, 0.06820476055145264, -0.030599039047956467, -0.008560577407479286, 0.022469110786914825, 0.01380642969161272, 0.0073180170729756355, 0.08489356935024261, 0.0018395419465377927, 0.000013220051187090576, 0.024830976501107216, 0.02165631763637066, 0.013352719135582447, 0.006471595726907253, 0.044456176459789276, -0.0029723134357482195, 0.02245151251554489, -0.014036154374480247, -0.03112652897834778, 0.0127604054287076, -0.024103736504912376, -0.0047496589832007885, 0.02376903034746647, -0.028435897082090378, 0.015357919037342072, 0.003873581299558282, -0.02685525082051754, -0.0021098656579852104, -0.027728905901312828, -0.014814898371696472, -0.0354619175195694, -0.03693343326449394, 0.03239060938358307, 0.028841331601142883, -0.03982749953866005, 0.011027595959603786, -0.01950470358133316, -0.016289742663502693, 0.009106071665883064, 0.02556225098669529, 0.013362137600779533, -0.04212392121553421, 0.04318853095173836, -0.03769758343696594, -0.02461027167737484, 0.026003161445260048, 0.01928696781396866, -0.05560028925538063, 0.021716557443141937, -0.02078430727124214, -0.014745096676051617, 0.006604206282645464, 0.006096849218010902, 0.03784378990530968, -0.0755734071135521, 0.03559334576129913, 0.03469712287187576, -0.025409940630197525, -0.045813821256160736, 0.00086184375686571, -0.026029285043478012, 0.021368946880102158, 0.051796622574329376, 0.02317800000309944, -0.0029252124950289726, 0.0015735671622678638, 0.007338114082813263, -0.036901071667671204, -0.029984505847096443, 0.03332992643117905, 0.026839181780815125, -0.040420908480882645, -0.0165790356695652, 0.00772277545183897, -0.018106473609805107, 0.010981076397001743, 0.03233390673995018, -0.0019914619624614716, 0.007560114376246929, 0.016999445855617523, 0.025252096354961395, 0.036227911710739136, 0.0006145054358057678, -0.010365184396505356, 0.020164458081126213, 0.027735019102692604, -0.015637323260307312, 0.04125788062810898, 0.001460933592170477, -0.06619833409786224, 0.019498640671372414, 0.017735661938786507, -0.01815369538962841, 0.02004939131438732, -0.007281312253326178, -0.0013835922582075, -0.04608787223696709, 0.012844247743487358, 0.017642680555582047, -0.03102225810289383, -0.01964866742491722, 0.03015819750726223, 0.05474143847823143, 0.04547283798456192, -0.004778943490236998, 0.029737645760178566, 0.037002913653850555, -0.04223591834306717, 0.028175681829452515, -0.0019794863183051348, 0.03763779252767563, -0.003176707774400711, 0.016425134614109993, 0.025076400488615036, 0.04491962492465973, 0.021837953478097916, -0.001422567293047905, 0.04817351698875427, -0.012163151055574417, 0.002858190331608057, 0.009554761461913586, 0.003813106333836913, 0.040766794234514236, 0.021576780825853348, 0.00205567036755383, 0.0305401049554348, -0.03548713028430939, 0.00918776635080576, -0.0062503148801624775, -0.009219801053404808, -0.046140603721141815, -0.012706369161605835, 0.058458879590034485, 0.026167094707489014, 0.02913896180689335, -0.020891476422548294, 0.0053624906577169895, -0.014668531715869904, 0.01868489384651184, 0.020777517929673195, 0.015178550966084003, -0.016959436237812042, -0.04453020170331001, -0.005466391332447529, -0.037144459784030914, -0.02904719114303589, -0.04082770273089409, 0.006594677455723286, 0.026706015691161156, -0.008556731976568699, -0.02349167875945568, -0.029081158339977264, -0.0024530221708118916, 0.03008691966533661, -0.04554010555148125, -0.011898517608642578, -0.059868067502975464, 0.016686035320162773, 0.016150889918208122, -0.04181754216551781 ]
<p>Let's say you have $X$ coins, each with a differing probability of landing heads (e.g. coin 1 has 10% chance of landing heads, coin 2 has 20% chance of landing heads, etc.).</p> <p>Now, let's say that you flip coin $i$ coin $Y_i$ times (each coin has a differing amount of flips). We know how many times each coin was flipped.</p> <p>Now let's say you do this every day for a really long time and record that info. Example, with 2 coins, on day 1: 50 flips total, 30 heads total, coin1 was flipped 20 times and coin2 flipped 30 times. Day 2: 80 flips, 66 heads total, coin1 60 flips, coin2 20 flips.</p> <p>What we know: total flips, total heads, how many times each coin was flipped.</p> <p>Given that, is there a way to determine an approximate probability that the given coin will flip heads? In the above example, coin1 has a 100% probability of heads and coin2 has a 33% probability.</p>
74,044
[ -0.03704443573951721, -0.01819886825978756, -0.0144638167694211, -0.017513616010546684, 0.03362048789858818, 0.008856115862727165, -0.009768434800207615, -0.013725400902330875, 0.010204724036157131, -0.010525953024625778, 0.04110973700881004, 0.06241089850664139, 0.03353806585073471, 0.0288503747433424, 0.0475437194108963, 0.004023328889161348, -0.037901945412158966, -0.00876697339117527, -0.004519549198448658, -0.0020139203406870365, 0.022819308564066887, 0.02086270973086357, 0.030561262741684914, -0.02487567812204361, -0.04499845951795578, 0.011279859580099583, 0.026623765006661415, -0.033007871359586716, 0.0036016220692545176, 0.07342647016048431, -0.0026578994002193213, -0.04051085188984871, 0.0392606295645237, 0.038013704121112823, 0.07370951026678085, -0.0035096362698823214, -0.010823826305568218, -0.03142424672842026, -0.013719762675464153, 0.018740270286798477, -0.053058791905641556, 0.0015555807622149587, -0.014085307717323303, 0.044785864651203156, 0.012570396065711975, 0.03604508936405182, -0.023123111575841904, -0.038863107562065125, -0.0015744718257337809, -0.05416545271873474, 0.08611849695444107, -0.030789969488978386, 0.043372925370931625, 0.024613890796899796, 0.01107590738683939, -0.01313006691634655, 0.05610109493136406, 0.0476294681429863, -0.023213373497128487, -0.005020623095333576, -0.04026653245091438, -0.02106243371963501, -0.011978904716670513, -0.026120038703083992, -0.02934119664132595, -0.002509749261662364, -0.03167986124753952, -0.02122057043015957, -0.0037544958759099245, -0.038881249725818634, 0.028134137392044067, 0.03092080168426037, 0.058743249624967575, 0.004034060053527355, 0.009652107022702694, -0.01567147672176361, 0.03616734594106674, 0.0064405943267047405, 0.029327163472771645, 0.038212087005376816, 0.0014306558296084404, 0.0014804889215156436, 0.03813553228974342, 0.030745720490813255, 0.05477561801671982, -0.03564566373825073, 0.060031041502952576, -0.024731919169425964, 0.027463320642709732, 0.031372200697660446, 0.0015518245054408908, -0.00006790493353037164, 0.030586550012230873, -0.026048466563224792, -0.05628509074449539, 0.01144414022564888, 0.015996046364307404, 0.020875506103038788, -0.017376024276018143, -0.01203250978142023, 0.016766929998993874, -0.04554834961891174, 0.015098021365702152, 0.04330149665474892, -0.05359254404902458, -0.03175830841064453, -0.010855572298169136, -0.008149449713528156, -0.013382747769355774, 0.006874679587781429, 0.005684025585651398, 0.03571748360991478, 0.01981954835355282, 0.018057920038700104, 0.025351764634251595, -0.00784241035580635, -0.017644908279180527, -0.02619609422981739, -0.005618594586849213, 0.06606733798980713, 0.03382189944386482, -0.024556411430239677, 0.032365716993808746, -0.055755216628313065, -0.03643696382641792, 0.02842818573117256, 0.03203574940562248, -0.021666506305336952, -0.059304554015398026, 0.08115299046039581, -0.00852160807698965, 0.0025725301820784807, 0.017961766570806503, -0.012490901164710522, 0.0178795475512743, -0.00843001063913107, -0.09159355610609055, -0.03708114102482796, 0.02675163745880127, -0.04070872813463211, -0.015133026987314224, -0.08365527540445328, 0.02494083158671856, 0.050429366528987885, 0.02764175646007061, 0.0227297842502594, 0.05899888649582863, 0.018581904470920563, 0.01602919027209282, 0.020556746050715446, -0.04279766231775284, -0.011769684962928295, 0.010021043941378593, -0.031254611909389496, -0.00386023405008018, -0.08154349029064178, 0.021571112796664238, 0.027373667806386948, -0.01506718248128891, -0.05071799084544182, 0.01321086473762989, 0.014392897486686707, -0.014782742597162724, -0.00622573122382164, 0.028290890157222748, -0.02718876674771309, 0.09506244212388992, 0.02927539497613907, 0.03603232651948929, 0.03526848927140236, -0.030684299767017365, 0.0005118823610246181, 0.044830746948719025, 0.04315374046564102, 0.06280802190303802, -0.03552324324846268, -0.004046223126351833, -0.024333104491233826, -0.007840221747756004, 0.009135672822594643, 0.0020454919431358576, 0.005299912765622139, 0.017041489481925964, 0.0008090037736110389, 0.04890681058168411, -0.028530843555927277, 0.01417110487818718, -0.03334661200642586, -0.0036715425085276365, -0.038874246180057526, -0.017737701535224915, -0.08116369694471359, 0.0008572806837037206, -0.017001952975988388, -0.016539596021175385, 0.017764730378985405, 0.021906109526753426, -0.002572240773588419, -0.006622812710702419, -0.04467601329088211, 0.007371080107986927, 0.009243391454219818, 0.04290999472141266, -0.05127311870455742, -0.026326565071940422, 0.06673578172922134, 0.04369863495230675, -0.015850258991122246, 0.04886600747704506, -0.04611819237470627, -0.019471121951937675, -0.036539122462272644, -0.06294281780719757, 0.004347312264144421, 0.016522260382771492, 0.004512564279139042, 0.04819825291633606, -0.006309874355792999, 0.008725253865122795, 0.01627969741821289, -0.054360534995794296, 0.051139604300260544, 0.07604792714118958, 0.015065375715494156, 0.009308864362537861, -0.0104368319734931, 0.023617414757609367, -0.011385571211576462, 0.04434540122747421, -0.056908272206783295, -0.06672008335590363, -0.006706357467919588, 0.00932482909411192, 0.021700354292988777, -0.01918802037835121, 0.01591402292251587, 0.06433817744255066, 0.04594722390174866, -0.017208173871040344, 0.04309551417827606, -0.0037472054827958345, 0.005660227499902248, -0.01962321624159813, 0.00830582994967699, 0.00313959876075387, 0.013080907054245472, 0.04720081016421318, 0.013218673877418041, -0.018286798149347305, -0.0009333579218946397, -0.030372342094779015, 0.03556370735168457, 0.02053099125623703, -0.008184012956917286, -0.025145182386040688, -0.0527513362467289, 0.049828916788101196, -0.005967794917523861, 0.009116833098232746, 0.013448065146803856, 0.009955809451639652, -0.0001689946511760354, -0.041349172592163086, -0.041490938514471054, 0.024520033970475197, 0.03763732686638832, -0.05660371482372284, -0.013226885348558426, 0.03309318795800209, 0.0036523030139505863, 0.000664638529997319, -0.019897185266017914, -0.008287012577056885, -0.01158901397138834, 0.011688455939292908, 0.019240977242588997, -0.014213132672011852, 0.01301674172282219, -0.042487435042858124, -0.03304078057408333, 0.029039399698376656, -0.023934973403811455, -0.007629621773958206, -0.013300427235662937, -0.09049677103757858, 0.04807541146874428, 0.024257374927401543, -0.015624300576746464, -0.013385319150984287, -0.017225157469511032, -0.0006233584135770798, 0.04557773470878601, 0.02835410088300705, -0.0608086995780468, 0.019897086545825005, -0.048356793820858, 0.02566840685904026, -0.051286060363054276, -0.004088185727596283, 0.03114829771220684, 0.034255724400281906, -0.04168449714779854, 0.016629237681627274, -0.035675279796123505, -0.01446008961647749, -0.020479433238506317, 0.007965906523168087, 0.02073097601532936, -0.02201581373810768, 0.003913624212145805, 0.046724069863557816, -0.024645641446113586, -0.04543079808354378, -0.08868487179279327, -0.10924382507801056, -0.001459068269468844, -0.012834030203521252, 0.01158250030130148, 0.00660159345716238, -0.028576070442795753, 0.07324295490980148, 0.01930949091911316, -0.03354409709572792, -0.01581280305981636, 0.0032076514326035976, 0.0014236735878512263, 0.01055938471108675, -0.017617087811231613, 0.007558615878224373, -0.04018794000148773, -0.008307309821248055, 0.024021444842219353, -0.042067863047122955, 0.07306279987096786, 0.042295996099710464, 0.01714109629392624, 0.012400553561747074, 0.00029754036222584546, 0.01013702992349863, 0.01141196209937334, 0.001814161310903728, -0.066048264503479, -0.015826422721147537, -0.0024227409157902002, 0.024748418480157852, 0.02089700661599636, -0.018816674128174782, 0.029196638613939285, -0.025366369634866714, 0.02874024584889412, -0.03212105855345726, 0.03803689405322075, -0.027865204960107803, -0.02315845899283886, -0.009659580886363983, 0.03961316496133804, 0.046402059495449066, -0.01930834911763668, 0.02380969747900963, 0.06027631834149361, 0.047968655824661255, -0.021486598998308182, -0.04285724461078644, -0.029955916106700897, -0.0036524070892482996, 0.02509516105055809, -0.051213447004556656, -0.02532340958714485, 0.006470324005931616, 0.033182293176651, 0.043785981833934784, -0.012804916128516197, 0.009479060769081116, 0.009494204074144363, -0.07958602160215378, 0.0011234747944399714, -0.02776588872075081, 0.056455522775650024, 0.01748272217810154, 0.03358440101146698, 0.008389448747038841, -0.032239675521850586, 0.016683166846632957, -0.01414558943361044, -0.08385373651981354, 0.01910962350666523, -0.012807684950530529, -0.033834218978881836, -0.011985763907432556, -0.014431371353566647, 0.05630790814757347, -0.022782932966947556, 0.04088953882455826, -0.0024188398383557796, 0.030228227376937866, -0.018898993730545044, 0.007152973674237728, -0.022555306553840637, -0.027534371241927147, 0.012467494234442711, 0.053453296422958374, 0.0459974929690361, -0.02844643034040928, 0.06237437576055527, 0.01946045458316803, -0.020693302154541016, 0.009545817971229553, -0.02301333099603653, -0.0039582327008247375, -0.0004910724819637835, 0.04105345532298088, 0.012005859985947609, 0.06330262869596481, -0.03529922291636467, 0.02333550713956356, 0.03688365966081619, 0.049373332411050797, 0.06312642246484756, -0.006867016199976206, -0.011365403421223164, -0.03634244203567505, -0.02857017330825329, 0.02166094444692135, 0.02233904041349888, 0.005083139985799789, 0.0021287230774760246, 0.02944876067340374, 0.009317019023001194, -0.04280729219317436, -0.014137351885437965, 0.06711984425783157, -0.025676079094409943, -0.0007872048299759626, -0.04792913794517517, 0.01362601201981306, -0.03684384003281593, -0.003585744882002473, 0.01163599081337452, -0.003367869881913066, 0.006532782223075628, 0.0005403604009188712, 0.040286462754011154, 0.009273439645767212, 0.011919076554477215, 0.028546307235956192, 0.0015163299394771457, 0.04192626476287842, 0.024511676281690598, -0.01566198840737343, 0.025015834718942642, 0.07032892107963562, 0.017864465713500977, 0.010824925266206264, -0.005510339047759771, -0.04335818812251091, 0.00028936678427271545, 0.01806619204580784, 0.050869476050138474, -0.03725293651223183, 0.00406040670350194, -0.008975342847406864, -0.012024319730699062, 0.05811917036771774, -0.0065795001573860645, 0.008182802237570286, -0.007554680574685335, -0.006874258629977703, -0.028845766559243202, -0.008545884862542152, -0.03900380805134773, 0.012635101564228535, -0.052479974925518036, 0.018881071358919144, -0.02469424530863762, -0.008411525748670101, -0.039657652378082275, -0.010985872708261013, 0.048334162682294846, 0.06348421424627304, -0.03145153075456619, -0.00978573877364397, -0.023763366043567657, 0.017352716997265816, -0.0037603352684527636, -0.06850947439670563, 0.015601187944412231, -0.0022760764695703983, -0.02452722378075123, 0.02731538563966751, -0.012351118959486485, -0.023057684302330017, 0.04632767289876938, -0.008061093278229237, -0.026974119246006012, -0.019907377660274506, -0.034743208438158035, 0.046468958258628845, 0.05705542489886284, 0.013316405937075615, 0.03804430738091469, 0.01969357207417488, 0.010499785654246807, 0.01681428588926792, 0.0004817710432689637, -0.010901665315032005, -0.029028013348579407, 0.0025986868422478437, -0.011088214814662933, -0.023395318537950516, -0.007868061773478985, 0.032044198364019394, -0.007435997948050499, 0.04108993709087372, -0.02010054886341095, 0.0015679084463045, -0.06234971433877945, 0.03463200107216835, 0.007593843620270491, -0.01663323864340782, -0.011634917929768562, 0.036530863493680954, 0.012088815681636333, -0.022762054577469826, 0.023632148280739784, -0.025639723986387253, -0.01809113658964634, -0.003613558830693364, -0.009668510407209396, 0.022198105230927467, -0.05762255936861038, 0.003346165409311652, 0.018503373488783836, -0.001245757914148271, 0.025229373946785927, -0.04739820212125778, 0.022348184138536453, 0.011641697026789188, -0.028942400589585304, 0.016943514347076416, 0.021802952513098717, 0.011401032097637653, 0.013167325407266617, -0.014673592522740364, -0.009436488151550293, -0.006874674931168556, 0.002773185493424535, -0.0671430230140686, -0.025370772927999496, 0.040699418634176254, 0.005705159157514572, -0.04314558953046799, -0.057494547218084335, 0.0224850345402956, -0.04253717511892319, -0.011171560734510422, -0.016731299459934235, -0.0020233860705047846, 0.0002222946786787361, -0.025793781504034996, -0.004038556944578886, 0.012170476838946342, 0.06130547821521759, 0.007990304380655289, -0.015175414271652699, -0.00823480635881424, -0.01633710414171219, -0.03183802589774132, -0.012459217570722103, 0.016611725091934204, -0.040224358439445496, -0.020389311015605927, -0.0043157669715583324, -0.01913546584546566, 0.023618407547473907, -0.04083949327468872, -0.03174350783228874, 0.002702535828575492, 0.016550375148653984, 0.0007350083324126899, -0.03376021608710289, -0.010999923571944237, 0.017342591658234596, 0.047304000705480576, -0.03685425966978073, -0.008976006880402565, 0.010121912695467472, -0.0025196452625095844, 0.020711446180939674, 0.02485520765185356, -0.02684152126312256, 0.0334208682179451, 0.0676460936665535, -0.02433990128338337, -0.01791265793144703, -0.0003332167980261147, -0.00411698454990983, 0.007752665318548679, -0.001155154313892126, -0.01622791215777397, 0.03778721019625664, 0.0024093848187476397, -0.016412833705544472, -0.004954799078404903, -0.050318360328674316, 0.017286213114857674, 0.05644913390278816, -0.024332506582140923, 0.046110693365335464, 0.028307650238275528, 0.0472986213862896, -0.0163184255361557, 0.006728917360305786, -0.006143814884126186, -0.019977949559688568, -0.00025637930957600474, 0.03734275698661804, 0.0013133911415934563, -0.032415617257356644, 0.03904560208320618, 0.012791155837476254, 0.021870121359825134, 0.0403933972120285, -0.007847712375223637, 0.02089870534837246, 0.0380227267742157, -0.029464799910783768, -0.031369004398584366, 0.006416195537894964, -0.047160595655441284, 0.001041848212480545, -0.05640003830194473, -0.0415678396821022, 0.052305661141872406, 0.014185084961354733, -0.028349563479423523, -0.027238648384809494, -0.026434248313307762, -0.03943441063165665, -0.027634985744953156, 0.014761455357074738, 0.021399294957518578, 0.033829957246780396, 0.010352689772844315, 0.008617337793111801, -0.00040207785787060857, 0.01693866215646267, 0.0015803303103893995, -0.11388144642114639, -0.020528994500637054, -0.029871810227632523, -0.06657204031944275, 0.024984782561659813, 0.020909393206238747, -0.019247418269515038, 0.016713321208953857, -0.03172480687499046, 0.01731119491159916, -0.008629407733678818, 0.039043623954057693, -0.01443355530500412, 0.05186990275979042, 0.03856367617845535, 0.03815032169222832, -0.04410163313150406, -0.022818876430392265, 0.11551516503095627, 0.046574667096138, 0.028789158910512924, -0.027147416025400162, 0.02701811119914055, -0.02854965627193451, -0.0040320358239114285, -0.01779494807124138, 0.027026312425732613, 0.03439737856388092, -0.0024236151948571205, 0.030221033841371536, 0.04930882155895233, -0.02747412398457527, -0.003837898839265108, 0.05985783413052559, -0.05455601587891579, -0.0040387948974967, 0.016423484310507774, -0.006892506964504719, 0.006392930634319782, -0.017551856115460396, -0.022847367450594902, 0.038611169904470444, -0.023208685219287872, -0.02404928393661976, 0.0027376797515898943, -0.029559480026364326, 0.001422292087227106, 0.010144437663257122, -0.042020104825496674, 0.018977196887135506, 0.039945702999830246, -0.006404894404113293, -0.028281476348638535, 0.02349826693534851, 0.035779885947704315, -0.015899859368801117, 0.016034189611673355, 0.015467862598598003, 0.031419966369867325, -0.027311518788337708, -0.01592419482767582, 0.021272430196404457, -0.03467641770839691, -0.03891049325466156, -0.06145176291465759, 0.027044039219617844, -0.023253396153450012, 0.016460031270980835, -0.02555767633020878, -0.010054443962872028, 0.01149214617908001, -0.034890659153461456, -0.008960709907114506, 0.033778589218854904, 0.02738216333091259, -0.035198625177145004, -0.0094533059746027, -0.014337473548948765, 0.0006282845861278474, 0.008314316160976887, 0.02444818615913391, 0.01998651959002018, -0.02420816756784916, -0.039901088923215866, 0.012860715389251709, 0.014883981086313725, 0.006812536157667637, -0.0017267271177843213, -0.009773734025657177, -0.004771018400788307, -0.02290027029812336, -0.008176177740097046, 0.006877138279378414, -0.042748432606458664, -0.02357933297753334, 0.013026945292949677, -0.034239351749420166, 0.024156631901860237, -0.019575249403715134, 0.014512056484818459, -0.020146241411566734, -0.009077207185328007, -0.04431914538145065, -0.0064806584268808365, 0.04019118472933769, 0.02972470223903656, -0.004793725907802582, -0.010691715404391289, 0.0003993174177594483, 0.03333241865038872, 0.0043381499126553535, -0.022963710129261017, -0.024930525571107864, -0.010611970908939838, -0.0280901025980711, 0.028705954551696777, -0.017787663266062737, 0.07336023449897766, 0.03020256571471691, 0.02741873823106289, 0.019741864874958992, 0.025663474574685097, 0.005131751298904419, 0.050133004784584045, -0.005276612937450409, -0.02746792882680893, -0.010704477317631245, 0.028937095776200294, 0.009679506532847881, -0.011493139900267124, -0.03205730766057968, -0.04254671931266785, 0.019819656386971474, 0.01762174256145954, -0.025643067434430122, -0.030552854761481285, -0.01713271625339985, -0.0064277034252882, 0.02078784443438053, -0.00201622536405921, 0.017308661714196205, -0.03574858605861664, -0.018812045454978943, -0.0012255435576662421, -0.011063664220273495, 0.009074149653315544, 0.024528075009584427, 0.020383194088935852, -0.016876371577382088, 0.05781790241599083, 0.006706045940518379, 0.004660143982619047, 0.015836548060178757, 0.022885696962475777, -0.013635466806590557, 0.04364769160747528, -0.04821588844060898, -0.04669664800167084, 0.05217882618308067, -0.06788962334394455, -0.030614102259278297, 0.0488019697368145, -0.004379408434033394, 0.04248002916574478, 0.06892631947994232, -0.00559233920648694, -0.02171381749212742, 0.01984386146068573, -0.05021361634135246, -0.025617729872465134, -0.0008113959338515997, 0.03234490379691124, 0.008604818023741245, 0.01757892593741417, 0.009363953024148941, 0.019093604758381844, -0.009890641085803509, 0.012549343518912792, 0.03353540971875191, 0.032805249094963074, -0.0009898376883938909, 0.005064215511083603, 0.04571528360247612, 0.02386447973549366, 0.003918686881661415, -0.03245959430932999, 0.050557829439640045, 0.012078466825187206, -0.04845106229186058, 0.009000297635793686, -0.009115226566791534, -0.00842600129544735, -0.08758965134620667, -0.005844346713274717, 0.00785840768367052, 0.0031787995249032974, 0.034142304211854935, -0.04824928194284439, 0.010117651894688606, -0.0043679941445589066, -0.040517695248126984, 0.058674197643995285, -0.008861416019499302, 0.005392448045313358, -0.013894382864236832, 0.048763640224933624, -0.014361845329403877, 0.026633530855178833, 0.021373357623815536, 0.02362598478794098, 0.04568769782781601, 0.014999724924564362, 0.022906959056854248, -0.0160834901034832, 0.020810037851333618, -0.006640275940299034, -0.00866350531578064, -0.05311698466539383, 0.044025830924510956, -0.0481533482670784, -0.053986456245183945, 0.032707639038562775, -0.005186175927519798, 0.010959062725305557, -0.02007920667529106, 0.016352180391550064, -0.0017590784700587392, 0.008150354027748108, 0.019435977563261986, -0.015110863372683525, 0.004241264890879393, 0.024784063920378685, -0.007611662615090609, 0.026017578318715096, 0.02128157764673233, -0.00998673215508461, 0.043961841613054276, -0.009788214229047298, -0.052390698343515396, 0.018216988071799278, 0.04979311674833298, -0.023417208343744278, -0.0016825604252517223, 0.010148306377232075, 0.01865921914577484, -0.012828314676880836, 0.020180372521281242, -0.03454583138227463, 0.013045026920735836, 0.024205248802900314, -0.008132279850542545, -0.034542568027973175, 0.00783433299511671, -0.03210405260324478, -0.05192394182085991, 0.013000383973121643, 0.03664334490895271, -0.017835218459367752, -0.06417490541934967, -0.00586964376270771, 0.026753757148981094, 0.005213459022343159, 0.012652397155761719, -0.017535537481307983, -0.04715347662568092, 0.019161686301231384, -0.03943207487463951, 0.028131429105997086, 0.04529934003949165, -0.0016456475714221597, -0.001391699886880815, -0.08345680683851242, 0.05324384570121765, -0.011496823281049728, -0.004451449029147625, -0.03614598140120506, -0.012920803390443325, -0.02373032458126545, -0.018440352752804756, 0.07264644652605057, 0.031644899398088455, -0.014142824336886406, -0.0060815331526100636, 0.038027435541152954, 0.026573259383440018, -0.0685395896434784, 0.016601920127868652, -0.044723812490701675, 0.01688995398581028, -0.0026070119347423315, -0.03625147044658661, -0.0059397658333182335, 0.0008721547201275826, 0.035126037895679474, -0.004496132023632526, 0.014189552515745163, 0.007535440847277641, -0.015021073631942272, 0.022098541259765625, 0.00007515596371376887, -0.007918186485767365, 0.04616658017039299, 0.007827600464224815, -0.009908083826303482, 0.02376498468220234, -0.04469187185168266, -0.04586919769644737, 0.03943031653761864, -0.04666782170534134, -0.03802052512764931, 0.03581531345844269, -0.020353145897388458, -0.012529119849205017, -0.052665796130895615, -0.033986665308475494, 0.0008726860396564007, -0.0279223695397377, 0.005879086907953024, 0.037757374346256256, 0.035619188100099564, 0.030467677861452103, -0.034831754863262177, 0.0011014675255864859, 0.00971596036106348, -0.00290441932156682, 0.009071903303265572, 0.018252674490213394, 0.038506053388118744, -0.017174389213323593, 0.015925271436572075, 0.016645867377519608, 0.024533426389098167, 0.008659183979034424, 0.01265252847224474, 0.051300935447216034, 0.010979664511978626, -0.009092454798519611, 0.025503922253847122, -0.014473235234618187, -0.02589157596230507, -0.008303103037178516, -0.007336820010095835, 0.07539904117584229, -0.008454169146716595, 0.015246729366481304, -0.025416141375899315, -0.013666699640452862, -0.02391497977077961, 0.002585136564448476, 0.029645321890711784, 0.027293013408780098, -0.016067398712038994, -0.014303848147392273, 0.006785680074244738, 0.026602692902088165, -0.00561171118170023, 0.015020924620330334, 0.0221231821924448, 0.017831947654485703, -0.0030456450767815113, -0.024802615866065025, -0.028004011139273643, -0.04995378106832504, -0.04103056713938713, 0.02075192891061306, 0.033183496445417404, 0.06366338580846786, 0.021315934136509895, -0.056576091796159744, -0.0070764292031526566, 0.019320832565426826, -0.06657576560974121, 0.011596687138080597, -0.04750330001115799, 0.02216409333050251, -0.001063850475475192, -0.017937956377863884 ]
<p>Is it plausible to have a positive coefficient with a negative marginal / impact effect after running multinomial logit model?</p>
1,031
[ -0.049194831401109695, -0.020525572821497917, -0.01924816332757473, 0.021062539890408516, 0.05624925717711449, 0.024425949901342392, -0.00648337509483099, -0.02321872115135193, 0.024069417268037796, -0.03970596566796303, 0.003738971659913659, 0.005775929428637028, 0.04549805447459221, -0.026866693049669266, 0.017167752608656883, 0.020492441952228546, -0.010664552450180054, 0.02336660400032997, 0.00006354655488394201, 0.03440667688846588, -0.011236259713768959, 0.045626234263181686, 0.04703415930271149, 0.01643739826977253, -0.0028425082564353943, 0.02817068062722683, 0.003719297470524907, -0.022126860916614532, -0.0016151826130226254, 0.04302741587162018, -0.011957733891904354, 0.004061604384332895, 0.013184336945414543, 0.018346723169088364, -0.00309942034073174, -0.014572345651686192, -0.05631353706121445, -0.044117674231529236, -0.009452824480831623, 0.017665863037109375, 0.0013635132927447557, -0.029696501791477203, 0.007509865798056126, 0.019521236419677734, -0.01796376332640648, -0.006418782286345959, -0.03467967361211777, -0.022581780329346657, 0.06366340816020966, -0.033685825765132904, 0.052232395857572556, -0.004067312926054001, 0.03685721009969711, 0.04747716337442398, -0.027713535353541374, -0.028490928933024406, 0.04986472800374031, 0.09467046707868576, -0.027978811413049698, 0.003480607410892844, -0.0017898340011015534, -0.010149295441806316, 0.0025492070708423853, -0.04571815952658653, -0.02893577329814434, 0.014210112392902374, 0.006149790715426207, -0.031431861221790314, 0.0724974274635315, -0.0069616069085896015, 0.028185850009322166, 0.023605212569236755, 0.01945803500711918, 0.0012214884627610445, 0.037011075764894485, -0.016927668824791908, 0.028227396309375763, 0.018359918147325516, 0.0015600807964801788, 0.04403727129101753, 0.0005142830777913332, 0.015785034745931625, 0.025838416069746017, 0.05775653198361397, 0.030983101576566696, -0.03510189428925514, 0.017238203436136246, -0.05039568245410919, 0.02698870748281479, -0.01924530230462551, -0.06246207281947136, -0.056108251214027405, 0.04262330010533333, 0.0008004408446140587, -0.022369088605046272, 0.04454357922077179, -0.019338730722665787, 0.04564487561583519, 0.07262289524078369, -0.015632379800081253, -0.02786925993859768, -0.005531873553991318, 0.017110809683799744, 0.04745345935225487, -0.026961829513311386, 0.001796295284293592, -0.041519105434417725, 0.017755167558789253, 0.005166142713278532, -0.0295951459556818, -0.029277777299284935, -0.0027148686349391937, 0.0088158855214715, -0.038893602788448334, 0.05339737981557846, -0.03929987922310829, 0.012168625369668007, -0.05218677222728729, 0.035157158970832825, 0.06466609239578247, -0.008923513814806938, -0.05607132986187935, 0.03775639832019806, -0.028642771765589714, -0.04122212156653404, -0.016086040064692497, 0.012809722684323788, -0.0022105413954705, -0.016820339486002922, 0.0115637993440032, 0.0017888207221403718, -0.010429728776216507, 0.04152544215321541, 0.0038080087397247553, 0.007313300855457783, 0.0062139336951076984, -0.06197899580001831, -0.03023534268140793, 0.03533333167433739, -0.01883997581899166, 0.012129031121730804, -0.03202584758400917, -0.040831755846738815, 0.01686355657875538, 0.07168780267238617, 0.022849682718515396, 0.028140245005488396, 0.055404182523489, 0.03989974409341812, 0.040384989231824875, 0.004976504482328892, 0.013080631382763386, -0.06263210624456406, -0.0017367411637678742, 0.0013074007583782077, -0.11620792001485825, 0.001960499444976449, 0.02784891240298748, -0.00809765886515379, -0.0027200691401958466, 0.037376850843429565, 0.044186607003211975, -0.010505435988307, 0.0031979128252714872, 0.00916043296456337, -0.030026426538825035, 0.056658800691366196, -0.008955494500696659, 0.0153941186144948, 0.003940703347325325, 0.022894393652677536, 0.011522975750267506, -0.0026142140850424767, 0.06784752756357193, 0.02349652722477913, -0.032837919890880585, -0.019975857809185982, -0.03779587894678116, 0.049833111464977264, -0.017728740349411964, -0.04958795756101608, -0.0038691565860062838, -0.07807240635156631, -0.03309003263711929, 0.03204250708222389, 0.042705927044153214, 0.015672022476792336, -0.013796292245388031, 0.05154752358794212, -0.028965502977371216, -0.05777774751186371, -0.06521696597337723, 0.06237805634737015, 0.012286066077649593, -0.015187624841928482, 0.03583308309316635, 0.015048217959702015, 0.02354869246482849, -0.01909160241484642, 0.04306264966726303, -0.031031547114253044, 0.0002139118587365374, 0.02005195990204811, -0.014574777334928513, 0.009791204705834389, 0.04630380496382713, 0.0736604705452919, 0.0072827693074941635, 0.004258729051798582, -0.048659492284059525, -0.0446220301091671, 0.03390434384346008, -0.012498816475272179, 0.0009483485482633114, -0.0023236258421093225, -0.015916382893919945, 0.026153655722737312, -0.009454487822949886, -0.028101542964577675, 0.03667851909995079, -0.09293221682310104, 0.06359393149614334, 0.08172523230314255, -0.024154480546712875, 0.027622835710644722, 0.020308777689933777, 0.021355783566832542, 0.009751931764185429, -0.016698261722922325, -0.008791172876954079, -0.0252581425011158, -0.012135818600654602, 0.04672757163643837, 0.004469845909625292, -0.05463689565658569, 0.04509560391306877, 0.032394520938396454, -0.025039605796337128, 0.001797530334442854, 0.02689437009394169, 0.009026510640978813, 0.0005815634503960609, 0.037060149013996124, 0.006209134589880705, 0.025205934420228004, 0.003045887453481555, -0.005490937735885382, 0.017444564029574394, 0.03199341893196106, -0.03793565556406975, 0.006092633120715618, 0.01900835894048214, 0.015382016077637672, 0.009642565622925758, -0.020785091444849968, 0.01170826144516468, 0.06296193599700928, -0.030407533049583435, 0.04450288414955139, 0.02889036387205124, 0.025505654513835907, 0.0031347249168902636, 0.010298176668584347, -0.024654611945152283, 0.021292734891176224, 0.061355844140052795, 0.0030895464587956667, -0.003148620715364814, 0.03323455527424812, -0.03755132853984833, 0.026820270344614983, -0.0001733539393171668, -0.01792183704674244, 0.00398424593731761, -0.015870744362473488, 0.056113842874765396, 0.0068041314370930195, 0.013547501526772976, -0.000022419184460886754, -0.012895012274384499, -0.024174822494387627, -0.005816275719553232, 0.0007929618586786091, 0.01121347863227129, -0.03990454971790314, -0.029713187366724014, -0.02277114987373352, -0.006219697184860706, 0.034059420228004456, -0.02107170782983303, -0.011560431681573391, 0.054971836507320404, -0.0324363186955452, -0.040843602269887924, -0.023600805550813675, -0.04364313185214996, -0.019132617861032486, -0.048596788197755814, -0.04742894694209099, 0.03641512989997864, 0.021862227469682693, -0.0289611779153347, 0.003424359718337655, -0.04274609312415123, -0.02875288389623165, -0.03280383720993996, -0.011874443851411343, 0.02089517191052437, -0.0272513497620821, 0.02322557382285595, -0.012661946006119251, -0.03155650570988655, 0.005775786470621824, -0.0899408832192421, -0.0369417779147625, 0.043092112988233566, -0.03546778857707977, 0.02429940737783909, -0.02684474177658558, -0.02696262300014496, 0.033676281571388245, 0.042126499116420746, -0.019264768809080124, -0.036766815930604935, -0.02442173659801483, -0.021409789100289345, -0.00664693396538496, 0.009242440573871136, 0.024514097720384598, 0.028885627165436745, 0.07087633013725281, -0.0061921728774905205, 0.019213462248444557, 0.005636188667267561, 0.021383842453360558, -0.014862683601677418, 0.04846885800361633, 0.018371010199189186, -0.03219224512577057, 0.02426217310130596, 0.019614331424236298, -0.021356770768761635, 0.02376163937151432, -0.02653989940881729, 0.037010230123996735, 0.004097600933164358, -0.02365424856543541, 0.02208472415804863, 0.02341214194893837, 0.005040389951318502, -0.06009373068809509, 0.027150040492415428, 0.040661200881004333, -0.00589183671399951, -0.035135507583618164, -0.020632976666092873, 0.04303962364792824, -0.04016106575727463, 0.013837511651217937, 0.03943965956568718, 0.00003978384120273404, -0.019154351204633713, -0.0058280350640416145, -0.01020993571728468, 0.020788775756955147, 0.028389517217874527, -0.00254428549669683, 0.03363395482301712, 0.034381646662950516, 0.022937104105949402, -0.0037286998704075813, -0.012062818743288517, -0.020217640325427055, -0.007110293954610825, -0.02020758017897606, -0.0008488995372317731, -0.018481485545635223, 0.00553160160779953, -0.020484305918216705, -0.008580686524510384, -0.010540473274886608, 0.004133680369704962, -0.03448008373379707, 0.0005081681301817298, -0.08120525628328323, -0.016642669215798378, -0.0376075804233551, 0.004189188126474619, 0.01946517638862133, -0.039566751569509506, 0.04579964652657509, -0.02026629075407982, -0.010426784865558147, -0.008892189711332321, 0.03857750818133354, -0.02572645992040634, 0.008585584349930286, -0.0028808200731873512, -0.013786612078547478, 0.012611865065991879, -0.013409673236310482, 0.021162444725632668, 0.004051636438816786, -0.002973918803036213, 0.03181808069348335, 0.003256451338529587, -0.021068764850497246, -0.03591761365532875, 0.000009117754416365642, 0.012674601748585701, 0.04594242200255394, 0.012243196368217468, 0.031825460493564606, -0.03987113758921623, 0.05541389063000679, 0.012094395235180855, 0.024408696219325066, 0.025472085922956467, -0.0182994082570076, -0.05799790099263191, -0.051611386239528656, -0.0628119707107544, 0.005776567384600639, 0.0121833560988307, 0.009013364091515541, 0.012664872221648693, 0.06036084145307541, 0.018373042345046997, -0.05004432797431946, 0.01551048457622528, 0.036318860948085785, 0.029790174216032028, -0.011272219009697437, -0.02297612838447094, 0.03104083426296711, -0.010853438638150692, -0.003411632962524891, 0.011021153070032597, 0.010800844058394432, -0.028632016852498055, -0.004549814388155937, 0.0553530752658844, 0.02405182458460331, -0.023997986689209938, 0.019216790795326233, 0.010796686634421349, 0.03714347258210182, 0.005457298364490271, -0.033202361315488815, 0.03458622470498085, 0.027016768231987953, -0.01183373387902975, -0.017090609297156334, 0.01699914038181305, -0.1072051078081131, -0.017835304141044617, 0.026240412145853043, 0.0357816219329834, -0.051448170095682144, 0.01154374610632658, -0.013906270265579224, 0.004447178449481726, -0.015270269475877285, -0.03192048892378807, 0.022773798555135727, -0.027365535497665405, 0.03799676522612572, 0.0000353968825947959, -0.03298765793442726, -0.056106820702552795, 0.04948027431964874, -0.02594006434082985, 0.0006467665079981089, -0.0163474902510643, 0.0023259585723280907, -0.00619809003546834, 0.028594080358743668, 0.04632147029042244, 0.07236983627080917, -0.005847642198204994, -0.03419442102313042, 0.01637236773967743, 0.0035293058026582003, -0.01996486820280552, -0.06582793593406677, 0.02086694911122322, 0.018904631957411766, -0.0024168407544493675, 0.06548043340444565, 0.00507418904453516, -0.008169267326593399, 0.006827508099377155, 0.02122706174850464, -0.006386420223861933, 0.018228111788630486, -0.06317634135484695, 0.026751194149255753, 0.013913186267018318, -0.060164518654346466, 0.04502442106604576, 0.016664225608110428, -0.052842069417238235, 0.02498014084994793, -0.03004288487136364, 0.029672672972083092, -0.025716692209243774, -0.02905101701617241, -0.004298376850783825, 0.01463350374251604, 0.024262702092528343, 0.018632210791110992, -0.00668655289337039, -0.0030611820984631777, -0.050492800772190094, 0.002653491450473666, -0.013425800018012524, -0.0020703694317489862, -0.005482184700667858, -0.025743406265974045, -0.020324118435382843, -0.0014919898239895701, 0.04137532040476799, -0.04275326430797577, 0.007833129726350307, -0.009213181212544441, 0.011169642210006714, 0.008080698549747467, -0.02350962534546852, 0.026598559692502022, -0.021261023357510567, -0.058436207473278046, -0.012163491919636726, -0.012703754007816315, 0.0263424813747406, 0.026606466621160507, 0.00210921885445714, -0.023380115628242493, -0.06495904177427292, -0.0057446579448878765, 0.05090689659118652, 0.019310882315039635, 0.02223088964819908, -0.03229938820004463, 0.015988102182745934, 0.005301233381032944, -0.010431967675685883, -0.08209691941738129, -0.03308962285518646, -0.019540634006261826, -0.03655765950679779, 0.024616284295916557, -0.007162739988416433, -0.02345779351890087, -0.029014885425567627, -0.06400898844003677, 0.010205664671957493, 0.07470894604921341, -0.04127062112092972, 0.012116125784814358, -0.021803075447678566, 0.00482452055439353, 0.05587812513113022, 0.013197099789977074, -0.03048180788755417, 0.0197590384632349, -0.014579659327864647, -0.007247225847095251, 0.018291600048542023, 0.01727157086133957, -0.030805382877588272, -0.030893338844180107, 0.001242394675500691, -0.0029078100342303514, 0.03313024714589119, -0.007046742830425501, -0.020119382068514824, 0.021243853494524956, -0.031069235876202583, -0.020622221753001213, 0.007658699993044138, 0.01720549911260605, -0.01992138661444187, -0.00041914943722076714, -0.007829351350665092, -0.012018184177577496, -0.06424138695001602, 0.013438498601317406, 0.07479269802570343, -0.03834153711795807, -0.006536383647471666, 0.007669827435165644, 0.061223361641168594, -0.004159350413829088, 0.009611805900931358, 0.002405051840469241, -0.018691780045628548, 0.03842013701796532, -0.01695837639272213, -0.023698337376117706, 0.014370402321219444, 0.00590249290689826, -0.018038522452116013, -0.02712423726916313, -0.05038565769791603, 0.010631437413394451, 0.039832282811403275, 0.0013849055394530296, 0.05878277122974396, 0.02389685809612274, -0.004860556684434414, -0.031764719635248184, -0.027654334902763367, 0.017061401158571243, 0.02818787470459938, -0.002105303108692169, 0.04681222885847092, -0.007736277766525745, 0.02126573957502842, 0.03301447629928589, -0.02424880489706993, 0.012897597625851631, -0.0049215503968298435, 0.008260066621005535, 0.007232410833239555, 0.02377569116652012, -0.031111041083931923, -0.04003015533089638, 0.020202703773975372, -0.07085837423801422, 0.024509349837899208, -0.04839927330613136, -0.02630024030804634, 0.04090014845132828, 0.043569788336753845, 0.011732697486877441, -0.08867434412240982, -0.019054770469665527, -0.045030057430267334, -0.011630818247795105, -0.007801496423780918, -0.0033053297083824873, 0.05359926074743271, -0.002563999267295003, 0.05433342605829239, -0.005298474337905645, 0.02143900655210018, -0.008341488428413868, -0.08535320311784744, -0.02142115868628025, -0.016621118411421776, -0.004228799603879452, -0.012926516123116016, 0.00546379154548049, -0.004152635578066111, -0.0019126213155686855, -0.05468936264514923, -0.0036492827348411083, 0.009741122834384441, 0.023894716054201126, -0.008474677801132202, 0.08420978486537933, -0.02761305868625641, 0.027541380375623703, -0.004989983048290014, -0.012670068070292473, 0.12067269533872604, 0.07699194550514221, 0.030205274000763893, -0.09548845142126083, 0.013143793679773808, 0.006868640426546335, -0.0011527652386575937, -0.0279182530939579, -0.0076968735083937645, 0.01089633908122778, -0.03376885876059532, 0.031058380380272865, 0.05512585490942001, 0.03535426780581474, 0.005647432990372181, 0.04847176373004913, -0.017922982573509216, -0.03584248572587967, -0.004455130081623793, -0.02544720284640789, 0.0008127808105200529, -0.02171028032898903, -0.01353007648140192, -0.01243763417005539, -0.014164762571454048, -0.019884180277585983, -0.011503387242555618, -0.003688701894134283, 0.007127285934984684, -0.018645701929926872, -0.0022845552302896976, -0.010275102220475674, 0.025891920551657677, 0.01527827326208353, -0.014211592264473438, -0.06395435333251953, 0.028337951749563217, -0.011494035832583904, -0.013856531120836735, 0.04301328957080841, -0.008519897237420082, -0.009548024274408817, 0.04458612948656082, 0.0111303785815835, -0.08314073830842972, 0.01218243408948183, -0.017241420224308968, 0.025048155337572098, 0.009137429296970367, 0.022708481177687645, -0.004638425074517727, 0.015662673860788345, -0.026370372623205185, -0.010401533916592598, -0.024281060323119164, 0.039450302720069885, 0.02376438118517399, -0.010685543529689312, -0.02124648354947567, 0.0030245629604905844, 0.0017958057578653097, 0.013797071762382984, 0.04240916669368744, 0.010764876380562782, -0.03688577562570572, -0.0009159047622233629, 0.013096140697598457, 0.041940294206142426, 0.0059953536838293076, -0.004118696786463261, 0.004588795825839043, -0.01860761269927025, -0.013537110760807991, -0.025097612291574478, -0.013146759010851383, 0.01923445239663124, -0.009342127479612827, 0.023016272112727165, 0.006721758749336004, -0.04397650435566902, -0.02253972366452217, 0.023560134693980217, -0.044371187686920166, -0.015592188574373722, -0.07948523759841919, 0.030973248183727264, 0.008853496983647346, 0.01650889217853546, 0.007066603749990463, 0.019601140171289444, -0.025843920186161995, 0.09092798084020615, -0.006161152850836515, -0.04860493913292885, -0.015960145741701126, -0.029767891392111778, -0.05968170240521431, -0.021332690492272377, 0.023438654839992523, 0.04594923555850983, -0.018880020827054977, 0.023364411666989326, 0.026151692494750023, 0.00916167814284563, -0.02699337713420391, 0.027760861441493034, 0.03868010640144348, -0.04887019842863083, 0.007180478423833847, -0.0033047774340957403, 0.003524531377479434, -0.017528271302580833, 0.007470279466360807, 0.0012318423250690103, -0.0619167685508728, 0.028483811765909195, -0.04123513028025627, -0.024271344766020775, 0.010140209458768368, -0.009614438749849796, 0.03448241949081421, -0.03130113333463669, -0.02455546334385872, -0.025462256744503975, 0.005953268148005009, -0.007950611412525177, -0.02500579133629799, 0.025571513921022415, 0.017067009583115578, -0.007547921501100063, 0.03772628679871559, 0.033176928758621216, 0.03449232876300812, 0.011825879104435444, 0.014825902879238129, 0.03764532878994942, 0.030233580619096756, 0.050763942301273346, 0.00516140554100275, -0.028818197548389435, 0.030363602563738823, -0.024801859632134438, -0.028933512046933174, 0.017368094995617867, -0.007394082844257355, 0.04997675493359566, 0.0064254021272063255, 0.013606147840619087, -0.009662392549216747, 0.05869581550359726, -0.002356345532462001, -0.011357339099049568, 0.011908496730029583, -0.01742587611079216, 0.0012576546287164092, -0.023543262854218483, -0.031937140971422195, 0.01823967695236206, -0.054509978741407394, 0.04535757377743721, 0.06385812163352966, -0.014489899389445782, -0.020485693588852882, 0.002552924444898963, -0.012841478921473026, 0.02430625446140766, 0.00144977867603302, -0.018111879006028175, -0.0030422783456742764, 0.026556186378002167, -0.030706606805324554, 0.028881724923849106, 0.006718008778989315, 0.023352153599262238, -0.03889942169189453, -0.05146590992808342, 0.03493791073560715, 0.002087286440655589, 0.04900732636451721, -0.034685079008340836, 0.04546147212386131, 0.028322037309408188, -0.026519034057855606, -0.0069242194294929504, 0.041519880294799805, -0.024658048525452614, -0.033178333193063736, -0.023842088878154755, -0.012865780852735043, 0.014752892777323723, 0.010607109405100346, 0.042837534099817276, 0.014667310751974583, 0.016213223338127136, -0.012018337845802307, -0.013854946941137314, -0.018465425819158554, -0.0169757641851902, 0.011959071271121502, -0.035099901258945465, 0.04527854919433594, -0.07881031185388565, -0.04228121414780617, 0.026289111003279686, 0.037325650453567505, 0.01563948765397072, 0.01701097935438156, 0.052462656050920486, 0.020983977243304253, 0.06111476942896843, 0.025595949962735176, 0.007574119605123997, 0.020317746326327324, 0.0016695032827556133, -0.0035919169895350933, 0.023582404479384422, -0.030025720596313477, 0.02736947312951088, 0.020625481382012367, 0.004035101272165775, -0.022954877465963364, 0.026690524071455002, -0.000028143462259322405, -0.03953093662858009, -0.021756647154688835, -0.030329003930091858, 0.029735621064901352, -0.01694304868578911, 0.022598395124077797, -0.07330060750246048, -0.032847803086042404, 0.06960637867450714, 0.042580410838127136, -0.008048526011407375, -0.018600352108478546, -0.011275696568191051, -0.031917035579681396, 0.029520392417907715, 0.00446700444445014, -0.00416940962895751, -0.04564396291971207, 0.012169234454631805, 0.002372852060943842, 0.0142626678571105, -0.02982865832746029, -0.0019315294921398163, -0.05916498601436615, 0.012498975731432438, -0.054346662014722824, 0.016895631328225136, 0.03846945986151695, -0.0033245410304516554, 0.028670962899923325, -0.08839374035596848, 0.05737674608826637, 0.021412819623947144, 0.010512634180486202, -0.03208889812231064, -0.04344603791832924, -0.04742153361439705, -0.02631164714694023, 0.05316124111413956, -0.017690224573016167, -0.05228568986058235, -0.008980810642242432, 0.03938506543636322, 0.00226997840218246, -0.01269538328051567, 0.03385816141963005, -0.018941281363368034, -0.0028716744855046272, 0.0024958422873169184, 0.014723607338964939, 0.020261317491531372, -0.0012682935921475291, -0.003506437176838517, -0.025005359202623367, 0.01687145233154297, -0.01982412114739418, -0.000918812642339617, 0.04035399854183197, -0.003907006233930588, -0.009597650729119778, 0.04360348358750343, -0.0006440238212235272, 0.04064536839723587, 0.021133774891495705, 0.0029954162891954184, -0.07066594064235687, 0.0013334963005036116, -0.013660666532814503, -0.009465732611715794, -0.003272304544225335, 0.004139306023716927, -0.0004898702609352767, -0.021715302020311356, 0.004934963770210743, 0.005924059543758631, 0.002976325573399663, 0.0025894956197589636, 0.011872510425746441, 0.04717494174838066, 0.03591078519821167, -0.0028211125172674656, 0.025538772344589233, -0.017540499567985535, 0.002805147087201476, 0.041044145822525024, 0.026576239615678787, 0.030328312888741493, 0.0010013239225372672, 0.008171149529516697, 0.005077654961496592, -0.00198699370957911, 0.04763321951031685, -0.0019921178463846445, 0.03423048555850983, -0.025619560852646828, -0.003289514221251011, 0.04107159748673439, 0.0353633351624012, 0.04773486405611038, 0.01094762608408928, 0.005839499644935131, 0.043619606643915176, 0.005737827625125647, 0.015159223228693008, -0.03092041052877903, -0.02309730276465416, -0.03102489374577999, 0.019195975735783577, 0.014121297746896744, 0.03412727266550064, 0.024119142442941666, -0.034061092883348465, 0.04910314455628395, -0.034902166575193405, -0.00842752493917942, -0.00887085311114788, 0.01804887317121029, -0.021168923005461693, -0.023156439885497093, 0.004817148670554161, -0.04147752374410629, -0.019521409645676613, -0.026337282732129097, 0.006243550684303045, 0.042717743664979935, 0.012679751962423325, -0.03281324356794357, -0.024493714794516563, -0.00930115021765232, 0.06920028477907181, -0.04448525980114937, -0.009875108487904072, -0.04411716014146805, -0.010398735292255878, -0.006398905999958515, -0.030789699405431747 ]
<p>I need to calculate the temporal trends for some climate variables with missing values. For example, last frost days defines as the last day of year with minimum temperature less than 0C. However, there are no any frost days in some years. </p> <p>My data look like: </p> <pre><code>lfd &lt;- c(NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, 190, 192, 189, 200, 185, 205, 203, 200, 207, NA, NA, 205) years &lt;- seq(1957, length.out = length(lfd)) </code></pre> <p>Now I use the linear regression in R (function lm) to calculate temporal trend. It seems the results are unreasonable for datasets with many missing values.</p> <p>How could I calculate the temporal trends with missing values? Thanks for any suggestions. </p>
74,045
[ 0.013063587248325348, -0.03600199520587921, -0.0083076860755682, 0.02423313446342945, 0.034661754965782166, -0.020220575854182243, 0.007961658760905266, -0.04450897127389908, 0.025138169527053833, -0.021999428048729897, 0.026467084884643555, 0.02922082506120205, 0.005666589364409447, -0.02623668499290943, 0.03868933767080307, 0.036852966994047165, -0.03553582355380058, -0.003930640406906605, 0.03256481885910034, 0.020503627136349678, -0.007004431914538145, 0.020723067224025726, 0.00002145360122085549, 0.008499504067003727, -0.030175790190696716, 0.040993738919496536, 0.010317541658878326, 0.01588604226708412, 0.022077826783061028, 0.04505705088376999, -0.037245046347379684, -0.051935434341430664, 0.03856131434440613, 0.027401581406593323, -0.018809977918863297, 0.010648799128830433, -0.020025024190545082, -0.02979862131178379, 0.004051524214446545, 0.0574522390961647, -0.01645175740122795, -0.03577544540166855, -0.001961265690624714, 0.022799387574195862, 0.0027754136826843023, 0.010841846466064453, 0.0252235010266304, -0.0011223931796848774, 0.04543764516711235, -0.01852751523256302, 0.05170031264424324, -0.019917290657758713, 0.06778015941381454, -0.013965330086648464, -0.02762307971715927, -0.012014376930892467, 0.08502677828073502, 0.0324581079185009, 0.005564008839428425, -0.07131362706422806, -0.0027912971563637257, -0.022159337997436523, 0.008987784385681152, 0.0003915794368367642, -0.03189174085855484, 0.004864872433245182, -0.031607285141944885, -0.014281665906310081, 0.030717452988028526, -0.03558868169784546, 0.008115658536553383, 0.0031706870067864656, 0.023159576579928398, -0.004825990181416273, -0.0006737622898072004, -0.013443903997540474, -0.023999955505132675, 0.03228733316063881, 0.027209246531128883, 0.03822767734527588, 0.007214704062789679, 0.012825085781514645, 0.07085458189249039, 0.03967173770070076, 0.014158407226204872, -0.014718107879161835, 0.08010316640138626, -0.03209417685866356, 0.020827537402510643, -0.009798885323107243, 0.002811446087434888, -0.003243360435590148, 0.06577230989933014, 0.014056863263249397, -0.0507052056491375, 0.0035010813735425472, 0.012979615479707718, 0.011213993653655052, 0.0277436301112175, -0.004126646090298891, 0.010191232897341251, -0.018490109592676163, 0.015856344252824783, 0.043469641357660294, -0.0559208020567894, -0.018600456416606903, -0.0189137551933527, -0.004490095656365156, 0.005042493809014559, -0.034819457679986954, -0.024386145174503326, 0.023825326934456825, -0.00011146776523673907, -0.0019182140240445733, 0.017263442277908325, -0.03896012157201767, -0.03409837186336517, 0.0030306477565318346, 0.03622417896986008, 0.07106064260005951, 0.02189880982041359, -0.029146049171686172, 0.01951775699853897, 0.00242623477242887, -0.048241909593343735, 0.012935328297317028, 0.011253071948885918, -0.007365718949586153, -0.03488872945308685, 0.04842226207256317, -0.038720324635505676, -0.03653937205672264, 0.03668410703539848, -0.032862287014722824, 0.06762333959341049, -0.0022852085530757904, -0.08217695355415344, -0.015058889053761959, 0.017246725037693977, -0.037025269120931625, 0.013677248731255531, -0.03405620902776718, 0.030684538185596466, -0.03167421743273735, 0.04592916741967201, 0.03803033381700516, 0.03477093204855919, 0.024223769083619118, 0.011948864907026291, -0.014052980579435825, -0.04205932840704918, 0.01242655050009489, 0.007830421440303326, -0.018553996458649635, -0.02351788990199566, -0.07173730432987213, 0.004421195015311241, 0.040707554668188095, -0.00466053606942296, 0.017958706244826317, 0.053554825484752655, 0.031068120151758194, -0.02356608957052231, 0.0013038935139775276, 0.012505858205258846, -0.05286881700158119, 0.09939270466566086, -0.005182397086173296, 0.02911433018743992, 0.028271663933992386, -0.010918096639215946, 0.019383277744054794, 0.02580382116138935, 0.06039378419518471, 0.04778733104467392, 0.009878778830170631, 0.008201099000871181, -0.0008579685818403959, -0.027236558496952057, 0.05640977993607521, -0.07876913249492645, -0.0008488640887662768, 0.009564095176756382, -0.012575466185808182, 0.019912239164114, 0.05774885416030884, -0.014151000417768955, -0.017763083800673485, 0.0517578087747097, -0.08469027280807495, -0.020523859187960625, -0.07198157161474228, -0.028641197830438614, 0.008100584149360657, 0.010275619104504585, 0.004318506456911564, -0.0014763305662199855, 0.06724875420331955, 0.01746232993900776, -0.02465558797121048, -0.026628151535987854, -0.006485459394752979, 0.023530738428235054, -0.030907927080988884, 0.021131575107574463, 0.02328588254749775, 0.07313235104084015, 0.006012259051203728, 0.024212708696722984, -0.038393907248973846, -0.03366440534591675, 0.01149158924818039, -0.05566684156656265, 0.016455920413136482, -0.010375219397246838, -0.01300936657935381, 0.004192607011646032, -0.02063954994082451, -0.021342065185308456, 0.042342618107795715, -0.017680684104561806, 0.025576842948794365, 0.07216166704893112, 0.021494107320904732, -0.011882704682648182, -0.000044954129407415166, 0.01631324738264084, 0.023465009406208992, -0.05411238595843315, -0.024386165663599968, -0.05993010103702545, -0.009712353348731995, 0.03396754711866379, 0.024174509570002556, -0.0420159213244915, 0.029483400285243988, 0.06585494428873062, 0.005191597156226635, 0.028599463403224945, 0.03091106191277504, 0.0015455675311386585, 0.004312766715884209, -0.0136438999325037, -0.003949093632400036, 0.021315036341547966, -0.003776599420234561, 0.013156001456081867, 0.013300664722919464, 0.047253113240003586, -0.0002115836541634053, 0.011181063018739223, 0.060201361775398254, 0.016274958848953247, -0.010679792612791061, -0.037171006202697754, -0.03114517219364643, 0.054025281220674515, -0.010741589590907097, -0.011552773416042328, 0.026802288368344307, 0.016635166481137276, 0.0005743371439166367, 0.01093779131770134, -0.011492783203721046, 0.020945724099874496, 0.05017169192433357, -0.04306000471115112, -0.008663533255457878, 0.01455826684832573, -0.01153656654059887, 0.039188284426927567, -0.04469476267695427, -0.03618993982672691, -0.05001302435994148, 0.029808253049850464, 0.047618865966796875, 0.0444365032017231, 0.016113532707095146, -0.033951908349990845, -0.01913139410316944, -0.015437476336956024, -0.0348990373313427, 0.0074423570185899734, 0.01359901949763298, -0.0201994888484478, -0.022621043026447296, 0.006813246291130781, -0.01620555855333805, 0.031291697174310684, -0.008623809553682804, -0.015086578205227852, 0.0307356845587492, 0.002775986446067691, -0.05181698873639107, -0.038665495812892914, -0.02331812120974064, -0.0010593751212581992, -0.025482716038823128, -0.026299839839339256, 0.039306458085775375, -0.010875485837459564, -0.01843593455851078, -0.014688380993902683, -0.07228948175907135, -0.007511749863624573, -0.06913672387599945, -0.021516941487789154, -0.0015664610546082258, -0.020561788231134415, -0.03250517696142197, 0.03183113411068916, -0.027217645198106766, 0.018579812720417976, -0.08070150762796402, -0.048176754266023636, 0.0335269533097744, 0.019927749410271645, 0.01610654778778553, -0.0037112601567059755, -0.019701873883605003, 0.04667988792061806, 0.04720376059412956, -0.03809165209531784, -0.06374666839838028, -0.009887855499982834, -0.025217533111572266, -0.02386320009827614, -0.008391009643673897, 0.007902541197836399, 0.026466120034456253, 0.007309833075851202, 0.0015756661305204034, 0.017647484317421913, 0.04455200955271721, 0.017306102439761162, 0.006698370445519686, -0.03021048568189144, 0.009189520962536335, 0.0008476776420138776, 0.03928021714091301, -0.019079992547631264, -0.027868889272212982, 0.0252511128783226, -0.04058147221803665, 0.035096775740385056, 0.022635595872998238, -0.043887533247470856, 0.0022880234755575657, -0.03196898102760315, 0.00960287544876337, -0.029674412682652473, 0.028838392347097397, 0.0178658589720726, 0.0120848985388875, -0.0022941557690501213, 0.00807641725987196, 0.010160703212022781, -0.001689275843091309, -0.01651768758893013, 0.049845416098833084, 0.03710655868053436, -0.03045472875237465, 0.022129524499177933, 0.006688255816698074, -0.01882960833609104, 0.034525316208601, -0.02495482563972473, -0.005551469977945089, 0.024132192134857178, 0.05241277813911438, 0.027781888842582703, 0.00231895106844604, -0.05292830243706703, 0.012400796636939049, -0.04653700441122055, -0.007580186240375042, -0.015666911378502846, 0.061602842062711716, -0.008406835608184338, 0.027836984023451805, 0.014091077260673046, 0.015947630628943443, 0.06582143157720566, -0.03333592787384987, -0.07208579778671265, 0.04984593763947487, 0.005422846879810095, 0.01099829189479351, -0.013786486349999905, 0.016028279438614845, 0.017545556649565697, 0.006166237872093916, 0.014291715808212757, -0.007184432353824377, -0.001498068799264729, -0.0011134285014122725, -0.048483334481716156, -0.008241106756031513, -0.003936011344194412, -0.0356290303170681, -0.005820949096232653, 0.009374095126986504, -0.02447550743818283, 0.014318577945232391, 0.050463225692510605, 0.02634299173951149, -0.03296445682644844, -0.004561979789286852, 0.013938413932919502, 0.013312804512679577, 0.03741732984781265, 0.03336852788925171, 0.00943708699196577, -0.04320932924747467, 0.011426501907408237, 0.05338998883962631, 0.012026192620396614, 0.035489194095134735, 0.047017261385917664, -0.04341468960046768, -0.015511916019022465, 0.00761417206376791, 0.036299072206020355, -0.009724278002977371, 0.05014545097947121, 0.027274828404188156, 0.06349839270114899, 0.027683209627866745, -0.03239595890045166, 0.024013614282011986, 0.050939202308654785, 0.027169402688741684, 0.017143385484814644, -0.0021928625646978617, -0.022963285446166992, -0.018615838140249252, -0.022260470315814018, 0.005620877258479595, 0.011388460174202919, 0.01815870776772499, -0.004051889292895794, 0.034026674926280975, -0.005721266381442547, -0.03502371534705162, -0.018633374944329262, 0.02627054788172245, 0.04237477108836174, 0.0050817811861634254, -0.044948283582925797, 0.03284144774079323, 0.04381264001131058, 0.018524279817938805, 0.019857194274663925, 0.02726813592016697, -0.1037708967924118, 0.014046776108443737, 0.03192877396941185, 0.012084289453923702, -0.025684703141450882, -0.06074776127934456, -0.049374181777238846, 0.02200121432542801, 0.040334418416023254, -0.03068499267101288, 0.015113686211407185, 0.000899052363820374, 0.027556514367461205, 0.003182679647579789, -0.058049462735652924, -0.02053716406226158, 0.012617571279406548, -0.014612593688070774, 0.04469749704003334, -0.026446061208844185, -0.05103810504078865, -0.016953928396105766, 0.01451296079903841, -0.01159418560564518, 0.053235627710819244, -0.025328239426016808, -0.001822581165470183, 0.02699013240635395, 0.013334318064153194, 0.00467058178037405, -0.03981371596455574, -0.005645728204399347, 0.00412401370704174, 0.012625141069293022, 0.05217086151242256, 0.028385015204548836, -0.0127934655174613, 0.021896420046687126, 0.025460155680775642, -0.03406141698360443, -0.02193360961973667, -0.04630287364125252, 0.019362984225153923, -0.00577884865924716, 0.026404758915305138, 0.05314432084560394, 0.06783659756183624, -0.021490832790732384, 0.0023297229781746864, -0.045567043125629425, 0.00559571385383606, 0.0067588347010314465, -0.0164859127253294, -0.05486932769417763, -0.033520523458719254, -0.012760554440319538, 0.02212614379823208, -0.022727256640791893, -0.015029003843665123, -0.0356222465634346, 0.03212882578372955, 0.04286409541964531, 0.029372092336416245, -0.0159761980175972, -0.017146814614534378, -0.009313821792602539, 0.008900769054889679, -0.012932618148624897, -0.03293841704726219, 0.019540734589099884, -0.0034553289879113436, -0.0035092525649815798, 0.024721192196011543, -0.03737698495388031, 0.0301328394562006, 0.009951140731573105, -0.023771118372678757, -0.0009590432164259255, -0.009714854881167412, -0.01169545017182827, -0.017005695030093193, 0.005823946557939053, -0.01629813387989998, -0.05825817584991455, 0.009581195190548897, 0.029659248888492584, 0.0006695724441669881, 0.021103236824274063, -0.03273652121424675, 0.027897993102669716, 0.010762456804513931, 0.011597411707043648, -0.061584051698446274, -0.07160045206546783, 0.028071017935872078, 0.004864438436925411, -0.03683929517865181, -0.0187436044216156, -0.0032853197772055864, -0.028776569291949272, 0.0013856802834197879, -0.02385045401751995, 0.06254678219556808, 0.0058043464086949825, -0.007878773845732212, -0.01958131603896618, -0.0004732389934360981, 0.06049618870019913, -0.015513930469751358, -0.011547335423529148, 0.0011055759387090802, -0.027245862409472466, -0.03016251139342785, -0.015636347234249115, 0.008975966833531857, -0.03189462795853615, 0.003167602466419339, -0.009434742853045464, 0.004480451345443726, 0.06611563265323639, 0.001335117849521339, -0.05575164034962654, 0.020769823342561722, -0.012891998514533043, 0.004661235958337784, -0.06664330512285233, 0.036778662353754044, -0.03444904461503029, -0.0018506429623812437, -0.031658146530389786, -0.03797803819179535, -0.010469868779182434, -0.026528066024184227, -0.0007288011838681996, -0.023887693881988525, 0.0156900305300951, 0.03662257269024849, 0.08253974467515945, -0.03261558338999748, 0.022567158564925194, 0.010225136764347553, -0.005144595634192228, 0.044582657516002655, 0.061942704021930695, -0.005853159353137016, -0.03648316487669945, 0.02912408672273159, -0.0143325449898839, -0.02815256640315056, -0.014280646108090878, -0.0021500273142009974, 0.051972489804029465, -0.012922004796564579, 0.02445649355649948, 0.04257948696613312, 0.005733414087444544, 0.02364509366452694, -0.039268024265766144, 0.001088221906684339, 0.007742969319224358, 0.021745160222053528, 0.022690027952194214, -0.031077919527888298, 0.016368629410862923, 0.009133998304605484, 0.03675103187561035, 0.0012542408658191562, 0.029212255030870438, -0.04147527739405632, -0.009349801577627659, -0.0004980810917913914, -0.021244743838906288, -0.020969152450561523, 0.014282974414527416, -0.005975430365651846, 0.019228531047701836, -0.037329986691474915, -0.04602770134806633, 0.0339629240334034, -0.024248261004686356, 0.009577376767992973, -0.03031623177230358, 0.0030323017854243517, -0.0138496533036232, 0.01261313445866108, 0.038667790591716766, -0.021818559616804123, 0.046547528356313705, 0.03465976566076279, 0.052708663046360016, -0.024970855563879013, 0.03640381246805191, -0.005414193496108055, -0.04753493145108223, -0.010706731118261814, -0.04816051572561264, 0.0007415774744004011, 0.0006372018833644688, 0.0022263554856181145, -0.012006777338683605, -0.015825040638446808, 0.011078202165663242, -0.008193328976631165, 0.03471299633383751, 0.0502108633518219, 0.002494438784196973, 0.06634521484375, 0.021650146692991257, -0.0016572130843997002, -0.031279776245355606, 0.0024861146230250597, 0.13220469653606415, 0.06803631782531738, 0.037894174456596375, -0.0878927931189537, 0.015613032504916191, 0.026768475770950317, 0.01122672576457262, -0.05880236253142357, 0.0011132131330668926, -0.015876520425081253, 0.01379923615604639, 0.05351708084344864, 0.05004296824336052, -0.03460969030857086, -0.0031162691302597523, 0.032353632152080536, -0.034617453813552856, 0.00817045196890831, 0.016600308939814568, 0.0067734625190496445, -0.0012991323601454496, -0.00847215298563242, -0.06220930814743042, 0.050443317741155624, 0.013181678019464016, 0.004700219724327326, -0.016370365396142006, -0.008508638478815556, -0.0077469912357628345, -0.023824336007237434, -0.0676792562007904, 0.02787320874631405, 0.019383473321795464, 0.06331576406955719, -0.007296327035874128, -0.01264834776520729, 0.018559198826551437, -0.030346892774105072, 0.010649516247212887, 0.026713671162724495, 0.025614099577069283, 0.008255907334387302, -0.029164956882596016, -0.003273443318903446, -0.029038557782769203, -0.008814573287963867, -0.052118632942438126, 0.049580007791519165, 0.010837015695869923, -0.006273440085351467, 0.01418318785727024, 0.0057421354576945305, -0.016384107992053032, -0.015361979603767395, -0.03264350816607475, 0.037111930549144745, 0.03951630741357803, -0.025927552953362465, -0.008010989986360073, 0.0004407172091305256, -0.015566241927444935, -0.00973557960242033, 0.02490980550646782, 0.02317085489630699, -0.03376307338476181, -0.009436947293579578, -0.013853372074663639, 0.07259295880794525, -0.028964892029762268, 0.019229967147111893, 0.009068782441318035, -0.008659258484840393, 0.0007725223549641669, -0.013905911706387997, 0.03847033903002739, -0.00345635530538857, 0.011908703483641148, -0.03686888888478279, -0.0021098386496305466, 0.0024744768161326647, -0.06252557039260864, 0.02089933305978775, 0.007710213307291269, -0.008886352181434631, -0.020891238003969193, 0.007322017569094896, 0.05509336292743683, 0.013049411587417126, 0.007491126190871, 0.002293742261826992, -0.012794706039130688, 0.08167792111635208, 0.010965201072394848, -0.06347807496786118, -0.02514229714870453, -0.010870628990232944, -0.012771571055054665, 0.027171114459633827, -0.027542974799871445, 0.038589321076869965, 0.04172681272029877, 0.014219341799616814, 0.020300041884183884, 0.02770240046083927, -0.011253460310399532, -0.00870990939438343, 0.04496489092707634, -0.061929259449243546, -0.002939315978437662, -0.023380756378173828, -0.002705910475924611, -0.028178326785564423, -0.02572789415717125, -0.023270998150110245, -0.010893811471760273, 0.02657349221408367, -0.05506472289562225, -0.05264207348227501, 0.016887011006474495, 0.021618394181132317, 0.0011393994791433215, -0.023092810064554214, -0.01420501060783863, -0.06916460394859314, -0.01892990618944168, -0.015801455825567245, -0.062835194170475, -0.020350608974695206, 0.022706137970089912, -0.052509233355522156, -0.005788169335573912, 0.03745498135685921, 0.018626313656568527, 0.014665858820080757, -0.011206937953829765, 0.039625175297260284, -0.0026900654193013906, 0.05192747712135315, -0.01820172555744648, -0.05688755214214325, -0.008265749551355839, -0.036103006452322006, -0.047377269715070724, 0.01653112657368183, 0.0007789376541040838, 0.001531930174678564, -0.04648162052035332, -0.016030842438340187, -0.036788459867239, 0.07295595854520798, -0.02429370954632759, 0.01999865658581257, -0.04567372053861618, 0.009575027041137218, 0.023487912490963936, -0.0026825442910194397, -0.032885439693927765, 0.013482814654707909, -0.02445147931575775, 0.0025305727031081915, 0.0603550560772419, 0.0061501432210206985, -0.0040152836591005325, -0.015740903094410896, -0.029539601877331734, 0.0036788079887628555, 0.00014880757953505963, 0.02204401232302189, 0.027152352035045624, 0.0671311765909195, -0.0036956779658794403, 0.011820542626082897, -0.023562734946608543, 0.03633232042193413, -0.1102336049079895, 0.02454070746898651, -0.008733215741813183, 0.02225080132484436, 0.011173434555530548, -0.016622235998511314, 0.008786790072917938, 0.025839166715741158, -0.027068743482232094, 0.005384012125432491, -0.021957896649837494, 0.019687892869114876, -0.00917017087340355, 0.018899094313383102, 0.003121130634099245, 0.024525241926312447, 0.04803778976202011, 0.0405876524746418, 0.02349851466715336, 0.036755986511707306, 0.04533888399600983, -0.06141422688961029, -0.0360599160194397, 0.004404435865581036, 0.030777137726545334, -0.04679175093770027, -0.003434431040659547, 0.017075253650546074, -0.021158048883080482, 0.0020595360547304153, -0.051911693066358566, 0.03362351283431053, 0.02513594552874565, 0.013605131767690182, -0.009940210729837418, 0.05368085205554962, 0.005023994017392397, -0.014406105503439903, -0.027797281742095947, 0.0002632726973388344, 0.006892150267958641, 0.007535398006439209, -0.040234148502349854, 0.012407270260155201, 0.025260696187615395, -0.02995653823018074, -0.025720465928316116, 0.01419030874967575, 0.004384292289614677, 0.02389046549797058, 0.0041191959753632545, 0.01742902398109436, -0.012774987146258354, -0.050580527633428574, -0.015646077692508698, -0.005910653620958328, -0.003089849604293704, 0.06626947224140167, 0.026528431102633476, -0.033320631831884384, 0.0017382116056978703, 0.00301473680883646, -0.04455622285604477, 0.005019036121666431, -0.0003120547335129231, 0.000626242021098733, -0.07086418569087982, 0.01125895231962204, -0.010907118208706379, -0.011214001104235649, -0.04111722484230995, -0.005028805695474148, -0.07086686044931412, 0.040636301040649414, -0.018614541739225388, 0.02273971401154995, 0.02889956161379814, -0.026551732793450356, 0.020895132794976234, -0.0799890086054802, 0.0787380039691925, -0.02469921112060547, 0.007737522944808006, -0.025331372395157814, 0.007719607558101416, -0.04338178411126137, 0.01681111380457878, 0.04675978422164917, -0.026214469224214554, 0.03230268135666847, -0.024314993992447853, 0.03262411057949066, -0.008578617125749588, -0.05007496848702431, 0.04980093985795975, 0.01372560579329729, -0.009738600812852383, 0.013976991176605225, -0.024008778855204582, 0.014081649482250214, 0.0027132504619657993, 0.014029048383235931, -0.010259292088449001, 0.031033633276820183, -0.003157060593366623, 0.000502335256896913, 0.008300882764160633, 0.013620463199913502, -0.02551824413239956, 0.02322164550423622, -0.026181641966104507, 0.03201442211866379, 0.025256957858800888, 0.014658047817647457, -0.052321936935186386, 0.036457862704992294, -0.034475523978471756, -0.0002064853470074013, 0.028376847505569458, -0.025340043008327484, -0.0004100001824554056, -0.07903136312961578, -0.034933291375637054, 0.015748707577586174, -0.01888038031756878, -0.008425776846706867, 0.022141259163618088, -0.008947698399424553, 0.021583236753940582, -0.017105476930737495, 0.012147130444645882, 0.009068017825484276, 0.026666909456253052, -0.006041677203029394, 0.020930472761392593, 0.020570525899529457, 0.0007197987288236618, 0.029943618923425674, -0.006840535439550877, -0.008313791826367378, 0.031690485775470734, -0.01850474439561367, 0.038039207458496094, -0.004704257007688284, -0.016081277281045914, 0.009226759895682335, -0.0037178578786551952, 0.02212260477244854, 0.010302425362169743, -0.012138267047703266, 0.020392511039972305, -0.02077745459973812, 0.020760705694556236, -0.04113686829805374, -0.07078798860311508, -0.037117764353752136, 0.013475458137691021, -0.02747373841702938, 0.005096220411360264, -0.03955058008432388, 0.04293959587812424, 0.045400794595479965, 0.021329132840037346, 0.02001226879656315, -0.014092359691858292, -0.009382294490933418, -0.029219752177596092, -0.0013941737124696374, 0.02938000299036503, -0.007130998652428389, -0.029894212260842323, -0.01743495836853981, -0.011558197438716888, 0.03438164293766022, 0.04725317284464836, -0.05011361092329025, -0.01694357581436634, -0.029599610716104507, 0.028774673119187355, -0.051104553043842316, -0.003800253150984645, -0.03902747854590416, -0.0011068449821323156, -0.0473012775182724, -0.04240742698311806 ]
<p>I am interested in developing a computational search of some types of non-coding RNAs (ncRNAs) on a new genome. I have some questions related to the nature of my experiment, because it is an exploratory study, and I can generate different results by applying different BLAST search strategies. The final output consists of different counts of each type of ncRNA for each BLAST strategy. </p> <p>How I can design good search strategies, taking into account that it is the first search on this new genome?</p> <p>References will be appreciated. </p> <p>Thanks!</p>
48,340
[ -0.04919624701142311, -0.05967202037572861, -0.013605667278170586, 0.003936368506401777, 0.032581303268671036, 0.0031736602541059256, 0.02104070782661438, -0.050202876329422, 0.013625155203044415, -0.023798523470759392, 0.027759814634919167, 0.02140292525291443, 0.05846886709332466, -0.0030757880304008722, -0.008527115918695927, -0.01780623011291027, -0.015979280695319176, -0.022886499762535095, -0.04933576285839081, 0.005763842258602381, 0.021368250250816345, 0.021870747208595276, -0.0007847978267818689, 0.028905780985951424, -0.006073149386793375, 0.009710506536066532, 0.014829868450760841, -0.04447682201862335, 0.02715364098548889, 0.032751861959695816, -0.058453209698200226, -0.006085189525038004, 0.05844975635409355, 0.037876058369874954, 0.03233485668897629, -0.015663867816329002, -0.06978075951337814, -0.060338836163282394, -0.002651447197422385, 0.007150729186832905, -0.04045926034450531, -0.008490022271871567, -0.045156028121709824, 0.023853085935115814, -0.018959224224090576, 0.04554416239261627, 0.0012136799050495028, -0.0006304694688878953, -0.0212711188942194, -0.04440580680966377, 0.04280160367488861, 0.010285279713571072, 0.03057515062391758, 0.0010456449817866087, 0.028176292777061462, 0.003129121847450733, 0.04341643303632736, 0.05637666583061218, 0.02794390544295311, -0.05450024455785751, -0.01691802404820919, -0.01680326648056507, 0.035093750804662704, -0.059329282492399216, -0.04525166377425194, 0.07103202491998672, 0.03627631813287735, 0.003222150495275855, 0.0032708728685975075, -0.011289816349744797, 0.02123291604220867, -0.004464185331016779, 0.015497907996177673, 0.002050828654319048, 0.016980282962322235, -0.025491345673799515, -0.0019399026641622186, 0.0323491133749485, 0.007989173755049706, 0.022340409457683563, 0.005657777655869722, -0.011603797785937786, 0.01623242162168026, 0.01387528982013464, 0.010473902337253094, -0.009149953722953796, 0.04196936637163162, -0.05397430434823036, 0.019848335534334183, -0.002239887835457921, 0.013630827888846397, -0.03649996593594551, 0.05127440020442009, -0.004050962161272764, -0.05402500554919243, 0.006126963533461094, -0.00501903286203742, 0.02857166714966297, -0.02007315680384636, -0.03922365605831146, -0.035392649471759796, -0.02512127347290516, 0.08281435817480087, 0.06824803352355957, -0.040765583515167236, 0.013988915830850601, -0.050923366099596024, 0.018448906019330025, -0.04295681044459343, 0.017370469868183136, -0.04244463890790939, 0.015285912901163101, 0.014391686767339706, 0.004385645966976881, 0.010227348655462265, -0.04431131109595299, -0.0024877372197806835, -0.03479563072323799, 0.0759996771812439, 0.0630142092704773, -0.004546409472823143, -0.033422451466321945, 0.05438985675573349, -0.03933199867606163, -0.034616366028785706, -0.02770312689244747, 0.042673200368881226, 0.02097666636109352, -0.02384245954453945, 0.0680750161409378, -0.04615374282002449, 0.01031951792538166, -0.006522637791931629, -0.026130206882953644, 0.028466373682022095, -0.024707112461328506, -0.09997249394655228, -0.08326622098684311, 0.07021589577198029, -0.04381341114640236, -0.01759376935660839, -0.06246543303132057, -0.019474180415272713, 0.04627286270260811, 0.0634951964020729, -0.02242281287908554, 0.030880765989422798, 0.027125127613544464, 0.003585664788261056, 0.027785344049334526, 0.0033193721901625395, -0.0018410502234473825, -0.010664422996342182, 0.0008969968766905367, -0.002828640630468726, -0.0574011467397213, 0.03618624433875084, 0.00247122417204082, 0.0049431901425123215, -0.008301468566060066, 0.013380653224885464, -0.004460916388779879, 0.009525272995233536, -0.02985984832048416, 0.04070841521024704, 0.011116576381027699, 0.05184286832809448, 0.012194912880659103, 0.008730649016797543, 0.048199787735939026, -0.02685949020087719, 0.033462271094322205, 0.028974328190088272, -0.0033517724368721247, 0.07238920778036118, -0.00003630670107668266, -0.017322422936558723, 0.00808121357113123, 0.02060399204492569, 0.008340463973581791, 0.022418783977627754, -0.030840054154396057, -0.004394936375319958, 0.03671833500266075, 0.06079983338713646, 0.025207089260220528, -0.006168344523757696, -0.018601756542921066, 0.06283107399940491, -0.03555983304977417, -0.029913803562521935, -0.060661934316158295, -0.005079822614789009, 0.04078580439090729, -0.014576125890016556, 0.045875489711761475, 0.007730786222964525, 0.010158665478229523, 0.016680795699357986, -0.0029186063911765814, -0.03524818271398544, 0.034773748368024826, 0.04654809832572937, 0.003215244971215725, -0.02508515492081642, 0.0384858101606369, -0.010200833901762962, -0.04669971019029617, 0.05224854126572609, 0.007553050760179758, -0.06476379930973053, -0.02751416712999344, -0.01586896739900112, 0.01396377757191658, 0.019024766981601715, 0.00980379804968834, -0.015379342250525951, 0.05863466486334801, -0.009160282090306282, -0.03425007313489914, -0.02723546139895916, 0.08571407943964005, 0.07910886406898499, 0.015410750173032284, 0.032134123146533966, 0.003347564022988081, 0.037570010870695114, 0.0011170487850904465, -0.01071656122803688, 0.02003672905266285, -0.0753634124994278, -0.024841129779815674, 0.05168674886226654, 0.029471728950738907, -0.05503636598587036, 0.010813351720571518, 0.04184756055474281, -0.005298580974340439, 0.029253404587507248, -0.00691199628636241, -0.025531014427542686, -0.04724077507853508, 0.044775575399398804, 0.054736245423555374, 0.02444990910589695, 0.0048479181714355946, 0.03589172661304474, -0.0094952043145895, 0.037158068269491196, -0.028769494965672493, 0.007303529419004917, 0.0389559268951416, -0.0028826806228607893, -0.006891449447721243, -0.02047104761004448, -0.03696136176586151, 0.022257376462221146, -0.008817520923912525, 0.01982688717544079, 0.017384538426995277, 0.006841805763542652, -0.008373993448913097, 0.0036433637142181396, 0.007197082974016666, 0.012733221054077148, 0.0315396673977375, 0.011934112757444382, -0.009437411092221737, 0.025157103314995766, -0.05456233024597168, 0.03971051052212715, 0.00948979053646326, -0.02357318252325058, -0.0429721400141716, 0.014875759370625019, -0.0017481240211054683, -0.00734991580247879, 0.05785035341978073, -0.00036377241485752165, -0.028849467635154724, -0.0004166982544120401, -0.0183009821921587, -0.008164234459400177, 0.04810977727174759, -0.061999622732400894, -0.013842168264091015, -0.019886072725057602, 0.011500579304993153, 0.01742500253021717, -0.04455786943435669, -0.020509719848632812, 0.05335948243737221, -0.016235072165727615, -0.051357366144657135, 0.014541721902787685, -0.03368886560201645, 0.01982180029153824, -0.014430421404540539, -0.009229294955730438, 0.058484502136707306, 0.009511238895356655, -0.06831858307123184, 0.02909071370959282, -0.010324261151254177, 0.01581626385450363, 0.021148132160305977, 0.010067633353173733, -0.014373044483363628, -0.022889990359544754, 0.008580198511481285, 0.012392939068377018, -0.0028918490279465914, 0.006165487691760063, -0.03728540986776352, -0.05245822295546532, -0.010523865930736065, -0.02078736200928688, 0.06926441937685013, -0.0036950043868273497, -0.015467560850083828, 0.07128987461328506, 0.040733546018600464, -0.023000136017799377, -0.061328403651714325, -0.026838328689336777, -0.033601313829422, -0.04421424865722656, 0.017289018258452415, -0.013447155244648457, -0.023340223357081413, -0.016026685014367104, 0.03250927850604057, 0.05548027157783508, 0.0625859722495079, 0.0038027309346944094, 0.012684392742812634, 0.04654480516910553, 0.022591648623347282, -0.006469701416790485, 0.03422873094677925, 0.04531678557395935, -0.014689454808831215, 0.019179873168468475, -0.01522304117679596, -0.021327262744307518, 0.02214907854795456, -0.05091359093785286, 0.02089504525065422, 0.004435807000845671, -0.018601490184664726, -0.012517665512859821, 0.006793526466935873, 0.011379790492355824, 0.0003419196291361004, 0.013593710027635098, 0.005041587632149458, 0.04871997609734535, -0.025910107418894768, -0.03112313151359558, 0.028143256902694702, 0.024418996647000313, -0.038542043417692184, 0.03143119439482689, -0.019887518137693405, -0.04060225561261177, 0.01741962879896164, 0.008627697825431824, 0.004620817489922047, 0.0027956306003034115, 0.0007156281499192119, 0.015110548585653305, 0.018355684354901314, -0.0566442646086216, -0.004410883877426386, 0.004835998173803091, -0.010219675488770008, -0.016539325937628746, 0.04509764537215233, -0.0072950017638504505, 0.031228402629494667, 0.028259476646780968, -0.01900303177535534, 0.017779449000954628, 0.005952236242592335, -0.0616193562746048, 0.02670386992394924, -0.02428869530558586, 0.014763040468096733, -0.0014672534307464957, -0.019859742373228073, -0.004615237470716238, 0.01348875928670168, 0.04131151735782623, -0.005640280432999134, 0.025215117260813713, -0.03293600678443909, 0.03026464767754078, -0.015990927815437317, -0.007062658667564392, -0.02804926224052906, 0.06371505558490753, -0.007879403419792652, 0.010940207168459892, 0.029351910576224327, 0.03985190764069557, -0.03938781097531319, -0.002592514967545867, -0.004149419255554676, -0.020510217174887657, -0.008247421123087406, 0.0186392180621624, 0.02311578392982483, 0.015965858474373817, -0.018843088299036026, 0.004508075304329395, 0.006565755698829889, 0.042815472930669785, 0.020807776600122452, 0.025997867807745934, -0.0033610581886023283, -0.015258317813277245, 0.010914243757724762, -0.03525719419121742, 0.0155325410887599, 0.020249443128705025, -0.003860726021230221, 0.058026719838380814, 0.018349960446357727, -0.024834655225276947, -0.009736386127769947, 0.048244647681713104, 0.01037747785449028, 0.016228120774030685, -0.004684911575168371, 0.004009993746876717, -0.01671333983540535, 0.008216585963964462, -0.006773925386369228, -0.0031308091711252928, 0.016028210520744324, 0.006272976286709309, 0.040193840861320496, -0.041225045919418335, -0.04270131513476372, 0.023676317185163498, -0.017025316134095192, 0.03921632841229439, -0.01629193313419819, -0.040880605578422546, 0.039840567857027054, 0.018786823377013206, 0.02395888790488243, -0.011875097639858723, -0.006841717287898064, -0.08420828729867935, -0.05042862147092819, 0.05936960503458977, 0.048141006380319595, -0.017819557338953018, -0.033927880227565765, -0.055204421281814575, 0.012012472376227379, 0.01684962585568428, -0.04082687199115753, 0.009089346043765545, -0.002881713444367051, -0.0065848492085933685, -0.022369807586073875, -0.025548551231622696, -0.02513781003654003, 0.013341795653104782, -0.04567373916506767, 0.03503130003809929, -0.025925880298018456, -0.01052248664200306, -0.03522427752614021, -0.01624157652258873, -0.02987864799797535, 0.032457135617733, -0.05315130576491356, -0.01887141540646553, 0.007420976646244526, 0.006703905761241913, -0.013095216825604439, -0.04572368785738945, 0.021324671804904938, 0.010816903784871101, -0.013273491524159908, 0.04626738280057907, -0.029589051380753517, -0.05307057872414589, 0.011531318537890911, 0.025013236328959465, -0.036046333611011505, 0.00169397983700037, -0.07351607829332352, 0.011706843972206116, 0.02651813253760338, -0.005910901352763176, 0.031762927770614624, 0.014232960529625416, -0.006041872315108776, 0.02742236852645874, -0.013456921093165874, -0.0003001614531967789, -0.033167559653520584, 0.007682581432163715, -0.0412607342004776, -0.0019431947730481625, -0.01876119337975979, 0.015838341787457466, -0.00422784173861146, 0.033039189875125885, -0.012408673763275146, -0.014045142568647861, -0.014684787020087242, 0.07489240914583206, 0.0003442774759605527, 0.007221530191600323, -0.012421821244060993, -0.0018218940822407603, -0.014811490662395954, -0.01645132154226303, 0.015812715515494347, 0.011144834570586681, 0.030521100386977196, 0.024255143478512764, -0.015164465643465519, 0.03451018035411835, -0.037597376853227615, 0.009327446110546589, 0.05831722170114517, -0.008870501071214676, 0.06855214387178421, 0.04223163425922394, -0.003699382534250617, 0.020173760131001472, -0.05215536803007126, -0.04442084580659866, 0.02631210722029209, -0.01855967380106449, 0.010153225623071194, -0.03831256181001663, 0.020244378596544266, -0.044210031628608704, -0.0054139308631420135, -0.04572904855012894, -0.04792733117938042, 0.0012432454386726022, -0.002136032562702894, 0.004142057616263628, -0.019911745563149452, 0.0122228367254138, 0.04480912908911705, -0.019111836329102516, -0.01803908310830593, 0.04037448763847351, -0.0029069124720990658, 0.007065927144140005, 0.011225292459130287, 0.003338913433253765, 0.061088886111974716, 0.0040435465052723885, -0.003479122882708907, 0.02790938690304756, -0.014666270464658737, 0.024153415113687515, -0.037164539098739624, 0.003692448837682605, -0.02095937915146351, -0.03217462822794914, -0.022090040147304535, 0.030852286145091057, 0.06624125689268112, -0.031625863164663315, -0.0118746068328619, 0.005785820540040731, -0.012249494902789593, -0.03246556222438812, -0.05342492833733559, -0.0198159571737051, -0.02242017164826393, 0.009661155752837658, -0.0366598442196846, -0.005085902288556099, -0.006267230957746506, -0.03912161663174629, 0.021085822954773903, -0.012136537581682205, 0.03736284002661705, -0.005394493695348501, 0.05187009274959564, -0.013127891346812248, 0.012650943361222744, 0.025208590552210808, -0.02109847217798233, 0.019494181498885155, 0.0233843345195055, 0.021719131618738174, 0.01472864206880331, 0.03917107358574867, -0.018094981089234352, -0.02712787501513958, -0.006899431813508272, 0.009673072956502438, 0.06631367653608322, 0.004577628802508116, 0.04833906888961792, 0.03757157549262047, 0.01168112549930811, -0.003031984670087695, -0.008216752670705318, 0.03164786845445633, -0.008587858639657497, 0.04588983580470085, 0.017637234181165695, 0.02204497717320919, 0.03357341140508652, 0.07025008648633957, 0.009391500614583492, 0.03953975439071655, 0.02463526837527752, 0.026892321184277534, 0.025387737900018692, 0.012579141184687614, -0.03670134395360947, -0.05114666000008583, -0.00753720011562109, -0.07703280448913574, 0.06008411571383476, -0.0023393481969833374, -0.03709012642502785, 0.039141424000263214, 0.03730262443423271, -0.01476957369595766, -0.03520302101969719, -0.022776572033762932, -0.03492598235607147, 0.03912466764450073, 0.012689350172877312, -0.036937519907951355, 0.025351695716381073, 0.029062749817967415, 0.05130220204591751, -0.014030874706804752, 0.012256918475031853, -0.03049207292497158, -0.06289321184158325, -0.02415335550904274, -0.034135859459638596, -0.0775214210152626, 0.014010529033839703, 0.01574717089533806, -0.02872057445347309, 0.03339128941297531, -0.0017759186448529363, 0.010984127409756184, -0.015269948169589043, 0.03887820243835449, -0.03422817587852478, 0.060850538313388824, 0.015164904296398163, 0.0008715344010852277, -0.0003945153148379177, -0.015744216740131378, 0.09068218618631363, 0.0841623917222023, 0.039653629064559937, -0.09604823589324951, 0.049636390060186386, 0.01793893240392208, 0.029477398842573166, 0.010882011614739895, 0.004278010223060846, 0.056694626808166504, 0.026623468846082687, 0.014371264725923538, -0.013543062843382359, -0.05220375582575798, 0.01748858392238617, 0.04510658606886864, -0.043735433369874954, -0.06150849536061287, 0.0004124975821468979, -0.0241895392537117, -0.019961409270763397, -0.027842126786708832, -0.023607179522514343, 0.015790708363056183, 0.01501603052020073, -0.03142876923084259, -0.002676136326044798, -0.07295366376638412, 0.01651613786816597, 0.02003522962331772, -0.01769365556538105, 0.015478990972042084, -0.04218519851565361, -0.005797720979899168, -0.010976714082062244, -0.007877040654420853, -0.0052341921254992485, -0.014867346733808517, 0.010736776515841484, 0.036075614392757416, 0.01908249780535698, -0.018642576411366463, 0.0027962084859609604, 0.05500894412398338, -0.019950317218899727, -0.01605983078479767, -0.010266660712659359, 0.06102824956178665, -0.024840062484145164, -0.006644610781222582, -0.0021412407513707876, 0.011497809551656246, 0.033200014382600784, -0.00480601005256176, -0.02336714416742325, 0.03432437777519226, 0.024732429534196854, -0.01333433948457241, -0.016743851825594902, -0.00741700129583478, 0.010782763361930847, 0.0009647670667618513, 0.03841012716293335, 0.015394044108688831, 0.020286638289690018, -0.031232599169015884, -0.010834086686372757, -0.0018985356437042356, -0.015599634498357773, 0.003410008270293474, -0.017943045124411583, 0.008605947718024254, -0.027913672849535942, 0.004375557415187359, 0.027915561571717262, 0.016039391979575157, 0.01566186361014843, -0.00036848694435320795, -0.026690678671002388, -0.015510286204516888, -0.035538069903850555, -0.012763047590851784, -0.04276390001177788, -0.02050146274268627, -0.05057292431592941, 0.02724161557853222, 0.06376628577709198, 0.038986966013908386, 0.013365394435822964, 0.04681352525949478, -0.007569357752799988, 0.023292865604162216, 0.02467009425163269, -0.034280482679605484, -0.003363999305292964, -0.01615414395928383, -0.00046551533159799874, -0.024935999885201454, -0.015128988772630692, -0.00510991970077157, 0.01209176890552044, 0.022467833012342453, 0.053758736699819565, 0.013872559182345867, 0.006477895192801952, 0.022077223286032677, 0.005339564755558968, -0.07288838922977448, -0.02652014046907425, 0.004815975204110146, 0.0335182249546051, -0.05297797918319702, -0.042363785207271576, -0.03083869256079197, -0.017089704051613808, 0.03977052494883537, -0.016053730621933937, -0.02366136945784092, -0.01067371852695942, -0.032261673361063004, 0.010985665954649448, -0.05471394956111908, -0.0035198028199374676, -0.03902054205536842, 0.008550030179321766, -0.013569270260632038, 0.005946008488535881, 0.02706138975918293, 0.02150726690888405, -0.006408226676285267, 0.004224539268761873, 0.007362124975770712, 0.015656623989343643, -0.002939964411780238, 0.015473387204110622, 0.032126206904649734, -0.024429935961961746, 0.009211920201778412, 0.016288574784994125, -0.015217727050185204, 0.0388018935918808, -0.047461312264204025, -0.044290941208601, 0.025218214839696884, -0.019578294828534126, 0.006667729001492262, 0.01093878410756588, -0.005245552863925695, 0.005500044673681259, 0.05617814138531685, -0.011420168913900852, -0.013036972843110561, -0.035080406814813614, 0.02695145644247532, -0.021737150847911835, -0.0030571683309972286, 0.0108760641887784, -0.015330077148973942, -0.030525336042046547, 0.039361245930194855, 0.03576529771089554, 0.028150422498583794, 0.0023201834410429, 0.018436962738633156, -0.0034750159829854965, 0.010679907165467739, 0.005508470814675093, -0.02860627882182598, 0.027816329151391983, 0.09135191887617111, -0.022342028096318245, 0.06909631937742233, -0.019439751282334328, 0.003268580883741379, -0.06025076285004616, -0.007465703878551722, 0.0028504999354481697, 0.01618858054280281, 0.03851420059800148, -0.04635118693113327, 0.00005222211984801106, 0.04590894654393196, -0.05101809650659561, -0.0018785982392728329, 0.022155852988362312, -0.0015020706923678517, -0.010011909529566765, 0.003211807459592819, -0.04263616353273392, 0.018496163189411163, 0.02447606436908245, 0.025576438754796982, 0.07696659862995148, 0.010541589930653572, -0.039753787219524384, -0.0623188391327858, 0.016066040843725204, 0.022098153829574585, 0.012651809491217136, -0.04683874920010567, 0.030645135790109634, -0.042585019022226334, -0.03078518994152546, 0.0007325697806663811, -0.05444137379527092, 0.026678921654820442, 0.05340367555618286, 0.021898023784160614, 0.005029380787163973, 0.03752858191728592, 0.0482013002038002, -0.005452603101730347, 0.03115706518292427, -0.00795797910541296, -0.012885231524705887, 0.025707585737109184, -0.010540572926402092, 0.04039721563458443, 0.02288919687271118, -0.003644379088655114, -0.0012202197685837746, 0.039449263364076614, -0.015777666121721268, -0.020722832530736923, -0.01619977131485939, 0.01980527490377426, 0.0055884369648993015, 0.007367278914898634, 0.002485177479684353, -0.022913482040166855, 0.01194338221102953, 0.018975472077727318, 0.012369305826723576, -0.01885882392525673, 0.0006422883598133922, -0.013359162025153637, -0.0580810010433197, 0.008086476475000381, -0.013355493545532227, -0.027648309245705605, -0.04331931099295616, -0.0010459150653332472, -0.01036219671368599, 0.013928631320595741, -0.01501750759780407, -0.008862883783876896, -0.017065107822418213, 0.07710616290569305, -0.034150104969739914, -0.0009694302571006119, 0.025915073230862617, -0.031162206083536148, -0.0025625149719417095, -0.05704071745276451, 0.06883350759744644, 0.013320835307240486, 0.024811286479234695, -0.049823012202978134, -0.04296720027923584, -0.01648525707423687, 0.028673414140939713, 0.021902138367295265, -0.03851323574781418, -0.012111464515328407, -0.019794628024101257, 0.010951559990644455, 0.019203761592507362, -0.041595522314310074, 0.0488022081553936, -0.010105044580996037, -0.024048475548624992, -0.018570469692349434, 0.0017833842430263758, -0.01776355691254139, 0.04816281422972679, 0.01465977169573307, 0.005147384945303202, -0.027121882885694504, -0.0012115506688132882, -0.019708121195435524, 0.023416003212332726, -0.01651962660253048, 0.015621243044734001, 0.04120733216404915, 0.007690783590078354, 0.001745491405017674, 0.028416378423571587, -0.012430274859070778, -0.025976726785302162, 0.05004021152853966, -0.06577525287866592, -0.023698247969150543, 0.006299328990280628, -0.02563723549246788, 0.008558987639844418, -0.03472790867090225, -0.024321913719177246, -0.017231527715921402, -0.02661004103720188, 0.03994819149374962, 0.013882814906537533, 0.007767307106405497, 0.016169989481568336, -0.003789059352129698, 0.041787289083004, -0.012070600874722004, -0.019133122637867928, -0.03217138722538948, 0.0018994924612343311, -0.02027704380452633, -0.02058972232043743, -0.003916937392205, 0.0014997044345363975, -0.04177103564143181, 0.05371255800127983, 0.021486300975084305, 0.04064817354083061, -0.04112149402499199, -0.02009124495089054, 0.01833384856581688, 0.0003344068245496601, -0.01702660135924816, -0.009104087948799133, -0.04742252454161644, 0.08132430911064148, -0.07058645784854889, 0.019207924604415894, -0.026096222922205925, -0.0181161817163229, -0.016430050134658813, 0.020183784887194633, -0.04662387818098068, 0.01932736113667488, 0.021115101873874664, 0.007127891760319471, 0.02441079169511795, 0.022008243948221207, 0.06729065626859665, -0.06573255360126495, 0.013582520186901093, -0.03380239009857178, -0.019060131162405014, 0.008704417385160923, -0.013226081617176533, -0.03993965685367584, -0.02755851484835148, 0.041252609342336655, -0.016463760286569595, -0.00866925623267889, -0.008751108311116695, -0.06561196595430374, -0.01665492355823517, 0.01807050220668316, 0.004422842059284449, -0.03159461170434952, -0.031095309183001518, -0.011572285555303097, 0.0062486459501087666, -0.03055056743323803 ]
<p>Let's say I ask a robot a question: "Why is partial differential equations no fun at all?" </p> <p>Suppose the robot is stupid and categorizes my question inside the class of "cats" so it replies with: "Cats are fluffy and awesome."</p> <p>So I reword my question over and over and sadly the robot keeps hitting the "cats" class. Sequential hits is an example of a risk factor. It indicates that perhaps something is wrong with the "cats" class in the robot's brain. Maybe the word "PDEs" appears as sample text under the class to draw from. </p> <p>Suppose I have a collection of classes (e.g. "cats", "dogs") that all share the same risk factors(e.g. "sequential hits","bad user scores",etc). </p> <p>Each risk factor has its own weight which I can adjust from 0-10 where 0 essentially means that I can completely drop the risk factor and 10 is the most important.</p> <p>For each class, I can multiply the occurrence of each risk factor by its respective weight and sum them all to obtain a risk score for the class.</p> <p>Thus, each class has a risk score and I can focus on fixing the classes with the highest risk scores.</p> <p>My question is this: How can I optimally choose the weights of the risk factors to give me what are truly the riskiest classes?</p> <p>This is a pretty open question. I am looking for ideas, papers, books, or statistical techniques that might be helpful to this endeavor. Much thanks.</p>
36,680
[ -0.03143268823623657, -0.02175150252878666, 0.024381820112466812, -0.021924495697021484, 0.019002186134457588, 0.01968955062329769, 0.02041321061551571, -0.011774345301091671, 0.04505803436040878, -0.040567487478256226, 0.012972109019756317, 0.0548672080039978, 0.054425355046987534, 0.05287249758839607, 0.009548306465148926, 0.00417630560696125, 0.006584667135030031, -0.001937762019224465, -0.010206004604697227, 0.0008839236106723547, 0.027457214891910553, 0.02546073868870735, 0.049489740282297134, -0.0241699256002903, -0.014776915311813354, 0.0175766684114933, 0.018691545352339745, -0.052963461726903915, -0.005397124215960503, 0.021938763558864594, -0.0420975387096405, 0.024978742003440857, -0.021622266620397568, 0.0188987348228693, 0.00548822246491909, 0.019336774945259094, -0.04338277131319046, -0.013305142521858215, -0.03401421383023262, 0.029854660853743553, 0.0024026883766055107, -0.03346775844693184, 0.00023392819275613874, 0.05401301756501198, 0.004144841805100441, -0.00014632352394983172, -0.020537888631224632, 0.00766173517331481, -0.002717840252444148, -0.044031184166669846, 0.05649619922041893, 0.007120158057659864, 0.04687556251883507, 0.017857080325484276, -0.0409272126853466, -0.006492465268820524, 0.02325880341231823, 0.09070826321840286, -0.023829955607652664, -0.05408453941345215, -0.030110951513051987, 0.0026664098259061575, 0.011970947496592999, -0.00913802720606327, -0.03895016387104988, 0.03855227306485176, 0.002083063358440995, -0.04360122233629227, 0.033493123948574066, -0.04179466888308525, -0.019772665575146675, 0.0109706474468112, 0.01757405884563923, -0.005604524631053209, 0.019229251891374588, -0.030802765861153603, 0.00003167844988638535, 0.06982395797967911, 0.013741056434810162, 0.013163965195417404, -0.020098889246582985, -0.0319337323307991, -0.02740474045276642, 0.0492229163646698, -0.007756886072456837, 0.030394483357667923, 0.06823921948671341, -0.02944314107298851, 0.0452583022415638, 0.04526025429368019, -0.008003569208085537, -0.01823814958333969, 0.004010132513940334, 0.03632868453860283, -0.025280196219682693, 0.02480626106262207, 0.009496301412582397, -0.0012041247682645917, 0.02214413322508335, -0.003424425609409809, -0.008608429692685604, -0.051327869296073914, -0.034365613013505936, 0.02739851363003254, -0.04768446832895279, -0.02050120383501053, -0.046507079154253006, -0.018008751794695854, -0.002151875989511609, -0.003888458479195833, -0.019300175830721855, 0.017782418057322502, 0.01739203743636608, -0.03906136006116867, 0.017215730622410774, -0.008734803646802902, -0.010434478521347046, -0.015495619736611843, 0.0030825072899460793, 0.04592110961675644, 0.0333685427904129, -0.010152292437851429, 0.046803198754787445, -0.029007691890001297, -0.0382203571498394, 0.023414092138409615, 0.07858502864837646, -0.02652215212583542, 0.00114437413867563, 0.02899501658976078, -0.015280293300747871, -0.0006821662536822259, 0.01964019238948822, 0.023399630561470985, 0.014255007728934288, -0.0006325518479570746, -0.062287673354148865, -0.030469419434666634, 0.04538942500948906, -0.017086651176214218, -0.033350735902786255, -0.05444234237074852, -0.034676238894462585, 0.048199690878391266, 0.04193723201751709, 0.016726313158869743, 0.023871127516031265, 0.035338547080755234, 0.01994115300476551, 0.021789148449897766, 0.008714674040675163, -0.0050017149187624454, -0.05311139300465584, 0.01648251712322235, -0.035955943167209625, -0.06163935735821724, 0.025090370327234268, 0.0023806742392480373, -0.0016675273654982448, 0.002958940574899316, 0.013102366589009762, -0.025773786008358, 0.014147048816084862, -0.03232429549098015, 0.01365075446665287, 0.005992616061121225, 0.07108666747808456, 0.03753272444009781, 0.021747367456555367, -0.0003089316305704415, -0.0006790234474465251, 0.03960747271776199, 0.0019710753113031387, 0.03510304540395737, 0.04159529134631157, -0.030210506170988083, -0.01664944551885128, -0.0065007382072508335, 0.010312815196812153, 0.0024678658228367567, -0.0054459357634186745, -0.05898264795541763, -0.010619635693728924, 0.002571085002273321, -0.006982830353081226, 0.016022786498069763, 0.010867143049836159, -0.03189031034708023, 0.04332249239087105, -0.011711605824530125, -0.02929437719285488, -0.06358630955219269, 0.004931502044200897, -0.056398794054985046, -0.011551087722182274, 0.03958027809858322, -0.03292069584131241, 0.018805962055921555, -0.003168015042319894, 0.0035344858188182116, -0.03655732795596123, 0.007328969892114401, 0.03579402714967728, 0.004156352486461401, -0.0046473233960568905, 0.013268237933516502, 0.015467782504856586, -0.04189373552799225, 0.030133776366710663, -0.053928129374980927, -0.06875038146972656, -0.0071758306585252285, 0.0066656009294092655, 0.012819102965295315, 0.030280031263828278, -0.033746980130672455, 0.027241142466664314, -0.03722016140818596, -0.013801132328808308, 0.013595198281109333, -0.02899041585624218, 0.08062643557786942, 0.08435036242008209, -0.01779845356941223, 0.012272932566702366, 0.037831708788871765, 0.022072240710258484, 0.04656486213207245, -0.002355520846322179, 0.008725522086024284, -0.0585009790956974, -0.02138836309313774, 0.008854667656123638, 0.01796608231961727, -0.054791517555713654, 0.03012225590646267, 0.058306772261857986, 0.045582838356494904, -0.0009509121300652623, 0.03841782361268997, -0.016345512121915817, 0.004511198494583368, 0.027375733479857445, 0.05243482068181038, 0.005243087187409401, -0.007266425061970949, 0.0482918955385685, 0.009677327238023281, 0.019219908863306046, 0.012107151560485363, 0.0065530212596058846, 0.04037337750196457, 0.03718465566635132, 0.0018718286883085966, -0.005624640267342329, -0.034644898027181625, 0.019749393686652184, -0.027982866391539574, 0.0037002726458013058, 0.037799179553985596, 0.008728938177227974, -0.01963144540786743, -0.0022493537981063128, -0.03157317265868187, -0.017626747488975525, 0.0325641855597496, -0.01850368082523346, -0.004137801937758923, 0.028045475482940674, -0.05877816304564476, -0.0043542091734707355, 0.03572713956236839, -0.03029031679034233, -0.035609811544418335, 0.034471627324819565, 0.02302061952650547, -0.003688712604343891, -0.01470828615128994, 0.0018756644567474723, -0.013402599841356277, 0.0274538304656744, -0.006241991184651852, 0.01637914963066578, -0.02244315668940544, -0.06993359327316284, 0.016021152958273888, -0.009522372856736183, -0.0019081090576946735, 0.04084799811244011, 0.006517914589494467, -0.013660416938364506, 0.004486314952373505, -0.011500837281346321, -0.0032954977359622717, -0.015345564112067223, -0.05475075915455818, 0.034260742366313934, 0.002034795004874468, 0.018025323748588562, 0.042509887367486954, -0.0076535288244485855, -0.07236944139003754, 0.01980406790971756, -0.008431515656411648, -0.04548608511686325, -0.029453471302986145, -0.021581094712018967, -0.013115696609020233, -0.013400466181337833, -0.007437658961862326, 0.012886237353086472, -0.026470918208360672, -0.04832863062620163, -0.08938685804605484, -0.06779602915048599, -0.007057261653244495, 0.02036268450319767, 0.019483335316181183, 0.018980998545885086, -0.006852582097053528, 0.07564028352499008, 0.010213514789938927, -0.08660253137350082, -0.03516574203968048, -0.021725459024310112, -0.012301539070904255, -0.019063817337155342, 0.03164305165410042, 0.024104034528136253, -0.03227091208100319, 0.01418139785528183, 0.031531233340501785, 0.039120864123106, 0.02924034558236599, 0.007965565659105778, -0.03361399471759796, 0.027317717671394348, -0.039833102375268936, -0.022188737988471985, 0.029004482552409172, 0.03720162436366081, -0.014028050005435944, 0.03949957340955734, -0.01406986266374588, 0.0019500114722177386, 0.013550727628171444, -0.05284987390041351, 0.007440151646733284, -0.011519305408000946, 0.006081344559788704, -0.030953453853726387, 0.013996108435094357, 0.009087571874260902, -0.027085257694125175, -0.01599401980638504, 0.029936054721474648, 0.04656614735722542, -0.03616124391555786, 0.012226403690874577, 0.026452312245965004, 0.09086361527442932, -0.0005584097234532237, -0.03766462579369545, -0.0642378032207489, 0.011179870925843716, 0.019012203440070152, -0.016880663111805916, 0.01853170245885849, 0.04377858713269234, 0.04813987389206886, 0.02635069005191326, -0.021409619599580765, -0.013723901472985744, 0.004104798659682274, -0.08920735865831375, -0.010619315318763256, -0.02439715340733528, 0.08015546947717667, 0.021753819659352303, 0.014235860668122768, 0.011743715964257717, -0.008551981300115585, -0.0033614905551075935, 0.02857161872088909, -0.09141968190670013, 0.01903671957552433, 0.03984189033508301, 0.001274407492019236, 0.029030540958046913, -0.020259477198123932, 0.032875481992959976, -0.004176797810941935, -0.039336394518613815, -0.008002844639122486, -0.005682443734258413, -0.05647948756814003, 0.00205017882399261, -0.0291371438652277, -0.0046365451999008656, 0.006530160550028086, 0.03585553914308548, 0.04665406420826912, -0.023271823301911354, 0.03985185921192169, 0.030284684151411057, 0.0020423063542693853, -0.007455525919795036, -0.022456137463450432, 0.03362132981419563, -0.011803170666098595, 0.05167631059885025, -0.02385823242366314, 0.0017737422604113817, -0.036153461784124374, 0.06927188485860825, -0.0053126635029911995, 0.028337063267827034, 0.0360591895878315, 0.016488490626215935, -0.005088926292955875, -0.06347066909074783, -0.042540132999420166, -0.006533740554004908, 0.007493550889194012, -0.013246521353721619, 0.0014907836448401213, 0.04029402509331703, 0.018047666177153587, -0.09264807403087616, 0.011355767957866192, 0.04660914093255997, -0.02082797698676586, -0.04945480823516846, 0.004435892216861248, -0.014018740504980087, -0.013216845691204071, -0.03089754655957222, 0.005108156707137823, 0.0055463798344135284, -0.014499898068606853, -0.004041696432977915, 0.018854664638638496, -0.016425156965851784, -0.04013869911432266, -0.02677498571574688, -0.01864897646009922, 0.022242911159992218, -0.012047603726387024, -0.006537009030580521, 0.0030580752063542604, 0.011851731687784195, 0.06448052078485489, -0.005906790494918823, -0.00799644086509943, -0.1051463857293129, -0.00452206376940012, 0.026378637179732323, 0.06781221181154251, -0.022587422281503677, 0.0024951801169663668, -0.0008024376584216952, -0.019196130335330963, 0.08663469552993774, -0.0415341854095459, 0.007312379311770201, -0.011129672639071941, -0.03285155072808266, -0.02027190290391445, -0.006819824688136578, -0.01955331861972809, -0.004253475461155176, -0.01666809804737568, 0.06246428191661835, -0.0012440779246389866, -0.004889370407909155, -0.05867087095975876, 0.0016352838138118386, 0.022005748003721237, 0.07477501779794693, -0.022434374317526817, -0.0002056015800917521, 0.021238144487142563, 0.009166672825813293, -0.058049462735652924, -0.06413248926401138, 0.01602003537118435, -0.003857289208099246, 0.00033943995367735624, 0.05101164057850838, -0.025662703439593315, 0.003215333679690957, 0.020854096859693527, 0.015430170111358166, -0.025406166911125183, -0.02360515296459198, 0.007657698821276426, 0.021001523360610008, 0.0696125477552414, 0.04551368206739426, 0.0285573098808527, 0.02470368891954422, 0.04840385913848877, 0.009098152630031109, -0.03738485649228096, 0.022966479882597923, 0.0005292082787491381, -0.011925770901143551, -0.03473810851573944, 0.005420776549726725, -0.003350385930389166, 0.03062780573964119, -0.000580966065172106, 0.01747702807188034, -0.013029107823967934, -0.028616461902856827, -0.011934214271605015, -0.023046722635626793, 0.004245453979820013, -0.023885808885097504, 0.048328980803489685, 0.024055611342191696, 0.045432139188051224, 0.03259262442588806, 0.013370122760534286, -0.06115008518099785, 0.01890261471271515, 0.0075557054951786995, -0.02510995976626873, -0.00794350728392601, -0.06155283376574516, 0.006300267297774553, 0.021683935075998306, -0.04147813841700554, 0.04290052875876427, 0.011290685273706913, 0.013089479878544807, 0.013425854966044426, -0.033234935253858566, -0.007804990746080875, 0.0035529842134565115, 0.018086744472384453, 0.02564949542284012, -0.006877495441585779, -0.008936049416661263, -0.006366587709635496, 0.0017673587426543236, -0.04560011997818947, -0.03291798755526543, 0.04640001058578491, 0.042063694447278976, -0.019215267151594162, -0.033818814903497696, 0.01814224384725094, -0.002961342688649893, -0.021985450759530067, -0.008542300201952457, 0.06429298967123032, -0.029054952785372734, -0.017415229231119156, 0.025575309991836548, 0.00944514386355877, 0.07290740311145782, 0.02310004271566868, 0.0044041583314538, 0.02300982177257538, -0.01614064909517765, 0.02817402593791485, -0.030689863488078117, 0.01999036967754364, -0.058274202048778534, -0.03625873103737831, -0.011088493280112743, 0.0046140095219016075, 0.03344595432281494, -0.028191428631544113, 0.008429399691522121, 0.03501828759908676, -0.022805510088801384, 0.006482745986431837, -0.02975383773446083, -0.01085870061069727, -0.03333711251616478, -0.0019701835699379444, 0.01259635016322136, 0.03580080345273018, -0.020798981189727783, -0.012806533835828304, -0.006274751853197813, 0.01825743541121483, -0.0184148121625185, 0.021626584231853485, 0.03671541064977646, -0.03128226846456528, -0.02733195200562477, -0.018329834565520287, -0.022799456492066383, 0.0615217387676239, 0.011868622153997421, 0.007534603122621775, 0.031117701902985573, 0.02387000247836113, 0.002696138573810458, -0.00039986465708352625, -0.05964580178260803, -0.0026921674143522978, 0.06114323064684868, -0.02171899378299713, 0.024738524109125137, 0.04286926984786987, 0.004274821374565363, -0.02192677929997444, -0.02982989326119423, -0.0010510297724977136, -0.020202064886689186, 0.004318616818636656, 0.052018627524375916, -0.020984826609492302, -0.0012673984747380018, 0.0382237546145916, 0.02655579149723053, 0.0523170605301857, 0.035589613020420074, 0.003850414650514722, 0.047042928636074066, 0.030067315325140953, -0.059267014265060425, -0.031043117865920067, 0.012498671188950539, -0.06987212598323822, 0.008165898732841015, -0.0018984187627211213, -0.07544330507516861, 0.040863048285245895, 0.005732290912419558, -0.011891623958945274, -0.03102220594882965, -0.038194432854652405, -0.0262097530066967, 0.03326290845870972, 0.03171608969569206, 0.009773886762559414, 0.023142343387007713, 0.0034411735832691193, 0.037573158740997314, -0.004245324060320854, 0.013016123324632645, -0.034274954348802567, -0.09051800519227982, -0.050539933145046234, -0.014094846323132515, -0.07197866588830948, -0.002400179859250784, 0.026279117912054062, -0.011550883762538433, 0.015840087085962296, -0.01605013944208622, 0.030119918286800385, 0.020000360906124115, 0.046331737190485, -0.033242784440517426, 0.04024132341146469, 0.007575394120067358, 0.01566779986023903, -0.02439793199300766, -0.016979724168777466, 0.1288122981786728, 0.06262438744306564, 0.06639435887336731, -0.05788058042526245, 0.0015579152386635542, 0.004894524347037077, 0.013774589635431767, 0.000019552955563995056, 0.02619011141359806, 0.03695542365312576, -0.007234072312712669, 0.014795665629208088, 0.017668014392256737, 0.027764111757278442, 0.027927394956350327, 0.0789172351360321, -0.09054499864578247, -0.017625629901885986, 0.009326692670583725, -0.004878987092524767, 0.029965294525027275, 0.002868238603696227, -0.03846500813961029, -0.016513114795088768, 0.008874625898897648, 0.00830193143337965, -0.008708862587809563, -0.05445677042007446, 0.0103234201669693, -0.002914465731009841, 0.024949967861175537, 0.04144943878054619, 0.009013560600578785, 0.01600334793329239, 0.005177644081413746, 0.018826505169272423, 0.021400926634669304, -0.01979110948741436, 0.008806005120277405, -0.0010864910436794162, 0.025242211297154427, -0.0161904264241457, 0.0012722923420369625, 0.03350861370563507, -0.0013564132386818528, -0.04088452085852623, -0.03143414109945297, 0.05452555790543556, -0.05855143442749977, 0.02415289916098118, -0.0032963096164166927, 0.014224188402295113, 0.015774453058838844, -0.05286788195371628, -0.035901397466659546, 0.006857866421341896, 0.02908460982143879, 0.03919171914458275, 0.007340347394347191, 0.002003905363380909, 0.031101707369089127, 0.0028283388819545507, 0.029746878892183304, -0.0022628908045589924, -0.02567894384264946, -0.03981734439730644, -0.038816943764686584, -0.006616663653403521, 0.0241547841578722, 0.008346582762897015, 0.0038981945253908634, -0.005685070995241404, -0.013541954569518566, -0.01864246465265751, -0.009908107109367847, 0.025865960866212845, 0.0024228922557085752, -0.007410332094877958, -0.024849705398082733, 0.006509177852421999, -0.0017363277729600668, 0.006891409866511822, -0.017635902389883995, 0.007754899561405182, -0.055694643408060074, -0.02826411835849285, 0.012019512243568897, 0.0662761926651001, 0.026107819750905037, 0.008028692565858364, 0.008021511137485504, 0.0452449657022953, -0.0101034389808774, -0.01329056266695261, -0.016075173392891884, 0.03568947687745094, 0.006600737571716309, 0.020707428455352783, 0.03492302820086479, 0.07100198417901993, 0.005940248258411884, -0.01850976049900055, -0.01657985895872116, 0.041263800114393234, -0.022884048521518707, -0.01085119042545557, 0.03512682765722275, -0.04422305151820183, -0.04003608971834183, 0.014841088093817234, -0.0022216038778424263, -0.05421263724565506, -0.031895916908979416, -0.038061339408159256, -0.04777410253882408, -0.0013363946927711368, 0.016905363649129868, -0.032304611057043076, 0.003607726190239191, 0.013025909662246704, 0.010813085362315178, -0.031279996037483215, 0.03183303773403168, -0.06683306396007538, -0.006120495498180389, -0.01788119412958622, -0.016065243631601334, -0.042087387293577194, 0.0080101964995265, -0.04273902252316475, -0.006063465960323811, -0.01430830080062151, 0.021902862936258316, -0.002529748482629657, 0.0021354216150939465, 0.0029173477087169886, -0.015048499219119549, 0.0631999745965004, -0.03964690864086151, -0.027448566630482674, 0.044290486723184586, -0.06665423512458801, 0.00020037914509885013, 0.006801391951739788, -0.015467854216694832, 0.03855197876691818, 0.04998450726270676, -0.001498670782893896, 0.02842448465526104, 0.0340934693813324, -0.016119452193379402, -0.03285956010222435, 0.020651981234550476, -0.025016142055392265, -0.004981661215424538, 0.0010380127932876348, 0.008702590130269527, -0.008324932307004929, -0.008756814524531364, -0.05447971075773239, 0.034846097230911255, -0.001899993745610118, -0.017478084191679955, 0.05244885012507439, -0.024427492171525955, 0.023800287395715714, -0.043643753975629807, 0.012871888466179371, 0.022864418104290962, 0.007741754408925772, -0.02876032330095768, 0.03180558979511261, -0.009343713521957397, 0.0019378337310627103, -0.08426018059253693, 0.021523170173168182, 0.022005952894687653, -0.005781727377325296, 0.03328036516904831, -0.029329756274819374, 0.01804426684975624, 0.002662046579644084, -0.03304991126060486, 0.035853661596775055, -0.011579140089452267, 0.027672313153743744, -0.02805189974606037, 0.04573548585176468, -0.05159946158528328, 0.04073726758360863, 0.02286655083298683, 0.010706579312682152, 0.043005529791116714, -0.023205475881695747, 0.013815862126648426, 0.007738378830254078, -0.007038694340735674, 0.028571179136633873, -0.0093877287581563, 0.016095362603664398, 0.04909370094537735, -0.03474157676100731, -0.0443059541285038, 0.016578342765569687, 0.021098274737596512, 0.005650592502206564, 0.03743166849017143, 0.025962095707654953, -0.005603374447673559, 0.009898487478494644, 0.02486911416053772, -0.03664568439126015, -0.0037656305357813835, -0.006386417895555496, 0.010590402409434319, 0.004776693414896727, 0.03266219422221184, 0.03477064520120621, 0.05281566455960274, -0.006549552083015442, -0.02289734035730362, 0.05276377499103546, -0.011284240521490574, -0.030079258605837822, 0.03067551553249359, -0.016528673470020294, 0.018044862896203995, -0.037500109523534775, -0.0017565378220751882, -0.03317040205001831, 0.016990523785352707, -0.01774982549250126, -0.031945835798978806, 0.008021075278520584, 0.03975977003574371, -0.04266510531306267, -0.0627003163099289, -0.01131790317595005, 0.016361963003873825, -0.03885788470506668, -0.02819056622684002, 0.037089936435222626, -0.0051681785844266415, -0.02530595287680626, -0.02134629152715206, -0.026921235024929047, -0.013750576414167881, 0.015590406954288483, -0.004710938315838575, 0.028321722522377968, -0.0012433012016117573, -0.009965350851416588, 0.011406359262764454, -0.08925878256559372, 0.030623944476246834, 0.002591798547655344, -0.008867746219038963, -0.03125889599323273, 0.027079766616225243, -0.0007904273807071149, 0.04617031291127205, 0.014429686591029167, -0.039100971072912216, 0.017227046191692352, -0.02253483422100544, -0.007108971942216158, 0.01605524681508541, -0.02383335679769516, 0.02695457451045513, -0.015653911978006363, -0.02252359129488468, -0.02912840060889721, 0.00916304811835289, 0.012769138440489769, -0.0019194070482626557, 0.020309889689087868, 0.0047198934480547905, -0.02077462337911129, 0.004399316851049662, -0.026363559067249298, -0.006215016823261976, 0.011124687269330025, 0.015610655769705772, 0.049007516354322433, 0.010893684811890125, -0.02295600436627865, -0.024410318583250046, -0.022125832736492157, -0.0024533492978662252, 0.0511917769908905, -0.0031667223665863276, -0.07115461677312851, 0.017303012311458588, -0.006407306529581547, 0.023074209690093994, -0.05954785645008087, 0.008753198198974133, 0.03365107253193855, -0.01640181802213192, 0.006841611582785845, 0.021575862541794777, 0.03797991946339607, 0.030579010024666786, 0.01808641292154789, 0.03774469718337059, 0.014602970331907272, -0.023302169516682625, -0.022860534489154816, 0.008391204290091991, 0.029065532609820366, -0.007222427055239677, 0.025583777576684952, 0.024850500747561455, -0.015125111676752567, 0.02703102119266987, 0.001766172586940229, 0.05417558178305626, -0.03425225988030434, -0.004369279369711876, 0.009274426847696304, -0.0010523240780457854, -0.004274892155081034, -0.01718345284461975, -0.011286229826509953, 0.04401598498225212, 0.005551697686314583, -0.017488909885287285, -0.07737681269645691, -0.001871285610832274, -0.05078502371907234, -0.0537906214594841, 0.03409443795681, 0.06571021676063538, -0.0028476244769990444, -0.048645101487636566, -0.012647937051951885, 0.01519749779254198, 0.02278236486017704, -0.006604114081710577, 0.017801927402615547, -0.005598202347755432, -0.01977231353521347, 0.001852926448918879, -0.004152563866227865, -0.015342834405601025, -0.014336567372083664, 0.041005104780197144, 0.04113633930683136, 0.031565163284540176, -0.01741245947778225, -0.03609869256615639, -0.030206728726625443, 0.02803235501050949, -0.04020671918988228, 0.017030270770192146, -0.0633842870593071, 0.015309608541429043, 0.017828507348895073, -0.008116054348647594 ]
<p>I was reading this <code>[paper][1]</code> related to sparse online gaussian processes. However, I didn't get how the denominator in the equation 1 was derived?<img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/vr3dG.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>It was supposed to be P(D). I didn't get how the denominator was obtained. Further, the paper is saying that the posterior may not be gaussian. I don't know why it is so?</p>
36,681
[ -0.01819876953959465, -0.011766264215111732, 0.03220060467720032, -0.045143790543079376, 0.046620503067970276, 0.0027452220674604177, -0.03602689504623413, -0.028892723843455315, 0.026194686070084572, -0.03105003759264946, 0.03301525488495827, 0.042565248906612396, 0.07054311037063599, 0.040409769862890244, -0.017200922593474388, 0.018963240087032318, -0.0004771276726387441, 0.0069248266518116, 0.01078493706882, -0.029547201469540596, -0.0048123132437467575, 0.05434887483716011, 0.0022563159000128508, -0.03516637906432152, -0.0025160324294120073, 0.0033532960806041956, 0.009944536723196507, 0.010423961095511913, -0.013724793680012226, 0.06950846314430237, -0.018759911879897118, -0.02840888686478138, -0.017617369070649147, 0.054453764110803604, 0.009333414025604725, -0.010351701639592648, -0.027675243094563484, -0.046388108283281326, -0.016032660380005836, 0.052616480737924576, 0.028618868440389633, -0.056922778487205505, -0.010520072653889656, 0.06414397060871124, -0.0368465892970562, 0.018426958471536636, 0.03865716978907585, -0.04005270451307297, 0.0624917671084404, -0.053839780390262604, 0.044708263128995895, 0.021580662578344345, 0.06261464208364487, 0.012498187832534313, 0.0021124989725649357, 0.01960006356239319, 0.06674810498952866, 0.09923255443572998, 0.005834989249706268, -0.051742877811193466, -0.03293143957853317, -0.040337659418582916, 0.026060299947857857, -0.006547555327415466, -0.011265146546065807, 0.005820129066705704, -0.00042169709922745824, -0.04468291252851486, 0.011803223751485348, -0.025755126029253006, 0.01737736165523529, 0.00287825264967978, 0.03135179355740547, -0.04335653409361839, 0.03662644326686859, -0.008420297876000404, 0.009179167449474335, 0.030905824154615402, 0.02867259830236435, 0.018660014495253563, 0.0013558035716414452, -0.027729889377951622, 0.014207599684596062, 0.05027047544717789, -0.014800033532083035, 0.017286622896790504, 0.0736711397767067, -0.01069292426109314, 0.016663067042827606, -0.00039437011582776904, -0.04370972886681557, 0.04310521110892296, 0.01583203859627247, -0.03827765956521034, -0.01764846220612526, 0.022027304396033287, 0.010631500743329525, 0.045409079641103745, -0.007346402853727341, -0.0206057820469141, -0.04122401028871536, -0.058394480496644974, -0.011033612303435802, 0.04256080090999603, -0.041026435792446136, -0.014605938456952572, -0.004905720241367817, 0.02913706563413143, -0.05996648967266083, -0.02441226691007614, -0.05778441205620766, 0.03746379166841507, 0.026345478370785713, -0.007901928387582302, 0.009471863508224487, -0.021214090287685394, -0.0020254405681043863, 0.006445639301091433, 0.044558167457580566, 0.06543881446123123, 0.015587379224598408, -0.002045065863057971, 0.029296597465872765, -0.04526759684085846, -0.04065796360373497, 0.013351868838071823, 0.011883269995450974, -0.00883654784411192, -0.05973844230175018, 0.0550406314432621, -0.020400959998369217, 0.0044967541471123695, 0.08362284302711487, 0.04151516035199165, -0.028870705515146255, -0.008051427081227303, -0.08463213592767715, -0.01330563984811306, 0.061721108853816986, 0.005199627950787544, 0.04927287995815277, -0.08895882964134216, -0.00845962855964899, 0.027252625674009323, 0.03748123720288277, -0.025385335087776184, 0.038401611149311066, 0.020344359800219536, 0.018800340592861176, -0.032077282667160034, -0.039437711238861084, -0.03060532733798027, -0.03690999746322632, -0.012484102509915829, -0.015348495915532112, -0.056237585842609406, 0.0237282682210207, 0.03236420452594757, -0.014859109185636044, -0.0061766766011714935, 0.07202990353107452, 0.005551591515541077, -0.03685803711414337, 0.004603355657309294, -0.0014021660899743438, -0.008195124566555023, 0.07501842826604843, 0.022029543295502663, 0.03325827047228813, 0.02123383805155754, 0.0062379417940974236, -0.0032475756015628576, -0.006005102768540382, 0.03576016053557396, 0.0501009076833725, -0.03882817551493645, -0.026824411004781723, -0.043739959597587585, 0.016128050163388252, 0.01687772199511528, -0.0028654085472226143, -0.04151421785354614, -0.02601206675171852, 0.024610405787825584, 0.005275051575154066, 0.02108924835920334, 0.007979695685207844, 0.008899264968931675, 0.013327572494745255, -0.018370695412158966, -0.007568086497485638, -0.07212470471858978, 0.002218236681073904, 0.04044703394174576, 0.007973656058311462, 0.010923369787633419, 0.0010791579261422157, 0.023728027939796448, 0.01924321800470352, -0.013783805072307587, 0.0010557402856647968, -0.0555126816034317, 0.034702055156230927, -0.02310759760439396, 0.001662838039919734, 0.04334926977753639, 0.050238143652677536, 0.0031711487099528313, 0.024327820166945457, -0.027097063139081, -0.02635594829916954, 0.004622923210263252, -0.001948427758179605, 0.030847471207380295, -0.0356995053589344, -0.0548645481467247, 0.027954673394560814, 0.0007012848509475589, 0.010948275215923786, 0.004400848876684904, -0.04566777125000954, 0.025061454623937607, 0.085406593978405, 0.019455615431070328, 0.0008656967547722161, 0.02821391634643078, -0.019097084179520607, 0.003624869277700782, -0.014779425226151943, -0.022365940734744072, -0.024855326861143112, -0.04436999559402466, 0.06643912941217422, 0.031705889850854874, 0.0035230901557952166, 0.013234653510153294, 0.044483378529548645, 0.0045081679709255695, 0.03742159157991409, 0.045832280069589615, -0.030791176483035088, -0.0425720252096653, 0.03262609243392944, -0.0010636247461661696, 0.0031389116775244474, 0.016384609043598175, -0.008327970281243324, 0.001027998747304082, 0.031286608427762985, 0.007433557882905006, -0.013622898608446121, 0.054525237530469894, -0.025747334584593773, 0.02241814322769642, -0.050482165068387985, 0.014125719666481018, 0.03667260706424713, -0.03640293329954147, 0.0003177279722876847, 0.004415872972458601, -0.011087857186794281, 0.009593290276825428, -0.029606224969029427, -0.04546612873673439, 0.017822157591581345, 0.04939845949411392, -0.041408341377973557, -0.0433136448264122, 0.022447286173701286, -0.048507094383239746, 0.019274910911917686, -0.021101191639900208, -0.04578632116317749, -0.027528807520866394, 0.018825285136699677, 0.02113226428627968, -0.011354450136423111, -0.023389218375086784, -0.02948351949453354, -0.036075323820114136, 0.0027432527858763933, 0.00028756962274201214, 0.02857598289847374, 0.01430272776633501, -0.04333284869790077, 0.0073982831090688705, -0.023604311048984528, -0.01307307556271553, 0.029507650062441826, 0.011374271474778652, 0.0077674961648881435, -0.003196447156369686, -0.017635367810726166, -0.08330375701189041, -0.02384965308010578, -0.017500167712569237, 0.006035594269633293, -0.00704148318618536, -0.009471672587096691, 0.0004316421691328287, 0.00781355518847704, 0.02156677097082138, 0.025047071278095245, -0.01797114685177803, -0.04057642072439194, -0.03287920728325844, -0.024853279814124107, 0.025571176782250404, 0.001771658775396645, 0.04652100056409836, 0.032185882329940796, -0.023704078048467636, -0.0006394254160113633, -0.08846201747655869, -0.07006088644266129, 0.03357765078544617, 0.00010408634261693805, 0.01563739962875843, 0.0127952191978693, -0.03326958045363426, 0.07195723801851273, 0.020016005262732506, -0.014246519654989243, 0.004060317296534777, -0.0076837921515107155, -0.018120823428034782, -0.009142257273197174, -0.010877327062189579, -0.027498923242092133, -0.014775030314922333, 0.02176727168262005, -0.014223353005945683, -0.005258932244032621, 0.09454674273729324, -0.008476518094539642, -0.011445481330156326, 0.03275865688920021, -0.011522987857460976, 0.0047687022015452385, 0.033362239599227905, 0.049903832376003265, 0.001800722093321383, 0.02961730770766735, -0.023486539721488953, 0.027745628729462624, 0.011551064439117908, -0.016532745212316513, 0.006533952429890633, -0.002519277622923255, -0.0030860265251249075, -0.06068526208400726, 0.04132344573736191, 0.017332812771201134, -0.056016284972429276, 0.002597114536911249, 0.0035295726265758276, 0.05608623847365379, -0.03635462746024132, 0.015231898985803127, 0.04258812591433525, 0.002592244651168585, -0.007538909558206797, -0.04455515369772911, 0.006434081122279167, -0.024720512330532074, -0.005821897182613611, 0.004188647959381342, -0.029574759304523468, 0.005574878770858049, -0.0004429911496117711, 0.005025022197514772, -0.017027897760272026, -0.029223909601569176, -0.01889943890273571, -0.07250569760799408, 0.007728003431111574, 0.007883704267442226, 0.008675121702253819, -0.007305608596652746, 0.0366675965487957, 0.023568352684378624, 0.001880173571407795, 0.01454620249569416, 0.016444534063339233, -0.05830581858754158, -0.014877538196742535, 0.0014785764506086707, -0.025442879647016525, 0.012421870604157448, -0.0032952148467302322, 0.056570012122392654, -0.0169207826256752, -0.024093719199299812, -0.0009574908763170242, 0.05592438206076622, -0.052623625844717026, -0.004874358884990215, -0.04249222204089165, -0.012943929061293602, -0.004883093759417534, -0.006981776561588049, 0.022099005058407784, -0.042185936123132706, 0.039875905960798264, 0.08536434173583984, -0.013160992413759232, -0.016594208776950836, -0.03596481308341026, 0.02225833758711815, 0.03009081818163395, 0.015214323997497559, 0.027633782476186752, 0.026942053809762, -0.01907520182430744, 0.05954911559820175, 0.025704676285386086, 0.07194888591766357, 0.043665479868650436, -0.036353569477796555, -0.040964458137750626, -0.05098612979054451, -0.01313384436070919, 0.019595790654420853, 0.0019656289368867874, -0.023219062015414238, 0.013591274619102478, 0.02504896931350231, 0.013719248585402966, 0.0012133909622207284, 0.01587500236928463, 0.04489554092288017, -0.00420741830021143, 0.011709610000252724, -0.04481086507439613, 0.01067783311009407, -0.0028262988198548555, 0.017410749569535255, 0.025930313393473625, 0.009103376418352127, 0.0077070267871022224, -0.020103024318814278, 0.022661974653601646, -0.02430572919547558, 0.003725112183019519, -0.003988106735050678, 0.025346511974930763, -0.004367117304354906, 0.01011024508625269, -0.043569691479206085, 0.005759056657552719, 0.08096663653850555, 0.05270667374134064, 0.021129827946424484, -0.0027728809509426355, -0.06979239732027054, -0.01156637817621231, 0.01641644723713398, 0.03548791632056236, -0.0043608397245407104, -0.00019403813348617405, -0.04818631336092949, 0.0024580475874245167, 0.025343485176563263, 0.000710712221916765, 0.018882403150200844, -0.010029181838035583, -0.004822313319891691, 0.0387597382068634, -0.03863270953297615, -0.04773389548063278, -0.0030724641401320696, -0.031028227880597115, 0.01957467384636402, 0.0012197024188935757, -0.03837546333670616, -0.05045468732714653, 0.020247746258974075, -0.010176639072597027, 0.04811503365635872, -0.03892039880156517, -0.014315479435026646, -0.029923690482974052, 0.004019284155219793, -0.03644198179244995, -0.03670987859368324, 0.0315326452255249, -0.027286063879728317, -0.01071155071258545, 0.08190715312957764, -0.05370505154132843, -0.02106427401304245, 0.03786083683371544, 0.032099734991788864, -0.04179950803518295, 0.004545425996184349, -0.022716693580150604, 0.04511108994483948, 0.060229863971471786, 0.001086879288777709, 0.055322322994470596, -0.000883289088960737, 0.007550638169050217, -0.033953163772821426, -0.031131548807024956, 0.027354996651411057, -0.01887432113289833, 0.041061680763959885, -0.04900934547185898, 0.011097188107669353, -0.014844471588730812, 0.018843142315745354, 0.016544217243790627, 0.01893703080713749, -0.015170467086136341, -0.053079213947057724, 0.008038938045501709, 0.027210811153054237, 0.005972354672849178, 0.024262867867946625, -0.0015019243583083153, 0.029291048645973206, 0.017179541289806366, 0.0006242733215913177, 0.01111509744077921, -0.034693434834480286, 0.03229677304625511, 0.009562516584992409, 0.0012055874103680253, -0.0030422413256019354, -0.017718065530061722, -0.023430416360497475, 0.033989306539297104, -0.018289828673005104, 0.021136194467544556, 0.002659530146047473, 0.03783111646771431, 0.001489284448325634, -0.024258024990558624, -0.014309351332485676, -0.023102199658751488, -0.023719174787402153, 0.021549848839640617, -0.0442763976752758, -0.005936668254435062, -0.02368435449898243, -0.011925853788852692, -0.06902953237295151, -0.02839113026857376, 0.03951996937394142, -0.004553478676825762, -0.044255681335926056, -0.05288396030664444, 0.011044478043913841, -0.033089276403188705, -0.03848138451576233, -0.006725537125021219, 0.028261693194508553, -0.003737512743100524, -0.002371132606640458, 0.012211048975586891, 0.04159820079803467, 0.024720821529626846, 0.005322571378201246, 0.02433563955128193, 0.019427087157964706, -0.0005523989093489945, -0.015768904238939285, -0.004600640386343002, 0.04906247928738594, -0.049619611352682114, -0.001046086777932942, -0.020867103710770607, -0.015230351127684116, 0.026458047330379486, -0.021218905225396156, 0.0027574808336794376, -0.010117577388882637, -0.0030604545027017593, 0.011146146804094315, -0.02214157208800316, -0.001923605683259666, -0.016998378559947014, -0.009611973538994789, 0.0059725698083639145, -0.013316482305526733, 0.019555101171135902, 0.04128497093915939, 0.030500121414661407, -0.018621059134602547, -0.0013737472472712398, 0.021031899377703667, 0.07404384762048721, -0.013968124985694885, 0.018687162548303604, 0.018037687987089157, -0.0007046315004117787, 0.026454100385308266, 0.012634173035621643, 0.02640097215771675, 0.03205951675772667, -0.011667503044009209, -0.03349080681800842, 0.006834831554442644, -0.06162521615624428, 0.03773147240281105, 0.08186863362789154, -0.02026827074587345, 0.06749866902828217, -0.016142647713422775, -0.01660906709730625, -0.0003675027983263135, -0.03474269062280655, -0.017491314560174942, -0.03466867282986641, -0.032236628234386444, 0.041801221668720245, -0.03620294854044914, -0.039391010999679565, 0.04363314062356949, -0.027449581772089005, 0.016039617359638214, 0.011958246119320393, 0.03918934240937233, 0.00944891944527626, 0.03113502264022827, -0.01297368947416544, -0.030736947432160378, 0.036565084010362625, -0.021988404914736748, 0.006835218518972397, -0.022131288424134254, -0.05028052255511284, 0.06478067487478256, 0.00013853158452548087, -0.0027406299486756325, -0.03108552284538746, -0.0033922051079571247, -0.021798115223646164, 0.02447059564292431, 0.037530507892370224, 0.006305703427642584, 0.011687686666846275, -0.009891746565699577, 0.01269569806754589, 0.01953068934381008, 0.03445238620042801, -0.005094368010759354, -0.03166037052869797, -0.04168037325143814, -0.04150717332959175, -0.014380999840795994, 0.006662983912974596, -0.004897112492471933, -0.03298752382397652, 0.01276302244514227, -0.017676809802651405, 0.0427376925945282, 0.039298295974731445, -0.0007961668306961656, 0.005269963294267654, 0.08734043687582016, 0.026870999485254288, 0.025628607720136642, -0.028875181451439857, -0.02051391825079918, 0.10169710963964462, 0.0999155268073082, 0.06380663067102432, -0.05849023163318634, 0.015705330297350883, -0.03641434758901596, -0.0019995153415948153, -0.02887449413537979, 0.013144581578671932, 0.032146602869033813, -0.012052228674292564, 0.01209696289151907, -0.02008865214884281, 0.024693874642252922, 0.014864656142890453, 0.019752271473407745, -0.03834686428308487, -0.06260380148887634, 0.006424421444535255, -0.021787265315651894, -0.00871540792286396, -0.020942190662026405, -0.03977047652006149, 0.027404727414250374, -0.01104061957448721, -0.026967991143465042, -0.015163611620664597, -0.012547720223665237, -0.022012021392583847, 0.004596294369548559, -0.003973851911723614, -0.004642429295927286, 0.02213803492486477, 0.012280360795557499, 0.004345312714576721, 0.009576519951224327, 0.03022337332367897, -0.01423304807394743, -0.01067600678652525, 0.024536078795790672, 0.017092736437916756, 0.030339602380990982, 0.00498784426599741, -0.00013523263623937964, -0.017260437831282616, -0.018991995602846146, -0.01432100497186184, 0.05707563832402229, -0.0012633742298930883, 0.019001569598913193, 0.02533084712922573, 0.0005918120732530951, 0.025212010368704796, -0.07393968105316162, -0.0036024923902004957, 0.05195740982890129, 0.03477933257818222, -0.016173632815480232, -0.012961278669536114, -0.01879567839205265, 0.016589563339948654, 0.009852506220340729, 0.004868488758802414, 0.021250052377581596, -0.00970067735761404, -0.024571936577558517, -0.04236164316534996, 0.04586157575249672, -0.0007485512178391218, -0.008079145103693008, -0.019093606621026993, 0.001814821152947843, -0.0016602817922830582, -0.001168304355815053, -0.02081197313964367, -0.03680168837308884, 0.02098337560892105, -0.005771998781710863, 0.008523602969944477, -0.00746994698420167, -0.059840358793735504, 0.05120234936475754, -0.04584147781133652, 0.0074312430806458, -0.00815196055918932, -0.020907877013087273, 0.013463283888995647, 0.04848245531320572, 0.0046275099739432335, 0.02227449044585228, -0.020464779809117317, 0.04884250462055206, -0.005971075501292944, -0.02144666202366352, -0.04781058058142662, -0.005430824588984251, -0.04210555925965309, -0.003914003260433674, 0.022094663232564926, 0.047634147107601166, 0.01748286560177803, 0.023290785029530525, 0.015389909967780113, 0.01309820357710123, -0.06136568263173103, 0.0009136380976997316, -0.024074533954262733, -0.05439396947622299, 0.032286033034324646, 0.019104229286313057, 0.00043148957774974406, -0.025214783847332, -0.00954588782042265, 0.00534977437928319, 0.019866259768605232, 0.0023270563688129187, 0.0027615525759756565, -0.0322771891951561, -0.054775889962911606, 0.004218137823045254, 0.04443774372339249, 0.0016968687996268272, -0.0005793878808617592, -0.01298734825104475, -0.005899726413190365, -0.030020713806152344, 0.0038311248645186424, 0.0008156883413903415, 0.03421740233898163, 0.0065254210494458675, -0.008315928280353546, -0.007704262621700764, -0.018236517906188965, 0.03643437847495079, 0.006283726077526808, 0.04148495942354202, -0.021930759772658348, 0.051095739006996155, -0.03334556147456169, -0.0667729452252388, 0.0027800218667834997, -0.04412498697638512, -0.06580179184675217, 0.020273959264159203, 0.02375057153403759, 0.01919180154800415, -0.00019434007117524743, 0.0016588415019214153, -0.05200368911027908, 0.03006513975560665, -0.017277227714657784, -0.008440048433840275, 0.01147556584328413, -0.023786470293998718, 0.02966686524450779, -0.040070969611406326, -0.022624516859650612, 0.03332100436091423, -0.001600754796527326, -0.01268676295876503, 0.01583719626069069, 0.005052440334111452, 0.007466161623597145, 0.005598010495305061, -0.015080675482749939, 0.02500552497804165, 0.02064071223139763, 0.023427970707416534, 0.012944000773131847, 0.057154640555381775, 0.01565317064523697, 0.016540223732590675, -0.025844631716609, 0.020082145929336548, -0.08277085423469543, -0.0068313139490783215, 0.003260681638494134, 0.01054621022194624, 0.031113747507333755, -0.03752925246953964, -0.01692487858235836, 0.08011205494403839, -0.046484652906656265, 0.030039146542549133, 0.026009509339928627, -0.034261055290699005, -0.05283841863274574, 0.031160350888967514, -0.022883877158164978, 0.04387497901916504, 0.02301071770489216, 0.0047960346564650536, 0.06806503981351852, 0.002086783992126584, 0.0029515796341001987, -0.04115968942642212, -0.02182772569358349, 0.05721411481499672, 0.0015397289535030723, -0.0256084892898798, 0.041604962199926376, -0.023090114817023277, -0.015428800135850906, 0.04583463817834854, 0.007178022526204586, -0.015080858953297138, -0.004691478796303272, 0.0580364391207695, 0.01543194055557251, -0.009828229434788227, 0.034803085029125214, 0.021080728620290756, 0.026620909571647644, -0.011600574478507042, 0.01194167323410511, 0.02871600352227688, 0.019126176834106445, 0.027497021481394768, 0.026637548580765724, -0.015360361896455288, -0.02839011885225773, 0.01773390918970108, -0.0408477708697319, -0.019564639776945114, 0.011410522274672985, 0.0015316446078941226, 0.0012978838058188558, -0.04162762314081192, 0.027969343587756157, -0.04989945515990257, 0.009032050147652626, 0.06038729473948479, -0.014536209404468536, -0.06439018994569778, 0.017866287380456924, -0.022760866209864616, -0.04514438658952713, 0.002173771383240819, -0.033314842730760574, -0.02394547127187252, -0.030147133395075798, 0.016719473525881767, 0.00490536168217659, -0.028152722865343094, 0.007866921834647655, -0.013217032887041569, -0.04435042664408684, 0.02098711207509041, -0.0037984633818268776, 0.013579955324530602, -0.006252980325371027, -0.01191861741244793, -0.020367130637168884, -0.11159791052341461, 0.07302428036928177, 0.009574215859174728, -0.08451259136199951, -0.01245314534753561, -0.01037791557610035, -0.017625881358981133, -0.02601933665573597, 0.019837532192468643, 0.023613037541508675, -0.005261360667645931, 0.031110908836126328, 0.027317291125655174, -0.011799916625022888, -0.02694639191031456, 0.01629955880343914, 0.018008122220635414, 0.0008504217257723212, -0.006210848223417997, -0.016067607328295708, -0.01226947084069252, 0.04586202651262283, 0.01884489133954048, 0.039877962321043015, -0.008341904729604721, 0.010371445678174496, -0.010773517191410065, 0.04136643558740616, 0.002947199856862426, 0.017536018043756485, 0.07779539376497269, -0.03246353939175606, 0.029819898307323456, -0.007483370136469603, 0.010818049311637878, -0.07503016293048859, -0.007957322522997856, -0.004347797483205795, -0.048792947083711624, 0.006601919885724783, -0.004060762468725443, 0.052529823035001755, -0.06971372663974762, -0.02850179560482502, 0.028838366270065308, -0.031723376363515854, -0.009597384370863438, 0.028492748737335205, 0.012907952070236206, 0.051682595163583755, 0.0036292225122451782, 0.016910653561353683, 0.042474955320358276, 0.006769274827092886, -0.017364656552672386, 0.04828444868326187, 0.006535684689879417, -0.033349644392728806, 0.03824710100889206, 0.01875481754541397, -0.028511185199022293, 0.03301283344626427, -0.02818184159696102, -0.009485931135714054, -0.03384748473763466, -0.016347771510481834, -0.019476352259516716, -0.04483776167035103, -0.015937821939587593, -0.023192312568426132, -0.010297776199877262, 0.04753536358475685, -0.013810558244585991, -0.005269021727144718, 0.007948335260152817, 0.010169905610382557, -0.028773469850420952, 0.014454076997935772, 0.028039800003170967, 0.015866480767726898, -0.013714700937271118, 0.001952105201780796, 0.03268103674054146, 0.0019491792190819979, 0.008388243615627289, -0.033435381948947906, 0.020246807485818863, 0.032891951501369476, -0.009344582445919514, 0.006031081546097994, -0.0347200445830822, -0.03022981621325016, -0.0219435952603817, -0.0029571019113063812, 0.012491750530898571, 0.01182661484926939, -0.028677627444267273, -0.013312711380422115, -0.028559129685163498, 0.07234759628772736, -0.014486088417470455, 0.02166804112493992, -0.03804503753781319, 0.009367444552481174, 0.0027526970952749252, -0.040953222662210464 ]
<p>Suppose I have a dataset with the following information:</p> <ul> <li>N objects, each of which can be rated</li> <li>The number of ratings per object is variable (raters are unidentified), e.g., there are 30 objects each with a unique id</li> <li>Each row has the predicted rating, the actual rating, and the difference between the two, which is an ordinal value, say between 0 and 10</li> </ul> <p>How do I measure the consistency of ratings per object and for the whole dataset? Basically, there is a distribution of "differences" per object. What are the various ways to approach this problem? Thank you. </p>
6,464
[ -0.0806952640414238, 0.009538153186440468, 0.0023538144305348396, -0.0053984858095645905, 0.039421677589416504, -0.005489799659699202, -0.004331458359956741, 0.003857778152450919, 0.03786134719848633, 0.027422558516263962, 0.05528637766838074, 0.01536878477782011, 0.04455907642841339, 0.039671316742897034, 0.004069611895829439, -0.019166605547070503, -0.0018756384961307049, -0.010057817213237286, -0.0028935731388628483, -0.015856005251407623, -0.018907753750681877, 0.01984875090420246, 0.016499850898981094, -0.03543604910373688, -0.038208577781915665, 0.041435785591602325, 0.013158950954675674, -0.0311528779566288, 0.04981360584497452, 0.024444160982966423, -0.039863258600234985, -0.037071336060762405, 0.005390406586229801, 0.04421328380703926, 0.009351661428809166, 0.014858865179121494, -0.007424631621688604, -0.03476162999868393, -0.05394600331783295, 0.022030184045433998, -0.020131360739469528, -0.025134321302175522, -0.03209083899855614, 0.0421251580119133, -0.019866302609443665, -0.0319029726088047, -0.006835623644292355, -0.006180011201649904, 0.012713040225207806, -0.03312655910849571, 0.11443372070789337, -0.018068160861730576, 0.06067994236946106, 0.04315396025776863, -0.057532329112291336, -0.0005825099651701748, 0.0562564879655838, 0.08372338861227036, -0.00998908281326294, -0.02879316546022892, -0.05261899158358574, -0.04879703000187874, 0.018780458718538284, -0.006826813332736492, -0.010806943289935589, 0.03525529056787491, -0.010397142730653286, -0.03857981786131859, 0.017321018502116203, -0.002366313710808754, 0.012869576923549175, 0.04417094960808754, 0.05757124722003937, -0.007969819009304047, 0.006195482332259417, -0.019365284591913223, 0.022741245105862617, -0.0017331881681457162, 0.06671379506587982, 0.013983447104692459, -0.0013317038537934422, 0.011990630999207497, 0.019609205424785614, 0.054582539945840836, 0.04200196638703346, -0.022598978132009506, 0.04716392233967781, 0.0037712911143898964, 0.0039777737110853195, 0.02518971636891365, -0.006024317350238562, -0.014082205481827259, 0.019427040591835976, 0.01051341276615858, -0.05716308578848839, 0.028626658022403717, -0.03771795704960823, 0.01782313734292984, -0.003802355146035552, 0.014944876544177532, 0.012506794184446335, -0.027505429461598396, 0.00789154414087534, 0.036854337900877, -0.04946606978774071, -0.049374669790267944, -0.033587682992219925, -0.01892179436981678, -0.0377681739628315, 0.017022429034113884, 0.01916658692061901, 0.024111101403832436, 0.014714952558279037, 0.030349398031830788, 0.03947870433330536, 0.006485606078058481, 0.007568706758320332, -0.018451062962412834, 0.038458097726106644, 0.03726658970117569, 0.018112726509571075, -0.024993199855089188, 0.023193666711449623, -0.017529331147670746, -0.03317395970225334, 0.025166094303131104, 0.05183035880327225, -0.00928481575101614, -0.034162912517786026, 0.06689810752868652, -0.06141689419746399, -0.02079113759100437, 0.04262499883770943, 0.01497007254511118, -0.0006990443216636777, -0.004009049851447344, -0.1142038032412529, -0.04046710953116417, -0.001257263240404427, -0.021315427497029305, -0.00973749253898859, -0.042993221431970596, -0.017105212435126305, 0.0313662551343441, 0.0404924675822258, 0.012396641075611115, 0.01391501072794199, 0.02035050094127655, 0.006214498076587915, -0.0009274027543142438, 0.00525544723495841, -0.026274504140019417, -0.003467216854915023, -0.041108034551143646, -0.036481305956840515, -0.05597437173128128, 0.004417578224092722, 0.02053488977253437, 0.003219692735001445, 0.008533717133104801, -0.0049946848303079605, -0.011710882186889648, -0.009821102023124695, -0.006500392686575651, 0.025312557816505432, -0.01340177096426487, 0.060222312808036804, -0.013911916874349117, 0.032574933022260666, 0.013694477267563343, -0.022852139547467232, 0.0039686402305960655, 0.017658498138189316, 0.057810164988040924, 0.07750224322080612, 0.007641852367669344, -0.020794516429305077, -0.034110549837350845, 0.010834985412657261, -0.022998755797743797, -0.02227867767214775, -0.04207263141870499, -0.024086901918053627, -0.03529268130660057, 0.026021281257271767, 0.015033887699246407, -0.014736293815076351, 0.03154834359884262, 0.022243479266762733, -0.046835001558065414, -0.032488513737916946, -0.06934058666229248, 0.029407911002635956, -0.03985922783613205, -0.04650590568780899, 0.020664909854531288, 0.0001276822731597349, -0.0009183968650177121, 0.010704596526920795, -0.00111892051063478, -0.05479782074689865, -0.019516093656420708, 0.014543024823069572, -0.03516737371683121, -0.0010790855158120394, 0.0383070670068264, 0.06418519467115402, -0.03349386155605316, 0.03751257807016373, -0.05007346719503403, -0.07302838563919067, -0.004304803907871246, -0.034555401653051376, -0.006356080528348684, 0.009809844195842743, -0.009045161306858063, 0.06134564429521561, 0.011604326777160168, -0.035994257777929306, 0.009611912071704865, -0.052541062235832214, 0.05461980774998665, 0.06817763298749924, 0.003744540037587285, -0.0031240996904671192, -0.009332195855677128, -0.004439221695065498, 0.006469683721661568, -0.006952374707907438, -0.02117813192307949, -0.04703017324209213, -0.01913188211619854, 0.010844126343727112, 0.0348208025097847, -0.03696228563785553, 0.0020206146873533726, 0.08825317025184631, 0.035400860011577606, 0.009525284171104431, 0.02339058183133602, -0.045083001255989075, -0.013116303831338882, 0.018615446984767914, -0.018616514280438423, 0.0471896268427372, 0.017194727435708046, -0.013502213172614574, 0.037490811198949814, 0.03748764097690582, 0.004215132910758257, 0.006444011814892292, 0.02994542568922043, 0.03383138030767441, 0.017415234819054604, -0.020869260653853416, -0.007107226178050041, 0.025650739669799805, -0.0013270631898194551, -0.006783330347388983, 0.041718725115060806, -0.0015938370488584042, 0.007325845770537853, 0.012925642542541027, -0.032712213695049286, 0.015877917408943176, 0.07678894698619843, -0.03249920904636383, 0.004365008324384689, 0.007372494786977768, -0.005849653854966164, 0.01523734163492918, -0.02216106280684471, -0.02967783249914646, -0.03821251168847084, 0.03763802349567413, 0.04477419704198837, -0.002031161217018962, 0.024662325158715248, -0.004524550400674343, -0.0009854190284386277, -0.001902581425383687, -0.020532945170998573, -0.0019751309882849455, -0.012279408052563667, -0.05291290953755379, -0.0070521533489227295, -0.021701373159885406, -0.02558032236993313, 0.010507909581065178, 0.02192033641040325, -0.025496939197182655, 0.048503559082746506, 0.013672580942511559, -0.049094751477241516, -0.013326670043170452, -0.02587580680847168, 0.035985901951789856, -0.03192383050918579, -0.043172579258680344, 0.010805042460560799, -0.010942215099930763, -0.016519667580723763, -0.009110338985919952, -0.03729141876101494, -0.013301725499331951, -0.04164917394518852, -0.011281808838248253, 0.041482143104076385, 0.011329285800457, 0.017376190051436424, 0.049096640199422836, 0.0010142571991309524, -0.029139705002307892, -0.08970105648040771, -0.06947483867406845, 0.01782546564936638, -0.013520686887204647, 0.04598814249038696, 0.008399559184908867, -0.005052441265434027, 0.07323698699474335, 0.02255486138164997, -0.04219074174761772, -0.0343085415661335, -0.005622351076453924, -0.01561663392931223, -0.014305004850029945, 0.01957649178802967, 0.0006204091478139162, -0.0023973225615918636, 0.017641151323914528, 0.02306285873055458, -0.0019164358964189887, 0.049634482711553574, -0.01185415219515562, -0.006721222307533026, 0.012393098324537277, 0.030538048595190048, -0.025926511734724045, 0.026000894606113434, 0.04044976830482483, -0.06513252854347229, -0.005654602311551571, 0.002703677164390683, -0.0017937200609594584, 0.009940726682543755, -0.04557976499199867, -0.00830134004354477, -0.010357075370848179, 0.020106742158532143, -0.021082615479826927, 0.053022027015686035, -0.011960849165916443, -0.02753578871488571, 0.004321690183132887, 0.040317315608263016, 0.07382939755916595, -0.0046980413608253, -0.001426036818884313, 0.08420827984809875, 0.03939936310052872, -0.02493174560368061, -0.010636958293616772, -0.016201892867684364, -0.01747583970427513, 0.024821482598781586, -0.04264754801988602, -0.028146473690867424, 0.019187355414032936, 0.020448552444577217, 0.03013981506228447, 0.0026988142635673285, -0.043780915439128876, 0.03915489837527275, -0.03900223225355148, 0.010116060264408588, -0.0075426120311021805, 0.06604895740747452, 0.011083829216659069, 0.0602998249232769, 0.0027211082633584738, -0.0025633189361542463, 0.011505257338285446, 0.003714669495820999, -0.04017418250441551, 0.03205593302845955, -0.020001955330371857, -0.009912009350955486, 0.004240578971803188, -0.02272495999932289, 0.0024068020284175873, -0.015413153916597366, 0.03799223154783249, -0.007986659184098244, 0.04368129000067711, -0.002171158092096448, -0.014228054322302341, -0.015344368293881416, 0.00011736196756828576, 0.0023734511341899633, 0.004639104474335909, -0.013420135714113712, -0.03305743634700775, 0.04387864097952843, 0.005456164479255676, 0.014237470924854279, -0.030893724411725998, -0.032005682587623596, 0.00006652996671618894, -0.007419925183057785, 0.06120089814066887, -0.01574905775487423, 0.020627809688448906, -0.006987677421420813, 0.05946003273129463, -0.0009988386882469058, 0.049430012702941895, 0.04012858495116234, -0.020702773705124855, -0.006771630607545376, -0.024151062592864037, -0.022813742980360985, 0.0023834072053432465, 0.02532471902668476, -0.0031336939428001642, -0.01721959561109543, 0.03816063702106476, 0.04871009290218353, -0.062216661870479584, -0.007382686249911785, 0.06495683640241623, 0.020453166216611862, -0.007302847225219011, -0.0072754318825900555, -0.011502619832754135, 0.013686152175068855, 0.009757814928889275, 0.015566373243927956, 0.016483942046761513, 0.01933438517153263, 0.02963307872414589, 0.03717772662639618, -0.012477600015699863, -0.038543157279491425, -0.03551800176501274, -0.0005657310248352587, 0.037551961839199066, -0.03150489553809166, -0.03343198075890541, 0.004595478530973196, 0.05918058380484581, 0.044068433344364166, 0.03582893684506416, -0.004340853076428175, -0.10433822870254517, 0.019213272258639336, 0.015108896419405937, 0.009837714955210686, -0.026834245771169662, -0.02301795966923237, -0.024683495983481407, -0.020469550043344498, 0.08899299800395966, -0.0333397313952446, 0.032378166913986206, 0.023498769849538803, 0.025384189561009407, -0.01813746988773346, -0.0251319520175457, -0.008024237118661404, 0.028347915038466454, -0.028544485569000244, 0.08177847415208817, 0.00591052183881402, -0.014576089568436146, -0.04143614321947098, 0.004002350382506847, 0.007940788753330708, 0.0813317820429802, -0.014150504022836685, 0.0160125270485878, -0.0033357092179358006, -0.010427001863718033, 0.010180817916989326, -0.044300712645053864, 0.012338596396148205, 0.002943481085821986, -0.03002748265862465, 0.057217683643102646, 0.008349407464265823, -0.006447494495660067, -0.005927309859544039, -0.012316795997321606, -0.04367239028215408, 0.014452958479523659, -0.03904753178358078, 0.04409866780042648, 0.01439587026834488, 0.011852146126329899, 0.044365666806697845, 0.032512638717889786, 0.014501934871077538, -0.00039422608097083867, -0.02472071535885334, 0.004753545392304659, -0.008727340027689934, -0.045292407274246216, -0.025506898760795593, -0.00250902958214283, -0.03671456128358841, 0.03281745687127113, 0.006280648522078991, 0.030483558773994446, -0.00020900584058836102, -0.0032870767172425985, -0.002924084896221757, 0.06537071615457535, -0.011405431665480137, -0.007233764976263046, 0.015736963599920273, -0.005670914892107248, 0.009657404385507107, -0.013212138786911964, 0.019749686121940613, -0.01712414063513279, 0.004988281987607479, -0.002851861994713545, -0.0424475334584713, 0.026951821520924568, -0.06582648307085037, -0.02838137373328209, 0.021312201395630836, -0.021009035408496857, 0.009297258220613003, 0.011770355515182018, 0.06074175238609314, 0.009365273639559746, -0.01807554066181183, 0.004628920927643776, 0.008989048190414906, -0.0015569677343592048, 0.042599018663167953, -0.033993400633335114, 0.02304779179394245, -0.021943841129541397, 0.005569888278841972, -0.0762191116809845, -0.023932138457894325, 0.03155001997947693, 0.01079874113202095, -0.026797715574502945, -0.047178782522678375, 0.005189224611967802, 0.006537632551044226, -0.014387541450560093, -0.007346192374825478, 0.014514324255287647, 0.02219831570982933, -0.03468100726604462, -0.045635443180799484, -0.006641981657594442, 0.07976337522268295, -0.015205727890133858, -0.019965296611189842, 0.011309248395264149, -0.024388672783970833, -0.03324393555521965, 0.024927206337451935, 0.018293816596269608, -0.04075954109430313, -0.03536812588572502, -0.04764399304986, 0.0446741059422493, 0.05128476023674011, -0.03636660799384117, 0.023573145270347595, -0.014080028980970383, -0.019284652546048164, -0.0025946616660803556, -0.005158357787877321, 0.022818315774202347, -0.030315503478050232, -0.03324303403496742, -0.020492885261774063, -0.016710586845874786, -0.018914373591542244, -0.015695489943027496, 0.001512526418082416, 0.014997408725321293, 0.002583600115031004, -0.0031032010447233915, 0.05353425815701485, -0.02669704332947731, -0.019999505952000618, -0.012350806035101414, -0.03446626663208008, 0.043383512645959854, -0.007920581847429276, -0.02191516011953354, -0.005800600163638592, 0.021286986768245697, -0.01664263755083084, -0.009407502599060535, -0.008649478666484356, -0.00966380350291729, 0.0635749101638794, 0.010411538183689117, 0.04463857784867287, 0.07492177188396454, 0.005469773896038532, -0.013825981877744198, -0.03118734434247017, -0.0064098769798874855, 0.0005828688736073673, 0.028419598937034607, 0.03179579973220825, -0.020603489130735397, 0.001589195104315877, 0.00007212116906885058, 0.0391814224421978, 0.043514132499694824, 0.04953094199299812, 0.007088088430464268, 0.003731700126081705, 0.028084740042686462, -0.04579629749059677, -0.02379874512553215, 0.05119011178612709, -0.04962678626179695, 0.017344655469059944, -0.03893440216779709, -0.0062130894511938095, 0.006978671997785568, 0.023131348192691803, 0.008271715603768826, -0.012392379343509674, -0.057901643216609955, -0.05044805258512497, 0.011523480527102947, 0.007192227058112621, 0.006271254736930132, 0.006298220716416836, 0.0036591815296560526, 0.033894337713718414, -0.00003823024235316552, 0.025123728439211845, -0.02971242554485798, -0.09957915544509888, -0.009640498086810112, -0.010625850409269333, -0.049948800355196, 0.027227550745010376, 0.03555786609649658, -0.025092557072639465, -0.013987235724925995, -0.009403184056282043, 0.01924392394721508, 0.04740636423230171, 0.03153735026717186, -0.02383858524262905, 0.05449793115258217, 0.0033273366279900074, 0.038375891745090485, 0.028283260762691498, 0.0006763971177861094, 0.11657353490591049, 0.08482032269239426, 0.03698105737566948, -0.010319040156900883, 0.01322155725210905, 0.029010670259594917, -0.026893386617302895, -0.02070361003279686, 0.027850797399878502, 0.04042355343699455, 0.003240186022594571, 0.016669269651174545, 0.023373069241642952, 0.02390618994832039, -0.010438949801027775, 0.06663479655981064, -0.028317155316472054, -0.004737483337521553, 0.024808049201965332, 0.02170577086508274, 0.022103987634181976, -0.02780226804316044, -0.028499025851488113, 0.022790925577282906, 0.04078742861747742, -0.0044231717474758625, -0.019520491361618042, -0.006422709673643112, 0.006546181160956621, -0.015046204440295696, -0.0023546896409243345, 0.008627130649983883, 0.016567938029766083, 0.012431144714355469, -0.004266729578375816, -0.002527478616684675, 0.03231378272175789, -0.014769205823540688, 0.03050312213599682, 0.04147879779338837, -0.0049057709984481335, -0.01752416603267193, -0.024586845189332962, 0.028736669570207596, -0.03970470279455185, -0.058005403727293015, -0.07550069689750671, 0.01748783141374588, -0.03563925623893738, -0.0034713810309767723, -0.00289076822809875, 0.012446152977645397, 0.00785260833799839, -0.04989754781126976, -0.014823662117123604, 0.03467794507741928, 0.007125013507902622, -0.019344139844179153, -0.05286095663905144, -0.012390988878905773, -0.0052152955904603004, -0.022992903366684914, 0.007383616175502539, 0.01623295433819294, -0.01964140683412552, -0.04942406341433525, -0.04408980533480644, 0.04789942502975464, 0.011798239313066006, 0.019286153838038445, -0.039330121129751205, -0.0523797981441021, 0.0012832492357119918, -0.013688165694475174, -0.005925951991230249, 0.0033314137253910303, 0.008529127575457096, -0.008814295753836632, 0.012469491921365261, -0.0228049848228693, -0.03334280103445053, 0.014396021142601967, -0.03834205120801926, -0.031596217304468155, -0.03610627353191376, 0.015539467334747314, 0.03660336136817932, 0.01791243813931942, 0.038089849054813385, 0.038388509303331375, 0.004425114952027798, 0.0229018684476614, -0.005839447490870953, -0.02595364861190319, -0.022194501012563705, -0.026852358132600784, -0.053401216864585876, 0.016743870452046394, -0.0028818545397371054, 0.09170522540807724, 0.009775418788194656, -0.011570041067898273, 0.008527952246367931, 0.03286503255367279, 0.0035700376611202955, 0.03413690999150276, -0.002156550996005535, -0.043411701917648315, -0.01385006494820118, -0.004291183315217495, 0.006089479196816683, -0.021048342809081078, -0.014095574617385864, -0.03312285989522934, -0.05722259357571602, 0.026651829481124878, -0.025658128783106804, -0.02347918599843979, -0.030306337401270866, -0.006563198287039995, 0.04932795464992523, -0.017751771956682205, 0.00584470946341753, -0.006724270526319742, 0.022245092317461967, -0.00045986264012753963, 0.001088345656171441, -0.03422433137893677, -0.000007962152267282363, -0.005026013124734163, 0.0015748164150863886, 0.0008734448929317296, -0.014164523221552372, 0.031402118504047394, -0.008188655599951744, 0.014558161608874798, -0.004147697705775499, 0.06988327950239182, -0.023681504651904106, -0.05170528218150139, 0.00921757984906435, -0.04985965043306351, -0.028698857873678207, 0.05301215127110481, -0.00961838848888874, 0.0334845632314682, 0.003298497060313821, -0.025312315672636032, -0.01654951274394989, 0.03884778916835785, -0.04803875833749771, -0.036554645746946335, -0.010012693703174591, -0.01050681434571743, 0.008370960131287575, 0.027897773310542107, 0.03983432799577713, -0.002075547818094492, -0.038732342422008514, 0.012326639145612717, 0.033451568335294724, 0.022009162232279778, -0.007607773412019014, 0.030410829931497574, 0.012164941988885403, -0.011915545910596848, 0.004823458846658468, 0.00678255083039403, 0.0091743478551507, 0.0643019825220108, -0.06952818483114243, 0.011184480041265488, 0.019289188086986542, 0.023760443553328514, -0.07993213087320328, -0.026928098872303963, -0.001603428740054369, 0.016896598041057587, 0.05527106299996376, -0.05436231195926666, 0.005076308734714985, 0.02569032460451126, -0.01945589669048786, 0.05453275516629219, -0.010036629624664783, 0.01216201577335596, -0.02683696150779724, 0.014983691275119781, -0.024800235405564308, 0.047910597175359726, 0.03855595737695694, 0.03735873103141785, 0.025903990492224693, 0.023920033127069473, 0.04238186404109001, -0.03175198659300804, -0.019128765910863876, 0.016205333173274994, 0.05468575283885002, -0.043845903128385544, 0.039787571877241135, -0.04745195433497429, -0.03168334811925888, 0.05151883512735367, -0.02198522537946701, 0.016955820843577385, 0.028691520914435387, 0.008038255386054516, -0.0346832312643528, 0.043921247124671936, 0.008139070123434067, 0.005031746346503496, -0.04282957687973976, 0.0022450690157711506, 0.036218322813510895, 0.00706654554232955, -0.008200571872293949, 0.008285315707325935, 0.06275750696659088, -0.017245592549443245, -0.015070130117237568, 0.021997159346938133, 0.010922905057668686, -0.02266794815659523, 0.01773860491812229, -0.004752910230308771, 0.05082399398088455, -0.016409169882535934, -0.0007875984883867204, -0.03974408656358719, -0.02658890374004841, 0.011921770870685577, 0.02214159443974495, -0.015726150944828987, 0.011760479770600796, 0.004895607475191355, -0.041871268302202225, 0.005267276428639889, 0.01007621269673109, 0.0058357506059110165, -0.07886947691440582, -0.009421068243682384, -0.032808952033519745, -0.04586801677942276, -0.004255048930644989, -0.03093557246029377, -0.016816698014736176, 0.05212211236357689, -0.030101878568530083, -0.03241517394781113, 0.022144941613078117, -0.042765967547893524, -0.033083852380514145, -0.06509672105312347, 0.038764189928770065, 0.026841716840863228, -0.02982233092188835, -0.018330300226807594, 0.011280425824224949, -0.044626545161008835, 0.0023326287046074867, 0.046907972544431686, 0.03970467299222946, -0.001746508409269154, -0.026515495032072067, 0.0018768113804981112, -0.006579581648111343, -0.06388392299413681, 0.02106158435344696, -0.010694815777242184, -0.030686236917972565, -0.016449321061372757, 0.013211783021688461, 0.01674114167690277, -0.03970189765095711, 0.025719711557030678, -0.04580627381801605, 0.005675226915627718, -0.002061016159132123, -0.018174534663558006, 0.04735082760453224, -0.0106967119500041, 0.0013663519639521837, 0.032522741705179214, -0.011357119306921959, -0.014212292619049549, 0.03086903877556324, 0.011758184060454369, -0.04965148866176605, 0.03611152991652489, -0.020790815353393555, -0.008506407029926777, 0.009062418714165688, 0.03381945565342903, -0.005257914774119854, -0.08592523634433746, -0.024042505770921707, 0.03589378297328949, -0.008898990228772163, 0.017177140340209007, 0.016285162419080734, 0.0264839306473732, 0.039970263838768005, -0.0038008829578757286, -0.003241895930841565, -0.015239023603498936, -0.004616800229996443, -0.011039001867175102, 0.022376416251063347, 0.05361087620258331, 0.011256534606218338, 0.018988067284226418, 0.026905478909611702, 0.002670248970389366, 0.04000458866357803, -0.010272393003106117, 0.03992895409464836, 0.009092351421713829, -0.0030193908605724573, 0.003041248768568039, 0.0008917966042645276, 0.002906489185988903, 0.042061787098646164, -0.016389915719628334, 0.030596312135457993, -0.026975935325026512, -0.024487752467393875, -0.06557583063840866, -0.01681864820420742, -0.03222384676337242, 0.020283814519643784, 0.03420889377593994, 0.04412400349974632, -0.0009396127425134182, 0.020674897357821465, -0.0062766666524112225, -0.008140993304550648, 0.0023460614029318094, -0.01979275792837143, 0.01410809438675642, -0.03163175284862518, -0.014429396018385887, -0.026174122467637062, -0.02235507406294346, -0.037308454513549805, -0.004793882369995117, 0.011180872097611427, 0.028970681130886078, 0.06296233087778091, -0.004216070752590895, -0.02394939586520195, -0.010105340741574764, 0.03405241295695305, -0.04132518172264099, -0.05016478896141052, -0.06935366988182068, 0.024853408336639404, -0.009016082622110844, -0.010176296345889568 ]
<p>I'm trying to validate a series of words that are provided by users. I'm trying to come up with a scoring system that will determine the likelihood that the series of words are indeed valid words.</p> <p>Assume the following input:</p> <pre><code>xxx yyy zzz </code></pre> <p>The first thing I do is check each word individually against a database of words that I have. So, let's say that <code>xxx</code> was in the database, so we are 100% sure it's a valid word. Then let's say that <code>yyy</code> doesn't exist in the database, but a possible variation of its spelling exist (say <code>yyyy</code>). We don't give <code>yyy</code> a score of 100%, but maybe something lower (let's say 90%). Then <code>zzz</code> just doesn't exist at all in the database. So, <code>zzz</code> gets a score of 0%.</p> <p>So we have something like this:</p> <pre><code>xxx = 100% yyy = 90% zzz = 0% </code></pre> <p>Assume further that the users are either going to either:</p> <ol> <li>Provide a list of all valid words (most likely)</li> <li>Provide a list of all invalid words (likely)</li> <li>Provide a list of a mix of valid and invalid words (not likely)</li> </ol> <p>As a whole, what is a good scoring system to determine a confidence score that <code>xxx yyy zzz</code> is a series of valid words? I'm not looking for anything too complex, but getting the average of the scores doesn't seem right. If some words in the list of words are valid, I think it increases the likelihood that the word not found in the database is an actual word also (it's just a limitation of the database that it doesn't contain that particular word).</p> <p>NOTE: The input will generally be a minimum of 2 words (and mostly 2 words), but can be 3, 4, 5 (and maybe even more in some rare cases).</p> <p><strong>EXAMPLE 1:</strong></p> <p>Say the following scores:</p> <pre><code>xxx = 100% yyy = 100% zzz = 0% </code></pre> <p>The average is 66.66%. But since already two words in the list exist in the database, the chances are that <code>zzz</code> is also a real word. Scoring this series of words as just 66.66% seems low.</p>
36,683
[ -0.02367210015654564, -0.03434836119413376, 0.01800231635570526, -0.018504703417420387, 0.024866284802556038, 0.013437985442578793, 0.015989992767572403, -0.0427989661693573, 0.035879094153642654, 0.031675562262535095, 0.07393475621938705, 0.06046261638402939, 0.05110207572579384, 0.03912726789712906, -0.008327801711857319, 0.0074691493064165115, 0.003111337311565876, -0.0016687503084540367, -0.004738779738545418, 0.010860812850296497, -0.02686888538300991, -0.012724232859909534, -0.005035707727074623, -0.018695129081606865, 0.0008200198062695563, -0.02071228250861168, 0.04245246574282646, -0.02851879969239235, 0.025155851617455482, 0.0514807291328907, -0.043041687458753586, -0.059878479689359665, 0.0062654884532094, 0.01975131779909134, 0.035301122814416885, 0.0638403370976448, -0.005848719272762537, -0.01190223265439272, -0.019913004711270332, -0.007523533422499895, 0.0029227572958916426, 0.018263686448335648, 0.02237080968916416, 0.017078332602977753, 0.0038453841116279364, 0.053019892424345016, -0.03141004592180252, 0.004552742466330528, 0.0004296432016417384, -0.026170089840888977, 0.026024671271443367, -0.020272599533200264, 0.03198198974132538, 0.009554043412208557, 0.04474181309342384, -0.008593461476266384, 0.0408492349088192, 0.06572574377059937, -0.005346217658370733, -0.04717428609728813, -0.042611148208379745, -0.028972866013646126, -0.004116290248930454, -0.024109531193971634, -0.016998298466205597, 0.013919557444751263, -0.00008519810216967016, 0.0008676552679389715, 0.053067646920681, -0.016052166000008583, -0.033350881189107895, 0.01649603620171547, 0.005009938962757587, -0.008173069916665554, 0.02208136022090912, -0.018622221425175667, 0.013824940659105778, 0.007692084182053804, 0.01728554628789425, 0.012569104321300983, 0.0050216782838106155, 0.0032387084793299437, -0.007234727498143911, 0.04305753856897354, 0.029706956818699837, -0.0035119822714477777, 0.03175809234380722, -0.07265578955411911, -0.007172777783125639, 0.004859342705458403, 0.023352423682808876, -0.028222009539604187, 0.023558640852570534, 0.025714198127388954, 0.003396229352802038, 0.038236066699028015, 0.007188758347183466, 0.019891072064638138, 0.025827480480074883, 0.028304005041718483, 0.013178270310163498, -0.041624173521995544, 0.02313327230513096, 0.029338307678699493, -0.032870590686798096, -0.03702578321099281, -0.022457832470536232, -0.026976414024829865, -0.005919919349253178, 0.006011574063450098, 0.03864124417304993, 0.05405755713582039, 0.010428197681903839, 0.04327448830008507, 0.029658805578947067, -0.033250462263822556, -0.0012868966441601515, -0.01439882442355156, 0.03300830349326134, 0.023093923926353455, 0.05069126561284065, -0.010683471336960793, 0.031386081129312515, -0.028897542506456375, -0.03325168415904045, -0.03654760122299194, -0.0013442945200949907, 0.018551139160990715, -0.0246255025267601, 0.05279264599084854, -0.05707225948572159, -0.026028169319033623, 0.03429986163973808, 0.00777089037001133, 0.04943101853132248, 0.024180009961128235, -0.04807629808783531, -0.008906376548111439, 0.02455104887485504, 0.03458521142601967, 0.020619619637727737, -0.037841588258743286, 0.016788402572274208, 0.024119289591908455, 0.042059894651174545, 0.003875377355143428, 0.04553858935832977, 0.018432514742016792, 0.01310723926872015, 0.03596356883645058, -0.030074385926127434, -0.03181743994355202, -0.009157511405646801, 0.013611805625259876, 0.006761654745787382, -0.050985947251319885, 0.04161332920193672, 0.0007609236054122448, -0.0061017973348498344, -0.03558442369103432, -0.01601226069033146, -0.0041487510316073895, -0.019412582740187645, -0.021311873570084572, 0.04852943494915962, -0.03193472698330879, 0.07339917123317719, 0.049502719193696976, 0.02013339102268219, 0.013022609055042267, -0.025304671376943588, 0.00673664640635252, 0.024752838537096977, -0.015052901580929756, 0.08217716217041016, -0.01307428628206253, -0.0004973455215804279, -0.04095132648944855, 0.03981592878699303, -0.0031491839326918125, -0.04351896420121193, 0.0087988106533885, -0.04479231685400009, 0.025530865415930748, 0.017853403463959694, 0.040411680936813354, 0.02540264092385769, 0.0081833740696311, 0.023288538679480553, -0.021378982812166214, -0.034814681857824326, -0.06412030011415482, -0.02206089347600937, -0.015376302413642406, -0.016332289204001427, 0.032357439398765564, -0.014562181197106838, 0.0046556731685996056, -0.01775495707988739, 0.006155977491289377, -0.05996562913060188, 0.002159443683922291, 0.04387101158499718, -0.037462268024683, 0.00814971886575222, 0.049086377024650574, 0.031082311645150185, -0.04481549188494682, 0.04549102857708931, -0.03312677517533302, -0.04214690253138542, -0.030398573726415634, -0.04960287734866142, -0.015665633603930473, -0.029732760041952133, -0.04305870831012726, 0.03453315421938896, 0.004223168827593327, 0.011097356677055359, -0.05466783046722412, -0.06589283049106598, 0.03652697429060936, 0.05949987843632698, -0.01381454337388277, 0.041761528700590134, -0.03415022790431976, 0.008372467942535877, 0.04497929662466049, 0.040103960782289505, -0.023446718230843544, -0.0726553201675415, -0.0006559473113156855, 0.04717453941702843, 0.02373676560819149, -0.04655130207538605, -0.01554955542087555, 0.05107952281832695, 0.0013564147520810366, -0.008783849887549877, 0.05354731157422066, -0.01935856230556965, 0.0425686277449131, 0.011587926186621189, 0.0332733616232872, 0.057824380695819855, 0.0273803249001503, 0.024955324828624725, 0.039829134941101074, -0.01858595386147499, 0.032644081860780716, 0.015667859464883804, -0.003619664814323187, 0.05076657235622406, 0.016834862530231476, -0.04354458302259445, -0.03384821489453316, 0.011203734204173088, -0.006733051501214504, -0.02973395213484764, 0.04664207249879837, -0.0062844897620379925, -0.0036435446236282587, 0.024917300790548325, -0.017401661723852158, -0.032596029341220856, 0.04803527146577835, -0.038984719663858414, -0.04166218638420105, 0.011916602030396461, -0.018646739423274994, -0.011791654862463474, 0.018587488681077957, -0.004480632022023201, -0.035007551312446594, 0.022324761375784874, 0.03959944099187851, -0.0022829666268080473, 0.023032987490296364, -0.029425984248518944, -0.024673478677868843, -0.01598961465060711, -0.02123880758881569, 0.015352834016084671, -0.0013948845444247127, -0.0736580565571785, -0.04077547416090965, 0.011959209106862545, -0.03444293141365051, 0.06297636032104492, 0.004460814408957958, -0.02487632818520069, 0.0330231711268425, -0.027622772380709648, -0.024354511871933937, -0.03347695246338844, -0.030516618862748146, 0.02156447246670723, -0.020871348679065704, -0.016879618167877197, 0.04847206547856331, 0.02384079433977604, -0.046684760600328445, 0.049992650747299194, -0.03350742533802986, -0.03219800814986229, -0.04639340192079544, -0.023999443277716637, -0.006453250534832478, -0.03046661987900734, 0.0064301867969334126, 0.023753009736537933, 0.008989308960735798, -0.03139425814151764, -0.058037202805280685, -0.07266410440206528, -0.01829162985086441, -0.013546181842684746, 0.050853848457336426, 0.006132451351732016, -0.010146507993340492, 0.07714848965406418, 0.013733312487602234, -0.04698391258716583, -0.03736382722854614, -0.01787625066936016, -0.03269662335515022, -0.01833527907729149, 0.003157363971695304, 0.009744569659233093, -0.04080146551132202, 0.011514149606227875, 0.03713706508278847, -0.004085408058017492, 0.03127878159284592, 0.01637733355164528, 0.01918746344745159, -0.008312242105603218, 0.030237646773457527, -0.05585796386003494, 0.03333822637796402, 0.04624815657734871, -0.043156735599040985, 0.0013317442499101162, 0.0069597563706338406, 0.016444697976112366, 0.020858457311987877, -0.04481000825762749, -0.0037938212044537067, -0.01039567869156599, -0.008957444690167904, -0.015300058759748936, 0.03931551054120064, -0.003334136214107275, -0.026024097576737404, 0.007835210300981998, 0.019274527207016945, 0.028347395360469818, 0.0015718002105131745, 0.030642319470643997, 0.037918731570243835, 0.0674886628985405, -0.014278911054134369, -0.014993557706475258, -0.04410867020487785, 0.00919849518686533, 0.005259293131530285, -0.033576373010873795, 0.006705809850245714, 0.046043455600738525, 0.04425373673439026, 0.038377564400434494, 0.0037616263143718243, -0.004658542573451996, 0.005376415327191353, -0.08172968775033951, 0.0073380921967327595, -0.039577666670084, 0.08087293803691864, 0.014714812859892845, 0.06405171006917953, 0.010792388580739498, -0.00790467020124197, -0.000051150254876120016, 0.03285088762640953, -0.09026788920164108, 0.028599511831998825, -0.035805270075798035, -0.012744537554681301, -0.03412855416536331, -0.0311567522585392, 0.030405933037400246, -0.035807203501462936, -0.010266010649502277, 0.004306761082261801, 0.023593494668602943, -0.0020801248028874397, 0.029460089281201363, 0.0006634462042711675, 0.012103145010769367, -0.011994638480246067, 0.032900888472795486, -0.029564552009105682, 0.03260926529765129, 0.03247553110122681, 0.014281979762017727, -0.0017105923034250736, -0.0022746091708540916, -0.06339000910520554, -0.0011690584942698479, 0.05695458501577377, 0.006599110551178455, 0.015060029923915863, 0.03949666768312454, -0.027149733155965805, -0.006128275766968727, 0.01283932477235794, 0.01443197950720787, 0.06215421110391617, 0.010875693522393703, -0.006894674152135849, -0.042407892644405365, -0.003836952382698655, -0.01798754185438156, 0.0016021971823647618, -0.00400511035695672, 0.011335517279803753, 0.001791455433703959, 0.009831427596509457, -0.07320187240839005, 0.024899333715438843, 0.0740770623087883, -0.005810079164803028, -0.027466094121336937, -0.011908710934221745, -0.0015321486862376332, 0.012595524080097675, 0.032704371958971024, 0.0019751887302845716, 0.050637658685445786, 0.02923637069761753, -0.022676965221762657, 0.026441488415002823, -0.031225575134158134, -0.05187707021832466, 0.023019876331090927, 0.007989252917468548, 0.03084784932434559, -0.021511513739824295, -0.01740071177482605, 0.03661414608359337, 0.04651770368218422, 0.021356629207730293, -0.008959981612861156, -0.027602626010775566, -0.07288766652345657, 0.018855184316635132, 0.06126096844673157, 0.0780448317527771, -0.03535010665655136, -0.03941986709833145, -0.055538762360811234, -0.022798625752329826, 0.049398332834243774, -0.03335820883512497, 0.01696108467876911, 0.02030975930392742, -0.006326495204120874, -0.010345795191824436, -0.015264279209077358, -0.025958891957998276, -0.004156149923801422, -0.045401524752378464, 0.017779316753149033, 0.006369943730533123, -0.032638922333717346, -0.02880118042230606, -0.018584877252578735, 0.020173247903585434, 0.043874166905879974, -0.05955364182591438, -0.0006611711578443646, -0.030974311754107475, 0.007138749584555626, -0.014265039004385471, -0.019564161077141762, 0.019644493237137794, -0.005782038904726505, -0.02737453766167164, 0.02042713575065136, 0.006760572083294392, -0.027829332277178764, 0.01669231988489628, 0.0022928251419216394, -0.048065632581710815, -0.005209257360547781, 0.025623606517910957, 0.01980362832546234, 0.057258155196905136, 0.060209400951862335, 0.03624686598777771, 0.007775403093546629, -0.015937935560941696, -0.006982451304793358, -0.06190970167517662, -0.033444590866565704, -0.035005293786525726, 0.04402574896812439, -0.046599578112363815, 0.02914590947329998, -0.03599416837096214, 0.016630923375487328, 0.006055700592696667, -0.015216187573969364, -0.035053551197052, 0.008431495167315006, 0.009216850623488426, 0.015540427528321743, 0.006433213595300913, -0.058685917407274246, -0.000624261621851474, 0.01252458430826664, -0.027084557339549065, 0.02856660634279251, 0.042870648205280304, -0.03904750943183899, 0.0025670924223959446, -0.011614981107413769, -0.03435579314827919, 0.014372831210494041, -0.038061078637838364, -0.0058917757123708725, 0.040853019803762436, 0.019361309707164764, 0.012984692119061947, 0.00473902840167284, 0.05961715430021286, -0.006570942234247923, -0.022948764264583588, 0.0017320889746770263, 0.010106445290148258, -0.008250880986452103, 0.023186095058918, 0.0062171537429094315, 0.048400767147541046, -0.00105170754250139, -0.05419041961431503, -0.02382025122642517, -0.020972976461052895, 0.05246886983513832, 0.014946915209293365, -0.028983982279896736, -0.03359423577785492, -0.04896007850766182, -0.01320191752165556, -0.004041425418108702, -0.020909791812300682, 0.04187735170125961, -0.01575469970703125, -0.014186779037117958, 0.011810747906565666, -0.017857860773801804, 0.08314815163612366, 0.03951273486018181, 0.005956355948001146, 0.03686775267124176, -0.004203686956316233, 0.029283078387379646, -0.005495382472872734, 0.003017831826582551, -0.043740060180425644, -0.03207075223326683, -0.027447419241070747, 0.03557199612259865, 0.03199225291609764, 0.00938269030302763, 0.008541817776858807, -0.002749788109213114, 0.008676876313984394, -0.03759095445275307, -0.02406053990125656, -0.021468689665198326, -0.022806789726018906, -0.01311744749546051, -0.018783772364258766, 0.020063064992427826, -0.03644619509577751, 0.011866562068462372, -0.0007492041913792491, 0.030952777713537216, -0.011875738389790058, -0.032422635704278946, 0.05404948815703392, -0.04262934625148773, -0.02388555370271206, 0.004479358904063702, -0.0315641388297081, 0.07135401666164398, 0.029454367235302925, -0.027003692463040352, 0.04288985952734947, 0.007597813382744789, -0.052730027586221695, -0.012570311315357685, -0.03484421595931053, -0.009432016871869564, 0.07069382816553116, 0.004294910933822393, 0.039544690400362015, 0.03710932284593582, -0.0068123918026685715, -0.0021853118669241667, -0.016294723376631737, -0.02611023187637329, 0.01107929740101099, -0.0006509126978926361, 0.012186061590909958, -0.014182303100824356, 0.0007842977647669613, 0.020205602049827576, -0.020885499194264412, 0.06657387316226959, 0.0417218916118145, 0.05322295054793358, -0.013827208429574966, -0.004882501903921366, -0.07294263690710068, -0.004599538166075945, 0.025150593370199203, -0.09025842696428299, -0.009565402753651142, 0.024767357856035233, -0.037166040390729904, 0.0417180210351944, 0.03613297641277313, -0.034988388419151306, -0.023072613403201103, -0.007191462907940149, -0.0385127067565918, 0.041759200394153595, 0.01934577338397503, -0.016199948266148567, 0.07291329652070999, -0.012569690123200417, 0.03861353546380997, 0.015641842037439346, 0.05459341034293175, -0.014683237299323082, -0.0729394257068634, 0.017811473459005356, -0.02353348210453987, -0.049876727163791656, 0.024606281891465187, 0.06448929756879807, 0.01163115631788969, -0.005573105067014694, -0.026863737031817436, 0.03826289251446724, 0.010603785514831543, 0.04264956712722778, -0.0314490869641304, 0.05305945500731468, 0.04053366184234619, 0.04935496672987938, -0.0014183222083374858, -0.048613715916872025, 0.1374414712190628, 0.058545224368572235, 0.05275382846593857, -0.05909579247236252, 0.02065289579331875, 0.014579910784959793, -0.025849226862192154, -0.020584292709827423, 0.001226356253027916, 0.05343765392899513, -0.00724339485168457, 0.022095751017332077, 0.00317580858245492, 0.013182333670556545, -0.002091089729219675, 0.04928464815020561, -0.06658981740474701, -0.009829067625105381, 0.01197926513850689, -0.012237805873155594, -0.01857384294271469, 0.006688446272164583, -0.061833929270505905, -0.011525584384799004, 0.05574334040284157, -0.03386583924293518, -0.01969720423221588, -0.021766474470496178, -0.015605995431542397, 0.014471130445599556, -0.003439108608290553, 0.0045503065921366215, 0.00382372853346169, 0.007470328360795975, 0.00792001187801361, -0.016197314485907555, 0.04218272864818573, -0.02178664691746235, 0.014559249393641949, 0.026081444695591927, 0.003256748430430889, 0.017358141019940376, -0.021110737696290016, 0.05926063656806946, -0.009316555224359035, -0.01836787723004818, -0.058711521327495575, 0.0453658290207386, 0.0288232434540987, 0.001021121279336512, -0.01758822798728943, 0.010279008187353611, 0.0016965667018666863, -0.014087318442761898, -0.004597458057105541, 0.025563186034560204, 0.03449311852455139, -0.020742932334542274, -0.029318468645215034, 0.01095142588019371, 0.020855702459812164, -0.017291905358433723, 0.003664396470412612, 0.03406922519207001, -0.0013078342890366912, -0.018571583554148674, -0.033110570162534714, 0.03924857825040817, 0.0004483552183955908, 0.028861092403531075, 0.011910670436918736, -0.020546723157167435, -0.020372310653328896, 0.00799698568880558, -0.02361650951206684, -0.007565245497971773, 0.027850184589624405, -0.015521900728344917, 0.006743687205016613, 0.0015852595679461956, 0.012481890618801117, 0.0074488334357738495, -0.01155157946050167, -0.01833394542336464, -0.045464836061000824, 0.000490612059365958, 0.02595329098403454, 0.01489437185227871, 0.008833885192871094, 0.010916114784777164, -0.001550803193822503, 0.044489774852991104, 0.002932764822617173, -0.024090653285384178, -0.028601767495274544, -0.005221993662416935, -0.013033022172749043, -0.004595529288053513, 0.0016989682335406542, 0.07871972024440765, 0.043378252536058426, 0.020352020859718323, 0.004985145293176174, 0.025506123900413513, -0.014466050080955029, -0.015624833293259144, -0.010107538662850857, -0.05906744301319122, -0.06449361890554428, 0.008461885154247284, 0.002490338869392872, -0.025190122425556183, 0.012482516467571259, -0.05197189003229141, -0.025372790172696114, 0.062183450907468796, -0.0013794656842947006, -0.016906533390283585, -0.008978438563644886, -0.030427120625972748, -0.04443178325891495, -0.008141092024743557, 0.01918064057826996, -0.004311930388212204, -0.018413685262203217, -0.015278327278792858, -0.027532249689102173, -0.01808428391814232, -0.014780278317630291, -0.008877260610461235, -0.002459312556311488, 0.005455325357615948, 0.022281210869550705, 0.0005437841173261404, -0.02117943949997425, -0.004439671523869038, 0.0018996052676811814, 0.029088841751217842, -0.03031935542821884, 0.033105913549661636, -0.01092459075152874, -0.053126052021980286, -0.04896356537938118, 0.016010001301765442, 0.00479553546756506, 0.027304144576191902, -0.026358874514698982, -0.008814957924187183, -0.02304978296160698, 0.022458938881754875, -0.006418643984943628, -0.05532977357506752, -0.023281635716557503, -0.00884526502341032, 0.037594396620988846, 0.009897137992084026, 0.00327215064316988, 0.010225048288702965, -0.0002917287638410926, -0.0006982848863117397, 0.030403776094317436, 0.014923091046512127, 0.007527452427893877, 0.043387677520513535, 0.01934470795094967, -0.004720751196146011, 0.005156728904694319, -0.013961250893771648, -0.06333121657371521, 0.03669033944606781, -0.035484716296195984, 0.01634107530117035, -0.00453442707657814, -0.008938588201999664, -0.05115634948015213, 0.007736770436167717, 0.03327805921435356, 0.014570754021406174, 0.0169064998626709, -0.014610351994633675, -0.010578382760286331, 0.029905151575803757, -0.04817759618163109, 0.011824673041701317, -0.0035709585063159466, 0.007729006931185722, -0.05881024897098541, 0.027394641190767288, -0.044068146497011185, 0.0028855304699391127, 0.0035884941462427378, 0.018754009157419205, 0.05754486471414566, 0.03106572851538658, -0.01628842018544674, -0.022639885544776917, -0.05194533243775368, 0.048367999494075775, -0.0005400212248787284, -0.018455155193805695, 0.0370216965675354, -0.048827167600393295, -0.04604002833366394, 0.012263842858374119, 0.003022989258170128, 0.011447496712207794, -0.010521717369556427, 0.031969547271728516, 0.019202742725610733, 0.04871198162436485, 0.036636993288993835, -0.011535365134477615, -0.02000250481069088, 0.0017107609892264009, 0.02959592267870903, 0.026123346760869026, -0.020846379920840263, 0.027694663032889366, 0.016930583864450455, 0.01715993322432041, -0.05216855928301811, 0.05780666694045067, 0.021215243265032768, 0.001889997161924839, -0.015336137264966965, -0.016045736148953438, 0.022660456597805023, -0.052242912352085114, -0.022859442979097366, -0.027254179120063782, 0.024022052064538002, 0.003919161856174469, 0.010269375517964363, -0.0021329016890376806, 0.01696000248193741, -0.024972040206193924, 0.001508276560343802, -0.010910389013588428, 0.009042066521942616, -0.025359343737363815, -0.04093041270971298, 0.0055547477677464485, -0.046480968594551086, 0.023417076095938683, 0.008925369940698147, 0.016127528622746468, -0.027361109852790833, 0.03529426082968712, -0.011019980534911156, -0.02363109216094017, 0.029558084905147552, -0.016578735783696175, 0.005242220126092434, -0.06458313763141632, 0.06623817980289459, -0.025979798287153244, -0.007191542070358992, -0.04706110432744026, -0.016739992424845695, -0.018286900594830513, 0.03218237683176994, 0.02889874204993248, 0.02235049195587635, -0.029364503920078278, -0.050168462097644806, -0.0037680258974432945, 0.0034081097692251205, -0.06641669571399689, 0.04346197471022606, -0.022244729101657867, -0.012311563827097416, -0.023457080125808716, 0.023244181647896767, -0.01722622849047184, 0.010600917972624302, 0.04052584618330002, -0.02049827203154564, -0.022791197523474693, -0.021595057100057602, -0.031951650977134705, 0.02911321446299553, 0.024947812780737877, -0.025535859167575836, 0.002375554060563445, -0.009886635467410088, -0.006054324097931385, 0.04602447524666786, 0.020079825073480606, -0.04831031337380409, 0.04389934986829758, -0.03960743919014931, -0.029073648154735565, -0.006106115877628326, 0.02621021680533886, 0.00592617504298687, -0.057076506316661835, 0.012041296809911728, 0.04071495309472084, -0.042372170835733414, -0.026505405083298683, 0.059669431298971176, -0.006920219864696264, 0.05750255659222603, -0.03215767815709114, 0.009813756681978703, -0.01585516147315502, -0.04392583295702934, -0.003558926749974489, -0.026129916310310364, 0.005806530360132456, 0.001699560903944075, 0.038141604512929916, 0.022873854264616966, -0.0036715564783662558, 0.03775915130972862, 0.026660269126296043, 0.025594593957066536, -0.05822011083364487, 0.013588842935860157, 0.037665098905563354, -0.002529601566493511, 0.025692198425531387, 0.006963022518903017, -0.019242504611611366, 0.035179655998945236, -0.03532576188445091, 0.013399280607700348, -0.0754154771566391, -0.028683841228485107, -0.05295209959149361, -0.005918846931308508, 0.011706752702593803, -0.026579374447464943, 0.008689213544130325, 0.032921332865953445, 0.022458644583821297, 0.04722004756331444, 0.009097209200263023, -0.00919440295547247, 0.02430654503405094, -0.01561957411468029, -0.018749000504612923, 0.023688461631536484, 0.002241510897874832, -0.0341297946870327, 0.018813783302903175, 0.00037927256198599935, 0.010748251341283321, 0.04377254843711853, -0.0033919592387974262, -0.018161481246352196, -0.02815789356827736, -0.016847023740410805, -0.010276776738464832, 0.02166462317109108, -0.06733239442110062, 0.02708227001130581, 0.023204199969768524, -0.03786405548453331 ]
<p>I have seen an apparently interesting quantity called the Bayesian complexity, which in this case is defined as $-2(\overline{\ln\mathfrak{L}} - \ln\mathfrak{L}_\mathrm{max})$. I am not sure what this is used for. I.e., what sorts of tests can be made on this quantity and what does it imply? </p>
36,684
[ -0.015387038700282574, -0.022076083347201347, 0.007828268222510815, -0.015230019576847553, 0.0378187820315361, 0.03261110186576843, 0.011885271407663822, -0.012001579627394676, 0.012121732346713543, -0.04057951644062996, 0.03462349995970726, 0.03735090792179108, 0.04566860944032669, 0.016772940754890442, 0.029293600469827652, 0.03854271396994591, -0.03767554089426994, 0.01884734071791172, -0.02592223882675171, -0.026229949668049812, 0.0011977915419265628, 0.04721783846616745, 0.07538065314292908, -0.00875577237457037, -0.05071993172168732, 0.030948316678404808, 0.022786883637309074, -0.019115187227725983, 0.01425968762487173, 0.07847390323877335, -0.01081909704953432, -0.012356916442513466, 0.033895399421453476, 0.050689697265625, 0.0218936987221241, -0.02772442437708378, -0.005738172214478254, -0.04152783378958702, -0.00021466151520144194, 0.04352805018424988, -0.04336188733577728, -0.040034350007772446, -0.010731466114521027, 0.033438485115766525, -0.025849001482129097, 0.0018547162180766463, -0.020378561690449715, -0.07449277490377426, 0.022311454638838768, -0.043602995574474335, 0.0586031936109066, 0.01596289500594139, 0.009033072739839554, 0.018102074041962624, 0.016931621357798576, -0.030672231689095497, 0.046526286751031876, 0.08225062489509583, 0.0006247186684049666, -0.056187257170677185, -0.06183890998363495, -0.023817557841539383, 0.047644566744565964, -0.007011929526925087, -0.054429907351732254, 0.04936143010854721, 0.003081669332459569, -0.015225421637296677, 0.02164621651172638, 0.03077695518732071, -0.0311092771589756, 0.015445192344486713, 0.028005246073007584, -0.004001083318144083, 0.03277717903256416, -0.032180484384298325, -0.01557194720953703, 0.024058068171143532, -0.019728733226656914, 0.05137794837355614, -0.001053918618708849, -0.020582610741257668, -0.006786947138607502, 0.033743731677532196, -0.02026345208287239, -0.020408373326063156, 0.08019565790891647, -0.03165104612708092, 0.0021111546084284782, -0.00351502257399261, -0.0463540218770504, -0.003194133983924985, 0.02958681248128414, -0.02010377310216427, -0.04829072579741478, 0.05298273637890816, -0.013158227317035198, 0.047548823058605194, 0.012449629604816437, -0.0338159017264843, -0.0178235936909914, -0.04713787883520126, 0.0175416711717844, 0.06623446196317673, -0.0320555679500103, -0.03214031085371971, -0.013205797411501408, 0.021024424582719803, -0.010898125357925892, -0.006622650660574436, -0.0010623703710734844, 0.008861232548952103, 0.024580972269177437, 0.009811793453991413, -0.017054148018360138, -0.03789252042770386, 0.024319473654031754, -0.024007175117731094, 0.02094789408147335, 0.0688699334859848, 0.015195914544165134, -0.011355042457580566, 0.04309826344251633, -0.02232098951935768, -0.06552481651306152, 0.029291721060872078, 0.027895169332623482, -0.023620959371328354, -0.02200392447412014, 0.05378593131899834, -0.0035554778296500444, -0.007311644963920116, 0.0534835010766983, 0.0071770320646464825, -0.004617009311914444, -0.01267293468117714, -0.0781383216381073, -0.05197979137301445, 0.03790022432804108, 0.016519876196980476, -0.02708877995610237, -0.06255700439214706, 0.01575092040002346, 0.04147486016154289, 0.02325710654258728, -0.0026723032351583242, 0.06245293840765953, 0.02757706120610237, -0.00378294731490314, -0.009447840973734856, -0.041242800652980804, -0.020687220618128777, 0.010135642252862453, 0.004756472073495388, -0.013660045340657234, -0.07166387140750885, 0.0018192243296653032, -0.00878466572612524, -0.02478020079433918, -0.0218015369027853, 0.04335746541619301, -0.018439050763845444, -0.01413673534989357, -0.008178504183888435, -0.006898181047290564, -0.01859554648399353, 0.09299289435148239, 0.03490165248513222, -0.0026358249597251415, 0.017050115391612053, 0.01254794467240572, 0.022446943446993828, 0.033436328172683716, 0.02823827974498272, 0.07236383855342865, -0.015484978444874287, -0.01641862839460373, -0.020071012899279594, 0.04283905401825905, 0.009142342023551464, -0.002663010498508811, 0.014188175089657307, -0.02107534185051918, 0.003443582681939006, 0.0027549786027520895, 0.01768629439175129, 0.0010925042442977428, -0.006902098190039396, 0.07195677608251572, -0.04091310501098633, -0.0250276867300272, -0.048108987510204315, -0.011471780948340893, 0.048510417342185974, -0.026351535692811012, 0.04071879759430885, 0.022301239892840385, 0.01160270906984806, -0.031568899750709534, -0.04172489419579506, -0.04634026810526848, 0.001363952993415296, 0.018880493938922882, -0.03341130539774895, 0.034409232437610626, 0.03378600254654884, 0.04097866266965866, -0.026179363951086998, 0.03627793863415718, -0.05632329359650612, -0.08471351861953735, -0.009928376413881779, -0.00905741285532713, 0.0314030796289444, -0.014191408641636372, -0.029001105576753616, 0.02052832767367363, 0.004582718946039677, -0.009708018973469734, 0.018580308184027672, -0.057172741740942, 0.08295612037181854, 0.03698987141251564, 0.03649910166859627, 0.009915441274642944, 0.03036472387611866, -0.00017526204464957118, 0.0037500637117773294, -0.023534266278147697, -0.0011117922840639949, -0.032401345670223236, -0.03370647877454758, 0.05375756695866585, 0.04162228852510452, -0.03845251724123955, 0.019007625058293343, 0.01038734894245863, 0.023851720616221428, 0.023613592609763145, 0.018824651837348938, -0.0339662991464138, -0.022974632680416107, -0.010508286766707897, 0.021624501794576645, -0.002175228437408805, 0.024668335914611816, 0.025138335302472115, 0.051472388207912445, 0.028988618403673172, -0.004051558673381805, -0.032664380967617035, 0.033637966960668564, 0.013671397231519222, 0.0026320968754589558, -0.0229854267090559, 0.0018197039607912302, 0.039589039981365204, -0.03367586433887482, 0.03777431696653366, 0.018762962892651558, 0.006048687733709812, 0.015967175364494324, -0.0031708546448498964, -0.005735865328460932, 0.05022909864783287, 0.008279157802462578, -0.047469284385442734, -0.017480378970503807, 0.039848122745752335, -0.04286199063062668, 0.03831201791763306, -0.003324510296806693, -0.03312506154179573, -0.030049044638872147, 0.04790215194225311, 0.023793069645762444, -0.013415253721177578, 0.013742816634476185, -0.004675022792071104, -0.040494147688150406, 0.0067937178537249565, -0.01645238883793354, 0.03494998812675476, 0.0005237996228970587, -0.037489719688892365, -0.012409684248268604, 0.026116816326975822, -0.00801981333643198, 0.04616431146860123, -0.04163232818245888, 0.008048704825341702, -0.003044726327061653, -0.04004080221056938, -0.04174008592963219, -0.018631959334015846, -0.042727030813694, 0.013166488148272038, -0.01601835899055004, -0.012158334255218506, 0.04261079430580139, 0.0014997133985161781, -0.03010936640202999, -0.0003397526452317834, -0.03936849907040596, -0.024710170924663544, -0.03177466243505478, -0.02853798121213913, 0.012906022369861603, -0.02450507879257202, 0.014944090507924557, 0.017488298937678337, -0.05518213286995888, -0.0000797106113168411, -0.06075208634138107, -0.06906959414482117, 0.012571007013320923, 0.004183870740234852, 0.027687927708029747, -0.02628372609615326, -0.019632605835795403, 0.04593512415885925, 0.026422744616866112, -0.030336853116750717, -0.01221557892858982, 0.01072581298649311, -0.011190501973032951, -0.016736002638936043, 0.0010680007981136441, 0.012886064127087593, 0.009035281836986542, 0.052397798746824265, 0.006662703584879637, 0.02678999863564968, 0.02046351507306099, -0.007989627309143543, 0.02282300777733326, 0.05135733634233475, -0.02237175963819027, 0.004657539073377848, 0.0008127517648972571, 0.03220191225409508, -0.023250453174114227, 0.058589816093444824, -0.0027776332572102547, 0.03768760338425636, 0.021769940853118896, -0.010204212740063667, 0.038749951869249344, 0.010994338430464268, 0.03311803936958313, -0.014474871568381786, 0.03817509114742279, -0.03419935330748558, 0.02239149995148182, -0.01113678328692913, 0.058740705251693726, 0.002795327687636018, -0.004406610503792763, 0.030116630718111992, 0.021859724074602127, 0.05406138300895691, -0.018278399482369423, -0.005116184242069721, -0.03198689967393875, -0.02659275196492672, -0.0077441041357815266, 0.0052019269205629826, -0.033211320638656616, 0.02443593367934227, 0.0236554853618145, -0.015468941070139408, -0.013968909159302711, -0.0393347404897213, -0.008714430965483189, -0.03188421204686165, -0.040220264345407486, -0.019672362133860588, 0.03399842977523804, -0.025542959570884705, 0.0088639622554183, 0.014276563189923763, 0.01567087136209011, 0.012531287968158722, 0.011762233451008797, -0.08394227176904678, -0.014485588297247887, -0.048210468143224716, -0.01279802992939949, 0.02067047543823719, -0.006306648254394531, 0.08116389811038971, -0.047535642981529236, -0.011901390738785267, -0.014953053556382656, 0.051566824316978455, -0.04966932162642479, 0.0007667730678804219, -0.02227776311337948, 0.012970644980669022, 0.020405955612659454, 0.024465635418891907, 0.006141545716673136, -0.013811313547194004, 0.0073883505538105965, 0.023536143824458122, -0.02307559736073017, -0.033994000405073166, -0.010887494310736656, 0.00032272018142975867, 0.007771109696477652, 0.01580720767378807, 0.017235687002539635, 0.03801180049777031, -0.02216944471001625, 0.04456576704978943, -0.009413108229637146, 0.033815350383520126, 0.054515451192855835, -0.007827549241483212, 0.01873060315847397, -0.03168536722660065, -0.012143486179411411, -0.005670967046171427, 0.020338116213679314, 0.0020510286558419466, 0.034971293061971664, 0.044338248670101166, 0.019480859860777855, -0.0429263636469841, 0.015434087254106998, 0.032821059226989746, -0.012634324841201305, -0.02165612019598484, -0.029256395995616913, -0.01086400169879198, -0.017181964591145515, 0.013699830509722233, 0.0030746539123356342, 0.0010675094090402126, -0.04365694150328636, 0.0003774088399950415, 0.014947350136935711, -0.05470454320311546, -0.020341141149401665, -0.04603563994169235, -0.019764889031648636, 0.024772970005869865, 0.022761568427085876, -0.01471024751663208, 0.008644518442451954, 0.01321982778608799, 0.028845392167568207, 0.03546561673283577, 0.032923586666584015, -0.06406132876873016, -0.013017804361879826, 0.033187974244356155, 0.047583457082509995, -0.01990612968802452, 0.02657163143157959, -0.023786330595612526, 0.0000034009890441666357, 0.043008770793676376, 0.01530273538082838, 0.012400098145008087, -0.02589220367372036, 0.004989291075617075, -0.02464890666306019, -0.005710129160434008, -0.009022130630910397, 0.0252094604074955, 0.026288751512765884, 0.04239434748888016, -0.020254742354154587, 0.015424738638103008, -0.039997879415750504, -0.038391247391700745, 0.007537818048149347, 0.06098475307226181, -0.006533429957926273, -0.011356508359313011, 0.01826300472021103, -0.010742676444351673, -0.013442891649901867, -0.05453294515609741, 0.007651608437299728, -0.008336883038282394, -0.041408319026231766, 0.012325956486165524, -0.06398171931505203, -0.05759827420115471, 0.04750978201627731, 0.025835011154413223, -0.033084623515605927, 0.02341214381158352, -0.01639198511838913, 0.04307767003774643, 0.0388692207634449, 0.011880635283887386, 0.0614018477499485, -0.018780546262860298, -0.002855504397302866, 0.03432652726769447, -0.008703007362782955, 0.02597467415034771, -0.04509643092751503, 0.003610902698710561, -0.03276917710900307, -0.019092418253421783, -0.03684590011835098, 0.04464473947882652, 0.014509758912026882, 0.020710062235593796, 0.0092289038002491, -0.011656009592115879, -0.042297378182411194, 0.0012099210871383548, 0.030764959752559662, -0.013103421777486801, 0.00041555811185389757, 0.04960716888308525, 0.0140971215441823, -0.012937330640852451, 0.035988111048936844, 0.002130264649167657, 0.027777977287769318, 0.020430590957403183, -0.011374825611710548, 0.02120232954621315, -0.026429157704114914, -0.010039388202130795, 0.03834301978349686, 0.006139923352748156, 0.0439099445939064, -0.0036073033697903156, -0.015774335712194443, -0.01779029332101345, -0.04343796521425247, -0.04556501656770706, 0.020765166729688644, -0.02010706625878811, 0.03963370993733406, -0.029686933383345604, -0.02232775092124939, -0.03366749733686447, -0.019085368141531944, -0.06151502579450607, -0.03250957652926445, 0.011024583131074905, -0.019818304106593132, -0.014708150178194046, -0.0352642685174942, 0.002057790057733655, -0.010090858675539494, -0.03439515456557274, -0.0028005847707390785, 0.059834010899066925, 0.029896952211856842, 0.0076624383218586445, -0.00031557021429762244, -0.007747562602162361, 0.028941400349140167, 0.019047075882554054, -0.005212231073528528, 0.02286539413034916, -0.014815432019531727, -0.027113821357488632, -0.008079531602561474, 0.021572990342974663, -0.03677478805184364, 0.014006422832608223, -0.007721286732703447, 0.0237332284450531, 0.022566933184862137, -0.052789293229579926, -0.03716105967760086, -0.008889079093933105, 0.006739730015397072, 0.00601732823997736, -0.003338305512443185, 0.01004096120595932, 0.00965026207268238, 0.028185013681650162, -0.028654919937253, -0.01925666816532612, 0.008402393199503422, -0.06453459709882736, 0.024909790605306625, 0.029525764286518097, -0.0015263037057593465, 0.011201287619769573, 0.04838741943240166, 0.0059901135973632336, -0.0029750633984804153, 0.014678499661386013, -0.015835873782634735, 0.00014160183491185308, 0.015312546864151955, 0.011282679624855518, 0.016408653929829597, 0.05621867626905441, -0.03343610465526581, -0.035322822630405426, -0.04341062158346176, 0.004934757947921753, 0.03802468627691269, -0.00018425457528792322, 0.05695240572094917, 0.04601805657148361, 0.006441971752792597, 0.011495583690702915, -0.00971970148384571, -0.02175535447895527, -0.005679821129888296, 0.013713551685214043, 0.0218557920306921, -0.03305806592106819, 0.023308947682380676, 0.029665881767868996, -0.010791296139359474, -0.013920923694968224, -0.01037717517465353, 0.01185048557817936, 0.0273092333227396, 0.03903743252158165, -0.05662468448281288, -0.057840216904878616, 0.07236270606517792, -0.006166769657284021, 0.00429772911593318, -0.02296159602701664, -0.03054872155189514, 0.04084533452987671, 0.023093102499842644, 0.019944030791521072, -0.051844436675310135, -0.020704034715890884, -0.037643663585186005, 0.024816788733005524, 0.01392410509288311, 0.0022700775880366564, 0.02910606563091278, -0.01807084120810032, 0.0017124791629612446, -0.009018920361995697, 0.04008888453245163, 0.007447859272360802, -0.08788304030895233, -0.028201347216963768, 0.003194606862962246, -0.03492197021842003, 0.018605204299092293, -0.003050226252526045, -0.026701850816607475, 0.014535465277731419, -0.02374880015850067, 0.008644264191389084, 0.023888632655143738, 0.017293142154812813, -0.028387263417243958, 0.06674712896347046, 0.006947689689695835, 0.037552088499069214, -0.01589837670326233, 0.021784020587801933, 0.09732919931411743, 0.0746765211224556, 0.03337421640753746, -0.08316711336374283, 0.014708517119288445, -0.0048169963993132114, 0.010193235240876675, -0.047272615134716034, 0.04592772573232651, 0.024385448545217514, -0.00721553573384881, -0.0095759816467762, 0.04204915463924408, 0.011753692291676998, -0.04999278485774994, 0.027951397001743317, -0.04406457394361496, -0.03836832940578461, 0.035176832228899, 0.022371899336576462, -0.004993529058992863, -0.022705474868416786, -0.04669300466775894, 0.01670260913670063, -0.003858473850414157, -0.015716999769210815, -0.005248624365776777, -0.040380459278821945, -0.012359053827822208, -0.01307318452745676, -0.002407604129984975, -0.014753942377865314, 0.04100535809993744, -0.023921335116028786, -0.011374509893357754, 0.005114564672112465, 0.00771582406014204, 0.033028800040483475, -0.026343433186411858, 0.05883340165019035, -0.0006400120328180492, -0.004477792419493198, -0.012862889096140862, 0.018894212320446968, -0.030538735911250114, -0.04267199710011482, -0.013724813237786293, 0.0352129228413105, 0.0046001928858459, 0.009801585227251053, -0.008105022832751274, -0.011994987726211548, -0.022161297500133514, -0.033823058009147644, 0.011036589741706848, 0.038306824862957, 0.04209880903363228, -0.021575139835476875, -0.03412995859980583, -0.006036774720996618, 0.026842370629310608, -0.013590754941105843, 0.02454228512942791, 0.024750934913754463, -0.015474427491426468, -0.02905854769051075, -0.006839219015091658, 0.012242346070706844, 0.036265283823013306, -0.029905570670962334, -0.012890246696770191, 0.0030472830403596163, -0.027323972433805466, -0.008553851395845413, 0.012625315226614475, -0.0037548921536654234, 0.006709971930831671, -0.009209876880049706, -0.031516119837760925, -0.010761793702840805, -0.04499188810586929, -0.011058462783694267, -0.0573325976729393, -0.01336539164185524, -0.05080642178654671, -0.010421141050755978, 0.0435015894472599, 0.0032630835194140673, 0.03895305097103119, 0.01171479094773531, 0.005288429092615843, 0.048791754990816116, 0.019499190151691437, -0.06400565057992935, -0.0015346488216891885, 0.007453395519405603, -0.03956505283713341, -0.0006074709235690534, 0.00671841436997056, 0.05217266082763672, 0.0016411308897659183, 0.026100333780050278, -0.002002623165026307, 0.019918983802199364, -0.025253523141145706, 0.0031558405607938766, 0.020232485607266426, -0.02445617876946926, -0.016339750960469246, -0.008647880516946316, -0.013821203261613846, -0.0005787802510894835, -0.02474362775683403, -0.027833757922053337, -0.0009073444525711238, 0.0100666219368577, 0.014557087793946266, -0.04034877568483353, 0.005117767956107855, 0.021501123905181885, 0.015723709017038345, -0.028521154075860977, 0.012286322191357613, -0.003458860330283642, 0.0024068476632237434, -0.026325881481170654, -0.009951876476407051, 0.011563722975552082, 0.010031507350504398, 0.020103389397263527, -0.05224848911166191, 0.019934574142098427, 0.02524014748632908, -0.009866662323474884, -0.017621470615267754, 0.02045760303735733, 0.010181025601923466, 0.03308764100074768, -0.051043931394815445, -0.030978063121438026, 0.06100967898964882, -0.06275266408920288, -0.057199425995349884, 0.047048356384038925, -0.016614165157079697, 0.019856015220284462, -0.00048101370339281857, 0.0031607667915523052, -0.031199898570775986, 0.04479195550084114, -0.02265849895775318, -0.022968100383877754, 0.0021598641760647297, 0.004744138568639755, -0.020605256780982018, -0.008574885316193104, 0.020731640979647636, -0.010774064809083939, 0.013989081606268883, -0.00033791616442613304, 0.0412202887237072, -0.007342558354139328, -0.01661599427461624, 0.0065429783426225185, -0.03172716498374939, 0.048148900270462036, 0.008959800936281681, -0.006335136480629444, 0.03582668676972389, 0.04030171409249306, 0.005448234733194113, 0.05632839351892471, -0.014775867573916912, 0.006694939453154802, -0.1223946213722229, -0.003936076071113348, 0.008475273847579956, 0.007479666732251644, 0.05255444720387459, -0.07138673216104507, 0.01546572707593441, 0.005051400046795607, -0.024054817855358124, 0.01407423336058855, -0.03360350802540779, 0.004609646741300821, -0.0471128411591053, -0.039009008556604385, -0.048264481127262115, 0.05618545040488243, 0.019897688180208206, 0.010840446688234806, 0.05772095173597336, 0.025334898382425308, -0.04457264393568039, -0.01738789863884449, 0.01975943334400654, 0.043738361448049545, -0.03882055729627609, -0.05568139627575874, 0.03089488297700882, -0.005446190945804119, -0.028590859845280647, 0.04266951233148575, 0.020859437063336372, 0.04045944660902023, 0.006474599242210388, 0.07226262241601944, 0.03283718228340149, 0.008414973504841328, 0.06570694595575333, -0.022584524005651474, -0.018064117059111595, 0.033455345779657364, -0.006548481993377209, 0.019555071368813515, -0.011815314181149006, 0.016545696184039116, -0.014878908172249794, -0.009057987481355667, -0.021136777475476265, 0.028780240565538406, -0.03175455331802368, -0.0035863390658050776, 0.023952437564730644, 0.0061056772246956825, 0.003265328938141465, -0.02782488986849785, 0.03795066848397255, -0.028612636029720306, -0.009840229526162148, 0.03337278217077255, 0.01818941719830036, -0.056846193969249725, -0.021614229306578636, -0.005947750061750412, -0.04635079577565193, 0.04000594839453697, -0.013841810636222363, 0.014441443607211113, -0.06357158720493317, -0.004033736884593964, -0.0038104718551039696, 0.013582571409642696, -0.007737103849649429, -0.02903890050947666, -0.07451662421226501, 0.02327924221754074, -0.002981842029839754, 0.029422026127576828, -0.0069029261358082294, -0.028913486748933792, 0.012704717926681042, -0.08097424358129501, 0.08920702338218689, -0.022345077246427536, 0.016416974365711212, -0.01920517347753048, 0.011304996907711029, -0.0120254410430789, -0.024483634158968925, 0.07784225791692734, 0.00811582151800394, -0.0056611644104123116, -0.027950512245297432, 0.025293195620179176, 0.007419385947287083, -0.025589454919099808, -0.003365859854966402, -0.04069707542657852, -0.02346576377749443, -0.029015926644206047, -0.030705325305461884, 0.02013637311756611, -0.006142508704215288, 0.02607620507478714, -0.020706064999103546, -0.02802351489663124, -0.028775010257959366, 0.009283156134188175, 0.056620024144649506, -0.01154230535030365, 0.02450501173734665, 0.05529147759079933, -0.0019206440774723887, 0.04069191962480545, 0.007755385711789131, -0.00098347885068506, -0.0793488621711731, 0.051514916121959686, 0.02301327884197235, -0.036244988441467285, 0.019532646983861923, 0.02172333002090454, -0.0031475394498556852, -0.0137887392193079, -0.03766307979822159, 0.05936308577656746, -0.009063172154128551, -0.012339412234723568, 0.012700602412223816, 0.02514532208442688, 0.06065600737929344, -0.02122482843697071, 0.010526393540203571, 0.02289494313299656, 0.004736702423542738, 0.0016491614514961839, 0.03370165079832077, 0.08661902695894241, 0.015643222257494926, 0.0512089766561985, 0.02899283915758133, -0.06425294280052185, 0.018352247774600983, 0.0017253311816602945, 0.03889674320816994, -0.054328802973032, 0.00443349638953805, -0.0020027055870741606, -0.021400196477770805, 0.036092162132263184, -0.02647627331316471, -0.0037644230760633945, 0.07971829175949097, -0.017429454252123833, 0.0008572222432121634, -0.03522735461592674, -0.004362091887742281, -0.051004793494939804, -0.027776731178164482, 0.023606272414326668, 0.026062963530421257, 0.01280896831303835, 0.011549117043614388, -0.017762940376996994, 0.007913535460829735, 0.031862352043390274, -0.03522876277565956, 0.014668703079223633, 0.0013281747233122587, -0.0009727905271574855, -0.005767602473497391, -0.01569725200533867, -0.024067174643278122, -0.040334224700927734, -0.02398865297436714, 0.05163271352648735, 0.04558832570910454, 0.005384907126426697, -0.051015350967645645, -0.003942225594073534, 0.045566316694021225, -0.0604032464325428, 0.023670993745326996, -0.06808090209960938, 0.046252280473709106, -0.04220402613282204, -0.019539644941687584 ]
<p>I am currently working on a project in which I have to eliminate outliers from non-normally distributed data sets. </p> <p>The data sets are subsets of a fairly large database (order of millions of observations) segmented into groups ranging from 30-200+ observations based on the type of product being looked at.</p> <p>The data is pricing data which could be abnormal in the data set due to the possibility of rush orders and other types of abnormal circumstances under which purchases are made which can drive prices above or below a typical range). The difficulty in trying to identify these outlier values is that not every group of observations follows a normal distribution so tests for outliers based on normality are not accurate in testing for outliers in this type of data. </p> <p>My current approach to this problem is to measure the standard deviation from the mean to flag all values less than three deviations from the mean of the group, this is used to flag the observations for administrative review later.</p> <p>then I measure skewness using the Pearson's coefficient of skewness. If the value of this statistic is beyond a certain threshold ±.4 then I get rid of the 1st percentile (if skew is lower than -.4) or I remove the 99th percentile of data (if the skew is greater than .4).</p> <p>This measurement of skew is repeated with a new measurement of skew each iteration with the same type of observation removal based on the parameter listed in the previous paragraph. The removed values are then given over to administrative review to determine whether they are true outliers with special attention being paid to any values within 3 standard deviations. </p> <p>is this a good approach to removal of outliers in this case? I don't have much experience with outlier detection in data not belonging to a normal distribution. </p> <p>so the steps listed explicitly are</p> <ol> <li><p>Calculate deviation from mean for each observation</p></li> <li><p>Calculate skewness of the pool of observation if skew>.4 remove 99th percentile observations if skew&lt;.4 remove 1st percentile observations</p></li> <li><p>values removed are then put under review to determine outlier status with special attention paid to values falling within 3 standard deviations of mean.</p></li> </ol>
74,046
[ -0.024568483233451843, 0.015147966332733631, 0.018363771960139275, 0.020418496802449226, 0.029304683208465576, 0.0012153226416558027, 0.0006001912406645715, -0.009496469981968403, 0.01272630225867033, -0.025667663663625717, 0.011625955812633038, 0.009000523015856743, 0.013851366937160492, 0.0060777622275054455, 0.020298892632126808, -0.008071602322161198, -0.030016494914889336, -0.007569219451397657, 0.0027592426631599665, -0.024663567543029785, 0.008360779844224453, 0.021934781223535538, 0.01609017141163349, -0.0015557497972622514, -0.06252945959568024, 0.03622903302311897, 0.016881342977285385, -0.02984078973531723, 0.017948422580957413, 0.03529469296336174, -0.06166096404194832, -0.029598819091916084, 0.014593580737709999, -0.001222514547407627, 0.036453358829021454, 0.007421320304274559, 0.01297437772154808, -0.006514057517051697, -0.01393426489084959, 0.028303762897849083, -0.031365178525447845, 0.0005809770082123578, -0.022251378744840622, -0.0030556151177734137, 0.015959976240992546, -0.0068473233841359615, -0.011194618418812752, -0.047715239226818085, 0.023156635463237762, -0.045454856008291245, 0.08505759388208389, -0.033189453184604645, -0.0014398942003026605, 0.027237486094236374, 0.001612520543858409, -0.015344890765845776, 0.056156136095523834, 0.07760798186063766, -0.009128697216510773, -0.03672035038471222, -0.007716909050941467, -0.012765656225383282, -0.0268086027354002, -0.02959383837878704, -0.037705887109041214, -0.014653217978775501, -0.014738890342414379, -0.03787581995129585, 0.029967665672302246, 0.0041569494642317295, 0.01858323998749256, 0.011664333753287792, -0.002158645773306489, -0.025623876601457596, 0.03109274059534073, -0.05063268542289734, -0.027751987800002098, 0.002830387093126774, 0.054165568202733994, 0.03646804764866829, 0.02804279699921608, -0.030618546530604362, 0.0068972003646194935, 0.03983490541577339, 0.039143480360507965, -0.024810971692204475, 0.10310409963130951, -0.05100410059094429, 0.006315135397017002, 0.04286731407046318, -0.01251949742436409, -0.01976107805967331, 0.05634642764925957, 0.017121564596891403, -0.03513393923640251, 0.02637789584696293, -0.03397537022829056, 0.022396672517061234, -0.024436159059405327, -0.012581109069287777, 0.014465762302279472, -0.02998010255396366, -0.010403216816484928, 0.08191676437854767, -0.012533843517303467, 0.009761531837284565, -0.005116404965519905, 0.028320973739027977, -0.003908009268343449, -0.010303106158971786, -0.015532432124018669, -0.01916120946407318, -0.01651054434478283, -0.030821090564131737, 0.0081687793135643, 0.029174553230404854, -0.020283183082938194, -0.047065235674381256, -0.0009746455471031368, 0.04187066853046417, 0.005542653612792492, -0.0036937014665454626, -0.012994623742997646, -0.01643858477473259, -0.04384453594684601, 0.023054178804159164, 0.028406646102666855, -0.00025994359748438, -0.0433543398976326, 0.025901060551404953, 0.025757916271686554, 0.0018219765042886138, 0.052631787955760956, -0.020398009568452835, 0.022593218833208084, -0.017022835090756416, -0.0641007199883461, -0.05985293537378311, 0.0573127306997776, 0.018942413851618767, -0.002925924491137266, -0.0318046435713768, -0.030521290376782417, 0.03289421275258064, -0.0019197899382561445, 0.009882552549242973, 0.01621873490512371, 0.034232355654239655, -0.004571734461933374, -0.01547608058899641, -0.02177520841360092, 0.014820161275565624, -0.016925159841775894, -0.03102089837193489, -0.022925399243831635, -0.08546313643455505, 0.030503256246447563, 0.0008544084848836064, -0.00804581493139267, -0.019868412986397743, -0.007331145461648703, 0.021645497530698776, 0.0131387859582901, -0.024281231686472893, 0.029636509716510773, 0.010207904502749443, 0.07285605370998383, -0.008404333144426346, 0.05165097489953041, 0.020725449547171593, 0.0038473247550427914, 0.038787126541137695, -0.002211151644587517, 0.02794334478676319, 0.05206070840358734, -0.02614942565560341, -0.0021437876857817173, -0.030284883454442024, 0.011030319146811962, -0.00021781880059279501, -0.020685333758592606, -0.004823935683816671, -0.007616653107106686, 0.012954029254615307, 0.03416420519351959, 0.045718107372522354, -0.00849933922290802, 0.003197727259248495, 0.07351625710725784, -0.06642796099185944, -0.019337182864546776, -0.05390286445617676, -0.016039252281188965, -0.008050728589296341, -0.05220795422792435, 0.035919781774282455, -0.01828848011791706, 0.014177496545016766, -0.01738155074417591, -0.004510358441621065, -0.023853616788983345, 0.029552865773439407, 0.05596545338630676, -0.0737539753317833, 0.019910713657736778, 0.061447396874427795, 0.042818568646907806, 0.0015080085722729564, 0.03184143453836441, -0.037875983864068985, -0.042491573840379715, -0.008631076663732529, -0.04773120582103729, -0.001224816427566111, 0.004190624225884676, -0.012493407353758812, 0.03266007825732231, 0.017880907282233238, -0.011506488546729088, 0.020345745608210564, -0.051673196256160736, 0.0968356505036354, 0.06785107403993607, -0.015004185028374195, -0.00382513040676713, -0.03463234752416611, -0.02334890514612198, -0.011007910594344139, -0.023588476702570915, -0.012058805674314499, -0.0566856823861599, -0.006332286633551121, 0.017114605754613876, 0.030211640521883965, -0.04006364196538925, 0.0067772031761705875, 0.06673163920640945, -0.015187866054475307, 0.035586003214120865, 0.00023532625345978886, 0.007639332674443722, -0.01487722061574459, 0.03291836753487587, -0.023429905995726585, 0.027280280366539955, 0.04128407686948776, 0.04625081270933151, 0.00526416627690196, 0.031125493347644806, 0.008318723179399967, 0.05368630588054657, 0.028866130858659744, 0.04264964535832405, 0.02994617074728012, -0.009751105681061745, -0.024183964356780052, 0.03346361964941025, -0.007687779143452644, -0.007893509231507778, 0.06626351177692413, 0.010019850917160511, 0.01284360233694315, 0.0025032367557287216, -0.00010722332081058994, 0.02948702871799469, 0.03539113700389862, -0.01997661031782627, 0.020393438637256622, 0.0035619023256003857, -0.048202358186244965, 0.01947886124253273, -0.033635981380939484, -0.02332286350429058, -0.020091183483600616, 0.029634738340973854, 0.03571563586592674, 0.027969541028141975, 0.007203750312328339, -0.038576722145080566, 0.02480747550725937, -0.0028102537617087364, 0.01856543868780136, 0.0019916491582989693, -0.0008213129476644099, -0.06859786063432693, -0.014904569834470749, 0.015307173132896423, -0.010002988390624523, -0.008174432441592216, -0.0010008126264438033, 0.020801080390810966, 0.038662590086460114, 0.010122994892299175, -0.0615798681974411, 0.00390198128297925, -0.022773029282689095, 0.022022157907485962, -0.023027390241622925, -0.04934707283973694, 0.03226720169186592, 0.018660500645637512, -0.02225487306714058, 0.045473866164684296, -0.025579437613487244, -0.030650969594717026, -0.030810482800006866, -0.00491748284548521, 0.03375173732638359, 0.0021608651150017977, -0.00008720605546841398, -0.007196179591119289, 0.002880900166928768, -0.003212863113731146, -0.07395542412996292, -0.04672670736908913, -0.029232138767838478, 0.033920954912900925, 0.05909516289830208, -0.00897673238068819, -0.030692780390381813, 0.0477093942463398, 0.052346013486385345, -0.03180457279086113, 0.0000988147221505642, -0.0006810945924371481, -0.03968483582139015, -0.023098208010196686, 0.017619337886571884, 0.01485537551343441, -0.002262937370687723, -0.025092579424381256, -0.023019088432192802, 0.0425981804728508, 0.030291300266981125, 0.020363735035061836, -0.02355108968913555, 0.004587702453136444, -0.007167892996221781, 0.009586057625710964, 0.042478591203689575, 0.024932006374001503, -0.02467355877161026, 0.0005068425089120865, 0.024991976097226143, 0.04192526265978813, 0.005495505873113871, -0.05628480389714241, 0.02517308108508587, -0.025585737079381943, -0.022662004455924034, -0.025142686441540718, 0.022203650325536728, 0.011320702731609344, -0.024134162813425064, -0.026180334389209747, -0.0028601642698049545, 0.0409582145512104, -0.008670915849506855, 0.022916682064533234, 0.0799982100725174, 0.019936153665184975, -0.007751586847007275, 0.012809555046260357, -0.007902250625193119, -0.036745525896549225, 0.008075532503426075, -0.0687745064496994, 0.026320012286305428, -0.01182742789387703, 0.04592649266123772, 0.0221524927765131, -0.005632241256535053, -0.028977595269680023, 0.001818711287342012, -0.0824292004108429, -0.025683727115392685, -0.031554341316223145, 0.041319556534290314, -0.008486242033541203, 0.02375117316842079, 0.020999092608690262, -0.03736148029565811, -0.015897875651717186, -0.0021812350023537874, -0.037812795490026474, 0.02336668036878109, -0.017153359949588776, 0.000997566501609981, 0.0007139851222746074, -0.045617926865816116, 0.023565776646137238, -0.03241998329758644, 0.05244961008429527, -0.029260339215397835, 0.06213688105344772, 0.008032533340156078, 0.02071867696940899, -0.010838501155376434, 0.006755785085260868, 0.004580697976052761, 0.0007529659196734428, -0.01820308156311512, -0.010886581614613533, 0.015886008739471436, 0.024563077837228775, 0.025037309154868126, -0.008883075788617134, -0.024818381294608116, -0.011046296916902065, 0.004317640792578459, 0.05582743510603905, -0.023806994780898094, 0.023408837616443634, -0.009376204572618008, 0.025745123624801636, 0.031144458800554276, 0.07728152722120285, 0.031001092866063118, 0.009525810368359089, -0.024016179144382477, -0.0361391082406044, -0.04684998095035553, 0.004435483366250992, 0.00478456262499094, 0.00025965948589146137, 0.0023559427354484797, 0.04684129357337952, -0.006095282267779112, -0.0795821100473404, -0.007741234265267849, 0.06441778689622879, 0.031152883544564247, 0.011680142022669315, -0.029148107394576073, -0.03980077803134918, 0.020259981974959373, -0.02298031561076641, -0.0012178582837805152, 0.024255800992250443, 0.012253140099346638, -0.009233872406184673, 0.025737997144460678, 0.009667698293924332, -0.036103881895542145, -0.013932423666119576, 0.02084493450820446, 0.04421685263514519, -0.008298685774207115, 0.020350134000182152, 0.04196677356958389, 0.027188751846551895, 0.03540889918804169, 0.02416679449379444, 0.032030943781137466, -0.08243241161108017, 0.011451923288404942, 0.04974280670285225, 0.06163948029279709, -0.01985509879887104, -0.011585310101509094, -0.04105079546570778, 0.007731215097010136, -0.016235467046499252, -0.041647277772426605, 0.026061300188302994, -0.03505668044090271, 0.02077881246805191, -0.010933546349406242, -0.04836313799023628, -0.0548582598567009, 0.010260654613375664, -0.0016414562705904245, -0.007231583818793297, -0.042754631489515305, -0.02691108174622059, -0.053314290940761566, -0.0034752837382256985, 0.02848893217742443, 0.058052610605955124, -0.02726977877318859, -0.03101080097258091, 0.017334768548607826, 0.02601231075823307, -0.00897378008812666, -0.05015191808342934, -0.008925406262278557, 0.007893024943768978, 0.022423362359404564, 0.03603117913007736, 0.015765337273478508, -0.03806394711136818, 0.007779322098940611, 0.03212149441242218, -0.014799714088439941, 0.01127355732023716, -0.01774216815829277, 0.04188990220427513, 0.02192739024758339, 0.04095878079533577, 0.02877015247941017, 0.02148517034947872, -0.006034647114574909, 0.006107077468186617, -0.042489297688007355, 0.011576429009437561, -0.03770304471254349, -0.025762688368558884, -0.05352894216775894, -0.013270745985209942, -0.024199839681386948, 0.05150540918111801, -0.028295427560806274, 0.0414762981235981, -0.008058669045567513, 0.001273036003112793, 0.016376351937651634, 0.026823822408914566, 0.011647065170109272, 0.019860126078128815, 0.0077263168059289455, 0.01773066446185112, -0.04033707454800606, 0.008400499820709229, 0.026670442894101143, -0.019997773692011833, 0.021935302764177322, 0.025337135419249535, -0.057123877108097076, -0.00172442477196455, -0.053985919803380966, -0.03371775895357132, -0.00681691849604249, 0.016538653522729874, 0.04643663018941879, 0.018344484269618988, 0.023378806188702583, 0.02579294890165329, -0.010740071535110474, -0.020445069298148155, 0.04573711007833481, -0.03989030793309212, 0.025730427354574203, -0.0008552016224712133, 0.0359373614192009, -0.0186106339097023, 0.013693789951503277, -0.07661567628383636, -0.005541839636862278, 0.030702216550707817, -0.01314874179661274, -0.0059949541464447975, -0.028107134625315666, 0.0021416000090539455, 0.012923487462103367, -0.035551249980926514, -0.014983722940087318, 0.048855580389499664, -0.025745026767253876, -0.029074368998408318, -0.013050231151282787, 0.02830422669649124, 0.09438353776931763, -0.027801094576716423, -0.022346703335642815, -0.016629349440336227, -0.010729710571467876, -0.04558192566037178, -0.010227908380329609, 0.03526323288679123, 0.010944107547402382, -0.013372071087360382, -0.05061986297369003, -0.0029182068537920713, 0.021470369771122932, -0.05729449540376663, -0.004630555398762226, -0.009670218452811241, -0.005539221689105034, 0.004725615959614515, -0.027163580060005188, -0.03351188078522682, 0.03705577924847603, 0.02223476953804493, -0.02821699157357216, 0.011597305536270142, -0.015562771819531918, -0.010055414400994778, 0.021599408239126205, 0.0019717917311936617, -0.006892924662679434, 0.026065858080983162, 0.07695458084344864, -0.007128095719963312, 0.02307548187673092, -0.02360403910279274, -0.02308313548564911, 0.0639692023396492, 0.003210905008018017, -0.02689141035079956, -0.0280869472771883, 0.024790074676275253, -0.01773614063858986, -0.016088245436549187, -0.013350889086723328, -0.016653409227728844, 0.05411941558122635, 0.03548228368163109, 0.060724690556526184, 0.04146674647927284, 0.012218593619763851, -0.009755703620612621, -0.05285101756453514, 0.008895116858184338, 0.02414822019636631, -0.005849821027368307, 0.03596503287553787, 0.012534640729427338, 0.047181252390146255, -0.0010125269182026386, -0.04050157591700554, 0.009572187438607216, 0.02155696228146553, 0.018404383212327957, 0.019679885357618332, 0.04619573801755905, -0.07180536538362503, -0.03583281487226486, 0.0307167898863554, -0.04302137717604637, 0.03191186487674713, -0.053128041326999664, -0.036130305379629135, 0.026367655023932457, 0.06215432658791542, -0.009289545938372612, -0.0533662848174572, -0.006610560696572065, -0.1039942279458046, 0.007790755480527878, 0.004166088066995144, -0.04952263459563255, 0.030765024945139885, 0.009042729623615742, 0.04361932352185249, 0.013446248136460781, 0.02496163174510002, -0.019396984949707985, -0.04462006315588951, -0.016975777223706245, 0.0009450258803553879, -0.008226416073739529, 0.03133392333984375, -0.014176908880472183, 0.020760158076882362, 0.0018065858166664839, -0.026163317263126373, 0.035414744168519974, 0.031094452366232872, -0.0007310637156479061, -0.015848636627197266, 0.04608561098575592, -0.00511693861335516, 0.021706992760300636, -0.017151663079857826, 0.016119694337248802, 0.11873268336057663, 0.10458550602197647, 0.012979015707969666, -0.06862436980009079, -0.006145913153886795, 0.018301984295248985, 0.005105358548462391, -0.023469898849725723, 0.033994629979133606, -0.00478665204718709, 0.005481719505041838, 0.06010196730494499, 0.03315931558609009, -0.00521796615794301, 0.0030353027395904064, 0.07178244739770889, -0.004035134334117174, 0.004809493664652109, 0.00905110128223896, 0.03463543951511383, 0.014120012521743774, 0.008066345006227493, -0.089327372610569, 0.04926592856645584, -0.02374277450144291, -0.033037442713975906, -0.019449541345238686, -0.013174518011510372, -0.012312659993767738, 0.00316070974804461, -0.002188214799389243, -0.0003373606305103749, 0.007125978823751211, -0.008738691918551922, -0.0015517877181991935, 0.00839073583483696, 0.01992684416472912, -0.07018793374300003, 0.010273410938680172, 0.031908806413412094, 0.0031521995551884174, -0.0014875259948894382, 0.019970279186964035, 0.024277329444885254, -0.054247524589300156, -0.025172503665089607, -0.027570530772209167, 0.03730542212724686, -0.025395434349775314, -0.036257822066545486, -0.027770819142460823, -0.027812976390123367, -0.005467613227665424, -0.04247985780239105, 0.003253309288993478, 0.010353640653192997, 0.010767378844320774, -0.03972712159156799, -0.009157933294773102, 0.01122406218200922, -0.002416553208604455, 0.015861589461565018, 0.033730119466781616, 0.004864143673330545, -0.0009643998346291482, -0.026442326605319977, -0.019174855202436447, 0.03961600363254547, 0.03611772134900093, -0.004094334319233894, 0.0020102353300899267, -0.025233270600438118, 0.0237150639295578, -0.0014563557924702764, -0.011074425652623177, 0.005782746709883213, 0.02897731028497219, 0.020567497238516808, 0.00947121623903513, -0.03829903155565262, -0.05029165372252464, 0.0429128035902977, -0.02835155837237835, 0.009259581565856934, -0.06691145896911621, -0.03775407746434212, 0.014052705839276314, 0.02545718103647232, 0.05043249949812889, 0.02527754008769989, 0.012140421196818352, 0.08485287427902222, 0.025565432384610176, -0.03370866924524307, 0.00909644179046154, 0.014595285058021545, -0.042054180055856705, 0.031823597848415375, 0.0101866340264678, 0.09941425919532776, 0.03742561116814613, 0.0036332192830741405, -0.024300698190927505, 0.0388764813542366, -0.03626628220081329, 0.0027563448529690504, 0.02602168172597885, -0.05223073065280914, -0.0067377276718616486, 0.0014376725303009152, -0.014548864215612411, -0.03896570950746536, 0.0031250754836946726, -0.018648982048034668, -0.017043016850948334, -0.026113593950867653, 0.011548505164682865, -0.0002169426588807255, -0.013608906418085098, -0.032546672970056534, 0.026184000074863434, -0.011493629775941372, -0.012810603715479374, 0.0011673183180391788, -0.032029759138822556, -0.004656196106225252, 0.013723118230700493, -0.022205304354429245, -0.005171814933419228, 0.04320260137319565, 0.014331495389342308, 0.016263475641608238, 0.03603402525186539, 0.035413242876529694, -0.016288721933960915, 0.007302068639546633, -0.019313322380185127, 0.00040787120815366507, -0.004558257292956114, -0.0013196844374760985, 0.05972651392221451, 0.004995958413928747, -0.033917248249053955, 0.03808039426803589, -0.01332915760576725, 0.011667902581393719, -0.003005938371643424, -0.029372990131378174, -0.028357790783047676, 0.04157942533493042, -0.010211717337369919, -0.031558383256196976, -0.04069368913769722, 0.03396515175700188, -0.016004888340830803, -0.0273596178740263, 0.022926731035113335, -0.00033772914321161807, -0.01708781160414219, 0.03136107325553894, 0.0150699932128191, 0.013272952288389206, -0.006901073269546032, -0.0011654443806037307, -0.0023599250707775354, 0.012600881978869438, -0.02195664495229721, 0.033887408673763275, 0.016194753348827362, 0.014595916494727135, -0.02108592726290226, 0.03203471377491951, -0.025116246193647385, -0.011209937743842602, -0.08642998337745667, -0.031143028289079666, 0.01429353654384613, 0.019149595871567726, 0.043182943016290665, -0.04178769513964653, -0.008612566627562046, 0.04978449270129204, -0.035026032477617264, 0.04710773006081581, -0.03823951631784439, 0.006660437677055597, -0.0557316318154335, 0.005079622380435467, -0.016756564378738403, -0.0021183770149946213, -0.010168571025133133, 0.002012580865994096, 0.01999620907008648, 0.03193096071481705, 0.004552198573946953, -0.012845593504607677, 0.004016744904220104, 0.01599423959851265, 0.033343181014060974, -0.09049522131681442, 0.024377260357141495, -0.034762606024742126, 0.030017798766493797, 0.013176457956433296, -0.016185667365789413, 0.008032066747546196, -0.018126949667930603, 0.007517893332988024, -0.0011860571103170514, 0.0474960096180439, 0.05295775830745697, 0.04728955030441284, 0.008236057125031948, -0.041109099984169006, 0.04203338548541069, 0.020515410229563713, -0.02585926465690136, 0.011420759372413158, 0.03936983272433281, -0.013497801497578621, -0.008543728850781918, -0.005787814501672983, -0.006679876707494259, -0.014716552570462227, -0.0028749024495482445, 0.03518754988908768, -0.012843449600040913, -0.022973328828811646, 0.012853909283876419, -0.04556872695684433, -0.015956606715917587, 0.08354537189006805, 0.03041643276810646, -0.03993162885308266, 0.019726071506738663, -0.02100788988173008, -0.019288666546344757, 0.02100755274295807, 0.008069522678852081, -0.024207593873143196, -0.09750871360301971, 0.008936465717852116, -0.04348980262875557, -0.029274694621562958, -0.023297231644392014, 0.008509431034326553, -0.013683199882507324, 0.06563489139080048, -0.012232611887156963, 0.004080220125615597, 0.017576850950717926, -0.013068398460745811, -0.03374132886528969, -0.07570679485797882, 0.05754740908741951, 0.02180350199341774, -0.044030044227838516, -0.02051502652466297, -0.038173023611307144, -0.0635647177696228, 0.02254915051162243, 0.049837417900562286, 0.03739464282989502, 0.01859775371849537, -0.021585702896118164, 0.009456233121454716, 0.017493611201643944, -0.05900001525878906, 0.042894840240478516, -0.03021399863064289, -0.0162894818931818, -0.028751838952302933, -0.019078390672802925, 0.018192468211054802, -0.03230800852179527, 0.00839844811707735, -0.019360680133104324, 0.025995668023824692, 0.033742282539606094, 0.014690997079014778, 0.025287460535764694, -0.0023303870111703873, -0.0267967376857996, 0.021357320249080658, -0.016037452965974808, -0.00506456708535552, 0.03809588402509689, 0.017051642760634422, -0.08784034848213196, -0.002416320377960801, 0.006802463438361883, -0.01865958981215954, -0.014636664651334286, 0.016878485679626465, 0.0024117736611515284, -0.07507850974798203, 0.02217111736536026, 0.013060233555734158, -0.051861997693777084, 0.003741944907233119, 0.015313197858631611, -0.03806362673640251, 0.03975739702582359, 0.0018711986485868692, 0.030515581369400024, 0.011307118460536003, -0.027218112722039223, 0.02455367147922516, 0.019047915935516357, 0.00910692848265171, 0.015020559541881084, -0.02701995149254799, 0.04318192973732948, 0.005149737931787968, 0.020246002823114395, -0.0010872763814404607, 0.05256051570177078, -0.007641972508281469, -0.025705857202410698, 0.0236227847635746, -0.016024792566895485, 0.0296053234487772, 0.016291489824652672, -0.026137929409742355, 0.005617127753794193, -0.00843960139900446, -0.007556704338639975, -0.035943470895290375, -0.0005397544009611011, -0.016036050394177437, 0.009688845835626125, -0.003830944886431098, 0.01852601394057274, -0.03042685054242611, 0.021788328886032104, 0.019029436632990837, 0.024992767721414566, -0.007699836511164904, -0.020810171961784363, 0.06141570210456848, -0.03091343864798546, 0.002518624998629093, -0.009896515868604183, -0.017981063574552536, -0.02682994119822979, -0.008158938027918339, -0.0116264708340168, 0.02444491907954216, 0.029354773461818695, 0.010649756528437138, -0.033532071858644485, -0.020894471555948257, 0.03619831055402756, -0.02216777764260769, 0.01814781315624714, -0.006774689070880413, 0.009896918199956417, -0.062144774943590164, -0.030670005828142166 ]
<p>I am using R for data analysis. R provides a <code>corr</code> function for calculating the correlation. <a href="http://www.statmethods.net/stats/correlations.html">This function</a> provides three different approaches/algorithms to estimating the <code>corr</code> which are Pearson, Spearman and Kendall. When should I use each of each of these methods? What factors determine which method should be used?</p>
74,047
[ -0.053956057876348495, 0.004227392375469208, -0.01374144945293665, 0.00302721094340086, -0.009809420444071293, 0.012089591473340988, -0.02087061107158661, -0.036181338131427765, 0.03590767830610275, 0.00436793826520443, 0.028202537447214127, 0.052284713834524155, 0.039728034287691116, 0.06458882987499237, 0.046489614993333817, 0.006023284047842026, 0.01938270404934883, -0.021485526114702225, -0.018330877646803856, -0.006870109587907791, -0.016021164134144783, 0.01076293084770441, -0.007964731194078922, -0.018335316330194473, -0.026949001476168633, 0.05488329380750656, -0.009591647423803806, -0.013791008852422237, 0.04705549031496048, 0.01586812362074852, -0.017181165516376495, -0.018438421189785004, 0.011596404016017914, 0.02712148241698742, 0.01820206269621849, -0.017905209213495255, -0.04196234419941902, -0.014260668307542801, -0.021071869879961014, 0.03959937021136284, -0.050488244742155075, -0.027419576421380043, -0.004070893861353397, 0.020510384812951088, -0.030569830909371376, 0.01992056705057621, -0.03214530646800995, -0.03400878980755806, 0.006493486929684877, -0.02828296460211277, 0.05289251357316971, 0.011933165602385998, 0.014915548264980316, 0.048170898109674454, 0.0002005266142077744, 0.00935673713684082, 0.045027755200862885, 0.04288985952734947, -0.01688063144683838, -0.060199201107025146, 0.0009135259315371513, -0.03496814891695976, -0.023783674463629723, -0.034408800303936005, -0.0048369416035711765, 0.041855987161397934, 0.01660776510834694, -0.0017454164335504174, 0.03905016928911209, -0.028312504291534424, 0.024518176913261414, 0.03292930871248245, 0.03980895131826401, -0.01725255325436592, 0.020787622779607773, -0.0557192787528038, -0.005209121387451887, 0.019707124680280685, 0.048547565937042236, 0.05371665954589844, 0.014763974584639072, -0.017601385712623596, 0.05530206859111786, 0.03318855166435242, 0.049270108342170715, -0.014561338350176811, 0.07332286983728409, -0.025613591074943542, -0.0028906716033816338, 0.016981398686766624, 0.006993441376835108, 0.011564896441996098, 0.04414809122681618, 0.02601618878543377, -0.005149066913872957, 0.0264024268835783, -0.027543354779481888, 0.05265982449054718, -0.002438898663967848, -0.002649016445502639, 0.013014952652156353, -0.022117482498288155, 0.011807930655777454, 0.053988389670848846, -0.01734018884599209, -0.003877210197970271, -0.02606741525232792, -0.002892446471378207, -0.0013000024482607841, -0.041410963982343674, -0.03265678137540817, 0.02729853428900242, -0.018317682668566704, 0.021236922591924667, 0.0398595929145813, 0.007430924568325281, -0.009145090356469154, -0.013333904556930065, 0.07617224752902985, 0.08119639754295349, 0.02901548333466053, -0.0229262113571167, -0.025529645383358, -0.025052295997738838, -0.03341691941022873, 0.015354995615780354, 0.013193919323384762, -0.0224971454590559, -0.04242853820323944, 0.055181391537189484, 0.008780130185186863, -0.04115388169884682, 0.0020979794207960367, -0.0063103968277573586, -0.0015907492488622665, 0.00310424598865211, -0.10134018957614899, -0.03816542029380798, 0.0407809242606163, -0.0018912378000095487, 0.02564290538430214, -0.039730336517095566, 0.009698383510112762, -0.012210547924041748, 0.04576963186264038, 0.0018123392947018147, 0.05573263019323349, -0.003916966263204813, 0.03275822475552559, 0.0012319486122578382, -0.09090674668550491, -0.024968670681118965, -0.028925443068146706, -0.023086678236722946, -0.027079587802290916, -0.07460205256938934, -0.005896632559597492, -0.013357886113226414, 0.023890860378742218, 0.001261032186448574, 0.045786090195178986, -0.0026691698003560305, -0.034442752599716187, -0.0059739975258708, 0.007425511255860329, -0.012815824709832668, 0.04577053710818291, 0.013411503285169601, 0.0494469590485096, -0.004252053331583738, -0.0007187231676653028, 0.02855977788567543, -0.010213849134743214, 0.04032212495803833, 0.044351592659950256, -0.045126236975193024, 0.012049280107021332, 0.010654306970536709, -0.003837066236883402, 0.001174328732304275, -0.04091423377394676, -0.016085267066955566, 0.021802043542265892, -0.035294875502586365, 0.03661035746335983, 0.024052297696471214, 0.010690211318433285, -0.013434115797281265, 0.048507120460271835, -0.016992686316370964, -0.06566240638494492, -0.0866781696677208, -0.0027292424347251654, -0.015396823175251484, -0.05994543433189392, 0.03329325094819069, 0.009653912857174873, 0.06408669799566269, -0.01061418280005455, -0.00158907740842551, -0.00930724572390318, 0.021550264209508896, 0.04673287644982338, -0.01161462627351284, 0.004639679566025734, 0.009157434105873108, 0.04088783264160156, -0.042594458907842636, 0.036655839532613754, -0.05525290220975876, -0.03640592843294144, -0.004826903343200684, -0.026164736598730087, 0.011896288953721523, -0.015985814854502678, -0.049067478626966476, 0.016633976250886917, 0.011509929783642292, -0.018759990110993385, 0.011815179139375687, -0.038850899785757065, 0.06313081830739975, 0.06165052577853203, 0.02745557203888893, -0.004023106303066015, -0.01548011228442192, 0.007507103029638529, 0.005979998502880335, -0.02305423840880394, -0.022311776876449585, -0.040347591042518616, 0.012770182453095913, 0.02418489009141922, -0.00682256743311882, -0.04972388222813606, 0.003553534159436822, 0.05073266848921776, 0.030883368104696274, -0.02336318977177143, 0.012875087559223175, -0.029351698234677315, -0.008688820526003838, 0.0040761190466582775, 0.036349933594465256, 0.014280365779995918, 0.009463638067245483, 0.014115214347839355, 0.007164828013628721, 0.05203835293650627, 0.0038567236624658108, -0.026711754500865936, 0.05696216970682144, -0.0138265835121274, 0.008230817504227161, -0.009795015677809715, -0.04288506880402565, 0.02706100605428219, -0.04920882731676102, 0.026720993220806122, 0.004004128742963076, -0.00803438201546669, -0.021918082609772682, 0.03707610070705414, -0.03665538504719734, -0.0009959646267816424, 0.0475725494325161, -0.01419631578028202, 0.0020645868498831987, 0.000355300260707736, -0.01909259706735611, 0.01376877911388874, -0.013154971413314342, -0.004488353617489338, -0.028520328924059868, -0.014917170628905296, 0.0427122600376606, -0.016183577477931976, 0.05171658843755722, -0.04363097995519638, 0.0038476709742099047, -0.025315014645457268, -0.03790861368179321, 0.0060263751074671745, -0.008640659041702747, -0.0927903950214386, -0.017149977385997772, 0.0057640704326331615, -0.02293337509036064, -0.011738189496099949, -0.03543756157159805, -0.010205189697444439, 0.022071698680520058, 0.020014150068163872, -0.06503072381019592, -0.014146708883345127, 0.00843682512640953, 0.02148803509771824, -0.014476794749498367, -0.0307477880269289, 0.0358925461769104, -0.019280163571238518, -0.01659630425274372, -0.0035130619071424007, -0.06458734720945358, -0.03493470326066017, -0.003256165189668536, 0.006993841379880905, -0.003214702708646655, 0.005256315227597952, -0.03605765476822853, 0.020146219059824944, -0.03444544970989227, -0.04482952877879143, -0.059037644416093826, -0.049386538565158844, 0.045375775545835495, 0.009648613631725311, 0.008516726084053516, -0.0008967301691882312, -0.013720895163714886, 0.03032011166214943, 0.015903105959296227, -0.030683228746056557, -0.042926620692014694, -0.01803131029009819, -0.014648664742708206, 0.010251314379274845, 0.013113866560161114, 0.03527588024735451, 0.024534637108445168, 0.0004074466123711318, -0.004390205256640911, 0.035483963787555695, 0.05582020431756973, -0.009383663535118103, 0.014585733413696289, 0.022646160796284676, 0.007534593343734741, -0.043173205107450485, 0.06516987085342407, 0.024843642488121986, -0.05243678763508797, 0.007353347726166248, -0.019833972677588463, -0.007812974974513054, 0.00854357797652483, -0.04060456529259682, 0.0006096601136960089, 0.003168376162648201, 0.02294228784739971, -0.047371432185173035, 0.009187796153128147, 0.010388667695224285, -0.030333463102579117, 0.016826797276735306, 0.019448328763246536, 0.010287723504006863, -0.05316806584596634, -0.006629650015383959, 0.03762590512633324, 0.03638939931988716, -0.0006866370094940066, -0.0013676874805241823, -0.03644568845629692, -0.03956598788499832, 0.01756105199456215, -0.05786567181348801, -0.01696845516562462, 0.059582002460956573, 0.030087238177657127, 0.010472406633198261, 0.01145900972187519, -0.048283662647008896, -0.0013521889923140407, -0.07767767459154129, 0.0013163842959329486, -0.015531645156443119, 0.06274136900901794, 0.030896177515387535, 0.045259688049554825, 0.027946854010224342, -0.024459613487124443, 0.03888174518942833, 0.00415391381829977, -0.051304347813129425, 0.06064695492386818, -0.00022388840443454683, -0.01450491975992918, 0.01210105698555708, -0.05386028438806534, 0.007577148266136646, -0.015870099887251854, 0.02404044196009636, 0.010328189469873905, 0.01698618195950985, 0.0017185311298817396, 0.012180173769593239, -0.004545466974377632, -0.03131735324859619, -0.0036565023474395275, 0.022012265399098396, 0.018403122201561928, -0.006129108369350433, 0.05095415189862251, 0.08372191339731216, 0.013836761005222797, -0.004138690419495106, 0.003842343809083104, -0.014313094317913055, 0.030666619539260864, 0.029862191528081894, 0.008837359957396984, -0.00613947631791234, -0.03200748190283775, 0.03417520970106125, 0.010811012238264084, 0.03794584423303604, 0.0447293259203434, -0.05678880959749222, -0.03153008222579956, 0.016655415296554565, 0.02654046192765236, 0.007286602631211281, 0.004839006345719099, 0.014353476464748383, -0.00345613737590611, 0.0669369176030159, 0.03986639529466629, -0.03756719082593918, 0.020322958007454872, 0.0814799964427948, 0.05218037962913513, 0.027230551466345787, -0.03477522358298302, 0.017940018326044083, 0.03103666380047798, -0.014990692026913166, 0.021680397912859917, 0.0039228047244250774, 0.002306612441316247, 0.023091880604624748, 0.03407812491059303, -0.04345066845417023, -0.004313931334763765, -0.0008075606892816722, 0.03633938729763031, 0.038847457617521286, -0.011724190786480904, -0.04192278906702995, -0.0070715234614908695, 0.018736964091658592, 0.014323374256491661, -0.01896369270980358, 0.007212504744529724, -0.04310271143913269, 0.009485890157520771, 0.05923135578632355, 0.05074569955468178, -0.05247402563691139, -0.0002874015481211245, -0.01538163237273693, -0.01596209406852722, 0.05010949447751045, -0.04983489587903023, 0.009470175951719284, -0.005107419565320015, 0.007429097313433886, -0.04390648752450943, -0.021679911762475967, -0.0643700659275055, 0.03620545193552971, -0.015373919159173965, 0.026292653754353523, -0.01517513394355774, -0.007005343679338694, -0.01818511076271534, -0.009890933521091938, 0.012177364900708199, 0.05179885774850845, -0.035075604915618896, 0.018200907856225967, 0.018994955345988274, 0.016678035259246826, 0.021113036200404167, -0.0441499687731266, -0.00535128079354763, -0.009843123145401478, 0.00038568765739910305, 0.05240878462791443, -0.0010779787553474307, -0.04761883616447449, -0.005538464058190584, 0.0110366465523839, 0.008411718532443047, 0.008470074273645878, -0.023967096582055092, 0.062170352786779404, 0.041151318699121475, 0.006409503519535065, 0.06981208175420761, 0.01339622214436531, -0.038874879479408264, -0.011956685222685337, -0.054643403738737106, -0.012821529991924763, 0.005824640858918428, -0.044113412499427795, -0.030218834057450294, 0.009694075211882591, -0.03015705570578575, 0.0466853603720665, 0.015282897278666496, 0.050339143723249435, -0.07959111034870148, 0.05419750139117241, 0.016561411321163177, 0.02981811948120594, -0.05600390210747719, 0.013107514940202236, 0.005676346365362406, -0.015802936628460884, 0.002435116795822978, -0.026665713638067245, 0.0459422767162323, -0.00384868448600173, -0.029319165274500847, 0.01598278246819973, -0.032052960246801376, 0.023072777315974236, -0.008300665766000748, -0.02857501246035099, 0.008265882730484009, -0.010846009477972984, 0.024948343634605408, 0.03228552266955376, 0.030097385868430138, -0.002798074157908559, -0.03835966810584068, -0.010014324449002743, 0.0082198865711689, -0.027276961132884026, 0.047960150986909866, -0.005591185763478279, 0.03729304298758507, -0.024243798106908798, -0.00031981203937903047, -0.04785878211259842, -0.06040345877408981, 0.03994613140821457, 0.005145312752574682, -0.020755376666784286, -0.0032479758374392986, 0.03435855731368065, -0.011713437736034393, -0.01825214922428131, -0.007970806211233139, 0.05007476359605789, -0.010909445583820343, 0.014704559929668903, -0.019330346956849098, 0.008358373306691647, 0.05962164327502251, -0.004861070774495602, 0.0251963809132576, 0.028254300355911255, -0.00968805979937315, -0.02564270980656147, 0.027115944772958755, 0.019450893625617027, -0.020494742318987846, -0.02723134122788906, -0.04706326872110367, -0.014333497732877731, 0.06922802329063416, 0.0060568456538021564, -0.027202067896723747, -0.012621830217540264, 0.0013338845456019044, -0.033619362860918045, -0.052868571132421494, -0.012787971645593643, 0.01328176911920309, 0.01066089328378439, -0.0043142419308424, -0.017046410590410233, -0.052282046526670456, -0.018020259216427803, 0.015378948301076889, 0.01778901182115078, -0.021129416301846504, 0.012772581540048122, 0.05811305344104767, -0.019691303372383118, 0.03849881887435913, -0.022845571860671043, -0.01910966821014881, 0.02568613737821579, -0.0010090910363942385, 0.01829058676958084, 0.009311232715845108, 0.037518881261348724, -0.021899474784731865, -0.02834337390959263, -0.02999868616461754, 0.018263379111886024, 0.08437631279230118, -0.044825468212366104, 0.06059688329696655, 0.06660237908363342, -0.007635684683918953, 0.005686517339199781, 0.010617385618388653, -0.02475193329155445, -0.02590193785727024, 0.05012686178088188, 0.030782435089349747, -0.040897127240896225, -0.025643497705459595, 0.04668477177619934, -0.0009824546286836267, 0.002663170453161001, 0.040802452713251114, -0.03069343976676464, 0.04300876334309578, -0.02399730682373047, -0.019550278782844543, -0.04020179808139801, -0.006427323911339045, -0.012999827973544598, 0.03325500711798668, -0.025844871997833252, -0.02749035693705082, 0.0336102694272995, 0.05106203630566597, -0.01095537468791008, -0.06572392582893372, -0.027543039992451668, -0.04332318156957626, -0.01416842732578516, 0.007769604213535786, -0.04740457981824875, 0.004191295709460974, 0.01538375299423933, 0.0479339137673378, 0.0033496692776679993, 0.05002592131495476, -0.039930883795022964, -0.11105046421289444, -0.034851543605327606, 0.003490050323307514, -0.027006465941667557, 0.031664662063121796, 0.005857081618160009, -0.04081105440855026, 0.0005000844830647111, -0.017556453123688698, 0.012672624550759792, 0.012318619526922703, 0.031242849305272102, -0.0215213131159544, 0.04332517087459564, -0.02368973381817341, -0.007818958722054958, 0.01141187734901905, 0.007313354406505823, 0.1067567989230156, 0.0780908614397049, 0.04719117656350136, -0.07168834656476974, 0.02897675335407257, 0.0022331385407596827, 0.01841803640127182, -0.03771281614899635, 0.03846271336078644, 0.0027758560609072447, 0.0013892619172111154, 0.05699693039059639, 0.03345441818237305, 0.0031214552000164986, 0.006337607279419899, 0.05429660156369209, -0.04459034278988838, -0.019508371129631996, -0.017560187727212906, 0.030183928087353706, -0.007647374179214239, -0.027142701670527458, -0.011113614775240421, -0.00011056414223276079, -0.015355273149907589, -0.020886436104774475, -0.019499845802783966, -0.0001437049504602328, -0.004468824248760939, 0.007835720665752888, -0.030230578035116196, 0.023262426257133484, 0.009388837032020092, 0.005767518188804388, 0.015701085329055786, 0.019428692758083344, 0.020222961902618408, -0.07808031141757965, 0.03940965235233307, -0.016073092818260193, -0.005934507120400667, -0.007151184603571892, 0.01710672304034233, 0.029023366048932076, -0.03610359504818916, 0.007854592986404896, -0.02067696303129196, 0.011279229074716568, 0.002625961322337389, 0.014113516546785831, -0.02805754542350769, 0.021397309377789497, 0.00956686120480299, -0.03917521610856056, -0.006711964495480061, 0.00802953727543354, 0.01495512668043375, -0.05299229174852371, 0.009426590986549854, -0.0431336909532547, -0.02438318356871605, -0.02335297130048275, 0.04951014369726181, 0.022709470242261887, -0.02842661924660206, -0.0027720120269805193, -0.054035384207963943, 0.03215136006474495, -0.020742982625961304, 0.010822352021932602, 0.0034982352517545223, 0.0034660559613257647, -0.06298545002937317, -0.010157746262848377, 0.018673254176974297, 0.003491700626909733, 0.018340665847063065, 0.011299863457679749, 0.006648828275501728, -0.029775258153676987, -0.0363922156393528, 0.020988954231142998, -0.0013710143975913525, -0.011652329005300999, -0.05665477737784386, -0.019758937880396843, 0.05181609094142914, 0.008278951048851013, 0.026496633887290955, 0.04153492674231529, -0.022717967629432678, 0.0445251427590847, 0.033857569098472595, -0.023566439747810364, -0.02039928361773491, -0.0026648484636098146, -0.047795116901397705, -0.03635866940021515, -0.040029916912317276, 0.03454964980483055, 0.0070053511299192905, -0.002239583060145378, -0.02781948447227478, 0.002567463554441929, -0.011277548968791962, 0.012899243272840977, -0.008768639527261257, -0.006742609199136496, 0.012003199197351933, 0.005593650043010712, 0.00885179452598095, -0.04782956466078758, 0.007802690379321575, -0.03149280324578285, -0.016445325687527657, 0.01520839985460043, -0.01785978488624096, -0.008288941346108913, 0.011310621164739132, -0.004281103610992432, 0.021986350417137146, -0.02991362102329731, 0.029163271188735962, -0.034869611263275146, 0.005402449518442154, -0.012796105816960335, 0.03630104660987854, -0.012910387478768826, 0.06288901716470718, -0.023031333461403847, 0.03735226392745972, 0.04947466030716896, -0.001023991615511477, 0.01797308959066868, -0.013006005436182022, -0.010623468086123466, -0.0031235504429787397, 0.04473946616053581, 0.0010664815781638026, -0.005880276672542095, 0.020927874371409416, -0.05208811163902283, -0.022016288712620735, -0.009940768592059612, -0.004058570135384798, -0.024215664714574814, 0.0025184324476867914, 0.008339549414813519, -0.0154655110090971, 0.014540833421051502, -0.044429149478673935, -0.012188085354864597, -0.05182885378599167, 0.028276529163122177, 0.04450122267007828, 0.004276617895811796, 0.0008217549184337258, 0.023478535935282707, -0.02389535866677761, 0.021762914955615997, 0.05359889939427376, -0.014871896244585514, 0.0024193429853767157, -0.019249331206083298, -0.003147521987557411, -0.027338506653904915, 0.01727120205760002, -0.0426422543823719, 0.03523457050323486, 0.08895380049943924, -0.03262938931584358, 0.06291935592889786, 0.022473169490695, -0.005523467902094126, -0.08782254159450531, -0.025731515139341354, 0.025841644033789635, -0.022498909384012222, 0.009822440333664417, -0.0435049794614315, -0.015303277410566807, 0.04716794937849045, -0.021639203652739525, 0.06964851915836334, -0.0047037857584655285, 0.0007849382818676531, -0.010826079174876213, 0.050568852573633194, 0.04563303664326668, 0.041450731456279755, 0.02985980547964573, -0.017848750576376915, 0.032098881900310516, 0.03750097379088402, 0.02963131107389927, 0.001753917895257473, -0.017636816948652267, 0.008037257008254528, 0.02358814887702465, -0.07097985595464706, 0.029822563752532005, -0.04795665293931961, -0.022488776594400406, 0.035533059388399124, -0.060306940227746964, 0.05650027096271515, 0.028421716764569283, 0.024225251749157906, -0.03298293799161911, 0.036554284393787384, 0.02753327414393425, -0.03708972781896591, -0.016119949519634247, 0.021389462053775787, 0.020750876516103745, 0.017959607765078545, -0.011826242320239544, 0.010668342001736164, -0.0029653673991560936, -0.005855761002749205, -0.008031541481614113, 0.020645461976528168, -0.016236411407589912, -0.041156038641929626, -0.0057684448547661304, 0.004940116312354803, 0.039151426404714584, 0.010768221691250801, 0.02712712250649929, -0.03150418773293495, -0.004840275272727013, 0.010202617384493351, 0.02357354946434498, -0.0328223891556263, -0.011254250071942806, -0.03380584716796875, -0.026222040876746178, 0.010123781859874725, -0.0013841713080182672, -0.0034052575938403606, -0.05369139090180397, 0.016171760857105255, 0.006007804069668055, -0.02769133448600769, -0.022659851238131523, -0.01037508249282837, -0.003589161904528737, 0.06766410917043686, -0.030425358563661575, -0.02153831720352173, 0.015388905070722103, -0.015381616540253162, -0.003722829045727849, -0.05286695435643196, 0.06225358694791794, 0.00730304978787899, -0.017739590257406235, -0.05949520692229271, -0.001471597352065146, -0.0536465048789978, 0.021525194868445396, 0.07782810926437378, 0.0068444120697677135, 0.03307494893670082, -0.015527589246630669, 0.02892570197582245, -0.016288183629512787, -0.04310724511742592, 0.019607361406087875, -0.012646122835576534, -0.029686100780963898, 0.010381774976849556, 0.01103590801358223, 0.03168044239282608, 0.007450030650943518, -0.018071169033646584, -0.05069815367460251, 0.07518253475427628, 0.006230825092643499, -0.00734297651797533, 0.01286114752292633, 0.020815342664718628, -0.012459143996238708, 0.02483101561665535, -0.03771402686834335, 0.03068147785961628, 0.06408316642045975, -0.01655261032283306, -0.018546469509601593, 0.0485789030790329, -0.029987167567014694, -0.03204679861664772, 0.043377771973609924, -0.005307747982442379, -0.00809798575937748, -0.06730712205171585, -0.0068361335434019566, 0.042152874171733856, -0.03150341287255287, 0.020931918174028397, 0.052051253616809845, 0.014088692143559456, 0.023698249831795692, 0.0015646109823137522, 0.0013943563681095839, 0.0003677377535495907, -0.03846846520900726, -0.00036190400714986026, 0.02390480227768421, 0.0431782491505146, -0.010338111780583858, -0.0022499575279653072, 0.029043879359960556, -0.012435008771717548, 0.027622520923614502, -0.036689672619104385, 0.03859136253595352, -0.030680645257234573, -0.01903856173157692, 0.0049140420742332935, -0.02047320455312729, 0.0030001152772456408, 0.011880864389240742, -0.009649410843849182, 0.020329877734184265, -0.052128441631793976, -0.008390825241804123, -0.02148963324725628, -0.01470643188804388, -0.009398186579346657, 0.011890830472111702, -0.012839601375162601, 0.017751727253198624, 0.0027590570971369743, -0.009445177391171455, 0.007521618157625198, -0.00018226895190309733, 0.019772345200181007, -0.0029507551807910204, 0.03497736155986786, -0.02379385381937027, 0.011850024573504925, -0.04049251601099968, 0.005139944143593311, -0.023310361430048943, -0.0037496837321668863, 0.02542656660079956, 0.0257106926292181, 0.019209228456020355, -0.0034472288098186255, -0.011563563719391823, -0.00925880204886198, 0.05950859561562538, -0.0610128715634346, -0.025724586099386215, -0.031045451760292053, 0.01159458328038454, 0.004262223374098539, 0.00728126335889101 ]
<p>I manipulate in R time series that can present <strong>revisions</strong>. I use in general the package 'xts' but it doesn't support revisions.</p> <p>Is there a package that deals with that?</p> <p>Alternatively, is there a best practice to store and manipulate revisions?</p>
36,687
[ 0.029091326519846916, 0.027759404852986336, -0.0017501113470643759, -0.0022650877945125103, 0.01109570637345314, 0.0267277043312788, -0.016116658225655556, -0.006696028634905815, -0.01541148778051138, -0.026841426268219948, 0.03013206459581852, 0.08324085175991058, 0.039348386228084564, 0.005948734004050493, 0.00789892952889204, -0.03344521299004555, -0.00485180364921689, -0.020365893840789795, -0.01432971190661192, -0.010947956703603268, -0.019390998408198357, -0.0020273777190595865, -0.04016433283686638, 0.006859592627733946, 0.005939573515206575, 0.02105015702545643, 0.028125856071710587, 0.02194739691913128, -0.02600245364010334, 0.07894134521484375, -0.06119581684470177, -0.028533486649394035, -0.003015084657818079, 0.051620446145534515, -0.004674050956964493, -0.01824958622455597, -0.013386785052716732, -0.062451619654893875, -0.006650825496762991, 0.0282625462859869, -0.03304934874176979, 0.019983680918812752, -0.002124055754393339, 0.055139169096946716, -0.038340065628290176, 0.03515227884054184, -0.010927381925284863, 0.014086229726672173, 0.03799055144190788, -0.015772785991430283, 0.034641869366168976, -0.021098345518112183, 0.0070524620823562145, 0.04862716421484947, -0.05499628558754921, 0.03592871502041817, 0.044590629637241364, 0.053621724247932434, 0.006833604536950588, -0.039904408156871796, -0.007569628302007914, -0.01343894749879837, -0.000285125570371747, -0.028593918308615685, -0.04395138844847679, 0.025071797892451286, -0.01625463180243969, -0.027327219024300575, 0.01784072443842888, -0.05616194009780884, 0.014998230151832104, 0.00570646533742547, 0.010182419791817665, 0.014779526740312576, 0.008017897605895996, -0.05491989478468895, 0.026414664462208748, -0.019614694640040398, 0.057891566306352615, 0.0587630458176136, 0.007437486667186022, 0.03611188009381294, 0.031821802258491516, -0.026939311996102333, -0.002737822476774454, -0.007842851802706718, 0.0937638059258461, -0.014973408542573452, 0.01728740893304348, 0.03492005914449692, 0.01133194100111723, -0.03089619241654873, 0.051068633794784546, -0.013385419733822346, -0.02878377214074135, -0.015744969248771667, -0.03307220712304115, 0.04709021374583244, -0.04823481664061546, 0.005305567756295204, -0.001550485729239881, -0.04844865947961807, 0.024813922122120857, 0.041951440274715424, -0.018748674541711807, -0.03036232478916645, -0.013821154832839966, -0.06397534161806107, -0.0249231718480587, -0.046151187270879745, 0.013652922585606575, -0.022489827126264572, -0.02816978469491005, 0.020473724231123924, -0.009475368075072765, 0.004322922322899103, -0.018656285479664803, -0.03765767812728882, 0.07662265747785568, 0.07905278354883194, 0.07630223780870438, -0.03232579678297043, 0.03489374369382858, -0.026821009814739227, -0.05277811735868454, 0.05179014801979065, -0.0008057216764427722, -0.001992500387132168, -0.0515829399228096, 0.05927710235118866, -0.017427001148462296, -0.042127665132284164, 0.044659677892923355, -0.010794628411531448, 0.03387797251343727, 0.0022578651551157236, -0.08711884915828705, -0.06602735072374344, 0.030208883807063103, -0.017631908878684044, -0.01728585548698902, -0.07445912063121796, 0.03220212459564209, 0.03700866177678108, 0.04336834326386452, 0.018782155588269234, 0.012607560493052006, 0.06449005007743835, 0.02475019358098507, 0.01197801437228918, -0.052960559725761414, 0.011087005957961082, 0.012066613882780075, -0.015807056799530983, -0.023599958047270775, -0.05656702071428299, 0.04476221278309822, 0.04930713027715683, -0.010253363288939, 0.01424142811447382, 0.0374404601752758, -0.008642774075269699, 0.008769320324063301, -0.012496579438447952, 0.030624454841017723, -0.042657334357500076, 0.10665981471538544, -0.021551912650465965, 0.020819751545786858, 0.008055050857365131, -0.00034215222694911063, 0.02307548187673092, 0.020797230303287506, 0.04180173575878143, 0.002087563741952181, 0.0012724061962217093, -0.01496312115341425, 0.009231489151716232, -0.05748816207051277, 0.027440641075372696, -0.018297655507922173, -0.011681786738336086, -0.0042356583289802074, -0.039005301892757416, 0.03454533591866493, 0.030454058200120926, -0.007277484051883221, -0.0076472037471830845, 0.025884633883833885, -0.06969635933637619, -0.025939276441931725, -0.04530004784464836, 0.021402105689048767, -0.03431650251150131, -0.00562444981187582, 0.004642347805202007, -0.013454724103212357, 0.03190687671303749, 0.002861796645447612, -0.0363759770989418, -0.018001142889261246, 0.012167156673967838, 0.01941254734992981, -0.05616509169340134, -0.034967102110385895, 0.01645781472325325, 0.041819456964731216, -0.024176757782697678, 0.02326865680515766, 0.008795822970569134, -0.061395615339279175, 0.022422073408961296, -0.08306503295898438, 0.026912186294794083, -0.019251681864261627, -0.022970853373408318, -0.0075243436731398106, 0.008137080818414688, -0.010794712230563164, 0.008142040111124516, -0.03825944662094116, 0.010336245410144329, 0.05497278645634651, 0.004072447307407856, 0.028206614777445793, -0.016397759318351746, -0.008219501003623009, 0.011567998677492142, 0.010319708846509457, -0.013639001175761223, -0.06487160176038742, 0.019801734015345573, 0.04544059932231903, 0.03581788018345833, -0.022522734478116035, 0.03982752561569214, 0.0308124627918005, 0.00016654115461278707, 0.03366706147789955, 0.04351465031504631, -0.0013867138186469674, -0.009062054567039013, 0.024063149467110634, -0.03398984298110008, 0.044056836515665054, 0.008790410123765469, 0.0026511603500694036, 0.0008168917265720665, 0.023737609386444092, 0.010667357593774796, -0.006472246255725622, -0.005131599958986044, 0.0004233326471876353, -0.023534884676337242, -0.00949828326702118, -0.03524935245513916, 0.06379130482673645, -0.02335355430841446, 0.013373460620641708, 0.017759529873728752, 0.028485257178544998, 0.022774796932935715, 0.05880823731422424, 0.013648438267409801, 0.02804250456392765, 0.0010958294151350856, -0.04977623000741005, -0.01351386308670044, 0.01479187048971653, -0.0074448296800255775, 0.034581251442432404, -0.051457516849040985, -0.01367751695215702, -0.01619763858616352, 0.012200052849948406, 0.03499174863100052, 0.007556968834251165, 0.01584077626466751, -0.00789558794349432, -0.010196981020271778, -0.0015498241409659386, 0.0013852810952812433, 0.007478763815015554, 0.02032969519495964, -0.0014728173846378922, 0.01741822436451912, 0.013671976514160633, -0.038767509162425995, 0.010924659669399261, -0.011203780770301819, -0.0032391168642789125, 0.03368278965353966, -0.01383356936275959, -0.05008980631828308, -0.04060019552707672, -0.006429316475987434, -0.004861928056925535, -0.018381379544734955, -0.02638222835958004, 0.015076576732099056, 0.010380876250565052, -0.007938889786601067, 0.01332898996770382, -0.06098821759223938, 0.02736608125269413, -0.03968822583556175, 0.009226193651556969, 0.02348245307803154, -0.01078192051500082, -0.025099709630012512, 0.054489199072122574, -0.012302400544285774, -0.025046013295650482, -0.059164196252822876, -0.042990632355213165, -0.006482954137027264, -0.023703835904598236, 0.033092088997364044, -0.024547327309846878, -0.013158906251192093, 0.015568233095109463, 0.0026614663656800985, -0.0003524099010974169, -0.035763319581747055, 0.0031345339957624674, -0.010343416593968868, -0.06585654616355896, 0.013693147338926792, -0.01329069398343563, -0.0076950364746153355, -0.01711675524711609, 0.0009501272579655051, 0.0016856309957802296, 0.047983888536691666, 0.02088373340666294, -0.03855375945568085, 0.003139085602015257, -0.023207539692521095, 0.052981581538915634, 0.007690357510000467, 0.020070755854249, 0.013105538673698902, 0.01336041372269392, -0.019583264365792274, 0.05770222470164299, 0.0062800124287605286, -0.029384437948465347, -0.00237807584926486, 0.00059931306168437, 0.014733328483998775, -0.004776380490511656, 0.045500531792640686, -0.0083578210324049, -0.020154902711510658, -0.039327606558799744, 0.03664637729525566, 0.014739533886313438, -0.013994874432682991, 0.0007225046283565462, 0.019795667380094528, 0.05075891315937042, -0.05806350335478783, -0.008545558899641037, -0.018751615658402443, 0.0028424386400729418, 0.012272744439542294, -0.03353998064994812, 0.02999761700630188, 0.053062114864587784, 0.007995898835361004, 0.028341790661215782, -0.012234707362949848, -0.03348391130566597, 0.029004612937569618, -0.08597909659147263, 0.025092607364058495, 0.0194561630487442, 0.0428321398794651, 0.030572570860385895, 0.04448423907160759, 0.013372555375099182, 0.01428237371146679, 0.03659297525882721, -0.021436773240566254, -0.04006022587418556, 0.03171804919838905, -0.007601753808557987, 0.022078106179833412, 0.01279886718839407, 0.003675076412037015, 0.006954161450266838, -0.006443945690989494, 0.01654077135026455, -0.03084282949566841, -0.010225873440504074, -0.03229561448097229, 0.002686444204300642, -0.017507608979940414, -0.015074721537530422, 0.0003877108683809638, 0.008219138719141483, 0.06964956969022751, -0.0453156903386116, 0.05614569038152695, 0.013628500513732433, 0.002967298962175846, 0.010069713927805424, -0.01860744133591652, -0.010142054408788681, 0.004882930312305689, 0.02283652499318123, 0.028127063065767288, 0.017170578241348267, -0.007772822864353657, 0.03712235391139984, 0.04226388409733772, 0.041028428822755814, 0.03329269215464592, 0.025586707517504692, -0.011768022552132607, -0.0012074626283720136, 0.0038721179589629173, 0.023290323093533516, -0.002808555494993925, -0.01054170448333025, 0.007358754053711891, 0.05640384554862976, 0.04142331704497337, -0.05681128054857254, 0.008797351270914078, 0.03470980376005173, 0.01755361631512642, 0.0031568193808197975, 0.006765157449990511, 0.00043724896386265755, 0.01208833884447813, -0.013100603595376015, 0.010417969897389412, 0.02946510538458824, 0.007342484313994646, 0.020835870876908302, -0.014818371273577213, 0.0016991195734590292, -0.0824342593550682, 0.005311792716383934, 0.004837397951632738, 0.034379687160253525, 0.021673500537872314, 0.04546768218278885, 0.032905980944633484, 0.0526258647441864, 0.001016431488096714, 0.03235052525997162, -0.005178503692150116, -0.10548991709947586, 0.03605009987950325, 0.057637326419353485, 0.04034141078591347, -0.012061217799782753, -0.04539700597524643, -0.06450118124485016, -0.048817139118909836, 0.0526222363114357, -0.03834319859743118, 0.008165366016328335, -0.01581965573132038, 0.007825259119272232, -0.05774925649166107, -0.0245825108140707, -0.006610044278204441, 0.024196816608309746, -0.041787054389715195, 0.07441796362400055, 0.013188398443162441, 0.0022442720364779234, -0.015579200349748135, 0.023571794852614403, -0.009589121676981449, 0.03465612977743149, 0.01964692771434784, -0.025132421404123306, 0.02453051693737507, 0.014110797084867954, -0.03891318663954735, -0.04400975629687309, -0.0011854463955387473, 0.023958029225468636, -0.0016000429168343544, 0.03464268893003464, 0.014972302131354809, -0.017463086172938347, 0.03211600333452225, 0.01695934124290943, -0.009525617584586143, 0.020741384476423264, -0.0021396540105342865, 0.04859860986471176, 0.040669359266757965, -0.008455322124063969, 0.06512913852930069, 0.07791171222925186, 0.005659700836986303, 0.0030726268887519836, -0.010225290432572365, 0.004441700875759125, -0.02593328431248665, -0.008057274855673313, -0.04769667237997055, -0.03295804560184479, -0.06035089120268822, -0.0037814867682754993, 0.001337244058959186, 0.031820643693208694, 0.012303631752729416, 0.0012569662649184465, 0.019018258899450302, 0.062420573085546494, 0.015584261156618595, -0.01884358935058117, 0.027277439832687378, -0.0049000754952430725, -0.05043802410364151, 0.022173061966896057, 0.0032805853988975286, -0.022129401564598083, -0.04493049159646034, 0.0456048958003521, -0.05172546207904816, 0.00915685947984457, -0.004452040418982506, -0.028027711436152458, -0.012488176114857197, 0.0032594765070825815, 0.041982825845479965, -0.00957775954157114, 0.030951740220189095, 0.021790144965052605, -0.046348556876182556, 0.028027454391121864, 0.031170958653092384, -0.015283860266208649, 0.0018284975085407495, -0.0734119787812233, 0.05695382505655289, -0.006454852409660816, 0.03841644898056984, -0.04767703637480736, -0.05121723562479019, 0.021173669025301933, -0.01117828581482172, -0.05822478234767914, -0.03197093680500984, 0.01345464400947094, -0.0078025879338383675, 0.012334933504462242, -0.029724016785621643, 0.036116909235715866, -0.01970820315182209, -0.007549368776381016, -0.02509291097521782, 0.04635890945792198, 0.07866934686899185, 0.0020847374107688665, 0.0153547627851367, 0.021231641992926598, -0.008418180979788303, -0.01955772377550602, -0.02179395779967308, 0.009403559379279613, -0.017149532213807106, -0.006548032164573669, -0.001480025239288807, 0.009799353778362274, 0.04583565518260002, -0.01382367592304945, 0.007415488362312317, 0.07955320179462433, -0.02821182645857334, 0.033862192183732986, -0.05939168110489845, -0.010820582509040833, -0.06947940587997437, 0.009871473535895348, -0.06290093809366226, 0.011370700784027576, 0.030877111479640007, -0.04073779284954071, -0.007035472895950079, -0.026508323848247528, -0.037327442318201065, 0.01845288649201393, 0.06623200327157974, -0.00942831952124834, 0.017792312428355217, 7.776340567033913e-7, -0.03349030390381813, 0.015886258333921432, 0.013601274229586124, 0.021699894219636917, 0.009172930382192135, -0.03916788101196289, -0.050678499042987823, -0.022502485662698746, 0.00863719917833805, -0.0008009578450582922, 0.03930860385298729, -0.04131872206926346, 0.025909213349223137, 0.02306251786649227, 0.003540166188031435, 0.022550705820322037, -0.014195107854902744, -0.029751727357506752, -0.0073026735335588455, -0.009735828265547752, 0.06282800436019897, -0.00029421018552966416, 0.026233239099383354, 0.019571110606193542, 0.015943048521876335, 0.014026978053152561, 0.03985601291060448, 0.013777622953057289, -0.017050618305802345, 0.012427907437086105, -0.0292500127106905, -0.03637677803635597, 0.014234816655516624, -0.05121638998389244, 0.010492297820746899, -0.0027879979461431503, -0.010438702069222927, 0.006181048229336739, -0.0042813788168132305, 0.02929268404841423, -0.024404380470514297, -0.03269515931606293, -0.05688032507896423, -0.01437546405941248, 0.007593114860355854, -0.023596545681357384, 0.020800717175006866, 0.006485462188720703, 0.06412447243928909, -0.004227213561534882, 0.027041055262088776, -0.03130422905087471, -0.08654162287712097, 0.0040908390656113625, 0.004625882022082806, -0.01814870350062847, 0.04256792366504669, 0.006043039727956057, 0.006099100690335035, 0.007082486990839243, -0.03659486398100853, 0.01621631719172001, -0.020484844222664833, 0.04574287310242653, 0.012729471549391747, 0.07312195003032684, -0.02833627350628376, 0.014453736133873463, -0.019516702741384506, -0.010269095189869404, 0.14249588549137115, 0.07987429201602936, 0.0637642964720726, -0.04555555060505867, 0.015160749666392803, 0.019805781543254852, 0.0193875003606081, 0.002860067179426551, 0.011949781328439713, 0.016689538955688477, -0.011859125457704067, 0.02046188712120056, 0.06693236529827118, -0.011716878972947598, 0.0010529238497838378, 0.03957781195640564, -0.04538671299815178, 0.021059511229395866, 0.00108133046887815, 0.01345487404614687, 0.0006803672877140343, -0.018178634345531464, -0.09984048455953598, -0.0062116049230098724, 0.015520084649324417, -0.047012463212013245, -0.01682441309094429, -0.02901201695203781, 0.004322097636759281, 0.02166309766471386, -0.021479103714227676, 0.015862444415688515, 0.010175426490604877, 0.05791998282074928, 0.03544678911566734, -0.009793861769139767, -0.008595976047217846, 0.01225289050489664, 0.041938185691833496, 0.06844109296798706, -0.01713077910244465, -0.002790893195196986, -0.018538184463977814, 0.022511037066578865, -0.023285917937755585, -0.033435288816690445, -0.07048574835062027, 0.01842191256582737, -0.01627846620976925, 0.008756272494792938, -0.027565956115722656, -0.004919152241200209, 0.004006589762866497, -0.014413020573556423, -0.023441504687070847, 0.0277818962931633, 0.009925920516252518, 0.0029939457308501005, -0.012856720015406609, 0.00003791463313973509, 0.017987806349992752, -0.024056678637862206, 0.031105242669582367, 0.04880306124687195, -0.07536125928163528, 0.013742595911026001, -0.023804573342204094, 0.003967987839132547, -0.023779308423399925, 0.0008649630472064018, -0.007103237323462963, -0.013916403986513615, -0.011015773750841618, -0.0390847772359848, 0.0321466438472271, -0.017822716385126114, -0.007080970797687769, -0.012963575311005116, 0.004552009049803019, -0.006392674520611763, -0.028256123885512352, 0.033224090933799744, -0.02666545659303665, -0.03946910426020622, -0.008300023153424263, 0.004018919076770544, 0.056728117167949677, 0.004022172652184963, 0.0283406563103199, 0.018787961453199387, -0.01784648932516575, 0.02762688137590885, 0.039028655737638474, -0.06750522553920746, 0.000864336034283042, 0.02570938691496849, -0.03878848999738693, -0.020578550174832344, -0.03406166285276413, 0.07962645590305328, 0.006600890774279833, 0.008919322863221169, 0.006169845350086689, 0.03580634295940399, 0.001841458841226995, 0.008766207844018936, 0.020604323595762253, -0.06894814968109131, -0.012400518171489239, -0.004561770241707563, -0.04383407160639763, -0.041650544852018356, -0.018410172313451767, -0.03243388235569, 0.015399422496557236, -0.022795045748353004, -0.017450112849473953, -0.058086540549993515, 0.04794899746775627, -0.015188604593276978, 0.019350558519363403, -0.010441338643431664, 0.02231052704155445, -0.02307097055017948, -0.03532746061682701, 0.002128648804500699, -0.008309992961585522, -0.0012852158397436142, 0.021295111626386642, -0.02217021770775318, 0.005667559336870909, 0.017339346930384636, -0.006232889834791422, 0.019447535276412964, 0.006408628076314926, -0.038345273584127426, 0.030701270326972008, 0.02409236505627632, -0.040248803794384, -0.07205981016159058, 0.0353153720498085, -0.05623052269220352, -0.01405048556625843, 0.010691088624298573, -0.018908360973000526, 0.01567184552550316, 0.007853700779378414, -0.003324528457596898, -0.01144539937376976, 0.02765066735446453, -0.022428521886467934, -0.0023252370301634073, 0.01913985051214695, 0.05028391256928444, 0.006006783340126276, 0.0007447231328114867, 0.025658370926976204, 0.012422844767570496, 0.0022875771392136812, 0.012217633426189423, 0.042731329798698425, 0.011676621623337269, -0.018880486488342285, -0.007803859189152718, -0.01494063250720501, 0.02787967026233673, 0.01042582280933857, -0.043805789202451706, 0.06840615719556808, 0.024116966873407364, -0.050119515508413315, -0.003040734212845564, 0.004340740852057934, -0.013662884943187237, -0.06730720400810242, 0.005067350342869759, 0.008538476191461086, -0.013512779958546162, 0.017349492758512497, -0.03828848525881767, 0.026286806911230087, 0.01478872075676918, -0.009497549384832382, 0.014378893189132214, -0.021246934309601784, -0.0011764379451051354, -0.012738244608044624, 0.0016478166216984391, -0.03305722028017044, 0.03860243037343025, 0.05021220073103905, 0.006498659495264292, 0.024313831701874733, -0.002987117040902376, 0.02878149412572384, -0.040411241352558136, -0.01269947923719883, 0.003237929893657565, 0.015025944449007511, -0.053532831370830536, 0.05899358540773392, -0.042137663811445236, -0.033301882445812225, 0.010836086235940456, -0.019909091293811798, -0.012146648950874805, -0.0028671487234532833, -0.00525645911693573, -0.00855746865272522, 0.05298910662531853, 0.022308940067887306, -0.025322359055280685, -0.022063499316573143, -0.02112310193479061, 0.012795616872608662, 0.03400442376732826, -0.0016754503594711423, -0.002825142815709114, 0.008405647240579128, -0.026631826534867287, -0.003537409473210573, 0.0025498552713543177, -0.016398439183831215, -0.01593923009932041, -0.01442502997815609, -0.00782894529402256, 0.010975216515362263, 0.0028573728632181883, 0.01405094563961029, -0.01359613984823227, 0.02325071394443512, 0.046857163310050964, -0.011747677810490131, -0.02317870408296585, 0.018896766006946564, -0.008366537280380726, -0.04562157019972801, 0.006490347441285849, -0.008492345921695232, -0.004325799643993378, -0.055580683052539825, -0.016298091039061546, 0.00921204499900341, -0.0029267934150993824, -0.050228316336870193, 0.030392101034522057, -0.014405835419893265, 0.057314109057188034, -0.0018099291482940316, -0.00948285311460495, -0.004151483997702599, 0.00019132117449771613, 0.02955629862844944, -0.07855747640132904, 0.03518422693014145, 0.008916663937270641, -0.03189662843942642, -0.02246629260480404, -0.014621340669691563, -0.04701659828424454, 0.04624481499195099, 0.05036291852593422, -0.0065877921879291534, 0.0023888887371867895, 0.008111587725579739, 0.055621881037950516, 0.03484226390719414, -0.032749224454164505, 0.057840775698423386, -0.035354919731616974, -0.0268554650247097, 0.00598849868401885, -0.029451819136738777, 0.012923513539135456, 0.041579026728868484, 0.028737708926200867, -0.02598557434976101, -0.00505065405741334, 0.02896166406571865, 0.004878579638898373, 0.026579882949590683, 0.0007013262948021293, -0.07098232954740524, -0.007761169690638781, 0.015552939847111702, 0.004002428147941828, 0.029189949855208397, 0.01825729012489319, -0.021394211798906326, 0.00964221078902483, -0.06599483639001846, -0.04257497936487198, 0.004906949121505022, -0.025140613317489624, -0.022031908854842186, -0.04213233292102814, -0.027412498369812965, 0.029584236443042755, -0.03503056988120079, 0.040570396929979324, 0.02974317967891693, 0.003730455646291375, 0.05453070253133774, 0.04461466521024704, 0.02939138002693653, 0.004044162575155497, -0.01942341960966587, -0.007881490513682365, 0.005231358576565981, 0.02745126187801361, -0.0002284775982843712, 0.0026174283120781183, 0.0052452231757342815, -0.015758419409394264, 0.012581282295286655, -0.005283272359520197, 0.059623755514621735, -0.0237666554749012, 0.0023965986911207438, 0.01142941415309906, -0.021248076111078262, 0.015610741451382637, 0.0015667987754568458, -0.014081796631217003, 0.03361609950661659, -0.04054778441786766, -0.00005980022979201749, -0.06578096002340317, -0.0023657395504415035, -0.016889000311493874, 0.018142009153962135, 0.017356855794787407, 0.02750428020954132, 0.00008267898374469951, 0.013192038983106613, -0.0028951552230864763, 0.004694846458733082, 0.017632190138101578, -0.023433925583958626, 0.0011107382597401738, -0.013024874962866306, -0.01354492548853159, -0.020024344325065613, -0.019049543887376785, -0.014172788709402084, -0.03489667549729347, 0.01780060864984989, -0.000736292393412441, 0.00860340055078268, -0.012457435950636864, -0.023231402039527893, -0.004153237212449312, -0.02663939632475376, -0.08663012832403183, -0.001599184121005237, -0.010011682286858559, 0.024331646040081978, -0.009985771961510181, -0.010909329168498516 ]
<p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/qTI9v.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>How can I calculate the mean of the first schema? I don't have the individual values of the sample. Std. Deviation (B) is 0.6441.</p>
74,048
[ -0.045762933790683746, -0.027888223528862, -0.0039063370786607265, 0.03040740266442299, 0.003696921281516552, -0.014424234628677368, 0.0018919366411864758, -0.033256303519010544, 0.013932130299508572, -0.01781981624662876, 0.07926604896783829, 0.03366868942975998, 0.00995034258812666, 0.055437006056308746, 0.015347626060247421, 0.006359202787280083, 0.017666053026914597, 0.0035878862254321575, -0.006791091524064541, -0.017854809761047363, 0.021048760041594505, -0.0181655865162611, 0.03177770972251892, -0.021247688680887222, -0.021584931761026382, 0.06085827201604843, 0.029570279642939568, -0.021335676312446594, 0.008377648890018463, 0.06606414914131165, -0.025528931990265846, -0.03954285755753517, 0.019068477675318718, -0.005135225597769022, 0.06363356113433838, -0.007073435001075268, -0.06862205266952515, 0.007773722521960735, -0.0038569793105125427, 0.024094102904200554, -0.008552593179047108, 0.02107441984117031, -0.02033817395567894, 0.04428607597947121, -0.002267222385853529, -0.006707902532070875, 0.008199489675462246, -0.043514225631952286, 0.026812657713890076, -0.036028265953063965, 0.07010951638221741, -0.025142081081867218, 0.03618859499692917, 0.021929781883955002, -0.023966271430253983, 0.018824046477675438, 0.03232488036155701, 0.03932872414588928, 0.03693188726902008, -0.025116601958870888, 0.023858986794948578, -0.0052405307069420815, 0.018513035029172897, 0.01736188307404518, -0.03677738830447197, -0.00973191112279892, -0.019341444596648216, -0.05310201272368431, 0.04665868356823921, 0.01989118754863739, 0.038861215114593506, 0.028002560138702393, 0.024071546271443367, -0.025247203186154366, 0.03723941743373871, -0.022894971072673798, -0.019696157425642014, 0.0091367457062006, 0.044269535690546036, 0.012967475689947605, 0.028522273525595665, -0.0011927809100598097, 0.04471249505877495, 0.013737068511545658, 0.022179750725626945, -0.03557511791586876, 0.0951845571398735, 0.01824306882917881, -0.038790054619312286, 0.0092674121260643, -0.0008958239923231304, -0.007591841742396355, 0.055448852479457855, -0.005065134726464748, -0.04644595831632614, 0.050935402512550354, -0.030927151441574097, 0.059262800961732864, -0.013702597469091415, -0.024616487324237823, -0.0002301148051628843, -0.03748199716210365, 0.04527207836508751, 0.013142266310751438, -0.04963017255067825, -0.010876387357711792, -0.005809670779854059, 0.03411812335252762, -0.01103175338357687, -0.02998911216855049, 0.019128676503896713, 0.041681788861751556, 0.020301194861531258, 0.020291557535529137, -0.006384353153407574, -0.0295033548027277, -0.009916667826473713, 0.013767214491963387, 0.0009023853344842792, 0.06701840460300446, 0.03646824508905411, -0.016390053555369377, 0.004071590956300497, 0.0035356590524315834, -0.062130577862262726, -0.011779597960412502, 0.01658397726714611, -0.020787276327610016, -0.04782968759536743, 0.05412478372454643, -0.02288614772260189, 0.00783402007073164, 0.06467507779598236, -0.015448235906660557, 0.006259986199438572, -0.03026185929775238, -0.07251434773206711, -0.06378623843193054, 0.024171089753508568, -0.02203504368662834, -0.012502851895987988, -0.05673684924840927, 0.021838277578353882, 0.06768860667943954, 0.012445766478776932, 0.03505667671561241, 0.017605295404791832, -0.021360309794545174, 0.03666550666093826, 0.03290548548102379, -0.030339742079377174, -0.02914278581738472, -0.027551624923944473, 0.006323313340544701, -0.013017533347010612, -0.07735852897167206, -0.03268825635313988, -0.010389495640993118, -0.020959898829460144, -0.009802911430597305, 0.014779114164412022, 0.025266140699386597, -0.001947761862538755, 0.00045344323734752834, 0.03070850856602192, -0.022536683827638626, 0.0880034938454628, 0.01747477613389492, 0.026120176538825035, 0.005286511033773422, 0.01770864985883236, 0.02327338419854641, 0.0014648644719272852, 0.016350114718079567, 0.032701119780540466, 0.011557106859982014, 0.0258721262216568, 0.020981045439839363, 0.057296909391880035, 0.014145671389997005, -0.05903472378849983, -0.03424294292926788, 0.0027430569753050804, 0.0202341265976429, 0.03355284035205841, 0.03844175487756729, -0.018896427005529404, -0.03986377641558647, 0.004056363366544247, -0.02573155239224434, -0.018568627536296844, -0.06561358273029327, -0.030176403000950813, 0.0001471726136514917, -0.026217369362711906, -0.010642323642969131, 0.015264108777046204, 0.03592289239168167, 0.002237066626548767, -0.010387890040874481, -0.027718424797058105, -0.030415741726756096, 0.03901486098766327, -0.021412041038274765, -0.015589891001582146, 0.06668111681938171, 0.06152883917093277, -0.04913735017180443, 0.03147851303219795, -0.025934189558029175, -0.03064833953976631, 0.00498410826548934, -0.032929908484220505, 0.020489726215600967, -0.04159066453576088, 0.005802363622933626, 0.001857856521382928, 0.039265524595975876, 0.005830463021993637, 0.000804292387329042, -0.041488632559776306, 0.05511609464883804, 0.05193255469202995, 0.02752627804875374, -0.00575945945456624, 0.009544311091303825, 0.06756702810525894, 0.035309288650751114, 0.00009725768177304417, -0.030588971450924873, -0.03769447281956673, 0.029766982421278954, 0.028392255306243896, 0.01136943232268095, -0.0015856262762099504, -0.022002220153808594, 0.05555177852511406, -0.013923660852015018, 0.0315362922847271, 0.013877934776246548, -0.016002442687749863, 0.0165422186255455, 0.012983166612684727, 0.018222160637378693, 0.01739306002855301, 0.0055609275586903095, 0.005313759669661522, -0.004255868960171938, 0.025559375062584877, 0.02573288604617119, -0.006686071399599314, 0.021878721192479134, 0.004297018516808748, -0.014281528070569038, -0.01963292434811592, -0.0008851121529005468, 0.06961588561534882, -0.017867233604192734, -0.009554438292980194, 0.052203092724084854, -0.020584892481565475, -0.033634547144174576, 0.013928213156759739, -0.020385457202792168, 0.024222029373049736, 0.037885647267103195, -0.0001602079428266734, 0.003803722793236375, 0.026683414354920387, -0.03406156226992607, 0.016080526635050774, -0.01853770762681961, -0.026108091697096825, -0.0035372888669371605, -0.000008173880814865697, -0.010284632444381714, -0.0315435566008091, 0.03305598348379135, -0.029079675674438477, 0.025488652288913727, -0.014209859073162079, 0.01316305436193943, -0.0322750099003315, -0.02495947666466236, -0.07847335189580917, 0.03017713688313961, 0.008879438042640686, -0.015265381895005703, 0.0003800120030064136, 0.009744858369231224, -0.026126738637685776, 0.05380864813923836, 0.006760870572179556, -0.05070806294679642, -0.014771477319300175, 0.017018554732203484, -0.0010502423392608762, -0.018085284158587456, 0.004289636854082346, 0.029778404161334038, 0.04209291562438011, -0.008269615471363068, 0.027659889310598373, -0.058351147919893265, -0.07534662634134293, -0.041580699384212494, 0.014739674516022205, 0.026719726622104645, -0.004434423521161079, 0.006384943146258593, -0.023286351934075356, -0.022956959903240204, 0.008292919024825096, -0.04510267823934555, -0.04651954770088196, 0.03507593274116516, -0.0019518419867381454, -0.0010356884449720383, -0.016953062266111374, -0.04842159152030945, 0.08391650766134262, 0.03933388367295265, -0.04563384875655174, -0.03399258852005005, -0.011798717081546783, 0.024190591648221016, -0.04153386130928993, 0.010172202251851559, 0.0139678455889225, -0.008409591391682625, -0.0027345416601747274, 0.01696181483566761, 0.03712042421102524, 0.06345831602811813, -0.034779928624629974, -0.0023801405914127827, 0.0215974859893322, 0.022543083876371384, -0.011902191676199436, 0.08774659037590027, 0.018960097804665565, 0.006187081336975098, 0.027656570076942444, -0.00929506029933691, 0.04387456923723221, 0.00883819442242384, -0.051634375005960464, 0.012716741301119328, 0.005743819288909435, -0.0063705965876579285, -0.031815849244594574, 0.0431448370218277, -0.0035928369034081697, 0.0025713713839650154, -0.01857032999396324, 0.014254778623580933, 0.00677633797749877, -0.00036885225563310087, -0.011794863268733025, 0.09381265938282013, 0.023519910871982574, -0.019461987540125847, -0.011957313865423203, 0.01695704087615013, -0.010121352970600128, 0.01878165453672409, -0.027201630175113678, -0.05082298442721367, 0.02703215181827545, 0.09090600162744522, 0.03135129064321518, -0.013359573669731617, -0.03477716073393822, -0.012624845840036869, -0.09192823618650436, -0.004815009888261557, -0.027874557301402092, 0.04946168139576912, 0.011216200888156891, 0.03077523037791252, 0.0016184241976588964, -0.0010825679637491703, 0.0056109800934791565, -0.0002952870854642242, -0.02810211107134819, 0.05437270924448967, 0.006681667175143957, -0.022840134799480438, -0.012888669967651367, -0.03550458326935768, 0.01881982386112213, -0.027023039758205414, 0.014789054170250893, -0.010989205911755562, 0.010296210646629333, -0.056092653423547745, -0.007475248072296381, -0.0017345169326290488, 0.04887872561812401, 0.0038479845970869064, 0.03760641813278198, 0.007211756426841021, -0.033411238342523575, -0.004285149276256561, 0.0341559462249279, 0.01816684752702713, -0.031391434371471405, -0.024357466027140617, 0.01860848441720009, -0.012663201428949833, 0.025756455957889557, 0.03782149404287338, 0.014356550760567188, -0.058347057551145554, 0.009058400057256222, -0.00304295402020216, 0.04733366519212723, 0.06453859061002731, 0.002843596739694476, -0.015734391286969185, -0.02212238684296608, -0.019441772252321243, 0.007359244395047426, -0.0038285593036562204, 0.005588923115283251, -0.004194207489490509, 0.05527399852871895, 0.01721927523612976, -0.04339957237243652, 0.012048609554767609, 0.05988093465566635, 0.02126331441104412, 0.024167578667402267, -0.061784178018569946, -0.03105047717690468, -0.007850324735045433, -0.033780310302972794, 0.04916345328092575, 0.03741282597184181, 0.011635297909379005, -0.031094461679458618, 0.05002386122941971, -0.0027449417393654585, -0.06343179941177368, -0.01821785606443882, -0.005471661686897278, 0.01451154425740242, -0.011434388346970081, -0.0033687998075038195, 0.02787073887884617, 0.03006121516227722, 0.029515886679291725, -0.007297799456864595, 0.009658955037593842, -0.06980741769075394, 0.0015529782976955175, -0.009421574883162975, 0.033982280641794205, -0.04087109491229057, -0.028357401490211487, -0.02164926566183567, -0.013488229364156723, 0.03355934098362923, -0.03276820108294487, 0.025375863537192345, 0.004720753524452448, 0.04156798496842384, -0.01636573113501072, -0.010046038776636124, -0.023254813626408577, 0.014353455975651741, -0.03468446061015129, 0.035206470638513565, -0.025734664872288704, -0.03794563561677933, -0.028528748080134392, 0.01526050828397274, 0.033470213413238525, 0.019168848171830177, -0.043005235493183136, 0.0033180213067680597, -0.004455271176993847, 0.02032761462032795, -0.03338172659277916, -0.06444101780653, -0.01821254938840866, -0.010998164303600788, -0.032640907913446426, 0.020349523052573204, -0.03574714809656143, -0.05058637261390686, 0.00678239855915308, -0.009263331070542336, -0.019056450575590134, -0.013777201063930988, -0.01188572309911251, 0.029425324872136116, 0.03580163046717644, 0.014913056045770645, 0.05752474442124367, -0.005534753203392029, 0.024046720936894417, -0.005646544508635998, -0.0237308070063591, -0.009419708512723446, 0.008264395408332348, -0.020771993324160576, -0.047648705542087555, -0.0010218169772997499, -0.03045477718114853, 0.0036391515750437975, -0.006971884053200483, 0.019970446825027466, -0.017489688470959663, 0.003454923164099455, 0.015607178211212158, 0.017499126493930817, 0.022298576310276985, -0.01359069999307394, 0.024389732629060745, 0.0008018205408006907, -0.017309321090579033, -0.06467034667730331, 0.038694366812705994, -0.060578860342502594, -0.023947833105921745, 0.003969576209783554, -0.024531159549951553, 0.03842097148299217, -0.04941932111978531, -0.02983999066054821, -0.0000694377813488245, -0.03496384248137474, 0.04026853293180466, -0.0277201309800148, 0.06801844388246536, 0.03313440829515457, -0.0064019011333584785, -0.019756386056542397, 0.006304848473519087, 0.0011798815103247762, 0.016075272113084793, -0.05333016812801361, 0.0462387353181839, 0.02569720707833767, 0.010047931224107742, -0.07957002520561218, -0.04744955524802208, 0.048669829964637756, 0.02365104667842388, -0.040418945252895355, -0.02344355918467045, -0.027696209028363228, 0.010263719595968723, -0.019800450652837753, 0.00860186293721199, 0.06367523968219757, -0.012668605893850327, -0.04822305589914322, -0.013285428285598755, 0.015646344050765038, 0.07783181965351105, -0.015599473379552364, 0.04655889794230461, 0.023842323571443558, -0.017282776534557343, -0.04356392100453377, 0.014332598075270653, 0.01219250075519085, -0.00898171216249466, 0.008725720457732677, -0.03527532145380974, 0.011286558583378792, 0.029047349467873573, -0.018009871244430542, 0.027510061860084534, -0.01862679235637188, 0.05973749980330467, 0.01335462648421526, -0.049941956996917725, 0.007661227136850357, 0.00018125909264199436, 0.027098948135972023, -0.017387541010975838, 0.04653632640838623, 0.011285683140158653, 0.024723544716835022, -0.00036128354258835316, 0.05110352858901024, -0.05383655056357384, 0.001409847871400416, 0.07858097553253174, -0.006561737507581711, -0.007506806403398514, 0.03617902845144272, -0.023233553394675255, 0.016152139753103256, 0.011314282193779945, -0.01469457522034645, 0.06448309868574142, 0.048698071390390396, -0.02937346138060093, 0.00851594191044569, -0.039451245218515396, 0.00765114463865757, 0.05562985688447952, -0.016933875158429146, 0.09024728089570999, 0.016830839216709137, 0.011716117151081562, 0.021770592778921127, -0.02440609410405159, 0.00579713424667716, -0.011387634091079235, -0.01079966314136982, 0.06790391355752945, -0.025927500799298286, -0.006366677116602659, 0.018095411360263824, 0.041325848549604416, -0.008699002675712109, 0.06510134786367416, 0.04558556526899338, -0.001206113025546074, -0.018577098846435547, -0.03248325735330582, -0.03365194424986839, 0.031384196132421494, -0.041456665843725204, 0.06388276815414429, -0.04292798042297363, 0.005371397826820612, 0.03320907801389694, 0.0017575192032381892, -0.01696610264480114, -0.043360497802495956, -0.007972747087478638, -0.082381471991539, -0.007942719385027885, 0.017038626596331596, 0.023359866812825203, 0.027147209271788597, 0.010770829394459724, 0.035284511744976044, -0.03620772436261177, 0.023659665137529373, -0.06349802017211914, -0.044453080743551254, -0.011322073638439178, -0.03632894903421402, -0.07985583692789078, 0.07054247707128525, 0.007459220476448536, -0.0028090595733374357, 0.045004863291978836, -0.05324159935116768, 0.05194718390703201, -0.013125612400472164, 0.04404338076710701, -0.018750129267573357, 0.06745090335607529, 0.025111807510256767, 0.011566736735403538, -0.005852142348885536, -0.007317502982914448, 0.12159626185894012, 0.05280005931854248, 0.02754255384206772, -0.07681998610496521, 0.0021653850562870502, 0.03187628835439682, 0.004546111915260553, 0.0013623046688735485, 0.013900472782552242, 0.0006979590398259461, 0.0037750829942524433, 0.021968044340610504, 0.04648705571889877, 0.03565526753664017, -0.019144993275403976, 0.0020861441735178232, 0.02979276143014431, -0.011256992816925049, 0.02776957117021084, -0.011694181710481644, -0.030529972165822983, 0.0022480834741145372, -0.07281363010406494, 0.025178726762533188, 0.02781769074499607, 0.0010054189478978515, -0.057049013674259186, -0.0011311025591567159, -0.01178736425936222, -0.0028357566334307194, 0.0399399995803833, 0.03390464559197426, 0.04547380283474922, 0.0047711958177387714, -0.03706676885485649, -0.008680537343025208, 0.03176439553499222, -0.009054317139089108, -0.0013004132779315114, 0.03676094114780426, -0.022062761709094048, -0.0030504984315484762, -0.00016979464271571487, 0.035235609859228134, -0.014627513475716114, -0.003153975820168853, -0.0031894478015601635, 0.026904838159680367, -0.005092171486467123, -0.029271455481648445, -0.01360483281314373, -0.004178533796221018, -0.012102529406547546, -0.024045079946517944, 0.008990185335278511, 0.022321505472064018, -0.0009482018067501485, -0.05454495921730995, -0.03346801549196243, -0.03137489780783653, 0.0023438537027686834, -0.016204481944441795, -0.009031982161104679, 0.018583163619041443, -0.0032228869386017323, -0.030147045850753784, -0.02915448322892189, 0.04651268571615219, 0.0020028227008879185, -0.01479171309620142, -0.0020629188511520624, -0.05283017456531525, -0.015376249328255653, 0.009262367151677608, 0.0016060213092714548, -0.039496421813964844, 0.03183768689632416, -0.007019230630248785, -0.00660007493570447, -0.011647840961813927, -0.03158903494477272, 0.0024182351771742105, -0.02222047559916973, -0.0001436067104805261, -0.01884283684194088, -0.02290325239300728, 0.022388508543372154, 0.03979545086622238, 0.006492774933576584, 0.038993265479803085, 0.04817843437194824, 0.010157115757465363, -0.0009567553643137217, -0.06137867644429207, 0.0022144950926303864, -0.0007384251803159714, -0.031910743564367294, 0.01721317693591118, -0.008061100728809834, 0.0396682471036911, 0.014491747133433819, -0.027668975293636322, 0.011532012373209, 0.03184957057237625, -0.016159886494278908, 0.01686115749180317, -0.020706655457615852, -0.052779290825128555, 0.02033468708395958, 0.042922746390104294, -0.03984355926513672, 0.005836385767906904, 0.014794668182730675, -0.0074248043820261955, -0.03432322293519974, 0.02194429561495781, -0.015202040784060955, -0.06480485200881958, -0.004825574811547995, -0.039420709013938904, 0.012751678936183453, -0.0007712363731116056, 0.022932862862944603, -0.04728293418884277, 0.010986569337546825, 0.017124248668551445, 0.010773721151053905, -0.03443818911910057, 0.013455764390528202, -0.006712399888783693, 0.019988656044006348, 0.03999698907136917, -0.012882202863693237, 0.012345321476459503, 0.0017231067176908255, -0.0029522499535232782, -0.01959528774023056, 0.033648181706666946, -0.002326861023902893, -0.00829264521598816, 0.02798275835812092, -0.05457528308033943, 0.027343841269612312, 0.01986236497759819, 0.0036038681864738464, 0.018833504989743233, 0.0041826399974524975, -0.04741508886218071, 0.006568251643329859, 0.07599035650491714, -0.0664285272359848, -0.049611326307058334, -0.04643075540661812, -0.049718573689460754, 0.023273732513189316, -0.004038271959871054, 0.016148053109645844, 0.03114132396876812, -0.03222426027059555, 0.02908041514456272, 0.021983619779348373, -0.01979120820760727, 0.007607925683259964, -0.02778739482164383, 0.025547347962856293, 0.007348691578954458, 0.01641390286386013, -0.0009574241703376174, 0.012275115586817265, 0.03975876420736313, -0.009029703214764595, -0.01930641382932663, -0.046694591641426086, 0.027048248797655106, -0.02333037741482258, -0.041654687374830246, 0.011858506128191948, -0.006401397753506899, 0.03282763808965683, -0.08439779281616211, -0.017607392743229866, 0.033944837749004364, -0.035892270505428314, -0.010705744847655296, 0.012505128979682922, -0.04478038102388382, -0.02190801315009594, 0.030504586175084114, -0.03292883560061455, 0.02185850590467453, 0.010351525619626045, 0.02157295122742653, 0.03307109698653221, 0.008724326267838478, 0.01578594744205475, -0.02959453873336315, -0.02644501067698002, 0.021895838901400566, 0.012323209084570408, -0.03334809094667435, -0.013905420899391174, -0.033215492963790894, -0.0038943570107221603, 0.04433794319629669, -0.03527336195111275, 0.010782646015286446, 0.019286973401904106, 0.03541196882724762, -0.003893593093380332, 0.022390520200133324, 0.008272704668343067, -0.037423085421323776, 0.01322285644710064, -0.03571018576622009, 0.024602677673101425, 0.010519114322960377, -0.018747219815850258, -0.0003716950595844537, 0.031113918870687485, 0.03590129315853119, -0.022793428972363472, 0.02357194386422634, -0.05130522698163986, -0.037952885031700134, -0.01824808306992054, 0.040788691490888596, -0.023855052888393402, -0.04640815407037735, 0.0024897793773561716, -0.030095765367150307, 0.05883140489459038, 0.042310405522584915, -0.0073164296336472034, -0.05571594089269638, 0.010773919522762299, 0.0026429942809045315, -0.007229246664792299, -0.006686253938823938, 0.010829604230821133, -0.05000172182917595, -0.0419788584113121, -0.0007791317766532302, -0.035047248005867004, 0.012010686099529266, -0.0007531831506639719, -0.0013159830123186111, 0.015958068892359734, 0.05352570489048958, -0.03276453912258148, 0.002607010304927826, -0.00999036431312561, -0.008980508893728256, 0.02011702209711075, -0.07790935039520264, 0.041397158056497574, 0.00840319599956274, -0.04647783935070038, -0.058077920228242874, -0.01990385912358761, -0.027134744450449944, 0.0056890277191996574, 0.047524504363536835, 0.004651626572012901, 0.03161543607711792, -0.017671216279268265, 0.006787145975977182, 0.017199445515871048, -0.03188123181462288, 0.03227223828434944, -0.024959631264209747, -0.01198124885559082, 0.018790263682603836, -0.028728952631354332, 0.04937756434082985, 0.026540394872426987, -0.009459209628403187, -0.013324284926056862, 0.01320438738912344, 0.01305101253092289, -0.0009449176141060889, 0.022804604843258858, 0.0031055095605552197, -0.01427016407251358, 0.03763291612267494, 0.010636961087584496, -0.002627655863761902, 0.0014621781883761287, -0.0095227574929595, -0.03862924501299858, 0.048859450966119766, -0.020971065387129784, 0.002153846202418208, -0.005215965677052736, 0.0017561394488438964, 0.015141480602324009, -0.06381414085626602, 0.012622767128050327, -0.010754169896245003, -0.04611532762646675, 0.013896032236516476, 0.035206977277994156, -0.022090794518589973, 0.03679483011364937, -0.04158203676342964, 0.03303353115916252, -0.03125573694705963, -0.034283339977264404, 0.01087312400341034, 0.003073282539844513, -0.0026517671067267656, -0.004851404577493668, -0.003829023102298379, 0.06343017518520355, -0.043241824954748154, 0.02410075068473816, -0.022336017340421677, -0.009480672888457775, -0.017867974936962128, -0.02590867690742016, 0.009653769433498383, -0.028906745836138725, 0.003942301031202078, 0.014879539608955383, -0.008162428624927998, 0.058805011212825775, -0.03462820127606392, -0.022272638976573944, -0.032485175877809525, -0.020707815885543823, -0.03519812226295471, 0.002317398088052869, 0.035058893263339996, -0.008255038410425186, 0.0019950484856963158, -0.03933798149228096, 0.0030976971611380577, 0.0035673666279762983, 0.04827360063791275, -0.013532196171581745, 0.018839197233319283, 0.003772422904148698, 0.010389009490609169, -0.013154899701476097, 0.0037181666120886803, -0.027249762788414955, 0.015283060260117054, -0.0025951419956982136, 0.030093034729361534, -0.003821361344307661, 0.007711147889494896, -0.0019632065668702126, -0.01576061360538006, 0.04151167348027229, -0.05158987641334534, -0.02967654913663864, -0.0393889844417572, -0.00001260372118849773, -0.010956446640193462, -0.02130921371281147 ]
<p>This is an ill posed problem I'm faced with at work.</p> <p>I have observations $X_i$, $i = 1,2,3,...N &gt; M$. I need want to compute $S = \sum_{i=1}^M X_i$. Unfortunately, $M$ is random, and extremely noisy. It turns out, I have some rough "goodness" measures, $w_i$ for each of the $X_i$. That is, $w_i$ low, means I don't trust $X_i$ very much, $w_i$ high, means I trust $X_i$ a lot. </p> <p>Moreover, "generally" as $i$ gets large, the $X_i$ get small. (There's a lot of dependence between $M$ and the $X_i$)</p> <p>In this application, it turns out that the <em>average</em> of the $X_i$ can very reliably (i.e. with relatively small standard deviation) be computed by: $A = \frac{\sum_{i=1}^M w_i X_i}{\sum_{i=1}^M w_i}$. We know the standard deviation of $A$ is relatively small by running a number of independent trials, and computing the sample standard deviation.</p> <p>But, I similarly need a "good" estimate (i.e. small standard deviation) of the straight sum of the $X_i$ and the obvious approach: $M * A$ has far too much variance for our application.</p> <p>Understand this is pretty vague, but any thoughts on how to proceed?</p>
74,049
[ -0.015199785120785236, 0.017971714958548546, -0.011480073444545269, -0.052925046533346176, 0.03001980297267437, 0.018600299954414368, -0.027671560645103455, -0.009675950743258, 0.02599295601248741, -0.032242171466350555, 0.05851959437131882, 0.04181971773505211, 0.08751282840967178, 0.03273259475827217, 0.04582970216870308, -0.008949249982833862, -0.013338114134967327, -0.027197908610105515, 0.006432041525840759, -0.023598605766892433, 0.034324515610933304, 0.04411155730485916, 0.006986013147979975, -0.03303088620305061, -0.05159163102507591, 0.013172482140362263, 0.0031514461152255535, -0.025686316192150116, 0.005168279632925987, 0.07433948665857315, -0.030419794842600822, -0.02690950781106949, 0.018506472930312157, 0.0488397479057312, 0.033591754734516144, 0.007617983967065811, -0.017357267439365387, -0.014494628645479679, 0.013167155906558037, 0.029198892414569855, -0.02625630795955658, -0.027479207143187523, -0.02817295864224434, -0.01983627863228321, -0.02782517485320568, 0.011301541700959206, 0.006745465565472841, -0.09239999949932098, 0.030224081128835678, -0.053720612078905106, 0.06422513723373413, 0.015506385825574398, 0.03847070783376694, 0.018486902117729187, -0.03288782760500908, -0.01306565385311842, 0.02875594049692154, 0.0767938420176506, 0.02252909168601036, -0.029696935787796974, -0.017016611993312836, -0.01935015432536602, 0.00794189516454935, -0.004712081979960203, -0.019952865317463875, 0.0230557881295681, -0.02800564654171467, -0.034295909106731415, 0.021909641101956367, -0.04852793738245964, 0.015558094717562199, 0.007673909422010183, 0.030630294233560562, 0.007756032049655914, -0.020698927342891693, 0.015380717813968658, 0.010051053017377853, -0.0014460888924077153, 0.055349789559841156, 0.016525333747267723, 0.00990012101829052, 0.017030445858836174, 0.047747135162353516, 0.026035889983177185, 0.0013287162873893976, -0.019080381840467453, 0.06272419542074203, -0.005301718134433031, 0.006605000700801611, 0.028797484934329987, -0.004525802563875914, -0.006869732867926359, 0.057039909064769745, -0.010237615555524826, -0.025339176878333092, 0.04154074192047119, -0.02762986347079277, 0.020205767825245857, -0.003026844933629036, -0.03248708322644234, -0.019052013754844666, -0.037981510162353516, -0.007018850184977055, 0.058519791811704636, -0.024736914783716202, -0.02467784471809864, -0.015971431508660316, 0.022069286555051804, -0.014996892772614956, -0.04695480689406395, 0.02800782211124897, 0.01048270147293806, 0.018763236701488495, -0.02093474380671978, 0.017985958606004715, 0.03215145319700241, -0.015841737389564514, -0.031772054731845856, 0.03920690715312958, 0.0865076556801796, 0.044640425592660904, -0.008555746637284756, 0.027282191440463066, -0.034612663090229034, -0.025036213919520378, 0.014190779998898506, 0.026551682502031326, -0.03326507657766342, -0.06852100789546967, 0.06265616416931152, 0.03394682705402374, -0.029550442472100258, 0.055705126374959946, 0.004509950056672096, 0.0056009441614151, -0.014438638463616371, -0.06247031316161156, -0.04881950840353966, 0.03888440504670143, -0.03680902719497681, -0.02195383794605732, -0.0609612874686718, 0.00837673805654049, 0.06368619948625565, 0.06441306322813034, 0.039010949432849884, 0.03744575381278992, 0.005563965532928705, 0.04704808071255684, 0.015424846671521664, -0.03968890383839607, -0.02192254364490509, -0.021344851702451706, -0.0003275094204582274, -0.0035066520795226097, -0.07040458917617798, 0.04556407034397125, 0.018872041255235672, -0.011631431058049202, -0.03384885564446449, 0.02651888132095337, 0.023769348859786987, 0.001291998545639217, 0.011984995566308498, 0.003198664402589202, -0.010864520445466042, 0.048407021909952164, 0.008600748144090176, 0.04111996665596962, 0.01011340320110321, -0.002633691532537341, -0.0009239135542884469, 0.0300703514367342, 0.027788830921053886, 0.061810240149497986, -0.04616943374276161, 0.024359658360481262, -0.018885064870119095, 0.023258322849869728, 0.0397537536919117, -0.015811948105692863, -0.03776468336582184, -0.01539526879787445, 0.008024651557207108, 0.034726496785879135, 0.036845993250608444, -0.00985772255808115, -0.0057767583057284355, 0.009122751653194427, -0.03873911499977112, -0.028699463233351707, -0.09483741223812103, -0.014794589951634407, -0.02168218232691288, -0.03727781027555466, 0.05170612037181854, -0.022523116320371628, -0.0002628116635605693, 0.007309797219932079, -0.009752621874213219, 0.003930695820599794, 0.002646239474415779, 0.06323247402906418, -0.029596999287605286, 0.016858119517564774, 0.03889138624072075, 0.03881940245628357, -0.021492792293429375, 0.05446843057870865, -0.0161555428057909, -0.06781315058469772, -0.03215637803077698, -0.0282563716173172, 0.01141428668051958, 0.006251456681638956, -0.01693899929523468, 0.015223526395857334, -0.06656713783740997, -0.001998655265197158, 0.003610283136367798, -0.037896111607551575, 0.07839891314506531, 0.029163310304284096, 0.025999221950769424, -0.018491949886083603, 0.014011348597705364, 0.045644987374544144, 0.0003307885199319571, -0.006768292747437954, -0.03820446506142616, -0.04167550802230835, 0.0077130054123699665, 0.037725262343883514, 0.05182024836540222, -0.031490758061409, -0.002493517939001322, 0.06628423929214478, 0.006885155104100704, 0.015869881957769394, 0.03600989282131195, -0.03064914233982563, -0.010064802132546902, 0.004176786635071039, -0.005665423348546028, 0.025677084922790527, 0.015773797407746315, -0.022726701572537422, 0.016151675954461098, 0.010628387331962585, 0.02245270647108555, -0.005060498137027025, 0.01864892989397049, -0.01986791007220745, -0.0015590559924021363, -0.024549126625061035, -0.032609663903713226, 0.03282498940825462, -0.018025675788521767, -0.0017540104454383254, 0.020710160955786705, -0.001355533953756094, 0.006810250226408243, -0.01708032935857773, -0.04529401287436485, 0.027089426293969154, -0.010023132897913456, -0.03932778909802437, 0.013956497423350811, 0.002727250335738063, -0.011519022285938263, 0.009918361902236938, -0.015355219133198261, 0.003957257606089115, -0.013542554341256618, -0.001932406914420426, 0.007795989513397217, 0.007909078150987625, -0.017005879431962967, -0.00552251935005188, -0.026444515213370323, 0.011334310285747051, -0.00011292555427644402, 0.030922235921025276, 0.014291875995695591, -0.03828394040465355, 0.002548589836806059, -0.0075994618237018585, -0.013801627792418003, 0.046912841498851776, 0.027078034356236458, 0.006039301864802837, 0.014526567421853542, 0.018246913328766823, -0.06070765107870102, -0.012379827909171581, -0.014562264084815979, 0.015810247510671616, -0.019179634749889374, -0.019864600151777267, 0.06703400611877441, 0.003218857804313302, -0.047584909945726395, 0.02006777934730053, -0.0023703391198068857, -0.030646376311779022, -0.035505373030900955, -0.011387735605239868, 0.009120071306824684, -0.00588129973039031, 0.02382638491690159, 0.026262369006872177, -0.02418636716902256, -0.0011196634732186794, -0.0925213173031807, -0.06451061367988586, 0.024561187252402306, 0.011806556023657322, 0.01124398410320282, 0.023549916222691536, -0.06243036687374115, 0.07776936143636703, 0.027934521436691284, -0.018350454047322273, -0.023571975529193878, 0.01541539840400219, -0.005446508061140776, -0.04791896417737007, -0.0008510558400303125, -0.003642230061814189, -0.011321195401251316, 0.02333679422736168, 0.02671429142355919, 0.005312889348715544, 0.03711025416851044, -0.0015000527491793036, 0.01814810186624527, 0.018864037469029427, -0.021898392587900162, 0.015456398949027061, 0.027685776352882385, 0.0037257021758705378, 0.005104484967887402, -0.023124275729060173, 0.011959537863731384, -0.0026750320103019476, 0.014857959002256393, -0.05019651725888252, -0.016329582780599594, -0.034824058413505554, 0.02973739244043827, -0.04926113039255142, 0.03677075356245041, 0.025304947048425674, -0.008608861826360226, 0.0047761183232069016, 0.0403098538517952, 0.0036202201154083014, -0.012721851468086243, 0.01539563573896885, 0.049960583448410034, 0.02970936894416809, -0.014204481616616249, -0.03639984875917435, -0.04291263967752457, -0.008904575370252132, 0.006107467692345381, -0.00780264288187027, -0.012319064699113369, 0.04912172630429268, 0.04892352595925331, 0.01974727027118206, -0.04446461424231529, -0.03338775411248207, 0.013050708919763565, -0.07990402728319168, -0.028738413006067276, -0.02172490395605564, 0.05789180099964142, 0.0013215815415605903, 0.018798300996422768, 0.009195978753268719, -0.02289077267050743, -0.0046268790028989315, 0.0276634581387043, -0.05487750470638275, 0.01999312825500965, -0.02136916294693947, -0.02508261427283287, 0.011685758829116821, -0.0048785158433020115, 0.026318633928894997, -0.005718224681913853, 0.01780514419078827, -0.012471870519220829, 0.03659489378333092, -0.022979915142059326, 0.0008207596256397665, -0.0441049188375473, -0.030350470915436745, -0.009414464235305786, 0.01962791569530964, 0.011558647267520428, -0.03202563524246216, 0.005767413880676031, 0.010970951057970524, -0.000704901700373739, -0.03756631910800934, -0.02011255919933319, 0.026758739724755287, -0.011058496311306953, 0.015744449570775032, 0.01834672875702381, 0.025205355137586594, -0.039049625396728516, 0.04318895936012268, -0.0036407699808478355, 0.05793898180127144, 0.029006779193878174, 0.02561352774500847, 0.010474232956767082, -0.06308881938457489, -0.02009465917944908, 0.04578382521867752, 0.013395720161497593, 0.007227422669529915, -0.009353935718536377, 0.03780926764011383, 0.007712829392403364, -0.07491940259933472, 0.009497486986219883, 0.06494937092065811, -0.014734657481312752, 0.00746947294101119, -0.028556128963828087, -0.019838010892271996, 0.009671301580965519, -0.010135740973055363, 0.04193711653351784, 0.0013902484206482768, 0.007895205169916153, -0.0329292006790638, 0.02080073393881321, -0.0005721675115637481, -0.022567719221115112, -0.0150275444611907, 0.030416805297136307, 0.0430479571223259, 0.018694845959544182, -0.015698997303843498, 0.012781786732375622, 0.046867258846759796, 0.03366197273135185, -0.001318255439400673, -0.0025980547070503235, -0.09581413865089417, 0.010436223819851875, 0.02812509797513485, 0.07638181746006012, -0.03548422455787659, 0.00963573157787323, -0.04774472117424011, -0.014126739464700222, 0.06554379314184189, -0.001188448746688664, 0.029961733147501945, 0.01882239244878292, -0.0178048238158226, 0.0070828828029334545, 0.0014203956816345453, -0.050158675760030746, 0.016047609969973564, -0.0019604729022830725, 0.045586857944726944, -0.039503373205661774, -0.04177023470401764, -0.0728374496102333, -0.008071106858551502, 0.06105487793684006, 0.05815727636218071, -0.0028535767924040556, 0.0018594322027638555, 0.010696658864617348, 0.05835339426994324, -0.0017406182596459985, -0.09139522910118103, 0.01502228807657957, -0.02726552076637745, -0.06302108615636826, 0.01766177825629711, -0.044233888387680054, -0.06444152444601059, 0.05718104541301727, 0.012766944244503975, -0.009882064536213875, -0.007317390758544207, -0.009738489054143429, 0.03415261581540108, 0.04150718078017235, 0.048695776611566544, 0.07035153359174728, 0.03651493042707443, 0.007791097741574049, 0.0059523512609303, 0.0027694592718034983, 0.0009170310804620385, -0.024847162887454033, -0.013735423795878887, -0.03686951473355293, -0.016135329380631447, -0.019050877541303635, 0.0305764339864254, 0.0049821361899375916, 0.019305245950818062, 0.007120892405509949, -0.04501749575138092, 0.00522369472309947, 0.022993501275777817, 0.008691800758242607, -0.025382524356245995, 0.05517975613474846, 0.047230590134859085, -0.0028549523558467627, -0.02976546250283718, 0.01567898504436016, 0.002163809258490801, 0.015588389709591866, 0.020233474671840668, -0.05296627804636955, 0.005428916309028864, -0.05440755560994148, -0.006628680508583784, 0.0029416820034384727, -0.009476187638938427, 0.05993599072098732, -0.009527193382382393, 0.054580606520175934, -0.0029282644391059875, -0.051204435527324677, -0.007008433807641268, -0.002403481164947152, 0.0011976318201050162, 0.05333211272954941, -0.04289255663752556, -0.05187937989830971, 0.007132040336728096, -0.011747624725103378, -0.06351485848426819, -0.020122531801462173, 0.016218552365899086, 0.04398978874087334, 0.001241471036337316, -0.030335836112499237, 0.019483594223856926, -0.028353461995720863, -0.012914004735648632, -0.027687590569257736, 0.04454018548130989, -0.026187201961874962, 0.002567217918112874, 0.008195508271455765, 0.04011537507176399, 0.05393033102154732, -0.019647568464279175, 0.0024120889138430357, 0.0389886349439621, -0.04035591334104538, -0.035330500453710556, -0.001395281171426177, 0.019246872514486313, -0.056270524859428406, -0.005343172699213028, -0.028736285865306854, -0.017633160576224327, 0.039029207080602646, -0.029138894751667976, -0.016839349642395973, 0.011786694638431072, 0.019969236105680466, 0.016100380569696426, -0.013995761051774025, 0.016689598560333252, 0.008939043618738651, 0.0438399575650692, -0.017886299639940262, -0.0008140775607898831, 0.009891731664538383, 0.00959310494363308, 0.04490582272410393, 0.033290669322013855, -0.027383090928196907, 0.007621408440172672, 0.038965318351984024, -0.02290286123752594, -0.024741370230913162, 0.008593359962105751, 0.026257427409291267, 0.025220150128006935, 0.010075011290609837, 0.022298984229564667, 0.03793400898575783, 0.039257243275642395, -0.04110176861286163, -0.043544571846723557, -0.042134858667850494, -0.0012699643848463893, 0.056935667991638184, -0.02329934388399124, 0.04205074533820152, 0.030916910618543625, 0.005978586617857218, -0.032759103924036026, -0.022908659651875496, -0.04128910228610039, -0.01854892633855343, -0.0060188258066773415, 0.0251651369035244, -0.010311305522918701, -0.003172209719195962, 0.031183645129203796, 0.024389196187257767, 0.004511997103691101, 0.00896979495882988, -0.014633211307227612, 0.01682584173977375, 0.011468862183392048, -0.005211677402257919, -0.04993238300085068, 0.04192879796028137, -0.053524017333984375, 0.005717225838452578, -0.024563506245613098, -0.008607875555753708, 0.0443442240357399, 0.03530547022819519, 0.00031078996835276484, -0.05025460943579674, -0.033376943320035934, -0.03549982234835625, 0.021422656252980232, 0.036474134773015976, -0.024830471724271774, 0.02464103512465954, 0.004858279600739479, 0.0018332607578486204, -0.010912773199379444, 0.037579428404569626, -0.024221690371632576, -0.07579077035188675, -0.01016626413911581, -0.014911395497620106, -0.031894005835056305, 0.03221406042575836, 0.032143015414476395, -0.03853880986571312, -0.0066066924482584, -0.039491914212703705, 0.04827198013663292, 0.0002783461532089859, 0.025983689352869987, -0.016831275075674057, 0.05028992518782616, 0.012331513687968254, 0.020381512120366096, 0.002443312667310238, 0.0028844804037362337, 0.11445695906877518, 0.055163100361824036, 0.04957820475101471, -0.0546223483979702, 0.01948065496981144, -0.019954197108745575, -0.023090336471796036, -0.019639385864138603, 0.041235048323869705, 0.010687491856515408, 0.007050785701721907, -0.008588670752942562, 0.04840558022260666, 0.005029306281358004, -0.0026614756789058447, 0.052541907876729965, -0.02710004895925522, -0.01676943339407444, 0.03122677654027939, -0.003726131748408079, 0.03445425629615784, -0.011427782475948334, -0.021239539608359337, 0.0491248220205307, -0.013833796605467796, -0.0238655935972929, 0.0035009889397770166, 0.0005319375195540488, -0.00593884801492095, 0.006098413374274969, -0.0214775912463665, 0.023209771141409874, 0.014693669974803925, 0.034350309520959854, 0.006035257130861282, 0.026949265971779823, 0.021004032343626022, -0.020106466487050056, 0.01791531592607498, 0.01605927012860775, 0.013031652197241783, 0.0034447964280843735, -0.009758316911756992, -0.0012808259343728423, -0.03329070657491684, -0.06323493272066116, -0.015288579277694225, 0.051583558320999146, -0.023822765797376633, 0.034583836793899536, -0.011145357973873615, -0.033968959003686905, -0.0064849527552723885, -0.03460793197154999, 0.01872960478067398, 0.02290445752441883, 0.010578813962638378, -0.053404923528432846, 0.0009886989137157798, -0.010308045893907547, 0.04260054975748062, -0.01059307437390089, 0.035467542707920074, 0.030632495880126953, -0.04125451296567917, -0.03740455582737923, -0.008039772510528564, 0.030426744371652603, 0.016457773745059967, -0.009905059821903706, -0.011997410096228123, -0.05572379752993584, -0.014961818233132362, -0.017278483137488365, 0.012356863357126713, -0.02728857472538948, 0.03777725622057915, -0.006523553282022476, -0.00883061345666647, 0.006971391383558512, -0.049725599586963654, -0.014096874743700027, -0.03522465005517006, 0.009642289951443672, -0.054552070796489716, -0.03845442458987236, -0.014158506877720356, 0.01988726109266281, 0.009631295688450336, -0.03791309893131256, 0.021466894075274467, 0.06506101787090302, 0.015220907516777515, -0.029011214151978493, 0.004295495338737965, -0.016670843586325645, -0.02602376975119114, 0.0282562505453825, 0.04736311361193657, 0.05109933018684387, 0.04185041785240173, 0.0075958045199513435, -0.00963128637522459, 0.011040613986551762, -0.023882173001766205, 0.008991030044853687, 0.02205977588891983, -0.06414084881544113, -0.02707139030098915, 0.02994944341480732, -0.009688303805887699, 0.00020274546113796532, 0.022625833749771118, -0.021172797307372093, -0.015121100470423698, -0.0029570970218628645, 0.0025023112539201975, -0.03279269114136696, 0.02259521558880806, -0.0018969542579725385, 0.015807276591658592, -0.017029331997036934, -0.006599335931241512, -0.016876941546797752, -0.017857559025287628, -0.014419599436223507, 0.010563445277512074, 0.011043274775147438, 0.01891547068953514, -0.03031129576265812, 0.0013170078163966537, 0.028265539556741714, 0.011744817718863487, -0.0015553906559944153, -0.008306975476443768, -0.000030487753974739462, -0.017012571915984154, 0.06659431755542755, -0.028687428683042526, -0.03378107026219368, 0.036053694784641266, -0.04999502748250961, -0.038645438849925995, 0.008681060746312141, -0.014072993770241737, 0.045440010726451874, 0.047595128417015076, -0.04952184855937958, -0.05196674168109894, 0.015268707647919655, -0.019870329648256302, -0.030411651358008385, -0.009281652979552746, 0.019050324335694313, 0.011171207763254642, -0.01137337926775217, 0.04652463644742966, -0.030903730541467667, 0.013490477576851845, 0.0026319019962102175, 0.03654259443283081, -0.027808940038084984, -0.030312636867165565, 0.05262051522731781, 0.014283561147749424, -0.00257576210424304, -0.005151948891580105, 0.015159900300204754, 0.011103415861725807, 0.06709137558937073, -0.03913102671504021, 0.03077039308845997, -0.026656730100512505, 0.0011200809385627508, -0.08627678453922272, -0.020984264090657234, 0.00826349575072527, 0.0016717936377972364, 0.035607386380434036, -0.07098478078842163, -0.000736590416636318, 0.053021322935819626, -0.062397390604019165, 0.032640088349580765, -0.04480898752808571, -0.01761174201965332, -0.023126844316720963, 0.011731872335076332, -0.03257176652550697, -0.011337758041918278, -0.020387951284646988, 0.019015563651919365, 0.03876396641135216, 0.024292336776852608, 0.00038141285767778754, -0.01856835000216961, -0.029434362426400185, 0.036438949406147, 0.03156062215566635, -0.06496759504079819, 0.01409354992210865, -0.015168274752795696, -0.03558231517672539, 0.023457476869225502, -0.0262751467525959, 0.014670412056148052, -0.026011303067207336, 0.04934472218155861, -0.010246030986309052, 0.05191190540790558, -0.0025129618588835, 0.02287227474153042, 0.023112893104553223, -0.0022974752355366945, 0.038061365485191345, 0.018716998398303986, -0.0012758681550621986, 0.009037063457071781, 0.05443882942199707, 0.002815914573147893, -0.033071164041757584, 0.01740807667374611, 0.005405072122812271, -0.023390458896756172, -0.002859430620446801, 0.012539857067167759, 0.004561706446111202, -0.06449936330318451, 0.02864375151693821, -0.018178289756178856, 0.01109573058784008, 0.027986209839582443, 0.041975438594818115, -0.02748032473027706, 0.01717924140393734, 0.009950556792318821, -0.045108359307050705, 0.021925410255789757, -0.014615653082728386, -0.01040462963283062, -0.07019732147455215, -0.013803640380501747, 0.02928302250802517, -0.0068788775242865086, -0.03459334746003151, -0.013152897357940674, -0.01782570220530033, 0.053233519196510315, -0.021090282127261162, 0.019159724935889244, -0.00046644575195387006, -0.023118164390325546, -0.000665965722873807, -0.09102955460548401, 0.06604722142219543, 0.0016448162496089935, 0.010034854523837566, 0.005577859003096819, -0.0036859093233942986, -0.018654001876711845, -0.029465384781360626, 0.059174299240112305, -0.000009502667126071174, 0.0002735490270424634, 0.00255778175778687, 0.04538742080330849, -0.0026652507949620485, -0.028849931433796883, 0.02521948516368866, -0.03829851746559143, 0.012778601609170437, -0.023952964693307877, -0.036014374345541, 0.04388975352048874, -0.00854681059718132, -0.009433094412088394, -0.024985583499073982, -0.00839352048933506, -0.00234375917352736, -0.00935330055654049, 0.044980380684137344, -0.0033172008115798235, -0.010326463729143143, 0.025765299797058105, -0.006613569334149361, 0.022156156599521637, 0.02013782411813736, -0.005492475815117359, -0.05170028284192085, 0.012269721366465092, -0.04569662734866142, -0.05656423047184944, -0.006858608685433865, 0.03514069318771362, -0.014541094191372395, -0.05318864434957504, -0.012377513572573662, 0.03479905053973198, -0.0187641903758049, 0.013203388080000877, 0.048628102988004684, 0.003024142002686858, 0.045160483568906784, 0.021508371457457542, -0.0013686094898730516, 0.06134253740310669, 0.0034684850834310055, -0.025264540687203407, 0.021320156753063202, 0.04698006063699722, -0.03130965307354927, 0.004234215244650841, 0.0220183152705431, -0.008255559019744396, 0.014817125163972378, -0.007627950515598059, 0.03277008980512619, -0.044898126274347305, -0.039542488753795624, 0.007846339605748653, -0.032405197620391846, 0.00020194058015476912, -0.035509850829839706, -0.0082298144698143, 0.08146696537733078, -0.009605399332940578, -0.00038824559305794537, -0.05481041222810745, -0.0072845956310629845, -0.0009014135575853288, -0.001803835853934288, -0.011401087045669556, 0.03055725060403347, -0.006920294836163521, -0.023882776498794556, -0.005701002199202776, -0.007716764695942402, 0.0336262546479702, -0.033019036054611206, 0.02279224991798401, 0.000420032418332994, 0.013952907174825668, -0.052940670400857925, -0.03413284197449684, -0.014007779769599438, -0.03853893652558327, 0.01436342392116785, 0.05617645010352135, 0.037572573870420456, 0.004983674734830856, -0.012411553412675858, -0.028610127046704292, 0.05741773545742035, -0.06181435286998749, 0.018245000392198563, -0.04549150913953781, 0.00006504180782940239, 0.0002572987286839634, -0.012772114016115665 ]
<p>Violin players were asked to rate 5 violins from least to most rich on a <code>[0 1]</code>, <code>0.05-increment</code> scale, <code>most always = 1</code> and <code>least always = 0</code>. They were then asked to set a "limit of acceptability," i.e., to set a point along the scale above which violins are considered acceptable in terms of richness. By setting <code>acceptable = 1</code> and <code>not acceptable = 0</code>, a binary variable is obtained for each player, in addition to their rating. So, as an example, for a player I have the variables <code>rating = [0.3 0.45 0 1 0.85]</code> and for a <code>limit = 0.45</code>, <code>acc = [0 1 0 1 1]</code>. I use Lin's concordance correlation coefficient to explore consistency within and between individuals for the case of ratings. However, this is not possible for the "acceptable" variable: when a player sets their <code>limit = 0</code>, then <code>acc = [1 1 1 1 1]</code> and hence the presence of zero variance becomes an issue. I am trying to figure out a good, interesting way to analyze the binary data, perhaps compare consistency in ratings with consistency in acceptability limits, or more in-depth relations between the two variables. I am not very experienced in statistics, so any suggestions and ideas are welcome. I primarily work with MATLAB.</p>
74,050
[ -0.026360807940363884, -0.0017410829896107316, 0.006005232688039541, -0.014676889404654503, 0.008299744687974453, 0.02630535140633583, 0.003954232670366764, 0.0005466158618219197, -0.004723300226032734, -0.025730911642313004, 0.030544733628630638, 0.0010049253469333053, 0.0640207827091217, 0.06644926220178604, -0.006558153312653303, -0.0214260071516037, 0.008806022815406322, -0.016648603603243828, -0.016982780769467354, 0.00011602238373598084, -0.009660960175096989, 0.025981523096561432, -0.007152121514081955, -0.005271597765386105, -0.0442388616502285, 0.058432020246982574, -0.004592554643750191, -0.01939372718334198, 0.0086431372910738, 0.024138575419783592, -0.055821023881435394, -0.016307447105646133, 0.0075219133868813515, -0.0023680066224187613, 0.06074756756424904, 0.0024433527141809464, -0.028097642585635185, -0.0037884782068431377, -0.00043605989776551723, 0.014334295876324177, -0.0386689230799675, -0.025204261764883995, -0.006610541138797998, 0.008313588798046112, -0.0078034671023488045, -0.005617656745016575, 0.017756231129169464, -0.04929216206073761, 0.0502617321908474, -0.005981603171676397, 0.08810169249773026, 0.027000349014997482, 0.03217392414808273, -0.004569686483591795, 0.006112361792474985, -0.026030994951725006, 0.04620806872844696, 0.05259115248918533, 0.043546561151742935, -0.046007513999938965, -0.023613203316926956, -0.040672771632671356, -0.013447001576423645, 0.0022840159945189953, 0.014487188309431076, 0.041165173053741455, 0.034145504236221313, -0.019162937998771667, 0.04846680909395218, -0.0069418419152498245, -0.011508912779390812, 0.021541878581047058, 0.03255776688456535, -0.057385120540857315, 0.04387694224715233, -0.0006059884908609092, 0.02162063680589199, -0.00862114503979683, 0.011225609108805656, 0.04040445759892464, -0.037908896803855896, 0.001977244857698679, -0.006075556389987469, 0.044424958527088165, 0.0604218989610672, -0.03428829088807106, 0.05404426530003548, -0.023051144555211067, 0.022882258519530296, 0.04590778425335884, 0.017491549253463745, -0.02547374926507473, 0.045351896435022354, 0.028281673789024353, -0.05839775502681732, 0.005653980188071728, -0.011597593314945698, 0.05318926274776459, -0.04708965867757797, 0.011549598537385464, 0.0003907006175722927, -0.006211298517882824, 0.020217210054397583, 0.02555030584335327, -0.00894266925752163, -0.02697295881807804, -0.041791949421167374, -0.009036822244524956, 0.011839985847473145, -0.010615324601531029, -0.007471961434930563, 0.017056453973054886, 0.06824524700641632, 0.01645561493933201, 0.028994036838412285, -0.014381174929440022, 0.012182213366031647, -0.037292614579200745, 0.082613006234169, 0.03488100692629814, 0.02640000358223915, -0.022396055981516838, 0.026160649955272675, -0.023069890215992928, -0.02438846044242382, 0.024559179320931435, 0.029534831643104553, 0.022736921906471252, -0.04085465893149376, 0.06766808032989502, -0.01859392784535885, -0.01563151180744171, 0.03682706132531166, -0.004334471188485622, -0.005681730806827545, -0.04437199980020523, -0.08631664514541626, -0.0480998232960701, 0.020147033035755157, 0.020719140768051147, -0.018200179561972618, -0.08806038647890091, -0.017699113115668297, 0.044456906616687775, 0.08334946632385254, -0.006957989186048508, 0.052388373762369156, 0.007778839208185673, 0.017403336241841316, 0.04202600196003914, -0.030026648193597794, -0.024002114310860634, -0.04400518164038658, -0.02980734594166279, -0.029607543721795082, -0.02915859781205654, -0.016478028148412704, 0.018929770216345787, -0.0017383632948622108, -0.015778785571455956, 0.020868021994829178, -0.01138486247509718, -0.02574462816119194, 0.004681441001594067, 0.038541529327631, 0.024694757536053658, 0.0791228637099266, -0.011204260401427746, 0.033032406121492386, 0.0026343080680817366, -0.0024988302029669285, -0.007454823702573776, 0.013917981646955013, 0.0323849618434906, 0.058847542852163315, -0.03191713988780975, -0.007043677382171154, -0.016486994922161102, 0.019419720396399498, 0.03913140669465065, -0.02104131691157818, -0.025122158229351044, -0.04838816449046135, -0.015418395400047302, 0.031174086034297943, 0.043130818754434586, -0.027668757364153862, 0.01815028488636017, 0.028463998809456825, -0.045638103038072586, -0.022921564057469368, -0.045905958861112595, -0.0005766793037764728, 0.018900582566857338, -0.054824020713567734, 0.03994876518845558, -0.007103620562702417, 0.006741909775882959, 0.0025378246791660786, 0.04460468888282776, -0.0292984526604414, -0.035692159086465836, 0.043198540806770325, -0.02760796807706356, -0.006001085974276066, 0.04335395246744156, 0.023352421820163727, -0.008136453106999397, 0.057188037782907486, -0.016673341393470764, -0.06591468304395676, 0.005071623250842094, -0.02117110975086689, 0.04614368826150894, 0.03904934972524643, -0.015883367508649826, 0.027018742635846138, -0.019490377977490425, -0.02130870334804058, -0.00609266571700573, -0.0077734519727528095, 0.04782016947865486, 0.05766216665506363, -0.02319679595530033, -0.00698846485465765, 0.019251519814133644, 0.009995240718126297, 0.0200240146368742, -0.03936002776026726, -0.03450118005275726, -0.04290688410401344, -0.016614316031336784, 0.032740019261837006, 0.06435282528400421, -0.033057134598493576, 0.0239466093480587, 0.06282702833414078, 0.012084020301699638, 0.002231024671345949, 0.044737089425325394, -0.01803298480808735, 0.0004725079343188554, 0.031865958124399185, 0.0140108997002244, 0.05071466788649559, -0.01847095787525177, -0.020997295156121254, 0.011554190889000893, 0.031202571466565132, 0.04429803788661957, 0.01869903691112995, -0.005212720949202776, 0.03249789774417877, 0.008385270833969116, 0.00495259091258049, 0.010487702675163746, 0.024673260748386383, -0.00823257863521576, 0.0005756861646659672, 0.06599393486976624, 0.02940080687403679, -0.04089409485459328, 0.021091166883707047, -0.018589438870549202, 0.006126444321125746, 0.035833947360515594, 0.014792781323194504, -0.02104349248111248, -0.0065576075576245785, -0.013389954343438148, 0.010037466883659363, -0.026518000289797783, -0.029688533395528793, -0.022716563194990158, 0.023323968052864075, 0.048149917274713516, 0.034416984766721725, 0.04681968316435814, -0.032595161348581314, -0.025055382400751114, -0.02625098265707493, -0.0031292561907321215, 0.012615511193871498, 0.006914343219250441, -0.07063957303762436, -0.024994375184178352, 0.037803102284669876, 0.030960457399487495, 0.006737587042152882, -0.002122320933267474, 0.014663636684417725, 0.034770142287015915, -0.022633306682109833, -0.04050624743103981, -0.009672393091022968, 0.0013795405393466353, -0.0019634112250059843, -0.014529682695865631, -0.01925296150147915, 0.03599611297249794, 0.021126210689544678, -0.05484047904610634, 0.04402204230427742, -0.036750271916389465, -0.025994379073381424, 0.004328235983848572, 0.0001096438427339308, -0.018529288470745087, 0.016512230038642883, 0.017843399196863174, 0.006479870527982712, -0.008688508532941341, -0.024852847680449486, -0.07223658263683319, -0.07782211899757385, 0.024184709414839745, -0.01218735333532095, 0.03724941238760948, 0.027991192415356636, -0.007368568796664476, 0.08272801339626312, 0.037194184958934784, 0.004932166542857885, -0.043445974588394165, 0.007769194897264242, -0.0012620912166312337, 0.0031285302247852087, -0.012394540011882782, 0.05427640676498413, -0.01925131492316723, 0.027119403705000877, 0.007197184953838587, 0.053140006959438324, 0.03834808990359306, -0.0070672486908733845, -0.027146873995661736, 0.030300170183181763, -0.009763422422111034, -0.04870609939098358, 0.051750004291534424, 0.03809116780757904, 0.00005415321356849745, 0.021450011059641838, -0.0031631842721253633, -0.03481656685471535, 0.019918140023946762, -0.04769688472151756, -0.014937273226678371, -0.0317351371049881, 0.025265231728553772, -0.02170865423977375, -0.0025995918549597263, 0.0329090841114521, -0.033831894397735596, -0.005981517024338245, 0.026276536285877228, 0.03151712194085121, 0.023872805759310722, 0.00677687581628561, 0.04289963096380234, 0.036390166729688644, 0.004785685800015926, 0.0126374252140522, -0.001783728483133018, 0.025109751150012016, 0.03212559223175049, -0.03468693792819977, -0.0002963192237075418, 0.04919805750250816, -0.029205145314335823, 0.022536233067512512, -0.03640236333012581, -0.0706246867775917, 0.024059487506747246, -0.06086436286568642, 0.01164329145103693, -0.06320136785507202, 0.029827067628502846, -0.0013557381462305784, 0.012840982526540756, 0.02853371389210224, 0.005433067679405212, -0.010382809676229954, -0.000004660984359361464, -0.07398709654808044, 0.019242309033870697, -0.01952335797250271, 0.03090529702603817, 0.009463942609727383, 0.0012856947723776102, -0.008477864786982536, -0.03991476446390152, 0.02371150441467762, -0.014323676005005836, 0.04887061566114426, -0.01952475681900978, -0.005693803075700998, -0.0753471776843071, -0.02065509557723999, 0.018147476017475128, -0.01223115622997284, -0.01615605130791664, -0.03833889588713646, 0.06847810000181198, -0.011592540889978409, 0.010831006802618504, -0.004941525869071484, -0.012232773937284946, -0.001183613552711904, 0.010520457290112972, 0.04333294928073883, -0.028921114280819893, 0.04887409880757332, -0.004207245539873838, 0.021258676424622536, -0.0018682351801544428, 0.04750136286020279, 0.05066392570734024, 0.00019504819647409022, 0.012824304401874542, -0.004695456940680742, -0.027834923937916756, -0.028324028477072716, 0.033748213201761246, 0.007052088156342506, -0.006284477189183235, 0.011402377858757973, 0.0236907210201025, -0.05349694937467575, 0.0178430937230587, 0.0342685841023922, 0.022301409393548965, 0.004988750442862511, -0.020864350721240044, -0.04178221523761749, 0.015995915979146957, 0.0002831745077855885, -0.006778220646083355, 0.04329816251993179, 0.01571708917617798, 0.0007329488871619105, 0.08385840803384781, 0.014334983192384243, -0.06297577917575836, -0.017652112990617752, -0.01639333926141262, 0.06496354192495346, -0.029980603605508804, -0.03601088002324104, -0.011129496619105339, 0.01332925446331501, 0.041147224605083466, 0.04245985671877861, -0.015340966172516346, -0.06657348573207855, -0.00491249468177557, 0.01691211201250553, 0.01729338802397251, -0.024228248745203018, 0.013385334983468056, -0.010674377903342247, -0.04935033246874809, 0.028842296451330185, 0.0228587556630373, 0.04338358715176582, -0.010825788602232933, 0.04749074578285217, -0.05904756486415863, -0.015678009018301964, -0.043602731078863144, 0.010714033618569374, -0.01732368767261505, 0.021138889715075493, 0.000744708115234971, -0.04517905041575432, -0.061909809708595276, 0.025039149448275566, 0.007018543314188719, 0.04989655315876007, -0.0333443284034729, 0.007171774283051491, 0.0545944906771183, 0.0047884751111269, 0.01952458918094635, -0.07626324892044067, 0.04372311010956764, 0.03345498442649841, -0.006264804862439632, 0.07396472245454788, 0.005350592080503702, -0.03251441940665245, -0.015038147568702698, 0.006888709031045437, -0.01623932272195816, 0.049821335822343826, -0.012649034149944782, 0.05609717592597008, 0.005193985998630524, 0.004341586492955685, 0.015924639999866486, 0.04196619987487793, -0.011386597529053688, -0.024408040568232536, -0.02361142262816429, 0.008065787144005299, -0.0308625940233469, 0.01040457934141159, -0.05724622681736946, -0.004800482653081417, -0.04879137873649597, 0.022200724110007286, 0.03594955429434776, 0.06900163739919662, -0.011859762482345104, -0.011689786799252033, 0.013522246852517128, 0.00885711144655943, -0.03106391616165638, -0.003514094976708293, -0.012716777622699738, 0.010815389454364777, -0.008247971534729004, -0.009342074394226074, 0.03192094340920448, -0.04704749956727028, -0.010015458799898624, 0.020237581804394722, -0.04595452547073364, 0.027064520865678787, -0.05984468013048172, -0.022823544219136238, -0.037259992212057114, -0.02934115007519722, 0.03936874866485596, -0.004717523697763681, 0.025233972817659378, 0.010019362904131413, -0.0028159888461232185, 0.019745267927646637, 0.02627050317823887, -0.02924800105392933, 0.05136454850435257, 0.0006307197036221623, 0.021935680881142616, -0.02567806839942932, -0.01687600091099739, -0.0607265941798687, -0.029792435467243195, 0.0012566978111863136, 0.006404828280210495, 0.0075933500193059444, 0.00890965573489666, 0.000209843841730617, 0.0013175966450944543, 0.01755988597869873, 0.01439070887863636, -0.003828576998785138, -0.026351094245910645, -0.028759589418768883, -0.005393062252551317, 0.019773593172430992, 0.06946816295385361, -0.02439716085791588, -0.020844580605626106, 0.023069415241479874, -0.02991567924618721, 0.0012826138408854604, 0.013244803063571453, -0.0038733533583581448, -0.051116880029439926, -0.037967849522829056, -0.02269848808646202, 0.0056769028306007385, 0.08393821865320206, 0.029801879078149796, -0.013438455760478973, -0.014986655674874783, -0.021796973422169685, -0.0028187627904117107, -0.001723529421724379, 0.02902851067483425, -0.0051022665575146675, -0.04756209999322891, -0.03064759634435177, -0.01825818233191967, -0.051556043326854706, -0.030464230105280876, -0.0032328458037227392, 0.011682203970849514, -0.044145435094833374, -0.00432716915383935, 0.04384418576955795, 0.016475649550557137, -0.03076929599046707, 0.008272702805697918, -0.027848241850733757, 0.016752412542700768, 0.011742992326617241, -0.03132706135511398, 0.00020773154392372817, 0.027402730658650398, 0.00683088693767786, -0.03487861528992653, -0.03510235622525215, 0.019006479531526566, 0.05011972412467003, 0.005743460729718208, 0.011260630562901497, 0.047673262655735016, -0.01725081354379654, -0.0030622307676821947, 0.011040601879358292, 0.006988176144659519, -0.014114770106971264, -0.001575480797328055, 0.05019262805581093, -0.054673220962285995, -0.0161764994263649, 0.02944541908800602, 0.042299844324588776, 0.015082129277288914, 0.031407132744789124, 0.0004843320930376649, 0.015414017252624035, 0.034497667104005814, -0.05439447984099388, -0.058885231614112854, 0.03259389474987984, -0.0287636686116457, 0.049704842269420624, 0.004835981875658035, -0.03162652626633644, 0.005627050995826721, 0.05945925414562225, -0.005654043052345514, -0.0794229581952095, -0.04097646102309227, -0.034501150250434875, 0.001371196354739368, 0.033816684037446976, -0.04293326288461685, 0.028657710179686546, -0.02919507771730423, 0.01145054679363966, -0.019880086183547974, 0.027101116254925728, -0.02031729742884636, -0.07197048515081406, -0.014909383840858936, -0.036006830632686615, -0.045342303812503815, 0.059518177062273026, -0.0026518371887505054, -0.015945985913276672, 0.05731963366270065, -0.0314883328974247, -0.00029941953835077584, 0.01096679549664259, 0.01276803482323885, 0.015154082328081131, 0.009203794412314892, -0.00992878433316946, 0.005809427239000797, 0.004748240113258362, 0.01794920675456524, 0.15081673860549927, 0.0644126906991005, 0.040263060480356216, -0.009905028156936169, 0.05127764865756035, 0.05842209234833717, -0.006526292767375708, -0.02323603443801403, 0.03289533779025078, 0.01059067901223898, 0.0035282366443425417, 0.0009178151958622038, 0.026436002925038338, 0.02600027620792389, 0.025195324793457985, 0.06511729210615158, -0.03424422815442085, -0.014060969464480877, 0.005667558871209621, 0.04215201735496521, 0.038468100130558014, -0.03197909891605377, -0.020668266341090202, 0.01898280158638954, 0.027547311037778854, -0.029077982529997826, -0.01678912527859211, -0.020151754841208458, 0.02381163462996483, -0.005850756075233221, 0.006458176299929619, 0.008000455796718597, 0.031133679673075676, 0.0032764445059001446, 0.010364348068833351, -0.009493456222116947, 0.035334836691617966, -0.0026546602603048086, -0.003999315667897463, 0.02405424602329731, -0.00472183246165514, -0.034346044063568115, 0.020379705354571342, -0.024416321888566017, -0.03067309409379959, -0.049070071429014206, -0.0439959391951561, -0.0017067624721676111, 0.007844570092856884, -0.03055337816476822, -0.024648090824484825, -0.015930023044347763, -0.007444777991622686, -0.05133005231618881, -0.020884990692138672, 0.020242471247911453, 0.008639519102871418, 0.007613888010382652, -0.03955427557229996, 0.003734248923137784, -0.03757932782173157, -0.010559889487922192, -0.012251120992004871, 0.015527197159826756, -0.039604801684617996, -0.020871298387646675, -0.058564960956573486, 0.059949684888124466, 0.013809285126626492, -0.012065191753208637, -0.0039705452509224415, 0.012359349057078362, -0.027935845777392387, -0.03234772011637688, -0.023744121193885803, 0.03905342519283295, 0.038999028503894806, 0.038814954459667206, -0.01610313169658184, -0.03572729602456093, -0.04672185331583023, 0.016578154638409615, -0.01788615807890892, -0.03540444001555443, -0.01732637733221054, -0.02871522307395935, 0.022428208962082863, 0.0024774987250566483, 0.012824923731386662, 0.003230627626180649, 0.017584849148988724, 0.06172405183315277, -0.020336195826530457, -0.034829214215278625, -0.007790681906044483, -0.00013790730736218393, -0.05248730257153511, 0.03234654292464256, 0.014578329399228096, 0.06642485409975052, -0.01006485428661108, 0.004806875251233578, -0.002579004503786564, 0.04942982643842697, -0.01107176672667265, 0.011690051294863224, 0.03952736034989357, -0.06152241677045822, -0.02900766022503376, 0.026456627994775772, -0.002016811864450574, -0.0332249291241169, -0.06284307688474655, -0.03424583002924919, -0.05203225463628769, -0.011228706687688828, -0.03151652216911316, -0.02602342702448368, -0.0032206031028181314, 0.0001475492026656866, -0.02589833177626133, -0.003713172860443592, -0.014814376831054688, -0.016596032306551933, 0.017001627013087273, -0.01718481443822384, 0.040370550006628036, -0.013823156245052814, 0.04195808619260788, -0.014826210215687752, -0.004698908422142267, 0.021007709205150604, -0.0013082838850095868, 0.01848464272916317, -0.03813425824046135, -0.03147139772772789, 0.008684989996254444, 0.039153050631284714, -0.04403835907578468, -0.008192175067961216, 0.024528663605451584, -0.058238085359334946, -0.0003477590798866004, -0.0025535374879837036, -0.004071395844221115, 0.00890619307756424, -0.010333712212741375, 0.01523815281689167, -0.03062005341053009, 0.024060871452093124, -0.034920834004879, -0.026102999225258827, -0.011986256577074528, 0.009388666599988937, 0.00650497293099761, 0.02908235788345337, 0.0038905444089323282, 0.017522379755973816, -0.0492822602391243, 0.02641913667321205, 0.07119116187095642, 0.013198981992900372, 0.015540097840130329, 0.020540647208690643, -0.035686083137989044, -0.022946953773498535, 0.002186104189604521, -0.031083108857274055, 0.024639425799250603, 0.0748821422457695, -0.02966344729065895, 0.00026057043578475714, -0.015415266156196594, -0.012452421709895134, -0.047364961355924606, -0.01573735661804676, -0.005700505338609219, 0.00021569467207882553, 0.0299326591193676, -0.035553596913814545, 0.024931708350777626, 0.02013942413032055, -0.03176919370889664, 0.029970839619636536, -0.023426538333296776, -0.00830825511366129, -0.051743559539318085, 0.00704019982367754, -0.059003692120313644, 0.0019173952750861645, 0.05474290996789932, 0.004348003305494785, 0.06139356270432472, 0.013613016344606876, -0.011539543978869915, -0.0030486148316413164, -0.016597239300608635, 0.0030259506311267614, 0.015085048042237759, -0.07114274799823761, -0.004409459885209799, -0.05909348651766777, -0.024780211970210075, 0.03978464752435684, -0.025493711233139038, -0.00008805005199974403, 0.022382037714123726, 0.00001044111377268564, -0.011680728755891323, 0.0616924986243248, -0.0074848574586212635, -0.001335256383754313, -0.020652947947382927, -0.016972651705145836, 0.021712789312005043, 0.007203965447843075, -0.035749487578868866, 0.022114960476756096, 0.02711406722664833, -0.014167473651468754, -0.05782924219965935, -0.0026524087879806757, -0.02700211852788925, -0.017453189939260483, -0.005518432706594467, 0.013348010368645191, 0.019032102078199387, -0.021245645359158516, 0.0005575076211243868, -0.022554468363523483, 0.0032400961499661207, 0.019393058493733406, 0.032763730734586716, -0.009136809036135674, -0.024738749489188194, -0.0031346476171165705, -0.014954524114727974, 0.018201274797320366, 0.045065365731716156, -0.0021256476175040007, -0.011127287521958351, -0.03692448139190674, -0.05264905467629433, 0.019285645335912704, 0.01047245692461729, 0.0006316503277048469, -0.025101253762841225, 0.05824285373091698, -0.03443779796361923, -0.011045201681554317, 0.00933501124382019, -0.04110636189579964, 0.01981278695166111, -0.0744817852973938, 0.048125673085451126, 0.016191581264138222, -0.002880585379898548, -0.02569829858839512, -0.0009556690929457545, -0.026743445545434952, 0.013487505726516247, 0.038126539438962936, -0.0038584412541240454, -0.0028046215884387493, 0.007148196455091238, 0.0024471431970596313, 0.019441362470388412, -0.004602034576237202, 0.0424649715423584, -0.02163158915936947, -0.007698243949562311, 0.009200474247336388, 0.01376077439635992, -0.03099949285387993, -0.021098390221595764, 0.023917458951473236, -0.01634165830910206, 0.005147239658981562, 0.023186296224594116, -0.02491629123687744, 0.04921814799308777, 0.012847541831433773, -0.03656709939241409, 0.03776957467198372, -0.027314169332385063, 0.0064097801223397255, 0.016260629519820213, 0.010527337901294231, -0.0712062194943428, 0.08809363096952438, -0.03287911042571068, -0.04480322077870369, -0.03158650919795036, 0.0163020808249712, -0.017076274380087852, -0.04623143747448921, 0.019783921539783478, 0.023815525695681572, -0.022775398567318916, -0.012592121958732605, 0.0110551118850708, 0.023835226893424988, 0.059902627021074295, 0.02647113800048828, -0.012066110037267208, -0.0039892056956887245, -0.045645784586668015, -0.00945693626999855, 0.002944546053186059, 0.053235094994306564, -0.01885322481393814, -0.014978292398154736, 0.003790078917518258, -0.0037943157367408276, 0.014261779375374317, 0.016690248623490334, 0.034339189529418945, -0.03812715411186218, -0.004588061012327671, 0.05393929034471512, 0.008770955726504326, 0.021147863939404488, 0.016947487369179726, 0.021805407479405403, 0.05088936910033226, -0.024272596463561058, -0.029962321743369102, -0.03157087042927742, -0.02424115501344204, -0.01332166325300932, 0.003167038084939122, -0.01772465370595455, 0.04799741879105568, -0.015009399503469467, 0.010561062954366207, -0.018147733062505722, -0.01580311544239521, 0.026930823922157288, -0.05071607232093811, -0.012927158735692501, 0.0020272010006010532, 0.004771439824253321, 0.027280203998088837, -0.013583192601799965, -0.02658092975616455, -0.03289542347192764, 0.03529570251703262, 0.02498389221727848, 0.027638772502541542, -0.02938026748597622, -0.04415861889719963, -0.008839824236929417, 0.033174190670251846, -0.03312908858060837, -0.018048148602247238, -0.05140244960784912, 0.02480083517730236, 0.007112151477485895, 0.017574956640601158 ]
<p>I am computing SVD on a matrix which is the empirical version of $E[XY^{\top}]$ for some $X \in \mathbb{R}^{m \times 1}$ and $Y \in \mathbb{R}^{n \times 1}$.</p> <p>I am wondering if there are standard ways to preprocess $x_1,\ldots,x_l$ and $y_1,\ldots,y_l$ before doing that (other than subtracting the mean and dividing by standard deviation).</p> <p>This is related to the question here: <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/12200/normalizing-variables-for-svd-pca">&quot;Normalizing&quot; variables for SVD / PCA</a>.</p>
162
[ -0.026960575953125954, 0.03763973340392113, -0.012329121120274067, -0.019387459382414818, 0.03912655636668205, -0.011519970372319221, -0.019909236580133438, -0.05188700556755066, 0.024218278005719185, -0.024646513164043427, 0.05606906861066818, 0.03290151059627533, 0.052971962839365005, 0.035779278725385666, 0.027207281440496445, -0.020668452605605125, -0.02413121424615383, -0.01674574241042137, 0.005565410479903221, 0.021643690764904022, 0.023290572687983513, -0.011202994734048843, 0.01155627891421318, 0.007878538221120834, -0.005535805132240057, 0.08625762164592743, 0.0014644794864580035, -0.02319442108273506, 0.022241998463869095, 0.07422924786806107, -0.018973618745803833, -0.036942917853593826, 0.03731643408536911, 0.056434519588947296, -0.023939255625009537, 0.008568745106458664, -0.003712350269779563, -0.016413241624832153, -0.0002545742900110781, 0.0346345454454422, -0.008484446443617344, 0.007889914326369762, 0.010030772536993027, 0.037721965461969376, -0.004039393737912178, 0.037936896085739136, 0.0017313294811174273, -0.04644684121012688, 0.0037823861930519342, -0.0351857915520668, 0.09580671787261963, 0.011444555595517159, 0.03174393251538277, 0.02765178494155407, -0.012597604654729366, -0.0005016598734073341, 0.046897731721401215, 0.04374130442738533, 0.03130168095231056, -0.06639982759952545, 0.00639721192419529, -0.014317700639367104, -0.0020796158351004124, -0.04035404324531555, -0.018870985135436058, 0.035308029502630234, 0.000025798752176342532, -0.013529323041439056, 0.028996901586651802, -0.036244798451662064, -0.016924463212490082, 0.01599457673728466, -0.00037961144698783755, -0.023192357271909714, 0.0018870050553232431, -0.007396646309643984, 0.0032899524085223675, 0.04358767345547676, 0.030308736488223076, 0.012049700133502483, 0.03196519985795021, 0.03569483011960983, 0.03154360130429268, 0.016627920791506767, -0.0050242929719388485, 0.028325483202934265, 0.07725562900304794, -0.011366275139153004, 0.01194724440574646, 0.01681373082101345, 0.025233225896954536, 0.022686460986733437, 0.06649775803089142, 0.002072354080155492, -0.054560091346502304, 0.02288474515080452, 0.005275900941342115, 0.03722997382283211, -0.006492184940725565, -0.030242450535297394, -0.004334463272243738, -0.02807484194636345, 0.0004181418917141855, 0.03885345533490181, -0.03188950940966606, -0.0025718992110341787, -0.055263154208660126, 0.027661157771945, -0.012346707284450531, -0.06509242206811905, -0.01197543554008007, 0.030683105811476707, -0.019597170874476433, -0.02229149267077446, 0.008317667990922928, -0.009800643660128117, -0.004131931345909834, 0.0009046061895787716, 0.04558360576629639, 0.05693279206752777, 0.024753810837864876, -0.03182104229927063, 0.028308354318141937, -0.013552991673350334, -0.05346241220831871, 0.020085763186216354, 0.03444432467222214, 0.009026476182043552, -0.058198366314172745, 0.041102420538663864, 0.004153163637965918, -0.048206087201833725, 0.04569597542285919, -0.014773991890251637, 0.022909611463546753, 0.020380990579724312, -0.07552090287208557, -0.038355469703674316, 0.03641289472579956, -0.005646387115120888, 0.0038202661089599133, -0.07081927359104156, -0.010092346929013729, 0.005889009218662977, 0.03448693826794624, -0.00013020676851738244, 0.03395010158419609, 0.012632915750145912, 0.02676401473581791, -0.0037904507480561733, -0.017205355688929558, -0.04243477061390877, -0.03366107866168022, -0.03000504896044731, -0.03709202632308006, -0.03432942181825638, 0.02925090864300728, 0.04356963187456131, -0.000588623050134629, 0.02788013033568859, 0.018697695806622505, 0.020901774987578392, -0.024611180648207664, 0.008880768902599812, 0.020401503890752792, -0.04996046423912048, 0.02692270651459694, 0.006105022970587015, 0.0269454438239336, 0.03499646112322807, -0.010556070134043694, 0.028363943099975586, 0.003361550159752369, 0.061435408890247345, 0.05629454553127289, -0.004880610853433609, -0.00964044313877821, -0.02081410028040409, 0.03427151218056679, 0.015587085857987404, -0.07195839285850525, -0.04832100868225098, -0.004677349701523781, 0.0006401953287422657, 0.032818425446748734, 0.09914690256118774, -0.006713893264532089, -0.031135356053709984, 0.0001163781707873568, -0.042886603623628616, -0.007168216165155172, -0.046839576214551926, 0.01334617380052805, -0.0130455968901515, -0.02840779349207878, 0.02753233164548874, -0.002131382003426552, 0.03580616042017937, -0.021811457350850105, -0.009139035828411579, -0.011741291731595993, 0.006506061647087336, 0.06865911930799484, -0.07504460215568542, -0.019323714077472687, 0.03285684064030647, 0.062410611659288406, 0.0022099376656115055, 0.023187322542071342, -0.03726727515459061, -0.033936772495508194, -0.016164671629667282, -0.032080672681331635, 0.057853374630212784, -0.01298321969807148, -0.0009134880383498967, 0.005445508286356926, 0.015213724225759506, -0.03455749899148941, -0.0007974238251335919, -0.022252675145864487, 0.036817409098148346, 0.030496928840875626, -0.0030273054726421833, -0.019452091306447983, -0.011991080828011036, 0.0435774140059948, 0.04015140235424042, -0.02479994110763073, -0.0014184406027197838, -0.01976051926612854, 0.0038716730196028948, 0.051605720072984695, 0.04180143401026726, -0.08379391580820084, 0.004540490452200174, 0.10252281278371811, 0.054554760456085205, 0.023691918700933456, 0.02407044731080532, -0.02230263128876686, -0.01032650750130415, -0.007775848265737295, 0.0491681769490242, -0.013370762579143047, -0.017282819375395775, 0.0018342183902859688, -0.002044401131570339, 0.050482552498579025, 0.042585186660289764, -0.029146790504455566, 0.014101392589509487, -0.02731739543378353, 0.03039136901497841, -0.025853808969259262, -0.004848210606724024, 0.05923960730433464, 0.011208423413336277, 0.004603971261531115, 0.01467602327466011, -0.022738231346011162, -0.01862310990691185, 0.011896028183400631, -0.010806428268551826, 0.0032067259307950735, 0.03209741786122322, -0.051422540098428726, 0.041104238480329514, 0.013203009963035583, -0.011048086918890476, 0.009879264049232006, -0.028351692482829094, -0.050911594182252884, -0.040547244250774384, 0.006776347756385803, 0.056096091866493225, -0.02029663883149624, 0.034084051847457886, -0.032093971967697144, -0.0020204666070640087, 0.013606484048068523, -0.013114900328218937, 0.024020656943321228, 0.015553743578493595, -0.04368441179394722, 0.003080288413912058, -0.07402021437883377, -0.011539631523191929, 0.018601804971694946, -0.012383406050503254, -0.015982259064912796, 0.030144842341542244, 0.02244834415614605, -0.02448197826743126, 0.007305148057639599, -0.008189640939235687, 0.04460902512073517, -0.007817956618964672, -0.009752015583217144, 0.0325118787586689, 0.019695177674293518, -0.04708809778094292, -0.022419558838009834, -0.034558575600385666, -0.014830789528787136, -0.025801029056310654, -0.04011918976902962, -0.011677943170070648, -0.011819659732282162, 0.015840139240026474, 0.04479188844561577, -0.03131949529051781, 0.030392823740839958, -0.05267632007598877, -0.023942142724990845, 0.029596712440252304, 0.01633945107460022, 0.046266186982393265, 0.014003257267177105, -0.03676594793796539, 0.0846426784992218, 0.024334702640771866, -0.02046172320842743, -0.04080060496926308, 0.027565639466047287, -0.03313609957695007, -0.02879437804222107, -0.01548883505165577, 0.01245922315865755, 0.019242258742451668, 0.031242817640304565, 0.014360309578478336, -0.014240085147321224, 0.08548202365636826, 0.01292956992983818, -0.006190819200128317, 0.01975051499903202, -0.013649584725499153, 0.022406501695513725, 0.055626578629016876, -0.003574294038116932, 0.024437308311462402, -0.023721814155578613, 0.016500795260071754, 0.028687849640846252, 0.01226777583360672, -0.021750526502728462, -0.0016323699383065104, -0.050092488527297974, 0.007967489771544933, -0.011439203284680843, 0.007404441479593515, 0.04001004621386528, -0.031162917613983154, 0.013667679391801357, 0.04002960026264191, 0.0019222216214984655, -0.026123683899641037, 0.040924154222011566, 0.05471525341272354, 0.02814214862883091, 0.001945042284205556, -0.017620593309402466, 0.00990243162959814, -0.031066857278347015, 0.030299590900540352, -0.011319012381136417, -0.010280260816216469, 0.017640966922044754, 0.04447537660598755, 0.015032278373837471, -0.0003410479112062603, -0.033263321965932846, 0.030060190707445145, -0.07309432327747345, 0.011906102299690247, -0.029935549944639206, 0.028117263689637184, 0.0456460677087307, 0.037638843059539795, 0.014649559743702412, -0.035756517201662064, 0.0022731684148311615, -0.016113916411995888, -0.07018876075744629, -0.011692728847265244, -0.02709588035941124, -0.015437399037182331, -0.02175711840391159, 0.007970325648784637, 0.055801209062337875, -0.02026369795203209, 0.0192837156355381, 0.006515423767268658, 0.004876040853559971, -0.04891762509942055, -0.024325523525476456, -0.018310539424419403, -0.011406278237700462, -0.049496911466121674, 0.018011778593063354, 0.04029104486107826, -0.012791113927960396, 0.03716781735420227, 0.0024009132757782936, -0.016534684225916862, -0.020767640322446823, -0.0034224134869873524, 0.0043800524435937405, 0.028024721890687943, 0.029815221205353737, -0.0028664213605225086, 0.04015948995947838, -0.03444408252835274, 0.014067639596760273, -0.0053673433139920235, 0.04474068060517311, 0.026959635317325592, -0.019314192235469818, 0.004347656853497028, -0.03687845170497894, -0.005633451975882053, 0.009083361364901066, 0.02467448078095913, -0.014394547790288925, 0.018367746844887733, 0.03801165893673897, 0.01851673796772957, -0.04113568365573883, 0.0022569054272025824, 0.059195853769779205, 0.01578584872186184, -0.005802607629448175, -0.03314325213432312, -0.011886611580848694, -0.01727977953851223, -0.0027010065969079733, 0.014483265578746796, 0.004286647774279118, 0.02231569215655327, -0.02673592045903206, 0.04037421569228172, -0.02628803811967373, -0.003528542583808303, 0.0018122961046174169, 0.02945188619196415, 0.06825502216815948, -0.017919044941663742, -0.04397201910614967, 0.04042230173945427, 0.04725063219666481, 0.037288494408130646, 0.010774927213788033, -0.0011174380779266357, -0.06080746278166771, 0.009240390732884407, 0.020562494173645973, 0.05151785537600517, -0.01370517909526825, -0.020903313532471657, -0.035534877330064774, 0.005267411470413208, 0.03821396827697754, -0.001421501743607223, 0.016023335978388786, -0.013182034716010094, -0.03595823049545288, -0.04994461312890053, -0.016953645274043083, -0.06823984533548355, 0.0015804916620254517, -0.009216898120939732, 0.06642847508192062, -0.03029075637459755, -0.04734008014202118, -0.05893973633646965, -0.014337568543851376, 0.0028686297591775656, 0.050471335649490356, 0.00998595729470253, -0.03198915347456932, -0.001986387651413679, 0.04218987748026848, -0.01876864768564701, -0.0808195248246193, 0.013881748542189598, 0.06128713861107826, -0.032166074961423874, 0.030733555555343628, -0.011856386438012123, -0.07138338685035706, 0.02855609729886055, 0.017955657094717026, -0.0021580487955361605, 0.0028851821552962065, 0.011818353086709976, 0.05136904865503311, 0.008026154711842537, 0.01494169607758522, 0.05433221906423569, 0.0072406274266541, 0.00022412596445064992, 0.007814250886440277, -0.051768817007541656, -0.0016894405707716942, -0.047684770077466965, -0.015689793974161148, -0.05243798717856407, -0.004853858612477779, -0.005977074149996042, 0.03838510811328888, -0.03828436881303787, 0.04049113392829895, 0.00674485182389617, -0.023448413237929344, 0.006654241122305393, 0.03338637948036194, -0.009394447319209576, -0.04283212870359421, 0.01588139496743679, 0.042981356382369995, -0.023080263286828995, -0.0008426917484030128, 0.01285620965063572, -0.019800636917352676, 0.013481714762747288, -0.002434340538457036, -0.03344281390309334, 0.006414703093469143, -0.045858003199100494, -0.01514520775526762, 0.0026949653401970863, -0.033184513449668884, 0.032756414264440536, -0.021147415041923523, 0.03626178950071335, -0.009882600978016853, 0.01775970123708248, 0.013098834082484245, 0.004341151099652052, 0.004390370566397905, 0.022172333672642708, -0.048495035618543625, 0.017780302092432976, -0.006558353081345558, 0.0068963030353188515, -0.04781820625066757, -0.05074133351445198, 0.01861093007028103, -0.002334101125597954, -0.011753110215067863, -0.04406595602631569, 0.010862527415156364, -0.021274354308843613, -0.036029718816280365, 0.004961033817380667, 0.04030046612024307, -0.04504543915390968, -0.020069686695933342, -0.010220853611826897, 0.04519175365567207, 0.08112259209156036, -0.0395660363137722, -0.0021165814250707626, 0.025762030854821205, -0.02220388501882553, -0.003960706759244204, 0.014279629103839397, 0.01962226629257202, -0.05383526161313057, 0.01580209471285343, -0.04622332751750946, -0.025142570957541466, 0.01866990700364113, -0.014776033349335194, 0.0043124486692249775, 0.017904609441757202, 0.020795756950974464, 0.0017928913002833724, -0.018414784222841263, 0.011608755216002464, 0.008019893430173397, -0.023422719910740852, 0.003802055958658457, -0.02423335798084736, -0.0073218089528381824, -0.004018146079033613, 0.02066342532634735, 0.002724116202443838, -0.007127175573259592, -0.0034579047933220863, 0.09732349216938019, 0.011662830598652363, 0.034865349531173706, -0.027355294674634933, -0.008179346099495888, 0.03138534724712372, 0.004610719159245491, -0.001283705816604197, 0.034163571894168854, 0.0025041531771421432, -0.020447973161935806, -0.08108339458703995, -0.06656581908464432, -0.011895074509084225, 0.04678114876151085, 0.013889889232814312, 0.08376648277044296, 0.04031747952103615, -0.015511204488575459, -0.009985472075641155, -0.04742210730910301, -0.01979537308216095, 0.0036247570533305407, -0.010614786297082901, 0.019075626507401466, 0.007731437683105469, -0.01415459718555212, 0.044207751750946045, 0.053989287465810776, -0.012986048124730587, 0.050601210445165634, 0.005069195758551359, -0.0005515189259313047, 0.029310882091522217, -0.01330883614718914, -0.02846481464803219, 0.04527387395501137, -0.041316960006952286, 0.024084558710455894, -0.011025352403521538, -0.014594214037060738, 0.03873931244015694, 0.06668916344642639, -0.026857953518629074, -0.031452104449272156, -0.01024970319122076, -0.06858571618795395, 0.000596300233155489, 0.04071246460080147, -0.010455933399498463, 0.01790437288582325, 0.002452309476211667, 0.02020876668393612, -0.030170291662216187, 0.03342316672205925, -0.0023551760241389275, -0.0619366429746151, -0.006793293170630932, -0.015642184764146805, -0.018770480528473854, 0.020470140501856804, 0.00611587380990386, -0.0031195401679724455, -0.014485679566860199, -0.03785362094640732, 0.020522790029644966, -0.029947416856884956, 0.046815525740385056, -0.005226894281804562, 0.046515487134456635, -0.011357921175658703, -0.0005126595497131348, -0.02296575717628002, -0.009383301250636578, 0.09454207122325897, 0.09354625642299652, 0.05898527055978775, -0.05978299304842949, 0.008390712551772594, 0.029277756810188293, 0.007854373194277287, -0.02939934842288494, -0.002454252215102315, -0.04032116383314133, -0.0030428345780819654, 0.014189546927809715, 0.024502485990524292, -0.013664614409208298, -0.029593482613563538, 0.04274691268801689, -0.015857050195336342, -0.018971189856529236, 0.03205381706357002, -0.005482007749378681, -0.05099112540483475, -0.018341263756155968, -0.039902061223983765, 0.04517916589975357, -0.02318827621638775, -0.04817761480808258, -0.03510536625981331, 0.001834031194448471, -0.0028304499574005604, -0.04606858640909195, -0.013758937828242779, 0.010495088063180447, 0.04259480908513069, 0.003908897750079632, -0.012813570909202099, 0.012556294910609722, 0.01424168236553669, -0.033960625529289246, 0.012138426303863525, 0.0045066880993545055, -0.03144364058971405, 0.0034153710585087538, 0.015101457946002483, -0.010525544174015522, -0.040834441781044006, -0.021009044721722603, 0.004263091832399368, 0.07595960795879364, -0.011807030066847801, -0.011623729951679707, -0.01071241032332182, -0.008069676347076893, -0.0392073318362236, -0.04092125594615936, 0.035432543605566025, 0.016265952959656715, 0.04078058898448944, 0.0029905468691140413, 0.010264432989060879, -0.023331118747591972, 0.015153764747083187, -0.010110885836184025, 0.026310797780752182, 0.025901686400175095, 0.0024643540382385254, -0.02317970246076584, 0.008739879354834557, 0.055348802357912064, -0.013447172939777374, -0.029781430959701538, -0.03227367252111435, -0.032941434532403946, -0.009822024963796139, -0.04733153432607651, 0.012097924016416073, -0.011826841160655022, 0.04824578016996384, -0.003307904116809368, -0.002672447357326746, -0.045330408960580826, -0.06779874116182327, 0.002844269620254636, -0.019588528200984, -0.0010275017702952027, -0.04892832785844803, 0.012904452160000801, 0.011877868324518204, 0.03729937598109245, 0.04516961798071861, -0.012061255984008312, 0.005958144553005695, 0.05856877937912941, 0.030814524739980698, -0.008115853182971478, -0.017549550160765648, -0.0022465544752776623, -0.012163645587861538, 0.01625100150704384, 0.0020101009868085384, 0.045945145189762115, 0.035628724843263626, -0.014400885440409184, -0.028572265058755875, 0.04861239343881607, -0.006260069087147713, 0.0016725081950426102, -0.019488545134663582, -0.05224323272705078, 0.02125486172735691, -0.012162805534899235, -0.007971778512001038, -0.005592806730419397, -0.0015837239334359765, -0.011574222706258297, 0.0037971013225615025, -0.011275592260062695, -0.007335349917411804, -0.00559421069920063, 0.00201233453117311, -0.040292225778102875, 0.031080642715096474, -0.028445523232221603, -0.0206715390086174, 0.013959848321974277, 0.019634412601590157, -0.014748119749128819, -0.032657187432050705, -0.026375850662589073, -0.017128661274909973, 0.01760355941951275, 0.04062501713633537, 0.03659225255250931, 0.021769234910607338, 0.013201680965721607, -0.05354345962405205, 0.03173244744539261, -0.012676293961703777, 0.05864395201206207, -0.018945889547467232, -0.020848840475082397, 0.010702729225158691, -0.042998287826776505, -0.0049157580360770226, 0.0038907763082534075, 0.03234768658876419, 0.04372713714838028, 0.003268084954470396, -0.01816125400364399, -0.06634263694286346, 0.023955566808581352, -0.0070054675452411175, -0.019991504028439522, -0.018198620527982712, -0.018296562135219574, -0.015472795814275742, 0.04368811473250389, 0.03355177119374275, -0.017031501978635788, -0.006512506399303675, 0.035066064447164536, 0.02016635425388813, -0.02573520317673683, -0.03221180662512779, 0.04050032049417496, -0.0003982113266829401, 0.02323552966117859, 0.013177243992686272, -0.02134212665259838, 0.07106727361679077, 0.038568753749132156, -0.02353822998702526, 0.004386566579341888, -0.014996298588812351, -0.0020097922533750534, -0.06992772966623306, -0.022164132446050644, 0.0025794103275984526, 0.0015631893184036016, 0.02378992922604084, -0.08099482208490372, 0.006294299848377705, 0.0529252327978611, -0.059190552681684494, 0.01437838189303875, 0.021523041650652885, -0.017312292009592056, -0.03161678463220596, 0.0402851440012455, 0.015919923782348633, -0.011337808333337307, -0.0012914440594613552, 0.00044899937347508967, 0.013708582147955894, 0.01947796531021595, 0.01814577914774418, -0.034534014761447906, -0.015195251442492008, 0.05159389600157738, -0.005948731675744057, -0.08245965093374252, 0.0211016982793808, -0.046230848878622055, -0.021092072129249573, 0.018570013344287872, 0.02239622175693512, 0.017926005646586418, 0.02581099607050419, 0.057283833622932434, -0.013233567588031292, 0.031550776213407516, 0.026410464197397232, 0.00617264537140727, -0.008483369834721088, -0.0016593413893133402, 0.012510109692811966, 0.03298882767558098, -0.026360714808106422, -0.005078424699604511, 0.030441028997302055, -0.03932624310255051, -0.03662823140621185, 0.02095809020102024, -0.02868620678782463, -0.035817280411720276, -0.01707417517900467, -0.039828166365623474, -0.026872487738728523, -0.04622281715273857, 0.018006296828389168, -0.0072605493478477, -0.01738116890192032, 0.011244019493460655, -0.01072845607995987, -0.01777762919664383, 0.017050020396709442, 0.01950027234852314, -0.045153260231018066, 0.03123345784842968, 0.014072448015213013, 0.007580909412354231, -0.06887443363666534, -0.024249590933322906, 0.008160203695297241, -0.046200357377529144, -0.02211141400039196, -0.055380742996931076, -0.04171530902385712, 0.0346335805952549, -0.0240209698677063, 0.014935631304979324, -0.0014174382667988539, -0.0022265289444476366, -0.008189814165234566, -0.03057650849223137, 0.04917379468679428, 0.010021088644862175, -0.05521102994680405, 0.012608055025339127, 0.01869063451886177, -0.041639216244220734, -0.02082950621843338, 0.056681569665670395, 0.024708496406674385, 0.020143549889326096, -0.0231512151658535, 0.022944366559386253, -0.00010097811900777742, -0.08467268943786621, 0.04309389367699623, -0.026879478245973587, -0.0050040194764733315, -0.022718625143170357, -0.03153587132692337, 0.03395581617951393, 0.022316621616482735, 0.03530048206448555, -0.017035815864801407, -0.013907832093536854, 0.01978575438261032, -0.019259629771113396, 0.053679246455430984, 0.036369688808918, -0.023361843079328537, 0.03425503149628639, 0.03350221365690231, 0.0005626390338875353, 0.00638608681038022, -0.018810350447893143, -0.001208454486913979, 0.01493422407656908, -0.05023236572742462, -0.016173388808965683, 0.003136748680844903, 0.015800047665834427, 0.026026656851172447, -0.08175735175609589, -0.01125827431678772, 0.03501778468489647, -0.051851361989974976, 0.02086339145898819, 0.015304910019040108, -0.006299846805632114, 0.028815163299441338, 0.01682395674288273, 0.058589812368154526, 0.034258414059877396, -0.007583077065646648, 0.010625630617141724, -0.007534276228398085, 0.04626452177762985, 0.011770271696150303, -0.023268571123480797, 0.022230807691812515, -0.0031850554514676332, 0.05281177908182144, -0.016093125566840172, 0.030614549294114113, -0.03415112942457199, -0.0129884984344244, 0.03526843339204788, -0.01858423836529255, -0.0019617744255810976, -0.04167784005403519, -0.03483272343873978, 0.047630928456783295, -0.046624556183815, -0.02495969831943512, -0.07251600921154022, -0.023515308275818825, 0.006718162912875414, -0.028808578848838806, -0.00016191968461498618, 0.016598908230662346, 0.008929857984185219, 0.0005595411639660597, -0.008058592677116394, -0.018757330253720284, 0.01572951301932335, -0.015148279257118702, 0.047723058611154556, -0.006297240033745766, 0.023429647088050842, 0.007662021555006504, -0.026468154042959213, -0.022799843922257423, -0.008109654299914837, 0.024647030979394913, 0.026957852765917778, 0.03929822891950607, -0.010085230693221092, -0.025272555649280548, 0.006001361180096865, 0.024454699829220772, -0.04598948732018471, -0.03934071213006973, -0.008791602216660976, 0.010350843891501427, -0.004967574030160904, -0.0016407030634582043 ]
<p>I have two models. First, $$z=\alpha_1x+\alpha_2+\epsilon$$ and second, $$z=\beta_1x+\beta_2y+\beta_3+\epsilon.$$</p> <p>What factors affect whether $\alpha_1\approx\beta_1$? Note that I don't care how accurately either model predicts $z$. I only care about how similar the coefficient of the $x$ term is in both models.</p> <p>Assume both $x$ and $y$ actually predict $z$ and don't interact.</p>
36,691
[ -0.03157174959778786, -0.032970577478408813, -0.02958039566874504, 0.012229904532432556, 0.02491799369454384, 0.02944980561733246, -0.005366509314626455, -0.01733776554465294, 0.05311841145157814, -0.009423998184502125, 0.007087525445967913, -0.001618396257981658, 0.09872657060623169, -0.003594044828787446, 0.02695257030427456, 0.0019829063676297665, -0.025757579132914543, 0.0178405549377203, 0.0014728510286659002, 0.0058942739851772785, 0.012821570038795471, 0.033273085951805115, 0.024682827293872833, 0.024575529620051384, -0.043773818761110306, 0.06512819230556488, 0.045283231884241104, -0.025706501677632332, -0.0028691617771983147, 0.008954296819865704, -0.003905654652044177, -0.015045367181301117, 0.006394247990101576, 0.0704386755824089, 0.02664080448448658, -0.005045897793024778, -0.019344788044691086, -0.024520795792341232, -0.02708769403398037, 0.04578610882163048, -0.052429404109716415, -0.024225477129220963, -0.014356457628309727, 0.01339713018387556, -0.0009973776759579778, -0.004155282396823168, -0.04185868427157402, -0.04104340821504593, 0.03813672438263893, -0.0059689730405807495, 0.04190120846033096, -0.014350015670061111, 0.021649781614542007, 0.06329333037137985, -0.019553741440176964, -0.025816956534981728, 0.05055064707994461, 0.08642600476741791, -0.010166332125663757, -0.032912153750658035, -0.0074140639044344425, -0.005047986749559641, 0.016165178269147873, 0.006320674903690815, -0.05285909026861191, 0.04388817027211189, 0.0014541358686983585, -0.025266475975513458, 0.020148156210780144, -0.02502523548901081, 0.006904848385602236, 0.02742554247379303, 0.01657884009182453, 0.023516042158007622, 0.0037617175839841366, -0.022123469039797783, -0.0024556447751820087, 0.07994599640369415, 0.06020163744688034, 0.03480236232280731, -0.030602265149354935, 0.007546279113739729, 0.04217338562011719, 0.015279408544301987, 0.02607749029994011, 0.01130321528762579, 0.045711539685726166, -0.011915543116629124, -0.024802014231681824, 0.020545832812786102, -0.03816166892647743, 0.02906237542629242, 0.03074047900736332, -0.014678677543997765, -0.017689025029540062, 0.0310805831104517, -0.01595006138086319, 0.014659801498055458, 0.024281108751893044, -0.01786494255065918, -0.0024008373729884624, -0.02622588910162449, -0.01829066500067711, 0.07052261382341385, 0.003714288817718625, -0.04185380041599274, -0.035190925002098083, -0.0378747321665287, -0.032737649977207184, -0.05174868553876877, -0.001948278397321701, 0.03654495254158974, -0.0036744752433151007, -0.016786912456154823, 0.019705239683389664, -0.004848804324865341, 0.007947566919028759, -0.03283468633890152, 0.050856441259384155, 0.05952782183885574, 0.035670049488544464, -0.023550113663077354, -0.012564634904265404, -0.007033565081655979, -0.01933843456208706, -0.016708428040146828, 0.04027751833200455, -0.06621948629617691, -0.04382522776722908, 0.04276452958583832, 0.025957737118005753, -0.033886611461639404, -0.0018482964951545, -0.02782142162322998, 0.028702545911073685, 0.021084243431687355, -0.06119846552610397, -0.051631487905979156, 0.003568854182958603, -0.02524113655090332, 0.014833217486739159, -0.03496543690562248, -0.0040301051922142506, 0.047679927200078964, 0.060190413147211075, 0.015683338046073914, 0.05463114008307457, 0.04181285202503204, 0.03392866998910904, 0.04827742278575897, -0.027391990646719933, -0.0340559184551239, -0.028068505227565765, 0.01097846683114767, -0.025961337611079216, -0.0302721057087183, 0.009442005306482315, -0.00998271256685257, -0.03624795377254486, 0.00608475599437952, 0.06908081471920013, 0.005438154097646475, -0.01441890187561512, -0.002061298117041588, 0.04523257538676262, -0.029394639655947685, 0.04576144739985466, 0.004071742761880159, 0.0652993768453598, 0.037257470190525055, -0.026047300547361374, 0.024591056630015373, 0.004956157878041267, 0.041264548897743225, 0.07224483042955399, 0.012787564657628536, -0.042731866240501404, -0.02516990154981613, -0.0263608880341053, 0.026761015877127647, -0.06469075381755829, -0.04309461638331413, -0.04587605968117714, 0.002703845500946045, -0.02538672462105751, 0.04801173880696297, 0.00637928256765008, -0.016091329976916313, 0.03178410604596138, -0.012535473331809044, -0.05516932159662247, -0.05481741204857826, 0.0056848726235330105, 0.002245834795758128, -0.008942527696490288, 0.0695328339934349, -0.014808409847319126, -0.0007037929026409984, -0.0003773889038711786, -0.0013449297985062003, -0.018057381734251976, 0.012182044796645641, 0.04422813281416893, -0.044615957885980606, 0.036066293716430664, 0.057448241859674454, 0.07159018516540527, -0.04213450103998184, 0.06543395668268204, -0.023250877857208252, -0.059669602662324905, 0.03501711040735245, -0.02971588261425495, 0.0027192288544028997, -0.045458290725946426, -0.004751462955027819, 0.009672955609858036, -0.014127994887530804, 0.010880201123654842, 0.028603561222553253, -0.06826400011777878, 0.0436854362487793, 0.06729669123888016, -0.01344592310488224, -0.024206742644309998, 0.005487292539328337, -0.0075947255827486515, 0.05756743997335434, -0.029767120257019997, -0.03899282589554787, -0.03240536153316498, -0.04533955454826355, 0.035132911056280136, 0.028085073456168175, -0.04111640155315399, 0.01704462431371212, 0.044309258460998535, 0.0067119598388671875, 0.00938438531011343, 0.03963562846183777, 0.01326226256787777, 0.005208649672567844, 0.0008499434334225953, 0.00848844088613987, 0.025463048368692398, 0.007746389601379633, 0.008798382245004177, -0.001378939370624721, 0.02619645558297634, -0.03175982087850571, -0.000983312726020813, 0.05700543150305748, 0.007154893130064011, 0.019688621163368225, -0.025914905592799187, -0.010626837611198425, 0.022185049951076508, -0.034539468586444855, 0.004935842473059893, 0.03108350932598114, 0.006866601761430502, 0.00197707605548203, 0.03485647961497307, 0.0128195621073246, 0.013550616800785065, 0.06656841933727264, -0.039308205246925354, 0.015976278111338615, 0.03229312598705292, -0.05440176650881767, 0.010556599125266075, -0.022481773048639297, -0.011235824786126614, 0.010518177412450314, -0.012115484103560448, 0.019040696322917938, -0.006625681184232235, 0.004624280612915754, -0.03202911093831062, -0.01445978693664074, 0.02112574316561222, -0.008190130814909935, 0.03752617537975311, 0.018452467396855354, -0.05651266127824783, 0.0037756545934826136, -0.042342741042375565, 0.006628419738262892, 0.029247857630252838, 0.015925602987408638, -0.0020058462396264076, 0.019894694909453392, -0.032008714973926544, -0.06599518656730652, -0.036663513630628586, -0.0458320714533329, 0.008183589205145836, -0.02893766015768051, -0.021476993337273598, 0.034163910895586014, 0.020332541316747665, -0.05512518063187599, 0.008376805111765862, -0.009952413849532604, -0.013849526643753052, -0.00581651646643877, -0.004407442640513182, -0.001154090161435306, -0.011389732360839844, 0.023028621450066566, 0.03452276811003685, -0.026538722217082977, 0.008763696998357773, -0.039961136877536774, -0.050556909292936325, 0.010247096419334412, 0.01313745230436325, 0.028857726603746414, 0.003235948970541358, -0.02646883763372898, 0.09027823060750961, 0.017966121435165405, -0.015224665403366089, -0.0336371548473835, -0.011009368114173412, -0.0361609123647213, -0.02069530263543129, 0.031285692006349564, 0.020884960889816284, 0.0004968752036802471, 0.035904690623283386, 0.002941007725894451, 0.03775982931256294, 0.011881058104336262, 0.0204501710832119, 0.012543382123112679, 0.03020419552922249, 0.04149193689227104, -0.03282822668552399, 0.009191309101879597, -0.007172010838985443, -0.013772455975413322, 0.007144029252231121, 0.008654420264065266, 0.031026117503643036, 0.013347195461392403, -0.046850334852933884, 0.007793471682816744, -0.007450491655617952, 0.012728645466268063, 0.007737088482826948, 0.06292004883289337, 0.03082132525742054, -0.04258591681718826, -0.017134642228484154, 0.02251608483493328, 0.05731735751032829, -0.014800840988755226, 0.008455490693449974, 0.03210600093007088, 0.0416673943400383, -0.02324778027832508, 0.018484823405742645, -0.06243790313601494, -0.003745462978258729, 0.0016685243463143706, -0.028813263401389122, -0.02640404924750328, 0.03314903378486633, 0.018508661538362503, -0.02348862960934639, -0.023457791656255722, -0.01747329905629158, -0.024771153926849365, -0.07749807834625244, -0.022805500775575638, -0.04452836140990257, 0.03671538829803467, 0.008371609263122082, 0.05583483725786209, -0.015747154131531715, -0.008432394824922085, 0.020296037197113037, -0.005811518989503384, -0.07689770311117172, 0.04147408902645111, -0.02401203103363514, 0.007581548765301704, 0.007102618459612131, 0.004827715456485748, 0.016762487590312958, -0.011763643473386765, 0.005198819562792778, -0.013874905183911324, 0.003947842866182327, -0.019833765923976898, 0.0012272094609215856, -0.05349588394165039, -0.035324569791555405, 0.017735308036208153, 0.03260368853807449, -0.008738831616938114, -0.03846191242337227, 0.02885725349187851, 0.010912902653217316, -0.023726556450128555, -0.024422267451882362, -0.04960669204592705, 0.028690354898571968, 0.0005896365037187934, 0.02311369962990284, 0.055516619235277176, -0.0013514107558876276, 0.0065865302458405495, -0.00144101376645267, 0.040345627814531326, 0.029106194153428078, 0.037456560879945755, 0.02906971611082554, -0.038757890462875366, -0.04145865887403488, -0.03758497163653374, 0.02057952620089054, 0.022980542853474617, -0.009919499047100544, 0.01459193043410778, 0.04410720616579056, 0.04029567167162895, 0.004676428157836199, 0.024083318188786507, 0.03929276019334793, 0.044555652886629105, -0.0056677404791116714, -0.015552851371467113, -0.013254556804895401, -0.008181873708963394, 0.010444861836731434, 0.03170880675315857, -0.01094970665872097, 0.01149847824126482, -0.009918115101754665, 0.0005420015077106655, -0.023336267098784447, -0.020917905494570732, 0.03680190071463585, 0.016899652779102325, 0.048325102776288986, 0.017946386709809303, -0.04759212210774422, -0.012184768915176392, 0.04065687581896782, 0.06086146831512451, 0.0044872998259961605, -0.0052795931696891785, -0.04479697346687317, -0.003940153401345015, 0.0390152782201767, 0.010488254018127918, -0.023698072880506516, -0.019165148958563805, -0.051853619515895844, -0.02252034842967987, 0.03817768022418022, -0.006777032744139433, 0.027474017813801765, 0.014951098710298538, -0.029371438547968864, 0.013086644932627678, -0.027118977159261703, -0.0764017403125763, 0.01699591614305973, 0.028906656429171562, 0.050625029951334, -0.006575117353349924, -0.002381223486736417, -0.03956478089094162, 0.012531337328255177, 0.04525906965136528, 0.06126514822244644, -0.00006284649862209335, -0.030186878517270088, -0.02002505026757717, 0.002361360937356949, -0.009236241690814495, -0.06662095338106155, 0.021851899102330208, 0.009297081269323826, -0.021934766322374344, 0.01099182479083538, -0.027446255087852478, -0.048226866871118546, 0.024102147668600082, 0.002319508930668235, -0.01683087646961212, -0.024699082598090172, -0.0015094788977876306, 0.04232129082083702, 0.05706742778420448, 0.017579760402441025, 0.053999435156583786, 0.02343173511326313, 0.013925915583968163, -0.014208416454494, -0.005205362569540739, -0.03297486901283264, -0.005000958684831858, -0.014439217746257782, -0.044540200382471085, -0.02923795022070408, -0.012082899920642376, 0.038243912160396576, -0.021625075489282608, 0.01042916625738144, -0.03980701044201851, -0.0038135380018502474, -0.00353790121152997, 0.025364087894558907, -0.05148415267467499, -0.0017707194201648235, 0.007260169368237257, 0.040037963539361954, -0.03216163069009781, 0.008524389937520027, 0.019773833453655243, -0.024684591218829155, -0.0007827747031114995, 0.010327118448913097, -0.04673298820853233, 0.031274694949388504, -0.012657011859118938, 0.008990132249891758, 0.004712202120572329, -0.0008594737737439573, 0.011673941276967525, -0.04496043920516968, 0.02138465829193592, 0.027609610930085182, -0.026235226541757584, -0.017364557832479477, 0.031002359464764595, 0.0007792534306645393, 0.039186906069517136, 0.0035171136260032654, 0.018027031794190407, 0.004660287406295538, -0.040198296308517456, -0.061401236802339554, -0.057704679667949677, 0.033965401351451874, 0.015478983521461487, 0.0026803549844771624, -0.0036781970411539078, 0.0034282375127077103, -0.024159284308552742, -0.0419125072658062, -0.022254548966884613, 0.026052772998809814, -0.0033854967914521694, -0.025956427678465843, -0.009167823009192944, 0.019234132021665573, 0.06725943833589554, 0.026312919333577156, 0.024490047246217728, 0.025352291762828827, -0.03554992750287056, 0.012097016908228397, 0.019080473110079765, 0.041275739669799805, -0.04322921484708786, -0.0007790758972987533, -0.019289910793304443, -0.007936671376228333, 0.052169181406497955, -0.029905742034316063, -0.0006747099687345326, 0.030040517449378967, 0.021629951894283295, 0.01439360436052084, -0.0015496860723942518, -0.01181357353925705, -0.008894153870642185, 0.006078872364014387, -0.009524730034172535, -0.004078700672835112, -0.016160763800144196, 0.021174490451812744, 0.021716872230172157, 0.011457300744950771, -0.028652867302298546, -0.017841849476099014, 0.07326287031173706, 0.00546390563249588, 0.03495560586452484, -0.0020358392503112555, 0.0033088575582951307, 0.08382952213287354, -0.012919443659484386, 0.02755442075431347, 0.016680225729942322, 0.04469455033540726, -0.025671320036053658, -0.05405118688941002, -0.0495411641895771, 0.027690446004271507, 0.059387754648923874, -0.030384335666894913, 0.05014951899647713, 0.022400101646780968, 0.004476661793887615, -0.016913464292883873, -0.034564048051834106, -0.023373020812869072, -0.013590042479336262, -0.023509517312049866, 0.022794781252741814, -0.031552739441394806, -0.03243366256356239, 0.006909047719091177, 0.01346905343234539, -0.008148705586791039, -0.004416257608681917, 0.031765591353178024, 0.03333625569939613, 0.027831867337226868, -0.034511350095272064, -0.011137156747281551, 0.027466071769595146, -0.022107325494289398, 0.005688794422894716, -0.034150246530771255, -0.01145238894969225, 0.07098705321550369, 0.05882616713643074, 0.021956006065011024, -0.08002492785453796, -0.05806709825992584, -0.025740383192896843, 0.01068937685340643, -0.0005860289093106985, 0.023575667291879654, 0.06671716272830963, 0.01594271883368492, 0.0075903283432126045, 0.002474087756127119, 0.032838791608810425, -0.03877098485827446, -0.11538729071617126, 0.011468439362943172, -0.003488518064841628, -0.04519443213939667, 0.011378093622624874, 0.007547428365796804, -0.052779413759708405, 0.03544890135526657, -0.05040236562490463, 0.009386288933455944, -0.011308777146041393, -0.007420036476105452, -0.01900940202176571, 0.024491293355822563, -0.00509516429156065, -0.00406898558139801, -0.0026356708258390427, -0.00735242385417223, 0.09806407988071442, 0.08497213572263718, 0.036495473235845566, -0.0741790235042572, 0.03776264935731888, -0.01020751241594553, -0.03173063322901726, -0.03835251182317734, 0.007817934267222881, 0.010243669152259827, -0.017031408846378326, 0.02722019888460636, 0.056370969861745834, -0.003079537535086274, -0.023125121369957924, 0.05309870466589928, -0.05455106869339943, 0.04011332988739014, 0.0029776371084153652, 0.0036860762629657984, 0.03719395399093628, -0.018765216693282127, 0.01796584576368332, 0.028435420244932175, -0.037920016795396805, -0.01770895905792713, -0.03644800931215286, -0.030973730608820915, 0.018492115661501884, -0.015474062412977219, -0.029166124761104584, 0.025382298976182938, 0.014284846372902393, 0.010690515860915184, 0.00514104263857007, 0.05458269268274307, 0.05724574625492096, -0.0378689281642437, 0.011336125433444977, 0.0164845772087574, -0.016730358824133873, 0.015640676021575928, 0.01572129875421524, 0.005770615767687559, -0.04262116551399231, -0.032735418528318405, -0.043276235461235046, 0.035901736468076706, 0.0017368061235174537, -0.029224654659628868, -0.006970463320612907, 0.017004959285259247, -0.001845325343310833, -0.04259004071354866, -0.04229521378874779, 0.03409577161073685, 0.0027989635709673166, -0.058649275451898575, 0.015299118123948574, 0.01667685993015766, 0.034932736307382584, -0.015097073279321194, 0.03576606884598732, -0.00479216780513525, -0.08355473726987839, 0.0013767469208687544, -0.001271139015443623, 0.05966982617974281, 0.03066571243107319, -0.007348085753619671, 0.011559064500033855, 0.0056925565004348755, -0.021268796175718307, -0.015270868316292763, 0.011307611130177975, 0.014257696457207203, 0.010397794656455517, 0.003371932776644826, 0.009806928224861622, -0.0032796876039355993, -0.048114482313394547, 0.015420055016875267, -0.01178122777491808, 0.027078423649072647, -0.06471437960863113, -0.016025938093662262, 0.04343465343117714, 0.033467017114162445, 0.028608553111553192, -0.00440328661352396, -0.038237933069467545, 0.05369731783866882, 0.023156289011240005, -0.048062629997730255, -0.04614691063761711, 0.0005806531407870352, -0.053981538861989975, -0.009564359672367573, -0.01663891412317753, 0.06818091869354248, 0.024366283789277077, 0.035606224089860916, 0.016527878120541573, 0.005449726711958647, -0.025834571570158005, 0.038650915026664734, -0.00834757462143898, -0.03790432587265968, -0.018288085237145424, 0.04151257500052452, 0.022279979661107063, -0.014140406623482704, -0.00453626224771142, -0.02278931997716427, -0.008910934440791607, 0.00015421400894410908, -0.03728252276778221, -0.03529701754450798, 0.019220275804400444, 0.003928712569177151, 0.01719171553850174, -0.042476553469896317, -0.02167537808418274, -0.01111517008394003, 0.015752948820590973, 0.03483564779162407, -0.004016317427158356, 0.010709849186241627, 0.007018117234110832, -0.017876947298645973, -0.011495482176542282, 0.04247666522860527, -0.00884512159973383, 0.02145352214574814, -0.029495125636458397, 0.00453980453312397, -0.0073791085742414, 0.037012722343206406, -0.048944246023893356, -0.06484374403953552, 0.02512044832110405, -0.03998938575387001, -0.03537603095173836, 0.014066485688090324, -0.038792628794908524, 0.007034949492663145, 0.009407480247318745, 0.027362503111362457, -0.03793223202228546, 0.0341760516166687, -0.02318686433136463, -0.0029887270648032427, -0.0043418630957603455, 0.03888362646102905, -0.0031939763575792313, -0.01403678860515356, -0.002628663321956992, 0.020298132672905922, 0.004976782947778702, 0.007569656241685152, 0.03365495800971985, -0.004804374650120735, -0.00997359212487936, -0.010060392320156097, 0.015094181522727013, -0.02794467657804489, -0.029927056282758713, 0.0035358997993171215, 0.037490684539079666, 0.0372246578335762, -0.01999121531844139, 0.017344454303383827, 0.02492581307888031, -0.001867252984084189, -0.08200939744710922, -0.03171787038445473, 0.023885920643806458, 0.012756772339344025, 0.028065377846360207, -0.04113127291202545, 0.0632743164896965, -0.0035302708856761456, -0.06457521766424179, 0.031230071559548378, 0.025686368346214294, 0.009527088142931461, -0.03275962546467781, -0.020373553037643433, -0.010020404122769833, -0.0006764460122212768, 0.02025410532951355, -0.007301372475922108, -0.018343616276979446, 0.010730821639299393, 0.0023399502970278263, -0.03788062185049057, -0.012090320698916912, -0.021651189774274826, -0.029753535985946655, -0.03937922418117523, 0.02514035627245903, -0.050900548696517944, -0.05435679107904434, 0.02518746629357338, 0.014222721569240093, 0.00427887961268425, -0.004463138524442911, -0.0011972594074904919, 0.01912308670580387, 0.05071563273668289, 0.022912856191396713, 0.00508005591109395, -0.035291485488414764, -0.011421418748795986, -0.00494934618473053, 0.0005562859587371349, 0.010807150043547153, 0.013252940028905869, 0.024023734033107758, 0.008970989845693111, -0.020112179219722748, -0.03430367261171341, 0.023877495899796486, -0.026675906032323837, -0.010184520855545998, 0.01704316772520542, -0.006952645722776651, -0.01901271380484104, -0.01538950577378273, -0.04589878395199776, -0.014852854423224926, 0.05403735116124153, 0.0500735267996788, -0.049583375453948975, -0.004896202124655247, -0.013475694693624973, -0.05623369291424751, 0.019046232104301453, 0.0042321705259382725, 0.0032541314139962196, -0.009976890869438648, 0.003804201493039727, 0.0118801798671484, 0.01943296194076538, -0.0030405388679355383, -0.07162720710039139, -0.0478239506483078, 0.04303142800927162, -0.04270059987902641, 0.0006977918674238026, 0.0014001436065882444, -0.016078826040029526, -0.018163388594985008, -0.04342786222696304, 0.048988327383995056, -0.022102858871221542, -0.03772105276584625, -0.034643497318029404, -0.005036295857280493, -0.05155162513256073, -0.025106629356741905, 0.05028892681002617, 0.008471228182315826, -0.013569086790084839, 0.005904880352318287, 0.04680284112691879, -0.0025413434486836195, -0.05149448290467262, 0.058940231800079346, 0.01794045977294445, -0.00998049695044756, 0.0015251731965690851, 0.002641166327521205, 0.00893547385931015, 0.03544069081544876, 0.020692022517323494, -0.022901102900505066, 0.017639849334955215, -0.009698796086013317, 0.0030281359795480967, 0.02186044305562973, -0.01755441352725029, 0.013507824391126633, 0.056524500250816345, 0.0302396509796381, 0.029178345575928688, 0.011194050312042236, 0.005234721582382917, -0.04065170884132385, 0.04672820866107941, -0.001434731064364314, -0.009914608672261238, -0.010787311010062695, -0.010624018497765064, -0.00654908362776041, -0.0513320155441761, 0.004480903502553701, 0.023607375100255013, -0.02126835472881794, -0.005212860647588968, 0.030378473922610283, 0.022363614290952682, 0.03683318942785263, -0.023757029324769974, 0.006382829509675503, 0.018942592665553093, -0.0002026050497079268, -0.0015443615848198533, 0.006920160260051489, 0.05008171498775482, 0.007729449309408665, 0.024440938606858253, 0.0474211648106575, 0.010227073915302753, -0.004625935107469559, -0.024072913452982903, 0.0013161655515432358, 0.004169979132711887, -0.024870852008461952, 0.04054168239235878, -0.020838970318436623, 0.016973048448562622, -0.013541962951421738, 0.011713419109582901, 0.06380653381347656, -0.087040014564991, 0.02110796421766281, -0.051235176622867584, 0.01117582619190216, -0.04058179259300232, 0.00935274362564087, 0.0014054955681785941, -0.0010338779538869858, 0.01617511361837387, -0.0182114839553833, -0.0025554124731570482, -0.02192576229572296, 0.007662829011678696, -0.01927443966269493, -0.027453264221549034, -0.01253755483776331, -0.0011030574096366763, -0.0340590737760067, 0.000769653997849673, -0.06621263176202774, -0.027005106210708618, 0.06860122084617615, 0.06871183216571808, 0.012772325426340103, -0.017964618280529976, -0.05294947698712349, -0.014067738316953182, 0.03375701233744621, -0.08163021504878998, -0.01576284132897854, -0.005516025237739086, 0.021671418100595474, 0.021987732499837875, -0.022426599636673927 ]
<p>We have two time series: $X_t$ and $R_t$, and a model saying that $R_{t+1} = (\mu(X_t) - \frac{1}{2}\sigma^2(X_t))\Delta T + \sigma(X_t) \sqrt{\Delta T} \epsilon_t$, where $\Delta T$ is given constant and $\epsilon_t$-s are independent normally distributed with zero mean and unit variance. Further we assume that the functions $\mu(x)$ and $\sigma(x)$ are linear for simplicity. I would like to use some standard method (MLE comes to my mind) to estimate parameters of functions $\mu(x)$ and $\sigma(x)$, but I am not sure how to do this. </p> <p>I would be grateful for detailed answers, because I am not really experienced with statistics.</p>
74,051
[ -0.003042625030502677, -0.030911492183804512, -0.01656482182443142, 0.0150003582239151, -0.015552436001598835, -0.010622008703649044, 0.010111267678439617, -0.04050695523619652, 0.021539585664868355, -0.03809848055243492, 0.03379826992750168, 0.035642921924591064, 0.06417567282915115, -0.0166787076741457, 0.058266300708055496, 0.0031951384153217077, -0.03200516104698181, 0.008124224841594696, -0.034662920981645584, 0.00036394796916283667, -0.018758784979581833, 0.05062044411897659, 0.023558564484119415, -0.020548878237605095, -0.02509748376905918, 0.049672938883304596, 0.021968791261315346, 0.007882755249738693, -0.017316292971372604, 0.042359862476587296, -0.0429513193666935, -0.024492690339684486, 0.01800992153584957, 0.07296527177095413, -0.016104232519865036, 0.012896263971924782, -0.037058476358652115, -0.026522327214479446, -0.0177397970110178, 0.049081508070230484, -0.06886018067598343, -0.015853047370910645, -0.00007326138438656926, 0.025884544476866722, -0.01031214278191328, 0.014812161214649677, -0.03520893305540085, -0.05985429883003235, 0.03832513466477394, -0.022054558619856834, 0.083905890583992, -0.011497187428176403, 0.06426745653152466, 0.011233825236558914, -0.015767257660627365, 0.003279291093349457, 0.054152678698301315, 0.06302819401025772, -0.011888965032994747, -0.043828461319208145, -0.008652973920106888, -0.02035679668188095, 0.014214301481842995, 0.006247150711715221, -0.031072597950696945, -0.01179287489503622, -0.00824138056486845, -0.01441802829504013, 0.037390902638435364, -0.019101597368717194, 0.039362676441669464, 0.013226166367530823, 0.05557938665151596, 0.013617632910609245, -0.013634965755045414, -0.004365892149507999, -0.018765810877084732, 0.01626651920378208, 0.012943250127136707, 0.02973124012351036, 0.010149732232093811, -0.014129776507616043, 0.04719902575016022, 0.02743178978562355, 0.02141955867409706, 0.02964717522263527, 0.06193256378173828, -0.0005217007710598409, 0.03661637008190155, 0.02075093798339367, -0.025900041684508324, 0.0002531162463128567, 0.05369430035352707, -0.022613810375332832, -0.05295589938759804, 0.050015199929475784, -0.027918741106987, 0.0036800873931497335, 0.023903604596853256, -0.014964243397116661, -0.008292358368635178, -0.045698437839746475, 0.006062767934054136, 0.06217768043279648, -0.0017368115950375795, -0.004058073274791241, 0.0213260967284441, -0.0311599001288414, -0.023526344448328018, -0.04898418113589287, -0.03110734187066555, -0.006924101617187262, -0.0014775090385228395, -0.01347713079303503, 0.03168462589383125, 0.0399443656206131, -0.02366209216415882, -0.03142242878675461, 0.04388218745589256, 0.07096314430236816, 0.013407285325229168, -0.018561452627182007, 0.0047078849747776985, 0.0048139821738004684, -0.04072205722332001, 0.05207841470837593, 0.005533404182642698, -0.03768954426050186, -0.0618269108235836, 0.07501061260700226, 0.0066869440488517284, -0.026706034317612648, 0.033195771276950836, -0.03092697449028492, 0.06339256465435028, 0.007434015162289143, -0.047774724662303925, -0.053847674280405045, 0.004981336183845997, -0.0384981743991375, 0.012671124190092087, -0.06927141547203064, -0.001746480935253203, 0.05530327558517456, 0.05239691957831383, 0.018210764974355698, 0.03349952772259712, 0.028418296948075294, 0.011045181192457676, 0.030885057523846626, -0.017205366864800453, -0.03850659355521202, -0.029151301831007004, 0.010807624086737633, -0.01726555824279785, -0.058443229645490646, -0.03231581673026085, 0.008317399770021439, -0.016334732994437218, 0.009920072741806507, 0.04862285777926445, 0.04748173803091049, -0.002610857831314206, 0.010950719006359577, 0.04479500651359558, -0.0647476315498352, 0.06203807517886162, -0.011185616254806519, 0.010199282318353653, -0.02193795144557953, -0.007315732538700104, 0.006305286195129156, 0.04694058746099472, 0.05070674046874046, 0.052233923226594925, -0.019358357414603233, -0.015563135966658592, -0.0022228651214390993, -0.013121156021952629, 0.033334583044052124, -0.043172385543584824, -0.019295519217848778, -0.018259599804878235, -0.00041852364665828645, 0.016018984839320183, 0.05735758692026138, 0.005787301808595657, -0.014933107420802116, 0.019183803349733353, -0.06359685212373734, 0.002216125139966607, -0.08468173444271088, -0.007359773851931095, -0.005598204676061869, -0.006452801637351513, 0.041212037205696106, -0.029242562130093575, 0.019236572086811066, -0.02687058039009571, -0.04940887540578842, -0.00585196865722537, 0.02092856355011463, 0.03293183073401451, -0.022127743810415268, 0.019122276455163956, 0.02660292014479637, 0.05853521078824997, 0.022370407357811928, 0.023010240867733955, -0.007503644097596407, -0.034366998821496964, 0.02020912431180477, -0.06926258653402328, 0.011569483205676079, -0.019522853195667267, -0.026838697493076324, 0.017629774287343025, -0.01917918585240841, -0.02021494135260582, 0.029292726889252663, -0.04426877945661545, 0.03581668809056282, 0.05013523995876312, 0.017282523214817047, -0.007361401338130236, 0.011248520575463772, 0.0433855876326561, 0.039957448840141296, -0.063152976334095, -0.009832333773374557, -0.037681788206100464, 0.0013414277927950025, 0.05118035525083542, 0.05069251358509064, -0.03122624382376671, -0.002496123779565096, 0.0779528021812439, 0.003180931555107236, 0.04154669865965843, 0.05662250518798828, 0.008594169281423092, -0.01569986529648304, -0.012054629623889923, -0.04999803006649017, 0.006675853859633207, 0.022621771320700645, 0.029235519468784332, 0.00008590721699874848, 0.015273470431566238, 0.00486308429390192, 0.007313162554055452, 0.01677197590470314, 0.026410507038235664, 0.011871065013110638, -0.009737602435052395, -0.0016279751434922218, 0.02702050656080246, -0.0025398966390639544, -0.003664713818579912, 0.015278643928468227, 0.007035485468804836, 0.008201191201806068, 0.031500183045864105, 0.03244084119796753, 0.035374924540519714, 0.014539270661771297, -0.02929445169866085, -0.01017239224165678, 0.022762278094887733, -0.045329704880714417, -0.0049201371148228645, -0.0021998416632413864, -0.01196218840777874, -0.01947208307683468, -0.030299240723252296, -0.014084487222135067, 0.045596472918987274, 0.04234691709280014, -0.00891141127794981, -0.035012830048799515, 0.029585929587483406, -0.01594328135251999, 0.02901632897555828, 0.010869452729821205, 0.005236441735178232, 0.006886713672429323, -0.009469286538660526, -0.013727247714996338, 0.027145864441990852, 0.011723571456968784, 0.007783607579767704, 0.015406212769448757, -0.02174294926226139, -0.06797424703836441, -0.040167830884456635, -0.0444825254380703, 0.011191276833415031, 0.008642373606562614, 0.0006858357810415328, 0.0546363890171051, 0.005910171661525965, -0.038834940642118454, 0.04276926815509796, -0.051434196531772614, -0.021704712882637978, -0.04898034408688545, 0.010506301186978817, 0.0000556670747755561, -0.0217807125300169, 0.039983123540878296, 0.030048398301005363, -0.02587628737092018, 0.010437275283038616, -0.043907202780246735, -0.03912244364619255, 0.015603497624397278, 0.02117213048040867, 0.05668191984295845, 0.015623729676008224, -0.05011981725692749, 0.07304851710796356, 0.005814188625663519, 0.010387282818555832, -0.02598661370575428, 0.00024420968838967383, -0.01579786092042923, -0.017776845023036003, 0.02274390310049057, 0.025241846218705177, -0.006832259241491556, 0.02504449337720871, -0.004223068710416555, 0.004646530374884605, 0.04595638066530228, 0.020237399265170097, 0.0018045060569420457, -0.00279686669819057, -0.013374141417443752, 0.0071578435599803925, 0.049656566232442856, -0.009125789627432823, 0.015579912811517715, 0.026608778163790703, 0.020648159086704254, -0.00849278923124075, 0.007091051898896694, -0.03045571781694889, 0.029291953891515732, -0.029882078990340233, -0.03126279264688492, -0.03441120684146881, 0.046805333346128464, 0.03444846346974373, -0.028293611481785774, -0.052421100437641144, -0.010047693736851215, 0.0028882003389298916, 0.01401348877698183, 0.013719615526497364, 0.024109303951263428, 0.01600644551217556, 0.006107646971940994, -0.04540413245558739, -0.013624723069369793, -0.00016029112157411873, 0.017406923696398735, -0.042382314801216125, -0.02864442579448223, 0.03824172541499138, 0.0077256266959011555, 0.004215868189930916, -0.016594361513853073, -0.014023439958691597, -0.02456122636795044, -0.07266206294298172, 0.018577920272946358, -0.020207371562719345, 0.05627220496535301, 0.01597822643816471, 0.02281998284161091, 0.021885963156819344, -0.016307111829519272, 0.022517602890729904, -0.0031857735011726618, -0.04766010120511055, 0.04049418866634369, -0.021427713334560394, -0.04078146442770958, -0.004572340752929449, 0.008812438696622849, 0.030044957995414734, -0.028821701183915138, 0.042316656559705734, -0.0018582878401502967, 0.008107693865895271, -0.04003605246543884, -0.009184777736663818, -0.04361934959888458, 0.008845528587698936, 0.0036080442368984222, 0.03243584558367729, -0.0023817725013941526, -0.06408955901861191, 0.00020886134007014334, 0.014473147690296173, -0.013830476440489292, -0.02239396795630455, -0.034080974757671356, 0.010081866756081581, 0.004020279739052057, 0.02657916396856308, 0.0447186641395092, -0.01016950886696577, -0.015135584399104118, 0.045145899057388306, 0.03829321637749672, 0.055651579052209854, 0.02663053385913372, 0.014180880039930344, -0.03202049061655998, -0.027935216203331947, -0.012112094089388847, -0.0026906782295554876, 0.03311408683657646, 0.013333488255739212, 0.02274695411324501, 0.060639455914497375, 0.017186909914016724, -0.043113823980093, 0.001681061345152557, 0.0634569525718689, -0.005901372991502285, -0.016186468303203583, -0.02741045504808426, -0.0003831844951491803, -0.0036504187155514956, 0.004180225543677807, 0.020651396363973618, 0.0108554158359766, -0.026711056008934975, -0.014886343851685524, 0.04471524804830551, -0.0028474698774516582, -0.02844342403113842, -0.011635074391961098, 0.07053731381893158, 0.06063830479979515, -0.00388797908090055, -0.0372161939740181, 0.005587906576693058, 0.06429871171712875, 0.04495948553085327, 0.009959808550775051, 0.01648567244410515, -0.06528878211975098, 0.0029667143244296312, 0.004810434766113758, 0.006205152720212936, -0.025072641670703888, -0.014065501280128956, -0.037329722195863724, 0.01536274328827858, 0.03313692659139633, -0.012870324775576591, 0.015355143696069717, 0.014017611742019653, -0.004203305579721928, -0.0027186996303498745, -0.02650287188589573, -0.05158846080303192, 0.005121657159179449, -0.028991540893912315, 0.01641983725130558, -0.02800351195037365, -0.03022831119596958, -0.045355260372161865, -0.001000300981104374, 0.006443739868700504, 0.08956462889909744, -0.015642477199435234, -0.01457251701503992, -0.0032445320393890142, 0.062293317168951035, -0.009152954444289207, -0.07276506721973419, 0.004968038760125637, 0.015807250514626503, -0.0174418818205595, 0.040440600365400314, -0.014776868745684624, -0.019031433388590813, 0.02964433655142784, 0.016331329941749573, -0.03968366980552673, -0.008346881717443466, 0.0008403384708799422, 0.03587314859032631, 0.04605530947446823, 0.044177230447530746, 0.0670350044965744, 0.028254011645913124, 0.003332065651193261, 0.007334496825933456, 0.005740975961089134, 0.013537258841097355, -0.02398655004799366, -0.024851862341165543, -0.03476717695593834, -0.009165002033114433, -0.029676910489797592, 0.03691600635647774, -0.01349073089659214, 0.06308815628290176, -0.016818204894661903, -0.003265359438955784, 0.035210102796554565, 0.04620220884680748, 0.0024507942143827677, -0.008320657536387444, 0.02055223099887371, 0.01428327988833189, -0.032937102019786835, -0.01555312518030405, -0.03618629276752472, -0.012642692774534225, 0.007327051367610693, 0.015344780869781971, -0.07313581556081772, 0.031383976340293884, -0.01513031218200922, -0.05497865006327629, -0.00905526988208294, -0.018387632444500923, 0.017635928466916084, -0.01838286593556404, 0.04177967086434364, 0.01928694359958172, -0.04377828538417816, 0.008289305493235588, 0.014475717209279537, 0.021409453824162483, 0.02202642150223255, -0.03589155897498131, 0.03204086795449257, 0.018926231190562248, -0.016110658645629883, -0.07712555676698685, -0.035153262317180634, 0.017424317076802254, 0.0009458056883886456, -0.021419430151581764, -0.04626420885324478, 0.04520225152373314, -0.03165234252810478, -0.018387455493211746, -0.01713002845644951, 0.05335821211338043, 0.006542838178575039, -0.019892755895853043, -0.026133015751838684, 0.03143301606178284, 0.06267000734806061, -0.0007923721568658948, 0.012327756732702255, 0.008370831608772278, -0.027515912428498268, -0.0367107167840004, 0.011537331156432629, 0.05516914650797844, -0.041331540793180466, 0.02194768376648426, -0.02709302492439747, -0.019853852689266205, 0.0424572229385376, -0.05081457272171974, -0.03817495331168175, 0.03446297347545624, 0.03675585985183716, 0.020420853048563004, -0.016528576612472534, -0.0028618096839636564, -0.026306528598070145, 0.020676927641034126, 0.011572043411433697, -0.008577292785048485, -0.026788609102368355, 0.00985234696418047, 0.0395546592772007, 0.01844644919037819, -0.008203214034438133, 0.026908911764621735, 0.06063887104392052, 0.02059207111597061, -0.005530319642275572, 0.0270839836448431, 0.028970299288630486, 0.048989925533533096, 0.000005697369942936348, 0.012742660939693451, 0.03273875266313553, 0.0049539352767169476, -0.04630943015217781, -0.05057787895202637, -0.004793393891304731, -0.025983063504099846, 0.060982100665569305, -0.03313798829913139, 0.08024970442056656, 0.03174353018403053, -0.017716998234391212, -0.03377440571784973, -0.04013247787952423, -0.008990337140858173, -0.01840072125196457, -0.03517080843448639, 0.03307582437992096, -0.008681120350956917, 0.003924571443349123, 0.004244051408022642, -0.02577531524002552, 0.0054243928752839565, 0.044547658413648605, 0.011366447433829308, 0.0408993698656559, 0.03633195161819458, -0.014670172706246376, 0.013331002555787563, 0.022231878712773323, -0.0296914204955101, 0.027462562546133995, -0.04478943720459938, 0.019706901162862778, 0.02744140475988388, 0.03967567905783653, -0.00542783597484231, -0.027502985671162605, -0.028715094551444054, -0.07008443027734756, -0.009169060736894608, 0.03661090135574341, -0.013153203763067722, 0.05371777340769768, 0.06964029371738434, 0.02335163578391075, 0.0036308804992586374, 0.04234693571925163, -0.0628451257944107, -0.0731717050075531, -0.003834634553641081, 0.002623818814754486, -0.034326717257499695, 0.060494475066661835, -0.004335539881139994, -0.025420773774385452, 0.02006985805928707, -0.029826531186699867, 0.00951757188886404, 0.00747451838105917, 0.011262401938438416, -0.05281652510166168, 0.11992249637842178, 0.005231535993516445, -0.013635518029332161, -0.013379894196987152, 0.030196573585271835, 0.08558208495378494, 0.09238580614328384, 0.04062642157077789, -0.06281474232673645, 0.0037862183526158333, -0.019332263618707657, -0.016119953244924545, -0.03933927044272423, 0.02326328493654728, 0.028204452246427536, -0.02250712923705578, 0.004092696122825146, 0.02845415100455284, 0.014984727837145329, -0.05060524120926857, 0.025954309850931168, -0.0005129934870637953, -0.005337022244930267, -0.0031099480111151934, -0.009624949656426907, 0.013652283698320389, 0.0206118393689394, -0.029858505353331566, 0.032111529260873795, -0.04273078590631485, -0.002909364877268672, -0.03570762649178505, -0.03665906563401222, -0.025581292808055878, -0.04072453826665878, -0.03348406404256821, 0.011606235057115555, 0.034140460193157196, 0.0321456640958786, -0.014035451225936413, -0.0126466890797019, -0.005980176851153374, -0.004303691443055868, 0.02730650082230568, 0.020136110484600067, -0.010331658646464348, 0.011928645893931389, 0.013082599267363548, -0.004914250690490007, -0.046130433678627014, -0.015407215803861618, -0.06320209056138992, 0.04688252508640289, -0.011919916607439518, -0.02185685746371746, 0.013266890309751034, 0.007408967241644859, -0.011334425769746304, -0.05128839612007141, -0.01682151108980179, 0.008644768968224525, 0.04245973750948906, -0.040448594838380814, 0.015360808931291103, -0.05119561403989792, 0.038780856877565384, -0.0054960548877716064, 0.034455668181180954, 0.002596246311441064, -0.04491085559129715, 0.00622260756790638, 0.0008544338052161038, 0.027325445786118507, -0.0027965933550149202, -0.014714554883539677, 0.00880077388137579, -0.025797322392463684, -0.01708397828042507, 0.0378638356924057, 0.04844754934310913, -0.019470104947686195, 0.04059803858399391, -0.013231337070465088, 0.006180961150676012, -0.010792694054543972, -0.071790412068367, 0.024643918499350548, -0.03306564688682556, 0.014901439659297466, -0.03664213791489601, -0.012980370782315731, 0.053188543766736984, 0.05175917595624924, -0.004477860406041145, -0.006315924227237701, 0.010032660327851772, 0.02883816510438919, 0.045873455703258514, -0.07600580900907516, -0.01652429811656475, 0.0033136599231511354, -0.009029911831021309, 0.005611104425042868, -0.03982046619057655, 0.03389851003885269, 0.037352193146944046, 0.02858857624232769, -0.04152604192495346, 0.01655091531574726, -0.02187258005142212, 0.008918211795389652, 0.007428934797644615, -0.04486183449625969, -0.02758006751537323, -0.0005541483405977488, 0.02787151001393795, 0.017036937177181244, -0.011185347102582455, -0.01665092445909977, 0.008485027588903904, -0.038753341883420944, -0.022658776491880417, -0.03780345991253853, 0.028505509719252586, -0.018317384645342827, -0.016674144193530083, -0.020290857180953026, 0.014038877561688423, 0.0038691202644258738, 0.0035451443400233984, 0.018296675756573677, -0.026531832292675972, -0.022700374945998192, 0.012488170526921749, -0.01331372745335102, -0.015292876400053501, 0.005167969968169928, 0.008482683449983597, 0.01970168575644493, -0.009350701235234737, 0.004529532510787249, -0.012538856826722622, 0.028356533497571945, -0.0334646999835968, -0.02877461165189743, 0.016899144276976585, -0.061467040330171585, -0.013580761849880219, 0.022978588938713074, 0.0257745161652565, 0.03950472176074982, 0.007907960563898087, -0.018292194232344627, -0.01618139073252678, -0.0023578638210892677, -0.037308793514966965, -0.0134186502546072, -0.036189280450344086, 0.019161047413945198, 0.003955991007387638, -0.044588714838027954, 0.04115154966711998, -0.0010859791655093431, 0.03563353419303894, 0.007719202432781458, 0.016152996569871902, -0.04526925086975098, 0.00754508376121521, 0.01844754070043564, -0.013504795730113983, 0.019695820286870003, -0.01382480375468731, 0.022828157991170883, 0.0500706247985363, 0.04274008423089981, -0.038264431059360504, 0.03764168918132782, -0.014828436076641083, -0.027856258675456047, -0.07037912309169769, 0.020855890586972237, 0.017885468900203705, -0.0017547305906191468, 0.042635634541511536, -0.056709565222263336, -0.02250971458852291, 0.04459933936595917, -0.014744737185537815, -0.03564067557454109, -0.02435034140944481, -0.003235927317291498, -0.020861968398094177, -0.029359543696045876, -0.008763886988162994, 0.005519221071153879, 0.029867753386497498, 0.030193250626325607, 0.03067360632121563, 0.03345124423503876, -0.0013689810875803232, -0.0013131045270711184, -0.007702562026679516, -0.016933845356106758, 0.05211732164025307, -0.09067123383283615, 0.011897624470293522, -0.06818899512290955, -0.02121555060148239, 0.032165274024009705, 0.0077086156234145164, 0.01692345179617405, -0.009861713275313377, 0.02375020831823349, -0.0013978499919176102, 0.04990832880139351, 0.008694804273545742, -0.023109588772058487, 0.0017223823815584183, -0.02430560439825058, 0.017449235543608665, 0.022121679037809372, -0.02753630466759205, -0.021865500137209892, 0.0069298166781663895, -0.01209552027285099, -0.01825430989265442, 0.025663895532488823, -0.028161754831671715, -0.032879579812288284, 0.04357855021953583, -0.007666763849556446, 0.02008729614317417, -0.03758130967617035, 0.010734536685049534, -0.025616830214858055, 0.03147411718964577, 0.03735721483826637, 0.030091170221567154, -0.0428808256983757, 0.00467426935210824, -0.009349506348371506, -0.04454576596617699, 0.025969848036766052, 0.004705014172941446, -0.024626944214105606, -0.07691589742898941, -0.029325902462005615, 0.012754430994391441, -0.01938878931105137, -0.04694949835538864, -0.009430108591914177, 0.0021384546998888254, 0.03652563318610191, -0.021741921082139015, 0.0276979748159647, -0.010277831926941872, 0.005356800276786089, 0.0005373152671381831, -0.05716748908162117, 0.04849370941519737, 0.02277589961886406, -0.019215146079659462, -0.012083462439477444, -0.03193165734410286, -0.042685817927122116, -0.03950177878141403, 0.05592324212193489, -0.0166434608399868, -0.012490292079746723, 0.00005507954119821079, 0.04364645853638649, 0.03467308357357979, -0.02939167246222496, 0.023992057889699936, -0.02107331156730652, -0.035690270364284515, -0.027894312515854836, -0.036597609519958496, 0.027165653184056282, 0.005826957523822784, 0.00895234476774931, -0.01083958987146616, 0.006846730597317219, 0.03328144922852516, -0.011288071051239967, -0.010051674209535122, 0.035536348819732666, -0.024353934451937675, 0.03222071751952171, 0.0077052609995007515, 0.009715860709547997, 0.0361376628279686, 0.015234810300171375, -0.060175132006406784, 0.019352570176124573, -0.004342023748904467, -0.014396186918020248, 0.003300536423921585, 0.0025790196377784014, -0.012908395379781723, -0.05186298489570618, -0.035565681755542755, 0.0392158217728138, -0.03999040648341179, 0.0037806464824825525, 0.05708518251776695, 0.010460041463375092, 0.014470904134213924, -0.007608881685882807, 0.004914004355669022, 0.013639107346534729, 0.023502644151449203, -0.017642464488744736, -0.013969200663268566, 0.03709742799401283, -0.01012062281370163, 0.008820917457342148, 0.03311237692832947, -0.027230635285377502, 0.011582465842366219, -0.05942109599709511, 0.00017818539345171303, -0.00989541970193386, -0.0387561172246933, 0.008090988732874393, -0.011358274146914482, 0.026067141443490982, 0.0049061221070587635, -0.04519490897655487, 0.06283039599657059, -0.026814287528395653, 0.026332207024097443, -0.015247168019413948, -0.01607566885650158, -0.01826281100511551, 0.008516654372215271, 0.005796065088361502, -0.0164999607950449, 0.010244402103126049, 0.02797267958521843, 0.01354969386011362, 0.00015777449880260974, 0.033858153969049454, -0.05487089976668358, 0.024442335590720177, 0.011342667043209076, -0.004985136445611715, -0.029352722689509392, -0.0406799390912056, -0.041192200034856796, -0.0490998737514019, 0.025505078956484795, 0.020264236256480217, 0.018198195844888687, -0.030308857560157776, -0.026301443576812744, 0.013979234732687473, 0.0747990608215332, -0.07347019016742706, -0.0131157748401165, -0.007833048701286316, 0.0037024538032710552, -0.007375177461653948, -0.015309950336813927 ]
<p>I'm only a linguist, so my knowledge of statistics is very basic.</p> <p>I fitted a logistic regression model with R (with <code>lrm(formula, y=T, x=T)</code>), and when I use the option <code>validate(lrm)</code>, I get some statistics I don't really understand.</p> <pre><code>index.orig training test optimism index.corrected n Dxy 0.5984 0.6112 0.5461 0.0651 0.5333 40 R2 0.3258 0.3676 0.2929 0.0747 0.2511 40 Intercept 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0105 0.0105 -0.0105 40 Slope 1.0000 1.0000 0.8427 0.1573 0.8427 40 Emax 0.0000 0.0000 0.0399 0.0399 0.0399 40 D 0.2713 0.3176 0.2394 0.0782 0.1931 40 U -0.0177 -0.0177 0.0092 -0.0269 0.0092 40 Q 0.2890 0.3353 0.2302 0.1051 0.1839 40 B 0.1864 0.1772 0.1972 -0.0201 0.2064 40 g 1.4632 1.6642 1.3460 0.3182 1.1449 40 gp 0.2840 0.3011 0.2703 0.0308 0.2532 40 </code></pre> <p>I don't really understand most of that. I think <code>R2</code> and <code>Dxy</code> are supposed to be statistics of how good the predictors are, but I'm not sure how I should interpret the values, does the corrected <code>Dyx = 0.651</code> mean that there is a strong correlation, while the corrected <code>R2 = 0.0747</code> means that the correlation is very weak? I think the model is overfitted, but I'm not sure if I'm right.</p> <p>Also, the other statistics are totally strange to me. What are <code>Emax, D, U, Q, B, g</code>, and <code>gp</code>?</p>
1,722
[ -0.03886494040489197, 0.0011796519393101335, -0.0013598445802927017, -0.0021436873357743025, 0.04970363900065422, 0.029808368533849716, 0.013121562078595161, -0.03847891837358475, 0.03399205952882767, -0.047043513506650925, 0.06486968696117401, 0.06962864100933075, 0.04916170611977577, 0.051906391978263855, 0.02221936732530594, 0.014974119141697884, 0.023440757766366005, 0.003805210581049323, 0.025655614212155342, 0.009999406524002552, 0.0026675902772694826, 0.007776415441185236, 0.01274870429188013, -0.003977642860263586, -0.002984221326187253, 0.06855541467666626, 0.03275230526924133, -0.01882256008684635, 0.00839816965162754, 0.00976602267473936, -0.04304898902773857, -0.0205436572432518, 0.01373671181499958, -0.011211012490093708, 0.016921482980251312, 0.03153061866760254, 0.018129300326108932, -0.01438577938824892, -0.018174590542912483, 0.04749051854014397, 0.000016980464351945557, -0.03256147727370262, 0.053292807191610336, 0.0115154217928648, 0.009060352109372616, 0.028941158205270767, -0.004637149162590504, -0.015585140325129032, 0.050490330904722214, 0.0017251837998628616, 0.04856417700648308, 0.02682235836982727, 0.029406826943159103, 0.04108751192688942, -0.019311081618070602, 0.011019526980817318, 0.05817457661032677, 0.07567305862903595, 0.00066549883922562, -0.0610724501311779, 0.00899476557970047, -0.03048139438033104, 0.011445015668869019, 0.02214023470878601, -0.005228541325777769, 0.0400322750210762, -0.007603920064866543, -0.006596317980438471, 0.0701621025800705, 0.0038550111930817366, 0.033213067799806595, 0.01013256050646305, 0.015578500926494598, -0.02035829983651638, 0.036166854202747345, -0.009662234224379063, 0.008434704504907131, 0.013325812295079231, 0.002600311301648617, 0.022058691829442978, 0.005358340684324503, 0.011207680217921734, 0.018161166459321976, 0.06131349131464958, 0.007323858793824911, -0.014828217215836048, 0.061932340264320374, -0.016207363456487656, 0.032637398689985275, 0.02191794477403164, -0.00744041008874774, 0.02488197200000286, 0.025887208059430122, -0.0026435076724737883, -0.013006229884922504, 0.023033762350678444, -0.0038787557277828455, 0.0522029735147953, 0.013121698051691055, 0.010798952542245388, -0.04457548260688782, -0.029302382841706276, -0.002396786119788885, 0.03988964110612869, -0.03829019144177437, -0.051729291677474976, -0.02577516809105873, -0.013215008191764355, -0.01351527962833643, -0.034683723002672195, 0.005486250389367342, 0.015569930896162987, -0.02573518082499504, -0.018435854464769363, 0.019368676468729973, -0.03971660137176514, -0.006533651612699032, -0.010550630278885365, 0.04420197010040283, 0.04076042398810387, 0.023980729281902313, -0.020181631669402122, 0.014253870584070683, -0.0025680826511234045, -0.036212824285030365, -0.0008997108670882881, 0.01762891560792923, 0.006611865013837814, 0.016622042283415794, 0.050659749656915665, -0.0204706359654665, -0.04482891038060188, 0.004550865385681391, 0.018171170726418495, 0.030180953443050385, 0.015226372517645359, -0.07028327882289886, -0.061366163194179535, 0.04042067751288414, 0.00582920154556632, 0.03215966373682022, -0.047373924404382706, -0.007940875366330147, 0.024856921285390854, 0.05233104154467583, 0.019105367362499237, 0.040594108402729034, 0.022030271589756012, -0.006168931256979704, 0.018607445061206818, -0.07130107283592224, -0.004002335015684366, -0.06147841364145279, -0.021351177245378494, -0.021134106442332268, -0.0687352865934372, 0.0006224358221516013, 0.004083386156708002, 0.00290888175368309, -0.004121432546526194, 0.01505443174391985, -0.013900699093937874, 0.00007549035217380151, -0.02855621837079525, -0.04189390689134598, -0.01749381609261036, 0.07796771079301834, 0.011290375143289566, 0.014499949291348457, 0.04602741077542305, -0.0392085500061512, 0.015510942786931992, 0.007789153605699539, 0.03354529291391373, 0.05525507777929306, -0.006079983431845903, 0.008515077643096447, -0.06911643594503403, -0.00020860438235104084, -0.024102261289954185, -0.06631113588809967, -0.05263165012001991, -0.04349163919687271, -0.027203187346458435, 0.018037445843219757, 0.02671085111796856, 0.018685441464185715, 0.00336477137170732, 0.05681098997592926, -0.05473422631621361, -0.07219203561544418, -0.04561520740389824, 0.001025912119075656, -0.028576958924531937, -0.019066689535975456, -0.0049757021479308605, 0.017231503501534462, 0.018492523580789566, -0.00037793631781823933, 0.0075208027847111225, -0.04741434007883072, -0.0019388343207538128, 0.04984796792268753, -0.012051001191139221, 0.019637947902083397, 0.04209192097187042, 0.014237473718822002, 0.005272078327834606, 0.049572549760341644, -0.03539269044995308, -0.05438391491770744, 0.029507316648960114, -0.0007690529455430806, 0.007651900872588158, -0.04484092444181442, -0.06409885734319687, 0.02718891203403473, 0.023686189204454422, -0.024882182478904724, -0.013453668914735317, -0.09555649012327194, 0.04761858284473419, 0.019168123602867126, -0.014549227431416512, 0.005131720565259457, 0.004556227009743452, -0.018356136977672577, 0.053684573620557785, -0.055343735963106155, 0.017659036442637444, -0.05032319948077202, -0.010092082433402538, 0.05544424057006836, 0.020400259643793106, -0.044607773423194885, -0.012916219420731068, 0.057355042546987534, 0.013410470448434353, -0.0017914482159540057, 0.014114764519035816, -0.015669062733650208, -0.028957229107618332, 0.004711170215159655, 0.018915487453341484, 0.00904871802777052, -0.016426224261522293, 0.00871994998306036, 0.048429638147354126, 0.003499382408335805, -0.0015516846906393766, -0.019435308873653412, 0.02816411666572094, 0.005761481821537018, -0.03532472997903824, -0.029380878433585167, -0.03197488933801651, 0.03158160671591759, -0.0013577688951045275, -0.0023843797389417887, 0.048750922083854675, 0.018193626776337624, -0.01453638356178999, 0.008989814668893814, -0.01661500707268715, 0.027317054569721222, 0.07945475727319717, -0.012526053935289383, -0.02712639980018139, 0.007279492914676666, -0.04801688343286514, 0.006812666077166796, -0.03415728732943535, -0.039221249520778656, -0.025253918021917343, 0.01791187934577465, 0.046217892318964005, 0.02261124923825264, -0.014410731382668018, -0.01665213331580162, -0.02866685763001442, -0.011718470603227615, -0.01182208675891161, 0.03763214498758316, 0.004922245163470507, -0.06337057799100876, -0.021969042718410492, -0.023985998705029488, 0.008837533183395863, 0.050845954567193985, 0.014921911992132664, -0.05602008476853371, 0.01581556536257267, -0.029345592483878136, -0.05850578099489212, -0.05594862997531891, -0.028151730075478554, 0.027194123715162277, -0.020544148981571198, -0.03696315735578537, 0.05412139371037483, -0.018991656601428986, -0.0069817001931369305, 0.005158501211553812, -0.06715941429138184, -0.010810035280883312, -0.030264679342508316, -0.014029460959136486, -0.0047904145903885365, 0.025378938764333725, -0.021935196593403816, 0.015766210854053497, -0.03353997692465782, -0.008273771964013577, -0.07189921289682388, -0.040401022881269455, 0.011499065905809402, 0.0015199020272120833, 0.008210151456296444, -0.013773873448371887, -0.0009643150260671973, 0.06681627035140991, 0.0024785022251307964, -0.038429390639066696, -0.05045171454548836, 0.02931744046509266, -0.043740082532167435, 0.002628341084346175, -0.008804600685834885, 0.0413627028465271, 0.07290808856487274, 0.048232950270175934, -0.01418348215520382, 0.03378607705235481, 0.03580005094408989, 0.023209312930703163, 0.009903957135975361, 0.04819139838218689, -0.016449689865112305, -0.015078666619956493, 0.036382727324962616, 0.03913344442844391, -0.03147803246974945, 0.008620142936706543, 0.010224778205156326, 0.016072459518909454, 0.00522626331076026, -0.04808899387717247, 0.012456908822059631, -0.009031730704009533, 0.0178694985806942, -0.029277432709932327, 0.019618185237050056, 0.013509414158761501, -0.06084571033716202, -0.027326054871082306, -0.01269984059035778, 0.06257781386375427, 0.006375438999384642, 0.02675407938659191, 0.04204379767179489, 0.03428833559155464, -0.02330242469906807, 0.01086956262588501, -0.010395923629403114, -0.027769168838858604, 0.011997392401099205, -0.05194852128624916, -0.010260352864861488, 0.06787151098251343, 0.013734808191657066, 0.0037230735179036856, 0.000982088502496481, -0.014113707467913628, 0.03364438936114311, -0.03544162958860397, 0.004371310584247112, -0.023056024685502052, 0.039119940251111984, 0.02632126398384571, 0.04747624322772026, -0.006973041221499443, -0.0024062739685177803, 0.020510196685791016, 0.00838643778115511, -0.05114341527223587, 0.049889251589775085, 0.00116838444955647, -0.039381369948387146, 0.02259574644267559, -0.04212823510169983, 0.017479419708251953, -0.0664309412240982, -0.007257587742060423, 0.00851078424602747, -0.014782057143747807, -0.01019606925547123, 0.03975015878677368, 0.032732971012592316, 0.0023611774668097496, -0.02869284152984619, -0.009987941011786461, -0.006219879724085331, -0.0066023580729961395, 0.02205394208431244, 0.058154504746198654, 0.008077193051576614, 0.01544591411948204, -0.02470238506793976, -0.0016063551884144545, 0.082738496363163, 0.02740253508090973, 0.04361889138817787, 0.028427258133888245, -0.05339924618601799, 0.01939222775399685, 0.04606550559401512, 0.025419557467103004, 0.06432502716779709, 0.0043022590689361095, -0.0003817995311692357, 0.0182153582572937, 0.008261808194220066, -0.0014030709862709045, -0.002626919886097312, 0.0055504669435322285, -0.006615464575588703, 0.04276639595627785, 0.04912238568067551, -0.03981563821434975, 0.008677667006850243, 0.04895275831222534, 0.0012987864902243018, 0.0047322711907327175, -0.02259649708867073, -0.027048414573073387, 0.009971619583666325, 0.046668119728565216, 0.0359429307281971, -0.02532317489385605, -0.014821462333202362, -0.004500517621636391, 0.046495843678712845, -0.023609619587659836, -0.06634065508842468, -0.022819889709353447, 0.020274199545383453, 0.004681223072111607, 0.020305411890149117, -0.05582590401172638, -0.00827744696289301, 0.044398631900548935, 0.01703505404293537, 0.005602240562438965, -0.004455600865185261, -0.09318146109580994, 0.02184659242630005, 0.029619349166750908, 0.05967043712735176, -0.049998145550489426, -0.029961515218019485, -0.035500235855579376, -0.008181864395737648, 0.003830342087894678, -0.012050767429172993, -0.008565320633351803, 0.000986867700703442, 0.022632194682955742, -0.017230533063411713, -0.02121070958673954, -0.07209700345993042, -0.021265093237161636, -0.020889772102236748, 0.007808386813849211, -0.018504753708839417, -0.053887415677309036, -0.0066930451430380344, -0.007635665591806173, -0.014394194819033146, 0.04618631303310394, -0.05792073532938957, -0.02631337381899357, 0.02329166978597641, 0.0006059093866497278, 0.02991972677409649, -0.05900002270936966, -0.01896529272198677, 0.014179898425936699, -0.0062627894803881645, 0.06101539358496666, -0.002546808449551463, -0.028407961130142212, 0.015326985158026218, 0.03104601614177227, 0.024642668664455414, -0.019099831581115723, -0.0398809090256691, 0.02662276290357113, 0.030725382268428802, -0.0014981157146394253, 0.03376049920916557, 0.0007646236917935312, -0.022546159103512764, 0.011229977011680603, -0.08342673629522324, -0.01816314086318016, -0.00300316559150815, -0.010404971428215504, -0.05169210210442543, -0.014355135150253773, 0.007652611471712589, 0.008666365407407284, 0.0012257868656888604, -0.004750685300678015, -0.04410208761692047, 0.013165205717086792, 0.02665671519935131, 0.004306348506361246, -0.01570230908691883, -0.0330413356423378, 0.04389997199177742, 0.017010491341352463, -0.02562006376683712, -0.02813297137618065, 0.013448440469801426, -0.03320249170064926, -0.001975961262360215, 0.04480021074414253, -0.02441459335386753, -0.029940959066152573, 0.024909336119890213, -0.03631369769573212, 0.01353607326745987, 0.004211231600493193, 0.01152772270143032, 0.03479494899511337, 0.03657194599509239, -0.035580143332481384, -0.0007623870624229312, -0.03299355506896973, 0.03167145699262619, 0.011020487174391747, 0.01474717166274786, 0.00879251305013895, 0.031887754797935486, -0.009515426121652126, -0.019270403310656548, -0.02976190857589245, -0.021833166480064392, 0.019666193053126335, -0.02123219333589077, -0.0741489827632904, -0.028472844511270523, -0.037341780960559845, -0.009097409434616566, -0.023310460150241852, 0.0230114683508873, 0.03691158443689346, -0.017416726797819138, -0.019123246893286705, -0.0027523937169462442, -0.010298876091837883, 0.05795915424823761, 0.005735910031944513, -0.031731683760881424, 0.03576955199241638, -0.008322570472955704, -0.023352177813649178, 0.020028000697493553, -0.044957369565963745, -0.040018487721681595, -0.024256369099020958, -0.04189873859286308, 0.04575515165925026, 0.01175029668956995, 0.010148892179131508, -0.03507525473833084, 0.0090585732832551, -0.005752038210630417, 0.013914504088461399, -0.04476829618215561, -0.02775806002318859, -0.04456881433725357, -0.001115152146667242, -0.0073318458162248135, -0.004136634059250355, -0.018995191901922226, 0.028090456500649452, 0.017873188480734825, 0.002259095199406147, -0.004564056638628244, 0.04631534591317177, 0.056250590831041336, 0.00376536650583148, 0.009576824493706226, -0.022134127095341682, -0.03337620571255684, 0.046424176543951035, 0.01705380156636238, -0.006251770071685314, 0.014271559193730354, 0.04792100191116333, -0.010013028047978878, -0.028919560834765434, -0.032907962799072266, 0.0004984370316378772, 0.06659721583127975, 0.0010391692630946636, 0.010580729693174362, 0.007244584616273642, -0.02071012742817402, 0.017648981884121895, -0.02798134833574295, -0.0373629629611969, 0.020966537296772003, -0.005272517446428537, 0.0135495625436306, -0.011808919720351696, -0.03161393105983734, 0.02960331179201603, -0.002400635974481702, 0.04373646900057793, 0.007818341255187988, 0.028946993872523308, 0.008996552787721157, -0.017554674297571182, -0.03287019580602646, -0.052922323346138, 0.03362097218632698, -0.039631348103284836, 0.00204628542996943, -0.03868154063820839, 0.015286579728126526, 0.028765790164470673, 0.04756941273808479, 0.008937804959714413, -0.04281799867749214, -0.005848664790391922, -0.0504690445959568, -0.017089614644646645, 0.01561691053211689, -0.04264271631836891, 0.02720671519637108, -0.009839060716331005, 0.024877360090613365, 0.0022633415646851063, 0.0138459587469697, -0.021936945617198944, -0.09310948848724365, -0.02649552747607231, 0.017439281567931175, -0.01944395713508129, 0.0758041962981224, 0.01992558129131794, -0.024972036480903625, 0.02214575745165348, -0.05870922654867172, -0.00944242998957634, 0.023496361449360847, 0.04203192517161369, -0.00008937390521168709, 0.06358864903450012, -0.008595546707510948, 0.009406636469066143, -0.0032707469072192907, -0.0681237056851387, 0.1385534703731537, 0.10794748365879059, 0.02649727091193199, -0.0632363110780716, 0.011653602123260498, 0.04089541733264923, 0.010122210718691349, -0.008862928487360477, -0.03168538212776184, 0.004430591594427824, -0.029551036655902863, 0.05925671011209488, 0.020927822217345238, 0.029575105756521225, 0.0025863610208034515, 0.027485601603984833, -0.022124653682112694, -0.038299016654491425, 0.010359375737607479, 0.017082637175917625, 0.007107914425432682, -0.027544710785150528, -0.028038183227181435, -0.029771912842988968, -0.0003142489294987172, -0.0012056628474965692, -0.02820264920592308, 0.007688875775784254, 0.005907934159040451, -0.0005152187659405172, 0.00025083875516429543, -0.021887699142098427, -0.006802020128816366, 0.022664356976747513, 0.02564143016934395, -0.022458907216787338, 0.015083828940987587, -0.028241204097867012, 0.008150036446750164, 0.009052376262843609, -0.019937552511692047, 0.012983893044292927, -0.0016315969405695796, 0.03709118440747261, -0.03819198161363602, -0.0258370041847229, -0.0348292738199234, 0.03183084353804588, -0.011724074371159077, -0.013452875427901745, 0.024157404899597168, 0.021855417639017105, 0.007311777211725712, -0.0047873202711343765, -0.026622043922543526, 0.04209912568330765, -0.00020993800717405975, -0.018768638372421265, -0.013955991715192795, -0.03912344574928284, 0.028949273750185966, 0.005042893346399069, 0.04177352786064148, 0.02928769402205944, -0.017678093165159225, -0.012171720154583454, -0.07002788782119751, 0.06151236593723297, -0.00902895163744688, 0.04524116590619087, 0.008085058070719242, 0.01865718699991703, -0.011325475759804249, -0.012606020085513592, 0.026951313018798828, 0.021238848567008972, 0.0321020744740963, -0.016317544505000114, -0.02893264964222908, -0.05673541873693466, -0.025050871074199677, 0.04039866849780083, -0.02039295621216297, -0.0031495082657784224, -0.06573208421468735, -0.026442740112543106, -0.017072977498173714, 0.03052886575460434, 0.041499294340610504, 0.0633903443813324, -0.05110730603337288, 0.03606467321515083, -0.015530641190707684, -0.0502578504383564, -0.0358521044254303, 0.01425042375922203, -0.028404846787452698, -0.029471665620803833, 0.0014036528300493956, 0.05084274709224701, 0.03591952472925186, 0.003320835530757904, -0.010059714317321777, 0.02015591226518154, -0.005265766754746437, -0.04261652007699013, 0.020947763696312904, -0.005319020710885525, -0.006126865278929472, 0.01129212323576212, -0.01892692968249321, -0.02230469323694706, -0.006843043025583029, -0.049619752913713455, -0.06651830673217773, 0.018625255674123764, 0.00487637659534812, -0.05891379341483116, 0.022708440199494362, 0.02375100739300251, -0.007995306514203548, -0.005312301684170961, -0.025011977180838585, -0.03554724529385567, 0.01180288102477789, -0.03436196967959404, -0.02994385175406933, -0.00815728958696127, -0.006573385559022427, -0.007182172499597073, 0.018207311630249023, 0.032984014600515366, 0.010256486013531685, -0.021685320883989334, -0.015418746508657932, 0.00873496849089861, 0.013435541652143002, 0.03073664754629135, -0.008983013220131397, 0.008028232492506504, -0.02173616550862789, -0.039206210523843765, -0.05370359867811203, 0.03392091020941734, 0.016241734847426414, 0.0320783294737339, -0.007561937440186739, 0.0212596133351326, -0.011817456223070621, 0.05131078511476517, -0.02449488639831543, -0.006248025689274073, -0.02089058980345726, -0.0006905951886437833, 0.019511612132191658, -0.0018249754793941975, 0.011568515561521053, 0.011224436573684216, -0.007663646247237921, 0.02938072942197323, 0.07270470261573792, -0.017959732562303543, 0.017666378989815712, 0.012622582726180553, -0.03944753482937813, -0.01035927515476942, 0.01338091678917408, -0.011980393901467323, 0.007613762281835079, 0.055954162031412125, 0.018851326778531075, 0.04322657734155655, 0.005857172422111034, 0.02201237343251705, -0.08753853291273117, -0.02265228144824505, 0.031296469271183014, 0.005869472865015268, 0.044248394668102264, -0.05850113183259964, -0.0022966472897678614, 0.014328667894005775, -0.02067692205309868, -0.0010527163976803422, -0.01748119480907917, 0.021930057555437088, -0.0010399274760857224, -0.009145714342594147, -0.031618427485227585, 0.02672288753092289, 0.020984482020139694, 0.012795169837772846, 0.052188195288181305, 0.010099707171320915, 0.018436836078763008, -0.0356176421046257, -0.03588693216443062, 0.030844278633594513, 0.02935003489255905, -0.03430488705635071, 0.027776332572102547, -0.026261044666171074, -0.01158927846699953, 0.014405968599021435, -0.004204956814646721, 0.024046534672379494, 0.029035186395049095, 0.025112558156251907, 0.03176027908921242, 0.023465728387236595, 0.0387239046394825, 0.0011018543737009168, 0.006310450378805399, 0.018716802820563316, 0.01764855533838272, 0.023458000272512436, -0.02810717560350895, 0.012406368739902973, -0.033295173197984695, 0.013739779591560364, -0.021113639697432518, 0.042243506759405136, -0.02510152943432331, 0.03655219078063965, 0.01243560016155243, -0.005256170406937599, -0.0031578605994582176, -0.02344747632741928, 0.00324780261144042, -0.027667371556162834, 0.004409993067383766, 0.021890820935368538, 0.05535605177283287, -0.032255884259939194, 0.026127023622393608, -0.0014384840615093708, -0.023195872083306313, -0.0077994223684072495, -0.02114020101726055, -0.009246651083230972, -0.0177683774381876, 0.003242647275328636, 0.0183220524340868, -0.021171271800994873, -0.005770160350948572, 0.021416587755084038, -0.04428703337907791, 0.02688748762011528, -0.013373504392802715, -0.011518293991684914, 0.008863457478582859, -0.022046729922294617, 0.050871338695287704, -0.08288604766130447, 0.058904558420181274, 0.0038035099860280752, -0.011604632250964642, -0.011546316556632519, -0.0012282866518944502, -0.04350621998310089, 0.04781888797879219, 0.039650365710258484, 0.03356606513261795, -0.01013004407286644, 0.0016260129632428288, 0.0390176959335804, 0.011736993677914143, -0.03969963639974594, 0.037431586533784866, -0.0002164704055758193, 0.004921748302876949, -0.024196665734052658, -0.009459798224270344, -0.0005935015506111085, 0.019016413018107414, 0.0315973237156868, -0.031661923974752426, 0.02293393574655056, 0.02740318886935711, 0.0062929862178862095, 0.04675471782684326, -0.007849588058888912, -0.02511466108262539, 0.04900602251291275, -0.019467700272798538, 0.004348886199295521, 0.0829240009188652, -0.01967017911374569, -0.09028664231300354, 0.02861708775162697, 0.016752740368247032, 0.0006593113066628575, 0.024340223520994186, 0.0024393920321017504, 0.0034178905189037323, -0.03562396019697189, 0.022281035780906677, 0.030983489006757736, -0.016696983948349953, -0.0008425167761743069, 0.026032211259007454, 0.031909357756376266, 0.044851768761873245, -0.029901321977376938, 0.023471422493457794, -0.005452414974570274, -0.046674858778715134, 0.019789427518844604, -0.0057586561888456345, 0.04471409320831299, 0.012133042328059673, 0.038465727120637894, 0.007619482930749655, -0.01840481348335743, 0.0024439787957817316, -0.0071177673526108265, 0.027828995138406754, -0.07924896478652954, -0.01013276632875204, -0.0008102852734737098, -0.011211087927222252, 0.03516702726483345, -0.002257916610687971, -0.011587575078010559, 0.01140500232577324, -0.05651580169796944, -0.006667269393801689, -0.039293184876441956, -0.024086810648441315, -0.02523418515920639, -0.011969649232923985, 0.02854245901107788, -0.010544627904891968, 0.04515865445137024, 0.036785922944545746, 0.02266104146838188, -0.016807597130537033, 0.0003386499884072691, -0.0019433944253250957, -0.0006155654555186629, 0.010194879025220871, 0.009226789698004723, -0.0231804046779871, -0.004297640174627304, -0.025275269523262978, -0.03784232586622238, 0.03896608203649521, 0.020764123648405075, -0.0007787278736941516, -0.08699469268321991, -0.02065526880323887, 0.02703120931982994, 0.023891182616353035, -0.040985796600580215, -0.002702187281101942, -0.02317674830555916, 0.013588299043476582, 0.02051279880106449, -0.0456254705786705 ]
<p>i try to implement a simple gaussian process regression in java. I almost got every step from the book <a href="http://www.GaussianProcess.org/gpml" rel="nofollow">http://www.GaussianProcess.org/gpml</a> .</p> <p>With my implementation of algorithm 2.1 on page 19 i'm able to produce results but:</p> <p>I have the strange behavior that all predicted datapoints where i do not have any target tend to be of zero value. Does anyone know this behavior or can explain where i could have taken a mistake?</p> <p>In my plot the red line marks the predicted values, black are the targets.</p> <p>Here is the prediction and covariance java code. The parameter array includes length scale and noise, I work with the idexes of the arrays as x inputs for the covaiance function:</p> <pre><code>private double generateCOV_RADIAL(int i, int j) { double covar = Math.pow(parameter[1], 2.0) * Math.exp(-1.0 * (Math.pow(i - j, 2.0)/(2 * Math.pow(parameter[0], 2.0)))); if(i==j) covar += Math.pow(parameter[2], 2); return covar; } public void predict(int predictFuture) throws IllegalArgumentException, IllegalAccessException, InvocationTargetException{ RealMatrix y = MatrixUtils.createColumnRealMatrix(this.targets); double mean = StatUtils.mean(this.targets); for(int i = 0; i &lt; this.targets.length;i++) { targets[i] -= mean; } RealMatrix K = MatrixUtils.createRealMatrix(cov); //identity matrix for I RealMatrix k_eye = MatrixUtils.createRealIdentityMatrix(cov.length); //choleski(K + sigman^2*I) CholeskyDecomposition L = null; try { L = new CholeskyDecompositionImpl( K.add( k_eye.scalarMultiply(Math.pow(parameter[2], 2)) ) ); } catch (NonSquareMatrixException e) { e.printStackTrace(); } catch (NotSymmetricMatrixException e) { e.printStackTrace(); } catch (NotPositiveDefiniteMatrixException e) { e.printStackTrace(); } //inverse of Ltranspose for left devision RealMatrix L_transpose_1 = new LUDecompositionImpl(L.getLT()).getSolver().getInverse(); //inverse of Ltranspose for left devision RealMatrix L_1 = new LUDecompositionImpl(L.getL()).getSolver().getInverse(); //alpha = L'\(L\y) RealMatrix alpha = L_transpose_1.multiply(L_1).multiply(y); double L_diag = 0.0; for(int i = 0; i &lt; L.getL().getColumnDimension();i++) { L_diag += Math.log(L.getL().getEntry(i, i)); } double logpyX = - y.transpose().multiply(alpha).scalarMultiply(0.5).getData()[0][0] - L_diag - predictFuture * Math.log(2 * Math.PI) * 0.5; double[] fstar = new double[targets.length + predictFuture]; double[] V = new double[targets.length + predictFuture]; for(int i = 0;i &lt; targets.length + predictFuture;i++) { double[] kstar = new double[targets.length]; for(int j = 0; j &lt; targets.length;j++) { double covar = (Double)covMethod.invoke(this,j,i); kstar[j] = covar; } //f*=k_*^T * alpha fstar[i] = MatrixUtils.createColumnRealMatrix(kstar).transpose().multiply(alpha).getData()[0][0]; fstar[i] += mean; //v = L\k_* RealMatrix v = L_1.multiply(MatrixUtils.createColumnRealMatrix(kstar)); //V[fstar] = k(x_*,x_*) - v^T*v double covar = (Double)covMethod.invoke(this,i,i); V[i] = covar - v.transpose().multiply(v).getData()[0][0] + Math.pow(parameter[2],2); } this.predicted_mean = fstar; this.predicted_variance = V; } </code></pre> <p>Thank you</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/hfjBL.jpg" alt="GP Example"></p>
74,052
[ -0.02569788321852684, -0.03651247173547745, 0.00006890942313475534, -0.013123072683811188, 0.05842537432909012, -0.013457710854709148, -0.060220152139663696, -0.058578893542289734, 0.003384198760613799, -0.009504827670753002, 0.0644085705280304, 0.01667480356991291, 0.044002655893564224, 0.05257216468453407, 0.0030793575569987297, 0.008875371888279915, -0.0724329799413681, 0.017329541966319084, 0.02519931271672249, -0.008796079084277153, -0.003338976763188839, 0.0422055721282959, 0.009476072154939175, -0.03885059431195259, -0.0173815730959177, 0.033317770808935165, 0.013639980927109718, -0.029050959274172783, 0.005064623896032572, 0.032300543040037155, -0.07007832825183868, -0.004224937409162521, 0.01215630304068327, -0.006611121352761984, 0.033158767968416214, 0.0422632098197937, 0.0030194169376045465, -0.060100238770246506, -0.0502595417201519, 0.0014089732430875301, 0.003363176481798291, -0.029305515810847282, 0.005816433113068342, 0.03591315448284149, 0.027429495006799698, 0.01614639163017273, -0.01915222965180874, -0.013132691383361816, 0.07653931528329849, -0.021799910813570023, 0.08304354548454285, 0.007365442346781492, 0.032715655863285065, 0.007314604707062244, -0.0466565378010273, 0.001146249589510262, 0.05315995216369629, 0.05655646696686745, -0.020312273874878883, -0.05131573975086212, 0.007325686048716307, -0.0018609482795000076, -0.009531179443001747, 0.009698139503598213, -0.019826704636216164, 0.02269129827618599, 0.010909488424658775, -0.016445215791463852, 0.024922622367739677, -0.010996979661285877, 0.05209425091743469, -0.024129090830683708, -0.009508389979600906, -0.018804052844643593, 0.02712937444448471, 0.014944499358534813, -0.01892634853720665, 0.03035668283700943, 0.044859979301691055, -0.007219533436000347, 0.038348082453012466, 0.031266454607248306, -0.018715959042310715, -0.008770161308348179, 0.0008211974054574966, 0.04646971449255943, 0.033393844962120056, -0.035260751843452454, 0.0056035700254142284, 0.062003202736377716, -0.01772487163543701, -0.021412694826722145, 0.048826996237039566, -0.003587067127227783, 0.006470941007137299, 0.06409045308828354, -0.010946886613965034, 0.04867439717054367, -0.014125729911029339, 0.01991458423435688, -0.03730454295873642, -0.0237319003790617, 0.018907370045781136, 0.03857666999101639, -0.018665602430701256, -0.0017240492161363363, -0.011222759261727333, -0.0014748607063665986, -0.025062918663024902, -0.052513569593429565, -0.019507527351379395, 0.009146853350102901, 0.008666453883051872, -0.0051042018458247185, 0.022238850593566895, -0.012866132892668247, -0.032406553626060486, 0.010911588557064533, 0.007526662200689316, 0.04830346256494522, 0.04932320863008499, 0.020737145096063614, 0.005366223864257336, -0.015917235985398293, -0.01650427281856537, 0.004984491970390081, 0.04453715309500694, -0.010800978168845177, -0.060269445180892944, 0.038983460515737534, 0.02738317660987377, -0.021812452003359795, 0.024760747328400612, -0.0021520599257200956, 0.03223804011940956, -0.006445680279284716, -0.08244084566831589, -0.03785146400332451, 0.03196180984377861, -0.04510178416967392, 0.024849724024534225, -0.07281875610351562, -0.03755360469222069, 0.012739942409098148, 0.056248653680086136, -0.02095210552215576, 0.017008688300848007, 0.021627651527523994, 0.056197330355644226, -0.005799205508083105, 0.003080911934375763, -0.015879446640610695, -0.06646305322647095, -0.029664112254977226, -0.018639760091900826, -0.04716561362147331, 0.020231051370501518, 0.012874381616711617, -0.01891462877392769, -0.003855967428535223, 0.05635024979710579, 0.011158746667206287, 0.03095608577132225, 0.021279452368617058, -0.020677607506513596, -0.03533080592751503, 0.06874221563339233, 0.03538459911942482, 0.04538213834166527, 0.015291829593479633, -0.022131159901618958, 0.03605971485376358, -0.007498926483094692, 0.022069983184337616, 0.03981207311153412, -0.0045665353536605835, 0.016178542748093605, -0.038681063801050186, -0.011872023344039917, -0.002857608487829566, -0.03223956376314163, -0.053675808012485504, 0.026220202445983887, 0.00035839181509800255, 0.03163807839155197, 0.03951127827167511, 0.018999040126800537, 0.000962449936196208, 0.016272690147161484, -0.03800252452492714, -0.002904157619923353, -0.032923031598329544, 0.0058227661065757275, 0.013735723681747913, -0.046316761523485184, 0.002129720523953438, -0.018501916900277138, 0.024945955723524094, 0.0203882846981287, -0.015228421427309513, -0.04326934367418289, -0.014273370616137981, 0.027450822293758392, -0.03291679173707962, 0.05603097006678581, 0.05333704128861427, 0.020428892225027084, -0.028183819726109505, 0.0579061359167099, -0.003089446108788252, -0.01564835198223591, 0.009336836636066437, -0.017337137833237648, -0.0050673517398536205, 0.023096024990081787, -0.034673698246479034, -0.0032698288559913635, 0.010854072868824005, -0.008383121341466904, 0.018589036539196968, -0.03397165238857269, 0.01610533706843853, 0.07579568773508072, -0.015567435882985592, -0.006874049082398415, 0.046130578964948654, -0.034640513360500336, 0.030781526118516922, -0.010269172489643097, -0.023107454180717468, -0.034054819494485855, -0.02413765713572502, -0.004878349136561155, 0.05618945136666298, -0.03596249967813492, -0.0233073141425848, 0.07716082781553268, 0.034314218908548355, 0.016389142721891403, 0.018460696563124657, 0.03389671444892883, -0.009195507504045963, 0.06170506775379181, 0.0018080574227496982, 0.006195696070790291, -0.015126239508390427, -0.0006258963840082288, 0.007306417915970087, 0.0439397394657135, 0.008145177736878395, -0.04008113965392113, 0.02055293694138527, -0.0039473725482821465, -0.004057139158248901, -0.04329749196767807, 0.007517724763602018, 0.011124235577881336, 0.007900538854300976, 0.00821582693606615, 0.07043958455324173, 0.007774145342409611, -0.007800261490046978, -0.031049516052007675, -0.032940078526735306, -0.02384595386683941, 0.03902175650000572, -0.014446175657212734, 0.014746411703526974, -0.0010147352004423738, -0.04747014492750168, 0.005136270076036453, 0.017990365624427795, -0.010774313472211361, -0.03220762312412262, 0.012915592640638351, 0.015350705944001675, 0.016363468021154404, 0.0013097448972985148, -0.01537416409701109, -0.0391719788312912, -0.03282346576452255, 0.0020201706793159246, 0.052160780876874924, 0.013257818296551704, -0.058549270033836365, 0.006872761994600296, -0.048169806599617004, 0.010127555578947067, 0.03882588818669319, -0.028941769152879715, -0.006983843166381121, 0.057185590267181396, -0.028447864577174187, -0.045255064964294434, -0.059097595512866974, -0.01234442088752985, -0.009438199922442436, -0.0430082306265831, -0.0007961955852806568, 0.057608217000961304, 0.009239946492016315, -0.03843415901064873, 0.039492376148700714, 0.017214467748999596, 0.0007102785748429596, -0.05610041692852974, -0.046482112258672714, 0.012965700589120388, -0.0026244292967021465, 0.05247543007135391, 0.017402106896042824, -0.018752500414848328, 0.047681912779808044, -0.059776876121759415, -0.07046365737915039, -0.02924160286784172, 0.01769256591796875, 0.024474600329995155, -0.02427176758646965, 0.026817932724952698, 0.0547606498003006, 0.011651590466499329, -0.03037092089653015, -0.060986265540122986, -0.00016724495799280703, -0.037165671586990356, -0.04889023303985596, 0.0071830167435109615, -0.004007119685411453, 0.0370914600789547, -0.0023944673594087362, -0.031209426000714302, 0.02935858815908432, 0.05227700620889664, -0.003311535343527794, 0.014367605559527874, 0.01967419497668743, -0.008670462295413017, -0.027696220204234123, 0.0735291913151741, -0.00040017618448473513, 0.0012811501510441303, -0.006577590946108103, 0.02470291033387184, -0.00028732066857628524, 0.009932231158018112, -0.03458437696099281, 0.00003929318700102158, -0.0526941679418087, 0.030854878947138786, -0.03927759826183319, 0.03145084157586098, 0.008198565803468227, -0.03262240067124367, -0.05250022932887077, 0.017151983454823494, 0.04556901752948761, -0.021881025284528732, -0.006809022277593613, 0.03245023265480995, 0.0033317403867840767, -0.00856619980186224, 0.0272346343845129, -0.02182222157716751, -0.005948454607278109, 0.04650993272662163, 0.024407939985394478, -0.019687103107571602, 0.04705708473920822, 0.01656763255596161, -0.02680387534201145, 0.004366649314761162, -0.015606211498379707, -0.03280016407370567, -0.03499317169189453, 0.020275793969631195, -0.05119464173913002, 0.06588225811719894, -0.002294090809300542, 0.05728515610098839, 0.044672053307294846, -0.020586354658007622, -0.015099842101335526, -0.003105812706053257, -0.04444406181573868, 0.006160651333630085, -0.012428998947143555, -0.030149664729833603, 0.010017079301178455, -0.049397338181734085, -0.04267353564500809, -0.007481596898287535, 0.022045698016881943, 0.03906989470124245, 0.02113782800734043, -0.04867870733141899, 0.01903156191110611, -0.0231028962880373, -0.02434461936354637, -0.036157626658678055, 0.023597562685608864, 0.03776417300105095, -0.011454355902969837, 0.04761655628681183, 0.041901182383298874, -0.017971979454159737, -0.00031062457128427923, -0.020597778260707855, -0.0037704294081777334, 0.01814216375350952, 0.0477016344666481, 0.02708769403398037, 0.027821648865938187, -0.001337251509539783, 0.033931758254766464, 0.008971072733402252, 0.023900769650936127, 0.07894385606050491, -0.01209612563252449, 0.00436613941565156, -0.055075909942388535, -0.007413351442664862, 0.06397276371717453, 0.014832374639809132, 0.005669193807989359, -0.009015634655952454, 0.032233722507953644, -0.015908926725387573, 0.030012542381882668, -0.012407772243022919, 0.10559503734111786, 0.0009892290690913796, 0.025738956406712532, -0.018516553565859795, -0.007422863971441984, 0.0007891099085099995, -0.011454306542873383, 0.015551134943962097, -0.01538422703742981, -0.03414681553840637, -0.005540403537452221, 0.04048244282603264, -0.007424077484756708, -0.00779681233689189, -0.0025340591091662645, 0.0034163801465183496, 0.023683011531829834, -0.015017091296613216, -0.0018088892102241516, 0.038882482796907425, 0.016131801530718803, -0.0030671856366097927, 0.031410105526447296, 0.022248167544603348, -0.026974737644195557, 0.03102085366845131, 0.03723685070872307, -0.00015794136561453342, -0.01126258447766304, 0.0005323193036019802, -0.05597492307424545, -0.027185488492250443, -0.01708395592868328, -0.03913072869181633, 0.02535407803952694, -0.03471364453434944, -0.0004238256369717419, -0.011283624917268753, -0.01858232170343399, -0.038505956530570984, -0.007643934804946184, -0.043569594621658325, 0.015228690579533577, -0.048668984323740005, -0.011916017159819603, -0.02916361205279827, 0.011120656505227089, 0.0014192481758072972, 0.037364110350608826, -0.07354661822319031, -0.0026559841353446245, -0.004995947238057852, 0.009892570786178112, -0.003901831107214093, -0.02467757649719715, 0.025996312499046326, 0.009383289143443108, 0.0160372294485569, 0.07644384354352951, -0.021355003118515015, -0.039549604058265686, 0.016132185235619545, 0.029430631548166275, -0.016914192587137222, -0.03154343366622925, -0.03522219508886337, -0.008539795875549316, 0.021533269435167313, -0.01351078785955906, 0.06929324567317963, 0.027835911139845848, -0.04973466694355011, -0.0019890957046300173, -0.06618739664554596, -0.004284805618226528, 0.003910397179424763, -0.033794429153203964, -0.06156653165817261, 0.00013557536294683814, 0.012035098858177662, -0.019385863095521927, 0.015951259061694145, 0.026194674894213676, -0.05039268732070923, 0.01587180607020855, 0.030831430107355118, 0.01683465950191021, -0.048092421144247055, 0.007796678226441145, 0.0029347226954996586, 0.01951131410896778, -0.005513226613402367, -0.010012679733335972, 0.030830413103103638, -0.024209098890423775, -0.00466156005859375, 0.02947167307138443, -0.03865717723965645, -0.014064314775168896, -0.04639994725584984, 0.021166685968637466, 0.013157682493329048, -0.0690818727016449, 0.016628989949822426, 0.004401562735438347, 0.034200266003608704, 0.05294366553425789, -0.030952882021665573, -0.023290036246180534, -0.02467215806245804, -0.02891581319272518, 0.01853509061038494, 0.004773297812789679, -0.002896752906963229, -0.035185929387807846, 0.006916256621479988, -0.060911789536476135, -0.031006360426545143, -0.008421744219958782, -0.06398104131221771, -0.03571571782231331, 0.00914047472178936, -0.05698872730135918, -0.023332390934228897, -0.015500618144869804, -0.02205999568104744, 0.038306087255477905, -0.025001823902130127, -0.008516923524439335, 0.04314897209405899, 0.006648240610957146, 0.06806442141532898, -0.004946005064994097, -0.02414575219154358, 0.03523937985301018, -0.015096787363290787, -0.04614464193582535, 0.01950877718627453, 0.03150894492864609, -0.020737091079354286, -0.021165473386645317, -0.024232743307948112, 0.00736478203907609, 0.006846378091722727, -0.022133508697152138, -0.03276250138878822, -0.0035451010335236788, 0.00022718062973581254, -0.007218015380203724, -0.03273061662912369, -0.03232130780816078, 0.002740351017564535, -0.052476681768894196, -0.002269305754452944, -0.017605366185307503, -0.0204036682844162, -0.018360164016485214, -0.00058410206111148, -0.008278627879917622, 0.008140952326357365, 0.01819515787065029, 0.0282051432877779, 0.020533913746476173, -0.009409270249307156, 0.006642954424023628, -0.042804088443517685, 0.025706538930535316, 0.0057068634778261185, 0.015937957912683487, 0.02263864316046238, 0.004653189331293106, -0.046794820576906204, -0.02373609133064747, -0.05228189751505852, 0.037578921765089035, 0.07650987058877945, -0.03089396096765995, 0.05321840941905975, 0.03096100129187107, 0.024609196931123734, -0.019851213321089745, -0.04617161676287651, -0.0032671696972101927, -0.03540186583995819, 0.007715484127402306, 0.029307479038834572, -0.009864160791039467, -0.005216173827648163, 0.008575543761253357, 0.035542044788599014, 0.028415411710739136, 0.01478180754929781, -0.000005980918558634585, 0.031271375715732574, -0.04566456377506256, -0.022210843861103058, -0.02027958072721958, 0.027868645265698433, -0.013643370941281319, 0.026800278574228287, -0.02027343399822712, -0.011926505714654922, 0.005512102972716093, 0.04013562574982643, 0.0021765371784567833, -0.03866208717226982, -0.007485385052859783, -0.017948288470506668, 0.01493839081376791, 0.004875035025179386, -0.027491051703691483, 0.004162345547229052, 0.024068379774689674, 0.025084827095270157, 0.026149656623601913, 0.039245449006557465, -0.06565193086862564, -0.08263427019119263, -0.057299576699733734, -0.04942016303539276, -0.04597179964184761, 0.050072189420461655, 0.0326843336224556, -0.07025855779647827, -0.0058200666680932045, -0.004183385521173477, 0.058952514082193375, 0.026911206543445587, -0.008650819770991802, -0.001947262091562152, 0.07884323596954346, -0.006576430983841419, -0.004397984594106674, -0.002293709199875593, 0.039408691227436066, 0.1458483785390854, 0.07327310740947723, 0.026734065264463425, -0.030350971966981888, -0.02461215667426586, -0.016319315880537033, 0.001583849429152906, -0.022347254678606987, 0.006272088270634413, -0.018331803381443024, -0.03857763484120369, 0.015648821368813515, 0.0024565611965954304, 0.010765395127236843, 0.02280140109360218, 0.004712996073067188, -0.02270282246172428, -0.027466459199786186, -0.01125896256417036, -0.013134467415511608, -0.0069646756164729595, 0.02382568083703518, -0.03206060081720352, 0.02154584415256977, -0.03706882894039154, -0.005828636698424816, -0.027694951742887497, 0.008712055161595345, 0.010096102021634579, 0.01309429295361042, -0.010409649461507797, 0.026121340692043304, 0.020393870770931244, 0.02034706622362137, 0.01561987679451704, 0.015682589262723923, 0.009991073049604893, -0.03951171785593033, -0.004854011349380016, -0.005841529928147793, -0.005619636736810207, 0.01795319654047489, 0.03625846281647682, 0.017277544364333153, -0.0024080793373286724, -0.04030165448784828, -0.04248125106096268, 0.07353676110506058, -0.028301779180765152, -0.02395608276128769, -0.011171630583703518, 0.016608620062470436, 0.012862375937402248, -0.09879902005195618, 0.011126498691737652, -0.012017141096293926, 0.014345169998705387, -0.020337454974651337, -0.044967904686927795, -0.006732405163347721, 0.03942306712269783, 0.017752384766936302, 0.009316697716712952, 0.029571086168289185, -0.038174379616975784, -0.01882300153374672, -0.04104221239686012, 0.07287003099918365, -0.017677143216133118, 0.009393628686666489, 0.02491339109838009, -0.033521540462970734, 0.006306578870862722, -0.05233711376786232, 0.011195807717740536, -0.013144489377737045, 0.026909951120615005, -0.00036737718619406223, -0.02838677167892456, -0.037300437688827515, -0.04065068066120148, -0.0014624580508098006, -0.02547970972955227, -0.026032041758298874, -0.022174200043082237, -0.011527596972882748, -0.005034325178712606, 0.0396663062274456, 0.007729955483227968, 0.012340929359197617, -0.02247496321797371, 0.03997291252017021, 0.005087061319500208, -0.039152842015028, -0.038356248289346695, 0.018205566331744194, -0.020822638645768166, 0.001960985129699111, -0.01899138279259205, 0.09201227873563766, 0.027346719056367874, 0.03542717918753624, 0.006774520501494408, 0.05453258007764816, -0.022826194763183594, -0.017744051292538643, 0.0025364398024976254, -0.024105127900838852, 0.005749387200921774, -0.02470264956355095, -0.0008192826062440872, -0.02472379058599472, 0.009605473838746548, -0.018056990578770638, -0.05153217539191246, 0.016297124326229095, -0.015475490130484104, -0.04762353375554085, 0.013692903332412243, -0.03659480810165405, -0.010060195811092854, 0.003918483853340149, -0.009895742870867252, -0.011168260127305984, -0.005399677436798811, -0.034817446023225784, -0.020913325250148773, -0.031787529587745667, 0.029760250821709633, -0.028642702847719193, 0.033131103962659836, 0.013922157697379589, 0.010440092533826828, 0.019365394487977028, 0.04162853956222534, 0.05675377696752548, -0.015429317951202393, 0.04540426656603813, -0.009811474941670895, 0.022753015160560608, 0.019115377217531204, -0.022977007552981377, -0.036120712757110596, -0.013885125517845154, 0.015710553154349327, 0.047950465232133865, 0.01525837555527687, -0.0026129768230021, -0.022667663171887398, 0.08491449058055878, -0.0013598616933450103, 0.037509143352508545, -0.0415947325527668, 0.011757584288716316, 0.03303734213113785, 0.00572357140481472, 0.03522694855928421, -0.018943117931485176, -0.010700923390686512, 0.006766403093934059, 0.006648949813097715, 0.00021060141443740577, 0.025170957669615746, 0.011496719904243946, -0.015349720604717731, -0.009338882751762867, 0.012417031452059746, 0.009248936548829079, 0.001789411879144609, 0.04225766286253929, -0.0059432461857795715, 0.027570482343435287, -0.02290719747543335, 0.036756809800863266, -0.05578669160604477, -0.034070901572704315, -0.007207788992673159, 0.007944419048726559, 0.025281423702836037, -0.018205005675554276, -0.008071999065577984, 0.0578860342502594, -0.05904974788427353, 0.02129742130637169, 0.0019312432268634439, -0.016288001090288162, -0.05138305574655533, 0.007033715955913067, -0.017489714547991753, 0.018613411113619804, 0.05373041704297066, 0.012742617167532444, 0.047509461641311646, 0.05078239366412163, 0.0009205075330100954, -0.027956927195191383, -0.04132752865552902, 0.033403344452381134, -0.013795613311231136, 0.00384468212723732, 0.01249186135828495, -0.012472806498408318, 0.01540427003055811, 0.02196977287530899, -0.014303767122328281, 0.005274046678096056, -0.01990876905620098, 0.051197491586208344, 0.06395483762025833, 0.06225525215268135, 0.041161105036735535, 0.004452868364751339, 0.032079409807920456, -0.006216853857040405, -0.0016329447971656919, 0.0035702441819012165, 0.011259838938713074, 0.0404488630592823, 0.03199392929673195, 0.020174391567707062, -0.004307036753743887, 0.028412088751792908, -0.016494624316692352, -0.027788344770669937, -0.001061611226759851, 0.0384720042347908, -0.01368433702737093, -0.034407760947942734, 0.034169070422649384, -0.039979539811611176, 0.010866272263228893, 0.018446531146764755, 0.004575826693326235, -0.027707615867257118, -0.013856538571417332, -0.00000869599807629129, -0.01808054931461811, 0.02170291729271412, 0.0065125213004648685, -0.03272966295480728, -0.029497649520635605, 0.023768970742821693, -0.009014847688376904, -0.004165529739111662, -0.014024336822330952, -0.022452544420957565, -0.044113196432590485, 0.03958391025662422, 0.023891057819128036, 0.027586450800299644, 0.0026849773712456226, -0.016811663284897804, 0.006124132312834263, -0.10518528521060944, 0.05840756744146347, -0.0005283296341076493, -0.02989019639790058, -0.03353213518857956, 0.01962159015238285, 0.007351509761065245, 0.037380654364824295, 0.017326196655631065, -0.007702789269387722, 0.04083750396966934, 0.0042917183600366116, 0.003763084067031741, -0.022442255169153214, -0.03883076459169388, 0.03568929061293602, 0.055827826261520386, -0.04352615773677826, -0.0007526708650402725, -0.01150194089859724, -0.008292849175632, 0.0655185878276825, 0.017323380336165428, 0.020691873505711555, 0.011844241060316563, -0.0016077214386314154, -0.0377599261701107, 0.005976625252515078, -0.005805245600640774, 0.007345431484282017, 0.06944835186004639, -0.03321225941181183, 0.03371603414416313, 0.009034285321831703, 0.006688049994409084, -0.05628169700503349, 0.0008423824328929186, -0.021490901708602905, -0.027217302471399307, -0.027817659080028534, -0.030284471809864044, 0.021871652454137802, -0.02633371390402317, 0.005566406063735485, 0.07531515508890152, -0.0028658024966716766, -0.006485248450189829, 0.0549473837018013, 0.0014211076777428389, 0.008680740371346474, 0.021942490711808205, 0.013323364779353142, -0.002284159418195486, -0.00566260376945138, 0.049341026693582535, 0.04166721925139427, 0.01706244796514511, 0.022816214710474014, -0.02403552457690239, 0.031584616750478745, -0.026890970766544342, -0.012194779701530933, -0.023131925612688065, 0.05804939568042755, -0.04673667997121811, -0.014781391248106956, -0.004885162226855755, -0.03583873063325882, 0.016868583858013153, 0.013008850626647472, 0.0027192803099751472, 0.0349402092397213, -0.019277803599834442, 0.000024633436623844318, -0.02413835935294628, 0.010020586661994457, -0.002179966075345874, -0.003276330651715398, 0.0011514381039887667, 0.01389855332672596, -0.0047257342375814915, 0.029162608087062836, 0.00937699805945158, 0.008593939244747162, 0.03972288593649864, -0.07758095115423203, 0.016922175884246826, 0.02972964197397232, -0.009465756826102734, 0.008605300448834896, 0.009404224343597889, -0.01479396503418684, -0.019736777991056442, 0.028636787086725235, 0.011020979844033718, -0.02020370028913021, -0.045105740427970886, 0.014654112979769707, 0.012359866872429848, 0.05544113367795944, -0.08155541867017746, 0.006773203145712614, 0.007082980126142502, 0.03433431684970856, -0.03644697740674019, 0.025099139660596848 ]
<p>I want to create an equation that consists of two independent variables "duration" and "data_transferred", and one dependent variable "meeting_quality"</p> <p>This is what I want:</p> <p>meeting_quality would be good, if more data is transferred in less duration.</p> <p>meeting_quality would be bad, if less data is transferred in more duration.</p> <p>What should be the equation presentation of above sentence? Thanks in advance.</p> <p>In fact, I want to use the values above equation in regression analysis. I would really be grateful for any further advice.</p>
74,053
[ -0.020131435245275497, -0.003503335639834404, -0.0032955592032521963, 0.01608288288116455, 0.027618462219834328, 0.022134171798825264, -0.01346532255411148, -0.025795578956604004, 0.052584875375032425, 0.0067350552417337894, 0.05952902138233185, 0.027561597526073456, 0.06564114987850189, 0.024366192519664764, 0.014412835240364075, 0.014983457513153553, 0.008292837999761105, 0.018523352220654488, -0.010039678774774075, -0.011488424614071846, 0.008215210400521755, -0.013907959684729576, 0.03190118074417114, 0.012268537655472755, -0.003767108777537942, 0.05312461033463478, 0.04511203244328499, -0.006821973714977503, -0.03263549879193306, 0.07029565423727036, -0.018358642235398293, -0.051645342260599136, 0.012718778103590012, 0.05822708457708359, 0.026336515322327614, 0.025758113712072372, -0.042686570435762405, -0.0032165730372071266, 0.01848340779542923, 0.019359387457370758, -0.023333262652158737, -0.008287680335342884, 0.050997912883758545, 0.056245021522045135, -0.027191108092665672, -0.0008376632467843592, 0.04365319386124611, -0.037803635001182556, 0.012212757021188736, -0.05471213161945343, 0.08621116727590561, -0.014549457468092442, 0.07167496532201767, 0.0063763875514268875, -0.01980091817677021, 0.031803570687770844, 0.028523797169327736, 0.04837363585829735, -0.0005395664484240115, -0.05066089704632759, 0.004263502545654774, 0.012069030664861202, 0.01722734607756138, 0.016316020861268044, -0.012160814367234707, 0.004376955796033144, -0.0175032801926136, 0.021629950031638145, 0.016690922901034355, -0.03523785620927811, -0.009138709865510464, 0.02282874658703804, 0.09043635427951813, -0.0004913079901598394, 0.02645685523748398, -0.051262833178043365, 0.03589308634400368, 0.025818560272455215, 0.018042370676994324, 0.05883987993001938, -0.017928684130311012, -0.001763506093993783, 0.009875571355223656, 0.0017125415615737438, -0.009007581509649754, -0.026015471667051315, 0.07766378670930862, -0.017294777557253838, 0.02236095257103443, 0.01846890151500702, -0.01656828634440899, 0.005987937096506357, 0.01716150902211666, 0.05729108303785324, 0.018602710217237473, -0.02216656319797039, 0.005820547230541706, 0.033599160611629486, 0.026500532403588295, -0.005190229043364525, 0.005942565854638815, -0.03449907526373863, -0.033035121858119965, 0.010986847802996635, -0.02580021508038044, 0.0013512009754776955, -0.01804949715733528, -0.04476543143391609, -0.0072422148659825325, -0.024684526026248932, -0.014676065184175968, -0.0204851683229208, 0.020062357187271118, 0.013769582845270634, 0.004062974825501442, -0.04662635549902916, -0.027733391150832176, 0.010966709814965725, 0.05458793789148331, 0.08556243777275085, 0.0537787489593029, -0.047353971749544144, 0.07389917224645615, 0.012236016802489758, -0.03726010397076607, 0.016298547387123108, -0.01884961500763893, -0.016729088500142097, -0.02025822550058365, 0.04666613042354584, -0.012805652804672718, -0.001182209001854062, 0.032209888100624084, -0.017768878489732742, 0.01512119174003601, 0.03275167569518089, -0.0583888478577137, -0.020107032731175423, 0.004887514282017946, 0.0031440563034266233, 0.019347742199897766, -0.07477855682373047, 0.007982163690030575, 0.021919438615441322, 0.05695438012480736, 0.01821725070476532, 0.026275120675563812, 0.004463141784071922, -0.0005680609028786421, -0.0030979709699749947, -0.03440195322036743, -0.012541348114609718, -0.01410083007067442, 0.008719824254512787, 0.006593305617570877, -0.047933463007211685, -0.014258175157010555, 0.06027306616306305, -0.020294953137636185, 0.027585642412304878, 0.04393305256962776, 0.007096785120666027, -0.015160173177719116, 0.029271159321069717, 0.02560701221227646, -0.02960430085659027, 0.05370001494884491, 0.029789024963974953, -0.005381800699979067, 0.009899748489260674, 0.028280114755034447, 0.028252646327018738, 0.005149883218109608, 0.00020533223869279027, -0.006865983363240957, -0.0032990442123264074, 0.009055476635694504, 0.03831222280859947, -0.012967384420335293, 0.022317014634609222, -0.03655629977583885, -0.055717822164297104, -0.0068124160170555115, 0.019108325242996216, 0.0022344132885336876, 0.03993966057896614, -0.013787507079541683, 0.01013854704797268, 0.035784024745225906, -0.02166254073381424, -0.036397647112607956, -0.060927435755729675, 0.01434185728430748, -0.025499925017356873, -0.022075530141592026, -0.0035252796951681376, -0.0076877642422914505, -0.017911255359649658, -0.009297888725996017, -0.0033521917648613453, -0.034918319433927536, -0.007530735805630684, 0.029204605147242546, -0.01240769773721695, 0.0063177417032420635, 0.07427091896533966, 0.06603682041168213, 0.012465336360037327, -0.0035729140508919954, -0.0018756220815703273, 0.0020753396674990654, 0.008515299297869205, -0.04513251781463623, 0.04596666246652603, -0.00964574795216322, -0.035950906574726105, 0.031011706218123436, 0.0024895661044865847, -0.0056014773435890675, 0.0320073738694191, -0.03918527439236641, 0.019768549129366875, 0.0775788351893425, 0.02274404838681221, 0.015908315777778625, -0.0071660797111690044, 0.02556244470179081, 0.048677317798137665, -0.03340901434421539, -0.04170903563499451, 0.00823310948908329, 0.02216983214020729, -0.005392090883105993, 0.001415353617630899, -0.030845502391457558, 0.0016778173157945275, 0.07512478530406952, 0.014430602081120014, 0.02021736465394497, 0.05593491345643997, 0.014362466521561146, 0.019900336861610413, 0.01666267029941082, -0.0014535197988152504, 0.017954571172595024, -0.0057571507059037685, -0.0059338100254535675, 0.017819389700889587, 0.03625497967004776, 0.01777101494371891, 0.027482712641358376, 0.0423535592854023, -0.010883134789764881, 0.005092242732644081, -0.012281039729714394, -0.012465228326618671, 0.04657784476876259, -0.050858255475759506, 0.03190329298377037, 0.05312404781579971, 0.00568067841231823, -0.013371529057621956, 0.03692568466067314, 0.001747072790749371, -0.003308410057798028, 0.026893258094787598, -0.01745900698006153, 0.03160816431045532, 0.02336469292640686, -0.02026563510298729, 0.02565493807196617, 0.0124882897362113, -0.019913116469979286, -0.059690117835998535, -0.03569073975086212, 0.029557563364505768, 0.011853226460516453, 0.0447823628783226, -0.004769249819219112, -0.02460404299199581, 0.015551832504570484, -0.026004314422607422, -0.02634914591908455, -0.036179255694150925, -0.041393719613552094, 0.01206890493631363, -0.0013490102719515562, -0.019456570968031883, 0.05331761762499809, 0.0011166700860485435, -0.00748855248093605, 0.01601315662264824, 0.004176207818090916, -0.04377928003668785, -0.04660763218998909, -0.010046398267149925, 0.024300340563058853, 0.014620231464505196, -0.018913455307483673, 0.053527332842350006, 0.002350526861846447, -0.034703150391578674, 0.024128030985593796, -0.05238477513194084, -0.042002007365226746, -0.010114206001162529, 0.008844800293445587, 0.024371016770601273, -0.02134547010064125, 0.016305912286043167, 0.012506891041994095, -0.0495830737054348, -0.012063084170222282, -0.10386306792497635, -0.11208657175302505, 0.031938083469867706, 0.006851251237094402, 0.037728551775217056, 0.0090398034080863, -0.05208325758576393, 0.07255125045776367, 0.005100581794977188, -0.03545209392905235, -0.03786155581474304, -0.005150396842509508, -0.02243513986468315, -0.053326837718486786, 0.03525400161743164, 0.004117089789360762, 0.02496715635061264, 0.004105960018932819, 0.011031966656446457, 0.03429543972015381, 0.041830796748399734, 0.003975215367972851, -0.006025642156600952, -0.033524226397275925, 0.007907915860414505, -0.018025869503617287, 0.04175443947315216, 0.028056621551513672, -0.04161151498556137, 0.003152130637317896, -0.002629050984978676, 0.04679674282670021, 0.013907923363149166, -0.049406323581933975, -0.03941303491592407, -0.010813324712216854, 0.0065616718493402, -0.023324444890022278, 0.007961397059261799, -0.006314595229923725, -0.000415150192566216, -0.0324559286236763, 0.043375398963689804, 0.019486581906676292, -0.04519961029291153, 0.0030984815675765276, 0.0542851947247982, 0.039752356708049774, -0.015418685041368008, -0.028046740218997, -0.009858635254204273, 0.022728582844138145, 0.028864679858088493, -0.00244592921808362, -0.02639530599117279, 0.054325103759765625, 0.004438538569957018, 0.005768490489572287, 0.011940390802919865, -0.0060188304632902145, 0.03281950578093529, -0.0690251961350441, 0.011731717735528946, 0.001270315726287663, 0.06756158918142319, 0.01755652017891407, 0.03709074482321739, 0.02342194877564907, -0.02948937751352787, 0.04638831317424774, -0.012673724442720413, -0.05468117818236351, 0.04248601570725441, -0.00971632543951273, -0.029284721240401268, 0.05116239935159683, -0.010007445700466633, 0.004312129225581884, -0.05736524984240532, -0.008043462410569191, 0.020299967378377914, 0.04578162357211113, -0.0431823767721653, 0.004741196054965258, -0.02119382657110691, -0.0030829226598143578, -0.02223885990679264, 0.01935035176575184, 0.05483580380678177, -0.01105236355215311, 0.014005417004227638, 0.055997226387262344, -0.014310812577605247, -0.04390636458992958, -0.00583939254283905, -0.0392165407538414, 0.046325743198394775, 0.0458589531481266, 0.008223372511565685, 0.016246037557721138, -0.050335440784692764, 0.06261122226715088, -0.026240523904561996, 0.005420842207968235, -0.00469997338950634, 0.0075871869921684265, -0.018762091174721718, -0.0019366774940863252, 0.0022355904802680016, 0.01769077219069004, 0.015759877860546112, 0.006605715490877628, -0.023395834490656853, 0.02763250842690468, -0.02043537236750126, -0.03992069140076637, 0.03431690111756325, 0.08719564229249954, 0.024656284600496292, -0.026413679122924805, -0.015522067435085773, -0.011387161910533905, 0.06061664596199989, -0.02933342754840851, -0.007091970182955265, 0.044930752366781235, 0.0091482475399971, -0.005955431144684553, 0.010831511579453945, 0.017178775742650032, -0.013363073579967022, 0.008553534746170044, 0.01991547830402851, -0.01022052951157093, 0.004544892348349094, -0.052314452826976776, 0.0012131030671298504, 0.06191686540842056, -0.0013311608927324414, 0.019344236701726913, 0.006320884916931391, -0.11048202961683273, 0.031084943562746048, 0.012782718986272812, 0.04789276048541069, -0.01122752483934164, -0.03203550726175308, -0.012502506375312805, -0.016163131222128868, 0.013929443433880806, -0.046928223222494125, 0.053909558802843094, -0.01985926739871502, -0.0188337080180645, 0.0014441172825172544, -0.006470277439802885, -0.04796670749783516, 0.02655389904975891, -0.014548590406775475, 0.03478270396590233, 0.0033312432933598757, -0.02631171979010105, 0.0023343407083302736, 0.03183254599571228, 0.01993218995630741, 0.04058995842933655, 0.01262830663472414, -0.03487521782517433, 0.0159901212900877, -0.003901213873177767, -0.05628141388297081, -0.041969433426856995, 0.015961866825819016, 0.04478288069367409, 0.01370874885469675, 0.025617310777306557, -0.0052136764861643314, -0.0030157663859426975, -0.004771585110574961, 0.010458852164447308, -0.020476972684264183, -0.0073517728596925735, -0.05313621833920479, 0.016811933368444443, 0.004116656258702278, 0.016107117757201195, 0.0525541789829731, 0.07477061450481415, -0.01483394019305706, -0.0009627676918171346, -0.017507754266262054, 0.015855906531214714, -0.004629937931895256, -0.013766098767518997, -0.01751537062227726, -0.0020178055856376886, -0.017818467691540718, -0.011617484502494335, -0.04131116718053818, 0.01838918961584568, -0.04461400955915451, -0.02221539616584778, 0.0007038293988443911, 0.06879160553216934, 0.012969011440873146, -0.035544682294130325, 0.0025448850356042385, -0.009892529807984829, 0.0010838508605957031, -0.03565776348114014, 0.020596414804458618, -0.059925660490989685, -0.011322212405502796, 0.03289642557501793, -0.012650780379772186, 0.012753862887620926, -0.031094465404748917, -0.03456112742424011, 0.028398705646395683, -0.057615816593170166, 0.015895608812570572, 0.014314316213130951, 0.044155288487672806, 0.004027462564408779, -0.02776050940155983, -0.02141934260725975, 0.027836240828037262, 0.007483772002160549, 0.04131315276026726, -0.031553056091070175, 0.03709619864821434, -0.013722541742026806, -0.022608838975429535, -0.1033952534198761, -0.039215702563524246, 0.0604117177426815, -0.00849531777203083, -0.02292238175868988, -0.030595306307077408, -0.0038797426968812943, -0.028509141877293587, -0.028832310810685158, -0.012818640097975731, 0.02151251770555973, 0.010533641092479229, -0.02207486517727375, -0.010635016486048698, 0.005756511352956295, 0.05081259459257126, 0.06067977100610733, 0.0432596392929554, 0.004502827767282724, -0.01343789603561163, -0.030967382714152336, -0.011724207550287247, 0.0423627607524395, -0.029511993750929832, -0.03848884254693985, -0.04562157392501831, -0.017994297668337822, 0.01370409969240427, -0.022978391498327255, 0.0046375822275877, -0.03607333451509476, -0.010461404919624329, -0.0029852385632693768, -0.05432664602994919, -0.01809089072048664, -0.044319864362478256, -0.004229746758937836, -0.01173646654933691, 0.022662850096821785, -0.043755751103162766, 0.022035690024495125, -0.039411623030900955, 0.010483819991350174, -0.031537991017103195, -0.019789688289165497, 0.05232972279191017, 0.03683029115200043, -0.0012004870222881436, 0.012698885053396225, -0.0016542593948543072, 0.029812851920723915, -0.003928511869162321, -0.02328377217054367, 0.020989013835787773, 0.03879339620471001, -0.03131776675581932, -0.007413518149405718, -0.01983058452606201, -0.011880897916853428, 0.07322975993156433, -0.03764801472425461, 0.038949817419052124, 0.05000797659158707, -0.005868908017873764, -0.015442593023180962, -0.039046041667461395, 0.0134243443608284, -0.011835443787276745, 0.0006334172212518752, 0.05606607347726822, -0.016126178205013275, -0.02594347670674324, 0.02087022364139557, 0.04151127487421036, 0.021598028019070625, 0.03998487442731857, -0.015040801838040352, -0.010599865578114986, -0.026559529826045036, -0.029277661815285683, -0.0522427074611187, -0.003067133715376258, -0.02311353199183941, 0.01874760165810585, -0.02394109033048153, -0.017652815207839012, 0.015598802827298641, 0.04545281082391739, 0.0017836831975728273, -0.05022171884775162, -0.008989252150058746, -0.048689741641283035, -0.007254248019307852, 0.03471953049302101, -0.045974861830472946, 0.009450453333556652, 0.011390116065740585, 0.03987319394946098, -0.020254744216799736, 0.029731258749961853, -0.026193024590611458, -0.05319029837846756, 0.017794271931052208, -0.03961760550737381, -0.016686800867319107, 0.018064066767692566, -0.013226657174527645, -0.020820949226617813, 0.006240404676645994, -0.0009530981769785285, -0.0033871985506266356, 0.0035315067507326603, 0.025515923276543617, -0.030602294951677322, 0.04274337366223335, 0.004718178883194923, -0.027650577947497368, -0.01636209338903427, -0.0016689120093360543, 0.12494666874408722, 0.06195357069373131, 0.027996830642223358, -0.06053338199853897, 0.0811518132686615, 0.017172718420624733, 0.01081851776689291, -0.03152139484882355, 0.012263849377632141, 0.002568889642134309, 0.0031824323814362288, 0.05686214566230774, 0.03654272481799126, -0.00237699830904603, 0.025039659813046455, 0.03647942841053009, -0.022479085251688957, -0.015406643971800804, 0.008989616297185421, 0.0010728412307798862, -0.014003261923789978, -0.0354001559317112, -0.04693489521741867, 0.019890913739800453, -0.006489968858659267, -0.0294477641582489, -0.002026183996349573, -0.02674735151231289, 0.017432549968361855, -0.011162303388118744, -0.03415271267294884, -0.02422059141099453, 0.015220372006297112, 0.056894123554229736, -0.030636394396424294, -0.027818500995635986, 0.025493670254945755, -0.04276115819811821, -0.027896292507648468, 0.041282109916210175, 0.03006926365196705, -0.023156262934207916, 0.01682155206799507, 0.012699894607067108, -0.025238152593374252, 0.0057519590482115746, 0.006703213322907686, 0.0017190075013786554, 0.025305816903710365, -0.02373672090470791, -0.02245808020234108, 0.052759427577257156, 0.004467287100851536, -0.055982593446969986, -0.007864036597311497, 0.060411058366298676, -0.010899201035499573, -0.02743764966726303, 0.019570529460906982, -0.03779394552111626, 0.01551720779389143, -0.011787516996264458, 0.013288522139191628, 0.027054499834775925, -0.01163449790328741, -0.04204149544239044, -0.045149486511945724, 0.03659455478191376, -0.011687088757753372, -0.013058322481811047, -0.019379789009690285, -0.05890684574842453, -0.0359298437833786, -0.03591470792889595, 0.04386679455637932, 0.059781525284051895, -0.037880636751651764, -0.014228396117687225, -0.004205641336739063, -0.0417342483997345, -0.009826981462538242, 0.03880973160266876, 0.031011682003736496, -0.029368098825216293, -0.006215551868081093, 0.012676149606704712, 0.0405891090631485, 0.000356270931661129, 0.01501146238297224, 0.0008912869961932302, -0.020887821912765503, 0.017235375940799713, 0.012716700322926044, -0.08053695410490036, 0.013990291394293308, -0.0090467045083642, -0.011340489611029625, -0.019194087013602257, 0.007290508598089218, 0.09308990091085434, -0.008683493360877037, -0.013371502049267292, -0.01936511881649494, 0.04081723093986511, -0.06536861509084702, 0.025010641664266586, 0.0270574688911438, -0.055330585688352585, 0.00790361687541008, 0.020107930526137352, 0.01741301827132702, 0.01672220416367054, 0.009369240142405033, -0.005252090748399496, -0.03652077540755272, 0.004698826465755701, -0.018292339518666267, -0.054536085575819016, 0.053830914199352264, 0.013562561012804508, 0.019057560712099075, -0.028021348640322685, 0.04002881795167923, -0.08479399979114532, -0.009503083303570747, -0.03125598654150963, -0.030294839292764664, -0.006249604281038046, -0.029444333165884018, -0.03716019168496132, -0.004978010896593332, 0.024623999372124672, 0.0007439167238771915, 0.03960253670811653, -0.019842714071273804, 0.02011994458734989, 0.0049551185220479965, 0.05694359168410301, -0.02390274964272976, -0.01773490197956562, 0.006584282498806715, -0.054304055869579315, 0.004260881803929806, 0.03154821693897247, -0.007408479228615761, 0.034951429814100266, 0.007533187512308359, -0.008687417022883892, -0.01875421032309532, 0.09657137095928192, -0.02014840953052044, -0.02024650387465954, -0.018325112760066986, -0.039580248296260834, 0.008455432951450348, -0.03798666596412659, -0.01580399088561535, -0.0031555627938359976, -0.024675901979207993, -0.013420711271464825, 0.0400286465883255, 0.004242571536451578, -0.02020791918039322, -0.004814487416297197, 0.039209287613630295, -0.02193547412753105, -0.002349751302972436, -0.018771059811115265, 0.019634101539850235, 0.02162064053118229, -0.027982739731669426, -0.0058763292618095875, 0.006374382879585028, 0.030253762379288673, -0.06743688136339188, -0.015161558985710144, 0.007863340899348259, 0.01146803516894579, 0.038710132241249084, -0.052829425781965256, 0.012004341930150986, 0.035205163061618805, -0.011246121488511562, 0.01087643951177597, -0.0014731882838532329, 0.01475406251847744, 0.0008128865738399327, 0.02457885816693306, -0.01718961074948311, 0.039481405168771744, 0.020023910328745842, 0.01994725689291954, 0.026424579322338104, -0.009564216248691082, -0.0057741496711969376, -0.05831560492515564, 0.0010693997610360384, -0.008414052426815033, 0.02762950398027897, -0.02456015534698963, 0.034564584493637085, -0.02159004472196102, -0.00893719308078289, 0.0672411099076271, -0.003998110070824623, 0.06561203300952911, 0.03297514468431473, 0.007635816931724548, 0.023577701300382614, 0.02530505321919918, -0.004500397946685553, -0.018977217376232147, -0.007936966605484486, -0.025101058185100555, -0.025160852819681168, 0.020456666126847267, 0.01225197035819292, 0.0029640791472047567, -0.012392605654895306, -0.012155194766819477, -0.0636669471859932, 0.026633940637111664, -0.004088439978659153, -0.004426248371601105, -0.01656772755086422, -0.015571136958897114, 0.0237814299762249, -0.05805964395403862, 0.007989536970853806, -0.013193055987358093, 0.0026221408043056726, 0.03168492391705513, -0.022658906877040863, -0.03576698526740074, 0.005457114893943071, -0.027544859796762466, -0.04136087745428085, -0.023681648075580597, 0.0024678127374500036, 0.007977204397320747, -0.03241272270679474, 0.006293758284300566, -0.0210399329662323, -0.03293677046895027, -0.032047808170318604, 0.008865094743669033, -0.03613164275884628, 0.01850980520248413, -0.02106470987200737, 0.007737725507467985, 0.011418303474783897, -0.030626393854618073, 0.03885770961642265, -0.0598815456032753, 0.04416975751519203, 0.013141315430402756, 0.004440362565219402, -0.028139544650912285, -0.04871394485235214, -0.006079959217458963, 0.012604564428329468, 0.07233338057994843, -0.005787520203739405, -0.013116086833178997, -0.023553602397441864, 0.008397179655730724, 0.018739992752671242, -0.01762978546321392, 0.03962865471839905, 0.015752701088786125, -0.0228237584233284, -0.036326222121715546, -0.035888541489839554, 0.012523041106760502, 0.030808638781309128, -0.001969349104911089, -0.014027683064341545, 0.022635484114289284, 0.013085872866213322, -0.05111568048596382, -0.013944782316684723, 0.003745960770174861, -0.004564832895994186, 0.058326393365859985, -0.008786606602370739, 0.00019775799592025578, 0.019428318366408348, -0.023489229381084442, -0.029370849952101707, 0.010011151432991028, -0.044414717704057693, -0.01042711641639471, 0.0006784303695894778, 0.006779804360121489, -0.006392879411578178, -0.05243273451924324, -0.00035837088944390416, -0.005749387200921774, -0.036119915544986725, 0.006599771790206432, 0.016207244247198105, 0.07601487636566162, 0.021357793360948563, -0.007612366694957018, 0.011381379328668118, -0.03434217721223831, -0.01888316683471203, 0.01207781583070755, 0.011360655538737774, -0.0008568178745917976, 0.030927713960409164, 0.0011355915339663625, 0.020757928490638733, -0.012000427581369877, 0.011532291769981384, -0.004842022433876991, 0.005052956752479076, 0.0025510666891932487, -0.019316498190164566, 0.022690769284963608, 0.018397077918052673, 0.010769481770694256, 0.01913149282336235, 0.006381272338330746, -0.0022403260227292776, -0.02140749804675579, 0.023418210446834564, -0.06503158062696457, 0.019754447042942047, -0.06229325383901596, 0.0482122004032135, 0.03818356990814209, 0.0166496392339468, -0.014933915808796883, 0.015016269870102406, 0.003734091529622674, -0.02688790112733841, -0.01374116912484169, -0.0032656427938491106, -0.01837223954498768, -0.019588075578212738, -0.05324087664484978, -0.014852380380034447, 0.0035547553561627865, -0.03886724263429642, -0.004196887835860252, 0.04599843919277191, 0.02673744410276413, 0.009291030466556549, -0.057062190026044846, -0.026111453771591187, 0.00924237072467804, 0.060117125511169434, -0.08682426810264587, -0.033425889909267426, -0.05507880449295044, 0.02883620746433735, -0.023375025019049644, 0.005509506445378065 ]
<p>I have a spreadsheet where the content is organized like that:</p> <pre> content | category1 | category2 | category3 | ... _________|___________|___________|___________| ... content 1| x | | x | ... content 2| | x | | ... ... </pre> <p>How can I present this information more effectively? For example, is there a Javascript library I could use or something like that, where we could choose to show only the rows which are associated to some categories, or set a category to a row, etc? Thanks in advance</p>
36,694
[ -0.06005197390913963, 0.0183941088616848, 0.02476889081299305, 0.04613155126571655, 0.03688818961381912, 0.028283335268497467, 0.022842630743980408, 0.0045384629629552364, 0.023784231394529343, -0.03208351135253906, 0.020404979586601257, 0.05817797780036926, 0.016166329383850098, 0.04980434849858284, 0.06325116008520126, -0.0024136528372764587, -0.005896408576518297, 0.008063089102506638, -0.0002550711506046355, -0.011906364001333714, -0.019286220893263817, 0.009858271107077599, 0.004669498652219772, 0.04138435795903206, -0.014027517288923264, 0.032032616436481476, 0.055481404066085815, 0.010495515540242195, 0.01595730520784855, 0.07107499986886978, -0.03039044514298439, -0.03460751846432686, -0.0012157034361734986, -0.0030722282826900482, 0.0440293550491333, -0.02261197753250599, -0.03330538794398308, -0.019328122958540916, -0.005144902039319277, -0.01983635686337948, -0.03939775004982948, -0.0048408606089651585, -0.03336756303906441, 0.023478081449866295, -0.07203439623117447, 0.0294167660176754, -0.037991996854543686, -0.005428322125226259, -0.024458879604935646, -0.0644218847155571, 0.08094529807567596, 0.020360402762889862, 0.07428694516420364, 0.043295588344335556, -0.04687179625034332, 0.030177496373653412, 0.014966974034905434, 0.08385579288005829, 0.005333158653229475, -0.05816436558961868, -0.02686179429292679, -0.07053709030151367, 0.0022635250352323055, -0.04001231491565704, -0.030594872310757637, 0.03602141514420509, -0.014646566472947598, 0.010527344420552254, 0.055356863886117935, -0.0005975827225483954, -0.01435139961540699, -0.016133524477481842, 0.04225746542215347, -0.0006032888195477426, 0.000211366917937994, -0.070597343146801, 0.03138799965381622, -0.008763105608522892, 0.042465437203645706, 0.030333803966641426, -0.009958317503333092, 0.009346856735646725, -0.014030271209776402, 0.019952870905399323, 0.05520673096179962, -0.0022963290102779865, 0.06758903712034225, -0.06353627890348434, 0.016147449612617493, 0.019211608916521072, -0.02805083803832531, -0.026248309761285782, 0.02530970610678196, 0.04017087072134018, -0.019846025854349136, 0.01325886882841587, -0.04245958849787712, 0.016509611159563065, 0.003930089995265007, 0.03625477850437164, 0.006778804585337639, 0.016116466373205185, 0.012048706412315369, 0.027872061356902122, -0.03669146075844765, 0.012609416618943214, -0.0454215370118618, -0.02495821751654148, 0.0346134714782238, -0.021878397092223167, 0.024631328880786896, 0.0034666811116039753, 0.04031835496425629, -0.01637769117951393, 0.0332682840526104, -0.0329432375729084, -0.005089157726615667, 0.0026336272712796926, 0.03983893245458603, 0.0658385157585144, 0.07665017247200012, -0.04811495169997215, 0.05685795843601227, -0.03551027923822403, -0.05681682750582695, -0.00534025439992547, -0.02084806002676487, -0.009704411961138248, -0.042003385722637177, 0.047319553792476654, -0.03422825038433075, 0.022213224321603775, 0.04970106855034828, -0.0322408452630043, 0.025818338617682457, 0.01545480452477932, -0.06363986432552338, -0.042009543627500534, 0.01593439280986786, -0.0007413005805574358, -0.006720525212585926, -0.013039284385740757, 0.014795253053307533, 0.013217000290751457, 0.05138920992612839, 0.02373593859374523, 0.008271806873381138, 0.05040574073791504, -0.014115587808191776, 0.02248809114098549, -0.041087131947278976, -0.0010619170498102903, 0.020441466942429543, -0.0010448225075379014, -0.01815444603562355, -0.06694287061691284, 0.006720211356878281, -0.006878230720758438, 0.022604789584875107, -0.015320248901844025, 0.036188166588544846, 0.004726184066385031, -0.010127952322363853, 0.003430545562878251, 0.031029371544718742, -0.002114169532433152, 0.10013130307197571, -0.006290041375905275, 0.030497323721647263, 0.02063579484820366, 0.03551299497485161, 0.00037622766103595495, 0.021862506866455078, 0.028275923803448677, 0.04608669504523277, -0.004120963625609875, -0.002896962920203805, 0.0071222372353076935, 0.017026638612151146, -0.01717817783355713, -0.017295248806476593, -0.07633812725543976, 0.037197571247816086, 0.0186363123357296, 0.036201659590005875, 0.012657937593758106, 0.002448630053550005, -0.038355063647031784, 0.038580261170864105, -0.03600842133164406, -0.011496287770569324, -0.06347163766622543, 0.0161161907017231, -0.007307393942028284, -0.002673148876056075, 0.012387105263769627, 0.011204982176423073, 0.0029292588587850332, 0.006311268545687199, 0.0003915651759598404, -0.013572731986641884, -0.02172885648906231, -0.01743723452091217, -0.031601693481206894, -0.03363369405269623, 0.025799565017223358, 0.020554114133119583, -0.044448450207710266, 0.020032839849591255, 0.007618220988661051, -0.03780382499098778, -0.0012580986367538571, -0.03089071810245514, 0.05319543182849884, -0.007884016260504723, -0.01729503646492958, 0.01373350527137518, 0.03262883424758911, -0.0007159283850342035, 0.025895021855831146, -0.03111785650253296, 0.06773761659860611, 0.019397152587771416, -0.0026284768246114254, 0.034274280071258545, -0.04960033670067787, 0.021901659667491913, -0.004375043790787458, 0.005929307080805302, -0.021343212574720383, -0.04853794351220131, 0.030655020847916603, 0.061327848583459854, 0.006042564287781715, -0.03894014284014702, 0.007018636912107468, 0.046924568712711334, -0.011458723805844784, 0.03598622605204582, 0.02606990747153759, -0.03669564798474312, 0.0278179869055748, 0.027166660875082016, 0.011218939907848835, 0.030279114842414856, -0.022153446450829506, -0.011727655306458473, 0.03537414222955704, 0.04041759669780731, -0.03333202376961708, -0.018550576642155647, 0.03278697654604912, -0.011351726949214935, 0.0067048086784780025, -0.00028039197786711156, -0.0405113622546196, 0.041479047387838364, -0.03661268949508667, 0.009124553762376308, 0.013477238826453686, 0.04642307013273239, -0.026299897581338882, -0.013804861344397068, -0.06323273479938507, -0.02061561681330204, 0.030261902138590813, -0.0665220320224762, -0.022245224565267563, 0.012888448312878609, 0.004711219575256109, 0.026087075471878052, 0.007596728857606649, -0.010752273723483086, -0.060980793088674545, 0.01994376629590988, 0.024210026487708092, -0.04348002374172211, -0.0007518245256505907, -0.013129008002579212, -0.048572979867458344, -0.03957045078277588, 0.0009654202731326222, 0.02566690929234028, -0.02685731090605259, -0.049857284873723984, -0.04152947664260864, 0.024138597771525383, -0.026724018156528473, 0.06458067148923874, -0.0005880345124751329, -0.0435548759996891, -0.0080303018912673, -0.01938438042998314, -0.036116842180490494, -0.007555311545729637, -0.012263529933989048, 0.04198829457163811, -0.04185008257627487, -0.01288331113755703, 0.04134887084364891, -0.03587688133120537, -0.031766753643751144, 0.01763024739921093, -0.0904587134718895, -0.01712380349636078, -0.02312312461435795, 0.021675389260053635, -0.027383066713809967, -0.02275562658905983, -0.020338527858257294, 0.01593533530831337, 0.013915481977164745, 0.022902915254235268, -0.021372413262724876, -0.0402214378118515, -0.004551878198981285, 0.011525590904057026, 0.03401869535446167, 0.02007736638188362, -0.00895776692777872, 0.040577955543994904, 0.0011454561026766896, -0.044782932847738266, -0.08222289383411407, -0.041646089404821396, -0.003203759668394923, -0.024281401187181473, 0.03792925179004669, 0.0182941984385252, -0.01418039109557867, -0.01777622289955616, 0.0019891520496457815, -0.0010926676914095879, 0.033595096319913864, 0.012283182702958584, -0.011819700710475445, 0.0008554284577257931, -0.011791191063821316, -0.024757739156484604, 0.02017144300043583, 0.05001416429877281, -0.01599421538412571, 0.013644320890307426, -0.0379086509346962, 0.028705213218927383, -0.002395592164248228, -0.014337259344756603, -0.009122627787292004, -0.043360281735658646, 0.04268154501914978, 0.040899209678173065, 0.031076252460479736, -0.004158190917223692, -0.00794787798076868, -0.0034297192469239235, 0.04592765122652054, 0.012282400391995907, -0.013204842805862427, -0.010069778189063072, 0.0742269977927208, 0.04511116072535515, -0.05550188571214676, 0.029029270634055138, 0.003490670118480921, -0.005873804911971092, 0.03711723908782005, -0.02601337432861328, -0.027391506358981133, 0.028236262500286102, 0.02138308808207512, 0.007356839254498482, 0.022310229018330574, -0.02008873037993908, -0.0020336087327450514, -0.08536553382873535, -0.022270388901233673, -0.009459830820560455, 0.05703384801745415, 0.008286231197416782, 0.06284046173095703, 0.028579557314515114, 0.006753294728696346, 0.017589053139090538, 0.02985122613608837, -0.0871979147195816, -0.006258247885853052, 0.02200627140700817, 0.0587368980050087, 0.01358370017260313, -0.001651362399570644, -0.013605771586298943, -0.04299400374293327, -0.021194439381361008, 0.02653460018336773, -0.01123050320893526, -0.0722501203417778, -0.015476756729185581, 0.012353571131825447, 0.032538432627916336, -0.015316433273255825, 0.0035591674968600273, 0.03693768382072449, 0.02432238683104515, 0.07236462086439133, 0.033063508570194244, -0.015893947333097458, 0.012898477725684643, -0.009124819189310074, 0.016382377594709396, 0.006456397008150816, 0.014463867992162704, -0.01308199018239975, 0.020419292151927948, -0.020714443176984787, -0.0034007246140390635, -0.03949690982699394, 0.011159109883010387, 0.032671231776475906, -0.0006461003213189542, 0.042033594101667404, -0.037885669618844986, 0.04410475492477417, -0.012995016761124134, 0.01512790285050869, 0.0008096996461972594, 0.028194254264235497, 0.016756344586610794, 0.04778195172548294, -0.05719315633177757, 0.010498293675482273, 0.07148270308971405, 0.03978670760989189, -0.041405562311410904, -0.013807045295834541, -0.01871972531080246, -0.0027885022573173046, -0.022163765504956245, 0.001861672499217093, -0.0034582803491503, -0.0028803786262869835, 0.03716349974274635, -0.011046873405575752, -0.04955839738249779, -0.0284432265907526, -0.010360291227698326, -0.020147481933236122, 0.019299976527690887, -0.016991065815091133, -0.03666102886199951, 0.03260430693626404, 0.03180061653256416, 0.03184741362929344, -0.008450083434581757, -0.007989912293851376, -0.11450178921222687, 0.011278660967946053, 0.07871971279382706, 0.027460861951112747, -0.037485744804143906, -0.03752327337861061, 0.011409531347453594, -0.017775017768144608, 0.03158951923251152, -0.03741290792822838, 0.0038207273464649916, -0.06625937670469284, 0.017393669113516808, 0.00435548136010766, -0.0005191601230762899, 0.021550685167312622, 0.004614084959030151, -0.031733062118291855, -0.0012549611274152994, 0.02354627661406994, -0.02119697630405426, -0.05538944527506828, 0.047776445746421814, 0.001611608429811895, 0.021140705794095993, -0.014780855737626553, -0.02368868701159954, 0.01203286461532116, 0.014732606709003448, -0.04702967777848244, -0.027236495167016983, 0.021746966987848282, 0.02165987715125084, 0.0005244390922598541, 0.03285034000873566, 0.004556508269160986, -0.014653139747679234, -0.009822199121117592, 0.004171432927250862, -0.007559482008218765, 0.02465028315782547, 0.00502566434442997, 0.004941960331052542, 0.00048679293831810355, -0.02083439938724041, 0.04211382940411568, 0.05370473489165306, -0.022989459335803986, -0.0047858539037406445, -0.004896155092865229, 0.023681145161390305, 0.0010356749407947063, -0.007802403066307306, -0.028333038091659546, 0.019891751930117607, -0.04358767345547676, 0.009909476153552532, -0.005776567384600639, 0.013261869549751282, -0.04810478165745735, -0.023493977263569832, -0.032320793718099594, 0.04075689613819122, 0.03546497970819473, -0.008466523140668869, 0.017629774287343025, -0.008270255289971828, -0.009751726873219013, -0.016282493248581886, 0.026131270453333855, -0.04629478603601456, -0.004544433206319809, 0.01182327326387167, -0.007520790211856365, 0.013433614745736122, -0.03141789510846138, -0.021273035556077957, -0.011896206066012383, -0.003477891208603978, 0.031717441976070404, 0.00494524696841836, 0.054650478065013885, 0.0039973631501197815, -0.04078356921672821, -0.0038573977071791887, 0.0663813054561615, 0.0001785038475645706, 0.014385465532541275, -0.02681158483028412, 0.026503076776862144, -0.0006928904913365841, -0.026331422850489616, -0.05678678676486015, -0.07495187222957611, 0.020568879321217537, 0.014807325787842274, -0.008427861146628857, -0.044895004481077194, 0.008717798627912998, 0.002732750726863742, -0.030764741823077202, -0.009951095096766949, 0.004458965267986059, -0.011860269121825695, 0.015265090391039848, 0.02466840110719204, -0.010348238050937653, 0.07178732007741928, 0.022174984216690063, -0.003985988441854715, -0.004733973648399115, 0.019749514758586884, -0.009950308129191399, -0.018643314018845558, -0.007803166750818491, -0.004064986482262611, -0.022209225222468376, -0.04290686920285225, 0.026541978120803833, 0.047148093581199646, -0.032115865498781204, 0.02397840842604637, 0.010334220714867115, 0.023663347586989403, -0.03720695152878761, -0.058573655784130096, 0.0002473484491929412, 0.00789820309728384, -0.022960038855671883, -0.028230460360646248, 0.014527538791298866, -0.05380336195230484, -0.010225920006632805, 0.012386372312903404, -0.015246571972966194, -0.008812358602881432, 0.010015454143285751, 0.05873193219304085, -0.01386343501508236, 0.013737472705543041, 0.01900598593056202, 0.01680433750152588, 0.07481583207845688, 0.016434697434306145, -0.006895816419273615, 0.01147953886538744, 0.042329590767621994, -0.010585587471723557, 0.0016134426696226, 0.027027677744627, -0.03271844610571861, 0.02801409922540188, -0.01386546902358532, 0.011896285228431225, 0.05525475740432739, 0.019781338050961494, 0.011769698932766914, -0.007236804347485304, -0.008424133993685246, 0.005780291277915239, 0.02722632698714733, 0.05888170748949051, -0.010025758296251297, 0.046477947384119034, 0.023492617532610893, -0.016037141904234886, 0.02381160482764244, 0.04219814017415047, 0.03159171715378761, 0.003991617355495691, 0.030318763107061386, -0.010278962552547455, -0.013768273405730724, 0.017464661970734596, -0.05005814880132675, 0.02431870438158512, -0.027197888121008873, -0.04754243046045303, 0.008003553375601768, 0.016206175088882446, -0.025342009961605072, -0.022964371368288994, -0.04140011966228485, -0.03655054420232773, 0.04441157355904579, -0.001647160854190588, 0.00567963719367981, -0.00005458448868012056, 0.00861861277371645, 0.037390585988759995, -0.03407973423600197, -0.00860596913844347, 0.009710961021482944, -0.04981982707977295, -0.018105395138263702, -0.03852326422929764, -0.02334846556186676, 0.018463870510458946, 0.008811975829303265, 0.0005622272146865726, 0.002112729474902153, -0.022355608642101288, -0.0345928929746151, 0.03925742954015732, 0.04773620516061783, -0.006695278454571962, 0.034483540803194046, 0.006313030607998371, 0.008646063506603241, 0.012884980998933315, -0.02872166968882084, 0.09286335110664368, 0.09256167709827423, 0.032777898013591766, -0.07172317802906036, -0.00017114158254116774, 0.05392671748995781, -0.03464850038290024, -0.04420969635248184, -0.007298903539776802, 0.014268395490944386, -0.014162663370370865, 0.007880175486207008, 0.04808672517538071, 0.027880867943167686, 0.02487827278673649, 0.037649836391210556, -0.022364651784300804, 0.0002504807198420167, 0.01694950833916664, -0.0035870508290827274, 0.0007938367780297995, -0.00468528363853693, -0.08299928158521652, -0.018644871190190315, 0.0950271412730217, -0.022689690813422203, -0.042590491473674774, -0.037781499326229095, -0.004467719234526157, 0.020964961498975754, -0.022071903571486473, -0.008425761945545673, 0.002015458419919014, 0.019061880186200142, 0.028061384335160255, 0.009402492083609104, 0.00021384462888818234, -0.011887832544744015, 0.012578234076499939, -0.004485026933252811, 0.0021889633499085903, -0.027059832587838173, 0.0032821123022586107, 0.017111843451857567, -0.044937316328287125, -0.020698370411992073, -0.043429408222436905, -0.007239489816129208, 0.005061553791165352, -0.0016128537245094776, 0.01394606288522482, 0.04364284873008728, -0.01824638433754444, -0.03737157955765724, -0.030554775148630142, 0.04619193449616432, -0.00628078356385231, -0.010701082646846771, -0.023788196966052055, -0.015992475673556328, 0.032260388135910034, -0.048949792981147766, 0.01813308708369732, 0.01738179288804531, 0.0014862518291920424, 0.02194448560476303, -0.049167875200510025, 0.020653510466217995, 0.00013257216778583825, 0.002973060356453061, 0.02458278089761734, -0.016688933596014977, -0.017696376889944077, -0.04189169779419899, 0.020021744072437286, 0.01162649318575859, -0.005730444099754095, -0.005483167711645365, 0.0010644259164109826, 0.029103973880410194, 0.003908616490662098, 0.026232654228806496, -0.01966155134141445, -0.017042456194758415, -0.03534751757979393, 0.012420552782714367, 0.09312854707241058, -0.015608604066073895, 0.011260062456130981, 0.04796711355447769, -0.02391085959970951, 0.04359360411763191, -0.011911562643945217, -0.026743214577436447, -0.05975975841283798, 0.021083228290081024, -0.047160398215055466, 0.002408453729003668, 0.0068114507012069225, 0.0730055719614029, -0.018534397706389427, -0.029388148337602615, -0.011519747786223888, 0.03698529675602913, 0.02275349758565426, 0.021010959520936012, 0.008692204020917416, -0.04976349696516991, 0.0016256847884505987, 0.010278175584971905, -0.01475112047046423, -0.0006176735041663051, 0.013052953407168388, -0.023567406460642815, 0.0056464457884430885, 0.03362448513507843, 0.002858078572899103, -0.006102862302213907, 0.024556612595915794, -0.0015442363219335675, 0.03870849683880806, -0.02451411820948124, 0.0016479301266372204, -0.04486885666847229, -0.050460416823625565, -0.012907205149531364, -0.024931970983743668, -0.0484476201236248, 0.01079836767166853, -0.013443212024867535, 0.02182392030954361, -0.0073245191015303135, -0.0030782900284975767, 0.011668846011161804, -0.01608067750930786, 0.017034631222486496, 0.007628812920302153, 0.04846968874335289, -0.03964122012257576, -0.015888245776295662, 0.014182526618242264, -0.017847368493676186, -0.012480426579713821, -0.029120273888111115, -0.026187531650066376, 0.04253270849585533, 0.002528300043195486, 0.016764536499977112, 0.013839038088917732, 0.06341173499822617, 0.01247004047036171, -0.030481042340397835, -0.0021474123932421207, -0.007287967950105667, 0.029673172160983086, 0.02260918915271759, -0.02383914589881897, 0.0008780425996519625, -0.030061332508921623, 0.02053256519138813, 0.07052158564329147, 0.023559004068374634, -0.04688465595245361, 0.02500472217798233, 0.05278819426894188, 0.04651128500699997, 0.02642865665256977, -0.0009520169114693999, -0.0027035169769078493, 0.00402528140693903, -0.09285429120063782, 0.012985565699636936, 0.026524070650339127, -0.003602611366659403, -0.033050063997507095, -0.028741514310240746, 0.019845198839902878, -0.021578321233391762, -0.017900483682751656, -0.0559091679751873, 0.013032186776399612, 0.016909366473555565, -0.0074010128155350685, 0.04053152725100517, 0.02097499370574951, -0.0000011257093319727574, 0.014828553423285484, 0.02530147135257721, -0.02195875346660614, 0.013018599711358547, 0.03184743970632553, 0.03555416315793991, 0.014423751272261143, -0.00655049504712224, -0.001344619900919497, -0.040759455412626266, -0.0120847187936306, 0.011988922022283077, 0.01663380116224289, -0.03781428560614586, 0.017152978107333183, -0.004260384943336248, -0.041338298469781876, 0.032428156584501266, -0.03618636727333069, 0.0034657095093280077, 0.04165787622332573, 0.01775875873863697, 0.02280436083674431, 0.022717436775565147, 0.0060677663423120975, -0.017445780336856842, -0.03618497774004936, 0.029077155515551567, 0.02297905646264553, -0.0035332178231328726, -0.0014872039901092649, 0.06197160854935646, 0.012579403817653656, 0.004237493500113487, -0.025213005021214485, -0.011366909369826317, -0.01992376334965229, 0.009371599182486534, -0.04985529184341431, -0.006130232010036707, 0.04492120444774628, -0.006503565236926079, -0.011453818529844284, -0.0587250255048275, 0.02832375466823578, 0.016387904062867165, -0.0231410451233387, 0.03932023048400879, 0.016388675197958946, -0.001385173643939197, -0.02289673499763012, -0.027086855843663216, 0.03675343468785286, -0.005829633679240942, -0.05281974747776985, -0.015999073162674904, 0.004617920611053705, -0.007767991162836552, -0.021679693832993507, -0.012313933111727238, 0.010508464649319649, 0.03964649885892868, -0.005863938946276903, -0.011133874766528606, 0.01989743672311306, 0.014144563116133213, 0.011583438143134117, -0.05537744238972664, 0.04941295459866524, 0.040876492857933044, -0.007190162781625986, -0.014572776854038239, -0.019617902114987373, -0.051058538258075714, 0.030567677691578865, 0.05554964765906334, -0.0495087169110775, -0.016106657683849335, -0.06165043264627457, 0.03127427399158478, 0.014491808600723743, -0.024135643616318703, 0.028287237510085106, -0.005811605136841536, -0.05872233957052231, 0.006477548740804195, -0.003971935249865055, 0.004267327021807432, -0.03234138712286949, -0.0049505983479321, -0.007726808078587055, -0.044315170496702194, -0.0379771813750267, -0.03475720062851906, 0.014931868761777878, 0.01878083124756813, -0.04203783720731735, 0.04668870195746422, -0.0199404489248991, 0.013673755340278149, 0.043379951268434525, 0.029164185747504234, -0.017206162214279175, 0.02535533346235752, -0.07558786123991013, -0.020725678652524948, 0.0027346760034561157, 0.038548629730939865, 0.013317545875906944, -0.10591505467891693, 0.018068430945277214, -0.0021736901253461838, -0.0603468157351017, 0.017591068521142006, 0.05385861545801163, 0.00677227508276701, 0.058526456356048584, -0.0028222822584211826, 0.019992925226688385, -0.026576325297355652, -0.025250647217035294, -0.006185447797179222, 0.000982404686510563, 0.015165707096457481, 0.024361994117498398, 0.03309928998351097, 0.05552240461111069, -0.007517736405134201, 0.03952592983841896, -0.005059652030467987, 0.031323712319135666, 0.005497102625668049, 0.04308727756142616, 0.011578541249036789, -0.038093291223049164, 0.0026634300593286753, -0.018438341096043587, -0.013202974572777748, -0.0019792208913713694, -0.0440933033823967, 0.003922715783119202, -0.0618949756026268, -0.011035766452550888, -0.041842855513095856, -0.015585890971124172, 0.00882608164101839, 0.028509855270385742, -0.03929004818201065, -0.0020642944145947695, 0.032519739121198654, -0.033038947731256485, 0.02430933527648449, 0.043280716985464096, -0.002326070098206401, -0.0516386404633522, -0.026497717946767807, 0.04111608490347862, -0.030433189123868942, -0.007028327323496342, 0.011570277623832226, 0.040195122361183167, 0.014279024675488472, 0.009683365002274513, -0.010972324758768082, 0.0208845604211092, -0.0007625048165209591, -0.02998427115380764, -0.0557107999920845, 0.002508055418729782, -0.03170106187462807, 0.00024317561474163085, -0.015951314941048622, 0.009307543747127056 ]
<p>In <code>R</code>, I would like to give multiline names to some data sets in <code>boxplot</code>, like this:</p> <pre><code>boxplot(rnorm(10), rnorm(10, mean=2), names=c("Normal", "Shifted\n*")) </code></pre> <p>Here, the names seem to be aligned with their bottom lines, which causes the text to overlap with the axis. How can I have multiline names which simply extend to the bottom instead of upwards?</p>
36,695
[ -0.031196175143122673, 0.003564096288755536, -0.03275862708687782, -0.006871503312140703, -0.010966618545353413, 0.007132166996598244, -0.037132423371076584, -0.013741196133196354, 0.0085498271510005, -0.02412238158285618, 0.07839041203260422, 0.02877689339220524, 0.046307556331157684, -0.013476992025971413, 0.03459255397319794, -0.020410165190696716, -0.017145821824669838, -0.007828955538570881, -0.0012898053973913193, -0.027526121586561203, 0.0022412920370697975, 0.0024964800104498863, 0.03252198174595833, 0.020891914144158363, 0.0036941964644938707, 0.08898770064115524, 0.04354041814804077, 0.010326569899916649, 0.021711142733693123, 0.0352042056620121, -0.011287372559309006, -0.013438562862575054, 0.045230187475681305, 0.00902576930820942, 0.024265198037028313, -0.0077776783145964146, -0.004914369899779558, -0.02106465771794319, 0.020637143403291702, 0.012289502657949924, -0.04154887795448303, 0.0010769892251119018, 0.0413668230175972, 0.014318639412522316, -0.011667403392493725, 0.017550868913531303, -0.00381452776491642, 0.012337317690253258, 0.008265664801001549, -0.003636073786765337, 0.04036999121308327, -0.006203003693372011, 0.04335480183362961, 0.06276440620422363, -0.06116519868373871, 0.017504775896668434, 0.06189292296767235, 0.08958616852760315, 0.010853658430278301, -0.07611125707626343, 0.006647445727139711, -0.026691962033510208, -0.013138840906322002, -0.0031263846904039383, -0.05812818184494972, 0.03034849278628826, -0.0633627250790596, 0.008604641072452068, 0.009453123435378075, -0.07237173616886139, -0.010205253958702087, 0.012694718316197395, 0.020223692059516907, -0.0696767196059227, -0.018507856875658035, -0.01913580670952797, 0.05833040550351143, -0.012640397995710373, 0.034153737127780914, 0.03489990904927254, 0.01903165690600872, 0.02978648617863655, 0.0324268601834774, 0.01934797130525112, 0.0160820372402668, 0.011653834022581577, 0.05531201511621475, -0.024277569726109505, 0.06277552992105484, 0.05135566368699074, 0.027273891493678093, 0.007228496950119734, 0.04797408729791641, 0.05316165089607239, -0.010962139815092087, 0.02266884595155716, -0.0032547698356211185, 0.03506510704755783, -0.005953044630587101, -0.04869275540113449, 0.0021275831386446953, -0.017822833731770515, 0.00729282246902585, 0.03862801194190979, -0.015372538939118385, -0.0019190729362890124, -0.0626663863658905, -0.031124010682106018, -0.009294673800468445, 0.025916267186403275, 0.005229232367128134, 0.009050512686371803, -0.040809109807014465, -0.015441503375768661, 0.02884291484951973, -0.054832931607961655, -0.0009422007715329528, 0.03001970238983631, 0.04258119687438011, 0.054449331015348434, 0.03813668712973595, -0.033518362790346146, 0.07136847078800201, -0.005616073962301016, -0.07057394832372665, -0.000054450196330435574, 0.0060396622866392136, 0.004804187919944525, -0.04407752677798271, 0.03421451896429062, -0.015932584181427956, -0.0011474969796836376, 0.04033647105097771, 0.0013136601774021983, 0.014127880334854126, -0.01045522466301918, -0.06856255233287811, -0.049514081329107285, 0.02539278194308281, -0.024670632556080818, -0.005597818177193403, -0.041292283684015274, 0.005419224034994841, -0.006154156755656004, 0.040172677487134933, 0.009959840215742588, 0.007861156947910786, 0.02926008217036724, 0.018194356933236122, -0.015020131133496761, 0.0018148901872336864, 0.02028745785355568, -0.011967126280069351, -0.0010460722260177135, 0.011483240872621536, -0.07516572624444962, -0.006237654481083155, 0.011542933993041515, -0.026973456144332886, -0.025104738771915436, 0.03888719528913498, -0.05152444168925285, 0.04630427435040474, -0.04148228093981743, -0.019209420308470726, -0.049261029809713364, 0.05632268637418747, 0.02372536063194275, 0.02523437887430191, 0.049678388983011246, -0.03916649892926216, 0.03223814442753792, -0.01355833187699318, 0.05239171162247658, 0.061588354408741, -0.056209996342659, 0.004854283761233091, 0.015064695850014687, 0.020791783928871155, 0.05435125157237053, -0.009588673710823059, -0.023656204342842102, -0.014478031545877457, -0.00820839125663042, 0.02654867433011532, 0.029340611770749092, 0.0007116468623280525, -0.0028355333488434553, 0.015274100936949253, -0.08019156754016876, 0.005048628896474838, -0.08602208644151688, 0.039602506905794144, -0.013188760727643967, -0.04308671876788139, -0.03314165398478508, 0.021374082192778587, 0.041579049080610275, -0.00458330474793911, 0.007466469891369343, -0.02472108043730259, 0.018372980877757072, 0.05219430476427078, -0.032568540424108505, -0.039715372025966644, 0.0383620522916317, 0.06979984045028687, -0.02746029756963253, 0.030220087617635727, -0.01840769313275814, -0.0022566630505025387, 0.022143550217151642, -0.0011745080118998885, 0.014040297828614712, -0.034293439239263535, 0.00133299280423671, 0.030505109578371048, 0.04016784578561783, 0.0012429566122591496, 0.020478926599025726, -0.005823240615427494, 0.0235830657184124, 0.05937919393181801, 0.018910184502601624, -0.014088459312915802, -0.031101901084184647, 0.02076876349747181, 0.05034381151199341, -0.007561761420220137, -0.0034028352238237858, -0.043235938996076584, -0.033738214522600174, 0.03298352286219597, 0.007500180974602699, -0.040398430079221725, 0.007612105458974838, 0.05222742259502411, 0.013473193161189556, 0.01270152349025011, 0.053378909826278687, -0.010737325996160507, -0.0009326663566753268, 0.0028284634463489056, 0.009598609060049057, 0.03612430766224861, -0.013386528007686138, 0.0514804907143116, -0.007901211269199848, 0.06685776263475418, -0.001318061025813222, -0.020298724994063377, -0.0013809425290673971, 0.005107739474624395, -0.006818415597081184, 0.011289047077298164, -0.023139484226703644, 0.02319379523396492, -0.04011589288711548, -0.017183640971779823, 0.04825405776500702, 0.04438973590731621, -0.02458202838897705, 0.025963151827454567, -0.010463114827871323, -0.03647362440824509, 0.04919864609837532, -0.0044545442797243595, -0.028445934876799583, 0.013192226178944111, -0.05203021317720413, 0.01927734725177288, -0.021114526316523552, -0.021990645676851273, -0.024891572073101997, 0.024149760603904724, 0.06363725662231445, 0.020690489560365677, 0.020287884399294853, -0.022016560658812523, -0.0311606265604496, 0.04277742654085159, -0.028618620708584785, 0.03034035861492157, -0.030680011957883835, -0.04834095388650894, 0.018869498744606972, -0.01782013103365898, -0.05274953693151474, 0.03678801283240318, 0.005783975590020418, -0.04710401967167854, 0.02354172244668007, -0.004617644939571619, -0.013598212972283363, -0.011309787631034851, -0.028542496263980865, 0.0373636893928051, -0.00988167803734541, 0.003039731178432703, 0.07631625235080719, 0.009492574259638786, -0.035166990011930466, 0.02842327207326889, -0.060646578669548035, -0.020561277866363525, -0.01674928516149521, -0.011900212615728378, 0.02775200456380844, 0.013400140218436718, 0.01811751164495945, 0.02147400751709938, -0.035130273550748825, -0.028231611475348473, -0.02183912880718708, -0.05505659058690071, 0.018787052482366562, 0.01135519053786993, 0.022988934069871902, 0.019863352179527283, 0.008077689446508884, 0.060309428721666336, 0.003796151839196682, -0.051495008170604706, -0.056306105107069016, -0.030654067173600197, 0.016473552212119102, -0.027920087799429893, -0.0010023181093856692, -0.005395802669227123, 0.024014189839363098, 0.001176150981336832, 0.03750896826386452, 0.01618967577815056, 0.04224099963903427, -0.021074295043945312, -0.007668354082852602, -0.011918410658836365, -0.018135052174329758, -0.029916970059275627, 0.002322740852832794, 0.036811623722314835, -0.009559287689626217, 0.006788249593228102, -0.018374335020780563, -0.003912697080522776, -0.00592871243134141, -0.032199427485466, -0.0004798274312634021, -0.03621545061469078, 0.037008028477430344, 0.0010754760587587953, -0.011370833963155746, 0.052813515067100525, -0.02778417058289051, -0.02758517675101757, 0.020268861204385757, 0.06529799848794937, -0.04647792875766754, 0.009487650357186794, 0.020876342430710793, 0.025379648432135582, -0.024490658193826675, 0.005517083220183849, 0.020006241276860237, -0.0063197314739227295, 0.01777658797800541, -0.016697227954864502, -0.018361642956733704, 0.017476540058851242, 0.037880830466747284, 0.007600307464599609, 0.05935804918408394, -0.032224416732788086, 0.09384068846702576, -0.05160021409392357, 0.019860031083226204, 0.004233749117702246, 0.048101287335157394, 0.03306058049201965, 0.012694844976067543, 0.022680873051285744, 0.002530008088797331, 0.02350562810897827, 0.0044031934812664986, -0.03295743465423584, 0.03492532670497894, 0.020301762968301773, -0.004666567780077457, -0.012037407606840134, -0.03303985297679901, 0.009559914469718933, -0.02093641087412834, 0.033914029598236084, -0.00276616751216352, 0.003211893839761615, -0.025919996201992035, 0.006468530278652906, -0.0342935249209404, -0.0006950502283871174, -0.000008174521099135745, 0.03722814470529556, 0.061196569353342056, -0.0005740004708059132, 0.019047748297452927, 0.008953291922807693, 0.004406239837408066, -0.043523840606212616, -0.023501336574554443, 0.024849260225892067, 0.019554652273654938, 0.029917290434241295, 0.03270974010229111, 0.008187491446733475, -0.0031722283456474543, 0.012114502489566803, -0.031063783913850784, 0.052937835454940796, 0.020044531673192978, 0.004108356311917305, 0.014163514599204063, -0.011923985555768013, -0.0002059565158560872, 0.010342035442590714, 0.036298349499702454, -0.00933182705193758, -0.012415202334523201, 0.02904607728123665, 0.04156486317515373, -0.048482708632946014, 0.009329987689852715, 0.057446613907814026, 0.04830152913928032, -0.00400233268737793, -0.018376639112830162, -0.010575980879366398, -0.01540559995919466, -0.005723212845623493, -0.0011061481200158596, -0.004303753841668367, -0.024522216990590096, 0.0215790793299675, -0.01682811789214611, -0.05322408303618431, -0.030693894252181053, 0.007487588562071323, 0.01863797940313816, 0.03965834155678749, -0.0032830608543008566, 0.02311462163925171, -0.02361697517335415, 0.038253165781497955, 0.017826257273554802, -0.007585320621728897, -0.03452161327004433, -0.08598770201206207, 0.0008001228561624885, 0.02736002765595913, 0.019932961091399193, 0.0025932423304766417, -0.056936778128147125, -0.016723131760954857, 0.00956486165523529, 0.0756307989358902, -0.03832223266363144, -0.002979894168674946, -0.024653373286128044, -0.0027853604406118393, -0.007474862039089203, -0.0002110579371219501, -0.0676693320274353, -0.001759996172040701, -0.05181896686553955, 0.012001355178654194, 0.026095973327755928, -0.020199453458189964, -0.062401190400123596, 0.02754383161664009, -0.02513277344405651, 0.04469676688313484, -0.03386129066348076, -0.02796294167637825, -0.010288204997777939, 0.006608420517295599, -0.0015319024678319693, -0.014687965624034405, 0.0001386940712109208, -0.00886012613773346, -0.00999679695814848, 0.06567703187465668, 0.004884062800556421, 0.004239991772919893, 0.0016139126382768154, 0.0009034271934069693, -0.001240433077327907, -0.01476904097944498, -0.002213466679677367, 0.0051751877181231976, 0.030171679332852364, 0.03313383087515831, 0.0285272765904665, 0.05471868813037872, -0.00216057151556015, 0.02814297378063202, -0.06502658128738403, 0.08269494771957397, -0.026086129248142242, -0.009693030267953873, -0.05021071434020996, 0.008246773853898048, -0.0033973013050854206, 0.015884321182966232, -0.0029648940544575453, -0.004847716074436903, -0.05726635083556175, 0.01646357588469982, 0.025730600580573082, 0.05048016831278801, 0.005039917770773172, -0.04492189735174179, 0.025965794920921326, 0.015586448833346367, -0.0014588781632483006, 0.0006848492776043713, 0.03186044842004776, -0.029026655480265617, -0.008764336816966534, 0.023290909826755524, -0.04021676629781723, 0.019188718870282173, -0.014130203984677792, 0.0017735649598762393, -0.007249530404806137, -0.012528949417173862, 0.002907109446823597, -0.017018098384141922, 0.00725150341168046, -0.004819360561668873, -0.05783040076494217, 0.017629988491535187, 0.038707178086042404, -0.020700281485915184, -0.009362099692225456, -0.049593470990657806, 0.04955097660422325, 0.031498052179813385, 0.01887337677180767, -0.03936509042978287, -0.0527338832616806, -0.0014061190886422992, -0.015366052277386189, 0.01795998588204384, -0.03273702785372734, -0.01696908101439476, 0.0029221447184681892, 0.01970558427274227, -0.021866369992494583, 0.004676742013543844, -0.025926008820533752, -0.01061515137553215, 0.002211804734542966, -0.00842532142996788, 0.0644221305847168, 0.010642750188708305, 0.01589673012495041, 0.004950125236064196, -0.004021132830530405, -0.0066102007403969765, 0.00766505254432559, 0.025395233184099197, -0.024540387094020844, -0.015519415028393269, -0.011181899346411228, 0.009715741500258446, 0.030857644975185394, 0.015010698698461056, 0.04524075612425804, -0.0030361611861735582, -0.0005006831488572061, 0.0001354203704977408, -0.05001368373632431, -0.002638715784996748, -0.05729338154196739, -0.03676306828856468, -0.04186677560210228, -0.008670859038829803, -0.016206365078687668, -0.016449812799692154, -0.027679244056344032, 0.008569695055484772, 0.012032045051455498, 0.002496658591553569, 0.07233089953660965, -0.012878965586423874, 0.0033734964672476053, -0.02650652825832367, -0.01683519408106804, 0.04235628992319107, 0.03709718957543373, -0.009936428628861904, 0.01844741217792034, -0.02050998993217945, -0.006139886099845171, 0.00831687357276678, -0.013797149993479252, -0.00781844649463892, 0.052333928644657135, -0.025483250617980957, 0.06321988254785538, 0.022109756246209145, 0.0004377499863039702, 0.026346134021878242, -0.02029282972216606, -0.022530298680067062, -0.0022824399638921022, 0.014505883678793907, 0.0852394849061966, -0.007284896448254585, 0.01620071567595005, 0.007687718141824007, -0.0047940826043486595, 0.050174444913864136, 0.04607295244932175, -0.0004399997415021062, -0.011727492325007915, -0.025339175015687943, 0.02742992714047432, -0.0421038419008255, 0.019986843690276146, -0.036251671612262726, 0.006900059524923563, 0.019338710233569145, -0.028583776205778122, 0.014079398475587368, 0.017150385305285454, -0.05061233043670654, 0.009015318006277084, -0.03113093227148056, -0.02916823886334896, -0.003996291197836399, 0.025974363088607788, -0.013092008419334888, 0.017969124019145966, -0.024614034220576286, 0.06573151797056198, -0.046586986631155014, 0.015138098038733006, -0.04611216485500336, -0.06184607371687889, -0.03940968215465546, -0.06028507277369499, -0.05223165452480316, 0.03439689055085182, -0.003148461924865842, 0.024188755080103874, -0.0020622252486646175, -0.04256504774093628, 0.015165767632424831, -0.021053237840533257, 0.02276509627699852, 0.01280954573303461, 0.04411745071411133, -0.004215571563690901, 0.01871441677212715, 0.026892108842730522, -0.08648888766765594, 0.1135452538728714, 0.0693543553352356, 0.07083271443843842, -0.080194853246212, 0.04028613865375519, 0.010966971516609192, -0.03708334639668465, -0.020230991765856743, 0.003328966908156872, -0.014709613285958767, 0.022678829729557037, 0.012504267506301403, 0.05721971020102501, 0.014531662687659264, 0.048706989735364914, 0.022626234218478203, -0.04357468709349632, -0.012040439993143082, 0.03398401662707329, 0.016231628134846687, 0.008138347417116165, -0.03178900480270386, -0.12326407432556152, 0.0063901725225150585, 0.034234363585710526, -0.00589725049212575, -0.03167691081762314, -0.018084514886140823, 0.011601204983890057, 0.04707816243171692, -0.011808657087385654, 0.020904572680592537, 0.024256525561213493, -0.0005797713529318571, 0.010688820853829384, -0.027460142970085144, 0.03899447247385979, -0.011661413125693798, 0.0290692038834095, 0.024380899965763092, 0.02631324902176857, 0.0011168160708621144, -0.0024431836791336536, 0.00985042005777359, -0.04000943526625633, -0.01946118287742138, -0.024557609111070633, -0.0011640033917501569, -0.05470430478453636, -0.018648846074938774, 0.005229994188994169, 0.048667289316654205, -0.00649226875975728, -0.032483626157045364, 0.004327347036451101, 0.03738902509212494, 0.013059866614639759, 0.010035918094217777, 0.0029772953130304813, 0.0015233185840770602, 0.02101207710802555, 0.009039757773280144, -0.012142394669353962, 0.0008955802186392248, -0.0028378507122397423, 0.018425658345222473, -0.04472780600190163, 0.029871338978409767, 0.003235411364585161, 0.006698396988213062, 0.007270790170878172, 0.0006279950030148029, -0.04414460062980652, -0.00862883310765028, 0.007768499664962292, 0.016979336738586426, -0.025852138176560402, 0.018673015758395195, -0.008697395212948322, -0.01225552149116993, -0.015186077915132046, 0.03311673179268837, -0.029538080096244812, -0.039728496223688126, -0.01729203201830387, -0.02518046647310257, 0.06214375048875809, 0.025920061394572258, 0.031221287325024605, 0.02264302968978882, -0.027597058564424515, 0.053156778216362, 0.01958487182855606, -0.005416286643594503, -0.02521817572414875, 0.009814804419875145, 0.00021956165437586606, -0.008076912723481655, -0.020959891378879547, 0.06617976725101471, 0.023087142035365105, -0.000564189103897661, -0.01605374552309513, 0.023474963381886482, -0.00787174329161644, -0.006677031517028809, 0.011714150197803974, -0.03395120054483414, 0.052354712039232254, 0.019043121486902237, 0.0029615219682455063, -0.05112490803003311, -0.023231176659464836, -0.046183619648218155, -0.058960627764463425, 0.03095296397805214, 0.011148754507303238, -0.024421069771051407, 0.02237905189394951, -0.008928315714001656, 0.014902736991643906, -0.028282029554247856, 0.012039486318826675, -0.06308352202177048, -0.027813823893666267, 0.007015227805823088, -0.03794495761394501, -0.033650968223810196, 0.028161056339740753, -0.028292903676629066, 0.015821510925889015, 0.01152823120355606, 0.021564152091741562, 0.011634033173322678, 0.005390658974647522, 0.018122820183634758, 0.027162430807948112, 0.03367745131254196, -0.029020728543400764, -0.032049451023340225, -0.017003418877720833, -0.06148484721779823, -0.03675010800361633, -0.019887376576662064, -0.02601435035467148, 0.020250407978892326, -0.009468866512179375, -0.006420067977160215, -0.04804559424519539, 0.0424419641494751, -0.018468214198946953, -0.04085744172334671, -0.022176172584295273, -0.01001787930727005, 0.034996397793293, 0.015064387582242489, -0.014856413006782532, -0.026872951537370682, -0.014343775808811188, 0.011626746505498886, 0.05621878057718277, 0.04667367413640022, -0.04149314761161804, -0.007474519312381744, -0.0026428119745105505, 0.030741525813937187, -0.010723315179347992, -0.010206565260887146, 0.038669127970933914, 0.019504597410559654, -0.07959549129009247, 0.023651817813515663, -0.017707008868455887, 0.008712287992238998, -0.07543176412582397, 0.005521747283637524, -0.002229445381090045, -0.04051414877176285, 0.06139427423477173, -0.0416063517332077, -0.013151868246495724, 0.002294621430337429, -0.019291577860713005, 0.029399294406175613, -0.004493434447795153, -0.021138843148946762, -0.009188574738800526, 0.022768156602978706, -0.028230976313352585, 0.021266059949994087, 0.04739794507622719, 0.032098621129989624, 0.007585588842630386, -0.025129161775112152, -0.013324787840247154, -0.004258840344846249, -0.039576150476932526, 0.023577943444252014, 0.005261408630758524, -0.05032363533973694, 0.01222307700663805, -0.0011421473463997245, -0.022747045382857323, 0.022947976365685463, 0.01983291283249855, -0.006820654962211847, 0.021884629502892494, -0.004001904278993607, 0.003288557520136237, 0.03501120209693909, -0.020138397812843323, -0.021245531737804413, -0.012681860476732254, 0.023016614839434624, 0.016412226483225822, -0.004994513001292944, 0.0019756443798542023, -0.017947444692254066, 0.015336675569415092, -0.021086569875478745, -0.04187477007508278, 0.04998993128538132, -0.03180542588233948, -0.0003231434093322605, -0.05911421775817871, 0.000514889950864017, 0.05246323347091675, -0.03492198511958122, 0.012738924473524094, -0.03234691917896271, 0.02312280796468258, 0.025332843884825706, 0.007332456763833761, -0.013769475743174553, 0.011396180838346481, 0.022742051631212234, -0.04588647559285164, -0.03369149565696716, 0.039832185953855515, -0.011312371119856834, -0.056183770298957825, -0.004053717944771051, -0.010208933614194393, -0.037091489881277084, -0.02878378890454769, -0.020976753905415535, -0.019614432007074356, 0.0027500023134052753, -0.013772154226899147, 0.04372609034180641, 0.025680402293801308, 0.003659741720184684, 0.002988369669765234, -0.08446689695119858, 0.035103946924209595, 0.01115028653293848, 0.00868335273116827, -0.04698627069592476, -0.007327624596655369, -0.02554401010274887, 0.016290606930851936, 0.07495728880167007, 0.01059985812753439, 0.006136855110526085, -0.05935961753129959, 0.03861968219280243, 0.014998756349086761, -0.03555503115057945, 0.053218670189380646, 0.010558460839092731, -0.029756154865026474, -0.001083311508409679, -0.023453237488865852, 0.007730521727353334, 0.03499629721045494, 0.011041298508644104, -0.019372394308447838, -0.007901716977357864, 0.010942431166768074, -0.06683969497680664, -0.022090546786785126, -0.023561781272292137, -0.03629711642861366, 0.05016564577817917, 0.021362895146012306, -0.02094334550201893, 0.049521658569574356, -0.0008297361782751977, -0.01069014985114336, 0.03071868233382702, -0.03997858986258507, -0.016398848965764046, -0.03976927697658539, 0.006954663898795843, -0.018212242051959038, -0.03955330699682236, 0.052267882972955704, 0.008971204981207848, -0.039372365921735764, 0.004611004143953323, 0.049957722425460815, 0.030741015449166298, 0.016451070085167885, 0.010823234915733337, -0.00535491481423378, -0.025812026113271713, -0.0384637787938118, 0.0027890687342733145, -0.010267293080687523, -0.017579583451151848, 0.005762429907917976, 0.036956917494535446, 0.03356930613517761, -0.03309597447514534, 0.037667714059352875, -0.01536289881914854, 0.047244470566511154, -0.03645215928554535, -0.01710135117173195, 0.01646958477795124, -0.0015687918057665229, 0.011515520513057709, -0.04433624818921089, -0.012273039668798447, -0.010989073663949966, -0.03972718492150307, 0.038986846804618835, -0.07663152366876602, -0.06350638717412949, -0.041886743158102036, 0.01468306127935648, -0.0160180926322937, 0.043482210487127304, -0.014826029539108276, 0.029679827392101288, 0.004659822676330805, -0.001392926787957549, 0.0425490103662014, -0.0044546350836753845, 0.0027225827798247337, -0.062022965401411057, 0.03143196552991867, 0.026914281770586967, 0.02044413425028324, 0.005067957565188408, -0.0022777817212045193, 0.01905234530568123, 0.011048189364373684, 0.013439805246889591, -0.03160202130675316, 0.01455030869692564, 0.013080064207315445, 0.012264883145689964, -0.05189904198050499, -0.019890345633029938, -0.02800297737121582, -0.012991877272725105, 0.05166419595479965, 0.0026524674613028765 ]
<p>I wanted to create a bubble chart which means a scatter plot with a separate variable indicating diameter of bubble. Is there any way to use bubble then as pie chart? I would really like to do this in MS Excel but I just don't know whether it is possible. </p> <hr> <p>I have another problem with the code proposed earlier in the post. Now that the first problem appears to be solved there is a problem in the line </p> <p><code>Set rngRow = Range(ThisWorkbook.Names(“PieChartValues”).RefersTo)</code></p> <p>and I tried to replace PieChartValues with the range from the first row to the last in which the pie charts values ( the values from which the pie chart is generated) - like "A1:G12" and all the data are in that range. The tab in the sheet I am working in is called "B" without quotes should I write </p> <p><code>Set rngRow = Range(ThisWorkbook.Names(“B”).RefersTo)</code></p> <hr> <p>i tried to implement the code of a link proposed earlier in VBA this is</p> <pre><code>Sub PieMarkers() Dim chtMarker As Chart Dim chtMain As Chart Dim intPoint As Integer Dim rngRow As Range Dim lngPointIndex As Long Application.ScreenUpdating = False Set chtMarker = ActiveSheet.ChartObjects(“chtMarker”).Chart Set chtMain = ActiveSheet.ChartObjects(“chtMain”).Chart Set chtMain = ActiveSheet.ChartObjects(“chtMain”).Chart Set rngRow = Range(ThisWorkbook.Names(“PieChartValues”).RefersTo) For Each rngRow In Range(“PieChartValues”).Rows chtMarker.SeriesCollection(1).Values = rngRow chtMarker.Parent.CopyPicture xlScreen, xlPicture lngPointIndex = lngPointIndex + 1 chtMain.SeriesCollection(1).Points(lngPointIndex).Paste Next lngPointIndex = 0 Application.ScreenUpdating = True End Sub </code></pre> <p>when I execute the code I get an error pointing to the line Set chtMarker = ActiveSheet.ChartObjects(“chtMarker”).Chart</p> <p>does anybody have an idea why? I have an object a pie chart named exactly chtMarker so the object should be there</p>
36,696
[ -0.01177468802779913, -0.0028139781206846237, 0.046028926968574524, 0.005278428550809622, -0.0030852798372507095, -0.007398561108857393, -0.050271980464458466, -0.022962020710110664, 0.031979531049728394, -0.03879421204328537, 0.0174093134701252, 0.05009504035115242, 0.05110522359609604, 0.026922157034277916, 0.043250277638435364, -0.009457365609705448, 0.0028505318332463503, -0.0022207628935575485, 0.008066468872129917, -0.0487971231341362, 0.007867749780416489, -0.01315050944685936, 0.012671269476413727, -0.0031645495910197496, 0.030118731781840324, 0.036519855260849, 0.0021079417783766985, -0.0191822312772274, -0.011317137628793716, 0.049424849450588226, -0.02518126368522644, -0.020271524786949158, 0.03913095220923424, -0.0027156907599419355, 0.03248027339577675, -0.0010786190396174788, -0.030283726751804352, -0.014570450410246849, 0.0011424325639382005, 0.011133149266242981, -0.06255324929952621, 0.01252883579581976, 0.01909349113702774, 0.03699420765042305, -0.02355370484292507, -0.045067958533763885, -0.0441584549844265, -0.01745716482400894, 0.03346835449337959, -0.04311642423272133, 0.04771590977907181, -0.011690795421600342, 0.05529947206377983, 0.02672800049185753, -0.04173143208026886, 0.00292360782623291, 0.028008554130792618, 0.03188532590866089, -0.010323140770196915, -0.01365808304399252, 0.027542388066649437, -0.01788773573935032, -0.00173675874248147, -0.054671820253133774, -0.04904172942042351, -0.013807756826281548, -0.011247341521084309, 0.029682563617825508, 0.007450227625668049, -0.034551773220300674, 0.02917601726949215, 0.0049800262786448, -0.004992175847291946, -0.016401831060647964, 0.04690011590719223, -0.05413182079792023, -0.00027855654479935765, -0.03192770481109619, 0.04513763636350632, 0.061814919114112854, -0.0003531690454110503, 0.0634494349360466, 0.04032459482550621, 0.0016180906677618623, 0.01898566447198391, 0.01947229728102684, 0.0678844004869461, -0.01829575002193451, 0.05061233043670654, 0.05322451889514923, -0.00633435882627964, -0.04311050474643707, 0.01580630987882614, 0.03387801721692085, -0.006479781121015549, 0.03883541375398636, -0.034475114196538925, 0.012144798412919044, -0.008115507662296295, 0.004947420675307512, 0.030452605336904526, -0.000532289850525558, 0.050114914774894714, 0.03640051931142807, -0.030133193358778954, -0.027716606855392456, -0.020947039127349854, -0.02547483704984188, 0.06269755214452744, -0.030956648290157318, -0.03374473750591278, 0.022545255720615387, -0.01489285472780466, -0.00743255065754056, 0.037436265498399734, -0.002009788528084755, 0.006363157648593187, 0.030264606699347496, 0.02479691244661808, 0.015621867030858994, 0.006161999423056841, -0.00994153693318367, 0.030879497528076172, -0.01233768742531538, -0.04894388094544411, 0.021726226434111595, 0.01090689841657877, -0.006238420959562063, -0.06883478164672852, 0.03764807805418968, 0.008811050094664097, -0.03320402279496193, 0.03507477417588234, 0.0068149203434586525, 0.050755131989717484, -0.02295399270951748, -0.09681415557861328, -0.06837214529514313, 0.02472737804055214, 0.021261733025312424, -0.01842096634209156, -0.04237247630953789, 0.03031391277909279, 0.041983965784311295, 0.025362210348248482, 0.01657630316913128, -0.03558417782187462, 0.028890354558825493, 0.04506741836667061, 0.02397429570555687, -0.0018174927681684494, 0.010709036141633987, 0.0194135420024395, -0.05595003813505173, -0.015362666919827461, -0.06840609759092331, 0.03510574251413345, 0.020413869991898537, -0.0354592427611351, -0.02840392291545868, 0.011834615841507912, -0.0033610619138926268, 0.011614126153290272, 0.026878688484430313, 0.023384766653180122, -0.04609639570116997, 0.10711000859737396, 0.028663231059908867, 0.020935365930199623, 0.035081785172224045, -0.03356437012553215, 0.025220656767487526, -0.010031308978796005, 0.010417654179036617, 0.07767711579799652, 0.04290219023823738, -0.013770662248134613, 0.013953741639852524, 0.01881449483335018, 0.017915891483426094, -0.011109528131783009, -0.0339517779648304, 0.011714513413608074, -0.010970229282975197, 0.06810189038515091, 0.04239705577492714, -0.010442464612424374, -0.028924917802214622, 0.030079910531640053, -0.048513296991586685, 0.00906458217650652, -0.04471037536859512, 0.010557466186583042, 0.006521556992083788, 0.01220803614705801, -0.0095902094617486, -0.015959829092025757, 0.00826783012598753, 0.0399446114897728, -0.006486352067440748, -0.0014370529679581523, -0.02421635575592518, 0.00985116045922041, -0.0883348137140274, -0.00606251135468483, 0.04886990785598755, 0.017496930435299873, -0.04978214204311371, 0.04583559185266495, -0.029066871851682663, 0.04145025461912155, 0.001397567568346858, -0.005994366016238928, 0.01976749114692211, -0.0180464219301939, 0.01756279170513153, 0.025511883199214935, 0.037409745156764984, -0.009476158767938614, 0.03974322974681854, -0.01422953698784113, 0.02635842375457287, 0.02953733503818512, -0.005898823495954275, 0.017988355830311775, -0.041751179844141006, 0.07662677764892578, 0.03745684400200844, 0.0074355751276016235, -0.019258154556155205, -0.040486015379428864, 0.007179345935583115, 0.02274947799742222, 0.02172822691500187, -0.04311970993876457, -0.027089513838291168, 0.07135128229856491, 0.007302041165530682, 0.0297421682626009, 0.02144775167107582, 0.009232817217707634, 0.028453117236495018, 0.022970782592892647, 0.03851495310664177, 0.020876437425613403, 0.04181360825896263, 0.0032473639585077763, -0.012192564085125923, 0.041147176176309586, -0.029287617653608322, -0.023121992126107216, -0.003092784434556961, 0.02396283484995365, -0.023826763033866882, -0.014301766641438007, 0.0023500488605350256, 0.05203951522707939, -0.04927152022719383, 0.03852267935872078, 0.03621629253029823, 0.01187681220471859, -0.04252912849187851, 0.01779814437031746, -0.026875946670770645, -0.025003651157021523, 0.05161198228597641, -0.022546809166669846, -0.057061903178691864, -0.0006220185314305127, -0.02174469642341137, 0.03229796513915062, -0.0076379175297915936, -0.01869383081793785, -0.011594472452998161, 0.016611719503998756, 0.020312517881393433, 0.012674261815845966, 0.030562492087483406, -0.024711264297366142, -0.03132247552275658, -0.025233712047338486, -0.004078234545886517, -0.0054775807075202465, -0.02245361916720867, -0.053400591015815735, -0.0017375466413795948, 0.028566516935825348, -0.004839770495891571, 0.04586099088191986, 0.014755266718566418, -0.02413957379758358, 0.017100438475608826, -0.005456811282783747, -0.05235115438699722, 0.007620200049132109, -0.036934711039066315, 0.02003743313252926, -0.04157806187868118, 0.005573626141995192, 0.06548824906349182, 0.01922520622611046, -0.03788622096180916, 0.033307477831840515, -0.04993859678506851, -0.001556510105729103, -0.0550394281744957, 0.013221176341176033, -0.0036606916692107916, -0.041918255388736725, 0.01911618746817112, 0.020350879058241844, -0.011203587986528873, 0.005645154044032097, -0.025840792804956436, -0.03841371461749077, 0.0012003808515146375, 0.02392895147204399, 0.03207683563232422, 0.020806588232517242, -0.023986373096704483, 0.07901660352945328, 0.013045763596892357, -0.04648968204855919, -0.033640604466199875, -0.006429670378565788, 0.02800023928284645, -0.023600347340106964, 0.021462982520461082, 0.0215953029692173, -0.03949262201786041, -0.03015943430364132, -0.012716716155409813, 0.03851540759205818, 0.03136714547872543, -0.028792718425393105, 0.026895882561802864, 0.007102876901626587, 0.0179543886333704, -0.03711911290884018, 0.03547922521829605, 0.014397169463336468, -0.005342642776668072, -0.0037964533548802137, -0.015529310330748558, 0.03220672905445099, 0.018075698986649513, -0.04026397690176964, 0.0070307012647390366, -0.046471234411001205, 0.05984232574701309, 0.037000179290771484, 0.030838392674922943, 0.015060298144817352, -0.007902750745415688, -0.012937743216753006, 0.03301345184445381, 0.0401620976626873, -0.05297356843948364, -0.0393923856317997, 0.08520329743623734, 0.012081539258360863, -0.03523198515176773, 0.009574558585882187, 0.019550681114196777, -0.018044034019112587, 0.037856318056583405, -0.03212844952940941, 0.013517131097614765, 0.012424828484654427, 0.03935370594263077, -0.0034272007178515196, 0.03796151280403137, -0.08436579257249832, 0.024809326976537704, -0.03333314135670662, -0.018511343747377396, -0.02092157118022442, 0.04859489947557449, -0.00845102034509182, 0.04367799684405327, 0.07727102935314178, 0.008806671015918255, 0.049721211194992065, 0.0029178205877542496, -0.03474407270550728, 0.02196919173002243, 0.024417389184236526, -0.027874814346432686, -0.003936217166483402, -0.03697512298822403, 0.0012087303912267089, 0.017468038946390152, -0.003127703908830881, -0.027529004961252213, -0.014899821020662785, -0.0327601321041584, -0.0011391820153221488, -0.0035189834889024496, 0.0237449798732996, -0.05136283114552498, 0.04818306118249893, 0.009163209237158298, 0.00040754399378784, 0.046772293746471405, 0.026983531191945076, -0.038998208940029144, -0.042546916753053665, -0.02692023664712906, -0.016239525750279427, 0.02165563590824604, 0.0038056084886193275, -0.016435712575912476, -0.012282995507121086, -0.020521603524684906, -0.00014164797903504223, -0.004328690003603697, 0.027216460555791855, 0.017215050756931305, -0.00725958589464426, -0.003958575893193483, -0.03279721736907959, -0.028255097568035126, 0.01606075093150139, 0.03215824440121651, -0.018243156373500824, 0.006574220955371857, 0.016908906400203705, -0.0015256471233442426, -0.0016483989311382174, 0.026477856561541557, 0.07733564078807831, 0.06654797494411469, -0.0033209139946848154, -0.037378810346126556, -0.016694022342562675, -0.022665340453386307, -0.02001883089542389, 0.015752388164401054, 0.0024494072422385216, -0.02050761692225933, -0.013615330681204796, 0.0269634872674942, 0.004244972951710224, -0.03546960651874542, -0.024963943287730217, 0.004722688812762499, 0.0363934189081192, -0.03675207495689392, -0.04368295148015022, 0.027334410697221756, -0.00031704307184554636, 0.017003417015075684, 0.04189158231019974, 0.004124450031667948, -0.10104817152023315, 0.0003779302933253348, 0.03016483411192894, 0.020282737910747528, -0.04480910301208496, -0.04155402630567551, -0.01642688922584057, -0.004031464457511902, 0.04726821556687355, -0.08477484434843063, 0.028893865644931793, -0.0700487494468689, 0.041776057332754135, -0.021268172189593315, -0.041138142347335815, -0.008989427238702774, 0.028729014098644257, -0.04173747077584267, 0.015568261034786701, -0.04371190071105957, -0.006714500952512026, -0.008499943651258945, -0.017961883917450905, -0.016338543966412544, 0.09057680517435074, -0.011507230810821056, -0.04062749445438385, 0.0006004872848279774, -0.018187370151281357, -0.0324726440012455, -0.024995263665914536, 0.0031501525081694126, -0.010931749828159809, 0.018395721912384033, 0.049627117812633514, 0.022174295037984848, -0.041250817477703094, 0.000795909552834928, 0.0019261549459770322, 0.0037794613745063543, -0.01969795860350132, -0.015857456251978874, 0.005468039307743311, 0.020212236791849136, -0.048592276871204376, 0.06780511885881424, 0.07162740081548691, -0.0375589095056057, 0.028497297316789627, -0.016322221606969833, 0.006657105404883623, -0.02190132811665535, -0.04044891521334648, -0.050706688314676285, 0.019690630957484245, -0.015020974911749363, 0.015515291132032871, 0.02471386268734932, -0.014596853405237198, -0.0514826737344265, -0.03643549978733063, 0.010771081782877445, 0.007809753529727459, 0.02306082658469677, 0.016897276043891907, -0.006814784836024046, 0.040746789425611496, 0.03181721270084381, -0.023711690679192543, 0.004180419258773327, 0.005453084595501423, 0.0003541705955285579, 0.0368591733276844, 0.0028922336641699076, -0.008188559673726559, -0.012876279652118683, 0.026643089950084686, -0.03543134406208992, -0.024895822629332542, 0.024465229362249374, 0.0058106533251702785, 0.030490802600979805, -0.003684139112010598, -0.05525005981326103, -0.009173423051834106, 0.05014732480049133, -0.020962772890925407, 0.011458647437393665, -0.049382831901311874, 0.03909984976053238, 0.02853473275899887, 0.00022678496316075325, -0.040383752435445786, -0.05020490288734436, -0.02121633291244507, 0.027789583429694176, 0.00675535760819912, 0.002820933936163783, -0.03845835477113724, 0.033123914152383804, 0.01943628489971161, 0.009873617440462112, 0.0012509453808888793, -0.0029405970126390457, -0.021734576672315598, 0.04483160004019737, 0.015791885554790497, 0.07531151920557022, 0.055367257446050644, -0.009982856921851635, -0.01438939943909645, -0.0021435776725411415, -0.03052397444844246, 0.04259826987981796, -0.0017074529314413667, -0.02302141673862934, -0.03086056560277939, -0.022800087928771973, 0.013342345133423805, 0.044347867369651794, 0.00040570710552856326, 0.02930513024330139, 0.010047545656561852, -0.02843235246837139, 0.008032585494220257, -0.06169850379228592, 0.00941027794033289, -0.03172379359602928, -0.01504905428737402, -0.043947648257017136, 0.04330797865986824, -0.029329275712370872, -0.003783604595810175, -0.04122481867671013, 0.006630371790379286, -0.0010689793853089213, 0.02602807991206646, 0.046244293451309204, -0.03330041468143463, -0.010920067317783833, -0.021183203905820847, -0.026267075911164284, 0.0004117319767829031, 0.006665886379778385, 0.0009647064143791795, 0.0004593916528392583, 0.028167221695184708, -0.013375373557209969, 0.00884732510894537, -0.02873994968831539, 0.0057950811460614204, 0.026401609182357788, 0.010572700761258602, 0.028335051611065865, 0.003683476708829403, -0.023649880662560463, -0.01776052638888359, -0.0741029903292656, -0.010637281462550163, -0.03884559124708176, -0.004431716166436672, 0.09343979507684708, 0.01885603368282318, -0.006080701947212219, 0.02631998434662819, -0.00469264667481184, 0.036602992564439774, -0.008399819023907185, 0.023116307333111763, 0.009393579326570034, -0.014139147475361824, -0.012525863014161587, -0.030633270740509033, 0.045225631445646286, -0.02034112438559532, 0.03912358731031418, 0.019018620252609253, -0.04844138026237488, 0.020849330350756645, 0.02573639713227749, -0.03724612295627594, -0.03226425126194954, -0.05966290831565857, -0.02484983205795288, 0.025035174563527107, -0.0211799219250679, -0.01901007629930973, 0.011176207102835178, 0.007616986054927111, -0.005246024113148451, -0.057612478733062744, 0.022762523964047432, -0.04092610999941826, -0.043089933693408966, -0.04205953702330589, -0.0351409874856472, -0.022241313010454178, 0.03461948037147522, -0.041935909539461136, -0.025387311354279518, 0.002558392472565174, -0.01802128180861473, -0.008315597660839558, -0.0034118862822651863, 0.02915586717426777, 0.009209003299474716, 0.10467543452978134, 0.010191201232373714, 0.010402608662843704, 0.034791044890880585, -0.04711659625172615, 0.1313733458518982, 0.06606043130159378, 0.012271839193999767, -0.04130536690354347, 0.005677735898643732, 0.02663942240178585, 0.00029040288063697517, -0.01593088172376156, 0.00215919385664165, -0.036188844591379166, 0.013908101245760918, 0.06569457054138184, 0.04110398516058922, -0.018003180623054504, 0.0353960283100605, 0.05268231779336929, 0.0034883003681898117, 0.004682105965912342, -0.010765986517071724, -0.0029519409872591496, -0.013015661388635635, 0.0008915810030885041, -0.06691960245370865, 0.0023980510886758566, -0.004829722922295332, -0.010950526222586632, 0.02653038501739502, -0.021685171872377396, 0.023957068100571632, 0.022897670045495033, -0.025428084656596184, 0.006184765137732029, 0.0342174656689167, -0.00015160210023168474, 0.01098571252077818, -0.023940935730934143, 0.021437035873532295, -0.02227611094713211, -0.0021006378810852766, 0.0498521514236927, -0.002309736330062151, -0.025044605135917664, -0.013224965892732143, 0.031324129551649094, -0.03923037648200989, 0.0035108288284391165, -0.01505300309509039, 0.01585542969405651, -0.01535575371235609, -0.01675204187631607, 0.022446103394031525, 0.05175687372684479, -0.040014564990997314, -0.03234455734491348, -0.004977927543222904, 0.009249480441212654, -0.0032576960511505604, -0.009489773772656918, -0.045072704553604126, 0.0077965050004422665, 0.010463686659932137, 0.0009956683497875929, 0.034707922488451004, 0.011137417517602444, -0.05872205272316933, 0.013338243588805199, -0.058974433690309525, -0.004553286358714104, -0.022229941561818123, -0.025062916800379753, 0.045615050941705704, 0.029015885666012764, -0.03056269884109497, -0.013502193614840508, -0.008178310468792915, 0.016862738877534866, 0.023490289226174355, 0.012653034180402756, 0.0006737675284966826, -0.00504924776032567, -0.0599166564643383, 0.036881327629089355, -0.020393922924995422, -0.030131470412015915, -0.011636354960501194, 0.002141593722626567, 0.09809716790914536, 0.05123153328895569, -0.010025781579315662, -0.023060856387019157, -0.051976487040519714, 0.07683782279491425, 0.011583955027163029, -0.050708986818790436, -0.020779648795723915, 0.03473053500056267, -0.0814499780535698, 0.002858214545994997, 0.0015123176854103804, 0.08834530413150787, 0.04155169427394867, -0.010510619729757309, -0.008952926844358444, 0.05026257410645485, -0.004046949557960033, 0.011225271970033646, -0.00392213836312294, -0.01978171057999134, 0.013047227635979652, -0.038838453590869904, -0.009289717301726341, -0.02560773305594921, -0.01986367255449295, -0.03315646946430206, 0.0025351776275783777, 0.010656097903847694, -0.00009060135926119983, -0.033903565257787704, 0.0042145890183746815, -0.012687450274825096, -0.03536532446742058, -0.04452119022607803, 0.020009689033031464, -0.0185512974858284, -0.02791602909564972, 0.007227254565805197, -0.014783913269639015, -0.024046219885349274, 0.05136619880795479, -0.01502214651554823, 0.015193122439086437, 0.023286981508135796, 0.07005932182073593, -0.004638483747839928, -0.02755836769938469, 0.014812097884714603, 0.014232737012207508, 0.0026880865916609764, -0.010088006965816021, -0.010021503083407879, 0.027126101776957512, -0.00022743118461221457, -0.05670963600277901, 0.008910342119634151, 0.0006164720398373902, 0.01115491334348917, 0.002388925291597843, 0.014855892397463322, -0.022955799475312233, 0.024177726358175278, 0.04204060882329941, -0.03183573856949806, -0.01012676116079092, 0.0028461834881454706, 0.018971269950270653, 0.015584331005811691, 0.02628946304321289, -0.015474112704396248, 0.0015595877775922418, -0.006447196938097477, 0.034171223640441895, 0.015983080491423607, -0.011025157757103443, -0.019682450219988823, 0.0033540879376232624, 0.00009143575880443677, 0.008366787806153297, 0.010921123437583447, 0.03506471589207649, 0.016306597739458084, -0.03703496977686882, 0.031912583857774734, 0.009836391545832157, -0.04068455845117569, -0.07466869056224823, -0.056697994470596313, -0.01511378027498722, -0.0066558681428432465, 0.01423485204577446, -0.029985550791025162, 0.03539608046412468, 0.05374903604388237, -0.054332435131073, 0.0016127944691106677, 0.03486863896250725, 0.032586339861154556, -0.03035632334649563, 0.02926311455667019, -0.0039002953562885523, -0.0033672235440462828, 0.05481243506073952, -0.0015469805803149939, -0.0071496786549687386, -0.009674164466559887, 0.026505377143621445, -0.015549496747553349, -0.007079086732119322, 0.028539227321743965, 0.022954415529966354, -0.0359201543033123, 0.007736478466540575, -0.06427855044603348, 0.0035666199401021004, 0.0038348063826560974, -0.031953442841768265, 0.04495351016521454, -0.004156156443059444, -0.02370741218328476, 0.027263043448328972, 0.02567763812839985, -0.027526820078492165, 0.0057739149779081345, -0.035693854093551636, 0.020486723631620407, 0.030503908172249794, 0.010965372435748577, -0.01460595615208149, 0.013092470355331898, -0.003554917173460126, -0.020090505480766296, -0.0479014553129673, -0.02756076119840145, 0.005446732509881258, 0.015415331348776817, -0.020524730905890465, 0.009857230819761753, 0.04656977578997612, -0.02785557508468628, 0.017197629436850548, -0.052548907697200775, 0.027493823319673538, 0.010443153791129589, -0.03727510944008827, 0.00046954589197412133, -0.0013435943983495235, 0.005775118712335825, -0.024838926270604134, -0.008957453072071075, 0.030995089560747147, -0.009507942013442516, -0.015221555717289448, -0.030224725604057312, 0.0030646990053355694, -0.01880803517997265, -0.013111947104334831, 0.02292621321976185, 0.017241155728697777, 0.02218099683523178, 0.006417905446141958, -0.013425316661596298, -0.008195972070097923, 0.04856575280427933, -0.01316127274185419, -0.05825662985444069, 0.02931676059961319, 0.01838034950196743, -0.06036818400025368, -0.03610982373356819, -0.022940825670957565, 0.001555072609335184, 0.02267027273774147, 0.049625568091869354, -0.011213744059205055, 0.033316534012556076, -0.02355579473078251, 0.003292080480605364, 0.01717696338891983, -0.022889312356710434, 0.019470402970910072, 0.023144908249378204, -0.061895761638879776, 0.0016429582610726357, 0.027284063398838043, -0.010822086594998837, 0.015409328043460846, 0.023658275604248047, 0.00027836087974719703, -0.014004787430167198, 0.029659314081072807, -0.030695976689457893, -0.005900330375880003, 0.0007296644616872072, -0.06589671224355698, 0.051739562302827835, 0.006726464722305536, -0.026925263926386833, 0.024856485426425934, -0.013655743561685085, -0.052392978221178055, 0.02505568414926529, -0.05017910152673721, 0.005196570418775082, -0.004612169694155455, -0.006863029208034277, -0.008383074775338173, -0.07939355075359344, 0.028177352622151375, -0.031178629025816917, -0.0028775795362889767, 0.017973819747567177, 0.03198309242725372, -0.014012935571372509, 0.03004518337547779, -0.016932880505919456, 0.011120130307972431, -0.03319786116480827, -0.011173662729561329, -0.0035830256529152393, -0.01334297377616167, 0.0019180398667231202, -0.017284490168094635, 0.04275394603610039, 0.026052990928292274, 0.036661483347415924, 0.02671767584979534, -0.00928310863673687, 0.0500514879822731, 0.05710191652178764, -0.0044694761745631695, 0.025031160563230515, -0.036591846495866776, -0.0028444051276892424, 0.03154613450169563, 0.004181960131973028, 0.03173879534006119, -0.05657459422945976, 0.028409048914909363, -0.03945423290133476, -0.04051736369729042, -0.03658474609255791, 0.035639528185129166, 0.005301571451127529, 0.02911888249218464, -0.0028012196999043226, 0.015414719469845295, 0.03019014373421669, 0.005103390663862228, 0.019693493843078613, -0.01332960743457079, -0.016646338626742363, -0.05321585014462471, 0.023455532267689705, -0.004618086386471987, 0.021966272965073586, -0.03235756605863571, 0.01935247890651226, 0.039297934621572495, 0.022879699245095253, -0.029964428395032883, 0.0012568479869514704, -0.025417495518922806, 0.013995817862451077, 0.024320542812347412, -0.04104632884263992, -0.0376187264919281, -0.0032898765057325363, 0.012533933855593204, 0.015673251822590828, -0.023307261988520622 ]
<p>What is the PDF of the difference of two i.i.d Laplace distributed random variables?</p> <p>I know that the difference of two i.i.d Normal variables is still the Normal distribution. Since the properties of the Laplace distribution are similar to the Normal distribution, I am guessing that the difference is also the Laplace distribution.</p> <p>I have tried to solve this using Mathematica. Neither <code>PDF</code> nor <code>Integrate</code> functions give a correct answer. Thank you!</p>
74,054
[ -0.013752980157732964, -0.010235194116830826, -0.005094065796583891, -0.039931464940309525, -0.007769405841827393, 0.012595804408192635, -0.04760800302028656, -0.0198915284126997, 0.028311509639024734, -0.02255430445075035, 0.03725453093647957, 0.015304100699722767, 0.06444064527750015, 0.04584266617894173, 0.06285272538661957, -0.0030230770353227854, -0.022437430918216705, 0.03881445527076721, 0.012739652767777443, -0.011500071734189987, 0.007757178973406553, 0.003938577137887478, 0.03132777661085129, -0.01638743467628956, -0.02971763350069523, 0.02974218688905239, 0.021050507202744484, -0.016124416142702103, 0.02189510501921177, 0.08132980018854141, -0.06649146974086761, -0.0184268057346344, -0.0027585537172853947, 0.04576748609542847, -0.017888817936182022, 0.0074587068520486355, -0.06817096471786499, -0.01522346492856741, -0.03257255628705025, 0.02768023870885372, -0.030896726995706558, 0.0067298077046871185, 0.015019524842500687, 0.036880988627672195, -0.006074313074350357, 0.033686500042676926, -0.0007806285284459591, -0.033148910850286484, 0.013661976903676987, -0.043034978210926056, 0.06268008053302765, -0.011286433786153793, 0.06950073689222336, 0.0300796777009964, -0.015876637771725655, -0.0034554535523056984, 0.03502274677157402, 0.08937329053878784, -0.017522193491458893, -0.0778181403875351, -0.012652575969696045, -0.0379740446805954, 0.011978279799222946, -0.040265120565891266, -0.03635445237159729, 0.013447415083646774, -0.02824486792087555, -0.04111117124557495, 0.0041582463309168816, -0.005183176137506962, 0.013528778217732906, 0.04572831839323044, -0.004346681758761406, -0.042246945202350616, 0.026673346757888794, -0.003029721789062023, 0.0072996835224330425, 0.006269299425184727, 0.019358349964022636, 0.05241744965314865, 0.011146211996674538, -0.012938324362039566, 0.04104803130030632, 0.02246474288403988, 0.05805202201008797, -0.03358651325106621, 0.1139904260635376, 0.006628958508372307, 0.0027842894196510315, 0.002598455175757408, -0.013933212496340275, 0.017948206514120102, 0.03916530683636665, -0.012606345117092133, 0.0008180928998626769, 0.06602313369512558, 0.009359733201563358, 0.027965962886810303, -0.026469623669981956, -0.04431350529193878, -0.005001903511583805, -0.05891511216759682, 0.022156964987516403, 0.07515228539705276, -0.015412888489663601, -0.017670052126049995, -0.0027560479938983917, -0.015253301709890366, -0.025429818779230118, 0.00495398323982954, -0.0005052108899690211, 0.04726645350456238, 0.01329423300921917, -0.018326271325349808, 0.020245375111699104, -0.007041629869490862, 0.013989638537168503, -0.01701814867556095, 0.02664121985435486, 0.07378870993852615, 0.04014352336525917, -0.0419921875, -0.008102502673864365, -0.019198689609766006, -0.03300004079937935, 0.035082194954156876, 0.045149024575948715, 0.02124011144042015, -0.03713979572057724, 0.04832226783037186, -0.052569374442100525, 0.02263214997947216, 0.022973325103521347, 0.009739329107105732, 0.029421932995319366, 0.0055815610103309155, -0.0529562309384346, -0.033082425594329834, 0.006886014249175787, -0.01887146383523941, 0.0007535755867138505, -0.07186207920312881, 0.003073434578254819, 0.010425425134599209, 0.060652099549770355, 0.0076476759277284145, 0.016070090234279633, -0.014828767627477646, 0.04993205517530441, 0.012503230012953281, -0.016127202659845352, -0.015113689936697483, 0.006538966670632362, -0.03769693523645401, -0.006815867964178324, -0.04963319003582001, -0.00013047766697127372, 0.025655820965766907, -0.042562276124954224, 0.005474310368299484, 0.018090177327394485, 0.007667538244277239, -0.00019653845811262727, -0.03471941500902176, 0.014761833474040031, -0.040627796202898026, 0.10311032831668854, 0.0017995685338974, 0.0279205534607172, 0.03750132769346237, -0.019627416506409645, 0.006983060389757156, -0.037582263350486755, 0.04123469814658165, 0.055715881288051605, -0.02088395692408085, -0.039654430001974106, 0.0007796227582730353, 0.017044035717844963, 0.019100822508335114, -0.03164589777588844, -0.003187623107805848, -0.041196309030056, -0.014164826832711697, 0.011689511127769947, 0.007625020574778318, 0.026438046246767044, -0.009731150232255459, -0.022431630641222, -0.054434504359960556, -0.029911546036601067, -0.043808531016111374, 0.01982640102505684, 0.004306726157665253, -0.051065344363451004, 0.001183635089546442, 0.017231767997145653, 0.011795503087341785, -0.012484963051974773, -0.02772863395512104, -0.039463575929403305, -0.0178812425583601, -0.0020845576655119658, -0.029257046058773994, -0.001182787586003542, 0.06631547957658768, 0.053715210407972336, -0.014864356257021427, 0.08070869743824005, -0.01207262184470892, -0.026056231930851936, 0.0050088707357645035, -0.04749073088169098, 0.030129840597510338, -0.011583632789552212, -0.0006514832493849099, 0.00974056776612997, 0.010648434981703758, 0.0072331903502345085, -0.00652662105858326, -0.014515207149088383, 0.04301417991518974, 0.07118874788284302, 0.024540085345506668, -0.015370013192296028, 0.004285963252186775, 0.021264683455228806, 0.030245013535022736, -0.018705079331994057, -0.025876305997371674, -0.046654507517814636, -0.015999268740415573, 0.05468668416142464, 0.03233126178383827, -0.06286288052797318, 0.01765834540128708, 0.05909835919737816, -0.015344568528234959, 0.06745551526546478, -0.00707385316491127, -0.003862217999994755, -0.05017263442277908, 0.012159088626503944, -0.0025735434610396624, -0.009994402527809143, -0.00918588787317276, 0.014819907955825329, 0.004972686059772968, 0.07224217057228088, -0.032940834760665894, -0.026369528844952583, 0.01855187490582466, -0.028673257678747177, 0.05245564505457878, 0.0035829213447868824, 0.011649643070995808, 0.038543663918972015, -0.010179663076996803, 0.009102528914809227, 0.020664462819695473, -0.01907401718199253, -0.005385938566178083, 0.019009828567504883, -0.02447519078850746, 0.023717796429991722, 0.04110153391957283, -0.015658533200621605, -0.015616907738149166, 0.011427978985011578, -0.02800852805376053, 0.013460593298077583, 0.007178937084972858, -0.03270295262336731, -0.022924989461898804, 0.012151812203228474, 0.017562955617904663, 0.019333356991410255, 0.007970108650624752, -0.011217663995921612, -0.01263250783085823, 0.022913407534360886, -0.008150365203619003, -0.01151704415678978, -0.035511985421180725, -0.0352422259747982, 0.023705707862973213, -0.006661492865532637, -0.018596617504954338, 0.03711709380149841, -0.011349217034876347, 0.015024776570498943, 0.04337123781442642, -0.004024263005703688, -0.07540352642536163, 0.0014449033187702298, -0.02390224114060402, 0.04374127835035324, -0.0029802878852933645, 0.005057077389210463, 0.054441794753074646, -0.008676217868924141, -0.05327918007969856, 0.03313285484910011, -0.016185952350497246, -0.031067699193954468, -0.05666498839855194, -0.01881968230009079, 0.03204324096441269, -0.0036467849276959896, 0.0012698821956291795, 0.02245723083615303, -0.03391939029097557, -0.015475855208933353, -0.04114614799618721, -0.05269769951701164, 0.016470400616526604, -0.02615157514810562, 0.04316456988453865, -0.00866703875362873, -0.049878500401973724, 0.04756689816713333, 0.02163649909198284, -0.03244686499238014, 0.008358370512723923, -0.018394269049167633, -0.012914830818772316, 0.0006341514526866376, 0.0175773985683918, 0.004522521048784256, -0.0106436712667346, 0.06097981706261635, 0.038980577141046524, 0.015167511999607086, 0.03826674446463585, -0.006102037616074085, -0.007061203010380268, 0.03804146870970726, 0.04550548642873764, -0.014342473819851875, 0.034745730459690094, 0.004214707296341658, -0.003656988497823477, 0.002602467080578208, 0.018278619274497032, 0.02022118680179119, 0.020379051566123962, -0.02640451304614544, 0.04932413250207901, -0.0073693240992724895, 0.01079410407692194, -0.04351375624537468, 0.02627076581120491, -0.002135810675099492, -0.029235590249300003, 0.005449437070637941, 0.004507148172706366, 0.038180362433195114, -0.009619501419365406, 0.008452150970697403, 0.05040132626891136, 0.028110411018133163, -0.045822687447071075, -0.02635146491229534, -0.04617714509367943, -0.025973763316869736, 0.031464628875255585, -0.016274863854050636, -0.015672022476792336, 0.03285866230726242, 0.025530222803354263, 0.015848873183131218, 0.0047861249186098576, -0.02099638432264328, 0.016260389238595963, -0.041232313960790634, 0.02807747572660446, 0.014257394708693027, 0.0397905558347702, 0.018935294821858406, 0.030229240655899048, 0.0033117143902927637, 0.005512451287358999, 0.024905042722821236, -0.018220631405711174, -0.08485908061265945, 0.06140165403485298, 0.012355883605778217, -0.02506786398589611, -0.05323226749897003, -0.020556386560201645, 0.025910336524248123, 0.0228220596909523, 0.022154882550239563, -0.020603960379958153, 0.0015327585861086845, -0.05039379000663757, 0.0035918622743338346, -0.03239031508564949, -0.03563831001520157, -0.039225127547979355, 0.03021078184247017, -0.022702818736433983, -0.02909909561276436, 0.02879251167178154, 0.028861628845334053, -0.013732599094510078, -0.01668396405875683, -0.02482607401907444, 0.014593054540455341, -0.0021713445894420147, 0.0403444729745388, 0.031005337834358215, 0.018354292958974838, 0.020252320915460587, 0.035255856812000275, -0.0004864619404543191, 0.04517287015914917, 0.052965257316827774, -0.02990230917930603, -0.0037688049487769604, -0.04466252401471138, -0.014446857385337353, -0.014195851050317287, 0.05331490561366081, -0.02807607874274254, 0.0025857379660010338, 0.001857880619354546, 0.0256249587982893, 0.0033220655750483274, 0.03709122911095619, 0.058378078043460846, 0.014326191507279873, 0.018088748678565025, -0.019469741731882095, -0.004601802211254835, -0.03145085275173187, -0.016018357127904892, 0.015097525902092457, 0.03046240843832493, -0.01442855503410101, -0.03267465531826019, 0.049720652401447296, -0.01544526033103466, -0.010385042987763882, -0.040836401283741, 0.004393952898681164, -0.005857557523995638, 0.029306819662451744, -0.003465988440439105, 0.018779145553708076, 0.04575405269861221, 0.03589444234967232, 0.03224516287446022, 0.032363805919885635, -0.057297028601169586, -0.01109746191650629, 0.027904527261853218, 0.04145605117082596, -0.037954188883304596, -0.024432102218270302, -0.08372817933559418, -0.017244402319192886, 0.06019023433327675, -0.04647909104824066, 0.0007997062057256699, -0.006388419773429632, 0.0009692904422990978, -0.013112388551235199, -0.0202043317258358, -0.049280814826488495, 0.020104611292481422, 0.022982001304626465, 0.017495982348918915, -0.015449265949428082, -0.024620158597826958, -0.04428448528051376, -0.027429819107055664, 0.0423043854534626, 0.11664190143346786, -0.008949823677539825, -0.0026588677428662777, 0.004197942558676004, 0.0006538227899000049, -0.021748753264546394, -0.06390068680047989, 0.029705526307225227, 0.008172598667442799, 0.030649175867438316, 0.03302406519651413, -0.03483792394399643, -0.031795039772987366, 0.021437274292111397, 0.005387214478105307, -0.004769268445670605, 0.015020188875496387, 0.011233191937208176, 0.038277700543403625, 0.030647510662674904, 0.008139150217175484, 0.060019370168447495, 0.013530028983950615, -0.016714679077267647, -0.01717214286327362, -0.03842880576848984, 0.010298509150743484, -0.04267978295683861, -0.03845710679888725, -0.03216908127069473, 0.014863008633255959, -0.026719747111201286, 0.01724492944777012, -0.018269389867782593, 0.01621156930923462, -0.005502102430909872, -0.037809208035469055, -0.006232764571905136, 0.020278511568903923, -0.016089316457509995, 0.0029092985205352306, -0.014555618166923523, -0.03273947164416313, 0.0051083434373140335, 0.0038690660148859024, 0.026888348162174225, -0.0038725407794117928, 0.003737278748303652, 0.0006483871256932616, -0.0267143826931715, 0.02599855698645115, -0.03763556852936745, -0.021822504699230194, -0.025241171941161156, -0.007450819946825504, -0.014787259511649609, 0.011343181133270264, 0.03684965893626213, 0.014870395883917809, -0.02502094954252243, -0.014097708277404308, 0.01680668443441391, 0.0017783252988010645, 0.038015130907297134, -0.01583716832101345, 0.037978291511535645, -0.014335216023027897, -0.023632623255252838, -0.09504051506519318, -0.037749502807855606, 0.009124758653342724, 0.004111278336495161, -0.026933463290333748, -0.06714898347854614, -0.04321683943271637, 0.02659064158797264, -0.021734051406383514, 0.014129298739135265, 0.034311629831790924, -0.008497824892401695, -0.02829808183014393, -0.017580116167664528, -0.012163707986474037, 0.07289508730173111, -0.01202390156686306, 0.011474821716547012, 0.00030593021074309945, -0.05128339305520058, -0.008668116293847561, -0.003981208894401789, 0.06880645453929901, -0.028401924297213554, 0.011056700721383095, -0.008452482521533966, -0.027396881952881813, 0.032958146184682846, -0.04789774864912033, -0.024182911962270737, 0.01677384227514267, 0.008456496521830559, 0.014501243829727173, -0.01694296859204769, -0.007208823226392269, -0.02550581283867359, -0.015868403017520905, -0.015860524028539658, 0.020597808063030243, -0.03244052827358246, -0.041421882808208466, -0.005521025974303484, 0.007022594567388296, 0.01211557351052761, 0.007420244161039591, 0.06706295162439346, -0.013691465370357037, 0.01600199192762375, -0.009892202913761139, 0.0060113659128546715, 0.01094750128686428, -0.015445001423358917, -0.00500988494604826, 0.02316911704838276, -0.010105719789862633, -0.033904388546943665, -0.03265031427145004, -0.0752168819308281, -0.0303147342056036, 0.03202804923057556, 0.005968497134745121, 0.030299268662929535, 0.028958985581994057, -0.007329955697059631, 0.012642258778214455, 0.00021425927116069943, 0.013596146367490292, 0.020795177668333054, -0.004195765126496553, 0.052205462008714676, 0.0028785066679120064, -0.019660884514451027, 0.05028124526143074, 0.06849692016839981, 0.016691047698259354, 0.04662517458200455, -0.00876304879784584, 0.020082222297787666, 0.03835410997271538, -0.002756904112175107, -0.04771300405263901, 0.04868341237306595, -0.04784844070672989, 0.03919626772403717, -0.015213506296277046, -0.04135682061314583, 0.06438234448432922, 0.03150900453329086, -0.03237149119377136, 0.0060766893438994884, 0.025043582543730736, -0.0359041728079319, 0.002740723779425025, 0.02680380642414093, 0.02864108607172966, 0.047390591353178024, 0.00513329915702343, 0.026226116344332695, -0.007224015425890684, 0.04811754450201988, -0.032430533319711685, -0.03782498836517334, -0.007892973721027374, -0.021678941324353218, -0.03759429603815079, 0.048855796456336975, -0.003911515697836876, -0.020450182259082794, 0.012402042746543884, 0.0031672439072281122, 0.0366031639277935, 0.028661631047725677, -0.004566539544612169, 0.005076889414340258, 0.09883669763803482, -0.011151471175253391, 0.04885316267609596, -0.014370209537446499, -0.031766027212142944, 0.11255215853452682, 0.07382234185934067, 0.051566362380981445, -0.07819199562072754, -0.002675512107089162, -0.005425909534096718, 0.019461143761873245, -0.01058768667280674, -0.011858501471579075, -0.0047856587916612625, 0.0008111117640510201, 0.050064533948898315, 0.05656660348176956, -0.021789470687508583, -0.02188941277563572, 0.00882384181022644, -0.02333485148847103, -0.030255213379859924, 0.0006765227299183607, 0.023943521082401276, -0.02167872153222561, -0.004230877384543419, -0.025840019807219505, 0.028901012614369392, -0.012428169138729572, 0.000056962002418003976, -0.03487124294042587, -0.03923233970999718, 0.0004898338811472058, -0.02150454930961132, -0.05608949065208435, -0.0024725934490561485, 0.04911394044756889, -0.004309820476919413, 0.012716398574411869, -0.0002858906809706241, 0.018603364005684853, -0.03354325890541077, -0.013016823679208755, 0.039644502103328705, 0.03223571553826332, -0.0047858827747404575, 0.010575697757303715, 0.016357412561774254, -0.049281321465969086, -0.07180500030517578, -0.020064465701580048, 0.02269900031387806, -0.02436521276831627, 0.01347555872052908, -0.016817200928926468, 0.02303781732916832, -0.04480071738362312, -0.038660045713186264, -0.022157834842801094, -0.00867551565170288, 0.03456226363778114, -0.016554148867726326, -0.007924823090434074, -0.012096582911908627, 0.05004848167300224, -0.011427181772887707, 0.046344857662916183, -0.009042531251907349, -0.05434998497366905, -0.005008982494473457, -0.01067872904241085, 0.06295531243085861, -0.027206681668758392, -0.034151747822761536, -0.033496443182229996, 0.004355278797447681, -0.009754985570907593, -0.0042444681748747826, -0.002148345345631242, 0.008260125294327736, 0.02190762385725975, 0.017316779121756554, -0.024485904723405838, -0.032549869269132614, -0.08112587779760361, 0.055885300040245056, 0.004466410726308823, 0.03982749208807945, -0.01907263696193695, 0.0034322040155529976, 0.030903417617082596, 0.038149524480104446, 0.04269689321517944, 0.01689065247774124, -0.016793446615338326, 0.0312776044011116, 0.012476281262934208, -0.02838236838579178, -0.028846265748143196, -0.004321650601923466, -0.05780581384897232, -0.02231602557003498, -0.03708484396338463, 0.016788044944405556, 0.0192730650305748, -0.003654052270576358, -0.0008727629319764674, 0.011353090405464172, -0.048678115010261536, 0.0007367810467258096, -0.038168177008628845, -0.021662771701812744, -0.011814008466899395, 0.010953397490084171, 0.005245327018201351, 0.0004632617346942425, 0.019779443740844727, -0.00518779456615448, -0.027929095551371574, 0.031472161412239075, 0.00633195461705327, -0.0043531060218811035, -0.03707275167107582, 0.004968447610735893, -0.00144161784555763, -0.011112495325505733, -0.004279605112969875, 0.014930629171431065, 0.019908923655748367, 0.01697094552218914, 0.014873863197863102, -0.030326183885335922, 0.010536689311265945, -0.005345355719327927, 0.003755503334105015, 0.045010171830654144, 0.008265233598649502, 0.005335685797035694, -0.01236090436577797, 0.03344942256808281, 0.01191157940775156, 0.029096480458974838, -0.012984362430870533, -0.030067946761846542, 0.06250026077032089, -0.027018427848815918, -0.05162041634321213, 0.03624887391924858, 0.006315041799098253, 0.018430331721901894, 0.037062134593725204, -0.02144380286335945, -0.048540450632572174, 0.07045150548219681, 0.01268103439360857, -0.020723288878798485, -0.0221857950091362, -0.03502357006072998, -0.005869664251804352, -0.017478514462709427, -0.007533367723226547, 0.0024016357492655516, 0.003587113693356514, 0.023386210203170776, 0.05844599008560181, -0.006488364655524492, -0.0027867069002240896, 0.03083205036818981, 0.009911095723509789, 0.008710145018994808, 0.026422347873449326, -0.007202307227998972, 0.06624773144721985, 0.017356576398015022, 0.01931816153228283, 0.005724686663597822, -0.01768682152032852, 0.009188024327158928, -0.10201790183782578, 0.0005616475245915353, 0.006471266038715839, -0.006209432613104582, 0.021441997960209846, -0.07701662927865982, -0.033462174236774445, 0.014141445979475975, -0.02628307230770588, -0.005985553376376629, -0.018408123403787613, -0.00011112562788184732, -0.025143519043922424, 0.026808304712176323, 0.0032847460824996233, 0.035553403198719025, 0.04850230738520622, 0.04218703880906105, 0.05603766068816185, 0.00613837456330657, -0.001195774762891233, 0.003992790821939707, -0.03691597282886505, -0.006369393784552813, -0.02049422264099121, -0.037291813641786575, 0.015620226971805096, -0.02219342440366745, 0.003078318201005459, 0.010648922063410282, -0.01074360590428114, 0.0185512937605381, -0.03395763412117958, -0.010654320009052753, 0.03281792253255844, 0.03444722667336464, -0.0042979540303349495, 0.009166196919977665, 0.0023740208707749844, -0.03545239940285683, 0.02386590838432312, 0.007751349359750748, -0.0407642163336277, 0.008130516856908798, 0.04265051335096359, -0.0235819723457098, -0.020714016631245613, 0.03141443058848381, 0.0076729063875973225, -0.05321668088436127, -0.026192449033260345, -0.027475053444504738, 0.05640197545289993, -0.02107148990035057, 0.012457420118153095, -0.04399234801530838, -0.04383515194058418, 0.04122041538357735, -0.016315901651978493, -0.007309144362807274, 0.008922378532588482, 0.004217896144837141, -0.06556584686040878, 0.03195599094033241, 0.008009242825210094, -0.014352201484143734, -0.05841217562556267, -0.030042419210076332, -0.02070644125342369, -0.024281952530145645, 0.0012284463737159967, -0.027605824172496796, -0.04562491551041603, 0.005776916164904833, 0.018348991870880127, 0.014832456596195698, -0.008213553577661514, -0.025001054629683495, -0.032826971262693405, -0.03884013369679451, 0.026310980319976807, -0.0073113529942929745, -0.06554757803678513, -0.055520400404930115, -0.013473737053573132, -0.03757910430431366, 0.018966134637594223, 0.04893874377012253, 0.035449109971523285, -0.02125655859708786, -0.004190984182059765, 0.02736613154411316, 0.060550205409526825, -0.0731426477432251, 0.003106283023953438, -0.020321326330304146, -0.024094756692647934, 0.002815777435898781, 0.00878110434859991, 0.019626691937446594, 0.04178951308131218, 0.008202522061765194, -0.01738930679857731, -0.011790342628955841, -0.00013207229494582862, -0.012973537668585777, -0.01707177795469761, -0.0022585673723369837, -0.027337385341525078, 0.06929177790880203, -0.018549690023064613, 0.016267677769064903, -0.02230670303106308, 0.020008275285363197, -0.03554583713412285, 0.027942867949604988, -0.0315202921628952, -0.03737768903374672, -0.008341128937900066, -0.00612413277849555, -0.0003763360728044063, -0.061675895005464554, -0.01871362142264843, 0.046986453235149384, -0.027142958715558052, -0.0010980735532939434, 0.015784841030836105, 0.02611595019698143, 0.059437572956085205, -0.013646780513226986, 0.024468110874295235, 0.02762199379503727, -0.007478244137018919, 0.029611816629767418, -0.007345610298216343, 0.00587448151782155, -0.02981717512011528, -0.011695638298988342, -0.012253598310053349, -0.012010929174721241, 0.01965816132724285, -0.0019201323157176375, 0.031406059861183167, -0.009936108253896236, -0.04048118367791176, 0.013092013075947762, 0.017807617783546448, 0.039818089455366135, 0.03171693533658981, -0.016884393990039825, 0.05076829344034195, -0.008796241134405136, 0.02683001384139061, -0.040939297527074814, 0.0007470428827218711, -0.0432320199906826, -0.008327373303472996, 0.055027108639478683, 0.031683772802352905, -0.020011795684695244, 0.01640613190829754, 0.004471762105822563, 0.011156170628964901, 0.035972706973552704, -0.04565387964248657, 0.013778693042695522, 0.015576273202896118, -0.002586249727755785, -0.057440582662820816, 0.0014625415205955505, -0.021964946761727333, -0.032273225486278534, 0.01988009177148342, 0.0430104099214077, 0.04908890277147293, 0.013504279777407646, -0.008725220337510109, 0.014068559743463993, 0.07974845916032791, -0.04593738913536072, -0.0070355781354010105, -0.040186807513237, 0.006977105513215065, 0.03752446919679642, -0.016324128955602646 ]
<p>I am comparing energy expenditure outputs from two devices that track physical activity in a free-living setting over 10 days. Doubly labeled water is the accepted criterion measurement for this, but 1) This technique only gives total energy expenditure and 2) I did not use this in my study...</p> <p>Both of the devices I used have previously been validated against DLW. These devices give a lot more information than DLW, namely time spent at specific PA thresholds and number of 'bouts' at each threshold. </p> <p>I would like to assess the level of agreement between the two devices. I know that Bland-Altman plots are commonly used to assess agreement between measuring devices but I am struggling to decide which test to use without a reference/criterion measurement. I would guess that a basic correlation would provide some information but was wondering if anybody could offer some more information and/or guidance for a more sophisticated statistical anaylsis. Maybe a regression / sum of squares would be appropriated?</p> <p>Any help would be much appreciated.</p>
74,055
[ -0.013397468253970146, -0.011108426377177238, -0.04742439463734627, -0.0034798532724380493, 0.050759412348270416, -0.018760893493890762, -0.005009838379919529, -0.06076917052268982, 0.02884400635957718, -0.023666325956583023, 0.03428808972239494, -0.007852651178836823, 0.020205136388540268, 0.023343393579125404, -0.0029013538733124733, -0.01653166301548481, -0.018804041668772697, -0.004570916760712862, 0.03406981751322746, -0.06347543001174927, 0.0013664104044437408, 0.003775530494749546, -0.011286740191280842, -0.0227570328861475, -0.04233876243233681, -0.013501464389264584, 0.031510014086961746, -0.04661184549331665, -0.031627167016267776, 0.02627250924706459, -0.07130217552185059, -0.037575747817754745, -0.023702774196863174, 0.004486271180212498, 0.00684805354103446, -0.01291535422205925, -0.032090652734041214, -0.019026024267077446, -0.058591779321432114, 0.05872255563735962, -0.05264700576663017, 0.019181668758392334, 0.013913780450820923, 0.012674936093389988, -0.02733142487704754, 0.010378995910286903, -0.00010217582166660577, -0.013733061961829662, 0.04024070128798485, -0.06310983747243881, 0.036956265568733215, -0.01502298004925251, 0.06117889657616615, 0.031035562977194786, 0.007448714692145586, 0.02037203125655651, 0.04436352849006653, 0.057688236236572266, 0.02369752898812294, -0.0739038810133934, -0.03567156195640564, -0.011355087161064148, 0.006481927819550037, 0.02179565280675888, -0.017486194148659706, -0.002107147127389908, 0.022954050451517105, -0.014249215833842754, 0.055840864777565, 0.010484402999281883, 0.031591467559337616, 0.006585037335753441, 0.0695355236530304, -0.01019491907209158, 0.0036741243675351143, 0.02124454639852047, -0.012809018604457378, 0.03976867347955704, 0.053845424205064774, 0.05536803975701332, 0.010798892937600613, 0.014752271585166454, 0.0324743315577507, 0.047948893159627914, 0.04052127152681351, -0.017036831006407738, 0.02979479543864727, -0.010745291598141193, -0.004725812468677759, 0.03147496283054352, 0.016781140118837357, 0.0025903794448822737, 0.03334707021713257, 0.02829858288168907, -0.002969963476061821, 0.013943087309598923, -0.027897238731384277, 0.03832017630338669, -0.021671460941433907, -0.04596441611647606, 0.008585412055253983, -0.03228089213371277, 0.012870044447481632, 0.06662491708993912, 0.002308514202013612, -0.012561005540192127, -0.039130400866270065, -0.00489286333322525, -0.012771098874509335, 0.008831034414470196, -0.034025028347969055, -0.0005044942372478545, 0.016478925943374634, 0.018863873556256294, -0.007951080799102783, -0.019562851637601852, -0.019083058461546898, 0.00487138144671917, 0.0811871737241745, 0.03517422080039978, 0.04644172266125679, -0.03370481729507446, 0.001918292255140841, -0.019826795905828476, -0.02758830599486828, 0.00890727061778307, 0.034195221960544586, -0.012118985876441002, -0.03024185821413994, 0.05885540321469307, 0.0038253532256931067, 0.010700410231947899, 0.057222913950681686, -0.023880893364548683, 0.0013795343693345785, 0.01926075853407383, -0.061260778456926346, -0.03498710319399834, 0.04299015924334526, -0.010485745035111904, 0.0003198186168447137, -0.04099556803703308, -0.042904023081064224, 0.01473486889153719, 0.047324080020189285, 0.008518836461007595, 0.03344036266207695, -0.00709513807669282, 0.020637264475226402, -0.0126953748986125, -0.051847998052835464, -0.0037560940254479647, -0.026810957118868828, -0.03298700228333473, -0.003991494420915842, -0.06651239842176437, 0.020673422142863274, 0.02306559309363365, -0.00909428671002388, 0.000999047071672976, 0.048917993903160095, 0.016083326190710068, -0.03684673085808754, -0.013595263473689556, 0.008224043995141983, -0.01920250616967678, 0.04269961267709732, -0.03997392579913139, 0.01579851098358631, -0.017994102090597153, 0.029045145958662033, 0.0487775020301342, 0.04852098226547241, 0.020402658730745316, 0.04511154443025589, -0.0019890661351382732, -0.009275875054299831, -0.010132911615073681, 0.014867213554680347, 0.008164582774043083, -0.04124711826443672, -0.02211649902164936, -0.034617554396390915, -0.028249453753232956, 0.00830384623259306, 0.0453743040561676, -0.013790084049105644, 0.009339611977338791, 0.04657905921339989, -0.025848092511296272, -0.05215388163924217, -0.06781808286905289, 0.002182538388296962, 0.012013754807412624, 0.005759704392403364, 0.027013450860977173, -0.009781887754797935, 0.018898282200098038, -0.02336512692272663, -0.028308037668466568, -0.018688324838876724, 0.012930283322930336, 0.03399055823683739, -0.028928695246577263, 0.007416574750095606, 0.024764200672507286, 0.04081187769770622, -0.02995527721941471, -0.0009705902193672955, -0.04463720694184303, -0.03242891654372215, -0.005746877286583185, -0.052057430148124695, 0.01652391441166401, 0.013062980026006699, -0.003060693619772792, -0.003006354905664921, 0.026400813832879066, -0.024439318105578423, 0.05565175041556358, -0.0069098928943276405, 0.09436336159706116, 0.03911333531141281, -0.04494960606098175, -0.0050095245242118835, 0.027284612879157066, 0.013813012279570103, 0.0014223646139726043, -0.040525585412979126, -0.024125616997480392, -0.02769058384001255, -0.028733858838677406, 0.03632432594895363, -0.007114164065569639, -0.015216381289064884, 0.00714374054223299, 0.03151016682386398, 0.0025157653726637363, -0.0028914690483361483, 0.023205401375889778, 0.019527172669768333, -0.018952280282974243, 0.004269883502274752, 0.08295438438653946, 0.01309998333454132, 0.0010496635222807527, -0.011016801930963993, 0.00048102487926371396, 0.028893161565065384, 0.011784873902797699, 0.008324270136654377, 0.05101613327860832, 0.02333367057144642, 0.038495924323797226, -0.009668138809502125, -0.019944284111261368, 0.033426277339458466, -0.02858852781355381, 0.010256568901240826, 0.02274547889828682, -0.0148838572204113, -0.007901054807007313, 0.016607170924544334, -0.03534969687461853, 0.03768882527947426, 0.026736022904515266, -0.012561304494738579, -0.03163188323378563, 0.01796579547226429, -0.03179655596613884, 0.05957301706075668, -0.05232302099466324, -0.02271150052547455, 0.0028984732925891876, -0.005957537330687046, 0.020072590559720993, 0.022967642173171043, 0.020965643227100372, -0.033503733575344086, 0.020342471078038216, 0.006043700035661459, -0.04325132817029953, -0.010067667812108994, 0.010978663340210915, -0.030695587396621704, -0.033243197947740555, -0.031205687671899796, -0.007859567180275917, 0.03918971121311188, -0.053623832762241364, 0.009778978303074837, 0.03918454051017761, 0.026428908109664917, -0.05310649052262306, -0.020672710612416267, 0.013381573371589184, -0.0030855736695230007, 0.007020517252385616, -0.01698538474738598, 0.04739997163414955, 0.001985228853300214, -0.0789836123585701, 0.023211345076560974, -0.036426372826099396, 0.01808285340666771, -0.017171358689665794, -0.019138986244797707, 0.021824363619089127, -0.022212060168385506, -0.007243338506668806, 0.02188187465071678, -0.034519925713539124, -0.015306071378290653, -0.06034768745303154, -0.1098753958940506, 0.06780699640512466, 0.0026390256825834513, 0.018578384071588516, 0.01073940098285675, -0.00736417667940259, 0.02288699895143509, 0.03466106206178665, -0.04544951021671295, -0.04720216989517212, -0.00303462240844965, -0.028668826445937157, -0.004660019651055336, 0.0024581681936979294, 0.008329296484589577, -0.0034206490963697433, 0.034293267875909805, -0.027078082785010338, 0.013502257876098156, 0.0020998786203563213, 0.010688680224120617, 0.005877802148461342, 0.008650623261928558, 0.0304012019187212, -0.013149632140994072, 0.03251151740550995, 0.029650917276740074, -0.044706813991069794, -0.03712853044271469, -0.011168988421559334, 0.010636684484779835, 0.00013854002463631332, -0.0406661182641983, 0.023111261427402496, -0.009547016583383083, 0.0013954885071143508, -0.03533289581537247, -0.017605800181627274, 0.039919156581163406, -0.026172827929258347, -0.018223829567432404, 0.046829141676425934, 0.06161544471979141, -0.0026170152705162764, 0.024800671264529228, 0.08716709911823273, 0.0464278906583786, 0.0017832444282248616, -0.026650721207261086, -0.028508111834526062, 0.024960651993751526, 0.0017541528213769197, -0.03671924024820328, -0.020363422110676765, 0.052768830209970474, -0.0023136227391660213, 0.029516620561480522, 0.005552354734390974, -0.039216410368680954, 0.0162432212382555, -0.09397781640291214, -0.005997552536427975, -0.010329673066735268, 0.0561990961432457, 0.01671808585524559, 0.03384118527173996, -0.006836907472461462, -0.0243314690887928, -0.021095510572195053, -0.020561298355460167, -0.047205496579408646, 0.03715815022587776, -0.04192429780960083, -0.018823668360710144, 0.07897895574569702, -0.007705010008066893, 0.0076337396167218685, -0.013194707222282887, -0.0038662427105009556, -0.01791124790906906, 0.059242259711027145, -0.040896009653806686, 0.02684609964489937, -0.007616066373884678, -0.02758222445845604, -0.008736697025597095, 0.0001385476643918082, 0.015987005084753036, -0.007348785176873207, 0.012530030682682991, 0.01197321992367506, -0.027021950110793114, -0.04034048318862915, 0.014626062475144863, 0.031720615923404694, 0.009126564487814903, 0.026959525421261787, 0.018155569210648537, 0.03610613942146301, 0.0026645688340067863, -0.022370077669620514, 0.01990392990410328, -0.001412782003171742, 0.0015370456967502832, -0.018019119277596474, -0.05210987478494644, -0.045744284987449646, -0.01291576400399208, 0.016272101551294327, 0.024369487538933754, 0.02490548975765705, -0.011965402401983738, 0.043933164328336716, -0.0007153013139031827, -0.006494749337434769, 0.05482427403330803, 0.05100209638476372, -0.016817279160022736, -0.02375096082687378, -0.04173446074128151, -0.04171275347471237, 0.0053389109671115875, -0.02345683053135872, 0.052538201212882996, 0.022604497149586678, 0.02036214806139469, -0.010293582454323769, 0.06035425886511803, -0.036647506058216095, -0.03801821544766426, 0.01951248198747635, 0.032400138676166534, 0.0489625483751297, -0.0048391795717179775, -0.050850238651037216, 0.010394948534667492, 0.03974127396941185, 0.012030242010951042, 0.01964028738439083, -0.0004700454301200807, -0.0619414821267128, -0.0021912644151598215, 0.04632780700922012, 0.054734013974666595, -0.021100057289004326, -0.015908101573586464, -0.026689013466238976, -0.008874542079865932, 0.022564636543393135, -0.02639860101044178, 0.026206515729427338, 0.02376125194132328, 0.04989852011203766, -0.011141822673380375, 0.00022407903452403843, -0.045804060995578766, -0.011665734462440014, -0.0035242941230535507, 0.043867725878953934, -0.04424700513482094, -0.02507246658205986, -0.007746975403279066, 0.02264677733182907, -0.0056773084215819836, 0.053568217903375626, -0.0016229753382503986, 0.0007414621068164706, 0.05961780250072479, -0.001872886554338038, -0.009757560677826405, -0.059523019939661026, -0.01806940697133541, 0.014387036673724651, 0.029426993802189827, 0.025679156184196472, -0.0006753363995812833, -0.028638197109103203, -0.02121780626475811, -0.018293173983693123, -0.029663167893886566, -0.01617712900042534, -0.020050156861543655, 0.06051849573850632, 0.02695203758776188, 0.024015411734580994, 0.06075504422187805, 0.01587805710732937, -0.020431535318493843, -0.01850133389234543, -0.016290122643113136, 0.000559673469979316, -0.01559381652623415, -0.004662292543798685, -0.062372516840696335, 0.0013445800868794322, -0.019710471853613853, 0.014036712236702442, -0.04747801646590233, 0.017642399296164513, 0.006022860761731863, -0.050791483372449875, -0.019031569361686707, 0.0043051284737885, 0.0006439089775085449, 0.018539056181907654, 0.02385471574962139, 0.021912196651101112, 0.013219816610217094, 0.014494172297418118, 0.006051676347851753, -0.02493511326611042, -0.024118266999721527, 0.021296724677085876, -0.03783935680985451, 0.013989407569169998, -0.009080817922949791, 0.006226851139217615, 0.01981886476278305, 0.0034025246277451515, 0.021919885650277138, -0.0071601164527237415, 0.04025747999548912, -0.015159313566982746, -0.07788160443305969, -0.055296391248703, 0.016452206298708916, -0.018356407061219215, 0.028995998203754425, -0.04357273131608963, 0.03372150659561157, -0.014661717228591442, -0.019930168986320496, -0.03989802300930023, -0.023043101653456688, 0.029248254373669624, 0.0006611958961002529, -0.000996626098640263, -0.01818014495074749, 0.03959476202726364, -0.02740638703107834, -0.02030351012945175, -0.013456914573907852, 0.0705936998128891, -0.023303097113966942, 0.005358703900128603, -0.020093772560358047, 0.010540054179728031, 0.06011740490794182, 0.0049322014674544334, -0.00890676025301218, -0.01733246073126793, 0.014292282052338123, -0.05944459140300751, -0.016400890424847603, -0.0017009394941851497, -0.03072226233780384, 0.019692590460181236, -0.01669301651418209, 0.006615842692553997, 0.0743231251835823, -0.044573333114385605, -0.04451055824756622, 0.015978578478097916, -0.01006371807307005, -0.012642690911889076, -0.021884825080633163, 0.04419802129268646, -0.020952817052602768, 0.016893597319722176, 0.007985931821167469, -0.007327791769057512, -0.04034658148884773, 0.0053411731496453285, -0.009000438265502453, -0.02904408611357212, -0.04281765595078468, -0.03167420253157616, 0.06083424761891365, 0.04360238090157509, 0.009037923067808151, 0.0363960787653923, -0.019027652218937874, 0.0497138537466526, -0.01760832965373993, 0.016037888824939728, 0.018912117928266525, 0.0009760382818058133, -0.030713023617863655, -0.04450599104166031, -0.036859180778265, -0.0009230374125763774, 0.03311484307050705, 0.024825148284435272, 0.04967157542705536, 0.03259978070855141, -0.018066510558128357, 0.017387690022587776, -0.03914370760321617, -0.007547819521278143, 0.00411517359316349, -0.01040178257972002, 0.05868814140558243, -0.02525145374238491, -0.04572603851556778, 0.054202597588300705, 0.025340400636196136, -0.00501945149153471, 0.05144326761364937, 0.04176991060376167, 0.014617111533880234, 0.014205211773514748, -0.040129322558641434, -0.07352302968502045, 0.000546737399417907, -0.04613365978002548, -0.007772225886583328, -0.01972920633852482, -0.040973931550979614, 0.04705417528748512, 0.02356867492198944, -0.017496904358267784, -0.04086802899837494, 0.006975898984819651, -0.056263066828250885, 0.011200761422514915, 0.005844874307513237, -0.012934673577547073, -0.015533781610429287, -0.018296580761671066, 0.05778416618704796, 0.015689058229327202, 0.04715733602643013, -0.005457456223666668, -0.051414672285318375, 0.007046426180750132, 0.021278351545333862, -0.06353922188282013, 0.06049737334251404, -0.03389932960271835, -0.030438750982284546, -0.010720688849687576, -0.014255381189286709, -0.014917551539838314, 0.002860115608200431, 0.013437421061098576, 0.01688355766236782, 0.024973945692181587, -0.01896090805530548, 0.01260534580796957, 0.01725868508219719, -0.013310916721820831, 0.1408672034740448, 0.04669920727610588, 0.01729290373623371, -0.047500524669885635, 0.02682788297533989, 0.03376204892992973, 0.06335730105638504, 0.010692300274968147, 0.00655769556760788, 0.03812089189887047, -0.00500968424603343, 0.040625978261232376, -0.015815721824765205, -0.0331091433763504, -0.01855330355465412, 0.06368555873632431, 0.013990787789225578, -0.020025234669446945, 0.08234448730945587, 0.0051784333772957325, 0.010542248375713825, -0.019758308306336403, 0.014278464019298553, 0.03709122911095619, 0.04489641264081001, -0.017568740993738174, -0.005718001164495945, -0.037116363644599915, 0.015637677162885666, 0.02620769664645195, -0.04763998091220856, -0.019425269216299057, -0.0048139081336557865, 0.03758539631962776, -0.009131226688623428, 0.017287544906139374, -0.016717590391635895, -0.04023965448141098, -0.017214937135577202, 0.029845260083675385, 0.048174623399972916, -0.039760809391736984, 0.002128568710759282, 0.014977085404098034, -0.04105830565094948, -0.01566425710916519, -0.005893079563975334, 0.016000067815184593, -0.027751950547099113, -0.0009136575390584767, -0.001982002053409815, -0.008719046600162983, 0.009047228842973709, -0.03784571960568428, 0.0073099201545119286, -0.003428894327953458, 0.036241449415683746, -0.018841994926333427, -0.021683795377612114, -0.03209225833415985, 0.010616393759846687, 0.006574572529643774, 0.02717926912009716, 0.010767280124127865, 0.002357272896915674, -0.01003123726695776, 0.017824919894337654, 0.03389642760157585, -0.003852828172966838, 0.005653512664139271, 0.018285483121871948, -0.0012946182396262884, -0.061400048434734344, 0.04324819892644882, 0.029588589444756508, 0.019834542647004128, 0.04511191323399544, 0.05862900987267494, -0.02049855701625347, -0.02158018760383129, -0.06283905357122421, -0.019323593005537987, -0.04181838408112526, -0.018178796395659447, -0.01901879720389843, 0.010619430802762508, 0.03203636035323143, 0.016944384202361107, 0.02063322439789772, 0.024529991671442986, 0.007323404774069786, 0.02834336645901203, 0.008422705344855785, -0.024831773713231087, 0.003322382690384984, -0.003848298918455839, -0.032533805817365646, -0.021418044343590736, -0.04678109288215637, 0.034176163375377655, 0.005712816491723061, 0.04119841754436493, -0.011141550727188587, -0.008877275511622429, 0.009761069901287556, 0.0014825788093730807, -0.020397227257490158, -0.03787960484623909, -0.025965360924601555, -0.020903686061501503, 0.004138173535466194, -0.012462275102734566, -0.013519302010536194, -0.05509820953011513, -0.023097548633813858, -0.041516225785017014, -0.03109278716146946, -0.015557453036308289, 0.002300941850990057, -0.05735491216182709, 0.0025866981595754623, -0.003992249723523855, 0.008076667785644531, -0.043148223310709, -0.03976380452513695, 0.0382579080760479, 0.03998703882098198, -0.03407057747244835, 0.019849158823490143, -0.02587943710386753, -0.03168017789721489, 0.06803470104932785, -0.0034181757364422083, -0.03681813180446625, 0.013979891315102577, 0.010494304820895195, -0.007130844984203577, 0.04573144018650055, -0.002946183318272233, 0.00035613615182228386, 0.046898722648620605, -0.04022221267223358, 0.0074798609130084515, 0.04810713604092598, 0.00007055165769997984, 0.0055733234621584415, 0.024869387969374657, -0.03953704237937927, 0.022069940343499184, 0.029977651312947273, -0.0210841353982687, -0.025037268176674843, -0.004137152340263128, -0.002438942203298211, -0.006539445370435715, 0.03676162287592888, -0.0012696634512394667, 0.007099282927811146, -0.0029176000971347094, 0.024766694754362106, 0.019470542669296265, 0.018159279599785805, -0.022537730634212494, -0.03165625035762787, -0.07238940894603729, -0.023054704070091248, 0.010249009355902672, -0.04036680981516838, 0.019502785056829453, 0.06368710100650787, -0.019767744466662407, 0.02236536145210266, -0.04803864285349846, -0.020329365506768227, -0.047724273055791855, -0.010242738761007786, -0.03513835743069649, 0.049585770815610886, 0.018571801483631134, -0.051418352872133255, 0.00860641710460186, 0.033866193145513535, -0.036532193422317505, -0.009387245401740074, 0.017833266407251358, 0.03182121366262436, -0.03732024505734444, 0.018409281969070435, -0.019468629732728004, 0.013943157158792019, 0.012514854781329632, 0.031561657786369324, 0.0164331067353487, 0.022985806688666344, -0.029027406126260757, -0.04646998271346092, -0.027331091463565826, 0.024664370343089104, 0.03533071652054787, -0.05008223280310631, 0.004829235374927521, -0.05028899759054184, -0.029036881402134895, 0.010619518347084522, -0.03998884931206703, 0.05116725340485573, -0.0011159676359966397, 0.003119184635579586, 0.00942984875291586, 0.05725228041410446, 0.01738929934799671, -0.024935726076364517, -0.031509608030319214, 0.02397710457444191, 0.00445306533947587, 0.01596231199800968, -0.01864856667816639, 0.024293173104524612, 0.010600652545690536, -0.008382388390600681, -0.02648678608238697, 0.05201857537031174, -0.0009901945013552904, -0.013302459381520748, 0.030458888038992882, -0.027646396309137344, 0.06216821447014809, -0.0310503076761961, -0.010841378942131996, -0.042950574308633804, -0.009798689745366573, 0.046114128082990646, -0.00037160454667173326, -0.02148364670574665, 0.006578008644282818, 0.025909949094057083, -0.011819213628768921, 0.006536190863698721, -0.0036684463266283274, -0.022153450176119804, -0.03196122124791145, -0.016338055953383446, -0.05854901671409607, -0.00914404820650816, -0.03288668766617775, -0.008686927147209644, -0.03661663830280304, 0.020019669085741043, -0.027050893753767014, 0.018309054896235466, 0.05837559700012207, -0.012351500801742077, -0.01098933257162571, -0.07075653225183487, 0.07124192267656326, 0.03440096229314804, -0.014450881630182266, -0.018783221021294594, 0.009225409477949142, -0.04502398893237114, 0.008887852542102337, 0.05737672373652458, 0.0051763770170509815, -0.044633641839027405, -0.02475230023264885, 0.0031685298308730125, -0.007167860399931669, -0.02975999005138874, 0.055732227861881256, -0.03777679428458214, -0.057688284665346146, 0.003716924460604787, -0.00907874759286642, -0.0027024864684790373, -0.02478882297873497, 0.05924969166517258, -0.05953948199748993, -0.011144181713461876, 0.0071139768697321415, 0.003389674238860607, 0.06377238780260086, 0.02095959149301052, 0.015188069082796574, 0.023329079151153564, 0.003727298928424716, 0.04823664575815201, 0.05175056681036949, -0.022972090169787407, -0.034548040479421616, 0.05177095904946327, 0.020752741023898125, 0.032896559685468674, 0.0035793709103018045, 0.015486380085349083, -0.019328825175762177, -0.05922582745552063, -0.01830163784325123, 0.019180286675691605, 0.03382939472794533, -0.005633741617202759, 0.057639945298433304, 0.07572321593761444, -0.0034756462555378675, -0.006276255939155817, 0.07936960458755493, -0.003252946073189378, 0.03927063196897507, 0.014650318771600723, 0.022227171808481216, 0.05212145298719406, 0.024133766070008278, 0.002680498640984297, 0.03361846134066582, -0.030937405303120613, 0.05911199375987053, 0.00530230300500989, 0.015562701970338821, -0.02353394590318203, -0.007032962050288916, 0.005596551112830639, 0.020156588405370712, -0.0188611913472414, 0.00835463311523199, 0.0072840917855501175, 0.037562739104032516, -0.030937068164348602, -0.019314123317599297, -0.048566848039627075, -0.0401117168366909, 0.0017381582874804735, 0.004453309345990419, 0.02096162736415863, 0.02996348962187767, -0.006689131259918213, 0.03322223946452141, -0.012025517411530018, -0.002535119652748108, -0.006291450932621956, 0.003930271603167057, 0.035371020436286926, -0.03172828257083893, -0.0002022881672019139, -0.03779641538858414, 0.0003259672084823251, -0.009153390303254128, 0.0014260526513680816, 0.021211382001638412, 0.05668258294463158, -0.0013312692753970623, 0.009956940077245235, -0.022664261981844902, 0.010137073695659637, 0.03508235141634941, -0.041535716503858566, -0.018504364416003227, -0.022138582542538643, 0.01657983474433422, 0.06696251779794693, 0.014893186278641224 ]
<p>I've used chi-square analysis in school, but was absent for the lesson, and I never quite got the hang of it. I've been successful with it in the past, but now I'm trying to use percentage values, and I'm not getting the answers I'm expecting. I'm doing a survey and comparing my findings with national averages, but when I use percentages (such as the percent of participants between the ages of 21 and 29) I get understandably tiny numbers (2.3% is 0.023). If I'm using percentages for the expected value, should it matter?</p> <p>Ex: Chi² for 21–29 age group is $(.084 - 0.1642)^2 / 0.1642 = .039187$</p> <p>The total chi-square value is 0.1368, which is much smaller than the 0.5% chi squared table value for 8 degrees of freedom, 17.535, but the numbers seem way off. Do I have to find the whole numbers?</p>
74,056
[ -0.0005361014627851546, -0.03923841193318367, 0.008351851254701614, -0.025522170588374138, 0.05781006067991257, -0.0007644667057320476, -0.02829061634838581, -0.05528490990400314, -0.01004877407103777, -0.015922170132398605, 0.009159527719020844, 0.047367166727781296, 0.0179570484906435, 0.02017519250512123, 0.009020800702273846, 0.02904008887708187, -0.04745925962924957, 0.01175384595990181, -0.00964758824557066, 0.01843150332570076, 0.004521956667304039, 0.004257583990693092, -0.0052777305245399475, -0.025454126298427582, -0.037741098552942276, 0.052039984613657, 0.04085490480065346, -0.04643206298351288, 0.03993348404765129, 0.07533185929059982, -0.04905291646718979, -0.021481633186340332, 0.028735326603055, -0.0011466501746326685, 0.031218543648719788, 0.0009271231247112155, -0.03026876039803028, -0.0005151943769305944, -0.010825705714523792, 0.0613759346306324, -0.05841247737407684, 0.011243611574172974, 0.007783383596688509, 0.0016638032393530011, -0.029235422611236572, 0.019266696646809578, 0.010685522109270096, -0.0612601712346077, 0.0359681062400341, -0.05611228942871094, 0.07389885932207108, 0.018601829186081886, 0.03923427686095238, 0.03271395340561867, 0.007650626823306084, -0.017455393448472023, 0.059064630419015884, 0.015719467774033546, -0.025212833657860756, -0.05053159222006798, -0.006770667154341936, -0.04389013350009918, -0.008639758452773094, -0.0377793088555336, -0.028486965224146843, 0.011020836420357227, -0.016526494175195694, -0.010671655647456646, 0.05126618221402168, -0.004563702270388603, 0.014576517976820469, 0.05595625191926956, 0.06132197380065918, -0.013261470012366772, -0.0009450066718272865, -0.05134116858243942, 0.039596956223249435, 0.03676069527864456, 0.026717735454440117, 0.04688514024019241, -0.009059681557118893, 0.008812139742076397, 0.03071172721683979, 0.01873089373111725, 0.033361323177814484, -0.024156490340828896, 0.07972276210784912, -0.02587212063372135, -0.000861062784679234, 0.010588436387479305, -0.03253981098532677, 0.009213420562446117, 0.02162148803472519, 0.006816249340772629, -0.0463736467063427, 0.03605315089225769, -0.023778945207595825, 0.04272788017988205, 0.005869640968739986, -0.032343197613954544, -0.022216441109776497, -0.010922133922576904, 0.038091372698545456, 0.03542080521583557, -0.06542926281690598, 0.005775789730250835, -0.050368987023830414, -0.006858511827886105, 0.000057962373830378056, -0.04771677777171135, 0.007070633582770824, 0.03496367484331131, 0.00113147241063416, 0.02467385306954384, 0.016574036329984665, -0.017687134444713593, -0.027070194482803345, -0.008202919736504555, 0.04539639502763748, 0.04130113869905472, 0.05126657336950302, -0.04717631638050079, 0.013050741516053677, -0.020132403820753098, -0.03276499733328819, 0.02790883556008339, -0.0013633001362904906, -0.013832448050379753, -0.06300849467515945, 0.016207808628678322, -0.005645113531500101, -0.013655690476298332, 0.02799835056066513, 0.01616872102022171, 0.012953698635101318, -0.018289096653461456, -0.08766450732946396, -0.024125028401613235, 0.03264141082763672, -0.009914480149745941, -0.021394828334450722, -0.10122276097536087, -0.008685184642672539, 0.028131013736128807, 0.06952968239784241, 0.0006024723988957703, 0.022817960008978844, -0.002429411979392171, 0.0394454300403595, 0.030780784785747528, -0.029028842225670815, 0.00745724281296134, -0.04666345939040184, -0.03950612619519234, 0.006536291912198067, -0.04735308885574341, 0.04146115481853485, 0.030817324295639992, 0.029238758608698845, -0.029007084667682648, 0.016825690865516663, -0.00153196114115417, -0.04306009039282799, 0.006886864546686411, 0.01393633522093296, -0.028767425566911697, 0.08085277676582336, 0.009898059070110321, 0.003091593971475959, 0.02718513086438179, 0.014258341863751411, -0.00553278299048543, 0.0219179205596447, 0.030881555750966072, 0.05563569813966751, 0.02634470723569393, 0.00157002336345613, -0.028053009882569313, 0.010150007903575897, 0.0031698073726147413, -0.09271847456693649, -0.009839281439781189, -0.01748093031346798, 0.02710866555571556, -0.002805182943120599, 0.04003830626606941, -0.005779379978775978, -0.046401720494031906, 0.02960154227912426, -0.03227103129029274, -0.05300375819206238, -0.05996973440051079, 0.024308502674102783, 0.004965146072208881, -0.035061098635196686, -0.01105227880179882, 0.03895701467990875, 0.025316815823316574, -0.03204021975398064, -0.034307826310396194, -0.00564299151301384, -0.00045548920752480626, 0.019313957542181015, -0.06090085580945015, -0.002159180585294962, 0.05022767558693886, 0.011781317181885242, -0.030261019244790077, 0.0571025013923645, -0.02233710326254368, -0.05471719056367874, -0.00392181845381856, -0.0343681275844574, 0.012690105475485325, -0.011201879940927029, -0.018507879227399826, -0.025474268943071365, 0.005829875357449055, -0.026161009445786476, 0.041481565684080124, -0.04782958701252937, 0.10561183840036392, 0.04155893623828888, 0.0014852926833555102, 0.0021865915041416883, 0.006049953866750002, 0.027064455673098564, 0.019104136154055595, -0.009743114933371544, -0.00016002151824068278, -0.07641036063432693, 0.0015380681725218892, 0.021887531504034996, -0.02482803910970688, -0.04637796804308891, -0.008552041836082935, 0.026984918862581253, 0.03150567784905434, 0.013252022676169872, 0.016304733231663704, -0.014414263889193535, -0.019998881965875626, -0.0012827395694330335, 0.012610448524355888, -0.03772289305925369, 0.01584656722843647, 0.03249140456318855, 0.028296617791056633, 0.013661163859069347, 0.03200463578104973, -0.02561708725988865, 0.04389970749616623, -0.025564899668097496, 0.005114457570016384, -0.016882121562957764, -0.010509256273508072, 0.03229059278964996, -0.02617652341723442, 0.00036295957397669554, 0.014882105402648449, 0.006599817890673876, -0.012602513656020164, -0.016138089820742607, -0.00872643943876028, 0.02124391682446003, 0.04214536398649216, -0.05841517820954323, 0.016163581982254982, 0.008276257663965225, 0.004755686968564987, -0.01202527154237032, -0.041464950889348984, -0.03669289872050285, -0.0364355631172657, 0.00865771435201168, 0.0474369116127491, -0.006611388176679611, 0.04246445745229721, 0.0038430788554251194, -0.028880717232823372, -0.016484715044498444, -0.017016734927892685, 0.0023312668781727552, 0.008552384562790394, -0.068359375, -0.018435999751091003, -0.031744278967380524, 0.0045970166102051735, -0.008225342258810997, -0.00007367375656031072, 0.009261907078325748, 0.0037897522561252117, 0.01599787175655365, -0.03982849046587944, 0.012096277438104153, -0.008838378824293613, 0.002703955862671137, -0.011854387819766998, 0.01632758416235447, 0.006364726927131414, -0.0027507904451340437, 0.009666411206126213, 0.061808325350284576, -0.02378063090145588, -0.03852778673171997, -0.02764621004462242, 0.020975075662136078, 0.03131003677845001, -0.005696648266166449, -0.010861099697649479, 0.002440218348056078, 0.0014769688714295626, -0.011666477657854557, -0.05027439817786217, -0.06338920444250107, 0.005589034408330917, 0.022703083232045174, 0.020676465705037117, 0.03174149990081787, 0.005035687237977982, 0.05955134332180023, 0.007597119081765413, -0.0349685363471508, 0.008444835431873798, -0.010683169588446617, -0.038120757788419724, -0.02722984366118908, 0.01241382397711277, 0.04955693706870079, -0.034902386367321014, 0.02852841652929783, -0.0473489873111248, 0.0339173898100853, 0.052472010254859924, 0.016797294840216637, -0.006153075024485588, 0.0086724404245615, 0.0006538704037666321, -0.012758472934365273, 0.02351355366408825, 0.02293909154832363, -0.033113785088062286, 0.005241568200290203, 0.026501677930355072, 0.0496942400932312, 0.020286614075303078, -0.0532064363360405, 0.04044258967041969, -0.03819037228822708, 0.002536076819524169, -0.051979802548885345, 0.02567915804684162, 0.013422125019133091, -0.004843591246753931, 0.0071694678626954556, -0.0025485060177743435, 0.03360555320978165, -0.008377039805054665, 0.00414831330999732, 0.06752234697341919, 0.015157537534832954, 0.02455875463783741, -0.004656131844967604, -0.011655358597636223, -0.0022334072273224592, 0.029491305351257324, -0.003925430588424206, -0.01777174510061741, 0.03426429256796837, 0.10174065828323364, 0.035602763295173645, -0.030680326744914055, -0.027243686839938164, 0.008348018862307072, -0.08794166892766953, 0.014089434407651424, -0.03909267857670784, 0.04675070568919182, -0.004134854767471552, 0.052233465015888214, -0.02267427183687687, -0.010995172895491123, -0.014909043908119202, -0.000004390708909340901, -0.03966253623366356, 0.04306866228580475, -0.027359209954738617, -0.01984834112226963, -0.000006933479198778514, -0.0230361707508564, 0.03185122832655907, -0.019208382815122604, -0.01543030422180891, -0.0072915200144052505, 0.018042517825961113, 0.004269569180905819, 0.02126276306807995, -0.032858021557331085, 0.0352599136531353, -0.005627214442938566, 0.04175517335534096, 0.01762397773563862, -0.0007506228284910321, -0.004848569631576538, 0.05071841552853584, -0.001215405878610909, -0.0072224196046590805, -0.007605553139001131, 0.025385782122612, 0.036622658371925354, 0.05728724226355553, 0.022001901641488075, -0.01245449110865593, -0.03548417240381241, 0.017837900668382645, -0.014585542492568493, 0.04371173307299614, 0.031922247260808945, -0.01875079795718193, -0.02432497777044773, -0.018671145662665367, -0.030236274003982544, -0.016961535438895226, 0.03702160716056824, -0.00134137028362602, 0.022609088569879532, 0.07213213294744492, 0.005610763095319271, -0.03221650421619415, 0.03677895665168762, 0.03974773734807968, -0.028096798807382584, -0.024297548457980156, -0.05025218427181244, 0.004673851188272238, -0.048178695142269135, -0.023683015257120132, -0.005233362782746553, -0.0062346505001187325, 0.01771099492907524, -0.011492625810205936, 0.03162049874663353, -0.011191883124411106, -0.03416595980525017, 0.013815272599458694, 0.00011087644088547677, 0.0523025207221508, 0.002730574458837509, -0.03837944567203522, 0.012745607644319534, 0.06413519382476807, 0.02944779396057129, 0.016135066747665405, 0.018155589699745178, -0.06427495181560516, 0.002079587196931243, 0.02176721952855587, 0.03712144121527672, -0.04280894249677658, -0.013389918953180313, -0.03978356346487999, 0.020732656121253967, 0.02815997786819935, -0.03332262858748436, 0.030025077983736992, -0.02345537766814232, 0.004073039162904024, -0.03246040269732475, -0.02053890936076641, -0.024057114496827126, -0.006313974503427744, -0.030580362305045128, 0.03483496606349945, -0.021336272358894348, -0.030903620645403862, -0.04242204874753952, 0.02571728639304638, 0.03432229161262512, 0.05913548171520233, -0.0008921604021452367, -0.037920039147138596, 0.01594329997897148, 0.043424077332019806, -0.0019848798401653767, -0.05545244738459587, 0.008765137754380703, -0.014964479021728039, 0.019342971965670586, 0.03672385960817337, -0.02540767751634121, -0.04282698780298233, 0.03097049705684185, 0.019000284373760223, -0.024139156565070152, -0.014566835947334766, -0.03197014331817627, 0.041666578501462936, 0.008426022715866566, 0.034237150102853775, 0.06603007763624191, 0.02982863038778305, -0.03116169385612011, -0.00040887302020564675, -0.03444632142782211, 0.014810954220592976, 0.001093236031010747, -0.013621514663100243, -0.05186186730861664, -0.017712291330099106, -0.007169280666857958, 0.020361587405204773, -0.015556136146187782, 0.04997287690639496, -0.04135619476437569, 0.008513009175658226, -0.010439100675284863, 0.021072693169116974, 0.01762424036860466, 0.04083734005689621, 0.0409945473074913, 0.03786835819482803, 0.010247420519590378, -0.013229702599346638, 0.03700792044401169, -0.02415577508509159, -0.01025461871176958, 0.010908612050116062, -0.031727880239486694, 0.0211300328373909, -0.06013863906264305, -0.04812566190958023, -0.007734691724181175, -0.03877608850598335, 0.02927326411008835, -0.03749982267618179, 0.012377126142382622, -0.01550059113651514, -0.03673763945698738, -0.019017623737454414, -0.009548326954245567, 0.010887050069868565, 0.08243879675865173, -0.027910880744457245, 0.017763784155249596, 0.015518194995820522, 0.006603713613003492, -0.054508086293935776, -0.051026638597249985, -0.008022712543606758, -0.00040515552973374724, -0.03455568104982376, -0.026693932712078094, -0.02282385714352131, -0.0013546119444072247, -0.03804757818579674, 0.006368229631334543, 0.039158426225185394, 0.018879158422350883, 0.023318132385611534, -0.011421908624470234, 0.009827244095504284, 0.09931059926748276, -0.01845899410545826, -0.029114332050085068, -0.002289737109094858, -0.014171641319990158, -0.01548963412642479, -0.005897955037653446, 0.043059155344963074, -0.050123345106840134, -0.005183732602745295, 0.01970694027841091, -0.01060844212770462, 0.0448928065598011, 0.005095351953059435, -0.03634591028094292, 0.015227985568344593, 0.014526898972690105, 0.015843279659748077, -0.005940084811300039, 0.007701215799897909, 0.00437981216236949, -0.013388088904321194, 0.013420885428786278, 0.005983341485261917, -0.04200856015086174, -0.006621425971388817, 0.01995239406824112, -0.011686110869050026, 0.0025749285705387592, -0.020789992064237595, 0.057549890130758286, -0.036076661199331284, -0.011099793948233128, -0.011888707056641579, -0.02166924811899662, 0.04554429650306702, 0.04645560309290886, -0.026395762339234352, 0.028345339000225067, 0.03079923614859581, 0.00006175531598273665, -0.016813185065984726, -0.017399271950125694, 0.014031344093382359, 0.07228650152683258, 0.00493269506841898, 0.0686003789305687, 0.050037458539009094, 0.028943104669451714, 0.016837626695632935, -0.010030661709606647, -0.03503541275858879, -0.0316636897623539, 0.013926070183515549, 0.007675018161535263, -0.023997483775019646, -0.008349072188138962, 0.011649634689092636, 0.011814849451184273, 0.007867468520998955, 0.04596402868628502, 0.040486861020326614, 0.020257581025362015, -0.006524772848933935, 0.025635361671447754, -0.03297913819551468, -0.003140807617455721, -0.009777473285794258, 0.053367730230093, -0.03494814410805702, -0.019306641072034836, 0.057507891207933426, 0.03405594825744629, 0.008443736471235752, -0.017254456877708435, -0.0014410518342629075, -0.006752230692654848, -0.026504425331950188, 0.013243110850453377, -0.020759357139468193, -0.009656712412834167, -0.009485756978392601, 0.04499856382608414, 0.00224590627476573, 0.01608353853225708, -0.016267627477645874, -0.08912912756204605, -0.028171926736831665, -0.00620105117559433, -0.044888220727443695, 0.02971716783940792, 0.014129013754427433, -0.04209215193986893, 0.002318808576092124, -0.029430391266942024, 0.03181765228509903, -0.009008273482322693, 0.047466062009334564, -0.03422074392437935, 0.03887428343296051, 0.009806059300899506, -0.00841261725872755, -0.00991563405841589, -0.004309616982936859, 0.10772590339183807, 0.0452159084379673, -0.01625155657529831, -0.06276073306798935, 0.03135004639625549, -0.05962096527218819, -0.018993716686964035, -0.015247616916894913, -0.016235848888754845, -0.00287642702460289, -0.008043779991567135, 0.05210915952920914, 0.06730051338672638, 0.025669651105999947, -0.02357175387442112, 0.06325127184391022, -0.004328103736042976, -0.06473299860954285, -0.0060239569284021854, 0.02967759221792221, -0.02771156094968319, -0.010404878295958042, -0.029509028419852257, 0.0014357808977365494, 0.0025224911514669657, -0.0158048365265131, -0.01732986606657505, -0.02531632035970688, -0.030320990830659866, -0.02012297324836254, -0.06049853563308716, -0.008931624703109264, 0.018810033798217773, -0.013649716041982174, -0.05082017183303833, 0.004735646303743124, -0.00511660473421216, -0.03162838891148567, 0.002179480157792568, 0.03700225055217743, -0.01696016825735569, 0.027970893308520317, 0.04369616508483887, 0.018166212365031242, -0.0539320707321167, -0.05128822103142738, -0.055160652846097946, 0.04671026021242142, -0.005624481476843357, -0.00323053658939898, -0.024357743561267853, -0.0025693795178085566, -0.021462934091687202, -0.041526589542627335, -0.0011940872063860297, 0.011822651140391827, 0.018556073307991028, -0.027835428714752197, -0.03652863949537277, -0.03630504012107849, 0.024415520951151848, -0.0181579627096653, 0.016108563169836998, 0.03253558278083801, -0.031145552173256874, -0.021922573447227478, -0.011029708199203014, 0.015111355111002922, -0.014983680099248886, 0.00046534472494386137, 0.013401543721556664, -0.0042546275071799755, -0.048406150192022324, 0.03522878885269165, -0.011197438463568687, 0.02591601386666298, 0.04009624943137169, -0.028373485431075096, -0.0077422009781003, -0.015129617415368557, -0.05406740680336952, 0.04838750883936882, -0.02528807520866394, 0.006115153897553682, -0.02671685814857483, -0.021841540932655334, 0.036407262086868286, 0.0031557739712297916, -0.0012706979177892208, 0.03651917353272438, -0.01791529543697834, 0.020290253683924675, 0.007154589053243399, -0.03177550807595253, -0.011324130930006504, -0.010100116021931171, -0.040137019008398056, -0.0015208147233352065, -0.0025900204200297594, 0.0664486289024353, 0.011675913818180561, 0.02105470933020115, 0.007255102973431349, 0.04347090795636177, 0.027163036167621613, 0.011234447360038757, 0.035310860723257065, -0.07029897719621658, -0.011493032798171043, 0.014341683126986027, 0.005342710763216019, -0.03604309260845184, -0.034884124994277954, -0.07141090929508209, -0.028951946645975113, 0.0130959777161479, -0.010801419615745544, -0.012687388807535172, -0.0011665989877656102, -0.036651935428380966, -0.012561029754579067, -0.0003820840211119503, -0.014614499174058437, -0.04572088271379471, 0.020982682704925537, 0.004270666278898716, -0.007410972844809294, 0.005734060890972614, -0.008202977478504181, 0.008577462285757065, 0.02291896380484104, 0.05099654197692871, -0.018512703478336334, 0.034661777317523956, -0.0006698428187519312, 0.04374019429087639, 0.0008193749818019569, 0.03685139864683151, -0.04908062145113945, -0.0119568957015872, 0.0695672482252121, -0.03209489956498146, -0.03785638511180878, 0.026060059666633606, 0.0010311756050214171, 0.041280098259449005, 0.020568637177348137, -0.02701295167207718, 0.009825918823480606, 0.027260204777121544, -0.032028838992118835, -0.020307419821619987, -0.006072393152862787, 0.015307796187698841, 0.013077488169074059, -0.010496173985302448, -0.043382734060287476, -0.009684565477073193, 0.0038609271869063377, 0.05498606711626053, 0.03609403595328331, 0.012835817411541939, 0.009443799965083599, -0.023179883137345314, 0.01388487033545971, 0.021634818986058235, 0.018967755138874054, 0.013973411172628403, 0.025031670928001404, 0.044342584908008575, -0.017411652952432632, 0.033174481242895126, -0.0038658364210277796, 0.043248943984508514, -0.07305442541837692, -0.03234383091330528, -0.007436024956405163, 0.050799012184143066, 0.0006938708829693496, -0.05222521722316742, 0.003002989338710904, 0.029951395466923714, -0.027856232598423958, 0.02756224200129509, -0.016096938401460648, -0.008328073658049107, -0.020291797816753387, 0.01794065162539482, 0.00995673704892397, 0.041929904371500015, 0.029068026691675186, 0.02101798541843891, 0.01576138846576214, 0.007480335421860218, -0.012406203895807266, -0.014203968457877636, 0.0016885794466361403, 0.023439763113856316, 0.012783749960362911, -0.06076307222247124, 0.026135139167308807, -0.012194267474114895, -0.07073429971933365, 0.055167511105537415, -0.015646707266569138, 0.022893207147717476, 0.011408817023038864, 0.012333733029663563, 0.021260229870676994, 0.03585899993777275, 0.07579261064529419, -0.018357310444116592, -0.024754125624895096, 0.009291774593293667, 0.01775074005126953, 0.06274476647377014, -0.03540388122200966, 0.002991294488310814, 0.05689249932765961, -0.014587159268558025, -0.02633875049650669, 0.02810564637184143, -0.008564501069486141, 0.02269384264945984, 0.005308324936777353, -0.03143610805273056, 0.004585308488458395, -0.02183978632092476, 0.07225538045167923, -0.05304498225450516, -0.014433364383876324, 0.031665246933698654, 0.03782162815332413, 0.008078492246568203, 0.020673664286732674, 0.0037925902288407087, -0.024628395214676857, 0.01842992566525936, 0.02606872096657753, 0.015083731152117252, -0.06341157853603363, -0.02660418301820755, 0.016792170703411102, -0.0306294783949852, 0.020362069830298424, -0.008764132857322693, -0.048470668494701385, 0.022695330902934074, 0.023397764191031456, 0.02204205095767975, 0.010965070687234402, 0.004217483103275299, -0.010921426117420197, -0.07520318776369095, 0.035408951342105865, 0.010578375309705734, -0.020611107349395752, -0.042284801602363586, 0.003693239763379097, -0.03707738220691681, 0.0013832002878189087, 0.04443826526403427, 0.025820523500442505, 0.002591904019936919, -0.017797967419028282, 0.020416302606463432, -0.0021114812698215246, -0.0367731936275959, 0.019720420241355896, -0.010835406370460987, -0.013393162749707699, -0.013149735517799854, -0.010557607747614384, 0.014159750193357468, -0.021670330315828323, 0.012406553141772747, -0.03754394128918648, 0.04003826901316643, 0.004673900548368692, -0.003189454087987542, 0.054358210414648056, 0.018068883568048477, -0.03821567818522453, 0.03862723708152771, -0.016169274225831032, 0.00010649327305145562, 0.05281434580683708, -0.027603356167674065, -0.02883502095937729, 0.04203181341290474, -0.026763390749692917, -0.03259817510843277, 0.019626302644610405, 0.02874920703470707, 0.010462548583745956, -0.05523202568292618, -0.006746285129338503, 0.05046042799949646, -0.04986190423369408, 0.009624188765883446, 0.05730496719479561, 0.03565218299627304, 0.003297174582257867, -0.0005702138296328485, 0.031765855848789215, 0.03173133730888367, -0.03490815684199333, 0.028428705409169197, 0.01569439098238945, -0.0005833436734974384, -0.01647287607192993, 0.00819026306271553, 0.02780737914144993, -0.02738446183502674, 0.01202096976339817, 0.0027436725795269012, 0.02193373069167137, -0.03682725131511688, 0.0022806229535490274, -0.017334332689642906, 0.0000842749432194978, 0.041460730135440826, -0.00006253296305658296, -0.0431862473487854, 0.07897193729877472, -0.011931559070944786, 0.003874915884807706, -0.009805348701775074, -0.01483205333352089, -0.022364960983395576, -0.018502147868275642, 0.03245027735829353, 0.0660536140203476, -0.023517191410064697, 0.0035964790731668472, -0.01917356438934803, 0.007036755792796612, 0.04200447350740433, -0.01340567972511053, 0.029916351661086082, -0.030558070167899132, 0.004806314129382372, -0.01448298990726471, -0.02611212246119976, -0.0036098610144108534, -0.03437963128089905, 0.03967040032148361, 0.037615712732076645, 0.02068270929157734, -0.019419865682721138, -0.02969587966799736, 0.020286373794078827, 0.04157675430178642, -0.06155265495181084, -0.026908332481980324, -0.0561693049967289, 0.045221682637929916, -0.01766064204275608, -0.024436140432953835 ]
<p>If we have two variables A={20 values} and B={20 values} and we want to measure the correlation between these two variables. Lets assume that the first n values are highly correlated but the remaining m values are not correlated. The overall correlation between A and B may not represent the importance of the relationship. Imagine that there is only weak correlation in some values, but several values show really good correspondence between A and B. Traditional correlation coefficients will not capture such relationship. Is there any measure or statistical method that can detect such relationship between A and B?</p>
36,700
[ -0.04298560321331024, 0.022043367847800255, -0.006484988145530224, 0.01634998805820942, 0.06536277383565903, 0.02200915291905403, 0.007918012328445911, -0.02857287786900997, 0.034503158181905746, -0.033165495842695236, 0.02170022577047348, 0.032388634979724884, 0.043597813695669174, 0.04313600808382034, 0.02652422897517681, -0.01096795592457056, -0.028039950877428055, 0.019017333164811134, 0.024270720779895782, -0.02250058390200138, 0.006995728705078363, 0.03676624223589897, 0.04044155776500702, 0.008487047627568245, -0.02016124315559864, 0.0682266354560852, 0.015308355912566185, -0.03979615122079849, 0.011660303920507431, 0.0381992943584919, -0.03993402421474457, -0.04495730996131897, 0.01565505564212799, 0.04725565016269684, 0.02761542983353138, -0.016605272889137268, -0.015846410766243935, -0.021651625633239746, -0.008861458860337734, 0.0333145447075367, -0.032831933349370956, -0.062253355979919434, 0.011580969206988811, 0.03815586864948273, -0.01962914504110813, 0.0005876842187717557, 0.020154396072030067, -0.040404062718153, 0.042321644723415375, -0.03685840591788292, 0.1107189804315567, 0.020961830392479897, 0.030267752707004547, 0.023070484399795532, -0.020700260996818542, -0.008365319110453129, 0.05479913577437401, 0.0683944895863533, -0.02227795124053955, -0.05226176604628563, -0.02791033685207367, -0.024294497445225716, 0.014297026209533215, 0.0059593236073851585, -0.03640546649694443, 0.04943924769759178, -0.0395771861076355, -0.009407708421349525, 0.04888923466205597, 0.008040625602006912, -0.015525315888226032, 0.013933902606368065, 0.05857216194272041, -0.01971554569900036, -0.010348460637032986, -0.032615792006254196, 0.027850644662976265, -0.029023543000221252, 0.04561154171824455, 0.045523952692747116, -0.017863240092992783, 0.0013672466157004237, 0.02550669200718403, 0.04182143881917, 0.019258873537182808, -0.010023202747106552, 0.04293489456176758, -0.03177763521671295, 0.02844441868364811, 0.011594471521675587, -0.03524952009320259, -0.012051813304424286, 0.026498757302761078, 0.03302278742194176, -0.06768108904361725, 0.01729154773056507, -0.025007814168930054, 0.049263354390859604, 0.03146892040967941, -0.04318046197295189, -0.019427858293056488, 0.012270215898752213, 0.012690690346062183, 0.0541120208799839, -0.025329826399683952, -0.012739627622067928, -0.02242848463356495, -0.018977202475070953, 0.008925234898924828, 0.0026526693254709244, -0.021996943280100822, -0.0013479669578373432, 0.024630630388855934, 0.0224388986825943, 0.05963650718331337, -0.0161429550498724, -0.020585335791110992, -0.014344875700771809, 0.05868446081876755, 0.098061203956604, 0.028705330565571785, -0.027847178280353546, -0.0034160232171416283, -0.009161839261651039, -0.027306852862238884, 0.005150963552296162, 0.02687276154756546, -0.01589992828667164, -0.020111452788114548, 0.07079333066940308, -0.006063095293939114, -0.010530270636081696, 0.012010247446596622, -0.03536026552319527, 0.05291536822915077, -0.0012616703752428293, -0.09046284854412079, -0.03506740182638168, 0.057353124022483826, -0.031836941838264465, -0.006219307892024517, -0.025504181161522865, 0.027248980477452278, 0.011778893880546093, 0.04825763404369354, 0.06106657162308693, 0.013956769369542599, -0.0068747298792004585, 0.03965826332569122, 0.022081522271037102, -0.00650956854224205, -0.033696893602609634, -0.0026259562000632286, -0.011460143141448498, -0.012739001773297787, -0.08015196770429611, -0.018137721344828606, 0.01727519929409027, -0.0018053501844406128, -0.03009122982621193, 0.006726083345711231, 0.026807408779859543, -0.029032783582806587, 0.0021785416174679995, 0.03478008508682251, 0.003000945085659623, 0.05914170295000076, 0.03130041062831879, 0.006229207385331392, 0.008322822861373425, 0.0032973524648696184, 0.0008282838389277458, 0.06570644676685333, 0.05905843526124954, 0.03299659490585327, -0.013948353938758373, -0.013729730620980263, 0.007809818722307682, 0.024876222014427185, -0.011701982468366623, -0.018298890441656113, -0.04447181150317192, -0.01710454374551773, 0.02661481499671936, 0.023120397701859474, 0.0239820908755064, -0.0014172636438161135, -0.0181877501308918, 0.017316671088337898, -0.039325352758169174, -0.02218170277774334, -0.06500024348497391, 0.011400170624256134, 0.001148228533565998, -0.03540356829762459, 0.031739380210638046, 0.028180597350001335, -0.0003793270152527839, -0.020648973062634468, -0.028460806235671043, -0.02453598380088806, -0.020886363461613655, 0.028767399489879608, -0.03501847758889198, 0.010458545759320259, -0.002127646468579769, 0.04398380592465401, -0.04350180923938751, 0.05286581441760063, -0.044468242675065994, -0.08270804584026337, 0.003762058448046446, -0.04644852131605148, 0.008020979352295399, -0.008600451052188873, -0.04377168416976929, 0.035553593188524246, -0.0261241365224123, -0.03237544000148773, 0.0248277485370636, -0.039125774055719376, 0.07567640393972397, 0.0275419894605875, 0.0433453731238842, 0.0037263103295117617, 0.007783993612974882, 0.04155261442065239, 0.012022849172353745, -0.028254028409719467, -0.04425983130931854, -0.051747772842645645, -0.0026222618762403727, 0.017404448240995407, 0.05514904484152794, -0.07619409263134003, -0.0006793175125494599, 0.057606298476457596, 0.04082701355218887, -0.00791249517351389, 0.01660967618227005, -0.01702640950679779, -0.011368926614522934, 0.0059421854093670845, 0.048770252615213394, -0.005700660869479179, 0.015574181452393532, -0.016664568334817886, 0.03365802392363548, 0.022101236507296562, 0.0096782511100173, -0.026860272511839867, 0.036564718931913376, 0.015600429847836494, 0.004095341544598341, -0.040474049746990204, -0.033425405621528625, 0.0472598634660244, -0.03831657022237778, 0.024810152128338814, 0.035122767090797424, 0.019616909325122833, 0.006278335582464933, 0.02460211142897606, -0.04038947820663452, 0.02790934033691883, 0.006718690041452646, -0.03796149790287018, -0.005493056494742632, 0.021590903401374817, -0.03149832412600517, 0.02510255016386509, -0.024263521656394005, -0.0018011144129559398, -0.02856997400522232, 0.01762193813920021, 0.04733146354556084, 0.007341747637838125, 0.021296881139278412, -0.003365529701113701, -0.045777447521686554, -0.020161030814051628, -0.032058097422122955, -0.03809243068099022, -0.021007239818572998, -0.04865361005067825, 0.00009562446211930364, 0.01322300173342228, -0.030352963134646416, 0.021397462114691734, -0.03400672599673271, 0.00980577152222395, 0.028915787115693092, -0.014114473015069962, -0.05813521891832352, -0.005921967327594757, -0.01087478268891573, 0.01784227229654789, -0.03310435265302658, -0.030800744891166687, 0.020861729979515076, -0.008973744697868824, -0.05658241733908653, 0.01849895715713501, -0.019244955852627754, -0.03704259172081947, -0.03164617344737053, -0.018857447430491447, 0.0018708794377744198, -0.03309151530265808, 0.012222672812640667, 0.025614026933908463, -0.04510520398616791, -0.04829733073711395, -0.07355616986751556, -0.06596191227436066, 0.03252582624554634, 0.010662767104804516, 0.027471357956528664, -0.0053278859704732895, -0.017217572778463364, 0.024594785645604134, 0.016124477609992027, -0.023130016401410103, -0.04660973325371742, -0.01149728149175644, -0.003085704520344734, -0.00014715954603161663, 0.011871068738400936, 0.02157437615096569, 0.031002672389149666, 0.03494716063141823, 0.01517986785620451, -0.011604218743741512, 0.055156681686639786, 0.004110889509320259, -0.0025835814885795116, 0.03372902423143387, -0.00248360401019454, 0.009515266865491867, 0.003693177830427885, 0.009686872363090515, -0.07424510270357132, 0.005526302382349968, 0.01962881349027157, -0.0035207478795200586, 0.026709428057074547, -0.014769644476473331, 0.026729676872491837, -0.014944914728403091, 0.013668588362634182, -0.035383451730012894, -0.013073472306132317, 0.009623534046113491, 0.037008460611104965, -0.02670348435640335, 0.07043705880641937, 0.040019817650318146, -0.005355902947485447, 0.0058661168441176414, 0.09349487721920013, 0.0191516000777483, -0.041500985622406006, -0.015696149319410324, -0.01684417389333248, -0.021585527807474136, 0.010999282822012901, 0.003772587049752474, -0.038398630917072296, 0.024424651637673378, 0.0039037500973790884, 0.013843884691596031, 0.015141574665904045, -0.03399316966533661, 0.024449173361063004, -0.0571967214345932, -0.021302688866853714, -0.03080683760344982, 0.04882844537496567, 0.012245062738656998, 0.05770497024059296, 0.005242001730948687, 0.009567519649863243, 0.000610044167842716, 0.014948382042348385, -0.08471733331680298, 0.04111165925860405, -0.04494449496269226, 0.007345191668719053, 0.032652001827955246, -0.034749094396829605, 0.006457160692662001, -0.029582077637314796, 0.0059842257760465145, -0.01687290519475937, 0.04486431926488876, -0.045826420187950134, 0.005620601121336222, -0.024688679724931717, 0.006731721106916666, -0.013172123581171036, 0.01915258727967739, 0.004517114255577326, -0.039605818688869476, 0.043747708201408386, 0.05304203927516937, -0.00929169449955225, -0.03174010291695595, -0.036041051149368286, 0.018688524141907692, 0.017134325578808784, 0.044341765344142914, 0.019603384658694267, 0.0441371351480484, -0.04649602621793747, 0.009077271446585655, 0.015346525236964226, 0.059437841176986694, 0.03212519362568855, -0.0030474166851490736, 0.0015489216893911362, -0.022864006459712982, -0.038993578404188156, -0.01507412176579237, 0.05448697507381439, 0.0036703466903418303, 0.012092404067516327, 0.047518666833639145, 0.00819631852209568, -0.047494255006313324, 0.022272657603025436, 0.06785525381565094, 0.06217917799949646, -0.0010287557961419225, -0.024139532819390297, -0.033191580325365067, 0.011851147748529911, 0.0013686399906873703, 0.0005766580579802394, -0.01757180318236351, -0.0012937230058014393, -0.02519397996366024, 0.0604548379778862, 0.014437688514590263, -0.028370818123221397, -0.008853078819811344, -0.010651975870132446, 0.04797970876097679, -0.017758172005414963, -0.024800613522529602, 0.0011473222402855754, 0.03650569170713425, 0.010612396523356438, 0.043122924864292145, 0.014210298657417297, -0.07832339406013489, 0.01844320259988308, 0.018387962132692337, 0.015744736418128014, -0.03941570967435837, -0.006994043476879597, -0.02362660877406597, -0.027492741122841835, 0.07045271247625351, -0.020077450200915337, 0.014486046507954597, -0.015891773626208305, 0.0295033510774374, -0.03836970031261444, 0.006686251610517502, -0.023062773048877716, 0.010379632003605366, -0.00886638555675745, 0.022487854585051537, -0.012042367830872536, -0.02834148146212101, -0.055352404713630676, 0.0028214307967573404, 0.04846867546439171, 0.05807853862643242, 0.00574673293158412, -0.00896947830915451, 0.00108093093149364, 0.0299492496997118, 0.030396705493330956, -0.08778542280197144, 0.04123280569911003, 0.01832306943833828, -0.051470059901475906, 0.05510716512799263, -0.009399432688951492, -0.04118580371141434, 0.005914239678531885, -0.024728894233703613, 0.016921047121286392, 0.0145981814712286, -0.007607040461152792, 0.059863220900297165, 0.02802986651659012, 0.009908134117722511, 0.04576478153467178, 0.021881496533751488, -0.01058689784258604, -0.006357504054903984, 0.0128294313326478, 0.014039651490747929, -0.050236981362104416, -0.014288322068750858, -0.015915771946310997, -0.014759131707251072, -0.031103845685720444, 0.04694875702261925, 0.004071246366947889, 0.009369315579533577, -0.00724131939932704, 0.034568902105093, -0.017498955130577087, 0.03672689571976662, -0.026358777657151222, -0.0022862297482788563, 0.0025332365185022354, 0.010350710712373257, 0.0027153792325407267, -0.03609189763665199, 0.024015987291932106, -0.015759091824293137, -0.020994029939174652, 0.002007451606914401, -0.023471716791391373, -0.02495756559073925, -0.03777932748198509, 0.00089424685575068, -0.004590481519699097, 0.007949240505695343, 0.035251885652542114, -0.008298088796436787, 0.022896206006407738, -0.026255114004015923, -0.033654503524303436, 0.012202156707644463, 0.0489845797419548, 0.007732488214969635, 0.023510631173849106, -0.03758945316076279, 0.030025770887732506, -0.028148191049695015, -0.012378288432955742, -0.06280097365379333, -0.03293546661734581, 0.00878723245114088, 0.034870266914367676, -0.01852353848516941, -0.0374283529818058, -0.00969661120325327, -0.019156234338879585, -0.010212612338364124, -0.007499478291720152, 0.04106910526752472, 0.020170781761407852, -0.0353178046643734, 0.009646751917898655, -0.00645587220788002, 0.06127389892935753, -0.01087840087711811, -0.04326048865914345, 0.001754095545038581, 0.00595846539363265, -0.02562304399907589, 0.007598389405757189, -0.005439959932118654, -0.025835825130343437, -0.013933484442532063, -0.04936394840478897, -0.0028331370558589697, 0.007338343653827906, -0.010947611182928085, -0.01561814360320568, -0.004978965036571026, -0.016630977392196655, 0.0017131577478721738, -0.014761604368686676, 0.018605433404445648, -0.011300325393676758, -0.016940372064709663, -0.014631127007305622, -0.009979559108614922, -0.021580707281827927, -0.03063245676457882, 0.039110876619815826, 0.04436323046684265, -0.049848876893520355, -0.002153611509129405, 0.03636600449681282, 0.010619807057082653, -0.019270557910203934, 0.00451528187841177, -0.008787630125880241, 0.023048190400004387, -0.015104061923921108, 0.019205808639526367, 0.030600475147366524, 0.04044882208108902, -0.03617607429623604, -0.0431138277053833, -0.019353173673152924, -0.02836763858795166, 0.08657415211200714, -0.02963665872812271, 0.06408118456602097, 0.03306363895535469, -0.003475442063063383, -0.012409279122948647, -0.017739277333021164, -0.006336826831102371, 0.02916606329381466, -0.010267994366586208, 0.03483102470636368, -0.0360771119594574, 0.010413373820483685, 0.01158114057034254, 0.026939723640680313, 0.016543472185730934, 0.04015865921974182, -0.017738979309797287, 0.03531404957175255, 0.061451591551303864, -0.00703391944989562, -0.04751989617943764, 0.022526349872350693, -0.025233784690499306, 0.018159054219722748, -0.011113438755273819, -0.017398949712514877, 0.01932954415678978, 0.04763627052307129, 0.009539828635752201, -0.020170563831925392, -0.05546961724758148, -0.026372844353318214, 0.0043741194531321526, 0.033956266939640045, -0.006972798146307468, 0.015085089951753616, 0.012146675027906895, 0.012241085059940815, -0.021535402163863182, 0.015981854870915413, -0.03007490374147892, -0.06613825261592865, -0.016354193910956383, -0.020115545019507408, -0.012672319076955318, 0.061596695333719254, -0.0004215602239128202, -0.015922492370009422, 0.03229783847928047, -0.005251436028629541, -0.015173114836215973, -0.0108955018222332, 0.004705709405243397, -0.027419529855251312, 0.06445945054292679, 0.02668142318725586, 0.01898077316582203, 0.02514067105948925, 0.004263017792254686, 0.07884247601032257, 0.06969068199396133, 0.04163428023457527, -0.05458924546837807, 0.027002576738595963, 0.007020857185125351, -0.02125668153166771, -0.06158452108502388, 0.03353867307305336, 0.0038180684205144644, -0.023610007017850876, 0.04124090448021889, 0.04948022961616516, 0.024802831932902336, 0.0060922750271856785, 0.09687511622905731, -0.027796762064099312, -0.03237178549170494, -0.005674747750163078, 0.014707348309457302, -0.006978272460401058, -0.031110461801290512, -0.023356247693300247, 0.015028635039925575, -0.018399804830551147, -0.03371893987059593, -0.030068136751651764, 0.03384885936975479, 0.0060380371287465096, -0.022799134254455566, -0.019818026572465897, 0.0029708100482821465, 0.034883663058280945, 0.016546018421649933, -0.0058129276148974895, 0.010972730815410614, 0.05354800447821617, 0.012208860367536545, 0.017668582499027252, -0.008010126650333405, 0.010624711401760578, -0.013033995404839516, -0.00936759915202856, 0.009257778525352478, -0.04370155557990074, -0.03551465645432472, -0.029397323727607727, 0.026309795677661896, -0.005640273913741112, -0.035457681864500046, -0.014709663577377796, -0.013211993500590324, -0.006542780436575413, -0.015769241377711296, -0.006824794225394726, 0.01681681163609028, 0.03508864715695381, -0.048053257167339325, -0.023491788655519485, -0.028985699638724327, 0.014543646015226841, -0.018962878733873367, 0.0542374923825264, 0.012787412852048874, -0.02857634611427784, 0.00037301832344383, -0.001265660161152482, 0.0558803454041481, 0.0230494886636734, -0.0218607597053051, -0.02039886824786663, 0.0002532719518058002, -0.012880648486316204, -0.011182986199855804, -0.00639250036329031, 0.016389314085245132, 0.01015189103782177, 0.022002534940838814, -0.014489316381514072, -0.021968360990285873, -0.012609033845365047, 0.016837280243635178, -0.022373851388692856, -0.03494973108172417, -0.05039912089705467, -0.013258067891001701, 0.04839733615517616, 0.040841665118932724, 0.01747853495180607, -0.028174184262752533, -0.027384668588638306, 0.018562037497758865, 0.04321448132395744, -0.057217683643102646, -0.0257276501506567, -0.04007590934634209, -0.0349854975938797, 0.004753230605274439, -0.016051849350333214, 0.02266487292945385, 0.037856705486774445, 0.03525753691792488, -0.004525760188698769, 0.0185230802744627, -0.03624158352613449, 0.001627422752790153, 0.011961769312620163, -0.03259856998920441, -0.021917400881648064, 0.0022599075455218554, -0.010963262990117073, -0.006707275286316872, -0.013661663047969341, -0.029065515846014023, -0.008556443266570568, 0.008047355338931084, 0.0033190117683261633, -0.031350258737802505, -0.02692330814898014, -0.004296264611184597, 0.00414370046928525, -0.04037637636065483, -0.0035308937076479197, -0.08276498317718506, -0.01856626756489277, 0.010313868522644043, 0.0036991089582443237, -0.005584892816841602, 0.02943679690361023, -0.03627476468682289, -0.0012668120907619596, 0.04755519703030586, 0.016553569585084915, -0.012670657597482204, -0.008373716846108437, -0.009337212890386581, 0.014372666366398335, 0.054322659969329834, -0.04571986943483353, -0.030519163236021996, 0.04123404994606972, -0.07270471751689911, -0.006408404093235731, 0.03469986096024513, -0.04162810370326042, 0.03934807330369949, 0.021229373291134834, 0.0060163638554513454, -0.021816479042172432, 0.02273816056549549, -0.014046380296349525, 0.001291454304009676, -0.00822403933852911, 0.005626935511827469, -0.020806021988391876, 0.0022250500041991472, -0.0036271833814680576, -0.00987868569791317, -0.03390064463019371, 0.016137106344103813, 0.06496019661426544, 0.03274720534682274, -0.014611675404012203, 0.029940977692604065, 0.018518807366490364, 0.029753005132079124, -0.0008218252914957702, -0.024324845522642136, 0.010381045751273632, 0.056878045201301575, -0.02934940718114376, 0.013663419522345066, 0.027857264503836632, 0.014502877369523048, -0.08928219228982925, -0.002344820648431778, -0.00489534018561244, 0.005505081731826067, 0.052196212112903595, -0.07418876141309738, 0.018385842442512512, 0.009972142986953259, -0.059742290526628494, 0.03797569498419762, -0.00891968235373497, -0.0013552447780966759, -0.007781336084008217, -0.012632466852664948, -0.044802453368902206, 0.04409368708729744, 0.022084202617406845, 0.05968157947063446, 0.03034011460840702, 0.01688009686768055, -0.0009201623033732176, -0.008400972932577133, -0.02542060799896717, -0.041261885315179825, 0.005267658270895481, -0.07233253121376038, 0.056008078157901764, -0.05009620636701584, -0.03736129403114319, 0.05696878954768181, -0.03845832496881485, 0.018733324483036995, -0.002565202070400119, 0.002818467328324914, 0.0034005630295723677, 0.04346198961138725, 0.012255179695785046, -0.038473110646009445, -0.008008113130927086, 0.0029741080943495035, 0.00017575526726432145, 0.028087863698601723, -0.03396199271082878, 0.018919995054602623, 0.023594126105308533, -0.0028724500443786383, -0.04405160993337631, -0.0074256835505366325, 0.013407522812485695, -0.005281852558255196, 0.0076344432309269905, -0.021974369883537292, 0.02758522890508175, -0.021815508604049683, 0.03638538345694542, -0.036011431366205215, -0.02562069147825241, 0.04177046939730644, 0.021244147792458534, -0.04618304595351219, -0.009780406951904297, -0.0012821925338357687, -0.031109079718589783, 0.022558797150850296, 0.01979774236679077, -0.009002240374684334, -0.07075643539428711, -0.00867733359336853, -0.010882293805480003, -0.022779565304517746, -0.015827348455786705, -0.013322737999260426, -0.02748945541679859, 0.06537279486656189, -0.03401694446802139, 0.039357054978609085, 0.015079728327691555, -0.030794251710176468, 0.02470816671848297, -0.05863221362233162, 0.03294074162840843, 0.011350443586707115, 0.039780087769031525, -0.009722077287733555, 0.000742164149414748, -0.02120739221572876, -0.0505981482565403, 0.05618419125676155, -0.020790686830878258, 0.027875840663909912, -0.013419067487120628, 0.03535258397459984, 0.0023422352969646454, -0.03411346301436424, 0.027393365278840065, -0.007783235516399145, -0.022841712459921837, -0.018872249871492386, -0.021512411534786224, 0.024061979725956917, -0.013949860818684101, 0.014325885102152824, -0.0360632985830307, -0.04145351052284241, 0.0055090500973165035, 0.006079981103539467, 0.03708632290363312, 0.0032401331700384617, -0.02008572593331337, 0.042859386652708054, 0.015579807572066784, 0.037640657275915146, 0.03797013685107231, 0.0033888539765030146, -0.06367306411266327, 0.039857350289821625, 0.009041604585945606, -0.038168229162693024, 0.02922678552567959, 0.052754517644643784, -0.04710093513131142, -0.06795337796211243, -0.018074817955493927, 0.027499770745635033, -0.0298598799854517, 0.0092698959633708, 0.023976366966962814, -0.007378583773970604, 0.020144492387771606, 0.023324714973568916, 0.01145954430103302, 0.013176572509109974, -0.024473898112773895, 0.01848420314490795, 0.038616444915533066, 0.05907829478383064, 0.002114650094881654, 0.02378111146390438, -0.0006976781296543777, -0.0028372660744935274, 0.0106339817866683, -0.010859307833015919, 0.012906312942504883, -0.016868315637111664, -0.014889112673699856, 0.05561995878815651, -0.009023395366966724, 0.054523568600416183, -0.02400505542755127, 0.0025495137088000774, 0.051024675369262695, -0.057347554713487625, -0.0021578583400696516, -0.03547309339046478, -0.013875806704163551, -0.014984429813921452, 0.02926802821457386, 0.02983076125383377, 0.00495615229010582, 0.007154681719839573, 0.02314148098230362, 0.01649092510342598, -0.019936146214604378, 0.01694401353597641, 0.004349350463598967, 0.03676554933190346, -0.023671235889196396, 0.008648254908621311, 0.0014061034889891744, 0.004917626269161701, -0.05265595763921738, -0.025144152343273163, 0.05133793130517006, 0.03884180262684822, 0.050026219338178635, -0.026227595284581184, 0.008484059944748878, -0.0002234805142506957, 0.03343696519732475, -0.06304987519979477, 0.013020938262343407, -0.046530772000551224, 0.004947018809616566, -0.015334449708461761, -0.0372866615653038 ]
<p>Do you know of any study where researchers have used Statistical Parametric Mapping for <strong>spatial data only</strong>? I found a lot of studies that used it for time-series analysis, but does this analysis work for data that don't share a time dimension? </p>
74,057
[ -0.04292195662856102, 0.005628957878798246, 0.003831045003607869, 0.009893853217363358, 0.04572410508990288, 0.0075324224308133125, 0.02602485381066799, -0.041618213057518005, 0.015784982591867447, -0.05758031830191612, -0.00960423145443201, 0.031441859900951385, 0.05438181385397911, -0.007605783175677061, 0.016778111457824707, -0.003149460069835186, 0.005373704247176647, 0.0021102833561599255, -0.03730113059282303, -0.02853095531463623, -0.004433371592313051, 0.010835466906428337, -0.0394311286509037, -0.039655476808547974, -0.020468268543481827, 0.020043684169650078, -0.01626870036125183, -0.036064326763153076, -0.01933187246322632, 0.07606947422027588, -0.043572843074798584, -0.0013960690703243017, -0.015229801647365093, 0.057655032724142075, -0.006124233826994896, -0.021142611280083656, -0.06932449340820312, -0.04094192013144493, 0.00013442328781820834, 0.060134150087833405, -0.03862582519650459, -0.011703714728355408, -0.02208748273551464, 0.06975606083869934, -0.03144280984997749, 0.04356297478079796, 0.003360395086929202, 0.005191102623939514, 0.021586013957858086, -0.023849690333008766, 0.08589458465576172, 0.011623946018517017, 0.02444591000676155, 0.03308315947651863, -0.028141338378190994, -0.006810788065195084, 0.057343825697898865, 0.01205909252166748, 0.00944132823497057, -0.026305019855499268, 0.0019193448824808002, 0.00027106437482871115, 0.03587780520319939, -0.02416158840060234, -0.035392168909311295, 0.021516159176826477, 0.000045452878111973405, -0.011998158879578114, 0.04484211280941963, -0.04370219632983208, -0.018847832456231117, -0.01728338934481144, 0.06462562829256058, -0.005062068812549114, -0.018468597903847694, 0.005138171836733818, 0.027642900124192238, 0.023615801706910133, 0.0575183667242527, 0.0012684690300375223, -0.017184613272547722, -0.009298568591475487, 0.014927220530807972, 0.026729678735136986, -0.006350367795675993, 0.018734632059931755, 0.03830110654234886, -0.07839316129684448, -0.008438145741820335, 0.019165361300110817, -0.000026256417186232284, -0.014964614063501358, 0.030406853184103966, 0.030088389292359352, -0.04437408968806267, 0.028190895915031433, 0.0016695278463885188, 0.025149676948785782, 0.0059564667753875256, -0.0043693119660019875, -0.026047497987747192, -0.037008170038461685, -0.013526041060686111, 0.0032880837097764015, 0.005294406320899725, -0.017743485048413277, 0.03946848586201668, -0.009735428728163242, -0.03734216094017029, 0.03535432368516922, -0.03619387373328209, -0.02677486278116703, 0.03984982147812843, -0.014287243597209454, 0.04858710244297981, -0.02660253830254078, 0.026416566222906113, -0.022646663710474968, 0.017783720046281815, 0.1124921590089798, 0.03456371650099754, -0.020581401884555817, -0.008692021481692791, -0.024553094059228897, -0.0778692439198494, 0.032175835222005844, -0.012721670791506767, -0.02080553025007248, -0.07846052199602127, 0.06264086067676544, 0.01931084133684635, 0.00010903010843321681, 0.06236911937594414, -0.0296408049762249, 0.04239616543054581, 0.03478121757507324, -0.06876705586910248, -0.04334266483783722, 0.041059933602809906, -0.009791070595383644, 0.0485176220536232, -0.014837208203971386, 0.009461998008191586, -0.029383545741438866, 0.00792011246085167, -0.015593456104397774, 0.04311596229672432, 0.013114533387124538, 0.05120304226875305, 0.00986948050558567, -0.03936338797211647, -0.0009332898771390319, 0.027425263077020645, -0.04037000611424446, -0.0009248057031072676, -0.10214663296937943, 0.029753202572464943, 0.017289746552705765, -0.023163488134741783, -0.014624850824475288, 0.03232616186141968, 0.01929912529885769, -0.004348593298345804, 0.0370921827852726, 0.002673697890713811, -0.008752923458814621, 0.04303106293082237, -0.006129874847829342, 0.028848053887486458, 0.02193542569875717, -0.03167133778333664, 0.05494228005409241, 0.04729871824383736, 0.02136877365410328, 0.021993907168507576, 0.010070215910673141, 0.011022417806088924, 0.039601366966962814, -0.0078619085252285, 0.0059098838828504086, -0.034266676753759384, 0.004207370337098837, -0.03770913556218147, -0.006558154243975878, -0.009656732901930809, 0.06650938093662262, -0.03064308874309063, -0.07276393473148346, 0.024225732311606407, -0.06570560485124588, -0.030482271686196327, -0.04515423998236656, 0.04019881412386894, -0.013721308670938015, -0.01675112545490265, 0.04011383652687073, -0.011179890483617783, 0.04309643432497978, -0.004493820481002331, -0.040485698729753494, -0.03378062695264816, -0.028029395267367363, 0.036437101662158966, -0.059334203600883484, 0.011330589652061462, 0.03583246096968651, 0.036298319697380066, -0.004851153120398521, 0.02653391845524311, -0.03415639325976372, -0.05294716730713844, -0.009070365689694881, -0.051138345152139664, 0.041980184614658356, -0.007250094320625067, -0.02847999893128872, -0.04060761258006096, 0.009449855424463749, -0.0763876661658287, 0.00593493040651083, -0.04005175828933716, 0.07597972452640533, 0.07480298727750778, -0.004493288230150938, 0.0012949997326359153, 0.03852827101945877, 0.028283804655075073, 0.006996322888880968, 0.015366924926638603, -0.023353558033704758, -0.056556541472673416, 0.0028707205783575773, 0.033255673944950104, 0.030039850622415543, -0.04313518851995468, 0.024522656574845314, 0.03976461663842201, 0.03028269112110138, -0.033494092524051666, 0.024297591298818588, -0.02004445344209671, -0.03036366030573845, 0.018316008150577545, -0.004715403541922569, 0.03637748956680298, -0.0015623612562194467, 0.006409353110939264, 0.003045798046514392, 0.016481800004839897, 0.009373333305120468, 0.012212843634188175, 0.024893980473279953, -0.01752053201198578, 0.013635208830237389, -0.005242079962044954, -0.013328411616384983, 0.04272061958909035, -0.024626564234495163, -0.0030659108888357878, 0.020541677251458168, 0.02918325364589691, 0.0063497144728899, 0.0017309131799265742, -0.012776135466992855, 0.021464424207806587, 0.012236109934747219, 0.004933285992592573, 0.05500452220439911, 0.033532556146383286, -0.04027215763926506, -0.004239026922732592, -0.05057426169514656, -0.019124384969472885, -0.04190089553594589, -0.016677848994731903, 0.03501598909497261, 0.008120713755488396, 0.00574673293158412, -0.011716828681528568, -0.003699799068272114, -0.016229769214987755, 0.012376422993838787, -0.0045631942339241505, 0.02074933797121048, -0.048851028084754944, 0.01265912875533104, -0.04351678863167763, 0.01815137267112732, 0.03204018250107765, -0.03565608337521553, -0.029791386798024178, 0.03865896165370941, -0.010499336756765842, -0.03286776691675186, -0.03183386102318764, -0.049620620906353, 0.045146115124225616, -0.04378455877304077, 0.012917421758174896, 0.06419723480939865, 0.0026701753959059715, -0.04353528842329979, 0.0053419084288179874, 0.0036235565785318613, -0.024056212976574898, -0.019853292033076286, 0.008590415120124817, -0.009507080540060997, -0.03207508474588394, 0.012656304985284805, 0.04691089317202568, -0.05468670278787613, 0.007092040032148361, -0.06287974119186401, -0.02789314277470112, 0.04116141051054001, -0.025214485824108124, 0.05431237071752548, -0.004579954780638218, -0.035452309995889664, 0.06386949121952057, 0.0057758912444114685, -0.03095666877925396, -0.045948535203933716, -0.0008462360710836947, -0.03550660237669945, -0.02295561507344246, -0.007445503957569599, -0.004456235095858574, 0.03222030773758888, 0.019926302134990692, -0.018136149272322655, 0.018303874880075455, 0.052868716418743134, 0.0440080463886261, -0.023281633853912354, 0.014838793314993382, 0.0016426753718405962, 0.00538588548079133, -0.0009084135526791215, 0.026529401540756226, -0.04204663261771202, 0.015271569602191448, -0.024302925914525986, 0.022026877850294113, -0.009371674619615078, -0.04410837963223457, 0.027874082326889038, -0.02880994789302349, -0.015110906213521957, -0.044871240854263306, 0.0037665655836462975, 0.0004111267626285553, 0.026763921603560448, -0.02578233741223812, 0.037400517612695694, 0.027555538341403008, 0.0005901601398363709, -0.011896561831235886, 0.033128201961517334, 0.04157032072544098, -0.003373790765181184, 0.01378583163022995, 0.014499238692224026, 0.04192480072379112, 0.02337389811873436, -0.004502405878156424, -0.03951233997941017, 0.012128758244216442, 0.04062993824481964, 0.0033819470554590225, 0.02588171698153019, -0.038721971213817596, 0.027842437848448753, -0.0771205723285675, 0.03793026879429817, -0.011116119101643562, 0.034948136657476425, -0.017035529017448425, 0.023799510672688484, 0.03131593018770218, 0.011735133826732635, -0.008268392644822598, 0.010948557406663895, -0.001013818196952343, -0.040890611708164215, -0.045403581112623215, -0.00036250927951186895, 0.006066546775400639, -0.0315595418214798, 0.013911755755543709, -0.012694026343524456, 0.029598452150821686, 0.00021745565754827112, 0.020018350332975388, -0.05413214862346649, -0.03397860750555992, 0.011335941031575203, -0.010678903199732304, -0.07271266728639603, 0.008174557238817215, 0.0491754375398159, -0.019457217305898666, 0.037774622440338135, 0.04487157240509987, 0.019548553973436356, 0.007575380150228739, -0.015320771373808384, 0.006599679589271545, -0.013284101150929928, 0.03272559493780136, -0.03738817945122719, 0.010048003867268562, -0.018898680806159973, 0.03940677270293236, 0.010970447212457657, 0.03185798227787018, 0.014648791402578354, -0.015808308497071266, -0.0126319769769907, -0.023830505087971687, -0.021792979910969734, 0.040345776826143265, 0.026801370084285736, 0.025476038455963135, -0.01187819056212902, 0.060879867523908615, 0.04142699018120766, -0.07300235331058502, 0.014460477977991104, 0.03714043274521828, 0.013424145989120007, 0.021698934957385063, -0.029157929122447968, -0.05699330195784569, 0.01404294278472662, -0.025586513802409172, 0.04589737579226494, -0.007583880331367254, -0.018573014065623283, 0.030739163979887962, 0.03774402663111687, 0.046562645584344864, -0.05432268977165222, -0.01177773717790842, -0.0069325328804552555, 0.0036658423487097025, 0.016344621777534485, -0.006993460934609175, 0.0240959282964468, 0.03999835252761841, 0.03813735768198967, 0.02674696035683155, -0.03743123263120651, -0.11443471163511276, 0.020374907180666924, 0.043493032455444336, -0.012272315099835396, 0.011733359657227993, 0.021696345880627632, -0.040415454655885696, 0.013820159249007702, -0.0012927447678521276, -0.0021914392709732056, 0.01575985550880432, -0.013235948048532009, 0.005084116477519274, -0.04993192106485367, -0.04538963362574577, -0.03102380596101284, 0.007316327188163996, 0.006411049980670214, 0.03979131951928139, -0.003937717527151108, -0.03388793021440506, -0.033636804670095444, 0.03424140065908432, 0.007743872236460447, 0.018516510725021362, 0.005738343112170696, -0.011022770777344704, -0.02670971304178238, 0.019007617607712746, -0.023824542760849, -0.06375858187675476, 0.019670724868774414, 0.017449965700507164, -0.013006934896111488, 0.06029379367828369, -0.02559637650847435, -0.04685329645872116, 0.035275112837553024, -0.0013277243124321103, -0.0015205583767965436, 0.015772413462400436, 0.008851035498082638, 0.04413055256009102, 0.014299171045422554, -0.004197956062853336, 0.04834873601794243, 0.017114995047450066, -0.018440021201968193, 0.0021492522209882736, -0.014865812845528126, 0.057543519884347916, -0.05602686479687691, -0.005832779221236706, -0.03671635314822197, -0.024375198408961296, -0.01728840358555317, 0.04081018641591072, 0.01885494962334633, 0.026481296867132187, -0.02627783827483654, 0.005004877224564552, -0.0017902906984090805, 0.03592309728264809, 0.01781512051820755, -0.007937291637063026, -0.005332279019057751, 0.01449497789144516, -0.025190187618136406, -0.011041364632546902, -0.018865244463086128, -0.01716427132487297, -0.007296951953321695, 0.024804186075925827, -0.02715838886797428, 0.01038556732237339, -0.019506769254803658, -0.020115533843636513, 0.018473446369171143, -0.040638893842697144, 0.02426857128739357, -0.03581362962722778, 0.013039182871580124, 0.01901736669242382, -0.08618292212486267, 0.004545398056507111, 0.02341338060796261, -0.012630889192223549, 0.017645500600337982, -0.019757745787501335, 0.029306642711162567, -0.029093587771058083, 0.016471412032842636, -0.06712735444307327, -0.06186313554644585, 0.03536735475063324, 0.003906615078449249, -0.034116681665182114, -0.028771286830306053, -0.0037749011535197496, -0.03141522407531738, -0.027778081595897675, -0.00539623387157917, 0.07288961112499237, -0.006732388399541378, -0.021209346130490303, -0.01226671040058136, 0.002171511761844158, 0.04745471477508545, -0.02750781551003456, -0.005363776348531246, 0.030089927837252617, -0.006440469529479742, 0.0054742731153965, -0.03178546577692032, 0.028710080310702324, -0.034230511635541916, 0.0088872779160738, -0.06215977296233177, 0.012199328280985355, 0.0340825617313385, -0.004289851989597082, -0.023676561191678047, 0.035773880779743195, -0.015440700575709343, -0.0059093935415148735, -0.01539735309779644, 0.01317284069955349, -0.02741738222539425, -0.007530600298196077, -0.035445865243673325, 0.026507437229156494, -0.03182663768529892, -0.011308747343719006, 0.04922008514404297, -0.025812581181526184, -0.035255905240774155, 0.03635982796549797, 0.02333272248506546, -0.020890293642878532, 0.0325639583170414, -0.003978055436164141, 0.016227494925260544, 0.03088424541056156, 0.0058190603740513325, 0.01111786998808384, 0.014841864816844463, 0.05066825449466705, -0.027105288580060005, -0.045264601707458496, -0.005613459274172783, 0.016972199082374573, 0.054270874708890915, -0.02349691279232502, 0.03589581325650215, 0.060152675956487656, -0.044008463621139526, -0.0018356575164943933, -0.039152227342128754, 0.011689597740769386, -0.0141474399715662, 0.0007736837142147124, 0.06787587702274323, 0.049545276910066605, 0.04751154035329819, 0.022928349673748016, 0.04111504182219505, 0.012818933464586735, 0.07158717513084412, 0.014559417963027954, 0.026863446459174156, 0.06458721309900284, -0.020923059433698654, -0.05747692286968231, 0.03829164057970047, -0.023906752467155457, 0.012548479251563549, -0.005671640858054161, -0.011245625093579292, 0.02028225176036358, 0.03276124969124794, 0.00002829888580890838, -0.051689907908439636, -0.004660686478018761, -0.0543355830013752, 0.019077477976679802, 0.021736929193139076, 0.00973090622574091, 0.023435959592461586, -0.007548223249614239, 0.04373376443982124, -0.04275556653738022, -0.021991796791553497, -0.012293929234147072, -0.028311461210250854, -0.023423030972480774, -0.004658254329115152, 0.0006386530585587025, 0.04026494920253754, -0.009495389647781849, -0.02944352850317955, 0.039603084325790405, -0.024971025064587593, -0.00411117821931839, -0.009681014344096184, 0.023461980745196342, 0.00291753769852221, 0.0844746008515358, 0.007817227393388748, 0.01833236776292324, -0.031914252787828445, -0.02514474093914032, 0.10423944890499115, 0.08263130486011505, 0.02241971530020237, -0.034479036927223206, 0.023994553834199905, -0.00036584402550943196, -0.017854586243629456, -0.03773096576333046, -0.013383462093770504, 0.03638391196727753, 0.005873892456293106, 0.014106495305895805, 0.07725518196821213, 0.019277287647128105, -0.027377260848879814, 0.05831773951649666, -0.046372201293706894, 0.0061699701473116875, 0.0295358095318079, -0.018164947628974915, -0.010360700078308582, -0.032334569841623306, -0.018494868651032448, -0.008145109750330448, -0.004513281397521496, -0.021165192127227783, -0.00387732801027596, -0.0314071923494339, -0.014989293180406094, 0.01556152943521738, -0.017740007489919662, 0.00793528277426958, 0.029334966093301773, 0.014165286906063557, -0.027510903775691986, -0.006431248504668474, -0.005191836506128311, -0.007459312677383423, -0.00832701288163662, 0.022770309820771217, 0.005702447611838579, -0.01717340014874935, -0.022638224065303802, -0.028269151225686073, -0.016820907592773438, -0.012805584818124771, -0.031231645494699478, 0.02126452699303627, 0.023253748193383217, -0.004468600265681744, -0.008199905045330524, 0.011848327703773975, 0.004876994993537664, -0.002192518673837185, -0.005839173216372728, -0.0028600043151527643, 0.055657822638750076, 0.006942556239664555, -0.0030867496971040964, -0.04672755300998688, -0.02030126005411148, -0.01952735148370266, 0.012881282716989517, 0.01717003434896469, -0.03673044592142105, 0.004637167323380709, -0.00954370852559805, 0.05749814584851265, -0.007058293092995882, -0.008788020350039005, 0.012173663824796677, 0.0013539944775402546, -0.048027340322732925, -0.03259230777621269, 0.03200797364115715, 0.006278228480368853, 0.029574135318398476, -0.0013793010730296373, -0.052307430654764175, -0.0028464116621762514, -0.05812479183077812, 0.02958277054131031, -0.036970388144254684, -0.0028955568559467793, -0.019650526344776154, 0.025222623720765114, 0.06397435069084167, 0.030487187206745148, 0.040599748492240906, 0.01979411020874977, -0.04316934570670128, 0.040649108588695526, -0.003956248518079519, -0.07529338449239731, -0.010815736837685108, -0.02998202107846737, -0.015559278428554535, -0.021481482312083244, -0.006625283043831587, 0.0169114600867033, 0.037331126630306244, 0.012279313057661057, 0.008399877697229385, 0.025427663698792458, 0.01728481613099575, -0.009594518691301346, 0.018087036907672882, -0.09503276646137238, -0.017078088596463203, 0.005164674017578363, -0.01801249012351036, -0.01488619577139616, 0.021355601027607918, -0.017377609387040138, 0.02600259892642498, 0.011705970391631126, -0.005235112272202969, -0.04101661965250969, 0.027141932398080826, 0.006068541668355465, 0.015235237777233124, -0.045632511377334595, -0.011527732945978642, -0.03401623293757439, -0.021262504160404205, -0.02240162342786789, -0.01712588593363762, 0.029546979814767838, -0.01144104078412056, -0.003613581182435155, 0.020214049145579338, 0.04024151712656021, -0.018310941755771637, 0.0007600294193252921, 0.015613865107297897, 0.021449225023388863, 0.005421594250947237, 0.03843880444765091, -0.022414278239011765, -0.024775885045528412, 0.020928623154759407, -0.036976270377635956, -0.03851538524031639, 0.02116471901535988, -0.04023785516619682, 0.016539260745048523, 0.011480013839900494, 0.027071839198470116, -0.0008190519874915481, 0.03669603914022446, -0.004901375155895948, -0.006548506207764149, -0.0047620004042983055, 0.005007691215723753, 0.027758536860346794, -0.006205385085195303, 0.02860056795179844, 0.003617221722379327, -0.017706427723169327, 0.023400170728564262, 0.023770103231072426, 0.041372377425432205, -0.006034681107848883, 0.04616270214319229, -0.03364558145403862, 0.026168495416641235, -0.002190361265093088, -0.03728852793574333, 0.04346854239702225, 0.05489127337932587, -0.003088909899815917, 0.005377727560698986, -0.005490513518452644, 0.01533515565097332, -0.09148524701595306, -0.01095488853752613, 0.01902114413678646, -0.0022843119222670794, 0.040723271667957306, -0.07412534207105637, 0.04342732951045036, 0.03517287224531174, -0.07690779119729996, -0.0037132378201931715, 0.017340037971735, 0.008185404352843761, -0.02492530085146427, -0.004644461441785097, 0.011785964481532574, 0.04690588638186455, 0.04097878560423851, 0.062017615884542465, -0.020462315529584885, 0.05966565012931824, 0.00891107227653265, -0.011538304388523102, -0.03686309605836868, 0.011470957659184933, 0.023928629234433174, -0.02795593813061714, 0.04954397678375244, -0.02524522691965103, -0.025732604786753654, -0.016696106642484665, -0.044707413762807846, -0.02143363654613495, 0.001484583248384297, 0.0225239135324955, -0.019588425755500793, 0.032764140516519547, 0.05006870999932289, -0.010408156551420689, -0.018338274210691452, -0.012254898436367512, -0.028948025777935982, 0.0304931178689003, -0.05975627526640892, 0.028406919911503792, -0.005276800133287907, -0.024014689028263092, 0.01871618814766407, 0.01077592745423317, -0.028140757232904434, -0.017236368730664253, -0.0032978735398501158, -0.01529003120958805, 0.03755779191851616, -0.005439245142042637, 0.02279110997915268, -0.031240802258253098, 0.022532057017087936, 0.035360902547836304, -0.007230616640299559, -0.04262421652674675, 0.03183234855532646, -0.013262602500617504, -0.06269080936908722, -0.0026334712747484446, -0.0027546093333512545, 0.012485906481742859, -0.04214613139629364, -0.03493921086192131, 0.0055808136239647865, 0.028725847601890564, -0.052851755172014236, 0.03092232346534729, -0.01887374371290207, 0.027355168014764786, 0.021858979016542435, 0.015105039812624454, 0.03516986221075058, -0.02665671333670616, 0.03951488062739372, -0.04178127273917198, 0.08634179830551147, 0.020418286323547363, 0.0009260986116714776, -0.023207731544971466, -0.017134616151452065, -0.022404570132493973, -0.007845686748623848, 0.022080736234784126, -0.010034983977675438, 0.0175602026283741, 0.008155028335750103, 0.03507494926452637, -0.011859752237796783, -0.017104918137192726, 0.01861993595957756, 0.009194966405630112, -0.016359349712729454, 0.01036283653229475, -0.025531895458698273, 0.00876312330365181, -0.026903877034783363, -0.006616372615098953, -0.019848598167300224, 0.009513214230537415, 0.022164568305015564, 0.006379637401551008, 0.031253524124622345, 0.05065909028053284, -0.05151556059718132, 0.04642139747738838, 0.008275906555354595, 0.01359427347779274, 0.01985340379178524, -0.01795957051217556, -0.031287264078855515, -0.0008468192536383867, -0.06691539287567139, -0.032104428857564926, 0.03034551441669464, 0.019214151427149773, 0.006491863168776035, -0.053360048681497574, -0.0005540001438930631, 0.021340535953640938, -0.03717181831598282, 0.0017584150191396475, 0.04002285376191139, 0.0077967289835214615, -0.01588962972164154, 0.02247135154902935, 0.009466568939387798, 0.026570957154035568, 0.019575534388422966, 0.03797711059451103, 0.03734534978866577, 0.023901021108031273, 0.013977844268083572, -0.0018219006014987826, -0.022491419687867165, -0.02470557764172554, -0.0052951364777982235, -0.004187268670648336, 0.055315278470516205, -0.04164495691657066, -0.018751973286271095, 0.03603942319750786, 0.03272373601794243, 0.0037716946098953485, 0.007935677655041218, -0.014908491633832455, 0.08927807956933975, -0.013575286604464054, -0.014379079453647137, -0.05418485030531883, -0.01376326847821474, -0.034819722175598145, 0.026474792510271072, -0.0007374838460236788, 0.017339138314127922, -0.009201888926327229, 0.03734422102570534, -0.002037342172116041, 0.024931183084845543, -0.02532867342233658, -0.02057068794965744, 0.028343914076685905, -0.026137685403227806, 0.015948817133903503, 0.0027766043785959482, 0.004514598753303289, 0.0029612889047712088, -0.024859648197889328, 0.003158861305564642, 0.012687970884144306, 0.02950861118733883, -0.024616915732622147, -0.014615267515182495, 0.011965938843786716, 0.021359600126743317, -0.09792597591876984, -0.022561203688383102, -0.021372808143496513, -0.006436362862586975, -0.004282275214791298, -0.0035840137861669064 ]
<p>I have a time series $x_t$. If I use the transformation $u_t = log(x_t) - log(x_{t-1})$, my new time series $u_t$ has properties of white noise (random). I wonder whether there is any practical interpretation for $u_t$?</p> <p>Thanks for your help.</p>
74,058
[ -0.0012283215764909983, -0.012180718593299389, 0.0018708283314481378, -0.026764556765556335, 0.02997659705579281, 0.022253097966313362, -0.0072434693574905396, -0.026508567854762077, -0.00040236461791209877, -0.06571106612682343, 0.014245949685573578, 0.0316372886300087, 0.0361538790166378, 0.030842192471027374, 0.0576699823141098, 0.02630612440407276, -0.02164299041032791, -0.016392435878515244, -0.021831052377820015, -0.012217462062835693, 0.024944502860307693, 0.01605825684964657, 0.021870318800210953, -0.014552811160683632, -0.028468439355492592, 0.04394478350877762, -0.035814668983221054, -0.0030713428277522326, 0.022024907171726227, 0.10053014010190964, -0.02051592245697975, 0.006892943289130926, -0.015477164648473263, 0.04896707087755203, -0.0012600328773260117, 0.021989529952406883, -0.009983903728425503, -0.03721623122692108, 0.00756031833589077, 0.03189210966229439, -0.046449411660432816, -0.01759284920990467, -0.02215542271733284, 0.03473161160945892, -0.00031613672035746276, 0.04513905942440033, -0.03106231801211834, -0.0326199010014534, 0.01694171503186226, -0.013812761753797531, 0.1048617884516716, -0.02387961372733116, 0.005475122947245836, 0.018364816904067993, -0.007350219413638115, 0.017910217866301537, 0.08112771809101105, 0.05459374561905861, -0.04008231684565544, -0.027931824326515198, -0.001935850828886032, -0.006514992099255323, -0.0002918270183727145, -0.02781684510409832, 0.0018208123510703444, 0.02490432746708393, -0.02498614601790905, -0.023306112736463547, 0.03293134272098541, 0.011129962280392647, 0.02726094424724579, 0.008911492303013802, 0.042378876358270645, -0.00823694746941328, 0.02807544358074665, -0.03140991926193237, 0.011588339693844318, -0.00607618922367692, 0.026499807834625244, 0.0297183059155941, 0.004304921720176935, -0.010468853637576103, 0.031745027750730515, 0.009443885646760464, 0.00613413006067276, -0.008085247129201889, 0.054356031119823456, -0.03270323947072029, 0.05224493518471718, 0.0636662095785141, 0.010345671325922012, -0.005214839242398739, 0.019267883151769638, 0.0036242634523659945, -0.03507065773010254, 0.035573624074459076, 0.003948096185922623, 0.01615706831216812, 0.012715407647192478, -0.0007781230378895998, 0.0029375983867794275, -0.03450746089220047, 0.04235369339585304, 0.03383450210094452, -0.029581544920802116, -0.006854042876511812, -0.005549528170377016, 0.009214265272021294, 0.009859278798103333, -0.041102245450019836, -0.04496651887893677, -0.000033889064070535824, 0.00018360500689595938, -0.020291730761528015, 0.051203250885009766, 0.02623753994703293, -0.012537380680441856, 0.0112784244120121, 0.017083970829844475, 0.03227168694138527, 0.022759588435292244, -0.025131750851869583, 0.05893600732088089, 0.005157967563718557, -0.04647881165146828, 0.033629000186920166, 0.008048061281442642, 0.0005489321774803102, -0.05225099250674248, 0.0795128345489502, -0.02145460806787014, -0.041608355939388275, 0.05180402845144272, 0.022127147763967514, 0.04853593185544014, -0.00784267671406269, -0.08869963139295578, -0.057665057480335236, 0.05521678179502487, -0.01386840920895338, 0.01843956671655178, -0.06831425428390503, 0.03998338431119919, 0.01854560896754265, 0.017411356791853905, 0.022785848006606102, 0.024678029119968414, -0.010176155716180801, 0.025738205760717392, 0.0004246303578838706, -0.01895930804312229, -0.02827189676463604, -0.011935845017433167, -0.050096847116947174, 0.0391925647854805, -0.07701272517442703, 0.013298491016030312, 0.03132334351539612, -0.04023027792572975, -0.023142822086811066, 0.051243748515844345, 0.007006762083619833, -0.0024415813386440277, 0.0014541062992066145, 0.0010239908006042242, -0.03457902744412422, 0.07259669154882431, 0.003158845007419586, 0.005341927520930767, 0.009626779705286026, 0.009026902727782726, 0.0031388401985168457, 0.04356765374541283, 0.07185835391283035, 0.034242793917655945, 0.004113978240638971, -0.00976516306400299, -0.001712675904855132, 0.01837324909865856, -0.00996890664100647, -0.01687638834118843, 0.00035433191806077957, -0.04099021106958389, -0.0087260277941823, -0.002259721513837576, 0.01920964941382408, -0.004042176529765129, -0.002826447831466794, 0.06433074176311493, -0.0626506432890892, -0.02904219925403595, -0.03521158546209335, -0.011509719304740429, -0.01810305006802082, 0.01178062241524458, 0.02669433131814003, -0.010583654046058655, 0.04089558124542236, -0.018962495028972626, -0.03322248533368111, -0.003632676787674427, 0.0057735806331038475, 0.010296296328306198, -0.03615864738821983, 0.010911541990935802, 0.011233959347009659, 0.007977663539350033, -0.005132749211043119, 0.03866599127650261, -0.02144336700439453, -0.021574649959802628, -0.005609575659036636, -0.029675735160708427, 0.029356934130191803, -0.03483273461461067, 0.009099764749407768, 0.04414067789912224, -0.045786526054143906, 0.00886632688343525, 0.024422992020845413, -0.030475525185465813, 0.04396072402596474, 0.06681223213672638, 0.01591298170387745, 0.011943573132157326, 0.032680217176675797, 0.01755385845899582, 0.021013259887695312, -0.02457764931023121, -0.05424776300787926, -0.04285530745983124, 0.012233572080731392, 0.0424262136220932, 0.07357706874608994, -0.006640613544732332, -0.0026100201066583395, 0.0706535205245018, 0.011065486818552017, 0.023481683805584908, 0.03830023854970932, -0.002635680604726076, -0.0043583703227341175, -0.0029590362682938576, 0.008661666885018349, 0.025601081550121307, -0.0329035222530365, -0.0074829584918916225, -0.003317272523418069, 0.05025412514805794, -0.032555002719163895, -0.044946882873773575, 0.027648726478219032, -0.004987711552530527, 0.03892073035240173, -0.026524944230914116, -0.01299182791262865, 0.05028243735432625, -0.029647773131728172, 0.0095862140879035, 0.004972764290869236, 0.007455477025359869, 0.02977626398205757, -0.009458305314183235, 0.001967138610780239, 0.026178203523159027, 0.02225244976580143, -0.013722102157771587, -0.00865434855222702, 0.03497973829507828, -0.023360474035143852, -0.0024011514615267515, -0.022982697933912277, -0.041744258254766464, -0.028158895671367645, 0.013767042197287083, 0.03562077879905701, 0.010056953877210617, 0.008768824860453606, -0.0404084213078022, -0.051778655499219894, -0.0033802350517362356, 0.008837609551846981, 0.011559633538126945, -0.0021657138131558895, -0.029329171404242516, 0.03552279248833656, -0.009933510795235634, -0.00440732529386878, 0.035793207585811615, -0.016533732414245605, 0.031147319823503494, 0.025078997015953064, -0.019365515559911728, -0.05995391681790352, -0.04278376325964928, -0.02508808672428131, 0.009619437158107758, -0.010769877582788467, -0.04159113019704819, 0.0895175039768219, -0.0205015167593956, -0.007863272912800312, -0.006160371005535126, -0.06283474713563919, -0.015433153137564659, -0.047258976846933365, 0.01512201689183712, 0.015512841753661633, -0.02418295107781887, 0.06001409515738487, 0.011026480235159397, -0.056280024349689484, -0.009481383487582207, -0.05972817912697792, -0.07265914976596832, 0.03081103041768074, -0.024694224819540977, 0.055959977209568024, 0.00024684416712261736, -0.0700945109128952, 0.06653391569852829, 0.029793482273817062, -0.04369991645216942, -0.04637764021754265, -0.013434447348117828, -0.01980520598590374, -0.04232161492109299, 0.011102366261184216, 0.019962875172495842, 0.0001359275629511103, 0.04079777002334595, 0.020819412544369698, 0.017041422426700592, 0.013932361267507076, 0.006868785247206688, -0.023655731230974197, 0.035085104405879974, -0.03536231815814972, 0.020055444911122322, 0.020018864423036575, -0.018229316920042038, -0.0024933377280831337, 0.0006220206269063056, 0.008663809858262539, 0.008692481555044651, 0.04514715448021889, -0.05665348842740059, 0.07001245766878128, 0.03875279054045677, 0.008945786394178867, -0.02518322877585888, 0.059808194637298584, -0.019181590527296066, -0.011243510991334915, -0.06133288890123367, 0.007033968809992075, 0.01998227648437023, 0.01886596344411373, 0.03427933529019356, 0.036661285907030106, 0.049103107303380966, -0.01266874186694622, -0.01881307177245617, -0.004491952247917652, -0.02496415004134178, 0.022007130086421967, 0.003529756795614958, -0.014780381694436073, 0.03717335686087608, 0.037562448531389236, 0.03330772742629051, -0.028759706765413284, -0.0660591870546341, -0.016897814348340034, -0.03409070149064064, -0.001352660357952118, -0.006734687369316816, 0.05264784023165703, 0.01060160156339407, 0.003189078764989972, 0.03650107979774475, -0.02595335803925991, 0.02115258388221264, -0.0048087895847857, -0.06041734665632248, 0.029585300013422966, -0.02507578209042549, 0.0017419483046978712, -0.040818486362695694, -0.021270737051963806, 0.042509473860263824, -0.018613167107105255, -0.02118065021932125, 0.015984877943992615, 0.013419879600405693, -0.07193770259618759, -0.010135611519217491, 0.01569756679236889, -0.02523583546280861, -0.02877679280936718, -0.006072706542909145, 0.008936743251979351, -0.026251668110489845, 0.03551341965794563, 0.03432368114590645, 0.038810845464468, 0.003184101777151227, 0.00533970957621932, 0.018995579332113266, 0.0033413469791412354, 0.0004660450213123113, -0.0001688220800133422, -0.02095797285437584, -0.03798392042517662, 0.0661497488617897, 0.015784990042448044, 0.04306440427899361, 0.026184964925050735, 0.004709574393928051, -0.027888089418411255, -0.06255271285772324, -0.010101242922246456, 0.05952891334891319, 0.007338658906519413, 0.03487859666347504, 0.030239565297961235, 0.06363179534673691, 0.01023181527853012, -0.04578689858317375, 0.012604535557329655, 0.0622146800160408, 0.0005120917339809239, 0.003397436114028096, -0.0048983655869960785, -0.010228064842522144, 0.025011597201228142, 0.008693564683198929, 0.0219231266528368, -0.009409945458173752, -0.03709528222680092, -0.021454572677612305, 0.014099051244556904, 0.03555329889059067, -0.024576013907790184, -0.04066973552107811, 0.028446076437830925, 0.0469815619289875, 0.027897750958800316, -0.024566231295466423, 0.04498254135251045, 0.02528451755642891, 0.024339165538549423, 0.06397254765033722, 0.012663250789046288, -0.07655946165323257, 0.03161950409412384, 0.018824458122253418, 0.0003266672429163009, -0.0378098227083683, -0.009273934178054333, -0.04778403416275978, 0.006483257282525301, 0.048070672899484634, -0.0015094017144292593, 0.04226704314351082, -0.010350874625146389, 0.0009488300420343876, 0.015213477425277233, -0.01742491126060486, -0.01865447871387005, 0.014508439227938652, 0.009237123653292656, 0.034139104187488556, -0.01803557761013508, -0.021259725093841553, -0.06077029928565025, -0.007389554753899574, -0.014831923879683018, 0.06920907646417618, -0.022076696157455444, -0.008809646591544151, -0.012593750841915607, 0.06931760907173157, -0.006270039826631546, -0.061964213848114014, 0.02701893262565136, 0.0121485386043787, 0.005480291787534952, 0.006050598807632923, 0.0102875716984272, -0.04760054871439934, -0.00447266548871994, 0.009129238314926624, 0.010964721441268921, -0.0001927380944835022, -0.007270572241395712, 0.026871884241700172, 0.02037019096314907, 0.011064807884395123, 0.04762539640069008, 0.06564510613679886, 0.0016064263181760907, 0.0035019831266254187, -0.01593262329697609, 0.05344756320118904, -0.07113450765609741, 0.02147231251001358, -0.024213938042521477, -0.003897963324561715, -0.032434362918138504, 0.04433857649564743, 0.006143567617982626, 0.03561472147703171, -0.006979574915021658, -0.027686158195137978, -0.029209911823272705, 0.026584360748529434, 0.007231951225548983, -0.02338613010942936, -0.009209532290697098, 0.006799088325351477, -0.015365283004939556, -0.012998758815228939, 0.007094399072229862, -0.010338246822357178, 0.007749853190034628, 0.028924254700541496, -0.0055109551176428795, -0.0024147420190274715, 0.005072667729109526, 0.011939751915633678, 0.03089955262839794, -0.009271000511944294, 0.023642979562282562, 0.021966371685266495, -0.012885576114058495, 0.010848036967217922, -0.04166049137711525, 0.024999292567372322, 0.006815640721470118, -0.01780971884727478, 0.0626167431473732, -0.06235026940703392, 0.027744930237531662, -0.008526458404958248, 0.001106226583942771, -0.08240138739347458, -0.045991189777851105, 0.023531978949904442, -0.011016082018613815, 0.006455738563090563, -0.046903058886528015, -0.00007330154039664194, -0.00545887416228652, -0.033359870314598083, -0.0016003343043848872, 0.06163256615400314, 0.04203775152564049, -0.018171221017837524, -0.025014759972691536, 0.037867456674575806, 0.11551251262426376, 0.0018057217821478844, 0.0037961232010275126, 0.045282766222953796, -0.03894783928990364, -0.042698536068201065, -0.000243803282501176, 0.04607260599732399, -0.038604479283094406, 0.019602470099925995, -0.0039339144714176655, -0.04287361726164818, 0.0025564408861100674, -0.0639372169971466, -0.03419611230492592, 0.023122256621718407, 0.04934271425008774, 0.021417731419205666, -0.02328319475054741, 0.020804647356271744, 0.00818006880581379, -0.009567264467477798, 0.014931516721844673, 0.002828725380823016, -0.0284434724599123, -0.02325635403394699, 0.04426822438836098, 0.020572587847709656, 0.0038341404870152473, 0.045058172196149826, 0.03883024677634239, 0.014008143916726112, -0.0784556046128273, -0.0238890890032053, -0.03169305995106697, 0.008857598528265953, 0.020352041348814964, 0.022067898884415627, 0.033023614436388016, 0.008921889588236809, -0.0543745718896389, -0.044431086629629135, -0.010664919391274452, -0.03560379892587662, 0.06651167571544647, -0.04314757138490677, 0.06823591142892838, 0.034348636865615845, -0.015376434661448002, 0.002593566430732608, 0.012972529977560043, -0.014947373420000076, -0.015572759322822094, -0.030820775777101517, -0.0018842582358047366, 0.011151093058288097, 0.0005744736408814788, -0.014454619027674198, -0.013346846215426922, 0.015914227813482285, 0.04222768917679787, 0.030812866985797882, 0.03879091516137123, 0.0075958846136927605, -0.0004151550820097327, -0.057378653436899185, 0.03669918701052666, -0.04536977410316467, 0.02728579193353653, -0.0329650342464447, 0.019061259925365448, 0.0418962687253952, 0.03225834667682648, -0.013157826848328114, -0.04024549573659897, 0.003184115281328559, -0.06422107666730881, -0.015203705057501793, 0.02388664148747921, -0.017805596813559532, 0.05200556293129921, 0.0029982009436935186, 0.04042933136224747, 0.0007038495969027281, 0.028491469100117683, 0.004724555648863316, -0.06250468641519547, 0.0012340177781879902, -0.022952640429139137, -0.047285087406635284, 0.048081688582897186, -0.04490531608462334, -0.023668555542826653, -0.013409025967121124, -0.04123150557279587, -0.0024800135288387537, 0.011852545663714409, 0.03557659313082695, -0.015773525461554527, 0.0968942865729332, 0.03261617571115494, 0.02515324391424656, -0.013990283012390137, 0.01808800734579563, 0.09241568297147751, 0.055189672857522964, 0.016832079738378525, -0.06734912097454071, -0.02918066829442978, -0.03541604056954384, 0.014018651098012924, -0.030203402042388916, 0.0250801220536232, 0.030709119513630867, 0.012927382253110409, 0.016311492770910263, 0.04826130345463753, -0.008233357220888138, -0.016845250502228737, 0.053496018052101135, -0.028913764283061028, -0.0020401582587510347, 0.02725038304924965, -0.005014352034777403, -0.01119473110884428, 0.01170463114976883, -0.06430743634700775, 0.008795524947345257, -0.020016193389892578, -0.03568150848150253, 0.007134010083973408, -0.02706165798008442, 0.010793795809149742, -0.004687052220106125, -0.03482766076922417, 0.012417415156960487, 0.031717654317617416, 0.012783447280526161, -0.028611179441213608, -0.008681810460984707, -0.023253055289387703, -0.006637708283960819, 0.02282721735537052, 0.02781820297241211, 0.02588650956749916, -0.015849877148866653, 0.00949402991682291, -0.0031866533681750298, -0.018376346677541733, -0.020536063238978386, -0.030416572466492653, 0.02230200730264187, -0.007893646135926247, 0.017124488949775696, -0.006623480934649706, 0.02993512712419033, -0.018379999324679375, -0.03830822557210922, 0.01510725449770689, 0.01869426853954792, 0.024764742702245712, -0.04126138985157013, -0.03110423870384693, -0.05647541955113411, -0.001419080886989832, -0.011535623110830784, 0.04202543571591377, 0.018501609563827515, -0.03839616850018501, -0.005449154879897833, -0.006105970125645399, 0.024783482775092125, -0.013392808847129345, -0.033978067338466644, -0.007444349117577076, -0.007728439290076494, -0.031151413917541504, -0.023055965080857277, -0.00002294164733029902, -0.04211023822426796, 0.037327274680137634, -0.016917258501052856, -0.021523596718907356, -0.018459856510162354, -0.06206127628684044, 0.03915441036224365, -0.025033319368958473, -0.005698115099221468, -0.05089019984006882, -0.020419016480445862, 0.009705917909741402, 0.05301016569137573, 0.026490624994039536, -0.0027848496101796627, -0.013288430869579315, 0.050323549658060074, 0.011601943522691727, -0.057675495743751526, -0.0001970060693565756, 0.014340512454509735, -0.007986477576196194, -0.004013723693788052, 0.0009122059564106166, 0.022660695016384125, 0.0375114344060421, 0.00015817070379853249, -0.05006199702620506, 0.04018751531839371, -0.017841724678874016, 0.0011786004761233926, 0.009123030118644238, -0.05216897279024124, 0.0012728000292554498, 0.013155531138181686, -0.0012529846280813217, -0.0017043935367837548, -0.04883938655257225, -0.03272600471973419, -0.01398893166333437, -0.025637483224272728, -0.006986256688833237, -0.030917542055249214, -0.0034814171958714724, -0.01916300319135189, 0.03721383959054947, -0.03507870063185692, -0.012273390777409077, -0.01662764884531498, -0.00007973326137289405, -0.002096479292958975, -0.022031007334589958, 0.0047349450178444386, 0.015457753092050552, 0.013983014039695263, -0.02124239131808281, 0.03465217351913452, 0.0051996042020618916, 0.0012274568434804678, -0.0423734150826931, 0.029566187411546707, -0.03730607032775879, 0.03576458618044853, -0.03388433903455734, -0.030991218984127045, 0.07000458240509033, -0.057948291301727295, -0.024221161380410194, 0.05641814321279526, -0.005303564481437206, 0.03789360076189041, -0.0017453584587201476, 0.003925790078938007, -0.006056484300643206, 0.036294493824243546, 0.003880477976053953, -0.004807690624147654, -0.03622812777757645, -0.021175237372517586, -0.0015689636347815394, 0.0013945100363343954, 0.0041126832365989685, 0.022820988669991493, -0.016864020377397537, -0.003407509531825781, 0.049700457602739334, 0.003845158265903592, -0.0023539995308965445, 0.012276511639356613, 0.0035070849116891623, -0.0029332339763641357, -0.003441059496253729, -0.019725270569324493, 0.04991302639245987, 0.04843977838754654, -0.020115822553634644, -0.005095887463539839, -0.007173104677349329, -0.02988462708890438, -0.07306642085313797, 0.006123722065240145, 0.03344110772013664, -0.022177744656801224, 0.0452045314013958, -0.03718523308634758, -0.006323740351945162, 0.015327461995184422, -0.018238049000501633, -0.01898610219359398, -0.015675198286771774, -0.029336636886000633, -0.04251095652580261, -0.008044918067753315, -0.03805401176214218, 0.034562233835458755, 0.03848748281598091, 0.014021601527929306, 0.012371107004582882, 0.029938723891973495, -0.004114856012165546, -0.0005159824504517019, -0.01216891035437584, 0.03489091619849205, 0.02454427443444729, -0.02292642742395401, 0.04811394214630127, -0.0516299232840538, -0.0397455096244812, 0.03746466338634491, -0.009638728573918343, 0.04329981282353401, -0.011301790364086628, 0.02669510245323181, 0.016274496912956238, 0.007333194836974144, 0.04392661154270172, -0.040104471147060394, -0.022397203370928764, 0.019147858023643494, 0.0251252893358469, 0.016745151951909065, -0.0015137895243242383, -0.009908906184136868, -0.02681131288409233, -0.021477680653333664, -0.0367206409573555, -0.008840970695018768, -0.008038131520152092, -0.01327001303434372, 0.008136805146932602, -0.015225660987198353, -0.02468271739780903, -0.027677658945322037, 0.03635259345173836, -0.020317118614912033, -0.004979679826647043, 0.05948401615023613, 0.0201525017619133, -0.024872366338968277, 0.0001061383809428662, 0.005317981820553541, -0.05386824905872345, 0.03212375193834305, 0.023589923977851868, -0.010290060192346573, -0.06462536007165909, -0.04558639973402023, -0.006036621518433094, -0.027426045387983322, -0.046904079616069794, 0.0035644371528178453, -0.009188802912831306, 0.040282994508743286, -0.016947653144598007, -0.004723776131868362, 0.01429681945592165, -0.021821144968271255, -0.028569377958774567, -0.03810130059719086, 0.07966633886098862, 0.009632011875510216, -0.011484757997095585, -0.037153180688619614, -0.03981989249587059, -0.021221686154603958, 0.016919661313295364, 0.04283054172992706, 0.008479783311486244, -0.002009353367611766, 0.02292792685329914, 0.031087279319763184, 0.021936923265457153, -0.05047549307346344, 0.0329437181353569, -0.0467296838760376, 0.005705478135496378, -0.017436092719435692, -0.04313409700989723, -0.004681047052145004, 0.0023040631785988808, -0.004817083943635225, -0.03681544214487076, -0.02851603738963604, 0.003695929190143943, -0.012666326016187668, 0.040771935135126114, 0.00041532531031407416, -0.027682477608323097, 0.03339853137731552, 0.009184309281408787, 0.013036529533565044, 0.00645294226706028, -0.008950815536081791, -0.07187598198652267, 0.03580030798912048, -0.03335113823413849, -0.03547417372465134, -0.0139309111982584, 0.03977841138839722, 0.006882295478135347, -0.024672510102391243, -0.060945428907871246, 0.008970692753791809, -0.03682605177164078, 0.0237039215862751, 0.046847712248563766, 0.004304237198084593, 0.03333649784326553, 0.01058154832571745, 0.008186731487512589, 0.0074990009889006615, -0.000714680296368897, -0.01631733402609825, 0.02634449303150177, 0.02649536356329918, -0.04168499633669853, -0.013443524949252605, -0.016901982948184013, -0.018685752525925636, 0.01833495870232582, 0.017001774162054062, 0.058893557637929916, -0.04323729872703552, -0.005315952468663454, 0.02221568673849106, -0.015338112600147724, 0.007130345795303583, 0.011129699647426605, -0.028007879853248596, 0.04213826358318329, -0.014514814130961895, 0.0058036018162965775, -0.04273580014705658, -0.0377708375453949, -0.03943994268774986, 0.01526948343962431, 0.043489158153533936, 0.011863687075674534, -0.025644490495324135, 0.02781754359602928, -0.021752454340457916, 0.013785880990326405, 0.01702733337879181, -0.05065121129155159, -0.00439096475020051, 0.030945155769586563, -0.0216678474098444, 0.010456705465912819, -0.03973293676972389, -0.03585074841976166, -0.04688824713230133, 0.011177107691764832, 0.0478619746863842, 0.0158698633313179, 0.016507240012288094, -0.03426351770758629, -0.004326432012021542, 0.06614567339420319, -0.05487111955881119, 0.011494799517095089, -0.006617673672735691, 0.021804699674248695, 0.007060229312628508, -0.01726481504738331 ]
<p>I am unclear about how to interpret the value of the Standard Error of the Mean (SEM) directly. For example, when a mean is reported as 5.00 + 0.50SEM, how do you directly relate the 0.50 to 5.00?</p> <p>To quickly run through the basic theory concerning the standard error: </p> <ol> <li>The standard deviation (SD) is a measure of dispersion around the mean </li> <li>The SEM is the SD of the sampling distribution for the sample mean</li> <li>This sampling distribution is derived from the means of an infinite number of samples from a statistical population and is normally distributed according to the Central Limit Theorem</li> <li>In a normal distribution, 68.3% of (randomly selected) values fall within +1SD, 95.4% +2SD and 99.7% +3SD</li> <li>The SEM decreases with increasing sample size</li> </ol> <p>QUESTION 1: Given points 2) and 4) is it correct to interpret the SEM in the same way as SD as a descriptive statistic? That is, for a sample with mean 5.00 and SEM 0.50, is it correct to conclude the true population mean lies between 4.50 and 5.50 with probability 68.3%?</p> <p>QUESTION 2: For a given statistical population being sampled, does the sampling distribution change with sample size (given point 5)? i.e. should point 3) be: "...derived from the means of an infinite number of samples of a given size from a statistical population..."? </p> <p>QUESTION 3: Since the SEM is not calculated directly but estimated from the SD of a sample, what effect does departure from a normal distribution of the sample have on calculation of the SEM? Put another way, if a sample has for example a highly skewed distribution, calculating the SD is inappropriate (it is a property of a normal distribution only), so can the SEM still be estimated reliably from the SD?</p>
48,370
[ -0.0334208644926548, -0.041763998568058014, 0.01695280335843563, 0.009572496637701988, 0.027489859610795975, 0.02399314008653164, -0.004396901465952396, -0.0399869829416275, 0.0036215067375451326, -0.02254331111907959, 0.024458114057779312, 0.018244074657559395, 0.05748029798269272, 0.026967806741595268, 0.03147085756063461, 0.004137550015002489, -0.016510680317878723, 0.011375555768609047, -0.010121595114469528, -0.030094964429736137, 0.014340863563120365, 0.05118357390165329, 0.013994256034493446, -0.04453771561384201, -0.07217700779438019, 0.021247517317533493, 0.029529517516493797, 0.005811908282339573, 0.029744306579232216, 0.05974763259291649, -0.037161827087402344, 0.008156676776707172, 0.04346124082803726, 0.03161508962512016, 0.02967550978064537, 0.015128185972571373, -0.024274548515677452, -0.03322445973753929, 0.010256504639983177, 0.009860247373580933, -0.07441148906946182, 0.017572948709130287, 0.0029147237073630095, -0.003831143258139491, -0.009188231080770493, -0.00005055373185314238, -0.01981416903436184, -0.051345717161893845, 0.01544465497136116, -0.04541459679603577, 0.0822719857096672, 0.014823639765381813, 0.010149928741157055, 0.01661340519785881, -0.0007318462012335658, -0.006307666189968586, 0.007126310840249062, 0.03634956106543541, -0.007881337776780128, -0.018494999036192894, 0.012032873928546906, -0.0145961819216609, -0.015610957518219948, -0.02763381600379944, -0.005743066314607859, 0.02306967042386532, -0.017242291942238808, -0.02325461432337761, 0.03386349231004715, 0.005278366152197123, 0.01568683423101902, 0.03765182942152023, 0.0014928564196452498, 0.028652634471654892, 0.044785819947719574, -0.03387714549899101, 0.006307702045887709, -0.0015116437571123242, 0.02040073648095131, 0.04950627312064171, 0.012275050394237041, -0.0043441783636808395, 0.06903228163719177, 0.020516926422715187, 0.040719762444496155, -0.027067532762885094, 0.0744805634021759, -0.02371676079928875, 0.03872976079583168, 0.01491764560341835, -0.008290822617709637, 0.026868028566241264, 0.042226098477840424, -0.025543944910168648, -0.027766965329647064, 0.0510849766433239, -0.03186348080635071, 0.06743624806404114, -0.0016257305396720767, -0.00749000022187829, -0.011117693968117237, -0.07084084302186966, 0.06508439779281616, 0.03089744783937931, -0.020589958876371384, -0.025607245042920113, -0.0061586229130625725, 0.015147512778639793, -0.01288185641169548, -0.053069859743118286, -0.005127890966832638, 0.015363232232630253, 0.016200900077819824, 0.03434866666793823, 0.014806505292654037, 0.019364919513463974, 0.00466987444087863, -0.0058687059208750725, 0.04711683839559555, 0.049600571393966675, 0.027460593730211258, -0.010776791721582413, -0.005657086614519358, -0.015596854500472546, -0.041154760867357254, 0.01311713270843029, -0.003379598492756486, -0.038668714463710785, -0.025712473317980766, 0.03875197470188141, 0.025073224678635597, 0.007794195786118507, 0.027614012360572815, 0.005622080061584711, 0.037841007113456726, -0.004174635745584965, -0.06064341962337494, -0.06054665893316269, 0.05264943093061447, 0.010907003656029701, -0.01813891902565956, -0.08409018814563751, -0.009903070516884327, 0.026626721024513245, -0.008042728528380394, 0.025429150089621544, 0.05084994435310364, -0.02293834649026394, 0.03428465500473976, 0.030130494385957718, -0.06688711047172546, 0.01224538218230009, -0.02491610497236252, -0.033294666558504105, -0.015027625486254692, -0.0802077129483223, 0.016770122572779655, 0.017749063670635223, 0.021245423704385757, -0.0477878712117672, 0.017536208033561707, -0.02838880568742752, 0.002891582902520895, -0.0053870948031544685, 0.03808971866965294, -0.017697861418128014, 0.06543657183647156, -0.0016922104405239224, 0.02483510971069336, 0.0067858207039535046, 0.010900785215198994, 0.0197038222104311, -0.019221162423491478, 0.0010953524615615606, 0.033840361982584, -0.035140201449394226, 0.02238621935248375, -0.024682074785232544, 0.013562262058258057, 0.009052800014615059, -0.06324143707752228, 0.026512665674090385, 0.012406968511641026, 0.00308205490000546, 0.01287804264575243, 0.03967547044157982, 0.004099609330296516, 0.008235854096710682, -0.014988822862505913, -0.026320768520236015, -0.05739375576376915, -0.08755122125148773, -0.014059857465326786, -0.02360980026423931, -0.02142992801964283, 0.03938988968729973, 0.008391199633479118, 0.04536521062254906, -0.012442365288734436, 0.003831358626484871, -0.022375084459781647, -0.0009910381631925702, 0.07945006340742111, -0.04124641790986061, -0.00019437659648247063, 0.05593467503786087, 0.021640654653310776, -0.0009118602029047906, 0.006466682069003582, -0.01864444836974144, -0.05792814493179321, 0.0038408825639635324, -0.005193744320422411, 0.018981540575623512, 0.012431054376065731, -0.030081188306212425, -0.009916798211634159, 0.021536588668823242, 0.012887208722531796, 0.08365271240472794, -0.015665577724575996, 0.0655447393655777, 0.04290706664323807, -0.0058559211902320385, 0.005012829788029194, 0.02688273973762989, 0.018518684431910515, 0.0013741868315264583, -0.02147030457854271, -0.006782250013202429, -0.04730862006545067, -0.01272993441671133, 0.006402909755706787, 0.017856700345873833, -0.018551839515566826, -0.020882252603769302, 0.03573604300618172, -0.004547215532511473, 0.016323385760188103, -0.0077797044068574905, 0.003878494957461953, -0.0025949624832719564, -0.03017381764948368, 0.004483971744775772, 0.025388648733496666, 0.012371501885354519, -0.012175229378044605, 0.022650159895420074, 0.02991471067070961, 0.00366418925113976, 0.05359850078821182, 0.05611531808972359, -0.026132194325327873, 0.024671610444784164, -0.009354212321341038, 0.019846078008413315, 0.02789219655096531, -0.0016546143451705575, -0.009805195033550262, 0.08101454377174377, -0.03273439407348633, -0.008147421292960644, -0.01633819006383419, -0.013361181132495403, 0.014861688017845154, 0.018904410302639008, -0.016298610717058182, -0.003431188641116023, 0.008347084745764732, -0.02057548426091671, 0.002432294189929962, -0.04628528654575348, -0.029711460694670677, -0.003631911939010024, -0.01864508166909218, 0.04161955043673515, -0.01264214888215065, 0.02456640638411045, -0.02552650310099125, -0.02353827655315399, -0.01054471917450428, 0.020487971603870392, -0.01777494139969349, 0.013072912581264973, -0.09000099450349808, -0.013270915485918522, 0.005892277229577303, -0.0436062254011631, 0.01188589259982109, 0.0012256922200322151, 0.02401403896510601, 0.03816935420036316, 0.02210606448352337, -0.03610003739595413, -0.017053162679076195, -0.018077710643410683, 0.00707490649074316, 0.01086737122386694, -0.05014335736632347, 0.07115581631660461, -0.018014654517173767, -0.0073263454250991344, 0.0561768040060997, -0.040063027292490005, -0.0904904156923294, -0.03456435725092888, 0.018794624134898186, -0.004736221861094236, 0.004319971892982721, -0.01526721939444542, 0.018276294693350792, -0.009265156462788582, -0.02132759429514408, -0.051381632685661316, -0.07560407370328903, 0.014168850146234035, 0.014876830391585827, 0.023923570290207863, 0.015432110987603664, -0.011171785183250904, 0.0676717758178711, 0.05298376828432083, -0.02435680851340294, 0.011563675478100777, -0.006693303119391203, 0.007544524502009153, -0.006218148395419121, 0.010410856455564499, 0.005442542489618063, -0.021489311009645462, -0.0012880358844995499, 0.02187846601009369, 0.04649899899959564, 0.01839587278664112, -0.029515177011489868, 0.009381439536809921, -0.009388230741024017, -0.009589972905814648, -0.0350986048579216, 0.04540019482374191, 0.03176731988787651, -0.0484364815056324, -0.0029838739428669214, -0.0030225093942135572, 0.03449048846960068, 0.019406145438551903, -0.0286560021340847, 0.015524770133197308, 0.010112877935171127, -0.015969669446349144, -0.03375184163451195, 0.030131930485367775, 0.023650160059332848, -0.03760272637009621, 0.016728194430470467, 0.014146105386316776, 0.006947997026145458, -0.028524108231067657, 0.017403006553649902, 0.05061342567205429, 0.06958971172571182, -0.017422759905457497, -0.044525664299726486, -0.0014704999048262835, 0.0012896152911707759, -0.01658254861831665, -0.005643227603286505, -0.023602690547704697, 0.06405720114707947, 0.09688420593738556, 0.022624511271715164, -0.0342661514878273, -0.02350614406168461, 0.000507377611938864, -0.09842763841152191, 0.0039886292070150375, -0.028728779405355453, 0.03736799582839012, 0.006667560897767544, 0.03971276059746742, 0.023660272359848022, -0.00966859981417656, 0.005787206348031759, 0.01723085343837738, -0.06066926568746567, 0.04698559641838074, -0.03295313939452171, -0.024994177743792534, -0.02259126305580139, -0.01340397447347641, 0.06154995411634445, -0.002294794423505664, 0.027400409802794456, -0.009382816031575203, 0.029725734144449234, -0.025197723880410194, 0.005485416390001774, 0.008390922099351883, -0.004203843884170055, 0.0064805359579622746, 0.014763080514967442, 0.007257180754095316, -0.04281802475452423, 0.010171358473598957, 0.05423096567392349, -0.023588303476572037, -0.023015689104795456, -0.039024047553539276, 0.03821420297026634, -0.00568293547257781, 0.06651729345321655, 0.03555465489625931, 0.04370337724685669, -0.04212488979101181, 0.043170295655727386, 0.03217469900846481, 0.040763385593891144, 0.022707639262080193, -0.010123955085873604, -0.03884631395339966, -0.047475870698690414, -0.007074849680066109, 0.038966890424489975, -0.007289331406354904, 0.01436492707580328, 0.005558997392654419, 0.08631620556116104, -0.010085119865834713, -0.06738339364528656, 0.04315919056534767, 0.04324730113148689, -0.008524099364876747, 0.022591300308704376, -0.05827866122126579, -0.015371788293123245, -0.027259211987257004, -0.005057608243077993, 0.050280433148145676, 0.04867483675479889, 0.0050526880659163, -0.006278608459979296, 0.02075786702334881, -0.01937614567577839, -0.04925509914755821, 0.002921466948464513, 0.012497945688664913, 0.050693824887275696, 0.01969393528997898, -0.007726548705250025, 0.03533416613936424, -0.00021250142890494317, 0.04236556589603424, 0.0019100483041256666, -0.014437833800911903, -0.07386713474988937, 0.0015626278473064303, 0.030482176691293716, 0.04931250214576721, -0.05159986391663551, 0.05573362484574318, -0.0427202470600605, 0.00998138077557087, 0.011234263889491558, -0.0577927865087986, 0.022556373849511147, -0.02822815254330635, 0.018824022263288498, -0.03536389395594597, -0.01362657267600298, -0.0639955997467041, 0.0022702401038259268, -0.01753196120262146, 0.00588772539049387, -0.05646267533302307, -0.0264485664665699, -0.04171361029148102, 0.0025748093612492085, 0.04083624109625816, 0.08587580174207687, 0.004674478899687529, -0.006375322584062815, -0.0005688577075488865, 0.03684375062584877, -0.011374049820005894, -0.0559811033308506, 0.010911274701356888, -0.02190178632736206, -0.014871614053845406, -0.0004157073562964797, -0.008667515590786934, -0.06327380239963531, 0.03900280222296715, 0.02661416493356228, -0.024910612031817436, -0.014546556398272514, -0.03553641587495804, 0.054162830114364624, 0.02866765856742859, 0.017782064154744148, 0.04973207786679268, -0.011832446791231632, -0.0053872172720730305, 0.011128818616271019, -0.041623953729867935, 0.001234048162586987, -0.024603992700576782, 0.0022063711658120155, -0.030065758153796196, 0.00999912153929472, -0.045819323509931564, 0.03143254667520523, 0.021224673837423325, 0.058524083346128464, -0.0011567058973014355, -0.011722477152943611, 0.03623686358332634, -0.002448558807373047, -0.003378311637789011, 0.023508459329605103, -0.0030924987513571978, 0.05422341823577881, -0.006899746134877205, -0.027360932901501656, 0.03523118421435356, -0.004430538974702358, -0.008786793798208237, 0.023106597363948822, -0.04007977619767189, -0.005076881963759661, -0.020736154168844223, -0.03997302055358887, 0.018360400572419167, -0.027942297980189323, 0.023229744285345078, -0.027964241802692413, 0.04534165561199188, 0.024348059669137, -0.022561850026249886, -0.013549665920436382, 0.02261841483414173, -0.005573060363531113, 0.030599551275372505, -0.021432574838399887, 0.04006550461053848, 0.010384645313024521, 0.017908062785863876, -0.07676022499799728, -0.04587612301111221, 0.005486542358994484, 0.00841271411627531, -0.017308637499809265, -0.00964088924229145, -0.01920873112976551, -0.008827602490782738, -0.03795124590396881, -0.02053898200392723, 0.03152511641383171, -0.012163483537733555, -0.04633704572916031, -0.022423913702368736, 0.02126007340848446, 0.11405680328607559, -0.048521656543016434, -0.0221217330545187, -0.001276358962059021, 0.006826181896030903, -0.033869702368974686, -0.016457898542284966, 0.03981884568929672, -0.03266827389597893, -0.03133006393909454, 0.009847467765212059, -0.006711551919579506, 0.041391145437955856, -0.015550645999610424, -0.026072973385453224, -0.0029008076526224613, -0.005479858256876469, 0.034735094755887985, -0.01710623688995838, -0.0035229315981268883, 0.015767471864819527, 0.037826769053936005, -0.018182145431637764, 0.022884992882609367, -0.022053444758057594, -0.004601816646754742, 0.04710586741566658, 0.03391566872596741, -0.014881491661071777, 0.05292563885450363, 0.06888674944639206, -0.01778201386332512, 0.06018668785691261, 0.006534298416227102, -0.036272358149290085, 0.03223705664277077, 0.00848794262856245, 0.0031610780861228704, 0.018125995993614197, 0.016720237210392952, -0.012052498757839203, -0.041808973997831345, -0.033982452005147934, 0.04150766506791115, 0.04220542684197426, -0.0013245498994365335, 0.015967421233654022, 0.04826520383358002, -0.02003878355026245, -0.0010968254646286368, -0.024562964215874672, 0.006459537893533707, -0.02480214089155197, -0.007202152628451586, 0.05421944707632065, -0.029268866404891014, -0.0011586282635107636, 0.012867642566561699, 0.004534970503300428, -0.013679624535143375, 0.01555536687374115, 0.04419087991118431, 0.004049366805702448, 0.027207734063267708, -0.021407676860690117, -0.024454915896058083, 0.015173993073403835, -0.011451584286987782, 0.0243197213858366, -0.008276741951704025, -0.03171991556882858, 0.029498742893338203, 0.0058504920452833176, 0.002755946945399046, -0.046065911650657654, 0.009349027648568153, -0.0421997494995594, -0.0006493195542134345, 0.00017684194608591497, -0.012919838540256023, -0.009889097884297371, -0.014493281953036785, 0.0110106710344553, -0.018055571243166924, 0.02011938765645027, -0.03342924639582634, -0.08688986301422119, -0.02653382159769535, -0.047974515706300735, -0.06596061587333679, 0.01862948201596737, -0.020862136036157608, -0.0359705314040184, 0.016794608905911446, -0.03836672008037567, 0.041320934891700745, 0.013832221738994122, 0.021505627781152725, -0.03131710737943649, 0.05688074603676796, 0.014975639060139656, 0.02286357432603836, -0.01492926012724638, -0.0077254329808056355, 0.11343351006507874, 0.04200885444879532, -0.005091984290629625, -0.04417700320482254, -0.00264244363643229, 0.00403551384806633, 0.0003378978872206062, 0.03296806663274765, 0.006553766317665577, -0.021227732300758362, 0.004950636997818947, 0.03389575332403183, 0.03622455894947052, -0.001213788171298802, -0.014551765285432339, 0.016103241592645645, -0.016716578975319862, -0.02325654961168766, 0.014412402175366879, -0.005696976091712713, 0.0012929533841088414, 0.007263000123202801, -0.04848635941743851, 0.006736452225595713, 0.009300321340560913, -0.018236074596643448, -0.025464074686169624, 0.010884860530495644, -0.034071184694767, -0.011145892553031445, -0.027784721925854683, -0.02087549678981304, 0.011112605221569538, -0.007910707034170628, -0.03834468498826027, -0.031449925154447556, -0.005588073283433914, -0.053208984434604645, 0.037933629006147385, 0.057236723601818085, -0.012054008431732655, 0.011585631407797337, 0.015396892093122005, 0.04415566101670265, -0.037305377423763275, -0.03743662312626839, 0.002096793381497264, 0.040212344378232956, -0.014239450916647911, -0.00520210899412632, -0.020187145099043846, -0.013837553560733795, -0.01483192853629589, -0.04911983013153076, 0.007034840062260628, 0.014154326170682907, 0.013117477297782898, -0.03948647901415825, -0.03805016726255417, -0.02912479266524315, 0.02433684654533863, -0.020718839019536972, 0.00626148097217083, 0.044180430471897125, -0.018424099311232567, -0.013473952189087868, -0.003507444402202964, 0.001373186125420034, -0.034780725836753845, 0.005719093140214682, -0.014347521588206291, 0.009660095907747746, -0.08979441970586777, 0.03920052945613861, -0.0004955748445354402, 0.0013107496779412031, 0.05552493780851364, -0.006874529644846916, 0.022259637713432312, -0.019909579306840897, -0.06343482434749603, 0.04612957313656807, -0.010937126353383064, 0.015523766167461872, -0.059818100184202194, 0.02151058427989483, 0.012504056096076965, 0.02064605988562107, -0.01943281851708889, -0.0144286397844553, 0.05019615963101387, 0.04087398573756218, -0.008337768726050854, -0.04286973178386688, -0.002701988210901618, 0.029498426243662834, -0.03052014485001564, 0.01853719912469387, -0.010366690345108509, 0.06001422926783562, -0.0006377786048687994, 0.013696840964257717, 0.004904621746391058, 0.016519419848918915, 0.013910222798585892, 0.007644270546734333, 0.0004962182720191777, -0.02414633333683014, 0.0035946685820817947, 0.036462001502513885, -0.024940699338912964, -0.016234759241342545, 0.0175237525254488, -0.03853067383170128, -0.05006149411201477, 0.0038091440219432116, 0.010802626609802246, -0.02345862239599228, -0.0010845032520592213, -0.035453323274850845, -0.004350374918431044, -0.005138523876667023, -0.016311610117554665, -0.007870404981076717, -0.02447361685335636, -0.005000801291316748, -0.01021537370979786, 0.00003647664198069833, 0.005768702831119299, -0.011331825517117977, -0.0072646355256438255, 0.04617340862751007, -0.016708822920918465, 0.004460682161152363, 0.0012960645835846663, 0.001903350348584354, 0.03012196533381939, 0.02784336358308792, -0.021602097898721695, -0.012091884389519691, 0.0809176042675972, -0.01840280555188656, -0.024040408432483673, 0.027699191123247147, -0.012501821853220463, -0.002894285134971142, 0.012625068426132202, 0.01831917092204094, -0.00774094695225358, 0.038282610476017, -0.03964059427380562, -0.005829761736094952, -0.03198622167110443, 0.01467127911746502, 0.008537204004824162, 0.010024718008935452, 0.008293396793305874, 0.02365899458527565, 0.025932474061846733, 0.050311461091041565, 0.034016143530607224, -0.017669757828116417, 0.01725069247186184, 0.03997070714831352, 0.014230388216674328, -0.02421385981142521, 0.015239394269883633, 0.016563137993216515, 0.017361897975206375, 0.07285197079181671, -0.049393512308597565, 0.05032266303896904, -0.044837187975645065, -0.02765740640461445, -0.0960065945982933, -0.032383013516664505, 0.014933000318706036, 0.006405279505997896, 0.011507468298077583, -0.05616536736488342, -0.028624482452869415, 0.017441561445593834, -0.03745635598897934, 0.007104597520083189, -0.02707497589290142, -0.04749148339033127, -0.05018727481365204, 0.026899056509137154, -0.015291097573935986, 0.022537700831890106, 0.02403121069073677, 0.016953736543655396, 0.030280500650405884, 0.021309074014425278, 0.03582792356610298, -0.012908038683235645, -0.04777398705482483, 0.03065050207078457, -0.016962451860308647, -0.06191443279385567, 0.003259070683270693, -0.04088794067502022, -0.005238319281488657, 0.05369670316576958, 0.006970501970499754, 0.02628985233604908, 0.027866840362548828, -0.008336381986737251, -0.03970012813806534, 0.04214920476078987, 0.032263342291116714, -0.002418430522084236, -0.05009988322854042, -0.009693499654531479, 0.016177134588360786, 0.03441961482167244, 0.0011193465907126665, -0.02391413226723671, 0.03771043196320534, -0.01464904472231865, -0.014232225716114044, 0.00802928488701582, -0.01736871711909771, -0.051562484353780746, -0.005745332688093185, 0.01147802360355854, -0.0041877045296132565, -0.014282472431659698, 0.06727144867181778, -0.021165484562516212, -0.008534062653779984, 0.042549390345811844, 0.03071683458983898, -0.03314603865146637, 0.022263262420892715, -0.01700870878994465, -0.021253032609820366, 0.008232362568378448, -0.007135487627238035, -0.010659534484148026, -0.06386793404817581, 0.0062307147309184074, -0.000978887896053493, -0.013973674736917019, -0.007971295155584812, -0.015627546235919, -0.054180484265089035, 0.05467601493000984, 0.003649733727797866, 0.041635993868112564, 0.023870693519711494, -0.02539355866611004, -0.005645559169352055, -0.07896587252616882, 0.09586327522993088, -0.01932053081691265, -0.004304300993680954, -0.0635872408747673, -0.030324382707476616, -0.037584755569696426, 0.02086891233921051, 0.051630500704050064, 0.03423639014363289, 0.004288310185074806, 0.011803526431322098, 0.042937666177749634, 0.02561507560312748, -0.0566263273358345, 0.023591410368680954, -0.013083436526358128, 0.006173293571919203, -0.0016381683526560664, -0.023621179163455963, 0.003636548761278391, -0.015553331933915615, 0.005099089350551367, -0.016888868063688278, 0.018841614946722984, 0.01697101816534996, -0.008720257319509983, 0.00567855779081583, 0.03740488365292549, -0.016720270738005638, 0.05358525365591049, -0.03742160648107529, 0.019248761236667633, 0.021809961646795273, 0.008670547045767307, -0.054284319281578064, -0.00332819577306509, -0.017591269686818123, -0.046338338404893875, -0.008585287258028984, -0.0005125749739818275, 0.004271823912858963, -0.05900564417243004, 0.024827741086483, 0.020622678101062775, -0.03497762978076935, -0.01510539185255766, 0.009523066692054272, 0.019638635218143463, 0.04915962368249893, -0.025390280410647392, -0.012282655574381351, 0.003182010492309928, -0.019854046404361725, -0.0013064945815131068, 0.013762766495347023, 0.005793019663542509, -0.007222846616059542, 0.00740041071549058, 0.012804514728486538, -0.002614125143736601, 0.025920530781149864, 0.007369633764028549, 0.039219461381435394, -0.026683654636144638, -0.0460130050778389, 0.02225828729569912, -0.003488523419946432, 0.012587746605277061, 0.008150081150233746, -0.012212748639285564, 0.06385038048028946, 0.03407413884997368, 0.006303788162767887, -0.013589481823146343, -0.027894005179405212, -0.03295695781707764, -0.015243236906826496, -0.0026161649730056524, 0.01354296412318945, 0.027384091168642044, -0.011615469120442867, 0.02160138078033924, 0.043884530663490295, 0.04525557532906532, -0.02916361205279827, 0.014712410978972912, -0.004104197956621647, 0.0056397276930511, -0.027050096541643143, -0.028910106047987938, 0.011870688758790493, -0.0015263687819242477, 0.002739574294537306, 0.027900107204914093, 0.02876727096736431, 0.016729693859815598, -0.00259542022831738, -0.013788564130663872, 0.05838602036237717, -0.04784597083926201, -0.013803903013467789, -0.05660795047879219, 0.00483988830819726, -0.01982373185455799, -0.03887265920639038 ]
<p>I've been working with spatial autocorrelation for a while and now I'm trying to move from more traditional estimators such as Moran's I or Geary's C to the new APLE estimator. I read Li's papers on APLE and also the reference on R-project. But I am still missing something very basic, as I still didn't understand something: the results of the APLE statistic are said to have a closed form but I didn't figure which one it is.</p> <p>For instance, while Moran's I can gom from -1 to 1, I couldn't figure which are the possible boundaries of APLE statistics. More interesting, I've been running tests in my older data, using the spdep package in R, and it seems to me that APLE can go up to 2. Any one has any hint on that? Please, any insights here would be very much appreciated.</p>
48,374
[ -0.04898347333073616, -0.01806190237402916, 0.004953861236572266, 0.007816961966454983, 0.022221051156520844, 0.011923231184482574, 0.0009636661852709949, -0.007891382090747356, 0.006193875335156918, -0.0641886293888092, 0.009822919964790344, 0.03970244526863098, 0.01624112017452717, 0.044515784829854965, 0.029637902975082397, -0.0033988733775913715, -0.0229294802993536, -0.004209338221698999, 0.016048511490225792, -0.022001413628458977, 0.018705517053604126, 0.002139526419341564, -0.035195253789424896, -0.009581084363162518, -0.030616343021392822, 0.05433822050690651, 0.033561039716005325, -0.020193828269839287, 0.003932301886379719, 0.09177321940660477, 0.00011281581100774929, -0.013552883639931679, 0.017771633341908455, 0.005091796163469553, 0.045837290585041046, -0.0018275537295266986, -0.02459084987640381, -0.008853170089423656, 0.003139824140816927, 0.04531340301036835, -0.028019746765494347, -0.029242398217320442, -0.03499028831720352, 0.0001967652206076309, -0.0366012342274189, 0.0004768390499521047, 0.021486952900886536, -0.026705535128712654, 0.040639154613018036, -0.006483418866991997, 0.09037664532661438, 0.029720671474933624, -0.00733234453946352, 0.020455069839954376, 0.006689108442515135, 0.004769741557538509, 0.07706330716609955, 0.03478294610977173, -0.02752223238348961, -0.0433766171336174, -0.007658840157091618, -0.03775625303387642, 0.017109224572777748, -0.03178100287914276, -0.02818925864994526, -0.006211793050169945, -0.00654073990881443, -0.002184059005230665, 0.03844383731484413, -0.010484836995601654, 0.008906942792236805, 0.026621665805578232, 0.04873348027467728, -0.0011012492468580604, 0.022397708147764206, -0.021407263353466988, 0.02396220900118351, 0.022485336288809776, 0.025087321177124977, 0.02874809503555298, 0.027449319139122963, 0.015438474714756012, 0.028757790103554726, 0.017811788246035576, 0.019099218770861626, -0.000831880490295589, 0.09011045098304749, -0.01109621487557888, 0.001997142331674695, 0.030841786414384842, -0.014869920909404755, -0.007602520752698183, 0.05980975553393364, 0.014312383718788624, -0.04129944369196892, 0.06285125762224197, -0.03549398481845856, 0.04222646355628967, -0.03269553184509277, -0.0017400559736415744, -0.034994591027498245, -0.050933580845594406, -0.019478876143693924, 0.0561281256377697, -0.025076335296034813, -0.000981294666416943, -0.022230617702007294, -0.013450942002236843, -0.06348063051700592, -0.016511430963873863, -0.02869362011551857, 0.042329251766204834, 0.022978514432907104, -0.004045566078275442, -0.0031072478741407394, -0.02335607260465622, 0.01930343173444271, 0.02227189391851425, 0.016348833218216896, 0.10902369767427444, 0.03391740098595619, 0.019899435341358185, -0.022733867168426514, -0.05538308620452881, -0.05219890922307968, 0.03624729812145233, 0.01278508547693491, -0.031833335757255554, -0.06981249153614044, 0.06810196489095688, 0.005931133404374123, 0.0036084356252104044, 0.022254008799791336, -0.02211655117571354, 0.015315246768295765, -0.010943971574306488, -0.07387961447238922, -0.07018262147903442, 0.033003903925418854, -0.01694507710635662, 0.02163286693394184, -0.037246815860271454, 0.002478115726262331, -0.016485542058944702, 0.06846584379673004, 0.004387921188026667, 0.06428341567516327, 0.0031400283332914114, -0.017592694610357285, 0.011795795522630215, -0.07067956775426865, -0.0027821690309792757, -0.03669457510113716, -0.026798326522111893, -0.009764667600393295, -0.07181020081043243, 0.022558240219950676, 0.011048025451600552, 0.024073543027043343, -0.01169658824801445, 0.07318228483200073, 0.00015364342834800482, -0.028405914083123207, 0.005111566744744778, 0.002762233605608344, -0.0016222597332671285, 0.07543099671602249, 0.0148163465783, 0.010659092105925083, 0.025955863296985626, 0.01001699361950159, -0.0016505151288583875, -0.0213469285517931, 0.02309032529592514, 0.06063017249107361, -0.04922943562269211, -0.0007932020234875381, -0.023557422682642937, -0.009613948874175549, 0.05156351998448372, -0.027620231732726097, 0.027702689170837402, 0.001333539723418653, -0.005054829642176628, 0.003884518053382635, 0.000672418565955013, -0.015560835599899292, 0.006409497931599617, 0.013465012423694134, -0.032559193670749664, -0.009926003403961658, -0.06617949903011322, 0.024493610486388206, 0.02022889070212841, -0.0012684459798038006, 0.0291681420058012, 0.022520529106259346, 0.021814711391925812, -0.001537794480100274, -0.03191758319735527, -0.04118771106004715, 0.015257232822477818, 0.03258431330323219, -0.050196923315525055, 0.033951763063669205, 0.05075406655669212, 0.0346112921833992, -0.00405424740165472, 0.020565837621688843, -0.04380308836698532, -0.007821076549589634, -0.004363700281828642, -0.007559663616120815, 0.03230380266904831, 0.03032900206744671, -0.021618975326418877, 0.012311062775552273, 0.027524223551154137, -0.04546911641955376, 0.005245031788945198, -0.07522472739219666, 0.059821248054504395, 0.08620699495077133, 0.013911544345319271, 0.011112508364021778, 0.007304780650883913, 0.021230584010481834, -0.017468353733420372, -0.05017801374197006, 0.003523582126945257, -0.01962599903345108, -0.026440618559718132, 0.05520715191960335, 0.008879720233380795, -0.019494542852044106, 0.00009531294199405238, 0.023455938324332237, 0.021033875644207, 0.012462933547794819, 0.05470031127333641, 0.009037322364747524, -0.009757342748343945, 0.012235415168106556, 0.0058668372221291065, 0.020817561075091362, 0.009165747091174126, 0.05278119817376137, 0.010259434580802917, 0.028930015861988068, -0.025071965530514717, -0.035678647458553314, 0.029802355915308, -0.03460359573364258, 0.03615150600671768, -0.01583111472427845, 0.018322700634598732, 0.05955157428979874, -0.052708860486745834, -0.014691635966300964, 0.03538166731595993, 0.03342517092823982, -0.005192687269300222, -0.01902921497821808, 0.003174689831212163, 0.05559476092457771, 0.021539637818932533, -0.01828613691031933, -0.016653580591082573, -0.00017044036940205842, -0.014416567981243134, 0.025248805060982704, -0.01797884702682495, -0.05461360886693001, -0.05334349721670151, 0.00008577970584155992, 0.05138706788420677, 0.021126996725797653, 0.00687986658886075, -0.0261272881180048, 0.032817501574754715, -0.0038052289746701717, 0.025186998769640923, 0.054410420358181, 0.026767240837216377, -0.040873538702726364, -0.010029318742454052, 0.0012527491198852658, -0.016060860827565193, 0.018333986401557922, -0.005933020729571581, 0.003918210510164499, 0.018263638019561768, 0.008563878946006298, -0.025508297607302666, -0.041350074112415314, -0.027386700734496117, -0.007694220170378685, -0.038045477122068405, -0.03535187616944313, 0.0430193655192852, 0.00940766278654337, -0.039923038333654404, 0.007314881309866905, -0.03972572088241577, -0.004654833115637302, -0.04766353219747543, -0.034672144800424576, 0.01605994626879692, -0.03002377785742283, 0.023859357461333275, -0.0031326692551374435, -0.023790990933775902, -0.00616588955745101, -0.048814479261636734, -0.06353435665369034, 0.005816145334392786, 0.004324373323470354, -0.0018757798243314028, -0.009865996427834034, -0.0039267572574317455, 0.06374339014291763, 0.046611908823251724, -0.014472328126430511, -0.06243040785193443, 0.014412974938750267, 0.0007143595139496028, -0.02494678646326065, 0.015602516010403633, -0.007961125113070011, -0.004574262071400881, 0.03926658257842064, -0.028856994584202766, 0.05623369291424751, 0.031141553074121475, -0.0072054010815918446, -0.01561001781374216, 0.01732225902378559, -0.04672493040561676, -0.026656322181224823, 0.024225780740380287, 0.05517130717635155, -0.02362770028412342, 0.010005172342061996, -0.025832010433077812, -0.015423750504851341, 0.018091363832354546, -0.060741204768419266, -0.004967203829437494, -0.030656568706035614, -0.015952888876199722, -0.04763621464371681, 0.03088064305484295, 0.0161895751953125, -0.022440293803811073, -0.00616724556311965, -0.0027895276434719563, 0.036483295261859894, -0.020669886842370033, -0.03840206563472748, 0.03209425508975983, 0.04162829369306564, 0.016616500914096832, 0.0003215367905795574, -0.018197182565927505, 0.024803059175610542, 0.009330014698207378, 0.0007248959154821932, -0.03661632537841797, -0.003419166198000312, 0.015580933541059494, 0.009917419403791428, 0.01752164028584957, -0.02061920240521431, 0.018481044098734856, -0.0713026225566864, 0.003239583456888795, -0.024553369730710983, 0.05128534138202667, 0.019856246188282967, 0.0005064714350737631, 0.018687549978494644, 0.020701179280877113, 0.036955446004867554, 0.023873375728726387, -0.05110757052898407, -0.03279321640729904, 0.007528992835432291, 0.02132708951830864, -0.012657719664275646, -0.009401055052876472, 0.05148104578256607, -0.020605213940143585, -0.007888193242251873, 0.018872639164328575, -0.011750340461730957, -0.01923276297748089, 0.02890315093100071, -0.016367802396416664, -0.019981473684310913, 0.006376660894602537, -0.00943027064204216, 0.035963453352451324, 0.005714163649827242, 0.03767075017094612, 0.013686319813132286, 0.009838979691267014, -0.0237308070063591, -0.02048546075820923, 0.014459315687417984, 0.048264045268297195, 0.04472429305315018, 0.01564505696296692, 0.011940903030335903, -0.004865732509642839, 0.028000276535749435, -0.008945495821535587, 0.030129538848996162, 0.0428096279501915, -0.00993533805012703, -0.013596693985164165, -0.019888143986463547, 0.008586376905441284, 0.020535079762339592, -0.010664531961083412, 0.006958312820643187, 0.02401290275156498, 0.07691894471645355, 0.010876232758164406, -0.07347901165485382, 0.023210084065794945, 0.02829972840845585, -0.031104959547519684, 0.0054658567532896996, -0.031034206971526146, -0.03452762961387634, 0.03818214312195778, 0.006823175121098757, 0.03180817887187004, -0.04891732707619667, -0.007728296332061291, 0.006725218612700701, 0.05230150371789932, -0.0371057391166687, -0.0462462417781353, 0.005928419530391693, -0.00722487922757864, 0.003291863249614835, 0.0047338553704321384, -0.03179662674665451, -0.030538007616996765, 0.003765440545976162, 0.030550073832273483, 0.015461665578186512, 0.014955155551433563, -0.0927552580833435, 0.0008915989310480654, 0.06688584387302399, 0.034053586423397064, 0.04123314097523689, 0.010815499350428581, -0.05673634260892868, -0.024472031742334366, -0.038127243518829346, -0.02436613105237484, 0.0027185697108507156, -0.02043367363512516, -0.01496401522308588, -0.0025820578448474407, -0.05621396005153656, -0.06824128329753876, -0.015510516241192818, -0.008556025102734566, 0.023454206064343452, -0.023698674514889717, -0.005742510315030813, -0.050186142325401306, 0.014351269230246544, 0.01929408311843872, 0.042364511638879776, -0.003816131269559264, 0.002035520039498806, 0.026089202612638474, 0.018519306555390358, -0.02755742520093918, -0.04934928938746452, 0.015384026803076267, 0.0019932545255869627, 0.014936127699911594, 0.08802279084920883, -0.03613458573818207, -0.03494802117347717, 0.025448186323046684, 0.042539507150650024, -0.008511120453476906, 0.005105616059154272, -0.01546122133731842, 0.09211017936468124, 0.01296002697199583, -0.001893641659989953, 0.05429964140057564, -0.016470996662974358, 0.0034701628610491753, -0.0071532526053488255, 0.0062517509795725346, 0.024446813389658928, 0.0037828446365892887, -0.0036381061654537916, -0.034141190350055695, -0.0009458736167289317, -0.017855368554592133, 0.03531239554286003, -0.007307968568056822, 0.009078176692128181, -0.021287493407726288, -0.0448976568877697, 0.03115336038172245, 0.036365389823913574, 0.00024193711578845978, 0.008821515366435051, -0.011622292920947075, 0.04027440398931503, -0.0064945160411298275, -0.02098006196320057, 0.01067142654210329, -0.03410302475094795, 0.013920205645263195, 0.013841917738318443, -0.02867252565920353, 0.02146407589316368, 0.010114067234098911, -0.019564760848879814, -0.005357454996556044, -0.01297395396977663, 0.04203343018889427, -0.013377557508647442, -0.012100372463464737, 0.031865112483501434, -0.019740646705031395, 0.012160570360720158, 0.010831956751644611, -0.03629905730485916, 0.03890268877148628, 0.024249082431197166, 0.027093589305877686, 0.0012314183404669166, -0.00042050215415656567, -0.09607994556427002, -0.034684792160987854, 0.05652382969856262, -0.010889839380979538, -0.05378750339150429, -0.01001853309571743, -0.03374718129634857, -0.019412679597735405, -0.013678894378244877, 0.005063364282250404, 0.0020869625732302666, -0.055530838668346405, 0.012512516230344772, 0.02242376282811165, 0.03253687545657158, 0.05497771129012108, 0.01623011939227581, -0.037192802876234055, 0.03941342607140541, -0.00602103304117918, -0.03621843829751015, -0.007479303050786257, 0.032790958881378174, -0.037314318120479584, 0.017389684915542603, -0.03010232001543045, -0.006094613112509251, 0.01669181138277054, -0.03225962072610855, -0.06451534479856491, 0.011677236296236515, -0.008069407194852829, 0.028231298550963402, -0.016637934371829033, -0.03174996376037598, -0.03544469177722931, -0.019975153729319572, -0.03600632771849632, -0.022109514102339745, 0.012272253632545471, 0.00044928997522220016, 0.026579657569527626, 0.0058805253356695175, -0.001671397709287703, 0.00832733977586031, 0.044468991458415985, -0.013889229856431484, 0.01609986461699009, 0.017105909064412117, -0.011598741635680199, 0.06264492869377136, 0.029901932924985886, -0.0025500222109258175, 0.004439552314579487, 0.04916652664542198, -0.08376702666282654, -0.003968191798776388, -0.02300533652305603, 0.014825926162302494, 0.07130680233240128, -0.008791524916887283, 0.06411895155906677, 0.03955090790987015, 0.008497174829244614, -0.04006548225879669, -0.02720019966363907, -0.005175827536731958, -0.020095231011509895, 0.001183378859423101, 0.05745580047369003, -0.05312085896730423, -0.0005354930181056261, -0.010189916007220745, 0.01938951015472412, -0.015024896711111069, 0.022401858121156693, -0.015582595020532608, 0.01765606924891472, 0.066981740295887, -0.01717490144073963, -0.0579800084233284, 0.05023675411939621, 0.013445687480270863, -0.007364584133028984, 0.015358117409050465, -0.029887313023209572, 0.031093567609786987, 0.04360203072428703, 0.03195444121956825, -0.03185699135065079, -0.022989491000771523, -0.05091773346066475, 0.02596285566687584, 0.0261220745742321, -0.012985771521925926, 0.026051485911011696, -0.00436847610399127, 0.04300133138895035, -0.0025544168893247843, 0.007870919071137905, -0.020880982279777527, -0.051089100539684296, 0.008715729229152203, -0.05522909015417099, -0.019943829625844955, 0.034873705357313156, 0.020390769466757774, 0.0015620096819475293, 0.003085648873820901, -0.02788403443992138, -0.034642741084098816, 0.008894768543541431, 0.03825429081916809, 0.026326218619942665, 0.04684959352016449, -0.01631213165819645, 0.017695579677820206, -0.03537977859377861, 0.007414668332785368, 0.12502999603748322, 0.08794312924146652, 0.015241257846355438, -0.09383437782526016, -0.008191735483705997, 0.004703510086983442, -0.01327960193157196, -0.017541484907269478, -0.015508675016462803, -0.03217558190226555, -0.04634474962949753, 0.06900807470083237, 0.06375154107809067, -0.004722636193037033, -0.0288977213203907, 0.04999985173344612, -0.02136252634227276, -0.01930985040962696, 0.019319256767630577, 0.00936319399625063, -0.0365915521979332, -0.01943344995379448, -0.020742708817124367, 0.021074572578072548, -0.011158748529851437, -0.028522109612822533, -0.02304399199783802, -0.024611836299300194, 0.009358224458992481, 0.022556785494089127, -0.014134322293102741, -0.021044915542006493, 0.032791491597890854, 0.009828699752688408, 0.0015269784489646554, -0.018491875380277634, 0.0015061221783980727, -0.04602726921439171, -0.015704749152064323, 0.0400889590382576, -0.011291422881186008, 0.004366080742329359, 0.022686557844281197, -0.029348740354180336, -0.029948722571134567, -0.05150256305932999, -0.0324072390794754, 0.06410836428403854, -0.01587790995836258, -0.012506609782576561, -0.003889342537149787, 0.012966909445822239, -0.0035107750445604324, -0.011226587928831577, -0.007561414036899805, -0.010601520538330078, 0.029044024646282196, -0.01213093288242817, -0.002647467190399766, -0.03973853588104248, -0.015234609134495258, 0.02679736539721489, 0.012226197868585587, 0.04685636982321739, -0.04397713765501976, 0.007190617732703686, -0.012802631594240665, 0.057666849344968796, 0.011800892651081085, -0.013885559514164925, -0.009407727979123592, 0.01890498958528042, -0.06621722131967545, -0.006403157487511635, 0.004757988732308149, -0.007250982336699963, 0.034002576023340225, 0.03156887739896774, -0.03541581332683563, -0.011073678731918335, -0.054301097989082336, -0.022857578471302986, -0.039792582392692566, 0.006556940730661154, -0.01859179139137268, -0.0006304318085312843, 0.012958511710166931, 0.007839925587177277, -0.0021250611171126366, 0.011828690767288208, -0.0032967906445264816, 0.05575321242213249, 0.015937907621264458, -0.014866734854876995, -0.020387448370456696, 0.005364134907722473, -0.05828138440847397, -0.018411511555314064, 0.002460226882249117, 0.060297735035419464, -0.017090385779738426, 0.02213876135647297, 0.009639572352170944, 0.010534863919019699, -0.04620041325688362, -0.024498192593455315, -0.009162758477032185, -0.009347360581159592, -0.016209382563829422, -0.019604966044425964, -0.030243126675486565, -0.038411203771829605, 0.007918797433376312, -0.005299873184412718, -0.03199217841029167, 0.010571627877652645, 0.0010928130941465497, -0.00719117559492588, 0.016427358612418175, 0.01523767039179802, 0.006259378977119923, -0.010820039547979832, -0.008800704963505268, -0.016372300684452057, -0.033665213733911514, -0.001725804409943521, -0.012284636497497559, 0.04935310035943985, 0.008331463672220707, -0.01186400093138218, -0.004771235398948193, 0.05444921553134918, 0.02349085919559002, 0.0001505981053924188, -0.009089970029890537, 0.03935094550251961, 0.014847418293356895, 0.1130184456706047, 0.005586267914623022, -0.026709701865911484, 0.028920019045472145, -0.015916794538497925, -0.051849376410245895, 0.022168753668665886, -0.046464767307043076, 0.01783330924808979, 0.00773595692589879, 0.0263284333050251, -0.03937336429953575, 0.07139217853546143, 0.004847366362810135, -0.01154578197747469, -0.011553377844393253, 0.018257182091474533, 0.024919867515563965, 0.011023236438632011, 0.05117335170507431, 0.0008323929505422711, -0.023995086550712585, 0.004056340549141169, 0.02743087150156498, -0.019379856064915657, 0.0028523881919682026, -0.01809774711728096, -0.08073156327009201, 0.012022464536130428, -0.011377490125596523, -0.03079209290444851, 0.021173283457756042, 0.023456141352653503, -0.00019040606275666505, 0.025554560124874115, 0.0069825127720832825, 0.0026567038148641586, -0.06484922766685486, -0.008648035116493702, 0.025769418105483055, 0.05185786262154579, 0.022793754935264587, -0.06646380573511124, -0.025024546310305595, 0.0429067388176918, -0.06406128406524658, 0.02670842409133911, 0.008016497828066349, -0.02637040801346302, -0.06000632792711258, 0.0026456795167177916, -0.028621509671211243, 0.030812518671154976, -0.00534006068482995, 0.028756652027368546, -0.002142266370356083, 0.04732681065797806, -0.04162348806858063, -0.0693625658750534, -0.039165519177913666, -0.0014663476031273603, 0.006605234462767839, -0.04537831246852875, 0.00947374477982521, -0.029647666960954666, 0.0018738481448963284, 0.04785109683871269, -0.044660426676273346, -0.005534993018954992, 0.003520203521475196, 0.04811910167336464, -0.0015258435159921646, 0.056140948086977005, 0.041337158530950546, 0.005080217495560646, 0.0018259460339322686, -0.022443067282438278, 0.009349695406854153, 0.02543541230261326, -0.03948911651968956, 0.010260076262056828, 0.010128931142389774, 0.01304533239454031, -0.021081212908029556, 0.015899473801255226, -0.03191358968615532, -0.0016410630196332932, 0.0025988249108195305, 0.010308993048965931, 0.021691642701625824, 0.0015102872857823968, 0.06316636502742767, 0.0031715822406113148, -0.0030200330074876547, 0.024258218705654144, 0.03568846732378006, -0.05019098520278931, 0.018762562423944473, -0.049169138073921204, -0.04528255760669708, 0.05498825013637543, -0.01769891567528248, -0.023681631311774254, -0.053333692252635956, -0.010238738730549812, -0.021192703396081924, -0.00155547633767128, -0.01344540249556303, 0.012995736673474312, -0.030055098235607147, 0.019542457535862923, 0.04732904210686684, 0.008753519505262375, 0.018401065841317177, 0.0036102014128118753, -0.0003697869833558798, -0.09661076217889786, 0.04758588969707489, 0.014967373572289944, 0.007394701708108187, -0.0350787490606308, -0.04293675720691681, -0.00983250979334116, -0.030535956844687462, 0.055552080273628235, 0.0031169166322797537, 0.016587361693382263, -0.011206853203475475, 0.043868258595466614, 0.003756569465622306, -0.006873650476336479, 0.026695847511291504, 0.005731639452278614, -0.04091731086373329, 0.01394384354352951, -0.031071897596120834, -0.014469579793512821, 0.01001015491783619, -0.015526900067925453, -0.011550052091479301, 0.016985228285193443, -0.0016000097384676337, -0.0020657458808273077, -0.005288637708872557, 0.024583516642451286, -0.02992345206439495, 0.09315189719200134, 0.005811695940792561, 0.014363249763846397, 0.00910016056150198, -0.01584385707974434, -0.026495877653360367, 0.014746597968041897, 0.008463326841592789, -0.019725238904356956, -0.011245504021644592, 0.011367888189852238, 0.0364554300904274, -0.03486333042383194, -0.010421199724078178, 0.018857529386878014, -0.02058999612927437, -0.012867411598563194, 0.038191258907318115, 0.003928152844309807, 0.03156566247344017, -0.003682199399918318, 0.02569630742073059, -0.002147734398022294, -0.021951481699943542, 0.02472618594765663, 0.04115920141339302, 0.04152434319257736, 0.0049721477553248405, -0.01596001721918583, 0.009613953530788422, -0.011716080829501152, -0.010400800965726376, -0.0364956259727478, 0.02539800852537155, -0.024037707597017288, 0.012342804111540318, 0.020857540890574455, 0.009000703692436218, 0.043177686631679535, -0.019523972645401955, -0.002615321660414338, 0.04530992731451988, -0.027436327189207077, -0.012056145817041397, -0.02928178943693638, -0.02547539584338665, -0.021305697038769722, -0.009454329498112202, 0.006775726098567247, 0.04148344323039055, 0.011928720399737358, 0.019612077623605728, 0.0076765939593315125, -0.025326566770672798, 0.013218744657933712, -0.02707487903535366, 0.02106114849448204, -0.016656259074807167, 0.010986174456775188, 0.019931122660636902, 0.011243777349591255, -0.022487996146082878, -0.001968691824004054, -0.00030963390599936247, -0.0027073228266090155, 0.038851961493492126, -0.0017461258685216308, -0.019545285031199455, 0.04012579470872879, 0.02400723658502102, -0.06567423045635223, -0.020324314013123512, -0.07789662480354309, 0.03123011253774166, -0.024004030972719193, -0.008955109864473343 ]
<p>My question might be easy for most of you to answer. I am starting to learn statistics and coding in R so my questions are on the basic level.</p> <p>I have a dataset of (two groups, replicates). My data is split based on the groups so I have 24 samples in group 1 and 20 samples in group 2. My data has replicates. So each set has 4 replicates, hence I have 6 sets in group 1 and 5 sets in group 2. Hence I have assigned indices to them to make it easier during permutation (indices from 1-11). What I want to do now is a routine permutation analysis to obtain the test statistic. I am using non paramteric method with resampling with replacement. </p> <p>My doubt\problem in R coding is that I have to pool the data together and then resample the groups. When I try to do this, <strong>I have to make sure I maintain the sample size for respective groups (that is after resampling the group lables, my new dataset should still contain 6 sets (24 samples) in group 1 and 5 sets (20 samples) in group 2.</strong> I am unable to achieve the latter. </p> <p>I tried something like this in my code:</p> <pre><code>n_resamples=100 permdat=function(dat){ for (i in 6:nc) { for (j in 1:n_resamples) { inds=unique(dat$ind) cc=dat$grp[dat$ind==inds] pcc=sample(cc,replace=T) ##for resampling with replacement #m&lt;-list() pdat=dat for(i in 1:length(inds)) { pdat$grp[pdat$ind==inds[i]]=pcc[i] #browser() } </code></pre> <p>This does not produce the desired result. Kindly help with R codes. </p> <p>Thanking you all for your help. :)</p> <p>Regards Ap</p>
74,059
[ -0.04239547625184059, 0.013485847972333431, 0.02244315855205059, -0.009708342142403126, 0.025043901056051254, 0.014366586692631245, -0.007562218699604273, -0.041401248425245285, 0.03792061284184456, -0.013497108593583107, 0.024719538167119026, 0.018407516181468964, 0.06873183697462082, 0.027817029505968094, 0.034175146371126175, 0.005013762507587671, -0.00877416506409645, 0.00691252900287509, -0.03288412466645241, -0.0017968615284189582, -0.006399040576070547, 0.014482940547168255, 0.007516998331993818, -0.012042385526001453, -0.01614310033619404, 0.03423508256673813, -0.003415799932554364, -0.010327126830816269, -0.018760159611701965, 0.10011006146669388, -0.06837448477745056, -0.0433066226541996, 0.04682457447052002, 0.036149099469184875, 0.0015097851864993572, 0.002339089522138238, -0.0210306104272604, -0.03738754615187645, -0.008260328322649002, 0.000737398921046406, -0.05040919780731201, 0.024392036721110344, -0.02544485032558441, 0.008120061829686165, 0.019543327391147614, 0.04140090569853783, 0.0009949789382517338, 0.0036732908338308334, 0.024654163047671318, -0.06291898339986801, 0.07577111572027206, 0.002206098521128297, 0.015015317127108574, -0.013651750981807709, -0.05160480737686157, 0.01131349615752697, 0.03425632417201996, 0.044843532145023346, 0.017305191606283188, -0.026644688099622726, -0.016682744026184082, -0.04085591435432434, 0.0263027586042881, 0.006414209492504597, -0.02181791514158249, 0.034209903329610825, -0.032889243215322495, 0.01599218137562275, 0.04380752518773079, -0.01722482591867447, 0.04075458645820618, 0.023649903014302254, 0.05280275270342827, -0.025841224938631058, 0.007262316532433033, -0.012398933991789818, 0.024176446720957756, -0.010680870153009892, 0.028152622282505035, 0.09290998429059982, -0.022703789174556732, 0.054367031902074814, 0.023309806361794472, 0.030138710513710976, 0.017620749771595, -0.032050084322690964, 0.03774507716298103, -0.03518414869904518, 0.060078103095293045, 0.032026369124650955, -0.007086465600878, -0.013272103853523731, 0.03498891741037369, 0.03980593383312225, -0.03798738121986389, 0.022579234093427658, -0.027304332703351974, 0.038631848990917206, -0.02438730001449585, 0.001482636434957385, -0.014129961840808392, -0.039700932800769806, 0.03883961960673332, 0.043124716728925705, -0.025835229083895683, 0.020308714359998703, -0.053090330213308334, -0.03521658852696419, 0.023541714996099472, -0.011617324315011501, 0.04479990154504776, 0.010335162281990051, -0.0021309375297278166, -0.033869415521621704, 0.02247881330549717, -0.01596234366297722, -0.025349052622914314, 0.047439947724342346, 0.07244639843702316, 0.056970108300447464, 0.0408400259912014, -0.027366872876882553, 0.058459021151065826, -0.04323256388306618, -0.0040215374901890755, 0.03572913631796837, -0.009654252789914608, 0.01931358315050602, -0.023831261321902275, 0.026344038546085358, -0.00832444243133068, -0.027855420485138893, 0.025976840406656265, -0.003499200800433755, 0.04516670107841492, -0.04053419828414917, -0.08071642369031906, -0.07038510590791702, 0.052093639969825745, -0.034436024725437164, -0.003793990006670356, -0.04116726294159889, 0.05568009987473488, -0.01250392384827137, 0.054634276777505875, -0.012457051314413548, 0.048849720507860184, 0.019457697868347168, -0.011457039043307304, 0.05173427239060402, -0.02940548025071621, -0.009505420923233032, -0.02732727862894535, -0.007104715798050165, -0.02137746848165989, -0.09847752749919891, 0.009805053472518921, 0.0011481002438813448, 0.012032024562358856, 0.009016050957143307, 0.01379411481320858, -0.03588087856769562, 0.004721986595541239, -0.03334823623299599, 0.006898164749145508, -0.011317935772240162, 0.023906858637928963, 0.008395139127969742, 0.01687120646238327, 0.024854717776179314, -0.02803736925125122, 0.0011186284245923162, 0.008453760296106339, 0.04534418135881424, 0.015403333120048046, -0.014606229960918427, 0.02374735102057457, -0.006693742237985134, 0.018611637875437737, 0.024208825081586838, 0.009384897537529469, -0.008371216244995594, 0.007781267631798983, -0.006738692056387663, 0.04342673718929291, -0.00694210035726428, 0.007382376119494438, -0.03179904818534851, 0.0275696013122797, -0.027218876406550407, -0.01943584345281124, -0.05504738539457321, -0.009729065001010895, 0.019017912447452545, -0.02713167667388916, -0.004468688741326332, -0.01933087222278118, 0.011559846810996532, 0.05515098199248314, -0.06702087074518204, -0.03598352149128914, -0.0291668139398098, 0.007515342906117439, -0.03481285274028778, -0.03559960797429085, 0.03494434431195259, 0.057871293276548386, -0.03474189341068268, 0.050252515822649, -0.04824930429458618, 0.005555633921176195, -0.0008082789718173444, -0.020545348525047302, 0.0031473063863813877, -0.006816124077886343, -0.007583819329738617, 0.006188463885337114, 0.042599622160196304, -0.04287531599402428, 0.06478677690029144, -0.06882128119468689, 0.031063547357916832, 0.0526389554142952, 0.013033431023359299, -0.015136773698031902, -0.010040029883384705, -0.012968637980520725, 0.01993059366941452, -0.045034945011138916, -0.011206982657313347, -0.07036668807268143, 0.02315450832247734, 0.01831400766968727, -0.014777136966586113, -0.03072255663573742, -0.006145970430225134, 0.06130702793598175, -0.014335425570607185, -0.016875583678483963, 0.05683990195393562, 0.018595989793539047, -0.015471229329705238, 0.020024126395583153, 0.015185395255684853, 0.04559680074453354, -0.006227822974324226, 0.0025890136603266, 0.006059433799237013, 0.07053512334823608, 0.024227548390626907, 0.0218358151614666, 0.008367444388568401, -0.007642738986760378, -0.011622022837400436, -0.030909789726138115, 0.012669484131038189, 0.022948967292904854, 0.008293217979371548, 0.008969426155090332, 0.07386380434036255, 0.0460662804543972, 0.012885862961411476, 0.012661488726735115, -0.006472451612353325, 0.011847203597426414, 0.022563140839338303, -0.01872832514345646, -0.000010485526217962615, -0.00485240388661623, -0.020764898508787155, 0.003627627855166793, 0.029475944116711617, 0.0012022958835586905, -0.056029610335826874, 0.042640917003154755, 0.004924884531646967, -0.018871283158659935, 0.023963138461112976, -0.062296152114868164, 0.032738033682107925, 0.00001714959398668725, -0.002277917927131057, 0.0032314287964254618, -0.015160847455263138, -0.04762459546327591, 0.01853630505502224, 0.004383321851491928, -0.016427207738161087, 0.007848260924220085, -0.024099843576550484, -0.05349388346076012, 0.009450988844037056, 0.011916002258658409, -0.050313081592321396, -0.005410381127148867, -0.05488789826631546, 0.021127190440893173, -0.04342438280582428, -0.017217522487044334, 0.06289073824882507, 0.027690893039107323, -0.02609645016491413, -0.002685273066163063, -0.04950482398271561, 0.009433113969862461, -0.0021582182962447405, -0.029756760224699974, 0.03035374917089939, 0.022129422053694725, -0.012820210307836533, 0.0243424940854311, -0.007342655677348375, -0.0073930649086833, -0.03151702135801315, -0.03958192467689514, -0.00696811405941844, 0.02989238314330578, 0.02078450657427311, 0.019536981359124184, -0.02426263503730297, 0.04572497680783272, 0.027790946885943413, -0.01014738716185093, -0.02153398096561432, -0.006449132226407528, -0.035349275916814804, 0.007316634524613619, 0.04708535224199295, 0.005923337768763304, 0.013987448066473007, -0.0011570564238354564, -0.0004948434070684016, 0.03277019411325455, 0.07521145790815353, -0.01666594296693802, -0.025853712111711502, -0.0006023633759468794, 0.021189900115132332, -0.018222864717245102, 0.0377986803650856, 0.009181072004139423, -0.023660384118556976, 0.005700192414224148, -0.007126298267394304, -0.01278003491461277, -0.012034441344439983, -0.04535099118947983, 0.013228784315288067, 0.007381512317806482, 0.0381370447576046, -0.022501803934574127, 0.04874715581536293, 0.02356809750199318, -0.053769856691360474, -0.024968795478343964, 0.037525877356529236, 0.034795086830854416, -0.05401017516851425, -0.005490902345627546, 0.041959043592214584, 0.036732543259859085, -0.041902583092451096, 0.006322483532130718, -0.027029961347579956, -0.00023888818395789713, -0.02428671158850193, -0.0035438728518784046, 0.005877833813428879, 0.023234864696860313, 0.0549386627972126, 0.04784402251243591, -0.000208587633096613, -0.016218284144997597, 0.03016636148095131, -0.04943418875336647, 0.02246854268014431, -0.03892955183982849, 0.06335298717021942, 0.028546053916215897, 0.05587080121040344, 0.061305902898311615, -0.004721337929368019, -0.009188268333673477, 0.006229234393686056, -0.07838034629821777, 0.05684449151158333, 0.031198741868138313, -0.008287637494504452, 0.016415612772107124, -0.03568274527788162, 0.026651624590158463, 0.01939266361296177, 0.031791891902685165, 0.024967851117253304, 0.003617667593061924, -0.041417088359594345, 0.0009304966661147773, -0.007416700944304466, 0.006890366319566965, 0.007430786732584238, 0.030493034049868584, 0.0404742956161499, -0.01703202724456787, 0.021770447492599487, 0.0050457012839615345, -0.003714748425409198, 0.019892530515789986, -0.022982493042945862, -0.006334525998681784, 0.010060557164251804, 0.029828211292624474, 0.021092751994729042, 0.03181876614689827, -0.023534685373306274, 0.00165027123875916, -0.014878672547638416, 0.035459328442811966, 0.05108650028705597, -0.006215306464582682, 0.019062243402004242, -0.016531486064195633, -0.01923438534140587, 0.013741602189838886, 0.010019205510616302, -0.016236208379268646, -0.016991861164569855, 0.0393807590007782, 0.02471107244491577, -0.03536928817629814, 0.017367670312523842, 0.050641659647226334, 0.014837515540421009, -0.015106752514839172, -0.0630987137556076, -0.00959823653101921, 0.011725146323442459, 0.012013648636639118, 0.01432847697287798, 0.009422284550964832, 0.008501129224896431, 0.004936184734106064, 0.0520024448633194, -0.011024829931557178, -0.04292713850736618, 0.01223740540444851, -0.009692034684121609, 0.03828000649809837, 0.004225375596433878, -0.012587016448378563, -0.0046662152744829655, 0.005837270524352789, 0.008213881403207779, -0.009652657434344292, -0.044496193528175354, -0.0854799747467041, 0.004036664962768555, 0.026404663920402527, 0.0736120268702507, -0.05013902857899666, 0.01744677871465683, -0.01827944442629814, -0.011075463145971298, 0.023365285247564316, -0.05595631152391434, 0.02932712808251381, -0.01953066512942314, -0.012904956005513668, -0.04781780764460564, -0.024747362360358238, -0.04339229315519333, -0.0015520312590524554, -0.04176216199994087, 0.006705992855131626, -0.034809667617082596, -0.03323252126574516, -0.045588135719299316, 0.009156073443591595, -0.009748677723109722, 0.04532412439584732, -0.04943898692727089, -0.025400780141353607, 0.01913728564977646, 0.014442900195717812, -0.014738490805029869, -0.04344132915139198, 0.011486832983791828, 0.005855563562363386, 0.022740822285413742, 0.056000541895627975, -0.014270421117544174, -0.012669934891164303, 0.029221035540103912, 0.02067379653453827, 0.006075676064938307, -0.012853307649493217, -0.01471581682562828, 0.0222282987087965, 0.008091271854937077, -0.006294097285717726, 0.03594443202018738, 0.012327556498348713, -0.002051711780950427, 0.00017721900076139718, -0.030019469559192657, 0.018246233463287354, -0.05084291100502014, -0.017523039132356644, -0.0375344455242157, -0.01889139786362648, -0.025708500295877457, 0.0443992093205452, -0.019946647807955742, 0.025332937017083168, -0.045561738312244415, 0.008820855058729649, 0.046734582632780075, 0.041352901607751846, 0.013729235157370567, 0.011579025536775589, -0.011295005679130554, 0.005984112154692411, -0.012085653841495514, -0.017341848462820053, 0.029730163514614105, -0.051217179745435715, -0.018321584910154343, 0.028048457577824593, -0.06496012955904007, 0.010120145045220852, -0.04404141381382942, -0.0035701480228453875, 0.01696288213133812, -0.04737488925457001, 0.005478808656334877, 0.0146045396104455, 0.039466384798288345, -0.011485016904771328, -0.03807023540139198, 0.004918758291751146, 0.018505780026316643, -0.040891390293836594, 0.008276977576315403, -0.039183005690574646, 0.07149362564086914, 0.011949119158089161, -0.014466999098658562, -0.0957791656255722, -0.06820978224277496, 0.0196060873568058, 0.029864860698580742, -0.025965597480535507, -0.05666185915470123, -0.04412573203444481, -0.00935569778084755, -0.002239930210635066, -0.023469461128115654, 0.04492008686065674, -0.02173112891614437, -0.0010257639223709702, -0.036451298743486404, -0.003851698013022542, 0.10416506230831146, -0.013867777772247791, -0.009838435798883438, 0.004208141937851906, -0.018093546852469444, -0.019533365964889526, 0.034506164491176605, -0.008090869523584843, -0.017800522968173027, -0.033738892525434494, -0.007128430996090174, 0.010186622850596905, 0.042039792984724045, -0.012890373356640339, -0.019092366099357605, -0.021435245871543884, -0.00453054578974843, 0.012734239920973778, -0.04678984731435776, -0.043210987001657486, -0.008776090107858181, -0.0256214439868927, -0.020551392808556557, 0.042595572769641876, -0.022351762279868126, 0.025506557896733284, 0.01038589607924223, -0.014281416311860085, 0.031866468489170074, 0.020975228399038315, 0.06143781542778015, -0.027217624709010124, -0.01376450713723898, -0.017976129427552223, -0.059803903102874756, 0.030346734449267387, 0.008706712163984776, -0.0035591069608926773, -0.00513451499864459, -0.03287340700626373, -0.01460734661668539, -0.011805564165115356, -0.013794978149235249, -0.0006071253446862102, 0.03403579816222191, -0.008735260926187038, 0.022742869332432747, 0.05175104737281799, 0.01321975328028202, 0.037093695253133774, 0.0280134454369545, 0.040822647511959076, -0.0018102985341101885, 0.03043743595480919, 0.0636613667011261, 0.011584115214645863, -0.01138298399746418, 0.03531666100025177, 0.018112890422344208, 0.03293975815176964, 0.03323962911963463, -0.007642768323421478, -0.03278791904449463, -0.009883436374366283, -0.020817087963223457, -0.023576198145747185, 0.029900265857577324, -0.040532127022743225, 0.02035415545105934, -0.0319928303360939, -0.023509668186306953, 0.04713121056556702, 0.04966599494218826, 0.01808810420334339, 0.004141958896070719, -0.034926578402519226, -0.07090743631124496, -0.012240266427397728, 0.054145898669958115, 0.008759132586419582, 0.04199056699872017, 0.027101827785372734, 0.01504923589527607, -0.03271253779530525, 0.025990113615989685, -0.055249836295843124, -0.056042153388261795, -0.0005614107940346003, -0.044466760009527206, -0.018445029854774475, 0.04408629983663559, -0.021982429549098015, 0.013709010556340218, 0.007788865361362696, -0.02049027383327484, 0.0235737394541502, 0.008969608694314957, 0.02610696293413639, -0.025727665051817894, 0.07305508852005005, 0.0008030784083530307, 0.048588864505290985, -0.025615740567445755, -0.02573130838572979, 0.12454311549663544, 0.06257593631744385, 0.03796214610338211, -0.0727371945977211, 0.03319071978330612, 0.02696315199136734, -0.04087366536259651, -0.007036527618765831, 0.02418258599936962, 0.014783825725317001, 0.0046091387048363686, 0.03853460028767586, 0.08119340986013412, 0.009293721057474613, 0.019200420007109642, 0.048324547708034515, -0.029123008251190186, 0.0030526979826390743, 0.01717323623597622, 0.01765882410109043, 0.0014802373480051756, -0.05217999219894409, -0.0688147321343422, 0.027964960783720016, 0.015268710441887379, 0.005040117539465427, -0.038922250270843506, -0.014907322824001312, 0.0010069598210975528, 0.03771774843335152, 0.0009950250387191772, 0.012456974014639854, -0.022906938567757607, -0.008728079497814178, -0.02800457552075386, -0.032081663608551025, 0.036656398326158524, -0.02804436907172203, 0.036344654858112335, 0.07037212699651718, 0.017928030341863632, 0.015617289580404758, -0.02828616462647915, 0.045407503843307495, -0.036786921322345734, -0.05338845029473305, -0.03297082707285881, 0.03813501074910164, -0.032708510756492615, -0.021816883236169815, 0.0007395186694338918, 0.005088099278509617, -0.006858749780803919, -0.04489060863852501, -0.018573755398392677, 0.04617402330040932, 0.0067514823749661446, -0.008573072962462902, -0.019495764747262, -0.017444785684347153, 0.016581015661358833, -0.024417558684945107, 0.020236486569046974, -0.00274360622279346, 0.01273721270263195, -0.04854271933436394, -0.02592337876558304, 0.0342499203979969, -0.0021670181304216385, 0.014274122193455696, 0.011160713620483875, -0.055181048810482025, -0.01660473830997944, -0.028407398611307144, -0.011170855723321438, -0.006421830505132675, 0.023735731840133667, -0.05734694376587868, -0.01477005984634161, -0.009484020061790943, -0.00036903118598274887, 0.026035403832793236, -0.034773994237184525, 0.0004997661453671753, -0.013180053792893887, 0.02224750444293022, 0.04217689111828804, 0.031936366111040115, 0.020580140873789787, 0.01816338114440441, 0.010642029345035553, 0.05374646931886673, 0.010473310016095638, -0.07964175194501877, -0.03105194680392742, -0.005303606390953064, -0.011618798598647118, -0.028136154636740685, -0.03661765903234482, 0.0793256014585495, 0.03327352926135063, -0.018004167824983597, -0.015773506835103035, -0.003441132605075836, 0.008583215065300465, 0.03343154862523079, -0.013114295899868011, -0.04095253720879555, 0.02849401719868183, 0.013561464846134186, 0.013055281713604927, -0.01774384081363678, 0.003817522432655096, -0.008948517963290215, -0.05452597886323929, 0.02092146687209606, -0.04598265886306763, -0.017979411408305168, 0.0012337462976574898, -0.023623762652277946, 0.027330690994858742, -0.03440377488732338, -0.006193609908223152, -0.027272144332528114, 0.00031740625854581594, 0.005567929241806269, 0.007545883301645517, -0.019482849165797234, 0.0009747567237354815, -0.04986995458602905, -0.04326248541474342, 0.056924495846033096, 0.007245646324008703, 0.03020448237657547, -0.002002889756113291, 0.01104980893433094, -0.007634815294295549, 0.010413921438157558, -0.0008987272740341723, -0.011946717277169228, 0.05957236513495445, -0.07088334858417511, -0.0036638437304645777, 0.022358471527695656, -0.0028433529660105705, 0.04136214032769203, 0.02506268210709095, 0.019431842491030693, -0.0030531673692166805, 0.054652173072099686, -0.040336791425943375, -0.024180876091122627, -0.006496565882116556, 0.002436195034533739, 0.03453729301691055, -0.0011614373652264476, -0.0003988801909144968, 0.011232075281441212, 0.0185575932264328, 0.047820813953876495, 0.02532019093632698, 0.03353295102715492, -0.015920741483569145, 0.002750840038061142, -0.02265336737036705, 0.05757109820842743, -0.0009003194863907993, -0.004693048540502787, 0.018539756536483765, 0.033425576984882355, -0.026019224897027016, 0.010205943137407303, -0.043555498123168945, -0.007893675938248634, -0.09238983690738678, -0.010970517992973328, -0.023818176239728928, -0.0018941669259220362, 0.058440010994672775, -0.03601115569472313, 0.01371676940470934, -0.02239024080336094, -0.010053676553070545, 0.014331869781017303, -0.031313538551330566, -0.015584615059196949, -0.0022380223963409662, 0.046094175428152084, -0.03363170102238655, 0.01404687762260437, 0.03192611783742905, 0.008089770562946796, 0.019776832312345505, 0.029152952134609222, 0.01056759338825941, -0.03895606845617294, 0.010299786925315857, -0.006183231249451637, 0.019340282306075096, -0.07815868407487869, 0.025163179263472557, -0.010574131272733212, -0.03451504558324814, 0.009545046836137772, -0.029237965121865273, 0.0036849260795861483, 0.023392649367451668, 0.011887621134519577, -0.01499159075319767, 0.062293317168951035, 0.008216180838644505, 0.028817296028137207, 0.007963486015796661, -0.023452356457710266, 0.0021472370717674494, 0.010483495891094208, 0.0013039708137512207, 0.025805817916989326, 0.058371901512145996, 0.006672916933894157, 0.009044204838573933, 0.03723730519413948, -0.011598214507102966, -0.0308537520468235, -0.008618216030299664, -0.007788496557623148, 0.000430385785875842, -0.002560574794188142, -0.004393763840198517, -0.03555746376514435, 0.03652029484510422, 0.0479128398001194, 0.013671898283064365, -0.005258672870695591, 0.0063504865393042564, -0.018957819789648056, -0.03408897668123245, -0.042116325348615646, 0.005936879198998213, -0.004495634697377682, -0.06355912238359451, -0.019233407452702522, 0.021657174453139305, 0.02163897268474102, -0.030531708151102066, 0.007886599749326706, -0.01283139456063509, 0.07189657539129257, -0.03266669064760208, 0.005252467002719641, -0.0018539666198194027, -0.002034083241596818, 0.031032707542181015, -0.039756979793310165, 0.03836563602089882, -0.004032954107969999, -0.01853291690349579, -0.06052234768867493, -0.0269134771078825, -0.04997415468096733, 0.06389129161834717, 0.026058899238705635, 0.011332585476338863, -0.01086474396288395, -0.052311211824417114, 0.005711543373763561, 0.0228711124509573, -0.05143275484442711, 0.06000402942299843, -0.0023190099745988846, -0.009921153075993061, -0.007519263308495283, -0.002774866297841072, 0.03776216506958008, 0.013213513419032097, -0.018840806558728218, -0.05303783714771271, 0.022420404478907585, -0.009076985530555248, -0.013355324044823647, -0.0024327400606125593, -0.05683271214365959, -0.01808447390794754, 0.00580528425052762, 0.015397145412862301, 0.029973259195685387, 0.020200759172439575, 0.007128496188670397, -0.043428756296634674, 0.01797838881611824, -0.04621432349085808, -0.009704516269266605, 0.03488614410161972, -0.031551167368888855, 0.01784156821668148, -0.04225983843207359, 0.013569534756243229, 0.012695690616965294, -0.027103856205940247, 0.004357173573225737, 0.05363853648304939, 0.017446519806981087, 0.017921406775712967, -0.008418585173785686, 0.0016188168665394187, -0.0069655124098062515, -0.018116235733032227, -0.020906582474708557, 0.0036201761104166508, -0.05062219873070717, -0.009024047292768955, 0.0056095244362950325, -0.0005653409170918167, 0.014582080766558647, 0.023594195023179054, 0.01061665266752243, 0.05826634541153908, 0.011602908372879028, 0.012307687662541866, 0.023393850773572922, -0.04007731378078461, -0.007205226458609104, -0.0163966603577137, -0.006961446721106768, 0.03027585707604885, -0.037160348147153854, 0.02748822048306465, -0.03469950333237648, -0.05289619415998459, -0.046180229634046555, -0.0056145088747143745, -0.0015281389933079481, 0.014277497306466103, 0.00003805101368925534, 0.03451501578092575, -0.0038598026148974895, -0.026772841811180115, 0.029086321592330933, -0.04591153562068939, 0.028709324076771736, -0.01649029366672039, 0.014798890799283981, -0.03924503177404404, -0.0028697417583316565, -0.023759156465530396, -0.03272455930709839, 0.00953871663659811, -0.011050881817936897, 0.03060799650847912, -0.015492879785597324, -0.029200248420238495, 0.03757459297776222, 0.0259334035217762, -0.026545120403170586, -0.01161663793027401, -0.0347779281437397, -0.012389164417982101, 0.0012578729074448347, 0.0037208215799182653 ]
<p>I have a logit model and am trying to understand and compare the predicted and observed values generated by the model. Let's say data set had 100 values and I generate all the predicted probabilities, and then I find the actual probabilities from the data set.</p> <p>If I'm comparing the predicted vs observed values, I'm thinking there are two ways to do it. One is to do it value by value, while the second would be to group by the 'predicted probabilities.'</p> <pre><code>Method 1: x_value pred_val obs_val 100 0.30 0.34 102 0.33 0.36 104 0.35 0.37 106 0.40 0.40 ... </code></pre> <p>I'm also thinking there has to some way to aggregate these values. So I'm thinking of aggregating all x values where the predicted probabilities is between 10 to 20% percent, then find the avg predicted value from that range, followed by the predicted value for that range.</p> <pre><code>Method 2: Pred_probs pred_val obs_val 10 to 20% vals 0.10 0.11 21 to 30% vals 0.12 0.16 31 to 50% vals 0.15 0.30 </code></pre> <p>What I'm wondering is:</p> <ol> <li><p>When there are a large number of data points, what use is having a list of the predicted and observed values for any given value of x?</p></li> <li><p>Does it ever make sense to do something as identified in 'Method 2'?</p></li> </ol>
74,060
[ -0.059815362095832825, 0.02235913649201393, -0.019318845123052597, -0.015406560152769089, 0.04936852678656578, 0.014480562880635262, 0.002116019371896982, -0.025448543950915337, 0.06141927093267441, 0.0044034626334905624, 0.011578655801713467, 0.023984229192137718, 0.04301289841532707, 0.0012740353122353554, 0.05908556655049324, 0.0033118710853159428, 0.005077361594885588, -0.012679537758231163, 0.01167298574000597, -0.006215683650225401, -0.02887137047946453, 0.020814072340726852, 0.0021219102200120687, -0.033920545130968094, -0.017271436750888824, 0.057467058300971985, 0.033669363707304, -0.025244269520044327, 0.01563255675137043, 0.06757401674985886, 0.006832067389041185, -0.05903872102499008, 0.007143262308090925, 0.03362646326422691, 0.03332874923944473, 0.02428426221013069, -0.0029637482948601246, -0.0209221001714468, -0.013276716694235802, 0.029232939705252647, -0.052244722843170166, 0.008487568236887455, 0.005775235127657652, -0.006117319688200951, 0.023987123742699623, 0.021967481821775436, -0.01268172636628151, -0.02100147306919098, 0.019683413207530975, -0.03310524672269821, 0.0392974354326725, -0.02779393270611763, 0.005639807786792517, 0.030942009761929512, -0.02200089395046234, -0.0012054481776431203, 0.032490845769643784, 0.07638931274414062, -0.01845458336174488, -0.08019182085990906, -0.0038493280299007893, 0.006371041759848595, -0.014405929483473301, -0.0032306744251400232, 0.009159560315310955, 0.003096482250839472, -0.007596846204251051, -0.006142786704003811, 0.03776118904352188, 0.001657367218285799, 0.023841718211770058, 0.02837480790913105, 0.014008809812366962, 0.01268674060702324, 0.007809221278876066, -0.034074921160936356, 0.02516831085085869, -0.036574117839336395, 0.04856559634208679, 0.02850998565554619, 0.01927250251173973, 0.04654684662818909, 0.02335291914641857, 0.0037505810614675283, 0.0049751210026443005, -0.01299396250396967, 0.037092022597789764, -0.010805359110236168, 0.011724863201379776, 0.02962682582437992, -0.009790079668164253, 0.04522550478577614, 0.020989589393138885, 0.025182317942380905, -0.030708404257893562, 0.04753894731402397, -0.018689969554543495, 0.04274964705109596, -0.005302770528942347, 0.018372338265180588, 0.018095990642905235, -0.03106796368956566, -0.0013696732930839062, 0.030917726457118988, -0.047380007803440094, -0.02891683764755726, -0.01217496395111084, -0.022540897130966187, -0.0011049258755519986, -0.05484863743185997, 0.008060955442488194, 0.01289850939065218, -0.0039680455811321735, 0.023455677554011345, -0.006870522629469633, -0.022180600091814995, -0.0028510799165815115, 0.008867016062140465, 0.018198873847723007, 0.031476110219955444, 0.03385492414236069, -0.012912123464047909, 0.02261277846992016, -0.03067675791680813, -0.043521177023649216, -0.017216617241501808, 0.02297753468155861, -0.004005156923085451, -0.06961680948734283, 0.05692322924733162, -0.03938082978129387, -0.03303741291165352, 0.04392873868346214, 0.003125958377495408, -0.0010341954184696078, 0.02002733200788498, -0.0648549422621727, -0.024280503392219543, 0.012775701470673084, -0.019856436178088188, 0.01710135117173195, -0.04663088917732239, -0.008870930410921574, 0.016394129022955894, 0.0327579565346241, 0.019782720133662224, 0.043820299208164215, 0.02032981440424919, -0.0011604503961279988, 0.014388578943908215, -0.028072983026504517, -0.022440774366259575, -0.017246026545763016, -0.023083718493580818, -0.023442594334483147, -0.049355365335941315, 0.0175520908087492, -0.017387179657816887, -0.005235740914940834, -0.014804608188569546, 0.0020895719062536955, -0.023257654160261154, -0.02307390607893467, 0.013307332061231136, 0.009307537227869034, -0.04512860253453255, 0.07054942846298218, 0.029238032177090645, 0.013331716880202293, 0.039088331162929535, -0.009057615883648396, -0.011813964694738388, 0.02967974916100502, 0.010873309336602688, 0.06536544859409332, 0.026377884671092033, -0.016335785388946533, -0.0617426373064518, 0.011142498813569546, 0.0005001691170036793, -0.031090332195162773, -0.013227769173681736, -0.026542406529188156, -0.004299049731343985, 0.026869887486100197, 0.02957003191113472, 0.023072747513651848, -0.03532326966524124, 0.04118478670716286, -0.05917820706963539, -0.03467933461070061, -0.07958175241947174, 0.021207978948950768, -0.0068518659099936485, -0.00676408177241683, 0.0021670234855264425, 0.01522469986230135, 0.017942311242222786, 0.007839025929570198, -0.024082479998469353, -0.03766939416527748, -0.007462533190846443, 0.042976051568984985, -0.029715465381741524, -0.00410216860473156, 0.03923938795924187, 0.027113638818264008, -0.05455004796385765, 0.040253765881061554, -0.06056321784853935, -0.028758695349097252, 0.01006696280092001, -0.030743733048439026, -0.02498168684542179, 0.01254210527986288, -0.014296334236860275, -0.007040884345769882, 0.007840033620595932, -0.005384960677474737, 0.004659988917410374, -0.09264689683914185, 0.0532681867480278, 0.11094465851783752, -0.010379176586866379, 0.010785200633108616, -0.014436731114983559, -0.006537940353155136, 0.027216946706175804, 0.013356995768845081, -0.013144462369382381, -0.054402150213718414, -0.01154129859060049, 0.02032812498509884, 0.02646326646208763, -0.02012106217443943, 0.01673101633787155, 0.08013996481895447, -0.008359458297491074, 0.014895501546561718, 0.03456980362534523, 0.031110838055610657, 0.041160766035318375, 0.008902426809072495, 0.022703230381011963, 0.05119176581501961, 0.012481329962611198, 0.008536983281373978, 0.03979547321796417, 0.013631446287035942, 0.006518256384879351, -0.008967217989265919, 0.06207074224948883, 0.004393136594444513, 0.003772065043449402, -0.013022969476878643, -0.016676627099514008, 0.04875457286834717, -0.015016180463135242, 0.002944105537608266, 0.016182273626327515, 0.008831706829369068, 0.0021008772309869528, 0.012938367202877998, -0.03114832378923893, 0.010664686560630798, 0.06720484048128128, -0.07922034710645676, 0.001284206984564662, 0.008782739751040936, -0.04448564350605011, 0.0021310849115252495, 0.01563807763159275, -0.036969125270843506, -0.0569683276116848, 0.03512069210410118, 0.04732947051525116, -0.007074019871652126, 0.04365110024809837, -0.042640332132577896, -0.04923315718770027, -0.04368796572089195, -0.04601100832223892, 0.02164020575582981, 0.022722851485013962, -0.05720961093902588, 0.0005437184008769691, -0.021530665457248688, -0.04073221981525421, 0.011277204379439354, -0.022917108610272408, -0.06835716962814331, 0.013745409436523914, -0.017188340425491333, -0.04026693478226662, -0.0467032827436924, -0.03133591264486313, 0.004724038764834404, 0.00621069734916091, -0.020973021164536476, 0.05044526234269142, -0.005942708812654018, -0.031483788043260574, -0.012318199500441551, -0.04898344352841377, 0.004928503185510635, -0.03338776156306267, 0.0034723645076155663, -0.012527965009212494, -0.003927354235202074, 0.02360658533871174, 0.033108510076999664, -0.023234501481056213, -0.03361104428768158, -0.055516816675662994, -0.04077572375535965, -0.016100283712148666, 0.024340368807315826, 0.005434690974652767, -0.015483287163078785, 0.02277824655175209, 0.06785354763269424, 0.013449848629534245, -0.0729827880859375, -0.05510551854968071, 0.026316536590456963, -0.01100278738886118, 0.02291799709200859, 0.0030539650470018387, -0.006603052373975515, -0.0028347026091068983, 0.020880425348877907, 0.002170905936509371, 0.023004190996289253, 0.04550258070230484, 0.011306519620120525, 0.027314946055412292, -0.000391207606298849, 0.006652832962572575, -0.04792741686105728, 0.038284316658973694, 0.019426191225647926, -0.029184315353631973, -0.0002606504422146827, -0.02699357457458973, 0.046814464032649994, 0.041565343737602234, -0.018736127763986588, 0.021622249856591225, 0.0015859942650422454, 0.018197720870375633, -0.012840735726058483, 0.04965202137827873, -0.00022763386368751526, -0.04272300377488136, -0.0304617490619421, 0.011229864321649075, 0.05410948768258095, -0.04429082199931145, -0.0015646001556888223, 0.026684051379561424, 0.04239372909069061, -0.008724210783839226, 0.005099541042000055, 0.01641005091369152, -0.015491625294089317, -0.017629100009799004, -0.020511440932750702, -0.003169460454955697, 0.05888655409216881, 0.04951349273324013, 0.005455243866890669, -0.01675773411989212, -0.014967500232160091, 0.013393023051321507, -0.07047417014837265, -0.011141764000058174, -0.036632247269153595, 0.06988713890314102, 0.04238566756248474, 0.07572521269321442, -0.0048195114359259605, -0.043265681713819504, 0.007890403270721436, 0.016318390145897865, -0.07131460309028625, 0.024200910702347755, 0.001922975992783904, 0.005250090267509222, -0.01907660998404026, -0.051886461675167084, 0.03929177299141884, -0.03956712782382965, 0.011444779112935066, 0.004441709257662296, 0.005390892270952463, -0.021991567686200142, -0.005981234833598137, -0.0016218358650803566, -0.0068658581003546715, -0.028291085734963417, -0.008633390069007874, 0.020139003172516823, -0.004371376242488623, 0.05906619876623154, 0.023901306092739105, -0.0017386176623404026, -0.010187198407948017, -0.021864498034119606, 0.02805270254611969, 0.0014691224787384272, 0.012985995970666409, 0.00045942122233100235, 0.014550906606018543, -0.039314933121204376, 0.04079756513237953, 0.049264077097177505, 0.07011358439922333, 0.07262790948152542, -0.021175168454647064, -0.029001375660300255, 0.022062016651034355, -0.010042996145784855, 0.017932206392288208, 0.00016518743359483778, 0.01654885523021221, -0.015654409304261208, 0.016658363863825798, 0.011966906487941742, -0.03448458015918732, 0.015602967701852322, 0.09125135093927383, -0.012670241296291351, -0.00036079229903407395, -0.007270865608006716, 0.0026100322138518095, -0.00543352821841836, 0.010677782818675041, 0.01345962006598711, 0.012970659881830215, 0.012492017820477486, 0.0010044410591945052, 0.032974909991025925, -0.030386950820684433, -0.02730584144592285, 0.01723329909145832, 0.03894477337598801, 0.03825676068663597, 0.00543528888374567, -0.05118364095687866, 0.007681721821427345, 0.0280685406178236, 0.032723311334848404, 0.024003390222787857, 0.030749760568141937, -0.08876366913318634, 0.00009684389806352556, 0.03694700822234154, 0.046079300343990326, -0.029273509979248047, -0.021665599197149277, -0.013239836320281029, 0.017416074872016907, 0.03596945106983185, -0.07310184091329575, 0.022734399884939194, -0.03643301501870155, -0.005601424258202314, -0.040247611701488495, -0.025124121457338333, -0.04242699220776558, -0.008061474189162254, -0.03768635913729668, 0.026175491511821747, 0.01115537341684103, -0.03477917239069939, -0.04554543271660805, 0.04991999641060829, 0.010268718004226685, 0.04545695707201958, -0.03802808001637459, -0.0395125187933445, -0.0023155459202826023, 0.05992424115538597, 0.0016180342063307762, -0.05258358642458916, -0.021458880975842476, 0.01095015462487936, -0.05154071003198624, 0.056390825659036636, 0.0023585513699799776, -0.04050591215491295, 0.02237887866795063, -0.011388112790882587, -0.021487515419721603, -0.015991974622011185, -0.03464321419596672, 0.0377536378800869, 0.031518369913101196, -0.013856259174644947, 0.058166224509477615, 0.012807207182049751, -0.01429680548608303, 0.007348441518843174, -0.04691479727625847, -0.03217920660972595, -0.0026851538568735123, -0.02469083108007908, -0.059542376548051834, 0.00039416621439158916, -0.0021785080898553133, 0.0056045642122626305, 0.0025528313126415014, 0.03285539895296097, -0.03454885259270668, 0.014291349798440933, 0.008015681058168411, 0.04273225739598274, 0.01541263610124588, -0.025672713294625282, -0.0166925135999918, 0.05046794191002846, -0.022812964394688606, -0.006717875134199858, 0.019496550783514977, -0.004124072380363941, 0.011621073819696903, 0.009645196609199047, -0.0409184992313385, 0.014875475317239761, -0.04965654015541077, -0.007471243850886822, 0.044992245733737946, -0.03516404703259468, -0.005522671155631542, 0.02479376643896103, 0.01730138063430786, -0.00409656623378396, -0.022350352257490158, -0.029234791174530983, 0.009685819037258625, 0.04443589597940445, 0.02833232469856739, -0.03956932947039604, 0.05996781215071678, -0.006282759364694357, -0.010321644134819508, -0.04555625095963478, -0.04259514436125755, 0.03366183862090111, -0.00008397610508836806, -0.034051600843667984, -0.014708452858030796, 0.00269519817084074, -0.03749000281095505, -0.014762181788682938, -0.002692366484552622, 0.04916422814130783, -0.05002536624670029, -0.032497912645339966, -0.0038055884651839733, 0.03858104720711708, 0.06499394029378891, -0.011759408749639988, -0.01449738908559084, 0.02392668090760708, 0.011754202656447887, -0.014967632479965687, 0.040509358048439026, 0.005336546804755926, -0.03351641073822975, -0.015242851339280605, -0.010930797085165977, 0.023931274190545082, 0.0580563098192215, 0.0020267379004508257, -0.0031430867966264486, -0.016505900770425797, 0.016421737149357796, -0.022649988532066345, -0.00788829941302538, 0.0020722877234220505, -0.0025340185966342688, 0.017154429107904434, -0.022630959749221802, -0.027755780145525932, -0.029344776645302773, -0.02308288961648941, 0.04922518879175186, 0.007867073640227318, 0.0031718986574560404, 0.029677631333470345, 0.07106425613164902, -0.008171377703547478, 0.00298497686162591, -0.0037601888179779053, -0.03851078078150749, 0.07680385559797287, 0.0012899941066280007, 0.0010072668083012104, 0.03823193907737732, 0.04083595797419548, 0.0006581306806765497, -0.023550981655716896, -0.018273556604981422, -0.020460344851017, 0.06927184015512466, -0.027602942660450935, 0.041158273816108704, 0.046611689031124115, 0.024178003892302513, 0.019253991544246674, -0.03401676565408707, -0.016400359570980072, -0.005707850679755211, -0.006984283681958914, 0.0554807074368, -0.024023842066526413, -0.056215859949588776, 0.012675227597355843, 0.002098828088492155, 0.021034646779298782, 0.013366076163947582, 0.00697551853954792, -0.006424677092581987, -0.0077824341133236885, -0.025615543127059937, 0.01076851412653923, 0.00825086422264576, -0.020979193970561028, -0.015327287837862968, -0.05009685829281807, -0.016177278012037277, 0.05334123224020004, 0.02500505931675434, -0.01849491149187088, -0.0802604928612709, -0.023447813466191292, -0.05385137349367142, 0.0020218666177242994, -0.03079981729388237, -0.005979098845273256, 0.0375746488571167, -0.0014982236316427588, 0.036415912210941315, 0.011434041894972324, -0.007488078437745571, -0.025833282619714737, -0.10321475565433502, -0.02529546245932579, -0.008002734743058681, -0.046009987592697144, 0.03167835995554924, 0.0031235897913575172, -0.006469230633229017, -0.005600041709840298, -0.026761850342154503, 0.024767383933067322, -0.019291425123810768, 0.02711641974747181, -0.012917294166982174, 0.08329512923955917, -0.011898444034159184, 0.028067033737897873, 0.010408678092062473, -0.008051696233451366, 0.12388616800308228, 0.07801856845617294, 0.02379029430449009, -0.03589639440178871, -0.0004575967031996697, 0.02722327783703804, -0.007853218354284763, 0.014460928738117218, -0.02388176880776882, 0.006691306829452515, 0.01051093265414238, 0.04461538791656494, 0.016009926795959473, 0.003934055101126432, -0.0007638880633749068, 0.04231429845094681, -0.022564196959137917, -0.008014742285013199, 0.03445436432957649, 0.02613123692572117, 0.006357154343277216, -0.02847934328019619, -0.06373096257448196, 0.016045760363340378, 0.03625178337097168, -0.012359085492789745, -0.023864328861236572, -0.035336896777153015, -0.0018987637013196945, -0.009726811200380325, -0.0022794115357100964, 0.023521846160292625, 0.016727924346923828, 0.02972395159304142, 0.0037506059743463993, 0.02654721401631832, 0.009743502363562584, -0.02903604321181774, 0.016488682478666306, 0.028699403628706932, -0.02938966639339924, -0.0005019897944293916, -0.011048763990402222, 0.05834119766950607, -0.05061836540699005, -0.019138867035508156, -0.06118159741163254, 0.04019845277070999, -0.010070244781672955, -0.05660101771354675, -0.02456575818359852, -0.00830750074237585, 0.001004803110845387, -0.037749044597148895, -0.01838742382824421, 0.04623531550168991, 0.015837792307138443, 0.0031624860130250454, -0.008828427642583847, -0.03990989550948143, -0.005381373222917318, 0.005238568875938654, 0.015546222217381, 0.02194051817059517, -0.006249582394957542, -0.02566688507795334, -0.013829849660396576, 0.05814671143889427, 0.010493346489965916, 0.04297906160354614, 0.012176478281617165, -0.029902298003435135, -0.013484477996826172, -0.033931322395801544, -0.0006078486330807209, -0.01591305434703827, 0.0007230984047055244, -0.005635210778564215, 0.003959577064961195, -0.04511410742998123, -0.020114591345191002, -0.0018485276959836483, 0.0025028842501342297, -0.04203689470887184, -0.04176566004753113, 0.0554739311337471, -0.009314805269241333, 0.015658844262361526, 0.031181851401925087, 0.016332169994711876, 0.01263539120554924, 0.054017581045627594, -0.027357636019587517, -0.04483842849731445, -0.05090080946683884, 0.027730606496334076, -0.0008193690446205437, -0.01361620333045721, 0.021244065836071968, 0.11174406111240387, -0.004475969821214676, 0.01601347140967846, -0.008564860559999943, 0.04395156353712082, 0.012875915504992008, 0.03125086426734924, 0.0086671132594347, -0.011572172865271568, -0.013641808182001114, 0.001936100423336029, 0.03163456544280052, -0.02122604288160801, -0.003946792334318161, -0.008730808272957802, -0.0761900469660759, 0.010526852682232857, -0.015739765018224716, -0.033023566007614136, 0.012095740996301174, -0.02072926051914692, 0.0063377125188708305, -0.00887985248118639, 0.005169157404452562, -0.02066555619239807, 0.01295673567801714, -0.01838831417262554, -0.07547422498464584, 0.0006803615833632648, 0.02532876655459404, -0.02737393230199814, -0.02334892563521862, 0.032924313098192215, 0.028771735727787018, 0.007730661891400814, -0.0275067500770092, 0.021140534430742264, -0.0036399448290467262, 0.04301133006811142, -0.01407506875693798, 0.0006497613503597677, 0.020108995959162712, -0.021005770191550255, -0.02281765639781952, 0.036237191408872604, 0.0017783723305910826, 0.06280064582824707, 0.008139710873365402, 0.009192904457449913, -0.006829683668911457, 0.052658289670944214, -0.05065194144845009, -0.0054717049933969975, -0.023651177063584328, -0.029410550370812416, 0.04342585802078247, 0.029653538018465042, 0.01039694994688034, 0.0356166698038578, -0.018120665103197098, 0.010350423865020275, 0.010641392320394516, -0.02112608589231968, -0.00806132610887289, 0.013950764201581478, 0.03257963806390762, 0.01503022201359272, -0.019686006009578705, 0.013415765017271042, -0.00022711815836373717, 0.026424294337630272, -0.05768173933029175, 0.020813988521695137, -0.008496091701090336, 0.015358302742242813, -0.03876913711428642, -0.0058724344708025455, 0.016794752329587936, -0.018364153802394867, 0.01372690312564373, -0.037565600126981735, 0.011823059059679508, 0.014425154775381088, -0.004048507660627365, 0.030271239578723907, -0.009567620232701302, 0.02104814723134041, -0.030210498720407486, 0.05597928911447525, -0.04810327664017677, 0.01676895283162594, 0.02147042006254196, 0.012161150574684143, 0.02678457461297512, -0.007015146780759096, 0.04258456081151962, -0.04395785555243492, -0.032922275364398956, 0.012368357740342617, -0.01072282250970602, -0.042776066809892654, 0.0647616907954216, -0.04089220240712166, -0.024091482162475586, 0.07952229678630829, -0.014566611498594284, 0.02290407009422779, 0.029694749042391777, 0.007317599840462208, -0.014775363728404045, 0.050679076462984085, 0.046872273087501526, 0.030051546171307564, -0.009102627635002136, 0.05396351218223572, 0.020085284486413002, 0.003994681406766176, -0.009114623069763184, 0.04243979975581169, 0.0309553612023592, -0.0034276843070983887, -0.018698900938034058, 0.04070117697119713, 0.007754442282021046, -0.02957780659198761, -0.02959566004574299, 0.003724179230630398, -0.0034747293684631586, -0.04901941120624542, 0.015161867253482342, -0.016584787517786026, -0.016034023836255074, 0.050645411014556885, 0.013693048618733883, -0.008532870560884476, 0.018883444368839264, -0.029641466215252876, -0.03475894033908844, -0.008953472599387169, 0.014830305241048336, -0.0041800071485340595, -0.023157404735684395, 0.002889009425416589, 0.0274234339594841, -0.008101902902126312, -0.038318004459142685, -0.011421404778957367, -0.04840439558029175, 0.037049371749162674, -0.04773043096065521, 0.05763984099030495, 0.07522629201412201, 0.013350375927984715, 0.0005415885825641453, -0.09876462072134018, 0.08099067956209183, 0.0033329157158732414, -0.043049830943346024, -0.05003749579191208, -0.0031336990650743246, -0.03454706445336342, 0.018332894891500473, 0.02578565664589405, 0.04016106575727463, 0.01025061123073101, -0.01540908683091402, 0.014792374335229397, 0.005092177074402571, -0.009676376357674599, 0.024481507018208504, 0.007813626900315285, -0.009843608364462852, -0.031030554324388504, -0.0015627882676199079, -0.019642828032374382, 0.004327050410211086, 0.053163185715675354, -0.014151026494801044, -0.0011291923001408577, -0.04056751728057861, -0.02073553204536438, 0.00921778753399849, 0.01853763498365879, -0.004652462434023619, -0.00001867077298811637, 0.018978308886289597, -0.018590807914733887, 0.04074200615286827, -0.02901555225253105, -0.06485086679458618, 0.029923846945166588, -0.03608011454343796, -0.02166837826371193, 0.01958666369318962, -0.00882900133728981, -0.008572378195822239, -0.053155116736888885, -0.01026148535311222, -0.0014610560610890388, -0.02648974023759365, -0.00161284941714257, 0.033124979585409164, 0.012169119901955128, 0.024848023429512978, 0.0010907786199823022, 0.0533527247607708, -0.025404296815395355, -0.04673602432012558, -0.003348379163071513, 0.0020343363285064697, 0.046827029436826706, 0.024810032919049263, -0.0006896416889503598, 0.03196066617965698, 0.028414377942681313, -0.002677181037142873, -0.018617844209074974, 0.06892000138759613, -0.03364783525466919, -0.002153260400518775, 0.0039400700479745865, -0.006952313240617514, 0.012763716280460358, 0.010861244983971119, -0.009245491586625576, 0.02367260493338108, -0.05800021439790726, -0.0068303439766168594, -0.049269504845142365, -0.023570630699396133, -0.020218094810843468, -0.017724277451634407, -0.00694917980581522, 0.03826891630887985, 0.0343269519507885, 0.019802894443273544, 0.012685010209679604, -0.021196682006120682, -0.01700500026345253, -0.006050910335034132, 0.015581458806991577, -0.03963220864534378, -0.016251565888524055, 0.01660897210240364, -0.02184470370411873, -0.02751622162759304, 0.0114938048645854, 0.03022349625825882, 0.01649531163275242, 0.03158699348568916, -0.018979016691446304, -0.05053454637527466, -0.004196015186607838, -0.0007341290474869311, -0.055011194199323654, 0.00994138978421688, -0.04152185842394829, 0.009875582531094551, 0.03579486533999443, -0.046779122203588486 ]
<p>I have a lot of data (gigs) that may be useful in predicting equity prices. I can import these as a series of features (columns) in a table where the companies are rows. I have time series information too.</p> <p>I have some machine learning experience but no experience as a trader.</p> <p>Is there some software or platform where I could easily import my data and it could backtest/forward test my data to see if it's useful?</p> <p>I understand that any machine learning system that's out there in public won't outperform the market enough to cover brokerage fees, but given my data, there's a chance it would. So I probably don't need state of the art in machine learning but I'd like to find a solution where I don't spend the next 6 months learning the stock market. I'd rather spend that time getting feedback on, and iterating on the input data, because as a data-oriented developer, that's where I can add value.</p> <p>Any help, much appreciated.</p>
44,147
[ 0.008738003671169281, -0.00419392716139555, 0.005149145144969225, -0.022243905812501907, 0.04196171835064888, -0.011539855971932411, -0.024651754647493362, -0.000815616687759757, 0.04797863960266113, -0.03825098276138306, 0.03766486048698425, 0.03690296784043312, 0.04541848972439766, 0.04011869803071022, -0.003470163093879819, 0.013538338243961334, -0.03409423679113388, -0.04327010735869408, -0.005315679591149092, -0.01763818971812725, -0.02234899252653122, 0.014901279471814632, 0.035601671785116196, 0.007330905180424452, -0.0392400287091732, 0.035130735486745834, 0.02499045617878437, -0.00983619224280119, -0.012340613640844822, 0.022768907248973846, -0.05362846329808235, -0.025181548669934273, 0.007640288211405277, 0.05546850711107254, 0.017536787316203117, 0.03302823752164841, -0.009305549785494804, -0.04351895675063133, -0.0012996172299608588, 0.001592981512658298, -0.03195613622665405, -0.028415266424417496, 0.018584689125418663, 0.03270317614078522, 0.0009042650344781578, -0.007034482434391975, -0.010923175141215324, -0.03178589418530464, 0.015465863049030304, -0.0405435748398304, 0.08093570172786713, -0.004807902500033379, 0.02250603958964348, 0.030693184584379196, -0.006702975369989872, -0.00026325747603550553, 0.02762729674577713, 0.09806511551141739, 0.0022012428380548954, -0.04634559527039528, 0.025021512061357498, 0.0064255245961248875, -0.015051053836941719, -0.06139172613620758, -0.03653675690293312, 0.039057184010744095, 0.007026779465377331, 0.0011524423025548458, 0.03389193117618561, -0.030641984194517136, 0.01938563399016857, 0.007867136970162392, 0.0579611212015152, 0.011190981604158878, 0.02574811317026615, -0.028768343850970268, 0.007845318876206875, 0.022906988859176636, 0.04308617487549782, 0.049873240292072296, -0.016979174688458443, 0.02272574044764042, 0.020292773842811584, 0.06236841157078743, 0.07195568829774857, -0.035094864666461945, 0.046980537474155426, -0.03864685818552971, 0.022073546424508095, 0.043640900403261185, -0.010502718389034271, -0.01340359728783369, 0.04436914995312691, -0.012894206680357456, -0.04481310397386551, -0.012017132714390755, -0.009051504544913769, 0.023285236209630966, -0.004536707419902086, -0.04321553185582161, 0.013095350004732609, -0.03334204480051994, -0.0143740214407444, 0.04096345603466034, -0.019445359706878662, -0.0027125664055347443, 0.0012931562960147858, -0.012191863730549812, -0.005934729240834713, -0.0013741602888330817, -0.013337363488972187, 0.009292975068092346, 0.012116804718971252, -0.044765301048755646, 0.0229496993124485, 0.00014564338198397309, -0.022948432713747025, -0.023088110610842705, 0.05001198500394821, 0.09001974016427994, 0.008668075315654278, -0.05912857502698898, 0.026928599923849106, -0.031211238354444504, -0.0378715842962265, 0.024931995198130608, -0.0009529836243018508, -0.04275508597493172, -0.060718290507793427, 0.05744003504514694, -0.03476935625076294, -0.027660898864269257, 0.02214130386710167, -0.033130887895822525, 0.04445092752575874, 0.03432541713118553, -0.09025068581104279, -0.05099337175488472, 0.04781798645853996, -0.03763319179415703, 0.03507623076438904, -0.055072639137506485, 0.0035784055944532156, 0.04742814227938652, 0.0574394166469574, 0.008951903320848942, 0.06283514201641083, -0.003982848487794399, 0.028509102761745453, 0.00441861804574728, -0.03947863355278969, -0.013297406025230885, -0.06471144407987595, 0.018161633983254433, -0.007834863848984241, -0.016796421259641647, 0.01701134815812111, 0.012855419889092445, -0.025144318118691444, -0.00833010021597147, 0.03212105855345726, 0.036062292754650116, -0.043927162885665894, -0.009300582110881805, -0.0391717329621315, -0.03334061801433563, 0.04396064206957817, 0.01388603262603283, 0.04922104999423027, 0.017159780487418175, -0.0039617447182536125, -0.046897534281015396, 0.020052410662174225, 0.008726374246180058, 0.0332457609474659, -0.0073220450431108475, 0.013172349892556667, -0.012140120379626751, 0.00575243029743433, -0.024880317971110344, -0.008091415278613567, -0.013712557964026928, -0.005455280654132366, -0.0012987436493858695, 0.026587167754769325, 0.028971869498491287, 0.023570111021399498, -0.008918196894228458, 0.03103581629693508, -0.05496734008193016, -0.048858825117349625, -0.059805773198604584, 0.027391327545046806, -0.0594542920589447, 0.007652405183762312, -0.011723206378519535, 0.014741688966751099, -0.003201862797141075, -0.03376564756035805, -0.0440717414021492, 0.009045092388987541, -0.033248450607061386, 0.014027147553861141, -0.02380799874663353, 0.0003107335651293397, 0.07364534586668015, 0.0215652734041214, -0.018357766792178154, 0.016671760007739067, -0.020898791030049324, -0.07660467177629471, 0.018822811543941498, -0.0383223332464695, 0.0022814152762293816, -0.005331403575837612, -0.005329974461346865, 0.047380175441503525, 0.023789653554558754, -0.007447818294167519, -0.02945758029818535, -0.016506923362612724, 0.048833563923835754, 0.023380422964692116, 0.04251103848218918, 0.01516704447567463, -0.039613693952560425, 0.00958908163011074, 0.014139275997877121, -0.016649503260850906, 0.01955476962029934, -0.030704405158758163, 0.014556256122887135, 0.026182075962424278, 0.02547614276409149, -0.0176768209785223, 0.0007049061823636293, 0.0849946066737175, -0.013811499811708927, 0.012881098315119743, 0.026549087837338448, -0.020570654422044754, 0.005030354484915733, 0.01397992018610239, -0.01074072066694498, 0.01509895920753479, -0.010448488406836987, 0.040787436068058014, 0.030561456456780434, 0.03590433672070503, 0.026224758476018906, 0.00017626247426960617, 0.029171999543905258, -0.008073901757597923, -0.009797929786145687, -0.00005786646215710789, -0.032045189291238785, 0.02718043141067028, -0.015590304508805275, -0.015633616596460342, 0.020929966121912003, 0.010481025092303753, 0.010881414636969566, -0.010400798171758652, -0.01949281617999077, -0.013824963010847569, 0.03411191329360008, -0.019391687586903572, 0.007599319331347942, 0.01998221129179001, -0.06305569410324097, 0.026228969916701317, 0.013556898571550846, 0.03208407387137413, -0.04214034974575043, 0.021209893748164177, 0.0358571894466877, -0.008021303452551365, 0.027671733871102333, 0.010589594952762127, -0.04987839236855507, 0.03246724605560303, -0.03654669597744942, 0.028987431898713112, -0.01346514280885458, -0.042007461190223694, -0.010335151106119156, 0.0025766557082533836, -0.021802570670843124, 0.0672227218747139, 0.027509242296218872, 0.0018808842869475484, 0.015644414350390434, 0.008675637654960155, -0.03932352736592293, -0.021659281104803085, -0.006374467629939318, 0.0008988086483441293, 0.01412708219140768, 0.0006790633779019117, 0.04775550961494446, -0.017212513834238052, -0.04665091261267662, 0.010232890024781227, -0.03445364907383919, 0.011640344746410847, -0.018212903290987015, -0.02369513548910618, 0.00004039341365569271, -0.015521209686994553, 0.0041939876973629, 0.024760717526078224, -0.015899719670414925, 0.013657758943736553, -0.04846887290477753, -0.050371140241622925, -0.001106404117308557, -0.013396227732300758, -0.0024642040953040123, 0.01664607971906662, -0.024295877665281296, 0.008129370398819447, 0.0005283542559482157, -0.04350082576274872, -0.033827655017375946, -0.01222807727754116, -0.003437065053731203, -0.05537617206573486, 0.030872853472828865, -0.00961413886398077, 0.025073416531085968, -0.024351395666599274, -0.009441758506000042, 0.03763097524642944, 0.07394316792488098, -0.003710760036483407, 0.01562253013253212, 0.010581869632005692, -0.01498921774327755, 0.014423144981265068, 0.01461897324770689, -0.008912569843232632, -0.04666629433631897, 0.004606504458934069, 0.020565638318657875, 0.0086252735927701, 0.029940996319055557, -0.04279192164540291, 0.025208236649632454, -0.020652174949645996, -0.020920824259519577, -0.006520857103168964, 0.0023822663351893425, -0.012195875868201256, -0.0641566812992096, 0.017510706558823586, 0.005056284833699465, 0.008722648955881596, 0.0441688671708107, -0.0007024485967122018, 0.06260236352682114, -0.0026987320743501186, -0.00448609609156847, -0.011946244165301323, 0.0005017264047637582, 0.025186462327837944, -0.013564356602728367, -0.016402948647737503, 0.02037082053720951, 0.04557046666741371, 0.016958855092525482, 0.029245954006910324, -0.012046420015394688, -0.05450062081217766, 0.01800345629453659, -0.028400594368577003, 0.00753221707418561, -0.023296980187296867, 0.07594495266675949, 0.012480453588068485, 0.06556610018014908, 0.02872111275792122, 0.008383214473724365, 0.060260314494371414, -0.0022662142291665077, -0.026685314252972603, 0.028744347393512726, 0.02709818072617054, 0.010026253759860992, -0.019870100542902946, 0.011944799683988094, -0.004761229734867811, -0.011002273298799992, -0.011707821860909462, 0.0311614740639925, 0.008095973171293736, -0.03577862307429314, 0.00811497401446104, -0.032713137567043304, 0.0010896826861426234, 0.007056323811411858, -0.0021010194905102253, -0.015568905510008335, 0.01223311759531498, 0.04168296977877617, 0.030526788905262947, -0.000903136795386672, -0.01723349466919899, 0.010387526825070381, 0.03052273765206337, 0.017126888036727905, 0.03769366070628166, 0.024579448625445366, 0.015899889171123505, -0.03492317721247673, 0.026329532265663147, -0.002926519373431802, 0.0010115482145920396, 0.011387159116566181, 0.017626961693167686, -0.01921650394797325, -0.03421805799007416, -0.019776085391640663, 0.026434607803821564, 0.00916755385696888, 0.0016645602881908417, 0.020094076171517372, 0.03366744890809059, 0.03300302475690842, -0.0506620891392231, 0.008315729908645153, 0.10975520312786102, 0.04217669740319252, -0.016719423234462738, -0.017476841807365417, -0.029284643009305, -0.016278522089123726, -0.029498949646949768, 0.030377745628356934, 0.03056623414158821, -0.018106019124388695, -0.011021486483514309, 0.03317021206021309, 0.0009385903249494731, -0.006272056605666876, 0.003662301693111658, 0.011303411796689034, 0.06576961278915405, 0.005892337299883366, 0.029901642352342606, 0.014268637634813786, 0.03472306206822395, 0.040596853941679, 0.02141336165368557, 0.03301847726106644, -0.1594669222831726, 0.015971286222338676, 0.0549648217856884, 0.04906052350997925, -0.020912567153573036, -0.05026044324040413, -0.05372055247426033, -0.017372503876686096, 0.014388369396328926, -0.022927934303879738, 0.01953895017504692, -0.001661497401073575, 0.013376523740589619, -0.03215451166033745, -0.0057037826627492905, -0.0031511669512838125, -0.0028354425448924303, -0.03793098405003548, 0.04916664958000183, -0.026266686618328094, -0.020931486040353775, -0.05314627289772034, 0.0022362535819411278, -0.020811188966035843, 0.04575445502996445, -0.017332730814814568, 0.005690938327461481, -0.019342156127095222, 0.03800811246037483, -0.03802616149187088, -0.06180722638964653, 0.014769120141863823, -0.011482424102723598, -0.025284217670559883, 0.05379955843091011, -0.01924949139356613, -0.07739678025245667, 0.043627187609672546, 0.010887663811445236, -0.013854257762432098, -0.0094446474686265, -0.05653076991438866, -0.012244350276887417, -0.010763931088149548, 0.05501807853579521, 0.05940397083759308, 0.047918446362018585, -0.013038074597716331, 0.0092817647382617, 0.011398919858038425, 0.015306028537452221, -0.04100716486573219, -0.039288610219955444, -0.007890229113399982, -0.025218946859240532, -0.03718675300478935, -0.027983199805021286, 0.02197037637233734, 0.05290089547634125, -0.036744844168424606, -0.007194429636001587, -0.019469531252980232, 0.022602101787924767, -0.0015734004555270076, -0.06407253444194794, -0.005301966797560453, 0.02362986095249653, -0.06309616565704346, 0.021281665191054344, 0.02564837597310543, -0.0006306549184955657, -0.007219071965664625, 0.0070923143066465855, -0.04050327092409134, -0.007508051116019487, -0.01692294143140316, -0.0066582197323441505, -0.0086807357147336, 0.03765173256397247, 0.06669902056455612, -0.004342189058661461, 0.04505004733800888, 0.009389843791723251, -0.03249876946210861, 0.008270921185612679, -0.006371646653860807, -0.0008883789996616542, -0.016463246196508408, -0.014821317046880722, 0.03523348644375801, -0.03786220774054527, -0.006938386708498001, -0.06774628907442093, -0.03307405859231949, 0.009794045239686966, -0.0072013009339571, -0.0445060171186924, -0.062041375786066055, 0.027832675725221634, -0.026648124679923058, -0.010333465412259102, -0.0029782119672745466, -0.015151397325098515, 0.030982844531536102, 0.0241517536342144, 0.04379519075155258, -0.01546880230307579, 0.028287509456276894, -0.0009729497251100838, 0.003968558739870787, 0.036999549716711044, 0.022321339696645737, 0.0008605424663983285, -0.00014141487190499902, -0.000236137057072483, -0.010613691061735153, -0.011641991324722767, -0.034734565764665604, -0.023799611255526543, 0.02224850095808506, -0.04184862598776817, 0.03362404555082321, 0.014909133315086365, -0.040578145533800125, -0.0024053757078945637, -0.03703562170267105, 0.005093400366604328, -0.013390135951340199, -0.040805965662002563, -0.051288798451423645, -0.00348319998010993, 0.01467893086373806, 0.0147935189306736, -0.014821101911365986, -0.008662375621497631, 0.012170504778623581, 0.0010330048389732838, 0.06888078898191452, 0.00951499491930008, -0.01569511741399765, -0.005734862759709358, -0.02773718349635601, 0.01952153816819191, -0.04002682864665985, 0.007295273710042238, -0.02689380571246147, 0.015958819538354874, -0.04811552166938782, -0.04652317613363266, -0.015279877930879593, -0.016817957162857056, 0.04357612878084183, 0.005899388808757067, 0.05330752581357956, 0.023094069212675095, 0.034510206431150436, -0.010111712850630283, -0.005153937265276909, -0.00614069914445281, 0.015151461586356163, -0.007474585901945829, 0.023269107565283775, 0.04482279717922211, 0.0019684352446347475, 0.03197139501571655, -0.016187753528356552, 0.001010695705190301, 0.049711644649505615, 0.01970698870718479, -0.010921811684966087, 0.03115290403366089, -0.015078913420438766, -0.044908490031957626, 0.01904197968542576, -0.04741540551185608, 0.04659506678581238, -0.04999319836497307, -0.0016644756542518735, 0.07870519906282425, 0.05380481481552124, 0.009469221346080303, -0.05046084523200989, -0.006510103587061167, -0.061261728405952454, 0.0032308956142514944, 0.05259046331048012, -0.024805743247270584, 0.042180050164461136, 0.013020196929574013, 0.021881893277168274, -0.01003401167690754, 0.032480351626873016, -0.007804316468536854, -0.07289376854896545, -0.009211380034685135, -0.04593926668167114, -0.045197948813438416, 0.04347798228263855, 0.015513182617723942, -0.011792981997132301, 0.014514496549963951, -0.026077289134263992, 0.010289458557963371, -0.04397936165332794, 0.025469934567809105, -0.055684253573417664, 0.09032981842756271, -0.03889342397451401, 0.005442571360617876, 0.00411540362983942, -0.006509873084723949, 0.11005332320928574, 0.06616455316543579, 0.03896321356296539, -0.07146595418453217, 0.017653372138738632, 0.004288500640541315, 0.013870361261069775, -0.04898405447602272, 0.023031974211335182, -0.02194587141275406, -0.0015365591971203685, 0.02356518805027008, 0.05372503399848938, -0.003699597669765353, 0.028169825673103333, 0.036347221583127975, -0.03897156938910484, 0.014693551696836948, 0.03214945271611214, 0.014312299899756908, 0.05081481486558914, 0.0033374319318681955, -0.03645063936710358, 0.014499567449092865, -0.030166197568178177, -0.021900681778788567, 0.02016073279082775, -0.04757314175367355, 0.010043028742074966, 0.019869059324264526, -0.03230384737253189, 0.0031488784588873386, 0.01073279045522213, 0.02736160345375538, 0.0054930332116782665, -0.02049894444644451, 0.02692743018269539, -0.026286719366908073, -0.014707179740071297, 0.003159823128953576, 0.004316976293921471, -0.010787068866193295, -0.031696658581495285, 0.017491387203335762, -0.024968797340989113, -0.02752363495528698, -0.06316529214382172, 0.018863432109355927, 0.00897638313472271, -0.010448168963193893, -0.009262767620384693, 0.04433948174118996, 0.0027985675260424614, -0.056538794189691544, -0.038858916610479355, 0.03669694438576698, 0.033135589212179184, -0.022046945989131927, -0.013198823668062687, 0.0191000085324049, 0.03919536620378494, -0.03581152856349945, 0.01361039374023676, -0.02901635505259037, -0.041259199380874634, 0.0007466019014827907, -0.03701264411211014, 0.030467350035905838, -0.009503640234470367, 0.02666187845170498, -0.028709452599287033, 0.005188485607504845, -0.014631125144660473, 0.002181081799790263, 0.0055361539125442505, 0.011013313196599483, -0.015885794535279274, -0.020855531096458435, -0.009299101307988167, -0.001710592652671039, -0.018202314153313637, 0.018141264095902443, -0.006881164386868477, 0.004045051988214254, -0.06115113943815231, 0.010082753375172615, 0.03718223050236702, 0.03885283321142197, 0.047497984021902084, 0.026129817590117455, 0.008224311284720898, 0.030147286131978035, 0.007908004336059093, -0.04782485589385033, -0.01895354501903057, -0.028869114816188812, -0.071745865046978, 0.006259732414036989, 0.0011223357869312167, 0.05638378858566284, 0.010051282122731209, 0.021873600780963898, -0.008441909216344357, 0.010567818768322468, -0.014306784607470036, 0.01573776639997959, -0.024499788880348206, -0.05375166982412338, 0.010129721835255623, 0.008692475035786629, 0.010697713121771812, -0.040547240525484085, -0.03277794271707535, -0.026019183918833733, -0.026439044624567032, 0.009490002878010273, 0.011164712719619274, -0.05803690478205681, 0.05581497773528099, 0.011661946773529053, 0.04715326428413391, -0.01826617307960987, 0.03857552260160446, -0.03387928754091263, -0.014123640954494476, -0.016588421538472176, -0.038293082267045975, 0.001702924259006977, 0.0014216013951227069, -0.03683580458164215, -0.003919846378266811, 0.0652887150645256, 0.03087538667023182, 0.010827988386154175, -0.020981701090931892, -0.0056010764092206955, -0.011653882451355457, 0.02538919448852539, -0.03827199712395668, -0.015035288408398628, 0.030251633375883102, -0.035124123096466064, -0.006657887250185013, 0.025952143594622612, 0.002493513049557805, 0.04167081043124199, 0.004386549349874258, -0.012848885729908943, -0.03054710663855076, 0.058749012649059296, -0.013664362020790577, 0.00009026296174852178, -0.0023271755781024694, 0.008311493322253227, 0.034365005791187286, 0.03336049243807793, 0.047623470425605774, -0.015174122527241707, -0.02470415271818638, 0.009193888865411282, 0.011271477676928043, 0.04598863050341606, -0.01611858792603016, 0.013062870129942894, 0.0039946031756699085, -0.024345282465219498, 0.040412839502096176, -0.029015274718403816, 0.040673572570085526, 0.001231013098731637, -0.019083639606833458, 0.01569196581840515, 0.01723424158990383, 0.027844471856951714, -0.05004137009382248, -0.003456964623183012, 0.03593318909406662, 0.005668544676154852, 0.051485326141119, -0.04145251214504242, 0.012520093470811844, 0.04455266892910004, -0.07258526980876923, 0.03894126042723656, 0.0365697480738163, -0.011810710653662682, -0.012952547520399094, 0.019253788515925407, 0.01456381380558014, -0.007019017357379198, 0.02617459185421467, -0.009288995526731014, 0.05633298307657242, 0.022588809952139854, -0.018899256363511086, 0.005550006870180368, -0.029976874589920044, 0.0253745149821043, -0.0036764994729310274, -0.02213890850543976, 0.02050946280360222, -0.06667085736989975, -0.03146347403526306, 0.03388003632426262, 0.010576114989817142, 0.04433078318834305, 0.028686678037047386, 0.027885161340236664, 0.010114888660609722, 0.007770621217787266, 0.04465404897928238, 0.022161981090903282, 0.0031700930558145046, -0.0024655938614159822, 0.01393006183207035, 0.023750044405460358, 0.025295624509453773, 0.04403555765748024, 0.02495281957089901, -0.017341678962111473, -0.0009551674593240023, 0.011426223441958427, -0.055485647171735764, 0.024398375302553177, 0.015792662277817726, 0.0025291643105447292, 0.0165270809084177, 0.009078794158995152, -0.01503780484199524, -0.003994131460785866, 0.010115782730281353, 0.012992714531719685, 0.006314679514616728, -0.030989017337560654, 0.028548145666718483, -0.016519667580723763, -0.04727970063686371, 0.021294591948390007, 0.02755340002477169, -0.00892112497240305, -0.04701559245586395, -0.006494591012597084, 0.012334792874753475, -0.054752010852098465, -0.05092225968837738, 0.010023522190749645, 0.02069898322224617, 0.04968604817986488, -0.027668310329318047, 0.028056083247065544, 0.061710137873888016, 0.006187185645103455, 0.023137716576457024, -0.07808462530374527, 0.06402267515659332, 0.020434681326150894, -0.03307482972741127, 0.018952501937747, -0.007772591430693865, -0.02764955535531044, -0.03252791240811348, 0.038206249475479126, -0.04118776321411133, 0.046191535890102386, -0.04478057101368904, 0.012646852061152458, 0.013296476565301418, -0.04762492701411247, 0.025680847465991974, -0.013844773173332214, -0.05696965754032135, -0.015930499881505966, -0.013543643988668919, 0.027623772621154785, 0.010936900041997433, 0.0010945159010589123, -0.016530046239495277, 0.008721841499209404, 0.020381877198815346, 0.001437036320567131, -0.018086548894643784, 0.011027027852833271, -0.025467585772275925, 0.03649460896849632, 0.010525669902563095, -0.01229537557810545, 0.03630251809954643, 0.004878568463027477, -0.06897040456533432, 0.06404555588960648, -0.052142225205898285, 0.005086294841021299, -0.03601818531751633, -0.00019433458510320634, -0.007532589603215456, -0.03467828780412674, 0.007537249941378832, 0.02895168960094452, -0.020669342949986458, 0.024528782814741135, 0.06034506857395172, -0.007940979674458504, 0.006165217608213425, -0.02093195542693138, 0.03280198574066162, 0.011371569707989693, -0.030874105170369148, -0.026425043120980263, -0.016919182613492012, 0.055455610156059265, -0.030438000336289406, 0.03621197119355202, 0.050994157791137695, -0.020960364490747452, -0.003375763539224863, -0.034337904304265976, 0.009283587336540222, -0.07136280089616776, -0.011808270588517189, 0.0017028066795319319, -0.022662833333015442, 0.019489243626594543, -0.00668324576690793, -0.02771131508052349, 0.056173376739025116, -0.022774921730160713, -0.03051835671067238, -0.020757734775543213, 0.016037005931138992, 0.02663317322731018, 0.02422281540930271, -0.01785776950418949, 0.02196972630918026, -0.00839278195053339, -0.014166396111249924, 0.02092921733856201, 0.002341214567422867, 0.0493122860789299, -0.036272287368774414, 0.006360250059515238, -0.01639421097934246, -0.012562088668346405, 0.005025529768317938, -0.01096485834568739, -0.034285105764865875, -0.053089722990989685, -0.032650500535964966, -0.00354104139842093, -0.016182254999876022, 0.013729823753237724, 0.0019612088799476624, -0.022922111675143242, 0.021007519215345383, -0.08253572136163712, 0.04640382155776024, -0.04886643588542938, -0.001826674910262227, -0.019427092745900154, -0.031297340989112854 ]
<p>I read that the k-means algorithm only converges to a local minimum and not to a global minimum. Why is this? I can logically think of how initialization could affect the final clustering and there is a possibility of sub-optimum clustering, but I did not find anything that will mathematically prove that.</p> <p>Also, why is k-means an iterative process? Can't we just partially differentiate the objective function w.r.t. to the centroids, equate it to zero to find the centroids that minimizes this function? Why do we have to use gradient descent to reach the minimum step by step?</p>
44,377
[ -0.06404515355825424, -0.0036546646151691675, -0.01059775985777378, -0.008715400472283363, 0.020149698480963707, 0.005190050229430199, -0.02287301979959011, -0.03969487547874451, 0.0021226429380476475, -0.03685726970434189, -0.007144961040467024, 0.04001975059509277, 0.018714219331741333, 0.04748925566673279, 0.02249385043978691, -0.010251114144921303, -0.016873126849532127, -0.014075780287384987, -0.0043570599518716335, -0.00013036152813583612, -0.018576649948954582, 0.034390613436698914, 0.04192936047911644, -0.016029376536607742, -0.03585881367325783, -0.011670777574181557, 0.012289495207369328, -0.02126738242805004, 0.017832988873124123, 0.06563246250152588, -0.03864338621497154, -0.0007125294068828225, -0.020196935161948204, 0.03145093098282814, 0.020623378455638885, 0.0009263873798772693, -0.04458782449364662, -0.01687745563685894, -0.04409514740109444, 0.009549802169203758, -0.03658803924918175, -0.03922634571790695, 0.007944826036691666, 0.02688087895512581, -0.0007021093624643981, 0.025657685473561287, -0.00006952518015168607, -0.03619065135717392, 0.011737920343875885, -0.05343571677803993, 0.08338846266269684, 0.014340016059577465, 0.0026602386496961117, 0.049790333956480026, -0.024723533540964127, 0.01740306057035923, 0.04514915868639946, 0.07216766476631165, -0.0058372351340949535, -0.026779750362038612, -0.020088108256459236, 0.004106922075152397, 0.02082606963813305, -0.005164683796465397, -0.01435321755707264, 0.06597313284873962, 0.01802968792617321, 0.02502533234655857, 0.04755670204758644, 0.007485483307391405, 0.005895030219107866, -0.0031732660718262196, 0.0564587228000164, -0.023522306233644485, -0.014411257579922676, -0.006887840572744608, -0.012938957661390305, -0.008632347919046879, 0.04731166735291481, 0.024619752541184425, 0.03266434371471405, 0.02377397194504738, 0.024132495746016502, 0.0005148662603460252, -0.000743018405046314, 0.012682606466114521, 0.10020040720701218, -0.00912541151046753, -0.004816611763089895, 0.045294955372810364, -0.02174956724047661, 0.018098969012498856, 0.037778668105602264, -0.02181258611381054, -0.00997754093259573, 0.06261957436800003, -0.0001483709638705477, 0.051739469170570374, 0.02512453868985176, -0.020374856889247894, 0.03170672431588173, -0.030324287712574005, -0.00414045387879014, 0.0231806430965662, -0.033234503120183945, -0.00408409396186471, -0.06447746604681015, 0.01463622972369194, -0.00963302981108427, -0.004391217138618231, -0.016216084361076355, 0.002206383040174842, 0.01617749221622944, 0.0015958072617650032, 0.036857180297374725, -0.017690744251012802, 0.012582640163600445, -0.02590899169445038, -0.006220066454261541, 0.051441483199596405, 0.038562238216400146, -0.02817618101835251, 0.010499746538698673, -0.05068229138851166, -0.040483713150024414, 0.018737809732556343, 0.012161714024841785, -0.03998056426644325, -0.015851961448788643, 0.014939641579985619, -0.008837561123073101, -0.031452734023332596, 0.020303361117839813, -0.0031166793778538704, 0.04554446041584015, -0.029413389042019844, -0.07804429531097412, -0.03530651330947876, 0.009820769540965557, -0.019860530272126198, 0.022664476186037064, -0.06969407945871353, -0.006716285366564989, 0.011039300821721554, 0.03744322806596756, 0.006783541291952133, 0.01847401261329651, 0.016546379774808884, 0.01985001564025879, 0.00030196941224858165, -0.026521556079387665, -0.007203276269137859, -0.03797202557325363, -0.02295779623091221, -0.0008468347368761897, -0.07503727078437805, 0.01951880380511284, 0.01446407102048397, 0.008486787788569927, -0.05653257668018341, 0.018124887719750404, 0.00677878363057971, 0.008861568756401539, -0.008394429460167885, 0.004781579133123159, 0.024387547746300697, 0.07369319349527359, 0.032402001321315765, 0.06873531639575958, 0.018325187265872955, 0.0024200533516705036, 0.02205842360854149, 0.016945527866482735, 0.0338108204305172, 0.049759190529584885, -0.029685383662581444, -0.01620333082973957, -0.03426310047507286, 0.05537081137299538, 0.0028371578082442284, -0.027994446456432343, -0.028738049790263176, 0.0070970747619867325, 0.03529921919107437, 0.010012947954237461, 0.043635137379169464, -0.0015155260916799307, -0.023986216634511948, 0.0009303774568252265, -0.02646701969206333, -0.007513369899243116, -0.0682973563671112, 0.013831870630383492, -0.024470441043376923, 0.0015457351692020893, 0.046744052320718765, 0.005441309418529272, -0.010439560748636723, -0.031531307846307755, -0.045552391558885574, -0.02447088621556759, -0.03067326545715332, 0.009713673032820225, -0.04824806749820709, -0.0012814057990908623, 0.06565207988023758, 0.012192999012768269, 0.004174411296844482, 0.06180441007018089, -0.04534267634153366, -0.056264303624629974, 0.012539063580334187, 0.004064660985022783, -0.02164805494248867, -0.01855039969086647, 0.015775056555867195, -0.009827382862567902, 0.02338803932070732, -0.0229756198823452, -0.014193067327141762, -0.06655506044626236, 0.09131508320569992, 0.06968584656715393, 0.006701950915157795, -0.003969330340623856, 0.0020553802605718374, -0.0071746595203876495, 0.008446099236607552, -0.0009464374161325395, -0.023350682109594345, -0.07876359671354294, -0.006526308134198189, 0.07628745585680008, 0.027879539877176285, -0.03536315634846687, 0.013040298596024513, 0.032357148826122284, 0.0389474481344223, 0.020731838420033455, -0.012806770391762257, -0.019116878509521484, 0.01694195717573166, 0.0039061682764440775, 0.02243117056787014, -0.026281055063009262, 0.0016239166725426912, 0.02814718894660473, -0.025573482736945152, 0.014565329067409039, 0.0067922319285571575, -0.033413589000701904, 0.052062395960092545, 0.017548315227031708, 0.010907658375799656, -0.014182480052113533, -0.0008344761445187032, 0.02864415943622589, -0.031207092106342316, -0.013440611772239208, 0.006427932996302843, 0.008175306022167206, -0.0015700915828347206, -0.017884792760014534, -0.04567449167370796, 0.012149038724601269, 0.027729064226150513, -0.03724619373679161, 0.02090926095843315, 0.002606890629976988, -0.02809867262840271, 0.024706000462174416, -0.013286647386848927, -0.02794419601559639, -0.06779637187719345, 0.01686224900186062, 0.025464417412877083, -0.02880280651152134, -0.005950186401605606, -0.032200805842876434, -0.00988868810236454, -0.022557422518730164, -0.02032587118446827, 0.019847672432661057, 0.004012932535260916, -0.017888909205794334, 0.006007933057844639, 0.00117319670971483, -0.004308952949941158, 0.016069095581769943, -0.009387066587805748, 0.014065495692193508, 0.007912758737802505, -0.0019793740939348936, -0.03467410057783127, 0.01533946581184864, -0.023310614749789238, 0.028782902285456657, 0.014896186999976635, 0.0417654812335968, 0.03801213204860687, 0.015116693452000618, -0.03597012534737587, 0.0411696694791317, -0.044096630066633224, -0.06804648786783218, -0.07465210556983948, 0.005068693310022354, 0.01953965611755848, -0.01852060854434967, -0.0060670990496873856, 0.036725904792547226, -0.06089107692241669, 0.01228058896958828, -0.02620052359998226, -0.06152194365859032, 0.041919805109500885, -0.022966211661696434, 0.03875530883669853, -0.011653277091681957, -0.023286497220396996, 0.10054313391447067, 0.02890196070075035, -0.04628809913992882, -0.037610314786434174, -0.00578264007344842, -0.04992776736617088, -0.008114565163850784, 0.032239511609077454, 0.0040620844811201096, 0.018317272886633873, 0.018121622502803802, 0.005529407411813736, 0.04916127771139145, 0.08370167016983032, 0.014895990490913391, -0.019732052460312843, 0.01251812744885683, 0.018057931214571, 0.005728998687118292, 0.022408686578273773, 0.03969944640994072, -0.039661794900894165, 0.0020622166339308023, 0.027034001424908638, 0.010586011223495007, -0.006841131020337343, -0.011219835840165615, 0.019930457696318626, -0.06136791780591011, 0.0211081150919199, -0.06738866865634918, 0.027227461338043213, -0.003089038422331214, -0.020817922428250313, 0.020691897720098495, 0.01783175952732563, 0.03794020786881447, -0.023541269823908806, -0.038383327424526215, 0.03173236921429634, 0.008125096559524536, -0.04482462257146835, 0.02187034673988819, 0.007923627272248268, -0.027496930211782455, 0.012309527955949306, 0.00940634123980999, 0.0017609141068533063, 0.024187523871660233, 0.035464800894260406, 0.01281692273914814, 0.0055467733182013035, -0.03412701189517975, -0.01385605800896883, -0.07784591615200043, 0.000693604233674705, -0.016768647357821465, 0.03488387167453766, -0.030042290687561035, 0.058640845119953156, 0.047745492309331894, 0.027379050850868225, -0.03307962790131569, 0.01617290824651718, -0.08535511791706085, 0.01729799434542656, -0.04674245044589043, -0.012372232042253017, -0.014255838468670845, -0.03868212178349495, 0.01731843501329422, -0.02626032941043377, 0.0029743837658315897, 0.0015446029137820005, 0.0163862444460392, -0.030213767662644386, 0.012861528433859348, -0.0029570949263870716, 0.019639642909169197, -0.02048684097826481, -0.012542792595922947, 0.06468236446380615, 0.0046538556925952435, 0.05712581425905228, 0.005054663401097059, -0.025392862036824226, -0.029852768406271935, -0.007083284202963114, 0.00016841378237586468, 0.03983212262392044, 0.02636357769370079, 0.00834081694483757, 0.03719191625714302, -0.013147829100489616, 0.020199637860059738, 0.02986660972237587, 0.06067982688546181, 0.0036215491127222776, -0.003818891476839781, 0.0024301134981215, -0.05444960296154022, -0.028017573058605194, 0.008657027035951614, 0.015018569305539131, 0.023157821968197823, 0.00014570327766705304, 0.02495449036359787, 0.021153664216399193, -0.03050055354833603, 0.00006695290358038619, 0.05769168958067894, 0.0022431323304772377, -0.04674756899476051, -0.038819536566734314, -0.006251257378607988, -0.011943862773478031, -0.017166033387184143, 0.04396970570087433, -0.028010409325361252, 0.0004890054697170854, 0.007596089504659176, 0.05463362857699394, -0.041390739381313324, -0.014575324952602386, -0.012347014620900154, 0.007931903004646301, 0.027351196855306625, -0.02397882007062435, -0.004982417915016413, 0.009043177589774132, 0.030666952952742577, 0.07108303904533386, 0.01452814880758524, 0.0071116480976343155, -0.06290259957313538, -0.010639478452503681, 0.03676014021039009, 0.01724093407392502, -0.030281847342848778, 0.01301369909197092, -0.05523087456822395, -0.04145163297653198, 0.04060593247413635, -0.03324689716100693, 0.051115732640028, 0.0011226939968764782, 0.018968775868415833, -0.02678118832409382, -0.005969648249447346, 0.0029880329966545105, -0.013082718476653099, 0.007596024312078953, 0.0433817133307457, -0.020687531679868698, -0.005590944550931454, -0.0784333273768425, -0.0034000922460108995, 0.02300005592405796, 0.07195284962654114, -0.007234404794871807, -0.0037313310895115137, 0.017909059301018715, 0.024690529331564903, 0.003505079774186015, -0.052347805351018906, 0.013469836674630642, 0.0061061326414346695, 0.006869287695735693, 0.03392209857702255, -0.009332384914159775, -0.0726129487156868, 0.05376885086297989, 0.03370559960603714, -0.02732314169406891, -0.026403913274407387, -0.0014152763178572059, 0.0495714396238327, 0.04365745931863785, 0.01589166559278965, 0.05731279402971268, -0.014331426471471786, -0.015257412567734718, 0.000001815440782593214, -0.036969877779483795, 0.024754106998443604, -0.027439873665571213, 0.007497599348425865, -0.043725259602069855, -0.003931797109544277, 0.0028106477111577988, 0.020460791885852814, 0.006701132748275995, 0.013027600944042206, -0.04721377417445183, -0.011123369447886944, -0.010857251472771168, 0.04173360392451286, 0.00665239105001092, -0.003365694312378764, 0.03764658421278, 0.045771367847919464, 0.005793245043605566, -0.036356642842292786, 0.03271595388650894, -0.011821124702692032, -0.00722527876496315, 0.017902428284287453, -0.0285769235342741, -0.016087958589196205, -0.0494782030582428, -0.0026980433613061905, 0.02033282071352005, -0.013117827475070953, 0.047181278467178345, -0.03545362502336502, 0.015686260536313057, 0.01494317501783371, -0.04905731603503227, -0.037118423730134964, -0.028602037578821182, -0.029971394687891006, 0.03923838585615158, -0.033510059118270874, 0.03743593022227287, 0.022253820672631264, -0.004064030013978481, -0.08866605162620544, -0.03628753125667572, 0.019441893324255943, 0.011645890772342682, -0.02345823310315609, -0.05077003315091133, 0.022216374054551125, -0.003317474387586117, -0.04502326250076294, -0.012353364378213882, 0.08093911409378052, -0.003435339778661728, -0.03183072805404663, 0.0036528680939227343, 0.05650796741247177, 0.07030268013477325, 0.01736106537282467, 0.005610902328044176, 0.011996076442301273, -0.02723034657537937, -0.0005364909302443266, 0.0039026164449751377, 0.029506830498576164, -0.019957954064011574, 0.020642727613449097, -0.03779830038547516, 0.019721170887351036, 0.03964528068900108, -0.009854155592620373, -0.015783125534653664, 0.02245800755918026, 0.013876204378902912, 0.01438816450536251, -0.033059749752283096, -0.011288086883723736, -0.011975408531725407, 0.004284967202693224, -0.015505297109484673, -0.02075587958097458, 0.0032291060779243708, -0.00243103108368814, 0.05105644837021828, 0.020274559035897255, 0.016225062310695648, 0.003086500335484743, 0.0370132140815258, -0.03540095314383507, -0.010842254385352135, -0.002802155213430524, -0.04368063434958458, 0.03204905614256859, -0.012941236607730389, -0.0016675496008247137, -0.01906435191631317, 0.07075095176696777, -0.018003670498728752, -0.0004022586508654058, -0.004815617110580206, 0.012761570513248444, 0.05922151729464531, 0.016651645302772522, 0.0509655624628067, 0.03950558975338936, -0.01275613158941269, -0.019729996100068092, -0.06038616597652435, -0.005258155521005392, -0.011132690124213696, -0.013559866696596146, 0.04459690302610397, 0.0014521473785862327, -0.028003353625535965, 0.010930907912552357, 0.030629253014922142, 0.0014995411038398743, 0.003472616896033287, 0.0204144436866045, 0.04238111525774002, 0.006140581332147121, -0.04618288204073906, -0.07790833711624146, 0.011847623623907566, -0.010719288140535355, 0.02187848463654518, -0.0003517590230330825, -0.05339081212878227, 0.03212352842092514, -0.010868818499147892, 0.0017458486836403608, -0.027715176343917847, -0.003706833114847541, -0.03021206334233284, 0.03623835742473602, -0.004126689396798611, -0.01486047450453043, 0.008217909373342991, 0.005771995522081852, -0.0009544854983687401, 0.016483379527926445, 0.002271973295137286, -0.015042135491967201, -0.05095434561371803, -0.05884726345539093, -0.04344000667333603, -0.04228977486491203, 0.021149104461073875, 0.0537746399641037, -0.07965642958879471, 0.024955466389656067, -0.02225257083773613, 0.019679298624396324, 0.0024521052837371826, 0.06401380151510239, 0.01367951836436987, 0.037463486194610596, 0.02418799139559269, 0.04990539699792862, -0.011601785197854042, -0.017092041671276093, 0.11542560905218124, 0.06136227026581764, 0.014526941813528538, -0.061757300049066544, 0.024247849360108376, -0.03701188042759895, -0.02134765312075615, -0.03255610913038254, 0.056850988417863846, 0.003264304483309388, 0.011911316774785519, 0.034624334424734116, 0.026470575481653214, 0.022147759795188904, -0.0031123028602451086, 0.05958724394440651, -0.0635572150349617, -0.05385485664010048, 0.015822693705558777, 0.004088928457349539, -0.014427702873945236, -0.012758350931107998, -0.04756872355937958, 0.0452287383377552, 0.009446106851100922, -0.03365841135382652, -0.007842428050935268, -0.010868136771023273, 0.02735043689608574, -0.02924301289021969, -0.0375463031232357, -0.002082069171592593, 0.00830891914665699, -0.04302230477333069, -0.0703011080622673, -0.0008737386087886989, 0.004724527709186077, -0.04883185029029846, 0.02896087057888508, -0.007474926300346851, 0.013779298402369022, -0.00018210972484666854, 0.0004939075442962348, -0.019997449591755867, -0.03581009432673454, -0.000025673953132354654, -0.026558075100183487, 0.05321197956800461, -0.021598679944872856, 0.03280903026461601, 0.01521079707890749, 0.009960073046386242, -0.010051187127828598, -0.03455217927694321, 0.007023934740573168, -0.00884892139583826, 0.03737448900938034, -0.004330773837864399, -0.0261212270706892, -0.046108365058898926, 0.03916628286242485, -0.011906235478818417, 0.02168443612754345, 0.015117274597287178, -0.031429827213287354, -0.019649947062134743, -0.04460516199469566, 0.03690750524401665, -0.01777596026659012, -0.006145836319774389, 0.0027361814863979816, -0.01553901843726635, -0.008715732023119926, 0.020864857360720634, -0.023531373590230942, -0.01016013603657484, 0.042526692152023315, -0.020269470289349556, 0.00021774602646473795, -0.008901728317141533, -0.050948891788721085, 0.004309916403144598, -0.01761575974524021, -0.022809593006968498, -0.022396620362997055, 0.016827598214149475, 0.04374140501022339, 0.0654766857624054, -0.00595648679882288, 0.04923286288976669, 0.002729207742959261, 0.019159231334924698, -0.010700278915464878, -0.02069850079715252, -0.008762364275753498, 0.009036964736878872, -0.047761254012584686, 0.023997269570827484, -0.008468945510685444, 0.038354698568582535, 0.03720677271485329, 0.028837351128458977, 0.013160714879631996, 0.034242093563079834, -0.014447886496782303, 0.041478708386421204, 0.002077409066259861, -0.03623844310641289, 0.02277085743844509, 0.021523548290133476, -0.015955617651343346, -0.045325618237257004, -0.02575124427676201, -0.027654344215989113, -0.005804332904517651, 0.035699084401130676, 0.0014798439806327224, -0.005103854462504387, 0.0090184910222888, -0.004513826221227646, 0.061219677329063416, -0.03409474343061447, -0.02954532392323017, -0.059189677238464355, 0.023585570976138115, -0.042277637869119644, -0.0008174530230462551, -0.0077435411512851715, 0.006086221896111965, 0.02636045217514038, -0.012827916070818901, 0.06069660559296608, 0.029360106214880943, 0.009613427333533764, 0.022851046174764633, -0.009520307183265686, -0.023001817986369133, 0.054493699222803116, -0.025975320488214493, -0.02503516525030136, 0.05773839354515076, -0.0518169142305851, -0.07658033072948456, -0.00934947095811367, -0.008311341516673565, 0.00545206293463707, 0.03606298193335533, -0.018809566274285316, -0.02934066206216812, 0.04772678390145302, -0.012279837392270565, 0.00992623995989561, -0.019489146769046783, 0.0023803485091775656, -0.010179468430578709, -0.012098517268896103, -0.00933049526065588, 0.0030210113618522882, -0.02048252522945404, -0.005736165214329958, 0.025496069341897964, -0.015964774414896965, -0.022876862436532974, 0.016917603090405464, 0.011718864552676678, 0.010325251147150993, 0.020720064640045166, 0.022672154009342194, 0.045040398836135864, 0.053399451076984406, -0.060008611530065536, 0.023668674752116203, -0.0276387557387352, -0.0018860559212043881, -0.10022596269845963, -0.007944575510919094, -0.007583022117614746, -0.009318238124251366, 0.03588366508483887, -0.04197161644697189, -0.005861286073923111, 0.037144552916288376, -0.06684130430221558, 0.04286834970116615, -0.01825190708041191, -0.023600758984684944, -0.053103018552064896, 0.01596698723733425, -0.010796192102134228, 0.015896141529083252, 0.009021665900945663, 0.05924198031425476, 0.00239642639644444, 0.006707662716507912, 0.0027961565647274256, 0.02414265088737011, -0.003080289578065276, 0.01484937034547329, -0.00968264415860176, -0.026034777984023094, 0.05221673101186752, -0.029169892892241478, -0.039301540702581406, -0.002235148102045059, -0.042795903980731964, -0.02109178900718689, 0.05156097188591957, 0.023435380309820175, 0.00550921680405736, 0.026450248435139656, 0.02913299947977066, -0.021356556564569473, -0.014703013934195042, 0.05233645439147949, 0.0055125984363257885, 0.032783497124910355, 0.001736137201078236, 0.026751762256026268, 0.029506199061870575, -0.026512976735830307, -0.02954166568815708, 0.018798578530550003, -0.039782747626304626, -0.0374179407954216, 0.012087001465260983, 0.020962541922926903, -0.0049033197574317455, -0.0395478717982769, 0.010962449014186859, -0.003802035702392459, -0.022613896057009697, 0.028777357190847397, 0.03966532647609711, 0.002972812857478857, 0.008302095346152782, 0.008829214610159397, -0.03801495209336281, 0.023888137191534042, 0.01648087613284588, 0.0016875403234735131, -0.050685036927461624, 0.015519232489168644, 0.031978100538253784, -0.026069434359669685, -0.0000017977386050915811, -0.016836484894156456, -0.004127766005694866, 0.05011580511927605, 0.011283930391073227, 0.024395909160375595, 0.019303422421216965, -0.03462006524205208, -0.02335849404335022, -0.09989296644926071, 0.07294180244207382, -0.009911268949508667, -0.00414065970107913, -0.02359747141599655, -0.014215204864740372, -0.04688802361488342, 0.024945639073848724, 0.04536678269505501, -0.00952969491481781, 0.010696236044168472, 0.009391291067004204, 0.014923918060958385, 0.033502381294965744, -0.033992622047662735, 0.04015596956014633, -0.03199489787220955, -0.028622984886169434, 0.0074004968628287315, -0.03545934334397316, 0.009525148198008537, 0.01260433066636324, -0.011909847147762775, 0.002124885795637965, 0.015790045261383057, 0.010270435363054276, 0.02305637113749981, 0.06183147057890892, 0.010989407077431679, -0.006090665236115456, 0.03753532096743584, -0.016778595745563507, -0.002558683278039098, 0.039734743535518646, 0.012591972947120667, -0.03999178484082222, 0.03620104119181633, -0.022593677043914795, -0.02277827076613903, -0.011857428587973118, 0.012105111964046955, 0.03175615891814232, -0.028191013261675835, -0.009116929955780506, 0.013200590386986732, -0.03617556020617485, -0.0022330170031636953, 0.03416061773896217, 0.0037953208666294813, 0.026395410299301147, 0.011805706657469273, -0.02051115222275257, 0.02309843897819519, 0.03263414278626442, 0.022887157276272774, 0.05657866224646568, 0.02157430537045002, 0.007726627867668867, 0.03557039424777031, -0.013276968151330948, 0.0030911157373338938, 0.02859397791326046, -0.037217553704977036, 0.02647087350487709, -0.022221801802515984, -0.03900333493947983, -0.0037604947574436665, -0.009469383396208286, -0.0052646612748503685, 0.015343431383371353, -0.02852187305688858, 0.05745607614517212, -0.02622595801949501, 0.024339571595191956, -0.001938967383466661, -0.031016679480671883, -0.013908067718148232, -0.010795218870043755, -0.007424267940223217, 0.04100516065955162, 0.006555864587426186, 0.0003764852590393275, -0.006493226625025272, 0.00564845884218812, 0.059387724846601486, 0.004192187916487455, 0.051914967596530914, -0.007172359153628349, -0.014426209032535553, -0.022963039577007294, 0.004401941783726215, -0.03524072468280792, -0.0492684580385685, 0.014241665601730347, 0.054835349321365356, 0.0358893908560276, 0.012687686830759048, -0.0353911817073822, -0.03223665431141853, 0.03486136347055435, -0.07685130089521408, -0.022240083664655685, -0.04754725471138954, -0.020020315423607826, 0.012051436118781567, -0.009719324298202991 ]
<p>Could anyone suggest the best method to predict the time gap between two events?</p> <p>For example, given that diabetics are at higher risk of developing hypertension, I would like to predict the time gap until patients develop hypertension after being diagnosed with diabetes. </p> <p>I will have both time dependent and independent covariates. Does this require a longitudinal approach? </p>
74,061
[ -0.010916034691035748, -0.029097074642777443, 0.011278718709945679, -0.006821506656706333, 0.003733042860403657, -0.00016717964899726212, -0.003718521911650896, -0.02135823667049408, 0.04959357902407646, -0.012054430320858955, 0.02134588733315468, 0.020976878702640533, 0.027701249346137047, 0.007566024083644152, 0.01550674345344305, 0.011445926502346992, 0.005426099058240652, -0.01291895192116499, -0.006559875328093767, -0.024883877485990524, 0.009089027531445026, -0.01309228502213955, -0.019416091963648796, 0.00011098281538579613, -0.0222226120531559, 0.04186997190117836, 0.039014238864183426, -0.03961773216724396, -0.026577025651931763, 0.04726496711373329, -0.041049275547266006, -0.034552641212940216, 0.01630258932709694, 0.0322149284183979, 0.00741211324930191, 0.0024608890525996685, -0.04146568104624748, -0.06779875606298447, -0.03135992959141731, 0.02395975962281227, -0.03304542973637581, -0.03773801401257515, -0.026367582380771637, 0.057062916457653046, -0.03927631676197052, 0.028919709846377373, -0.006016022991389036, -0.033202797174453735, 0.032025594264268875, -0.04199524596333504, 0.04143008962273598, -0.03625781461596489, 0.10048225522041321, 0.018414493650197983, -0.037418801337480545, -0.015135500580072403, 0.0409318245947361, 0.07579045742750168, 0.00877820048481226, -0.015532970428466797, -0.024075327441096306, 0.008983509615063667, 0.020419098436832428, 0.009544625878334045, -0.05045684427022934, 0.009079501032829285, -0.01809651218354702, -0.026662450283765793, 0.01377714890986681, -0.037512123584747314, -0.00104001525323838, 0.013870138674974442, 0.03486548364162445, -0.000662686419673264, 0.01505934726446867, -0.04274102672934532, -0.017197411507368088, 0.016987040638923645, 0.030406910926103592, 0.025408651679754257, 0.0040253158658742905, -0.014375193975865841, 0.04106391966342926, 0.03860066831111908, -0.0008394611068069935, -0.0004752164823003113, 0.05086265504360199, -0.022390546277165413, -0.010417315177619457, 0.04300672933459282, -0.03824373707175255, 0.011273604817688465, 0.02351464331150055, -0.004662854131311178, -0.020181456580758095, 0.05084151029586792, -0.0322263166308403, 0.03458590805530548, 0.026684535667300224, 0.02691199816763401, -0.011338145472109318, -0.053416866809129715, 0.022972702980041504, 0.04468267783522606, -0.017250215634703636, -0.04780355095863342, -0.03006640635430813, -0.018335754051804543, -0.00018487263878341764, 0.003364681964740157, -0.043977249413728714, 0.004484126344323158, 0.00843521486967802, -0.01902179978787899, 0.006564972922205925, -0.027891477569937706, -0.007190636824816465, -0.01301999855786562, 0.05806879699230194, 0.08264864236116409, 0.03640315309166908, -0.026479868218302727, 0.0006449564243666828, 0.012956386432051659, -0.044322676956653595, -0.00983059499412775, 0.05704331025481224, -0.03429921343922615, -0.016023064032197, 0.06871824711561203, -0.009821463376283646, -0.01068215724080801, 0.038214556872844696, -0.016985459253191948, 0.042257003486156464, 0.03771879896521568, -0.07321121543645859, -0.02341349422931671, 0.015819400548934937, -0.012320287525653839, 0.012098618783056736, -0.045522090047597885, -0.00974772684276104, 0.0025203463155776262, 0.07972898334264755, 0.01982325129210949, 0.02428414672613144, 0.025480158627033234, 0.015330228954553604, 0.013043565675616264, -0.017245018854737282, -0.0038604759611189365, 0.008358468301594257, 0.038266997784376144, -0.017290638759732246, -0.08198095858097076, -0.014414247125387192, 0.024797741323709488, -0.04057027027010918, 0.01585022360086441, 0.0635644793510437, -0.006490148603916168, -0.011515290476381779, 0.000711140688508749, 0.03872847929596901, -0.03565763682126999, 0.09694981575012207, -0.011862554587423801, 0.020056338980793953, 0.007715500425547361, 0.03977014124393463, 0.02364019677042961, 0.027392983436584473, 0.05155106261372566, 0.018157368525862694, 0.008487858809530735, 0.01290314830839634, 0.04965454339981079, -0.025281621143221855, -0.010910430923104286, -0.007991855964064598, -0.03038799948990345, -0.02587057836353779, -0.031834449619054794, 0.023441080003976822, 0.02867240458726883, -0.0020123107824474573, 0.0060774837620556355, 0.03779328241944313, -0.029798462986946106, -0.020610740408301353, -0.05810971185564995, 0.0003691420133691281, 0.008186783641576767, -0.0042099254205822945, 0.03291666507720947, -0.040657587349414825, 0.02292655035853386, -0.019770396873354912, -0.015308672562241554, -0.04854083061218262, -0.004710859153419733, 0.04446393996477127, -0.057914551347494125, 0.01499665156006813, 0.014248567633330822, 0.05565128102898598, -0.016233734786510468, 0.00979151763021946, -0.06059882417321205, -0.01761586405336857, 0.011234802193939686, -0.06330480426549911, 0.04560443013906479, -0.03195778653025627, -0.025809235870838165, -0.022688785567879677, -0.03387727960944176, -0.030854733660817146, 0.022115524858236313, -0.05165013670921326, 0.051436830312013626, 0.055767327547073364, 0.013230695389211178, -0.01537218689918518, -0.018754206597805023, 0.05226748809218407, 0.01863759756088257, -0.03393588587641716, -0.055068012326955795, -0.050193339586257935, -0.012911398895084858, 0.014962419867515564, 0.02652846835553646, -0.0015252991579473019, 0.03585594519972801, 0.0344761423766613, 0.01628897525370121, 0.0025197314098477364, 0.04090012237429619, 0.000753124593757093, -0.013507806695997715, 0.008570796810090542, 0.030299853533506393, -0.006792351137846708, -0.015589788556098938, 0.024256804957985878, -0.019585702568292618, 0.05000604689121246, -0.027091650292277336, -0.006497390568256378, 0.046937599778175354, 0.013222171925008297, 0.014001402072608471, -0.02193302847445011, -0.06007322669029236, 0.04016555845737457, 0.011020694859325886, 0.002406216459348798, 0.024242784827947617, 0.0360768586397171, -0.005564243532717228, 0.029568897560238838, -0.008693676441907883, 0.019432462751865387, 0.027995504438877106, -0.033904340118169785, 0.03145815059542656, 0.012368233874440193, -0.0597720593214035, 0.023377640172839165, -0.012982456013560295, -0.050159767270088196, -0.01963985525071621, -0.02966269850730896, 0.004972201772034168, 0.004457831382751465, 0.007662237621843815, 0.0014476354699581861, -0.02372707799077034, 0.045736245810985565, -0.027089592069387436, 0.02030511572957039, -0.007964064367115498, -0.012408236041665077, 0.01038769818842411, -0.013904797844588757, 0.0057984692975878716, 0.039147116243839264, -0.011535030789673328, 0.0032790249679237604, 0.005609128158539534, 0.0067387716844677925, -0.07708635926246643, -0.07202507555484772, -0.0001925524848047644, 0.033532314002513885, -0.026973089203238487, -0.041138045489788055, 0.046204935759305954, -0.0010044870432466269, -0.045623332262039185, 0.005501056555658579, -0.001926177879795432, 0.029427815228700638, -0.04582764208316803, 0.02908104471862316, 0.009613553062081337, 0.008352445438504219, 0.00006963063788134605, 0.03843836113810539, -0.04515397921204567, 0.02463540807366371, -0.08813700079917908, -0.07842586934566498, 0.057474907487630844, 0.017195144668221474, 0.036175258457660675, -0.0093129463493824, -0.005199745297431946, 0.041390467435121536, 0.01259349100291729, 0.006544323638081551, -0.03284910321235657, -0.023023774847388268, -0.0171290785074234, -0.006727918051183224, 0.011020942591130733, 0.026470087468624115, 0.02310653030872345, -0.006002613343298435, -0.001376370433717966, 0.03566029667854309, 0.04721532016992569, 0.018515732139348984, 0.012994632124900818, -0.00022548636479768902, 0.01704290136694908, 0.0043863956816494465, 0.0037592777516692877, 0.012064590118825436, -0.012823149561882019, -0.008956574834883213, -0.03541197255253792, 0.02713717892765999, 0.007946651428937912, -0.05200643092393875, 0.007978292182087898, -0.02804110199213028, 0.0020852142479270697, -0.022736355662345886, 0.022184524685144424, 0.008821479976177216, -0.013082160614430904, -0.03264082595705986, 0.015189792029559612, 0.04590044170618057, -0.019706564024090767, 0.006453379523009062, 0.045215412974357605, 0.038878414779901505, 0.0064505659975111485, 0.014235460199415684, -0.04548240080475807, -0.0033865920267999172, 0.038979556411504745, -0.061237823218107224, 0.01844712160527706, 0.021759992465376854, 0.007096386048942804, 0.0026167414616793394, 0.0204373300075531, -0.03954984247684479, -0.009673968888819218, -0.07578527182340622, 0.01184199657291174, -0.0014340324560180306, 0.061686716973781586, 0.007452740333974361, 0.039135824888944626, 0.01648322120308876, -0.014562265016138554, 0.04557447507977486, 0.0037034666165709496, -0.06268564611673355, 0.0005347439437173307, -0.050673890858888626, 0.002035808051005006, 0.010164490900933743, 0.007250099442899227, 0.027053100988268852, -0.002491259714588523, -0.007050027139484882, -0.02897937037050724, 0.025153962895274162, -0.04042195528745651, 0.013866281136870384, -0.049434613436460495, -0.026828737929463387, -0.01834440417587757, -0.04463295638561249, 0.019570350646972656, 0.0024015798699110746, 0.023888904601335526, 0.06741413474082947, 0.03520536795258522, -0.001961010741069913, -0.004784801043570042, -0.004570627119392157, 0.016406195238232613, 0.0581388883292675, 0.04656536132097244, 0.012876835651695728, -0.06058916077017784, 0.03833791986107826, -0.026724837720394135, -0.0099014388397336, 0.04342780262231827, 0.016506310552358627, -0.015877706930041313, -0.03320721909403801, -0.027950763702392578, 0.019289936870336533, 0.022017061710357666, 0.05117218196392059, 0.019376901909708977, 0.031380269676446915, 0.012919815257191658, -0.06430484354496002, 0.021923154592514038, 0.08714652806520462, 0.029074886813759804, -0.016978008672595024, -0.031405314803123474, -0.006225865799933672, -0.005149251315742731, -0.017332937568426132, 0.030895810574293137, 0.01036645844578743, -0.023375796154141426, 0.014489826746284962, 0.013257789425551891, 0.000948759145103395, -0.004450772888958454, -0.0019961781799793243, 0.034115269780159, 0.05423011630773544, 0.053750697523355484, -0.03997452184557915, 0.04700388014316559, -0.005216679535806179, 0.030048923566937447, 0.04499887675046921, 0.03231978416442871, -0.10328533500432968, 0.00624855188652873, 0.042982760816812515, 0.029675358906388283, -0.058686092495918274, -0.04135991632938385, -0.01980707049369812, -0.004477687645703554, 0.05524202436208725, -0.017857180908322334, -0.0029683040920645, -0.000038387977838283405, -0.013633317314088345, -0.025525756180286407, -0.045650482177734375, -0.04491438344120979, 0.05882682278752327, 0.010424427688121796, 0.023938968777656555, -0.004337916616350412, -0.019128240644931793, 0.005972189363092184, -0.005236177239567041, 0.03750075772404671, 0.08914926648139954, -0.01187894120812416, -0.011401036754250526, 0.005834474228322506, -0.0120928343385458, -0.013599078170955181, -0.059569574892520905, 0.030760714784264565, -0.0021004120353609324, -0.016724085435271263, 0.030738908797502518, -0.02500096894800663, -0.023595448583364487, -0.009525981731712818, 0.017635364085435867, -0.04219723865389824, 0.013211173936724663, -0.006551842670887709, 0.024236537516117096, 0.03607168793678284, -0.011733905412256718, 0.053286049515008926, 0.04550468176603317, 0.008565830066800117, 0.0011889636516571045, -0.010066833347082138, 0.017041360959410667, -0.004107978194952011, -0.034911610186100006, -0.038503460586071014, -0.037298765033483505, -0.0440572164952755, 0.016599470749497414, -0.04882175102829933, -0.0008818110800348222, -0.015079819597303867, 0.0012870033970102668, 0.020577838644385338, 0.03780549019575119, -0.008890044875442982, -0.01310840342193842, 0.001186196692287922, -0.033509012311697006, 0.02011724002659321, -0.0030450960621237755, 0.033013634383678436, -0.0065039535984396935, 0.04508890211582184, 0.020856834948062897, -0.041799940168857574, -0.015057987533509731, -0.026908447965979576, -0.04262273386120796, 0.03102727234363556, -0.01240996178239584, 0.027771808207035065, -0.01983250305056572, 0.03119339793920517, 0.0039365338161587715, -0.02617715671658516, 0.002311036456376314, 0.0674450695514679, 0.0015460412250831723, 0.03357022628188133, -0.037323519587516785, 0.04883599281311035, -0.02095494605600834, -0.024540405720472336, -0.054593078792095184, -0.05485280230641365, 0.059483494609594345, 0.013258201070129871, -0.04012793302536011, -0.025866365060210228, 0.03147043660283089, -0.05520467460155487, -0.011836446821689606, -0.02222066931426525, 0.05125569552183151, -0.005018251482397318, -0.021535413339734077, -0.01727887988090515, 0.013426537625491619, 0.052934542298316956, 0.02428794652223587, 0.020688464865088463, 0.00836896151304245, -0.017709992825984955, -0.006238200236111879, -0.011184114962816238, 0.020226817578077316, -0.027337851002812386, 0.015375779941678047, -0.049630701541900635, -0.0033622747287154198, 0.04518615081906319, -0.035151608288288116, -0.034292787313461304, 0.009635916911065578, -0.0073465872555971146, -0.0013931593857705593, -0.06594592332839966, 0.018109945580363274, -0.002964317798614502, -0.002979198470711708, 0.009600159712135792, 0.021552350372076035, 0.014681197702884674, -0.017849678173661232, 0.019937945529818535, 0.013620797544717789, -0.01975301280617714, 0.0004908083938062191, -0.020546652376651764, -0.002690086839720607, 0.01925814338028431, -0.010436938144266605, -0.021735232323408127, 0.023556077852845192, 0.0008545992895960808, -0.018818721175193787, 0.008993440307676792, 0.005200719460844994, -0.07851573079824448, -0.06154084950685501, -0.010975828394293785, -0.00813381653279066, 0.06457683444023132, -0.039978183805942535, 0.0466715507209301, 0.04387418180704117, 0.009412622079253197, -0.02066950500011444, -0.049776509404182434, -0.005594790913164616, -0.0052814907394349575, -0.02476690523326397, 0.04857492074370384, -0.04039957746863365, -0.012059074826538563, 0.02704799361526966, 0.03593890368938446, 0.011797736398875713, 0.04505199193954468, -0.010183168575167656, 0.013832442462444305, 0.03303343057632446, -0.02111978270113468, -0.03621111437678337, 0.00843016617000103, -0.04131191968917847, -0.021749434992671013, -0.06175720691680908, -0.0026067730505019426, 0.029082857072353363, 0.056749310344457626, 0.011419137008488178, -0.026958107948303223, 0.0051336027681827545, -0.0506669282913208, -0.003900305600836873, 0.013441442511975765, 0.003162720240652561, 0.038537632673978806, 0.0019475583685562015, 0.029893089085817337, 0.019495246931910515, 0.011017972603440285, -0.013356351293623447, -0.08705209940671921, -0.014968717470765114, -0.029570305719971657, -0.011295526288449764, 0.02402586303651333, -0.0012085011694580317, -0.05821162462234497, -0.005294423084706068, 0.018795451149344444, -0.006043070461601019, -0.014010541141033173, 0.024837402626872063, -0.008013741113245487, 0.06650044023990631, 0.020449046045541763, -0.01286870427429676, 0.006419307552278042, 0.022303396835923195, 0.12323596328496933, 0.08083930611610413, 0.024961017072200775, -0.06078729405999184, 0.03693533316254616, 0.021592650562524796, 0.010064800269901752, -0.032376497983932495, 0.0406210795044899, 0.014959006570279598, -0.029475783929228783, 0.06224163621664047, 0.03825334832072258, 0.0168104637414217, -0.005469095427542925, 0.07511698454618454, -0.023176321759819984, 0.027299566194415092, -0.012051001191139221, -0.0069938646629452705, -0.0117743369191885, -0.010019974783062935, -0.02610856294631958, 0.03514963015913963, -0.034670744091272354, -0.030622173100709915, -0.005156269762665033, 0.011254806071519852, -0.005712622310966253, -0.005700528156012297, -0.013011584058403969, 0.0035908622667193413, 0.025352511554956436, 0.027181698009371758, -0.013351687230169773, 0.00902071874588728, 0.003402221016585827, -0.021540101617574692, -0.0033077632542699575, 0.008503947407007217, 0.011486842297017574, -0.02652745321393013, 0.0013048158725723624, 0.0014827823033556342, -0.060807570815086365, -0.04422307759523392, -0.02501135692000389, 0.04470156133174896, -0.019116053357720375, -0.012718390673398972, -0.021936360746622086, -0.006835355423390865, 0.02174566499888897, -0.028237992897629738, -0.03514116257429123, 0.011490859091281891, 0.020360590890049934, -0.015599742531776428, 0.03847065195441246, -0.016515985131263733, 0.019503973424434662, -0.00016371026868000627, 0.05807386711239815, -0.018034039065241814, -0.029317228123545647, 0.0028066029772162437, -0.0026205952744930983, 0.006896467879414558, -0.01147263403981924, 0.01038755476474762, 0.01709476113319397, 0.006813460495322943, -0.030938467010855675, -0.017504919320344925, 0.003236368764191866, 0.00403878279030323, 0.00035012527951039374, -0.004972612019628286, -0.030694639310240746, -0.0342208556830883, -0.028185594826936722, 0.018658911809325218, 0.002812538528814912, -0.0026760997716337442, -0.039265215396881104, 0.018899939954280853, 0.026746759191155434, 0.06396526098251343, -0.010987959802150726, 0.03451140969991684, -0.028167061507701874, 0.06024687737226486, 0.031634021550416946, -0.06971751898527145, 0.004734843969345093, -0.028458621352910995, -0.017170483246445656, 0.0063337478786706924, -0.031711146235466, 0.0519910603761673, 0.0026624854654073715, 0.03848310932517052, -0.008505859412252903, 0.0174869354814291, -0.0019389137160032988, 0.025304147973656654, -0.0015884442254900932, -0.04839169979095459, -0.018421992659568787, -0.03349354863166809, 0.03908931463956833, 0.029023723676800728, 0.008389228023588657, 0.01636497862637043, -0.02729497104883194, 0.030046286061406136, -0.042820971459150314, -0.015835100784897804, 0.013427238911390305, 0.0013831447577103972, 0.03167489916086197, -0.02987303026020527, 0.014225570484995842, -0.05677693337202072, -0.012725269421935081, 0.007906817831099033, -0.03778235241770744, 0.00948749016970396, 0.04207221791148186, -0.040962256491184235, -0.004387407563626766, 0.037314627319574356, -0.005607715342193842, 0.01739053800702095, 0.033834051340818405, 0.046053286641836166, -0.031298812478780746, 0.02241894230246544, -0.005832842085510492, -0.01660563237965107, -0.0023585690651088953, -0.04786139726638794, -0.037921834737062454, 0.010749159380793571, 0.010547444224357605, 0.02412625402212143, 0.014993657357990742, -0.0007002474740147591, 0.01227633561939001, 0.03402676433324814, -0.023639148101210594, -0.0528508760035038, -0.019190292805433273, 0.008916978724300861, -0.024644508957862854, -0.0021880767308175564, 0.007301333360373974, 0.027099275961518288, -0.019297849386930466, 0.0002365732507314533, 0.038539111614227295, 0.02892904169857502, -0.008045755326747894, 0.004960297141224146, 0.002554485574364662, 0.006513692904263735, -0.02821728028357029, 0.014589516445994377, 0.05860308185219765, 0.06276407837867737, 0.009401560761034489, 0.02291867882013321, 0.0019061659695580602, 0.01795334741473198, -0.08245766907930374, -0.025277549400925636, -0.00238067377358675, 0.03333553671836853, 0.028088320046663284, -0.027070974931120872, 0.0017639844445511699, -0.002452419837936759, -0.033688854426145554, 0.03101380541920662, 0.02684609778225422, 0.027454407885670662, -0.0037689509335905313, 0.023784805089235306, -0.00019599145161919296, 0.007104983553290367, 0.030040333047509193, 0.022406334057450294, 0.010637270286679268, 0.06500084698200226, 0.03329002112150192, -0.02004222385585308, -0.013325418345630169, -0.0024500112049281597, 0.024766752496361732, -0.086665578186512, 0.028671175241470337, -0.03343856707215309, -0.01678003929555416, -0.0050928108394145966, -0.03383617475628853, 0.050863441079854965, 0.04075820744037628, 0.001925247604958713, 0.003950329497456551, 0.026014836505055428, 0.005061929579824209, -0.03853179141879082, 0.013444983400404453, 0.007194875739514828, -0.012932547368109226, 0.007546070963144302, -0.050547920167446136, 0.031713176518678665, 0.021117012947797775, -0.01399206556379795, -0.017269760370254517, 0.015797482803463936, 0.005648650228977203, -0.046429120004177094, 0.018041761592030525, -0.01768519915640354, 0.0062665631994605064, -0.03177347779273987, -0.022748729214072227, -0.009314903989434242, -0.023633746430277824, 0.07154867053031921, 0.02213113382458687, -0.037620484828948975, 0.010238594375550747, -0.018850956112146378, -0.06173287704586983, 0.031188854947686195, -0.00794273242354393, -0.008192198351025581, -0.05482802912592888, 0.007091335486620665, -0.032032374292612076, 0.01104605570435524, -0.045023269951343536, 0.0027757855132222176, -0.01809225231409073, 0.028135353699326515, 0.01140420138835907, 0.001097136060707271, 0.06468888372182846, -0.0038189475890249014, 0.026116233319044113, -0.06426302343606949, 0.05243290588259697, -0.008540879935026169, -0.030353810638189316, -0.029818901792168617, -0.00961762573570013, -0.03371449559926987, -0.01934765838086605, 0.1038786768913269, 0.027137961238622665, 0.017670251429080963, -0.02320820465683937, 0.03768223524093628, -0.01658524200320244, -0.010250631719827652, 0.020642073825001717, 0.002293509664013982, 0.013658693991601467, -0.0217581856995821, 0.00297338142991066, 0.008735725656151772, 0.02012268453836441, -0.002667192602530122, -0.036543089896440506, 0.03159124776721001, 0.04541870579123497, 0.030705323442816734, 0.003202463034540415, 0.02431231178343296, -0.020791146904230118, 0.04628557339310646, -0.02979745902121067, 0.008541250601410866, 0.017591893672943115, -0.037326693534851074, -0.07771267741918564, 0.029109803959727287, -0.044085241854190826, -0.023857254534959793, -0.011371112428605556, -0.0211910642683506, -0.038649652153253555, -0.07234370708465576, -0.00009529264934826642, 0.021821919828653336, -0.03633761778473854, 0.023248640820384026, 0.019102826714515686, 0.006064136978238821, 0.025594940409064293, -0.020448002964258194, -0.004238363355398178, 0.05468041077256203, 0.013020665384829044, 0.013321113772690296, 0.008688691072165966, 0.05607185885310173, 0.004813659004867077, -0.003068101592361927, 0.0030903450679033995, 0.011486612260341644, 0.016163328662514687, -0.014850160107016563, 0.034207094460725784, -0.0037447395734488964, -0.030093876644968987, -0.001960007008165121, 0.0006002087029628456, 0.022726908326148987, 0.02586364932358265, 0.012168070301413536, 0.020091060549020767, -0.013614941388368607, -0.0009846752509474754, -0.05037081986665726, -0.03909428417682648, -0.04122812673449516, 0.01692650280892849, 0.015810757875442505, 0.000799873610958457, -0.007785293273627758, 0.01608169451355934, 0.016366062685847282, -0.026444217190146446, -0.019170980900526047, -0.010745001956820488, 0.034565094858407974, -0.014997636899352074, -0.02202845923602581, -0.020213164389133453, -0.02554500475525856, -0.009772541001439095, -0.016719799488782883, 0.01058975514024496, 0.047798916697502136, 0.053436875343322754, -0.015122316777706146, 0.009707936085760593, -0.013716354966163635, 0.028760433197021484, -0.10833528637886047, -0.007308959495276213, -0.06955791264772415, 0.004038036800920963, 0.006784448865801096, -0.0014186932239681482 ]
<p>I have been using successfully DBNs for classification for MNIST and some other tasks.</p> <p>I was thinking of doing dimensionality reduction before training, in order to boost performance. However, when I tried out using the output of PCA to train a deep belief network the results were quite bad.</p> <p>I understand that DBNs learn features from the image and that PCA might project the data into a space where things do not look as similar anymore, but I was not expecting such a bad result.</p> <p>Any ideas why this could be? I was especially suprised because this paper has succesfully used it: <a href="http://cs.stanford.edu/people/ang/papers/nips07-sparsedeepbeliefnetworkv2.pdf" rel="nofollow">paper here</a></p> <p>Thank you!</p>
74,062
[ -0.009251249954104424, 0.008131139911711216, 0.005632038228213787, -0.03672312945127487, 0.047319937497377396, -0.009878299199044704, -0.06697815656661987, -0.04103381559252739, 0.04728936031460762, -0.062498245388269424, 0.02425311878323555, 0.03514296934008598, 0.03956792131066322, 0.052811410278081894, -0.016447458416223526, -0.001182108768261969, -0.0072001125663518906, -0.010989884845912457, -0.015458352863788605, -0.034718312323093414, 0.012266352772712708, 0.04378907009959221, 0.003916454501450062, 0.00021086027845740318, 0.0009559115278534591, 0.03178685903549194, 0.016929814592003822, 0.0018916807603091002, 0.005988218821585178, 0.06197207048535347, -0.038851525634527206, -0.0056401765905320644, -0.02115100622177124, 0.058189135044813156, 0.032786499708890915, 0.023060137405991554, 0.01757395826280117, -0.06587410718202591, 0.012053323909640312, 0.04447224736213684, 0.02599332109093666, -0.027159428223967552, 0.019333356991410255, 0.07323317229747772, -0.02631719410419464, 0.033439572900533676, -0.008971217088401318, -0.01967008225619793, 0.022407731041312218, -0.05602816492319107, 0.07999870181083679, -0.0062154075130820274, 0.0059685613960027695, 0.04706115275621414, -0.016877738758921623, 0.012583962641656399, 0.04086960107088089, 0.08085592836141586, -0.009771597571671009, -0.06477726995944977, -0.009646298363804817, -0.0587308406829834, 0.01370954792946577, -0.042544376105070114, -0.02975653111934662, 0.04881857708096504, 0.03185075521469116, -0.05469612777233124, 0.03237757831811905, -0.022672824561595917, 0.015325786545872688, -0.02171759493649006, 0.03022879734635353, -0.027129778638482094, 0.013385053724050522, 0.008759264834225178, -0.008404048159718513, -0.0026855336036533117, 0.027967991307377815, 0.015261813998222351, -0.027108818292617798, 0.01596290059387684, -0.044817760586738586, 0.012067579664289951, 0.02313404716551304, -0.00010466745152371004, 0.04622548446059227, -0.03861508145928383, -0.0030737046618014574, 0.023096924647688866, -0.01163081917911768, 0.003238796954974532, 0.019472230225801468, -0.022667549550533295, 0.017806867137551308, 0.018962200731039047, 0.015044042840600014, 0.01921609602868557, 0.009113435633480549, -0.07307950407266617, -0.018702955916523933, -0.015301610343158245, 0.01576411910355091, 0.03435523062944412, -0.011647969484329224, -0.0481376051902771, -0.05352383106946945, -0.0011306797387078404, -0.04837198182940483, 0.029011469334363937, -0.016367418691515923, 0.005664704833179712, 0.015235483646392822, -0.0018271333537995815, 0.016606925055384636, -0.028067581355571747, 0.004474193789064884, -0.008591417223215103, 0.04244731366634369, 0.09171415120363235, 0.020138856023550034, -0.008869478479027748, 0.04143451154232025, -0.06314811110496521, -0.0367433987557888, -0.007594276685267687, 0.029261739924550056, -0.0024056334514170885, -0.019014820456504822, 0.05389244481921196, -0.021634671837091446, -0.03512481227517128, 0.05739045515656471, 0.007750311400741339, 0.018132897093892097, 0.031829189509153366, -0.06535385549068451, -0.025657815858721733, 0.05854065716266632, -0.030981702730059624, 0.014216046780347824, -0.042950429022312164, -0.0013352903770282865, 0.03993016481399536, 0.038775090128183365, -0.034610312432050705, 0.04111151769757271, 0.01344478689134121, 0.019734913483262062, -0.011193039827048779, -0.01964828372001648, -0.03826227784156799, -0.02448376640677452, 0.008090093731880188, -0.08501458168029785, -0.05518360063433647, 0.036922160536050797, 0.036508020013570786, -0.002279685577377677, -0.01625683903694153, 0.032252565026283264, -0.01351639349013567, -0.02407434582710266, -0.03658410161733627, -0.0353911891579628, -0.033764734864234924, 0.06331561505794525, 0.0030505401082336903, 0.04748142138123512, -0.0009904666803777218, -0.015694336965680122, 0.009395556524395943, 0.025737715885043144, 0.053632065653800964, 0.05933827906847, 0.021740291267633438, -0.010577358305454254, -0.025606872513890266, 0.03691219165921211, -0.002256000880151987, 0.011059320531785488, -0.030831173062324524, -0.04481225833296776, 0.010465618222951889, -0.028836729004979134, 0.054726868867874146, 0.009998553432524204, -0.06426369398832321, 0.016800932586193085, -0.01061988715082407, -0.015413613989949226, -0.06097232550382614, 0.03624756634235382, -0.008457229472696781, 0.012891154736280441, 0.006711861118674278, 0.010583930648863316, 0.013584415428340435, -0.0016572048189118505, -0.0046314396895468235, -0.011907593347132206, -0.02308904379606247, -0.011426959186792374, -0.04194207489490509, -0.04303083196282387, 0.0010564950061962008, 0.04272833466529846, -0.031795039772987366, 0.02915995381772518, -0.037204500287771225, -0.04055336117744446, 0.005149262025952339, 0.0014735145960003138, -0.012923678383231163, -0.043156880885362625, 0.019383132457733154, 0.03651987016201019, 0.012810321524739265, -0.03740997239947319, -0.0023062285035848618, -0.041567232459783554, 0.0758034959435463, 0.023879099637269974, -0.03376602753996849, 0.05421143025159836, 0.014744226820766926, 0.02230026200413704, -0.005836693104356527, -0.002234682673588395, 0.015287516638636589, -0.03143159672617912, 0.0010581467067822814, 0.03487197682261467, 0.034069303423166275, -0.03287465125322342, 0.003982515539973974, 0.043374206870794296, 0.046552933752536774, 0.03168146312236786, 0.016814103350043297, 0.0014675721758976579, -0.03762277215719223, 0.0053526596166193485, 0.014809462241828442, -0.0002577895356807858, -0.015068484470248222, -0.014405246824026108, -0.01734546571969986, 0.04953101649880409, -0.0054430910386145115, -0.036574240773916245, 0.04272768273949623, 0.0022892665583640337, 0.0035211751237511635, -0.010581034235656261, -0.04078144207596779, 0.02491370402276516, -0.0010152606992051005, -0.03432292491197586, 0.0164655689150095, 0.007868650369346142, 0.008224090561270714, -0.04772240296006203, -0.05517606809735298, 0.03385458514094353, 0.07853443920612335, -0.03166412189602852, 0.006128411740064621, 0.026346303522586823, -0.045421212911605835, -0.007775274105370045, -0.033353544771671295, -0.003044338896870613, -0.0177752822637558, 0.054745275527238846, 0.06353793293237686, -0.024802863597869873, 0.045286282896995544, -0.05340586602687836, 0.027369260787963867, 0.008224904537200928, -0.010180206038057804, 0.03357001021504402, 0.011029462330043316, -0.07722829282283783, -0.008248105645179749, -0.01118785422295332, 0.0005072683561593294, 0.0016769953072071075, -0.0056462883949279785, 0.006203631870448589, 0.002653559437021613, -0.013472402468323708, -0.019606035202741623, -0.032850977033376694, -0.028941601514816284, 0.036798492074012756, 0.00928509421646595, -0.042982812970876694, 0.03535957261919975, 0.03074740432202816, -0.00865936279296875, -0.019420649856328964, 0.004374577198177576, 0.003826881293207407, -0.00398155115544796, -0.005384885706007481, -0.008961625397205353, 0.00044902449008077383, -0.014902973547577858, 0.056159328669309616, -0.009837170131504536, 0.007584570441395044, -0.0648452490568161, -0.06531723588705063, 0.023828867822885513, 0.016238439828157425, 0.03970418870449066, -0.008100800216197968, 0.03337239846587181, 0.0787898525595665, 0.02109280414879322, -0.023855060338974, -0.021839803084731102, -0.024809887632727623, -0.06721125543117523, -0.024906614795327187, -0.01065999548882246, 0.0037302644923329353, -0.007204082794487476, 0.03945453092455864, -0.03549853712320328, 0.014681889675557613, 0.034838780760765076, 0.013610737398266792, -0.02882513217628002, 0.046931542456150055, 0.009347383864223957, -0.019028957933187485, 0.007170356810092926, 0.055574022233486176, -0.07460139691829681, 0.02068500407040119, 0.013541527092456818, 0.01055939868092537, -0.03936741128563881, -0.03954362869262695, -0.010839315131306648, -0.05162527784705162, 0.05227983370423317, -0.019091220572590828, -0.0001213208306580782, -0.007907450199127197, -0.008718027733266354, -0.004708369728177786, 0.017541849985718727, 0.07627682387828827, -0.0074365041218698025, 0.015135364606976509, 0.03257816657423973, 0.001664936076849699, 0.013500492088496685, 0.011975460685789585, 0.010321348905563354, -0.04345061630010605, 0.0000015042845689094975, 0.023776711896061897, 0.039328448474407196, 0.035606563091278076, 0.01871192269027233, 0.019419971853494644, 0.01894918829202652, -0.017808686941862106, 0.022258277982473373, -0.05244520679116249, 0.0302715003490448, -0.008066217415034771, 0.033298056572675705, 0.010441497899591923, 0.015263528563082218, 0.025035299360752106, -0.011269972659647465, -0.004092368762940168, 0.02011369913816452, -0.06303565204143524, -0.0109602315351367, -0.013375720009207726, 0.023616263642907143, 0.013485589995980263, -0.022232726216316223, 0.015212621539831161, -0.0072889612056314945, -0.003107215743511915, -0.002299379324540496, 0.0689987912774086, -0.06864872574806213, 0.0034773671068251133, -0.000708529376424849, -0.0030210239347070456, -0.04813408479094505, 0.001585435471497476, 0.041753143072128296, 0.01834891550242901, 0.0391073115170002, 0.0077689229510724545, -0.0026466944254934788, 0.0005352297448553145, -0.0337374322116375, 0.02181212604045868, 0.030466431751847267, 0.038225140422582626, -0.012502233497798443, 0.01795079931616783, -0.020627416670322418, 0.009193946607410908, 0.006775313522666693, 0.057024262845516205, -0.012122315354645252, 0.010565605014562607, 0.03217106685042381, -0.02705841138958931, -0.04212351515889168, -0.01536474097520113, 0.03759502246975899, -0.04941194877028465, -0.016497032716870308, -0.008206005208194256, 0.04862535744905472, -0.022905509918928146, 0.004491779953241348, 0.05662500858306885, 0.010686933062970638, -0.02262156270444393, -0.04108043760061264, -0.03577790781855583, -0.0124772097915411, -0.00769662344828248, 0.028693879023194313, 0.001987043535336852, -0.019537361338734627, -0.02003917284309864, 0.05372012034058571, -0.05091475695371628, -0.01714075542986393, -0.01756337098777294, 0.011601458303630352, 0.025492528453469276, -0.023719221353530884, 0.0441860593855381, 0.006462095305323601, 0.04325201362371445, 0.056109074503183365, 0.031074821949005127, 0.024592271074652672, -0.07330326735973358, -0.024851588532328606, 0.05508727207779884, 0.07723108679056168, -0.006796958390623331, -0.039083316922187805, -0.06050697714090347, -0.01935405097901821, 0.06399991363286972, -0.04494724050164223, 0.01861521415412426, 0.058247148990631104, 0.009338845498859882, -0.03125359117984772, -0.025100000202655792, -0.03536979481577873, -0.02502630278468132, -0.02712320350110531, 0.07813423126935959, 0.013018504716455936, -0.042166903614997864, -0.042285699397325516, 0.0017705083591863513, 0.015668563544750214, 0.026384878903627396, 0.011357908137142658, -0.025180933997035027, -0.03280287981033325, 0.0031533807050436735, -0.015132076106965542, -0.07078157365322113, 0.040989771485328674, 0.015246697701513767, -0.022625258192420006, 0.0680576041340828, -0.014091270044445992, -0.01586759276688099, 0.014895171858370304, -0.042881712317466736, -0.01620662957429886, -0.044361554086208344, -0.05452367663383484, 0.03958798572421074, 0.03266051039099693, -0.031035784631967545, 0.04303581640124321, -0.022187991067767143, -0.007100661750882864, 0.015884267166256905, -0.05324223265051842, 0.054717112332582474, -0.05022479221224785, 0.02057468146085739, -0.009174458682537079, 0.0017508050659671426, -0.027118396013975143, 0.03533293679356575, 0.030731113627552986, 0.05247035250067711, 0.008211704902350903, 0.0018885909812524915, 0.0053861262276768684, 0.025566453114151955, -0.008569411933422089, -0.0003309273160994053, 0.008786310441792011, 0.017307208850979805, 0.010513059794902802, 0.003030260093510151, 0.001617907197214663, 0.010501179844141006, -0.011013987474143505, 0.024730131030082703, -0.030282001942396164, -0.0327073410153389, -0.01678571105003357, -0.027137795463204384, 0.035058315843343735, -0.012537621892988682, 0.030424781143665314, -0.009109978564083576, 0.02571716345846653, 0.019955769181251526, -0.05937458202242851, 0.005996847525238991, -0.011776149272918701, -0.015237241983413696, 0.03208647668361664, -0.056811220943927765, 0.004372606985270977, -0.019443253055214882, 0.02130832150578499, -0.05071849003434181, -0.046226274222135544, -0.016866357997059822, -0.007156741805374622, -0.010743075050413609, -0.04442891851067543, 0.005168041214346886, 0.022021757438778877, -0.013438345864415169, 0.008585100062191486, 0.04494727402925491, -0.03141868859529495, 0.01657116413116455, 0.015258591622114182, -0.006804377306252718, 0.08080999553203583, -0.013201961293816566, 0.001598898321390152, 0.0008168615750037134, -0.008506174199283123, -0.007531024515628815, -0.039137788116931915, 0.03380692005157471, -0.0395730696618557, -0.017054565250873566, -0.036988623440265656, 0.03318256512284279, 0.044850025326013565, -0.01663672924041748, 0.008604118600487709, 0.011441582813858986, -0.037738900631666183, -0.003660839982330799, -0.0035592762287706137, -0.026196390390396118, -0.024922559037804604, -0.03211004659533501, -0.01361018605530262, 0.010660716332495213, 0.015027075074613094, -0.04111845791339874, -0.019169457256793976, 0.004668237175792456, 0.0061609456315636635, -0.005702626425772905, 0.03230377659201622, -0.01696092262864113, 0.009675403125584126, -0.02105567418038845, -0.05542827397584915, 0.04499974474310875, 0.003999441862106323, 0.022120214998722076, -0.03176746144890785, 0.03385474160313606, -0.04923068359494209, -0.015854407101869583, -0.049328990280628204, 0.00015357891970779747, 0.04990110546350479, 0.04748225212097168, 0.04334394261240959, 0.023525666445493698, -0.024780530482530594, 0.00943654216825962, -0.02388611063361168, -0.019197678193449974, 0.025110462680459023, -0.017717765644192696, 0.06939317286014557, -0.003946992568671703, -0.04155141860246658, 0.022442609071731567, 0.021833492442965508, 0.046363022178411484, 0.050527576357126236, 0.016837237402796745, 0.003278649877756834, 0.037524014711380005, -0.036624740809202194, -0.04224679619073868, 0.011007498018443584, -0.046366576105356216, -0.012385297566652298, -0.00464246142655611, -0.020161371678113937, 0.05231563374400139, 0.04813767224550247, -0.023183586075901985, -0.024049412459135056, -0.04093661531805992, -0.03742798790335655, -0.03434625640511513, 0.039058513939380646, 0.006947145331650972, 0.012950838543474674, -0.04044627770781517, -0.0007529837894253433, 0.01485062949359417, 0.02448020502924919, -0.007691248785704374, -0.04878508299589157, -0.06983710825443268, -0.02282767929136753, -0.022825591266155243, 0.02892036736011505, -0.02368444763123989, -0.033087149262428284, 0.026042455807328224, -0.03716868534684181, 0.04901636764407158, 0.012473390437662601, -0.0030514674726873636, 0.025911713019013405, 0.008771456778049469, -0.011509602889418602, 0.02309548109769821, 0.006726761814206839, -0.008272740989923477, 0.1165907010436058, 0.07109487801790237, 0.04807116836309433, -0.050726089626550674, 0.014855178073048592, 0.01894976757466793, -0.006843527778983116, -0.02208813838660717, 0.042833536863327026, 0.007099698297679424, -0.0032350700348615646, -0.021796103566884995, 0.015659378841519356, 0.022254275158047676, -0.03338977321982384, -0.02300398424267769, -0.0498076006770134, -0.0082861864939332, 0.03993641585111618, 0.007732681464403868, -0.0050214314833283424, -0.0156403835862875, -0.015989867970347404, 0.00047065987018868327, -0.015955744311213493, -0.03496243432164192, -0.007342706900089979, 0.0149191590026021, -0.008347314782440662, -0.04643150418996811, -0.007126733660697937, -0.007615047972649336, -0.00791935808956623, -0.01126180775463581, 0.02671550028026104, 0.025446182116866112, 0.006724772974848747, -0.0023941383697092533, -0.005561200901865959, 0.03475221246480942, 0.01216166839003563, -0.023453285917639732, -0.01877482794225216, 0.006077961530536413, -0.037091463804244995, -0.0435999296605587, -0.03944455832242966, 0.06321228295564651, 0.001063726027496159, 0.007952800951898098, 0.03125190734863281, -0.024410778656601906, -0.0056176818907260895, -0.07310696691274643, -0.022264767438173294, 0.04399855062365532, 0.02153356932103634, 0.028293168172240257, -0.04730412736535072, -0.010233900509774685, 0.008309083990752697, -0.02211989089846611, 0.030736630782485008, 0.010035084560513496, 0.024043595418334007, -0.002758049638941884, -0.011643905192613602, 0.04863393306732178, 0.0043431734666228294, 0.01945241168141365, -0.02517884410917759, 0.0022273827344179153, 0.008918161503970623, -0.054755084216594696, -0.00019692110072355717, -0.02484142780303955, 0.03413044661283493, -0.019795728847384453, -0.0425952672958374, 0.016416246071457863, -0.07213990390300751, -0.015417447313666344, -0.029030170291662216, -0.0018474654061719775, -0.033200472593307495, 0.032376375049352646, 0.037955090403556824, 0.003987123258411884, 0.04539061710238457, 0.02419610507786274, -0.01704428158700466, 0.05671752616763115, 0.021428149193525314, -0.011960879899561405, -0.002089960500597954, -0.008067562244832516, -0.039105646312236786, 0.006516527850180864, -0.000883106142282486, 0.03555695340037346, 0.025636635720729828, -0.012836931273341179, 0.0009207333787344396, 0.037768010050058365, -0.008168146014213562, -0.010402125306427479, -0.006396876648068428, -0.039901889860630035, 0.010260363109409809, 0.00042290473356842995, 0.005680909845978022, -0.050052449107170105, -0.03397836163640022, -0.043802410364151, -0.009244962595403194, 0.00008365867688553408, 0.009286352433264256, -0.040912747383117676, -0.00007945190009195358, 0.0351966917514801, 0.041720498353242874, -0.002682166174054146, -0.01593913324177265, -0.030503714457154274, 0.018562667071819305, -0.022557372227311134, -0.019583866000175476, -0.0208946131169796, 0.04076850786805153, -0.013953320682048798, 0.0027991507668048143, 0.04766986519098282, -0.0020635868422687054, 0.020063452422618866, -0.03333388641476631, 0.03095441870391369, 0.003728939453139901, 0.010145546868443489, -0.021928420290350914, -0.01657000742852688, 0.016219578683376312, -0.03169802203774452, -0.049891840666532516, 0.008389202877879143, 0.00028854949050582945, 0.02567336894571781, 0.012686858884990215, 0.0029004826210439205, -0.01637542061507702, 0.03849349543452263, -0.029128404334187508, -0.0184464268386364, 0.019357120618224144, 0.01393223274499178, -0.015567825175821781, 0.03622996062040329, 0.029844751581549644, 0.0013904321240261197, -0.026452364400029182, -0.007139954715967178, 0.0124982800334692, 0.022938629612326622, -0.03082934208214283, 0.009004781022667885, -0.06031827628612518, 0.001796763390302658, 0.010043219663202763, 0.006386266555637121, 0.01800801418721676, 0.032497406005859375, -0.028020083904266357, 0.01850896142423153, 0.002574435668066144, 0.027110042050480843, -0.07765080034732819, 0.0030324857216328382, -0.007647610269486904, 0.015699442476034164, 0.051036857068538666, -0.08255746215581894, 0.03334331139922142, 0.02842170000076294, -0.05200662463903427, 0.006535349879413843, 0.002514652442187071, 0.005706599447876215, -0.041600361466407776, 0.01707686297595501, -0.016216862946748734, 0.023800620809197426, 0.00811727810651064, 0.02290954813361168, 0.018560679629445076, 0.01476271077990532, 0.006936864461749792, -0.009445060975849628, -0.029595300555229187, 0.054867491126060486, -0.02486911602318287, -0.005369100254029036, 0.05569174140691757, -0.05122862011194229, -0.053428277373313904, 0.029417913407087326, -0.012447647750377655, -0.003917563706636429, 0.045649204403162, 0.03939000517129898, 0.04358840733766556, 0.0028188556898385286, 0.06863004714250565, -0.012833526358008385, 0.01817386783659458, -0.007902760989964008, 0.004926146008074284, 0.006097677629441023, 0.0058414144441485405, 0.015906155109405518, 0.024605801329016685, -0.019600937142968178, -0.0007247537723742425, -0.011892279610037804, -0.004397364798933268, 0.013533172197639942, -0.023181498050689697, -0.001535702613182366, 0.00934505369514227, -0.02591882459819317, 0.03951789811253548, -0.038595814257860184, -0.008913987316191196, 0.02175646647810936, 0.007888087071478367, 0.01036958396434784, 0.04368426278233528, 0.0026642868760973215, -0.06861171126365662, -0.017281068488955498, 0.0009919869480654597, -0.02535204589366913, -0.014757833443582058, 0.023389995098114014, 0.02897622063755989, -0.015228156000375748, -0.014663243666291237, -0.05717719718813896, -0.045817989856004715, 0.04151206091046333, -0.027719363570213318, 0.07256418466567993, 0.009302268736064434, -0.037544019520282745, -0.0051315962336957455, -0.09337878227233887, 0.05701290816068649, -0.032665859907865524, -0.03753437474370003, -0.002827177755534649, 0.015171508304774761, -0.021661894395947456, 0.00039839581586420536, 0.045985378324985504, 0.00005682184928446077, 0.019814347848296165, -0.008395282551646233, -0.04569704458117485, 0.012573734857141972, -0.030595773831009865, 0.010197880677878857, -0.014835010282695293, 0.006238817702978849, 0.01185411587357521, -0.0013294542441144586, 0.014697737991809845, 0.011875366792082787, 0.011243094690144062, -0.006692554801702499, 0.012771264649927616, 0.01738310046494007, 0.026870928704738617, 0.050764940679073334, -0.010992429219186306, 0.015681855380535126, 0.049113210290670395, -0.015822824090719223, 0.01347785908728838, 0.027775853872299194, 0.033299803733825684, -0.029107805341482162, 0.025745246559381485, -0.008928265422582626, -0.01111498475074768, 0.025915496051311493, 0.06046634912490845, 0.02700471691787243, -0.0591970719397068, 0.01304034236818552, 0.02415793016552925, -0.035212382674217224, 0.005057904869318008, 0.04408479109406471, -0.00013690513151232153, 0.00943740177899599, -0.0076531837694346905, 0.03344104439020157, 0.03447150066494942, 0.020380407571792603, -0.0019510145066305995, 0.007194537669420242, 0.017220521345734596, -0.025220254436135292, 0.048752836883068085, 0.01875447668135166, -0.023238714784383774, 0.04333188384771347, -0.03488829359412193, 0.060465674847364426, -0.07464239746332169, -0.02474243752658367, 0.02220267988741398, 0.03470313176512718, 0.02047630213201046, -0.017660511657595634, -0.022443203255534172, 0.06499658524990082, -0.008192352950572968, -0.015154344961047173, -0.013572384603321552, -0.05648709461092949, 0.001901279087178409, 0.026022443547844887, 0.014798689633607864, 0.06920694559812546, 0.013812348246574402, 0.02671768330037594, 0.014407198876142502, -0.009412667714059353, 0.02471092715859413, -0.027015015482902527, -0.003721218090504408, -0.012033537030220032, -0.0011734560830518603, 0.015896299853920937, -0.01067986711859703, -0.002623393665999174, -0.018406016752123833, 0.01118064671754837, 0.022959725931286812, 0.029450060799717903, 0.0010843586642295122, -0.008751602843403816, 0.03647761791944504, 0.01611761376261711, -0.03910226747393608, 0.001945889089256525, -0.05081932246685028, 0.012054141610860825, 0.017934320494532585, -0.006314663216471672 ]
<p>I am a little bit confused about the machine learning outcomes on my dataset. I would be grateful if anyone can enlighten me on this:</p> <p>When features are statistically different between two groups, shouldn't the machine learning able to predict the right class with a reasonable accuracy? The data consists of 9 features where 8 of them were significantly different between the groups (two tailed independent ttest). Total observations were 71 (30 and 41). However, the machine learning were only able to produce around 65% classification accuracy (10 fold cross validation). I have used SVM with RBF kernel, kNN, Random Forest, and Naive Bayes. My question is, is it normal? Is it possible to get higher classification accuracy when the features were not significantly different between the groups? Thanks.</p>
36,705
[ -0.04133457690477371, -0.019052907824516296, -0.027295392006635666, -0.014005305245518684, 0.03633684292435646, -0.006100578233599663, -0.036324478685855865, -0.0033705350942909718, 0.03192683309316635, -0.025208983570337296, 0.028167035430669785, -0.0023927611764520407, 0.04168710112571716, 0.021092969924211502, 0.011147869750857353, -0.0033416617661714554, -0.006927323527634144, -0.025157757103443146, 0.0135825639590621, 0.017860539257526398, -0.025007814168930054, 0.04371725767850876, 0.014734838157892227, -0.010321117006242275, -0.036915507167577744, 0.0485859215259552, 0.014750838279724121, -0.013550478965044022, 0.025465283542871475, 0.0033025802113115788, -0.014059429056942463, -0.005303184501826763, 0.009661870077252388, 0.032720308750867844, 0.022734344005584717, -0.008308134973049164, -0.03948317840695381, -0.023035624995827675, -0.027202969416975975, 0.037031952291727066, -0.0137544060125947, -0.011801529675722122, -0.03978808969259262, 0.056860849261283875, -0.03599940612912178, 0.014226489700376987, -0.005183960776776075, -0.020591018721461296, 0.026186184957623482, -0.042460136115550995, 0.0838366374373436, 0.01685398630797863, 0.0684620589017868, 0.049142077565193176, -0.019638385623693466, -0.009553195908665657, 0.036519091576337814, 0.07369183003902435, -0.025731829926371574, -0.03251670300960541, -0.015008270740509033, -0.04720868170261383, 0.003085826290771365, 0.016727259382605553, -0.04116135835647583, 0.05015668272972107, -0.0019068238325417042, -0.017948657274246216, 0.02261066623032093, 0.014543060213327408, 0.02682853490114212, 0.03501688688993454, 0.04642387107014656, -0.002190752886235714, 0.04176042601466179, -0.04165856912732124, 0.011778580956161022, 0.0477883405983448, 0.021548068150877953, 0.023639047518372536, 0.03308309242129326, 0.005882113240659237, -0.009823082014918327, 0.047972433269023895, 0.04067971557378769, -0.025836080312728882, 0.03545956686139107, -0.008942569606006145, 0.006740723270922899, 0.034286271780729294, -0.01102067343890667, 0.025610221549868584, 0.058002304285764694, 0.006475622765719891, -0.05649568513035774, 0.03787081316113472, 0.0028678246308118105, 0.020236054435372353, 0.038907572627067566, -0.019317829981446266, 0.031536173075437546, -0.01838826946914196, 0.024739837273955345, 0.05578777939081192, -0.026785364374518394, -0.022230399772524834, -0.07169220596551895, -0.02895614132285118, -0.02178676426410675, 0.023899996653199196, 0.006514756008982658, -0.01583775132894516, 0.016766289249062538, -0.03778313100337982, 0.033151477575302124, -0.005862085148692131, -0.03617306053638458, -0.027780037373304367, 0.03990530967712402, 0.060618095099925995, 0.018763741478323936, -0.044501591473817825, 0.030543480068445206, -0.01320709753781557, 0.006095764692872763, 0.01988399215042591, 0.04307471588253975, -0.024878909811377525, -0.039133135229349136, 0.037852175533771515, -0.01702238619327545, -0.02271535061299801, 0.020120039582252502, -0.021827375516295433, -0.004586800001561642, -0.005882090888917446, -0.09306071698665619, -0.07435569167137146, 0.019143808633089066, -0.008995534852147102, 0.021067844703793526, -0.052051711827516556, -0.016352087259292603, 0.020142700523138046, 0.04938369244337082, -0.009324204176664352, 0.06959009915590286, 0.025535855442285538, 0.03070518933236599, -0.012879332527518272, -0.02682003378868103, 0.012653974816203117, -0.03391469642519951, 0.0009119160240516067, -0.035074472427368164, -0.08686471730470657, -0.007735677063465118, -0.006477308459579945, -0.005214201286435127, -0.010020498186349869, -0.006005025003105402, -0.022855244576931, 0.004999098833650351, 0.0030617613811045885, 0.034095119684934616, 0.008859488181769848, 0.03621292859315872, 0.018907710909843445, 0.03622417524456978, 0.028983240947127342, -0.0231305044144392, -0.00036358993384055793, 0.04049200937151909, 0.058551013469696045, 0.002819705056026578, -0.008111394941806793, 0.017414459958672523, -0.037585433572530746, 0.04027557745575905, -0.009913373738527298, -0.03654731065034866, -0.023409031331539154, -0.03011282905936241, 0.005241010803729296, -0.008390234783291817, 0.0363042950630188, -0.008736460469663143, -0.022968076169490814, 0.05367051810026169, -0.021442729979753494, -0.04657522216439247, -0.04290507361292839, 0.0019416926661506295, -0.050182607024908066, -0.02844903990626335, -0.004249942488968372, 0.028860200196504593, 0.023495424538850784, -0.044615764170885086, -0.0029118862003087997, -0.029024232178926468, -0.001632727449759841, 0.008350221440196037, -0.013405713252723217, 0.0157362949103117, 0.039659883826971054, -0.016344059258699417, -0.02748030610382557, 0.030490152537822723, -0.04247640445828438, -0.0750594288110733, 0.03331098333001137, -0.013115176931023598, -0.004988555330783129, 0.0009051805245690048, -0.018398093059659004, 0.01521086972206831, 0.011739473789930344, -0.03674064576625824, 0.04721749573945999, -0.051444754004478455, 0.07200991362333298, 0.01785401999950409, -0.0132514089345932, -0.013254474848508835, 0.0007020729826763272, 0.005569394212216139, -0.00643370533362031, -0.03495768830180168, -0.02113514579832554, -0.06440524011850357, -0.0386078879237175, 0.04443269595503807, 0.02968515269458294, -0.016674146056175232, 0.03562000021338463, 0.03188273683190346, 0.033129166811704636, 0.02942819893360138, 0.0003513391420710832, 0.002042016014456749, -0.01660025492310524, 0.04952459782361984, 0.03732316941022873, -0.008672022260725498, 0.0005823739338666201, 0.036751460283994675, 0.02625063993036747, 0.054849572479724884, 0.010123437270522118, -0.021313456818461418, 0.05660909041762352, -0.014080127701163292, -0.010399769991636276, -0.008052370510995388, -0.006456767208874226, 0.020016761496663094, -0.006560897454619408, 0.011853654868900776, 0.03779062628746033, 0.031509879976511, 0.0163926649838686, -0.01856978051364422, -0.009028579108417034, 0.03937928006052971, 0.03990590572357178, -0.0071871476247906685, -0.004137908108532429, 0.013750926591455936, -0.02877769246697426, 0.021287651732563972, 0.0022682617418468, -0.020993974059820175, -0.014483393169939518, 0.06274506449699402, 0.04642593860626221, -0.008856321685016155, 0.052602317184209824, -0.011806750670075417, -0.015354238450527191, 0.01963808760046959, -0.01730826124548912, 0.04741331934928894, -0.016514018177986145, -0.07446566969156265, 0.00602378137409687, -0.019105011597275734, -0.01785358227789402, 0.03330639749765396, -0.0024449778720736504, -0.023608004674315453, 0.011349964886903763, -0.01577652245759964, -0.057533349841833115, -0.014205739833414555, -0.05994119867682457, 0.03114115260541439, 0.009078974835574627, -0.025405632331967354, 0.0034228910226374865, -0.01781110092997551, -0.0017432388849556446, 0.04906927049160004, -0.01815062388777733, -0.024085428565740585, -0.006136622279882431, 0.020536359399557114, 0.024406034499406815, 0.006244671996682882, 0.003838867414742708, 0.04393722862005234, -0.023630227893590927, -0.031324077397584915, -0.061995137482881546, -0.06716056168079376, 0.030531348660588264, -0.03269124776124954, 0.02156084030866623, 0.003186208428815007, -0.007371861021965742, 0.0675390288233757, 0.04875865578651428, -0.03178870305418968, -0.01852928288280964, 0.010988599620759487, -0.07119845598936081, 0.010897914879024029, 0.021309060975909233, 0.027232995256781578, 0.03794332221150398, 0.03408830612897873, 0.0004166121070738882, 0.030734356492757797, 0.07793434709310532, -0.05632339045405388, -0.04038778692483902, 0.059108130633831024, 0.029759110882878304, -0.010154735296964645, 0.029668278992176056, 0.01920848898589611, -0.02724350243806839, 0.003349707927554846, 0.04108215123414993, 0.011267469264566898, 0.013563585467636585, -0.04775533825159073, 0.022717958316206932, -0.00958329252898693, 0.05090958625078201, -0.06351614743471146, -0.0011744892690330744, -0.0041497936472296715, -0.027715301141142845, -0.001738978666253388, 0.008994405157864094, 0.040634822100400925, -0.030169948935508728, -0.002435981063172221, 0.08128833770751953, 0.029509127140045166, 0.022517554461956024, -0.031802594661712646, -0.016690103337168694, -0.015165434218943119, 0.03134922683238983, -0.009274783544242382, -0.022386012598872185, 0.023747438564896584, 0.03567010164260864, 0.021667197346687317, 0.009569539688527584, -0.06984132528305054, 0.028336208313703537, -0.04156823456287384, 0.013634389266371727, -0.017415203154087067, 0.045329559594392776, 0.0103645920753479, 0.03672671690583229, 0.019037356600165367, -0.022954868152737617, 0.02283153496682644, -0.01325027272105217, -0.033066462725400925, 0.01416008360683918, -0.004164671991020441, -0.016888635233044624, 0.0016813232796266675, -0.06656988710165024, 0.02320593222975731, -0.005840492434799671, 0.02920045517385006, 0.00603611720725894, 0.03412407636642456, -0.05703144147992134, -0.020460641011595726, -0.04194987192749977, -0.022947752848267555, -0.002058357698842883, 0.014706064946949482, -0.01874493807554245, 0.021115608513355255, 0.05710965767502785, 0.04734056442975998, -0.018078649416565895, -0.002375266281887889, -0.04209551587700844, 0.01085551269352436, -0.01867419295012951, 0.04456304758787155, 0.045354776084423065, 0.04095769301056862, -0.051221441477537155, 0.011492835357785225, -0.00516766682267189, 0.06260725855827332, 0.047747399657964706, 0.006044262088835239, -0.033514462411403656, -0.051768530160188675, -0.047493625432252884, 0.022992059588432312, 0.01953938789665699, 0.014226469211280346, 0.012470549903810024, 0.05289096385240555, 0.028542377054691315, -0.09282924979925156, -0.02141851745545864, 0.03906149044632912, 0.004726317711174488, -0.005500397644937038, -0.04685967415571213, -0.011409229598939419, -0.008866879157721996, -0.021733270958065987, 0.02880147658288479, -0.011920996010303497, -0.038347940891981125, -0.01910308003425598, 0.05317160114645958, -0.039301853626966476, -0.0529816560447216, -0.0137655483558774, 0.010838898830115795, 0.018940487876534462, 0.022250812500715256, -0.023103607818484306, -0.0007520522340200841, 0.03563828021287918, 0.04397978261113167, 0.023204276338219643, 0.009658953174948692, -0.07817886024713516, 0.014726811088621616, 0.03609738498926163, 0.032765135169029236, -0.05021385848522186, -0.02576877735555172, -0.03941764682531357, 0.015148145146667957, 0.02411682903766632, -0.019404958933591843, 0.02808712050318718, 0.01825520023703575, -0.02379949949681759, -0.024769257754087448, 0.0054711587727069855, -0.038662973791360855, 0.012426969595253468, -0.03644822537899017, 0.04049937427043915, -0.030891479924321175, -0.05282128229737282, -0.02233896590769291, -0.0028306422755122185, 0.05157413333654404, 0.007361624389886856, -0.019900934770703316, -0.024226069450378418, -0.02858605608344078, 0.01918528601527214, 0.009489664807915688, -0.047873616218566895, -0.009026017040014267, -0.003522886661812663, -0.01230743806809187, 0.03388698771595955, 0.0024490486830472946, -0.04178405925631523, 0.021876653656363487, 0.015418780036270618, -0.005654450505971909, -0.038544513285160065, -0.020473072305321693, -0.005788867827504873, 0.04230787605047226, 0.015206844545900822, 0.052627820521593094, 0.027741583064198494, 0.03329452499747276, -0.001513132592663169, -0.05376318469643593, 0.0527515634894371, -0.019307734444737434, -0.02661476843059063, -0.0016231249319389462, -0.04294658824801445, -0.00664845434948802, 0.033434174954891205, 0.0224801916629076, 0.04390166699886322, -0.041886135935783386, -0.0024530673399567604, 0.01784360408782959, 0.02588239125907421, -0.010324017144739628, -0.001995688769966364, -0.026917632669210434, 0.011163828894495964, -0.03342192620038986, 0.02816460095345974, 0.003716603387147188, -0.009966190904378891, -0.010669589042663574, 0.03277665004134178, -0.04848023131489754, 0.009918889962136745, -0.038537800312042236, -0.012635665014386177, -0.0187520794570446, -0.022203806787729263, 0.03445377200841904, 0.021111762151122093, 0.03637855499982834, -0.013823616318404675, -0.02633284404873848, -0.031076690182089806, -0.01047621201723814, 0.007984932512044907, 0.06207187473773956, -0.03233509883284569, 0.04912169277667999, 0.007740589790046215, -0.025562899187207222, -0.08626805245876312, -0.03584739565849304, -0.0040692551992833614, 0.009214296005666256, -0.03604315593838692, -0.028147989884018898, 0.01686931774020195, -0.0031585069373250008, -0.027339262887835503, 0.0003889001382049173, 0.056272149085998535, 0.011565669439733028, -0.02023088000714779, 0.0036078207194805145, -0.029949506744742393, 0.09421597421169281, -0.007422308903187513, 0.014927291311323643, -0.0004791279789060354, 0.01235236693173647, -0.015901736915111542, 0.01608208753168583, 0.02778744325041771, -0.03289242461323738, -0.007831411436200142, -0.05081886798143387, 0.03927081078290939, 0.04641938582062721, -0.027753107249736786, 0.003711674828082323, 0.018809963017702103, 0.006625260226428509, 0.017955854535102844, -0.013607235625386238, 0.011963533237576485, 0.015857867896556854, -0.038150712847709656, -0.017379004508256912, 0.006253655534237623, 0.0021030663046985865, -0.028071388602256775, 0.026057181879878044, -0.013061027973890305, -0.014509459026157856, 0.012165513820946217, 0.08295828849077225, -0.0005164481117390096, 0.02080242894589901, -0.006888435687869787, -0.0550251342356205, 0.038880668580532074, 0.0056413221172988415, -0.001998578431084752, -0.011552387848496437, 0.0415201336145401, -0.04153197631239891, -0.001445939764380455, -0.029570501297712326, -0.002674599876627326, 0.06148584932088852, 0.004167370032519102, 0.046864964067935944, 0.07732531428337097, 0.034090522676706314, -0.019171645864844322, -0.056037575006484985, -0.009074508212506771, 0.009160640649497509, 0.018393564969301224, 0.033104512840509415, 0.0036049666814506054, 0.0009285254636779428, 0.038212500512599945, 0.018788371235132217, 0.031854644417762756, 0.04377339780330658, 0.020929088816046715, 0.016144413501024246, 0.027990613132715225, 0.010694699361920357, -0.06256319582462311, 0.01948988437652588, -0.02790156751871109, 0.0012534982524812222, -0.03567931428551674, 0.028209298849105835, 0.046804532408714294, 0.045183658599853516, 0.00934117566794157, -0.03127947077155113, -0.02564697526395321, -0.031816110014915466, 0.00839692447334528, 0.02333720028400421, 0.013632627204060555, 0.04106676205992699, 0.010540838353335857, 0.014245362021028996, 0.02330680750310421, 0.02165761962532997, -0.02804710902273655, -0.09705911576747894, -0.04681381210684776, -0.04182588309049606, -0.04522324725985527, 0.018290136009454727, 0.00631098635494709, -0.056219447404146194, 0.026076752692461014, -0.04717905819416046, 0.04130477085709572, -0.022708633914589882, 0.0007651938358321786, -0.029768217355012894, 0.05166572704911232, 0.012316792272031307, 0.04709665849804878, 0.03140725567936897, 0.002963018137961626, 0.10012006014585495, 0.057541586458683014, 0.02520183101296425, -0.03671899437904358, 0.0014936266234144568, -0.018993068486452103, -0.04208570718765259, -0.039765872061252594, 0.04088238254189491, 0.013959618285298347, -0.010080736130475998, 0.03248305991292, 0.026946965605020523, 0.04384055361151695, -0.011227604933083057, 0.06352180242538452, -0.011003394611179829, 0.002467484213411808, 0.025269577279686928, 0.005099076312035322, 0.035941231995821, -0.042033128440380096, -0.033839188516139984, 0.002437385031953454, -0.03348570689558983, -0.005811937153339386, 0.0010410589165985584, 0.011346346698701382, 0.025828851386904716, 0.011953135021030903, -0.00783888716250658, -0.009278795681893826, -0.015939921140670776, 0.018522877246141434, -0.049084875732660294, -0.00029839377384632826, 0.008700672537088394, -0.01548195444047451, 0.016151105985045433, 0.018061159178614616, 0.002908815862610936, -0.03207424655556679, 0.01721125841140747, -0.0072597311809659, -0.04718742147088051, -0.035729072988033295, -0.05677753686904907, 0.06747783720493317, -0.012437010183930397, 0.0014245961792767048, -0.00028185747214592993, 0.02168935537338257, -0.018920812755823135, -0.06282977014780045, -0.02488214708864689, -0.014911510050296783, -0.0018048668280243874, -0.021188437938690186, -0.019268490374088287, -0.0421120822429657, 0.03492650017142296, -0.007406961638480425, 0.019523996859788895, -0.01856858655810356, -0.013000146485865116, -0.02361089177429676, -0.009104502387344837, 0.024624571204185486, -0.00835002213716507, -0.002738008741289377, -0.0031304480507969856, -0.014631083235144615, -0.006565261632204056, -0.00623765354976058, 0.0025502140633761883, 0.02107394114136696, -0.0073929233476519585, -0.008034776896238327, -0.032697517424821854, -0.01817607507109642, -0.034804441034793854, -0.006408855319023132, -0.03090015798807144, 0.008464802987873554, -0.02051471918821335, -0.01296384446322918, -0.011238990351557732, 0.006591187324374914, 0.023863187059760094, 0.03325599059462547, 0.016488073393702507, 0.012016570195555687, -0.010909553617238998, -0.049408841878175735, -0.0339830219745636, -0.012585884891450405, -0.04527396708726883, 0.0059343003667891026, 0.01457242202013731, 0.04682227969169617, 0.01224068645387888, 0.0009514075354672968, 0.0004182774864602834, 0.023004354909062386, 0.006309630814939737, 0.020408237352967262, -0.03254707157611847, -0.018227020278573036, -0.005734337493777275, -0.022084005177021027, -0.0181376151740551, -0.029802488163113594, -0.03298762068152428, -0.027464943006634712, -0.027610033750534058, 0.03928422927856445, -0.013916617259383202, -0.03863408789038658, -0.007968328893184662, -0.0016150870360434055, 0.03201466426253319, -0.01689852774143219, 0.013126508332788944, -0.04852352291345596, -0.009191293269395828, -0.006498119793832302, -0.026914384216070175, -0.017481885850429535, 0.011319112963974476, -0.0026183577720075846, -0.005887469742447138, 0.04691290855407715, 0.010814602486789227, 0.01789792627096176, -0.0014232855755835772, 0.005399839952588081, -0.02723998762667179, 0.06272408366203308, -0.044437870383262634, -0.010594469495117664, 0.05406349524855614, -0.033549439162015915, -0.044274598360061646, 0.04111117497086525, -0.03583863750100136, 0.03406522795557976, 0.030313165858387947, 0.00932665728032589, 0.011433815583586693, 0.08035235852003098, -0.018145088106393814, -0.004557825159281492, 0.008297012187540531, 0.01812157593667507, -0.003175675170496106, 0.028812602162361145, 0.014414411969482899, 0.0011223477777093649, -0.023082474246621132, 0.005710481200367212, 0.04429353401064873, 0.04339019954204559, -0.036464620381593704, -0.0075655425898730755, -0.017719002440571785, 0.025639275088906288, 0.024791352450847626, 0.013861943036317825, 0.044125355780124664, 0.026260383427143097, -0.015570798888802528, 0.026731587946414948, -0.004751106724143028, 0.02903137356042862, -0.05726656690239906, -0.019147692248225212, 0.03368900343775749, 0.003905808087438345, 0.02246248535811901, -0.046589676290750504, -0.005073892883956432, 0.028535572811961174, -0.034267608076334, 0.01667947694659233, -0.018346019089221954, -0.013890727423131466, -0.04836183786392212, 0.028659513220191002, -0.024478351697325706, -0.0015827711904421449, 0.04808858036994934, 0.02358950674533844, 0.04521533101797104, 0.024999456480145454, -0.02417057938873768, -0.02554434910416603, -0.04181506112217903, 0.0323585607111454, 0.024274917319417, -0.04757755622267723, 0.010186598636209965, -0.041343118995428085, -0.0772276297211647, 0.02019505575299263, -0.0014306111261248589, 0.0025545505341142416, 0.0415959395468235, 0.012808599509298801, 0.016222549602389336, 0.01894691213965416, 0.05016602575778961, -0.04742883890867233, -0.010579779744148254, 0.019756009802222252, 0.014462201856076717, 0.011946916580200195, -0.011289559304714203, 0.008631073869764805, -0.007662066258490086, -0.03630594536662102, -0.03368223085999489, 0.026546334847807884, -0.010398752987384796, -0.057402852922677994, -0.020310984924435616, 0.02502848580479622, 0.02238192968070507, -0.04254521057009697, 0.02695622481405735, -0.0497601255774498, -0.0074080778285861015, 0.04678957909345627, 0.03521319478750229, -0.005406544543802738, -0.0012080649612471461, -0.030056148767471313, -0.044029392302036285, -0.011189306154847145, -0.00748256454244256, 0.00319140637293458, -0.04526006430387497, 0.025246499106287956, 0.009693232364952564, -0.016777124255895615, -0.00814383290708065, -0.021183665841817856, -0.032439544796943665, 0.04620729386806488, -0.010439559817314148, 0.04866022616624832, 0.018939988687634468, -0.025860056281089783, -0.017026223242282867, -0.09083836525678635, 0.06294336169958115, -0.01735031232237816, -0.028019370511174202, -0.02563917078077793, 0.01694871298968792, -0.056807734072208405, -0.013691640459001064, 0.03858551010489464, 0.028670508414506912, 0.026536844670772552, -0.0013345082988962531, -0.0092794643715024, 0.004681068006902933, -0.04654206335544586, 0.04606594145298004, 0.002221890492364764, -0.02884850837290287, -0.007650225423276424, 0.0020140346605330706, 0.011420351453125477, 0.018381157889962196, 0.005196976941078901, -0.05792882665991783, 0.021329736337065697, 0.013796958141028881, 0.010556457564234734, 0.03975611552596092, -0.028932951390743256, 0.00041428572149015963, 0.052695512771606445, 0.023026376962661743, -0.0027085179463028908, 0.018078897148370743, 0.003295114729553461, -0.045936089009046555, 0.030784275382757187, 0.004186722915619612, -0.013529989868402481, -0.030667277052998543, 0.046813394874334335, 0.00006459092401200905, -0.06490276008844376, 0.0022689485922455788, 0.042056940495967865, -0.011084303259849548, 0.012991516850888729, 0.04121718183159828, 0.020671796053647995, 0.011038539931178093, -0.03166380152106285, 0.023691492155194283, 0.0023550130426883698, -0.03374459594488144, 0.013107994571328163, 0.0047247447073459625, 0.03610405698418617, 0.0019910945557057858, 0.021423788741230965, -0.004833454266190529, -0.028959613293409348, 0.0016529739368706942, 0.003707833355292678, 0.06031657010316849, -0.023488614708185196, -0.008204253390431404, -0.014065808616578579, -0.004922992084175348, 0.020232951268553734, 0.009207437746226788, -0.014544329605996609, 0.05740853026509285, -0.025203954428434372, -0.016968989744782448, -0.03931162506341934, -0.0219965111464262, -0.009792964905500412, 0.009628107771277428, 0.002142762066796422, 0.0394708625972271, 0.03444569185376167, 0.006127992644906044, 0.00013470921840053052, 0.01596469059586525, 0.043605051934719086, -0.0012540954630821943, 0.0150389913469553, -0.05232935771346092, -0.02349786087870598, 0.0028293472714722157, 0.013429309241473675, -0.015270018018782139, -0.03010159730911255, 0.00997364241629839, 0.061257254332304, 0.06531680375337601, -0.01652609184384346, -0.04572885110974312, 0.0035280564334243536, 0.055753275752067566, -0.07435836642980576, -0.0012986806686967611, -0.04977882653474808, 0.009973789565265179, 0.009690661914646626, -0.06205935776233673 ]
<p>Suppose I have a big online company, and many of my customers churned (i.e. they were paying, and then stopped). My goal is to understand why each of them churned.</p> <p>First I identify the complete set of reasons for churning, $H_1,\ldots,H_n$. E.g. "the website is confusing", "the customer lost interest", etc. Then by observation I identify a set of customer behaviors which are correlated with the churn rate, $O_1,\ldots,O_m$. Each of them is directly measurable, e.g. the number of days he logged in, or the amount of time he spent at my website the day he signed up. Assume that computing $\Pr[O_j=\cdot]$ is easy, and that all of my customers are mutually independent.</p> <p>I know that each $H_i$ is related to a subset of the $O_j$'s. E.g. if a churned customer logged in $d$ days, then the probability that he lost interest is $f(d)$, with $f$ a decreasing function. (One of my problems is accurately computing this function $f$.)</p> <p>My goal is to compute, for each churned customer, and for each $i$, the probability that he churned because of $H_i$, i.e. $$ \Pr[H_i] = \sum_j \Pr[H_i\ |\ O_j=x_j] \Pr[O_j=x_j] $$ where $x_j$ is the value of $O_j$ for the given customer.</p> <p>Now, suppose I send a survey to all churned customers, asking for their reasons, but certainly only a few of them answer it. I want then to update all the functions $f_{ij}(\cdot) = \Pr[H_i\ |\ O_j=\cdot]$ based on the new evidence, so that I can compute more accurately $\Pr[H_i]$ for all the churned customers which haven't answered the survey.</p> <p>My question is how can I do this exactly? and how can I get "good" estimates for the original $f_{ij}$'s? Is my approach correct?</p> <p>EDIT: Now I realize that the formula I gave for $\Pr[H_i]$ is obviously wrong. The $O_j$'s don't form a partition. I think I should compute $\Pr[H_i\ |\ (O_1,\ldots,O_m)=(x_1,\ldots,x_m)]$ directly, since the $O_j$'s are not even pairwise independent.</p>
74,063
[ -0.043011583387851715, -0.0032308364752680063, 0.04495292901992798, -0.028392048552632332, 0.026406344026327133, 0.0027215711306780577, 0.0007058146875351667, 0.012282881885766983, -0.004832987207919359, -0.036670587956905365, -0.008627544157207012, 0.02534404769539833, 0.041031595319509506, 0.05017469450831413, 0.0004771233652718365, 0.021729789674282074, -0.059507809579372406, 0.039852116256952286, 0.00039080437272787094, -0.003688689786940813, 0.029819587245583534, 0.03376105800271034, 0.013891765847802162, -0.07001430541276932, -0.0527464896440506, 0.0073639932088553905, -0.014504056423902512, -0.05297977104783058, -0.013602671213448048, 0.08773928880691528, -0.031333595514297485, -0.031401220709085464, 0.0013432312989607453, 0.04834834486246109, 0.017663415521383286, 0.03973491117358208, -0.03562406823039055, 0.016833605244755745, -0.010003364644944668, -0.005747584626078606, -0.03998561576008797, 0.006979902740567923, -0.006830907892435789, 0.027945304289460182, 0.002371340524405241, -0.010853171348571777, -0.024927901104092598, -0.011693223379552364, 0.009455841965973377, -0.048737432807683945, 0.06931845098733902, -0.03063715435564518, -0.02609010972082615, -0.023974820971488953, -0.015483667142689228, -0.0301261767745018, 0.0012315703788772225, 0.06491564214229584, 0.017217766493558884, -0.05492626503109932, -0.015168869867920876, -0.024982191622257233, 0.01382835116237402, -0.05610885098576546, -0.02737104892730713, 0.08199192583560944, 0.030529681593179703, -0.009466106072068214, 0.019827289506793022, -0.02790403924882412, -0.005387645214796066, -0.0030468683689832687, -0.009750914759933949, 0.007746140006929636, 0.02673904038965702, -0.02582400105893612, -0.018065139651298523, 0.006459102500230074, 0.03582323342561722, 0.009865906089544296, -0.0005619738367386162, -0.018676917999982834, 0.004755071830004454, 0.0521252304315567, 0.01611580140888691, -0.018599733710289, 0.08145935088396072, -0.02344338409602642, 0.0424920916557312, 0.018327130004763603, -0.001118268584832549, 0.009212986566126347, 0.018861355260014534, -0.007967866957187653, -0.04465198144316673, 0.010271417908370495, -0.009701200760900974, 0.018507130444049835, 0.008445214480161667, -0.01634121686220169, -0.020184528082609177, -0.0610940158367157, -0.03437632694840431, 0.043845489621162415, -0.0475088395178318, 0.009550251998007298, 0.02596021071076393, -0.013728325255215168, -0.03921515494585037, -0.024476390331983566, -0.007575628813356161, 0.041492581367492676, -0.018821828067302704, 0.025661643594503403, -0.01558420155197382, -0.00040630492730997503, -0.03434727340936661, -0.04012015461921692, 0.043439850211143494, 0.041039396077394485, 0.020872879773378372, -0.014475159347057343, -0.016054553911089897, -0.04613324999809265, -0.046391457319259644, 0.02170235849916935, 0.02635771967470646, -0.013095056638121605, -0.04078461229801178, 0.02221183106303215, 0.014975393190979958, -0.04395072162151337, 0.025229889899492264, 0.051123663783073425, -0.013289116322994232, 0.026958078145980835, -0.09365890175104141, -0.013881772756576538, 0.05906199291348457, -0.016006961464881897, 0.012033902108669281, -0.04636272042989731, -0.03488793969154358, 0.05346057191491127, 0.039328403770923615, -0.0023699726443737745, 0.04118708521127701, 0.03216281533241272, 0.03263597562909126, 0.023556793108582497, -0.038304898887872696, -0.011172250844538212, -0.048201847821474075, 0.03736008703708649, -0.05792250856757164, -0.03406268358230591, 0.02170756459236145, 0.0392911322414875, -0.01189741212874651, -0.031096255406737328, 0.025404220446944237, 0.007688555400818586, -0.060109544545412064, -0.013720851391553879, 0.0129485372453928, -0.007585817016661167, 0.06537269800901413, -0.012364332564175129, 0.021534914150834084, -0.004044562578201294, -0.02588791400194168, -0.0005974696832709014, 0.022347059100866318, 0.02173054777085781, 0.05829603224992752, -0.033197302371263504, -0.03131144866347313, -0.0014288232196122408, 0.00174537836574018, 0.020093275234103203, 0.020604345947504044, -0.03123113140463829, -0.06796080619096756, -0.019825223833322525, 0.005797258578240871, 0.03482469171285629, 0.01892559789121151, -0.01777256838977337, 0.02771640010178089, -0.043530289083719254, -0.024674544110894203, -0.05350417271256447, 0.018151046708226204, -0.04209618642926216, -0.009656039997935295, 0.01633267290890217, -0.008388090878725052, -0.023264795541763306, 0.006448754109442234, -0.050241801887750626, -0.023067902773618698, -0.004988531116396189, 0.06929109245538712, -0.05229197442531586, -0.020420445129275322, -0.022896911948919296, 0.01139166671782732, -0.004940356127917767, 0.035443760454654694, -0.06197429820895195, -0.02706790715456009, -0.0008054906502366066, -0.05359650403261185, -0.003255049465224147, -0.02820589765906334, 0.004332422278821468, 0.018837863579392433, -0.014771513640880585, 0.028755422681570053, 0.015106753446161747, -0.028853124007582664, 0.0321858786046505, 0.060528770089149475, 0.015134192071855068, 0.0023367172107100487, 0.021103929728269577, -0.004911230877041817, 0.012154176831245422, -0.013554125092923641, -0.015884554013609886, -0.05070680007338524, -0.03377038985490799, 0.052858177572488785, 0.04678790271282196, -0.02630900777876377, 0.0017062175320461392, 0.05395091325044632, 0.03770890831947327, -0.0005121506401337683, 0.010858003050088882, -0.05248859152197838, -0.02211795002222061, 0.0530247688293457, -0.0007413816056214273, -0.003963828086853027, 0.003439530963078141, -0.0073100971058011055, -0.0026882679667323828, 0.018445473164319992, 0.017506830394268036, 0.0031228181906044483, 0.0020323614589869976, 0.04559348151087761, 0.01812601462006569, -0.012893120758235455, 0.010870902799069881, 0.03000648505985737, -0.00989572610706091, -0.019558647647500038, 0.0002152313245460391, -0.005724324844777584, 0.012120277620851994, 0.0015519376611337066, -0.05675496160984039, 0.016173653304576874, 0.011060492135584354, -0.0618504099547863, 0.01304252352565527, 0.032836735248565674, -0.026376359164714813, 0.02673123963177204, -0.007765569258481264, -0.025232788175344467, 0.02589408867061138, 0.016604099422693253, 0.021916618570685387, 0.0023483221884816885, 0.00010356744314776734, -0.021594440564513206, 0.012842496857047081, -0.01687631756067276, -0.01797228679060936, 0.013683217577636242, 0.02442362904548645, -0.0475563183426857, 0.000994573812931776, 0.021814921870827675, -0.021851254627108574, 0.02086540125310421, 0.02959534525871277, -0.009108684957027435, 0.02768488973379135, 0.009485308080911636, -0.04705563560128212, -0.020624680444598198, -0.016954731196165085, 0.02375577762722969, -0.00941870640963316, 0.004218164831399918, 0.04114493727684021, 0.03281056508421898, -0.043441060930490494, 0.015300750732421875, -0.034578852355480194, -0.04358668252825737, -0.060911744832992554, -0.06455521285533905, -0.008135974407196045, -0.02029057778418064, -0.004590773489326239, -0.005668737459927797, 0.03494739532470703, 0.005392355844378471, -0.089896559715271, -0.09857981652021408, 0.022475168108940125, -0.00004182699558441527, 0.03573136031627655, 0.02387317642569542, 0.010506687685847282, 0.0402798168361187, 0.04639379307627678, -0.03878846764564514, -0.012219898402690887, 0.013393460772931576, -0.012632939964532852, -0.010319648310542107, 0.02503041923046112, 0.023505298420786858, -0.028571205213665962, 0.006206098478287458, 0.012069634161889553, 0.008588606491684914, 0.053237780928611755, 0.02924674190580845, 0.011509143747389317, 0.025668365880846977, -0.015938905999064445, 0.03956357389688492, 0.016626475378870964, 0.017028683796525, -0.03579593822360039, -0.020775053650140762, 0.013051869347691536, 0.007621206808835268, 0.030765540897846222, -0.04382146894931793, 0.015741907060146332, 0.01254711952060461, -0.05977388471364975, 0.004589903634041548, 0.028582623228430748, 0.009448140859603882, -0.07565076649188995, -0.017899425700306892, 0.02201477251946926, 0.05990855023264885, -0.04576796293258667, 0.019908709451556206, 0.0862729400396347, 0.004664329346269369, -0.06729129701852798, -0.015153860673308372, -0.03787096217274666, -0.01125364564359188, 0.03131868690252304, -0.06292667239904404, -0.0065354541875422, 0.017331983894109726, 0.04129438474774361, 0.005455531645566225, -0.01919175125658512, -0.026791727170348167, -0.0028314930386841297, -0.021966636180877686, -0.016695108264684677, -0.0036746214609593153, 0.07422850281000137, 0.008621111512184143, 0.059571947902441025, -0.017278343439102173, -0.02275015600025654, -0.015608035959303379, 0.0230875164270401, -0.052827801555395126, -0.000338292884407565, -0.007582706864923239, 0.021628672257065773, 0.00048564764438197017, -0.050176575779914856, 0.05729527771472931, -0.01273281592875719, 0.021304424852132797, -0.03054756112396717, 0.029822880402207375, -0.0472218282520771, 0.006357502657920122, -0.04881415516138077, -0.027278875932097435, 0.007834282703697681, 0.019941864535212517, 0.04831725358963013, -0.009742680005729198, 0.02589290589094162, 0.004108079243451357, 0.0226596686989069, -0.007147118914872408, -0.03292946517467499, -0.0026338533498346806, 0.007396393921226263, 0.015817999839782715, -0.025932807475328445, 0.03729657828807831, 0.023212868720293045, 0.06403730809688568, 0.0043849763460457325, 0.021801862865686417, 0.03953096270561218, 0.0017100428231060505, 0.021464843302965164, -0.031181517988443375, -0.016402674838900566, 0.026104118674993515, 0.056675415486097336, -0.027325833216309547, 0.016914188861846924, 0.07904563844203949, 0.007301246281713247, -0.04690654203295708, 0.0069494713097810745, 0.049453627318143845, 0.02865000255405903, 0.010043066926300526, -0.03159771487116814, -0.010405251756310463, -0.004872651770710945, 0.01431189477443695, -0.0006100512109696865, 0.02080361358821392, -0.019205398857593536, -0.0405571423470974, 0.03083125129342079, 0.018180234357714653, -0.0010401559993624687, -0.010806752368807793, 0.032382965087890625, 0.0456211157143116, 0.0002096895914291963, -0.00938570499420166, 0.0031796719413250685, 0.04026024416089058, 0.03392774984240532, 0.009409521706402302, 0.0340735949575901, -0.09244795143604279, 0.012519161216914654, 0.025221697986125946, 0.02055358700454235, -0.026804443448781967, 0.0359821654856205, -0.05037004500627518, -0.024721408262848854, 0.007031220942735672, -0.013747367076575756, 0.04413384199142456, 0.007540164981037378, 0.006320639979094267, -0.007307821419090033, -0.043904103338718414, -0.022503608837723732, 0.02815830335021019, -0.03749914467334747, 0.02657911740243435, -0.058046650141477585, -0.0595080740749836, -0.05016569793224335, 0.005790348630398512, 0.03694478049874306, 0.08891493827104568, -0.008714248426258564, -0.00039692383143119514, 0.011801963672041893, 0.02327435463666916, 0.0028059801552444696, -0.0467524416744709, 0.025692591443657875, -0.011949620209634304, -0.02154051885008812, 0.03955581784248352, -0.03161371126770973, -0.02389129064977169, 0.038874201476573944, 0.03167512267827988, -0.01927804946899414, 0.009228432551026344, -0.040963899344205856, 0.027445431798696518, 0.04434983804821968, 0.03757956996560097, 0.036609355360269547, 0.037241507321596146, -0.0017739635659381747, 0.02562638372182846, 0.00719172740355134, -0.039870522916316986, -0.010006430558860302, -0.021976949647068977, -0.014406832866370678, 0.016625596210360527, 0.013866547495126724, 0.0560622476041317, 0.05067087337374687, 0.009492039680480957, -0.017936866730451584, 0.0013881877530366182, -0.050237931311130524, -0.0052610901184380054, -0.017615677788853645, 0.013340501114726067, 0.020291848108172417, 0.03792274743318558, 0.014821176417171955, 0.010888045653700829, 0.02890813909471035, -0.0485481321811676, 0.034133195877075195, -0.01589766889810562, -0.019424740225076675, 0.006705539301037788, -0.07826381921768188, -0.015591057948768139, 0.019970551133155823, -0.0076772659085690975, 0.03967965766787529, 0.030120190232992172, 0.061899807304143906, 0.009122978895902634, 0.01712227426469326, -0.007573464885354042, 0.014826754108071327, 0.010923531837761402, 0.00869464036077261, 0.016410736367106438, 0.0037689588498324156, -0.011007622815668583, -0.01359262689948082, -0.035378728061914444, -0.00222820439375937, 0.0067886714823544025, -0.0010670641204342246, -0.05046745389699936, -0.049548663198947906, 0.005446145310997963, 0.011546042747795582, -0.041969187557697296, 0.018177062273025513, 0.016205422580242157, 0.013058695010840893, 0.01996183767914772, -0.00958455540239811, 0.025840535759925842, 0.046346236020326614, -0.0004996583447791636, -0.011146004311740398, 0.03540914133191109, 0.011864548549056053, -0.014044318348169327, 0.022524524480104446, -0.013030584901571274, -0.015113829635083675, 0.0013716393150389194, -0.0284145288169384, 0.018583448603749275, 0.003921056166291237, -0.02320113591849804, -0.002835048595443368, -0.005367451347410679, -0.018924763426184654, -0.043444178998470306, -0.022670185193419456, -0.03604451194405556, 0.029587892815470695, 0.019492236897349358, 0.007142385467886925, 0.005876277107745409, 0.026962732896208763, -0.00748151121661067, 0.00034146071993745863, 0.006104611791670322, -0.015890752896666527, 0.0272812619805336, 0.024455316364765167, -0.02134784683585167, -0.026656141504645348, 0.02931613102555275, 0.021058863028883934, 0.04376671090722084, -0.04204661771655083, -0.005303124897181988, -0.008430227637290955, 0.022458570078015327, -0.018134016543626785, -0.04418493062257767, -0.05576517432928085, 0.03770638629794121, 0.04894722253084183, 0.03617461770772934, 0.0798015296459198, 0.007361230906099081, 0.034353047609329224, -0.004864854272454977, -0.004548624157905579, -0.0033385115675628185, -0.0069181229919195175, -0.0002286024100612849, 0.025606373324990273, -0.030895313248038292, -0.010791520588099957, 0.06585930287837982, 0.0036423769779503345, 0.03831510618329048, 0.02768678031861782, -0.0047240788117051125, 0.002535115694627166, 0.07435604184865952, -0.06356294453144073, -0.04707547649741173, 0.021937325596809387, -0.08026019483804703, 0.022788697853684425, -0.05235321447253227, -0.05957353115081787, 0.04297047108411789, 0.05273547023534775, -0.0011599927674978971, -0.011124116368591785, -0.0242502149194479, -0.07249866425991058, -0.0018569724634289742, 0.01572122983634472, 0.01927001029253006, 0.03126637637615204, 0.005105904769152403, 0.07154271006584167, -0.01081105973571539, 0.02852594293653965, 0.0028190314769744873, -0.040332138538360596, -0.000447362894192338, 0.007043762598186731, -0.049456093460321426, -0.011224986054003239, 0.004830171819776297, -0.021784506738185883, -0.015085713006556034, -0.004663798958063126, 0.02776682749390602, 0.0305955708026886, 0.024662764742970467, -0.02928793989121914, 0.04876831918954849, -0.012388616800308228, 0.010205033235251904, -0.024144824594259262, -0.037425294518470764, 0.14929841458797455, 0.04462703689932823, 0.04136233031749725, -0.044393643736839294, 0.0014716535806655884, 0.05330200493335724, 0.001902148243971169, -0.062315668910741806, 0.03323078155517578, 0.0074022444896399975, -0.023441243916749954, 0.003248077118769288, 0.02243540808558464, -0.005832529626786709, -0.007862717844545841, 0.05517825484275818, -0.03453044593334198, -0.005363762378692627, 0.032415129244327545, -0.006983734667301178, -0.026258092373609543, -0.014384004287421703, -0.04490097239613533, 0.0421568863093853, 0.005124391056597233, -0.05247170105576515, 0.010396678000688553, -0.013257679529488087, -0.02287442237138748, 0.019296448677778244, -0.04524144157767296, 0.03853034973144531, 0.003787871915847063, -0.0036473004147410393, 0.027790162712335587, 0.03778057545423508, 0.0013681793352589011, -0.031124526634812355, 0.012055445462465286, 0.0332694835960865, 0.021445486694574356, 0.0032893125899136066, 0.0029479332733899355, 0.03190723434090614, 0.0002319055492989719, -0.05180631950497627, -0.06719077378511429, 0.044688791036605835, 0.006868967320770025, 0.00805029645562172, 0.014885240234434605, -0.021757028996944427, -0.012500917539000511, -0.031076740473508835, 0.006242149509489536, 0.03397436812520027, 0.016575265675783157, -0.013511589728295803, -0.00523437699303031, 0.0020760700572282076, 0.022984294220805168, 0.028708772733807564, 0.02614927850663662, 0.022811230272054672, -0.05498262867331505, -0.05500437319278717, 0.004716156516224146, 0.02514522522687912, 0.0065758004784584045, 0.01469286996871233, -0.0341607965528965, -0.016731252893805504, 0.019584447145462036, -0.015317250043153763, -0.04278963431715965, -0.02835875377058983, 0.012599710375070572, 0.0010562106035649776, -0.009991616010665894, -0.01606246456503868, -0.015799757093191147, 0.005717397667467594, 0.00009746057185111567, -0.012110421434044838, -0.04028306528925896, -0.057635825127363205, 0.012882720679044724, 0.01621795818209648, 0.07966349273920059, -0.039223890751600266, 0.010733925737440586, 0.06056125834584236, 0.0318785198032856, -0.017954064533114433, -0.03347212076187134, -0.018668157979846, -0.037122275680303574, -0.007515902630984783, 0.01490387786179781, 0.05279277265071869, 0.049969617277383804, 0.014528012834489346, 0.026030106469988823, -0.015594461932778358, -0.0250263474881649, 0.013270744122564793, 0.03594029322266579, -0.043790798634290695, 0.03124256618320942, 0.012515125796198845, -0.003681904636323452, -0.016676729544997215, -0.004456226248294115, -0.004536385182291269, 0.020548410713672638, 0.05817115306854248, -0.029938193038105965, -0.04589015990495682, -0.013833516277372837, -0.013672983273863792, 0.05474435165524483, -0.0028947670944035053, 0.01803830824792385, -0.028209980577230453, -0.03959888964891434, -0.0022535661701112986, 0.022227652370929718, 0.011109198443591595, -0.00878679845482111, -0.00812361016869545, -0.016576213762164116, 0.029039375483989716, 0.026527564972639084, -0.0043771895579993725, -0.0258889589458704, 0.037609510123729706, -0.015608510933816433, 0.015213304199278355, -0.016374491155147552, -0.04872732236981392, 0.027603356167674065, -0.0380571149289608, 0.0193935576826334, 0.020166654139757156, 0.0162730161100626, 0.05393063277006149, 0.03890877217054367, -0.018898624926805496, 0.003270735265687108, 0.001007047831080854, -0.019726717844605446, 0.0031340497080236673, -0.014332907274365425, 0.0196828730404377, 0.018333975225687027, 0.0012175616575405002, -0.005026903003454208, 0.04262964054942131, 0.017449485138058662, 0.0046247877180576324, 0.05365952104330063, -0.0021961366292089224, -0.012633121572434902, 0.005491374526172876, 0.010054096579551697, -0.015570255927741528, -0.024476854130625725, 0.021769896149635315, 0.02378913015127182, 0.042636871337890625, -0.003974066115915775, 0.02571800723671913, 0.013993172906339169, -0.004480978939682245, -0.09862984716892242, -0.013872652314603329, 0.029727820307016373, 0.02869391441345215, 0.034602608531713486, -0.0239202119410038, -0.026350263506174088, 0.016060881316661835, -0.0504862479865551, 0.05207589268684387, -0.014624170027673244, 0.024768410250544548, -0.00893089547753334, -0.004560790024697781, -0.03409434109926224, -0.008203314617276192, 0.025668233633041382, 0.019815586507320404, 0.019759584218263626, 0.016874194145202637, -0.007010235451161861, -0.011544272303581238, -0.02196941338479519, 0.025893129408359528, 0.007894128561019897, -0.0573873296380043, 0.04734961688518524, -0.055826421827077866, -0.010998958721756935, 0.06047472730278969, 0.015252127312123775, -0.031328678131103516, -0.013054046779870987, -0.0033095970284193754, -0.002213960513472557, 0.027679594233632088, 0.01005858276039362, -0.020233474671840668, 0.014432364143431187, 0.04400721192359924, -0.0037567720282822847, 0.03119068592786789, -0.0065736486576497555, 0.015957675874233246, 0.04477117583155632, -0.0008664242341183126, -0.014897857792675495, 0.004849039949476719, 0.013224650174379349, -0.017238570377230644, 0.0334443636238575, -0.04301049932837486, 0.005397411994636059, -0.011934726499021053, 0.00763138709589839, -0.014779656194150448, 0.02426634356379509, 0.054948799312114716, 0.025776544585824013, 0.00353613612242043, -0.0013271337375044823, -0.017138827592134476, -0.0422150194644928, 0.04189315810799599, 0.01595953106880188, -0.040183860808610916, -0.07274799793958664, -0.008285805583000183, -0.01505087036639452, -0.03754224255681038, -0.03833455964922905, 0.004930420778691769, -0.0332535095512867, 0.04202289506793022, -0.021886218339204788, -0.007542718667536974, -0.030507398769259453, -0.012473003938794136, -0.008332115598022938, -0.06912841647863388, 0.03656088188290596, 0.03069707565009594, 0.004257729277014732, -0.0006826802273280919, -0.021583447232842445, -0.03330923989415169, -0.003065350465476513, 0.04916701465845108, -0.04006184637546539, -0.008434340357780457, -0.015655241906642914, 0.013986718840897083, 0.03370232135057449, -0.02205040119588375, 0.04387566074728966, -0.04783674329519272, 0.014792900532484055, 0.0013125980040058494, 0.00017928105080500245, 0.02855273149907589, -0.006878980901092291, 0.003970811143517494, -0.00018396701489109546, -0.03526074066758156, -0.007575621362775564, -0.013007069937884808, 0.02610483579337597, -0.007939704693853855, 0.004004384856671095, 0.019066134467720985, 0.02573627233505249, -0.0038340508472174406, -0.003160732565447688, -0.01865997724235058, -0.09289669990539551, 0.04741453006863594, -0.037735555320978165, -0.030684592202305794, 0.02914183773100376, 0.0217093788087368, 0.02299325540661812, -0.06608971208333969, -0.014635147526860237, 0.04199039936065674, 0.0002852574398275465, -0.028654364868998528, 0.01469667162746191, -0.0011875268537551165, 0.026964271441102028, 0.02540258690714836, 0.016920415684580803, -0.0043148742988705635, -0.07366964966058731, 0.009609361179172993, 0.028775654733181, 0.01722654141485691, -0.004635955672711134, 0.02456110715866089, 0.023146454244852066, -0.01764766126871109, 0.019045935943722725, -0.01361502893269062, -0.019185369834303856, -0.04852008819580078, 0.018319295719265938, 0.026161817833781242, -0.0025254248175770044, -0.01527941320091486, 0.015408049337565899, -0.013599828816950321, 0.062135640531778336, -0.018912114202976227, 0.024690696969628334, -0.052015915513038635, 0.01588393561542034, -0.034091249108314514, 0.025427907705307007, -0.00623365817591548, 0.035743240267038345, 0.006629223469644785, 0.0026614386588335037, 0.000796773936599493, 0.03544427827000618, -0.0022322621662169695, -0.005499727558344603, 0.01110594067722559, 0.05514652281999588, -0.01682586595416069, -0.0010039032204076648, -0.041840266436338425, 0.005191579461097717, -0.038149524480104446, -0.01092926599085331, 0.065988689661026, 0.02816948853433132, -0.00444987416267395, 0.006236437242478132, -0.04250200837850571, 0.06272217631340027, -0.03225687891244888, -0.004592915531247854, -0.05612391233444214, -0.0021766601130366325, 0.009517603553831577, -0.03804515674710274 ]
<p>In calculating the pseudoinverse of a matrix $A$, of size (m,n), I need to choose a tolerance threshold for the eigenvalues. I'm trying to understand how I should pick this. Matlab default is to use the $norm(A)*max(m,n)*eps$, where the norm is norm-2 and the eps is the machine epsilon. Any ideas as to why this is the default value?</p> <p>Moreover, there are cases in which $ A $ is only interesting in comparison to other values. For example, I'd like to calculate the eigenvalues of $C + BB^TA^{-0.5}$ where A,B,C are matrices, but B can have a very large second dimension. In this example, how should we choose the tolerance? </p>
33,239
[ 0.011284268461167812, 0.027739999815821648, -0.0021484929602593184, -0.034848205745220184, 0.040647536516189575, 0.02163929119706154, -0.033598463982343674, -0.02471955679357052, 0.009516139514744282, -0.02420114167034626, 0.02478049322962761, 0.01570591889321804, 0.0449681393802166, 0.040383897721767426, 0.04403836652636528, -0.004150402266532183, -0.01713002286851406, -0.04994901642203331, 0.011513075791299343, -0.025545477867126465, 0.016000304371118546, 0.037837255746126175, 0.03275594487786293, -0.03195097669959068, -0.03967093676328659, 0.023427847772836685, 0.03651122376322746, -0.000603043707087636, -0.0009465957409702241, 0.033336326479911804, -0.05534428358078003, -0.042320288717746735, 0.03308258578181267, 0.021154817193746567, -0.015453997999429703, 0.0017525097355246544, -0.010470440611243248, -0.017307328060269356, 0.0014395678881555796, 0.03762713447213173, -0.0030930200591683388, -0.009171324782073498, 0.047836266458034515, 0.01324131153523922, -0.010373763740062714, 0.03979089856147766, -0.0011017660144716501, -0.019454246386885643, 0.04052690044045448, -0.023889122530817986, 0.07299339026212692, 0.05029826983809471, 0.012294077314436436, -0.0043821195140480995, 0.00997983105480671, 0.01577245257794857, 0.05315723642706871, 0.04482075199484825, 0.02425837516784668, -0.08512569218873978, -0.0027438600081950426, -0.03338160738348961, 0.011355577036738396, -0.021154480054974556, -0.027464164420962334, 0.023863621056079865, -0.011183395981788635, -0.017365869134664536, 0.03295116871595383, -0.0332203134894371, -0.028293674811720848, 0.009429756551980972, 0.011690261773765087, -0.08327428996562958, 0.06023940071463585, -0.008029013872146606, 0.026158243417739868, 0.02587343193590641, 0.028755463659763336, 0.013965800404548645, -0.005296939052641392, 0.026264941319823265, -0.006628059316426516, 0.04997364059090614, -0.002936712931841612, -0.025287887081503868, 0.03276154771447182, -0.030383510515093803, 0.004217931535094976, 0.017531603574752808, -0.00571355689316988, 0.004438390489667654, 0.0654287114739418, -0.04272554814815521, -0.005108254961669445, 0.011336125433444977, 0.009855920448899269, 0.04682214558124542, -0.00009755884093465284, -0.02797066979110241, -0.0335511714220047, -0.03783227503299713, -0.01696258969604969, 0.04238195717334747, 0.005897874012589455, 0.048892147839069366, -0.015772422775626183, 0.025751516222953796, 0.024173740297555923, -0.01850048452615738, -0.019759923219680786, 0.013699781149625778, -0.018222764134407043, 0.026633696630597115, 0.040231604129076004, 0.010744558647274971, 0.006283476948738098, -0.03558291494846344, 0.029879366979002953, 0.05510750412940979, 0.009524657391011715, 0.009103426709771156, 0.02543785609304905, -0.04440566152334213, -0.05026319622993469, 0.016486847773194313, 0.010622784495353699, 0.02716928906738758, -0.04610651731491089, 0.030420472845435143, -0.0022410026285797358, -0.05243677645921707, 0.006819070316851139, -0.009951443411409855, 0.03379329293966293, -0.003374303923919797, -0.058727651834487915, -0.05737399682402611, 0.043828148394823074, -0.02046981453895569, -0.01522794645279646, -0.08811621367931366, 0.001214586547575891, 0.04316834732890129, 0.0878460630774498, 0.06398675590753555, 0.04239337146282196, 0.02740517258644104, 0.03263944014906883, 0.015674801543354988, -0.04382894188165665, -0.00962822139263153, -0.044223763048648834, -0.03324458375573158, 0.013263236731290817, -0.013263769447803497, -0.016409197822213173, -0.001347580342553556, 0.0030140350572764874, 0.011033701710402966, 0.037067100405693054, -0.01453774981200695, -0.0420430563390255, -0.013153926469385624, 0.01592358760535717, 0.00423805508762598, 0.07917700707912445, 0.009771919809281826, 0.023995790630578995, 0.010250023566186428, -0.03526676446199417, -0.0003439679858274758, -0.00019371570670045912, 0.05168687179684639, 0.04010137915611267, -0.013833830133080482, 0.021148061379790306, -0.009354998357594013, 0.029095642268657684, 0.021861141547560692, -0.050491634756326675, -0.04640877991914749, 0.008738800883293152, 0.03301459923386574, 0.007250447291880846, 0.05606323853135109, -0.004525713622570038, -0.0034226407296955585, 0.01877855509519577, -0.02810748666524887, -0.022118709981441498, -0.04776901379227638, 0.01929878629744053, 0.024008197709918022, -0.046937327831983566, 0.01754031889140606, -0.016567738726735115, -0.01712140440940857, 0.0012944643385708332, -0.0010920704808086157, -0.0064046429470181465, 0.0046440172009170055, 0.017550446093082428, -0.0489136204123497, 0.02051563933491707, 0.04062013328075409, 0.03927440196275711, -0.005300996359437704, 0.044616296887397766, -0.023884892463684082, -0.05000512674450874, 0.007085366640239954, -0.04538873955607414, 0.019580909982323647, 0.03843776881694794, -0.076424740254879, -0.03379777818918228, -0.031348470598459244, -0.027697715908288956, -0.0046882410533726215, -0.01692470908164978, 0.0767110139131546, 0.036129627376794815, 0.03422559052705765, 0.007430914789438248, -0.0035799993202090263, 0.034393273293972015, -0.0007448343676514924, -0.01427294872701168, -0.034001074731349945, -0.053066570311784744, 0.011065095663070679, 0.02589273639023304, 0.0525471568107605, -0.05206432193517685, 0.022544685751199722, 0.041626591235399246, 0.011739412322640419, 0.024418527260422707, 0.013968359678983688, -0.026096682995557785, -0.019293876364827156, 0.01734970323741436, 0.04660729691386223, 0.01152461115270853, -0.008674508891999722, -0.01495675090700388, 0.03941737860441208, 0.03005683235824108, 0.018602753058075905, 0.0061523751355707645, 0.022185038775205612, -0.04117624834179878, 0.010450547561049461, -0.015043322928249836, 0.018103359267115593, 0.022885272279381752, 0.006793605163693428, -0.028123486787080765, 0.06464259326457977, -0.03404739871621132, 0.029316836968064308, 0.019658492878079414, -0.041383013129234314, 0.014481266029179096, 0.01003639679402113, -0.028065498918294907, -0.011461998336017132, 0.014702982269227505, 0.007807835005223751, 0.03769310563802719, -0.048568930476903915, -0.030347084626555443, -0.04258441925048828, 0.028636394068598747, 0.0700034499168396, -0.014090760610997677, 0.020069871097803116, -0.016753755509853363, -0.017664996907114983, -0.023031240329146385, -0.00485908193513751, 0.013226070441305637, -0.005839770194143057, -0.03736523911356926, 0.001651443773880601, -0.040549106895923615, -0.018669340759515762, 0.03472208231687546, -0.001484143198467791, 0.04232092946767807, 0.007799212820827961, -0.004831749014556408, -0.026323888450860977, -0.02262687496840954, 0.012606736272573471, -0.01604447141289711, 0.03421996906399727, -0.045956801623106, 0.033067137002944946, -0.011873972602188587, -0.036785632371902466, 0.027764467522501945, -0.032308340072631836, -0.021979540586471558, -0.04562487453222275, -0.041364721953868866, -0.011079222895205021, -0.020037870854139328, 0.013156156055629253, -0.001045547309331596, -0.001641949755139649, -0.00981063861399889, -0.029056159779429436, -0.03826992213726044, -0.005341863725334406, -0.04340426251292229, 0.02383393421769142, 0.002909822389483452, -0.012184841558337212, 0.0841154083609581, 0.03620878979563713, 0.01874825544655323, -0.04316309839487076, -0.01287651713937521, 0.0037612481974065304, -0.05544830858707428, 0.011787359602749348, 0.06524469703435898, -0.0008517640526406467, 0.04245631769299507, -0.0076088691130280495, 0.045518096536397934, 0.05946400761604309, -0.031636517494916916, -0.028772195801138878, 0.004632924217730761, -0.010936347767710686, 0.0012781608384102583, 0.02280953712761402, 0.013795834966003895, 0.018179159611463547, 0.02658618427813053, -0.0018165435176342726, 0.026428868994116783, 0.009340477176010609, -0.04184728115797043, -0.00839205365628004, -0.07362625747919083, 0.04084771126508713, -0.030900688841938972, 0.024976516142487526, 0.016015056520700455, 0.00006072339238016866, -0.012298058718442917, 0.03606940060853958, -0.012832807376980782, -0.058937594294548035, -0.011943093501031399, 0.007659181021153927, -0.0034966350067406893, 0.008290342055261135, 0.0078146206215024, 0.00499177910387516, -0.0195259228348732, 0.016537785530090332, -0.02016431838274002, -0.048105545341968536, 0.057122863829135895, 0.034043218940496445, 0.013160170055925846, 0.003757722210139036, -0.040020860731601715, 0.002586778486147523, -0.06448487937450409, -0.016107751056551933, -0.02798873372375965, 0.07563679665327072, -0.011455457657575607, 0.006492265034466982, 0.027286389842629433, 0.00674192700535059, -0.008015221916139126, 0.0014390165451914072, -0.04800519719719887, 0.006369589827954769, -0.025493618100881577, -0.002103775506839156, -0.0012962983455508947, 0.007072901353240013, 0.047373466193675995, -0.028699522837996483, -0.028287500143051147, 0.04087093099951744, 0.034100793302059174, -0.035689909011125565, 0.013824069872498512, -0.05236044153571129, -0.0065417056903243065, -0.048260871320962906, 0.0004156438517384231, 0.012340539135038853, -0.020519724115729332, 0.03531269729137421, -0.0041533769108355045, -0.03499086946249008, -0.026301153004169464, 0.033256594091653824, 0.01841094344854355, 0.0028016334399580956, 0.0328344888985157, 0.033851515501737595, 0.04913955181837082, -0.03244844451546669, -0.029611023142933846, 0.013777653686702251, 0.0631926953792572, 0.03149893134832382, 0.016670556738972664, -0.011037014424800873, -0.05037432536482811, -0.013728565536439419, -0.0019399183802306652, 0.03025246597826481, -0.02078135684132576, 0.02417750097811222, 0.028301184996962547, 0.01620251126587391, -0.05119543522596359, 0.009351699613034725, 0.05252228304743767, 0.009844023734331131, -0.03554220870137215, -0.047385323792696, -0.014976207166910172, -0.030650325119495392, 0.002551368437707424, -0.010653187520802021, -0.011991726234555244, -0.01445547491312027, -0.023101050406694412, 0.056232795119285583, -0.018710866570472717, -0.005907444749027491, 0.004504096694290638, 0.06262526661157608, 0.02461475320160389, 0.003483155043795705, -0.011268364265561104, -0.00595355499535799, 0.011764817871153355, 0.05825911834836006, 0.024923140183091164, -0.013565178029239178, -0.04347104951739311, -0.0032790869008749723, 0.04532020539045334, 0.031012127175927162, 0.00408304575830698, -0.04547847434878349, -0.0492478646337986, -0.008748332038521767, 0.04251338914036751, -0.0026149002369493246, 0.059030238538980484, -0.0015431201318278909, 0.019511252641677856, -0.043963171541690826, 0.007536702323704958, -0.009836586192250252, 0.005342191085219383, 0.019502071663737297, 0.04977972060441971, -0.041589803993701935, -0.023682834580540657, -0.05826515331864357, -0.024851951748132706, 0.0106334388256073, 0.06374876946210861, 0.013207907788455486, -0.023430045694112778, 0.0063963280990719795, 0.019843656569719315, 0.014129589311778545, -0.025699185207486153, 0.0003246941196266562, 0.03873781859874725, 0.009186874143779278, 0.04851270094513893, -0.014583383686840534, -0.02181418053805828, 0.035761646926403046, 0.01744350790977478, 0.00041059800423681736, -0.011297493241727352, -0.001702162902802229, 0.038617029786109924, 0.021351616829633713, -0.031667560338974, 0.057713355869054794, 0.008292391896247864, -0.004614473320543766, -0.015722377225756645, -0.05252247303724289, -0.002952289069071412, -0.019970448687672615, -0.01022045686841011, -0.026926584541797638, -0.0010718870908021927, -0.03572802245616913, 0.025245364755392075, 0.01887926273047924, 0.059937406331300735, -0.0063310954719781876, -0.008226022124290466, 0.011329252272844315, 0.08157727122306824, 0.00915463361889124, -0.01354206819087267, 0.05251286178827286, 0.02444484643638134, -0.0006857466651126742, 0.006129384506493807, 0.04721388593316078, -0.008398260921239853, 0.013479392975568771, 0.05269816890358925, -0.014665137976408005, -0.004181989468634129, -0.0006447039777413011, -0.015193884260952473, 0.00028887856751680374, -0.05255814269185066, 0.03221554309129715, 0.0011836481280624866, 0.004832468926906586, -0.001054859603755176, -0.015754740685224533, 0.006162628531455994, 0.012215256690979004, -0.01748848520219326, 0.030337687581777573, -0.07790663838386536, 0.020265519618988037, -0.021900659427046776, 0.015020850114524364, -0.07932715117931366, -0.0016222981503233314, -0.014381901361048222, 0.00013419875176623464, -0.017797211185097694, -0.009745211340487003, -0.03010784648358822, -0.042014311999082565, -0.02688508853316307, 0.013611653819680214, 0.05433434993028641, -0.02627328410744667, -0.027869300916790962, 0.020711936056613922, 0.04899017885327339, 0.062438204884529114, -0.025502923876047134, 0.0153586957603693, 0.024335118010640144, -0.007959282957017422, 0.007408286910504103, 0.0037035548593848944, 0.018364880234003067, -0.04618265479803085, -0.0024808167945593596, -0.05536353588104248, 0.0007657215464860201, 0.03192141652107239, -0.022176839411258698, -0.012126761488616467, 0.04717479273676872, 0.0031314396765083075, 0.0326780304312706, -0.02088331989943981, -0.006209102459251881, -0.03427484631538391, 0.023370714858174324, 0.028914498165249825, -0.047007594257593155, 0.006921118125319481, -0.0256989486515522, 0.031128229573369026, 0.024991950020194054, 0.017055580392479897, -0.0037605140823870897, 0.07943414896726608, -0.0269049983471632, 0.0007929150597192347, -0.03596211597323418, -0.023803936317563057, 0.0543869212269783, 0.01697079837322235, -0.01805196888744831, -0.006618117447942495, 0.015620933845639229, -0.04443990811705589, -0.0538066104054451, -0.06345956772565842, 0.04608052223920822, 0.03234093263745308, 0.012686274014413357, 0.029293691739439964, 0.03784968703985214, 0.002036613877862692, -0.02715260162949562, -0.03659561276435852, -0.022960152477025986, 0.012156838551163673, -0.011600526981055737, 0.016830332577228546, -0.05317503958940506, -0.035995323210954666, 0.009156876243650913, 0.01817520521581173, -0.00657224515452981, 0.02747172862291336, 0.023768018931150436, 0.017407018691301346, -0.005444842856377363, -0.043511226773262024, -0.02181236259639263, 0.04622259363532066, -0.05122620239853859, 0.020469950512051582, 0.022065894678235054, -0.01203903928399086, 0.020314978435635567, 0.004045512061566114, 0.0286709051579237, -0.04326017573475838, 0.017655927687883377, -0.029525697231292725, -0.00125837919767946, 0.03559121862053871, -0.03552757203578949, 0.003644045442342758, -0.010797344148159027, 0.02195652388036251, 0.009627860970795155, 0.018171066418290138, -0.041267700493335724, -0.05043502524495125, -0.047411415725946426, -0.04952877387404442, -0.038658663630485535, 0.003261944279074669, 0.026797877624630928, -0.02317672036588192, 0.03218235820531845, -0.034760791808366776, 0.024363316595554352, 0.0031983156222850084, 0.03947872295975685, 0.0037682282272726297, 0.024710049852728844, 0.012126256711781025, 0.00476977089419961, 0.016958311200141907, 0.020743846893310547, 0.13068653643131256, 0.08260266482830048, 0.024744536727666855, -0.06279006600379944, 0.07073331624269485, 0.01154417172074318, 0.029243072494864464, -0.026341209188103676, 0.029211288318037987, -0.025638144463300705, -0.012557802721858025, 0.023217739537358284, 0.036480747163295746, 0.0070752231404185295, 0.007416000589728355, 0.008700637146830559, -0.02708716318011284, -0.015421107411384583, 0.03314363956451416, 0.06966984272003174, 0.02086830325424671, -0.03760768473148346, 0.0019630591850727797, 0.021732183173298836, -0.03902536258101463, -0.010366829112172127, -0.019942590966820717, -0.018673470243811607, -0.009853814728558064, -0.021030759438872337, 0.00013490895798895508, 0.02318652905523777, 0.020839545875787735, 0.010186867788434029, 0.004645857494324446, 0.0365339033305645, 0.0051412940956652164, -0.01945655234158039, -0.01277894526720047, 0.01020124088972807, -0.032868579030036926, -0.018135670572519302, -0.012143041007220745, -0.01783503219485283, -0.0407513789832592, -0.02648530900478363, -0.01897503063082695, 0.040127165615558624, 0.006142197642475367, 0.024906424805521965, -0.0034518162719905376, -0.00744827464222908, 0.01560035441070795, -0.03110049106180668, -0.030103661119937897, -0.014216181822121143, 0.0065567162819206715, -0.012842339463531971, 0.020999962463974953, -0.002854449674487114, 0.03062170371413231, 0.0185676459223032, 0.023104149848222733, 0.02381858229637146, -0.036583755165338516, 0.019014457240700722, -0.005190831609070301, 0.033294763416051865, -0.01920950971543789, -0.0015454912791028619, 0.013032035902142525, -0.004683553706854582, -0.03256438300013542, -0.0617290660738945, -0.00513041764497757, -0.021353181451559067, 0.01808861456811428, -0.034304939210414886, -0.021852588281035423, -0.020196137949824333, -0.08884565532207489, -0.005044890567660332, -0.040898632258176804, 0.008987965062260628, -0.03948916867375374, -0.03793817386031151, -0.0021012239158153534, 0.019611824303865433, -0.01773996092379093, -0.004901571664959192, 0.009151496924459934, 0.03059040941298008, 0.013310685753822327, -0.012152301147580147, 0.011271314695477486, -0.02787410467863083, -0.06531020253896713, 0.04444301500916481, -0.006744957063347101, 0.014680338092148304, 0.0017521352274343371, 0.0016309034544974566, 0.00004138744770898484, 0.0499405711889267, -0.03380947187542915, -0.027947677299380302, 0.009936178103089333, -0.037014614790678024, 0.004645909648388624, 0.03816691040992737, -0.01703874208033085, -0.05496002361178398, 0.006749480962753296, -0.0464065819978714, -0.024079984053969383, 0.004775908309966326, 0.04025194048881531, -0.017803575843572617, 0.03137621283531189, -0.0016302346484735608, -0.0064636641182005405, -0.05798974633216858, -0.016490118578076363, -0.007454400882124901, 0.01815740205347538, 0.009343277662992477, -0.00395225128158927, -0.0394340455532074, -0.012153935618698597, -0.028756456449627876, -0.012335572391748428, -0.0029425194952636957, 0.02613173797726631, 0.025995362550020218, -0.016453847289085388, -0.003467418486252427, -0.016471853479743004, 0.0760197564959526, -0.024677466601133347, -0.0010705951135605574, 0.018574722111225128, -0.07331015914678574, -0.003428581403568387, 0.018143823370337486, -0.03297590836882591, -0.019595135003328323, 0.0034020619932562113, 0.0009788272436708212, -0.0384320393204689, 0.0388464629650116, -0.04245791211724281, -0.03863273188471794, 0.007990802638232708, 0.01470971293747425, -0.004978038836270571, -0.02486688829958439, 0.01932985708117485, -0.03648098558187485, 0.01878981478512287, -0.01751902885735035, 0.03168277442455292, -0.010709196329116821, -0.047660425305366516, 0.021817145869135857, -0.005382218863815069, 0.022441396489739418, 0.02360500767827034, 0.0153920603916049, 0.01927950605750084, 0.04769638180732727, -0.017345113679766655, -0.030174560844898224, 0.014932171441614628, 0.028745803982019424, -0.07285906374454498, -0.009690053761005402, 0.006026005372405052, -0.003828766057267785, 0.019561607390642166, -0.041330061852931976, 0.003857539501041174, 0.07546032220125198, -0.066095732152462, 0.0390462651848793, -0.024725839495658875, 0.008752064779400826, -0.03618032485246658, -0.018999679014086723, -0.02612852118909359, 0.023872701451182365, 0.01256896834820509, -0.02963516116142273, 0.07458153367042542, -0.024097731336951256, -0.06153088063001633, -0.06497572362422943, -0.0005052786436863244, 0.054036129266023636, -0.0027888116892427206, -0.053754184395074844, 0.00814745295792818, 0.03172239661216736, -0.0659044086933136, 0.038424331694841385, -0.03608917444944382, -0.021811706945300102, -0.015863267704844475, 0.038142431527376175, 0.012877254746854305, 0.055159300565719604, 0.054888155311346054, 0.03654705733060837, 0.031590644270181656, -0.019798096269369125, 0.0001239120465470478, 0.007050985004752874, 0.009388185106217861, 0.06738974899053574, 0.03266787528991699, -0.002889035502448678, -0.05876229330897331, -0.006082252599298954, -0.012356942519545555, -0.014895148575305939, -0.006740131415426731, -0.00008235083805629984, 0.008596750907599926, -0.072053462266922, 0.03765946254134178, -0.0029291471000760794, -0.017776988446712494, -0.008351336233317852, 0.040704403072595596, -0.0025131443981081247, 0.020160170271992683, -0.019560594111680984, -0.057060305029153824, 0.03162071108818054, 0.024652665480971336, -0.03539818897843361, -0.08994510769844055, -0.025958895683288574, -0.023928770795464516, -0.033470187336206436, -0.005237055942416191, -0.0353989340364933, -0.04152125120162964, 0.050880953669548035, 0.010235806927084923, 0.03377030789852142, -0.02705804444849491, -0.004495458677411079, 0.025624949485063553, -0.08440123498439789, 0.025527246296405792, -0.025124339386820793, 0.010874893516302109, 0.001417948747985065, -0.0008670518873259425, -0.006678596138954163, 0.03132915496826172, 0.03391720727086067, 0.05443485081195831, 0.014901679940521717, 0.01177859865128994, 0.011022049002349377, 0.030029766261577606, -0.02668008580803871, 0.027775581926107407, 0.007197140250355005, 0.0030380769167095423, -0.03437205031514168, -0.0011931813787668943, 0.020433850586414337, 0.028706425800919533, 0.020007111132144928, 0.01454555056989193, 0.004448252264410257, 0.010492746718227863, -0.017864489927887917, 0.06331788748502731, 0.01384374126791954, -0.023707590997219086, 0.05598659813404083, -0.004160970449447632, 0.008881679736077785, 0.026250069960951805, -0.001507081207819283, -0.058210454881191254, 0.010514873079955578, -0.01769081875681877, -0.013779786415398121, -0.0026464564725756645, 0.019498588517308235, 0.006793273147195578, -0.05960426852107048, -0.015452508814632893, 0.06415686756372452, -0.02469785325229168, -0.018133040517568588, 0.020707547664642334, 0.0257476307451725, 0.0380905382335186, -0.009623507037758827, 0.06614106893539429, 0.04409785941243172, -0.015772495418787003, 0.011519763618707657, 0.00852248165756464, 0.00911460630595684, -0.005423526745289564, 0.036037836223840714, 0.04009604454040527, -0.030814627185463905, 0.034141380339860916, -0.03322778642177582, 0.018626056611537933, -0.05249110981822014, -0.013644114136695862, 0.058638643473386765, -0.020001614466309547, 0.02864825539290905, -0.01619960553944111, -0.02299576625227928, 0.061732932925224304, -0.01842411234974861, 0.0029600090347230434, -0.020437370985746384, 0.014988794922828674, -0.012750370427966118, -0.010803129523992538, -0.019303061068058014, 0.047451552003622055, -0.025870947167277336, 0.01017158292233944, -0.008958274498581886, 0.004208173602819443, 0.018495656549930573, -0.026040760800242424, 0.01645532436668873, 0.05302422121167183, -0.007021103519946337, -0.021423175930976868, -0.013409692794084549, -0.030617035925388336, 0.009603088721632957, 0.02808832935988903, 0.0512358583509922, 0.021118570119142532, -0.01113883312791586, -0.06011755391955376, -0.009189916774630547, 0.000868049799464643, -0.04001891240477562, -0.03486841171979904, -0.03168249875307083, 0.008649097755551338, -0.006490626372396946, 0.04702000692486763 ]
<p>I have a dataset that includes variables about customer income levels. The income was collected in binned fashion (<code>Which range describes your income? 0-25k, 25k-50k,...</code>). My question is how best use this for modeling using <code>glmnet</code> and <code>gbm</code> packages in <code>R</code>.</p> <p>I have looked at the <code>grouped</code> packaged in <code>R</code> but it seems to do everything (coursening and regression) for you. Is there a package that converts binned data back to continuous data for use in with other algos?</p> <p>EDIT: The current method I'm using is to convert them to the mid-point of the range (<code>0-25k -&gt; 12500</code>), then using an <code>ifelse()</code> stmt to code a few variables to convey the fact that there is a relationship between the levels.</p> <pre><code>incOver25k &lt;- ifelse(df1$income &gt;= 25000,1,0) incOver50k &lt;- ifelse(df1$income &gt;= 50000,1,0) </code></pre> <p>Then use these flags instead of using <code>model.matrix()</code>. </p> <p>Was curious if there were any better ideas.</p>
74,064
[ 0.0031258061062544584, 0.025091882795095444, 0.0019624687265604734, 0.00632802490144968, 0.016227010637521744, -0.014490995556116104, 0.0012537697330117226, -0.037750955671072006, 0.0508858859539032, -0.006632218137383461, 0.040219005197286606, 0.048937514424324036, 0.022663114592432976, 0.0027053970843553543, 0.04734447970986366, 0.026545820757746696, -0.012541437521576881, -0.027498774230480194, 0.004402281250804663, 0.0009594973525963724, -0.010743900202214718, 0.003878058632835746, -0.0270911306142807, -0.02284298837184906, -0.02922770194709301, 0.03908451274037361, 0.0333046093583107, -0.05041709542274475, 0.00446424400433898, 0.031175266951322556, -0.04933840408921242, -0.025760924443602562, 0.009838094934821129, 0.0427674800157547, 0.014763383194804192, 0.014073764905333519, 0.006510608363896608, -0.031522803008556366, -0.038397565484046936, 0.003955259453505278, -0.0342429094016552, -0.005458161700516939, 0.023633677512407303, 0.030582036823034286, 0.024249449372291565, 0.013468677178025246, 0.012713233940303326, -0.007019910961389542, 0.05780326947569847, -0.022834312170743942, 0.048272766172885895, -0.018264833837747574, 0.03285970538854599, 0.008599753491580486, 0.002217181259766221, 0.010492300614714622, 0.0618511438369751, 0.041120387613773346, -0.01251673512160778, -0.010600217618048191, -0.014878078363835812, -0.04185501113533974, 0.005196701269596815, -0.00292792241089046, -0.007355965673923492, -0.012387102469801903, 0.02090531773865223, -0.011573952622711658, 0.024133335798978806, -0.03273874148726463, -0.016751188784837723, 0.008117329329252243, 0.017521001398563385, -0.026349108666181564, 0.029812166467308998, -0.05991299822926521, -0.014691159129142761, -0.010364008136093616, 0.038238734006881714, 0.039337385445833206, -0.053560759872198105, 0.0009952333057299256, -0.005776675418019295, 0.04201957955956459, 0.01029577013105154, -0.018113866448402405, 0.06080789119005203, -0.03725810721516609, 0.039909083396196365, 0.041663724929094315, -0.02979016862809658, 0.00400394294410944, 0.03617766499519348, 0.04001064971089363, -0.03149355575442314, 0.07901010662317276, -0.007987851276993752, -0.001417701132595539, 0.016488850116729736, -0.01338888332247734, -0.0239724088460207, -0.012292762286961079, 0.008569508790969849, 0.03472885861992836, -0.054080020636320114, 0.005440380424261093, -0.033068541437387466, -0.062470365315675735, 0.0004963269457221031, -0.03891986608505249, -0.03651849552989006, 0.025071697309613228, 0.018607160076498985, -0.0054162126034498215, 0.01975511945784092, -0.045794710516929626, 0.029927678406238556, -0.0034046503715217113, 0.06188014894723892, 0.07633505016565323, 0.05526110529899597, 0.0007121259695850313, 0.0035524179693311453, -0.023127112537622452, -0.05491103604435921, 0.004543042276054621, 0.000027439602490630932, -0.02981829084455967, -0.054569464176893234, 0.026507049798965454, -0.007980159483850002, -0.01791827566921711, 0.04547959566116333, -0.0186564140021801, 0.0381777323782444, 0.010801191441714764, -0.05240148305892944, -0.059261735528707504, 0.021038653329014778, -0.014652867801487446, 0.0442194938659668, -0.024251926690340042, 0.012502492405474186, 0.03225220367312431, 0.04929354041814804, 0.035905033349990845, 0.022516800090670586, -0.011488511227071285, -0.010136834345757961, -0.013112698681652546, -0.021115196868777275, -0.02805081196129322, -0.04363333806395531, -0.017901873216032982, 0.011416681110858917, -0.05229242891073227, 0.01612185500562191, -0.004148439504206181, -0.044097963720560074, -0.013807659968733788, 0.02663133107125759, 0.02156219258904457, -0.01968238689005375, -0.016995921730995178, 0.00039514474337920547, 0.0020308427046984434, 0.05529886484146118, -0.016964079812169075, 0.06686202436685562, 0.02067619375884533, -0.0009830822236835957, 0.009706362150609493, 0.0017545624868944287, 0.03606340289115906, 0.038884587585926056, 0.003323181066662073, 0.02634395845234394, -0.02869435027241707, 0.0417514368891716, 0.025398854166269302, -0.03077095001935959, -0.019738206639885902, 0.015803931280970573, -0.021254850551486015, 0.028239931911230087, -0.0015262310625985265, -0.02460111305117607, -0.03633566200733185, 0.06690128892660141, -0.03394761309027672, -0.04455737769603729, -0.055901795625686646, 0.003167171962559223, 0.0295720137655735, -0.009017212316393852, -0.018315458670258522, -0.024061212316155434, 0.055238280445337296, -0.025463925674557686, -0.007965099066495895, -0.043007444590330124, -0.009033642709255219, 0.05495596304535866, -0.042314562946558, -0.013606566935777664, -0.0027667612303048372, 0.011589905247092247, -0.05051063373684883, 0.06027771532535553, -0.02043130248785019, 0.006926573812961578, 0.01946789212524891, -0.01838517002761364, 0.03928769379854202, -0.013822995126247406, 0.003583564655855298, 0.04323965683579445, -0.007240182254463434, -0.009910465218126774, 0.055260349065065384, -0.06228175759315491, 0.04376468062400818, 0.08599389344453812, 0.013081926852464676, 0.019875621423125267, -0.013945026323199272, -0.011289454065263271, 0.03842373564839363, -0.02383165992796421, -0.003867506282404065, -0.03706900030374527, 0.005789448972791433, -0.010099697858095169, 0.007343511562794447, 0.008908438496291637, 0.019506361335515976, 0.07863268256187439, 0.0026317655574530363, 0.028328225016593933, 0.012410314753651619, 0.014374876394867897, 0.00930631160736084, 0.04795141890645027, 0.018050847575068474, 0.03630823642015457, 0.011115055531263351, 0.008572064340114594, 0.0010535435285419226, 0.01398712769150734, 0.007740276865661144, 0.015183373354375362, 0.0652683898806572, 0.01801944151520729, 0.013784864917397499, -0.029722101986408234, -0.012729288078844547, 0.05470019206404686, -0.0321626216173172, -0.0067423745058476925, 0.05057550221681595, 0.000905381515622139, -0.07327776402235031, 0.02410927414894104, -0.02421821653842926, 0.0041954610496759415, 0.038114141672849655, -0.03751293569803238, 0.013633301481604576, 0.03552139550447464, -0.028913212940096855, 0.013702553696930408, -0.03220392391085625, -0.0540393702685833, -0.09687674045562744, 0.038135841488838196, 0.02571256272494793, 0.00019637156219687313, 0.028167542070150375, -0.030743440613150597, -0.011011334136128426, 0.0048937126994132996, 0.017769910395145416, 0.02514827810227871, -0.022095225751399994, -0.0630931407213211, -0.008969886228442192, 0.002549568424001336, -0.02017018012702465, 0.029195860028266907, 0.006211603060364723, -0.04413397237658501, 0.002396099269390106, 0.011059841141104698, -0.02771562710404396, -0.007135402411222458, 0.0068595316261053085, 0.013035847805440426, 0.026714716106653214, -0.03623662143945694, 0.0602625235915184, 0.010697233490645885, -0.03725548833608627, -0.011924875900149345, -0.05250921845436096, -0.023022910580039024, -0.03178786486387253, 0.013768383301794529, 0.025627557188272476, 0.02658599242568016, 0.00927790254354477, 0.03256791830062866, -0.0036332039162516594, 0.02765967696905136, -0.07623007893562317, -0.05401447042822838, 0.00688847666606307, 0.00889168493449688, -0.0022252968046814203, 0.031852319836616516, 0.02588513493537903, 0.05719583481550217, 0.07016227394342422, -0.01697677932679653, -0.04783376678824425, -0.05142143368721008, -0.004148696083575487, -0.025171659886837006, 0.0026631474029272795, 0.03795793280005455, 0.02436544932425022, -0.006396526005119085, -0.0054223123006522655, 0.020224738866090775, 0.03917873650789261, -0.021854477003216743, -0.00021426848252303898, 0.016983525827527046, -0.02984783798456192, -0.0017467448487877846, 0.02381962724030018, 0.017254194244742393, -0.015080919489264488, 0.021315384656190872, -0.024362944066524506, 0.011786439456045628, 0.0020376311149448156, -0.007754804566502571, 0.002343373838812113, -0.030330000445246696, 0.019594576209783554, 0.020193755626678467, 0.004063121043145657, 0.036097727715969086, -0.06059384346008301, 0.026920007541775703, 0.020179901272058487, 0.025876861065626144, -0.00772497383877635, -0.012338517233729362, 0.02322034165263176, 0.0049428753554821014, -0.04414251819252968, 0.0421052947640419, 0.044404227286577225, -0.029504792764782906, 0.02188153751194477, -0.03727854788303375, -0.023310858756303787, 0.03351280838251114, 0.03256827965378761, 0.03174339234828949, 0.0035343619529157877, -0.03226437047123909, 0.022991150617599487, -0.06836729496717453, 0.003601028583943844, -0.03489883616566658, 0.05667975917458534, 0.024008385837078094, 0.031963903456926346, 0.007721283007413149, -0.0023466614075005054, 0.037904150784015656, 0.007168311160057783, -0.027337025851011276, 0.039262060075998306, 0.005356928333640099, 0.019042912870645523, 0.005899815354496241, -0.011710490100085735, 0.015675321221351624, -0.01722051575779915, 0.00311740068718791, -0.021022871136665344, -0.009556900709867477, -0.036411043256521225, 0.03000185452401638, -0.0018485956825315952, -0.018770476803183556, 0.00020231858070474118, -0.016805924475193024, 0.014062520116567612, -0.01199304312467575, 0.027319101616740227, 0.030221350491046906, 0.020989740267395973, 0.008733506314456463, -0.009506694972515106, 0.002018105471506715, 0.00005011571556678973, 0.05039892718195915, 0.0248409491032362, 0.015335275791585445, -0.04377169907093048, 0.015357558615505695, -0.013485720381140709, 0.025277642533183098, 0.02381652034819126, -0.0358232818543911, 0.01944015361368656, -0.021951308473944664, -0.02426176145672798, 0.019452529028058052, 0.0027247194666415453, -0.005771508440375328, -0.022188734263181686, 0.05515449121594429, 0.02586958557367325, -0.030318692326545715, 0.06332308053970337, 0.12087995558977127, 0.04050229862332344, -0.02838262915611267, -0.01334051787853241, 0.003808207344263792, -0.00951079186052084, -0.022940805181860924, 0.07191983610391617, -0.005911106709390879, 0.01952339895069599, 0.02801014669239521, 0.06094978749752045, -0.028795389458537102, -0.006773434113711119, 0.020255086943507195, 0.03436613827943802, 0.06131961569190025, -0.014814792200922966, -0.06063881888985634, -0.024111147969961166, 0.06663480401039124, -0.002674468094483018, 0.023243600502610207, -0.010639892891049385, -0.13436415791511536, 0.012905612587928772, 0.04226737469434738, 0.032979968935251236, -0.03579864278435707, -0.03815479949116707, -0.08303713798522949, -0.046039026230573654, 0.01222266722470522, -0.025441544130444527, 0.03838016837835312, -0.05116133764386177, 0.023904332891106606, -0.01173448096960783, 0.01891106367111206, -0.024982912465929985, 0.013935478404164314, -0.03752586618065834, 0.011508502066135406, -0.013752476312220097, -0.029930666089057922, -0.0188661590218544, 0.04430684074759483, 0.009403111413121223, 0.03523474559187889, -0.04150313884019852, -0.05526146665215492, 0.031400859355926514, 0.009962781332433224, -0.019807271659374237, -0.040522415190935135, -0.020294681191444397, 0.011735115200281143, 0.00810530036687851, 0.049639493227005005, 0.01823451742529869, -0.045098721981048584, -0.02013792097568512, 0.05221619829535484, -0.010981624945998192, -0.013502751477062702, -0.02539779245853424, 0.021549042314291, -0.007094336673617363, -0.0064056082628667355, 0.02909623645246029, 0.01620110124349594, -0.03284537419676781, 0.024789849296212196, -0.04732080549001694, 0.0094070415943861, -0.022925587370991707, -0.04038858413696289, -0.06885460764169693, -0.014123184606432915, -0.008474420756101608, 0.0101211192086339, 0.02464979514479637, 0.03368460759520531, -0.013318775221705437, 0.0016711140051484108, 0.0164888184517622, 0.0440567322075367, -0.02904152125120163, -0.02766348049044609, 0.018639184534549713, -0.012083414942026138, -0.0007198518724180758, 0.005577077157795429, 0.022202152758836746, -0.007227325811982155, 0.004841144196689129, -0.004454242996871471, -0.02906877174973488, 0.02969241887331009, -0.02962481789290905, -0.015116482973098755, -0.021466895937919617, -0.03920980542898178, 0.01702769100666046, 0.016801202669739723, 0.05365835502743721, 0.032944224774837494, -0.018962275236845016, -0.02310016192495823, 0.026397384703159332, 0.002713486086577177, -0.026585232466459274, -0.023448660969734192, 0.05418376624584198, -0.010435636155307293, -0.009116582572460175, -0.056315772235393524, -0.08545245975255966, 0.02974853292107582, -0.021434854716062546, 0.011462774127721786, -0.03278834745287895, 0.018757762387394905, 0.008898281492292881, 0.04588764160871506, -0.013430423103272915, 0.03369488939642906, -0.045432914048433304, -0.01650749146938324, -0.0218584556132555, 0.006943421438336372, 0.07831258326768875, 0.03476698324084282, -0.026338785886764526, 0.048210080713033676, 0.0026378887705504894, -0.030464420095086098, 0.02986397221684456, -0.0008873043116182089, -0.03202471509575844, -0.01096055656671524, -0.042985156178474426, 0.000328769936459139, 0.08106935769319534, -0.016631262376904488, -0.025574255734682083, 0.017430640757083893, -0.014707405120134354, 0.05938087776303291, 0.007324705831706524, -0.00004945452747051604, -0.031439464539289474, -0.018612751737236977, -0.047241706401109695, 0.0008108048350550234, -0.03343963623046875, -0.010542523115873337, 0.02823675610125065, -0.009881610982120037, -0.02048802748322487, 0.02503029815852642, 0.07566847652196884, 0.033438414335250854, -0.00016326351033058017, 0.01976591721177101, -0.006291183177381754, 0.08077961951494217, 0.008323648944497108, -0.005121072754263878, -0.012266028672456741, 0.05098634585738182, -0.03211212903261185, -0.02032644674181938, -0.03183310478925705, -0.01319137867540121, 0.04317913204431534, -0.017159484326839447, 0.047427672892808914, 0.027003899216651917, -0.0007353394175879657, -0.006752525921911001, -0.048463400453329086, -0.005686715245246887, -0.008455945178866386, 0.01439240574836731, 0.06412934511899948, -0.031940411776304245, -0.0071137151680886745, 0.01209996547549963, 0.01918180100619793, 0.01003949623554945, 0.03077705204486847, -0.028622429817914963, 0.009701231494545937, 0.017634570598602295, -0.017112109810113907, -0.04714854434132576, 0.04812829568982124, -0.017004767432808876, 0.02204206772148609, -0.05814092606306076, -0.05308600515127182, 0.04550691321492195, 0.02933417074382305, -0.023802150040864944, -0.023475369438529015, 0.007791031617671251, -0.03818966820836067, 0.02549455128610134, 0.02610509842634201, -0.04568053036928177, 0.02501722425222397, 0.021669022738933563, 0.029026716947555542, -0.04735473915934563, 0.0018008156912401319, 0.0020632229279726744, -0.03286903724074364, -0.026404475793242455, -0.059526775032281876, -0.040790051221847534, 0.026618728414177895, 0.010625471360981464, 0.0026686450000852346, 0.0261062104254961, -0.02998405136168003, -0.035060297697782516, -0.020008109509944916, 0.0008846332202665508, -0.003564346581697464, 0.06527440994977951, -0.01923198066651821, -0.0396793931722641, 0.0036649536341428757, -0.015885883942246437, 0.11651439964771271, 0.04798334836959839, 0.03182202950119972, -0.05282009392976761, -0.003726873779669404, 0.015589004382491112, -0.002559925429522991, -0.01627058908343315, -0.003959587775170803, -0.03005152940750122, -0.009018207900226116, 0.039100050926208496, 0.06226964667439461, 0.020156294107437134, 0.03832579031586647, 0.035581767559051514, -0.029153386130928993, 0.023045888170599937, 0.0034669656306505203, 0.025354212149977684, -0.025646869093179703, -0.03820129483938217, -0.027012549340724945, 0.019600259140133858, 0.04247938096523285, -0.0247498806566, -0.013627626933157444, 0.018009720370173454, -0.011450892314314842, 0.01801791600883007, -0.04459351301193237, 0.014508351683616638, 0.005923172924667597, 0.02137289009988308, 0.05425148457288742, -0.02871312014758587, 0.027927931398153305, 0.004663761705160141, -0.012877913191914558, 0.030192624777555466, -0.012697824276983738, -0.006750375032424927, -0.011192230507731438, 0.004863516893237829, -0.0366557240486145, -0.04568943753838539, -0.03684341162443161, 0.009119600988924503, 0.005864681676030159, -0.03568004071712494, -0.02160227857530117, 0.029996266588568687, -0.013983371667563915, -0.03581099212169647, -0.03609903156757355, 0.04280979558825493, 0.016224758699536324, 0.005152450874447823, -0.007757280021905899, 0.008453244343400002, 0.004671178758144379, 0.011733727529644966, 0.015878532081842422, 0.014309638179838657, -0.01841258630156517, -0.009388890117406845, -0.02368391864001751, 0.05231679230928421, 0.003590094158425927, -0.003904786892235279, 0.028847603127360344, -0.045067764818668365, -0.02908097766339779, -0.02944447658956051, 0.022839931771159172, 0.025676753371953964, -0.03448677435517311, -0.032807864248752594, 0.00005154862810741179, -0.008981295861303806, -0.022619500756263733, 0.0056064496748149395, 0.033397261053323746, -0.025062816217541695, -0.009783667512238026, 0.007506728637963533, -0.018930163234472275, 0.027864214032888412, 0.05430418998003006, 0.006377589888870716, -0.020214304327964783, 0.0775253176689148, -0.02469925582408905, -0.05506198853254318, -0.0022095604799687862, -0.012565769255161285, -0.050960198044776917, 0.016931653022766113, -0.025921111926436424, 0.07126834243535995, -0.010650986805558205, -0.01346996147185564, -0.027524059638381004, 0.031023187562823296, -0.007455640006810427, 0.052217934280633926, 0.027019815519452095, -0.03686433285474777, 0.05940306931734085, 0.014280116185545921, 0.0038294808473438025, -0.028970709070563316, -0.021202782168984413, -0.018268264830112457, -0.019832195714116096, -0.014106937684118748, -0.02244509942829609, -0.030695557594299316, 0.031795114278793335, -0.012546890415251255, -0.011594072915613651, -0.04148224741220474, -0.00850981567054987, -0.038354262709617615, 0.0024782666005194187, -0.0038294324185699224, -0.04267314076423645, 0.0022965718526393175, 0.009861691854894161, -0.02611437253654003, 0.012370514683425426, 0.05802428722381592, 0.017878230661153793, -0.031933534890413284, -0.017288196831941605, 0.02099747210741043, 0.019220206886529922, 0.039835959672927856, -0.024797771126031876, -0.0011974647641181946, 0.005389832891523838, -0.009007468819618225, -0.01101341936737299, -0.013207209296524525, -0.0037360636051744223, 0.045581985265016556, -0.02499355748295784, -0.03485048562288284, -0.045026250183582306, 0.04561591520905495, -0.02389414794743061, -0.02667280100286007, -0.02522887848317623, 0.03678523004055023, -0.012388449162244797, 0.014187546446919441, -0.016661817207932472, 0.002715871436521411, 0.009092358872294426, 0.027948100119829178, 0.042470626533031464, 0.015343575738370419, -0.024123353883624077, 0.01624440774321556, -0.036139972507953644, -0.028343796730041504, 0.0025522583164274693, -0.019530821591615677, 0.022605029866099358, 0.034410685300827026, -0.02964426577091217, 0.01537119597196579, 0.00006713528273394331, 0.01991819217801094, -0.10647502541542053, -0.059487227350473404, 0.0226447731256485, -0.00033839757088571787, 0.0337010957300663, -0.06884454935789108, 0.0012794876238331199, -0.01249744277447462, -0.06313875317573547, -0.014474712312221527, 0.0008886351133696735, 0.04504789412021637, -0.03998564928770065, 0.019714314490556717, -0.036056578159332275, 0.00035730583476834, 0.021335015073418617, -0.006568795070052147, 0.05020209029316902, -0.0027231986168771982, 0.027445895597338676, -0.03795242682099342, -0.023953717201948166, -0.014402195811271667, -0.004851990845054388, -0.0512869618833065, 0.03532888740301132, -0.026299651712179184, -0.014514639973640442, 0.03852870687842369, -0.047424789518117905, 0.049999695271253586, 0.033402904868125916, 0.04701165109872818, 0.028804607689380646, 0.062463730573654175, 0.03247224539518356, -0.0021380523685365915, 0.0116566251963377, 0.01699281856417656, 0.03739164024591446, 0.014941477216780186, -0.01424373872578144, 0.02154594101011753, 0.03087918646633625, 0.003704369068145752, -0.007072254084050655, 0.021715233102440834, -0.015784060582518578, 0.020240185782313347, -0.02076917141675949, 0.023800576105713844, 0.013014137744903564, -0.045858629047870636, 0.022297458723187447, -0.06155109778046608, -0.019442759454250336, 0.00957380048930645, 0.025252701714634895, -0.002889865543693304, -0.0013928208500146866, -0.021538544446229935, -0.05508774146437645, -0.0075126648880541325, 0.03220265731215477, -0.028062116354703903, -0.008557065390050411, -0.03326891362667084, 0.007141398265957832, -0.0025933547876775265, -0.00216451077722013, -0.003028878942131996, -0.028730029240250587, 0.053364239633083344, -0.047218579798936844, 0.022245382890105247, 0.07156576216220856, 0.0036012937780469656, 0.033110495656728745, -0.05795406177639961, 0.04248272255063057, 0.037582654505968094, 0.03902454301714897, 0.0059924740344285965, -0.04778965935111046, -0.03261757642030716, 0.0010578245855867863, 0.07824493944644928, 0.012991719879209995, 0.018666068091988564, -0.038690708577632904, 0.008858089335262775, 0.0037665050476789474, -0.020091479644179344, 0.033861249685287476, 0.005594817455857992, -0.05744084715843201, -0.018048401921987534, -0.024646848440170288, -0.013317711651325226, -0.006235317327082157, -0.0038551336620002985, 0.0060891201719641685, -0.012208486907184124, -0.0033752298913896084, 0.0012122816406190395, -0.0006784847937524319, 0.010400575585663319, -0.03307351842522621, 0.04095274209976196, 0.010417000390589237, 0.006156325805932283, 0.03593030571937561, 0.026018470525741577, -0.0513128824532032, 0.06855832040309906, -0.03990890458226204, 0.013503900729119778, -0.01040225476026535, 0.024914171546697617, -0.015308717265725136, -0.058077048510313034, 0.03555447235703468, 0.013271108269691467, -0.049808163195848465, 0.028698420152068138, 0.004824555478990078, -0.02144799567759037, 0.026555759832262993, -0.026415707543492317, -0.0012734890915453434, 0.012869966216385365, -0.008779446594417095, 0.020363494753837585, -0.0017561258282512426, 0.018810871988534927, 0.013031595386564732, 0.012549404054880142, 0.029474901035428047, 0.002619040198624134, 0.004997252486646175, -0.016150103881955147, 0.035641707479953766, -0.01045205257833004, -0.014220109209418297, 0.019747726619243622, 0.008150785230100155, -0.0066611748188734055, 0.0011103510623797774, 0.0033124256879091263, -0.024619974195957184, -0.043675102293491364, -0.008653221651911736, -0.030286381021142006, -0.02718544937670231, -0.02928997203707695, -0.004097664728760719, -0.017881838604807854, 0.04233953356742859, 0.018649112433195114, 0.02473302371799946, 0.018772132694721222, -0.018717840313911438, 0.030082136392593384, 0.00727500207722187, -0.009712706319987774, -0.023388635367155075, 0.013854201883077621, -0.014317728579044342, -0.008732154034078121, -0.0050663393922150135, -0.027695436030626297, 0.036368973553180695, 0.03866472467780113, 0.029726261273026466, -0.056340910494327545, -0.016756704077124596, 0.0032964448910206556, 0.015463648363947868, -0.04040749743580818, -0.044664788991212845, -0.025627318769693375, -0.04110967740416527, 0.005859697703272104, -0.04416732117533684 ]
<p>I am interested in fitting a Poisson/negative binomial distribution to estimate the number of times a phenomenon happens within a period, let's just say 10 years. I can count the events from monthly reports, but unfortunately, there are reports missing. So for one sample, I might have 120 observational slots, but for some others I might have 30. The event can happen if it is not observed. </p> <p>The missing slots pattern is random (ie not correlated between samples), and it can result in anything from a nearly complete observational record to a very decimated one.</p> <p>How can I cope with this?</p>
74,065
[ -0.013638680800795555, -0.037030573934316635, -0.008974231779575348, 0.0050407047383487225, 0.049365218728780746, -0.007105051539838314, 0.048453643918037415, -0.0025926283560693264, 0.032704394310712814, -0.014759985730051994, 0.017447397112846375, 0.06628534197807312, 0.006337950937449932, -0.006166377104818821, 0.01283455640077591, -0.012076213955879211, -0.02433859556913376, -0.0062043736688792706, 0.009320257231593132, -0.03886062651872635, -0.007098184898495674, 0.014506622217595577, 0.030311696231365204, 0.0203530453145504, -0.0060702902264893055, 0.017483137547969818, 0.03307421877980232, -0.01695951074361801, -0.006691342685371637, 0.0398058220744133, -0.05735829845070839, -0.02415364421904087, 0.0055940235033631325, 0.0633058026432991, -0.000715223082806915, -0.006313004996627569, -0.020496126264333725, -0.04557524621486664, -0.012392559088766575, 0.03392687067389488, -0.05908522382378578, -0.019639788195490837, -0.007800769060850143, 0.02408519759774208, -0.028548920527100563, 0.003733498277142644, 0.005740548949688673, -0.045531805604696274, 0.03694650158286095, -0.05614698305726051, 0.03203197941184044, -0.004513127729296684, 0.06064150854945183, 0.009197898209095001, -0.033823225647211075, -0.027535568922758102, 0.06314344704151154, 0.04700833559036255, -0.0023405556567013264, -0.042092882096767426, -0.003418135456740856, -0.028724031522870064, -0.003589008003473282, -0.024163587018847466, -0.021474473178386688, 0.0340907983481884, -0.03686809539794922, -0.04657996818423271, 0.03448756784200668, -0.03848952054977417, 0.05208950862288475, -0.0015680243959650397, 0.051180168986320496, -0.009620105847716331, 0.013569779694080353, -0.06785833090543747, 0.004402629099786282, 0.03453110158443451, 0.03151419013738632, 0.028194142505526543, -0.009536338038742542, 0.0019691267516463995, 0.044010087847709656, 0.03298404440283775, 0.02343953400850296, -0.03268802911043167, 0.07116501778364182, -0.041780173778533936, 0.011903509497642517, -0.008421266451478004, -0.03166217356920242, -0.006850271951407194, 0.06003687158226967, 0.021382981911301613, -0.04808779060840607, 0.02420119382441044, -0.034011393785476685, 0.02884092926979065, 0.007955476641654968, 0.004961589351296425, 0.014216127805411816, -0.012370242737233639, 0.01929033175110817, 0.100654736161232, -0.043114177882671356, -0.011605069041252136, -0.001825390849262476, 0.00044352060649544, -0.011798450723290443, -0.012180137448012829, -0.012187776155769825, 0.002746732672676444, 0.04165736958384514, -0.012828314676880836, 0.02881898544728756, 0.0363791398704052, -0.014367532916367054, -0.024764787405729294, 0.008953310549259186, 0.07789737731218338, 0.010743151418864727, -0.0271000973880291, 0.030255796387791634, -0.05464649945497513, -0.058746807277202606, 0.004314063582569361, 0.02792269177734852, -0.018214542418718338, -0.04718565568327904, 0.05169117450714111, 0.006727217696607113, -0.027872199192643166, 0.07276678085327148, -0.035564009100198746, 0.06158396601676941, 0.02540496177971363, -0.07182621955871582, -0.057877760380506516, 0.009365099482238293, -0.01879693567752838, -0.013853776268661022, -0.04848097637295723, 0.02827504277229309, 0.048790305852890015, 0.05021357908844948, 0.03239525854587555, -0.021552326157689095, 0.008123458363115788, 0.03581305965781212, 0.004906800575554371, -0.013470386154949665, 0.031775183975696564, -0.00804551038891077, 0.004343245178461075, -0.035756535828113556, -0.08176933228969574, 0.05383763089776039, 0.009959114715456963, 0.0015808527823537588, -0.02291511930525303, 0.05040482431650162, 0.041605111211538315, -0.02152378484606743, -0.01934603601694107, 0.04631552845239639, -0.04422491416335106, 0.0862608402967453, 0.0014508588938042521, -0.01740512065589428, -0.0034153484739363194, 0.03068891353905201, 0.02442714385688305, 0.03495284542441368, 0.0500161238014698, 0.04590599238872528, -0.03098210319876671, 0.012875936925411224, -0.007714141625910997, 0.002570242155343294, 0.026710273697972298, -0.008679322898387909, -0.03113148920238018, -0.007543644867837429, -0.000012321806025283877, 0.04358917847275734, 0.020168887451291084, 0.008742095902562141, -0.000048834790504770353, 0.05350847542285919, -0.06039799377322197, -0.030659520998597145, -0.062112610787153244, -0.004862568806856871, 0.00045475043589249253, 0.003212643787264824, 0.06297612935304642, -0.007393201347440481, 0.012092657387256622, -0.022332046180963516, -0.020260537043213844, -0.009392539039254189, -0.039766427129507065, 0.033232178539037704, -0.062472011893987656, -0.02745046839118004, 0.03348616138100624, 0.054726291447877884, 0.00011045030259992927, 0.06564538180828094, -0.06051335856318474, -0.01892835646867752, -0.05101065710186958, -0.06777040660381317, 0.009858889505267143, -0.009838923811912537, -0.009352101944386959, 0.028629859909415245, -0.016484875231981277, -0.01841537095606327, 0.026541879400610924, -0.034730616956949234, 0.04431866481900215, 0.05564345791935921, 0.015984462574124336, -0.005015810951590538, 0.02438577264547348, 0.028508152812719345, -0.012869151309132576, -0.04312979429960251, -0.022578170523047447, -0.06088137626647949, 0.018013861030340195, 0.02930353954434395, -0.022546924650669098, -0.03474896773695946, 0.031712185591459274, 0.06682601571083069, -0.0067912074737250805, 0.018760155886411667, 0.03215981647372246, -0.018826736137270927, 0.013127586804330349, 0.012019029818475246, 0.009724541567265987, 0.025044577196240425, 0.007536600809544325, 0.05660087615251541, -0.017295800149440765, -0.00837875995784998, 0.011941522359848022, -0.017961405217647552, 0.03863966092467308, 0.00943221990019083, 0.010731295682489872, -0.018953610211610794, -0.020459512248635292, 0.06683342903852463, -0.021512266248464584, 0.004171222914010286, 0.010719416663050652, -0.011492929421365261, 0.01666567660868168, 0.014347441494464874, -0.011439934372901917, 0.00943165086209774, 0.038736362010240555, -0.0375814214348793, -0.02623611129820347, -0.0014811733271926641, -0.02033090591430664, 0.01133872289210558, -0.02798192948102951, -0.051965292543172836, -0.056587159633636475, 0.02125314064323902, 0.03317020460963249, 0.04388225078582764, 0.018641984090209007, 0.015160558745265007, -0.026801174506545067, -0.014690082520246506, 0.012638024054467678, 0.022981537505984306, 0.01909567415714264, -0.026266058906912804, -0.00038313830737024546, 0.031943053007125854, -0.012533256784081459, 0.012996598146855831, -0.005635750945657492, -0.028461778536438942, 0.013618633151054382, -0.013525118120014668, -0.03817722946405411, -0.005653547588735819, -0.0028303470462560654, -0.027963118627667427, -0.04823775589466095, -0.01000296976417303, 0.05746539309620857, 0.01401807926595211, -0.030727451667189598, -0.005499162245541811, -0.057981014251708984, -0.01258300431072712, -0.06689879298210144, -0.031047848984599113, 0.02788158319890499, -0.029955372214317322, -0.03075828216969967, 0.014058318920433521, 0.0004888433613814414, 0.03600284829735756, -0.03878858685493469, -0.0785951092839241, -0.02334033139050007, -0.030562976375222206, 0.030515117570757866, 0.008222168311476707, 0.027415696531534195, 0.0506022609770298, 0.03531082347035408, -0.008245226927101612, -0.00015777423686813563, -0.0004495039756875485, -0.011875925585627556, -0.015679018571972847, 0.04268830269575119, 0.01881839521229267, 0.03976055234670639, 0.010341373272240162, -0.000476423476357013, 0.008503595367074013, 0.02933441661298275, 0.03379124402999878, -0.013689039275050163, 0.0040876371785998344, 0.004188433289527893, 0.0018457272090017796, 0.02084289863705635, -0.002293269382789731, -0.04250963032245636, 0.010062295012176037, -0.04274655506014824, -0.008612772449851036, 0.04689396917819977, -0.04007315635681152, -0.023195700719952583, -0.03944011405110359, 0.019192878156900406, -0.006636792793869972, 0.011103127151727676, -0.013752357102930546, -0.02714882604777813, -0.02705538459122181, 0.017575176432728767, 0.05221778526902199, -0.005861461162567139, -0.027338366955518723, 0.0512322299182415, 0.02087104693055153, 0.00032507546711713076, -0.008601857349276543, -0.023138416931033134, -0.007789124269038439, 0.01751398667693138, -0.014714797958731651, -0.010591338388621807, 0.030027294531464577, 0.04998726397752762, 0.04033342003822327, -0.023173566907644272, -0.0445222482085228, 0.012740680947899818, -0.044223472476005554, -0.006796266883611679, -0.015946857631206512, 0.05029531195759773, -0.01929536648094654, -0.028740257024765015, 0.01567932404577732, 0.008408645167946815, 0.008467514999210835, 0.02826300635933876, -0.0562078021466732, 0.02686302550137043, -0.021324288100004196, -0.008350006304681301, -0.04432220011949539, 0.02792440913617611, 0.05887013301253319, 0.0011795657919719815, 0.02413330413401127, 0.006091179791837931, 0.029995165765285492, -0.027252331376075745, 0.0050363242626190186, -0.01171966828405857, 0.009155455976724625, -0.0038872254081070423, -0.016957882791757584, 0.0225178562104702, 0.0171097069978714, 0.05432262644171715, 0.02980971708893776, 0.026540709659457207, -0.03527715057134628, -0.031381215900182724, 0.02644280530512333, -0.02011124975979328, 0.01931670494377613, 0.02113799937069416, 0.029071448370814323, -0.04651171341538429, 0.010998545214533806, -0.016049478203058243, 0.01590653695166111, 0.04472764953970909, 0.040042389184236526, -0.007511341478675604, -0.031992752104997635, 0.003910680767148733, 0.005541647784411907, 0.016674473881721497, 0.025620680302381516, 0.030773278325796127, 0.0508662611246109, 0.008751309476792812, -0.06810177862644196, 0.00030547394999302924, 0.035182468593120575, 0.008048039861023426, 0.04211166501045227, -0.01716582477092743, 0.01465004961937666, -0.006546332035213709, 0.016126582399010658, -0.011928020976483822, 0.02367919497191906, -0.021982243284583092, 0.018170185387134552, 0.03634721413254738, -0.005816392134875059, -0.04624997451901436, -0.004721451550722122, 0.017026377841830254, 0.047609321773052216, -0.009317670948803425, -0.017745357006788254, 0.06193115934729576, 0.018687335774302483, 0.018206503242254257, 0.026611177250742912, -0.0025782340671867132, -0.09875699877738953, -0.004294890910387039, 0.06108473986387253, 0.03592159226536751, -0.018570933490991592, -0.03501954302191734, -0.05923010781407356, -0.00013554611359722912, 0.029865672811865807, -0.018544020131230354, -0.005954024847596884, -0.007775109726935625, 0.01255534216761589, -0.014297811314463615, -0.05220932513475418, -0.02543479949235916, 0.03201044723391533, -0.03229286149144173, 0.05828273668885231, -0.03850354254245758, -0.0227371696382761, -0.03367682173848152, 0.051283031702041626, 0.015561514534056187, 0.08871544897556305, 0.0030884358566254377, 0.006756145041435957, 0.005517094396054745, 0.0045788181014359, 0.013110212050378323, -0.05439681559801102, -0.01767641305923462, -0.007905310019850731, 0.019476188346743584, 0.027750713750720024, -0.0017959920223802328, -0.010219995863735676, -0.016313424333930016, -0.0014662803150713444, -0.030100280418992043, -0.007499889936298132, -0.04074528440833092, 0.023267850279808044, 0.01672803983092308, 0.02036370150744915, 0.06587962061166763, 0.05454636365175247, 0.0034069507382810116, 0.02352193184196949, -0.047258272767066956, -0.0027883436996489763, -0.01742657460272312, -0.0019813713151961565, -0.0655074194073677, 0.017109723761677742, -0.01885324716567993, 0.031242571771144867, -0.01747984066605568, -0.0013977522030472755, 0.017468957230448723, 0.000854385260026902, 0.02709886245429516, 0.041492193937301636, 0.004400831181555986, 0.009109104983508587, -0.0027263087686151266, 0.01959974505007267, -0.003756812075152993, -0.024148929864168167, 0.01290261372923851, 0.008325569331645966, -0.026987306773662567, 0.016553036868572235, -0.05637240409851074, -0.015355530194938183, -0.0536322146654129, -0.009932901710271835, 0.03774358704686165, -0.00452002789825201, 0.032169491052627563, -0.027678124606609344, 0.024544836953282356, -0.0001713837991701439, -0.014431734569370747, -0.018987685441970825, -0.0077537596225738525, -0.015509058721363544, 0.046602241694927216, -0.07796341925859451, 0.029890544712543488, -0.020688049495220184, 0.000057246932556154206, -0.08899415284395218, -0.06954550743103027, 0.053659792989492416, 0.039343684911727905, -0.038856275379657745, -0.028987033292651176, 0.0016227825544774532, 0.015956571325659752, 0.0008031646138988435, -0.013652447611093521, 0.03996117413043976, -0.03338300809264183, -0.023583171889185905, -0.017386121675372124, 0.009074801579117775, 0.07708283513784409, -0.005088362377136946, -0.027121638879179955, 0.047044072300195694, -0.041191987693309784, -0.04554564878344536, -0.006137541029602289, 0.001993706915527582, -0.029628721997141838, -0.020737800747156143, -0.02114788442850113, 0.007707570679485798, 0.013630718924105167, -0.07025720179080963, -0.014259818010032177, 0.01803077943623066, 0.029423411935567856, 0.03330838680267334, -0.04752415046095848, 0.031696170568466187, -0.02824474684894085, -0.003192306961864233, -0.0317801907658577, -0.013863280415534973, 0.014776774682104588, 0.0034256393555551767, 0.023316528648138046, 0.011152904480695724, -0.01304914616048336, 0.036279305815696716, 0.01816587895154953, 0.0022277103271335363, -0.00972664076834917, 0.002888602437451482, 0.0021396521478891373, 0.045407794415950775, 0.011136947199702263, -0.0020145224407315254, 0.01418657973408699, 0.01457887515425682, -0.04986371472477913, -0.055075518786907196, -0.04031927138566971, -0.00864496361464262, 0.04584188759326935, -0.013623924925923347, 0.04117242619395256, 0.013793230056762695, -0.011645030230283737, 0.011560609564185143, -0.022485556080937386, 0.01645650714635849, 0.011838873848319054, 0.007691041100770235, 0.03583166003227234, 0.015123645775020123, 0.03260718658566475, 0.01769941672682762, 0.011192509904503822, 0.013747488148510456, 0.05734226852655411, -0.01616562344133854, 0.03078528121113777, 0.014021849259734154, -0.015007371082901955, -0.037132684141397476, -0.004460022784769535, -0.057503532618284225, 0.02095898799598217, -0.02979099191725254, -0.01740245148539543, 0.031289055943489075, 0.03360398858785629, 0.00441016023978591, -0.010093657299876213, -0.05253652483224869, -0.0486891008913517, 0.016052136197686195, 0.031249213963747025, 0.01973191648721695, 0.058666277676820755, 0.02195323258638382, 0.029126783832907677, 0.019352320581674576, 0.018686043098568916, -0.020187627524137497, -0.058467380702495575, -0.02165190316736698, -0.023255910724401474, -0.03529513627290726, 0.05616024509072304, 0.017268309369683266, 0.008413795381784439, 0.010514595545828342, 0.002803368726745248, 0.004208240192383528, 0.006862173788249493, 0.05104552209377289, -0.038924846798181534, 0.04748924821615219, 0.0442163459956646, -0.0010488382540643215, -0.02284836769104004, 0.02553369663655758, 0.11898992955684662, 0.08316259831190109, 0.04840356856584549, -0.07090503722429276, -0.011551899835467339, 0.031577467918395996, 0.00398537190631032, -0.01147108431905508, 0.037532877177000046, 0.010204494930803776, -0.027238154783844948, 0.05517500266432762, 0.031654104590415955, 0.0026087630540132523, 0.011985388584434986, 0.0852808728814125, -0.03485057130455971, -0.010890799574553967, -0.019217051565647125, 0.001271831220947206, 0.026812313124537468, 0.0027563669718801975, -0.05108777433633804, 0.050699636340141296, 0.0019382255850359797, -0.01946304365992546, -0.02943478152155876, 0.0020348099060356617, -0.026149816811084747, 0.005474302917718887, -0.011570555157959461, 0.027201298624277115, 0.04247110337018967, 0.019929522648453712, 0.005539530888199806, -0.01942879520356655, 0.010106283240020275, -0.010682624764740467, 0.02274535410106182, 0.009699074551463127, -0.0002122197620337829, 0.0007855400326661766, 0.007620214484632015, -0.005555986892431974, -0.03933195769786835, -0.014650415629148483, -0.03374255448579788, 0.05907260254025459, -0.027946121990680695, 0.022368963807821274, -0.018196184188127518, -0.029255084693431854, -0.00860594492405653, -0.02535688504576683, -0.035039447247982025, 0.011556649580597878, 0.027088327333331108, -0.043555110692977905, -0.026348179206252098, 0.005789848044514656, 0.010753460228443146, 0.003884217469021678, 0.03297324478626251, 0.06133602559566498, 0.0016952683217823505, -0.020975345745682716, -0.030444761738181114, 0.041110750287771225, -0.007601248100399971, 0.005121584516018629, 0.005049092695116997, -0.055658165365457535, -0.019128110259771347, 0.006691626738756895, 0.0062883938662707806, -0.003990908619016409, 0.04172142222523689, -0.023790419101715088, -0.01764397695660591, 0.009555496275424957, -0.023910189047455788, -0.0017139846459031105, -0.011809764429926872, -0.009584816172719002, -0.03258959576487541, -0.0060221971943974495, -0.0069909305311739445, 0.05062010884284973, -0.007858891040086746, 0.014672485180199146, 0.012282835319638252, 0.07864143699407578, 0.02241678349673748, -0.04048314690589905, -0.02226943150162697, -0.04461831599473953, -0.039296604692935944, -0.004741304088383913, -0.021427052095532417, 0.0382305383682251, 0.004816222470253706, 0.016484636813402176, 0.0277694184333086, 0.007545143365859985, -0.031691569834947586, 0.013954724185168743, 0.0042389752343297005, -0.07792409509420395, -0.015346990898251534, -0.03376568853855133, -0.01357933972030878, -0.01360698975622654, -0.028196657076478004, -0.010159045457839966, -0.01120674517005682, 0.04600086063146591, -0.002427765866741538, -0.06740380823612213, 0.034568142145872116, 0.013733658008277416, -0.0017402633093297482, -0.004030655138194561, 0.020877784118056297, -0.0684293583035469, 0.0007102907402440906, -0.00047579166130162776, -0.03372384235262871, -0.014072936959564686, 0.00942910648882389, -0.0207610372453928, -0.003612466622143984, 0.03129034861922264, 0.014852860011160374, 0.01973014324903488, 0.029590308666229248, 0.007280981633812189, -0.009449504315853119, 0.050095997750759125, -0.03971186652779579, -0.02256566286087036, 0.01730434224009514, -0.05155792459845543, -0.032775502651929855, 0.06963648647069931, 0.0037219272926449776, 0.03297741338610649, 0.006002156995236874, -0.008776777423918247, -0.027998555451631546, 0.022745899856090546, -0.03916404768824577, -0.03573627769947052, -0.03050837107002735, 0.04325404390692711, 0.008413688279688358, -0.0016674696234986186, -0.010518934577703476, 0.004872129298746586, -0.012384842149913311, -0.014632416889071465, 0.06434374302625656, 0.031112592667341232, -0.0031500300392508507, 0.00966243352741003, 0.008682859130203724, 0.029110053554177284, 0.002285947557538748, 0.01507639791816473, -0.007911985740065575, 0.04676380008459091, -0.029763244092464447, 0.030581695958971977, -0.01261894404888153, 0.018914131447672844, -0.08223693817853928, -0.03212062641978264, 0.004207957535982132, -0.0030896535608917475, 0.012013017199933529, -0.031217655166983604, 0.0007345512858591974, 0.02647513896226883, 0.018286321312189102, 0.022713899612426758, -0.019638607278466225, 0.008965015411376953, -0.03371430188417435, 0.015856385231018066, -0.02733519859611988, -0.019242186099290848, 0.047736525535583496, 0.008671519346535206, 0.015211101621389389, 0.04180213063955307, 0.008484785445034504, -0.05765966325998306, -0.035655632615089417, -0.016880786046385765, 0.022456565871834755, -0.06627658009529114, 0.042053669691085815, -0.03777346387505531, -0.012797140516340733, 0.030481113120913506, -0.03599471226334572, 0.0050866068340837955, 0.0010491249850019813, 0.03129863739013672, -0.041085969656705856, 0.07069261372089386, 0.03715857118368149, -0.013954907655715942, 0.01470044907182455, -0.021883556619286537, 0.020008735358715057, 0.01831578090786934, -0.04717433080077171, 0.036588482558727264, 0.030976427718997, -0.0032120675314217806, -0.0037072503473609686, 0.002166151534765959, 0.023636724799871445, 0.015758246183395386, 0.024533472955226898, 0.013923275284469128, 0.02856598235666752, 0.007716307882219553, 0.002331431955099106, -0.038087982684373856, 0.0225237850099802, 0.04987535998225212, 0.05242164433002472, -0.03103340044617653, 0.007692668121308088, -0.03976554051041603, -0.04924079403281212, -0.0018784217536449432, 0.0032826035749167204, -0.01986118033528328, -0.04763897880911827, 0.0038262514863163233, 0.019904043525457382, 0.026841988787055016, -0.017554519698023796, -0.02224711887538433, -0.049153946340084076, 0.03223103657364845, -0.0190614964812994, -0.017117831856012344, 0.021693356335163116, -0.007993745617568493, 0.023866675794124603, -0.0760638564825058, 0.03710365295410156, -0.025815509259700775, -0.016916360706090927, -0.01622011698782444, -0.03372950851917267, -0.024107474833726883, 0.018329594284296036, 0.03922601416707039, -0.053887028247117996, -0.009665840305387974, -0.009015532210469246, 0.017526527866721153, 0.026464978232979774, -0.05093221366405487, 0.03880862146615982, -0.039460573345422745, -0.03361076861619949, 0.006718811579048634, -0.030498571693897247, -0.003826346481218934, -0.02095596119761467, -0.00011519138206494972, 0.0048326049000024796, 0.031232215464115143, 0.026727458462119102, -0.02449606917798519, 0.035272933542728424, 0.02516348846256733, 0.0013081012293696404, 0.023345664143562317, 0.034926898777484894, 0.026568157598376274, 0.021211199462413788, 0.014828608371317387, -0.08491282165050507, 0.03390374407172203, -0.03472421318292618, -0.019373983144760132, 0.02699187397956848, 0.002235336694866419, -0.011622077785432339, -0.07074786722660065, -0.0059067304246127605, 0.020300494506955147, -0.01770130731165409, 0.0177751611918211, 0.045381590723991394, -0.011350239627063274, 0.01500625442713499, -0.013200893998146057, 0.007752904202789068, 0.022334201261401176, 0.010918909683823586, -0.010256108827888966, 0.030912915244698524, 0.0205963384360075, -0.02620747685432434, 0.027462860569357872, 0.022320954129099846, 0.014996957965195179, 0.016429318115115166, 0.001990827266126871, 0.04544232040643692, -0.020006883889436722, -0.014748947694897652, 0.02099839225411415, -0.0060889809392392635, 0.003963193856179714, 0.009672613814473152, 0.006752559915184975, 0.035258859395980835, 0.0020374839659780264, 0.025438405573368073, -0.04616902396082878, -0.016627075150609016, -0.004052686970680952, 0.0018882699077948928, -0.0223211869597435, 0.01655123569071293, 0.0006592418649233878, 0.028849471360445023, -0.00487625552341342, 0.008714553900063038, 0.05631880834698677, -0.06520043313503265, 0.0022074158769100904, -0.018764672800898552, 0.006125529762357473, -0.0065448349341750145, -0.015603738836944103, -0.011273219250142574, -0.04379837587475777, -0.004688146058470011, 0.02095297910273075, -0.014130046591162682, -0.01996202953159809, -0.030205611139535904, -0.026421869173645973, 0.0145005714148283, -0.06410709768533707, -0.031540267169475555, -0.07692735642194748, -0.0020997703541070223, -0.028880536556243896, -0.020830854773521423 ]
<p>I am using the <code>flexmix</code> package to estimate latent class multinomial logit models in R. In choice theory, there can be variables associated with the alternative (generic) or that vary with the agent (alternative-specific).</p> <p>The <code>nnet</code> package that underlies <code>FLXMRmultinom</code> can't accommodate generic variables. So far, I haven't seen that the <code>FLXMRcondlogit</code> can handle alternative-specific ones.</p> <p>The most flexible package for MNL models is <code>mlogit</code>. Has anyone seen an implementation of this for <code>flexmix</code>?</p>
36,709
[ -0.033756788820028305, -0.019250568002462387, 0.029361575841903687, 0.024496879428625107, -0.00037466658977791667, 0.023292439058423042, -0.026524830609560013, -0.024258041754364967, 0.041736356914043427, -0.029114417731761932, 0.03226612135767937, 0.04020567610859871, 0.09307605028152466, 0.048899587243795395, 0.020262615755200386, -0.019797509536147118, 0.0003938751178793609, -0.030627448111772537, -0.0012655596947297454, -0.04137144237756729, -0.008367291651666164, 0.03369106724858284, -0.017421768978238106, -0.02831176668405533, 0.011309478431940079, 0.033765725791454315, -0.03918180614709854, -0.018805736675858498, 0.013210184872150421, 0.051255933940410614, -0.04567868262529373, 0.0028870736714452505, -0.04085688292980194, 0.016896571964025497, -0.001253332826308906, 0.039287105202674866, -0.051452893763780594, -0.023985490202903748, 0.00719221169129014, -0.0007854807772673666, -0.03004343807697296, -0.020495407283306122, -0.009672186337411404, 0.017282679677009583, -0.02279704064130783, 0.029507936909794807, -0.012658441439270973, -0.0010223649442195892, 0.06502030044794083, 0.006357735022902489, 0.0635378360748291, 0.05974067375063896, -0.002046185778453946, 0.025208180770277977, -0.03952734172344208, -0.012892364524304867, 0.07489786297082901, 0.08099574595689774, -0.00029362866189330816, -0.041836488991975784, -0.02676539309322834, -0.02321610413491726, 0.04060426726937294, -0.07834970206022263, -0.031661055982112885, 0.0021865349262952805, 0.008517530746757984, 0.0005904711433686316, 0.03318489342927933, -0.03909755498170853, 0.0046221972443163395, 0.015382731333374977, 0.014725386165082455, 0.015315801836550236, 0.024446696043014526, -0.03669944778084755, -0.0033117225393652916, 0.01843482255935669, 0.05378321185708046, 0.021903790533542633, 0.006172437220811844, 0.032773666083812714, 0.004189542029052973, -0.01726800948381424, -0.044565312564373016, -0.03381384536623955, 0.02900795079767704, -0.006124521140009165, 0.0020647684577852488, -0.019187146797776222, -0.05487546697258949, 0.000928630877751857, 0.07333066314458847, 0.036307770758867264, -0.01452456321567297, 0.05547517538070679, -0.009313676506280899, 0.036146923899650574, 0.02398071624338627, -0.0012521359603852034, -0.03934207558631897, 0.0005409998702816665, -0.015214947052299976, 0.0344393327832222, -0.004253765102475882, 0.007571069523692131, -0.0217455942183733, -0.046168021857738495, -0.018698619678616524, -0.012326749972999096, -0.010846486315131187, 0.005354319699108601, 0.014647302217781544, -0.020147915929555893, 0.019701311364769936, -0.04540639743208885, -0.04849071428179741, -0.02804689109325409, 0.043650031089782715, 0.09271668642759323, 0.04994737356901169, -0.0150562459602952, 0.05280788615345955, -0.02730933390557766, -0.05354563519358635, -0.011262361891567707, 0.021352829411625862, -0.018699223175644875, -0.03303133323788643, 0.026603221893310547, -0.027997052296996117, -0.023944703862071037, 0.021065603941679, -0.02258479595184326, -0.0031298480462282896, -0.013102468103170395, -0.07038383930921555, -0.0736413523554802, 0.014213134534657001, 0.016447637230157852, 0.0033510541543364525, -0.038119636476039886, -0.03160993382334709, 0.010398712940514088, 0.06767482310533524, -0.027759958058595657, 0.05540075525641441, 0.05464833229780197, -0.03399248048663139, 0.019065512344241142, -0.017109235748648643, 0.013172931037843227, -0.023020584136247635, -0.0021234306041151285, 0.008198550902307034, -0.07657545059919357, 0.021136565133929253, 0.02004074677824974, -0.03258434683084488, 0.006224996875971556, 0.0631721094250679, 0.010624545626342297, -0.02738841250538826, 0.023293478414416313, 0.012227647006511688, 0.003295434406027198, 0.057066693902015686, 0.00497861485928297, 0.03428492695093155, 0.01863963156938553, -0.010744943283498287, 0.008972196839749813, -0.024791447445750237, 0.05641341954469681, 0.014386170543730259, 0.006746085826307535, 0.0009060836746357381, -0.014645174145698547, 0.01729678362607956, 0.026494383811950684, -0.037615515291690826, 0.0002981575671583414, 0.0004854613507632166, -0.06340038031339645, -0.02847992070019245, 0.013729553669691086, 0.018491247668862343, 0.0020201827865093946, 0.07666532695293427, -0.023554127663373947, -0.04182784631848335, -0.08688294142484665, 0.022485380992293358, -0.0034543427173048258, -0.016152383759617805, 0.021818581968545914, 0.01025513093918562, 0.0637488141655922, 0.02233155630528927, -0.02057311125099659, -0.03533776104450226, 0.01783432997763157, 0.030752750113606453, -0.02499282732605934, -0.0011730024125427008, 0.011312278918921947, 0.023120231926441193, -0.044815465807914734, -0.005134554114192724, 0.0036044574808329344, -0.053335633128881454, 0.013461422175168991, -0.06073702499270439, 0.04613874852657318, 0.007931903935968876, -0.02097288891673088, 0.005038590170443058, 0.017268557101488113, -0.029153352603316307, 0.04877115413546562, -0.025413356721401215, 0.03814851492643356, 0.07483337074518204, -0.01649792678654194, 0.030441448092460632, 0.018115226179361343, -0.030803993344306946, 0.027032770216464996, -0.03410368040204048, -0.008100371807813644, -0.03967389836907387, -0.0335354320704937, 0.0727018192410469, 0.018270062282681465, -0.011714370921254158, 0.011623354628682137, 0.043512169271707535, 0.003506074193865061, 0.01731758564710617, 0.017135299742221832, -0.0035092614125460386, -0.04362666234374046, 0.007982474751770496, 0.04429380223155022, 0.015491812489926815, 0.002496087923645973, 0.03929935768246651, 0.013445664197206497, 0.025416700169444084, -0.011099456809461117, 0.02206561528146267, 0.020746871829032898, 0.03056528978049755, -0.027851194143295288, 0.0001177405210910365, -0.02095845714211464, 0.038621846586465836, -0.022560536861419678, 0.02594982087612152, 0.04963172599673271, 0.024876734241843224, -0.012141323648393154, 0.046776559203863144, -0.021832626312971115, 0.04888946935534477, 0.03563467040657997, -0.02146076411008835, 0.008533425629138947, 0.016666924580931664, -0.035838782787323, -0.0034292899072170258, -0.012492046691477299, -0.005453210324048996, -0.015131451189517975, 0.03816952556371689, -0.005958891473710537, -0.02293272316455841, 0.015588469803333282, -0.028948310762643814, -0.01860816963016987, 0.004607453476637602, 0.0030138003639876842, 0.017236260697245598, 0.005274818278849125, -0.054228316992521286, -0.004032558295875788, -0.019362805411219597, -0.03466573357582092, 0.0019157985225319862, -0.014645048417150974, -0.009366622194647789, 0.06584455817937851, -0.016239117830991745, -0.0606674887239933, -0.008927361108362675, 0.019306626170873642, 0.00787416659295559, -0.0006519814487546682, -0.00025357844424434006, 0.012764624319970608, -0.011517106555402279, -0.05177268013358116, 0.024836549535393715, -0.07707589119672775, -0.023524058982729912, -0.03726089373230934, 0.0009745523566380143, -0.011119133792817593, -0.0096432501450181, 0.024851994588971138, 0.036882705986499786, -0.019585752859711647, 0.003996018785983324, -0.09211090207099915, -0.05227120965719223, 0.003815121715888381, -0.006248222663998604, 0.02657119743525982, -0.010666156187653542, 0.004421184305101633, 0.06353668868541718, 0.04890056699514389, -0.0429561510682106, -0.04822066053748131, -0.0064388299360871315, 0.01884014531970024, -0.019763179123401642, 0.00720276078209281, 0.018528178334236145, -0.014985830523073673, 0.014783710241317749, 0.0003784129803534597, 0.0069001647643744946, 0.03831327706575394, 0.04297871142625809, -0.014333206228911877, 0.02767295017838478, -0.022330770269036293, -0.017562445253133774, 0.05344147980213165, -0.00025479134637862444, 0.01354994811117649, 0.011653382331132889, -0.03809446841478348, -0.008039077743887901, -0.021152205765247345, -0.05671211704611778, 0.009412862360477448, 0.0016229251632466912, -0.0012905638432130218, -0.012835228815674782, 0.02197972685098648, -0.002439553616568446, -0.0577695406973362, -0.00319226598367095, 0.050515249371528625, 0.02940180152654648, -0.045023363083601, 0.025129184126853943, 0.07507754862308502, 0.019978273659944534, -0.025136182084679604, -0.01528140064328909, -0.0008864899282343686, 0.013492978177964687, -0.0009491117089055479, -0.03205014765262604, 0.012472767382860184, 0.015809258446097374, 0.02909231185913086, 0.02739246003329754, 0.022694047540426254, -0.013494273647665977, 0.03543351963162422, -0.061746302992105484, -0.012467999011278152, -0.01750129833817482, 0.030798321589827538, -0.00848525669425726, 0.0069351461715996265, -0.006170745473355055, 0.010475356131792068, 0.014639658853411674, 0.02392156422138214, -0.06582525372505188, 0.030429812148213387, 0.012292489409446716, 0.009181377477943897, 0.028763549402356148, -0.01722738705575466, 0.0557386688888073, 0.027187326923012733, -0.005321293603628874, 0.004455432295799255, -0.0033220001496374607, -0.020219668745994568, -0.014384168200194836, 0.011489322409033775, -0.04742933437228203, 0.030408497899770737, 0.0009583514765836298, 0.003914476837962866, -0.01857377216219902, -0.035647470504045486, 0.014248884283006191, -0.020341474562883377, -0.026452558115124702, -0.005812432151287794, 0.00618662778288126, -0.020011326298117638, 0.049351222813129425, 0.04202505946159363, 0.03916393965482712, -0.03444803133606911, 0.04352671653032303, 0.01766418106853962, 0.04913194105029106, 0.029298994690179825, -0.0036725173704326153, -0.026453662663698196, -0.05607270821928978, -0.02730376087129116, 0.0465654581785202, 0.037286657840013504, 0.007109403610229492, -0.041549280285835266, 0.06752102077007294, 0.04656084626913071, -0.023905014619231224, -0.025761771947145462, 0.03879518434405327, 0.016832105815410614, -0.026228195056319237, -0.00907880812883377, 0.004616949707269669, -0.004413217306137085, 0.019182531163096428, 0.028263643383979797, 0.0013285543536767364, 0.003183361142873764, -0.006402744445949793, 0.019179288297891617, 0.0025022211484611034, -0.023634010925889015, 0.011413772590458393, 0.012849786318838596, 0.03163951635360718, -0.011866586282849312, -0.011603419668972492, -0.0007863232749514282, 0.027926655486226082, 0.017273355275392532, 0.04918229952454567, 0.0008630446973256767, -0.09212972223758698, 0.017824340611696243, 0.040660254657268524, 0.04649932682514191, -0.029302207753062248, -0.020025093108415604, -0.01477493904531002, -0.0036077669356018305, -1.988250630802213e-7, -0.010297933593392372, 0.007698838599026203, 0.021308347582817078, -0.01257177535444498, -0.01446577813476324, -0.034618694335222244, -0.010112601332366467, -0.012274982407689095, -0.05473943427205086, 0.02512298710644245, -0.04580676555633545, -0.003760415129363537, -0.016342351213097572, 0.06107401102781296, -0.009457744657993317, 0.01950167492032051, -0.021012239158153534, -0.03776656463742256, 0.007946954108774662, -0.014390082098543644, -0.06275241822004318, -0.04789665341377258, 0.0037429891526699066, 0.01816949062049389, -0.009230214171111584, 0.054347533732652664, -0.023937731981277466, -0.007090018130838871, 0.025764331221580505, 0.019369639456272125, -0.00933561846613884, 0.00647249398753047, -0.0041381195187568665, 0.01367736142128706, 0.028401130810379982, 0.02736050821840763, 0.06009552255272865, 0.010241314768791199, 0.03196289762854576, 0.03367379307746887, -0.033583108335733414, 0.0008885764400474727, -0.015490361489355564, -0.031221609562635422, -0.03461481258273125, -0.04316682368516922, -0.007765594869852066, 0.05254446715116501, 0.030931906774640083, 0.030239438638091087, -0.027118081226944923, -0.03677228093147278, 0.004450136795639992, 0.015525094233453274, -0.0011549449991434813, -0.015442678704857826, 0.005814050789922476, 0.009364540688693523, 0.009925753809511662, 0.018843451514840126, 0.03835105895996094, -0.03709917888045311, -0.025715623050928116, 0.01903386041522026, -0.01646329089999199, -0.0038453093729913235, -0.022163867950439453, -0.051369618624448776, 0.006247506011277437, 0.01070910319685936, 0.015734057873487473, 0.058513835072517395, 0.03955557942390442, -0.03408002853393555, -0.06359542906284332, -0.030381634831428528, 0.007301647216081619, 0.0004766600613947958, -0.004483008291572332, -0.015879401937127113, 0.013978138566017151, -0.01223466731607914, -0.032316260039806366, -0.07902202755212784, -0.04552764445543289, -0.020214149728417397, -0.022374019026756287, -0.03199264779686928, -0.030772240832448006, -0.005103779025375843, -0.001690203556790948, -0.018057528883218765, 0.0006019729771651328, 0.043592315167188644, -0.007503371685743332, 0.011649388819932938, -0.045690447092056274, 0.04003326594829559, 0.045322731137275696, 0.026665350422263145, 0.020386096090078354, 0.027713920921087265, -0.0013665023725479841, -0.0032144843135029078, 0.00729799922555685, 0.018558897078037262, 0.00832614116370678, -0.029205741360783577, 0.003938657231628895, 0.02734888158738613, 0.014876814559102058, 0.004211687948554754, -0.012246801517903805, 0.045946646481752396, -0.056490182876586914, -0.024779584258794785, -0.06142236292362213, -0.0032913859467953444, 0.018448157235980034, 0.013533029705286026, -0.057229869067668915, 0.011505586095154285, -0.02451183833181858, -0.010333909653127193, 0.03409404307603836, -0.039198629558086395, -0.014109497889876366, 0.018995022401213646, 0.07580628246068954, 0.024333715438842773, 0.025892196223139763, 0.03623473644256592, -0.029993832111358643, 0.06974539160728455, 0.009998951107263565, 0.0006911446689628065, -0.04564188793301582, 0.016600433737039566, -0.030051862820982933, -0.04942120984196663, -0.033203087747097015, 0.02238556183874607, 0.015664637088775635, -0.009150272235274315, 0.03731163218617439, 0.05564546212553978, -0.030751150101423264, -0.0023260191082954407, -0.011197047308087349, 0.00228068046271801, 0.030083617195487022, 0.053471408784389496, 0.07033555954694748, 0.004279115237295628, 0.009122109971940517, 0.06517046689987183, -0.0006524671334773302, 0.0056558577343821526, 0.016264474019408226, 0.007666933815926313, 0.031147219240665436, 0.04451325908303261, -0.013637336902320385, -0.06028815731406212, 0.010101194493472576, -0.06520549207925797, 0.039207179099321365, -0.05862721428275108, -0.061120111495256424, 0.03916988894343376, 0.015292963944375515, 0.005721440073102713, -0.04726622626185417, -0.017649652436375618, -0.035127926617860794, 0.015531398355960846, 0.011282911524176598, -0.000546199909877032, 0.029193289577960968, -0.0026763519272208214, 0.03170086815953255, -0.048445869237184525, 0.04714418947696686, 0.015639355406165123, -0.10067012906074524, -0.046351224184036255, 0.022966817021369934, -0.014428647235035896, 0.0010948341805487871, 0.015347867272794247, -0.012662558816373348, 0.02712654508650303, -0.06553924828767776, -0.020977837964892387, -0.03898196667432785, -0.0030436923261731863, 0.028338635340332985, 0.0491127148270607, -0.0492427684366703, -0.01818077638745308, -0.01726572774350643, -0.027781128883361816, 0.13107125461101532, 0.04975852742791176, 0.07595628499984741, -0.08406713604927063, 0.008925422094762325, -0.028458870947360992, 0.005534496158361435, -0.01459199283272028, -0.027396978810429573, 0.015212822705507278, 0.0020768498070538044, 0.042414966970682144, 0.030875226482748985, 0.022336097434163094, 0.0022515025921165943, 0.051110949367284775, -0.021939437836408615, 0.0017791606951504946, 0.036529239267110825, -0.014726504683494568, 0.02266136184334755, -0.047643691301345825, -0.03530951589345932, -0.011154969222843647, 0.045782528817653656, -0.0422227643430233, -0.0073685422539711, -0.044430579990148544, 0.020538462325930595, 0.0022889873944222927, -0.004910471849143505, -0.008420412428677082, 0.01061683427542448, 0.015731878578662872, 0.026788363233208656, -0.0048447661101818085, 0.01584673300385475, -0.007151189260184765, 0.015110298059880733, 0.04239519685506821, 0.02510244771838188, -0.006158286705613136, -0.008773465640842915, 0.020073985680937767, -0.047479864209890366, 0.018238592892885208, -0.01728677749633789, 0.018029075115919113, -0.017115211114287376, -0.021298371255397797, 0.00020221142040099949, 0.022035295143723488, 0.03946377709507942, -0.003544769948348403, -0.0302179716527462, 0.029299791902303696, 0.05325544998049736, 0.0053512039594352245, 0.0385330468416214, -0.024662494659423828, -0.009210720658302307, -0.016696825623512268, 0.002699374221265316, -0.006967132445424795, -0.04723690077662468, -0.025187646970152855, -0.005300195887684822, 0.010209850035607815, 0.019291790202260017, -0.014621171168982983, -0.00484886858612299, 0.0017821399960666895, -0.007079694885760546, -0.024613535031676292, -0.01223705057054758, 0.016869299113750458, 0.015570994466543198, -0.009559865109622478, 0.021234069019556046, -0.035955578088760376, -0.027926543727517128, -0.030162572860717773, -0.03245958313345909, 0.02154395915567875, -0.018232766538858414, 0.009666291996836662, 0.025676580145955086, -0.007482827641069889, -0.003953495062887669, 0.012826620601117611, -0.04683244600892067, 0.02945881523191929, 0.02352486550807953, -0.04223814606666565, 0.0019677875097841024, -0.02046961337327957, -0.049589116126298904, -0.017257772386074066, -0.017697304487228394, 0.055520180612802505, -0.020707547664642334, 0.03317606821656227, 0.009730522520840168, 0.002507980680093169, 0.002517740009352565, 0.006378785241395235, 0.03012888692319393, -0.054401107132434845, 0.026447059586644173, -0.014839024282991886, 0.019174782559275627, -0.05303533002734184, 0.008673278614878654, -0.03806309401988983, -0.03485069423913956, 0.038311783224344254, -0.04209723696112633, -0.0716157928109169, 0.011894035153090954, -0.003923211246728897, -0.002369847148656845, -0.013043035753071308, 0.029599815607070923, -0.009753544814884663, -0.012016750872135162, -0.04131530225276947, 0.013913162052631378, 0.020277876406908035, 0.007432449609041214, -0.0623394250869751, -0.00801865290850401, 0.03217654675245285, 0.008936531841754913, -0.00005268806853564456, 0.0057883053086698055, 0.0004910722491331398, 0.045215800404548645, 0.05405839905142784, -0.023337826132774353, 0.013568687252700329, 0.03568679839372635, -0.039607271552085876, -0.011209714226424694, 0.00003998667307314463, -0.008465069346129894, 0.051576368510723114, -0.006270925980061293, 0.014798104763031006, -0.007434196304529905, 0.04212251305580139, -0.022318873554468155, -0.020620694383978844, -0.0025472084525972605, 0.0458693727850914, 0.020827950909733772, -0.02395152673125267, -0.04013955965638161, 0.012381277047097683, -0.023389026522636414, 0.010688883252441883, 0.04588792473077774, -0.0023750043474137783, -0.022611228749155998, 0.023522451519966125, -0.02459958754479885, -0.00867590680718422, -0.001855592243373394, 0.01640412211418152, -0.0035317770671099424, 0.04163874685764313, -0.003628465114161372, 0.01595732755959034, 0.001816224423237145, 0.01938290148973465, -0.1027672067284584, 0.009145071730017662, -0.009975126013159752, 0.042967163026332855, 0.04060528427362442, -0.029984604567289352, 0.01863645389676094, 0.039405837655067444, -0.04759541153907776, -0.00487313698977232, -0.004696476738899946, 0.021330785006284714, -0.021409261971712112, -0.01734987460076809, -0.022378886118531227, 0.003731751348823309, -0.005777729209512472, -0.00816909596323967, 0.054966285824775696, -0.01897481642663479, 0.0074938638135790825, -0.03230717033147812, -0.027638843283057213, -0.02133241854608059, 0.026021648198366165, -0.07087092846632004, 0.04681951925158501, -0.05852646753191948, -0.04038574919104576, 0.013183076865971088, -0.002336326753720641, 0.05275382101535797, 0.03489988297224045, 0.028165560215711594, 0.008352739736437798, 0.05765824764966965, 0.020996926352381706, 0.03169850632548332, -0.013551962561905384, 0.00789870135486126, 0.021397260949015617, 0.020320691168308258, -0.03431975841522217, 0.0007251331117004156, 0.006599103100597858, 0.000973717134911567, 0.01105978712439537, 0.04892073944211006, -0.008035204373300076, -0.006336210761219263, -0.03076084516942501, -0.03842242807149887, 0.0022218767553567886, 0.0003608701517805457, -0.0023036100901663303, -0.051743581891059875, 0.0020768765825778246, 0.0486556813120842, -0.023292269557714462, 0.022754119709134102, -0.015868140384554863, -0.03318791836500168, -0.023937523365020752, 0.009215455502271652, 0.010251330211758614, -0.03237355872988701, -0.03349343687295914, 0.002631673589348793, 0.018865317106246948, -0.0188736692070961, 0.0028549544513225555, 0.00457552308216691, -0.044116418808698654, 0.022036409005522728, -0.04382975772023201, -0.010729285888373852, 0.011445960029959679, -0.0038976899813860655, 0.04712894931435585, -0.04329656809568405, 0.06892029941082001, 0.027125151827931404, 0.012827657163143158, -0.02186645194888115, -0.014627560041844845, -0.02272362820804119, 0.028502406552433968, 0.036265838891267776, -0.020622573792934418, -0.016754217445850372, 0.015780581161379814, 0.028714314103126526, 0.01368525717407465, -0.037193525582551956, 0.06044602766633034, 0.018685242161154747, -0.033149782568216324, -0.003356107510626316, 0.016710927709937096, 0.01757938601076603, 0.005035997834056616, 0.024543315172195435, -0.012780963443219662, 0.010423318482935429, -0.0020783969666808844, -0.012470480054616928, -0.016607923433184624, -0.03379620984196663, 0.005357103422284126, 0.030959073454141617, -0.009219224564731121, 0.004487662110477686, 0.013109203428030014, 0.010408632457256317, -0.05363902077078819, 0.011589289642870426, -0.05697156488895416, -0.06012343987822533, 0.0022600058000534773, 0.022013872861862183, 0.004733645357191563, -0.06528324633836746, 0.04225935414433479, 0.005497776437550783, 0.016116216778755188, -0.010149977169930935, 0.01676151528954506, 0.06078282743692398, 0.060637377202510834, 0.0018345239805057645, 0.03977356478571892, -0.020830785855650902, -0.017864223569631577, 0.03801877796649933, 0.012487010098993778, 0.018480395898222923, -0.010490856133401394, -0.00804892648011446, -0.015927504748106003, -0.025963345542550087, 0.04505227133631706, -0.008469405584037304, 0.05143400654196739, -0.02899814397096634, -0.021149931475520134, 0.044775158166885376, 0.02305862307548523, 0.03644935414195061, -0.022509826347231865, -0.03278321027755737, 0.04534241929650307, -0.007550492882728577, 0.0036321100778877735, -0.03635470196604729, 0.003604297060519457, -0.00741747859865427, 0.008259456604719162, -0.0006706647691316903, -0.009951555170118809, 0.03462996706366539, 0.061486367136240005, 0.04037237539887428, -0.04811472445726395, 0.056931622326374054, -0.029536589980125427, -0.00016299144772347063, -0.013585364446043968, -0.010087448172271252, 0.006305119954049587, -0.017900142818689346, 0.00004419262404553592, -0.012329960241913795, 0.008570707403123379, -0.0018239619676023722, 0.008214964531362057, -0.03888269513845444, -0.03799974173307419, 0.03171193599700928, 0.05112115293741226, -0.046874210238456726, 0.02938000299036503, -0.05050167441368103, -0.05666156858205795, 0.0040558637119829655, 0.01155734620988369 ]
<p>I need to predict with a simple model if a bank customer is still active.</p> <p>I have some information like the date of the last meeting with the customer, but some of them didn't have any meeting with their advisor.</p> <pre><code>Customer_Id | Last_meeting_date (in days from now) | Gender |... A 115 F ... B NA F ... </code></pre> <p>Is it possible to use a special value/flag like 1000 to "indicate" to the tree that we don't have any date ?</p> <p>In my mind, the decision tree isn't linear like regression, so it can make an exception, like if Last_meeting_date=1000 then... but I'm not sure of it.</p>
36,710
[ -0.009421939961612225, -0.021540271118283272, -0.0036363222170621157, 0.04856610298156738, 0.05073771998286247, -0.011723127216100693, -0.019312473013997078, -0.025228919461369514, 0.03700074180960655, 0.016509758308529854, 0.0585542768239975, 0.03676323965191841, 0.02767089009284973, 0.017967212945222855, -0.013905603438615799, 0.014928390271961689, 0.003925892058759928, -0.01855934038758278, 0.0023249154910445213, -0.007084357552230358, -0.003762361593544483, 0.007363941054791212, 0.022070985287427902, 0.02369081601500511, 0.0009590054978616536, 0.029128298163414, 0.012174715287983418, 0.0006084786145947874, -0.004592810291796923, 0.010991216637194157, -0.05925653874874115, -0.07374297082424164, 0.007873421534895897, 0.04653702676296234, 0.04709097370505333, -0.008764605037868023, -0.002790998201817274, -0.04250434786081314, -0.034549031406641006, 0.020135652273893356, 0.03801028057932854, 0.004617472179234028, 0.03467089310288429, 0.06832453608512878, -0.031054535880684853, 0.009687024168670177, -0.006865285336971283, 0.0002454949135426432, 0.06859596073627472, -0.02952638640999794, -0.012164468877017498, -0.06550619006156921, 0.0445668064057827, 0.016814539209008217, -0.030063245445489883, -0.011633651331067085, 0.03217869997024536, 0.05372239276766777, -0.02680489793419838, -0.030186381191015244, -0.020712262019515038, -0.05784091353416443, 0.032580915838479996, 0.026007793843746185, -0.02711034193634987, -0.014897990971803665, 0.0016594075132161379, -0.04627547413110733, 0.01842273399233818, -0.024769408628344536, 0.0018612344283610582, -0.012780497781932354, 0.011972049251198769, -0.016550205647945404, 0.015129591338336468, -0.050616003572940826, -0.011413132771849632, 0.013394046574831009, 0.03283063694834709, 0.04773040860891342, -0.022204333916306496, -0.01127876527607441, 0.026571311056613922, 0.02357432059943676, 0.04007818177342415, -0.00659487908706069, 0.06190776452422142, -0.029366083443164825, 0.022274095565080643, -0.004543227609246969, -0.00017426579142920673, -0.007131461054086685, 0.018867621198296547, -0.01495177298784256, -0.050975192338228226, 0.035464268177747726, -0.006347995717078447, 0.03125668317079544, 0.05377480015158653, 0.02666698582470417, -0.020663941279053688, -0.037640538066625595, 0.026925278827548027, 0.03088766150176525, -0.041667837649583817, -0.03908951207995415, -0.009166761301457882, -0.0004916577599942684, -0.025742724537849426, -0.02289731428027153, -0.012697748839855194, 0.001181592233479023, 0.003154248930513859, -0.025969695299863815, 0.004250371363013983, -0.01873883418738842, -0.029091838747262955, -0.008900810033082962, 0.005872198846191168, 0.039690423756837845, 0.038084059953689575, -0.013432382605969906, 0.03394802287220955, -0.008287097327411175, -0.03836296126246452, 0.003180872881785035, 0.0035667791962623596, -0.022984536364674568, -0.02856992743909359, 0.04205797612667084, -0.028893768787384033, 0.011565801687538624, 0.07741472125053406, -0.0009370626648887992, 0.06463528424501419, 0.0036165600176900625, -0.0539054274559021, -0.0353495255112648, -0.0021386209409683943, 0.011315641924738884, 0.04613041505217552, -0.04716092348098755, 0.006820774637162685, 0.0559319406747818, 0.058254312723875046, 0.012706934474408627, 0.03214344009757042, 0.016580777242779732, -0.02931230701506138, 0.0001265697937924415, -0.025401979684829712, -0.01444999035447836, -0.01852198876440525, 0.0011292615672573447, -0.019177289679646492, -0.05864210054278374, 0.04295017570257187, 0.011480145156383514, -0.042967360466718674, -0.03588997572660446, 0.013856342993676662, -0.00457953754812479, -0.0059498390182852745, 0.0058174231089651585, -0.007422857452183962, -0.040036749094724655, 0.10200277715921402, -0.01626027561724186, 0.031873226165771484, 0.004115454386919737, -0.0024511420633643866, 0.03446975350379944, 0.023449277505278587, 0.04251326620578766, 0.05396248772740364, 0.016726046800613403, -0.004101397003978491, -0.033331189304590225, 0.042294248938560486, 0.012460230849683285, -0.04628942906856537, -0.02393471635878086, -0.04811255261301994, 0.0366242341697216, -0.00878125336021185, -0.02415204979479313, -0.013557635247707367, -0.03108949586749077, 0.053488846868276596, -0.05751124396920204, -0.04055830091238022, -0.05143124237656593, 0.003175891935825348, 0.00013675574155058712, 0.03835773468017578, -0.00003837446274701506, -0.011927500367164612, -0.010112384334206581, -0.026144446805119514, -0.011167884804308414, -0.04449091851711273, 0.0063839866779744625, 0.06351995468139648, -0.0694354698061943, 0.011084819212555885, 0.02738037146627903, 0.012080923654139042, 0.015856532379984856, 0.04104490950703621, -0.05821165069937706, -0.05187147483229637, 0.000029269347578519955, -0.08900713175535202, -0.0023511708714067936, -0.022669708356261253, -0.019160564988851547, 0.06897125393152237, -0.002822109730914235, -0.03879803791642189, 0.016437293961644173, -0.04590099677443504, 0.037410393357276917, 0.1316278576850891, 0.007535120472311974, 0.03457922115921974, -0.00915687344968319, -0.0033722103107720613, -0.0066049532033503056, -0.019269896671175957, -0.03643949702382088, -0.017754357308149338, -0.018221404403448105, -0.006293177139014006, -0.008515708148479462, 0.01881956309080124, 0.04745594412088394, 0.05695216730237007, -0.0126144178211689, 0.005036510992795229, 0.013606480322778225, 0.005779113620519638, 0.05751688778400421, 0.027577504515647888, 0.005432002246379852, 0.0305754654109478, 0.01585417613387108, 0.03634517639875412, -0.0034398380666971207, 0.02307688072323799, -0.008777636103332043, 0.013158335350453854, -0.00559279415756464, 0.014791746623814106, 0.0033711350988596678, 0.008998507633805275, -0.020406151190400124, 0.050491735339164734, -0.03424070402979851, -0.007565243169665337, 0.022727536037564278, -0.02792597934603691, -0.0015109560918062925, -0.021007854491472244, -0.03517933562397957, -0.004663664381951094, 0.06370088458061218, -0.06144014000892639, 0.012041452340781689, 0.0343569777905941, -0.021386533975601196, 0.005312578286975622, -0.031236769631505013, -0.03251570463180542, -0.029427649453282356, 0.027763815596699715, 0.05618606135249138, 0.02911279909312725, 0.05852523446083069, -0.008572068065404892, -0.004558009095489979, -0.013523091562092304, -0.007114458363503218, 0.007782583124935627, 0.006756858434528112, -0.04863397032022476, -0.02990155667066574, 0.06276300549507141, -0.021757708862423897, 0.0056468285620212555, -0.01719033531844616, -0.028472959995269775, 0.03324836120009422, -0.002835534978657961, -0.03331112489104271, -0.04733796790242195, -0.02476673573255539, 0.010644257068634033, -0.019144665449857712, -0.06068184971809387, -0.02260538376867771, 0.014471601694822311, -0.024493012577295303, -0.005745277740061283, -0.04821169003844261, 0.011178658343851566, -0.019483529031276703, -0.026739567518234253, -0.018559042364358902, -0.019790951162576675, 0.0029735579155385494, 0.047466255724430084, 0.0009268764406442642, 0.009047426283359528, -0.07849191874265671, -0.03853720799088478, -0.0004304083704482764, 0.0022911960259079933, 0.03373432531952858, 0.0025801074225455523, 0.005202136002480984, 0.06619761884212494, 0.024070413783192635, -0.03089451789855957, -0.04654517024755478, -0.039090655744075775, -0.030693046748638153, -0.06870333850383759, 0.0084349000826478, -0.007541217841207981, 0.04044552147388458, -0.024657059460878372, -0.026668664067983627, 0.025247331708669662, 0.04503573477268219, 0.0017594145610928535, -0.0034264479763805866, -0.02280213125050068, 0.0076024956069886684, -0.004308308940380812, 0.04735114425420761, 0.03185274824500084, -0.018538769334554672, 0.03479108214378357, -0.05088089033961296, 0.037032827734947205, 0.0380915068089962, -0.07295377552509308, 0.020238066092133522, -0.0248350091278553, 0.02832571230828762, 0.010798722505569458, 0.05202142521739006, -0.019146425649523735, -0.04909167066216469, -0.01591615378856659, -0.009174196049571037, 0.0547659695148468, -0.04949430376291275, -0.003504672320559621, 0.03949088230729103, 0.015801092609763145, -0.006680634804069996, 0.008153908886015415, 0.006026400253176689, 0.024839362129569054, 0.034531526267528534, -0.04027685150504112, 0.001009610015898943, 0.043117403984069824, 0.0433112308382988, -0.02274564653635025, 0.011351857334375381, -0.024544036015868187, -0.01856907270848751, -0.03381173685193062, -0.015046251006424427, -0.027616819366812706, 0.03703191503882408, 0.036969300359487534, -0.02365710772573948, 0.022041020914912224, -0.03253302350640297, 0.022499576210975647, 0.02050512656569481, -0.059468548744916916, -0.007118741516023874, 0.029342878609895706, -0.012929770164191723, -0.003387227887287736, -0.019449507817626, 0.019505226984620094, -0.04561906307935715, 0.004405586048960686, -0.023395685479044914, 0.009809322655200958, 0.00004725255712401122, 0.0039866892620921135, -0.025043873116374016, 0.025088010355830193, -0.013340570032596588, -0.0047585428692400455, 0.014158651232719421, 0.006943593267351389, 0.003201857442036271, 0.004610289819538593, -0.005078789312392473, -0.028864290565252304, -0.01678895391523838, -0.011779597960412502, -0.011026791296899319, 0.03549373522400856, 0.036375872790813446, 0.017302006483078003, -0.04664895683526993, -0.003877387847751379, 0.026712095364928246, 0.013228170573711395, 0.03742694482207298, 0.05496200919151306, -0.009372258558869362, 0.01617395505309105, -0.005011075176298618, 0.009021608158946037, -0.020117416977882385, -0.03074868768453598, -0.011847528629004955, 0.04754721745848656, 0.04121485725045204, -0.04728993773460388, 0.034187015146017075, 0.07176225632429123, 0.04973708093166351, -0.040780209004879, -0.005905265919864178, 0.04100814461708069, 0.026932492852211, -0.01811578869819641, -0.0005860108649358153, 0.050314560532569885, 0.02066047489643097, 0.0029819977935403585, -0.01082125399261713, -0.027814166620373726, -0.023803476244211197, 0.000299869105219841, 0.032502416521310806, 0.029175156727433205, -0.0209149532020092, -0.024407586082816124, 0.023464815691113472, 0.024339210242033005, -0.012354283593595028, 0.033914174884557724, 0.011128075420856476, -0.11760132014751434, 0.018357137218117714, 0.06907172501087189, 0.02758776769042015, -0.009428445249795914, -0.05598711967468262, -0.035001128911972046, -0.01901039481163025, -0.00665127020329237, -0.001599321374669671, 0.0023379416670650244, -0.0340600460767746, 0.00466564204543829, 0.0014053372433409095, -0.03309319540858269, -0.00524525111541152, 0.02992846630513668, -0.012273404747247696, 0.05410080775618553, 0.009736324660480022, -0.03890301659703255, -0.019025728106498718, 0.0077084144577383995, 0.002149607753381133, 0.023814242333173752, -0.017564138397574425, -0.022484969347715378, -0.005424278322607279, -0.004016234539449215, -0.03266071528196335, -0.06215694919228554, -0.021752241998910904, 0.015897400677204132, 0.019979778677225113, 0.041456520557403564, -0.004797714296728373, -0.00869915820658207, -0.002230860060080886, 0.048670776188373566, -0.012587860226631165, -0.019613534212112427, -0.010150204412639141, 0.007312160916626453, -0.012474083341658115, 0.0027761743403971195, 0.006103374529629946, 0.027683738619089127, -0.0014983167639002204, 0.007313344161957502, -0.026704512536525726, 0.006252684164792299, 0.01940283738076687, -0.0023314361460506916, -0.041792888194322586, -0.01861572451889515, -0.014933327212929726, -0.006005098577588797, -0.00803965050727129, 0.011305597610771656, 0.0011650692904368043, -0.0008643441251479089, -0.03951164335012436, 0.045756515115499496, -0.003199831349775195, -0.0068952785804867744, -0.06291445344686508, 0.00015598621394019574, -0.08016445487737656, 0.012597293592989445, 0.020768482238054276, -0.04691619053483009, 0.02700495347380638, 0.02794714644551277, 0.0011544103035703301, 0.016263147816061974, -0.015513158403337002, -0.0029296122957021, 0.01928003877401352, 0.014029928483068943, -0.0022898411843925714, -0.0157118272036314, 0.03357294201850891, 0.004776574205607176, -0.017367631196975708, -0.00013039421173743904, 0.014381267130374908, -0.0018063712632283568, -0.008453096263110638, -0.01744452491402626, 0.09543030709028244, -0.017744282260537148, -0.04253518208861351, -0.02805708535015583, -0.0433846153318882, 0.027202356606721878, 0.007180471904575825, -0.05092475935816765, -0.019892672076821327, 0.013678855262696743, -0.020723873749375343, 0.004502176772803068, -0.002188799437135458, 0.08427876979112625, -0.014252693392336369, 0.008256603963673115, 0.0035348099190741777, -0.015447903424501419, 0.05493898689746857, 0.009199478663504124, 0.0010497269686311483, 0.020912403240799904, -0.0194380059838295, 0.0038337032310664654, -0.02217642217874527, 0.013398666866123676, -0.0334106981754303, -0.002386800479143858, -0.040133338421583176, 0.0026989090256392956, 0.06495963037014008, 0.02518332377076149, -0.006134386640042067, -0.02741149440407753, -0.008762761950492859, 0.024185845628380775, -0.03136669471859932, 0.005737424362450838, -0.008327115327119827, -0.011890345253050327, -0.011817716993391514, 0.016155652701854706, 0.013407031074166298, 0.00890272855758667, -0.02547026425600052, 0.012410319410264492, 0.00999254360795021, 0.025528227910399437, 0.0721820592880249, -0.023658141493797302, 0.01596134714782238, -0.009642287157475948, -0.018159152939915657, 0.06244296580553055, 0.01731031946837902, -0.03059227392077446, -0.013023682869970798, 0.017163975164294243, -0.02998635731637478, -0.04660411179065704, 0.001695033977739513, -0.0020534496288746595, 0.017825568094849586, -0.028438739478588104, 0.03660082072019577, 0.00404810905456543, 0.03799821808934212, 0.009871715679764748, -0.04204835742712021, -0.01806691102683544, 0.004866919945925474, 0.006712737958878279, 0.043818969279527664, 0.0010092813754454255, 0.044420015066862106, 0.03590652346611023, 0.024310441687703133, 0.05313775688409805, 0.04528973996639252, 0.008771855384111404, 0.002147069200873375, 0.008815107867121696, -0.04380055516958237, -0.04113142564892769, 0.03538978844881058, -0.02564539946615696, -0.02798968181014061, -0.010125195607542992, -0.05518578737974167, 0.02985084243118763, 0.0135386036708951, 0.03319160267710686, -0.032814331352710724, -0.0050342632457613945, -0.08647558093070984, -0.011248988099396229, 0.01070201676338911, 0.007938046008348465, 0.07572077214717865, -0.015842601656913757, 0.015584699809551239, -0.002094346098601818, -0.008773479610681534, -0.009186053648591042, -0.07157351821660995, -0.04256667569279671, -0.013322317972779274, -0.02924148179590702, 0.027336370199918747, -0.024236489087343216, -0.009216304868459702, 0.002876855432987213, -0.03511662781238556, 0.01991356536746025, 0.031091930344700813, 0.08501075953245163, 0.012674991972744465, 0.04629756882786751, 0.0016955484170466661, 0.01064192596822977, -0.009783967398107052, 0.01699529029428959, 0.13616108894348145, 0.08586647361516953, 0.033661480993032455, -0.021592993289232254, 0.01191377267241478, 0.012152100913226604, -0.012684586457908154, -0.016348637640476227, -0.00777977192774415, 0.02056204155087471, -0.021810835227370262, 0.03599679470062256, 0.029756590723991394, -0.03955509141087532, -0.0216522179543972, 0.0011865247506648302, -0.01052849367260933, 0.019483739510178566, 0.0406176783144474, 0.013663365505635738, 0.011775714345276356, -0.055957235395908356, -0.03335033729672432, 0.03921869397163391, 0.05423610284924507, -0.03713362663984299, -0.026579106226563454, 0.00918534304946661, 0.013528741896152496, -0.014867848716676235, -0.019393960013985634, 0.010691375471651554, 0.03626208007335663, 0.05709005892276764, 0.022345202043652534, 0.019103815779089928, -0.007781995926052332, -0.029604623094201088, 0.033910397440195084, 0.04948241636157036, -0.006303086411207914, -0.008337224833667278, 0.01359171699732542, 0.008996861055493355, -0.047931719571352005, -0.042919352650642395, -0.023936839774250984, 0.027602743357419968, 0.04627259448170662, -0.04138927906751633, -0.00876118615269661, -0.017049850896000862, 0.02622426301240921, -0.023061316460371017, -0.013699016533792019, 0.0272025428712368, 0.024497365579009056, -0.0073552546091377735, -0.016403647139668465, -0.009182802401483059, 0.008038128726184368, 0.0020121708512306213, 0.00977452751249075, 0.017539551481604576, -0.01924188993871212, -0.0034607595298439264, -0.03327850624918938, 0.022315289825201035, -0.004471117164939642, 0.017789853736758232, 0.019841555505990982, -0.022862982004880905, -0.021914536133408546, -0.025909509509801865, 0.029218362644314766, 0.021874623373150826, -0.010873480699956417, -0.02142801694571972, 0.003458271501585841, -0.029428713023662567, 0.0006670484435744584, 0.014924672432243824, -0.005175406578928232, -0.00840869639068842, -0.00026797334430739284, 0.030282843858003616, 0.019719097763299942, 0.03603794798254967, 0.018384015187621117, -0.03485724329948425, -0.017076818272471428, 0.07802436500787735, -0.0026216187980026007, -0.038914866745471954, -0.060757361352443695, -0.004678034223616123, -0.03362612426280975, 0.05574214830994606, 0.014073708094656467, 0.06577294319868088, 0.007322106976062059, 0.011364143341779709, -0.016952738165855408, -0.00015989453822840005, 0.00501096248626709, 0.002358175814151764, 0.024306481704115868, -0.07036890834569931, -0.015140432864427567, -0.02693502977490425, -0.010402610525488853, -0.026753507554531097, -0.027133794501423836, -0.007620989810675383, -0.020674049854278564, 0.01474629808217287, -0.011360528878867626, -0.023567376658320427, 0.023431269451975822, 0.00385309848934412, -0.012437691912055016, -0.0022550614085048437, 0.016641097143292427, -0.035926561802625656, -0.025742966681718826, 0.0429697260260582, -0.05684702843427658, -0.01586904004216194, -0.026544611901044846, -0.012529206462204456, 0.008553382009267807, 0.01408752053976059, 0.024391645565629005, 0.01641293801367283, -0.009633119218051434, -0.0038976846262812614, 0.013637319207191467, 0.04886304587125778, -0.0581439733505249, -0.04545490816235542, 0.02111465111374855, -0.06031373143196106, -0.017634594812989235, 0.05079216882586479, 0.01789158023893833, 0.035419248044490814, -0.012814110144972801, 0.0019843345507979393, 0.016520773991942406, 0.053853366523981094, -0.030178118497133255, -0.023338958621025085, -0.012582153081893921, 0.01988297700881958, -0.013320298865437508, 0.012300893664360046, -0.021369656547904015, 0.014294956810772419, -0.03882646560668945, -0.01979718543589115, 0.050885703414678574, 0.03503775596618652, -0.03152024745941162, -0.005119957495480776, 0.015931492671370506, -0.022898854687809944, -0.006697994656860828, 0.010722842998802662, -0.014941156841814518, 0.0020028722938150167, -0.00907890684902668, 0.011016173288226128, -0.01772855408489704, 0.05117908492684364, -0.10286986827850342, -0.03320294991135597, 0.02932758256793022, 0.01997489482164383, 0.028023235499858856, -0.03178313747048378, 0.01112687774002552, 0.03193272277712822, -0.06706544756889343, 0.008070790208876133, 0.023801425471901894, 0.005946173332631588, -0.045287296175956726, 0.0361735001206398, -0.03412725776433945, 0.02114320546388626, 0.047621726989746094, 0.012361845932900906, 0.05327197164297104, 0.00021085482148919255, 0.026510732248425484, -0.04528011381626129, -0.019732419401407242, 0.01889646425843239, -0.0034182053059339523, -0.053772203624248505, 0.03279538452625275, -0.059591516852378845, -0.050790779292583466, 0.024614837020635605, -0.052890513092279434, -0.003568301908671856, 0.04429591819643974, 0.012843734584748745, 0.0297513660043478, 0.06537028402090073, 0.024505196139216423, -0.035211607813835144, 0.028842415660619736, 0.0182383731007576, -0.018797529861330986, 0.017736921086907387, 0.033258046954870224, 0.047011598944664, 0.015124231576919556, -0.03697221726179123, -0.01600823365151882, 0.0007435776060447097, -0.006300858687609434, -0.03343139961361885, 0.005739337299019098, -0.016285426914691925, -0.004105306696146727, -0.04041783884167671, -0.03632321208715439, 0.009225904941558838, 0.03338036313652992, 0.05280747264623642, 0.02270621992647648, -0.006297181826084852, -0.004435267765074968, -0.020838705822825432, -0.04883934184908867, 0.012373288162052631, 0.03549031540751457, -0.02070939540863037, -0.0012168532703071833, -0.013104958459734917, -0.021407026797533035, -0.005323424004018307, -0.011519650928676128, 0.04339374974370003, 0.008907859213650227, 0.050594691187143326, -0.045504532754421234, 0.014353516511619091, 0.05798671394586563, -0.02350442111492157, 0.00906721968203783, -0.11222530901432037, 0.0362989604473114, 0.03438970074057579, 0.05446232110261917, -0.043344367295503616, -0.008200448006391525, -0.07172712683677673, 0.012288573198020458, 0.05133644863963127, -0.03688273951411247, 0.018609976395964622, -0.014484313316643238, -0.018724068999290466, -0.016672469675540924, -0.02641027607023716, 0.04051923006772995, -0.007569595240056515, 0.03139858692884445, -0.02327141724526882, -0.029616767540574074, -0.0017391860019415617, -0.0021067513152956963, 0.021638209000229836, 0.02020341157913208, -0.0006682687671855092, 0.017914066091179848, -0.01839735545217991, 0.025171037763357162, 0.027556246146559715, -0.00034215449704788625, 0.03382795304059982, 0.046257056295871735, -0.013143084943294525, 0.031068170443177223, 0.016033371910452843, -0.0491182804107666, 0.038633037358522415, -0.01805446669459343, 0.010779770091176033, 0.006433558184653521, 0.03162200003862381, 0.004843868315219879, -0.056029558181762695, -0.0006759540410712361, 0.02484164573252201, -0.016972532495856285, 0.023341266438364983, -0.00494066858664155, 0.0022519126068800688, 0.03995544835925102, 0.0035811681300401688, 0.03786374628543854, -0.004693382885307074, -0.0010777737479656935, 0.017114227637648582, -0.021601153537631035, -0.013291960582137108, -0.0013534969184547663, 0.04012422636151314, 0.009189378470182419, 0.017741631716489792, 0.002032442484050989, -0.03739096224308014, 0.05928171053528786, 0.048022013157606125, 0.01172685343772173, 0.01744965836405754, 0.019026055932044983, 0.022343650460243225, 0.012817950919270515, 0.011408126913011074, 0.005904951598495245, -0.07636328041553497, -0.024713439866900444, -0.038319483399391174, -0.022830162197351456, -0.012905992567539215, 0.026541313156485558, 0.03385112062096596, 0.03594796359539032, -0.023945121094584465, 0.036663688719272614, 0.026173332706093788, 0.02527913823723793, 0.022951463237404823, -0.02711651287972927, 0.01666732132434845, -0.0011470031458884478, -0.013981157913804054, 0.012685497291386127, -0.03177369758486748, -0.042246218770742416, -0.018778955563902855, 0.03621286526322365, 0.011362522840499878, 0.022367535158991814, -0.006062519736588001, -0.02774721384048462, -0.0025277414824813604, 0.00830788817256689, -0.029559660702943802, 0.003239790676161647, -0.04122690483927727, 0.019419675692915916, -0.04819818213582039, -0.056335002183914185 ]
<p>I have one categorical dichotomous dependent variable (yes/no - retention of newly learned words) and two independent variables - both are categorical. One independent variable is "delay between exposure and test" and has two levels (short time delay/week time delay). The other IV is "word type" and relates to the types of words children were exposed to - object label, colour label etc. I have run a binary logistic regression on my data (440 participants - 44 per condition of word type and time delay) using the "Enter" Method and defined both IVs as categorical using the categorical tab. The initial outputs - Block 0 "Variables not in the Equation", Block 1 Omnibus Tests of Model Coeffcients and the Hosmer and Lemeshow Test all suggest that the model is significant and the Block 1 Classification Table suggests there's been an 11% improvement in predicting the DV (when compared to the Block 0 classification table). Yet the Block 1 "Variables in the Equation" Table shows no main effect of either of the IVs nor an Interaction effect - and not by a long way (time delay p=0.37; word type p=0.37; Word type*Time Delay p=0.401. I don't know how to interpret this as all the examples I've seen in my book and online show at least one significant main effect when the model is significant. It also seems somewhat illogical for SPSS to report that the model is significant but that neither of the IVs are having a significant effect! Also, my data are quite clear and it seems very likely that there is a main effect of time delay. Retention of all word types except one fall from around 65% in the short delay to around 33% after one week. </p> <p>I have tried changing the indicator from first to last (ie from short delay to the week delay) for the time delay variable and concerningly the results change - I thought when the IV was dichotomous it didn't matter which of the categories was used as the control group (indicator). Even more of a concern, it produces a main effect of word type rather than time delay.</p> <p>I have used dummy coding and effectively treated each of my word type categories as different IVs and this produces completely different results. Again - this is a concern as I would expect very similar results since it should effectively be running the same data.</p> <p>Can anyone help?</p>
33,244
[ -0.04598134383559227, -0.02456939034163952, 0.026203405112028122, -0.01050829142332077, 0.017488092184066772, -0.022560978308320045, -0.005654442124068737, -0.0072890380397439, 0.04468054324388504, -0.04771682620048523, 0.01712721772491932, 0.02175114117562771, 0.04719017446041107, 0.024771815165877342, -0.013653624802827835, 0.0453701987862587, 0.0227879136800766, -0.0027390916366130114, 0.012165170162916183, 0.04344906285405159, -0.051213063299655914, 0.03228146955370903, 0.016632040962576866, -0.011475685052573681, 0.014969190582633018, 0.07147318869829178, 0.015672236680984497, -0.05799451470375061, 0.018821386620402336, -0.006602906621992588, -0.027759119868278503, -0.011469767428934574, -0.036789387464523315, -0.03215678036212921, -0.007476978003978729, 0.02868082746863365, -0.0028283449355512857, -0.04244736209511757, 0.00031368466443382204, -0.005409106146544218, -0.024763507768511772, -0.0074581485241651535, -0.017113791778683662, 0.05163218080997467, -0.029368257150053978, 0.004228835925459862, -0.030207199975848198, -0.01048820186406374, 0.042737897485494614, -0.007898646406829357, 0.03459109738469124, 0.014111869037151337, 0.023952439427375793, 0.054341401904821396, -0.012598245404660702, -0.01032314170151949, 0.05282008647918701, 0.05604667216539383, -0.01376647874712944, -0.014918338507413864, -0.00711540412157774, -0.012602024711668491, -0.025003384798765182, -0.015572688542306423, -0.009466307237744331, -0.001183307496830821, 0.04044967517256737, 0.015253828838467598, 0.065252885222435, -0.01417152862995863, 0.038830049335956573, 0.0037804378662258387, 0.047807447612285614, 0.016678128391504288, 0.026255639269948006, -0.013681244105100632, -0.015659214928746223, 0.03389636054635048, 0.03698141872882843, 0.06213236600160599, 0.006490257102996111, 0.009452844969928265, -0.01637466624379158, 0.03939453884959221, -0.008960584178566933, -0.009145661257207394, 0.04024885222315788, -0.038132116198539734, 0.010732699185609818, 0.030054137110710144, -0.03954287990927696, 0.001569520914927125, 0.06820416450500488, -0.008043874986469746, -0.0034732057247310877, 0.026188336312770844, -0.020398573949933052, 0.037440940737724304, 0.030921829864382744, 0.004963964223861694, -0.007205411326140165, -0.015488934703171253, 0.0369097925722599, 0.04489889368414879, -0.02425500378012657, -0.007668097969144583, -0.03582723066210747, 0.00842864066362381, -0.03181633725762367, -0.03824860602617264, -0.004089978523552418, 0.03911823406815529, 0.011939674615859985, 0.00017836596816778183, -0.002733222907409072, -0.04690096154808998, -0.016645945608615875, 0.00010958810162264854, 0.04665667936205864, 0.062490448355674744, 0.04710808023810387, -0.042415961623191833, 0.015303452499210835, -0.01785970665514469, -0.06261935830116272, -0.016567468643188477, 0.026681942865252495, -0.026049818843603134, -0.055683668702840805, 0.06543529778718948, 0.043566279113292694, 0.01586981862783432, 0.046185512095689774, -0.009309817105531693, 0.03315829858183861, 0.04053950682282448, -0.07792001962661743, -0.06997806578874588, -0.005346609745174646, -0.032238274812698364, 0.02635778672993183, -0.0501839742064476, -0.04165976122021675, 0.005705696530640125, 0.052864622324705124, 0.01057040598243475, 0.023392224684357643, 0.02610030770301819, 0.03603610023856163, 0.04830271005630493, -0.018000608310103416, 0.01502264104783535, -0.016699032858014107, -0.009199756197631359, -0.021486464887857437, -0.08716682344675064, 0.03418369218707085, 0.0529661700129509, -0.02052619308233261, -0.022603698074817657, -0.001652982085943222, 0.015476597473025322, -0.0027897285763174295, -0.014322885312139988, 0.009085765108466148, -0.036958206444978714, 0.029206519946455956, -0.03277750313282013, 0.05776744335889816, 0.0014744035433977842, 0.04896136373281479, 0.024563247337937355, 0.02304738573729992, 0.05361076071858406, -0.0232094656676054, -0.005481136962771416, -0.00043491291580721736, 0.008549471385776997, -0.03917830437421799, -0.009311159141361713, -0.03060731291770935, -0.033205047249794006, -0.06515772640705109, 0.01560272928327322, 0.005494889337569475, 0.0224897637963295, -0.010706963017582893, 0.036180105060338974, 0.04973558709025383, -0.01686818338930607, -0.06895210593938828, -0.03349806368350983, 0.04161474108695984, -0.032663870602846146, -0.03610176593065262, 0.043744102120399475, -0.03937086462974548, 0.023369532078504562, 0.029938222840428352, 0.005243734922260046, -0.03403720259666443, -0.01293750386685133, 0.03525833785533905, -0.06018193066120148, 0.02045806683599949, 0.04984087496995926, 0.02033323235809803, -0.03259514644742012, 0.024735480546951294, -0.04255395382642746, -0.024895820766687393, 0.03803788125514984, 0.009419132955372334, 0.04473736509680748, -0.03084656037390232, -0.045187897980213165, 0.037646856158971786, 0.008672096766531467, -0.017348675057291985, 0.029105838388204575, -0.04659660905599594, 0.095587819814682, 0.03233008831739426, -0.0005861100507900119, 0.012447907589375973, 0.048781730234622955, 0.031308311969041824, 0.030509542673826218, -0.02380415052175522, -0.026378024369478226, -0.004316295497119427, -0.027189038693904877, 0.05208766460418701, 0.012612123042345047, -0.015471241436898708, 0.0049616205506026745, 0.004004636313766241, 0.016234174370765686, 0.02891278639435768, 0.023309867829084396, 0.038681577891111374, -0.0443170927464962, 0.024913489818572998, 0.040678806602954865, 0.0057836128398776054, 0.0019261756679043174, 0.020935971289873123, -0.019390495494008064, 0.05385582521557808, -0.007440679706633091, 0.016722198575735092, 0.024460922926664352, 0.05426134914159775, -0.01986520178616047, -0.028853390365839005, 0.004108515568077564, 0.027016980573534966, -0.046538081020116806, -0.006829966325312853, 0.0865655392408371, 0.022089309990406036, 0.01017017662525177, 0.011296023614704609, -0.005496954079717398, 0.04664880409836769, 0.02081708051264286, -0.019004832953214645, 0.0159456767141819, 0.023364586755633354, -0.053737822920084, 0.029141249135136604, -0.010019104927778244, -0.04351693391799927, -0.008870629593729973, 0.03676571696996689, 0.014753276482224464, -0.0010749034117907286, -0.0060063018463552, -0.01911589503288269, 0.035406675189733505, 0.012035948224365711, -0.0012098747538402677, 0.05876432731747627, -0.01844940520823002, -0.047999292612075806, -0.009300606325268745, -0.044765301048755646, -0.009124984964728355, 0.03792792558670044, -0.04521729424595833, -0.07871322333812714, 0.02917937934398651, -0.013252354227006435, -0.045660097151994705, -0.05838261544704437, -0.04994126036763191, -0.0004383458581287414, -0.0517670139670372, -0.04228857159614563, 0.021089663729071617, 0.00341224716976285, -0.045941807329654694, 0.004177210386842489, 0.0009103743941523135, -0.009661096148192883, 0.011295648291707039, -0.006545513868331909, 0.003888776758685708, -0.004369470290839672, -0.025066565722227097, -0.01971997693181038, 0.0027172034606337547, -0.016798870638012886, -0.054053787142038345, -0.06314586848020554, 0.030355466529726982, -0.0015544387279078364, 0.03647807613015175, -0.05565953254699707, 0.03214920684695244, 0.10137932002544403, 0.017630234360694885, 0.02430296689271927, -0.07045745849609375, -0.006985493935644627, -0.04608062654733658, -0.04501556232571602, 0.030882971361279488, 0.048360344022512436, 0.008028232492506504, -0.006045850925147533, -0.037250082939863205, 0.02565472386777401, 0.05067910999059677, 0.011782791465520859, -0.013334108516573906, 0.05770369619131088, -0.023007581010460854, -0.03965296223759651, 0.020358311012387276, 0.038052257150411606, -0.039812371134757996, -0.022867882624268532, -0.020455366000533104, 0.05224866047501564, 0.002366345375776291, -0.028637023642659187, -0.005430556368082762, -0.04194416105747223, -0.012577430345118046, 0.0006929124938324094, -0.016731778159737587, -0.009037594310939312, -0.03853147476911545, -0.04275039955973625, -0.023482298478484154, 0.02730189450085163, 0.009445801377296448, 0.035740360617637634, 0.060532696545124054, 0.0355699323117733, 0.00546204624697566, -0.0029244162142276764, -0.07576528191566467, -0.01794113591313362, 0.022999104112386703, -0.016108687967061996, 0.01745283044874668, 0.026893746107816696, 0.032899558544158936, 0.0005258442251943052, -0.0033067052718251944, -0.03621697425842285, -0.034098461270332336, -0.0461338572204113, 0.029222918674349785, -0.022566817700862885, 0.04636301100254059, 0.021636569872498512, 0.02641366235911846, 0.007893749512732029, -0.01218667533248663, -0.022016795352101326, 0.04395413398742676, -0.049538832157850266, 0.014293689280748367, -0.03387456759810448, -0.018963603302836418, 0.0384603776037693, -0.003012873698025942, 0.017666682600975037, 0.009212921373546124, 0.014189033769071102, 0.0036358600482344627, 0.028156176209449768, -0.048002276569604874, 0.014328105375170708, 0.0007010143017396331, 0.0018829724285751581, -0.027760740369558334, -0.0021079513244330883, -0.025788942351937294, -0.013448020443320274, 0.0012051801895722747, 0.007356905844062567, -0.00434854393824935, 0.03209152817726135, -0.05312512442469597, -0.02688021957874298, 0.0686696395277977, 0.03897712752223015, 0.04347284883260727, 0.00615018792450428, -0.08002764731645584, 0.02015901543200016, 0.024498729035258293, -0.011620679870247841, 0.04846354201436043, -0.004805698525160551, -0.026737505570054054, -0.08093271404504776, -0.01430671289563179, 0.012379067949950695, 0.061151016503572464, 0.006973747629672289, 0.000594831130001694, 0.047145068645477295, 0.01834106631577015, -0.03804060444235802, -0.0005001111421734095, 0.03193081542849541, 0.025404401123523712, -0.03342857211828232, -0.00716269388794899, 0.00048251182306557894, -0.014652282930910587, 0.002633661264553666, 0.03342820703983307, 0.025412090122699738, 0.014992213808000088, -0.032587312161922455, 0.0342380590736866, -0.015146620571613312, -0.02317758835852146, -0.015329509973526001, -0.005721426568925381, -0.03340040519833565, 0.02185036987066269, -0.035447314381599426, 0.015570093877613544, 0.03186403587460518, 0.009136560373008251, 0.024805912747979164, 0.039616022258996964, -0.096477210521698, 0.005299310199916363, 0.0356273278594017, 0.049173228442668915, -0.024354828521609306, 0.023237738758325577, -0.023412153124809265, -0.010301015339791775, -0.001680092653259635, -0.020981809124350548, 0.06769965589046478, 0.0016339985886588693, 0.02228998765349388, -0.045350246131420135, -0.04159132391214371, -0.03161066770553589, 0.008382788859307766, -0.018604997545480728, 0.03868371248245239, -0.015521867200732231, -0.011209988035261631, -0.037372563034296036, -0.018827322870492935, 0.0010857016313821077, 0.023146679624915123, -0.024843545630574226, -0.01591840200126171, 0.037317562848329544, -0.027169059962034225, -0.03446958214044571, -0.03814869001507759, 0.004722489509731531, -0.02673465758562088, -0.0162186436355114, 0.04462932422757149, -0.03199825435876846, -0.04266806319355965, 0.001980497734621167, 0.028148628771305084, -0.014404196292161942, -0.009350466541945934, -0.006374830845743418, 0.050721824169158936, -0.012081977911293507, -0.013263795524835587, 0.038360293954610825, 0.033367086201906204, 0.009222597815096378, 0.03039093315601349, -0.015984825789928436, 0.018962090834975243, -0.01560725923627615, -0.028137048706412315, -0.023223333060741425, -0.010084707289934158, -0.03195950388908386, 0.04020129516720772, -0.01352688018232584, -0.01721157319843769, -0.06438460946083069, -0.022523093968629837, 0.021508866921067238, 0.026548581197857857, -0.008522781543433666, -0.0038017905317246914, -0.002415297320112586, -0.015137703157961369, -0.020616963505744934, 0.01913028210401535, 0.034814100712537766, -0.025268573313951492, -0.0029334446880966425, 0.020842673256993294, -0.03928812965750694, -0.011001937091350555, -0.00022753296070732176, -0.013047746382653713, -0.003743833862245083, 0.009011825546622276, -0.016693463549017906, -0.02465326339006424, 0.030983205884695053, 0.004873963072896004, -0.05370037257671356, -0.03170429542660713, 0.037355758249759674, 0.00394411338493228, 0.04602300003170967, -0.0007812720723450184, 0.016574790701270103, -0.013688374310731888, -0.02015378698706627, -0.06713064759969711, -0.053651370108127594, 0.029997197911143303, 0.0016196020878851414, -0.058382611721754074, -0.005033986642956734, 0.016483448445796967, -0.010891715064644814, -0.050760336220264435, -0.014390758238732815, 0.07160140573978424, -0.030769243836402893, 0.011369641870260239, 0.008016236126422882, -0.0071631246246397495, 0.045252107083797455, 0.03902681544423103, -0.012392248027026653, -0.02297644503414631, -0.017823657020926476, -0.0008905005524866283, 0.016124967485666275, 0.0012973671546205878, -0.02554175816476345, -0.010981898754835129, -0.021345822140574455, 0.021832633763551712, 0.01967420056462288, -0.029020478948950768, -0.04007687792181969, 0.016394948586821556, -0.032905735075473785, 0.02431347407400608, -0.04564386233687401, 0.0004967352142557502, -0.005310395732522011, 0.003982557915151119, -0.01522755715996027, 0.02794891782104969, -0.017223773524165154, 0.006608300376683474, 0.033283524215221405, -0.021837059408426285, 0.010094287805259228, -0.02162753790616989, 0.05006764829158783, 0.010388285852968693, 0.032495319843292236, -0.0002723369107116014, -0.0005076286033727229, 0.028725875541567802, 0.017146868631243706, 0.024155065417289734, 0.005660633090883493, -0.002947410801425576, -0.0260471124202013, 0.0026095639914274216, -0.04683445394039154, -0.002083512721583247, 0.06877952069044113, 0.024915730580687523, 0.03879997506737709, 0.03247401863336563, -0.03116140328347683, -0.01791480742394924, -0.022628067061305046, -0.02200309745967388, -0.0030333036556839943, 0.0010963736567646265, 0.0456530824303627, -0.004589547868818045, -0.01602819748222828, 0.02573619969189167, 0.012634271755814552, 0.020404919981956482, 0.0676172748208046, 0.02096172794699669, -0.028569836169481277, 0.03236912563443184, -0.04963494464755058, -0.060388971120119095, 0.0057243057526648045, -0.05788193270564079, -0.009951827116310596, -0.012507646344602108, -0.02560316026210785, 0.037274062633514404, 0.04951486364006996, 0.0255830530077219, -0.07777255028486252, -0.02607729844748974, -0.074946828186512, -0.017822859808802605, 0.0232559684664011, -0.01333658304065466, -0.012210141867399216, -0.003917634021490812, 0.029952598735690117, 0.0056611173786222935, 0.03461000323295593, -0.04854903742671013, -0.08955451101064682, 0.0060253385454416275, 0.001807787804864347, -0.03018867038190365, 0.0760466605424881, -0.012069694697856903, -0.030797630548477173, -0.023009955883026123, -0.04763742536306381, 0.0076705459505319595, 0.00514258723706007, -0.01836099661886692, 0.002707126084715128, 0.05791144073009491, -0.0031971700955182314, 0.0052092913538217545, 0.02531636692583561, -0.002211072714999318, 0.142520934343338, 0.06401827931404114, 0.010199925862252712, -0.0338701568543911, 0.03626692667603493, 0.012907505966722965, 0.05338476225733757, -0.031000535935163498, 0.014292947016656399, 0.013427055440843105, -0.03887961432337761, 0.029459768906235695, 0.030569320544600487, 0.03475183993577957, -0.027800217270851135, 0.03682549670338631, -0.027051493525505066, -0.010824653320014477, 0.004128283355385065, -0.00811757892370224, 0.018654577434062958, -0.013954533264040947, 0.008990605361759663, 0.0014594398671761155, 0.009230092167854309, 0.0015043943421915174, -0.0021649845875799656, -0.014309382997453213, 0.009372761473059654, -0.022794947028160095, -0.015021979808807373, -0.01192779652774334, 0.012415295466780663, 0.026687515899538994, -0.021278781816363335, -0.010118857026100159, 0.01980496011674404, -0.04612180218100548, 0.02823719009757042, 0.03222738578915596, -0.006752853747457266, 0.0014975541271269321, 0.011698512360453606, 0.02794407494366169, -0.047557283192873, -0.045645441859960556, -0.023312849923968315, 0.06650947034358978, -0.0009066693601198494, -0.035131700336933136, -0.002195123117417097, -0.021433092653751373, 0.013798794709146023, -0.05404916778206825, -0.040571440011262894, 0.008718907833099365, -0.0017411512089893222, -0.036752812564373016, -0.009217041544616222, -0.019082942977547646, -0.012338063679635525, 0.00021262113295961171, 0.03128352388739586, 0.020052142441272736, -0.030621560290455818, -0.017667395994067192, -0.024748191237449646, 0.02980949729681015, 0.02989453263580799, 0.020679308101534843, 0.008739570155739784, 0.00925816036760807, -0.007881325669586658, 0.018388869240880013, -0.007393921725451946, 0.043684449046850204, 0.0020353517029434443, -0.0305088609457016, -0.056129518896341324, -0.04447310045361519, -0.034625209867954254, 0.0019374476978555322, -0.006367526948451996, -0.0013028060784563422, -0.07920262217521667, 0.008334429934620857, 0.022268932312726974, 0.029929472133517265, 0.018128376454114914, 0.024720080196857452, -0.008742760866880417, 0.030399499461054802, 0.010941470973193645, -0.06225551292300224, -0.008491060696542263, -0.011852966621518135, -0.0064634885638952255, -0.0017299382016062737, -0.0033136385027319193, 0.04409436136484146, -0.005232077557593584, -0.00567054096609354, 0.013722540810704231, 0.031308937817811966, 0.013952350243926048, 0.05099954828619957, 0.005877126939594746, -0.05240606889128685, 0.023833276703953743, -0.02234589494764805, -0.012945310212671757, -0.006962853949517012, -0.005707928445190191, -0.06846484541893005, -0.000427646329626441, 0.014557022601366043, -0.02927675098180771, -0.01308993436396122, 0.005628611892461777, -0.029554570093750954, 0.05152313411235809, -0.03971601277589798, 0.025511182844638824, -0.05064452067017555, 0.00024568915250711143, -0.04389381408691406, -0.01814584992825985, 0.003935487009584904, 0.020648671314120293, -0.027118463069200516, 0.026284461840987206, 0.0026650612708181143, -0.007839011028409004, -0.012733795680105686, -0.011968540027737617, 0.01765338145196438, 0.012741790153086185, 0.05618524178862572, 0.02855915017426014, -0.032180581241846085, 0.012538682669401169, -0.02449340559542179, -0.026028942316770554, 0.050574891269207, -0.004030494950711727, 0.023300331085920334, 0.028105856850743294, 0.019977271556854248, 0.015161989256739616, 0.07981501519680023, -0.006013946607708931, -0.025226349011063576, 0.04431525245308876, -0.03796688839793205, 0.0022219109814614058, -0.020763421431183815, -0.012987877242267132, 0.046899039298295975, -0.016234394162893295, 0.024040227755904198, 0.03979676216840744, 0.03344222158193588, 0.000005243514351604972, -0.000825692608486861, -0.058089081197977066, 0.028783665969967842, -0.009550511837005615, -0.014320893213152885, 0.0314045175909996, 0.02290555089712143, -0.0007598055526614189, 0.03169175237417221, 0.00402047298848629, 0.020362846553325653, -0.06399199366569519, -0.010591365396976471, 0.012182634323835373, 0.08589994162321091, 0.04786268621683121, -0.025431320071220398, -0.0036825432907789946, 0.00529493298381567, -0.033444251865148544, 0.01958390511572361, -0.02952302247285843, 0.0027328559663146734, -0.03951255977153778, 0.008857052773237228, -0.029261427000164986, -0.034886281937360764, 0.014745423570275307, 0.006731975823640823, 0.011282546445727348, 0.06558658182621002, -0.01882682926952839, -0.022131165489554405, -0.007338003721088171, 0.0004410377878230065, 0.00270969420671463, -0.02565712295472622, 0.008120782673358917, -0.018562868237495422, 0.005155702121555805, 0.013449003919959068, 0.018959814682602882, 0.03480494022369385, 0.05820970982313156, 0.03347251936793327, 0.024631178006529808, 0.03722966089844704, 0.025119900703430176, -0.02524777501821518, 0.0326734222471714, -0.0077218967489898205, 0.014022703282535076, 0.03100762702524662, -0.021457910537719727, -0.020302096381783485, 0.008783716708421707, -0.04721051827073097, -0.00205809623003006, 0.007049881387501955, -0.011775331571698189, 0.0036369385197758675, 0.011818031780421734, -0.01239211019128561, -0.010925978422164917, -0.02152985706925392, 0.00996059738099575, -0.05386263504624367, -0.03482048586010933, 0.03455793485045433, -0.009642173536121845, -0.04881468415260315, 0.0119777237996459, -0.048727769404649734, -0.0145787438377738, 0.004861492197960615, -0.014899048954248428, 0.026656977832317352, -0.02438637614250183, -0.01426516193896532, 0.002759210765361786, 0.00488820718601346, -0.034356292337179184, 0.05073463171720505, -0.025640640407800674, 0.0540749728679657, -0.028504906222224236, -0.007362188771367073, 0.01488343346863985, -0.015524033457040787, 0.04852363094687462, -0.059574760496616364, 0.042854852974414825, -0.0004738591378554702, -0.05873517692089081, -0.03728165477514267, -0.013236705213785172, -0.01726299338042736, 0.04908198490738869, 0.06750050187110901, -0.0404127761721611, -0.05676564574241638, 0.0016865826910361648, 0.04691208526492119, 0.006914960220456123, -0.02491549402475357, 0.02226562798023224, 0.026879027485847473, -0.004463563673198223, -0.004165447782725096, -0.011900185607373714, 0.016775615513324738, -0.017469510436058044, 0.03704070672392845, -0.03182472288608551, 0.007979831658303738, -0.005856873467564583, -0.0018560501048341393, 0.009041703306138515, 0.01632073149085045, -0.013194759376347065, 0.031374555081129074, -0.011031663045287132, -0.038755178451538086, 0.0452907532453537, -0.008360697887837887, -0.06332956999540329, 0.03416109085083008, -0.012773762457072735, 0.002206098288297653, 0.018052617087960243, 0.027719669044017792, 0.02474617026746273, 0.001165734021924436, 0.009219519793987274, 0.019962524995207787, 0.015046859160065651, -0.007734938059002161, 0.06665417551994324, 0.022601034492254257, -0.003983349073678255, -0.007726236712187529, 0.01045955903828144, 0.005936616566032171, 0.014743044041097164, 0.03754524886608124, 0.026521027088165283, 0.0010309572098776698, -0.007486690767109394, -0.00006848554767202586, 0.03616659343242645, -0.029131878167390823, 0.022838333621621132, 0.00852185022085905, 0.018820378929376602, -0.011179987341165543, 0.013475872576236725, 0.02112031914293766, 0.021621890366077423, -0.018169628456234932, 0.05622592568397522, -0.008517448790371418, 0.023853344842791557, -0.02365926094353199, -0.013626768253743649, -0.026514211669564247, 0.015838414430618286, -0.023321790620684624, 0.01114495936781168, 0.03708416968584061, 0.01862523891031742, 0.009799140505492687, 0.005293519236147404, -0.003274539252743125, -0.050776753574609756, -0.03357774764299393, -0.018802499398589134, -0.012559880502521992, -0.008261548355221748, -0.01643401011824608, -0.016191693022847176, 0.0038377337623387575, -0.03893326595425606, -0.020403152331709862, 0.045761626213788986, 0.02963109500706196, -0.000012499342119554058, -0.049646299332380295, -0.001721867243759334, 0.015648478642106056, 0.07780078798532486, -0.038483209908008575, 0.003926113713532686, -0.030236324295401573, 0.04802795872092247, 0.016041038557887077, -0.00028213547193445265 ]
<p>I need help with the following question:</p> <p>Consider $m$ observations $(y_1; n_1); ... ; (y_m; n_m)$, where $y_i \sim Bin(n_i; θ_i)$ are binomial variables. Assume that $θ_i \sim w_1Beta(α_1; β_1) + w_2Beta(α_2; β_2)$ are mixture from two Beta distributions $(w_1 + w_2 = 1)$. </p> <ul> <li>Derive a Laplace approximation of the likelihood and each mixture component of the prior. </li> <li>Derive the empirical Bayes likelihood of the data by integrating out i using the Laplace approximation, and leave the hyper-parameters $(w_j ; α_j ; β_j)$ (j = 1; 2) </li> <li>Derive the EM algorithm to estimate the hyperparameters (you may use also mixture of Gaussian prior to approximate mixture of Beta prior)</li> </ul>
48,384
[ -0.03943432867527008, 0.005256344564259052, -0.0049890815280377865, -0.0024682332295924425, 0.04687441512942314, 0.014474084600806236, 0.006550352089107037, -0.009594853036105633, 0.045324672013521194, -0.034647390246391296, 0.014218609780073166, 0.05478936806321144, 0.08076269924640656, 0.0027477750554680824, 0.03847908601164818, -0.01313423365354538, -0.021746190264821053, 0.004283256828784943, 0.0035411652643233538, 0.0070569803938269615, 0.0099196070805192, 0.01779521442949772, 0.021470487117767334, -0.03288519009947777, -0.04583005979657173, 0.03239292651414871, 0.03367956727743149, -0.035636454820632935, -0.022583015263080597, 0.07756524533033371, -0.024993713945150375, -0.0223176721483469, 0.03479098528623581, 0.030012959614396095, -0.03194437175989151, -0.028942327946424484, -0.06878367066383362, -0.025251276791095734, -0.011660760268568993, 0.03189481794834137, -0.02283974550664425, -0.0461602546274662, -0.02558627538383007, 0.0025323876179754734, -0.01674574613571167, -0.0194285586476326, -0.008171431720256805, -0.02954730950295925, -0.005954954773187637, -0.034139033406972885, 0.07738077640533447, 0.006673096679151058, 0.04759756475687027, 0.03677085414528847, -0.012902959249913692, -0.01962006837129593, 0.023964272812008858, 0.09848286211490631, 0.03341509774327278, -0.03977299481630325, -0.03767156973481178, -0.046984076499938965, 0.007389989215880632, -0.04607035592198372, -0.03430372476577759, 0.04946473240852356, -0.0073154037818312645, 0.0007324098260141909, 0.00739180576056242, -0.025437070056796074, 0.03355677053332329, 0.006110457703471184, 0.036840811371803284, 0.0036257512401789427, 0.006520313676446676, -0.027892496436834335, 0.000608765403740108, 0.04846134036779404, 0.03620745614171028, 0.024859841912984848, 0.015946481376886368, 0.007599656470119953, 0.030758028849959373, 0.04691433161497116, -0.007251710165292025, -0.014652721583843231, 0.09177304804325104, 0.013161985203623772, -0.00898344349116087, 0.027971060946583748, -0.014592299237847328, 0.03416705131530762, 0.04167729616165161, -0.012524132616817951, -0.037805527448654175, 0.06642068177461624, -0.005690281745046377, 0.04554462060332298, 0.00437195785343647, -0.021965833380818367, -0.009904589504003525, -0.01850290596485138, 0.0007984294788911939, 0.06339550018310547, -0.03170356899499893, -0.050150711089372635, -0.006779570132493973, 0.006608937401324511, -0.013859301805496216, -0.039336901158094406, -0.008181273937225342, 0.04116244241595268, 0.015684157609939575, -0.041707009077072144, 0.0005834992625750601, -0.006384020205587149, 0.002939031459391117, -0.0313163660466671, 0.04286924749612808, 0.07818496972322464, 0.028298083692789078, -0.036574169993400574, 0.011533147655427456, -0.017451882362365723, -0.05575333908200264, -0.015386523678898811, -0.002743674209341407, -0.019412824884057045, -0.026149611920118332, 0.03817912936210632, 0.0008900989778339863, -0.03169993311166763, 0.07195410877466202, 0.009417692199349403, -0.027244770899415016, -0.00267228065058589, -0.05085169896483421, -0.04785197973251343, 0.0023605157621204853, -0.010641787201166153, 0.019800683483481407, -0.06286004185676575, 0.007012571208178997, 0.05699184909462929, 0.05663217976689339, 0.01248463336378336, 0.021726470440626144, 0.022029006853699684, 0.052242543548345566, -0.0015999581664800644, -0.042342714965343475, -0.037195589393377304, -0.02706550993025303, 0.011040540412068367, -0.03786681219935417, -0.10295983403921127, 0.013619332574307919, -0.0023956617806106806, -0.022165533155202866, -0.011771961115300655, 0.03028053604066372, 0.02264263853430748, -0.023558197543025017, -0.020178712904453278, 0.028520114719867706, -0.029356496408581734, 0.07158461213111877, 0.00774235837161541, 0.017727872356772423, 0.06207664683461189, -0.023579871281981468, 0.026123324409127235, -0.012995057739317417, 0.040047354996204376, 0.037327930331230164, -0.03995818272233009, -0.03134239464998245, -0.015124634839594364, 0.020398559048771858, 0.035886529833078384, 0.003832685062661767, -0.026245594024658203, -0.013912592083215714, 0.009985649026930332, 0.02899545431137085, 0.036990728229284286, -0.009959985502064228, -0.046512264758348465, 0.006569164339452982, -0.042537059634923935, -0.034901972860097885, -0.07648260146379471, -0.011049815453588963, -0.05606592446565628, -0.01807178370654583, 0.05607328936457634, -0.023382950574159622, -0.01692393235862255, 0.0017122604185715318, -0.007902869023382664, -0.013328108936548233, -0.0028764167800545692, 0.038707394152879715, -0.024800080806016922, 0.011735143139958382, 0.0487251915037632, 0.049845945090055466, -0.03546444699168205, 0.06121476739645004, -0.028008101508021355, -0.03893129155039787, 0.012479783967137337, -0.04576711356639862, -0.00397920235991478, 0.003664012299850583, -0.00596932927146554, -0.014817027375102043, -0.03152715787291527, -0.015495993196964264, 0.01605011150240898, -0.036919478327035904, 0.05445350334048271, 0.06672867387533188, 0.030725980177521706, -0.015046543441712856, 0.012118603102862835, 0.0003684343828354031, 0.04175815358757973, 0.0017153728986158967, 0.016051553189754486, -0.047153372317552567, 0.006535207852721214, 0.06599434465169907, 0.00932492595165968, -0.042598385363817215, 0.04883991926908493, 0.016306845471262932, 0.003997426480054855, 0.015290074050426483, 0.019093768671154976, 0.0065064881928265095, -0.0038205841556191444, 0.016313418745994568, 0.005561360623687506, -0.01257114764302969, 0.0014471240574494004, 0.020689407363533974, 0.0011680669849738479, 0.05312282219529152, -0.0400482602417469, -0.014703452587127686, 0.043411847203969955, -0.020797202363610268, 0.0035303093027323484, -0.046878598630428314, -0.024708189070224762, 0.07476978003978729, -0.004772080574184656, 0.020924625918269157, 0.02849481627345085, 0.016758542507886887, 0.033232707530260086, 0.005601424258202314, -0.014049544930458069, 0.010422089137136936, 0.024927692487835884, -0.04988473653793335, 0.013908732682466507, 0.005683799274265766, -0.0426907055079937, 0.03750377893447876, -0.003075632033869624, -0.02618533745408058, -0.014451763592660427, 0.02239413931965828, 0.004824214149266481, 0.011862749233841896, -0.011781874112784863, -0.04873279109597206, -0.04991624876856804, -0.006222384981811047, -0.023535870015621185, 0.03351367637515068, -0.012488835491240025, -0.06483142822980881, 0.023237334564328194, -0.03877169266343117, 0.024894658476114273, 0.04194032400846481, 0.029661301523447037, -0.02692554146051407, -0.002155983354896307, 0.012618182227015495, -0.0738682746887207, -0.03390834107995033, 0.012957812286913395, -0.006109441164880991, -0.02476082369685173, 0.003587917657569051, 0.051559001207351685, 0.02333395555615425, -0.01167101040482521, 0.029301417991518974, -0.01205387432128191, -0.031796373426914215, -0.03312379866838455, -0.0007524459506385028, -0.005464646965265274, 0.00905978586524725, 0.02889818698167801, 0.029364313930273056, -0.00552707351744175, -0.0012673953315243125, -0.08445344865322113, -0.0700092539191246, 0.024248551577329636, 0.0028512345161288977, 0.029136640951037407, 0.008522775955498219, -0.04015066474676132, 0.07441771030426025, 0.029037121683359146, -0.0416952408850193, -0.008899400942027569, 0.020415684208273888, -0.013637484982609749, -0.016025865450501442, -0.00006993916758801788, 0.010115793906152248, 0.019258636981248856, 0.018206695094704628, 0.025287093594670296, -0.005279627628624439, 0.046275850385427475, 0.016713641583919525, 0.02803969755768776, 0.03747710585594177, 0.010252085514366627, -0.002387557178735733, 0.039544183760881424, -0.001066809636540711, 0.021372519433498383, 0.017809314653277397, -0.017252689227461815, 0.008316832594573498, 0.01613079011440277, -0.02279292233288288, 0.008993604220449924, -0.02054852806031704, -0.014361743815243244, -0.02252652309834957, 0.05329243466258049, 0.04417005553841591, -0.0529874823987484, 0.02183089777827263, 0.0006730500608682632, 0.02832433022558689, -0.038849227130413055, -0.013908691704273224, 0.07216526567935944, 0.023223387077450752, -0.03863461688160896, -0.04911617562174797, -0.004649100359529257, 0.0023253518156707287, 0.0019673483911901712, -0.0165423396974802, -0.015035645104944706, 0.009706061333417892, 0.05954364687204361, 0.026215650141239166, -0.030094442889094353, -0.04781804978847504, -0.007579365745186806, -0.0673154816031456, 0.031832121312618256, -0.010067139752209187, 0.017014427110552788, 0.019418010488152504, 0.036209892481565475, 0.008354037068784237, 0.0023783280048519373, 0.03477966785430908, 0.015892159193754196, -0.07110823690891266, 0.03274963051080704, 0.010770588181912899, -0.013247056864202023, 0.010795670561492443, -0.015697307884693146, 0.047630976885557175, -0.017472296953201294, -0.007780792657285929, -0.01239374652504921, 0.021904336288571358, -0.026150278747081757, 0.009469487704336643, -0.07580925524234772, -0.024783525615930557, -0.00465374393388629, 0.021537913009524345, -0.010955041274428368, -0.0028941810596734285, 0.015348096378147602, 0.02895362116396427, -0.007528573740273714, -0.003789749462157488, -0.020432688295841217, 0.01475410908460617, -0.025655755773186684, 0.029031578451395035, 0.026372822001576424, 0.04815666750073433, -0.020867202430963516, 0.019161421805620193, 0.01510805543512106, 0.04038970544934273, 0.04206331819295883, 0.003627670230343938, -0.024623412638902664, -0.01371885184198618, 0.001321054296568036, 0.005216389428824186, 0.04963024705648422, 0.0036959259305149317, 0.016711194068193436, 0.04230758920311928, 0.021175632253289223, -0.03749643266201019, 0.004235814791172743, 0.051628585904836655, 0.030738141387701035, 0.029468411579728127, -0.036196380853652954, -0.0023208458442240953, -0.00385308382101357, -0.007685279473662376, 0.025600461289286613, -0.010884488932788372, 0.009908923879265785, -0.03692646697163582, 0.03393936902284622, -0.038686905056238174, -0.002886697184294462, 0.021940315142273903, 0.029288044199347496, 0.020641330629587173, 0.050072990357875824, -0.04594143107533455, 0.01317407377064228, 0.05818038061261177, 0.05942527949810028, -0.012466262094676495, 0.008005122654139996, -0.0858568325638771, -0.0033637501765042543, 0.013678996823728085, 0.024663513526320457, -0.0261492021381855, -0.011938526295125484, -0.06050018221139908, 0.0011495916405692697, 0.023599356412887573, -0.010602198541164398, 0.03132467716932297, -0.026803448796272278, -0.001987745985388756, 0.006965239532291889, 0.01296263188123703, -0.0778474360704422, 0.005441402085125446, -0.02139107510447502, 0.03235144540667534, -0.008157521486282349, -0.018191473558545113, -0.03631221503019333, -0.010518141090869904, 0.05660223215818405, 0.09196872264146805, 0.01776864007115364, -0.039566125720739365, 0.007484626490622759, 0.016300542280077934, -0.046949177980422974, -0.06264635920524597, 0.03746163100004196, -0.007344089914113283, -0.03530677407979965, 0.03141745924949646, -0.036030516028404236, -0.03541816398501396, 0.018933460116386414, 0.009069674648344517, -0.02460341528058052, -0.021060355007648468, -0.0033287471160292625, 0.03564334288239479, 0.041599106043577194, 0.0030154732521623373, 0.0836104229092598, -0.006128895096480846, -0.02771867625415325, -0.005001210607588291, -0.04151341691613197, -0.021617284044623375, -0.03840714320540428, 0.006324398797005415, -0.032862503081560135, 0.014389663934707642, -0.02954808622598648, 0.03782424330711365, -0.022781217470765114, 0.015635574236512184, 0.003025987185537815, -0.04656432196497917, 0.018924487754702568, 0.022449510172009468, -0.001478266785852611, -0.0017268857918679714, -0.03313329815864563, 0.01749298721551895, 0.021199969574809074, 0.0027263036463409662, 0.05710067227482796, -0.03727421164512634, 0.019222106784582138, 0.0010553390020504594, -0.027935359627008438, 0.012876441702246666, -0.023365842178463936, -0.02593918889760971, 0.017986509948968887, -0.005516292527318001, 0.013007105328142643, -0.007377445697784424, 0.04391904175281525, 0.01669144071638584, 0.00029809330590069294, -0.03987259790301323, 0.02380366437137127, -0.0028670048341155052, 0.057126790285110474, -0.01494416780769825, 0.008865466341376305, 0.006054960656911135, -0.0036127702333033085, -0.051089268177747726, -0.05387752875685692, 0.03970813751220703, 0.013805309310555458, -0.0021349911112338305, -0.03469898924231529, 0.011542275547981262, 0.0016205311985686421, -0.045367531478405, 0.0023827210534363985, 0.0635281354188919, -0.01314885076135397, -0.01678360626101494, 0.009420009329915047, 0.05449587479233742, 0.0578497052192688, 0.021312236785888672, 0.007597723510116339, 0.02152937650680542, -0.02815893106162548, -0.01943531073629856, 0.015162711963057518, 0.016205579042434692, -0.04870240017771721, 0.021624932065606117, -0.024402132257819176, 0.0028334702365100384, 0.05710954964160919, -0.040996868163347244, -0.019269177690148354, 0.0065263002179563046, 0.048475299030542374, -0.02311118133366108, -0.04003676399588585, -0.024395357817411423, 0.017465602606534958, 0.009247848764061928, -0.018520761281251907, -0.004003025591373444, -0.015786299481987953, -0.01199005451053381, 0.06699654459953308, -0.024321861565113068, -0.01639951951801777, -0.005649100057780743, 0.08018749207258224, -0.02648085355758667, 0.028110921382904053, 0.019065408036112785, -0.0034459030721336603, 0.021860996261239052, 0.015199418179690838, -0.0003382486174814403, 0.04194169119000435, 0.01763586886227131, -0.0532136969268322, 0.0013906609965488315, -0.058368586003780365, 0.023996712639927864, 0.07142692804336548, -0.010224220342934132, 0.019809404388070107, 0.001719586318358779, 0.009747177362442017, -0.01949276588857174, -0.011603644117712975, -0.007655892986804247, 0.003139419248327613, -0.008648966439068317, 0.03286617994308472, -0.0023498241789638996, -0.030390676110982895, 0.06393586844205856, 0.0010973279131576419, 0.033810168504714966, 0.01583128422498703, 0.000999793759547174, 0.023976966738700867, 0.03742879256606102, -0.019871395081281662, -0.05363503098487854, 0.03889237344264984, -0.030092215165495872, 0.006876110099256039, -0.024234171956777573, -0.056801386177539825, 0.045443132519721985, 0.05845531448721886, -0.001904616947285831, -0.040193986147642136, -0.012893164530396461, -0.03206823393702507, 0.027149278670549393, 0.014513980597257614, 0.015450705774128437, 0.07076657563447952, 0.009999300353229046, 0.02376197651028633, -0.009589442983269691, 0.03523341193795204, -0.008911678567528725, -0.07097501307725906, -0.011751560494303703, -0.0034862104803323746, -0.02970099449157715, 0.00009945480996975675, -0.003281328361481428, -0.03197995945811272, 0.02460017241537571, -0.010822194628417492, 0.05332004278898239, 0.012508649379014969, 0.037164222449064255, -0.012519746087491512, 0.056579191237688065, 0.007164436392486095, 0.023815801367163658, -0.01795659214258194, 0.001736025675199926, 0.09577173739671707, 0.1018005907535553, 0.061560217291116714, -0.06029742956161499, -0.0038437610492110252, 0.01972690038383007, -0.009873149916529655, -0.039039161056280136, -0.013225493021309376, 0.008193757385015488, -0.04265535995364189, -0.013143092393875122, 0.06502982974052429, 0.003197649959474802, 0.002279074164107442, 0.060899823904037476, -0.02494320273399353, -0.011168024502694607, 0.005756264086812735, -0.012117605656385422, -0.022105557844042778, -0.03514055162668228, -0.03334546089172363, 0.03344062715768814, 0.01934075728058815, -0.058900319039821625, -0.019151216372847557, -0.01872975565493107, -0.007059847470372915, 0.00634776521474123, -0.03249867632985115, -0.010417654179036617, -0.0011292845010757446, -0.018289437517523766, 0.01451627817004919, 0.0007062230724841356, 0.015277154743671417, -0.01754581369459629, 0.030746109783649445, 0.026121845468878746, 0.014394140802323818, 0.018806038424372673, 0.019311295822262764, 0.02569052204489708, -0.04504195600748062, -0.039041392505168915, -0.025494972243905067, 0.0612744577229023, -0.01781247928738594, -0.013563666492700577, 0.005780279636383057, -0.03267508000135422, -0.00033057815744541585, -0.057269249111413956, 0.016480697318911552, 0.026046348735690117, -0.002036014338955283, -0.027915827929973602, -0.0020557185634970665, -0.046139683574438095, 0.03736547753214836, 0.0066519672982394695, 0.00013846864749211818, 0.008951250463724136, -0.04046022146940231, -0.024016112089157104, -0.001831364817917347, 0.036734260618686676, 0.006287368480116129, -0.04348212853074074, 0.0004815908905584365, -0.0344010628759861, -0.01807916909456253, -0.005965379998087883, 0.019008047878742218, -0.0336664654314518, 0.005772036965936422, 0.015850791707634926, -0.0261326115578413, 0.008749553933739662, -0.03652442991733551, -0.011379876174032688, -0.008674180135130882, -0.01686975173652172, -0.053762659430503845, -0.014913258142769337, 0.02114635333418846, 0.039855118840932846, 0.0005745689268223941, -0.008725026622414589, -0.00793417077511549, 0.04821636900305748, 0.014105139300227165, -0.032866086810827255, -0.02928915247321129, 0.0133805051445961, -0.027254989370703697, 0.012927391566336155, -0.01417966466397047, 0.05331817641854286, 0.018539682030677795, 0.041447944939136505, 0.008399656973779202, 0.005416681990027428, -0.014642932452261448, 0.03473544493317604, -0.04177943244576454, -0.052751827985048294, -0.005123952403664589, -0.0053779371082782745, 0.011138970963656902, -0.0019988776184618473, 0.00006558922177646309, -0.0260474793612957, -0.012496830895543098, 0.012924684211611748, -0.019252710044384003, -0.03513142094016075, -0.005687493830919266, 0.0038404467049986124, 0.00005007467916584574, -0.020651238039135933, 0.019022097811102867, 0.03442750871181488, 0.0017516242805868387, -0.004307050257921219, -0.005421503446996212, 0.01117150392383337, 0.03568599745631218, -0.046024665236473083, -0.014933902770280838, 0.04646541550755501, 0.01336667500436306, 0.024859894067049026, -0.016619617119431496, 0.00925167091190815, 0.013697952963411808, 0.034103650599718094, -0.03132718428969383, -0.03801501914858818, 0.040224507451057434, -0.04324590042233467, -0.02660943567752838, 0.01607181504368782, -0.013751152902841568, 0.016315679997205734, 0.034730833023786545, -0.018335485830903053, -0.054223742336034775, 0.03491894528269768, -0.033962737768888474, -0.021567825227975845, -0.015843819826841354, 0.003949036821722984, 0.005607370287179947, -0.022926613688468933, -0.005749390460550785, 0.043193601071834564, 0.019315365701913834, 0.0288779828697443, 0.04265330731868744, 0.04452834278345108, -0.011916948482394218, 0.02870658040046692, 0.027615491300821304, 0.016711676493287086, 0.007258969359099865, 0.0008029783493839204, -0.008897481486201286, 0.06442929059267044, -0.02377300336956978, 0.0637952908873558, -0.015966156497597694, -0.012004408985376358, -0.09121226519346237, -0.008368945680558681, 0.004370056092739105, -0.0012220731005072594, 0.04107518866658211, -0.05202655494213104, 0.04357583448290825, 0.044135529547929764, -0.011150490492582321, 0.023614680394530296, -0.008664430119097233, -0.0054641226306557655, -0.027209846302866936, 0.024066608399152756, -0.018693288788199425, 0.0007273168885149062, 0.007576055824756622, 0.03494991362094879, 0.04440853372216225, -0.004756619222462177, -0.015074347145855427, -0.01676073670387268, -0.03445754945278168, -0.00892838928848505, 0.026292139664292336, -0.0766298770904541, 0.054628729820251465, -0.04423825442790985, -0.03136782348155975, 0.032776523381471634, 0.018802190199494362, 0.023803699761629105, 0.011990595608949661, 0.00995392631739378, 0.015856372192502022, 0.015489625744521618, 0.019710568711161613, 0.013691102154552937, 0.01278818491846323, 0.000966751656960696, 0.0025090081617236137, -0.0018088381038978696, -0.03906770795583725, 0.011266110464930534, 0.0051039294339716434, -0.0034637877251952887, -0.026633059605956078, 0.014663057401776314, 0.00834634155035019, -0.03985840082168579, -0.013169271871447563, -0.019897054880857468, -0.005418375600129366, -0.02479756809771061, 0.026352526620030403, -0.018173078075051308, -0.006451008841395378, 0.04167169705033302, 0.007391674909740686, -0.024436021223664284, 0.008623087778687477, -0.02220165729522705, -0.049078360199928284, 0.021062862128019333, 0.027588332071900368, -0.021455997601151466, -0.04389714077115059, -0.02107839845120907, 0.0009328981395810843, 0.014002667739987373, -0.02833298034965992, -0.0026858411729335785, -0.057690054178237915, 0.056878700852394104, -0.03710055351257324, 0.004756283015012741, 0.02205408550798893, 0.017560642212629318, 0.005618521943688393, -0.062204793095588684, 0.04823726415634155, -0.01713297888636589, -0.048665400594472885, -0.0014290546532720327, -0.0038677568081766367, -0.037272725254297256, -0.016453994438052177, 0.06157512217760086, 0.01290892157703638, 0.015597445890307426, -0.000008714341674931347, 0.02534312941133976, 0.0037756995297968388, -0.06556563079357147, 0.040601324290037155, -0.012855065055191517, -0.024472232908010483, -0.006827442441135645, -0.0059257978573441505, 0.0343223437666893, 0.023593049496412277, -0.008637757040560246, -0.021801048889756203, -0.015272231772542, 0.007110618986189365, -0.0011735730804502964, -0.045031871646642685, -0.034423429518938065, 0.004664239473640919, 0.05593752861022949, 0.0022751742508262396, 0.03537015616893768, 0.00456819636747241, -0.01117590069770813, -0.05339944735169411, 0.02235005795955658, -0.02725895307958126, -0.017662029713392258, 0.004966731648892164, -0.0391140952706337, -0.014885727316141129, -0.09276088327169418, 0.0008200823212973773, -0.002975967712700367, -0.04480965435504913, 0.014939174056053162, 0.03352627903223038, -0.005505925975739956, 0.06858986616134644, 0.01936119794845581, 0.03168458119034767, 0.027063146233558655, -0.008764968253672123, 0.02909238636493683, 0.04846520721912384, 0.04402100294828415, -0.044618237763643265, 0.014152796939015388, 0.05394495651125908, -0.0036096610128879547, 0.015765497460961342, -0.02454247884452343, 0.015069525688886642, -0.02773282118141651, -0.06303928047418594, 0.03131861239671707, -0.026547297835350037, 0.004684362560510635, -0.023572178557515144, -0.021699702367186546, 0.05652603507041931, -0.0389128178358078, 0.0011867238208651543, -0.010628116317093372, 0.011484725400805473, -0.05402907729148865, 0.007639831863343716, -0.01950990967452526, -0.0012065659975633025, 0.008519232273101807, 0.005644557997584343, -0.00463341036811471, -0.022607246413826942, -0.0023721957113593817, -0.025751829147338867, -0.021853357553482056, -0.005178987048566341, -0.007821664214134216, 0.00011840211664093658, -0.05188318341970444, -0.012215263210237026, -0.043245911598205566, 0.01669757254421711, 0.01945146918296814, 0.01817101612687111, -0.008735244162380695, 0.004566862713545561, -0.004941865801811218, 0.03293122351169586, -0.042204197496175766, -0.0001573358167661354, -0.012745058164000511, -0.011279609985649586, 0.008953138254582882, -0.0315726175904274 ]
<p>I have a huge dataset (millions of rows, thousands of columns) and <code>glmnet</code> Lasso regularised regression is too slow.</p> <p>I am wondering what other libraries there are that try to implement regularised linear model estimation extremely efficiently? I don't necessarily need a distributed solution (it can estimate on one CPU), and it is fine for me to load all data to RAM (so an <code>R</code> solution may be fine, if one exists that's faster somehow than <code>glmnet</code>). It also does not necessarily need to be Lasso or Elastic Net.</p> <p>I can use java, python or R.</p> <p>My data is pretty messy, some columns are sparse, some have heavy autocorrelation, etc. </p>
33,249
[ -0.048909228295087814, 0.04737311974167824, -0.020407531410455704, -0.01637800969183445, 0.03368070721626282, -0.0033346519339829683, -0.019345710054039955, -0.01905863918364048, 0.022739548236131668, -0.032963111996650696, 0.06143670529127121, 0.049795929342508316, 0.06675899773836136, -0.002517892513424158, 0.013993468135595322, -0.0096734669059515, -0.038197796791791916, -0.007942475378513336, -0.02262645587325096, -0.03791456297039986, 0.0010178179945796728, 0.009041285142302513, 0.01183847151696682, 0.0009905407205224037, -0.01943473145365715, 0.04702318459749222, 0.01802460476756096, -0.01460023783147335, -0.03843807429075241, 0.058606553822755814, -0.02514147013425827, -0.0161335077136755, -0.024570543318986893, 0.05646197125315666, 0.020381661131978035, 0.007911881431937218, -0.029079671949148178, -0.0467836931347847, -0.025588637217879295, 0.05686108022928238, 0.03243374824523926, -0.05554916709661484, -0.009000102058053017, 0.012920348905026913, 0.012790743261575699, 0.06643127650022507, 0.002194956410676241, -0.0350695438683033, 0.027538936585187912, -0.028425004333257675, 0.07376314699649811, -0.007776011247187853, 0.05139504745602608, 0.000583467714022845, -0.03494436666369438, 0.02122347615659237, 0.03978089988231659, 0.07675627619028091, 0.002053143223747611, -0.07580335438251495, -0.02549884282052517, -0.014236030168831348, 0.02056301012635231, -0.054319530725479126, -0.031044183298945427, 0.03938958793878555, -0.019289931282401085, 0.000927607761695981, 0.022990072146058083, 0.006935916841030121, 0.004573799669742584, 0.011436788365244865, 0.048640549182891846, 0.011510759592056274, 0.0020846943370997906, -0.01808173768222332, -0.024173904210329056, 0.0015280962688848376, 0.05765359848737717, 0.008792988955974579, -0.01808352768421173, 0.022978708148002625, 0.007922434248030186, -0.011099460534751415, 0.024979243054986, -0.01642785407602787, 0.07428152859210968, -0.015802759677171707, 0.0069521148689091206, 0.031958580017089844, -0.015924042090773582, -0.007751895114779472, 0.03324319049715996, 0.018651360645890236, -0.024203211069107056, 0.016263941302895546, 0.0021418279502540827, 0.027120567858219147, 0.01402661856263876, -0.022045131772756577, -0.02088644914329052, -0.04115987941622734, -0.03549831733107567, 0.0548795610666275, -0.024953696876764297, 0.008122913539409637, -0.0404365211725235, -0.025623386725783348, -0.07242389023303986, -0.0068870242685079575, -0.010602015070617199, 0.008788883686065674, -0.01976170390844345, -0.013001509010791779, 0.020831072703003883, -0.033005762845277786, -0.002887691603973508, -0.018903402611613274, 0.024835769087076187, 0.11706505715847015, 0.01758110336959362, -0.028413770720362663, 0.032053351402282715, -0.04199589788913727, -0.039331190288066864, 0.028432033956050873, 0.0012588930549100041, -0.04240237921476364, -0.04334540665149689, 0.07005853950977325, -0.008215345442295074, -0.07342246919870377, 0.04550337418913841, 0.0023022876121103764, 0.024563388898968697, -0.023926520720124245, -0.07211954891681671, -0.07879631966352463, 0.05610940605401993, -0.03507150337100029, 0.03301490843296051, -0.01888301968574524, 0.03067583031952381, 0.0003707669966388494, 0.07394453883171082, 0.05772938206791878, 0.03248357027769089, 0.04173293709754944, -0.000128801359096542, -0.05105876177549362, -0.016606280580163002, -0.031431738287210464, -0.018460851162672043, 0.03123086504638195, -0.0021230897400528193, -0.06022530049085617, 0.012848706915974617, -0.01925966888666153, -0.032529350370168686, 0.04268954321742058, 0.041591960936784744, 0.02441345527768135, -0.003407616401091218, 0.01278961356729269, 0.001051022089086473, -0.03705340251326561, 0.05007233843207359, 0.015770800411701202, 0.06367619335651398, 0.032675039023160934, -0.007624207995831966, -0.014985403046011925, 0.04684663563966751, 0.031087158247828484, 0.037313949316740036, -0.015965571627020836, -0.014539499767124653, -0.01127449981868267, 0.021553268656134605, 0.04559925198554993, -0.03184875473380089, -0.02713589370250702, 0.013275316916406155, -0.018222853541374207, 0.019235102459788322, 0.03896792232990265, 0.012722278945147991, -0.04333766549825668, 0.04358813539147377, -0.041297294199466705, -0.0201560091227293, -0.04454747959971428, 0.026766253635287285, 0.017379822209477425, 0.011197729036211967, 0.01150404755026102, 0.021402036771178246, 0.00959757436066866, 0.005188160575926304, -0.016679760068655014, 0.0007086137193255126, 0.031893543899059296, 0.018348105251789093, 0.008617233484983444, -0.035630904138088226, 0.043965477496385574, 0.02178613282740116, -0.04488755390048027, 0.05657970905303955, -0.022247890010476112, -0.04935538023710251, 0.004220147151499987, -0.024978334084153175, -0.01772976852953434, -0.03268001973628998, -0.017338810488581657, 0.014938175678253174, -0.005617931019514799, -0.011094671674072742, 0.0001357852015644312, -0.05567105486989021, 0.050802819430828094, 0.0468413382768631, 0.03224087134003639, 0.021825343370437622, -0.009287441149353981, -0.04631742462515831, -0.013711018487811089, -0.033138249069452286, 0.002679581521078944, -0.052985046058893204, -0.01617412082850933, 0.03983772173523903, 0.040819201618433, -0.02600187435746193, 0.017444118857383728, 0.07918339967727661, 0.021849215030670166, 0.025666454806923866, -0.0016754656098783016, -0.044199198484420776, -0.03930974751710892, -0.006091320421546698, 0.00039990190998651087, 0.00963515229523182, -0.0012651551514863968, -0.017776157706975937, 0.017768118530511856, 0.04943326488137245, -0.0070915077812969685, -0.018340401351451874, 0.027051320299506187, 0.026980893686413765, -0.03652727231383324, -0.0038330929819494486, -0.03973453491926193, 0.014675445854663849, 0.0011971689527854323, 0.01613464578986168, 0.017154281958937645, -0.019831636920571327, 0.039877552539110184, -0.009371571242809296, -0.032972872257232666, 0.01984478533267975, 0.021893786266446114, -0.0463675856590271, -0.015275831334292889, 0.034707747399806976, -0.0414997935295105, 0.04662087559700012, -0.029874764382839203, -0.005636453162878752, -0.07450278103351593, 0.033277228474617004, 0.02581009455025196, -0.00783565640449524, 0.024026740342378616, -0.008674094453454018, -0.008693528361618519, 0.030391359701752663, -0.05032409355044365, 0.03989425301551819, 0.014627814292907715, -0.04818490892648697, 0.0046135494485497475, -0.012518290430307388, -0.029332581907510757, 0.026491040363907814, 0.027137866243720055, -0.006707303691655397, 0.028172289952635765, -0.0037147062830626965, -0.08758354187011719, -0.023663798347115517, -0.04301441088318825, 0.0365142896771431, 0.013663728721439838, 0.008470986969769001, 0.02416669949889183, -0.0053446632809937, -0.035408444702625275, 0.01174992322921753, -0.01625957153737545, 0.0279842559248209, -0.03497158735990524, -0.010533437132835388, 0.017240483313798904, -0.005287029780447483, -0.008033772930502892, 0.054712917655706406, -0.03751156106591225, 0.0013152799801900983, -0.07240665704011917, -0.021683258935809135, 0.015999451279640198, 0.010670089162886143, -0.01579999551177025, 0.04792802780866623, -0.00003691007805173285, 0.05312377214431763, 0.03249729052186012, -0.011936112307012081, -0.0437844954431057, -0.0031392518430948257, -0.013047338463366032, -0.03875282406806946, 0.023714790120720863, -0.03817033767700195, 0.002574051497504115, 0.006864855997264385, -0.024621373042464256, 0.0028786698821932077, 0.04484865814447403, 0.017569446936249733, 0.01328526996076107, 0.009674758650362492, -0.015140672214329243, 0.012265804223716259, 0.022161776199936867, 0.022921057417988777, -0.008805139921605587, 0.01541264820843935, -0.004924916662275791, -0.01501153502613306, -0.01568954810500145, -0.050854843109846115, -0.035125985741615295, -0.011363431811332703, 0.0010412344709038734, -0.04514371231198311, -0.0036944032181054354, -0.009080961346626282, -0.051878202706575394, 0.024365875869989395, 0.059354495257139206, 0.022883711382746696, 0.01354038156569004, 0.02079993486404419, 0.011920096352696419, 0.003453676588833332, -0.0245798509567976, 0.01831507310271263, -0.03704386204481125, -0.014636713080108166, -0.0009168570977635682, -0.01638624630868435, -0.00024381694674957544, 0.03220999613404274, 0.025073638185858727, -0.008909338153898716, -0.038435112684965134, -0.03194696828722954, 0.0358332060277462, -0.05971166118979454, 0.044780317693948746, -0.0004203012795187533, 0.05890104919672012, 0.014521190896630287, 0.020648811012506485, 0.00439941743388772, -0.01202397421002388, 0.03321385383605957, -0.0012022018199786544, -0.07042837888002396, 0.012589369900524616, -0.02048492059111595, -0.011444365605711937, 0.014788257889449596, 0.002090267837047577, 0.013099309988319874, 0.004282104317098856, 0.0197623111307621, -0.011284192092716694, 0.016216734424233437, -0.0312827043235302, 0.02363893948495388, 0.03325317054986954, -0.009262640960514545, 0.005132449325174093, -0.014038216322660446, -0.0161467082798481, -0.021718421950936317, 0.029592663049697876, 0.04423924908041954, 0.00028321347781457007, -0.04200388491153717, -0.008264667354524136, 0.03219818323850632, 0.02670946903526783, 0.021479351446032524, 0.010787171311676502, 0.02989029511809349, -0.04409432038664818, 0.0049246749840676785, -0.009611213579773903, 0.011890974827110767, 0.008049232885241508, 0.0056259105913341045, -0.002242343034595251, -0.07039675861597061, -0.022281119599938393, -0.002452469663694501, 0.038891322910785675, 0.016515342518687248, 0.02282045967876911, -0.001722003216855228, 0.04944562911987305, -0.03748882934451103, -0.00509437033906579, 0.07610789686441422, -0.016682913526892662, -0.01715586706995964, 0.004514405038207769, -0.03206406161189079, -0.0033477903343737125, 0.005230682902038097, 0.04554058611392975, -0.020880920812487602, -0.002791658276692033, 0.010710126720368862, 0.01338583417236805, -0.042782727628946304, 0.01083778589963913, -0.02588699385523796, 0.04788889363408089, 0.05766329914331436, -0.024621928110718727, -0.015494780614972115, -0.026382235810160637, 0.06701505184173584, 0.04502396285533905, 0.035924870520830154, 0.009788629598915577, -0.09101209789514542, 0.03245994448661804, 0.03477604314684868, 0.0600309856235981, -0.032779861241579056, -0.031473737210035324, -0.05811673775315285, -0.037911880761384964, 0.05104522407054901, -0.04240142181515694, -0.008461247198283672, 0.000051497230742825195, -0.006013398990035057, 0.00519331032410264, -0.025807054713368416, -0.011896553449332714, -0.027247821912169456, -0.04550977051258087, 0.026184862479567528, -0.009311920031905174, -0.034982830286026, -0.0504784919321537, 0.04251345247030258, -0.008203364908695221, 0.028981994837522507, -0.007254783995449543, -0.0017133334185928106, -0.000879425962921232, 0.02655867673456669, -0.008406254462897778, -0.04632441699504852, -0.007118728943169117, 0.00026075178175233305, -0.04956375062465668, 0.04639093577861786, -0.016393253579735756, -0.04324096441268921, 0.020577892661094666, 0.010907243937253952, -0.04196304827928543, -0.023500921204686165, -0.031392332166433334, 0.009525682777166367, 0.04407684877514839, 0.03973880410194397, 0.054530780762434006, 0.023950397968292236, 0.0064245350658893585, 0.005084680393338203, -0.017344050109386444, -0.001319727161899209, -0.04957039654254913, -0.03535999357700348, -0.02291262522339821, -0.03450281172990799, -0.02566494792699814, 0.029142851009964943, 0.0015624936204403639, 0.04506436735391617, 0.010419702157378197, 0.010825776495039463, -0.011756282299757004, 0.05628455430269241, -0.006594162900000811, -0.023062052205204964, 0.04369860142469406, 0.03602088615298271, 0.014423096552491188, -0.013141032308340073, 0.04065776243805885, 0.02243434265255928, -0.006248539313673973, 0.00447694119066, -0.024051323533058167, 0.019153999164700508, -0.005821488332003355, -0.028989730402827263, 0.018855063244700432, -0.02508576214313507, 0.02417677454650402, 0.014824078418314457, 0.05457381159067154, -0.012438412755727768, -0.0602644681930542, -0.021809065714478493, -0.005825680680572987, -0.028203994035720825, 0.006836674176156521, -0.048735737800598145, 0.010739723220467567, -0.0494920089840889, -0.009401017799973488, -0.06856118142604828, -0.051254045218229294, 0.023433946073055267, 0.0032354271970689297, -0.0007408967358060181, -0.059651851654052734, 0.01012509036809206, -0.013326591812074184, 0.0014945283764973283, 0.007951335050165653, 0.027707194909453392, -0.020976193249225616, 0.01036141999065876, -0.010194364935159683, 0.0038166085723787546, 0.025957999750971794, 0.01635783538222313, 0.03187275305390358, -0.001747534959577024, 0.011375940404832363, -0.03359275683760643, -0.01703605055809021, 0.03724644333124161, -0.02594374120235443, 0.007834040559828281, -0.06558118015527725, -0.007983134128153324, 0.05056881532073021, 0.017791418358683586, 0.012523270212113857, 0.03805633261799812, -0.005200586747378111, -0.012098630890250206, -0.03237035870552063, 0.015513909049332142, 0.009163389913737774, 0.003782863263040781, -0.03207213431596756, -0.026379283517599106, 0.0067436243407428265, -0.013372358866035938, 0.034235790371894836, 0.031206464394927025, -0.016020076349377632, -0.017528776079416275, 0.048889026045799255, -0.013939392752945423, 0.03005119599401951, 0.0061124349012970924, -0.01871737278997898, 0.051274288445711136, -0.01785191334784031, 0.026175597682595253, 0.005342522636055946, 0.02422427386045456, -0.0565737746655941, -0.028470218181610107, -0.018407970666885376, -0.009079341776669025, 0.03540981933474541, -0.008289266377687454, 0.028002694249153137, 0.05228590592741966, 0.020479993894696236, 0.0076175956055521965, -0.03937675803899765, -0.021603813394904137, 0.0332985520362854, 0.01586255617439747, 0.07103320211172104, 0.02007651887834072, -0.014873980544507504, 0.047634948045015335, 0.009980783797800541, 0.01542987022548914, 0.03862413391470909, -0.03383168578147888, 0.03064579889178276, 0.014436719939112663, -0.030794164165854454, -0.038352061063051224, 0.011393735185265541, -0.04487094283103943, 0.027878371998667717, 0.005742472596466541, -0.038976218551397324, 0.058041367679834366, 0.02274763211607933, 0.03292892500758171, -0.014670955017209053, -0.024983147159218788, -0.06191745772957802, 0.024532727897167206, 0.02027755230665207, -0.02149316668510437, 0.017230020835995674, 0.006809192709624767, 0.027109475806355476, 0.019546901807188988, 0.06478355824947357, -0.023509176447987556, -0.10958454012870789, -0.016036605462431908, -0.018845602869987488, -0.01910180225968361, 0.06267184019088745, 0.04144860431551933, -0.03726881369948387, 0.01610286347568035, -0.03897974640130997, 0.007450421806424856, -0.004635302349925041, 0.0554930716753006, 0.023696500808000565, 0.04982298985123634, -0.01613716408610344, -0.025244347751140594, -0.025629594922065735, -0.014873208478093147, 0.11715798079967499, 0.07752106338739395, 0.05288690701127052, -0.0656680315732956, -0.013272703625261784, -0.01922396570444107, -0.04270844906568527, -0.04193979874253273, 0.014919918961822987, -0.02066926099359989, 0.013134511187672615, 0.04504799097776413, 0.01952287368476391, 0.03514765575528145, 0.01502874493598938, 0.02506646141409874, -0.016570448875427246, 0.021122975274920464, 0.019215356558561325, 0.016046814620494843, 0.037943169474601746, 0.017323864623904228, -0.056936439126729965, 0.014401020482182503, -0.012224508449435234, -0.03663371503353119, -0.03832443803548813, -0.03502310812473297, 0.02065003104507923, -0.020058540627360344, -0.023607591167092323, -0.0014349527191370726, -0.029431434348225594, 0.002402793150395155, 0.005071448627859354, 0.02314521186053753, 0.006207694299519062, 0.024837708100676537, -0.010515587404370308, 0.029319709166884422, 0.0028359072748571634, 0.026566924527287483, -0.012520700693130493, 0.005822953302413225, -0.025420935824513435, -0.01849842630326748, -0.054991915822029114, 0.04450346529483795, -0.03305977210402489, 0.0030633516144007444, 0.014781809411942959, 0.021856460720300674, 0.023173291236162186, -0.034988563507795334, -0.026362748816609383, 0.006289276294410229, 0.021539928391575813, -0.01634102687239647, 0.01493985764682293, 0.010868760757148266, 0.04518737271428108, -0.0011751526035368443, 0.011970266699790955, 0.012636197730898857, -0.006374588701874018, -0.025922751054167747, 0.008087506517767906, 0.03251924365758896, -0.007322078570723534, 0.027647776529192924, -0.0004631252959370613, -0.010662360116839409, 0.026780331507325172, -0.0031141883227974176, 0.05173703655600548, -0.004972527269273996, -0.0038574703503400087, -0.03797497600317001, -0.008415804244577885, -0.050318438559770584, -0.04567940533161163, 0.01589961163699627, -0.049811992794275284, 0.01540466770529747, -0.04463218152523041, -0.015442490577697754, 0.029982224106788635, 0.03303276747465134, 0.008532585576176643, -0.001335994340479374, -0.021192926913499832, 0.00807484332472086, 0.004306530114263296, -0.039031386375427246, -0.016133340075612068, -0.053819067776203156, -0.027518145740032196, 0.029021915048360825, -0.019133014604449272, 0.09205178916454315, 0.02050250768661499, 0.005900945980101824, -0.03872765973210335, 0.019458431750535965, -0.021285435184836388, 0.016845151782035828, -0.008215069770812988, -0.06767763197422028, 0.0069943624548614025, -0.000973582617007196, 0.01615866646170616, -0.028779419139027596, -0.019145259633660316, -0.0448002852499485, -0.018043432384729385, 0.014959403313696384, 0.012275299988687038, -0.05890607833862305, 0.03032577410340309, 0.011622943915426731, 0.06415176391601562, -0.039854273200035095, 0.022056149318814278, -0.03109150007367134, 0.01842418499290943, -0.00901149120181799, -0.04858647659420967, -0.0032306688372045755, 0.0024815707001835108, -0.020112382248044014, 0.0007289605564437807, 0.002927106572315097, -0.0013528488343581557, 0.00024506470072083175, 0.028297094628214836, 0.020385779440402985, -0.015185654163360596, 0.049393180757761, -0.020579451695084572, -0.02515752613544464, 0.04717801511287689, -0.05381367355585098, -0.050194863229990005, 0.026677124202251434, -0.02439124695956707, 0.027087604627013206, 0.028871912509202957, -0.01476745679974556, -0.02191866748034954, 0.04349374398589134, -0.00798557698726654, -0.005998348351567984, -0.011203490197658539, 0.016554467380046844, 0.012593025341629982, 0.008693317882716656, 0.016213832423090935, -0.02061881311237812, -0.03631412610411644, 0.026699965819716454, 0.04806336760520935, 0.010937356390058994, 0.026666151359677315, 0.03473692014813423, 0.02393278479576111, 0.03522526100277901, 0.028452668339014053, -0.007774010766297579, 0.031804490834474564, 0.02568189613521099, -0.036032065749168396, 0.013260859064757824, 0.03019247204065323, 0.04228157550096512, -0.09509803354740143, 0.011952191591262817, -0.004569795448333025, 0.009368539787828922, 0.020260123535990715, -0.06896456331014633, -0.00039305147947743535, 0.06116703897714615, -0.03733557462692261, 0.03783722594380379, -0.0017331464914605021, -0.01833728887140751, -0.011023038066923618, 0.008855977095663548, 0.0303307194262743, 0.006420297548174858, 0.02879096008837223, 0.003960310947149992, 0.040105853229761124, 0.03120776265859604, 0.03706817328929901, -0.03093091957271099, -0.021513186395168304, 0.00846268329769373, 0.024039702489972115, -0.04106729477643967, 0.02505253627896309, -0.057315610349178314, 0.0006910650990903378, 0.040347594767808914, 0.001705247675999999, 0.01320460345596075, 0.016456283628940582, 0.02668832615017891, -0.012621607631444931, 0.04941229149699211, 0.029243232682347298, -0.015336123295128345, 0.011159071698784828, -0.013296500779688358, 0.01300758495926857, 0.03458698093891144, -0.00019278797844890505, 0.033947426825761795, 0.009672311134636402, -0.0045730480924248695, 0.014832528308033943, 0.021528121083974838, 0.034156434237957, -0.01614314131438732, 0.015468157827854156, -0.003587157931178808, 0.017970804125070572, -0.02012002095580101, -0.02319871075451374, -0.04109695181250572, 0.006774022243916988, 0.00898897834122181, -0.002989725675433874, -0.04854201897978783, 0.03738880529999733, -0.00040683732368052006, -0.01726902835071087, 0.0010985000990331173, -0.0093551529571414, 0.010683764703571796, -0.07013143599033356, 0.013806512579321861, 0.01182179432362318, -0.043686650693416595, -0.01825081743299961, -0.028929751366376877, -0.022388121113181114, 0.0496424101293087, 0.0025261472910642624, 0.026240354403853416, 0.01910882070660591, 0.011447163298726082, 0.012172957882285118, -0.0735485851764679, 0.06932363659143448, 0.00783840287476778, 0.0007393165142275393, -0.012910244055092335, 0.016891052946448326, 0.005381690803915262, -0.014662022702395916, 0.056486453860998154, -0.0071791778318583965, 0.021264497190713882, -0.02110920660197735, 0.0029721404425799847, 0.009714743122458458, -0.027006009593605995, -0.00035816471790894866, -0.011384728364646435, -0.04364066943526268, -0.004736987873911858, -0.014197904616594315, -0.0005347627447918057, -0.008414919488132, 0.041956909000873566, 0.02378198876976967, -0.024539507925510406, 0.007074919529259205, -0.0067919581197202206, 0.043660540133714676, -0.004569611512124538, -0.015650028362870216, 0.03442763164639473, -0.011655895039439201, -0.02273692563176155, -0.00473359040915966, -0.019323045387864113, -0.013186347670853138, 0.041812557727098465, -0.05398445948958397, -0.016053801402449608, -0.020237289369106293, -0.007816033437848091, -0.027277871966362, -0.07361861318349838, 0.025575963780283928, 0.0007986724958755076, -0.02282290905714035, 0.018749454990029335, 0.013112980872392654, -0.020785721018910408, 0.06722632050514221, -0.02077963389456272, 0.023932496085762978, 0.03345029056072235, 0.03415963798761368, -0.012535683810710907, 0.03996751457452774, 0.005922796670347452, -0.0031211012974381447, 0.02033323235809803, 0.004299380350857973, -0.0162146408110857, 0.04280763119459152, -0.014105443842709064, 0.030570613220334053, -0.05796816572546959, -0.04068434238433838, -0.001873979577794671, -0.006791069637984037, 0.011413919739425182, -0.0339905209839344, -0.01622910052537918, 0.05474032089114189, -0.05329742282629013, -0.037728309631347656, -0.02534504048526287, -0.006698371842503548, -0.0018456499092280865, 0.009945778176188469, -0.04202188923954964, 0.03306417539715767, -0.007083290722221136, 0.03435531631112099, 0.023255635052919388, -0.010528955608606339, 0.06141626462340355, -0.03542141243815422, 0.02674325928092003, -0.023529991507530212, -0.028133202344179153, -0.004265166353434324, -0.01742437109351158, 0.008374636061489582, -0.02465425245463848, 0.020934686064720154, 0.045266322791576385, 0.030940713360905647, -0.02388007938861847, -0.011604288592934608, -0.005371734034270048, 0.022486092522740364, -0.08039697259664536, 0.0007562990067526698, -0.038001250475645065, 0.010399803519248962, -0.011712516658008099, -0.016450338065624237 ]
<p>I have a data set and I want to examine an hypothesis in there and probably Network Analysis should prove or reject my theory.</p> <p>I have a list of products and a group of people who give the product to each other. Anyone can sell it to another in any price he want (hopefully someone will buy it).</p> <p>So, imagine a chain of products transfers between the people. Except the sell price, one will also take a percentage of the sale only of the next one who will re-sell the product. And also, if I sell for the first time a product, I will take a percentage forever for every sale.</p> <p>Example:</p> <p>A -> B -> C</p> <p>Person A will take the money from sale to Person B. Person B will take the money of the sale to person C and Person A will take a percentage of this sale as the previous owner and the creator of the chain. If person C sell the product to someone else, only person B will take the previous percentage, but person A will take the percentage of the creator.</p> <p>I believe that there are people that try to exploit the system and create small or bigger circles to take advantage of these percentages of next sales to "hide" themselves.</p> <p>Is there any way to identify those people?</p>
74,066
[ 0.004361602943390608, -0.014692502096295357, 0.010140280239284039, -0.03255459666252136, 0.02212735079228878, -0.02399749495089054, -0.02544865757226944, -0.005648411810398102, 0.003247550455853343, -0.030769074335694313, 0.013303400948643684, 0.011150848120450974, 0.015401645563542843, 0.022782735526561737, 0.009232701733708382, 0.0038751971442252398, -0.06072826310992241, 0.010226191952824593, -0.00038957729702815413, 0.0004185695725027472, 0.006980167236179113, 0.03404335305094719, 0.007816188968718052, -0.014791229739785194, -0.04519001394510269, 0.04045940190553665, 0.02002396248281002, -0.03734688088297844, 0.025497570633888245, 0.052692413330078125, -0.028523113578557968, -0.010637734085321426, -0.017349813133478165, 0.007794006261974573, 0.03037732094526291, 0.017141371965408325, -0.04913921281695366, -0.037146423012018204, 0.0035644753370434046, 0.026359114795923233, -0.026949340477585793, 0.02491837739944458, 0.005513743497431278, 0.03541829064488411, 0.00041171067277900875, 0.01557241566479206, 0.021382464095950127, -0.02677346207201481, 0.03969389200210571, -0.05368368700146675, 0.10235854238271713, -0.006548331584781408, -0.0057754190638661385, 0.01753547228872776, -0.005866330582648516, 0.000020471519746934064, 0.03319994732737541, 0.09333682060241699, -0.0465938001871109, -0.04619164764881134, -0.03428063541650772, 0.01962047442793846, -0.008260619826614857, -0.03302169591188431, -0.042999353259801865, 0.021879078820347786, -0.03206995502114296, -0.007923956960439682, 0.03903308883309364, 0.015210348181426525, 0.025703556835651398, 0.013684303499758244, 0.045802030712366104, 0.002916489029303193, -0.025393612682819366, -0.00450177164748311, -0.0019373830873519182, 0.01961391419172287, 0.05022576451301575, 0.03182780742645264, 0.020094407722353935, -0.04120927304029465, 0.0011879531666636467, 0.06378547847270966, 0.01813955046236515, -0.010934306308627129, 0.04443461820483208, -0.06858614832162857, 0.03727981075644493, 0.029196741059422493, -0.033455703407526016, -0.011348262429237366, 0.034264352172613144, 0.012387370690703392, -0.06579587608575821, 0.010767835192382336, -0.002586064161732793, 0.021845849230885506, 0.0082838274538517, -0.022290822118520737, -0.02636049874126911, -0.02275657095015049, -0.03126801550388336, 0.04479547217488289, 0.0012984710047021508, 0.0018248880514875054, -0.02827351540327072, -0.002908304799348116, -0.0071921818889677525, -0.0035337635781615973, -0.04023797810077667, -0.021453265100717545, 0.028884198516607285, 0.020545462146401405, 0.008230127394199371, -0.008638668805360794, -0.0532025508582592, -0.02631337195634842, 0.08060968667268753, 0.040183063596487045, 0.01575320214033127, -0.003070782870054245, 0.038917701691389084, -0.003975613042712212, -0.024139469489455223, 0.011803538538515568, 0.013994810171425343, -0.025212693959474564, -0.04664158076047897, 0.05216539278626442, 0.04497736692428589, -0.04692879691720009, 0.0510963536798954, -0.0161809790879488, 0.06281748414039612, 0.0026886791456490755, -0.09557896107435226, -0.06594546139240265, 0.06553129106760025, -0.011596775613725185, 0.03613469749689102, -0.053060855716466904, 0.00271993619389832, -0.004272491671144962, 0.08895274996757507, 0.00203592493198812, 0.011230898089706898, 0.023463493213057518, 0.0583847314119339, 0.038416698575019836, -0.015954867005348206, -0.0379459373652935, -0.002672359347343445, -0.022705940529704094, -0.0255038533359766, -0.05240588262677193, 0.00017791063874028623, 0.0645269826054573, -0.03389761596918106, -0.030658813193440437, 0.026815297082066536, 0.01905270852148533, -0.016205033287405968, 0.017261696979403496, -0.04088520258665085, -0.009470072574913502, 0.056906647980213165, -0.010924448259174824, 0.03115643747150898, 0.021405240520834923, -0.0026564323343336582, 0.08092327415943146, -0.01736382208764553, 0.04015563800930977, 0.0346214734017849, -0.03814238682389259, -0.00004729655120172538, 0.01236742828041315, -0.006456720642745495, 0.033744484186172485, -0.04621892794966698, -0.016859833151102066, -0.023514216765761375, 0.0003116048173978925, 0.041633982211351395, 0.0064776865765452385, -0.009051510132849216, -0.04963166266679764, 0.005641058553010225, -0.04092741385102272, -0.037886835634708405, -0.07267583906650543, 0.0009267936693504453, -0.030282093212008476, -0.014084176160395145, -0.018413739278912544, 0.01933320239186287, -0.00570226414129138, -0.05148720741271973, -0.041745733469724655, -0.025207767263054848, -0.007477445062249899, 0.05790618062019348, -0.03454416245222092, -0.004595821723341942, 0.03151886910200119, 0.016747450456023216, -0.044293519109487534, 0.07131253927946091, -0.03790009394288063, -0.026485832408070564, 0.03982888162136078, -0.012550056912004948, 0.01888645999133587, -0.029973560944199562, 0.04025201126933098, 0.04539242386817932, 0.021226244047284126, 0.0024793052580207586, 0.03285671025514603, -0.05425513535737991, 0.04801047220826149, 0.06878544390201569, 0.02098204754292965, -0.025742830708622932, -0.019148916006088257, 0.03653602674603462, 0.014346752315759659, -0.007656554691493511, -0.0473819337785244, -0.07654373347759247, -0.009017497301101685, 0.012796487659215927, 0.024377325549721718, -0.03994675353169441, -0.0171962957829237, 0.06356574594974518, 0.06916770339012146, 0.004532556049525738, -0.02004346251487732, -0.0141376918181777, 0.006723935715854168, 0.004710562061518431, 0.033059921115636826, 0.01578623242676258, 0.042736995965242386, 0.01592600718140602, -0.0006261739181354642, 0.047742392867803574, -0.013689941726624966, 0.02225431427359581, 0.0003544555511325598, 0.003225550753995776, 0.01075831800699234, 0.010318446904420853, 0.02267698384821415, 0.0311971977353096, -0.0019535827450454235, -0.00003191936411894858, -0.005551200360059738, 0.014600117690861225, -0.019681157544255257, -0.013447032310068607, -0.06206117942929268, 0.029155276715755463, 0.04131634160876274, -0.04849068447947502, 0.0023042424581944942, 0.027494993060827255, -0.035363681614398956, 0.03617474064230919, 0.002805085852742195, 0.009789502248167992, -0.002818605164065957, 0.03312318027019501, 0.03272368386387825, 0.0056443284265697, 0.017172491177916527, -0.04119699448347092, -0.03574668616056442, 0.004845551680773497, 0.014011231251060963, 0.00761423772200942, 0.01829387992620468, -0.07341209799051285, -0.008236951194703579, 0.023266397416591644, -0.02854050137102604, 0.025756288319826126, -0.00009706184937385842, 0.005399089306592941, 0.055789485573768616, -0.014190156944096088, -0.027770109474658966, -0.01682613603770733, -0.02552230842411518, 0.03453239053487778, -0.027993135154247284, -0.013356293551623821, 0.010301753878593445, 0.0567358061671257, -0.001345509197562933, 0.044158510863780975, -0.04677619785070419, -0.012256717309355736, -0.024831589311361313, -0.04009152948856354, 0.01934417523443699, 0.014854549430310726, 0.027317829430103302, -0.029309332370758057, 0.00862982589751482, -0.029040666297078133, -0.060340024530887604, -0.10321201384067535, -0.006562034599483013, 0.00014793600712437183, -0.01041379850357771, 0.03914343938231468, -0.004783904645591974, 0.08437889814376831, 0.0407220683991909, -0.0502283088862896, -0.019623786211013794, -0.04498423635959625, -0.03518788516521454, -0.02395283244550228, 0.035363830626010895, 0.022639641538262367, -0.014045720919966698, -0.008050818927586079, 0.025464212521910667, 0.015484846197068691, 0.06594905257225037, -0.046704623848199844, -0.010221424512565136, 0.05734139680862427, 0.006932569667696953, -0.011512727476656437, 0.02622361108660698, 0.021094387397170067, -0.03641043230891228, 0.024154208600521088, 0.015484851785004139, 0.03213841840624809, 0.006471781991422176, -0.06873391568660736, -0.03202670440077782, -0.020464902743697166, -0.027648495510220528, 0.011915809474885464, -0.003128266194835305, -0.005592919420450926, -0.027851391583681107, 0.01014007069170475, 0.007226588204503059, 0.03194376081228256, -0.010960188694298267, 0.03250782936811447, 0.047601114958524704, 0.015968000516295433, -0.02503216080367565, -0.0029210522770881653, -0.03595993295311928, -0.005398828070610762, -0.01791561394929886, -0.00943769421428442, 0.000459662958746776, 0.01622140035033226, 0.04779418557882309, 0.01658300682902336, 0.021495232358574867, -0.042057450860738754, -0.020748957991600037, -0.0747668594121933, -0.015083328820765018, -0.02904652990400791, 0.05232466012239456, -0.014237227849662304, 0.05890394747257233, 0.0015645012026652694, 0.026340758427977562, -0.017850536853075027, 0.0026496800128370523, -0.06901442259550095, 0.023030631244182587, -0.013273951597511768, 0.04784613102674484, -0.006818242371082306, -0.022191008552908897, 0.020690908655524254, -0.020542364567518234, -0.014035639353096485, -0.001087716780602932, 0.023550791665911674, -0.060489386320114136, 0.0030916857067495584, -0.018630458042025566, -0.0008551054052077234, 0.0035491925664246082, 0.026603346690535545, 0.02874467335641384, 0.02083992399275303, 0.015666093677282333, 0.05174936726689339, -0.001422567991539836, -0.01266499888151884, -0.03489484637975693, -0.028186628594994545, 0.056231386959552765, 0.03033834882080555, -0.006371879018843174, 0.020027417689561844, -0.0327107310295105, -0.005450761411339045, -0.017018262296915054, 0.025003734976053238, 0.022067271173000336, 0.022368213161826134, 0.011773727834224701, -0.050435181707143784, -0.032913196831941605, 0.0062742638401687145, 0.03513476997613907, 0.008435506373643875, 0.016350092366337776, 0.06731338053941727, 0.04214141517877579, -0.03036283142864704, 0.0012621200876310468, 0.061458613723516464, 0.0361081026494503, -0.024268195033073425, -0.02333543263375759, 0.01210009679198265, 0.019406607374548912, 0.019932163879275322, -0.006773232948035002, -0.0037318640388548374, 0.007547775283455849, 0.031136656180024147, 0.0409657247364521, 0.044588059186935425, -0.05074383318424225, 0.03957904502749443, -0.014083686284720898, 0.035326242446899414, -0.02936210297048092, 0.006012846250087023, 0.034346792846918106, 0.019538382068276405, 0.014716905541718006, 0.03294738754630089, 0.015820235013961792, -0.10142312943935394, -0.0124285239726305, 0.033262547105550766, 0.04391464591026306, -0.04487689584493637, -0.016096962615847588, -0.03309028223156929, -0.013276777230203152, 0.038694530725479126, -0.03127487003803253, 0.048920728266239166, 0.005586661864072084, 0.009940696880221367, -0.038882169872522354, -0.018122948706150055, -0.009473178535699844, -0.020153524354100227, -0.04522398114204407, 0.018901431933045387, -0.02177410200238228, -0.004229611251503229, -0.04371034353971481, 0.01580248400568962, 0.026446469128131866, 0.03749912232160568, -0.008708570152521133, -0.03137047961354256, -0.002918506972491741, 0.04481292888522148, -0.017149247229099274, -0.06002672389149666, 0.0651467964053154, -0.004438949283212423, -0.018030205741524696, 0.05000066012144089, -0.03665604069828987, -0.020228764042258263, -0.014216496609151363, -0.015226395800709724, -0.004234082996845245, -0.019919702783226967, -0.028792571276426315, 0.04576245695352554, 0.052970364689826965, -0.011934158392250538, 0.04078591242432594, 0.05680957809090614, -0.007852924056351185, 0.008126012049615383, 0.002995455637574196, 0.0023601099383085966, -0.009382643736898899, 0.003540104953572154, -0.0064665330573916435, 0.0013359752483665943, -0.011363665573298931, -0.001300699426792562, 0.061794769018888474, 0.024021293967962265, -0.01842663623392582, -0.018551012501120567, -0.0072920918464660645, 0.052519429475069046, -0.022541062906384468, 0.03344489261507988, 0.0013826744398102164, -0.0011764009250327945, 0.033148143440485, -0.013371031731367111, 0.005775493569672108, -0.026656806468963623, 0.013403932563960552, 0.0011059074895456433, 0.0032170501071959734, -0.013303201645612717, -0.05026119202375412, -0.062033750116825104, 0.003629859769716859, -0.038548361510038376, 0.0588025338947773, -0.014220446348190308, 0.015140028670430183, 0.03538284823298454, -0.03377949818968773, 0.012943568639457226, 0.016974423080682755, -0.0071586789563298225, 0.029680367559194565, -0.026088301092386246, 0.0328427329659462, -0.01919005624949932, 0.009398727677762508, -0.05471336469054222, -0.023729830980300903, 0.013632500544190407, -0.008786896243691444, -0.051817044615745544, -0.038580991327762604, 0.0009860129794105887, 0.0005158592248335481, -0.012736666947603226, -0.03429728373885155, 0.04007919132709503, -0.008805994875729084, 0.013612180948257446, 0.014680203050374985, 0.0015110113890841603, 0.07637237757444382, 0.0165437962859869, -0.026809489354491234, 0.00170725432690233, 0.017055915668606758, 0.011696435511112213, 0.006204046308994293, -0.012692509219050407, -0.025889817625284195, -0.05137953907251358, -0.042034510523080826, 0.04307902604341507, 0.03438505530357361, -0.040565475821495056, 0.007367903832346201, 0.018519315868616104, 0.0346958227455616, -0.002789557445794344, 0.013789458200335503, -0.006429476663470268, -0.00001222578066517599, -0.013153810985386372, 0.017318546772003174, 0.01767704449594021, -0.004709607921540737, -0.0004956046468578279, 0.03430434688925743, 0.0027450411580502987, -0.057846006006002426, 0.005201962310820818, 0.051482416689395905, -0.02293601632118225, -0.03476933762431145, -0.005162565503269434, -0.04092372581362724, 0.0657782256603241, -0.024422982707619667, 0.00647412333637476, -0.01562981866300106, 0.041246965527534485, -0.04208940267562866, -0.030869027599692345, -0.05104317516088486, -0.015963267534971237, 0.04234236851334572, 0.014281632378697395, 0.028074683621525764, 0.05400380119681358, 0.03273455426096916, -0.008107288740575314, 0.0022446990478783846, 0.00022856626310385764, -0.0034740895498543978, -0.006518126465380192, 0.008651653304696083, -0.045101750642061234, -0.019220562651753426, 0.025618351995944977, 0.005247565917670727, -0.007313592825084925, 0.04126426950097084, 0.018640607595443726, 0.008193235844373703, 0.04523341357707977, -0.03642050921916962, -0.015421338379383087, 0.05922213941812515, -0.03874284401535988, 0.05712238699197769, -0.034412045031785965, -0.03592482954263687, 0.05329315736889839, 0.02701466903090477, 0.002689903136342764, -0.04185659438371658, -0.04525868594646454, -0.02598423883318901, 0.009962053969502449, -0.003107719123363495, 0.0036556152626872063, 0.033503372222185135, 0.006162569392472506, 0.015026681125164032, -0.02643507719039917, 0.02758263237774372, -0.007624324876815081, -0.06008877232670784, -0.04167928546667099, -0.006934062577784061, -0.028846727684140205, -0.015977155417203903, -0.004789694212377071, -0.003766024950891733, 0.025471733883023262, -0.04372125118970871, -0.020965036004781723, -0.023010514676570892, 0.030132770538330078, 0.007825112901628017, 0.06914763897657394, -0.002795027568936348, 0.04392499476671219, -0.010236378759145737, -0.012671194970607758, 0.12230399996042252, 0.02623397298157215, -0.0148050207644701, -0.046845290809869766, 0.02176988497376442, 0.020400144159793854, -0.016223322600126266, -0.060526952147483826, 0.02037850394845009, 0.013627704232931137, -0.0021543889306485653, 0.05457887426018715, 0.046061646193265915, 0.022651486098766327, 0.030068352818489075, 0.07982905209064484, -0.01813066564500332, -0.01234099268913269, 0.057814404368400574, -0.0013275891542434692, -0.030033128336071968, -0.025900766253471375, -0.058552827686071396, 0.037333302199840546, 0.0005276694428175688, -0.01195433083921671, -0.01620537042617798, -0.004448162391781807, 0.03784957900643349, -0.004605078604072332, 0.01653699204325676, 0.02268408052623272, 0.016488119959831238, 0.0013478024629876018, -0.0023310729302465916, 0.008269652724266052, 0.03698069229722023, -0.024585068225860596, 0.03378818556666374, 0.054776471108198166, 0.023475375026464462, -0.013477652333676815, 0.013089997693896294, 0.027861371636390686, -0.028426453471183777, -0.0312074963003397, -0.022534310817718506, 0.008526482619345188, -0.019125744700431824, -0.015823567286133766, -0.015312306582927704, -0.01270611584186554, -0.0023899918887764215, -0.017149826511740685, -0.03879094496369362, -0.0014939149841666222, 0.020111098885536194, -0.019676538184285164, -0.035368870943784714, -0.016404947265982628, -0.0019895334262400866, -0.002000683918595314, 0.02180321142077446, -0.0231490395963192, -0.04400041699409485, -0.02789221704006195, -0.01192794181406498, 0.053156301379203796, -0.012933569960296154, -0.005041481927037239, 0.0076383985579013824, -0.04806172102689743, -0.008920896798372269, 0.020513759925961494, -0.01896119862794876, 0.007549795787781477, -0.0025593996979296207, -0.00047159063979052007, 0.04771673306822777, 0.02050100825726986, 0.017641453072428703, 0.01185472309589386, -0.013511340133845806, 0.008833490312099457, -0.041061628609895706, -0.00305853970348835, 0.04883786663413048, 0.02133474126458168, 0.006431045476347208, 0.003021291457116604, 0.008488786406815052, 0.05663559213280678, -0.00965886190533638, -0.010550299659371376, -0.022927168756723404, -0.0683402419090271, -0.03295337036252022, 0.024287385866045952, -0.030439389869570732, 0.051763080060482025, 0.02106240577995777, -0.03546394035220146, -0.0114831468090415, -0.021093355491757393, -0.008593937382102013, 0.032923582941293716, 0.017395690083503723, -0.09137331694364548, -0.004817976616322994, 0.013471471145749092, -0.015271895565092564, -0.022179530933499336, -0.02535850927233696, 0.0023503240663558245, -0.00029370610718615353, -0.01905994676053524, 0.008743860758841038, -0.03584761917591095, 0.009206293150782585, -0.0352354533970356, 0.028197452425956726, -0.03306150063872337, -0.009894141927361488, -0.042189985513687134, -0.049527961760759354, -0.008601322770118713, 0.031244127079844475, -0.007081600371748209, 0.030066415667533875, 0.02701173536479473, 0.04173721745610237, 0.021167345345020294, -0.024297891184687614, -0.031952399760484695, -0.04428422823548317, 0.03551549091935158, -0.012501288205385208, 0.0035777101293206215, -0.036966074258089066, -0.05004533380270004, 0.05412201210856438, -0.026315312832593918, -0.006449033971875906, 0.017954040318727493, -0.020752079784870148, 0.07173265516757965, -0.005631936248391867, -0.025789562612771988, -0.006807900965213776, 0.02476665750145912, -0.022851990535855293, -0.005648467224091291, 0.003434783313423395, 0.027325784787535667, 0.002991284476593137, 0.015915382653474808, -0.00038533014594577253, 0.012198458425700665, -0.008466454222798347, 0.010277495719492435, 0.035021912306547165, -0.0063218832947313786, -0.030725182965397835, 0.00855307187885046, 0.014766475185751915, -0.016986126080155373, 0.00913438480347395, 0.02146046794950962, 0.06700433790683746, 0.013242634944617748, -0.04000621289014816, 0.00020771451818291098, -0.023053672164678574, 0.005142153240740299, -0.05195493996143341, -0.03372155874967575, 0.004205992911010981, 0.02194305881857872, 0.023753102868795395, -0.03494493290781975, -0.010095851495862007, 0.0018351641483604908, -0.05749841034412384, 0.05640801042318344, -0.0021883859299123287, 0.01074961293488741, -0.049404218792915344, 0.021469799801707268, -0.03662838414311409, 0.0324677899479866, 0.014977062121033669, 0.052256226539611816, 0.03164243325591087, 0.01329345814883709, 0.01099708303809166, -0.013997259549796581, -0.03784382343292236, -0.011034499853849411, 0.012061819434165955, -0.056845057755708694, 0.04371420666575432, -0.04041095823049545, -0.04357833415269852, 0.04258883744478226, 0.002464821795001626, -0.00036264379741624, 0.008378352969884872, -0.010362423956394196, 0.03505663946270943, 0.04596972092986107, 0.005427389871329069, 0.029840456321835518, 0.01284017413854599, -0.005897906608879566, -0.00733204698190093, 0.04512571170926094, 0.030731210485100746, -0.004036962520331144, 0.015587970614433289, -0.00851195678114891, -0.015779994428157806, -0.03665627911686897, -0.014813368208706379, 0.005205837544053793, 0.00794360414147377, -0.0143479835242033, 0.01562832109630108, -0.013705593533813953, 0.028281299397349358, -0.048417724668979645, -0.0048516844399273396, 0.0077877044677734375, 0.014280639588832855, -0.026118041947484016, 0.009156433865427971, -0.008259089663624763, -0.03897595405578613, 0.05494332313537598, 0.024756258353590965, -0.002158860210329294, -0.06157411262392998, 0.007200050633400679, 0.016504963859915733, 0.005030718166381121, -0.023925377056002617, -0.02288658916950226, 0.0032612576615065336, 0.052642516791820526, -0.019757920876145363, -0.003283068537712097, -0.004195068031549454, -0.010050858370959759, 0.010996349155902863, -0.09285235404968262, 0.04411909729242325, 0.013426976278424263, 0.0074473656713962555, -0.06481868773698807, -0.00840135756880045, -0.024988584220409393, -0.03225884214043617, 0.013086903840303421, -0.042772963643074036, -0.0011612728703767061, 0.004804491996765137, 0.026478147134184837, 0.014987409114837646, -0.037542957812547684, 0.028847992420196533, -0.017301449552178383, -0.014141405001282692, -0.007770206313580275, -0.016573550179600716, -0.016729295253753662, 0.015199272893369198, 0.016754694283008575, 0.0032086276914924383, -0.03776116669178009, -0.010421776212751865, -0.017060192301869392, 0.0020927886944264174, -0.020259562879800797, 0.018821528181433678, 0.039239369332790375, 0.016739537939429283, 0.009745913557708263, 0.005936012137681246, -0.026512611657381058, -0.06000608578324318, 0.06709593534469604, -0.041673265397548676, -0.030718693509697914, -0.01769622415304184, -0.026408767327666283, -0.025624964386224747, -0.015786170959472656, 0.017653843387961388, 0.04344148933887482, -0.02463638037443161, 0.02108042687177658, 0.02601277269423008, 0.0014305649092420936, -0.00637198518961668, 0.024965746328234673, 0.03127448260784149, -0.016791963949799538, 0.013748851604759693, -0.015158820897340775, 0.035057488828897476, 0.01655823364853859, 0.0142809534445405, 0.013411296531558037, 0.006959946826100349, 0.012106388807296753, 0.059615034610033035, -0.022948971018195152, -0.0020099489483982325, -0.057524822652339935, 0.037292465567588806, 0.03686370328068733, -0.058496758341789246, 0.02053973078727722, 0.023721996694803238, -0.006582564674317837, 0.05731521546840668, 0.0017087399028241634, 0.029919181019067764, -0.006783803924918175, 0.03076406940817833, -0.012343001551926136, 0.01759047619998455, 0.020926469936966896, 0.01091925147920847, -0.02950442209839821, -0.0013778917491436005, -0.022891558706760406, 0.01807336136698723, 0.027404559776186943, 0.0031434763222932816, 0.04875241219997406, -0.0011886326828971505, -0.001878882641904056, -0.03633489832282066, -0.028194492682814598, -0.02594710700213909, -0.020876212045550346, 0.010777773335576057, 0.018297279253602028, 0.016022903844714165, 0.013784957118332386, -0.0038529024459421635, 0.01721159927546978, 0.037715934216976166, -0.08947990089654922, -0.0026096070650964975, -0.0248943530023098, 0.023168904706835747, -0.005728114861994982, -0.056895893067121506 ]